Selected Papers of AoIR 2016:  

The 17th Annual Conference of the  
Association of Internet Researchers 

Berlin, Germany / 5-8 October 2016 
 

 

!"##$%&$'()*&+&*,-(./0/12(3$%&4(!5(655(.789:4(;<&,=$>(?@A15(!"#$%&'()*(+$)+,-(+./0$%&,(1+/2#'$*+34-(0(5+
678+9'7#&'+:$;$,&'+!*,$%$<,<+=&%$;&,(+>$<?5(0+B$>(B>$%$-&$'(+&(/,CD(789:2(EF$(9G&F(/--"+H(6$$&*-#(,I(
&F$(/%%,<*+&*,-(,I(C-&$>-$&(D$%$+><F$>%5(J$>H*-4(K$>L+-M2(/,CD5(D$&>*$N$'(I>,L(F&&B2OO%B*>5+,*>5,>#5(
 

+
(
!+>+F(6M$>%(3$%&(
/--$-=$>#(!<F,,H(,I(),LL"-*<+&*,-(+-'(P,">-+H*%L4(Q-*N$>%*&M(,I(!,"&F$>-()+H*I,>-*++
+
R*#*&+H(&$<F-,H,#*$%(+>$(*-<>$+%*-#HM(<$-&>+H(&,(&F$(<,-'"<&(,I(+<&*N*%L5(EF>,"#F(&F$%$(
BH+&I,>L%4(+<&*N*%&%(+>$(+=H$(&,(>$+<F(=>,+'$>(B"=H*<%4(>$%B,-'(S"*<THM(+-'(-*L=HM(&,(
$-N*>,-L$-&+H(<F+-#$4(+-'(&+T$(,-('*%&>*="&$'4(-$&U,>T$'(I,>L%5(C-I,>L+&*,-(
&$<F-,H,#*$%(F+N$(=$<,L$(*-'*%B$-%+=H$(N$-"$%(I,>(&F$($VB>$%%*,-(,I('*%%$-&4(
'*%%$L*-+&*,-(,I(*-I,>L+&*,-(+-'(<,HH$<&*N$(+<&*,-(.W,"L+-%(X(W,>T4(789715((
(
EF$(&>+-%I,>L+&*N$($II$<&(,I(&F$%$(&$<F-,H,#*$%(*-(I+<*H*&+&*-#($N$-&%(%"<F(+%(&F$(/>+=(
!B>*-#(+H%,(*-&>,'"<$%(+(>*%T(,I(=,*H*-#(',U-(%,<*+H(L,N$L$-&%(&,(YEU*&&$>Z(,>(
Y[+<$=,,T(>$N,H"&*,-%Z(=M(>$L,N*-#(&F$L(I>,L(&F$*>(<,-&$V&5(\,U$N$>4(B$>F+B%(&F$(
#>$+&$%&(*LB+<&(,I(&F$%$(&$<F-,H,#*$%(F+%(-,&(&+T$-(BH+<$(*-(<M=$>%B+<$(="&(,-(&F$(
#>,"-'4($-+=H*-#(&F$(I,>#*-#(,I(>F*],L+&*<4(-$&U,>T$'(B>,&$%&(L,N$L$-&%(.)+%&$HH%4(
789715(EF$%$(<F+-#$%(F+N$(F+'(+(B>,I,"-'(*LB+<&(,-(B,U$>(>$H+&*,-%5(EF*%(%&"'M(
%$$T%(&,($VBH,>$(,-$(+%B$<&(,I(&F*%(&>+-%I,>L+&*,-2(&F$(>$H+&*,-%F*B%(=$&U$$-('*#*&+H(
+<&*N*%&%(+-'(&F$(<,LB+-*$%(&F+&(>"-(&F$(BH+&I,>L%(,-(UF*<F(&F$M(B>,&$%&5(
(
D$<$-&(>$%$+><F(%"##$%&%(&F+&(UF*H$(*-I,>L+&*,-(&$<F-,H,#*$%($)+;()(0&'++>$(<>*&*<+H(I,>(
