Bangladesh J. Plant Taxon. 31(1): 187-195, 2024 (June) - Review paper © 2024 Bangladesh Association of Plant Taxonomists DOI: https://doi.org/10.3329/bjpt.v29i2.74402 SYSTEMATIC POSITION OF MIYAKEA INTEGRIFOLIA MIYABE & TATEW. IN THE INFRAGENERIC CLASSIFICATION OF PULSATILLA (RANUNCULACEAE): PALYNOLOGICAL CHALLENGES A.K.M. GOLAM SARWAR1* AND HIDEKI TAKAHASHI2 1Laboratory of Plant Systematics, Department of Crop Botany, Bangladesh Agricultural University, Mymensingh 2202, Bangladesh 2The Hokkaido University Museum, Hokkaido University, N10 W8, Sapporo 060-0810, Japan Keywords: Miyakea; pollen morphology; Pulsatilla. Abstract Miyakea integrifolia Miyabe and Tatew. was considered to be an endemic genus and species to Sakhalin Island, Russia, but the monotypic genus Miyakea was later subsumed into Pulsatilla as P. integrifolia (Miyabe & Tatew.) Vorosch. This taxonomic treatment has been supported by many botanists. At present, there are two opinions on the systematic position of P. integrifolia within the genus Pulsatilla: i) a separate monotypic subgenus Miyakea situated at the last position; ii) a close relative of P. patens and P. vernalis in ser. Patentes within the species-rich subgen. Pulsatilla. Since palynological evidence might be promising morphological traits for clarifying the systematic position of Miyakea, a table summarizing the pollen morphological traits within the genus Pulsatilla was prepared using the previous appropriate palynological reports. Hitherto, the morphology of Miyakea pollen supports the second opinion i.e., a close relative of P. patens and P. vernalis. Moreover, we pointed out the issues that should be focused on in future research on the pollen morphology of Pulsatilla s.l. Introduction Genus Pulsatilla Miller (Pasqueflowers), contains ca. 40 perennial species, belongs to the tribe Anemoneae DC., subfamily Ranunculoideae Hutch. in the family Ranunculaceae A.L.Juss. (Tamura, 1991, 1993, 1995). Although phylogenies based on molecular data indicated that Pulsatilla was embedded within Anemone s.l. (Hoot et al., 1994, 2012), all previous molecular phylogenetic studies agreed regarding the monophyly of the genus Pulsatilla (Sramkó et al., 2019); therefore, the genus Pulsatilla is retained here. Miyakea integrifolia Miyabe and Tatew., a closely related taxon of Pulsatilla, was collected from the mountain range of the palaeozoic formation situated on the Sea of Okhotsk side of Sakhalin Island in 1934 and was first described as a new monotypic and endemic genus in 1935 (Miyabe and Tatewaki, 1935, 1937). The presence of coriaceous, simple, entire, and evergreen radical leaves with three prominent parallel veins on the underside was regarded as the most prominent generic feature of this taxon (Miyabe and Tatewaki, 1935, 1941). Although the generic status had been maintained by Sugawara (1939), Czerepanov (1995), Starodubtsev (1995), Smirnov (2002), Barkalov and Taran (2004), Nishikawa (2008) and Eryemin et al. (2019). Voroshilov (1966) considered the genus Miyakea to be Pulsatilla and published the name P. integrifolia (Miyabe & Tatew.) Vorosch. This view was followed by Czerepanov (1973) and Voroshilov (1982); furthermore, Tamura (1991, 1995) and Grey-Wilson (2014, 2020) recognized this species as a separate monotypic subgenus Miyakea situated at the last position *Corresponding author, E-mail: drsarwar@bau.edu.bd https://doi.org/10.3329/bjpt.v29i2.74402 mailto:drsarwar@bau.edu.bd 188 SARWAR AND TAKAHASHI within the classification system of Pulsatilla. On the other hand, the most recent molecular phylogenetic study by Sramkó et al. (2019) showed that M. integrifolia is subsumed into the genus Pulsatilla but is considered to be a closely related sister species to P. vernalis in ser. Patentes of