Acta Polytechnica Acta Polytechnica 53(2):219–222, 2013 © Czech Technical University in Prague, 2013 available online at http://ctn.cvut.cz/ap/ VELIKHOV ELECTROTHERMAL INSTABILITY CANCELLATION BY A MODIFICATION OF ELECTRICAL CONDUCTIVITY VALUE IN A STREAMER BY MAGNETIC CONFINEMENT Jean P. Petita, Jean C. Doreb,∗ a Research manager, Lambda Laboratory, France b Technical manager, Lambda Laboratory, France ∗ corresponding author: contact@lambda-laboratory.fr Abstract. We present a method, confirmed experimentally, allowing the cancellation of Velikhov instability by operating a local magnetic field reduction along a lane, which enhances local electric conductivity and electron-gas collision frequency, due to a local passage into a Coulomb collision regime and the subsequent lowering of the Hall parameter below its critical value, close to 2. Keywords: non equilibrium plasmas, MHD, Velikhov instability. 1. Introduction Electrothermal instability was discovered by E. Ve- likhov, a student of Andrei Sakharov. His paper [20], presented at the international MHD congress in New- castle in 1962, announced the complete ruin of the dreams of researchers and engineers working on electric current production processes by direct energy conversion of a fluid. The use of enthalpy associated with a gaseous supersonic flux obtained from hydrocarbon combustion was first considered. Theoretically, a 60 % conversion efficiency was ex- pected. However, problems were caused by the tech- nological constraints due to wall and electrodes behaviour. Effectively, by adding a more easily ionizable substance to the fluid, caesium, its con- ductivity only allowed an acceptable output at tem- peratures above 3000 ◦C. When this MHD energy production was seen to have failed, the Russians pushed the technology to extremes at the Kurtcha- tov Institute in Moscow with the U-25 generator. Its enormous MHD nozzle equipped with Zirco- nium oxyde electrodes only allowed a temperature of 2500 ◦C to be attained. Given the non-linear in- crease of the ionization level according to the tem- perature, these few degrees of difference compared with the 3000 ◦C obliged the abandon of this formula despite the great amount of work done by several coun- tries such as the USA, the UK, France, Germany, Italy, Poland, China and others. Another formula suggested by the American Kerrebrock [2, 3] consisted of aiming at a non-equilibrium operation with a considerably higher electronic temperature than that of the gas, i.e. of the heavy species, as is the case in a fluores- cent tube. Then the MHD regime can be described by writing the energy conservation equation (V × B) · Je = 3 ne k (Te −Tg) ∑ s6=e me ms δs〈ves〉 , where δs refers to an ineslatic loss. This could not be applied to gases issuing from hydrocarbon com- bustion because of the presence of carbon dioxyde which hinders the electronic temperature increase by immediately absorbing the energy and maintaining a thermodynamic equilibrium. It can only concern heat carrying fluids, made up of rare gases seeded with caesium. This formula is seductive and makes use of electromotive fields with a high VB and involves high Hall parameter values. But in 1962 E. Velikhov predicted the appearance of the turbulence affecting the electron gas, making the plasma totally unho- mogenous in a time period comparable to that of the establishment of the ionization itself. This theory was widely verified in laboratories. 2. Experimental 2.1. Experiment in hot gas In 1961 Bert Zauderer [21] used a shock tube as a short duration generator of hot swift rare gases flows, driven into a Faraday MHD converter, and got strong in- teraction parameters, due to the high electrical con- ductivity of Argon at 10 000 K at one bar pressure (3000 Sievert/m). In 1967, using a similar installa- tion, held in the Institute of Fluids Mechanics of Mar- seille, France, J. P. Petit managed [18, 17] to obtain the first and only non-equilibrium electric power pro- duction. The test gas was a mixture of helium and argon, where argon played the role of a seed. The for- mula only allowed experimentation for a maximum of 50 µs but was