Bioscience Journal  |  2023  |  vol. 39, e39005  |  ISSN 1981-3163 
 

1 

 

 
 

Neuza Helena Carvalho DE OLIVEIRA1 , Anderson Prates COELHO1 , Flávia Constantino MEIRELLES1 , 

Ancelmo CAZUZA NETO2 , Leandro Borges LEMOS3  
 
1 Postgraduate Program in Plant Production, School of Agricultural and Veterinarian Sciences, Universidade Estadual Paulista (Unesp), 
Jaboticabal, São Paulo, Brazil. 
2 Postgraduate Program in Soil Science, School of Agricultural and Veterinarian Sciences, Universidade Estadual Paulista (Unesp), Jaboticabal, 
São Paulo, Brazil.  
3 Department in Agricultural Production Sciences, School of Agricultural and Veterinarian Sciences, Universidade Estadual Paulista (Unesp), 
Jaboticabal, São Paulo, Brazil.  
 
Corresponding author:  
Neuza Helena Carvalho de Oliveira 
hcarvalhoagro@gmail.com  
 
How to cite: DE OLIVEIRA, N.H.C., et al. Response of early-cycle common bean cultivars with carioca, black and speckled grains to top-dressing 
nitrogen fertilization. Bioscience Journal. 2023, 39, e39005. https://doi.org/10.14393/BJ-v39n0a2023-61040 

 
 
Abstract 
The aim was to evaluate the agronomic and qualitative attributes of early-cycle common bean cultivars with 
different grains types grains in response to top-dressing nitrogen (N) doses. The experiment was carried out 
using a randomized block design, in a split-plot scheme, with 4 replicates. The plots consisted of the cultivars 
IAC Nuance, IAC 1849 Polaco and IAC Veloz, with speckled, Carioca and black grains, respectively. The 
subplots were formed by N doses applied as top-dressing: 0 kg ha-1, 60 kg ha-1 (applied in the stage of third 
trifoliate leaf), 120 kg ha-1 (1/2 applied at third trifoliate leaf stage + 1/2 applied at the floral bud stage) and 
180 kg ha-1 (1/3 applied at the first trifoliate leaf stage + 1/3 applied at the third trifoliate leaf stage +  1/3 
applied at the floral bud stage). IAC Veloz stood out for grain yield, showing the highest grain yield in the 
lowest N doses, being classified as efficient to the use of N. The cultivars IAC Nuance and IAC 1849 Polaco 
reached maximum yields with 155 and 163 kg ha-1 of N. The IAC Nuance was the most responsive, increasing 
grain yield by up to 25.3% due to nitrogen fertilization. Increasing N doses applied as top-dressing increased 
the sieve yield and crude protein content of the common bean cultivars, with IAC Nuance standing out. The 
cultivars showed good grain quality, and IAC 1849 Polaco and IAC Veloz had the shortest cooking time and 
IAC Veloz also had the fastest hydration. 
 
Keywords: Commercial Group. Cooking Time. Export Beans. Genotypes. Phaseolus vulgaris L. 
 
1. Introduction 
 

Common bean (Phaseolus vulgaris L.) is a crop of high food, social and economic importance. Brazil 
stands out as the world’s largest producer and consumer of beans (FAO 2019). In 2020, Brazilian production 
reached 3.2 million tons, of which 0.5 million tons were black beans, 2.0 million tons were colored beans, 
which include Carioca and special beans, and 0.7 million tons were cowpea (Vigna unguiculata (L.) Walp) 
(Conab 2020). Nutritionally, beans are rich in crude protein, with levels in the grains that can range from 18 
to 25%, and minerals such as phosphorus, calcium and magnesium, iron, zinc and copper (Klasener et al. 
2020). 

RESPONSE OF EARLY-CYCLE COMMON BEAN CULTIVARS 
WITH CARIOCA, BLACK AND SPECKLED GRAINS TO TOP-

DRESSING NITROGEN FERTILIZATION 

https://orcid.org/0000-0002-8253-8108
https://orcid.org/0000-0003-2472-9704
https://orcid.org/0000-0003-3923-8449
https://orcid.org/0000-0002-1849-5828
https://orcid.org/0000-0003-1781-1267


Bioscience Journal  |  2023  |  vol. 39, e39005  |  https://doi.org/10.14393/BJ-v39n0a2023-61040 

 

 
2 

Response of early-cycle common bean cultivars with carioca, black and speckled grains to top-dressing nitrogen fertilization 

Brazil has a diversity of common bean cultivars from different commercial groups, such as Carioca, 
black and special. Carioca beans are the most cultivated in Brazil, with 70% of production, followed by black 
beans. However, Brazil is not self-sufficient in the production of black beans, so imports are necessary to 
supply the market. These two types of grains are also the most appreciated by consumers (Chiorato et al. 
2020a, Chiorato et al. 2020b). Grains with white, red, cream and yellow seed coat, among others, with 
absence or presence of streaks or strips of other colors, are known as special grain beans. The production of 
this type of grain is still incipient in Brazil, but its cultivation can be an alternative for crop diversification and 
minimization of income fluctuation for producers; in addition, it can be marketed in the domestic and foreign 
markets, as it is a differentiated product with high added value (Ribeiro et al. 2014; Alves et al. 2020; 
Carbonell et al. 2020). Both black and special beans are little produced in the state of São Paulo, which can 
be a good alternative of niche market for producers. 

When recommending a common bean cultivar to the producer, in addition to the commercial type 
of grains, other agronomic attributes are important, such as adaptability to the region of cult ivation, 
production potential, plant size, cycle, resistance to pests and diseases, tolerance to abiotic factors such as 
drought and high temperatures, as well as efficiency and response to the use of nutrients (Lemos et al. 2015). 
As for the cycle, earliness is an attribute increasingly sought after by the producer, because it allows better 
adequacy of the crop within a system of crop rotation and intercropping, water and energy savings in 
irrigated systems, cultivation of the crop in a period of the year more favorable to the development of plants, 
and faster return on invested capital (Lemos et al. 2015; Bettiol et al. 2020). 

Regarding the response of cultivars to the use of nutrients, it is necessary to evaluate the efficiency 
in the absorption and utilization of nitrogen (N), since it is the nutrient most extracted by common bean 
plants (Fageria et al. 2015; Leal et al. 2019). According to Soratto et al. (2013), for each ton of grain produced, 
common bean plants extract on average 40 kg ha-1 of N. 

Although common bean plants perform symbiosis with bacteria of the genus Rhizobium, the 
biological fixation of N is insufficient to meet the requirements of this nutrient during their cycle, so N 
fertilizer needs to be applied via fertilization (Aragão et al. 2020; Bettiol et al. 2020; Dias et al. 2020). There 
are studies in the literature indicating the response of the crop to the top-dressing application of doses 
greater than 180 kg ha-1 (Farinelli and Lemos 2010; Soratto et al. 2017; Souza et al. 2019). 

