Maataloustieteellinen A ikakauskirja Vol. 62: 63—75, 1990 Improvement of annual forage and seed production in the sub-humid zone of Nigeria through supplement irrigation J.O. AKINOLA*, A.A. ADDO**, and K.C. OLUFOKUNBI*** * Department of Animal Science, Faculty of Agriculture, Ahmadu Bello University, P.M.B. 1044, Zaria, Nigeria ** Department of Vocational and Technical Education, Faculty of Education, Ahmadu Bello University, Zaria, Nigeria *** Department of Agricultural Economics, Obafemi Awolowo University, Ile-Ife, Nigeria Abstract. A two-year study was conducted at Shika in the Northern Guinea Savanna of Nigeria to evaluate several perennial and annual forage species for seasonal and total annual herbage and/or seed production. Over the entire experimental period, total dry matter (DM) yields for grasses, perennial and hay-suited annual legumes varied from 27.5 to 79.1, 18.8 to 40.3 and 40.5 to 50.5 t/ha, to which irrigation contributed 48 to66, 50 to 57 and 56 % respec- tively. Irrigated grass crude protein (CP) contents averaged 5.3 and 9.9 %; and legume CP contents 16.1 and 18.8 % for the May and December harvests while rainfed grass CP contents ranged from 7.7 % (August) to 10.9 % (October), the corresponding legume values being 18.7 and 20.9 %. Irrigated cropping accounted for 55 to 56 % of the 9 207 to 12461 kg/haseed yield recorded in dual purpose legumes. It was inferred that on the basis of total herbage yield, distribution of yield and responsiveness to irrigation Pennisetum purpureum, Brachiaria decumbens, Cajanus cajan Acc UQ 50 or 3D 8104 and S. guianensis cv Cook proved to be promising; reasonable seed yield levels were obtained from C. cajan 3D 8104, Glycine max Acc. 49-14 and M 216 and Vigna unguiculata Acc Ivu 1283, whether irrigated or rainfed. The potential of irrigation is discussed in relation to feed, food and livestock production. Index words: irrigation, tropical legumes and grasses 63 JOURNAL OF AGRICULTURAL SCIENCE IN FINLAND https://www.c-info.fi/en/info/?token=1eHns6EaiXp_Lz4q.PFMYKRYC4Ya4Utv8kDMFlQ.w9aLDBsCQJqK8ZBWJQKgPglMW_Dey7b70DSfdQpOIy1BFhAwWlmNeEo6b_q_-zTcR59gCKktqYMjgQ7XPdDCYJnFRaRrJzKSypic9Cpaq7C5_mPv_qHrGlD9x0Hs_sn1eRZwEwLvB7xEh3unV7N_BJb6EOZbQDx_gvIWF7tCHsCuhAlBq4WQS6OOy2Nrebm0Qkvgozkaz2F6GA Introduction For the past 27 years, and more especially since the late 1970’5, it has proved increasingly difficult for Nigeria to provide even a quar- ter of the minimum animal protein require- ments of her teeming population despite the substantial agricultural potential in terms of land, climate and human resources. While there has been a marked shortfall in the na- tional gross protein supply, animal based pro- tein percentage of the human diet has also continually diminished. Computed animal protein supply declined from 8.6 grams daily per caput in 1968 to 6.5 grams in 1980 and be- low 6.0 grams in 1985. These figures repre- sent about 25 to 17 per cent of the minimum daily animal protein intakerecommended by the British Medical Association. Accurate human and livestock population figures for Nigeria are presently unavailable. However, humanpopulation tends to increase more rapidly (presumably because of the phenomenally high birth rates particularly in the rural areas and comparatively low aver- age death rates due to considerably improved primary health care delivery). Based on a projected 2.5—3.2 per cent annual growth rate, this may rise from an estimated 84.9 mil- lion in 1984(Oloruntoba, 1984) to about 134.0 millionby the end of the century. On the other hand, the supply of livestock products by the country’s estimated 9.3 million head of cattle (some authorities quote 11 to 15 million), 8.8 million sheep, 20.8 million goats, 0.86 million pigs and 133.5 million poultry grows only at a rate of about 0.75 per cent annually. Hinged on the above, it is expected that the livestock population level ought to satisfy the country’s animal protein needs but, would be found deficient when translated into performance and livestock units, because of serious ineffi- ciencies in the current livestock production systems. Since the overall annual requirement of animal products grows at a rate of 5 per cent, a rather wide gap thus exists between the domestic supply and demand, a discrepancy which cannot be taken care of even by 1992, unless the supply of animal products grows at an unprecedented annual ra L e higher than 11 per cent. A major constraint on livestock production is theperennial feed shortage, especially dur- ing the drier part of the year. The Pulani pastoralists, who account for over 90 per cent of Nigeria’s cattle population, depend almost exclusively on the natural grasslands and an extensive system of management. Notable characteristics of this include: the use of unim- proved