sufficient to allow a conclusive exper- iment. The idea was to make it that ionization devel- opment, leading the plasma to a Coulomb collision dominated regime, bring about a drop in the Hall pa- rameter to below its critical value of around 2 in such a regime. This method allowed a stable operation to be attained, with a pressure of close to one bar, with a gas temperature of 4000 ◦C and an electronic 219 http://ctn.cvut.cz/ap/ Jean P. Petit, Jean C. Dore Acta Polytechnica Figure 1. Velikhov instability, development and an- nihilation. temperature up to 10 000 ◦C. However calculations showed that it would not be possible to go below. The image (Fig. 1) refers to an experiment managed in a schock driven wind tunnel, coupled to a Faraday MHD converter. Up and down a series of spots show the places of cathodes and anodes. The magnetic field, 2 T, is perpendicular to the plane of the figure. The picture was taken in 1965, using a TRW electronic- optic fast image converter, the first one available in France. The arrow shows the inlet of the fluid. The constant section of the chanel is 5 × 5 cm and the length of the MHD section is 10 cm. We can see clearly on the image that instability begins to ap- pear at the MHD channel’s entry and is then absorbed by the ionisation development itself. This last rises the ion density. When the plasma is Coulomb domi- nated, the Hall parameter, whose value at the entrance is 8, falls below the critical value. This was evoked in a previous paper [10]. This rapid rise of the col- lision frequency, due to large Coulomb cross section damps the Hall parameter, whose value, at the in- let, was close to 8. If this passage to collision dom- inated regime is fast enough, it competes efficiently with the development of the electrothermal instability. In a collision dominated regime, in a two tempera- ture plasma, the critical value of the Hall parameter is close to 2. If β is driven below this value, after the ion- ization is fully developed, the plasma becomes stable. See the right portion of the picture. Formulas giving the critical value of the Hall parameter and growth rate of the instability are given in [10]. In our shock tube this Velikhov instability cancella- tion could not be managed down to 4000 K. In a shock tube the temperature and the gas velocity are closely related. For lower temperatures, the induced electrical field V×B was not strong enough to give the required ionization velocity and too weak to drive the plasma into the Coulomb dominated plasma regime, so that this method was not technologically interesting. 2.2. The impossibility to continue this research. In France, at the end of the sixties, or, for other coun- tries at the beginning of the seventies, the MHD elec- tric power generation was progressively abandonned. Budgets were completely cut, and the author, un- til retired, shifted to kinetic theory of gases, astro- physics and cosmology. After publishing some the- oretical works about electrothermal instability [16] (see also [1]) he discovered in 1981 a second method, for Velikhov instability cancellation, firstly published at the French Academy of Science [8], then pre- sented in the eight international MHD meeting, held in Moscow [6]. He supported this attendance by his own funding. Years passed. Due to the lack of funding J. P. Petit was unable to attend meetings in Tsukuba, Beijing, where his communications were accepted [12, 15] and finally gave up. The explanation of the rarity of publications about Velikhov instability cancellation is the following: this is a key problem for classified research, devoted to MHD controlled hypersonic flight in high altitude. 