Baltic Journal of Economic Studies 50 Vol. 8 No. 4, 2022 This is an Open Access article, distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution CC BY 4.0 1 Sumy National Agrarian University, Ukraine (corresponding author) E-mail: bohdan.hnatkivskyi@lnu.edu.ua ORCID: https://orcid.org/0000-0001-5146-9077 2 State Biotechnological University, Ukraine E-mail: poltavetsanatolii949@gmail.com ORCID: https://orcid.org/0000-0002-3310-3271 3 Sumy National Agrarian University, Ukraine ORCID: https://orcid.org/0000-0002-0624-2938 DOI: https://doi.org/10.30525/2256-0742/2022-8-4-50-57 ANALYSIS OF THE CURRENT STATE OF ORGANIZATION OF LAND USE MANAGEMENT IN AGRICULTURAL ENTERPRISES Bohdan Hnatkivskyi1, Anatolii Poltavets2, Olena Havrylchenko3 Abstract. The subject of the research is to study the current state of organization of land use management in agricultural enterprises. Methodology. In the course of the study, general scientific methods were used, in particular, theoretical generalization; methods of analysis and synthesis and statistical analysis, the method of SWOT-analysis of opportunities and threats was applied, and the graphical method was used to visualize the results of the study. The aim of the article is to analyze the current state of organization of land use management in agricultural enterprises. Conclusions of the study. Thus, having systematized the factors that determine the peculiarities of the organization of land management in agricultural enterprises, three groups were identified: natural-climatic and geographical, organizational-economic, agrotechnical and agrochemical. Based on the SWOT analysis of land resources as an object of management, it is determined that the purpose of land resources management of agricultural enterprises is to ensure the efficient use of land as the main factor of agricultural production in the long term on the basis of reproduction of productive land and increase the sustainability of agricultural landscapes, taking into account the balance of public and private interests. It should be noted that all subjects of land relations have the opportunity to minimize the negative consequences caused by the manifestation of weaknesses of land resources identified on the basis of SWOT analysis. First of all, such opportunities are related to the increase of state support for agriculture and rural development; strengthening of state control over the targeted use of agricultural land and its reproduction; improvement of the financial condition of agricultural enterprises and intensification of their innovation activities; development of adaptive landscape farming systems; appearance on the market of innovations in the form of new breeding-genetic, technical-technological and organizational-managerial solutions that ensure the preservation and improvement of the consumer qualities of productive lands, as well as the prevention of their degradation. Key words: land resources, land relations, agricultural enterprises, management of land resources, management organization of use. JEL Classification: E20, H56, O10 1. Introduction An indispensable condition for the comprehensive improvement of agricultural production, based on a variety of forms of ownership and management, is the effective and rational use of land resources, which brings to the fore the formation of land relations adequate to the market economy as the basis of production relations in agriculture regarding the implementation of land ownership. In the course of agrarian reforms, the problems of land use have become more acute: soil depletion and productivity of agricultural land are increasing, farming systems and production technologies are being disrupted, reclamation and soil protection works have virtually ceased. In modern theory and practice of land resources management a special role belongs to a group of economic methods. Their essence is to determine the ways of influencing the material and property interests of land use entities aimed at the efficient use and preservation of the resource potential of land with the use of rent assessment tools, comparison of costs and results in the process of stimulating active and more productive economic activity. The application of economic methods of land resources management in the agricultural sector of the economy has a number of specific features. Baltic Journal of Economic Studies 51 Vol. 8 No. 4, 2022 Their purpose is the fastest possible adaptation of agricultural producers to qualitatively new conditions of management, as well as minimization of negative processes that worsen the possibilities of land use. Management methods should be adapted to regional conditions. The main methods are differentiation of land payments depending on the quality of land, location, type of use and composition of land. In addition, fines are sometimes applied for loss of soil fertility, erosion, violation of land and environmental legislation. In addition, in the theory and practice of land resources management there are various methods that differ in approaches and specific features of management, the degree of impact on the object of management, such as technical, technological, political, organizational, managerial, socio-psychological, etc. The research of solving the problems of managing the use of land resources of agricultural enterprises is devoted to the work of many scientists, but the current situation in agriculture requires new ideas, assessment of ongoing processes, updating methods of economic recovery and its stabilization, improving the efficiency of land use. In this regard, a number of scientific, theoretical, methodological and practical problems need to be solved. Particularly acute are the issues of objectively necessary priorities in the implementation of measures to manage the use of land resources, the principles and conditions for the implementation of these measures, the creation of a mechanism that will ensure the efficient use of land resources, and other organizational issues. 