id sid tid token lemma pos bracis-19020 1 1 a a DET bracis-19020 1 2 protocol protocol NOUN bracis-19020 1 3 for for ADP bracis-19020 1 4 argumentation argumentation NOUN bracis-19020 1 5 - - PUNCT bracis-19020 1 6 based base VERB bracis-19020 1 7 persuasive persuasive ADJ bracis-19020 1 8 negotiation negotiation NOUN bracis-19020 1 9 dialogues dialogue NOUN bracis-19020 1 10 | | ADV bracis-19020 1 11 springer springer NOUN bracis-19020 1 12 nature nature NOUN bracis-19020 1 13 link link PROPN bracis-19020 1 14 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 1 15 formerly formerly ADV bracis-19020 1 16 springerlink springerlink NOUN bracis-19020 1 17 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 1 18 skip skip VERB bracis-19020 1 19 to to ADP bracis-19020 1 20 main main ADJ bracis-19020 1 21 content content NOUN bracis-19020 1 22 advertisement advertisement NOUN bracis-19020 1 23 log log NOUN bracis-19020 1 24 in in ADP bracis-19020 1 25 menu menu NOUN bracis-19020 1 26 find find VERB bracis-19020 1 27 a a DET bracis-19020 1 28 journal journal NOUN bracis-19020 1 29 publish publish VERB bracis-19020 1 30 with with ADP bracis-19020 1 31 us we PRON bracis-19020 1 32 track track VERB bracis-19020 1 33 your your PRON bracis-19020 1 34 research research NOUN bracis-19020 1 35 search search NOUN bracis-19020 1 36 cart cart NOUN bracis-19020 1 37 home home NOUN bracis-19020 1 38 intelligent intelligent ADJ bracis-19020 1 39 systems system NOUN bracis-19020 1 40 conference conference NOUN bracis-19020 1 41 paper paper NOUN bracis-19020 1 42 a a DET bracis-19020 1 43 protocol protocol NOUN bracis-19020 1 44 for for ADP bracis-19020 1 45 argumentation argumentation NOUN bracis-19020 1 46 - - PUNCT bracis-19020 1 47 based base VERB bracis-19020 1 48 persuasive persuasive ADJ bracis-19020 1 49 negotiation negotiation NOUN bracis-19020 1 50 dialogues dialogue NOUN bracis-19020 1 51 conference conference NOUN bracis-19020 1 52 paper paper NOUN bracis-19020 1 53 first first ADV bracis-19020 1 54 online online ADV bracis-19020 1 55 : : PUNCT bracis-19020 1 56 28 28 NUM bracis-19020 1 57 november november PROPN bracis-19020 1 58 2021 2021 NUM bracis-19020 1 59 pp pp ADP bracis-19020 1 60 18–32 18–32 NUM bracis-19020 1 61 cite cite VERB bracis-19020 1 62 this this DET bracis-19020 1 63 conference conference NOUN bracis-19020 1 64 paper paper NOUN bracis-19020 1 65 access access NOUN bracis-19020 1 66 provided provide VERB bracis-19020 1 67 by by ADP bracis-19020 1 68 university university PROPN bracis-19020 1 69 of of ADP bracis-19020 1 70 notre notre PROPN bracis-19020 1 71 dame dame PROPN bracis-19020 1 72 hesburgh hesburgh PROPN bracis-19020 1 73 library library PROPN bracis-19020 1 74 download download PROPN bracis-19020 1 75 book book NOUN bracis-19020 1 76 pdf pdf PROPN bracis-19020 1 77 download download NOUN bracis-19020 1 78 book book NOUN bracis-19020 1 79 epub epub PROPN bracis-19020 1 80 intelligent intelligent ADJ bracis-19020 1 81 systems system NOUN bracis-19020 1 82 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 1 83 bracis bracis NOUN bracis-19020 1 84 2021 2021 NUM bracis-19020 1 85 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 1 86 a a DET bracis-19020 1 87 protocol protocol NOUN bracis-19020 1 88 for for ADP bracis-19020 1 89 argumentation argumentation NOUN bracis-19020 1 90 - - PUNCT bracis-19020 1 91 based base VERB bracis-19020 1 92 persuasive persuasive ADJ bracis-19020 1 93 negotiation negotiation NOUN bracis-19020 1 94 dialogues dialogue NOUN bracis-19020 1 95 download download VERB bracis-19020 1 96 book book NOUN bracis-19020 1 97 pdf pdf PROPN bracis-19020 1 98 download download NOUN bracis-19020 1 99 book book PROPN bracis-19020 1 100 epub epub PROPN bracis-19020 1 101 mariela mariela PROPN bracis-19020 1 102 morveli morveli PROPN bracis-19020 1 103 - - PUNCT bracis-19020 1 104 espinoza espinoza PROPN bracis-19020 1 105     SPACE bracis-19020 1 106 orcid orcid NOUN bracis-19020 1 107 : : PUNCT bracis-19020 1 108 orcid.org/0000-0002-7376-227110 orcid.org/0000-0002-7376-227110 PROPN bracis-19020 1 109 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 1 110 ayslan ayslan NOUN bracis-19020 1 111 possebom possebom NOUN bracis-19020 1 112     SPACE bracis-19020 1 113 orcid orcid NOUN bracis-19020 1 114 : : PUNCT bracis-19020 1 115 orcid.org/0000-0002-1347-585211 orcid.org/0000-0002-1347-585211 NOUN bracis-19020 1 116 & & CCONJ bracis-19020 1 117 cesar cesar PROPN bracis-19020 1 118 augusto augusto PROPN bracis-19020 1 119 tacla tacla ADJ bracis-19020 1 120     SPACE bracis-19020 1 121 orcid orcid NOUN bracis-19020 1 122 : : PUNCT bracis-19020 1 123 orcid.org/0000-0002-8244-897010 orcid.org/0000-0002-8244-897010 PROPN bracis-19020 1 124     SPACE bracis-19020 1 125 part part NOUN bracis-19020 1 126 of of ADP bracis-19020 1 127 the the DET bracis-19020 1 128 book book NOUN bracis-19020 1 129 series series NOUN bracis-19020 1 130 : : PUNCT bracis-19020 1 131 lecture lecture NOUN bracis-19020 1 132 notes note NOUN bracis-19020 1 133 in in ADP bracis-19020 1 134 computer computer NOUN bracis-19020 1 135 science science NOUN bracis-19020 1 136 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 1 137 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 1 138 lnai lnai ADJ bracis-19020 1 139 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 1 140 volume volume NOUN bracis-19020 1 141 13073 13073 NUM bracis-19020 1 142 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 1 143 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 1 144 included include VERB bracis-19020 1 145 in in ADP bracis-19020 1 146 the the DET bracis-19020 1 147 following follow VERB bracis-19020 1 148 conference conference NOUN bracis-19020 1 149 series series NOUN bracis-19020 1 150 : : PUNCT bracis-19020 1 151 brazilian brazilian ADJ bracis-19020 1 152 conference conference NOUN bracis-19020 1 153 on on ADP bracis-19020 1 154 intelligent intelligent ADJ bracis-19020 1 155 systems system NOUN bracis-19020 1 156 802 802 NUM bracis-19020 1 157 accesses access VERB bracis-19020 1 158 2 2 NUM bracis-19020 1 159 citations citation NOUN bracis-19020 1 160 abstract abstract ADJ bracis-19020 1 161 argumentation argumentation NOUN bracis-19020 1 162 - - PUNCT bracis-19020 1 163 based base VERB bracis-19020 1 164 persuasive persuasive ADJ bracis-19020 1 165 negotiation negotiation NOUN bracis-19020 1 166 is be AUX bracis-19020 1 167 a a DET bracis-19020 1 168 form form NOUN bracis-19020 1 169 of of ADP bracis-19020 1 170 negotiation negotiation NOUN bracis-19020 1 171 dialogue dialogue NOUN bracis-19020 1 172 in in ADP bracis-19020 1 173 which which PRON bracis-19020 1 174 agents agent NOUN bracis-19020 1 175 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 1 176 with with ADP bracis-19020 1 177 different different ADJ bracis-19020 1 178 interests interest NOUN bracis-19020 1 179 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 1 180 goals goal NOUN bracis-19020 1 181 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 1 182 exchange exchange NOUN bracis-19020 1 183 proposals proposal NOUN bracis-19020 1 184 that that PRON bracis-19020 1 185 are be AUX bracis-19020 1 186 supported support VERB bracis-19020 1 187 by by ADP bracis-19020 1 188 rhetorical rhetorical ADJ bracis-19020 1 189 arguments argument NOUN bracis-19020 1 190 such such ADJ bracis-19020 1 191 as as ADP bracis-19020 1 192 threats threat NOUN bracis-19020 1 193 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 1 194 rewards reward NOUN bracis-19020 1 195 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 1 196 or or CCONJ bracis-19020 1 197 appeals appeal NOUN bracis-19020 1 198 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 2 1 besides besides SCONJ bracis-19020 2 2 rhetorical rhetorical ADJ bracis-19020 2 3 arguments argument NOUN bracis-19020 2 4 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 2 5 additional additional ADJ bracis-19020 2 6 kinds kind NOUN bracis-19020 2 7 of of ADP bracis-19020 2 8 illocutions illocution NOUN bracis-19020 2 9 may may AUX bracis-19020 2 10 also also ADV bracis-19020 2 11 be be AUX bracis-19020 2 12 exchanged exchange VERB bracis-19020 2 13 during during ADP bracis-19020 2 14 the the DET bracis-19020 2 15 dialogue dialogue NOUN bracis-19020 2 16 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 2 17 for for ADP bracis-19020 2 18 instance instance NOUN bracis-19020 2 19 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 2 20 agents agent NOUN bracis-19020 2 21 may may AUX bracis-19020 2 22 ask ask VERB bracis-19020 2 23 for for ADP bracis-19020 2 24 explanations explanation NOUN bracis-19020 2 25 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 2 26 give give VERB bracis-19020 2 27 explanations explanation NOUN bracis-19020 2 28 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 2 29 or or CCONJ bracis-19020 2 30 attack attack NOUN bracis-19020 2 31 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 2 32 or or CCONJ bracis-19020 2 33 contradict contradict VERB bracis-19020 2 34 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 2 35 previous previous ADJ bracis-19020 2 36 arguments argument NOUN bracis-19020 2 37 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 3 1 this this DET bracis-19020 3 2 paper paper NOUN bracis-19020 3 3 presents present VERB bracis-19020 3 4 a a DET bracis-19020 3 5 formal formal ADJ bracis-19020 3 6 protocol protocol NOUN bracis-19020 3 7 for for ADP bracis-19020 3 8 argumentation argumentation NOUN bracis-19020 3 9 - - PUNCT bracis-19020 3 10 based base VERB bracis-19020 3 11 persuasive persuasive ADJ bracis-19020 3 12 negotiation negotiation NOUN bracis-19020 3 13 dialogues dialogue NOUN bracis-19020 3 14 in in ADP bracis-19020 3 15 which which PRON bracis-19020 3 16 a a DET bracis-19020 3 17 proponent proponent ADJ bracis-19020 3 18 agent agent NOUN bracis-19020 3 19 tries try VERB bracis-19020 3 20 to to PART bracis-19020 3 21 persuade persuade VERB bracis-19020 3 22 his his PRON bracis-19020 3 23 opponent opponent NOUN bracis-19020 3 24 to to PART bracis-19020 3 25 perform perform VERB bracis-19020 3 26 a a DET bracis-19020 3 27 given give VERB bracis-19020 3 28 action action NOUN bracis-19020 3 29 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 3 30 the the DET bracis-19020 3 31 opponent opponent NOUN bracis-19020 3 32 tries try VERB bracis-19020 3 33 to to PART bracis-19020 3 34 maintain maintain VERB bracis-19020 3 35 his his PRON bracis-19020 3 36 position position NOUN bracis-19020 3 37 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 4 1 the the DET bracis-19020 4 2 protocol protocol NOUN bracis-19020 4 3 is be AUX bracis-19020 4 4 modelled model VERB bracis-19020 4 5 as as ADP bracis-19020 4 6 a a DET bracis-19020 4 7 dialogue dialogue NOUN bracis-19020 4 8 game game NOUN bracis-19020 4 9 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 4 10 i.e. i.e. X bracis-19020 4 11 the the DET bracis-19020 4 12 interactions interaction NOUN bracis-19020 4 13 between between ADP bracis-19020 4 14 the the DET bracis-19020 4 15 proponent proponent NOUN bracis-19020 4 16 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 4 17 the the DET bracis-19020 4 18 opponent opponent NOUN bracis-19020 4 19 are be AUX bracis-19020 4 20 governed govern VERB bracis-19020 4 21 by by ADP bracis-19020 4 22 a a DET bracis-19020 4 23 set set NOUN bracis-19020 4 24 of of ADP bracis-19020 4 25 rules rule NOUN bracis-19020 4 26 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 4 27 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 4 28 the the DET bracis-19020 4 29 outcome outcome NOUN bracis-19020 4 30 of of ADP bracis-19020 4 31 the the DET bracis-19020 4 32 dialogue dialogue NOUN bracis-19020 4 33 is be AUX bracis-19020 4 34 determined determine VERB bracis-19020 4 35 by by ADP bracis-19020 4 36 applying apply VERB bracis-19020 4 37 an an DET bracis-19020 4 38 argumentation argumentation NOUN bracis-19020 4 39 semantics semantic NOUN bracis-19020 4 40 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 5 1 we we PRON bracis-19020 5 2 prove prove VERB bracis-19020 5 3 the the DET bracis-19020 5 4 soundness soundness NOUN bracis-19020 5 5 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 5 6 completeness completeness NOUN bracis-19020 5 7 of of ADP bracis-19020 5 8 our our PRON bracis-19020 5 9 proposal proposal NOUN bracis-19020 5 10 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 5 11 illustrate illustrate VERB bracis-19020 5 12 the the DET bracis-19020 5 13 proposed propose VERB bracis-19020 5 14 protocol protocol NOUN bracis-19020 5 15 by by ADP bracis-19020 5 16 using use VERB bracis-19020 5 17 an an DET bracis-19020 5 18 example example NOUN bracis-19020 5 19 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 6 1 supported support VERB bracis-19020 6 2 by by ADP bracis-19020 6 3 capes cape NOUN bracis-19020 6 4 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 7 1 access access NOUN bracis-19020 7 2 provided provide VERB bracis-19020 7 3 by by ADP bracis-19020 7 4 university university PROPN bracis-19020 7 5 of of ADP bracis-19020 7 6 notre notre PROPN bracis-19020 7 7 dame dame PROPN bracis-19020 7 8 hesburgh hesburgh PROPN bracis-19020 7 9 library library PROPN bracis-19020 7 10 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 8 1 download download PROPN bracis-19020 8 2 conference conference NOUN bracis-19020 8 3 paper paper NOUN bracis-19020 8 4 pdf pdf NOUN bracis-19020 8 5 similar similar ADJ bracis-19020 8 6 content content NOUN bracis-19020 8 7 being be AUX bracis-19020 8 8 viewed view VERB bracis-19020 8 9 by by ADP bracis-19020 8 10 others other NOUN bracis-19020 8 11 negotiation negotiation NOUN bracis-19020 8 12 as as ADP bracis-19020 8 13 practical practical ADJ bracis-19020 8 14 argumentation argumentation NOUN bracis-19020 8 15 article article NOUN bracis-19020 8 16 01 01 NUM bracis-19020 8 17 june june PROPN bracis-19020 8 18 2023 2023 NUM bracis-19020 8 19 persuasion persuasion NOUN bracis-19020 8 20 dialogues dialogue NOUN bracis-19020 8 21 via via ADP bracis-19020 8 22 restricted restricted ADJ bracis-19020 8 23 interfaces interface NOUN bracis-19020 8 24 using use VERB bracis-19020 8 25 probabilistic probabilistic ADJ bracis-19020 8 26 argumentation argumentation NOUN bracis-19020 8 27 chapter chapter NOUN bracis-19020 8 28 © © PROPN bracis-19020 8 29 2016 2016 NUM bracis-19020 8 30 on on ADP bracis-19020 8 31 a a DET bracis-19020 8 32 formal formal ADJ bracis-19020 8 33 treatment treatment NOUN bracis-19020 8 34 of of ADP bracis-19020 8 35 deception deception NOUN bracis-19020 8 36 in in ADP bracis-19020 8 37 argumentative argumentative ADJ bracis-19020 8 38 dialogues dialogue NOUN bracis-19020 8 39 chapter chapter NOUN bracis-19020 8 40 © © PROPN bracis-19020 8 41 2017 2017 NUM bracis-19020 8 42 explore explore VERB bracis-19020 8 43 related relate VERB bracis-19020 8 44 subjects subject NOUN bracis-19020 8 45 discover discover VERB bracis-19020 8 46 the the DET bracis-19020 8 47 latest late ADJ bracis-19020 8 48 articles article NOUN bracis-19020 8 49 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 8 50 books book NOUN bracis-19020 8 51 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 8 52 news news NOUN bracis-19020 8 53 in in ADP bracis-19020 8 54 related related ADJ bracis-19020 8 55 subjects subject NOUN bracis-19020 8 56 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 8 57 suggested suggest VERB bracis-19020 8 58 using use VERB bracis-19020 8 59 machine machine NOUN bracis-19020 8 60 learning learning NOUN bracis-19020 8 61 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 9 1 dispute dispute NOUN bracis-19020 9 2 resolution resolution NOUN bracis-19020 9 3 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 9 4 mediation mediation NOUN bracis-19020 9 5 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 9 6 arbitration arbitration NOUN bracis-19020 9 7 diplomacy diplomacy NOUN bracis-19020 9 8 diplomatics diplomatic NOUN bracis-19020 9 9 lobbying lobbying NOUN bracis-19020 9 10 mediation mediation NOUN bracis-19020 9 11 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 9 12 conflict conflict NOUN bracis-19020 9 13 management management NOUN bracis-19020 9 14 pragmatics pragmatic NOUN bracis-19020 9 15 1 1 NUM bracis-19020 9 16 introduction introduction NOUN bracis-19020 9 17 negotiation negotiation NOUN bracis-19020 9 18 is be AUX bracis-19020 9 19 a a DET bracis-19020 9 20 key key ADJ bracis-19020 9 21 form form NOUN bracis-19020 9 22 of of ADP bracis-19020 9 23 interaction interaction NOUN bracis-19020 9 24 among among ADP bracis-19020 9 25 agents agent NOUN bracis-19020 9 26 that that PRON bracis-19020 9 27 can can AUX bracis-19020 9 28 be be AUX bracis-19020 9 29 used use VERB bracis-19020 9 30 for for ADP bracis-19020 9 31 resolving resolve VERB bracis-19020 9 32 conflicts conflict NOUN bracis-19020 9 33 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 9 34 reaching reach VERB bracis-19020 9 35 agreements agreement NOUN bracis-19020 9 36 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 10 1 formal formal ADJ bracis-19020 10 2 argumentation argumentation NOUN bracis-19020 10 3 is be AUX bracis-19020 10 4 a a DET bracis-19020 10 5 process process NOUN bracis-19020 10 6 based base VERB bracis-19020 10 7 on on ADP bracis-19020 10 8 the the DET bracis-19020 10 9 construction construction NOUN bracis-19020 10 10 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 10 11 comparison comparison NOUN bracis-19020 10 12 of of ADP bracis-19020 10 13 arguments argument NOUN bracis-19020 10 14 considering consider VERB bracis-19020 10 15 the the DET bracis-19020 10 16 conflicts conflict NOUN bracis-19020 10 17 that that PRON bracis-19020 10 18 may may AUX bracis-19020 10 19 emerge emerge VERB bracis-19020 10 20 among among ADP bracis-19020 10 21 them they PRON bracis-19020 10 22 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 11 1 such such ADJ bracis-19020 11 2 conflict conflict NOUN bracis-19020 11 3 are be AUX bracis-19020 11 4 called call VERB bracis-19020 11 5 attacks attack NOUN bracis-19020 11 6 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 12 1 the the DET bracis-19020 12 2 idea idea NOUN bracis-19020 12 3 is be AUX bracis-19020 12 4 to to PART bracis-19020 12 5 determine determine VERB bracis-19020 12 6 set(s set(s PROPN bracis-19020 12 7 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 12 8 of of ADP bracis-19020 12 9 non non ADJ bracis-19020 12 10 - - ADJ bracis-19020 12 11 conflicting conflicting ADJ bracis-19020 12 12 arguments argument NOUN bracis-19020 12 13 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 12 14 called call VERB bracis-19020 12 15 extensions extension NOUN bracis-19020 12 16 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 12 17 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 12 18 which which PRON bracis-19020 12 19 are be AUX bracis-19020 12 20 considered consider VERB bracis-19020 12 21 acceptable acceptable ADJ bracis-19020 12 22 or or CCONJ bracis-19020 12 23 justified justify VERB bracis-19020 12 24 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 13 1 the the DET bracis-19020 13 2 function function NOUN bracis-19020 13 3 in in ADP bracis-19020 13 4 charge charge NOUN bracis-19020 13 5 of of ADP bracis-19020 13 6 calculating calculate VERB bracis-19020 13 7 the the DET bracis-19020 13 8 extensions extension NOUN bracis-19020 13 9 is be AUX bracis-19020 13 10 called call VERB bracis-19020 13 11 semantics semantic NOUN bracis-19020 14 1 [ [ X bracis-19020 14 2 13 13 NUM bracis-19020 14 3 ] ] PUNCT bracis-19020 14 4 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 15 1 some some PRON bracis-19020 15 2 works work VERB bracis-19020 15 3 on on ADP bracis-19020 15 4 negotiation negotiation NOUN bracis-19020 15 5 argue argue VERB bracis-19020 15 6 that that SCONJ bracis-19020 15 7 argumentation argumentation NOUN bracis-19020 15 8 – – PUNCT bracis-19020 15 9 using use VERB bracis-19020 15 10 explanatory explanatory ADJ bracis-19020 15 11 arguments argument NOUN bracis-19020 15 12 – – PUNCT bracis-19020 15 13 allows allow VERB bracis-19020 15 14 that that SCONJ bracis-19020 15 15 an an DET bracis-19020 15 16 agent agent NOUN bracis-19020 15 17 acquire acquire VERB bracis-19020 15 18 additional additional ADJ bracis-19020 15 19 information information NOUN bracis-19020 15 20 about about ADP bracis-19020 15 21 his his PRON bracis-19020 15 22 opponents opponent NOUN bracis-19020 15 23 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 15 24 which which PRON bracis-19020 15 25 can can AUX bracis-19020 15 26 be be AUX bracis-19020 15 27 used use VERB bracis-19020 15 28 for for ADP bracis-19020 15 29 attacking attack VERB bracis-19020 15 30 his his PRON bracis-19020 15 31 opponent opponent NOUN bracis-19020 15 32 ’s ’s PART bracis-19020 15 33 proposals proposal NOUN bracis-19020 15 34 or or CCONJ bracis-19020 15 35 justifying justify VERB bracis-19020 15 36 his his PRON bracis-19020 15 37 own own ADJ bracis-19020 15 38 proposals proposal NOUN bracis-19020 15 39 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 15 40 e.g. e.g. ADV bracis-19020 15 41 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 15 42 [ [ X bracis-19020 15 43 3 3 NUM bracis-19020 15 44 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 15 45 12 12 NUM bracis-19020 15 46 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 15 47 26 26 NUM bracis-19020 15 48 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 15 49 29 29 NUM bracis-19020 15 50 ] ] PUNCT bracis-19020 15 51 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 15 52 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 16 1 besides besides SCONJ bracis-19020 16 2 explanatory explanatory ADJ bracis-19020 16 3 arguments argument NOUN bracis-19020 16 4 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 16 5 there there PRON bracis-19020 16 6 exist exist VERB bracis-19020 16 7 other other ADJ bracis-19020 16 8 kinds kind NOUN bracis-19020 16 9 of of ADP bracis-19020 16 10 arguments argument NOUN bracis-19020 16 11 that that PRON bracis-19020 16 12 can can AUX bracis-19020 16 13 be be AUX bracis-19020 16 14 used use VERB bracis-19020 16 15 in in ADP bracis-19020 16 16 negotiation negotiation NOUN bracis-19020 16 17 dialogues dialogue NOUN bracis-19020 16 18 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 16 19 act act VERB bracis-19020 16 20 as as ADP bracis-19020 16 21 persuasive persuasive ADJ bracis-19020 16 22 elements element NOUN bracis-19020 16 23 aiming aim VERB bracis-19020 16 24 to to AUX bracis-19020 16 25 force force VERB bracis-19020 16 26 or or CCONJ bracis-19020 16 27 convince convince VERB bracis-19020 16 28 an an DET bracis-19020 16 29 opponent opponent NOUN bracis-19020 16 30 to to PART bracis-19020 16 31 accept accept VERB bracis-19020 16 32 readily readily ADV bracis-19020 16 33 a a DET bracis-19020 16 34 given give VERB bracis-19020 16 35 proposal proposal NOUN bracis-19020 16 36 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 16 37 these these PRON bracis-19020 16 38 are be AUX bracis-19020 16 39 called call VERB bracis-19020 16 40 rhetorical rhetorical ADJ bracis-19020 16 41 arguments argument NOUN bracis-19020 16 42 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 16 43 e.g. e.g. ADV bracis-19020 16 44 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 16 45 in in ADP bracis-19020 16 46 [ [ X bracis-19020 16 47 20,21,22 20,21,22 NUM bracis-19020 16 48 ] ] PUNCT bracis-19020 16 49 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 16 50 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 17 1 according accord VERB bracis-19020 17 2 to to ADP bracis-19020 17 3 ramchurn ramchurn NOUN bracis-19020 17 4 et et NOUN bracis-19020 17 5 al al PROPN bracis-19020 17 6 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 18 1 [ [ X bracis-19020 18 2 27 27 NUM bracis-19020 18 3 ] ] X bracis-19020 18 4 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 18 5 a a DET bracis-19020 18 6 negotiation negotiation NOUN bracis-19020 18 7 involving involve VERB bracis-19020 18 8 these these DET bracis-19020 18 9 kinds kind NOUN bracis-19020 18 10 of of ADP bracis-19020 18 11 arguments argument NOUN bracis-19020 18 12 is be AUX bracis-19020 18 13 called call VERB bracis-19020 18 14 persuasive persuasive ADJ bracis-19020 18 15 negotiation negotiation NOUN bracis-19020 18 16 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 19 1 we we PRON bracis-19020 19 2 can can AUX bracis-19020 19 3 describe describe VERB bracis-19020 19 4 the the DET bracis-19020 19 5 rhetorical rhetorical ADJ bracis-19020 19 6 arguments argument NOUN bracis-19020 19 7 as as SCONJ bracis-19020 19 8 follows follow VERB bracis-19020 19 9 : : PUNCT bracis-19020 19 10 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 19 11 i i NOUN bracis-19020 19 12 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 19 13 threats threat NOUN bracis-19020 19 14 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 19 15 which which PRON bracis-19020 19 16 try try VERB bracis-19020 19 17 to to PART bracis-19020 19 18 persuade persuade VERB bracis-19020 19 19 an an DET bracis-19020 19 20 opponent opponent NOUN bracis-19020 19 21 agent agent NOUN bracis-19020 19 22 by by ADP bracis-19020 19 23 using use VERB bracis-19020 19 24 the the DET bracis-19020 19 25 argument argument NOUN bracis-19020 19 26 that that SCONJ bracis-19020 19 27 something something PRON bracis-19020 19 28 negative negative ADJ bracis-19020 19 29 will will AUX bracis-19020 19 30 happen happen VERB bracis-19020 19 31 to to ADP bracis-19020 19 32 him he PRON bracis-19020 19 33 if if SCONJ bracis-19020 19 34 he he PRON bracis-19020 19 35 does do AUX bracis-19020 19 36 not not PART bracis-19020 19 37 accept accept VERB bracis-19020 19 38 to to PART bracis-19020 19 39 do do VERB bracis-19020 19 40 the the DET bracis-19020 19 41 requirement requirement NOUN bracis-19020 19 42 sent send VERB bracis-19020 19 43 by by ADP bracis-19020 19 44 the the DET bracis-19020 19 45 proponent proponent NOUN bracis-19020 19 46 ; ; PUNCT bracis-19020 19 47 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 19 48 ii ii NOUN bracis-19020 19 49 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 19 50 rewards reward NOUN bracis-19020 19 51 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 19 52 which which PRON bracis-19020 19 53 try try VERB bracis-19020 19 54 to to PART bracis-19020 19 55 persuade persuade VERB bracis-19020 19 56 an an DET bracis-19020 19 57 opponent opponent NOUN bracis-19020 19 58 by by ADP bracis-19020 19 59 using use VERB bracis-19020 19 60 the the DET bracis-19020 19 61 argument argument NOUN bracis-19020 19 62 that that SCONJ bracis-19020 19 63 something something PRON bracis-19020 19 64 positive positive ADJ bracis-19020 19 65 will will AUX bracis-19020 19 66 happen happen VERB bracis-19020 19 67 to to ADP bracis-19020 19 68 him he PRON bracis-19020 19 69 if if SCONJ bracis-19020 19 70 he he PRON bracis-19020 19 71 accepts accept VERB bracis-19020 19 72 to to PART bracis-19020 19 73 do do VERB bracis-19020 19 74 the the DET bracis-19020 19 75 requirement requirement NOUN bracis-19020 19 76 sent send VERB bracis-19020 19 77 by by ADP bracis-19020 19 78 the the DET bracis-19020 19 79 proponent proponent NOUN bracis-19020 19 80 ; ; PUNCT bracis-19020 19 81 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 19 82 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 19 83 iii iii NOUN bracis-19020 19 84 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 19 85 appeals appeal NOUN bracis-19020 19 86 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 19 87 which which PRON bracis-19020 19 88 try try VERB bracis-19020 19 89 to to PART bracis-19020 19 90 persuade persuade VERB bracis-19020 19 91 an an DET bracis-19020 19 92 opponent opponent NOUN bracis-19020 19 93 in in ADP bracis-19020 19 94 the the DET bracis-19020 19 95 same same ADJ bracis-19020 19 96 form form NOUN bracis-19020 19 97 than than ADP bracis-19020 19 98 rewards reward NOUN bracis-19020 19 99 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 19 100 but but CCONJ bracis-19020 19 101 this this DET bracis-19020 19 102 positive positive ADJ bracis-19020 19 103 event event NOUN bracis-19020 19 104 will will AUX bracis-19020 19 105 depend depend VERB bracis-19020 19 106 on on ADP bracis-19020 19 107 the the DET bracis-19020 19 108 opponent opponent NOUN bracis-19020 19 109 ; ; PUNCT bracis-19020 19 110 hence hence ADV bracis-19020 19 111 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 19 112 appeals appeal NOUN bracis-19020 19 113 can can AUX bracis-19020 19 114 be be AUX bracis-19020 19 115 seen see VERB bracis-19020 19 116 as as ADP bracis-19020 19 117 self self NOUN bracis-19020 19 118 - - PUNCT bracis-19020 19 119 rewards reward NOUN bracis-19020 19 120 [ [ X bracis-19020 19 121 4 4 NUM bracis-19020 19 122 ] ] PUNCT bracis-19020 19 123 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 20 1 rhetorical rhetorical ADJ bracis-19020 20 2 arguments argument NOUN bracis-19020 20 3 have have AUX bracis-19020 20 4 been be AUX bracis-19020 20 5 studied study VERB bracis-19020 20 6 in in ADP bracis-19020 20 7 terms term NOUN bracis-19020 20 8 of of ADP bracis-19020 20 9 speech speech NOUN bracis-19020 20 10 acts act NOUN bracis-19020 20 11 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 20 12 e.g. e.g. ADV bracis-19020 20 13 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 20 14 [ [ X bracis-19020 20 15 27 27 NUM bracis-19020 20 16 ] ] PUNCT bracis-19020 20 17 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 20 18 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 20 19 in in ADP bracis-19020 20 20 other other ADJ bracis-19020 20 21 articles article NOUN bracis-19020 20 22 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 20 23 a a DET bracis-19020 20 24 logical logical ADJ bracis-19020 20 25 formalization formalization NOUN bracis-19020 20 26 has have AUX bracis-19020 20 27 been be AUX bracis-19020 20 28 given give VERB bracis-19020 20 29 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 20 30 e.g. e.g. ADV bracis-19020 20 31 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 20 32 [ [ X bracis-19020 20 33 5 5 NUM bracis-19020 20 34 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 20 35 6 6 NUM bracis-19020 20 36 ] ] NUM bracis-19020 20 37 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 20 38 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 21 1 it it PRON bracis-19020 21 2 was be AUX bracis-19020 21 3 also also ADV bracis-19020 21 4 studied study VERB bracis-19020 21 5 how how SCONJ bracis-19020 21 6 to to PART bracis-19020 21 7 evaluate evaluate VERB bracis-19020 21 8 their their PRON bracis-19020 21 9 strength strength NOUN bracis-19020 21 10 values value NOUN bracis-19020 21 11 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 21 12 e.g. e.g. ADV bracis-19020 21 13 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 21 14 [ [ X bracis-19020 21 15 6 6 NUM bracis-19020 21 16 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 21 17 21 21 NUM bracis-19020 21 18 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 21 19 22 22 NUM bracis-19020 21 20 ] ] PUNCT bracis-19020 21 21 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 21 22 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 22 1 however however ADV bracis-19020 22 2 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 22 3 to to ADP bracis-19020 22 4 the the DET bracis-19020 22 5 best good ADJ bracis-19020 22 6 of of ADP bracis-19020 22 7 our our PRON bracis-19020 22 8 knowledge knowledge NOUN bracis-19020 22 9 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 22 10 no no DET bracis-19020 22 11 study study NOUN bracis-19020 22 12 about about ADP bracis-19020 22 13 a a DET bracis-19020 22 14 protocol protocol NOUN bracis-19020 22 15 involving involve VERB bracis-19020 22 16 these these DET bracis-19020 22 17 arguments argument NOUN bracis-19020 22 18 has have AUX bracis-19020 22 19 been be AUX bracis-19020 22 20 proposed propose VERB bracis-19020 22 21 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 23 1 in in ADP bracis-19020 23 2 order order NOUN bracis-19020 23 3 to to PART bracis-19020 23 4 better well ADV bracis-19020 23 5 understand understand VERB bracis-19020 23 6 the the DET bracis-19020 23 7 problem problem NOUN bracis-19020 23 8 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 23 9 imagine imagine VERB bracis-19020 23 10 a a DET bracis-19020 23 11 scenario scenario NOUN bracis-19020 23 12 where where SCONJ bracis-19020 23 13 two two NUM bracis-19020 23 14 agents agent NOUN bracis-19020 23 15 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 23 16 maria maria PROPN bracis-19020 23 17 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 23 18 m m NOUN bracis-19020 23 19 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 23 20 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 23 21 carlos carlos PROPN bracis-19020 23 22 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 23 23 c c PROPN bracis-19020 23 24 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 23 25 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 23 26 are be AUX bracis-19020 23 27 discussing discuss VERB bracis-19020 23 28 about about ADP bracis-19020 23 29 household household NOUN bracis-19020 23 30 chores chore NOUN bracis-19020 23 31 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 24 1 maria maria PROPN bracis-19020 24 2 is be AUX bracis-19020 24 3 trying try VERB bracis-19020 24 4 to to PART bracis-19020 24 5 persuade persuade VERB bracis-19020 24 6 carlos carlos PROPN bracis-19020 24 7 to to PART bracis-19020 24 8 do do VERB bracis-19020 24 9 the the DET bracis-19020 24 10 cleaning cleaning NOUN bracis-19020 24 11 of of ADP bracis-19020 24 12 their their PRON bracis-19020 24 13 apartment apartment NOUN bracis-19020 24 14 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 25 1 the the DET bracis-19020 25 2 following follow VERB bracis-19020 25 3 dialogue dialogue NOUN bracis-19020 25 4 shows show VERB bracis-19020 25 5 how how SCONJ bracis-19020 25 6 agreement agreement NOUN bracis-19020 25 7 is be AUX bracis-19020 25 8 reached reach VERB bracis-19020 25 9 : : PUNCT bracis-19020 25 10 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 25 11 1 1 X bracis-19020 25 12 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 25 13 m m ADP bracis-19020 25 14 : : PUNCT bracis-19020 25 15 carlos carlo NOUN bracis-19020 25 16 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 25 17 could could AUX bracis-19020 25 18 you you PRON bracis-19020 25 19 please please INTJ bracis-19020 25 20 do do VERB bracis-19020 25 21 the the DET bracis-19020 25 22 cleaning cleaning NOUN bracis-19020 25 23 ? ? PUNCT bracis-19020 26 1 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 26 2 2 2 X bracis-19020 26 3 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 26 4 c c NOUN bracis-19020 26 5 : : PUNCT bracis-19020 27 1 no no INTJ bracis-19020 27 2 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 27 3 i i PRON bracis-19020 27 4 can can AUX bracis-19020 27 5 not not PART bracis-19020 27 6 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 27 7 i i PRON bracis-19020 27 8 have have VERB bracis-19020 27 9 to to PART bracis-19020 27 10 work work VERB bracis-19020 27 11 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 28 1 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 28 2 3 3 X bracis-19020 28 3 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 28 4 m m VERB bracis-19020 28 5 : : PUNCT bracis-19020 28 6 if if SCONJ bracis-19020 28 7 you you PRON bracis-19020 28 8 do do VERB bracis-19020 28 9 the the DET bracis-19020 28 10 cleaning cleaning NOUN bracis-19020 28 11 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 28 12 i i PRON bracis-19020 28 13 could could AUX bracis-19020 28 14 help help VERB bracis-19020 28 15 you you PRON bracis-19020 28 16 with with ADP bracis-19020 28 17 your your PRON bracis-19020 28 18 reports report NOUN bracis-19020 28 19 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 28 20 you you PRON bracis-19020 28 21 can can AUX bracis-19020 28 22 finish finish VERB bracis-19020 28 23 your your PRON bracis-19020 28 24 work work NOUN bracis-19020 28 25 early early ADV bracis-19020 28 26 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 29 1 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 29 2 4 4 X bracis-19020 29 3 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 29 4 c c NOUN bracis-19020 29 5 : : PUNCT bracis-19020 29 6 you you PRON bracis-19020 29 7 can can AUX bracis-19020 29 8 not not PART bracis-19020 29 9 help help VERB bracis-19020 29 10 me i PRON bracis-19020 29 11 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 30 1 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 30 2 5 5 X bracis-19020 30 3 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 30 4 m m ADP bracis-19020 30 5 : : PUNCT bracis-19020 30 6 why why SCONJ bracis-19020 30 7 ? ? PUNCT bracis-19020 31 1 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 31 2 6 6 NUM bracis-19020 31 3 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 31 4 c c NOUN bracis-19020 31 5 : : PUNCT bracis-19020 31 6 because because SCONJ bracis-19020 31 7 these these DET bracis-19020 31 8 reports report NOUN bracis-19020 31 9 are be AUX bracis-19020 31 10 about about ADP bracis-19020 31 11 a a DET bracis-19020 31 12 topic topic NOUN bracis-19020 31 13 you you PRON bracis-19020 31 14 do do AUX bracis-19020 31 15 not not PART bracis-19020 31 16 know know VERB bracis-19020 31 17 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 32 1 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 32 2 7 7 X bracis-19020 32 3 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 32 4 m m VERB bracis-19020 32 5 : : PUNCT bracis-19020 33 1 well well INTJ bracis-19020 33 2 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 33 3 if if SCONJ bracis-19020 33 4 you you PRON bracis-19020 33 5 do do AUX bracis-19020 33 6 not not PART bracis-19020 33 7 do do VERB bracis-19020 33 8 the the DET bracis-19020 33 9 cleaning cleaning NOUN bracis-19020 33 10 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 33 11 i i PRON bracis-19020 33 12 will will AUX bracis-19020 33 13 not not PART bracis-19020 33 14 go go VERB bracis-19020 33 15 to to ADP bracis-19020 33 16 your your PRON bracis-19020 33 17 mother mother NOUN bracis-19020 33 18 ’s ’s PART bracis-19020 33 19 house house NOUN bracis-19020 33 20 on on ADP bracis-19020 33 21 saturday saturday PROPN bracis-19020 33 22 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 34 1 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 34 2 8) 8) NUM bracis-19020 34 3 c c NOUN bracis-19020 34 4 : : PUNCT bracis-19020 34 5 if if SCONJ bracis-19020 34 6 you you PRON bracis-19020 34 7 will will AUX bracis-19020 34 8 not not PART bracis-19020 34 9 go go VERB bracis-19020 34 10 to to ADP bracis-19020 34 11 my my PRON bracis-19020 34 12 mother mother NOUN bracis-19020 34 13 ’s ’s PART bracis-19020 34 14 house house NOUN bracis-19020 34 15 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 34 16 i i PRON bracis-19020 34 17 will will AUX bracis-19020 34 18 not not PART bracis-19020 34 19 talk talk VERB bracis-19020 34 20 to to ADP bracis-19020 34 21 her she PRON bracis-19020 34 22 about about ADP bracis-19020 34 23 the the DET bracis-19020 34 24 work work NOUN bracis-19020 34 25 for for ADP bracis-19020 34 26 your your PRON bracis-19020 34 27 brother brother NOUN bracis-19020 34 28 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 35 1 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 35 2 9 9 X bracis-19020 35 3 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 35 4 m m VERB bracis-19020 35 5 : : PUNCT bracis-19020 35 6 that that PRON bracis-19020 35 7 is be AUX bracis-19020 35 8 not not PART bracis-19020 35 9 longer long ADV bracis-19020 35 10 necessary necessary ADJ bracis-19020 35 11 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 35 12 my my PRON bracis-19020 35 13 brother brother NOUN bracis-19020 35 14 got get VERB bracis-19020 35 15 a a DET bracis-19020 35 16 job job NOUN bracis-19020 35 17 yesterday yesterday NOUN bracis-19020 35 18 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 36 1 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 36 2 10 10 NUM bracis-19020 36 3 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 36 4 c c NOUN bracis-19020 36 5 : : PUNCT bracis-19020 36 6 ok ok INTJ bracis-19020 36 7 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 37 1 you you PRON bracis-19020 37 2 win win VERB bracis-19020 37 3 ! ! PUNCT bracis-19020 38 1 in in ADP bracis-19020 38 2 this this DET bracis-19020 38 3 example example NOUN bracis-19020 38 4 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 38 5 maria maria PROPN bracis-19020 38 6 succeeds succeed VERB bracis-19020 38 7 in in ADP bracis-19020 38 8 persuading persuade VERB bracis-19020 38 9 her her PRON bracis-19020 38 10 husband husband NOUN bracis-19020 38 11 carlos carlos PROPN bracis-19020 38 12 to to PART bracis-19020 38 13 do do VERB bracis-19020 38 14 the the DET bracis-19020 38 15 cleaning cleaning NOUN bracis-19020 38 16 of of ADP bracis-19020 38 17 their their PRON bracis-19020 38 18 apartment apartment NOUN bracis-19020 38 19 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 39 1 on on ADP bracis-19020 39 2 the the DET bracis-19020 39 3 first first ADJ bracis-19020 39 4 attempt attempt NOUN bracis-19020 39 5 to to PART bracis-19020 39 6 persuade persuade VERB bracis-19020 39 7 carlos carlos PROPN bracis-19020 39 8 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 39 9 maria maria PROPN bracis-19020 39 10 uses use VERB bracis-19020 39 11 a a DET bracis-19020 39 12 reward reward NOUN bracis-19020 39 13 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 39 14 line line NOUN bracis-19020 39 15 3 3 NUM bracis-19020 39 16 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 39 17 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 39 18 which which PRON bracis-19020 39 19 is be AUX bracis-19020 39 20 not not PART bracis-19020 39 21 accepted accept VERB bracis-19020 39 22 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 39 23 resulting result VERB bracis-19020 39 24 in in ADP bracis-19020 39 25 an an DET