JOURNAL OF THE SCIENTIFIC AGRICULTURAL SOCIETY OF FINLAND 296 Maataloustieteellinen Aikakauskirja Voi. 49: 296-314, 1977 Effect of added magnesium, potassium, lime and nitrogen on oats 11. Nutrient contents, cation ratios and magnesium uptake Raili Jokinen Agricultural Research Centre, Department of Agricultural Chemistry and Physics 01300 Vantaa 30, Finland Abstract. In a pot experiment on sphagnum peat soil the magnesium fertilization in- creased significantly the magnesium content of the grains and the straws of oats. The addition of potassium fertilization decreased the magnesium content when the plants received a magnesium fertilization. Without magnesium the rate of potassium fertiliza- tion did not have an effect on the magnesium content of the straws. The increase in the equivalent ratio of the three potassium rates and the two magnesium rates decreased the magnesium content of both the grains and the straws. Along with the magnesium fertiliza- tion the addition of lime decreased the magnesium content of the grains and increased that of the straws. Doubling the amount of the nitrogen fertilization with the magnesium fertilizer increased the magnesium content of the grains and the straws. In the case of magnesium deficiency the addition of lime or nitrogen did not have an effect on the mag- nesium content of the yields. The rate of magnesium, potassium, lime and nitrogen did not have an effect on the potassium content of the grains. The potassium content of the straws increased with the addition of potassium. Without the magnesium fertilization the potassium content, as well as, the ratios K/Mg and K/(Ca + Mg) in the grains and the straws were high. A part of the missing magnesium had, perhaps, been substituted for by potassium. The calcium content of the grains and the straws obtained without magnesium fer- tilization was significantly higher than the calcium content with magnesium fertilization. The oats substituted possibly in part also calcium for the missing magnesium. The effect of added magnesium, potassium, lime and nitrogen on the magnesium uptake by oats was discussed. Introduction The positive effect on the magnesium content of the grains of cereals caused by magnesium fertilization has been rather slight both in pot experiments and in field experiments (Lehne and Koepke 1962, Jokinen and Simojoki 1975, Jorgensen 1976). The advantageous effect of the magnesium fertili- zation has been greater on the magnesium content of cereal shoots harvested before the heading (Jerlström 1975) as well as on that of the straws (Jor- gensen 1976) than on the magnesium content of the grains. https://www.c-info.fi/en/info/?token=C9-__KOtsxDihj27.LncKYfYu_OsWbHQXFjhpoA.NZoIuzVoUIy2ReTtJYxqYlmHRQAu7bCvabRLM4HhQKDX1zMNSTkZdtWxz5-JGb4XhDPFatn-EntRc-tHm6rXbXvTfQnhMz4s3ndizxWCPVqbnHj1qQBJQR6QlHXOnnRXSFc1Ffck4xHnkUcLSLR9x-gf0O5u8BsjOjCu 297 It has been proposed that the decrease in the magnesium content or in the magnesium uptake by plants due to potassium fertilization is caused by the antagonism between potassium and magnesium (Welte and Werner 1963, Alston 1966 b). On the other hand, it has been observed that the shortage of a certain cation causes an increase in the uptake of other cations (Grimme et al. 1974, Mengel et al. 1976). According to Terman et al. (1975) it is possible to obtain definite information about the antagonism between cations only if the addition of the nutrients does not have an effect on the yield. In a pot experiment on a mineral soil the use of lime lowered the magne- sium content of barley harvested before heading (Jerlström 1975). The com- petition between calcium and magnesium in oat shoots was not strong (Alston 1966 a, 1966 b). In solution-culture experiments (Falade 1973) an increase in the magnesium content of a nutrient solution caused a decrease in the calcium content of corn shoots. The total quantity of cations taken up by plants increases as a result of the extent of nitrogen fertilization increasing, and nitrogen in nitrate form raises the quantity of the cations more clearly than the nitrogen in am- monium form (Hansen 1972). In rield experiments the addition of nitrogen fertilizer promoted the uptake of potassium, calcium and magnesium into green oats (Häland 1971). The purpose of this experiment is to clarify the effect of magnesium, potas- sium and nitrogen fertilization, as well as that of lime supply, on the nut- rient content and on the magnesium uptake of oat grains and straws thus treated. The significance of the combination effects of the nutrients will also be studied. Material and methods In a pot experiment, carried out in factorial design, were studied the effects of three different rates of magnesium (Mg0 = 0, Mg1 = 200 and Mg2 = 400 mg/pot Mg), of three rates of potassium (K x = 415, K 2 = 830 and K 4 = 1660 mg/pot K), two of lime (Cax = 2400 and Ca3 = 7200 mg/pot Ca) and of two of nitrogen (N x = 1000 and N 2 2000 mg/pot N) on the nutrient contents, the cationic ratios and the magnesium uptake of the grain and the straw yields of oats during three seasons. As the growth base in 5 liters Mitscherlich-pots was used 250 g of air-dry Sphagnum-peat 4.2). A more detailed description of the experiment has been presented previously (Jokinen 1977). The total nitrogen was determined for the grain and straw samples by means of the Kjeldal-method. The magnesium, potassium and calcium con- tents of the plant samples were determined by means ot atomic absorption spectrophotometry from ash obtained by dry ashing (500° C) and extracting into 0.1 N hydrochloric acid. In the calcium and magnesium determinations the interferences were eliminated by using 5 % La-solution. The nutrient contents are expressed as mg/g dry-matter. In the statistical treatment of the data the same methods were used as in the testing of the yields. 298 Results Magnesium content of grains and straws Magnesium fertilization increased in all the years significantly the magne- sium content of both the grains and the straws regardless of the rate of liming, and potassium and nitrogen fertilization (Table 1). The magnesium content of the yields increased as the rate of magnesium fertilization was increased. The magnesium content of the grains received with the magnesium fertili- zation remained almost constant from year to year, even though the fertili- zation was reneved yearly. The coefficient of variation in all the data was 0.21 for the magnesium content of the grains and 0.58 for the magnesium con- tent of the straws. The effect of the three different potassium rates used in the experiment did not differ from each other as far as the effect on the magnesium content of the grains was concerned, when there was no magnesium fertilization. The magnesium content of the straws, on the other hand, decreased due to the effect of the potassium fertilization in the first and the second years in yields which had received an abundant nitrogen fertilization and liming. Quantities of potassium fertilizer supplied along with the magnesium fertilization did not alter the magnesium content of the grains, either. The magnesium con- tent of the corresponding straw yields decreased year by year, and the dif- ference in the magnesium content with the greatest potassium rate and with the smallest one was significant. The equivalent ratios between the three rates of