id	sid	eid	entity	type
tahrj-8728	1	1	india	GPE
tahrj-8728	1	2	24	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	1	3	june 2025	DATE
tahrj-8728	1	4	e8728 issn	PERSON
tahrj-8728	1	5	2340-9592	DATE
tahrj-8728	1	6	10.17561/tahrj.v23.8728	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	1	7	1	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	1	8	india	GPE
tahrj-8728	1	9	ahmed*	PERSON
tahrj-8728	1	10	india	GPE
tahrj-8728	2	1	the supreme court of india	ORG
tahrj-8728	2	2	sci	ORG
tahrj-8728	3	1	india	GPE
tahrj-8728	3	2	1950	DATE
tahrj-8728	5	1	21	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	6	1	sc of india	ORG
tahrj-8728	7	1	indian	NORP
tahrj-8728	8	1	firstly	ORDINAL
tahrj-8728	8	2	european	NORP
tahrj-8728	8	3	inter-american	NORP
tahrj-8728	8	4	african	NORP
tahrj-8728	9	1	european	NORP
tahrj-8728	9	2	american	NORP
tahrj-8728	9	3	the african court's	ORG
tahrj-8728	9	4	kenyan	NORP
tahrj-8728	10	1	kenya	GPE
tahrj-8728	10	2	the supreme court of india	ORG
tahrj-8728	11	1	sc	GPE
tahrj-8728	12	1	wednesbury	GPE
tahrj-8728	12	2	ecthr	ORG
tahrj-8728	12	3	african	NORP
tahrj-8728	13	1	1	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	13	2	european	NORP
tahrj-8728	14	1	european union	ORG
tahrj-8728	14	2	eu	ORG
tahrj-8728	14	3	german	NORP
tahrj-8728	14	4	2018	DATE
tahrj-8728	15	1	mathew, 2008	ORG
tahrj-8728	16	1	alec stone	PERSON
tahrj-8728	16	2	jud mathews	PERSON
tahrj-8728	16	3	2008	DATE
tahrj-8728	19	1	o.p jindal global university	ORG
tahrj-8728	19	2	india	GPE
tahrj-8728	19	3	sabreen.ahmed@jgu.edu.in https://doi.org/10.17561/tahrj.v23.8728	DATE
tahrj-8728	19	4	india	GPE
tahrj-8728	19	5	24	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	19	6	june 2025	DATE
tahrj-8728	19	7	e8728 issn	PERSON
tahrj-8728	19	8	2340-9592	DATE
tahrj-8728	19	9	10.17561	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	19	10	2	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	19	11	the european convention	ORG
tahrj-8728	19	12	1999	DATE
tahrj-8728	20	1	eu	ORG
tahrj-8728	20	2	echr	GPE
tahrj-8728	21	1	8 to 11	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	22	1	the european court	ORG
tahrj-8728	23	1	belgian	NORP
tahrj-8728	23	2	1968	DATE
tahrj-8728	23	3	14	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	24	1	uk	GPE
tahrj-8728	24	2	1990	DATE
tahrj-8728	24	3	37	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	25	1	two	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	25	2	1	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	25	3	2	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	27	1	1983	DATE
tahrj-8728	28	1	three	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	28	2	1991	DATE
tahrj-8728	29	1	first	ORDINAL
tahrj-8728	29	2	second	ORDINAL
tahrj-8728	32	1	third	ORDINAL
tahrj-8728	32	2	second	ORDINAL
tahrj-8728	32	3	nada	PERSON
tahrj-8728	32	4	switzerland	GPE
tahrj-8728	32	5	2012	DATE
tahrj-8728	32	6	ecthr	ORG
tahrj-8728	32	7	8 to 11	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	33	1	8(2	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	34	1	nada	ORG
tahrj-8728	34	2	2012	DATE
tahrj-8728	34	3	167	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	37	1	europe	LOC
tahrj-8728	37	2	english	NORP
tahrj-8728	38	1	the united kingdom	GPE
tahrj-8728	38	2	uk	GPE
tahrj-8728	39	1	uk	GPE
tahrj-8728	40	1	one	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	40	2	2011	DATE
tahrj-8728	40	3	wilson	PERSON
tahrj-8728	40	4	first	ORDINAL
tahrj-8728	41	1	second	ORDINAL
tahrj-8728	41	2	https://doi.org/10.17561/tahrj.v23.8728	FAC
tahrj-8728	41	3	ahmed	PERSON
tahrj-8728	41	4	24	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	41	5	june 2025	DATE
tahrj-8728	41	6	e8728 issn	PERSON
tahrj-8728	41	7	2340-9592	DATE
tahrj-8728	41	8	10.17561/tahrj.v23.8728	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	41	9	3	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	43	1	fourth	ORDINAL
tahrj-8728	44	1	the 1990s	DATE
tahrj-8728	44	2	uk	GPE
tahrj-8728	44	3	1948	DATE
tahrj-8728	47	1	1985	DATE
tahrj-8728	48	1	the house of lords	ORG
tahrj-8728	48	2	1991	DATE
tahrj-8728	51	1	uk	GPE
tahrj-8728	51	2	1998	DATE
tahrj-8728	52	1	1999	DATE
tahrj-8728	53	1	gardy v. united kingdom	PERSON
tahrj-8728	53	2	1999	DATE
tahrj-8728	54	1	2001	DATE
tahrj-8728	55	1	bingham	PERSON
tahrj-8728	56	1	daly, 2001	ORG
tahrj-8728	57	1	24-28	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	58	1	daly	PERSON
tahrj-8728	58	2	wednesbury	PERSON
tahrj-8728	58	3	english	LANGUAGE
tahrj-8728	60	1	india	GPE
tahrj-8728	60	2	24	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	60	3	june 2025	DATE
tahrj-8728	60	4	e8728 issn	PERSON
tahrj-8728	60	5	2340-9592	DATE
tahrj-8728	60	6	10.17561	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	60	7	4	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	60	8	two	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	60	9	2015	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	60	10	2015	DATE
tahrj-8728	60	11	133	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	62	1	2015	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	62	2	1	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	63	1	eu	ORG
tahrj-8728	63	2	2015	DATE
tahrj-8728	64	1	104	ORG
tahrj-8728	65	1	two	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	65	2	kennedy	PERSON
tahrj-8728	65	3	2015	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	67	1	daly	PERSON
tahrj-8728	67	2	1998	DATE
tahrj-8728	69	1	post-daly	NORP
tahrj-8728	69	2	two	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	70	1	3	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	71	1	1.1	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	71	2	article 33 of the 1951 geneva convention	LAW
tahrj-8728	71	3	1967	DATE
tahrj-8728	72	1	article 33 (	LAW
tahrj-8728	72	2	1	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	73	1	unhcr	ORG
tahrj-8728	73	2	1997	DATE
tahrj-8728	74	1	https://doi.org/10.17561/tahrj.v23.8728	FAC
tahrj-8728	74	2	24	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	74	3	june 2025	DATE
tahrj-8728	74	4	e8728 issn	PERSON
tahrj-8728	74	5	2340-9592	DATE
tahrj-8728	74	6	10.17561/tahrj.v23.8728	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	74	7	5	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	75	1	3(1	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	75	2	un	ORG
tahrj-8728	75	3	the general assembly	ORG
tahrj-8728	75	4	1967	DATE
tahrj-8728	76	1	article 1	LAW
tahrj-8728	77	1	1951	DATE
tahrj-8728	78	1	2018	DATE
tahrj-8728	79	1	2018	DATE
tahrj-8728	81	1	hathaway	PERSON
tahrj-8728	81	2	harvey	PERSON
tahrj-8728	81	3	33	DATE
tahrj-8728	82	1	hathaway	PERSON
tahrj-8728	82	2	2005	DATE
tahrj-8728	83	1	353-354	QUANTITY
tahrj-8728	84	1	geoff gilbert	PERSON
tahrj-8728	84	2	2003	DATE
tahrj-8728	84	3	goodwin gill	PERSON
tahrj-8728	84	4	1996	DATE
tahrj-8728	84	5	33	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	85	1	goodwin	PERSON
tahrj-8728	85	2	1996	DATE
tahrj-8728	86	1	gilbert	PERSON
tahrj-8728	86	2	2003	DATE
