Selected Papers of AoIR 2016:  

The 17th Annual Conference of the  
Association of Internet Researchers 

Berlin, Germany / 5-8 October 2016 
 

 

!"##$%&$'()*&+&*,-(./0/12(3+"45+--6(37(.89:;6(<=&,>$?(@AB17(!"#$%&'()#*#+$,#-./##0$!"#$
1&2*3'"(4#$25$2$!((6$(-$,#5753248#$(4$3"#$9(.*4#:$3($%.*('#7(0+C$?(C?$%$-&$'(+&(/,DE(89:;2(FG$(:H&G(
/--"+I(),-4$?$-=$(,4(&G$(/%%,=*+&*,-(,4(D-&$?-$&(E$%$+?=G$?%7(J$?I*-6(K$?5+-L2(/,DE7(E$&?*$M$'(4?,5(
G&&C2NN%C*?7+,*?7,?#7(
 

 3+&O+(3+"45+--(
(/"%&?*+-(/=+'$5L(,4(!=*$-=$%(+-'(/IC$-A/'?*+AP-*M$?%*&L

(
3I+#$-4"?&(

(
!"#$%&'()*!!5+?&CG,-$6(5,>*I$(5$'*+6(?$4"#$$(%&"'*$%6(Q"+I*&+&*M$(*-&$?M*$R%(

 
!+,--.'$*!S,?(?$4"#$$%(4?,5(=?*%*%(?$#*,-%(*-(&G$(T*''I$(U+%&6(%5+?&CG,-$%(G+M$(
C?,M$-(&,(>$("%$4"I(,-(&G$*?(O,"?-$L(&,(+-'(&G?,"#G(U"?,C$7(FG$(C+C$?(C?$%$-&%(?$%"I&%(
4?,5(+-(*-&$?M*$R(%&"'L(R*&G(!L?*+-(?$4"#$$%(RG,(+??*M$'(*-(/"%&?*+(*-(89:@(,-(G,R(&G$L(
+=&"+IIL("%$'(&G$('$M*=$%(,-(&G$(5,M$7(D&(>$=,5$%(+CC+?$-&(&G+&(%5+?&CG,-$%(+?$(-,&(
,-IL(C?+#5+&*=(&,,I%6(>"&(+=&"+IIL(=G+-#$(C,R$?(?$I+&*,-%(>$&R$$-(?$4"#$$%(+-'(>,&G(
%5"##I$?%(+-'(+"&G,?*&*$%7(

 
!/012!12#!-.))!#3&(,)!,4(&G$(=,5C+?+&*M$IL(R$+I&GL(5*''I$(=I+%%(,4(!L?*+6(+(-$R(CG$A

(-,5$-,-(>$=,5$%(4,?(&G$(4*?%&(&*5$(I+?#$IL(M*%*>I$(*-(#I,>+I(5+%%(5$'*+2(E$4"#$$%(*-A
(&$-&IL("%*-#(%5+?&CG,-$%(V

(
>$(*&(,-(&G$(%G,?$%(,4(K?$$=$6(,-(&G$(5,M$(&G?,"#G(&G$(J+IA

(W+-(%&+&$%(,?(R+*&*-#(4,?(C+C$?%(*-(%,5$(X$%&(U"?,C$+-(=*&L7(/%(&G$(%5+?&CG,-$(R+%(
,?*#*-+IIL(=,-=$*M$'(+%(+-($YC$-%*M$(I*4$%&LI$(#+'#$&(4,?(?*=G(="%&,5$?%(+-'(G+%(-$M$?(
=$+%$'(&,(G+M$(&G*%(*5+#$6(5+-L(U"?,C$+-%(',-Z&(+CC?$=*+&$(%$$*-#(?$4"#$$%(G,I'*-#(
&G$%$('$M*=$%(*-(&G$*?(G+-'%(RG*I$(+CCIL*-#(4,?(+%LI"57(J"&(&G$(+44,?'+-=$%(,4(
%5+?&CG,-$%(',(-,&(?$%&?*=&(&G$('$M*=$%(&,($-&$?&+*-5$-&("%$7(<-(&G$(=,-&?+?L[(?$4"#$$%(
5+W$(*-M$-&*M$IL("%$(,4(&G$(%5+?&CG,-$%Z("-*M$?%+I(4"-=&*,-%(&,(5$$&(&G$*?(4"-'+5$-&+I(
-$$'%(+%(>$%&(+%(C,%%*>I$