potassium (415 mg = 10.6 me, 830 mg = 21.2 me and 1660 mg = 42.5 me) and the two rates of magnesium (200 mg =16.5 me and 400 mg = 32.9 me) in the annual fer- tilization were 0.32, 0.65, 1.29 and 2.58. The magnesium content of the grains and the straws of oats depended on the variations of the ratio K/Mg in all the data on the average as follows: K/Mg in the fertilization 0.32 0.65 1.29 2.58 Mg rag/g Grains 1.5d 1.4' 1.3» 1.2» Straws 2.6d 2.0 C 1.7b 1.2» An increase of the ratio from 0.32 to 2.58 decreased the magnesium content of the grains by 20 % and that of the straws by 54 %. The differences between the magnesium contents in the grains on one hand, and in the straws on the other hand, obtained with all the different values of the ratio, were significant. Tripling the rate of lime had in some cases a slight positive effect on the magnesium content of the grains (the first year), while in other cases (the third year) the effect was negative. The magnesium content of the straws increased significantly in the first two years as lime was added, and most clearly at the low potassium level. In the third year also the magnesium content of the straws was depressed as the lime rate was increased at the highest potassium rate. 299 Table 1. Magnesium content of grains and straws (Mg mg/g dry matter). V h I j V/d n Ki K, Kj K; K, K 4 Grains Ist year Nx Mg0 1.0» 1.0" 0.9" 1.1» 0.9» I.o* Mg x 1.30 1.21 l.lc 1.3e l.2 d I.2 2nd year Ni Mg0 0.4a*o 0.3»* 0.2» 0.3a* 0.2» 0.2» Mg, 1.6hH I.2e' 0.6° 2.0"" I.Bl* 1.1» Mg, 2.2"» I.Bl* l.le 2.6n 2.2 m 1.30'g N, Mg0 0.4»*0 0.5*0 0.5*0 0.81 0.601 0.5*0 Mgx 1.4'8* 1.2 e' o.B* 2.2 m 1.4'8* 1.3 e'B Mg, 2.1!°» 1.7H 1.58*1 3.30 2.0"™ 2.l*° 3rd year Nx Mg0 0.5» 0.5» 0.4» 0.5» 0.5» 0.3» Mg x 2.6* 1.8» 1.5*0 2.7* 2.0° I.l* Mg, 3.30' 2.5* . 2.6* 3.7' 2.9*» 1.6*0 The results of the same year do not differ statistically sigcificantly if the same index letter appears. 300 Grains obtained by an ample nitrogen fertilization have seldom a signi- ficantly higher magnesium content than by using a small rate of nitrogen. Doubling the nitrogen fertilization rate increased the magnesium content of the straws in the first year regardless of the rate of lime, and magnesium and potassium fertilization. An increase in the nitrogen fertilization rate did not any longer have a clear positive effect on the magnesium content of the second year straw yields as it had done in the first year. Potassium content of grains and straws The potassium content of the grains did not depend in the first year sig- nificantly on the studied variables (Table 2). The following year the potas- sium content of grains obtained without any magnesium fertilization and with an abundant nitrogen fertilization was higher than the potassium content of the other corresponding grains obtained by magnesium fertilization. The same was observed to be also true of the grains of the third year. An increase in the potassium rate increased the potassium content of the grains only when there was no magnesium fertilization. The potassium content of the straws increased sharply as the rate of potas- sium fertilization was increased, and the increase was independent of the amount of lime, and magnesium and nitrogen fertilization. As was the case with the grains, the potassium content of the straws was also in the second year significantly higher with the high nitrogen rate than the potassium con- tent of the straws obtained by magnesium fertilization. Tripling the rate of lime depressed in the first year the potassium content of the straws. Doubling the nitrogen fertilization rate also affected negatively the potassium content of the straws, through only in the second