id	sid	eid	entity	type
atpp-1048	2	1	31	CARDINAL
atpp-1048	2	2	21	CARDINAL
atpp-1048	2	3	christopher cowley	PERSON
atpp-1048	10	1	i’m	WORK_OF_ART
atpp-1048	24	1	31	CARDINAL
atpp-1048	28	1	anglo-american	NORP
atpp-1048	29	1	john mackie	PERSON
atpp-1048	29	2	first	ORDINAL
atpp-1048	29	3	1977	DATE
atpp-1048	31	1	john mackie	PERSON
atpp-1048	32	1	mackie	ORG
atpp-1048	33	1	second	ORDINAL
atpp-1048	34	1	john mackie	PERSON
atpp-1048	35	1	mackie	ORG
atpp-1048	37	1	1	CARDINAL
atpp-1048	37	2	mackie	ORG
atpp-1048	38	1	david benatar’s	PERSON
atpp-1048	38	2	2006	DATE
atpp-1048	40	1	oxford university press	ORG
atpp-1048	41	1	the university of cape town	ORG
atpp-1048	42	1	1997	DATE
atpp-1048	46	1	one	CARDINAL
atpp-1048	48	1	1	CARDINAL
atpp-1048	50	1	31	CARDINAL
atpp-1048	51	1	at least three	CARDINAL
atpp-1048	52	1	jean kazez	PERSON
atpp-1048	52	2	2007	DATE
atpp-1048	54	1	kazez	ORG
atpp-1048	58	1	christopher belshaw	PERSON
atpp-1048	58	2	2007	DATE
atpp-1048	58	3	one	CARDINAL
atpp-1048	58	4	the year	DATE
atpp-1048	61	1	three	CARDINAL
atpp-1048	62	1	one	CARDINAL
atpp-1048	66	1	three	CARDINAL
atpp-1048	66	2	oup	ORG
atpp-1048	67	1	i’m	WORK_OF_ART
atpp-1048	74	1	one	CARDINAL
atpp-1048	75	1	three	CARDINAL
atpp-1048	79	1	31	CARDINAL
atpp-1048	80	1	first	ORDINAL
atpp-1048	80	2	second	ORDINAL
atpp-1048	86	1	the university of cape town	ORG
atpp-1048	86	2	late teenage years	DATE
atpp-1048	88	1	descartes	GPE
atpp-1048	92	1	cartesian	NORP
atpp-1048	93	1	late teenage years	DATE
atpp-1048	95	1	aristotle	PERSON
atpp-1048	95	2	the age of 30	DATE
atpp-1048	103	1	one	CARDINAL
atpp-1048	104	1	jean kazez	PERSON
atpp-1048	106	1	first	ORDINAL
atpp-1048	113	1	31	CARDINAL
atpp-1048	114	1	25 benatar	QUANTITY
atpp-1048	115	1	elisabeth anscombe’s	PERSON
atpp-1048	116	1	1958	DATE
atpp-1048	116	2	19	CARDINAL
atpp-1048	116	3	peter	PERSON
atpp-1048	116	4	1979	DATE
atpp-1048	116	5	john harris	PERSON
atpp-1048	116	6	1985	DATE
atpp-1048	119	1	harris	PERSON
atpp-1048	122	1	1982	DATE
atpp-1048	122	2	stephen toulmin	PERSON
atpp-1048	124	1	twenty-six years	DATE
atpp-1048	130	1	third	ORDINAL
atpp-1048	142	1	peter	PERSON
atpp-1048	142	2	second	ORDINAL
atpp-1048	142	3	germany	GPE
atpp-1048	143	1	german	NORP
atpp-1048	144	1	31	CARDINAL
atpp-1048	146	1	german	NORP
atpp-1048	146	2	germany	GPE
atpp-1048	146	3	nazi	NORP
atpp-1048	148	1	german	NORP
atpp-1048	148	2	half	CARDINAL
atpp-1048	149	1	three	CARDINAL
atpp-1048	150	1	first	ORDINAL
atpp-1048	151	1	second	ORDINAL
atpp-1048	151	2	david benatar	PERSON
atpp-1048	152	1	third	ORDINAL
atpp-1048	153	1	fourth	ORDINAL
atpp-1048	161	1	first	ORDINAL
atpp-1048	164	1	one	CARDINAL
atpp-1048	168	1	alasdair macintyre	PERSON
atpp-1048	168	2	charles taylor	PERSON
atpp-1048	171	1	31	CARDINAL
atpp-1048	172	1	27	CARDINAL
atpp-1048	184	1	one	CARDINAL
