Bull 31 Aqeel Abbas Al-Zubaidi Bull. Iraq nat. Hist. Mus. July, (2018) 15 (1): 31-40 FACIES ANALYSIS AND NEW DISCOVERY OF A MASTODONT FROM INJANA FORMATION (LATE MIOCENE) NEAR THARTHAR LAKE- MIDDLE OF IRAQ Aqeel Abbas Al-Zubaidi Iraq Natural History Research Center and Museum, University of Baghdad, Baghdad, Iraq Corresponding author: aazubaidi@yahoo.com Received Date: 09 January 2018 Accepted Date:04 February 2018 ABSTRACT The study area comprises Injana Formation (Late Miocene), exposed on the hills nearby of Tharthar Lake and about 120 km north of Baghdad city. This study depends on sedimentologic and facies analysis to recognize paleoenvironment and recognize the kinds of vertebrate bone fossils during Late Miocene. Sedimentologic and facies analysis showed many sedimentary facies: facies (Se) of scoured erosional surface, facies of (Sp) cross- bedded sandstones, facies (Fs) of fine sandstone facies, facies of (Fc) claystone, and facies of (C) calcareous clay. Facies analysis referred to the sub environments which are: point bar, over bank and floodplain in addition to fining upward cycles of deposition, which refers to meandering fluvial depositional environment. Large vertebrate bone fossils were collected from the study area; the studied bone fossils probably are related to Proboscidea, Mastodont of Hemrin, which is named (Hemrin Mastodont). The current study considered the studied bone fossil as a new discovery of Proboscidea, Mastodont, which can be named (Tharthar Mastodont) after the name of the collection site of Tharthar Lake, from Injana Formation (Late Miocene), middle of Iraq. It was living near meandering fluvial environment which provided also plant diversity for herbivores. Key words: Bone fossils, Facies analysis, Injana Formation, Iraq, Proboscidea, Mastodont. INTRODUCTION Injana Formation (Late Miocene) comprises claystone, siltstone, mudstone and sandstone rock units (Bellen et al., 1959). Many authors studied its paleocurrent (Kukal and Saadallah, 1970), stratigraphy and sedimentology (Al-Naqib, 1959; Basi, 1973; Al-Mubarak and Youkhana, 1976; Al-Sammarai, 1978; Jassim et al., 1984; Al-Rawi et al., 1993; Al-Zubaidi, 2004). Facies analysis of its exposures, north Baghdad between Baiji and Sammarraa, showed many fining upward cycles of meandering fluvial system (Basi, 2007). Many sites were studied in countries of the region, such as: two species of proboscidean fossils of Late Miocene in the Axion Valley, Macedonia-Greece (Konidaris and Koufus, 2013); mammalian site in Akkasdagi in Turkey, L. Miocene (Valli, 2005.); Proboscidea in addition to many vertebrate fossils in Maragheh Formation, northwest Iran (Berner et al., 1996, 2001). Some vertebrate fossil sites were discovered in Iraq (Piveteau, 1935; Al-Naqib, 1959; Bellen, et al., 1959; Al-Zubaidi and Jan, 2015). Some mastodont species, of order proboscidea were DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.26842/binhm.7.2018.15.1.0031 32 Facies Analysis and New Discovery of a Mastodont recognized beside 20 types of vertebrate bone fossils within sandstone beds of Injana Formation (Thomas et al., 1981). Occurrence and history of Proboscidea: The earliest genera of the order Proboscidea appeared at North Africa during Early Miocene, about 50 million years ago. Mastodonts were expanded, about 20 mya, from Africa into Asia, Europe, then after to North America (Haynes, 1991). Nowadays there are two living genera, locally restricted, of the order Proboscidea: the African elephant Loxodonta africana (Blumenbach, 1797) and the Asian elephant Elephaus maximus (Linnaeus, 1758), (Gohlich, 1999). Two genera of Mammuths (Brookes, 1828) and Mammut (Blumenbach, 1799), synonyms of mastodonts or gomphotheres that disappeared from Europe, North Asia and North America. Three genera of mastodonts (gomphotheres) were also extinct from the world (Haynes, 1991). This study aims to determine the paleoenvironment, according to sedimentological facies model, and to recognize vertebrate bone fossils in L. Miocene site on the hills nearby Tharthar Lake, west Sammarraa city. MATERIALS AND METHODS Location: The study area is located in the hills nearby the Tharthar Lake beach, about 120 km north of the Baghdad city (Map 1). Field surveys and lithofacies descriptions included sedimentary structures