id	sid	tid	token	lemma	pos
cblr-1208	1	1	microsoft	microsoft	PROPN
cblr-1208	1	2	word	word	NOUN
cblr-1208	1	3	3	3	X
cblr-1208	1	4	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	1	5	lecture_morgenstern_print_approved.docx	lecture_morgenstern_print_approved.docx	PROPN
cblr-1208	1	6	lecture_commentary_final	lecture_commentary_final	PROPN
cblr-1208	1	7	commentary	commentary	NOUN
cblr-1208	1	8	:	:	PUNCT
cblr-1208	1	9	applying	apply	VERB
cblr-1208	1	10	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	1	11	rule	rule	NOUN
cblr-1208	1	12	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	1	13	reason	reason	NOUN
cblr-1208	1	14	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	1	15	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	1	16	post	post	ADJ
cblr-1208	1	17	-	-	ADJ
cblr-1208	1	18	actavis	actavis	ADJ
cblr-1208	1	19	world	world	NOUN
cblr-1208	1	20	saul	saul	PROPN
cblr-1208	1	21	p.	p.	PROPN
cblr-1208	1	22	morgenstern	morgenstern	PROPN
cblr-1208	1	23	&	&	CCONJ
cblr-1208	1	24	adam	adam	PROPN
cblr-1208	1	25	m.	m.	PROPN
cblr-1208	1	26	pergament	pergament	PROPN
cblr-1208	1	27	*	*	PUNCT
cblr-1208	1	28	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	1	29	ftc	ftc	PROPN
cblr-1208	1	30	v.	v.	ADP
cblr-1208	1	31	actavis	actavis	PROPN
cblr-1208	1	32	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	1	33	133	133	NUM
cblr-1208	1	34	s.	s.	PROPN
cblr-1208	1	35	ct	ct	PROPN
cblr-1208	1	36	.	.	PROPN
cblr-1208	1	37	2223	2223	NUM
cblr-1208	1	38	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-1208	1	39	2013	2013	NUM
cblr-1208	1	40	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-1208	1	41	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	1	42	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	1	43	supreme	supreme	PROPN
cblr-1208	1	44	court	court	PROPN
cblr-1208	1	45	held	hold	VERB
cblr-1208	1	46	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	1	47	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	1	48	cases	case	NOUN
cblr-1208	1	49	challenging	challenge	VERB
cblr-1208	1	50	alleged	alleged	ADJ
cblr-1208	1	51	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	1	52	reverse	reverse	ADJ
cblr-1208	1	53	payment	payment	NOUN
cblr-1208	1	54	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	1	55	settlements	settlement	NOUN
cblr-1208	1	56	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	1	57	patent	patent	NOUN
cblr-1208	1	58	litigation	litigation	NOUN
cblr-1208	1	59	arising	arise	VERB
cblr-1208	1	60	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	1	61	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	1	62	context	context	NOUN
cblr-1208	1	63	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	1	64	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	1	65	hatch	hatch	PROPN
cblr-1208	1	66	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-1208	1	67	waxman	waxman	PROPN
cblr-1208	1	68	act	act	PROPN
cblr-1208	1	69	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	1	70	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	1	71	rule	rule	NOUN
cblr-1208	1	72	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	1	73	reason	reason	NOUN
cblr-1208	1	74	applies	apply	VERB
cblr-1208	1	75	—	—	PUNCT
cblr-1208	1	76	no	no	PRON
cblr-1208	1	77	per	per	X
cblr-1208	1	78	se	se	X
cblr-1208	1	79	rules	rule	NOUN
cblr-1208	1	80	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	1	81	no	no	DET
cblr-1208	1	82	quick	quick	ADJ
cblr-1208	1	83	look	look	NOUN
cblr-1208	1	84	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	1	85	no	no	DET
cblr-1208	1	86	shortcuts	shortcut	NOUN
cblr-1208	1	87	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	2	1	actavis	actavis	PROPN
cblr-1208	2	2	arose	arise	VERB
cblr-1208	2	3	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	2	4	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	2	5	context	context	NOUN
cblr-1208	2	6	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	2	7	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	2	8	motion	motion	NOUN
cblr-1208	2	9	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	2	10	dismiss	dismiss	VERB
cblr-1208	2	11	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	2	12	explicitly	explicitly	ADV
cblr-1208	2	13	left	leave	VERB
cblr-1208	2	14	to	to	ADP
cblr-1208	2	15	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	2	16	lower	low	ADJ
cblr-1208	2	17	courts	court	NOUN
cblr-1208	2	18	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	2	19	task	task	NOUN
cblr-1208	2	20	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	2	21	structuring	structure	VERB
cblr-1208	2	22	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	2	23	rule	rule	NOUN
cblr-1208	2	24	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	2	25	reason	reason	NOUN
cblr-1208	2	26	analysis	analysis	NOUN
cblr-1208	2	27	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	3	1	following	follow	VERB
cblr-1208	3	2	actavis	actavis	NOUN
cblr-1208	3	3	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	3	4	how	how	SCONJ
cblr-1208	3	5	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	3	6	lower	low	ADJ
cblr-1208	3	7	courts	court	NOUN
cblr-1208	3	8	should	should	AUX
cblr-1208	3	9	apply	apply	VERB
cblr-1208	3	10	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	3	11	rule	rule	NOUN
cblr-1208	3	12	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	3	13	reason	reason	NOUN
cblr-1208	3	14	has	have	AUX
cblr-1208	3	15	been	be	AUX
cblr-1208	3	16	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	3	17	subject	subject	NOUN
cblr-1208	3	18	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	3	19	considerable	considerable	ADJ
cblr-1208	3	20	debate	debate	NOUN
cblr-1208	3	21	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	4	1	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	4	2	ftc	ftc	PROPN
cblr-1208	4	3	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	4	4	private	private	ADJ
cblr-1208	4	5	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
cblr-1208	4	6	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	4	7	as	as	ADV
cblr-1208	4	8	well	well	ADV
cblr-1208	4	9	as	as	ADP
cblr-1208	4	10	law	law	NOUN
cblr-1208	4	11	professors	professor	NOUN
cblr-1208	4	12	aligned	align	VERB
cblr-1208	4	13	with	with	ADP
cblr-1208	4	14	their	their	PRON
cblr-1208	4	15	views	view	NOUN
cblr-1208	4	16	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	4	17	have	have	AUX
cblr-1208	4	18	attempted	attempt	VERB
cblr-1208	4	19	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	4	20	find	find	VERB
cblr-1208	4	21	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	4	22	actavis	actavis	ADJ
cblr-1208	4	23	justifications	justification	NOUN
cblr-1208	4	24	for	for	ADP
cblr-1208	4	25	injecting	inject	VERB
cblr-1208	4	26	shortcuts	shortcut	NOUN
cblr-1208	4	27	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	4	28	presumptions	presumption	NOUN
cblr-1208	4	29	that	that	PRON
cblr-1208	4	30	would	would	AUX
cblr-1208	4	31	undermine	undermine	VERB
cblr-1208	4	32	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	4	33	court	court	NOUN
cblr-1208	4	34	’s	’s	PART
cblr-1208	4	35	clear	clear	ADJ
cblr-1208	4	36	holdings	holding	NOUN
cblr-1208	4	37	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	5	1	those	those	DET
cblr-1208	5	2	efforts	effort	NOUN
cblr-1208	5	3	have	have	AUX
cblr-1208	5	4	thus	thus	ADV
cblr-1208	5	5	far	far	ADV
cblr-1208	5	6	been	be	AUX
cblr-1208	5	7	largely	largely	ADV
cblr-1208	5	8	rejected	reject	VERB
cblr-1208	5	9	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	5	10	post	post	ADJ
cblr-1208	5	11	-	-	ADJ
cblr-1208	5	12	actavis	actavis	ADJ
cblr-1208	5	13	litigation	litigation	NOUN
cblr-1208	5	14	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	6	1	as	as	SCONJ
cblr-1208	6	2	we	we	PRON
cblr-1208	6	3	argue	argue	VERB
cblr-1208	6	4	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	6	5	courts	court	NOUN
cblr-1208	6	6	should	should	AUX
cblr-1208	6	7	continue	continue	VERB
cblr-1208	6	8	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	6	9	reject	reject	VERB
cblr-1208	6	10	such	such	ADJ
cblr-1208	6	11	efforts	effort	NOUN
cblr-1208	6	12	—	—	PUNCT
cblr-1208	6	13	which	which	PRON
cblr-1208	6	14	rest	rest	VERB
cblr-1208	6	15	on	on	ADP
cblr-1208	6	16	presumptions	presumption	NOUN
cblr-1208	6	17	rather	rather	ADV
cblr-1208	6	18	than	than	ADP
cblr-1208	6	19	proof	proof	NOUN
cblr-1208	6	20	—	—	PUNCT
cblr-1208	6	21	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	6	22	preserve	preserve	VERB
cblr-1208	6	23	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	6	24	integrity	integrity	NOUN
cblr-1208	6	25	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	6	26	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	6	27	rule	rule	NOUN
cblr-1208	6	28	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	6	29	reason	reason	NOUN
cblr-1208	6	30	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	7	1	i.	i.	PROPN
cblr-1208	7	2	introduction	introduction	NOUN
cblr-1208	7	3	.................................................................	.................................................................	PUNCT
cblr-1208	7	4	46	46	NUM
cblr-1208	7	5	ii	ii	NOUN
cblr-1208	7	6	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	8	1	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	8	2	twin	twin	ADJ
cblr-1208	8	3	holdings	holding	NOUN
cblr-1208	8	4	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	8	5	actavis	actavi	NOUN
cblr-1208	8	6	:	:	PUNCT
cblr-1208	8	7	all	all	DET
cblr-1208	8	8	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	8	9	rest	rest	NOUN
cblr-1208	8	10	is	be	AUX
cblr-1208	8	11	commentary	commentary	NOUN
cblr-1208	8	12	................................................................	................................................................	PUNCT
cblr-1208	9	1	48	48	NUM
cblr-1208	9	2	*	*	PUNCT
cblr-1208	9	3	saul	saul	PROPN
cblr-1208	9	4	p.	p.	PROPN
cblr-1208	9	5	morgenstern	morgenstern	PROPN
cblr-1208	9	6	is	be	AUX
cblr-1208	9	7	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	9	8	partner	partner	NOUN
cblr-1208	9	9	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	9	10	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	9	11	firm	firm	NOUN
cblr-1208	9	12	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	9	13	arnold	arnold	PROPN
cblr-1208	9	14	&	&	CCONJ
cblr-1208	9	15	porter	porter	PROPN
cblr-1208	9	16	kaye	kaye	PROPN
cblr-1208	9	17	scholer	scholer	PROPN
cblr-1208	9	18	llp	llp	PROPN
cblr-1208	9	19	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-1208	9	20	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	9	21	arnold	arnold	PROPN
cblr-1208	9	22	&	&	CCONJ
cblr-1208	9	23	porter	porter	PROPN
cblr-1208	9	24	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	9	25	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-1208	9	26	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	9	27	resident	resident	NOUN
cblr-1208	9	28	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	9	29	its	its	PRON
cblr-1208	9	30	new	new	PROPN
cblr-1208	9	31	york	york	PROPN
cblr-1208	9	32	office	office	PROPN
cblr-1208	9	33	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	10	1	adam	adam	PROPN
cblr-1208	10	2	m.	m.	PROPN
cblr-1208	10	3	pergament	pergament	NOUN
cblr-1208	10	4	is	be	AUX
cblr-1208	10	5	an	an	DET
cblr-1208	10	6	associate	associate	NOUN
cblr-1208	10	7	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	10	8	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	10	9	firm	firm	ADJ
cblr-1208	10	10	resident	resident	NOUN
cblr-1208	10	11	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	10	12	its	its	PRON
cblr-1208	10	13	washington	washington	PROPN
cblr-1208	10	14	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	10	15	d.c	d.c	PROPN
cblr-1208	10	16	.	.	PROPN
cblr-1208	10	17	office	office	PROPN
cblr-1208	10	18	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	11	1	this	this	DET
cblr-1208	11	2	commentary	commentary	NOUN
cblr-1208	11	3	represents	represent	VERB
cblr-1208	11	4	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	11	5	views	view	NOUN
cblr-1208	11	6	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	11	7	its	its	PRON
cblr-1208	11	8	authors	author	NOUN
cblr-1208	11	9	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	11	10	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	11	11	should	should	AUX
cblr-1208	11	12	not	not	PART
cblr-1208	11	13	be	be	AUX
cblr-1208	11	14	read	read	VERB
cblr-1208	11	15	as	as	ADP
cblr-1208	11	16	representing	represent	VERB
cblr-1208	11	17	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	11	18	views	view	NOUN
cblr-1208	11	19	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	11	20	any	any	DET
cblr-1208	11	21	other	other	ADJ
cblr-1208	11	22	person	person	NOUN
cblr-1208	11	23	or	or	CCONJ
cblr-1208	11	24	entity	entity	NOUN
cblr-1208	11	25	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	11	26	including	include	VERB
cblr-1208	11	27	arnold	arnold	PROPN
cblr-1208	11	28	&	&	CCONJ
cblr-1208	11	29	porter	porter	PROPN
cblr-1208	11	30	or	or	CCONJ
cblr-1208	11	31	any	any	PRON
cblr-1208	11	32	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	11	33	its	its	PRON
cblr-1208	11	34	clients	client	NOUN
cblr-1208	11	35	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	12	1	this	this	DET
cblr-1208	12	2	commentary	commentary	NOUN
cblr-1208	12	3	is	be	AUX
cblr-1208	12	4	provided	provide	VERB
cblr-1208	12	5	for	for	ADP
cblr-1208	12	6	news	news	NOUN
cblr-1208	12	7	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	12	8	information	information	NOUN
cblr-1208	12	9	purposes	purpose	NOUN
cblr-1208	12	10	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	12	11	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	12	12	encourage	encourage	VERB
cblr-1208	12	13	discussion	discussion	NOUN
cblr-1208	12	14	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	12	15	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	12	16	law	law	NOUN
cblr-1208	12	17	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	12	18	its	its	PRON
cblr-1208	12	19	potential	potential	ADJ
cblr-1208	12	20	applications	application	NOUN
cblr-1208	12	21	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	12	22	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	12	23	does	do	AUX
cblr-1208	12	24	not	not	PART
cblr-1208	12	25	take	take	VERB
cblr-1208	12	26	into	into	ADP
cblr-1208	12	27	account	account	NOUN
cblr-1208	12	28	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	12	29	specific	specific	ADJ
cblr-1208	12	30	facts	fact	NOUN
cblr-1208	12	31	or	or	CCONJ
cblr-1208	12	32	circumstances	circumstance	NOUN
cblr-1208	12	33	that	that	PRON
cblr-1208	12	34	may	may	AUX
cblr-1208	12	35	apply	apply	VERB
cblr-1208	12	36	to	to	ADP
cblr-1208	12	37	individual	individual	ADJ
cblr-1208	12	38	situations	situation	NOUN
cblr-1208	12	39	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	13	1	it	it	PRON
cblr-1208	13	2	does	do	AUX
cblr-1208	13	3	not	not	PART
cblr-1208	13	4	constitute	constitute	VERB
cblr-1208	13	5	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	13	6	nor	nor	CCONJ
cblr-1208	13	7	should	should	AUX
cblr-1208	13	8	it	it	PRON
cblr-1208	13	9	be	be	AUX
cblr-1208	13	10	considered	consider	VERB
cblr-1208	13	11	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	13	12	legal	legal	ADJ
cblr-1208	13	13	advice	advice	NOUN
cblr-1208	13	14	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	13	15	generally	generally	ADV
cblr-1208	13	16	or	or	CCONJ
cblr-1208	13	17	as	as	ADP
cblr-1208	13	18	to	to	ADP
cblr-1208	13	19	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	13	20	specific	specific	ADJ
cblr-1208	13	21	matter	matter	NOUN
cblr-1208	13	22	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	13	23	or	or	CCONJ
cblr-1208	13	24	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	13	25	warranty	warranty	NOUN
cblr-1208	13	26	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	13	27	any	any	DET
cblr-1208	13	28	kind	kind	NOUN
cblr-1208	13	29	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	14	1	readers	reader	NOUN
cblr-1208	14	2	are	be	AUX
cblr-1208	14	3	responsible	responsible	ADJ
cblr-1208	14	4	for	for	ADP
cblr-1208	14	5	obtaining	obtain	VERB
cblr-1208	14	6	legal	legal	ADJ
cblr-1208	14	7	advice	advice	NOUN
cblr-1208	14	8	from	from	ADP
cblr-1208	14	9	their	their	PRON
cblr-1208	14	10	own	own	ADJ
cblr-1208	14	11	legal	legal	ADJ
cblr-1208	14	12	counsel	counsel	NOUN
cblr-1208	14	13	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	15	1	lecture_commentary_final	lecture_commentary_final	PROPN
cblr-1208	15	2	46	46	NUM
cblr-1208	15	3	columbia	columbia	PROPN
cblr-1208	15	4	business	business	NOUN
cblr-1208	15	5	law	law	PROPN
cblr-1208	15	6	review	review	NOUN
cblr-1208	15	7	[	[	X
cblr-1208	15	8	vol	vol	NOUN
cblr-1208	15	9	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	15	10	2018	2018	NUM
cblr-1208	15	11	a.	a.	NOUN
cblr-1208	15	12	background	background	NOUN
cblr-1208	15	13	on	on	ADP
cblr-1208	15	14	hatch	hatch	NOUN
cblr-1208	15	15	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-1208	15	16	waxman	waxman	PROPN
cblr-1208	15	17	act	act	NOUN
cblr-1208	15	18	features	feature	VERB
cblr-1208	15	19	that	that	PRON
cblr-1208	15	20	incentivize	incentivize	VERB
cblr-1208	15	21	patent	patent	NOUN
cblr-1208	15	22	litigation	litigation	NOUN
cblr-1208	15	23	settlements	settlement	NOUN
cblr-1208	15	24	involving	involve	VERB
cblr-1208	15	25	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	15	26	reverse	reverse	ADJ
cblr-1208	15	27	payments	payment	NOUN
cblr-1208	15	28	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	15	29	..............................	..............................	PUNCT
cblr-1208	15	30	48	48	NUM
cblr-1208	15	31	b.	b.	NOUN
cblr-1208	15	32	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	15	33	holdings	holding	NOUN
cblr-1208	15	34	.........................................................	.........................................................	PUNCT
cblr-1208	15	35	51	51	NUM
cblr-1208	15	36	c.	c.	NOUN
cblr-1208	15	37	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	15	38	commentary	commentary	NOUN
cblr-1208	15	39	...................................................	...................................................	PUNCT
cblr-1208	15	40	51	51	NUM
cblr-1208	15	41	iii	iii	NOUN
cblr-1208	15	42	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	16	1	actavis	actavis	PROPN
cblr-1208	16	2	requires	require	VERB
cblr-1208	16	3	inquiry	inquiry	NOUN
cblr-1208	16	4	under	under	ADP
cblr-1208	16	5	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	16	6	rule	rule	NOUN
cblr-1208	16	7	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	16	8	reason	reason	NOUN
cblr-1208	16	9	—	—	PUNCT
cblr-1208	16	10	without	without	ADP
cblr-1208	16	11	shortcuts	shortcut	NOUN
cblr-1208	16	12	........................................	........................................	PUNCT
cblr-1208	16	13	54	54	NUM
cblr-1208	16	14	iv	iv	NOUN
cblr-1208	16	15	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	16	16	presumptions	presumption	NOUN
cblr-1208	16	17	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	16	18	shortcuts	shortcut	NOUN
cblr-1208	16	19	that	that	PRON
cblr-1208	16	20	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	16	21	ftc	ftc	PROPN
cblr-1208	16	22	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	16	23	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
cblr-1208	16	24	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	16	25	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	16	26	professors	professor	NOUN
cblr-1208	16	27	seek	seek	VERB
cblr-1208	16	28	are	be	AUX
cblr-1208	16	29	contrary	contrary	ADJ
cblr-1208	16	30	to	to	ADP
cblr-1208	16	31	actavis	actavis	ADJ
cblr-1208	16	32	’	'	PUNCT
cblr-1208	16	33	holdings	holding	NOUN
cblr-1208	16	34	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	16	35	could	could	AUX
cblr-1208	16	36	damage	damage	VERB
cblr-1208	16	37	rule	rule	NOUN
cblr-1208	16	38	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	16	39	reason	reason	NOUN
cblr-1208	16	40	analysis	analysis	NOUN
cblr-1208	16	41	generally	generally	ADV
cblr-1208	16	42	......................................................................	......................................................................	PUNCT
cblr-1208	17	1	56	56	NUM
cblr-1208	17	2	v.	v.	ADP
cblr-1208	17	3	applying	apply	VERB
cblr-1208	17	4	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	17	5	rule	rule	NOUN
cblr-1208	17	6	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	17	7	reason	reason	NOUN
cblr-1208	17	8	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	17	9	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	17	10	reverse	reverse	VERB
cblr-1208	17	11	payment	payment	NOUN
cblr-1208	17	12	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	17	13	settlement	settlement	NOUN
cblr-1208	17	14	agreements	agreement	NOUN
cblr-1208	17	15	...............................................	...............................................	PUNCT
cblr-1208	18	1	61	61	NUM
cblr-1208	18	2	a.	a.	NOUN
cblr-1208	18	3	but	but	CCONJ
cblr-1208	18	4	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-1208	18	5	for	for	ADP
cblr-1208	18	6	world	world	NOUN
cblr-1208	18	7	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	18	8	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	18	9	alternative	alternative	ADJ
cblr-1208	18	10	settlement	settlement	NOUN
cblr-1208	18	11	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	18	12	..........	..........	PUNCT
cblr-1208	18	13	61	61	NUM
cblr-1208	18	14	b.	b.	NOUN
cblr-1208	18	15	but	but	CCONJ
cblr-1208	18	16	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-1208	18	17	for	for	ADP
cblr-1208	18	18	world	world	NOUN
cblr-1208	18	19	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	18	20	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	18	21	no	no	DET
cblr-1208	18	22	settlement	settlement	NOUN
cblr-1208	18	23	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	18	24	........................	........................	PUNCT
cblr-1208	18	25	64	64	NUM
cblr-1208	18	26	vi	vi	NOUN
cblr-1208	18	27	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	18	28	conclusion	conclusion	NOUN
cblr-1208	18	29	....................................................................	....................................................................	PUNCT
cblr-1208	18	30	69	69	NUM
cblr-1208	18	31	i.	i.	NOUN
cblr-1208	18	32	introduction	introduction	NOUN
cblr-1208	18	33	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	18	34	1898	1898	NUM
cblr-1208	18	35	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	18	36	as	as	ADP
cblr-1208	18	37	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	18	38	judge	judge	NOUN
cblr-1208	18	39	on	on	ADP
cblr-1208	18	40	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	18	41	sixth	sixth	ADJ
cblr-1208	18	42	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-1208	18	43	court	court	NOUN
cblr-1208	18	44	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	18	45	appeals	appeal	NOUN
cblr-1208	18	46	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	18	47	william	william	PROPN
cblr-1208	18	48	howard	howard	PROPN
cblr-1208	18	49	taft	taft	PROPN
cblr-1208	18	50	wrote	write	VERB
cblr-1208	18	51	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	18	52	landmark	landmark	NOUN
cblr-1208	18	53	antitrust	antitrust	ADJ
cblr-1208	18	54	decision	decision	NOUN
cblr-1208	18	55	united	united	PROPN
cblr-1208	18	56	states	states	PROPN
cblr-1208	18	57	v.	v.	CCONJ
cblr-1208	18	58	addyston	addyston	PROPN
cblr-1208	18	59	pipe	pipe	PROPN
cblr-1208	18	60	&	&	CCONJ
cblr-1208	18	61	steel	steel	NOUN
cblr-1208	18	62	co.1	co.1	PROPN
cblr-1208	18	63	there	there	ADV
cblr-1208	18	64	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	18	65	he	he	PRON
cblr-1208	18	66	recognized	recognize	VERB
cblr-1208	18	67	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	18	68	distinction	distinction	NOUN
cblr-1208	18	69	between	between	ADP
cblr-1208	18	70	naked	naked	ADJ
cblr-1208	18	71	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	18	72	ancillary	ancillary	ADJ
cblr-1208	18	73	restraints	restraint	NOUN
cblr-1208	18	74	that	that	PRON
cblr-1208	18	75	would	would	AUX
cblr-1208	18	76	help	help	VERB
cblr-1208	18	77	set	set	VERB
cblr-1208	18	78	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	18	79	stage	stage	NOUN
cblr-1208	18	80	for	for	ADP
cblr-1208	18	81	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	18	82	modern	modern	ADJ
cblr-1208	18	83	day	day	NOUN
cblr-1208	18	84	rule	rule	NOUN
cblr-1208	18	85	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	18	86	reason	reason	NOUN
cblr-1208	18	87	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	19	1	taft	taft	PROPN
cblr-1208	19	2	would	would	AUX
cblr-1208	19	3	go	go	VERB
cblr-1208	19	4	on	on	ADP
cblr-1208	19	5	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	19	6	become	become	VERB
cblr-1208	19	7	president	president	NOUN
cblr-1208	19	8	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	19	9	chief	chief	ADJ
cblr-1208	19	10	justice	justice	NOUN
cblr-1208	19	11	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	19	12	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	19	13	united	united	PROPN
cblr-1208	19	14	states	states	PROPN
cblr-1208	19	15	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	20	1	more	more	ADJ
cblr-1208	20	2	than	than	ADP
cblr-1208	20	3	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	20	4	century	century	NOUN
cblr-1208	20	5	later	later	ADV
cblr-1208	20	6	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	20	7	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	20	8	supreme	supreme	PROPN
cblr-1208	20	9	court	court	PROPN
cblr-1208	20	10	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	20	11	ftc	ftc	PROPN
cblr-1208	20	12	v.	v.	ADP
cblr-1208	20	13	actavis2	actavis2	PROPN
cblr-1208	20	14	held	hold	VERB
cblr-1208	20	15	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	20	16	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	20	17	rule	rule	NOUN
cblr-1208	20	18	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	20	19	reason	reason	NOUN
cblr-1208	20	20	applies	apply	VERB
cblr-1208	20	21	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	20	22	cases	case	NOUN
cblr-1208	20	23	challenging	challenge	VERB
cblr-1208	20	24	alleged	alleged	ADJ
cblr-1208	20	25	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	20	26	reverse	reverse	ADJ
cblr-1208	20	27	payment	payment	NOUN
cblr-1208	20	28	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	20	29	settlements	settlement	NOUN
cblr-1208	20	30	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	20	31	litigation	litigation	NOUN
cblr-1208	20	32	arising	arise	VERB
cblr-1208	20	33	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	20	34	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	20	35	context	context	NOUN
cblr-1208	20	36	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	20	37	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	20	38	hatchwaxman	hatchwaxman	PROPN
cblr-1208	20	39	act	act	PROPN
cblr-1208	20	40	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	21	1	how	how	SCONJ
cblr-1208	21	2	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	21	3	lower	low	ADJ
cblr-1208	21	4	courts	court	NOUN
cblr-1208	21	5	should	should	AUX
cblr-1208	21	6	apply	apply	VERB
cblr-1208	21	7	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	21	8	rule	rule	NOUN
cblr-1208	21	9	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	21	10	reason	reason	NOUN
cblr-1208	21	11	following	follow	VERB
cblr-1208	21	12	actavis	actavis	PROPN
cblr-1208	21	13	is	be	AUX
cblr-1208	21	14	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	21	15	subject	subject	NOUN
cblr-1208	21	16	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	21	17	considerable	considerable	ADJ
cblr-1208	21	18	debate	debate	NOUN
cblr-1208	21	19	;	;	PUNCT
cblr-1208	21	20	what	what	PRON
cblr-1208	21	21	is	be	AUX
cblr-1208	21	22	clear	clear	ADJ
cblr-1208	21	23	is	be	AUX
cblr-1208	21	24	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	21	25	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	21	26	actavis	actavis	ADJ
cblr-1208	21	27	court	court	NOUN
cblr-1208	21	28	might	might	AUX
cblr-1208	21	29	have	have	AUX
cblr-1208	21	30	done	do	VERB
cblr-1208	21	31	well	well	ADV
cblr-1208	21	32	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	21	33	draw	draw	VERB
cblr-1208	21	34	lessons	lesson	NOUN
cblr-1208	21	35	from	from	ADP
cblr-1208	21	36	taft	taft	PROPN
cblr-1208	21	37	’s	’s	PART
cblr-1208	21	38	jurisprudence	jurisprudence	NOUN
cblr-1208	21	39	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	21	40	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	21	41	from	from	ADP
cblr-1208	21	42	his	his	PRON
cblr-1208	21	43	sage	sage	NOUN
cblr-1208	21	44	1	1	NUM
cblr-1208	21	45	united	united	PROPN
cblr-1208	21	46	states	states	PROPN
cblr-1208	21	47	v.	v.	CCONJ
cblr-1208	21	48	addyston	addyston	PROPN
cblr-1208	21	49	pipe	pipe	PROPN
cblr-1208	21	50	&	&	CCONJ
cblr-1208	21	51	steel	steel	PROPN
cblr-1208	21	52	co.	co.	PROPN
cblr-1208	21	53	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	21	54	85	85	NUM
cblr-1208	21	55	f.	f.	PROPN
cblr-1208	21	56	271	271	NUM
cblr-1208	21	57	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-1208	21	58	6th	6th	ADJ
cblr-1208	21	59	cir	cir	NOUN
cblr-1208	21	60	.	.	PROPN
cblr-1208	21	61	1898	1898	NUM
cblr-1208	21	62	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-1208	21	63	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	21	64	aff’d	aff’d	VERB
cblr-1208	21	65	175	175	NUM
cblr-1208	21	66	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-1208	21	67	.	.	PROPN
cblr-1208	21	68	211	211	NUM
cblr-1208	21	69	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-1208	21	70	1899	1899	NUM
cblr-1208	21	71	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-1208	21	72	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	22	1	2	2	NUM
cblr-1208	22	2	ftc	ftc	PROPN
cblr-1208	22	3	v.	v.	ADP
cblr-1208	22	4	actavis	actavis	PROPN
cblr-1208	22	5	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	22	6	133	133	NUM
cblr-1208	22	7	s.	s.	PROPN
cblr-1208	22	8	ct	ct	PROPN
cblr-1208	22	9	.	.	PROPN
cblr-1208	22	10	2223	2223	NUM
cblr-1208	22	11	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-1208	22	12	2013	2013	NUM
cblr-1208	22	13	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-1208	22	14	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	23	1	lecture_commentary_final	lecture_commentary_final	PROPN
cblr-1208	24	1	no	no	INTJ
cblr-1208	24	2	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	25	1	1:45	1:45	NUM
cblr-1208	25	2	]	]	PUNCT
cblr-1208	25	3	commentary	commentary	NOUN
cblr-1208	25	4	:	:	PUNCT
cblr-1208	25	5	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	25	6	rule	rule	NOUN
cblr-1208	25	7	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	25	8	reason	reason	NOUN
cblr-1208	25	9	47	47	NUM
cblr-1208	25	10	advice	advice	NOUN
cblr-1208	25	11	:	:	PUNCT
cblr-1208	25	12	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	25	13	do	do	AUX
cblr-1208	25	14	n’t	not	PART
cblr-1208	25	15	write	write	VERB
cblr-1208	25	16	so	so	SCONJ
