Editorial

This year AJISS turns twenty-five. In 1983, during a meeting of the Asso-
ciation of Muslim Social Scientists’ (AMSS) executive board in Plainfield,
Indiana, the pros and cons of establishing a journal were discussed in great
detail and at length. The board members, Dr.Waheed Fakri (president), Dr.
Sulayman S. Nyang (vice president), and Dawood Zwink (treasurer) agreed
that the United States needed a Muslim-led and Muslim-organized schol-
arly publication to address important issues at home and abroad. In their
vision, the journal would educate university and college students, as well as
policymakers, with respect to the life and conditions of Muslims in the social
sciences. In addition, the journal would be a vehicle for articulating and
aggregating Muslim views and understanding of the social sciences. 

Another objective was to provide a forum for Muslim scholars, and
especially for those associated with the AMSS, to publish their research.
At the time, it was felt that Muslim scholars engaged in social science
research projects with an Islamic perspective found mainstream scholarly
journals inhospitable. The board thought that the proposed journal would
become – as it has – a forum for cutting-edge research in the social sci-
ences and the humanities, employing both the standard social science
research methodologies as well as the Islamic theoretical and methodolog-
ical perspectives.

Two issues were critical: (1) obtaining the financial resources needed to
sustain the proposed journal and (2) its viability and effectiveness. After the
go-ahead decision had been taken, and in order to establish the journal, the
board members drew upon the intellect and services of AMSS members as
well as friends and sympathizers. With this in mind, Dr. Mumtaz Ahmad, a
respected and active AMSS member and friend of Dr. Nyang, was proposed
as the journal’s co-editor. Dr. Nyang became the editor-in-chief and Dr.
Ahmad, a former editor of a scholarly journal in Pakistan, became the edi-
tor. Several prominent Muslims were invited to serve on the advisory board
to widen the circle of involvement. 

Their hard work came to fruition in 1984, when the first issue of the
American Journal of Islamic Studies (AJIS) was published. For the first cou-
ple of years, the headquarters of the AJIS was located in the briefcases of
Drs. Nyang and Ahmad. The editorial board meetings were held around their

PDF created with pdfFactory trial version www.software-partners.co.uk

http://www.software-partners.co.uk
http://www.software-partners.co.uk


dining tables and occasionally in the lounge of the Dupont Plaza Hotel in the
Dupont Circle area of Washington, DC. They would meet on weekends at
dinner (alternatively at each other’s home), write letters to prospective con-
tributors, do the initial review, forward the suitable ones to referees, correct
the proofs, compile the mailing list, and do other editorial and clerical work.
Most of the time they would finish past midnight, and then one of them
would rush over to Br. Fakhri Al-Barzinji’s International Graphics Press with
the corrected proofs, often pleading with him to deliver the journal on time
but to wait for the check for another month. They received very encourag-
ing feedback on the first two issues from their peers, and were quite excited
that the experiment was bearing fruit.

Due to a change in financial sponsorship, which helped establish the
journal’s long-term financial viability, in 1987 it was renamed the American
Journal of Islamic Social Sciences (AJISS) and gained new editorial board
members. Dr. AbdulHamid AbuSulayman, then president of the International
Institute of Islamic Thought (IIIT), was elected AMSS president and became
the journal’s editor-in-chief. Dr. Sayyid Muhammad Syeed, at that time IIIT’s
academic director, was entrusted with the editorial duties. Other editorial staff
members were also hired.

The transition from AJIS to AJISS was the result of Dr. AbuSulayman’s,
Dr. Syeed’s, and IIIT’s attempt to give the journal a more Islamo-centric per-
spective based upon the ideas of Dr. Ismail Raji al-Faruqi, a co-founder of
AMSS. Thus, it reflected the understanding that the journal, now housed
within IIIT’s headquarters, would make a significant contribution to the
development and articulation of the ideas propounded by Islamic social sci-
ence. This was in keeping with IIIT’s long-standing belief in the Islamization
of knowledge. One noticeable change in the journal’s editorials was the inno-
vative Islamic injection that Dr. AbuSulayman added to its character.

