Impaginato 91 Adv. Hort. Sci., 2021 35(1): 91­96 DOI: 10.13128/ahsc­9681 Warm stratification improves embryos development and seed germination of Cycas revoluta J. Benjelloun, S. Bouzroud (*), Z.E. Triqui, Q. Lahlimi Alami, R. Layachi, A. Smouni, A. Guedira Laboratoire de Biotechnologie et Physiologie Végétales, Centre de Biotechnologie Végétale et Microbienne Biodiversité et Environnement, Faculté des Sciences, Université Mohammed V de Rabat, Morocco. Key words: Cycas revoluta, development, germination, treatment, warm strati­ fication, zygotic embryos. Abstract: The broad objective of this research is to study the effect of warm stratification on Cycas revoluta zygotic embryos length, seed germination and plant development. Four warm treatments were applied to seeds. Our results showed that seeds storage at room temperature or 30°C improved significantly zygotic embryos length. Moreover, time of germination was significantly reduced with the warm stratification. The highest percentage of germination was obtained with seeds warm treated at 30°C for 2 months while only 25% of seeds were able to germinate in the control. Regarding seedlings development, our results demonstrated that warm stratification did not affect plant develop­ ment. No significant differences have been recorded in all the evaluated para­ meters except for root length. Taken together, these results underlined the beneficial effect of warm stratification on Cycas revoluta seed germination and plant development and proposed a new method to improve seed germination of Cycas revoluta. 1. Introduction The sago palm (Cycas revoluta L.) is one of the widespread ornamental trees, grown in temperate, subtropical and tropical regions more precise­ ly in Miyazaki and Kagoshima Prefectures in Kyushu District down to the Ryukyu Islands, Okinawa Prefecture in Japan (Zarchini et al., 2011). Described as one of the most primitive species among the living cycads, Cycas revoluta has been used as an indoor and outdoor landscape plant for centuries (Stevenson, 1990; Jones, 1994). Cycas revoluta is propagated either from seeds, which remain viable for only a short time, or from vegetative offshoots (Demiray et al., 2017). Germination of seed of Cycas revoluta is hard and time consuming (Zarchini et al., 2011). Seeds can take 3 to 9 months to initiate germina­ tion before they can continue to germinate for periods of a year or more. C. revoluta seeds also demonstrates rapid loss of viability and low mor­ (*) Corresponding author: sarah.bouzroud@gmail.com Citation: BENJELLOUN J., BOUZROUD S., TRIQUI Z.E., LAH­ LIMI ALAMI Q., LAYACHI R., SMOUNI A., GUEDIRA A., 2021 ­ Warm stratification improves embryos development and seed germination of Cycas revo‐ luta. ­ Adv. Hort. Sci., 35(1): 91­96 Copyright: © 2021 Benjelloun J., Bouzroud S., Triqui Z.E., Lahlimi Alami Q., Layachi R., Smouni A., Guedira A. This is an open access, peer reviewed article published by Firenze University Press (http://www.fupress.net/index.php/ahs/) and distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited. Data Availability Statement: All relevant data are within the paper and its Supporting Information files. Author Contribution Statement J.B, A.S and A.G.conceived and designed the experiment. J.B., S.B. performed experiments and collected the data. J.B., S.B., Z.T., Q.L.A., and R.L. contributed reagents/materials/analysis tools. J.B., S.B., A.S. and A.G. analyzed data and wrote the manuscript. Competing Interests: The authors declare no competing interests. Received for publication 6 September 2020 Accepted for publication 12 February 2020 AHS Advances in Horticultural Science Short note https://doi.org/10.36253/ahsc-9681 http://www.fupress.net/index.php/ahs/ http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ Adv. Hort. Sci., 2021 35(1): 91­96 92 phogenic potential, which hinder its conservation (NADERI et al., 2015). Breaking dormancy is the main problem faced by all Cycas revoluta (Frett, 1987). Several attempts have been made to overcome with Cycas revoluta seed dormancy problem. Priming treatments of seeds seems to offer a new way to increase seeds germination percentage. Mechanical and chemical scarification has been described widely as an efficient way to improve germination of the hard­seeds species of Cycas and some other species known for their hard­coated seeds (Frett, 1987; Rouhi et al., 2010). Indeed, several studies have reported a great responsiveness of Cycads seeds to various pretreat­ ments, namely, scarification, depulping, exposure to chemical substances like potassium nitrate, gibberel­ lic acid or sulfuric acid or soaking in hot water for specific period of time (Zarchini et al., 2011; Millaku et al., 2012). Warm stratification was also used to improve seed germination of many species such as Sambucus and Symphoricarpos (Baskin et al., 2002). The present study aimed to improve the germination of Cycas revoluta seeds through different warm strat­ ification treatments as a way to develop an efficient in vivo germination protocol for this ornamental species. 