id	sid	tid	token	lemma	pos
tahrj-8728	1	1	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	1	2	analysis	analysis	NOUN
tahrj-8728	1	3	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	1	4	non	non	ADJ
tahrj-8728	1	5	-	-	ADJ
tahrj-8728	1	6	refoulement	refoulement	ADJ
tahrj-8728	1	7	jurisprudence	jurisprudence	NOUN
tahrj-8728	1	8	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	1	9	india	india	PROPN
tahrj-8728	1	10	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	1	11	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	1	12	comparative	comparative	ADJ
tahrj-8728	1	13	approach	approach	NOUN
tahrj-8728	1	14	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	1	15	age	age	NOUN
tahrj-8728	1	16	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	1	17	human	human	ADJ
tahrj-8728	1	18	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	1	19	journal	journal	NOUN
tahrj-8728	1	20	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	1	21	24	24	NUM
tahrj-8728	1	22	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	1	23	june	june	PROPN
tahrj-8728	1	24	2025	2025	NUM
tahrj-8728	1	25	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	1	26	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	1	27	e8728	e8728	PROPN
tahrj-8728	1	28	issn	issn	PROPN
tahrj-8728	1	29	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	1	30	2340	2340	NUM
tahrj-8728	1	31	-	-	SYM
tahrj-8728	1	32	9592	9592	NUM
tahrj-8728	1	33	doi	doi	NOUN
tahrj-8728	1	34	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	1	35	10.17561	10.17561	NUM
tahrj-8728	1	36	/	/	SYM
tahrj-8728	1	37	tahrj.v23.8728	tahrj.v23.8728	PROPN
tahrj-8728	1	38	1	1	NUM
tahrj-8728	1	39	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	1	40	analysis	analysis	NOUN
tahrj-8728	1	41	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	1	42	non	non	ADJ
tahrj-8728	1	43	-	-	ADJ
tahrj-8728	1	44	refoulement	refoulement	ADJ
tahrj-8728	1	45	jurisprudence	jurisprudence	NOUN
tahrj-8728	1	46	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	1	47	india	india	PROPN
tahrj-8728	1	48	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	1	49	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	1	50	comparative	comparative	ADJ
tahrj-8728	1	51	approach	approach	NOUN
tahrj-8728	1	52	sabreen	sabreen	PROPN
tahrj-8728	1	53	ahmed	ahmed	PROPN
tahrj-8728	1	54	*	*	PROPN
tahrj-8728	1	55	abstract	abstract	PROPN
tahrj-8728	1	56	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	1	57	india	india	PROPN
tahrj-8728	1	58	does	do	AUX
tahrj-8728	1	59	not	not	PART
tahrj-8728	1	60	have	have	VERB
tahrj-8728	1	61	an	an	DET
tahrj-8728	1	62	explicit	explicit	ADJ
tahrj-8728	1	63	refugee	refugee	NOUN
tahrj-8728	1	64	regime	regime	NOUN
tahrj-8728	1	65	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	1	66	most	most	ADJ
tahrj-8728	1	67	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	1	68	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	1	69	jurisprudence	jurisprudence	NOUN
tahrj-8728	1	70	on	on	ADP
tahrj-8728	1	71	refugee	refugee	NOUN
tahrj-8728	1	72	protection	protection	NOUN
tahrj-8728	1	73	comes	come	VERB
tahrj-8728	1	74	from	from	ADP
tahrj-8728	1	75	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	1	76	judgements	judgement	NOUN
tahrj-8728	1	77	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	2	1	however	however	ADV
tahrj-8728	2	2	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	2	3	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	2	4	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	2	5	absence	absence	NOUN
tahrj-8728	2	6	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	2	7	law	law	NOUN
tahrj-8728	2	8	or	or	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	2	9	explicit	explicit	ADJ
tahrj-8728	2	10	domestication	domestication	NOUN
tahrj-8728	2	11	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	2	12	international	international	ADJ
tahrj-8728	2	13	refugee	refugee	NOUN
tahrj-8728	2	14	law	law	NOUN
tahrj-8728	2	15	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	2	16	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	2	17	supreme	supreme	PROPN
tahrj-8728	2	18	court	court	PROPN
tahrj-8728	2	19	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	2	20	india	india	PROPN
tahrj-8728	2	21	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	2	22	sci	sci	PROPN
tahrj-8728	2	23	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	2	24	struggles	struggle	VERB
tahrj-8728	2	25	with	with	ADP
tahrj-8728	2	26	consistent	consistent	ADJ
tahrj-8728	2	27	interpretation	interpretation	NOUN
tahrj-8728	2	28	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	2	29	non	non	ADJ
tahrj-8728	2	30	-	-	ADJ
tahrj-8728	2	31	refoulement	refoulement	ADJ
tahrj-8728	2	32	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	3	1	many	many	ADJ
tahrj-8728	3	2	scholars	scholar	NOUN
tahrj-8728	3	3	suggest	suggest	VERB
tahrj-8728	3	4	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	3	5	presence	presence	NOUN
tahrj-8728	3	6	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	3	7	non	non	ADJ
tahrj-8728	3	8	-	-	ADJ
tahrj-8728	3	9	refoulement	refoulement	ADJ
tahrj-8728	3	10	as	as	ADP
tahrj-8728	3	11	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	3	12	substantive	substantive	ADJ
tahrj-8728	3	13	right	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	3	14	under	under	ADP
tahrj-8728	3	15	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	3	16	right	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	3	17	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	3	18	life	life	NOUN
tahrj-8728	3	19	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	3	20	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	3	21	constitution	constitution	NOUN
tahrj-8728	3	22	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	3	23	india	india	PROPN
tahrj-8728	3	24	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	3	25	1950	1950	NUM
tahrj-8728	3	26	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	3	27	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	4	1	however	however	ADV
tahrj-8728	4	2	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	4	3	it	it	PRON
tahrj-8728	4	4	has	have	AUX
tahrj-8728	4	5	not	not	PART
tahrj-8728	4	6	been	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	4	7	consistently	consistently	ADV
tahrj-8728	4	8	accepted	accept	VERB
tahrj-8728	4	9	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	5	1	significantly	significantly	ADV
tahrj-8728	5	2	art	art	NOUN
tahrj-8728	5	3	21	21	NUM
tahrj-8728	5	4	allows	allow	VERB
tahrj-8728	5	5	limitation	limitation	NOUN
tahrj-8728	5	6	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	5	7	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	5	8	form	form	NOUN
tahrj-8728	5	9	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	5	10	‘	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	5	11	procedure	procedure	NOUN
tahrj-8728	5	12	established	establish	VERB
tahrj-8728	5	13	by	by	ADP
tahrj-8728	5	14	law	law	NOUN
tahrj-8728	5	15	’	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	5	16	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	5	17	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	5	18	avail	avail	VERB
tahrj-8728	5	19	constitutional	constitutional	ADJ
tahrj-8728	5	20	justification	justification	NOUN
tahrj-8728	5	21	for	for	ADP
tahrj-8728	5	22	limiting	limit	VERB
tahrj-8728	5	23	nonrefoulement	nonrefoulement	ADJ
tahrj-8728	5	24	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	5	25	citing	cite	VERB
tahrj-8728	5	26	national	national	ADJ
tahrj-8728	5	27	security	security	NOUN
tahrj-8728	5	28	concerns	concern	NOUN
tahrj-8728	5	29	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	6	1	an	an	DET
tahrj-8728	6	2	analysis	analysis	NOUN
tahrj-8728	6	3	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	6	4	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	6	5	recent	recent	ADJ
tahrj-8728	6	6	repatriation	repatriation	NOUN
tahrj-8728	6	7	judgment	judgment	NOUN
tahrj-8728	6	8	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	6	9	sc	sc	PROPN
tahrj-8728	6	10	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	6	11	india	india	PROPN
tahrj-8728	6	12	suggests	suggest	VERB
tahrj-8728	6	13	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	6	14	application	application	NOUN
tahrj-8728	6	15	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	6	16	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	6	17	wednesbury	wednesbury	NOUN
tahrj-8728	6	18	-	-	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	6	19	like	like	ADJ
tahrj-8728	6	20	approach	approach	NOUN
tahrj-8728	6	21	which	which	PRON
tahrj-8728	6	22	is	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	6	23	aimed	aim	VERB
tahrj-8728	6	24	at	at	ADP
tahrj-8728	6	25	finding	find	VERB
tahrj-8728	6	26	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	6	27	reasonable	reasonable	ADJ
tahrj-8728	6	28	justification	justification	NOUN
tahrj-8728	6	29	for	for	ADP
tahrj-8728	6	30	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	6	31	state	state	NOUN
tahrj-8728	6	32	’s	’s	PART
tahrj-8728	6	33	action	action	NOUN
tahrj-8728	6	34	without	without	ADP
tahrj-8728	6	35	getting	get	VERB
tahrj-8728	6	36	into	into	ADP
tahrj-8728	6	37	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	6	38	‘	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	6	39	balancing	balance	VERB
tahrj-8728	6	40	mechanism	mechanism	NOUN
tahrj-8728	6	41	’	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	6	42	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	7	1	this	this	DET
tahrj-8728	7	2	article	article	NOUN
tahrj-8728	7	3	adopts	adopt	VERB
tahrj-8728	7	4	comparative	comparative	ADJ
tahrj-8728	7	5	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	7	6	analytical	analytical	ADJ
tahrj-8728	7	7	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	7	8	doctrinal	doctrinal	ADJ
tahrj-8728	7	9	methodology	methodology	NOUN
tahrj-8728	7	10	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	7	11	examine	examine	VERB
tahrj-8728	7	12	how	how	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	7	13	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	7	14	indian	indian	ADJ
tahrj-8728	7	15	judiciary	judiciary	NOUN
tahrj-8728	7	16	can	can	AUX
tahrj-8728	7	17	utilize	utilize	VERB
tahrj-8728	7	18	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	7	19	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	7	20	analysis	analysis	NOUN
tahrj-8728	7	21	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	7	22	non	non	ADJ
tahrj-8728	7	23	-	-	ADJ
tahrj-8728	7	24	refoulement	refoulement	ADJ
tahrj-8728	7	25	cases	case	NOUN
tahrj-8728	7	26	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	7	27	attain	attain	VERB
tahrj-8728	7	28	better	well	ADJ
tahrj-8728	7	29	outcomes	outcome	NOUN
tahrj-8728	7	30	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	8	1	firstly	firstly	ADV
tahrj-8728	8	2	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	8	3	this	this	DET
tahrj-8728	8	4	article	article	NOUN
tahrj-8728	8	5	explains	explain	VERB
tahrj-8728	8	6	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	8	7	concepts	concept	NOUN
tahrj-8728	8	8	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	8	9	wednesbury	wednesbury	NOUN
tahrj-8728	8	10	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	8	11	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	8	12	analysis	analysis	NOUN
tahrj-8728	8	13	rooted	root	VERB
tahrj-8728	8	14	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	8	15	european	european	ADJ
tahrj-8728	8	16	jurisprudence	jurisprudence	NOUN
tahrj-8728	8	17	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	8	18	its	its	PRON
tahrj-8728	8	19	application	application	NOUN
tahrj-8728	8	20	by	by	ADP
tahrj-8728	8	21	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	8	22	ecthr	ecthr	PROPN
tahrj-8728	8	23	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	8	24	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	8	25	inter	inter	ADJ
tahrj-8728	8	26	-	-	ADJ
tahrj-8728	8	27	american	american	ADJ
tahrj-8728	8	28	system	system	NOUN
tahrj-8728	8	29	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	8	30	human	human	ADJ
tahrj-8728	8	31	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	8	32	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	8	33	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	8	34	african	african	ADJ
tahrj-8728	8	35	courts	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	8	36	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	9	1	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	9	2	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	9	3	absence	absence	NOUN
tahrj-8728	9	4	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	9	5	any	any	DET
tahrj-8728	9	6	consistent	consistent	ADJ
tahrj-8728	9	7	european	european	ADJ
tahrj-8728	9	8	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	9	9	american	american	ADJ
tahrj-8728	9	10	scholarship	scholarship	NOUN
tahrj-8728	9	11	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	9	12	this	this	DET
tahrj-8728	9	13	article	article	NOUN
tahrj-8728	9	14	draws	draw	VERB
tahrj-8728	9	15	from	from	ADP
tahrj-8728	9	16	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	9	17	african	african	ADJ
tahrj-8728	9	18	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	9	19	's	's	PART
tahrj-8728	9	20	jurisprudence	jurisprudence	NOUN
tahrj-8728	9	21	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	9	22	understand	understand	VERB
tahrj-8728	9	23	how	how	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	9	24	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	9	25	analysis	analysis	NOUN
tahrj-8728	9	26	is	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	9	27	interpreted	interpret	VERB
tahrj-8728	9	28	regionally	regionally	ADV
tahrj-8728	9	29	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	9	30	applied	apply	VERB
tahrj-8728	9	31	by	by	ADP
tahrj-8728	9	32	national	national	ADJ
tahrj-8728	9	33	courts	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	9	34	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	9	35	kenyan	kenyan	ADJ
tahrj-8728	9	36	high	high	ADJ
tahrj-8728	9	37	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	9	38	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	9	39	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	9	40	non	non	ADJ
tahrj-8728	9	41	-	-	ADJ
tahrj-8728	9	42	refoulement	refoulement	ADJ
tahrj-8728	9	43	cases	case	NOUN
tahrj-8728	9	44	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	10	1	finally	finally	ADV
tahrj-8728	10	2	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	10	3	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	10	4	article	article	NOUN
tahrj-8728	10	5	suggests	suggest	VERB
tahrj-8728	10	6	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	10	7	without	without	ADP
tahrj-8728	10	8	any	any	DET
tahrj-8728	10	9	constitutional	constitutional	ADJ
tahrj-8728	10	10	provision	provision	NOUN
tahrj-8728	10	11	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	10	12	limitation	limitation	NOUN
tahrj-8728	10	13	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	10	14	like	like	INTJ
tahrj-8728	10	15	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	10	16	kenya	kenya	PROPN
tahrj-8728	10	17	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	10	18	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	10	19	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	10	20	supreme	supreme	PROPN
tahrj-8728	10	21	court	court	PROPN
tahrj-8728	10	22	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	10	23	india	india	PROPN
tahrj-8728	10	24	needs	need	VERB
tahrj-8728	10	25	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	10	26	adopt	adopt	VERB
tahrj-8728	10	27	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	10	28	‘	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	10	29	rainbow	rainbow	NOUN
tahrj-8728	10	30	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	10	31	review	review	NOUN
tahrj-8728	10	32	’	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	10	33	approach	approach	NOUN
tahrj-8728	10	34	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	10	35	refoulement	refoulement	ADJ
tahrj-8728	10	36	decisions	decision	NOUN
tahrj-8728	10	37	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	10	38	achieve	achieve	VERB
tahrj-8728	10	39	better	well	ADJ
tahrj-8728	10	40	outcomes	outcome	NOUN
tahrj-8728	10	41	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	11	1	this	this	PRON
tahrj-8728	11	2	would	would	AUX
tahrj-8728	11	3	allow	allow	VERB
tahrj-8728	11	4	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	11	5	sc	sc	PROPN
tahrj-8728	11	6	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	11	7	make	make	VERB
tahrj-8728	11	8	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	11	9	gradual	gradual	ADJ
tahrj-8728	11	10	shift	shift	NOUN
tahrj-8728	11	11	towards	towards	ADP
tahrj-8728	11	12	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	11	13	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	11	14	analysis	analysis	NOUN
tahrj-8728	11	15	from	from	ADP
tahrj-8728	11	16	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	11	17	wednesbury	wednesbury	PROPN
tahrj-8728	11	18	principle	principle	PROPN
tahrj-8728	11	19	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	11	20	depending	depend	VERB
tahrj-8728	11	21	on	on	ADP
tahrj-8728	11	22	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	11	23	criticality	criticality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	11	24	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	11	25	human	human	ADJ
tahrj-8728	11	26	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	11	27	violation	violation	NOUN
tahrj-8728	11	28	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	11	29	without	without	ADP
tahrj-8728	11	30	signalling	signal	VERB
tahrj-8728	11	31	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	11	32	complete	complete	ADJ
tahrj-8728	11	33	change	change	NOUN
tahrj-8728	11	34	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	11	35	judicial	judicial	ADJ
tahrj-8728	11	36	attitude	attitude	NOUN
tahrj-8728	11	37	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	12	1	keywords	keyword	NOUN
tahrj-8728	12	2	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	12	3	non	non	ADJ
tahrj-8728	12	4	refoulement	refoulement	NOUN
tahrj-8728	12	5	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	12	6	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	12	7	analysis	analysis	NOUN
tahrj-8728	12	8	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	12	9	wednesbury	wednesbury	PROPN
tahrj-8728	12	10	principle	principle	PROPN
tahrj-8728	12	11	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	12	12	ecthr	ecthr	PROPN
tahrj-8728	12	13	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	12	14	african	african	ADJ
tahrj-8728	12	15	courts	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	12	16	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	13	1	1	1	X
tahrj-8728	13	2	.	.	X
tahrj-8728	13	3	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	13	4	-	-	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	13	5	based	base	VERB
tahrj-8728	13	6	context	context	NOUN
tahrj-8728	13	7	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	13	8	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	13	9	analysis	analysis	NOUN
tahrj-8728	13	10	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	13	11	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	13	12	european	european	ADJ
tahrj-8728	13	13	legal	legal	ADJ
tahrj-8728	13	14	system	system	NOUN
tahrj-8728	13	15	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	13	16	as	as	ADP
tahrj-8728	13	17	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	13	18	general	general	ADJ
tahrj-8728	13	19	principle	principle	NOUN
tahrj-8728	13	20	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	13	21	law	law	NOUN
tahrj-8728	13	22	finds	find	VERB
tahrj-8728	13	23	space	space	NOUN
tahrj-8728	13	24	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	13	25	most	most	ADJ
tahrj-8728	13	26	legal	legal	ADJ
tahrj-8728	13	27	systems	system	NOUN
tahrj-8728	13	28	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	14	1	significantly	significantly	ADV
tahrj-8728	14	2	invoked	invoke	VERB
tahrj-8728	14	3	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	14	4	terms	term	NOUN
tahrj-8728	14	5	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	14	6	its	its	PRON
tahrj-8728	14	7	constitutional	constitutional	ADJ
tahrj-8728	14	8	adjudication	adjudication	NOUN
tahrj-8728	14	9	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	14	10	european	european	PROPN
tahrj-8728	14	11	union	union	PROPN
tahrj-8728	14	12	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	14	13	eu	eu	NOUN
tahrj-8728	14	14	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	14	15	law	law	NOUN
tahrj-8728	14	16	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	14	17	finds	find	VERB
tahrj-8728	14	18	its	its	PRON
tahrj-8728	14	19	origin	origin	NOUN
tahrj-8728	14	20	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	14	21	german	german	ADJ
tahrj-8728	14	22	constitutional	constitutional	ADJ
tahrj-8728	14	23	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	14	24	administrative	administrative	ADJ
tahrj-8728	14	25	jurisprudence	jurisprudence	NOUN
tahrj-8728	14	26	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	14	27	tridimas	tridima	NOUN
tahrj-8728	14	28	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	14	29	2018	2018	NUM
tahrj-8728	14	30	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	14	31	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	15	1	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	15	2	this	this	DET
tahrj-8728	15	3	context	context	NOUN
tahrj-8728	15	4	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	15	5	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	15	6	is	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	15	7	considered	consider	VERB
tahrj-8728	15	8	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	15	9	defining	define	VERB
tahrj-8728	15	10	principle	principle	NOUN
tahrj-8728	15	11	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	15	12	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	15	13	limited	limited	ADJ
tahrj-8728	15	14	government	government	NOUN
tahrj-8728	15	15	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	15	16	acts	act	VERB
tahrj-8728	15	17	as	as	ADP
tahrj-8728	15	18	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	15	19	preferred	preferred	ADJ
tahrj-8728	15	20	procedure	procedure	NOUN
tahrj-8728	15	21	for	for	ADP
tahrj-8728	15	22	managing	manage	VERB
tahrj-8728	15	23	disputes	dispute	NOUN
tahrj-8728	15	24	involving	involve	VERB
tahrj-8728	15	25	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	15	26	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	15	27	provision	provision	NOUN
tahrj-8728	15	28	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	15	29	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	15	30	conflicting	conflict	VERB
tahrj-8728	15	31	state	state	NOUN
tahrj-8728	15	32	interest	interest	NOUN
tahrj-8728	15	33	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	15	34	sweet	sweet	ADJ
tahrj-8728	15	35	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	15	36	mathew	mathew	PROPN
tahrj-8728	15	37	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	15	38	2008	2008	NUM
tahrj-8728	15	39	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	15	40	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	16	1	alec	alec	PROPN
tahrj-8728	16	2	stone	stone	PROPN
tahrj-8728	16	3	sweet	sweet	ADJ
tahrj-8728	16	4	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	16	5	jud	jud	PROPN
tahrj-8728	16	6	mathews	mathews	PROPN
tahrj-8728	16	7	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	16	8	2008	2008	NUM
tahrj-8728	16	9	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	16	10	have	have	AUX
tahrj-8728	16	11	noted	note	VERB
tahrj-8728	16	12	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	16	13	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	16	14	analysis	analysis	NOUN
tahrj-8728	16	15	‘	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	16	16	emerged	emerge	VERB
tahrj-8728	16	17	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	16	18	then	then	ADV
tahrj-8728	16	19	diffused	diffuse	VERB
tahrj-8728	16	20	as	as	ADP
tahrj-8728	16	21	an	an	DET
tahrj-8728	16	22	unwritten	unwritten	ADJ
tahrj-8728	16	23	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	16	24	general	general	ADJ
tahrj-8728	16	25	principle	principle	NOUN
tahrj-8728	16	26	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	16	27	law	law	NOUN
tahrj-8728	16	28	through	through	ADP
tahrj-8728	16	29	judicial	judicial	ADJ
tahrj-8728	16	30	recognition	recognition	NOUN
tahrj-8728	16	31	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	16	32	choice	choice	NOUN
tahrj-8728	16	33	’	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	16	34	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	17	1	thereby	thereby	ADV
tahrj-8728	17	2	materializing	materialize	VERB
tahrj-8728	17	3	as	as	ADP
tahrj-8728	17	4	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	17	5	judicial	judicial	ADJ
tahrj-8728	17	6	doctrine	doctrine	NOUN
tahrj-8728	17	7	for	for	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	17	8	courts	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	17	9	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	17	10	apply	apply	VERB
tahrj-8728	17	11	while	while	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	17	12	reviewing	review	VERB
tahrj-8728	17	13	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	17	14	legality	legality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	17	15	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	17	16	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	17	17	government	government	NOUN
tahrj-8728	17	18	action	action	NOUN
tahrj-8728	17	19	vis	vis	X
tahrj-8728	17	20	a	a	X
tahrj-8728	17	21	vis	vis	X
tahrj-8728	17	22	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	17	23	fundamental	fundamental	ADJ
tahrj-8728	17	24	right	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	17	25	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	18	1	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	18	2	international	international	ADJ
tahrj-8728	18	3	human	human	ADJ
tahrj-8728	18	4	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	18	5	law	law	NOUN
tahrj-8728	18	6	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	18	7	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	18	8	plays	play	VERB
tahrj-8728	18	9	an	an	DET
tahrj-8728	18	10	important	important	ADJ
tahrj-8728	18	11	role	role	NOUN
tahrj-8728	18	12	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	18	13	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	18	14	application	application	NOUN
tahrj-8728	18	15	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	18	16	human	human	ADJ
tahrj-8728	18	17	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	18	18	instruments	instrument	NOUN
tahrj-8728	18	19	like	like	ADP
tahrj-8728	18	20	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	18	21	international	international	ADJ
tahrj-8728	18	22	covenant	covenant	NOUN
tahrj-8728	18	23	on	on	ADP
tahrj-8728	18	24	civil	civil	ADJ
tahrj-8728	18	25	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	18	26	political	political	ADJ
tahrj-8728	18	27	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	18	28	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	18	29	‘	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	18	30	iccpr	iccpr	ADJ
tahrj-8728	18	31	’	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	18	32	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	18	33	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	19	1	from	from	ADP
tahrj-8728	19	2	there	there	ADV
tahrj-8728	19	3	it	it	PRON
tahrj-8728	19	4	even	even	ADV
tahrj-8728	19	5	*	*	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	19	6	jindal	jindal	PROPN
tahrj-8728	19	7	global	global	PROPN
tahrj-8728	19	8	law	law	PROPN
tahrj-8728	19	9	school	school	NOUN
tahrj-8728	19	10	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	19	11	o.p	o.p	PROPN
tahrj-8728	19	12	jindal	jindal	PROPN
tahrj-8728	19	13	global	global	PROPN
tahrj-8728	19	14	university	university	PROPN
tahrj-8728	19	15	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	19	16	sonipat	sonipat	PROPN
tahrj-8728	19	17	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	19	18	india	india	PROPN
tahrj-8728	19	19	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	19	20	e	e	X
tahrj-8728	19	21	-	-	NOUN
tahrj-8728	19	22	mail	mail	NOUN
tahrj-8728	19	23	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	19	24	sabreen.ahmed@jgu.edu.in	sabreen.ahmed@jgu.edu.in	PROPN
tahrj-8728	19	25	https://doi.org/10.17561/tahrj.v23.8728	https://doi.org/10.17561/tahrj.v23.8728	PROPN
tahrj-8728	19	26	mailto:sabreen.ahmed@jgu.edu.in	mailto:sabreen.ahmed@jgu.edu.in	NUM
tahrj-8728	19	27	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	19	28	analysis	analysis	NOUN
tahrj-8728	19	29	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	19	30	non	non	ADJ
tahrj-8728	19	31	-	-	ADJ
tahrj-8728	19	32	refoulement	refoulement	ADJ
tahrj-8728	19	33	jurisprudence	jurisprudence	NOUN
tahrj-8728	19	34	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	19	35	india	india	PROPN
tahrj-8728	19	36	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	19	37	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	19	38	comparative	comparative	ADJ
tahrj-8728	19	39	approach	approach	NOUN
tahrj-8728	19	40	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	19	41	age	age	NOUN
tahrj-8728	19	42	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	19	43	human	human	ADJ
tahrj-8728	19	44	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	19	45	journal	journal	NOUN
tahrj-8728	19	46	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	19	47	24	24	NUM
tahrj-8728	19	48	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	19	49	june	june	PROPN
tahrj-8728	19	50	2025	2025	NUM
tahrj-8728	19	51	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	19	52	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	19	53	e8728	e8728	PROPN
tahrj-8728	19	54	issn	issn	PROPN
tahrj-8728	19	55	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	19	56	2340	2340	NUM
tahrj-8728	19	57	-	-	SYM
tahrj-8728	19	58	9592	9592	NUM
tahrj-8728	19	59	doi	doi	NOUN
tahrj-8728	19	60	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	19	61	10.17561	10.17561	NUM
tahrj-8728	19	62	/	/	SYM
tahrj-8728	19	63	tahrj.v23.8728	tahrj.v23.8728	PROPN
tahrj-8728	19	64	2	2	NUM
tahrj-8728	19	65	translates	translate	VERB
tahrj-8728	19	66	into	into	ADP
tahrj-8728	19	67	regional	regional	ADJ
tahrj-8728	19	68	human	human	ADJ
tahrj-8728	19	69	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	19	70	instruments	instrument	NOUN
tahrj-8728	19	71	like	like	ADP
tahrj-8728	19	72	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	19	73	european	european	PROPN
tahrj-8728	19	74	convention	convention	PROPN
tahrj-8728	19	75	on	on	ADP
tahrj-8728	19	76	human	human	ADJ
tahrj-8728	19	77	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	19	78	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	19	79	echr	echr	PROPN
tahrj-8728	19	80	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	19	81	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	19	82	ellis	ellis	PROPN
tahrj-8728	19	83	1999	1999	NUM
tahrj-8728	19	84	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	19	85	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	20	1	since	since	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	20	2	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	20	3	principle	principle	NOUN
tahrj-8728	20	4	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	20	5	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	20	6	permeates	permeate	VERB
tahrj-8728	20	7	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	20	8	whole	whole	ADJ
tahrj-8728	20	9	eu	eu	PROPN
tahrj-8728	20	10	legal	legal	ADJ
tahrj-8728	20	11	system	system	NOUN
tahrj-8728	20	12	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	20	13	echr	echr	PROPN
tahrj-8728	20	14	offers	offer	VERB
tahrj-8728	20	15	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	20	16	good	good	ADJ
tahrj-8728	20	17	starting	starting	NOUN
tahrj-8728	20	18	point	point	NOUN
tahrj-8728	20	19	for	for	ADP
tahrj-8728	20	20	understanding	understand	VERB
tahrj-8728	20	21	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	20	22	principle	principle	NOUN
tahrj-8728	20	23	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	21	1	art	art	NOUN
tahrj-8728	21	2	8	8	NUM
tahrj-8728	21	3	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	21	4	11	11	NUM
tahrj-8728	21	5	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	21	6	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	21	7	convention	convention	NOUN
tahrj-8728	21	8	lays	lay	VERB
tahrj-8728	21	9	down	down	ADP
tahrj-8728	21	10	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	21	11	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	21	12	test	test	NOUN
tahrj-8728	21	13	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	22	1	however	however	ADV
tahrj-8728	22	2	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	22	3	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	22	4	european	european	PROPN
tahrj-8728	22	5	court	court	PROPN
tahrj-8728	22	6	has	have	AUX
tahrj-8728	22	7	conducted	conduct	VERB
tahrj-8728	22	8	such	such	ADJ
tahrj-8728	22	9	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	22	10	inquiry	inquiry	NOUN
tahrj-8728	22	11	for	for	ADP
tahrj-8728	22	12	other	other	ADJ
tahrj-8728	22	13	convention	convention	NOUN
tahrj-8728	22	14	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	22	15	as	as	ADV
tahrj-8728	22	16	well	well	ADV
tahrj-8728	22	17	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	23	1	for	for	ADP
tahrj-8728	23	2	example	example	NOUN
tahrj-8728	23	3	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	23	4	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	23	5	belgian	belgian	ADJ
tahrj-8728	23	6	linguistics	linguistic	NOUN
tahrj-8728	23	7	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	23	8	1968	1968	NUM
tahrj-8728	23	9	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	23	10	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	23	11	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	23	12	held	hold	VERB
tahrj-8728	23	13	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	23	14	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	23	15	art	art	NOUN
tahrj-8728	23	16	14	14	NUM
tahrj-8728	23	17	is	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	23	18	violated	violate	VERB
tahrj-8728	23	19	when	when	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	23	20	it	it	PRON
tahrj-8728	23	21	is	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	23	22	established	establish	VERB
tahrj-8728	23	23	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	23	24	there	there	PRON
tahrj-8728	23	25	is	be	VERB
tahrj-8728	23	26	no	no	DET
tahrj-8728	23	27	reasonable	reasonable	ADJ
tahrj-8728	23	28	relationship	relationship	NOUN
tahrj-8728	23	29	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	23	30	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	23	31	between	between	ADP
tahrj-8728	23	32	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	23	33	means	mean	NOUN
tahrj-8728	23	34	employed	employ	VERB
tahrj-8728	23	35	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	23	36	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	23	37	aim	aim	NOUN
tahrj-8728	23	38	sought	seek	VERB
tahrj-8728	23	39	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	23	40	be	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	23	41	realized	realize	VERB
tahrj-8728	23	42	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	24	1	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	24	2	simple	simple	ADJ
tahrj-8728	24	3	terms	term	NOUN
tahrj-8728	24	4	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	24	5	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	24	6	analysis	analysis	NOUN
tahrj-8728	24	7	aims	aim	VERB
tahrj-8728	24	8	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	24	9	strike	strike	VERB
tahrj-8728	24	10	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	24	11	balance	balance	NOUN
tahrj-8728	24	12	between	between	ADP
tahrj-8728	24	13	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	24	14	interest	interest	NOUN
tahrj-8728	24	15	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	24	16	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	24	17	community	community	NOUN
tahrj-8728	24	18	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	24	19	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	24	20	protection	protection	NOUN
tahrj-8728	24	21	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	24	22	an	an	DET
tahrj-8728	24	23	individual	individual	NOUN
tahrj-8728	24	24	’s	’s	PART
tahrj-8728	24	25	fundamental	fundamental	ADJ
tahrj-8728	24	26	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	24	27	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	24	28	cossey	cossey	NOUN
tahrj-8728	24	29	v.	v.	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	24	30	uk	uk	PROPN
tahrj-8728	24	31	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	24	32	1990	1990	NUM
tahrj-8728	24	33	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	24	34	para	para	NOUN
tahrj-8728	24	35	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	24	36	37	37	NUM
tahrj-8728	24	37	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	24	38	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	25	1	essentially	essentially	ADV
tahrj-8728	25	2	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	25	3	it	it	PRON
tahrj-8728	25	4	entails	entail	VERB
tahrj-8728	25	5	two	two	NUM
tahrj-8728	25	6	tests	test	NOUN
tahrj-8728	25	7	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	25	8	1	1	X
tahrj-8728	25	9	.	.	X
tahrj-8728	25	10	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	25	11	test	test	NOUN
tahrj-8728	25	12	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	25	13	suitability	suitability	NOUN
tahrj-8728	25	14	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	25	15	2	2	NUM
tahrj-8728	25	16	.	.	X
tahrj-8728	25	17	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	25	18	test	test	NOUN
tahrj-8728	25	19	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	25	20	necessity	necessity	NOUN
tahrj-8728	25	21	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	26	1	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	26	2	former	former	ADJ
tahrj-8728	26	3	determines	determine	VERB
tahrj-8728	26	4	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	26	5	relationship	relationship	NOUN
tahrj-8728	26	6	between	between	ADP
tahrj-8728	26	7	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	26	8	measure	measure	NOUN
tahrj-8728	26	9	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	26	10	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	26	11	objective	objective	NOUN
tahrj-8728	26	12	it	it	PRON
tahrj-8728	26	13	aims	aim	VERB
tahrj-8728	26	14	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	26	15	achieve	achieve	VERB
tahrj-8728	26	16	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	27	1	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	27	2	latter	latter	ADJ
tahrj-8728	27	3	assesses	assess	VERB
tahrj-8728	27	4	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	27	5	consequences	consequence	NOUN
tahrj-8728	27	6	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	27	7	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	27	8	measure	measure	NOUN
tahrj-8728	27	9	on	on	ADP
tahrj-8728	27	10	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	27	11	right	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	27	12	worthy	worthy	ADJ
tahrj-8728	27	13	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	27	14	legal	legal	ADJ
tahrj-8728	27	15	protection	protection	NOUN
tahrj-8728	27	16	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	27	17	fromancais	fromancais	PROPN
tahrj-8728	27	18	v	v	PROPN
tahrj-8728	27	19	forma	forma	NOUN
tahrj-8728	27	20	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	27	21	1983	1983	NUM
tahrj-8728	27	22	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	27	23	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	28	1	additionally	additionally	ADV
tahrj-8728	28	2	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	28	3	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	28	4	comprehensive	comprehensive	ADJ
tahrj-8728	28	5	three	three	NUM
tahrj-8728	28	6	-	-	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	28	7	part	part	NOUN
tahrj-8728	28	8	test	test	NOUN
tahrj-8728	28	9	for	for	ADP
tahrj-8728	28	10	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	28	11	analysis	analysis	NOUN
tahrj-8728	28	12	was	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	28	13	given	give	VERB
tahrj-8728	28	14	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	28	15	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	28	16	opinion	opinion	NOUN
tahrj-8728	28	17	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	28	18	van	van	PROPN
tahrj-8728	28	19	gerven	gerven	PROPN
tahrj-8728	28	20	ag	ag	PROPN
tahrj-8728	28	21	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	28	22	spuc	spuc	PROPN
tahrj-8728	28	23	v	v	ADP
tahrj-8728	28	24	grogan	grogan	PROPN
tahrj-8728	28	25	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	28	26	1991	1991	NUM
tahrj-8728	28	27	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	28	28	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	29	1	first	first	ADV
tahrj-8728	29	2	was	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	29	3	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	29	4	test	test	NOUN
tahrj-8728	29	5	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	29	6	suitability	suitability	NOUN
tahrj-8728	29	7	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	29	8	second	second	ADV
tahrj-8728	29	9	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	29	10	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	29	11	test	test	NOUN
tahrj-8728	29	12	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	29	13	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	29	14	least	least	ADV
tahrj-8728	29	15	restrictive	restrictive	ADJ
tahrj-8728	29	16	alternative	alternative	NOUN
tahrj-8728	29	17	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	29	18	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	29	19	finally	finally	ADV
tahrj-8728	29	20	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	29	21	stricto	stricto	X
tahrj-8728	29	22	sensu	sensu	NOUN
tahrj-8728	29	23	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	30	1	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	30	2	test	test	NOUN
tahrj-8728	30	3	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	30	4	suitability	suitability	NOUN
tahrj-8728	30	5	aims	aim	VERB
tahrj-8728	30	6	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	30	7	establish	establish	VERB
tahrj-8728	30	8	if	if	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	30	9	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	30	10	measure	measure	NOUN
tahrj-8728	30	11	adopted	adopt	VERB
tahrj-8728	30	12	by	by	ADP
tahrj-8728	30	13	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	30	14	state	state	NOUN
tahrj-8728	30	15	is	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	30	16	suitable	suitable	ADJ
tahrj-8728	30	17	for	for	ADP
tahrj-8728	30	18	achieving	achieve	VERB
tahrj-8728	30	19	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	30	20	prescribed	prescribed	ADJ
tahrj-8728	30	21	aim	aim	NOUN
tahrj-8728	30	22	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	31	1	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	31	2	test	test	NOUN
tahrj-8728	31	3	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	31	4	least	least	ADJ
tahrj-8728	31	5	restrictive	restrictive	ADJ
tahrj-8728	31	6	alternative	alternative	ADJ
tahrj-8728	31	7	test	test	NOUN
tahrj-8728	31	8	aims	aim	VERB
tahrj-8728	31	9	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	31	10	establish	establish	VERB
tahrj-8728	31	11	if	if	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	31	12	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	31	13	measure	measure	NOUN
tahrj-8728	31	14	is	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	31	15	necessary	necessary	ADJ
tahrj-8728	31	16	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	31	17	if	if	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	31	18	there	there	PRON
tahrj-8728	31	19	are	be	VERB
tahrj-8728	31	20	no	no	DET
tahrj-8728	31	21	alternative	alternative	ADJ
tahrj-8728	31	22	means	mean	NOUN
tahrj-8728	31	23	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	31	24	achieving	achieve	VERB
tahrj-8728	31	25	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	31	26	desired	desire	VERB
tahrj-8728	31	27	outcome	outcome	NOUN
tahrj-8728	31	28	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	32	1	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	32	2	third	third	ADJ
tahrj-8728	32	3	test	test	NOUN
tahrj-8728	32	4	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	32	5	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	32	6	continuum	continuum	NOUN
tahrj-8728	32	7	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	32	8	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	32	9	second	second	ADJ
tahrj-8728	32	10	test	test	NOUN
tahrj-8728	32	11	examines	examine	NOUN
tahrj-8728	32	12	irrespective	irrespective	ADV
tahrj-8728	32	13	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	32	14	no	no	DET
tahrj-8728	32	15	less	less	ADV
tahrj-8728	32	16	restrictive	restrictive	ADJ
tahrj-8728	32	17	means	mean	NOUN
tahrj-8728	32	18	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	32	19	if	if	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	32	20	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	32	21	measure	measure	NOUN
tahrj-8728	32	22	has	have	VERB
tahrj-8728	32	23	an	an	DET
tahrj-8728	32	24	excessive	excessive	ADJ
tahrj-8728	32	25	effect	effect	NOUN
tahrj-8728	32	26	on	on	ADP
tahrj-8728	32	27	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	32	28	right	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	32	29	similarly	similarly	ADV
tahrj-8728	32	30	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	32	31	nada	nada	PROPN
tahrj-8728	32	32	v.	v.	PROPN
tahrj-8728	32	33	switzerland	switzerland	PROPN
tahrj-8728	32	34	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	32	35	2012	2012	NUM
tahrj-8728	32	36	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	32	37	offers	offer	VERB
tahrj-8728	32	38	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	32	39	structured	structured	ADJ
tahrj-8728	32	40	inquiry	inquiry	NOUN
tahrj-8728	32	41	conducted	conduct	VERB
tahrj-8728	32	42	by	by	ADP
tahrj-8728	32	43	ecthr	ecthr	NOUN
tahrj-8728	32	44	regarding	regard	VERB
tahrj-8728	32	45	art	art	NOUN
tahrj-8728	32	46	8	8	NUM
tahrj-8728	32	47	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	32	48	11	11	NUM
tahrj-8728	32	49	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	32	50	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	32	51	convention	convention	NOUN
tahrj-8728	32	52	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	33	1	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	33	2	ascertaining	ascertain	VERB
tahrj-8728	33	3	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	33	4	right	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	33	5	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	33	6	respect	respect	VERB
tahrj-8728	33	7	for	for	ADP
tahrj-8728	33	8	private	private	ADJ
tahrj-8728	33	9	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	33	10	family	family	NOUN
tahrj-8728	33	11	life	life	NOUN
tahrj-8728	33	12	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	33	13	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	33	14	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	33	15	asserted	assert	VERB
tahrj-8728	33	16	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	33	17	any	any	DET
tahrj-8728	33	18	interference	interference	NOUN
tahrj-8728	33	19	would	would	AUX
tahrj-8728	33	20	amount	amount	VERB
tahrj-8728	33	21	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	33	22	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	33	23	breach	breach	NOUN
tahrj-8728	33	24	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	33	25	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	33	26	article	article	NOUN
tahrj-8728	33	27	unless	unless	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	33	28	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	33	29	requirement	requirement	NOUN
tahrj-8728	33	30	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	33	31	art	art	NOUN
tahrj-8728	33	32	8(2	8(2	NUM
tahrj-8728	33	33	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	33	34	were	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	33	35	satisfied	satisfied	ADJ
tahrj-8728	33	36	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	34	1	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	34	2	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	34	3	determined	determine	VERB
tahrj-8728	34	4	whether	whether	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	34	5	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	34	6	interference	interference	NOUN
tahrj-8728	34	7	was	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	34	8	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	34	9	‘	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	34	10	accordance	accordance	NOUN
tahrj-8728	34	11	with	with	ADP
tahrj-8728	34	12	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	34	13	law	law	NOUN
tahrj-8728	34	14	’	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	34	15	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	34	16	‘	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	34	17	was	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	34	18	pursued	pursue	VERB
tahrj-8728	34	19	for	for	ADP
tahrj-8728	34	20	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	34	21	legitimate	legitimate	ADJ
tahrj-8728	34	22	aim	aim	NOUN
tahrj-8728	34	23	’	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	34	24	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	34	25	was	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	34	26	‘	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	34	27	necessary	necessary	ADJ
tahrj-8728	34	28	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	34	29	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	34	30	democratic	democratic	ADJ
tahrj-8728	34	31	society	society	NOUN
tahrj-8728	34	32	’	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	34	33	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	34	34	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	34	35	achieve	achieve	VERB
tahrj-8728	34	36	such	such	ADJ
tahrj-8728	34	37	aims	aim	NOUN
tahrj-8728	34	38	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	34	39	nada	nada	PROPN
tahrj-8728	34	40	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	34	41	2012	2012	NUM
tahrj-8728	34	42	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	34	43	p.	p.	NOUN
tahrj-8728	34	44	167	167	NUM
tahrj-8728	34	45	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	34	46	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	35	1	as	as	ADP
tahrj-8728	35	2	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	35	3	last	last	ADJ
tahrj-8728	35	4	limb	limb	NOUN
tahrj-8728	35	5	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	35	6	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	35	7	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	35	8	test	test	NOUN
tahrj-8728	35	9	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	35	10	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	35	11	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	35	12	also	also	ADV
tahrj-8728	35	13	applied	apply	VERB
tahrj-8728	35	14	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	35	15	least	least	ADV
tahrj-8728	35	16	restrictive	restrictive	ADJ
tahrj-8728	35	17	means	mean	NOUN
tahrj-8728	35	18	test	test	NOUN
tahrj-8728	35	19	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	36	1	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	36	2	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	36	3	held	hold	VERB
tahrj-8728	36	4	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	36	5	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	36	6	for	for	ADP
tahrj-8728	36	7	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	36	8	measure	measure	NOUN
tahrj-8728	36	9	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	36	10	be	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	36	11	regarded	regard	VERB
tahrj-8728	36	12	as	as	ADV
tahrj-8728	36	13	proportionate	proportionate	ADJ
tahrj-8728	36	14	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	36	15	necessary	necessary	ADJ
tahrj-8728	36	16	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	36	17	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	36	18	democratic	democratic	ADJ
tahrj-8728	36	19	society	society	NOUN
tahrj-8728	36	20	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	36	21	recourse	recourse	VERB
tahrj-8728	36	22	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	36	23	an	an	DET
tahrj-8728	36	24	alternative	alternative	ADJ
tahrj-8728	36	25	measure	measure	NOUN
tahrj-8728	36	26	that	that	PRON
tahrj-8728	36	27	would	would	AUX
tahrj-8728	36	28	cause	cause	VERB
tahrj-8728	36	29	less	less	ADJ
tahrj-8728	36	30	damage	damage	NOUN
tahrj-8728	36	31	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	36	32	fundamental	fundamental	ADJ
tahrj-8728	36	33	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	36	34	must	must	AUX
tahrj-8728	36	35	be	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	36	36	applied	apply	VERB
tahrj-8728	36	37	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	37	1	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	37	2	light	light	NOUN
tahrj-8728	37	3	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	37	4	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	37	5	echr	echr	PROPN
tahrj-8728	37	6	jurisprudence	jurisprudence	NOUN
tahrj-8728	37	7	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	37	8	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	37	9	decisions	decision	NOUN
tahrj-8728	37	10	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	37	11	standard	standard	NOUN
tahrj-8728	37	12	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	37	13	review	review	NOUN
tahrj-8728	37	14	adopted	adopt	VERB
tahrj-8728	37	15	by	by	ADP
tahrj-8728	37	16	domestic	domestic	ADJ
tahrj-8728	37	17	courts	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	37	18	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	37	19	europe	europe	PROPN
tahrj-8728	37	20	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	37	21	particularly	particularly	ADV
tahrj-8728	37	22	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	37	23	english	english	ADJ
tahrj-8728	37	24	courts	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	37	25	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	37	26	are	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	37	27	relevant	relevant	ADJ
tahrj-8728	37	28	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	38	1	following	follow	VERB
tahrj-8728	38	2	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	38	3	non	non	ADJ
tahrj-8728	38	4	-	-	ADJ
tahrj-8728	38	5	uniform	uniform	ADJ
tahrj-8728	38	6	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	38	7	non	non	ADJ
tahrj-8728	38	8	-	-	ADJ
tahrj-8728	38	9	mutually	mutually	ADV
tahrj-8728	38	10	exclusive	exclusive	ADJ
tahrj-8728	38	11	case	case	NOUN
tahrj-8728	38	12	-	-	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	38	13	by	by	ADP
tahrj-8728	38	14	-	-	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	38	15	case	case	NOUN
tahrj-8728	38	16	standards	standard	NOUN
tahrj-8728	38	17	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	38	18	review	review	NOUN
tahrj-8728	38	19	for	for	ADP
tahrj-8728	38	20	public	public	ADJ
tahrj-8728	38	21	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	38	22	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	38	23	administrative	administrative	ADJ
tahrj-8728	38	24	practice	practice	NOUN
tahrj-8728	38	25	cases	case	NOUN
tahrj-8728	38	26	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	38	27	jurisprudence	jurisprudence	NOUN
tahrj-8728	38	28	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	38	29	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	38	30	united	united	ADJ
tahrj-8728	38	31	kingdom	kingdom	PROPN
tahrj-8728	38	32	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	38	33	uk	uk	PROPN
tahrj-8728	38	34	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	38	35	offers	offer	VERB
tahrj-8728	38	36	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	38	37	variety	variety	NOUN
tahrj-8728	38	38	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	38	39	opportunities	opportunity	NOUN
tahrj-8728	38	40	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	38	41	weigh	weigh	VERB
tahrj-8728	38	42	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	38	43	benefits	benefit	NOUN
tahrj-8728	38	44	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	38	45	each	each	DET
tahrj-8728	38	46	process(es	process(es	NOUN
tahrj-8728	38	47	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	38	48	individually	individually	ADV
tahrj-8728	38	49	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	39	1	for	for	ADP
tahrj-8728	39	2	instance	instance	NOUN
tahrj-8728	39	3	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	39	4	many	many	ADJ
tahrj-8728	39	5	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	39	6	-	-	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	39	7	based	base	VERB
tahrj-8728	39	8	judgments	judgment	NOUN
tahrj-8728	39	9	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	39	10	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	39	11	uk	uk	PROPN
tahrj-8728	39	12	have	have	AUX
tahrj-8728	39	13	set	set	VERB
tahrj-8728	39	14	out	out	ADP
tahrj-8728	39	15	grounds	ground	NOUN
tahrj-8728	39	16	for	for	ADP
tahrj-8728	39	17	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	39	18	review	review	NOUN
tahrj-8728	39	19	borrowed	borrow	VERB
tahrj-8728	39	20	from	from	ADP
tahrj-8728	39	21	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	39	22	ecthr	ecthr	NOUN
tahrj-8728	39	23	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	40	1	one	one	NUM
tahrj-8728	40	2	example	example	NOUN
tahrj-8728	40	3	is	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	40	4	quila	quila	NOUN
tahrj-8728	40	5	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	40	6	another	another	PRON
tahrj-8728	40	7	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	40	8	2011	2011	NUM
tahrj-8728	40	9	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	40	10	whereby	whereby	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	40	11	lord	lord	PROPN
tahrj-8728	40	12	wilson	wilson	PROPN
tahrj-8728	40	13	encapsulated	encapsulate	VERB
tahrj-8728	40	14	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	40	15	test	test	NOUN
tahrj-8728	40	16	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	40	17	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	40	18	present	present	ADJ
tahrj-8728	40	19	case	case	NOUN
tahrj-8728	40	20	as	as	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	40	21	follows	follow	VERB
tahrj-8728	40	22	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	40	23	first	first	ADV
tahrj-8728	40	24	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	40	25	is	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	40	26	there	there	PRON
tahrj-8728	40	27	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	40	28	sufficiently	sufficiently	ADV
tahrj-8728	40	29	important	important	ADJ
tahrj-8728	40	30	legislative	legislative	ADJ
tahrj-8728	40	31	object	object	NOUN
tahrj-8728	40	32	?	?	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	41	1	second	second	ADJ
tahrj-8728	41	2	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	41	3	are	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	41	4	measures	measure	NOUN
tahrj-8728	41	5	adopted	adopt	VERB
tahrj-8728	41	6	rationally	rationally	ADV
tahrj-8728	41	7	connected	connect	VERB
tahrj-8728	41	8	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	41	9	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	41	10	https://doi.org/10.17561/tahrj.v23.8728	https://doi.org/10.17561/tahrj.v23.8728	PROPN
tahrj-8728	41	11	sabreen	sabreen	PROPN
tahrj-8728	41	12	ahmed	ahme	VERB
tahrj-8728	41	13	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	41	14	age	age	NOUN
tahrj-8728	41	15	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	41	16	human	human	ADJ
tahrj-8728	41	17	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	41	18	journal	journal	NOUN
tahrj-8728	41	19	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	41	20	24	24	NUM
tahrj-8728	41	21	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	41	22	june	june	PROPN
tahrj-8728	41	23	2025	2025	NUM
tahrj-8728	41	24	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	41	25	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	41	26	e8728	e8728	PROPN
tahrj-8728	41	27	issn	issn	PROPN
tahrj-8728	41	28	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	41	29	2340	2340	NUM
tahrj-8728	41	30	-	-	SYM
tahrj-8728	41	31	9592	9592	NUM
tahrj-8728	41	32	doi	doi	NOUN
tahrj-8728	41	33	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	41	34	10.17561	10.17561	NUM
tahrj-8728	41	35	/	/	SYM
tahrj-8728	41	36	tahrj.v23.8728	tahrj.v23.8728	PROPN
tahrj-8728	41	37	3	3	NUM
tahrj-8728	41	38	legislative	legislative	ADJ
tahrj-8728	41	39	object	object	NOUN
tahrj-8728	41	40	?	?	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	42	1	are	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	42	2	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	42	3	measures	measure	NOUN
tahrj-8728	42	4	no	no	ADV
tahrj-8728	42	5	more	more	ADJ
tahrj-8728	42	6	than	than	ADP
tahrj-8728	42	7	necessary	necessary	ADJ
tahrj-8728	42	8	?	?	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	43	1	fourth	fourth	ADV
tahrj-8728	43	2	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	43	3	do	do	AUX
tahrj-8728	43	4	they	they	PRON
tahrj-8728	43	5	strike	strike	VERB
tahrj-8728	43	6	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	43	7	balance	balance	NOUN
tahrj-8728	43	8	between	between	ADP
tahrj-8728	43	9	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	43	10	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	43	11	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	43	12	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	43	13	individual	individual	NOUN
tahrj-8728	43	14	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	43	15	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	43	16	interests	interest	NOUN
tahrj-8728	43	17	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	43	18	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	43	19	community	community	NOUN
tahrj-8728	43	20	?	?	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	44	1	earlier	early	ADV
tahrj-8728	44	2	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	44	3	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	44	4	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	44	5	1990s	1990	NOUN
tahrj-8728	44	6	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	44	7	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	44	8	ground	ground	NOUN
tahrj-8728	44	9	standard	standard	NOUN
tahrj-8728	44	10	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	44	11	review	review	NOUN
tahrj-8728	44	12	opted	opt	VERB
tahrj-8728	44	13	by	by	ADP
tahrj-8728	44	14	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	44	15	uk	uk	PROPN
tahrj-8728	44	16	courts	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	44	17	was	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	44	18	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	44	19	wednesbury	wednesbury	PROPN
tahrj-8728	44	20	rationality	rationality	PROPN
tahrj-8728	44	21	review	review	PROPN
tahrj-8728	44	22	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	44	23	associated	associate	VERB
tahrj-8728	44	24	provincial	provincial	ADJ
tahrj-8728	44	25	houses	house	NOUN
tahrj-8728	44	26	ltd	ltd	PROPN
tahrj-8728	44	27	.	.	PROPN
tahrj-8728	44	28	v	v	PROPN
tahrj-8728	44	29	wednesbury	wednesbury	PROPN
tahrj-8728	44	30	corporation	corporation	PROPN
tahrj-8728	44	31	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	44	32	1948	1948	NUM
tahrj-8728	44	33	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	44	34	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	45	1	it	it	PRON
tahrj-8728	45	2	stated	state	VERB
tahrj-8728	45	3	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	45	4	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	45	5	decision	decision	NOUN
tahrj-8728	45	6	may	may	AUX
tahrj-8728	45	7	be	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	45	8	attacked	attack	VERB
tahrj-8728	45	9	if	if	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	45	10	it	it	PRON
tahrj-8728	45	11	is	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	45	12	so	so	ADV
tahrj-8728	45	13	unreasonable	unreasonable	ADJ
tahrj-8728	45	14	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	45	15	no	no	DET
tahrj-8728	45	16	reasonable	reasonable	ADJ
tahrj-8728	45	17	decision	decision	NOUN
tahrj-8728	45	18	-	-	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	45	19	maker	maker	NOUN
tahrj-8728	45	20	could	could	AUX
tahrj-8728	45	21	have	have	AUX
tahrj-8728	45	22	made	make	VERB
tahrj-8728	45	23	it	it	PRON
tahrj-8728	45	24	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	46	1	this	this	DET
tahrj-8728	46	2	test	test	NOUN
tahrj-8728	46	3	was	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	46	4	limited	limit	VERB
tahrj-8728	46	5	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	46	6	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	46	7	sense	sense	NOUN
tahrj-8728	46	8	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	46	9	it	it	PRON
tahrj-8728	46	10	required	require	VERB
tahrj-8728	46	11	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	46	12	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	46	13	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	46	14	be	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	46	15	only	only	ADV
tahrj-8728	46	16	satisfied	satisfied	ADJ
tahrj-8728	46	17	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	46	18	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	46	19	‘	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	46	20	decision	decision	NOUN
tahrj-8728	46	21	was	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	46	22	so	so	ADV
tahrj-8728	46	23	unreasonable	unreasonable	ADJ
tahrj-8728	46	24	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	46	25	it	it	PRON
tahrj-8728	46	26	would	would	AUX
tahrj-8728	46	27	not	not	PART
tahrj-8728	46	28	have	have	AUX
tahrj-8728	46	29	been	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	46	30	made	make	VERB
tahrj-8728	46	31	by	by	ADP
tahrj-8728	46	32	any	any	DET
tahrj-8728	46	33	reasonable	reasonable	ADJ
tahrj-8728	46	34	public	public	ADJ
tahrj-8728	46	35	authority	authority	NOUN
tahrj-8728	46	36	’	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	46	37	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	47	1	it	it	PRON
tahrj-8728	47	2	was	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	47	3	made	make	VERB
tahrj-8728	47	4	clear	clear	ADJ
tahrj-8728	47	5	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	47	6	such	such	DET
tahrj-8728	47	7	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	47	8	rationality	rationality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	47	9	review	review	NOUN
tahrj-8728	47	10	suggested	suggest	VERB
tahrj-8728	47	11	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	47	12	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	47	13	irrationality	irrationality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	47	14	would	would	AUX
tahrj-8728	47	15	only	only	ADV
tahrj-8728	47	16	apply	apply	VERB
tahrj-8728	47	17	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	47	18	an	an	DET
tahrj-8728	47	19	administrative	administrative	ADJ
tahrj-8728	47	20	action	action	NOUN
tahrj-8728	47	21	which	which	PRON
tahrj-8728	47	22	is	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	47	23	so	so	ADV
tahrj-8728	47	24	outrageous	outrageous	ADJ
tahrj-8728	47	25	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	47	26	its	its	PRON
tahrj-8728	47	27	defiance	defiance	NOUN
tahrj-8728	47	28	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	47	29	logic	logic	NOUN
tahrj-8728	47	30	or	or	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	47	31	if	if	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	47	32	accepted	accept	VERB
tahrj-8728	47	33	moral	moral	ADJ
tahrj-8728	47	34	standards	standard	NOUN
tahrj-8728	47	35	that	that	PRON
tahrj-8728	47	36	no	no	DET
tahrj-8728	47	37	sensible	sensible	ADJ
tahrj-8728	47	38	person	person	NOUN
tahrj-8728	47	39	who	who	PRON
tahrj-8728	47	40	had	have	AUX
tahrj-8728	47	41	applied	apply	VERB
tahrj-8728	47	42	his	his	PRON
tahrj-8728	47	43	mind	mind	NOUN
tahrj-8728	47	44	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	47	45	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	47	46	question	question	NOUN
tahrj-8728	47	47	could	could	AUX
tahrj-8728	47	48	have	have	AUX
tahrj-8728	47	49	arrived	arrive	VERB
tahrj-8728	47	50	at	at	ADP
tahrj-8728	47	51	it	it	PRON
tahrj-8728	47	52	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	47	53	council	council	NOUN
tahrj-8728	47	54	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	47	55	civil	civil	ADJ
tahrj-8728	47	56	service	service	NOUN
tahrj-8728	47	57	unions	union	NOUN
tahrj-8728	47	58	v	v	ADP
tahrj-8728	47	59	minister	minister	NOUN
tahrj-8728	47	60	for	for	ADP
tahrj-8728	47	61	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	47	62	civil	civil	ADJ
tahrj-8728	47	63	service	service	NOUN
tahrj-8728	47	64	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	47	65	1985	1985	NUM
tahrj-8728	47	66	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	47	67	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	48	1	although	although	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	48	2	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	48	3	house	house	NOUN
tahrj-8728	48	4	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	48	5	lords	lord	NOUN
tahrj-8728	48	6	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	48	7	r	r	PROPN
tahrj-8728	48	8	v.	v.	ADP
tahrj-8728	48	9	secretary	secretary	PROPN
tahrj-8728	48	10	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	48	11	state	state	NOUN
tahrj-8728	48	12	for	for	ADP
tahrj-8728	48	13	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	48	14	home	home	NOUN
tahrj-8728	48	15	department	department	NOUN
tahrj-8728	48	16	ex	ex	PRON
tahrj-8728	48	17	p	p	X
tahrj-8728	48	18	brind	brind	NOUN
tahrj-8728	48	19	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	48	20	1991	1991	NUM
tahrj-8728	48	21	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	48	22	accepted	accept	VERB
tahrj-8728	48	23	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	48	24	wednesbury	wednesbury	NOUN
tahrj-8728	48	25	could	could	AUX
tahrj-8728	48	26	vary	vary	VERB
tahrj-8728	48	27	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	48	28	its	its	PRON
tahrj-8728	48	29	intensity	intensity	NOUN
tahrj-8728	48	30	while	while	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	48	31	determining	determine	VERB
tahrj-8728	48	32	fundamental	fundamental	ADJ
tahrj-8728	48	33	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	48	34	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	48	35	it	it	PRON
tahrj-8728	48	36	was	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	48	37	never	never	ADV
tahrj-8728	48	38	abandoned	abandon	VERB
tahrj-8728	48	39	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	49	1	at	at	ADP
tahrj-8728	49	2	this	this	DET
tahrj-8728	49	3	point	point	NOUN
tahrj-8728	49	4	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	49	5	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	49	6	courts	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	49	7	also	also	ADV
tahrj-8728	49	8	began	begin	VERB
tahrj-8728	49	9	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	49	10	reconfigure	reconfigure	VERB
tahrj-8728	49	11	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	49	12	wednesbury	wednesbury	PROPN
tahrj-8728	49	13	review	review	PROPN
tahrj-8728	49	14	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	49	15	acknowledge	acknowledge	VERB
tahrj-8728	49	16	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	49	17	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	49	18	test	test	NOUN
tahrj-8728	49	19	was	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	49	20	modifiable	modifiable	ADJ
tahrj-8728	49	21	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	50	1	however	however	ADV
tahrj-8728	50	2	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	50	3	with	with	ADP
tahrj-8728	50	4	wednesbury	wednesbury	NOUN
tahrj-8728	50	5	unreasonableness	unreasonableness	NOUN
tahrj-8728	50	6	still	still	ADV
tahrj-8728	50	7	on	on	ADP
tahrj-8728	50	8	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	50	9	table	table	NOUN
tahrj-8728	50	10	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	50	11	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	50	12	courts	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	50	13	realized	realize	VERB
tahrj-8728	50	14	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	50	15	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	50	16	more	more	ADV
tahrj-8728	50	17	comprehensive	comprehensive	ADJ
tahrj-8728	50	18	analysis	analysis	NOUN
tahrj-8728	50	19	appeared	appear	VERB
tahrj-8728	50	20	pertinent	pertinent	ADJ
tahrj-8728	50	21	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	50	22	review	review	VERB
tahrj-8728	50	23	cases	case	NOUN
tahrj-8728	50	24	involving	involve	VERB
tahrj-8728	50	25	substantive	substantive	ADJ
tahrj-8728	50	26	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	50	27	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	51	1	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	51	2	context	context	NOUN
tahrj-8728	51	3	for	for	ADP
tahrj-8728	51	4	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	51	5	need	need	NOUN
tahrj-8728	51	6	appeared	appear	VERB
tahrj-8728	51	7	after	after	ADP
tahrj-8728	51	8	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	51	9	emerging	emerge	VERB
tahrj-8728	51	10	trend	trend	NOUN
tahrj-8728	51	11	towards	towards	ADP
tahrj-8728	51	12	human	human	ADJ
tahrj-8728	51	13	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	51	14	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	51	15	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	51	16	uk	uk	PROPN
tahrj-8728	51	17	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	51	18	following	follow	VERB
tahrj-8728	51	19	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	51	20	human	human	ADJ
tahrj-8728	51	21	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	51	22	act	act	NOUN
tahrj-8728	51	23	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	51	24	1998	1998	NUM
tahrj-8728	51	25	subsuming	subsume	VERB
tahrj-8728	51	26	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	51	27	echr	echr	PROPN
tahrj-8728	51	28	code	code	NOUN
tahrj-8728	51	29	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	51	30	line	line	NOUN
tahrj-8728	51	31	with	with	ADP
tahrj-8728	51	32	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	51	33	mechanisms	mechanism	NOUN
tahrj-8728	51	34	set	set	VERB
tahrj-8728	51	35	by	by	ADP
tahrj-8728	51	36	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	51	37	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	51	38	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	52	1	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	52	2	mcharg	mcharg	NOUN
tahrj-8728	52	3	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	52	4	1999	1999	NUM
tahrj-8728	52	5	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	52	6	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	53	1	naturally	naturally	ADV
tahrj-8728	53	2	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	53	3	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	53	4	courts	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	53	5	began	begin	VERB
tahrj-8728	53	6	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	53	7	acknowledge	acknowledge	VERB
tahrj-8728	53	8	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	53	9	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	53	10	actual	actual	ADJ
tahrj-8728	53	11	test	test	NOUN
tahrj-8728	53	12	requires	require	VERB
tahrj-8728	53	13	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	53	14	concept	concept	NOUN
tahrj-8728	53	15	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	53	16	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	53	17	mirroring	mirror	VERB
tahrj-8728	53	18	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	53	19	ecthr	ecthr	NOUN
tahrj-8728	53	20	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	53	21	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	53	22	convention	convention	NOUN
tahrj-8728	53	23	itself	itself	PRON
tahrj-8728	53	24	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	53	25	smith	smith	NOUN
tahrj-8728	53	26	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	53	27	gardy	gardy	PROPN
tahrj-8728	53	28	v.	v.	ADP
tahrj-8728	53	29	united	united	PROPN
tahrj-8728	53	30	kingdom	kingdom	PROPN
tahrj-8728	53	31	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	53	32	1999	1999	NUM
tahrj-8728	53	33	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	53	34	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	54	1	finally	finally	ADV
tahrj-8728	54	2	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	54	3	an	an	DET
tahrj-8728	54	4	explicit	explicit	ADJ
tahrj-8728	54	5	transition	transition	NOUN
tahrj-8728	54	6	from	from	ADP
tahrj-8728	54	7	wednesbury	wednesbury	PROPN
tahrj-8728	54	8	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	54	9	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	54	10	more	more	ADV
tahrj-8728	54	11	intense	intense	ADJ
tahrj-8728	54	12	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	54	13	analysis	analysis	NOUN
tahrj-8728	54	14	was	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	54	15	seen	see	VERB
tahrj-8728	54	16	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	54	17	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	54	18	case	case	NOUN
tahrj-8728	54	19	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	54	20	r	r	NOUN
tahrj-8728	54	21	v.	v.	ADP
tahrj-8728	54	22	secretary	secretary	PROPN
tahrj-8728	54	23	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	54	24	state	state	NOUN
tahrj-8728	54	25	for	for	ADP
tahrj-8728	54	26	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	54	27	home	home	NOUN
tahrj-8728	54	28	department	department	PROPN
tahrj-8728	54	29	ex	ex	PROPN
tahrj-8728	54	30	parte	parte	PROPN
tahrj-8728	54	31	daly	daly	PROPN
tahrj-8728	54	32	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	54	33	2001	2001	NUM
tahrj-8728	54	34	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	54	35	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	55	1	lord	lord	PROPN
tahrj-8728	55	2	bingham	bingham	PROPN
tahrj-8728	55	3	stated	state	VERB
tahrj-8728	55	4	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	55	5	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	55	6	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	55	7	infringement	infringement	NOUN
tahrj-8728	55	8	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	55	9	prisoner	prisoner	NOUN
tahrj-8728	55	10	’s	’s	PART
tahrj-8728	55	11	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	55	12	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	55	13	maintain	maintain	VERB
tahrj-8728	55	14	their	their	PRON
tahrj-8728	55	15	confidentiality	confidentiality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	55	16	is	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	55	17	greater	great	ADJ
tahrj-8728	55	18	than	than	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	55	19	is	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	55	20	shown	show	VERB
tahrj-8728	55	21	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	55	22	be	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	55	23	necessary	necessary	ADJ
tahrj-8728	55	24	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	55	25	serve	serve	VERB
tahrj-8728	55	26	legitimate	legitimate	ADJ
tahrj-8728	55	27	public	public	ADJ
tahrj-8728	55	28	objectives	objective	NOUN
tahrj-8728	55	29	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	56	1	this	this	PRON
tahrj-8728	56	2	showed	show	VERB
tahrj-8728	56	3	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	56	4	complete	complete	ADJ
tahrj-8728	56	5	abandonment	abandonment	NOUN
tahrj-8728	56	6	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	56	7	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	56	8	wednesbury	wednesbury	PROPN
tahrj-8728	56	9	review	review	PROPN
tahrj-8728	56	10	especially	especially	ADV
tahrj-8728	56	11	where	where	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	56	12	fundamental	fundamental	ADJ
tahrj-8728	56	13	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	56	14	were	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	56	15	at	at	ADP
tahrj-8728	56	16	stake	stake	NOUN
tahrj-8728	56	17	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	56	18	daly	daly	PROPN
tahrj-8728	56	19	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	56	20	2001	2001	NUM
tahrj-8728	56	21	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	56	22	pp	pp	ADJ
tahrj-8728	56	23	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	57	1	24	24	NUM
tahrj-8728	57	2	-	-	SYM
tahrj-8728	57	3	28	28	NUM
tahrj-8728	57	4	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	57	5	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	58	1	justifying	justify	VERB
tahrj-8728	58	2	such	such	DET
tahrj-8728	58	3	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	58	4	shift	shift	NOUN
tahrj-8728	58	5	towards	towards	ADP
tahrj-8728	58	6	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	58	7	analysis	analysis	NOUN
tahrj-8728	58	8	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	58	9	lord	lord	PROPN
tahrj-8728	58	10	crooke	crooke	PROPN
tahrj-8728	58	11	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	58	12	daly	daly	PROPN
tahrj-8728	58	13	stated	state	VERB
tahrj-8728	58	14	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	58	15	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	58	16	wednesbury	wednesbury	PROPN
tahrj-8728	58	17	was	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	58	18	an	an	DET
tahrj-8728	58	19	unfortunate	unfortunate	ADJ
tahrj-8728	58	20	retrogressive	retrogressive	ADJ
tahrj-8728	58	21	decision	decision	NOUN
tahrj-8728	58	22	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	58	23	english	english	ADJ
tahrj-8728	58	24	administrative	administrative	ADJ
tahrj-8728	58	25	law	law	NOUN
tahrj-8728	58	26	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	58	27	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	58	28	so	so	ADV
tahrj-8728	58	29	far	far	ADV
tahrj-8728	58	30	as	as	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	58	31	it	it	PRON
tahrj-8728	58	32	suggested	suggest	VERB
tahrj-8728	58	33	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	58	34	there	there	PRON
tahrj-8728	58	35	are	be	VERB
tahrj-8728	58	36	degrees	degree	NOUN
tahrj-8728	58	37	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	58	38	unreasonableness	unreasonableness	NOUN
tahrj-8728	58	39	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	58	40	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	58	41	only	only	ADV
tahrj-8728	58	42	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	58	43	very	very	ADV
tahrj-8728	58	44	extreme	extreme	ADJ
tahrj-8728	58	45	degree	degree	NOUN
tahrj-8728	58	46	can	can	AUX
tahrj-8728	58	47	bring	bring	VERB
tahrj-8728	58	48	an	an	DET
tahrj-8728	58	49	administrative	administrative	ADJ
tahrj-8728	58	50	action	action	NOUN
tahrj-8728	58	51	within	within	ADP
tahrj-8728	58	52	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	58	53	legitimate	legitimate	ADJ
tahrj-8728	58	54	scope	scope	NOUN
tahrj-8728	58	55	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	58	56	judicial	judicial	ADJ
tahrj-8728	58	57	review	review	NOUN
tahrj-8728	58	58	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	59	1	however	however	ADV
tahrj-8728	59	2	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	59	3	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	59	4	law	law	NOUN
tahrj-8728	59	5	can	can	AUX
tahrj-8728	59	6	never	never	ADV
tahrj-8728	59	7	be	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	59	8	justified	justify	VERB
tahrj-8728	59	9	merely	merely	ADV
tahrj-8728	59	10	by	by	ADP
tahrj-8728	59	11	finding	find	VERB
tahrj-8728	59	12	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	59	13	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	59	14	decision	decision	NOUN
tahrj-8728	59	15	under	under	ADP
tahrj-8728	59	16	review	review	NOUN
tahrj-8728	59	17	is	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	59	18	not	not	PART
tahrj-8728	59	19	absurd	absurd	ADJ
tahrj-8728	59	20	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	59	21	hence	hence	ADV
tahrj-8728	59	22	valid	valid	ADJ
tahrj-8728	59	23	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	60	1	https://doi.org/10.17561/tahrj.v23.8728	https://doi.org/10.17561/tahrj.v23.8728	NOUN
tahrj-8728	60	2	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	60	3	analysis	analysis	NOUN
tahrj-8728	60	4	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	60	5	non	non	ADJ
tahrj-8728	60	6	-	-	ADJ
tahrj-8728	60	7	refoulement	refoulement	ADJ
tahrj-8728	60	8	jurisprudence	jurisprudence	NOUN
tahrj-8728	60	9	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	60	10	india	india	PROPN
tahrj-8728	60	11	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	60	12	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	60	13	comparative	comparative	ADJ
tahrj-8728	60	14	approach	approach	NOUN
tahrj-8728	60	15	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	60	16	age	age	NOUN
tahrj-8728	60	17	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	60	18	human	human	ADJ
tahrj-8728	60	19	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	60	20	journal	journal	NOUN
tahrj-8728	60	21	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	60	22	24	24	NUM
tahrj-8728	60	23	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	60	24	june	june	PROPN
tahrj-8728	60	25	2025	2025	NUM
tahrj-8728	60	26	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	60	27	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	60	28	e8728	e8728	PROPN
tahrj-8728	60	29	issn	issn	PROPN
tahrj-8728	60	30	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	60	31	2340	2340	NUM
tahrj-8728	60	32	-	-	SYM
tahrj-8728	60	33	9592	9592	NUM
tahrj-8728	60	34	doi	doi	NOUN
tahrj-8728	60	35	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	60	36	10.17561	10.17561	NUM
tahrj-8728	60	37	/	/	SYM
tahrj-8728	60	38	tahrj.v23.8728	tahrj.v23.8728	PROPN
tahrj-8728	60	39	4	4	NUM
tahrj-8728	60	40	however	however	ADV
tahrj-8728	60	41	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	60	42	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	60	43	‘	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	60	44	shift	shift	NOUN
tahrj-8728	60	45	’	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	60	46	could	could	AUX
tahrj-8728	60	47	not	not	PART
tahrj-8728	60	48	be	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	60	49	formally	formally	ADV
tahrj-8728	60	50	translated	translate	VERB
tahrj-8728	60	51	into	into	ADP
tahrj-8728	60	52	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	60	53	complete	complete	ADJ
tahrj-8728	60	54	disregard	disregard	NOUN
tahrj-8728	60	55	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	60	56	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	60	57	wednesbury	wednesbury	PROPN
tahrj-8728	60	58	principle	principle	NOUN
tahrj-8728	60	59	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	60	60	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	60	61	following	follow	VERB
tahrj-8728	60	62	cases	case	NOUN
tahrj-8728	60	63	because	because	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	60	64	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	60	65	rigid	rigid	ADJ
tahrj-8728	60	66	constitutional	constitutional	ADJ
tahrj-8728	60	67	division	division	NOUN
tahrj-8728	60	68	between	between	ADP
tahrj-8728	60	69	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	60	70	two	two	NUM
tahrj-8728	60	71	would	would	AUX
tahrj-8728	60	72	not	not	PART
tahrj-8728	60	73	only	only	ADV
tahrj-8728	60	74	be	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	60	75	difficult	difficult	ADJ
tahrj-8728	60	76	but	but	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	60	77	also	also	ADV
tahrj-8728	60	78	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	60	79	as	as	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	60	80	noted	note	VERB
tahrj-8728	60	81	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	60	82	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	60	83	case	case	NOUN
tahrj-8728	60	84	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	60	85	keyu	keyu	NOUN
tahrj-8728	60	86	v.	v.	ADP
tahrj-8728	60	87	secretary	secretary	NOUN
tahrj-8728	60	88	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	60	89	state	state	NOUN
tahrj-8728	60	90	for	for	ADP
tahrj-8728	60	91	foreign	foreign	ADJ
tahrj-8728	60	92	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	60	93	commonwealth	commonwealth	PROPN
tahrj-8728	60	94	affairs	affair	NOUN
tahrj-8728	60	95	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	60	96	2015	2015	NUM
tahrj-8728	60	97	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	60	98	“	"	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	60	99	would	would	AUX
tahrj-8728	60	100	have	have	VERB
tahrj-8728	60	101	potentially	potentially	ADV
tahrj-8728	60	102	profound	profound	ADJ
tahrj-8728	60	103	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	60	104	far	far	ADV
tahrj-8728	60	105	-	-	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	60	106	reaching	reach	VERB
tahrj-8728	60	107	consequences	consequence	NOUN
tahrj-8728	60	108	”	"	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	60	109	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	60	110	keyu	keyu	NOUN
tahrj-8728	60	111	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	60	112	2015	2015	NUM
tahrj-8728	60	113	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	60	114	para	para	NOUN
tahrj-8728	60	115	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	60	116	133	133	NUM
tahrj-8728	60	117	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	60	118	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	61	1	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	61	2	nature	nature	NOUN
tahrj-8728	61	3	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	61	4	both	both	DET
tahrj-8728	61	5	standards	standard	NOUN
tahrj-8728	61	6	is	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	61	7	thus	thus	ADV
tahrj-8728	61	8	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	61	9	that	that	PRON
tahrj-8728	61	10	placed	place	VERB
tahrj-8728	61	11	within	within	ADP
tahrj-8728	61	12	specific	specific	ADJ
tahrj-8728	61	13	contexts	contexts	NOUN
tahrj-8728	61	14	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	61	15	their	their	PRON
tahrj-8728	61	16	existence	existence	NOUN
tahrj-8728	61	17	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	61	18	independent	independent	ADJ
tahrj-8728	61	19	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	61	20	one	one	NUM
tahrj-8728	61	21	another	another	DET
tahrj-8728	61	22	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	61	23	is	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	61	24	hardly	hardly	ADV
tahrj-8728	61	25	distinguishable	distinguishable	ADJ
tahrj-8728	61	26	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	62	1	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	62	2	pham	pham	PROPN
tahrj-8728	62	3	v.	v.	PROPN
tahrj-8728	62	4	home	home	PROPN
tahrj-8728	62	5	secretary	secretary	PROPN
tahrj-8728	62	6	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	62	7	2015	2015	NUM
tahrj-8728	62	8	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	62	9	1	1	NUM
tahrj-8728	62	10	wlr	wlr	NOUN
tahrj-8728	62	11	1591	1591	NUM
tahrj-8728	62	12	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	62	13	lord	lord	PROPN
tahrj-8728	62	14	sumption	sumption	NOUN
tahrj-8728	62	15	while	while	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	62	16	observing	observe	VERB
tahrj-8728	62	17	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	62	18	difference	difference	NOUN
tahrj-8728	62	19	between	between	ADP
tahrj-8728	62	20	wednesbury	wednesbury	NOUN
tahrj-8728	62	21	unreasonableness	unreasonableness	NOUN
tahrj-8728	62	22	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	62	23	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	62	24	review	review	NOUN
tahrj-8728	62	25	stated	state	VERB
tahrj-8728	62	26	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	62	27	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	62	28	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	62	29	former	former	ADJ
tahrj-8728	62	30	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	62	31	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	62	32	asks	ask	VERB
tahrj-8728	62	33	whether	whether	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	62	34	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	62	35	decision	decision	NOUN
tahrj-8728	62	36	was	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	62	37	within	within	ADP
tahrj-8728	62	38	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	62	39	range	range	NOUN
tahrj-8728	62	40	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	62	41	rational	rational	ADJ
tahrj-8728	62	42	balances	balance	NOUN
tahrj-8728	62	43	that	that	PRON
tahrj-8728	62	44	may	may	AUX
tahrj-8728	62	45	be	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	62	46	struck	strike	VERB
tahrj-8728	62	47	whereas	whereas	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	62	48	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	62	49	under	under	ADP
tahrj-8728	62	50	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	62	51	latter	latter	ADJ
tahrj-8728	62	52	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	62	53	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	62	54	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	62	55	has	have	VERB
tahrj-8728	62	56	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	62	57	form	form	VERB
tahrj-8728	62	58	its	its	PRON
tahrj-8728	62	59	own	own	ADJ
tahrj-8728	62	60	view	view	NOUN
tahrj-8728	62	61	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	62	62	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	62	63	balance	balance	NOUN
tahrj-8728	62	64	struck	strike	VERB
tahrj-8728	62	65	by	by	ADP
tahrj-8728	62	66	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	62	67	decision	decision	NOUN
tahrj-8728	62	68	maker	maker	NOUN
tahrj-8728	62	69	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	63	1	lord	lord	PROPN
tahrj-8728	63	2	sumption	sumption	PROPN
tahrj-8728	63	3	further	far	ADV
tahrj-8728	63	4	noted	note	VERB
tahrj-8728	63	5	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	63	6	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	63	7	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	63	8	use	use	NOUN
tahrj-8728	63	9	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	63	10	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	63	11	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	63	12	cases	case	NOUN
tahrj-8728	63	13	involving	involve	VERB
tahrj-8728	63	14	human	human	ADJ
tahrj-8728	63	15	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	63	16	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	63	17	eu	eu	PROPN
tahrj-8728	63	18	law	law	NOUN
tahrj-8728	63	19	but	but	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	63	20	not	not	PART
tahrj-8728	63	21	domestic	domestic	ADJ
tahrj-8728	63	22	law	law	NOUN
tahrj-8728	63	23	produced	produce	VERB
tahrj-8728	63	24	“	"	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	63	25	some	some	DET
tahrj-8728	63	26	rather	rather	ADV
tahrj-8728	63	27	arbitrary	arbitrary	ADJ
tahrj-8728	63	28	distinctions	distinction	NOUN
tahrj-8728	63	29	between	between	ADP
tahrj-8728	63	30	essentially	essentially	ADV
tahrj-8728	63	31	similar	similar	ADJ
tahrj-8728	63	32	issues	issue	NOUN
tahrj-8728	63	33	”	"	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	63	34	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	63	35	pham	pham	PROPN
tahrj-8728	63	36	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	63	37	2015	2015	NUM
tahrj-8728	63	38	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	63	39	para	para	NOUN
tahrj-8728	63	40	.	.	PROPN
tahrj-8728	64	1	104	104	NUM
tahrj-8728	64	2	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	65	1	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	65	2	approach	approach	NOUN
tahrj-8728	65	3	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	65	4	highlighting	highlight	VERB
tahrj-8728	65	5	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	65	6	similarities	similarity	NOUN
tahrj-8728	65	7	between	between	ADP
tahrj-8728	65	8	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	65	9	two	two	NUM
tahrj-8728	65	10	standards	standard	NOUN
tahrj-8728	65	11	began	begin	VERB
tahrj-8728	65	12	with	with	ADP
tahrj-8728	65	13	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	65	14	case	case	NOUN
tahrj-8728	65	15	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	65	16	kennedy	kennedy	PROPN
tahrj-8728	65	17	v	v	PROPN
tahrj-8728	65	18	charity	charity	PROPN
tahrj-8728	65	19	commission	commission	PROPN
tahrj-8728	65	20	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	65	21	secretary	secretary	NOUN
tahrj-8728	65	22	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	65	23	state	state	NOUN
tahrj-8728	65	24	for	for	ADP
tahrj-8728	65	25	justice	justice	NOUN
tahrj-8728	65	26	intervening	intervene	VERB
tahrj-8728	65	27	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	65	28	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	65	29	2015	2015	NUM
