id	sid	eid	entity	type
blj-2302	1	1	lawjournalvolume11 brandeis university law journal	ORG
blj-2302	1	2	2023-2024	DATE
blj-2302	1	3	11	CARDINAL
blj-2302	1	4	winterbottom v. wright	PERSON
blj-2302	1	5	thomas v. winchester	PERSON
blj-2302	1	6	harrison sugarman434	PERSON
blj-2302	3	1	winterbottom v. wright	PERSON
blj-2302	3	2	thomas v. winchester	PERSON
blj-2302	6	1	i. introduction james mcgreevey	PERSON
blj-2302	6	2	new jersey	GPE
blj-2302	6	3	american	NORP
blj-2302	7	1	the 1930s	DATE
blj-2302	7	2	american	NORP
blj-2302	7	3	435	CARDINAL
blj-2302	7	4	james mcgreevey	PERSON
blj-2302	7	5	james mcgreevey	PERSON
blj-2302	8	1	434	CARDINAL
blj-2302	8	2	2024	CARDINAL
blj-2302	9	1	117	CARDINAL
blj-2302	9	2	brandeis university law journal	ORG
blj-2302	9	3	2023-2024	DATE
blj-2302	9	4	11	CARDINAL
blj-2302	10	1	american	NORP
blj-2302	10	2	18th-century	DATE
blj-2302	10	3	1815-1855	DATE
blj-2302	12	1	these years	DATE
blj-2302	15	1	winterbottom v. wright	PERSON
blj-2302	15	2	1842	DATE
blj-2302	15	3	thomas v. winchester	PERSON
blj-2302	15	4	1852	DATE
blj-2302	15	5	two	CARDINAL
blj-2302	15	6	a decade	DATE
blj-2302	16	1	between two or	CARDINAL
blj-2302	17	1	two	CARDINAL
blj-2302	18	1	american	NORP
blj-2302	20	1	two	CARDINAL
blj-2302	21	1	two	CARDINAL
blj-2302	21	2	438	CARDINAL
blj-2302	21	3	1362	CARDINAL
blj-2302	22	1	437	CARDINAL
blj-2302	22	2	436	CARDINAL
blj-2302	22	3	1591	DATE
blj-2302	23	1	436	CARDINAL
blj-2302	23	2	henry campbell black	PERSON
blj-2302	23	3	1060	DATE
blj-2302	23	4	1374	CARDINAL
blj-2302	23	5	4th	ORDINAL
blj-2302	23	6	1968	DATE
blj-2302	24	1	pdf	ORG
blj-2302	25	1	118	CARDINAL
blj-2302	25	2	brandeis university law journal	ORG
blj-2302	25	3	2023-2024	DATE
blj-2302	25	4	11	CARDINAL
blj-2302	26	1	between late 19th century	DATE
blj-2302	28	1	winterbottom v. wright	PERSON
blj-2302	29	1	first	ORDINAL
blj-2302	29	2	twelve	CARDINAL
blj-2302	29	3	450	CARDINAL
blj-2302	29	4	rome	GPE
blj-2302	29	5	britain	GPE
blj-2302	29	6	43	CARDINAL
blj-2302	29	7	english	LANGUAGE
blj-2302	30	1	summa theologica	ORG
blj-2302	30	2	st.	GPE
blj-2302	30	3	thomas aquinas	PERSON
blj-2302	30	4	english	LANGUAGE
blj-2302	30	5	english	LANGUAGE
blj-2302	30	6	1842	DATE
blj-2302	30	7	american	NORP
blj-2302	30	8	443	CARDINAL
blj-2302	31	1	959–960	CARDINAL
blj-2302	32	1	442	CARDINAL
blj-2302	32	2	958–959	CARDINAL
blj-2302	33	1	441 owen	PERSON
blj-2302	33	2	supra	PERSON
blj-2302	33	3	439	CARDINAL
blj-2302	33	4	958	CARDINAL
blj-2302	34	1	440	CARDINAL
blj-2302	34	2	john c. reitz	PERSON
blj-2302	34	3	37 am	TIME
blj-2302	35	1	j. comp	PERSON
blj-2302	36	1	247	CARDINAL
blj-2302	36	2	249	CARDINAL
blj-2302	36	3	1989	DATE
blj-2302	37	1	439 david g. owen	PERSON
