College and Research Libraries


such areas of librarianship as developing 
collections, legal deposit, the growth of li-
braries, cataloging, union catalogs, the use 
of materials, rare and precious materials, li-
braries, types of libraries (public, university, 
technical university, special, and national), 
and special - s~bjects (buildings, mechaniza-
tion, international exchange of publications, 
and copyright problems). 

In general, the monograph provides an 
interesting basis on which to consider the 
extension of library services on a worldwide 
basis. In the present world struggle for bal-
ance, with nuclear war as a persistent possi-
bility, libraries may seem to be somewhat on 
a low level of importance. The truth of the 
matter is that only thro\].gh international 
cooperation on all matters, including library 
services, can there be developed solutions 
to many national and international prob-
lem~. IFLA's program is designed to help 
libraries extend their services, and to direct 
attention to steps that may be taken that 
will be beneficial to libraries as a group.-
Maurice F. Tauber, Columbia University. 

Italian Studies 
Con11egno di Studi sulle Biblioteche Univer-

sitarie, 16-17 Maggio 1!;60. (Pubblicazioni 
della Soprintendenza Bibliografica per la 
Campania e la Calabria, n.8.) Napoli: 
1962. 67p. 

This small collection of papers and record-
ed discussions is a byproduct of the profes-
sional activities of Robert Vosper in Italy 
during the short period he spent there as a 
Fulbright lecturer from March through May 
1960 (see CRL 22: 199-210). These papers 
w.ere presented during a two-day regional 
conference organized under the auspices of 
the Italian Library Association (AlB) and 
the local USIS in Naples. Following an in-
troductory statement by Dr. Guerriera Guer-
rieri, regional chairman of the AlB, Mr. 
Vosper read the opening paper. After pay-
ing due tribute to the great names and wis-
dom of early Italian giants such as Panizzi, 
and some allusions to earlier American-
Italian professional exchanges, he swiftly 
sketched the pattern of growth in American 
university libraries. His outline of current 
developments is devoted to three areas of 

library work, (1) services to students, (2) 
services for research, and (3) cooperative 
services. He traces the use of libraries by 
students from early days in American aca-
demic libraries to the recent trend toward 
undergraduate libraries and completely open 
shelves. As a disciple of Powell, he could 
not fail to nod in the direction of free read-
ing with the inclusion of competitions for 
the best student personal library. His re-
view of services to research starts with the 
growth of the great academic collections 
and goes on to the usual aids of interlibrary 
loan and microcopy. This leads naturally to 
the third subject, cooperation. As a chairman 
of the Farmington Plan Committee of Amer-
ican Research Libraries, Robert Vosper was 
well qualified to speak on this subject. He 
ends his paper with comments on national 
programs designed to coordinate United 
States resources and suggests that interna-
tional programs of similar scope cannot be 
far behind. 

The second paper, by the director of the 
University library of Naples, presents a lu-
cid picture of the principal academic li-
brary organization of Italy. Vosper's article 
contains an extensive description of this 
fairly complex system, so very different from 
ours. On reading Professor Lanzara's paper, 
one feels a most striking contrast between 
the Italian pattern and ours. While the his-
toric development of Italian institutions is 
much different from ours, it still is difficult 
for us to conceive of the great academic 
institutions in Italy with libraries as poorly 
supported, staffed, and housed as they are. 
In fact , however, they differ little from other 
European libraries, and the same diffuse or-
ganization exists in many other non-Euro-
pean countries. One cannot help but be im-
pressed by the obviously high level of intelli-
gence and dignity exhibited in this paper 
expressing the frustration of able people 
limited by minimal support and administra-
tive understanding. 

The third paper, offered by an academic, 
not a librarian, brings to view a stark pic-
ture of the modest level of support assigned 
to the academic libraries. This paper is thor-
oughly documented with statistical tables. 
The professor illuminates the weaknesses of 
the old and even present systematics of 
Italian academic libraries, deploring the 
modest level of support they are able to offer 

524 COLLEGE AND RESEARCH LIBRARIES 



to research. He calls for better organization, 
both local and national, for better control 
and management of all resources, and finally, 
for better funding. His paper should make 
good reading for some of our own faculty, 
many of whom do not appreciate how much 
they have. 