In view of the above, the aim of this study was to evaluate the agronomic and qualitative attributes 
of early-cycle common bean cultivars with different types of grains in response to the top -dressing 
application of N doses. 
 
2. Material and Methods 
 

The experiment was conducted at the Universidade Estadual Paulista (Unesp), School of Agricultural 
and Veterinarian Sciences, Jaboticabal, São Paulo, Brazil, near the coordinates 21º 14’ 59” S and 48º 17’16” 
W, at an altitude of 570 m. In the spring-summer crop season of 2018/2019, the area was cultivated with 
soybean (Glycine max L.), under conventional soil tillage, using the cultivar Pioneer 95R95 IPRO, sown on 
November 22, 2018 and harvested on March 22, 2019, with an average yield of 4.5 t ha-1. 

According to Köppen’s classification, the climate of the region is characterized as Aw - humid tropical 
with rainy season in summer and dry season in winter, showing an average annual temperature of 22 ºC and 
average annual precipitation of 1,425 mm. The soil is classified as clay-textured Latossolo Vermelho 
eutroférrico (Oxisol). Its chemical analysis, in the 0-0.20 m layer, showed the following results: pH (CaCl2) = 
5.9, OM = 19 g dm-3, Presin = 52 mg dm-3, K = 5.6 mmolc dm-3, Ca = 41 mmolc dm-3, Mg = 18 mmolc dm-3, H+Al 
= 24 mmolc dm-3, SB = 64.6 mmolc dm-3, CEC = 89 mmolc dm-3, V = 75%, B = 0.22 mg dm-3, Cu = 0.6 mg dm-3, 
Fe = 11 mg dm-3, Mn = 61.3 mg dm-3 and Zn = 3.7 mg dm-3. The results of the particle-size analysis showed: 
clay = 540 g kg-1; silt = 230 g kg-1 and sand = 230 g kg-1. 

The design used was randomized blocks, in a split-plot scheme, with four replicates. The plots were 
composed of the common bean cultivars IAC Nuance, IAC 1849 Polaco and IAC Veloz. The cultivars have 
determinate growth habit, type I and early cycle with 75 days. IAC Nuance has special type grains of rounded 
shape, speckled in cream color with reddish streaks, Cranberry type, intended for export; IAC 1849 Polaco 
has Carioca type grains, of cream color with light brown streaks and tolerance to darkening; and IAC Veloz 



Bioscience Journal  |  2023  |  vol. 39, e39005  |  https://doi.org/10.14393/BJ-v39n0a2023-61040 

 
 

 
3 

DE OLIVEIRA, N.H.C., et al. 

has black grains and produces a chocolate-colored broth (Carbonell et al. 2020; Chiorato et al. 2020a,b). The 
subplots were formed by N doses applied as top-dressing: 0 kg ha-1 (without application), 60 kg ha-1 (applied 
at phenological stage V4 - third trifoliate leaf), 120 kg ha-1 (half of the dose applied at V4 + half the dose at R5 
- floral bud), 180 kg ha-1 (one-third of the dose applied at V3 - first trifoliate leaf + one-third of the dose 
applied at V4 + one-third of the dose applied at R5). Top-dressing N fertilization was applied along a 
continuous strip, at 0.10 m distance from the crop row, using as source polymer-coated controlled-release 
urea (Kimcoat® - 45% N), followed by irrigation with a 15 mm water depth. Each experimental subplot 
consisted of five 5.0-m long rows, spaced by 0.45 m, considering the three central rows as usable area. 

The seeds of the common bean cultivars came from the Agronomic Institute of Campinas (IAC) and 
were treated with fungicide + insecticide (StandakTop®) at a dose of 2 mL per kg of seed. For inoculation 
with Rhizobium, the product StarFix Feijão was used at a dose of 4 mL per kg of seed. The common bean 
crop was grown in the 2019 autumn-winter season in a no-tillage system. Sowing was performed on July 05, 
2019, with spacing of 0.45 m between rows, using 11 seeds per meter. The final population was 216,000 
plants ha-1. Sowing fertilization was carried out using 8 kg ha-1 of N, 40 kg ha-1 of P2O5 and 40 kg ha-1 of K2O, 
following the recommendations of Ambrosano et al. (1997). For the control of weeds, the pre -emergence 
herbicide Dual Gold (1.25 L ha-1 c.p.) was applied 1 day after sowing (DAS) and the post-emergence herbicides 
Select (0.4 L c.p. ha-1) and Flex (0.9 L c.p. ha-1) were applied at 27 DAS. For the control of pest insects and 
diseases, the following products were sprayed: Benevia (750 mL c.p. ha-1) at 23 DAS, Engeo Pleno (125 mL 
c.p. ha-1) and Opera (0.5 L c.p. ha-1) at 49 DAS. Irrigation was applied using a conventional sprinkler system, 
with variable interval and total water depth of 315 mm. 

Agronomic attributes were evaluated when the plants reached R6 stage (full flowering). Ten plants 
were randomly collected in the usable area of each subplot, washed with deionized water, dried in an oven 
at 65 ºC for 72 hours and then weighed to determine shoot dry matter (g plant-1). To determine leaf N 
content, the third trifoliate leaf with petiole was collected from the middle third, in 20 plants, following the 
recommendations of Ambrosano et al. (1997). The leaves were washed in running water, deionized water 
with neutral detergent (0.1%) and deionized water and subsequently kept in an air circulation oven at 
temperature of 65 ºC until reaching constant weight. After drying, the material was ground and subjected 
to chemical analysis to determine leaf N content by sulfuric acid digestion, distillation in strongly alkaline 
medium and titration with sulfuric acid solution. Cultivars IAC Nuance, IAC Veloz and IAC 1849 Polaco 
flowered at 41, 50 and 51 DAS, with a total cycle of 66, 73 and 75 DAS, respectively. At harvest, ten plants 
were collected in each experimental unit in the central row of each subplot to determine the number of 
pods per plant and number of grains per pod. 100-grain weight (g) was determined by weighing four 
subsamples of 100 grains per subplot, correcting the data to moisture content of 0.13 g g -1. For the 
evaluation of grain yield, the plants of the usable area of each subplot were harvested, sun -dried and 
mechanically threshed. Then, the grains were weighed and the data were corrected to moisture content of 
0.13 g g-1. 