tahrj-8728	87	1	lauterpacht	ORG
tahrj-8728	87	2	bethlehem	ORG
tahrj-8728	87	3	2009	DATE
tahrj-8728	88	1	1.2	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	88	2	ecthr	ORG
tahrj-8728	88	3	europe	LOC
tahrj-8728	88	4	3	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	89	1	the 1970s	DATE
tahrj-8728	89	2	cassese	NORP
tahrj-8728	89	3	1993	DATE
tahrj-8728	89	4	the united kingdom	GPE
tahrj-8728	89	5	1989	DATE
tahrj-8728	90	1	ecthr	ORG
tahrj-8728	91	1	3	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	91	2	1995	DATE
tahrj-8728	92	1	3	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	92	2	1979-1980	DATE
tahrj-8728	92	3	163	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	93	1	mavronicola	ORG
tahrj-8728	93	2	2013	DATE
tahrj-8728	93	3	the united kingdom	GPE
tahrj-8728	93	4	1991	DATE
tahrj-8728	93	5	india	GPE
tahrj-8728	93	6	24	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	93	7	june 2025	DATE
tahrj-8728	93	8	e8728 issn	PERSON
tahrj-8728	93	9	2340-9592	DATE
tahrj-8728	93	10	10.17561/tahrj.v23.8728	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	93	11	6	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	93	12	article 3	LAW
tahrj-8728	94	1	first	ORDINAL
tahrj-8728	94	2	chahal v.	PERSON
tahrj-8728	94	3	the united kingdom	GPE
tahrj-8728	94	4	1996	DATE
tahrj-8728	94	5	british	NORP
tahrj-8728	94	6	3	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	96	1	3	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	97	1	ecthr	ORG
tahrj-8728	97	2	3	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	98	1	saadi v. italy	PERSON
tahrj-8728	98	2	2008	DATE
tahrj-8728	100	1	wellington	GPE
tahrj-8728	100	2	2008	DATE
tahrj-8728	102	1	3	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	103	1	scott	PERSON
tahrj-8728	103	2	3	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	103	3	europe	LOC
tahrj-8728	103	4	francesco	ORG
tahrj-8728	103	5	2013	DATE
tahrj-8728	104	1	3	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	104	2	3	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	104	3	europe	LOC
tahrj-8728	107	1	1998	DATE
tahrj-8728	110	1	babar ahmad	PERSON
tahrj-8728	110	2	uk	GPE
tahrj-8728	110	3	2012	DATE
tahrj-8728	110	4	ecthr	ORG
tahrj-8728	110	5	wellington	GPE
tahrj-8728	111	1	colorado	GPE
tahrj-8728	112	1	3	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	112	2	babar	PERSON
tahrj-8728	112	3	https://doi.org/10.17561/tahrj.v23.8728	LAW
tahrj-8728	112	4	ahmed	PERSON
tahrj-8728	112	5	24	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	112	6	june 2025	DATE
tahrj-8728	112	7	e8728 issn	PERSON
tahrj-8728	112	8	2340-9592	DATE
tahrj-8728	112	9	10.17561/tahrj.v23.8728	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	112	10	ahmed v uk	PERSON
tahrj-8728	112	11	2012	DATE
tahrj-8728	115	1	3	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	116	1	3	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	116	2	ecthr	ORG
tahrj-8728	117	1	2005	DATE
tahrj-8728	119	1	hirsi jamaa	PERSON
tahrj-8728	119	2	italy	GPE
tahrj-8728	119	3	2012	DATE
tahrj-8728	119	4	italy	GPE
tahrj-8728	119	5	may 6, 2009	DATE
tahrj-8728	119	6	three	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	119	7	italy	GPE
tahrj-8728	119	8	about 200	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	120	1	libyan	NORP
tahrj-8728	120	2	italy	GPE
tahrj-8728	120	3	libya	GPE
tahrj-8728	120	4	february 2009	DATE
tahrj-8728	121	1	11	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	121	2	somalis	NORP
tahrj-8728	121	3	13	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	121	4	eritreans	NORP
tahrj-8728	121	5	italy	GPE
tahrj-8728	121	6	3	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	122	1	411	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	122	2	2016	DATE
tahrj-8728	122	3	74	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	122	4	article 13	LAW
tahrj-8728	124	1	1998	DATE
tahrj-8728	124	2	167	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	124	3	article 1 of the convention	LAW
tahrj-8728	124	4	article 4 of protocol	LAW
tahrj-8728	125	1	4	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	125	2	2012	DATE
tahrj-8728	125	3	180	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	125	4	article 3 by	LAW
tahrj-8728	125	5	libyan	NORP
tahrj-8728	125	6	libyan	NORP
tahrj-8728	126	1	ecthr	GPE
tahrj-8728	126	2	n.d.	GPE
tahrj-8728	126	3	n.t.	GPE
tahrj-8728	127	1	spain	GPE
tahrj-8728	127	2	2020	DATE
tahrj-8728	128	1	spain	GPE
tahrj-8728	128	2	india	GPE
tahrj-8728	128	3	24	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	128	4	june 2025	DATE
tahrj-8728	128	5	e8728 issn	PERSON
tahrj-8728	128	6	2340-9592	DATE
tahrj-8728	128	7	10.17561/tahrj.v23.8728	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	128	8	8	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	128	9	n.d.	GPE
tahrj-8728	128	10	n.t, 2020	ORG
tahrj-8728	128	11	124	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	128	12	article 4 of protocol	LAW
tahrj-8728	129	1	4	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	129	2	article 13 of the echr	LAW
tahrj-8728	130	1	article 3 of the echr	LAW
tahrj-8728	131	1	n.d.	GPE
tahrj-8728	131	2	n.t, 2020	ORG
tahrj-8728	131	3	242	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	133	1	ecthr	ORG
tahrj-8728	133	2	3	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	135	1	3	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	136	1	1.3	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	137	1	inter-american	NORP
tahrj-8728	137	2	african	NORP
tahrj-8728	137	3	inter-american	NORP
tahrj-8728	137	4	inter-american	NORP
tahrj-8728	137	5	inter-american	NORP
tahrj-8728	138	1	american	NORP
tahrj-8728	138	2	1969	DATE
tahrj-8728	138	3	2013	DATE
tahrj-8728	138	4	9	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	140	1	4	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	140	2	5	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	140	3	8.1	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	140	4	25	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	140	5	lixinski	PERSON
tahrj-8728	140	6	2019	DATE
tahrj-8728	142	1	article 30 of the convention	LAW
tahrj-8728	143	1	2009	DATE
tahrj-8728	143	2	https://doi.org/10.17561/tahrj.v23.8728	FAC
tahrj-8728	143	3	ahmed	PERSON
tahrj-8728	143	4	24	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	143	5	june 2025	DATE
tahrj-8728	143	6	e8728 issn	PERSON
tahrj-8728	143	7	2340-9592	DATE
tahrj-8728	143	8	10.17561/tahrj.v23.8728	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	143	9	9	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	145	1	brazil	GPE
tahrj-8728	145	2	2010	DATE
tahrj-8728	145	3	principio de ponderación	ORG
tahrj-8728	145	4	8	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	145	5	american	NORP
tahrj-8728	147	1	brazil	GPE
tahrj-8728	147	2	2010	DATE
tahrj-8728	147	3	178	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	148	1	article 22	LAW
tahrj-8728	150	1	8	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	151	1	1951	DATE
tahrj-8728	151	2	1967	DATE
