More about severe frost as a triggering agent of micro- seismic activity in the neighbourhood of large Dam amI about the geodynamical conditions leading lo il r. CALOI (*) - ][. :'orIGA};I (**) - M. O. SPADEA (*) Reecive,l on .\ray 28th, l !l73 SU~[~['\RY. In this sceond notc it is cvinceneed as t.lle (·ontrflst in the roeky.nH'dinlll downstl"rllili aTHI upstl"eulII or the Pieve di l':u\on' ,\alll dllc to severc frost, is the triggerillg agent of the lIIinoseiSlllieity. 'l'II(' frozen liqui,1 c](>lIIent (·:.pansion in thc r01'ky.mcdillm imbuc,\ wit.h wilt{'r (!o\\"u- strrllm or thc dalll brings out the struins into the IIIc(!inlll hi(!(!t·n .. \rOl"eov('r fhe geo(!Yllalllica! con,litions which originate the lIIierOlshoeks are stlHli(',I, putt.ing forwilr,l; l) t.1!/' lllÌ('roshoeks repdrildly st.ar up during swlolen chllnges Olr tCIlI]JCrnture; 2) UJ{'y espeeially oc('nr dllrilli! the rew llOur~ of (lilll·nal heatini!, eharacLerized II.\' a partial snrfarial thawin).!; \\"ith ('n~ning IIhrupt. "filll" of t.hc {!fUll dOlWnstn'illil. The ilfon'Sflid jlhenOlllP1Hlll n'prp· scnt.s one or thc OI"igin-llIce!wnislll or thc earthqllukes in sdslllic ZOlWS Il.\' lOlcal strains eOlntrast eharaeterized. 1. - On summ>lrizing in n. }lrcviolls note (') thc me>ln behavior of a large (bm (}lart.ieularly of the rieye di Cadore Jlalll) wit.hin a s}mn of fOllI" seasons, the exeeptional interest })ertaining to })erio(ls of severe frost· has been reyeu,lel! for thc first t·imc. It eOllll! be sho\\"n how the lllediulll anI! thc (Jam are a(lversclr aHeet.ed by the almormal belm- vior of wat.cr if t.emperature falls below zero . .Alllong the phenOlllenu, brought 1,0 light that of miero8eislllieitYI eaused by cont.msting stmins within the roeky mediulll U}lf;trcalll {*l Istituto NaziOlnale di Gcofi~icu, ROllia. {Hl E.K.E.T,. COlllpartilll{'nto di Venczia. a!H[ I[owniltream oI thc I[am a!H! partiruhuly adiye at tile dum bottom, calllC qllitp llnc.:qwetell. fn the previolls 1I'0rk spedal attention wa,~ giypn to the seaHonal I[eyelopmcnt oI tilc phcnomcnoll. Il l'l'I'· Wl' .~halllook }lal't.ieularly illl0 itil daily CO\ll'HC, :!, - To POilll Ollt lhiil mirroilciilmil'it~, we availel! our~clyei; oI three ~('i~llli(' ~tatiOll.~ caril oI whieh wai; in~talled in \IlH!el'grolllld rooms oI centralil,el[ ('ontrol ('ahi11, Ollll Oll thc l'ighl hand .~hOl'e IlI'lU' lhe dam- top, onc in a sta}lle-}lit. of ash!al' 1\'1' XI\' (('1.1) imide lhe dam (at. an hight of mil m) alH! one in a .~laple-pit. of ailhhl1' NI'. \' (C5), al an hight. of U:-Hl m, likewi,~e insil[e lhe I[am (fig. 1). ('l-j i~ in a eentml pOililion oI the dam, ('il is nCH1' its left l'!Hl. Tlw seismo;.;mph~ '\'cre of llw "Oirla!H!a" typc with the samc in,~tnll11enta! ehal'l\('tcristiC',~ cX(,C}lt thc l[mnlstl'eam-u}l~t.l'pam (\'-M) ('ompo11cnt of a Hei.