The qualitative attributes of the grains were evaluated 30 days after harvest. The grains were 
classified according to size and shape based on their passage through a set of sieves with oblong holes 
[11/64” × 3/4 (4.37 × 19.05 mm), 12/64” × 3/4 (4.76 × 19.05 mm), 13/64” × 3/4 (5.16 × 19.05 mm) and 14/64” 
× 3/4 (5.56 × 19.05 mm)] under shaking for one minute (Santis et al. 2019). The percentage of grains was 
calculated by the relationship between the weight of grains retained on each sieve and the total weight of 
the sample of each subplot. The relative grain production on sieves was also calculated, according to the 
methodology described by Carbonell et al. (2010), using equation 1. 

 
( ) ( ) ( ) ( ) ( ) ( )

S15S14S13S12S11S10

6S1510S1410S136S124S111S10
RGPS

+++++

+++++
=                    (1) 

 
Where: RGPS: relative grain production on sieves; S10: sieve 10; S11: sieve 11; S12: sieve 12; S13: 

sieve 13; S14: sieve 14; S15: sieve 15; 
Crude protein content (CPC%) was determined by sulfuric digestion and the following equation was 

used for calculation: CPC = 6.25 x Total N, where CPC, in percentage, is the crude protein content, and total 
N is the N content in the grains. The other quality evaluations were performed with the grains retained on 



Bioscience Journal  |  2023  |  vol. 39, e39005  |  https://doi.org/10.14393/BJ-v39n0a2023-61040 

 

 
4 

Response of early-cycle common bean cultivars with carioca, black and speckled grains to top-dressing nitrogen fertilization 

sieve 13. Cooking time (minutes) was determined using a Mattson cooker, according to the methodology 
described in Farinelli and Lemos (2010). Hydration capacity (hours:minutes) was determined by evaluating 
the volume of water not absorbed by the grains, at 1-h intervals, for 22 hours. Analysis of polynomial 
regression between time (hours) and hydration capacity (mL) was carried out to determine the time required 
for maximum hydration of common bean grains (Santis et al. 2019). 

The data were subjected to analysis of variance using the F test (p < 0.05) and means were compared 
by Tukey test (p < 0.05). The effects of top-dressing N doses and the interaction between common bean 
cultivars and N doses were assessed by polynomial regression. Pearson’s simple correlation analysis between 
agronomic and qualitative attributes was also performed. Due to the structure dependency of the original 
data set, multivariate statistical analysis by principal components (PCs) was used. The data were 
standardized with zero mean and unit variance. The number of PCs was selected based on the Kaiser 
criterion, using those with eigenvalues greater than 1 (Kaiser 1958). The statistical programs AgroEstat and 
Statistica v.7 were used for univariate statistics, multivariate statistics and Pearson’s correlation. 
 
3. Results 
 

Regarding agronomic attributes, it can be verified that shoot dry matter was significantly influenced 
by cultivars, with IAC Veloz having the highest value (5.08 g plant-1), while IAC Nuance and IAC 1849 Polaco 
showed no differences (Table 1). The N doses promoted a linear increase in dry matter for the three common 
bean cultivars (Figure 1A). The N dose of 180 kg ha-1, compared to the absence of top-dressing application 
of N, enabled increments in shoot dry matter of 51%, 41% and 98% for the cultivars IAC Nuance, IAC 1849 
Polaco and IAC Veloz, respectively. 
 
Table 1. Agronomic attributes of early-cycle common bean cultivars fertilized with top-dressing nitrogen. 
Jaboticabal, São Paulo – 2019¹. 

Cultivar  
DM 

(g plant-1) 
LNC 

(g kg-1) 
NPP 
(nº) 

NGP 
(nº) 

100GW 
(g) 

GY 
(kg ha-1) 

IAC Nuance 3.88 b 31.50 c 8.34   b 3.63 c 35.52 a 1.342 b 
IAC 1489 Polaco 4.01 b 39.20 b 10.60 b 4.00 b 22.92 b 1.672 b 

IAC Veloz 5.08 a 45.37 a 15.96 a 4.81 a 21.25 c 2.603 a 

F test       
Cultivar (C) 8.08* 45.67** 32.41** 55.42** 426.35** 38.81** 
N doses (N) 13.16** 5.98** 1.56NS 0.75NS 2.18NS 4.79** 

C*N 1.55NS 4.31** 0.43NS 0.70NS 0.58NS 0.67NS 
CV for cultivar (%) 21.71 10.63 23.67 8.57 5.69 18.86 
CV for doses (%) 19.55 7.28 12.61 7.78 5.28 14.37 

¹ DM – shoot dry matter; LNC – leaf nitrogen content; NPP – number of pods per plant; NGP – number of grains per pod; 100GW – 100-grain 
weight; GY – grain yield. Means followed by different letters in the rows differ from each other by Tukey test at 5% pro bability level. NS Not 
significant by F test. ** Significant by F test (p < 0.01). * Significant by F test (p < 0.05). 

 
Top-dressing N application promoted an increase in leaf N content, with a difference between 

cultivars and for the interaction between cultivars (C) and N doses (Tables 1 and 2). The cultivar IAC Nuance 
was inferior to the others and, at the N dose of 60 kg ha-1 and under no N application, it showed values below 
the range considered adequate or of sufficiency for common bean, from 30 to 50 g kg-1 (Ambrosano et al. 
1997). The cultivar IAC Veloz was superior to the others, showing higher leaf N content at a N dose of 180 
kg ha-1, but with a value above the maximum recommended. It is worth pointing out that the cultivars IAC 
1849 Polaco and IAC Veloz had high leaf N contents even where there was no fertilizer application. Negative 
and significant correlations were also observed between leaf N content and the qualitative attributes 
cooking time (r = -0.42**) and sieve yield ≥11 (r=-0.61**), ≥12 (r=-0.72**), ≥13 (r=-0.79**) and ≥14 (r=-0.76**). 

The number of pods per plant was influenced by the cultivar factor and the C x N interaction (Table 
1 and Figure 1B). The cultivar IAC Veloz was superior to the others, with an average of 16 pods per plant, but 
without response to fertilizer application. The addition of N promoted quadratic effect on the cultivars IAC 
Nuance and IAC 1849 Polaco, with maximum number of pods per plant equal to 9 and 10, respectively, at 
doses of 145 and 122 kg ha-1. 



Bioscience Journal  |  2023  |  vol. 39, e39005  |  https://doi.org/10.14393/BJ-v39n0a2023-61040 

 
 

 
5 

DE OLIVEIRA, N.H.C., et al. 