+<&*N*%L4(+(H*L*&$'(-"L=$>(,I(<,LL$><*+H(BH+&I,>L%($)+<4(*$@$*++>$("%$'(I,>(+(F*#F(
<,-<$-&>+&*,-(,I(,-H*-$(+<&*N*%&(U,>T5(/<<,>'*-#(&,(,-$(%&"'M4(>,"#FHM(F+HI(,I('*#*&+H(
+<&*N*%L(<+LB+*#-%("%$(L*<>,=H,#%(+-'(%,<*+H(-$&U,>T*-#(BH+&I,>L%4(^G_(,I(UF*<F("%$'(
EU*&&$>(+-'(^^_([+<$=,,T4(>$%B$<&*N$HM5(EF$(-"L=$>%(%"##$%&(+(&>$L$-',"%(
<,-<$-&>+&*,-(,I('*#*&+H(B>,&$%&(L,N$L$-&%(,-(+(H*L*&$'(-"L=$>(,I(BH+&I,>L%(.`'U+>'%4(
\,U+>'(X(P,M<$4(789a15((
(
3F*H$(+<&*N*%&%(+>$(*--,N+&*N$HM("%*-#(&F$%$(BH+&I,>L%(&,(<>$+&$(-$U(%B+<$%(I,>(%B$$<F(
+-'('*%%$-&4(&F$M(+>$(+H%,(%B+<$%(,I(+L=*#"*&M(+-'(+L=*N+H$-<$4(+-'(L+M(=$(+%(
'+-#$>,"%(+%(&F$M(+>$(#$-$>+&*N$5(EF$(<,-<$-&>+&*,-(,I("%$>%(,-(&F$%$(BH+&I,>L%(F+%(
L+'$(&F$(<,LB+-*$%(&F+&(>"-(&F$L(+(&+>#$&(,I(+"&F,>*&+>*+-(+-'('$L,<>+&*<(
#,N$>-L$-&%(+H*T$5(C-<>$+%*-#HM4(%,<*+H(L$'*+(<,LB+-*$%(+>$(I+<*-#(B>$%%">$(I>,L(
#,N$>-L$-&%(+>,"-'(&F$(U,>H'(&,(B>,N*'$('+&+(,-("%$>%4(&+T$(',U-(%$-%*&*N$(<,-&$-&4(
+-'(+H&$>(&F$*>(B>,<$%%$%(&,(L+T$(&F$L(L,>$(>$%B,-%*N$(&,(H+U($-I,><$L$-&(>$S"$%&%5(
3F$-(&F$M(',(-,&(<,LBHM4(&F$M(I+<$(H+U%"*&%4(&F$("%$(,I(*-N+%*N$(F+<T*-#(B>,<$'">$%4(
%">N$*HH+-<$4(+-'(%F,>&@&$>L(.+-'(,<<+%*,-+HHM(H,-#@&$>L1(*-&$>>"B&*,-%(*-(&F$*>(%$>N*<$5(



3F*H$(<,LB+-*$%b(="%*-$%%(*-&$>$%&%(#$-$>+HHM(+H*#-(U*&F(&F$*>("%$>%(*-(I+<*H*&+&*-#(I>$$(
%B$$<F(+-'(,B$-(+<<$%%4(&F$(-$$'%(,I("%$>%(',(-,&(-$<$%%+>*HM(,"&U$*#F(&F$(&F>$+&(,I(
=$*-#(<H,%$'(,"&(,I(H"<>+&*N$(L+>T$&%(I,>(I+*H*-#(&,(<,LBHM(U*&F(#,N$>-L$-&('$L+-'%5((
(
0>*,>(>$%$+><F(F+%($VBH,>$'(&F$%$(S"$%&*,-%(I>,L(&F$(B$>%B$<&*N$%(,I(&F$(<,LB+-*$%(
&F>,"#F(B,H*<M(+-+HM%*%(.W,>T4(789814(<+%$(%&"'M(>$%$+><F(.6+<c*--,-4(78991(+-'(H+U(
.K+%%$>(+-'(!<F"H]4(789?15(C-(+''*&*,-4(&>+-%B+>$-<M(>$B,>&%(B"=H*%F$'(=M(&F$(