2. Materials and Methods Plant material Freshly harvested seeds collected from 50 years old female mature plants grown in Faculty of Sciences garden, University Mohammed V in Rabat (Morocco) were used in this study. Zygotic embryos length measurement Seeds were soaked in water for 48 hours in order to soften the sacrotesta; the orange external layer. The sacrotesta was then removed mechanically with a knife. Seeds were then flamed with ethanol for 2 minutes. Sclerotesta layer was mechanically eliminat­ ed. The megagametophytes were surface sterilized for 20 minutes by soaking in 30% dilution of NaOCl containing 2­3 drops of Tween­20, followed by 3­4 rinses with sterile distilled water. After surface steril­ ization, megagametophytes were pooled, longitudi­ nally bisected and the zygotic embryo (ZE) was excised from each megagametophyte. ZEs length was measured and the mean was calculated from at least 20 biological replicates. Warm stratification treatments and seeds cultivation After removing the sacrotesta mechanically, equal samples of seeds were subjected to different treat­ ments. Treatments consisted in seed storage at room temperature (18­20°C) or 30°C for 2 or 4 months depending on the treatment (Table 1). The warm stratification temperatures were chosen based on previous reports that underlined the beneficial effect of seed storage at 18°C and 30°C on seed’s germina­ tion (Roh et al., 2004; Baldos et al., 2014; Keun et al., 2016). Untreated seeds were cultivated immediately and referred as control treatment (T0). Seeds of Cycas revoluta were then planted in bins containing steril­ ized soil at 2­5 cm depth. Cultures were incubated at 25±2°C, with a photoperiod of 16 hours of light and 8 hours of darkness and watered daily depending on soil moisture. Germination and plant growth parameters recording Weekly observations were performed and seed emergence was recorded after 10 months of cultiva­ tion. The data for the kinetic of germination and time of germination (days) were recorded. Percentage of germination was calculated after ten months of cul­ ture. Number of leaves, stip height and width, root length and the length of the most developed leaf were determined at the end of the experiment. Statistical analysis Zygotic embryos length, time of germination, number of leaves, stip height and width, root length and the length of the most developed leaf were com­ pared using a fixed model of analysis of variance (ANOVA). For each parameter and condition, means were calculated based on at least thirty biological replicates. In case of significant difference between groups, a Tukey test was used for means separation, at risk of 0.05. Table 1 ­ Different heat treatments used to enhance seed ger­ mination of Cycas revoluta Treatment Type of treatment Time of application T0 Control/Untreated 0 hours T1 Room temperature (18­20°C) 2 months T2 30°C 2 months T3 Room temperature (18­20°C) 4 months T4 30°C 4 months Benjelloun et al. ‐ Warm stratification and Cycas revoluta germination 93 3. Results Effect of warm stratification on zygotic embryos length Zygotic embryos (ZEs) length was investigated in the different warm pre­treatments. Our results showed that all the applied treatments (T1, T2, T3 and T4) influenced ZEs length compared with the untreat­ ed seeds (T0) (Fig. 1). ZEs length of seeds subjected to T1, T2, T3 and T4 was significantly enhanced, but no significant difference was observed between T3 and T4 seeds. Indeed, ZEs length increased by 134%, 276%, 300% and 342% in T1, T2, T3 and T4 warm treat­ ed seeds respectively when compared to untreated seeds. Effect of warm stratification on seed’s germination As mean to gain more insight on the effect of warm storage on seed germination, time of germina­ tion (calculated starting from the first day of seeds cultivation), percentage of germination and its kinetic were determined for each treatment. The results were summarized in figures 2, 3 and 4. Effect