Maataloustieteellinen Aikakauskirja Vol. }2: 49}-}O4. 1980 The effect of selenium fertilizers on the selenium content of barley, spring wheat and potatoes JOHAN KORKMAN Kemira Oy, 00101 Helsinki 10, Finland Abstract When Se-cnriched fertilizers were given to barley and spring wheat on fine sand soils in Southern Finland the Se content in the grain was raised as follows: 50 g Sc/ha increased the Se content by around 50 fig/kg; 250 g Sc/ha by appr. 400 U g/kg; and 500 g Sc/ha by a little more than 900 fA g/kg. The selenium content of potatoes rose to Se/kg dry matter when the soil was enriched with 500 g Se in the form of Na 2 per hectare. The selenium content ofpotatoes was found to be very low when no ad- ded selenium was given. The selenium content of potatoes did not fall when the potatoes were boiled. Introduction Selenium is not an indispensable nutrient for crops. Nevertheless, there have been experimental attempts at raising the selenium content of agricultural produce; in the USA (CARY and ALLAWAY 1973), in New Zealand (GRANT 1965, DAVIES andWATKINSON 1966), and in Denmark (GISSEL-NIELSEN 1971, 1975). TheSe quantities used in the experiments have varied greatly, ranging from a few grammes when crops were sprayed (GISSEL-NIELSEN 1971) to several kilogrammes per hectare when transmitted through the soil (CARY and ALLAWAY 1973). When the selenium has been transmitted through the soil, selenium fertilizer quantities in the re- gion of 100 g Se/ha have proved sufficient to give the desired Se level for fodder crops and hay, 50—100 u g Se/kg (GRANT 1965, GISSEL-NIELSEN 1977). It has been found that much smaller Se quantities give the same results when crops are sprayed if the spraying is done at the right time (GISSEL-NIELSEN 1977). Pure selenium, selenate and selenite were used in the experiments to increase the selenium content of the fertilizers. GISSEL-NIELSEN (1977) has conducted many experiments and he holds that selenite is the best source, even though selenate may be more effective than selenite for raising the selenium content of crops. The same re- searcher has also demonstrated (GISSEL-NIELSEN 1977) that the sulphate content of the soil has a much greater influence on how selenate is transmitted than on how selenite is transmitted. The present study made use of selenite only. The selenite was employed to raise the selenium content of the fertilizers and for crop spraying purposes. The study aims 6 495 JOURNAL OF THE SCIENTIFIC AGRICULTURAL SOCIETY OF FINLAND https://www.c-info.fi/en/info/?token=FcYNuottLf5ROAU5.20_lQZjYb5YFItSDGKG_hg.mXj917rFx_M4qrIUfaE48cY5889tfLkLyCIQfTpxc9M06_83VLCs0QdKrcudpgpLHo8fxzXJTyXnW4Qu6c13ySRky0tYdtw5elHnQoqWPVrShtBGQF8Iq_6SndH0YJPv5dbK-YH-TjGxs6zAbTGc6qwNO72s7qkWn6zA 496 at reaching a preliminary assessment of the manner in which the selenium content of barley, spring wheat and potatoes is raised when selenite fertilizers are sprayed and transmitted through the soil. The selenium-enriched barley obtained as a result of spraying has been used in feed tests on chickens, pigs and horses (KÄÄNTEE and KURKELA 1980a, and 1980b). Materials and methods The fertilizers used in the experiments were prepared at the small factory of Ke- mira Oy’s research plant. Ordinary commercial products were used as raw material; the fertilizers were granulated by being sprinkled with NajSeOj-JHjO solute. The Se content aims for the fertilizers were 0.01 % Se, 0.05 % Se and 0.10 % Se and these levels were realized. A tractor spray was used for carrying out the selenium spraying: a solution of sodium selenite in 400 litres of water was used over one hectare. The field tests were carried out at the Kotkaniemi experimental farm at Vihti. The fertilizers which were meant to be transmitted through the soil were placed with a combined drilling machine. The Kemira Oy Oulu research plant conducted the selenium analyses. The hy- dridemethod was used (SAARI and PAASO 1 980). Results 1 Spraying Suvi barley (sown 17. 