bracis-19020 39 26 attack attack NOUN bracis-19020 39 27 to to ADP bracis-19020 39 28 her her PRON bracis-19020 39 29 reward reward NOUN bracis-19020 39 30 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 39 31 line line NOUN bracis-19020 39 32 4 4 NUM bracis-19020 39 33 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 39 34 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 40 1 in in ADP bracis-19020 40 2 this this DET bracis-19020 40 3 settings setting NOUN bracis-19020 40 4 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 40 5 an an DET bracis-19020 40 6 attack attack NOUN bracis-19020 40 7 is be AUX bracis-19020 40 8 a a DET bracis-19020 40 9 contradictory contradictory ADJ bracis-19020 40 10 statement statement NOUN bracis-19020 40 11 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 41 1 since since SCONJ bracis-19020 41 2 her her PRON bracis-19020 41 3 reward reward NOUN bracis-19020 41 4 was be AUX bracis-19020 41 5 not not PART bracis-19020 41 6 successful successful ADJ bracis-19020 41 7 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 41 8 she she PRON bracis-19020 41 9 uses use VERB bracis-19020 41 10 a a DET bracis-19020 41 11 more more ADV bracis-19020 41 12 powerful powerful ADJ bracis-19020 41 13 argument argument NOUN bracis-19020 41 14 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 41 15 i.e. i.e. X bracis-19020 41 16 a a DET bracis-19020 41 17 threat(line threat(line PROPN bracis-19020 41 18 7 7 NUM bracis-19020 41 19 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 41 20 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 41 21 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 41 22 then then ADV bracis-19020 41 23 he he PRON bracis-19020 41 24 also also ADV bracis-19020 41 25 answers answer VERB bracis-19020 41 26 with with ADP bracis-19020 41 27 another another DET bracis-19020 41 28 threat threat NOUN bracis-19020 41 29 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 41 30 line line NOUN bracis-19020 41 31 8) 8) NUM bracis-19020 41 32 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 41 33 which which PRON bracis-19020 41 34 we we PRON bracis-19020 41 35 can can AUX bracis-19020 41 36 call call VERB bracis-19020 41 37 a a DET bracis-19020 41 38 counter counter NOUN bracis-19020 41 39 - - NOUN bracis-19020 41 40 threat threat NOUN bracis-19020 41 41 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 42 1 she she PRON bracis-19020 42 2 answers answer VERB bracis-19020 42 3 attacking attack VERB bracis-19020 42 4 carlos carlos PROPN bracis-19020 42 5 ’ ' PUNCT bracis-19020 42 6 counter counter NOUN bracis-19020 42 7 - - NOUN bracis-19020 42 8 threat threat NOUN bracis-19020 42 9 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 42 10 line line NOUN bracis-19020 42 11 9 9 NUM bracis-19020 42 12 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 42 13 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 43 1 notice notice VERB bracis-19020 43 2 that that SCONJ bracis-19020 43 3 this this DET bracis-19020 43 4 attack attack NOUN bracis-19020 43 5 is be AUX bracis-19020 43 6 not not PART bracis-19020 43 7 a a DET bracis-19020 43 8 counter counter NOUN bracis-19020 43 9 - - NOUN bracis-19020 43 10 threat threat NOUN bracis-19020 43 11 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 43 12 which which PRON bracis-19020 43 13 indicates indicate VERB bracis-19020 43 14 that that SCONJ bracis-19020 43 15 there there PRON bracis-19020 43 16 is be VERB bracis-19020 43 17 more more ADJ bracis-19020 43 18 than than ADP bracis-19020 43 19 one one NUM bracis-19020 43 20 way way NOUN bracis-19020 43 21 to to PART bracis-19020 43 22 attack attack VERB bracis-19020 43 23 a a DET bracis-19020 43 24 rhetorical rhetorical ADJ bracis-19020 43 25 argument argument NOUN bracis-19020 43 26 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 44 1 finally finally ADV bracis-19020 44 2 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 44 3 carlos carlos PROPN bracis-19020 44 4 accepts accept VERB bracis-19020 44 5 to to PART bracis-19020 44 6 do do VERB bracis-19020 44 7 the the DET bracis-19020 44 8 cleaning cleaning NOUN bracis-19020 44 9 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 45 1 besides besides SCONJ bracis-19020 45 2 rhetorical rhetorical ADJ bracis-19020 45 3 arguments argument NOUN bracis-19020 45 4 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 45 5 their their PRON bracis-19020 45 6 corresponding corresponding ADJ bracis-19020 45 7 attacks attack NOUN bracis-19020 45 8 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 45 9 we we PRON bracis-19020 45 10 can can AUX bracis-19020 45 11 notice notice VERB bracis-19020 45 12 that that SCONJ bracis-19020 45 13 an an DET bracis-19020 45 14 explanation explanation NOUN bracis-19020 45 15 is be AUX bracis-19020 45 16 required require VERB bracis-19020 45 17 during during ADP bracis-19020 45 18 the the DET bracis-19020 45 19 conversation conversation NOUN bracis-19020 45 20 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 45 21 line line NOUN bracis-19020 45 22 5 5 NUM bracis-19020 45 23 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 45 24 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 45 25 this this PRON bracis-19020 45 26 means mean VERB bracis-19020 45 27 that that SCONJ bracis-19020 45 28 agents agent NOUN bracis-19020 45 29 can can AUX bracis-19020 45 30 make make VERB bracis-19020 45 31 questions question NOUN bracis-19020 45 32 to to ADP bracis-19020 45 33 each each DET bracis-19020 45 34 other other ADJ bracis-19020 45 35 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 45 36 can can AUX bracis-19020 45 37 use use VERB bracis-19020 45 38 explanatory explanatory ADJ bracis-19020 45 39 arguments argument NOUN bracis-19020 45 40 to to PART bracis-19020 45 41 justify justify VERB bracis-19020 45 42 their their PRON bracis-19020 45 43 opinions opinion NOUN bracis-19020 45 44 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 46 1 figure figure VERB bracis-19020 46 2     SPACE bracis-19020 46 3 1 1 NUM bracis-19020 46 4 shows show VERB bracis-19020 46 5 the the DET bracis-19020 46 6 outline outline NOUN bracis-19020 46 7 of of ADP bracis-19020 46 8 the the DET bracis-19020 46 9 dialogue dialogue NOUN bracis-19020 46 10 in in ADP bracis-19020 46 11 terms term NOUN bracis-19020 46 12 of of ADP bracis-19020 46 13 rhetorical rhetorical ADJ bracis-19020 46 14 arguments argument NOUN bracis-19020 46 15 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 46 16 attacks attack NOUN bracis-19020 46 17 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 46 18 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 46 19 other other ADJ bracis-19020 46 20 illocutions illocution NOUN bracis-19020 46 21 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 47 1 fig fig NOUN bracis-19020 47 2 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 48 1 1 1 NUM bracis-19020 48 2 . . NUM bracis-19020 48 3 outline outline NOUN bracis-19020 48 4 of of ADP bracis-19020 48 5 the the DET bracis-19020 48 6 dialogue dialogue NOUN bracis-19020 48 7 between between ADP bracis-19020 48 8 maria maria PROPN bracis-19020 48 9 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 48 10 carlos carlos PROPN bracis-19020 48 11 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 48 12 which which PRON bracis-19020 48 13 ends end VERB bracis-19020 48 14 successfully successfully ADV bracis-19020 48 15 for for ADP bracis-19020 48 16 maria maria PROPN bracis-19020 48 17 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 49 1 full full ADJ bracis-19020 49 2 size size NOUN bracis-19020 49 3 image image NOUN bracis-19020 49 4 from from ADP bracis-19020 49 5 this this DET bracis-19020 49 6 scenario scenario NOUN bracis-19020 49 7 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 49 8 we we PRON bracis-19020 49 9 can can AUX bracis-19020 49 10 observe observe VERB bracis-19020 49 11 that that SCONJ bracis-19020 49 12 during during ADP bracis-19020 49 13 a a DET bracis-19020 49 14 persuasive persuasive ADJ bracis-19020 49 15 negotiation negotiation NOUN bracis-19020 49 16 dialogue dialogue NOUN bracis-19020 49 17 agents agent NOUN bracis-19020 49 18 can can AUX bracis-19020 49 19 exchange exchange VERB bracis-19020 49 20 rhetorical rhetorical ADJ bracis-19020 49 21 arguments argument NOUN bracis-19020 49 22 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 49 23 attacks attack NOUN bracis-19020 49 24 to to ADP bracis-19020 49 25 rhetorical rhetorical ADJ bracis-19020 49 26 arguments argument NOUN bracis-19020 49 27 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 49 28 questions question NOUN bracis-19020 49 29 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 49 30 explanatory explanatory ADJ bracis-19020 49 31 arguments argument NOUN bracis-19020 49 32 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 49 33 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 49 34 attacks attack NOUN bracis-19020 49 35 to to PART bracis-19020 49 36 explanatory explanatory ADJ bracis-19020 49 37 arguments argument NOUN bracis-19020 49 38 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 50 1 most most ADJ bracis-19020 50 2 of of ADP bracis-19020 50 3 the the DET bracis-19020 50 4 research research NOUN bracis-19020 50 5 about about ADP bracis-19020 50 6 protocols protocol NOUN bracis-19020 50 7 in in ADP bracis-19020 50 8 literature literature NOUN bracis-19020 50 9 is be AUX bracis-19020 50 10 focused focus VERB bracis-19020 50 11 on on ADP bracis-19020 50 12 negotiation negotiation NOUN bracis-19020 50 13 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 50 14 e e NOUN bracis-19020 50 15 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 50 16 g. g. PROPN bracis-19020 50 17 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 50 18 [ [ X bracis-19020 50 19 1 1 NUM bracis-19020 50 20 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 50 21 11 11 NUM bracis-19020 50 22 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 50 23 16 16 NUM bracis-19020 50 24 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 50 25 28 28 NUM bracis-19020 50 26 ] ] NUM bracis-19020 50 27 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 50 28 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 50 29 some some DET bracis-19020 50 30 others other NOUN bracis-19020 50 31 on on ADP bracis-19020 50 32 persuasion persuasion NOUN bracis-19020 50 33 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 50 34 e.g. e.g. ADV bracis-19020 50 35 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 50 36 [ [ X bracis-19020 50 37 10 10 NUM bracis-19020 50 38 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 50 39 17 17 NUM bracis-19020 50 40 ] ] PUNCT bracis-19020 50 41 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 50 42 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 50 43 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 50 44 some some DET bracis-19020 50 45 others other NOUN bracis-19020 50 46 on on ADP bracis-19020 50 47 argumentation argumentation NOUN bracis-19020 50 48 - - PUNCT bracis-19020 50 49 based base VERB bracis-19020 50 50 dialogues dialogue NOUN bracis-19020 50 51 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 50 52 e.g. e.g. ADV bracis-19020 50 53 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 50 54 [ [ X bracis-19020 50 55 8 8 NUM bracis-19020 50 56 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 50 57 9 9 NUM bracis-19020 50 58 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 50 59 14 14 NUM bracis-19020 50 60 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 50 61 23 23 NUM bracis-19020 50 62 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 50 63 25 25 NUM bracis-19020 50 64 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 50 65 30 30 NUM bracis-19020 50 66 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 50 67 31 31 NUM bracis-19020 50 68 ] ] PUNCT bracis-19020 50 69 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 50 70 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 51 1 although although SCONJ bracis-19020 51 2 some some PRON bracis-19020 51 3 of of ADP bracis-19020 51 4 these these DET bracis-19020 51 5 protocols protocol NOUN bracis-19020 51 6 take take VERB bracis-19020 51 7 into into ADP bracis-19020 51 8 account account NOUN bracis-19020 51 9 explanatory explanatory ADJ bracis-19020 51 10 arguments argument NOUN bracis-19020 51 11 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 51 12 attacks attack NOUN bracis-19020 51 13 among among ADP bracis-19020 51 14 them they PRON bracis-19020 51 15 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 51 16 these these PRON bracis-19020 51 17 are be AUX bracis-19020 51 18 not not PART bracis-19020 51 19 embedded embed VERB bracis-19020 51 20 in in ADP bracis-19020 51 21 a a DET bracis-19020 51 22 persuasive persuasive ADJ bracis-19020 51 23 negotiation negotiation NOUN bracis-19020 51 24 dialogue dialogue NOUN bracis-19020 51 25 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 51 26 according accord VERB bracis-19020 51 27 to to ADP bracis-19020 51 28 the the DET bracis-19020 51 29 definition definition NOUN bracis-19020 51 30 of of ADP bracis-19020 51 31 [ [ X bracis-19020 51 32 27 27 NUM bracis-19020 51 33 ] ] PUNCT bracis-19020 51 34 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 51 35 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 51 36 do do AUX bracis-19020 51 37 not not PART bracis-19020 51 38 interact interact VERB bracis-19020 51 39 with with ADP bracis-19020 51 40 other other ADJ bracis-19020 51 41 kinds kind NOUN bracis-19020 51 42 of of ADP bracis-19020 51 43 arguments argument NOUN bracis-19020 51 44 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 52 1 thus thus ADV bracis-19020 52 2 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 52 3 the the DET bracis-19020 52 4 research research NOUN bracis-19020 52 5 questions question NOUN bracis-19020 52 6 that that PRON bracis-19020 52 7 are be AUX bracis-19020 52 8 addressed address VERB bracis-19020 52 9 in in ADP bracis-19020 52 10 this this DET bracis-19020 52 11 paper paper NOUN bracis-19020 52 12 are be AUX bracis-19020 52 13 : : PUNCT bracis-19020 52 14 1 1 X bracis-19020 52 15 . . X bracis-19020 53 1 how how SCONJ bracis-19020 53 2 can can AUX bracis-19020 53 3 rhetorical rhetorical VERB bracis-19020 53 4 arguments argument NOUN bracis-19020 53 5 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 53 6 explanatory explanatory ADJ bracis-19020 53 7 arguments argument NOUN bracis-19020 53 8 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 53 9 attacks attack NOUN bracis-19020 53 10 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 53 11 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 53 12 other other ADJ bracis-19020 53 13 illocutions illocution NOUN bracis-19020 53 14 be be AUX bracis-19020 53 15 combined combine VERB bracis-19020 53 16 in in ADP bracis-19020 53 17 a a DET bracis-19020 53 18 coherent coherent ADJ bracis-19020 53 19 dialogue dialogue NOUN bracis-19020 53 20 ? ? PUNCT bracis-19020 54 1 2 2 X bracis-19020 54 2 . . X bracis-19020 54 3 how how SCONJ bracis-19020 54 4 can can AUX bracis-19020 54 5 argumentation argumentation VERB bracis-19020 54 6 techniques technique NOUN bracis-19020 54 7 be be AUX bracis-19020 54 8 used use VERB bracis-19020 54 9 in in ADP bracis-19020 54 10 this this DET bracis-19020 54 11 kind kind NOUN bracis-19020 54 12 of of ADP bracis-19020 54 13 dialogue dialogue NOUN bracis-19020 54 14 ? ? PUNCT bracis-19020 55 1 in in ADP bracis-19020 55 2 order order NOUN bracis-19020 55 3 to to PART bracis-19020 55 4 address address VERB bracis-19020 55 5 the the DET bracis-19020 55 6 first first ADJ bracis-19020 55 7 question question NOUN bracis-19020 55 8 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 55 9 we we PRON bracis-19020 55 10 propose propose VERB bracis-19020 55 11 a a DET bracis-19020 55 12 protocol protocol NOUN bracis-19020 55 13 that that PRON bracis-19020 55 14 has have VERB bracis-19020 55 15 a a DET bracis-19020 55 16 dialogue dialogue NOUN bracis-19020 55 17 game game NOUN bracis-19020 55 18 form form NOUN bracis-19020 55 19 where where SCONJ bracis-19020 55 20 utterances utterance NOUN bracis-19020 55 21 are be AUX bracis-19020 55 22 viewed view VERB bracis-19020 55 23 as as ADP bracis-19020 55 24 moves move NOUN bracis-19020 55 25 in in ADP bracis-19020 55 26 a a DET bracis-19020 55 27 game game NOUN bracis-19020 55 28 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 55 29 which which PRON bracis-19020 55 30 is be AUX bracis-19020 55 31 guided guide VERB bracis-19020 55 32 according accord VERB bracis-19020 55 33 to to ADP bracis-19020 55 34 a a DET bracis-19020 55 35 defined define VERB bracis-19020 55 36 set set NOUN bracis-19020 55 37 of of ADP bracis-19020 55 38 rules rule NOUN bracis-19020 55 39 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 56 1 according accord VERB bracis-19020 56 2 mcburney mcburney PROPN bracis-19020 56 3 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 56 4 parsons parson NOUN bracis-19020 56 5 [ [ X bracis-19020 56 6 18 18 NUM bracis-19020 56 7 ] ] X bracis-19020 56 8 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 56 9 formal formal ADJ bracis-19020 56 10 dialogue dialogue NOUN bracis-19020 56 11 games game NOUN bracis-19020 56 12 allow allow VERB bracis-19020 56 13 sufficient sufficient ADJ bracis-19020 56 14 flexibility flexibility NOUN bracis-19020 56 15 of of ADP bracis-19020 56 16 expression expression NOUN bracis-19020 56 17 while while SCONJ bracis-19020 56 18 avoid avoid VERB bracis-19020 56 19 state state NOUN bracis-19020 56 20 - - PUNCT bracis-19020 56 21 space space NOUN bracis-19020 56 22 explosion explosion NOUN bracis-19020 56 23 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 57 1 regarding regard VERB bracis-19020 57 2 the the DET bracis-19020 57 3 second second ADJ bracis-19020 57 4 question question NOUN bracis-19020 57 5 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 57 6 an an DET bracis-19020 57 7 important important ADJ bracis-19020 57 8 part part NOUN bracis-19020 57 9 of of ADP bracis-19020 57 10 a a DET bracis-19020 57 11 dialogue dialogue NOUN bracis-19020 57 12 is be AUX bracis-19020 57 13 the the DET bracis-19020 57 14 outcome outcome NOUN bracis-19020 57 15 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 58 1 in in ADP bracis-19020 58 2 this this DET bracis-19020 58 3 case case NOUN bracis-19020 58 4 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 58 5 the the DET bracis-19020 58 6 outcome outcome NOUN bracis-19020 58 7 has have VERB bracis-19020 58 8 to to PART bracis-19020 58 9 determine determine VERB bracis-19020 58 10 the the DET bracis-19020 58 11 final final ADJ bracis-19020 58 12 status status NOUN bracis-19020 58 13 of of ADP bracis-19020 58 14 the the DET bracis-19020 58 15 dialogue dialogue NOUN bracis-19020 58 16 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 58 17 that that ADV bracis-19020 58 18 is is ADV bracis-19020 58 19 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 58 20 it it PRON bracis-19020 58 21 ends end VERB bracis-19020 58 22 with with ADP bracis-19020 58 23 an an DET bracis-19020 58 24 agreement agreement NOUN bracis-19020 58 25 or or CCONJ bracis-19020 58 26 not not PART bracis-19020 58 27 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 58 28 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 58 29 the the DET bracis-19020 58 30 winner winner NOUN bracis-19020 58 31 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 58 32 if if SCONJ bracis-19020 58 33 there there PRON bracis-19020 58 34 is be VERB bracis-19020 58 35 an an DET bracis-19020 58 36 agreement agreement NOUN bracis-19020 58 37 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 58 38 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 58 39 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 58 40 the the DET bracis-19020 58 41 set set NOUN bracis-19020 58 42 of of ADP bracis-19020 58 43 commitments commitment NOUN bracis-19020 58 44 the the DET bracis-19020 58 45 winner winner NOUN bracis-19020 58 46 agent agent NOUN bracis-19020 58 47 has have VERB bracis-19020 58 48 to to PART bracis-19020 58 49 fulfil fulfil VERB bracis-19020 58 50 after after ADP bracis-19020 58 51 the the DET bracis-19020 58 52 dialogue dialogue NOUN bracis-19020 58 53 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 58 54 for for ADP bracis-19020 58 55 example example NOUN bracis-19020 58 56 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 58 57 maria maria PROPN bracis-19020 58 58 will will AUX bracis-19020 58 59 go go VERB bracis-19020 58 60 to to ADP bracis-19020 58 61 the the DET bracis-19020 58 62 house house NOUN bracis-19020 58 63 of of ADP bracis-19020 58 64 the the DET bracis-19020 58 65 mother mother NOUN bracis-19020 58 66 - - PUNCT bracis-19020 58 67 in in ADP bracis-19020 58 68 - - PUNCT bracis-19020 58 69 law law NOUN bracis-19020 58 70 since since SCONJ bracis-19020 58 71 carlos carlos PROPN bracis-19020 58 72 will will AUX bracis-19020 58 73 do do VERB bracis-19020 58 74 the the DET bracis-19020 58 75 cleaning cleaning NOUN bracis-19020 58 76 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 59 1 we we PRON bracis-19020 59 2 will will AUX bracis-19020 59 3 use use VERB bracis-19020 59 4 argumentation argumentation NOUN bracis-19020 59 5 semantics semantic NOUN bracis-19020 59 6 to to PART bracis-19020 59 7 determine determine VERB bracis-19020 59 8 the the DET bracis-19020 59 9 outcome outcome NOUN bracis-19020 59 10 of of ADP bracis-19020 59 11 the the DET bracis-19020 59 12 dialogue dialogue NOUN bracis-19020 59 13 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 60 1 next next ADJ bracis-19020 60 2 section section NOUN bracis-19020 60 3 presents present VERB bracis-19020 60 4 the the DET bracis-19020 60 5 main main ADJ bracis-19020 60 6 concepts concept NOUN bracis-19020 60 7 about about ADP bracis-19020 60 8 argumentation argumentation NOUN bracis-19020 60 9 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 60 10 argumentation argumentation NOUN bracis-19020 60 11 semantics semantic NOUN bracis-19020 60 12 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 61 1 section section NOUN bracis-19020 61 2     SPACE bracis-19020 61 3 3 3 NUM bracis-19020 61 4 concerns concern NOUN bracis-19020 61 5 with with ADP bracis-19020 61 6 the the DET bracis-19020 61 7 type type NOUN bracis-19020 61 8 of of ADP bracis-19020 61 9 arguments argument NOUN bracis-19020 61 10 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 61 11 attacks attack NOUN bracis-19020 61 12 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 62 1 section section NOUN bracis-19020 62 2     SPACE bracis-19020 62 3 4 4 NUM bracis-19020 62 4 presents present VERB bracis-19020 62 5 the the DET bracis-19020 62 6 proposed propose VERB bracis-19020 62 7 protocol protocol NOUN bracis-19020 62 8 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 62 9 that that ADV bracis-19020 62 10 is is ADV bracis-19020 62 11 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 62 12 the the DET bracis-19020 62 13 rules rule NOUN bracis-19020 62 14 that that PRON bracis-19020 62 15 govern govern VERB bracis-19020 62 16 the the DET bracis-19020 62 17 interactions interaction NOUN bracis-19020 62 18 among among ADP bracis-19020 62 19 the the DET bracis-19020 62 20 agents agent NOUN bracis-19020 62 21 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 62 22 the the DET bracis-19020 62 23 argumentation argumentation NOUN bracis-19020 62 24 framework framework NOUN bracis-19020 62 25 that that PRON bracis-19020 62 26 determines determine VERB bracis-19020 62 27 the the DET bracis-19020 62 28 outcome outcome NOUN bracis-19020 62 29 of of ADP bracis-19020 62 30 the the DET bracis-19020 62 31 dialogue dialogue NOUN bracis-19020 62 32 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 62 33 the the DET bracis-19020 62 34 main main ADJ bracis-19020 62 35 properties property NOUN bracis-19020 62 36 of of ADP bracis-19020 62 37 the the DET bracis-19020 62 38 approach approach NOUN bracis-19020 62 39 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 63 1 in in ADP bracis-19020 63 2 sect sect NOUN bracis-19020 63 3 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 63 4     SPACE bracis-19020 63 5 5 5 NUM bracis-19020 63 6 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 63 7 we we PRON bracis-19020 63 8 illustrate illustrate VERB bracis-19020 63 9 our our PRON bracis-19020 63 10 new new ADJ bracis-19020 63 11 protocol protocol NOUN bracis-19020 63 12 by by ADP bracis-19020 63 13 applying apply VERB bracis-19020 63 14 it it PRON bracis-19020 63 15 to to ADP bracis-19020 63 16 the the DET bracis-19020 63 17 example example NOUN bracis-19020 63 18 given give VERB bracis-19020 63 19 in in ADP bracis-19020 63 20 introduction introduction NOUN bracis-19020 63 21 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 64 1 finally finally ADV bracis-19020 64 2 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 64 3 sect sect NOUN bracis-19020 64 4 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 64 5     SPACE bracis-19020 65 1 6 6 NUM bracis-19020 65 2 is be AUX bracis-19020 65 3 devoted devote VERB bracis-19020 65 4 to to ADP bracis-19020 65 5 conclusions conclusion NOUN bracis-19020 65 6 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 65 7 future future ADJ bracis-19020 65 8 work work NOUN bracis-19020 65 9 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 66 1 2 2 NUM bracis-19020 66 2 background background NOUN bracis-19020 66 3 in in ADP bracis-19020 66 4 this this DET bracis-19020 66 5 section section NOUN bracis-19020 66 6 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 66 7 we we PRON bracis-19020 66 8 present present VERB bracis-19020 66 9 the the DET bracis-19020 66 10 concepts concept NOUN bracis-19020 66 11 of of ADP bracis-19020 66 12 argumentation argumentation NOUN bracis-19020 66 13 framework framework NOUN bracis-19020 66 14 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 66 15 the the DET bracis-19020 66 16 acceptability acceptability NOUN bracis-19020 66 17 semantics semantic NOUN bracis-19020 66 18 for for ADP bracis-19020 66 19 linear linear ADJ bracis-19020 66 20 dialogues dialogue NOUN bracis-19020 66 21 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 67 1 an an DET bracis-19020 67 2 argumentation argumentation NOUN bracis-19020 67 3 framework framework NOUN bracis-19020 67 4 consists consist VERB bracis-19020 67 5 of of ADP bracis-19020 67 6 a a DET bracis-19020 67 7 set set NOUN bracis-19020 67 8 of of ADP bracis-19020 67 9 arguments argument NOUN bracis-19020 67 10 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 67 11 a a DET bracis-19020 67 12 attack attack NOUN bracis-19020 67 13 relation relation NOUN bracis-19020 67 14 between between ADP bracis-19020 67 15 them they PRON bracis-19020 67 16 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 68 1 the the DET bracis-19020 68 2 following follow VERB bracis-19020 68 3 definitions definition NOUN bracis-19020 68 4 were be AUX bracis-19020 68 5 extracted extract VERB bracis-19020 68 6 from from ADP bracis-19020 68 7 [ [ X bracis-19020 68 8 2 2 NUM bracis-19020 68 9 ] ] PUNCT bracis-19020 68 10 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 68 11 [ [ X bracis-19020 68 12 13 13 NUM bracis-19020 68 13 ] ] PUNCT bracis-19020 68 14 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 69 1 definition definition NOUN bracis-19020 69 2 1 1 NUM bracis-19020 69 3 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 69 4 argumentation argumentation NOUN bracis-19020 69 5 framework framework NOUN bracis-19020 69 6 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 69 7 an an DET bracis-19020 69 8 argumentation argumentation NOUN bracis-19020 69 9 framework framework NOUN bracis-19020 69 10 is be AUX bracis-19020 69 11 an an DET bracis-19020 69 12 ordered order VERB bracis-19020 69 13 pair pair NOUN bracis-19020 69 14 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 69 15 where where SCONJ bracis-19020 69 16 \(\mathtt \(\mathtt NOUN bracis-19020 69 17 { { PUNCT bracis-19020 69 18 arg}\ arg}\ NOUN bracis-19020 69 19 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 69 20 is be AUX bracis-19020 69 21 a a DET bracis-19020 69 22 finite finite ADJ bracis-19020 69 23 set set NOUN bracis-19020 69 24 of of ADP bracis-19020 69 25 arguments argument NOUN bracis-19020 69 26 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 69 27 a a DET bracis-19020 69 28 binary binary ADJ bracis-19020 69 29 relation relation NOUN bracis-19020 69 30 on on ADP bracis-19020 69 31 \(\mathtt \(\mathtt NOUN bracis-19020 69 32 { { PUNCT bracis-19020 69 33 arg}\ arg}\ NOUN bracis-19020 69 34 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 69 35 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 69 36 i.e. i.e. X bracis-19020 69 37 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 69 38 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 69 39 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 70 1 we we PRON bracis-19020 70 2 call call VERB bracis-19020 70 3 an an DET bracis-19020 70 4 attack attack NOUN bracis-19020 70 5 relation relation NOUN bracis-19020 70 6 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 70 7 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 70 8 a a DET bracis-19020 70 9 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 70 10     SPACE bracis-19020 70 11 b b NOUN bracis-19020 70 12 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 70 13 means mean VERB bracis-19020 70 14 that that DET bracis-19020 70 15 argument argument NOUN bracis-19020 70 16 a a DET bracis-19020 70 17 attacks attack NOUN bracis-19020 70 18 argument argument NOUN bracis-19020 70 19 b. b. PROPN bracis-19020 70 20 before before ADP bracis-19020 70 21 presenting present VERB bracis-19020 70 22 the the DET bracis-19020 70 23 acceptability acceptability NOUN bracis-19020 70 24 notion notion NOUN bracis-19020 70 25 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 70 26 it it PRON bracis-19020 70 27 is be AUX bracis-19020 70 28 important important ADJ bracis-19020 70 29 to to PART bracis-19020 70 30 study study VERB bracis-19020 70 31 linear linear ADJ bracis-19020 70 32 discussions discussion NOUN bracis-19020 70 33 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 71 1 a a DET bracis-19020 71 2 linear linear ADJ bracis-19020 71 3 discussion discussion NOUN bracis-19020 71 4 is be AUX bracis-19020 71 5 a a DET bracis-19020 71 6 sequence sequence NOUN bracis-19020 71 7 of of ADP bracis-19020 71 8 arguments argument NOUN bracis-19020 71 9 such such ADJ bracis-19020 71 10 that that SCONJ bracis-19020 71 11 each each DET bracis-19020 71 12 argument argument NOUN bracis-19020 71 13 attacks attack VERB bracis-19020 71 14 the the DET bracis-19020 71 15 argument argument NOUN bracis-19020 71 16 preceding precede VERB bracis-19020 71 17 it it PRON bracis-19020 71 18 in in ADP bracis-19020 71 19 the the DET bracis-19020 71 20 sequence sequence NOUN bracis-19020 71 21 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 72 1 this this DET bracis-19020 72 2 sequence sequence NOUN bracis-19020 72 3 will will AUX bracis-19020 72 4 determine determine VERB bracis-19020 72 5 which which DET bracis-19020 72 6 arguments argument NOUN bracis-19020 72 7 can can AUX bracis-19020 72 8 be be AUX bracis-19020 72 9 considered consider VERB bracis-19020 72 10 acceptable acceptable ADJ bracis-19020 72 11 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 72 12 which which PRON bracis-19020 72 13 can can AUX bracis-19020 72 14 not not PART bracis-19020 72 15 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 73 1 definition definition NOUN bracis-19020 73 2 2 2 NUM bracis-19020 73 3 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 73 4 linear linear NOUN bracis-19020 73 5 discussions discussion NOUN bracis-19020 73 6 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 73 7 let let AUX bracis-19020 73 8 be be AUX bracis-19020 73 9 an an DET bracis-19020 73 10 argumentation argumentation NOUN bracis-19020 73 11 framework framework NOUN bracis-19020 73 12 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 73 13 \(a \(a NOUN bracis-19020 73 14 \in \in PROPN bracis-19020 73 15 \mathtt \mathtt PROPN bracis-19020 73 16 { { PUNCT bracis-19020 73 17 arg}\ arg}\ PROPN bracis-19020 73 18 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 73 19 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 74 1 a a DET bracis-19020 74 2 linear linear ADJ bracis-19020 74 3 discussion discussion NOUN bracis-19020 74 4 for for ADP bracis-19020 74 5 a a PRON bracis-19020 74 6 in in ADP bracis-19020 74 7 \(\mathtt \(\mathtt NOUN bracis-19020 74 8 { { PUNCT bracis-19020 74 9 arg}\ arg}\ NOUN bracis-19020 74 10 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 74 11 is be AUX bracis-19020 74 12 a a DET bracis-19020 74 13 sequence sequence NOUN bracis-19020 74 14 \(s \(s NOUN bracis-19020 74 15 = = SYM bracis-19020 74 16 \langle \langle PROPN bracis-19020 74 17 a_1 a_1 NOUN bracis-19020 74 18 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 74 19 ... ... PUNCT bracis-19020 74 20 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 74 21 a_n a_n PROPN bracis-19020 74 22 \rangle \rangle NUM bracis-19020 74 23 \ \ NOUN bracis-19020 74 24 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 74 25 of of ADP bracis-19020 74 26 elements element NOUN bracis-19020 74 27 of of ADP bracis-19020 74 28 \(\mathtt \(\mathtt NOUN bracis-19020 74 29 { { PUNCT bracis-19020 74 30 arg}\ arg}\ NOUN bracis-19020 74 31 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 74 32 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 74 33 where where SCONJ bracis-19020 74 34 n n PRON bracis-19020 74 35 is be AUX bracis-19020 74 36 a a DET bracis-19020 74 37 positive positive ADJ bracis-19020 74 38 integer integer NOUN bracis-19020 74 39 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 74 40 such such ADJ bracis-19020 74 41 that that DET bracis-19020 74 42 \(a_1 \(a_1 PROPN bracis-19020 74 43 = = SYM bracis-19020 74 44 a\ a\ PROPN bracis-19020 74 45 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 74 46 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 74 47 \(\forall \(\forall ADV bracis-19020 74 48 i i PRON bracis-19020 74 49 \in \in PROPN bracis-19020 74 50 \{2 \{2 PROPN bracis-19020 74 51 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 74 52 3 3 NUM bracis-19020 74 53 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 74 54 .. .. PUNCT bracis-19020 74 55 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 75 1 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 75 2 n\}\ n\}\ NOUN bracis-19020 75 3 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 75 4 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 76 1 next next ADV bracis-19020 76 2 we we PRON bracis-19020 76 3 present present VERB bracis-19020 76 4 the the DET bracis-19020 76 5 semantics semantic NOUN bracis-19020 76 6 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 76 7 which which PRON bracis-19020 76 8 determines determine VERB bracis-19020 76 9 what what DET bracis-19020 76 10 arguments argument NOUN bracis-19020 76 11 are be AUX bracis-19020 76 12 considered consider VERB bracis-19020 76 13 acceptable acceptable ADJ bracis-19020 76 14 or or CCONJ bracis-19020 76 15 justified justify VERB bracis-19020 76 16 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 77 1 first first ADV bracis-19020 77 2 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 77 3 it it PRON bracis-19020 77 4 is be AUX bracis-19020 77 5 necessary necessary ADJ bracis-19020 77 6 the the DET bracis-19020 77 7 notion notion NOUN bracis-19020 77 8 of of ADP bracis-19020 77 9 supporters supporter NOUN bracis-19020 77 10 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 78 1 given give VERB bracis-19020 78 2 three three NUM bracis-19020 78 3 arguments argument NOUN bracis-19020 78 4 \(a_1\ \(a_1\ NOUN bracis-19020 78 5 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 78 6 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 78 7 \(a_2\ \(a_2\ PROPN bracis-19020 78 8 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 78 9 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 78 10 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 78 11 \(a_3\ \(a_3\ NOUN bracis-19020 78 12 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 78 13 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 79 1 if if SCONJ bracis-19020 79 2 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 79 3 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 79 4 then then ADV bracis-19020 79 5 \(a_3\ \(a_3\ NOUN bracis-19020 79 6 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 79 7 supports support VERB bracis-19020 79 8 \(a_1\ \(a_1\ NOUN bracis-19020 79 9 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 79 10 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 80 1 the the DET bracis-19020 80 2 acceptability acceptability NOUN bracis-19020 80 3 notion notion NOUN bracis-19020 80 4 is be AUX bracis-19020 80 5 directly directly ADV bracis-19020 80 6 related relate VERB bracis-19020 80 7 to to PART bracis-19020 80 8 argument argument VERB bracis-19020 80 9 a a PRON bracis-19020 80 10 because because SCONJ bracis-19020 80 11 it it PRON bracis-19020 80 12 represents represent VERB bracis-19020 80 13 the the DET bracis-19020 80 14 central central ADJ bracis-19020 80 15 point point NOUN bracis-19020 80 16 of of ADP bracis-19020 80 17 the the DET bracis-19020 80 18 discussion discussion NOUN bracis-19020 80 19 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 81 1 thus thus ADV bracis-19020 81 2 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 81 3 given give VERB bracis-19020 81 4 a a DET bracis-19020 81 5 sequence sequence NOUN bracis-19020 81 6 s s PART bracis-19020 81 7 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 81 8 we we PRON bracis-19020 81 9 can can AUX bracis-19020 81 10 say say VERB bracis-19020 81 11 that that SCONJ bracis-19020 81 12 \(\forall \(\forall ADV bracis-19020 81 13 a_i a_i PROPN bracis-19020 81 14 \in \in ADJ bracis-19020 81 15 s\ s\ NOUN bracis-19020 81 16 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 81 17 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 81 18 \(a_i\ \(a_i\ NOUN bracis-19020 81 19 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 81 20 supports support VERB bracis-19020 81 21 a a PRON bracis-19020 81 22 if if SCONJ bracis-19020 81 23 i i PRON bracis-19020 81 24 is be AUX bracis-19020 81 25 odd odd ADJ bracis-19020 81 26 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 81 27 it it PRON bracis-19020 81 28 attacks attack VERB bracis-19020 81 29 a a PRON bracis-19020 81 30 if if SCONJ bracis-19020 81 31 i i PRON bracis-19020 81 32 is be AUX bracis-19020 81 33 even even ADV bracis-19020 81 34 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 82 1 let let VERB bracis-19020 82 2 \(\mathtt \(\mathtt NOUN bracis-19020 82 3 { { PUNCT bracis-19020 82 4 sup}(a)\ sup}(a)\ NOUN bracis-19020 82 5 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 82 6 return return VERB bracis-19020 82 7 all all DET bracis-19020 82 8 the the DET bracis-19020 82 9 supporters supporter NOUN bracis-19020 82 10 of of ADP bracis-19020 82 11 \(a_1\ \(a_1\ PROPN bracis-19020 82 12 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 82 13 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 82 14 \(\mathtt \(\mathtt AUX bracis-19020 82 15 { { PUNCT bracis-19020 82 16 att}(a)\ att}(a)\ NOUN bracis-19020 82 17 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 82 18 return return VERB bracis-19020 82 19 all all DET bracis-19020 82 20 its its PRON bracis-19020 82 21 attackers attacker NOUN bracis-19020 82 22 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 83 1 definition definition NOUN bracis-19020 83 2 3 3 NUM bracis-19020 83 3 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 83 4 semantics semantic NOUN bracis-19020 83 5 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 83 6 let let AUX bracis-19020 83 7 be be AUX bracis-19020 83 8 an an DET bracis-19020 83 9 argumentation argumentation NOUN bracis-19020 83 10 framework framework NOUN bracis-19020 83 11 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 83 12 \(a \(a NOUN bracis-19020 83 13 \in \in PROPN bracis-19020 83 14 \mathtt \mathtt PROPN bracis-19020 83 15 { { PUNCT bracis-19020 83 16 arg}\ arg}\ PROPN bracis-19020 83 17 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 83 18 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 83 19 s s VERB bracis-19020 83 20 a a DET bracis-19020 83 21 sequence sequence NOUN bracis-19020 83 22 for for ADP bracis-19020 83 23 a a PRON bracis-19020 83 24 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 83 25 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 83 26 n n CCONJ bracis-19020 83 27 the the DET bracis-19020 83 28 length length NOUN bracis-19020 83 29 of of ADP bracis-19020 83 30 s. s. PROPN bracis-19020 83 31 it it PRON bracis-19020 83 32 holds hold VERB bracis-19020 83 33 that that SCONJ bracis-19020 83 34 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 83 35 i i NOUN bracis-19020 83 36 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 83 37 if if SCONJ bracis-19020 83 38 n n PRON bracis-19020 83 39 is be AUX bracis-19020 83 40 odd odd ADJ bracis-19020 83 41 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 83 42 then then ADV bracis-19020 83 43 \(a \(a NOUN bracis-19020 83 44 \cup \cup VERB bracis-19020 83 45 \mathtt \mathtt PROPN bracis-19020 83 46 { { PUNCT bracis-19020 83 47 sup}(a)\ sup}(a)\ NOUN bracis-19020 83 48 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 83 49 are be AUX bracis-19020 83 50 acceptable acceptable ADJ bracis-19020 83 51 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 83 52 or or CCONJ bracis-19020 83 53 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 83 54 ii ii NOUN bracis-19020 83 55 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 83 56 if if SCONJ bracis-19020 83 57 n n PRON bracis-19020 83 58 is be AUX bracis-19020 83 59 even even ADV bracis-19020 83 60 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 83 61 then then ADV bracis-19020 83 62 \ \ PROPN bracis-19020 83 63 