2. Current state of organization of land use management in agricultural enterprises Land relations are a special economic category not only because of the specifics of land as an object of common interest, but also because of its dual nature, that is, it participates in the reproduction process as a natural factor and as a commodity. In this regard, the aspects characterizing land resources can be divided into two groups: technological aspect (effective use of the natural potential of land) and socio-economic aspect (cost parameters) (Korobska, 2020; Popov, 2018). When distributing land resources, the first group of interests is aimed at the functional and economic properties of the land fund: the scale, proportions and priorities of its distribution in accordance with the level of economic development; types of their intended use; intensity of exploitation, productivity, as well as environmental conditions. Table 1 Distribution of the land fund of Ukraine by types of land in 2020 (Agropolit.com, 2020) Оblast (region) Agricultural land, thousand ha of them: arable fallow haymakers pastures perennial plantations Vinnytsia 2012 1730 1 49 184 48 Volhynia 1048 672 0 162 202 12 Dnipro 2512 2127 0,03 17 314 53 Donetsk 2044 1654 1 43 289 58 Zhytomyr 1504 1144 41 119 178 22 Transcarpathian 451 200 0 94 129 27 Zaporizhzhia 2238 1901 0 83 216 38 Ivano-Frankivsk 621 401 2 82 121 15 Kyiv 1609 1321 13 101 117 57 Kropyvnytskyi 2032 1769 0 23 216 24 Luhansk 1907 1275 45 94 462 30 Lviv 1240 771 0,2 192 251 23 Mykolaiv 2000 1708 4 3 252 34 Odesa 2588 2077 27 51 351 82 Poltava 2167 1817 2 142 183 23 Rivne 922 658 3 126 124 11 Sumy 1695 1235 0,04 273 165 23 Ternopil 1035 851 3 24 145 14 Kharkiv 2361 1937 8 109 286 42 Kherson 1962 1780 0 10 150 23 Khmelnytskyi 1561 1326 0,7 91 105 38 Cherkasy 1450 1272 8 64 78 27 Chernivtsi 470 331 0 41 68 30 Chernihiv 2060 1456 22 297 262 24 Total in Ukraine 41329 32698 190 2294 5263 864 Baltic Journal of Economic Studies 52 Vol. 8 No. 4, 2022 The most important type of land resources is agricultural land, which serves as the main means of production and subject of labor. They are subject to special protection and their transfer to other categories for non-agricultural needs is allowed only in exceptional cases. The distribution of the land fund of Ukraine by types of land is shown in Table 1. Currently, Ukrainians cultivate about one third of arable land in Europe, or 32.7 million hectares. Also, according to statistics, there are twice as many people per one inhabitant of Ukraine than per one European. In the structure of land holdings, the bulk of land is privately owned, about 31 million hectares, and 10.4 million hectares are in state and communal ownership. At the same time, about a third of the land, 32.7 million hectares, is under arable land. The largest amount of agricultural land is cultivated in Odesa, Zaporizhzhia and Kharkiv regions – more than 2 200 thousand hectares. The least land is owned by residents of Transcarpathian and Chernivtsi regions – less than 500 thousand hectares (Agropolit.com, 2020). In Ukraine, land use is subject to payment. The purpose of the land payment is to stimulate the rational use, protection and restoration of land, increase soil fertility, formation of special funds to finance these measures, as well as filling local budgets. The forms of payment for land are land tax and rent. The introduction of land tax is caused by the need to increase the efficiency of agricultural production through more rational use of land and other factors. Local budgets in European countries are mostly filled with revenues from the taxation of real estate (including land), the share of which reaches one third, or even exceeds half of all tax revenues of local budgets. In Ukraine, it is relatively low – only 13% (including almost 10% of the land payment) (Figure 1) (Tsina derzhavy, 2019). The cost of land lease depends on the demand, the level of competition, the type of agricultural land, whether it is arable land, hayfields, pastures or perennial plantations, the quality of the land, as well as the level of awareness of potential buyers. In the system of payments for land, rent is a market indicator to a greater extent than land tax. This is logical, since the practice of annual adjustment of rent rates for the use of land plots allowed most landlords to bring them in line with the level of demand for them. For the state authorities that determine the amount of land taxation and other indicators of land value (cadastral value, market value), rent can serve as an indicator of the market value of land plots of different purpose and location in accordance with supply and demand. It should be emphasized that in foreign economic literature the concepts of rent are essentially perceived as identical. Indeed, all types of rents are essentially modified forms of land rent extraction, and fluctuations in land rent rates reflect trends in rent changes. According to the results of research by scientists of the Institute of Agrarian Economics, the highest cost of renting one hectare of state-owned agricultural land is recorded in Kropyvnytskyi region – 8.4 thou- sand UAH, and the lowest – 0.9 thousand UAH – in Transcarpathian region (Figure 2) (Agropolit.com, 2019; Agropolit.com, 2020). 