College and Research Libraries


ASHBY J. F R I S T O E 

Paperbound Books: Many Problems, 
No Solutions 

The paperbound revolution began several decades ago with the re-
placement of animal glues by synthetic glues. Publishers, who now 
issue perfect bound editions in great quantities, have created serious 
binding problems for librarians. Answers to some of these problems 
lie in the development of new materials, machines, and techniques 
for use in the workshop of the library. If the work could be done in 
the library, some troublesome delays would be eliminated. Consider-
ing the rapid scientific and technological developments, it should be 
only a matter of time until someone provides the answers needed. 

H E P A P E R B O U N D R E V O L U T I O N o f t h e 
past three decades has been received 
with varying degrees of enthusiasm by 
publishers, the public, and librarians. 
Publishers welcome the profits accompa-
nying high volume sales. The low cost 
appeals to the public and librarians. Pa-
perbounds are a mixed blessing, how-
ever, to librarians interested in durabil-
ity as well as low cost, because they 
have encountered n e w problems created 
by certain characteristics of these books 
and magnified by the swiftly changing 
patterns of production in the publishing 
world. 

There have always been books bound 
in paper or flexible covers, but the cur-
rent boom began in England in 1935 
with Penguin Books. When Pocket Books 
appeared in the United States in 1939 
the boom was well on its way. For pur-
poses of this paper, a paperbound book 
is any soft-cover monograph issued in 
more than fifty pages. This definition 
excludes periodicals. The Bowker An-
nual lists two broad types of paper-
bound books: "mass-market" and "other 

Mr. Fristoe is Chief of Technical Proc-
essing, University of North Carolina. 

than mass-market."1 There is no clear 
line between the two categories, but 
generally mass-market paperbounds are 
found on the racks in drugstores or 
newsstands and are cheaper than those 
usually sold by bookstores or published 
by scholarly organizations. 

L I B R A R Y U S E O F P A P E R B O U N D S 

When paperbounds first appeared 
they were often issued as cheap re-
prints of popular hard-cover books, pri-
marily fiction. This pattern has changed 
and they now encompass the whole 
spectrum of fiction and nonfiction. With 
the appearance of quality paperbounds 
the price range increased considerably, 
and such paperbounds currently may 
cost as much as $3.95. At first paper-
bounds were little used by librarians, 
but this has also changed. Many libraries 
now buy them in single or multiple 
copies. They buy them with good reason 
—they are cheaper than hardbounds. 
The Bowker Annual indicates that in 
1965 an adult trade paperbound cost 

1 The Bowker Annual of Library and Book Trade 
Information ( N e w York, 1 9 6 7 ) , p. 46. 

/ 437 



438 / College 6- Research Libraries • September 1968 

T A B L E 1 

A D U L T T R A D E B O O K S S O L D P R I M A R I L Y THROUGH U . S . B O O K S E L L E R S 

C A T E G O R Y Y E A R V O L U M E S S O L D Y E A R V O L U M E S S O L D P E R C E N T C H A N G E 

Hardbound 1958 32,298,000 1963 40,213,000 24.2 increase 
Paperbound 1958 5,661,000 1963 48,874,000 763.3 increase 

only one-third as much as a hardbound.2 
Librarians often buy paperbounds for 

other compelling reasons. Many books 
are available only in this form. Some are 
published as paperbounds before ap-
pearing in hard cover, and some never 
appear in hard cover. Many hard-cover 
books go out of print and appear again 
only as paperbound reprints. Foreign ti-
tles are often available only as paper-
bounds. Of particular concern to the ac-
ademic librarian is the fact that many 
publications of societies, associations, in-
stitutes, and similar scholarly organiza-
tions are offered only in paper covers. 

Libraries sometimes use paperbound 
books to satisfy heavy, transient demand 
for current popular books. They may ac-
quire multiple copies of some titles. 
There is often no effort to catalog these 
books. They are frequently shelved by 
broad categories on drugstore-type dis-
play racks. Circulation methods vary but 
are often quite informal. When they 
wear out or are no longer in demand, 
the library may then acquire durable 
hard-cover editions of the same titles. 
Other libraries add paperbounds to their 
permanent collections. When this occurs 
the books must be cataloged and pre-
pared for long-time use. To serve this 
purpose the books must be reasonably 
durable, but the cost of rebinding should 
be modest. The expense of rebinding 

2 Ibid., p . 5 3 . 

has always been important to libraries 
and, in view of the changing patterns in 
the publishing world, it deserves the 
consideration of both librarians and the 
book trade at this time. 