The number of grains per pod was higher in the cultivar IAC Veloz, which differed statistically from 
the others and was not influenced by N doses or C x N interaction (Table 1). 100-grain weight was significantly 
influenced by the cultivars, and IAC Nuance had higher average (35.52 g) compared to the others (Table 1). 
Also for the 100-grain weight, it was possible to observe the difference in the response of the cultivars to 
the N doses (Figure 1C). IAC Nuance showed a quadratic increment, with the highest value (36.14 g) 
promoted by the N dose of 102.3 kg ha-1. For the cultivars IAC 1849 Polaco and IAC Veloz, the increments of 
N promoted a linear increase in the 100-grain weight. This response is related to the fact that N is associated 
with organic compounds after being absorbed by plants, originating proteins that increase grain weight 
(Amaral et al. 2016). 
 
Table 2. Analysis of the cultivar x nitrogen doses interaction for leaf nitrogen content¹. 

 Leaf N content (g kg-1) 

N doses (kg ha-1) IAC Nuance IAC 1849 Polaco IAC Veloz 

0 29.75 abB 39.20 aA 40.76 bA 
60 28.70 bC 38.85 aB 45.50 bA 

120 34.30 aB 40.25 aA 43.58 bA 
180 33.25 abB 38.50 aB 51.63 aA 

F test for C x N interaction    4.31** 
CV (%) 7.28 

¹ Means followed by the same lowercase letter in the column and uppercase letter in the row do not differ from each other by Tukey test at 5% 
probability level. ** Significant by F test (p < 0.01). 

 

 
Figure 1. Analysis of the cultivar x nitrogen doses interaction for A - shoot dry matter, B - number of pods 

per plant, C - 100-grain weight and D - grain yield. *(p<0.05); **(p<0.01). 
 

The cultivar IAC Veloz obtained higher grain yield than the others, and IAC Nuance and IAC 1849 
Polaco showed statistically equal production performance (Table 1). For the interaction between C and N, it 
can be observed that the cultivar IAC Veloz showed increasing grain yield as a function of N doses, and it was 
not possible to find a maximum point, with increments of 17 kg ha-1 for every 10 kg ha-1 of N applied (Figure 
1D). At a dose of 180 kg ha-1, the IAC Veloz grain yield was 2.761 kg ha-1. The cultivars IAC Nuance and IAC 

A

y = 0.0088x + 3.0783  R² = 0.97**

y = 0.0077x + 3.3143  R² = 0.75**

y = 0.0187x + 3.4009   R² = 0.99**

2

3

4

5

6

7

0 60 120 180

S
h

o
o

t 
d

ry
 m

a
tt

e
r 

(g
 p

la
n

t-
1
)

N doses (kg ha-1)

IAC Nuance

IAC 1849 Polaco

IAC Veloz

B

y = -9E-05x2 + 0.0262x + 7.16
R² = 0.96**

y = -7E-05x2 + 0.0172x + 9.8825
R² = 0.99**

5
7
9

11
13
15
17
19

0 60 120 180N
u

m
b

e
r 

o
f 

p
o

d
s 

p
e

r 
p

la
n

t

N doses (kg ha-1)

IAC Nuance

IAC 1849 Polaco

IAC Veloz y = 16

C

y = -0.0002x2 + 0.0409x + 34.055
R² = 0.89**

y = 0.0056x + 22.417
R² = 0.99**

y = 0.0066x + 20.67
R² = 0.96**

18

24

30

36

0 60 120 180

1
0

0
-g

ra
in

 w
e

ig
h

t 
(g

)

N doses (kg ha-1)

IAC Nuance

IAC 1849 Polaco

IAC Veloz

D

y = -0.0121x2 + 3.7638x + 1156.1
R² = 0.9044**

y = -0.0112x2 + 3.6695x + 1483.8
R² = 0.8406**

y = 1.7407x + 2447.3
R² = 0.7243**

1000

1400

1800

2200

2600

3000

0 60 120 180

G
ra

in
 y

ie
ld

 (
kg

 h
a

-1
)

N doses (kg ha-1)

IAC Nuance

IAC 1849 Polaco

IAC Veloz



Bioscience Journal  |  2023  |  vol. 39, e39005  |  https://doi.org/10.14393/BJ-v39n0a2023-61040 

 

 
6 

Response of early-cycle common bean cultivars with carioca, black and speckled grains to top-dressing nitrogen fertilization 

1849 Polaco showed maximum grain yields of 1,449 and 1,784 kg ha-1, at N doses of 155 and 163 kg ha-1, 
respectively. The cultivar IAC Veloz obtained higher grain yield at all N doses applied as top -dressing. In the 
absence of top-dressing N application, the cultivars IAC Veloz, IAC 1849 Polaco and IAC Nuance obtained 
grain yields of 2,447 kg ha-1, 1,484 kg ha-1 and 1,156 kg ha-1, respectively. The differences between maximum 
and minimum grain yield of cultivars IAC Nuance, IAC 1849 Polaco and IAC Veloz as a function o f N doses 
were 12.8, 25.3 and 20.2%, respectively. Furthermore, it was observed that grain yield was positively and 
significantly correlated with the number of pods per plant (r=0.90**) and the number of grains per pod 
(r=0.80**). 

Regarding the qualitative attributes of the grains, it was found that the sieve yields ≥11, ≥12, ≥13 and 
≥14 were influenced by the cultivars and N doses (Table 3 and Figure 2). The cultivar IAC Nuance showed 
higher yield in all sieves, with values ranging from 84 to 97%. The cultivar IAC 1849 Polaco did not differ from 
IAC Nuance in the amount of grains retained on the sieve ≥11, and IAC Veloz had the lowest values due to 
its lower 100-grain weight (Table 1), but obtained an outstanding value, close to 90%. For sieve yield ≥11 
and ≥12, the N doses promoted a quadratic increase, with maximum values of 95 and 86%, respectively, for 
the N doses of 111 and 150 kg ha-1. The sieve yields ≥13 and ≥14 increased linearly, and it was not possible 
to find a maximum point. The relative grain production on sieves (RGPS) was significantly affected only by 
the cultivar factor, with IAC Nuance and IAC 1849 Polaco being superior to IAC Veloz (Table 3). 
 
Table 3. Sieve yields greater than or equal to 11, 12, 13 and 14, and relative grain production on sieves for 
early-cycle common bean cultivars fertilized with top-dressing nitrogen. Jaboticabal, São Paulo – 2019¹. 

¹ SY≥ 11 - sieve yield greater than or equal to 11; SY≥ 12 - sieve yield greater than or equal to 12; SY≥ 13 - sieve yield greater than or equal to 13; 
SY≥ 14 - sieve yield greater than or equal to 14; RGPS - relative grain production on sieves. Means followed by different letters in the rows differ 
from each other by Tukey test at 5% probability level. NS Not significant by F test. ** Significant by F test (p < 0.01). * Significant by F test (p < 
0.05). 

