Reviews.indd


courses offered, the profile of faculty 
hired, and the ways in which academic 
institutions are structured. 

And how has the curriculum changed 
during the past 100 years? The details 
of their argument cannot be eff ectively 
summarized in a review of this length, 
but there are some very basic conclusions 
at which the authors arrive that may, in 
themselves, serve to attract the reader. 
As most anecdotal evidence would sug-
gest, the “relative emphasis allott ed to 
teaching and research in the humanities 
sharply declined during [the twentieth 
century].” The beneficiary of this change 
in focus, however, was not the natural 
sciences, but the social sciences, whose 
growth during the period in question is 
described as “spectacular.” As significant 
as the decline of the humanities was the 
decline in emphasis on “basic” disciplin-
ary fields such as philosophy, chemistry, 
and economics, in favor of “applied” 
fields, including law, civil engineering, 
and management. The rise of the social 
sciences and the rise of applied academic 
disciplines—these are the preeminent sto-
ries of the changing academic landscape 
in the twentieth century. 

The authors dedicate one chapter each 
to changes over time in the broadly de-
fined fields of the humanities, the social 
sciences, and the natural sciences. They 
also dedicate a chapter to the study of the 
discipline of history, which, they argue, 
is the one most likely to be continually 
shaped (and reshaped) by changing per-
ceptions of what is “reality.” The result is 
a complex work that will be of interest to 
scholars in many fields, as well as to any 
critics of higher education who wish to 
embrace a more thoughtful view of the 
reasons behind curriculum change than 
some we have seen in the past.—Scott
Walter, University of Illinois at Urbana-
Champaign. 

1. Elizabeth Redden, “Divisive Semester 
at Florida” Inside Higher Ed (Dec. 4, 2006). 
Available online from http://insidehighered. 
com/news/2006/12/04/uf. 

Book Reviews 281 

Groen, Frances K. Access to Medical 
Knowledge: Libraries, Digitization, and 
the Public Good. Lanham, Md.: Scare-
crow, 2007. 281p. alk. paper, $55 (ISBN 
0810852721). LC 2006-20465. 

Since the beginning of the twentieth cen-
tury, the field of medical librarianship has 
evolved dramatically, gaining momentum 
in the midst of political and social influ-
ences throughout the world. In this book, 
Groen successfully presents the history 
and development of medical librarianship 
in genuinely interesting and informative 
detail, spanning from the early 1900s to 
the present day. In addition, she depicts 
the struggles and challenges that medical 
librarians have had to face and how cur-
rent values in the profession have been 
shaped through overcoming adversity. 
Although not every important event in 
such a large time frame could be included, 
this book does discuss the major events 
that most influenced the development of 
medical librarianship. As an expert in the 
field of medical librarianship, Groen has 
been immersed in research on libraries 
for several decades. Her main purpose 
in writing this book, as stated in the first 
sentence of the preface, is “to understand 
why librarians … make the choices and 
develop the services that they do.” Her 
purpose is clearly achieved, as powerful 
influences from wars, politics, and society 
have contributed greatly to the choices 
and services offered by medical libraries. 
The result is that medical librarianship 
has become a stronger profession and, 
due to improvements in technology, will 
continue to grow and develop. 

The book is well organized, and the 
order of the chapters flows nicely. In the 
preface, the author explains why medical 
librarianship is important to her, both 
personally and professionally. The brief 
introduction delightfully describes the 
author’s personal experiences with using 
libraries and how her interest in research-
ing them developed. The main portion 
of the book is divided into four parts, 
most of which consist of several chapters. 
Part I provides a general background on 



282 College & Research Libraries 

librarians and their values in relation to 
society. Part II delves into the history of 
medical librarianship, starting with pre-
1900 events and moving from the early 
1900s through the late 1900s. This section 
is very detailed and covers much mate-
rial, from the beginnings of the Medical 
Libraries Association to the development 
of medical libraries across Europe. Part III 
explains current issues in the profession 
such as the digitization of materials, use 
of the Internet, as well as new ways of 
accessing medical information. 

Perhaps the most interesting section is 
Part IV, where the author discusses future 
implications for medical librarianship, 
including issues of economic and biblio-
graphic control, open access, and control 
of copyright. Although these universal 
concerns are sensitive, they are addressed 
in such an informative manner that read-
ers are rightly reminded of the signifi-
cance of these issues and why librarians 
should take a stand on them. 

The conclusion introduces several 
problems that medical librarians will 
have to face in the future; most important 
of these: being able to provide access to 
medical information as well as being able 
to preserve it. Accordingly, the author also 
offers several solutions to these problems, 
such as actively negotiating with pub-
lishers with regard to copyright issues, 
establishing institutional repositories, and 
promoting health by providing accurate 
medical information to the public. 

The bibliography and index are both 
useful resources. The bibliography only 
contains monographic information, while 
a short notes section at the end of each 
chapter contains citations for the journal 
articles the author consulted. This book 
would be of interest to academics, librar-
ians, historians, college students, as well 
as anybody from the general public who 
is interested in learning more about the 
history and development of medical 
librarianship. Even so, the language and 
writing style are seemingly more geared 
toward readers who are familiar with 
library-related terms and phrases (e.g., 

May 2007 

PubMed and NLM). Obviously the most 
fitting audience for this book would be 
medical librarians. 

 Groen’s book provides a compre-
hensive look at the history of medical 
librarianship. Today, access to medical 
information is becoming more and more 
important, and it is crucial for librarians 
to learn from history so that a positive 
vision can be developed for the future of 
medical libraries. This book is a valuable 
resource, and researchers and librarians 
in the academic world can learn much 
from it.—Judy P. Bolstad, University of 
California, Berkeley. 

Human Computer Interaction Research 
in Web Design and Evaluation. Eds. 
Panayiotis Zaphiris and Sri Kurni-
anan. Hershey, Pa.: Idea Group, 2007. 
319p. $79.95 (paper); $94.95 (cloth) 
(ISBN 1599042479; 1599042460). LC 
2006-19158. 

Human-Computer Interaction (HCI) is 
an emerging field of study that seeks to 
combine the methods and insights of psy-
chology, sociology, computer science, and 
informatics to improve our understand-
ing of how humans use computers. This 
book is a collection of fourteen essays, by 
HCI theoreticians and practitioners from 
around the globe, that focus on bringing 
the concepts, models, theories, and find-
ings of the discipline to the study of Web 
design and evaluation. 

The chapters are arranged into four 
sections. Section I provides an introduc-
tion and theoretical foundation that elabo-
rates a framework of HCI concepts and 
models and how they can be employed 
in the study of Web design and in the 
evaluation of Web sites. A common theme 
here is that User-Centered Design (UCD) 
and Usability Engineering (UE) should 
be an integral part of the soft ware design 
life-cycle rather than an aft erthought or ad 
hoc feature. Section II is concerned with 
the role of analysis in Web design, and the 
single essay in this section looks closely 
at the role of task analysis in the Web de-
sign process. The design of Web sites is a