5. 1978) growing on sandy loam was sprayed on 21. 6. 1978. The barley was being grown for experimental fodder and was just beginning to sprout when the spraying was carried out. Follow-up samples of the Suvi barley were taken the next year. The spraying treatment was repeated on another plot of sandy loam in the sum- mer of 1979. The Aapo barley had been sown on 17—18. 5. and the spraying was carried out on 21. 6. 1979 when the barley was sprouting. The initial selenium con- tent of the plot sprayed in 1979 was slightly higher than the soil sprayed the year before. 2 Fertilisers transmitted through the soil Grain The selenium fertilizer experiments conducted in 1978—79 were carried out on coarse mineral soil. Barley and spring wheat were treated with experimental fertili- zers which were enriched with Na2Se0 3 . Half of the experiment site was limed with 5 t/ha of agricultural lime before the experiment was instigated. The mean analysis results of the soil samples taken on 1 1. 5. 1978 before liming and fertilizing were as follows; 497 Table 1. The effect of Na 2 Sc0 3 spraying on the Se content of barley, 1978—79. barley grain Se content 11 g/kg dry matter 1978 spraying residual effect in 1979 1. untreated 10 10 2 0.1 kg/ha Se in the form of Na2 SeO, 170 10 3. 0.5 " " " 680 20 4. 1.0 " " " 1000 10 Table 2. The effect of Na2 ScO s spraying on the Sc content of barley, 1979 barley grain Sc content jj, g/kg dry matter 1 untreated 40 2. 0.1 kg/ha Se in the form of Na 2 SeOj 3. 0,5 500 1100 4 1.0 2500 soil type pH H 2 O coarse sand 6,0 Ca NH 4 Ac K NH 4 Ac P NH 4 Ac Mg NH 4Ac B hot water 824 mg/1 soil 154 6,5 80 0,5 Cu 2M HCI Mn MgS04 5,1 4,4 Four fertilizer types were prepared for the grain experiments. The main nutrient and boron content of each type was the same: N 15, P 8.7, K 1 2.4 and B 0.03 %. Selenium content was regulated to four levels with Na2Se0 3 : 0.00, 0.01, 0.5, and 0.10 % Se. The quantity of fertilizer with which the grain was treated was 500 kg/ha. The spring wheat (Tähti variety) harvest was very low both years. The mean 1978 wheat harvest was 1790 kg grain/ha. The 1979 figure was as low as 1310 kg grain/ha. The barley harvest was satisfactory: an average of 4975 kg/ha was ob- tained in 1978, and an average of 3255 kg/ha in 1979. Neither year’s spring whe- at crop was affected by the Se fertilizing. Halving with liming had no significant ef- fect on the grain harvest either. Soil samples were taken in the spring of 1979 after the first year of tests in or- der that selenium analyses might be made. Following the first year of tests the experiment site was divided into two. One half of the site was re-treated with the same Se-enrichcd fertilizer, whereas the other half was treated with normal, seleniumless fertilizer. The type of fertilizer used was the same as that which had been employed the previous year. Liming was not repea- ted. 498 Table 3. The effect of the selenium content of fertilizers on the selenium content of grain, 1978.The same letter in the vertical column = no significant deviation of figures (p = 0.05). grain selenium content Sc (I g/kg spring wheat barley fertilizer limed unlimed limed unlimed Se content kernel middle husk kernel middle husk 1 0.00%5e 170a 175a 117a 100a 105a 137a 40a 50a 2 0.01 %Se 135a 210ab 247a 135a 153a 197a 130b 130a 3 0.05 %Se 467 b 600bc 765 b 290 b 435 b 575 b 450c 480 b 4 0.10%5e 737 b 840 c 1032 b 970 c 1050c 132 5 c 1110 d 1200c Table 4. The quantities of water soluble selenium