and low yielding native grasses; strik- ing seasonal fluctuations in the quantity and quality of available forage to the extent that overgrazing, severe liveweight losses and in fact high mortality occur during the dry sea- son; livestock owners’ greater interest in the numerical strength than in the care of their livestock; lack of provision for supporting grazing during droughts and long dry seasons with supplements such as cropresidues, agro- industrial by-products and/or high quality feed reserves; shortage of water and mineral licks. Other bottlenecks comprise tse-tse fly in- festation particularly in the humid zone; manipulation of predominantly unproductive livestock breeds and generally inadequate veterinary care and services. The hectarage on hand for livestock graz- ing in Nigeria is decreasing rapidly, possibly as a result of a combination of factors such as mounting population pressure, urbaniza- tion, industralization, land use for crop pro- duction and other agricultural programmes and, desert encroachment. New strategies therefore have to be devisedand developed for improving land meant for agro-pastoralism to match the much needed high output of ani- mal products per animal and per hectare. This is in addition to breeding and utilizing highly productive animals, sizably raising the level of livestock husbandry and applying optimal feeding regimes. One feasible logistic is the integration of ir- rigated forage production into the overall land use package for improving the plane of ani- mal nutrition and hence increasing not only meat and milk output but also the degree of 64 3 animal resistance to attack by pests and dis- eases. The Federal Government of Nigeria, upon realising the need to make more land cultiva- ble, increase crop yields per hectare through a more efficientproduction system and guar- antee sufficient agricultural raw materials for the country’s rapidly developing industries, decided to set-up large irrigation schemes un- der several River Basin and Rural Develop- ment Authorities (RBRDAs). These Authori- ties were mandated to exploit, harness and manage the country’s water resources with the objective of extenuating drought effects and raising all-inclusive agricultural productivity, among other things. More unambiquously, land would be cultivated for the production of crops and livestock both within and out- side the irrigation schemes. Although this im- plicates the production of forage crops, at best irrigation efforts have been concentrated on cereal crops and the residue made available for livestock feeding. Investigations in the subhumid zone of Nigeria (de Leeuw, 1972; Akinola, 1975) demonstrated the potential for forage produc- tion under dry season irrigation conditions. These studies suggested the need for long-term research on the yield responses of forage spe- cies to irrigation and different agronomic practises with a view to removing the con- straints of chronic dry season scarcity of sup- plementary feeds. This paper presents the results of experi- ments conducted over a two-year period to ex- amine a number of forage crops for seasonal and total annual herbage and seed yields when grown under rainfed and dry season irrigated situations. The speculation was that the find- ings might help in the development of irriga- tion assisted forage production programmes, which would alleviate the problem of dry sea- son feed shortages particularly in the sub- humid and drier zones of Nigeria. Materials and methods Location The experimental location was a low-lying area of the National Animal Production Re- search Institute (NAPRI), Shika (latitude 11°12'N, longitude 7°33'E), 22 km north-east of Zaria in the Northern Guinea Savanna of Nigeria. The dry season lasts approximately from October to April while July to Septem- ber accounts for two-thirds of the 1034 mm long-term (1929—1976) mean annual rainfall. The study years contrasted in rainfall intensi- ty and distribution as demonstrated by the occurrence of 857 mm from April to Septem- ber in 1975 and 1284 mm between April and October in 1976. Mean maximum and mini- mum temperatures vary between 35.2/21.3°C (April) and 27.1/12.0°C (January). Mean relative humidity ranges from 15.2 % in January-February to 75.4 % in July-August while sunshine hours decline from 9.4 in November to 5.6 in August. Analysis showed that the o—ls0—15 cm horizon of the sandy clay loan soil, hitherto followed, was characterised apH (H 2O) of 6.2; 1.24 % organic matter; 0.085 % total nitrogen; 0.40 kg/ha water extractable phosphorus; and 1.33, 3.56, 0.38 mequiv. exchangeable mag- nesium, calcium and potassium 100 g, respec- tively. Land preparation On 30 December 1974, the land which had been cleared and two days earlier flood irrigat- ed, was disc-ploughed and harrowed twice. Following compound fertilizer (20N: 10P2O 5 : 10k2O) application by hand broadcast at the rate of 377 kg/ha, 60 cm ridges were made and the furrows filled with irrigation water (Doorn van, 1972). At the start of the second cropping year (December 1975) this level of fertilizer was again applied. 