blj-2302	37	2	26	CARDINAL
blj-2302	37	3	litig	PERSON
blj-2302	38	1	956	CARDINAL
blj-2302	38	2	2007	DATE
blj-2302	39	1	119	CARDINAL
blj-2302	39	2	brandeis university law journal	ORG
blj-2302	39	3	2023-2024	DATE
blj-2302	39	4	11	CARDINAL
blj-2302	39	5	winterbottom v. wright	GPE
blj-2302	39	6	first	ORDINAL
blj-2302	40	1	winterbottom	ORG
blj-2302	40	2	august 8	DATE
blj-2302	40	3	1840.445	CARDINAL
blj-2302	40	4	wright	PERSON
blj-2302	40	5	it.446	LAW
blj-2302	40	6	winterbottom	ORG
blj-2302	40	7	wright	PERSON
blj-2302	40	8	exchequer	CARDINAL
blj-2302	40	9	wright	PERSON
blj-2302	40	10	winterbottom	PERSON
blj-2302	40	11	wright	PERSON
blj-2302	40	12	winterbottom	GPE
blj-2302	40	13	winterbottom	PERSON
blj-2302	40	14	wright	PERSON
blj-2302	40	15	winterbottom	GPE
blj-2302	40	16	nathaniel atkinson	PERSON
blj-2302	40	17	atkinson	PERSON
blj-2302	40	18	451	CARDINAL
blj-2302	41	1	109	CARDINAL
blj-2302	42	1	450	CARDINAL
blj-2302	43	1	winterbottom v. wright	PERSON
blj-2302	43	2	supra	PERSON
blj-2302	43	3	445	CARDINAL
blj-2302	43	4	110–116	CARDINAL
blj-2302	44	1	448	CARDINAL
blj-2302	44	2	436	CARDINAL
blj-2302	44	3	267	CARDINAL
blj-2302	45	1	447	CARDINAL
blj-2302	45	2	exchequer	CARDINAL
blj-2302	45	3	one	CARDINAL
blj-2302	45	4	four	CARDINAL
blj-2302	45	5	england	GPE
blj-2302	45	6	english	NORP
blj-2302	45	7	the late 19th century	DATE
blj-2302	47	1	446	CARDINAL
blj-2302	48	1	445	CARDINAL
blj-2302	48	2	110–116	CARDINAL
blj-2302	49	1	444	CARDINAL
blj-2302	49	2	960	CARDINAL
blj-2302	50	1	120	CARDINAL
blj-2302	50	2	brandeis university law journal	ORG
blj-2302	50	3	2023-2024	DATE
blj-2302	50	4	11	CARDINAL
blj-2302	50	5	wright	PERSON
blj-2302	50	6	wright	PERSON
blj-2302	50	7	winterbottom	GPE
blj-2302	50	8	wright	PERSON
blj-2302	50	9	winterbottom	PERSON
blj-2302	50	10	ten years later	DATE
blj-2302	50	11	thomas v. winchester	PERSON
blj-2302	50	12	winterbottom v. wright	PERSON
blj-2302	51	1	mary ann thomas	PERSON
blj-2302	51	2	thomas	PERSON
blj-2302	51	3	dr.	PERSON
blj-2302	51	4	foord	GPE
blj-2302	51	5	thomas	PERSON
blj-2302	51	6	belladonna	PERSON
blj-2302	52	1	thomas	PERSON
blj-2302	52	2	winchester	PRODUCT
blj-2302	52	3	a. gilbert	PERSON
blj-2302	53	1	gilbert	PERSON
blj-2302	53	2	aspinwall	ORG
blj-2302	53	3	dr.	PERSON
blj-2302	53	4	the new york court of appeals	ORG
blj-2302	53	5	1852	DATE
blj-2302	53	6	winchester	PERSON
blj-2302	53	7	first	ORDINAL
blj-2302	53	8	460 thomas v. winchester	PERSON
blj-2302	53	9	456	CARDINAL
blj-2302	54	1	459	CARDINAL
blj-2302	56	1	d.	NORP
blj-2302	56	2	daniel breen	PERSON
blj-2302	56	3	454	CARDINAL
blj-2302	57	1	457	CARDINAL
blj-2302	58	1	456	CARDINAL
blj-2302	59	1	thomas v. winchester	PERSON