of soil samples after one test year. fertilizer Sc content water soluble Se mg/1 limed unlimed 1 0.00 %Se 0.0063 0.0068 2 0.01 %Se 0.005 3 0.0060 3 0.05 %Sc 0.0058 0.0065 4 0.10%5e 0.0090 0.0090 Tabic 5. The effect of selenium content of fertilizers on the selenium content of spring wheat grains, 1979. The same letter in the vertical column = no significant deviation of figures (p = 0.05). fertilizer grain selenium content Se*) fl g/kg Sc content limed unlimcd 1979 1978 kernel middle husk kernel middle husk mean 1 0.00%5e 0.00 %Se 60 55 75 60 65 75 65 a 2a 0.00%5c 0.01 %Sc 40 50 50 90 95 60 64 a 3a 0.00%5c 0.05%5e 70 70 60 110 115 75 83a 4a 0.00%5e 0.10%5e 170 200 160 120 120 150 153a 2b0.01%5c 0.01%5e 135 195 195 190 235 210 193a 3b0.05%5e 0.05%5c 415 470 560 410 495 625 496 b 4b 0.10%5e 0.10%5e 1150 1400 1800 1100 1750 1800 1500c *) limed/unlimed F = 0.51 i.c. liming has no significant effect Table 6. The effect of the selenium content of fertilizers on the selenium content of barley grains, 1979. The sa- me letter in the vertical column = no significant deviation of figures (p = 0.05). fertilizer Sc content 1979 1978 grain selenium content limed*) unlimed 1 0.00% Sc 0.00% Sc 40a 75a 2a 0.00% Sc 0.01% Sc 5 5 a 60a 3a 0.00% Sc 0.05 % Se 70 ab 85 ab 4a 0.00% Sc 0.10 %Sc 105bc 130 b 2b 0.01 %Se 0.01 %Se 110c 95b 3b 0.05 %Se 0.05 %Se 370 d 390c 4b 0,10% Sc 0.10 % Sc 1100c 1300d ') limed/unlimcd F = 5.97 x, i.e. the Se content on limed soil is significantly lower 499 Potatoes The selenium fertilizer experiments conducted in 1978—79 were carried out on coarse mineral soil. Rekord potatoes were treated with experimental fertilizers which were enriched with Na 2Se0 3 . Half of the experiment site was limed with 5 t/ha of agricultural lime before the experiment was instigated. The mean analysis results of the soil samples taken on 22. 5. 1978 before liming and fertilizing were as follows: soil type fine sand pH 6.15 Ca NH 4Ac 1400 mg/1 soil K NH 4 Ac 167 P NH 4 Ac 17 Mg NH 4 Ac 158 B hot water 0.8 Cu 2M HO 7.6 " Mn MgSQ 4 6.8 Four batches of fertilizer were prepared for the experiment. Apart from the sele- nium content, all the batches had identical nutrient contents: N 8.0, P 10.5, K 11.6, S 10.7, Mg 2.5, Cu 0.4, Mn 0.7, Zn 0,03, Mo 0.02 and B 0.1 5%. The qu- antity of fertilizer with which the potatoes were treated was 1000 kg/ha. The Se fertilizer treatment was not repeated in 1979 on test plots which were treated with selenium-enriched fertilizer in, 1978 (cp. the section on grain). Instead, a control experiment was set up on another spot on the same plot. The mean analysis results for this area prior to liming and fertilizing were as follows: soil type coarse fine sand pH H 2 O 60 Ca NH 4 Ac 1640 mg/1 soil K NH 4 Ac 164 P NH 4 Ac 16 Mg NH 4 Ac 102 B hot water 0. 5 Cu 2M HCI 8.1 Mn MgS04 12.6 Se water 0.0136 " The same fertilizer type was used in the 1979 potato fertilizing experiments as had been employed the year before. 500 Table 7. Potato crop, 1978 and 1979. potato crop kg/ha fertilizer Se content 1978 1979 1978 1979 limed unlimed limed unlimed 1 0.00 %Se 0.00 %Se 28 570 29 810 21 400 25 120 2 0.01 %Se 0.00 %Se 37 170 33 400 24 830 26 100 3 0.03 %Sc 0.00 %Se 34 790 31 950 26 240 23 450 4 0.10 %Sc 0.00 %Se 35 100 26 640 23 980 21 260 1978 1979 F s x F s x Se fertilizing 2.91 0.01 5.6% 4.4% liming 2.24 0.78 4.3% 6.2% Table 8. The effect of the selenium content of fertilizers on the selenium content ofpotatoes in 1978, and the re- sidual effect in 1979. The same letter in the vertical column = no significant deviation of figures (p = 0.05) potato Sc content Se fl g/kg dry matter 1978 1979fertilizer Se content 1979 1978 1979 limed unlimed limed unlimcd 1 0.00 %Se 0.00 %Sc <■ 10a