tahrj-8728	151	3	1961	DATE
tahrj-8728	151	4	1990	DATE
tahrj-8728	152	1	haitian	NORP
tahrj-8728	152	2	haitian	NORP
tahrj-8728	152	3	1993	DATE
tahrj-8728	152	4	the united states	GPE
tahrj-8728	152	5	second	ORDINAL
tahrj-8728	152	6	article 26	LAW
tahrj-8728	152	7	american	NORP
tahrj-8728	153	1	inter-american	NORP
tahrj-8728	153	2	2018	DATE
tahrj-8728	153	3	180	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	154	1	the inter-american court	ORG
tahrj-8728	154	2	2014	DATE
tahrj-8728	154	3	article 22 of achr	LAW
tahrj-8728	155	1	https://doi.org/10.17561/tahrj.v23.8728	DATE
tahrj-8728	155	2	india	GPE
tahrj-8728	155	3	24	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	155	4	june 2025	DATE
tahrj-8728	155	5	e8728 issn	PERSON
tahrj-8728	155	6	2340-9592	DATE
tahrj-8728	155	7	10.17561/tahrj.v23.8728	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	155	8	10	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	156	1	august 2014	DATE
tahrj-8728	156	2	230	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	157	1	pacheco	PERSON
tahrj-8728	157	2	bolivia	GPE
tahrj-8728	157	3	2013	DATE
tahrj-8728	158	1	inter-american	NORP
tahrj-8728	158	2	2018	DATE
tahrj-8728	161	1	2	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	161	2	african	NORP
tahrj-8728	161	3	african	NORP
tahrj-8728	163	1	the african court of human	ORG
tahrj-8728	163	2	christopher r mitilika	PERSON
tahrj-8728	163	3	united republic	GPE
tahrj-8728	163	4	tanzania	GPE
tahrj-8728	163	5	2013	DATE
tahrj-8728	164	1	first	ORDINAL
tahrj-8728	165	1	second	ORDINAL
tahrj-8728	166	1	third	ORDINAL
tahrj-8728	168	1	first	ORDINAL
tahrj-8728	169	1	third	ORDINAL
tahrj-8728	171	1	2013	DATE
tahrj-8728	171	2	the tanzania regulation	ORG
tahrj-8728	175	1	27	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	175	2	2	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	177	1	pour la protection des driots de l’homme	ORG
tahrj-8728	177	2	v. republic	GPE
tahrj-8728	177	3	cote	GPE
tahrj-8728	177	4	2016	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	177	5	12	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	178	1	https://doi.org/10.17561/tahrj.v23.8728	FAC
tahrj-8728	178	2	ahmed	PERSON
tahrj-8728	178	3	24	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	178	4	june 2025	DATE
tahrj-8728	178	5	e8728 issn	PERSON
tahrj-8728	178	6	2340-9592	DATE
tahrj-8728	178	7	10.17561/tahrj.v23.8728	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	178	8	11	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	180	1	the african commission	ORG
tahrj-8728	180	2	kenya	GPE
tahrj-8728	180	3	2013	DATE
tahrj-8728	181	1	mau	PERSON
tahrj-8728	183	1	first	ORDINAL
tahrj-8728	187	1	issa konate	PERSON
tahrj-8728	187	2	2014	DATE
tahrj-8728	188	1	lohe issa	PERSON
tahrj-8728	188	2	two	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	190	1	the national court	ORG
tahrj-8728	190	2	the african court for review	ORG
tahrj-8728	191	1	three	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	192	1	first	ORDINAL
tahrj-8728	192	2	burkina	GPE
tahrj-8728	192	3	faso	GPE
tahrj-8728	193	1	second	ORDINAL
tahrj-8728	194	1	third	ORDINAL
tahrj-8728	195	1	burkino	GPE
tahrj-8728	197	1	third	ORDINAL
tahrj-8728	202	1	european	NORP
tahrj-8728	203	1	ecthr	ORG
tahrj-8728	204	1	united kingdom	GPE
tahrj-8728	204	2	1976	DATE
tahrj-8728	204	3	first	ORDINAL
tahrj-8728	205	1	frantziou	ORG
tahrj-8728	205	2	2014	DATE
tahrj-8728	206	1	india	GPE
tahrj-8728	206	2	24	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	206	3	june 2025	DATE
tahrj-8728	206	4	e8728 issn	PERSON
tahrj-8728	206	5	2340-9592	DATE
tahrj-8728	206	6	10.17561	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	206	7	12	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	208	1	2017	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	208	2	rwanda	GPE
tahrj-8728	209	1	rwanda	GPE
tahrj-8728	210	1	rwanda	GPE
tahrj-8728	216	1	anudo ochieng anudo v. united republic	PERSON
tahrj-8728	216	2	2018	DATE
tahrj-8728	217	1	anudo	PERSON
tahrj-8728	217	2	tanzania	GPE
tahrj-8728	217	3	kenya	GPE
tahrj-8728	218	1	tanzania	GPE
tahrj-8728	218	2	kenya	GPE
tahrj-8728	219	1	anudo	PERSON
tahrj-8728	219	2	tanzania	GPE
tahrj-8728	219	3	kenya	GPE
tahrj-8728	219	4	african	NORP
tahrj-8728	223	1	tanzania	GPE
tahrj-8728	226	1	https://doi.org/10.17561/tahrj.v23.8728	FAC
tahrj-8728	226	2	ahmed	PERSON
tahrj-8728	226	3	24	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	226	4	june 2025	DATE
tahrj-8728	226	5	e8728 issn	PERSON
tahrj-8728	226	6	2340-9592	DATE
tahrj-8728	226	7	10.17561	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	226	8	13 2.1	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	227	1	africa	LOC
tahrj-8728	228	1	africa	LOC
tahrj-8728	228	2	kenya	GPE
tahrj-8728	229	1	kenya	GPE
tahrj-8728	229	2	2010	DATE
tahrj-8728	230	1	kenya	GPE
tahrj-8728	230	2	1951	DATE
tahrj-8728	230	3	1967	DATE
tahrj-8728	230	4	african	NORP
tahrj-8728	231	1	2006	DATE
tahrj-8728	231	2	kenya	GPE
tahrj-8728	232	1	4	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	232	2	33	DATE
tahrj-8728	232	3	1951	DATE
tahrj-8728	233	1	24	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	233	2	kenya	GPE
tahrj-8728	236	1	24	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	236	2	2012	DATE
tahrj-8728	239	1	cha sheria	PERSON
tahrj-8728	239	2	2017	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	240	1	gazette refugee camps citing	ORG
tahrj-8728	241	1	39	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	241	2	kenya	GPE
tahrj-8728	242	1	24	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	244	1	india	GPE
tahrj-8728	244	2	24	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	244	3	june 2025	DATE
tahrj-8728	244	4	e8728 issn	PERSON
tahrj-8728	244	5	2340-9592	DATE
tahrj-8728	244	6	10.17561	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	244	7	14	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	244	8	firstly	ORDINAL
tahrj-8728	251	1	kenyan	NORP
tahrj-8728	255	1	kenya	GPE
tahrj-8728	256	1	3	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	256	2	india	GPE
tahrj-8728	259	1	india	GPE
tahrj-8728	259	2	24	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	259	3	kenya	GPE
tahrj-8728	259	4	india	GPE
tahrj-8728	259	5	1950	DATE
tahrj-8728	259	6	19	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	260	1	india	GPE
tahrj-8728	260	2	chandra	NORP
tahrj-8728	260	3	2004	DATE
tahrj-8728	261	1	uk	GPE
tahrj-8728	261	2	wednesbury	GPE
tahrj-8728	261	3	india	GPE
tahrj-8728	262	1	indian	NORP
tahrj-8728	262	2	chandra	NORP
tahrj-8728	262	3	2004	DATE
tahrj-8728	264	1	rao v. state	PERSON
tahrj-8728	264	2	mp (	ORG
tahrj-8728	264	3	1915	DATE
tahrj-8728	266	1	https://doi.org/10.17561/tahrj.v23.8728	FAC
tahrj-8728	266	2	ahmed	PERSON
tahrj-8728	266	3	24	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	266	4	june 2025	DATE
tahrj-8728	266	5	e8728 issn	PERSON
tahrj-8728	266	6	2340-9592	DATE
tahrj-8728	266	7	10.17561/tahrj.v23.8728	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	266	8	15	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	266	9	article 19(1)(g	LAW
