id	sid	eid	entity	type
tahrj-8305	1	1	22	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	1	2	june 2024	DATE
tahrj-8305	1	3	2340-9592	DATE
tahrj-8305	1	4	10.17561/tahrj.v22.8305 1	MONEY
tahrj-8305	1	5	chadha2	PERSON
tahrj-8305	1	6	tyagi3	PERSON
tahrj-8305	1	7	srivastava4	PERSON
tahrj-8305	1	8	indian	NORP
tahrj-8305	3	1	one	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	7	1	mens rea	PERSON
tahrj-8305	8	1	i.	PERSON
tahrj-8305	12	1	article 19(1)(a	LAW
tahrj-8305	12	2	indian	NORP
tahrj-8305	13	1	india	GPE
tahrj-8305	15	1	article 19(1)(a	LAW
tahrj-8305	15	2	article 19(2	LAW
tahrj-8305	15	3	indian	NORP
tahrj-8305	16	1	1	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	16	2	university of delhi	ORG
tahrj-8305	16	3	2	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	16	4	op jindal global university	ORG
tahrj-8305	16	5	haryana	GPE
tahrj-8305	16	6	india	GPE
tahrj-8305	16	7	vchadha@jgu.edu.in	GPE
tahrj-8305	17	1	3	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	17	2	the supreme court of india	ORG
tahrj-8305	17	3	4	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	17	4	indian	NORP
tahrj-8305	17	5	john s dryzek	PERSON
tahrj-8305	17	6	oxford university press	ORG
tahrj-8305	17	7	2000	DATE
tahrj-8305	17	8	6	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	17	9	india	GPE
tahrj-8305	19	1	http://doi.org/10.17561/tahrj.v22.8305 mailto:vijaytyagi31@gmail.com	PERSON
tahrj-8305	19	2	mailto:vchadha@jgu.edu.in mailto:tyagilavam97@gmail.com mailto:shambhavi.srivastava96@gmail.com	PERSON
tahrj-8305	19	3	22	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	19	4	june 2024	DATE
tahrj-8305	19	5	2340-9592	DATE
tahrj-8305	19	6	10.17561/tahrj.v22.8305 2	MONEY
tahrj-8305	19	7	the “proteus of the	EVENT
tahrj-8305	19	8	india	GPE
tahrj-8305	19	9	justice	ORG
tahrj-8305	19	10	british	NORP
tahrj-8305	21	1	1774,9	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	21	2	21	DATE
tahrj-8305	21	3	the supreme court of bengal	ORG
tahrj-8305	22	1	186110	DATE
tahrj-8305	23	1	9	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	24	1	1865,11	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	25	1	first	ORDINAL
tahrj-8305	25	2	indian	NORP
tahrj-8305	25	3	1926.12	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	26	1	postindependence	PERSON
tahrj-8305	26	2	the supreme court of india	ORG
tahrj-8305	26	3	12913	DATE
tahrj-8305	26	4	21514	DATE
tahrj-8305	27	1	article 19(2)15 on the right	LAW
tahrj-8305	27	2	article 19(1)(a)16 of the constitution	LAW
tahrj-8305	28	1	195217	DATE
tahrj-8305	28	2	1926	DATE
tahrj-8305	29	1	1952	DATE
tahrj-8305	29	2	shri h.n.	ORG
tahrj-8305	29	3	india	GPE
tahrj-8305	31	1	february 28, 1963	DATE
tahrj-8305	31	2	197119	DATE
tahrj-8305	32	1	7	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	32	2	j. moskovitz	PERSON
tahrj-8305	32	3	43	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	32	4	l. rev	PERSON
tahrj-8305	32	5	8	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	32	6	shekhar dutta & amba	ORG
tahrj-8305	32	7	2	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	32	8	l. rev	PERSON
tahrj-8305	32	9	2009	DATE
tahrj-8305	32	10	9	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	32	11	1774	DATE
tahrj-8305	32	12	21	DATE
tahrj-8305	32	13	63	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	32	14	1774	DATE
tahrj-8305	32	15	united kingdom	GPE
tahrj-8305	32	16	india	GPE
tahrj-8305	32	17	10	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	32	18	indian	NORP
tahrj-8305	32	19	1861	DATE
tahrj-8305	32	20	11	DATE
tahrj-8305	32	21	1861	DATE
tahrj-8305	32	22	united kingdom	GPE
tahrj-8305	32	23	india	GPE
tahrj-8305	32	24	11	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	32	25	1865	DATE
tahrj-8305	32	26	15	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	32	27	united kingdom	GPE
tahrj-8305	32	28	india	GPE
tahrj-8305	32	29	12	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	32	30	1926	DATE
tahrj-8305	32	31	12	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	32	32	1926	DATE
tahrj-8305	32	33	13	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	32	34	india	GPE
tahrj-8305	34	1	129	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	34	2	14	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	34	3	india	GPE
tahrj-8305	36	1	215	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	36	2	15	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	36	3	india	GPE
tahrj-8305	38	1	19(2	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	38	2	16	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	38	3	india	GPE
tahrj-8305	39	1	19(1)(a	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	39	2	17	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	39	3	1952	DATE
tahrj-8305	39	4	32	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	39	5	1952	DATE
tahrj-8305	39	6	india	GPE
tahrj-8305	39	7	18	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	39	8	sanyal committee	ORG