blj-2302	59	2	https://www.nycourts.gov/reporter/archives/thomas_winchester.htm	DATE
blj-2302	59	3	dec 3	DATE
blj-2302	59	4	2023	CARDINAL
blj-2302	60	1	455	CARDINAL
blj-2302	61	1	454	CARDINAL
blj-2302	61	2	daniel breen	PERSON
blj-2302	61	3	2021	CARDINAL
blj-2302	62	1	453	CARDINAL
blj-2302	63	1	110–116	CARDINAL
blj-2302	64	1	452	CARDINAL
blj-2302	64	2	brandeis university law journal	ORG
blj-2302	64	3	2023-2024	DATE
blj-2302	64	4	11	CARDINAL
blj-2302	65	1	negligence.462	ORG
blj-2302	65	2	thomas	PERSON
blj-2302	65	3	thomas v. winchester crystalised	PERSON
blj-2302	65	4	winterbottom v. wright	PERSON
blj-2302	66	1	two	CARDINAL
blj-2302	67	1	first	ORDINAL
blj-2302	67	2	winterbottom v. wright	PERSON
blj-2302	67	3	thomas v. winchester	PERSON
blj-2302	69	1	second	ORDINAL
blj-2302	69	2	anglo-american	NORP
blj-2302	69	3	american	NORP
blj-2302	70	1	donald g. gifford	PERSON
blj-2302	70	2	david g. owen	PERSON
blj-2302	70	3	joseph f. rice school	PERSON
blj-2302	71	1	464	CARDINAL
blj-2302	71	2	daniel breen	PERSON
blj-2302	71	3	454	CARDINAL
blj-2302	72	1	463	CARDINAL
blj-2302	73	1	brandeis university law journal	ORG
blj-2302	73	2	2023-2024	DATE
blj-2302	73	3	11	CARDINAL
blj-2302	74	1	two	CARDINAL
blj-2302	75	1	american	NORP
blj-2302	75	2	american	NORP
blj-2302	75	3	the second half of the 19th century	DATE
blj-2302	76	1	owen	PERSON
blj-2302	76	2	american	NORP
blj-2302	76	3	us	GPE
blj-2302	76	4	the beginning of the 20th	DATE
blj-2302	79	1	american	NORP
blj-2302	79	2	469	CARDINAL
blj-2302	79	3	u.s.	GPE
blj-2302	79	4	2022	CARDINAL
blj-2302	80	1	468	CARDINAL
blj-2302	81	1	30–31	CARDINAL
blj-2302	81	2	467	CARDINAL
blj-2302	81	3	donald g. gifford	PERSON
blj-2302	81	4	30	CARDINAL
blj-2302	81	5	2017	CARDINAL
blj-2302	82	1	466	CARDINAL
blj-2302	83	1	supra	PERSON
blj-2302	83	2	439	CARDINAL
blj-2302	83	3	963	CARDINAL
blj-2302	84	1	123	CARDINAL
blj-2302	84	2	brandeis university law journal	ORG
blj-2302	84	3	2023-2024	DATE
blj-2302	84	4	11	CARDINAL
blj-2302	84	5	alexander hamilton	PERSON
blj-2302	86	1	american	NORP
blj-2302	86	2	morton horowitz	PERSON
blj-2302	86	3	eighteenth-century	DATE
blj-2302	89	1	american	NORP
blj-2302	89	2	ny	GPE
blj-2302	89	3	american	NORP
blj-2302	89	4	thomas v. winchester	PERSON
blj-2302	89	5	winterbottom v. wright	PERSON
blj-2302	89	6	english	NORP
blj-2302	89	7	winterbottom v. wright	GPE
blj-2302	89	8	american	NORP
blj-2302	89	9	the ny court of appeals	ORG
blj-2302	89	10	britain	GPE
blj-2302	89	11	us	GPE
blj-2302	90	1	474	CARDINAL
blj-2302	90	2	daniel breen	PERSON
blj-2302	90	3	454	CARDINAL
blj-2302	90	4	supra	PERSON
blj-2302	90	5	467	CARDINAL
blj-2302	90	6	50	CARDINAL
blj-2302	90	7	owen	PERSON
blj-2302	90	8	supra	PERSON
blj-2302	90	9	439	CARDINAL