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 83 64 \mathtt \mathtt X bracis-19020 83 65 { { PUNCT bracis-19020 83 66 att}(a)\ att}(a)\ NOUN bracis-19020 83 67 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 83 68 are be AUX bracis-19020 83 69 acceptable acceptable ADJ bracis-19020 83 70 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 84 1 let let AUX bracis-19020 84 2 be be AUX bracis-19020 84 3 a a DET bracis-19020 84 4 semantics semantic NOUN bracis-19020 84 5 function function NOUN bracis-19020 84 6 that that PRON bracis-19020 84 7 returns return VERB bracis-19020 84 8 the the DET bracis-19020 84 9 set set NOUN bracis-19020 84 10 of of ADP bracis-19020 84 11 acceptable acceptable ADJ bracis-19020 84 12 arguments argument NOUN bracis-19020 84 13 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 85 1 3 3 NUM bracis-19020 85 2 building building NOUN bracis-19020 85 3 blocks block NOUN bracis-19020 85 4 in in ADP bracis-19020 85 5 this this DET bracis-19020 85 6 section section NOUN bracis-19020 85 7 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 85 8 we we PRON bracis-19020 85 9 present present VERB bracis-19020 85 10 the the DET bracis-19020 85 11 topic topic NOUN bracis-19020 85 12 language language NOUN bracis-19020 85 13 used use VERB bracis-19020 85 14 to to PART bracis-19020 85 15 represent represent VERB bracis-19020 85 16 the the DET bracis-19020 85 17 content content NOUN bracis-19020 85 18 of of ADP bracis-19020 85 19 illocutions illocution NOUN bracis-19020 85 20 exchanged exchange VERB bracis-19020 85 21 by by ADP bracis-19020 85 22 agents agent NOUN bracis-19020 85 23 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 86 1 we we PRON bracis-19020 86 2 also also ADV bracis-19020 86 3 present present VERB bracis-19020 86 4 the the DET bracis-19020 86 5 definitions definition NOUN bracis-19020 86 6 of of ADP bracis-19020 86 7 the the DET bracis-19020 86 8 kinds kind NOUN bracis-19020 86 9 of of ADP bracis-19020 86 10 arguments argument NOUN bracis-19020 86 11 that that PRON bracis-19020 86 12 can can AUX bracis-19020 86 13 be be AUX bracis-19020 86 14 exchanged exchange VERB bracis-19020 86 15 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 86 16 study study VERB bracis-19020 86 17 the the DET bracis-19020 86 18 possible possible ADJ bracis-19020 86 19 attacks attack NOUN bracis-19020 86 20 to to ADP bracis-19020 86 21 each each PRON bracis-19020 86 22 of of ADP bracis-19020 86 23 them they PRON bracis-19020 86 24 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 87 1 according accord VERB bracis-19020 87 2 to to ADP bracis-19020 87 3 van van PROPN bracis-19020 87 4 veenen veenen PROPN bracis-19020 87 5 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 87 6 prakken prakken VERB bracis-19020 87 7 [ [ PUNCT bracis-19020 87 8 30 30 NUM bracis-19020 87 9 ] ] PUNCT bracis-19020 87 10 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 87 11 formal formal ADJ bracis-19020 87 12 dialogue dialogue NOUN bracis-19020 87 13 games game NOUN bracis-19020 87 14 have have VERB bracis-19020 87 15 a a DET bracis-19020 87 16 topic topic NOUN bracis-19020 87 17 language language NOUN bracis-19020 87 18 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 87 19 expressed express VERB bracis-19020 87 20 in in ADP bracis-19020 87 21 a a DET bracis-19020 87 22 certain certain ADJ bracis-19020 87 23 logic logic NOUN bracis-19020 87 24 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 87 25 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 87 26 a a DET bracis-19020 87 27 communication communication NOUN bracis-19020 87 28 language language NOUN bracis-19020 87 29 with with ADP bracis-19020 87 30 a a DET bracis-19020 87 31 protocol protocol NOUN bracis-19020 87 32 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 87 33 which which PRON bracis-19020 87 34 specifies specify VERB bracis-19020 87 35 the the DET bracis-19020 87 36 allowed allow VERB bracis-19020 87 37 moves move NOUN bracis-19020 87 38 at at ADP bracis-19020 87 39 each each DET bracis-19020 87 40 point point NOUN bracis-19020 87 41 in in ADP bracis-19020 87 42 a a DET bracis-19020 87 43 dialogue dialogue NOUN bracis-19020 87 44 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 88 1 we we PRON bracis-19020 88 2 can can AUX bracis-19020 88 3 say say VERB bracis-19020 88 4 that that SCONJ bracis-19020 88 5 a a DET bracis-19020 88 6 persuasive persuasive ADJ bracis-19020 88 7 negotiation negotiation NOUN bracis-19020 88 8 dialogue dialogue NOUN bracis-19020 88 9 happens happen VERB bracis-19020 88 10 between between ADP bracis-19020 88 11 a a DET bracis-19020 88 12 proponent proponent ADJ bracis-19020 88 13 agent agent NOUN bracis-19020 88 14 p p NOUN bracis-19020 88 15 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 88 16 an an DET bracis-19020 88 17 opponent opponent NOUN bracis-19020 88 18 agent agent NOUN bracis-19020 88 19 o o INTJ bracis-19020 88 20 about about ADP bracis-19020 88 21 a a DET bracis-19020 88 22 topic topic NOUN bracis-19020 88 23 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 89 1 in in ADP bracis-19020 89 2 this this DET bracis-19020 89 3 work work NOUN bracis-19020 89 4 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 89 5 the the DET bracis-19020 89 6 topic topic NOUN bracis-19020 89 7 language language NOUN bracis-19020 89 8 is be AUX bracis-19020 89 9 specified specify VERB bracis-19020 89 10 using use VERB bracis-19020 89 11 the the DET bracis-19020 89 12 classical classical ADJ bracis-19020 89 13 logical logical ADJ bracis-19020 89 14 language language NOUN bracis-19020 89 15 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 90 1 symbols symbol NOUN bracis-19020 90 2 \(\wedge \(\wedge VERB bracis-19020 90 3 \),\(\vee \),\(\vee PROPN bracis-19020 90 4 \ \ NOUN bracis-19020 90 5 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 90 6 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 90 7 \(\lnot \(\lnot ADV bracis-19020 90 8 \ \ NOUN bracis-19020 90 9 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 90 10 denote denote VERB bracis-19020 90 11 the the DET bracis-19020 90 12 logical logical ADJ bracis-19020 90 13 connectives connective NOUN bracis-19020 90 14 conjunction conjunction NOUN bracis-19020 90 15 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 90 16 disjunction disjunction NOUN bracis-19020 90 17 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 90 18 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 90 19 negation negation NOUN bracis-19020 90 20 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 90 21 respectively respectively ADV bracis-19020 90 22 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 91 1 besides besides ADV bracis-19020 91 2 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 91 3 \(\vdash \(\vdash NOUN bracis-19020 91 4 \ \ NOUN bracis-19020 91 5 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 91 6 stands stand VERB bracis-19020 91 7 for for ADP bracis-19020 91 8 the the DET bracis-19020 91 9 classical classical ADJ bracis-19020 91 10 inference inference NOUN bracis-19020 91 11 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 91 12 \(\equiv \(\equiv PROPN bracis-19020 91 13 \ \ PROPN bracis-19020 91 14 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 91 15 logical logical ADJ bracis-19020 91 16 equivalence equivalence NOUN bracis-19020 91 17 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 92 1 from from ADP bracis-19020 92 2 we we PRON bracis-19020 92 3 can can AUX bracis-19020 92 4 distinguish distinguish VERB bracis-19020 92 5 the the DET bracis-19020 92 6 three three NUM bracis-19020 92 7 following follow VERB bracis-19020 92 8 sets set NOUN bracis-19020 92 9 of of ADP bracis-19020 92 10 formulas formula NOUN bracis-19020 92 11 : : PUNCT bracis-19020 92 12 contains contain VERB bracis-19020 92 13 the the DET bracis-19020 92 14 goals goal NOUN bracis-19020 92 15 the the DET bracis-19020 92 16 agent agent NOUN bracis-19020 92 17 pursues pursue VERB bracis-19020 92 18 ; ; PUNCT bracis-19020 92 19 contains contain VERB bracis-19020 92 20 what what PRON bracis-19020 92 21 the the DET bracis-19020 92 22 agent agent NOUN bracis-19020 92 23 believes believe VERB bracis-19020 92 24 the the DET bracis-19020 92 25 goals goal NOUN bracis-19020 92 26 of of ADP bracis-19020 92 27 the the DET bracis-19020 92 28 other other ADJ bracis-19020 92 29 agent agent NOUN bracis-19020 92 30 are be AUX bracis-19020 92 31 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 92 32 that that ADV bracis-19020 92 33 is is ADV bracis-19020 92 34 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 92 35 his his PRON bracis-19020 92 36 opponent opponent NOUN bracis-19020 92 37 ’s ’s PART bracis-19020 92 38 goals goal NOUN bracis-19020 92 39 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 92 40 ; ; PUNCT bracis-19020 92 41 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 92 42 is be AUX bracis-19020 92 43 the the DET bracis-19020 92 44 knowledge knowledge NOUN bracis-19020 92 45 base base NOUN bracis-19020 92 46 of of ADP bracis-19020 92 47 the the DET bracis-19020 92 48 agent agent NOUN bracis-19020 92 49 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 92 50 which which PRON bracis-19020 92 51 gathers gather VERB bracis-19020 92 52 the the DET bracis-19020 92 53 information information NOUN bracis-19020 92 54 the the DET bracis-19020 92 55 agent agent NOUN bracis-19020 92 56 has have VERB bracis-19020 92 57 about about ADP bracis-19020 92 58 the the DET bracis-19020 92 59 environment environment NOUN bracis-19020 92 60 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 93 1 goals goal NOUN bracis-19020 93 2 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 93 3 opponent opponent NOUN bracis-19020 93 4 ’s ’s PART bracis-19020 93 5 goals goal NOUN bracis-19020 93 6 are be AUX bracis-19020 93 7 represented represent VERB bracis-19020 93 8 with with ADP bracis-19020 93 9 positive positive ADJ bracis-19020 93 10 literalsfootnote literalsfootnote NOUN bracis-19020 93 11 1 1 NUM bracis-19020 93 12 from from ADP bracis-19020 93 13 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 94 1 besides besides ADV bracis-19020 94 2 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 94 3 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 94 4 are be AUX bracis-19020 94 5 finite finite ADJ bracis-19020 94 6 sets set NOUN bracis-19020 94 7 such such ADJ bracis-19020 94 8 that that PRON bracis-19020 94 9 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 95 1 now now ADV bracis-19020 95 2 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 95 3 let let VERB bracis-19020 95 4 us we PRON bracis-19020 95 5 present present VERB bracis-19020 95 6 the the DET bracis-19020 95 7 definitions definition NOUN bracis-19020 95 8 of of ADP bracis-19020 95 9 arguments argument NOUN bracis-19020 95 10 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 95 11 explanatory explanatory ADJ bracis-19020 95 12 arguments argument NOUN bracis-19020 95 13 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 95 14 rhetorical rhetorical ADJ bracis-19020 95 15 arguments argument NOUN bracis-19020 95 16 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 95 17 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 95 18 attacks attack NOUN bracis-19020 95 19 involved involve VERB bracis-19020 95 20 during during ADP bracis-19020 95 21 a a DET bracis-19020 95 22 persuasive persuasive ADJ bracis-19020 95 23 negotiation negotiation NOUN bracis-19020 95 24 dialogue dialogue NOUN bracis-19020 95 25 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 96 1 in in ADP bracis-19020 96 2 what what PRON bracis-19020 96 3 follows follow VERB bracis-19020 96 4 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 96 5 for for ADP bracis-19020 96 6 a a DET bracis-19020 96 7 given give VERB bracis-19020 96 8 argument argument NOUN bracis-19020 96 9 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 96 10 the the DET bracis-19020 96 11 function function NOUN bracis-19020 96 12 \(\mathtt \(\mathtt VERB bracis-19020 96 13 { { PUNCT bracis-19020 96 14 supp}\ supp}\ NOUN bracis-19020 96 15 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 96 16 returns return VERB bracis-19020 96 17 all all DET bracis-19020 96 18 the the DET bracis-19020 96 19 beliefs belief NOUN bracis-19020 96 20 of of ADP bracis-19020 96 21 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 96 22 called call VERB bracis-19020 96 23 support support NOUN bracis-19020 96 24 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 96 25 used use VERB bracis-19020 96 26 to to PART bracis-19020 96 27 build build VERB bracis-19020 96 28 the the DET bracis-19020 96 29 argument argument NOUN bracis-19020 96 30 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 96 31 \(\mathtt \(\mathtt NOUN bracis-19020 96 32 { { PUNCT bracis-19020 96 33 conc}\ conc}\ PROPN bracis-19020 96 34 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 96 35 returns return VERB bracis-19020 96 36 its its PRON bracis-19020 96 37 conclusion conclusion NOUN bracis-19020 96 38 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 97 1 the the DET bracis-19020 97 2 first first ADJ bracis-19020 97 3 one one NOUN bracis-19020 97 4 is be AUX bracis-19020 97 5 a a DET bracis-19020 97 6 basic basic ADJ bracis-19020 97 7 definition definition NOUN bracis-19020 97 8 where where SCONJ bracis-19020 97 9 any any DET bracis-19020 97 10 element element NOUN bracis-19020 97 11 of of ADP bracis-19020 97 12 can can AUX bracis-19020 97 13 be be AUX bracis-19020 97 14 an an DET bracis-19020 97 15 argument argument NOUN bracis-19020 97 16 whereas whereas SCONJ bracis-19020 97 17 explanatory explanatory ADJ bracis-19020 97 18 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 97 19 rhetorical rhetorical ADJ bracis-19020 97 20 arguments argument NOUN bracis-19020 97 21 have have VERB bracis-19020 97 22 a a DET bracis-19020 97 23 deductive deductive ADJ bracis-19020 97 24 form form NOUN bracis-19020 97 25 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 98 1 indeed indeed ADV bracis-19020 98 2 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 98 3 a a DET bracis-19020 98 4 fact fact NOUN bracis-19020 98 5 or or CCONJ bracis-19020 98 6 a a DET bracis-19020 98 7 goal goal NOUN bracis-19020 98 8 is be AUX bracis-19020 98 9 entailed entail VERB bracis-19020 98 10 from from ADP bracis-19020 98 11 the the DET bracis-19020 98 12 support support NOUN bracis-19020 98 13 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 99 1 definition definition NOUN bracis-19020 99 2 4 4 NUM bracis-19020 99 3 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 99 4 argument argument NOUN bracis-19020 99 5 [ [ X bracis-19020 99 6 19 19 NUM bracis-19020 99 7 ] ] PUNCT bracis-19020 99 8 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 99 9 let let AUX bracis-19020 99 10 be be AUX bracis-19020 99 11 a a DET bracis-19020 99 12 knowledge knowledge NOUN bracis-19020 99 13 base base NOUN bracis-19020 99 14 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 100 1 an an DET bracis-19020 100 2 argument argument NOUN bracis-19020 100 3 a a PRON bracis-19020 100 4 is be AUX bracis-19020 100 5 \(\varphi \(\varphi PUNCT bracis-19020 100 6 \ \ NOUN bracis-19020 100 7 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 100 8 if if SCONJ bracis-19020 100 9 with with ADP bracis-19020 100 10 \(\mathtt \(\mathtt NOUN bracis-19020 100 11 { { PUNCT bracis-19020 100 12 supp}(a)\ supp}(a)\ NOUN bracis-19020 100 13 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 100 14 = = NOUN bracis-19020 100 15 \(\{\varphi \(\{\varphi NOUN bracis-19020 100 16 \}\ \}\ NOUN bracis-19020 100 17 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 100 18 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 100 19 \(\mathtt \(\mathtt VERB bracis-19020 100 20 { { PUNCT bracis-19020 100 21 conc}(a conc}(a PROPN bracis-19020 100 22 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 100 23 = = SYM bracis-19020 100 24 \varphi \varphi PROPN bracis-19020 100 25 \ \ NOUN bracis-19020 100 26 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 100 27 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 101 1 explanations explanation NOUN bracis-19020 101 2 are be AUX bracis-19020 101 3 the the DET bracis-19020 101 4 most most ADV bracis-19020 101 5 common common ADJ bracis-19020 101 6 category category NOUN bracis-19020 101 7 of of ADP bracis-19020 101 8 arguments argument NOUN bracis-19020 101 9 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 102 1 they they PRON bracis-19020 102 2 represent represent VERB bracis-19020 102 3 the the DET bracis-19020 102 4 reasons reason NOUN bracis-19020 102 5 to to PART bracis-19020 102 6 believe believe VERB bracis-19020 102 7 in in ADP bracis-19020 102 8 a a DET bracis-19020 102 9 fact fact NOUN bracis-19020 102 10 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 103 1 definition definition NOUN bracis-19020 103 2 5 5 NUM bracis-19020 103 3 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 103 4 explanatory explanatory ADJ bracis-19020 103 5 argument argument NOUN bracis-19020 103 6 [ [ X bracis-19020 103 7 7 7 NUM bracis-19020 103 8 ] ] PUNCT bracis-19020 103 9 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 103 10 let let AUX bracis-19020 103 11 be be AUX bracis-19020 103 12 the the DET bracis-19020 103 13 knowledge knowledge NOUN bracis-19020 103 14 base base NOUN bracis-19020 103 15 of of ADP bracis-19020 103 16 an an DET bracis-19020 103 17 agent agent NOUN bracis-19020 103 18 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 104 1 an an DET bracis-19020 104 2 explanatory explanatory ADJ bracis-19020 104 3 argument argument NOUN bracis-19020 104 4 is be AUX bracis-19020 104 5 a a DET bracis-19020 104 6 tuple tuple NOUN bracis-19020 104 7 such such ADJ bracis-19020 104 8 that that SCONJ bracis-19020 104 9 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 104 10 i i NOUN bracis-19020 104 11 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 104 12 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 104 13 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 104 14 ii ii NOUN bracis-19020 104 15 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 104 16 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 104 17 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 104 18 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 104 19 iii iii X bracis-19020 104 20 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 104 21 is be AUX bracis-19020 104 22 consistent consistent ADJ bracis-19020 104 23 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 104 24 minimal.footnote minimal.footnote NUM bracis-19020 104 25 2 2 NUM bracis-19020 104 26 with with ADP bracis-19020 104 27 : : PUNCT bracis-19020 104 28 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 104 29 \(\mathtt \(\mathtt NOUN bracis-19020 104 30 { { PUNCT bracis-19020 104 31 conc}(a)=h\ conc}(a)=h\ NOUN bracis-19020 104 32 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 104 33 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 105 1 unlike unlike ADP bracis-19020 105 2 explanatory explanatory ADJ bracis-19020 105 3 arguments argument NOUN bracis-19020 105 4 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 105 5 rhetorical rhetorical ADJ bracis-19020 105 6 arguments argument NOUN bracis-19020 105 7 are be AUX bracis-19020 105 8 also also ADV bracis-19020 105 9 made make VERB bracis-19020 105 10 up up ADP bracis-19020 105 11 by by ADP bracis-19020 105 12 goals goal NOUN bracis-19020 105 13 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 105 14 opponent opponent NOUN bracis-19020 105 15 ’s ’s PART bracis-19020 105 16 goals goal NOUN bracis-19020 105 17 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 106 1 definition definition NOUN bracis-19020 106 2 6 6 NUM bracis-19020 106 3 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 106 4 rhetorical rhetorical ADJ bracis-19020 106 5 arguments argument NOUN bracis-19020 106 6 [ [ X bracis-19020 106 7 7 7 NUM bracis-19020 106 8 ] ] PUNCT bracis-19020 106 9 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 106 10 let let AUX bracis-19020 106 11 be be AUX bracis-19020 106 12 the the DET bracis-19020 106 13 knowledge knowledge NOUN bracis-19020 106 14 base base NOUN bracis-19020 106 15 of of ADP bracis-19020 106 16 an an DET bracis-19020 106 17 agent agent NOUN bracis-19020 106 18 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 106 19 be be AUX bracis-19020 106 20 his his PRON bracis-19020 106 21 goals goal NOUN bracis-19020 106 22 base base NOUN bracis-19020 106 23 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 106 24 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 106 25 be be AUX bracis-19020 106 26 his his PRON bracis-19020 106 27 opponent opponent NOUN bracis-19020 106 28 ’s ’s PART bracis-19020 106 29 goals goal NOUN bracis-19020 106 30 base base VERB bracis-19020 106 31 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 107 1 a a DET bracis-19020 107 2 threat threat NOUN bracis-19020 107 3 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 107 4 reward reward NOUN bracis-19020 107 5 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 107 6 or or CCONJ bracis-19020 107 7 appeal appeal NOUN bracis-19020 107 8 is be AUX bracis-19020 107 9 a a DET bracis-19020 107 10 triple triple ADJ bracis-19020 107 11 such such ADJ bracis-19020 107 12 that that SCONJ bracis-19020 107 13 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 107 14 i i NOUN bracis-19020 107 15 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 107 16 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 107 17 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 107 18 ii ii NOUN bracis-19020 107 19 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 107 20 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 107 21 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 107 22 iii iii NOUN bracis-19020 107 23 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 107 24     SPACE bracis-19020 107 25 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 107 26 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 107 27 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 107 28 iv iv X bracis-19020 107 29 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 107 30 is be AUX bracis-19020 107 31 consistent consistent ADJ bracis-19020 107 32 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 107 33 minimal minimal ADJ bracis-19020 107 34 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 108 1 besides besides SCONJ bracis-19020 108 2 : : PUNCT bracis-19020 108 3 in in ADP bracis-19020 108 4 the the DET bracis-19020 108 5 case case NOUN bracis-19020 108 6 of of ADP bracis-19020 108 7 threats threat NOUN bracis-19020 108 8 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 108 9 it it PRON bracis-19020 108 10 holds hold VERB bracis-19020 108 11 that that SCONJ bracis-19020 108 12 in in ADP bracis-19020 108 13 the the DET bracis-19020 108 14 case case NOUN bracis-19020 108 15 of of ADP bracis-19020 108 16 rewards reward NOUN bracis-19020 108 17 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 108 18 appeals appeal NOUN bracis-19020 108 19 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 108 20 it it PRON bracis-19020 108 21 holds hold VERB bracis-19020 108 22 that that PRON bracis-19020 108 23 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 109 1 with with ADP bracis-19020 109 2 : : PUNCT bracis-19020 109 3 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 109 4 \(\mathtt \(\mathtt NOUN bracis-19020 109 5 { { PUNCT bracis-19020 109 6 conc}(a)=g\ conc}(a)=g\ PROPN bracis-19020 109 7 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 109 8 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 109 9 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 109 10 \(\mathtt \(\mathtt NOUN bracis-19020 109 11 { { PUNCT bracis-19020 109 12 opgoal}(a)=go\ opgoal}(a)=go\ INTJ bracis-19020 109 13 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 109 14 returns return VERB bracis-19020 109 15 the the DET bracis-19020 109 16 goal goal NOUN bracis-19020 109 17 that that PRON bracis-19020 109 18 is be AUX bracis-19020 109 19 being be AUX bracis-19020 109 20 threatened threaten VERB bracis-19020 109 21 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 109 22 rewarded reward VERB bracis-19020 109 23 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 109 24 or or CCONJ bracis-19020 109 25 appealed appeal VERB bracis-19020 109 26 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 110 1 it it PRON bracis-19020 110 2 is be AUX bracis-19020 110 3 also also ADV bracis-19020 110 4 necessary necessary ADJ bracis-19020 110 5 to to PART bracis-19020 110 6 define define VERB bracis-19020 110 7 the the DET bracis-19020 110 8 attacks attack NOUN bracis-19020 110 9 each each DET bracis-19020 110 10 kind kind NOUN bracis-19020 110 11 of of ADP bracis-19020 110 12 argument argument NOUN bracis-19020 110 13 may may AUX bracis-19020 110 14 receive receive VERB bracis-19020 110 15 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 111 1 an an DET bracis-19020 111 2 attack attack NOUN bracis-19020 111 3 relation relation NOUN bracis-19020 111 4 between between ADP bracis-19020 111 5 two two NUM bracis-19020 111 6 arguments argument NOUN bracis-19020 111 7 a a DET bracis-19020 111 8 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 111 9 b b NOUN bracis-19020 111 10 denotes denote NOUN bracis-19020 111 11 the the DET bracis-19020 111 12 fact fact NOUN bracis-19020 111 13 that that SCONJ bracis-19020 111 14 these these DET bracis-19020 111 15 arguments argument NOUN bracis-19020 111 16 can can AUX bracis-19020 111 17 not not PART bracis-19020 111 18 be be AUX bracis-19020 111 19 accepted accept VERB bracis-19020 111 20 simultaneously simultaneously ADV bracis-19020 111 21 since since SCONJ bracis-19020 111 22 they they PRON bracis-19020 111 23 contradict contradict VERB bracis-19020 111 24 each each DET bracis-19020 111 25 other other ADJ bracis-19020 111 26 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 112 1 in in ADP bracis-19020 112 2 the the DET bracis-19020 112 3 case case NOUN bracis-19020 112 4 of of ADP bracis-19020 112 5 explanatory explanatory ADJ bracis-19020 112 6 arguments argument NOUN bracis-19020 112 7 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 112 8 two two NUM bracis-19020 112 9 kinds kind NOUN bracis-19020 112 10 of of ADP bracis-19020 112 11 attacks attack NOUN bracis-19020 112 12 can can AUX bracis-19020 112 13 be be AUX bracis-19020 112 14 determined determine VERB bracis-19020 112 15 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 112 16 undercuts undercut NOUN bracis-19020 112 17 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 112 18 rebuttals rebuttal NOUN bracis-19020 112 19 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 113 1 an an DET bracis-19020 113 2 undercutting undercutting ADJ bracis-19020 113 3 argument argument NOUN bracis-19020 113 4 is be AUX bracis-19020 113 5 an an DET bracis-19020 113 6 argument argument NOUN bracis-19020 113 7 whose whose DET bracis-19020 113 8 conclusion conclusion NOUN bracis-19020 113 9 contradicts contradict VERB bracis-19020 113 10 some some PRON bracis-19020 113 11 of of ADP bracis-19020 113 12 the the DET bracis-19020 113 13 elements element NOUN bracis-19020 113 14 of of ADP bracis-19020 113 15 the the DET bracis-19020 113 16 support support NOUN bracis-19020 113 17 of of ADP bracis-19020 113 18 another another DET bracis-19020 113 19 argument argument NOUN bracis-19020 113 20 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 113 21 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 113 22 a a DET bracis-19020 113 23 rebutting rebut VERB bracis-19020 113 24 argument argument NOUN bracis-19020 113 25 is be AUX bracis-19020 113 26 an an DET bracis-19020 113 27 argument argument NOUN bracis-19020 113 28 whose whose DET bracis-19020 113 29 conclusion conclusion NOUN bracis-19020 113 30 is be AUX bracis-19020 113 31 the the DET bracis-19020 113 32 negation negation NOUN bracis-19020 113 33 of of ADP bracis-19020 113 34 the the DET bracis-19020 113 35 conclusion conclusion NOUN bracis-19020 113 36 of of ADP bracis-19020 113 37 another another DET bracis-19020 113 38 argument argument NOUN bracis-19020 113 39 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 114 1 formally formally ADV bracis-19020 114 2 : : PUNCT bracis-19020 114 3 definition definition NOUN bracis-19020 114 4 7 7 NUM bracis-19020 114 5 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 114 6 attacks attack NOUN bracis-19020 114 7 to to PART bracis-19020 114 8 explanatory explanatory ADJ bracis-19020 114 9 arguments argument NOUN bracis-19020 114 10 [ [ X bracis-19020 114 11 7 7 NUM bracis-19020 114 12 ] ] PUNCT bracis-19020 114 13 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 114 14 let let VERB bracis-19020 114 15 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 114 16 be be AUX bracis-19020 114 17 two two NUM bracis-19020 114 18 explanatory explanatory ADJ bracis-19020 114 19 arguments argument NOUN bracis-19020 114 20 : : PUNCT bracis-19020 114 21 undercuts undercut VERB bracis-19020 114 22 iff iff PROPN bracis-19020 114 23 such such ADJ bracis-19020 114 24 that that DET bracis-19020 114 25 \(h \(h NOUN bracis-19020 114 26 ' ' PUNCT bracis-19020 114 27 \equiv \equiv PROPN bracis-19020 114 28 \lnot \lnot PROPN bracis-19020 114 29 h''\ h''\ PRON bracis-19020 114 30 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 114 31 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 115 1 rebuts rebut VERB bracis-19020 115 2 iff iff PROPN bracis-19020 115 3 \(h \(h PROPN bracis-19020 115 4 \equiv \equiv PROPN bracis-19020 115 5 \lnot \lnot PROPN bracis-19020 115 6 h'\ h'\ PROPN bracis-19020 115 7 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 115 8 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 116 1 regarding regard VERB bracis-19020 116 2 attacks attack NOUN bracis-19020 116 3 to to ADP bracis-19020 116 4 rhetorical rhetorical ADJ bracis-19020 116 5 arguments argument NOUN bracis-19020 116 6 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 116 7 we we PRON bracis-19020 116 8 have have AUX bracis-19020 116 9 distinguished distinguish VERB bracis-19020 116 10 three three NUM bracis-19020 116 11 types type NOUN bracis-19020 116 12 of of ADP bracis-19020 116 13 attacks attack NOUN bracis-19020 116 14 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 117 1 the the DET bracis-19020 117 2 first first ADJ bracis-19020 117 3 one one NUM bracis-19020 117 4 occurs occur VERB bracis-19020 117 5 when when SCONJ bracis-19020 117 6 a a DET bracis-19020 117 7 threat threat NOUN bracis-19020 117 8 is be AUX bracis-19020 117 9 attacked attack VERB bracis-19020 117 10 by by ADP bracis-19020 117 11 another another DET bracis-19020 117 12 threat threat NOUN bracis-19020 117 13 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 117 14 we we PRON bracis-19020 117 15 can can AUX bracis-19020 117 16 call call VERB bracis-19020 117 17 it it PRON bracis-19020 117 18 a a DET bracis-19020 117 19 counter counter NOUN bracis-19020 117 20 - - NOUN bracis-19020 117 21 threat threat NOUN bracis-19020 117 22 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 117 23 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 118 1 in in ADP bracis-19020 118 2 this this DET bracis-19020 118 3 case case NOUN bracis-19020 118 4 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 118 5 there there PRON bracis-19020 118 6 is be VERB bracis-19020 118 7 no no DET bracis-19020 118 8 a a DET bracis-19020 118 9 logical logical ADJ bracis-19020 118 10 contradiction contradiction NOUN bracis-19020 118 11 but but CCONJ bracis-19020 118 12 we we PRON bracis-19020 118 13 can can AUX bracis-19020 118 14 notice notice VERB bracis-19020 118 15 that that SCONJ bracis-19020 118 16 the the DET bracis-19020 118 17 goal goal NOUN bracis-19020 118 18 threatened threaten VERB bracis-19020 118 19 by by ADP bracis-19020 118 20 an an DET bracis-19020 118 21 agent agent NOUN bracis-19020 118 22 is be AUX bracis-19020 118 23 used use VERB bracis-19020 118 24 by by ADP bracis-19020 118 25 the the DET bracis-19020 118 26 opponent opponent NOUN bracis-19020 118 27 to to PART bracis-19020 118 28 construct construct VERB bracis-19020 118 29 another another DET bracis-19020 118 30 threat threat NOUN bracis-19020 118 31 as as SCONJ bracis-19020 118 32 can can AUX bracis-19020 118 33 be be AUX bracis-19020 118 34 observed observe VERB bracis-19020 118 35 in in ADP bracis-19020 118 36 lines line NOUN bracis-19020 118 37 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 118 38 7 7 NUM bracis-19020 118 39 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 118 40 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 118 41 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 118 42 8) 8) NUM bracis-19020 118 43 of of ADP bracis-19020 118 44 the the DET bracis-19020 118 45 example example NOUN bracis-19020 118 46 given give VERB bracis-19020 118 47 in in ADP bracis-19020 118 48 introduction introduction NOUN bracis-19020 118 49 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 119 1 definition definition NOUN bracis-19020 119 2 8 8 NUM bracis-19020 119 3 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 119 4 counter counter NOUN bracis-19020 119 5 - - NOUN bracis-19020 119 6 threat threat NOUN bracis-19020 119 7 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 119 8 let let AUX bracis-19020 119 9 be be AUX bracis-19020 119 10 the the DET bracis-19020 119 11 set set NOUN bracis-19020 119 12 of of ADP bracis-19020 119 13 goals goal NOUN bracis-19020 119 14 of of ADP bracis-19020 119 15 an an DET bracis-19020 119 16 proponent proponent ADJ bracis-19020 119 17 agent agent NOUN bracis-19020 119 18 p p NOUN bracis-19020 119 19 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 119 20 be be AUX bracis-19020 119 21 a a DET bracis-19020 119 22 threat threat NOUN bracis-19020 119 23 of of ADP bracis-19020 119 24 p p NOUN bracis-19020 119 25 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 119 26 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 119 27 be be AUX bracis-19020 119 28 a a DET bracis-19020 119 29 threat threat NOUN bracis-19020 119 30 of of ADP bracis-19020 119 31 opponent opponent ADJ bracis-19020 119 32 agent agent NOUN bracis-19020 120 1 o. o. INTJ bracis-19020 120 2 we we PRON bracis-19020 120 3 say say VERB bracis-19020 120 4 that that SCONJ bracis-19020 120 5 \(th_o\ \(th_o\ ADV bracis-19020 120 6 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 120 7 counter counter NOUN bracis-19020 120 8 - - PUNCT bracis-19020 120 9 threatens threaten VERB bracis-19020 120 10 \(th_p\ \(th_p\ NOUN bracis-19020 120 11 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 120 12 when when SCONJ bracis-19020 120 13 \(g'=go\ \(g'=go\ NUM bracis-19020 120 14 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 120 15 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 120 16 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 121 1 the the DET bracis-19020 121 2 second second ADJ bracis-19020 121 3 type type NOUN bracis-19020 121 4 of of ADP bracis-19020 121 5 attack attack NOUN bracis-19020 121 6 occurs occur VERB bracis-19020 121 7 when when SCONJ bracis-19020 121 8 the the DET bracis-19020 121 9 opponent opponent NOUN bracis-19020 121 10 answers answer VERB bracis-19020 121 11 disesteeming disesteem VERB bracis-19020 121 12 his his PRON bracis-19020 121 13 threatened threaten VERB bracis-19020 121 14 / / SYM bracis-19020 121 15 rewarded reward VERB bracis-19020 121 16 / / PUNCT bracis-19020 121 17 appealed appeal VERB bracis-19020 121 18 goal goal NOUN bracis-19020 121 19 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 121 20 denies deny VERB bracis-19020 121 21 his his PRON bracis-19020 121 22 interest interest NOUN bracis-19020 121 23 in in ADP bracis-19020 121 24 achieving achieve VERB bracis-19020 121 25 it it PRON bracis-19020 121 26 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 122 1 for for ADP bracis-19020 122 2 example example NOUN bracis-19020 122 3 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 122 4 line line NOUN bracis-19020 122 5 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 122 6 9 9 NUM bracis-19020 122 7 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 122 8 of of ADP bracis-19020 122 9 the the DET bracis-19020 122 10 example example NOUN bracis-19020 122 11 given give VERB bracis-19020 122 12 in in ADP bracis-19020 122 13 introduction introduction NOUN bracis-19020 122 14 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 123 1 in in ADP bracis-19020 123 2 line line NOUN bracis-19020 123 3 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 123 4 8) 8) NUM bracis-19020 123 5 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 123 6 carlos carlos PROPN bracis-19020 123 7 threatens threaten VERB bracis-19020 123 8 maria maria PROPN bracis-19020 123 9 with with ADP bracis-19020 123 10 not not PART bracis-19020 123 11 talking talk VERB bracis-19020 123 12 with with ADP bracis-19020 123 13 his his PRON bracis-19020 123 14 mother mother NOUN bracis-19020 123 15 about about ADP bracis-19020 123 16 a a DET bracis-19020 123 17 job job NOUN bracis-19020 123 18 for for ADP bracis-19020 123 19 maria maria PROPN bracis-19020 123 20 ’s ’s PART bracis-19020 123 21 brother brother NOUN bracis-19020 123 22 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 123 23 in in ADP bracis-19020 123 24 line line NOUN bracis-19020 123 25 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 123 26 9 9 NUM bracis-19020 123 27 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 123 28 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 123 29 she she PRON bracis-19020 123 30 says say VERB bracis-19020 123 31 that that SCONJ bracis-19020 123 32 her her PRON bracis-19020 123 33 brother brother NOUN bracis-19020 123 34 already already ADV bracis-19020 123 35 got get VERB bracis-19020 123 36 a a DET bracis-19020 123 37 job job NOUN bracis-19020 123 38 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 124 1 this this DET bracis-19020 124 2 attack attack NOUN bracis-19020 124 3 has have VERB bracis-19020 124 4 the the DET bracis-19020 124 5 form form NOUN bracis-19020 124 6 of of ADP bracis-19020 124 7 an an DET bracis-19020 124 8 explanatory explanatory ADJ bracis-19020 124 9 argument argument NOUN bracis-19020 124 10 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 125 1 definition definition NOUN bracis-19020 125 2 9 9 NUM bracis-19020 125 3 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 125 4 disesteemation disesteemation NOUN bracis-19020 125 5 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 125 6 let let AUX bracis-19020 125 7 be be AUX bracis-19020 125 8 a a DET bracis-19020 125 9 rhetorical rhetorical ADJ bracis-19020 125 10 argument argument NOUN bracis-19020 125 11 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 126 1 an an DET bracis-19020 126 2 argument argument NOUN bracis-19020 126 3 disesteems disesteem VERB bracis-19020 126 4 a a DET bracis-19020 126 5 when when SCONJ bracis-19020 126 6 \(g'=\lnot \(g'=\lnot ADV bracis-19020 126 7 go\ go\ NOUN bracis-19020 126 8 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 126 9 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 127 1 to to ADP bracis-19020 127 2 the the DET bracis-19020 127 3 best good ADJ bracis-19020 127 4 of of ADP bracis-19020 127 5 our our PRON bracis-19020 127 6 knowledge knowledge NOUN bracis-19020 127 7 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 127 8 the the DET bracis-19020 127 9 two two NUM bracis-19020 127 10 previous previous ADJ bracis-19020 127 11 types type NOUN bracis-19020 127 12 of of ADP bracis-19020 127 13 attacks attack NOUN bracis-19020 127 14 were be AUX bracis-19020 127 15 not not PART bracis-19020 127 16 studied study VERB bracis-19020 127 17 before before ADV bracis-19020 127 18 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 128 1 on on ADP bracis-19020 128 2 the the DET bracis-19020 128 3 other other ADJ bracis-19020 128 4 hand hand NOUN bracis-19020 128 5 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 128 6 a a DET bracis-19020 128 7 rhetorical rhetorical ADJ bracis-19020 128 8 argument argument NOUN bracis-19020 128 9 can can AUX bracis-19020 128 10 also also ADV bracis-19020 128 11 be be AUX bracis-19020 128 12 undercut undercut ADJ bracis-19020 128 13 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 129 1 4 4 NUM bracis-19020 129 2 the the DET bracis-19020 129 3 proposal proposal NOUN bracis-19020 129 4 in in ADP bracis-19020 129 5 this this DET bracis-19020 129 6 section section NOUN bracis-19020 129 7 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 129 8 we we PRON bracis-19020 129 9 present present VERB bracis-19020 129 10 the the DET bracis-19020 129 11 language language NOUN bracis-19020 129 12 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 129 13 the the DET bracis-19020 129 14 rules rule NOUN bracis-19020 129 15 for for ADP bracis-19020 129 16 the the DET bracis-19020 129 17 dialogue dialogue NOUN bracis-19020 129 18 game game NOUN bracis-19020 129 19 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 130 1 besides besides SCONJ bracis-19020 130 2 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 130 3 we we PRON bracis-19020 130 4 present present VERB bracis-19020 130 5 the the DET bracis-19020 130 6 argumentation argumentation NOUN bracis-19020 130 7 framework framework NOUN bracis-19020 130 8 that that PRON bracis-19020 130 9 represents represent VERB bracis-19020 130 10 the the DET bracis-19020 130 11 dialogue dialogue NOUN bracis-19020 130 12 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 130 13 determines determine VERB bracis-19020 130 14 its its PRON bracis-19020 130 15 outcome outcome NOUN bracis-19020 130 16 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 131 1 4.1 4.1 NUM bracis-19020 131 2 the the DET bracis-19020 131 3 proposed propose VERB bracis-19020 131 4 protocol protocol NOUN bracis-19020 131 5 the the DET bracis-19020 131 6 game game NOUN bracis-19020 131 7 is be AUX bracis-19020 131 8 mainly mainly ADV bracis-19020 131 9 based base VERB bracis-19020 131 10 on on ADP bracis-19020 131 11 the the DET bracis-19020 