tahrj-8305	40	1	h.d	ORG
tahrj-8305	40	2	153	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	40	3	61	DATE
tahrj-8305	40	4	1963	DATE
tahrj-8305	40	5	19	DATE
tahrj-8305	40	6	1971	DATE
tahrj-8305	40	7	70	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	40	8	1952	DATE
tahrj-8305	40	9	india	GPE
tahrj-8305	40	10	http://doi.org/10.17561/tahrj.v22.8305 vijay k. tyagi	GPE
tahrj-8305	40	11	vaibhav chadha	PERSON
tahrj-8305	40	12	tyagi	ORG
tahrj-8305	40	13	shambhavi srivastava	PERSON
tahrj-8305	40	14	22	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	40	15	june 2024	DATE
tahrj-8305	40	16	2340-9592	DATE
tahrj-8305	40	17	10.17561/tahrj.v22.8305 3	MONEY
tahrj-8305	40	18	1971	DATE
tahrj-8305	40	19	justice	ORG
tahrj-8305	42	1	section 2(b	LAW
tahrj-8305	43	1	section 2(c	LAW
tahrj-8305	44	1	three	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	45	1	third	ORDINAL
tahrj-8305	46	1	india	GPE
tahrj-8305	49	1	iii highlights	PERSON
tahrj-8305	50	1	20	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	50	2	agra v. rohtas	ORG
tahrj-8305	50	3	singh	GPE
tahrj-8305	50	4	1998	DATE
tahrj-8305	50	5	4	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	50	6	409	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	50	7	21	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	50	8	supreme court bar association v. union of india & anr.	ORG
tahrj-8305	51	1	1998	DATE
tahrj-8305	51	2	4	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	51	3	409	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	51	4	22	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	51	5	1971	DATE
tahrj-8305	51	6	15	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	51	7	23	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	51	8	1971	DATE
tahrj-8305	51	9	15	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	51	10	2(c	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	51	11	24	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	51	12	pratap singh v. ajit prasad	ORG
tahrj-8305	51	13	1966	DATE
tahrj-8305	52	1	305	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	52	2	22	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	52	3	june 2024	DATE
tahrj-8305	52	4	2340-9592	DATE
tahrj-8305	52	5	10.17561/tahrj.v22.8305 4	MONEY
tahrj-8305	52	6	mens rea element	PERSON
tahrj-8305	56	1	hardwicke	PERSON
tahrj-8305	56	2	1742	DATE
tahrj-8305	58	1	justice wilmot	ORG
tahrj-8305	58	2	wilkes case27	GPE
tahrj-8305	58	3	1765	DATE
tahrj-8305	59	1	wilmot	PERSON
tahrj-8305	60	1	the supreme court of india	ORG
tahrj-8305	60	2	judges30	GPE
tahrj-8305	62	1	the supreme court of india	ORG
tahrj-8305	62	2	india	GPE
tahrj-8305	62	3	indians	NORP
tahrj-8305	62	4	the supreme court of india	ORG
tahrj-8305	62	5	justice	ORG
tahrj-8305	63	1	harijai,34	GPE
tahrj-8305	63	2	the supreme court of india	ORG
tahrj-8305	64	1	bhushan case,35	PERSON
tahrj-8305	64	2	the supreme court of india	ORG
tahrj-8305	64	3	25	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	64	4	2	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	64	5	291	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	64	6	469 26	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	64	7	borric & lowe	ORG
tahrj-8305	64	8	3rd	ORDINAL
tahrj-8305	64	9	331	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	64	10	1996	DATE
tahrj-8305	64	11	27	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	64	12	1765	DATE
tahrj-8305	64	13	243 28	DATE
tahrj-8305	64	14	arundhati roy	PERSON
tahrj-8305	64	15	air 2002 sc 1375	ORG
tahrj-8305	64	16	brahma prakash sharma & ors.	ORG
tahrj-8305	65	1	uttar pradesh	ORG
tahrj-8305	65	2	1953 scr 1169	DATE
tahrj-8305	65	3	s. mulgaokar	PERSON
tahrj-8305	65	4	1978	DATE
tahrj-8305	65	5	3	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	65	6	339	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	66	1	namboodripad	PERSON
tahrj-8305	66	2	t. narayan	ORG
tahrj-8305	66	3	1970	DATE
tahrj-8305	66	4	2	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	66	5	325	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	66	6	maharashtra, air 1970 sc	ORG
tahrj-8305	66	7	221	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	66	8	r.k.	GPE
tahrj-8305	66	9	anand v. registrar	PERSON
tahrj-8305	66	10	delhi high court	ORG
tahrj-8305	66	11	2009	DATE
tahrj-8305	66	12	8	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	66	13	106 29	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	66	14	trinidad	GPE
tahrj-8305	66	15	tobago	GPE
tahrj-8305	66	16	1981	DATE
tahrj-8305	66	17	1	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	66	18	244	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	66	19	248 30	DATE
tahrj-8305	66	20	gallagher v. durack	PERSON
tahrj-8305	66	21	1983	DATE
tahrj-8305	66	22	152	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	66	23	238	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	66	24	243 31	DATE