and grain size were done on the rock bed units within Injana Formation (Late Miocene) exposed on the hills nearby Tharthar Lake beach. Lab and office works implicated facies analysis of lithofacies and prediction of facies model. Some large and small vertebrate bone fossils presences within cross-bedded sandstone were collected by fishermen from Tharthar Lake and were presented to the Iraq Natural History Research Center and Museum. Photos of bone fossils were taken and sent to three world authorities in vertebrate bone fossils taxonomy to confirm identification: Dr. William J. Sanders, Paleontology Museum, University of Michigan, USA. Dr. Andrea M. Valli, Vector Higo Research Centre, France and Afifi H. Abdul Gafar, Geological Museum, Egypt. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION Sedimentology: best exposed sections, on hills, more than 15 meters in high, nearby Tharthar Lake beach, about 50 kilometers west Sammarraa city, of Injana Formation were described; facies is a term used previously to describe grain size and sedimentary structures for rocks and sediments (Moore, 1949; Teichert, 1958). In the present study, five facies were recognized, following Miall (1977, 1978, 1988) from Injana Formation (Tab. 1, Diag. 1) as follow: 1- Facies (Se), Scoured erosional surface: this surface resulted from erosion on old sediments occurred on channel floor and coincided with high flow regime and discharge during flood and rainy season. On this surface there were coarse and very coarse sandstone, mud balls, claystone fragments in addition to large and small pieces of vertebrate bones were deposited. Involved surface formed by erosion on old bed, during fluvial flood and rainy seasons which caused high flow regime of fluvial system (stream current), (Maill, 1978; Oplustil et al., 2005; Basi, 2007). 2- Facies (Sp), Cross- bedded sandstone facies: this facies often overlain facies (Se) and composed of cross-bedded sandstone up to 1.2 meters in thickness, grain size range from medium to coarse grains and contains mud ball and small fragments of claystone and bone (Diag. 1). It is resulted from sand dune migration as a bed- load on channel floor or 33 Aqeel Abbas Al-Zubaidi as a channel lag deposits. This facies is similar to that described by Allen (1964) and Selley (1977) and it represents the lower part of river point bar sub environment. 3- Facies (Fs), Fine sandstone: it comprises of fine sandstone with silty and clayey materials, and reaches 2.6 meters in thickness, very fine sandstone alternated with mudstone and claystone. The main sedimentary structures, in this facies, are the parallel and cross laminations; this facies is underlain by facies (Sp) and overlain by (Fc) mudstone or claystone. Facies (Fs) are deposited from suspension materials due to presence of mudstone and claystone in addition to cross and parallel laminations (Diag. 1). It represents either upper part of point bar or over- bank sub environment (Maill, 1978; Oplustil et al., 2005). 4- Facies (Fc), Claystone facies: It is composed of a massive or a parallel lamination of claystone and mudstone and ranges from 1.9 – 4 meters in thickness (Diag. 1). The abundance of massive claystone and mudstone and the presence of parallel laminations refer to quite water environment of deposition (Miall, 1978). Involved facies refer to vertical accression of suspended clay materials on flood- plain basin. 5- Facies (C), Limy mud: It is composed of very fine layers of limy mud sediments, up to 0.3 meters in thickness and has gray to light gray color (Diag. 1). It reflects lakstrine- river sediments under arid climate conditions of back- swamp and/or oxbow lake, located on flood- plain sub environment (Basi, 2007). Table (1): Lithofacies and interpretation of Injana Formation (Late Miocene). Facies code Lithofacies Sedimentary structures Interpretation Se Erosional scours with mud balls and large bone fragments Crude cross- beddings Scoured fill (high flow regime and discharge) resulted from river flood and rainy seasons Sp Medium- v. coarse sand with small mud ball and small bone fragments Planar cross- bedded Sand dune, (low flow regime), lower part of point bar Fm Fine sandstone with silty and clayey materials Parallel and cross laminations Upper part of point bar or over- bank sub