tahrj-8728	266	10	6	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	266	11	19	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	267	1	madras	GPE
tahrj-8728	267	2	1952	DATE
tahrj-8728	268	1	chandra	NORP
tahrj-8728	268	2	2020	DATE
tahrj-8728	269	1	chandra	NORP
tahrj-8728	269	2	2020	DATE
tahrj-8728	270	1	1984	DATE
tahrj-8728	271	1	2004	DATE
tahrj-8728	271	2	2016	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	271	3	chandra	NORP
tahrj-8728	271	4	2020	DATE
tahrj-8728	272	1	sc	ORG
tahrj-8728	272	2	chandra	NORP
tahrj-8728	272	3	2020	DATE
tahrj-8728	274	1	19	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	276	1	chandra	NORP
tahrj-8728	276	2	2020	DATE
tahrj-8728	276	3	519	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	277	1	manohar lohia	PERSON
tahrj-8728	277	2	1960	DATE
tahrj-8728	278	1	o	DATE
tahrj-8728	278	2	k ghosh v e	PERSON
tahrj-8728	278	3	joseph	PERSON
tahrj-8728	278	4	1963	DATE
tahrj-8728	279	1	one	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	281	1	chandra	NORP
tahrj-8728	281	2	2020	DATE
tahrj-8728	281	3	529	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	285	1	manohar lal sharma	PERSON
tahrj-8728	285	2	india	GPE
tahrj-8728	285	3	2021	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	286	1	madhya pradesh	ORG
tahrj-8728	286	2	2016	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	286	3	sc	GPE
tahrj-8728	289	1	1986	DATE
tahrj-8728	289	2	canadian	NORP
tahrj-8728	289	3	19	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	290	1	india	GPE
tahrj-8728	290	2	24	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	290	3	june 2025	DATE
tahrj-8728	290	4	e8728 issn	PERSON
tahrj-8728	290	5	2340-9592	DATE
tahrj-8728	290	6	10.17561	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	290	7	16	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	291	1	subramanian swamy v. union of india	ORG
tahrj-8728	291	2	2016	DATE
tahrj-8728	291	3	499	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	291	4	500	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	291	5	section 199	LAW
tahrj-8728	292	1	19	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	297	1	india	GPE
tahrj-8728	297	2	2019	DATE
tahrj-8728	300	1	1	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	301	1	2.	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	302	1	3	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	303	1	4.	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	305	1	1	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	306	1	2	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	307	1	3	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	308	1	a.	PERSON
tahrj-8728	310	1	4	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	311	1	three-fold	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	311	2	21	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	311	3	2019	DATE
tahrj-8728	311	4	504	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	315	1	https://doi.org/10.17561/tahrj.v23.8728	FAC
tahrj-8728	315	2	ahmed	PERSON
tahrj-8728	315	3	24	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	315	4	june 2025	DATE
tahrj-8728	315	5	e8728 issn	PERSON
tahrj-8728	315	6	2340-9592	DATE
tahrj-8728	315	7	10.17561/tahrj.v23.8728	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	315	8	17	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	315	9	two	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	320	1	louis de raedt v. union of	ORG
tahrj-8728	320	2	india	GPE
tahrj-8728	320	3	1991	DATE
tahrj-8728	321	1	3.1	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	322	1	india	GPE
tahrj-8728	323	1	india	GPE
tahrj-8728	324	1	alexander	ORG
tahrj-8728	324	2	2021	DATE
tahrj-8728	325	1	india	GPE
tahrj-8728	325	2	1951	DATE
tahrj-8728	325	3	33	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	327	1	jus	NORP
tahrj-8728	328	1	kumar, 2018	ORG
tahrj-8728	328	2	india	GPE
tahrj-8728	329	1	21	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	330	1	21	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	331	1	hans muller	PERSON
tahrj-8728	331	2	nuremberg	GPE
tahrj-8728	331	3	calcutta	ORG
tahrj-8728	331	4	1955	DATE
tahrj-8728	331	5	the supreme court of india	ORG
tahrj-8728	331	6	21	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	331	7	loius de raedt v. union	PERSON
tahrj-8728	331	8	india	GPE
tahrj-8728	331	9	1991	DATE
tahrj-8728	331	10	21	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	333	1	arunachal pradesh v. national human rights commission	ORG
tahrj-8728	333	2	1996	DATE
tahrj-8728	333	3	sc	GPE
tahrj-8728	334	1	arunachal pradesh.	ORG
tahrj-8728	335	1	mohammad salimullah v. union	PERSON
tahrj-8728	335	2	2021	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	336	1	august 8, 2017	DATE
tahrj-8728	336	2	the ministry of home affairs	ORG
tahrj-8728	336	3	40,000	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	336	4	krishna	PERSON
tahrj-8728	336	5	sanjeev, 2017	ORG
tahrj-8728	337	1	mohammad	PERSON
tahrj-8728	337	2	india	GPE
tahrj-8728	337	3	24	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	337	4	june 2025	DATE
tahrj-8728	337	5	e8728 issn	PERSON
tahrj-8728	337	6	2340-9592	DATE
tahrj-8728	337	7	10.17561	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	337	8	18	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	337	9	salimullah v union of india 2021	ORG
tahrj-8728	338	1	14	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	338	2	21	DATE
tahrj-8728	338	3	19	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	338	4	1	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	339	1	sc	GPE
tahrj-8728	340	1	21	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	341	1	19	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	341	2	1	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	344	1	mohammad salimullah v. union	PERSON
tahrj-8728	344	2	2021	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	345	1	article 51(c	LAW
tahrj-8728	345	2	india	GPE
tahrj-8728	345	3	article 21	LAW
tahrj-8728	346	1	india	GPE
tahrj-8728	346	2	1946	DATE
tahrj-8728	346	3	section 3(1	LAW
tahrj-8728	348	1	manipur	GPE
tahrj-8728	348	2	2021	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	349	1	21	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	349	2	mohammad salimullah	PERSON
tahrj-8728	349	3	2021	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	351	1	21	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	351	2	the supreme court	ORG
tahrj-8728	353	1	sc	GPE
tahrj-8728	353	2	mohammad salimullah	PERSON
tahrj-8728	353	3	2021	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	353	4	nandita haskar	PERSON
tahrj-8728	353	5	2021	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	357	1	https://doi.org/10.17561/tahrj.v23.8728	FAC
tahrj-8728	357	2	ahmed	PERSON
tahrj-8728	357	3	24	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	357	4	june 2025	DATE
tahrj-8728	357	5	e8728 issn	PERSON