tahrj-8305	66	25	4	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	66	26	55 32	DATE
tahrj-8305	66	27	abhinav chandrachud	PERSON
tahrj-8305	66	28	16	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	66	29	2017	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	66	30	33	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	66	31	dayal markarha	ORG
tahrj-8305	66	32	madhya pradesh	LOC
tahrj-8305	66	33	1978	DATE
tahrj-8305	66	34	921 34	DATE
tahrj-8305	66	35	harijai	PERSON
tahrj-8305	66	36	singh	GPE
tahrj-8305	66	37	anr	ORG
tahrj-8305	66	38	air 1997 sc	ORG
tahrj-8305	66	39	73 35	TIME
tahrj-8305	66	40	prashant bhushan	PERSON
tahrj-8305	66	41	ors.	GPE
tahrj-8305	66	42	air 2020 sc 4114	ORG
tahrj-8305	66	43	http://doi.org/10.17561/tahrj.v22.8305 vijay k. tyagi	PERSON
tahrj-8305	66	44	vaibhav chadha	PERSON
tahrj-8305	66	45	tyagi	ORG
tahrj-8305	66	46	shambhavi srivastava	PERSON
tahrj-8305	66	47	22	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	66	48	june 2024	DATE
tahrj-8305	66	49	2340-9592	DATE
tahrj-8305	66	50	10.17561/tahrj.v22.8305 5	MONEY
tahrj-8305	66	51	the supreme court of india	ORG
tahrj-8305	67	1	millions	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	67	2	millions	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	69	1	uncertainty.36	GPE
tahrj-8305	69	2	the supreme court of india	ORG
tahrj-8305	69	3	article 12937 and	LAW
tahrj-8305	69	4	article 21538 of the constitution respectively	LAW
tahrj-8305	70	1	129	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	70	2	215	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	70	3	1971	DATE
tahrj-8305	71	1	the supreme court of india	ORG
tahrj-8305	71	2	1971.40	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	73	1	the supreme court of india	ORG
tahrj-8305	76	1	the supreme court of india	ORG
tahrj-8305	76	2	two	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	79	1	36	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	79	2	fali s. nariman	PERSON
tahrj-8305	79	3	2	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	79	4	nja	ORG
tahrj-8305	79	5	january 2004	DATE
tahrj-8305	79	6	37	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	80	1	129	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	80	2	38	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	80	3	india	GPE
tahrj-8305	82	1	215	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	82	2	39	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	82	3	sebi	GPE
tahrj-8305	82	4	air 2012 sc 3829	ORG
tahrj-8305	82	5	r.k.	GPE
tahrj-8305	82	6	anand v. registrar	PERSON
tahrj-8305	82	7	delhi high court	ORG
tahrj-8305	82	8	2009	DATE
tahrj-8305	82	9	8	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	82	10	106 40	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	82	11	jabalpur	GPE
tahrj-8305	82	12	1993	DATE
tahrj-8305	82	13	supp	GPE
tahrj-8305	83	1	1	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	83	2	41	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	83	3	vinay chandra mishra	PERSON
tahrj-8305	83	4	air 1995 sc	ORG
tahrj-8305	83	5	2348 42	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	83	6	sukhdev	GPE
tahrj-8305	83	7	singh	GPE
tahrj-8305	83	8	1954	DATE
tahrj-8305	83	9	156 43	QUANTITY
tahrj-8305	83	10	brahma prakash sharma	PERSON
tahrj-8305	83	11	supra	PERSON
tahrj-8305	83	12	24	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	83	13	baradakanta mishra	PERSON
tahrj-8305	83	14	orissa high court	ORG
tahrj-8305	83	15	1974	DATE
tahrj-8305	83	16	710 44	DATE
tahrj-8305	83	17	p.n. duda v. v.p. shankar & ors.	PERSON
tahrj-8305	83	18	1988	DATE
tahrj-8305	83	19	1208	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	83	20	22	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	83	21	june 2024	DATE
tahrj-8305	83	22	2340-9592	DATE
tahrj-8305	83	23	10.17561/tahrj.v22.8305 6	MONEY
tahrj-8305	83	24	suo moto	ORG
tahrj-8305	84	1	section 15(1	LAW
tahrj-8305	84	2	197145	DATE
tahrj-8305	88	1	the supreme court of india	ORG
tahrj-8305	88	2	prashant bhushan	PERSON
tahrj-8305	88	3	four	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	90	1	one	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	90	2	patrick anthony chinamasa,51	PERSON
tahrj-8305	90	3	the supreme court	ORG
tahrj-8305	90	4	zimbabwe	GPE
tahrj-8305	93	1	45	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	93	2	1971	DATE
tahrj-8305	93	3	15	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	93	4	15(1	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	93	5	46	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	93	6	17	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	93	7	rakesh shukla	PERSON
tahrj-8305	93	8	indian	NORP
tahrj-8305	93	9	5	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	93	10	48 prashant bhushan	QUANTITY
tahrj-8305	93	11	supra	PERSON
tahrj-8305	93	12	31	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	94	1	ranjan gogoi	PERSON
tahrj-8305	94	2	14 june 2021	DATE