of warm stratification on the time of germina‐ tion Minimum time of germination (163.33 days) was recorded in seeds stored at 30°C for 4 months fol­ lowed by those stored at 30°C for 2 months (198.19 days) and those stored at room temperature for 4 months (202 days). Note that the difference between these three treatments was statistically insignificant. Untreated seeds (T0) and those stored at room tem­ perature for 2 months (T1) took the maximum time duration for germination with an average of 294.4 days and 256.75 days respectively (Fig. 2). Effect of warm stratification on the percentage of germination Investigating the percentage of germination of seeds from the four different treatments and the untreated ones revealed that seed germination response varied among the different warm treat­ ments. The highest percentage of germination (49.33%) was recorded in seeds stored for 2 months at 30°C while the lowest value of 8% was observed for seeds stored at room temperature for 4 months (Fig. 3). Untreated seeds showed although a percent­ age of germination around 25%. Effect of warm stratification on the kinetic of germi‐ nation Investigating the kinetic of germination revealed a high variability between the different treatments applied (Fig. 4). Our data showed that seeds storage at 30°C for two or four months (T2) allowed seeds to germinate faster. Indeed, seeds started to germinate Fig. 1 ­ Effect of warm stratification treatments on Cycas revolu‐ ta embryos length. (A) Zygotic embryos isolated from seeds subjected to T0, T1, T2, T3 and T4. Scale bars=1 cm. (B) Zygotic embryos length in the different treat­ ments. Bars are mean ± SD of at least thirty biological replicates. Asterisks indicate statistical difference accor­ ding to Tukey test (p<0.05). Fig. 2 ­ Effect of different warm stratification treatments on the time of germination of Cycas revoluta embryos Bars are mean ± SD of at least thirty biological replicates. Asterisks indicate statistical difference according to Tukey test (p<0.05). Adv. Hort. Sci., 2021 35(1): 91­96 94 after four months of culture whereas, the first germi­ nated seeds appeared after five months and 6 months respectively for T1 and T0. Seeds storage at room temperature for four months (T3) delayed the germination by one month compared to untreated seeds (T0). These data joined those related to time of germination. Effect of warm stratification on plant’s growth and development Seeds pre­treatment with temperature affected zygotic embryos length and their germination. These results prompted us to see whether the pre­treat­ ment can influence seedlings growth and develop­ ment. Several growth parameters namely, number of leaves per plant, stip height and width, root length and the length of the most developed leaf were eval­ uated. Table 2 summarized the results. Data analysis had shown that seeds pre­treatment did not affect the number of leaves per plant. Seeds storage for 2 months at 30°C gave a maximum num­ ber of leaves per plant (1.50±0.59) while the lowest value was obtained with T4 treatment (1.14±0.37). Note that these differences remained insignificant. Leaf length was also not significantly affected by the priming treatments. It was found that maximum leaf length was 57.33±3.05 cm in seedlings subjected to T3 treatment while a minimum of 48.22±4.23 cm was recorded with T1 treatment. Stip height showed no significant difference between the different treatments. Stip width, on the other hand, displayed significant variations between the different treatments. A significant increase in stip width was observed in seedlings subjected to T1 and T2 as compared to the control (T0) while non­signifi­ cant changes was observed between the remaining treatments(T3 and T4). Regarding root development, root length showed significant variations between the different treat­ ments. Seeds storage for 2 months at 30°C resulted in a significant increase in root length compared to untreated seeds while a decrease in root length was observed with T3 and T4 treatments. Fig. 3 ­ Effect of different warm stratification treatments on the percentage of germination of Cycas revoluta embryos. Fig. 4 ­ Effect of different warm stratification treatments on the kinetic of germination of Cycas revoluta embryos. Table 2 ­ Effect of different priming treatments on growth parameters of Cycas revoluta seedlings Values are mean ± SD of at least thirty biological replicates. Values with different letters indicate the statistical significance (p<0.05) according