id	sid	eid	entity	type
cblr-1689	1	1	amex	ORG
cblr-1689	1	2	dennis w. carlton* i.	PERSON
cblr-1689	1	3	93 ii	QUANTITY
cblr-1689	3	1	95 iii	QUANTITY
cblr-1689	3	2	98	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	3	3	amex	ORG
cblr-1689	3	4	100	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	3	5	i. introduction	PERSON
cblr-1689	3	6	the supreme court’s	ORG
cblr-1689	3	7	ohio	GPE
cblr-1689	3	8	american express co.	ORG
cblr-1689	4	1	amex	ORG
cblr-1689	4	2	american	NORP
cblr-1689	4	3	cash.2	PERSON
cblr-1689	5	1	william howard taft	PERSON
cblr-1689	5	2	september 14, 2018	DATE
cblr-1689	5	3	new york	GPE
cblr-1689	6	1	gustavo bamberger	PERSON
cblr-1689	6	2	daniel feder	PERSON
cblr-1689	6	3	patrick gallagher	PERSON
cblr-1689	6	4	allan shampine	PERSON
cblr-1689	6	5	ralph winter	PERSON
cblr-1689	7	1	1	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	7	2	ohio	GPE
cblr-1689	8	1	express co.	ORG
cblr-1689	8	2	138 s. ct.	PERSON
cblr-1689	8	3	2774	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	8	4	2280	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	8	5	2018	DATE
cblr-1689	9	1	2	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	9	2	2282–83	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	10	1	3	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	10	2	united states	GPE
cblr-1689	11	1	express co.	ORG
cblr-1689	11	2	88	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	11	3	f. supp	PERSON
cblr-1689	12	1	3d 143	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	12	2	163	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	12	3	2015	DATE
cblr-1689	12	4	838	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	12	5	179	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	12	6	2d	DATE
cblr-1689	12	7	2016	DATE
cblr-1689	12	8	aff’d sub nom	ORG
cblr-1689	12	9	ohio	GPE
cblr-1689	14	1	express co.	ORG
cblr-1689	14	2	138 s. ct	PERSON
cblr-1689	14	3	2274	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	14	4	2018	DATE
cblr-1689	15	1	94	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	15	2	columbia business law review	ORG
cblr-1689	15	3	2019	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	15	4	australia4	ORG
cblr-1689	15	5	the united states	GPE
cblr-1689	15	6	new york6	GPE
cblr-1689	16	1	ralph	PERSON
cblr-1689	16	2	winter	DATE
cblr-1689	16	3	one	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	17	1	carlton	ORG
cblr-1689	17	2	winter	DATE
cblr-1689	17	3	herein.11 4	DATE
cblr-1689	17	4	2016	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	17	5	1	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	17	6	austl	GPE
cblr-1689	18	1	5	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	18	2	2015/751	DATE
cblr-1689	18	3	european	NORP
cblr-1689	18	4	29	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	18	5	april 2015	DATE
cblr-1689	19	1	11	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	19	2	2015	DATE
cblr-1689	19	3	l 123) 1, 13	DATE
cblr-1689	19	4	6	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	19	5	n.y.	GPE
cblr-1689	20	1	518	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	20	2	2018	DATE
cblr-1689	21	1	w. carlton & ralph a. winter	ORG
cblr-1689	21	2	61	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	21	3	j.l. & econ	ORG
cblr-1689	22	1	215	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	22	2	2018	DATE
cblr-1689	24	1	the united states	GPE
cblr-1689	25	1	215	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	25	2	8	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	25	3	9	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	25	4	10	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	25	5	11	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	25	6	carlton & winter	ORG
cblr-1689	25	7	7	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	27	1	95 ii	QUANTITY
cblr-1689	29	1	two	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	31	1	two	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	33	1	two	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	42	1	12	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	43	1	217	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	44	1	96	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	44	2	columbia business law review	ORG
cblr-1689	45	1	2019	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	48	1	vmfns	GPE
cblr-1689	51	1	13	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	51	2	223	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	52	1	14	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	53	1	217	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	54	1	16	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	54	2	223	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	54	3	1	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	57	1	97	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	58	1	prices.18	DATE
cblr-1689	68	1	17	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	68	2	the late 1990s	DATE
cblr-1689	68	3	amex	ORG
cblr-1689	69	1	ohio	GPE
cblr-1689	71	1	express co.	ORG
cblr-1689	71	2	138 s. ct.	PERSON
cblr-1689	71	3	2774	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	71	4	2293–94	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	71	5	2018	DATE
cblr-1689	71	6	j.	PERSON
cblr-1689	72	1	18	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	72	2	carlton & winter	ORG
cblr-1689	72	3	7	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	72	4	231	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	72	5	19	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	72	6	98	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	72	7	columbia business law review	ORG
cblr-1689	72	8	2019	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	73	1	visa	ORG
cblr-1689	73	2	mastercard	ORG
cblr-1689	73	3	american	NORP
cblr-1689	75	1	20	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	76	1	express co.	ORG