year. Calcium content of grains and straws The calcium content of the grains was every year somewhat higher without magnesium fertilization than with magnesium (Table 3). The difference in the calcium contents was most pronounced with the abundant rate of lime app- lication. Quadrupling the potassium rate depressed the calcium content of the grains in the first year at both levels of nitrogen fertilization and lime app- lication, but in the second year only with the abundant lime rate. Tripling the rate of lime application increased significantly the calcium content of the straws in the first year regardless of the rate of potassium, mag- nesium and nitrogen fertilization. In the third year increasing the rate of lime increased the calcium content of the straws only if there was no magnesium fertilization or a slight rate of potassium application. The magnesium fertilization and a quadrupled potassium fertilization both depressed the calcium content of the straws regardless of the rates of liming and nitrogen fertilization. In all the years the calcium content of the straws was at its maximum when they had received no magnesium fertilization, but had received abundantly lime and nitrogen as well as a slight rate of potas- sium. 301 Table 2. Potassium content of grains and straws (K/mg/g dry matter). Ca x Ca 3 Kj Kj Kj K, K, K 4 Grains Ist year N, Mg0 5.4»" 5.4»» 5.6abcd 5.9bcde s.9»cde 5.4 a» Mg, 5.3»» 5.4»» 5.7 abcd 5.7 abcd 5.4»b 5.5»bc Mg, 5.2» s.s ab<> 5.7a »cd 5.4 ab 5.3 ab 5.5»be N 2 Mg0 5.8 abcd 5.9 bcde 6.1 cd <> 6.4 e 6.2 de 6.2 dl> Mg, s.s abc s.9b cle 5 gbcde 5 gbcde 6.1 cde 6.0 cde Mg 2 5.8 abcd 5.5»»c s.B abcd s.6abcd 5.8»»cd 6.1 cde 2nd year Nx Mg„ 6.9ab 7.l a»<= 7.5»c 7.0 abc 6.9 ab 6.5 ab Mg x 6.2ab 6.7 ab 6.B ab 6.0» 6.0» 6.2 ab Mg, 6.3ab 6.4ab 6.6ab 6.4 ab 5.7a 6.1 a N, Mg„ 6.4ab 8.4" 13.1« 9.2 d 14.2» 9.7 d Mgi 5.8 a 5.7 a 6.2ab 5.8» 6.2 ab 6.2 ab Mg, 6.1» 5.6» 6.1» 5.9» 5.9» 6.2»b 3rd year Nx Mg0 6.9ab 7.7»<= 8.6« i 9.2d 9.9 d Mgx 6.8 ab 6.2» 7.1 ab 6.6» b 6.0» 5.9» Mg, 7.1» b 6.5» b 7.4»b 6.7»" 6.4»" 6.0» Straws Ist year Nx Mg0 4.8»" 10.2'«h 21.5lm s.o** B.4<= 18.2k Mg x 4.9» b 9.5'k 22.1 mn 4.1» 9.7'e» 17.7 k Mg, 4.4» 10.5«h 22.9" 4.6a» 10.0'eh 18.2k N, Mg0 5.6»c 9.9's>> 18.0" 7.3 d 10.6»i 15.91 Mg x 5.5»° 11.4' 20.81 5.6» 9.5'* 17.5* Mg, 6.5cd 11.5* 22.3 mn 6.2° 9.3' 15.01 2nd year Nx Mg0 9.0 ab° 15.3«ie 39.8» 8.0a »° 12.3a »° 33.4» 1 Mg, 6.9»» 14.2° d° 32.7bl 5.9» 12.7a »° d 30.2» Mg, 5.8» 15.0° d° 33.9"1 5.7» 13.7 b ° d 28.9k» N, Mg0 11.2ab° 24.7'k 48.01 11.3ab ° 20.9°' 48.91 Mg, 5.8» 6.4» b 19.4d°r 5.1» 8.6 ab ° 20.9°' Mg, 4.8» 8.7»»° 22.1°' 5.3» 9.8 ab ° 20.9°' 3rd year Nx Mg0 15.7» 36.4»»° d 48.5»° d 19.8» 63.5 d 65.2 d Mg x 11.3» 20.9» b 53.0° d 15.8» 27.2»»° 52.3»° Mg, 9.9» 20.4» 51.6»°d 15.1» 27.4a»° 59.5 d Meaning of index letters same as in Table 1. Table 3. Calcium content of grains and straws (Ca mg/g dry matter). K, K 2 K t K a K 2 K 4 Grains Ist year Nx Mg„ 2.o de 1.9de 1.4»b 2.0 de 1.7cd 1.4»" Mg x 1.7cd 1.5»bc 1.3" 1.7 cd 1.5»b<= 1.3» Mg 2 1.7 cd 1.4»" 1.2» 1.8»« 1.4»» 1.2» N 2 Mg0 2.0 de 1.8cd 1.5»b » 2.2<» 2.0 de 1.8»d Mg x 1.9 d« 1.5»bc 1.3» 2.1» 1.6bc 1.4»b Mg 2 1.7» 1.4»b 1.2» 2.1» 1.6bc 1.4» 2nd year N, Mg0 1.0bc I.l° 0.8» b 1.2 c 1.0bc 0.8» b Mg t 0.8» bo 0.8»b 0.7» b 0.9» bc 0.8» b 0.6» Mg2 0.8» b 0.8»b 0.6»» 1.0be 0.7» b 0.6» N 2 Mg0 1.0bc 1.0bo 1.9 d 2.4 e 2.6<> 1.7 d Mg t I.o b ° 0.9»b « 0.7» b 1.1» 1.0bo 0.8» b Mg 2 1.0b e 5.2» bc 3.6» 9.3 fg 7.0" def 5.0» bc N 2 Mg0 7.8 det« B.l detgh 7.1 cdef 28.1 m 23.61 11.11 Mgj 7.0 cder 6.2»i>cd 4.2» b 15.3Jk 10.9hI 7.5 de'« Mg 2 7.2cdef 5.9»bcd 4.8» bc 17.lk 10.6bI 7.6 dc'« 3rd year Nx Mg0 8.1» 7.5» 6.6» 26.9 d 19.5" 14.7b Mg x 6.6» 5.3» 5.1» 12.7b 7.4» 5.0» Mg 2 5.8» 4.5» 5.7» 11.8 b 7.5» 5.0» Meaning of index letters same as in Table 1. 