131 12 following follow VERB bracis-19020 131 13 ideas idea NOUN bracis-19020 131 14 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 132 1 each each DET bracis-19020 132 2 move move NOUN bracis-19020 132 3 in in ADP bracis-19020 132 4 the the DET bracis-19020 132 5 dialogue dialogue NOUN bracis-19020 132 6 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 132 7 except except SCONJ bracis-19020 132 8 the the DET bracis-19020 132 9 initial initial ADJ bracis-19020 132 10 one one NUM bracis-19020 132 11 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 132 12 replies reply VERB bracis-19020 132 13 to to ADP bracis-19020 132 14 the the DET bracis-19020 132 15 previous previous ADJ bracis-19020 132 16 move move NOUN bracis-19020 132 17 of of ADP bracis-19020 132 18 the the DET bracis-19020 132 19 other other ADJ bracis-19020 132 20 agent agent NOUN bracis-19020 132 21 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 132 22 we we PRON bracis-19020 132 23 refer refer VERB bracis-19020 132 24 to to ADP bracis-19020 132 25 the the DET bracis-19020 132 26 previous previous ADJ bracis-19020 132 27 move move NOUN bracis-19020 132 28 as as ADP bracis-19020 132 29 its its PRON bracis-19020 132 30 target target NOUN bracis-19020 132 31 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 132 32 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 133 1 in in ADP bracis-19020 133 2 [ [ X bracis-19020 133 3 24 24 NUM bracis-19020 133 4 ] ] PUNCT bracis-19020 133 5 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 133 6 the the DET bracis-19020 133 7 author author NOUN bracis-19020 133 8 proposes propose VERB bracis-19020 133 9 the the DET bracis-19020 133 10 idea idea NOUN bracis-19020 133 11 of of ADP bracis-19020 133 12 attack attack NOUN bracis-19020 133 13 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 133 14 surrender surrender NOUN bracis-19020 133 15 as as ADP bracis-19020 133 16 a a DET bracis-19020 133 17 categorization categorization NOUN bracis-19020 133 18 of of ADP bracis-19020 133 19 the the DET bracis-19020 133 20 possible possible ADJ bracis-19020 133 21 replies reply NOUN bracis-19020 133 22 to to ADP bracis-19020 133 23 previous previous ADJ bracis-19020 133 24 moves move NOUN bracis-19020 133 25 during during ADP bracis-19020 133 26 the the DET bracis-19020 133 27 dialogue dialogue NOUN bracis-19020 133 28 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 134 1 a a DET bracis-19020 134 2 reply reply NOUN bracis-19020 134 3 is be AUX bracis-19020 134 4 a a DET bracis-19020 134 5 surrender surrender NOUN bracis-19020 134 6 when when SCONJ bracis-19020 134 7 it it PRON bracis-19020 134 8 is be AUX bracis-19020 134 9 not not PART bracis-19020 134 10 against against ADP bracis-19020 134 11 the the DET bracis-19020 134 12 previous previous ADJ bracis-19020 134 13 move move NOUN bracis-19020 134 14 ; ; PUNCT bracis-19020 134 15 otherwise otherwise ADV bracis-19020 134 16 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 134 17 it it PRON bracis-19020 134 18 is be AUX bracis-19020 134 19 an an DET bracis-19020 134 20 attack attack NOUN bracis-19020 134 21 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 135 1 in in ADP bracis-19020 135 2 summary summary NOUN bracis-19020 135 3 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 135 4 a a DET bracis-19020 135 5 reply reply NOUN bracis-19020 135 6 can can AUX bracis-19020 135 7 either either CCONJ bracis-19020 135 8 be be AUX bracis-19020 135 9 an an DET bracis-19020 135 10 attack attack NOUN bracis-19020 135 11 or or CCONJ bracis-19020 135 12 a a DET bracis-19020 135 13 surrender surrender NOUN bracis-19020 135 14 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 136 1 table table NOUN bracis-19020 136 2     SPACE bracis-19020 136 3 1 1 NUM bracis-19020 136 4 presents present VERB bracis-19020 136 5 the the DET bracis-19020 136 6 persuasion persuasion NOUN bracis-19020 136 7 communication communication NOUN bracis-19020 136 8 language language NOUN bracis-19020 136 9 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 136 10 which which PRON bracis-19020 136 11 takes take VERB bracis-19020 136 12 into into ADP bracis-19020 136 13 account account NOUN bracis-19020 136 14 the the DET bracis-19020 136 15 attacks attack NOUN bracis-19020 136 16 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 136 17 the the DET bracis-19020 136 18 surrenders surrender NOUN bracis-19020 136 19 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 137 1 in in ADP bracis-19020 137 2 this this DET bracis-19020 137 3 table table NOUN bracis-19020 137 4 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 137 5 a a DET bracis-19020 137 6 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 137 7 b b NOUN bracis-19020 137 8 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 137 9 c c NOUN bracis-19020 137 10 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 137 11 d d NOUN bracis-19020 137 12 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 137 13 e e NOUN bracis-19020 137 14 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 137 15 \(c'\ \(c'\ NOUN bracis-19020 137 16 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 137 17 are be AUX bracis-19020 137 18 arguments argument NOUN bracis-19020 137 19 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 138 1 let let VERB bracis-19020 138 2 us we PRON bracis-19020 138 3 recall recall VERB bracis-19020 138 4 that that SCONJ bracis-19020 138 5 an an DET bracis-19020 138 6 attack attack NOUN bracis-19020 138 7 relation relation NOUN bracis-19020 138 8 between between ADP bracis-19020 138 9 two two NUM bracis-19020 138 10 arguments argument NOUN bracis-19020 138 11 denotes denote VERB bracis-19020 138 12 the the DET bracis-19020 138 13 fact fact NOUN bracis-19020 138 14 that that SCONJ bracis-19020 138 15 these these DET bracis-19020 138 16 arguments argument NOUN bracis-19020 138 17 can can AUX bracis-19020 138 18 not not PART bracis-19020 138 19 be be AUX bracis-19020 138 20 accepted accept VERB bracis-19020 138 21 simultaneously simultaneously ADV bracis-19020 138 22 since since SCONJ bracis-19020 138 23 they they PRON bracis-19020 138 24 contradict contradict VERB bracis-19020 138 25 each each DET bracis-19020 138 26 other other ADJ bracis-19020 138 27 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 139 1 following follow VERB bracis-19020 139 2 this this DET bracis-19020 139 3 idea idea NOUN bracis-19020 139 4 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 139 5 we we PRON bracis-19020 139 6 can can AUX bracis-19020 139 7 say say VERB bracis-19020 139 8 that that SCONJ bracis-19020 139 9 rejecting reject VERB bracis-19020 139 10 a a DET bracis-19020 139 11 request request NOUN bracis-19020 139 12 is be AUX bracis-19020 139 13 an an DET bracis-19020 139 14 attack attack NOUN bracis-19020 139 15 because because SCONJ bracis-19020 139 16 it it PRON bracis-19020 139 17 is be AUX bracis-19020 139 18 a a DET bracis-19020 139 19 contradiction contradiction NOUN bracis-19020 139 20 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 140 1 we we PRON bracis-19020 140 2 can can AUX bracis-19020 140 3 also also ADV bracis-19020 140 4 say say VERB bracis-19020 140 5 that that SCONJ bracis-19020 140 6 a a DET bracis-19020 140 7 rhetorical rhetorical ADJ bracis-19020 140 8 argument argument NOUN bracis-19020 140 9 attacks attack VERB bracis-19020 140 10 a a DET bracis-19020 140 11 rejection rejection NOUN bracis-19020 140 12 because because SCONJ bracis-19020 140 13 it it PRON bracis-19020 140 14 defends defend VERB bracis-19020 140 15 a a DET bracis-19020 140 16 different different ADJ bracis-19020 140 17 position position NOUN bracis-19020 140 18 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 141 1 thus thus ADV bracis-19020 141 2 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 141 3 we we PRON bracis-19020 141 4 will will AUX bracis-19020 141 5 consider consider VERB bracis-19020 141 6 an an DET bracis-19020 141 7 attack attack NOUN bracis-19020 141 8 those those PRON bracis-19020 141 9 defined define VERB bracis-19020 141 10 in in ADP bracis-19020 141 11 previous previous ADJ bracis-19020 141 12 section section NOUN bracis-19020 141 13 – – PUNCT bracis-19020 141 14 which which PRON bracis-19020 141 15 are be AUX bracis-19020 141 16 more more ADV bracis-19020 141 17 related related ADJ bracis-19020 141 18 to to ADP bracis-19020 141 19 logical logical ADJ bracis-19020 141 20 inconsistency inconsistency NOUN bracis-19020 141 21 – – PUNCT bracis-19020 141 22 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 141 23 also also ADV bracis-19020 141 24 those those PRON bracis-19020 141 25 that that PRON bracis-19020 141 26 support support VERB bracis-19020 141 27 a a DET bracis-19020 141 28 different different ADJ bracis-19020 141 29 position position NOUN bracis-19020 141 30 during during ADP bracis-19020 141 31 the the DET bracis-19020 141 32 dialogue dialogue NOUN bracis-19020 141 33 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 142 1 it it PRON bracis-19020 142 2 is be AUX bracis-19020 142 3 reasonable reasonable ADJ bracis-19020 142 4 to to PART bracis-19020 142 5 think think VERB bracis-19020 142 6 that that SCONJ bracis-19020 142 7 all all DET bracis-19020 142 8 the the DET bracis-19020 142 9 illocutions illocution NOUN bracis-19020 142 10 used use VERB bracis-19020 142 11 by by ADP bracis-19020 142 12 the the DET bracis-19020 142 13 proponent proponent NOUN bracis-19020 142 14 p p NOUN bracis-19020 142 15 aim aim NOUN bracis-19020 142 16 to to PART bracis-19020 142 17 support support VERB bracis-19020 142 18 his his PRON bracis-19020 142 19 position position NOUN bracis-19020 142 20 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 142 21 which which PRON bracis-19020 142 22 is be AUX bracis-19020 142 23 contrary contrary ADJ bracis-19020 142 24 to to ADP bracis-19020 142 25 the the DET bracis-19020 142 26 position position NOUN bracis-19020 142 27 of of ADP bracis-19020 142 28 the the DET bracis-19020 142 29 opponent opponent NOUN bracis-19020 142 30 o. o. INTJ bracis-19020 142 31 in in ADP bracis-19020 142 32 the the DET bracis-19020 142 33 attack attack NOUN bracis-19020 142 34 column column NOUN bracis-19020 142 35 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 142 36 besides besides SCONJ bracis-19020 142 37 the the DET bracis-19020 142 38 possible possible ADJ bracis-19020 142 39 attacks attack NOUN bracis-19020 142 40 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 142 41 the the DET bracis-19020 142 42 conditions condition NOUN bracis-19020 142 43 that that PRON bracis-19020 142 44 relate relate VERB bracis-19020 142 45 the the DET bracis-19020 142 46 attacked attack VERB bracis-19020 142 47 with with ADP bracis-19020 142 48 its its PRON bracis-19020 142 49 attacker attacker NOUN bracis-19020 142 50 are be AUX bracis-19020 142 51 stated state VERB bracis-19020 142 52 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 143 1 in in ADP bracis-19020 143 2 order order NOUN bracis-19020 143 3 to to PART bracis-19020 143 4 standardize standardize VERB bracis-19020 143 5 the the DET bracis-19020 143 6 content content NOUN bracis-19020 143 7 of of ADP bracis-19020 143 8 speech speech NOUN bracis-19020 143 9 acts act NOUN bracis-19020 143 10 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 143 11 all all PRON bracis-19020 143 12 of of ADP bracis-19020 143 13 them they PRON bracis-19020 143 14 are be AUX bracis-19020 143 15 arguments argument NOUN bracis-19020 143 16 ; ; PUNCT bracis-19020 143 17 whether whether SCONJ bracis-19020 143 18 they they PRON bracis-19020 143 19 are be AUX bracis-19020 143 20 explanatory explanatory ADJ bracis-19020 143 21 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 143 22 rhetorical rhetorical ADJ bracis-19020 143 23 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 143 24 or or CCONJ bracis-19020 143 25 the the DET bracis-19020 143 26 basic basic ADJ bracis-19020 143 27 ones one NOUN bracis-19020 143 28 according accord VERB bracis-19020 143 29 to to ADP bracis-19020 143 30 definition definition NOUN bracis-19020 143 31 4 4 NUM bracis-19020 143 32 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 144 1 the the DET bracis-19020 144 2 idea idea NOUN bracis-19020 144 3 is be AUX bracis-19020 144 4 that that SCONJ bracis-19020 144 5 the the DET bracis-19020 144 6 proponent proponent ADJ bracis-19020 144 7 agent agent NOUN bracis-19020 144 8 uses use VERB bracis-19020 144 9 rhetorical rhetorical ADJ bracis-19020 144 10 arguments argument NOUN bracis-19020 144 11 to to PART bracis-19020 144 12 try try VERB bracis-19020 144 13 to to PART bracis-19020 144 14 convince convince VERB bracis-19020 144 15 his his PRON bracis-19020 144 16 opponent opponent NOUN bracis-19020 144 17 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 145 1 thus thus ADV bracis-19020 145 2 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 145 3 in in ADP bracis-19020 145 4 this this DET bracis-19020 145 5 first first ADJ bracis-19020 145 6 version version NOUN bracis-19020 145 7 of of ADP bracis-19020 145 8 the the DET bracis-19020 145 9 protocol protocol NOUN bracis-19020 145 10 only only ADV bracis-19020 145 11 the the DET bracis-19020 145 12 proponent proponent NOUN bracis-19020 145 13 can can AUX bracis-19020 145 14 use use VERB bracis-19020 145 15 rhetorical rhetorical ADJ bracis-19020 145 16 arguments argument NOUN bracis-19020 145 17 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 145 18 that that PRON bracis-19020 145 19 is be AUX bracis-19020 145 20 threats threat NOUN bracis-19020 145 21 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 145 22 rewards reward NOUN bracis-19020 145 23 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 145 24 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 145 25 appeals appeal NOUN bracis-19020 145 26 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 146 1 counter counter NOUN bracis-19020 146 2 - - NOUN bracis-19020 146 3 threats threat NOUN bracis-19020 146 4 act act VERB bracis-19020 146 5 as as ADP bracis-19020 146 6 attacks attack NOUN bracis-19020 146 7 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 146 8 in in ADP bracis-19020 146 9 this this DET bracis-19020 146 10 sense sense NOUN bracis-19020 146 11 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 146 12 these these PRON bracis-19020 146 13 can can AUX bracis-19020 146 14 be be AUX bracis-19020 146 15 used use VERB bracis-19020 146 16 by by ADP bracis-19020 146 17 the the DET bracis-19020 146 18 opponent opponent NOUN bracis-19020 146 19 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 147 1 after after ADP bracis-19020 147 2 a a DET bracis-19020 147 3 rhetorical rhetorical ADJ bracis-19020 147 4 argument argument NOUN bracis-19020 147 5 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 147 6 the the DET bracis-19020 147 7 opponent opponent NOUN bracis-19020 147 8 can can AUX bracis-19020 147 9 accept accept VERB bracis-19020 147 10 the the DET bracis-19020 147 11 proposal proposal NOUN bracis-19020 147 12 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 147 13 send send VERB bracis-19020 147 14 an an DET bracis-19020 147 15 attack attack NOUN bracis-19020 147 16 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 147 17 or or CCONJ bracis-19020 147 18 withdraw withdraw VERB bracis-19020 147 19 from from ADP bracis-19020 147 20 the the DET bracis-19020 147 21 dialogue dialogue NOUN bracis-19020 147 22 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 148 1 the the DET bracis-19020 148 2 last last ADJ bracis-19020 148 3 case case NOUN bracis-19020 148 4 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 148 5 may may AUX bracis-19020 148 6 happen happen VERB bracis-19020 148 7 when when SCONJ bracis-19020 148 8 he he PRON bracis-19020 148 9 has have VERB bracis-19020 148 10 no no DET bracis-19020 148 11 attack attack NOUN bracis-19020 148 12 to to PART bracis-19020 148 13 send send VERB bracis-19020 148 14 but but CCONJ bracis-19020 148 15 does do AUX bracis-19020 148 16 not not PART bracis-19020 148 17 want want VERB bracis-19020 148 18 to to PART bracis-19020 148 19 accept accept VERB bracis-19020 148 20 the the DET bracis-19020 148 21 proposal proposal NOUN bracis-19020 148 22 or or CCONJ bracis-19020 148 23 when when SCONJ bracis-19020 148 24 he he PRON bracis-19020 148 25 has have VERB bracis-19020 148 26 an an DET bracis-19020 148 27 explanation explanation NOUN bracis-19020 148 28 for for ADP bracis-19020 148 29 a a DET bracis-19020 148 30 questioning questioning NOUN bracis-19020 148 31 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 149 1 note note VERB bracis-19020 149 2 that that SCONJ bracis-19020 149 3 attacks attack NOUN bracis-19020 149 4 can can AUX bracis-19020 149 5 also also ADV bracis-19020 149 6 be be AUX bracis-19020 149 7 attacked attack VERB bracis-19020 149 8 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 149 9 can can AUX bracis-19020 149 10 be be AUX bracis-19020 149 11 questioned question VERB bracis-19020 149 12 in in ADP bracis-19020 149 13 an an DET bracis-19020 149 14 element element NOUN bracis-19020 149 15 of of ADP bracis-19020 149 16 their their PRON bracis-19020 149 17 support support NOUN bracis-19020 149 18 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 150 1 only only ADV bracis-19020 150 2 counter counter NOUN bracis-19020 150 3 - - NOUN bracis-19020 150 4 threats threat NOUN bracis-19020 150 5 can can AUX bracis-19020 150 6 not not PART bracis-19020 150 7 be be AUX bracis-19020 150 8 questioned question VERB bracis-19020 150 9 because because SCONJ bracis-19020 150 10 it it PRON bracis-19020 150 11 is be AUX bracis-19020 150 12 based base VERB bracis-19020 150 13 on on ADP bracis-19020 150 14 goals goal NOUN bracis-19020 150 15 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 150 16 not not PART bracis-19020 150 17 in in ADP bracis-19020 150 18 beliefs belief NOUN bracis-19020 150 19 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 151 1 table table NOUN bracis-19020 151 2 1 1 NUM bracis-19020 151 3 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 151 4 speech speech NOUN bracis-19020 151 5 acts act NOUN bracis-19020 151 6 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 151 7 possible possible ADJ bracis-19020 151 8 replies reply NOUN bracis-19020 151 9 in in ADP bracis-19020 151 10 full full ADJ bracis-19020 151 11 size size NOUN bracis-19020 151 12 table table NOUN bracis-19020 151 13 the the DET bracis-19020 151 14 third third ADJ bracis-19020 151 15 component component NOUN bracis-19020 151 16 of of ADP bracis-19020 151 17 a a DET bracis-19020 151 18 dialogue dialogue NOUN bracis-19020 151 19 game game NOUN bracis-19020 151 20 is be AUX bracis-19020 151 21 the the DET bracis-19020 151 22 protocol protocol NOUN bracis-19020 151 23 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 151 24 which which PRON bracis-19020 151 25 specifies specify VERB bracis-19020 151 26 the the DET bracis-19020 151 27 allowed allow VERB bracis-19020 151 28 moves move NOUN bracis-19020 151 29 at at ADP bracis-19020 151 30 each each DET bracis-19020 151 31 point point NOUN bracis-19020 151 32 in in ADP bracis-19020 151 33 a a DET bracis-19020 151 34 dialogue dialogue NOUN bracis-19020 151 35 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 152 1 thus thus ADV bracis-19020 152 2 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 152 3 let let VERB bracis-19020 152 4 us we PRON bracis-19020 152 5 define define VERB bracis-19020 152 6 first first ADV bracis-19020 152 7 of of ADP bracis-19020 152 8 all all PRON bracis-19020 152 9 what what PRON bracis-19020 152 10 a a DET bracis-19020 152 11 move move NOUN bracis-19020 152 12 is be AUX bracis-19020 152 13 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 153 1 definition definition NOUN bracis-19020 153 2 10 10 NUM bracis-19020 153 3 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 153 4 move move NOUN bracis-19020 153 5 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 153 6 a a DET bracis-19020 153 7 move move NOUN bracis-19020 153 8 is be AUX bracis-19020 153 9 a a DET bracis-19020 153 10 tuple tuple NOUN bracis-19020 153 11 \(m= \(m= NOUN bracis-19020 154 1 \langle \langle PROPN bracis-19020 154 2 i i PROPN bracis-19020 154 3 d d PROPN bracis-19020 154 4 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 154 5 sd sd PROPN bracis-19020 154 6 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 154 7 tg tg PRON bracis-19020 154 8 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 154 9 sp\rangle sp\rangle ADJ bracis-19020 154 10 \ \ NOUN bracis-19020 154 11 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 154 12 where where SCONJ bracis-19020 154 13 : : PUNCT bracis-19020 154 14 \(id \(id PROPN bracis-19020 154 15 \in \in PROPN bracis-19020 154 16 \mathbb \mathbb PROPN bracis-19020 154 17 { { PUNCT bracis-19020 154 18 n}\ n}\ NOUN bracis-19020 154 19 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 154 20 is be AUX bracis-19020 154 21 the the DET bracis-19020 154 22 identifier identifier NOUN bracis-19020 154 23 of of ADP bracis-19020 154 24 the the DET bracis-19020 154 25 move move NOUN bracis-19020 154 26 ; ; PUNCT bracis-19020 154 27 \(sd \(sd ADJ bracis-19020 154 28 \in \in ADJ bracis-19020 154 29 \{p \{p NOUN bracis-19020 154 30 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 154 31 o\}\ o\}\ NOUN bracis-19020 154 32 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 154 33 is be AUX bracis-19020 154 34 the the DET bracis-19020 154 35 sender sender NOUN bracis-19020 154 36 of of ADP bracis-19020 154 37 the the DET bracis-19020 154 38 message message NOUN bracis-19020 154 39 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 154 40 i.e. i.e. X bracis-19020 154 41 the the DET bracis-19020 154 42 agent agent NOUN bracis-19020 154 43 that that PRON bracis-19020 154 44 makes make VERB bracis-19020 154 45 the the DET bracis-19020 154 46 move move NOUN bracis-19020 154 47 ; ; PUNCT bracis-19020 154 48 \(tg \(tg VERB bracis-19020 154 49 \in \in PROPN bracis-19020 154 50 \mathbb \mathbb PROPN bracis-19020 154 51 { { PUNCT bracis-19020 154 52 n}\ n}\ NOUN bracis-19020 154 53 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 154 54 is be AUX bracis-19020 154 55 target target NOUN bracis-19020 154 56 of of ADP bracis-19020 154 57 the the DET bracis-19020 154 58 move move NOUN bracis-19020 154 59 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 154 60 i.e. i.e. X bracis-19020 154 61 a a DET bracis-19020 154 62 previous previous ADJ bracis-19020 154 63 move move NOUN bracis-19020 154 64 to to PART bracis-19020 154 65 which which PRON bracis-19020 154 66 it it PRON bracis-19020 154 67 is be AUX bracis-19020 154 68 directed direct VERB bracis-19020 154 69 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 155 1 the the DET bracis-19020 155 2 target target NOUN bracis-19020 155 3 of of ADP bracis-19020 155 4 a a DET bracis-19020 155 5 move move NOUN bracis-19020 155 6 is be AUX bracis-19020 155 7 the the DET bracis-19020 155 8 identifier identifier NOUN bracis-19020 155 9 of of ADP bracis-19020 155 10 some some DET bracis-19020 155 11 earlier early ADJ bracis-19020 155 12 move move NOUN bracis-19020 155 13 in in ADP bracis-19020 155 14 the the DET bracis-19020 155 15 dialogue dialogue NOUN bracis-19020 155 16 ; ; PUNCT bracis-19020 155 17 is be AUX bracis-19020 155 18 an an DET bracis-19020 155 19 speech speech NOUN bracis-19020 155 20 act act NOUN bracis-19020 155 21 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 156 1 let let AUX bracis-19020 156 2 be be AUX bracis-19020 156 3 a a DET bracis-19020 156 4 set set NOUN bracis-19020 156 5 of of ADP bracis-19020 156 6 moves move NOUN bracis-19020 156 7 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 157 1 as as ADP bracis-19020 157 2 for for ADP bracis-19020 157 3 notation notation NOUN bracis-19020 157 4 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 157 5 we we PRON bracis-19020 157 6 use use VERB bracis-19020 157 7 id(m id(m PUNCT bracis-19020 157 8 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 157 9 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 157 10 sd(m sd(m NOUN bracis-19020 157 11 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 157 12 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 157 13 tg(m tg(m NUM bracis-19020 157 14 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 157 15 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 157 16 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 157 17 sp(m sp(m NOUN bracis-19020 157 18 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 157 19 to to PART bracis-19020 157 20 refer refer VERB bracis-19020 157 21 to to ADP bracis-19020 157 22 each each PRON bracis-19020 157 23 of of ADP bracis-19020 157 24 the the DET bracis-19020 157 25 components component NOUN bracis-19020 157 26 of of ADP bracis-19020 157 27 a a DET bracis-19020 157 28 given give VERB bracis-19020 157 29 move move NOUN bracis-19020 157 30 m. m. NOUN bracis-19020 157 31 for for ADP bracis-19020 157 32 the the DET bracis-19020 157 33 sake sake NOUN bracis-19020 157 34 of of ADP bracis-19020 157 35 simplicity simplicity NOUN bracis-19020 157 36 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 157 37 when when SCONJ bracis-19020 157 38 we we PRON bracis-19020 157 39 want want VERB bracis-19020 157 40 to to PART bracis-19020 157 41 refer refer VERB bracis-19020 157 42 to to ADP bracis-19020 157 43 the the DET bracis-19020 157 44 i i PROPN bracis-19020 157 45 - - PUNCT bracis-19020 157 46 th th X bracis-19020 157 47 move move NOUN bracis-19020 157 48 in in ADP bracis-19020 157 49 a a DET bracis-19020 157 50 sequence sequence NOUN bracis-19020 157 51 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 157 52 we we PRON bracis-19020 157 53 use use VERB bracis-19020 157 54 \(m_i\ \(m_i\ NOUN bracis-19020 157 55 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 157 56 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 158 1 besides besides ADV bracis-19020 158 2 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 158 3 we we PRON bracis-19020 158 4 use use VERB bracis-19020 158 5 \(\mathtt \(\mathtt NOUN bracis-19020 158 6 { { PUNCT bracis-19020 158 7 argum}(sp(m))\ argum}(sp(m))\ PROPN bracis-19020 158 8 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 158 9 to to PART bracis-19020 158 10 refer refer VERB bracis-19020 158 11 to to ADP bracis-19020 158 12 the the DET bracis-19020 158 13 argument argument NOUN bracis-19020 158 14 associated associate VERB bracis-19020 158 15 to to ADP bracis-19020 158 16 a a DET bracis-19020 158 17 given give VERB bracis-19020 158 18 speech speech NOUN bracis-19020 158 19 act act NOUN bracis-19020 158 20 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 159 1 a a DET bracis-19020 159 2 dialogue dialogue NOUN bracis-19020 159 3 can can AUX bracis-19020 159 4 be be AUX bracis-19020 159 5 seen see VERB bracis-19020 159 6 as as ADP bracis-19020 159 7 a a DET bracis-19020 159 8 set set NOUN bracis-19020 159 9 of of ADP bracis-19020 159 10 moves move NOUN bracis-19020 159 11 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 159 12 which which PRON bracis-19020 159 13 fulfil fulfil VERB bracis-19020 159 14 some some DET bracis-19020 159 15 conditions condition NOUN bracis-19020 159 16 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 160 1 let let VERB bracis-19020 160 2 us we PRON bracis-19020 160 3 now now ADV bracis-19020 160 4 present present VERB bracis-19020 160 5 the the DET bracis-19020 160 6 formal formal ADJ bracis-19020 160 7 definition definition NOUN bracis-19020 160 8 of of ADP bracis-19020 160 9 dialogue dialogue NOUN bracis-19020 160 10 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 161 1 definition definition NOUN bracis-19020 161 2 11 11 NUM bracis-19020 161 3 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 161 4 dialogue dialogue NOUN bracis-19020 161 5 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 161 6 a a DET bracis-19020 161 7 dialogue dialogue NOUN bracis-19020 161 8 d d NOUN bracis-19020 161 9 between between ADP bracis-19020 161 10 two two NUM bracis-19020 161 11 agents agent NOUN bracis-19020 161 12 p p NOUN bracis-19020 161 13 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 161 14 o o PROPN bracis-19020 161 15 is be AUX bracis-19020 161 16 a a DET bracis-19020 161 17 finite finite ADJ bracis-19020 161 18 sequence sequence NOUN bracis-19020 161 19 \(\langle \(\langle PROPN bracis-19020 161 20 m_1 m_1 PROPN bracis-19020 161 21 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 161 22 ... ... PUNCT bracis-19020 161 23 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 161 24 m_n m_n PUNCT bracis-19020 162 1 \rangle \rangle NOUN bracis-19020 162 2 \ \ NOUN bracis-19020 162 3 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 162 4 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 162 5 such such ADJ bracis-19020 162 6 that that SCONJ bracis-19020 162 7 : : PUNCT bracis-19020 162 8 \(m_1= \(m_1= PROPN bracis-19020 162 9 \langle \langle PROPN bracis-19020 162 10 1 1 NUM bracis-19020 162 11 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 162 12 p p X bracis-19020 162 13 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 162 14 - - PUNCT bracis-19020 162 15 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 162 16 request(a request(a NOUN bracis-19020 162 17 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 162 18 \rangle \rangle PROPN bracis-19020 162 19 \ \ NOUN bracis-19020 162 20 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 162 21 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 163 1 it it PRON bracis-19020 163 2 means mean VERB bracis-19020 163 3 that that SCONJ bracis-19020 163 4 the the DET bracis-19020 163 5 first first ADJ bracis-19020 163 6 utterance utterance NOUN bracis-19020 163 7 is be AUX bracis-19020 163 8 sent send VERB bracis-19020 163 9 by by ADP bracis-19020 163 10 the the DET bracis-19020 163 11 proponent proponent ADJ bracis-19020 163 12 agent agent NOUN bracis-19020 163 13 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 163 14 has have VERB bracis-19020 163 15 to to PART bracis-19020 163 16 be be AUX bracis-19020 163 17 a a DET bracis-19020 163 18 request request NOUN bracis-19020 163 19 ; ; PUNCT bracis-19020 163 20 the the DET bracis-19020 163 21 content content NOUN bracis-19020 163 22 of of ADP bracis-19020 163 23 \(m_k\ \(m_k\ NOUN bracis-19020 163 24 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 163 25 is be AUX bracis-19020 163 26 request(a request(a NOUN bracis-19020 163 27 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 163 28 iff iff NOUN bracis-19020 163 29 \(k=1\ \(k=1\ NOUN bracis-19020 163 30 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 163 31 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 164 1 it it PRON bracis-19020 164 2 means mean VERB bracis-19020 164 3 that that SCONJ bracis-19020 164 4 a a DET bracis-19020 164 5 request request NOUN bracis-19020 164 6 can can AUX bracis-19020 164 7 only only ADV bracis-19020 164 8 be be AUX bracis-19020 164 9 sent send VERB bracis-19020 164 10 in in ADP bracis-19020 164 11 the the DET bracis-19020 164 12 first first ADJ bracis-19020 164 13 move move NOUN bracis-19020 164 14 ; ; PUNCT bracis-19020 164 15 \(tg(m_1)=0\ \(tg(m_1)=0\ NOUN bracis-19020 164 16 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 164 17 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 165 1 it it PRON bracis-19020 165 2 means mean VERB bracis-19020 165 3 that that SCONJ bracis-19020 165 4 the the DET bracis-19020 165 5 first first ADJ bracis-19020 165 6 utterance utterance NOUN bracis-19020 165 7 has have VERB bracis-19020 165 8 no no DET bracis-19020 165 9 target target NOUN bracis-19020 165 10 ; ; PUNCT bracis-19020 165 11 \(\forall \(\forall ADV bracis-19020 165 12 k k X bracis-19020 165 13 > > X bracis-19020 165 14 1\ 1\ NUM bracis-19020 165 15 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 165 16 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 165 17 it it PRON bracis-19020 165 18 holds hold VERB bracis-19020 165 19 that that PRON bracis-19020 165 20 \(tg(m_k)=j\ \(tg(m_k)=j\ NUM bracis-19020 165 21 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 165 22 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 165 23 for for ADP bracis-19020 165 24 \(j \(j PROPN bracis-19020 165 25 = = PROPN bracis-19020 165 26 k-1\ k-1\ PROPN bracis-19020 165 27 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 165 28 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 166 1 it it PRON bracis-19020 166 2 means mean VERB bracis-19020 166 3 that that SCONJ bracis-19020 166 4 the the DET bracis-19020 166 5 target target NOUN bracis-19020 166 6 of of ADP bracis-19020 166 7 a a DET bracis-19020 166 8 move move NOUN bracis-19020 166 9 is be AUX bracis-19020 166 10 always always ADV bracis-19020 166 11 the the DET bracis-19020 166 12 previous previous ADJ bracis-19020 166 13 move move NOUN bracis-19020 166 14 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 167 1 let let AUX bracis-19020 167 2 stand stand VERB bracis-19020 167 3 for for ADP bracis-19020 167 4 the the DET bracis-19020 167 5 set set NOUN bracis-19020 167 6 of of ADP bracis-19020 167 7 all all DET bracis-19020 167 8 dialogues dialogue NOUN bracis-19020 167 9 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 168 1 in in ADP bracis-19020 168 2 the the DET bracis-19020 168 3 illustrative illustrative ADJ bracis-19020 168 4 example example NOUN bracis-19020 168 5 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 168 6 we we PRON bracis-19020 168 7 can can AUX bracis-19020 168 8 see see VERB bracis-19020 168 9 that that SCONJ bracis-19020 168 10 the the DET bracis-19020 168 11 proponent proponent NOUN bracis-19020 168 12 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 168 13 the the DET bracis-19020 168 14 opponent opponent NOUN bracis-19020 168 15 agents agent NOUN bracis-19020 168 16 take take VERB bracis-19020 168 17 the the DET bracis-19020 168 18 turn turn NOUN bracis-19020 168 19 to to PART bracis-19020 168 20 speak speak VERB bracis-19020 168 21 one one NUM bracis-19020 168 22 after after ADP bracis-19020 168 23 another another PRON bracis-19020 168 24 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 169 1 these these DET bracis-19020 169 2 moves move NOUN bracis-19020 169 3 are be AUX bracis-19020 169 4 controlled control VERB bracis-19020 169 5 by by ADP bracis-19020 169 6 a a DET bracis-19020 169 7 function function NOUN bracis-19020 169 8 that that PRON bracis-19020 169 9 determines determine VERB bracis-19020 169 10 which which PRON bracis-19020 169 11 of of ADP bracis-19020 169 12 the the DET bracis-19020 169 13 agents agent NOUN bracis-19020 169 14 will will AUX bracis-19020 169 15 make make VERB bracis-19020 169 16 the the DET bracis-19020 169 17 next next ADJ bracis-19020 169 18 move move NOUN bracis-19020 169 19 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 170 1 take take VERB bracis-19020 170 2 into into ADP bracis-19020 170 3 account account NOUN bracis-19020 170 4 that that SCONJ bracis-19020 170 5 such such ADJ bracis-19020 170 6 move move NOUN bracis-19020 170 7 must must AUX bracis-19020 170 8 agree agree VERB bracis-19020 170 9 with with ADP bracis-19020 170 10 the the DET bracis-19020 170 11 possible possible ADJ bracis-19020 170 12 replies reply NOUN bracis-19020 170 13 defined define VERB bracis-19020 170 14 in in ADP bracis-19020 170 15 table table NOUN bracis-19020 170 16     SPACE bracis-19020 170 17 1 1 NUM bracis-19020 170 18 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 171 1 thus thus ADV bracis-19020 171 2 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 171 3 a a DET bracis-19020 171 4 turn turn NOUN bracis-19020 171 5 - - PUNCT bracis-19020 171 6 taking take VERB bracis-19020 171 7 function function NOUN bracis-19020 171 8 is be AUX bracis-19020 171 9 a a DET bracis-19020 171 10 mapping mapping NOUN bracis-19020 171 11 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 171 12 such such ADJ bracis-19020 171 13 that that SCONJ bracis-19020 171 14 given give VERB bracis-19020 171 15 a a DET bracis-19020 171 16 dialogue dialogue NOUN bracis-19020 171 17 \(d=\langle \(d=\langle NOUN bracis-19020 171 18 m_1 m_1 PROPN bracis-19020 171 19 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 171 20 ... ... PUNCT bracis-19020 171 21 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 171 22 m_i m_i PUNCT bracis-19020 171 23 \rangle \rangle NOUN bracis-19020 171 24 \ \ PROPN bracis-19020 171 25 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 171 26 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 171 27 it it PRON bracis-19020 171 28 holds hold VERB bracis-19020 171 29 that that SCONJ bracis-19020 171 30 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 171 31 i i NOUN bracis-19020 171 32 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 171 33 \(t(\emptyset \(t(\emptyset VERB bracis-19020 171 34 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 172 1 = = PUNCT bracis-19020 173 1 p\ p\ NOUN bracis-19020 173 2 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 173 3 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 173 4 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 173 5 ii ii NOUN bracis-19020 173 6 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 173 7 \(t(d)=p\ \(t(d)=p\ NOUN bracis-19020 173 8 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 173 9 if if SCONJ bracis-19020 173 10 i i PRON bracis-19020 173 11 is be AUX bracis-19020 173 12 even even ADV bracis-19020 173 13 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 173 14 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 173 15 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 173 16 iii iii X bracis-19020 173 17 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 173 18 \(t(d)=o\ \(t(d)=o\ NOUN bracis-19020 173 19 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 173 20 if if SCONJ bracis-19020 173 21 i i PRON bracis-19020 173 22 is be AUX bracis-19020 173 23 odd odd ADJ bracis-19020 173 24 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 174 1 we we PRON bracis-19020 174 2 can can AUX bracis-19020 174 3 notice notice VERB bracis-19020 174 4 that that SCONJ bracis-19020 174 5 our our PRON bracis-19020 174 6 definition definition NOUN bracis-19020 174 7 of of ADP bracis-19020 174 8 turn turn NOUN bracis-19020 174 9 - - PUNCT bracis-19020 174 10 taking take VERB bracis-19020 174 11 forces force NOUN bracis-19020 174 12 a a DET bracis-19020 174 13 strict strict ADJ bracis-19020 174 14 interleaving interleaving NOUN bracis-19020 174 15 between between ADP bracis-19020 174 16 agents agent NOUN bracis-19020 174 17 p p NOUN bracis-19020 174 18 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 174 19 o. o. PROPN bracis-19020 174 20 next next ADV bracis-19020 174 21 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 174 22 we we PRON bracis-19020 174 23 define define VERB bracis-19020 174 24 our our PRON bracis-19020 174 25 protocol protocol NOUN bracis-19020 174 26 in in ADP bracis-19020 174 27 terms term NOUN bracis-19020 174 28 of of ADP bracis-19020 174 29 legal legal ADJ bracis-19020 174 30 moves move NOUN bracis-19020 174 31 the the DET bracis-19020 174 32 agents agent NOUN bracis-19020 174 33 can can AUX bracis-19020 174 34 perform perform VERB bracis-19020 174 35 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 175 1 in in ADP bracis-19020 175 2 table table NOUN bracis-19020 175 3     SPACE bracis-19020 175 4 1 1 NUM bracis-19020 175 5 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 175 6 we we PRON bracis-19020 175 7 can can AUX bracis-19020 175 8 notice notice VERB bracis-19020 175 9 that that SCONJ bracis-19020 175 10 the the DET bracis-19020 175 11 answer answer NOUN bracis-19020 175 12 for for ADP bracis-19020 175 13 a a DET bracis-19020 175 14 speech speech NOUN bracis-19020 175 15 act act NOUN bracis-19020 175 16 why(a why(a X bracis-19020 175 17 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 175 18 is be AUX bracis-19020 175 19 an an DET bracis-19020 175 20 explanation explanation NOUN bracis-19020 175 21 for for ADP bracis-19020 175 22 it it PRON bracis-19020 175 23 ; ; PUNCT bracis-19020 175 24 however however ADV bracis-19020 175 25 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 175 26 there there PRON bracis-19020 175 27 is be VERB bracis-19020 175 28 a a DET bracis-19020 175 29 need need NOUN bracis-19020 175 30 for for ADP bracis-19020 175 31 a a DET bracis-19020 175 32 stop stop NOUN bracis-19020 175 33 condition condition NOUN bracis-19020 175 34 \(\mathtt \(\mathtt NOUN bracis-19020 175 35 { { PUNCT bracis-19020 175 36 cond}\ cond}\ NOUN bracis-19020 175 37 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 175 38 in in ADP bracis-19020 175 39 order order NOUN bracis-19020 175 40 to to PART bracis-19020 175 41 avoid avoid VERB bracis-19020 175 42 infinite infinite ADJ bracis-19020 175 43 questioning questioning NOUN bracis-19020 175 44 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 176 1 this this DET bracis-19020 176 2 condition condition NOUN bracis-19020 176 3 can can AUX bracis-19020 176 4 be be AUX bracis-19020 176 5 a a DET bracis-19020 176 6 maximum maximum ADJ bracis-19020 176 7 number number NOUN bracis-19020 176 8 of of ADP bracis-19020 176 9 rounds round NOUN bracis-19020 176 10 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 177 1 definition definition NOUN bracis-19020 177 2 12 12 NUM bracis-19020 177 3 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 177 4 legal legal ADJ bracis-19020 177 5 - - PUNCT bracis-19020 177 6 move move NOUN bracis-19020 177 7 function function NOUN bracis-19020 177 8 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 177 9 a a DET bracis-19020 177 10 legal legal ADJ bracis-19020 177 11 - - PUNCT bracis-19020 177 12 move move NOUN bracis-19020 177 13 function function NOUN bracis-19020 177 14 is be AUX bracis-19020 177 15 a a DET bracis-19020 177 16 mapping mapping NOUN bracis-19020 177 17 such such ADJ bracis-19020 177 18 that that SCONJ bracis-19020 177 19 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 177 20 given give VERB bracis-19020 177 21 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 177 22 for for ADP bracis-19020 177 23 