tahrj-8728	65	30	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	65	31	where	where	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	65	32	lord	lord	PROPN
tahrj-8728	65	33	mance	mance	PROPN
tahrj-8728	65	34	noted	note	VERB
tahrj-8728	65	35	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	65	36	even	even	ADV
tahrj-8728	65	37	though	though	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	65	38	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	65	39	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	65	40	unreasonableness	unreasonableness	NOUN
tahrj-8728	65	41	may	may	AUX
tahrj-8728	65	42	have	have	AUX
tahrj-8728	65	43	similar	similar	ADJ
tahrj-8728	65	44	elements	element	NOUN
tahrj-8728	65	45	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	65	46	advantage	advantage	NOUN
tahrj-8728	65	47	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	65	48	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	65	49	terminology	terminology	NOUN
tahrj-8728	65	50	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	65	51	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	65	52	is	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	65	53	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	65	54	it	it	PRON
tahrj-8728	65	55	introduces	introduce	VERB
tahrj-8728	65	56	an	an	DET
tahrj-8728	65	57	element	element	NOUN
tahrj-8728	65	58	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	65	59	structure	structure	NOUN
tahrj-8728	65	60	into	into	ADP
tahrj-8728	65	61	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	65	62	exercise	exercise	NOUN
tahrj-8728	65	63	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	65	64	by	by	ADP
tahrj-8728	65	65	directing	direct	VERB
tahrj-8728	65	66	attention	attention	NOUN
tahrj-8728	65	67	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	65	68	factors	factor	NOUN
tahrj-8728	65	69	such	such	ADJ
tahrj-8728	65	70	as	as	ADP
tahrj-8728	65	71	suitability	suitability	NOUN
tahrj-8728	65	72	or	or	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	65	73	appropriateness	appropriateness	NOUN
tahrj-8728	65	74	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	65	75	necessity	necessity	NOUN
tahrj-8728	65	76	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	65	77	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	65	78	balance	balance	NOUN
tahrj-8728	65	79	or	or	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	65	80	imbalance	imbalance	NOUN
tahrj-8728	65	81	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	65	82	benefits	benefit	NOUN
tahrj-8728	65	83	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	65	84	disadvantages	disadvantage	NOUN
tahrj-8728	65	85	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	66	1	lord	lord	PROPN
tahrj-8728	66	2	mance	mance	PROPN
tahrj-8728	66	3	also	also	ADV
tahrj-8728	66	4	highlighted	highlight	VERB
tahrj-8728	66	5	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	66	6	these	these	DET
tahrj-8728	66	7	factors	factor	NOUN
tahrj-8728	66	8	may	may	AUX
tahrj-8728	66	9	be	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	66	10	relevant	relevant	ADJ
tahrj-8728	66	11	outside	outside	ADP
tahrj-8728	66	12	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	66	13	convention	convention	NOUN
tahrj-8728	66	14	too	too	ADV
tahrj-8728	66	15	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	66	16	i.e.	i.e.	X
tahrj-8728	66	17	even	even	ADV
tahrj-8728	66	18	where	where	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	66	19	wednesbury	wednesbury	PROPN
tahrj-8728	66	20	applies	apply	VERB
tahrj-8728	66	21	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	67	1	therefore	therefore	ADV
tahrj-8728	67	2	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	67	3	daly	daly	PROPN
tahrj-8728	67	4	suggests	suggest	VERB
tahrj-8728	67	5	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	67	6	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	67	7	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	67	8	test	test	NOUN
tahrj-8728	67	9	be	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	67	10	applied	apply	VERB
tahrj-8728	67	11	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	67	12	all	all	DET
tahrj-8728	67	13	human	human	ADJ
tahrj-8728	67	14	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	67	15	cases	case	NOUN
tahrj-8728	67	16	even	even	ADV
tahrj-8728	67	17	if	if	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	67	18	outside	outside	ADP
tahrj-8728	67	19	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	67	20	scope	scope	NOUN
tahrj-8728	67	21	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	67	22	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	67	23	human	human	ADJ
tahrj-8728	67	24	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	67	25	act	act	NOUN
tahrj-8728	67	26	1998	1998	NUM
tahrj-8728	67	27	so	so	ADV
tahrj-8728	67	28	far	far	ADV
tahrj-8728	67	29	as	as	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	67	30	fundamental	fundamental	ADJ
tahrj-8728	67	31	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	67	32	or	or	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	67	33	human	human	ADJ
tahrj-8728	67	34	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	67	35	are	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	67	36	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	67	37	question	question	NOUN
tahrj-8728	67	38	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	68	1	this	this	PRON
tahrj-8728	68	2	is	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	68	3	because	because	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	68	4	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	68	5	analysis	analysis	NOUN
tahrj-8728	68	6	is	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	68	7	clearer	clear	ADJ
tahrj-8728	68	8	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	68	9	transparent	transparent	ADJ
tahrj-8728	68	10	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	68	11	enhances	enhance	VERB
tahrj-8728	68	12	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	68	13	intensity	intensity	NOUN
tahrj-8728	68	14	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	68	15	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	68	16	review	review	NOUN
tahrj-8728	68	17	depending	depend	VERB
tahrj-8728	68	18	on	on	ADP
tahrj-8728	68	19	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	68	20	context	context	NOUN
tahrj-8728	68	21	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	69	1	however	however	ADV
tahrj-8728	69	2	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	69	3	post	post	ADJ
tahrj-8728	69	4	-	-	ADJ
tahrj-8728	69	5	daly	daly	ADJ
tahrj-8728	69	6	jurisprudence	jurisprudence	NOUN
tahrj-8728	69	7	clarifies	clarify	VERB
tahrj-8728	69	8	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	69	9	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	69	10	two	two	NUM
tahrj-8728	69	11	standards	standard	NOUN
tahrj-8728	69	12	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	69	13	review	review	NOUN
tahrj-8728	69	14	are	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	69	15	not	not	PART
tahrj-8728	69	16	mutually	mutually	ADV
tahrj-8728	69	17	exclusive	exclusive	ADJ
tahrj-8728	69	18	;	;	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	69	19	they	they	PRON
tahrj-8728	69	20	operate	operate	VERB
tahrj-8728	69	21	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	69	22	parallel	parallel	NOUN
tahrj-8728	69	23	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	69	24	serving	serve	VERB
tahrj-8728	69	25	similar	similar	ADJ
tahrj-8728	69	26	purposes	purpose	NOUN
tahrj-8728	69	27	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	69	28	employing	employ	VERB
tahrj-8728	69	29	comparable	comparable	ADJ
tahrj-8728	69	30	methodologies	methodology	NOUN
tahrj-8728	69	31	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	69	32	achieve	achieve	VERB
tahrj-8728	69	33	largely	largely	ADV
tahrj-8728	69	34	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	69	35	same	same	ADJ
tahrj-8728	69	36	outcomes	outcome	NOUN
tahrj-8728	69	37	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	70	1	this	this	DET
tahrj-8728	70	2	argument	argument	NOUN
tahrj-8728	70	3	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	70	4	however	however	ADV
tahrj-8728	70	5	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	70	6	has	have	VERB
tahrj-8728	70	7	its	its	PRON
tahrj-8728	70	8	limitations	limitation	NOUN
tahrj-8728	70	9	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	70	10	which	which	PRON
tahrj-8728	70	11	are	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	70	12	discussed	discuss	VERB
tahrj-8728	70	13	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	70	14	part	part	NOUN
tahrj-8728	70	15	3	3	NUM
tahrj-8728	70	16	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	70	17	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	70	18	paper	paper	NOUN
tahrj-8728	70	19	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	71	1	1.1	1.1	NUM
tahrj-8728	71	2	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	71	3	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	71	4	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	71	5	nonrefoulement	nonrefoulement	ADJ
tahrj-8728	71	6	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	71	7	principle	principle	NOUN
tahrj-8728	71	8	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	71	9	non	non	ADJ
tahrj-8728	71	10	-	-	ADJ
tahrj-8728	71	11	refoulement	refoulement	ADJ
tahrj-8728	71	12	is	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	71	13	explicitly	explicitly	ADV
tahrj-8728	71	14	provided	provide	VERB
tahrj-8728	71	15	for	for	ADP
tahrj-8728	71	16	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	71	17	article	article	NOUN
tahrj-8728	71	18	33	33	NUM
tahrj-8728	71	19	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	71	20	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	71	21	1951	1951	NUM
tahrj-8728	71	22	geneva	geneva	NOUN
tahrj-8728	71	23	convention	convention	NOUN
tahrj-8728	71	24	relating	relate	VERB
tahrj-8728	71	25	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	71	26	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	71	27	status	status	NOUN
tahrj-8728	71	28	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	71	29	refugees	refugee	NOUN
tahrj-8728	71	30	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	71	31	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	71	32	also	also	ADV
tahrj-8728	71	33	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	71	34	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	71	35	1967	1967	NUM
tahrj-8728	71	36	protocol	protocol	NOUN
tahrj-8728	71	37	linked	link	VERB
tahrj-8728	71	38	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	71	39	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	71	40	latter	latter	ADJ
tahrj-8728	71	41	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	72	1	article	article	NOUN
tahrj-8728	72	2	33	33	NUM
tahrj-8728	72	3	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	72	4	1	1	NUM
tahrj-8728	72	5	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	72	6	specifies	specifie	NOUN
tahrj-8728	72	7	that	that	PRON
tahrj-8728	72	8	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	72	9	state	state	NOUN
tahrj-8728	72	10	party	party	NOUN
tahrj-8728	72	11	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	72	12	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	72	13	convention	convention	NOUN
tahrj-8728	72	14	or	or	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	72	15	its	its	PRON
tahrj-8728	72	16	protocol	protocol	NOUN
tahrj-8728	72	17	may	may	AUX
tahrj-8728	72	18	not	not	PART
tahrj-8728	72	19	return	return	VERB
tahrj-8728	72	20	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	72	21	“	"	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	72	22	refouler	refouler	NOUN
tahrj-8728	72	23	”	"	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	72	24	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	72	25	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	72	26	refugee	refugee	NOUN
tahrj-8728	72	27	“	"	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	72	28	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	72	29	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	72	30	frontiers	frontier	NOUN
tahrj-8728	72	31	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	72	32	territories	territory	NOUN
tahrj-8728	72	33	where	where	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	72	34	his	his	PRON
tahrj-8728	72	35	life	life	NOUN
tahrj-8728	72	36	or	or	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	72	37	freedom	freedom	NOUN
tahrj-8728	72	38	would	would	AUX
tahrj-8728	72	39	be	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	72	40	threatened	threaten	VERB
tahrj-8728	72	41	on	on	ADP
tahrj-8728	72	42	account	account	NOUN
tahrj-8728	72	43	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	72	44	his	his	PRON
tahrj-8728	72	45	race	race	NOUN
tahrj-8728	72	46	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	72	47	religion	religion	NOUN
tahrj-8728	72	48	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	72	49	nationality	nationality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	72	50	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	72	51	membership	membership	NOUN
tahrj-8728	72	52	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	72	53	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	72	54	particular	particular	ADJ
tahrj-8728	72	55	social	social	ADJ
tahrj-8728	72	56	group	group	NOUN
tahrj-8728	72	57	or	or	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	72	58	political	political	ADJ
tahrj-8728	72	59	opinion	opinion	NOUN
tahrj-8728	72	60	”	"	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	72	61	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	73	1	unhcr	unhcr	PROPN
tahrj-8728	73	2	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	73	3	1997	1997	NUM
tahrj-8728	73	4	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	73	5	notes	note	VERB
tahrj-8728	73	6	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	73	7	non	non	ADJ
tahrj-8728	73	8	-	-	ADJ
tahrj-8728	73	9	refoulement	refoulement	ADJ
tahrj-8728	73	10	is	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	73	11	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	73	12	cornerstone	cornerstone	NOUN
tahrj-8728	73	13	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	73	14	asylum	asylum	NOUN
tahrj-8728	73	15	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	73	16	international	international	ADJ
tahrj-8728	73	17	refugee	refugee	NOUN
tahrj-8728	73	18	law	law	NOUN
tahrj-8728	73	19	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	74	1	further	far	ADV
tahrj-8728	74	2	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	74	3	it	it	PRON
tahrj-8728	74	4	explains	explain	VERB
tahrj-8728	74	5	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	74	6	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	74	7	application	application	NOUN
tahrj-8728	74	8	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	74	9	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	74	10	provision	provision	NOUN
tahrj-8728	74	11	is	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	74	12	not	not	PART
tahrj-8728	74	13	dependent	dependent	ADJ
tahrj-8728	74	14	on	on	ADP
tahrj-8728	74	15	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	74	16	lawful	lawful	ADJ
tahrj-8728	74	17	residence	residence	NOUN
tahrj-8728	74	18	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	74	19	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	74	20	https://doi.org/10.17561/tahrj.v23.8728	https://doi.org/10.17561/tahrj.v23.8728	PROPN
tahrj-8728	74	21	sabreen	sabreen	PROPN
tahrj-8728	74	22	ahmed	ahme	VERB
tahrj-8728	74	23	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	74	24	age	age	NOUN
tahrj-8728	74	25	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	74	26	human	human	ADJ
tahrj-8728	74	27	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	74	28	journal	journal	NOUN
tahrj-8728	74	29	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	74	30	24	24	NUM
tahrj-8728	74	31	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	74	32	june	june	PROPN
tahrj-8728	74	33	2025	2025	NUM
tahrj-8728	74	34	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	74	35	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	74	36	e8728	e8728	PROPN
tahrj-8728	74	37	issn	issn	PROPN
tahrj-8728	74	38	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	74	39	2340	2340	NUM
tahrj-8728	74	40	-	-	SYM
tahrj-8728	74	41	9592	9592	NUM
tahrj-8728	74	42	doi	doi	NOUN
tahrj-8728	74	43	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	74	44	10.17561	10.17561	NUM
tahrj-8728	74	45	/	/	SYM
tahrj-8728	74	46	tahrj.v23.8728	tahrj.v23.8728	PROPN
tahrj-8728	74	47	5	5	NUM
tahrj-8728	74	48	refugee	refugee	NOUN
tahrj-8728	74	49	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	74	50	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	74	51	territory	territory	NOUN
tahrj-8728	74	52	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	74	53	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	74	54	contracting	contracting	NOUN
tahrj-8728	74	55	state	state	NOUN
tahrj-8728	74	56	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	75	1	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	75	2	note	note	NOUN
tahrj-8728	75	3	also	also	ADV
tahrj-8728	75	4	makes	make	VERB
tahrj-8728	75	5	mention	mention	NOUN
tahrj-8728	75	6	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	75	7	art	art	NOUN
tahrj-8728	75	8	3(1	3(1	NUM
tahrj-8728	75	9	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	75	10	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	75	11	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	75	12	un	un	PROPN
tahrj-8728	75	13	declaration	declaration	PROPN
tahrj-8728	75	14	on	on	ADP
tahrj-8728	75	15	territorial	territorial	ADJ
tahrj-8728	75	16	asylum	asylum	NOUN
tahrj-8728	75	17	adopted	adopt	VERB
tahrj-8728	75	18	unanimously	unanimously	ADV
tahrj-8728	75	19	by	by	ADP
tahrj-8728	75	20	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	75	21	general	general	ADJ
tahrj-8728	75	22	assembly	assembly	NOUN
tahrj-8728	75	23	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	75	24	1967	1967	NUM
tahrj-8728	75	25	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	75	26	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	76	1	it	it	PRON
tahrj-8728	76	2	stated	state	VERB
tahrj-8728	76	3	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	76	4	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	76	5	no	no	DET
tahrj-8728	76	6	person	person	NOUN
tahrj-8728	76	7	referred	refer	VERB
tahrj-8728	76	8	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	76	9	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	76	10	article	article	NOUN
tahrj-8728	76	11	1	1	NUM
tahrj-8728	76	12	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	76	13	para	para	NOUN
tahrj-8728	76	14	1	1	NUM
tahrj-8728	76	15	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	76	16	shall	shall	AUX
tahrj-8728	76	17	be	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	76	18	subjected	subject	VERB
tahrj-8728	76	19	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	76	20	measures	measure	NOUN
tahrj-8728	76	21	such	such	ADJ
tahrj-8728	76	22	as	as	ADP
tahrj-8728	76	23	rejection	rejection	NOUN
tahrj-8728	76	24	at	at	ADP
tahrj-8728	76	25	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	76	26	frontier	frontier	NOUN
tahrj-8728	76	27	or	or	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	76	28	if	if	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	76	29	he	he	PRON
tahrj-8728	76	30	has	have	AUX
tahrj-8728	76	31	already	already	ADV
tahrj-8728	76	32	entered	enter	VERB
tahrj-8728	76	33	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	76	34	territory	territory	NOUN
tahrj-8728	76	35	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	76	36	which	which	PRON
tahrj-8728	76	37	he	he	PRON
tahrj-8728	76	38	seeks	seek	VERB
tahrj-8728	76	39	asylum	asylum	NOUN
tahrj-8728	76	40	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	76	41	expulsion	expulsion	NOUN
tahrj-8728	76	42	or	or	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	76	43	compulsory	compulsory	ADJ
tahrj-8728	76	44	return	return	NOUN
tahrj-8728	76	45	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	76	46	any	any	DET
tahrj-8728	76	47	state	state	NOUN
tahrj-8728	76	48	where	where	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	76	49	he	he	PRON
tahrj-8728	76	50	may	may	AUX
tahrj-8728	76	51	be	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	76	52	subjected	subject	VERB
tahrj-8728	76	53	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	76	54	persecution	persecution	NOUN
tahrj-8728	76	55	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	77	1	art	art	NOUN
tahrj-8728	77	2	33(2	33(2	NUM
tahrj-8728	77	3	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	77	4	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	77	5	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	77	6	convention	convention	NOUN
tahrj-8728	77	7	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	77	8	1951	1951	NUM
tahrj-8728	77	9	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	77	10	provides	provide	VERB
tahrj-8728	77	11	exceptions	exception	NOUN
tahrj-8728	77	12	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	77	13	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	77	14	non	non	ADJ
tahrj-8728	77	15	-	-	ADJ
tahrj-8728	77	16	refoulement	refoulement	ADJ
tahrj-8728	77	17	obligation	obligation	NOUN
tahrj-8728	77	18	whereby	whereby	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	77	19	there	there	PRON
tahrj-8728	77	20	are	be	VERB
tahrj-8728	77	21	reasonable	reasonable	ADJ
tahrj-8728	77	22	grounds	ground	NOUN
tahrj-8728	77	23	for	for	ADP
tahrj-8728	77	24	regarding	regard	VERB
tahrj-8728	77	25	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	77	26	refugee	refugee	NOUN
tahrj-8728	77	27	as	as	ADP
tahrj-8728	77	28	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	77	29	danger	danger	NOUN
tahrj-8728	77	30	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	77	31	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	77	32	security	security	NOUN
tahrj-8728	77	33	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	77	34	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	77	35	country	country	NOUN
tahrj-8728	77	36	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	77	37	which	which	PRON
tahrj-8728	77	38	he	he	PRON
tahrj-8728	77	39	is	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	77	40	or	or	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	77	41	who	who	PRON
tahrj-8728	77	42	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	77	43	having	having	AUX
tahrj-8728	77	44	been	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	77	45	convicted	convict	VERB
tahrj-8728	77	46	by	by	ADP
tahrj-8728	77	47	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	77	48	final	final	ADJ
tahrj-8728	77	49	judgement	judgement	NOUN
tahrj-8728	77	50	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	77	51	particularly	particularly	ADV
tahrj-8728	77	52	serious	serious	ADJ
tahrj-8728	77	53	crime	crime	NOUN
tahrj-8728	77	54	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	77	55	constitutes	constitute	VERB
tahrj-8728	77	56	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	77	57	danger	danger	NOUN
tahrj-8728	77	58	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	77	59	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	77	60	community	community	NOUN
tahrj-8728	77	61	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	77	62	that	that	DET
tahrj-8728	77	63	country	country	NOUN
tahrj-8728	77	64	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	78	1	while	while	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	78	2	these	these	DET
tahrj-8728	78	3	exceptions	exception	NOUN
tahrj-8728	78	4	are	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	78	5	argued	argue	VERB
tahrj-8728	78	6	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	78	7	weaken	weaken	VERB
tahrj-8728	78	8	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	78	9	refugee	refugee	NOUN
tahrj-8728	78	10	protection	protection	NOUN
tahrj-8728	78	11	machinery	machinery	NOUN
tahrj-8728	78	12	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	78	13	there	there	PRON
tahrj-8728	78	14	are	be	VERB
tahrj-8728	78	15	vast	vast	ADJ
tahrj-8728	78	16	debates	debate	NOUN
tahrj-8728	78	17	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	78	18	academia	academia	NOUN
tahrj-8728	78	19	about	about	ADP
tahrj-8728	78	20	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	78	21	implementation	implementation	NOUN
tahrj-8728	78	22	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	78	23	such	such	ADJ
tahrj-8728	78	24	exceptions	exception	NOUN
tahrj-8728	78	25	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	78	26	teferra	teferra	NOUN
tahrj-8728	78	27	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	78	28	2018	2018	NUM
tahrj-8728	78	29	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	78	30	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	79	1	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	79	2	these	these	DET
tahrj-8728	79	3	debates	debate	NOUN
tahrj-8728	79	4	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	79	5	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	79	6	application	application	NOUN
tahrj-8728	79	7	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	79	8	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	79	9	analysis	analysis	NOUN
tahrj-8728	79	10	is	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	79	11	also	also	ADV
tahrj-8728	79	12	frequently	frequently	ADV
tahrj-8728	79	13	discussed	discuss	VERB
tahrj-8728	79	14	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	79	15	especially	especially	ADV
tahrj-8728	79	16	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	79	17	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	79	18	context	context	NOUN
tahrj-8728	79	19	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	79	20	refoulement	refoulement	NOUN
tahrj-8728	79	21	triggered	trigger	VERB
tahrj-8728	79	22	by	by	ADP
tahrj-8728	79	23	national	national	ADJ
tahrj-8728	79	24	security	security	NOUN
tahrj-8728	79	25	grounds	ground	NOUN
tahrj-8728	79	26	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	79	27	teferra	teferra	NOUN
tahrj-8728	79	28	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	79	29	2018	2018	NUM
tahrj-8728	79	30	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	79	31	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	80	1	this	this	PRON
tahrj-8728	80	2	means	mean	VERB
tahrj-8728	80	3	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	80	4	there	there	PRON
tahrj-8728	80	5	is	be	VERB
tahrj-8728	80	6	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	80	7	requirement	requirement	NOUN
tahrj-8728	80	8	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	80	9	balance	balance	VERB
tahrj-8728	80	10	security	security	NOUN
tahrj-8728	80	11	interests	interest	NOUN
tahrj-8728	80	12	with	with	ADP
tahrj-8728	80	13	possible	possible	ADJ
tahrj-8728	80	14	dangers	danger	NOUN
tahrj-8728	80	15	faced	face	VERB
tahrj-8728	80	16	by	by	ADP
tahrj-8728	80	17	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	80	18	refugees	refugee	NOUN
tahrj-8728	80	19	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	81	1	hathaway	hathaway	PROPN
tahrj-8728	81	2	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	81	3	harvey	harvey	PROPN
tahrj-8728	81	4	oppose	oppose	VERB
tahrj-8728	81	5	such	such	DET
tahrj-8728	81	6	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	81	7	balancing	balance	VERB
tahrj-8728	81	8	mechanism	mechanism	NOUN
tahrj-8728	81	9	because	because	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	81	10	art	art	NOUN
tahrj-8728	81	11	33	33	NUM
tahrj-8728	81	12	has	have	VERB
tahrj-8728	81	13	an	an	DET
tahrj-8728	81	14	inbuilt	inbuilt	ADJ
tahrj-8728	81	15	threshold	threshold	NOUN
tahrj-8728	81	16	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	81	17	severity	severity	NOUN
tahrj-8728	81	18	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	82	1	moreover	moreover	ADV
tahrj-8728	82	2	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	82	3	they	they	PRON
tahrj-8728	82	4	argue	argue	VERB
tahrj-8728	82	5	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	82	6	there	there	PRON
tahrj-8728	82	7	is	be	VERB
tahrj-8728	82	8	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	82	9	requirement	requirement	NOUN
tahrj-8728	82	10	for	for	ADP
tahrj-8728	82	11	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	82	12	strong	strong	ADJ
tahrj-8728	82	13	standard	standard	NOUN
tahrj-8728	82	14	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	82	15	national	national	ADJ
tahrj-8728	82	16	security	security	NOUN
tahrj-8728	82	17	under	under	ADP
tahrj-8728	82	18	art	art	NOUN
tahrj-8728	82	19	33(2	33(2	NUM
tahrj-8728	82	20	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	82	21	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	82	22	hathaway	hathaway	PROPN
tahrj-8728	82	23	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	82	24	2005	2005	NUM
tahrj-8728	82	25	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	82	26	pp	pp	ADJ
tahrj-8728	82	27	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	83	1	353	353	NUM
tahrj-8728	83	2	-	-	NUM
tahrj-8728	83	3	354	354	NUM
tahrj-8728	83	4	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	83	5	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	84	1	contrarily	contrarily	ADV
tahrj-8728	84	2	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	84	3	professor	professor	PROPN
tahrj-8728	84	4	geoff	geoff	PROPN
tahrj-8728	84	5	gilbert	gilbert	PROPN
tahrj-8728	84	6	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	84	7	2003	2003	NUM
tahrj-8728	84	8	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	84	9	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	84	10	goodwin	goodwin	PROPN
tahrj-8728	84	11	gill	gill	PROPN
tahrj-8728	84	12	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	84	13	1996	1996	NUM
tahrj-8728	84	14	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	84	15	contend	contend	VERB
tahrj-8728	84	16	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	84	17	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	84	18	analysis	analysis	NOUN
tahrj-8728	84	19	is	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	84	20	essential	essential	ADJ
tahrj-8728	84	21	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	84	22	art	art	NOUN
tahrj-8728	84	23	33	33	NUM
tahrj-8728	84	24	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	85	1	goodwin	goodwin	PROPN
tahrj-8728	85	2	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	85	3	1996	1996	NUM
tahrj-8728	85	4	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	85	5	states	state	VERB
tahrj-8728	85	6	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	85	7	principles	principle	NOUN
tahrj-8728	85	8	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	85	9	natural	natural	ADJ
tahrj-8728	85	10	justice	justice	NOUN
tahrj-8728	85	11	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	85	12	due	due	ADJ
tahrj-8728	85	13	process	process	NOUN
tahrj-8728	85	14	are	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	85	15	inherent	inherent	ADJ
tahrj-8728	85	16	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	85	17	international	international	ADJ
tahrj-8728	85	18	law	law	NOUN
tahrj-8728	85	19	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	85	20	require	require	VERB
tahrj-8728	85	21	something	something	PRON
tahrj-8728	85	22	more	more	ADJ
tahrj-8728	85	23	than	than	ADP
tahrj-8728	85	24	an	an	DET
tahrj-8728	85	25	‘	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	85	26	exception	exception	NOUN
tahrj-8728	85	27	’	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	85	28	clause	clause	NOUN
tahrj-8728	85	29	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	86	1	similarly	similarly	ADV
tahrj-8728	86	2	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	86	3	professor	professor	PROPN
tahrj-8728	86	4	gilbert	gilbert	PROPN
tahrj-8728	86	5	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	86	6	2003	2003	NUM
tahrj-8728	86	7	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	86	8	advocates	advocate	NOUN
tahrj-8728	86	9	for	for	ADP
tahrj-8728	86	10	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	86	11	balancing	balancing	NOUN
tahrj-8728	86	12	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	86	13	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	86	14	refugee	refugee	NOUN
tahrj-8728	86	15	’s	’s	PART
tahrj-8728	86	16	fear	fear	NOUN
tahrj-8728	86	17	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	86	18	persecution	persecution	NOUN
tahrj-8728	86	19	against	against	ADP
tahrj-8728	86	20	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	86	21	danger	danger	NOUN
tahrj-8728	86	22	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	86	23	he	he	PRON
tahrj-8728	86	24	or	or	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	86	25	she	she	PRON
tahrj-8728	86	26	presents	present	VERB
tahrj-8728	86	27	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	86	28	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	86	29	security	security	NOUN
tahrj-8728	86	30	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	86	31	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	86	32	country	country	NOUN
tahrj-8728	86	33	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	87	1	moreover	moreover	ADV
tahrj-8728	87	2	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	87	3	from	from	ADP
tahrj-8728	87	4	an	an	DET
tahrj-8728	87	5	absolute	absolute	ADJ
tahrj-8728	87	6	right	right	ADJ
tahrj-8728	87	7	context	context	NOUN
tahrj-8728	87	8	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	87	9	lauterpacht	lauterpacht	NOUN
tahrj-8728	87	10	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	87	11	bethlehem	bethlehem	PROPN
tahrj-8728	87	12	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	87	13	2009	2009	NUM
tahrj-8728	87	14	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	87	15	argued	argue	VERB
tahrj-8728	87	16	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	87	17	this	this	DET
tahrj-8728	87	18	absolute	absolute	ADJ
tahrj-8728	87	19	ban	ban	NOUN
tahrj-8728	87	20	requires	require	VERB
tahrj-8728	87	21	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	87	22	asylum	asylum	NOUN
tahrj-8728	87	23	state	state	NOUN
tahrj-8728	87	24	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	87	25	give	give	VERB
tahrj-8728	87	26	full	full	ADJ
tahrj-8728	87	27	consideration	consideration	NOUN
tahrj-8728	87	28	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	87	29	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	87	30	dangers	danger	NOUN
tahrj-8728	87	31	faced	face	VERB
tahrj-8728	87	32	by	by	ADP
tahrj-8728	87	33	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	87	34	refugees	refugee	NOUN
tahrj-8728	87	35	before	before	ADP
tahrj-8728	87	36	executing	execute	VERB
tahrj-8728	87	37	its	its	PRON
tahrj-8728	87	38	deportation	deportation	NOUN
tahrj-8728	87	39	order	order	NOUN
tahrj-8728	87	40	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	88	1	1.2	1.2	NUM
tahrj-8728	88	2	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	88	3	ecthr	ecthr	PROPN
tahrj-8728	88	4	jurisprudence	jurisprudence	NOUN
tahrj-8728	88	5	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	88	6	from	from	ADP
tahrj-8728	88	7	no	no	DET
tahrj-8728	88	8	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	88	9	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	88	10	something	something	PRON
tahrj-8728	88	11	illusory	illusory	ADJ
tahrj-8728	88	12	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	88	13	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	88	14	context	context	NOUN
tahrj-8728	88	15	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	88	16	europe	europe	PROPN
tahrj-8728	88	17	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	88	18	there	there	PRON
tahrj-8728	88	19	is	be	VERB
tahrj-8728	88	20	no	no	DET
tahrj-8728	88	21	explicit	explicit	ADJ
tahrj-8728	88	22	right	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	88	23	against	against	ADP
tahrj-8728	88	24	non	non	ADJ
tahrj-8728	88	25	-	-	ADJ
tahrj-8728	88	26	refoulement	refoulement	ADJ
tahrj-8728	88	27	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	88	28	however	however	ADV
tahrj-8728	88	29	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	88	30	it	it	PRON
tahrj-8728	88	31	has	have	AUX
tahrj-8728	88	32	been	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	88	33	read	read	VERB
tahrj-8728	88	34	into	into	ADP
tahrj-8728	88	35	art	art	NOUN
tahrj-8728	88	36	3	3	NUM
tahrj-8728	88	37	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	88	38	echr	echr	PROPN
tahrj-8728	88	39	which	which	PRON
tahrj-8728	88	40	states	state	VERB
tahrj-8728	88	41	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	88	42	‘	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	88	43	no	no	DET
tahrj-8728	88	44	one	one	NOUN
tahrj-8728	88	45	shall	shall	AUX
tahrj-8728	88	46	be	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	88	47	subjected	subject	VERB
tahrj-8728	88	48	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	88	49	torture	torture	NOUN
tahrj-8728	88	50	or	or	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	88	51	inhuman	inhuman	ADJ
tahrj-8728	88	52	or	or	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	88	53	degrading	degrading	ADJ
tahrj-8728	88	54	treatment	treatment	NOUN
tahrj-8728	88	55	or	or	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	88	56	punishment	punishment	NOUN
tahrj-8728	88	57	’	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	88	58	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	89	1	although	although	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	89	2	such	such	DET
tahrj-8728	89	3	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	89	4	construction	construction	NOUN
tahrj-8728	89	5	implying	imply	VERB
tahrj-8728	89	6	non	non	ADJ
tahrj-8728	89	7	-	-	ADJ
tahrj-8728	89	8	refoulement	refoulement	ADJ
tahrj-8728	89	9	obligations	obligation	NOUN
tahrj-8728	89	10	dates	date	VERB
tahrj-8728	89	11	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	89	12	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	89	13	1970s	1970	NOUN
tahrj-8728	89	14	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	89	15	cassese	cassese	NOUN
tahrj-8728	89	16	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	89	17	1993	1993	NUM
tahrj-8728	89	18	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	89	19	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	89	20	it	it	PRON
tahrj-8728	89	21	materialized	materialize	VERB
tahrj-8728	89	22	only	only	ADV
tahrj-8728	89	23	with	with	ADP
tahrj-8728	89	24	soering	soere	VERB
tahrj-8728	89	25	v.	v.	ADP
tahrj-8728	89	26	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	89	27	united	united	PROPN
tahrj-8728	89	28	kingdom	kingdom	PROPN
tahrj-8728	89	29	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	89	30	1989	1989	NUM
tahrj-8728	89	31	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	89	32	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	90	1	since	since	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	90	2	then	then	ADV
tahrj-8728	90	3	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	90	4	ecthr	ecthr	PROPN
tahrj-8728	90	5	has	have	VERB
tahrj-8728	90	6	time	time	NOUN
tahrj-8728	90	7	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	90	8	again	again	ADV
tahrj-8728	90	9	expanded	expand	VERB
tahrj-8728	90	10	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	90	11	jurisprudence	jurisprudence	NOUN
tahrj-8728	90	12	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	90	13	many	many	ADJ
tahrj-8728	90	14	cases	case	NOUN
tahrj-8728	90	15	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	91	1	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	91	2	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	91	3	has	have	AUX
tahrj-8728	91	4	described	describe	VERB
tahrj-8728	91	5	art	art	NOUN
tahrj-8728	91	6	3	3	NUM
tahrj-8728	91	7	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	91	8	be	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	91	9	absolute	absolute	ADJ
tahrj-8728	91	10	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	91	11	harris	harris	PROPN
tahrj-8728	91	12	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	91	13	1995	1995	NUM
tahrj-8728	91	14	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	91	15	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	92	1	this	this	PRON
tahrj-8728	92	2	means	mean	VERB
tahrj-8728	92	3	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	92	4	art	art	NOUN
tahrj-8728	92	5	3	3	NUM
tahrj-8728	92	6	admits	admit	VERB
tahrj-8728	92	7	no	no	DET
tahrj-8728	92	8	exceptions	exception	NOUN
tahrj-8728	92	9	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	92	10	can	can	AUX
tahrj-8728	92	11	not	not	PART
tahrj-8728	92	12	be	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	92	13	derogated	derogate	VERB
tahrj-8728	92	14	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	92	15	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	92	16	applies	apply	VERB
tahrj-8728	92	17	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	92	18	everyone	everyone	PRON
tahrj-8728	92	19	no	no	ADV
tahrj-8728	92	20	matter	matter	ADV
tahrj-8728	92	21	what	what	PRON
tahrj-8728	92	22	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	92	23	ireland	ireland	NOUN
tahrj-8728	92	24	v.	v.	ADP
tahrj-8728	92	25	uk	uk	PROPN
tahrj-8728	92	26	1979	1979	NUM
tahrj-8728	92	27	-	-	SYM
tahrj-8728	92	28	1980	1980	NUM
tahrj-8728	92	29	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	92	30	p.	p.	NOUN
tahrj-8728	92	31	163	163	NUM
tahrj-8728	92	32	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	92	33	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	93	1	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	93	2	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	93	3	context	context	NOUN
tahrj-8728	93	4	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	93	5	non	non	ADJ
tahrj-8728	93	6	-	-	ADJ
tahrj-8728	93	7	refoulement	refoulement	ADJ
tahrj-8728	93	8	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	93	9	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	93	10	resulting	result	VERB
tahrj-8728	93	11	obligation	obligation	NOUN
tahrj-8728	93	12	is	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	93	13	not	not	PART
tahrj-8728	93	14	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	93	15	deport	deport	VERB
tahrj-8728	93	16	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	93	17	expel	expel	NOUN
tahrj-8728	93	18	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	93	19	extradite	extradite	ADJ
tahrj-8728	93	20	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	93	21	reject	reject	VERB
tahrj-8728	93	22	at	at	ADP
tahrj-8728	93	23	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	93	24	frontier	frontier	NOUN
tahrj-8728	93	25	or	or	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	93	26	otherwise	otherwise	ADV
tahrj-8728	93	27	‘	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	93	28	refoule	refoule	NOUN
tahrj-8728	93	29	’	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	93	30	someone	someone	PRON
tahrj-8728	93	31	at	at	ADP
tahrj-8728	93	32	risk	risk	NOUN
tahrj-8728	93	33	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	93	34	mavronicola	mavronicola	PROPN
tahrj-8728	93	35	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	93	36	messineo	messineo	NOUN
tahrj-8728	93	37	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	93	38	2013	2013	NUM
tahrj-8728	93	39	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	93	40	p.595	p.595	NOUN
tahrj-8728	93	41	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	93	42	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	93	43	vivalrajah	vivalrajah	PROPN
tahrj-8728	93	44	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	93	45	others	other	NOUN
tahrj-8728	93	46	v.	v.	ADP
tahrj-8728	93	47	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	93	48	united	united	PROPN
tahrj-8728	93	49	kingdom	kingdom	PROPN
tahrj-8728	93	50	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	93	51	1991	1991	NUM
tahrj-8728	93	52	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	93	53	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	93	54	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	93	55	said	say	VERB
tahrj-8728	93	56	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	93	57	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	93	58	https://doi.org/10.17561/tahrj.v23.8728	https://doi.org/10.17561/tahrj.v23.8728	VERB
tahrj-8728	93	59	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	93	60	analysis	analysis	NOUN
tahrj-8728	93	61	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	93	62	non	non	ADJ
tahrj-8728	93	63	-	-	ADJ
tahrj-8728	93	64	refoulement	refoulement	ADJ
tahrj-8728	93	65	jurisprudence	jurisprudence	NOUN
tahrj-8728	93	66	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	93	67	india	india	PROPN
tahrj-8728	93	68	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	93	69	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	93	70	comparative	comparative	ADJ
tahrj-8728	93	71	approach	approach	NOUN
tahrj-8728	93	72	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	93	73	age	age	NOUN
tahrj-8728	93	74	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	93	75	human	human	ADJ
tahrj-8728	93	76	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	93	77	journal	journal	NOUN
tahrj-8728	93	78	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	93	79	24	24	NUM
tahrj-8728	93	80	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	93	81	june	june	PROPN
tahrj-8728	93	82	2025	2025	NUM
tahrj-8728	93	83	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	93	84	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	93	85	e8728	e8728	PROPN
tahrj-8728	93	86	issn	issn	PROPN
tahrj-8728	93	87	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	93	88	2340	2340	NUM
tahrj-8728	93	89	-	-	SYM
tahrj-8728	93	90	9592	9592	NUM
tahrj-8728	93	91	doi	doi	NOUN
tahrj-8728	93	92	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	93	93	10.17561	10.17561	NUM
tahrj-8728	93	94	/	/	SYM
tahrj-8728	93	95	tahrj.v23.8728	tahrj.v23.8728	PROPN
tahrj-8728	93	96	6	6	NUM
tahrj-8728	93	97	expulsion	expulsion	NOUN
tahrj-8728	93	98	by	by	ADP
tahrj-8728	93	99	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	93	100	contracting	contracting	NOUN
tahrj-8728	93	101	state	state	NOUN
tahrj-8728	93	102	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	93	103	an	an	DET
tahrj-8728	93	104	asylum	asylum	NOUN
tahrj-8728	93	105	seeker	seeker	NOUN
tahrj-8728	93	106	may	may	AUX
tahrj-8728	93	107	give	give	VERB
tahrj-8728	93	108	rise	rise	NOUN
tahrj-8728	93	109	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	93	110	an	an	DET
tahrj-8728	93	111	issue	issue	NOUN
tahrj-8728	93	112	under	under	ADP
tahrj-8728	93	113	article	article	NOUN
tahrj-8728	93	114	3	3	NUM
tahrj-8728	93	115	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	93	116	hence	hence	ADV
tahrj-8728	93	117	suggests	suggest	VERB
tahrj-8728	93	118	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	93	119	responsibility	responsibility	NOUN
tahrj-8728	93	120	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	93	121	that	that	DET
tahrj-8728	93	122	state	state	NOUN
tahrj-8728	93	123	under	under	ADP
tahrj-8728	93	124	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	93	125	convention	convention	NOUN
tahrj-8728	93	126	where	where	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	93	127	substantial	substantial	ADJ
tahrj-8728	93	128	grounds	ground	NOUN
tahrj-8728	93	129	have	have	AUX
tahrj-8728	93	130	been	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	93	131	shown	show	VERB
tahrj-8728	93	132	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	93	133	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	93	134	person	person	NOUN
tahrj-8728	93	135	concerned	concern	VERB
tahrj-8728	93	136	faced	face	VERB
tahrj-8728	93	137	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	93	138	real	real	ADJ
tahrj-8728	93	139	risk	risk	NOUN
tahrj-8728	93	140	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	93	141	being	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	93	142	subjected	subject	VERB
tahrj-8728	93	143	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	93	144	torture	torture	NOUN
tahrj-8728	93	145	or	or	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	93	146	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	93	147	inhuman	inhuman	ADJ
tahrj-8728	93	148	or	or	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	93	149	degrading	degrading	ADJ
tahrj-8728	93	150	treatment	treatment	NOUN
tahrj-8728	93	151	or	or	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	93	152	punishment	punishment	NOUN
tahrj-8728	93	153	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	93	154	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	93	155	country	country	NOUN
tahrj-8728	93	156	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	93	157	which	which	PRON
tahrj-8728	93	158	he	he	PRON
tahrj-8728	93	159	returned	return	VERB
tahrj-8728	93	160	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	94	1	further	far	ADV
tahrj-8728	94	2	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	94	3	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	94	4	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	94	5	first	first	ADJ
tahrj-8728	94	6	deportation	deportation	NOUN
tahrj-8728	94	7	case	case	NOUN
tahrj-8728	94	8	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	94	9	chahal	chahal	NOUN
tahrj-8728	94	10	v.	v.	ADP
tahrj-8728	94	11	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	94	12	united	united	PROPN
tahrj-8728	94	13	kingdom	kingdom	PROPN
tahrj-8728	94	14	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	94	15	1996	1996	NUM
tahrj-8728	94	16	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	94	17	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	94	18	british	british	ADJ
tahrj-8728	94	19	government	government	NOUN
tahrj-8728	94	20	claimed	claim	VERB
tahrj-8728	94	21	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	94	22	art	art	NOUN
tahrj-8728	94	23	3	3	NUM
tahrj-8728	94	24	allows	allow	VERB
tahrj-8728	94	25	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	94	26	state	state	NOUN
tahrj-8728	94	27	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	94	28	expel	expel	VERB
tahrj-8728	94	29	an	an	DET
tahrj-8728	94	30	alien	alien	NOUN
tahrj-8728	94	31	if	if	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	94	32	such	such	ADJ
tahrj-8728	94	33	removal	removal	NOUN
tahrj-8728	94	34	was	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	94	35	required	require	VERB
tahrj-8728	94	36	on	on	ADP
tahrj-8728	94	37	national	national	ADJ
tahrj-8728	94	38	security	security	NOUN
tahrj-8728	94	39	grounds	ground	NOUN
tahrj-8728	94	40	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	95	1	this	this	PRON
tahrj-8728	95	2	needs	need	VERB
tahrj-8728	95	3	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	95	4	be	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	95	5	balanced	balance	VERB
tahrj-8728	95	6	with	with	ADP
tahrj-8728	95	7	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	95	8	non	non	ADJ
tahrj-8728	95	9	-	-	ADJ
tahrj-8728	95	10	refoulement	refoulement	ADJ
tahrj-8728	95	11	obligations	obligation	NOUN
tahrj-8728	95	12	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	96	1	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	96	2	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	96	3	rejected	reject	VERB
tahrj-8728	96	4	this	this	DET
tahrj-8728	96	5	reasoning	reasoning	NOUN
tahrj-8728	96	6	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	96	7	stated	state	VERB
tahrj-8728	96	8	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	96	9	art	art	NOUN
tahrj-8728	96	10	3	3	NUM
tahrj-8728	96	11	was	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	96	12	an	an	DET
tahrj-8728	96	13	absolute	absolute	ADJ
tahrj-8728	96	14	right	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	96	15	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	97	1	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	97	2	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	97	3	context	context	NOUN
tahrj-8728	97	4	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	97	5	balance	balance	NOUN
tahrj-8728	97	6	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	97	7	ecthr	ecthr	PROPN
tahrj-8728	97	8	stated	state	VERB
tahrj-8728	97	9	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	97	10	‘	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	97	11	art	art	NOUN
tahrj-8728	97	12	3	3	NUM
tahrj-8728	97	13	makes	make	VERB
tahrj-8728	97	14	no	no	DET
tahrj-8728	97	15	exceptions	exception	NOUN
tahrj-8728	97	16	even	even	ADV
tahrj-8728	97	17	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	97	18	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	97	19	event	event	NOUN
tahrj-8728	97	20	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	97	21	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	97	22	public	public	ADJ
tahrj-8728	97	23	emergency	emergency	NOUN
tahrj-8728	97	24	threatening	threaten	VERB
tahrj-8728	97	25	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	97	26	life	life	NOUN
tahrj-8728	97	27	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	97	28	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	97	29	nation	nation	NOUN
tahrj-8728	97	30	’	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	97	31	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	98	1	moreover	moreover	ADV
tahrj-8728	98	2	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	98	3	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	98	4	saadi	saadi	PROPN
tahrj-8728	98	5	v.	v.	PROPN
tahrj-8728	98	6	italy	italy	PROPN
tahrj-8728	98	7	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	98	8	2008	2008	NUM
tahrj-8728	98	9	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	98	10	ecthr	ecthr	PROPN
tahrj-8728	98	11	concluded	conclude	VERB
tahrj-8728	98	12	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	98	13	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	98	14	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	98	15	concepts	concept	NOUN
tahrj-8728	98	16	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	98	17	risk	risk	NOUN
tahrj-8728	98	18	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	98	19	dangerousness	dangerousness	NOUN
tahrj-8728	98	20	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	98	21	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	98	22	context	context	NOUN
tahrj-8728	98	23	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	98	24	refugees	refugee	NOUN
tahrj-8728	98	25	do	do	AUX
tahrj-8728	98	26	not	not	PART
tahrj-8728	98	27	lend	lend	VERB
tahrj-8728	98	28	themselves	themselves	PRON
tahrj-8728	98	29	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	98	30	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	98	31	balancing	balancing	NOUN
tahrj-8728	98	32	test	test	NOUN
tahrj-8728	98	33	because	because	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	98	34	they	they	PRON
tahrj-8728	98	35	are	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	98	36	notions	notion	NOUN
tahrj-8728	98	37	needing	need	VERB
tahrj-8728	98	38	independent	independent	ADJ
tahrj-8728	98	39	assessment	assessment	NOUN
tahrj-8728	98	40	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	99	1	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	99	2	prospect	prospect	NOUN
tahrj-8728	99	3	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	99	4	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	99	5	person	person	NOUN
tahrj-8728	99	6	may	may	AUX
tahrj-8728	99	7	pose	pose	VERB
tahrj-8728	99	8	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	99	9	serious	serious	ADJ
tahrj-8728	99	10	threat	threat	NOUN
tahrj-8728	99	11	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	99	12	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	99	13	community	community	NOUN
tahrj-8728	99	14	if	if	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	99	15	not	not	PART
tahrj-8728	99	16	returned	return	VERB
tahrj-8728	99	17	does	do	AUX
tahrj-8728	99	18	not	not	PART
tahrj-8728	99	19	reduce	reduce	VERB
tahrj-8728	99	20	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	99	21	degree	degree	NOUN
tahrj-8728	99	22	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	99	23	risk	risk	NOUN
tahrj-8728	99	24	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	99	25	ill	ill	ADJ
tahrj-8728	99	26	-	-	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	99	27	treatment	treatment	NOUN
tahrj-8728	99	28	that	that	PRON
tahrj-8728	99	29	he	he	PRON
tahrj-8728	99	30	or	or	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	99	31	she	she	PRON
tahrj-8728	99	32	may	may	AUX
tahrj-8728	99	33	face	face	VERB
tahrj-8728	99	34	after	after	ADP
tahrj-8728	99	35	returning	return	VERB
tahrj-8728	99	36	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	100	1	for	for	ADP
tahrj-8728	100	2	this	this	DET
tahrj-8728	100	3	reason	reason	NOUN
tahrj-8728	100	4	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	100	5	it	it	PRON
tahrj-8728	100	6	would	would	AUX
tahrj-8728	100	7	be	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	100	8	incorrect	incorrect	ADJ
tahrj-8728	100	9	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	100	10	require	require	VERB
tahrj-8728	100	11	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	100	12	higher	high	ADJ
tahrj-8728	100	13	standard	standard	NOUN
tahrj-8728	100	14	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	100	15	proof	proof	NOUN
tahrj-8728	100	16	where	where	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	100	17	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	100	18	person	person	NOUN
tahrj-8728	100	19	is	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	100	20	considered	consider	VERB
tahrj-8728	100	21	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	100	22	represent	represent	VERB
tahrj-8728	100	23	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	100	24	danger	danger	NOUN
tahrj-8728	100	25	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	100	26	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	100	27	community	community	NOUN
tahrj-8728	100	28	since	since	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	100	29	assessment	assessment	NOUN
tahrj-8728	100	30	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	100	31	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	100	32	level	level	NOUN
tahrj-8728	100	33	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	100	34	risk	risk	NOUN
tahrj-8728	100	35	is	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	100	36	independent	independent	ADJ
tahrj-8728	100	37	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	100	38	such	such	DET
tahrj-8728	100	39	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	100	40	test	test	NOUN
tahrj-8728	100	41	…	…	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	100	42	’	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	100	43	however	however	ADV
tahrj-8728	100	44	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	100	45	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	100	46	r	r	NOUN
tahrj-8728	100	47	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	100	48	wellington	wellington	PROPN
tahrj-8728	100	49	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	100	50	v.	v.	PROPN
tahrj-8728	100	51	secretary	secretary	PROPN
tahrj-8728	100	52	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	100	53	state	state	NOUN
tahrj-8728	100	54	for	for	ADP
tahrj-8728	100	55	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	100	56	home	home	NOUN
tahrj-8728	100	57	department	department	PROPN
tahrj-8728	100	58	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	100	59	2008	2008	NUM
tahrj-8728	100	60	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	100	61	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	100	62	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	100	63	accepted	accept	VERB
tahrj-8728	100	64	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	100	65	application	application	NOUN
tahrj-8728	100	66	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	100	67	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	100	68	‘	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	100	69	minimum	minimum	ADJ
tahrj-8728	100	70	level	level	NOUN
tahrj-8728	100	71	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	100	72	severity	severity	NOUN
tahrj-8728	100	73	’	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	100	74	test	test	NOUN
tahrj-8728	100	75	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	101	1	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	101	2	this	this	PRON
tahrj-8728	101	3	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	101	4	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	101	5	uk	uk	PROPN
tahrj-8728	101	6	government	government	NOUN
tahrj-8728	101	7	requested	request	VERB
tahrj-8728	101	8	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	101	9	balance	balance	VERB
tahrj-8728	101	10	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	101	11	severity	severity	NOUN
tahrj-8728	101	12	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	101	13	ill	ill	ADJ
tahrj-8728	101	14	-	-	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	101	15	treatment	treatment	NOUN
tahrj-8728	101	16	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	101	17	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	101	18	person	person	NOUN
tahrj-8728	101	19	returned	return	VERB
tahrj-8728	101	20	with	with	ADP
tahrj-8728	101	21	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	101	22	danger	danger	NOUN
tahrj-8728	101	23	it	it	PRON
tahrj-8728	101	24	posed	pose	VERB
tahrj-8728	101	25	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	101	26	society	society	NOUN
tahrj-8728	101	27	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	102	1	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	102	2	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	102	3	stated	state	VERB
tahrj-8728	102	4	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	102	5	these	these	DET
tahrj-8728	102	6	notions	notion	NOUN
tahrj-8728	102	7	be	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	102	8	assessed	assess	VERB
tahrj-8728	102	9	independently	independently	ADV
tahrj-8728	102	10	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	102	11	however	however	ADV
tahrj-8728	102	12	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	102	13	it	it	PRON
tahrj-8728	102	14	is	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	102	15	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	102	16	be	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	102	17	assessed	assess	VERB
tahrj-8728	102	18	if	if	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	102	19	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	102	20	‘	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	102	21	minimum	minimum	ADJ
tahrj-8728	102	22	level	level	NOUN
tahrj-8728	102	23	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	102	24	severity	severity	NOUN
tahrj-8728	102	25	’	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	102	26	has	have	AUX
tahrj-8728	102	27	been	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	102	28	met	meet	VERB
tahrj-8728	102	29	for	for	ADP
tahrj-8728	102	30	art	art	NOUN
tahrj-8728	102	31	3	3	NUM
tahrj-8728	102	32	purposes	purpose	NOUN
tahrj-8728	102	33	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	103	1	lord	lord	PROPN
tahrj-8728	103	2	scott	scott	PROPN
tahrj-8728	103	3	states	state	VERB
tahrj-8728	103	4	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	103	5	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	103	6	majority	majority	NOUN
tahrj-8728	103	7	view	view	NOUN
tahrj-8728	103	8	implied	imply	VERB
tahrj-8728	103	9	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	103	10	‘	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	103	11	relativist	relativist	ADJ
tahrj-8728	103	12	approach	approach	NOUN
tahrj-8728	103	13	’	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	103	14	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	103	15	art	art	NOUN
tahrj-8728	103	16	3	3	NUM
tahrj-8728	103	17	whereby	whereby	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	103	18	it	it	PRON
tahrj-8728	103	19	suggested	suggest	VERB
tahrj-8728	103	20	inhuman	inhuman	ADJ
tahrj-8728	103	21	or	or	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	103	22	degrading	degrading	ADJ
tahrj-8728	103	23	treatment	treatment	NOUN
tahrj-8728	103	24	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	103	25	europe	europe	PROPN
tahrj-8728	103	26	might	might	AUX
tahrj-8728	103	27	not	not	PART
tahrj-8728	103	28	be	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	103	29	so	so	ADV
tahrj-8728	103	30	categorized	categorize	VERB
tahrj-8728	103	31	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	103	32	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	103	33	receiving	receive	VERB
tahrj-8728	103	34	country	country	NOUN
tahrj-8728	103	35	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	103	36	natasa	natasa	NOUN
tahrj-8728	103	37	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	103	38	francesco	francesco	PROPN
tahrj-8728	103	39	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	103	40	2013	2013	NUM
tahrj-8728	103	41	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	103	42	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	104	1	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	104	2	absolute	absolute	ADJ
tahrj-8728	104	3	nature	nature	NOUN
tahrj-8728	104	4	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	104	5	art	art	NOUN
tahrj-8728	104	6	3	3	NUM
tahrj-8728	104	7	was	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	104	8	now	now	ADV
tahrj-8728	104	9	based	base	VERB
tahrj-8728	104	10	only	only	ADV
tahrj-8728	104	11	on	on	ADP
tahrj-8728	104	12	torture	torture	NOUN
tahrj-8728	104	13	implying	imply	VERB
tahrj-8728	104	14	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	104	15	what	what	PRON
tahrj-8728	104	16	is	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	104	17	torture	torture	NOUN
tahrj-8728	104	18	for	for	ADP
tahrj-8728	104	19	art	art	NOUN
tahrj-8728	104	20	3	3	NUM
tahrj-8728	104	21	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	104	22	europe	europe	PROPN
tahrj-8728	104	23	is	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	104	24	torture	torture	NOUN
tahrj-8728	104	25	everywhere	everywhere	ADV
tahrj-8728	104	26	else	else	ADV
tahrj-8728	104	27	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	105	1	but	but	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	105	2	not	not	PART
tahrj-8728	105	3	inhuman	inhuman	ADJ
tahrj-8728	105	4	or	or	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	105	5	degrading	degrading	ADJ
tahrj-8728	105	6	treatment	treatment	NOUN
tahrj-8728	105	7	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	106	1	this	this	PRON
tahrj-8728	106	2	means	mean	VERB
tahrj-8728	106	3	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	106	4	after	after	ADP
tahrj-8728	106	5	balancing	balance	VERB
tahrj-8728	106	6	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	106	7	inhuman	inhuman	ADJ
tahrj-8728	106	8	or	or	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	106	9	degrading	degrading	ADJ
tahrj-8728	106	10	treatment	treatment	NOUN
tahrj-8728	106	11	with	with	ADP
tahrj-8728	106	12	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	106	13	danger	danger	NOUN
tahrj-8728	106	14	posed	pose	VERB
tahrj-8728	106	15	by	by	ADP
tahrj-8728	106	16	him	he	PRON
tahrj-8728	106	17	or	or	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	106	18	her	she	PRON
tahrj-8728	106	19	if	if	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	106	20	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	106	21	inhuman	inhuman	ADJ
tahrj-8728	106	22	or	or	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	106	23	degrading	degrading	ADJ
tahrj-8728	106	24	treatment	treatment	NOUN
tahrj-8728	106	25	is	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	106	26	not	not	PART
tahrj-8728	106	27	severe	severe	ADJ
tahrj-8728	106	28	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	106	29	he	he	PRON
tahrj-8728	106	30	may	may	AUX
tahrj-8728	106	31	be	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	106	32	removed	remove	VERB
tahrj-8728	106	33	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	107	1	similarly	similarly	ADV
tahrj-8728	107	2	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	107	3	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	107	4	socialist	socialist	ADJ
tahrj-8728	107	5	party	party	NOUN
tahrj-8728	107	6	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	107	7	others	other	NOUN
tahrj-8728	107	8	v.	v.	ADP
tahrj-8728	107	9	turkey	turkey	PROPN
tahrj-8728	107	10	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	107	11	1998	1998	NUM
tahrj-8728	107	12	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	107	13	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	107	14	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	107	15	said	say	VERB
tahrj-8728	107	16	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	107	17	considering	consider	VERB
tahrj-8728	107	18	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	107	19	national	national	ADJ
tahrj-8728	107	20	security	security	NOUN
tahrj-8728	107	21	exception	exception	NOUN
tahrj-8728	107	22	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	107	23	non	non	ADJ
tahrj-8728	107	24	-	-	ADJ
tahrj-8728	107	25	refoulement	refoulement	ADJ
tahrj-8728	107	26	obligations	obligation	NOUN
tahrj-8728	107	27	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	107	28	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	107	29	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	107	30	should	should	AUX
tahrj-8728	107	31	carry	carry	VERB
tahrj-8728	107	32	out	out	ADP
tahrj-8728	107	33	scrutiny	scrutiny	NOUN
tahrj-8728	107	34	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	108	1	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	108	2	task	task	NOUN
tahrj-8728	108	3	is	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	108	4	not	not	PART
tahrj-8728	108	5	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	108	6	substitute	substitute	VERB
tahrj-8728	108	7	its	its	PRON
tahrj-8728	108	8	view	view	NOUN
tahrj-8728	108	9	for	for	ADP
tahrj-8728	108	10	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	108	11	relevant	relevant	ADJ
tahrj-8728	108	12	national	national	ADJ
tahrj-8728	108	13	authority	authority	NOUN
tahrj-8728	108	14	but	but	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	108	15	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	108	16	review	review	VERB
tahrj-8728	108	17	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	108	18	decision	decision	NOUN
tahrj-8728	108	19	delivered	deliver	VERB
tahrj-8728	108	20	by	by	ADP
tahrj-8728	108	21	them	they	PRON
tahrj-8728	108	22	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	109	1	such	such	DET
tahrj-8728	109	2	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	109	3	review	review	NOUN
tahrj-8728	109	4	should	should	AUX
tahrj-8728	109	5	satisfy	satisfy	VERB
tahrj-8728	109	6	those	those	DET
tahrj-8728	109	7	national	national	ADJ
tahrj-8728	109	8	authorities	authority	NOUN
tahrj-8728	109	9	who	who	PRON
tahrj-8728	109	10	made	make	VERB
tahrj-8728	109	11	such	such	DET
tahrj-8728	109	12	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	109	13	decision	decision	NOUN
tahrj-8728	109	14	after	after	ADP
tahrj-8728	109	15	an	an	DET
tahrj-8728	109	16	acceptable	acceptable	ADJ
tahrj-8728	109	17	assessment	assessment	NOUN
tahrj-8728	109	18	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	109	19	relevant	relevant	ADJ
tahrj-8728	109	20	factors	factor	NOUN
tahrj-8728	109	21	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	110	1	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	110	2	babar	babar	PROPN
tahrj-8728	110	3	ahmad	ahmad	PROPN
tahrj-8728	110	4	v	v	ADP
tahrj-8728	110	5	uk	uk	PROPN
tahrj-8728	110	6	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	110	7	2012	2012	NUM
tahrj-8728	110	8	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	110	9	ecthr	ecthr	PROPN
tahrj-8728	110	10	agreed	agree	VERB
tahrj-8728	110	11	with	with	ADP
tahrj-8728	110	12	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	110	13	wellington	wellington	PROPN
tahrj-8728	110	14	rationale	rationale	NOUN
tahrj-8728	110	15	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	111	1	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	111	2	this	this	DET
tahrj-8728	111	3	case	case	NOUN
tahrj-8728	111	4	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	111	5	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	111	6	applicants	applicant	NOUN
tahrj-8728	111	7	claimed	claim	VERB
tahrj-8728	111	8	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	111	9	on	on	ADP
tahrj-8728	111	10	account	account	NOUN
tahrj-8728	111	11	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	111	12	being	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	111	13	extradited	extradite	VERB
tahrj-8728	111	14	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	111	15	there	there	PRON
tahrj-8728	111	16	is	be	VERB
tahrj-8728	111	17	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	111	18	prospect	prospect	NOUN
tahrj-8728	111	19	for	for	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	111	20	them	they	PRON
tahrj-8728	111	21	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	111	22	be	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	111	23	imprisoned	imprison	VERB
tahrj-8728	111	24	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	111	25	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	111	26	‘	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	111	27	supermax	supermax	ADJ
tahrj-8728	111	28	’	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	111	29	security	security	NOUN
tahrj-8728	111	30	prison	prison	NOUN
tahrj-8728	111	31	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	111	32	colorado	colorado	PROPN
tahrj-8728	111	33	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	112	1	also	also	ADV
tahrj-8728	112	2	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	112	3	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	112	4	conditions	condition	NOUN
tahrj-8728	112	5	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	112	6	detention	detention	NOUN
tahrj-8728	112	7	would	would	AUX
tahrj-8728	112	8	breach	breach	VERB
tahrj-8728	112	9	art	art	NOUN
tahrj-8728	112	10	3	3	NUM
tahrj-8728	112	11	due	due	ADP
tahrj-8728	112	12	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	112	13	prolonged	prolonged	ADJ
tahrj-8728	112	14	periods	period	NOUN
tahrj-8728	112	15	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	112	16	‘	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	112	17	solitary	solitary	ADJ
tahrj-8728	112	18	confinement	confinement	NOUN
tahrj-8728	112	19	’	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	112	20	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	112	21	babar	babar	PROPN
tahrj-8728	112	22	https://doi.org/10.17561/tahrj.v23.8728	https://doi.org/10.17561/tahrj.v23.8728	PROPN
tahrj-8728	112	23	sabreen	sabreen	PROPN
tahrj-8728	112	24	ahmed	ahme	VERB
tahrj-8728	112	25	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	112	26	age	age	NOUN
tahrj-8728	112	27	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	112	28	human	human	ADJ
tahrj-8728	112	29	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	112	30	journal	journal	NOUN
tahrj-8728	112	31	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	112	32	24	24	NUM
tahrj-8728	112	33	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	112	34	june	june	PROPN
tahrj-8728	112	35	2025	2025	NUM
tahrj-8728	112	36	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	112	37	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	112	38	e8728	e8728	PROPN
tahrj-8728	112	39	issn	issn	PROPN
tahrj-8728	112	40	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	112	41	2340	2340	NUM
tahrj-8728	112	42	-	-	SYM
tahrj-8728	112	43	9592	9592	NUM
tahrj-8728	112	44	doi	doi	NOUN
tahrj-8728	112	45	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	112	46	10.17561	10.17561	NUM
tahrj-8728	112	47	/	/	SYM
tahrj-8728	112	48	tahrj.v23.8728	tahrj.v23.8728	PROPN
tahrj-8728	112	49	7	7	NUM
tahrj-8728	112	50	ahmed	ahmed	PROPN
tahrj-8728	112	51	v	v	PROPN
tahrj-8728	112	52	uk	uk	PROPN
tahrj-8728	112	53	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	112	54	2012	2012	NUM
tahrj-8728	112	55	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	112	56	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	113	1	they	they	PRON
tahrj-8728	113	2	also	also	ADV
tahrj-8728	113	3	argued	argue	VERB
tahrj-8728	113	4	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	113	5	if	if	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	113	6	they	they	PRON
tahrj-8728	113	7	were	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	113	8	convicted	convict	VERB
tahrj-8728	113	9	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	113	10	they	they	PRON
tahrj-8728	113	11	would	would	AUX
tahrj-8728	113	12	face	face	VERB
tahrj-8728	113	13	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	113	14	mandatory	mandatory	ADJ
tahrj-8728	113	15	sentence	sentence	NOUN
tahrj-8728	113	16	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	113	17	life	life	NOUN
tahrj-8728	113	18	imprisonment	imprisonment	NOUN
tahrj-8728	113	19	without	without	ADP
tahrj-8728	113	20	any	any	DET
tahrj-8728	113	21	possibility	possibility	NOUN
tahrj-8728	113	22	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	113	23	parole	parole	NOUN
tahrj-8728	113	24	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	114	1	they	they	PRON
tahrj-8728	114	2	argued	argue	VERB
tahrj-8728	114	3	this	this	PRON
tahrj-8728	114	4	was	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	114	5	disproportionate	disproportionate	ADJ
tahrj-8728	114	6	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	114	7	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	114	8	offences	offence	NOUN
tahrj-8728	114	9	they	they	PRON
tahrj-8728	114	10	were	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	114	11	accused	accuse	VERB
tahrj-8728	114	12	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	114	13	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	115	1	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	115	2	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	115	3	held	hold	VERB
tahrj-8728	115	4	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	115	5	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	115	6	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	115	7	absolute	absolute	ADJ
tahrj-8728	115	8	nature	nature	NOUN
tahrj-8728	115	9	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	115	10	art	art	NOUN
tahrj-8728	115	11	3	3	NUM
tahrj-8728	115	12	does	do	AUX
tahrj-8728	115	13	not	not	PART
tahrj-8728	115	14	bar	bar	VERB
tahrj-8728	115	15	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	115	16	removal	removal	NOUN
tahrj-8728	115	17	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	115	18	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	115	19	person	person	NOUN
tahrj-8728	115	20	if	if	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	115	21	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	115	22	act	act	NOUN
tahrj-8728	115	23	or	or	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	115	24	omission	omission	NOUN
tahrj-8728	115	25	does	do	AUX
tahrj-8728	115	26	not	not	PART
tahrj-8728	115	27	fulfil	fulfil	VERB
tahrj-8728	115	28	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	115	29	‘	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	115	30	minimum	minimum	ADJ
tahrj-8728	115	31	level	level	NOUN
tahrj-8728	115	32	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	115	33	severity	severity	NOUN
tahrj-8728	115	34	test	test	NOUN
tahrj-8728	115	35	’	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	115	36	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	116	1	nevertheless	nevertheless	ADV
tahrj-8728	116	2	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	116	3	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	116	4	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	116	5	absence	absence	NOUN
tahrj-8728	116	6	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	116	7	an	an	DET
tahrj-8728	116	8	exception	exception	NOUN
tahrj-8728	116	9	clause	clause	NOUN
tahrj-8728	116	10	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	116	11	art	art	NOUN
tahrj-8728	116	12	3	3	NUM
tahrj-8728	116	13	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	116	14	ecthr	ecthr	PROPN
tahrj-8728	116	15	jurisprudence	jurisprudence	NOUN
tahrj-8728	116	16	also	also	ADV
tahrj-8728	116	17	does	do	AUX
tahrj-8728	116	18	not	not	PART
tahrj-8728	116	19	encapsulate	encapsulate	VERB
tahrj-8728	116	20	how	how	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	116	21	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	116	22	analysis	analysis	NOUN
tahrj-8728	116	23	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	116	24	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	116	25	context	context	NOUN
tahrj-8728	116	26	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	116	27	‘	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	116	28	minimum	minimum	ADJ
tahrj-8728	116	29	level	level	NOUN
tahrj-8728	116	30	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	116	31	severity	severity	NOUN
tahrj-8728	116	32	’	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	116	33	would	would	AUX
tahrj-8728	116	34	apply	apply	VERB
tahrj-8728	116	35	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	116	36	case	case	NOUN
tahrj-8728	116	37	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	116	38	national	national	ADJ
tahrj-8728	116	39	security	security	NOUN
tahrj-8728	116	40	concerns	concern	NOUN
tahrj-8728	116	41	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	117	1	it	it	PRON
tahrj-8728	117	2	has	have	AUX
tahrj-8728	117	3	been	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	117	4	left	leave	VERB
tahrj-8728	117	5	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	117	6	be	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	117	7	determined	determine	VERB
tahrj-8728	117	8	on	on	ADP
tahrj-8728	117	9	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	117	10	case	case	NOUN
tahrj-8728	117	11	-	-	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	117	12	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	117	13	-	-	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	117	14	case	case	NOUN
tahrj-8728	117	15	basis	basis	NOUN
tahrj-8728	117	16	which	which	PRON
tahrj-8728	117	17	is	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	117	18	more	more	ADV
tahrj-8728	117	19	theoretical	theoretical	ADJ
tahrj-8728	117	20	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	117	21	illusory	illusory	ADJ
tahrj-8728	117	22	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	117	23	unless	unless	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	117	24	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	117	25	grand	grand	PROPN
tahrj-8728	117	26	chamber	chamber	NOUN
tahrj-8728	117	27	sets	set	VERB
tahrj-8728	117	28	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	117	29	record	record	NOUN
tahrj-8728	117	30	straight	straight	ADJ
tahrj-8728	117	31	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	117	32	mamatkulov	mamatkulov	NOUN
tahrj-8728	117	33	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	117	34	askar	askar	PROPN
tahrj-8728	117	35	v	v	PROPN
tahrj-8728	117	36	turkey	turkey	NOUN
tahrj-8728	117	37	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	117	38	2005	2005	NUM
tahrj-8728	117	39	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	117	40	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	118	1	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	118	2	case	case	NOUN
tahrj-8728	118	3	-	-	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	118	4	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	118	5	-	-	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	118	6	case	case	NOUN
tahrj-8728	118	7	-	-	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	118	8	based	base	VERB
tahrj-8728	118	9	analysis	analysis	NOUN
tahrj-8728	118	10	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	118	11	non	non	ADJ
tahrj-8728	118	12	-	-	ADJ
tahrj-8728	118	13	refoulement	refoulement	ADJ
tahrj-8728	118	14	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	118	15	parallel	parallel	ADJ
tahrj-8728	118	16	balancing	balancing	NOUN
tahrj-8728	118	17	mechanisms	mechanism	NOUN
tahrj-8728	118	18	complicates	complicate	VERB
tahrj-8728	118	19	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	118	20	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	118	21	’s	’s	PART
tahrj-8728	118	22	jurisprudence	jurisprudence	NOUN
tahrj-8728	118	23	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	118	24	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	118	25	extent	extent	NOUN
tahrj-8728	118	26	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	118	27	no	no	DET
tahrj-8728	118	28	practical	practical	ADJ
tahrj-8728	118	29	trend	trend	NOUN
tahrj-8728	118	30	seems	seem	VERB
tahrj-8728	118	31	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	118	32	emerge	emerge	VERB
tahrj-8728	118	33	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	119	1	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	119	2	hirsi	hirsi	PROPN
tahrj-8728	119	3	jamaa	jamaa	NOUN
tahrj-8728	119	4	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	119	5	others	other	NOUN
tahrj-8728	119	6	v.	v.	ADP
tahrj-8728	119	7	italy	italy	PROPN
tahrj-8728	119	8	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	119	9	2012	2012	NUM
tahrj-8728	119	10	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	119	11	for	for	ADP
tahrj-8728	119	12	example	example	NOUN
tahrj-8728	119	13	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	119	14	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	119	15	violations	violation	NOUN
tahrj-8728	119	16	alleged	allege	VERB
tahrj-8728	119	17	against	against	ADP
tahrj-8728	119	18	italy	italy	PROPN
tahrj-8728	119	19	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	119	20	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	119	21	case	case	NOUN
tahrj-8728	119	22	were	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	119	23	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	119	24	on	on	ADP
tahrj-8728	119	25	may	may	PROPN
tahrj-8728	119	26	6	6	NUM
tahrj-8728	119	27	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	119	28	2009	2009	NUM
tahrj-8728	119	29	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	119	30	three	three	NUM
tahrj-8728	119	31	boats	boat	NOUN
tahrj-8728	119	32	were	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	119	33	intercepted	intercept	VERB
tahrj-8728	119	34	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	119	35	international	international	ADJ
tahrj-8728	119	36	waters	water	NOUN
tahrj-8728	119	37	bound	bind	VERB
tahrj-8728	119	38	for	for	ADP
tahrj-8728	119	39	italy	italy	PROPN
tahrj-8728	119	40	with	with	ADP
tahrj-8728	119	41	about	about	ADV
tahrj-8728	119	42	200	200	NUM
tahrj-8728	119	43	people	people	NOUN
tahrj-8728	119	44	on	on	ADP
tahrj-8728	119	45	board	board	NOUN
tahrj-8728	119	46	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	120	1	once	once	ADV
tahrj-8728	120	2	rescued	rescue	VERB
tahrj-8728	120	3	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	120	4	migrants	migrant	NOUN
tahrj-8728	120	5	were	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	120	6	forcibly	forcibly	ADV
tahrj-8728	120	7	handed	hand	VERB
tahrj-8728	120	8	over	over	ADP
tahrj-8728	120	9	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	120	10	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	120	11	libyan	libyan	ADJ
tahrj-8728	120	12	authorities	authority	NOUN
tahrj-8728	120	13	as	as	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	120	14	required	require	VERB
tahrj-8728	120	15	by	by	ADP
tahrj-8728	120	16	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	120	17	bilateral	bilateral	ADJ
tahrj-8728	120	18	agreement	agreement	NOUN
tahrj-8728	120	19	between	between	ADP
tahrj-8728	120	20	italy	italy	PROPN
tahrj-8728	120	21	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	120	22	libya	libya	PROPN
tahrj-8728	120	23	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	120	24	february	february	PROPN
tahrj-8728	120	25	2009	2009	NUM
tahrj-8728	120	26	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	121	1	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	121	2	appeal	appeal	NOUN
tahrj-8728	121	3	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	121	4	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	121	5	ecthr	ecthr	NOUN
tahrj-8728	121	6	was	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	121	7	filed	file	VERB
tahrj-8728	121	8	by	by	ADP
tahrj-8728	121	9	11	11	NUM
tahrj-8728	121	10	somalis	somalis	PROPN
tahrj-8728	121	11	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	121	12	13	13	NUM
tahrj-8728	121	13	eritreans	eritreans	PROPN
tahrj-8728	121	14	who	who	PRON
tahrj-8728	121	15	were	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	121	16	present	present	ADJ
tahrj-8728	121	17	on	on	ADP
tahrj-8728	121	18	board	board	NOUN
tahrj-8728	121	19	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	121	20	who	who	PRON
tahrj-8728	121	21	accused	accuse	VERB
tahrj-8728	121	22	italy	italy	PROPN
tahrj-8728	121	23	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	121	24	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	121	25	violation	violation	NOUN
tahrj-8728	121	26	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	121	27	various	various	ADJ
tahrj-8728	121	28	provisions	provision	NOUN
tahrj-8728	121	29	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	121	30	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	121	31	echr	echr	NOUN
tahrj-8728	121	32	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	121	33	but	but	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	121	34	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	121	35	most	most	ADV
tahrj-8728	121	36	serious	serious	ADJ
tahrj-8728	121	37	concerning	concern	VERB
tahrj-8728	121	38	articles	article	NOUN
tahrj-8728	121	39	3	3	NUM
tahrj-8728	121	40	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	121	41	4	4	NUM
tahrj-8728	121	42	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	121	43	additional	additional	ADJ
tahrj-8728	121	44	protocol	protocol	NOUN
tahrj-8728	121	45	no	no	INTJ
tahrj-8728	121	46	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	122	1	411	411	NUM
tahrj-8728	122	2	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	122	3	see	see	INTJ
tahrj-8728	122	4	scovazzi	scovazzi	NOUN
tahrj-8728	122	5	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	122	6	2016	2016	NUM
tahrj-8728	122	7	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	122	8	p.	p.	NOUN
tahrj-8728	122	9	74	74	NUM
tahrj-8728	122	10	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	122	11	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	122	12	combination	combination	NOUN
tahrj-8728	122	13	with	with	ADP
tahrj-8728	122	14	article	article	NOUN
tahrj-8728	122	15	13	13	NUM
tahrj-8728	122	16	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	123	1	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	123	2	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	123	3	while	while	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	123	4	allowing	allow	VERB
tahrj-8728	123	5	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	123	6	appeal	appeal	NOUN
tahrj-8728	123	7	relatively	relatively	ADV
tahrj-8728	123	8	extended	extend	VERB
tahrj-8728	123	9	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	123	10	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NOUN
tahrj-8728	123	11	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	123	12	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	123	13	intervening	intervene	VERB
tahrj-8728	123	14	state	state	NOUN
tahrj-8728	123	15	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	123	16	so	so	ADV
tahrj-8728	123	17	far	far	ADV
tahrj-8728	123	18	as	as	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	123	19	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	123	20	echr	echr	PROPN
tahrj-8728	123	21	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	123	22	were	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	123	23	concerned	concern	VERB
tahrj-8728	123	24	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	123	25	also	also	ADV
tahrj-8728	123	26	protect	protect	VERB
tahrj-8728	123	27	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	123	28	ensure	ensure	VERB
tahrj-8728	123	29	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	123	30	obligations	obligation	NOUN
tahrj-8728	123	31	towards	towards	ADP
tahrj-8728	123	32	migrants	migrant	NOUN
tahrj-8728	123	33	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	123	34	international	international	ADJ
tahrj-8728	123	35	waters	water	NOUN
tahrj-8728	123	36	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	124	1	if	if	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	124	2	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	124	3	state	state	NOUN
tahrj-8728	124	4	authorities	authority	NOUN
tahrj-8728	124	5	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	124	6	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	124	7	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	124	8	exercise	exercise	NOUN
tahrj-8728	124	9	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	124	10	their	their	PRON
tahrj-8728	124	11	powers	power	NOUN
tahrj-8728	124	12	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	124	13	act	act	VERB
tahrj-8728	124	14	imperiously	imperiously	ADV
tahrj-8728	124	15	towards	towards	ADP
tahrj-8728	124	16	people	people	NOUN
tahrj-8728	124	17	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	124	18	gill	gill	PROPN
tahrj-8728	124	19	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	124	20	1998	1998	NUM
tahrj-8728	124	21	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	124	22	p.	p.	NOUN
tahrj-8728	124	23	167	167	NUM
tahrj-8728	124	24	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	124	25	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	124	26	prevent	prevent	VERB
tahrj-8728	124	27	migrants	migrant	NOUN
tahrj-8728	124	28	from	from	ADP
tahrj-8728	124	29	reaching	reach	VERB
tahrj-8728	124	30	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	124	31	borders	border	NOUN
tahrj-8728	124	32	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	124	33	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	124	34	state	state	NOUN
tahrj-8728	124	35	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	124	36	this	this	PRON
tahrj-8728	124	37	constitutes	constitute	VERB
tahrj-8728	124	38	an	an	DET
tahrj-8728	124	39	exercise	exercise	NOUN
tahrj-8728	124	40	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	124	41	state	state	NOUN
tahrj-8728	124	42	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NOUN
tahrj-8728	124	43	as	as	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	124	44	provided	provide	VERB
tahrj-8728	124	45	for	for	ADP
tahrj-8728	124	46	by	by	ADP
tahrj-8728	124	47	article	article	NOUN
tahrj-8728	124	48	1	1	NUM
tahrj-8728	124	49	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	124	50	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	124	51	convention	convention	NOUN
tahrj-8728	124	52	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	124	53	therefore	therefore	ADV
tahrj-8728	124	54	makes	make	VERB
tahrj-8728	124	55	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	124	56	state	state	NOUN
tahrj-8728	124	57	responsible	responsible	ADJ
tahrj-8728	124	58	for	for	ADP
tahrj-8728	124	59	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	124	60	violation	violation	NOUN
tahrj-8728	124	61	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	124	62	article	article	NOUN
tahrj-8728	124	63	4	4	NUM
tahrj-8728	124	64	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	124	65	protocol	protocol	NOUN
tahrj-8728	125	1	no	no	INTJ
tahrj-8728	125	2	.	.	NOUN
tahrj-8728	125	3	4	4	NUM
tahrj-8728	125	4	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	125	5	hirsi	hirsi	NOUN
tahrj-8728	125	6	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	125	7	2012	2012	NUM
tahrj-8728	125	8	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	125	9	para	para	NOUN
tahrj-8728	125	10	.	.	PROPN
tahrj-8728	125	11	180	180	NUM
tahrj-8728	125	12	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	125	13	similarly	similarly	ADV
tahrj-8728	125	14	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	125	15	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	125	16	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	125	17	also	also	ADV
tahrj-8728	125	18	recognized	recognize	VERB
tahrj-8728	125	19	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	125	20	potential	potential	ADJ
tahrj-8728	125	21	risks	risk	NOUN
tahrj-8728	125	22	faced	face	VERB
tahrj-8728	125	23	by	by	ADP
tahrj-8728	125	24	migrants	migrant	NOUN
tahrj-8728	125	25	who	who	PRON
tahrj-8728	125	26	would	would	AUX
tahrj-8728	125	27	be	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	125	28	subjected	subject	VERB
tahrj-8728	125	29	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	125	30	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	125	31	treatments	treatment	NOUN
tahrj-8728	125	32	prohibited	prohibit	VERB
tahrj-8728	125	33	by	by	ADP
tahrj-8728	125	34	article	article	NOUN
tahrj-8728	125	35	3	3	NUM
tahrj-8728	125	36	by	by	ADP
tahrj-8728	125	37	libyan	libyan	ADJ
tahrj-8728	125	38	authorities	authority	NOUN
tahrj-8728	125	39	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	125	40	as	as	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	125	41	they	they	PRON
tahrj-8728	125	42	would	would	AUX
tahrj-8728	125	43	enter	enter	VERB
tahrj-8728	125	44	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	125	45	libyan	libyan	ADJ
tahrj-8728	125	46	territory	territory	NOUN
tahrj-8728	125	47	illegally	illegally	ADV
tahrj-8728	125	48	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	125	49	bearing	bear	VERB
tahrj-8728	125	50	no	no	DET
tahrj-8728	125	51	practical	practical	ADJ
tahrj-8728	125	52	difference	difference	NOUN
tahrj-8728	125	53	from	from	ADP
tahrj-8728	125	54	already	already	ADV
tahrj-8728	125	55	present	present	ADJ
tahrj-8728	125	56	illegal	illegal	ADJ