blj-2302	90	10	960	CARDINAL
blj-2302	91	1	473	CARDINAL
blj-2302	91	2	469	CARDINAL
blj-2302	92	1	472	CARDINAL
blj-2302	92	2	j. horwitz	PERSON
blj-2302	92	3	19 am	TIME
blj-2302	93	1	j. leg.	PERSON
blj-2302	95	1	251	CARDINAL
blj-2302	95	2	251	CARDINAL
blj-2302	95	3	1975	DATE
blj-2302	96	1	471	CARDINAL
blj-2302	97	1	470	CARDINAL
blj-2302	97	2	alexander hamilton	PERSON
blj-2302	97	3	401	CARDINAL
blj-2302	97	4	409	CARDINAL
blj-2302	97	5	alexander hamilton ed	PERSON
blj-2302	97	6	gideon ed.	PERSON
blj-2302	97	7	2001	DATE
blj-2302	98	1	124	CARDINAL
blj-2302	98	2	brandeis university law journal	ORG
blj-2302	98	3	2023-2024	DATE
blj-2302	98	4	11	CARDINAL
blj-2302	99	1	the decades prior	DATE
blj-2302	99	2	63 percent	PERCENT
blj-2302	99	3	american	NORP
blj-2302	99	4	gifford	PERSON
blj-2302	99	5	american	NORP
blj-2302	99	6	481	CARDINAL
blj-2302	100	1	18	CARDINAL
blj-2302	100	2	479	CARDINAL
blj-2302	101	1	19	DATE
blj-2302	101	2	478	CARDINAL
blj-2302	101	3	supra	PERSON
blj-2302	101	4	467	CARDINAL
blj-2302	101	5	31	DATE
blj-2302	102	1	477	CARDINAL
blj-2302	102	2	469	CARDINAL
blj-2302	103	1	476	CARDINAL
blj-2302	103	2	2022	CARDINAL
blj-2302	104	1	475	CARDINAL
blj-2302	104	2	supra	PERSON
blj-2302	104	3	467	CARDINAL
blj-2302	104	4	17	CARDINAL
blj-2302	104	5	125	CARDINAL
blj-2302	104	6	brandeis university law journal	ORG
blj-2302	104	7	2023-2024	DATE
blj-2302	104	8	11	CARDINAL
blj-2302	105	1	lewis mumford	PERSON
blj-2302	105	2	american	NORP
blj-2302	105	3	the 20th century	DATE
blj-2302	108	1	paleotechnic technology	ORG
blj-2302	108	2	1842	DATE
blj-2302	108	3	lemuel shaw	PERSON
blj-2302	108	4	the massachusetts supreme court	ORG
blj-2302	108	5	farwell v. boston & worcester	ORG
blj-2302	108	6	1842	DATE
blj-2302	108	7	487	CARDINAL
blj-2302	108	8	farwell v. boston & w. r. r. corp	ORG
blj-2302	108	9	55	DATE
blj-2302	108	10	486	CARDINAL
blj-2302	108	11	469	CARDINAL
blj-2302	108	12	485	CARDINAL
blj-2302	108	13	10	CARDINAL
blj-2302	109	1	484	CARDINAL
blj-2302	110	1	19	DATE
blj-2302	110	2	483	CARDINAL
blj-2302	112	1	brandeis university law journal	ORG
blj-2302	112	2	2023-2024	DATE
blj-2302	112	3	11	CARDINAL
blj-2302	112	4	shaw	PERSON
blj-2302	112	5	shaw	PERSON
blj-2302	113	1	winterbottom v. wright	GPE
blj-2302	114	1	france	GPE
blj-2302	116	1	winterbottom	ORG
blj-2302	116	2	492	CARDINAL
blj-2302	118	1	490	CARDINAL
blj-2302	118	2	supra	PERSON
blj-2302	118	3	445	CARDINAL
blj-2302	118	4	111	CARDINAL
blj-2302	119	1	489	CARDINAL
blj-2302	120	1	488	CARDINAL
blj-2302	120	2	469	CARDINAL
blj-2302	121	1	127	CARDINAL
blj-2302	121	2	brandeis university law journal	ORG
blj-2302	121	3	2023-2024	DATE
blj-2302	121	4	11	CARDINAL
blj-2302	122	1	winterbottom	ORG