all all PRON bracis-19020 177 24 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 177 25 the the DET bracis-19020 177 26 following follow VERB bracis-19020 177 27 rules rule NOUN bracis-19020 177 28 must must AUX bracis-19020 177 29 be be AUX bracis-19020 177 30 satisfied satisfied ADJ bracis-19020 177 31 : : PUNCT bracis-19020 177 32 \(r_1:\ \(r_1:\ NUM bracis-19020 177 33 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 177 34 ; ; PUNCT bracis-19020 177 35 \(r_2:\ \(r_2:\ PROPN bracis-19020 177 36 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 177 37 sp(m sp(m NOUN bracis-19020 177 38 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 177 39 is be AUX bracis-19020 177 40 a a DET bracis-19020 177 41 legal legal ADJ bracis-19020 177 42 speech speech NOUN bracis-19020 177 43 act act NOUN bracis-19020 177 44 after after ADP bracis-19020 177 45 d d PROPN bracis-19020 177 46 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 177 47 considering consider VERB bracis-19020 177 48 table table NOUN bracis-19020 177 49     SPACE bracis-19020 177 50 1 1 NUM bracis-19020 177 51 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 177 52 ; ; PUNCT bracis-19020 177 53 \(r_3:\ \(r_3:\ X bracis-19020 177 54 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 177 55 if if SCONJ bracis-19020 177 56 \(\exists \(\exist NOUN bracis-19020 177 57 m_i m_i PUNCT bracis-19020 177 58 | | ADV bracis-19020 177 59 tg(m_i)=m_k\ tg(m_i)=m_k\ NOUN bracis-19020 177 60 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 177 61 – – PUNCT bracis-19020 177 62 for for ADP bracis-19020 177 63 \(1 \(1 PROPN bracis-19020 177 64 < < X bracis-19020 177 65 i i PROPN bracis-19020 177 66 \le \le PROPN bracis-19020 177 67 n\ n\ NOUN bracis-19020 177 68 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 177 69 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 177 70 \(k \(k NOUN bracis-19020 177 71 < < NOUN bracis-19020 177 72 i\ i\ X bracis-19020 177 73 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 177 74 – – PUNCT bracis-19020 177 75 then then ADV bracis-19020 177 76 \(\not \(\not ADV bracis-19020 177 77 \exists \exist NOUN bracis-19020 177 78 m_j m_j PROPN bracis-19020 177 79 | | ADV bracis-19020 177 80 tg(m_j)=m_k\ tg(m_j)=m_k\ NUM bracis-19020 177 81 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 177 82 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 177 83 for for ADP bracis-19020 177 84 \(i \(i NOUN bracis-19020 177 85 \ne \ne PROPN bracis-19020 177 86 j\ j\ PROPN bracis-19020 177 87 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 177 88 ; ; PUNCT bracis-19020 177 89 \(r_4:\ \(r_4:\ NUM bracis-19020 177 90 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 177 91 if if SCONJ bracis-19020 177 92 \(sp(m)=threat(a)\ \(sp(m)=threat(a)\ X bracis-19020 177 93 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 177 94 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 177 95 \(sp(m)=reward(a)\ \(sp(m)=reward(a)\ NOUN bracis-19020 177 96 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 177 97 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 177 98 or or CCONJ bracis-19020 177 99 \(sp(m)=appeal(a)\ \(sp(m)=appeal(a)\ ADP bracis-19020 177 100 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 177 101 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 177 102 then then ADV bracis-19020 177 103 \(sd(m)=p\ \(sd(m)=p\ PROPN bracis-19020 177 104 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 177 105 ; ; PUNCT bracis-19020 177 106 \(r_5:\ \(r_5:\ NOUN bracis-19020 177 107 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 177 108 if if SCONJ bracis-19020 177 109 \(sp(m)=why(a)\ \(sp(m)=why(a)\ NOUN bracis-19020 177 110 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 177 111 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 177 112 \(\mathtt \(\mathtt NOUN bracis-19020 177 113 { { PUNCT bracis-19020 177 114 cond}==true\ cond}==true\ NOUN bracis-19020 177 115 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 177 116 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 177 117 then then ADV bracis-19020 177 118 the the DET bracis-19020 177 119 sender sender NOUN bracis-19020 177 120 agent agent NOUN bracis-19020 177 121 has have VERB bracis-19020 177 122 to to PART bracis-19020 177 123 change change VERB bracis-19020 177 124 his his PRON bracis-19020 177 125 move move NOUN bracis-19020 177 126 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 177 127 use use VERB bracis-19020 177 128 another another DET bracis-19020 177 129 speech speech NOUN bracis-19020 177 130 act act NOUN bracis-19020 177 131 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 178 1 rule rule NOUN bracis-19020 178 2 1 1 NUM bracis-19020 178 3 says say VERB bracis-19020 178 4 that that SCONJ bracis-19020 178 5 the the DET bracis-19020 178 6 sender sender NOUN bracis-19020 178 7 of of ADP bracis-19020 178 8 a a DET bracis-19020 178 9 move move NOUN bracis-19020 178 10 has have VERB bracis-19020 178 11 to to PART bracis-19020 178 12 obey obey VERB bracis-19020 178 13 the the DET bracis-19020 178 14 turn turn NOUN bracis-19020 178 15 - - PUNCT bracis-19020 178 16 taking take VERB bracis-19020 178 17 function function NOUN bracis-19020 178 18 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 179 1 rule rule NOUN bracis-19020 179 2 2 2 NUM bracis-19020 179 3 has have VERB bracis-19020 179 4 to to PART bracis-19020 179 5 do do VERB bracis-19020 179 6 with with ADP bracis-19020 179 7 the the DET bracis-19020 179 8 valid valid ADJ bracis-19020 179 9 answers answer NOUN bracis-19020 179 10 to to ADP bracis-19020 179 11 speech speech NOUN bracis-19020 179 12 acts act NOUN bracis-19020 179 13 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 180 1 rule rule NOUN bracis-19020 180 2 3 3 NUM bracis-19020 180 3 means mean VERB bracis-19020 180 4 that that SCONJ bracis-19020 180 5 there there PRON bracis-19020 180 6 is be VERB bracis-19020 180 7 no no DET bracis-19020 180 8 move move NOUN bracis-19020 180 9 with with ADP bracis-19020 180 10 the the DET bracis-19020 180 11 same same ADJ bracis-19020 180 12 target target NOUN bracis-19020 180 13 in in ADP bracis-19020 180 14 a a DET bracis-19020 180 15 dialogue dialogue NOUN bracis-19020 180 16 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 181 1 rule rule VERB bracis-19020 181 2 4 4 NUM bracis-19020 181 3 ensures ensure VERB bracis-19020 181 4 that that SCONJ bracis-19020 181 5 only only ADV bracis-19020 181 6 the the DET bracis-19020 181 7 proponent proponent NOUN bracis-19020 181 8 can can AUX bracis-19020 181 9 send send VERB bracis-19020 181 10 a a DET bracis-19020 181 11 rhetorical rhetorical ADJ bracis-19020 181 12 argument argument NOUN bracis-19020 181 13 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 182 1 finally finally ADV bracis-19020 182 2 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 182 3 rule rule VERB bracis-19020 182 4 5 5 NUM bracis-19020 182 5 concerns concern NOUN bracis-19020 182 6 with with ADP bracis-19020 182 7 avoiding avoid VERB bracis-19020 182 8 infinite infinite ADJ bracis-19020 182 9 questions question NOUN bracis-19020 182 10 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 183 1 besides besides SCONJ bracis-19020 183 2 the the DET bracis-19020 183 3 rules rule NOUN bracis-19020 183 4 related relate VERB bracis-19020 183 5 to to ADP bracis-19020 183 6 legal legal ADJ bracis-19020 183 7 moves move NOUN bracis-19020 183 8 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 183 9 it it PRON bracis-19020 183 10 is be AUX bracis-19020 183 11 important important ADJ bracis-19020 183 12 to to PART bracis-19020 183 13 define define VERB bracis-19020 183 14 some some DET bracis-19020 183 15 rules rule NOUN bracis-19020 183 16 about about ADP bracis-19020 183 17 the the DET bracis-19020 183 18 beginning beginning NOUN bracis-19020 183 19 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 183 20 the the DET bracis-19020 183 21 end end NOUN bracis-19020 183 22 of of ADP bracis-19020 183 23 the the DET bracis-19020 183 24 dialogue dialogue NOUN bracis-19020 183 25 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 184 1 \(r_6:\ \(r_6:\ X bracis-19020 184 2 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 184 3 if if SCONJ bracis-19020 184 4 \(id(m)=1\ \(id(m)=1\ NOUN bracis-19020 184 5 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 184 6 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 184 7 then then ADV bracis-19020 184 8 \(sd(m)=p\ \(sd(m)=p\ PROPN bracis-19020 184 9 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 184 10 ; ; PUNCT bracis-19020 184 11 \(r_7:\ \(r_7:\ X bracis-19020 184 12 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 184 13 if if SCONJ bracis-19020 184 14 \(id(m)=1\ \(id(m)=1\ NOUN bracis-19020 184 15 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 184 16 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 184 17 then then ADV bracis-19020 184 18 \(sp(m)=request(a)\ \(sp(m)=request(a)\ VERB bracis-19020 184 19 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 184 20 ; ; PUNCT bracis-19020 184 21 \(r_8:\ \(r_8:\ NOUN bracis-19020 184 22 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 184 23 if if SCONJ bracis-19020 184 24 \(sp(m \(sp(m NOUN bracis-19020 184 25 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 185 1 = = NOUN bracis-19020 185 2 accept(\varphi accept(\varphi NOUN bracis-19020 185 3 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 185 4 \ \ PROPN bracis-19020 185 5 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 185 6 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 185 7 then then ADV bracis-19020 185 8 d d PROPN bracis-19020 185 9 ends end VERB bracis-19020 185 10 with with ADP bracis-19020 185 11 an an DET bracis-19020 185 12 agreement agreement NOUN bracis-19020 185 13 ; ; PUNCT bracis-19020 185 14 \(r_9:\ \(r_9:\ NOUN bracis-19020 185 15 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 185 16 if if SCONJ bracis-19020 185 17 \(sp(m \(sp(m NOUN bracis-19020 185 18 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 186 1 = = VERB bracis-19020 186 2 concede(\varphi concede(\varphi ADJ bracis-19020 186 3 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 186 4 \ \ PROPN bracis-19020 186 5 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 186 6 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 186 7 then then ADV bracis-19020 186 8 d d PROPN bracis-19020 186 9 ends end VERB bracis-19020 186 10 with with ADP bracis-19020 186 11 an an DET bracis-19020 186 12 agreement agreement NOUN bracis-19020 186 13 \(r_{10}\ \(r_{10}\ NOUN bracis-19020 186 14 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 186 15 if if SCONJ bracis-19020 186 16 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 186 17 then then ADV bracis-19020 186 18 d d PROPN bracis-19020 186 19 ends end VERB bracis-19020 186 20 without without ADP bracis-19020 186 21 an an DET bracis-19020 186 22 agreement agreement NOUN bracis-19020 186 23 ; ; PUNCT bracis-19020 186 24 rule rule NOUN bracis-19020 186 25 6 6 NUM bracis-19020 186 26 says say VERB bracis-19020 186 27 that that SCONJ bracis-19020 186 28 the the DET bracis-19020 186 29 proponent proponent ADJ bracis-19020 186 30 agent agent NOUN bracis-19020 186 31 always always ADV bracis-19020 186 32 begins begin VERB bracis-19020 186 33 the the DET bracis-19020 186 34 dialogue dialogue NOUN bracis-19020 186 35 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 186 36 rule rule VERB bracis-19020 186 37 7 7 NUM bracis-19020 186 38 asserts assert VERB bracis-19020 186 39 that that SCONJ bracis-19020 186 40 the the DET bracis-19020 186 41 first first ADJ bracis-19020 186 42 movement movement NOUN bracis-19020 186 43 is be AUX bracis-19020 186 44 a a DET bracis-19020 186 45 request request NOUN bracis-19020 186 46 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 187 1 rules rule NOUN bracis-19020 187 2 8 8 NUM bracis-19020 187 3 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 187 4 9 9 NUM bracis-19020 187 5 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 187 6 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 187 7 10 10 NUM bracis-19020 187 8 have have VERB bracis-19020 187 9 to to PART bracis-19020 187 10 do do VERB bracis-19020 187 11 with with ADP bracis-19020 187 12 the the DET bracis-19020 187 13 termination termination NOUN bracis-19020 187 14 of of ADP bracis-19020 187 15 a a DET bracis-19020 187 16 dialogue dialogue NOUN bracis-19020 187 17 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 188 1 a a DET bracis-19020 188 2 dialogue dialogue NOUN bracis-19020 188 3 system system NOUN bracis-19020 188 4 also also ADV bracis-19020 188 5 has have VERB bracis-19020 188 6 effect effect NOUN bracis-19020 188 7 or or CCONJ bracis-19020 188 8 commitment commitment NOUN bracis-19020 188 9 rules rule NOUN bracis-19020 188 10 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 188 11 which which PRON bracis-19020 188 12 specify specify VERB bracis-19020 188 13 the the DET bracis-19020 188 14 effects effect NOUN bracis-19020 188 15 of of ADP bracis-19020 188 16 moves move NOUN bracis-19020 188 17 on on ADP bracis-19020 188 18 the the DET bracis-19020 188 19 participants participant NOUN bracis-19020 188 20 ’ ' PUNCT bracis-19020 188 21 commitments commitment NOUN bracis-19020 188 22 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 189 1 a a DET bracis-19020 189 2 commitment commitment NOUN bracis-19020 189 3 store store NOUN bracis-19020 189 4 gathers gather VERB bracis-19020 189 5 the the DET bracis-19020 189 6 statements statement NOUN bracis-19020 189 7 each each DET bracis-19020 189 8 agent agent NOUN bracis-19020 189 9 have have AUX bracis-19020 189 10 made make VERB bracis-19020 189 11 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 189 12 the the DET bracis-19020 189 13 challenges challenge NOUN bracis-19020 189 14 they they PRON bracis-19020 189 15 have have AUX bracis-19020 189 16 issued issue VERB bracis-19020 189 17 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 190 1 commitment commitment NOUN bracis-19020 190 2 rules rule NOUN bracis-19020 190 3 define define VERB bracis-19020 190 4 how how SCONJ bracis-19020 190 5 these these DET bracis-19020 190 6 commitment commitment NOUN bracis-19020 190 7 stores store NOUN bracis-19020 190 8 have have VERB bracis-19020 190 9 to to PART bracis-19020 190 10 be be AUX bracis-19020 190 11 updated update VERB bracis-19020 190 12 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 190 13 whether whether SCONJ bracis-19020 190 14 particular particular ADJ bracis-19020 190 15 illocutions illocution NOUN bracis-19020 190 16 can can AUX bracis-19020 190 17 be be AUX bracis-19020 190 18 uttered utter VERB bracis-19020 190 19 at at ADP bracis-19020 190 20 a a DET bracis-19020 190 21 particular particular ADJ bracis-19020 190 22 time time NOUN bracis-19020 190 23 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 191 1 let let VERB bracis-19020 191 2 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 191 3 be be AUX bracis-19020 191 4 the the DET bracis-19020 191 5 commitment commitment NOUN bracis-19020 191 6 stores store NOUN bracis-19020 191 7 of of ADP bracis-19020 191 8 the the DET bracis-19020 191 9 proponent proponent NOUN bracis-19020 191 10 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 191 11 the the DET bracis-19020 191 12 opponent opponent NOUN bracis-19020 191 13 agent agent NOUN bracis-19020 191 14 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 191 15 respectively respectively ADV bracis-19020 191 16 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 192 1 the the DET bracis-19020 192 2 set set NOUN bracis-19020 192 3 of of ADP bracis-19020 192 4 commitment commitment NOUN bracis-19020 192 5 rules rule NOUN bracis-19020 192 6 is be AUX bracis-19020 192 7 the the DET bracis-19020 192 8 followings following NOUN bracis-19020 192 9 : : PUNCT bracis-19020 193 1 1 1 X bracis-19020 193 2 . . X bracis-19020 193 3 \(cr_1:\ \(cr_1:\ NUM bracis-19020 193 4 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 193 5 if if SCONJ bracis-19020 193 6 \(sp(m_i \(sp(m_i ADV bracis-19020 193 7 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 193 8 = = SYM bracis-19020 193 9 why(a)\ why(a)\ PROPN bracis-19020 193 10 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 193 11 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 193 12 \(sd(m_i)=p\ \(sd(m_i)=p\ NOUN bracis-19020 193 13 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 193 14 then then ADV bracis-19020 193 15 2 2 X bracis-19020 193 16 . . X bracis-19020 193 17 \(cr_2:\ \(cr_2:\ PROPN bracis-19020 193 18 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 193 19 if if SCONJ bracis-19020 193 20 \(sp(m_i \(sp(m_i ADV bracis-19020 193 21 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 193 22 = = SYM bracis-19020 193 23 reward(a)\ reward(a)\ NOUN bracis-19020 193 24 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 193 25 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 193 26 \(sd(m_i)=p\ \(sd(m_i)=p\ NOUN bracis-19020 193 27 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 193 28 then then ADV bracis-19020 193 29 3 3 X bracis-19020 193 30 . . X bracis-19020 193 31 \(cr_3:\ \(cr_3:\ NOUN bracis-19020 193 32 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 193 33 if if SCONJ bracis-19020 193 34 \(sp(m_i \(sp(m_i ADV bracis-19020 193 35 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 193 36 = = SYM bracis-19020 193 37 threat(a)\ threat(a)\ NOUN bracis-19020 193 38 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 193 39 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 193 40 \(sd(m_i)=p\ \(sd(m_i)=p\ NOUN bracis-19020 193 41 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 193 42 then then ADV bracis-19020 193 43 4 4 X bracis-19020 193 44 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 194 1 \(cr_4:\ \(cr_4:\ NOUN bracis-19020 194 2 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 194 3 if if SCONJ bracis-19020 194 4 \(sp(m_i \(sp(m_i ADV bracis-19020 194 5 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 194 6 = = SYM bracis-19020 194 7 explanation(a)\ explanation(a)\ NOUN bracis-19020 194 8 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 194 9 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 194 10 \(sd(m_i)=p\ \(sd(m_i)=p\ NOUN bracis-19020 194 11 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 194 12 then then ADV bracis-19020 194 13 5 5 NUM bracis-19020 194 14 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 195 1 \(cr_5:\ \(cr_5:\ NOUN bracis-19020 195 2 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 196 1 if if SCONJ bracis-19020 196 2 \(sp(m_i \(sp(m_i ADV bracis-19020 196 3 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 196 4 = = SYM bracis-19020 196 5 accept(\varphi accept(\varphi NOUN bracis-19020 196 6 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 196 7 \ \ PROPN bracis-19020 196 8 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 196 9 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 196 10 \(sd(m_i)=p\ \(sd(m_i)=p\ NOUN bracis-19020 196 11 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 196 12 then then ADV bracis-19020 196 13 it it PRON bracis-19020 196 14 also also ADV bracis-19020 196 15 holds hold VERB bracis-19020 196 16 that that SCONJ bracis-19020 196 17 : : PUNCT bracis-19020 196 18 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 196 19 i i NOUN bracis-19020 196 20 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 196 21 \(cr_2\ \(cr_2\ PROPN bracis-19020 196 22 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 196 23 also also ADV bracis-19020 196 24 holds hold VERB bracis-19020 196 25 appeal(a appeal(a PROPN bracis-19020 196 26 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 196 27 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 196 28 ii ii NOUN bracis-19020 196 29 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 196 30 \(cr_2\ \(cr_2\ PROPN bracis-19020 196 31 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 196 32 also also ADV bracis-19020 196 33 holds hold VERB bracis-19020 196 34 counter counter NOUN bracis-19020 196 35 - - NOUN bracis-19020 196 36 threat(b threat(b NOUN bracis-19020 196 37 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 196 38 ; ; PUNCT bracis-19020 196 39 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 196 40 iii iii X bracis-19020 196 41 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 196 42 \(cr_4\ \(cr_4\ PROPN bracis-19020 196 43 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 196 44 also also ADV bracis-19020 196 45 holds hold VERB bracis-19020 196 46 for for ADP bracis-19020 196 47 undercut(b undercut(b NOUN bracis-19020 196 48 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 196 49 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 196 50 rebuttal(b rebuttal(b NOUN bracis-19020 196 51 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 196 52 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 196 53 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 196 54 disesteemate(b disesteemate(b X bracis-19020 196 55 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 196 56 ; ; PUNCT bracis-19020 196 57 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 196 58 iv iv X bracis-19020 196 59 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 196 60 \(cr_5\ \(cr_5\ PROPN bracis-19020 196 61 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 196 62 also also ADV bracis-19020 196 63 holds hold VERB bracis-19020 196 64 for for ADP bracis-19020 196 65 \(concede(\varphi \(concede(\varphi ADJ bracis-19020 196 66 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 196 67 \ \ NOUN bracis-19020 196 68 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 196 69 ; ; PUNCT bracis-19020 196 70 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 196 71 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 196 72 v v NOUN bracis-19020 196 73 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 196 74 these these DET bracis-19020 196 75 rules rule NOUN bracis-19020 196 76 hold hold VERB bracis-19020 196 77 for for ADP bracis-19020 196 78 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 197 1 finally finally ADV bracis-19020 197 2 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 197 3 it it PRON bracis-19020 197 4 holds hold VERB bracis-19020 197 5 that that SCONJ bracis-19020 197 6 both both PRON bracis-19020 197 7 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 197 8 are be AUX bracis-19020 197 9 consistent consistent ADJ bracis-19020 197 10 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 198 1 4.2 4.2 NUM bracis-19020 198 2 argumentation argumentation NOUN bracis-19020 198 3 framework framework NOUN bracis-19020 198 4 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 198 5 dialogue dialogue NOUN bracis-19020 198 6 outcome outcome NOUN bracis-19020 198 7 in in ADP bracis-19020 198 8 this this DET bracis-19020 198 9 subsection subsection NOUN bracis-19020 198 10 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 198 11 we we PRON bracis-19020 198 12 present present VERB bracis-19020 198 13 the the DET bracis-19020 198 14 argumentation argumentation NOUN bracis-19020 198 15 framework framework NOUN bracis-19020 198 16 for for ADP bracis-19020 198 17 a a DET bracis-19020 198 18 persuasive persuasive ADJ bracis-19020 198 19 negotiation negotiation NOUN bracis-19020 198 20 dialogue dialogue NOUN bracis-19020 198 21 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 198 22 how how SCONJ bracis-19020 198 23 to to PART bracis-19020 198 24 determine determine VERB bracis-19020 198 25 the the DET bracis-19020 198 26 outcome outcome NOUN bracis-19020 198 27 of of ADP bracis-19020 198 28 the the DET bracis-19020 198 29 dialogue dialogue NOUN bracis-19020 198 30 based base VERB bracis-19020 198 31 on on ADP bracis-19020 198 32 the the DET bracis-19020 198 33 semantics semantic NOUN bracis-19020 198 34 defined define VERB bracis-19020 198 35 in in ADP bracis-19020 198 36 sect sect NOUN bracis-19020 198 37 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 198 38     SPACE bracis-19020 199 1 2 2 NUM bracis-19020 199 2 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 199 3 definition definition NOUN bracis-19020 199 4 13 13 NUM bracis-19020 199 5 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 199 6 dialogue dialogue NOUN bracis-19020 199 7 argumentation argumentation NOUN bracis-19020 199 8 framework framework NOUN bracis-19020 199 9 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 199 10 an an DET bracis-19020 199 11 af af NOUN bracis-19020 199 12 for for ADP bracis-19020 199 13 a a DET bracis-19020 199 14 negotiation negotiation NOUN bracis-19020 199 15 persuasive persuasive ADJ bracis-19020 199 16 dialogue dialogue NOUN bracis-19020 199 17 is be AUX bracis-19020 199 18 a a DET bracis-19020 199 19 tuple tuple NOUN bracis-19020 199 20 such such ADJ bracis-19020 199 21 that that PRON bracis-19020 199 22 : : PUNCT bracis-19020 199 23 is be AUX bracis-19020 199 24 a a DET bracis-19020 199 25 dialogue dialogue NOUN bracis-19020 199 26 constructed construct VERB bracis-19020 199 27 under under ADP bracis-19020 199 28 the the DET bracis-19020 199 29 rules rule NOUN bracis-19020 199 30 of of ADP bracis-19020 199 31 protocol protocol NOUN bracis-19020 199 32 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 199 33 the the DET bracis-19020 199 34 commitment commitment NOUN bracis-19020 199 35 rules rule NOUN bracis-19020 199 36 ; ; PUNCT bracis-19020 199 37 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 199 38 are be AUX bracis-19020 199 39 the the DET bracis-19020 199 40 commitments commitment NOUN bracis-19020 199 41 sets set NOUN bracis-19020 199 42 of of ADP bracis-19020 199 43 the the DET bracis-19020 199 44 proponent proponent NOUN bracis-19020 199 45 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 199 46 the the DET bracis-19020 199 47 opponent opponent NOUN bracis-19020 199 48 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 199 49 respectively respectively ADV bracis-19020 199 50 ; ; PUNCT bracis-19020 199 51 \(\mathtt \(\mathtt NOUN bracis-19020 199 52 { { PUNCT bracis-19020 199 53 arg}=\{\mathtt arg}=\{\mathtt NOUN bracis-19020 199 54 { { PUNCT bracis-19020 199 55 argum}(sp(m_i argum}(sp(m_i NOUN bracis-19020 199 56 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 199 57 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 200 1 \mid \mid ADP bracis-19020 200 2 m_i m_i SYM bracis-19020 200 3 \in \in PROPN bracis-19020 200 4 d\ d\ PROPN bracis-19020 200 5 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 200 6 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 200 7 for for ADP bracis-19020 200 8 \(1 \(1 PROPN bracis-19020 200 9 \le \le PROPN bracis-19020 200 10 i i PRON bracis-19020 200 11 < < X bracis-19020 200 12 n n X bracis-19020 200 13 \}\ \}\ NOUN bracis-19020 200 14 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 200 15 ; ; PUNCT bracis-19020 200 16 ; ; PUNCT bracis-19020 200 17 recall recall VERB bracis-19020 200 18 that that SCONJ bracis-19020 200 19 the the DET bracis-19020 200 20 speech speech NOUN bracis-19020 200 21 acts act VERB bracis-19020 200 22 that that PRON bracis-19020 200 23 end end VERB bracis-19020 200 24 a a DET bracis-19020 200 25 dialogue dialogue NOUN bracis-19020 200 26 are be AUX bracis-19020 200 27 not not PART bracis-19020 200 28 associated associate VERB bracis-19020 200 29 with with ADP bracis-19020 200 30 an an DET bracis-19020 200 31 argument argument NOUN bracis-19020 200 32 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 200 33 which which PRON bracis-19020 200 34 is be AUX bracis-19020 200 35 reflected reflect VERB bracis-19020 200 36 in in ADP bracis-19020 200 37 the the DET bracis-19020 200 38 set set NOUN bracis-19020 200 39 of of ADP bracis-19020 200 40 arguments argument NOUN bracis-19020 200 41 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 201 1 we we PRON bracis-19020 201 2 can can AUX bracis-19020 201 3 notice notice VERB bracis-19020 201 4 that that SCONJ bracis-19020 201 5 \(\mathtt \(\mathtt NOUN bracis-19020 201 6 { { PUNCT bracis-19020 201 7 arg}\ arg}\ NOUN bracis-19020 201 8 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 201 9 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 201 10 form form VERB bracis-19020 201 11 a a DET bracis-19020 201 12 linear linear ADJ bracis-19020 201 13 discussion discussion NOUN bracis-19020 201 14 with with ADP bracis-19020 201 15 a a DET bracis-19020 201 16 sequence sequence NOUN bracis-19020 201 17 \(s \(s NOUN bracis-19020 201 18 = = SYM bracis-19020 201 19 \langle \langle PROPN bracis-19020 201 20 a_1 a_1 NOUN bracis-19020 201 21 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 201 22 ... ... PUNCT bracis-19020 201 23 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 201 24 a_{n-1 a_{n-1 ADP bracis-19020 201 25 } } PUNCT bracis-19020 201 26 \rangle \rangle PROPN bracis-19020 201 27 \ \ NOUN bracis-19020 201 28 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 201 29 where where SCONJ bracis-19020 201 30 n n PRON bracis-19020 201 31 is be AUX bracis-19020 201 32 the the DET bracis-19020 201 33 number number NOUN bracis-19020 201 34 of of ADP bracis-19020 201 35 movements movement NOUN bracis-19020 201 36 of of ADP bracis-19020 201 37 d d NOUN bracis-19020 201 38 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 201 39 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 201 40 \(a_1=\mathtt \(a_1=\mathtt NOUN bracis-19020 201 41 { { PUNCT bracis-19020 201 42 argum}(sp(m_1))\ argum}(sp(m_1))\ PROPN bracis-19020 201 43 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 201 44 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 202 1 this this PRON bracis-19020 202 2 means mean VERB bracis-19020 202 3 that that SCONJ bracis-19020 202 4 we we PRON bracis-19020 202 5 can can AUX bracis-19020 202 6 apply apply VERB bracis-19020 202 7 the the DET bracis-19020 202 8 semantics semantic NOUN bracis-19020 202 9 given give VERB bracis-19020 202 10 in in ADP bracis-19020 202 11 definition definition NOUN bracis-19020 202 12 14 14 NUM bracis-19020 202 13 in in ADP bracis-19020 202 14 order order NOUN bracis-19020 202 15 to to PART bracis-19020 202 16 define define VERB bracis-19020 202 17 the the DET bracis-19020 202 18 acceptable acceptable ADJ bracis-19020 202 19 arguments argument NOUN bracis-19020 202 20 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 202 21 based base VERB bracis-19020 202 22 on on ADP bracis-19020 202 23 these these DET bracis-19020 202 24 arguments argument NOUN bracis-19020 202 25 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 202 26 we we PRON bracis-19020 202 27 can can AUX bracis-19020 202 28 define define VERB bracis-19020 202 29 the the DET bracis-19020 202 30 outcome outcome NOUN bracis-19020 202 31 of of ADP bracis-19020 202 32 the the DET bracis-19020 202 33 dialogue dialogue NOUN bracis-19020 202 34 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 202 35 that that ADV bracis-19020 202 36 is is ADV bracis-19020 202 37 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 202 38 the the DET bracis-19020 202 39 winner winner NOUN bracis-19020 202 40 of of ADP bracis-19020 202 41 the the DET bracis-19020 202 42 dialogue dialogue NOUN bracis-19020 202 43 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 203 1 if if SCONJ bracis-19020 203 2 the the DET bracis-19020 203 3 proponent proponent NOUN bracis-19020 203 4 wins win VERB bracis-19020 203 5 the the DET bracis-19020 203 6 dialogue dialogue NOUN bracis-19020 203 7 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 203 8 that that ADV bracis-19020 203 9 is is ADV bracis-19020 203 10 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 203 11 he he PRON bracis-19020 203 12 persuades persuade VERB bracis-19020 203 13 his his PRON bracis-19020 203 14 opponent opponent NOUN bracis-19020 203 15 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 203 16 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 203 17 then then ADV bracis-19020 203 18 the the DET bracis-19020 203 19 opponent opponent NOUN bracis-19020 203 20 has have VERB bracis-19020 203 21 to to PART bracis-19020 203 22 perform perform VERB bracis-19020 203 23 the the DET bracis-19020 203 24 required require VERB bracis-19020 203 25 action action NOUN bracis-19020 203 26 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 203 27 the the DET bracis-19020 203 28 proposed propose VERB bracis-19020 203 29 threat threat NOUN bracis-19020 203 30 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 203 31 reward reward NOUN bracis-19020 203 32 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 203 33 or or CCONJ bracis-19020 203 34 appeal appeal NOUN bracis-19020 203 35 has have VERB bracis-19020 203 36 to to PART bracis-19020 203 37 be be AUX bracis-19020 203 38 fulfilled fulfil VERB bracis-19020 203 39 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 204 1 note note VERB bracis-19020 204 2 that that SCONJ bracis-19020 204 3 the the DET bracis-19020 204 4 proponent proponent NOUN bracis-19020 204 5 can can AUX bracis-19020 204 6 send send VERB bracis-19020 204 7 more more ADJ bracis-19020 204 8 than than ADP bracis-19020 204 9 one one NUM bracis-19020 204 10 rhetorical rhetorical ADJ bracis-19020 204 11 argument argument NOUN bracis-19020 204 12 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 204 13 in in ADP bracis-19020 204 14 this this DET bracis-19020 204 15 case case NOUN bracis-19020 204 16 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 204 17 the the DET bracis-19020 204 18 last last ADJ bracis-19020 204 19 rhetorical rhetorical ADJ bracis-19020 204 20 argument argument NOUN bracis-19020 204 21 sent send VERB bracis-19020 204 22 during during ADP bracis-19020 204 23 the the DET bracis-19020 204 24 dialogue dialogue NOUN bracis-19020 204 25 is be AUX bracis-19020 204 26 the the DET bracis-19020 204 27 one one NOUN bracis-19020 204 28 that that PRON bracis-19020 204 29 has have VERB bracis-19020 204 30 to to PART bracis-19020 204 31 be be AUX bracis-19020 204 32 fulfilled fulfil VERB bracis-19020 204 33 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 205 1 on on ADP bracis-19020 205 2 the the DET bracis-19020 205 3 other other ADJ bracis-19020 205 4 hand hand NOUN bracis-19020 205 5 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 205 6 when when SCONJ bracis-19020 205 7 the the DET bracis-19020 205 8 proponent proponent NOUN bracis-19020 205 9 loses lose VERB bracis-19020 205 10 the the DET bracis-19020 205 11 dialogue dialogue NOUN bracis-19020 205 12 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 205 13 the the DET bracis-19020 205 14 opponent opponent NOUN bracis-19020 205 15 does do AUX bracis-19020 205 16 not not PART bracis-19020 205 17 have have VERB bracis-19020 205 18 to to PART bracis-19020 205 19 perform perform VERB bracis-19020 205 20 the the DET bracis-19020 205 21 required require VERB bracis-19020 205 22 action action NOUN bracis-19020 205 23 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 205 24 no no DET bracis-19020 205 25 offer offer NOUN bracis-19020 205 26 has have VERB bracis-19020 205 27 to to PART bracis-19020 205 28 be be AUX bracis-19020 205 29 fulfilled fulfil VERB bracis-19020 205 30 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 206 1 before before SCONJ bracis-19020 206 2 define define VERB bracis-19020 206 3 the the DET bracis-19020 206 4 outcome outcome NOUN bracis-19020 206 5 of of ADP bracis-19020 206 6 the the DET bracis-19020 206 7 dialogue dialogue NOUN bracis-19020 206 8 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 206 9 we we PRON bracis-19020 206 10 have have VERB bracis-19020 206 11 to to PART bracis-19020 206 12 make make VERB bracis-19020 206 13 a a DET bracis-19020 206 14 modification modification NOUN bracis-19020 206 15 on on ADP bracis-19020 206 16 the the DET bracis-19020 206 17 semantics semantic NOUN bracis-19020 206 18 due due ADP bracis-19020 206 19 to to ADP bracis-19020 206 20 the the DET bracis-19020 206 21 condition condition NOUN bracis-19020 206 22 of of ADP bracis-19020 206 23 the the DET bracis-19020 206 24 last last ADJ bracis-19020 206 25 movement movement NOUN bracis-19020 206 26 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 207 1 definition definition NOUN bracis-19020 207 2 14 14 NUM bracis-19020 207 3 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 207 4 daf daf PROPN bracis-19020 207 5 semantics semantic NOUN bracis-19020 207 6 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 207 7 let let AUX bracis-19020 207 8 be be AUX bracis-19020 207 9 a a DET bracis-19020 207 10 dialogue dialogue NOUN bracis-19020 207 11 argumentation argumentation NOUN bracis-19020 207 12 framework framework NOUN bracis-19020 207 13 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 207 14 \(a \(a NOUN bracis-19020 207 15 \in \in PROPN bracis-19020 207 16 \mathtt \mathtt PROPN bracis-19020 207 17 { { PUNCT bracis-19020 207 18 arg}\ arg}\ PROPN bracis-19020 207 19 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 207 20 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 207 21 s s VERB bracis-19020 207 22 a a DET bracis-19020 207 23 sequence sequence NOUN bracis-19020 207 24 for for ADP bracis-19020 207 25 a a PRON bracis-19020 207 26 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 207 27 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 207 28 \(n=|\mathtt \(n=|\mathtt X bracis-19020 207 29 { { PUNCT bracis-19020 207 30 arg}|+1\ arg}|+1\ NOUN bracis-19020 207 31 ): ): PUNCT bracis-19020 207 32 if if SCONJ bracis-19020 207 33 n n PRON bracis-19020 207 34 is be AUX bracis-19020 207 35 odd odd ADJ bracis-19020 207 36 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 207 37 \(sp(m_n)=accept(\varphi \(sp(m_n)=accept(\varphi VERB bracis-19020 207 38 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 207 39 \ \ NOUN bracis-19020 207 40 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 207 41 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 207 42 or or CCONJ bracis-19020 207 43 \(sp(m_n)=concede(\varphi \(sp(m_n)=concede(\varphi VERB bracis-19020 207 44 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 207 45 \ \ NOUN bracis-19020 207 46 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 207 47 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 207 48 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 207 49 then then ADV bracis-19020 207 50 \(\mathtt \(\mathtt VERB bracis-19020 207 51 { { PUNCT bracis-19020 207 52 att}(a)\ att}(a)\ NOUN bracis-19020 207 53 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 207 54 are be AUX bracis-19020 207 55 acceptable acceptable ADJ bracis-19020 207 56 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 208 1 if if SCONJ bracis-19020 208 2 n n NOUN bracis-19020 208 3 is be AUX bracis-19020 208 4 even even ADV bracis-19020 208 5 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 208 6 \(sp(m_n)=accept(\varphi \(sp(m_n)=accept(\varphi VERB bracis-19020 208 7 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 208 8 \ \ NOUN bracis-19020 208 9 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 208 10 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 208 11 or or CCONJ bracis-19020 208 12 \(sp(m_n)=concede(\varphi \(sp(m_n)=concede(\varphi VERB bracis-19020 208 13 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 208 14 \ \ NOUN bracis-19020 208 15 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 208 16 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 208 17 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 208 18 then then ADV bracis-19020 208 19 \(a \(a NOUN bracis-19020 208 20 \cup \cup VERB bracis-19020 208 21 \mathtt \mathtt PROPN bracis-19020 208 22 { { PUNCT bracis-19020 208 23 sup}(a)\ sup}(a)\ NOUN bracis-19020 208 24 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 208 25 are be AUX bracis-19020 208 26 acceptable acceptable ADJ bracis-19020 208 27 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 209 1 if if SCONJ bracis-19020 209 2 \(sp(m_n)=withdraw\ \(sp(m_n)=withdraw\ NOUN bracis-19020 209 3 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 209 4 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 209 5 then then ADV bracis-19020 209 6 there there PRON bracis-19020 209 7 are be VERB bracis-19020 209 8 no no DET bracis-19020 209 9 acceptable acceptable ADJ bracis-19020 209 10 arguments argument NOUN bracis-19020 209 11 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 210 1 let let AUX bracis-19020 210 2 be be AUX bracis-19020 210 3 a a DET bracis-19020 210 4 semantics semantic NOUN bracis-19020 210 5 function function NOUN bracis-19020 210 6 that that PRON bracis-19020 210 7 returns return VERB bracis-19020 210 8 the the DET bracis-19020 210 9 set set NOUN bracis-19020 210 10 of of ADP bracis-19020 210 11 acceptable acceptable ADJ bracis-19020 210 12 arguments argument NOUN bracis-19020 210 13 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 211 1 we we PRON bracis-19020 211 2 can can AUX bracis-19020 211 3 now now ADV bracis-19020 211 4 define define VERB bracis-19020 211 5 the the DET bracis-19020 211 6 outcome outcome NOUN bracis-19020 211 7 of of ADP bracis-19020 211 8 the the DET bracis-19020 211 9 dialogue dialogue NOUN bracis-19020 211 10 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 212 1 definition definition NOUN bracis-19020 212 2 15 15 NUM bracis-19020 212 3 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 212 4 dialogue dialogue NOUN bracis-19020 212 5 outcome outcome NOUN bracis-19020 212 6 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 212 7 let let AUX bracis-19020 212 8 be be AUX bracis-19020 212 9 a a DET bracis-19020 212 10 dialogue dialogue NOUN bracis-19020 212 11 argumentation argumentation NOUN bracis-19020 212 12 framework framework NOUN bracis-19020 212 13 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 212 14 \(a \(a NOUN bracis-19020 212 15 \in \in PROPN bracis-19020 212 16 \mathtt \mathtt PROPN bracis-19020 212 17 { { PUNCT bracis-19020 212 18 arg}\ arg}\ NOUN bracis-19020 212 19 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 212 20 is be AUX bracis-19020 212 21 an an DET bracis-19020 212 22 argument argument NOUN bracis-19020 212 23 that that PRON bracis-19020 212 24 