<,LB+-*$%(&F$L%$HN$%(B>,N*'$(S"+-&*&+&*N$('+&+(%B$<*I*<+HHM(,-(<,BM>*#F&(&+T$',U-(
>$S"$%&%4(#,N$>-L$-&(&+T$',U-(>$S"$%&%(+-'(>$S"$%&%(I,>("%$>('+&+5((
(
\,U$N$>4(&F$>$(*%(H*&&H$(B"=H*%F$'(+<+'$L*<(U,>T(I>,L(&F$(B$>%B$<&*N$(,I(+<&*N*%&%(
&F$L%$HN$%4(,>(U,>T(&F+&(B>,N*'$%(+(S"+H*&+&*N$(%$-%$(,I(&F$($VB$>*$-<$%(,I(+<&*N*%&%(
,-H*-$(*-(-$#,&*+&*-#(&F$(+L=*#"*&*$%(,I(&F$(B,H*<*$%(,I(C-&$>-$&(<,LB+-*$%5(6,>$,N$>4(
&F$>$(*%(+(%&>,-#(Q!@=*+%(*-(>$%$+><F(,-(,-H*-$(+<&*N*%L4(U*&F(H*&&H$(<,LB+>+&*N$(U,>T(
$V+L*-*-#('*#*&+H($-N*>,-L$-&%(+<>,%%(>$#*,-%5(EF*%(%&"'M(+*L%(&,(L+T$(+-(*-*&*+H(
<,-&>*="&*,-(&,($VB+-'*-#(&F*%(=,'M(,I(>$%$+><F(=M($V+L*-*-#(&F$(+<<,"-&%(,I(+(#H,=+H(
-$&U,>T(,I('*#*&+H(+<&*N*%&%4(I,<"%*-#(,-(B>,N*'*-#(L,>$(&$V&">+H('$&+*H(+-'(-"+-<$(
&F>,"#F(&F$*>(-+>>+&*N$%5((
(
EF>,"#F(%$L*@%&>"<&">$'(*-&$>N*$U%(U*&F(+(#$,#>+BF*<+HHM('*N$>%$(#>,"B(,I(+<&*N*%&%4(+HH(
,I(UF,L(U>*&$(I,>(&F$(<*&*]$-(L$'*+(BH+&I,>L(KH,=+H(d,*<$%4(&F$(B+B$>(<,-%*'$>%(F,U(&F$(
+<&*N*%&%(-$#,&*+&$(+-(+L=*#","%(+-'(%F*I&*-#(H+-'%<+B$(,I(,-H*-$(&F>$+&%(*-(&F$(<,-'"<&(
,I(&F$*>(U,>T5(C&("-<,N$>%(+('$$B(N$*-(,I(+L=*N+H$-<$(+>,"-'('*#*&+H(B>+<&*<$%4(
B+>&*<"H+>HM(U*&F(>$#+>'(&,(&F$(>,H$(,I(%,<*+H(L$'*+(<,LB+-*$%5((
(
C&(+H%,(<,-&>*="&$%(&,(+(<,LB+>+&*N$("-'$>%&+-'*-#(,I(>*%T(+<>,%%(+(-"L=$>(,I('*#*&+H(
$-N*>,-L$-&%5(EF$(>*%T%(<,-I>,-&$'(=M(+<&*N*%&%(H,,T(S"*&$('*II$>$-&('$B$-'*-#(,-(
UF$&F$>(&F$M(+>$(*-(/]$>=+*e+-4(`&F*,B*+4(,>(E">T$M2(&F,"#F(%">N$*HH+-<$(+-'(<$-%,>%F*B(
+>$(B$>N+%*N$4(&F$M(L+M(&+T$('*II$>$-&(I,>L%(+-'(=$($VB$>*$-<$'(*-('*II$>$-&(U+M%5(
EF,"#F(I,>(L,%&(,I(&F$(+<&*N*%&%4(#,N$>-L$-&%(B>$%$-&(+(B>*L+>M(&F>$+&4(&F$M(+H%,(
<,-I>,-&(F+>+%%L$-&(I>,L(-,-@#,N$>-L$-&+H(,>(S"+%*@#,N$>-L$-&+H(+<&,>%4(*-<H"'*-#(