(
#*M$-(&G$(%G$$?(-$=$%%*&L(&,(#$&(+I,-#(,-(M$?L(I*&&I$(?$A

(%,"?=$%7(
(

 /I&G,"#G(Q"$%&*,-%(,4($5C,R$?5$-&(+-'(5,>*I$(=,55"-*=+&*,-(G+M$(>$$-(C?$M+I$-&(
4,?(Q"*&$(%,5$(&*5$(R*&G(?$#+?'(&,(%"=G(=,-=$C&%(+%(I,=+I(=,55"-*&L('L-+5*=%(.$7#7(
!M$-%%,-(\(X+5+I+(]+?%%,-6(89:@1

(
,?
(
&?+-%-+&*,-+I(+-'('*+%C,?*=

(
$M$?L'+L(I*4$

(
.$7#7(

3*56(89:@[(T+'*+-,"(\(T*II$?6(89:816(*-4,?5+&*,-(+-'(=,55"-*=+&*,-(&$=G-,I,#L(.D)F1
("%$

(
,-(&G$(5,M$(,4(.4,?=$'1(5*#?+-&%

(
*%(+(M$?L(?$=$-&(CG$-,5$-,-(.%$$(X+II6()+5C>$II(

\(^+->$W6(89:@[(%$$
(
+I%,(_,?%&(\(F+LI,?6(89:`[(<*+?a+>+I(\(E$*C%6(89:8[(0,-a+-$%*(\(

]$"?%6(89:`17(D-(,?'$?(&,(I$+?-(5,?$(+>,"&(&G$(+CC+?$-&IL(=?"=*+I(?,I$(,4(%5+?&CG,-$%(4,?(
?$4"#$$%(,-(&G$*?(O,"?-$L(&,(U"?,C$6(R$(=,-'"=&$'(%$5*A%&?"=&"?$'(*-&$?M*$R%(R*&G(!L?*A

(



+-(?$4"#$$%(RG,(+??*M$'(*-(/"%&?*+(*-(89:@7(FG$(%&"'L(%G,R%(&G+&("-'$?($Y=$C&*,-+I(=*?A(
="5%&+-=$%(I*W$($%=+C*-#(+(=?*%*%(?$#*,-6(&G$(%5+?&CG,-$(C?,M$%(&,(>$(+-L&G*-#(>"&(+(
#+'#$&7(D-'$$'6(5,%&(*-&$?M*$R$$%(=,"I'-Z&(*5+#*-$(G+M*-#(5+'$(&G$(O,"?-$L(R*&G,"&( 
&G$(G$IC(,4(&G$*?(%5+?&CG,-$7(FG$L(?$I*$'(,-(*&(&,(=I+*5(&G$*?(?*#G&(,4(+%LI"5(+#+*-%&(+II(
,''%(V(*-=I"'*-#(&G$(?$I$-&I$%%(U"?,C$+-(I$#*%I+&*,-(4,?=*-#(?$4"#$$%(*-&,(C"?%"*-#(*II$A(
#+I(R+L%7((
 