represents represent VERB bracis-19020 212 25 a a DET bracis-19020 212 26 required required ADJ bracis-19020 212 27 action action NOUN bracis-19020 212 28 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 212 29 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 212 30 p p NOUN bracis-19020 212 31 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 212 32 o o X bracis-19020 212 33 the the DET bracis-19020 212 34 proponent proponent NOUN bracis-19020 212 35 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 212 36 the the DET bracis-19020 212 37 opponent opponent NOUN bracis-19020 212 38 agent agent NOUN bracis-19020 212 39 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 212 40 respectively respectively ADV bracis-19020 212 41 : : PUNCT bracis-19020 212 42 if if SCONJ bracis-19020 212 43 then then ADV bracis-19020 212 44 p p NOUN bracis-19020 212 45 wins win VERB bracis-19020 212 46 the the DET bracis-19020 212 47 dialogue dialogue NOUN bracis-19020 212 48 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 212 49 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 212 50 o o NOUN bracis-19020 212 51 has have VERB bracis-19020 212 52 to to PART bracis-19020 212 53 perform perform VERB bracis-19020 212 54 \(\mathtt \(\mathtt NOUN bracis-19020 212 55 { { PUNCT bracis-19020 212 56 conc}(a)\ conc}(a)\ NOUN bracis-19020 212 57 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 212 58 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 213 1 if if SCONJ bracis-19020 213 2 then then ADV bracis-19020 213 3 p p NOUN bracis-19020 213 4 loses lose VERB bracis-19020 213 5 the the DET bracis-19020 213 6 dialogue dialogue NOUN bracis-19020 213 7 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 214 1 4.3 4.3 NUM bracis-19020 214 2 properties property NOUN bracis-19020 214 3 of of ADP bracis-19020 214 4 the the DET bracis-19020 214 5 proposal proposal NOUN bracis-19020 214 6 in in ADP bracis-19020 214 7 this this DET bracis-19020 214 8 section section NOUN bracis-19020 214 9 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 214 10 we we PRON bracis-19020 214 11 will will AUX bracis-19020 214 12 study study VERB bracis-19020 214 13 some some DET bracis-19020 214 14 properties property NOUN bracis-19020 214 15 of of ADP bracis-19020 214 16 our our PRON bracis-19020 214 17 proposal proposal NOUN bracis-19020 214 18 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 215 1 the the DET bracis-19020 215 2 aim aim NOUN bracis-19020 215 3 is be AUX bracis-19020 215 4 to to PART bracis-19020 215 5 evaluate evaluate VERB bracis-19020 215 6 its its PRON bracis-19020 215 7 legality legality NOUN bracis-19020 215 8 in in ADP bracis-19020 215 9 the the DET bracis-19020 215 10 sense sense NOUN bracis-19020 215 11 of of ADP bracis-19020 215 12 fulfillment fulfillment NOUN bracis-19020 215 13 of of ADP bracis-19020 215 14 the the DET bracis-19020 215 15 rules rule NOUN bracis-19020 215 16 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 215 17 the the DET bracis-19020 215 18 soundness soundness NOUN bracis-19020 215 19 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 215 20 completeness completeness NOUN bracis-19020 215 21 of of ADP bracis-19020 215 22 the the DET bracis-19020 215 23 argumentation argumentation NOUN bracis-19020 215 24 process process NOUN bracis-19020 215 25 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 216 1 the the DET bracis-19020 216 2 first first ADJ bracis-19020 216 3 proposition proposition NOUN bracis-19020 216 4 concerns concern NOUN bracis-19020 216 5 with with ADP bracis-19020 216 6 the the DET bracis-19020 216 7 legality legality NOUN bracis-19020 216 8 of of ADP bracis-19020 216 9 the the DET bracis-19020 216 10 moves move NOUN bracis-19020 216 11 exchanged exchange VERB bracis-19020 216 12 during during ADP bracis-19020 216 13 the the DET bracis-19020 216 14 dialogue dialogue NOUN bracis-19020 216 15 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 217 1 proposition proposition NOUN bracis-19020 217 2 1 1 NUM bracis-19020 217 3 given give VERB bracis-19020 217 4 \(d=\langle \(d=\langle NOUN bracis-19020 217 5 m_1 m_1 X bracis-19020 217 6 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 217 7 ... ... PUNCT bracis-19020 217 8 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 217 9 m_n m_n PUNCT bracis-19020 217 10 \rangle \rangle NOUN bracis-19020 217 11 \ \ NOUN bracis-19020 217 12 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 217 13 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 217 14 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 217 15 \(d'=\langle \(d'=\langle VERB bracis-19020 217 16 m_1 m_1 PROPN bracis-19020 217 17 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 217 18 ... ... PUNCT bracis-19020 217 19 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 217 20 n_m n_m PUNCT bracis-19020 217 21 \rangle \rangle NOUN bracis-19020 217 22 \ \ NOUN bracis-19020 217 23 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 217 24 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 217 25 where where SCONJ bracis-19020 217 26 \(1 \(1 PROPN bracis-19020 217 27 \le \le PROPN bracis-19020 217 28 m m NOUN bracis-19020 217 29 \le \le NOUN bracis-19020 217 30 n\ n\ NOUN bracis-19020 217 31 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 217 32 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 217 33 considering consider VERB bracis-19020 217 34 that that PRON bracis-19020 217 35 is be AUX bracis-19020 217 36 compatible compatible ADJ bracis-19020 217 37 with with ADP bracis-19020 217 38 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 217 39 fulfils fulfil VERB bracis-19020 217 40 all all PRON bracis-19020 217 41 of of ADP bracis-19020 217 42 the the DET bracis-19020 217 43 previously previously ADV bracis-19020 217 44 established establish VERB bracis-19020 217 45 rules rule NOUN bracis-19020 217 46 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 218 1 we we PRON bracis-19020 218 2 can can AUX bracis-19020 218 3 say say VERB bracis-19020 218 4 that that SCONJ bracis-19020 218 5 if if SCONJ bracis-19020 218 6 \(\forall \(\forall ADV bracis-19020 218 7 m\ m\ ADJ bracis-19020 218 8 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 218 9 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 218 10 \(d'\ \(d'\ NOUN bracis-19020 218 11 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 218 12 is be AUX bracis-19020 218 13 a a DET bracis-19020 218 14 legal legal ADJ bracis-19020 218 15 dialogue dialogue NOUN bracis-19020 218 16 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 218 17 then then ADV bracis-19020 218 18 d d PROPN bracis-19020 218 19 is be AUX bracis-19020 218 20 also also ADV bracis-19020 218 21 a a DET bracis-19020 218 22 legal legal ADJ bracis-19020 218 23 dialogue dialogue NOUN bracis-19020 218 24 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 219 1 next next ADJ bracis-19020 219 2 propositions proposition NOUN bracis-19020 219 3 concerns concern NOUN bracis-19020 219 4 with with ADP bracis-19020 219 5 the the DET bracis-19020 219 6 soundness soundness NOUN bracis-19020 219 7 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 219 8 completeness completeness NOUN bracis-19020 219 9 of of ADP bracis-19020 219 10 the the DET bracis-19020 219 11 argumentation argumentation NOUN bracis-19020 219 12 process process NOUN bracis-19020 219 13 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 220 1 proposition proposition NOUN bracis-19020 220 2 2 2 NUM bracis-19020 220 3     SPACE bracis-19020 220 4 be be AUX bracis-19020 220 5 a a DET bracis-19020 220 6 dialogue dialogue NOUN bracis-19020 220 7 argumentation argumentation NOUN bracis-19020 220 8 framework framework NOUN bracis-19020 220 9 : : PUNCT bracis-19020 220 10 if if SCONJ bracis-19020 220 11 \(\forall \(\forall ADV bracis-19020 220 12 a a DET bracis-19020 220 13 \in \in ADJ bracis-19020 220 14 \mathtt \mathtt PROPN bracis-19020 220 15 { { PUNCT bracis-19020 220 16 arg}\ arg}\ PROPN bracis-19020 220 17 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 220 18 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 220 19 if if SCONJ bracis-19020 220 20 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 220 21 then then ADV bracis-19020 220 22 \(\forall \(\forall ADV bracis-19020 220 23 a'\ a'\ PROPN bracis-19020 220 24 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 221 1 such such ADJ bracis-19020 221 2 that that SCONJ bracis-19020 221 3 \(a \(a NOUN bracis-19020 221 4 ' ' PART bracis-19020 221 5 = = NUM bracis-19020 221 6 \mathtt \mathtt PROPN bracis-19020 221 7 { { PUNCT bracis-19020 221 8 argus}(sp(m'))\ argus}(sp(m'))\ NOUN bracis-19020 221 9 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 221 10 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 221 11 \(a \(a NOUN bracis-19020 221 12 = = X bracis-19020 221 13 \mathtt \mathtt PROPN bracis-19020 221 14 { { PUNCT bracis-19020 221 15 argus}(sp(m))\ argus}(sp(m))\ PROPN bracis-19020 221 16 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 221 17 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 221 18 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 221 19 \(sd(m)=sd(m')\ \(sd(m)=sd(m')\ PROPN bracis-19020 221 20 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 221 21 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 221 22 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 221 23 such such ADJ bracis-19020 221 24 that that SCONJ bracis-19020 221 25 \(a \(a NOUN bracis-19020 221 26 ' ' PART bracis-19020 221 27 = = NUM bracis-19020 221 28 \mathtt \mathtt PROPN bracis-19020 221 29 { { PUNCT bracis-19020 221 30 argus}(sp(m'))\ argus}(sp(m'))\ NOUN bracis-19020 221 31 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 221 32 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 221 33 \(a \(a NOUN bracis-19020 221 34 = = PROPN bracis-19020 221 35 \mathtt \mathtt PROPN bracis-19020 221 36 { { PUNCT bracis-19020 221 37 argus}(sp(m))\ argus}(sp(m))\ PROPN bracis-19020 221 38 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 221 39 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 221 40 \(sd(m)=sd(m')\ \(sd(m)=sd(m')\ NOUN bracis-19020 221 41 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 221 42 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 222 1 the the DET bracis-19020 222 2 first first ADJ bracis-19020 222 3 item item NOUN bracis-19020 222 4 say say VERB bracis-19020 222 5 that that SCONJ bracis-19020 222 6 if if SCONJ bracis-19020 222 7 an an DET bracis-19020 222 8 argument argument NOUN bracis-19020 222 9 sent send VERB bracis-19020 222 10 by by ADP bracis-19020 222 11 one one NUM bracis-19020 222 12 the the DET bracis-19020 222 13 agents agent NOUN bracis-19020 222 14 is be AUX bracis-19020 222 15 acceptable acceptable ADJ bracis-19020 222 16 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 222 17 then then ADV bracis-19020 222 18 all all DET bracis-19020 222 19 the the DET bracis-19020 222 20 arguments argument NOUN bracis-19020 222 21 sent send VERB bracis-19020 222 22 by by ADP bracis-19020 222 23 the the DET bracis-19020 222 24 same same ADJ bracis-19020 222 25 agent agent NOUN bracis-19020 222 26 have have VERB bracis-19020 222 27 to to PART bracis-19020 222 28 be be AUX bracis-19020 222 29 acceptable acceptable ADJ bracis-19020 222 30 as as ADV bracis-19020 222 31 well well ADV bracis-19020 222 32 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 223 1 the the DET bracis-19020 223 2 second second ADJ bracis-19020 223 3 item item NOUN bracis-19020 223 4 says say VERB bracis-19020 223 5 that that SCONJ bracis-19020 223 6 all all DET bracis-19020 223 7 acceptable acceptable ADJ bracis-19020 223 8 arguments argument NOUN bracis-19020 223 9 were be AUX bracis-19020 223 10 sent send VERB bracis-19020 223 11 by by ADP bracis-19020 223 12 the the DET bracis-19020 223 13 same same ADJ bracis-19020 223 14 agent agent NOUN bracis-19020 223 15 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 224 1 5 5 NUM bracis-19020 224 2 applying apply VERB bracis-19020 224 3 the the DET bracis-19020 224 4 proposal proposal NOUN bracis-19020 224 5 to to ADP bracis-19020 224 6 the the DET bracis-19020 224 7 illustrative illustrative ADJ bracis-19020 224 8 example example NOUN bracis-19020 224 9 in in ADP bracis-19020 224 10 this this DET bracis-19020 224 11 section section NOUN bracis-19020 224 12 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 224 13 we we PRON bracis-19020 224 14 evaluate evaluate VERB bracis-19020 224 15 if if SCONJ bracis-19020 224 16 the the DET bracis-19020 224 17 example example NOUN bracis-19020 224 18 given give VERB bracis-19020 224 19 in in ADP bracis-19020 224 20 introduction introduction NOUN bracis-19020 224 21 fulfills fulfill VERB bracis-19020 224 22 the the DET bracis-19020 224 23 rules rule NOUN bracis-19020 224 24 of of ADP bracis-19020 224 25 the the DET bracis-19020 224 26 protocol protocol NOUN bracis-19020 224 27 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 225 1 besides besides SCONJ bracis-19020 225 2 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 225 3 we we PRON bracis-19020 225 4 determine determine VERB bracis-19020 225 5 the the DET bracis-19020 225 6 outcome outcome NOUN bracis-19020 225 7 of of ADP bracis-19020 225 8 the the DET bracis-19020 225 9 dialogue dialogue NOUN bracis-19020 225 10 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 226 1 we we PRON bracis-19020 226 2 use use VERB bracis-19020 226 3 p p NOUN bracis-19020 226 4 to to PART bracis-19020 226 5 refer refer VERB bracis-19020 226 6 to to ADP bracis-19020 226 7 maria maria PROPN bracis-19020 226 8 because because SCONJ bracis-19020 226 9 her her PRON bracis-19020 226 10 role role NOUN bracis-19020 226 11 in in ADP bracis-19020 226 12 the the DET bracis-19020 226 13 dialogue dialogue NOUN bracis-19020 226 14 is be AUX bracis-19020 226 15 to to PART bracis-19020 226 16 be be AUX bracis-19020 226 17 the the DET bracis-19020 226 18 proponent proponent NOUN bracis-19020 226 19 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 226 20 o o NOUN bracis-19020 226 21 to to PART bracis-19020 226 22 refer refer VERB bracis-19020 226 23 to to ADP bracis-19020 226 24 carlos carlos PROPN bracis-19020 226 25 because because SCONJ bracis-19020 226 26 his his PRON bracis-19020 226 27 role role NOUN bracis-19020 226 28 in in ADP bracis-19020 226 29 the the DET bracis-19020 226 30 dialogue dialogue NOUN bracis-19020 226 31 is be AUX bracis-19020 226 32 to to PART bracis-19020 226 33 be be AUX bracis-19020 226 34 the the DET bracis-19020 226 35 opponent opponent NOUN bracis-19020 226 36 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 227 1 next next ADV bracis-19020 227 2 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 227 3 we we PRON bracis-19020 227 4 have have VERB bracis-19020 227 5 the the DET bracis-19020 227 6 set set NOUN bracis-19020 227 7 of of ADP bracis-19020 227 8 moves move NOUN bracis-19020 227 9 : : PUNCT bracis-19020 227 10 \(m_1\ \(m_1\ PROPN bracis-19020 227 11 ): ): PUNCT bracis-19020 227 12 : : PUNCT bracis-19020 227 13 \(\langle \(\langle PROPN bracis-19020 227 14 1 1 NUM bracis-19020 227 15 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 227 16 p p X bracis-19020 227 17 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 227 18 0 0 NUM bracis-19020 227 19 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 227 20 request(\langle request(\langle ADJ bracis-19020 227 21 \{cleaning\ \{cleaning\ PROPN bracis-19020 227 22 } } PUNCT bracis-19020 227 23 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 227 24 cleaning clean VERB bracis-19020 227 25 \rangle \rangle NOUN bracis-19020 227 26 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 227 27 \rangle \rangle PROPN bracis-19020 227 28 \ \ NOUN bracis-19020 227 29 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 227 30 \(m_2\ \(m_2\ PROPN bracis-19020 227 31 ): ): PUNCT bracis-19020 227 32 : : PUNCT bracis-19020 227 33 \(\langle \(\langle PROPN bracis-19020 227 34 2 2 NUM bracis-19020 227 35 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 227 36 o o NOUN bracis-19020 227 37 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 227 38 1 1 NUM bracis-19020 227 39 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 227 40 reject(\langle reject(\langle ADJ bracis-19020 227 41 \{cleaning\ \{cleaning\ PROPN bracis-19020 227 42 } } PUNCT bracis-19020 227 43 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 227 44 cleaning clean VERB bracis-19020 227 45 \rangle \rangle NOUN bracis-19020 227 46 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 228 1 \rangle \rangle PROPN bracis-19020 228 2 \ \ ADJ bracis-19020 228 3 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 229 1 \(m_3\ \(m_3\ PROPN bracis-19020 229 2 ): ): PUNCT bracis-19020 229 3 : : PUNCT bracis-19020 229 4 \(\langle \(\langle PROPN bracis-19020 229 5 3 3 NUM bracis-19020 229 6 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 229 7 p p X bracis-19020 229 8 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 229 9 2 2 NUM bracis-19020 229 10 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 229 11 reward(\langle reward(\langle NOUN bracis-19020 229 12 \{cleaning \{cleane VERB bracis-19020 229 13 \rightarrow \rightarrow PROPN bracis-19020 229 14 can\_help can\_help PROPN bracis-19020 229 15 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 229 16 can\_help can\_help NOUN bracis-19020 229 17 \rightarrow \rightarrow PROPN bracis-19020 229 18 finish\_work\ finish\_work\ PROPN bracis-19020 229 19 } } PUNCT bracis-19020 229 20 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 229 21 cleaning cleaning NOUN bracis-19020 229 22 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 229 23 finish\_work finish\_work NUM bracis-19020 229 24 \rangle \rangle NOUN bracis-19020 229 25 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 229 26 \rangle \rangle PROPN bracis-19020 229 27 \ \ NOUN bracis-19020 229 28 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 229 29 \(m_4\ \(m_4\ NOUN bracis-19020 229 30 ): ): PUNCT bracis-19020 229 31 : : PUNCT bracis-19020 229 32 \(\langle \(\langle PROPN bracis-19020 229 33 4 4 NUM bracis-19020 229 34 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 229 35 o o NOUN bracis-19020 229 36 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 229 37 3 3 NUM bracis-19020 229 38 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 229 39 undercut(\langle undercut(\langle NOUN bracis-19020 229 40 \{\lnot \{\lnot ADV bracis-19020 229 41 can\_help\ can\_help\ NOUN bracis-19020 229 42 } } PUNCT bracis-19020 229 43 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 229 44 \lnot \lnot PROPN bracis-19020 229 45 can\_help\rangle can\_help\rangle PROPN bracis-19020 229 46 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 229 47 \rangle \rangle PROPN bracis-19020 229 48 \ \ ADJ bracis-19020 229 49 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 230 1 \(m_5\ \(m_5\ ADJ bracis-19020 230 2 ): ): PUNCT bracis-19020 230 3 : : PUNCT bracis-19020 230 4 \(\langle \(\langle PROPN bracis-19020 230 5 5 5 NUM bracis-19020 230 6 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 230 7 p p X bracis-19020 230 8 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 230 9 4 4 NUM bracis-19020 230 10 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 230 11 why why SCONJ bracis-19020 230 12 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 230 13 \langle \langle VERB bracis-19020 230 14 \{\lnot \{\lnot ADV bracis-19020 230 15 can\_help\ can\_help\ NOUN bracis-19020 230 16 } } PUNCT bracis-19020 230 17 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 230 18 \lnot \lnot PROPN bracis-19020 230 19 can\_help)\rangle can\_help)\rangle PROPN bracis-19020 230 20 \ \ NOUN bracis-19020 230 21 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 230 22 \(m_6\ \(m_6\ PROPN bracis-19020 230 23 ): ): PUNCT bracis-19020 230 24 : : PUNCT bracis-19020 230 25 \(\langle \(\langle PROPN bracis-19020 230 26 6 6 NUM bracis-19020 230 27 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 230 28 o o NOUN bracis-19020 230 29 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 230 30 5 5 NUM bracis-19020 230 31 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 230 32 explanation(\langle explanation(\langle NOUN bracis-19020 230 33 \{work \{work NOUN bracis-19020 230 34 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 230 35 work work NOUN bracis-19020 230 36 \rightarrow \rightarrow PROPN bracis-19020 230 37 \lnot \lnot PROPN bracis-19020 230 38 cleaning\ cleaning\ PROPN bracis-19020 230 39 } } PUNCT bracis-19020 230 40 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 230 41 \lnot \lnot PROPN bracis-19020 230 42 cleaning\rangle cleaning\rangle NUM bracis-19020 230 43 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 230 44 \rangle \rangle PROPN bracis-19020 230 45 \ \ ADJ bracis-19020 230 46 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 230 47 \(m_7\ \(m_7\ NOUN bracis-19020 230 48 ): ): PUNCT bracis-19020 230 49 : : PUNCT bracis-19020 230 50 \(\langle \(\langle PROPN bracis-19020 230 51 7 7 NUM bracis-19020 230 52 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 230 53 p p X bracis-19020 230 54 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 230 55 6 6 NUM bracis-19020 230 56 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 230 57 threat threat NOUN bracis-19020 230 58 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 230 59 \langle \langle AUX bracis-19020 230 60 \{\lnot \{\lnot ADV bracis-19020 230 61 cleaning clean VERB bracis-19020 230 62 \rightarrow \rightarrow PROPN bracis-19020 230 63 \lnot \lnot PROPN bracis-19020 230 64 going\_mother\_house\ going\_mother\_house\ NOUN bracis-19020 230 65 } } PUNCT bracis-19020 230 66 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 230 67 cleaning cleaning NOUN bracis-19020 230 68 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 230 69 going\_mother\_house going\_mother\_house NOUN bracis-19020 230 70 \rangle \rangle NOUN bracis-19020 230 71 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 230 72 \rangle \rangle PROPN bracis-19020 230 73 \ \ ADJ bracis-19020 230 74 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 230 75 \(m_{8}\ \(m_{8}\ NUM bracis-19020 230 76 ): ): PUNCT bracis-19020 230 77 : : PUNCT bracis-19020 230 78 \(\langle \(\langle PROPN bracis-19020 230 79 8 8 NUM bracis-19020 230 80 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 230 81 o o NOUN bracis-19020 230 82 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 230 83 7 7 NUM bracis-19020 230 84 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 230 85 counte\)-\(threat(\langle counte\)-\(threat(\langle NOUN bracis-19020 230 86 \{\lnot \{\lnot ADV bracis-19020 230 87 going\_mother\_house going\_mother\_house VERB bracis-19020 230 88 \rightarrow \rightarrow PROPN bracis-19020 230 89 \lnot \lnot PROPN bracis-19020 230 90 talking\_about\_brother\_work\ talking\_about\_brother\_work\ NUM bracis-19020 230 91 } } PUNCT bracis-19020 230 92 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 230 93 going\_mother\_house going\_mother\_house NOUN bracis-19020 230 94 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 230 95 talking\_about\_brother\_work talking\_about\_brother\_work NOUN bracis-19020 230 96 \rangle \rangle NOUN bracis-19020 230 97 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 231 1 \rangle \rangle PROPN bracis-19020 231 2 \ \ ADJ bracis-19020 231 3 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 231 4 \(m_9\ \(m_9\ NOUN bracis-19020 231 5 ): ): PUNCT bracis-19020 231 6 : : PUNCT bracis-19020 231 7 \(\langle \(\langle PROPN bracis-19020 231 8 9 9 NUM bracis-19020 231 9 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 231 10 p p X bracis-19020 231 11 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 231 12 8 8 NUM bracis-19020 231 13 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 231 14 disesteemate(\langle disesteemate(\langle ADJ bracis-19020 231 15 \{brother\_has\_work \{brother\_has\_work NOUN bracis-19020 231 16 \rightarrow \rightarrow PROPN bracis-19020 231 17 \lnot \lnot PROPN bracis-19020 231 18 talking\_about\_brother\_work talking\_about\_brother\_work NOUN bracis-19020 231 19 \ \ NOUN bracis-19020 231 20 } } PUNCT bracis-19020 231 21 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 231 22 \lnot \lnot PROPN bracis-19020 231 23 talking\_about\_brother\_work talking\_about\_brother\_work NOUN bracis-19020 231 24 \rangle \rangle NOUN bracis-19020 231 25 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 231 26 \rangle \rangle PROPN bracis-19020 231 27 \ \ NOUN bracis-19020 231 28 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 231 29 \(m_{10}\ \(m_{10}\ ADV bracis-19020 231 30 ): ): PUNCT bracis-19020 231 31 : : PUNCT bracis-19020 231 32 \(\langle \(\langle PROPN bracis-19020 231 33 10 10 NUM bracis-19020 231 34 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 231 35 o o NOUN bracis-19020 231 36 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 231 37 9 9 NUM bracis-19020 231 38 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 231 39 concede(\lnot concede(\lnot PRON bracis-19020 231 40 talking\_about\_brother\_work)\rangle talking\_about\_brother\_work)\rangle PROPN bracis-19020 231 41 \ \ NOUN bracis-19020 231 42 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 231 43 we we PRON bracis-19020 231 44 have have VERB bracis-19020 231 45 a a DET bracis-19020 231 46 dialogue dialogue NOUN bracis-19020 231 47 \(d=\{m_1 \(d=\{m_1 PROPN bracis-19020 231 48 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 231 49 m_2 m_2 PROPN bracis-19020 231 50 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 231 51 m_3 m_3 PROPN bracis-19020 231 52 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 231 53 m_4 m_4 PRON bracis-19020 231 54 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 231 55 m_5 m_5 PROPN bracis-19020 231 56 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 231 57 m_6 m_6 PROPN bracis-19020 231 58 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 231 59 m_7 m_7 NOUN bracis-19020 231 60 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 231 61 m_8 m_8 NOUN bracis-19020 231 62 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 231 63 m_9 m_9 NOUN bracis-19020 231 64 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 231 65 m_{10}\}\ m_{10}\}\ PROPN bracis-19020 231 66 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 231 67 where where SCONJ bracis-19020 231 68 the the DET bracis-19020 231 69 request request NOUN bracis-19020 231 70 is be AUX bracis-19020 231 71 the the DET bracis-19020 231 72 first first ADJ bracis-19020 231 73 move move NOUN bracis-19020 231 74 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 231 75 the the DET bracis-19020 231 76 target target NOUN bracis-19020 231 77 of of ADP bracis-19020 231 78 every every DET bracis-19020 231 79 move move NOUN bracis-19020 231 80 is be AUX bracis-19020 231 81 the the DET bracis-19020 231 82 previous previous ADJ bracis-19020 231 83 move move NOUN bracis-19020 231 84 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 232 1 regarding regard VERB bracis-19020 232 2 the the DET bracis-19020 232 3 rules rule NOUN bracis-19020 232 4 of of ADP bracis-19020 232 5 the the DET bracis-19020 232 6 legal legal ADJ bracis-19020 232 7 - - PUNCT bracis-19020 232 8 move move NOUN bracis-19020 232 9 function function NOUN bracis-19020 232 10 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 232 11 we we PRON bracis-19020 232 12 can can AUX bracis-19020 232 13 say say VERB bracis-19020 232 14 that that SCONJ bracis-19020 232 15 all all DET bracis-19020 232 16 the the DET bracis-19020 232 17 moves move NOUN bracis-19020 232 18 of of ADP bracis-19020 232 19 d d NOUN bracis-19020 232 20 follow follow VERB bracis-19020 232 21 these these DET bracis-19020 232 22 rules rule NOUN bracis-19020 232 23 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 233 1 let let VERB bracis-19020 233 2 us we PRON bracis-19020 233 3 now now ADV bracis-19020 233 4 present present VERB bracis-19020 233 5 the the DET bracis-19020 233 6 commitments commitment NOUN bracis-19020 233 7 sets set VERB bracis-19020 233 8 : : PUNCT bracis-19020 233 9 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 234 1 we we PRON bracis-19020 234 2 can can AUX bracis-19020 234 3 notice notice VERB bracis-19020 234 4 that that SCONJ bracis-19020 234 5 both both DET bracis-19020 234 6 commitment commitment NOUN bracis-19020 234 7 sets set NOUN bracis-19020 234 8 are be AUX bracis-19020 234 9 consistent consistent ADJ bracis-19020 234 10 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 235 1 note note VERB bracis-19020 235 2 also also ADV bracis-19020 235 3 that that PRON bracis-19020 235 4 includes include VERB bracis-19020 235 5 the the DET bracis-19020 235 6 requested request VERB bracis-19020 235 7 action action NOUN bracis-19020 235 8 as as ADP bracis-19020 235 9 a a DET bracis-19020 235 10 positive positive ADJ bracis-19020 235 11 literal literal ADJ bracis-19020 235 12 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 235 13 cleaning cleaning NOUN bracis-19020 235 14 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 235 15 whereas whereas SCONJ bracis-19020 235 16 includes include VERB bracis-19020 235 17 the the DET bracis-19020 235 18 requested request VERB bracis-19020 235 19 action action NOUN bracis-19020 235 20 as as ADP bracis-19020 235 21 a a DET bracis-19020 235 22 negative negative ADJ bracis-19020 235 23 literal literal ADJ bracis-19020 235 24 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 235 25 \(\lnot \(\lnot ADV bracis-19020 235 26 cleaning\ cleaning\ VERB bracis-19020 235 27 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 235 28 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 235 29 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 236 1 now now ADV bracis-19020 236 2 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 236 3 let let VERB bracis-19020 236 4 us we PRON bracis-19020 236 5 define define VERB bracis-19020 236 6 the the DET bracis-19020 236 7 dialogue dialogue NOUN bracis-19020 236 8 argumentation argumentation NOUN bracis-19020 236 9 framework framework NOUN bracis-19020 236 10 : : PUNCT bracis-19020 236 11 where where SCONJ bracis-19020 236 12 \(\mathtt \(\mathtt NOUN bracis-19020 236 13 { { PUNCT bracis-19020 236 14 arg}=\{a_1 arg}=\{a_1 PROPN bracis-19020 236 15 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 236 16 a_2 a_2 PROPN bracis-19020 236 17 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 236 18 a_3 a_3 PROPN bracis-19020 236 19 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 236 20 a_4 a_4 PROPN bracis-19020 236 21 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 236 22 a_5 a_5 NOUN bracis-19020 236 23 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 236 24 a_6 a_6 PROPN bracis-19020 236 25 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 236 26 a_7 a_7 PROPN bracis-19020 236 27 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 236 28 a_8 a_8 PROPN bracis-19020 236 29 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 236 30 a_9\}\ a_9\}\ PROPN bracis-19020 236 31 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 236 32 such such ADJ bracis-19020 236 33 that that SCONJ bracis-19020 236 34 each each DET bracis-19020 236 35 argument argument NOUN bracis-19020 236 36 is be AUX bracis-19020 236 37 associated associate VERB bracis-19020 236 38 to to ADP bracis-19020 236 39 the the DET bracis-19020 236 40 number number NOUN bracis-19020 236 41 of of ADP bracis-19020 236 42 the the DET bracis-19020 236 43 move move NOUN bracis-19020 236 44 in in ADP bracis-19020 236 45 the the DET bracis-19020 236 46 dialogue dialogue NOUN bracis-19020 236 47 d d NOUN bracis-19020 236 48 ; ; PUNCT bracis-19020 236 49 ; ; PUNCT bracis-19020 236 50 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 237 1 d d NOUN bracis-19020 237 2 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 237 3 the the DET bracis-19020 237 4 commitment commitment NOUN bracis-19020 237 5 sets set NOUN bracis-19020 237 6 were be AUX bracis-19020 237 7 presented present VERB bracis-19020 237 8 above above ADV bracis-19020 237 9 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 238 1 the the DET bracis-19020 238 2 result result NOUN bracis-19020 238 3 of of ADP bracis-19020 238 4 applying apply VERB bracis-19020 238 5 the the DET bracis-19020 238 6 semantics semantic NOUN bracis-19020 238 7 is be AUX bracis-19020 238 8 : : PUNCT bracis-19020 238 9 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 239 1 we we PRON bracis-19020 239 2 can can AUX bracis-19020 239 3 now now ADV bracis-19020 239 4 determine determine VERB bracis-19020 239 5 the the DET bracis-19020 239 6 outcome outcome NOUN bracis-19020 239 7 of of ADP bracis-19020 239 8 the the DET bracis-19020 239 9 dialogue dialogue NOUN bracis-19020 239 10 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 240 1 we we PRON bracis-19020 240 2 can can AUX bracis-19020 240 3 notice notice VERB bracis-19020 240 4 that that SCONJ bracis-19020 240 5 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 240 6 this this PRON bracis-19020 240 7 means mean VERB bracis-19020 240 8 that that SCONJ bracis-19020 240 9 p p PROPN bracis-19020 240 10 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 240 11 maria maria PROPN bracis-19020 240 12 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 240 13 wins win VERB bracis-19020 240 14 the the DET bracis-19020 240 15 dialogue dialogue NOUN bracis-19020 240 16 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 240 17 o o PROPN bracis-19020 240 18 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 240 19 carlos carlos PROPN bracis-19020 240 20 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 240 21 has have VERB bracis-19020 240 22 to to PART bracis-19020 240 23 do do VERB bracis-19020 240 24 the the DET bracis-19020 240 25 cleaning cleaning NOUN bracis-19020 240 26 of of ADP bracis-19020 240 27 the the DET bracis-19020 240 28 apartment apartment NOUN bracis-19020 240 29 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 240 30 cleaning cleaning NOUN bracis-19020 240 31 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 240 32 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 241 1 6 6 NUM bracis-19020 241 2 conclusions conclusion NOUN bracis-19020 241 3 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 241 4 future future ADJ bracis-19020 241 5 work work NOUN bracis-19020 241 6 in in ADP bracis-19020 241 7 this this DET bracis-19020 241 8 paper paper NOUN bracis-19020 241 9 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 241 10 we we PRON bracis-19020 241 11 have have AUX bracis-19020 241 12 presented present VERB bracis-19020 241 13 a a DET bracis-19020 241 14 protocol protocol NOUN bracis-19020 241 15 for for ADP bracis-19020 241 16 a a DET bracis-19020 241 17 persuasive persuasive ADJ bracis-19020 241 18 negotiation negotiation NOUN bracis-19020 241 19 dialogue dialogue NOUN bracis-19020 241 20 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 242 1 in in ADP bracis-19020 242 2 the the DET bracis-19020 242 3 resulting result VERB bracis-19020 242 4 dialogue dialogue NOUN bracis-19020 242 5 game game NOUN bracis-19020 242 6 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 242 7 agents agent NOUN bracis-19020 242 8 can can AUX bracis-19020 242 9 exchange exchange VERB bracis-19020 242 10 rhetorical rhetorical ADJ bracis-19020 242 11 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 242 12 explanatory explanatory ADJ bracis-19020 242 13 arguments argument NOUN bracis-19020 242 14 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 242 15 can can AUX bracis-19020 242 16 utter utter VERB bracis-19020 242 17 attacks attack NOUN bracis-19020 242 18 for for ADP bracis-19020 242 19 such such ADJ bracis-19020 242 20 arguments argument NOUN bracis-19020 242 21 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 242 22 can can AUX bracis-19020 242 23 question question VERB bracis-19020 242 24 an an DET bracis-19020 242 25 element element NOUN bracis-19020 242 26 of of ADP bracis-19020 242 27 explanatory explanatory ADJ bracis-19020 242 28 arguments argument NOUN bracis-19020 242 29 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 242 30 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 242 31 also also ADV bracis-19020 242 32 can can AUX bracis-19020 242 33 use use VERB bracis-19020 242 34 negotiation negotiation NOUN bracis-19020 242 35 speech speech NOUN bracis-19020 242 36 acts act VERB bracis-19020 242 37 to to PART bracis-19020 242 38 request request VERB bracis-19020 242 39 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 242 40 reject reject VERB bracis-19020 242 41 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 242 42 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 242 43 finish finish VERB bracis-19020 242 44 the the DET bracis-19020 242 45 dialogue dialogue NOUN bracis-19020 242 46 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 243 1 the the DET bracis-19020 243 2 use use NOUN bracis-19020 243 3 of of ADP bracis-19020 243 4 additional additional ADJ bracis-19020 243 5 kinds kind NOUN bracis-19020 243 6 of of ADP bracis-19020 243 7 illocutions illocution NOUN bracis-19020 243 8 enriches enrich VERB bracis-19020 243 9 the the DET bracis-19020 243 10 dialogue dialogue NOUN bracis-19020 243 11 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 243 12 allows allow VERB bracis-19020 243 13 the the DET bracis-19020 243 14 agents agent NOUN bracis-19020 243 15 to to PART bracis-19020 243 16 not not PART bracis-19020 243 17 only only ADV bracis-19020 243 18 try try VERB bracis-19020 243 19 to to PART bracis-19020 243 20 persuade persuade VERB bracis-19020 243 21 the the DET bracis-19020 243 22 other other ADJ bracis-19020 243 23 party party NOUN bracis-19020 243 24 but but CCONJ bracis-19020 243 25 to to PART bracis-19020 243 26 defend defend VERB bracis-19020 243 27 their their PRON bracis-19020 243 28 positions position NOUN bracis-19020 243 29 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 244 1 the the DET bracis-19020 244 2 proposed propose VERB bracis-19020 244 3 protocol protocol NOUN bracis-19020 244 4 is be AUX bracis-19020 244 5 also also ADV bracis-19020 244 6 flexible flexible ADJ bracis-19020 244 7 since since SCONJ bracis-19020 244 8 it it PRON bracis-19020 244 9 allows allow VERB bracis-19020 244 10 for for ADP bracis-19020 244 11 different different ADJ bracis-19020 244 12 alternative alternative ADJ bracis-19020 244 13 replies reply NOUN bracis-19020 244 14 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 244 15 which which PRON bracis-19020 244 16 were be AUX bracis-19020 244 17 categorized categorize VERB bracis-19020 244 18 as as ADP bracis-19020 244 19 attacks attack NOUN bracis-19020 244 20 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 244 21 surrenders surrender NOUN bracis-19020 244 22 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 245 1 for for ADP bracis-19020 245 2 future future ADJ bracis-19020 245 3 research research NOUN bracis-19020 245 4 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 245 5 we we PRON bracis-19020 245 6 propose propose VERB bracis-19020 245 7 two two NUM bracis-19020 245 8 possible possible ADJ bracis-19020 245 9 directions direction NOUN bracis-19020 245 10 : : PUNCT bracis-19020 245 11 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 245 12 i i NOUN bracis-19020 245 13 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 245 14 the the DET bracis-19020 245 15 first first ADJ bracis-19020 245 16 one one NUM bracis-19020 245 17 is be AUX bracis-19020 245 18 to to PART bracis-19020 245 19 improve improve VERB bracis-19020 245 20 the the DET bracis-19020 245 21 protocol protocol NOUN bracis-19020 245 22 itself itself PRON bracis-19020 245 23 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 245 24 for for ADP bracis-19020 245 25 example example NOUN bracis-19020 245 26 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 245 27 allowing allow VERB bracis-19020 245 28 that that SCONJ bracis-19020 245 29 the the DET bracis-19020 245 30 target target NOUN bracis-19020 245 31 of of ADP bracis-19020 245 32 an an DET bracis-19020 245 33 utterance utterance NOUN bracis-19020 245 34 to to PART bracis-19020 245 35 be be AUX bracis-19020 245 36 any any PRON bracis-19020 245 37 of of ADP bracis-19020 245 38 the the DET bracis-19020 245 39 earlier early ADJ bracis-19020 245 40 moves move NOUN bracis-19020 245 41 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 245 42 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 245 43 ii ii NOUN bracis-19020 245 44 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 245 45 the the DET bracis-19020 245 46 second second ADJ bracis-19020 245 47 one one NOUN bracis-19020 245 48 is be AUX bracis-19020 245 49 extending extend VERB bracis-19020 245 50 the the DET bracis-19020 245 51 protocol protocol NOUN bracis-19020 245 52 for for ADP bracis-19020 245 53 more more ADJ bracis-19020 245 54 than than ADP bracis-19020 245 55 two two NUM bracis-19020 245 56 agents agent NOUN bracis-19020 245 57 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 245 58 which which PRON bracis-19020 245 59 also also ADV bracis-19020 245 60 has have VERB bracis-19020 245 61 consequences consequence NOUN bracis-19020 245 62 on on ADP bracis-19020 245 63 the the DET bracis-19020 245 64 possible possible ADJ bracis-19020 245 65 attacks attack NOUN bracis-19020 245 66 for for ADP bracis-19020 245 67 arguments argument NOUN bracis-19020 245 68 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 246 1 notes note VERB bracis-19020 246 2 1.a 1.a NUM bracis-19020 246 3 literal literal NOUN bracis-19020 246 4 is be AUX bracis-19020 246 5 either either CCONJ bracis-19020 246 6 an an DET bracis-19020 246 7 atomic atomic ADJ bracis-19020 246 8 formula formula NOUN bracis-19020 246 9 or or CCONJ bracis-19020 246 10 the the DET bracis-19020 246 11 negation negation NOUN bracis-19020 246 12 of of ADP bracis-19020 246 13 an an DET bracis-19020 246 14 atomic atomic ADJ bracis-19020 246 15 formula formula NOUN bracis-19020 246 16 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 247 1 when when SCONJ bracis-19020 247 2 a a DET bracis-19020 247 3 