302 303 Table 4. Nitrogen content of grains and straws {N mg/g dry matter). K! K 2 K 4 K, K 2 K 4 Ist year Nj Mg0 16.8»» 14.8» 14.8» 15.7»» 13.7» 14.0» Mg x 16.0»" 14.5» 14.8» 15.2» 14.4» 14.0» Mg, 16.4»» 13.8» 14.7» 16.5»" 15.9»* 13.7» N 2 Mg 0 24.5*° 20.5»°* 22.2°*° 31.9» 23.6°*° i9.3bc Mg! 29.2'* 24.3*° 23.4°*° 29.4f* 23.6°* e 20.3»°* Mg, 31.2» 26.5°' 25.5°' 30.3* 23.9°*° 20.3»°* 2nd year N, Mg 0 23.1»» 17.0»" 19.2»" 17.3»» 15.7»" 14.5» Mgj 17.0»» 15.9»» 17.0»» 15.4»" 14.8» 14.1» Mg 2 16.5»b 17.3»" 18.6»» 15.3»» 15.0» 13.4» N, Mg, 33.7»° 31.4»° - 45.1= 43.5° Mg! 30.6» 23.3»» 24.0»» 25.6»» 20.9»» 21.2»» Mg 2 30.6» 24.0»» 25.0»» 28.5» 23.9»» 22.0»» 3rd, year N, Mg„ 42.8» 21.6»» - - Mg x 27.6°* 25.2»° 31.5* 20.3» 19.9» 21.2»» Mg 2 24.7»° 25.9» 27.8°* 19.7» 20.3» 21.3»» Straws Ist year Nj Mg 0 s.B»°* 4.9»»° 5.6»°* 5.6»°* 4.4»» 3.5» Mgx 5.3»»c* 4.1»» 4.5»» 5.8»c * 3.9»» 3.1» Mg 2 5.7»c * 4.7»»° 4.3»» 4.9abc 3.9»» 3.4» N 2 Mg„ 12.0» 7.2*° 6.s°*° 15.1» 9.8' 6.6°*° Mgl 12.38 8.3" 7.2*° 13.85» 7.6*° 5.7»°* Mg2 12.4» 8.2" 7.l*° 13.68» 7.9ef 5.6»cd 2ad year N x Mg0 11.2°* 6.7»» 7.0»» 6.7»» 5.4»» 4.8» Mg t 7.4»» 5.9»» 5.0»» 6.0»» 4.5»» 4.3»» Mg, 6.9»» 5.7»» 4.5»» 5.6»» 4.3»» 3.9» N, Mg„ 22.5° 31.8' 32.8' 30.8' 31.6' 38.3* Mgj 13.3* 7.3»» 6.7»» 12.4°* 7.1»» 7.3»» Mg, 12.6* 7.8»» 7.6»» 11.8°* 8.5»° 6.0»» 3rd year N x Mg 0 23.8*° 25.8*°' 28.6°' 21.4* 30.6' 37.1* Mgi 11.6»° 10.5»»° 12.9° 9.4abc 5.7 a 6.6»» Mg, 10.7»»° 9.5»»° 14.6° 9.0»»° 6.8»» 5.5» Meaning of index letters same as in Table 1. 304 Nitrogen content of grains and straws The effect of the magnesium fertilization on the nitrogen content of the grains was slight during the whole experiment at all the rates of potassium and nitrogen fertilization and at all the rates of lime application (Table 4). Exceptions were the increase, caused by the magnesium fertilization, in the nitrogen content in the first year in the grains, and the depression of the nitrogen content in the second and the third years. Doubling the rate of nitrogen fertilization increased significantly the nitrogen content of the grains of the first year regardless of the rate of magnesium and potassium fertili- zation and the rate of lime application. The plants which had received an abundant nitrogen and potassium fer- tilization developed in the second year so few grains that there was not enough for nitrogen content determinations. In the third year it was pos- sible to determine the nitrogen content of the grains at the two smallest rates of potassium application at the level of low lime application. The nitrogen content of the straws decreased as the rate of potassium ferti- lization was increased. In all the years the differences were the most pronoun- ced for the yields which had received a magnesium fertilization as well as abundant nitrogen fertilization and liming. Without the magnesium fertili- zation the straws contained in the second year more nitrogen with an abun- dant rate of nitrogen application than the yields that had been obtained by using magnesium fertilization. Interdependence of cation contents in grains and straws In the grains there was between the magnesium and calcium content or the magnesium and potassium content no significant correlation. In the straws the magnesium content was depressed as the potassium content increased. Within the data of this experiment the correlation coefficients between the cation contents were as follows: Mg mg/g Grains Straws r Ca mg/g -0.075 -0.020 K mg/g -0.127 -0.295** Potassium to magnesium ratio (K/Mg) in grains and straws In all the years the annually renewed