cblr-1208	25	17	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	25	18	you	you	PRON
cblr-1208	25	19	can	can	AUX
cblr-1208	25	20	be	be	AUX
cblr-1208	25	21	understood	understand	VERB
cblr-1208	25	22	;	;	PUNCT
cblr-1208	25	23	write	write	VERB
cblr-1208	25	24	so	so	SCONJ
cblr-1208	25	25	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	25	26	you	you	PRON
cblr-1208	25	27	ca	can	AUX
cblr-1208	25	28	n’t	not	PART
cblr-1208	25	29	be	be	AUX
cblr-1208	25	30	misunderstood	misunderstood	ADJ
cblr-1208	25	31	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	25	32	”3	”3	PUNCT
cblr-1208	25	33	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	25	34	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	25	35	lead	lead	NOUN
cblr-1208	25	36	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-1208	25	37	up	up	NOUN
cblr-1208	25	38	to	to	ADP
cblr-1208	25	39	actavis	actavis	NUM
cblr-1208	25	40	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	25	41	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	25	42	federal	federal	PROPN
cblr-1208	25	43	trade	trade	PROPN
cblr-1208	25	44	commission	commission	PROPN
cblr-1208	25	45	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-1208	25	46	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	25	47	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	25	48	ftc	ftc	PROPN
cblr-1208	25	49	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	25	50	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-1208	25	51	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	25	52	private	private	ADJ
cblr-1208	25	53	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
cblr-1208	25	54	seeking	seek	VERB
cblr-1208	25	55	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	25	56	challenge	challenge	VERB
cblr-1208	25	57	socalled	socalle	VERB
cblr-1208	25	58	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	25	59	reverse	reverse	ADJ
cblr-1208	25	60	payment	payment	NOUN
cblr-1208	25	61	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	25	62	settlements	settlement	NOUN
cblr-1208	25	63	sought	seek	VERB
cblr-1208	25	64	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	25	65	rule	rule	NOUN
cblr-1208	25	66	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	25	67	presumptive	presumptive	ADJ
cblr-1208	25	68	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	25	69	if	if	SCONJ
cblr-1208	25	70	not	not	PART
cblr-1208	25	71	per	per	ADP
cblr-1208	25	72	se	se	X
cblr-1208	25	73	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	25	74	illegality	illegality	NOUN
cblr-1208	25	75	for	for	ADP
cblr-1208	25	76	such	such	ADJ
cblr-1208	25	77	agreements	agreement	NOUN
cblr-1208	25	78	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	26	1	at	at	ADP
cblr-1208	26	2	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	26	3	same	same	ADJ
cblr-1208	26	4	time	time	NOUN
cblr-1208	26	5	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	26	6	parties	party	NOUN
cblr-1208	26	7	to	to	ADP
cblr-1208	26	8	such	such	ADJ
cblr-1208	26	9	settlements	settlement	NOUN
cblr-1208	26	10	advocated	advocate	VERB
cblr-1208	26	11	for	for	ADP
cblr-1208	26	12	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	26	13	rule	rule	NOUN
cblr-1208	26	14	that	that	PRON
cblr-1208	26	15	rendered	render	VERB
cblr-1208	26	16	them	they	PRON
cblr-1208	26	17	virtually	virtually	ADV
cblr-1208	26	18	per	per	ADP
cblr-1208	26	19	se	se	X
cblr-1208	26	20	lawful	lawful	ADJ
cblr-1208	26	21	as	as	ADV
cblr-1208	26	22	long	long	ADV
cblr-1208	26	23	as	as	SCONJ
cblr-1208	26	24	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	26	25	settlement	settlement	NOUN
cblr-1208	26	26	was	be	AUX
cblr-1208	26	27	within	within	ADP
cblr-1208	26	28	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	26	29	term	term	NOUN
cblr-1208	26	30	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	26	31	substance	substance	NOUN
cblr-1208	26	32	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	26	33	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	26	34	patent	patent	NOUN
cblr-1208	26	35	—	—	PUNCT
cblr-1208	26	36	dubbed	dub	VERB
cblr-1208	26	37	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	26	38	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	26	39	scope	scope	NOUN
cblr-1208	26	40	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	26	41	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	26	42	patent	patent	NOUN
cblr-1208	26	43	test”—which	test”—which	PRON
cblr-1208	26	44	was	be	AUX
cblr-1208	26	45	adopted	adopt	VERB
cblr-1208	26	46	by	by	ADP
cblr-1208	26	47	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	26	48	majority	majority	NOUN
cblr-1208	26	49	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	26	50	courts	court	NOUN
cblr-1208	26	51	led	lead	VERB
cblr-1208	26	52	by	by	ADP
cblr-1208	26	53	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	26	54	court	court	NOUN
cblr-1208	26	55	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	26	56	appeals	appeal	NOUN
cblr-1208	26	57	for	for	ADP
cblr-1208	26	58	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	26	59	eleventh	eleventh	ADJ
cblr-1208	26	60	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-1208	26	61	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	27	1	on	on	ADP
cblr-1208	27	2	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	27	3	strength	strength	NOUN
cblr-1208	27	4	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	27	5	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	27	6	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-1208	27	7	split	split	NOUN
cblr-1208	27	8	created	create	VERB
cblr-1208	27	9	by	by	ADP
cblr-1208	27	10	an	an	DET
cblr-1208	27	11	outlier	outlier	ADJ
cblr-1208	27	12	third	third	ADJ
cblr-1208	27	13	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-1208	27	14	decision	decision	NOUN
cblr-1208	27	15	applying	apply	VERB
cblr-1208	27	16	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	27	17	so	so	ADV
cblr-1208	27	18	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-1208	27	19	called	call	VERB
cblr-1208	27	20	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	27	21	quick	quick	ADJ
cblr-1208	27	22	look	look	NOUN
cblr-1208	27	23	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	27	24	rule	rule	NOUN
cblr-1208	27	25	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	27	26	reason	reason	NOUN
cblr-1208	27	27	analysis,4	analysis,4	NOUN
cblr-1208	27	28	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	27	29	supreme	supreme	PROPN
cblr-1208	27	30	court	court	PROPN
cblr-1208	27	31	took	take	VERB
cblr-1208	27	32	up	up	ADP
cblr-1208	27	33	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	27	34	question	question	NOUN
cblr-1208	27	35	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	27	36	actavis	actavis	NOUN
cblr-1208	27	37	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	27	38	rejected	reject	VERB
cblr-1208	27	39	both	both	DET
cblr-1208	27	40	positions	position	NOUN
cblr-1208	27	41	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	28	1	it	it	PRON
cblr-1208	28	2	held	hold	VERB
cblr-1208	28	3	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	28	4	socalled	socalle	VERB
cblr-1208	28	5	reverse	reverse	ADJ
cblr-1208	28	6	payment	payment	NOUN
cblr-1208	28	7	settlement	settlement	NOUN
cblr-1208	28	8	agreements	agreement	NOUN
cblr-1208	28	9	challenged	challenge	VERB
cblr-1208	28	10	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	28	11	subsequent	subsequent	ADJ
cblr-1208	28	12	antitrust	antitrust	ADJ
cblr-1208	28	13	litigation	litigation	NOUN
cblr-1208	28	14	must	must	AUX
cblr-1208	28	15	be	be	AUX
cblr-1208	28	16	analyzed	analyze	VERB
cblr-1208	28	17	under	under	ADP
cblr-1208	28	18	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	28	19	full	full	ADJ
cblr-1208	28	20	rule	rule	NOUN
cblr-1208	28	21	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	28	22	reason	reason	NOUN
cblr-1208	28	23	—	—	PUNCT
cblr-1208	28	24	no	no	PRON
cblr-1208	28	25	per	per	X
cblr-1208	28	26	se	se	X
cblr-1208	28	27	rules	rule	NOUN
cblr-1208	28	28	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	28	29	no	no	DET
cblr-1208	28	30	quick	quick	ADJ
cblr-1208	28	31	look	look	NOUN
cblr-1208	28	32	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	28	33	no	no	DET
cblr-1208	28	34	shortcuts.5	shortcuts.5	PROPN
cblr-1208	28	35	following	follow	VERB
cblr-1208	28	36	actavis	actavis	PROPN
cblr-1208	28	37	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	28	38	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	28	39	ftc	ftc	PROPN
cblr-1208	28	40	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	28	41	private	private	ADJ
cblr-1208	28	42	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
cblr-1208	28	43	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	28	44	as	as	ADV
cblr-1208	28	45	well	well	ADV
cblr-1208	28	46	as	as	SCONJ
cblr-1208	28	47	law	law	NOUN
cblr-1208	28	48	professors	professor	NOUN
cblr-1208	28	49	aligned	align	VERB
cblr-1208	28	50	with	with	ADP
cblr-1208	28	51	their	their	PRON
cblr-1208	28	52	views	view	NOUN
cblr-1208	28	53	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	28	54	have	have	AUX
cblr-1208	28	55	attempted	attempt	VERB
cblr-1208	28	56	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	28	57	find	find	VERB
cblr-1208	28	58	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	28	59	actavis	actavis	ADJ
cblr-1208	28	60	justifications	justification	NOUN
cblr-1208	28	61	for	for	ADP
cblr-1208	28	62	injecting	inject	VERB
cblr-1208	28	63	shortcuts	shortcut	NOUN
cblr-1208	28	64	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	28	65	presumptions	presumption	NOUN
cblr-1208	28	66	that	that	PRON
cblr-1208	28	67	would	would	AUX
cblr-1208	28	68	undermine	undermine	VERB
cblr-1208	28	69	those	those	DET
cblr-1208	28	70	clear	clear	ADJ
cblr-1208	28	71	holdings	holding	NOUN
cblr-1208	28	72	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	29	1	those	those	DET
cblr-1208	29	2	efforts	effort	NOUN
cblr-1208	29	3	have	have	AUX
cblr-1208	29	4	thus	thus	ADV
cblr-1208	29	5	far	far	ADV
cblr-1208	29	6	been	be	AUX
cblr-1208	29	7	largely	largely	ADV
cblr-1208	29	8	rejected	reject	VERB
cblr-1208	29	9	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	29	10	postactavis	postactavis	ADJ
cblr-1208	29	11	litigation	litigation	NOUN
cblr-1208	29	12	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	29	13	most	most	ADV
cblr-1208	29	14	notably	notably	ADV
cblr-1208	29	15	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	29	16	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	29	17	re	re	PROPN
cblr-1208	29	18	wellbutrin	wellbutrin	NOUN
cblr-1208	29	19	xl	xl	PROPN
cblr-1208	29	20	antitrust	antitrust	ADJ
cblr-1208	29	21	litigation,6	litigation,6	NOUN
cblr-1208	29	22	which	which	PRON
cblr-1208	29	23	was	be	AUX
cblr-1208	29	24	decided	decide	VERB
cblr-1208	29	25	by	by	ADP
cblr-1208	29	26	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	29	27	third	third	ADJ
cblr-1208	29	28	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-1208	29	29	—	—	PUNCT
cblr-1208	29	30	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	29	31	same	same	ADJ
cblr-1208	29	32	court	court	NOUN
cblr-1208	29	33	that	that	PRON
cblr-1208	29	34	had	have	VERB
cblr-1208	29	35	before	before	SCONJ
cblr-1208	29	36	actavis	actavis	PROPN
cblr-1208	29	37	adopted	adopt	VERB
cblr-1208	29	38	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	29	39	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	29	40	quick	quick	ADJ
cblr-1208	29	41	look	look	NOUN
cblr-1208	29	42	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	29	43	approach	approach	NOUN
cblr-1208	29	44	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	30	1	we	we	PRON
cblr-1208	30	2	explain	explain	VERB
cblr-1208	30	3	below	below	ADP
cblr-1208	30	4	why	why	SCONJ
cblr-1208	30	5	courts	court	NOUN
cblr-1208	30	6	should	should	AUX
cblr-1208	30	7	3	3	NUM
cblr-1208	30	8	gerald	gerald	PROPN
cblr-1208	30	9	lebovits	lebovit	NOUN
cblr-1208	30	10	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	30	11	free	free	ADJ
cblr-1208	30	12	at	at	ADP
cblr-1208	30	13	last	last	ADJ
cblr-1208	30	14	from	from	ADP
cblr-1208	30	15	obscurity	obscurity	NOUN
cblr-1208	30	16	:	:	PUNCT
cblr-1208	30	17	achieving	achieve	VERB
cblr-1208	30	18	clarity	clarity	NOUN
cblr-1208	30	19	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	30	20	16	16	NUM
cblr-1208	30	21	scribes	scribe	NOUN
cblr-1208	30	22	j.	j.	PROPN
cblr-1208	30	23	legal	legal	PROPN
cblr-1208	30	24	writing	write	VERB
cblr-1208	30	25	127	127	NUM
cblr-1208	30	26	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	30	27	127	127	NUM
cblr-1208	30	28	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-1208	30	29	2015	2015	NUM
cblr-1208	30	30	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-1208	30	31	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-1208	30	32	quoting	quote	VERB
cblr-1208	30	33	president	president	NOUN
cblr-1208	30	34	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	30	35	later	later	ADV
cblr-1208	30	36	chief	chief	PROPN
cblr-1208	30	37	justice	justice	PROPN
cblr-1208	30	38	taft	taft	PROPN
cblr-1208	30	39	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-1208	30	40	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	31	1	4	4	NUM
cblr-1208	31	2	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	31	3	re	re	NOUN
cblr-1208	31	4	k	k	X
cblr-1208	31	5	-	-	ADJ
cblr-1208	31	6	dur	dur	ADJ
cblr-1208	31	7	antitrust	antitrust	ADJ
cblr-1208	31	8	litig	litig	NOUN
cblr-1208	31	9	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	32	1	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	32	2	686	686	NUM
cblr-1208	32	3	f.3d	f.3d	NUM
cblr-1208	32	4	197	197	NUM
cblr-1208	32	5	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	32	6	218	218	NUM
cblr-1208	32	7	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-1208	32	8	3d	3d	PROPN
cblr-1208	32	9	cir	cir	NOUN
cblr-1208	32	10	.	.	PROPN
cblr-1208	32	11	2013	2013	NUM
cblr-1208	32	12	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-1208	32	13	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	32	14	vacated	vacate	VERB
cblr-1208	32	15	sub	sub	PROPN
cblr-1208	32	16	nom	nom	PROPN
cblr-1208	32	17	.	.	PROPN
cblr-1208	32	18	merck	merck	PROPN
cblr-1208	32	19	&	&	CCONJ
cblr-1208	32	20	co.	co.	PROPN
cblr-1208	32	21	v.	v.	ADP
cblr-1208	32	22	la	la	PROPN
cblr-1208	32	23	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	32	24	wholesale	wholesale	PROPN
cblr-1208	32	25	drug	drug	PROPN
cblr-1208	32	26	co.	co.	PROPN
cblr-1208	32	27	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	32	28	133	133	NUM
cblr-1208	32	29	s.	s.	PROPN
cblr-1208	32	30	ct	ct	PROPN
cblr-1208	32	31	.	.	PROPN
cblr-1208	32	32	2849	2849	NUM
cblr-1208	32	33	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-1208	32	34	2013	2013	NUM
cblr-1208	32	35	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-1208	32	36	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	33	1	5	5	NUM
cblr-1208	33	2	see	see	VERB
cblr-1208	33	3	actavis	actavis	PROPN
cblr-1208	33	4	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	33	5	133	133	NUM
cblr-1208	33	6	s.	s.	PROPN
cblr-1208	33	7	ct	ct	PROPN
cblr-1208	33	8	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	34	1	at	at	ADP
cblr-1208	34	2	2237	2237	NUM
cblr-1208	34	3	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-1208	34	4	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	34	5	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	34	6	ftc	ftc	PROPN
cblr-1208	34	7	urges	urge	VERB
cblr-1208	34	8	us	we	PRON
cblr-1208	34	9	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	34	10	hold	hold	VERB
cblr-1208	34	11	that	that	DET
cblr-1208	34	12	reverse	reverse	ADJ
cblr-1208	34	13	payment	payment	NOUN
cblr-1208	34	14	settlement	settlement	NOUN
cblr-1208	34	15	agreements	agreement	NOUN
cblr-1208	34	16	are	be	AUX
cblr-1208	34	17	presumptively	presumptively	ADV
cblr-1208	34	18	unlawful	unlawful	ADJ
cblr-1208	34	19	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	34	20	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	34	21	courts	court	NOUN
cblr-1208	34	22	reviewing	review	VERB
cblr-1208	34	23	such	such	ADJ
cblr-1208	34	24	agreements	agreement	NOUN
cblr-1208	34	25	should	should	AUX
cblr-1208	34	26	proceed	proceed	VERB
cblr-1208	34	27	via	via	ADP
cblr-1208	34	28	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	34	29	‘	'	PUNCT
cblr-1208	34	30	quick	quick	ADJ
cblr-1208	34	31	look	look	NOUN
cblr-1208	34	32	’	'	PUNCT
cblr-1208	34	33	approach	approach	NOUN
cblr-1208	34	34	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	34	35	rather	rather	ADV
cblr-1208	34	36	than	than	ADP
cblr-1208	34	37	applying	apply	VERB
cblr-1208	34	38	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	34	39	‘	'	PUNCT
cblr-1208	34	40	rule	rule	NOUN
cblr-1208	34	41	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	34	42	reason	reason	NOUN
cblr-1208	34	43	’	'	PUNCT
cblr-1208	34	44	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	34	45	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	34	46	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	35	1	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	36	1	we	we	PRON
cblr-1208	36	2	decline	decline	VERB
cblr-1208	36	3	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	36	4	do	do	VERB
cblr-1208	36	5	so	so	ADV
cblr-1208	36	6	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	36	7	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	36	8	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-1208	37	1	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-1208	37	2	citation	citation	NOUN
cblr-1208	37	3	omitted	omit	VERB
cblr-1208	37	4	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-1208	37	5	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	38	1	6	6	NUM
cblr-1208	38	2	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	38	3	re	re	PROPN
cblr-1208	38	4	wellbutrin	wellbutrin	NOUN
cblr-1208	38	5	xl	xl	PROPN
cblr-1208	38	6	antitrust	antitrust	ADJ
cblr-1208	38	7	litig	litig	NOUN
cblr-1208	38	8	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	38	9	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	38	10	868	868	NUM
cblr-1208	38	11	f.3d	f.3d	NUM
cblr-1208	38	12	132	132	NUM
cblr-1208	38	13	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	38	14	167	167	NUM
cblr-1208	38	15	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-1208	38	16	3rd	3rd	ADJ
cblr-1208	38	17	cir	cir	NOUN
cblr-1208	38	18	.	.	PROPN
cblr-1208	38	19	2017	2017	NUM
cblr-1208	38	20	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-1208	38	21	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	39	1	lecture_commentary_final	lecture_commentary_final	PROPN
cblr-1208	39	2	48	48	NUM
cblr-1208	39	3	columbia	columbia	PROPN
cblr-1208	39	4	business	business	NOUN
cblr-1208	39	5	law	law	PROPN
cblr-1208	39	6	review	review	NOUN
cblr-1208	39	7	[	[	X
cblr-1208	39	8	vol	vol	NOUN
cblr-1208	39	9	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	39	10	2018	2018	NUM
cblr-1208	39	11	continue	continue	VERB
cblr-1208	39	12	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	39	13	reject	reject	VERB
cblr-1208	39	14	such	such	ADJ
cblr-1208	39	15	efforts	effort	NOUN
cblr-1208	39	16	—	—	PUNCT
cblr-1208	39	17	which	which	PRON
cblr-1208	39	18	rest	rest	VERB
cblr-1208	39	19	on	on	ADP
cblr-1208	39	20	presumptions	presumption	NOUN
cblr-1208	39	21	rather	rather	ADV
cblr-1208	39	22	than	than	ADP
cblr-1208	39	23	proof	proof	NOUN
cblr-1208	39	24	—	—	PUNCT
cblr-1208	39	25	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	39	26	preserve	preserve	VERB
cblr-1208	39	27	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	39	28	integrity	integrity	NOUN
cblr-1208	39	29	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	39	30	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	39	31	rule	rule	NOUN
cblr-1208	39	32	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	39	33	reason	reason	NOUN
cblr-1208	39	34	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	40	1	ii	ii	PROPN
cblr-1208	40	2	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	41	1	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	41	2	twin	twin	ADJ
cblr-1208	41	3	holdings	holding	NOUN
cblr-1208	41	4	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	41	5	actavis	actavi	NOUN
cblr-1208	41	6	:	:	PUNCT
cblr-1208	41	7	all	all	DET
cblr-1208	41	8	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	41	9	rest	rest	NOUN
cblr-1208	41	10	is	be	AUX
cblr-1208	41	11	commentary	commentary	NOUN
cblr-1208	41	12	a.	a.	NOUN
cblr-1208	41	13	background	background	NOUN
cblr-1208	41	14	on	on	ADP
cblr-1208	41	15	hatch	hatch	NOUN
cblr-1208	41	16	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-1208	41	17	waxman	waxman	PROPN
cblr-1208	41	18	act	act	NOUN
cblr-1208	41	19	features	feature	VERB
cblr-1208	41	20	that	that	PRON
cblr-1208	41	21	incentivize	incentivize	VERB
cblr-1208	41	22	patent	patent	NOUN
cblr-1208	41	23	litigation	litigation	NOUN
cblr-1208	41	24	settlements	settlement	NOUN
cblr-1208	41	25	involving	involve	VERB
cblr-1208	41	26	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	41	27	reverse	reverse	ADJ
cblr-1208	41	28	payments	payment	NOUN
cblr-1208	41	29	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	41	30	patent	patent	NOUN
cblr-1208	41	31	settlement	settlement	NOUN
cblr-1208	41	32	agreements	agreement	NOUN
cblr-1208	41	33	involving	involve	VERB
cblr-1208	41	34	so	so	ADV
cblr-1208	41	35	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-1208	41	36	called	call	VERB
cblr-1208	41	37	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	41	38	reverse	reverse	ADJ
cblr-1208	41	39	payments	payment	NOUN
cblr-1208	41	40	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	41	41	arise	arise	VERB
cblr-1208	41	42	most	most	ADV
cblr-1208	41	43	frequently	frequently	ADV
cblr-1208	41	44	under	under	ADP
cblr-1208	41	45	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	41	46	hatch	hatch	NOUN
cblr-1208	41	47	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-1208	41	48	waxman	waxman	NOUN
cblr-1208	41	49	act.7	act.7	PROPN
cblr-1208	41	50	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	41	51	act	act	NOUN
cblr-1208	41	52	allows	allow	VERB
cblr-1208	41	53	generic	generic	ADJ
cblr-1208	41	54	drug	drug	NOUN
cblr-1208	41	55	manufacturers	manufacturer	NOUN
cblr-1208	41	56	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	41	57	obtain	obtain	VERB
cblr-1208	41	58	expedited	expedite	VERB
cblr-1208	41	59	food	food	NOUN
cblr-1208	41	60	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	41	61	drug	drug	NOUN
cblr-1208	41	62	administration	administration	NOUN
cblr-1208	41	63	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-1208	41	64	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	41	65	fda	fda	PROPN
cblr-1208	41	66	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	41	67	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-1208	41	68	approval	approval	NOUN
cblr-1208	41	69	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	41	70	market	market	VERB
cblr-1208	41	71	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	41	72	previously	previously	ADV
cblr-1208	41	73	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-1208	41	74	approved	approve	VERB
cblr-1208	41	75	drug	drug	NOUN
cblr-1208	41	76	by	by	ADP
cblr-1208	41	77	filing	file	VERB
cblr-1208	41	78	an	an	DET
cblr-1208	41	79	abbreviated	abbreviate	VERB
cblr-1208	41	80	new	new	ADJ
cblr-1208	41	81	drug	drug	NOUN
cblr-1208	41	82	application	application	NOUN
cblr-1208	41	83	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-1208	41	84	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	41	85	anda	anda	PROPN
cblr-1208	41	86	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	41	87	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-1208	41	88	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	42	1	when	when	SCONJ
cblr-1208	42	2	filing	file	VERB
cblr-1208	42	3	an	an	DET
cblr-1208	42	4	anda	anda	NOUN
cblr-1208	42	5	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	42	6	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	42	7	generic	generic	ADJ
cblr-1208	42	8	manufacturer	manufacturer	NOUN
cblr-1208	42	9	must	must	AUX
cblr-1208	42	10	certify	certify	VERB
cblr-1208	42	11	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	42	12	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	42	13	generic	generic	ADJ
cblr-1208	42	14	drug	drug	NOUN
cblr-1208	42	15	has	have	VERB
cblr-1208	42	16	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	42	17	same	same	ADJ
cblr-1208	42	18	active	active	ADJ
cblr-1208	42	19	ingredients	ingredient	NOUN
cblr-1208	42	20	as	as	ADP
cblr-1208	42	21	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	42	22	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	42	23	is	be	AUX
cblr-1208	42	24	biologically	biologically	ADV
cblr-1208	42	25	equivalent	equivalent	ADJ
cblr-1208	42	26	to	to	ADP
cblr-1208	42	27	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	42	28	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	42	29	previously	previously	ADV
cblr-1208	42	30	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-1208	42	31	approved	approve	VERB
cblr-1208	42	32	brand	brand	NOUN
cblr-1208	42	33	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-1208	42	34	name	name	NOUN
cblr-1208	42	35	drug.8	drug.8	PROPN
cblr-1208	42	36	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	42	37	obtain	obtain	VERB
cblr-1208	42	38	fda	fda	PROPN
cblr-1208	42	39	approval	approval	NOUN
cblr-1208	42	40	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	42	41	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	42	42	generic	generic	ADJ
cblr-1208	42	43	manufacturer	manufacturer	NOUN
cblr-1208	42	44	must	must	AUX
cblr-1208	42	45	also	also	ADV
cblr-1208	42	46	certify	certify	VERB
cblr-1208	42	47	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	42	48	one	one	NUM
cblr-1208	42	49	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	42	50	several	several	ADJ
cblr-1208	42	51	ways	way	NOUN
cblr-1208	42	52	that	that	PRON
cblr-1208	42	53	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	42	54	generic	generic	ADJ
cblr-1208	42	55	drug	drug	NOUN
cblr-1208	42	56	does	do	AUX
cblr-1208	42	57	not	not	PART
cblr-1208	42	58	infringe	infringe	VERB
cblr-1208	42	59	valid	valid	ADJ
cblr-1208	42	60	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	42	61	outstanding	outstanding	ADJ
cblr-1208	42	62	patents	patent	NOUN
cblr-1208	42	63	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	43	1	one	one	NUM
cblr-1208	43	2	such	such	ADJ
cblr-1208	43	3	way	way	NOUN
cblr-1208	43	4	is	be	AUX
cblr-1208	43	5	through	through	ADP
cblr-1208	43	6	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	43	7	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	43	8	paragraph	paragraph	NOUN
cblr-1208	43	9	iv	iv	NUM
cblr-1208	43	10	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	43	11	certification	certification	NOUN
cblr-1208	43	12	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	43	13	which	which	PRON
cblr-1208	43	14	states	state	VERB
cblr-1208	43	15	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	43	16	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	43	17	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	43	18	patent	patent	NOUN
cblr-1208	43	19	is	be	AUX
cblr-1208	43	20	either	either	CCONJ
cblr-1208	43	21	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	43	22	invalid	invalid	ADJ
cblr-1208	43	23	or	or	CCONJ
cblr-1208	43	24	will	will	AUX
cblr-1208	43	25	not	not	PART
cblr-1208	43	26	be	be	AUX
cblr-1208	43	27	infringed	infringe	VERB
cblr-1208	43	28	by	by	ADP
cblr-1208	43	29	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	43	30	manufacture	manufacture	NOUN
cblr-1208	43	31	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	43	32	use	use	NOUN
cblr-1208	43	33	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	43	34	or	or	CCONJ
cblr-1208	43	35	sale	sale	NOUN
cblr-1208	43	36	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	43	37	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	43	38	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	43	39	generic	generic	ADJ
cblr-1208	43	40	drug.9	drug.9	PROPN
cblr-1208	43	41	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	43	42	first	first	ADJ
cblr-1208	43	43	generic	generic	ADJ
cblr-1208	43	44	manufacturer	manufacturer	NOUN
cblr-1208	43	45	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	43	46	file	file	VERB
cblr-1208	43	47	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	43	48	paragraph	paragraph	NOUN
cblr-1208	43	49	iv	iv	NUM
cblr-1208	43	50	certification	certification	NOUN
cblr-1208	43	51	is	be	AUX
cblr-1208	43	52	eligible	eligible	ADJ
cblr-1208	43	53	for	for	ADP
cblr-1208	43	54	180	180	NUM
cblr-1208	43	55	days	day	NOUN
cblr-1208	43	56	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	43	57	market	market	NOUN
cblr-1208	43	58	exclusivity	exclusivity	NOUN
cblr-1208	43	59	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	43	60	during	during	ADP
cblr-1208	43	61	which	which	DET
cblr-1208	43	62	time	time	NOUN
cblr-1208	43	63	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	43	64	fda	fda	PROPN
cblr-1208	43	65	can	can	AUX
cblr-1208	43	66	not	not	PART
cblr-1208	43	67	approve	approve	VERB
cblr-1208	43	68	another	another	DET
cblr-1208	43	69	generic	generic	ADJ
cblr-1208	43	70	manufacturer	manufacturer	NOUN
cblr-1208	43	71	’s	’s	PART
cblr-1208	43	72	anda.10	anda.10	ADJ
cblr-1208	43	73	following	follow	VERB
cblr-1208	43	74	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	43	75	paragraph	paragraph	NOUN
cblr-1208	43	76	iv	iv	NUM
cblr-1208	43	77	certification	certification	NOUN
cblr-1208	43	78	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	43	79	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	43	80	brand	brand	NOUN
cblr-1208	43	81	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-1208	43	82	name	name	NOUN
cblr-1208	43	83	manufacturer	manufacturer	NOUN
cblr-1208	43	84	has	have	VERB
cblr-1208	43	85	forty	forty	NUM
cblr-1208	43	86	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-1208	43	87	five	five	NUM
cblr-1208	43	88	days	day	NOUN
cblr-1208	43	89	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	43	90	file	file	VERB
cblr-1208	43	91	an	an	DET
cblr-1208	43	92	infringement	infringement	NOUN
cblr-1208	43	93	action	action	NOUN
cblr-1208	43	94	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	43	95	which	which	PRON
cblr-1208	43	96	stays	stay	VERB
cblr-1208	43	97	fda	fda	PROPN
cblr-1208	43	98	7	7	NUM
cblr-1208	43	99	drug	drug	NOUN
cblr-1208	43	100	price	price	NOUN
cblr-1208	43	101	competition	competition	NOUN
cblr-1208	43	102	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	43	103	patent	patent	NOUN
cblr-1208	43	104	term	term	NOUN
cblr-1208	43	105	restoration	restoration	NOUN
cblr-1208	43	106	act	act	NOUN
cblr-1208	43	107	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	43	108	1984	1984	NUM
cblr-1208	43	109	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	43	110	pub	pub	NOUN
cblr-1208	43	111	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	44	1	l.	l.	PROPN
cblr-1208	44	2	no	no	INTJ
cblr-1208	44	3	.	.	PROPN
cblr-1208	45	1	98	98	NUM
cblr-1208	45	2	-	-	SYM