literal literal NOUN bracis-19020 247 4 is be AUX bracis-19020 247 5 an an DET bracis-19020 247 6 atomic atomic ADJ bracis-19020 247 7 formula formula NOUN bracis-19020 247 8 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 247 9 we we PRON bracis-19020 247 10 say say VERB bracis-19020 247 11 that that SCONJ bracis-19020 247 12 it it PRON bracis-19020 247 13 is be AUX bracis-19020 247 14 a a DET bracis-19020 247 15 positive positive ADJ bracis-19020 247 16 literal literal NOUN bracis-19020 247 17 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 247 18 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 247 19 when when SCONJ bracis-19020 247 20 a a DET bracis-19020 247 21 literal literal NOUN bracis-19020 247 22 is be AUX bracis-19020 247 23 the the DET bracis-19020 247 24 negation negation NOUN bracis-19020 247 25 of of ADP bracis-19020 247 26 an an DET bracis-19020 247 27 atomic atomic ADJ bracis-19020 247 28 formula formula NOUN bracis-19020 247 29 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 247 30 we we PRON bracis-19020 247 31 say say VERB bracis-19020 247 32 it it PRON bracis-19020 247 33 is be AUX bracis-19020 247 34 a a DET bracis-19020 247 35 negative negative ADJ bracis-19020 247 36 literal literal NOUN bracis-19020 247 37 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 248 1 2.minimal 2.minimal NUM bracis-19020 248 2 means mean VERB bracis-19020 248 3 that that SCONJ bracis-19020 248 4 there there PRON bracis-19020 248 5 is be VERB bracis-19020 248 6 no no DET bracis-19020 248 7 such such ADJ bracis-19020 248 8 that that PRON bracis-19020 248 9 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 248 10 consistent consistent ADJ bracis-19020 248 11 means mean VERB bracis-19020 248 12 that that SCONJ bracis-19020 248 13 it it PRON bracis-19020 248 14 is be AUX bracis-19020 248 15 not not PART bracis-19020 248 16 the the DET bracis-19020 248 17 case case NOUN bracis-19020 248 18 that that SCONJ bracis-19020 248 19 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 248 20 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 248 21 for for ADP bracis-19020 248 22 any any DET bracis-19020 248 23 h h NOUN bracis-19020 248 24 [ [ X bracis-19020 248 25 15 15 NUM bracis-19020 248 26 ] ] PUNCT bracis-19020 248 27 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 249 1 references reference NOUN bracis-19020 249 2 aknine aknine PROPN bracis-19020 249 3 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 249 4 s. s. PROPN bracis-19020 249 5 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 249 6 pinson pinson PROPN bracis-19020 249 7 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 249 8 s. s. PROPN bracis-19020 249 9 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 249 10 shakun shakun NOUN bracis-19020 249 11 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 249 12 m.f m.f PROPN bracis-19020 249 13 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 249 14 : : PUNCT bracis-19020 250 1 an an DET bracis-19020 250 2 extended extended ADJ bracis-19020 250 3 multi multi ADJ bracis-19020 250 4 - - ADJ bracis-19020 250 5 agent agent ADJ bracis-19020 250 6 negotiation negotiation NOUN bracis-19020 250 7 protocol protocol NOUN bracis-19020 250 8 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 251 1 auton auton PROPN bracis-19020 251 2 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 252 1 agents agent NOUN bracis-19020 252 2 multi multi ADJ bracis-19020 252 3 - - ADJ bracis-19020 252 4 agent agent ADJ bracis-19020 252 5 syst syst NOUN bracis-19020 252 6 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 253 1 8(1 8(1 NOUN bracis-19020 253 2 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 253 3 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 253 4 5–45 5–45 PROPN bracis-19020 253 5 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 253 6 2004 2004 NUM bracis-19020 253 7 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 253 8 article article NOUN bracis-19020 253 9     SPACE bracis-19020 253 10 google google PROPN bracis-19020 253 11 scholar scholar NOUN bracis-19020 253 12     SPACE bracis-19020 253 13 amgoud amgoud NOUN bracis-19020 253 14 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 253 15 l. l. PROPN bracis-19020 253 16 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 253 17 ben ben PROPN bracis-19020 253 18 - - PUNCT bracis-19020 253 19 naim naim PROPN bracis-19020 253 20 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 253 21 j. j. PROPN bracis-19020 253 22 : : PUNCT bracis-19020 253 23 ranking rank VERB bracis-19020 253 24 - - PUNCT bracis-19020 253 25 based base VERB bracis-19020 253 26 semantics semantic NOUN bracis-19020 253 27 for for ADP bracis-19020 253 28 argumentation argumentation NOUN bracis-19020 253 29 frameworks framework NOUN bracis-19020 253 30 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 254 1 in in ADP bracis-19020 254 2 : : PUNCT bracis-19020 254 3 liu liu PROPN bracis-19020 254 4 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 254 5 w. w. PROPN bracis-19020 254 6 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 254 7 subrahmanian subrahmanian PROPN bracis-19020 254 8 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 254 9 v.s. v.s. ADJ bracis-19020 254 10 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 254 11 wijsen wijsen PROPN bracis-19020 254 12 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 254 13 j. j. PROPN bracis-19020 254 14 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 254 15 eds eds PROPN bracis-19020 254 16 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 254 17 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 254 18 sum sum NOUN bracis-19020 254 19 2013 2013 NUM bracis-19020 254 20 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 255 1 lncs lncs PROPN bracis-19020 255 2 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 255 3 lnai lnai ADJ bracis-19020 255 4 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 255 5 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 255 6 vol vol NOUN bracis-19020 255 7 . . PROPN bracis-19020 255 8 8078 8078 NUM bracis-19020 255 9 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 255 10 pp pp ADP bracis-19020 255 11 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 256 1 134–147 134–147 NUM bracis-19020 256 2 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 256 3 springer springer NOUN bracis-19020 256 4 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 256 5 heidelberg heidelberg PROPN bracis-19020 256 6 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 256 7 2013 2013 NUM bracis-19020 256 8 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 256 9 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 257 1 https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-642-40381-1_11 https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-642-40381-1_11 PROPN bracis-19020 257 2 chapter chapter NOUN bracis-19020 257 3     SPACE bracis-19020 257 4 google google PROPN bracis-19020 257 5 scholar scholar NOUN bracis-19020 257 6     SPACE bracis-19020 257 7 amgoud amgoud NOUN bracis-19020 257 8 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 257 9 l. l. PROPN bracis-19020 257 10 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 257 11 parsons parson NOUN bracis-19020 257 12 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 257 13 s. s. PROPN bracis-19020 257 14 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 257 15 maudet maudet NOUN bracis-19020 257 16 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 257 17 n. n. NOUN bracis-19020 257 18 : : PUNCT bracis-19020 258 1 arguments argument NOUN bracis-19020 258 2 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 258 3 dialogue dialogue NOUN bracis-19020 258 4 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 258 5 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 258 6 negotiation negotiation NOUN bracis-19020 258 7 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 259 1 in in ADP bracis-19020 259 2 : : PUNCT bracis-19020 259 3 proceedings proceeding NOUN bracis-19020 259 4 of of ADP bracis-19020 259 5 the the DET bracis-19020 259 6 14th 14th ADJ bracis-19020 259 7 european european ADJ bracis-19020 259 8 conference conference NOUN bracis-19020 259 9 on on ADP bracis-19020 259 10 artificial artificial ADJ bracis-19020 259 11 intelligence intelligence NOUN bracis-19020 259 12 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 259 13 vol vol NOUN bracis-19020 259 14 . . PROPN bracis-19020 259 15 10 10 NUM bracis-19020 259 16 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 259 17 pp pp ADJ bracis-19020 259 18 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 260 1 338–342 338–342 NUM bracis-19020 260 2 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 261 1 ios ios PROPN bracis-19020 261 2 press press NOUN bracis-19020 261 3 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 261 4 2000 2000 NUM bracis-19020 261 5 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 261 6 google google NOUN bracis-19020 261 7 scholar scholar NOUN bracis-19020 261 8     SPACE bracis-19020 261 9 amgoud amgoud NOUN bracis-19020 261 10 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 261 11 l. l. PROPN bracis-19020 261 12 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 261 13 prade prade NOUN bracis-19020 261 14 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 261 15 h. h. NOUN bracis-19020 261 16 : : PUNCT bracis-19020 261 17 threat threat NOUN bracis-19020 261 18 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 261 19 reward reward VERB bracis-19020 261 20 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 261 21 explanatory explanatory ADJ bracis-19020 261 22 arguments argument NOUN bracis-19020 261 23 : : PUNCT bracis-19020 261 24 generation generation NOUN bracis-19020 261 25 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 261 26 evaluation evaluation NOUN bracis-19020 261 27 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 262 1 in in ADP bracis-19020 262 2 : : PUNCT bracis-19020 262 3 proceedings proceeding NOUN bracis-19020 262 4 of of ADP bracis-19020 262 5 the the DET bracis-19020 262 6 ecai ecai PROPN bracis-19020 262 7 workshop workshop NOUN bracis-19020 262 8 on on ADP bracis-19020 262 9 computational computational ADJ bracis-19020 262 10 models model NOUN bracis-19020 262 11 of of ADP bracis-19020 262 12 natural natural ADJ bracis-19020 262 13 argument argument NOUN bracis-19020 262 14 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 262 15 pp pp X bracis-19020 262 16 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 263 1 73–76 73–76 NUM bracis-19020 263 2 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 263 3 2004 2004 NUM bracis-19020 263 4 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 263 5 google google PROPN bracis-19020 263 6 scholar scholar NOUN bracis-19020 263 7     SPACE bracis-19020 263 8 amgoud amgoud NOUN bracis-19020 263 9 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 263 10 l. l. PROPN bracis-19020 263 11 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 263 12 prade prade NOUN bracis-19020 263 13 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 263 14 h. h. NOUN bracis-19020 263 15 : : PUNCT bracis-19020 263 16 formal formal ADJ bracis-19020 263 17 handling handling NOUN bracis-19020 263 18 of of ADP bracis-19020 263 19 threats threat NOUN bracis-19020 263 20 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 263 21 rewards reward NOUN bracis-19020 263 22 in in ADP bracis-19020 263 23 a a DET bracis-19020 263 24 negotiation negotiation NOUN bracis-19020 263 25 dialogue dialogue NOUN bracis-19020 263 26 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 264 1 in in ADP bracis-19020 264 2 : : PUNCT bracis-19020 264 3 proceedings proceeding NOUN bracis-19020 264 4 of of ADP bracis-19020 264 5 the the DET bracis-19020 264 6 fourth fourth ADJ bracis-19020 264 7 international international ADJ bracis-19020 264 8 joint joint ADJ bracis-19020 264 9 conference conference NOUN bracis-19020 264 10 on on ADP bracis-19020 264 11 autonomous autonomous ADJ bracis-19020 264 12 agents agent NOUN bracis-19020 264 13 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 264 14 multiagent multiagent NOUN bracis-19020 264 15 systems system NOUN bracis-19020 264 16 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 264 17 pp pp ADV bracis-19020 264 18 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 265 1 529–536 529–536 NUM bracis-19020 265 2 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 265 3 acm acm PROPN bracis-19020 265 4 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 265 5 2005 2005 NUM bracis-19020 265 6 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 265 7 google google PROPN bracis-19020 265 8 scholar scholar NOUN bracis-19020 265 9     SPACE bracis-19020 265 10 amgoud amgoud NOUN bracis-19020 265 11 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 265 12 l. l. PROPN bracis-19020 265 13 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 265 14 prade prade NOUN bracis-19020 265 15 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 265 16 h. h. NOUN bracis-19020 265 17 : : PUNCT bracis-19020 265 18 handling handle VERB bracis-19020 265 19 threats threat NOUN bracis-19020 265 20 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 265 21 rewards reward NOUN bracis-19020 265 22 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 265 23 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 265 24 explanatory explanatory ADJ bracis-19020 265 25 arguments argument NOUN bracis-19020 265 26 in in ADP bracis-19020 265 27 a a DET bracis-19020 265 28 unified unified ADJ bracis-19020 265 29 setting setting NOUN bracis-19020 265 30 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 266 1 int int NOUN bracis-19020 266 2 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 267 1 j. j. PROPN bracis-19020 267 2 intell intell PROPN bracis-19020 267 3 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 268 1 syst syst PROPN bracis-19020 268 2 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 269 1 20(12 20(12 NUM bracis-19020 269 2 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 269 3 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 269 4 1195–1218 1195–1218 NUM bracis-19020 269 5 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 269 6 2005 2005 NUM bracis-19020 269 7 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 269 8 article article NOUN bracis-19020 269 9     SPACE bracis-19020 269 10 google google PROPN bracis-19020 269 11 scholar scholar NOUN bracis-19020 269 12     SPACE bracis-19020 269 13 amgoud amgoud NOUN bracis-19020 269 14 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 269 15 l. l. PROPN bracis-19020 269 16 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 269 17 prade prade NOUN bracis-19020 269 18 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 269 19 h. h. NOUN bracis-19020 269 20 : : PUNCT bracis-19020 269 21 formal formal ADJ bracis-19020 269 22 handling handling NOUN bracis-19020 269 23 of of ADP bracis-19020 269 24 threats threat NOUN bracis-19020 269 25 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 269 26 rewards reward NOUN bracis-19020 269 27 in in ADP bracis-19020 269 28 a a DET bracis-19020 269 29 negotiation negotiation NOUN bracis-19020 269 30 dialogue dialogue NOUN bracis-19020 269 31 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 270 1 in in ADP bracis-19020 270 2 : : PUNCT bracis-19020 270 3 parsons parson NOUN bracis-19020 270 4 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 270 5 s. s. PROPN bracis-19020 270 6 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 270 7 maudet maudet PROPN bracis-19020 270 8 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 270 9 n. n. NOUN bracis-19020 270 10 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 270 11 moraitis moraitis PROPN bracis-19020 270 12 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 270 13 p. p. PROPN bracis-19020 270 14 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 270 15 rahwan rahwan PROPN bracis-19020 270 16 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 270 17 i. i. PROPN bracis-19020 270 18 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 270 19 eds eds PROPN bracis-19020 270 20 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 270 21 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 270 22 argmas argma VERB bracis-19020 270 23 2005 2005 NUM bracis-19020 270 24 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 271 1 lncs lncs PROPN bracis-19020 271 2 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 271 3 lnai lnai ADJ bracis-19020 271 4 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 271 5 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 271 6 vol vol NOUN bracis-19020 271 7 . . NOUN bracis-19020 271 8 4049 4049 NUM bracis-19020 271 9 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 271 10 pp pp ADJ bracis-19020 271 11 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 272 1 88–103 88–103 NUM bracis-19020 272 2 . . NOUN bracis-19020 272 3 springer springer NOUN bracis-19020 272 4 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 272 5 heidelberg heidelberg PROPN bracis-19020 272 6 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 272 7 2006 2006 NUM bracis-19020 272 8 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 272 9 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 273 1 https://doi.org/10.1007/11794578_6 https://doi.org/10.1007/11794578_6 PROPN bracis-19020 273 2 chapter chapter NOUN bracis-19020 273 3     SPACE bracis-19020 273 4 math math NOUN bracis-19020 273 5     SPACE bracis-19020 273 6 google google PROPN bracis-19020 273 7 scholar scholar NOUN bracis-19020 273 8     SPACE bracis-19020 273 9 belardinelli belardinelli PROPN bracis-19020 273 10 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 273 11 f. f. PROPN bracis-19020 273 12 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 273 13 grossi grossi PROPN bracis-19020 273 14 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 273 15 d. d. PROPN bracis-19020 273 16 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 273 17 maudet maudet NOUN bracis-19020 273 18 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 273 19 n. n. NOUN bracis-19020 273 20 : : PUNCT bracis-19020 273 21 a a DET bracis-19020 273 22 formal formal ADJ bracis-19020 273 23 analysis analysis NOUN bracis-19020 273 24 of of ADP bracis-19020 273 25 dialogues dialogue NOUN bracis-19020 273 26 on on ADP bracis-19020 273 27 infinite infinite ADJ bracis-19020 273 28 argumentation argumentation NOUN bracis-19020 273 29 frameworks framework NOUN bracis-19020 273 30 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 274 1 in in ADP bracis-19020 274 2 : : PUNCT bracis-19020 274 3 24th 24th ADJ bracis-19020 274 4 international international ADJ bracis-19020 274 5 joint joint ADJ bracis-19020 274 6 conference conference NOUN bracis-19020 274 7 on on ADP bracis-19020 274 8 artificial artificial ADJ bracis-19020 274 9 intelligence intelligence NOUN bracis-19020 274 10 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 274 11 ijcai-15 ijcai-15 PROPN bracis-19020 274 12 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 274 13 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 274 14 pp pp ADP bracis-19020 274 15 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 275 1 861–867 861–867 NUM bracis-19020 275 2 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 275 3 2015 2015 NUM bracis-19020 275 4 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 275 5 google google PROPN bracis-19020 275 6 scholar scholar NOUN bracis-19020 275 7     SPACE bracis-19020 275 8 bentahar bentahar PROPN bracis-19020 275 9 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 275 10 j. j. PROPN bracis-19020 275 11 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 275 12 moulin moulin PROPN bracis-19020 275 13 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 275 14 b. b. PROPN bracis-19020 275 15 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 275 16 chaib chaib NOUN bracis-19020 275 17 - - PUNCT bracis-19020 275 18 draa draa NOUN bracis-19020 275 19 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 275 20 b. b. NOUN bracis-19020 275 21 : : PUNCT bracis-19020 275 22 specifying specify VERB bracis-19020 275 23 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 275 24 implementing implement VERB bracis-19020 275 25 a a DET bracis-19020 275 26 persuasion persuasion NOUN bracis-19020 275 27 dialogue dialogue NOUN bracis-19020 275 28 game game NOUN bracis-19020 275 29 using use VERB bracis-19020 275 30 commitments commitment NOUN bracis-19020 275 31 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 275 32 arguments argument NOUN bracis-19020 275 33 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 276 1 in in ADP bracis-19020 276 2 : : PUNCT bracis-19020 276 3 rahwan rahwan PROPN bracis-19020 276 4 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 276 5 i. i. PROPN bracis-19020 276 6 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 276 7 moraïtis moraïtis PROPN bracis-19020 276 8 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 276 9 p. p. NOUN bracis-19020 276 10 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 276 11 reed reed NOUN bracis-19020 276 12 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 276 13 c. c. PROPN bracis-19020 276 14 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 276 15 eds eds PROPN bracis-19020 276 16 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 276 17 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 276 18 argmas argmas PROPN bracis-19020 276 19 2004 2004 NUM bracis-19020 276 20 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 277 1 lncs lncs PROPN bracis-19020 277 2 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 277 3 lnai lnai ADJ bracis-19020 277 4 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 277 5 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 277 6 vol vol NOUN bracis-19020 277 7 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 277 8 3366 3366 NUM bracis-19020 277 9 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 277 10 pp pp ADP bracis-19020 277 11 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 278 1 130–148 130–148 NUM bracis-19020 278 2 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 278 3 springer springer NOUN bracis-19020 278 4 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 278 5 heidelberg heidelberg PROPN bracis-19020 278 6 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 278 7 2005 2005 NUM bracis-19020 278 8 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 278 9 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 279 1 https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-540-32261-0_9 https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-540-32261-0_9 NOUN bracis-19020 279 2 chapter chapter NOUN bracis-19020 279 3     SPACE bracis-19020 279 4 google google PROPN bracis-19020 279 5 scholar scholar NOUN bracis-19020 279 6     SPACE bracis-19020 279 7 boella boella NOUN bracis-19020 279 8 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 279 9 g. g. PROPN bracis-19020 279 10 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 279 11 hulstijn hulstijn NOUN bracis-19020 279 12 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 279 13 j. j. PROPN bracis-19020 279 14 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 279 15 van van PROPN bracis-19020 279 16 der der PROPN bracis-19020 279 17 torre torre PROPN bracis-19020 279 18 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 279 19 l. l. PROPN bracis-19020 279 20 : : PUNCT bracis-19020 279 21 persuasion persuasion NOUN bracis-19020 279 22 strategies strategy NOUN bracis-19020 279 23 in in ADP bracis-19020 279 24 dialogue dialogue NOUN bracis-19020 279 25 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 280 1 in in ADP bracis-19020 280 2 : : PUNCT bracis-19020 280 3 proceedings proceeding NOUN bracis-19020 280 4 of of ADP bracis-19020 280 5 the the DET bracis-19020 280 6 ecai ecai PROPN bracis-19020 280 7 workshop workshop NOUN bracis-19020 280 8 on on ADP bracis-19020 280 9 computational computational ADJ bracis-19020 280 10 models model NOUN bracis-19020 280 11 of of ADP bracis-19020 280 12 natural natural ADJ bracis-19020 280 13 argument argument NOUN bracis-19020 280 14 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 280 15 cmna cmna NOUN bracis-19020 280 16 2004 2004 NUM bracis-19020 280 17 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 280 18 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 280 19 valencia valencia PROPN bracis-19020 280 20 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 280 21 2004 2004 NUM bracis-19020 280 22 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 280 23 google google PROPN bracis-19020 280 24 scholar scholar NOUN bracis-19020 280 25     SPACE bracis-19020 280 26 calvaresi calvaresi NOUN bracis-19020 280 27 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 280 28 d. d. PROPN bracis-19020 280 29 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 280 30 et et PROPN bracis-19020 280 31 al al PROPN bracis-19020 280 32 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 280 33 : : PUNCT bracis-19020 280 34 multi multi ADJ bracis-19020 280 35 - - ADJ bracis-19020 280 36 agent agent ADJ bracis-19020 280 37 systems system NOUN bracis-19020 280 38 ’ ' PUNCT bracis-19020 280 39 negotiation negotiation NOUN bracis-19020 280 40 protocols protocol NOUN bracis-19020 280 41 for for ADP bracis-19020 280 42 cyber cyber NOUN bracis-19020 280 43 - - PUNCT bracis-19020 280 44 physical physical ADJ bracis-19020 280 45 systems system NOUN bracis-19020 280 46 : : PUNCT bracis-19020 280 47 results result VERB bracis-19020 280 48 from from ADP bracis-19020 280 49 a a DET bracis-19020 280 50 systematic systematic ADJ bracis-19020 280 51 literature literature NOUN bracis-19020 280 52 review review NOUN bracis-19020 280 53 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 281 1 in in ADP bracis-19020 281 2 : : PUNCT bracis-19020 281 3 icaart icaart NOUN bracis-19020 281 4 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 281 5 1 1 NUM bracis-19020 281 6 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 281 7 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 281 8 pp pp ADP bracis-19020 281 9 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 282 1 224–235 224–235 NUM bracis-19020 282 2 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 282 3 2018 2018 NUM bracis-19020 282 4 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 282 5 google google PROPN bracis-19020 282 6 scholar scholar NOUN bracis-19020 282 7     SPACE bracis-19020 282 8 dimopoulos dimopoulo NOUN bracis-19020 282 9 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 282 10 y. y. PROPN bracis-19020 282 11 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 282 12 moraitis moraitis PROPN bracis-19020 282 13 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 282 14 p. p. NOUN bracis-19020 282 15 : : PUNCT bracis-19020 282 16 advances advance NOUN bracis-19020 282 17 in in ADP bracis-19020 282 18 argumentation argumentation NOUN bracis-19020 282 19 based base VERB bracis-19020 282 20 negotiation negotiation NOUN bracis-19020 282 21 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 283 1 in in ADP bracis-19020 283 2 : : PUNCT bracis-19020 283 3 negotiation negotiation NOUN bracis-19020 283 4 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 283 5 argumentation argumentation NOUN bracis-19020 283 6 in in ADP bracis-19020 283 7 multi multi ADJ bracis-19020 283 8 - - ADJ bracis-19020 283 9 agent agent ADJ bracis-19020 283 10 systems system NOUN bracis-19020 283 11 : : PUNCT bracis-19020 283 12 fundamentals fundamental NOUN bracis-19020 283 13 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 283 14 theories theory NOUN bracis-19020 283 15 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 283 16 systems system NOUN bracis-19020 283 17 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 283 18 applications application NOUN bracis-19020 283 19 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 283 20 pp pp ADV bracis-19020 283 21 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 284 1 82–125 82–125 NOUN bracis-19020 284 2 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 284 3 2011 2011 NUM bracis-19020 284 4 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 284 5 google google PROPN bracis-19020 284 6 scholar scholar NOUN bracis-19020 284 7     SPACE bracis-19020 284 8 dung dung NOUN bracis-19020 284 9 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 284 10 p.m. p.m. ADV bracis-19020 284 11 : : PUNCT bracis-19020 284 12 on on ADP bracis-19020 284 13 the the DET bracis-19020 284 14 acceptability acceptability NOUN bracis-19020 284 15 of of ADP bracis-19020 284 16 arguments argument NOUN bracis-19020 284 17 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 284 18 its its PRON bracis-19020 284 19 fundamental fundamental ADJ bracis-19020 284 20 role role NOUN bracis-19020 284 21 in in ADP bracis-19020 284 22 nonmonotonic nonmonotonic ADJ bracis-19020 284 23 reasoning reasoning NOUN bracis-19020 284 24 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 284 25 logic logic NOUN bracis-19020 284 26 programming programming NOUN bracis-19020 284 27 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 284 28 n n CCONJ bracis-19020 284 29 - - PUNCT bracis-19020 284 30 person person NOUN bracis-19020 284 31 games game NOUN bracis-19020 284 32 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 285 1 artif artif INTJ bracis-19020 285 2 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 286 1 intell intell PROPN bracis-19020 286 2 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 287 1 77(2 77(2 X bracis-19020 287 2 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 287 3 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 288 1 321–357 321–357 NUM bracis-19020 288 2 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 288 3 1995 1995 NUM bracis-19020 288 4 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 288 5 article article NOUN bracis-19020 288 6     SPACE bracis-19020 288 7 mathscinet mathscinet NOUN bracis-19020 288 8     SPACE bracis-19020 288 9 google google PROPN bracis-19020 288 10 scholar scholar NOUN bracis-19020 288 11     SPACE bracis-19020 288 12 heras hera NOUN bracis-19020 288 13 barberá barberá NOUN bracis-19020 288 14 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 288 15 s.m s.m PROPN bracis-19020 288 16 . . PROPN bracis-19020 288 17 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 288 18 botti botti PROPN bracis-19020 288 19 navarro navarro PROPN bracis-19020 288 20 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 288 21 v.j v.j PROPN bracis-19020 288 22 . . PROPN bracis-19020 288 23 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 288 24 julian julian PROPN bracis-19020 288 25 inglada inglada PROPN bracis-19020 288 26 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 288 27 v.j v.j PROPN bracis-19020 288 28 . . PROPN bracis-19020 288 29 : : PUNCT bracis-19020 288 30 case case NOUN bracis-19020 288 31 - - PUNCT bracis-19020 288 32 based base VERB bracis-19020 288 33 argumentation argumentation NOUN bracis-19020 288 34 framework framework NOUN bracis-19020 288 35 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 289 1 dialogue dialogue NOUN bracis-19020 289 2 protocol protocol PROPN bracis-19020 289 3 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 289 4 2011 2011 NUM bracis-19020 289 5 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 289 6 google google NOUN bracis-19020 289 7 scholar scholar NOUN bracis-19020 289 8     SPACE bracis-19020 289 9 hunter hunter NOUN bracis-19020 289 10 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 289 11 a. a. NOUN bracis-19020 289 12 : : PUNCT bracis-19020 289 13 base base NOUN bracis-19020 289 14 logics logic NOUN bracis-19020 289 15 in in ADP bracis-19020 289 16 argumentation argumentation NOUN bracis-19020 289 17 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 290 1 in in ADP bracis-19020 290 2 : : PUNCT bracis-19020 290 3 comma comma NOUN bracis-19020 290 4 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 290 5 pp pp ADJ bracis-19020 290 6 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 291 1 275–286 275–286 NUM bracis-19020 291 2 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 291 3 2010 2010 NUM bracis-19020 291 4 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 291 5 google google PROPN bracis-19020 291 6 scholar scholar NOUN bracis-19020 291 7     SPACE bracis-19020 291 8 ito ito PROPN bracis-19020 291 9 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 291 10 t. t. PROPN bracis-19020 291 11 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 291 12 klein klein PROPN bracis-19020 291 13 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 291 14 m. m. NOUN bracis-19020 291 15 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 291 16 hattori hattori PROPN bracis-19020 291 17 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 291 18 h. h. PROPN bracis-19020 291 19 : : PUNCT bracis-19020 291 20 a a DET bracis-19020 291 21 multi multi ADJ bracis-19020 291 22 - - ADJ bracis-19020 291 23 issue issue NOUN bracis-19020 291 24 negotiation negotiation NOUN bracis-19020 291 25 protocol protocol NOUN bracis-19020 291 26 among among ADP bracis-19020 291 27 agents agent NOUN bracis-19020 291 28 with with ADP bracis-19020 291 29 nonlinear nonlinear ADJ bracis-19020 291 30 utility utility NOUN bracis-19020 291 31 functions function NOUN bracis-19020 291 32 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 292 1 multiagent multiagent PROPN bracis-19020 292 2 grid grid PROPN bracis-19020 292 3 syst syst PROPN bracis-19020 292 4 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 293 1 4(1 4(1 NOUN bracis-19020 293 2 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 294 1 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 294 2 67–83 67–83 NUM bracis-19020 294 3 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 294 4 2008 2008 NUM bracis-19020 294 5 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 294 6 article article NOUN bracis-19020 294 7     SPACE bracis-19020 294 8 google google PROPN bracis-19020 294 9 scholar scholar NOUN bracis-19020 294 10     SPACE bracis-19020 294 11 letia letia PROPN bracis-19020 294 12 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 294 13 i.a i.a PROPN bracis-19020 294 14 . . PROPN bracis-19020 294 15 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 294 16 vartic vartic PROPN bracis-19020 294 17 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 294 18 r. r. PROPN bracis-19020 294 19 : : PUNCT bracis-19020 294 20 defeasible defeasible ADJ bracis-19020 294 21 protocols protocol NOUN bracis-19020 294 22 in in ADP bracis-19020 294 23 persuasion persuasion NOUN bracis-19020 294 24 dialogues dialogue NOUN bracis-19020 294 25 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 295 1 in in ADP bracis-19020 295 2 : : PUNCT bracis-19020 295 3 proceedings proceeding NOUN bracis-19020 295 4 of of ADP bracis-19020 295 5 the the DET bracis-19020 295 6 2006 2006 NUM bracis-19020 295 7 ieee ieee NOUN bracis-19020 295 8 / / SYM bracis-19020 295 9 wic wic PROPN bracis-19020 295 10 / / SYM bracis-19020 295 11 acm acm PROPN bracis-19020 295 12 international international ADJ bracis-19020 295 13 conference conference NOUN bracis-19020 295 14 on on ADP bracis-19020 295 15 web web NOUN bracis-19020 295 16 intelligence intelligence NOUN bracis-19020 295 17 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 295 18 intelligent intelligent ADJ bracis-19020 295 19 agent agent NOUN bracis-19020 295 20 technology technology NOUN bracis-19020 295 21 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 295 22 pp pp ADJ bracis-19020 295 23 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 296 1 359–362 359–362 NUM bracis-19020 296 2 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 297 1 ieee ieee NOUN bracis-19020 297 2 computer computer NOUN bracis-19020 297 3 society society NOUN bracis-19020 297 4 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 297 5 2006 2006 NUM bracis-19020 297 6 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 297 7 google google PROPN bracis-19020 297 8 scholar scholar NOUN bracis-19020 297 9     SPACE bracis-19020 297 10 mcburney mcburney NOUN bracis-19020 297 11 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 297 12 p. p. PROPN bracis-19020 297 13 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 297 14 parsons parson NOUN bracis-19020 297 15 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 297 16 s. s. PROPN bracis-19020 297 17 : : PUNCT bracis-19020 297 18 dialogue dialogue NOUN bracis-19020 297 19 games game NOUN bracis-19020 297 20 for for ADP bracis-19020 297 21 agent agent NOUN bracis-19020 297 22 argumentation argumentation NOUN bracis-19020 297 23 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 298 1 in in ADP bracis-19020 298 2 : : PUNCT bracis-19020 298 3 simari simari PROPN bracis-19020 298 4 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 298 5 g. g. PROPN bracis-19020 298 6 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 298 7 rahwan rahwan PROPN bracis-19020 298 8 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 298 9 i. i. PROPN bracis-19020 298 10 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 298 11 eds eds PROPN bracis-19020 298 12 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 298 13 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 299 1 argumentation argumentation NOUN bracis-19020 299 2 in in ADP bracis-19020 299 3 artificial artificial ADJ bracis-19020 299 4 intelligence intelligence NOUN bracis-19020 299 5 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 299 6 pp pp ADV bracis-19020 299 7 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 300 1 261–280 261–280 NUM bracis-19020 300 2 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 300 3 springer springer NOUN bracis-19020 300 4 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 300 5 boston boston PROPN bracis-19020 300 6 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 300 7 2009 2009 NUM bracis-19020 300 8 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 300 9 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 301 1 https://doi.org/10.1007/978-0-387-98197-0_13 https://doi.org/10.1007/978-0-387-98197-0_13 NOUN bracis-19020 301 2 modgil modgil NOUN bracis-19020 301 3 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 301 4 s. s. PROPN bracis-19020 301 5 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 301 6 prakken prakken VERB bracis-19020 301 7 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 301 8 h. h. PROPN bracis-19020 301 9 : : PUNCT bracis-19020 301 10 the the DET bracis-19020 301 11 aspic+ aspic+ ADJ bracis-19020 301 12 framework framework NOUN bracis-19020 301 13 for for ADP bracis-19020 301 14 structured structured ADJ bracis-19020 301 15 argumentation argumentation NOUN bracis-19020 301 16 : : PUNCT bracis-19020 301 17 a a DET bracis-19020 301 18 tutorial tutorial NOUN bracis-19020 301 19 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 302 1 argument argument NOUN bracis-19020 302 2 comput comput NOUN bracis-19020 302 3 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 303 1 5(1 5(1 NUM bracis-19020 303 2 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 303 3 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 303 4 31–62 31–62 NUM bracis-19020 303 5 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 303 6 2014 2014 NUM bracis-19020 303 7 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 303 8 article article NOUN bracis-19020 303 9     SPACE bracis-19020 303 10 google google PROPN bracis-19020 303 11 scholar scholar NOUN bracis-19020 303 12     SPACE bracis-19020 303 13 morveli morveli PROPN bracis-19020 303 14 - - PUNCT bracis-19020 303 15 espinoza espinoza PROPN bracis-19020 303 16 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 303 17 m. m. NOUN bracis-19020 303 18 : : PUNCT bracis-19020 303 19 persuasive persuasive ADJ bracis-19020 303 20 negotiation negotiation NOUN bracis-19020 303 21 dialogues dialogue NOUN bracis-19020 303 22 using use VERB bracis-19020 303 23 rhetorical rhetorical ADJ bracis-19020 303 24 arguments argument NOUN bracis-19020 303 25 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 304 1 in in ADP bracis-19020 304 2 : : PUNCT bracis-19020 304 3 proceedings proceeding NOUN bracis-19020 304 4 of of ADP bracis-19020 304 5 the the DET bracis-19020 304 6 16th 16th ADJ bracis-19020 304 7 conference conference NOUN bracis-19020 304 8 on on ADP bracis-19020 304 9 autonomous autonomous ADJ bracis-19020 304 10 agents agent NOUN bracis-19020 304 11 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 304 12 multiagent multiagent NOUN bracis-19020 304 13 systems system NOUN bracis-19020 304 14 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 304 15 aamas aamas PROPN bracis-19020 304 16 2017 2017 NUM bracis-19020 304 17 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 304 18 pp pp ADJ bracis-19020 304 19 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 304 20 1845–1846 1845–1846 NUM bracis-19020 304 21 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 305 1 international international ADJ bracis-19020 305 2 foundation foundation PROPN bracis-19020 305 3 for for ADP bracis-19020 305 4 autonomous autonomous ADJ bracis-19020 305 5 agents agent NOUN bracis-19020 305 6 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 305 7 multiagent multiagent NOUN bracis-19020 305 8 systems system NOUN bracis-19020 305 9 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 305 10 2017 2017 NUM bracis-19020 305 11 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 305 12 google google NOUN bracis-19020 305 13 scholar scholar NOUN bracis-19020 305 14     SPACE bracis-19020 305 15 morveli morveli PROPN bracis-19020 305 16 - - PUNCT bracis-19020 305 17 espinoza espinoza PROPN bracis-19020 305 18 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 305 19 m. m. NOUN bracis-19020 305 20 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 305 21 nieves nieve NOUN bracis-19020 305 22 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 305 23 j.c j.c PROPN bracis-19020 305 24 . . PROPN bracis-19020 305 25 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 305 26 tacla tacla ADJ bracis-19020 305 27 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 305 28 c.a c.a PROPN bracis-19020 305 29 . . PROPN bracis-19020 305 30 : : PUNCT bracis-19020 305 31 measuring measure VERB bracis-19020 305 32 the the DET bracis-19020 305 33 strength strength NOUN bracis-19020 305 34 of of ADP bracis-19020 305 35 threats threat NOUN bracis-19020 305 36 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 305 37 rewards reward NOUN bracis-19020 305 38 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 305 39 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 305 40 appeals appeal NOUN bracis-19020 305 41 in in ADP bracis-19020 305 42 persuasive persuasive ADJ bracis-19020 305 43 negotiation negotiation NOUN bracis-19020 305 44 dialogues dialogue NOUN bracis-19020 305 45 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 306 1 knowl knowl PROPN bracis-19020 306 2 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 307 1 eng eng PROPN bracis-19020 307 2 . . PROPN bracis-19020 307 3 rev rev PROPN bracis-19020 307 4 . . PROPN bracis-19020 307 5 35 35 NUM bracis-19020 307 6 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 307 7 1–27 1–27 NUM bracis-19020 307 8 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 307 9 2020 2020 NUM bracis-19020 307 10 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 307 11 article article NOUN bracis-19020 307 12     SPACE bracis-19020 307 13 google google PROPN bracis-19020 307 14 scholar scholar NOUN bracis-19020 307 15     SPACE bracis-19020 307 16 morveli morveli PROPN bracis-19020 307 17     SPACE bracis-19020 307 18 espinoza espinoza PROPN bracis-19020 307 19 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 307 20 m. m. NOUN bracis-19020 307 21 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 307 22 possebom possebom ADJ bracis-19020 307 23 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 307 24 a.t a.t PROPN bracis-19020 307 25 . . PROPN bracis-19020 307 26 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 307 27 tacla tacla ADJ bracis-19020 307 28 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 307 29 c.a c.a PROPN bracis-19020 307 30 . . PROPN bracis-19020 307 31 : : PUNCT bracis-19020 307 32 on on ADP bracis-19020 307 33 the the DET bracis-19020 307 34 calculation calculation NOUN bracis-19020 307 35 of of ADP bracis-19020 307 36 the the DET bracis-19020 307 37 strength strength NOUN bracis-19020 307 38 of of ADP bracis-19020 307 39 threats threat NOUN bracis-19020 307 40 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 308 1 knowl knowl PROPN bracis-19020 308 2 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 309 1 inf inf PROPN bracis-19020 309 2 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 309 3 syst syst PROPN bracis-19020 309 4 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 310 1 62(4 62(4 NUM bracis-19020 310 2 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 310 3 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 310 4 1511–1538 1511–1538 NUM bracis-19020 310 5 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 310 6 2019 2019 NUM bracis-19020 310 7 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 310 8 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 311 1 https://doi.org/10.1007/s10115-019-01399-2 https://doi.org/10.1007/s10115-019-01399-2 PROPN bracis-19020 311 2 article article PROPN bracis-19020 311 3     SPACE bracis-19020 311 4 google google PROPN bracis-19020 311 5 scholar scholar NOUN bracis-19020 311 6     SPACE bracis-19020 311 7 perrussel perrussel NOUN bracis-19020 311 8 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 311 9 l. l. PROPN bracis-19020 311 10 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 311 11 doutre doutre PROPN bracis-19020 311 12 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 311 13 s. s. PROPN bracis-19020 311 14 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 311 15 thévenin thévenin PROPN bracis-19020 311 16 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 311 17 j.