tahrj-8305	94	3	50	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	94	4	nja	ORG
tahrj-8305	94	5	supra	PERSON
tahrj-8305	94	6	32 51	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	94	7	s.c. 113/2000	ORG
tahrj-8305	94	8	6	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	94	9	november 2000	DATE
tahrj-8305	95	1	s.c. 113/2000	ORG
tahrj-8305	95	2	6 november 2000	DATE
tahrj-8305	96	1	53	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	97	1	20	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	97	2	http://doi.org/10.17561/tahrj.v22.8305 https://thewire.in/law/contempt-powers-of-indian-courts-dont-measure-up-to-the-principles-of-natural-justice https://thewire.in/law/contempt-powers-of-indian-courts-dont-measure-up-to-the-principles-of-natural-justice https://www.livelaw.in/top-stories/who-goes-to-court-ex-cji-ranjan-gogoi-says-judiciary-is-ramshackled-169809	ORG
tahrj-8305	97	3	vijay	NORP
tahrj-8305	97	4	k. tyagi	PERSON
tahrj-8305	97	5	vaibhav chadha	PERSON
tahrj-8305	97	6	tyagi	ORG
tahrj-8305	97	7	shambhavi srivastava	PERSON
tahrj-8305	97	8	22	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	97	9	june 2024	DATE
tahrj-8305	97	10	2340-9592	DATE
tahrj-8305	97	11	10.17561/tahrj.v22.8305 7	MONEY
tahrj-8305	100	1	j.	PERSON
tahrj-8305	100	2	australian	NORP
tahrj-8305	100	3	nsw	ORG
tahrj-8305	100	4	mundey,55	PRODUCT
tahrj-8305	105	1	four	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	105	2	the supreme court of india	ORG
tahrj-8305	106	1	4	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	106	2	india	GPE
tahrj-8305	107	1	first	ORDINAL
tahrj-8305	107	2	two	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	107	3	second	ORDINAL
tahrj-8305	108	1	next three	DATE
tahrj-8305	108	2	two	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	109	1	namboodripad	PERSON
tahrj-8305	109	2	p.n.	GPE
tahrj-8305	109	3	first	ORDINAL
tahrj-8305	110	1	the supreme court of india	ORG
tahrj-8305	110	2	kerala	GPE
tahrj-8305	111	1	indian	NORP
tahrj-8305	111	2	54	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	111	3	2002	DATE
tahrj-8305	111	4	20 55	DATE
tahrj-8305	111	5	1972	DATE
tahrj-8305	111	6	2	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	111	7	887 56	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	112	1	908	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	112	2	57	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	112	3	supra	PERSON
tahrj-8305	112	4	24	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	112	5	22	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	112	6	june 2024	DATE
tahrj-8305	112	7	2340-9592	DATE
tahrj-8305	112	8	10.17561/tahrj.v22.8305 8	MONEY
tahrj-8305	114	1	the supreme court	ORG
tahrj-8305	114	2	marx	PERSON
tahrj-8305	115	1	article 19(1)(a	LAW
tahrj-8305	116	1	marx	PERSON
tahrj-8305	116	2	lenin	PERSON
tahrj-8305	116	3	marx	PERSON
tahrj-8305	116	4	engel	PERSON
tahrj-8305	117	1	about two decades later	DATE
tahrj-8305	117	2	the supreme court of india	ORG
tahrj-8305	117	3	p.n.	GPE
tahrj-8305	117	4	shiv shankar wherein	ORG
tahrj-8305	117	5	the supreme court	ORG
tahrj-8305	117	6	article 31	LAW
tahrj-8305	118	1	the supreme court of india	ORG
tahrj-8305	119	1	the supreme court	ORG
tahrj-8305	119	2	cooper	PERSON
tahrj-8305	120	1	the supreme court	ORG
tahrj-8305	122	1	namboodripad	GPE
tahrj-8305	123	1	the supreme court of india	ORG
tahrj-8305	123	2	the supreme court	ORG
tahrj-8305	124	1	justice	ORG
tahrj-8305	125	1	namboodripad	GPE
tahrj-8305	125	2	marx	PERSON
tahrj-8305	126	1	58	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	126	2	1970	DATE
tahrj-8305	126	3	2015 59	DATE
tahrj-8305	126	4	shiv shankar	PERSON
tahrj-8305	126	5	supra	PERSON
tahrj-8305	127	1	40	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	127	2	60 1988	DATE
tahrj-8305	127	3	61	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	127	4	sathe	ORG
tahrj-8305	127	5	the supreme court	ORG
tahrj-8305	127	6	37	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	127	7	1384	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	127	8	2002	DATE
tahrj-8305	127	9	k. tyagi	PERSON
tahrj-8305	127	10	vaibhav chadha	PERSON
tahrj-8305	127	11	tyagi	ORG
tahrj-8305	127	12	shambhavi srivastava	PERSON
tahrj-8305	127	13	22	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	127	14	june 2024	DATE
tahrj-8305	127	15	2340-9592	DATE
tahrj-8305	127	16	10.17561/tahrj.v22.8305 9	MONEY
tahrj-8305	128	1	hari singh nagra	PERSON
tahrj-8305	128	2	prashant bhushan	PERSON
tahrj-8305	128	3	the supreme court of india	ORG
tahrj-8305	129	1	hari singh	GPE
tahrj-8305	129	2	the supreme court of india	ORG
tahrj-8305	129	3	kapil sibal	PERSON
tahrj-8305	130	1	the supreme court of india	ORG
tahrj-8305	130	2	the supreme court	ORG
tahrj-8305	132	1	the supreme court of india	ORG
tahrj-8305	132	2	arundhati	PERSON
tahrj-8305	137	1	the supreme court of india	ORG
tahrj-8305	138	1	arundhati roy,65	PERSON
tahrj-8305	140	1	the supreme court of india	ORG