cblr-1208	45	3	417	417	NUM
cblr-1208	45	4	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	45	5	98	98	NUM
cblr-1208	45	6	stat	stat	NOUN
cblr-1208	45	7	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	46	1	1585	1585	NUM
cblr-1208	46	2	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-1208	46	3	codified	codify	VERB
cblr-1208	46	4	at	at	ADP
cblr-1208	46	5	21	21	NUM
cblr-1208	46	6	u.s.c	u.s.c	NOUN
cblr-1208	46	7	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	47	1	§	§	PROPN
cblr-1208	47	2	§	§	PROPN
cblr-1208	47	3	301	301	NUM
cblr-1208	47	4	et	et	PROPN
cblr-1208	47	5	seq	seq	PROPN
cblr-1208	47	6	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	47	7	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-1208	47	8	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	48	1	8	8	NUM
cblr-1208	48	2	see	see	VERB
cblr-1208	48	3	21	21	NUM
cblr-1208	48	4	u.s.c	u.s.c	ADJ
cblr-1208	48	5	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	49	1	§	§	PROPN
cblr-1208	49	2	355(j)(2)(a)(ii	355(j)(2)(a)(ii	NUM
cblr-1208	49	3	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-1208	49	4	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	49	5	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-1208	49	6	iv	iv	X
cblr-1208	49	7	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-1208	49	8	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-1208	49	9	2017	2017	NUM
cblr-1208	49	10	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-1208	49	11	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	50	1	9	9	NUM
cblr-1208	50	2	see	see	VERB
cblr-1208	50	3	21	21	NUM
cblr-1208	50	4	u.s.c	u.s.c	ADJ
cblr-1208	50	5	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	51	1	§	§	PROPN
cblr-1208	51	2	355(j)(2)(a)(vii)(iv	355(j)(2)(a)(vii)(iv	NUM
cblr-1208	51	3	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-1208	51	4	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	52	1	10	10	NUM
cblr-1208	52	2	see	see	VERB
cblr-1208	52	3	21	21	NUM
cblr-1208	52	4	u.s.c	u.s.c	ADJ
cblr-1208	52	5	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	53	1	§	§	NOUN
cblr-1208	53	2	355(j)(5)(b)(iv	355(j)(5)(b)(iv	NUM
cblr-1208	53	3	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-1208	53	4	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	54	1	lecture_commentary_final	lecture_commentary_final	PROPN
cblr-1208	55	1	no	no	INTJ
cblr-1208	55	2	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	56	1	1:45	1:45	NUM
cblr-1208	56	2	]	]	PUNCT
cblr-1208	56	3	commentary	commentary	NOUN
cblr-1208	56	4	:	:	PUNCT
cblr-1208	56	5	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	56	6	rule	rule	NOUN
cblr-1208	56	7	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	56	8	reason	reason	NOUN
cblr-1208	56	9	49	49	NUM
cblr-1208	56	10	approval	approval	NOUN
cblr-1208	56	11	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	56	12	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	56	13	anda	anda	NOUN
cblr-1208	56	14	for	for	ADP
cblr-1208	56	15	thirty	thirty	NUM
cblr-1208	56	16	months	month	NOUN
cblr-1208	56	17	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	56	18	allow	allow	VERB
cblr-1208	56	19	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	56	20	infringement	infringement	NOUN
cblr-1208	56	21	action	action	NOUN
cblr-1208	56	22	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-1208	56	23	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	56	24	paragraph	paragraph	NOUN
cblr-1208	56	25	iv	iv	NUM
cblr-1208	56	26	litigation	litigation	NOUN
cblr-1208	56	27	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-1208	56	28	to	to	ADP
cblr-1208	56	29	proceed.11	proceed.11	NOUN
cblr-1208	56	30	typically	typically	ADV
cblr-1208	56	31	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	56	32	because	because	SCONJ
cblr-1208	56	33	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	56	34	generic	generic	ADJ
cblr-1208	56	35	manufacturer	manufacturer	NOUN
cblr-1208	56	36	that	that	PRON
cblr-1208	56	37	files	file	VERB
cblr-1208	56	38	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	56	39	paragraph	paragraph	NOUN
cblr-1208	56	40	iv	iv	NUM
cblr-1208	56	41	certification	certification	NOUN
cblr-1208	56	42	has	have	VERB
cblr-1208	56	43	yet	yet	ADV
cblr-1208	56	44	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	56	45	enter	enter	VERB
cblr-1208	56	46	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	56	47	market	market	NOUN
cblr-1208	56	48	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	56	49	it	it	PRON
cblr-1208	56	50	can	can	AUX
cblr-1208	56	51	not	not	PART
cblr-1208	56	52	be	be	AUX
cblr-1208	56	53	liable	liable	ADJ
cblr-1208	56	54	for	for	ADP
cblr-1208	56	55	patent	patent	NOUN
cblr-1208	56	56	infringement	infringement	NOUN
cblr-1208	56	57	damages.12	damages.12	PROPN
cblr-1208	56	58	thus	thus	ADV
cblr-1208	56	59	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	56	60	unlike	unlike	ADP
cblr-1208	56	61	traditional	traditional	ADJ
cblr-1208	56	62	patent	patent	NOUN
cblr-1208	56	63	litigation	litigation	NOUN
cblr-1208	56	64	between	between	ADP
cblr-1208	56	65	patent	patent	NOUN
cblr-1208	56	66	owners	owner	NOUN
cblr-1208	56	67	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	56	68	infringers	infringer	NOUN
cblr-1208	56	69	—	—	PUNCT
cblr-1208	56	70	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	56	71	which	which	PRON
cblr-1208	56	72	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	56	73	infringer	infringer	NOUN
cblr-1208	56	74	runs	run	VERB
cblr-1208	56	75	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	56	76	risk	risk	NOUN
cblr-1208	56	77	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	56	78	removal	removal	NOUN
cblr-1208	56	79	from	from	ADP
cblr-1208	56	80	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	56	81	market	market	NOUN
cblr-1208	56	82	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	56	83	incurring	incur	VERB
cblr-1208	56	84	damages	damage	NOUN
cblr-1208	56	85	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-1208	56	86	for	for	ADP
cblr-1208	56	87	past	past	ADJ
cblr-1208	56	88	infringement	infringement	NOUN
cblr-1208	56	89	—	—	PUNCT
cblr-1208	56	90	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	56	91	only	only	ADJ
cblr-1208	56	92	economic	economic	ADJ
cblr-1208	56	93	risks	risk	NOUN
cblr-1208	56	94	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	56	95	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	56	96	first	first	ADJ
cblr-1208	56	97	filing	file	VERB
cblr-1208	56	98	generic	generic	ADJ
cblr-1208	56	99	manufacturer	manufacturer	NOUN
cblr-1208	56	100	runs	run	VERB
cblr-1208	56	101	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	56	102	litigating	litigating	NOUN
cblr-1208	56	103	are	be	AUX
cblr-1208	56	104	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	56	105	cost	cost	NOUN
cblr-1208	56	106	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	56	107	litigation	litigation	NOUN
cblr-1208	56	108	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	56	109	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	56	110	opportunity	opportunity	NOUN
cblr-1208	56	111	cost	cost	NOUN
cblr-1208	56	112	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	56	113	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	56	114	180	180	NUM
cblr-1208	56	115	days	day	NOUN
cblr-1208	56	116	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	56	117	exclusive	exclusive	ADJ
cblr-1208	56	118	generic	generic	ADJ
cblr-1208	56	119	sales	sale	NOUN
cblr-1208	56	120	it	it	PRON
cblr-1208	56	121	can	can	AUX
cblr-1208	56	122	not	not	PART
cblr-1208	56	123	make	make	VERB
cblr-1208	56	124	if	if	SCONJ
cblr-1208	56	125	it	it	PRON
cblr-1208	56	126	loses	lose	VERB
cblr-1208	56	127	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	57	1	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	57	2	contrast	contrast	NOUN
cblr-1208	57	3	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	57	4	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	57	5	brand	brand	NOUN
cblr-1208	57	6	manufacturer	manufacturer	NOUN
cblr-1208	57	7	faces	face	VERB
cblr-1208	57	8	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	57	9	risk	risk	NOUN
cblr-1208	57	10	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	57	11	its	its	PRON
cblr-1208	57	12	patent	patent	NOUN
cblr-1208	57	13	is	be	AUX
cblr-1208	57	14	held	hold	VERB
cblr-1208	57	15	invalid	invalid	ADJ
cblr-1208	57	16	or	or	CCONJ
cblr-1208	57	17	non	non	ADJ
cblr-1208	57	18	-	-	ADJ
cblr-1208	57	19	infringed	infringe	VERB
cblr-1208	57	20	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	57	21	which	which	PRON
cblr-1208	57	22	costs	cost	VERB
cblr-1208	57	23	it	it	PRON
cblr-1208	57	24	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	57	25	market	market	NOUN
cblr-1208	57	26	exclusivity	exclusivity	NOUN
cblr-1208	57	27	that	that	PRON
cblr-1208	57	28	comes	come	VERB
cblr-1208	57	29	with	with	ADP
cblr-1208	57	30	owning	own	VERB
cblr-1208	57	31	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	57	32	valid	valid	ADJ
cblr-1208	57	33	patent	patent	NOUN
cblr-1208	57	34	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	58	1	as	as	ADP
cblr-1208	58	2	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	58	3	result	result	NOUN
cblr-1208	58	4	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	58	5	while	while	SCONJ
cblr-1208	58	6	all	all	DET
cblr-1208	58	7	settlements	settlement	NOUN
cblr-1208	58	8	involve	involve	VERB
cblr-1208	58	9	consideration	consideration	NOUN
cblr-1208	58	10	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	58	11	some	some	DET
cblr-1208	58	12	sort	sort	NOUN
cblr-1208	58	13	flowing	flow	VERB
cblr-1208	58	14	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	58	15	both	both	DET
cblr-1208	58	16	directions	direction	NOUN
cblr-1208	58	17	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	58	18	paragraph	paragraph	NOUN
cblr-1208	58	19	iv	iv	NUM
cblr-1208	58	20	litigation	litigation	NOUN
cblr-1208	58	21	settlements	settlement	NOUN
cblr-1208	58	22	for	for	ADP
cblr-1208	58	23	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	58	24	number	number	NOUN
cblr-1208	58	25	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	58	26	years	year	NOUN
cblr-1208	58	27	often	often	ADV
cblr-1208	58	28	included	include	VERB
cblr-1208	58	29	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	58	30	substantial	substantial	ADJ
cblr-1208	58	31	cash	cash	NOUN
cblr-1208	58	32	payment	payment	NOUN
cblr-1208	58	33	by	by	ADP
cblr-1208	58	34	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
cblr-1208	58	35	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-1208	58	36	brand	brand	NOUN
cblr-1208	58	37	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-1208	58	38	name	name	NOUN
cblr-1208	58	39	manufacturer	manufacturer	NOUN
cblr-1208	58	40	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-1208	58	41	to	to	ADP
cblr-1208	58	42	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	58	43	alleged	allege	VERB
cblr-1208	58	44	infringer	infringer	NOUN
cblr-1208	58	45	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-1208	58	46	generic	generic	ADJ
cblr-1208	58	47	manufacturer	manufacturer	NOUN
cblr-1208	58	48	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-1208	58	49	as	as	ADP
cblr-1208	58	50	part	part	NOUN
cblr-1208	58	51	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	58	52	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	58	53	settlement.13	settlement.13	NOUN
cblr-1208	58	54	because	because	SCONJ
cblr-1208	58	55	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	58	56	11	11	NUM
cblr-1208	58	57	see	see	VERB
cblr-1208	58	58	21	21	NUM
cblr-1208	58	59	u.s.c	u.s.c	ADJ
cblr-1208	58	60	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	59	1	§	§	PROPN
cblr-1208	59	2	355(j)(5)(b)(iii	355(j)(5)(b)(iii	PROPN
cblr-1208	59	3	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-1208	59	4	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	60	1	12	12	NUM
cblr-1208	60	2	see	see	VERB
cblr-1208	60	3	gerald	gerald	PROPN
cblr-1208	60	4	sobel	sobel	PROPN
cblr-1208	60	5	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	60	6	consideration	consideration	NOUN
cblr-1208	60	7	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	60	8	patent	patent	NOUN
cblr-1208	60	9	validity	validity	NOUN
cblr-1208	60	10	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	60	11	antitrust	antitrust	ADJ
cblr-1208	60	12	cases	case	NOUN
cblr-1208	60	13	challenging	challenge	VERB
cblr-1208	60	14	hatch	hatch	NOUN
cblr-1208	60	15	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-1208	60	16	waxman	waxman	PROPN
cblr-1208	60	17	act	act	PROPN
cblr-1208	60	18	settlements	settlement	NOUN
cblr-1208	60	19	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	60	20	20	20	NUM
cblr-1208	60	21	fed	fed	PROPN
cblr-1208	60	22	cir	cir	NOUN
cblr-1208	60	23	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	61	1	b.j	b.j	PROPN
cblr-1208	61	2	.	.	PROPN
cblr-1208	61	3	47	47	NUM
cblr-1208	61	4	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	61	5	51	51	NUM
cblr-1208	61	6	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-1208	61	7	2010	2010	NUM
cblr-1208	61	8	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-1208	61	9	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-1208	61	10	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	61	11	unlike	unlike	ADP
cblr-1208	61	12	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	61	13	usual	usual	ADJ
cblr-1208	61	14	patent	patent	NOUN
cblr-1208	61	15	case	case	NOUN
cblr-1208	61	16	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	61	17	there	there	PRON
cblr-1208	61	18	are	be	VERB
cblr-1208	61	19	ordinarily	ordinarily	ADV
cblr-1208	61	20	no	no	DET
cblr-1208	61	21	damages	damage	NOUN
cblr-1208	61	22	claims	claim	NOUN
cblr-1208	61	23	against	against	ADP
cblr-1208	61	24	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	61	25	generic	generic	ADJ
cblr-1208	61	26	because	because	SCONJ
cblr-1208	61	27	hatch	hatch	NOUN
cblr-1208	61	28	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-1208	61	29	waxman	waxman	NOUN
cblr-1208	61	30	forces	force	VERB
cblr-1208	61	31	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	61	32	litigation	litigation	NOUN
cblr-1208	61	33	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	61	34	occur	occur	VERB
cblr-1208	61	35	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	61	36	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	61	37	period	period	NOUN
cblr-1208	61	38	prior	prior	ADV
cblr-1208	61	39	to	to	ADP
cblr-1208	61	40	marketing	marketing	NOUN
cblr-1208	61	41	by	by	ADP
cblr-1208	61	42	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	61	43	generic	generic	ADJ
cblr-1208	61	44	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	62	1	as	as	ADP
cblr-1208	62	2	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	62	3	result	result	NOUN
cblr-1208	62	4	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	62	5	no	no	DET
cblr-1208	62	6	sales	sale	NOUN
cblr-1208	62	7	or	or	CCONJ
cblr-1208	62	8	profits	profit	NOUN
cblr-1208	62	9	are	be	AUX
cblr-1208	62	10	lost	lose	VERB
cblr-1208	62	11	by	by	ADP
cblr-1208	62	12	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	62	13	patentee	patentee	NOUN
cblr-1208	62	14	to	to	ADP
cblr-1208	62	15	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	62	16	generic	generic	ADJ
cblr-1208	62	17	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	63	1	while	while	SCONJ
cblr-1208	63	2	patent	patent	NOUN
cblr-1208	63	3	infringement	infringement	NOUN
cblr-1208	63	4	suits	suit	NOUN
cblr-1208	63	5	are	be	AUX
cblr-1208	63	6	often	often	ADV
cblr-1208	63	7	settled	settle	VERB
cblr-1208	63	8	by	by	ADP
cblr-1208	63	9	compromise	compromise	NOUN
cblr-1208	63	10	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	63	11	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	63	12	damages	damage	NOUN
cblr-1208	63	13	claim	claim	NOUN
cblr-1208	63	14	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	63	15	that	that	DET
cblr-1208	63	16	vehicle	vehicle	NOUN
cblr-1208	63	17	is	be	AUX
cblr-1208	63	18	typically	typically	ADV
cblr-1208	63	19	not	not	PART
cblr-1208	63	20	available	available	ADJ
cblr-1208	63	21	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	63	22	hatch	hatch	NOUN
cblr-1208	63	23	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-1208	63	24	waxman	waxman	NOUN
cblr-1208	63	25	cases	case	NOUN
cblr-1208	63	26	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	63	27	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	63	28	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-1208	63	29	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	64	1	13	13	NUM
cblr-1208	64	2	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	64	3	course	course	NOUN
cblr-1208	64	4	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	64	5	as	as	SCONJ
cblr-1208	64	6	many	many	ADJ
cblr-1208	64	7	have	have	AUX
cblr-1208	64	8	observed	observe	VERB
cblr-1208	64	9	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	64	10	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	64	11	any	any	DET
cblr-1208	64	12	settlement	settlement	NOUN
cblr-1208	64	13	agreement	agreement	NOUN
cblr-1208	64	14	can	can	AUX
cblr-1208	64	15	be	be	AUX
cblr-1208	64	16	characterized	characterize	VERB
cblr-1208	64	17	as	as	ADP
cblr-1208	64	18	involving	involve	VERB
cblr-1208	64	19	‘	'	PUNCT
cblr-1208	64	20	compensation	compensation	NOUN
cblr-1208	64	21	’	'	PUNCT
cblr-1208	64	22	to	to	ADP
cblr-1208	64	23	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	64	24	defendant	defendant	NOUN
cblr-1208	64	25	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	64	26	who	who	PRON
cblr-1208	64	27	would	would	AUX
cblr-1208	64	28	not	not	PART
cblr-1208	64	29	settle	settle	VERB
cblr-1208	64	30	unless	unless	SCONJ
cblr-1208	64	31	he	he	PRON
cblr-1208	64	32	had	have	VERB
cblr-1208	64	33	something	something	PRON
cblr-1208	64	34	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	64	35	show	show	VERB
cblr-1208	64	36	for	for	ADP
cblr-1208	64	37	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	64	38	settlement	settlement	NOUN
cblr-1208	64	39	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	64	40	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	65	1	asahi	asahi	PROPN
cblr-1208	65	2	glass	glass	PROPN
cblr-1208	65	3	co.	co.	PROPN
cblr-1208	65	4	v.	v.	ADP
cblr-1208	65	5	pentech	pentech	NOUN
cblr-1208	65	6	pharms	pharm	NOUN
cblr-1208	65	7	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	65	8	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	65	9	inc	inc	PROPN
cblr-1208	65	10	.	.	PROPN
cblr-1208	65	11	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	65	12	289	289	NUM
cblr-1208	65	13	f.	f.	PROPN
cblr-1208	65	14	supp	supp	PROPN
cblr-1208	65	15	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	66	1	2d	2d	PROPN
cblr-1208	66	2	986	986	NUM
cblr-1208	66	3	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	66	4	994	994	NUM
cblr-1208	66	5	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-1208	66	6	2003	2003	NUM
cblr-1208	66	7	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-1208	66	8	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	67	1	for	for	ADP
cblr-1208	67	2	example	example	NOUN
cblr-1208	67	3	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	67	4	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	67	5	traditional	traditional	ADJ
cblr-1208	67	6	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	67	7	patent	patent	NOUN
cblr-1208	67	8	infringement	infringement	NOUN
cblr-1208	67	9	cases	case	NOUN
cblr-1208	67	10	involving	involve	VERB
cblr-1208	67	11	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	67	12	wide	wide	ADJ
cblr-1208	67	13	variety	variety	NOUN
cblr-1208	67	14	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	67	15	products	product	NOUN
cblr-1208	67	16	have	have	AUX
cblr-1208	67	17	been	be	AUX
cblr-1208	67	18	settled	settle	VERB
cblr-1208	67	19	on	on	ADP
cblr-1208	67	20	terms	term	NOUN
cblr-1208	67	21	that	that	PRON
cblr-1208	67	22	include	include	VERB
cblr-1208	67	23	forgiveness	forgiveness	NOUN
cblr-1208	67	24	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	67	25	some	some	PRON
cblr-1208	67	26	or	or	CCONJ
cblr-1208	67	27	all	all	PRON
cblr-1208	67	28	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	67	29	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	67	30	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-1208	67	31	for	for	ADP
cblr-1208	67	32	past	past	ADJ
cblr-1208	67	33	infringement	infringement	NOUN
cblr-1208	67	34	damages	damage	NOUN
cblr-1208	67	35	alongside	alongside	ADP
cblr-1208	67	36	provisions	provision	NOUN
cblr-1208	67	37	for	for	ADP
cblr-1208	67	38	withdrawal	withdrawal	NOUN
cblr-1208	67	39	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	67	40	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	67	41	infringing	infringe	VERB
cblr-1208	67	42	product	product	NOUN
cblr-1208	67	43	from	from	ADP
cblr-1208	67	44	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	67	45	market	market	NOUN
cblr-1208	67	46	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	67	47	acknowledgments	acknowledgment	NOUN
cblr-1208	67	48	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	67	49	validity	validity	NOUN
cblr-1208	67	50	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	67	51	enforceability	enforceability	NOUN
cblr-1208	67	52	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	67	53	infringement	infringement	NOUN
cblr-1208	67	54	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	67	55	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	67	56	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	67	57	transfer	transfer	NOUN
cblr-1208	67	58	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	67	59	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	67	60	value	value	NOUN
cblr-1208	67	61	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	67	62	from	from	ADP
cblr-1208	67	63	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	67	64	patent	patent	NOUN
cblr-1208	67	65	owner	owner	NOUN
cblr-1208	67	66	to	to	ADP
cblr-1208	67	67	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	67	68	infringer	infringer	NOUN
cblr-1208	67	69	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	67	70	facilitate	facilitate	VERB
cblr-1208	67	71	reaching	reach	VERB
cblr-1208	67	72	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	67	73	settlement	settlement	NOUN
cblr-1208	67	74	agreement	agreement	NOUN
cblr-1208	67	75	that	that	PRON
cblr-1208	67	76	lecture_commentary_final	lecture_commentary_final	PROPN
cblr-1208	67	77	50	50	NUM
cblr-1208	67	78	columbia	columbia	PROPN
cblr-1208	67	79	business	business	NOUN
cblr-1208	67	80	law	law	NOUN
cblr-1208	67	81	review	review	NOUN
cblr-1208	68	1	[	[	X
cblr-1208	68	2	vol	vol	NOUN
cblr-1208	68	3	.	.	NOUN
cblr-1208	68	4	2018	2018	NUM
cblr-1208	68	5	traditional	traditional	ADJ
cblr-1208	68	6	patent	patent	NOUN
cblr-1208	68	7	litigation	litigation	NOUN
cblr-1208	68	8	cash	cash	NOUN
cblr-1208	68	9	ordinarily	ordinarily	ADV
cblr-1208	68	10	flows	flow	VERB
cblr-1208	68	11	from	from	ADP
cblr-1208	68	12	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	68	13	alleged	alleged	ADJ
cblr-1208	68	14	infringer	infringer	NOUN
cblr-1208	68	15	to	to	ADP
cblr-1208	68	16	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	68	17	patent	patent	NOUN
cblr-1208	68	18	owner	owner	NOUN
cblr-1208	68	19	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	68	20	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	68	21	consideration	consideration	NOUN
cblr-1208	68	22	that	that	PRON
cblr-1208	68	23	flows	flow	VERB
cblr-1208	68	24	from	from	ADP
cblr-1208	68	25	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	68	26	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
cblr-1208	68	27	to	to	ADP
cblr-1208	68	28	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	68	29	defendant	defendant	NOUN
cblr-1208	68	30	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	68	31	such	such	ADJ
cblr-1208	68	32	paragraph	paragraph	NOUN
cblr-1208	68	33	iv	iv	NUM
cblr-1208	68	34	litigation	litigation	NOUN
cblr-1208	68	35	settlements	settlement	NOUN
cblr-1208	68	36	came	come	VERB
cblr-1208	68	37	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	68	38	be	be	AUX
cblr-1208	68	39	called	call	VERB
cblr-1208	68	40	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	68	41	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	68	42	reverse	reverse	ADJ
cblr-1208	68	43	payment	payment	NOUN
cblr-1208	68	44	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	69	1	”14	”14	NOUN
cblr-1208	69	2	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	69	3	actavis	actavis	PROPN
cblr-1208	69	4	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	69	5	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	69	6	supreme	supreme	PROPN
cblr-1208	69	7	court	court	PROPN
cblr-1208	69	8	resolved	resolve	VERB
cblr-1208	69	9	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	69	10	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-1208	69	11	split	split	NOUN
cblr-1208	69	12	regarding	regard	VERB
cblr-1208	69	13	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	69	14	level	level	NOUN
cblr-1208	69	15	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	69	16	antitrust	antitrust	ADJ
cblr-1208	69	17	scrutiny	scrutiny	NOUN
cblr-1208	69	18	that	that	PRON
cblr-1208	69	19	lower	low	ADJ
cblr-1208	69	20	courts	court	NOUN
cblr-1208	69	21	should	should	AUX
cblr-1208	69	22	apply	apply	VERB
cblr-1208	69	23	to	to	ADP
cblr-1208	69	24	settlements	settlement	NOUN
cblr-1208	69	25	involving	involve	VERB
cblr-1208	69	26	alleged	allege	VERB
cblr-1208	69	27	reverse	reverse	ADJ
cblr-1208	69	28	payments	payment	NOUN
cblr-1208	69	29	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	70	1	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	70	2	eleventh	eleventh	ADJ
cblr-1208	70	3	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-1208	70	4	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-1208	70	5	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	70	6	others	other	NOUN
cblr-1208	70	7	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-1208	70	8	had	have	AUX
cblr-1208	70	9	applied	apply	VERB
cblr-1208	70	10	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	70	11	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	70	12	scope	scope	NOUN
cblr-1208	70	13	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	70	14	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	70	15	patent	patent	NOUN
cblr-1208	70	16	test	test	NOUN
cblr-1208	70	17	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	70	18	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	70	19	holding	hold	VERB
cblr-1208	70	20	that	that	PRON
cblr-1208	70	21	reverse	reverse	VERB
cblr-1208	70	22	payment	payment	NOUN
cblr-1208	70	23	settlements	settlement	NOUN
cblr-1208	70	24	are	be	AUX
cblr-1208	70	25	lawful	lawful	ADJ
cblr-1208	70	26	so	so	ADV
cblr-1208	70	27	long	long	ADV
cblr-1208	70	28	as	as	SCONJ
cblr-1208	70	29	they	they	PRON
cblr-1208	70	30	do	do	AUX
cblr-1208	70	31	not	not	PART
cblr-1208	70	32	restrain	restrain	VERB
cblr-1208	70	33	trade	trade	NOUN
cblr-1208	70	34	beyond	beyond	ADP
cblr-1208	70	35	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	70	36	legitimate	legitimate	ADJ
cblr-1208	70	37	scope	scope	NOUN
cblr-1208	70	38	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	70	39	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	70	40	patent	patent	NOUN
cblr-1208	70	41	’s	’s	PART
cblr-1208	70	42	exclusionary	exclusionary	ADJ
cblr-1208	70	43	potential.15	potential.15	NOUN
cblr-1208	70	44	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	70	45	third	third	ADJ
cblr-1208	70	46	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-1208	70	47	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	70	48	meanwhile	meanwhile	ADV
cblr-1208	70	49	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	70	50	applied	apply	VERB
cblr-1208	70	51	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	70	52	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	70	53	quick	quick	ADJ
cblr-1208	70	54	look	look	NOUN
cblr-1208	70	55	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	70	56	test	test	NOUN
cblr-1208	70	57	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	71	1	under	under	ADP
cblr-1208	71	2	that	that	DET
cblr-1208	71	3	test	test	NOUN
cblr-1208	71	4	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	71	5	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	71	6	reverse	reverse	ADJ
cblr-1208	71	7	payment	payment	NOUN
cblr-1208	71	8	settlement	settlement	NOUN
cblr-1208	71	9	is	be	AUX
cblr-1208	71	10	prima	prima	NOUN
cblr-1208	71	11	facie	facie	NOUN
cblr-1208	71	12	evidence	evidence	NOUN
cblr-1208	71	13	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	71	14	an	an	DET
cblr-1208	71	15	unreasonable	unreasonable	ADJ
cblr-1208	71	16	restraint	restraint	NOUN
cblr-1208	71	17	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	71	18	trade	trade	NOUN
cblr-1208	71	19	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	71	20	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	71	21	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	71	22	defendant	defendant	NOUN
cblr-1208	71	23	has	have	VERB
cblr-1208	71	24	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	71	25	burden	burden	NOUN
cblr-1208	71	26	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	71	27	showing	show	VERB
cblr-1208	71	28	procompetitive	procompetitive	ADJ
cblr-1208	71	29	justifications	justification	NOUN
cblr-1208	71	30	for	for	ADP
cblr-1208	71	31	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	71	32	settlement	settlement	NOUN
cblr-1208	71	33	agreement.16	agreement.16	PROPN
cblr-1208	71	34	both	both	PRON
cblr-1208	71	35	terminates	terminate	VERB
cblr-1208	71	36	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	71	37	challenge	challenge	NOUN
cblr-1208	71	38	to	to	ADP
cblr-1208	71	39	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	71	40	patent	patent	NOUN
cblr-1208	71	41	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	71	42	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	71	43	often	often	ADV
cblr-1208	71	44	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	71	45	results	result	NOUN
cblr-1208	71	46	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	71	47	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	71	48	generic	generic	ADJ
cblr-1208	71	49	exiting	exit	VERB
cblr-1208	71	50	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	71	51	market	market	NOUN
cblr-1208	71	52	or	or	CCONJ
cblr-1208	71	53	agreeing	agree	VERB
cblr-1208	71	54	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	71	55	pay	pay	VERB
cblr-1208	71	56	future	future	ADJ
cblr-1208	71	57	royalties	royalty	NOUN
cblr-1208	71	58	to	to	ADP
cblr-1208	71	59	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	71	60	patentee	patentee	NOUN
cblr-1208	71	61	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	72	1	14	14	NUM
cblr-1208	72	2	ftc	ftc	PROPN
cblr-1208	72	3	v.	v.	ADP
cblr-1208	72	4	actavis	actavis	PROPN
cblr-1208	72	5	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	72	6	133	133	NUM