6 2,1 2,5 77 13 20,4 63,4 51 24 4 9 13 57 65 30 18,8 18,5 44 13,6 41,4 33 10 5,1 44,5 35,6 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100 Ukraine Czech Republic Slovakia Poland Hungary Italy France VAT and excise duties рersonal income tax profit tax real estate tax, including land tax other taxes Figure 1. Structure of revenues to local budgets of European countries (in 2020), % (Tsina derzhavy, 2019) Baltic Journal of Economic Studies 53 Vol. 8 No. 4, 2022 Thus, in Ukraine, the average annual rent for state-owned land plots leased at land auctions is 3431 UAH/ha, while the average annual rent for shares is 1613 UAH/ha. Agricultural production involves the use of both productive land (agricultural land) and land on which objects related to the activities of agricultural entities are located. Ensuring the reproduction of productive lands is one of the priority tasks in the organization of management of the use of agricultural land resources. Reproduction of agricul- tural land resources is carried out in the process of their economic use. Withdrawal of land from economic turnover, as a rule, leads to its degradation associated with the loss of consumer qualities and increased costs necessary for their reintroduction into the production process. The close intertwining of the processes of repro- duction of agricultural land resources with the processes of agricultural production determines the dependence of the efficiency of reproduction processes on a set of various factors that affect their quality in different ways. It is proposed to systematize the factors that determine the peculiarities of land resources management of agricultural enterprises by the following groups: natural-climatic and geographical, organizational- economic, agrotechnical and agroche-mical (Table 2). The organization of land use management in agricultural enterprises is considered as one of the functions of the farming system, which includes the introduction of crop rotations, soil cultivation, application of fertilizers and plant protection products, seed production, technological and technical support, land reclamation and environ- mental protection measures. Particular attention in the management of land resources of agricultural enterprises has recently been paid to the systems of adaptive landscape farming, which allow to take into account the characteristics of each land plot involved in economic circulation, and to ensure the growth of agricultural landscapes sustainability and preservation of soil fertility. Obviously, these factors have a complex impact on the reproduction of land resources, which makes it extremely difficult to reliably assess the individual level of impact of each of them. To assess the efficiency of land resources reproduction, it is proposed to use indicators that reflect changes in soil fertility, productivity of arable land and natural forage lands, the share of land subject to wind and water erosion, the proportion of land involved in economic turnover, the number of land disputes that arise and the effectiveness of their resolution, etc. Kr op yv ny tsk yi Vo lhy nia Figure 2. Average annual rent for state-owned land plots leased out at land auctions for the sale of land shares (units) by regions of Ukraine (2020), thousand UAH/ha Baltic Journal of Economic Studies 54 Vol. 8 No. 4, 2022 3. Analysis of opportunities and threats to the organization of land use management in agricultural enterprises The state, using a wide range of administrative and economic management methods, promotes the formation of an adequate institutional environment of land relations, which regulates the processes of land management, including their reproduction. The practically uncontrolled growth of land concentration in the hands of large agricultural enterprises, combined with the growing intensity of productive land use, necessitates a review of issues related to the organization of land use management of agricultural enterprises aimed at ensuring a balance of interests of the state, landowners and land users of agricultural land. Land as a strategic resource of agricultural production has a number of features that determine its strengths and weaknesses as a factor of production, and requires an objective assessment of the possibilities of improving the efficiency of reproductive processes and identifying threats to the loss of land reproduction and its degradation. The development of the national economy is impossible without the formation and implemen- tation of an effective policy in the field of distribution and use of land resources. Formation of strategic directions of land use and land ownership is possible only with the help of modern research tools. The search for tools for strategic analysis of the formation, distribution and use of land resources makes it possible to assert that a wide range of analytical tools can be used to study the development of land relations and develop strategic goals for the long term: business advantage models, McNair's performance pyramid, benchmarking, SWOT analysis, discriminant analysis, cluster analysis, PESTEL analysis, etc. (Dankevich, 2018). SWOT analysis is one of the most common analytical methods that allows to comprehensively assess the