-m j.-m PROPN bracis-19020 311 18 . . PROPN bracis-19020 311 19 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 311 20 mcburney mcburney PROPN bracis-19020 311 21 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 311 22 p. p. NOUN bracis-19020 311 23 : : PUNCT bracis-19020 311 24 a a DET bracis-19020 311 25 persuasion persuasion NOUN bracis-19020 311 26 dialog dialog NOUN bracis-19020 311 27 for for ADP bracis-19020 311 28 gaining gain VERB bracis-19020 311 29 access access NOUN bracis-19020 311 30 to to ADP bracis-19020 311 31 information information NOUN bracis-19020 311 32 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 312 1 in in ADP bracis-19020 312 2 : : PUNCT bracis-19020 312 3 rahwan rahwan PROPN bracis-19020 312 4 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 312 5 i. i. PROPN bracis-19020 312 6 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 312 7 parsons parson NOUN bracis-19020 312 8 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 312 9 s. s. PROPN bracis-19020 312 10 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 312 11 reed reed PROPN bracis-19020 312 12 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 312 13 c. c. PROPN bracis-19020 312 14 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 312 15 eds eds PROPN bracis-19020 312 16 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 312 17 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 312 18 argmas argma VERB bracis-19020 312 19 2007 2007 NUM bracis-19020 312 20 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 313 1 lncs lncs PROPN bracis-19020 313 2 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 313 3 lnai lnai ADJ bracis-19020 313 4 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 313 5 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 313 6 vol vol NOUN bracis-19020 313 7 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 313 8 4946 4946 NUM bracis-19020 313 9 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 313 10 pp pp ADV bracis-19020 313 11 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 314 1 63–79 63–79 NUM bracis-19020 314 2 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 315 1 springer springer NOUN bracis-19020 315 2 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 315 3 heidelberg heidelberg PROPN bracis-19020 315 4 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 315 5 2008 2008 NUM bracis-19020 315 6 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 315 7 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 316 1 https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-540-78915-4_5 https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-540-78915-4_5 PROPN bracis-19020 316 2 chapter chapter NOUN bracis-19020 316 3     SPACE bracis-19020 316 4 google google PROPN bracis-19020 316 5 scholar scholar NOUN bracis-19020 316 6     SPACE bracis-19020 316 7 prakken prakken VERB bracis-19020 316 8 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 316 9 h. h. NOUN bracis-19020 316 10 : : PUNCT bracis-19020 316 11 coherence coherence NOUN bracis-19020 316 12 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 316 13 flexibility flexibility NOUN bracis-19020 316 14 in in ADP bracis-19020 316 15 dialogue dialogue NOUN bracis-19020 316 16 games game NOUN bracis-19020 316 17 for for ADP bracis-19020 316 18 argumentation argumentation NOUN bracis-19020 316 19 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 317 1 j. j. PROPN bracis-19020 317 2 logic logic PROPN bracis-19020 317 3 comput comput PROPN bracis-19020 317 4 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 318 1 15(6 15(6 X bracis-19020 318 2 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 318 3 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 318 4 1009–1040 1009–1040 NUM bracis-19020 318 5 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 318 6 2005 2005 NUM bracis-19020 318 7 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 318 8 article article NOUN bracis-19020 318 9     SPACE bracis-19020 318 10 mathscinet mathscinet NOUN bracis-19020 318 11     SPACE bracis-19020 318 12 google google PROPN bracis-19020 318 13 scholar scholar NOUN bracis-19020 318 14     SPACE bracis-19020 318 15 prakken prakken VERB bracis-19020 318 16 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 318 17 h. h. NOUN bracis-19020 318 18 : : PUNCT bracis-19020 318 19 models model NOUN bracis-19020 318 20 of of ADP bracis-19020 318 21 persuasion persuasion NOUN bracis-19020 318 22 dialogue dialogue NOUN bracis-19020 318 23 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 319 1 in in ADP bracis-19020 319 2 : : PUNCT bracis-19020 319 3 argumentation argumentation NOUN bracis-19020 319 4 in in ADP bracis-19020 319 5 artificial artificial ADJ bracis-19020 319 6 intelligence intelligence NOUN bracis-19020 319 7 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 319 8 pp pp ADJ bracis-19020 319 9 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 320 1 281–300 281–300 NUM bracis-19020 320 2 . . X bracis-19020 320 3 springer springer NOUN bracis-19020 320 4 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 320 5 boston boston PROPN bracis-19020 320 6 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 320 7 2009 2009 NUM bracis-19020 320 8 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 320 9 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 321 1 https://doi.org/10.1007/978-0-387-98197-0_14 https://doi.org/10.1007/978-0-387-98197-0_14 NOUN bracis-19020 321 2 rahwan rahwan NOUN bracis-19020 321 3 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 321 4 i. i. PROPN bracis-19020 321 5 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 321 6 ramchurn ramchurn NOUN bracis-19020 321 7 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 321 8 s.d s.d PROPN bracis-19020 321 9 . . PROPN bracis-19020 321 10 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 321 11 jennings jennings PROPN bracis-19020 321 12 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 321 13 n.r n.r PROPN bracis-19020 321 14 . . PROPN bracis-19020 321 15 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 321 16 mcburney mcburney PROPN bracis-19020 321 17 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 321 18 p. p. PROPN bracis-19020 321 19 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 321 20 parsons parson NOUN bracis-19020 321 21 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 321 22 s. s. PROPN bracis-19020 321 23 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 321 24 sonenberg sonenberg PROPN bracis-19020 321 25 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 321 26 l. l. PROPN bracis-19020 321 27 : : PUNCT bracis-19020 321 28 argumentation argumentation NOUN bracis-19020 321 29 - - PUNCT bracis-19020 321 30 based base VERB bracis-19020 321 31 negotiation negotiation NOUN bracis-19020 321 32 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 322 1 knowl knowl PROPN bracis-19020 322 2 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 323 1 eng eng PROPN bracis-19020 323 2 . . PROPN bracis-19020 323 3 rev rev PROPN bracis-19020 323 4 . . PROPN bracis-19020 323 5 18(04 18(04 NUM bracis-19020 323 6 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 323 7 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 323 8 343–375 343–375 NUM bracis-19020 323 9 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 323 10 2003 2003 NUM bracis-19020 323 11 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 323 12 article article NOUN bracis-19020 323 13     SPACE bracis-19020 323 14 google google PROPN bracis-19020 323 15 scholar scholar NOUN bracis-19020 323 16     SPACE bracis-19020 323 17 ramchurn ramchurn NOUN bracis-19020 323 18 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 323 19 s.d s.d PROPN bracis-19020 323 20 . . PROPN bracis-19020 323 21 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 323 22 jennings jennings PROPN bracis-19020 323 23 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 323 24 n.r n.r PROPN bracis-19020 323 25 . . PROPN bracis-19020 323 26 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 323 27 sierra sierra PROPN bracis-19020 323 28 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 323 29 c. c. PROPN bracis-19020 323 30 : : PUNCT bracis-19020 323 31 persuasive persuasive ADJ bracis-19020 323 32 negotiation negotiation NOUN bracis-19020 323 33 for for ADP bracis-19020 323 34 autonomous autonomous ADJ bracis-19020 323 35 agents agent NOUN bracis-19020 323 36 : : PUNCT bracis-19020 323 37 a a DET bracis-19020 323 38 rhetorical rhetorical ADJ bracis-19020 323 39 approach approach NOUN bracis-19020 323 40 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 323 41 2003 2003 NUM bracis-19020 323 42 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 323 43 google google PROPN bracis-19020 323 44 scholar scholar NOUN bracis-19020 323 45     SPACE bracis-19020 323 46 saha saha NOUN bracis-19020 323 47 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 323 48 s. s. PROPN bracis-19020 323 49 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 323 50 sen sen PROPN bracis-19020 323 51 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 323 52 s. s. PROPN bracis-19020 323 53 : : PUNCT bracis-19020 323 54 an an DET bracis-19020 323 55 efficient efficient ADJ bracis-19020 323 56 protocol protocol NOUN bracis-19020 323 57 for for ADP bracis-19020 323 58 negotiation negotiation NOUN bracis-19020 323 59 over over ADP bracis-19020 323 60 multiple multiple ADJ bracis-19020 323 61 indivisible indivisible ADJ bracis-19020 323 62 resources resource NOUN bracis-19020 323 63 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 324 1 in in ADP bracis-19020 324 2 : : PUNCT bracis-19020 324 3 ijcai ijcai NOUN bracis-19020 324 4 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 324 5 vol vol NOUN bracis-19020 324 6 . . PROPN bracis-19020 324 7 7 7 NUM bracis-19020 324 8 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 324 9 pp pp ADJ bracis-19020 324 10 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 325 1 1494–1499 1494–1499 NUM bracis-19020 325 2 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 325 3 2007 2007 NUM bracis-19020 325 4 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 325 5 google google PROPN bracis-19020 325 6 scholar scholar NOUN bracis-19020 325 7     SPACE bracis-19020 325 8 sierra sierra PROPN bracis-19020 325 9 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 325 10 c. c. PROPN bracis-19020 325 11 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 325 12 jennings jennings PROPN bracis-19020 325 13 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 325 14 n.r n.r PROPN bracis-19020 325 15 . . PROPN bracis-19020 325 16 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 325 17 noriega noriega PROPN bracis-19020 325 18 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 325 19 p. p. PROPN bracis-19020 325 20 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 325 21 parsons parson NOUN bracis-19020 325 22 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 325 23 s. s. PROPN bracis-19020 325 24 : : PUNCT bracis-19020 325 25 a a DET bracis-19020 325 26 framework framework NOUN bracis-19020 325 27 for for ADP bracis-19020 325 28 argumentation argumentation NOUN bracis-19020 325 29 - - PUNCT bracis-19020 325 30 based base VERB bracis-19020 325 31 negotiation negotiation NOUN bracis-19020 325 32 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 326 1 in in ADP bracis-19020 326 2 : : PUNCT bracis-19020 326 3 singh singh PROPN bracis-19020 326 4 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 326 5 m.p m.p PROPN bracis-19020 326 6 . . PROPN bracis-19020 326 7 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 326 8 rao rao PROPN bracis-19020 326 9 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 326 10 a. a. PROPN bracis-19020 326 11 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 326 12 wooldridge wooldridge PROPN bracis-19020 326 13 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 326 14 m.j m.j PROPN bracis-19020 326 15 . . PROPN bracis-19020 326 16 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 326 17 eds ed NOUN bracis-19020 326 18 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 326 19 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 327 1 atal atal ADJ bracis-19020 327 2 1997 1997 NUM bracis-19020 327 3 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 328 1 lncs lncs PROPN bracis-19020 328 2 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 328 3 vol vol NOUN bracis-19020 328 4 . . NOUN bracis-19020 328 5 1365 1365 NUM bracis-19020 328 6 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 328 7 pp pp ADJ bracis-19020 328 8 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 329 1 177–192 177–192 NUM bracis-19020 329 2 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 329 3 springer springer NOUN bracis-19020 329 4 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 329 5 heidelberg heidelberg PROPN bracis-19020 329 6 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 329 7 1998 1998 NUM bracis-19020 329 8 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 329 9 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 330 1 https://doi.org/10.1007/bfb0026758 https://doi.org/10.1007/bfb0026758 PROPN bracis-19020 330 2 chapter chapter NOUN bracis-19020 330 3     SPACE bracis-19020 330 4 google google PROPN bracis-19020 330 5 scholar scholar NOUN bracis-19020 330 6     SPACE bracis-19020 330 7 van van PROPN bracis-19020 330 8 veenen veenen PROPN bracis-19020 330 9 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 330 10 j. j. PROPN bracis-19020 330 11 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 330 12 prakken prakken VERB bracis-19020 330 13 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 330 14 h. h. PROPN bracis-19020 330 15 : : PUNCT bracis-19020 330 16 a a DET bracis-19020 330 17 protocol protocol NOUN bracis-19020 330 18 for for ADP bracis-19020 330 19 arguing argue VERB bracis-19020 330 20 about about ADP bracis-19020 330 21 rejections rejection NOUN bracis-19020 330 22 in in ADP bracis-19020 330 23 negotiation negotiation NOUN bracis-19020 330 24 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 331 1 in in ADP bracis-19020 331 2 : : PUNCT bracis-19020 331 3 parsons parson NOUN bracis-19020 331 4 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 331 5 s. s. PROPN bracis-19020 331 6 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 331 7 maudet maudet PROPN bracis-19020 331 8 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 331 9 n. n. NOUN bracis-19020 331 10 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 331 11 moraitis moraitis PROPN bracis-19020 331 12 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 331 13 p. p. PROPN bracis-19020 331 14 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 331 15 rahwan rahwan PROPN bracis-19020 331 16 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 331 17 i. i. PROPN bracis-19020 331 18 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 331 19 eds eds PROPN bracis-19020 331 20 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 331 21 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 331 22 argmas argma VERB bracis-19020 331 23 2005 2005 NUM bracis-19020 331 24 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 332 1 lncs lncs PROPN bracis-19020 332 2 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 332 3 lnai lnai ADJ bracis-19020 332 4 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 332 5 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 332 6 vol vol NOUN bracis-19020 332 7 . . NOUN bracis-19020 332 8 4049 4049 NUM bracis-19020 332 9 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 332 10 pp pp ADJ bracis-19020 332 11 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 333 1 138–153 138–153 NUM bracis-19020 333 2 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 333 3 springer springer NOUN bracis-19020 333 4 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 333 5 heidelberg heidelberg PROPN bracis-19020 333 6 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 333 7 2006 2006 NUM bracis-19020 333 8 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 333 9 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 334 1 https://doi.org/10.1007/11794578_9 https://doi.org/10.1007/11794578_9 VERB bracis-19020 334 2 chapter chapter NOUN bracis-19020 334 3     SPACE bracis-19020 334 4 math math NOUN bracis-19020 334 5     SPACE bracis-19020 334 6 google google PROPN bracis-19020 334 7 scholar scholar NOUN bracis-19020 334 8     SPACE bracis-19020 334 9 wang wang PROPN bracis-19020 334 10 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 334 11 g. g. PROPN bracis-19020 334 12 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 334 13 wong wong PROPN bracis-19020 334 14 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 334 15 t. t. PROPN bracis-19020 334 16 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 334 17 wang wang PROPN bracis-19020 334 18 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 334 19 x. x. PROPN bracis-19020 334 20 : : PUNCT bracis-19020 334 21 a a DET bracis-19020 334 22 negotiation negotiation NOUN bracis-19020 334 23 protocol protocol NOUN bracis-19020 334 24 to to PART bracis-19020 334 25 support support VERB bracis-19020 334 26 agent agent NOUN bracis-19020 334 27 argumentation argumentation NOUN bracis-19020 334 28 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 334 29 ontology ontology NOUN bracis-19020 334 30 interoperability interoperability NOUN bracis-19020 334 31 in in ADP bracis-19020 334 32 mas mas PROPN bracis-19020 334 33 - - PUNCT bracis-19020 334 34 based base VERB bracis-19020 334 35 virtual virtual ADJ bracis-19020 334 36 enterprises enterprise NOUN bracis-19020 334 37 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 335 1 in in ADP bracis-19020 335 2 : : PUNCT bracis-19020 335 3 2010 2010 NUM bracis-19020 335 4 seventh seventh ADJ bracis-19020 335 5 international international ADJ bracis-19020 335 6 conference conference NOUN bracis-19020 335 7 on on ADP bracis-19020 335 8 information information NOUN bracis-19020 335 9 technology technology NOUN bracis-19020 335 10 : : PUNCT bracis-19020 335 11 new new ADJ bracis-19020 335 12 generations generation NOUN bracis-19020 335 13 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 335 14 itng itng ADJ bracis-19020 335 15 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 335 16 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 335 17 pp pp ADJ bracis-19020 335 18 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 336 1 448–453 448–453 NUM bracis-19020 336 2 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 337 1 ieee ieee NOUN bracis-19020 337 2 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 337 3 2010 2010 NUM bracis-19020 337 4 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 337 5 google google PROPN bracis-19020 337 6 scholar scholar NOUN bracis-19020 337 7     SPACE bracis-19020 337 8 download download NOUN bracis-19020 337 9 references reference NOUN bracis-19020 337 10 author author NOUN bracis-19020 337 11 information information NOUN bracis-19020 337 12 authors author NOUN bracis-19020 337 13 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 337 14 affiliations affiliation NOUN bracis-19020 337 15 program program NOUN bracis-19020 337 16 in in ADP bracis-19020 337 17 electrical electrical ADJ bracis-19020 337 18 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 337 19 computer computer NOUN bracis-19020 337 20 engineering engineering NOUN bracis-19020 337 21 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 337 22 cpgei cpgei PROPN bracis-19020 337 23 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 337 24 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 337 25 federal federal ADJ bracis-19020 337 26 university university NOUN bracis-19020 337 27 of of ADP bracis-19020 337 28 technology technology NOUN bracis-19020 337 29 of of ADP bracis-19020 337 30 parana parana PROPN bracis-19020 337 31 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 337 32 utfpr utfpr PROPN bracis-19020 337 33 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 337 34 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 337 35 curitiba curitiba PROPN bracis-19020 337 36 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 337 37 brazil brazil PROPN bracis-19020 337 38 mariela mariela PROPN bracis-19020 337 39 morveli morveli PROPN bracis-19020 337 40 - - PUNCT bracis-19020 337 41 espinoza espinoza PROPN bracis-19020 337 42     SPACE bracis-19020 337 43 & & CCONJ bracis-19020 337 44     SPACE bracis-19020 337 45 cesar cesar PROPN bracis-19020 337 46 augusto augusto PROPN bracis-19020 337 47 tacla tacla PROPN bracis-19020 337 48 paraná paraná PROPN bracis-19020 337 49 federal federal PROPN bracis-19020 337 50 institute institute PROPN bracis-19020 337 51 of of ADP bracis-19020 337 52 education education PROPN bracis-19020 337 53 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 337 54 science science NOUN bracis-19020 337 55 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 337 56 technology technology NOUN bracis-19020 337 57 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 337 58 ifpr ifpr NOUN bracis-19020 337 59 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 337 60 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 337 61 paranavai paranavai NOUN bracis-19020 337 62 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 337 63 brazil brazil PROPN bracis-19020 337 64 ayslan ayslan PROPN bracis-19020 337 65 possebom possebom PROPN bracis-19020 337 66 authors author NOUN bracis-19020 337 67 mariela mariela PROPN bracis-19020 337 68 morveli morveli PROPN bracis-19020 337 69 - - PUNCT bracis-19020 337 70 espinozaview espinozaview NOUN bracis-19020 337 71 author author NOUN bracis-19020 337 72 publications publication NOUN bracis-19020 337 73 search search NOUN bracis-19020 337 74 author author NOUN bracis-19020 337 75 on on ADP bracis-19020 337 76 : : PUNCT bracis-19020 337 77 pubmed pubmed PROPN bracis-19020 337 78     SPACE bracis-19020 337 79 google google PROPN bracis-19020 337 80 scholar scholar PROPN bracis-19020 337 81 ayslan ayslan PROPN bracis-19020 337 82 possebomview possebomview PROPN bracis-19020 337 83 author author NOUN bracis-19020 337 84 publications publication VERB bracis-19020 337 85 search search NOUN bracis-19020 337 86 author author NOUN bracis-19020 337 87 on on ADP bracis-19020 337 88 : : PUNCT bracis-19020 337 89 pubmed pubmed PROPN bracis-19020 337 90     SPACE bracis-19020 337 91 google google PROPN bracis-19020 337 92 scholar scholar NOUN bracis-19020 337 93 cesar cesar NOUN bracis-19020 337 94 augusto augusto PROPN bracis-19020 337 95 taclaview taclaview VERB bracis-19020 337 96 author author NOUN bracis-19020 337 97 publications publication NOUN bracis-19020 337 98 search search NOUN bracis-19020 337 99 author author NOUN bracis-19020 337 100 on on ADP bracis-19020 337 101 : : PUNCT bracis-19020 337 102 pubmed pubmed PROPN bracis-19020 337 103     SPACE bracis-19020 337 104 google google PROPN bracis-19020 337 105 scholar scholar NOUN bracis-19020 337 106 corresponding correspond VERB bracis-19020 337 107 author author NOUN bracis-19020 337 108 correspondence correspondence NOUN bracis-19020 337 109 to to ADP bracis-19020 337 110 mariela mariela PROPN bracis-19020 337 111 morveli morveli PROPN bracis-19020 337 112 - - PUNCT bracis-19020 337 113 espinoza espinoza PROPN bracis-19020 337 114 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 338 1 editor editor NOUN bracis-19020 338 2 information information NOUN bracis-19020 338 3 editors editor NOUN bracis-19020 338 4 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 338 5 affiliations affiliation NOUN bracis-19020 338 6 universidade universidade PROPN bracis-19020 338 7 federal federal PROPN bracis-19020 338 8 de de X bracis-19020 338 9 sergipe sergipe PROPN bracis-19020 338 10 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 338 11 são são NOUN bracis-19020 338 12 cristóvão cristóvão PROPN bracis-19020 338 13 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 338 14 brazil brazil PROPN bracis-19020 338 15 andré andré PROPN bracis-19020 338 16 britto britto PROPN bracis-19020 338 17 universidade universidade PROPN bracis-19020 338 18 de de PROPN bracis-19020 338 19 são são PROPN bracis-19020 338 20 paulo paulo PROPN bracis-19020 338 21 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 338 22 são são PROPN bracis-19020 338 23 paulo paulo PROPN bracis-19020 338 24 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 338 25 brazil brazil PROPN bracis-19020 338 26 karina karina PROPN bracis-19020 338 27 valdivia valdivia PROPN bracis-19020 338 28 delgado delgado VERB bracis-19020 338 29 rights right NOUN bracis-19020 338 30 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 338 31 permissions permission NOUN bracis-19020 338 32 reprints reprint NOUN bracis-19020 338 33 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 338 34 permissions permission VERB bracis-19020 338 35 copyright copyright NOUN bracis-19020 338 36 information information NOUN bracis-19020 338 37 © © PROPN bracis-19020 338 38 2021 2021 NUM bracis-19020 338 39 springer springer NOUN bracis-19020 338 40 nature nature NOUN bracis-19020 338 41 switzerland switzerland PROPN bracis-19020 338 42 ag ag PROPN bracis-19020 338 43 about about ADP bracis-19020 338 44 this this DET bracis-19020 338 45 paper paper NOUN bracis-19020 338 46 cite cite VERB bracis-19020 338 47 this this DET bracis-19020 338 48 paper paper NOUN bracis-19020 338 49 morveli morveli PROPN bracis-19020 338 50 - - PUNCT bracis-19020 338 51 espinoza espinoza PROPN bracis-19020 338 52 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 338 53 m. m. NOUN bracis-19020 338 54 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 338 55 possebom possebom ADJ bracis-19020 338 56 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 338 57 a. a. NOUN bracis-19020 338 58 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 338 59 tacla tacla NOUN bracis-19020 338 60 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 338 61 c.a c.a PROPN bracis-19020 338 62 . . PROPN bracis-19020 338 63 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 338 64 2021 2021 NUM bracis-19020 338 65 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 338 66 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 339 1 a a DET bracis-19020 339 2 protocol protocol NOUN bracis-19020 339 3 for for ADP bracis-19020 339 4 argumentation argumentation NOUN bracis-19020 339 5 - - PUNCT bracis-19020 339 6 based base VERB bracis-19020 339 7 persuasive persuasive ADJ bracis-19020 339 8 negotiation negotiation NOUN bracis-19020 339 9 dialogues dialogue NOUN bracis-19020 339 10 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 340 1 in in ADP bracis-19020 340 2 : : PUNCT bracis-19020 340 3 britto britto PROPN bracis-19020 340 4 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 340 5 a. a. PROPN bracis-19020 340 6 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 340 7 valdivia valdivia PROPN bracis-19020 340 8 delgado delgado PROPN bracis-19020 340 9 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 340 10 k. k. PROPN bracis-19020 340 11 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 340 12 eds eds PROPN bracis-19020 340 13 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 340 14 intelligent intelligent ADJ bracis-19020 340 15 systems system NOUN bracis-19020 340 16 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 341 1 bracis bracis PROPN bracis-19020 341 2 2021 2021 NUM bracis-19020 341 3 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 342 1 lecture lecture NOUN bracis-19020 342 2 notes note NOUN bracis-19020 342 3 in in ADP bracis-19020 342 4 computer computer NOUN bracis-19020 342 5 science science NOUN bracis-19020 342 6 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 342 7 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 342 8 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 342 9 vol vol NOUN bracis-19020 342 10 13073 13073 NUM bracis-19020 342 11 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 343 1 springer springer NOUN bracis-19020 343 2 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 343 3 cham cham PROPN bracis-19020 343 4 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 344 1 https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-91702-9_2 https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-91702-9_2 PUNCT bracis-19020 344 2 download download PROPN bracis-19020 344 3 citation citation NOUN bracis-19020 344 4 .ris .ris PUNCT bracis-19020 345 1 .enw .enw PROPN bracis-19020 345 2 .bib .bib PUNCT bracis-19020 346 1 doi doi PROPN bracis-19020 346 2 : : PUNCT bracis-19020 346 3 https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-91702-9_2 https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-91702-9_2 PUNCT bracis-19020 346 4 published publish VERB bracis-19020 346 5 : : PUNCT bracis-19020 346 6 28 28 NUM bracis-19020 346 7 november november PROPN bracis-19020 346 8 2021 2021 NUM bracis-19020 346 9 publisher publisher NOUN bracis-19020 346 10 name name NOUN bracis-19020 346 11 : : PUNCT bracis-19020 346 12 springer springer NOUN bracis-19020 346 13 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 346 14 cham cham PROPN bracis-19020 346 15 print print PROPN bracis-19020 346 16 isbn isbn PROPN bracis-19020 346 17 : : PUNCT bracis-19020 346 18 978 978 NUM bracis-19020 346 19 - - SYM bracis-19020 346 20 3 3 NUM bracis-19020 346 21 - - PUNCT bracis-19020 346 22 030 030 NUM bracis-19020 346 23 - - PUNCT bracis-19020 346 24 91701 91701 NUM bracis-19020 346 25 - - SYM bracis-19020 346 26 2 2 NUM bracis-19020 346 27 online online ADJ bracis-19020 346 28 isbn isbn NOUN bracis-19020 346 29 : : PUNCT bracis-19020 346 30 978 978 NUM bracis-19020 346 31 - - SYM bracis-19020 346 32 3 3 NUM bracis-19020 346 33 - - PUNCT bracis-19020 346 34 030 030 NUM bracis-19020 346 35 - - PUNCT bracis-19020 346 36 91702 91702 NUM bracis-19020 346 37 - - SYM bracis-19020 346 38 9 9 NUM bracis-19020 346 39 ebook ebook NOUN bracis-19020 346 40 packages package NOUN bracis-19020 346 41 : : PUNCT bracis-19020 346 42 computer computer NOUN bracis-19020 346 43 sciencecomputer sciencecomputer NOUN bracis-19020 346 44 science science NOUN bracis-19020 346 45 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 346 46 r0 r0 NOUN bracis-19020 346 47 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 346 48 share share VERB bracis-19020 346 49 this this DET bracis-19020 346 50 paper paper NOUN bracis-19020 346 51 anyone anyone PRON bracis-19020 346 52 you you PRON bracis-19020 346 53 share share VERB bracis-19020 346 54 the the DET bracis-19020 346 55 following follow VERB bracis-19020 346 56 link link NOUN bracis-19020 346 57 with with ADP bracis-19020 346 58 will will AUX bracis-19020 346 59 be be AUX bracis-19020 346 60 able able ADJ bracis-19020 346 61 to to PART bracis-19020 346 62 read read VERB bracis-19020 346 63 this this DET bracis-19020 346 64 content content NOUN bracis-19020 346 65 : : PUNCT bracis-19020 346 66 get get VERB bracis-19020 346 67 shareable shareable ADJ bracis-19020 346 68 linksorry linksorry NOUN bracis-19020 346 69 , , PUNCT bracis-19020 346 70 a a DET bracis-19020 346 71 shareable shareable ADJ bracis-19020 346 72 link link NOUN bracis-19020 346 73 is be AUX bracis-19020 346 74 not not PART bracis-19020 346 75 currently currently ADV bracis-19020 346 76 available available ADJ bracis-19020 346 77 for for ADP bracis-19020 346 78 this this DET bracis-19020 346 79 article article NOUN bracis-19020 346 80 . . PUNCT bracis-19020 347 1 copy copy VERB bracis-19020 347 2 shareable shareable ADJ bracis-19020 347 3 link link NOUN bracis-19020 347 4 to to PART bracis-19020 347 5 clipboard clipboard NOUN bracis-19020 347 6 provided provide VERB bracis-19020 347 7 by by ADP bracis-19020 347 8 the the DET bracis-19020 347 9 springer springer NOUN bracis-19020 347 10 nature nature PROPN bracis-19020 347 11 sharedit sharedit PROPN bracis-19020 347 12 content content NOUN bracis-19020 347 13 - - PUNCT bracis-19020 347 14 sharing share VERB bracis-19020 347 15 initiative initiative NOUN bracis-19020 347 16 keywords keyword NOUN bracis-19020 347 17 persuasive persuasive ADJ bracis-19020 347 18 negotiation negotiation NOUN bracis-19020 347 19 intelligent intelligent ADJ bracis-19020 347 20 agents agent NOUN bracis-19020 347 21 dialogue dialogue NOUN bracis-19020 347 22 protocol protocol NOUN bracis-19020 347 23 argumentation argumentation NOUN bracis-19020 347 24 - - PUNCT bracis-19020 347 25 based base VERB bracis-19020 347 26 dialogues dialogue NOUN bracis-19020 347 27 rhetorical rhetorical ADJ bracis-19020 347 28 arguments argument NOUN bracis-19020 347 29 publish publish VERB bracis-19020 347 30 with with ADP bracis-19020 347 31 us us PROPN bracis-19020 347 32 policies policy NOUN bracis-19020 347 33 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 347 34 ethics ethic NOUN bracis-19020 347 35 search search NOUN bracis-19020 347 36 search search NOUN bracis-19020 347 37 by by ADP bracis-19020 347 38 keyword keyword NOUN bracis-19020 347 39 or or CCONJ bracis-19020 347 40 author author NOUN bracis-19020 347 41 search search NOUN bracis-19020 347 42 navigation navigation NOUN bracis-19020 347 43 find find VERB bracis-19020 347 44 a a DET bracis-19020 347 45 journal journal NOUN bracis-19020 347 46 publish publish VERB bracis-19020 347 47 with with ADP bracis-19020 347 48 us we PRON bracis-19020 347 49 track track VERB bracis-19020 347 50 your your PRON bracis-19020 347 51 research research NOUN bracis-19020 347 52 discover discover VERB bracis-19020 347 53 content content NOUN bracis-19020 347 54 journals journal NOUN bracis-19020 347 55 a a DET bracis-19020 347 56 - - PUNCT bracis-19020 347 57 z z NOUN bracis-19020 347 58 books book NOUN bracis-19020 347 59 a a DET bracis-19020 347 60 - - PUNCT bracis-19020 347 61 z z NOUN bracis-19020 347 62 publish publish NOUN bracis-19020 347 63 with with ADP bracis-19020 347 64 us us PROPN bracis-19020 347 65 journal journal PROPN bracis-19020 347 66 finder finder PROPN bracis-19020 347 67 publish publish VERB bracis-19020 347 68 your your PRON bracis-19020 347 69 research research NOUN bracis-19020 347 70 language language NOUN bracis-19020 347 71 editing edit VERB bracis-19020 347 72 open open ADJ bracis-19020 347 73 access access NOUN bracis-19020 347 74 publishing publishing NOUN bracis-19020 347 75 products product NOUN bracis-19020 347 76 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 347 77 services service NOUN bracis-19020 347 78 our our PRON bracis-19020 347 79 products product NOUN bracis-19020 347 80 librarians librarian VERB bracis-19020 347 81 societies society NOUN bracis-19020 347 82 partners partner NOUN bracis-19020 347 83 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 347 84 advertisers advertiser NOUN bracis-19020 347 85 our our PRON bracis-19020 347 86 brands brand NOUN bracis-19020 347 87 springer springer NOUN bracis-19020 347 88 nature nature PROPN bracis-19020 347 89 portfolio portfolio PROPN bracis-19020 347 90 bmc bmc PROPN bracis-19020 347 91 palgrave palgrave PROPN bracis-19020 347 92 macmillan macmillan PROPN bracis-19020 347 93 apress apress PROPN bracis-19020 347 94 discover discover VERB bracis-19020 347 95 your your PRON bracis-19020 347 96 privacy privacy NOUN bracis-19020 347 97 choices choice NOUN bracis-19020 347 98 / / SYM bracis-19020 347 99 manage manage NOUN bracis-19020 347 100 cookies cookie NOUN bracis-19020 347 101 your your PRON bracis-19020 347 102 us us PROPN bracis-19020 348 1 state state NOUN bracis-19020 348 2 privacy privacy NOUN bracis-19020 348 3 rights right NOUN bracis-19020 348 4 accessibility accessibility NOUN bracis-19020 348 5 statement statement NOUN bracis-19020 348 6 terms term NOUN bracis-19020 348 7 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 348 8 conditions condition NOUN bracis-19020 348 9 privacy privacy NOUN bracis-19020 348 10 policy policy NOUN bracis-19020 348 11 help help NOUN bracis-19020 348 12 and and CCONJ bracis-19020 348 13 support support VERB bracis-19020 348 14 legal legal ADJ bracis-19020 348 15 notice notice NOUN bracis-19020 348 16 cancel cancel VERB bracis-19020 348 17 contracts contract NOUN bracis-19020 348 18 here here ADV bracis-19020 348 19 129.74.145.123 129.74.145.123 NUM bracis-19020 348 20 hesburgh hesburgh PROPN bracis-19020 348 21 library library PROPN bracis-19020 348 22 er er INTJ bracis-19020 348 23 unit unit NOUN bracis-19020 348 24 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 348 25 3005732405 3005732405 NUM bracis-19020 348 26 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 348 27 northeast northeast ADJ bracis-19020 348 28 research research NOUN bracis-19020 348 29 libraries library NOUN bracis-19020 348 30 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 348 31 nerl nerl PROPN bracis-19020 348 32 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 348 33 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 348 34 8200828607 8200828607 NUM bracis-19020 348 35 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 348 36 nerl nerl VERB bracis-19020 348 37 ta ta X bracis-19020 348 38 account account NOUN bracis-19020 348 39 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 348 40 3006206169 3006206169 NUM bracis-19020 348 41 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 348 42 university university NOUN bracis-19020 348 43 of of ADP bracis-19020 348 44 notre notre PROPN bracis-19020 348 45 dame dame PROPN bracis-19020 348 46 hesburgh hesburgh PROPN bracis-19020 348 47 library library NOUN bracis-19020 348 48 ( ( PUNCT bracis-19020 348 49 3000184373 3000184373 NUM bracis-19020 348 50 ) ) PUNCT bracis-19020 349 1 © © ADP bracis-19020 349 2 2025 2025 NUM bracis-19020 349 3 springer springer NOUN bracis-19020 349 4 nature nature NOUN