blj-2302	122	2	thomas v. winchester	PERSON
blj-2302	122	3	belladonna	PERSON
blj-2302	123	1	two	CARDINAL
blj-2302	124	1	ruggles	PERSON
blj-2302	125	1	ruggles	PERSON
blj-2302	126	1	498	CARDINAL
blj-2302	126	2	497	CARDINAL
blj-2302	126	3	daniel breen	PERSON
blj-2302	126	4	454	CARDINAL
blj-2302	127	1	496	CARDINAL
blj-2302	129	1	thomas v. winchester	PERSON
blj-2302	129	2	456	CARDINAL
blj-2302	130	1	493	CARDINAL
blj-2302	131	1	128	CARDINAL
blj-2302	131	2	brandeis university law journal	ORG
blj-2302	131	3	2023-2024	DATE
blj-2302	131	4	11	CARDINAL
blj-2302	133	1	1820	DATE
blj-2302	139	1	502	CARDINAL
blj-2302	140	1	11	CARDINAL
blj-2302	141	1	500	CARDINAL
blj-2302	141	2	supra	PERSON
blj-2302	141	3	467	CARDINAL
blj-2302	141	4	9	CARDINAL
blj-2302	141	5	11	DATE
blj-2302	141	6	499	CARDINAL
blj-2302	142	1	brandeis university law journal	ORG
blj-2302	142	2	2023-2024	DATE
blj-2302	142	3	11	CARDINAL
blj-2302	142	4	winterbottom v. wright	GPE
blj-2302	143	1	james scarlett abinger	PERSON
blj-2302	144	1	winterbottom	GPE
blj-2302	145	1	abinger	PERSON
blj-2302	146	1	wright	PERSON
blj-2302	146	2	winterbottom	GPE
blj-2302	147	1	nysc	GPE
blj-2302	147	2	thomas v. winchester	PERSON
blj-2302	148	1	charles ruggles	PERSON
blj-2302	148	2	wright v. winterbottom	PERSON
blj-2302	152	1	508	CARDINAL
blj-2302	152	2	507	CARDINAL
blj-2302	152	3	thomas v. winchester	PERSON
blj-2302	152	4	456	CARDINAL
blj-2302	153	1	506	CARDINAL
blj-2302	153	2	daniel breen	PERSON
blj-2302	153	3	454	CARDINAL
blj-2302	154	1	505	CARDINAL
blj-2302	156	1	503	CARDINAL
blj-2302	156	2	winterbottom v. wright	PERSON
blj-2302	156	3	supra	PERSON
blj-2302	156	4	445	CARDINAL
blj-2302	156	5	112	CARDINAL
blj-2302	157	1	130	CARDINAL
blj-2302	157	2	brandeis university law journal	ORG
blj-2302	157	3	2023-2024	DATE
blj-2302	157	4	11	CARDINAL
blj-2302	160	1	thomas v. winchester	PERSON
blj-2302	160	2	1916	DATE
blj-2302	160	3	macpherson v. buick motor company	ORG
blj-2302	160	4	benjamin cardozo	PERSON
blj-2302	160	5	the ny court of appeals	ORG
blj-2302	160	6	the early 20th century	DATE
blj-2302	160	7	carodozo	PERSON
blj-2302	160	8	514	CARDINAL
blj-2302	161	1	512	CARDINAL
blj-2302	161	2	daniel breen	PERSON
blj-2302	161	3	2021	CARDINAL
blj-2302	162	1	511	CARDINAL
blj-2302	163	1	510	CARDINAL
blj-2302	163	2	daniel breen	PERSON
blj-2302	163	3	454	CARDINAL
blj-2302	164	1	509	CARDINAL
blj-2302	165	1	131	CARDINAL
blj-2302	165	2	brandeis university law journal	ORG
blj-2302	165	3	2023-2024	DATE
blj-2302	165	4	11	CARDINAL
blj-2302	166	1	516	CARDINAL
blj-2302	166	2	supra	PERSON
blj-2302	166	3	467	CARDINAL
blj-2302	166	4	5	CARDINAL
blj-2302	166	5	515	CARDINAL
blj-2302	166	6	469	CARDINAL
blj-2302	166	7	132	CARDINAL