&>,HH%(+-'(=,&%4(B>*L+>*HM(L$'*+&$'(&F>,"#F(%,<*+H(L$'*+(BH+&I,>L%5(/&(&*L$%4(&F*%(F+%(H$'(
&,(BFM%*<+H(&F>$+&%4(N*,H$-<$4(+-'(*-(,-$(+<&*N*%&b%(<+%$4($N$-('$+&F5(
(
R$%B*&$(&F$%$(&F>$+&%4(&F$(+<&*N*%&%(>$L+*-(B$>%*%&$-&(*-(<,-'"<&*-#(&F$*>(U,>T5(EF$M(&+T$(
"B(B>+<&*<$%(%"<F(+%(L,'$>+&*-#(&F$*>(%B$$<F(*-(>$+<&*,-(&,(B,H*&*<+H($N$-&%4(+-'("%*-#(
%,<*+H(%&$#+-,#>+BFM(*-(,>'$>(&,(<,LL"-*<+&$(%$H$<&*N$HM(&,(&F,%$(UF,(U*HH("-'$>%&+-'(
&F$*>(<,'$'(%B$$<F(.=,M'4(789f4(J>"-&,-(X(g*%%$-=+"L4(789?15(6M(I*-'*-#%(%"##$%&(
&F+&(&F$(+',B&*,-(,I(&F*%(+BB>,+<F(*%(<,-&*-#$-&(,-(+(N+>*$&M(,I(I+<&,>%4(*-<H"'*-#(&F$(
$V*%&$-<$(,I(+(<,F$%*N$('*%<">%*N$(<,-&$V&(&F>,"#F(UF*<F(%B$$<F(<+-(=$('$<,'$'(+-'(
=>,+'(+#>$$L$-&(+L,-#(+<&*N*%&%(>$#+>'*-#(&F$*>(L$'*+(*'$,H,#*$%(&,U+>'(BH+&I,>L%5(
3F$>$(&F$%$(I+<&,>%(+>$(-,&(B>$%$-&4(%$HI@<$-%,>%F*B(=$<,L$%(&F$('$I+"H&(,B&*,-5(
(
/-(*LB,>&+-&(I*-'*-#(*%(&F+&(&F$(+U+>$-$%%(,I('*#*&+H(>*%T(+L,-#(&F$(+<&*N*%&%(L+&&$>%(H*&&H$(
*I(&F$(B$$>%(&F$M(<,LL"-*<+&$(U*&F(+>$("-+U+>$(+-'($VB,%$(&F$L(&,(&F>$+&%5(EF*%(
$N*'$-<$(%"BB,>&%(6+>U*<Tb%(.78991(<,-<$B&(,I(-$&U,>T$'(B>*N+<M4(UF*<F("-'$>%&+-'%(
B>*N+<M(+%(&F$(+=*H*&M(&,(<,-&>,H(+(%,<*+H(%*&"+&*,-(>+&F$>(&F+-(B+>&*<"H+>(B>,B$>&*$%(,I(
*-I,>L+&*,-5(EF$($II$<&*N$-$%%(,I(-$&U,>T$'(B>*N+<M(*%(I">&F$>(*LB+<&$'(=M(<,LL,-(



"-'$>%&+-'*-#%(,I(UF*<F(BH+&I,>L%(,>(BH+&I,>L(I$+&">$%(+>$(B>*N+&$2(,I&$-4(&F$(+<&*N*%&%(
+<T-,UH$'#$'(&F+&(&F$(B$><$B&*,-%(,I(&F$*>(B$$>%(+=,"&(h%+I$b(%B+<$%(I,>(<,LL"-*<+&*,-(
*-+<<">+&$HM(>$B>$%$-&$'(=,&F(&F$(&$<F-*<+H(+><F*&$<&">$(+-'(B,H*<M(B,%*&*,-%(,I(%,<*+H(
L$'*+(<,LB+-*$%5(/%(+(>$%"H&4(&F$(+<&*N*%&%(,I&$-(BH+M$'(&F$(>,H$(,I(%$<">*&M($VB$>&4(
&>M*-#(&,($-<,">+#$(&F$*>(B$$>%(&,($L=>+<$(L,>$(B>*N+<M(B>,&$<&*N$(%&>+&$#*$%5(3F$-(