to Tukey test. Treatments Number of leaves/plant Stip height (cm) Stip width (cm) Leaf length (cm) Root length (cm) T0 1.31±0.47 a 3±0.47 a 1.81±0.19 b 50.63±6.24 abc 26.62±3.15 bc T1 1.20±0.42 a 3.92±0.32 a 2.10±0.24 a 48.22±4.23 bc 21.60±2.07 cd T2 1.50±0.59 a 3.77±0.45 a 2.15±0.22 a 55.91±4.25 ab 35.42±2.69 a T3 1.33±0.57 a 3.5±0.86 a 1.86±0.30 ab 57.33±3.05 a 31.66±2.31 ab T4 1.14±0.37 a 3.50±0.47 a 1.58±0.15 b 49±5 c 21±3 d Benjelloun et al. ‐ Warm stratification and Cycas revoluta germination 95 4. Discussion and Conclusions Cycas revoluta is an ornamental tree that has been widely used as an indoor and outdoor land­ scape. However, despite its importance in landscape design, it is facing problems regarding its germination mainly due to the hard­coat (Ullah et al., 2020). Different methods have been tested to overcome hardseededness. These include mechanical, chemi­ cal, and physical scarification treatments to make the seed coat permeable for water uptake. Several reports have shown that seeds pre­treatment with sulphuric acid (H2SO4), potassium nitrate (KNO3) or GA3 results in a better germination results. Indeed, Zamia furfuracea and Cycas revoluta germinations were assessed by Schutzman, using a chemical scari­ fication with concentrated H2SO4 and then soaking them in gibberellic acid (GA3) (Schutzman, 1984, 1989). However, these pretreatments are not always reliable with cycads (Dehgan and Yuen, 1983). For instance, Zarchini et al. (2011) have found that the use of sulphuric acid even at lower concentrations seems to affect negatively seed’s germination while combined with hot water seems to improve Cycas revoluta seed germination. It is well admitted that seeds storage in a warm environment usually results in relatively rapid embryos development (Baskin et al., 2002; Merritt et al., 2007; Razavi and Hajiboland, 2009). However, no previous work has been conducted to study the effect of seed storage in warm conditions on Cycas revoluta germination and seedlings development. Thus, we investigated the effect of warm storage on zygotic embryos development, seeds germination and growth of young seedlings of Cycas revoluta. Our results showed that warm storage at 30°C for 2 months or 4 months speeded the germination when compared to the untreated plot (Fig. 2). Seeds stor­ age at 30°C for 2 months improves also the germina­ tion percentage. Meanwhile, the prolonged storage at 30°C for 4 months reduced the germination per­ centage by half compared to the untreated plot which suggest that prolonged storage have an inhibi­ tive effect rather than stimulating the germination (Fig. 3). Chen et al. (2007) have found that Prunus campanulata seeds required 4­6 weeks of warm fol­ lowed by 8 weeks of cold stratification for maximum germination percentage. This finding was explained by the accumulation of high amounts of GA as a result of the cold stratification while GAs in warm stratified embryos were significantly low. Thus, Prunus warm stratified embryos failed to germinate since GAs content was very low. In H. salicornicum and S. imbricate, seeds germination was significantly improved when seeds were stored at 40±2°C for three months (El­Keblawy, 2013). Warm stratification for at least 1 month appeared to be essential for the germination of Japanese snowbell (Styrax japonicus) (Baskin, 2009). Indeed, Roh and Bentz (2003) found that without warm stratification, seeds were not able to germinate. Seed’s dormancy in some orchids, mainly Epipactis palustris and Goodyera pubescens, could be overcame by a warm incubation of seeds followed by cold storage. This was explained by the fact that warm and cold stratification increased seeds permeability to water thereby softening the testa (Roh and Bentz, 2003). Thus, the increase observed in germination percentage could be attributed to the increase of seed’s hard coat permeability caused by the warm storage which allow the removal of the physical barrier to water absorption. Besides the improvement of seeds germination percentage and the reduction of the germination time, warm storage improved significantly zygotic embryos length which suggest that warm scarification result in a better development of zygotic embryos. Regarding seedlings development, our data showed that warm scarification did not affect plant development (Fig. 5). Indeed, no significant differences have been record­ ed in all the evaluated parameters except for root length. Taken together, these results suggest that warm scarification improved seeds development and germination by prompting zygotic embryos length, increasing germination percentage and reducing time of germination. Fig. 5 ­ Cycas revoluta plants obtained from pre­treated seeds with temperature (T1, T2, T3 and T4) and untreated seeds (T0). 