cblr-1208	72	7	s.	s.	PROPN
cblr-1208	72	8	ct	ct	PROPN
cblr-1208	72	9	.	.	PROPN
cblr-1208	72	10	2223	2223	NUM
cblr-1208	72	11	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	72	12	2227	2227	NUM
cblr-1208	72	13	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-1208	72	14	2013	2013	NUM
cblr-1208	72	15	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-1208	72	16	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	73	1	15	15	NUM
cblr-1208	73	2	ftc	ftc	PROPN
cblr-1208	73	3	v.	v.	PROPN
cblr-1208	73	4	watson	watson	PROPN
cblr-1208	73	5	pharmaceuticals	pharmaceuticals	PROPN
cblr-1208	73	6	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	73	7	677	677	NUM
cblr-1208	73	8	f.3d	f.3d	NUM
cblr-1208	73	9	1298	1298	NUM
cblr-1208	73	10	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	73	11	1312	1312	NUM
cblr-1208	73	12	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-1208	73	13	11th	11th	ADJ
cblr-1208	73	14	cir	cir	NOUN
cblr-1208	73	15	.	.	PROPN
cblr-1208	73	16	2012	2012	NUM
cblr-1208	73	17	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-1208	73	18	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	74	1	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	74	2	eleventh	eleventh	ADJ
cblr-1208	74	3	circuit	circuit	PROPN
cblr-1208	74	4	’s	’s	PART
cblr-1208	74	5	view	view	NOUN
cblr-1208	74	6	arguably	arguably	ADV
cblr-1208	74	7	recognizes	recognize	VERB
cblr-1208	74	8	—	—	PUNCT
cblr-1208	74	9	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	74	10	patent	patent	NOUN
cblr-1208	74	11	language	language	NOUN
cblr-1208	74	12	—	—	PUNCT
cblr-1208	74	13	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	74	14	fact	fact	NOUN
cblr-1208	74	15	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	74	16	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	74	17	settlement	settlement	NOUN
cblr-1208	74	18	agreement	agreement	NOUN
cblr-1208	74	19	removes	remove	VERB
cblr-1208	74	20	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-1208	74	21	for	for	ADP
cblr-1208	74	22	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	74	23	generic	generic	ADJ
cblr-1208	74	24	manufacturer	manufacturer	NOUN
cblr-1208	74	25	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	74	26	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	74	27	market	market	NOUN
cblr-1208	74	28	as	as	ADP
cblr-1208	74	29	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	74	30	whole	whole	NOUN
cblr-1208	74	31	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-1208	74	32	an	an	DET
cblr-1208	74	33	existing	exist	VERB
cblr-1208	74	34	barrier	barrier	NOUN
cblr-1208	74	35	to	to	ADP
cblr-1208	74	36	entry	entry	NOUN
cblr-1208	74	37	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	74	38	one	one	NOUN
cblr-1208	74	39	can	can	AUX
cblr-1208	74	40	not	not	PART
cblr-1208	74	41	be	be	AUX
cblr-1208	74	42	certain	certain	ADJ
cblr-1208	74	43	would	would	AUX
cblr-1208	74	44	have	have	AUX
cblr-1208	74	45	been	be	AUX
cblr-1208	74	46	lifted	lift	VERB
cblr-1208	74	47	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	74	48	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	74	49	absence	absence	NOUN
cblr-1208	74	50	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	74	51	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	74	52	settlement	settlement	NOUN
cblr-1208	74	53	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	75	1	lifting	lift	VERB
cblr-1208	75	2	that	that	DET
cblr-1208	75	3	veil	veil	NOUN
cblr-1208	75	4	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	75	5	uncertainty	uncertainty	NOUN
cblr-1208	75	6	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	75	7	assuring	assure	VERB
cblr-1208	75	8	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	75	9	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	75	10	generic	generic	NOUN
cblr-1208	75	11	can	can	AUX
cblr-1208	75	12	enter	enter	VERB
cblr-1208	75	13	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	75	14	market	market	NOUN
cblr-1208	75	15	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-1208	75	16	barring	bar	VERB
cblr-1208	75	17	other	other	ADJ
cblr-1208	75	18	obstacles	obstacle	NOUN
cblr-1208	75	19	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-1208	75	20	is	be	AUX
cblr-1208	75	21	inherently	inherently	ADV
cblr-1208	75	22	procompetitive	procompetitive	ADJ
cblr-1208	75	23	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	76	1	there	there	PRON
cblr-1208	76	2	is	be	VERB
cblr-1208	76	3	no	no	DET
cblr-1208	76	4	principle	principle	NOUN
cblr-1208	76	5	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	76	6	antitrust	antitrust	ADJ
cblr-1208	76	7	law	law	NOUN
cblr-1208	76	8	that	that	PRON
cblr-1208	76	9	requires	require	VERB
cblr-1208	76	10	parties	party	NOUN
cblr-1208	76	11	entering	enter	VERB
cblr-1208	76	12	into	into	ADP
cblr-1208	76	13	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	76	14	procompetitive	procompetitive	ADJ
cblr-1208	76	15	agreement	agreement	NOUN
cblr-1208	76	16	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	76	17	negotiate	negotiate	VERB
cblr-1208	76	18	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	76	19	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	76	20	most	most	ADV
cblr-1208	76	21	procompetitive	procompetitive	ADJ
cblr-1208	76	22	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	76	23	agreement	agreement	NOUN
cblr-1208	76	24	possible	possible	ADJ
cblr-1208	76	25	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	77	1	see	see	VERB
cblr-1208	77	2	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	77	3	e.g.	e.g.	ADV
cblr-1208	77	4	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	77	5	king	king	PROPN
cblr-1208	77	6	drug	drug	PROPN
cblr-1208	77	7	co.	co.	PROPN
cblr-1208	77	8	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	77	9	florence	florence	PROPN
cblr-1208	77	10	v.	v.	ADP
cblr-1208	77	11	smithkline	smithkline	PROPN
cblr-1208	77	12	beecham	beecham	PROPN
cblr-1208	77	13	corp	corp	PROPN
cblr-1208	77	14	.	.	PROPN
cblr-1208	77	15	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	77	16	791	791	NUM
cblr-1208	77	17	f.3d	f.3d	NUM
cblr-1208	77	18	388	388	NUM
cblr-1208	77	19	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	77	20	408–09	408–09	NUM
cblr-1208	77	21	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-1208	77	22	3d	3d	PROPN
cblr-1208	77	23	cir	cir	NOUN
cblr-1208	77	24	.	.	PROPN
cblr-1208	77	25	2015	2015	NUM
cblr-1208	77	26	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-1208	77	27	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	78	1	as	as	ADP
cblr-1208	78	2	such	such	ADJ
cblr-1208	78	3	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	78	4	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	78	5	eleventh	eleventh	ADJ
cblr-1208	78	6	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-1208	78	7	’s	’s	PART
cblr-1208	78	8	refusal	refusal	NOUN
cblr-1208	78	9	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	78	10	examine	examine	VERB
cblr-1208	78	11	whether	whether	SCONJ
cblr-1208	78	12	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	78	13	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	78	14	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	78	15	absence	absence	NOUN
cblr-1208	78	16	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	78	17	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	78	18	payment	payment	NOUN
cblr-1208	78	19	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	78	20	parties	party	NOUN
cblr-1208	78	21	might	might	AUX
cblr-1208	78	22	have	have	AUX
cblr-1208	78	23	agreed	agree	VERB
cblr-1208	78	24	to	to	ADP
cblr-1208	78	25	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	78	26	different	different	ADJ
cblr-1208	78	27	entry	entry	NOUN
cblr-1208	78	28	date	date	NOUN
cblr-1208	78	29	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	78	30	or	or	CCONJ
cblr-1208	78	31	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	78	32	allow	allow	VERB
cblr-1208	78	33	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	78	34	federal	federal	PROPN
cblr-1208	78	35	trade	trade	PROPN
cblr-1208	78	36	commission	commission	PROPN
cblr-1208	78	37	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-1208	78	38	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	78	39	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	78	40	ftc	ftc	PROPN
cblr-1208	78	41	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	78	42	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-1208	78	43	or	or	CCONJ
cblr-1208	78	44	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
cblr-1208	78	45	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	78	46	speculate	speculate	VERB
cblr-1208	78	47	as	as	ADP
cblr-1208	78	48	to	to	ADP
cblr-1208	78	49	what	what	PRON
cblr-1208	78	50	an	an	DET
cblr-1208	78	51	optimal	optimal	ADJ
cblr-1208	78	52	entry	entry	NOUN
cblr-1208	78	53	date	date	NOUN
cblr-1208	78	54	would	would	AUX
cblr-1208	78	55	have	have	AUX
cblr-1208	78	56	been	be	AUX
cblr-1208	78	57	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	78	58	made	make	VERB
cblr-1208	78	59	antitrust	antitrust	ADJ
cblr-1208	78	60	sense	sense	NOUN
cblr-1208	78	61	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	79	1	16	16	NUM
cblr-1208	79	2	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	79	3	re	re	NOUN
cblr-1208	79	4	k	k	X
cblr-1208	79	5	-	-	ADJ
cblr-1208	79	6	dur	dur	ADJ
cblr-1208	79	7	antitrust	antitrust	ADJ
cblr-1208	79	8	litig	litig	NOUN
cblr-1208	79	9	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	80	1	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	80	2	686	686	NUM
cblr-1208	80	3	f.3d	f.3d	NUM
cblr-1208	80	4	197	197	NUM
cblr-1208	80	5	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	80	6	218	218	NUM
cblr-1208	80	7	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-1208	80	8	3d	3d	PROPN
cblr-1208	80	9	cir	cir	NOUN
cblr-1208	80	10	.	.	PROPN
cblr-1208	80	11	2012	2012	NUM
cblr-1208	80	12	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-1208	80	13	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	80	14	vacated	vacate	VERB
cblr-1208	80	15	sub	sub	PROPN
cblr-1208	80	16	nom	nom	PROPN
cblr-1208	80	17	.	.	PROPN
cblr-1208	80	18	merck	merck	PROPN
cblr-1208	80	19	&	&	CCONJ
cblr-1208	80	20	co.	co.	PROPN
cblr-1208	80	21	v.	v.	ADP
cblr-1208	80	22	la	la	PROPN
cblr-1208	80	23	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	80	24	wholesale	wholesale	PROPN
cblr-1208	80	25	drug	drug	PROPN
cblr-1208	80	26	co.	co.	PROPN
cblr-1208	80	27	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	80	28	133	133	NUM
cblr-1208	80	29	s.	s.	PROPN
cblr-1208	80	30	ct	ct	PROPN
cblr-1208	80	31	.	.	PROPN
cblr-1208	80	32	2849	2849	NUM
cblr-1208	80	33	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-1208	80	34	2013	2013	NUM
cblr-1208	80	35	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-1208	80	36	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	81	1	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	81	2	third	third	ADJ
cblr-1208	81	3	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-1208	81	4	’s	’s	PART
cblr-1208	81	5	approach	approach	NOUN
cblr-1208	81	6	arguably	arguably	ADV
cblr-1208	81	7	ignores	ignore	VERB
cblr-1208	81	8	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	81	9	benefits	benefit	NOUN
cblr-1208	81	10	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	81	11	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	81	12	settlement	settlement	NOUN
cblr-1208	81	13	agreement	agreement	NOUN
cblr-1208	81	14	as	as	ADP
cblr-1208	81	15	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	81	16	whole	whole	NOUN
cblr-1208	81	17	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	81	18	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	81	19	simply	simply	ADV
cblr-1208	81	20	assumes	assume	VERB
cblr-1208	81	21	either	either	CCONJ
cblr-1208	81	22	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	81	23	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-1208	81	24	i	i	NOUN
cblr-1208	81	25	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-1208	81	26	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	81	27	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	81	28	absence	absence	NOUN
cblr-1208	81	29	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	81	30	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	81	31	payment	payment	NOUN
cblr-1208	81	32	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	81	33	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	81	34	parties	party	NOUN
cblr-1208	81	35	would	would	AUX
cblr-1208	81	36	have	have	AUX
cblr-1208	81	37	agreed	agree	VERB
cblr-1208	81	38	to	to	ADP
cblr-1208	81	39	an	an	DET
cblr-1208	81	40	earlier	early	ADJ
cblr-1208	81	41	entry	entry	NOUN
cblr-1208	81	42	date	date	NOUN
cblr-1208	81	43	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	81	44	antitrust	antitrust	ADJ
cblr-1208	81	45	law	law	NOUN
cblr-1208	81	46	requires	require	VERB
cblr-1208	81	47	them	they	PRON
cblr-1208	81	48	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	81	49	do	do	VERB
cblr-1208	81	50	so	so	ADV
cblr-1208	81	51	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	81	52	or	or	CCONJ
cblr-1208	81	53	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-1208	81	54	ii	ii	NOUN
cblr-1208	81	55	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-1208	81	56	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	81	57	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	81	58	absence	absence	NOUN
cblr-1208	81	59	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	81	60	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	81	61	settlement	settlement	NOUN
cblr-1208	81	62	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	81	63	generic	generic	ADJ
cblr-1208	81	64	manufacturer	manufacturer	NOUN
cblr-1208	81	65	would	would	AUX
cblr-1208	81	66	have	have	AUX
cblr-1208	81	67	prevailed	prevail	VERB
cblr-1208	81	68	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	82	1	as	as	SCONJ
cblr-1208	82	2	noted	note	VERB
cblr-1208	82	3	above	above	ADV
cblr-1208	82	4	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	82	5	lecture_commentary_final	lecture_commentary_final	PROPN
cblr-1208	83	1	no	no	NOUN
cblr-1208	83	2	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	84	1	1:45	1:45	NUM
cblr-1208	84	2	]	]	PUNCT
cblr-1208	84	3	commentary	commentary	NOUN
cblr-1208	84	4	:	:	PUNCT
cblr-1208	84	5	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	84	6	rule	rule	NOUN
cblr-1208	84	7	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	84	8	reason	reason	NOUN
cblr-1208	84	9	51	51	NUM
cblr-1208	84	10	b.	b.	NOUN
cblr-1208	84	11	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	84	12	holdings	holding	NOUN
cblr-1208	84	13	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	84	14	actavis	actavis	PROPN
cblr-1208	84	15	case	case	NOUN
cblr-1208	84	16	must	must	AUX
cblr-1208	84	17	be	be	AUX
cblr-1208	84	18	considered	consider	VERB
cblr-1208	84	19	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	84	20	light	light	NOUN
cblr-1208	84	21	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	84	22	its	its	PRON
cblr-1208	84	23	procedural	procedural	ADJ
cblr-1208	84	24	posture	posture	NOUN
cblr-1208	84	25	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	85	1	there	there	ADV
cblr-1208	85	2	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	85	3	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	85	4	eleventh	eleventh	ADJ
cblr-1208	85	5	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-1208	85	6	had	have	AUX
cblr-1208	85	7	affirmed	affirm	VERB
cblr-1208	85	8	dismissal	dismissal	NOUN
cblr-1208	85	9	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	85	10	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	85	11	complaint	complaint	NOUN
cblr-1208	85	12	brought	bring	VERB
cblr-1208	85	13	by	by	ADP
cblr-1208	85	14	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	85	15	ftc	ftc	PROPN
cblr-1208	85	16	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	86	1	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	86	2	only	only	ADJ
cblr-1208	86	3	task	task	NOUN
cblr-1208	86	4	before	before	SCONJ
cblr-1208	86	5	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	86	6	supreme	supreme	PROPN
cblr-1208	86	7	court	court	PROPN
cblr-1208	86	8	was	be	AUX
cblr-1208	86	9	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	86	10	decide	decide	VERB
cblr-1208	86	11	whether	whether	SCONJ
cblr-1208	86	12	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	86	13	ftc	ftc	PROPN
cblr-1208	86	14	’s	’s	PART
cblr-1208	86	15	complaint	complaint	NOUN
cblr-1208	86	16	stated	state	VERB
cblr-1208	86	17	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	86	18	plausible	plausible	ADJ
cblr-1208	86	19	claim.17	claim.17	NOUN
cblr-1208	86	20	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	86	21	court	court	NOUN
cblr-1208	86	22	reversed	reverse	VERB
cblr-1208	86	23	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	86	24	holding	hold	VERB
cblr-1208	86	25	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	86	26	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	86	27	eleventh	eleventh	ADJ
cblr-1208	86	28	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-1208	86	29	should	should	AUX
cblr-1208	86	30	have	have	AUX
cblr-1208	86	31	permitted	permit	VERB
cblr-1208	86	32	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	86	33	ftc	ftc	PROPN
cblr-1208	86	34	’s	’s	PART
cblr-1208	86	35	lawsuit	lawsuit	NOUN
cblr-1208	86	36	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	86	37	proceed.18	proceed.18	VERB
cblr-1208	86	38	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	86	39	court	court	NOUN
cblr-1208	86	40	held	hold	VERB
cblr-1208	86	41	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	86	42	reverse	reverse	VERB
cblr-1208	86	43	payment	payment	NOUN
cblr-1208	86	44	settlements	settlement	NOUN
cblr-1208	86	45	—	—	PUNCT
cblr-1208	86	46	even	even	ADV
cblr-1208	86	47	where	where	SCONJ
cblr-1208	86	48	they	they	PRON
cblr-1208	86	49	permit	permit	VERB
cblr-1208	86	50	entry	entry	NOUN
cblr-1208	86	51	within	within	ADP
cblr-1208	86	52	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	86	53	scope	scope	NOUN
cblr-1208	86	54	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	86	55	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	86	56	relevant	relevant	ADJ
cblr-1208	86	57	patent	patent	NOUN
cblr-1208	86	58	—	—	PUNCT
cblr-1208	86	59	can	can	AUX
cblr-1208	86	60	sometimes	sometimes	ADV
cblr-1208	86	61	violate	violate	VERB
cblr-1208	86	62	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	86	63	antitrust	antitrust	ADJ
cblr-1208	86	64	laws.19	laws.19	NOUN
cblr-1208	86	65	but	but	CCONJ
cblr-1208	86	66	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	86	67	court	court	NOUN
cblr-1208	86	68	rejected	reject	VERB
cblr-1208	86	69	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	86	70	ftc	ftc	PROPN
cblr-1208	86	71	’s	’s	PART
cblr-1208	86	72	position	position	NOUN
cblr-1208	86	73	that	that	PRON
cblr-1208	86	74	reverse	reverse	VERB
cblr-1208	86	75	payment	payment	NOUN
cblr-1208	86	76	settlement	settlement	NOUN
cblr-1208	86	77	agreements	agreement	NOUN
cblr-1208	86	78	are	be	AUX
cblr-1208	86	79	presumptively	presumptively	ADV
cblr-1208	86	80	unlawful	unlawful	ADJ
cblr-1208	86	81	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	86	82	subject	subject	ADJ
cblr-1208	86	83	to	to	ADP
cblr-1208	86	84	review	review	NOUN
cblr-1208	86	85	under	under	ADP
cblr-1208	86	86	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	86	87	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	86	88	quick	quick	ADJ
cblr-1208	86	89	look	look	NOUN
cblr-1208	86	90	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	86	91	test.20	test.20	NOUN
cblr-1208	86	92	instead	instead	ADV
cblr-1208	86	93	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	86	94	under	under	ADP
cblr-1208	86	95	actavis	actavis	NOUN
cblr-1208	86	96	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	86	97	courts	court	NOUN
cblr-1208	86	98	must	must	AUX
cblr-1208	86	99	scrutinize	scrutinize	VERB
cblr-1208	86	100	reverse	reverse	ADJ
cblr-1208	86	101	payment	payment	NOUN
cblr-1208	86	102	settlement	settlement	NOUN
cblr-1208	86	103	agreements	agreement	NOUN
cblr-1208	86	104	under	under	ADP
cblr-1208	86	105	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	86	106	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	86	107	rule	rule	NOUN
cblr-1208	86	108	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	86	109	reason	reason	NOUN
cblr-1208	86	110	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	87	1	”21	”21	PROPN
cblr-1208	87	2	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	87	3	actavis	actavis	PROPN
cblr-1208	87	4	holdings	holding	NOUN
cblr-1208	87	5	end	end	VERB
cblr-1208	87	6	there	there	ADV
cblr-1208	87	7	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	88	1	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	88	2	rest	rest	NOUN
cblr-1208	88	3	is	be	AUX
cblr-1208	88	4	commentary	commentary	NOUN
cblr-1208	88	5	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	89	1	c.	c.	NOUN
cblr-1208	90	1	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	90	2	commentary	commentary	NOUN
cblr-1208	90	3	writing	write	VERB
cblr-1208	90	4	for	for	ADP
cblr-1208	90	5	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	90	6	actavis	actavis	ADJ
cblr-1208	90	7	majority	majority	NOUN
cblr-1208	90	8	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	90	9	justice	justice	NOUN
cblr-1208	90	10	breyer	breyer	NOUN
cblr-1208	90	11	did	do	AUX
cblr-1208	90	12	not	not	PART
cblr-1208	90	13	purport	purport	VERB
cblr-1208	90	14	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	90	15	adopt	adopt	VERB
cblr-1208	90	16	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	90	17	new	new	ADJ
cblr-1208	90	18	rule	rule	NOUN
cblr-1208	90	19	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	90	20	reason	reason	NOUN
cblr-1208	90	21	analysis	analysis	NOUN
cblr-1208	90	22	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	91	1	indeed	indeed	ADV
cblr-1208	91	2	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	91	3	he	he	PRON
cblr-1208	91	4	explicitly	explicitly	ADV
cblr-1208	91	5	left	leave	VERB
cblr-1208	91	6	to	to	ADP
cblr-1208	91	7	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	91	8	lower	low	ADJ
cblr-1208	91	9	courts	court	NOUN
cblr-1208	91	10	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	91	11	task	task	NOUN
cblr-1208	91	12	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	91	13	structuring	structure	VERB
cblr-1208	91	14	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	91	15	rule	rule	NOUN
cblr-1208	91	16	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	91	17	reason	reason	NOUN
cblr-1208	91	18	analysis.22	analysis.22	PROPN
cblr-1208	91	19	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	91	20	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	91	21	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	91	22	rejecting	reject	VERB
cblr-1208	91	23	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	91	24	quick	quick	ADJ
cblr-1208	91	25	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-1208	91	26	look	look	NOUN
cblr-1208	91	27	test	test	NOUN
cblr-1208	91	28	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	91	29	he	he	PRON
cblr-1208	91	30	wrote	write	VERB
cblr-1208	91	31	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	91	32	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	91	33	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	91	34	ftc	ftc	PROPN
cblr-1208	91	35	must	must	AUX
cblr-1208	91	36	prove	prove	VERB
cblr-1208	91	37	its	its	PRON
cblr-1208	91	38	case	case	NOUN
cblr-1208	91	39	as	as	ADP
cblr-1208	91	40	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	91	41	other	other	ADJ
cblr-1208	91	42	rule	rule	NOUN
cblr-1208	91	43	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-1208	91	44	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	91	45	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-1208	91	46	reason	reason	NOUN
cblr-1208	91	47	cases	case	NOUN
cblr-1208	91	48	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	92	1	”23	”23	ADV
cblr-1208	92	2	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	92	3	first	first	ADJ
cblr-1208	92	4	assumption	assumption	NOUN
cblr-1208	92	5	is	be	AUX
cblr-1208	92	6	legally	legally	ADV
cblr-1208	92	7	untenable	untenable	ADJ
cblr-1208	92	8	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	93	1	see	see	VERB
cblr-1208	93	2	supra	supra	PROPN
cblr-1208	93	3	note	note	PROPN
cblr-1208	93	4	15	15	NUM
cblr-1208	93	5	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	94	1	as	as	SCONJ
cblr-1208	94	2	shown	show	VERB
cblr-1208	94	3	below	below	ADP
cblr-1208	94	4	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	94	5	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	94	6	second	second	ADJ
cblr-1208	94	7	assumption	assumption	NOUN
cblr-1208	94	8	is	be	AUX
cblr-1208	94	9	inherently	inherently	ADV
cblr-1208	94	10	speculative	speculative	ADJ
cblr-1208	94	11	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	94	12	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	94	13	equally	equally	ADV
cblr-1208	94	14	untenable	untenable	ADJ
cblr-1208	94	15	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	95	1	see	see	VERB
cblr-1208	95	2	infra	infra	NOUN
cblr-1208	95	3	notes	note	NOUN
cblr-1208	95	4	69–73	69–73	NUM
cblr-1208	95	5	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	95	6	accompanying	accompany	VERB
cblr-1208	95	7	text	text	NOUN
cblr-1208	95	8	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	96	1	17	17	NUM
cblr-1208	96	2	see	see	VERB
cblr-1208	96	3	actavis	actavis	PROPN
cblr-1208	96	4	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	96	5	133	133	NUM
cblr-1208	96	6	s.	s.	PROPN
cblr-1208	96	7	ct	ct	PROPN
cblr-1208	96	8	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	97	1	at	at	ADP
cblr-1208	97	2	2227	2227	NUM
cblr-1208	97	3	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	98	1	18	18	NUM
cblr-1208	98	2	see	see	VERB
cblr-1208	98	3	i	i	PRON
cblr-1208	98	4	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-1208	98	5	19	19	NUM
cblr-1208	98	6	see	see	VERB
cblr-1208	98	7	i	i	PRON
cblr-1208	98	8	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-1208	98	9	20	20	NUM
cblr-1208	98	10	see	see	VERB
cblr-1208	98	11	i	i	PRON
cblr-1208	98	12	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-1208	98	13	at	at	ADP
cblr-1208	98	14	2237	2237	NUM
cblr-1208	98	15	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	99	1	21	21	NUM
cblr-1208	99	2	see	see	VERB
cblr-1208	99	3	i	i	PROPN
cblr-1208	99	4	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-1208	99	5	22	22	NUM
cblr-1208	100	1	i	i	PRON
cblr-1208	100	2	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-1208	100	3	at	at	ADP
cblr-1208	100	4	2238	2238	NUM
cblr-1208	100	5	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	101	1	23	23	NUM
cblr-1208	102	1	i	i	PRON
cblr-1208	102	2	d.	d.	NOUN
cblr-1208	102	3	at	at	ADP
cblr-1208	102	4	2237	2237	NUM
cblr-1208	102	5	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	103	1	lecture_commentary_final	lecture_commentary_final	PROPN
cblr-1208	103	2	52	52	NUM
cblr-1208	103	3	columbia	columbia	PROPN
cblr-1208	103	4	business	business	NOUN
cblr-1208	103	5	law	law	PROPN
cblr-1208	103	6	review	review	NOUN
cblr-1208	103	7	[	[	X
cblr-1208	103	8	vol	vol	NOUN
cblr-1208	103	9	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	103	10	2018	2018	NUM
cblr-1208	103	11	however	however	ADV
cblr-1208	103	12	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	103	13	justice	justice	NOUN
cblr-1208	103	14	breyer	breyer	NOUN
cblr-1208	103	15	offered	offer	VERB
cblr-1208	103	16	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	103	17	five	five	NUM
cblr-1208	103	18	sets	set	NOUN
cblr-1208	103	19	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	103	20	considerations	consideration	NOUN
cblr-1208	103	21	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	103	22	justifying	justify	VERB
cblr-1208	103	23	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	103	24	court	court	NOUN
cblr-1208	103	25	’s	’s	PART
cblr-1208	103	26	holding.24	holding.24	NOUN
cblr-1208	103	27	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	103	28	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	103	29	considerations	consideration	NOUN
cblr-1208	103	30	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	103	31	are	be	AUX
cblr-1208	103	32	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	103	33	however	however	ADV
cblr-1208	103	34	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	103	35	laden	laden	ADJ
cblr-1208	103	36	with	with	ADP
cblr-1208	103	37	conditional	conditional	ADJ
cblr-1208	103	38	language	language	NOUN
cblr-1208	103	39	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	104	1	for	for	ADP
cblr-1208	104	2	instance	instance	NOUN
cblr-1208	104	3	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	104	4	he	he	PRON
cblr-1208	104	5	observed	observe	VERB
cblr-1208	104	6	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	104	7	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	104	8	sometimes	sometimes	ADV
cblr-1208	104	9	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	104	10	patent	patent	NOUN
cblr-1208	104	11	settlements	settlement	NOUN
cblr-1208	104	12	will	will	AUX
cblr-1208	104	13	have	have	VERB
cblr-1208	104	14	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	104	15	genuine	genuine	ADJ
cblr-1208	104	16	adverse	adverse	ADJ
cblr-1208	104	17	effects	effect	NOUN
cblr-1208	104	18	on	on	ADP
cblr-1208	104	19	competition,”25	competition,”25	NOUN
cblr-1208	104	20	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	104	21	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	104	22	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	104	23	these	these	DET
cblr-1208	104	24	anticompetitive	anticompetitive	ADJ
cblr-1208	104	25	consequences	consequence	NOUN
cblr-1208	104	26	will	will	AUX
cblr-1208	104	27	at	at	ADP
cblr-1208	104	28	least	least	ADJ
cblr-1208	104	29	sometimes	sometimes	ADV
cblr-1208	104	30	prove	prove	VERB
cblr-1208	104	31	unjustified	unjustified	ADJ
cblr-1208	104	32	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	105	1	”26	”26	VERB
cblr-1208	105	2	most	most	ADV
cblr-1208	105	3	notably	notably	ADV
cblr-1208	105	4	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	105	5	he	he	PRON
cblr-1208	105	6	predicted	predict	VERB
cblr-1208	105	7	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	105	8	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	105	9	it	it	PRON
cblr-1208	105	10	is	be	AUX
cblr-1208	105	11	normally	normally	ADV
cblr-1208	105	12	not	not	PART
cblr-1208	105	13	necessary	necessary	ADJ
cblr-1208	105	14	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	105	15	litigate	litigate	VERB
cblr-1208	105	16	patent	patent	NOUN
cblr-1208	105	17	validity	validity	NOUN
cblr-1208	105	18	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	105	19	answer	answer	VERB
cblr-1208	105	20	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	105	21	antitrust	antitrust	ADJ
cblr-1208	105	22	question	question	NOUN