65 Experimental design Three experiments were laid down, each in a randomized complete block design with three replicates, for species herbage and/or seed yield comparisons under rainfed and ir- rigated conditions. A plot measured 6 m x 4.2 m and was separated lengthwise from the next by a metre-wide gap, and, breadthwise by an unplanted ridge while blocks were demarcated by bunds. Planting and management Details of the plant species studied are presented in Table 1. Local Cajanus cajan accession is tall, late maturing and acropetal in the flower development pattern whereas Table 1. Species, immediate origin and sowing rates. Species Immediate origin Sowing rate (kg/ha) Experiment I Perennial grasses and legumes for herbage production Grasses (Perennials) Andropogon gayanus (Gamba) Brachiaria decumbens (Signal) Cenchrus ciliaris cv Biloela (Buffel) Chloris gayana cv Callide (Rhodes) Digitaria smutsii (Woolly finger) S S Q s s Q s s 50* V 7.5 7.5 V Panicum maximum var Trichoglume (Green panic) Pennisetum purpureum (Elephant cv Ngala) Pennisetum purpureum (Elephant cv Shika) 7.5 V V Legumes (Short-livedperennials) Cajanus cajan (Pigeonpea) Acc Local Cajanus cajan (Pigeonpea) Acc. 3D 8104 Cajanus cajan (Pigeonpea) Acc. UQ 50 M 25 I 25 Q 25 Legumes (Perennials) Centrosema pubescens (Centro) S S Q Q Q Q 10 Desmodium scorpiurus (Samoan clover) 7.5 Desmodium uncinatum cv Silverleaf (Silverleaf desmodium) Neonotonia wightii cv Cooper (Cooper glycine) 7.5 10 Macroptilium atropurpureum cv Siratro (Siratro) Stylosanthes guianensis cv Cook (Cook stylo) 10 7.5 Experiment 2 Hay-suited annual legumes for herbage production Glycine max (Soybean) var Congo Yellow M 45 Glycine max (Soybean) var Malayan M 45 Glycine max (Soybean) var Potchefstroom 55 ,M 45 Vigna unguiculata (Cowpea) Acc. Ivu 1283 I 25 Experiment 3 Short-lived perennial and annual legumes for seed production Cajanus cajan (Pigeonpea) Acc. 3D 8104 I 20 Glycine max (Soybean) var Improved Pelican M 40 Glycine max (Soybean) Acc 49-14 Q 40 Glycine max (Soybean) Acc M 216 M 40 Vigna unguiculata (Cowpea) Acc Ivu 1283 I 20 * Seed with involucre sown. V = Vegetatively established. I = International Institute of Tropical Agriculture, Ibadan, Nigeria. Q = University of Queensland, Queensland, Australia. M&S = Mokwa and Shika Stations of the Institute for Agricultural Research, Ahmadu Bello University, Zaria, Nigeria. 66 the C. cajan accessions 3D 8104 and UQ 50 are intermediate and basipetal (Akinola and Whiteman, 1972). Except the C. cajan acces- sions used, Glycine max and Vigna unguicula- ta which had no problem of hardseededness, all legumes were scarified with concentrated sulphuric acid before inoculation with the ap- propriate Rhizobium strain. Seeds were drilled in shallow (1—3 cm) grooves on ridge tops at rates depending on size, germinability and in- tended use or sprigs planted 30 cm apart with- in the ridge on 2 January, 1975. Irrigation was supplied once weekly from November to May unless over 25 mmrain fell shortly before the scheduled irrigation date. Experiment I No subsequent weeding was necessary af- ter that carried out on 20 February, 1975. Her- bage dry matter (DM) yield estimates were based on the inner 4.8 m X 3 m of each plot, the rest being cut and discarded on the dates shown in Table 2. Thus irrigated dry season periods of growths and regrowths totalled 209 and 207 days while rainfed wet season Table 2. Dry matter yields (t/ha) of irrigated and rainfed perennial grasses and legumes. 1975 1976 Harvest Ir* Ra Ra Ir Ir Ra Ra Ir Harvest date 16/5 18/8 15/10 19/12 Species 10/5 9/8 8/10 21/12 Species Species Age** 134 94 58 75 total 133 91 60 74 total A. gayanus 6.28 4.22 3.04 B. decumbens 12.30 5.84 3.53 C. ciliaris 6.82 6.33 2.90 C. gayana 7.57 6.56 3.20 D. smutsii 8.71 4.79 2.18 P. maximum var trichoglume 10.65 5.75 2.29 P. Purpureum cv Ngala 25.36 7.17 5.35 P. purpureum cv Shika 23.89 7.14 5.97 C. cajan, Local 7.55 6.16 3.15 C. cajan, 3D 8104 6.56 5.93 4.60 C. cajan, UQ 50 9.14 6.82 4.70 C. pubescens 4.81 3.77 2.59 D. scorpiurus 3.52 3.10 2.18 D. uncinatum 4.88 3.69 2.05 M. atropurpureum 4.30 3.15 2.71 N. wightii 5.98 3.39 3.17 S. guianensis 7.19 4.88 2.41 Harvest mean 9.15 5.22 3.30 LSD (P =0.05) 1.81 15.35 4.48 3.11 2.55 2.03 12.17 2.30 23.97 10.98 7.54 4.42 2.25 25.19 2.18 18.23 5.63 4.85 3.08 2.33 15.89 1.98 19.31 6.23 5.81 3.17 1.40 16.61 1.59 17.27 7.12 5.13 2.81 1.70 16.76 1.76 20.45 6.08 3.67 2.63 1.85 14.23 4.43 42.31 17.97 8.84 