C H A N G I N G P A T T E R N S 

Broad acceptance of the paperbound 
book has brought significant changes in 
numbers of volumes sold and titles 
issued. The tables below consist of fig-
ures derived from the Book Trade Sta-
tistics sections of the 1960 through 1967 
issues of the Bowker Annual. 

Table 1 shows not only a rapid rate of 
growth in sales of paperbound books but 
also indicates that hardbounds have 
been overtaken in volumes sold. At the 
University of North Carolina library 
during the last seven months of 1966, 
29.6 per cent of all books acquired were 
in paper covers. During the same period 
in 1967 the figure had risen to 46.7 per 
cent. Total acquisitions for 1967 mean-
while rose 38.4 per cent. An additional 
count of current acquisitions made dur-
ing a two-week period in March 1968, 
showed that 23.7 per cent of all domes-
tic acquisitions were paperbounds. 

It is interesting to note that during 
the same period of time, the proportion-
ate increase in sale of technical, scien-
tific, and professional books was 73.9 per 
cent. 

Statistics of foreign titles imported 
T A B L E 2 

T E C H N I C A L , S C I E N T I F I C , AND P R O F E S S I O N A L B O O K S S O L D I N U . S . 

C A T E G O R Y Y E A R V O L U M E S S O L D Y E A R V O L U M E S S O L D P E R C E N T C H A N G E 

All types 1958 23,801,000 1963 41,391,000 73.9 increase 



Paperbound Books: Many Problems, No Solutions / 4 3 9 

T A B L E 3 

F O R E I G N B O O K I M P O R T S D I S T R I B U T E D IN T H E U . S . 

C A T E G O R Y Y E A R T I T L E S Y E A R T I T L E S P E R C E N T C H A N G E 

All types 1959 1,900 1960 2,158 13.5 increase All types 
1960 2,158 1961 1,568 27.3 decrease 

" " 1961 1,568 1962 2,051 30.8 increase 
" " 1962 2,051 1963° 2,161 5.3 increase 
" 1964* 4,797 1965 4,670 2.6 decrease 
" " 1965 4,670 1966 6,347 35.9 increase 

° In 1964 Publisher's Weekly changed its method of counting imports and it is not now jjossible to compare 
figures for 1 9 6 3 and 1964. 

show considerable fluctuation during the 
eight-year period represented in Table 
3. From 1964 to 1966 the number of ti-
tles increased by more than a third. No 
figures are available for a comparison of 
foreign hard- and soft-cover imports. A 
tally of books received at the University 
of North Carolina library for a two-week 
period in March 1968, revealed that 49.8 
per cent of foreign imports were paper-
bounds. 

Perhaps the most striking change oc-
curs in Table 4, where non-mass-market 
titles increased by 1967.7 per cent dur-
ing a ten-year period while mass-market 
titles increased by only 80.07 per cent. 
A change in this trend may be indi-
cated by the very modest increase in 
non-mass-market titles from 1965 to 
1966. 

H o w P A P E R B O U N D B O O K S A R E B O U N D 

Librarians today must manage ever 
increasing numbers of titles and a grow-
ing ratio of paperbound to hardbound 
books. This growth has brought serious 
new binding problems to librarians. The 
common paperbound is usually bound in 

large quantities by an edition binder. 
The method most frequently used is 
known as "perfect" binding. Such a bind-
ing does not require sewing, rounding, 
or backing. The pages are trimmed, the 
back is fanned and glued to the spine. 
Occasionally other methods of binding 
are used. In some paperbounds the 
pages are held together by wire staples 
and in others sewing and staples are 
used together. Common paperbacks us-
ually appear with glued-on covers, 
cheap paper, narrow margins, and in 
non-standard size. 

Publications of societies, associations, 
and other scholarly organizations differ 
frequently from the common paper-
backs in form. They may have no cov-
ers, they may be issued in fascicules, or 
they may be larger than the common 
paperbacks. Often they are printed on a 
quality calendered paper; they may 
even appear in loose-leaf form. At times 
the only thing they have in common 
with conventional paperbacks is the lack 
of a hard cover. 