On the second day of the conference, the 
opening paper was given by Professor Fran-
cesco Ghiretti, who has had experience as 
a researcher in both Italian and American 
libraries, particularly in his field, biology. 
He paints a grim picture of the trials of 
research in the typical academic constella-
tion of little libraries attached to the "insti-
'tutes" of a university in Italy. In contrast, 
he describes his experiences in American li-
braries and finally asks why Italian libraries . 
cannot at least match those of other Euro-
pean countries, such as Sweden, Denmark, 
or England, if not America. He answers his 
own question with a stirring protest against 
the continuing proliferation of autonomous 
institutes and individual research and a 
plea for enforced collaboration, unification, 
or centralization. 

A short series of statements follow by three 
librarians responsible for small institute li-
braries of the type earlier mentioned. In 
each of these there is evident an intelligent 
appreciation of the changes needed and an 
awareness of the hazards of the course. In 
the discussion period a group of librarians 
who had visited libraries in the United States 
made short statements. Among these were 
Alberto Guarino, Ernesto Giangrasso, and 
Angela Daneu Lattanzi. The latter suggests 
a direct attack by the regional library as-
sociation in many of the areas mentioned. 
She speaks of microcopy as a means of cen-
tralizing little-used books, of cooperation in 
acquisitions within a university, if not on a 
larger scale, of improved and more numerous 
bibliographic tools in book form, of catalog 
cards, and of union catalogs. She also com-
ments on pers_onnel and training for profes-
sional librarianship. 

In brief, those who may still look back 
to the "great" libraries of Western Europe 
as our sources should find this little com-
pilation an eye-opening bit of reading. At 
the same time, the reader will undoubtedly 
be greatly affected by the obviously intense 
eagerness of the capable people here record-
ed to carry out a program which should en-

NOVEMBER 1963 

able them to meet their problems. Their 
problems are, in fact, different from ours 
only in degree, and we can all profit by 
studying what they produce.-]errold Orne, 
University of North Carolina. 

Photocopies 
Photocopies from Abroad, Directory of 

Photocopying and Microcopying Services. 
(Publication No. 347.) The Hague, Neth-

erlands: International Federation for 
Documentation, n.d. 25p. 5 guilders. 

In 1950 the FID published its Directory 
of Microfilm and Photocopying Services 
(Publication No. 244). This sixty-five-page 
booklet listed some 177 institutions in eighty-
five countries. By 1955 there were enough 
changes to justify a new edition: Directory 
of Photocopying and Microcopying Services 
(Publication No. 278). Growing from a 5y2 

x 8Y2 inch size to roughly 8Y2 x 11, it 
covered in fifty pages 192 services in ninety-
four countries. This second edition included 
useful chapters on the copyright problem, a 
survey of processes, recommended sizes for 
photocopies, and the use of UNESCO cou-
pons. 

A new edition has been needed for some 
time. Rising costs and the advent of new 
copying processes have increased the normal 
rate of change in photocopying prices and 
services. In the Foreword to the present 
volume there is a suggestion that publica-
tion be at more frequent intervals. A ques-
tionnaire sheet (two copies) is appended at 
the end .of the booklet to enable informa-
tion to be brought up to date. One can 
hope that we will not have to wait eight 
years for the next issue. 

The present edition updates the previous 
one, but it does not supplant it, so that one 
should not discard the second edition. This 
one covers 155 services in thirty-eight coun-
tries, and is based on a survey carri~d out 
in 1962. It no longer notes reference insti-
tutions in each country, listing only those 
institutions that offer photoduplication ser-
vice. Neither does it include the helpful 
expository chapters added to the second edi-
tion. It notes national directories when these 
are available. A check of institutions listed 
for the United States discloses one new one 

525