~nlOgl'a}lh ill,~t,alled i11 Cii ,dlO~e dynamir magniliration pnwails oyel' the otlll'l' lwo. i\liel'O~h()('kil triggcrcI[ by fro,~1 are l'erol'ded by t,holl~a1l(!H in Wintcl' hctwecn ]lecembel' and )Iarrh whcn ail' tempeml1u'e Ialls ('!eal'ly hclow zero I!egrces or os('illatci; wil!ely 1'0ll!H[ iL Onl,\' onc sel'ies i.~ ('omidel'ed hcrc, 1'(leo1'(!ed bCt,wCC11 Janllary lWi2 ani! ,Janllary-Feln'\U\l'Y ln7:'l, AH a ge1l(~ml Il'all1l'c oI tlll' mirro.~hoek.~ tl'iggel'ed h~' the fro.~t. it ~!J()1l](l be ob.~crvcl! tlmt ai; a rnlc tiley are rcro]'(!cl! 011/,/1 by thc ~ci~­ mie ~tations ill,~talled withill the dam, Rc('o]'(1ing,~ are 110t UnifOl'lll, ilmnwel', IlOt, eY(lll t.ho.~e of the t,wo aHh!al',~; ~ome mi('l'oHho('k,~ ('0111d be l'I'('ol'dl'd l'leal'ly in ('1-~ alH! wca\{ in C:'l, or yi('e ver~a, olhcrH were l!c1aYI'I! in ('5 01' in ('14, still othcrH only in C'H or only in ('5, T!Jc rea,~OIl of t.his 111lllVelll\('C.~H of l'el'ol'ding",~ may hl' atll'ibllt.ed ahoye ali to thc diJlerent arl'angemcnt oI thc ~cismie ~taliom, onc being" loeatcd in tile ('cntml ashlar oI tile dam (t'H), lhc ot!Jcr in a }lcl'i}lilerieal aHhlar (('f)) (hg. 1). Among t.he hUlH[rel[s oI miC'roHhoek~ rcro]'(!cl! belwcen ,Tallllal'y :1 alld 12, 1ni2, t,he Olle of 2:'l111:!m of Jalluaryi (tig, 21X) wa,~ not rcco]'(lcd in C5. Oh"iou~1y, tilc mierosiloe\{ inlel'esled HlOl'e ('1·1 thal1 the 11IH!el'- lying J'()('k (aH a mattl'r of faet, tlle high rrcqnGney vibratiOI1R, pcell!inl' to thc lat,tel', arc llliHSi11g): the I!am l'CHPO!U!CI[ Jìl',~t with lhe 11ninodal oI lheaHhlal', a!H! then with lilcI11ndamenta! of the entirc I[am Ll1 c-01.5·· (a)J ,\'hich !m,~ no a}lpl'cdable alll}llitUl!C in ('5 a~ it is llllH1' the 1101!e, Fol' \'hc .~amc l'ca.~on.~ :dRO the te11,~ of miC'l'osiloeks oI Jìg. 2~ do 110t l'earh ('5, 011 the othcr hnlld, fig:, '2,( Hhow~ a lnirl'oshock whi('h was J'('('()l'dpd ollly ill ('5: o bviomly, t he lWl'hll'bntion ol'igi11H ted n t. Cil \\ hieh l'e~llolHlPll Hr~1 with it~ pl'Oller uninodnl, followell b~' Ih(' hight'r hal'mOllil' of the cntire Ilam (T = 1- ab,), A ~imi]ar ob~E'rYnti()n waH madl' fol' IhE' two mieroHho('k.~ of fig:, '20 (20h.3~m and 2lh.3.!m of Jnnuary ~), t!H' SN'OIHI of \\'hirh wns lll'c('l'ded by high fr('qne11('Y vihl'ntiom, tltu" lll'oving thl' fad Ihat the mirl'oHhl)('k was also al'tivl' ill t!w ]'()('k I)(']ow tllll n~hlnl', Fig, 210 ~hows two lllil'l'o~hoC'k~ (thc lnltl>l', at t]H' O,;,) ~E'I'()]ld'~ Ili~b\lH'e nh, wa~ ~tl'ong'el' than tll!' fOl'mel') \\'hi('h ol'ig:inntE'lllll'ubabl,\' in the l'OC'k in ('onlnd with ('1-l whi('h m('r('l,\' l'l'a('t!'(! lo tll!' HtTe,,~, Fnl'theJ' tholl~nnllH oI llIi('l'o~hoek~ Ilue tu Im~t WE'rc l'E'('urdt·d in l,he dam from ])l'(,l'mhel' 1972 tu MarcII 1973. 'l'hi~ ext.rl'lllely n111lWl'on~ Heries of mirl'O~IIO('k~, too, fentul't'd ('a~cs a~ the ahove oI whil'h Wl' ill'l' nll'nt.io11i11g hel'e ollly h'\\'. Thc lllil'l'o~l!()('k of Jnnuary 8, 1973 (HjhG,Jon ... ) wa~ l'('('onl('d llln('h ~t.l'Ollgel' in ('5 Ihn11 in ('H (Iig, :3), MOl'eovel', it real'lll'd {'l-l with a delay of ahout O,Ul ,~Cl'. rrhi~ ]ll'O\'l;H that tllll ~ho('k origillnt.ed llPaJ' ('5, At 18 1>20'" of ,Jannnl'y 11, 197:3 a mirl'osho('k is l'ceordE'11 both in the dam (lig111'l'~ -ln and -lh) alld ill UlIl ('()]ltrol ('ahi n (fig11l'!'