cblr-1689	76	2	138 s. ct	PERSON
cblr-1689	77	1	2282	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	80	1	21	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	80	2	2281	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	81	1	22	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	81	2	23	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	81	3	17	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	82	1	24	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	82	2	25	DATE
cblr-1689	84	1	express co.	ORG
cblr-1689	84	2	138 s. ct	PERSON
cblr-1689	85	1	2283	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	86	1	amex	ORG
cblr-1689	87	1	d.	NORP
cblr-1689	89	1	99	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	89	2	cash.26	NORP
cblr-1689	91	1	amex	ORG
cblr-1689	91	2	rewards27	PERSON
cblr-1689	91	3	carlton & winter	ORG
cblr-1689	92	1	one	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	95	1	carlton & winter	ORG
cblr-1689	95	2	amex	ORG
cblr-1689	95	3	26	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	95	4	carlton & winter	ORG
cblr-1689	95	5	7	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	95	6	234	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	95	7	27	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	96	1	express co.	ORG
cblr-1689	96	2	138 s. ct	PERSON
cblr-1689	97	1	2280	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	98	1	28	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	98	2	2286	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	99	1	29	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	99	2	carlton & winter	ORG
cblr-1689	99	3	7	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	99	4	30	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	99	5	carlton & winter	ORG
cblr-1689	99	6	7	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	99	7	240	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	100	1	237–38	DATE
cblr-1689	100	2	32	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	100	3	two	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	101	1	jean-charles rochet	PERSON
cblr-1689	101	2	two	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	101	3	37 rand	MONEY
cblr-1689	101	4	j. econ	PERSON
cblr-1689	102	1	645	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	102	2	2006	DATE
cblr-1689	105	1	100	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	105	2	columbia business law review	ORG
cblr-1689	106	1	2019	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	107	1	amex	ORG
cblr-1689	107	2	two	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	108	1	first	ORDINAL
cblr-1689	108	2	two	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	109	1	second	ORDINAL
cblr-1689	109	2	two	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	110	1	second	ORDINAL
cblr-1689	110	2	first	ORDINAL
cblr-1689	110	3	second	ORDINAL
cblr-1689	111	1	two	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	113	1	two	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	113	2	two	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	113	3	33	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	114	1	express co.	ORG
cblr-1689	114	2	138 s. ct.	PERSON
cblr-1689	115	1	2288	DATE
cblr-1689	116	1	34	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	116	2	carlton & winter	ORG
cblr-1689	116	3	7	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	116	4	230	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	116	5	35	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	116	6	george j. stigler	PERSON
cblr-1689	116	7	76	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	116	8	j. pol.	PERSON
cblr-1689	117	1	econ	ORG
cblr-1689	118	1	149	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	118	2	150–51	DATE
cblr-1689	118	3	1968	DATE
cblr-1689	119	1	36	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	120	1	express co.	ORG
cblr-1689	120	2	138 s. ct	PERSON
cblr-1689	121	1	2280	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	122	1	2286	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	123	1	38	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	123	2	32	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	123	3	664	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	125	1	101	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	127	1	two	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	128	1	two	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	131	1	two-sided[.]”42	MONEY
cblr-1689	131	2	one	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	131	3	two	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	132	1	two	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	132	2	two	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	134	1	two	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	137	1	39	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	137	2	carlton & winter	ORG
cblr-1689	137	3	7	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	137	4	217	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	137	5	40	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	137	6	carlton & winter	ORG
cblr-1689	137	7	7	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	137	8	250–51	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	138	1	41	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	138	2	32	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	138	3	646	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	139	1	42	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	140	1	664–65	DATE
cblr-1689	141	1	44	DATE
cblr-1689	141	2	102	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	141	3	columbia business law review	ORG
cblr-1689	141	4	2019	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	141	5	two	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	143	1	two	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	144	1	three	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	144	2	1	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	144	3	2	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	144	4	3	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	144	5	alternative.46	PERSON