cblr-1208	105	23	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	105	24	because	because	SCONJ
cblr-1208	105	25	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	105	26	[	[	X
cblr-1208	105	27	a]n	a]n	NOUN
cblr-1208	105	28	unexplained	unexplaine	VERB
cblr-1208	105	29	large	large	ADJ
cblr-1208	105	30	reverse	reverse	ADJ
cblr-1208	105	31	payment	payment	NOUN
cblr-1208	105	32	itself	itself	PRON
cblr-1208	105	33	would	would	AUX
cblr-1208	105	34	normally	normally	ADV
cblr-1208	105	35	suggest	suggest	VERB
cblr-1208	105	36	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	105	37	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	105	38	patentee	patentee	NOUN
cblr-1208	105	39	has	have	VERB
cblr-1208	105	40	serious	serious	ADJ
cblr-1208	105	41	doubts	doubt	NOUN
cblr-1208	105	42	about	about	ADP
cblr-1208	105	43	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	105	44	patent	patent	NOUN
cblr-1208	105	45	’s	’s	PART
cblr-1208	105	46	survival	survival	NOUN
cblr-1208	105	47	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	105	48	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	105	49	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	105	50	using	use	VERB
cblr-1208	105	51	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	105	52	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	105	53	payment	payment	NOUN
cblr-1208	105	54	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	105	55	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	105	56	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	106	1	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	106	2	prevent	prevent	VERB
cblr-1208	106	3	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	106	4	risk	risk	NOUN
cblr-1208	106	5	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	106	6	competition	competition	NOUN
cblr-1208	106	7	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	107	1	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	108	1	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	109	1	constitutes	constitute	VERB
cblr-1208	109	2	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	109	3	relevant	relevant	ADJ
cblr-1208	109	4	anticompetitive	anticompetitive	ADJ
cblr-1208	109	5	harm	harm	NOUN
cblr-1208	109	6	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	110	1	”27	”27	ADJ
cblr-1208	110	2	justice	justice	PROPN
cblr-1208	110	3	breyer	breyer	NOUN
cblr-1208	110	4	’s	’s	PART
cblr-1208	110	5	reliance	reliance	NOUN
cblr-1208	110	6	on	on	ADP
cblr-1208	110	7	words	word	NOUN
cblr-1208	110	8	like	like	ADP
cblr-1208	110	9	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	110	10	sometimes	sometimes	ADV
cblr-1208	110	11	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	110	12	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	110	13	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	110	14	normally	normally	ADV
cblr-1208	110	15	suggests	suggest	VERB
cblr-1208	110	16	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	110	17	do	do	VERB
cblr-1208	110	18	not	not	PART
cblr-1208	110	19	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	110	20	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	110	21	our	our	PRON
cblr-1208	110	22	view	view	NOUN
cblr-1208	110	23	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	110	24	24	24	NUM
cblr-1208	110	25	see	see	VERB
cblr-1208	110	26	i	i	PRON
cblr-1208	110	27	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-1208	110	28	at	at	ADP
cblr-1208	110	29	2234	2234	NUM
cblr-1208	110	30	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	111	1	25	25	NUM
cblr-1208	111	2	see	see	VERB
cblr-1208	111	3	i	i	PRON
cblr-1208	111	4	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-1208	111	5	at	at	ADP
cblr-1208	111	6	2234–35	2234–35	NUM
cblr-1208	111	7	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	112	1	26	26	NUM
cblr-1208	112	2	see	see	VERB
cblr-1208	112	3	i	i	PRON
cblr-1208	112	4	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-1208	112	5	at	at	ADP
cblr-1208	112	6	2235–36	2235–36	NUM
cblr-1208	112	7	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	113	1	27	27	NUM
cblr-1208	113	2	see	see	VERB
cblr-1208	113	3	i	i	PRON
cblr-1208	113	4	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-1208	113	5	at	at	ADP
cblr-1208	113	6	2236–37	2236–37	PROPN
cblr-1208	113	7	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	114	1	justice	justice	NOUN
cblr-1208	114	2	breyer	breyer	NOUN
cblr-1208	114	3	also	also	ADV
cblr-1208	114	4	observed	observe	VERB
cblr-1208	114	5	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	114	6	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	114	7	where	where	SCONJ
cblr-1208	114	8	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	114	9	reverse	reverse	ADJ
cblr-1208	114	10	payment	payment	NOUN
cblr-1208	114	11	threatens	threaten	VERB
cblr-1208	114	12	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	114	13	work	work	VERB
cblr-1208	114	14	unjustified	unjustified	ADJ
cblr-1208	114	15	anticompetitive	anticompetitive	ADJ
cblr-1208	114	16	harm	harm	NOUN
cblr-1208	114	17	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	114	18	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	114	19	patentee	patentee	NOUN
cblr-1208	114	20	likely	likely	ADV
cblr-1208	114	21	possesses	possess	VERB
cblr-1208	114	22	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	114	23	power	power	NOUN
cblr-1208	114	24	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	114	25	bring	bring	VERB
cblr-1208	114	26	that	that	DET
cblr-1208	114	27	harm	harm	NOUN
cblr-1208	114	28	about	about	ADP
cblr-1208	114	29	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	114	30	practice	practice	NOUN
cblr-1208	114	31	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	114	32	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	114	33	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	114	34	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	114	35	parties	party	NOUN
cblr-1208	114	36	may	may	AUX
cblr-1208	114	37	still	still	ADV
cblr-1208	114	38	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	114	39	settle	settle	VERB
cblr-1208	114	40	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	114	41	other	other	ADJ
cblr-1208	114	42	ways	way	NOUN
cblr-1208	114	43	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	114	44	such	such	ADJ
cblr-1208	114	45	as	as	ADP
cblr-1208	114	46	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	114	47	by	by	ADP
cblr-1208	114	48	allowing	allow	VERB
cblr-1208	114	49	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	114	50	generic	generic	ADJ
cblr-1208	114	51	manufacturer	manufacturer	NOUN
cblr-1208	114	52	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	114	53	enter	enter	VERB
cblr-1208	114	54	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	114	55	patentee	patentee	NOUN
cblr-1208	114	56	’s	’s	PART
cblr-1208	114	57	market	market	NOUN
cblr-1208	114	58	prior	prior	ADV
cblr-1208	114	59	to	to	ADP
cblr-1208	114	60	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	114	61	patent	patent	NOUN
cblr-1208	114	62	’s	’s	PART
cblr-1208	114	63	expiration	expiration	NOUN
cblr-1208	114	64	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	114	65	without	without	ADP
cblr-1208	114	66	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	114	67	patentee	patentee	NOUN
cblr-1208	114	68	paying	pay	VERB
cblr-1208	114	69	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	114	70	challenger	challenger	NOUN
cblr-1208	114	71	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	114	72	stay	stay	VERB
cblr-1208	114	73	out	out	ADV
cblr-1208	114	74	prior	prior	ADV
cblr-1208	114	75	to	to	ADP
cblr-1208	114	76	that	that	DET
cblr-1208	114	77	point	point	NOUN
cblr-1208	114	78	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	114	79	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	115	1	i	i	PRON
cblr-1208	115	2	d.	d.	VERB
cblr-1208	115	3	at	at	ADP
cblr-1208	115	4	2236–37	2236–37	NUM
cblr-1208	115	5	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	116	1	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	116	2	course	course	NOUN
cblr-1208	116	3	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	116	4	even	even	ADV
cblr-1208	116	5	an	an	DET
cblr-1208	116	6	entry	entry	NOUN
cblr-1208	116	7	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-1208	116	8	date	date	NOUN
cblr-1208	116	9	settlement	settlement	NOUN
cblr-1208	116	10	that	that	PRON
cblr-1208	116	11	complies	comply	VERB
cblr-1208	116	12	fully	fully	ADV
cblr-1208	116	13	with	with	SCONJ
cblr-1208	116	14	actavis	actavis	PROPN
cblr-1208	116	15	prevents	prevent	VERB
cblr-1208	116	16	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	116	17	risk	risk	NOUN
cblr-1208	116	18	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	116	19	competition	competition	NOUN
cblr-1208	116	20	until	until	ADP
cblr-1208	116	21	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	116	22	agreedupon	agreedupon	NOUN
cblr-1208	116	23	entry	entry	NOUN
cblr-1208	116	24	date	date	NOUN
cblr-1208	116	25	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	117	1	thus	thus	ADV
cblr-1208	117	2	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	117	3	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	117	4	prevention	prevention	NOUN
cblr-1208	117	5	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	117	6	risk	risk	NOUN
cblr-1208	117	7	alone	alone	ADV
cblr-1208	117	8	can	can	AUX
cblr-1208	117	9	not	not	PART
cblr-1208	117	10	be	be	AUX
cblr-1208	117	11	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	117	12	basis	basis	NOUN
cblr-1208	117	13	for	for	ADP
cblr-1208	117	14	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	117	15	judgment	judgment	NOUN
cblr-1208	117	16	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	117	17	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	117	18	settlement	settlement	NOUN
cblr-1208	117	19	violates	violate	VERB
cblr-1208	117	20	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	117	21	antitrust	antitrust	ADJ
cblr-1208	117	22	laws	law	NOUN
cblr-1208	117	23	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	118	1	for	for	ADP
cblr-1208	118	2	this	this	DET
cblr-1208	118	3	reason	reason	NOUN
cblr-1208	118	4	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	118	5	professor	professor	NOUN
cblr-1208	118	6	michael	michael	PROPN
cblr-1208	118	7	a.	a.	PROPN
cblr-1208	118	8	carrier	carrier	PROPN
cblr-1208	118	9	overextends	overextend	VERB
cblr-1208	118	10	actavis	actavis	PROPN
cblr-1208	118	11	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	118	12	suggesting	suggest	VERB
cblr-1208	118	13	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	118	14	our	our	PRON
cblr-1208	118	15	approach	approach	NOUN
cblr-1208	118	16	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	118	17	fails	fail	VERB
cblr-1208	118	18	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	118	19	sufficiently	sufficiently	ADV
cblr-1208	118	20	appreciate	appreciate	VERB
cblr-1208	118	21	actavis	actavis	PROPN
cblr-1208	118	22	’s	’s	PART
cblr-1208	118	23	focus	focus	NOUN
cblr-1208	118	24	on	on	ADP
cblr-1208	118	25	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	118	26	‘	'	PUNCT
cblr-1208	118	27	prevent[ion	prevent[ion	NOUN
cblr-1208	118	28	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	118	29	]	]	PUNCT
cblr-1208	118	30	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	118	31	risk	risk	NOUN
cblr-1208	118	32	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	118	33	competition	competition	NOUN
cblr-1208	118	34	’	'	PUNCT
cblr-1208	118	35	as	as	ADP
cblr-1208	118	36	‘	'	PUNCT
cblr-1208	118	37	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	118	38	relevant	relevant	ADJ
cblr-1208	118	39	anticompetitive	anticompetitive	ADJ
cblr-1208	118	40	harm	harm	NOUN
cblr-1208	118	41	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	118	42	’	'	PUNCT
cblr-1208	119	1	actavis	actavis	PROPN
cblr-1208	119	2	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	119	3	133	133	NUM
cblr-1208	119	4	s.	s.	PROPN
cblr-1208	119	5	ct	ct	PROPN
cblr-1208	119	6	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	119	7	at	at	ADP
cblr-1208	119	8	2236	2236	NUM
cblr-1208	119	9	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	119	10	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	119	11	see	see	VERB
cblr-1208	119	12	michael	michael	PROPN
cblr-1208	119	13	a.	a.	NOUN
cblr-1208	119	14	carrier	carrier	PROPN
cblr-1208	119	15	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	119	16	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	119	17	rule	rule	NOUN
cblr-1208	119	18	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	119	19	reason	reason	NOUN
cblr-1208	119	20	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	119	21	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	119	22	postactavis	postactavis	ADJ
cblr-1208	119	23	world	world	NOUN
cblr-1208	119	24	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	119	25	2018	2018	NUM
cblr-1208	119	26	colum	colum	NOUN
cblr-1208	119	27	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	120	1	bus	bus	NOUN
cblr-1208	120	2	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	121	1	l.	l.	PROPN
cblr-1208	121	2	rev	rev	PROPN
cblr-1208	121	3	.	.	PROPN
cblr-1208	121	4	25	25	NUM
cblr-1208	121	5	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	121	6	38	38	NUM
cblr-1208	121	7	n.69	n.69	NOUN
cblr-1208	121	8	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-1208	121	9	2018	2018	NUM
cblr-1208	121	10	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-1208	121	11	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	122	1	one	one	PRON
cblr-1208	122	2	might	might	AUX
cblr-1208	122	3	be	be	AUX
cblr-1208	122	4	able	able	ADJ
cblr-1208	122	5	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	122	6	justify	justify	VERB
cblr-1208	122	7	using	use	VERB
cblr-1208	122	8	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	122	9	prevention	prevention	NOUN
cblr-1208	122	10	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	122	11	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	122	12	risk	risk	NOUN
cblr-1208	122	13	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	122	14	competition	competition	NOUN
cblr-1208	122	15	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	122	16	as	as	ADP
cblr-1208	122	17	anticompetitive	anticompetitive	ADJ
cblr-1208	122	18	harm	harm	NOUN
cblr-1208	122	19	justifying	justify	VERB
cblr-1208	122	20	allowing	allow	VERB
cblr-1208	122	21	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	122	22	case	case	NOUN
cblr-1208	122	23	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	122	24	proceed	proceed	VERB
cblr-1208	122	25	past	past	ADP
cblr-1208	122	26	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	122	27	motion	motion	NOUN
cblr-1208	122	28	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	122	29	dismiss	dismiss	VERB
cblr-1208	122	30	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	122	31	which	which	PRON
cblr-1208	122	32	is	be	AUX
cblr-1208	122	33	all	all	DET
cblr-1208	122	34	that	that	DET
cblr-1208	122	35	justice	justice	NOUN
cblr-1208	122	36	breyer	breyer	NOUN
cblr-1208	122	37	did	do	VERB
cblr-1208	122	38	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	122	39	actavis	actavis	PROPN
cblr-1208	122	40	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	123	1	but	but	CCONJ
cblr-1208	123	2	actavis	actavis	ADJ
cblr-1208	123	3	mandates	mandate	NOUN
cblr-1208	123	4	that	that	PRON
cblr-1208	123	5	alleged	allege	VERB
cblr-1208	123	6	reverse	reverse	NOUN
cblr-1208	123	7	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-1208	123	8	payment	payment	NOUN
cblr-1208	123	9	settlements	settlement	NOUN
cblr-1208	123	10	be	be	AUX
cblr-1208	123	11	evaluated	evaluate	VERB
cblr-1208	123	12	under	under	ADP
cblr-1208	123	13	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	123	14	rule	rule	NOUN
cblr-1208	123	15	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	123	16	reason	reason	NOUN
cblr-1208	123	17	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	124	1	see	see	VERB
cblr-1208	124	2	actavis	actavis	PROPN
cblr-1208	124	3	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	124	4	133	133	NUM
cblr-1208	124	5	s.	s.	PROPN
cblr-1208	124	6	ct	ct	PROPN
cblr-1208	124	7	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	125	1	at	at	ADP
cblr-1208	125	2	2237	2237	NUM
cblr-1208	125	3	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	126	1	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	126	2	any	any	DET
cblr-1208	126	3	event	event	NOUN
cblr-1208	126	4	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	126	5	actavis	actavis	PROPN
cblr-1208	126	6	does	do	AUX
cblr-1208	126	7	not	not	PART
cblr-1208	126	8	provide	provide	VERB
cblr-1208	126	9	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	126	10	basis	basis	NOUN
cblr-1208	126	11	for	for	ADP
cblr-1208	126	12	relieving	relieve	VERB
cblr-1208	126	13	an	an	DET
cblr-1208	126	14	antitrust	antitrust	ADJ
cblr-1208	126	15	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
cblr-1208	126	16	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	126	17	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	126	18	obligation	obligation	NOUN
cblr-1208	126	19	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	126	20	prove	prove	VERB
cblr-1208	126	21	injury	injury	NOUN
cblr-1208	126	22	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	126	23	fact	fact	NOUN
cblr-1208	126	24	—	—	PUNCT
cblr-1208	126	25	an	an	DET
cblr-1208	126	26	element	element	NOUN
cblr-1208	126	27	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	126	28	antitrust	antitrust	ADJ
cblr-1208	126	29	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-1208	126	30	—	—	PUNCT
cblr-1208	126	31	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	126	32	obtain	obtain	VERB
cblr-1208	126	33	relief	relief	NOUN
cblr-1208	126	34	under	under	ADP
cblr-1208	126	35	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	126	36	antitrust	antitrust	ADJ
cblr-1208	126	37	laws	law	NOUN
cblr-1208	126	38	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	127	1	lecture_commentary_final	lecture_commentary_final	ADJ
cblr-1208	128	1	no	no	INTJ
cblr-1208	128	2	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	129	1	1:45	1:45	NUM
cblr-1208	129	2	]	]	PUNCT
cblr-1208	129	3	commentary	commentary	NOUN
cblr-1208	129	4	:	:	PUNCT
cblr-1208	129	5	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	129	6	rule	rule	NOUN
cblr-1208	129	7	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	129	8	reason	reason	NOUN
cblr-1208	129	9	53	53	NUM
cblr-1208	129	10	provide	provide	VERB
cblr-1208	129	11	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	129	12	basis	basis	NOUN
cblr-1208	129	13	on	on	ADP
cblr-1208	129	14	which	which	PRON
cblr-1208	129	15	one	one	PRON
cblr-1208	129	16	can	can	AUX
cblr-1208	129	17	impose	impose	VERB
cblr-1208	129	18	presumptions	presumption	NOUN
cblr-1208	129	19	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	129	20	shortcuts	shortcut	NOUN
cblr-1208	129	21	on	on	ADP
cblr-1208	129	22	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	129	23	rule	rule	NOUN
cblr-1208	129	24	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	129	25	reason	reason	NOUN
cblr-1208	129	26	analysis	analysis	NOUN
cblr-1208	129	27	required	require	VERB
cblr-1208	129	28	—	—	PUNCT
cblr-1208	129	29	particularly	particularly	ADV
cblr-1208	129	30	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	129	31	light	light	NOUN
cblr-1208	129	32	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	129	33	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	129	34	holding	holding	NOUN
cblr-1208	129	35	rejecting	reject	VERB
cblr-1208	129	36	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	129	37	ftc	ftc	PROPN
cblr-1208	129	38	’s	’s	PART
cblr-1208	129	39	effort	effort	NOUN
cblr-1208	129	40	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	129	41	do	do	AUX
cblr-1208	129	42	just	just	ADV
cblr-1208	129	43	that	that	PRON
cblr-1208	129	44	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	130	1	more	more	ADV
cblr-1208	130	2	importantly	importantly	ADV
cblr-1208	130	3	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	130	4	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	130	5	majority	majority	NOUN
cblr-1208	130	6	’s	’s	PART
cblr-1208	130	7	casual	casual	ADJ
cblr-1208	130	8	substitution	substitution	NOUN
cblr-1208	130	9	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	130	10	presumed	presume	VERB
cblr-1208	130	11	patentee	patentee	NOUN
cblr-1208	130	12	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	130	13	doubts	doubt	NOUN
cblr-1208	130	14	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	130	15	for	for	ADP
cblr-1208	130	16	actual	actual	ADJ
cblr-1208	130	17	judicial	judicial	ADJ
cblr-1208	130	18	findings	finding	NOUN
cblr-1208	130	19	is	be	AUX
cblr-1208	130	20	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	130	21	as	as	SCONJ
cblr-1208	130	22	discussed	discuss	VERB
cblr-1208	130	23	below	below	ADV
cblr-1208	130	24	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	130	25	particularly	particularly	ADV
cblr-1208	130	26	troubling	troubling	ADJ
cblr-1208	130	27	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	130	28	without	without	ADP
cblr-1208	130	29	legal	legal	ADJ
cblr-1208	130	30	foundation.28	foundation.28	NOUN
cblr-1208	130	31	chief	chief	PROPN
cblr-1208	130	32	justice	justice	NOUN
cblr-1208	130	33	roberts	roberts	PROPN
cblr-1208	130	34	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	130	35	joined	join	VERB
cblr-1208	130	36	by	by	ADP
cblr-1208	130	37	justices	justice	NOUN
cblr-1208	130	38	scalia	scalia	PROPN
cblr-1208	130	39	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	130	40	thomas	thomas	PROPN
cblr-1208	130	41	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	130	42	dissented	dissent	VERB
cblr-1208	130	43	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	131	1	addressing	address	VERB
cblr-1208	131	2	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	131	3	tension	tension	NOUN
cblr-1208	131	4	between	between	ADP
cblr-1208	131	5	patent	patent	NOUN
cblr-1208	131	6	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	131	7	antitrust	antitrust	ADJ
cblr-1208	131	8	policies	policy	NOUN
cblr-1208	131	9	at	at	ADP
cblr-1208	131	10	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	131	11	core	core	NOUN
cblr-1208	131	12	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	131	13	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	131	14	majority	majority	NOUN
cblr-1208	131	15	’s	’s	PART
cblr-1208	131	16	opinion	opinion	NOUN
cblr-1208	131	17	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	131	18	he	he	PRON
cblr-1208	131	19	wrote	write	VERB
cblr-1208	131	20	:	:	PUNCT
cblr-1208	131	21	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	131	22	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	131	23	problem	problem	NOUN
cblr-1208	131	24	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	131	25	as	as	SCONJ
cblr-1208	131	26	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	131	27	court	court	NOUN
cblr-1208	131	28	correctly	correctly	ADV
cblr-1208	131	29	recognizes	recognize	VERB
cblr-1208	131	30	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	131	31	is	be	AUX
cblr-1208	131	32	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	131	33	we	we	PRON
cblr-1208	131	34	’re	’re	VERB
cblr-1208	131	35	not	not	PART
cblr-1208	131	36	quite	quite	ADV
cblr-1208	131	37	certain	certain	ADJ
cblr-1208	131	38	if	if	SCONJ
cblr-1208	131	39	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	131	40	patent	patent	NOUN
cblr-1208	131	41	is	be	AUX
cblr-1208	131	42	actually	actually	ADV
cblr-1208	131	43	valid	valid	ADJ
cblr-1208	131	44	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	131	45	or	or	CCONJ
cblr-1208	131	46	if	if	SCONJ
cblr-1208	131	47	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	131	48	competitor	competitor	NOUN
cblr-1208	131	49	is	be	AUX
cblr-1208	131	50	infringing	infringe	VERB
cblr-1208	131	51	it	it	PRON
cblr-1208	131	52	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	132	1	but	but	CCONJ
cblr-1208	132	2	that	that	PRON
cblr-1208	132	3	is	be	AUX
cblr-1208	132	4	always	always	ADV
cblr-1208	132	5	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	132	6	case	case	NOUN
cblr-1208	132	7	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	132	8	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	132	9	is	be	AUX
cblr-1208	132	10	plainly	plainly	ADV
cblr-1208	132	11	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	132	12	question	question	NOUN
cblr-1208	132	13	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	132	14	patent	patent	NOUN
cblr-1208	132	15	law	law	NOUN
cblr-1208	132	16	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	133	1	”29	”29	AUX
cblr-1208	133	2	accordingly	accordingly	ADV
cblr-1208	133	3	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	133	4	chief	chief	ADJ
cblr-1208	133	5	justice	justice	NOUN
cblr-1208	133	6	roberts	roberts	PROPN
cblr-1208	133	7	disagreed	disagree	VERB
cblr-1208	133	8	with	with	ADP
cblr-1208	133	9	justice	justice	NOUN
cblr-1208	133	10	breyer	breyer	NOUN
cblr-1208	133	11	’s	’s	PART
cblr-1208	133	12	suggestion	suggestion	NOUN
cblr-1208	133	13	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	133	14	it	it	PRON
cblr-1208	133	15	will	will	AUX
cblr-1208	133	16	not	not	PART
cblr-1208	133	17	normally	normally	ADV
cblr-1208	133	18	be	be	AUX
cblr-1208	133	19	necessary	necessary	ADJ
cblr-1208	133	20	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	133	21	litigate	litigate	VERB
cblr-1208	133	22	patent	patent	NOUN
cblr-1208	133	23	validity	validity	NOUN
cblr-1208	133	24	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	133	25	answer	answer	VERB
cblr-1208	133	26	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	133	27	antitrust	antitrust	ADJ
cblr-1208	133	28	question	question	NOUN
cblr-1208	133	29	:	:	PUNCT
cblr-1208	134	1	[	[	X
cblr-1208	134	2	s]ettling	s]ettle	VERB
cblr-1208	134	3	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	134	4	patent	patent	NOUN
cblr-1208	134	5	claim	claim	NOUN
cblr-1208	134	6	can	can	AUX
cblr-1208	134	7	not	not	PART
cblr-1208	134	8	possibly	possibly	ADV
cblr-1208	134	9	impose	impose	VERB
cblr-1208	134	10	unlawful	unlawful	ADJ
cblr-1208	134	11	anticompetitive	anticompetitive	ADJ
cblr-1208	134	12	harm	harm	NOUN
cblr-1208	134	13	if	if	SCONJ
cblr-1208	134	14	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	134	15	patent	patent	NOUN
cblr-1208	134	16	holder	holder	NOUN
cblr-1208	134	17	is	be	AUX
cblr-1208	134	18	acting	act	VERB
cblr-1208	134	19	within	within	ADP
cblr-1208	134	20	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	134	21	scope	scope	NOUN
cblr-1208	134	22	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	134	23	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	134	24	valid	valid	ADJ
cblr-1208	134	25	patent	patent	NOUN
cblr-1208	134	26	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	134	27	therefore	therefore	ADV
cblr-1208	134	28	permitted	permit	VERB
cblr-1208	134	29	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	134	30	do	do	VERB
cblr-1208	134	31	precisely	precisely	ADV
cblr-1208	134	32	what	what	PRON
cblr-1208	134	33	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	134	34	antitrust	antitrust	ADJ
cblr-1208	134	35	suit	suit	NOUN
cblr-1208	134	36	claims	claim	VERB
cblr-1208	134	37	is	be	AUX
cblr-1208	134	38	unlawful	unlawful	ADJ
cblr-1208	134	39	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	135	1	this	this	PRON
cblr-1208	135	2	means	mean	VERB
cblr-1208	135	3	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	135	4	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	135	5	any	any	DET
cblr-1208	135	6	such	such	ADJ
cblr-1208	135	7	antitrust	antitrust	ADJ
cblr-1208	135	8	suit	suit	NOUN
cblr-1208	135	9	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	135	10	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	135	11	defendant	defendant	NOUN
cblr-1208	135	12	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-1208	135	13	patent	patent	NOUN
cblr-1208	135	14	holder	holder	NOUN
cblr-1208	135	15	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-1208	135	16	will	will	AUX
cblr-1208	135	17	want	want	VERB
cblr-1208	135	18	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	135	19	use	use	VERB
cblr-1208	135	20	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	135	21	validity	validity	NOUN
cblr-1208	135	22	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	135	23	his	his	PRON
cblr-1208	135	24	patent	patent	NOUN
cblr-1208	135	25	as	as	ADP
cblr-1208	135	26	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	135	27	defense	defense	NOUN
cblr-1208	135	28	—	—	PUNCT
cblr-1208	135	29	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	135	30	other	other	ADJ
cblr-1208	135	31	words	word	NOUN
cblr-1208	135	32	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	135	33	he	he	PRON
cblr-1208	135	34	’ll	’ll	AUX
cblr-1208	135	35	want	want	VERB
cblr-1208	135	36	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	135	37	say	say	VERB
cblr-1208	135	38	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	135	39	i	i	PRON
cblr-1208	135	40	can	can	AUX
cblr-1208	135	41	do	do	VERB
cblr-1208	135	42	this	this	PRON
cblr-1208	135	43	because	because	SCONJ
cblr-1208	135	44	i	i	PRON
cblr-1208	135	45	have	have	VERB
cblr-1208	135	46	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	135	47	valid	valid	ADJ
cblr-1208	135	48	patent	patent	NOUN
cblr-1208	135	49	that	that	PRON
cblr-1208	135	50	lets	let	VERB
cblr-1208	135	51	me	i	PRON
cblr-1208	135	52	do	do	VERB
cblr-1208	135	53	this	this	PRON
cblr-1208	135	54	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	136	1	”30	”30	PROPN
cblr-1208	136	2	as	as	SCONJ
cblr-1208	136	3	chief	chief	PROPN
cblr-1208	136	4	justice	justice	NOUN
cblr-1208	136	5	roberts	roberts	PROPN
cblr-1208	136	6	recognized	recognize	VERB
cblr-1208	136	7	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	136	8	there	there	PRON
cblr-1208	136	9	is	be	VERB
cblr-1208	136	10	tension	tension	NOUN
cblr-1208	136	11	between	between	ADP
cblr-1208	136	12	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	136	13	actavis	actavis	PROPN
cblr-1208	136	14	court	court	NOUN
cblr-1208	136	15	’s	’s	PART
cblr-1208	136	16	holding	hold	VERB
cblr-1208	136	17	mandating	mandate	VERB
cblr-1208	136	18	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	136	19	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
cblr-1208	136	20	must	must	AUX
cblr-1208	136	21	prove	prove	VERB
cblr-1208	136	22	their	their	PRON
cblr-1208	136	23	claims	claim	NOUN
cblr-1208	136	24	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	136	25	as	as	ADP
cblr-1208	136	26	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	136	27	other	other	ADJ
cblr-1208	136	28	rule	rule	NOUN
cblr-1208	136	29	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-1208	136	30	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	136	31	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-1208	136	32	reason	reason	NOUN
cblr-1208	136	33	cases,”31	cases,”31	ADJ