 
The cultivars IAC Nuance and IAC 1849 Polaco did not differ in relation to crude protein content and 

were superior to IAC Veloz (Table 4), obtaining values close to those observed by Santis et al. (2019) in  a 
study with 13 common bean cultivars. Regarding the C x N interaction, all cultivars showed linear increase 
in crude protein content with increasing N doses (Figure 3), which is consistent with the results obtained by 
Farinelli and Lemos (2010) and Amaral et al. (2016). For the cultivar IAC Nuance, the increments were 1.56, 
3.12 and 4.68% for N doses of 60, 120 and 180 kg ha-1, in comparison to the absence of top-dressing N 
application. These increments were equal to 1.38, 2.76 and 4.14% for IAC 1849 Polaco and 2.41, 4.83 and 
7.25% for IAC Veloz. It is worth pointing out that a negative and significant correlation was observed between 
crude protein content and grain yield (r=-0.41**). 

The cultivars IAC 1849 Polaco and IAC Veloz had shorter cooking time, differing statistically from IAC 
Nuance (Table 4). IAC 1849 Polaco and IAC Veloz showed normal resistance to cooking, and IAC Nuance 
showed medium resistance to cooking, according to the scale proposed by Proctor and Watts (1987). 
Regarding the C x N interaction, the cultivar IAC Nuance obtained the longest cooking time at all doses 
applied (Table 5). 

Regarding the hydration capacity of the grains, there were differences between the cultivars in 
relation to the time necessary for maximum hydration (Table 4). The cultivar IAC Veloz required 12h05min 
to reach maximum grain hydration, differing from IAC Nuance and IAC 1849 Polaco, which had values of 
14h27min and 19h41min, respectively.  

 

Cultivar 
SY ≥ 11 

(%) 
SY ≥ 12 

(%) 
SY ≥ 13 

(%) 
SY ≥ 14 

(%) 
RGPS 

IAC Nuance 97.37 a 97.37 a 94.83 a 84.00 a 7.95 a 
IAC 1849 Polaco 97.37 a 88.12 b 62.62 b 12.43 b 8.25 a 

IAC Veloz 89.12 b 71.37 c 23.56 c 1.81 c 6.26 b 

F test      
Cultivar (C) 10.84* 40.12** 449.94** 1007.2** 18.49** 

N doses (N) 0.70NS 0.49NS 1.36NS 3.61NS 1.06NS 

C*N 0.99NS 2.07NS 0.81NS 1.36NS 2.03NS 

CV for cultivar (%) 17.1 25.18 9.41 15.99 13.33 
CV for doses (%) 5.05 12.1 9.03 14.75 5.35 



Bioscience Journal  |  2023  |  vol. 39, e39005  |  https://doi.org/10.14393/BJ-v39n0a2023-61040 

 
 

 
7 

DE OLIVEIRA, N.H.C., et al. 

 

 
Figure 2. Sieve yield A - ≥11, B - ≥ 12, C - ≥ 13 and D - ≥ 14 in early-cycle common bean cultivars fertilized 

with top-dressing nitrogen. *(p<0.05); **(p<0.01). 
 

 
Figure 3. Analysis of the cultivar x nitrogen doses interaction for crude protein content. *(p<0.05); 

**(p<0.01) 
 
Table 4. Crude protein content, cooking time and time for maximum hydration in early-cycle common bean 
cultivars fertilized with top-dressing nitrogen. Jaboticabal, São Paulo – 2019¹. 

¹ Means followed by different letters in the rows differ from each other by Tukey test at 5% probability level. NS Not significant by F test. ** 
Significant by F test (p < 0.01). * Significant by F test (p < 0.05). 

A

y = -9E-07x2 + 0.0002x + 0.9411
R² = 0.83**

0,93

0,94

0,95

0,96

0 60 120 180

S
Y

 ≥
 1

1

N doses (kg ha-1)

B

y = -1E-06x2 + 0.0003x + 0.8439
R² = 0.99**

0,84

0,85

0,86

0,87

0 60 120 180

S
Y

 ≥
 1

2

N doses (kg ha-1)

C

y = 0.0004x + 0.5702
R² = 0.92**

0,56

0,58

0,6

0,62

0,64

0 60 120 180

S
Y

 ≥
 1

3

N doses (kg ha-1)

D

y = 0.0002x + 0.3069
R² = 0.8634**

0,3

0,31

0,32

0,33

0,34

0,35

0,36

0 60 120 180

S
Y

 ≥
 1

4

N doses (kg ha-1)

y = 0.026x + 20.41   R² = 0.99**

y = 0.023x + 20.78   R² = 0.82**

y = 0.0403x + 15.37   R² = 0.97**

14

16

18

20

22

24

26

0 50 100 150 200

C
P

C
 (

%
)

N doses (kg ha-1)

IAC Nuance

IAC 1849 Polaco

IAC Veloz

Cultivar 
Crude protein content Cooking time Time for maximum hydration 

(%) (minutes) (hours:minutes) 

IAC Nuance 22.8 a 31 a 14:27 b 
IAC 1849 Polaco 22.9 a 21 b 19:41 a 

IAC Veloz 19.0 b 23 b 12:05 c 

F test    
Cultivar (C) 33.04* 95.38** 103.82** 
N doses (N) 24.37** 2.75NS 2.67NS 

C*N 1.09NS 4.37** 0.86NS 
CV for cultivar (%) 7.61 8.99 11.14 
CV for doses (%) 7.04 8.90 9.72 



Bioscience Journal  |  2023  |  vol. 39, e39005  |  https://doi.org/10.14393/BJ-v39n0a2023-61040 

 

 
8 

Response of early-cycle common bean cultivars with carioca, black and speckled grains to top-dressing nitrogen fertilization 

Regarding the multivariate analysis of principal components (PCs), it was possible to verify that the 
first two PCs were responsible for explaining 88.77% of the total variability of the data (Figure 4). The 
variables that most discriminated PC1 were those related to the distribution of grains on the sieves: sieve 
yield ≥11, sieve yield ≥12, sieve yield ≥13, sieve yield ≥14, with factor scores of 0.88, 0.97, 0.99 and 0.88, 
respectively, in addition to crude protein, 100-grain weight and cooking time, with factor scores of 0.55, 0.87 
and 0.63. The variable most related to PC2 was the time for maximum grain hydration, with a factor score 
of 0.95. 
 

 
Figure 4. Biplot of principal components (PC) for common bean cultivars under nitrogen doses as a 

function of agronomic attributes (DM: shoot dry matter, LNC: leaf nitrogen content, NPP: number of pods 
per plant, NGP: number of grains per pod, 100GW: 100-grain weight and GY: grain yield) and grain quality 

attributes (SY11: sieve yield greater than or equal to 11, SY12: sieve yield greater than or equal to 12, SY13: 
sieve yield greater than or equal to 13, SY14: sieve yield greater than or equal to 14, CPC: crude protein 
content, CT: cooking time and TMH: time for maximum hydration). Letters indicate the common bean 

cultivars and numbers indicate nitrogen doses (N: IAC Nuance, P: IAC 1849 Polaco, V: IAC Veloz - 0, 60, 120 
and 180: 0, 60, 120 and 180 kg ha-1 of nitrogen). 