tahrj-8305	140	2	50 lakh motorcycle	MONEY
tahrj-8305	140	3	62	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	140	4	hari singh nagra & ors	ORG
tahrj-8305	141	1	kapil sibal & ors.	PERSON
tahrj-8305	141	2	2011	DATE
tahrj-8305	141	3	cri lj 102	PERSON
tahrj-8305	141	4	63	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	141	5	air 2002 sc	ORG
tahrj-8305	142	1	1375 64	DATE
tahrj-8305	144	1	66	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	144	2	prashant bhushan	PERSON
tahrj-8305	144	3	supra	PERSON
tahrj-8305	144	4	31	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	144	5	22	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	144	6	june 2024	DATE
tahrj-8305	144	7	2340-9592	DATE
tahrj-8305	144	8	10.17561/tahrj.v22.8305 10	MONEY
tahrj-8305	144	9	the 6 years	DATE
tahrj-8305	144	10	india	GPE
tahrj-8305	144	11	the supreme court	ORG
tahrj-8305	144	12	4	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	145	1	justice	ORG
tahrj-8305	147	1	30 years	DATE
tahrj-8305	147	2	the supreme court of india	ORG
tahrj-8305	147	3	arundhati	GPE
tahrj-8305	147	4	the supreme court of india	ORG
tahrj-8305	148	1	hari singh nagra,68	ORG
tahrj-8305	152	1	mens rea	PERSON
tahrj-8305	152	2	mens rea	PERSON
tahrj-8305	152	3	the actus reus	ORG
tahrj-8305	154	1	mens rea	PERSON
tahrj-8305	157	1	iv.i	ORG
tahrj-8305	159	1	section 5	LAW
tahrj-8305	159	2	1971	DATE
tahrj-8305	160	1	section 13(b	LAW
tahrj-8305	160	2	67	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	160	3	arundhati	GPE
tahrj-8305	160	4	supra	PERSON
tahrj-8305	161	1	59	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	161	2	68	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	161	3	hari singh nagra	ORG
tahrj-8305	161	4	58 69	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	161	5	mrityunjoy das & anr	ORG
tahrj-8305	162	1	sayed hasibur rahaman & ors.	ORG
tahrj-8305	162	2	air 2001	ORG
tahrj-8305	162	3	1293 70	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	162	4	1971	DATE
tahrj-8305	162	5	15	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	162	6	5	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	162	7	http://doi.org/10.17561/tahrj.v22.8305 vijay k. tyagi	PERSON
tahrj-8305	162	8	vaibhav chadha	PERSON
tahrj-8305	162	9	tyagi	ORG
tahrj-8305	162	10	shambhavi srivastava	PERSON
tahrj-8305	162	11	22	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	162	12	june 2024	DATE
tahrj-8305	162	13	2340-9592	DATE
tahrj-8305	162	14	10.17561/tahrj.v22.8305 11	MONEY
tahrj-8305	163	1	”71	GPE
tahrj-8305	164	1	two	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	164	2	section 8	LAW
tahrj-8305	164	3	1971	DATE
tahrj-8305	165	1	mens rea	GPE
tahrj-8305	165	2	the supreme court of india	ORG
tahrj-8305	165	3	section 8	LAW
tahrj-8305	167	1	one	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	168	1	justice shah	PERSON
tahrj-8305	170	1	1923	DATE
tahrj-8305	171	1	ten years later	DATE
tahrj-8305	174	1	two	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	175	1	indian	NORP
tahrj-8305	175	2	mens rea	GPE
tahrj-8305	176	1	one	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	176	2	first	ORDINAL
tahrj-8305	176	3	the supreme court of india	ORG
tahrj-8305	176	4	brahm prakash	PERSON
tahrj-8305	178	1	the supreme court of india	ORG
tahrj-8305	178	2	1969	DATE
tahrj-8305	178	3	71	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	178	4	72	DATE
tahrj-8305	178	5	1923	DATE
tahrj-8305	178	6	25	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	178	7	bom lr	PERSON
tahrj-8305	178	8	15 74	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	179	1	ishwardas shah v. emperor	PERSON
tahrj-8305	179	2	1933	DATE
tahrj-8305	179	3	bom	ORG
tahrj-8305	179	4	96 75	QUANTITY
tahrj-8305	179	5	brahma prakash sharma	PERSON
tahrj-8305	179	6	supra	PERSON
tahrj-8305	179	7	24 76	DATE
tahrj-8305	179	8	namboodripad	GPE
tahrj-8305	179	9	supra	PERSON
tahrj-8305	180	1	24	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	180	2	22	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	180	3	june 2024	DATE
tahrj-8305	180	4	2340-9592	DATE
tahrj-8305	180	5	10.17561/tahrj.v22.8305 12	MONEY
tahrj-8305	182	1	1971	DATE
tahrj-8305	182	2	section 8 of the act	LAW
tahrj-8305	183	1	1971	DATE
tahrj-8305	184	1	s.	PERSON
tahrj-8305	184	2	one	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	184	3	the 1970s decade	DATE
tahrj-8305	184	4	1971	DATE
tahrj-8305	184	5	krishna iyer j.	PERSON
tahrj-8305	184	6	the supreme court of india	ORG
tahrj-8305	184	7	six	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	185	1	sixth	ORDINAL
tahrj-8305	186	1	krishna iyer j.	PERSON
tahrj-8305	187	1	krishna iyer	PERSON
tahrj-8305	189	1	one	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	193	1	the supreme court of india	ORG
tahrj-8305	194	1	the supreme court	ORG
tahrj-8305	194	2	77	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	194	3	1978	DATE