Not all original board members were persuaded by the rationales
behind the name change. There was some concern that it implied that
“Islamic social science” is already an accomplished fact, whereas these mem-
bers considered it to be a work in progress. In addition, there was an appre-
hension that the new title would restrict the journal’s coverage to social sci-
ences and that scholars of humanities would feel discouraged from submit-
ting their work. However, after three years it was understood that financial
viability ruled the day. Since the journal was now financially secure and all
of the steps needed to secure a name and a place in the academy were now
evident to the journal’s editors and the AMSS membership, it was decided
to continue the financial relationship with IIIT while leaving the editorial

ii The American Journal of Islamic Social Sciences 25:1

PDF created with pdfFactory trial version www.software-partners.co.uk

http://www.software-partners.co.uk
http://www.software-partners.co.uk


duties in the hands of the editors. What was remarkable about the journal,
both then as well as now, was its vision for Muslims in the academy. 

Over the years, the attempt to realize the goals of the journal’s founders
has taken the form of articles and book reviews contributed by both recog-
nized and young scholars who write for the journal. Certainly, a growing
body of knowledge has developed from the research works of Muslims and
non-Muslims interested in Muslim perspectives on the social sciences. 

In conclusion, three points deserve attention: (1) the driving spirit that
inspired and galvanized the founders to create such a journal, (2) the win-
win relationship of IIIT and AMSS, which has kept the journal growing
without necessarily compromising its relevance and scholarly credibility,
and (3) the great deal of credit that should be given to the leadership of Dr.
Waheed Fakri and his board for their bold decision to undertake this task.
Similarly, the countless hours expended by Dr. Ahmad to recruit Muslim and
non-Muslim contributors added a great weight to the collaborative nature of
his relationship with the founding editor-in-chief, Dr. Nyang. Thus twenty-
five years on and after a succession of dedicated editors, AJIS/AJISS has
every right to be proud of its consistent track record of serving as a forum
for bringing Muslim perspectives to bear on contemporary issues facing
Muslims, and indeed the world, today. Recording the history of such Amer-
ican Muslim social, intellectual, and political associations as AMSS/AJISS is
crucial, for the resulting track record helps to anchor Muslims in the histori-
cal social fabric of American society. (Many thanks to Dr. Sulayman Nyang,
Dr. Mumtaz Ahmad, and Layla Sein for contributing to this brief history.) 

With this celebratory year, we are pleased to announce the journal’s new
editorial structure. A new team of experts, all of whom are committed to
AJISS’ continued success, have honored us by agreeing to serve as associ-
ate editors. First, I would like to thank the outgoing board members for their
invaluable contribution to AJISS’ growth and development. We pray that
God will reward you and your families with success in this life and the next.
I would now like to introduce the new associate editors: Dr. Imad-ad-Dean
Ahmad, Dr. Mehmet Asutay, Dr. Marcia Hermansen, Dr. Haifaa Jawad, and
Dr. Ahmad Yousif. As you will see from the short biographies at the end of
the editorial, their combined expertise represents a wealth of information for
AJISS to tap. We welcome them and wish them well in this new venture.

It is also fitting that in this anniversary year we share with our readers
the achievements of one of AJISS’ strongest supporters: Dr. Jamal Barzinji
(vice president, IIIT). In June 2007, Dr. Bazinji accepted the International
Center for Religion and Diplomacy’s (ICRD) first “Faith in Action” award

Editorial iii

PDF created with pdfFactory trial version www.software-partners.co.uk

http://www.software-partners.co.uk
http://www.software-partners.co.uk


at a dinner in Georgetown. The ICRD, founded in 2000, aims “to promote
conflict resolution around the globe using common threads in religion.”
They have ongoing projects in Sudan, Kashmir, Pakistan, and Iran. The
award is meant to distinguish those “exceptional individuals who increase
religious understanding in a way that enables others to see the ‘spark of the
divine’ in their fellow human beings.”

The ICRD chose Dr. Barzinji for “his work in enhancing Islamic
thought around the world to accommodate the challenges of modernity.” Dr.
Anwar Ibrahim (former deputy prime minister of Malaysia) spoke on his
long friendship with Dr. Barzinji, and Rep. Keith Ellison (D-MN), the first-
ever Muslim congressman, gave the keynote address. In his acceptance
speech Dr. Barzinji said:

Allow me to tell you how greatly and deeply honored I am to accept this award
as a trustee of IIIT, and on behalf of IIIT, its Board of Trustees, my colleagues
here in the US, and those spread across the globe, without whom none of our
work would have been possible. IIIT works for a mission of reform of Thought
and Education, aspiring to use the power of faith and ideas to generate social
transformation in a culture of moderation, tolerance and understanding. Prophet
Muhammed teaches us: faith is “that which is established in the heart and veri-
fied through action.” Among the men who put their faith in action and gave up
their lives for it are Malcom X who said “A man who stands for nothing, will fall
for any thing.” A man who stood for his faith was the reverend Martin Luther
King, Jr., who once referred to “a creative battle to end the long night of injus-
tice.” Faith in Action is this creative battle; that gives us the hope that “something
extraordinary can always happen in our lives.” And it appears to be extraordinary
to end extremism and terrorism, to root out intolerance, to bring balance to our
foreign policy, to abolish bigotry, and to restore respect and honor for our civil
and Constitutional rights. We must put our faith into action for peace, peace at
home and around the world. It is with this resolve, that I accept this award. (mus-
limlinkpaper.com/mybo2/index2.php?option=com_content&do_pdf=1&id=
1022.) 

* * *

In this issue, our first article echoes Dr Barzinji’s above-mentioned senti-
ments by focusing on the role played by language in a conflict, specifically
how it can be used to alienate and contribute to hatred on both sides. Ahmad
Shehu Abdussalam’s “Intra-Muslim Conflicts: A Linguistic Representation”
investigates this phenomenon and concludes that while negativity expressed
through language contributes to conflict, the opposite is also true, for conflicts
can be ameliorated (along with other conditions) via a more positive lin-
guistic representation of the other side. This conclusion, while seemingly

iv The American Journal of Islamic Social Sciences 25:1

PDF created with pdfFactory trial version www.software-partners.co.uk

http://www.software-partners.co.uk
http://www.software-partners.co.uk


self-evident, appears to be a lesson that people find exceedingly difficult to
follow: witness the negative effects that Islamo-facism has had on the Muslim
world and the concomitant rise in anti-American/western sentiment.

Our next piece investigates how Shi`i jurists have interpreted the con-
cept of bada (the idea that God alters His own decrees) over time. Cemil
Hakyemez’s “Bada and Its Role in the Debates over Shi`i Doctrine” con-
cludes that over time, jurists settled on an understanding of bada that gave
precedence to a rational interpretation of the doctrine over other possible
interpretations. H. A. Hellyer’s “Muslims in Europe: Precedent and Present”
reminds us of the historical interconnections between Muslims and Europe
as way to emphasize the wrongheadedness as well as the dangers of the cur-
rent alienation of Muslims engendered by specific European and American
actions and policies.

Given the rise of embezzlement in the white-collar sector over the past
decade, scholars have turned their attention to religious institutions. Since
most of resulting literature has focused on the church, Maliah Sulaiman, Siti
Alawiah Siraj, and Shahul Hameed Mohamed Ibrahim decided to investi-
gate the situation in state mosques in West Malaysia. Their study, “Internal
Control Systems in West Malaysia’s State Mosques,” concludes that the
state mosques “have a strong internal control system pertaining to the receipt
of income and disbursement of funds.”

Our article section closes with a detailed examination of the legal, polit-
ical, economic, and spiritual origins and teachings of human rights in Islam
in order to show the common identity of classical American and classical
Islamic thought so that Muslims, Christians, and Jews can unite against reli-
gious extremism. This article is a response to what Robert Dickson Crane
believes is a new strategy to single out Islam’s essential values, deny that they
exist, and assert that their absence constitutes the Islamic threat. 

In our forum section, we feature Dr. Sulayman Nyang’s inaugural edi-
torial for the American Journal of Islamic Studies. Despite the passage of
twenty-five years and the comings and goings of key personnel, the ideas
and the vision contained therein remain just as valid today as they were then.

Finally, it is with sadness that we announce the passing of Dr. Ilyas Ba-
Yunus, a pillar of the North American Muslim community and a past presi-
dent of AMSS. Inna lillahi wa inna ilayhi raji`un. We pray that God will for-
give his sins, grant him Paradise, and give his family patience during their
time of loss. His son, Asad Bayunus, has graciously allowed us to publish
the obituary he wrote for his father. 