subgen. Pulsatilla. Thus, ser. Patentes has been composed of three Pulsatilla species: P. integrifolia [≡Miyakea integrifolia], P. patens, and P. vernalis. The inclusion of P. integrifolia and P. vernalis within ser. Patentes is an unexpected result, as no specialist of Pulsatilla has ever considered the species included in this clade to be related (Sramkó et al., 2019). Several studies on the pollen morphology of Pulsatilla species have been conducted: Kumazawa (1936), Ikuse (1956, 2001), Huynh (1970), Nakamura (1980), and Wang et al. (1995) with light microscopy (LM); Clarke et al. (1991) and Baladehi et al. (2013) with LM and scanning electron microscopy (SEM); Nowicke and Skvarla (1995), Miyoshi et al. (2011), Fujiki et al. (2016), and Sarwar and Takahashi (2023) with SEM; Xi (1985) and PalDat (2023) with LM, SEM, and transmission electron microscopy (TEM). Palynological studies of Miyakea integrifolia [as P. integrifolia] have not been carried out except for the SEM micrograph shown by Nowicke and Skvarla (1995) in “Die Natürlichen Pflanzenfamilien” on the family Ranunculaceae (Hiepko, 1995). A summary table of the palynological traits of Pulsatilla including Miyakea integrifolia was made from appropriate palynological references (Huynh, 1970; Xi, 1985; Clarke et al., 1991; Nowicke and Skvarla, 1995; Miyoshi et al., 2011; Baladehi et al., 2013; Fujiki et al., 2016; Sarwar and Takahashi, 2023; PalDat, 2023) following the classification system within the genus Pulsatilla by Sramkó et al. (2019) (Table 1). Descriptive terminology follows Punt et al. (1994, 2007) and Hesse et al. (2009). An overview of pollen morphological traits in the infrageneric taxonomy of Pulsatilla by Sramkó et al. (2019) The most recent DNA-based classification of Pulsatilla by Sramkó et al. (2019) is characterized by the following three main results; i) the genus was separated into three subgenera, Kostyczewianae, Preonanthus and Pulsatilla, ii) the monotypic subgen. Kostyczewianae consisting of only P. kostyczewii was basally placed in the classification, iii) three species (P. integrifolia [≡Miyakea integrifolia], P. patens s.l. and P. vernalis) formed the single ser. Patentes of sect. Pulsatilla within the species-rich third subgen. Pulsatilla. The basally positioned subgen. Kostyczewianae in the Sramkó et al.’s system was characterized by 2- to 3-colpate pollen with small grain size below 30 μm in the longest axis (Table 1). The two apertures state is palynologically exceptional within the genus Pulsatilla and supports the subgeneric status, but further studies are needed because 2-colpate pollen was reported in only 40% of pollen grains in Xi (1985). Within the recent DNA-based classification by Sramkó et al. (2019), most species examined in the second subgen. Preonanthus (including two sects. Preonanthus and Preonanthopsis) were characterized by having commonly pantocolpate pollen with a medium (30 μm or more but below 40 μm) grain size (Table 1). The palynological evidence would support possibly the unity of subgen. Preonanthus. The species-rich third subgen. Pulsatilla (including three sects. Tatewakianae, Pulsatilla, and Semicampanaria) is characterized by the following three palynological groups; i) diploid species with medium- to large-sized 3-colpate pollen (sect. Tatewakianae [poorly studied], ser. Patentes of sect. Pulsatilla, and sect. Semicampanaria excluding ser. Albanae); ii) tetraploid species with large-sized 3-colpate pollen (ser. Pulsatilla of sect. Pulsatilla); iii) diploid species with medium- sized pantoporate pollen (ser. Albanae of sect. Semicampanaria) (Table 1). SYSTEMATIC POSITION OF MIYAKEA INTEGRIFOLIA 189 The irregular and occasional appearance of pantocolpate pollen adding to the usual 3-colpate pollen was observed in