tahrj-8728	357	6	2340-9592	DATE
tahrj-8728	357	7	10.17561/tahrj.v23.8728	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	357	8	19 3.2	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	358	1	india	GPE
tahrj-8728	359	1	india	GPE
tahrj-8728	360	1	michael taggart	PERSON
tahrj-8728	360	2	knight	ORG
tahrj-8728	360	3	2010	DATE
tahrj-8728	361	1	taggart	ORG
tahrj-8728	363	1	subwednesbury	ORG
tahrj-8728	363	2	2010	DATE
tahrj-8728	364	1	taggart	ORG
tahrj-8728	365	1	craig	PERSON
tahrj-8728	365	2	2010	DATE
tahrj-8728	366	1	dean knight	PERSON
tahrj-8728	366	2	2010	DATE
tahrj-8728	366	3	philip	PERSON
tahrj-8728	366	4	2004	DATE
tahrj-8728	366	5	mark elliott	PERSON
tahrj-8728	366	6	2001	DATE
tahrj-8728	367	1	david mullan	PERSON
tahrj-8728	367	2	2010	DATE
tahrj-8728	368	1	craig	PERSON
tahrj-8728	368	2	murray hunt	PERSON
tahrj-8728	368	3	philip joseph	PERSON
tahrj-8728	368	4	2009	DATE
tahrj-8728	368	5	joseph	PERSON
tahrj-8728	368	6	2007	DATE
tahrj-8728	368	7	craig	PERSON
tahrj-8728	368	8	2010	DATE
tahrj-8728	369	1	2009	DATE
tahrj-8728	371	1	taggart	ORG
tahrj-8728	371	2	2008	DATE
tahrj-8728	372	1	2008	DATE
tahrj-8728	373	1	2008	DATE
tahrj-8728	373	2	taggart	ORG
tahrj-8728	373	3	wednesbury	GPE
tahrj-8728	375	1	taggart	ORG
tahrj-8728	375	2	2008	DATE
tahrj-8728	376	1	two	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	377	1	srirangam	ORG
tahrj-8728	377	2	2016	DATE
tahrj-8728	379	1	india	GPE
tahrj-8728	379	2	24	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	379	3	june 2025	DATE
tahrj-8728	379	4	e8728 issn	PERSON
tahrj-8728	379	5	2340-9592	DATE
tahrj-8728	379	6	10.17561/tahrj.v23.8728	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	379	7	20	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	384	1	bingham	PERSON
tahrj-8728	384	2	1996	DATE
tahrj-8728	392	1	indian	NORP
tahrj-8728	394	1	new zealand	GPE
tahrj-8728	394	2	taggart	ORG
tahrj-8728	394	3	one	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	394	4	2010	DATE
tahrj-8728	395	1	new zealand	GPE
tahrj-8728	396	1	indian	NORP
tahrj-8728	397	1	https://doi.org/10.17561/tahrj.v23.8728	LAW
tahrj-8728	397	2	ahmed	PERSON
tahrj-8728	397	3	24	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	397	4	june 2025	DATE
tahrj-8728	397	5	e8728 issn	PERSON
tahrj-8728	397	6	2340-9592	DATE
tahrj-8728	397	7	10.17561/tahrj.v23.8728	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	397	8	21	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	397	9	taggart	ORG
tahrj-8728	397	10	india	GPE
tahrj-8728	398	1	sci	ORG
tahrj-8728	399	1	india	GPE
tahrj-8728	399	2	kenyan	NORP
tahrj-8728	399	3	cha sheria	PERSON
tahrj-8728	399	4	2017	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	400	1	kenyan	NORP
tahrj-8728	401	1	south africa	GPE
tahrj-8728	401	2	canada	GPE
tahrj-8728	401	3	new zealand	GPE
tahrj-8728	401	4	the united kingdom	GPE
tahrj-8728	401	5	the united states of america	GPE
tahrj-8728	401	6	india	GPE
tahrj-8728	402	1	balakrishnan	GPE
tahrj-8728	402	2	2010	DATE
tahrj-8728	403	1	anne-marie	PERSON
tahrj-8728	404	1	1994	DATE
tahrj-8728	405	1	indian	NORP
tahrj-8728	407	1	sci	ORG
tahrj-8728	407	2	india	GPE
tahrj-8728	408	1	gandhi v. union of india	ORG
tahrj-8728	408	2	1978	DATE
tahrj-8728	409	1	21	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	409	2	u.s.	GPE
tahrj-8728	410	1	kharak	GPE
tahrj-8728	410	2	singh	GPE
tahrj-8728	410	3	uttar pradesh	ORG
tahrj-8728	410	4	1963	DATE
tahrj-8728	410	5	bennett & coleman v. union of india (	ORG
tahrj-8728	410	6	1973	DATE
tahrj-8728	410	7	bachan singh v. union of india	ORG
tahrj-8728	410	8	1980	DATE
tahrj-8728	411	1	indian	NORP
tahrj-8728	411	2	kenyan	NORP
tahrj-8728	411	3	india	GPE
tahrj-8728	412	1	first	ORDINAL
tahrj-8728	413	1	second	ORDINAL
tahrj-8728	414	1	third	ORDINAL
tahrj-8728	418	1	kenya	GPE
tahrj-8728	418	2	kenyan	NORP
tahrj-8728	418	3	the supreme court of india	ORG
tahrj-8728	419	1	india	GPE
tahrj-8728	419	2	24	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	419	3	june 2025	DATE
tahrj-8728	419	4	e8728 issn	PERSON
tahrj-8728	419	5	2340-9592	DATE
tahrj-8728	419	6	10.17561	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	419	7	22 4	DATE
tahrj-8728	420	1	the supreme court of india	ORG
tahrj-8728	422	1	wednesbury	GPE
tahrj-8728	422	2	salimullah	GPE
tahrj-8728	424	1	ecthr	ORG
tahrj-8728	424	2	uk	GPE
tahrj-8728	424	3	african	NORP
tahrj-8728	429	1	first	ORDINAL
tahrj-8728	429	2	one	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	430	1	two	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	433	1	eu	ORG
tahrj-8728	433	2	kenya	GPE
tahrj-8728	434	1	indian	NORP
tahrj-8728	436	1	indian	NORP
tahrj-8728	438	1	https://doi.org/10.17561/tahrj.v23.8728	FAC
tahrj-8728	438	2	ahmed	PERSON
tahrj-8728	438	3	24	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	438	4	june 2025	DATE
tahrj-8728	438	5	e8728 issn	PERSON
tahrj-8728	438	6	2340-9592	DATE
tahrj-8728	438	7	10.17561	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	438	8	23	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	438	9	manahil kidwai	PERSON
tahrj-8728	439	1	books goodwin	PERSON
tahrj-8728	439	2	g. s.	PERSON
tahrj-8728	439	3	mcadam	GPE
tahrj-8728	439	4	j. (1996	ORG
tahrj-8728	441	1	4th	ORDINAL
tahrj-8728	442	1	oxford	NORP
tahrj-8728	442	2	oxford university	ORG
tahrj-8728	443	1	hailbronner	ORG
tahrj-8728	443	2	k.	PERSON
tahrj-8728	443	3	hathaway	PERSON
tahrj-8728	443	4	j. c.	PERSON
tahrj-8728	445	1	cambridge	GPE
tahrj-8728	445	2	cambridge university press	ORG
tahrj-8728	446	1	harris	ORG
tahrj-8728	446	2	d. j. et al	PERSON
tahrj-8728	446	3	1995	DATE
tahrj-8728	447	1	harris	PERSON
tahrj-8728	447	2	the european convention	ORG
tahrj-8728	448	1	london	GPE
tahrj-8728	449	1	eills	GPE
tahrj-8728	449	2	e. (1999	ORG
tahrj-8728	450	1	europe	LOC
tahrj-8728	451	1	hart publishing	LAW
tahrj-8728	452	1	joseph, p. a.	PERSON
tahrj-8728	452	2	2007	DATE
tahrj-8728	453	1	new zealand	GPE
tahrj-8728	454	1	3rd	ORDINAL
tahrj-8728	455	1	wellington	PERSON
tahrj-8728	456	1	brookers	ORG
tahrj-8728	457	1	chapters cassese	ORG
tahrj-8728	457	2	a.	PERSON
tahrj-8728	457	3	1993	DATE
tahrj-8728	458	1	macdonald	GPE
tahrj-8728	458	2	r. s. j.	PERSON
tahrj-8728	459	1	european	NORP
tahrj-8728	460	1	dordrecht	ORG
tahrj-8728	460	2	martinus nijhoff	GPE
tahrj-8728	460	3	225	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	461	1	chandra, a.	PERSON
tahrj-8728	461	2	2020	DATE
tahrj-8728	462	1	the indian supreme court’	ORG
tahrj-8728	462	2	m.	PERSON
tahrj-8728	462	3	lang, a. (eds.	ORG
tahrj-8728	463	1	cambridge	GPE
tahrj-8728	464	1	cambridge	GPE
tahrj-8728	464	2	cambridge university press	ORG
tahrj-8728	465	1	458541	DATE
tahrj-8728	466	1	gilbert	PERSON
tahrj-8728	466	2	2003	DATE
tahrj-8728	467	1	e.	GPE
tahrj-8728	467	2	turk	GPE
tahrj-8728	467	3	nicholson	PERSON
tahrj-8728	467	4	f.	PERSON
tahrj-8728	468	1	unhcr	ORG
tahrj-8728	469	1	cambridge	GPE
tahrj-8728	469	2	cambridge university press	ORG
tahrj-8728	470	1	425	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	471	1	cbo9780511493973.023	DATE
tahrj-8728	471	2	m.	PERSON