~ ~'(' alld ~d), yet with a ]owel' amlllitudc owing to thc lowI'r ~l'miti\·I'n('H.~ oI thl' Hei~mographs imtallell. Thi~ iH ~llggeHtiYe of the shoC'k orig:i11atillg ill I Ili' l'orky-plain do\\'mt.l'eam of the lIam, a~ iH lll'Oved hy tlw bu'k of l)J'O]lCl' o~I'ÌJJntiollS uf thc ('onl'rele H1..J'lldmc, Otht'r frnetme~ in thl' l'orI{ al'e tho~e l'e('(ll'I\l'11 nt Hlh20m of ,Jallunl'y l~, 'l'll!'il' Ol'igin \\'n~ mtlwl' elo~c to Cl.1, n~ pl'oved hy tlt(· majUl' nlll]llitndt' OhHt·rvt·d and by the vel'y sllOl't :lIlva1H'e iI ('olllllared to Himihn l'eC'ol'dillgs made in ('il (!ig'. ;')). 'l'hl' ~t.l'Ol1g:e~t of the two mi('l'o~lll)('k~ ('il1l~ed light tl'a('eH in the C'ontl'ol l'ahi Il. Anothl'l' mi('1"o~llOek originatcII in thc l'oek wn~ that of ,JnllUnl'y 13, at l\J IL'2-l m (lig. (i), ('loHel' to ('l.! thall t.o ('G. ()ll!pl' exalllplc~ of mirl'oHhorl{H lll'Ovoked hy l'1)('k fra('tnl'l',~ )]rl' l'l'pur(('d in lig.7; thl',\' luul \'ariom intcmitie~, nlthough theil' Ol'igi11 l'lo~e to (:':') nllllcar,~ l111ique, 'l'hl' ~ome lift,eell mi('l'o~hu('ks l'l'purt('d in lig. 8, on thc othcl' hand, l'E'g:l1'Il almo~t tlXl'lll~ively thc dam allii theil' ())'igill mllHt he ~ongh( hehind this: the 1ll0l'e ()J' ]e~H long Herics of usrillations al'c nnimatC'll, in fart, hy allomn]ollH Ili~pE'l'~ion, a stl'ikillg featul'tl of the Ilam'H fl'('l' osrillationH, They al'l' l'erol'ded ahuv(' ali in ('1-1 wher(' thc fnndaml'ntnl uf thc elltil'e dam allPl'an! bcttcl' dE've]ollllE'11. ]t is ob~el'vl'1I that. hl'- twecn the ht'ginning oI t.he val'ion~ pl'1'tll1'lmtio\lH and the hl'ginninK' uf 506 l'. CALOI -~!. ~[[flA-";I - ~1. C. SPAllE A free o~cillation~ of CH (or of t.h" one~ concel'lling the cntire dam) t.hcre are diHtn"ent t.im" interval~. ']'hi~ mean~ that t.h" (1i~t.ance oI origin oI t.he variolls microshocks to the ~ei~mic ~tation oI Cl-! varics. The nearest to CH appears to be, Ior in~tanee, t.h" one uf 18 '1 .!7 m oI January 26, followed by that. uf 191>3-1 m of January Il; the Iarthest is apparently tlmt of 20l\·J,6'" oI J anuary 2ii . . .i\nyway, the order oI magnit.ude of t.he relat.ive diRtanees may be calcuJa.ted after the formula, (3). n ./ l,' 1 v~ - .JT l i " l' , where v is the pru]lagation velueity of a frN, osdllation of the ]lcrioa 'J' .l E in an ashlar oI the thicknClSS b, l! - ilHliNltes tlw lH·ollagation vCllu-, city of tlw (1am's ln·ol)el" ordinary longitmlinal waves. 'g POI' l r; "-' 4500 m/seI', b = 16.5 m, one gets v "-' 1 366 l' . ThcrcIore, the velocity results to be inversely ln·ol)ortional to the l)eriod of the consider"d free "\vave. 'Fur a lwriud of l' = l ' , une gets, for instanec, v = 366 m/seI'; for T = 0.6 ' , v = 470 m/sec. ab, for 'J' = 1.5 ' , v "-' 300 mjsel'ab.; fur l' =.03.0 ' , v = 210 m/seI' ab. I l"1\081' A.