Paperbound books may be rebound 
either at a commercial bindery or in the 

T A B L E 4 

P A P E R B O U N D T I T L E S I S S U E D B Y U . S . P U B L I S H E R S 

C A T E G O R Y Y E A R T I T L E S Y E A R T I T L E S P E R C E N T C H A N G E 

Mass-market 1957 1,114 1966 2,006 80.07 increase 
Other than mass-market 1957 355 1966 7,340 1967.7 increase 

Mass-market 1965 2,349 1966 2,006 14.6 decrease 
Other than mass-market 1965 6,968 1966 7,340 5.3 increase 



440 / College 6- Research Libraries • September 1968 

library. The commercial binder can re-
bind in library binding or in cardboard 
covered with plastic or vinyl. Library 
binding is a type of binding designed to 
assure the strength and durability need-
ed to withstand heavy library use. Un-
like edition binding, where large quanti-
ties of a single title are bound by mass 
production techniques, library binding 
requires special attention to individual 
items varying in size and shape. In li-
brary binding the paper cover is ripped 
from the spine, the pages are sewn to-
gether, trimmed, rounded and backed, 
reinforced, and glued to a cloth- or 
buckram-covered case. The result is 
stronger and more durable than hard-
cover edition binding, but the cost is 
higher. Unfortunately, many paper-
bounds have such narrow margins they 
cannot be rebound in library binding. 

Another type of commercial binding, 
commonly known as Permabind or Vina-
bind, is similar to perfect binding. Sew-
ing is eliminated but other features are 
added. The covers are removed, pasted 
on cardboard, and cased. The case is 
covered with a thin sheet of plastic or 
vinyl through which the original cover 
can be seen. The result is an attractive, 
relatively durable book. This type of 
binding costs less than library binding, 
but it brings other problems with it. 
Large or heavy volumes tend to fall 
apart. Quality paperbounds and schol-
arly publications are often printed on 
calendered paper which does not accept 
even the new synthetic glues well. Loose 
pages are a common result. Binders 
using this method provide a guarantee, 
but a book with loose pages must be re-
turned to the bindery to be replaced or 
rebound by the binder, and this takes 
the book out of use. 

Some rebinding of paperbounds is 
done in libraries by means of simple 
techniques and cheap materials. This 
type of rebinding usually involves re-
moving the cover, sewing, stapling, or 
glueing. A case is usually made from 

adhesive coated cloth, cardboard, and 
cloth hinges and this is glued or stapled 
to the book. The result is neither attrac-
tive nor very durable, but the work can 
be done quickly and the cost is low. 

W H E N PAPERBOUND BOOKS A R E BOUND 

When a librarian buys a book in a 
hard-cover edition he can buy the book 
from the publisher or through a dealer. 
His decision is based on relative price 
and service offered by the publisher and 
dealer. When he buys a paperbound 
book for permanent addition to the col-
lection he has an additional decision: he 
must decide when the book is to be re-
bound. The book can be rebound either 
before or after it reaches the library. 
Some dealers specialize in locating and 
rebinding paperbound books before 
shipping to the library. They usually 
take orders only for domestic mass-mar-
ket or "quality" books. They will not 
normally take orders for non-trade pa-
perbound books because there is little 
or no profit even when the order can be 
filled. Such material is difficult to locate, 
and the likelihood of failure is quite 
high. Book dealers make no money on 
books they fail to find. 

Some dealers rebind paperbound 
books as part of blanket order arrange-
ments with libraries. They obtain all ti-
tles issued by a particular publisher or 
published in a particular country, or in 
a certain language or subject area. They 
have all soft cover books rebound prior 
to delivery to the library. Dealers han-
dling such blanket order arrangments do 
not have the problem of filling individu-
al orders. They must, of course, screen 
the titles located, but this is not as diffi-
cult as trying to locate obscure sources 
of short-run paperbounds. 

A curious new aspect of paperbounds 
has recently developed in England. 
Some English paperbounds now appear 
with the following notice on the back of 
the title page: "These books are sold 
subject to the condition that they shall 