tahrj-8728	471	3	2009	DATE
tahrj-8728	472	1	dyzenhaus	GPE
tahrj-8728	472	2	d.	NORP
tahrj-8728	472	3	m.	PERSON
tahrj-8728	472	4	huscroft	GPE
tahrj-8728	473	1	michael taggart	PERSON
tahrj-8728	474	1	oxford	NORP
tahrj-8728	474	2	hart publishing	LAW
tahrj-8728	475	1	99	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	476	1	knight	ORG
tahrj-8728	476	2	d. r.	PERSON
tahrj-8728	476	3	2008	DATE
tahrj-8728	477	1	d. r.	PERSON
tahrj-8728	478	1	https://doi.org/10.17561/tahrj.v23.8728 https://doi.org/10.1163/9789004633599_017 https://doi.org/10.1163/9789004633599_017 https://doi.org/10.1017/9781108596268.009 https://doi.org/10.1017/cbo9780511493973.023 https://doi.org/10.1017/cbo9780511493973.023	DATE
tahrj-8728	478	2	india	GPE
tahrj-8728	478	3	24	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	478	4	june 2025	DATE
tahrj-8728	478	5	e8728 issn	PERSON
tahrj-8728	478	6	2340-9592	DATE
tahrj-8728	478	7	10.17561	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	478	8	24	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	478	9	kenneth keith	PERSON
tahrj-8728	479	1	wellington	GPE
tahrj-8728	479	2	victoria university press	ORG
tahrj-8728	480	1	180	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	480	2	lauterpacht	ORG
tahrj-8728	480	3	s. e.	PERSON
tahrj-8728	480	4	bethlehem	GPE
tahrj-8728	480	5	d.	GPE
tahrj-8728	480	6	2009	DATE
tahrj-8728	481	1	e.	GPE
tahrj-8728	481	2	turk	GPE
tahrj-8728	481	3	nicholson	PERSON
tahrj-8728	481	4	f.	PERSON
tahrj-8728	483	1	cambridge	GPE
tahrj-8728	483	2	cambridge university press	ORG
tahrj-8728	484	1	87	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	485	1	2019	DATE
tahrj-8728	486	1	inter-american	NORP
tahrj-8728	486	2	fabri	GPE
tahrj-8728	486	3	h. r.	PERSON
tahrj-8728	486	4	ed	PERSON
tahrj-8728	487	1	max	PERSON
tahrj-8728	488	1	oxford	NORP
tahrj-8728	488	2	oxford university	ORG
tahrj-8728	489	1	takis	GPE
tahrj-8728	489	2	t.	GPE
tahrj-8728	489	3	2018	DATE
tahrj-8728	490	1	r.	NORP
tahrj-8728	491	1	oxford	NORP
tahrj-8728	491	2	european union	ORG
tahrj-8728	491	3	european	NORP
tahrj-8728	492	1	united kingdom	GPE
tahrj-8728	492	2	oxford	NORP
tahrj-8728	493	1	alexander, a.	ORG
tahrj-8728	493	2	2021	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	494	1	mohammad salimullah v. union	PERSON
tahrj-8728	494	2	the supreme court of india	ORG
tahrj-8728	494	3	cmr university journal	ORG
tahrj-8728	495	1	balakrishnan	PERSON
tahrj-8728	495	2	k. g.	PERSON
tahrj-8728	495	3	2010	DATE
tahrj-8728	496	1	india	GPE
tahrj-8728	496	2	22	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	496	3	1	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	497	1	1-16	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	497	2	2010	DATE
tahrj-8728	498	1	new zealand	GPE
tahrj-8728	498	2	265	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	499	1	elliott	PERSON
tahrj-8728	499	2	m. (	PERSON
tahrj-8728	499	3	2001	DATE
tahrj-8728	500	1	1998	DATE
tahrj-8728	500	2	cambridge	GPE
tahrj-8728	500	3	60	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	500	4	301	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	501	1	hathaway	PERSON
tahrj-8728	501	2	j. c.	PERSON
tahrj-8728	501	3	harvey	GPE
tahrj-8728	501	4	c. j. (	PERSON
tahrj-8728	501	5	2001	DATE
tahrj-8728	502	1	cornell international law journal	ORG
tahrj-8728	502	2	34	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	503	1	257-320	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	504	1	knight	PERSON
tahrj-8728	504	2	2010	DATE
tahrj-8728	505	1	new zealand	GPE
tahrj-8728	505	2	393	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	506	1	mavronicola	ORG
tahrj-8728	506	2	n.	PERSON
tahrj-8728	506	3	f.	PERSON
tahrj-8728	506	4	2013	DATE
tahrj-8728	508	1	article 3 echr	LAW
tahrj-8728	508	2	ahmad	PERSON
tahrj-8728	508	3	76(6	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	508	4	10251048	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	508	5	a.	PERSON
tahrj-8728	508	6	1999	DATE
tahrj-8728	509	1	the european court of human rights’	ORG
tahrj-8728	509	2	62(5	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	510	1	671-696	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	511	1	mullan	PERSON
tahrj-8728	511	2	2010	DATE
tahrj-8728	512	1	canadian	NORP
tahrj-8728	512	2	new zealand	GPE
tahrj-8728	512	3	233	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	513	1	sabreen ahmed	PERSON
tahrj-8728	513	2	24	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	513	3	june 2025	DATE
tahrj-8728	513	4	e8728 issn	PERSON
tahrj-8728	513	5	2340-9592	DATE
tahrj-8728	513	6	10.17561/tahrj.v23.8728	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	513	7	25	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	513	8	steyn	PERSON
tahrj-8728	513	9	2004	DATE
tahrj-8728	514	1	english	LANGUAGE
tahrj-8728	515	1	588–591	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	515	2	2016	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	516	1	european	NORP
tahrj-8728	516	2	european journal of international law	ORG
tahrj-8728	516	3	74	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	517	1	1994	DATE
tahrj-8728	518	1	university of richmond law review	ORG
tahrj-8728	518	2	29	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	518	3	99	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	519	1	srirangam	ORG
tahrj-8728	519	2	2016	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	520	1	4	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	520	2	10.14296	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	520	3	a.s.	GPE
tahrj-8728	520	4	mathews	ORG
tahrj-8728	520	5	j. (2008	PERSON
tahrj-8728	521	1	columbia journal of transnational law	ORG
tahrj-8728	521	2	47	DATE
tahrj-8728	522	1	68-149	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	523	1	taggart	ORG
tahrj-8728	523	2	m. (2008	PERSON
tahrj-8728	524	1	new zealand	GPE
tahrj-8728	524	2	423	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	525	1	z. m.	PERSON
tahrj-8728	525	2	2018	DATE
tahrj-8728	526	1	article 33(2	LAW
tahrj-8728	526	2	1951	DATE
tahrj-8728	526	3	refugee convention	EVENT
tahrj-8728	526	4	african	NORP
tahrj-8728	527	1	304-332	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	528	1	chandra	PERSON
tahrj-8728	528	2	a.	PERSON
tahrj-8728	528	3	2004	DATE
tahrj-8728	529	1	india	GPE
tahrj-8728	529	2	oxford	NORP
tahrj-8728	529	3	64	DATE
tahrj-8728	529	4	04.09.24	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	530	1	frantziou	PERSON
tahrj-8728	530	2	e.	PERSON
tahrj-8728	530	3	2014	DATE
tahrj-8728	531	1	ucl	ORG
tahrj-8728	531	2	october 2014	DATE
tahrj-8728	531	3	european	NORP
tahrj-8728	532	1	ucl	ORG
tahrj-8728	535	1	04.10.24	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	536	1	kumar, a. (	PERSON
tahrj-8728	536	2	2018	DATE
tahrj-8728	537	1	indian	NORP
tahrj-8728	539	1	02.10.24	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	540	1	un	ORG
tahrj-8728	540	2	unhcr	ORG
tahrj-8728	540	3	1997	DATE
tahrj-8728	541	1	unhcr	ORG
tahrj-8728	542	1	02.09.24	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	543	1	2013	DATE