4.54 2.58 33.93 3.83 40.83 21.04 10.52 3.95 2.80 38.31 2.78 19.64 8.83 4.38 1.86 0.69 15.76 3.69 20.78 9.23 4.92 2.03 0.95 17.13 2.87 23.53 10.17 4.09 1.75 0.79 16.80 2.20 13.37 5.29 4.25 1.13 0.53 11.20 1.58 10.38 3.83 3.35 0.75 0.51 8.44 1.98 12.60 3.72 3.16 0.93 0.38 8.19 2.01 12.17 4.11 3.13 1.31 0.54 9.09 1.89 14.43 4.76 4.28 1.06 0.45 10.55 2.05 16.53 6.97 5.18 1.52 0.44 14.11 2.41 20.08 8.03 5.07 2.32 1.31 16.73 3.29** 1.21 *• 1.21** 0.72** 4.31 *• 3.16** 1.82** 0.59** 0.45** 4.91** LSD (P =0.05) mean over two years Irrigated Rainfed Total harvests harvests harvests Year (Y) 0.384** 0.241** 0.225** 0.384** 0.241** 0.318** 0.592NS 0.341** 0.450** I.llB** 0.702" 0.656** 1.582NS 0.993** 0.927NS 1.582** 0.993** 1.311** 2.237** 1.404** 1.854** Harvest (H) YxH Species (S) YxS HxS YxHxS + Ir, Ra = Irrigated and rainfed harvests. * + Days from planting (16/5/75 only) or cut back. NS =Non-significant at P = 0.05; *• Significant at P =0.01. 67 68 periods amounted to 151 and 152 days in 1975 and 1976, respectively. Harvesting was with the hand sickle and cutting heights above the ridge top were 30 cm for C. cajan, 20 cm for Andropogon gayanus and Pennisetum pur- pureum, and 15 cm for theremaining species. The harvested material was weighed, sub- sampled, oven-dried at 80°C for 48 hours, milled and analysed for crude protein (CP = N% x 6.25) content (Aoac, 1970) on plot ba- sis. Experiment 2 Ridges were weeded, cleared of trash and remoulded prior to each of the second, third and fourth sowings on 17 July 1975, 18 De- cember 1975 and 22 July 1976. Each produc- tion cycle required one hand weeding. Har- vesting and sampling for DM yield and CP content determination were as described in Ex- periment 1 except that plants were cut at the cotyledonary node. Days to hay stage, defined as timeof first filled pod changing from green to yellow in 50 °7o of plants, varied from 85 (G. max var Congo Yellow and V. unguiculata Acc. Ivu 1283) to 115 for July sowings and from 120 to 140 for December sowings. Experiment 3 Land preparation procedures and sowing dates in respect of G. max and V. unguiculata were similar to those outlined for Experiment 2 crops above. The G. max examined com- prised relatively early (day 100) Improved Pelican and intermediate (day 116) maturing accessions 49-14 and M216. These days to maturity relied on Shika data during normal growing season. Harvesting for seed yield oc- curred when 90 to 95 % of filled pods had desiccated and were recorded as April/May and end of October for the irrigated and rainfed crops, respectively. C. cajan 3D 8104 stands remained in theplots from the trial es- tablishment to termination but were cut back to 30 cm after each pod harvest in June (ir- rigated) and December (rainfed). At harvest, reproductive branches were cut with hand sickles, sundried for three to four days and threshed. Sub-samples from the seeds recovered were dried to constant weight in hermetically sealed glass desiccator jars for seed yield determination and analysed for CP content (See Experiment 1) G. max CP content being derived from the formula CP = N%x5.71 (Watt and Merrill, 1963). Statistical analysis Statistical analysis of the data was carried out as described by Steel and Torrie (1960). Results Experiment I Dry matter yield The DM yields for four irrigated and four rainfed harvests during the two experimental years are presented in Table 2. Total DM yields were significantly higher (P/0.01) in 1975 (except for Brachiaria decumbens) de- spite the higher 1976 rainfall, 1976 grass and legume yields being lower by 12.5 and 22.5 % respectively. DM yields maximised in May and declined significantly with subsequent harvests to a December lowest so that the pooled ir- rigated harvests far out-yielded the rainfed harvests. Significant species DM yield differ- ences occurred between years and among har- vests within a year. Over both years, the Pen- nisetum purpureum cultivars gave the highest grass DM yields (cv Ngala 76.24 and cv Shika 79.14 t/ha), followed by B. decumbens (49.16 t/ha) with the lowest (27.52 t/ha) resulting from A. gayanus. For the legumes, Stylo- santhes guianensis DM yield (30.64 t/ha) ranked next to the Cajanus cajan Acc. yields (35.40 to 40.33 t/ha), the lowest (18.82 t/ha) for Desmodium scorpiurus being, however, non-significantly different D. uncinatum and Macroptilium atropurpureum yields. Irrigated grass harvests contributed 48 °7o, through 59 % to approximately 66 ®/o of the two-year total DM yields for Chloris gayana (lowest), Panicum maximum var Trichoglume and P. purpureum respectively. The cor- responding legume figures were 50 % for D. scorpiurus, 54 % for S. guianensis and 54 to 57 % for the C. cajan accessions. Unlike other swards, B. decumbens total annual DM yield was