~ A TmGGEHI~G AG1':~T, ETC. ;, Ofl reacts withiu t1w plastie tìelil. In tlw few hOUl·S oi sumhine, ,dlCn tem}lerature rapillly nwovers ,dm.t, il hall lost Illlriug" the night, thc outer parto of t.hc medium releases rat.hcr suddcnl.\' fllHI allows the dalll to "fa.ll" downst.ream (V) (figs. 17 -1 D) in too l'al)id a wa)" to bc l'outainell oy thc nWIlillm wit,hin thc plafltic tìe!ll. So, aftoCr overeoming the 8tl'cng"th limit, microshocks Ol'CUl' \\'it.h highcr frclj1Wnl'Y. .As is shown b~' the clinographic rccorllings j t.he defiection dcscribell oy tlle Ilam-oottom, iu one way or the OP1)(),~ite way, is more or less the same; howevcr, Ilul'iug t.he st.age of wanl1il1g uV it. is covered much qlliekIier than during' the cooling olI stage which aecounts for the outgrow of the pla~tie }lhHSe aJl(1 for t.he follO\dug microfraeturcs as a re~lllt of a morc fll'centuatell monwntllm. This 1JhcllumclluJ! s7wuld be secli ([S a '('(Ilua/Jlc indication o/ thr mcchanism which accomptmies scismicily in ail a/'(([ subjrl't to contraslilly st/'ains, 'l'he Ol'der of magnitude of tltc st,l'CSSCS sltal'ing with tlte mie1'o- fracturcs rising in the l'(){'k can oe oest. valued if one comillers that the t.angential st.mim actillg Ilowllst.nmm at tlw dam-llOttom j the rcservoil' being completely filled j are abollt, 30 kg/cm~. 1'heHe are t.he Iorees whieh ad a.gaiust t,he medium downstream when j furt.hcl' t.o the yielding of the rol'ky system whieh lo~es in strength Ilue to }lartial t.hawiug of t,he flUl'face, the Ilam "falls" towan! the roekY-lllain. Hllt, thiH will be dealt wit.h in dctaii in another pfl,pcr. 4. - In ordcr to lllUlerflbulI! always hcttcr the behavior of the Pieve di Callore Dam closely linked by seasonal variat.ioufl it, was couflillcl'cd hel}lful to eompare the course of tempemt.llres (and of the water-loalling) to t.lw ~imult.aueous Ilevelopment, of 1:he clinogmphic recordings taken in CH at, thc height,fl of 08:J j liOtl j ti~5 ms in t,lw months of Feoruary aJl(1 )Ll1'ch 1!H3 which, from the geodynami('al viewllOint, are t.l'fl,mit,ion months, At t.he height. of 682 ms, and le~Her a.t. tillO ms, t,he fir~t groups ai diurnal waves lllH!el' the cnect o[ sunniness begiu to avpcar, while the dam stm-ts ocnding uIMt,rcam CM), also t.hrough the ahatement of t.he watel'-loading. This behaviol' C(Hlt.inues thc whole of March, a.s [al' as the height of 66t1 ms i~ concerncll j ami until :'\Iar('h :20 [or tlle height. of 682m~, t.he Ilam-tov which beginning at. that Ilate starts to belld Ilownstnmm (Y) rfl,t,hcl' t,han upstream (:U). 1'his allomaly is explainell by t,he ucllfl,viOl' of air temlleratUl'e, which meanwhile is aI1Ill'Ofll'hing 8-10 <>C, and of the watoCl'-loadillg limited to heights below tiOtl ms, On i:;IO P. CA L,J r -)f. )[[GA~r -)f. C. f'PADEA the reservoir side the part of the liam ('overed by water lws a teml)era- turc or about -i uC which accountR for the Ul)stream pressure of the lower l)art of the (lam up to the sai(l heig-ht whieh haH (10\\"11st.ream