tahrj-8305	194	4	3	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	194	5	339 78 mulgaokar	QUANTITY
tahrj-8305	194	6	73	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	194	7	33 79	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	195	1	17 80	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	195	2	36	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	195	3	http://doi.org/10.17561/tahrj.v22.8305 vijay k. tyagi	PERSON
tahrj-8305	195	4	vaibhav chadha	PERSON
tahrj-8305	195	5	tyagi	ORG
tahrj-8305	195	6	shambhavi srivastava	PERSON
tahrj-8305	195	7	22	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	195	8	june 2024	DATE
tahrj-8305	195	9	2340-9592	DATE
tahrj-8305	195	10	10.17561/tahrj.v22.8305 13	MONEY
tahrj-8305	195	11	india	GPE
tahrj-8305	195	12	v. butterworth,81	PERSON
tahrj-8305	195	13	justice	ORG
tahrj-8305	196	1	d.c	GPE
tahrj-8305	197	1	saxena,82 the supreme court of india	ORG
tahrj-8305	197	2	mens rea	GPE
tahrj-8305	197	3	section 2(c	LAW
tahrj-8305	199	1	justice	ORG
tahrj-8305	200	1	2016	DATE
tahrj-8305	200	2	the supreme court of india	ORG
tahrj-8305	200	3	singh	GPE
tahrj-8305	201	1	prashant bhushan,85	PERSON
tahrj-8305	201	2	eighteen	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	204	1	the supreme court of india	ORG
tahrj-8305	204	2	sen,87	ORG
tahrj-8305	205	1	81	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	205	2	1963	DATE
tahrj-8305	205	3	1	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	205	4	696	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	205	5	82 1996	DATE
tahrj-8305	205	6	7	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	205	7	216	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	205	8	40 84	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	205	9	singh rana v. state	PERSON
tahrj-8305	205	10	u.p.	GPE
tahrj-8305	205	11	2016	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	205	12	8	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	205	13	335 85	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	205	14	prashant bhushan	PERSON
tahrj-8305	206	1	supra	PERSON
tahrj-8305	206	2	31 86	DATE
tahrj-8305	206	3	v. op gupta	PERSON
tahrj-8305	206	4	1971	DATE
tahrj-8305	206	5	1132	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	206	6	hira lal dixit	PERSON
tahrj-8305	206	7	1955 1	DATE
tahrj-8305	206	8	677	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	206	9	brahma prakash sharma	PERSON
tahrj-8305	206	10	supra	PERSON
tahrj-8305	206	11	24	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	206	12	73	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	206	13	36	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	207	1	d.c	GPE
tahrj-8305	207	2	saxena	PERSON
tahrj-8305	207	3	78	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	207	4	prashant bhushan	PERSON
tahrj-8305	207	5	supra	PERSON
tahrj-8305	207	6	31	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	207	7	48	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	207	8	harv l. rev	PERSON
tahrj-8305	207	9	885	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	207	10	898 87	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	207	11	1970	DATE
tahrj-8305	207	12	sc 1821	EVENT
tahrj-8305	207	13	22	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	207	14	june 2024	DATE
tahrj-8305	207	15	2340-9592	DATE
tahrj-8305	207	16	10.17561/tahrj.v22.8305 14	MONEY
tahrj-8305	210	1	section 13(a	LAW
tahrj-8305	210	2	india	GPE
tahrj-8305	213	1	india	GPE
tahrj-8305	213	2	india	GPE
tahrj-8305	213	3	india	GPE
tahrj-8305	215	1	article 19(1)(a	LAW
tahrj-8305	216	1	two	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	216	2	88	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	216	3	supra	PERSON
tahrj-8305	216	4	83	DATE
tahrj-8305	216	5	8-9 89	PERCENT
tahrj-8305	216	6	1971	DATE
tahrj-8305	216	7	15	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	216	8	90	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	216	9	india	GPE
tahrj-8305	216	10	4	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	216	11	u.c.l.a.l.r	DATE
tahrj-8305	217	1	64	DATE
tahrj-8305	217	2	1957	DATE
tahrj-8305	217	3	91	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	217	4	rajeev dhawan & balbir singh	ORG
tahrj-8305	217	5	the supreme court	ORG
tahrj-8305	217	6	21	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	217	7	1,	PERCENT
tahrj-8305	217	8	8 (1979	DATE
tahrj-8305	217	9	92	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	217	10	anuradha bhasin v. union	PERSON
tahrj-8305	217	11	india	GPE
tahrj-8305	217	12	2020	DATE
tahrj-8305	217	13	sc 25	FAC
tahrj-8305	217	14	justice k.s. puttuswamy v. union	PERSON
tahrj-8305	217	15	india	GPE
tahrj-8305	217	16	2019	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	217	17	1	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	217	18	hira lal dixit	PERSON
tahrj-8305	217	19	82	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	217	20	82	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	217	21	baradakanta mishra	PERSON