 
4. Discussion 
 

Studies in the literature have reported a linear increase in the dry matter content of common bean 
with the addition of N. Soratto et al. (2017), studying N fertilization in common bean, concluded that the use 
of top-dressing N fertilizer increased shoot dry matter production in the cultivars IPR 139 and BRS Pérola, 
both of indeterminate growth habit, normal cycle and Carioca grains. The same performance was observed 
by Bettiol et al. (2020) using the cultivars IAC Imperador and IPR Curió, both of determinate growth habit, 
early cycle and Carioca grains. This occurs because N is directly related to the increase of net photosynthesis 
(Taiz and Zeiger 2017), positively affecting the absorption and accumulation of nutrients and increase of 
yield (Fageria et al. 2015). 

All in all, the cultivars presented leaf N contents within the range considered adequate for common 
bean (Ambrosano et al., 1997). This may have occurred due to the presence of residual N from the soybean 
crop previously cultivated in the area (Ambrosano et al. 1997), due to the plant’s ability to perform biological 
N fixation (Aragão et al. 2019; Bettiol et al. 2020, Dias et al. 2020) and due to the fertility of the soil in the 
experimental area. 

Souza et al. (2019), using the cultivar IAC Alvorada, verified that there was a linear increase in the 
number of pods per plant with the increase of N doses applied as top-dressing up to 200 kg ha-1, and it was 
not possible to find a maximum point. This demonstrates that this agronomic attribute can be influenced by 

N0

N60

N120

P0

P60

P120

V0
V120

V180

-4 -3 -2 -1 0 1 2 3 4
-3.0

-2.5

-2.0

-1.5

-1.0

-0.5

0.0

0.5

1.0

1.5

2.0

2.5

3.0

PC1: 68.35%

PC2: 16.86%

V60

P180

N180

TMHTMH

SY11

CPC
SY12

SY13

CT

DM

LNC

NGP
NPP

GY

100GW
SY14



Bioscience Journal  |  2023  |  vol. 39, e39005  |  https://doi.org/10.14393/BJ-v39n0a2023-61040 

 
 

 
9 

DE OLIVEIRA, N.H.C., et al. 

the addition of top-dressing N differently among cultivars. The number of grains per pod was not influenced 
by N doses since this attribute has high genetic heritability, hence being little affected by the environment 
and crop management, such as N fertilization (Nascente et al. 2017). 

The cultivar IAC Nuance showing the higher 100-grain weight value. This result occurred because this 
cultivar belongs to the group of speckled grains intended for export (special type), which are larger and 
heavier, as described by Carbonell et al. (2020). For IAC 1849 Polaco and IAC Veloz, this attribute showed a 
different response compared to the other production components, being lower, because these cultivars had 
a higher number of pods per plant and grains per pod. Due to the adjustment in the balance of 
photoassimilates sent to the different production components, the increase in the number of pods per plant 
and grains per pod reduces the amount of photoassimilates distributed to each grain, reducing the 100-grain 
weight (Fageria et al. 2015). Thus, plants with a high number of pods per plant and grains per pod may have 
lower values of 100-grain weight. 

The linear increase in the yield of cultivar IAC Veloz as a function of N doses corroborates those of 
other studies, in which the common bean did not reach its maximum grain yield with the top-dressing 
application of N doses until 180 kg ha-1 (Farinelli and Lemos 2010; Soratto et al. 2017; Souza et al. 2019). 
Although the yield variation of IAC Veloz as a function of N doses was linear, the yield increments were small. 
This result characterizes that IAC Veloz is an efficient N use cultivar, that is, it produces satisfactorily well 
under low N availability conditions, and has a low N response, as it increases its productivity little due to the 
greater availability of N in the soil (Fageria et al. 2015). 

Based on the principles of efficiency and responsiveness in the use of nutrients reported by Fageria 
et al. (2015), the cultivar IAC Veloz proved to be the most efficient in the N use, because it presented the 
highest grain yield in low N doses, while the cultivar IAC Nuance was the most responsive, being the cultivar 
with the highest relative increase in grain yield as a function of N doses. These results corroborate those 
reported by Leal et al. (2019), who observed differences in the efficiency and response of 16 common bean 
cultivars of the Carioca commercial group. 

The higher sieves yield for IAC Nuance occurred because this cultivar has rounded grains intended 
for export (Carbonell et al. 2020), as well as a higher 100-grain weight (Table 1). For sieve yield ≥11 and ≥12, 
the cultivars IAC 1849 Polaco and IAC Veloz had values higher than 70%, which is used as a reference by 
packing industries to pay a bonus to the producer because the grains are large and with good acceptance in 
the market (Carbonell et al. 2010). The linear increase of sieve yields ≥13 and ≥14 can be explained by the 
fact that the increase in N doses applied as top-dressing, associated with soil fertility and appropriate crop 
management practices, promoted an increase in shoot dry matter, positively affecting leaf N content and 
yield, leading to larger grains from the moment when there was greater availability of the nutrient in the 
soil-plant system (Fageria et al. 2015). 

The values of RGPS for all cultivars were above or close to 7, which is proposed by Carbonell et al. 
(2010) as indicative of grains with good acceptance by the market and packing industries. Bettiol et al. (2020) 
also verified that there was no effect of the forms of N supply on this qualitative attribute, obtaining values 
of 6.78 and 6.83 for the cultivars IPR Curió and IAC Imperador, respectively. 

For the cultivar IAC Veloz, due to the higher number of pods per plant, grains per pod and grain yield 
(Table 1), there may have been an effect of dilution in the crude protein content due to the lower amount 
of N in the grains, and the same performance was observed by Farinelli and Lemos (2010) and Amaral et al. 
(2016). 