higher in 1976 in 1976 because of better May-October growth compared with the relat- ed 1975 period. In only Cenchrus ciliaris and C. gayana were irrigated harvest yields equal to or less than rainfed harvest yields. Crude protein content Average annual and harvest by harvest CP contents for all species are summarised in Ta- ble 3. CP contents were similar for both years but were significantly affected by harvest. Harvests taken in May had the lowest aver- age CP contents, followed by those taken in August, December and October, irrespective of year. Legumes CP contents doubled those of the grasses, which resulted in the highly sig- nificant species differences encountered. Ir- rigated grass CP contents averaged 5.3 % and Table 3. Crude protein contents (% dry matter) of irrigated and rainfed perennial grasses and legumes. 1975 1976 Harvest Ir + Ra Ra Ir Ir Ra Ra Ir Harvest date 16/5 18/8 15/10 29/12 10/5 9/8 8/10 21/12 Age* + 134 94 58 75 Mean 133 91 60 74Species 134 94 58 75 Mean 133 91 60 74 Mean A. gayanus 5.1 8.6 12.3 B. decumbens 5.4 7.4 10.8 C. ciliaris 5.2 7.6 10.3 C. gayana 5.3 6.3 9,8 D. smutsii 5.6 8.0 12.2 P. maximum var trichoglume 5.1 7.5 10.7 P. purpureum cv Ngala 4.9 7.5 11.7 P. purpureum cv Shika 4.8 7.9 11.6 C. cajan, Local 15.5 16.9 21.3 C. cajan, 3D 8104 16.8 17.8 19.8 C. cajan, UQ 50 16.3 18.3 19.8 C. pubescens 15.9 17.3 21.5 D. scorpiurus 16.9 20.6 22.6 D. uncinatum 14.7 17.0 18.6 M. atropurpureum 16.3 19.4 23.5 N. wightii 18.2 21.3 22.0 S. guianensis 15.6 18.1 20.3 Harvest mean 11.0 13.4 16.4 LSD (P =0.05) Year (Y) Harvest (H) YxH Species (S) YxS HxS YxHxS 12.0 9.5 5.8 8.5 11.7 10.7 9.2 9.8 8.4 5.3 7.9 11.0 10.3 8.6 8.8 8.0 6.0 7.9 10.0 9.4 8.3 9.8 7.8 5.5 8.1 10.4 9.9 8.5 10.5 9.1 5.0 7.8 11.6 11.0 8.9 9.5 8.2 5.2 8.2 10.2 9.2 8.2 9.3 8.3 5.1 6.3 10.2 9.4 7.8 9.9 8.6 5.0 6.5 9.9 9.3 7.7 19.0 18.2 14.8 17.2 19.7 18.7 17.6 19.3 18.4 16.1 18.6 20.5 20.0 18.8 18.8 18.3 15.5 17.9 19.3 19.5 18.1 19.0 18.4 15.4 18.1 21.7 19.5 18.7 21.6 20.5 17.3 21.8 23.8 22.5 21.4 17.9 17.1 13.9 16.3 18.1 17.6 16.5 21.9 20.3 15.8 20.0 21.4 20.1 19.3 21.1 20.7 18.8 20.8 22.5 22.2 21.1 19.3 18.3 16.3 17.7 20.9 20.3 18.8 15.1 14.0 11.0 13.5 16.0 15.1 13.9 2.18** 2.77** 3.07** 2.26** 1.67** 2.33** 2.81** 2.70** 3.77** 2.34** LSD (P =0.05) mean over two years Irrigated Rainfed Total harvests harvests harvests 0.521NS 0.472NS 0.328NS 0.521** 0.472** 0.464** 0.737NS 0.668NS 0.656NS 1.520** 1.377** 0.957** 2.149NS 1.948NS 1.353NS 2.149** 1.948NS 1.914NS 3.039NS 2.755NS 2.706NS + Ir, Ra = Irrigated and rainfed harvests. + + Days from planting (16/5/75 only) or cut back. NS = Non-significant at P = 0.05; ** Significant at P =0.01 69 9.9 %, and legumes, 16.1 °/o and 18.8 °7o, for the May and December harvests respectively. Average rainfed grass CP contents varied from 7.7 % (August) to 10.9 % (October), the corresponding values for the legumes being 18.7 % and 20.9 °7o. The two P. purpureum cvs and P. maximum var tichoglume main- tained the lowest CP contents under irrigated, and A. gayanus and D. smutsii the highest, whether irrigated or rainfed. Legume CP con- tents increased from low for D. uncinatum, through S. guianensis and C. cajan, to high for D. scorpiurus and Neonotonia wightii. Crude protein yield The overall effect of year on calculate to- tal CP yield (t DM/ha x °7o CP x 1000) was similar to that observed for total DM yield. Average annual irrigated legume CP yield was 1.0 % more, and grass CP yield 2.9 % less, than the respective rainfed CP yields. The total irrigated grass CP yields in eight har- vests ranged from 1021 kg/ha for A. gayanus to 2792 and 2794 kg/ha for P. purpureum cvs Shika and Ngala, amounting to 44 %, 55 % and 56 °7o of the total two-year CP yields. Comparatively, the legume values ranged from 1634 kg/ha for D. uncinatum, through 2701 kg/ha for S. guianensis, to 3683 kg/ha for C. cajan Acc UQ 50 and amounted to 49 %, 51 *Vo and 54 % of the total two-year CP yields. Experiment 2 Dry matter yield DM yields from one irrigated and one rainfed cropping per year of annual legumes, over 1975 and 1976, totalled slightly more than 40 t/ha (lowest) for V. unguiculata or G. max var Congo Yellow and approximate- ly 54.5 t/ha (highest) for G. max var Pot- chefstroom 55 (Table 4). The overall year ef- fect was non-significant but, regardless of year, average DM yield was significantly greater for irrigated cropping. The contribu- tion of as much as 56 °7o by irrigated cropping to total annual DM yield must have influenced the significant year x cropping interaction. Obvious DM yield differencesbetween but not within croppings were demonstrated by the species. Table 4. Dry matter yields (t/ha) of irrigated and rainfed hay-suited annual legumes. 