tahrj-8728	125	57	migrants	migrant	NOUN
tahrj-8728	125	58	there	there	ADV
tahrj-8728	125	59	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	126	1	against	against	ADP
tahrj-8728	126	2	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	126	3	backdrop	backdrop	NOUN
tahrj-8728	126	4	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	126	5	this	this	DET
tahrj-8728	126	6	rationale	rationale	NOUN
tahrj-8728	126	7	stands	stand	VERB
tahrj-8728	126	8	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	126	9	contentious	contentious	ADJ
tahrj-8728	126	10	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	126	11	highly	highly	ADV
tahrj-8728	126	12	debated	debated	ADJ
tahrj-8728	126	13	ruling	ruling	NOUN
tahrj-8728	126	14	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	126	15	ecthr	ecthr	PROPN
tahrj-8728	126	16	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	126	17	n.d	n.d	PROPN
tahrj-8728	126	18	.	.	PROPN
tahrj-8728	126	19	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	126	20	n.t	n.t	PROPN
tahrj-8728	126	21	.	.	PROPN
tahrj-8728	127	1	v.	v.	PROPN
tahrj-8728	127	2	spain	spain	PROPN
tahrj-8728	127	3	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	127	4	2020	2020	NUM
tahrj-8728	127	5	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	128	1	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	128	2	which	which	PRON
tahrj-8728	128	3	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	128	4	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	128	5	stressed	stress	VERB
tahrj-8728	128	6	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	128	7	importance	importance	NOUN
tahrj-8728	128	8	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	128	9	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	128	10	state	state	NOUN
tahrj-8728	128	11	's	's	PART
tahrj-8728	128	12	role	role	NOUN
tahrj-8728	128	13	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	128	14	protecting	protect	VERB
tahrj-8728	128	15	external	external	ADJ
tahrj-8728	128	16	borders	border	NOUN
tahrj-8728	128	17	while	while	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	128	18	rejecting	reject	VERB
tahrj-8728	128	19	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	128	20	decision	decision	NOUN
tahrj-8728	128	21	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	128	22	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	128	23	chamber	chamber	NOUN
tahrj-8728	128	24	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	128	25	echr	echr	PROPN
tahrj-8728	128	26	holding	hold	VERB
tahrj-8728	128	27	that	that	PRON
tahrj-8728	128	28	spain	spain	PROPN
tahrj-8728	128	29	carried	carry	VERB
tahrj-8728	128	30	out	out	ADP
tahrj-8728	128	31	collective	collective	ADJ
tahrj-8728	128	32	rejections	rejection	NOUN
tahrj-8728	128	33	without	without	ADP
tahrj-8728	128	34	considering	consider	VERB
tahrj-8728	128	35	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	128	36	personal	personal	ADJ
tahrj-8728	128	37	circumstances	circumstance	NOUN
tahrj-8728	128	38	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	128	39	each	each	PRON
tahrj-8728	128	40	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	128	41	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	128	42	migrants	migrant	NOUN
tahrj-8728	128	43	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	128	44	without	without	ADP
tahrj-8728	128	45	resorting	resort	VERB
tahrj-8728	128	46	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	128	47	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	128	48	decision	decision	NOUN
tahrj-8728	128	49	-	-	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	128	50	making	make	VERB
tahrj-8728	128	51	https://doi.org/10.17561/tahrj.v23.8728	https://doi.org/10.17561/tahrj.v23.8728	NOUN
tahrj-8728	128	52	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	128	53	analysis	analysis	NOUN
tahrj-8728	128	54	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	128	55	non	non	ADJ
tahrj-8728	128	56	-	-	ADJ
tahrj-8728	128	57	refoulement	refoulement	ADJ
tahrj-8728	128	58	jurisprudence	jurisprudence	NOUN
tahrj-8728	128	59	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	128	60	india	india	PROPN
tahrj-8728	128	61	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	128	62	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	128	63	comparative	comparative	ADJ
tahrj-8728	128	64	approach	approach	NOUN
tahrj-8728	128	65	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	128	66	age	age	NOUN
tahrj-8728	128	67	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	128	68	human	human	ADJ
tahrj-8728	128	69	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	128	70	journal	journal	NOUN
tahrj-8728	128	71	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	128	72	24	24	NUM
tahrj-8728	128	73	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	128	74	june	june	PROPN
tahrj-8728	128	75	2025	2025	NUM
tahrj-8728	128	76	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	128	77	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	128	78	e8728	e8728	PROPN
tahrj-8728	128	79	issn	issn	PROPN
tahrj-8728	128	80	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	128	81	2340	2340	NUM
tahrj-8728	128	82	-	-	SYM
tahrj-8728	128	83	9592	9592	NUM
tahrj-8728	128	84	doi	doi	NOUN
tahrj-8728	128	85	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	128	86	10.17561	10.17561	NUM
tahrj-8728	128	87	/	/	SYM
tahrj-8728	128	88	tahrj.v23.8728	tahrj.v23.8728	PROPN
tahrj-8728	128	89	8	8	NUM
tahrj-8728	128	90	process	process	NOUN
tahrj-8728	128	91	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	128	92	n.d	n.d	PROPN
tahrj-8728	128	93	.	.	PROPN
tahrj-8728	128	94	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	128	95	n.t	n.t	PROPN
tahrj-8728	128	96	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	128	97	2020	2020	NUM
tahrj-8728	128	98	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	128	99	para	para	NOUN
tahrj-8728	128	100	.	.	PROPN
tahrj-8728	128	101	124	124	NUM
tahrj-8728	128	102	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	128	103	negating	negate	VERB
tahrj-8728	128	104	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	128	105	declaration	declaration	NOUN
tahrj-8728	128	106	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	128	107	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	128	108	chamber	chamber	NOUN
tahrj-8728	128	109	that	that	PRON
tahrj-8728	128	110	such	such	ADJ
tahrj-8728	128	111	process	process	NOUN
tahrj-8728	128	112	stands	stand	VERB
tahrj-8728	128	113	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	128	114	violation	violation	NOUN
tahrj-8728	128	115	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	128	116	article	article	NOUN
tahrj-8728	128	117	4	4	NUM
tahrj-8728	128	118	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	128	119	protocol	protocol	NOUN
tahrj-8728	129	1	no	no	INTJ
tahrj-8728	129	2	.	.	NOUN
tahrj-8728	129	3	4	4	NUM
tahrj-8728	129	4	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	129	5	article	article	NOUN
tahrj-8728	129	6	13	13	NUM
tahrj-8728	129	7	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	129	8	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	129	9	echr	echr	PROPN
tahrj-8728	129	10	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	130	1	both	both	DET
tahrj-8728	130	2	courts	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	130	3	rejected	reject	VERB
tahrj-8728	130	4	arguments	argument	NOUN
tahrj-8728	130	5	made	make	VERB
tahrj-8728	130	6	towards	towards	ADP
tahrj-8728	130	7	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	130	8	violations	violation	NOUN
tahrj-8728	130	9	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	130	10	article	article	NOUN
tahrj-8728	130	11	3	3	NUM
tahrj-8728	130	12	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	130	13	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	130	14	echr	echr	PROPN
tahrj-8728	130	15	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	131	1	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	131	2	grand	grand	PROPN
tahrj-8728	131	3	chamber	chamber	PROPN
tahrj-8728	131	4	even	even	ADV
tahrj-8728	131	5	went	go	VERB
tahrj-8728	131	6	on	on	ADP
tahrj-8728	131	7	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	131	8	note	note	VERB
tahrj-8728	131	9	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	131	10	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	131	11	refoulement	refoulement	NOUN
tahrj-8728	131	12	was	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	131	13	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	131	14	consequence	consequence	NOUN
tahrj-8728	131	15	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	131	16	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	131	17	applicants	applicant	NOUN
tahrj-8728	131	18	’	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	131	19	“	"	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	131	20	own	own	ADJ
tahrj-8728	131	21	conduct	conduct	NOUN
tahrj-8728	131	22	”	"	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	131	23	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	131	24	n.d	n.d	PROPN
tahrj-8728	131	25	.	.	PROPN
tahrj-8728	131	26	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	131	27	n.t	n.t	PROPN
tahrj-8728	131	28	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	131	29	2020	2020	NUM
tahrj-8728	131	30	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	131	31	para	para	NOUN
tahrj-8728	131	32	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	131	33	242	242	NUM
tahrj-8728	131	34	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	131	35	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	132	1	this	this	PRON
tahrj-8728	132	2	garnered	garner	VERB
tahrj-8728	132	3	specific	specific	ADJ
tahrj-8728	132	4	criticism	criticism	NOUN
tahrj-8728	132	5	from	from	ADP
tahrj-8728	132	6	scholars	scholar	NOUN
tahrj-8728	132	7	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	132	8	refugee	refugee	NOUN
tahrj-8728	132	9	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	132	10	advocates	advocate	NOUN
tahrj-8728	132	11	as	as	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	132	12	individual	individual	ADJ
tahrj-8728	132	13	situations	situation	NOUN
tahrj-8728	132	14	were	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	132	15	not	not	PART
tahrj-8728	132	16	comprehensively	comprehensively	ADV
tahrj-8728	132	17	assessed	assess	VERB
tahrj-8728	132	18	nor	nor	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	132	19	accessibility	accessibility	NOUN
tahrj-8728	132	20	limitations	limitation	NOUN
tahrj-8728	132	21	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	132	22	asylum	asylum	NOUN
tahrj-8728	132	23	procedures	procedure	NOUN
tahrj-8728	132	24	were	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	132	25	analysed	analyse	VERB
tahrj-8728	132	26	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	132	27	leading	lead	VERB
tahrj-8728	132	28	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	132	29	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	132	30	horrible	horrible	ADJ
tahrj-8728	132	31	precedent	precedent	NOUN
tahrj-8728	132	32	justifying	justify	VERB
tahrj-8728	132	33	collective	collective	ADJ
tahrj-8728	132	34	expulsions	expulsion	NOUN
tahrj-8728	132	35	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	133	1	so	so	ADV
tahrj-8728	133	2	far	far	ADV
tahrj-8728	133	3	it	it	PRON
tahrj-8728	133	4	can	can	AUX
tahrj-8728	133	5	be	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	133	6	concluded	conclude	VERB
tahrj-8728	133	7	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	133	8	ecthr	ecthr	PROPN
tahrj-8728	133	9	has	have	AUX
tahrj-8728	133	10	earlier	early	ADV
tahrj-8728	133	11	set	set	VERB
tahrj-8728	133	12	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	133	13	‘	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	133	14	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	133	15	test	test	NOUN
tahrj-8728	133	16	’	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	133	17	only	only	ADV
tahrj-8728	133	18	for	for	ADP
tahrj-8728	133	19	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	133	20	qualified	qualified	ADJ
tahrj-8728	133	21	right	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	133	22	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	133	23	has	have	AUX
tahrj-8728	133	24	agreed	agree	VERB
tahrj-8728	133	25	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	133	26	absolute	absolute	ADJ
tahrj-8728	133	27	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	133	28	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	133	29	art	art	NOUN
tahrj-8728	133	30	3	3	NUM
tahrj-8728	133	31	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	133	32	are	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	133	33	neither	neither	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	133	34	subject	subject	ADJ
tahrj-8728	133	35	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	133	36	any	any	DET
tahrj-8728	133	37	exceptions	exception	NOUN
tahrj-8728	133	38	or	or	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	133	39	balancing	balancing	NOUN
tahrj-8728	133	40	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	134	1	however	however	ADV
tahrj-8728	134	2	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	134	3	ambiguity	ambiguity	NOUN
tahrj-8728	134	4	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	134	5	standards	standard	NOUN
tahrj-8728	134	6	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	134	7	various	various	ADJ
tahrj-8728	134	8	cases	case	NOUN
tahrj-8728	134	9	suggests	suggest	VERB
tahrj-8728	134	10	no	no	DET
tahrj-8728	134	11	conclusive	conclusive	ADJ
tahrj-8728	134	12	pattern	pattern	NOUN
tahrj-8728	134	13	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	135	1	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	135	2	newfound	newfound	ADJ
tahrj-8728	135	3	limb	limb	NOUN
tahrj-8728	135	4	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	135	5	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	135	6	‘	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	135	7	minimum	minimum	ADJ
tahrj-8728	135	8	severity	severity	NOUN
tahrj-8728	135	9	test	test	NOUN
tahrj-8728	135	10	’	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	135	11	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	135	12	non	non	ADJ
tahrj-8728	135	13	-	-	ADJ
tahrj-8728	135	14	refoulement	refoulement	ADJ
tahrj-8728	135	15	cases	case	NOUN
tahrj-8728	135	16	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	135	17	not	not	PART
tahrj-8728	135	18	only	only	ADV
tahrj-8728	135	19	defeats	defeat	VERB
tahrj-8728	135	20	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	135	21	point	point	NOUN
tahrj-8728	135	22	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	135	23	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	135	24	absolute	absolute	ADJ
tahrj-8728	135	25	nature	nature	NOUN
tahrj-8728	135	26	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	135	27	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	135	28	right	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	135	29	under	under	ADP
tahrj-8728	135	30	art	art	NOUN
tahrj-8728	135	31	3	3	NUM
tahrj-8728	135	32	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	135	33	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	135	34	echr	echr	PROPN
tahrj-8728	135	35	but	but	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	135	36	also	also	ADV
tahrj-8728	135	37	creates	create	VERB
tahrj-8728	135	38	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	135	39	confusing	confusing	ADJ
tahrj-8728	135	40	balancing	balancing	NOUN
tahrj-8728	135	41	mechanism	mechanism	NOUN
tahrj-8728	135	42	for	for	ADP
tahrj-8728	135	43	non	non	ADJ
tahrj-8728	135	44	-	-	ADJ
tahrj-8728	135	45	refoulement	refoulement	ADJ
tahrj-8728	135	46	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	135	47	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	136	1	1.3	1.3	NUM
tahrj-8728	136	2	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	137	1	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	137	2	analysis	analysis	NOUN
tahrj-8728	137	3	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	137	4	the	the	PRON
tahrj-8728	137	5	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	137	6	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	137	7	inter	inter	ADJ
tahrj-8728	137	8	-	-	ADJ
tahrj-8728	137	9	american	american	ADJ
tahrj-8728	137	10	human	human	ADJ
tahrj-8728	137	11	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	137	12	system	system	NOUN
tahrj-8728	137	13	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	137	14	iahrs	iahrs	NOUN
tahrj-8728	137	15	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	137	16	before	before	ADP
tahrj-8728	137	17	delving	delve	VERB
tahrj-8728	137	18	into	into	ADP
tahrj-8728	137	19	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	137	20	african	african	ADJ
tahrj-8728	137	21	stance	stance	NOUN
tahrj-8728	137	22	on	on	ADP
tahrj-8728	137	23	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	137	24	analysis	analysis	NOUN
tahrj-8728	137	25	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	137	26	brief	brief	ADJ
tahrj-8728	137	27	reference	reference	NOUN
tahrj-8728	137	28	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	137	29	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	137	30	affirmative	affirmative	ADJ
tahrj-8728	137	31	practice	practice	NOUN
tahrj-8728	137	32	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	137	33	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	137	34	doctrine	doctrine	NOUN
tahrj-8728	137	35	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	137	36	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	137	37	inter	inter	ADJ
tahrj-8728	137	38	-	-	ADJ
tahrj-8728	137	39	american	american	ADJ
tahrj-8728	137	40	human	human	ADJ
tahrj-8728	137	41	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	137	42	system	system	NOUN
tahrj-8728	137	43	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	137	44	iahrs	iahrs	NOUN
tahrj-8728	137	45	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	137	46	especially	especially	ADV
tahrj-8728	137	47	through	through	ADP
tahrj-8728	137	48	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	137	49	inter	inter	ADJ
tahrj-8728	137	50	-	-	ADJ
tahrj-8728	137	51	american	american	ADJ
tahrj-8728	137	52	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	137	53	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	137	54	human	human	ADJ
tahrj-8728	137	55	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	137	56	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	137	57	iacthr	iacthr	PROPN
tahrj-8728	137	58	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	137	59	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	137	60	inter	inter	ADJ
tahrj-8728	137	61	-	-	ADJ
tahrj-8728	137	62	american	american	ADJ
tahrj-8728	137	63	commission	commission	NOUN
tahrj-8728	137	64	on	on	ADP
tahrj-8728	137	65	human	human	ADJ
tahrj-8728	137	66	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	137	67	should	should	AUX
tahrj-8728	137	68	be	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	137	69	made	make	VERB
tahrj-8728	137	70	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	138	1	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	138	2	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	138	3	while	while	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	138	4	interpreting	interpret	VERB
tahrj-8728	138	5	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	138	6	applying	apply	VERB
tahrj-8728	138	7	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	138	8	principles	principle	NOUN
tahrj-8728	138	9	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	138	10	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	138	11	american	american	ADJ
tahrj-8728	138	12	convention	convention	PROPN
tahrj-8728	138	13	on	on	ADP
tahrj-8728	138	14	human	human	ADJ
tahrj-8728	138	15	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	138	16	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	138	17	1969	1969	NUM
tahrj-8728	138	18	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	138	19	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	138	20	achr	achr	NOUN
tahrj-8728	138	21	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	138	22	also	also	ADV
tahrj-8728	138	23	employs	employ	VERB
tahrj-8728	138	24	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	138	25	‘	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	138	26	balancing	balance	VERB
tahrj-8728	138	27	test	test	NOUN
tahrj-8728	138	28	’	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	138	29	defined	define	VERB
tahrj-8728	138	30	as	as	ADP
tahrj-8728	138	31	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	138	32	means	means	NOUN
tahrj-8728	138	33	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	138	34	weighing	weigh	VERB
tahrj-8728	138	35	competing	compete	VERB
tahrj-8728	138	36	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	138	37	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	138	38	interests	interest	NOUN
tahrj-8728	138	39	against	against	ADP
tahrj-8728	138	40	one	one	NUM
tahrj-8728	138	41	another	another	DET
tahrj-8728	138	42	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	138	43	which	which	PRON
tahrj-8728	138	44	can	can	AUX
tahrj-8728	138	45	also	also	ADV
tahrj-8728	138	46	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	138	47	some	some	DET
tahrj-8728	138	48	readings	reading	NOUN
tahrj-8728	138	49	be	be	VERB
tahrj-8728	138	50	an	an	DET
tahrj-8728	138	51	opportunity	opportunity	NOUN
tahrj-8728	138	52	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	138	53	incorporate	incorporate	VERB
tahrj-8728	138	54	local	local	ADJ
tahrj-8728	138	55	circumstances	circumstance	NOUN
tahrj-8728	138	56	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	138	57	subsidiarity	subsidiarity	NOUN
tahrj-8728	138	58	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	138	59	sagüés	sagüés	NOUN
tahrj-8728	138	60	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	138	61	2013	2013	NUM
tahrj-8728	138	62	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	138	63	p.	p.	NOUN
tahrj-8728	138	64	9	9	NUM
tahrj-8728	138	65	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	138	66	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	139	1	although	although	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	139	2	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	139	3	test	test	NOUN
tahrj-8728	139	4	is	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	139	5	heavily	heavily	ADV
tahrj-8728	139	6	contextual	contextual	ADJ
tahrj-8728	139	7	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	139	8	i.e.	i.e.	X
tahrj-8728	139	9	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	139	10	case	case	NOUN
tahrj-8728	139	11	-	-	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	139	12	by	by	ADP
tahrj-8728	139	13	-	-	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	139	14	case	case	NOUN
tahrj-8728	139	15	based	base	VERB
tahrj-8728	139	16	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	139	17	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	139	18	no	no	DET
tahrj-8728	139	19	thread	thread	NOUN
tahrj-8728	139	20	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	139	21	standard	standard	ADJ
tahrj-8728	139	22	practice	practice	NOUN
tahrj-8728	139	23	exists	exist	VERB
tahrj-8728	139	24	as	as	ADP
tahrj-8728	139	25	such	such	ADJ
tahrj-8728	139	26	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	140	1	similarly	similarly	ADV
tahrj-8728	140	2	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	140	3	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	140	4	test	test	NOUN
tahrj-8728	140	5	remains	remain	VERB
tahrj-8728	140	6	very	very	ADV
tahrj-8728	140	7	limited	limited	ADJ
tahrj-8728	140	8	given	give	VERB
tahrj-8728	140	9	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	140	10	gross	gross	ADJ
tahrj-8728	140	11	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	140	12	systematic	systematic	ADJ
tahrj-8728	140	13	human	human	ADJ
tahrj-8728	140	14	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	140	15	context	context	NOUN
tahrj-8728	140	16	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	140	17	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	140	18	cases	case	NOUN
tahrj-8728	140	19	that	that	PRON
tahrj-8728	140	20	are	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	140	21	usually	usually	ADV
tahrj-8728	140	22	dealt	deal	VERB
tahrj-8728	140	23	with	with	ADP
tahrj-8728	140	24	by	by	ADP
tahrj-8728	140	25	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	140	26	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	140	27	within	within	ADP
tahrj-8728	140	28	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	140	29	convention	convention	NOUN
tahrj-8728	140	30	for	for	ADP
tahrj-8728	140	31	example	example	NOUN
tahrj-8728	140	32	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	140	33	violations	violation	NOUN
tahrj-8728	140	34	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	140	35	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	140	36	such	such	ADJ
tahrj-8728	140	37	as	as	ADP
tahrj-8728	140	38	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	140	39	right	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	140	40	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	140	41	life	life	NOUN
tahrj-8728	140	42	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	140	43	art	art	NOUN
tahrj-8728	140	44	4	4	NUM
tahrj-8728	140	45	achr	achr	NOUN
tahrj-8728	140	46	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	140	47	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	140	48	physical	physical	ADJ
tahrj-8728	140	49	integrity	integrity	NOUN
tahrj-8728	140	50	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	140	51	art	art	NOUN
tahrj-8728	140	52	5	5	NUM
tahrj-8728	140	53	achr	achr	NOUN
tahrj-8728	140	54	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	140	55	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	140	56	judicial	judicial	ADJ
tahrj-8728	140	57	guarantees	guarantee	NOUN
tahrj-8728	140	58	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	140	59	arts	art	NOUN
tahrj-8728	140	60	8.1	8.1	NUM
tahrj-8728	140	61	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	140	62	25	25	NUM
tahrj-8728	140	63	achr	achr	NOUN
tahrj-8728	140	64	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	140	65	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	140	66	lixinski	lixinski	ADJ
tahrj-8728	140	67	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	140	68	2019	2019	NUM
tahrj-8728	140	69	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	140	70	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	141	1	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	141	2	absolute	absolute	ADJ
tahrj-8728	141	3	nature	nature	NOUN
tahrj-8728	141	4	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	141	5	such	such	ADJ
tahrj-8728	141	6	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	141	7	eliminates	eliminate	VERB
tahrj-8728	141	8	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	141	9	exercising	exercising	NOUN
tahrj-8728	141	10	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	141	11	balancing	balancing	NOUN
tahrj-8728	141	12	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	141	13	but	but	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	141	14	non	non	ADJ
tahrj-8728	141	15	-	-	ADJ
tahrj-8728	141	16	absolute	absolute	ADJ
tahrj-8728	141	17	convention	convention	NOUN
tahrj-8728	141	18	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	141	19	are	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	141	20	subject	subject	ADJ
tahrj-8728	141	21	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	141	22	scrutiny	scrutiny	NOUN
tahrj-8728	141	23	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	141	24	due	due	ADJ
tahrj-8728	141	25	process	process	NOUN
tahrj-8728	141	26	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	141	27	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	141	28	analyses	analysis	NOUN
tahrj-8728	141	29	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	142	1	this	this	PRON
tahrj-8728	142	2	is	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	142	3	also	also	ADV
tahrj-8728	142	4	explicitly	explicitly	ADV
tahrj-8728	142	5	enshrined	enshrine	VERB
tahrj-8728	142	6	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	142	7	article	article	NOUN
tahrj-8728	142	8	30	30	NUM
tahrj-8728	142	9	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	142	10	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	142	11	convention	convention	NOUN
tahrj-8728	142	12	which	which	PRON
tahrj-8728	142	13	states	state	VERB
tahrj-8728	142	14	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	142	15	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	142	16	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	142	17	restrictions	restriction	NOUN
tahrj-8728	142	18	that	that	PRON
tahrj-8728	142	19	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	142	20	pursuant	pursuant	ADJ
tahrj-8728	142	21	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	142	22	this	this	DET
tahrj-8728	142	23	convention	convention	NOUN
tahrj-8728	142	24	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	142	25	may	may	AUX
tahrj-8728	142	26	be	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	142	27	placed	place	VERB
tahrj-8728	142	28	on	on	ADP
tahrj-8728	142	29	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	142	30	enjoyment	enjoyment	NOUN
tahrj-8728	142	31	or	or	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	142	32	exercise	exercise	NOUN
tahrj-8728	142	33	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	142	34	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	142	35	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	142	36	or	or	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	142	37	freedoms	freedom	NOUN
tahrj-8728	142	38	recognized	recognize	VERB
tahrj-8728	142	39	herein	herein	NOUN
tahrj-8728	142	40	may	may	AUX
tahrj-8728	142	41	not	not	PART
tahrj-8728	142	42	be	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	142	43	applied	apply	VERB
tahrj-8728	142	44	except	except	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	142	45	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	142	46	accordance	accordance	NOUN
tahrj-8728	142	47	with	with	ADP
tahrj-8728	142	48	laws	law	NOUN
tahrj-8728	142	49	enacted	enact	VERB
tahrj-8728	142	50	for	for	ADP
tahrj-8728	142	51	reasons	reason	NOUN
tahrj-8728	142	52	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	142	53	general	general	ADJ
tahrj-8728	142	54	interest	interest	NOUN
tahrj-8728	142	55	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	142	56	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	142	57	accordance	accordance	NOUN
tahrj-8728	142	58	with	with	ADP
tahrj-8728	142	59	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	142	60	purpose	purpose	NOUN
tahrj-8728	142	61	for	for	ADP
tahrj-8728	142	62	which	which	PRON
tahrj-8728	142	63	such	such	ADJ
tahrj-8728	142	64	restrictions	restriction	NOUN
tahrj-8728	142	65	have	have	AUX
tahrj-8728	142	66	been	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	142	67	established	establish	VERB
tahrj-8728	142	68	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	143	1	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	143	2	usón	usón	ADJ
tahrj-8728	143	3	ramírez	ramírez	PROPN
tahrj-8728	143	4	v	v	ADP
tahrj-8728	143	5	venezuela	venezuela	PROPN
tahrj-8728	143	6	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	143	7	2009	2009	NUM
tahrj-8728	143	8	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	143	9	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	143	10	iacthr	iacthr	NOUN
tahrj-8728	143	11	noted	note	VERB
tahrj-8728	143	12	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	143	13	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	143	14	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	143	15	restriction	restriction	NOUN
tahrj-8728	143	16	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	143	17	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	143	18	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	143	19	case	case	NOUN
tahrj-8728	143	20	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	143	21	restriction	restriction	NOUN
tahrj-8728	143	22	on	on	ADP
tahrj-8728	143	23	effective	effective	ADJ
tahrj-8728	143	24	exercise	exercise	NOUN
tahrj-8728	143	25	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	143	26	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	143	27	right	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	143	28	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	143	29	freedom	freedom	NOUN
tahrj-8728	143	30	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	143	31	expression	expression	NOUN
tahrj-8728	143	32	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	143	33	shall	shall	AUX
tahrj-8728	143	34	be	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	143	35	https://doi.org/10.17561/tahrj.v23.8728	https://doi.org/10.17561/tahrj.v23.8728	PROPN
tahrj-8728	143	36	sabreen	sabreen	PROPN
tahrj-8728	143	37	ahmed	ahme	VERB
tahrj-8728	143	38	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	143	39	age	age	NOUN
tahrj-8728	143	40	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	143	41	human	human	ADJ
tahrj-8728	143	42	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	143	43	journal	journal	NOUN
tahrj-8728	143	44	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	143	45	24	24	NUM
tahrj-8728	143	46	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	143	47	june	june	PROPN
tahrj-8728	143	48	2025	2025	NUM
tahrj-8728	143	49	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	143	50	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	143	51	e8728	e8728	PROPN
tahrj-8728	143	52	issn	issn	PROPN
tahrj-8728	143	53	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	143	54	2340	2340	NUM
tahrj-8728	143	55	-	-	SYM
tahrj-8728	143	56	9592	9592	NUM
tahrj-8728	143	57	doi	doi	NOUN
tahrj-8728	143	58	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	143	59	10.17561	10.17561	NUM
tahrj-8728	143	60	/	/	SYM
tahrj-8728	143	61	tahrj.v23.8728	tahrj.v23.8728	PROPN
tahrj-8728	143	62	9	9	NUM
tahrj-8728	143	63	proportional	proportional	NOUN
tahrj-8728	143	64	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	143	65	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	143	66	interest	interest	NOUN
tahrj-8728	143	67	that	that	PRON
tahrj-8728	143	68	justifies	justify	VERB
tahrj-8728	143	69	it	it	PRON
tahrj-8728	143	70	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	143	71	shall	shall	AUX
tahrj-8728	143	72	be	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	143	73	closely	closely	ADV
tahrj-8728	143	74	adjusted	adjust	VERB
tahrj-8728	143	75	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	143	76	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	143	77	achievement	achievement	NOUN
tahrj-8728	143	78	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	143	79	such	such	ADJ
tahrj-8728	143	80	legitimate	legitimate	ADJ
tahrj-8728	143	81	objective	objective	NOUN
tahrj-8728	143	82	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	143	83	interfering	interfere	VERB
tahrj-8728	143	84	as	as	ADV
tahrj-8728	143	85	little	little	ADJ
tahrj-8728	143	86	as	as	ADP
tahrj-8728	143	87	possible	possible	ADJ
tahrj-8728	143	88	with	with	ADP
tahrj-8728	143	89	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	143	90	right	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	143	91	at	at	ADP
tahrj-8728	143	92	question	question	NOUN
tahrj-8728	143	93	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	144	1	similarly	similarly	ADV
tahrj-8728	144	2	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	144	3	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	144	4	gomes	gomes	PROPN
tahrj-8728	144	5	lund	lund	PROPN
tahrj-8728	144	6	et	et	PROPN
tahrj-8728	144	7	al	al	PROPN
tahrj-8728	144	8	.	.	PROPN
tahrj-8728	145	1	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	145	2	"	"	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	145	3	guerrilha	guerrilha	NOUN
tahrj-8728	145	4	do	do	AUX
tahrj-8728	145	5	araguaia	araguaia	NOUN
tahrj-8728	145	6	"	"	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	145	7	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	145	8	v	v	PROPN
tahrj-8728	145	9	brazil	brazil	PROPN
tahrj-8728	145	10	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	145	11	2010	2010	NUM
tahrj-8728	145	12	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	145	13	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	145	14	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	145	15	while	while	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	145	16	balancing	balance	VERB
tahrj-8728	145	17	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	145	18	right	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	145	19	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	145	20	access	access	NOUN
tahrj-8728	145	21	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	145	22	justice	justice	NOUN
tahrj-8728	145	23	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	145	24	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	145	25	presumed	presume	VERB
tahrj-8728	145	26	victims	victim	NOUN
tahrj-8728	145	27	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	145	28	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	145	29	human	human	ADJ
tahrj-8728	145	30	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	145	31	violation	violation	NOUN
tahrj-8728	145	32	against	against	ADP
tahrj-8728	145	33	state	state	NOUN
tahrj-8728	145	34	interests	interest	NOUN
tahrj-8728	145	35	noted	note	VERB
tahrj-8728	145	36	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	145	37	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	145	38	applying	apply	VERB
tahrj-8728	145	39	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	145	40	principle	principle	NOUN
tahrj-8728	145	41	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	145	42	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	145	43	[	[	X
tahrj-8728	145	44	principio	principio	X
tahrj-8728	145	45	de	de	PROPN
tahrj-8728	145	46	ponderación	ponderación	PROPN
tahrj-8728	145	47	]	]	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	145	48	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	145	49	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	145	50	state	state	NOUN
tahrj-8728	145	51	has	have	AUX
tahrj-8728	145	52	omitted	omit	VERB
tahrj-8728	145	53	any	any	DET
tahrj-8728	145	54	mention	mention	NOUN
tahrj-8728	145	55	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	145	56	victims	victim	NOUN
tahrj-8728	145	57	'	'	PART
tahrj-8728	145	58	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	145	59	arising	arise	VERB
tahrj-8728	145	60	under	under	ADP
tahrj-8728	145	61	articles	article	NOUN
tahrj-8728	145	62	8	8	NUM
tahrj-8728	145	63	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	145	64	25	25	NUM
tahrj-8728	145	65	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	145	66	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	145	67	american	american	PROPN
tahrj-8728	145	68	convention	convention	PROPN
tahrj-8728	145	69	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	146	1	indeed	indeed	ADV
tahrj-8728	146	2	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	146	3	said	say	VERB
tahrj-8728	146	4	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	146	5	[	[	X
tahrj-8728	146	6	ponderación	ponderación	NOUN
tahrj-8728	146	7	]	]	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	146	8	is	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	146	9	made	make	VERB
tahrj-8728	146	10	between	between	ADP
tahrj-8728	146	11	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	146	12	state	state	NOUN
tahrj-8728	146	13	’s	’s	PART
tahrj-8728	146	14	obligations	obligation	NOUN
tahrj-8728	146	15	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	146	16	respect	respect	VERB
tahrj-8728	146	17	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	146	18	guarantee	guarantee	NOUN
tahrj-8728	146	19	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	146	20	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	146	21	principle	principle	NOUN
tahrj-8728	146	22	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	146	23	legality	legality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	146	24	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	146	25	but	but	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	146	26	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	146	27	right	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	146	28	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	146	29	judicial	judicial	ADJ
tahrj-8728	146	30	guarantees	guarantee	NOUN
tahrj-8728	146	31	[	[	X
tahrj-8728	146	32	fair	fair	ADJ
tahrj-8728	146	33	trial	trial	NOUN
tahrj-8728	146	34	]	]	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	146	35	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	146	36	judicial	judicial	ADJ
tahrj-8728	146	37	protection	protection	NOUN
tahrj-8728	146	38	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	146	39	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	146	40	victims	victim	NOUN
tahrj-8728	146	41	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	146	42	their	their	PRON
tahrj-8728	146	43	next	next	ADJ
tahrj-8728	146	44	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	146	45	kin	kin	PROPN
tahrj-8728	146	46	are	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	146	47	not	not	PART
tahrj-8728	146	48	included	include	VERB
tahrj-8728	146	49	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	146	50	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	146	51	analysis	analysis	NOUN
tahrj-8728	146	52	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	146	53	which	which	PRON
tahrj-8728	146	54	have	have	AUX
tahrj-8728	146	55	been	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	146	56	sacrificed	sacrifice	VERB
tahrj-8728	146	57	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	146	58	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	146	59	most	most	ADV
tahrj-8728	146	60	extreme	extreme	ADJ
tahrj-8728	146	61	way	way	NOUN
tahrj-8728	146	62	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	146	63	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	146	64	present	present	ADJ
tahrj-8728	146	65	case	case	NOUN
tahrj-8728	146	66	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	146	67	gomes	gomes	PROPN
tahrj-8728	146	68	lund	lund	PROPN
tahrj-8728	146	69	et	et	PROPN
tahrj-8728	146	70	al	al	PROPN
tahrj-8728	146	71	.	.	PROPN
tahrj-8728	147	1	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	147	2	"	"	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	147	3	guerrilha	guerrilha	NOUN
tahrj-8728	147	4	do	do	AUX
tahrj-8728	147	5	araguaia	araguaia	NOUN
tahrj-8728	147	6	"	"	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	147	7	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	147	8	v	v	PROPN
tahrj-8728	147	9	brazil	brazil	PROPN
tahrj-8728	147	10	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	147	11	2010	2010	NUM
tahrj-8728	147	12	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	147	13	para	para	NOUN
tahrj-8728	147	14	.	.	PROPN
tahrj-8728	147	15	178	178	NUM
tahrj-8728	147	16	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	147	17	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	148	1	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	148	2	non	non	ADJ
tahrj-8728	148	3	-	-	ADJ
tahrj-8728	148	4	refoulement	refoulement	ADJ
tahrj-8728	148	5	context	context	NOUN
tahrj-8728	148	6	article	article	NOUN
tahrj-8728	148	7	22	22	NUM
tahrj-8728	148	8	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	148	9	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	148	10	achr	achr	NOUN
tahrj-8728	148	11	affirms	affirm	VERB
tahrj-8728	148	12	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	148	13	para	para	NOUN
tahrj-8728	148	14	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	149	1	7	7	NUM
tahrj-8728	149	2	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	149	3	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	149	4	right	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	149	5	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	149	6	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	149	7	person	person	NOUN
tahrj-8728	149	8	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	149	9	seek	seek	VERB
tahrj-8728	149	10	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	149	11	be	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	149	12	granted	grant	VERB
tahrj-8728	149	13	asylum	asylum	NOUN
tahrj-8728	149	14	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	149	15	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	149	16	foreign	foreign	ADJ
tahrj-8728	149	17	territory	territory	NOUN
tahrj-8728	149	18	if	if	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	149	19	she	she	PRON
tahrj-8728	149	20	or	or	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	149	21	he	he	PRON
tahrj-8728	149	22	risks	risk	VERB
tahrj-8728	149	23	persecution	persecution	NOUN
tahrj-8728	149	24	for	for	ADP
tahrj-8728	149	25	political	political	ADJ
tahrj-8728	149	26	offenses	offense	NOUN
tahrj-8728	149	27	or	or	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	149	28	related	relate	VERB
tahrj-8728	149	29	common	common	ADJ
tahrj-8728	149	30	crimes	crime	NOUN
tahrj-8728	149	31	’	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	149	32	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	149	33	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	149	34	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	149	35	para	para	PROPN
tahrj-8728	149	36	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	150	1	8	8	NUM
tahrj-8728	150	2	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	150	3	[	[	X
tahrj-8728	150	4	i]n	i]n	NOUN
tahrj-8728	150	5	no	no	DET
tahrj-8728	150	6	case	case	NOUN
tahrj-8728	150	7	may	may	AUX
tahrj-8728	150	8	an	an	DET
tahrj-8728	150	9	alien	alien	NOUN
tahrj-8728	150	10	be	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	150	11	deported	deport	VERB
tahrj-8728	150	12	or	or	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	150	13	returned	return	VERB
tahrj-8728	150	14	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	150	15	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	150	16	country	country	NOUN
tahrj-8728	150	17	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	150	18	regardless	regardless	ADV
tahrj-8728	150	19	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	150	20	whether	whether	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	150	21	or	or	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	150	22	not	not	PART
tahrj-8728	150	23	it	it	PRON
tahrj-8728	150	24	is	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	150	25	his	his	PRON
tahrj-8728	150	26	country	country	NOUN
tahrj-8728	150	27	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	150	28	origin	origin	NOUN
tahrj-8728	150	29	if	if	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	150	30	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	150	31	that	that	DET
tahrj-8728	150	32	country	country	NOUN
tahrj-8728	150	33	his	his	PRON
tahrj-8728	150	34	right	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	150	35	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	150	36	life	life	NOUN
tahrj-8728	150	37	or	or	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	150	38	personal	personal	ADJ
tahrj-8728	150	39	freedom	freedom	NOUN
tahrj-8728	150	40	is	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	150	41	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	150	42	danger	danger	NOUN
tahrj-8728	150	43	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	150	44	being	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	150	45	violated	violate	VERB
tahrj-8728	150	46	because	because	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	150	47	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	150	48	his	his	PRON
tahrj-8728	150	49	race	race	NOUN
tahrj-8728	150	50	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	150	51	nationality	nationality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	150	52	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	150	53	religion	religion	NOUN
tahrj-8728	150	54	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	150	55	social	social	ADJ
tahrj-8728	150	56	status	status	NOUN
tahrj-8728	150	57	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	150	58	or	or	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	150	59	political	political	ADJ
tahrj-8728	150	60	opinions	opinion	NOUN
tahrj-8728	150	61	”	"	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	150	62	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	151	1	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	151	2	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	151	3	thus	thus	ADV
tahrj-8728	151	4	rely	rely	VERB
tahrj-8728	151	5	on	on	ADP
tahrj-8728	151	6	these	these	DET
tahrj-8728	151	7	provisions	provision	NOUN
tahrj-8728	151	8	along	along	ADP
tahrj-8728	151	9	with	with	ADP
tahrj-8728	151	10	international	international	ADJ
tahrj-8728	151	11	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	151	12	general	general	ADJ
tahrj-8728	151	13	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	151	14	treaty	treaty	NOUN
tahrj-8728	151	15	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	151	16	laws	law	NOUN
tahrj-8728	151	17	such	such	ADJ
tahrj-8728	151	18	as	as	ADP
tahrj-8728	151	19	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	151	20	1951	1951	NUM
tahrj-8728	151	21	convention	convention	NOUN
tahrj-8728	151	22	on	on	ADP
tahrj-8728	151	23	refugees	refugee	NOUN
tahrj-8728	151	24	its	its	PRON
tahrj-8728	151	25	1967	1967	NUM
tahrj-8728	151	26	protocol	protocol	NOUN
tahrj-8728	151	27	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	151	28	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	151	29	1961	1961	NUM
tahrj-8728	151	30	convention	convention	NOUN
tahrj-8728	151	31	relating	relate	VERB
tahrj-8728	151	32	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	151	33	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	151	34	status	status	NOUN
tahrj-8728	151	35	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	151	36	stateless	stateless	NOUN
tahrj-8728	151	37	persons	person	NOUN
tahrj-8728	151	38	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	151	39	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	151	40	convention	convention	NOUN
tahrj-8728	151	41	on	on	ADP
tahrj-8728	151	42	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	151	43	reduction	reduction	NOUN
tahrj-8728	151	44	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	151	45	statelessness	statelessness	NOUN
tahrj-8728	151	46	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	151	47	or	or	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	151	48	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	151	49	1990	1990	NUM
tahrj-8728	151	50	international	international	ADJ
tahrj-8728	151	51	convention	convention	NOUN
tahrj-8728	151	52	on	on	ADP
tahrj-8728	151	53	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	151	54	protection	protection	NOUN
tahrj-8728	151	55	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	151	56	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	151	57	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	151	58	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	151	59	all	all	DET
tahrj-8728	151	60	migrant	migrant	ADJ
tahrj-8728	151	61	workers	worker	NOUN
tahrj-8728	151	62	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	151	63	members	member	NOUN
tahrj-8728	151	64	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	151	65	their	their	PRON
tahrj-8728	151	66	families	family	NOUN
tahrj-8728	151	67	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	151	68	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	151	69	balance	balance	VERB
tahrj-8728	151	70	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	151	71	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	151	72	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	151	73	individuals	individual	NOUN
tahrj-8728	151	74	along	along	ADP
tahrj-8728	151	75	with	with	ADP
tahrj-8728	151	76	state	state	NOUN
tahrj-8728	151	77	interests	interest	NOUN
tahrj-8728	151	78	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	152	1	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	152	2	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	152	3	case	case	NOUN
tahrj-8728	152	4	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	152	5	haitian	haitian	ADJ
tahrj-8728	152	6	interdiction	interdiction	NOUN
tahrj-8728	152	7	–	–	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	152	8	haitian	haitian	ADJ
tahrj-8728	152	9	boat	boat	NOUN
tahrj-8728	152	10	people	people	NOUN
tahrj-8728	152	11	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	152	12	1993	1993	NUM
tahrj-8728	152	13	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	152	14	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	152	15	commission	commission	NOUN
tahrj-8728	152	16	found	find	VERB
tahrj-8728	152	17	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	152	18	united	united	PROPN
tahrj-8728	152	19	states	states	PROPN
tahrj-8728	152	20	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	152	21	violation	violation	NOUN
tahrj-8728	152	22	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	152	23	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	152	24	principle	principle	NOUN
tahrj-8728	152	25	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	152	26	non	non	ADJ
tahrj-8728	152	27	-	-	ADJ
tahrj-8728	152	28	refoulement	refoulement	ADJ
tahrj-8728	152	29	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	152	30	having	having	AUX
tahrj-8728	152	31	based	base	VERB
tahrj-8728	152	32	its	its	PRON
tahrj-8728	152	33	argument	argument	NOUN
tahrj-8728	152	34	on	on	ADP
tahrj-8728	152	35	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	152	36	second	second	ADJ
tahrj-8728	152	37	part	part	NOUN
tahrj-8728	152	38	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	152	39	article	article	NOUN
tahrj-8728	152	40	26	26	NUM
tahrj-8728	152	41	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	152	42	right	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	152	43	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	152	44	asylum	asylum	NOUN
tahrj-8728	152	45	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	152	46	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	152	47	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	152	48	american	american	ADJ
tahrj-8728	152	49	declaration	declaration	PROPN
tahrj-8728	152	50	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	153	1	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	153	2	that	that	DET
tahrj-8728	153	3	sense	sense	NOUN
tahrj-8728	153	4	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	153	5	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	153	6	principle	principle	NOUN
tahrj-8728	153	7	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	153	8	non	non	ADJ
tahrj-8728	153	9	-	-	ADJ
tahrj-8728	153	10	refoulement	refoulement	ADJ
tahrj-8728	153	11	is	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	153	12	not	not	PART
tahrj-8728	153	13	an	an	DET
tahrj-8728	153	14	exclusive	exclusive	ADJ
tahrj-8728	153	15	component	component	NOUN
tahrj-8728	153	16	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	153	17	international	international	ADJ
tahrj-8728	153	18	refugee	refugee	NOUN
tahrj-8728	153	19	protection	protection	NOUN
tahrj-8728	153	20	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	153	21	but	but	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	153	22	serves	serve	VERB
tahrj-8728	153	23	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	153	24	protect	protect	VERB
tahrj-8728	153	25	other	other	ADJ
tahrj-8728	153	26	universal	universal	ADJ
tahrj-8728	153	27	human	human	ADJ
tahrj-8728	153	28	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	153	29	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	153	30	advisory	advisory	ADJ
tahrj-8728	153	31	opinion	opinion	NOUN
tahrj-8728	153	32	oc-25/18	oc-25/18	PROPN
tahrj-8728	153	33	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	153	34	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	153	35	institution	institution	NOUN
tahrj-8728	153	36	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	153	37	asylum	asylum	NOUN
tahrj-8728	153	38	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	153	39	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	153	40	its	its	PRON
tahrj-8728	153	41	recognition	recognition	NOUN
tahrj-8728	153	42	as	as	ADP
tahrj-8728	153	43	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	153	44	human	human	ADJ
tahrj-8728	153	45	right	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	153	46	under	under	ADP
tahrj-8728	153	47	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	153	48	inter	inter	ADJ
tahrj-8728	153	49	-	-	ADJ
tahrj-8728	153	50	american	american	ADJ
tahrj-8728	153	51	system	system	NOUN
tahrj-8728	153	52	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	153	53	protection	protection	NOUN
tahrj-8728	153	54	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	153	55	2018	2018	NUM
tahrj-8728	153	56	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	153	57	para	para	NOUN
tahrj-8728	153	58	.	.	PROPN
tahrj-8728	153	59	180	180	NUM
tahrj-8728	153	60	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	153	61	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	154	1	similarly	similarly	ADV
tahrj-8728	154	2	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	154	3	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	154	4	inter	inter	ADJ
tahrj-8728	154	5	-	-	ADJ
tahrj-8728	154	6	american	american	ADJ
tahrj-8728	154	7	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	154	8	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	154	9	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	154	10	case	case	NOUN
tahrj-8728	154	11	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	154	12	advisory	advisory	ADJ
tahrj-8728	154	13	opinion	opinion	NOUN
tahrj-8728	154	14	oc-21/14	oc-21/14	NOUN
tahrj-8728	154	15	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	154	16	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	154	17	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	154	18	guarantees	guarantee	NOUN
tahrj-8728	154	19	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	154	20	children	child	NOUN
tahrj-8728	154	21	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	154	22	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	154	23	context	context	NOUN
tahrj-8728	154	24	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	154	25	migration	migration	NOUN
tahrj-8728	154	26	and/or	and/or	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	154	27	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	154	28	need	need	NOUN
tahrj-8728	154	29	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	154	30	international	international	ADJ
tahrj-8728	154	31	protection	protection	NOUN
tahrj-8728	154	32	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	154	33	2014	2014	NUM
tahrj-8728	154	34	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	154	35	interpreted	interpret	VERB
tahrj-8728	154	36	article	article	NOUN
tahrj-8728	154	37	22	22	NUM
tahrj-8728	154	38	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	154	39	achr	achr	NOUN
tahrj-8728	154	40	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	154	41	relation	relation	NOUN
tahrj-8728	154	42	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	154	43	other	other	ADJ
tahrj-8728	154	44	convention	convention	NOUN
tahrj-8728	154	45	provisions	provision	NOUN
tahrj-8728	154	46	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	154	47	like	like	ADP
tahrj-8728	154	48	access	access	NOUN
tahrj-8728	154	49	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	154	50	justice	justice	NOUN
tahrj-8728	154	51	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	154	52	due	due	ADJ
tahrj-8728	154	53	process	process	NOUN
tahrj-8728	154	54	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	155	1	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	155	2	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	155	3	established	establish	VERB
tahrj-8728	155	4	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	155	5	‘	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	155	6	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	155	7	flagrant	flagrant	ADJ
tahrj-8728	155	8	violation	violation	NOUN
tahrj-8728	155	9	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	155	10	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	155	11	basic	basic	ADJ
tahrj-8728	155	12	guarantees	guarantee	NOUN
tahrj-8728	155	13	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	155	14	due	due	ADJ
tahrj-8728	155	15	process	process	NOUN
tahrj-8728	155	16	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	155	17	cases	case	NOUN
tahrj-8728	155	18	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	155	19	administrative	administrative	ADJ
tahrj-8728	155	20	proceedings	proceeding	NOUN
tahrj-8728	155	21	related	relate	VERB
tahrj-8728	155	22	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	155	23	migratory	migratory	ADJ
tahrj-8728	155	24	status	status	NOUN
tahrj-8728	155	25	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	155	26	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	155	27	expulsion	expulsion	NOUN
tahrj-8728	155	28	or	or	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	155	29	deportation	deportation	NOUN
tahrj-8728	155	30	proceedings	proceeding	NOUN
tahrj-8728	155	31	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	155	32	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	155	33	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	155	34	proceedings	proceeding	NOUN
tahrj-8728	155	35	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	155	36	determine	determine	VERB
tahrj-8728	155	37	refugee	refugee	NOUN
tahrj-8728	155	38	https://doi.org/10.17561/tahrj.v23.8728	https://doi.org/10.17561/tahrj.v23.8728	PROPN
tahrj-8728	155	39	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	155	40	analysis	analysis	NOUN
tahrj-8728	155	41	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	155	42	non	non	ADJ
tahrj-8728	155	43	-	-	ADJ
tahrj-8728	155	44	refoulement	refoulement	ADJ
tahrj-8728	155	45	jurisprudence	jurisprudence	NOUN
tahrj-8728	155	46	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	155	47	india	india	PROPN
tahrj-8728	155	48	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	155	49	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	155	50	comparative	comparative	ADJ
tahrj-8728	155	51	approach	approach	NOUN
tahrj-8728	155	52	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	155	53	age	age	NOUN
tahrj-8728	155	54	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	155	55	human	human	ADJ
tahrj-8728	155	56	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	155	57	journal	journal	NOUN
tahrj-8728	155	58	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	155	59	24	24	NUM
tahrj-8728	155	60	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	155	61	june	june	PROPN
tahrj-8728	155	62	2025	2025	NUM
tahrj-8728	155	63	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	155	64	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	155	65	e8728	e8728	PROPN
tahrj-8728	155	66	issn	issn	PROPN
tahrj-8728	155	67	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	155	68	2340	2340	NUM
tahrj-8728	155	69	-	-	SYM
tahrj-8728	155	70	9592	9592	NUM
tahrj-8728	155	71	doi	doi	NOUN
tahrj-8728	155	72	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	155	73	10.17561	10.17561	NUM
tahrj-8728	155	74	/	/	SYM
tahrj-8728	155	75	tahrj.v23.8728	tahrj.v23.8728	PROPN
tahrj-8728	155	76	10	10	NUM
tahrj-8728	155	77	status	status	NOUN
tahrj-8728	155	78	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	155	79	may	may	AUX
tahrj-8728	155	80	result	result	VERB
tahrj-8728	155	81	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	155	82	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	155	83	violation	violation	NOUN
tahrj-8728	155	84	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	155	85	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	155	86	principle	principle	NOUN
tahrj-8728	155	87	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	155	88	non	non	ADJ
tahrj-8728	155	89	-	-	ADJ
tahrj-8728	155	90	refoulement	refoulement	ADJ
tahrj-8728	155	91	’	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	155	92	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	156	1	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	156	2	advisory	advisory	ADJ
tahrj-8728	156	3	opinion	opinion	NOUN
tahrj-8728	156	4	oc-21/14	oc-21/14	NOUN
tahrj-8728	156	5	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	156	6	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	156	7	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	156	8	guarantees	guarantee	NOUN
tahrj-8728	156	9	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	156	10	children	child	NOUN
tahrj-8728	156	11	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	156	12	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	156	13	context	context	NOUN
tahrj-8728	156	14	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	156	15	migration	migration	NOUN
tahrj-8728	156	16	and/or	and/or	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	156	17	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	156	18	need	need	NOUN
tahrj-8728	156	19	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	156	20	international	international	ADJ
tahrj-8728	156	21	protection	protection	NOUN
tahrj-8728	156	22	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	156	23	august	august	PROPN
tahrj-8728	156	24	2014	2014	NUM
tahrj-8728	156	25	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	156	26	para	para	NOUN
tahrj-8728	156	27	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	156	28	230	230	NUM
tahrj-8728	156	29	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	156	30	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	157	1	concerning	concern	VERB
tahrj-8728	157	2	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	157	3	scope	scope	NOUN
tahrj-8728	157	4	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	157	5	application	application	NOUN
tahrj-8728	157	6	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	157	7	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	157	8	non	non	ADJ
tahrj-8728	157	9	-	-	ADJ
tahrj-8728	157	10	refoulement	refoulement	ADJ
tahrj-8728	157	11	principle	principle	NOUN
tahrj-8728	157	12	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	157	13	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	157	14	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	157	15	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	157	16	pacheco	pacheco	PROPN
tahrj-8728	157	17	tineo	tineo	VERB
tahrj-8728	157	18	family	family	PROPN
tahrj-8728	157	19	v.	v.	ADP
tahrj-8728	157	20	plurinational	plurinational	PROPN
tahrj-8728	157	21	state	state	PROPN
tahrj-8728	157	22	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	157	23	bolivia	bolivia	PROPN
tahrj-8728	157	24	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	157	25	2013	2013	NUM
tahrj-8728	157	26	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	157	27	posited	posit	VERB
tahrj-8728	157	28	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	157	29	states	state	NOUN
tahrj-8728	157	30	also	also	ADV
tahrj-8728	157	31	have	have	VERB
tahrj-8728	157	32	an	an	DET
tahrj-8728	157	33	obligation	obligation	NOUN
tahrj-8728	157	34	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	157	35	not	not	PART
tahrj-8728	157	36	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	157	37	hand	hand	VERB
tahrj-8728	157	38	over	over	ADP
tahrj-8728	157	39	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	157	40	person	person	NOUN
tahrj-8728	157	41	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	157	42	need	need	NOUN
tahrj-8728	157	43	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	157	44	international	international	ADJ
tahrj-8728	157	45	protection	protection	NOUN
tahrj-8728	157	46	where	where	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	157	47	there	there	PRON
tahrj-8728	157	48	is	be	VERB
tahrj-8728	157	49	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	157	50	possibility	possibility	NOUN
tahrj-8728	157	51	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	157	52	he	he	PRON
tahrj-8728	157	53	may	may	AUX
tahrj-8728	157	54	risk	risk	VERB
tahrj-8728	157	55	persecution	persecution	NOUN
tahrj-8728	157	56	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	157	57	or	or	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	157	58	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	157	59	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	157	60	state	state	NOUN
tahrj-8728	157	61	from	from	ADP
tahrj-8728	157	62	which	which	PRON
tahrj-8728	157	63	he	he	PRON
tahrj-8728	157	64	may	may	AUX
tahrj-8728	157	65	be	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	157	66	returned	return	VERB
tahrj-8728	157	67	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	157	68	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	157	69	country	country	NOUN
tahrj-8728	157	70	where	where	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	157	71	such	such	DET
tahrj-8728	157	72	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	157	73	risk	risk	NOUN
tahrj-8728	157	74	exists	exist	VERB
tahrj-8728	157	75	i.e.	i.e.	X
tahrj-8728	157	76	“	"	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	157	77	indirect	indirect	ADJ
tahrj-8728	157	78	refoulement	refoulement	NOUN
tahrj-8728	157	79	”	"	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	157	80	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	158	1	similarly	similarly	ADV
tahrj-8728	158	2	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	158	3	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	158	4	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	158	5	advisory	advisory	ADJ
tahrj-8728	158	6	opinion	opinion	NOUN
tahrj-8728	158	7	oc-25/18	oc-25/18	PROPN
tahrj-8728	158	8	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	158	9	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	158	10	institution	institution	NOUN
tahrj-8728	158	11	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	158	12	asylum	asylum	NOUN
tahrj-8728	158	13	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	158	14	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	158	15	its	its	PRON
tahrj-8728	158	16	recognition	recognition	NOUN
tahrj-8728	158	17	as	as	ADP
tahrj-8728	158	18	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	158	19	human	human	ADJ
tahrj-8728	158	20	right	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	158	21	under	under	ADP
tahrj-8728	158	22	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	158	23	inter	inter	ADJ
tahrj-8728	158	24	-	-	ADJ
tahrj-8728	158	25	american	american	ADJ
tahrj-8728	158	26	system	system	NOUN
tahrj-8728	158	27	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	158	28	protection	protection	NOUN
tahrj-8728	158	29	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	158	30	2018	2018	NUM
tahrj-8728	158	31	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	158	32	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	158	33	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	158	34	emphasized	emphasize	VERB
tahrj-8728	158	35	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	158	36	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	158	37	principle	principle	NOUN
tahrj-8728	158	38	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	158	39	non	non	ADJ
tahrj-8728	158	40	-	-	ADJ
tahrj-8728	158	41	refoulement	refoulement	ADJ
tahrj-8728	158	42	also	also	ADV
tahrj-8728	158	43	requires	require	VERB
tahrj-8728	158	44	positive	positive	ADJ
tahrj-8728	158	45	state	state	NOUN
tahrj-8728	158	46	action	action	NOUN
tahrj-8728	158	47	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	158	48	including	include	VERB
tahrj-8728	158	49	individualized	individualized	ADJ
tahrj-8728	158	50	risk	risk	NOUN
tahrj-8728	158	51	assessment	assessment	NOUN
tahrj-8728	158	52	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	158	53	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	158	54	case	case	NOUN
tahrj-8728	158	55	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	158	56	refoulement	refoulement	NOUN
tahrj-8728	158	57	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	159	1	these	these	DET
tahrj-8728	159	2	judgements	judgement	NOUN
tahrj-8728	159	3	are	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	159	4	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
tahrj-8728	159	5	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	159	6	establish	establish	VERB
tahrj-8728	159	7	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	159	8	iahrs	iahrs	ADJ
tahrj-8728	159	9	jurisprudence	jurisprudence	NOUN
tahrj-8728	159	10	has	have	AUX
tahrj-8728	159	11	been	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	159	12	covertly	covertly	ADV
tahrj-8728	159	13	converging	converge	VERB
tahrj-8728	159	14	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	159	15	coalescing	coalesce	VERB
tahrj-8728	159	16	around	around	ADP
tahrj-8728	159	17	central	central	ADJ
tahrj-8728	159	18	themes	theme	NOUN
tahrj-8728	159	19	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	159	20	prongs	prong	NOUN
tahrj-8728	159	21	for	for	ADP
tahrj-8728	159	22	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	159	23	balancing	balance	VERB
tahrj-8728	159	24	test	test	NOUN
tahrj-8728	159	25	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	159	26	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	159	27	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	159	28	locating	locate	VERB
tahrj-8728	159	29	state	state	NOUN
tahrj-8728	159	30	interests	interest	NOUN
tahrj-8728	159	31	with	with	ADP
tahrj-8728	159	32	individual	individual	ADJ
tahrj-8728	159	33	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	159	34	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	160	1	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	160	2	practice	practice	NOUN
tahrj-8728	160	3	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	160	4	unlike	unlike	ADP
tahrj-8728	160	5	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	160	6	echr	echr	NOUN
tahrj-8728	160	7	does	do	AUX
tahrj-8728	160	8	not	not	PART
tahrj-8728	160	9	take	take	VERB
tahrj-8728	160	10	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	160	11	doctrinal	doctrinal	ADJ
tahrj-8728	160	12	form	form	NOUN
tahrj-8728	160	13	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	160	14	nonrefoulement	nonrefoulement	ADJ
tahrj-8728	160	15	context	context	NOUN
tahrj-8728	160	16	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	160	17	but	but	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	160	18	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	160	19	same	same	ADJ
tahrj-8728	160	20	exists	exist	VERB
tahrj-8728	160	21	albeit	albeit	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	160	22	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	160	23	multiple	multiple	ADJ
tahrj-8728	160	24	manifestation	manifestation	NOUN
tahrj-8728	160	25	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	161	1	2	2	X
tahrj-8728	161	2	.	.	X
tahrj-8728	161	3	african	african	ADJ
tahrj-8728	161	4	courts	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	161	5	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	161	6	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	161	7	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	161	8	analysis	analysis	NOUN
tahrj-8728	161	9	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	161	10	meaning	meaning	NOUN
tahrj-8728	161	11	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	161	12	context	context	NOUN
tahrj-8728	161	13	unlike	unlike	ADP
tahrj-8728	161	14	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	161	15	echr	echr	NOUN
tahrj-8728	161	16	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	161	17	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	161	18	african	african	ADJ
tahrj-8728	161	19	charter	charter	NOUN
tahrj-8728	161	20	on	on	ADP
tahrj-8728	161	21	human	human	ADJ
tahrj-8728	161	22	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	161	23	people	people	NOUN
tahrj-8728	161	24	’s	’s	PART
tahrj-8728	161	25	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	161	26	is	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	161	27	silent	silent	ADJ
tahrj-8728	161	28	on	on	ADP
tahrj-8728	161	29	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	161	30	requirements	requirement	NOUN
tahrj-8728	161	31	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	161	32	any	any	DET
tahrj-8728	161	33	restriction	restriction	NOUN
tahrj-8728	161	34	on	on	ADP
tahrj-8728	161	35	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	161	36	human	human	ADJ
tahrj-8728	161	37	right	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	161	38	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	162	1	hence	hence	ADV
tahrj-8728	162	2	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	162	3	most	most	ADJ
tahrj-8728	162	4	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	162	5	these	these	DET
tahrj-8728	162	6	restrictions	restriction	NOUN
tahrj-8728	162	7	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	162	8	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	162	9	human	human	ADJ
tahrj-8728	162	10	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	162	11	context	context	NOUN
tahrj-8728	162	12	come	come	VERB
tahrj-8728	162	13	from	from	ADP
tahrj-8728	162	14	judicial	judicial	ADJ
tahrj-8728	162	15	creativity	creativity	NOUN
tahrj-8728	162	16	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	163	1	following	follow	VERB
tahrj-8728	163	2	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	163	3	very	very	ADV
tahrj-8728	163	4	similar	similar	ADJ
tahrj-8728	163	5	construction	construction	NOUN
tahrj-8728	163	6	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	163	7	ecthr	ecthr	PROPN
tahrj-8728	163	8	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	163	9	analysis	analysis	NOUN
tahrj-8728	163	10	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	163	11	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	163	12	african	african	ADJ
tahrj-8728	163	13	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	163	14	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	163	15	human	human	NOUN
tahrj-8728	163	16	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	163	17	people	people	NOUN
tahrj-8728	163	18	’s	’s	PART
tahrj-8728	163	19	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	163	20	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	163	21	acthpr	acthpr	NOUN
tahrj-8728	163	22	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	163	23	held	hold	VERB
tahrj-8728	163	24	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	163	25	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	163	26	any	any	DET
tahrj-8728	163	27	restriction	restriction	NOUN
tahrj-8728	163	28	on	on	ADP
tahrj-8728	163	29	human	human	ADJ
tahrj-8728	163	30	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	163	31	needs	need	VERB
tahrj-8728	163	32	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	163	33	conform	conform	VERB
tahrj-8728	163	34	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	163	35	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	163	36	threepart	threepart	NOUN
tahrj-8728	163	37	test	test	NOUN
tahrj-8728	163	38	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	163	39	tanganyika	tanganyika	X
tahrj-8728	163	40	law	law	NOUN
tahrj-8728	163	41	society	society	NOUN
tahrj-8728	163	42	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	163	43	legal	legal	ADJ
tahrj-8728	163	44	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	163	45	human	human	ADJ
tahrj-8728	163	46	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	163	47	centre	centre	NOUN
tahrj-8728	163	48	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	163	49	reverend	reverend	PROPN
tahrj-8728	163	50	christopher	christopher	PROPN
tahrj-8728	163	51	r	r	PROPN
tahrj-8728	163	52	mitilika	mitilika	PROPN
tahrj-8728	163	53	v	v	PROPN
tahrj-8728	163	54	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	163	55	united	united	PROPN
tahrj-8728	163	56	republic	republic	PROPN
tahrj-8728	163	57	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	163	58	tanzania	tanzania	PROPN
tahrj-8728	163	59	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	163	60	2013	2013	NUM
tahrj-8728	163	61	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	163	62	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	164	1	first	first	ADV
tahrj-8728	164	2	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	164	3	it	it	PRON
tahrj-8728	164	4	should	should	AUX
tahrj-8728	164	5	be	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	164	6	prescribed	prescribe	VERB
tahrj-8728	164	7	by	by	ADP
tahrj-8728	164	8	law	law	NOUN
tahrj-8728	164	9	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	165	1	second	second	ADJ
tahrj-8728	165	2	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	165	3	it	it	PRON
tahrj-8728	165	4	serves	serve	VERB
tahrj-8728	165	5	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	165	6	legitimate	legitimate	ADJ
tahrj-8728	165	7	aim	aim	NOUN
tahrj-8728	165	8	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	166	1	third	third	ADJ
tahrj-8728	166	2	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	166	3	it	it	PRON
tahrj-8728	166	4	is	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	166	5	proportionate	proportionate	ADJ
tahrj-8728	166	6	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	166	7	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	166	8	aim	aim	NOUN
tahrj-8728	166	9	pursued	pursue	VERB
tahrj-8728	166	10	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	167	1	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	167	2	ascertain	ascertain	VERB
tahrj-8728	167	3	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	167	4	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	167	5	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	167	6	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	167	7	assesses	assess	VERB
tahrj-8728	167	8	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	167	9	following	following	NOUN
tahrj-8728	167	10	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	168	1	first	first	ADV
tahrj-8728	168	2	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	168	3	its	its	PRON
tahrj-8728	168	4	suitability	suitability	NOUN
tahrj-8728	168	5	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	169	1	then	then	ADV
tahrj-8728	169	2	it	it	PRON
tahrj-8728	169	3	's	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	169	4	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	169	5	necessity	necessity	NOUN
tahrj-8728	169	6	—	—	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	169	7	third	third	ADJ
tahrj-8728	169	8	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	169	9	stricto	stricto	X
tahrj-8728	169	10	sensu	sensu	NOUN
tahrj-8728	169	11	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	170	1	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	170	2	acthpr	acthpr	NOUN
tahrj-8728	170	3	does	do	AUX
tahrj-8728	170	4	not	not	PART
tahrj-8728	170	5	apply	apply	VERB
tahrj-8728	170	6	all	all	DET
tahrj-8728	170	7	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	170	8	tests	test	NOUN
tahrj-8728	170	9	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	170	10	might	might	AUX
tahrj-8728	170	11	decide	decide	VERB
tahrj-8728	170	12	based	base	VERB
tahrj-8728	170	13	on	on	ADP
tahrj-8728	170	14	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	170	15	initial	initial	ADJ
tahrj-8728	170	16	tests	test	NOUN
tahrj-8728	170	17	if	if	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	170	18	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	170	19	issue	issue	NOUN
tahrj-8728	170	20	at	at	ADP
tahrj-8728	170	21	hand	hand	NOUN
tahrj-8728	170	22	fails	fail	VERB
tahrj-8728	170	23	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	170	24	meet	meet	VERB
tahrj-8728	170	25	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	170	26	criteria	criterion	NOUN
tahrj-8728	170	27	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	171	1	for	for	ADP
tahrj-8728	171	2	example	example	NOUN
tahrj-8728	171	3	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	171	4	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	171	5	tanganyika	tanganyika	X
tahrj-8728	171	6	law	law	NOUN
tahrj-8728	171	7	society	society	NOUN
tahrj-8728	171	8	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	171	9	2013	2013	NUM
tahrj-8728	171	10	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	171	11	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	171	12	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	171	13	tanzania	tanzania	PROPN
tahrj-8728	171	14	regulation	regulation	NOUN
tahrj-8728	171	15	prohibited	prohibit	VERB
tahrj-8728	171	16	independent	independent	ADJ
tahrj-8728	171	17	candidates	candidate	NOUN
tahrj-8728	171	18	from	from	ADP
tahrj-8728	171	19	seeking	seek	VERB
tahrj-8728	171	20	public	public	ADJ
tahrj-8728	171	21	office	office	NOUN
tahrj-8728	171	22	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	172	1	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	172	2	law	law	NOUN
tahrj-8728	172	3	society	society	NOUN
tahrj-8728	172	4	contended	contend	VERB
tahrj-8728	172	5	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	172	6	such	such	ADJ
tahrj-8728	172	7	restriction	restriction	NOUN
tahrj-8728	172	8	on	on	ADP
tahrj-8728	172	9	candidacy	candidacy	NOUN
tahrj-8728	172	10	was	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	172	11	on	on	ADP
tahrj-8728	172	12	account	account	NOUN
tahrj-8728	172	13	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	172	14	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	172	15	social	social	ADJ
tahrj-8728	172	16	needs	need	NOUN
tahrj-8728	172	17	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	172	18	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	172	19	country	country	NOUN
tahrj-8728	172	20	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	172	21	all	all	DET
tahrj-8728	172	22	candidates	candidate	NOUN
tahrj-8728	172	23	either	either	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	172	24	ascertain	ascertain	VERB
tahrj-8728	172	25	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	172	26	sponsor	sponsor	NOUN
tahrj-8728	172	27	or	or	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	172	28	be	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	172	29	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	172	30	member	member	NOUN
tahrj-8728	172	31	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	172	32	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	172	33	political	political	ADJ
tahrj-8728	172	34	party	party	NOUN
tahrj-8728	172	35	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	173	1	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	173	2	applicant	applicant	NOUN
tahrj-8728	173	3	contended	contend	VERB
tahrj-8728	173	4	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	173	5	this	this	PRON
tahrj-8728	173	6	conflicted	conflict	VERB
tahrj-8728	173	7	with	with	ADP
tahrj-8728	173	8	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	173	9	constitution	constitution	NOUN
tahrj-8728	173	10	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	173	11	should	should	AUX
tahrj-8728	173	12	therefore	therefore	ADV
tahrj-8728	173	13	be	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	173	14	declared	declare	VERB
tahrj-8728	173	15	void	void	ADJ
tahrj-8728	173	16	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	174	1	here	here	ADV
tahrj-8728	174	2	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	174	3	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	174	4	found	find	VERB
tahrj-8728	174	5	such	such	DET
tahrj-8728	174	6	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	174	7	regulation	regulation	NOUN
tahrj-8728	174	8	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	174	9	be	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	174	10	violative	violative	ADJ
tahrj-8728	174	11	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	174	12	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	174	13	applicant	applicant	NOUN
tahrj-8728	174	14	’s	’s	PART
tahrj-8728	174	15	right	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	174	16	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	174	17	political	political	ADJ
tahrj-8728	174	18	participation	participation	NOUN
tahrj-8728	174	19	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	175	1	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	175	2	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	175	3	said	say	VERB
tahrj-8728	175	4	such	such	DET
tahrj-8728	175	5	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	175	6	measure	measure	NOUN
tahrj-8728	175	7	did	do	AUX
tahrj-8728	175	8	not	not	PART
tahrj-8728	175	9	meet	meet	VERB
tahrj-8728	175	10	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	175	11	legitimacy	legitimacy	NOUN
tahrj-8728	175	12	criteria	criterion	NOUN
tahrj-8728	175	13	under	under	ADP
tahrj-8728	175	14	art	art	NOUN
tahrj-8728	175	15	27	27	NUM
tahrj-8728	175	16	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	175	17	2	2	NUM
tahrj-8728	175	18	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	175	19	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	175	20	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	175	21	achpr	achpr	NOUN
tahrj-8728	175	22	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	175	23	can	can	AUX
tahrj-8728	175	24	not	not	PART
tahrj-8728	175	25	stand	stand	VERB
tahrj-8728	175	26	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	176	1	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	176	2	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	176	3	did	do	AUX
tahrj-8728	176	4	not	not	PART
tahrj-8728	176	5	proceed	proceed	VERB
tahrj-8728	176	6	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	176	7	balance	balance	VERB
tahrj-8728	176	8	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	176	9	competing	compete	VERB
tahrj-8728	176	10	interests	interest	NOUN
tahrj-8728	176	11	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	176	12	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	176	13	at	at	ADP
tahrj-8728	176	14	hand	hand	NOUN
tahrj-8728	176	15	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	176	16	deemed	deem	VERB
tahrj-8728	176	17	as	as	ADP
tahrj-8728	176	18	unnecessary	unnecessary	ADJ
tahrj-8728	176	19	given	give	VERB
tahrj-8728	176	20	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	176	21	measure	measure	NOUN
tahrj-8728	176	22	failed	fail	VERB
tahrj-8728	176	23	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	176	24	even	even	ADV
tahrj-8728	176	25	meet	meet	VERB
tahrj-8728	176	26	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	176	27	initial	initial	ADJ
tahrj-8728	176	28	criteria	criterion	NOUN
tahrj-8728	176	29	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	176	30	legitimacy	legitimacy	NOUN
tahrj-8728	176	31	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	177	1	similarly	similarly	ADV
tahrj-8728	177	2	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	177	3	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	177	4	actions	action	NOUN
tahrj-8728	177	5	pour	pour	VERB
tahrj-8728	177	6	la	la	PROPN
tahrj-8728	177	7	protection	protection	PROPN
tahrj-8728	177	8	des	des	PROPN
tahrj-8728	177	9	driots	driot	NOUN
tahrj-8728	177	10	de	de	X
tahrj-8728	177	11	l’homme	l’homme	PROPN
tahrj-8728	177	12	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	177	13	apdh	apdh	NOUN
tahrj-8728	177	14	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	177	15	v.	v.	ADP
tahrj-8728	177	16	republic	republic	NOUN
tahrj-8728	177	17	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	177	18	cote	cote	PROPN
tahrj-8728	177	19	d’ivoire	d’ivoire	PROPN
tahrj-8728	177	20	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	177	21	2016	2016	NUM
tahrj-8728	177	22	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	177	23	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	177	24	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	177	25	held	hold	VERB
tahrj-8728	177	26	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	177	27	setting	set	VERB
tahrj-8728	177	28	up	up	ADP
tahrj-8728	177	29	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	177	30	an	an	DET
tahrj-8728	177	31	electoral	electoral	ADJ
tahrj-8728	177	32	body	body	NOUN
tahrj-8728	177	33	which	which	PRON
tahrj-8728	177	34	is	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	177	35	neither	neither	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	177	36	independent	independent	ADJ
tahrj-8728	177	37	nor	nor	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	177	38	impartial	impartial	ADJ
tahrj-8728	177	39	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	177	40	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	177	41	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	177	42	state	state	NOUN
tahrj-8728	177	43	has	have	AUX
tahrj-8728	177	44	breached	breach	VERB
tahrj-8728	177	45	art	art	NOUN
tahrj-8728	177	46	12	12	NUM
tahrj-8728	177	47	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	177	48	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	177	49	achpr	achpr	NOUN
tahrj-8728	177	50	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	178	1	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	178	2	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	178	3	https://doi.org/10.17561/tahrj.v23.8728	https://doi.org/10.17561/tahrj.v23.8728	PROPN
tahrj-8728	178	4	sabreen	sabreen	PROPN
tahrj-8728	178	5	ahmed	ahme	VERB
tahrj-8728	178	6	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	178	7	age	age	NOUN
tahrj-8728	178	8	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	178	9	human	human	ADJ
tahrj-8728	178	10	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	178	11	journal	journal	NOUN
tahrj-8728	178	12	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	178	13	24	24	NUM
tahrj-8728	178	14	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	178	15	june	june	PROPN
tahrj-8728	178	16	2025	2025	NUM
tahrj-8728	178	17	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	178	18	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	178	19	e8728	e8728	PROPN
tahrj-8728	178	20	issn	issn	PROPN
tahrj-8728	178	21	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	178	22	2340	2340	NUM
tahrj-8728	178	23	-	-	SYM
tahrj-8728	178	24	9592	9592	NUM
tahrj-8728	178	25	doi	doi	NOUN
tahrj-8728	178	26	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	178	27	10.17561	10.17561	NUM
tahrj-8728	178	28	/	/	SYM
tahrj-8728	178	29	tahrj.v23.8728	tahrj.v23.8728	PROPN
tahrj-8728	178	30	11	11	NUM
tahrj-8728	178	31	did	do	AUX
tahrj-8728	178	32	not	not	PART
tahrj-8728	178	33	apply	apply	VERB
tahrj-8728	178	34	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	178	35	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	178	36	analysis	analysis	NOUN
tahrj-8728	178	37	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	178	38	examine	examine	VERB
tahrj-8728	178	39	if	if	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	178	40	such	such	DET
tahrj-8728	178	41	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	178	42	restriction	restriction	NOUN
tahrj-8728	178	43	on	on	ADP
tahrj-8728	178	44	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	178	45	right	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	178	46	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	178	47	political	political	ADJ
tahrj-8728	178	48	participation	participation	NOUN
tahrj-8728	178	49	was	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	178	50	proportionate	proportionate	ADJ
tahrj-8728	178	51	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	179	1	usually	usually	ADV
tahrj-8728	179	2	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	179	3	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	179	4	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	179	5	applies	apply	VERB
tahrj-8728	179	6	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	179	7	strict	strict	ADJ
tahrj-8728	179	8	necessity	necessity	NOUN
tahrj-8728	179	9	test	test	NOUN
tahrj-8728	179	10	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	179	11	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	179	12	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	179	13	analysis	analysis	NOUN
tahrj-8728	179	14	once	once	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	179	15	it	it	PRON
tahrj-8728	179	16	is	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	179	17	affirmed	affirm	VERB
tahrj-8728	179	18	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	179	19	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	179	20	restriction	restriction	NOUN
tahrj-8728	179	21	on	on	ADP
tahrj-8728	179	22	an	an	DET
tahrj-8728	179	23	individual	individual	NOUN
tahrj-8728	179	24	’s	’s	PART
tahrj-8728	179	25	right	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	179	26	is	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	179	27	provided	provide	VERB
tahrj-8728	179	28	by	by	ADP
tahrj-8728	179	29	law	law	NOUN
tahrj-8728	179	30	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	179	31	serves	serve	VERB
tahrj-8728	179	32	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	179	33	legitimate	legitimate	ADJ
tahrj-8728	179	34	purpose	purpose	NOUN
tahrj-8728	179	35	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	180	1	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	180	2	similar	similar	ADJ
tahrj-8728	180	3	pattern	pattern	NOUN
tahrj-8728	180	4	can	can	AUX
tahrj-8728	180	5	be	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	180	6	observed	observe	VERB
tahrj-8728	180	7	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	180	8	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	180	9	african	african	ADJ
tahrj-8728	180	10	commission	commission	PROPN
tahrj-8728	180	11	on	on	ADP
tahrj-8728	180	12	human	human	ADJ
tahrj-8728	180	13	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	180	14	people	people	NOUN
tahrj-8728	180	15	’s	’s	PART
tahrj-8728	180	16	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	180	17	v.	v.	ADP
tahrj-8728	180	18	republic	republic	PROPN
tahrj-8728	180	19	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	180	20	kenya	kenya	PROPN