Paperbound Books: Many Problems, No Solutions / 441 

not, by way of trade or otherwise, be 
lent, resold, hired out or otherwise cir-
culated without the publisher's prior 
consent in any form of binding or cover 
other than that in which they are pub-
lished and without a similar condition 
including this condition being imposed 
on the subsequent purchaser." This ap-
pears to be an effort by the publisher to 
increase the sale of the more expensive 
hard cover edition. A publisher can, of 
course, declare such a limitation in the 
use of his product, but ultimately the 
question must be decided in court. Pub-
lishers in the United States have not yet 
seen fit to follow the same path. Unfor-
tunately many books first appear as pa-
perbounds, and many of these may nev-
er be reprinted in hard cover form. 
When hard cover first editions go out of 
print, cheap paperbound reprints may 
be the only form available to librarians. 
Penguin Books is now producing a series 
of hard-cover Penguin Literary Editions 
for books which first appeared in soft 
covers. This is only a partial solution, 
and it is unlikely that many publishers 
will adopt it. It is certainly not an ade-
quate solution for the problem of out-of-
print material. The librarian is at the 
mercy of the publisher who, quite na-
turally, will publish another edition only 
when he feels a profit will be made. 

P R O B L E M S 

Several problems face the librarian 
who adds paperbound books to his per-
manent collection. An article in the Jan-
uary 30, 1967, Publishers Weekly dis-
cussed many aspects of paperbound 
publishing and stressed increased sales, 
number of titles, and consumer demand. 
It did not acknowledge the existence of a 
library demand for these books. In 1956 
academic libraries spent $17,407,000 
on books, but by 1965 the figure had 
risen to $76,836,398.3 This trend will 

3 Ibid., p . 6 . 

probably be adversely affected by con-
flicting demands of the Vietnam war, 
but the annual increase was larger than 
federal aid even in the fiscal year end-
ing June 30, 1966. During that year total 
federal aid to academic libraries for li-
brary materials was only $8,200,000, when 
the annual increase was $10,000,000.4 
No figures are available to show what 
proportion of academic book expendi-
tures is spent on paperbounds, but 
it should at least be a factor to be con-
sidered by publishers. Many first edi-
tions appear only as "quality" paper-
bounds, and librarians would welcome 
the simultaneous appearance of these ti-
tles in hard and soft cover. The librarian 
who intends to put a paperbound book 
into service is concerned with durability. 
The publisher must keep his costs as 
low as possible in order to make a profit. 
Most of his customers are not concerned 
with durability. In effect, the publisher 
has passed the cost of binding on to the 
librarian. 

When a paperbound book leaves the 
library for rebinding it may be out of 
service for as much as a month. In many 
instances, for one reason or another, the 
delay is even longer. If the book is cat-
aloged before binding, the catalog cards 
cannot be filed in the catalog until the 
book is returned, and a special proce-
dure must be established to delay the 
filing of the cards. An alternative is to 
delay the cataloging until the book has 
been bound; this too, may cause prob-
lems. The library must be prepared to 
accept occasional errors in the form of 
the author and title on the spine of the 
book, and the task of adding the call 
number has been shifted to the library. 
All of these add to the cost and lead 
to frustrations, but the librarian has lit-
tle choice if he is to add the book to 
his collection. It appears that the library 
must find an internal solution. 

4 Ibid., p . 2 1 . 



442 / College 6- Research Libraries • September 1968 

P O S S I B L E SOLUTIONS 

There is, unfortunately, no good solu-
tion to the problem of achieving dur-
able binding at modest cost. Arthur 
Plotnik, in "The 'Hardpaper' Book," dis-
cusses the emergence of a new product 
"about midway between the hardbound 
and paperbound trade book—intermedi-
ate in price, appearance and durability 
—perfectly suited for those intermediate 
library needs where a paperback is not 
durable enough and a hardcover too 
costly."5 The hardpaper book, as de-
scribed by Mr. Plotnik, is a considerable 
improvement over the paperback, and 
is cheaper than the hard-cover book. 
Unfortunately, it is not perfectly suited 
for library use. Most of the products he 

5 Arthur Plotnik, "The 'Hardpaper' Book," Library 
Journal, XCI ( M a y 15, 1 9 6 6 ) , 2 4 0 7 - 1 2 . 

describes are either perfect bindings in 
mylar plastic covered boards, library 
bindings, or "bind-it-yourself-kits." The 
latter appear to be a possible solution 
because the work can be done in the li-
brary, but these kits are not cheap and 
the result appears to be no more durable 
than the usual library product. These 
kits do not represent a major break-
through. 

Dealers may eventually accept orders 
for foreign and domestic scholarly pa-
perbound books. At least one dealer has 
recently proposed to act as a central 
agency for paperbound titles of all pub-
lishers, commercial and nonprofit, for-
eign and domestic. Perhaps this is the 
beginning of a trend, and perhaps deal-
ers may be induced to bind before de-
livery.