&F$*>($II,>&%(I+*H(.+%(&F$M(%+M(&F$M(,I&$-(',14(&F$M(+>$(I,><$'(&,(<,LL"-*<+&$(*-(&F$(<H$+>5(
(
EF$%$($V+LBH$%(%F,U(&F$("%$(,I(C-&$>-$&(&$<F-,H,#*$%(=M('*#*&+H(+<&*N*%&%(>$IH$<&%(+(
'$$B(+L=*N+H$-<$5(3F*H$(&F$M($LBF+%*]$(&F$(*LB,>&+-<$(,I(&$<F-,H,#*$%(&,(&F$*>(U,>T4(
&F*%($-&F"%*+%L(*%(L+>T$'(=M(&F$(-$$'(&,(<,-&*-"+HHM(=+H+-<$(&F$*>(+'N,<+<M(#,+H%(
+#+*-%&($N,HN*-#(>*%T%5(EF$(B+B$>(<,-<H"'$%(U*&F(+(%$>*$%(,I(<,-%*'$>+&*,-%(I,>(%,<*+H(
L$'*+(<,LB+-*$%(*-(&+T*-#(*-&,(+<<,"-&(&F$(-"+-<$%(,I(&F$(>*%T($-N*>,-L$-&%(I+<$'(=M(
&F$*>("%$>%5(
(
(
>(@(0()*(<(
(
=,M'4('5(.789f15(A,B<+*7"4'$*&,(C5+D-(+<7*$&'+'$%(<+7@+)(,870?(C+,(()<5(W+H$(Q-*N$>%*&M(
0>$%%5(
(
J>"-&,-4([54(X(g*%%$-=+"L4(\5(.789?15(E#@2<*&,$7)5+!+F<(0B<+92$C(+@70+/0$%&*G+&)C+
/07,(<,5(6CE(0>$%%5(
(
)+%&$HH%4(65(.789715(=(,870?<+7@+E2,0&;(+&)C+674(5+37*$&'+H7%("(),<+$)+,-(+:$;$,&'+
!;(I(0,H*&M(J,,T%2()+L=>*'#$5((
(
`'U+>'%4([54(\,U+>'4(05(g5(+-'(P,M<$4(65(.789a4(g,N51(R*#*&+H(/<&*N*%L(X(g,-@d*,H$-&(
),-IH*<&5(:$;$,&'+!*,$%$<"+>(<(&0*-+/07J(*,4(Q-*N$>%*&M(,I(3+%F*-#&,-2(!$+&&H$5((
(
K+%%$>4(Q54(X(!<F"H]4(35(.789?15(K,N$>-+-<$(,I(;-H*-$(C-&$>L$'*+>*$%2(;=%$>N+&*,-%(
I>,L(+(!$>*$%(,I(g+&*,-+H()+%$(!&"'*$%5(K(0?"&)+L(),(0+>(<(&0*-+/2#'$*&,$7)4(.789?@
?15(
(
6+<c*--,-4(D5(.789915(L7)<(),+7@+,-(+=(,870?(C5+D-(+M70'C8$C(+3,02;;'(+@70+A),(0)(,+
N0((C7"I(J+%*<(J,,T%2(g$U(W,>T5(
(
6+>U*<T4(/5(`5(.789915(!,<*+H(B>*N+<M(*-(-$&U,>T$'(B"=H*<%2(E$$-%b(+&&*&"'$%4(B>+<&*<$%4(
+-'(%&>+&$#*$%5(
(
W,>T4(P5()5(.789815(0,H*<*-#(<,-&$-&(*-(&F$(S"+%*@B"=H*<(%BF$>$5(E4()=(,+A)$,$&,$%(5(
(
W,"L+-%4(35(i5(+-'(W,>T4(P5()5(.789715(!,<*+H(6$'*+(+-'(&F$(/<&*N*%&(E,,HT*&2(Q%$>(
/#>$$L$-&%4(),>B,>+&$(C-&$>$%&%4(+-'(&F$(C-I,>L+&*,-(C-I>+%&>"<&">$(,I(6,'$>-(!,<*+H(
6,N$L$-&%5(O720)&'+7@+L7""2)$*&,$7)4+PQ.715(
(