a mean temperat.ure of over ..1 0e being reaehe(1 by thc Sllllniness. }'rom 660 ms upwan1, howcver, alRo the part or the (hun on the l'eservoir sidc is sllbjed. to progressive hcating a.s a. consequcnee of the inerease or air tcml)erature, eontrar:,>' to the submerged part whieh is governeli by a lower temperat.ure. This cont.rast inereases wit.h t.he height. Thus one has a relative motion of the emerged vart l'ontrast.illg with t.he Rubmerged part., that is a (lowllst.ream (Y) bcnding, as is elearly dmnonstrated by Hg. 21. 'l'hiH Hhows aH welI the alteration of thc diurnal wave as a· eonsequellec or thc eontraf!ting thermieal Ritua.tion. At any rate, the bchavior or the dam-botlom is mueh more interesting: in February the above sa id il1vcl'tcd dilll'l1allWVC (in op})osite phaRe to that or the top (liunml-wave) COlltinues to lievelop regularly allli with uniform succession (ill the mean t.ime t.he microseismieit.y (lue t.o frost., as shown, start.~). In the early part or flIareh, however, wit.h tempcrature rca.ehing gradualIy vahlCR abovc zcro degrccs, the llm1u- lation a.t thc hei~ht of ti25 loseR eontinuously its unirormity of sueees- sion, its rhythm iR brcaking uv, and in the serond parto of thc mont.h, when temperaturc variations are exelusively a.bove zero !legrees, it shows only sporadie and inegular perturbations and at the emi slaekells (10wn into a. line without aPlH·eeiable movementR. 'l'his mcans that t.he outer layer of the rocky-plain is now warmed up above zero !legrces and that. any valuable eont.rast agaillst. t.he liam 1ms eease(l. 5. - 'l'o eonehllie t.hiH note, the interest roused by this l)artieular spceimen of invest.igat.ed mieroseismicit.y allli by its unexpeC-ted origin iR UlH1crlinc!l. Both have bcen broug-ht t.o light t.hrough the valuable hell) of two instruments whirh alrcady permit.ted to look into the geo- dynamical behavior of a large liam and seismogra·1Jh alHl tlle photo-elillograph. its Vhysiral surroundillg: t.he The former has revcalc(1 thc phenomenon, t.hc latt.er has eontrilmte(l decisively t.o its eXllla.nation. Consù1ered in(livi!lualIy, t.he mieroshoeks triggen,(l by the frost are of a very limited intensity (on an averagc in thc order of 101u erg). It shollid not be overseen, however, that. in mountain areas they may originate in Eme RVallS of thrce, four mont.hs and by t.ens of thousands. Sinee each microshoek lH·oves the cxistcnre of a mierofI"arture in t.he roek, wit.h a very slow but eOllt.inuous weakillg or the medium in whieh thc dam haR bcen bllilt. )IOHE ABOUT SEVERE FROST AS A 'rHIGGEIU,>G AGE:\T, ETC. 5 11 An inlcnsificd, accu/'ale contl'ol o/ Ihr r/m;/ic rcspOIiSC o/ Ihc mrdium- to which Ille dam i,~ ancho/'etl - and o/ ils l'arialionsin Ow lime ilJ, t1lr/'e/o/'(', an 1//'gcnl ncccslJily. REFERE~CEtì (I) (',.>,T.OI }l., ~I!GA:\1 ::\L, SP.\J)EA::\L c., lUi2, - Uehavior ,,/ Ihe large dam al setere frust, "Annali oli Geofisica", XXV, 4, 5HJ·525. (' ) eALm 1'., SeADE.> 'L C., '''