tahrj-8728	180	21	case	case	NOUN
tahrj-8728	180	22	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	180	23	2013	2013	NUM
tahrj-8728	180	24	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	180	25	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	181	1	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	181	2	state	state	NOUN
tahrj-8728	181	3	evicted	evict	VERB
tahrj-8728	181	4	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	181	5	ogiek	ogiek	ADJ
tahrj-8728	181	6	population	population	NOUN
tahrj-8728	181	7	from	from	ADP
tahrj-8728	181	8	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	181	9	mau	mau	PROPN
tahrj-8728	181	10	forest	forest	PROPN
tahrj-8728	181	11	area	area	NOUN
tahrj-8728	181	12	for	for	ADP
tahrj-8728	181	13	reasons	reason	NOUN
tahrj-8728	181	14	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	181	15	preserving	preserve	VERB
tahrj-8728	181	16	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	181	17	natural	natural	ADJ
tahrj-8728	181	18	environment	environment	NOUN
tahrj-8728	181	19	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	182	1	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	182	2	ogiek	ogiek	ADJ
tahrj-8728	182	3	population	population	NOUN
tahrj-8728	182	4	claimed	claim	VERB
tahrj-8728	182	5	this	this	PRON
tahrj-8728	182	6	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	182	7	be	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	182	8	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	182	9	violation	violation	NOUN
tahrj-8728	182	10	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	182	11	their	their	PRON
tahrj-8728	182	12	cultural	cultural	ADJ
tahrj-8728	182	13	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	182	14	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	183	1	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	183	2	acthpr	acthpr	NOUN
tahrj-8728	183	3	applied	apply	VERB
tahrj-8728	183	4	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	183	5	first	first	ADJ
tahrj-8728	183	6	test	test	NOUN
tahrj-8728	183	7	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	183	8	argued	argue	VERB
tahrj-8728	183	9	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	183	10	preserving	preserve	VERB
tahrj-8728	183	11	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	183	12	natural	natural	ADJ
tahrj-8728	183	13	environment	environment	NOUN
tahrj-8728	183	14	is	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	183	15	not	not	PART
tahrj-8728	183	16	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	183	17	legitimate	legitimate	ADJ
tahrj-8728	183	18	justification	justification	NOUN
tahrj-8728	183	19	for	for	ADP
tahrj-8728	183	20	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	183	21	eviction	eviction	NOUN
tahrj-8728	183	22	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	183	23	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	183	24	ogiek	ogiek	ADJ
tahrj-8728	183	25	population	population	NOUN
tahrj-8728	183	26	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	184	1	hence	hence	ADV
tahrj-8728	184	2	there	there	PRON
tahrj-8728	184	3	is	be	VERB
tahrj-8728	184	4	no	no	DET
tahrj-8728	184	5	need	need	NOUN
tahrj-8728	184	6	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	184	7	apply	apply	VERB
tahrj-8728	184	8	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	184	9	necessity	necessity	NOUN
tahrj-8728	184	10	or	or	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	184	11	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	184	12	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	184	13	test	test	NOUN
tahrj-8728	184	14	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	185	1	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	185	2	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	185	3	was	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	185	4	dissatisfied	dissatisfied	ADJ
tahrj-8728	185	5	with	with	ADP
tahrj-8728	185	6	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	185	7	argument	argument	NOUN
tahrj-8728	185	8	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	185	9	interference	interference	NOUN
tahrj-8728	185	10	prompted	prompt	VERB
tahrj-8728	185	11	by	by	ADP
tahrj-8728	185	12	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	185	13	need	need	NOUN
tahrj-8728	185	14	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	185	15	protect	protect	VERB
tahrj-8728	185	16	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	185	17	common	common	ADJ
tahrj-8728	185	18	interest	interest	NOUN
tahrj-8728	185	19	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	186	1	it	it	PRON
tahrj-8728	186	2	was	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	186	3	held	hold	VERB
tahrj-8728	186	4	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	186	5	dispossessing	dispossess	VERB
tahrj-8728	186	6	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	186	7	ogiek	ogiek	ADJ
tahrj-8728	186	8	population	population	NOUN
tahrj-8728	186	9	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	186	10	their	their	PRON
tahrj-8728	186	11	land	land	NOUN
tahrj-8728	186	12	was	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	186	13	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	186	14	violation	violation	NOUN
tahrj-8728	186	15	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	186	16	their	their	PRON
tahrj-8728	186	17	right	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	186	18	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	186	19	property	property	NOUN
tahrj-8728	186	20	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	187	1	so	so	ADV
tahrj-8728	187	2	far	far	ADV
tahrj-8728	187	3	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	187	4	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	187	5	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	187	6	has	have	AUX
tahrj-8728	187	7	managed	manage	VERB
tahrj-8728	187	8	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	187	9	reach	reach	VERB
tahrj-8728	187	10	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	187	11	balancing	balancing	NOUN
tahrj-8728	187	12	mechanism	mechanism	NOUN
tahrj-8728	187	13	only	only	ADV
tahrj-8728	187	14	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	187	15	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	187	16	loge	loge	PROPN
tahrj-8728	187	17	issa	issa	PROPN
tahrj-8728	187	18	konate	konate	PROPN
tahrj-8728	187	19	case	case	NOUN
tahrj-8728	187	20	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	187	21	2014	2014	NUM
tahrj-8728	187	22	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	187	23	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	188	1	this	this	DET
tahrj-8728	188	2	case	case	NOUN
tahrj-8728	188	3	concerned	concerned	ADJ
tahrj-8728	188	4	journalist	journalist	NOUN
tahrj-8728	188	5	lohe	lohe	PROPN
tahrj-8728	188	6	issa	issa	PROPN
tahrj-8728	188	7	who	who	PRON
tahrj-8728	188	8	wrote	write	VERB
tahrj-8728	188	9	two	two	NUM
tahrj-8728	188	10	articles	article	NOUN
tahrj-8728	188	11	for	for	ADP
tahrj-8728	188	12	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	188	13	newspaper	newspaper	NOUN
tahrj-8728	188	14	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	188	15	which	which	PRON
tahrj-8728	188	16	he	he	PRON
tahrj-8728	188	17	accused	accuse	VERB
tahrj-8728	188	18	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	188	19	state	state	NOUN
tahrj-8728	188	20	prosecutor	prosecutor	NOUN
tahrj-8728	188	21	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	188	22	corruption	corruption	NOUN
tahrj-8728	188	23	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	189	1	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	189	2	prosecution	prosecution	NOUN
tahrj-8728	189	3	filed	file	VERB
tahrj-8728	189	4	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	189	5	defamation	defamation	NOUN
tahrj-8728	189	6	came	come	VERB
tahrj-8728	189	7	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	190	1	he	he	PRON
tahrj-8728	190	2	was	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	190	3	convicted	convict	VERB
tahrj-8728	190	4	by	by	ADP
tahrj-8728	190	5	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	190	6	national	national	PROPN
tahrj-8728	190	7	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	190	8	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	190	9	brought	bring	VERB
tahrj-8728	190	10	before	before	ADP
tahrj-8728	190	11	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	190	12	african	african	ADJ
tahrj-8728	190	13	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	190	14	for	for	ADP
tahrj-8728	190	15	review	review	NOUN
tahrj-8728	190	16	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	191	1	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	191	2	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	191	3	applied	apply	VERB
tahrj-8728	191	4	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	191	5	three	three	NUM
tahrj-8728	191	6	-	-	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	191	7	part	part	NOUN
tahrj-8728	191	8	test	test	NOUN
tahrj-8728	191	9	as	as	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	191	10	follows	follow	VERB
tahrj-8728	191	11	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	192	1	first	first	ADV
tahrj-8728	192	2	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	192	3	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	192	4	question	question	NOUN
tahrj-8728	192	5	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	192	6	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	192	7	legality	legality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	192	8	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	192	9	burkina	burkina	PROPN
tahrj-8728	192	10	faso	faso	PROPN
tahrj-8728	192	11	’s	’s	PART
tahrj-8728	192	12	defamation	defamation	NOUN
tahrj-8728	192	13	laws	law	NOUN
tahrj-8728	192	14	that	that	PRON
tahrj-8728	192	15	allowed	allow	VERB
tahrj-8728	192	16	restriction	restriction	NOUN
tahrj-8728	192	17	on	on	ADP
tahrj-8728	192	18	one	one	NUM
tahrj-8728	192	19	’s	’s	PART
tahrj-8728	192	20	freedom	freedom	NOUN
tahrj-8728	192	21	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	192	22	expression	expression	NOUN
tahrj-8728	192	23	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	192	24	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	193	1	second	second	ADJ
tahrj-8728	193	2	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	193	3	does	do	AUX
tahrj-8728	193	4	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	193	5	restriction	restriction	NOUN
tahrj-8728	193	6	serve	serve	VERB
tahrj-8728	193	7	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	193	8	legitimate	legitimate	ADJ
tahrj-8728	193	9	purpose	purpose	NOUN
tahrj-8728	193	10	?	?	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	194	1	third	third	ADJ
tahrj-8728	194	2	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	194	3	is	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	194	4	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	194	5	restriction	restriction	NOUN
tahrj-8728	194	6	necessary	necessary	ADJ
tahrj-8728	194	7	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	194	8	achieve	achieve	VERB
tahrj-8728	194	9	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	194	10	purpose	purpose	NOUN
tahrj-8728	194	11	?	?	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	195	1	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	195	2	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	195	3	found	find	VERB
tahrj-8728	195	4	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	195	5	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	195	6	domestic	domestic	ADJ
tahrj-8728	195	7	laws	law	NOUN
tahrj-8728	195	8	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	195	9	burkino	burkino	PROPN
tahrj-8728	195	10	faso	faso	PROPN
tahrj-8728	195	11	allowed	allow	VERB
tahrj-8728	195	12	for	for	ADP
tahrj-8728	195	13	criminal	criminal	ADJ
tahrj-8728	195	14	penalties	penalty	NOUN
tahrj-8728	195	15	for	for	ADP
tahrj-8728	195	16	defamation	defamation	NOUN
tahrj-8728	195	17	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	195	18	was	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	195	19	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	195	20	permissible	permissible	ADJ
tahrj-8728	195	21	restriction	restriction	NOUN
tahrj-8728	195	22	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	195	23	one	one	NUM
tahrj-8728	195	24	’s	’s	PART
tahrj-8728	195	25	freedom	freedom	NOUN
tahrj-8728	195	26	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	195	27	expression	expression	NOUN
tahrj-8728	195	28	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	195	29	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	196	1	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	196	2	purpose	purpose	NOUN
tahrj-8728	196	3	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	196	4	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	196	5	restriction	restriction	NOUN
tahrj-8728	196	6	was	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	196	7	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	196	8	protect	protect	VERB
tahrj-8728	196	9	one	one	NUM
tahrj-8728	196	10	’s	’s	PART
tahrj-8728	196	11	reputation	reputation	NOUN
tahrj-8728	196	12	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	196	13	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	196	14	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	196	15	found	find	VERB
tahrj-8728	196	16	this	this	PRON
tahrj-8728	196	17	as	as	ADP
tahrj-8728	196	18	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	196	19	legitimate	legitimate	ADJ
tahrj-8728	196	20	purpose	purpose	NOUN
tahrj-8728	196	21	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	197	1	turning	turn	VERB
tahrj-8728	197	2	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	197	3	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	197	4	third	third	ADJ
tahrj-8728	197	5	analysis	analysis	NOUN
tahrj-8728	197	6	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	197	7	whether	whether	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	197	8	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	197	9	criminal	criminal	ADJ
tahrj-8728	197	10	penalties	penalty	NOUN
tahrj-8728	197	11	were	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	197	12	necessary	necessary	ADJ
tahrj-8728	197	13	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	197	14	proportionate	proportionate	ADJ
tahrj-8728	197	15	against	against	ADP
tahrj-8728	197	16	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	197	17	freedom	freedom	NOUN
tahrj-8728	197	18	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	197	19	expression	expression	NOUN
tahrj-8728	197	20	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	197	21	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	197	22	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	197	23	held	hold	VERB
tahrj-8728	197	24	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	197	25	there	there	PRON
tahrj-8728	197	26	should	should	AUX
tahrj-8728	197	27	have	have	AUX
tahrj-8728	197	28	been	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	197	29	lesser	less	ADJ
tahrj-8728	197	30	interference	interference	NOUN
tahrj-8728	197	31	with	with	ADP
tahrj-8728	197	32	free	free	ADJ
tahrj-8728	197	33	speech	speech	NOUN
tahrj-8728	197	34	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	198	1	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	198	2	criminal	criminal	ADJ
tahrj-8728	198	3	penalties	penalty	NOUN
tahrj-8728	198	4	though	though	ADV
tahrj-8728	198	5	legitimate	legitimate	ADJ
tahrj-8728	198	6	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	198	7	where	where	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	198	8	not	not	PART
tahrj-8728	198	9	proportional	proportional	ADJ
tahrj-8728	198	10	as	as	ADP
tahrj-8728	198	11	civil	civil	ADJ
tahrj-8728	198	12	recourse	recourse	NOUN
tahrj-8728	198	13	could	could	AUX
tahrj-8728	198	14	have	have	AUX
tahrj-8728	198	15	been	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	198	16	enough	enough	ADJ
tahrj-8728	198	17	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	198	18	save	save	VERB
tahrj-8728	198	19	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	198	20	reputation	reputation	NOUN
tahrj-8728	198	21	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	198	22	question	question	NOUN
tahrj-8728	198	23	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	199	1	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	199	2	law	law	NOUN
tahrj-8728	199	3	calling	call	VERB
tahrj-8728	199	4	for	for	ADP
tahrj-8728	199	5	criminal	criminal	ADJ
tahrj-8728	199	6	penalties	penalty	NOUN
tahrj-8728	199	7	was	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	199	8	found	find	VERB
tahrj-8728	199	9	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	199	10	be	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	199	11	disproportionate	disproportionate	ADJ
tahrj-8728	199	12	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	199	13	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	199	14	freedom	freedom	NOUN
tahrj-8728	199	15	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	199	16	speech	speech	NOUN
tahrj-8728	199	17	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	199	18	expression	expression	NOUN
tahrj-8728	199	19	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	200	1	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	200	2	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	200	3	took	take	VERB
tahrj-8728	200	4	into	into	ADP
tahrj-8728	200	5	consideration	consideration	NOUN
tahrj-8728	200	6	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	200	7	practice	practice	NOUN
tahrj-8728	200	8	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	200	9	international	international	ADJ
tahrj-8728	200	10	courts	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	200	11	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	200	12	bodies	body	NOUN
tahrj-8728	200	13	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	200	14	human	human	ADJ
tahrj-8728	200	15	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	200	16	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	200	17	state	state	VERB
tahrj-8728	200	18	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	200	19	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	200	20	‘	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	200	21	freedom	freedom	NOUN
tahrj-8728	200	22	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	200	23	expression	expression	NOUN
tahrj-8728	200	24	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	200	25	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	200	26	democratic	democratic	ADJ
tahrj-8728	200	27	society	society	NOUN
tahrj-8728	200	28	must	must	AUX
tahrj-8728	200	29	be	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	200	30	subject	subject	ADJ
tahrj-8728	200	31	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	200	32	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	200	33	far	far	ADV
tahrj-8728	200	34	lesser	less	ADJ
tahrj-8728	200	35	degree	degree	NOUN
tahrj-8728	200	36	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	200	37	interference	interference	NOUN
tahrj-8728	200	38	’	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	200	39	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	201	1	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	201	2	careful	careful	ADJ
tahrj-8728	201	3	analysis	analysis	NOUN
tahrj-8728	201	4	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	201	5	these	these	DET
tahrj-8728	201	6	judgements	judgement	NOUN
tahrj-8728	201	7	suggests	suggest	VERB
tahrj-8728	201	8	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	201	9	pattern	pattern	NOUN
tahrj-8728	201	10	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	201	11	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	201	12	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	201	13	’s	’s	PART
tahrj-8728	201	14	scrutiny	scrutiny	NOUN
tahrj-8728	201	15	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	201	16	all	all	DET
tahrj-8728	201	17	interference	interference	NOUN
tahrj-8728	201	18	measures	measure	NOUN
tahrj-8728	201	19	by	by	ADP
tahrj-8728	201	20	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	201	21	national	national	ADJ
tahrj-8728	201	22	authorities	authority	NOUN
tahrj-8728	201	23	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	202	1	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	202	2	theory	theory	NOUN
tahrj-8728	202	3	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	202	4	margin	margin	NOUN
tahrj-8728	202	5	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	202	6	appreciation	appreciation	NOUN
tahrj-8728	202	7	devised	devise	VERB
tahrj-8728	202	8	within	within	ADP
tahrj-8728	202	9	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	202	10	european	european	ADJ
tahrj-8728	202	11	human	human	ADJ
tahrj-8728	202	12	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	202	13	jurisprudence	jurisprudence	NOUN
tahrj-8728	202	14	holds	hold	VERB
tahrj-8728	202	15	value	value	NOUN
tahrj-8728	202	16	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	202	17	this	this	DET
tahrj-8728	202	18	regard	regard	NOUN
tahrj-8728	202	19	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	203	1	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	203	2	concept	concept	NOUN
tahrj-8728	203	3	informs	inform	VERB
tahrj-8728	203	4	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	203	5	reasoning	reasoning	NOUN
tahrj-8728	203	6	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	203	7	ecthr	ecthr	NOUN
tahrj-8728	203	8	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	203	9	its	its	PRON
tahrj-8728	203	10	assessment	assessment	NOUN
tahrj-8728	203	11	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	203	12	those	those	DET
tahrj-8728	203	13	provisions	provision	NOUN
tahrj-8728	203	14	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	203	15	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	203	16	convention	convention	NOUN
tahrj-8728	203	17	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	203	18	its	its	PRON
tahrj-8728	203	19	protocols	protocol	NOUN
tahrj-8728	203	20	that	that	PRON
tahrj-8728	203	21	require	require	VERB
tahrj-8728	203	22	balancing	balance	VERB
tahrj-8728	203	23	with	with	ADP
tahrj-8728	203	24	other	other	ADJ
tahrj-8728	203	25	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	203	26	or	or	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	203	27	need	need	VERB
tahrj-8728	203	28	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	203	29	be	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	203	30	weighed	weigh	VERB
tahrj-8728	203	31	up	up	ADP
tahrj-8728	203	32	against	against	ADP
tahrj-8728	203	33	other	other	ADJ
tahrj-8728	203	34	aspects	aspect	NOUN
tahrj-8728	203	35	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	203	36	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	203	37	public	public	ADJ
tahrj-8728	203	38	interest	interest	NOUN
tahrj-8728	203	39	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	204	1	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	204	2	rationale	rationale	NOUN
tahrj-8728	204	3	was	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	204	4	first	first	ADV
tahrj-8728	204	5	introduced	introduce	VERB
tahrj-8728	204	6	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	204	7	handyside	handyside	PROPN
tahrj-8728	204	8	v	v	ADP
tahrj-8728	204	9	united	united	ADJ
tahrj-8728	204	10	kingdom	kingdom	PROPN
tahrj-8728	204	11	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	204	12	1976	1976	NUM
tahrj-8728	204	13	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	204	14	where	where	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	204	15	it	it	PRON
tahrj-8728	204	16	was	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	204	17	held	hold	VERB
tahrj-8728	204	18	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	204	19	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	204	20	sequence	sequence	NOUN
tahrj-8728	204	21	is	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	204	22	involved	involve	VERB
tahrj-8728	204	23	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	204	24	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	204	25	process	process	NOUN
tahrj-8728	204	26	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	204	27	securing	secure	VERB
tahrj-8728	204	28	human	human	ADJ
tahrj-8728	204	29	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	204	30	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	204	31	an	an	DET
tahrj-8728	204	32	assessment	assessment	NOUN
tahrj-8728	204	33	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	204	34	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	204	35	compatibility	compatibility	NOUN
tahrj-8728	204	36	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	204	37	national	national	ADJ
tahrj-8728	204	38	measures	measure	NOUN
tahrj-8728	204	39	with	with	ADP
tahrj-8728	204	40	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	204	41	convention	convention	NOUN
tahrj-8728	204	42	is	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	204	43	first	first	ADV
tahrj-8728	204	44	made	make	VERB
tahrj-8728	204	45	by	by	ADP
tahrj-8728	204	46	national	national	ADJ
tahrj-8728	204	47	courts	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	204	48	;	;	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	204	49	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	204	50	subsequently	subsequently	ADV
tahrj-8728	204	51	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	204	52	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	204	53	review	review	NOUN
tahrj-8728	204	54	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	204	55	this	this	DET
tahrj-8728	204	56	assessment	assessment	NOUN
tahrj-8728	204	57	is	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	204	58	undertaken	undertake	VERB
tahrj-8728	204	59	by	by	ADP
tahrj-8728	204	60	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	204	61	ecthr	ecthr	NOUN
tahrj-8728	204	62	if	if	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	204	63	needed	need	VERB
tahrj-8728	204	64	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	205	1	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	205	2	frantziou	frantziou	NOUN
tahrj-8728	205	3	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	205	4	2014	2014	NUM
tahrj-8728	205	5	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	205	6	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	206	1	for	for	ADP
tahrj-8728	206	2	example	example	NOUN
tahrj-8728	206	3	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	206	4	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	206	5	tanganyika	tanganyika	X
tahrj-8728	206	6	while	while	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	206	7	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	206	8	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	206	9	accepted	accept	VERB
tahrj-8728	206	10	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	206	11	principle	principle	NOUN
tahrj-8728	206	12	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	206	13	importance	importance	NOUN
tahrj-8728	206	14	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	206	15	applying	apply	VERB
tahrj-8728	206	16	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	206	17	‘	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	206	18	margin	margin	NOUN
tahrj-8728	206	19	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	206	20	appreciation	appreciation	NOUN
tahrj-8728	206	21	’	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	206	22	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	206	23	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	206	24	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	206	25	reiterated	reiterate	VERB
tahrj-8728	206	26	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	206	27	need	need	NOUN
tahrj-8728	206	28	for	for	ADP
tahrj-8728	206	29	applying	apply	VERB
tahrj-8728	206	30	such	such	ADJ
tahrj-8728	206	31	https://doi.org/10.17561/tahrj.v23.8728	https://doi.org/10.17561/tahrj.v23.8728	PROPN
tahrj-8728	206	32	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	206	33	analysis	analysis	NOUN
tahrj-8728	206	34	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	206	35	non	non	ADJ
tahrj-8728	206	36	-	-	ADJ
tahrj-8728	206	37	refoulement	refoulement	ADJ
tahrj-8728	206	38	jurisprudence	jurisprudence	NOUN
tahrj-8728	206	39	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	206	40	india	india	PROPN
tahrj-8728	206	41	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	206	42	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	206	43	comparative	comparative	ADJ
tahrj-8728	206	44	approach	approach	NOUN
tahrj-8728	206	45	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	206	46	age	age	NOUN
tahrj-8728	206	47	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	206	48	human	human	ADJ
tahrj-8728	206	49	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	206	50	journal	journal	NOUN
tahrj-8728	206	51	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	206	52	24	24	NUM
tahrj-8728	206	53	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	206	54	june	june	PROPN
tahrj-8728	206	55	2025	2025	NUM
tahrj-8728	206	56	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	206	57	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	206	58	e8728	e8728	PROPN
tahrj-8728	206	59	issn	issn	PROPN
tahrj-8728	206	60	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	206	61	2340	2340	NUM
tahrj-8728	206	62	-	-	SYM
tahrj-8728	206	63	9592	9592	NUM
tahrj-8728	206	64	doi	doi	NOUN
tahrj-8728	206	65	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	206	66	10.17561	10.17561	NUM
tahrj-8728	206	67	/	/	SYM
tahrj-8728	206	68	tahrj.v23.8728	tahrj.v23.8728	PROPN
tahrj-8728	206	69	12	12	NUM
tahrj-8728	206	70	discretion	discretion	NOUN
tahrj-8728	206	71	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	206	72	good	good	ADJ
tahrj-8728	206	73	faith	faith	NOUN
tahrj-8728	206	74	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	206	75	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	206	76	assess	assess	VERB
tahrj-8728	206	77	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	206	78	relevance	relevance	NOUN
tahrj-8728	206	79	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	206	80	sufficiency	sufficiency	NOUN
tahrj-8728	206	81	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	206	82	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	206	83	fair	fair	ADJ
tahrj-8728	206	84	balance	balance	NOUN
tahrj-8728	206	85	between	between	ADP
tahrj-8728	206	86	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	206	87	general	general	ADJ
tahrj-8728	206	88	interest	interest	NOUN
tahrj-8728	206	89	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	206	90	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	206	91	community	community	NOUN
tahrj-8728	206	92	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	206	93	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	206	94	individual	individual	NOUN
tahrj-8728	206	95	’s	’s	PART
tahrj-8728	206	96	fundamental	fundamental	ADJ
tahrj-8728	206	97	right	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	206	98	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	207	1	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	207	2	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	207	3	few	few	ADJ
tahrj-8728	207	4	rare	rare	ADJ
tahrj-8728	207	5	cases	case	NOUN
tahrj-8728	207	6	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	207	7	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	207	8	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	207	9	has	have	AUX
tahrj-8728	207	10	been	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	207	11	completely	completely	ADV
tahrj-8728	207	12	non	non	ADJ
tahrj-8728	207	13	-	-	ADJ
tahrj-8728	207	14	receptive	receptive	ADJ
tahrj-8728	207	15	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	207	16	such	such	ADJ
tahrj-8728	207	17	state	state	NOUN
tahrj-8728	207	18	discretion	discretion	NOUN
tahrj-8728	207	19	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	208	1	for	for	ADP
tahrj-8728	208	2	example	example	NOUN
tahrj-8728	208	3	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	208	4	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	208	5	ingabire	ingabire	PROPN
tahrj-8728	208	6	victoirie	victoirie	PROPN
tahrj-8728	208	7	umuhoza	umuhoza	PROPN
tahrj-8728	208	8	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	208	9	2017	2017	NUM
tahrj-8728	208	10	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	208	11	applicant	applicant	NOUN
tahrj-8728	208	12	argued	argue	VERB
tahrj-8728	208	13	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	208	14	rwanda	rwanda	PROPN
tahrj-8728	208	15	interfered	interfere	VERB
tahrj-8728	208	16	with	with	ADP
tahrj-8728	208	17	his	his	PRON
tahrj-8728	208	18	freedom	freedom	NOUN
tahrj-8728	208	19	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	208	20	expression	expression	NOUN
tahrj-8728	208	21	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	208	22	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	208	23	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	208	24	upheld	uphold	VERB
tahrj-8728	208	25	it	it	PRON
tahrj-8728	208	26	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	209	1	rwanda	rwanda	PROPN
tahrj-8728	209	2	argued	argue	VERB
tahrj-8728	209	3	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	209	4	they	they	PRON
tahrj-8728	209	5	intended	intend	VERB
tahrj-8728	209	6	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	209	7	minimise	minimise	VERB
tahrj-8728	209	8	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	209	9	risk	risk	NOUN
tahrj-8728	209	10	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	209	11	‘	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	209	12	double	double	ADJ
tahrj-8728	209	13	genocide	genocide	NOUN
tahrj-8728	209	14	’	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	209	15	incited	incite	VERB
tahrj-8728	209	16	by	by	ADP
tahrj-8728	209	17	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	209	18	applicant	applicant	NOUN
tahrj-8728	209	19	turning	turn	VERB
tahrj-8728	209	20	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	209	21	citizens	citizen	NOUN
tahrj-8728	209	22	against	against	ADP
tahrj-8728	209	23	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	209	24	government	government	NOUN
tahrj-8728	209	25	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	209	26	spreading	spread	VERB
tahrj-8728	209	27	rumors	rumor	NOUN
tahrj-8728	209	28	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	209	29	internal	internal	ADJ
tahrj-8728	209	30	strife	strife	NOUN
tahrj-8728	209	31	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	210	1	however	however	ADV
tahrj-8728	210	2	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	210	3	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	210	4	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	210	5	stated	state	VERB
tahrj-8728	210	6	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	210	7	while	while	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	210	8	it	it	PRON
tahrj-8728	210	9	acknowledged	acknowledge	VERB
tahrj-8728	210	10	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	210	11	history	history	NOUN
tahrj-8728	210	12	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	210	13	genocide	genocide	NOUN
tahrj-8728	210	14	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	210	15	rwanda	rwanda	PROPN
tahrj-8728	210	16	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	210	17	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	210	18	need	need	NOUN
tahrj-8728	210	19	for	for	ADP
tahrj-8728	210	20	measures	measure	NOUN
tahrj-8728	210	21	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	210	22	be	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	210	23	adopted	adopt	VERB
tahrj-8728	210	24	not	not	PART
tahrj-8728	210	25	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	210	26	incite	incite	VERB
tahrj-8728	210	27	another	another	PRON
tahrj-8728	210	28	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	210	29	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	210	30	said	say	VERB
tahrj-8728	210	31	restrictions	restriction	NOUN
tahrj-8728	210	32	are	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	210	33	disproportionate	disproportionate	ADJ
tahrj-8728	210	34	restrictions	restriction	NOUN
tahrj-8728	210	35	on	on	ADP
tahrj-8728	210	36	his	his	PRON
tahrj-8728	210	37	human	human	ADJ
tahrj-8728	210	38	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	210	39	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	211	1	while	while	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	211	2	this	this	PRON
tahrj-8728	211	3	is	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	211	4	not	not	PART
tahrj-8728	211	5	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	211	6	general	general	ADJ
tahrj-8728	211	7	trend	trend	NOUN
tahrj-8728	211	8	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	211	9	shut	shut	VERB
tahrj-8728	211	10	down	down	ADP
tahrj-8728	211	11	all	all	DET
tahrj-8728	211	12	arguments	argument	NOUN
tahrj-8728	211	13	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	211	14	margin	margin	NOUN
tahrj-8728	211	15	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	211	16	appreciation	appreciation	NOUN
tahrj-8728	211	17	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	211	18	it	it	PRON
tahrj-8728	211	19	can	can	AUX
tahrj-8728	211	20	be	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	211	21	concluded	conclude	VERB
tahrj-8728	211	22	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	211	23	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	211	24	acthpr	acthpr	NOUN
tahrj-8728	211	25	generally	generally	ADV
tahrj-8728	211	26	has	have	VERB
tahrj-8728	211	27	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	211	28	cautious	cautious	ADJ
tahrj-8728	211	29	approach	approach	NOUN
tahrj-8728	211	30	while	while	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	211	31	dealing	deal	VERB
tahrj-8728	211	32	with	with	ADP
tahrj-8728	211	33	‘	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	211	34	margin	margin	NOUN
tahrj-8728	211	35	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	211	36	appreciation	appreciation	NOUN
tahrj-8728	211	37	’	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	211	38	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	211	39	human	human	ADJ
tahrj-8728	211	40	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	211	41	cases	case	NOUN
tahrj-8728	211	42	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	212	1	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	212	2	careful	careful	ADJ
tahrj-8728	212	3	look	look	NOUN
tahrj-8728	212	4	suggests	suggest	VERB
tahrj-8728	212	5	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	212	6	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	212	7	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	212	8	does	do	AUX
tahrj-8728	212	9	not	not	PART
tahrj-8728	212	10	adopt	adopt	VERB
tahrj-8728	212	11	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	212	12	mere	mere	ADJ
tahrj-8728	212	13	procedural	procedural	ADJ
tahrj-8728	212	14	approach	approach	NOUN
tahrj-8728	212	15	while	while	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	212	16	determining	determine	VERB
tahrj-8728	212	17	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	212	18	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	212	19	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	212	20	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	212	21	state	state	NOUN
tahrj-8728	212	22	measure	measure	NOUN
tahrj-8728	212	23	but	but	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	212	24	scrutinises	scrutinise	VERB
tahrj-8728	212	25	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	212	26	decision	decision	NOUN
tahrj-8728	212	27	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	213	1	this	this	PRON
tahrj-8728	213	2	means	mean	VERB
tahrj-8728	213	3	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	213	4	only	only	ADV
tahrj-8728	213	5	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
tahrj-8728	213	6	reasons	reason	NOUN
tahrj-8728	213	7	for	for	ADP
tahrj-8728	213	8	carrying	carry	VERB
tahrj-8728	213	9	out	out	ADP
tahrj-8728	213	10	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	213	11	measure	measure	NOUN
tahrj-8728	213	12	are	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	213	13	not	not	PART
tahrj-8728	213	14	enough	enough	ADJ
tahrj-8728	213	15	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	213	16	it	it	PRON
tahrj-8728	213	17	is	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	213	18	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	213	19	be	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	213	20	assessed	assess	VERB
tahrj-8728	213	21	if	if	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	213	22	such	such	DET
tahrj-8728	213	23	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	213	24	measure	measure	NOUN
tahrj-8728	213	25	is	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	213	26	also	also	ADV
tahrj-8728	213	27	necessary	necessary	ADJ
tahrj-8728	213	28	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	213	29	proportional	proportional	ADJ
tahrj-8728	213	30	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	213	31	achieve	achieve	VERB
tahrj-8728	213	32	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	213	33	objective	objective	NOUN
tahrj-8728	213	34	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	214	1	this	this	PRON
tahrj-8728	214	2	means	mean	VERB
tahrj-8728	214	3	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	214	4	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	214	5	acthpr	acthpr	ADJ
tahrj-8728	214	6	jurisprudence	jurisprudence	NOUN
tahrj-8728	214	7	is	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	214	8	entirely	entirely	ADV
tahrj-8728	214	9	based	base	VERB
tahrj-8728	214	10	on	on	ADP
tahrj-8728	214	11	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	214	12	‘	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	214	13	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	214	14	analysis	analysis	NOUN
tahrj-8728	214	15	’	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	214	16	instead	instead	ADV
tahrj-8728	214	17	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	214	18	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	214	19	‘	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	214	20	wednesbury	wednesbury	NOUN
tahrj-8728	214	21	principle	principle	NOUN
tahrj-8728	214	22	’	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	214	23	so	so	ADV
tahrj-8728	214	24	far	far	ADV
tahrj-8728	214	25	as	as	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	214	26	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	214	27	human	human	ADJ
tahrj-8728	214	28	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	214	29	case	case	NOUN
tahrj-8728	214	30	is	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	214	31	concerned	concern	VERB
tahrj-8728	214	32	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	215	1	however	however	ADV
tahrj-8728	215	2	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	215	3	there	there	PRON
tahrj-8728	215	4	has	have	AUX
tahrj-8728	215	5	been	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	215	6	no	no	DET
tahrj-8728	215	7	direct	direct	ADJ
tahrj-8728	215	8	application	application	NOUN
tahrj-8728	215	9	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	215	10	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	215	11	analysis	analysis	NOUN
tahrj-8728	215	12	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	215	13	nonrefoulement	nonrefoulement	ADJ
tahrj-8728	215	14	cases	case	NOUN
tahrj-8728	215	15	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	216	1	nevertheless	nevertheless	ADV
tahrj-8728	216	2	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	216	3	anudo	anudo	NOUN
tahrj-8728	216	4	ochieng	ochieng	PROPN
tahrj-8728	216	5	anudo	anudo	PROPN
tahrj-8728	216	6	v.	v.	PROPN
tahrj-8728	216	7	united	united	PROPN
tahrj-8728	216	8	republic	republic	PROPN
tahrj-8728	216	9	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	216	10	tanzania	tanzania	PROPN
tahrj-8728	216	11	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	216	12	2018	2018	NUM
tahrj-8728	216	13	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	216	14	comes	come	VERB
tahrj-8728	216	15	very	very	ADV
tahrj-8728	216	16	close	close	ADV
tahrj-8728	216	17	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	216	18	such	such	ADJ
tahrj-8728	216	19	determination	determination	NOUN
tahrj-8728	216	20	so	so	ADV
tahrj-8728	216	21	far	far	ADV
tahrj-8728	216	22	as	as	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	216	23	‘	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	216	24	arbitrary	arbitrary	ADJ
tahrj-8728	216	25	removal	removal	NOUN
tahrj-8728	216	26	’	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	216	27	is	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	216	28	concerned	concern	VERB
tahrj-8728	216	29	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	217	1	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	217	2	this	this	DET
tahrj-8728	217	3	case	case	NOUN
tahrj-8728	217	4	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	217	5	mr	mr	PROPN
tahrj-8728	217	6	.	.	PROPN
tahrj-8728	217	7	anudo	anudo	PROPN
tahrj-8728	217	8	was	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	217	9	forced	force	VERB
tahrj-8728	217	10	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	217	11	live	live	VERB
tahrj-8728	217	12	between	between	ADP
tahrj-8728	217	13	non	non	ADJ
tahrj-8728	217	14	-	-	ADJ
tahrj-8728	217	15	man	man	ADJ
tahrj-8728	217	16	’s	’s	PART
tahrj-8728	217	17	border	border	NOUN
tahrj-8728	217	18	between	between	ADP
tahrj-8728	217	19	tanzania	tanzania	PROPN
tahrj-8728	217	20	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	217	21	kenya	kenya	NOUN
tahrj-8728	217	22	as	as	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	217	23	neither	neither	DET
tahrj-8728	217	24	country	country	NOUN
tahrj-8728	217	25	recognized	recognize	VERB
tahrj-8728	217	26	him	he	PRON
tahrj-8728	217	27	as	as	ADP
tahrj-8728	217	28	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	217	29	citizen	citizen	NOUN
tahrj-8728	217	30	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	218	1	he	he	PRON
tahrj-8728	218	2	applied	apply	VERB
tahrj-8728	218	3	for	for	ADP
tahrj-8728	218	4	marriage	marriage	NOUN
tahrj-8728	218	5	licenses	license	NOUN
tahrj-8728	218	6	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	218	7	was	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	218	8	accused	accuse	VERB
tahrj-8728	218	9	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	218	10	misrepresentation	misrepresentation	NOUN
tahrj-8728	218	11	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	218	12	leading	lead	VERB
tahrj-8728	218	13	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	218	14	his	his	PRON
tahrj-8728	218	15	expulsion	expulsion	NOUN
tahrj-8728	218	16	from	from	ADP
tahrj-8728	218	17	tanzania	tanzania	PROPN
tahrj-8728	218	18	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	218	19	kenya	kenya	PROPN
tahrj-8728	218	20	where	where	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	218	21	he	he	PRON
tahrj-8728	218	22	was	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	218	23	arrested	arrest	VERB
tahrj-8728	218	24	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	218	25	convicted	convict	VERB
tahrj-8728	218	26	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	219	1	mr	mr	PROPN
tahrj-8728	219	2	.	.	PROPN
tahrj-8728	219	3	anudo	anudo	PROPN
tahrj-8728	219	4	challenged	challenge	VERB
tahrj-8728	219	5	tanzania	tanzania	PROPN
tahrj-8728	219	6	’s	’s	PART
tahrj-8728	219	7	action	action	NOUN
tahrj-8728	219	8	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	219	9	removal	removal	NOUN
tahrj-8728	219	10	or	or	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	219	11	deportation	deportation	NOUN
tahrj-8728	219	12	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	219	13	kenya	kenya	NOUN
tahrj-8728	219	14	under	under	ADP
tahrj-8728	219	15	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	219	16	african	african	ADJ
tahrj-8728	219	17	charter	charter	NOUN
tahrj-8728	219	18	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	219	19	human	human	NOUN
tahrj-8728	219	20	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	219	21	people	people	NOUN
tahrj-8728	219	22	’s	’s	PART
tahrj-8728	219	23	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	219	24	calling	call	VERB
tahrj-8728	219	25	such	such	ADJ
tahrj-8728	219	26	removal	removal	NOUN
tahrj-8728	219	27	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	219	28	deprivation	deprivation	NOUN
tahrj-8728	219	29	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	219	30	nationality	nationality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	219	31	as	as	ADP
tahrj-8728	219	32	arbitrary	arbitrary	ADJ
tahrj-8728	219	33	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	220	1	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	220	2	close	close	ADJ
tahrj-8728	220	3	observation	observation	NOUN
tahrj-8728	220	4	suggests	suggest	VERB
tahrj-8728	220	5	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	220	6	shift	shift	NOUN
tahrj-8728	220	7	towards	towards	ADP
tahrj-8728	220	8	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	220	9	‘	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	220	10	wednesbury	wednesbury	NOUN
tahrj-8728	220	11	principle	principle	NOUN
tahrj-8728	220	12	’	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	220	13	or	or	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	220	14	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	220	15	more	more	ADV
tahrj-8728	220	16	procedural	procedural	ADJ
tahrj-8728	220	17	approach	approach	NOUN
tahrj-8728	220	18	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	221	1	as	as	ADV
tahrj-8728	221	2	disappointing	disappointing	ADJ
tahrj-8728	221	3	as	as	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	221	4	this	this	PRON
tahrj-8728	221	5	may	may	AUX
tahrj-8728	221	6	come	come	VERB
tahrj-8728	221	7	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	221	8	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	221	9	consistent	consistent	ADJ
tahrj-8728	221	10	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	221	11	analysis	analysis	NOUN
tahrj-8728	221	12	jurisprudence	jurisprudence	NOUN
tahrj-8728	221	13	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	221	14	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	221	15	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	221	16	does	do	AUX
tahrj-8728	221	17	allow	allow	VERB
tahrj-8728	221	18	more	more	ADJ
tahrj-8728	221	19	discretionary	discretionary	ADJ
tahrj-8728	221	20	space	space	NOUN
tahrj-8728	221	21	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	221	22	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	221	23	state	state	NOUN
tahrj-8728	221	24	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	221	25	cases	case	NOUN
tahrj-8728	221	26	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	221	27	removal	removal	NOUN
tahrj-8728	221	28	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	221	29	assesses	assesse	NOUN
tahrj-8728	221	30	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	221	31	only	only	ADV
tahrj-8728	221	32	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	221	33	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	221	34	extent	extent	NOUN
tahrj-8728	221	35	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	221	36	determining	determine	VERB
tahrj-8728	221	37	‘	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	221	38	whether	whether	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	221	39	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	221	40	given	give	VERB
tahrj-8728	221	41	interference	interference	NOUN
tahrj-8728	221	42	reasonably	reasonably	ADV
tahrj-8728	221	43	consists	consist	VERB
tahrj-8728	221	44	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	221	45	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	221	46	reasonable	reasonable	ADJ
tahrj-8728	221	47	approach	approach	NOUN
tahrj-8728	221	48	’	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	221	49	–	–	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	221	50	meaning	mean	VERB
tahrj-8728	221	51	whether	whether	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	221	52	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	221	53	authorities	authority	NOUN
tahrj-8728	221	54	supplied	supply	VERB
tahrj-8728	221	55	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
tahrj-8728	221	56	reasons	reason	NOUN
tahrj-8728	221	57	for	for	ADP
tahrj-8728	221	58	their	their	PRON
tahrj-8728	221	59	actions	action	NOUN
tahrj-8728	221	60	?	?	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	222	1	this	this	PRON
tahrj-8728	222	2	does	do	AUX
tahrj-8728	222	3	not	not	PART
tahrj-8728	222	4	carry	carry	VERB
tahrj-8728	222	5	out	out	ADP
tahrj-8728	222	6	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	222	7	analysis	analysis	NOUN
tahrj-8728	222	8	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	222	9	detail	detail	NOUN
tahrj-8728	222	10	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	222	11	however	however	ADV
tahrj-8728	222	12	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	222	13	still	still	ADV
tahrj-8728	222	14	determines	determine	VERB
tahrj-8728	222	15	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	222	16	sufficiency	sufficiency	NOUN
tahrj-8728	222	17	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	222	18	reasons	reason	NOUN
tahrj-8728	222	19	by	by	ADP
tahrj-8728	222	20	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	222	21	state	state	NOUN
tahrj-8728	222	22	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	222	23	suggesting	suggest	VERB
tahrj-8728	222	24	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	222	25	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	222	26	-	-	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	222	27	like	like	ADJ
tahrj-8728	222	28	analysis	analysis	NOUN
tahrj-8728	222	29	which	which	PRON
tahrj-8728	222	30	is	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	222	31	not	not	PART
tahrj-8728	222	32	completely	completely	ADV
tahrj-8728	222	33	wednesbury	wednesbury	NOUN
tahrj-8728	222	34	either	either	ADV
tahrj-8728	222	35	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	223	1	therefore	therefore	ADV
tahrj-8728	223	2	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	223	3	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	223	4	this	this	DET
tahrj-8728	223	5	case	case	NOUN
tahrj-8728	223	6	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	223	7	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	223	8	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	223	9	decided	decide	VERB
tahrj-8728	223	10	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	223	11	tanzania	tanzania	PROPN
tahrj-8728	223	12	had	have	AUX
tahrj-8728	223	13	violated	violate	VERB
tahrj-8728	223	14	iccpr	iccpr	ADV
tahrj-8728	223	15	by	by	ADP
tahrj-8728	223	16	expelling	expel	VERB
tahrj-8728	223	17	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	223	18	applicant	applicant	NOUN
tahrj-8728	223	19	without	without	ADP
tahrj-8728	223	20	presenting	present	VERB
tahrj-8728	223	21	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
tahrj-8728	223	22	reasons	reason	NOUN
tahrj-8728	223	23	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	224	1	however	however	ADV
tahrj-8728	224	2	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	224	3	it	it	PRON
tahrj-8728	224	4	did	do	AUX
tahrj-8728	224	5	not	not	PART
tahrj-8728	224	6	analyse	analyse	VERB
tahrj-8728	224	7	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	224	8	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	224	9	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	224	10	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	224	11	decision	decision	NOUN
tahrj-8728	224	12	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	225	1	here	here	ADV
tahrj-8728	225	2	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	225	3	although	although	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	225	4	his	his	PRON
tahrj-8728	225	5	nationality	nationality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	225	6	was	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	225	7	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	225	8	question	question	NOUN
tahrj-8728	225	9	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	225	10	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	225	11	he	he	PRON
tahrj-8728	225	12	was	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	225	13	not	not	PART
tahrj-8728	225	14	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	225	15	refugee	refugee	NOUN
tahrj-8728	225	16	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	225	17	such	such	ADJ
tahrj-8728	225	18	reasoning	reasoning	NOUN
tahrj-8728	225	19	can	can	AUX
tahrj-8728	225	20	be	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	225	21	seen	see	VERB
tahrj-8728	225	22	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	225	23	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	225	24	light	light	NOUN
tahrj-8728	225	25	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	225	26	arbitrary	arbitrary	ADJ
tahrj-8728	225	27	removal	removal	NOUN
tahrj-8728	225	28	irrespective	irrespective	ADV
tahrj-8728	225	29	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	225	30	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	225	31	status	status	NOUN
tahrj-8728	225	32	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	225	33	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	225	34	applicant	applicant	NOUN
tahrj-8728	225	35	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	226	1	https://doi.org/10.17561/tahrj.v23.8728	https://doi.org/10.17561/tahrj.v23.8728	PROPN
tahrj-8728	226	2	sabreen	sabreen	PROPN
tahrj-8728	226	3	ahmed	ahme	VERB
tahrj-8728	226	4	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	226	5	age	age	NOUN
tahrj-8728	226	6	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	226	7	human	human	ADJ
tahrj-8728	226	8	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	226	9	journal	journal	NOUN
tahrj-8728	226	10	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	226	11	24	24	NUM
tahrj-8728	226	12	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	226	13	june	june	PROPN
tahrj-8728	226	14	2025	2025	NUM
tahrj-8728	226	15	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	226	16	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	226	17	e8728	e8728	PROPN
tahrj-8728	226	18	issn	issn	PROPN
tahrj-8728	226	19	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	226	20	2340	2340	NUM
tahrj-8728	226	21	-	-	SYM
tahrj-8728	226	22	9592	9592	NUM
tahrj-8728	226	23	doi	doi	NOUN
tahrj-8728	226	24	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	226	25	10.17561	10.17561	NUM
tahrj-8728	226	26	/	/	SYM
tahrj-8728	226	27	tahrj.v23.8728	tahrj.v23.8728	PROPN
tahrj-8728	226	28	13	13	NUM
tahrj-8728	226	29	2.1	2.1	NUM
tahrj-8728	226	30	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	227	1	national	national	ADJ
tahrj-8728	227	2	courts	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	227	3	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	227	4	africa	africa	PROPN
tahrj-8728	227	5	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	227	6	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	227	7	analysis	analysis	NOUN
tahrj-8728	227	8	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	227	9	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	227	10	threshold	threshold	NOUN
tahrj-8728	227	11	?	?	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	228	1	contrary	contrary	ADJ
tahrj-8728	228	2	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	228	3	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	228	4	direct	direct	ADJ
tahrj-8728	228	5	application	application	NOUN
tahrj-8728	228	6	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	228	7	such	such	DET
tahrj-8728	228	8	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	228	9	balancing	balancing	NOUN
tahrj-8728	228	10	mechanism	mechanism	NOUN
tahrj-8728	228	11	with	with	ADP
tahrj-8728	228	12	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	228	13	regional	regional	ADJ
tahrj-8728	228	14	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	228	15	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	228	16	such	such	ADJ
tahrj-8728	228	17	application	application	NOUN
tahrj-8728	228	18	can	can	AUX
tahrj-8728	228	19	be	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	228	20	found	find	VERB
tahrj-8728	228	21	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	228	22	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	228	23	approaches	approach	NOUN
tahrj-8728	228	24	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	228	25	national	national	ADJ
tahrj-8728	228	26	courts	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	228	27	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	228	28	africa	africa	PROPN
tahrj-8728	228	29	like	like	ADP
tahrj-8728	228	30	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	228	31	kenya	kenya	PROPN
tahrj-8728	228	32	high	high	PROPN
tahrj-8728	228	33	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	228	34	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	229	1	such	such	ADJ
tahrj-8728	229	2	application	application	NOUN
tahrj-8728	229	3	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	229	4	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	229	5	analysis	analysis	NOUN
tahrj-8728	229	6	by	by	ADP
tahrj-8728	229	7	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	229	8	judiciary	judiciary	NOUN
tahrj-8728	229	9	is	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	229	10	constitutionally	constitutionally	ADV
tahrj-8728	229	11	motivated	motivated	ADJ
tahrj-8728	229	12	due	due	ADP
tahrj-8728	229	13	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	229	14	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	229	15	presence	presence	NOUN
tahrj-8728	229	16	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	229	17	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	229	18	specific	specific	ADJ
tahrj-8728	229	19	limitation	limitation	NOUN
tahrj-8728	229	20	clause	clause	NOUN
tahrj-8728	229	21	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	229	22	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	229	23	constitution	constitution	NOUN
tahrj-8728	229	24	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	229	25	kenya	kenya	PROPN
tahrj-8728	229	26	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	229	27	2010	2010	NUM
tahrj-8728	229	28	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	229	29	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	230	1	kenya	kenya	PROPN
tahrj-8728	230	2	is	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	230	3	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	230	4	signatory	signatory	NOUN
tahrj-8728	230	5	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	230	6	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	230	7	1951	1951	NUM
tahrj-8728	230	8	convention	convention	NOUN
tahrj-8728	230	9	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	230	10	1967	1967	NUM
tahrj-8728	230	11	protocol	protocol	NOUN
tahrj-8728	230	12	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	230	13	au	au	PROPN
tahrj-8728	230	14	convention	convention	PROPN
tahrj-8728	230	15	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	230	16	iccpr	iccpr	PROPN
tahrj-8728	230	17	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	230	18	icescr	icescr	NOUN
tahrj-8728	230	19	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	230	20	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	230	21	african	african	ADJ
tahrj-8728	230	22	charter	charter	NOUN
tahrj-8728	230	23	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	230	24	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	230	25	udhr	udhr	ADV
tahrj-8728	230	26	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	231	1	domestically	domestically	ADV
tahrj-8728	231	2	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	231	3	it	it	PRON
tahrj-8728	231	4	has	have	VERB
tahrj-8728	231	5	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	231	6	refugee	refugee	PROPN
tahrj-8728	231	7	act	act	NOUN
tahrj-8728	231	8	2006	2006	NUM
tahrj-8728	231	9	along	along	ADP
tahrj-8728	231	10	with	with	ADP
tahrj-8728	231	11	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	231	12	constitution	constitution	NOUN
tahrj-8728	231	13	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	231	14	kenya	kenya	PROPN
tahrj-8728	231	15	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	232	1	sections	section	NOUN
tahrj-8728	232	2	4	4	NUM
tahrj-8728	232	3	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	232	4	16	16	NUM
tahrj-8728	232	5	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	232	6	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	232	7	refugee	refugee	NOUN
tahrj-8728	232	8	act	act	NOUN
tahrj-8728	232	9	crystallize	crystallize	VERB
tahrj-8728	232	10	art	art	NOUN
tahrj-8728	232	11	33	33	NUM
tahrj-8728	232	12	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	232	13	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	232	14	exceptions	exception	NOUN
tahrj-8728	232	15	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	232	16	art	art	NOUN
tahrj-8728	232	17	33(2	33(2	NOUN
tahrj-8728	232	18	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	232	19	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	232	20	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	232	21	1951	1951	NUM
tahrj-8728	232	22	refugee	refugee	NOUN
tahrj-8728	232	23	convention	convention	NOUN
tahrj-8728	232	24	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	233	1	art	art	NOUN
tahrj-8728	233	2	24	24	NUM
tahrj-8728	233	3	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	233	4	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	233	5	constitution	constitution	NOUN
tahrj-8728	233	6	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	233	7	kenya	kenya	PROPN
tahrj-8728	233	8	also	also	ADV
tahrj-8728	233	9	allows	allow	VERB
tahrj-8728	233	10	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	233	11	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	233	12	bill	bill	NOUN
tahrj-8728	233	13	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	233	14	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	233	15	may	may	AUX
tahrj-8728	233	16	be	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	233	17	limited	limit	VERB
tahrj-8728	233	18	given	give	VERB
tahrj-8728	233	19	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	233	20	limitation	limitation	NOUN
tahrj-8728	233	21	is	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	233	22	reasonable	reasonable	ADJ
tahrj-8728	233	23	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	233	24	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	233	25	justifiable	justifiable	ADJ
tahrj-8728	233	26	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	233	27	an	an	DET
tahrj-8728	233	28	open	open	ADJ
tahrj-8728	233	29	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	233	30	democratic	democratic	ADJ
tahrj-8728	233	31	society	society	NOUN
tahrj-8728	233	32	based	base	VERB
tahrj-8728	233	33	on	on	ADP
tahrj-8728	233	34	human	human	ADJ
tahrj-8728	233	35	dignity	dignity	NOUN
tahrj-8728	233	36	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	233	37	equality	equality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	233	38	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	233	39	freedom	freedom	NOUN
tahrj-8728	233	40	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	233	41	taking	take	VERB
tahrj-8728	233	42	into	into	ADP
tahrj-8728	233	43	account	account	NOUN
tahrj-8728	233	44	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	233	45	relevant	relevant	ADJ
tahrj-8728	233	46	factors	factor	NOUN
tahrj-8728	233	47	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	233	48	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	233	49	a	a	X
tahrj-8728	233	50	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	233	51	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	233	52	nature	nature	NOUN
tahrj-8728	233	53	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	233	54	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	233	55	or	or	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	233	56	fundamental	fundamental	ADJ
tahrj-8728	233	57	freedoms	freedom	NOUN
tahrj-8728	233	58	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	233	59	b	b	NOUN
tahrj-8728	233	60	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	233	61	importance	importance	NOUN
tahrj-8728	233	62	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	233	63	purpose	purpose	NOUN
tahrj-8728	233	64	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	233	65	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	233	66	limitation	limitation	NOUN
tahrj-8728	233	67	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	233	68	c	c	NOUN
tahrj-8728	233	69	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	233	70	nature	nature	NOUN
tahrj-8728	233	71	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	233	72	extent	extent	NOUN
tahrj-8728	233	73	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	233	74	limitation	limitation	NOUN
tahrj-8728	233	75	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	233	76	d	d	X
tahrj-8728	233	77	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	233	78	need	need	VERB
tahrj-8728	233	79	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	233	80	ensure	ensure	VERB
tahrj-8728	233	81	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	233	82	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	233	83	enjoyment	enjoyment	NOUN
tahrj-8728	233	84	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	233	85	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	233	86	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	233	87	fundamental	fundamental	ADJ
tahrj-8728	233	88	freedom	freedom	NOUN
tahrj-8728	233	89	by	by	ADP
tahrj-8728	233	90	any	any	DET
tahrj-8728	233	91	individual	individual	NOUN
tahrj-8728	233	92	does	do	AUX
tahrj-8728	233	93	not	not	PART
tahrj-8728	233	94	prejudice	prejudice	VERB
tahrj-8728	233	95	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	233	96	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	233	97	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	233	98	fundamental	fundamental	ADJ
tahrj-8728	233	99	freedoms	freedom	NOUN
tahrj-8728	233	100	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	233	101	others	other	NOUN
tahrj-8728	233	102	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	233	103	e	e	NOUN
tahrj-8728	233	104	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	233	105	relation	relation	NOUN
tahrj-8728	233	106	between	between	ADP
tahrj-8728	233	107	limitation	limitation	NOUN
tahrj-8728	233	108	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	233	109	its	its	PRON
tahrj-8728	233	110	purpose	purpose	NOUN
tahrj-8728	233	111	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	233	112	whether	whether	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	233	113	there	there	PRON
tahrj-8728	233	114	are	be	VERB
tahrj-8728	233	115	less	less	ADV
tahrj-8728	233	116	restrictive	restrictive	ADJ
tahrj-8728	233	117	means	mean	NOUN
tahrj-8728	233	118	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	233	119	achieve	achieve	VERB
tahrj-8728	233	120	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	233	121	purpose	purpose	NOUN
tahrj-8728	233	122	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	234	1	this	this	PRON
tahrj-8728	234	2	means	mean	VERB
tahrj-8728	234	3	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	234	4	if	if	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	234	5	national	national	ADJ
tahrj-8728	234	6	security	security	NOUN
tahrj-8728	234	7	is	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	234	8	cited	cite	VERB
tahrj-8728	234	9	as	as	ADP
tahrj-8728	234	10	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	234	11	reason	reason	NOUN
tahrj-8728	234	12	for	for	ADP
tahrj-8728	234	13	imposing	impose	VERB
tahrj-8728	234	14	any	any	DET
tahrj-8728	234	15	restrictive	restrictive	ADJ
tahrj-8728	234	16	measures	measure	NOUN
tahrj-8728	234	17	on	on	ADP
tahrj-8728	234	18	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	234	19	enjoyment	enjoyment	NOUN
tahrj-8728	234	20	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	234	21	fundamental	fundamental	ADJ
tahrj-8728	234	22	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	234	23	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	234	24	refugees	refugee	NOUN
tahrj-8728	234	25	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	234	26	states	state	NOUN
tahrj-8728	234	27	must	must	AUX
tahrj-8728	234	28	demonstrate	demonstrate	VERB
tahrj-8728	234	29	how	how	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	234	30	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	234	31	specific	specific	ADJ
tahrj-8728	234	32	person	person	NOUN
tahrj-8728	234	33	's	's	PART
tahrj-8728	234	34	presence	presence	NOUN
tahrj-8728	234	35	or	or	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	234	36	activity	activity	NOUN
tahrj-8728	234	37	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	234	38	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	234	39	area	area	NOUN
tahrj-8728	234	40	is	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	234	41	causing	cause	VERB
tahrj-8728	234	42	danger	danger	NOUN
tahrj-8728	234	43	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	234	44	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	234	45	country	country	NOUN
tahrj-8728	234	46	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	235	1	also	also	ADV
tahrj-8728	235	2	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	235	3	how	how	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	235	4	his	his	PRON
tahrj-8728	235	5	or	or	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	235	6	her	her	PRON
tahrj-8728	235	7	removal	removal	NOUN
tahrj-8728	235	8	would	would	AUX
tahrj-8728	235	9	alleviate	alleviate	VERB
tahrj-8728	235	10	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	235	11	menace	menace	NOUN
tahrj-8728	235	12	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	236	1	interpreting	interpret	VERB
tahrj-8728	236	2	art	art	NOUN
tahrj-8728	236	3	24	24	NUM
tahrj-8728	236	4	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	236	5	randu	randu	NOUN
tahrj-8728	236	6	nzai	nzai	ADV
tahrj-8728	236	7	ruwa	ruwa	ADV
tahrj-8728	236	8	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	236	9	others	other	NOUN
tahrj-8728	236	10	v.	v.	ADP
tahrj-8728	236	11	minister	minister	PROPN
tahrj-8728	236	12	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	236	13	internal	internal	ADJ
tahrj-8728	236	14	security	security	NOUN
tahrj-8728	236	15	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	236	16	another	another	PRON
tahrj-8728	236	17	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	236	18	2012	2012	NUM
tahrj-8728	236	19	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	236	20	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	236	21	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	236	22	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	236	23	stated	state	VERB
tahrj-8728	236	24	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	236	25	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	236	26	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	236	27	arm	arm	NOUN
tahrj-8728	236	28	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	236	29	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	236	30	government	government	NOUN
tahrj-8728	236	31	is	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	236	32	best	well	ADV
tahrj-8728	236	33	suited	suited	ADJ
tahrj-8728	236	34	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	236	35	decide	decide	VERB
tahrj-8728	236	36	national	national	ADJ
tahrj-8728	236	37	security	security	NOUN
tahrj-8728	236	38	matters	matter	NOUN
tahrj-8728	236	39	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	237	1	what	what	PRON
tahrj-8728	237	2	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	237	3	government	government	NOUN
tahrj-8728	237	4	says	say	VERB
tahrj-8728	237	5	about	about	ADP
tahrj-8728	237	6	national	national	ADJ
tahrj-8728	237	7	security	security	NOUN
tahrj-8728	237	8	should	should	AUX
tahrj-8728	237	9	normally	normally	ADV
tahrj-8728	237	10	be	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	237	11	believed	believe	VERB
tahrj-8728	237	12	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	238	1	however	however	ADV
tahrj-8728	238	2	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	238	3	when	when	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	238	4	there	there	PRON
tahrj-8728	238	5	is	be	VERB
tahrj-8728	238	6	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	238	7	complaint	complaint	NOUN
tahrj-8728	238	8	about	about	ADP
tahrj-8728	238	9	wrongfully	wrongfully	ADV
tahrj-8728	238	10	invoking	invoke	VERB
tahrj-8728	238	11	national	national	ADJ
tahrj-8728	238	12	security	security	NOUN
tahrj-8728	238	13	such	such	ADJ
tahrj-8728	238	14	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	238	15	it	it	PRON
tahrj-8728	238	16	implicates	implicate	VERB
tahrj-8728	238	17	fundamental	fundamental	ADJ
tahrj-8728	238	18	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	238	19	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	238	20	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	238	21	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	238	22	needs	need	VERB
tahrj-8728	238	23	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	238	24	be	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	238	25	judicially	judicially	ADV
tahrj-8728	238	26	satisfied	satisfied	ADJ
tahrj-8728	238	27	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	238	28	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	238	29	action	action	NOUN
tahrj-8728	238	30	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	238	31	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	238	32	state	state	NOUN
tahrj-8728	238	33	is	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	238	34	reasonable	reasonable	ADJ
tahrj-8728	238	35	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	238	36	justifiable	justifiable	ADJ
tahrj-8728	238	37	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	239	1	this	this	DET
tahrj-8728	239	2	line	line	NOUN
tahrj-8728	239	3	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	239	4	jurisprudence	jurisprudence	NOUN
tahrj-8728	239	5	was	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	239	6	also	also	ADV
tahrj-8728	239	7	followed	follow	VERB
tahrj-8728	239	8	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	239	9	kitua	kitua	PROPN
tahrj-8728	239	10	cha	cha	PROPN
tahrj-8728	239	11	sheria	sheria	PROPN
tahrj-8728	239	12	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	239	13	others	other	NOUN
tahrj-8728	239	14	v.	v.	ADP
tahrj-8728	239	15	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	239	16	attorney	attorney	NOUN
tahrj-8728	239	17	general	general	NOUN
tahrj-8728	239	18	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	239	19	2017	2017	NUM
tahrj-8728	239	20	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	239	21	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	240	1	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	240	2	state	state	NOUN
tahrj-8728	240	3	argued	argue	VERB
tahrj-8728	240	4	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	240	5	by	by	ADP
tahrj-8728	240	6	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	240	7	directive	directive	NOUN
tahrj-8728	240	8	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	240	9	all	all	DET
tahrj-8728	240	10	refugees	refugee	NOUN
tahrj-8728	240	11	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	240	12	asylum	asylum	NOUN
tahrj-8728	240	13	seekers	seeker	NOUN
tahrj-8728	240	14	must	must	AUX
tahrj-8728	240	15	reside	reside	VERB
tahrj-8728	240	16	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	240	17	gazette	gazette	PROPN
tahrj-8728	240	18	refugee	refugee	NOUN
tahrj-8728	240	19	camps	camp	NOUN
tahrj-8728	240	20	citing	cite	VERB
tahrj-8728	240	21	national	national	ADJ
tahrj-8728	240	22	security	security	NOUN
tahrj-8728	240	23	reasons	reason	NOUN
tahrj-8728	240	24	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	241	1	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	241	2	claimants	claimant	NOUN
tahrj-8728	241	3	argued	argue	VERB
tahrj-8728	241	4	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	241	5	it	it	PRON
tahrj-8728	241	6	violated	violate	VERB
tahrj-8728	241	7	art	art	NOUN
tahrj-8728	241	8	39	39	NUM
tahrj-8728	241	9	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	241	10	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	241	11	constitution	constitution	NOUN
tahrj-8728	241	12	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	241	13	kenya	kenya	PROPN
tahrj-8728	241	14	which	which	PRON
tahrj-8728	241	15	allowed	allow	VERB
tahrj-8728	241	16	freedom	freedom	NOUN
tahrj-8728	241	17	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	241	18	movement	movement	NOUN
tahrj-8728	241	19	for	for	ADP
tahrj-8728	241	20	all	all	PRON
tahrj-8728	241	21	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	242	1	further	far	ADV
tahrj-8728	242	2	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	242	3	they	they	PRON
tahrj-8728	242	4	claimed	claim	VERB
tahrj-8728	242	5	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	242	6	such	such	DET
tahrj-8728	242	7	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	242	8	limitation	limitation	NOUN
tahrj-8728	242	9	on	on	ADP
tahrj-8728	242	10	their	their	PRON
tahrj-8728	242	11	right	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	242	12	was	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	242	13	beyond	beyond	ADP
tahrj-8728	242	14	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	242	15	scope	scope	NOUN
tahrj-8728	242	16	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	242	17	art	art	NOUN
tahrj-8728	242	18	24	24	NUM
tahrj-8728	242	19	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	242	20	which	which	PRON
tahrj-8728	242	21	limits	limit	VERB
tahrj-8728	242	22	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	242	23	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	242	24	fundamental	fundamental	ADJ
tahrj-8728	242	25	freedoms	freedom	NOUN
tahrj-8728	242	26	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	243	1	arguing	argue	VERB
tahrj-8728	243	2	such	such	ADJ
tahrj-8728	243	3	containment	containment	NOUN
tahrj-8728	243	4	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	243	5	refugee	refugee	NOUN
tahrj-8728	243	6	camps	camp	NOUN
tahrj-8728	243	7	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	243	8	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	243	9	context	context	NOUN
tahrj-8728	243	10	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	243	11	non	non	ADJ
tahrj-8728	243	12	-	-	ADJ
tahrj-8728	243	13	refoulement	refoulement	ADJ
tahrj-8728	243	14	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	243	15	petitioners	petitioner	NOUN
tahrj-8728	243	16	argued	argue	VERB
tahrj-8728	243	17	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	243	18	after	after	ADP
tahrj-8728	243	19	moving	move	VERB
tahrj-8728	243	20	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	243	21	refugees	refugee	NOUN
tahrj-8728	243	22	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	243	23	refugee	refugee	NOUN
tahrj-8728	243	24	camps	camp	NOUN
tahrj-8728	243	25	they	they	PRON
tahrj-8728	243	26	would	would	AUX
tahrj-8728	243	27	be	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	243	28	sent	send	VERB
tahrj-8728	243	29	back	back	ADV
tahrj-8728	243	30	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	243	31	their	their	PRON
tahrj-8728	243	32	home	home	NOUN
tahrj-8728	243	33	countries	country	NOUN
tahrj-8728	243	34	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	244	1	https://doi.org/10.17561/tahrj.v23.8728	https://doi.org/10.17561/tahrj.v23.8728	NOUN
tahrj-8728	244	2	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	244	3	analysis	analysis	NOUN
tahrj-8728	244	4	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	244	5	non	non	ADJ
tahrj-8728	244	6	-	-	ADJ
tahrj-8728	244	7	refoulement	refoulement	ADJ
tahrj-8728	244	8	jurisprudence	jurisprudence	NOUN
tahrj-8728	244	9	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	244	10	india	india	PROPN
tahrj-8728	244	11	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	244	12	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	244	13	comparative	comparative	ADJ
tahrj-8728	244	14	approach	approach	NOUN
tahrj-8728	244	15	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	244	16	age	age	NOUN
tahrj-8728	244	17	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	244	18	human	human	ADJ
tahrj-8728	244	19	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	244	20	journal	journal	NOUN
tahrj-8728	244	21	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	244	22	24	24	NUM
tahrj-8728	244	23	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	244	24	june	june	PROPN
tahrj-8728	244	25	2025	2025	NUM
tahrj-8728	244	26	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	244	27	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	244	28	e8728	e8728	PROPN
tahrj-8728	244	29	issn	issn	PROPN
tahrj-8728	244	30	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	244	31	2340	2340	NUM
tahrj-8728	244	32	-	-	SYM
tahrj-8728	244	33	9592	9592	NUM
tahrj-8728	244	34	doi	doi	NOUN
tahrj-8728	244	35	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	244	36	10.17561	10.17561	NUM
tahrj-8728	244	37	/	/	SYM
tahrj-8728	244	38	tahrj.v23.8728	tahrj.v23.8728	PROPN
tahrj-8728	244	39	14	14	NUM
tahrj-8728	244	40	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	244	41	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	244	42	stated	state	VERB
tahrj-8728	244	43	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	244	44	firstly	firstly	ADV
tahrj-8728	244	45	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	244	46	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	244	47	real	real	ADJ
tahrj-8728	244	48	connection	connection	NOUN
tahrj-8728	244	49	must	must	AUX
tahrj-8728	244	50	be	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	244	51	established	establish	VERB
tahrj-8728	244	52	between	between	ADP
tahrj-8728	244	53	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	244	54	affected	affected	ADJ
tahrj-8728	244	55	persons	person	NOUN
tahrj-8728	244	56	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	244	57	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	244	58	danger	danger	NOUN
tahrj-8728	244	59	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	244	60	national	national	ADJ
tahrj-8728	244	61	security	security	NOUN
tahrj-8728	244	62	concerns	concern	NOUN
tahrj-8728	244	63	posed	pose	VERB
tahrj-8728	244	64	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	245	1	further	far	ADV
tahrj-8728	245	2	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	245	3	it	it	PRON
tahrj-8728	245	4	must	must	AUX
tahrj-8728	245	5	be	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	245	6	shown	show	VERB
tahrj-8728	245	7	how	how	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	245	8	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	245	9	removal	removal	NOUN
tahrj-8728	245	10	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	245	11	all	all	DET
tahrj-8728	245	12	urban	urban	ADJ
tahrj-8728	245	13	refugees	refugee	NOUN
tahrj-8728	245	14	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	245	15	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	245	16	refugee	refugee	NOUN
tahrj-8728	245	17	camps	camp	NOUN
tahrj-8728	245	18	can	can	AUX
tahrj-8728	245	19	alleviate	alleviate	VERB
tahrj-8728	245	20	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	245	21	insecurity	insecurity	NOUN
tahrj-8728	245	22	threats	threat	NOUN
tahrj-8728	245	23	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	246	1	additionally	additionally	ADV
tahrj-8728	246	2	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	246	3	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	246	4	risk	risk	NOUN
tahrj-8728	246	5	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	246	6	danger	danger	NOUN
tahrj-8728	246	7	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	246	8	suffering	suffering	NOUN
tahrj-8728	246	9	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	246	10	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	246	11	person	person	NOUN
tahrj-8728	246	12	concerned	concern	VERB
tahrj-8728	246	13	needs	need	VERB
tahrj-8728	246	14	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	246	15	be	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	246	16	squared	square	VERB
tahrj-8728	246	17	with	with	ADP
tahrj-8728	246	18	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	246	19	intended	intend	VERB
tahrj-8728	246	20	results	result	NOUN
tahrj-8728	246	21	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	247	1	finally	finally	ADV
tahrj-8728	247	2	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	247	3	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	247	4	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	247	5	held	hold	VERB
tahrj-8728	247	6	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	247	7	confining	confine	VERB
tahrj-8728	247	8	some	some	DET
tahrj-8728	247	9	persons	person	NOUN
tahrj-8728	247	10	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	247	11	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	247	12	refugee	refugee	NOUN
tahrj-8728	247	13	camps	camp	NOUN
tahrj-8728	247	14	does	do	AUX
tahrj-8728	247	15	not	not	PART
tahrj-8728	247	16	serve	serve	VERB
tahrj-8728	247	17	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	247	18	solve	solve	VERB
tahrj-8728	247	19	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	247	20	insecurity	insecurity	NOUN
tahrj-8728	247	21	problem	problem	NOUN
tahrj-8728	247	22	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	248	1	further	far	ADV
tahrj-8728	248	2	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	248	3	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	248	4	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	248	5	asserted	assert	VERB
tahrj-8728	248	6	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	248	7	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	248	8	while	while	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	248	9	national	national	ADJ
tahrj-8728	248	10	security	security	NOUN
tahrj-8728	248	11	can	can	AUX
tahrj-8728	248	12	not	not	PART
tahrj-8728	248	13	be	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	248	14	compromised	compromise	VERB
tahrj-8728	248	15	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	248	16	safeguards	safeguard	NOUN
tahrj-8728	248	17	must	must	AUX
tahrj-8728	248	18	bear	bear	VERB
tahrj-8728	248	19	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	248	20	relationship	relationship	NOUN
tahrj-8728	248	21	with	with	ADP
tahrj-8728	248	22	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	248	23	measures	measure	NOUN
tahrj-8728	248	24	taken	take	VERB
tahrj-8728	248	25	by	by	ADP
tahrj-8728	248	26	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	248	27	state	state	NOUN
tahrj-8728	248	28	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	249	1	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	249	2	state	state	NOUN
tahrj-8728	249	3	fails	fail	VERB
tahrj-8728	249	4	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	249	5	demonstrate	demonstrate	VERB
tahrj-8728	249	6	how	how	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	249	7	refugees	refugee	NOUN
tahrj-8728	249	8	are	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	249	9	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	249	10	main	main	ADJ
tahrj-8728	249	11	source	source	NOUN
tahrj-8728	249	12	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	249	13	insecurity	insecurity	NOUN
tahrj-8728	249	14	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	249	15	does	do	VERB
tahrj-8728	249	16	nothing	nothing	PRON
tahrj-8728	249	17	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	249	18	justify	justify	VERB
tahrj-8728	249	19	how	how	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	249	20	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	249	21	use	use	NOUN
tahrj-8728	249	22	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	249	23	security	security	NOUN
tahrj-8728	249	24	operations	operation	NOUN
tahrj-8728	249	25	will	will	AUX
tahrj-8728	249	26	solve	solve	VERB
tahrj-8728	249	27	security	security	NOUN
tahrj-8728	249	28	concerns	concern	NOUN
tahrj-8728	249	29	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	250	1	through	through	ADP
tahrj-8728	250	2	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	250	3	constitutional	constitutional	ADJ
tahrj-8728	250	4	lens	len	NOUN
tahrj-8728	250	5	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	250	6	all	all	PRON
tahrj-8728	250	7	that	that	PRON
tahrj-8728	250	8	is	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	250	9	visible	visible	ADJ
tahrj-8728	250	10	is	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	250	11	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	250	12	violation	violation	NOUN
tahrj-8728	250	13	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	250	14	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	250	15	right	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	250	16	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	250	17	refugees	refugee	NOUN
tahrj-8728	250	18	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	250	19	free	free	ADJ
tahrj-8728	250	20	movement	movement	NOUN
tahrj-8728	250	21	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	250	22	non	non	ADJ
tahrj-8728	250	23	-	-	ADJ
tahrj-8728	250	24	refoulement	refoulement	ADJ
tahrj-8728	250	25	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	251	1	this	this	DET
tahrj-8728	251	2	way	way	NOUN
tahrj-8728	251	3	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	251	4	kenyan	kenyan	ADJ
tahrj-8728	251	5	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	251	6	applies	apply	VERB
tahrj-8728	251	7	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	251	8	true	true	ADJ
tahrj-8728	251	9	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	251	10	analysis	analysis	NOUN
tahrj-8728	251	11	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	251	12	rarely	rarely	ADV
tahrj-8728	251	13	invokes	invoke	VERB
tahrj-8728	251	14	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	251	15	wednesbury	wednesbury	PROPN
tahrj-8728	251	16	principle	principle	PROPN
tahrj-8728	251	17	while	while	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	251	18	determining	determine	VERB
tahrj-8728	251	19	any	any	DET
tahrj-8728	251	20	detention	detention	NOUN
tahrj-8728	251	21	or	or	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	251	22	deportation	deportation	NOUN
tahrj-8728	251	23	decisions	decision	NOUN
tahrj-8728	251	24	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	252	1	this	this	PRON
tahrj-8728	252	2	is	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	252	3	significantly	significantly	ADV
tahrj-8728	252	4	possible	possible	ADJ
tahrj-8728	252	5	due	due	ADP
tahrj-8728	252	6	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	252	7	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	252	8	constitutional	constitutional	ADJ
tahrj-8728	252	9	provision	provision	NOUN
tahrj-8728	252	10	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	252	11	limitation	limitation	NOUN
tahrj-8728	252	12	which	which	PRON
tahrj-8728	252	13	is	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	252	14	similar	similar	ADJ
tahrj-8728	252	15	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	252	16	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	252	17	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	252	18	-	-	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	252	19	designed	design	VERB
tahrj-8728	252	20	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	252	21	analysis	analysis	NOUN
tahrj-8728	252	22	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	253	1	ironically	ironically	ADV
tahrj-8728	253	2	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	253	3	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	253	4	courts	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	253	5	who	who	PRON
tahrj-8728	253	6	designed	design	VERB
tahrj-8728	253	7	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	253	8	test	test	NOUN
tahrj-8728	253	9	failed	fail	VERB
tahrj-8728	253	10	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	253	11	apply	apply	VERB
tahrj-8728	253	12	it	it	PRON
tahrj-8728	253	13	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	253	14	cases	case	NOUN
tahrj-8728	253	15	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	253	16	non	non	ADJ
tahrj-8728	253	17	-	-	ADJ
tahrj-8728	253	18	refoulement	refoulement	ADJ
tahrj-8728	253	19	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	254	1	unfortunately	unfortunately	ADV
tahrj-8728	254	2	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	254	3	it	it	PRON
tahrj-8728	254	4	was	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	254	5	not	not	PART
tahrj-8728	254	6	directly	directly	ADV
tahrj-8728	254	7	applied	apply	VERB
tahrj-8728	254	8	by	by	ADP
tahrj-8728	254	9	other	other	ADJ
tahrj-8728	254	10	regional	regional	ADJ
tahrj-8728	254	11	courts	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	254	12	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	254	13	non	non	ADJ
tahrj-8728	254	14	-	-	ADJ
tahrj-8728	254	15	refoulement	refoulement	ADJ
tahrj-8728	254	16	cases	case	NOUN
tahrj-8728	254	17	either	either	ADV
tahrj-8728	254	18	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	254	19	even	even	ADV
tahrj-8728	254	20	though	though	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	254	21	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	254	22	test	test	NOUN
tahrj-8728	254	23	was	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	254	24	interpreted	interpret	VERB
tahrj-8728	254	25	broadly	broadly	ADV
tahrj-8728	254	26	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	255	1	however	however	ADV
tahrj-8728	255	2	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	255	3	it	it	PRON