Editorial v

PDF created with pdfFactory trial version www.software-partners.co.uk

http://www.software-partners.co.uk
http://www.software-partners.co.uk


Ilyas Ba-Yunus: A Muslim American Sociologist
1932-2007

Dr. Ilyas Ba-Yunus, a pioneering Muslim American sociologist, a founding member
of MSA and the first president of ISNA, passed away on Oct. 5 in Miami, FL. A pio-
neer of the Muslim American community and an advocate for protecting the
Muslim family and community, he was honored with the ISNA Community Service
Recognition Award in 2006. An American flag was flown in his honor at the United
States Capitol. Ba-Yunus, born in Aurangabad, Hyderabad (a state occupied by
India in 1948), was a 1960 Fulbright scholar at the University of Minnesota, where
he completed an MA in geography. He then went on to earn an MA in sociology
(University of Illinois) and a Ph.D. in sociology (Oklahoma State University). Over
the years, he established standards for studying Muslim Americans.

An active member of the University of Minnesota’s Muslim association right after
his arrival, he recalled for “Islamic Horizons” in 2003 how the MSA was founded:
“It was a stormy and icy morning, the first day of January 1963, when change came
for the Muslim American community. The Muslim student group – at that time the
Islamic Cultural Society – at the University of Minnesota had just received an invi-
tation from the Muslim Student Association of University of Illinois at Urbana-
Champaign (UIUC) – another of the few Muslim student groups scattered across the
nation at the time – asking us to join an effort to form a national organization of
Muslim students in the U.S. and Canada. It would be called ‘the MSA’ – Muslim
Students Association. Along with 13 other local Muslim student organizations from
around the country, we answered the challenge.”

Ba-Yunus spent nearly all of his free time working for MSA, traveling to various
campuses, lecturing and organizing programs nationwide. In 1969, he was elected
MSA vice president, but soon had to assume the presidency when the then-president
was debilitated in an auto accident.

After completing his Ph.D., Ba-Yunus began teaching at Bradley University.
Among his proposals and projects was a report advocating the establishment of a
community-based organization to succeed MSA, as more Muslim students were
finishing their studies and settling in North America. Out of this discussion came
the Islamic Society of North America (ISNA), an umbrella organization consisting
of the MSA, the Association of Muslim Social Scientists, the Islamic Medical
Association, and other Muslim organizations.

In 1972, Ba-Yunus settled into his career, teaching at the State University of New
York at Cortland as a tenured professor until his retirement in 2003. He dedicated
his scholarship to his chosen field of Islamic Sociology, often drawing parallels
between Ibn Taymiyya, who was from the Hadramaut province of Yemen, and him-
self, who’s grandfather was also from Hadramaut. He was a part of the fabric of
AMSS, not only from its inception, but also as its president from 1975-1976. It was
through AMSS and East-West University that Dr. Ba-Yunus began and introduced
his thorough study of Muslims in America, calculating the most authoritative esti-
mate of the Muslim population in the United States as well as the demographic and
religious tendencies of the Muslim populus.

vi The American Journal of Islamic Social Sciences 25:1

PDF created with pdfFactory trial version www.software-partners.co.uk

http://www.software-partners.co.uk
http://www.software-partners.co.uk


His scholarship and hard work also drew the attention of then Pakistan’s Presi-
dent, General Zia Ul Haq, who often called him to Islamabad to discuss issues of
national and international importance. General Zia also asked Dr. Ba-Yunus to serve
as Pakistan’s Ambassador to Iran just prior to the Iranian revolution, but due to the
development of ISNA in the United States at the same time, he declined the offer to
allow him to participate in our community.

As ISNA’s first president (1983-85), he oversaw the organization’s earliest growth
and formative periods while living at the headquarters in Plainfield, IN. Since then,
he served on its Majlis al-Shura board in various capacities, most recently as the
chairman of the Islamic Media Foundation (IMF). He also started the ISNA
Matrimonial Referral Service, which emerged directly out of his research on
divorce among the Muslim community in North America.

Many of Ba-Yunus’ research and publications focused on the demographics and
sociology of Muslims in North America. In 1989, he helped develop the curriculum
of the International Islamic University (IIU) in Malaysia. He also traveled to Turkey
numerous times to discuss his writings on Islamic sociology. During his career, he
wrote six books; was published in several others; and contributed to numerous pub-
lications, journals, and magazines, among them “Islamic Horizons.” His most recent
book, Muslims in the United States (Greenwood Press: 2006), was co-authored with
Kassim Kone. His most recent achievement was the formation of the ISNA House
of Community Representatives, a body meant to increase the direct participation of
affiliated Muslim communities in the ISNA Majlis al-Shura.

