2021-12-21 Besu Contributor Call - Besu - LF Decentralized Trust Atlassian uses cookies to improve your browsing experience, perform analytics and research, and conduct advertising. Accept all cookies to indicate that you agree to our use of cookies on your device. Atlassian cookies and tracking notice, (opens new window) PreferencesOnly necessaryAccept all LF Decentralized Trust LF Decentralized Trust Spaces Apps Templates Create Besu All content Shortcuts Meetings Meetings  This trigger is hidden How-to articles How-to articles  This trigger is hidden Content Results will update as you type. Code of Conduct Contributing Developing and Conventions Documentation Community Governance Programs & Grants Meetings Agendas 2019 Agendas 2020 Agendas 2021 Agendas 2021-01-19 Office Hours 2021-02-02 Office Hours 2021-02-16 Office Hours 2021-03-02 Besu Contributor Call 2021-03-16 Besu Office Hours 2021-03-30 Besu Office Hours 2021-04-13 Besu Contributor Call 2021-04-26 Besu Office Hours 2021-05-11 Besu Office Hours 2021-05-24 Besu Contributor Call 2021-06-08 Besu Contributor Call 2021-06-21 Besu Contributor Call 2021-07-06 Besu Contributor Call 2021-07-19 Besu Contributor Call 2021-08-03 Besu Contributor Call 2021-08-16 Besu Contributor Call 2021-08-31 Besu Contributor Call 2021-09-13 Besu Contributor Call 2021-09-28 Besu Contributor Call 2021-10-11 Besu Contributor Call 2021-10-26 Besu Contributor Call 2021-11-09 Besu Contributor Call 2021-11-23 Besu Contributor Call 2021-12-07 Besu Contributor Call 2021-12-21 Besu Contributor Call 2021-12-30 Besu Contributor Call (off cycle) 2022 Agendas 2023 Agendas 2024 Agendas 2025 Agendas Notes Suspend APAC Contributor Call Design Documents Security Audits Start Here Performance & Stability How-to articles Incident Reports Besu Roadmap & Planning How to Contribute You‘re viewing this with anonymous access, so some content might be blocked. Close Besu / 2021-12-21 Besu Contributor Call More actions 2021-12-21 Besu Contributor Call Francesco Andreoli Ry Jones Sally MacFarlane +3 Owned by Francesco Andreoli Last updated: Dec 21, 2021 by Ry Jones (Meeting Link: â�¨https://zoom.us/j/97540031823?pwd=dEJrRW1LakFlWnZPelI3VGxoVjg2dz09) EMEA/AMER Friendly Time -  (https://www.timeanddate.com/worldclock/converter.html?iso=20201012T150000&p1=224&p2=179&p3=1440&p4=195&p5=47) 8 AM Tuesday San Francisco 11 AM Tuesday New York 3 PM Tuesday UTC 5 PM Tuesday Paris/Berlin 1 AM Wednesday Brisbane Agenda  Housekeeping Antitrust notice - https://www.linuxfoundation.org/antitrust-policy/ This meeting is being recorded Please Mute unless speaking If you have a question use the raise hand feature Discussion: Besu Incentive Program Goals  Teams free to do what they want with validator value and validator tx fees (rewards)  Keys will be divested over 6 month periods (allowing more and more funds to be withdrawn)  Provide long-term incentives to folks that are building Ethereum Mainnet clients  Offered to all mainnet client teams (execution and consensus)  EF will provide validator keys at a later time depending on incentive program milestones Performance metrics Taken over a monthly time frame Over 95% attestation and block proposal inclusions  Avoid slashing for these validators - slashed validators will be removed from the program Consensus client issues - EF will not penalize execution layer client for consensus issues on the other client  Execution layer has to be quick enough (performant) to create the block  Interoperability  Trust in this process by EF - good faith interop (could use canary nodes for combinations that are less tested) Why Now? Prepping for the Merge Helps measure performance and confirms meeting protocol expectations How do we run this program across the Besu community?  This is a big ask for time from community members - Not all should be forced to be node operators Concerns are: All maintainers can't run a release  Data not shared from ConsenSys with the community Lack of transparency from ConsenSys team on roadmap Money will make this open source project more challenging with the community  PRs that need to be reviewed in timely manner Ideas for Incentivizing Besu community Near term idea: Bounty program Near term idea: Clear benchmarks/requirements for operator validator nodes Medium/long term idea: Besu DAO Next Steps: More detailed document around Incentive Program on Wiki Agenda for next call (potentially off-cycle): Incentive program (30 mins) Cost of running nodes Besu maintainer progress/community concerns (30 mins) Note: We did not have time to address these other items: General Announcements Release updates Release process in general, plan for diversifying who can make a release.(Justin Florentine ) How many maintainers required to sign off on a release? GAR-E - what does it still need to reduce friction? What role (if any) does CircleCI have in releasing? Work Updates Static code analysis (Justin Florentine) Example output here: https://sonarcloud.io/dashboard?id=hyperledger-cicd_besu How do we know when we should turn on build gating? Matrix/Rocketchat discussion asking the community (Grace Hartley (Deactivated))  Fill the survey when is coming out Ongoing Vert.x upgrade Justin Florentine Discussion of the Ethereum Foundation announcement Other Business  Open Forum Design process proposal for further modularization: transaction pooling and block building is a hot topic lately. Justin Florentinewould like to start a design for factoring out block building much like we did with the EVM. What design artifacts should we produce (if any) prior to submitting PRs? Inactivity clause for moving maintainers to emeritus status - the current guide says a quarter of inactivity. Do we want to extend that? 6 months? Longer? > A general measure of inactivity will be no commits or code review comments for one reporting quarter, although this will not be strictly enforced if the maintainer expresses a reasonable intent to continue contributing. Future Topics View recording:    File Modified Labels No labels Preview View PDF File Besu PKI Support.pdf Nov 23, 2021 by Francesco Andreoli Labels No labels Preview View File BESU-2021-12-21-Recording.transcript.vtt Dec 21, 2021 by Ry Jones Labels No labels Preview View Text File BESU-2021-12-21-chat.txt Dec 21, 2021 by Ry Jones Download All Passcode: , multiple selections available, Related content More info Collapse 2021-05-24 Besu Contributor Call 2021-05-24 Besu Contributor Call Besu More like this 2021-11-09 Besu Contributor Call 2021-11-09 Besu Contributor Call Besu More like this 2021-07-06 Besu Contributor Call 2021-07-06 Besu Contributor Call Besu More like this 2021-12-30 Besu Contributor Call (off cycle) 2021-12-30 Besu Contributor Call (off cycle) Besu More like this 2022-01-11 Besu Contributor Call - Off-Cycle 2022-01-11 Besu Contributor Call - Off-Cycle Besu More like this 2022-12-20 Contributor Call 2022-12-20 Contributor Call Besu More like this {"serverDuration": 15, "requestCorrelationId": "cdaf870ec228413cad76709bf7c6cbcc"}