tahrj-8728	255	4	was	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	255	5	subsequently	subsequently	ADV
tahrj-8728	255	6	adopted	adopt	VERB
tahrj-8728	255	7	by	by	ADP
tahrj-8728	255	8	some	some	DET
tahrj-8728	255	9	states	state	NOUN
tahrj-8728	255	10	like	like	ADP
tahrj-8728	255	11	kenya	kenya	PROPN
tahrj-8728	255	12	through	through	ADP
tahrj-8728	255	13	constitutional	constitutional	ADJ
tahrj-8728	255	14	provisions	provision	NOUN
tahrj-8728	255	15	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	255	16	then	then	ADV
tahrj-8728	255	17	applied	apply	VERB
tahrj-8728	255	18	by	by	ADP
tahrj-8728	255	19	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	255	20	national	national	ADJ
tahrj-8728	255	21	courts	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	255	22	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	255	23	its	its	PRON
tahrj-8728	255	24	true	true	ADJ
tahrj-8728	255	25	form	form	NOUN
tahrj-8728	255	26	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	256	1	3	3	X
tahrj-8728	256	2	.	.	X
tahrj-8728	256	3	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	256	4	analysis	analysis	NOUN
tahrj-8728	256	5	jurisprudence	jurisprudence	NOUN
tahrj-8728	256	6	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	256	7	india	india	PROPN
tahrj-8728	256	8	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	256	9	scope	scope	NOUN
tahrj-8728	256	10	for	for	ADP
tahrj-8728	256	11	non	non	ADJ
tahrj-8728	256	12	refoulement	refoulement	NOUN
tahrj-8728	256	13	?	?	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	257	1	so	so	ADV
tahrj-8728	257	2	far	far	ADV
tahrj-8728	257	3	it	it	PRON
tahrj-8728	257	4	can	can	AUX
tahrj-8728	257	5	be	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	257	6	concluded	conclude	VERB
tahrj-8728	257	7	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	257	8	ecthr	ecthr	PROPN
tahrj-8728	257	9	produces	produce	VERB
tahrj-8728	257	10	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	257	11	very	very	ADV
tahrj-8728	257	12	confusing	confusing	ADJ
tahrj-8728	257	13	jurisprudence	jurisprudence	NOUN
tahrj-8728	257	14	on	on	ADP
tahrj-8728	257	15	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	257	16	application	application	NOUN
tahrj-8728	257	17	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	257	18	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	257	19	analysis	analysis	NOUN
tahrj-8728	257	20	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	257	21	non	non	ADJ
tahrj-8728	257	22	-	-	ADJ
tahrj-8728	257	23	refoulement	refoulement	ADJ
tahrj-8728	257	24	cases	case	NOUN
tahrj-8728	257	25	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	258	1	while	while	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	258	2	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	258	3	acthpr	acthpr	NOUN
tahrj-8728	258	4	sets	set	VERB
tahrj-8728	258	5	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	258	6	fantastic	fantastic	ADJ
tahrj-8728	258	7	jurisprudence	jurisprudence	NOUN
tahrj-8728	258	8	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	258	9	application	application	NOUN
tahrj-8728	258	10	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	258	11	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	258	12	analysis	analysis	NOUN
tahrj-8728	258	13	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	258	14	human	human	ADJ
tahrj-8728	258	15	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	258	16	cases	case	NOUN
tahrj-8728	258	17	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	258	18	it	it	PRON
tahrj-8728	258	19	lacks	lack	VERB
tahrj-8728	258	20	instances	instance	NOUN
tahrj-8728	258	21	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	258	22	direct	direct	ADJ
tahrj-8728	258	23	application	application	NOUN
tahrj-8728	258	24	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	258	25	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	258	26	non	non	ADJ
tahrj-8728	258	27	-	-	ADJ
tahrj-8728	258	28	refoulment	refoulment	ADJ
tahrj-8728	258	29	context	context	NOUN
tahrj-8728	258	30	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	259	1	moreover	moreover	ADV
tahrj-8728	259	2	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	259	3	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	259	4	national	national	ADJ
tahrj-8728	259	5	courts	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	259	6	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	259	7	india	india	PROPN
tahrj-8728	259	8	do	do	AUX
tahrj-8728	259	9	not	not	PART
tahrj-8728	259	10	have	have	VERB
tahrj-8728	259	11	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	259	12	limitation	limitation	NOUN
tahrj-8728	259	13	provision	provision	NOUN
tahrj-8728	259	14	like	like	ADP
tahrj-8728	259	15	that	that	PRON
tahrj-8728	259	16	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	259	17	art	art	NOUN
tahrj-8728	259	18	24	24	NUM
tahrj-8728	259	19	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	259	20	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	259	21	constitution	constitution	NOUN
tahrj-8728	259	22	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	259	23	kenya	kenya	PROPN
tahrj-8728	259	24	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	259	25	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	259	26	rely	rely	VERB
tahrj-8728	259	27	on	on	ADP
tahrj-8728	259	28	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	259	29	constitution	constitution	NOUN
tahrj-8728	259	30	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	259	31	india	india	PROPN
tahrj-8728	259	32	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	259	33	1950	1950	NUM
tahrj-8728	259	34	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	259	35	provides	provide	VERB
tahrj-8728	259	36	separate	separate	ADJ
tahrj-8728	259	37	limitation	limitation	NOUN
tahrj-8728	259	38	clauses	clause	NOUN
tahrj-8728	259	39	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	259	40	like	like	ADP
tahrj-8728	259	41	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	259	42	art	art	NOUN
tahrj-8728	259	43	19	19	NUM
tahrj-8728	259	44	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	260	1	traditionally	traditionally	ADV
tahrj-8728	260	2	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	260	3	just	just	ADV
tahrj-8728	260	4	like	like	ADP
tahrj-8728	260	5	all	all	DET
tahrj-8728	260	6	common	common	ADJ
tahrj-8728	260	7	law	law	NOUN
tahrj-8728	260	8	countries	country	NOUN
tahrj-8728	260	9	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	260	10	india	india	PROPN
tahrj-8728	260	11	has	have	AUX
tahrj-8728	260	12	followed	follow	VERB
tahrj-8728	260	13	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	260	14	wednesbury	wednesbury	NOUN
tahrj-8728	260	15	unreasonableness	unreasonableness	NOUN
tahrj-8728	260	16	as	as	ADP
tahrj-8728	260	17	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	260	18	standard	standard	NOUN
tahrj-8728	260	19	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	260	20	limitation	limitation	NOUN
tahrj-8728	260	21	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	260	22	chandra	chandra	PROPN
tahrj-8728	260	23	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	260	24	2004	2004	NUM
tahrj-8728	260	25	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	260	26	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	261	1	when	when	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	261	2	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	261	3	analysis	analysis	NOUN
tahrj-8728	261	4	emerged	emerge	VERB
tahrj-8728	261	5	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	261	6	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	261	7	uk	uk	PROPN
tahrj-8728	261	8	courts	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	261	9	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	261	10	wednesbury	wednesbury	PROPN
tahrj-8728	261	11	became	become	VERB
tahrj-8728	261	12	debatable	debatable	ADJ
tahrj-8728	261	13	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	261	14	india	india	PROPN
tahrj-8728	261	15	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	262	1	however	however	ADV
tahrj-8728	262	2	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	262	3	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	262	4	few	few	ADJ
tahrj-8728	262	5	scholars	scholar	NOUN
tahrj-8728	262	6	have	have	AUX
tahrj-8728	262	7	called	call	VERB
tahrj-8728	262	8	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	262	9	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	262	10	approach	approach	NOUN
tahrj-8728	262	11	mispacked	mispacke	VERB
tahrj-8728	262	12	for	for	ADP
tahrj-8728	262	13	indian	indian	ADJ
tahrj-8728	262	14	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NOUN
tahrj-8728	262	15	given	give	VERB
tahrj-8728	262	16	they	they	PRON
tahrj-8728	262	17	are	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	262	18	invoked	invoke	VERB
tahrj-8728	262	19	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	262	20	other	other	ADJ
tahrj-8728	262	21	jurisdictions	jurisdiction	NOUN
tahrj-8728	262	22	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	262	23	are	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	262	24	not	not	PART
tahrj-8728	262	25	suitable	suitable	ADJ
tahrj-8728	262	26	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	262	27	chandra	chandra	PROPN
tahrj-8728	262	28	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	262	29	2004	2004	NUM
tahrj-8728	262	30	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	262	31	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	263	1	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	263	2	revisit	revisit	NOUN
tahrj-8728	263	3	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	263	4	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	263	5	previous	previous	ADJ
tahrj-8728	263	6	cases	case	NOUN
tahrj-8728	263	7	suggests	suggest	VERB
tahrj-8728	263	8	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	263	9	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	263	10	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	263	11	has	have	AUX
tahrj-8728	263	12	used	use	VERB
tahrj-8728	263	13	‘	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	263	14	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	263	15	’	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	263	16	language	language	NOUN
tahrj-8728	263	17	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	263	18	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	263	19	context	context	NOUN
tahrj-8728	263	20	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	263	21	reasonableness	reasonableness	NOUN
tahrj-8728	263	22	analysis	analysis	NOUN
tahrj-8728	263	23	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	264	1	for	for	ADP
tahrj-8728	264	2	example	example	NOUN
tahrj-8728	264	3	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	264	4	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	264	5	chintaman	chintaman	PROPN
tahrj-8728	264	6	rao	rao	PROPN
tahrj-8728	264	7	v.	v.	ADP
tahrj-8728	264	8	state	state	PROPN
tahrj-8728	264	9	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	264	10	mp	mp	PROPN
tahrj-8728	264	11	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	264	12	1915	1915	NUM
tahrj-8728	264	13	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	264	14	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	264	15	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	264	16	stated	state	VERB
tahrj-8728	264	17	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	264	18	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	264	19	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	264	20	limitation	limitation	NOUN
tahrj-8728	264	21	imposed	impose	VERB
tahrj-8728	264	22	on	on	ADP
tahrj-8728	264	23	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	264	24	person	person	NOUN
tahrj-8728	264	25	should	should	AUX
tahrj-8728	264	26	not	not	PART
tahrj-8728	264	27	be	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	264	28	arbitrary	arbitrary	ADJ
tahrj-8728	264	29	or	or	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	264	30	excessive	excessive	ADJ
tahrj-8728	264	31	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	265	1	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	265	2	word	word	NOUN
tahrj-8728	265	3	reasonable	reasonable	ADJ
tahrj-8728	265	4	implies	imply	VERB
tahrj-8728	265	5	intelligent	intelligent	ADJ
tahrj-8728	265	6	care	care	NOUN
tahrj-8728	265	7	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	265	8	deliberation	deliberation	NOUN
tahrj-8728	265	9	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	266	1	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	266	2	quality	quality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	266	3	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	266	4	reasonableness	reasonableness	NOUN
tahrj-8728	266	5	can	can	AUX
tahrj-8728	266	6	not	not	PART
tahrj-8728	266	7	https://doi.org/10.17561/tahrj.v23.8728	https://doi.org/10.17561/tahrj.v23.8728	PROPN
tahrj-8728	266	8	sabreen	sabreen	PROPN
tahrj-8728	266	9	ahmed	ahme	VERB
tahrj-8728	266	10	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	266	11	age	age	NOUN
tahrj-8728	266	12	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	266	13	human	human	ADJ
tahrj-8728	266	14	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	266	15	journal	journal	NOUN
tahrj-8728	266	16	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	266	17	24	24	NUM
tahrj-8728	266	18	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	266	19	june	june	PROPN
tahrj-8728	266	20	2025	2025	NUM
tahrj-8728	266	21	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	266	22	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	266	23	e8728	e8728	PROPN
tahrj-8728	266	24	issn	issn	PROPN
tahrj-8728	266	25	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	266	26	2340	2340	NUM
tahrj-8728	266	27	-	-	SYM
tahrj-8728	266	28	9592	9592	NUM
tahrj-8728	266	29	doi	doi	NOUN
tahrj-8728	266	30	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	266	31	10.17561	10.17561	NUM
tahrj-8728	266	32	/	/	SYM
tahrj-8728	266	33	tahrj.v23.8728	tahrj.v23.8728	PROPN
tahrj-8728	266	34	15	15	NUM
tahrj-8728	266	35	be	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	266	36	attained	attain	VERB
tahrj-8728	266	37	if	if	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	266	38	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	266	39	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	266	40	freedom	freedom	NOUN
tahrj-8728	266	41	guaranteed	guarantee	VERB
tahrj-8728	266	42	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	266	43	article	article	NOUN
tahrj-8728	266	44	19(1)(g	19(1)(g	NUM
tahrj-8728	266	45	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	266	46	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	266	47	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	266	48	social	social	ADJ
tahrj-8728	266	49	control	control	NOUN
tahrj-8728	266	50	permitted	permit	VERB
tahrj-8728	266	51	by	by	ADP
tahrj-8728	266	52	clause	clause	NOUN
tahrj-8728	266	53	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	266	54	6	6	NUM
tahrj-8728	266	55	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	266	56	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	266	57	art	art	NOUN
tahrj-8728	266	58	19	19	NUM
tahrj-8728	266	59	are	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	266	60	properly	properly	ADV
tahrj-8728	266	61	balanced	balanced	ADJ
tahrj-8728	266	62	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	267	1	similarly	similarly	ADV
tahrj-8728	267	2	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	267	3	vg	vg	NOUN
tahrj-8728	267	4	row	row	NOUN
tahrj-8728	267	5	v.	v.	ADP
tahrj-8728	267	6	state	state	NOUN
tahrj-8728	267	7	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	267	8	madras	madras	X
tahrj-8728	267	9	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	267	10	1952	1952	NUM
tahrj-8728	267	11	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	267	12	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	267	13	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	267	14	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	267	15	held	hold	VERB
tahrj-8728	267	16	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	267	17	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	267	18	determining	determine	VERB
tahrj-8728	267	19	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	267	20	reasonableness	reasonableness	NOUN
tahrj-8728	267	21	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	267	22	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	267	23	restrictions	restriction	NOUN
tahrj-8728	267	24	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	267	25	fundamental	fundamental	ADJ
tahrj-8728	267	26	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	267	27	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	267	28	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	267	29	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	267	30	should	should	AUX
tahrj-8728	267	31	determine	determine	VERB
tahrj-8728	267	32	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	267	33	underlying	underlie	VERB
tahrj-8728	267	34	purpose	purpose	NOUN
tahrj-8728	267	35	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	267	36	extent	extent	NOUN
tahrj-8728	267	37	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	267	38	urgency	urgency	NOUN
tahrj-8728	267	39	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	267	40	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	267	41	evil	evil	NOUN
tahrj-8728	267	42	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	267	43	be	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	267	44	remedied	remedied	ADJ
tahrj-8728	267	45	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	267	46	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	267	47	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	267	48	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	267	49	imposition	imposition	NOUN
tahrj-8728	267	50	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	268	1	however	however	ADV
tahrj-8728	268	2	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	268	3	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	268	4	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	268	5	rarely	rarely	ADV
tahrj-8728	268	6	examines	examine	VERB
tahrj-8728	268	7	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	268	8	necessity	necessity	NOUN
tahrj-8728	268	9	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	268	10	measures	measure	NOUN
tahrj-8728	268	11	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	268	12	chandra	chandra	NOUN
tahrj-8728	268	13	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	268	14	2020	2020	NUM
tahrj-8728	268	15	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	268	16	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	268	17	also	also	ADV
tahrj-8728	268	18	does	do	AUX
tahrj-8728	268	19	not	not	PART
tahrj-8728	268	20	properly	properly	ADV
tahrj-8728	268	21	determine	determine	VERB
tahrj-8728	268	22	how	how	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	268	23	measures	measure	NOUN
tahrj-8728	268	24	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	268	25	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	268	26	are	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	268	27	balanced	balanced	ADJ
tahrj-8728	268	28	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	269	1	this	this	PRON
tahrj-8728	269	2	suggests	suggest	VERB
tahrj-8728	269	3	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	269	4	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	269	5	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	269	6	guise	guise	NOUN
tahrj-8728	269	7	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	269	8	articulating	articulating	ADJ
tahrj-8728	269	9	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	269	10	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	269	11	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	269	12	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	269	13	applies	apply	VERB
tahrj-8728	269	14	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	269	15	‘	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	269	16	wednesbury	wednesbury	NOUN
tahrj-8728	269	17	review	review	NOUN
tahrj-8728	269	18	’	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	269	19	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	269	20	chandra	chandra	PROPN
tahrj-8728	269	21	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	269	22	2020	2020	NUM
tahrj-8728	269	23	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	269	24	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	270	1	this	this	PRON
tahrj-8728	270	2	means	mean	VERB
tahrj-8728	270	3	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	270	4	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	270	5	measure	measure	NOUN
tahrj-8728	270	6	needs	need	VERB
tahrj-8728	270	7	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	270	8	be	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	270	9	set	set	VERB
tahrj-8728	270	10	aside	aside	ADV
tahrj-8728	270	11	only	only	ADV
tahrj-8728	270	12	if	if	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	270	13	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	270	14	petitioner	petitioner	NOUN
tahrj-8728	270	15	can	can	AUX
tahrj-8728	270	16	show	show	VERB
tahrj-8728	270	17	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	270	18	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	270	19	measure	measure	NOUN
tahrj-8728	270	20	was	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	270	21	so	so	ADV
tahrj-8728	270	22	outrageous	outrageous	ADJ
tahrj-8728	270	23	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	270	24	no	no	DET
tahrj-8728	270	25	sensible	sensible	ADJ
tahrj-8728	270	26	person	person	NOUN
tahrj-8728	270	27	could	could	AUX
tahrj-8728	270	28	have	have	AUX
tahrj-8728	270	29	arrived	arrive	VERB
tahrj-8728	270	30	at	at	ADP
tahrj-8728	270	31	it	it	PRON
tahrj-8728	270	32	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	270	33	council	council	NOUN
tahrj-8728	270	34	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	270	35	civil	civil	ADJ
tahrj-8728	270	36	service	service	NOUN
tahrj-8728	270	37	unions	union	NOUN
tahrj-8728	270	38	v	v	ADP
tahrj-8728	270	39	minister	minister	NOUN
tahrj-8728	270	40	for	for	ADP
tahrj-8728	270	41	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	270	42	civil	civil	ADJ
tahrj-8728	270	43	service	service	NOUN
tahrj-8728	270	44	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	270	45	1984	1984	NUM
tahrj-8728	270	46	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	270	47	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	271	1	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	271	2	careful	careful	ADJ
tahrj-8728	271	3	review	review	NOUN
tahrj-8728	271	4	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	271	5	cases	case	NOUN
tahrj-8728	271	6	concerning	concern	VERB
tahrj-8728	271	7	fundamental	fundamental	ADJ
tahrj-8728	271	8	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	271	9	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	271	10	from	from	ADP
tahrj-8728	271	11	2004	2004	NUM
tahrj-8728	271	12	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	271	13	2016	2016	NUM
tahrj-8728	271	14	suggests	suggest	VERB
tahrj-8728	271	15	this	this	DET
tahrj-8728	271	16	pattern	pattern	NOUN
tahrj-8728	271	17	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	271	18	chandra	chandra	PROPN
tahrj-8728	271	19	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	271	20	2020	2020	NUM
tahrj-8728	271	21	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	271	22	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	272	1	though	though	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	272	2	not	not	PART
tahrj-8728	272	3	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	272	4	consistent	consistent	ADJ
tahrj-8728	272	5	structured	structure	VERB
tahrj-8728	272	6	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	272	7	test	test	NOUN
tahrj-8728	272	8	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	272	9	sc	sc	PROPN
tahrj-8728	272	10	judgements	judgement	NOUN
tahrj-8728	272	11	offer	offer	VERB
tahrj-8728	272	12	some	some	DET
tahrj-8728	272	13	common	common	ADJ
tahrj-8728	272	14	elements	element	NOUN
tahrj-8728	272	15	applied	apply	VERB
tahrj-8728	272	16	by	by	ADP
tahrj-8728	272	17	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	272	18	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	272	19	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	272	20	determining	determine	VERB
tahrj-8728	272	21	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	272	22	limitation	limitation	NOUN
tahrj-8728	272	23	which	which	PRON
tahrj-8728	272	24	suggests	suggest	VERB
tahrj-8728	272	25	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	272	26	wednesbury	wednesbury	NOUN
tahrj-8728	272	27	-	-	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	272	28	like	like	ADJ
tahrj-8728	272	29	approach	approach	NOUN
tahrj-8728	272	30	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	272	31	chandra	chandra	PROPN
tahrj-8728	272	32	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	272	33	2020	2020	NUM
tahrj-8728	272	34	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	272	35	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	273	1	this	this	DET
tahrj-8728	273	2	common	common	ADJ
tahrj-8728	273	3	structure	structure	NOUN
tahrj-8728	273	4	can	can	AUX
tahrj-8728	273	5	be	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	273	6	focused	focus	VERB
tahrj-8728	273	7	on	on	ADP
tahrj-8728	273	8	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	273	9	worthiness	worthiness	NOUN
tahrj-8728	273	10	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	273	11	purpose	purpose	NOUN
tahrj-8728	273	12	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	273	13	suitability	suitability	NOUN
tahrj-8728	273	14	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	273	15	means	mean	NOUN
tahrj-8728	273	16	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	273	17	achieving	achieve	VERB
tahrj-8728	273	18	that	that	DET
tahrj-8728	273	19	purpose	purpose	NOUN
tahrj-8728	273	20	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	273	21	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	273	22	balancing	balancing	NOUN
tahrj-8728	273	23	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	273	24	whether	whether	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	273	25	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	273	26	state	state	NOUN
tahrj-8728	273	27	is	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	273	28	justified	justify	VERB
tahrj-8728	273	29	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	273	30	limiting	limit	VERB
tahrj-8728	273	31	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	273	32	right	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	273	33	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	274	1	under	under	ADP
tahrj-8728	274	2	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	274	3	worthy	worthy	ADJ
tahrj-8728	274	4	purpose	purpose	NOUN
tahrj-8728	274	5	test	test	NOUN
tahrj-8728	274	6	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	274	7	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	274	8	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	274	9	determines	determine	VERB
tahrj-8728	274	10	if	if	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	274	11	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	274	12	right	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	274	13	can	can	AUX
tahrj-8728	274	14	be	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	274	15	restricted	restrict	VERB
tahrj-8728	274	16	under	under	ADP
tahrj-8728	274	17	art	art	NOUN
tahrj-8728	274	18	19	19	NUM
tahrj-8728	274	19	or	or	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	274	20	for	for	ADP
tahrj-8728	274	21	reasons	reason	NOUN
tahrj-8728	274	22	for	for	ADP
tahrj-8728	274	23	general	general	ADJ
tahrj-8728	274	24	public	public	ADJ
tahrj-8728	274	25	interest	interest	NOUN
tahrj-8728	274	26	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	275	1	there	there	PRON
tahrj-8728	275	2	are	be	VERB
tahrj-8728	275	3	no	no	DET
tahrj-8728	275	4	listed	list	VERB
tahrj-8728	275	5	worthy	worthy	ADJ
tahrj-8728	275	6	or	or	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	275	7	unworthy	unworthy	ADJ
tahrj-8728	275	8	purposes	purpose	NOUN
tahrj-8728	275	9	as	as	ADP
tahrj-8728	275	10	such	such	ADJ
tahrj-8728	275	11	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	276	1	however	however	ADV
tahrj-8728	276	2	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	276	3	what	what	PRON
tahrj-8728	276	4	it	it	PRON
tahrj-8728	276	5	means	mean	VERB
tahrj-8728	276	6	is	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	276	7	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	276	8	whether	whether	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	276	9	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	276	10	purpose	purpose	NOUN
tahrj-8728	276	11	is	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	276	12	legitimate	legitimate	ADJ
tahrj-8728	276	13	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	276	14	chandra	chandra	NOUN
tahrj-8728	276	15	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	276	16	2020	2020	NUM
tahrj-8728	276	17	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	276	18	p.	p.	NOUN
tahrj-8728	276	19	519	519	NUM
tahrj-8728	276	20	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	276	21	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	277	1	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	277	2	suitability	suitability	NOUN
tahrj-8728	277	3	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	277	4	means	mean	NOUN
tahrj-8728	277	5	has	have	AUX
tahrj-8728	277	6	been	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	277	7	interpreted	interpret	VERB
tahrj-8728	277	8	as	as	ADP
tahrj-8728	277	9	requiring	require	VERB
tahrj-8728	277	10	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	277	11	direct	direct	ADJ
tahrj-8728	277	12	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	277	13	proximate	proximate	NOUN
tahrj-8728	277	14	link	link	NOUN
tahrj-8728	277	15	between	between	ADP
tahrj-8728	277	16	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	277	17	restriction	restriction	NOUN
tahrj-8728	277	18	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	277	19	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	277	20	goal	goal	NOUN
tahrj-8728	277	21	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	277	22	superintendent	superintendent	NOUN
tahrj-8728	277	23	central	central	ADJ
tahrj-8728	277	24	prison	prison	NOUN
tahrj-8728	277	25	v	v	PROPN
tahrj-8728	277	26	ram	ram	PROPN
tahrj-8728	277	27	manohar	manohar	PROPN
tahrj-8728	277	28	lohia	lohia	PROPN
tahrj-8728	277	29	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	277	30	1960	1960	NUM
tahrj-8728	277	31	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	277	32	additionally	additionally	ADV
tahrj-8728	277	33	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	277	34	it	it	PRON
tahrj-8728	277	35	is	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	277	36	emphasized	emphasize	VERB
tahrj-8728	277	37	by	by	ADP
tahrj-8728	277	38	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	277	39	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	277	40	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	277	41	such	such	ADJ
tahrj-8728	277	42	goals	goal	NOUN
tahrj-8728	277	43	should	should	AUX
tahrj-8728	277	44	be	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	277	45	rational	rational	ADJ
tahrj-8728	277	46	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	277	47	not	not	PART
tahrj-8728	277	48	hypothetical	hypothetical	ADJ
tahrj-8728	277	49	or	or	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	277	50	illusory	illusory	ADJ
tahrj-8728	277	51	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	278	1	for	for	ADP
tahrj-8728	278	2	example	example	NOUN
tahrj-8728	278	3	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	278	4	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	278	5	o	o	PROPN
tahrj-8728	278	6	k	k	PROPN
tahrj-8728	278	7	ghosh	ghosh	PROPN
tahrj-8728	278	8	v	v	PROPN
tahrj-8728	278	9	e	e	PROPN
tahrj-8728	278	10	x	x	PROPN
tahrj-8728	278	11	joseph	joseph	PROPN
tahrj-8728	278	12	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	278	13	1963	1963	NUM
tahrj-8728	278	14	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	278	15	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	279	1	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	279	2	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	279	3	held	hold	VERB
tahrj-8728	279	4	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	279	5	non	non	ADJ
tahrj-8728	279	6	-	-	NOUN
tahrj-8728	279	7	payment	payment	NOUN
tahrj-8728	279	8	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	279	9	taxes	taxis	NOUN
tahrj-8728	279	10	by	by	ADP
tahrj-8728	279	11	one	one	NUM
tahrj-8728	279	12	individual	individual	NOUN
tahrj-8728	279	13	would	would	AUX
tahrj-8728	279	14	ignite	ignite	VERB
tahrj-8728	279	15	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	279	16	revolution	revolution	NOUN
tahrj-8728	279	17	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	279	18	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	279	19	future	future	NOUN
tahrj-8728	279	20	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	279	21	thereby	thereby	ADV
tahrj-8728	279	22	destroying	destroy	VERB
tahrj-8728	279	23	public	public	ADJ
tahrj-8728	279	24	order	order	NOUN
tahrj-8728	279	25	is	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	279	26	imaginary	imaginary	ADJ
tahrj-8728	279	27	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	280	1	finally	finally	ADV
tahrj-8728	280	2	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	280	3	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	280	4	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	280	5	balancing	balancing	NOUN
tahrj-8728	280	6	mechanism	mechanism	NOUN
tahrj-8728	280	7	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	280	8	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	280	9	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	280	10	balances	balance	VERB
tahrj-8728	280	11	‘	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	280	12	if	if	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	280	13	all	all	DET
tahrj-8728	280	14	things	thing	NOUN
tahrj-8728	280	15	considered	consider	VERB
tahrj-8728	280	16	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	280	17	should	should	AUX
tahrj-8728	280	18	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	280	19	measure	measure	NOUN
tahrj-8728	280	20	outweigh	outweigh	VERB
tahrj-8728	280	21	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	280	22	right	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	280	23	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	280	24	context	context	NOUN
tahrj-8728	280	25	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	281	1	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	281	2	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	281	3	does	do	AUX
tahrj-8728	281	4	not	not	PART
tahrj-8728	281	5	perform	perform	VERB
tahrj-8728	281	6	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	281	7	analysis	analysis	NOUN
tahrj-8728	281	8	but	but	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	281	9	determines	determine	VERB
tahrj-8728	281	10	what	what	DET
tahrj-8728	281	11	priority	priority	NOUN
tahrj-8728	281	12	is	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	281	13	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	281	14	chandra	chandra	PROPN
tahrj-8728	281	15	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	281	16	2020	2020	NUM
tahrj-8728	281	17	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	281	18	p.	p.	NOUN
tahrj-8728	281	19	529	529	NUM
tahrj-8728	281	20	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	281	21	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	282	1	it	it	PRON
tahrj-8728	282	2	is	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	282	3	not	not	PART
tahrj-8728	282	4	seen	see	VERB
tahrj-8728	282	5	as	as	ADP
tahrj-8728	282	6	an	an	DET
tahrj-8728	282	7	independent	independent	ADJ
tahrj-8728	282	8	stage	stage	NOUN
tahrj-8728	282	9	but	but	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	282	10	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	282	11	continuum	continuum	NOUN
tahrj-8728	282	12	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	282	13	other	other	ADJ
tahrj-8728	282	14	stages	stage	NOUN
tahrj-8728	282	15	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	283	1	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	283	2	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	283	3	also	also	ADV
tahrj-8728	283	4	does	do	AUX
tahrj-8728	283	5	n’t	not	PART
tahrj-8728	283	6	apply	apply	VERB
tahrj-8728	283	7	less	less	ADV
tahrj-8728	283	8	restrictive	restrictive	ADJ
tahrj-8728	283	9	means	mean	NOUN
tahrj-8728	283	10	at	at	ADP
tahrj-8728	283	11	this	this	DET
tahrj-8728	283	12	stage	stage	NOUN
tahrj-8728	283	13	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	284	1	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	284	2	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	284	3	has	have	AUX
tahrj-8728	284	4	repeatedly	repeatedly	ADV
tahrj-8728	284	5	held	hold	VERB
tahrj-8728	284	6	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	284	7	it	it	PRON
tahrj-8728	284	8	will	will	AUX
tahrj-8728	284	9	not	not	PART
tahrj-8728	284	10	examine	examine	VERB
tahrj-8728	284	11	if	if	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	284	12	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	284	13	better	well	ADJ
tahrj-8728	284	14	policy	policy	NOUN
tahrj-8728	284	15	could	could	AUX
tahrj-8728	284	16	be	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	284	17	made	make	VERB
tahrj-8728	284	18	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	284	19	or	or	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	284	20	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	284	21	better	well	ADJ
tahrj-8728	284	22	law	law	NOUN
tahrj-8728	284	23	could	could	AUX
tahrj-8728	284	24	be	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	284	25	designed	design	VERB
tahrj-8728	284	26	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	285	1	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	285	2	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	285	3	refuses	refuse	VERB
tahrj-8728	285	4	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	285	5	analyze	analyze	VERB
tahrj-8728	285	6	any	any	DET
tahrj-8728	285	7	other	other	ADJ
tahrj-8728	285	8	method	method	NOUN
tahrj-8728	285	9	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	285	10	achieve	achieve	VERB
tahrj-8728	285	11	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	285	12	aims	aim	NOUN
tahrj-8728	285	13	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	285	14	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	285	15	law	law	NOUN
tahrj-8728	285	16	but	but	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	285	17	only	only	ADV
tahrj-8728	285	18	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	285	19	constitutionality	constitutionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	285	20	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	285	21	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	285	22	law	law	NOUN
tahrj-8728	285	23	at	at	ADP
tahrj-8728	285	24	hand	hand	NOUN
tahrj-8728	285	25	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	285	26	manohar	manohar	PROPN
tahrj-8728	285	27	lal	lal	PROPN
tahrj-8728	285	28	sharma	sharma	PROPN
tahrj-8728	285	29	v	v	PROPN
tahrj-8728	285	30	union	union	PROPN
tahrj-8728	285	31	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	285	32	india	india	PROPN
tahrj-8728	285	33	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	285	34	2021	2021	NUM
tahrj-8728	285	35	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	285	36	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	286	1	however	however	ADV
tahrj-8728	286	2	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	286	3	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	286	4	recent	recent	ADJ
tahrj-8728	286	5	cases	case	NOUN
tahrj-8728	286	6	like	like	ADP
tahrj-8728	286	7	cases	case	NOUN
tahrj-8728	286	8	like	like	ADP
tahrj-8728	286	9	modern	modern	ADJ
tahrj-8728	286	10	dental	dental	ADJ
tahrj-8728	286	11	college	college	NOUN
tahrj-8728	286	12	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	286	13	research	research	NOUN
tahrj-8728	286	14	centre	centre	PROPN
tahrj-8728	286	15	v.	v.	ADP
tahrj-8728	286	16	state	state	NOUN
tahrj-8728	286	17	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	286	18	madhya	madhya	PROPN
tahrj-8728	286	19	pradesh	pradesh	PROPN
tahrj-8728	286	20	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	286	21	2016	2016	NUM
tahrj-8728	286	22	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	286	23	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	286	24	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	286	25	sc	sc	NOUN
tahrj-8728	286	26	suggested	suggest	VERB
tahrj-8728	286	27	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	286	28	it	it	PRON
tahrj-8728	286	29	would	would	AUX
tahrj-8728	286	30	adopt	adopt	VERB
tahrj-8728	286	31	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	286	32	structured	structured	ADJ
tahrj-8728	286	33	fourpart	fourpart	NOUN
tahrj-8728	286	34	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	286	35	test	test	NOUN
tahrj-8728	286	36	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	287	1	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	287	2	issue	issue	NOUN
tahrj-8728	287	3	before	before	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	287	4	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	287	5	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	287	6	was	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	287	7	whether	whether	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	287	8	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	287	9	impugned	impugn	VERB
tahrj-8728	287	10	legislations	legislation	NOUN
tahrj-8728	287	11	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	287	12	rules	rule	NOUN
tahrj-8728	287	13	that	that	PRON
tahrj-8728	287	14	sought	seek	VERB
tahrj-8728	287	15	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	287	16	regulate	regulate	VERB
tahrj-8728	287	17	admission	admission	NOUN
tahrj-8728	287	18	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	287	19	fees	fee	NOUN
tahrj-8728	287	20	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	287	21	affirmative	affirmative	ADJ
tahrj-8728	287	22	action	action	NOUN
tahrj-8728	287	23	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	287	24	certain	certain	ADJ
tahrj-8728	287	25	types	type	NOUN
tahrj-8728	287	26	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	287	27	private	private	ADJ
tahrj-8728	287	28	colleges	college	NOUN
tahrj-8728	287	29	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	287	30	were	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	287	31	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	287	32	breach	breach	NOUN
tahrj-8728	287	33	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	287	34	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	287	35	freedom	freedom	NOUN
tahrj-8728	287	36	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	287	37	occupation	occupation	NOUN
tahrj-8728	287	38	under	under	ADP
tahrj-8728	287	39	art	art	NOUN
tahrj-8728	287	40	19(1	19(1	NUM
tahrj-8728	287	41	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	287	42	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	287	43	g	g	NOUN
tahrj-8728	287	44	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	287	45	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	287	46	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	287	47	constitution	constitution	NOUN
tahrj-8728	287	48	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	288	1	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	288	2	majority	majority	NOUN
tahrj-8728	288	3	decision	decision	NOUN
tahrj-8728	288	4	agreed	agree	VERB
tahrj-8728	288	5	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	288	6	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	288	7	test	test	NOUN
tahrj-8728	288	8	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	288	9	reasonableness	reasonableness	NOUN
tahrj-8728	288	10	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	288	11	this	this	DET
tahrj-8728	288	12	scenario	scenario	NOUN
tahrj-8728	288	13	is	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	288	14	that	that	PRON
tahrj-8728	288	15	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	288	16	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	288	17	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	289	1	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	289	2	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	289	3	relied	rely	VERB
tahrj-8728	289	4	on	on	ADP
tahrj-8728	289	5	r	r	PROPN
tahrj-8728	289	6	v.	v.	ADP
tahrj-8728	289	7	oakes	oakes	PROPN
tahrj-8728	289	8	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	289	9	1986	1986	NUM
tahrj-8728	289	10	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	289	11	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	289	12	canadian	canadian	ADJ
tahrj-8728	289	13	test	test	NOUN
tahrj-8728	289	14	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	289	15	state	state	VERB
tahrj-8728	289	16	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	289	17	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	289	18	doctrine	doctrine	NOUN
tahrj-8728	289	19	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	289	20	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	289	21	is	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	289	22	envisaged	envisage	VERB
tahrj-8728	289	23	within	within	ADP
tahrj-8728	289	24	art	art	NOUN
tahrj-8728	289	25	19	19	NUM
tahrj-8728	289	26	itself	itself	PRON
tahrj-8728	289	27	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	290	1	however	however	ADV
tahrj-8728	290	2	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	290	3	when	when	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	290	4	it	it	PRON
tahrj-8728	290	5	came	come	VERB
tahrj-8728	290	6	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	290	7	https://doi.org/10.17561/tahrj.v23.8728	https://doi.org/10.17561/tahrj.v23.8728	VERB
tahrj-8728	290	8	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	290	9	analysis	analysis	NOUN
tahrj-8728	290	10	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	290	11	non	non	ADJ
tahrj-8728	290	12	-	-	ADJ
tahrj-8728	290	13	refoulement	refoulement	ADJ
tahrj-8728	290	14	jurisprudence	jurisprudence	NOUN
tahrj-8728	290	15	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	290	16	india	india	PROPN
tahrj-8728	290	17	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	290	18	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	290	19	comparative	comparative	ADJ
tahrj-8728	290	20	approach	approach	NOUN
tahrj-8728	290	21	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	290	22	age	age	NOUN
tahrj-8728	290	23	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	290	24	human	human	ADJ
tahrj-8728	290	25	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	290	26	journal	journal	NOUN
tahrj-8728	290	27	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	290	28	24	24	NUM
tahrj-8728	290	29	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	290	30	june	june	PROPN
tahrj-8728	290	31	2025	2025	NUM
tahrj-8728	290	32	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	290	33	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	290	34	e8728	e8728	PROPN
tahrj-8728	290	35	issn	issn	PROPN
tahrj-8728	290	36	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	290	37	2340	2340	NUM
tahrj-8728	290	38	-	-	SYM
tahrj-8728	290	39	9592	9592	NUM
tahrj-8728	290	40	doi	doi	NOUN
tahrj-8728	290	41	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	290	42	10.17561	10.17561	NUM
tahrj-8728	290	43	/	/	SYM
tahrj-8728	290	44	tahrj.v23.8728	tahrj.v23.8728	PROPN
tahrj-8728	290	45	16	16	NUM
tahrj-8728	290	46	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	290	47	actual	actual	ADJ
tahrj-8728	290	48	application	application	NOUN
tahrj-8728	290	49	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	290	50	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	290	51	test	test	NOUN
tahrj-8728	290	52	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	290	53	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	290	54	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	290	55	went	go	VERB
tahrj-8728	290	56	with	with	ADP
tahrj-8728	290	57	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	290	58	assumption	assumption	NOUN
tahrj-8728	290	59	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	290	60	such	such	DET
tahrj-8728	290	61	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	290	62	restriction	restriction	NOUN
tahrj-8728	290	63	on	on	ADP
tahrj-8728	290	64	private	private	ADJ
tahrj-8728	290	65	colleges	college	NOUN
tahrj-8728	290	66	was	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	290	67	essential	essential	ADJ
tahrj-8728	290	68	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	290	69	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	290	70	interest	interest	NOUN
tahrj-8728	290	71	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	290	72	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	290	73	general	general	ADJ
tahrj-8728	290	74	public	public	NOUN
tahrj-8728	290	75	without	without	ADP
tahrj-8728	290	76	engaging	engage	VERB
tahrj-8728	290	77	with	with	ADP
tahrj-8728	290	78	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	290	79	question	question	NOUN
tahrj-8728	290	80	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	290	81	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	290	82	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	290	83	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	290	84	such	such	ADJ
tahrj-8728	290	85	measures	measure	NOUN
tahrj-8728	290	86	or	or	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	290	87	determining	determine	VERB
tahrj-8728	290	88	if	if	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	290	89	there	there	PRON
tahrj-8728	290	90	exist	exist	VERB
tahrj-8728	290	91	less	less	ADV
tahrj-8728	290	92	intrusive	intrusive	ADJ
tahrj-8728	290	93	means	mean	NOUN
tahrj-8728	290	94	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	291	1	following	follow	VERB
tahrj-8728	291	2	this	this	DET
tahrj-8728	291	3	judgment	judgment	NOUN
tahrj-8728	291	4	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	291	5	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	291	6	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	291	7	delivered	deliver	VERB
tahrj-8728	291	8	subramanian	subramanian	ADJ
tahrj-8728	291	9	swamy	swamy	PROPN
tahrj-8728	291	10	v.	v.	ADP
tahrj-8728	291	11	union	union	PROPN
tahrj-8728	291	12	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	291	13	india	india	PROPN
tahrj-8728	291	14	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	291	15	2016	2016	NUM
tahrj-8728	291	16	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	291	17	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	291	18	dealing	deal	VERB
tahrj-8728	291	19	with	with	ADP
tahrj-8728	291	20	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	291	21	constitutionality	constitutionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	291	22	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	291	23	sections	section	NOUN
tahrj-8728	291	24	499	499	NUM
tahrj-8728	291	25	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	291	26	500	500	NUM
tahrj-8728	291	27	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	291	28	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	291	29	ipc	ipc	PROPN
tahrj-8728	291	30	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	291	31	section	section	PROPN
tahrj-8728	291	32	199	199	NUM
tahrj-8728	291	33	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	291	34	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	291	35	crpc	crpc	ADJ
tahrj-8728	291	36	1973	1973	NUM
tahrj-8728	291	37	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	291	38	dealing	deal	VERB
tahrj-8728	291	39	with	with	ADP
tahrj-8728	291	40	criminal	criminal	ADJ
tahrj-8728	291	41	defamation	defamation	NOUN
tahrj-8728	291	42	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	292	1	it	it	PRON
tahrj-8728	292	2	was	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	292	3	contended	contend	VERB
tahrj-8728	292	4	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	292	5	these	these	DET
tahrj-8728	292	6	provisions	provision	NOUN
tahrj-8728	292	7	were	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	292	8	violative	violative	ADJ
tahrj-8728	292	9	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	292	10	freedom	freedom	NOUN
tahrj-8728	292	11	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	292	12	speech	speech	NOUN
tahrj-8728	292	13	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	292	14	expression	expression	NOUN
tahrj-8728	292	15	under	under	ADP
tahrj-8728	292	16	art	art	NOUN
tahrj-8728	292	17	19	19	NUM
tahrj-8728	292	18	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	292	19	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	292	20	constitution	constitution	NOUN
tahrj-8728	292	21	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	293	1	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	293	2	this	this	DET
tahrj-8728	293	3	case	case	NOUN
tahrj-8728	293	4	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	293	5	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	293	6	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	293	7	went	go	VERB
tahrj-8728	293	8	with	with	ADP
tahrj-8728	293	9	modern	modern	ADJ
tahrj-8728	293	10	college	college	NOUN
tahrj-8728	293	11	's	's	PART
tahrj-8728	293	12	rationale	rationale	NOUN
tahrj-8728	293	13	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	293	14	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	293	15	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	293	16	analysis	analysis	NOUN
tahrj-8728	293	17	was	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	293	18	already	already	ADV
tahrj-8728	293	19	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	293	20	part	part	NOUN
tahrj-8728	293	21	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	293	22	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	293	23	reasonableness	reasonableness	NOUN
tahrj-8728	293	24	test	test	NOUN
tahrj-8728	293	25	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	294	1	further	far	ADV
tahrj-8728	294	2	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	294	3	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	294	4	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	294	5	held	hold	VERB
tahrj-8728	294	6	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	294	7	such	such	ADJ
tahrj-8728	294	8	provisions	provision	NOUN
tahrj-8728	294	9	did	do	AUX
tahrj-8728	294	10	not	not	PART
tahrj-8728	294	11	violate	violate	VERB
tahrj-8728	294	12	free	free	ADJ
tahrj-8728	294	13	speech	speech	NOUN
tahrj-8728	294	14	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	294	15	expression	expression	NOUN
tahrj-8728	294	16	‘	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	294	17	disproportionately	disproportionately	ADV
tahrj-8728	294	18	’	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	294	19	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	295	1	as	as	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	295	2	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	295	3	there	there	PRON
tahrj-8728	295	4	is	be	VERB
tahrj-8728	295	5	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	295	6	separate	separate	ADJ
tahrj-8728	295	7	right	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	295	8	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	295	9	reputation	reputation	NOUN
tahrj-8728	295	10	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	295	11	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	295	12	right	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	295	13	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	295	14	free	free	ADJ
tahrj-8728	295	15	speech	speech	NOUN
tahrj-8728	295	16	can	can	AUX
tahrj-8728	295	17	not	not	PART
tahrj-8728	295	18	include	include	VERB
tahrj-8728	295	19	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	295	20	right	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	295	21	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	295	22	defame	defame	VERB
tahrj-8728	295	23	others	other	NOUN
tahrj-8728	295	24	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	296	1	however	however	ADV
tahrj-8728	296	2	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	296	3	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	296	4	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	296	5	did	do	AUX
tahrj-8728	296	6	not	not	PART
tahrj-8728	296	7	even	even	ADV
tahrj-8728	296	8	consider	consider	VERB
tahrj-8728	296	9	why	why	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	296	10	‘	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	296	11	civil	civil	ADJ
tahrj-8728	296	12	defamation	defamation	NOUN
tahrj-8728	296	13	’	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	296	14	can	can	AUX
tahrj-8728	296	15	not	not	PART
tahrj-8728	296	16	be	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	296	17	applied	apply	VERB
tahrj-8728	296	18	as	as	ADP
tahrj-8728	296	19	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	296	20	less	less	ADV
tahrj-8728	296	21	intrusive	intrusive	ADJ
tahrj-8728	296	22	means	mean	NOUN
tahrj-8728	296	23	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	296	24	cases	case	NOUN
tahrj-8728	296	25	where	where	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	296	26	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	296	27	right	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	296	28	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	296	29	reputation	reputation	NOUN
tahrj-8728	296	30	is	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	296	31	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	296	32	conflict	conflict	NOUN
tahrj-8728	296	33	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	297	1	very	very	ADV
tahrj-8728	297	2	recently	recently	ADV
tahrj-8728	297	3	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	297	4	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	297	5	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	297	6	delivered	deliver	VERB
tahrj-8728	297	7	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	297	8	landmark	landmark	NOUN
tahrj-8728	297	9	judgment	judgment	NOUN
tahrj-8728	297	10	on	on	ADP
tahrj-8728	297	11	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	297	12	right	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	297	13	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	297	14	privacy	privacy	NOUN
tahrj-8728	297	15	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	297	16	puttaswamy	puttaswamy	PROPN
tahrj-8728	297	17	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	297	18	ii	ii	NOUN
tahrj-8728	297	19	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	297	20	v.	v.	ADP
tahrj-8728	297	21	union	union	PROPN
tahrj-8728	297	22	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	297	23	india	india	PROPN
tahrj-8728	297	24	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	297	25	2019	2019	NUM
tahrj-8728	297	26	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	297	27	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	298	1	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	298	2	question	question	NOUN
tahrj-8728	298	3	was	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	298	4	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	298	5	‘	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	298	6	whether	whether	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	298	7	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	298	8	right	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	298	9	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	298	10	privacy	privacy	NOUN
tahrj-8728	298	11	is	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	298	12	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	298	13	fundamental	fundamental	ADJ
tahrj-8728	298	14	right	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	298	15	’	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	298	16	?	?	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	299	1	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	299	2	this	this	DET
tahrj-8728	299	3	case	case	NOUN
tahrj-8728	299	4	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	299	5	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	299	6	petitioners	petitioner	NOUN
tahrj-8728	299	7	argued	argue	VERB
tahrj-8728	299	8	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	299	9	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	299	10	right	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	299	11	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	299	12	privacy	privacy	NOUN
tahrj-8728	299	13	can	can	AUX
tahrj-8728	299	14	be	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	299	15	limited	limit	VERB
tahrj-8728	299	16	by	by	ADP
tahrj-8728	299	17	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	299	18	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	299	19	test	test	NOUN
tahrj-8728	299	20	that	that	PRON
tahrj-8728	299	21	is	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	299	22	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	300	1	1	1	X
tahrj-8728	300	2	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	300	3	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	300	4	action	action	NOUN
tahrj-8728	300	5	must	must	AUX
tahrj-8728	300	6	be	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	300	7	by	by	ADP
tahrj-8728	300	8	law	law	NOUN
tahrj-8728	300	9	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	301	1	2	2	X
tahrj-8728	301	2	.	.	X
tahrj-8728	301	3	must	must	AUX
tahrj-8728	301	4	be	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	301	5	necessary	necessary	ADJ
tahrj-8728	301	6	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	301	7	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	301	8	democratic	democratic	ADJ
tahrj-8728	301	9	society	society	NOUN
tahrj-8728	301	10	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	302	1	3	3	X
tahrj-8728	302	2	.	.	X
tahrj-8728	302	3	interference	interference	NOUN
tahrj-8728	302	4	must	must	AUX
tahrj-8728	302	5	be	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	302	6	proportionate	proportionate	ADJ
tahrj-8728	302	7	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	302	8	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	302	9	need	need	NOUN
tahrj-8728	302	10	for	for	ADP
tahrj-8728	302	11	such	such	DET
tahrj-8728	302	12	an	an	DET
tahrj-8728	302	13	interference	interference	NOUN
tahrj-8728	302	14	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	303	1	4	4	X
tahrj-8728	303	2	.	.	X
tahrj-8728	303	3	there	there	PRON
tahrj-8728	303	4	must	must	AUX
tahrj-8728	303	5	be	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	303	6	procedural	procedural	ADJ
tahrj-8728	303	7	guarantees	guarantee	NOUN
tahrj-8728	303	8	against	against	ADP
tahrj-8728	303	9	abuse	abuse	NOUN
tahrj-8728	303	10	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	303	11	such	such	ADJ
tahrj-8728	303	12	interference	interference	NOUN
tahrj-8728	303	13	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	304	1	while	while	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	304	2	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	304	3	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	304	4	agreed	agree	VERB
tahrj-8728	304	5	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	304	6	such	such	ADJ
tahrj-8728	304	7	limitation	limitation	NOUN
tahrj-8728	304	8	needs	need	VERB
tahrj-8728	304	9	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	304	10	be	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	304	11	as	as	ADP
tahrj-8728	304	12	per	per	ADP
tahrj-8728	304	13	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	304	14	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	304	15	test	test	NOUN
tahrj-8728	304	16	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	304	17	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	304	18	encapsulation	encapsulation	NOUN
tahrj-8728	304	19	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	304	20	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	304	21	was	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	304	22	very	very	ADV
tahrj-8728	304	23	different	different	ADJ
tahrj-8728	304	24	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	305	1	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	305	2	majority	majority	NOUN
tahrj-8728	305	3	opinion	opinion	NOUN
tahrj-8728	305	4	stated	state	VERB
tahrj-8728	305	5	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	305	6	following	following	NOUN
tahrj-8728	305	7	as	as	ADP
tahrj-8728	305	8	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	305	9	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	305	10	test	test	NOUN
tahrj-8728	305	11	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	305	12	1	1	X
tahrj-8728	305	13	.	.	X
tahrj-8728	305	14	legitimate	legitimate	ADJ
tahrj-8728	305	15	aim	aim	NOUN
tahrj-8728	305	16	such	such	ADJ
tahrj-8728	305	17	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	305	18	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	305	19	goal	goal	NOUN
tahrj-8728	305	20	is	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	305	21	sufficiently	sufficiently	ADV
tahrj-8728	305	22	important	important	ADJ
tahrj-8728	305	23	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	306	1	2	2	X
tahrj-8728	306	2	.	.	X
tahrj-8728	306	3	necessity	necessity	NOUN
tahrj-8728	306	4	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	306	5	means	mean	NOUN
tahrj-8728	306	6	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	307	1	3	3	X
tahrj-8728	307	2	.	.	X
tahrj-8728	307	3	identify	identify	VERB
tahrj-8728	307	4	alternatives	alternative	NOUN
tahrj-8728	307	5	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	307	6	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	307	7	measure	measure	NOUN
tahrj-8728	307	8	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	308	1	a.	a.	NOUN
tahrj-8728	308	2	effectiveness	effectiveness	NOUN
tahrj-8728	308	3	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	308	4	each	each	DET
tahrj-8728	308	5	measure	measure	NOUN
tahrj-8728	308	6	b.	b.	PROPN
tahrj-8728	308	7	examine	examine	VERB
tahrj-8728	308	8	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	308	9	impact	impact	NOUN
tahrj-8728	308	10	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	308	11	each	each	DET
tahrj-8728	308	12	measure	measure	NOUN
tahrj-8728	308	13	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	309	1	c.	c.	NOUN
tahrj-8728	309	2	determine	determine	VERB
tahrj-8728	309	3	if	if	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	309	4	there	there	PRON
tahrj-8728	309	5	is	be	VERB
tahrj-8728	309	6	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	309	7	preferable	preferable	ADJ
tahrj-8728	309	8	alternative	alternative	NOUN
tahrj-8728	309	9	that	that	PRON
tahrj-8728	309	10	realizes	realize	VERB
tahrj-8728	309	11	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	309	12	aim	aim	NOUN
tahrj-8728	309	13	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	309	14	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	309	15	real	real	ADJ
tahrj-8728	309	16	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	309	17	substantial	substantial	ADJ
tahrj-8728	309	18	manner	manner	NOUN
tahrj-8728	309	19	but	but	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	309	20	is	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	309	21	less	less	ADV
tahrj-8728	309	22	intrusive	intrusive	ADJ
tahrj-8728	309	23	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	310	1	4	4	X
tahrj-8728	310	2	.	.	X
tahrj-8728	310	3	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	310	4	strictu	strictu	VERB
tahrj-8728	310	5	sensu	sensu	NOUN
tahrj-8728	310	6	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	310	7	this	this	PRON
tahrj-8728	310	8	should	should	AUX
tahrj-8728	310	9	follow	follow	VERB
tahrj-8728	310	10	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	310	11	‘	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	310	12	bright	bright	ADJ
tahrj-8728	310	13	line	line	NOUN
tahrj-8728	310	14	’	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	310	15	rule	rule	NOUN
tahrj-8728	310	16	while	while	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	310	17	balancing	balancing	NOUN
tahrj-8728	310	18	which	which	PRON
tahrj-8728	310	19	means	mean	VERB
tahrj-8728	310	20	balancing	balance	VERB
tahrj-8728	310	21	based	base	VERB
tahrj-8728	310	22	on	on	ADP
tahrj-8728	310	23	some	some	DET
tahrj-8728	310	24	established	establish	VERB
tahrj-8728	310	25	rules	rule	NOUN
tahrj-8728	310	26	or	or	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	310	27	by	by	ADP
tahrj-8728	310	28	creating	create	VERB
tahrj-8728	310	29	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	310	30	sound	sound	NOUN
tahrj-8728	310	31	rule	rule	NOUN
tahrj-8728	310	32	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	311	1	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	311	2	minority	minority	NOUN
tahrj-8728	311	3	opinion	opinion	NOUN
tahrj-8728	311	4	laid	lay	VERB
tahrj-8728	311	5	down	down	ADP
tahrj-8728	311	6	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	311	7	three	three	NUM
tahrj-8728	311	8	-	-	ADJ
tahrj-8728	311	9	fold	fold	ADJ
tahrj-8728	311	10	criteria	criterion	NOUN
tahrj-8728	311	11	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	311	12	legality	legality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	311	13	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	311	14	legitimacy	legitimacy	NOUN
tahrj-8728	311	15	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	311	16	aims	aim	NOUN
tahrj-8728	311	17	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	311	18	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	311	19	as	as	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	311	20	envisaged	envisage	VERB
tahrj-8728	311	21	under	under	ADP
tahrj-8728	311	22	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	311	23	‘	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	311	24	procedural	procedural	ADJ
tahrj-8728	311	25	mandate	mandate	NOUN
tahrj-8728	311	26	’	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	311	27	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	311	28	art	art	NOUN
tahrj-8728	311	29	21	21	NUM
tahrj-8728	311	30	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	311	31	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	311	32	constitution	constitution	NOUN
tahrj-8728	311	33	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	311	34	puttaswamy	puttaswamy	PROPN
tahrj-8728	311	35	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	311	36	ii	ii	NOUN
tahrj-8728	311	37	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	311	38	v	v	PROPN
tahrj-8728	311	39	union	union	NOUN
tahrj-8728	311	40	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	311	41	india	india	PROPN
tahrj-8728	311	42	2019	2019	NUM
tahrj-8728	311	43	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	311	44	p.	p.	NOUN
tahrj-8728	311	45	504	504	NUM
tahrj-8728	311	46	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	311	47	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	312	1	what	what	PRON
tahrj-8728	312	2	legitimacy	legitimacy	NOUN
tahrj-8728	312	3	entailed	entail	VERB
tahrj-8728	312	4	was	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	312	5	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	312	6	determine	determine	VERB
tahrj-8728	312	7	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	312	8	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	312	9	measures	measure	NOUN
tahrj-8728	312	10	can	can	AUX
tahrj-8728	312	11	be	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	312	12	justified	justify	VERB
tahrj-8728	312	13	by	by	ADP
tahrj-8728	312	14	law	law	NOUN
tahrj-8728	312	15	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	312	16	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	312	17	not	not	PART
tahrj-8728	312	18	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	312	19	scrutinise	scrutinise	VERB
tahrj-8728	312	20	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	312	21	law	law	NOUN
tahrj-8728	312	22	as	as	ADP
tahrj-8728	312	23	such	such	ADJ
tahrj-8728	312	24	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	313	1	moreover	moreover	ADV
tahrj-8728	313	2	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	313	3	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	313	4	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	313	5	limb	limb	NOUN
tahrj-8728	313	6	ensures	ensure	VERB
tahrj-8728	313	7	that	that	PRON
tahrj-8728	313	8	interference	interference	NOUN
tahrj-8728	313	9	with	with	ADP
tahrj-8728	313	10	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	313	11	right	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	313	12	is	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	313	13	not	not	PART
tahrj-8728	313	14	disproportionate	disproportionate	ADJ
tahrj-8728	313	15	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	313	16	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	313	17	purpose	purpose	NOUN
tahrj-8728	313	18	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	313	19	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	313	20	law	law	NOUN
tahrj-8728	313	21	which	which	PRON
tahrj-8728	313	22	requires	require	VERB
tahrj-8728	313	23	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	313	24	rational	rational	ADJ
tahrj-8728	313	25	nexus	nexus	NOUN
tahrj-8728	313	26	between	between	ADP
tahrj-8728	313	27	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	313	28	measure	measure	NOUN
tahrj-8728	313	29	adopted	adopt	VERB
tahrj-8728	313	30	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	313	31	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	313	32	aim	aim	NOUN
tahrj-8728	313	33	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	314	1	however	however	ADV
tahrj-8728	314	2	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	314	3	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	314	4	nexus	nexus	NOUN
tahrj-8728	314	5	was	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	314	6	interpreted	interpret	VERB
tahrj-8728	314	7	as	as	ADP
tahrj-8728	314	8	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	314	9	if	if	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	314	10	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	314	11	means	mean	NOUN
tahrj-8728	314	12	used	use	VERB
tahrj-8728	314	13	could	could	AUX
tahrj-8728	314	14	achieve	achieve	VERB
tahrj-8728	314	15	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	314	16	aim	aim	NOUN
tahrj-8728	314	17	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	315	1	https://doi.org/10.17561/tahrj.v23.8728	https://doi.org/10.17561/tahrj.v23.8728	PROPN
tahrj-8728	315	2	sabreen	sabreen	PROPN
tahrj-8728	315	3	ahmed	ahme	VERB
tahrj-8728	315	4	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	315	5	age	age	NOUN
tahrj-8728	315	6	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	315	7	human	human	ADJ
tahrj-8728	315	8	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	315	9	journal	journal	NOUN
tahrj-8728	315	10	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	315	11	24	24	NUM
tahrj-8728	315	12	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	315	13	june	june	PROPN
tahrj-8728	315	14	2025	2025	NUM
tahrj-8728	315	15	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	315	16	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	315	17	e8728	e8728	PROPN
tahrj-8728	315	18	issn	issn	PROPN
tahrj-8728	315	19	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	315	20	2340	2340	NUM
tahrj-8728	315	21	-	-	SYM
tahrj-8728	315	22	9592	9592	NUM
tahrj-8728	315	23	doi	doi	NOUN
tahrj-8728	315	24	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	315	25	10.17561	10.17561	NUM
tahrj-8728	315	26	/	/	SYM
tahrj-8728	315	27	tahrj.v23.8728	tahrj.v23.8728	PROPN
tahrj-8728	315	28	17	17	NUM
tahrj-8728	315	29	while	while	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	315	30	presenting	present	VERB
tahrj-8728	315	31	two	two	NUM
tahrj-8728	315	32	different	different	ADJ
tahrj-8728	315	33	versions	version	NOUN
tahrj-8728	315	34	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	315	35	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	315	36	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	315	37	test	test	NOUN
tahrj-8728	315	38	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	315	39	majority	majority	NOUN
tahrj-8728	315	40	opinion	opinion	NOUN
tahrj-8728	315	41	tried	try	VERB
tahrj-8728	315	42	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	315	43	take	take	VERB
tahrj-8728	315	44	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	315	45	more	more	ADV
tahrj-8728	315	46	scrutinised	scrutinise	VERB
tahrj-8728	315	47	approach	approach	NOUN
tahrj-8728	315	48	than	than	ADP
tahrj-8728	315	49	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	315	50	minority	minority	NOUN
tahrj-8728	315	51	opinion	opinion	NOUN
tahrj-8728	315	52	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	316	1	nevertheless	nevertheless	ADV
tahrj-8728	316	2	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	316	3	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	316	4	majority	majority	NOUN
tahrj-8728	316	5	test	test	NOUN
tahrj-8728	316	6	also	also	ADV
tahrj-8728	316	7	failed	fail	VERB
tahrj-8728	316	8	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	316	9	examine	examine	VERB
tahrj-8728	316	10	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	316	11	law	law	NOUN
tahrj-8728	316	12	itself	itself	PRON
tahrj-8728	316	13	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	316	14	that	that	ADV
tahrj-8728	316	15	is	is	ADV
tahrj-8728	316	16	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	316	17	how	how	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	316	18	it	it	PRON
tahrj-8728	316	19	works	work	VERB
tahrj-8728	316	20	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	316	21	how	how	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	316	22	it	it	PRON
tahrj-8728	316	23	violates	violate	VERB
tahrj-8728	316	24	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	316	25	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	316	26	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	316	27	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	316	28	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	316	29	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	316	30	limb	limb	NOUN
tahrj-8728	316	31	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	317	1	it	it	PRON
tahrj-8728	317	2	only	only	ADV
tahrj-8728	317	3	tests	test	VERB
tahrj-8728	317	4	for	for	ADP
tahrj-8728	317	5	logical	logical	ADJ
tahrj-8728	317	6	consistency	consistency	NOUN
tahrj-8728	317	7	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	317	8	which	which	PRON
tahrj-8728	317	9	is	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	317	10	not	not	PART
tahrj-8728	317	11	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	317	12	true	true	ADJ
tahrj-8728	317	13	test	test	NOUN
tahrj-8728	317	14	for	for	ADP
tahrj-8728	317	15	determining	determine	VERB
tahrj-8728	317	16	how	how	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	317	17	intrusive	intrusive	ADJ
tahrj-8728	317	18	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	317	19	measure	measure	NOUN
tahrj-8728	317	20	is	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	317	21	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	318	1	thereby	thereby	ADV
tahrj-8728	318	2	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	318	3	test	test	NOUN
tahrj-8728	318	4	is	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	318	5	less	less	ADV
tahrj-8728	318	6	intensive	intensive	ADJ
tahrj-8728	318	7	so	so	ADV
tahrj-8728	318	8	far	far	ADV
tahrj-8728	318	9	as	as	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	318	10	an	an	DET
tahrj-8728	318	11	examination	examination	NOUN
tahrj-8728	318	12	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	318	13	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	318	14	necessity	necessity	NOUN
tahrj-8728	318	15	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	318	16	effectiveness	effectiveness	NOUN
tahrj-8728	318	17	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	318	18	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	318	19	measure	measure	NOUN
tahrj-8728	318	20	is	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	318	21	concerned	concern	VERB
tahrj-8728	318	22	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	319	1	consequently	consequently	ADV
tahrj-8728	319	2	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	319	3	this	this	PRON
tahrj-8728	319	4	impacts	impact	VERB
tahrj-8728	319	5	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	319	6	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	319	7	analysis	analysis	NOUN
tahrj-8728	319	8	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	319	9	balancing	balance	VERB
tahrj-8728	319	10	such	such	ADJ
tahrj-8728	319	11	measures	measure	NOUN
tahrj-8728	319	12	with	with	ADP
tahrj-8728	319	13	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	319	14	right	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	319	15	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	319	16	question	question	NOUN
tahrj-8728	319	17	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	320	1	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	320	2	effect	effect	NOUN
tahrj-8728	320	3	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	320	4	while	while	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	320	5	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	320	6	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	320	7	did	do	AUX
tahrj-8728	320	8	move	move	VERB
tahrj-8728	320	9	slightly	slightly	ADV
tahrj-8728	320	10	away	away	ADV
tahrj-8728	320	11	from	from	ADP
tahrj-8728	320	12	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	320	13	wednesbury	wednesbury	PROPN
tahrj-8728	320	14	principle	principle	NOUN
tahrj-8728	320	15	or	or	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	320	16	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	320	17	reasonableness	reasonableness	NOUN
tahrj-8728	320	18	analysis	analysis	NOUN
tahrj-8728	320	19	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	320	20	it	it	PRON
tahrj-8728	320	21	reduced	reduce	VERB
tahrj-8728	320	22	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	320	23	reach	reach	NOUN
tahrj-8728	320	24	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	320	25	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	320	26	analysis	analysis	NOUN
tahrj-8728	320	27	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	320	28	louis	louis	NOUN
tahrj-8728	320	29	de	de	ADP
tahrj-8728	320	30	raedt	raedt	PROPN
tahrj-8728	320	31	v.	v.	ADP
tahrj-8728	320	32	union	union	PROPN
tahrj-8728	320	33	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	320	34	india	india	PROPN
tahrj-8728	320	35	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	320	36	1991	1991	NUM
tahrj-8728	320	37	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	320	38	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	321	1	3.1	3.1	NUM
tahrj-8728	321	2	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	322	1	‘	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	322	2	non	non	ADJ
tahrj-8728	322	3	-	-	ADJ
tahrj-8728	322	4	refoulment	refoulment	ADJ
tahrj-8728	322	5	’	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	322	6	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	322	7	india	india	PROPN
tahrj-8728	322	8	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	322	9	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	322	10	fundamental	fundamental	ADJ
tahrj-8728	322	11	right	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	322	12	?	?	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	323	1	india	india	PROPN
tahrj-8728	323	2	follows	follow	VERB
tahrj-8728	323	3	dualist	dualist	ADJ
tahrj-8728	323	4	system	system	NOUN
tahrj-8728	323	5	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	323	6	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	323	7	application	application	NOUN
tahrj-8728	323	8	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	323	9	international	international	ADJ
tahrj-8728	323	10	law	law	NOUN
tahrj-8728	323	11	i.e.	i.e.	X
tahrj-8728	323	12	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	323	13	order	order	NOUN
tahrj-8728	323	14	for	for	ADP
tahrj-8728	323	15	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	323	16	treaty	treaty	NOUN
tahrj-8728	323	17	obligation	obligation	NOUN
tahrj-8728	323	18	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	323	19	become	become	VERB
tahrj-8728	323	20	binding	bind	VERB
tahrj-8728	323	21	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	323	22	it	it	PRON
tahrj-8728	323	23	has	have	VERB
tahrj-8728	323	24	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	323	25	be	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	323	26	backed	back	VERB
tahrj-8728	323	27	by	by	ADP
tahrj-8728	323	28	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	323	29	legislative	legislative	ADJ
tahrj-8728	323	30	enactment	enactment	NOUN
tahrj-8728	323	31	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	324	1	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	324	2	alexander	alexander	NOUN
tahrj-8728	324	3	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	324	4	2021	2021	NUM
tahrj-8728	324	5	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	324	6	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	325	1	however	however	ADV
tahrj-8728	325	2	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	325	3	given	give	VERB
tahrj-8728	325	4	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	325	5	india	india	PROPN
tahrj-8728	325	6	has	have	AUX
tahrj-8728	325	7	not	not	PART
tahrj-8728	325	8	ratified	ratify	VERB
tahrj-8728	325	9	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	325	10	1951	1951	NUM
tahrj-8728	325	11	convention	convention	NOUN
tahrj-8728	325	12	relating	relate	VERB
tahrj-8728	325	13	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	325	14	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	325	15	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	325	16	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	325	17	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	325	18	refugees	refugee	NOUN
tahrj-8728	325	19	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	325	20	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	325	21	does	do	AUX
tahrj-8728	325	22	not	not	PART
tahrj-8728	325	23	have	have	VERB
tahrj-8728	325	24	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	325	25	comprehensive	comprehensive	ADJ
tahrj-8728	325	26	nationwide	nationwide	ADJ
tahrj-8728	325	27	refugee	refugee	NOUN
tahrj-8728	325	28	mechanism	mechanism	NOUN
tahrj-8728	325	29	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	325	30	application	application	NOUN
tahrj-8728	325	31	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	325	32	art	art	NOUN
tahrj-8728	325	33	33	33	NUM
tahrj-8728	325	34	prohibiting	prohibit	VERB
tahrj-8728	325	35	non	non	ADJ
tahrj-8728	325	36	-	-	ADJ
tahrj-8728	325	37	refoulement	refoulement	ADJ
tahrj-8728	325	38	or	or	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	325	39	return	return	NOUN
tahrj-8728	325	40	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	325	41	refugees	refugee	NOUN
tahrj-8728	325	42	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	325	43	places	place	NOUN
tahrj-8728	325	44	where	where	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	325	45	their	their	PRON
tahrj-8728	325	46	lives	life	NOUN
tahrj-8728	325	47	are	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	325	48	at	at	ADP
tahrj-8728	325	49	threat	threat	NOUN
tahrj-8728	325	50	does	do	AUX
tahrj-8728	325	51	not	not	PART
tahrj-8728	325	52	find	find	VERB
tahrj-8728	325	53	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	325	54	consistent	consistent	ADJ
tahrj-8728	325	55	interpretation	interpretation	NOUN
tahrj-8728	325	56	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	326	1	some	some	DET
tahrj-8728	326	2	scholars	scholar	NOUN
tahrj-8728	326	3	have	have	AUX
tahrj-8728	326	4	argued	argue	VERB
tahrj-8728	326	5	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	326	6	application	application	NOUN
tahrj-8728	326	7	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	326	8	non	non	ADJ
tahrj-8728	326	9	-	-	ADJ
tahrj-8728	326	10	refoulement	refoulement	ADJ
tahrj-8728	326	11	obligations	obligation	NOUN
tahrj-8728	326	12	by	by	ADP
tahrj-8728	326	13	international	international	ADJ
tahrj-8728	326	14	human	human	ADJ
tahrj-8728	326	15	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	326	16	obligations	obligation	NOUN
tahrj-8728	326	17	emanating	emanate	VERB
tahrj-8728	326	18	from	from	ADP
tahrj-8728	326	19	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	326	20	udhr	udhr	NOUN
tahrj-8728	326	21	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	326	22	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	326	23	iccpr	iccpr	ADJ
tahrj-8728	326	24	provisions	provision	NOUN
tahrj-8728	326	25	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	327	1	some	some	PRON
tahrj-8728	327	2	have	have	AUX
tahrj-8728	327	3	also	also	ADV
tahrj-8728	327	4	argued	argue	VERB
tahrj-8728	327	5	direct	direct	ADJ
tahrj-8728	327	6	application	application	NOUN
tahrj-8728	327	7	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	327	8	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	327	9	obligation	obligation	NOUN
tahrj-8728	327	10	as	as	ADP
tahrj-8728	327	11	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	327	12	part	part	NOUN
tahrj-8728	327	13	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	327	14	customary	customary	ADJ
tahrj-8728	327	15	international	international	ADJ
tahrj-8728	327	16	law	law	NOUN
tahrj-8728	327	17	extending	extend	VERB
tahrj-8728	327	18	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	327	19	jus	jus	ADJ
tahrj-8728	327	20	cogens	cogen	NOUN
tahrj-8728	327	21	or	or	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	327	22	premptory	premptory	ADJ
tahrj-8728	327	23	norm	norm	NOUN
tahrj-8728	327	24	argument	argument	NOUN
tahrj-8728	327	25	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	327	26	this	this	DET
tahrj-8728	327	27	regard	regard	NOUN
tahrj-8728	327	28	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	328	1	but	but	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	328	2	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	328	3	country	country	NOUN
tahrj-8728	328	4	’s	’s	PART
tahrj-8728	328	5	position	position	NOUN
tahrj-8728	328	6	on	on	ADP
tahrj-8728	328	7	customary	customary	ADJ
tahrj-8728	328	8	international	international	ADJ
tahrj-8728	328	9	law	law	NOUN
tahrj-8728	328	10	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	328	11	administrative	administrative	ADJ
tahrj-8728	328	12	practical	practical	ADJ
tahrj-8728	328	13	interpretations	interpretation	NOUN
tahrj-8728	328	14	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	328	15	kumar	kumar	PROPN
tahrj-8728	328	16	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	328	17	2018	2018	NUM
tahrj-8728	328	18	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	328	19	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	328	20	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	328	21	principle	principle	NOUN
tahrj-8728	328	22	so	so	ADV
tahrj-8728	328	23	far	far	ADV
tahrj-8728	328	24	fall	fall	VERB
tahrj-8728	328	25	short	short	ADJ
tahrj-8728	328	26	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	328	27	creating	create	VERB
tahrj-8728	328	28	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	328	29	binding	bind	VERB
tahrj-8728	328	30	legal	legal	ADJ
tahrj-8728	328	31	obligation	obligation	NOUN
tahrj-8728	328	32	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	328	33	non	non	ADJ
tahrj-8728	328	34	-	-	ADJ
tahrj-8728	328	35	refoulement	refoulement	ADJ
tahrj-8728	328	36	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	328	37	india	india	PROPN
tahrj-8728	328	38	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	329	1	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	329	2	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	329	3	absence	absence	NOUN
tahrj-8728	329	4	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	329	5	any	any	DET
tahrj-8728	329	6	domestic	domestic	ADJ
tahrj-8728	329	7	law	law	NOUN
tahrj-8728	329	8	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	329	9	this	this	DET
tahrj-8728	329	10	effect	effect	NOUN
tahrj-8728	329	11	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	329	12	judiciary	judiciary	NOUN
tahrj-8728	329	13	approaches	approach	VERB
tahrj-8728	329	14	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	329	15	question	question	NOUN
tahrj-8728	329	16	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	329	17	non	non	ADJ
tahrj-8728	329	18	-	-	ADJ
tahrj-8728	329	19	refoulement	refoulement	ADJ
tahrj-8728	329	20	from	from	ADP
tahrj-8728	329	21	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	329	22	constitutional	constitutional	ADJ
tahrj-8728	329	23	perspective	perspective	NOUN
tahrj-8728	329	24	under	under	ADP
tahrj-8728	329	25	art	art	NOUN
tahrj-8728	329	26	21	21	NUM
tahrj-8728	329	27	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	329	28	right	right	ADV
tahrj-8728	329	29	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	329	30	life	life	NOUN
tahrj-8728	329	31	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	329	32	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	329	33	utilises	utilise	VERB
tahrj-8728	329	34	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	329	35	international	international	ADJ
tahrj-8728	329	36	human	human	ADJ
tahrj-8728	329	37	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	329	38	convention	convention	NOUN
tahrj-8728	329	39	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	329	40	this	this	DET
tahrj-8728	329	41	context	context	NOUN
tahrj-8728	329	42	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	330	1	however	however	ADV
tahrj-8728	330	2	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	330	3	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	330	4	application	application	NOUN
tahrj-8728	330	5	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	330	6	art	art	NOUN
tahrj-8728	330	7	21	21	NUM
tahrj-8728	330	8	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	330	9	non	non	ADJ
tahrj-8728	330	10	-	-	ADJ
tahrj-8728	330	11	refoulement	refoulement	ADJ
tahrj-8728	330	12	is	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	330	13	also	also	ADV
tahrj-8728	330	14	debatable	debatable	ADJ
tahrj-8728	330	15	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	331	1	for	for	ADP
tahrj-8728	331	2	example	example	NOUN
tahrj-8728	331	3	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	331	4	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	331	5	hans	hans	PROPN
tahrj-8728	331	6	muller	muller	PROPN
tahrj-8728	331	7	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	331	8	nuremberg	nuremberg	PROPN
tahrj-8728	331	9	v.	v.	ADP
tahrj-8728	331	10	superintendent	superintendent	PROPN
tahrj-8728	331	11	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	331	12	presidency	presidency	NOUN
tahrj-8728	331	13	jail	jail	NOUN
tahrj-8728	331	14	calcutta	calcutta	NOUN
tahrj-8728	331	15	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	331	16	1955	1955	NUM
tahrj-8728	331	17	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	331	18	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	331	19	supreme	supreme	PROPN
tahrj-8728	331	20	court	court	PROPN
tahrj-8728	331	21	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	331	22	india	india	PROPN
tahrj-8728	331	23	held	hold	VERB
tahrj-8728	331	24	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	331	25	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	331	26	government	government	NOUN
tahrj-8728	331	27	has	have	VERB
tahrj-8728	331	28	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	331	29	power	power	NOUN
tahrj-8728	331	30	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	331	31	deport	deport	VERB
tahrj-8728	331	32	foreigners	foreigner	NOUN
tahrj-8728	331	33	despite	despite	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	331	34	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	331	35	applicability	applicability	NOUN
tahrj-8728	331	36	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	331	37	art	art	NOUN
tahrj-8728	331	38	21	21	NUM
tahrj-8728	331	39	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	331	40	such	such	ADJ
tahrj-8728	331	41	cases	case	NOUN
tahrj-8728	331	42	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	331	43	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	331	44	loius	loius	PROPN
tahrj-8728	331	45	de	de	PROPN
tahrj-8728	331	46	raedt	raedt	PROPN
tahrj-8728	331	47	v.	v.	ADP
tahrj-8728	331	48	union	union	PROPN
tahrj-8728	331	49	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	331	50	india	india	PROPN
tahrj-8728	331	51	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	331	52	1991	1991	NUM
tahrj-8728	331	53	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	331	54	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	331	55	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	331	56	held	hold	VERB
tahrj-8728	331	57	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	331	58	art	art	NOUN
tahrj-8728	331	59	21	21	NUM
tahrj-8728	331	60	applies	apply	VERB
tahrj-8728	331	61	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	331	62	not	not	PART
tahrj-8728	331	63	only	only	ADV
tahrj-8728	331	64	citizens	citizen	NOUN
tahrj-8728	331	65	but	but	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	331	66	also	also	ADV
tahrj-8728	331	67	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	331	68	foreigners	foreigner	NOUN
tahrj-8728	331	69	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	332	1	however	however	ADV
tahrj-8728	332	2	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	332	3	this	this	DET