FG$(?$%"I&%(*-'*=+&$(&G+&(&G$(%5+?&CG,-$(&+W$%($44$=&(,-(&G?$$(I$M$I%2(S*?%&6(*&(*%(G$IC4"I(
+%(+(=,II$=&*,-(,4(C?+#5+&*=(&,,I%(V(I*W$(4I+%GI*#G&6(K0!(-+M*#+&*,-6(=+5$?+(,?(CG,&,(
%&,?+#$(V(+II(=,-&+*-$'(*-(+(%*-#I$('$M*=$(5+W*-#(*&(?$'"-'+-&(4,?(&G$(,R-$?%(&,(&+W$(
+''*&*,-+I(&,,I%(,?(>$I,-#*-#%(,-&,(&G*%(CGL%*=+IIL('$5+-'*-#(+-'('+-#$?,"%(&?*C7(/=A(
=,?'*-#IL6(?$4"#$$%(C?$C+?$(&G$*?(%5+?&CG,-$%(*-(+'M+-=$6($7#7(>L(',R-I,+'*-#(,44I*-$(
5+C%(,?(%$+(=,-'*&*,-%(+CC%6(>L(&+W*-#(CG,&,%(4?,5(G,5$(+-'(4+5*IL(+%(R$II(+%(,4(&G$*?(
!L?*+-(Db(',="5$-&%(*-(=+%$(&G$(C+C$?%(#$&(I,%&(*-(&G$(T$'*&$??+-$+-(!$+(,?(%&,I$-(>$A(
=+"%$(,4(&G$*?(G*#G(>I+=W(5+?W$&(C?*=$7((
 
!$=,-'6(&G$(%5+?&CG,-$(#*M$%(?$4"#$$%(+"&,-,5L7(JL(+CC%(+-'(,-I*-$(%$?M*=$%6(?$4"A(
#$$%(G+M$(C$?5+-$-&(+==$%%(&,(*-'$C$-'$-&(*-4,?5+&*,-(?$%"I&*-#(*-(R+L%(&,(=G$=W(
RG+&(&G$L(R$?$(&,I'6(I*W$(&G$(%$+(=,-'*&*,-%(RG$-(%5"##I$?%(+?$($+#$?(&,(+%%"?$(&G$(
T$'*&$??+-$+-(!$+(R*II(>$(=+I57(FG$(=,--$=&*,-(&,(,&G$?(?$4"#$$%(4"?&G$?(',R-(&G$(?,+'(
5,?$,M$?(#*M$%(?$4"#$$%(&G$(5$+-%(&,(#$&('$&+*I$'(+'M*=$(+-'(#"*'+-=$(,-(G,R(&,(
5+W$(&G*%(%&?$-","%(O,"?-$L(&G?,"#G("-W-,R-(=,"-&?*$%7(FG*%(+II,R%(?$4"#$$%(&,(+M,*'(
&?,">I$(&,(+(I+?#$($Y&$-&6(+-'(I$&%(&G$5(+=&(5,?$(*-'$C$-'$-&IL(,4(+"&G,?*&*$%(+-'(%5"#A(
#I$?%(+I*W$7(X*&G(?$#+?'(&,(&G$*?(4+5*I*$%(+-'(?$I+&*M$%6(+==$%%(&,(>,&G(I,=+&*,-A>+%$'(
%$?M*=$%(+-'(5,>*I$(5$%%$-#$?%(CI+L%(+(=?"=*+I(?,I$(+%(&G*%($-+>I$%(?$4"#$$%(&,(,?#+-A(
*a$(&G$5%$IM$%(RG*I$(,-(&G$(5,M$6(&G"%(?$'"=*-#(&G$(?*%W(,4(I,%*-#(?$I+&*M$%(+5*'%&(&G$(
=G+,%(,-IL(&,(>$(%$C+?+&$'(4,?(I,-#(L$+?%(&,(=,5$(V(+(4+&$(5+-L(?$4"#$$(4+5*I*$%(*-(
,&G$?(&*5$%(+-'N,?(*-(,&G$?(CI+=$%(G+M$(&,(4+=$7(]*W$R*%$6(R*&G(%5+?&CG,-$%(?$4"#$$%(
=+-(C$?5+-$-&IL(%&+L(*-(&,"=G(R*&G(&G,%$(&G$L(G+'(&,(I$+M$(>$G*-'(*-(!L?*+(#*M*-#(?$4"A(
#$$%(+I%,(&G$(5$+-%(&,(%&+L(=I,%$(&,(&G$($M$-&%(*-(&G$*?(G,5$(=,"-&?L(>L(*-'$C$-'$-&(
?$C,?&%(4?,5(C$,CI$(&G$L(&?"%&7((
 