1975 1976 Ra Species Ir Ra SpeciesCropping Ir* totalSpecies total G. max var Congo Yellow G. max var Malayan G. max var Potchefstroom 55 V. unguiculata Acc. IVu 1283 Cropping mean LSD (P =0.05) 12.1 8.3 20.410.4 9.8 20.2 14.0 10.0 24.013.0 11.6 24.6 14.211.0 25.216.9 12.429.3 10.48.6 19.012.2 9.321.5 12.010.3 22.313.8 10.023.8 3.43NS 3.34NS 4.05* 4.36NS 3.33NS 4.59»* LSD (P =0.05) mean over two years I.OONS I.oo* Year (Y) Cropping (C) YxG 1.42* 1.42*Species (S) YxS 2.00NS 2.00NS 2.83NS CxS YxCxS + lr, Ra = Irrigated and rainfed croppings. NS = Non-significant at P = 0.05; *, ** = Significant at P =0.05, P=0.01. 70 Crude protein content The legumes averaged more CP contents in 1975 (Table 5), a reverse of the DM yield situation, although in neither case were the differences significant. Irrigated and rainfed CP contents compared favourably and the slightly higher value under irrigation were con- sistent among species in 1975 only. Crude protein yield Altogether, G. max vars Congo Yellow, Malayan and Potchefstroom 55 and V. ungui- culata produced estimated CP yields of 5582, 6429, 7449 and 5830 kg/ha to which irrigation contributed 56 %, 57 % and 56 %, respec- tively. Irrigated cropping was significantly su- perior to rainfed cropping and all the CP yield responses to irrigation tended to be better in 1976. Experiment 3 Seed yield G. max var Improved Pelican produced sig- nificantly the lowest total seed yield (9207 Table 5. Crude protein contents (% dry matter) of irrigated and rainfed hay-suited annual legumes. 1975 1976 Cropping Ir + Ra Species lr Ra Species Species total total G. max var Congo Yellow G. max var Malayan G. max var Potchefstroom 55 V. unguiculata Acc. IVu 1283 Cropping mean LSD (P = 0.05) 14.4 13.8 14.1 13.6 13.6 13.7 13.4 13.2 13.3 14.0 12.7 13.4 14.113.7 13.913.4 14.013.7 15.214.9 15.113.8 14.114.0 14.313.9 14.113.8 13.613.7 3.74NS 3.81NS 2.22NS 3.36NS 3.36NS 1.93NS + lr, Ra = Irrigated and rainfed croppings. NS = Non-significant at P = 0.05. Table 6. Seed yields (kg/ha) of irrigated and rainfed perennial and annual legumes. 1975 1976 Cropping Ir+ Ra Species lr Ra Species Species total total C. cajan Acc 3D 8104 3562 2743 6305 3329 2827 6156 G. max var Improved Pelican 2623 2260 4882 2375 1949 4324 G. max Acc 49-14 3118 2733 5851 3505 2786 6291 G. max Acc M 216 3482 2958 6440 3290 2391 5681 V. unguiculata Acc IVu 1283 2951 2504 5455 3246 2347 5593 Cropping mean 3147 2640 5787 3149 2460 5609 LSD (P =0.05) 517.6* 510.7NS 644.6* 479.7** 627.8NS 705.4** LSD (P =0.05) mean over two years Year (Y) 145.0NS 145.0** 205 .ONS 229.2*» 324.2NS 324.2NS 458.4NS Cropping (C) YxG Species (S) YxS CxS YxCxS + lr, Ra = Irrigated and rainfed croppings. NS = Non-significant at P =0.05; *, ** = Significant at P =0.05, P =0.01. 71 kg/ha) over the two years compared with the highest (12 461 kg/ha) recorded for C. cajan Acc. 3D 8104 although the latter only differed marginally from other species yields. The meagre greater average 1975 seed yield was strongly influenced by C. cajan Acc. 3D 8104 and G. max Improved Pelican and M 216 (Ta- ble 6). For both years irrigated cropping gave precisely similar total seed yields which signifi- cantly exceeded yields by the corresponding rainfed cropping. Species seed yield differ- ences within season were significant for ir- rigated croppings and could be accounted for by the low G. max var Improved Pelican yield. On the average, irrigated C. cajan, G. max and V. unguiculata contributed 55 °/o, 55 °lo and 56 % of the overall annual seed yields. Seed crude protein content Seed CP contents tended to have increased generally in 1976 (Table 7). Irrigated crop- pings produced seeds withsignificantly higher CP contents, an observation that was consis- tent for all legumes except G. max Acc. 49-14 in 1975. The major species differences within cropping evolved from the inherently higher values for G. max which considerably out- stripped those of C. cajan and V. unguiculata. Seed crude protein yield Since total seed yields were nearly uniform across the legumes (Table 6), the marked differences in calculated seed CP yields must have been sponsored by the seed CP contents, While V. unguiculata and C. cajan produced yields of 2536 and 2617 kg/ha, G. max yields varied from 3520 kg/ha for va. Improved Pelican to 4746 and 4793 kg/ha for Accs 49-14 and M 216 over the entire two-year period. The higher G. max Acc. 49-14 and V. ungui- culata yields recorded in 1976 were a depar- ture from the average species response trend. Irrigated cropping gave greater CP yields than rainfed croppings and accounted for 55 to 58 % of average annual CP yields. Discussion This study suggested that, if irrigation as- sisted, the total annual herbage DM, CP and Table 7. Seed crude protein contents (% air-dry matter) of irrigated and rainfed perennial and annual legumes. 