tahrj-8728	544	1	i. diálogo	PERSON
tahrj-8728	544	2	jurisprudencial y control de convencionalidad	PERSON
tahrj-8728	545	1	una mirada comparada’	ORG
tahrj-8728	546	1	seminario internacional diálogo jurisprudencial e https://doi.org/10.17561/tahrj.v23.8728 https://ohrh.law.ox.ac.uk/proportionality-in-india-a-bridge-to-nowhere	PERSON
tahrj-8728	546	2	india	GPE
tahrj-8728	546	3	24	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	546	4	june 2025	DATE
tahrj-8728	546	5	e8728 issn	PERSON
tahrj-8728	546	6	2340-9592	DATE
tahrj-8728	546	7	10.17561	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	546	8	26	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	546	9	impacto de las	ORG
tahrj-8728	546	10	de la corte interamericana de derechos humanos	ORG
tahrj-8728	547	1	mexico city	GPE
tahrj-8728	547	2	11	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	547	3	october 2013	DATE
tahrj-8728	548	1	8-11	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	549	1	american	NORP
tahrj-8728	549	2	1969	DATE
tahrj-8728	550	1	1950	DATE
tahrj-8728	551	1	189	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	551	2	150	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	551	3	april 22, 1954	DATE
tahrj-8728	552	1	united nations	ORG
tahrj-8728	553	1	1951	DATE
tahrj-8728	554	1	1946	DATE
tahrj-8728	555	1	kenya	GPE
tahrj-8728	556	1	kenya	GPE
tahrj-8728	556	2	2010	DATE
tahrj-8728	557	1	un	ORG
tahrj-8728	557	2	g.a res	PERSON
tahrj-8728	558	1	2312	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	558	2	1967	DATE
tahrj-8728	559	1	inter-american	NORP
tahrj-8728	559	2	19 august 2014	DATE
tahrj-8728	560	1	inter-american	NORP
tahrj-8728	560	2	inter-american	NORP
tahrj-8728	560	3	30 may 2018	DATE
tahrj-8728	561	1	african	NORP
tahrj-8728	561	2	kenya	GPE
tahrj-8728	561	3	2013	DATE
tahrj-8728	562	1	apdh v. republic of	ORG
tahrj-8728	562	2	cote	GPE
tahrj-8728	562	3	2016	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	562	4	2	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	562	5	141	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	563	1	1948	DATE
tahrj-8728	563	2	1	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	563	3	223	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	564	1	babar ahmad	PERSON
tahrj-8728	564	2	the united kingdom	GPE
tahrj-8728	564	3	24027/07	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	564	4	11949/08	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	564	5	36742/08	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	564	6	66911/09	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	564	7	67354/09	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	564	8	council of europe:	ORG
tahrj-8728	564	9	european	NORP
tahrj-8728	564	10	10	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	564	11	april 2012	DATE
tahrj-8728	565	1	bachan singh	ORG
tahrj-8728	566	1	india	GPE
tahrj-8728	566	2	1980	DATE
tahrj-8728	566	3	2	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	566	4	684	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	567	1	belgian	NORP
tahrj-8728	567	2	1968	DATE
tahrj-8728	567	3	1	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	567	4	252	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	567	5	bennett & coleman v. union of india	ORG
tahrj-8728	567	6	1973	DATE
tahrj-8728	567	7	2	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	568	1	chahal v.	PERSON
tahrj-8728	568	2	the united kingdom	GPE
tahrj-8728	568	3	1996	DATE
tahrj-8728	568	4	apfsp	PERSON
tahrj-8728	568	5	22414/93	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	569	1	chintaman rao v. state	PERSON
tahrj-8728	569	2	m.p (	GPE
tahrj-8728	569	3	1	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	569	4	118	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	570	1	cossey v. united kingdom	PERSON
tahrj-8728	570	2	1990	DATE
tahrj-8728	571	1	https://doi.org/10.17561/tahrj.v23.8728	FAC
tahrj-8728	571	2	ahmed	PERSON
tahrj-8728	571	3	24	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	571	4	june 2025	DATE
tahrj-8728	571	5	e8728 issn	PERSON
tahrj-8728	571	6	2340-9592	DATE
tahrj-8728	571	7	10.17561	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	571	8	27	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	571	9	1984	DATE
tahrj-8728	572	1	1985	DATE
tahrj-8728	572	2	3	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	572	3	11741	DATE
tahrj-8728	573	1	1985	DATE
tahrj-8728	573	2	374	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	573	3	410	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	574	1	1983	DATE
tahrj-8728	574	2	395	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	575	1	gomes lund et al	PERSON
tahrj-8728	576	1	brazil	GPE
tahrj-8728	576	2	inter-american	NORP
tahrj-8728	577	1	219	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	577	2	24 november 2010	DATE
tahrj-8728	578	1	handyside	PERSON
tahrj-8728	578	2	united kingdom	GPE
tahrj-8728	578	3	no 5493/72	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	579	1	1976	DATE
tahrj-8728	580	1	haitian	NORP
tahrj-8728	580	2	haitian	NORP
tahrj-8728	580	3	u.s. supreme court	ORG
tahrj-8728	580	4	21 june 1993	DATE
tahrj-8728	581	1	hans muller	PERSON
tahrj-8728	581	2	nuremberg	GPE
tahrj-8728	581	3	calcutta	ORG
tahrj-8728	581	4	1955	DATE
tahrj-8728	581	5	air sc 367	ORG
tahrj-8728	582	1	hirsi jamaa	PERSON
tahrj-8728	582	2	italy	GPE
tahrj-8728	583	1	27765/09	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	583	2	23	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	583	3	february 2012	DATE
tahrj-8728	584	1	ingabire victoire umuhoza v. republic	PERSON
tahrj-8728	584	2	rwanda	GPE
tahrj-8728	584	3	2017	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	585	1	ireland	GPE
tahrj-8728	585	2	uk	GPE
tahrj-8728	585	3	1979-1980	DATE
tahrj-8728	585	4	25	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	586	1	kennedy v. charity commission	PERSON
tahrj-8728	587	1	2015	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	587	2	20	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	587	3	2015	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	588	1	kharak	GPE
tahrj-8728	588	2	singh v. state	EVENT
tahrj-8728	588	3	uttar pradesh	ORG
tahrj-8728	588	4	1963	DATE
tahrj-8728	588	5	1295	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	589	1	kitua cha sheria	PERSON
tahrj-8728	589	2	2017	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	589	3	108	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	589	4	2014	DATE
tahrj-8728	590	1	lohe issa konate	PERSON
tahrj-8728	590	2	burkino	PERSON
tahrj-8728	590	3	faso	GPE
tahrj-8728	590	4	2014	DATE
tahrj-8728	590	5	004/2013	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	591	1	louis de raedt v. union	PERSON
tahrj-8728	591	2	india	GPE
tahrj-8728	591	3	1991	DATE
tahrj-8728	591	4	3	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	591	5	554	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	592	1	askar v. turkey	PERSON
tahrj-8728	592	2	2005	DATE