cblr-1689	147	1	practice.47	ORG
cblr-1689	147	2	amex	ORG
cblr-1689	147	3	two	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	147	4	one	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	147	5	two	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	147	6	process.48	GPE
cblr-1689	147	7	45	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	147	8	ohio	GPE
cblr-1689	148	1	express co.	ORG
cblr-1689	148	2	138 s. ct.	PERSON
cblr-1689	148	3	2774	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	148	4	2284	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	148	5	2018	DATE
cblr-1689	149	1	46	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	150	1	d. 47 carlton & winter	ORG
cblr-1689	150	2	7	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	150	3	239	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	151	1	48	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	152	1	express co.	ORG
cblr-1689	152	2	138 s. ct	PERSON
cblr-1689	153	1	2287	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	154	1	49	DATE
cblr-1689	156	1	103	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	156	2	the department of justice	ORG
cblr-1689	158	1	flaws.52	ORG
cblr-1689	159	1	four	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	160	1	first	ORDINAL
cblr-1689	160	2	two	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	161	1	two	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	162	1	two	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	162	2	two	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	162	3	two	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	163	1	prices.57	LOC
cblr-1689	163	2	50	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	166	1	51	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	167	1	2290	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	168	1	2297–301	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	168	2	j.	PERSON
cblr-1689	169	1	53	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	169	2	2287	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	170	1	54	DATE
cblr-1689	171	1	annual	DATE
cblr-1689	172	1	55	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	172	2	32	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	172	3	664–65	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	173	1	56	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	173	2	carlton & winter	ORG
cblr-1689	173	3	7	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	173	4	231	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	174	1	104	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	174	2	2019	DATE
cblr-1689	175	1	second	ORDINAL
cblr-1689	175	2	rewards.62	PRODUCT
cblr-1689	176	1	third	ORDINAL
cblr-1689	178	1	fourth	ORDINAL
cblr-1689	179	1	first	ORDINAL
cblr-1689	179	2	58	DATE
cblr-1689	179	3	ohio	GPE
cblr-1689	180	1	express co.	ORG
cblr-1689	180	2	138 s. ct.	PERSON
cblr-1689	180	3	2774	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	180	4	2289–90	DATE
cblr-1689	180	5	2018	DATE
cblr-1689	181	1	dennis w. carlton &	PERSON
cblr-1689	181	2	jeffrey m. perloff	PERSON
cblr-1689	181	3	414–25	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	181	4	4th	ORDINAL
cblr-1689	181	5	2005	DATE
cblr-1689	182	1	59	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	182	2	carlton & perloff	ORG
cblr-1689	182	3	58	DATE
cblr-1689	182	4	421–22	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	183	1	60	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	183	2	ohio	GPE
cblr-1689	184	1	express co.	ORG
cblr-1689	184	2	138 s. ct	PERSON
cblr-1689	184	3	2274	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	184	4	2304	DATE
cblr-1689	184	5	2018	DATE
cblr-1689	184	6	j.	PERSON
cblr-1689	185	1	61	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	188	1	2293–94	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	188	2	j.	PERSON
cblr-1689	189	1	64	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	190	1	2294	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	190	2	j.	PERSON
cblr-1689	192	1	105	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	192	2	two	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	193	1	one	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	193	2	one	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	193	3	two	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	193	4	one	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	194	1	two	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	194	2	two	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	195	1	one	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	196	1	one	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	197	1	three	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	198	1	one	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	198	2	two	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	199	1	amex	ORG
cblr-1689	200	1	three	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	205	1	one	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	205	2	two	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	205	3	65	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	206	1	66	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	206	2	2295	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	206	3	j.	PERSON
cblr-1689	207	1	106	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	207	2	columbia business law review	ORG
cblr-1689	208	1	2019	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	208	2	two	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	208	3	one	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	208	4	amex	ORG
cblr-1689	209	1	one	CARDINAL
cblr-1689	209	2	two	CARDINAL