1975 1976 Ra Species Ir Ra SpeciesCropping Ir + Species mean mean C. cajan Acc 3D 8104 21.6 20.7 21.2 21.5 19.9 20.7 G. max var Improved Pelican 38.2 37.5 37.9 39.4 37.7 38.6 G. max Acc 49-14 38.8 39.0 38.9 40.1 38.1 39.1 G. max Acc M 216 40.2 38.1 39.2 40.5 38.9 39.7 V. unguiculata Acc IVu 1283 23.4 21.5 22.5 23.9 22.6 23.3 Cropping mean 32.4 31.4 31.9 33.1 31.4 32.3 LSD (P =0.05) 3.42** 1.96** 1.75** 2.23** 1.74** 1.29*» LSD (P =0.05) mean over two years Year (Y) 1.43NS 1.43** 2.03NS 2.26** 3.20NS 3.20NS 4.53NS Cropping (C) YxG Species (S) YxS CxS YxCxS + Ir, Ra = Irrigated and rainfed croppings. NS = Non-significant at P =0.05; ** = Significant at P =0.01. 72 seed yield of a number of promising perennial and annual forages/field crops could be at least doubled. Application of irrigation ex- tended the growing season of the environment which represents the Nigerian subhumids with the approximately seven dry months a year and occasional drought incidents. In relation to earlier investigations conducted in Shika upland areas on herbage production from P. purpureum (Akinola, 1976), V. unguiculaia (Akinola and Davies, 1978) and B. decum- bens (Akinola, 1977), and seed production from the tested cultivars of V. unguiculaia (Akinola and Davies, 1978) and G. max (Akinola, 1980) the present results have clearly identified water shortage as a principal constraint to the realisation of the potential yield and quality of adapted forages. The need to use irrigation water judiciously was obvious. Although in the trials, P. purpu- reum and B. decumbens, among the grasses, responded best to irrigation water, the 20— 23 t DM/ha obtained by de Leeuw (1972) from 100-day old P. purpureum established in mid-February at the same site indicated a higher growth rate explicable in terms of ap- propriate timing of irrigation and planting. Establishment in early January or commence- ment of irrigating forage regrowth as early as in December appeared, therefore, undesirable. This could be explained mainly as limitation on growth imposed by the low December— January temperatures. CP contents of grasses harvested in May were low and therefore associated with the long growth interval. Grass herbage thus ob- tainedwould have to be supplemented before feeding to livestock for at least body weight maintenance. The legumes on the other hand contained high CP levels throughout the year. However, since selection for irrigation must be based on material to support profitable meat and milk production ventures which rely not only on high CP content but also adequate herbage energy levels, the legumes to immedi- ately recommend would be C. cajan and 5. guicmensis. Anthracnose disease was not en- countered by S. guianensis under irrigation and wet season stand counts indicated less than five per cent mortality. The large CP yields estimated are notable. While grass CP yields relied heavily on high DM yields, legume CP yields would be ob- served to have been strongly influenced by high CP contents. Most importantly, the year- round DM and CP yield stabilization ex- perienced (Moline, Rehm and Nichols, 1974) certainly points out the significant role irriga- tion could play in overall agricultural output. Although some responsive pure swards have been recognized, more work still needs to be done on grass-legume compatibility under ir- rigation for fuller exploitation of the cli- matic and adaphic environment and to sup- port integration into other cropping systems. Since, currently, wheat and tomatoes are grown under irrigation, the investment cost of irrigating additional hectarages for combat- ing feed shortage, improving livestock nutri- tion and survival and increasing leguminous grain production for human consumption (Addo, Akinola and Yusuf, 1987) and indus- trial purposes, should be minimal. However, this notwithstanding it is necessary to inves- tigate the presumptive cost/benefit ratio of in- vesting in irrigation facilities. Animal population per se is of little impor- tance and the major worry should concern the number of animal units (AU) per hectare. Since overgrazing stems from the sociological inclination of the Fulani herdsmen towards possessing large AU’s than administering proper husbandry and feeding, these short- comings would be substantially reduced by in- creased herbage availability. Shika research has produced encouraging results from a few of the forages examined for beef production from set stocking (Okeagu and Akinola, 1982) cattle milk production when ensiled (Umoh, 1975), sheep dressing percentage in feedlot operations (Adu and Brinckman, 1981)and goat feed cost/unit liveweight gain when pen fed (Ikhatua and Adu, 1984). Moreover, work there also suggested the pos- sibility of animal genetic influences (Ehoche, Adu and Olorunju, 1983) on