cblr-1208	136	34	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	136	35	justice	justice	NOUN
cblr-1208	136	36	breyer	breyer	NOUN
cblr-1208	136	37	’s	’s	PART
cblr-1208	136	38	justifications	justification	NOUN
cblr-1208	136	39	for	for	ADP
cblr-1208	136	40	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	136	41	court	court	NOUN
cblr-1208	136	42	’s	’s	PART
cblr-1208	136	43	holdings	holding	NOUN
cblr-1208	136	44	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	137	1	28	28	NUM
cblr-1208	137	2	see	see	VERB
cblr-1208	137	3	infra	infra	NOUN
cblr-1208	137	4	notes	note	VERB
cblr-1208	137	5	69–73	69–73	NUM
cblr-1208	137	6	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	137	7	accompanying	accompany	VERB
cblr-1208	137	8	text	text	NOUN
cblr-1208	137	9	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	138	1	29	29	NUM
cblr-1208	138	2	actavis	actavis	NOUN
cblr-1208	138	3	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	138	4	133	133	NUM
cblr-1208	138	5	s.	s.	PROPN
cblr-1208	138	6	ct	ct	PROPN
cblr-1208	138	7	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	139	1	at	at	ADP
cblr-1208	139	2	2240	2240	NUM
cblr-1208	139	3	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-1208	139	4	roberts	roberts	PROPN
cblr-1208	139	5	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	139	6	c.j	c.j	PROPN
cblr-1208	139	7	.	.	PROPN
cblr-1208	139	8	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	139	9	dissenting	dissent	VERB
cblr-1208	139	10	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-1208	139	11	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	140	1	30	30	NUM
cblr-1208	141	1	i	i	PRON
cblr-1208	141	2	d.	d.	NOUN
cblr-1208	141	3	at	at	ADP
cblr-1208	141	4	2244	2244	NUM
cblr-1208	141	5	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	142	1	31	31	NUM
cblr-1208	142	2	actavis	actavi	NOUN
cblr-1208	142	3	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	142	4	133	133	NUM
cblr-1208	142	5	s.	s.	PROPN
cblr-1208	142	6	ct	ct	PROPN
cblr-1208	142	7	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	143	1	at	at	ADP
cblr-1208	143	2	2237	2237	NUM
cblr-1208	143	3	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	144	1	lecture_commentary_final	lecture_commentary_final	PROPN
cblr-1208	144	2	54	54	NUM
cblr-1208	144	3	columbia	columbia	PROPN
cblr-1208	144	4	business	business	NOUN
cblr-1208	144	5	law	law	PROPN
cblr-1208	144	6	review	review	NOUN
cblr-1208	144	7	[	[	X
cblr-1208	144	8	vol	vol	NOUN
cblr-1208	144	9	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	144	10	2018	2018	NUM
cblr-1208	144	11	iii	iii	NOUN
cblr-1208	144	12	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	145	1	actavis	actavis	PROPN
cblr-1208	145	2	requires	require	VERB
cblr-1208	145	3	inquiry	inquiry	NOUN
cblr-1208	145	4	under	under	ADP
cblr-1208	145	5	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	145	6	rule	rule	NOUN
cblr-1208	145	7	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	145	8	reason	reason	NOUN
cblr-1208	145	9	—	—	PUNCT
cblr-1208	145	10	without	without	ADP
cblr-1208	145	11	shortcuts	shortcut	NOUN
cblr-1208	145	12	from	from	ADP
cblr-1208	145	13	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	145	14	dawn	dawn	NOUN
cblr-1208	145	15	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	145	16	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	145	17	rule	rule	NOUN
cblr-1208	145	18	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	145	19	reason	reason	NOUN
cblr-1208	145	20	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	145	21	addyston	addyston	PROPN
cblr-1208	145	22	pipe32	pipe32	NOUN
cblr-1208	145	23	through	through	ADP
cblr-1208	145	24	modern	modern	ADJ
cblr-1208	145	25	times	time	NOUN
cblr-1208	145	26	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	145	27	rule	rule	NOUN
cblr-1208	145	28	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	145	29	reason	reason	NOUN
cblr-1208	145	30	analysis	analysis	NOUN
cblr-1208	145	31	has	have	AUX
cblr-1208	145	32	grown	grow	VERB
cblr-1208	145	33	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	145	34	embrace	embrace	VERB
cblr-1208	145	35	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	145	36	core	core	NOUN
cblr-1208	145	37	principle	principle	NOUN
cblr-1208	145	38	:	:	PUNCT
cblr-1208	145	39	judging	judge	VERB
cblr-1208	145	40	whether	whether	SCONJ
cblr-1208	145	41	an	an	DET
cblr-1208	145	42	agreement	agreement	NOUN
cblr-1208	145	43	violates	violate	VERB
cblr-1208	145	44	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	145	45	law	law	NOUN
cblr-1208	145	46	requires	require	VERB
cblr-1208	145	47	an	an	DET
cblr-1208	145	48	analysis	analysis	NOUN
cblr-1208	145	49	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	145	50	anticompetitive	anticompetitive	ADJ
cblr-1208	145	51	effects.33	effects.33	NOUN
cblr-1208	145	52	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	145	53	course	course	NOUN
cblr-1208	145	54	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	145	55	asking	ask	VERB
cblr-1208	145	56	whether	whether	SCONJ
cblr-1208	145	57	an	an	DET
cblr-1208	145	58	agreement	agreement	NOUN
cblr-1208	145	59	has	have	AUX
cblr-1208	145	60	anticompetitive	anticompetitive	ADJ
cblr-1208	145	61	effects	effect	NOUN
cblr-1208	145	62	leads	lead	VERB
cblr-1208	145	63	to	to	ADP
cblr-1208	145	64	an	an	DET
cblr-1208	145	65	inevitable	inevitable	ADJ
cblr-1208	145	66	question	question	NOUN
cblr-1208	145	67	:	:	PUNCT
cblr-1208	145	68	compared	compare	VERB
cblr-1208	145	69	to	to	ADP
cblr-1208	145	70	what	what	PRON
cblr-1208	145	71	?	?	PUNCT
cblr-1208	146	1	answering	answer	VERB
cblr-1208	146	2	that	that	DET
cblr-1208	146	3	question	question	NOUN
cblr-1208	146	4	requires	require	VERB
cblr-1208	146	5	benchmarking	benchmarke	VERB
cblr-1208	146	6	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	146	7	resulting	result	VERB
cblr-1208	146	8	market	market	NOUN
cblr-1208	146	9	against	against	ADP
cblr-1208	146	10	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	146	11	market	market	NOUN
cblr-1208	146	12	posited	posit	VERB
cblr-1208	146	13	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	146	14	counterfactually	counterfactually	PROPN
cblr-1208	146	15	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	146	16	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	146	17	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	146	18	absence	absence	NOUN
cblr-1208	146	19	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	146	20	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	146	21	allegedly	allegedly	ADV
cblr-1208	146	22	anticompetitive	anticompetitive	ADJ
cblr-1208	146	23	agreement.34	agreement.34	NOUN
cblr-1208	146	24	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	146	25	counterfactual	counterfactual	ADJ
cblr-1208	146	26	market	market	NOUN
cblr-1208	146	27	has	have	AUX
cblr-1208	146	28	come	come	VERB
cblr-1208	146	29	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	146	30	be	be	AUX
cblr-1208	146	31	called	call	VERB
cblr-1208	146	32	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	146	33	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	146	34	but	but	CCONJ
cblr-1208	146	35	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-1208	146	36	for	for	ADP
cblr-1208	146	37	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	146	38	world	world	NOUN
cblr-1208	146	39	—	—	PUNCT
cblr-1208	146	40	i.e.	i.e.	X
cblr-1208	146	41	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	146	42	what	what	PRON
cblr-1208	146	43	would	would	AUX
cblr-1208	146	44	have	have	AUX
cblr-1208	146	45	happened	happen	VERB
cblr-1208	146	46	but	but	CCONJ
cblr-1208	146	47	for	for	ADP
cblr-1208	146	48	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	146	49	allegedly	allegedly	ADV
cblr-1208	146	50	anticompetitive	anticompetitive	ADJ
cblr-1208	146	51	agreement.35	agreement.35	PROPN
cblr-1208	146	52	describing	describe	VERB
cblr-1208	146	53	such	such	DET
cblr-1208	146	54	a	a	PRON
cblr-1208	146	55	but	but	CCONJ
cblr-1208	146	56	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-1208	146	57	for	for	ADP
cblr-1208	146	58	world	world	NOUN
cblr-1208	146	59	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	146	60	determining	determine	VERB
cblr-1208	146	61	whether	whether	SCONJ
cblr-1208	146	62	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	146	63	32	32	NUM
cblr-1208	146	64	united	united	ADJ
cblr-1208	146	65	states	states	PROPN
cblr-1208	146	66	v.	v.	ADP
cblr-1208	146	67	addyston	addyston	PROPN
cblr-1208	146	68	pipe	pipe	PROPN
cblr-1208	146	69	&	&	CCONJ
cblr-1208	146	70	steel	steel	PROPN
cblr-1208	146	71	co.	co.	PROPN
cblr-1208	146	72	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	146	73	85	85	NUM
cblr-1208	146	74	f.	f.	PROPN
cblr-1208	146	75	271	271	NUM
cblr-1208	146	76	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-1208	146	77	6th	6th	ADJ
cblr-1208	146	78	cir	cir	NOUN
cblr-1208	146	79	.	.	PROPN
cblr-1208	146	80	1898	1898	NUM
cblr-1208	146	81	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-1208	146	82	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	146	83	aff’d	aff’d	VERB
cblr-1208	146	84	175	175	NUM
cblr-1208	146	85	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-1208	146	86	.	.	PROPN
cblr-1208	146	87	211	211	NUM
cblr-1208	146	88	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-1208	146	89	1899	1899	NUM
cblr-1208	146	90	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-1208	146	91	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	147	1	33	33	NUM
cblr-1208	147	2	see	see	VERB
cblr-1208	147	3	william	william	PROPN
cblr-1208	147	4	h.	h.	PROPN
cblr-1208	147	5	rooney	rooney	PROPN
cblr-1208	147	6	&	&	CCONJ
cblr-1208	147	7	timothy	timothy	PROPN
cblr-1208	147	8	g.	g.	PROPN
cblr-1208	147	9	fleming	fleming	PROPN
cblr-1208	147	10	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	147	11	introduction	introduction	NOUN
cblr-1208	147	12	:	:	PUNCT
cblr-1208	147	13	william	william	PROPN
cblr-1208	147	14	howard	howard	PROPN
cblr-1208	147	15	taft	taft	PROPN
cblr-1208	147	16	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	147	17	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	147	18	origin	origin	NOUN
cblr-1208	147	19	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	147	20	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	147	21	rule	rule	NOUN
cblr-1208	147	22	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	147	23	reason	reason	NOUN
cblr-1208	147	24	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	147	25	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	147	26	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	147	27	actavis	actavis	ADJ
cblr-1208	147	28	challenge	challenge	NOUN
cblr-1208	147	29	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	147	30	2018	2018	NUM
cblr-1208	147	31	colum	colum	NOUN
cblr-1208	147	32	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	148	1	bus	bus	NOUN
cblr-1208	148	2	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	149	1	l.	l.	PROPN
cblr-1208	149	2	rev	rev	PROPN
cblr-1208	149	3	.	.	PROPN
cblr-1208	149	4	1	1	NUM
cblr-1208	149	5	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	149	6	14	14	NUM
cblr-1208	149	7	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-1208	149	8	2018	2018	NUM
cblr-1208	149	9	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-1208	149	10	;	;	PUNCT
cblr-1208	149	11	see	see	VERB
cblr-1208	149	12	also	also	ADV
cblr-1208	149	13	carrier	carrier	NOUN
cblr-1208	149	14	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	149	15	supra	supra	PROPN
cblr-1208	149	16	note	note	NOUN
cblr-1208	149	17	27	27	NUM
cblr-1208	149	18	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	149	19	at	at	ADP
cblr-1208	149	20	29	29	NUM
cblr-1208	149	21	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	150	1	34	34	NUM
cblr-1208	150	2	see	see	VERB
cblr-1208	150	3	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	150	4	e.g.	e.g.	ADV
cblr-1208	150	5	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	150	6	chicago	chicago	PROPN
cblr-1208	150	7	bd	bd	PROPN
cblr-1208	150	8	.	.	PROPN
cblr-1208	150	9	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	150	10	trade	trade	PROPN
cblr-1208	150	11	v.	v.	ADP
cblr-1208	150	12	united	united	PROPN
cblr-1208	150	13	states	states	PROPN
cblr-1208	150	14	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	150	15	246	246	NUM
cblr-1208	150	16	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-1208	150	17	.	.	PROPN
cblr-1208	150	18	231	231	NUM
cblr-1208	150	19	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	150	20	238	238	NUM
cblr-1208	150	21	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-1208	150	22	1918	1918	NUM
cblr-1208	150	23	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-1208	150	24	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-1208	150	25	explaining	explain	VERB
cblr-1208	150	26	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	150	27	under	under	ADP
cblr-1208	150	28	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	150	29	rule	rule	NOUN
cblr-1208	150	30	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	150	31	reason	reason	NOUN
cblr-1208	150	32	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	150	33	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	150	34	court	court	NOUN
cblr-1208	150	35	must	must	AUX
cblr-1208	150	36	consider	consider	VERB
cblr-1208	150	37	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	150	38	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	150	39	facts	fact	NOUN
cblr-1208	150	40	peculiar	peculiar	ADJ
cblr-1208	150	41	to	to	ADP
cblr-1208	150	42	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	150	43	business	business	NOUN
cblr-1208	150	44	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	150	45	which	which	PRON
cblr-1208	150	46	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	150	47	restraint	restraint	NOUN
cblr-1208	150	48	is	be	AUX
cblr-1208	150	49	applied	apply	VERB
cblr-1208	150	50	;	;	PUNCT
cblr-1208	150	51	its	its	PRON
cblr-1208	150	52	condition	condition	NOUN
cblr-1208	150	53	before	before	ADP
cblr-1208	150	54	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	150	55	after	after	SCONJ
cblr-1208	150	56	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	150	57	restraint	restraint	NOUN
cblr-1208	150	58	was	be	AUX
cblr-1208	150	59	imposed	impose	VERB
cblr-1208	150	60	;	;	PUNCT
cblr-1208	150	61	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	150	62	nature	nature	NOUN
cblr-1208	150	63	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	150	64	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	150	65	restraint	restraint	NOUN
cblr-1208	150	66	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	150	67	its	its	PRON
cblr-1208	150	68	effect	effect	NOUN
cblr-1208	150	69	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	150	70	actual	actual	ADJ
cblr-1208	150	71	or	or	CCONJ
cblr-1208	150	72	probable	probable	ADJ
cblr-1208	150	73	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	150	74	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-1208	150	75	;	;	PUNCT
cblr-1208	150	76	nat’l	nat’l	NOUN
cblr-1208	150	77	soc’y	soc’y	NOUN
cblr-1208	150	78	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	150	79	prof’l	prof’l	NOUN
cblr-1208	150	80	eng’rs	eng’rs	PROPN
cblr-1208	150	81	v.	v.	PROPN
cblr-1208	150	82	united	united	PROPN
cblr-1208	150	83	states	states	PROPN
cblr-1208	150	84	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	150	85	435	435	NUM
cblr-1208	150	86	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-1208	150	87	.	.	PROPN
cblr-1208	150	88	679	679	NUM
cblr-1208	150	89	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	150	90	688	688	NUM
cblr-1208	150	91	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-1208	150	92	1978	1978	NUM
cblr-1208	150	93	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-1208	150	94	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-1208	150	95	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	150	96	rule	rule	NOUN
cblr-1208	150	97	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	150	98	reason	reason	NOUN
cblr-1208	150	99	focuses	focus	VERB
cblr-1208	150	100	on	on	ADP
cblr-1208	150	101	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	150	102	challenged	challenge	VERB
cblr-1208	150	103	restraint	restraint	NOUN
cblr-1208	150	104	’s	’s	PART
cblr-1208	150	105	impact	impact	NOUN
cblr-1208	150	106	on	on	ADP
cblr-1208	150	107	competitive	competitive	ADJ
cblr-1208	150	108	conditions	condition	NOUN
cblr-1208	150	109	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	150	110	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-1208	150	111	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	151	1	35	35	NUM
cblr-1208	151	2	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	151	3	analysis	analysis	NOUN
cblr-1208	151	4	is	be	AUX
cblr-1208	151	5	excused	excuse	VERB
cblr-1208	151	6	only	only	ADV
cblr-1208	151	7	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	151	8	per	per	ADP
cblr-1208	151	9	se	se	X
cblr-1208	151	10	cases	case	NOUN
cblr-1208	151	11	—	—	PUNCT
cblr-1208	151	12	not	not	PART
cblr-1208	151	13	because	because	SCONJ
cblr-1208	151	14	those	those	DET
cblr-1208	151	15	cases	case	NOUN
cblr-1208	151	16	involve	involve	VERB
cblr-1208	151	17	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	151	18	different	different	ADJ
cblr-1208	151	19	competitive	competitive	ADJ
cblr-1208	151	20	harm	harm	NOUN
cblr-1208	151	21	—	—	PUNCT
cblr-1208	151	22	but	but	CCONJ
cblr-1208	151	23	because	because	SCONJ
cblr-1208	151	24	long	long	ADJ
cblr-1208	151	25	experience	experience	NOUN
cblr-1208	151	26	teaches	teach	VERB
cblr-1208	151	27	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	151	28	there	there	PRON
cblr-1208	151	29	is	be	VERB
cblr-1208	151	30	little	little	ADJ
cblr-1208	151	31	too	too	ADV
cblr-1208	151	32	potential	potential	ADJ
cblr-1208	151	33	market	market	NOUN
cblr-1208	151	34	benefit	benefit	NOUN
cblr-1208	151	35	to	to	ADP
cblr-1208	151	36	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	151	37	agreement	agreement	NOUN
cblr-1208	151	38	at	at	ADP
cblr-1208	151	39	issue	issue	NOUN
cblr-1208	151	40	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	151	41	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	151	42	significant	significant	ADJ
cblr-1208	151	43	if	if	SCONJ
cblr-1208	151	44	not	not	PART
cblr-1208	151	45	certain	certain	ADJ
cblr-1208	151	46	risk	risk	NOUN
cblr-1208	151	47	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	151	48	harm	harm	NOUN
cblr-1208	151	49	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	151	50	such	such	ADJ
cblr-1208	151	51	as	as	ADP
cblr-1208	151	52	agreements	agreement	NOUN
cblr-1208	151	53	among	among	ADP
cblr-1208	151	54	competitors	competitor	NOUN
cblr-1208	151	55	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	151	56	fix	fix	VERB
cblr-1208	151	57	or	or	CCONJ
cblr-1208	151	58	raise	raise	VERB
cblr-1208	151	59	prices	price	NOUN
cblr-1208	151	60	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	151	61	rig	rig	NOUN
cblr-1208	151	62	bids	bid	NOUN
cblr-1208	151	63	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	151	64	or	or	CCONJ
cblr-1208	151	65	allocate	allocate	ADJ
cblr-1208	151	66	markets	market	NOUN
cblr-1208	151	67	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	152	1	see	see	VERB
cblr-1208	152	2	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	152	3	e.g.	e.g.	ADV
cblr-1208	152	4	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	152	5	nat’l	nat’l	NOUN
cblr-1208	152	6	collegiate	collegiate	VERB
cblr-1208	152	7	athletic	athletic	ADJ
cblr-1208	152	8	ass’n	ass’n	NOUN
cblr-1208	152	9	v.	v.	ADP
cblr-1208	152	10	bd	bd	PROPN
cblr-1208	152	11	.	.	PROPN
cblr-1208	152	12	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	152	13	regents	regent	NOUN
cblr-1208	152	14	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	152	15	univ	univ	PROPN
cblr-1208	152	16	.	.	PROPN
cblr-1208	152	17	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	152	18	oklahoma	oklahoma	PROPN
cblr-1208	152	19	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	152	20	468	468	NUM
cblr-1208	152	21	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-1208	152	22	.	.	PROPN
cblr-1208	152	23	85	85	NUM
cblr-1208	152	24	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	152	25	103	103	NUM
cblr-1208	152	26	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	152	27	104	104	NUM
cblr-1208	152	28	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-1208	152	29	1984	1984	NUM
cblr-1208	152	30	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-1208	152	31	;	;	PUNCT
cblr-1208	152	32	broad	broad	ADJ
cblr-1208	152	33	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	153	1	music	music	NOUN
cblr-1208	153	2	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	153	3	inc	inc	PROPN
cblr-1208	153	4	.	.	PROPN
cblr-1208	153	5	v.	v.	PROPN
cblr-1208	153	6	columbia	columbia	PROPN
cblr-1208	153	7	broad	broad	PROPN
cblr-1208	153	8	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	154	1	sys	sys	PROPN
cblr-1208	154	2	.	.	PROPN
cblr-1208	154	3	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	154	4	441	441	NUM
cblr-1208	154	5	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-1208	154	6	.	.	PROPN
cblr-1208	154	7	1	1	NUM
cblr-1208	154	8	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	154	9	19–20	19–20	NUM
cblr-1208	154	10	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-1208	154	11	1979	1979	NUM
cblr-1208	154	12	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-1208	154	13	;	;	PUNCT
cblr-1208	154	14	nat’l	nat’l	NOUN
cblr-1208	154	15	soc’y	soc’y	NOUN
cblr-1208	154	16	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	154	17	prof’l	prof’l	NOUN
cblr-1208	154	18	eng’rs	eng’rs	PROPN
cblr-1208	154	19	v.	v.	PROPN
cblr-1208	154	20	united	united	PROPN
cblr-1208	154	21	states	states	PROPN
cblr-1208	154	22	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	154	23	435	435	NUM
cblr-1208	154	24	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-1208	154	25	.	.	PROPN
cblr-1208	154	26	679	679	NUM
cblr-1208	154	27	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	154	28	692	692	NUM
cblr-1208	154	29	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-1208	154	30	1978	1978	NUM
cblr-1208	154	31	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-1208	154	32	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	155	1	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	155	2	recent	recent	ADJ
cblr-1208	155	3	decades	decade	NOUN
cblr-1208	155	4	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	155	5	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	155	6	universe	universe	NOUN
cblr-1208	155	7	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	155	8	agreements	agreement	NOUN
cblr-1208	155	9	deemed	deem	VERB
cblr-1208	155	10	per	per	ADP
cblr-1208	155	11	se	se	X
cblr-1208	155	12	unlawful	unlawful	ADJ
cblr-1208	155	13	has	have	AUX
cblr-1208	155	14	shrunk	shrink	VERB
cblr-1208	155	15	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	155	16	as	as	SCONJ
cblr-1208	155	17	courts	court	NOUN
cblr-1208	155	18	have	have	AUX
cblr-1208	155	19	recognized	recognize	VERB
cblr-1208	155	20	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	155	21	agreements	agreement	NOUN
cblr-1208	155	22	previously	previously	ADV
cblr-1208	155	23	thought	think	VERB
cblr-1208	155	24	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	155	25	be	be	AUX
cblr-1208	155	26	always	always	ADV
cblr-1208	155	27	or	or	CCONJ
cblr-1208	155	28	almost	almost	ADV
cblr-1208	155	29	always	always	ADV
cblr-1208	155	30	anticompetitive	anticompetitive	ADJ
cblr-1208	155	31	effect	effect	NOUN
cblr-1208	155	32	have	have	AUX
cblr-1208	155	33	been	be	AUX
cblr-1208	155	34	shown	show	VERB
cblr-1208	155	35	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	155	36	yield	yield	VERB
cblr-1208	155	37	benefits	benefit	NOUN
cblr-1208	155	38	for	for	ADP
cblr-1208	155	39	competition	competition	NOUN
cblr-1208	155	40	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	156	1	see	see	VERB
cblr-1208	156	2	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	156	3	e.g.	e.g.	ADV
cblr-1208	156	4	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	156	5	leegin	leegin	NOUN
cblr-1208	156	6	creative	creative	ADJ
cblr-1208	156	7	leather	leather	NOUN
cblr-1208	156	8	prods	prod	NOUN
cblr-1208	156	9	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	156	10	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	156	11	inc	inc	PROPN
cblr-1208	156	12	.	.	PROPN
cblr-1208	157	1	v.	v.	PROPN
cblr-1208	157	2	psks	psks	PROPN
cblr-1208	157	3	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	157	4	inc	inc	PROPN
cblr-1208	157	5	.	.	PROPN
cblr-1208	157	6	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	157	7	551	551	NUM
cblr-1208	157	8	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-1208	157	9	.	.	PROPN
cblr-1208	157	10	877	877	NUM
cblr-1208	157	11	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-1208	157	12	2007	2007	NUM
cblr-1208	157	13	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-1208	157	14	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	158	1	lecture_commentary_final	lecture_commentary_final	PROPN
cblr-1208	159	1	no	no	INTJ
cblr-1208	159	2	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	160	1	1:45	1:45	NUM
cblr-1208	160	2	]	]	PUNCT
cblr-1208	160	3	commentary	commentary	NOUN
cblr-1208	160	4	:	:	PUNCT
cblr-1208	160	5	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	160	6	rule	rule	NOUN
cblr-1208	160	7	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	160	8	reason	reason	NOUN
cblr-1208	160	9	55	55	NUM
cblr-1208	160	10	post	post	ADJ
cblr-1208	160	11	-	-	ADJ
cblr-1208	160	12	agreement	agreement	ADJ
cblr-1208	160	13	market	market	NOUN
cblr-1208	160	14	is	be	AUX
cblr-1208	160	15	less	less	ADV
cblr-1208	160	16	competitive	competitive	ADJ
cblr-1208	160	17	than	than	ADP
cblr-1208	160	18	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	160	19	but	but	CCONJ
cblr-1208	160	20	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-1208	160	21	for	for	ADP
cblr-1208	160	22	market	market	NOUN
cblr-1208	160	23	is	be	AUX
cblr-1208	160	24	an	an	DET
cblr-1208	160	25	essential	essential	ADJ
cblr-1208	160	26	step	step	NOUN
cblr-1208	160	27	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	160	28	determining	determine	VERB
cblr-1208	160	29	whether	whether	SCONJ
cblr-1208	160	30	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	160	31	challenged	challenge	VERB
cblr-1208	160	32	agreement	agreement	NOUN
cblr-1208	160	33	has	have	AUX
cblr-1208	160	34	caused	cause	VERB
cblr-1208	160	35	injury	injury	NOUN
cblr-1208	160	36	to	to	ADP
cblr-1208	160	37	competition	competition	NOUN
cblr-1208	160	38	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	161	1	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	161	2	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	161	3	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	161	4	course	course	NOUN
cblr-1208	161	5	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	161	6	injury	injury	NOUN
cblr-1208	161	7	to	to	ADP
cblr-1208	161	8	competition	competition	NOUN
cblr-1208	161	9	is	be	AUX
cblr-1208	161	10	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	161	11	required	require	VERB
cblr-1208	161	12	element	element	NOUN
cblr-1208	161	13	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	161	14	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	161	15	antitrust	antitrust	ADJ
cblr-1208	161	16	violation	violation	NOUN
cblr-1208	161	17	—	—	PUNCT
cblr-1208	161	18	no	no	DET
cblr-1208	161	19	injury	injury	NOUN
cblr-1208	161	20	to	to	ADP
cblr-1208	161	21	competition	competition	NOUN
cblr-1208	161	22	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	161	23	no	no	DET
cblr-1208	161	24	antitrust	antitrust	ADJ
cblr-1208	161	25	violation.36	violation.36	NOUN
cblr-1208	161	26	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	161	27	actavis	actavis	ADJ
cblr-1208	161	28	holdings	holding	NOUN
cblr-1208	161	29	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	161	30	which	which	PRON
cblr-1208	161	31	rule	rule	VERB
cblr-1208	161	32	out	out	ADP
cblr-1208	161	33	per	per	ADP
cblr-1208	161	34	se	se	X
cblr-1208	161	35	rules	rule	NOUN
cblr-1208	161	36	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	161	37	presumptions	presumption	NOUN
cblr-1208	161	38	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	161	39	pose	pose	VERB
cblr-1208	161	40	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	161	41	challenge	challenge	NOUN
cblr-1208	161	42	for	for	ADP
cblr-1208	161	43	courts	court	NOUN
cblr-1208	161	44	attempting	attempt	VERB
cblr-1208	161	45	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	161	46	implement	implement	VERB
cblr-1208	161	47	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	161	48	rule	rule	NOUN
cblr-1208	161	49	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	161	50	reason	reason	NOUN
cblr-1208	161	51	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	161	52	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	161	53	case	case	NOUN
cblr-1208	161	54	involving	involve	VERB
cblr-1208	161	55	alleged	allege	VERB
cblr-1208	161	56	reverse	reverse	ADJ
cblr-1208	161	57	payments	payment	NOUN
cblr-1208	161	58	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	162	1	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	162	2	starting	starting	NOUN
cblr-1208	162	3	point	point	NOUN
cblr-1208	162	4	for	for	ADP
cblr-1208	162	5	analysis	analysis	NOUN
cblr-1208	162	6	must	must	AUX
cblr-1208	162	7	be	be	AUX
cblr-1208	162	8	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	162	9	settlement	settlement	NOUN
cblr-1208	162	10	that	that	PRON
cblr-1208	162	11	resolves	resolve	NOUN
cblr-1208	162	12	bona	bona	VERB
cblr-1208	162	13	fide	fide	VERB
cblr-1208	162	14	patent	patent	NOUN
cblr-1208	162	15	litigation	litigation	NOUN
cblr-1208	162	16	that	that	PRON
cblr-1208	162	17	either	either	DET
cblr-1208	162	18	party	party	NOUN
cblr-1208	162	19	could	could	AUX
cblr-1208	162	20	conceivably	conceivably	ADV
cblr-1208	162	21	win	win	VERB
cblr-1208	162	22	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	162	23	as	as	SCONJ
cblr-1208	162	24	opposed	oppose	VERB
cblr-1208	162	25	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	162	26	sham	sham	VERB
cblr-1208	162	27	litigation.37	litigation.37	NOUN
cblr-1208	162	28	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	162	29	settlement	settlement	NOUN
cblr-1208	162	30	typically	typically	ADV
cblr-1208	162	31	includes	include	VERB
cblr-1208	162	32	an	an	DET
cblr-1208	162	33	entry	entry	NOUN
cblr-1208	162	34	date	date	NOUN
cblr-1208	162	35	beyond	beyond	ADP
cblr-1208	162	36	which	which	PRON
cblr-1208	162	37	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	162	38	generic	generic	ADJ
cblr-1208	162	39	challenger	challenger	NOUN
cblr-1208	162	40	might	might	AUX
cblr-1208	162	41	have	have	AUX
cblr-1208	162	42	entered	enter	VERB
cblr-1208	162	43	if	if	SCONJ
cblr-1208	162	44	it	it	PRON
cblr-1208	162	45	won	win	VERB
cblr-1208	162	46	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	162	47	patent	patent	NOUN