96 Adv. Hort. Sci., 2021 35(1): 91­96 This study aims to study the effect of seeds stor­ age at different temperatures on Cycas revoluta seeds germination and development in order to develop an efficient in vivo germination protocol that can be used for mass production of this ornamental tree. Based on our results, we found that seeds storage at 30°C for 2 months or 4 months reduced time of germina­ tion. However, the highest percentage of germination was only assessed when seeds were stored at 30°C for 2 months. Taken together, this protocol repre­ sents a useful and potential method to improve com­ mercial mass propagation of Cycas revoluta. References BALDOS O.C., DEFRANK J., FRAMER M., SAKAMOTO G.S., 2014 ­ Storage humidity and temperature affect dor‐ mancy loss and viability of tanglehead (Heteropogon contortus) seeds. ­ HortSci., 49: 1328­1334. BASKIN C.C., ZACKRISSON O., BASKIN J.M., 2002 ­ Role of warm stratification in promoting germination of seeds of Empetrum hermaphroditum (Empetraceae), a cir‐ cumboreal species with a stony endocarp. ­ Am. J. Bot., 89: 486­493. BASKIN J.M., 2009 ­ The woody plant seed manual. ­ Nativ. Plants J., 10(3): 300­301. CHEN S.Y., CHIEN C.T., CHUNG J.D., YANGY.S., KUO S.R., 2007 ­ Dormancy‐break and germination in seeds of Prunus campanulata (Rosaceae): role of covering layers and changes in concentration of abscisic acid and gib‐ berellins. ­ Seed Sci. Res., 17(1): 21­32. DEHGAN B., YUEN C.K.K.H., 1983 ­ Seed morphology in relation to dispersal, evolution, and propagation of Cycas L. ­ Bot. Gaz., 144(3): 412­418. DEMIRAY H., DEREBOYLU A.E., YAZICI Z.I., BILDIK S., BUL­ BUL K., SENOL S.G., PIRHAN A.F., 2017 ­ In vitro seed germination of Cycas revoluta thunb. ­ Bangladesh J. Bot., 46(2): 559­564. EL­KEBLAWY A., 2013 ­ Effects of seed storage on germina‐ tion of two succulent desert halophytes with little dor‐ mancy and transient seed bank. ­ Acta Ecol. Sin., 33(6): 338­343. FRETT J.J., 1987 ­ Seed germination of Cycas revoluta. ­ J. Environ. Hortic., 5: 105­106. JONES D.L., 1994 ­ Cycads of the world. ­ Smithsonian Inst. Press, Washington, DC, USA, pp. 312. KEUN S.J., HEE K.J., KYUNG L.A., 2016 ­ Effect of warm and cold stratification, and ethanol treatment on germina‐ tion of Corylopsis seeds. ­ Hortic. Sci., 43: 84­91. MERRITT D.J., TURNER S.R., CLARKE S., DIXON K.W., 2007 ­ Seed dormancy and germination stimulation syn‐ dromes for Australian temperate species. ­ Aust. J. Bot., 55: 336­344. MILLAKU F., GASHI B., ABDULLAI K., ALIU S., OSMANI M., KRASNIQI E., MATA V., RYSHA A., 2012 ­ Effects of cold‐ stratification, gibberellic acid and potassium nitrate on seed germination of yellow gentian (Gentiana lutea L.). ­ African J. Biotechnol., 11: 13173­13178. NADERI R., MOHAISENI K., DA SILVA J.A.T., OMIDI M., NADERI B., 2015 ­ Simplified regeneration protocol for Cycas revoluta Thunb. Mature zygotic embryos. ­ Not. Sci. Biol., 7: 62­65. RAZAVI S.M., HAJIBOLAND R., 2009 ­ Dormancy breaking and germination of Prangos ferulaceae seeds. ­ EurAsian J. Biosci., 3: 78­83. ROH M.S., BENTZ J.A., 2003 ­ Germination of styrax japoni‐ cus seeds as influenced by storage and sowing condi‐ tions. ­ Acta Horticulturae, 620: 411­416. ROH M.S., BENTZ J.A., WANG P., ERCHENG L.I., KOSHIOKA M., 2004 ­ Maturity and temperature stratification affect the germination of Styrax japonicus seeds. ­ J. Hortic. Sci. Biotechnol., 79(4): 645­651. ROUHI H.R., AFSHARI R.T., SHAKARAMI K., 2010 ­ Seed treatments to overcome dormancy of waterlily tulip (Tulipa kaufmanniana Regel.). ­ Aust. J. Crop Sci. 4(9): 718­721. SCHUTZMAN B., 1984 ­ A new species of Zamia L. (Zamiaceae, Cycadales) from Chiapas, Mexico. ­ Phytologia, 55: 299­304. SCHUTZMAN B., 1989 ­ A new species of Zamia from Honduras. ­ Syst. Bot., 14(2): 214­219. STEVENSON D.W., 1990 ­ Morphology and systematics of the Cycadales. ­ Mem. New York Bot. Gard., 57: 8­55. ULLAH Z., HASSAN I., HAFIZ I.A., ABBASI N.A., 2020 ­ Effect of different priming treatments on seed germination of sago palm (Cycas revoluta L.). ­ World J. Biol. Biotechnol., 5: 1­3. ZARCHINI M., HASHEMABADI D., KAVIANI B., FALLAHABA­ DI P.R., NEGAHDAR N., 2011 ­ Improved germination conditions in Cycas revoluta L. by using sulfuric acid and hot water. ­ Plant Omics., 4(7): 350­353.