2.3. Back to experiments in cold plasma He was retired since 5 years when young men sug- gested to restart private MHD research, out of any of- ficial institution. J. C. Doré had some place in his small garage. The team got funding, selling a book of J. P. Petit, and J. C. Doré built a small low pressure test installation. Then the work restarted. Thanks to this original funding system, the men of Lambda Laboratory could buy material and at- tend international meetings. The attention was con- centrated on disk shaped accelerators systems, cor- responding to previously published papers. The set of ideas can be found in the proceedings of refer- ence [11]. The final purpose is to show that shock waves and turbulence can be eliminated around disk- shaped flying machines, by suitable Lorentz force field action [7, 5, 19, 12, 4, 13, 14, 15]. The lack of other papers about this subject deserves the same explana- tion: in highly scientifically advanced countries (USA, Russia) all that stuff corresponds to highly classified research. The successive experimental works achieved by J. C. Doré in his small garage are necessary steps towards this central goal. The Velikhov instability con- trol is just one of them. In 2010 J. C. Doré and J. P. Pe- tit presented a successful wall confinment experiment, close to a disk shaped machine by magnetic pressure gradient inversion [9]. Recently we achieved stable spi- ral current pattern, that will be the next presentation and publication. Back to the present subject the photo (Fig. 2) shows the extremely unhomogenous aspect, connected to the development of instability in low pressure air. The magnetic field, produced by a large coil, is perpendicular to the plane of the figure. The photo (Fig. 2 made in Lambda Laboratory CCD camera F4 1 s) shows the extremely unhomoge- nous aspect, connected to the development of instabil- ity. In the following (Fig. 3 made in Lambda Labora- tory CCD camera F4 1 s) we attenuated the magnetic field in a lane by reducing to 200 Gs. 220 vol. 53 no. 2/2013 Velikhov Electrothermal Instability Cancellation Figure 2. Instability. Figure 3. Controlled instability. 3. Results and Discussion The current was thus incited to take the route of least electric resistance so as to bring the plasma, locally, into a Coulomb dominated regime, where we know that the Hall parameter critical value is then close to 2. The local Hall parameter value becomes, locally, lower than this value, the plasma is then brought into a sta- ble configuration. The experiment aims to create spiral currents in order to obtain a quasi radial force field, even though the local Hall parameter value is low. The discharge geometry is then completely controlled by the magnetic geometry and not by the Hall effect. 4. Conclusion This electrothermal instability is one of the great- est problems of cold, non-equilibrium magnetized plasmas, particularly in relation to the development of equipment used at altitudes well above 30 km, where the flight regime is necessarily hypersonic and where gas flow control towards the ramjets can be done using an MHD controlled inlet. Then Velikhov instability must then be totally cancelled [11]. The in- tention of the Lambda Laboratory team is to extend the research to suck low density gas by Lorentz force action, around a disk shaped MHD aerodyne model. Beyond, we believe that strong sucking action on sur- rounding air can prevent the birth of shock waves and turbulence around a MHD aerodyne, moving in super- sonic, and event hypersonic velocity in air. We think that silent and shockless flight is possible, at super- sonic velocity, in dense air. Acknowledgements This research is solely sponsored by private funds. The au- thors thank all those who support us by private dona- tions and without whom this research would not be pos- sible. The authors thanks their collaborators, members of the Lambda Laboratory: Mathieu Ader, Xavier Lafont and for their technical help: Jacques Legalland, Jacques Juan, . . . References [1] M. G. Haines, A. H. Nelson. Analysis of the growth of electrothermal waves. In 10th symp. on Engineering Aspects of MHD. Cambridge, 1969. [2] J. L. Kerrebrock. Non-equilibrium effects on conductivity and electrode heat transfer in ionized gases. Tech. Rep. technical note 4, AFOSR-165, Guggenheim Jet Propulsion Center, Caltech, Pasadena, California, 1960. [3] J. L. Kerrebrock. Conduction in gases with elevated electron temperature. In Proc. 2nd Symp. Eng. Aspects of MHD, pp. 327–346. 