P. patens, P. vulgaris, P. halleri, P. chinensis, and P. dahurica within the third subgen. Pulsatilla (Table 1). This palynological phenomenon indicates at least a similarity between the second subgen. Preonanthus and the species-rich third subgen. Pulsatilla. The majority of the species (eight examined among the twelve species) comprising the last series Albanae within the third subgen. Pulsatilla was characterized by having the most specialized pantoporate pollen within the genus Pulsatilla (Table 1). The evolutionary trend of pollen types; from tricolpate through pantocolpate to pantoporate was postulated in Pulsatilla (Xi, 1985). Series Albanae could be distinguished from other series within the genus Pulsatilla in the pollen aperture traits (Huynh, 1970; Tamura, 1995). Monophyly and the last position of series Albanae in the classification of Sramkó et al. (2019) was well supported by the present palynological evidence, and the section-level separation of Albanae should be possibly considered. Although Nowicke and Skvarla (1995) pointed out that the pollen morphology of Ranunculaceae has generally limited taxonomic values, palynological traits, in some cases, indicate homogeneity at the infrageneric level in the Pulsatilla classification by Sramkó et al. (2019). Systematic affiliation of Miyakea based on the palynological traits and future challenges At present, there are two opinions on the systematic position of Miyakea [P. integrifolia] within the genus Pulsatilla: i) a separate monotypic subgen. Miyakea situated at the last position mainly based on morphological and anatomical studies (Tamura, 1991, 1995; Grey-Wilson, 2014, 2020), ii) a close relative of P. patens and P. vernalis in ser. Patentes within the species-rich subgen. Pulsatilla mainly based on DNA and chromosome analyses (Sramkó et al., 2019). Miyakea pollen was first studied by Nowicke and Skvarla (1995) in SEM and they showed that 3-colpate aperture and supratectal microspinulate ornamentation with distinct tectal perforations. A tri-colpate aperture of Miyakea pollen is the same as in many species of subgen. Pulsatilla (excluding series Albanae) within Pulsatilla. Although exine ornamentation such as supratectal microspinules is the same character between Pulsatilla and Miyakea, this feature is common within the Ranunculaceae (44 of the 48 genera examined; Nowicke and Skvarla, 1995). Nowicke and Skvarla (1995) suggested that elongated tectal perforations on the surface view of Miyakea pollen were regarded as characteristic palynological features distinguished from Pulsatilla. But the surface shape of tectal perforations of Miyakea [as P. integrifolia] in their SEM micrograph may not be evidently different from that of P. patens (Xi, 1985; Plate 3, fig. 4) and P. vernalis (Clarke et al., 1991; Plate 47, Fig. 2) within ser. Patentes. Therefore, the exine ornamentation of Miyakea pollen may not support positively the opinion with the separate monotypic subgen. Miyakea (Miyabe and Tatew.) Tamura. As in Table 1, the presence of distinct tectal perforations in SEM micrographs in most Pulsatilla pollen was different from indistinct perforations on the pollen in some samples of Pulsatilla; P. kostyczewii, P. patens, P. grandis and P. pratensis and P. cernua. However, considering the different preparation methods and micrograph resolution between them, we did not consider the presence/absence (or distinct/indistinct) of tectal perforations as the taxonomic informative palynological character at the current research stage. To compare the exine ornamentation between species within Pulsatilla, it is necessary to thoroughly remove the surface 190 SARWAR AND TAKAHASHI SYSTEMATIC POSITION OF MIYAKEA INTEGRIFOLIA 191 192 SARWAR AND TAKAHASHI SYSTEMATIC POSITION OF MIYAKEA INTEGRIFOLIA 193 194 SARWAR AND