tahrj-8728	332	4	line	line	NOUN
tahrj-8728	332	5	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	332	6	jurisprudence	jurisprudence	NOUN
tahrj-8728	332	7	has	have	AUX
tahrj-8728	332	8	been	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	332	9	applied	apply	VERB
tahrj-8728	332	10	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	332	11	all	all	DET
tahrj-8728	332	12	subsequent	subsequent	ADJ
tahrj-8728	332	13	cases	case	NOUN
tahrj-8728	332	14	blurring	blur	VERB
tahrj-8728	332	15	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	332	16	line	line	NOUN
tahrj-8728	332	17	between	between	ADP
tahrj-8728	332	18	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	332	19	foreigner	foreigner	NOUN
tahrj-8728	332	20	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	332	21	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	332	22	refugee	refugee	NOUN
tahrj-8728	332	23	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	333	1	nevertheless	nevertheless	ADV
tahrj-8728	333	2	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	333	3	there	there	PRON
tahrj-8728	333	4	are	be	VERB
tahrj-8728	333	5	cases	case	NOUN
tahrj-8728	333	6	like	like	ADP
tahrj-8728	333	7	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	333	8	state	state	NOUN
tahrj-8728	333	9	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	333	10	arunachal	arunachal	PROPN
tahrj-8728	333	11	pradesh	pradesh	PROPN
tahrj-8728	333	12	v.	v.	ADP
tahrj-8728	333	13	national	national	PROPN
tahrj-8728	333	14	human	human	PROPN
tahrj-8728	333	15	rights	rights	PROPN
tahrj-8728	333	16	commission	commission	NOUN
tahrj-8728	333	17	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	333	18	1996	1996	NUM
tahrj-8728	333	19	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	333	20	where	where	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	333	21	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	333	22	sc	sc	PROPN
tahrj-8728	333	23	has	have	AUX
tahrj-8728	333	24	taken	take	VERB
tahrj-8728	333	25	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	333	26	proactive	proactive	ADJ
tahrj-8728	333	27	approach	approach	NOUN
tahrj-8728	333	28	towards	towards	ADP
tahrj-8728	333	29	refugees	refugee	NOUN
tahrj-8728	333	30	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	334	1	it	it	PRON
tahrj-8728	334	2	was	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	334	3	held	hold	VERB
tahrj-8728	334	4	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	334	5	this	this	DET
tahrj-8728	334	6	case	case	NOUN
tahrj-8728	334	7	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	334	8	while	while	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	334	9	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	334	10	refugee	refugee	NOUN
tahrj-8728	334	11	applications	application	NOUN
tahrj-8728	334	12	for	for	ADP
tahrj-8728	334	13	citizenship	citizenship	NOUN
tahrj-8728	334	14	are	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	334	15	due	due	ADJ
tahrj-8728	334	16	for	for	ADP
tahrj-8728	334	17	consideration	consideration	NOUN
tahrj-8728	334	18	then	then	ADV
tahrj-8728	334	19	they	they	PRON
tahrj-8728	334	20	can	can	AUX
tahrj-8728	334	21	not	not	PART
tahrj-8728	334	22	be	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	334	23	evicted	evict	VERB
tahrj-8728	334	24	from	from	ADP
tahrj-8728	334	25	arunachal	arunachal	PROPN
tahrj-8728	334	26	pradesh	pradesh	PROPN
tahrj-8728	334	27	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	335	1	recently	recently	ADV
tahrj-8728	335	2	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	335	3	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	335	4	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	335	5	dealt	deal	VERB
tahrj-8728	335	6	with	with	ADP
tahrj-8728	335	7	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	335	8	question	question	NOUN
tahrj-8728	335	9	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	335	10	deportation	deportation	NOUN
tahrj-8728	335	11	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	335	12	rohingya	rohingya	NOUN
tahrj-8728	335	13	refugees	refugee	NOUN
tahrj-8728	335	14	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	335	15	mohammad	mohammad	PROPN
tahrj-8728	335	16	salimullah	salimullah	PROPN
tahrj-8728	335	17	v.	v.	ADP
tahrj-8728	335	18	union	union	PROPN
tahrj-8728	335	19	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	335	20	india	india	PROPN
tahrj-8728	335	21	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	335	22	2021	2021	NUM
tahrj-8728	335	23	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	335	24	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	336	1	on	on	ADP
tahrj-8728	336	2	august	august	PROPN
tahrj-8728	336	3	8	8	NUM
tahrj-8728	336	4	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	336	5	2017	2017	NUM
tahrj-8728	336	6	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	336	7	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	336	8	ministry	ministry	PROPN
tahrj-8728	336	9	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	336	10	home	home	PROPN
tahrj-8728	336	11	affairs	affair	NOUN
tahrj-8728	336	12	advised	advise	VERB
tahrj-8728	336	13	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	336	14	state	state	NOUN
tahrj-8728	336	15	government	government	NOUN
tahrj-8728	336	16	through	through	ADP
tahrj-8728	336	17	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	336	18	letter	letter	NOUN
tahrj-8728	336	19	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	336	20	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	336	21	deportation	deportation	NOUN
tahrj-8728	336	22	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	336	23	40,000	40,000	NUM
tahrj-8728	336	24	rohingya	rohingya	NOUN
tahrj-8728	336	25	refugees	refugee	NOUN
tahrj-8728	336	26	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	336	27	krishna	krishna	PROPN
tahrj-8728	336	28	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	336	29	sanjeev	sanjeev	PROPN
tahrj-8728	336	30	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	336	31	2017	2017	NUM
tahrj-8728	336	32	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	336	33	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	337	1	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	337	2	government	government	NOUN
tahrj-8728	337	3	argued	argue	VERB
tahrj-8728	337	4	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	337	5	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	337	6	influx	influx	NOUN
tahrj-8728	337	7	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	337	8	immigrants	immigrant	NOUN
tahrj-8728	337	9	posed	pose	VERB
tahrj-8728	337	10	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	337	11	national	national	ADJ
tahrj-8728	337	12	security	security	NOUN
tahrj-8728	337	13	threat	threat	NOUN
tahrj-8728	337	14	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	337	15	hence	hence	ADV
tahrj-8728	337	16	needed	need	VERB
tahrj-8728	337	17	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	337	18	be	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	337	19	deported	deport	VERB
tahrj-8728	337	20	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	337	21	mohammad	mohammad	PROPN
tahrj-8728	337	22	https://doi.org/10.17561/tahrj.v23.8728	https://doi.org/10.17561/tahrj.v23.8728	PROPN
tahrj-8728	337	23	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	337	24	analysis	analysis	NOUN
tahrj-8728	337	25	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	337	26	non	non	ADJ
tahrj-8728	337	27	-	-	ADJ
tahrj-8728	337	28	refoulement	refoulement	ADJ
tahrj-8728	337	29	jurisprudence	jurisprudence	NOUN
tahrj-8728	337	30	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	337	31	india	india	PROPN
tahrj-8728	337	32	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	337	33	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	337	34	comparative	comparative	ADJ
tahrj-8728	337	35	approach	approach	NOUN
tahrj-8728	337	36	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	337	37	age	age	NOUN
tahrj-8728	337	38	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	337	39	human	human	ADJ
tahrj-8728	337	40	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	337	41	journal	journal	NOUN
tahrj-8728	337	42	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	337	43	24	24	NUM
tahrj-8728	337	44	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	337	45	june	june	PROPN
tahrj-8728	337	46	2025	2025	NUM
tahrj-8728	337	47	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	337	48	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	337	49	e8728	e8728	PROPN
tahrj-8728	337	50	issn	issn	PROPN
tahrj-8728	337	51	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	337	52	2340	2340	NUM
tahrj-8728	337	53	-	-	SYM
tahrj-8728	337	54	9592	9592	NUM
tahrj-8728	337	55	doi	doi	NOUN
tahrj-8728	337	56	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	337	57	10.17561	10.17561	NUM
tahrj-8728	337	58	/	/	SYM
tahrj-8728	337	59	tahrj.v23.8728	tahrj.v23.8728	PROPN
tahrj-8728	337	60	18	18	NUM
tahrj-8728	337	61	salimullah	salimullah	NOUN
tahrj-8728	337	62	v	v	ADP
tahrj-8728	337	63	union	union	NOUN
tahrj-8728	337	64	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	337	65	india	india	PROPN
tahrj-8728	337	66	2021	2021	NUM
tahrj-8728	337	67	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	337	68	rejoinder	rejoinder	NOUN
tahrj-8728	337	69	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	337	70	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	338	1	it	it	PRON
tahrj-8728	338	2	was	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	338	3	also	also	ADV
tahrj-8728	338	4	argued	argue	VERB
tahrj-8728	338	5	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	338	6	art	art	NOUN
tahrj-8728	338	7	14	14	NUM
tahrj-8728	338	8	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	338	9	21	21	NUM
tahrj-8728	338	10	apply	apply	VERB
tahrj-8728	338	11	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	338	12	foreigners	foreigner	NOUN
tahrj-8728	338	13	as	as	ADV
tahrj-8728	338	14	well	well	ADV
tahrj-8728	338	15	as	as	ADP
tahrj-8728	338	16	citizens	citizen	NOUN
tahrj-8728	338	17	but	but	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	338	18	there	there	PRON
tahrj-8728	338	19	is	be	VERB
tahrj-8728	338	20	no	no	DET
tahrj-8728	338	21	application	application	NOUN
tahrj-8728	338	22	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	338	23	art	art	NOUN
tahrj-8728	338	24	19	19	NUM
tahrj-8728	338	25	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	338	26	1	1	NUM
tahrj-8728	338	27	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	338	28	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	338	29	e	e	NOUN
tahrj-8728	338	30	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	338	31	on	on	ADP
tahrj-8728	338	32	foreigners	foreigner	NOUN
tahrj-8728	338	33	which	which	PRON
tahrj-8728	338	34	talks	talk	VERB
tahrj-8728	338	35	about	about	ADP
tahrj-8728	338	36	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	338	37	right	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	338	38	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	338	39	reside	reside	VERB
tahrj-8728	338	40	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	338	41	settle	settle	VERB
tahrj-8728	338	42	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	339	1	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	339	2	this	this	PRON
tahrj-8728	339	3	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	339	4	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	339	5	sc	sc	PROPN
tahrj-8728	339	6	upheld	uphold	VERB
tahrj-8728	339	7	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	339	8	deportation	deportation	NOUN
tahrj-8728	339	9	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	340	1	surprisingly	surprisingly	ADV
tahrj-8728	340	2	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	340	3	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	340	4	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	340	5	did	do	AUX
tahrj-8728	340	6	not	not	PART
tahrj-8728	340	7	dwell	dwell	VERB
tahrj-8728	340	8	upon	upon	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	340	9	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	340	10	application	application	NOUN
tahrj-8728	340	11	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	340	12	art	art	NOUN
tahrj-8728	340	13	21	21	NUM
tahrj-8728	340	14	at	at	ADV
tahrj-8728	340	15	all	all	ADV
tahrj-8728	340	16	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	341	1	only	only	ADV
tahrj-8728	341	2	based	base	VERB
tahrj-8728	341	3	on	on	ADP
tahrj-8728	341	4	art	art	NOUN
tahrj-8728	341	5	19	19	NUM
tahrj-8728	341	6	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	341	7	1	1	NUM
tahrj-8728	341	8	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	341	9	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	341	10	e	e	NOUN
tahrj-8728	341	11	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	341	12	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	341	13	it	it	PRON
tahrj-8728	341	14	was	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	341	15	decided	decide	VERB
tahrj-8728	341	16	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	341	17	foreigners	foreigner	NOUN
tahrj-8728	341	18	could	could	AUX
tahrj-8728	341	19	be	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	341	20	deported	deport	VERB
tahrj-8728	341	21	as	as	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	341	22	they	they	PRON
tahrj-8728	341	23	did	do	AUX
tahrj-8728	341	24	not	not	PART
tahrj-8728	341	25	have	have	VERB
tahrj-8728	341	26	any	any	DET
tahrj-8728	341	27	right	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	341	28	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	341	29	reside	reside	VERB
tahrj-8728	341	30	or	or	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	341	31	settle	settle	VERB
tahrj-8728	341	32	within	within	ADP
tahrj-8728	341	33	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	341	34	territory	territory	NOUN
tahrj-8728	341	35	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	342	1	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	342	2	careful	careful	ADJ
tahrj-8728	342	3	analysis	analysis	NOUN
tahrj-8728	342	4	suggests	suggest	VERB
tahrj-8728	342	5	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	342	6	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	342	7	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	342	8	focused	focus	VERB
tahrj-8728	342	9	on	on	ADP
tahrj-8728	342	10	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	342	11	application	application	NOUN
tahrj-8728	342	12	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	342	13	‘	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	342	14	due	due	ADJ
tahrj-8728	342	15	process	process	NOUN
tahrj-8728	342	16	’	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	342	17	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	342	18	returning	return	VERB
tahrj-8728	342	19	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	342	20	refugees	refugee	NOUN
tahrj-8728	342	21	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	342	22	did	do	AUX
tahrj-8728	342	23	not	not	PART
tahrj-8728	342	24	scrutinise	scrutinise	VERB
tahrj-8728	342	25	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	342	26	legality	legality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	342	27	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	342	28	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	342	29	deportation	deportation	NOUN
tahrj-8728	342	30	itself	itself	PRON
tahrj-8728	342	31	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	343	1	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	343	2	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	343	3	refused	refuse	VERB
tahrj-8728	343	4	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	343	5	apply	apply	VERB
tahrj-8728	343	6	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	343	7	international	international	ADJ
tahrj-8728	343	8	law	law	NOUN
tahrj-8728	343	9	obligations	obligation	NOUN
tahrj-8728	343	10	saying	say	VERB
tahrj-8728	343	11	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	343	12	it	it	PRON
tahrj-8728	343	13	is	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	343	14	beyond	beyond	ADP
tahrj-8728	343	15	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	343	16	scope	scope	NOUN
tahrj-8728	343	17	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	343	18	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	343	19	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	343	20	’s	’s	PART
tahrj-8728	343	21	power	power	NOUN
tahrj-8728	343	22	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	343	23	analyse	analyse	VERB
tahrj-8728	343	24	or	or	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	343	25	take	take	VERB
tahrj-8728	343	26	into	into	ADP
tahrj-8728	343	27	consideration	consideration	NOUN
tahrj-8728	343	28	something	something	PRON
tahrj-8728	343	29	happening	happen	VERB
tahrj-8728	343	30	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	343	31	other	other	ADJ
tahrj-8728	343	32	jurisdictions	jurisdiction	NOUN
tahrj-8728	343	33	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	344	1	additionally	additionally	ADV
tahrj-8728	344	2	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	344	3	mohammad	mohammad	PROPN
tahrj-8728	344	4	salimullah	salimullah	PROPN
tahrj-8728	344	5	v.	v.	ADP
tahrj-8728	344	6	union	union	PROPN
tahrj-8728	344	7	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	344	8	india	india	PROPN
tahrj-8728	344	9	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	344	10	2021	2021	NUM
tahrj-8728	344	11	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	344	12	rationale	rationale	NOUN
tahrj-8728	344	13	made	make	VERB
tahrj-8728	344	14	clear	clear	ADJ
tahrj-8728	344	15	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	344	16	‘	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	344	17	national	national	ADJ
tahrj-8728	344	18	courts	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	344	19	could	could	AUX
tahrj-8728	344	20	draw	draw	VERB
tahrj-8728	344	21	inspiration	inspiration	NOUN
tahrj-8728	344	22	from	from	ADP
tahrj-8728	344	23	treaties	treaty	NOUN
tahrj-8728	344	24	or	or	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	344	25	convention	convention	NOUN
tahrj-8728	344	26	unless	unless	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	344	27	it	it	PRON
tahrj-8728	344	28	is	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	344	29	not	not	PART
tahrj-8728	344	30	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	344	31	contravention	contravention	NOUN
tahrj-8728	344	32	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	344	33	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	344	34	municipal	municipal	ADJ
tahrj-8728	344	35	law	law	NOUN
tahrj-8728	344	36	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	344	37	’	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	345	1	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	345	2	locate	locate	VERB
tahrj-8728	345	3	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	345	4	subject	subject	NOUN
tahrj-8728	345	5	matter	matter	NOUN
tahrj-8728	345	6	more	more	ADV
tahrj-8728	345	7	inclusively	inclusively	ADV
tahrj-8728	345	8	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	345	9	it	it	PRON
tahrj-8728	345	10	is	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	345	11	important	important	ADJ
tahrj-8728	345	12	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	345	13	review	review	VERB
tahrj-8728	345	14	article	article	NOUN
tahrj-8728	345	15	51(c	51(c	NUM
tahrj-8728	345	16	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	345	17	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	345	18	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	345	19	constitution	constitution	NOUN
tahrj-8728	345	20	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	345	21	india	india	PROPN
tahrj-8728	345	22	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	345	23	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	345	24	fundamental	fundamental	ADJ
tahrj-8728	345	25	right	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	345	26	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	345	27	life	life	NOUN
tahrj-8728	345	28	under	under	ADP
tahrj-8728	345	29	article	article	NOUN
tahrj-8728	345	30	21	21	NUM
tahrj-8728	345	31	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	346	1	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	346	2	inference	inference	NOUN
tahrj-8728	346	3	that	that	PRON
tahrj-8728	346	4	practicing	practice	VERB
tahrj-8728	346	5	non	non	ADJ
tahrj-8728	346	6	-	-	ADJ
tahrj-8728	346	7	refoulement	refoulement	ADJ
tahrj-8728	346	8	would	would	AUX
tahrj-8728	346	9	be	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	346	10	against	against	ADP
tahrj-8728	346	11	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	346	12	municipal	municipal	ADJ
tahrj-8728	346	13	law	law	NOUN
tahrj-8728	346	14	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	346	15	india	india	PROPN
tahrj-8728	346	16	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	346	17	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	346	18	particular	particular	ADJ
tahrj-8728	346	19	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	346	20	foreigners	foreigner	NOUN
tahrj-8728	346	21	act	act	VERB
tahrj-8728	346	22	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	346	23	1946	1946	NUM
tahrj-8728	346	24	as	as	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	346	25	it	it	PRON
tahrj-8728	346	26	does	do	AUX
tahrj-8728	346	27	not	not	PART
tahrj-8728	346	28	hold	hold	VERB
tahrj-8728	346	29	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	346	30	obligation	obligation	NOUN
tahrj-8728	346	31	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	346	32	text	text	NOUN
tahrj-8728	346	33	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	346	34	spirit	spirit	NOUN
tahrj-8728	346	35	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	346	36	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	346	37	legislation	legislation	NOUN
tahrj-8728	346	38	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	346	39	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	346	40	its	its	PRON
tahrj-8728	346	41	section	section	NOUN
tahrj-8728	346	42	3(1	3(1	NUM
tahrj-8728	346	43	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	346	44	grants	grant	VERB
tahrj-8728	346	45	wide	wide	ADJ
tahrj-8728	346	46	discretion	discretion	NOUN
tahrj-8728	346	47	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	346	48	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	346	49	central	central	ADJ
tahrj-8728	346	50	government	government	NOUN
tahrj-8728	346	51	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	346	52	prohibit	prohibit	VERB
tahrj-8728	346	53	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	346	54	regulate	regulate	VERB
tahrj-8728	346	55	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	346	56	restrict	restrict	VERB
tahrj-8728	346	57	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	346	58	entry	entry	NOUN
tahrj-8728	346	59	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	346	60	foreigners	foreigner	NOUN
tahrj-8728	346	61	is	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	346	62	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	346	63	distasteful	distasteful	ADJ
tahrj-8728	346	64	insinuation	insinuation	NOUN
tahrj-8728	346	65	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	347	1	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	347	2	justification	justification	NOUN
tahrj-8728	347	3	for	for	ADP
tahrj-8728	347	4	collective	collective	ADJ
tahrj-8728	347	5	deportations	deportation	NOUN
tahrj-8728	347	6	against	against	ADP
tahrj-8728	347	7	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	347	8	arguments	argument	NOUN
tahrj-8728	347	9	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	347	10	national	national	ADJ
tahrj-8728	347	11	security	security	NOUN
tahrj-8728	347	12	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	347	13	legitimacy	legitimacy	NOUN
tahrj-8728	347	14	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	347	15	power	power	NOUN
tahrj-8728	347	16	leads	lead	VERB
tahrj-8728	347	17	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	347	18	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	347	19	violations	violation	NOUN
tahrj-8728	347	20	explicitly	explicitly	ADV
tahrj-8728	347	21	recognized	recognize	VERB
tahrj-8728	347	22	by	by	ADP
tahrj-8728	347	23	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	347	24	apex	apex	PROPN
tahrj-8728	347	25	court	court	PROPN
tahrj-8728	347	26	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	347	27	previous	previous	ADJ
tahrj-8728	347	28	instances	instance	NOUN
tahrj-8728	347	29	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	348	1	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	348	2	contrast	contrast	NOUN
tahrj-8728	348	3	stands	stand	VERB
tahrj-8728	348	4	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	348	5	case	case	NOUN
tahrj-8728	348	6	nandita	nandita	PROPN
tahrj-8728	348	7	haksar	haksar	PROPN
tahrj-8728	348	8	v.	v.	ADP
tahrj-8728	348	9	state	state	PROPN
tahrj-8728	348	10	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	348	11	manipur	manipur	PROPN
tahrj-8728	348	12	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	348	13	2021	2021	NUM
tahrj-8728	348	14	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	348	15	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	348	16	decided	decide	VERB
tahrj-8728	348	17	by	by	ADP
tahrj-8728	348	18	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	348	19	manipur	manipur	PROPN
tahrj-8728	348	20	high	high	ADJ
tahrj-8728	348	21	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	348	22	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	349	1	although	although	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	349	2	it	it	PRON
tahrj-8728	349	3	is	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	349	4	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	349	5	high	high	ADJ
tahrj-8728	349	6	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	349	7	judgment	judgment	NOUN
tahrj-8728	349	8	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	349	9	this	this	DET
tahrj-8728	349	10	case	case	NOUN
tahrj-8728	349	11	emphasized	emphasize	VERB
tahrj-8728	349	12	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	349	13	application	application	NOUN
tahrj-8728	349	14	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	349	15	art	art	NOUN
tahrj-8728	349	16	21	21	NUM
tahrj-8728	349	17	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	349	18	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	349	19	constitution	constitution	NOUN
tahrj-8728	349	20	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	349	21	such	such	ADJ
tahrj-8728	349	22	matters	matter	NOUN
tahrj-8728	349	23	leading	lead	VERB
tahrj-8728	349	24	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	349	25	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	349	26	more	more	ADV
tahrj-8728	349	27	nuanced	nuanced	ADJ
tahrj-8728	349	28	interpretation	interpretation	NOUN
tahrj-8728	349	29	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	349	30	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	349	31	issue	issue	NOUN
tahrj-8728	349	32	at	at	ADP
tahrj-8728	349	33	hand	hand	NOUN
tahrj-8728	349	34	than	than	ADP
tahrj-8728	349	35	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	349	36	sc	sc	PROPN
tahrj-8728	349	37	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	349	38	mohammad	mohammad	PROPN
tahrj-8728	349	39	salimullah	salimullah	PROPN
tahrj-8728	349	40	v	v	PROPN
tahrj-8728	349	41	union	union	NOUN
tahrj-8728	349	42	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	349	43	india	india	PROPN
tahrj-8728	349	44	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	349	45	2021	2021	NUM
tahrj-8728	349	46	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	349	47	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	350	1	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	350	2	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	350	3	highlighted	highlight	VERB
tahrj-8728	350	4	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	350	5	importance	importance	NOUN
tahrj-8728	350	6	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	350	7	providing	provide	VERB
tahrj-8728	350	8	relief	relief	NOUN
tahrj-8728	350	9	from	from	ADP
tahrj-8728	350	10	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	350	11	threat	threat	NOUN
tahrj-8728	350	12	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	350	13	life	life	NOUN
tahrj-8728	350	14	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	350	15	liberty	liberty	NOUN
tahrj-8728	350	16	rather	rather	ADV
tahrj-8728	350	17	than	than	ADP
tahrj-8728	350	18	prioritizing	prioritize	VERB
tahrj-8728	350	19	violations	violation	NOUN
tahrj-8728	350	20	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	350	21	domestic	domestic	ADJ
tahrj-8728	350	22	laws	law	NOUN
tahrj-8728	350	23	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	351	1	it	it	PRON
tahrj-8728	351	2	carefully	carefully	ADV
tahrj-8728	351	3	situated	situate	VERB
tahrj-8728	351	4	nonrefoulement	nonrefoulement	NOUN
tahrj-8728	351	5	within	within	ADP
tahrj-8728	351	6	art	art	NOUN
tahrj-8728	351	7	21	21	NUM
tahrj-8728	351	8	taking	take	VERB
tahrj-8728	351	9	from	from	ADP
tahrj-8728	351	10	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	351	11	earlier	early	ADJ
tahrj-8728	351	12	jurisprudence	jurisprudence	NOUN
tahrj-8728	351	13	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	351	14	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	351	15	supreme	supreme	PROPN
tahrj-8728	351	16	court	court	PROPN
tahrj-8728	351	17	supporting	support	VERB
tahrj-8728	351	18	such	such	DET
tahrj-8728	351	19	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	351	20	view	view	NOUN
tahrj-8728	351	21	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	352	1	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	352	2	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	352	3	context	context	NOUN
tahrj-8728	352	4	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	352	5	national	national	ADJ
tahrj-8728	352	6	security	security	NOUN
tahrj-8728	352	7	concerns	concern	NOUN
tahrj-8728	352	8	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	352	9	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	352	10	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	352	11	said	say	VERB
tahrj-8728	352	12	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	352	13	since	since	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	352	14	there	there	PRON
tahrj-8728	352	15	is	be	VERB
tahrj-8728	352	16	no	no	DET
tahrj-8728	352	17	evidence	evidence	NOUN
tahrj-8728	352	18	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	352	19	prove	prove	VERB
tahrj-8728	352	20	such	such	DET
tahrj-8728	352	21	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	352	22	contention	contention	NOUN
tahrj-8728	352	23	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	352	24	it	it	PRON
tahrj-8728	352	25	can	can	AUX
tahrj-8728	352	26	not	not	PART
tahrj-8728	352	27	be	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	352	28	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	352	29	basis	basis	NOUN
tahrj-8728	352	30	for	for	ADP
tahrj-8728	352	31	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	352	32	deportation	deportation	NOUN
tahrj-8728	352	33	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	352	34	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	352	35	refugees	refugee	NOUN
tahrj-8728	352	36	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	352	37	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	352	38	place	place	NOUN
tahrj-8728	352	39	where	where	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	352	40	their	their	PRON
tahrj-8728	352	41	lives	life	NOUN
tahrj-8728	352	42	are	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	352	43	threatened	threaten	VERB
tahrj-8728	352	44	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	353	1	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	353	2	lens	lens	NOUN
tahrj-8728	353	3	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	353	4	review	review	NOUN
tahrj-8728	353	5	jurisprudence	jurisprudence	NOUN
tahrj-8728	353	6	discussed	discuss	VERB
tahrj-8728	353	7	before	before	ADV
tahrj-8728	353	8	suggests	suggest	VERB
tahrj-8728	353	9	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	353	10	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	353	11	sc	sc	PROPN
tahrj-8728	353	12	has	have	AUX
tahrj-8728	353	13	applied	apply	VERB
tahrj-8728	353	14	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	353	15	wednesbury	wednesbury	NOUN
tahrj-8728	353	16	-	-	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	353	17	like	like	ADJ
tahrj-8728	353	18	principle	principle	NOUN
tahrj-8728	353	19	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	353	20	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	353	21	mohammad	mohammad	PROPN
tahrj-8728	353	22	salimullah	salimullah	PROPN
tahrj-8728	353	23	case	case	NOUN
tahrj-8728	353	24	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	353	25	2021	2021	NUM
tahrj-8728	353	26	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	353	27	whereas	whereas	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	353	28	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	353	29	high	high	ADJ
tahrj-8728	353	30	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	353	31	has	have	AUX
tahrj-8728	353	32	scrutinised	scrutinise	VERB
tahrj-8728	353	33	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	353	34	deportation	deportation	NOUN
tahrj-8728	353	35	based	base	VERB
tahrj-8728	353	36	on	on	ADP
tahrj-8728	353	37	something	something	PRON
tahrj-8728	353	38	that	that	PRON
tahrj-8728	353	39	inclines	incline	VERB
tahrj-8728	353	40	more	more	ADJ
tahrj-8728	353	41	towards	towards	ADP
tahrj-8728	353	42	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	353	43	balancing	balancing	NOUN
tahrj-8728	353	44	mechanism	mechanism	NOUN
tahrj-8728	353	45	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	353	46	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	353	47	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	353	48	analysis	analysis	NOUN
tahrj-8728	353	49	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	353	50	nandita	nandita	PROPN
tahrj-8728	353	51	haskar	haskar	PROPN
tahrj-8728	353	52	case	case	NOUN
tahrj-8728	353	53	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	353	54	2021	2021	NUM
tahrj-8728	353	55	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	353	56	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	354	1	even	even	ADV
tahrj-8728	354	2	if	if	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	354	3	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	354	4	hc	hc	NOUN
tahrj-8728	354	5	did	do	AUX
tahrj-8728	354	6	not	not	PART
tahrj-8728	354	7	consider	consider	VERB
tahrj-8728	354	8	necessity	necessity	NOUN
tahrj-8728	354	9	tests	test	NOUN
tahrj-8728	354	10	or	or	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	354	11	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	354	12	least	least	ADV
tahrj-8728	354	13	intrusive	intrusive	ADJ
tahrj-8728	354	14	means	mean	NOUN
tahrj-8728	354	15	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	354	16	it	it	PRON
tahrj-8728	354	17	moved	move	VERB
tahrj-8728	354	18	towards	towards	ADP
tahrj-8728	354	19	balancing	balance	VERB
tahrj-8728	354	20	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	354	21	measure	measure	NOUN
tahrj-8728	354	22	against	against	ADP
tahrj-8728	354	23	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	354	24	fundamental	fundamental	ADJ
tahrj-8728	354	25	right	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	354	26	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	354	27	life	life	NOUN
tahrj-8728	354	28	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	355	1	although	although	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	355	2	this	this	PRON
tahrj-8728	355	3	does	do	AUX
tahrj-8728	355	4	not	not	PART
tahrj-8728	355	5	set	set	VERB
tahrj-8728	355	6	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	355	7	precedent	precedent	NOUN
tahrj-8728	355	8	for	for	ADP
tahrj-8728	355	9	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	355	10	application	application	NOUN
tahrj-8728	355	11	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	355	12	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	355	13	analysis	analysis	NOUN
tahrj-8728	355	14	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	355	15	non	non	ADJ
tahrj-8728	355	16	-	-	ADJ
tahrj-8728	355	17	refoulement	refoulement	ADJ
tahrj-8728	355	18	cases	case	NOUN
tahrj-8728	355	19	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	355	20	still	still	ADV
tahrj-8728	355	21	it	it	PRON
tahrj-8728	355	22	showcases	showcase	VERB
tahrj-8728	355	23	familiarity	familiarity	NOUN
tahrj-8728	355	24	with	with	ADP
tahrj-8728	355	25	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	355	26	analysis	analysis	NOUN
tahrj-8728	355	27	jurisprudence	jurisprudence	NOUN
tahrj-8728	355	28	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	355	29	attempts	attempt	VERB
tahrj-8728	355	30	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	355	31	move	move	VERB
tahrj-8728	355	32	towards	towards	ADP
tahrj-8728	355	33	something	something	PRON
tahrj-8728	355	34	like	like	ADP
tahrj-8728	355	35	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	355	36	which	which	PRON
tahrj-8728	355	37	is	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	355	38	not	not	PART
tahrj-8728	355	39	entirely	entirely	ADV
tahrj-8728	355	40	wednesbury	wednesbury	NOUN
tahrj-8728	355	41	-	-	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	355	42	like	like	ADJ
tahrj-8728	355	43	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	356	1	hence	hence	ADV
tahrj-8728	356	2	lays	lay	VERB
tahrj-8728	356	3	down	down	ADP
tahrj-8728	356	4	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	356	5	pathway	pathway	NOUN
tahrj-8728	356	6	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	356	7	adopt	adopt	VERB
tahrj-8728	356	8	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	356	9	better	well	ADJ
tahrj-8728	356	10	approach	approach	NOUN
tahrj-8728	356	11	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	356	12	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	356	13	question	question	NOUN
tahrj-8728	356	14	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	356	15	non	non	ADJ
tahrj-8728	356	16	-	-	ADJ
tahrj-8728	356	17	refoulement	refoulement	ADJ
tahrj-8728	356	18	which	which	PRON
tahrj-8728	356	19	stems	stem	VERB
tahrj-8728	356	20	from	from	ADP
tahrj-8728	356	21	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	356	22	constitution	constitution	NOUN
tahrj-8728	356	23	itself	itself	PRON
tahrj-8728	356	24	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	356	25	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	356	26	not	not	PART
tahrj-8728	356	27	from	from	ADP
tahrj-8728	356	28	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	356	29	refugee	refugee	NOUN
tahrj-8728	356	30	convention	convention	NOUN
tahrj-8728	356	31	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	357	1	https://doi.org/10.17561/tahrj.v23.8728	https://doi.org/10.17561/tahrj.v23.8728	PROPN
tahrj-8728	357	2	sabreen	sabreen	PROPN
tahrj-8728	357	3	ahmed	ahme	VERB
tahrj-8728	357	4	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	357	5	age	age	NOUN
tahrj-8728	357	6	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	357	7	human	human	ADJ
tahrj-8728	357	8	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	357	9	journal	journal	NOUN
tahrj-8728	357	10	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	357	11	24	24	NUM
tahrj-8728	357	12	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	357	13	june	june	PROPN
tahrj-8728	357	14	2025	2025	NUM
tahrj-8728	357	15	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	357	16	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	357	17	e8728	e8728	PROPN
tahrj-8728	357	18	issn	issn	PROPN
tahrj-8728	357	19	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	357	20	2340	2340	NUM
tahrj-8728	357	21	-	-	SYM
tahrj-8728	357	22	9592	9592	NUM
tahrj-8728	357	23	doi	doi	NOUN
tahrj-8728	357	24	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	357	25	10.17561	10.17561	NUM
tahrj-8728	357	26	/	/	SYM
tahrj-8728	357	27	tahrj.v23.8728	tahrj.v23.8728	PROPN
tahrj-8728	357	28	19	19	NUM
tahrj-8728	357	29	3.2	3.2	NUM
tahrj-8728	357	30	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	358	1	‘	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	358	2	rainbow	rainbow	NOUN
tahrj-8728	358	3	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	358	4	review	review	NOUN
tahrj-8728	358	5	’	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	358	6	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	358	7	non	non	ADJ
tahrj-8728	358	8	-	-	ADJ
tahrj-8728	358	9	refoulement	refoulement	ADJ
tahrj-8728	358	10	cases	case	NOUN
tahrj-8728	358	11	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	358	12	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	358	13	way	way	NOUN
tahrj-8728	358	14	forward	forward	ADV
tahrj-8728	358	15	for	for	ADP
tahrj-8728	358	16	india	india	PROPN
tahrj-8728	358	17	?	?	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	359	1	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	359	2	such	such	DET
tahrj-8728	359	3	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	359	4	context	context	NOUN
tahrj-8728	359	5	where	where	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	359	6	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	359	7	existing	exist	VERB
tahrj-8728	359	8	jurisprudence	jurisprudence	NOUN
tahrj-8728	359	9	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	359	10	india	india	PROPN
tahrj-8728	359	11	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	359	12	neither	neither	PRON
tahrj-8728	359	13	supports	support	VERB
tahrj-8728	359	14	complete	complete	ADJ
tahrj-8728	359	15	abandonment	abandonment	NOUN
tahrj-8728	359	16	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	359	17	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	359	18	wednesbury	wednesbury	NOUN
tahrj-8728	359	19	-	-	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	359	20	like	like	ADJ
tahrj-8728	359	21	approach	approach	NOUN
tahrj-8728	359	22	nor	nor	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	359	23	application	application	NOUN
tahrj-8728	359	24	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	359	25	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	359	26	analysis	analysis	NOUN
tahrj-8728	359	27	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	359	28	its	its	PRON
tahrj-8728	359	29	true	true	ADJ
tahrj-8728	359	30	form	form	NOUN
tahrj-8728	359	31	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	359	32	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	359	33	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	359	34	needs	need	VERB
tahrj-8728	359	35	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	359	36	aspire	aspire	VERB
tahrj-8728	359	37	for	for	ADP
tahrj-8728	359	38	something	something	PRON
tahrj-8728	359	39	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	359	40	between	between	ADP
tahrj-8728	359	41	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	360	1	this	this	PRON
tahrj-8728	360	2	finds	find	VERB
tahrj-8728	360	3	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	360	4	place	place	NOUN
tahrj-8728	360	5	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	360	6	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	360	7	concept	concept	NOUN
tahrj-8728	360	8	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	360	9	‘	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	360	10	rainbow	rainbow	NOUN
tahrj-8728	360	11	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	360	12	review	review	NOUN
tahrj-8728	360	13	’	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	360	14	by	by	ADP
tahrj-8728	360	15	michael	michael	PROPN
tahrj-8728	360	16	taggart	taggart	PROPN
tahrj-8728	360	17	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	360	18	knight	knight	NOUN
tahrj-8728	360	19	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	360	20	2010	2010	NUM
tahrj-8728	360	21	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	360	22	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	361	1	taggart	taggart	PROPN
tahrj-8728	361	2	argues	argue	VERB
tahrj-8728	361	3	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	361	4	under	under	ADP
tahrj-8728	361	5	this	this	DET
tahrj-8728	361	6	approach	approach	NOUN
tahrj-8728	361	7	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	361	8	context	context	NOUN
tahrj-8728	361	9	-	-	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	361	10	specific	specific	ADJ
tahrj-8728	361	11	variable	variable	ADJ
tahrj-8728	361	12	-	-	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	361	13	intensity	intensity	NOUN
tahrj-8728	361	14	wednesbury	wednesbury	PROPN
tahrj-8728	361	15	test	test	NOUN
tahrj-8728	361	16	is	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	361	17	gradually	gradually	ADV
tahrj-8728	361	18	replaced	replace	VERB
tahrj-8728	361	19	by	by	ADP
tahrj-8728	361	20	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	361	21	context	context	NOUN
tahrj-8728	361	22	-	-	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	361	23	specific	specific	ADJ
tahrj-8728	361	24	variable	variable	ADJ
tahrj-8728	361	25	-	-	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	361	26	intensity	intensity	NOUN
tahrj-8728	361	27	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	361	28	test	test	NOUN
tahrj-8728	361	29	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	362	1	this	this	PRON
tahrj-8728	362	2	means	mean	VERB
tahrj-8728	362	3	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	362	4	wednesbury	wednesbury	NOUN
tahrj-8728	362	5	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	362	6	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	362	7	can	can	AUX
tahrj-8728	362	8	be	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	362	9	placed	place	VERB
tahrj-8728	362	10	on	on	ADP
tahrj-8728	362	11	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	362	12	scale	scale	NOUN
tahrj-8728	362	13	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	362	14	judges	judge	NOUN
tahrj-8728	362	15	can	can	AUX
tahrj-8728	362	16	move	move	VERB
tahrj-8728	362	17	from	from	ADP
tahrj-8728	362	18	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	362	19	end	end	NOUN
tahrj-8728	362	20	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	362	21	wednesbury	wednesbury	NOUN
tahrj-8728	362	22	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	362	23	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	362	24	other	other	ADJ
tahrj-8728	362	25	end	end	NOUN
tahrj-8728	362	26	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	362	27	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	362	28	analysis	analysis	NOUN
tahrj-8728	362	29	depending	depend	VERB
tahrj-8728	362	30	upon	upon	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	362	31	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	362	32	question	question	NOUN
tahrj-8728	362	33	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	362	34	fundamental	fundamental	ADJ
tahrj-8728	362	35	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	362	36	at	at	ADP
tahrj-8728	362	37	hand	hand	NOUN
tahrj-8728	362	38	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	363	1	according	accord	VERB
tahrj-8728	363	2	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	363	3	taggart	taggart	NOUN
tahrj-8728	363	4	at	at	ADP
tahrj-8728	363	5	points	point	NOUN
tahrj-8728	363	6	where	where	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	363	7	subwednesbury	subwednesbury	NOUN
tahrj-8728	363	8	ends	end	VERB
tahrj-8728	363	9	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	363	10	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	363	11	review	review	NOUN
tahrj-8728	363	12	begins	begin	VERB
tahrj-8728	363	13	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	363	14	knight	knight	NOUN
tahrj-8728	363	15	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	363	16	2010	2010	NUM
tahrj-8728	363	17	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	363	18	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	364	1	scholars	scholar	NOUN
tahrj-8728	364	2	who	who	PRON
tahrj-8728	364	3	subscribe	subscribe	VERB
tahrj-8728	364	4	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	364	5	monolithic	monolithic	ADJ
tahrj-8728	364	6	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	364	7	review	review	NOUN
tahrj-8728	364	8	are	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	364	9	disappointed	disappoint	VERB
tahrj-8728	364	10	by	by	ADP
tahrj-8728	364	11	taggart	taggart	NOUN
tahrj-8728	364	12	’s	’s	PART
tahrj-8728	364	13	qualified	qualified	ADJ
tahrj-8728	364	14	acceptance	acceptance	NOUN
tahrj-8728	364	15	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	364	16	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	364	17	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	364	18	his	his	PRON
tahrj-8728	364	19	rainbow	rainbow	NOUN
tahrj-8728	364	20	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	364	21	review	review	NOUN
tahrj-8728	364	22	approach	approach	NOUN
tahrj-8728	364	23	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	365	1	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	365	2	craig	craig	PROPN
tahrj-8728	365	3	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	365	4	2010	2010	NUM
tahrj-8728	365	5	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	365	6	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	366	1	others	other	NOUN
tahrj-8728	366	2	like	like	ADP
tahrj-8728	366	3	dean	dean	PROPN
tahrj-8728	366	4	knight	knight	PROPN
tahrj-8728	366	5	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	366	6	2010	2010	NUM
tahrj-8728	366	7	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	366	8	are	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	366	9	skeptical	skeptical	ADJ
tahrj-8728	366	10	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	366	11	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	366	12	along	along	ADP
tahrj-8728	366	13	with	with	ADP
tahrj-8728	366	14	philip	philip	PROPN
tahrj-8728	366	15	sales	sale	NOUN
tahrj-8728	366	16	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	366	17	2004	2004	NUM
tahrj-8728	366	18	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	366	19	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	366	20	mark	mark	PROPN
tahrj-8728	366	21	elliott	elliott	PROPN
tahrj-8728	366	22	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	366	23	2001	2001	NUM
tahrj-8728	366	24	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	366	25	who	who	PRON
tahrj-8728	366	26	advance	advance	VERB
tahrj-8728	366	27	similar	similar	ADJ
tahrj-8728	366	28	arguments	argument	NOUN
tahrj-8728	366	29	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	366	30	albeit	albeit	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	366	31	differently	differently	ADV
tahrj-8728	366	32	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	367	1	for	for	ADP
tahrj-8728	367	2	david	david	PROPN
tahrj-8728	367	3	mullan	mullan	PROPN
tahrj-8728	367	4	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	367	5	2010	2010	NUM
tahrj-8728	367	6	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	367	7	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	367	8	should	should	AUX
tahrj-8728	367	9	inform	inform	VERB
tahrj-8728	367	10	rationality	rationality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	367	11	review	review	NOUN
tahrj-8728	367	12	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	368	1	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	368	2	frontrunning	frontrunne	VERB
tahrj-8728	368	3	opponents	opponent	NOUN
tahrj-8728	368	4	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	368	5	rainbow	rainbow	NOUN
tahrj-8728	368	6	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	368	7	review	review	NOUN
tahrj-8728	368	8	like	like	ADP
tahrj-8728	368	9	professor	professor	PROPN
tahrj-8728	368	10	craig	craig	PROPN
tahrj-8728	368	11	along	along	ADP
tahrj-8728	368	12	with	with	ADP
tahrj-8728	368	13	murray	murray	PROPN
tahrj-8728	368	14	hunt	hunt	PROPN
tahrj-8728	368	15	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	368	16	philip	philip	PROPN
tahrj-8728	368	17	joseph	joseph	PROPN
tahrj-8728	368	18	are	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	368	19	against	against	ADP
tahrj-8728	368	20	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	368	21	hypothesis	hypothesis	NOUN
tahrj-8728	368	22	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	368	23	“	"	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	368	24	bifurcation	bifurcation	NOUN
tahrj-8728	368	25	”	"	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	368	26	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	368	27	hunt	hunt	NOUN
tahrj-8728	368	28	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	368	29	2009	2009	NUM
tahrj-8728	368	30	;	;	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	368	31	joseph	joseph	PROPN
tahrj-8728	368	32	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	368	33	2007	2007	NUM
tahrj-8728	368	34	;	;	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	368	35	craig	craig	PROPN
tahrj-8728	368	36	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	368	37	2010	2010	NUM
tahrj-8728	368	38	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	368	39	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	369	1	hunt	hunt	NOUN
tahrj-8728	369	2	specifically	specifically	ADV
tahrj-8728	369	3	is	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	369	4	vexed	vex	VERB
tahrj-8728	369	5	by	by	ADP
tahrj-8728	369	6	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	369	7	‘	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	369	8	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	369	9	’	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	369	10	–	–	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	369	11	‘	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	369	12	public	public	ADJ
tahrj-8728	369	13	wrongs	wrong	NOUN
tahrj-8728	369	14	’	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	369	15	dichotomy	dichotomy	NOUN
tahrj-8728	369	16	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	369	17	hunt	hunt	NOUN
tahrj-8728	369	18	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	369	19	2009	2009	NUM
tahrj-8728	369	20	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	369	21	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	369	22	how	how	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	369	23	significant	significant	ADJ
tahrj-8728	369	24	it	it	PRON
tahrj-8728	369	25	gets	get	VERB
tahrj-8728	369	26	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	369	27	practical	practical	ADJ
tahrj-8728	369	28	cases	case	NOUN
tahrj-8728	369	29	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	370	1	taggart	taggart	NOUN
tahrj-8728	370	2	while	while	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	370	3	acknowledging	acknowledge	VERB
tahrj-8728	370	4	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	370	5	‘	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	370	6	this	this	DET
tahrj-8728	370	7	sort	sort	NOUN
tahrj-8728	370	8	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	370	9	line	line	NOUN
tahrj-8728	370	10	drawing	drawing	NOUN
tahrj-8728	370	11	has	have	AUX
tahrj-8728	370	12	gone	go	VERB
tahrj-8728	370	13	out	out	ADP
tahrj-8728	370	14	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	370	15	fashion	fashion	NOUN
tahrj-8728	370	16	’	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	370	17	noted	note	VERB
tahrj-8728	370	18	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	370	19	it	it	PRON
tahrj-8728	370	20	‘	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	370	21	can	can	AUX
tahrj-8728	370	22	appear	appear	VERB
tahrj-8728	370	23	formalistic	formalistic	ADJ
tahrj-8728	370	24	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	370	25	possibly	possibly	ADV
tahrj-8728	370	26	arbitrary	arbitrary	ADJ
tahrj-8728	370	27	’	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	370	28	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	371	1	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	371	2	taggart	taggart	NOUN
tahrj-8728	371	3	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	371	4	2008	2008	NUM
tahrj-8728	371	5	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	371	6	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	372	1	but	but	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	372	2	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	372	3	same	same	ADJ
tahrj-8728	372	4	demarcation	demarcation	NOUN
tahrj-8728	372	5	would	would	AUX
tahrj-8728	372	6	make	make	VERB
tahrj-8728	372	7	administrative	administrative	ADJ
tahrj-8728	372	8	law	law	NOUN
tahrj-8728	372	9	more	more	ADV
tahrj-8728	372	10	predictable	predictable	ADJ
tahrj-8728	372	11	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	372	12	would	would	AUX
tahrj-8728	372	13	encourage	encourage	VERB
tahrj-8728	372	14	‘	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	372	15	lawyers	lawyer	NOUN
tahrj-8728	372	16	[	[	X
tahrj-8728	372	17	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	372	18	]	]	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	372	19	argue	argue	VERB
tahrj-8728	372	20	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	372	21	judges	judge	NOUN
tahrj-8728	372	22	[	[	X
tahrj-8728	372	23	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	372	24	]	]	PART
tahrj-8728	372	25	articulate	articulate	VERB
tahrj-8728	372	26	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	372	27	clearly	clearly	ADV
tahrj-8728	372	28	reasoned	reason	VERB
tahrj-8728	372	29	position	position	NOUN
tahrj-8728	372	30	’	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	372	31	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	372	32	close	close	ADJ
tahrj-8728	372	33	cases	case	NOUN
tahrj-8728	372	34	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	372	35	taggart	taggart	NOUN
tahrj-8728	372	36	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	372	37	2008	2008	NUM
tahrj-8728	372	38	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	372	39	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	373	1	scholars	scholar	NOUN
tahrj-8728	373	2	who	who	PRON
tahrj-8728	373	3	offer	offer	VERB
tahrj-8728	373	4	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	373	5	variegated	variegate	VERB
tahrj-8728	373	6	unreasonableness	unreasonableness	NOUN
tahrj-8728	373	7	or	or	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	373	8	simplified	simplified	ADJ
tahrj-8728	373	9	formulations	formulation	NOUN
tahrj-8728	373	10	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	373	11	unreasonableness	unreasonableness	NOUN
tahrj-8728	373	12	also	also	ADV
tahrj-8728	373	13	seem	seem	VERB
tahrj-8728	373	14	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	373	15	be	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	373	16	disappointed	disappoint	VERB
tahrj-8728	373	17	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	373	18	knight	knight	NOUN
tahrj-8728	373	19	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	373	20	2008	2008	NUM
tahrj-8728	373	21	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	373	22	as	as	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	373	23	taggart	taggart	NOUN
tahrj-8728	373	24	proposes	propose	VERB
tahrj-8728	373	25	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	373	26	eradication	eradication	NOUN
tahrj-8728	373	27	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	373	28	such	such	ADJ
tahrj-8728	373	29	developments	development	NOUN
tahrj-8728	373	30	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	373	31	for	for	ADP
tahrj-8728	373	32	him	he	PRON
tahrj-8728	373	33	there	there	PRON
tahrj-8728	373	34	was	be	VERB
tahrj-8728	373	35	no	no	DET
tahrj-8728	373	36	room	room	NOUN
tahrj-8728	373	37	for	for	ADP
tahrj-8728	373	38	wednesbury	wednesbury	PROPN
tahrj-8728	373	39	’s	’s	PART
tahrj-8728	373	40	offspring	offspring	NOUN
tahrj-8728	373	41	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	373	42	variegated	variegate	VERB
tahrj-8728	373	43	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	373	44	intensified	intensify	VERB
tahrj-8728	373	45	or	or	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	373	46	‘	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	373	47	cookeian	cookeian	NOUN
tahrj-8728	373	48	’	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	373	49	unreasonableness	unreasonableness	NOUN
tahrj-8728	373	50	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	374	1	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	374	2	supremacy	supremacy	NOUN
tahrj-8728	374	3	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	374	4	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	374	5	traditional	traditional	ADJ
tahrj-8728	374	6	conception	conception	NOUN
tahrj-8728	374	7	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	374	8	wednesbury	wednesbury	PROPN
tahrj-8728	374	9	unreasonableness	unreasonableness	NOUN
tahrj-8728	374	10	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	374	11	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	374	12	‘	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	374	13	longstop	longstop	NOUN
tahrj-8728	374	14	’	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	374	15	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	374	16	‘	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	374	17	safety	safety	NOUN
tahrj-8728	374	18	net	net	NOUN
tahrj-8728	374	19	’	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	374	20	or	or	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	374	21	‘	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	374	22	residual	residual	ADJ
tahrj-8728	374	23	’	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	374	24	kind	kind	NOUN
tahrj-8728	374	25	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	374	26	should	should	AUX
tahrj-8728	374	27	be	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	374	28	restored	restore	VERB
tahrj-8728	374	29	on	on	ADP
tahrj-8728	374	30	this	this	DET
tahrj-8728	374	31	side	side	NOUN
tahrj-8728	374	32	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	374	33	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	374	34	rainbow	rainbow	NOUN
tahrj-8728	374	35	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	375	1	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	375	2	taggart	taggart	NOUN
tahrj-8728	375	3	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	375	4	2008	2008	NUM
tahrj-8728	375	5	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	375	6	limitations	limitation	NOUN
tahrj-8728	375	7	building	build	VERB
tahrj-8728	375	8	on	on	ADP
tahrj-8728	375	9	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	375	10	recent	recent	ADJ
tahrj-8728	375	11	approach	approach	NOUN
tahrj-8728	375	12	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	375	13	uk	uk	PROPN
tahrj-8728	375	14	courts	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	375	15	as	as	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	375	16	noted	note	VERB
tahrj-8728	375	17	earlier	early	ADV
tahrj-8728	375	18	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	375	19	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	375	20	paper	paper	NOUN
tahrj-8728	375	21	–	–	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	375	22	around	around	ADP
tahrj-8728	375	23	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	375	24	fact	fact	NOUN
tahrj-8728	375	25	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	375	26	both	both	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	375	27	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	375	28	tests	test	NOUN
tahrj-8728	375	29	are	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	375	30	intertwined	intertwine	VERB
tahrj-8728	375	31	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	375	32	hardly	hardly	ADV
tahrj-8728	375	33	distinguishable	distinguishable	ADJ
tahrj-8728	375	34	arguments	argument	NOUN
tahrj-8728	375	35	are	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	375	36	advanced	advanced	ADJ
tahrj-8728	375	37	against	against	ADP
tahrj-8728	375	38	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	375	39	scales	scale	NOUN
tahrj-8728	375	40	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	375	41	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	375	42	variability	variability	NOUN
tahrj-8728	375	43	approach	approach	NOUN
tahrj-8728	375	44	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	376	1	however	however	ADV
tahrj-8728	376	2	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	376	3	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	376	4	difference	difference	NOUN
tahrj-8728	376	5	between	between	ADP
tahrj-8728	376	6	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	376	7	two	two	NUM
tahrj-8728	376	8	approaches	approach	NOUN
tahrj-8728	376	9	placed	place	VERB
tahrj-8728	376	10	on	on	ADP
tahrj-8728	376	11	each	each	DET
tahrj-8728	376	12	side	side	NOUN
tahrj-8728	376	13	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	376	14	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	376	15	rainbow	rainbow	NOUN
tahrj-8728	376	16	is	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	376	17	not	not	PART
tahrj-8728	376	18	only	only	ADV
tahrj-8728	376	19	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	376	20	name	name	NOUN
tahrj-8728	376	21	but	but	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	376	22	also	also	ADV
tahrj-8728	376	23	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	376	24	kind	kind	NOUN
tahrj-8728	376	25	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	377	1	as	as	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	377	2	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	377	3	srirangam	srirangam	PROPN
tahrj-8728	377	4	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	377	5	2016	2016	NUM
tahrj-8728	377	6	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	377	7	points	point	VERB
tahrj-8728	377	8	out	out	ADP
tahrj-8728	377	9	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	377	10	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	377	11	key	key	ADJ
tahrj-8728	377	12	difference	difference	NOUN
tahrj-8728	377	13	lies	lie	VERB
tahrj-8728	377	14	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	377	15	how	how	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	377	16	each	each	DET
tahrj-8728	377	17	standard	standard	NOUN
tahrj-8728	377	18	approaches	approach	VERB
tahrj-8728	377	19	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	377	20	"	"	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	377	21	relative	relative	ADJ
tahrj-8728	377	22	weight	weight	NOUN
tahrj-8728	377	23	given	give	VERB
tahrj-8728	377	24	by	by	ADP
tahrj-8728	377	25	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	377	26	decision	decision	NOUN
tahrj-8728	377	27	-	-	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	377	28	maker	maker	NOUN
tahrj-8728	377	29	"	"	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	377	30	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	377	31	different	different	ADJ
tahrj-8728	377	32	factors	factor	NOUN
tahrj-8728	377	33	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	378	1	while	while	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	378	2	wednesbury	wednesbury	NOUN
tahrj-8728	378	3	focuses	focus	VERB
tahrj-8728	378	4	on	on	ADP
tahrj-8728	378	5	whether	whether	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	378	6	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	378	7	particular	particular	ADJ
tahrj-8728	378	8	consideration	consideration	NOUN
tahrj-8728	378	9	was	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	378	10	legitimate	legitimate	ADJ
tahrj-8728	378	11	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	378	12	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	378	13	mandates	mandate	NOUN
tahrj-8728	378	14	courts	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	378	15	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	378	16	assess	assess	VERB
tahrj-8728	378	17	if	if	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	378	18	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	378	19	weight	weight	NOUN
tahrj-8728	378	20	assigned	assign	VERB
tahrj-8728	378	21	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	378	22	each	each	DET
tahrj-8728	378	23	factor	factor	NOUN
tahrj-8728	378	24	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	378	25	even	even	ADV
tahrj-8728	378	26	if	if	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	378	27	legitimate	legitimate	ADJ
tahrj-8728	378	28	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	378	29	was	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	378	30	appropriate	appropriate	ADJ
tahrj-8728	378	31	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	378	32	reaching	reach	VERB
tahrj-8728	378	33	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	378	34	balanced	balanced	ADJ
tahrj-8728	378	35	decision	decision	NOUN
tahrj-8728	378	36	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	379	1	even	even	ADV
tahrj-8728	379	2	if	if	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	379	3	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	379	4	argument	argument	NOUN
tahrj-8728	379	5	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	379	6	varied	varied	ADJ
tahrj-8728	379	7	wednesbury	wednesbury	NOUN
tahrj-8728	379	8	is	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	379	9	placed	place	VERB
tahrj-8728	379	10	with	with	ADP
tahrj-8728	379	11	degrees	degree	NOUN
tahrj-8728	379	12	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	379	13	https://doi.org/10.17561/tahrj.v23.8728	https://doi.org/10.17561/tahrj.v23.8728	PROPN
tahrj-8728	379	14	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	379	15	analysis	analysis	NOUN
tahrj-8728	379	16	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	379	17	non	non	ADJ
tahrj-8728	379	18	-	-	ADJ
tahrj-8728	379	19	refoulement	refoulement	ADJ
tahrj-8728	379	20	jurisprudence	jurisprudence	NOUN
tahrj-8728	379	21	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	379	22	india	india	PROPN
tahrj-8728	379	23	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	379	24	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	379	25	comparative	comparative	ADJ
tahrj-8728	379	26	approach	approach	NOUN
tahrj-8728	379	27	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	379	28	age	age	NOUN
tahrj-8728	379	29	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	379	30	human	human	ADJ
tahrj-8728	379	31	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	379	32	journal	journal	NOUN
tahrj-8728	379	33	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	379	34	24	24	NUM
tahrj-8728	379	35	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	379	36	june	june	PROPN
tahrj-8728	379	37	2025	2025	NUM
tahrj-8728	379	38	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	379	39	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	379	40	e8728	e8728	PROPN
tahrj-8728	379	41	issn	issn	PROPN
tahrj-8728	379	42	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	379	43	2340	2340	NUM
tahrj-8728	379	44	-	-	SYM
tahrj-8728	379	45	9592	9592	NUM
tahrj-8728	379	46	doi	doi	NOUN
tahrj-8728	379	47	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	379	48	10.17561	10.17561	NUM
tahrj-8728	379	49	/	/	SYM
tahrj-8728	379	50	tahrj.v23.8728	tahrj.v23.8728	PROPN
tahrj-8728	379	51	20	20	NUM
tahrj-8728	379	52	unreasonableness	unreasonableness	NOUN
tahrj-8728	379	53	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	379	54	same	same	ADJ
tahrj-8728	379	55	can	can	AUX
tahrj-8728	379	56	not	not	PART
tahrj-8728	379	57	sufficiently	sufficiently	ADV
tahrj-8728	379	58	overcome	overcome	VERB
tahrj-8728	379	59	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	379	60	structure	structure	NOUN
tahrj-8728	379	61	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	379	62	sophistication	sophistication	NOUN
tahrj-8728	379	63	involved	involve	VERB
tahrj-8728	379	64	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	379	65	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	379	66	review	review	NOUN
tahrj-8728	379	67	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	379	68	an	an	DET
tahrj-8728	379	69	administrative	administrative	ADJ
tahrj-8728	379	70	decision	decision	NOUN
tahrj-8728	379	71	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	380	1	thus	thus	ADV
tahrj-8728	380	2	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	380	3	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	380	4	borderline	borderline	NOUN
tahrj-8728	380	5	cases	case	NOUN
tahrj-8728	380	6	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	380	7	it	it	PRON
tahrj-8728	380	8	becomes	become	VERB
tahrj-8728	380	9	necessary	necessary	ADJ
tahrj-8728	380	10	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	380	11	acknowledge	acknowledge	VERB
tahrj-8728	380	12	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	380	13	neither	neither	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	380	14	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	380	15	nor	nor	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	380	16	wednesbury	wednesbury	NOUN
tahrj-8728	380	17	review	review	NOUN
tahrj-8728	380	18	are	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	380	19	monolithic	monolithic	ADJ
tahrj-8728	380	20	standards	standard	NOUN
tahrj-8728	380	21	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	380	22	review	review	NOUN
tahrj-8728	380	23	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	380	24	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	380	25	both	both	PRON
tahrj-8728	380	26	exist	exist	VERB
tahrj-8728	380	27	with	with	ADP
tahrj-8728	380	28	variable	variable	ADJ
tahrj-8728	380	29	intensity	intensity	NOUN
tahrj-8728	380	30	depending	depend	VERB
tahrj-8728	380	31	on	on	ADP
tahrj-8728	380	32	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	380	33	context	context	NOUN
tahrj-8728	380	34	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	380	35	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	380	36	given	give	VERB
tahrj-8728	380	37	case	case	NOUN
tahrj-8728	380	38	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	381	1	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	381	2	non	non	ADJ
tahrj-8728	381	3	-	-	ADJ
tahrj-8728	381	4	refoulement	refoulement	ADJ
tahrj-8728	381	5	cases	case	NOUN
tahrj-8728	381	6	particularly	particularly	ADV
tahrj-8728	381	7	such	such	ADJ
tahrj-8728	381	8	intensity	intensity	NOUN
tahrj-8728	381	9	needs	need	VERB
tahrj-8728	381	10	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	381	11	be	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	381	12	determined	determine	VERB
tahrj-8728	381	13	on	on	ADP
tahrj-8728	381	14	grounds	ground	NOUN
tahrj-8728	381	15	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	381	16	evidence	evidence	NOUN
tahrj-8728	381	17	suggesting	suggest	VERB
tahrj-8728	381	18	national	national	ADJ
tahrj-8728	381	19	security	security	NOUN
tahrj-8728	381	20	concerns	concern	NOUN
tahrj-8728	381	21	posed	pose	VERB
tahrj-8728	381	22	by	by	ADP
tahrj-8728	381	23	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	381	24	refugee	refugee	NOUN
tahrj-8728	381	25	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	381	26	evidence	evidence	NOUN
tahrj-8728	381	27	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	381	28	threat	threat	NOUN
tahrj-8728	381	29	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	381	30	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	381	31	life	life	NOUN
tahrj-8728	381	32	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	381	33	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	381	34	refugee	refugee	NOUN
tahrj-8728	381	35	at	at	ADP
tahrj-8728	381	36	hand	hand	NOUN
tahrj-8728	381	37	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	382	1	if	if	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	382	2	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	382	3	evidence	evidence	NOUN
tahrj-8728	382	4	suggests	suggest	VERB
tahrj-8728	382	5	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	382	6	real	real	ADJ
tahrj-8728	382	7	risk	risk	NOUN
tahrj-8728	382	8	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	382	9	national	national	ADJ
tahrj-8728	382	10	security	security	NOUN
tahrj-8728	382	11	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	382	12	then	then	ADV
tahrj-8728	382	13	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	382	14	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	382	15	can	can	AUX
tahrj-8728	382	16	apply	apply	VERB
tahrj-8728	382	17	some	some	DET
tahrj-8728	382	18	deference	deference	NOUN
tahrj-8728	382	19	under	under	ADP
tahrj-8728	382	20	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	382	21	wednesbury	wednesbury	PROPN
tahrj-8728	382	22	test	test	NOUN
tahrj-8728	382	23	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	382	24	making	make	VERB
tahrj-8728	382	25	it	it	PRON
tahrj-8728	382	26	some	some	DET
tahrj-8728	382	27	sort	sort	NOUN
tahrj-8728	382	28	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	382	29	subwednesbury	subwednesbury	NOUN
tahrj-8728	382	30	test	test	NOUN
tahrj-8728	382	31	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	383	1	such	such	DET
tahrj-8728	383	2	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	383	3	sub	sub	ADJ
tahrj-8728	383	4	-	-	ADJ
tahrj-8728	383	5	wednesbury	wednesbury	ADJ
tahrj-8728	383	6	test	test	NOUN
tahrj-8728	383	7	is	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	383	8	advocated	advocate	VERB
tahrj-8728	383	9	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	383	10	all	all	DET
tahrj-8728	383	11	human	human	ADJ
tahrj-8728	383	12	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	383	13	cases	case	NOUN
tahrj-8728	383	14	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	384	1	for	for	ADP
tahrj-8728	384	2	example	example	NOUN
tahrj-8728	384	3	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	384	4	sir	sir	PROPN
tahrj-8728	384	5	bingham	bingham	PROPN
tahrj-8728	384	6	mr	mr	PROPN
tahrj-8728	384	7	’s	’s	PART
tahrj-8728	384	8	speech	speech	NOUN
tahrj-8728	384	9	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	384	10	r	r	PROPN
tahrj-8728	384	11	v.	v.	ADP
tahrj-8728	384	12	ministry	ministry	PROPN
tahrj-8728	384	13	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	384	14	defence	defence	PROPN
tahrj-8728	384	15	ex	ex	PROPN
tahrj-8728	384	16	parte	parte	PROPN
tahrj-8728	384	17	smith	smith	PROPN
tahrj-8728	384	18	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	384	19	1996	1996	NUM
tahrj-8728	384	20	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	384	21	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	384	22	where	where	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	384	23	he	he	PRON
tahrj-8728	384	24	states	state	VERB
tahrj-8728	384	25	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	384	26	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	384	27	judging	judge	VERB
tahrj-8728	384	28	whether	whether	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	384	29	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	384	30	decision	decision	NOUN
tahrj-8728	384	31	-	-	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	384	32	maker	maker	NOUN
tahrj-8728	384	33	has	have	AUX
tahrj-8728	384	34	exceeded	exceed	VERB
tahrj-8728	384	35	this	this	DET
tahrj-8728	384	36	margin	margin	NOUN
tahrj-8728	384	37	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	384	38	appreciation	appreciation	NOUN
tahrj-8728	384	39	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	384	40	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	384	41	human	human	ADJ
tahrj-8728	384	42	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	384	43	context	context	NOUN
tahrj-8728	384	44	is	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	384	45	important	important	ADJ
tahrj-8728	384	46	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	385	1	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	385	2	more	more	ADV
tahrj-8728	385	3	substantial	substantial	ADJ
tahrj-8728	385	4	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	385	5	interference	interference	NOUN
tahrj-8728	385	6	with	with	ADP
tahrj-8728	385	7	human	human	ADJ
tahrj-8728	385	8	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	385	9	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	385	10	the	the	PRON
tahrj-8728	385	11	more	more	ADV
tahrj-8728	385	12	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	385	13	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	385	14	will	will	AUX
tahrj-8728	385	15	require	require	VERB
tahrj-8728	385	16	by	by	ADP
tahrj-8728	385	17	way	way	NOUN
tahrj-8728	385	18	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	385	19	justification	justification	NOUN
tahrj-8728	385	20	before	before	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	385	21	it	it	PRON
tahrj-8728	385	22	is	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	385	23	satisfied	satisfied	ADJ
tahrj-8728	385	24	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	385	25	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	385	26	decision	decision	NOUN
tahrj-8728	385	27	is	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	385	28	reasonable	reasonable	ADJ
tahrj-8728	385	29	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	386	1	this	this	PRON
tahrj-8728	386	2	means	mean	VERB
tahrj-8728	386	3	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	386	4	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	386	5	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	386	6	absence	absence	NOUN
tahrj-8728	386	7	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	386	8	any	any	DET
tahrj-8728	386	9	real	real	ADJ
tahrj-8728	386	10	evidence	evidence	NOUN
tahrj-8728	386	11	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	386	12	national	national	ADJ
tahrj-8728	386	13	security	security	NOUN
tahrj-8728	386	14	concern	concern	NOUN
tahrj-8728	386	15	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	386	16	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	386	17	analysis	analysis	NOUN
tahrj-8728	386	18	must	must	AUX
tahrj-8728	386	19	be	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	386	20	applied	apply	VERB
tahrj-8728	386	21	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	387	1	from	from	ADP
tahrj-8728	387	2	here	here	ADV
tahrj-8728	387	3	on	on	ADP
tahrj-8728	387	4	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	387	5	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	387	6	review	review	NOUN
tahrj-8728	387	7	gets	get	VERB
tahrj-8728	387	8	increasingly	increasingly	ADV
tahrj-8728	387	9	intrusive	intrusive	ADJ
tahrj-8728	387	10	as	as	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	387	11	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	387	12	context	context	NOUN
tahrj-8728	387	13	changes	change	VERB
tahrj-8728	387	14	from	from	ADP
tahrj-8728	387	15	human	human	ADJ
tahrj-8728	387	16	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	387	17	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	387	18	more	more	ADV
tahrj-8728	387	19	fundamental	fundamental	ADJ
tahrj-8728	387	20	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	387	21	absolute	absolute	ADJ
tahrj-8728	387	22	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	387	23	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	388	1	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	388	2	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	388	3	context	context	NOUN
tahrj-8728	388	4	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	388	5	non	non	ADJ
tahrj-8728	388	6	-	-	ADJ
tahrj-8728	388	7	refoulement	refoulement	ADJ
tahrj-8728	388	8	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	388	9	it	it	PRON
tahrj-8728	388	10	means	mean	VERB
tahrj-8728	388	11	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	388	12	when	when	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	388	13	there	there	PRON
tahrj-8728	388	14	is	be	VERB
tahrj-8728	388	15	no	no	DET
tahrj-8728	388	16	real	real	ADJ
tahrj-8728	388	17	evidence	evidence	NOUN
tahrj-8728	388	18	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	388	19	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	388	20	national	national	ADJ
tahrj-8728	388	21	security	security	NOUN
tahrj-8728	388	22	threat	threat	NOUN
tahrj-8728	388	23	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	388	24	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	388	25	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	388	26	analysis	analysis	NOUN
tahrj-8728	388	27	has	have	VERB
tahrj-8728	388	28	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	388	29	be	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	388	30	applied	apply	VERB
tahrj-8728	388	31	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	388	32	its	its	PRON
tahrj-8728	388	33	true	true	ADJ
tahrj-8728	388	34	form	form	NOUN
tahrj-8728	388	35	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	388	36	most	most	ADV
tahrj-8728	388	37	intrusively	intrusively	ADV
tahrj-8728	388	38	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	389	1	this	this	PRON
tahrj-8728	389	2	suggests	suggest	VERB
tahrj-8728	389	3	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	389	4	even	even	ADV
tahrj-8728	389	5	wednesbury	wednesbury	PROPN
tahrj-8728	389	6	has	have	VERB
tahrj-8728	389	7	some	some	DET
tahrj-8728	389	8	balancing	balance	VERB
tahrj-8728	389	9	test	test	NOUN
tahrj-8728	389	10	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	389	11	however	however	ADV
tahrj-8728	389	12	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	389	13	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	389	14	applies	apply	VERB
tahrj-8728	389	15	institutional	institutional	ADJ
tahrj-8728	389	16	deference	deference	NOUN
tahrj-8728	389	17	as	as	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	389	18	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	389	19	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	389	20	lacks	lack	VERB
tahrj-8728	389	21	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	389	22	specialized	specialized	ADJ
tahrj-8728	389	23	knowledge	knowledge	NOUN
tahrj-8728	389	24	often	often	ADV
tahrj-8728	389	25	possessed	possess	VERB
tahrj-8728	389	26	by	by	ADP
tahrj-8728	389	27	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	389	28	decision	decision	NOUN
tahrj-8728	389	29	makers	maker	NOUN
tahrj-8728	389	30	themselves	themselves	PRON
tahrj-8728	389	31	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	390	1	however	however	ADV
tahrj-8728	390	2	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	390	3	when	when	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	390	4	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	390	5	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	390	6	is	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	390	7	approached	approach	VERB
tahrj-8728	390	8	with	with	ADP
tahrj-8728	390	9	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	390	10	fundamental	fundamental	ADJ
tahrj-8728	390	11	question	question	NOUN
tahrj-8728	390	12	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	390	13	then	then	ADV
tahrj-8728	390	14	it	it	PRON
tahrj-8728	390	15	takes	take	VERB
tahrj-8728	390	16	on	on	ADP
tahrj-8728	390	17	constitutional	constitutional	ADJ
tahrj-8728	390	18	deference	deference	NOUN
tahrj-8728	390	19	which	which	PRON
tahrj-8728	390	20	increases	increase	VERB
tahrj-8728	390	21	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	390	22	scrutiny	scrutiny	NOUN
tahrj-8728	390	23	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	390	24	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	390	25	decision	decision	NOUN
tahrj-8728	390	26	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	390	27	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	390	28	decision	decision	NOUN
tahrj-8728	390	29	maker	maker	NOUN
tahrj-8728	390	30	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	391	1	now	now	ADV
tahrj-8728	391	2	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	391	3	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	391	4	’s	’s	PART
tahrj-8728	391	5	job	job	NOUN
tahrj-8728	391	6	will	will	AUX
tahrj-8728	391	7	turn	turn	VERB
tahrj-8728	391	8	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	391	9	determining	determine	VERB
tahrj-8728	391	10	whether	whether	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	391	11	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	391	12	decision	decision	NOUN
tahrj-8728	391	13	taken	take	VERB
tahrj-8728	391	14	falls	fall	NOUN
tahrj-8728	391	15	within	within	ADP
tahrj-8728	391	16	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	391	17	range	range	NOUN
tahrj-8728	391	18	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	391	19	reasonable	reasonable	ADJ
tahrj-8728	391	20	decisions	decision	NOUN
tahrj-8728	391	21	open	open	ADJ
tahrj-8728	391	22	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	391	23	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	391	24	decision	decision	NOUN
tahrj-8728	391	25	maker	maker	NOUN
tahrj-8728	391	26	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	392	1	both	both	DET
tahrj-8728	392	2	these	these	DET
tahrj-8728	392	3	concepts	concept	NOUN
tahrj-8728	392	4	already	already	ADV
tahrj-8728	392	5	exist	exist	VERB
tahrj-8728	392	6	within	within	ADP
tahrj-8728	392	7	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	392	8	indian	indian	ADJ
tahrj-8728	392	9	jurisprudence	jurisprudence	NOUN
tahrj-8728	392	10	;	;	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	392	11	however	however	ADV
tahrj-8728	392	12	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	392	13	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	392	14	application	application	NOUN
tahrj-8728	392	15	is	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	392	16	wobbly	wobbly	ADJ
tahrj-8728	392	17	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	392	18	inconsistent	inconsistent	ADJ
tahrj-8728	392	19	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	392	20	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	392	21	unstructured	unstructure	VERB
tahrj-8728	392	22	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	393	1	therefore	therefore	ADV
tahrj-8728	393	2	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	393	3	applying	apply	VERB
tahrj-8728	393	4	these	these	DET
tahrj-8728	393	5	tests	test	NOUN
tahrj-8728	393	6	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	393	7	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	393	8	structured	structured	ADJ
tahrj-8728	393	9	way	way	NOUN
tahrj-8728	393	10	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	393	11	like	like	ADP
tahrj-8728	393	12	that	that	PRON
tahrj-8728	393	13	suggested	suggest	VERB
tahrj-8728	393	14	by	by	ADP
tahrj-8728	393	15	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	393	16	‘	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	393	17	rainbow	rainbow	NOUN
tahrj-8728	393	18	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	393	19	review	review	NOUN
tahrj-8728	393	20	’	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	393	21	approach	approach	NOUN
tahrj-8728	393	22	would	would	AUX
tahrj-8728	393	23	enable	enable	VERB
tahrj-8728	393	24	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	393	25	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	393	26	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	393	27	produce	produce	VERB
tahrj-8728	393	28	better	well	ADJ
tahrj-8728	393	29	outcomes	outcome	NOUN
tahrj-8728	393	30	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	393	31	human	human	ADJ
tahrj-8728	393	32	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	393	33	cases	case	NOUN
tahrj-8728	393	34	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	393	35	most	most	ADV
tahrj-8728	393	36	significantly	significantly	ADV
tahrj-8728	393	37	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	393	38	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	393	39	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	393	40	contexts	contexts	NOUN
tahrj-8728	393	41	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	393	42	‘	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	393	43	non	non	ADJ
tahrj-8728	393	44	-	-	ADJ
tahrj-8728	393	45	refoulement	refoulement	ADJ
tahrj-8728	393	46	’	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	393	47	cases	case	NOUN
tahrj-8728	393	48	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	394	1	like	like	ADP
tahrj-8728	394	2	how	how	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	394	3	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	394	4	new	new	PROPN
tahrj-8728	394	5	zealand	zealand	PROPN
tahrj-8728	394	6	taggart	taggart	PROPN
tahrj-8728	394	7	’s	’s	PART
tahrj-8728	394	8	approach	approach	NOUN
tahrj-8728	394	9	is	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	394	10	only	only	ADV
tahrj-8728	394	11	normatively	normatively	ADV
tahrj-8728	394	12	accepted	accept	VERB
tahrj-8728	394	13	through	through	ADP
tahrj-8728	394	14	explicit	explicit	ADJ
tahrj-8728	394	15	means	mean	NOUN
tahrj-8728	394	16	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	394	17	even	even	ADV
tahrj-8728	394	18	though	though	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	394	19	its	its	PRON
tahrj-8728	394	20	judiciary	judiciary	NOUN
tahrj-8728	394	21	leans	lean	VERB
tahrj-8728	394	22	on	on	ADP
tahrj-8728	394	23	contextualism	contextualism	NOUN
tahrj-8728	394	24	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	394	25	covert	covert	ADJ
tahrj-8728	394	26	variability	variability	NOUN
tahrj-8728	394	27	i.e.	i.e.	X
tahrj-8728	394	28	not	not	PART
tahrj-8728	394	29	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	394	30	one	one	NUM
tahrj-8728	394	31	-	-	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	394	32	size	size	NOUN
tahrj-8728	394	33	-	-	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	394	34	fits	fit	VERB
tahrj-8728	394	35	-	-	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	394	36	all	all	DET
tahrj-8728	394	37	approach	approach	NOUN
tahrj-8728	394	38	should	should	AUX
tahrj-8728	394	39	be	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	394	40	adopted	adopt	VERB
tahrj-8728	394	41	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	394	42	all	all	DET
tahrj-8728	394	43	cases	case	NOUN
tahrj-8728	394	44	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	394	45	knight	knight	NOUN
tahrj-8728	394	46	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	394	47	2010	2010	NUM
tahrj-8728	394	48	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	394	49	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	395	1	thus	thus	ADV
tahrj-8728	395	2	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	395	3	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	395	4	judicial	judicial	ADJ
tahrj-8728	395	5	approach	approach	NOUN
tahrj-8728	395	6	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	395	7	new	new	PROPN
tahrj-8728	395	8	zealand	zealand	PROPN
tahrj-8728	395	9	regards	regard	VERB
tahrj-8728	395	10	variability	variability	NOUN
tahrj-8728	395	11	is	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	395	12	not	not	PART
tahrj-8728	395	13	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	395	14	acknowledge	acknowledge	VERB
tahrj-8728	395	15	it	it	PRON
tahrj-8728	395	16	as	as	ADP
tahrj-8728	395	17	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	395	18	formal	formal	ADJ
tahrj-8728	395	19	or	or	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	395	20	doctrinal	doctrinal	ADJ
tahrj-8728	395	21	practice	practice	NOUN
tahrj-8728	395	22	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	396	1	similarly	similarly	ADV
tahrj-8728	396	2	indian	indian	ADJ
tahrj-8728	396	3	courts	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	396	4	often	often	ADV
tahrj-8728	396	5	go	go	VERB
tahrj-8728	396	6	beyond	beyond	ADP
tahrj-8728	396	7	traditional	traditional	ADJ
tahrj-8728	396	8	grounds	ground	NOUN
tahrj-8728	396	9	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	396	10	review	review	NOUN
tahrj-8728	396	11	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	396	12	enforce	enforce	VERB
tahrj-8728	396	13	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	396	14	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	396	15	direct	direct	ADJ
tahrj-8728	396	16	policies	policy	NOUN
tahrj-8728	396	17	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	396	18	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	396	19	intervene	intervene	VERB
tahrj-8728	396	20	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	396	21	governmental	governmental	ADJ
tahrj-8728	396	22	decisions	decision	NOUN
tahrj-8728	396	23	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	396	24	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	396	25	way	way	NOUN
tahrj-8728	396	26	that	that	PRON
tahrj-8728	396	27	is	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	396	28	less	less	ADV
tahrj-8728	396	29	constrained	constrain	VERB
tahrj-8728	396	30	by	by	ADP
tahrj-8728	396	31	formal	formal	ADJ
tahrj-8728	396	32	categoriesthereby	categoriesthereby	NOUN
tahrj-8728	396	33	being	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	396	34	contextspecific	contextspecific	ADJ
tahrj-8728	396	35	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	397	1	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	397	2	kind	kind	NOUN
tahrj-8728	397	3	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	397	4	deference	deference	NOUN
tahrj-8728	397	5	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	397	6	governmental	governmental	ADJ
tahrj-8728	397	7	decisions	decision	NOUN
tahrj-8728	397	8	implied	imply	VERB
tahrj-8728	397	9	by	by	ADP
tahrj-8728	397	10	https://doi.org/10.17561/tahrj.v23.8728	https://doi.org/10.17561/tahrj.v23.8728	PROPN
tahrj-8728	397	11	sabreen	sabreen	PROPN
tahrj-8728	397	12	ahmed	ahme	VERB
tahrj-8728	397	13	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	397	14	age	age	NOUN
tahrj-8728	397	15	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	397	16	human	human	ADJ
tahrj-8728	397	17	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	397	18	journal	journal	NOUN
tahrj-8728	397	19	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	397	20	24	24	NUM
tahrj-8728	397	21	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	397	22	june	june	PROPN
tahrj-8728	397	23	2025	2025	NUM