1962. [4] B. Lebrun. Approche theorique de la suppression des ondes de choc se formant autour d’un obstacle effile place dans un ecoulement supersonique d’argon ionise a l’aide de forces de Laplace (Theoretical study of shock wave annihilation around a flat wing in hot supersonic argon flow with Lorentz forces). Aix-Marseille University; Journal of Mechanics, France, 1987. Dir. by J. P. Petit. Engineer-Doctor thesis. [5] J. P. Petit. Convertisseurs MHD d’un genre nouveau (New MHD converters). CRAS, French Academy of Sciences 281(11):157–160, 1975. [6] J. P. Petit. Cancellation of the Velikhov instability by magnetic confinement. In 8th International Conference on the MHD Electrical Power Generation. Moscow, Russia, 1983. [7] J. P. Petit. Is supersonic flight without shock wave possible? In 8th International Conference on MHD Electrical Power Generation. Moscow, Russia, 1983. [8] J. P. Petit, M. Billiotte. Method for eliminating Velikhov instability. CRAS, Academy of Science 1981. [9] J. P. Petit, J. C. Dore. Wall confinement technique by magnetic gradient inversion. In 3rd Euro-Asian Pulsed Power Conference (EAPPC2010). Jeju, Korea, 2010. (and in Acta Polonica A 121(3):611, March 2012). 221 Jean P. Petit, Jean C. Dore Acta Polytechnica [10] J. P. Petit, J. Geffray. Non equilibrium plasma instabilities. In 2nd Euro-Asian Pulsed Power Conference (EAPPC2008). Vilnius, Lithuania, 2008. (and in Acta Physica Polonica A 115(6):1170–1173, June 2009). [11] J. P. Petit, J. Geffray, F. David. MHD hypersonic flow control for aerospace applications. In 16th AIAA/DLR/DGLR International Space Planes and Hypersonic Systems and Technologies Conference (HyTASP). Bremen, Germany, 2009. AIAA-2009-7348. [12] J. P. Petit, B. Lebrun. Shock wave cancellation in gas by Lorentz force action. In 9th International Conference on MHD Electrical Power Generation. Proceedings III, part 14.E – MHD flow, pp. 1359–1368. Tsukuba, Japan, 1986. Article 5. [13] J. P. Petit, B. Lebrun. Shock wave annihilation by MHD action in supersonic flow. Quasi one dimensional steady analysis and thermal blockage. European Journal of Mechanics B/Fluids 8(2):163–178, 1989. [14] J. P. Petit, B. Lebrun. Shock wave annihilation by MHD action in supersonic flows. Two-dimensional steady non-isentropic analysis. Anti-shock criterion, and shock tube simulations for isentropic flows. European Journal of Mechanics B/Fluids 8(4):307–326, 1989. [15] J. P. Petit, B. Lebrun. Theoretical analysis of shock wave anihilation with MHD force field. In 11th International Conference on MHD Electrical Power Generation. Proceedings III, part 9 – Fluid dynamics, pp. 748–753. Beijing, China, 1992. Article 4. [16] J. P. Petit, J. Valensi. Growth rate of electrothermal instability and critical Hall parameter in closed-cycle MHD generators when the electron mobility is variable. CRAS, Academy of Science 269, 1969. [17] J. P. Petit, J. Valensi, J. P. Caressa. Electrical characteristics of a converter using as a conversion fluid a binary mix of rare gases with non-equilibrium ionization. In 8th International Conference on MHD Electrical Power Generation, proceedings 3. International Atomic Energy Agency, Varsovie, Pologne, 1968. [18] J. P. Petit, J. Valensi, J. P. Caressa. Theoretical and experimental study in shock tube of non-equilibrium phenomena in a closed-cycle MHD generator. In 8th International Conference on MHD Electrical Power Generation, proceedings 2, pp. 745–750. International Atomic Energy Agency, Varsovie, Poland, 1968. [19] J. P. Petit, M. Viton. Convertisseurs MHD d’un genre nouveau. Appareils a induction (New MHD converters: induction machines). CRAS, French Academy of Sciences 284:167–179, 1977. [20] E. P. Velikhov. Hall instability of current-carrying clightly-ionized plasmas. In 1st International Symposium on Magnetoplasmadynamics Electrical Power Generation. Newcastle-upon-Tyne, England, 1962. Paper 47. [21] B. Zauderer. Experimental study of non equilibrium ionzation in MHD generators. AIAA Jr 4(6):701–707, 1968. 222 Acta Polytechnica 53(2):219–222, 2013 1 Introduction 2 Experimental 2.1 Experiment in hot gas 2.2 The impossibility to continue this research. 2.3 Back to experiments in cold plasma 3 Results and Discussion 4 Conclusion Acknowledgements References