He is survived by Sayeda, his wife of thirty-nine years, his son Asad, and his two-
year old granddaughter Hafsah.

Biographies of the New Assistant Editors
IMAD-AD-DEAN AHMAD, PH.D.: Dr. Ahmad graduated cum laude from
Harvard in 1970 and went on to obtain a Ph.D. in astronomy and astrophysics
from the University of Arizona (1975). Currently president of the Minaret of
Freedom Institute, an Islamic think-tank in Metropolitan Washington, DC,
he is an internationally sought-after speaker on matters relating to Islam and
Muslims. In addition, he is an author and teaches courses at the University of
Maryland (religion and progress; religion, science, and freedom) and at
Georgetown University’s Center on Muslim-Christian Understanding (Islam,
science, and development). 

MEHMET ASUTAY, PH.D.: Dr. Asutay earned his Ph.D. in political economics
from the University of Leicester. Before moving to Durham University, he
was a lecturer in economics and social theory at the Markfield Institute of
Higher Education (affiliated to Loughborough University), where he taught
international development and finance, quantitative methods, cross-cultural
management, and research methodology in social sciences. His reaserch
interests are political economy; public choice; institutional economics; devel-

Editorial vii

PDF created with pdfFactory trial version www.software-partners.co.uk

http://www.software-partners.co.uk
http://www.software-partners.co.uk


opment economics; international finance; the political economy of Turkey
and the Middle East; and Islamic economics, finance, and management. He
has numerous publications and conferences presentations to his credit.

MARCIA HERMANSEN, PH.D.: In her capacity as a professor of theology and
director of the Islamic World Studies program at Loyola University (Chi-
cago), Dr. Hermansen teaches courses in Islamic studies and religious stud-
ies. She received her Ph.D. from the University of Chicago in Arabic and
Islamic studies. During her research and language training, she lived for
extended periods in Egypt, Jordan, India, Iran, Turkey, and Pakistan. She con-
ducts research in Arabic, Persian, Urdu, and Turkish as well as in major
European languages. Her book, The Conclusive Argument from God, a study
and translation (from Arabic) of Shah Wali Allah of Delhi’s Hujjat Allah al-
Baligha, was published in 1996. She is co-editor of the Encyclopedia of Islam
and the Muslim World (2003) and over the years has contributed numerous
academic articles in the fields of Islamic thought, Sufism, Islam and Muslims
in South Asia, Muslims in America, and women and gender in Islam. 

HAIFAA JAWAD PH.D.: Dr. Jawad, B.A. and M.A. (Baghdad University),
Ph.D. (Exeter University) is senior lecturer in Islamic and Middle Eastern
studies, Department of Theology and Religion, University of Birmingham.
She specializes in the socio-political study of Islam; modern Islamic thought;
contemporary Islamic issues; Islamic spirituality; Islamic ethics; Christian,
Jewish, and Muslim relations; Euro-Arab relations; Middle East politics;
Islam and the West; Islam and democracy; women’s issues in Islam; and fem-
inism and Islam. Among her many publications are “Female Conversion to
Islam: The Sufi Paradigm,” in K. Nieuwkerk (ed.), Women Embracing Islam:
Gender and Conversion in the West (Texas University Press: 2006)  and
“Islam and Democracy in the 21st Century,” in Gabriele Marranci (ed.),
Muslims, Globalisation, and Secularism (Springer: forthcoming). 

AHMAD YOUSIF, PH.D.: Dr. Yousif is currently teaching at the Department of
Religious Studies, University of Winnipeg, Manitoba, Canada. He teaches
courses on classical and contemporary Islam, including “Muslims in Can-
ada.” The author of four books and numerous articles published in scholarly
journals, Yousif is an active participant in both national and international
academic gatherings. As a professor of Islamic studies, he is widely credited
with having pioneered the research areas on Muslims in Canada, Islam in
Southeast Asia, religious minorities, and world religions.

Katherine Bullock
Editor, AJISS and Vice President, AMSS

viii The American Journal of Islamic Social Sciences 25:1

PDF created with pdfFactory trial version www.software-partners.co.uk

http://www.software-partners.co.uk
http://www.software-partners.co.uk