FG*?'6(&G$(+44,?'+-=$%(,4(&G$(%5+?&CG,-$(=,5>*-$'(R*&G(&G$(?$4"#$$%Z(=,??$%C,-'*-#(
"%$(C?+=&*=$%(*-'$$'(=G+-#$(C,R$?(?$I+&*,-%(>$&R$$-(*-'*M*'"+I%(+-'(+"&G,?*&*$%7(E$4"A(
#$$%(R*&G(%5+?&CG,-$%(',-Z&(G+M$(&,(%&+?&(4?,5(&G$(%=?+&=G(,-IL(&,(5+W$(&G$(%+5$(5*%A(
&+W$%(+%(&G,%$(?$4"#$$%(C?$=$'*-#7(FG$L(+?$(C$?5+-$-&IL(=,--$=&$'(&,(4I,R%(,4(*-4,?A(
5+&*,-(+-'(C$,CI$(.%$$(+I%,()+%&$II%6(89991(*-(&G$(4,?5(,4(&G$($YC$?*$-=$%(+-'(&G$(
W-,RI$'#$(+=="5"I+&$'(>L(&G,"%+-'%(,4(?$4"#$$%7(FG$(W-,RI$'#$(*%(-,&(,-IL(I*5*&$'(&,(
C+%&($M$-&%(>"&(*-=I"'$%("C'+&$%(,-(&G$(&G*-#%(#,*-#(,-(%*5"I&+-$,"%IL(*-(,&G$?(CI+=$%6(
+&(,&G$?(>,?'$?%6(*-(,&G$?(=,"-&?*$%7(FG*%(W-,RI$'#$(=G+-#$%(C,R$?(?$I+&*,-%(5,%&('*A(
?$=&IL(+%(*&(#*M$%(?$4"#$$%(,C&*,-%(&,(+=&6(+-'(?$'"=$%(&G$(*-4,?5+&*,-(%"C$?*,?*&L(>,?'$?(
=,-&?,I%(+-'(,&G$?(+"&G,?*&*$%("%$'(%&?+&$#*=+IIL7(FG$(%G*4&(>$=,5$%(+I%,(M$?L(C+IC+>I$(
*-(&G$(=+%$(,4(&G,%$(RG,(*-&$-'(&,(5+W$(+(C?,4*&(,"&(,4(?$4"#$$%($7#7(>L(,44$?*-#(5,-$L(
=G+-#$(,-(,M$?C?*=$'(?+&$%7(D-%&$+'(,4(O"%&(+==$C&*-#(&G$(=,-'*&*,-%6(?$4"#$$%(=+-(
=G$=W(&G$(+=&"+I(?+&$%(,-(&G$*?(%5+?&CG,-$%(&,(&G$-(5+W$(&G$*?(=I+*57( 
!,(*-(&G$(=+%$(,4(?$4"#$$%6(&G$(C,&$-&*+I(,4(%5+?&CG,-$%(+%("-*M$?%+I('$M*=$%(&,(+=&"+IIL(
=G+-#$(C,R$?(?$I+&*,-%(+-'(&G"%(I*4$(%&,?*$%(>$=,5$%(+CC+?$-&(,-=$(5,?$7(_$?$6(
%5+?&CG,-$%(+?$($5C,R$?*-#(&,,I%(&G+&(#*M$(-$R(I$M$I%(,4(+#$-=L(&,(C$,CI$(*-(%&+&$%(,4(