tahrj-8728	397	24	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	397	25	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	397	26	e8728	e8728	PROPN
tahrj-8728	397	27	issn	issn	PROPN
tahrj-8728	397	28	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	397	29	2340	2340	NUM
tahrj-8728	397	30	-	-	SYM
tahrj-8728	397	31	9592	9592	NUM
tahrj-8728	397	32	doi	doi	NOUN
tahrj-8728	397	33	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	397	34	10.17561	10.17561	NUM
tahrj-8728	397	35	/	/	SYM
tahrj-8728	397	36	tahrj.v23.8728	tahrj.v23.8728	PROPN
tahrj-8728	397	37	21	21	NUM
tahrj-8728	397	38	taggart	taggart	NOUN
tahrj-8728	397	39	is	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	397	40	not	not	PART
tahrj-8728	397	41	always	always	ADV
tahrj-8728	397	42	seen	see	VERB
tahrj-8728	397	43	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	397	44	india	india	PROPN
tahrj-8728	397	45	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	397	46	where	where	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	397	47	courts	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	397	48	sometimes	sometimes	ADV
tahrj-8728	397	49	engage	engage	VERB
tahrj-8728	397	50	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	397	51	fact	fact	NOUN
tahrj-8728	397	52	-	-	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	397	53	finding	finding	NOUN
tahrj-8728	397	54	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	397	55	issue	issue	VERB
tahrj-8728	397	56	broad	broad	ADJ
tahrj-8728	397	57	directives	directive	NOUN
tahrj-8728	397	58	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	397	59	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	397	60	examine	examine	VERB
tahrj-8728	397	61	policy	policy	NOUN
tahrj-8728	397	62	decisions	decision	NOUN
tahrj-8728	397	63	more	more	ADV
tahrj-8728	397	64	intrusively	intrusively	ADV
tahrj-8728	397	65	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	398	1	this	this	DET
tahrj-8728	398	2	judicial	judicial	ADJ
tahrj-8728	398	3	tendency	tendency	NOUN
tahrj-8728	398	4	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	398	5	‘	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	398	6	activism	activism	NOUN
tahrj-8728	398	7	’	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	398	8	by	by	ADP
tahrj-8728	398	9	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	398	10	sci	sci	PROPN
tahrj-8728	398	11	elevates	elevate	VERB
tahrj-8728	398	12	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	398	13	argument	argument	NOUN
tahrj-8728	398	14	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	398	15	favor	favor	NOUN
tahrj-8728	398	16	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	398	17	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	398	18	analyses	analysis	NOUN
tahrj-8728	398	19	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	398	20	cases	case	NOUN
tahrj-8728	398	21	involving	involve	VERB
tahrj-8728	398	22	substantial	substantial	ADJ
tahrj-8728	398	23	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	398	24	-	-	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	398	25	violation	violation	NOUN
tahrj-8728	398	26	like	like	INTJ
tahrj-8728	398	27	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	398	28	non	non	ADJ
tahrj-8728	398	29	-	-	ADJ
tahrj-8728	398	30	refoulement	refoulement	ADJ
tahrj-8728	398	31	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	399	1	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	399	2	determining	determine	VERB
tahrj-8728	399	3	how	how	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	399	4	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	399	5	analysis	analysis	NOUN
tahrj-8728	399	6	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	399	7	practise	practise	NOUN
tahrj-8728	399	8	can	can	AUX
tahrj-8728	399	9	be	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	399	10	applied	apply	VERB
tahrj-8728	399	11	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	399	12	nonrefoulement	nonrefoulement	ADJ
tahrj-8728	399	13	cases	case	NOUN
tahrj-8728	399	14	when	when	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	399	15	national	national	ADJ
tahrj-8728	399	16	security	security	NOUN
tahrj-8728	399	17	concerns	concern	NOUN
tahrj-8728	399	18	exist	exist	VERB
tahrj-8728	399	19	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	399	20	india	india	PROPN
tahrj-8728	399	21	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	399	22	lessons	lesson	NOUN
tahrj-8728	399	23	can	can	AUX
tahrj-8728	399	24	be	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	399	25	learnt	learn	VERB
tahrj-8728	399	26	from	from	ADP
tahrj-8728	399	27	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	399	28	kenyan	kenyan	ADJ
tahrj-8728	399	29	high	high	PROPN
tahrj-8728	399	30	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	399	31	’s	’s	PART
tahrj-8728	399	32	approach	approach	NOUN
tahrj-8728	399	33	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	399	34	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	399	35	kitua	kitua	PROPN
tahrj-8728	399	36	cha	cha	PROPN
tahrj-8728	399	37	sheria	sheria	PROPN
tahrj-8728	399	38	case	case	NOUN
tahrj-8728	399	39	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	399	40	2017	2017	NUM
tahrj-8728	399	41	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	399	42	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	400	1	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	400	2	kenyan	kenyan	ADJ
tahrj-8728	400	3	high	high	ADJ
tahrj-8728	400	4	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	400	5	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	400	6	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	400	7	light	light	NOUN
tahrj-8728	400	8	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	400	9	constitutional	constitutional	ADJ
tahrj-8728	400	10	provision	provision	NOUN
tahrj-8728	400	11	provides	provide	VERB
tahrj-8728	400	12	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	400	13	guide	guide	NOUN
tahrj-8728	400	14	on	on	ADP
tahrj-8728	400	15	how	how	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	400	16	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	400	17	analysis	analysis	NOUN
tahrj-8728	400	18	be	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	400	19	applied	apply	VERB
tahrj-8728	400	20	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	400	21	cases	case	NOUN
tahrj-8728	400	22	where	where	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	400	23	non	non	ADJ
tahrj-8728	400	24	-	-	ADJ
tahrj-8728	400	25	refoulement	refoulement	ADJ
tahrj-8728	400	26	conflicts	conflict	NOUN
tahrj-8728	400	27	with	with	ADP
tahrj-8728	400	28	national	national	ADJ
tahrj-8728	400	29	security	security	NOUN
tahrj-8728	400	30	concerns	concern	NOUN
tahrj-8728	400	31	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	400	32	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	400	33	achieve	achieve	VERB
tahrj-8728	400	34	better	well	ADJ
tahrj-8728	400	35	outcomes	outcome	NOUN
tahrj-8728	400	36	for	for	ADP
tahrj-8728	400	37	refugee	refugee	NOUN
tahrj-8728	400	38	protection	protection	NOUN
tahrj-8728	400	39	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	401	1	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	401	2	reliance	reliance	NOUN
tahrj-8728	401	3	on	on	ADP
tahrj-8728	401	4	foreign	foreign	ADJ
tahrj-8728	401	5	precedents	precedent	NOUN
tahrj-8728	401	6	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	401	7	public	public	ADJ
tahrj-8728	401	8	law	law	NOUN
tahrj-8728	401	9	litigation	litigation	NOUN
tahrj-8728	401	10	is	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	401	11	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	401	12	well	well	ADV
tahrj-8728	401	13	-	-	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	401	14	established	establish	VERB
tahrj-8728	401	15	practice	practice	NOUN
tahrj-8728	401	16	now	now	ADV
tahrj-8728	401	17	persistent	persistent	ADJ
tahrj-8728	401	18	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	401	19	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	401	20	decisions	decision	NOUN
tahrj-8728	401	21	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	401	22	constitutional	constitutional	ADJ
tahrj-8728	401	23	courts	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	401	24	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	401	25	common	common	ADJ
tahrj-8728	401	26	law	law	NOUN
tahrj-8728	401	27	jurisdictions	jurisdiction	NOUN
tahrj-8728	401	28	such	such	ADJ
tahrj-8728	401	29	as	as	ADP
tahrj-8728	401	30	south	south	PROPN
tahrj-8728	401	31	africa	africa	PROPN
tahrj-8728	401	32	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	401	33	canada	canada	PROPN
tahrj-8728	401	34	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	401	35	new	new	PROPN
tahrj-8728	401	36	zealand	zealand	PROPN
tahrj-8728	401	37	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	401	38	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	401	39	united	united	PROPN
tahrj-8728	401	40	kingdom	kingdom	PROPN
tahrj-8728	401	41	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	401	42	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	401	43	united	united	PROPN
tahrj-8728	401	44	states	states	PROPN
tahrj-8728	401	45	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	401	46	america	america	PROPN
tahrj-8728	401	47	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	401	48	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	401	49	india	india	PROPN
tahrj-8728	401	50	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	402	1	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	402	2	balakrishnan	balakrishnan	PROPN
tahrj-8728	402	3	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	402	4	2010	2010	NUM
tahrj-8728	402	5	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	402	6	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	403	1	anne	anne	PROPN
tahrj-8728	403	2	-	-	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	403	3	marie	marie	PROPN
tahrj-8728	403	4	slaughter	slaughter	PROPN
tahrj-8728	403	5	used	use	VERB
tahrj-8728	403	6	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	403	7	expression	expression	NOUN
tahrj-8728	403	8	‘	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	403	9	trans	trans	ADJ
tahrj-8728	403	10	-	-	ADJ
tahrj-8728	403	11	judicial	judicial	ADJ
tahrj-8728	403	12	communication	communication	NOUN
tahrj-8728	403	13	’	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	403	14	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	403	15	describe	describe	VERB
tahrj-8728	403	16	this	this	DET
tahrj-8728	403	17	trend	trend	NOUN
tahrj-8728	403	18	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	404	1	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	404	2	slaughter	slaughter	NOUN
tahrj-8728	404	3	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	404	4	1994	1994	NUM
tahrj-8728	404	5	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	404	6	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	405	1	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	405	2	primary	primary	ADJ
tahrj-8728	405	3	reason	reason	NOUN
tahrj-8728	405	4	for	for	ADP
tahrj-8728	405	5	such	such	ADJ
tahrj-8728	405	6	practice	practice	NOUN
tahrj-8728	405	7	is	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	405	8	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	405	9	similarities	similarity	NOUN
tahrj-8728	405	10	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	405	11	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	405	12	jurisprudence	jurisprudence	NOUN
tahrj-8728	405	13	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	405	14	indian	indian	ADJ
tahrj-8728	405	15	law	law	NOUN
tahrj-8728	405	16	with	with	ADP
tahrj-8728	405	17	that	that	PRON
tahrj-8728	405	18	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	405	19	these	these	DET
tahrj-8728	405	20	countries	country	NOUN
tahrj-8728	405	21	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	406	1	similarly	similarly	ADV
tahrj-8728	406	2	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	406	3	foreign	foreign	ADJ
tahrj-8728	406	4	judgments	judgment	NOUN
tahrj-8728	406	5	are	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	406	6	helpful	helpful	ADJ
tahrj-8728	406	7	when	when	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	406	8	for	for	ADP
tahrj-8728	406	9	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	406	10	given	give	VERB
tahrj-8728	406	11	question	question	NOUN
tahrj-8728	406	12	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	406	13	law	law	NOUN
tahrj-8728	406	14	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	406	15	no	no	DET
tahrj-8728	406	16	established	establish	VERB
tahrj-8728	406	17	legal	legal	ADJ
tahrj-8728	406	18	position	position	NOUN
tahrj-8728	406	19	seems	seem	VERB
tahrj-8728	406	20	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	406	21	emerge	emerge	VERB
tahrj-8728	406	22	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	407	1	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	407	2	sci	sci	PROPN
tahrj-8728	407	3	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	407	4	many	many	ADJ
tahrj-8728	407	5	landmark	landmark	NOUN
tahrj-8728	407	6	judgments	judgment	NOUN
tahrj-8728	407	7	relied	rely	VERB
tahrj-8728	407	8	on	on	ADP
tahrj-8728	407	9	foreign	foreign	ADJ
tahrj-8728	407	10	precedents	precedent	NOUN
tahrj-8728	407	11	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	407	12	inform	inform	VERB
tahrj-8728	407	13	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	407	14	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	407	15	india	india	PROPN
tahrj-8728	407	16	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	408	1	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	408	2	maneka	maneka	PROPN
tahrj-8728	408	3	gandhi	gandhi	PROPN
tahrj-8728	408	4	v.	v.	ADP
tahrj-8728	408	5	union	union	PROPN
tahrj-8728	408	6	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	408	7	india	india	PROPN
tahrj-8728	408	8	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	408	9	1978	1978	NUM
tahrj-8728	408	10	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	408	11	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	408	12	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	408	13	apex	apex	PROPN
tahrj-8728	408	14	court	court	PROPN
tahrj-8728	408	15	read	read	VERB
tahrj-8728	408	16	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	408	17	‘	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	408	18	substantive	substantive	ADJ
tahrj-8728	408	19	due	due	ADJ
tahrj-8728	408	20	process	process	NOUN
tahrj-8728	408	21	guarantee	guarantee	NOUN
tahrj-8728	408	22	’	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	408	23	into	into	ADP
tahrj-8728	408	24	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	408	25	language	language	NOUN
tahrj-8728	408	26	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	408	27	art	art	NOUN
tahrj-8728	408	28	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	409	1	21	21	NUM
tahrj-8728	409	2	borrowing	borrowing	NOUN
tahrj-8728	409	3	from	from	ADP
tahrj-8728	409	4	u.s	u.s	PROPN
tahrj-8728	409	5	.	.	PROPN
tahrj-8728	409	6	decisions	decision	NOUN
tahrj-8728	409	7	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	409	8	laid	lay	VERB
tahrj-8728	409	9	down	down	ADP
tahrj-8728	409	10	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	409	11	position	position	NOUN
tahrj-8728	409	12	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	409	13	governmental	governmental	ADJ
tahrj-8728	409	14	action	action	NOUN
tahrj-8728	409	15	is	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	409	16	subject	subject	ADJ
tahrj-8728	409	17	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	409	18	scrutiny	scrutiny	NOUN
tahrj-8728	409	19	on	on	ADP
tahrj-8728	409	20	multiple	multiple	ADJ
tahrj-8728	409	21	grounds	ground	NOUN
tahrj-8728	409	22	such	such	ADJ
tahrj-8728	409	23	as	as	ADP
tahrj-8728	409	24	fairness	fairness	NOUN
tahrj-8728	409	25	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	409	26	reasonableness	reasonableness	NOUN
tahrj-8728	409	27	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	409	28	non	non	ADJ
tahrj-8728	409	29	-	-	NOUN
tahrj-8728	409	30	arbitrariness	arbitrariness	NOUN
tahrj-8728	409	31	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	410	1	other	other	ADJ
tahrj-8728	410	2	cases	case	NOUN
tahrj-8728	410	3	include	include	VERB
tahrj-8728	410	4	kharak	kharak	PROPN
tahrj-8728	410	5	singh	singh	PROPN
tahrj-8728	410	6	v.	v.	ADP
tahrj-8728	410	7	state	state	PROPN
tahrj-8728	410	8	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	410	9	uttar	uttar	PROPN
tahrj-8728	410	10	pradesh	pradesh	PROPN
tahrj-8728	410	11	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	410	12	1963	1963	NUM
tahrj-8728	410	13	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	410	14	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	410	15	bennett	bennett	PROPN
tahrj-8728	410	16	&	&	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	410	17	coleman	coleman	PROPN
tahrj-8728	410	18	v.	v.	PROPN
tahrj-8728	410	19	union	union	PROPN
tahrj-8728	410	20	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	410	21	india	india	PROPN
tahrj-8728	410	22	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	410	23	1973	1973	NUM
tahrj-8728	410	24	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	410	25	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	410	26	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	410	27	bachan	bachan	PROPN
tahrj-8728	410	28	singh	singh	PROPN
tahrj-8728	410	29	v.	v.	ADP
tahrj-8728	410	30	union	union	PROPN
tahrj-8728	410	31	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	410	32	india	india	PROPN
tahrj-8728	410	33	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	410	34	1980	1980	NUM
tahrj-8728	410	35	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	410	36	among	among	ADP
tahrj-8728	410	37	others	other	NOUN
tahrj-8728	410	38	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	411	1	following	follow	VERB
tahrj-8728	411	2	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	411	3	same	same	ADJ
tahrj-8728	411	4	analogy	analogy	NOUN
tahrj-8728	411	5	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	411	6	it	it	PRON
tahrj-8728	411	7	can	can	AUX
tahrj-8728	411	8	be	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	411	9	determined	determine	VERB
tahrj-8728	411	10	how	how	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	411	11	indian	indian	ADJ
tahrj-8728	411	12	courts	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	411	13	can	can	AUX
tahrj-8728	411	14	navigate	navigate	VERB
tahrj-8728	411	15	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	411	16	existing	exist	VERB
tahrj-8728	411	17	kenyan	kenyan	ADJ
tahrj-8728	411	18	jurisprudence	jurisprudence	NOUN
tahrj-8728	411	19	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	411	20	apply	apply	VERB
tahrj-8728	411	21	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	411	22	analysis	analysis	NOUN
tahrj-8728	411	23	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	411	24	non	non	ADJ
tahrj-8728	411	25	-	-	ADJ
tahrj-8728	411	26	refoulement	refoulement	ADJ
tahrj-8728	411	27	cases	case	NOUN
tahrj-8728	411	28	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	411	29	india	india	PROPN
tahrj-8728	411	30	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	412	1	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	412	2	encapsulate	encapsulate	VERB
tahrj-8728	412	3	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	412	4	same	same	ADJ
tahrj-8728	412	5	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	412	6	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	412	7	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	412	8	first	first	ADV
tahrj-8728	412	9	must	must	AUX
tahrj-8728	412	10	determine	determine	VERB
tahrj-8728	412	11	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	412	12	real	real	ADJ
tahrj-8728	412	13	connection	connection	NOUN
tahrj-8728	412	14	between	between	ADP
tahrj-8728	412	15	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	412	16	person	person	NOUN
tahrj-8728	412	17	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	412	18	question	question	NOUN
tahrj-8728	412	19	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	412	20	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	412	21	alleged	allege	VERB
tahrj-8728	412	22	national	national	ADJ
tahrj-8728	412	23	security	security	NOUN
tahrj-8728	412	24	concern	concern	NOUN
tahrj-8728	412	25	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	413	1	second	second	ADJ
tahrj-8728	413	2	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	413	3	it	it	PRON
tahrj-8728	413	4	must	must	AUX
tahrj-8728	413	5	be	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	413	6	shown	show	VERB
tahrj-8728	413	7	how	how	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	413	8	their	their	PRON
tahrj-8728	413	9	refoulement	refoulement	NOUN
tahrj-8728	413	10	will	will	AUX
tahrj-8728	413	11	ensure	ensure	VERB
tahrj-8728	413	12	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	413	13	security	security	NOUN
tahrj-8728	413	14	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	413	15	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	413	16	nation	nation	NOUN
tahrj-8728	413	17	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	414	1	third	third	ADV
tahrj-8728	414	2	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	414	3	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	414	4	risk	risk	NOUN
tahrj-8728	414	5	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	414	6	danger	danger	NOUN
tahrj-8728	414	7	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	414	8	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	414	9	person	person	NOUN
tahrj-8728	414	10	concerned	concern	VERB
tahrj-8728	414	11	be	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	414	12	balanced	balance	VERB
tahrj-8728	414	13	with	with	ADP
tahrj-8728	414	14	intended	intend	VERB
tahrj-8728	414	15	results	result	NOUN
tahrj-8728	414	16	for	for	ADP
tahrj-8728	414	17	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	414	18	security	security	NOUN
tahrj-8728	414	19	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	414	20	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	414	21	nation	nation	NOUN
tahrj-8728	414	22	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	414	23	see	see	VERB
tahrj-8728	414	24	if	if	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	414	25	such	such	ADJ
tahrj-8728	414	26	security	security	NOUN
tahrj-8728	414	27	can	can	AUX
tahrj-8728	414	28	be	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	414	29	attained	attain	VERB
tahrj-8728	414	30	without	without	ADP
tahrj-8728	414	31	removal	removal	NOUN
tahrj-8728	414	32	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	415	1	this	this	DET
tahrj-8728	415	2	decision	decision	NOUN
tahrj-8728	415	3	runs	run	VERB
tahrj-8728	415	4	simultaneously	simultaneously	ADV
tahrj-8728	415	5	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	415	6	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	415	7	fact	fact	NOUN
tahrj-8728	415	8	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	415	9	national	national	ADJ
tahrj-8728	415	10	security	security	NOUN
tahrj-8728	415	11	concerns	concern	NOUN
tahrj-8728	415	12	can	can	AUX
tahrj-8728	415	13	not	not	PART
tahrj-8728	415	14	be	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	415	15	compromised	compromise	VERB
tahrj-8728	415	16	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	416	1	however	however	ADV
tahrj-8728	416	2	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	416	3	requires	require	VERB
tahrj-8728	416	4	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	416	5	state	state	NOUN
tahrj-8728	416	6	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	416	7	demonstrate	demonstrate	VERB
tahrj-8728	416	8	how	how	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	416	9	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	416	10	refugees	refugee	NOUN
tahrj-8728	416	11	are	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	416	12	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	416	13	main	main	ADJ
tahrj-8728	416	14	source	source	NOUN
tahrj-8728	416	15	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	416	16	insecurity	insecurity	NOUN
tahrj-8728	416	17	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	417	1	if	if	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	417	2	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	417	3	state	state	NOUN
tahrj-8728	417	4	fails	fail	VERB
tahrj-8728	417	5	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	417	6	justify	justify	VERB
tahrj-8728	417	7	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	417	8	meet	meet	VERB
tahrj-8728	417	9	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	417	10	standards	standard	NOUN
tahrj-8728	417	11	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	417	12	review	review	NOUN
tahrj-8728	417	13	where	where	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	417	14	no	no	DET
tahrj-8728	417	15	real	real	ADJ
tahrj-8728	417	16	evidence	evidence	NOUN
tahrj-8728	417	17	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	417	18	national	national	ADJ
tahrj-8728	417	19	security	security	NOUN
tahrj-8728	417	20	threat	threat	NOUN
tahrj-8728	417	21	exists	exist	VERB
tahrj-8728	417	22	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	417	23	all	all	PRON
tahrj-8728	417	24	that	that	PRON
tahrj-8728	417	25	remains	remain	VERB
tahrj-8728	417	26	is	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	417	27	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	417	28	violation	violation	NOUN
tahrj-8728	417	29	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	417	30	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	417	31	fundamental	fundamental	ADJ
tahrj-8728	417	32	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	417	33	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	417	34	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	417	35	refugees	refugee	NOUN
tahrj-8728	417	36	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	418	1	while	while	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	418	2	such	such	ADJ
tahrj-8728	418	3	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	418	4	review	review	NOUN
tahrj-8728	418	5	is	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	418	6	enabled	enable	VERB
tahrj-8728	418	7	by	by	ADP
tahrj-8728	418	8	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	418	9	constitution	constitution	NOUN
tahrj-8728	418	10	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	418	11	kenya	kenya	PROPN
tahrj-8728	418	12	for	for	ADP
tahrj-8728	418	13	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	418	14	kenyan	kenyan	ADJ
tahrj-8728	418	15	high	high	ADJ
tahrj-8728	418	16	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	418	17	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	418	18	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	418	19	supreme	supreme	PROPN
tahrj-8728	418	20	court	court	PROPN
tahrj-8728	418	21	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	418	22	india	india	PROPN
tahrj-8728	418	23	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	418	24	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	418	25	absence	absence	NOUN
tahrj-8728	418	26	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	418	27	similar	similar	ADJ
tahrj-8728	418	28	constitutional	constitutional	ADJ
tahrj-8728	418	29	provision	provision	NOUN
tahrj-8728	418	30	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	418	31	can	can	AUX
tahrj-8728	418	32	resort	resort	VERB
tahrj-8728	418	33	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	418	34	such	such	ADJ
tahrj-8728	418	35	application	application	NOUN
tahrj-8728	418	36	by	by	ADP
tahrj-8728	418	37	taking	take	VERB
tahrj-8728	418	38	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	418	39	‘	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	418	40	rainbow	rainbow	NOUN
tahrj-8728	418	41	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	418	42	review	review	NOUN
tahrj-8728	418	43	’	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	418	44	approach	approach	NOUN
tahrj-8728	418	45	for	for	ADP
tahrj-8728	418	46	producing	produce	VERB
tahrj-8728	418	47	similar	similar	ADJ
tahrj-8728	418	48	outcomes	outcome	NOUN
tahrj-8728	418	49	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	418	50	nonrefoulement	nonrefoulement	ADJ
tahrj-8728	418	51	cases	case	NOUN
tahrj-8728	418	52	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	419	1	https://doi.org/10.17561/tahrj.v23.8728	https://doi.org/10.17561/tahrj.v23.8728	NOUN
tahrj-8728	419	2	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	419	3	analysis	analysis	NOUN
tahrj-8728	419	4	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	419	5	non	non	ADJ
tahrj-8728	419	6	-	-	ADJ
tahrj-8728	419	7	refoulement	refoulement	ADJ
tahrj-8728	419	8	jurisprudence	jurisprudence	NOUN
tahrj-8728	419	9	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	419	10	india	india	PROPN
tahrj-8728	419	11	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	419	12	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	419	13	comparative	comparative	ADJ
tahrj-8728	419	14	approach	approach	NOUN
tahrj-8728	419	15	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	419	16	age	age	NOUN
tahrj-8728	419	17	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	419	18	human	human	ADJ
tahrj-8728	419	19	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	419	20	journal	journal	NOUN
tahrj-8728	419	21	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	419	22	24	24	NUM
tahrj-8728	419	23	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	419	24	june	june	PROPN
tahrj-8728	419	25	2025	2025	NUM
tahrj-8728	419	26	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	419	27	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	419	28	e8728	e8728	PROPN
tahrj-8728	419	29	issn	issn	PROPN
tahrj-8728	419	30	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	419	31	2340	2340	NUM
tahrj-8728	419	32	-	-	SYM
tahrj-8728	419	33	9592	9592	NUM
tahrj-8728	419	34	doi	doi	NOUN
tahrj-8728	419	35	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	419	36	10.17561	10.17561	NUM
tahrj-8728	419	37	/	/	SYM
tahrj-8728	419	38	tahrj.v23.8728	tahrj.v23.8728	PROPN
tahrj-8728	419	39	22	22	NUM
tahrj-8728	419	40	4	4	NUM
tahrj-8728	419	41	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	419	42	conclusion	conclusion	NOUN
tahrj-8728	419	43	while	while	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	419	44	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	419	45	status	status	NOUN
tahrj-8728	419	46	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	419	47	non	non	ADJ
tahrj-8728	419	48	-	-	ADJ
tahrj-8728	419	49	refoulement	refoulement	ADJ
tahrj-8728	419	50	as	as	ADP
tahrj-8728	419	51	an	an	DET
tahrj-8728	419	52	international	international	ADJ
tahrj-8728	419	53	obligation	obligation	NOUN
tahrj-8728	419	54	under	under	ADP
tahrj-8728	419	55	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	419	56	refugee	refugee	NOUN
tahrj-8728	419	57	convention	convention	NOUN
tahrj-8728	419	58	is	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	419	59	debatable	debatable	ADJ
tahrj-8728	419	60	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	419	61	its	its	PRON
tahrj-8728	419	62	presence	presence	NOUN
tahrj-8728	419	63	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	419	64	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	419	65	form	form	NOUN
tahrj-8728	419	66	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	419	67	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	419	68	human	human	ADJ
tahrj-8728	419	69	right	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	419	70	or	or	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	419	71	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	419	72	fundamental	fundamental	ADJ
tahrj-8728	419	73	right	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	419	74	can	can	AUX
tahrj-8728	419	75	not	not	PART
tahrj-8728	419	76	be	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	419	77	dismissed	dismiss	VERB
tahrj-8728	419	78	entirely	entirely	ADV
tahrj-8728	419	79	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	420	1	this	this	PRON
tahrj-8728	420	2	finds	find	VERB
tahrj-8728	420	3	space	space	NOUN
tahrj-8728	420	4	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	420	5	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	420	6	jurisprudence	jurisprudence	NOUN
tahrj-8728	420	7	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	420	8	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	420	9	supreme	supreme	PROPN
tahrj-8728	420	10	court	court	PROPN
tahrj-8728	420	11	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	420	12	india	india	PROPN
tahrj-8728	420	13	itself	itself	PRON
tahrj-8728	420	14	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	421	1	however	however	ADV
tahrj-8728	421	2	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	421	3	an	an	DET
tahrj-8728	421	4	inconsistent	inconsistent	ADJ
tahrj-8728	421	5	approach	approach	NOUN
tahrj-8728	421	6	diminishes	diminish	VERB
tahrj-8728	421	7	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	421	8	protection	protection	NOUN
tahrj-8728	421	9	mechanism	mechanism	NOUN
tahrj-8728	421	10	offered	offer	VERB
tahrj-8728	421	11	by	by	ADP
tahrj-8728	421	12	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	421	13	non	non	ADJ
tahrj-8728	421	14	-	-	ADJ
tahrj-8728	421	15	refoulement	refoulement	ADJ
tahrj-8728	421	16	obligation	obligation	NOUN
tahrj-8728	421	17	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	422	1	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	422	2	this	this	DET
tahrj-8728	422	3	context	context	NOUN
tahrj-8728	422	4	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	422	5	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	422	6	wednesbury	wednesbury	NOUN
tahrj-8728	422	7	-	-	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	422	8	like	like	ADJ
tahrj-8728	422	9	analysis	analysis	NOUN
tahrj-8728	422	10	rooted	root	VERB
tahrj-8728	422	11	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	422	12	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	422	13	‘	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	422	14	unreasonableness	unreasonableness	NOUN
tahrj-8728	422	15	’	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	422	16	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	422	17	deportation	deportation	NOUN
tahrj-8728	422	18	decisions	decision	NOUN
tahrj-8728	422	19	which	which	PRON
tahrj-8728	422	20	only	only	ADV
tahrj-8728	422	21	assesses	assesse	NOUN
tahrj-8728	422	22	‘	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	422	23	due	due	ADJ
tahrj-8728	422	24	process	process	NOUN
tahrj-8728	422	25	’	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	422	26	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	422	27	as	as	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	422	28	seen	see	VERB
tahrj-8728	422	29	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	422	30	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	422	31	salimullah	salimullah	NOUN
tahrj-8728	422	32	case	case	NOUN
tahrj-8728	422	33	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	422	34	produces	produce	VERB
tahrj-8728	422	35	incorrect	incorrect	ADJ
tahrj-8728	422	36	outcomes	outcome	NOUN
tahrj-8728	422	37	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	423	1	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	423	2	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	423	3	’s	’s	PART
tahrj-8728	423	4	recent	recent	ADJ
tahrj-8728	423	5	trend	trend	NOUN
tahrj-8728	423	6	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	423	7	restraint	restraint	NOUN
tahrj-8728	423	8	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	423	9	intervening	intervene	VERB
tahrj-8728	423	10	with	with	ADP
tahrj-8728	423	11	administrative	administrative	ADJ
tahrj-8728	423	12	practices	practice	NOUN
tahrj-8728	423	13	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	423	14	refugee	refugee	NOUN
tahrj-8728	423	15	cases	case	NOUN
tahrj-8728	423	16	especially	especially	ADV
tahrj-8728	423	17	given	give	VERB
tahrj-8728	423	18	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	423	19	absence	absence	NOUN
tahrj-8728	423	20	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	423	21	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	423	22	nationwide	nationwide	ADJ
tahrj-8728	423	23	refugee	refugee	NOUN
tahrj-8728	423	24	policy	policy	NOUN
tahrj-8728	423	25	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	423	26	reflects	reflect	VERB
tahrj-8728	423	27	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	423	28	distasteful	distasteful	ADJ
tahrj-8728	423	29	precedent	precedent	NOUN
tahrj-8728	423	30	capable	capable	ADJ
tahrj-8728	423	31	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	423	32	varying	vary	VERB
tahrj-8728	423	33	interpretations	interpretation	NOUN
tahrj-8728	423	34	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	423	35	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	423	36	future	future	NOUN
tahrj-8728	423	37	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	424	1	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	424	2	decision	decision	NOUN
tahrj-8728	424	3	was	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	424	4	devoid	devoid	ADJ
tahrj-8728	424	5	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	424	6	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	424	7	greater	great	ADJ
tahrj-8728	424	8	scrutiny	scrutiny	NOUN
tahrj-8728	424	9	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	424	10	human	human	ADJ
tahrj-8728	424	11	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	424	12	violations	violation	NOUN
tahrj-8728	424	13	manifested	manifest	VERB
tahrj-8728	424	14	with	with	ADP
tahrj-8728	424	15	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	424	16	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	424	17	review	review	NOUN
tahrj-8728	424	18	established	establish	VERB
tahrj-8728	424	19	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	424	20	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	424	21	jurisprudence	jurisprudence	NOUN
tahrj-8728	424	22	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	424	23	ecthr	ecthr	PROPN
tahrj-8728	424	24	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	424	25	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	424	26	uk	uk	PROPN
tahrj-8728	424	27	courts	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	424	28	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	424	29	iahrs	iahrs	NOUN
tahrj-8728	424	30	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	424	31	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	424	32	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	424	33	african	african	ADJ
tahrj-8728	424	34	courts	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	424	35	as	as	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	424	36	already	already	ADV
tahrj-8728	424	37	discussed	discuss	VERB
tahrj-8728	424	38	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	425	1	understanding	understand	VERB
tahrj-8728	425	2	variable	variable	ADJ
tahrj-8728	425	3	intensity	intensity	NOUN
tahrj-8728	425	4	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	425	5	this	this	DET
tahrj-8728	425	6	regard	regard	NOUN
tahrj-8728	425	7	as	as	ADP
tahrj-8728	425	8	reflecting	reflect	VERB
tahrj-8728	425	9	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	425	10	compromise	compromise	NOUN
tahrj-8728	425	11	between	between	ADP
tahrj-8728	425	12	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	425	13	principles	principle	NOUN
tahrj-8728	425	14	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	425	15	vigilance	vigilance	NOUN
tahrj-8728	425	16	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	425	17	restraint	restraint	NOUN
tahrj-8728	425	18	opens	open	VERB
tahrj-8728	425	19	up	up	ADP
tahrj-8728	425	20	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	425	21	view	view	NOUN
tahrj-8728	425	22	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	425	23	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	425	24	more	more	ADV
tahrj-8728	425	25	contextspecific	contextspecific	ADJ
tahrj-8728	425	26	variability	variability	NOUN
tahrj-8728	425	27	paradigm	paradigm	NOUN
tahrj-8728	425	28	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	426	1	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	426	2	-	-	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	426	3	based	base	VERB
tahrj-8728	426	4	cases	case	NOUN
tahrj-8728	426	5	particularly	particularly	ADV
tahrj-8728	426	6	need	need	VERB
tahrj-8728	426	7	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	426	8	move	move	VERB
tahrj-8728	426	9	towards	towards	ADP
tahrj-8728	426	10	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	426	11	through	through	ADP
tahrj-8728	426	12	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	426	13	‘	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	426	14	rainbow	rainbow	NOUN
tahrj-8728	426	15	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	426	16	review	review	NOUN
tahrj-8728	426	17	’	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	426	18	approach	approach	NOUN
tahrj-8728	426	19	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	427	1	this	this	PRON
tahrj-8728	427	2	would	would	AUX
tahrj-8728	427	3	allow	allow	VERB
tahrj-8728	427	4	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	427	5	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	427	6	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	427	7	apply	apply	VERB
tahrj-8728	427	8	wednesbury	wednesbury	NOUN
tahrj-8728	427	9	analysis	analysis	NOUN
tahrj-8728	427	10	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	427	11	non	non	ADJ
tahrj-8728	427	12	-	-	ADJ
tahrj-8728	427	13	human	human	ADJ
tahrj-8728	427	14	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	427	15	cases	case	NOUN
tahrj-8728	427	16	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	427	17	sub	sub	NOUN
tahrj-8728	427	18	-	-	NOUN
tahrj-8728	427	19	wednesbury	wednesbury	NOUN
tahrj-8728	427	20	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	427	21	qualified	qualified	ADJ
tahrj-8728	427	22	human	human	ADJ
tahrj-8728	427	23	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	427	24	cases	case	NOUN
tahrj-8728	427	25	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	427	26	as	as	ADP
tahrj-8728	427	27	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	427	28	intensity	intensity	NOUN
tahrj-8728	427	29	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	427	30	violation	violation	NOUN
tahrj-8728	427	31	increases	increase	NOUN
tahrj-8728	427	32	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	427	33	absolute	absolute	ADJ
tahrj-8728	427	34	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	427	35	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	427	36	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	427	37	apply	apply	VERB
tahrj-8728	427	38	true	true	ADJ
tahrj-8728	427	39	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	427	40	analysis	analysis	NOUN
tahrj-8728	427	41	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	428	1	it	it	PRON
tahrj-8728	428	2	is	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	428	3	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	428	4	value	value	NOUN
tahrj-8728	428	5	that	that	PRON
tahrj-8728	428	6	such	such	ADJ
tahrj-8728	428	7	standard	standard	ADJ
tahrj-8728	428	8	differentiation	differentiation	NOUN
tahrj-8728	428	9	will	will	AUX
tahrj-8728	428	10	be	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	428	11	hard	hard	ADJ
tahrj-8728	428	12	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	428	13	place	place	VERB
tahrj-8728	428	14	by	by	ADP
tahrj-8728	428	15	courts	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	428	16	against	against	ADP
tahrj-8728	428	17	multiple	multiple	ADJ
tahrj-8728	428	18	cases	case	NOUN
tahrj-8728	428	19	practically	practically	ADV
tahrj-8728	428	20	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	428	21	but	but	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	428	22	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	428	23	same	same	ADJ
tahrj-8728	428	24	is	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	428	25	not	not	PART
tahrj-8728	428	26	impracticable	impracticable	ADJ
tahrj-8728	428	27	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	429	1	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	429	2	first	first	ADJ
tahrj-8728	429	3	step	step	NOUN
tahrj-8728	429	4	towards	towards	ADP
tahrj-8728	429	5	such	such	DET
tahrj-8728	429	6	an	an	DET
tahrj-8728	429	7	assessment	assessment	NOUN
tahrj-8728	429	8	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	429	9	judicial	judicial	ADJ
tahrj-8728	429	10	intervention	intervention	NOUN
tahrj-8728	429	11	thus	thus	ADV
tahrj-8728	429	12	will	will	AUX
tahrj-8728	429	13	be	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	429	14	based	base	VERB
tahrj-8728	429	15	on	on	ADP
tahrj-8728	429	16	one	one	NUM
tahrj-8728	429	17	stage	stage	NOUN
tahrj-8728	429	18	–	–	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	429	19	whether	whether	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	429	20	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	429	21	judges	judge	NOUN
tahrj-8728	429	22	consider	consider	VERB
tahrj-8728	429	23	something	something	PRON
tahrj-8728	429	24	had	have	AUX
tahrj-8728	429	25	gone	go	VERB
tahrj-8728	429	26	sufficiently	sufficiently	ADV
tahrj-8728	429	27	wrong	wrong	ADJ
tahrj-8728	429	28	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	429	29	justify	justify	VERB
tahrj-8728	429	30	intervention	intervention	NOUN
tahrj-8728	429	31	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	430	1	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	430	2	courts	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	430	3	could	could	AUX
tahrj-8728	430	4	then	then	ADV
tahrj-8728	430	5	plot	plot	VERB
tahrj-8728	430	6	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	430	7	degree	degree	NOUN
tahrj-8728	430	8	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	430	9	intensity	intensity	NOUN
tahrj-8728	430	10	on	on	ADP
tahrj-8728	430	11	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	430	12	continuum	continuum	NOUN
tahrj-8728	430	13	between	between	ADP
tahrj-8728	430	14	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	430	15	two	two	NUM
tahrj-8728	430	16	practices	practice	NOUN
tahrj-8728	430	17	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	430	18	restraint	restraint	NOUN
tahrj-8728	430	19	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	430	20	vigilance	vigilance	NOUN
tahrj-8728	430	21	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	430	22	explaining	explain	VERB
tahrj-8728	430	23	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	430	24	contextual	contextual	ADJ
tahrj-8728	430	25	factors	factor	NOUN
tahrj-8728	430	26	leading	lead	VERB
tahrj-8728	430	27	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	430	28	such	such	DET
tahrj-8728	430	29	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	430	30	decision	decision	NOUN
tahrj-8728	430	31	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	431	1	they	they	PRON
tahrj-8728	431	2	may	may	AUX
tahrj-8728	431	3	then	then	ADV
tahrj-8728	431	4	apply	apply	VERB
tahrj-8728	431	5	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	431	6	intensity	intensity	NOUN
tahrj-8728	431	7	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	431	8	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	431	9	circumstances	circumstance	NOUN
tahrj-8728	431	10	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	431	11	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	431	12	particular	particular	ADJ
tahrj-8728	431	13	case	case	NOUN
tahrj-8728	431	14	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	432	1	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	432	2	field	field	NOUN
tahrj-8728	432	3	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	432	4	human	human	ADJ
tahrj-8728	432	5	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	432	6	would	would	AUX
tahrj-8728	432	7	need	need	VERB
tahrj-8728	432	8	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	432	9	involve	involve	VERB
tahrj-8728	432	10	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	432	11	more	more	ADV
tahrj-8728	432	12	intensive	intensive	ADJ
tahrj-8728	432	13	review	review	NOUN
tahrj-8728	432	14	is	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	432	15	already	already	ADV
tahrj-8728	432	16	sufficiently	sufficiently	ADV
tahrj-8728	432	17	established	establish	VERB
tahrj-8728	432	18	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	433	1	summarily	summarily	ADV
tahrj-8728	433	2	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	433	3	careful	careful	ADJ
tahrj-8728	433	4	analysis	analysis	NOUN
tahrj-8728	433	5	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	433	6	vast	vast	ADJ
tahrj-8728	433	7	number	number	NOUN
tahrj-8728	433	8	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	433	9	case	case	NOUN
tahrj-8728	433	10	laws	law	NOUN
tahrj-8728	433	11	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	433	12	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	433	13	paper	paper	NOUN
tahrj-8728	433	14	suggest	suggest	VERB
tahrj-8728	433	15	that	that	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	433	16	while	while	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	433	17	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	433	18	approach	approach	NOUN
tahrj-8728	433	19	adopted	adopt	VERB
tahrj-8728	433	20	by	by	ADP
tahrj-8728	433	21	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	433	22	eu	eu	PROPN
tahrj-8728	433	23	jurisprudence	jurisprudence	NOUN
tahrj-8728	433	24	is	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	433	25	rather	rather	ADV
tahrj-8728	433	26	confusing	confusing	ADJ
tahrj-8728	433	27	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	433	28	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	433	29	acthpr	acthpr	ADV
tahrj-8728	433	30	does	do	AUX
tahrj-8728	433	31	not	not	PART
tahrj-8728	433	32	guarantee	guarantee	VERB
tahrj-8728	433	33	its	its	PRON
tahrj-8728	433	34	application	application	NOUN
tahrj-8728	433	35	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	433	36	non	non	ADJ
tahrj-8728	433	37	-	-	ADJ
tahrj-8728	433	38	refoulement	refoulement	ADJ
tahrj-8728	433	39	cases	case	NOUN
tahrj-8728	433	40	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	433	41	it	it	PRON
tahrj-8728	433	42	is	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	433	43	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	433	44	kenya	kenya	PROPN
tahrj-8728	433	45	high	high	PROPN
tahrj-8728	433	46	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	433	47	that	that	PRON
tahrj-8728	433	48	has	have	AUX
tahrj-8728	433	49	encapsulated	encapsulate	VERB
tahrj-8728	433	50	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	433	51	analysis	analysis	NOUN
tahrj-8728	433	52	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	433	53	instances	instance	NOUN
tahrj-8728	433	54	where	where	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	433	55	non	non	ADJ
tahrj-8728	433	56	-	-	ADJ
tahrj-8728	433	57	refoulement	refoulement	ADJ
tahrj-8728	433	58	conflicts	conflict	NOUN
tahrj-8728	433	59	with	with	ADP
tahrj-8728	433	60	national	national	ADJ
tahrj-8728	433	61	security	security	NOUN
tahrj-8728	433	62	concerns	concern	NOUN
tahrj-8728	433	63	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	434	1	this	this	DET
tahrj-8728	434	2	comparison	comparison	NOUN
tahrj-8728	434	3	offers	offer	VERB
tahrj-8728	434	4	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	434	5	recalibration	recalibration	NOUN
tahrj-8728	434	6	for	for	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	434	7	indian	indian	ADJ
tahrj-8728	434	8	courts	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	434	9	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	434	10	restructure	restructure	VERB
tahrj-8728	434	11	their	their	PRON
tahrj-8728	434	12	non	non	ADJ
tahrj-8728	434	13	-	-	ADJ
tahrj-8728	434	14	refoulement	refoulement	ADJ
tahrj-8728	434	15	jurisprudence	jurisprudence	NOUN
tahrj-8728	434	16	based	base	VERB
tahrj-8728	434	17	on	on	ADP
tahrj-8728	434	18	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	434	19	standard	standard	NOUN
tahrj-8728	434	20	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	434	21	review	review	NOUN
tahrj-8728	434	22	that	that	PRON
tahrj-8728	434	23	is	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	434	24	appropriately	appropriately	ADV
tahrj-8728	434	25	applicable	applicable	ADJ
tahrj-8728	434	26	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	434	27	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	434	28	context	context	NOUN
tahrj-8728	434	29	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	434	30	each	each	DET
tahrj-8728	434	31	case	case	NOUN
tahrj-8728	434	32	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	435	1	similarly	similarly	ADV
tahrj-8728	435	2	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	435	3	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	435	4	uniformity	uniformity	NOUN
tahrj-8728	435	5	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	435	6	approach	approach	NOUN
tahrj-8728	435	7	can	can	AUX
tahrj-8728	435	8	be	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	435	9	generalized	generalize	VERB
tahrj-8728	435	10	once	once	ADV
tahrj-8728	435	11	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	435	12	structured	structured	ADJ
tahrj-8728	435	13	analysis	analysis	NOUN
tahrj-8728	435	14	is	be	AUX
tahrj-8728	435	15	formulated	formulate	VERB
tahrj-8728	435	16	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	436	1	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	436	2	‘	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	436	3	rainbow	rainbow	NOUN
tahrj-8728	436	4	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	436	5	review	review	NOUN
tahrj-8728	436	6	’	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	436	7	thus	thus	ADV
tahrj-8728	436	8	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	436	9	with	with	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	436	10	all	all	DET
tahrj-8728	436	11	its	its	PRON
tahrj-8728	436	12	limitations	limitation	NOUN
tahrj-8728	436	13	acknowledged	acknowledge	VERB
tahrj-8728	436	14	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	436	15	offers	offer	VERB
tahrj-8728	436	16	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	436	17	plan	plan	NOUN
tahrj-8728	436	18	for	for	SCONJ
tahrj-8728	436	19	indian	indian	ADJ
tahrj-8728	436	20	courts	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	436	21	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	436	22	not	not	PART
tahrj-8728	436	23	rely	rely	VERB
tahrj-8728	436	24	on	on	ADP
tahrj-8728	436	25	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	436	26	refugee	refugee	NOUN
tahrj-8728	436	27	convention	convention	NOUN
tahrj-8728	436	28	or	or	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	436	29	locate	locate	VERB
tahrj-8728	436	30	any	any	DET
tahrj-8728	436	31	inconsistency	inconsistency	NOUN
tahrj-8728	436	32	with	with	ADP
tahrj-8728	436	33	municipal	municipal	ADJ
tahrj-8728	436	34	laws	law	NOUN
tahrj-8728	436	35	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	436	36	concluding	conclude	VERB
tahrj-8728	436	37	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	436	38	decision	decision	NOUN
tahrj-8728	436	39	involving	involve	VERB
tahrj-8728	436	40	non	non	ADJ
tahrj-8728	436	41	-	-	ADJ
tahrj-8728	436	42	refoulement	refoulement	ADJ
tahrj-8728	436	43	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	437	1	it	it	PRON
tahrj-8728	437	2	does	do	VERB
tahrj-8728	437	3	so	so	ADV
tahrj-8728	437	4	without	without	ADP
tahrj-8728	437	5	abandoning	abandon	VERB
tahrj-8728	437	6	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	437	7	wednesbury	wednesbury	PROPN
tahrj-8728	437	8	principle	principle	NOUN
tahrj-8728	437	9	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	437	10	by	by	ADP
tahrj-8728	437	11	only	only	ADV
tahrj-8728	437	12	moving	move	VERB
tahrj-8728	437	13	across	across	ADP
tahrj-8728	437	14	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	437	15	scale	scale	NOUN
tahrj-8728	437	16	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	437	17	review	review	NOUN
tahrj-8728	437	18	towards	towards	ADP
tahrj-8728	437	19	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	437	20	more	more	ADV
tahrj-8728	437	21	intense	intense	ADJ
tahrj-8728	437	22	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	437	23	analysis	analysis	NOUN
tahrj-8728	437	24	based	base	VERB
tahrj-8728	437	25	on	on	ADP
tahrj-8728	437	26	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	437	27	contextual	contextual	ADJ
tahrj-8728	437	28	intensity	intensity	NOUN
tahrj-8728	437	29	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	437	30	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	437	31	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	437	32	violation	violation	NOUN
tahrj-8728	437	33	placed	place	VERB
tahrj-8728	437	34	before	before	ADP
tahrj-8728	437	35	it	it	PRON
tahrj-8728	437	36	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	438	1	https://doi.org/10.17561/tahrj.v23.8728	https://doi.org/10.17561/tahrj.v23.8728	PROPN
tahrj-8728	438	2	sabreen	sabreen	PROPN
tahrj-8728	438	3	ahmed	ahme	VERB
tahrj-8728	438	4	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	438	5	age	age	NOUN
tahrj-8728	438	6	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	438	7	human	human	ADJ
tahrj-8728	438	8	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	438	9	journal	journal	NOUN
tahrj-8728	438	10	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	438	11	24	24	NUM
tahrj-8728	438	12	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	438	13	june	june	PROPN
tahrj-8728	438	14	2025	2025	NUM
tahrj-8728	438	15	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	438	16	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	438	17	e8728	e8728	PROPN
tahrj-8728	438	18	issn	issn	PROPN
tahrj-8728	438	19	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	438	20	2340	2340	NUM
tahrj-8728	438	21	-	-	SYM
tahrj-8728	438	22	9592	9592	NUM
tahrj-8728	438	23	doi	doi	NOUN
tahrj-8728	438	24	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	438	25	10.17561	10.17561	NUM
tahrj-8728	438	26	/	/	SYM
tahrj-8728	438	27	tahrj.v23.8728	tahrj.v23.8728	PROPN
tahrj-8728	438	28	23	23	NUM
tahrj-8728	438	29	acknowledgement	acknowledgement	NOUN
tahrj-8728	438	30	i	i	PRON
tahrj-8728	438	31	would	would	AUX
tahrj-8728	438	32	like	like	VERB
tahrj-8728	438	33	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	438	34	thank	thank	VERB
tahrj-8728	438	35	ms	ms	PROPN
tahrj-8728	438	36	manahil	manahil	PROPN
tahrj-8728	438	37	kidwai	kidwai	PROPN
tahrj-8728	438	38	for	for	ADP
tahrj-8728	438	39	her	her	PRON
tahrj-8728	438	40	valuable	valuable	ADJ
tahrj-8728	438	41	research	research	NOUN
tahrj-8728	438	42	assistance	assistance	NOUN
tahrj-8728	438	43	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	438	44	support	support	NOUN
tahrj-8728	438	45	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	438	46	bringing	bring	VERB
tahrj-8728	438	47	this	this	DET
tahrj-8728	438	48	piece	piece	NOUN
tahrj-8728	438	49	together	together	ADV
tahrj-8728	438	50	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	439	1	reference	reference	NOUN
tahrj-8728	439	2	list	list	NOUN
tahrj-8728	439	3	books	book	VERB
tahrj-8728	439	4	goodwin	goodwin	PROPN
tahrj-8728	439	5	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	439	6	g.	g.	PROPN
tahrj-8728	439	7	s.	s.	PROPN
tahrj-8728	439	8	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	439	9	mcadam	mcadam	PROPN
tahrj-8728	439	10	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	439	11	j.	j.	PROPN
tahrj-8728	439	12	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	439	13	1996	1996	NUM
tahrj-8728	439	14	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	439	15	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	440	1	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	440	2	refugee	refugee	NOUN
tahrj-8728	440	3	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	440	4	international	international	ADJ
tahrj-8728	440	5	law	law	NOUN
tahrj-8728	440	6	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	441	1	4th	4th	ADJ
tahrj-8728	441	2	ed	ed	NOUN
tahrj-8728	441	3	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	442	1	oxford	oxford	NOUN
tahrj-8728	442	2	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	442	3	oxford	oxford	PROPN
tahrj-8728	442	4	university	university	PROPN
tahrj-8728	442	5	press	press	NOUN
tahrj-8728	442	6	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	443	1	hailbronner	hailbronner	PROPN
tahrj-8728	443	2	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	443	3	k.	k.	PROPN
tahrj-8728	443	4	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	443	5	hathaway	hathaway	PROPN
tahrj-8728	443	6	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	443	7	j.	j.	PROPN
tahrj-8728	443	8	c.	c.	PROPN
tahrj-8728	443	9	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	443	10	2005	2005	NUM
tahrj-8728	443	11	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	443	12	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	444	1	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	444	2	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	444	3	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	444	4	refugees	refugee	NOUN
tahrj-8728	444	5	under	under	ADP
tahrj-8728	444	6	international	international	ADJ
tahrj-8728	444	7	law	law	NOUN
tahrj-8728	444	8	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	445	1	cambridge	cambridge	PROPN
tahrj-8728	445	2	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	445	3	cambridge	cambridge	PROPN
tahrj-8728	445	4	university	university	PROPN
tahrj-8728	445	5	press	press	NOUN
tahrj-8728	445	6	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	446	1	harris	harris	PROPN
tahrj-8728	446	2	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	446	3	d.	d.	PROPN
tahrj-8728	446	4	j.	j.	PROPN
tahrj-8728	446	5	et	et	PROPN
tahrj-8728	446	6	al	al	PROPN
tahrj-8728	446	7	.	.	PROPN
tahrj-8728	446	8	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	446	9	1995	1995	NUM
tahrj-8728	446	10	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	446	11	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	447	1	harris	harris	PROPN
tahrj-8728	447	2	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	447	3	o’boyle	o’boyle	PROPN
tahrj-8728	447	4	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	447	5	warbrick	warbrick	ADJ
tahrj-8728	447	6	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	447	7	law	law	NOUN
tahrj-8728	447	8	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	447	9	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	447	10	european	european	PROPN
tahrj-8728	447	11	convention	convention	PROPN
tahrj-8728	447	12	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	447	13	human	human	ADJ
tahrj-8728	447	14	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	447	15	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	448	1	london	london	PROPN
tahrj-8728	448	2	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	448	3	butterworths	butterworth	NOUN
tahrj-8728	448	4	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	449	1	eills	eill	NOUN
tahrj-8728	449	2	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	449	3	e.	e.	PROPN
tahrj-8728	449	4	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	449	5	1999	1999	NUM
tahrj-8728	449	6	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	449	7	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	450	1	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	450	2	principle	principle	NOUN
tahrj-8728	450	3	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	450	4	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	450	5	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	450	6	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	450	7	laws	law	NOUN
tahrj-8728	450	8	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	450	9	europe	europe	PROPN
tahrj-8728	450	10	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	451	1	hart	hart	PROPN
tahrj-8728	451	2	publishing	publishing	PROPN
tahrj-8728	451	3	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	452	1	joseph	joseph	PROPN
tahrj-8728	452	2	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	452	3	p.	p.	NOUN
tahrj-8728	452	4	a.	a.	NOUN
tahrj-8728	452	5	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	452	6	2007	2007	NUM
tahrj-8728	452	7	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	452	8	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	453	1	constitutional	constitutional	ADJ
tahrj-8728	453	2	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	453	3	administrative	administrative	ADJ
tahrj-8728	453	4	law	law	NOUN
tahrj-8728	453	5	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	453	6	new	new	PROPN
tahrj-8728	453	7	zealand	zealand	PROPN
tahrj-8728	453	8	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	454	1	3rd	3rd	ADJ
tahrj-8728	454	2	ed	ed	NOUN
tahrj-8728	454	3	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	455	1	wellington	wellington	PROPN
tahrj-8728	455	2	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	456	1	brookers	brooker	NOUN
tahrj-8728	456	2	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	457	1	chapters	chapter	NOUN
tahrj-8728	457	2	cassese	cassese	PROPN
tahrj-8728	457	3	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	457	4	a.	a.	NOUN
tahrj-8728	457	5	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	457	6	1993	1993	NUM
tahrj-8728	457	7	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	457	8	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	458	1	‘	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	458	2	prohibition	prohibition	NOUN
tahrj-8728	458	3	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	458	4	torture	torture	NOUN
tahrj-8728	458	5	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	458	6	inhuman	inhuman	ADJ
tahrj-8728	458	7	or	or	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	458	8	degrading	degrading	ADJ
tahrj-8728	458	9	treatment	treatment	NOUN
tahrj-8728	458	10	or	or	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	458	11	punishment	punishment	NOUN
tahrj-8728	458	12	’	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	458	13	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	458	14	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	458	15	macdonald	macdonald	PROPN
tahrj-8728	458	16	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	458	17	r.	r.	PROPN
tahrj-8728	458	18	s.	s.	PROPN
tahrj-8728	458	19	j.	j.	PROPN
tahrj-8728	458	20	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	458	21	ed	ed	NOUN
tahrj-8728	458	22	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	458	23	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	459	1	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	459	2	european	european	ADJ
tahrj-8728	459	3	system	system	NOUN
tahrj-8728	459	4	for	for	ADP
tahrj-8728	459	5	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	459	6	protection	protection	NOUN
tahrj-8728	459	7	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	459	8	human	human	ADJ
tahrj-8728	459	9	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	459	10	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	460	1	dordrecht	dordrecht	PROPN
tahrj-8728	460	2	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	460	3	martinus	martinus	PROPN
tahrj-8728	460	4	nijhoff	nijhoff	PROPN
tahrj-8728	460	5	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	460	6	pp	pp	ADJ
tahrj-8728	460	7	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	460	8	225	225	NUM
tahrj-8728	460	9	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	461	1	https://doi	https://doi	X
tahrj-8728	461	2	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	461	3	org/10.1163/9789004633599_017	org/10.1163/9789004633599_017	PROPN
tahrj-8728	461	4	chandra	chandra	PROPN
tahrj-8728	461	5	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	461	6	a.	a.	NOUN
tahrj-8728	461	7	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	461	8	2020	2020	NUM
tahrj-8728	461	9	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	461	10	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	462	1	‘	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	462	2	limitation	limitation	NOUN
tahrj-8728	462	3	analysis	analysis	NOUN
tahrj-8728	462	4	by	by	ADP
tahrj-8728	462	5	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	462	6	indian	indian	PROPN
tahrj-8728	462	7	supreme	supreme	PROPN
tahrj-8728	462	8	court	court	PROPN
tahrj-8728	462	9	’	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	462	10	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	462	11	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	462	12	kremnitzer	kremnitzer	PROPN
tahrj-8728	462	13	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	462	14	m.	m.	NOUN
tahrj-8728	462	15	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	462	16	steiner	steiner	NOUN
tahrj-8728	462	17	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	462	18	t.	t.	PROPN
tahrj-8728	462	19	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	462	20	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	462	21	lang	lang	PROPN
tahrj-8728	462	22	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	462	23	a.	a.	PROPN
tahrj-8728	462	24	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	462	25	eds	ed	NOUN
tahrj-8728	462	26	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	462	27	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	462	28	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	462	29	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	462	30	action	action	NOUN
tahrj-8728	462	31	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	462	32	comparative	comparative	ADJ
tahrj-8728	462	33	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	462	34	empirical	empirical	ADJ
tahrj-8728	462	35	perspectives	perspective	NOUN
tahrj-8728	462	36	on	on	ADP
tahrj-8728	462	37	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	462	38	judicial	judicial	ADJ
tahrj-8728	462	39	practice	practice	NOUN
tahrj-8728	462	40	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	463	1	cambridge	cambridge	PROPN
tahrj-8728	463	2	studies	study	NOUN
tahrj-8728	463	3	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	463	4	constitutional	constitutional	ADJ
tahrj-8728	463	5	law	law	NOUN
tahrj-8728	463	6	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	464	1	cambridge	cambridge	PROPN
tahrj-8728	464	2	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	464	3	cambridge	cambridge	PROPN
tahrj-8728	464	4	university	university	PROPN
tahrj-8728	464	5	press	press	NOUN
tahrj-8728	464	6	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	464	7	pp	pp	ADJ
tahrj-8728	464	8	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	465	1	458541	458541	NUM
tahrj-8728	465	2	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	466	1	https://doi.org/10.1017/9781108596268.009	https://doi.org/10.1017/9781108596268.009	PROPN
tahrj-8728	466	2	gilbert	gilbert	PROPN
tahrj-8728	466	3	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	466	4	g.	g.	PROPN
tahrj-8728	466	5	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	466	6	2003	2003	NUM
tahrj-8728	466	7	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	466	8	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	467	1	‘	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	467	2	current	current	ADJ
tahrj-8728	467	3	issues	issue	NOUN
tahrj-8728	467	4	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	467	5	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	467	6	application	application	NOUN
tahrj-8728	467	7	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	467	8	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	467	9	exclusion	exclusion	NOUN
tahrj-8728	467	10	clauses	clause	NOUN
tahrj-8728	467	11	’	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	467	12	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	467	13	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	467	14	feller	feller	NOUN
tahrj-8728	467	15	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	467	16	e.	e.	PROPN
tahrj-8728	467	17	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	467	18	turk	turk	PROPN
tahrj-8728	467	19	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	467	20	v.	v.	ADV
tahrj-8728	467	21	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	467	22	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	467	23	nicholson	nicholson	PROPN
tahrj-8728	467	24	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	467	25	f.	f.	PROPN
tahrj-8728	467	26	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	467	27	eds	eds	PROPN
tahrj-8728	467	28	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	467	29	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	468	1	refugee	refugee	NOUN
tahrj-8728	468	2	protection	protection	NOUN
tahrj-8728	468	3	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	468	4	international	international	ADJ
tahrj-8728	468	5	law	law	NOUN
tahrj-8728	468	6	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	468	7	unhcr	unhcr	PROPN
tahrj-8728	468	8	’s	’s	PART
tahrj-8728	468	9	global	global	ADJ
tahrj-8728	468	10	consultations	consultation	NOUN
tahrj-8728	468	11	on	on	ADP
tahrj-8728	468	12	international	international	ADJ
tahrj-8728	468	13	protection	protection	NOUN
tahrj-8728	468	14	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	469	1	cambridge	cambridge	PROPN
tahrj-8728	469	2	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	469	3	cambridge	cambridge	PROPN
tahrj-8728	469	4	university	university	PROPN
tahrj-8728	469	5	press	press	NOUN
tahrj-8728	469	6	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	469	7	pp	pp	X
tahrj-8728	469	8	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	470	1	425	425	NUM
tahrj-8728	470	2	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	471	1	https://doi.org/10.1017/	https://doi.org/10.1017/	ADJ
tahrj-8728	471	2	cbo9780511493973.023	cbo9780511493973.023	PROPN
tahrj-8728	471	3	hunt	hunt	NOUN
tahrj-8728	471	4	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	471	5	m.	m.	NOUN
tahrj-8728	471	6	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	471	7	2009	2009	NUM
tahrj-8728	471	8	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	471	9	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	472	1	‘	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	472	2	against	against	ADP
tahrj-8728	472	3	bifurcation	bifurcation	NOUN
tahrj-8728	472	4	’	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	472	5	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	472	6	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	472	7	dyzenhaus	dyzenhaus	PROPN
tahrj-8728	472	8	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	472	9	d.	d.	PROPN
tahrj-8728	472	10	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	472	11	hunt	hunt	NOUN
tahrj-8728	472	12	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	472	13	m.	m.	NOUN
tahrj-8728	472	14	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	472	15	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	472	16	huscroft	huscroft	ADV
tahrj-8728	472	17	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	472	18	g.	g.	PROPN
tahrj-8728	472	19	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	472	20	eds	eds	PROPN
tahrj-8728	472	21	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	472	22	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	473	1	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	473	2	simple	simple	ADJ
tahrj-8728	473	3	common	common	ADJ
tahrj-8728	473	4	lawyer	lawyer	NOUN
tahrj-8728	473	5	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	473	6	essays	essay	NOUN
tahrj-8728	473	7	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	473	8	honour	honour	NOUN
tahrj-8728	473	9	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	473	10	michael	michael	PROPN
tahrj-8728	473	11	taggart	taggart	PROPN
tahrj-8728	473	12	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	474	1	oxford	oxford	PROPN
tahrj-8728	474	2	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	474	3	hart	hart	PROPN
tahrj-8728	474	4	publishing	publishing	PROPN
tahrj-8728	474	5	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	474	6	pp	pp	ADJ
tahrj-8728	474	7	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	475	1	99	99	NUM
tahrj-8728	475	2	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	476	1	knight	knight	PROPN
tahrj-8728	476	2	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	476	3	d.	d.	PROPN
tahrj-8728	476	4	r.	r.	PROPN
tahrj-8728	476	5	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	476	6	2008	2008	NUM
tahrj-8728	476	7	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	476	8	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	477	1	‘	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	477	2	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	477	3	murky	murky	ADJ
tahrj-8728	477	4	methodology	methodology	NOUN
tahrj-8728	477	5	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	477	6	standards	standard	NOUN
tahrj-8728	477	7	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	477	8	review	review	NOUN
tahrj-8728	477	9	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	477	10	administrative	administrative	ADJ
tahrj-8728	477	11	law	law	NOUN
tahrj-8728	477	12	’	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	477	13	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	477	14	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	477	15	geiringer	geiringer	NOUN
tahrj-8728	477	16	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	477	17	c.	c.	PROPN
tahrj-8728	477	18	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	477	19	knight	knight	PROPN
tahrj-8728	477	20	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	477	21	d.	d.	PROPN
tahrj-8728	477	22	r.	r.	PROPN
tahrj-8728	477	23	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	477	24	eds	eds	PROPN
tahrj-8728	477	25	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	477	26	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	478	1	seeing	see	VERB
tahrj-8728	478	2	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	478	3	world	world	NOUN
tahrj-8728	478	4	whole	whole	NOUN
tahrj-8728	478	5	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	478	6	https://doi.org/10.17561/tahrj.v23.8728	https://doi.org/10.17561/tahrj.v23.8728	PROPN
tahrj-8728	478	7	https://doi.org/10.1163/9789004633599_017	https://doi.org/10.1163/9789004633599_017	PROPN
tahrj-8728	478	8	https://doi.org/10.1163/9789004633599_017	https://doi.org/10.1163/9789004633599_017	PROPN
tahrj-8728	478	9	https://doi.org/10.1017/9781108596268.009	https://doi.org/10.1017/9781108596268.009	PROPN
tahrj-8728	478	10	https://doi.org/10.1017/cbo9780511493973.023	https://doi.org/10.1017/cbo9780511493973.023	PROPN
tahrj-8728	478	11	https://doi.org/10.1017/cbo9780511493973.023	https://doi.org/10.1017/cbo9780511493973.023	NOUN
tahrj-8728	478	12	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	478	13	analysis	analysis	NOUN
tahrj-8728	478	14	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	478	15	non	non	ADJ
tahrj-8728	478	16	-	-	ADJ
tahrj-8728	478	17	refoulement	refoulement	ADJ
tahrj-8728	478	18	jurisprudence	jurisprudence	NOUN
tahrj-8728	478	19	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	478	20	india	india	PROPN
tahrj-8728	478	21	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	478	22	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	478	23	comparative	comparative	ADJ
tahrj-8728	478	24	approach	approach	NOUN
tahrj-8728	478	25	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	478	26	age	age	NOUN
tahrj-8728	478	27	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	478	28	human	human	ADJ
tahrj-8728	478	29	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	478	30	journal	journal	NOUN
tahrj-8728	478	31	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	478	32	24	24	NUM
tahrj-8728	478	33	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	478	34	june	june	PROPN
tahrj-8728	478	35	2025	2025	NUM
tahrj-8728	478	36	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	478	37	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	478	38	e8728	e8728	PROPN
tahrj-8728	478	39	issn	issn	PROPN
tahrj-8728	478	40	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	478	41	2340	2340	NUM
tahrj-8728	478	42	-	-	SYM
tahrj-8728	478	43	9592	9592	NUM
tahrj-8728	478	44	doi	doi	NOUN
tahrj-8728	478	45	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	478	46	10.17561	10.17561	NUM
tahrj-8728	478	47	/	/	SYM
tahrj-8728	478	48	tahrj.v23.8728	tahrj.v23.8728	PROPN
tahrj-8728	478	49	24	24	NUM
tahrj-8728	478	50	essays	essay	NOUN
tahrj-8728	478	51	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	478	52	honour	honour	NOUN
tahrj-8728	478	53	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	478	54	sir	sir	PROPN
tahrj-8728	478	55	kenneth	kenneth	PROPN
tahrj-8728	478	56	keith	keith	PROPN
tahrj-8728	478	57	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	479	1	wellington	wellington	PROPN
tahrj-8728	479	2	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	479	3	victoria	victoria	PROPN
tahrj-8728	479	4	university	university	PROPN
tahrj-8728	479	5	press	press	NOUN
tahrj-8728	479	6	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	479	7	pp	pp	ADJ
tahrj-8728	479	8	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	480	1	180	180	NUM
tahrj-8728	480	2	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	480	3	lauterpacht	lauterpacht	PROPN
tahrj-8728	480	4	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	480	5	s.	s.	PROPN
tahrj-8728	480	6	e.	e.	PROPN
tahrj-8728	480	7	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	480	8	bethlehem	bethlehem	PROPN
tahrj-8728	480	9	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	480	10	d.	d.	PROPN
tahrj-8728	480	11	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	480	12	2009	2009	NUM
tahrj-8728	480	13	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	480	14	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	481	1	‘	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	481	2	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	481	3	scope	scope	NOUN
tahrj-8728	481	4	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	481	5	content	content	NOUN
tahrj-8728	481	6	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	481	7	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	481	8	principle	principle	NOUN
tahrj-8728	481	9	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	481	10	non	non	ADJ
tahrj-8728	481	11	-	-	ADJ
tahrj-8728	481	12	refoulement	refoulement	ADJ
tahrj-8728	481	13	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	481	14	opinion	opinion	NOUN
tahrj-8728	481	15	’	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	481	16	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	481	17	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	481	18	feller	feller	NOUN
tahrj-8728	481	19	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	481	20	e.	e.	PROPN
tahrj-8728	481	21	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	481	22	turk	turk	PROPN
tahrj-8728	481	23	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	481	24	v.	v.	ADV
tahrj-8728	481	25	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	481	26	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	481	27	nicholson	nicholson	PROPN
tahrj-8728	481	28	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	481	29	f.	f.	PROPN
tahrj-8728	481	30	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	481	31	eds	eds	PROPN
tahrj-8728	481	32	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	481	33	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	482	1	refugee	refugee	NOUN
tahrj-8728	482	2	protection	protection	NOUN
tahrj-8728	482	3	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	482	4	international	international	ADJ
tahrj-8728	482	5	law	law	NOUN
tahrj-8728	482	6	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	483	1	cambridge	cambridge	PROPN
tahrj-8728	483	2	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	483	3	cambridge	cambridge	PROPN
tahrj-8728	483	4	university	university	PROPN
tahrj-8728	483	5	press	press	NOUN
tahrj-8728	483	6	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	483	7	pp	pp	ADJ
tahrj-8728	483	8	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	484	1	87	87	NUM
tahrj-8728	484	2	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	485	1	https://doi.org/10.1017/	https://doi.org/10.1017/	PROPN
tahrj-8728	485	2	cbo9780511493973.008	cbo9780511493973.008	PROPN
tahrj-8728	485	3	lixinski	lixinski	ADJ
tahrj-8728	485	4	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	485	5	l.	l.	PROPN
tahrj-8728	485	6	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	485	7	2019	2019	NUM
tahrj-8728	485	8	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	485	9	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	486	1	‘	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	486	2	balancing	balance	VERB
tahrj-8728	486	3	test	test	NOUN
tahrj-8728	486	4	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	486	5	inter	inter	ADJ
tahrj-8728	486	6	-	-	ADJ
tahrj-8728	486	7	american	american	ADJ
tahrj-8728	486	8	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	486	9	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	486	10	human	human	ADJ
tahrj-8728	486	11	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	486	12	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	486	13	iacthr	iacthr	PROPN
tahrj-8728	486	14	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	486	15	’	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	486	16	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	486	17	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	486	18	fabri	fabri	PROPN
tahrj-8728	486	19	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	486	20	h.	h.	PROPN
tahrj-8728	486	21	r.	r.	PROPN
tahrj-8728	486	22	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	486	23	ed	ed	NOUN
tahrj-8728	486	24	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	486	25	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	487	1	max	max	PROPN
tahrj-8728	487	2	planck	planck	PROPN
tahrj-8728	487	3	encyclopedia	encyclopedia	NOUN
tahrj-8728	487	4	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	487	5	international	international	ADJ
tahrj-8728	487	6	procedural	procedural	ADJ
tahrj-8728	487	7	law	law	NOUN
tahrj-8728	487	8	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	488	1	oxford	oxford	NOUN
tahrj-8728	488	2	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	488	3	oxford	oxford	PROPN
tahrj-8728	488	4	university	university	PROPN
tahrj-8728	488	5	press	press	NOUN
tahrj-8728	488	6	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	489	1	https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.4253276	https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.4253276	PROPN
tahrj-8728	489	2	takis	takis	PROPN
tahrj-8728	489	3	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	489	4	t.	t.	PROPN
tahrj-8728	489	5	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	489	6	2018	2018	NUM
tahrj-8728	489	7	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	489	8	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	490	1	‘	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	490	2	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	490	3	principle	principle	NOUN
tahrj-8728	490	4	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	490	5	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	490	6	’	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	490	7	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	490	8	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	490	9	schutze	schutze	ADJ
tahrj-8728	490	10	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	490	11	r.	r.	PROPN
tahrj-8728	490	12	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	490	13	tridimas	tridima	NOUN
tahrj-8728	490	14	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	490	15	t.	t.	PROPN
tahrj-8728	490	16	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	490	17	eds	eds	PROPN
tahrj-8728	490	18	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	490	19	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	491	1	oxford	oxford	ADJ
tahrj-8728	491	2	principles	principle	NOUN
tahrj-8728	491	3	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	491	4	european	european	PROPN
tahrj-8728	491	5	union	union	PROPN
tahrj-8728	491	6	law	law	NOUN
tahrj-8728	491	7	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	491	8	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	491	9	european	european	ADJ
tahrj-8728	491	10	legal	legal	ADJ
tahrj-8728	491	11	order	order	NOUN
tahrj-8728	491	12	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	492	1	united	united	PROPN
tahrj-8728	492	2	kingdom	kingdom	PROPN
tahrj-8728	492	3	;	;	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	492	4	online	online	ADJ
tahrj-8728	492	5	edn	edn	NOUN
tahrj-8728	492	6	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	492	7	oxford	oxford	PROPN
tahrj-8728	492	8	academic	academic	NOUN
tahrj-8728	492	9	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	493	1	journal	journal	PROPN
tahrj-8728	493	2	articles	articles	PROPN
tahrj-8728	493	3	alexander	alexander	PROPN
tahrj-8728	493	4	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	493	5	a.	a.	NOUN
tahrj-8728	493	6	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	493	7	2021	2021	NUM
tahrj-8728	493	8	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	493	9	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	494	1	‘	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	494	2	critical	critical	ADJ
tahrj-8728	494	3	analysis	analysis	NOUN
tahrj-8728	494	4	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	494	5	mohammad	mohammad	PROPN
tahrj-8728	494	6	salimullah	salimullah	PROPN
tahrj-8728	494	7	v.	v.	ADP
tahrj-8728	494	8	union	union	PROPN
tahrj-8728	494	9	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	494	10	india	india	PROPN
tahrj-8728	494	11	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	494	12	has	have	VERB
tahrj-8728	494	13	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	494	14	supreme	supreme	PROPN
tahrj-8728	494	15	court	court	PROPN
tahrj-8728	494	16	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	494	17	india	india	PROPN
tahrj-8728	494	18	acted	act	VERB
tahrj-8728	494	19	as	as	ADP
tahrj-8728	494	20	executive	executive	NOUN
tahrj-8728	494	21	?	?	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	494	22	’	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	494	23	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	494	24	cmr	cmr	PROPN
tahrj-8728	494	25	university	university	PROPN
tahrj-8728	494	26	journal	journal	NOUN
tahrj-8728	494	27	for	for	ADP
tahrj-8728	494	28	contemporary	contemporary	ADJ
tahrj-8728	494	29	legal	legal	ADJ
tahrj-8728	494	30	affairs	affair	NOUN
tahrj-8728	494	31	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	495	1	balakrishnan	balakrishnan	PROPN
tahrj-8728	495	2	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	495	3	k.	k.	PROPN
tahrj-8728	495	4	g.	g.	PROPN
tahrj-8728	495	5	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	495	6	2010	2010	NUM
tahrj-8728	495	7	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	495	8	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	496	1	‘	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	496	2	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	496	3	role	role	NOUN
tahrj-8728	496	4	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	496	5	foreign	foreign	ADJ
tahrj-8728	496	6	precedents	precedent	NOUN
tahrj-8728	496	7	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	496	8	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	496	9	country	country	NOUN
tahrj-8728	496	10	's	's	PART
tahrj-8728	496	11	legal	legal	ADJ
tahrj-8728	496	12	system	system	NOUN
tahrj-8728	496	13	’	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	496	14	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	496	15	national	national	ADJ
tahrj-8728	496	16	law	law	NOUN
tahrj-8728	496	17	school	school	NOUN
tahrj-8728	496	18	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	496	19	india	india	PROPN
tahrj-8728	496	20	review	review	PROPN
tahrj-8728	496	21	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	496	22	22	22	NUM
tahrj-8728	496	23	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	496	24	1	1	NUM
tahrj-8728	496	25	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	496	26	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	496	27	pp	pp	ADJ
tahrj-8728	496	28	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	497	1	1	1	NUM
tahrj-8728	497	2	-	-	SYM
tahrj-8728	497	3	16	16	NUM
tahrj-8728	497	4	craig	craig	NOUN
tahrj-8728	497	5	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	497	6	p.	p.	NOUN
tahrj-8728	497	7	p.	p.	NOUN
tahrj-8728	497	8	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	497	9	2010	2010	NUM
tahrj-8728	497	10	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	497	11	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	498	1	‘	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	498	2	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	498	3	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	498	4	rationality	rationality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	498	5	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	498	6	review	review	NOUN
tahrj-8728	498	7	’	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	498	8	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	498	9	new	new	PROPN
tahrj-8728	498	10	zealand	zealand	PROPN
tahrj-8728	498	11	law	law	PROPN
tahrj-8728	498	12	review	review	NOUN
tahrj-8728	498	13	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	498	14	p.	p.	NOUN
tahrj-8728	498	15	265	265	NUM
tahrj-8728	498	16	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	499	1	elliott	elliott	PROPN
tahrj-8728	499	2	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	499	3	m.	m.	NOUN
tahrj-8728	499	4	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	499	5	2001	2001	NUM
tahrj-8728	499	6	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	499	7	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	500	1	‘	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	500	2	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	500	3	human	human	ADJ
tahrj-8728	500	4	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	500	5	act	act	NOUN
tahrj-8728	500	6	1998	1998	NUM
tahrj-8728	500	7	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	500	8	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	500	9	standard	standard	NOUN
tahrj-8728	500	10	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	500	11	substantive	substantive	ADJ
tahrj-8728	500	12	review	review	NOUN
tahrj-8728	500	13	’	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	500	14	cambridge	cambridge	PROPN
tahrj-8728	500	15	law	law	PROPN
tahrj-8728	500	16	journal	journal	NOUN
tahrj-8728	500	17	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	500	18	60	60	NUM
tahrj-8728	500	19	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	500	20	p.	p.	NOUN
tahrj-8728	500	21	301	301	NUM
tahrj-8728	500	22	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	501	1	hathaway	hathaway	PROPN
tahrj-8728	501	2	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	501	3	j.	j.	PROPN
tahrj-8728	501	4	c.	c.	PROPN
tahrj-8728	501	5	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	501	6	harvey	harvey	PROPN
tahrj-8728	501	7	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	501	8	c.	c.	PROPN
tahrj-8728	501	9	j.	j.	PROPN
tahrj-8728	501	10	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	501	11	2001	2001	NUM
tahrj-8728	501	12	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	501	13	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	502	1	‘	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	502	2	framing	frame	VERB
tahrj-8728	502	3	refugee	refugee	NOUN
tahrj-8728	502	4	protection	protection	NOUN
tahrj-8728	502	5	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	502	6	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	502	7	new	new	ADJ
tahrj-8728	502	8	world	world	NOUN
tahrj-8728	502	9	disorder	disorder	NOUN
tahrj-8728	502	10	’	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	502	11	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	502	12	cornell	cornell	PROPN
tahrj-8728	502	13	international	international	ADJ
tahrj-8728	502	14	law	law	PROPN
tahrj-8728	502	15	journal	journal	NOUN
tahrj-8728	502	16	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	502	17	34	34	NUM
tahrj-8728	502	18	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	502	19	pp	pp	ADJ
tahrj-8728	502	20	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	503	1	257	257	NUM
tahrj-8728	503	2	-	-	SYM
tahrj-8728	503	3	320	320	NUM
tahrj-8728	503	4	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	504	1	knight	knight	PROPN
tahrj-8728	504	2	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	504	3	d.	d.	PROPN
tahrj-8728	504	4	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	504	5	2010	2010	NUM
tahrj-8728	504	6	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	504	7	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	505	1	‘	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	505	2	mapping	map	VERB
tahrj-8728	505	3	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	505	4	rainbow	rainbow	NOUN
tahrj-8728	505	5	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	505	6	review	review	NOUN
tahrj-8728	505	7	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	505	8	recognising	recognise	VERB
tahrj-8728	505	9	variable	variable	ADJ
tahrj-8728	505	10	intensity	intensity	NOUN
tahrj-8728	505	11	’	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	505	12	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	505	13	new	new	PROPN
tahrj-8728	505	14	zealand	zealand	PROPN
tahrj-8728	505	15	law	law	PROPN
tahrj-8728	505	16	review	review	NOUN
tahrj-8728	505	17	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	505	18	p.	p.	NOUN
tahrj-8728	505	19	393	393	NUM
tahrj-8728	505	20	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	506	1	mavronicola	mavronicola	PROPN
tahrj-8728	506	2	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	506	3	n.	n.	NOUN
tahrj-8728	506	4	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	506	5	messineo	messineo	NOUN