tahrj-8305	217	22	supra	PERSON
tahrj-8305	217	23	39	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	217	24	brahma prakash sharma	PERSON
tahrj-8305	217	25	supra	PERSON
tahrj-8305	217	26	24	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	217	27	prashant bhushan	PERSON
tahrj-8305	217	28	supra	PERSON
tahrj-8305	217	29	31	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	217	30	http://doi.org/10.17561/tahrj.v22.8305 vijay k. tyagi	PERSON
tahrj-8305	217	31	vaibhav chadha	PERSON
tahrj-8305	217	32	tyagi	ORG
tahrj-8305	217	33	shambhavi srivastava	PERSON
tahrj-8305	217	34	22	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	217	35	june 2024	DATE
tahrj-8305	217	36	2340-9592	DATE
tahrj-8305	217	37	10.17561/tahrj.v22.8305 15	MONEY
tahrj-8305	219	1	article 19(1)(a	LAW
tahrj-8305	230	1	mens rea element	PERSON
tahrj-8305	231	1	hira lal	PERSON
tahrj-8305	231	2	one	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	231	3	the supreme court of india	ORG
tahrj-8305	231	4	94	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	231	5	shubham kashyap kalita	PERSON
tahrj-8305	231	6	raajdwip vardhan	PERSON
tahrj-8305	231	7	prashant bhushan	PERSON
tahrj-8305	231	8	11	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	231	9	131	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	231	10	2020	DATE
tahrj-8305	232	1	22	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	232	2	june 2024	DATE
tahrj-8305	232	3	2340-9592	DATE
tahrj-8305	232	4	10.17561/tahrj.v22.8305 16	MONEY
tahrj-8305	235	1	mens rea element	PERSON
tahrj-8305	235	2	britain	GPE
tahrj-8305	235	3	english	NORP
tahrj-8305	235	4	india	GPE
tahrj-8305	236	1	india	GPE
tahrj-8305	237	1	india	GPE
tahrj-8305	237	2	singapore	GPE
tahrj-8305	239	1	mens rea	GPE
tahrj-8305	239	2	english	LANGUAGE
tahrj-8305	239	3	odhams press ltd.	ORG
tahrj-8305	241	1	2011	DATE
tahrj-8305	241	2	mens rea	PERSON
tahrj-8305	241	3	95 hira lal dixit	QUANTITY
tahrj-8305	241	4	82 96	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	241	5	shadrake alan	PERSON
tahrj-8305	241	6	2011	DATE
tahrj-8305	241	7	26 97	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	241	8	1992	DATE
tahrj-8305	241	9	173	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	241	10	592	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	241	11	wong yeung ng v. secretary	PERSON
tahrj-8305	241	12	justice	ORG
tahrj-8305	241	13	1999	DATE
tahrj-8305	241	14	2	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	241	15	24 98	DATE
tahrj-8305	241	16	nash	PERSON
tahrj-8305	242	1	1960	DATE
tahrj-8305	242	2	2	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	242	3	188	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	242	4	200	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	243	1	1974	DATE
tahrj-8305	243	2	273	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	243	3	298	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	243	4	2001	DATE
tahrj-8305	243	5	5	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	243	6	449	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	243	7	68	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	243	8	45 99	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	243	9	92	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	243	10	29 100	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	243	11	john fairfax &	ORG
tahrj-8305	244	1	mcrae	PERSON
tahrj-8305	244	2	1955	DATE
tahrj-8305	244	3	93	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	244	4	351	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	244	5	371 101	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	244	6	1957	DATE
tahrj-8305	244	7	3	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	244	8	494 102	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	245	1	497 103	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	245	2	92	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	245	3	http://doi.org/10.17561/tahrj.v22.8305 vijay k. tyagi	PERSON
tahrj-8305	245	4	vaibhav chadha	PERSON
tahrj-8305	245	5	tyagi	ORG
tahrj-8305	245	6	shambhavi srivastava	PERSON
tahrj-8305	245	7	22	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	245	8	june 2024	DATE
tahrj-8305	245	9	2340-9592	DATE
tahrj-8305	245	10	10.17561/tahrj.v22.8305 17	MONEY
tahrj-8305	245	11	wai pang104	GPE
tahrj-8305	246	1	the supreme court of singapore	ORG
tahrj-8305	247	1	actus reus	ORG
tahrj-8305	247	2	actus reus	ORG
tahrj-8305	248	1	singapore	GPE
tahrj-8305	249	1	the singapore courts	ORG
tahrj-8305	249	2	section 3(1)(d	LAW
tahrj-8305	249	3	section 3(6	LAW
tahrj-8305	249	4	justice	ORG
tahrj-8305	249	5	2016105	DATE
tahrj-8305	249	6	3(1)(d	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	249	7	the actus reus	ORG
tahrj-8305	251	1	39	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	253	1	3(6	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	256	1	mens rea	PERSON