tahrj-8728	592	3	41	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	592	4	gandhi v. union of india	ORG
tahrj-8728	592	5	1978	DATE
tahrj-8728	592	6	1	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	592	7	248	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	593	1	manohar lal sharma v. union	PERSON
tahrj-8728	593	2	2021	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	593	3	air sc 5396	ORG
tahrj-8728	594	1	madhya pradesh	ORG
tahrj-8728	594	2	2016	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	594	3	7	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	594	4	353	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	595	1	mohammad salimullah v. union	PERSON
tahrj-8728	595	2	2021	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	595	3	air sc	ORG
tahrj-8728	595	4	1753	DATE
tahrj-8728	596	1	n.d.	GPE
tahrj-8728	596	2	n.t.	GPE
tahrj-8728	596	3	spain	GPE
tahrj-8728	596	4	8675/15	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	596	5	13 february 2020	DATE
tahrj-8728	597	1	nada	ORG
tahrj-8728	597	2	switzerland	GPE
tahrj-8728	597	3	2012	DATE
tahrj-8728	597	4	no 10593/08	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	598	1	manipur	GPE
tahrj-8728	599	1	6	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	599	2	2021	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	601	1	k ghosh v. e x joseph	PERSON
tahrj-8728	601	2	1963	DATE
tahrj-8728	601	3	air sc 812	ORG
tahrj-8728	602	1	pacheco tineo family	PERSON
tahrj-8728	602	2	bolivia	GPE
tahrj-8728	602	3	inter-american	NORP
tahrj-8728	602	4	272	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	602	5	25	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	602	6	november 2013	DATE
tahrj-8728	603	1	pham v. home	ORG
tahrj-8728	603	2	2015	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	603	3	1	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	604	1	india	GPE
tahrj-8728	604	2	24	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	604	3	june 2025	DATE
tahrj-8728	604	4	e8728 issn	PERSON
tahrj-8728	604	5	2340-9592	DATE
tahrj-8728	604	6	10.17561/tahrj.v23.8728	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	604	7	28	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	604	8	india	GPE
tahrj-8728	604	9	2019	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	604	10	1	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	604	11	2011	DATE
tahrj-8728	604	12	45	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	605	1	1996	DATE
tahrj-8728	605	2	517	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	606	1	1986	DATE
tahrj-8728	606	2	1	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	607	1	r. v.	PERSON
tahrj-8728	609	1	1996	DATE
tahrj-8728	609	2	4	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	609	3	427	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	610	1	1991	DATE
tahrj-8728	610	2	1	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	610	3	696	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	611	1	p daly (2001	ORG
tahrj-8728	611	2	ukhl 26	FAC
tahrj-8728	612	1	wellington	GPE
tahrj-8728	612	2	2008	DATE
tahrj-8728	612	3	ukhl 72	ORG
tahrj-8728	613	1	2012	DATE
tahrj-8728	613	2	468	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	613	3	2010	DATE
tahrj-8728	614	1	the union of india	ORG
tahrj-8728	614	2	mohammad salimullah v. union	PERSON
tahrj-8728	614	3	2017	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	615	1	793	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	615	2	2017	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	616	1	saadi v. italy	PERSON
tahrj-8728	616	2	2008	DATE
tahrj-8728	617	1	smith	PERSON
tahrj-8728	617	2	gardy v. united kingdom	PERSON
tahrj-8728	617	3	1999	DATE
tahrj-8728	617	4	29	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	617	5	493	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	618	1	1998	DATE
tahrj-8728	618	2	20/1997/804/1007	DATE
tahrj-8728	618	3	ecthr	GPE
tahrj-8728	619	1	the united kingdom	GPE
tahrj-8728	619	2	1989	DATE
tahrj-8728	621	1	spuc v grogan	PERSON
tahrj-8728	621	2	1991	DATE
tahrj-8728	621	3	c-159/90	ORG
tahrj-8728	622	1	arunachal pradesh v. national human rights commission 1996 scc	ORG
tahrj-8728	622	2	1	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	622	3	742	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	623	1	subramaniam swamy v union	PERSON
tahrj-8728	623	2	india	GPE
tahrj-8728	623	3	2016	DATE
tahrj-8728	623	4	air sc 2728	ORG
tahrj-8728	624	1	1960	DATE
tahrj-8728	624	2	2	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	625	1	christopher r mitilika	PERSON
tahrj-8728	625	2	united republic	GPE
tahrj-8728	625	3	tanzania	GPE
tahrj-8728	625	4	2013	DATE
tahrj-8728	625	5	african	NORP
tahrj-8728	626	1	tanzania	GPE
tahrj-8728	626	2	christopher r. mitilika	PERSON
tahrj-8728	626	3	united republic	GPE
tahrj-8728	626	4	2013	DATE
tahrj-8728	626	5	011/2011	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	627	1	ochieng anudo	PERSON
tahrj-8728	627	2	united republic	GPE
tahrj-8728	627	3	2018	DATE
tahrj-8728	628	1	usón ramírez v. venezuela	PERSON
tahrj-8728	628	2	inter-american	NORP
tahrj-8728	628	3	207	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	628	4	20	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	628	5	november 2009	DATE
tahrj-8728	629	1	madras	GPE
tahrj-8728	629	2	1952	DATE
tahrj-8728	629	3	air sc 196	ORG
tahrj-8728	630	1	the united kingdom	GPE
tahrj-8728	630	2	1991	DATE
tahrj-8728	631	1	https://doi.org/10.17561/tahrj.v23.8728	FAC
tahrj-8728	631	2	ahmed	PERSON
tahrj-8728	631	3	24	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	631	4	june 2025	DATE
tahrj-8728	631	5	e8728 issn	PERSON
tahrj-8728	631	6	2340-9592	DATE
tahrj-8728	631	7	10.17561/tahrj.v23.8728	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	631	8	29	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	631	9	das,	ORG
tahrj-8728	631	10	k. n.	PERSON
tahrj-8728	631	11	s.	PERSON
tahrj-8728	631	12	2017	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	632	1	india	GPE
tahrj-8728	632	2	un	ORG
tahrj-8728	632	3	reuters	ORG
tahrj-8728	633	1	4th	ORDINAL
tahrj-8728	633	2	2024	DATE
tahrj-8728	633	3	22nd october 2024	DATE
tahrj-8728	633	4	india	GPE
tahrj-8728	633	5	1	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	634	1	european	NORP
tahrj-8728	634	2	1.1	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	635	1	1.2	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	636	1	ecthr	ORG
tahrj-8728	636	2	1.3	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	637	1	inter-american	NORP
tahrj-8728	637	2	2	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	637	3	african	NORP
tahrj-8728	637	4	2.1	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	638	1	africa	LOC
tahrj-8728	639	1	3	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	639	2	india	GPE
tahrj-8728	640	1	3.1	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	641	1	india	GPE
tahrj-8728	642	1	3.2	CARDINAL
tahrj-8728	643	1	india	GPE
tahrj-8728	644	1	4	CARDINAL