strengths and weaknesses of the company, as well as the opportunities and threats affecting it. Conducting a SWOT analysis is important because identifying opportunities and threats related to the organization of land management in agricultural enterprises should be the basis for turning opportunities into strengths and preventing the realization of threats by taking appropriate measures to prevent them (Table 3). The strengths of agricultural land as an object of land resources management of agricultural enterprises are as follows: productive lands have natural reproductive potential, which can be increased in the process of their rational use in economic activity; in Ukraine, soils are characterized by a high level of natural fertility; diversity of soils and natural climatic zones allows to grow a wide range of crops; rural areas of zones with a high level of soil and agro-climatic potential are characterized by a high level of agricultural development; Increasing the efficiency of agricultural production has provided an increase in the quality of the material and technical base of agricultural enterprises and an increase in investment in the reproduction of productive land; the tendency to involve previously unused agricultural land in economic circulation (Sharyi, Tymoshevskyi, Mishchenko, Yurko, 2019; Kovaliv, 2016) At the same time, land resources as a factor of production give rise to a number of problems related Table 2 Systematization of factors that determine the features of the organization of land use management at agricultural enterprises Natural-climatic and geographical Organizational and economic Agrotechnical and agrochemical Temperature regime Intensity of use of productive land Following the scientifically proved agricultural system Topography and threats of wind and water erosion Level of efficiency of land users functioning Land processing technologies Soil fertility Level of development of technical and technological base of land users Level of use of fertilizers and plant protection products Moisture supply Level of economic development of territories Scale and effectiveness of environmental protection measures Level of active solar radiation Level of development of infrastructure and personnel support Technologies for growing agricultural crops Type of agricultural landscape Level of investment attractiveness of agricultural production Level of biologization of agriculture Location relative to places of processing and sale of products Availability of target programs for preserving soil fertility Improving the productive qualities of natural fodder lands Location relative to transport network locations Quality of state control over land use and protection Level of farming culture Baltic Journal of Economic Studies 55 Vol. 8 No. 4, 2022 to the organization of land use management in agricultural enterprises, which can be defined as weaknesses. These include the diversity of soils and climatic conditions that require diversification of farming systems and constant adaptation of agricultural technologies to changing economic conditions; the uniqueness of each land plot, which requires consideration of specific features in the organization of use and reproduction, implementation of measures for the conservation and development of agricultural landscapes; limited capacities of agricultural enterprises to develop and implement a strategy for the transition to adaptive landscape farming systems; the presence of certain contradictions between the ecological and economic efficiency of reproductive processes, which require a compromise between the possibilities of increasing the intensity of land use and increasing the sustainability of agro- ecosystems by reducing the level of anthropogenic pressure; lack of an effective system of state regulation of reproduction of productive lands and stimulation of land users and landowners to increase their fertility; underdevelopment of the land market and land mortgage system, which significantly reduces the consumer properties of land as an element of the subsystem of financial support of economic activity (Dankevich, 2018). It should be emphasized that all subjects of land relations have the opportunity to minimize the negative consequences caused by the manifestation of the above-mentioned shortcomings of land resources. First of all, such opportunities are related to the increase of state support for agriculture and rural development; strengthening of state control over the targeted use of agricultural land and its reproduction; improvement of the financial condition of agricultural enterprises and intensification of their innovation activities; development of adaptive Table 3 Matrix of SWOT analysis of opportunities and threats to the organization of land use management in agricultural enterprises Strengths Weaknesses – productive lands have natural reproductive potential, which can be increased in the process of their rational use in economic activity; – in Ukraine, soils are characterized by a high level of natural fertility; – the diversity of soils and climatic zones allows to grow a wide range of crops; – rural areas of zones with high soil and agroclimatic potential are characterized by a high level of agricultural development; – increase in the efficiency of agricultural production is ensured by the growth of the quality of the material and technical base of agricultural enterprises and the increase in investments in the reproduction of productive lands; – the tendency to involve