Book Reviews 211

compelling examples of planning, de-
veloping an action plan, achieving being 
embedded, sustaining that achievement, 
and evaluating the success for continued 
sustainability. 

The Embedded Librarian is written in a 
clear and approachable style with Shu-
maker ’s voice sounding through with 
concise and succinct information. He 
approaches the topic with knowledge 
and well thought-out examples. While 
there is not much here that has not been 
presented in the professional literature, 
it is a benefit that the author here brings 
together a great deal of information or-
ganized under reasonable chapter head-
ings. It is a benefit to the reader that each 
chapter ends with a summary and a list 
of reference sources. Having the material 
laid out in this way will prove much more 
effective to those who would acquire this 
title as a tool to furthering their embedded 
librarianship or as an entry point. The 
chapter on “Evaluating Your Success” 
will also prove to be of great value to both 
groups as well, as it presents scenarios 
in the form of case studies and takes into 
consideration varying characteristics and 
types of libraries. In the current age of as-
sessing all that information professionals 
do, it is useful to have such straightfor-
ward material. However, a prior section, 
“Chapter 7: Assessing Your Readiness,” 
will be most useful to those librarians who 
are ready to gauge whether they have, as 
Shumaker puts it, reached maturity. His 
questionnaire and scale are very useful. 
Additionally, the descriptors for interpret-
ing the outcomes within the scale: “highly 
embedded, developing, emerging and not 
embedded” are as well. 

Clearly, in the current information 
professional arena, there are more and 
more forces driving change and more op-
portunities to do so. Technology has been 
both an advantage and a disadvantage to 
this change. The Embedded Librarian offers 
not only an assessment tool but a concrete 
methodology with examples, analysis, 
and processes. Written for information 
professionals, library school students, 

the embedded, and those considering 
it, the book offers a review, practical 
strategies, and applications about being 
embedded.—Loreen S. Henry, University 
of Texas, Dallas.

Colin Franklin. Obsessions and Confessions 
of a Book Life. New Castle, Del.: Oak 
Knoll Press; Camberwell, Victoria, 
Australia: Books of Kells; London: 
Bernard Quaritch, 2012. 262p. alk. 
paper, $49.95 (ISBN: 9781584563044). 
LC2012-018734.

Both a memoir and a collection of dis-
crete topical essays, Colin Franklin’s 
book about his personal and professional 
intersections with the world of books is 
a delight. During his 88 years, Franklin 
has been a publisher, an author, a book 
dealer, and a book collector, and all these 
roles are depicted here. Though this 
is nowhere stated, the first seven of its 
fifteen chapters, or essays, loosely form 
a chronological narrative, interspersed 
with musings on such things as connois-
seurship and of the various ways in which 
collectors perceive and pursue books as 
“love objects.” The memoirs begin with 
Franklin’s recollections of his earliest 
childhood encounters with books. He 
writes of the joy derived from his youthful 
purchase of a disbound copy of Pilgrim’s 
Progress “…printed about 1790. For bind-
ing it at Whiteleys” (a shop near where 
he lived) “I charged my parents’ account, 
for reading it I waited more than thirty 
years…I wanted the book, treasured it 
and can only now begin to explain why.” 
Obsessions and Confessions takes on that 
task by analysis and example.

In 1949, Franklin began working at the 
London offices of publishers Routledge 
& Kegan Paul, a firm that had been pur-
chased by Franklin’s grandfather in 1907. 
One of the most evocative and charming 
portions of this book is its second chapter, 
“In a Golden Age of Publishing,” which 
describes the recent Oxford graduate’s 
immersion into the career he would 
pursue for twenty-one years. On his first 
day, his uncle told him that he would 



212 College & Research Libraries March 2013

be “in charge of publicity and jackets,” 
which included the designing of the 
latter. Through this, his appreciation of 
the visual appeal of books was bolstered 
by the practical experience of trying to 
make books look good. His office in the 
Victorian building that served as both 
staff headquarters and stock warehouse 
was next to that of philosopher and art 
historian Herbert Read, who served part-
time as a literary adviser and from whom 
Franklin claims to have learned how to 
be “lazy.” A recurrent painful intrusion 
into that laziness is described: “I often 
found there were few troubles in my life 
so excruciating as meeting authors. There 
we sat in my small room, the two of us, as 
he seized the moment of total egoism to 
explain his book…there were times when, 
trying to follow an author’s exposition, I 
suffered near-ulcerous stomach pain.” 

For that and other reasons, Franklin 
decided to chart a new course in his life 
and became a book dealer, and the next 
few chapters offer witty and sharp-eyed 
reminiscences of other dealers, such as 
Hans Kraus, and of clients, including 
his most important, the American mil-
lionaire Paul Mellon, whom he aided in 
augmenting the magnificent collection 
that eventually moved with Mellon to his 
English country house at Wormsley Park. 

As is often the case with book dealers, 
Franklin’s own collecting and scholarly in-
terests and his work in the trade went hand 
in hand, or sometimes hand out of hand. 
For example, his deep interest in William 
Morris (whom he describes as one of his 
heroes) led him to the acquisition of a com-
plete set of all the Kelmscott Press books, 
including an example of each title printed 
on vellum when such existed, or on paper 
when no vellum copies were printed. One 
notable exception to this was his copy of 
the Kelmscott Chaucer, which was on pa-
per not vellum; but even that was special, 
being a presentation copy from Morris and 
Burne-Jones to Swinburne. Franklin sold 
this beloved set to fund other ventures.

Morris is the topic of one of the more 
or less self-contained essays that make 

up the chapters of the second half of 
the book. Along with an assessment of 
Morris, these essays include as topics the 
Daniel Press, the manuscript of Nijinski’s 
unexpurgated autobiography and the 
troubles and pleasures the temporary 
ownership of that document brought to 
Franklin, and the elegance of the print-
ing of Giambattista Bodoni, who in the 
author’s eyes was typographically “the 
finest of them all.” Along with these 
are Franklin’s convincing defense of the 
Bowdler family and their various editions 
of “Bowdlerized” Shakespeare plays, and 
three essays devoted to men who Frank-
lin wishes had more current renown: 
the Oxford engraver Joseph Skelton, the 
comic writer Robert Surtees and his chief 
illustrator John Leech (the latter a surpris-
ing favorite of Ruskin’s), and finally the 
18th-century amateur antiquary William 
Fowler. The Fowler essay is one of the 
longest and best in the book. Franklin 
owns all of the very rare folio volumes 
of Fowler’s works, including the almost 
impossibly rare third volume. Fowler 
created accurate and luminously hand-
colored engravings of ancient Roman 
mosaic floors that had been unearthed 
from English soil and of English stained 
glass windows. The story of his life and 
unusual publications is fascinating.

The book closes with an essay about 
the author’s sister, the scientist Rosalind 
Franklin, who died of cancer in 1958 at 
the age of 37. Rosalind Franklin was key 
to the discovery of the structure of DNA, 
and Franklin recounts and clarifies her 
contribution, which for many years was 
insufficiently recognized.

Colin Franklin has written many valu-
able books. This latest one will inform 
and please book lovers of all sorts.—Scott 
Krafft, Northwestern University.

Priscilla K. Shontz and Richard A. 
Murray. What Do Employers Want: A 
Guide for Library Science Students. 1st 
ed. California: Library Unlimited, 
2012. 119p. $45 (ISBN 9781598848281). 
LC2012-005693.