The values for the cooking time of the IAC Nuance cultivar are close to those verified by Carbonell et 
al. (2020), of 33 minutes, in a study with cultivars of special bean for export (IAC Nuance, IAC Tigre, IAC 
Boreal and IAC Harmonia), in 18 environments in the rainy, dry and winter seasons. Alves et al. (2020), using 
special grain cultivars and top-dressing N application of 90 kg ha-1, in the winter season, found an average 
value of 28 minutes. Ribeiro et al. (2014) evaluated 29 special grain bean strains in the state of Rio Grande 
do Sul and verified that the cooking time ranged from 14 to 36 minutes. The cultivar IAC 1849 Polaco, of 
Carioca grain, was the only one for which the cooking time did not differ statistically with the increase in top-
dressing N doses, obtaining values between 20 and 22 minutes, which are below the cooking time of 30 
minutes observed by Chiorato et al. (2020a). The cultivar IAC Veloz, of black grains, had the longest cooking 



Bioscience Journal  |  2023  |  vol. 39, e39005  |  https://doi.org/10.14393/BJ-v39n0a2023-61040 

 

 
10 

Response of early-cycle common bean cultivars with carioca, black and speckled grains to top-dressing nitrogen fertilization 

time at the N dose of 180 kg ha-1, with a value of 27 minutes, which is below the cooking time of 32 minutes 
verified by Chiorato et al. (2020b). 

The results to maximum hydration time demonstrate the superiority of IAC Veloz in terms of this 
qualitative attribute, since in Brazilian cookery, during the process of food preparation, bean grains are 
soaked for approximately 12 h (Santis et al. 2019). Alves et al. (2020), working with five common bean 
cultivars with Carioca grain (BRS Estilo, BRS MG Majestoso, BRS Ametista, BRS Cometa and BRS Notável) and 
five cultivars with special grain for export (BRS MG Realce, BRS Embaixador, BRS FS 305, BRS Executivo and 
BRS Garça), verified on average for each group values of 13h18min and 14h16min, respectively. Although 
there was no effect of N doses and C x N interaction on this qualitative attribute, it can be verified that the 
cultivar IAC Veloz also stood out, obtaining the shortest times for maximum grain hydration at each top -
dressing N dose (Table 6). However, Farinelli and Lemos (2010) verified that there was an increase in the 
time for maximum grain hydration with N doses of 0, 40, 80 and 120 kg ha-1 applied as top-dressing. The 
authors also reported that the hydration capacity of common bean grains is dependent on the cultivar, 
storage conditions and environment, emphasizing the need for scientific studies about the influence of N 
fertilization on this qualitative characteristic. 

Analysis of the biplot showed a positive correlation between the variables crude protein, 100-grain 
weight, cooking time and sieve yield greater than or equal to 11, 12, 13 and 14 and negative correlation of 
these variables with leaf N content, number of grains per pod, number of pods per plant, grain yield and dry 
matter. This indicates the dilution effect discussed earlier, in which higher grain yields are inversely 
correlated with the protein content of the grains. In addition, there is a direct correlation between protein 
content, 100-grain weight and cooking time, i.e., the larger the size and protein content of the grains, the 
longer the cooking time. This can be justified by the greater difficulty of water in breaking down the 
molecules of carbohydrates and proteins of the grains and promoting their ideal cooking. It was verified that 
the time for maximum hydration was not correlated with any other variable, being the only one 
discriminated by PC2, that is, the variation in the time for maximum hydration of common bean grains is 
independent of the other variables analyzed. 
 
5. Conclusions 
 

Early-cycle common bean cultivars with different types of grains respond differently to N doses 
applied as top-dressing regarding agronomic and qualitative attributes. The cultivar IAC Veloz stood out in 
terms of shoot dry matter production, leaf N content, number of pods per plant and number of grains per 
pod, and the use of increasing N doses up to 180 kg ha-1 applied as top-dressing increased grain yield linearly, 
so it was classified as efficient to the N use. The cultivars IAC Nuance and IAC 1849 Polaco reached maximum 
grain yields of 1,741 and 1,784 kg ha-1 with 155 and 163 kg ha-1 of N applied as top-dressing, with increases 
in grain yield due to the N application of up to 25.3 and 20.2%, respectively. This demonstrates that, among 
the evaluated cultivars, the IAC Nuance is the one with the greatest response to nitrogen fertilizati on. 
Increasing doses of top-dressing N increase the sieve yield and crude protein content of common bean, with 
the cultivar IAC Nuance standing out for the amount of grains retained on all sieves. The cultivars have good 
grain quality, and IAC 1849 Polaco and IAC Veloz stood out with the shortest cooking time and IAC Veloz also 
with the fastest hydration. 
 
Authors' Contributions: OLIVEIRA, N.H.C.: conception and design, acquisition of data, analysis and interpretation of data, drafting the 
manuscript, final  approval;  COELHO,  A.P.:  analysis  and  interpretation  of  data,  drafting  the  manuscript,  final  approval;  MEIRELLES,   F.C.: 
acquisition of data, analysis  and  interpretation  of  data,  final  approval;  CAZUZA NETO,  A.:  analysis  and  interp retation  of data, drafting the 
manuscript, final approval; LEMOS, L.B.: supervision, drafting the manuscript, final approval. All authors have read and appr oved the final version 
of the manuscript. 
 
Conflicts of Interest: The authors declare no conflicts of interest. 
 
Ethics Approval: Not applicable. 
 
Acknowledgments: The authors would like to thank the CAPES (Coordenação de Aperfeiçoamento de Pessoal de Nível Superior -Brasil), Finance 
Code 001. 
 
 



Bioscience Journal  |  2023  |  vol. 39, e39005  |  https://doi.org/10.14393/BJ-v39n0a2023-61040 

 
 

 
11 

DE OLIVEIRA, N.H.C., et al. 

References 
 
ALVES, M.A.P., et al. Desempenho agronômico e qualitativo de cultivares de feijoeiro dos grupos comerciais carioca e especial na época de 
inverno. Revista de la Faculdad de Agronomía. 2020, 119, 1-8. https://doi.org/10.24215/16699513e046  
 
AMARAL, C.B., et al. Produtividade e qualidade do feijoeiro cultivado sobre palhadas de gramíneas e adubado com nitrogênio em  plantio 
direto. Pesquisa Agropecuária Brasileira. 2016, 51(9), 1602-1609. https://doi.org/10.1590/s0100-204x2016000900060 
 
AMBROSANO, et al. 1997. Feijão. In: RAIJ, B.V., et al. (Eds.). Recomendação de adubação e calagem para o Estado de São Paulo. (p. 194-195). 
Campinas: Instituto Agronômico de Campinas. 
 