previously unused agricultural land into economic circulation – diversity of soils and climatic conditions that require diversification of farming systems and constant adaptation of agricultural technologies to changing economic conditions; – uniqueness of each land plot, which requires consideration of specific features in the organization of use and reproduction, implementation of measures for the conservation and development of agricultural landscapes; – limited capacity of agricultural enterprises to develop and implement a strategy for the transition to adaptive landscape farming systems; – the presence of certain contradictions between the environmental and economic efficiency of reproductive processes, which require a compromise between the possibilities of increasing the intensity of land use and increasing the sustainability of agro-ecosystems by reducing the level of anthropogenic pressure; – lack of an effective system of state regulation of reproduction of productive lands and stimulation of land users and landowners to increase their fertility; – underdevelopment of the land market and land mortgage system, which significantly reduces the consumer properties of land as an element of the subsystem of financial support of economic activity. Opportunities Threats – increasing the volume of state support for agriculture and rural development; – strengthening state control over the targeted use of agricultural land and its reproduction; – improving the financial condition of agricultural enterprises and intensifying their innovative activities; – development of adaptive landscape farming systems; – appearance of innovations in the market in the form of new breeding and genetic, technical, technological, organizational and managerial solutions that ensure the preservation and improvement of consumer qualities of productive lands, as well as prevention of their degradation. – almost uncontrolled concentration of agricultural land in the hands of large agricultural enterprises; – the presence of a significant number of land plots that are not registered in the cadastre, which leads to the existence of the shadow sector of land use and lack of proper control over the reproduction of land resources; – the possibility of reducing state support for agriculture; – imbalance between large, medium and small forms of agricultural production leads to a decrease in the efficiency of reproduction of land resources of farms and households; – reduction of the rural population and its labor potential Baltic Journal of Economic Studies 56 Vol. 8 No. 4, 2022 landscape farming systems; appearance on the market of innovations in the form of new breeding-genetic, technical-technological and organizational-managerial solutions that ensure the preservation and growth of consumer qualities of productive lands, as well as the prevention of their degradation. There are also a number of systemic problems that threaten the reproduction of land resources. Among them, the following threats should be highlighted: almost uncontrolled concentration of agricultural land in the hands of large companies; the presence of a significant number of land plots not registered in the cadastre, which leads to the existence of the shadow sector of land use and lack of proper control over the reproduction of land resources; the possibility of reducing state support for agriculture; imbalance between large, medium and small forms of agricultural production leads to a decrease in the efficiency of reproduction of land resources of farms and households; reduction of the rural population and its labor potential (Ibatullin, Stepenko, Sakal, 2012). The organization of land use management in agricultural enterprises should be focused on the fullest use of their strengths and available opportu- nities to improve the efficiency of their use, which minimize the negative impact of conditions and threats that adversely affect the reproduction of productive land (Miroshnychenko, 2010; Dekhtyarenko, Drapikovskyi, Ivanova, 2009). Most scholars study the changes in the impact of governance in the context of war and globalization (Pryshchepa, Kardash, Yakymchuk, 2020; Irtyshcheva, et etc., 2022; Vyshnevska, et al., 2022). On this basis, the purpose of land use management of agricultural enterprises is to ensure the efficient use of land as the main factor of agricultural production in the long term on the basis of reproduction of productive land and increasing the sustainability of agricultural landscapes, taking into account the balance of public and private interests. It is proposed to highlight the following as priority tasks for the organization of land use management in agricultural enterprises: – Conducting a comprehensive inventory of agri- cultural land with the definition of real boundaries of land plots, their registration in the cadastre and delimitation of property rights; – completion of re-registration of land shares into specific forms of ownership of specific land plots; – formation of land market infrastructure, streng- thening state control over the level of concentration of productive land in individual owners, ensuring transparency of all land transactions; – development of institutional environment for regulation of land relations and public control over land turnover and efficiency of its use; – development of a system of motivation of landow- ners and land users in preserving soil fertility and consumer properties of productive lands; – identification of land plots that