magnesium fertilization decreased the ratio K/Mg in grains (Table 5). The two rates of magnesium application showed no difference in this respect. An inrease in the rate of potassium fer- tilization increased the ratio only in the grains obtained without magnesium fertilization. In the straws the ratio K/Mg likewise decreased significantly every year as a result of the magnesium fertilization. An increase in the rate of potas- sium application increased the ratio K/Mg very clearly without the magnesium fertilization. The increase in the value of the ratio was greater at the low level of nitrogen application than at the high level of nitrogen application. Tripling the rate of lime application decreased the ratio K/Mg at the highest rate of 305 potassium fertilization irrespective of the rate of magnesium in the first year. In the following years an increase in the rate of lime application at the low rate of nitrogen and the highest rate of potassium application increased the ratio. An increase in the ratio of potassium to magnesium in fertilization, increa- sed significantly the ratio of the same cations in the grains and the straws. In all the data from the three years the results were as follows: K/Mg in fertilization 0.32 0.65 1.29 2.58 K/Mg in yields Grains 1.3» 1.4" I.s<= 1.6" Straws 0.8» 1.6b 4.1c 8.3 d The increase in the ratio K/Mg was greater in the straws than in the grains. The two rates of magnesium or the three of potassium fertilization both altered the potassium to magnesium ratio in the yields less than the cation ratios in the fertilization. Ratio of potassium to the sum of calcium and magnesium (Kj (Ca + Mg) ) in grains and straws The magnesium fertilization depressed in the second and the third years the ratio K/ (Ca + Mg) in the grains irrespective of the rate of nitrogen and potassium fertilization and the rate of liming (Table 6). The two rates of magnesium application did not show a significant difference in the results. Neither an increase in the rate of liming nor one in nitrogen fertilization produced an effect on the ratio in the grains. The increase in the ratio caused by quadrupling the rate of potassium fertilization in grains produced without magnesium fertilization was significant from the second year on. Upon increasing the rate of potassium fertilization the ratio K/ (Ca + Mg) in the straws increased every year. The increase in the ratio caused by potas- sium fertilization was smaller at the rate of tripled lime application than at the rate of slight lime application. Also, doubling the rate of nitrogen fertili- zation retarded the increase of the ratio in the first two years. Magnesium uptake The amount of magnesium taken up by the grains depended more clearly on the amount of the yield than on the magnesium content. With the straws, on the other hand, the significance of the magnesium content was greater than that of the yield. The changes in the amount of magnesium taken up by the whole yield followed the changes in the uptake of magnesium by the straws. The amount of magnesium taken up by the grains and the straws increased significantly every year upon increasing the rate of magnesium fertilization, and independent of other tested nutrients (Table 7). Only in the third year did the yields which had received small amounts of calcium and the two greatest rates of potassium take up equal amounts of magnesium when using two different rates of magnesium fertilizer. Table 5. Potassium to magnesium ratio (K/Mg) in grains and straws. K, K, K, K, K« Grains Ist year Nj Mg0 1.7c "e 1.8de ' I.9°'* I.7°<>° 2.o'k 1.8 d°' Mgx 1.3»" 1.4»» 1.6° d 1.4»* 1.4»" 1.4»» Mg, 1.2» 1.3»" I.s*° 1.2» 1.3»» I.s*° N 2 Mg0 I.B