ARAGÃO, O.O.S., et al. Effect of pot size on the growth of common bean in experiment with Rhizobium. Journal of Soil Science and Plant 
Nutrition. 2020, 20, 865-871. https://doi.org/10.1007/s42729-020-00172-7.7 
 
BETTIOL, J.V.T., et al. Sustainable production of common beans: inoculation, co-inoculation and mineral fertilization in early-cycle cultivars. 
Journal of Plant Nutrition. 2020, 43, 1-13. https://doi.org/10.1080/01904167.2020.1822403 
 
CARBONELL, S.A.M., et al. Tamanho de grão comercial em cultivares de feijoeiro. Ciência Rural. 2010, 40, 2067-2073. 
https://dx.doi.org/10.1590/S0103-84782010005000159 
 
CARBONELL, S.A.M., et al. IAC Nuance and IAC Tigre: common bean cultivars for special markets. Crop Breeding and Applied Biotechnology. 
2020, 20(3), e26732035. http://dx.doi.org/10.1590/1984- 70332020v20n3c39 
 
CHIORATO, A.F., et al. IAC 1849 Polaco: carioca common bean cultivar with an early maturity and tolerance to seed darkening. Crop Breeding 
and Applied Biotechnology. 2020a, 20(3), e30232036. http://dx.doi.org/10.1590/1984- 70332020v20n3c40 
 
CHIORATO, A.F., et al. IAC Veloz: a new early-cycle black bean cultivar. Crop Breeding and Applied Biotechnology. 2020b, 20(3), e25412034. 
http://dx.doi.org/10.1590/1984- 70332020v20n3c38 
 
CONAB - Companhia Nacional de Abastecimento. 2020. Acompanhamento da safra brasileira – grãos. CONAB, Brasília. 
 
DIAS, P.A.S., et al. Production and disease resistance of elite black bean lines previously selected using mineral nitrogen fertilization cultivat ed 
with natural versus artificial nitrogen supplementation. Genetics and Molecular Research. 2020, 19, gmr18491. 
http://dx.doi.org/10.4238/gmr18491 
 
FAGERIA, N.K., et al. 2015. Nutrição mineral do feijoeiro. Brasília: Embrapa. 
 
FAO - Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations. 2019. The global economy of pulses. Rome: Fao. 
 
FARINELLI, R. and LEMOS, L.B. Produtividade, eficiência agronômica, características nutricionais e tecnológicas do feijão adubado com 
nitrogênio em plantio direto e convencional. Bragantia. 2010, 69, 165-172. https://doi.org/10.1590/S0006-87052010000100021 
 
KAISER, H.F. The varimax criterion for analytic rotation in factor analysis. Psychometrika. 1958, 23, 187-200. 
https://dx.doi.org/10.1007/BF02289233  
 
KLASENER, G.R., et al. Consumer preference and the technological and nutritional quality of different bean colours. Acta Scientiarum 
Agronomy. 2020, 42, e43689. https://doi.org/10.4025/actasciagron.v42i1.43689  
 
LEAL, F.T., et al. Use efficiency and responsivity to nitrogen of common bean cultivars. Ciência e Agrotecnologia. 2019, 46, e004919. 
http://dx.doi.org/10.1590/1413-7054201943004919  
 
LEMOS, B.L., et al. 2015. Cultivares. In: ARF, O., et al. (Eds.). Aspectos gerais da cultura do feijão Phaseolus vulgaris (p. 181-207). Botucatu: 
Fepaf. 
 
NASCENTE, A.S., et al. Common bean grain yield as affected by sulfur fertilization and cultivars. Revista Ceres. 2017, 64(5), 548-552. 
https://doi.org/10.1590/0034-737x201764050013  
 
PROCTOR, J.R. and WATTS, B.M. Development of a modified Mattson Bean Cooker procedure based on sensory panel cookability eval uation. 
Canadian Institute of Food Science and Technology Journal. 1987, 20, 9-14. https://dx.doi.org/1016/S0315- 5463(87)70662-2 
 
RIBEIRO, N.D., et al. Desempenho agronômico e qualidade de cozimento de linhagens de feijão de grãos especiais. Revista Ciência Agronômica. 
2014, 45, 92-100. https://doi.org/10.1590/S1806-66902014000100012  
 
SANTIS, F.P., et al. Componentes de produção, produtividade e atributos tecnológicos de cultivares de feijoeiro do grupo comercial carioca. 
Colloquium Agrariae. 2019, 15, 21-30. https://doi.org/10.5747/ca. 2019.v15.n6.a332  
 
SORATTO, R.P., et al. Épocas de aplicação de nitrogênio em feijoeiro cultivado após milho solteiro ou consorciado com braquiá ria. Pesquisa 
Agropecuária Brasileira. 2013, 48, 1351-1359. https://doi.org/10.1590/S0100-204X2013001000006 
 

https://doi.org/10.24215/16699513e046
https://doi.org/10.1590/s0100-204x2016000900060
https://doi.org/10.1590/s0100-204x2016000900060
https://doi.org/10.1007/s42729-020-00172-7.7
https://doi.org/10.1007/s42729-020-00172-7.7
https://doi.org/10.1080/01904167.2020.1822403
https://dx.doi.org/10.1590/S0103-84782010005000159
https://dx.doi.org/10.1590/S0103-84782010005000159
http://dx.doi.org/10.1590/1984-%2070332020v20n3c39
http://dx.doi.org/10.1590/1984-%2070332020v20n3c40
http://dx.doi.org/10.1590/1984-%2070332020v20n3c38
http://dx.doi.org/10.4238/gmr18491
http://dx.doi.org/10.4238/gmr18491
https://doi.org/10.1590/S0006-87052010000100021
https://doi.org/10.1590/S0006-87052010000100021
https://dx.doi.org/10.1007/BF02289233
https://doi.org/10.4025/actasciagron.v42i1.43689
http://dx.doi.org/10.1590/1413-7054201943004919
https://doi.org/10.1590/0034-737x201764050013
https://dx.doi.org/1016/S0315-%205463(87)70662-2
https://doi.org/10.1590/S1806-66902014000100012
https://doi.org/10.5747/ca.%202019.v15.n6.a332


Bioscience Journal  |  2023  |  vol. 39, e39005  |  https://doi.org/10.14393/BJ-v39n0a2023-61040 

 

 
12 

Response of early-cycle common bean cultivars with carioca, black and speckled grains to top-dressing nitrogen fertilization 

SORATTO, R.P., et al. Plant density and nitrogen fertilization on common bean nutrition and yield. Revista Caatinga. 2017, 30, 670-678. 
https://doi.org/10.1590/1983-21252017v30n315rc  
 
SOUZA, S.S., et al., Maize cropping systems and response of common bean in succession subjected to nitrogen fertilization. Pesquisa 
Agropecuária Tropical. 2019, 49, e55718. http://dx.doi.org/10.1590/1983-40632019v4955718 
 
TAIZ, L. and ZEIGER, E. 2017. Fisiologia Vegetal. Porto Alegre: Artmed. 
 
 
Received: 13 May 2021 | Accepted: 8 May 2022 | Published: 03 February 2023 
 
 

 
 
  

This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, 
distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited. 

https://doi.org/10.1590/1983-21252017v30n315rc
http://dx.doi.org/10.1590/1983-40632019v4955718