cblr-1208	162	48	litigation	litigation	NOUN
cblr-1208	162	49	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	162	50	earlier	early	ADV
cblr-1208	162	51	than	than	SCONJ
cblr-1208	162	52	it	it	PRON
cblr-1208	162	53	would	would	AUX
cblr-1208	162	54	have	have	AUX
cblr-1208	162	55	entered	enter	VERB
cblr-1208	162	56	if	if	SCONJ
cblr-1208	162	57	it	it	PRON
cblr-1208	162	58	had	have	AUX
cblr-1208	162	59	lost	lose	VERB
cblr-1208	162	60	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	162	61	patent	patent	NOUN
cblr-1208	162	62	litigation	litigation	NOUN
cblr-1208	162	63	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	163	1	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	163	2	settlement	settlement	NOUN
cblr-1208	163	3	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	163	4	bona	bona	ADJ
cblr-1208	163	5	fide	fide	NOUN
cblr-1208	163	6	patent	patent	NOUN
cblr-1208	163	7	litigation	litigation	NOUN
cblr-1208	163	8	is	be	AUX
cblr-1208	163	9	both	both	PRON
cblr-1208	163	10	lawful	lawful	ADJ
cblr-1208	163	11	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	163	12	procompetitive	procompetitive	ADJ
cblr-1208	163	13	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	164	1	among	among	ADP
cblr-1208	164	2	other	other	ADJ
cblr-1208	164	3	benefits	benefit	NOUN
cblr-1208	164	4	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	164	5	settlements	settlement	NOUN
cblr-1208	164	6	provide	provide	VERB
cblr-1208	164	7	certainty	certainty	NOUN
cblr-1208	164	8	as	as	ADP
cblr-1208	164	9	to	to	ADP
cblr-1208	164	10	when	when	SCONJ
cblr-1208	164	11	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	164	12	patent	patent	NOUN
cblr-1208	164	13	barrier	barrier	NOUN
cblr-1208	164	14	to	to	ADP
cblr-1208	164	15	entry	entry	NOUN
cblr-1208	164	16	will	will	AUX
cblr-1208	164	17	be	be	AUX
cblr-1208	164	18	lifted	lift	VERB
cblr-1208	164	19	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	164	20	an	an	DET
cblr-1208	164	21	entry	entry	NOUN
cblr-1208	164	22	date	date	NOUN
cblr-1208	164	23	earlier	early	ADV
cblr-1208	164	24	than	than	ADP
cblr-1208	164	25	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	164	26	patent	patent	NOUN
cblr-1208	164	27	expiration	expiration	NOUN
cblr-1208	164	28	date	date	NOUN
cblr-1208	164	29	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	165	1	that	that	DET
cblr-1208	165	2	certainty	certainty	PROPN
cblr-1208	165	3	is	be	AUX
cblr-1208	165	4	important	important	ADJ
cblr-1208	165	5	to	to	ADP
cblr-1208	165	6	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	165	7	generic	generic	NOUN
cblr-1208	165	8	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	165	9	it	it	PRON
cblr-1208	165	10	is	be	AUX
cblr-1208	165	11	important	important	ADJ
cblr-1208	165	12	for	for	ADP
cblr-1208	165	13	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	165	14	brand	brand	NOUN
cblr-1208	165	15	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	165	16	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	165	17	it	it	PRON
cblr-1208	165	18	is	be	AUX
cblr-1208	165	19	important	important	ADJ
cblr-1208	165	20	to	to	ADP
cblr-1208	165	21	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	165	22	patients	patient	NOUN
cblr-1208	165	23	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	165	24	payers	payer	NOUN
cblr-1208	165	25	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	166	1	it	it	PRON
cblr-1208	166	2	saves	save	VERB
cblr-1208	166	3	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	166	4	parties	party	NOUN
cblr-1208	166	5	money	money	NOUN
cblr-1208	166	6	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	166	7	business	business	NOUN
cblr-1208	166	8	time	time	NOUN
cblr-1208	166	9	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	166	10	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	166	11	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	166	12	distraction	distraction	NOUN
cblr-1208	166	13	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	166	14	litigation	litigation	NOUN
cblr-1208	166	15	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	167	1	it	it	PRON
cblr-1208	167	2	also	also	ADV
cblr-1208	167	3	relieves	relieve	VERB
cblr-1208	167	4	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	167	5	courts	court	NOUN
cblr-1208	167	6	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	167	7	taxpayers	taxpayer	NOUN
cblr-1208	167	8	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	167	9	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	167	10	costs	cost	NOUN
cblr-1208	167	11	imposed	impose	VERB
cblr-1208	167	12	by	by	ADP
cblr-1208	167	13	litigation	litigation	NOUN
cblr-1208	167	14	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	168	1	courts	court	NOUN
cblr-1208	168	2	must	must	AUX
cblr-1208	168	3	be	be	AUX
cblr-1208	168	4	disciplined	discipline	VERB
cblr-1208	168	5	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	168	6	avoiding	avoid	VERB
cblr-1208	168	7	unwarranted	unwarranted	ADJ
cblr-1208	168	8	shortcuts	shortcut	NOUN
cblr-1208	168	9	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	169	1	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	169	2	marketing	marketing	NOUN
cblr-1208	169	3	phrase	phrase	NOUN
cblr-1208	169	4	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	169	5	pay	pay	VERB
cblr-1208	169	6	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-1208	169	7	for	for	ADP
cblr-1208	169	8	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-1208	169	9	delay	delay	NOUN
cblr-1208	169	10	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	169	11	carries	carry	VERB
cblr-1208	169	12	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	169	13	presumption	presumption	NOUN
cblr-1208	169	14	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	169	15	where	where	SCONJ
cblr-1208	169	16	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	169	17	patent	patent	NOUN
cblr-1208	169	18	settlement	settlement	NOUN
cblr-1208	169	19	includes	include	VERB
cblr-1208	169	20	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	169	21	reverse	reverse	ADJ
cblr-1208	169	22	payment	payment	NOUN
cblr-1208	169	23	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	169	24	entry	entry	NOUN
cblr-1208	169	25	is	be	AUX
cblr-1208	169	26	necessarily	necessarily	ADV
cblr-1208	169	27	delayed	delay	VERB
cblr-1208	169	28	beyond	beyond	ADP
cblr-1208	169	29	what	what	PRON
cblr-1208	169	30	would	would	AUX
cblr-1208	169	31	have	have	AUX
cblr-1208	169	32	transpired	transpire	VERB
cblr-1208	169	33	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	169	34	some	some	DET
cblr-1208	169	35	alternative	alternative	ADJ
cblr-1208	169	36	scenario	scenario	NOUN
cblr-1208	169	37	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	170	1	but	but	CCONJ
cblr-1208	170	2	whether	whether	SCONJ
cblr-1208	170	3	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	170	4	payment	payment	NOUN
cblr-1208	170	5	that	that	PRON
cblr-1208	170	6	accompanies	accompany	VERB
cblr-1208	170	7	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	170	8	patent	patent	NOUN
cblr-1208	170	9	litigation	litigation	NOUN
cblr-1208	170	10	settlement	settlement	NOUN
cblr-1208	170	11	is	be	AUX
cblr-1208	170	12	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	170	13	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	170	14	restraint	restraint	NOUN
cblr-1208	170	15	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	170	16	at	at	ADV
cblr-1208	170	17	all	all	ADV
cblr-1208	170	18	is	be	AUX
cblr-1208	170	19	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	170	20	question	question	NOUN
cblr-1208	170	21	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	170	22	fact	fact	NOUN
cblr-1208	170	23	that	that	PRON
cblr-1208	170	24	must	must	AUX
cblr-1208	170	25	36	36	NUM
cblr-1208	170	26	see	see	VERB
cblr-1208	170	27	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	170	28	e.g.	e.g.	ADV
cblr-1208	170	29	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	170	30	phillip	phillip	PROPN
cblr-1208	170	31	e.	e.	PROPN
cblr-1208	170	32	areeda	areeda	PROPN
cblr-1208	170	33	&	&	CCONJ
cblr-1208	170	34	herbert	herbert	PROPN
cblr-1208	170	35	hovenkamp	hovenkamp	PROPN
cblr-1208	170	36	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	170	37	antitrust	antitrust	ADJ
cblr-1208	170	38	law	law	NOUN
cblr-1208	170	39	:	:	PUNCT
cblr-1208	170	40	an	an	DET
cblr-1208	170	41	analysis	analysis	NOUN
cblr-1208	170	42	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	170	43	antitrust	antitrust	ADJ
cblr-1208	170	44	principles	principle	NOUN
cblr-1208	170	45	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	170	46	their	their	PRON
cblr-1208	170	47	application	application	NOUN
cblr-1208	170	48	¶	¶	PROPN
cblr-1208	170	49	337a	337a	PROPN
cblr-1208	170	50	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-1208	170	51	4th	4th	ADJ
cblr-1208	170	52	ed	ed	NOUN
cblr-1208	170	53	.	.	PROPN
cblr-1208	170	54	2017	2017	NUM
cblr-1208	170	55	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-1208	170	56	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-1208	170	57	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	170	58	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	170	59	say	say	VERB
cblr-1208	170	60	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	170	61	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	170	62	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
cblr-1208	170	63	has	have	AUX
cblr-1208	170	64	not	not	PART
cblr-1208	170	65	shown	show	VERB
cblr-1208	170	66	any	any	DET
cblr-1208	170	67	injury	injury	NOUN
cblr-1208	170	68	to	to	ADP
cblr-1208	170	69	competition	competition	NOUN
cblr-1208	170	70	is	be	AUX
cblr-1208	170	71	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	170	72	conclude	conclude	VERB
cblr-1208	170	73	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	170	74	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	170	75	antitrust	antitrust	ADJ
cblr-1208	170	76	laws	law	NOUN
cblr-1208	170	77	have	have	AUX
cblr-1208	170	78	not	not	PART
cblr-1208	170	79	been	be	AUX
cblr-1208	170	80	violated	violate	VERB
cblr-1208	170	81	at	at	ADV
cblr-1208	170	82	all	all	ADV
cblr-1208	170	83	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	170	84	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	170	85	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-1208	170	86	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	171	1	37	37	NUM
cblr-1208	171	2	prof’l	prof’l	NOUN
cblr-1208	171	3	real	real	ADJ
cblr-1208	171	4	estate	estate	NOUN
cblr-1208	171	5	inv’rs	inv’rs	NOUN
cblr-1208	171	6	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	171	7	inc	inc	PROPN
cblr-1208	171	8	.	.	PROPN
cblr-1208	171	9	v.	v.	PROPN
cblr-1208	171	10	columbia	columbia	PROPN
cblr-1208	171	11	pictures	picture	NOUN
cblr-1208	171	12	indus	indus	PROPN
cblr-1208	171	13	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	171	14	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	171	15	508	508	NUM
cblr-1208	171	16	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-1208	171	17	.	.	PROPN
cblr-1208	171	18	49	49	NUM
cblr-1208	171	19	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	171	20	60	60	NUM
cblr-1208	171	21	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-1208	171	22	1993	1993	NUM
cblr-1208	171	23	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-1208	171	24	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	172	1	lecture_commentary_final	lecture_commentary_final	PROPN
cblr-1208	172	2	56	56	NUM
cblr-1208	172	3	columbia	columbia	PROPN
cblr-1208	172	4	business	business	NOUN
cblr-1208	172	5	law	law	PROPN
cblr-1208	172	6	review	review	NOUN
cblr-1208	172	7	[	[	X
cblr-1208	172	8	vol	vol	NOUN
cblr-1208	172	9	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	172	10	2018	2018	NUM
cblr-1208	172	11	be	be	AUX
cblr-1208	172	12	proven	prove	VERB
cblr-1208	172	13	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	173	1	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	173	2	establish	establish	VERB
cblr-1208	173	3	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	173	4	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	173	5	payment	payment	NOUN
cblr-1208	173	6	is	be	AUX
cblr-1208	173	7	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	173	8	restraint	restraint	NOUN
cblr-1208	173	9	requires	require	VERB
cblr-1208	173	10	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	173	11	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
cblr-1208	173	12	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	173	13	show	show	VERB
cblr-1208	173	14	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	173	15	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	173	16	without	without	ADP
cblr-1208	173	17	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	173	18	payment	payment	NOUN
cblr-1208	173	19	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	173	20	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	173	21	market	market	NOUN
cblr-1208	173	22	would	would	AUX
cblr-1208	173	23	have	have	AUX
cblr-1208	173	24	been	be	AUX
cblr-1208	173	25	more	more	ADV
cblr-1208	173	26	competitive	competitive	ADJ
cblr-1208	173	27	—	—	PUNCT
cblr-1208	173	28	i.e.	i.e.	X
cblr-1208	173	29	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	173	30	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	173	31	generic	generic	ADJ
cblr-1208	173	32	entry	entry	NOUN
cblr-1208	173	33	would	would	AUX
cblr-1208	173	34	have	have	AUX
cblr-1208	173	35	taken	take	VERB
cblr-1208	173	36	place	place	NOUN
cblr-1208	173	37	sooner	soon	ADV
cblr-1208	173	38	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	174	1	iv	iv	X
cblr-1208	174	2	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	174	3	presumptions	presumption	NOUN
cblr-1208	174	4	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	174	5	shortcuts	shortcut	NOUN
cblr-1208	174	6	that	that	PRON
cblr-1208	174	7	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	174	8	ftc	ftc	PROPN
cblr-1208	174	9	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	174	10	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
cblr-1208	174	11	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	174	12	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	174	13	professors	professor	NOUN
cblr-1208	174	14	seek	seek	VERB
cblr-1208	174	15	are	be	AUX
cblr-1208	174	16	contrary	contrary	ADJ
cblr-1208	174	17	to	to	ADP
cblr-1208	174	18	actavis	actavis	ADJ
cblr-1208	174	19	’	'	PUNCT
cblr-1208	174	20	holdings	holding	NOUN
cblr-1208	174	21	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	174	22	could	could	AUX
cblr-1208	174	23	damage	damage	VERB
cblr-1208	174	24	rule	rule	NOUN
cblr-1208	174	25	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	174	26	reason	reason	NOUN
cblr-1208	174	27	analysis	analysis	NOUN
cblr-1208	174	28	generally	generally	ADV
cblr-1208	174	29	following	follow	VERB
cblr-1208	174	30	actavis	actavis	NOUN
cblr-1208	174	31	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	174	32	however	however	ADV
cblr-1208	174	33	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	174	34	commentators	commentator	NOUN
cblr-1208	174	35	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	174	36	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
cblr-1208	174	37	have	have	AUX
cblr-1208	174	38	seized	seize	VERB
cblr-1208	174	39	on	on	ADP
cblr-1208	174	40	justice	justice	NOUN
cblr-1208	174	41	breyer	breyer	NOUN
cblr-1208	174	42	’s	’s	PART
cblr-1208	174	43	commentary	commentary	NOUN
cblr-1208	174	44	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	174	45	construing	construe	VERB
cblr-1208	174	46	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	174	47	actavis	actavis	NOUN
cblr-1208	174	48	holding	hold	VERB
cblr-1208	174	49	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	174	50	permit	permit	VERB
cblr-1208	174	51	shortcuts	shortcut	NOUN
cblr-1208	174	52	that	that	PRON
cblr-1208	174	53	replace	replace	VERB
cblr-1208	174	54	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	174	55	traditional	traditional	ADJ
cblr-1208	174	56	analysis	analysis	NOUN
cblr-1208	174	57	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	174	58	anticompetitive	anticompetitive	ADJ
cblr-1208	174	59	effects	effect	NOUN
cblr-1208	174	60	under	under	ADP
cblr-1208	174	61	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	174	62	rule	rule	NOUN
cblr-1208	174	63	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	174	64	reason	reason	NOUN
cblr-1208	174	65	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	174	66	cases	case	NOUN
cblr-1208	174	67	involving	involve	VERB
cblr-1208	174	68	alleged	allege	VERB
cblr-1208	174	69	reverse	reverse	ADJ
cblr-1208	174	70	payments	payment	NOUN
cblr-1208	174	71	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	175	1	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	175	2	approach	approach	NOUN
cblr-1208	175	3	that	that	PRON
cblr-1208	175	4	professor	professor	NOUN
cblr-1208	175	5	michael	michael	PROPN
cblr-1208	175	6	carrier	carrier	PROPN
cblr-1208	175	7	has	have	AUX
cblr-1208	175	8	proposed	propose	VERB
cblr-1208	175	9	is	be	AUX
cblr-1208	175	10	one	one	NUM
cblr-1208	175	11	example.38	example.38	NOUN
cblr-1208	175	12	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	175	13	burden	burden	NOUN
cblr-1208	175	14	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-1208	175	15	shifting	shift	VERB
cblr-1208	175	16	framework	framework	NOUN
cblr-1208	175	17	for	for	ADP
cblr-1208	175	18	applying	apply	VERB
cblr-1208	175	19	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	175	20	rule	rule	NOUN
cblr-1208	175	21	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	175	22	reason	reason	NOUN
cblr-1208	175	23	that	that	PRON
cblr-1208	175	24	professor	professor	NOUN
cblr-1208	175	25	carrier	carrier	NOUN
cblr-1208	175	26	outlines	outline	NOUN
cblr-1208	175	27	accurately	accurately	ADV
cblr-1208	175	28	describes	describe	VERB
cblr-1208	175	29	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	175	30	way	way	NOUN
cblr-1208	175	31	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	175	32	order	order	VERB
cblr-1208	175	33	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	175	34	process	process	NOUN
cblr-1208	175	35	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	175	36	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	175	37	rule	rule	NOUN
cblr-1208	175	38	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	175	39	reason	reason	NOUN
cblr-1208	175	40	litigation.39	litigation.39	NOUN
cblr-1208	175	41	under	under	ADP
cblr-1208	175	42	this	this	DET
cblr-1208	175	43	framework	framework	NOUN
cblr-1208	175	44	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	175	45	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	175	46	rule	rule	NOUN
cblr-1208	175	47	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	175	48	reason	reason	NOUN
cblr-1208	175	49	analysis	analysis	NOUN
cblr-1208	175	50	has	have	VERB
cblr-1208	175	51	four	four	NUM
cblr-1208	175	52	potential	potential	ADJ
cblr-1208	175	53	steps	step	NOUN
cblr-1208	175	54	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	176	1	first	first	ADV
cblr-1208	176	2	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	176	3	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	176	4	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
cblr-1208	176	5	has	have	VERB
cblr-1208	176	6	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	176	7	burden	burden	NOUN
cblr-1208	176	8	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	176	9	showing	show	VERB
cblr-1208	176	10	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	176	11	substantial	substantial	ADJ
cblr-1208	176	12	anticompetitive	anticompetitive	ADJ
cblr-1208	176	13	effect.40	effect.40	NOUN
cblr-1208	176	14	second	second	ADJ
cblr-1208	176	15	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	176	16	if	if	SCONJ
cblr-1208	176	17	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	176	18	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
cblr-1208	176	19	meets	meet	VERB
cblr-1208	176	20	its	its	PRON
cblr-1208	176	21	burden	burden	NOUN
cblr-1208	176	22	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	176	23	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	176	24	defendant	defendant	NOUN
cblr-1208	176	25	has	have	VERB
cblr-1208	176	26	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	176	27	burden	burden	NOUN
cblr-1208	176	28	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	176	29	showing	show	VERB
cblr-1208	176	30	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	176	31	procompetitive	procompetitive	ADJ
cblr-1208	176	32	justification.41	justification.41	NOUN
cblr-1208	176	33	third	third	NOUN
cblr-1208	176	34	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	176	35	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	176	36	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
cblr-1208	176	37	can	can	AUX
cblr-1208	176	38	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	176	39	but	but	CCONJ
cblr-1208	176	40	need	need	VERB
cblr-1208	176	41	not	not	PART
cblr-1208	176	42	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	176	43	show	show	VERB
cblr-1208	176	44	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	176	45	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	176	46	restraint	restraint	NOUN
cblr-1208	176	47	is	be	AUX
cblr-1208	176	48	not	not	PART
cblr-1208	176	49	reasonably	reasonably	ADV
cblr-1208	176	50	necessary	necessary	ADJ
cblr-1208	176	51	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	176	52	achieve	achieve	VERB
cblr-1208	176	53	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	176	54	defendant	defendant	NOUN
cblr-1208	176	55	’s	’s	PART
cblr-1208	176	56	objective	objective	NOUN
cblr-1208	176	57	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	176	58	or	or	CCONJ
cblr-1208	176	59	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	176	60	there	there	PRON
cblr-1208	176	61	are	be	VERB
cblr-1208	176	62	less	less	ADV
cblr-1208	176	63	restrictive	restrictive	ADJ
cblr-1208	176	64	alternatives.42	alternatives.42	NOUN
cblr-1208	176	65	according	accord	VERB
cblr-1208	176	66	to	to	ADP
cblr-1208	176	67	professor	professor	NOUN
cblr-1208	176	68	carrier	carrier	NOUN
cblr-1208	176	69	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	176	70	if	if	SCONJ
cblr-1208	176	71	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	176	72	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
cblr-1208	176	73	can	can	AUX
cblr-1208	176	74	not	not	PART
cblr-1208	176	75	show	show	VERB
cblr-1208	176	76	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	176	77	less	less	ADV
cblr-1208	176	78	restrictive	restrictive	ADJ
cblr-1208	176	79	alternative	alternative	NOUN
cblr-1208	176	80	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	176	81	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	176	82	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
cblr-1208	176	83	does	do	AUX
cblr-1208	176	84	not	not	PART
cblr-1208	176	85	lose	lose	VERB
cblr-1208	176	86	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	176	87	case	case	NOUN
cblr-1208	176	88	;	;	PUNCT
cblr-1208	176	89	it	it	PRON
cblr-1208	176	90	simply	simply	ADV
cblr-1208	176	91	means	mean	VERB
cblr-1208	176	92	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	176	93	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	176	94	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
cblr-1208	176	95	does	do	AUX
cblr-1208	176	96	not	not	PART
cblr-1208	176	97	prevail	prevail	VERB
cblr-1208	176	98	at	at	ADP
cblr-1208	176	99	step	step	NOUN
cblr-1208	176	100	three.43	three.43	PROPN
cblr-1208	176	101	fourth	fourth	ADJ
cblr-1208	176	102	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	176	103	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	176	104	court	court	NOUN
cblr-1208	176	105	38	38	NUM
cblr-1208	176	106	carrier	carrier	NOUN
cblr-1208	176	107	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	176	108	supra	supra	PROPN
cblr-1208	176	109	note	note	NOUN
cblr-1208	176	110	27	27	NUM
cblr-1208	176	111	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	176	112	at	at	ADP
cblr-1208	176	113	40–43	40–43	NUM
cblr-1208	176	114	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	177	1	39	39	NUM
cblr-1208	178	1	i	i	PRON
cblr-1208	178	2	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-1208	178	3	at	at	ADP
cblr-1208	178	4	29–31	29–31	PROPN
cblr-1208	178	5	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	178	6	40	40	NUM
cblr-1208	179	1	i	i	PRON
cblr-1208	179	2	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-1208	179	3	at	at	ADP
cblr-1208	179	4	29	29	NUM
cblr-1208	179	5	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	180	1	41	41	NUM
cblr-1208	181	1	i	i	PRON
cblr-1208	181	2	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-1208	181	3	at	at	ADP
cblr-1208	181	4	29–30	29–30	NUM
cblr-1208	181	5	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	182	1	42	42	NUM
cblr-1208	183	1	i	i	PRON
cblr-1208	183	2	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-1208	183	3	at	at	ADP
cblr-1208	183	4	30	30	NUM
cblr-1208	183	5	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	184	1	43	43	NUM
cblr-1208	185	1	i	i	PRON
cblr-1208	185	2	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-1208	185	3	lecture_commentary_final	lecture_commentary_final	PROPN
cblr-1208	186	1	no	no	INTJ
cblr-1208	186	2	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	187	1	1:45	1:45	NUM
cblr-1208	187	2	]	]	PUNCT
cblr-1208	187	3	commentary	commentary	NOUN
cblr-1208	187	4	:	:	PUNCT
cblr-1208	187	5	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	187	6	rule	rule	NOUN
cblr-1208	187	7	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	187	8	reason	reason	NOUN
cblr-1208	187	9	57	57	NUM
cblr-1208	187	10	must	must	AUX
cblr-1208	187	11	balance	balance	VERB
cblr-1208	187	12	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	187	13	anticompetitive	anticompetitive	ADJ
cblr-1208	187	14	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	187	15	procompetitive	procompetitive	ADJ
cblr-1208	187	16	effects.44	effects.44	NOUN
cblr-1208	187	17	so	so	ADV
cblr-1208	187	18	far	far	ADV
cblr-1208	187	19	so	so	ADV
cblr-1208	187	20	good	good	ADJ
cblr-1208	187	21	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	188	1	while	while	SCONJ
cblr-1208	188	2	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	188	3	process	process	NOUN
cblr-1208	188	4	professor	professor	NOUN
cblr-1208	188	5	carrier	carrier	NOUN
cblr-1208	188	6	describes	describe	VERB
cblr-1208	188	7	is	be	AUX
cblr-1208	188	8	an	an	DET
cblr-1208	188	9	uncontroversial	uncontroversial	ADJ
cblr-1208	188	10	description	description	NOUN
cblr-1208	188	11	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	188	12	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	188	13	litigation	litigation	NOUN
cblr-1208	188	14	process	process	NOUN
cblr-1208	188	15	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	188	16	process	process	NOUN
cblr-1208	188	17	does	do	AUX
cblr-1208	188	18	not	not	PART
cblr-1208	188	19	dictate	dictate	VERB
cblr-1208	188	20	substance	substance	NOUN
cblr-1208	188	21	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	189	1	as	as	SCONJ
cblr-1208	189	2	noted	note	VERB
cblr-1208	189	3	above	above	ADV
cblr-1208	189	4	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	189	5	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	189	6	framework	framework	NOUN
cblr-1208	189	7	requires	require	VERB
cblr-1208	189	8	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	189	9	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
cblr-1208	189	10	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	189	11	establish	establish	VERB
cblr-1208	189	12	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	189	13	as	as	ADP
cblr-1208	189	14	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	189	15	predicate	predicate	NOUN
cblr-1208	189	16	for	for	ADP
cblr-1208	189	17	moving	move	VERB
cblr-1208	189	18	forward	forward	ADV
cblr-1208	189	19	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	189	20	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	189	21	substantial	substantial	ADJ
cblr-1208	189	22	anticompetitive	anticompetitive	ADJ
cblr-1208	189	23	effect.45	effect.45	PROPN
cblr-1208	189	24	professor	professor	NOUN
cblr-1208	189	25	carrier	carrier	NOUN
cblr-1208	189	26	proposes	propose	VERB
cblr-1208	189	27	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	189	28	allow	allow	VERB
cblr-1208	189	29	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
cblr-1208	189	30	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	189	31	satisfy	satisfy	VERB
cblr-1208	189	32	that	that	DET
cblr-1208	189	33	obligation	obligation	NOUN
cblr-1208	189	34	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	189	35	reverse	reverse	ADJ
cblr-1208	189	36	payment	payment	NOUN
cblr-1208	189	37	cases	case	NOUN
cblr-1208	189	38	by	by	ADP
cblr-1208	189	39	relying	rely	VERB
cblr-1208	189	40	on	on	ADP
cblr-1208	189	41	layers	layer	NOUN
cblr-1208	189	42	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	189	43	presumptions	presumption	NOUN
cblr-1208	189	44	that	that	PRON
cblr-1208	189	45	would	would	AUX
cblr-1208	189	46	undermine	undermine	VERB
cblr-1208	189	47	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	189	48	rule	rule	NOUN
cblr-1208	189	49	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	189	50	reason	reason	NOUN
cblr-1208	189	51	inquiry	inquiry	NOUN
cblr-1208	189	52	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	190	1	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	190	2	particular	particular	ADJ
cblr-1208	190	3	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	190	4	professor	professor	NOUN
cblr-1208	190	5	carrier	carrier	NOUN
cblr-1208	190	6	maintains	maintain	VERB
cblr-1208	190	7	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	190	8	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	190	9	actavis	actavis	PROPN
cblr-1208	190	10	court	court	NOUN
cblr-1208	190	11	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	190	12	adopted	adopt	VERB
cblr-1208	190	13	shortcuts	shortcut	NOUN
cblr-1208	190	14	favoring	favor	VERB
cblr-1208	190	15	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
cblr-1208	190	16	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	191	1	”46	”46	VERB
cblr-1208	191	2	he	he	PRON
cblr-1208	191	3	reads	read	VERB
cblr-1208	191	4	into	into	ADP
cblr-1208	191	5	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	191	6	rule	rule	NOUN
cblr-1208	191	7	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	191	8	reason	reason	NOUN
cblr-1208	191	9	analysis	analysis	NOUN
cblr-1208	191	10	justice	justice	NOUN
cblr-1208	191	11	breyer	breyer	NOUN
cblr-1208	191	12	’s	’s	PART
cblr-1208	191	13	observation	observation	NOUN
cblr-1208	191	14	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	191	15	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	191	16	size	size	NOUN
cblr-1208	191	17	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	191	18	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	191	19	unexplained	unexplained	ADJ
cblr-1208	191	20	payment	payment	NOUN
cblr-1208	191	21	may	may	AUX