tahrj-8728	506	6	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	506	7	f.	f.	PROPN
tahrj-8728	506	8	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	506	9	2013	2013	NUM
tahrj-8728	506	10	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	506	11	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	507	1	‘	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	507	2	relatively	relatively	ADV
tahrj-8728	507	3	absolute	absolute	ADJ
tahrj-8728	507	4	?	?	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	508	1	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	508	2	undermining	undermining	NOUN
tahrj-8728	508	3	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	508	4	article	article	NOUN
tahrj-8728	508	5	3	3	NUM
tahrj-8728	508	6	echr	echr	PROPN
tahrj-8728	508	7	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	508	8	ahmad	ahmad	PROPN
tahrj-8728	508	9	v	v	ADP
tahrj-8728	508	10	uk	uk	PROPN
tahrj-8728	508	11	’	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	508	12	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	508	13	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	508	14	modern	modern	ADJ
tahrj-8728	508	15	law	law	NOUN
tahrj-8728	508	16	review	review	NOUN
tahrj-8728	508	17	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	508	18	76(6	76(6	NOUN
tahrj-8728	508	19	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	508	20	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	508	21	pp	pp	PROPN
tahrj-8728	508	22	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	508	23	10251048	10251048	NUM
tahrj-8728	508	24	mcharg	mcharg	NOUN
tahrj-8728	508	25	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	508	26	a.	a.	NOUN
tahrj-8728	508	27	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	508	28	1999	1999	NUM
tahrj-8728	508	29	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	508	30	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	509	1	‘	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	509	2	reconciling	reconcile	VERB
tahrj-8728	509	3	human	human	ADJ
tahrj-8728	509	4	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	509	5	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	509	6	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	509	7	public	public	ADJ
tahrj-8728	509	8	interest	interest	NOUN
tahrj-8728	509	9	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	509	10	conceptual	conceptual	ADJ
tahrj-8728	509	11	problems	problem	NOUN
tahrj-8728	509	12	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	509	13	doctrinal	doctrinal	ADJ
tahrj-8728	509	14	uncertainty	uncertainty	NOUN
tahrj-8728	509	15	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	509	16	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	509	17	jurisprudence	jurisprudence	NOUN
tahrj-8728	509	18	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	509	19	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	509	20	european	european	PROPN
tahrj-8728	509	21	court	court	PROPN
tahrj-8728	509	22	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	509	23	human	human	ADJ
tahrj-8728	509	24	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	509	25	’	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	509	26	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	509	27	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	509	28	modern	modern	ADJ
tahrj-8728	509	29	law	law	NOUN
tahrj-8728	509	30	review	review	NOUN
tahrj-8728	509	31	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	509	32	62(5	62(5	NOUN
tahrj-8728	509	33	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	509	34	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	509	35	pp	pp	PROPN
tahrj-8728	509	36	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	510	1	671	671	NUM
tahrj-8728	510	2	-	-	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	510	3	696	696	NUM
tahrj-8728	510	4	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	511	1	mullan	mullan	PROPN
tahrj-8728	511	2	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	511	3	d.	d.	PROPN
tahrj-8728	511	4	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	511	5	2010	2010	NUM
tahrj-8728	511	6	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	511	7	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	512	1	‘	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	512	2	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	512	3	—	—	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	512	4	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	512	5	proportionate	proportionate	ADJ
tahrj-8728	512	6	response	response	NOUN
tahrj-8728	512	7	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	512	8	an	an	DET
tahrj-8728	512	9	emerging	emerge	VERB
tahrj-8728	512	10	crisis	crisis	NOUN
tahrj-8728	512	11	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	512	12	canadian	canadian	ADJ
tahrj-8728	512	13	judicial	judicial	ADJ
tahrj-8728	512	14	review	review	NOUN
tahrj-8728	512	15	law	law	NOUN
tahrj-8728	512	16	?	?	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	512	17	’	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	512	18	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	512	19	new	new	PROPN
tahrj-8728	512	20	zealand	zealand	PROPN
tahrj-8728	512	21	law	law	PROPN
tahrj-8728	512	22	review	review	PROPN
tahrj-8728	512	23	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	512	24	233	233	NUM
tahrj-8728	512	25	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	513	1	https://doi.org/10.17561/tahrj.v23.8728	https://doi.org/10.17561/tahrj.v23.8728	PROPN
tahrj-8728	513	2	https://doi.org/10.1017/cbo9780511493973.008	https://doi.org/10.1017/cbo9780511493973.008	PROPN
tahrj-8728	513	3	https://doi.org/10.1017/cbo9780511493973.008	https://doi.org/10.1017/cbo9780511493973.008	PROPN
tahrj-8728	513	4	https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.4253276	https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.4253276	PROPN
tahrj-8728	513	5	sabreen	sabreen	PROPN
tahrj-8728	513	6	ahmed	ahme	VERB
tahrj-8728	513	7	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	513	8	age	age	NOUN
tahrj-8728	513	9	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	513	10	human	human	ADJ
tahrj-8728	513	11	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	513	12	journal	journal	NOUN
tahrj-8728	513	13	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	513	14	24	24	NUM
tahrj-8728	513	15	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	513	16	june	june	PROPN
tahrj-8728	513	17	2025	2025	NUM
tahrj-8728	513	18	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	513	19	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	513	20	e8728	e8728	PROPN
tahrj-8728	513	21	issn	issn	PROPN
tahrj-8728	513	22	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	513	23	2340	2340	NUM
tahrj-8728	513	24	-	-	SYM
tahrj-8728	513	25	9592	9592	NUM
tahrj-8728	513	26	doi	doi	NOUN
tahrj-8728	513	27	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	513	28	10.17561	10.17561	NUM
tahrj-8728	513	29	/	/	SYM
tahrj-8728	513	30	tahrj.v23.8728	tahrj.v23.8728	PROPN
tahrj-8728	513	31	25	25	NUM
tahrj-8728	513	32	sales	sale	NOUN
tahrj-8728	513	33	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	513	34	p.	p.	NOUN
tahrj-8728	513	35	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	513	36	steyn	steyn	PROPN
tahrj-8728	513	37	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	513	38	k.	k.	PROPN
tahrj-8728	513	39	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	513	40	2004	2004	NUM
tahrj-8728	513	41	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	513	42	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	514	1	‘	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	514	2	legitimate	legitimate	ADJ
tahrj-8728	514	3	expectations	expectation	NOUN
tahrj-8728	514	4	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	514	5	english	english	ADJ
tahrj-8728	514	6	public	public	ADJ
tahrj-8728	514	7	law	law	NOUN
tahrj-8728	514	8	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	514	9	an	an	DET
tahrj-8728	514	10	analysis	analysis	NOUN
tahrj-8728	514	11	’	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	514	12	public	public	ADJ
tahrj-8728	514	13	law	law	NOUN
tahrj-8728	514	14	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	514	15	pp	pp	ADP
tahrj-8728	514	16	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	515	1	588–591	588–591	NUM
tahrj-8728	515	2	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	515	3	scovazzi	scovazzi	PROPN
tahrj-8728	515	4	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	515	5	t.	t.	PROPN
tahrj-8728	515	6	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	515	7	2016	2016	NUM
tahrj-8728	515	8	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	515	9	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	516	1	‘	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	516	2	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	516	3	effect	effect	NOUN
tahrj-8728	516	4	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	516	5	european	european	ADJ
tahrj-8728	516	6	court	court	PROPN
tahrj-8728	516	7	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	516	8	human	human	ADJ
tahrj-8728	516	9	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	516	10	case	case	NOUN
tahrj-8728	516	11	law	law	NOUN
tahrj-8728	516	12	on	on	ADP
tahrj-8728	516	13	domestic	domestic	ADJ
tahrj-8728	516	14	courts	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	516	15	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	516	16	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	516	17	review	review	NOUN
tahrj-8728	516	18	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	516	19	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	516	20	literature	literature	NOUN
tahrj-8728	516	21	’	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	516	22	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	516	23	european	european	PROPN
tahrj-8728	516	24	journal	journal	PROPN
tahrj-8728	516	25	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	516	26	international	international	ADJ
tahrj-8728	516	27	law	law	NOUN
tahrj-8728	516	28	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	516	29	p.	p.	NOUN
tahrj-8728	516	30	74	74	NUM
tahrj-8728	516	31	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	517	1	slaughter	slaughter	NOUN
tahrj-8728	517	2	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	517	3	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	517	4	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	517	5	1994	1994	NUM
tahrj-8728	517	6	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	517	7	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	518	1	‘	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	518	2	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	518	3	typology	typology	NOUN
tahrj-8728	518	4	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	518	5	transjudicial	transjudicial	ADJ
tahrj-8728	518	6	communication	communication	NOUN
tahrj-8728	518	7	’	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	518	8	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	518	9	university	university	PROPN
tahrj-8728	518	10	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	518	11	richmond	richmond	PROPN
tahrj-8728	518	12	law	law	PROPN
tahrj-8728	518	13	review	review	NOUN
tahrj-8728	518	14	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	518	15	29	29	NUM
tahrj-8728	518	16	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	518	17	p.	p.	NOUN
tahrj-8728	518	18	99	99	NUM
tahrj-8728	518	19	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	519	1	srirangam	srirangam	PROPN
tahrj-8728	519	2	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	519	3	v.	v.	PROPN
tahrj-8728	519	4	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	519	5	2016	2016	NUM
tahrj-8728	519	6	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	519	7	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	520	1	‘	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	520	2	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	520	3	difference	difference	NOUN
tahrj-8728	520	4	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	520	5	kind	kind	ADJ
tahrj-8728	520	6	–	–	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	520	7	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	520	8	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	520	9	wednesbury	wednesbury	PROPN
tahrj-8728	520	10	’	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	520	11	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	520	12	international	international	ADJ
tahrj-8728	520	13	sustainable	sustainable	ADJ
tahrj-8728	520	14	law	law	NOUN
tahrj-8728	520	15	review	review	NOUN
tahrj-8728	520	16	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	520	17	4	4	NUM
tahrj-8728	520	18	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	520	19	doi	doi	NOUN
tahrj-8728	520	20	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	520	21	10.14296	10.14296	NUM
tahrj-8728	520	22	/	/	SYM
tahrj-8728	520	23	islr.v4i1.2335	islr.v4i1.2335	NOUN
tahrj-8728	520	24	.	.	NOUN
tahrj-8728	520	25	sweet	sweet	ADJ
tahrj-8728	520	26	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	520	27	a.s	a.s	PROPN
tahrj-8728	520	28	.	.	PROPN
tahrj-8728	520	29	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	520	30	mathews	mathews	PROPN
tahrj-8728	520	31	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	520	32	j.	j.	PROPN
tahrj-8728	520	33	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	520	34	2008	2008	NUM
tahrj-8728	520	35	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	520	36	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	521	1	‘	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	521	2	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	521	3	balancing	balancing	NOUN
tahrj-8728	521	4	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	521	5	global	global	ADJ
tahrj-8728	521	6	constitutionalism	constitutionalism	NOUN
tahrj-8728	521	7	’	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	521	8	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	521	9	columbia	columbia	PROPN
tahrj-8728	521	10	journal	journal	PROPN
tahrj-8728	521	11	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	521	12	transnational	transnational	ADJ
tahrj-8728	521	13	law	law	NOUN
tahrj-8728	521	14	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	521	15	47	47	NUM
tahrj-8728	521	16	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	521	17	pp	pp	ADJ
tahrj-8728	521	18	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	522	1	68	68	NUM
tahrj-8728	522	2	-	-	SYM
tahrj-8728	522	3	149	149	NUM
tahrj-8728	522	4	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	523	1	taggart	taggart	NOUN
tahrj-8728	523	2	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	523	3	m.	m.	NOUN
tahrj-8728	523	4	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	523	5	2008	2008	NUM
tahrj-8728	523	6	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	523	7	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	524	1	‘	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	524	2	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	524	3	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	524	4	deference	deference	NOUN
tahrj-8728	524	5	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	524	6	wednesbury	wednesbury	PROPN
tahrj-8728	524	7	’	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	524	8	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	524	9	new	new	PROPN
tahrj-8728	524	10	zealand	zealand	PROPN
tahrj-8728	524	11	law	law	PROPN
tahrj-8728	524	12	review	review	NOUN
tahrj-8728	524	13	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	524	14	p.	p.	NOUN
tahrj-8728	524	15	423	423	NUM
tahrj-8728	524	16	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	525	1	teferra	teferra	NOUN
tahrj-8728	525	2	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	525	3	z.	z.	PROPN
tahrj-8728	525	4	m.	m.	PROPN
tahrj-8728	525	5	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	525	6	2018	2018	NUM
tahrj-8728	525	7	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	525	8	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	526	1	‘	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	526	2	revisiting	revisit	VERB
tahrj-8728	526	3	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	526	4	rule	rule	NOUN
tahrj-8728	526	5	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	526	6	non	non	ADJ
tahrj-8728	526	7	-	-	ADJ
tahrj-8728	526	8	refoulement	refoulement	ADJ
tahrj-8728	526	9	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	526	10	its	its	PRON
tahrj-8728	526	11	exceptions	exception	NOUN
tahrj-8728	526	12	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	526	13	does	do	AUX
tahrj-8728	526	14	article	article	NOUN
tahrj-8728	526	15	33(2	33(2	NUM
tahrj-8728	526	16	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	526	17	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	526	18	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	526	19	1951	1951	NUM
tahrj-8728	526	20	refugee	refugee	NOUN
tahrj-8728	526	21	convention	convention	NOUN
tahrj-8728	526	22	require	require	VERB
tahrj-8728	526	23	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	526	24	application	application	NOUN
tahrj-8728	526	25	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	526	26	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	526	27	principle	principle	NOUN
tahrj-8728	526	28	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	526	29	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	526	30	?	?	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	526	31	’	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	526	32	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	526	33	african	african	ADJ
tahrj-8728	526	34	yearbook	yearbook	NOUN
tahrj-8728	526	35	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	526	36	international	international	ADJ
tahrj-8728	526	37	law	law	NOUN
tahrj-8728	526	38	online	online	NOUN
tahrj-8728	526	39	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	526	40	23(1	23(1	NOUN
tahrj-8728	526	41	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	526	42	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	526	43	pp	pp	PROPN
tahrj-8728	526	44	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	527	1	304	304	NUM
tahrj-8728	527	2	-	-	SYM
tahrj-8728	527	3	332	332	NUM
tahrj-8728	527	4	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	528	1	webpages	webpage	NOUN
tahrj-8728	528	2	/	/	SYM
tahrj-8728	528	3	websites	website	NOUN
tahrj-8728	528	4	/	/	SYM
tahrj-8728	528	5	other	other	ADJ
tahrj-8728	528	6	media	medium	NOUN
tahrj-8728	528	7	chandra	chandra	PROPN
tahrj-8728	528	8	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	528	9	a.	a.	NOUN
tahrj-8728	528	10	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	528	11	2004	2004	NUM
tahrj-8728	528	12	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	528	13	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	529	1	‘	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	529	2	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	529	3	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	529	4	india	india	PROPN
tahrj-8728	529	5	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	529	6	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	529	7	bridge	bridge	NOUN
tahrj-8728	529	8	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	529	9	nowhere	nowhere	ADV
tahrj-8728	529	10	’	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	529	11	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	529	12	oxford	oxford	PROPN
tahrj-8728	529	13	human	human	ADJ
tahrj-8728	529	14	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	529	15	hub	hub	NOUN
tahrj-8728	529	16	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	529	17	64	64	NUM
tahrj-8728	529	18	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	529	19	available	available	ADJ
tahrj-8728	529	20	at	at	ADP
tahrj-8728	529	21	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	529	22	https://ohrh.law.ox.ac.uk/proportionality-in-india-abridge-to-nowhere	https://ohrh.law.ox.ac.uk/proportionality-in-india-abridge-to-nowhere	PROPN
tahrj-8728	529	23	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	529	24	accessed	access	VERB
tahrj-8728	529	25	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	529	26	04.09.24	04.09.24	NOUN
tahrj-8728	529	27	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	529	28	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	530	1	frantziou	frantziou	PROPN
tahrj-8728	530	2	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	530	3	e.	e.	PROPN
tahrj-8728	530	4	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	530	5	2014	2014	NUM
tahrj-8728	530	6	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	530	7	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	531	1	‘	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	531	2	ucl	ucl	VERB
tahrj-8728	531	3	policy	policy	NOUN
tahrj-8728	531	4	briefing	briefing	PROPN
tahrj-8728	531	5	-	-	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	531	6	october	october	PROPN
tahrj-8728	531	7	2014	2014	NUM
tahrj-8728	531	8	;	;	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	531	9	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	531	10	margin	margin	NOUN
tahrj-8728	531	11	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	531	12	appreciation	appreciation	NOUN
tahrj-8728	531	13	doctrine	doctrine	NOUN
tahrj-8728	531	14	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	531	15	european	european	ADJ
tahrj-8728	531	16	human	human	ADJ
tahrj-8728	531	17	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	531	18	law	law	NOUN
tahrj-8728	531	19	’	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	531	20	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	532	1	ucl	ucl	PROPN
tahrj-8728	532	2	laws	law	NOUN
tahrj-8728	532	3	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	533	1	available	available	ADJ
tahrj-8728	533	2	at	at	ADP
tahrj-8728	533	3	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	533	4	https://www	https://www	PROPN
tahrj-8728	533	5	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	534	1	ucl.ac.uk/public-policy/sites/public-policy/files/migrated-files/european_human	ucl.ac.uk/public-policy/sites/public-policy/files/migrated-files/european_human	PROPN
tahrj-8728	535	1	_	_	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	535	2	rights_law.pdf	rights_law.pdf	NOUN
tahrj-8728	535	3	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	535	4	accessed	access	VERB
tahrj-8728	535	5	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	535	6	04.10.24	04.10.24	NOUN
tahrj-8728	535	7	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	535	8	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	536	1	kumar	kumar	PROPN
tahrj-8728	536	2	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	536	3	a.	a.	PROPN
tahrj-8728	536	4	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	536	5	2018	2018	NUM
tahrj-8728	536	6	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	536	7	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	537	1	‘	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	537	2	situating	situate	VERB
tahrj-8728	537	3	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	537	4	principle	principle	NOUN
tahrj-8728	537	5	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	537	6	non	non	ADJ
tahrj-8728	537	7	-	-	ADJ
tahrj-8728	537	8	refoulement	refoulement	ADJ
tahrj-8728	537	9	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	537	10	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	537	11	indian	indian	ADJ
tahrj-8728	537	12	legal	legal	ADJ
tahrj-8728	537	13	scenario	scenario	NOUN
tahrj-8728	537	14	’	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	537	15	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	538	1	social	social	ADJ
tahrj-8728	538	2	science	science	PROPN
tahrj-8728	538	3	research	research	NOUN
tahrj-8728	538	4	network	network	NOUN
tahrj-8728	538	5	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	539	1	available	available	ADJ
tahrj-8728	539	2	at	at	ADP
tahrj-8728	539	3	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	539	4	https://papers.ssrn	https://papers.ssrn	PROPN
tahrj-8728	539	5	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	539	6	com	com	NOUN
tahrj-8728	539	7	/	/	SYM
tahrj-8728	539	8	abstract=3316317	abstract=3316317	PROPN
tahrj-8728	539	9	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	539	10	accessed	access	VERB
tahrj-8728	539	11	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	539	12	02.10.24	02.10.24	NUM
tahrj-8728	539	13	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	539	14	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	540	1	un	un	PROPN
tahrj-8728	540	2	high	high	PROPN
tahrj-8728	540	3	commissioner	commissioner	NOUN
tahrj-8728	540	4	for	for	ADP
tahrj-8728	540	5	refugees	refugee	NOUN
tahrj-8728	540	6	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	540	7	unhcr	unhcr	PROPN
tahrj-8728	540	8	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	540	9	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	540	10	1997	1997	NUM
tahrj-8728	540	11	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	540	12	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	541	1	‘	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	541	2	unhcr	unhcr	PROPN
tahrj-8728	541	3	note	note	NOUN
tahrj-8728	541	4	on	on	ADP
tahrj-8728	541	5	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	541	6	principle	principle	NOUN
tahrj-8728	541	7	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	541	8	non	non	ADJ
tahrj-8728	541	9	-	-	ADJ
tahrj-8728	541	10	refoulement	refoulement	ADJ
tahrj-8728	541	11	’	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	541	12	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	542	1	available	available	ADJ
tahrj-8728	542	2	at	at	ADP
tahrj-8728	542	3	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	542	4	https://www.refworld.org/	https://www.refworld.org/	NOUN
tahrj-8728	542	5	docid/438c6d972.html	docid/438c6d972.html	PROPN
tahrj-8728	542	6	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	542	7	accessed	access	VERB
tahrj-8728	542	8	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	542	9	02.09.24	02.09.24	NOUN
tahrj-8728	542	10	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	542	11	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	543	1	conference	conference	NOUN
tahrj-8728	543	2	papers	paper	NOUN
tahrj-8728	543	3	sagüés	sagüés	VERB
tahrj-8728	543	4	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	543	5	p.	p.	PROPN
tahrj-8728	543	6	n.	n.	NOUN
tahrj-8728	543	7	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	543	8	2013	2013	NUM
tahrj-8728	543	9	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	543	10	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	544	1	‘	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	544	2	panel	panel	NOUN
tahrj-8728	544	3	i.	i.	PROPN
tahrj-8728	544	4	diálogo	diálogo	PROPN
tahrj-8728	544	5	jurisprudencial	jurisprudencial	PROPN
tahrj-8728	544	6	y	y	PROPN
tahrj-8728	544	7	control	control	PROPN
tahrj-8728	544	8	de	de	PROPN
tahrj-8728	544	9	convencionalidad	convencionalidad	PROPN
tahrj-8728	544	10	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	545	1	una	una	PROPN
tahrj-8728	545	2	mirada	mirada	PROPN
tahrj-8728	545	3	comparada	comparada	PROPN
tahrj-8728	545	4	’	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	545	5	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	546	1	seminario	seminario	PROPN
tahrj-8728	546	2	internacional	internacional	PROPN
tahrj-8728	546	3	diálogo	diálogo	PROPN
tahrj-8728	546	4	jurisprudencial	jurisprudencial	ADJ
tahrj-8728	546	5	e	e	PROPN
tahrj-8728	546	6	https://doi.org/10.17561/tahrj.v23.8728	https://doi.org/10.17561/tahrj.v23.8728	PROPN
tahrj-8728	546	7	https://ohrh.law.ox.ac.uk/proportionality-in-india-a-bridge-to-nowhere	https://ohrh.law.ox.ac.uk/proportionality-in-india-a-bridge-to-nowhere	PROPN
tahrj-8728	546	8	https://ohrh.law.ox.ac.uk/proportionality-in-india-a-bridge-to-nowhere	https://ohrh.law.ox.ac.uk/proportionality-in-india-a-bridge-to-nowhere	PROPN
tahrj-8728	546	9	https://www.ucl.ac.uk/public-policy/sites/public-policy/files/migrated-files/european_human_rights_law.pdf	https://www.ucl.ac.uk/public-policy/sites/public-policy/files/migrated-files/european_human_rights_law.pdf	NOUN
tahrj-8728	546	10	https://www.ucl.ac.uk/public-policy/sites/public-policy/files/migrated-files/european_human_rights_law.pdf	https://www.ucl.ac.uk/public-policy/sites/public-policy/files/migrated-files/european_human_rights_law.pdf	NOUN
tahrj-8728	546	11	https://www.ucl.ac.uk/public-policy/sites/public-policy/files/migrated-files/european_human_rights_law.pdf	https://www.ucl.ac.uk/public-policy/sites/public-policy/files/migrated-files/european_human_rights_law.pdf	NOUN
tahrj-8728	546	12	https://papers.ssrn.com/abstract=3316317	https://papers.ssrn.com/abstract=3316317	NOUN
tahrj-8728	546	13	https://papers.ssrn.com/abstract=3316317	https://papers.ssrn.com/abstract=3316317	VERB
tahrj-8728	546	14	https://www.refworld.org/docid/438c6d972.html	https://www.refworld.org/docid/438c6d972.html	PRON
tahrj-8728	546	15	https://www.refworld.org/docid/438c6d972.html	https://www.refworld.org/docid/438c6d972.html	ADJ
tahrj-8728	546	16	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	546	17	analysis	analysis	NOUN
tahrj-8728	546	18	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	546	19	non	non	ADJ
tahrj-8728	546	20	-	-	ADJ
tahrj-8728	546	21	refoulement	refoulement	ADJ
tahrj-8728	546	22	jurisprudence	jurisprudence	NOUN
tahrj-8728	546	23	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	546	24	india	india	PROPN
tahrj-8728	546	25	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	546	26	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	546	27	comparative	comparative	ADJ
tahrj-8728	546	28	approach	approach	NOUN
tahrj-8728	546	29	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	546	30	age	age	NOUN
tahrj-8728	546	31	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	546	32	human	human	ADJ
tahrj-8728	546	33	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	546	34	journal	journal	NOUN
tahrj-8728	546	35	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	546	36	24	24	NUM
tahrj-8728	546	37	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	546	38	june	june	PROPN
tahrj-8728	546	39	2025	2025	NUM
tahrj-8728	546	40	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	546	41	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	546	42	e8728	e8728	PROPN
tahrj-8728	546	43	issn	issn	PROPN
tahrj-8728	546	44	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	546	45	2340	2340	NUM
tahrj-8728	546	46	-	-	SYM
tahrj-8728	546	47	9592	9592	NUM
tahrj-8728	546	48	doi	doi	NOUN
tahrj-8728	546	49	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	546	50	10.17561	10.17561	NUM
tahrj-8728	546	51	/	/	SYM
tahrj-8728	546	52	tahrj.v23.8728	tahrj.v23.8728	PROPN
tahrj-8728	546	53	26	26	NUM
tahrj-8728	546	54	impacto	impacto	X
tahrj-8728	546	55	de	de	PROPN
tahrj-8728	546	56	las	las	PROPN
tahrj-8728	546	57	sentencias	sentencias	PROPN
tahrj-8728	546	58	de	de	X
tahrj-8728	546	59	la	la	PROPN
tahrj-8728	546	60	corte	corte	PROPN
tahrj-8728	546	61	interamericana	interamericana	PROPN
tahrj-8728	546	62	de	de	PROPN
tahrj-8728	546	63	derechos	derechos	PROPN
tahrj-8728	546	64	humanos	humanos	PROPN
tahrj-8728	546	65	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	547	1	mexico	mexico	PROPN
tahrj-8728	547	2	city	city	PROPN
tahrj-8728	547	3	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	547	4	11	11	NUM
tahrj-8728	547	5	october	october	NOUN
tahrj-8728	547	6	2013	2013	NUM
tahrj-8728	547	7	pp	pp	NOUN
tahrj-8728	547	8	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	548	1	8	8	NUM
tahrj-8728	548	2	-	-	SYM
tahrj-8728	548	3	11	11	NUM
tahrj-8728	548	4	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	549	1	legal	legal	ADJ
tahrj-8728	549	2	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	549	3	judicial	judicial	ADJ
tahrj-8728	549	4	sources	source	NOUN
tahrj-8728	549	5	legal	legal	ADJ
tahrj-8728	549	6	references	reference	NOUN
tahrj-8728	549	7	american	american	PROPN
tahrj-8728	549	8	convention	convention	PROPN
tahrj-8728	549	9	on	on	ADP
tahrj-8728	549	10	human	human	ADJ
tahrj-8728	549	11	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	549	12	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	549	13	1969	1969	NUM
tahrj-8728	549	14	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	550	1	constitution	constitution	NOUN
tahrj-8728	550	2	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	550	3	india	india	PROPN
tahrj-8728	550	4	1950	1950	NUM
tahrj-8728	550	5	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	551	1	convention	convention	NOUN
tahrj-8728	551	2	on	on	ADP
tahrj-8728	551	3	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	551	4	status	status	NOUN
tahrj-8728	551	5	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	551	6	refugees	refugee	NOUN
tahrj-8728	551	7	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	551	8	189	189	NUM
tahrj-8728	551	9	u.n.t.s	u.n.t.s	PROPN
tahrj-8728	551	10	.	.	PROPN
tahrj-8728	551	11	150	150	NUM
tahrj-8728	551	12	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	551	13	entered	enter	VERB
tahrj-8728	551	14	into	into	ADP
tahrj-8728	551	15	force	force	NOUN
tahrj-8728	551	16	april	april	PROPN
tahrj-8728	551	17	22	22	NUM
tahrj-8728	551	18	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	551	19	1954	1954	NUM
tahrj-8728	551	20	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	551	21	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	552	1	united	united	PROPN
tahrj-8728	552	2	nations	nations	PROPN
tahrj-8728	552	3	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	553	1	1951	1951	NUM
tahrj-8728	553	2	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	554	1	foreigners	foreigner	NOUN
tahrj-8728	554	2	act	act	VERB
tahrj-8728	554	3	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	554	4	1946	1946	NUM
tahrj-8728	554	5	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	555	1	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	555	2	constitution	constitution	NOUN
tahrj-8728	555	3	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	555	4	kenya	kenya	PROPN
tahrj-8728	556	1	[	[	X
tahrj-8728	556	2	kenya	kenya	X
tahrj-8728	556	3	]	]	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	556	4	2010	2010	NUM
tahrj-8728	556	5	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	557	1	un	un	PROPN
tahrj-8728	557	2	declaration	declaration	PROPN
tahrj-8728	557	3	on	on	ADP
tahrj-8728	557	4	territorial	territorial	ADJ
tahrj-8728	557	5	asylum	asylum	NOUN
tahrj-8728	557	6	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	557	7	g.a	g.a	PROPN
tahrj-8728	557	8	res	re	NOUN
tahrj-8728	557	9	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	558	1	2312	2312	NUM
tahrj-8728	558	2	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	558	3	xxii	xxii	PROPN
tahrj-8728	558	4	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	558	5	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	558	6	1967	1967	NUM
tahrj-8728	558	7	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	559	1	case	case	NOUN
tahrj-8728	559	2	law	law	NOUN
tahrj-8728	559	3	advisory	advisory	ADJ
tahrj-8728	559	4	opinion	opinion	NOUN
tahrj-8728	559	5	oc-21/14	oc-21/14	NOUN
tahrj-8728	559	6	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	559	7	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	559	8	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	559	9	guarantees	guarantee	NOUN
tahrj-8728	559	10	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	559	11	children	child	NOUN
tahrj-8728	559	12	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	559	13	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	559	14	context	context	NOUN
tahrj-8728	559	15	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	559	16	migration	migration	NOUN
tahrj-8728	559	17	and/or	and/or	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	559	18	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	559	19	need	need	NOUN
tahrj-8728	559	20	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	559	21	international	international	ADJ
tahrj-8728	559	22	protection	protection	NOUN
tahrj-8728	559	23	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	559	24	inter	inter	ADJ
tahrj-8728	559	25	-	-	ADJ
tahrj-8728	559	26	american	american	ADJ
tahrj-8728	559	27	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	559	28	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	559	29	human	human	ADJ
tahrj-8728	559	30	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	559	31	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	559	32	19	19	NUM
tahrj-8728	559	33	august	august	PROPN
tahrj-8728	559	34	2014	2014	NUM
tahrj-8728	559	35	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	560	1	advisory	advisory	ADJ
tahrj-8728	560	2	opinion	opinion	NOUN
tahrj-8728	560	3	oc-25/18	oc-25/18	PROPN
tahrj-8728	560	4	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	560	5	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	560	6	institution	institution	NOUN
tahrj-8728	560	7	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	560	8	asylum	asylum	NOUN
tahrj-8728	560	9	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	560	10	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	560	11	its	its	PRON
tahrj-8728	560	12	recognition	recognition	NOUN
tahrj-8728	560	13	as	as	ADP
tahrj-8728	560	14	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	560	15	human	human	ADJ
tahrj-8728	560	16	right	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	560	17	under	under	ADP
tahrj-8728	560	18	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	560	19	inter	inter	ADJ
tahrj-8728	560	20	-	-	ADJ
tahrj-8728	560	21	american	american	ADJ
tahrj-8728	560	22	system	system	NOUN
tahrj-8728	560	23	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	560	24	protection	protection	NOUN
tahrj-8728	560	25	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	560	26	inter	inter	ADJ
tahrj-8728	560	27	-	-	ADJ
tahrj-8728	560	28	american	american	ADJ
tahrj-8728	560	29	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	560	30	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	560	31	human	human	ADJ
tahrj-8728	560	32	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	560	33	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	560	34	30	30	NUM
tahrj-8728	560	35	may	may	PROPN
tahrj-8728	560	36	2018	2018	NUM
tahrj-8728	560	37	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	561	1	african	african	ADJ
tahrj-8728	561	2	commission	commission	PROPN
tahrj-8728	561	3	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	561	4	human	human	NOUN
tahrj-8728	561	5	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	561	6	people	people	NOUN
tahrj-8728	561	7	’s	’s	PART
tahrj-8728	561	8	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	561	9	v.	v.	ADP
tahrj-8728	561	10	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	561	11	republic	republic	NOUN
tahrj-8728	561	12	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	561	13	kenya	kenya	PROPN
tahrj-8728	561	14	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	561	15	2013	2013	NUM
tahrj-8728	561	16	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	561	17	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	561	18	app	app	VERB
tahrj-8728	561	19	no	no	DET
tahrj-8728	561	20	006/2012	006/2012	NUM
tahrj-8728	561	21	acthpr	acthpr	NOUN
tahrj-8728	561	22	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	562	1	apdh	apdh	PROPN
tahrj-8728	562	2	v.	v.	PROPN
tahrj-8728	562	3	republic	republic	PROPN
tahrj-8728	562	4	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	562	5	cote	cote	PROPN
tahrj-8728	562	6	d’ivoire	d’ivoire	PROPN
tahrj-8728	562	7	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	562	8	2016	2016	NUM
tahrj-8728	562	9	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	562	10	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	562	11	2	2	NUM
tahrj-8728	562	12	afclr	afclr	ADP
tahrj-8728	562	13	141	141	NUM
tahrj-8728	562	14	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	563	1	associated	associate	VERB
tahrj-8728	563	2	provincial	provincial	ADJ
tahrj-8728	563	3	picture	picture	NOUN
tahrj-8728	563	4	houses	house	NOUN
tahrj-8728	563	5	ltd	ltd	PROPN
tahrj-8728	563	6	v.	v.	PROPN
tahrj-8728	563	7	wednesbury	wednesbury	PROPN
tahrj-8728	563	8	corporation	corporation	PROPN
tahrj-8728	563	9	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	563	10	1948	1948	NUM
tahrj-8728	563	11	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	563	12	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	563	13	1	1	NUM
tahrj-8728	563	14	kb	kb	PROPN
tahrj-8728	563	15	223	223	NUM
tahrj-8728	563	16	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	563	17	ca	ca	NOUN
tahrj-8728	563	18	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	563	19	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	564	1	babar	babar	PROPN
tahrj-8728	564	2	ahmad	ahmad	PROPN
tahrj-8728	564	3	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	564	4	others	other	NOUN
tahrj-8728	564	5	v.	v.	ADP
tahrj-8728	564	6	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	564	7	united	united	PROPN
tahrj-8728	564	8	kingdom	kingdom	PROPN
tahrj-8728	564	9	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	564	10	applications	application	NOUN
tahrj-8728	564	11	nos	nos	X
tahrj-8728	564	12	.	.	PROPN
tahrj-8728	564	13	24027/07	24027/07	NUM
tahrj-8728	564	14	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	564	15	11949/08	11949/08	NUM
tahrj-8728	564	16	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	564	17	36742/08	36742/08	NUM
tahrj-8728	564	18	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	564	19	66911/09	66911/09	NUM
tahrj-8728	564	20	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	564	21	67354/09	67354/09	NUM
tahrj-8728	564	22	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	564	23	council	council	PROPN
tahrj-8728	564	24	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	564	25	europe	europe	PROPN
tahrj-8728	564	26	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	564	27	european	european	PROPN
tahrj-8728	564	28	court	court	PROPN
tahrj-8728	564	29	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	564	30	human	human	ADJ
tahrj-8728	564	31	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	564	32	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	564	33	10	10	NUM
tahrj-8728	564	34	april	april	PROPN
tahrj-8728	564	35	2012	2012	NUM
tahrj-8728	564	36	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	565	1	bachan	bachan	PROPN
tahrj-8728	565	2	singh	singh	PROPN
tahrj-8728	566	1	v.	v.	ADP
tahrj-8728	566	2	union	union	PROPN
tahrj-8728	566	3	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	566	4	india	india	PROPN
tahrj-8728	566	5	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	566	6	1980	1980	NUM
tahrj-8728	566	7	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	566	8	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	566	9	2	2	NUM
tahrj-8728	566	10	scc	scc	NOUN
tahrj-8728	566	11	684	684	NUM
tahrj-8728	566	12	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	567	1	belgian	belgian	ADJ
tahrj-8728	567	2	linguistics	linguistic	NOUN
tahrj-8728	567	3	case	case	NOUN
tahrj-8728	567	4	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	567	5	1968	1968	NUM
tahrj-8728	567	6	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	567	7	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	567	8	1	1	NUM
tahrj-8728	567	9	ehrr	ehrr	VERB
tahrj-8728	567	10	252	252	NUM
tahrj-8728	567	11	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	567	12	bennett	bennett	PROPN
tahrj-8728	567	13	&	&	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	567	14	coleman	coleman	PROPN
tahrj-8728	567	15	v.	v.	PROPN
tahrj-8728	567	16	union	union	PROPN
tahrj-8728	567	17	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	567	18	india	india	PROPN
tahrj-8728	567	19	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	567	20	1973	1973	NUM
tahrj-8728	567	21	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	567	22	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	567	23	2	2	NUM
tahrj-8728	567	24	scc	scc	NOUN
tahrj-8728	567	25	788	788	NUM
tahrj-8728	567	26	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	568	1	chahal	chahal	NOUN
tahrj-8728	568	2	v.	v.	ADP
tahrj-8728	568	3	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	568	4	united	united	PROPN
tahrj-8728	568	5	kingdom	kingdom	PROPN
tahrj-8728	568	6	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	568	7	1996	1996	NUM
tahrj-8728	568	8	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	568	9	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	568	10	apfsp	apfsp	VERB
tahrj-8728	568	11	no	no	DET
tahrj-8728	568	12	22414/93	22414/93	NUM
tahrj-8728	568	13	ecthr	ecthr	NOUN
tahrj-8728	568	14	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	569	1	chintaman	chintaman	PROPN
tahrj-8728	569	2	rao	rao	PROPN
tahrj-8728	569	3	v.	v.	ADP
tahrj-8728	569	4	state	state	NOUN
tahrj-8728	569	5	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	569	6	m.p	m.p	PROPN
tahrj-8728	569	7	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	569	8	1915	1915	NUM
tahrj-8728	569	9	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	569	10	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	569	11	1	1	NUM
tahrj-8728	569	12	air	air	NOUN
tahrj-8728	569	13	sc	sc	PROPN
tahrj-8728	569	14	118	118	NUM
tahrj-8728	569	15	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	570	1	cossey	cossey	PROPN
tahrj-8728	570	2	v.	v.	PROPN
tahrj-8728	570	3	united	united	PROPN
tahrj-8728	570	4	kingdom	kingdom	PROPN
tahrj-8728	570	5	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	570	6	1990	1990	NUM
tahrj-8728	570	7	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	570	8	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	570	9	app	app	VERB
tahrj-8728	570	10	no	no	DET
tahrj-8728	570	11	10843/84	10843/84	NUM
tahrj-8728	570	12	ecthr	ecthr	NOUN
tahrj-8728	570	13	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	571	1	https://doi.org/10.17561/tahrj.v23.8728	https://doi.org/10.17561/tahrj.v23.8728	PROPN
tahrj-8728	571	2	sabreen	sabreen	PROPN
tahrj-8728	571	3	ahmed	ahme	VERB
tahrj-8728	571	4	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	571	5	age	age	NOUN
tahrj-8728	571	6	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	571	7	human	human	ADJ
tahrj-8728	571	8	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	571	9	journal	journal	NOUN
tahrj-8728	571	10	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	571	11	24	24	NUM
tahrj-8728	571	12	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	571	13	june	june	PROPN
tahrj-8728	571	14	2025	2025	NUM
tahrj-8728	571	15	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	571	16	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	571	17	e8728	e8728	PROPN
tahrj-8728	571	18	issn	issn	PROPN
tahrj-8728	571	19	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	571	20	2340	2340	NUM
tahrj-8728	571	21	-	-	SYM
tahrj-8728	571	22	9592	9592	NUM
tahrj-8728	571	23	doi	doi	NOUN
tahrj-8728	571	24	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	571	25	10.17561	10.17561	NUM
tahrj-8728	571	26	/	/	SYM
tahrj-8728	571	27	tahrj.v23.8728	tahrj.v23.8728	PROPN
tahrj-8728	571	28	27	27	NUM
tahrj-8728	571	29	council	council	NOUN
tahrj-8728	571	30	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	571	31	civil	civil	ADJ
tahrj-8728	571	32	service	service	NOUN
tahrj-8728	571	33	unions	union	NOUN
tahrj-8728	571	34	v.	v.	ADP
tahrj-8728	571	35	minister	minister	PROPN
tahrj-8728	571	36	for	for	ADP
tahrj-8728	571	37	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	571	38	civil	civil	ADJ
tahrj-8728	571	39	service	service	NOUN
tahrj-8728	571	40	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	571	41	1984	1984	NUM
tahrj-8728	571	42	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	571	43	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	571	44	ukhl	ukhl	NOUN
tahrj-8728	571	45	9	9	NUM
tahrj-8728	571	46	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	572	1	council	council	NOUN
tahrj-8728	572	2	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	572	3	civil	civil	ADJ
tahrj-8728	572	4	service	service	NOUN
tahrj-8728	572	5	unions	union	NOUN
tahrj-8728	572	6	v	v	ADP
tahrj-8728	572	7	minister	minister	NOUN
tahrj-8728	572	8	for	for	ADP
tahrj-8728	572	9	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	572	10	civil	civil	ADJ
tahrj-8728	572	11	service	service	NOUN
tahrj-8728	572	12	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	572	13	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	572	14	1985	1985	NUM
tahrj-8728	572	15	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	572	16	3	3	NUM
tahrj-8728	572	17	wlr	wlr	NOUN
tahrj-8728	572	18	11741	11741	NUM
tahrj-8728	572	19	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	573	1	council	council	NOUN
tahrj-8728	573	2	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	573	3	civil	civil	ADJ
tahrj-8728	573	4	service	service	NOUN
tahrj-8728	573	5	unions	union	NOUN
tahrj-8728	573	6	v.	v.	ADP
tahrj-8728	573	7	minister	minister	PROPN
tahrj-8728	573	8	for	for	ADP
tahrj-8728	573	9	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	573	10	civil	civil	ADJ
tahrj-8728	573	11	service	service	NOUN
tahrj-8728	573	12	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	573	13	1985	1985	NUM
tahrj-8728	573	14	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	573	15	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	573	16	ac	ac	PROPN
tahrj-8728	573	17	374	374	NUM
tahrj-8728	573	18	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	573	19	hl	hl	NOUN
tahrj-8728	573	20	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	573	21	410	410	NUM
tahrj-8728	573	22	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	574	1	fromancais	fromancais	PROPN
tahrj-8728	574	2	v.	v.	PROPN
tahrj-8728	574	3	forma	forma	PROPN
tahrj-8728	574	4	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	574	5	1983	1983	NUM
tahrj-8728	574	6	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	574	7	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	574	8	case	case	NOUN
tahrj-8728	574	9	c-66/82	c-66/82	NOUN
tahrj-8728	574	10	ecr	ecr	PROPN
tahrj-8728	574	11	395	395	NUM
tahrj-8728	574	12	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	575	1	gomes	gomes	PROPN
tahrj-8728	575	2	lund	lund	PROPN
tahrj-8728	575	3	et	et	PROPN
tahrj-8728	575	4	al	al	PROPN
tahrj-8728	575	5	.	.	PROPN
tahrj-8728	576	1	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	576	2	“	"	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	576	3	guerrilha	guerrilha	NOUN
tahrj-8728	576	4	do	do	AUX
tahrj-8728	576	5	araguaia	araguaia	NOUN
tahrj-8728	576	6	”	"	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	576	7	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	576	8	v.	v.	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	576	9	brazil	brazil	PROPN
tahrj-8728	576	10	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	576	11	inter	inter	ADJ
tahrj-8728	576	12	-	-	ADJ
tahrj-8728	576	13	american	american	ADJ
tahrj-8728	576	14	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	576	15	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	576	16	human	human	ADJ
tahrj-8728	576	17	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	576	18	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	576	19	series	series	NOUN
tahrj-8728	576	20	c	c	PROPN
tahrj-8728	577	1	no	no	INTJ
tahrj-8728	577	2	.	.	PROPN
tahrj-8728	577	3	219	219	NUM
tahrj-8728	577	4	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	577	5	judgment	judgment	NOUN
tahrj-8728	577	6	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	577	7	24	24	NUM
tahrj-8728	577	8	november	november	PROPN
tahrj-8728	577	9	2010	2010	NUM
tahrj-8728	577	10	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	578	1	handyside	handyside	PROPN
tahrj-8728	578	2	v	v	ADP
tahrj-8728	578	3	united	united	ADJ
tahrj-8728	578	4	kingdom	kingdom	PROPN
tahrj-8728	578	5	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	578	6	app	app	NOUN
tahrj-8728	578	7	no	no	DET
tahrj-8728	578	8	5493/72	5493/72	NUM
tahrj-8728	579	1	[	[	X
tahrj-8728	579	2	1976	1976	NUM
tahrj-8728	579	3	]	]	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	579	4	echr	echr	PROPN
tahrj-8728	580	1	5	5	X
tahrj-8728	580	2	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	580	3	haitian	haitian	ADJ
tahrj-8728	580	4	interdiction	interdiction	NOUN
tahrj-8728	580	5	–	–	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	580	6	haitian	haitian	ADJ
tahrj-8728	580	7	boat	boat	NOUN
tahrj-8728	580	8	people	people	NOUN
tahrj-8728	580	9	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	580	10	u.s	u.s	PROPN
tahrj-8728	580	11	.	.	PROPN
tahrj-8728	580	12	supreme	supreme	PROPN
tahrj-8728	580	13	court	court	PROPN
tahrj-8728	580	14	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	580	15	judgment	judgment	NOUN
tahrj-8728	580	16	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	580	17	21	21	NUM
tahrj-8728	580	18	june	june	PROPN
tahrj-8728	580	19	1993	1993	NUM
tahrj-8728	580	20	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	581	1	hans	hans	PROPN
tahrj-8728	581	2	muller	muller	PROPN
tahrj-8728	581	3	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	581	4	nuremberg	nuremberg	PROPN
tahrj-8728	581	5	v.	v.	ADP
tahrj-8728	581	6	superintendent	superintendent	PROPN
tahrj-8728	581	7	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	581	8	presidency	presidency	NOUN
tahrj-8728	581	9	jail	jail	NOUN
tahrj-8728	581	10	calcutta	calcutta	NOUN
tahrj-8728	581	11	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	581	12	1955	1955	NUM
tahrj-8728	581	13	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	581	14	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	581	15	air	air	PROPN
tahrj-8728	581	16	sc	sc	PROPN
tahrj-8728	581	17	367	367	NUM
tahrj-8728	581	18	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	582	1	hirsi	hirsi	PROPN
tahrj-8728	582	2	jamaa	jamaa	PROPN
tahrj-8728	582	3	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	582	4	others	other	NOUN
tahrj-8728	582	5	v.	v.	ADP
tahrj-8728	582	6	italy	italy	PROPN
tahrj-8728	582	7	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	582	8	application	application	NOUN
tahrj-8728	582	9	no	no	NOUN
tahrj-8728	582	10	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	583	1	27765/09	27765/09	NUM
tahrj-8728	583	2	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	583	3	judgment	judgment	NOUN
tahrj-8728	583	4	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	583	5	23	23	NUM
tahrj-8728	583	6	february	february	NOUN
tahrj-8728	583	7	2012	2012	NUM
tahrj-8728	583	8	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	584	1	ingabire	ingabire	PROPN
tahrj-8728	584	2	victoire	victoire	PROPN
tahrj-8728	584	3	umuhoza	umuhoza	PROPN
tahrj-8728	584	4	v.	v.	ADP
tahrj-8728	584	5	republic	republic	PROPN
tahrj-8728	584	6	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	584	7	rwanda	rwanda	PROPN
tahrj-8728	584	8	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	584	9	2017	2017	NUM
tahrj-8728	584	10	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	584	11	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	584	12	application	application	NOUN
tahrj-8728	584	13	003/2014	003/2014	NUM
tahrj-8728	584	14	acthpr	acthpr	ADJ
tahrj-8728	584	15	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	585	1	ireland	ireland	PROPN
tahrj-8728	585	2	v.	v.	ADP
tahrj-8728	585	3	uk	uk	PROPN
tahrj-8728	585	4	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	585	5	1979	1979	NUM
tahrj-8728	585	6	-	-	SYM
tahrj-8728	585	7	1980	1980	NUM
tahrj-8728	585	8	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	585	9	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	585	10	ehrr	ehrr	VERB
tahrj-8728	585	11	25	25	NUM
tahrj-8728	585	12	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	586	1	kennedy	kennedy	PROPN
tahrj-8728	586	2	v.	v.	PROPN
tahrj-8728	586	3	charity	charity	PROPN
tahrj-8728	586	4	commission	commission	PROPN
tahrj-8728	586	5	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	586	6	secretary	secretary	NOUN
tahrj-8728	586	7	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	586	8	state	state	NOUN
tahrj-8728	586	9	for	for	ADP
tahrj-8728	586	10	justice	justice	NOUN
tahrj-8728	586	11	intervening	intervene	VERB
tahrj-8728	586	12	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	587	1	[	[	X
tahrj-8728	587	2	2015	2015	NUM
tahrj-8728	587	3	]	]	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	587	4	uksc	uksc	NOUN
tahrj-8728	587	5	20	20	NUM
tahrj-8728	587	6	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	587	7	keyu	keyu	NOUN
tahrj-8728	587	8	v.	v.	ADP
tahrj-8728	587	9	secretary	secretary	PROPN
tahrj-8728	587	10	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	587	11	state	state	NOUN
tahrj-8728	587	12	for	for	ADP
tahrj-8728	587	13	foreign	foreign	ADJ
tahrj-8728	587	14	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	587	15	commonwealth	commonwealth	NOUN
tahrj-8728	587	16	affairs	affair	NOUN
tahrj-8728	587	17	[	[	X
tahrj-8728	587	18	2015	2015	NUM
tahrj-8728	587	19	]	]	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	587	20	uksc	uksc	NOUN
tahrj-8728	587	21	69	69	NUM
tahrj-8728	587	22	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	588	1	kharak	kharak	PROPN
tahrj-8728	588	2	singh	singh	PROPN
tahrj-8728	588	3	v.	v.	ADP
tahrj-8728	588	4	state	state	PROPN
tahrj-8728	588	5	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	588	6	uttar	uttar	PROPN
tahrj-8728	588	7	pradesh	pradesh	PROPN
tahrj-8728	588	8	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	588	9	air	air	NOUN
tahrj-8728	588	10	1963	1963	NUM
tahrj-8728	588	11	sc	sc	PROPN
tahrj-8728	588	12	1295	1295	NUM
tahrj-8728	588	13	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	589	1	kitua	kitua	PROPN
tahrj-8728	589	2	cha	cha	PROPN
tahrj-8728	589	3	sheria	sheria	PROPN
tahrj-8728	589	4	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	589	5	others	other	NOUN
tahrj-8728	589	6	v.	v.	ADP
tahrj-8728	589	7	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	589	8	attorney	attorney	NOUN
tahrj-8728	589	9	general	general	NOUN
tahrj-8728	589	10	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	589	11	2017	2017	NUM
tahrj-8728	589	12	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	589	13	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	589	14	civil	civil	ADJ
tahrj-8728	589	15	appeal	appeal	NOUN
tahrj-8728	589	16	108	108	NUM
tahrj-8728	589	17	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	589	18	2014	2014	NUM
tahrj-8728	589	19	eklr	eklr	ADJ
tahrj-8728	589	20	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	590	1	lohe	lohe	PROPN
tahrj-8728	590	2	issa	issa	PROPN
tahrj-8728	590	3	konate	konate	PROPN
tahrj-8728	590	4	v.	v.	PROPN
tahrj-8728	590	5	burkino	burkino	PROPN
tahrj-8728	590	6	faso	faso	PROPN
tahrj-8728	590	7	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	590	8	2014	2014	NUM
tahrj-8728	590	9	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	590	10	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	590	11	app	app	X
tahrj-8728	590	12	no	no	INTJ
tahrj-8728	590	13	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	590	14	004/2013	004/2013	NUM
tahrj-8728	590	15	acthpr	acthpr	ADJ
tahrj-8728	590	16	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	591	1	louis	louis	PROPN
tahrj-8728	591	2	de	de	ADP
tahrj-8728	591	3	raedt	raedt	PROPN
tahrj-8728	591	4	v.	v.	ADP
tahrj-8728	591	5	union	union	PROPN
tahrj-8728	591	6	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	591	7	india	india	PROPN
tahrj-8728	591	8	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	591	9	1991	1991	NUM
tahrj-8728	591	10	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	591	11	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	591	12	3	3	NUM
tahrj-8728	591	13	scc	scc	NOUN
tahrj-8728	591	14	554	554	NUM
tahrj-8728	591	15	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	592	1	mamatkulov	mamatkulov	NOUN
tahrj-8728	592	2	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	592	3	askar	askar	PROPN
tahrj-8728	592	4	v.	v.	ADP
tahrj-8728	592	5	turkey	turkey	PROPN
tahrj-8728	592	6	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	592	7	2005	2005	NUM
tahrj-8728	592	8	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	592	9	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	592	10	41	41	NUM
tahrj-8728	592	11	ehrr	ehrr	NOUN
tahrj-8728	592	12	25	25	NUM
tahrj-8728	592	13	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	592	14	maneka	maneka	PROPN
tahrj-8728	592	15	gandhi	gandhi	PROPN
tahrj-8728	592	16	v.	v.	ADP
tahrj-8728	592	17	union	union	PROPN
tahrj-8728	592	18	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	592	19	india	india	PROPN
tahrj-8728	592	20	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	592	21	1978	1978	NUM
tahrj-8728	592	22	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	592	23	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	592	24	1	1	NUM
tahrj-8728	592	25	scc	scc	PROPN
tahrj-8728	592	26	248	248	NUM
tahrj-8728	592	27	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	593	1	manohar	manohar	PROPN
tahrj-8728	593	2	lal	lal	PROPN
tahrj-8728	593	3	sharma	sharma	PROPN
tahrj-8728	593	4	v.	v.	ADP
tahrj-8728	593	5	union	union	PROPN
tahrj-8728	593	6	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	593	7	india	india	PROPN
tahrj-8728	593	8	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	593	9	2021	2021	NUM
tahrj-8728	593	10	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	593	11	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	593	12	air	air	PROPN
tahrj-8728	593	13	sc	sc	PROPN
tahrj-8728	593	14	5396	5396	NUM
tahrj-8728	593	15	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	594	1	modern	modern	ADJ
tahrj-8728	594	2	dental	dental	ADJ
tahrj-8728	594	3	college	college	NOUN
tahrj-8728	594	4	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	594	5	research	research	NOUN
tahrj-8728	594	6	centre	centre	PROPN
tahrj-8728	594	7	v.	v.	ADP
tahrj-8728	594	8	state	state	NOUN
tahrj-8728	594	9	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	594	10	madhya	madhya	PROPN
tahrj-8728	594	11	pradesh	pradesh	PROPN
tahrj-8728	594	12	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	594	13	2016	2016	NUM
tahrj-8728	594	14	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	594	15	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	594	16	7	7	NUM
tahrj-8728	594	17	scc	scc	NOUN
tahrj-8728	594	18	353	353	NUM
tahrj-8728	594	19	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	595	1	mohammad	mohammad	PROPN
tahrj-8728	595	2	salimullah	salimullah	PROPN
tahrj-8728	595	3	v.	v.	ADP
tahrj-8728	595	4	union	union	PROPN
tahrj-8728	595	5	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	595	6	india	india	PROPN
tahrj-8728	595	7	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	595	8	2021	2021	NUM
tahrj-8728	595	9	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	595	10	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	595	11	air	air	PROPN
tahrj-8728	595	12	sc	sc	PROPN
tahrj-8728	595	13	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	595	14	civil	civil	ADJ
tahrj-8728	595	15	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	595	16	1753	1753	NUM
tahrj-8728	595	17	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	596	1	n.d	n.d	PROPN
tahrj-8728	596	2	.	.	PROPN
tahrj-8728	596	3	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	596	4	n.t	n.t	PROPN
tahrj-8728	596	5	.	.	PROPN
tahrj-8728	596	6	v.	v.	PROPN
tahrj-8728	596	7	spain	spain	PROPN
tahrj-8728	596	8	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	596	9	applications	application	NOUN
tahrj-8728	596	10	nos	nos	X
tahrj-8728	596	11	.	.	PROPN
tahrj-8728	596	12	8675/15	8675/15	NUM
tahrj-8728	596	13	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	596	14	8697/15	8697/15	NUM
tahrj-8728	596	15	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	596	16	judgment	judgment	NOUN
tahrj-8728	596	17	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	596	18	13	13	NUM
tahrj-8728	596	19	february	february	NOUN
tahrj-8728	596	20	2020	2020	NUM
tahrj-8728	596	21	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	597	1	nada	nada	PROPN
tahrj-8728	597	2	v.	v.	PROPN
tahrj-8728	597	3	switzerland	switzerland	PROPN
tahrj-8728	597	4	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	597	5	2012	2012	NUM
tahrj-8728	597	6	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	597	7	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	597	8	app	app	VERB
tahrj-8728	597	9	no	no	DET
tahrj-8728	597	10	10593/08	10593/08	PROPN
tahrj-8728	597	11	[	[	X
tahrj-8728	597	12	gc	gc	X
tahrj-8728	597	13	]	]	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	597	14	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	598	1	nandita	nandita	PROPN
tahrj-8728	598	2	haksar	haksar	PROPN
tahrj-8728	598	3	v.	v.	ADP
tahrj-8728	598	4	state	state	PROPN
tahrj-8728	598	5	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	598	6	manipur	manipur	PROPN
tahrj-8728	598	7	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	598	8	w.p.(crl	w.p.(crl	PROPN
tahrj-8728	598	9	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	598	10	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	599	1	no	no	INTJ
tahrj-8728	599	2	.	.	NOUN
tahrj-8728	599	3	6	6	NUM
tahrj-8728	599	4	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	599	5	2021	2021	NUM
tahrj-8728	599	6	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	600	1	o	o	X
tahrj-8728	601	1	k	k	PROPN
tahrj-8728	601	2	ghosh	ghosh	PROPN
tahrj-8728	601	3	v.	v.	PROPN
tahrj-8728	601	4	e	e	PROPN
tahrj-8728	601	5	x	x	PROPN
tahrj-8728	601	6	joseph	joseph	PROPN
tahrj-8728	601	7	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	601	8	1963	1963	NUM
tahrj-8728	601	9	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	601	10	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	601	11	air	air	PROPN
tahrj-8728	601	12	sc	sc	PROPN
tahrj-8728	601	13	812	812	NUM
tahrj-8728	601	14	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	602	1	pacheco	pacheco	PROPN
tahrj-8728	602	2	tineo	tineo	VERB
tahrj-8728	602	3	family	family	PROPN
tahrj-8728	602	4	v.	v.	ADP
tahrj-8728	602	5	plurinational	plurinational	PROPN
tahrj-8728	602	6	state	state	PROPN
tahrj-8728	602	7	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	602	8	bolivia	bolivia	PROPN
tahrj-8728	602	9	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	602	10	inter	inter	ADJ
tahrj-8728	602	11	-	-	ADJ
tahrj-8728	602	12	american	american	ADJ
tahrj-8728	602	13	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	602	14	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	602	15	human	human	ADJ
tahrj-8728	602	16	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	602	17	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	602	18	series	series	NOUN
tahrj-8728	602	19	c	c	PROPN
tahrj-8728	602	20	no	no	INTJ
tahrj-8728	602	21	.	.	PROPN
tahrj-8728	602	22	272	272	NUM
tahrj-8728	602	23	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	602	24	judgment	judgment	NOUN
tahrj-8728	602	25	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	602	26	25	25	NUM
tahrj-8728	602	27	november	november	PROPN
tahrj-8728	602	28	2013	2013	NUM
tahrj-8728	602	29	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	603	1	pham	pham	PROPN
tahrj-8728	603	2	v.	v.	PROPN
tahrj-8728	603	3	home	home	PROPN
tahrj-8728	603	4	secretary	secretary	PROPN
tahrj-8728	603	5	[	[	X
tahrj-8728	603	6	2015	2015	NUM
tahrj-8728	603	7	]	]	SYM
tahrj-8728	603	8	1	1	NUM
tahrj-8728	603	9	wlr	wlr	NOUN
tahrj-8728	603	10	1591	1591	NUM
tahrj-8728	603	11	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	604	1	https://doi.org/10.17561/tahrj.v23.8728	https://doi.org/10.17561/tahrj.v23.8728	NOUN
tahrj-8728	604	2	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	604	3	analysis	analysis	NOUN
tahrj-8728	604	4	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	604	5	non	non	ADJ
tahrj-8728	604	6	-	-	ADJ
tahrj-8728	604	7	refoulement	refoulement	ADJ
tahrj-8728	604	8	jurisprudence	jurisprudence	NOUN
tahrj-8728	604	9	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	604	10	india	india	PROPN
tahrj-8728	604	11	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	604	12	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	604	13	comparative	comparative	ADJ
tahrj-8728	604	14	approach	approach	NOUN
tahrj-8728	604	15	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	604	16	age	age	NOUN
tahrj-8728	604	17	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	604	18	human	human	ADJ
tahrj-8728	604	19	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	604	20	journal	journal	NOUN
tahrj-8728	604	21	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	604	22	24	24	NUM
tahrj-8728	604	23	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	604	24	june	june	PROPN
tahrj-8728	604	25	2025	2025	NUM
tahrj-8728	604	26	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	604	27	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	604	28	e8728	e8728	PROPN
tahrj-8728	604	29	issn	issn	PROPN
tahrj-8728	604	30	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	604	31	2340	2340	NUM
tahrj-8728	604	32	-	-	SYM
tahrj-8728	604	33	9592	9592	NUM
tahrj-8728	604	34	doi	doi	NOUN
tahrj-8728	604	35	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	604	36	10.17561	10.17561	NUM
tahrj-8728	604	37	/	/	SYM
tahrj-8728	604	38	tahrj.v23.8728	tahrj.v23.8728	PROPN
tahrj-8728	604	39	28	28	NUM
tahrj-8728	604	40	puttaswamy	puttaswamy	PROPN
tahrj-8728	604	41	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	604	42	ii	ii	NOUN
tahrj-8728	604	43	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	604	44	v.	v.	ADP
tahrj-8728	604	45	union	union	PROPN
tahrj-8728	604	46	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	604	47	india	india	PROPN
tahrj-8728	604	48	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	604	49	2019	2019	NUM
tahrj-8728	604	50	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	604	51	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	604	52	1	1	NUM
tahrj-8728	604	53	scc	scc	NOUN
tahrj-8728	604	54	1	1	NUM
tahrj-8728	604	55	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	604	56	quila	quila	NOUN
tahrj-8728	604	57	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	604	58	another	another	PRON
tahrj-8728	604	59	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	604	60	2011	2011	NUM
tahrj-8728	604	61	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	604	62	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	604	63	uksc	uksc	VERB
tahrj-8728	604	64	45	45	NUM
tahrj-8728	604	65	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	605	1	r	r	PROPN
tahrj-8728	605	2	v.	v.	ADP
tahrj-8728	605	3	ministry	ministry	PROPN
tahrj-8728	605	4	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	605	5	defence	defence	PROPN
tahrj-8728	605	6	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	605	7	1996	1996	NUM
tahrj-8728	605	8	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	605	9	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	605	10	qb	qb	PROPN
tahrj-8728	605	11	517	517	NUM
tahrj-8728	605	12	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	606	1	r	r	NOUN
tahrj-8728	606	2	v	v	ADP
tahrj-8728	606	3	oakes	oakes	PROPN
tahrj-8728	606	4	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	606	5	1986	1986	NUM
tahrj-8728	606	6	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	606	7	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	606	8	1	1	NUM
tahrj-8728	606	9	scr	scr	NOUN
tahrj-8728	606	10	103	103	NUM
tahrj-8728	606	11	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	607	1	r.	r.	PROPN
tahrj-8728	607	2	v.	v.	PROPN
tahrj-8728	607	3	secretary	secretary	PROPN
tahrj-8728	607	4	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	607	5	state	state	NOUN
tahrj-8728	607	6	for	for	ADP
tahrj-8728	607	7	defence	defence	NOUN
tahrj-8728	607	8	;	;	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	607	9	ex	ex	X
tahrj-8728	607	10	parte	parte	PROPN
tahrj-8728	607	11	smith	smith	PROPN
tahrj-8728	607	12	et	et	PROPN
tahrj-8728	607	13	al	al	PROPN
tahrj-8728	607	14	.	.	PROPN
tahrj-8728	608	1	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	609	1	1996	1996	NUM
tahrj-8728	609	2	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	609	3	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	609	4	4	4	NUM
tahrj-8728	609	5	all	all	PRON
tahrj-8728	609	6	e.r	e.r	PROPN
tahrj-8728	609	7	.	.	PROPN
tahrj-8728	609	8	427	427	NUM
tahrj-8728	609	9	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	610	1	r	r	NOUN
tahrj-8728	610	2	v.	v.	ADP
tahrj-8728	610	3	secretary	secretary	PROPN
tahrj-8728	610	4	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	610	5	state	state	NOUN
tahrj-8728	610	6	for	for	ADP
tahrj-8728	610	7	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	610	8	home	home	NOUN
tahrj-8728	610	9	department	department	NOUN
tahrj-8728	610	10	ex	ex	PRON
tahrj-8728	610	11	p	p	X
tahrj-8728	610	12	brind	brind	NOUN
tahrj-8728	610	13	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	610	14	1991	1991	NUM
tahrj-8728	610	15	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	610	16	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	610	17	1	1	NUM
tahrj-8728	610	18	ac	ac	PROPN
tahrj-8728	610	19	696	696	NUM
tahrj-8728	610	20	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	610	21	hl	hl	NOUN
tahrj-8728	610	22	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	610	23	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	611	1	r	r	NOUN
tahrj-8728	611	2	v.	v.	ADP
tahrj-8728	611	3	secretary	secretary	PROPN
tahrj-8728	611	4	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	611	5	state	state	NOUN
tahrj-8728	611	6	for	for	ADP
tahrj-8728	611	7	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	611	8	home	home	NOUN
tahrj-8728	611	9	department	department	NOUN
tahrj-8728	611	10	ex	ex	PROPN
tahrj-8728	611	11	p	p	PROPN
tahrj-8728	611	12	daly	daly	PROPN
tahrj-8728	611	13	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	611	14	2001	2001	NUM
tahrj-8728	611	15	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	611	16	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	611	17	ukhl	ukhl	VERB
tahrj-8728	611	18	26	26	NUM
tahrj-8728	611	19	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	612	1	r	r	NOUN
tahrj-8728	612	2	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	612	3	wellington	wellington	PROPN
tahrj-8728	612	4	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	612	5	v.	v.	PROPN
tahrj-8728	612	6	secretary	secretary	PROPN
tahrj-8728	612	7	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	612	8	state	state	NOUN
tahrj-8728	612	9	for	for	ADP
tahrj-8728	612	10	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	612	11	home	home	NOUN
tahrj-8728	612	12	department	department	NOUN
tahrj-8728	612	13	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	612	14	2008	2008	NUM
tahrj-8728	612	15	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	612	16	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	612	17	ukhl	ukhl	NOUN
tahrj-8728	612	18	72	72	NUM
tahrj-8728	612	19	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	613	1	randu	randu	NOUN
tahrj-8728	613	2	nzai	nzai	ADV
tahrj-8728	613	3	ruwa	ruwa	ADV
tahrj-8728	613	4	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	613	5	others	other	NOUN
tahrj-8728	613	6	v.	v.	ADP
tahrj-8728	613	7	minister	minister	PROPN
tahrj-8728	613	8	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	613	9	internal	internal	ADJ
tahrj-8728	613	10	security	security	NOUN
tahrj-8728	613	11	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	613	12	another	another	PRON
tahrj-8728	613	13	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	613	14	2012	2012	NUM
tahrj-8728	613	15	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	613	16	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	613	17	miscellaneous	miscellaneous	ADJ
tahrj-8728	613	18	application	application	NOUN
tahrj-8728	613	19	468	468	NUM
tahrj-8728	613	20	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	613	21	2010	2010	NUM
tahrj-8728	613	22	eklr	eklr	ADJ
tahrj-8728	613	23	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	614	1	rejoinder	rejoinder	NOUN
tahrj-8728	614	2	on	on	ADP
tahrj-8728	614	3	behalf	behalf	NOUN
tahrj-8728	614	4	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	614	5	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	614	6	union	union	PROPN
tahrj-8728	614	7	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	614	8	india	india	PROPN
tahrj-8728	614	9	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	614	10	mohammad	mohammad	PROPN
tahrj-8728	614	11	salimullah	salimullah	PROPN
tahrj-8728	614	12	v.	v.	ADP
tahrj-8728	614	13	union	union	PROPN
tahrj-8728	614	14	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	614	15	india	india	PROPN
tahrj-8728	614	16	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	614	17	2017	2017	NUM
tahrj-8728	614	18	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	614	19	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	614	20	writ	writ	NOUN
tahrj-8728	614	21	petition	petition	NOUN
tahrj-8728	614	22	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	614	23	civil	civil	ADJ
tahrj-8728	614	24	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	614	25	no	no	NOUN
tahrj-8728	614	26	.	.	NOUN
tahrj-8728	615	1	793	793	NUM
tahrj-8728	615	2	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	615	3	2017	2017	NUM
tahrj-8728	615	4	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	616	1	saadi	saadi	PROPN
tahrj-8728	616	2	v.	v.	PROPN
tahrj-8728	616	3	italy	italy	PROPN
tahrj-8728	616	4	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	616	5	2008	2008	NUM
tahrj-8728	616	6	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	616	7	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	616	8	app	app	VERB
tahrj-8728	616	9	no	no	DET
tahrj-8728	616	10	37201/06	37201/06	NUM
tahrj-8728	616	11	ecthr	ecthr	NOUN
tahrj-8728	616	12	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	617	1	smith	smith	PROPN
tahrj-8728	617	2	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	617	3	gardy	gardy	PROPN
tahrj-8728	617	4	v.	v.	ADP
tahrj-8728	617	5	united	united	PROPN
tahrj-8728	617	6	kingdom	kingdom	PROPN
tahrj-8728	617	7	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	617	8	1999	1999	NUM
tahrj-8728	617	9	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	617	10	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	617	11	29	29	NUM
tahrj-8728	617	12	ehrr	ehrr	VERB
tahrj-8728	617	13	493	493	NUM
tahrj-8728	617	14	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	618	1	socialist	socialist	ADJ
tahrj-8728	618	2	party	party	NOUN
tahrj-8728	618	3	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	618	4	others	other	NOUN
tahrj-8728	618	5	v.	v.	ADP
tahrj-8728	618	6	turkey	turkey	PROPN
tahrj-8728	618	7	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	618	8	1998	1998	NUM
tahrj-8728	618	9	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	618	10	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	618	11	app	app	X
tahrj-8728	618	12	20/1997/804/1007	20/1997/804/1007	NUM
tahrj-8728	618	13	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	618	14	ecthr	ecthr	PROPN
tahrj-8728	618	15	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	619	1	soering	soere	VERB
tahrj-8728	619	2	v.	v.	ADP
tahrj-8728	619	3	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	619	4	united	united	PROPN
tahrj-8728	619	5	kingdom	kingdom	PROPN
tahrj-8728	619	6	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	619	7	1989	1989	NUM
tahrj-8728	619	8	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	619	9	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	619	10	app	app	X
tahrj-8728	619	11	no	no	INTJ
tahrj-8728	619	12	.	.	PROPN
tahrj-8728	620	1	14038/88	14038/88	NUM
tahrj-8728	620	2	ecthr	ecthr	PROPN
tahrj-8728	620	3	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	621	1	spuc	spuc	PROPN
tahrj-8728	621	2	v	v	ADP
tahrj-8728	621	3	grogan	grogan	PROPN
tahrj-8728	621	4	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	621	5	1991	1991	NUM
tahrj-8728	621	6	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	621	7	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	621	8	c-159/90	c-159/90	NOUN
tahrj-8728	621	9	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	622	1	state	state	NOUN
tahrj-8728	622	2	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	622	3	arunachal	arunachal	PROPN
tahrj-8728	622	4	pradesh	pradesh	PROPN
tahrj-8728	622	5	v.	v.	ADP
tahrj-8728	622	6	national	national	PROPN
tahrj-8728	622	7	human	human	PROPN
tahrj-8728	622	8	rights	rights	PROPN
tahrj-8728	622	9	commission	commission	PROPN
tahrj-8728	622	10	1996	1996	NUM
tahrj-8728	622	11	scc	scc	X
tahrj-8728	622	12	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	622	13	1	1	NUM
tahrj-8728	622	14	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	622	15	742	742	NUM
tahrj-8728	622	16	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	623	1	subramaniam	subramaniam	PROPN
tahrj-8728	623	2	swamy	swamy	PROPN
tahrj-8728	623	3	v	v	ADP
tahrj-8728	623	4	union	union	PROPN
tahrj-8728	623	5	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	623	6	india	india	PROPN
tahrj-8728	623	7	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	623	8	2016	2016	NUM
tahrj-8728	623	9	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	623	10	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	623	11	air	air	PROPN
tahrj-8728	623	12	sc	sc	PROPN
tahrj-8728	623	13	2728	2728	NUM
tahrj-8728	623	14	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	624	1	superintendent	superintendent	NOUN
tahrj-8728	624	2	central	central	ADJ
tahrj-8728	624	3	prison	prison	NOUN
tahrj-8728	624	4	v.	v.	ADP
tahrj-8728	624	5	ram	ram	PROPN
tahrj-8728	624	6	manohar	manohar	PROPN
tahrj-8728	624	7	lohia	lohia	PROPN
tahrj-8728	624	8	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	624	9	1960	1960	NUM
tahrj-8728	624	10	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	624	11	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	624	12	2	2	NUM
tahrj-8728	624	13	scr	scr	NOUN
tahrj-8728	624	14	821	821	NUM
tahrj-8728	624	15	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	625	1	tanganyika	tanganyika	PROPN
tahrj-8728	625	2	law	law	NOUN
tahrj-8728	625	3	society	society	NOUN
tahrj-8728	625	4	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	625	5	legal	legal	ADJ
tahrj-8728	625	6	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	625	7	human	human	ADJ
tahrj-8728	625	8	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	625	9	centre	centre	NOUN
tahrj-8728	625	10	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	625	11	reverend	reverend	PROPN
tahrj-8728	625	12	christopher	christopher	PROPN
tahrj-8728	625	13	r	r	PROPN
tahrj-8728	625	14	mitilika	mitilika	PROPN
tahrj-8728	625	15	v	v	PROPN
tahrj-8728	625	16	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	625	17	united	united	PROPN
tahrj-8728	625	18	republic	republic	PROPN
tahrj-8728	625	19	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	625	20	tanzania	tanzania	PROPN
tahrj-8728	625	21	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	625	22	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	625	23	2013	2013	NUM
tahrj-8728	625	24	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	625	25	african	african	ADJ
tahrj-8728	625	26	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	625	27	on	on	ADP
tahrj-8728	625	28	human	human	ADJ
tahrj-8728	625	29	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	625	30	peoples	people	NOUN
tahrj-8728	625	31	'	'	PART
tahrj-8728	625	32	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	625	33	applications	application	NOUN
tahrj-8728	625	34	no	no	NOUN
tahrj-8728	625	35	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	625	36	009/2011	009/2011	PROPN
tahrj-8728	625	37	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	625	38	no	no	INTJ
tahrj-8728	625	39	.	.	NOUN
tahrj-8728	625	40	011/2011	011/2011	NUM
tahrj-8728	625	41	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	626	1	tanganyika	tanganyika	PROPN
tahrj-8728	626	2	law	law	NOUN
tahrj-8728	626	3	society	society	NOUN
tahrj-8728	626	4	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	626	5	legal	legal	ADJ
tahrj-8728	626	6	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	626	7	human	human	ADJ
tahrj-8728	626	8	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	626	9	centre	centre	PROPN
tahrj-8728	626	10	v.	v.	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	626	11	tanzania	tanzania	PROPN
tahrj-8728	626	12	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	626	13	reverend	reverend	PROPN
tahrj-8728	626	14	christopher	christopher	PROPN
tahrj-8728	626	15	r.	r.	PROPN
tahrj-8728	626	16	mitilika	mitilika	PROPN
tahrj-8728	626	17	v.	v.	PROPN
tahrj-8728	626	18	united	united	PROPN
tahrj-8728	626	19	republic	republic	PROPN
tahrj-8728	626	20	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	626	21	tanzania	tanzania	PROPN
tahrj-8728	626	22	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	626	23	2013	2013	NUM
tahrj-8728	626	24	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	626	25	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	626	26	app	app	X
tahrj-8728	626	27	no	no	INTJ
tahrj-8728	626	28	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	626	29	009/2011	009/2011	PROPN
tahrj-8728	626	30	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	626	31	011/2011	011/2011	NUM
tahrj-8728	626	32	acthpr	acthpr	ADJ
tahrj-8728	626	33	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	627	1	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	627	2	matter	matter	NOUN
tahrj-8728	627	3	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	627	4	anudo	anudo	PROPN
tahrj-8728	627	5	ochieng	ochieng	PROPN
tahrj-8728	627	6	anudo	anudo	PROPN
tahrj-8728	627	7	v	v	PROPN
tahrj-8728	627	8	united	united	PROPN
tahrj-8728	627	9	republic	republic	PROPN
tahrj-8728	627	10	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	627	11	tanzania	tanzania	PROPN
tahrj-8728	627	12	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	627	13	2018	2018	NUM
tahrj-8728	627	14	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	627	15	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	627	16	app	app	X
tahrj-8728	627	17	no	no	INTJ
tahrj-8728	627	18	.	.	PROPN
tahrj-8728	627	19	012/2015	012/2015	NUM
tahrj-8728	627	20	acthpr	acthpr	ADJ
tahrj-8728	627	21	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	628	1	usón	usón	PROPN
tahrj-8728	628	2	ramírez	ramírez	PROPN
tahrj-8728	628	3	v.	v.	PROPN
tahrj-8728	628	4	venezuela	venezuela	PROPN
tahrj-8728	628	5	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	628	6	inter	inter	ADJ
tahrj-8728	628	7	-	-	ADJ
tahrj-8728	628	8	american	american	ADJ
tahrj-8728	628	9	court	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	628	10	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	628	11	human	human	ADJ
tahrj-8728	628	12	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	628	13	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	628	14	series	series	NOUN
tahrj-8728	628	15	c	c	PROPN
tahrj-8728	628	16	no	no	INTJ
tahrj-8728	628	17	.	.	PROPN
tahrj-8728	628	18	207	207	NUM
tahrj-8728	628	19	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	628	20	judgment	judgment	NOUN
tahrj-8728	628	21	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	628	22	20	20	NUM
tahrj-8728	628	23	november	november	PROPN
tahrj-8728	628	24	2009	2009	NUM
tahrj-8728	628	25	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	629	1	vg	vg	ADP
tahrj-8728	629	2	row	row	NOUN
tahrj-8728	629	3	v.	v.	ADP
tahrj-8728	629	4	state	state	NOUN
tahrj-8728	629	5	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	629	6	madras	madras	X
tahrj-8728	629	7	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	629	8	1952	1952	NUM
tahrj-8728	629	9	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	629	10	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	629	11	air	air	PROPN
tahrj-8728	629	12	sc	sc	PROPN
tahrj-8728	629	13	196	196	NUM
tahrj-8728	629	14	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	630	1	vivalrajah	vivalrajah	PROPN
tahrj-8728	630	2	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	630	3	others	other	NOUN
tahrj-8728	630	4	v.	v.	ADP
tahrj-8728	630	5	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	630	6	united	united	PROPN
tahrj-8728	630	7	kingdom	kingdom	PROPN
tahrj-8728	630	8	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	630	9	1991	1991	NUM
tahrj-8728	630	10	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	630	11	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	630	12	ser	ser	VERB
tahrj-8728	630	13	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	630	14	no	no	DET
tahrj-8728	630	15	215	215	NUM
tahrj-8728	630	16	ecthr	ecthr	NOUN
tahrj-8728	630	17	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	631	1	https://doi.org/10.17561/tahrj.v23.8728	https://doi.org/10.17561/tahrj.v23.8728	PROPN
tahrj-8728	631	2	sabreen	sabreen	PROPN
tahrj-8728	631	3	ahmed	ahme	VERB
tahrj-8728	631	4	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	631	5	age	age	NOUN
tahrj-8728	631	6	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	631	7	human	human	ADJ
tahrj-8728	631	8	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	631	9	journal	journal	NOUN
tahrj-8728	631	10	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	631	11	24	24	NUM
tahrj-8728	631	12	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	631	13	june	june	PROPN
tahrj-8728	631	14	2025	2025	NUM
tahrj-8728	631	15	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	631	16	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	631	17	e8728	e8728	PROPN
tahrj-8728	631	18	issn	issn	PROPN
tahrj-8728	631	19	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	631	20	2340	2340	NUM
tahrj-8728	631	21	-	-	SYM
tahrj-8728	631	22	9592	9592	NUM
tahrj-8728	631	23	doi	doi	NOUN
tahrj-8728	631	24	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	631	25	10.17561	10.17561	NUM
tahrj-8728	631	26	/	/	SYM
tahrj-8728	631	27	tahrj.v23.8728	tahrj.v23.8728	PROPN
tahrj-8728	631	28	29	29	NUM
tahrj-8728	631	29	newspapers	newspaper	NOUN
tahrj-8728	631	30	das	das	PROPN
tahrj-8728	631	31	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	631	32	k.	k.	PROPN
tahrj-8728	631	33	n.	n.	PROPN
tahrj-8728	631	34	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	631	35	miglani	miglani	PROPN
tahrj-8728	631	36	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	631	37	s.	s.	PROPN
tahrj-8728	631	38	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	631	39	2017	2017	NUM
tahrj-8728	631	40	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	631	41	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	632	1	‘	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	632	2	india	india	PROPN
tahrj-8728	632	3	says	say	VERB
tahrj-8728	632	4	to	to	PART
tahrj-8728	632	5	deport	deport	VERB
tahrj-8728	632	6	all	all	DET
tahrj-8728	632	7	rohingya	rohingya	PROPN
tahrj-8728	632	8	regardless	regardless	ADV
tahrj-8728	632	9	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	632	10	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	632	11	un	un	PROPN
tahrj-8728	632	12	registration	registration	NOUN
tahrj-8728	632	13	’	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	632	14	,	,	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	632	15	reuters	reuters	PROPN
tahrj-8728	632	16	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	633	1	received	receive	VERB
tahrj-8728	633	2	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	633	3	4th	4th	ADJ
tahrj-8728	633	4	march	march	PROPN
tahrj-8728	633	5	2024	2024	NUM
tahrj-8728	633	6	accepted	accept	VERB
tahrj-8728	633	7	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	633	8	22nd	22nd	ADJ
tahrj-8728	633	9	october	october	PROPN
tahrj-8728	633	10	2024	2024	NUM
tahrj-8728	633	11	https://doi.org/10.17561/tahrj.v23.8728	https://doi.org/10.17561/tahrj.v23.8728	PROPN
tahrj-8728	633	12	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	633	13	analysis	analysis	NOUN
tahrj-8728	633	14	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	633	15	non	non	ADJ
tahrj-8728	633	16	-	-	ADJ
tahrj-8728	633	17	refoulement	refoulement	ADJ
tahrj-8728	633	18	jurisprudence	jurisprudence	NOUN
tahrj-8728	633	19	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	633	20	india	india	PROPN
tahrj-8728	633	21	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	633	22	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	633	23	comparative	comparative	ADJ
tahrj-8728	633	24	approach	approach	NOUN
tahrj-8728	633	25	1	1	NUM
tahrj-8728	633	26	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	634	1	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	634	2	-	-	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	634	3	based	base	VERB
tahrj-8728	634	4	context	context	NOUN
tahrj-8728	634	5	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	634	6	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	634	7	analysis	analysis	NOUN
tahrj-8728	634	8	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	634	9	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	634	10	european	european	ADJ
tahrj-8728	634	11	legal	legal	ADJ
tahrj-8728	634	12	system	system	NOUN
tahrj-8728	634	13	1.1	1.1	NUM
tahrj-8728	634	14	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	635	1	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	635	2	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	635	3	nonrefoulement	nonrefoulement	ADJ
tahrj-8728	635	4	1.2	1.2	NUM
tahrj-8728	635	5	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	636	1	ecthr	ecthr	PROPN
tahrj-8728	636	2	jurisprudence	jurisprudence	NOUN
tahrj-8728	636	3	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	636	4	from	from	ADP
tahrj-8728	636	5	no	no	DET
tahrj-8728	636	6	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	636	7	to	to	ADP
tahrj-8728	636	8	something	something	PRON
tahrj-8728	636	9	illusory	illusory	ADJ
tahrj-8728	636	10	1.3	1.3	NUM
tahrj-8728	636	11	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	637	1	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	637	2	analysis	analysis	NOUN
tahrj-8728	637	3	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	637	4	the	the	PRON
tahrj-8728	637	5	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	637	6	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	637	7	inter	inter	ADJ
tahrj-8728	637	8	-	-	ADJ
tahrj-8728	637	9	american	american	ADJ
tahrj-8728	637	10	human	human	ADJ
tahrj-8728	637	11	rights	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	637	12	system	system	NOUN
tahrj-8728	637	13	(	(	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	637	14	iahrs	iahrs	NOUN
tahrj-8728	637	15	)	)	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	637	16	2	2	NUM
tahrj-8728	637	17	.	.	X
tahrj-8728	637	18	african	african	ADJ
tahrj-8728	637	19	courts	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	637	20	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	637	21	the	the	DET
tahrj-8728	637	22	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	637	23	analysis	analysis	NOUN
tahrj-8728	637	24	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	637	25	meaning	meaning	NOUN
tahrj-8728	637	26	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	637	27	context	context	NOUN
tahrj-8728	637	28	2.1	2.1	NUM
tahrj-8728	637	29	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	638	1	national	national	ADJ
tahrj-8728	638	2	courts	court	NOUN
tahrj-8728	638	3	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	638	4	africa	africa	PROPN
tahrj-8728	638	5	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	638	6	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	638	7	analysis	analysis	NOUN
tahrj-8728	638	8	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	638	9	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	638	10	threshold	threshold	NOUN
tahrj-8728	638	11	?	?	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	639	1	3	3	X
tahrj-8728	639	2	.	.	X
tahrj-8728	639	3	proportionality	proportionality	NOUN
tahrj-8728	639	4	analysis	analysis	NOUN
tahrj-8728	639	5	jurisprudence	jurisprudence	NOUN
tahrj-8728	639	6	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	639	7	india	india	PROPN
tahrj-8728	639	8	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	639	9	scope	scope	NOUN
tahrj-8728	639	10	for	for	ADP
tahrj-8728	639	11	non	non	ADJ
tahrj-8728	639	12	refoulement	refoulement	NOUN
tahrj-8728	639	13	?	?	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	640	1	3.1	3.1	NUM
tahrj-8728	640	2	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	641	1	‘	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	641	2	non	non	ADJ
tahrj-8728	641	3	-	-	ADJ
tahrj-8728	641	4	refoulment	refoulment	ADJ
tahrj-8728	641	5	’	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	641	6	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	641	7	india	india	PROPN
tahrj-8728	641	8	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	641	9	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	641	10	fundamental	fundamental	ADJ
tahrj-8728	641	11	right	right	NOUN
tahrj-8728	641	12	?	?	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	642	1	3.2	3.2	NUM
tahrj-8728	642	2	.	.	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	643	1	‘	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	643	2	rainbow	rainbow	NOUN
tahrj-8728	643	3	of	of	ADP
tahrj-8728	643	4	review	review	NOUN
tahrj-8728	643	5	’	'	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	643	6	in	in	ADP
tahrj-8728	643	7	non	non	ADJ
tahrj-8728	643	8	-	-	ADJ
tahrj-8728	643	9	refoulement	refoulement	ADJ
tahrj-8728	643	10	cases	case	NOUN
tahrj-8728	643	11	:	:	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	643	12	a	a	DET
tahrj-8728	643	13	way	way	NOUN
tahrj-8728	643	14	forward	forward	ADV
tahrj-8728	643	15	for	for	ADP
tahrj-8728	643	16	india	india	PROPN
tahrj-8728	643	17	?	?	PUNCT
tahrj-8728	644	1	4	4	X
tahrj-8728	644	2	.	.	X
tahrj-8728	644	3	conclusion	conclusion	NOUN
tahrj-8728	644	4	acknowledgement	acknowledgement	NOUN
tahrj-8728	644	5	reference	reference	NOUN
tahrj-8728	644	6	list	list	NOUN
tahrj-8728	644	7	books	book	NOUN
tahrj-8728	644	8	chapters	chapter	NOUN
tahrj-8728	644	9	journal	journal	PROPN
tahrj-8728	644	10	articles	article	NOUN
tahrj-8728	644	11	webpages	webpage	NOUN
tahrj-8728	644	12	/	/	SYM
tahrj-8728	644	13	websites	website	NOUN
tahrj-8728	644	14	/	/	SYM
tahrj-8728	644	15	other	other	ADJ
tahrj-8728	644	16	media	medium	NOUN
tahrj-8728	644	17	conference	conference	NOUN
tahrj-8728	644	18	papers	paper	NOUN
tahrj-8728	644	19	legal	legal	ADJ
tahrj-8728	644	20	and	and	CCONJ
tahrj-8728	644	21	judicial	judicial	ADJ
tahrj-8728	644	22	sources	source	NOUN
tahrj-8728	644	23	legal	legal	ADJ
tahrj-8728	644	24	references	reference	NOUN
tahrj-8728	644	25	case	case	NOUN
tahrj-8728	644	26	law	law	NOUN
tahrj-8728	644	27	newspapers	newspaper	NOUN