environment Fc Claystone and mudstone Massive or parallel lamination of claystone and mudstone Vertical accression of suspended clay materials on flood- plain basin C Limy mudstone Massive to laminated Back- swamp and/or oxbow lake on flood plain Rock bed succession of Injana Formation (Late Miocene) at studied area composed of: facies (Se) scoured erosional surface resulting during fluvial flood and rainy season to increase discharge and flow energy and transported bone of died animals and deposited on the scoured surfaces. Facies (Se) are overlain by facies (Sp) cross- bedded sand stone; the later facies are deposited on scoured surface to form lower part of point bar, followed by facies (Fs) fine sandstone of upper part of point bar and / or overbank sub environment, then facies (Fc) 34 Facies Analysis and New Discovery of a Mastodont are claystone deposited on flood- plain basin, and facies (C) limy mud are deposited from shallow lakstrine- river of back- swamps and/ or oxbow lakes during arid climatic conditions. Facies analysis of Injana Formation near Tharthar Lake shows three subenvironments: river channel, over bank and flood plain, that all refer to the meandering river environment (Diag. 2), resemble to the facies of the model by Allen (1964) and Miall (1977, 1978, 1988); it agrees also with Basi (2007) work on the subsurface section on Injana Formation near Sammarraa, and with Al-Banna (1982) work on the same formation in the north of Iraq, who concluded meandering or braided environment of deposition of upper part. The main direction of involved paleocurrents of fluvial system were from north east to south east (Kukal and Saadallah, 1970) which resulted from Zagros Belt uplift, and was caused by plate tectonic convergence of Arabian and Iranian plates. Vertebrate bone fossils: small and large fragments of vertebrate bone fossils were collected from facies (Sp) exposed on the hills nearby Tharthar Lake. Large bone fossil was more than 40 cm in length and 22 cm in thickness (Pl. 1), and was presented by fishermen, near Tharthar Lake, about 50 km west Sammarraa city. It is well known that the Wooly mammuths lived in the cool and dry environments of northern hemisphere (Lister and Sher, 2001; Bravo et al., 2008), while the studied bone fossil was deposited from meandering fluvial system at semi dry and warm climate during Late Miocene. Bone fossils included small and large pieces which refer to medium distance of transportation during multicycle of deposition. Photos of bone were taken and sent to three world authorities of vertebrate bone fossils. W. J. Sanders and A. H. abdul Gafar who mentioned that the large bone (Pl. 1) represented Femur of order Proboscidea. Andrea M. F. Valli, who referred to some important notes on the photo of studied large fossil, “It must be the distal part of a femur of large mammal; I think it belong to a proboscidian, but I can not specify the species; may be a mastodont; do you know kind of species you have in your country at this period”. Litreture surveys on mastodont occurrence in Iraq showed complete skulls, some isolated molars and post cranial elements of Choerolophodont mastodont genus, named Injana Mastodont, which were discovered on the north east flanks of Hemrin Southern Anticline within rock bed unit of Mukdadiya Formation (Pliocene) (Thomas, et al., 1981); in addition, another bone of Mastodont was found, by H. Al-Hashimi in 1977, (Buday, 1980) within Mukdadiya Formation (Pliocene), but he did not mention the collection site. The studied femur bone fossils found within facies (Sp) cross- bedded sandstone of Injana Formation (Late Miocene) near Tharthar Lake may be related temporally and spatially to the Hemrin Mastodont, which is not far away from the studied site. According to sedimentological and facies analysis, the studied Tharthar Mastodont was lived near meandering fluvial system which includes river channel, overbank and floodplain sub environments (Diag. 2); all provide water and suitable plants for vegetarian animals particularly for mastodont. Paleocurrent of Injana rivers flow from north east high-land Zagros thrust belt toward south west low-land (Mesopotamian basin now); since the gradient increased due to uplifting, folding and thrusting which resulted from the collision of Arabian