$5$?#$-=L7(/I&G,"#G(*&(*%(&G$(=,--$=&*M$(C,R$?(,4(&G$(D-&$?-$&(&G+&(I*$%(>$-$+&G($+=G(
+-'($M$?L(,-$(,4(&G$(?$4"#$$%Z(C?+=&*=$%6(*&(*%(,-IL(>L(%5+?&CG,-$%(+%(5,>*I$('$M*=$%( 
&G+&(&G*%(C,R$?(=+-(+=&"+IIL(>$(+CCI*$'(*-(%"=G(=?*&*=+I(%*&"+&*,-%(&G+&(,4&$-(=,5$(R*&G(
'*44*="I&(=,-'*&*,-%7(X$(C?,>+>IL(G+M$(,-IL(>$#"-(&,(#?+%C(&G$(4"II(5$+-*-#(,4(+(5,>*I$6(
=,--$=&$'($M$?L'+L(I*4$(4,?($M$?L,-$(*-(&G*%(R,?I'7((
 
4#5#'#67#)! 
)+%&$II%6(T7(.899917(!"#$*75#$(-$3"#$4#3)(*;$5(87#3:$<=4+$#+>?>(<Y4,?'6(P737(+-'(T+I'$-6(
P7!72(X*I$LAJI+=WR$II7((
(
_,?%&6(_7(/76(\(F+LI,?6(U7(J7(.89:`17(FG$(?,I$(,4(5,>*I$(CG,-$%(*-(&G$(5$'*+&*,-(,4(>,?A
'$?(=?,%%*-#%2(+(%&"'L(,4(_+*&*(+-'(&G$(b,5*-*=+-(E$C">I*=7(!"#$@.53*26724$9(.*426$(-$
@43"*('(6(/:A$=B.816(:@@A:H97(
(
3*56(c7(.89:@6(b$=$5>$?(d:17(T,>*I$(CG,-$(4,?($5C,R$?5$-&e(KI,>+I(-+--*$%(*-(0+?*%7(
C#+72A$D.63.*#$E$1(87#3:A$FG.`16(@8@A@df7((
(
T+'*+-,"6(T7(\(T*II$?6(b7(.89:817(C7/*237(4$24+$H#)$C#+720$!*2454237(426$I2&767#5$24+$
J(6:&#+72>$g$R(c,?W2(E,"&I$'#$7((
(
<*+?a+>+I6(076(\(E$*C%6(P7(b7(.89:817(T*#?+&*,-(+-'('*+%C,?+(*-(&G$(+#$(,4(*-4,?5+&*,-(
+-'(=,55"-*=+&*,-(&$=G-,I,#*$%7(9(.*426$(-$%3"478$24+$C7/*237(4$13.+7#5A$FG.f16(:dddA(
:ddB7((
(
0,-a+-$%*6(!76(\(]$"?%6(37(.89:`17(<-('*#*&+I(=?,%%*-#%(*-(U"?,C$7(D*(5574/50$9(.*426$(-$
C7/*237(4$E$D.63.*#A$B<:16(dA887(
((
!M$-%%,-6(^76(\(X+5+I+(]+?%%,-6()7(.89:@6(b$=$5>$?(f17(!*&"+&$'($5C,R$?5$-&2(T,A(
>*I$(CG,-$%(C?+=&*=$%(+5,-#(5+?W$&(R,5$-(*-(3+5C+I+7(C(K76#$C#+72$E$D(&&.4782L$
37(4A$M<816(89@A8897(((
(
X+II6(T76()+5C>$II6(T7<7(\(^+->$W6(b7(.89:@17(!L?*+-(?$4"#$$%(+-'(*-4,?5+&*,-(C?$=+?*A
&L7(H#)$C#+72$E$1(87#3:>(/'M+-=$(,-I*-$(C">I*=+&*,-7(',*2(:97::HHN:`;:```B:@@f:f;H(
h89:;A9BA:`i7(