tahrj-8305	256	2	singapore	GPE
tahrj-8305	257	1	extendedmens rea	GPE
tahrj-8305	259	1	south african	NORP
tahrj-8305	259	2	mens rea	GPE
tahrj-8305	260	1	claasen j.	PERSON
tahrj-8305	260	2	104	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	260	3	2016	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	260	4	1	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	260	5	992 105	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	260	6	justice	ORG
tahrj-8305	260	7	2016	DATE
tahrj-8305	260	8	19	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	260	9	singapore	GPE
tahrj-8305	260	10	106	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	260	11	v. ravi s	PERSON
tahrj-8305	260	12	2023	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	260	13	78 107	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	260	14	xu yuan chen	PERSON
tahrj-8305	261	1	2023	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	261	2	87	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	261	3	108	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	261	4	1970	DATE
tahrj-8305	261	5	3	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	261	6	655	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	261	7	22	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	261	8	june 2024	DATE
tahrj-8305	261	9	2340-9592	DATE
tahrj-8305	261	10	10.17561/tahrj.v22.8305 18	MONEY
tahrj-8305	262	1	justice	ORG
tahrj-8305	264	1	south african	NORP
tahrj-8305	264	2	one	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	264	3	the actus reus	ORG
tahrj-8305	265	1	mens rea	PERSON
tahrj-8305	265	2	mauritian	NORP
tahrj-8305	266	1	mauritian	NORP
tahrj-8305	266	2	singapore	GPE
tahrj-8305	268	1	mens rea	GPE
tahrj-8305	268	2	england	GPE
tahrj-8305	268	3	wales	GPE
tahrj-8305	269	1	atkin	PERSON
tahrj-8305	269	2	english	LANGUAGE
tahrj-8305	269	3	trinidad	GPE
tahrj-8305	269	4	justice	ORG
tahrj-8305	270	1	the mauritian board	ORG
tahrj-8305	272	1	109 1970	DATE
tahrj-8305	272	2	3	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	272	3	657	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	272	4	110	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	272	5	94	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	272	6	111	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	273	1	3	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	273	2	1081 112	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	274	1	ac	ORG
tahrj-8305	274	2	322	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	275	1	322	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	275	2	http://doi.org/10.17561/tahrj.v22.8305 vijay k. tyagi	PERSON
tahrj-8305	275	3	vaibhav chadha	PERSON
tahrj-8305	275	4	tyagi	ORG
tahrj-8305	275	5	shambhavi srivastava	PERSON
tahrj-8305	275	6	22	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	275	7	june 2024	DATE
tahrj-8305	275	8	2340-9592	DATE
tahrj-8305	275	9	10.17561/tahrj.v22.8305 19	MONEY
tahrj-8305	275	10	justice	ORG
tahrj-8305	275	11	mauritian	NORP
tahrj-8305	275	12	justice	ORG
tahrj-8305	276	1	mens rea	PERSON
tahrj-8305	276	2	singapore	GPE
tahrj-8305	276	3	south african	NORP
tahrj-8305	276	4	r. v. van niekerk	PERSON
tahrj-8305	277	1	india	GPE
tahrj-8305	277	2	singapore	GPE
tahrj-8305	278	1	south africa	GPE
tahrj-8305	278	2	mauritius	ORG
tahrj-8305	284	1	singapore	GPE
tahrj-8305	284	2	south africa	GPE
tahrj-8305	284	3	mauritius	ORG
tahrj-8305	284	4	england	GPE
tahrj-8305	286	1	second	ORDINAL
tahrj-8305	288	1	england	GPE
tahrj-8305	290	1	three	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	291	1	one	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	291	2	mauritius	ORG
tahrj-8305	292	1	mauritius	ORG
tahrj-8305	293	1	second	ORDINAL
tahrj-8305	293	2	singapore	GPE
tahrj-8305	294	1	114	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	294	2	107	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	294	3	48	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	294	4	hira lal	PERSON
tahrj-8305	296	1	82	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	296	2	22	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	296	3	june 2024	DATE
tahrj-8305	296	4	2340-9592	DATE
tahrj-8305	296	5	10.17561/tahrj.v22.8305 20	MONEY
tahrj-8305	297	1	third	ORDINAL
tahrj-8305	297	2	south africa	GPE
tahrj-8305	297	3	india	GPE
tahrj-8305	299	1	mens rea	PERSON
tahrj-8305	301	1	indian	NORP
tahrj-8305	302	1	two	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	302	2	article 19(2	LAW
tahrj-8305	302	3	indian	NORP
tahrj-8305	304	1	over years	DATE
tahrj-8305	305	1	indian	NORP
tahrj-8305	307	1	1st october 2023	DATE
tahrj-8305	307	2	18th	ORDINAL
tahrj-8305	307	3	2023	CARDINAL
tahrj-8305	308	1	i.	PERSON
tahrj-8305	311	1	namboodripad	GPE
tahrj-8305	312	1	hari singh nagra	PERSON
tahrj-8305	312	2	prashant bhushan	PERSON
tahrj-8305	313	1	mens rea	PERSON
tahrj-8305	313	2	iv.i	ORG
tahrj-8305	315	1	iv.iii	PRODUCT
tahrj-8305	316	1	mens rea element	PERSON