require immediate environmental protection measures and minimization of anthropogenic load, as well as development of measures to improve agricultural landscapes; – development of a wide range of scientifically based modern farming systems, taking into account the natural and climatic characteristics of specific territo- ries and the production direction of economic entities; – development of recommendations on the location of agricultural production by territories and categories of economic entities, which ensure the increase of efficiency of productive land use. The implementation of these tasks requires the concentration of efforts and resources of all subjects of land relations, but it should be noted that certain functions of the organization of land use management in agricultural enterprises also belong to the compe- tence of the state, which within the framework of land policy determines the strategy of productive land use and their reproduction. 4. Conclusions Thus, having systematized the factors that deter- mine the peculiarities of the organization of land management in agricultural enterprises, three groups were identified: natural-climatic and geographical, organizational-economic, agrotechnical and agro- chemical. Based on the SWOT analysis of land resources as an object of management, it is deter- mined that the purpose of land resources management of agricultural enterprises is to ensure the efficient use of land as the main factor of agricultural production in the long term on the basis of reproduction of productive land and increase the sustainability of agricultural landscapes, taking into account the balance of public and private interests. It should be noted that all subjects of land relations have opportunities to minimize the negative consequences caused by the manifestation of weaknesses of land resources identified on the basis of SWOT analysis. First of all, these opportunities are associated with an increase in state support for agriculture and rural development; strengthening of state control over the targeted use of agricultural land and its reproduction; improvement of the financial condition of agricultural enterprises and intensifi- cation of their innovative activities; development of adaptive landscape farming systems; appearance of innovations in the market in the form of new breeding and genetic, technical, technological, organizational and managerial solutions that ensure the preservation and improvement of consumer qualities of productive lands, as well as prevention of their degradation. Baltic Journal of Economic Studies 57 Vol. 8 No. 4, 2022 References: Korobska, A. O. (2020). State regulation of agricultural land use in Ukraine (PhD Thesis). Kamianets-Podilskyi. Popov, A. S. (2018). Development of agricultural land consolidation: world experience and Ukrainian perspectives: monograph. Kharkiv: FOP Panov A. M. Agropolit.com (2020). Land Directory of Ukraine 2020. Available at: https://agropolit.com/storage/2020/ Zemelniy_dovidnyk_2020.pdf ?utm_source=mailchimp&utm_campaign=0300ccc2e1f0&utm_medium=page (accessed August 21, 2022). Tsina derzhavy (2019). How do local budgets in European countries and Ukraine earn money? Available at: https://cost.ua/744-na-chomu-zaroblyayut-mistsevi-byudzhety-v-krayinakh-evropy-ta-v-ukrayini/ (accessed August 21, 2022). Agropolit.com (2019). The highest cost of land rent was recorded in Kirovohrad Oblast. Available at: https://agropolit.com/news/13269-nayvischa-vartist-orendi-zemli-zafiksovana-na-kirovogradschini (accessed August 21, 2022). Dankevich, V. E. (2018). SWOT and PESTEL analysis of the current state of land relations in Ukraine. Economy of agro-industrial complex, vol. 7, рp. 93–103. Sharyi, G. I., Tymoshevskyi, V. V., Mishchenko, R . A., & Yurko, I. A. (2019). Management of land resources: a study guide. Poltava: PoltNTU. Kovaliv, O. (2016). Implementation of land reform in Ukraine: a new paradigm: monograph. Kyiv: DIA. Martyn, A. G. (2011). Regulation of the land market in Ukraine: monograph. Kyiv: Agrar Media Group. Ibatullin, Sh. I., Stepenko, O. V., & Sakal, O. V. (2012). Mechanisms of management of land relations in the context of ensuring sustainable development. Kyiv: State institution "Institute of Environmental Economics and Sustainable Development of the National Academy of Sciences of Ukraine". Miroshnychenko, A. M. (2010). Conflicts in legal regulation of land relations in Ukraine. (2nd ed.). Kyiv: Alerta. Dekhtyarenko, Yu. F., Drapikovskyi, O. I., & Ivanova, I. B. (2009). Regulation of land relations in the modern city: monograph. In Vakulenko V. M., Orlatogo M. K. (Ed.). Kyiv: NADU. Pryshchepa, O., Kardash, O., Yakymchuk, A., et al.(2020). Optimization of multi-channel queuing systems with a single retail attempt: Economic approach. Decision Science Letters, vol. 9(4), рp. 559–564. Irtyshcheva, I. and etc. (2022). The economy of war and postwar economic development: world and Ukrainian realities. Baltic Journal of Economic Studies, vol. 8, рр. 78–82. Irtyshcheva, I., et al. (2022). Development of socialization of the economy on the conditions of financing sports and health activities. International Journal of Health Sciences, vol. 6, рp. 2819–2826. Vyshnevska, O. et al. (2022). The Influence of Globalization Processes on Forecasting the Activities of Market Entities. Journal of Optimization in Industrial Engineering, vol. 15(1), рp. 261–268. Received on: 21th of September, 2022 Accepted on: 27th of October, 2022 Published on: 30th of November, 2022