and Iranian Plates. CONCLUSIONS Facies analysis of Injana Formation (Late Miocene) exposed on the hills near Tharthar Lake, about 50 km west Sammarraa city, Middle of Iraq, showed meandering fluvial environment that includes: river channel, overbank and flood plain sub environments. The mentioned river flows from Zagros fold belt at the northeast, to the foreland basin at southeast (now Middle of Iraq); when the gradient was increased due to uplifting, folding and thrusting resulted from collision of Arabian and Iranian Plates and closing of Tethys Sea. Sub 35 Aqeel Abbas Al-Zubaidi environments of meandering river systems contributed to enhance wide plant diversity and provide water, food and place for living and reproduction of Mastodont. During high rate rainy seasons, the above mentioned rivers flooded and increased discharge and flow energy to produce facies (Se), and the transporting bone of died Mastodont was deposited within facies (Sp) cross-bedded sandstone as a bed load on the facies (Se) to form lower part of point bar. Map (1): Location Map of study area. 36 Facies Analysis and New Discovery of a Mastodont Diagram (1): Vertical facies succession of Injana Formation at study area, near Tharthar Lake, Middle Iraq. 37 Aqeel Abbas Al-Zubaidi Diagram (2): Block diagram shows the paleoenvironment of Injana Formation at study area, near Tharthar Lake, Middle Iraq. Plate (1): Bone fossil, femure of Proboscidea, mastodonts (in two views) was collected from Injana Formation near Tharthar Lake- Middle of Iraq (scale: 15 cm). ACKNOWLEDGEMENT The author wish to acknowledge Prof. Dr. Mohammad K. Mohammad for his review of the manuscript and comments. LITERATURE CITED Al-Banna, N. Y. M. 1982. Sedimentological study of the Upper. Fars Formation in selected areas- Northern Iraq. M. Sc. Thesis. Mosul University, 177 pp. Al-Mubark, M. and Youkhana, R. 1976. Report on the regional geological mapping of Al- Fatha- Mosul area. GEOSURV, internal report no. 753. 38 Facies Analysis and New Discovery of a Mastodont Al-Naqib, K. M. 1959. Geology of southern area of Kirkuk Liwa. Technical Publication, International Petroleum Company, 50 pp. Al-Rawi, Y. T., Al-Sayyab, A. S., Jassim, J. M., Tamar- Agha, M. Y., Al- Sammarai, A. L., Karim, S. A., Basi, M. A., Dhiab, S. H., Faris, F. M. and Anwar, J. F. 1993. New names for some of the Middile Miocene- Pliocene Formations of Iraq (Fatha, Injana, Mukdadiya and Bai Hassan Formations), Iraqi Geological Journal, 25(1): 1-17. Al-Sammarai, K. I. 1978. Petrology of the Upper Fars Sandstones and the origin of their cement. M. Sc. Thesis, University of Baghdad, 141 pp. Al-Zubaidi, A. A. 2004. Mineralogical and geochemical study of rocks of Injana Formation from selected area, Central Iraq, and assessment of utilization for ceramic industries. Ph. D. Thesis. Department of Geology, University of Baghdad, 140 pp. (in Arabic). Al-Zubaidi, A. A. and Jan, S. K. 2015. Vertebrate fossils in Fatha, Injana and Mukdadiya Formations in Iraq. Iraqi Journal of Science, 56(3A): 1983-1988. Allen, J. R. L. 1964. Studies in fluviatile sedimentation of six cyclothems from the Lower Old Red Sandstone, Anglo- Welsh Basin. Sedimentology, 3:163- 138. Basi, M. A. 1973. Geology of Injana area, Hemrin south. Unpub. M. Sc. Thesis, University of Baghdad, 141 pp. Basi, M. A. 2007. Subsurface sedimentological study of Injana Formation (Late Miocene) in the area extended from Baiji to Sammarra cities. Central Iraq. Iraqi Bulletin of Geology and Mining, 3 (2) :43- 51. Bellen, R. C. V., Dunnington, H. V., Wetzel, R. and Morton, D. M. I. 1959. Lexique Stratigraphique International. 03 10Asie, Iraq, 333pp. Bernor, R. L., Solounias, N., Swisher III, C. C. and Van Couvering, J. A. 1996. The correlation of three classical “Pikermian” mammal faunas- Maragheh, Samos and Pikermi-with the European MN unit system. In: The Evolution of Western Eurasian Neogene Mammal Faunas, Bernor, R. L., Fahlbusch, V. and Mittmann, H. W.(eds.). Columbia University Press, New York, pp137-156. Bernor, R. L., Fortelius, M. and Rook, L. 2001. Evolutionary biogeography and paleoecology of the Oreopithecus bambolii Faunal Zone (late Miocene,Tusco-Sardinian Province). Bolletino della Società Paleontologica Italiana, 40(2): 139-148. Buday, T. 1980. The regional geology of Iraq: stratigraphy and paleogeography. In: Geosurvey of Iraq, Kassab, I. I. M. and Jassim , S. Z. (eds.)