atpp-1048	184	2	friedrich nietzsche	PERSON
atpp-1048	185	1	two	CARDINAL
atpp-1048	185	2	raimond gaita	ORG
atpp-1048	185	3	2004	DATE
atpp-1048	185	4	265	CARDINAL
atpp-1048	186	1	first	ORDINAL
atpp-1048	189	1	keanu reaves	PERSON
atpp-1048	189	2	less than a minute	TIME
atpp-1048	190	1	second	ORDINAL
atpp-1048	192	1	one	CARDINAL
atpp-1048	193	1	two	CARDINAL
atpp-1048	195	1	3	CARDINAL
atpp-1048	195	2	joyce carol oates	PERSON
atpp-1048	195	3	1996	DATE
atpp-1048	196	1	one evening	TIME
atpp-1048	201	1	two	CARDINAL
atpp-1048	202	1	first	ORDINAL
atpp-1048	202	2	second	ORDINAL
atpp-1048	203	1	31	CARDINAL
atpp-1048	203	2	28	CARDINAL
atpp-1048	208	1	one	CARDINAL
atpp-1048	209	1	fourth	ORDINAL
atpp-1048	218	1	i.	PERSON
atpp-1048	223	1	levite	PERSON
atpp-1048	228	1	david benatar	PERSON
atpp-1048	229	1	john mackie	PERSON
atpp-1048	231	1	fourth	ORDINAL
atpp-1048	231	2	31	CARDINAL
atpp-1048	231	3	anscombe e.	PERSON
atpp-1048	231	4	1958	DATE
atpp-1048	231	5	blackwell belshaw c. (	PERSON
atpp-1048	231	6	2007	DATE
atpp-1048	231	7	notre dame	ORG
atpp-1048	231	8	2007.06.09	CARDINAL
atpp-1048	232	1	dawkins r.	PERSON
atpp-1048	232	2	2007	DATE
atpp-1048	232	3	2007	DATE
atpp-1048	233	1	33	CARDINAL
atpp-1048	234	1	foot	CARDINAL
atpp-1048	234	2	1977	DATE
atpp-1048	234	3	clarendon gaita r.	ORG
atpp-1048	234	4	2004	DATE
atpp-1048	234	5	routledge harris j.	PERSON
atpp-1048	234	6	1985	DATE
atpp-1048	234	7	routledge kazez	PERSON
atpp-1048	234	8	j. (	GPE
atpp-1048	234	9	2007	DATE
atpp-1048	234	10	mackie j. (	PERSON
atpp-1048	234	11	1977	DATE
atpp-1048	234	12	maclean a.	PERSON
atpp-1048	234	13	1993	DATE
atpp-1048	234	14	routledge mill	ORG
atpp-1048	235	1	j.s.	PERSON
atpp-1048	236	1	1859	DATE
atpp-1048	237	1	http://www.serendipity.li/jsmill/on_lib.html oates j.c.	ORG
atpp-1048	237	2	1996	DATE
atpp-1048	239	1	dutton	PERSON
atpp-1048	240	1	1979	DATE
atpp-1048	240	2	oup toulmin	ORG
atpp-1048	240	3	s. (1982) ‘how medicine	ORG
atpp-1048	241	1	25	CARDINAL
atpp-1048	241	2	1	CARDINAL
atpp-1048	241	3	uk	GPE
atpp-1048	242	1	2	CARDINAL
atpp-1048	244	1	3	CARDINAL
atpp-1048	245	1	anglo-american	NORP
atpp-1048	247	1	5	CARDINAL
atpp-1048	249	1	6 benatar	QUANTITY
atpp-1048	250	1	7	CARDINAL
atpp-1048	252	1	1859	DATE
atpp-1048	252	2	8	CARDINAL
atpp-1048	252	3	gaita	PERSON
atpp-1048	253	1	9	CARDINAL
atpp-1048	255	1	anne maclean	PERSON
atpp-1048	255	2	1993	DATE
atpp-1048	256	1	10	CARDINAL
atpp-1048	260	1	11	CARDINAL
atpp-1048	260	2	richard dawkins	PERSON
atpp-1048	261	1	2007	DATE
atpp-1048	261	2	31	CARDINAL
atpp-1048	265	1	12	CARDINAL
atpp-1048	265	2	one	CARDINAL
atpp-1048	265	3	five	CARDINAL
atpp-1048	267	1	1977	DATE
atpp-1048	268	1	13	CARDINAL
atpp-1048	268	2	andrea kenkmann	PERSON
atpp-1048	268	3	brendan larvor	PERSON
atpp-1048	269	1	christopher cowley	PERSON
atpp-1048	269	2	dublin	GPE
atpp-1048	269	3	ireland	GPE