the various an- 73 imal performances obtained could not be overlooked. Consequently the need would arise for breeding and maintaining animals with genetic potential for production to effi- ciently complement any increased and stabi- lized plane of nutrition. There is a dearth of information from Nigeria’s irrigation schemes on soil water ta- ble and the amount of surface irrigation wa- ter required to avoid over-irrigation when op- timum forage yield and quality are envisaged. Other areas that need further work include soil conservation, soil permeability assessment, potential of lining canals and ditches and of devices for drainage to prevent water-logging. Acknowledgements. The authors are grateful to the staff of Pasture Agronomy Department and Biochemis- try Laboratory, NAPRI, Shika, for plant sampling and analysis. The Directors of the Institute for Agricultural Research, Samaru and NAPRI are thanked for permis- sion to publish this work, which forms part ofa research programme approved by the Boards of Governors ofboth Institutes. J.O.A. would wish to thank the Board of Re- search of the Ahmadu Bello University, Zaria, for fund- ing aspects of this study. Finally, we would like to thank the Scientific Agricul- tural Society of Finland for including our study in their journal. References Addo, A.A.; Akinola, J.O. and Yusuf, H. 1987. Chem- ical composition and organoleptic properties of bis- cuits fortified with pigeonpea flour. Nigerian Food Journal 5: 24—29. Adu, I.F. and Brinckman, W.L. 1981. Feedlot perfor- mance and carcass characteristics of sheep fed vary- ing concentrate levels. Journal ofAnimalProduction Research I: I—l2. Akinola, J.O. 1975. Preliminary assessment of forage legumes under irrigation for out-of-season dry mat- ter and crude protein production. Samaru Agricul- ture Newsletter, 17: 62—67. Akinola, J.O. 1976. Influence of spacing on perfor- mance of elephant grass (Pennisetum purpureum Schum.) duringthe year of establishment in the North- ern Guinea Savanna ofNigeria. Nigerian Journal of Animal Production 3: 172—180. Akinola, J.O. 1977. Establishment of Brachiaria/legume pastures in a Northern Guinea Savanna environment of Nigeria. Proceedings of the 13th International Grassland Congress. Leipzig, German Democratic Rebublic; Voi. 11, 216—226. Akinola, J.O. 1980. Soybean research at Shika, North- ern Nigeria. Proceedings of the First Conference of Nigerian Soybean Scientists. Institute of Agricultural Research and Training, Moor Plantation, Ibadan, Ni- geria, pp. 41—52. Akinola, J.O. and Davies, J.H. 1978. Effects of sowing date on forage and seed production of 14varieties of cowpea (Vigna unguiculata). Experimental Agricul- ture. 14: 197—203. Aoac 1970. Official methods of analysis (11th Edition) Association of Official Analytical Chemists. Washing- ton, D.C. Doorn, J.W. van 1972. Recommendations on irrigated field lay-out in the Kano river project. Second Nige- ria Irrigation Seminar, Zaria, Nigeria. Pp. 90—95. Ehoche, 0.W., Adu, I.F. and Olorunju, S.A.S. 1983. Milk yield, composition and lactation length in Yanka- sa crossbred ewes. Annual Report, National Animal Production Research Institute, Shika, Zaria, Zaria, Pp. 67—69. Ikhatua, U.J. and Anu, I.F. 1984. A comparative evalu- ation of the utilization of groundnut haulms and Digitaria smutsii by Red Sokoto goats. Journal ofAn- imal Production Research 4: 145—152. Kleinschmidt, F.H. and Skerman, P.J. 1977. Irrigation of tropics pasture legumes. In: Skerman, P.J. (ed) Tropical Forage legumes.FAO Plant Production and Protection SeriesNo. 2, FAO, Rome. Pp, 150—158. Leeuw, P.N. de 1972. Irrigated forage crops at Shika Re- search Station. Proceedings of the 2nd Nigeria Irri- gation Seminar, Zaria. 152—156. Moline, W.J.; Rehm, G.W. and Nichols, J.T. 1974. Fertilizer responses of irrigated grasslands. In: Mays, D. (ed.) Forage fertilization. American Society of Agronomy. Madison, pp. 213—229. Okeagu, M.U. and Akinola, J.O. 1982. Effect of nitro- gen rate on liveweight gain of WhitePulani steers con- tinuously grazed on signal grass (Brachiaria decum- bens Stapf.) Journal ofAnimalProduction Research 2: 91—98. Oloruntoba, B.S. 1984. Towards self-sufficiency in food production in Nigeria. Public Lecture, Nigerian In- stitute of International Affairs, Lagos. Steel, R.G.D. and Torrie, H.J. 1960. Principles and procedures of statistics, 2nd Ed. McGraw-Hill Book Co. Inc., New York, 426 pp. 74 75 Umoh, J.E. 1975. A short-term comparison of the value of maize mucuna silage and elephant grass (Pennise- turn purpureum) silage for milk production. Samaru Agricultural Newsletter, 17: 57—61. Wait, B.K. and Merrill, A.L. 1963. Composition of foods raw, processed, prepared. United States Department Agricultural Handbook No. 8 190 pp. Ms received October 10, 1989