., Baghdad, 445 pp. Gohlich, U. 1999. The Miocene land mammals of Europe. In: Gertrud E. Rössner and Kurt Hessig (eds.), Institute fur Palaonutologie and Historische Geologie, Munchen, Germany, 515pp. Haynes, G. 1991. Mammuth, mastodonts. and elephants: Biology, behavior, and the fossils record. Cambridge University Press, 397pp. 39 Aqeel Abbas Al-Zubaidi Jassim, S. Z., Karim, S. A., Basi, M. A., Al- Mubarak, M. and Munir, J. 1984. Final report on the regional geological survey of Iraq, Vol. 3, Stratigraphy. GEOSURV, internal report number 498. Konidaris, G. E. and Koufos, G. D. 2013. Late Miocene Proboscidea (Mammalia) from Macedonia and Samos Island, Greece: Preliminary Results, 87(1): 121–140. Kukal, Z. and Saadallah, A. A. 1970. Paleocurrent in Mesopotamian Geosyncline. Sander Drukkans der Geologischen Runschan Band, 59: 666- 685. Lister, A. M. and Sher, A. V. 2001. The origin and evolution of the woolly mammoth. Science, 294: 1094- 1097. Miall, A. D. 1977. Fluvial sedimentology. Lecture series, Canadian Society of Petrolium Geologist, Calgary, 37pp. Miall, A. D. 1978. Fluvial sedimentology. Canadian Society Petroleum Geologists, Memoir, 5: 859 pp. Miall, A. D. 1988. Reservoir heterogeneities in fluvial sandstones: Lession from outcrop studies. American Association of Petroleum Geologist Bulletin,72(6) : 682- 697. Moore, R. C. 1949. Meaning of facies. In: Longwell, C. (eds.), Sedimentary facies in geological history. Geol. Soc. Amer. Memior 39: 1- 34. In: A. D. Miall, 2016. Stratigraphy: A Modern Synthesis, A comprehensive review of modern stratigraphic methods. Springer, 454 pp. NogÚes- Bravo, D., Rodriguez, J., Hortal, J., Batra, P. and Araujo, M. B. 2008. Climate change, humans, and the extinction of woolly mammoth. Plos Biology, 6 (4): e 79. Opluštil, S., Martínek, K. and Tasáryová, Z., 2005. Facies and architectural analysis of fluvial deposits of the Nýřany Member and the Týne Formation (Westphalian D– Barruelian) in the Kladno- Rakovník and Pilsen basins. Bulletin of Geosciences, 80(1): 45–66. Piveteau, J. 1935. Mammiferes du Pontien de Iraq. Bulletin of Geological Society of France, 5(5): 468- 470. Selley, R. C. 1977. An Introduction to Sedimentology. Academic Press London, New York, 408 pp. Teichert, C. 1958. Concept of facies. American Association of Petroleum Geologist Bulletin, 42: 2718- 2744. Thomas, H., Behnam, H. A. M. and Ligabue, G. 1981. New discoveries of vertebrate fossils in the "Bakhtiari Formation", Injana area, Hemrin South, Iraq. Journal of Geological Society of Iraq, 14 (1): 43-53. Valli, A. M. F.2005. Taphonomy of the Late Miocene Mammals locality of Akkasdagi, Turkey. Geodiversitas, 27 (4):793-80. 40 Facies Analysis and New Discovery of a Mastodont Bull. Iraq nat. Hist. Mus. (2018) 15 (1): 31-40 التحليل السحني واكتشاف جديد للماستودونت من تكوين انجانة وسط العراق -قرب بحيرة الثرثار (مايوسين متأخر) عقيل عباس الزبيدي جامعة بغداد ،ومتحف التاريخ الطبيعي العراقيمركز بحوث aazubaidi@yahoo.com 90/98/8902 :تاريخ القبول 90/90/8902 :تاريخ االستالم الخالصة الذي ينكشف على التالل القريبة من ( مايوسين متأخر)تهتم هذه الدراسة بتكوين انجانة وتعتمد على تطبيق علم . كم الى الشمال من مدينة بغداد 021بحيرة الثرثار التي تبعد بحوالي الرسوبيات سيما التحليل السحني لتحديد البيئة الترسيبة القديمة، وتشخيص نوع الفقريات . ايوسين المتأخرخالل الم سحنة : اشار علم الرسوبيات والتحليل السحني الى وجود عدة سحنات رسوبية، مثل (Se ) سطح التعرية المتعرج، وسحنة(Sp ) الصخور الرملية ذات التطبق المتقاطع، وسحنة (Fs ) الصخور الرملية الناعمة، وسحنة(Fc ) الصخور الطينية، وسحنة(C) الصخور الحواجز : وقد اشار التحليل السحني الى وجود البيئات الثانوية االتية. لجيريةالطينية ا اللسانية، وفوق الضفة، والسهل الفيضي؛ الى جانب وجود دورات التناعم الى االعلى، التي وتم جمع عظام متحجرات كبيرة من منطقة . تشير الى البيئة الترسيبية لالنهار االلتوائية . تصويرها وارسالها الى عدد من المتخصصين في علم المتحجراتالدراسة، والتي تم ولوحظ بان العظام المتحجرة قيد الدراسة ذات عالقة بالماستودونت من الخرطوميات في اسة الحالية تشير الى ان روبذلك فان الد ؛(ماستودونت حمرين)حمرين والذي يطلق عليه ميات، الماستودونت، والذي يمكن ان العظم المتحجر المدروس هو اكتشاف جديد للخرطو في وسط العراق، قرب ( المايوسين المتأخر)من تكوين انجانة ( ماستودونت الثرثار)تسميته . توائية التي توفر التنوع النباتي الى الحيوانات عشبية التغذيةلبيئة االنهار اال