TAKAHASHI material (perine, pollenkitt, and so on) and observe the surface ornamentation of the swollen pollen grains by SEM. The palynological trait of flat tectum versus undulate tectum (Nowicke and Skvarla, 1995) may be problematical for comparison at the species level. Palynological studies need to be performed on more species that have not yet been observed (Table 1). The pollen morphology of Far East Asian species (e.g., P. magadanensis, P. tatewakii, P. sugawarai, and P. tongkangensis) in particular should be clarified. Palynological studies by LM should clarify aperture type and pollen grain size within a species or between populations. These palynological traits are related to chromosome number (cf. Table 1). The TEM study on Pulsatilla pollen wall has been conducted only in restricted species; P. chinensis and P. campanella in Xi (1985), and P. grandis in PalDat (2023). Structural diversity within the exine wall in Pulsatilla pollen is not yet known. Acknowledgments The first author is particularly grateful to the Japan Society for the Promotion of Science (JSPS) for a BRIDGE Fellowship for FY2022 when this study was conducted, and Prof. Masahiro Ôhara at the Laboratory of Systematic Entomology, The Hokkaido University Museum is thanked for hosting during the fellowship. References Baladehi, M.H., Habibi, M. and Azizian, D. 2013. Pollen morphology of Iranian species of Anemone L. and Pulsatilla Mill. (Ranunculaceae) and its implications. Acta Botanica Gallica: Botany Letters 160: 1-8. Barkalov, V.Yu. and Taran, A.A. 2004. A checklist of vascular plants of Sakhalin Island. In: Bogatov, V., Barkalov, V.Yu., Lelej, A.S., Makarchrenko, E.A. and Storozhenko, S.Y. (eds.), Flora and Fauna of Sakhalin Island (Materials of International Sakhalin Island Project), Dalnauka, Vladivostok. pp. 39-66. (in Russian with English summary). Clarke, G.C.S., Punt, W. and Hoen, P.P. 1991. The Northwest European Pollen Flora, 51. Ranunculaceae. Rev. Palaeob. Palynol. 69: 117-271. Czerepanov [Cherepanov], S.K. 1973. Additamenta et Corrigenda ad “Floram URSS” (tomi I-XXX). Nauka, Leningrad. (in Russian). Czerepanov [Cherepanov], S.K. 1995. Vascular Plants of Russia and Adjacent States (The Former USSR). Cambridge University Press, Cambridge. Eryemin, V.M., Taran, A.A. and Chabanenko, S.I. 2019. Red Book, Sakhalin State, Plants and Fungi. Technoprint, Kemerovo. (in Russian). Fujiki, T., Miyoshi, N. and Kimura, H. 2016. Pollen Flora of Japan. 2nd ed., Hokkaido University Press, Sapporo. (in Japanese). Grey-Wilson, C. 2014. Pasque-flowers. The Genus Pulsatilla. The Charlotte-Louise Press, Kenninghall. Grey-Wilson, C. 2020. Pasque-flowers. The Genus Pulsatilla, new edition. The Alpine Garden Society, Worcestershire. Hesse, M., Halbritter, H., Zetter, R., Weber, M., Buchner, R., Frosch-Radivo, A. and Ulrich, S. 2009. Pollen Terminology, An Illustrated Handbook. Springer-Verlag. Hiepko, P. (ed.). 1995. Die Natürlichen Pflanzenfamilien nebst ihren Gattungen und wichtigsten Arten, inbedondere den Nutzpflanzen. Band 17a IV. Angiospermae: Ordnung Ranunculales, Fam. Ranunculaceae. Duncker & Humboldt, Berlin. Hoot, S.B., Meyer, K.M. and Manning, J.C. 2012. Phylogeny and reclassification of Anemone (Ranunculaceae), with an emphasis on Austral species. Syst. Bot. 37: 139-152. Hoot, S.B., Palmer, J.D. and Reznicek, A.A. 1994. Phylogenetic relationships in Anemone based on morphology and chloroplast DNA variations. Syst. Bot. 19: 169-200. Huynh, K.-L. 1970. Le pollen et la systematique du genre Pulsatilla. Bot. Jb. 89: 584-607. Ikuse, M. 1956. Pollen Grains of Japan. Hirokawa Publishing Co., Tokyo. (in Japanese). SYSTEMATIC POSITION OF MIYAKEA INTEGRIFOLIA 195 Ikuse, M. 2001. Pollen Grains of Japan. 2nd ed., Hirokawa Publishing Co., Tokyo. (in Japanese). Kumazawa, M. 1936. Pollen grain morphology in Ranunculaceae, Lardizabalaceae and Berberidaceae. Jap. J. Bot. 8: 19-46 (with 5 plates). Miyabe, K. and Tatewaki, M. 1935. Contributions to the flora of northern Japan V. Trans. Sapporo Nat. Hist. Soc. 14: 1-10. Miyabe, K. and Tatewaki, M. 1937. On the significance of the Schmidt Line in the plant distribution in Saghalien. Proc. Imp. Acad., Japan Acad. 13: 24-26. doi: 10.2183/pjab1912.13.24 Miyabe, K. and Tatewaki, M. 1941. Contributions to the flora of northern Japan XIV. Trans. Sapporo Nat. Hist. Soc. 17(1): 49-55. Miyoshi, N., Fujiki, T. and Kimura, H. 2011. Pollen Flora of Japan. Hokkaido University Press, Sapporo. (in Japanese). Nakamura, J. 1980. Diagnostic characters of pollen grains of Japan, Part I and II. Special Publications vol. 12 and 13. Osaka Museum of Natural History, Osaka. (in Japanese). Nishikawa, T. 2008. Chromosome Atlas of Flowering Plants in Japan. National Museum of Nature and Science, Tokyo. Nowicke, J.W. and Skvarla, J.J. 1995. Pollen Morphology. In: Hiepko, P. (ed.), Die Natürlichen Pflanzenfamilien nebst ihren Gattungen und wichtigsten Arten, inbedondere den Nutzpflanzen. Band 17a IV. Angiospermae: Ordnung Ranunculales, Fam. Ranunculaceae, Duncker & Humboldt, Berlin. pp. 129-159. PalDat. 2023. https://www.paldat.org [Retrieved on 23 January 2023] Probatova, N.S., Barkalov, V.Yu. and Rudyka, E.G. 2007. Caryology of the Flora of Sakhalin and the Kurile Islands. Dalnauka, Vladivostok. Punt, W., Blackmore, S., Nilsson, S. and Le Thomas, A. 1994. Glossary of Pollen and Spore Terminology. LPP Foundation, Utrecht. Punt, W., Hoen, P.P., Blackmore, S., Nilsson, S. and Le Thomas, A. 2007. Glossary of pollen and spore terminology. Rev. Palaeobot. Palynol. 143: 1–81. Sarwar, A.K.M. Golam and Takahashi, H. 2023. Discrepancies in reports of pollen morphology for Pulsatilla cernua (Ranunculaceae). Jpn. J. Palynol. 68: 55-58. Smirnov, A.A. 2002. Distribution of Vascular Plants in Sakhalin Island. Institute of Marine Geology and Geophysics, Russian Academy of Sciences, Far East Branch, Yuzhno-Sakhalinsk. Sramkó, G., Laczkó, L., Volkova, P.A., Bateman, R.M. and Minarec, J. 2019. Evolutionary history of the Pasque-flowers (Pulsatilla, Ranunculuaceae): molecular phylogenetics, systematics and rDNA evolution. Molecular Phylogenetics and Evolution 135: 45-61. Starobubtsev, V.N. 1995. Miyakea. In: Charkevicz, S.S. (principal ed.), Plantae Vasculares Orientis Extremi Sovietici 7, Nauka, Saint Petersburg. pp. 83. (in Russian). Sugawara, S. 1939. Illustrated Flora of Saghalien with Descriptions and Figures of Phanerogams and Higher Cryptogams Indigenous to Saghalien. Araceae―Magnolicaceae Vol. II. Karafuto-shokubutsu-zushi- kankokai, Tokyo. (in Japanese). Tamura, M. 1991. A new classification of the family Ranunculaceae 2. Acta Phytotax. Geobot. 42: 177-187. (in Japanese with English summary). Tamura, M. 1993. Ranunculaceae. In: Kubitzki, K., Rohwer, J.G. and Bittrich, V. (eds.), The Families and Genera of Vascular Plants II, Springer-Verlag, Berlin. pp. 563-583. Tamura, M. 1995. II. Systematic Part. In: Hiepko, P. (ed.), Die Natürlichen Pflanzenfamilien nebst ihren Gattungen und wichtigsten Arten, inbedondere den Nutzpflanzen. Band 17a IV. Angiospermae: Ordnung Ranunculales, Fam. Ranunculaceae, Duncker & Humboldt, Berlin. pp. 223-519. Voroshilov, V.N. 1966. Flora of the Soviet Far East. [Fl. Sovetsk. Dal’n. Vost.]. Nauka, Moscow. Voroshilov, V.N. 1982. Opredelitelj Rastenyi Sovetskogo Daljnego. Nauka, Moscow. Wang, F., Chien, N., Zhang, Y. and Yang, H. 1995. Pollen Flora of China. 2nd ed., Science Press, Beijing. Xi, Y.-Z. 1985. Studies of pollen morphology of Pulsatilla Mill. Acta Phytotax. Sin. 23: 336-343. (Manuscript received on 3 June, 2023; revised on 1 January, 2024) https://www.paldat.org