cblr-1208	191	22	serve	serve	VERB
cblr-1208	191	23	as	as	ADP
cblr-1208	191	24	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	191	25	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	191	26	workable	workable	ADJ
cblr-1208	191	27	surrogate	surrogate	NOUN
cblr-1208	191	28	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	191	29	for	for	ADP
cblr-1208	191	30	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	191	31	strength	strength	NOUN
cblr-1208	191	32	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	191	33	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	191	34	patent.47	patent.47	NOUN
cblr-1208	191	35	he	he	PRON
cblr-1208	191	36	thus	thus	ADV
cblr-1208	191	37	proposes	propose	VERB
cblr-1208	191	38	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	191	39	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	191	40	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
cblr-1208	191	41	may	may	AUX
cblr-1208	191	42	meet	meet	VERB
cblr-1208	191	43	its	its	PRON
cblr-1208	191	44	burden	burden	NOUN
cblr-1208	191	45	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	191	46	showing	show	VERB
cblr-1208	191	47	substantial	substantial	ADJ
cblr-1208	191	48	anticompetitive	anticompetitive	ADJ
cblr-1208	191	49	effects	effect	NOUN
cblr-1208	191	50	by	by	ADP
cblr-1208	191	51	showing	show	VERB
cblr-1208	191	52	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	191	53	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	191	54	limit	limit	NOUN
cblr-1208	191	55	on	on	ADP
cblr-1208	191	56	generic	generic	ADJ
cblr-1208	191	57	entry	entry	NOUN
cblr-1208	191	58	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	191	59	compensation	compensation	NOUN
cblr-1208	191	60	to	to	ADP
cblr-1208	191	61	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	191	62	generic	generic	NOUN
cblr-1208	191	63	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	191	64	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	192	1	put	put	VERB
cblr-1208	192	2	another	another	DET
cblr-1208	192	3	way	way	NOUN
cblr-1208	192	4	—	—	PUNCT
cblr-1208	192	5	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	192	6	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
cblr-1208	192	7	merely	merely	ADV
cblr-1208	192	8	has	have	VERB
cblr-1208	192	9	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	192	10	show	show	VERB
cblr-1208	192	11	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	192	12	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	192	13	large	large	ADJ
cblr-1208	192	14	unexplained	unexplained	ADJ
cblr-1208	192	15	payment	payment	NOUN
cblr-1208	192	16	was	be	AUX
cblr-1208	192	17	made	make	VERB
cblr-1208	192	18	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	192	19	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	192	20	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	192	21	required	require	VERB
cblr-1208	192	22	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	192	23	anticompetitive	anticompetitive	ADJ
cblr-1208	192	24	effect	effect	NOUN
cblr-1208	192	25	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	192	26	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	192	27	anything	anything	PRON
cblr-1208	192	28	other	other	ADJ
cblr-1208	192	29	than	than	ADP
cblr-1208	192	30	immediate	immediate	ADJ
cblr-1208	192	31	entry	entry	NOUN
cblr-1208	192	32	is	be	AUX
cblr-1208	192	33	presumed	presume	VERB
cblr-1208	192	34	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	193	1	according	accord	VERB
cblr-1208	193	2	to	to	ADP
cblr-1208	193	3	professor	professor	NOUN
cblr-1208	193	4	carrier	carrier	NOUN
cblr-1208	193	5	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	193	6	this	this	PRON
cblr-1208	193	7	presents	present	VERB
cblr-1208	193	8	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
cblr-1208	193	9	with	with	ADP
cblr-1208	193	10	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	193	11	powerful	powerful	ADJ
cblr-1208	193	12	tools	tool	NOUN
cblr-1208	193	13	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	193	14	for	for	ADP
cblr-1208	193	15	overcoming	overcome	VERB
cblr-1208	193	16	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	193	17	first	first	ADJ
cblr-1208	193	18	step	step	NOUN
cblr-1208	193	19	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	193	20	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	193	21	burden	burden	NOUN
cblr-1208	193	22	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-1208	193	23	shifting	shift	VERB
cblr-1208	193	24	inquiry.48	inquiry.48	NOUN
cblr-1208	193	25	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	193	26	course	course	NOUN
cblr-1208	193	27	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	193	28	relieving	relieve	VERB
cblr-1208	193	29	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	193	30	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
cblr-1208	193	31	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	193	32	its	its	PRON
cblr-1208	193	33	obligation	obligation	NOUN
cblr-1208	193	34	to	to	ADP
cblr-1208	193	35	44	44	NUM
cblr-1208	193	36	i	i	PROPN
cblr-1208	193	37	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-1208	193	38	professor	professor	PROPN
cblr-1208	193	39	carrier	carrier	NOUN
cblr-1208	193	40	is	be	AUX
cblr-1208	193	41	correct	correct	ADJ
cblr-1208	193	42	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	193	43	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	193	44	application	application	NOUN
cblr-1208	193	45	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	193	46	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	193	47	rule	rule	NOUN
cblr-1208	193	48	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	193	49	reason	reason	NOUN
cblr-1208	193	50	framework	framework	NOUN
cblr-1208	193	51	is	be	AUX
cblr-1208	193	52	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	193	53	same	same	ADJ
cblr-1208	193	54	whether	whether	SCONJ
cblr-1208	193	55	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	193	56	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
cblr-1208	193	57	is	be	AUX
cblr-1208	193	58	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	193	59	ftc	ftc	PROPN
cblr-1208	193	60	or	or	CCONJ
cblr-1208	193	61	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	193	62	private	private	ADJ
cblr-1208	193	63	party	party	NOUN
cblr-1208	193	64	seeking	seek	VERB
cblr-1208	193	65	damages	damage	NOUN
cblr-1208	193	66	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	194	1	see	see	VERB
cblr-1208	194	2	i	i	PRON
cblr-1208	194	3	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-1208	194	4	at	at	ADP
cblr-1208	194	5	44	44	NUM
cblr-1208	194	6	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	195	1	both	both	PRON
cblr-1208	195	2	have	have	VERB
cblr-1208	195	3	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	195	4	establish	establish	VERB
cblr-1208	195	5	anticompetitive	anticompetitive	ADJ
cblr-1208	195	6	effects	effect	NOUN
cblr-1208	195	7	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	195	8	get	get	VERB
cblr-1208	195	9	past	past	ADJ
cblr-1208	195	10	step	step	NOUN
cblr-1208	195	11	one	one	NUM
cblr-1208	195	12	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	195	13	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	195	14	analysis	analysis	NOUN
cblr-1208	195	15	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	196	1	as	as	SCONJ
cblr-1208	196	2	professor	professor	NOUN
cblr-1208	196	3	carrier	carrier	NOUN
cblr-1208	196	4	notes	note	VERB
cblr-1208	196	5	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	196	6	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	196	7	private	private	ADJ
cblr-1208	196	8	party	party	NOUN
cblr-1208	196	9	seeking	seek	VERB
cblr-1208	196	10	damages	damage	NOUN
cblr-1208	196	11	must	must	AUX
cblr-1208	196	12	also	also	ADV
cblr-1208	196	13	prove	prove	VERB
cblr-1208	196	14	antitrust	antitrust	ADJ
cblr-1208	196	15	injury	injury	NOUN
cblr-1208	196	16	—	—	PUNCT
cblr-1208	196	17	i.e.	i.e.	X
cblr-1208	196	18	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	196	19	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	196	20	it	it	PRON
cblr-1208	196	21	suffered	suffer	VERB
cblr-1208	196	22	injury	injury	NOUN
cblr-1208	196	23	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	196	24	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	196	25	type	type	NOUN
cblr-1208	196	26	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	196	27	antitrust	antitrust	ADJ
cblr-1208	196	28	laws	law	NOUN
cblr-1208	196	29	were	be	AUX
cblr-1208	196	30	intended	intend	VERB
cblr-1208	196	31	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	196	32	prevent	prevent	VERB
cblr-1208	196	33	—	—	PUNCT
cblr-1208	196	34	as	as	ADP
cblr-1208	196	35	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	196	36	result	result	NOUN
cblr-1208	196	37	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	196	38	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	196	39	reduction	reduction	NOUN
cblr-1208	196	40	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	196	41	competition	competition	NOUN
cblr-1208	196	42	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	196	43	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	196	44	to	to	ADP
cblr-1208	196	45	what	what	DET
cblr-1208	196	46	degree	degree	NOUN
cblr-1208	196	47	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	197	1	see	see	VERB
cblr-1208	197	2	i	i	PRON
cblr-1208	197	3	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-1208	197	4	at	at	ADP
cblr-1208	197	5	42	42	NUM
cblr-1208	197	6	n.94	n.94	PROPN
cblr-1208	197	7	.	.	PROPN
cblr-1208	197	8	45	45	NUM
cblr-1208	198	1	i	i	PROPN
cblr-1208	198	2	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-1208	198	3	at	at	ADP
cblr-1208	198	4	29	29	NUM
cblr-1208	198	5	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	199	1	46	46	NUM
cblr-1208	200	1	i	i	PRON
cblr-1208	200	2	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-1208	200	3	at	at	ADP
cblr-1208	200	4	37	37	NUM
cblr-1208	200	5	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	201	1	47	47	NUM
cblr-1208	202	1	i	i	PRON
cblr-1208	202	2	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-1208	202	3	at	at	ADP
cblr-1208	202	4	36	36	NUM
cblr-1208	202	5	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	202	6	48	48	NUM
cblr-1208	202	7	while	while	SCONJ
cblr-1208	202	8	professor	professor	NOUN
cblr-1208	202	9	carrier	carrier	NOUN
cblr-1208	202	10	acknowledges	acknowledge	VERB
cblr-1208	202	11	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	202	12	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	202	13	burden	burden	NOUN
cblr-1208	202	14	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-1208	202	15	shifting	shift	VERB
cblr-1208	202	16	framework	framework	NOUN
cblr-1208	202	17	makes	make	VERB
cblr-1208	202	18	sense	sense	NOUN
cblr-1208	202	19	as	as	ADP
cblr-1208	202	20	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	202	21	means	mean	NOUN
cblr-1208	202	22	for	for	ADP
cblr-1208	202	23	minimizing	minimize	VERB
cblr-1208	202	24	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	202	25	number	number	NOUN
cblr-1208	202	26	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	202	27	cases	case	NOUN
cblr-1208	202	28	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	202	29	which	which	PRON
cblr-1208	202	30	courts	court	NOUN
cblr-1208	202	31	must	must	AUX
cblr-1208	202	32	balance	balance	VERB
cblr-1208	202	33	anticompetitive	anticompetitive	ADJ
cblr-1208	202	34	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	202	35	procompetitive	procompetitive	ADJ
cblr-1208	202	36	effects	effect	NOUN
cblr-1208	202	37	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	202	38	he	he	PRON
cblr-1208	202	39	proposes	propose	VERB
cblr-1208	202	40	an	an	DET
cblr-1208	202	41	application	application	NOUN
cblr-1208	202	42	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	202	43	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	202	44	framework	framework	NOUN
cblr-1208	202	45	that	that	PRON
cblr-1208	202	46	would	would	AUX
cblr-1208	202	47	effectively	effectively	ADV
cblr-1208	202	48	eliminate	eliminate	VERB
cblr-1208	202	49	lecture_commentary_final	lecture_commentary_final	PROPN
cblr-1208	202	50	58	58	NUM
cblr-1208	202	51	columbia	columbia	PROPN
cblr-1208	202	52	business	business	NOUN
cblr-1208	202	53	law	law	PROPN
cblr-1208	202	54	review	review	NOUN
cblr-1208	202	55	[	[	X
cblr-1208	202	56	vol	vol	NOUN
cblr-1208	202	57	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	202	58	2018	2018	NUM
cblr-1208	202	59	prove	prove	VERB
cblr-1208	202	60	anticompetitive	anticompetitive	ADJ
cblr-1208	202	61	effects	effect	NOUN
cblr-1208	202	62	as	as	SCONJ
cblr-1208	202	63	it	it	PRON
cblr-1208	202	64	would	would	AUX
cblr-1208	202	65	be	be	AUX
cblr-1208	202	66	required	require	VERB
cblr-1208	202	67	to	to	ADP
cblr-1208	202	68	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	202	69	any	any	DET
cblr-1208	202	70	other	other	ADJ
cblr-1208	202	71	rule	rule	NOUN
cblr-1208	202	72	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	202	73	reason	reason	NOUN
cblr-1208	202	74	analysis	analysis	NOUN
cblr-1208	202	75	gives	give	VERB
cblr-1208	202	76	it	it	PRON
cblr-1208	202	77	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	202	78	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	202	79	powerful	powerful	ADJ
cblr-1208	202	80	tool	tool	NOUN
cblr-1208	202	81	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	202	82	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	202	83	as	as	SCONJ
cblr-1208	202	84	it	it	PRON
cblr-1208	202	85	assumes	assume	VERB
cblr-1208	202	86	away	away	ADV
cblr-1208	202	87	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	202	88	core	core	NOUN
cblr-1208	202	89	obligation	obligation	NOUN
cblr-1208	202	90	one	one	NOUN
cblr-1208	202	91	acquires	acquire	VERB
cblr-1208	202	92	upon	upon	SCONJ
cblr-1208	202	93	filing	file	VERB
cblr-1208	202	94	an	an	DET
cblr-1208	202	95	antitrust	antitrust	ADJ
cblr-1208	202	96	complaint	complaint	NOUN
cblr-1208	202	97	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	203	1	doing	do	VERB
cblr-1208	203	2	so	so	ADV
cblr-1208	203	3	based	base	VERB
cblr-1208	203	4	on	on	ADP
cblr-1208	203	5	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	203	6	proffered	proffered	ADJ
cblr-1208	203	7	assumptions	assumption	NOUN
cblr-1208	203	8	would	would	AUX
cblr-1208	203	9	be	be	AUX
cblr-1208	203	10	misguided	misguide	VERB
cblr-1208	203	11	for	for	ADP
cblr-1208	203	12	at	at	ADV
cblr-1208	203	13	least	least	ADV
cblr-1208	203	14	two	two	NUM
cblr-1208	203	15	reasons	reason	NOUN
cblr-1208	203	16	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	204	1	first	first	ADV
cblr-1208	204	2	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	204	3	it	it	PRON
cblr-1208	204	4	requires	require	VERB
cblr-1208	204	5	reading	read	VERB
cblr-1208	204	6	actavis	actavi	NOUN
cblr-1208	204	7	—	—	PUNCT
cblr-1208	204	8	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	204	9	decision	decision	NOUN
cblr-1208	204	10	on	on	ADP
cblr-1208	204	11	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	204	12	motion	motion	NOUN
cblr-1208	204	13	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	204	14	dismiss	dismiss	VERB
cblr-1208	204	15	—	—	PUNCT
cblr-1208	204	16	as	as	ADP
cblr-1208	204	17	intending	intend	VERB
cblr-1208	204	18	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	204	19	sub	sub	VERB
cblr-1208	204	20	silentio	silentio	PROPN
cblr-1208	204	21	upend	upend	VERB
cblr-1208	204	22	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	204	23	century	century	NOUN
cblr-1208	204	24	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	204	25	rule	rule	NOUN
cblr-1208	204	26	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	204	27	reason	reason	NOUN
cblr-1208	204	28	jurisprudence	jurisprudence	NOUN
cblr-1208	204	29	by	by	ADP
cblr-1208	204	30	injecting	inject	VERB
cblr-1208	204	31	shortcuts	shortcut	NOUN
cblr-1208	204	32	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	204	33	presumptions	presumption	NOUN
cblr-1208	204	34	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	204	35	despite	despite	SCONJ
cblr-1208	204	36	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	204	37	court	court	NOUN
cblr-1208	204	38	’s	’s	PART
cblr-1208	204	39	affirmative	affirmative	ADJ
cblr-1208	204	40	holding	holding	NOUN
cblr-1208	204	41	explicitly	explicitly	ADV
cblr-1208	204	42	rejecting	reject	VERB
cblr-1208	204	43	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	204	44	ftc	ftc	PROPN
cblr-1208	204	45	’s	’s	PART
cblr-1208	204	46	request	request	NOUN
cblr-1208	204	47	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	204	48	it	it	PRON
cblr-1208	204	49	do	do	AUX
cblr-1208	204	50	so	so	ADV
cblr-1208	204	51	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	205	1	second	second	ADV
cblr-1208	205	2	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	205	3	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	205	4	articulated	articulated	ADJ
cblr-1208	205	5	presumption	presumption	NOUN
cblr-1208	205	6	—	—	PUNCT
cblr-1208	205	7	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	205	8	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	205	9	payment	payment	NOUN
cblr-1208	205	10	itself	itself	PRON
cblr-1208	205	11	can	can	AUX
cblr-1208	205	12	satisfy	satisfy	VERB
cblr-1208	205	13	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	205	14	step	step	NOUN
cblr-1208	205	15	one	one	NUM
cblr-1208	205	16	requirement	requirement	NOUN
cblr-1208	205	17	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	205	18	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	205	19	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
cblr-1208	205	20	show	show	VERB
cblr-1208	205	21	anticompetitive	anticompetitive	ADJ
cblr-1208	205	22	effects	effect	NOUN
cblr-1208	205	23	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	205	24	order	order	NOUN
cblr-1208	205	25	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	205	26	shift	shift	VERB
cblr-1208	205	27	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	205	28	burden	burden	NOUN
cblr-1208	205	29	to	to	ADP
cblr-1208	205	30	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	205	31	defendant	defendant	NOUN
cblr-1208	205	32	—	—	PUNCT
cblr-1208	205	33	rests	rest	VERB
cblr-1208	205	34	on	on	ADP
cblr-1208	205	35	other	other	ADJ
cblr-1208	205	36	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	205	37	unsustainable	unsustainable	ADJ
cblr-1208	205	38	presumptions	presumption	NOUN
cblr-1208	205	39	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	206	1	once	once	SCONJ
cblr-1208	206	2	these	these	PRON
cblr-1208	206	3	are	be	AUX
cblr-1208	206	4	examined	examine	VERB
cblr-1208	206	5	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	206	6	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	206	7	house	house	NOUN
cblr-1208	206	8	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	206	9	cards	card	NOUN
cblr-1208	206	10	falls	fall	VERB
cblr-1208	206	11	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	207	1	professor	professor	NOUN
cblr-1208	207	2	carrier	carrier	NOUN
cblr-1208	207	3	does	do	AUX
cblr-1208	207	4	not	not	PART
cblr-1208	207	5	explicitly	explicitly	ADV
cblr-1208	207	6	define	define	VERB
cblr-1208	207	7	what	what	PRON
cblr-1208	207	8	constitutes	constitute	VERB
cblr-1208	207	9	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	207	10	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	207	11	large	large	ADJ
cblr-1208	207	12	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	207	13	payment.49	payment.49	NOUN
cblr-1208	207	14	nor	nor	CCONJ
cblr-1208	207	15	did	do	VERB
cblr-1208	207	16	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	207	17	actavis	actavis	PROPN
cblr-1208	207	18	court	court	NOUN
cblr-1208	207	19	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	208	1	justice	justice	NOUN
cblr-1208	208	2	breyer	breyer	NOUN
cblr-1208	208	3	suggested	suggest	VERB
cblr-1208	208	4	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	208	5	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	208	6	reverse	reverse	ADJ
cblr-1208	208	7	payment	payment	NOUN
cblr-1208	208	8	reflects	reflect	VERB
cblr-1208	208	9	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	208	10	traditional	traditional	ADJ
cblr-1208	208	11	settlement	settlement	NOUN
cblr-1208	208	12	considerations	consideration	NOUN
cblr-1208	208	13	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	208	14	where	where	SCONJ
cblr-1208	208	15	it	it	PRON
cblr-1208	208	16	does	do	AUX
cblr-1208	208	17	not	not	PART
cblr-1208	208	18	exceed	exceed	VERB
cblr-1208	208	19	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	208	20	avoided	avoid	VERB
cblr-1208	208	21	litigation	litigation	NOUN
cblr-1208	208	22	costs	cost	NOUN
cblr-1208	208	23	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	209	1	”50	”50	NOUN
cblr-1208	210	1	but	but	CCONJ
cblr-1208	210	2	this	this	DET
cblr-1208	210	3	observation	observation	NOUN
cblr-1208	210	4	is	be	AUX
cblr-1208	210	5	insufficient	insufficient	ADJ
cblr-1208	210	6	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	210	7	support	support	VERB
cblr-1208	210	8	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	210	9	proposition	proposition	NOUN
cblr-1208	210	10	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	210	11	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	210	12	payment	payment	NOUN
cblr-1208	210	13	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	210	14	excess	excess	NOUN
cblr-1208	210	15	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	210	16	avoided	avoid	VERB
cblr-1208	210	17	litigation	litigation	NOUN
cblr-1208	210	18	costs	cost	NOUN
cblr-1208	210	19	satisfies	satisfy	VERB
cblr-1208	210	20	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	210	21	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
cblr-1208	210	22	’s	’s	PART
cblr-1208	210	23	burden	burden	NOUN
cblr-1208	210	24	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	210	25	prove	prove	VERB
cblr-1208	210	26	anticompetitive	anticompetitive	ADJ
cblr-1208	210	27	effects	effect	NOUN
cblr-1208	210	28	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	211	1	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	211	2	existence	existence	NOUN
cblr-1208	211	3	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	211	4	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	211	5	payment	payment	NOUN
cblr-1208	211	6	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	211	7	excess	excess	NOUN
cblr-1208	211	8	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	211	9	litigation	litigation	NOUN
cblr-1208	211	10	costs	cost	NOUN
cblr-1208	211	11	alone	alone	ADV
cblr-1208	211	12	does	do	AUX
cblr-1208	211	13	not	not	PART
cblr-1208	211	14	establish	establish	VERB
cblr-1208	211	15	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	211	16	generic	generic	ADJ
cblr-1208	211	17	entry	entry	NOUN
cblr-1208	211	18	would	would	AUX
cblr-1208	211	19	have	have	AUX
cblr-1208	211	20	taken	take	VERB
cblr-1208	211	21	place	place	NOUN
cblr-1208	211	22	earlier	early	ADV
cblr-1208	211	23	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	211	24	the	the	PRON
cblr-1208	211	25	but	but	CCONJ
cblr-1208	211	26	its	its	PRON
cblr-1208	211	27	first	first	ADJ
cblr-1208	211	28	step	step	NOUN
cblr-1208	211	29	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	212	1	indeed	indeed	ADV
cblr-1208	212	2	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	212	3	as	as	SCONJ
cblr-1208	212	4	described	describe	VERB
cblr-1208	212	5	above	above	ADV
cblr-1208	212	6	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	212	7	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	212	8	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	212	9	limit	limit	NOUN
cblr-1208	212	10	on	on	ADP
cblr-1208	212	11	generic	generic	ADJ
cblr-1208	212	12	entry	entry	NOUN
cblr-1208	212	13	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	212	14	compensation	compensation	NOUN
cblr-1208	212	15	to	to	ADP
cblr-1208	212	16	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	212	17	generic	generic	NOUN
cblr-1208	212	18	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	212	19	are	be	AUX
cblr-1208	212	20	features	feature	NOUN
cblr-1208	212	21	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	212	22	nearly	nearly	ADV
cblr-1208	212	23	every	every	DET
cblr-1208	212	24	settlement	settlement	NOUN
cblr-1208	212	25	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	212	26	litigation	litigation	NOUN
cblr-1208	212	27	that	that	PRON
cblr-1208	212	28	arises	arise	VERB
cblr-1208	212	29	under	under	ADP
cblr-1208	212	30	paragraph	paragraph	NOUN
cblr-1208	212	31	iv	iv	NUM
cblr-1208	212	32	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	212	33	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	212	34	hatch	hatch	NOUN
cblr-1208	212	35	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-1208	212	36	waxman	waxman	PROPN
cblr-1208	212	37	act	act	PROPN
cblr-1208	212	38	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	213	1	i	i	PRON
cblr-1208	213	2	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-1208	213	3	at	at	ADP
cblr-1208	213	4	41	41	NUM
cblr-1208	213	5	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	214	1	professor	professor	NOUN
cblr-1208	214	2	carrier	carrier	NOUN
cblr-1208	214	3	also	also	ADV
cblr-1208	214	4	states	state	VERB
cblr-1208	214	5	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	214	6	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	214	7	actavis	actavis	PROPN
cblr-1208	214	8	court	court	NOUN
cblr-1208	214	9	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	214	10	was	be	AUX
cblr-1208	214	11	not	not	PART
cblr-1208	214	12	willing	willing	ADJ
cblr-1208	214	13	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	214	14	accept	accept	VERB
cblr-1208	214	15	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	214	16	procompetitive	procompetitive	ADJ
cblr-1208	214	17	justifications	justification	NOUN
cblr-1208	214	18	beyond	beyond	ADP
cblr-1208	214	19	avoided	avoid	VERB
cblr-1208	214	20	litigation	litigation	NOUN
cblr-1208	214	21	costs	cost	NOUN
cblr-1208	214	22	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	214	23	or	or	CCONJ
cblr-1208	214	24	costs	cost	NOUN
cblr-1208	214	25	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	214	26	generic	generic	ADJ
cblr-1208	214	27	services	service	NOUN
cblr-1208	214	28	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	215	1	i	i	PRON
cblr-1208	215	2	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-1208	215	3	at	at	ADP
cblr-1208	215	4	38	38	NUM
cblr-1208	215	5	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	216	1	note	note	NOUN
cblr-1208	216	2	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	216	3	however	however	ADV
cblr-1208	216	4	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	216	5	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	216	6	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	216	7	court	court	NOUN
cblr-1208	216	8	expressly	expressly	ADV
cblr-1208	216	9	stated	state	VERB
cblr-1208	216	10	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	216	11	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	216	12	there	there	PRON
cblr-1208	216	13	may	may	AUX
cblr-1208	216	14	be	be	AUX
cblr-1208	216	15	other	other	ADJ
cblr-1208	216	16	justifications	justification	NOUN
cblr-1208	216	17	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	216	18	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	216	19	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	216	20	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	216	21	more	more	ADV
cblr-1208	216	22	fundamentally	fundamentally	ADV
cblr-1208	216	23	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	216	24	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	216	25	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	216	26	actavis	actavis	PROPN
cblr-1208	216	27	court	court	NOUN
cblr-1208	216	28	did	do	AUX
cblr-1208	216	29	not	not	PART
cblr-1208	216	30	purport	purport	VERB
cblr-1208	216	31	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	216	32	apply	apply	VERB
cblr-1208	216	33	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	216	34	rule	rule	NOUN
cblr-1208	216	35	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	216	36	reason	reason	NOUN
cblr-1208	216	37	analysis	analysis	NOUN
cblr-1208	216	38	;	;	PUNCT
cblr-1208	216	39	it	it	PRON
cblr-1208	216	40	held	hold	VERB
cblr-1208	216	41	only	only	ADV
cblr-1208	216	42	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	216	43	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	216	44	ftc	ftc	PROPN
cblr-1208	216	45	had	have	AUX
cblr-1208	216	46	stated	state	VERB
cblr-1208	216	47	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	216	48	plausible	plausible	ADJ
cblr-1208	216	49	claim	claim	NOUN
cblr-1208	216	50	such	such	ADJ
cblr-1208	216	51	that	that	DET
cblr-1208	216	52	dismissal	dismissal	NOUN
cblr-1208	216	53	was	be	AUX
cblr-1208	216	54	unwarranted	unwarranted	ADJ
cblr-1208	216	55	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	217	1	actavis	actavi	NOUN
cblr-1208	217	2	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	217	3	133	133	NUM
cblr-1208	217	4	s.	s.	PROPN
cblr-1208	217	5	ct	ct	PROPN
cblr-1208	217	6	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	217	7	at	at	ADP
cblr-1208	217	8	2236	2236	NUM
cblr-1208	217	9	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	218	1	49	49	NUM
cblr-1208	218	2	we	we	PRON
cblr-1208	218	3	agree	agree	VERB
cblr-1208	218	4	with	with	ADP
cblr-1208	218	5	professor	professor	NOUN
cblr-1208	218	6	carrier	carrier	NOUN
cblr-1208	218	7	that	that	PRON
cblr-1208	218	8	most	most	ADJ
cblr-1208	218	9	courts	court	NOUN
cblr-1208	218	10	have	have	AUX
cblr-1208	218	11	held	hold	VERB
cblr-1208	218	12	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	218	13	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	218	14	payment	payment	NOUN
cblr-1208	218	15	is	be	AUX
cblr-1208	218	16	not	not	PART
cblr-1208	218	17	limited	limit	VERB
cblr-1208	218	18	to	to	ADP
cblr-1208	218	19	cash	cash	NOUN
cblr-1208	218	20	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	219	1	50	50	NUM
cblr-1208	219	2	ftc	ftc	PROPN
cblr-1208	219	3	v.	v.	ADP
cblr-1208	219	4	actavis	actavis	PROPN
cblr-1208	219	5	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	219	6	133	133	NUM
cblr-1208	219	7	s.	s.	PROPN
cblr-1208	219	8	ct	ct	PROPN
cblr-1208	219	9	.	.	PROPN
cblr-1208	219	10	2223	2223	NUM
cblr-1208	219	11	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	219	12	2236	2236	NUM
cblr-1208	219	13	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-1208	219	14	2013	2013	NUM
cblr-1208	219	15	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-1208	219	16	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	220	1	lecture_commentary_final	lecture_commentary_final	PROPN
cblr-1208	221	1	no	no	INTJ
cblr-1208	221	2	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	222	1	1:45	1:45	NUM
cblr-1208	222	2	]	]	PUNCT
cblr-1208	222	3	commentary	commentary	NOUN
cblr-1208	222	4	:	:	PUNCT
cblr-1208	222	5	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	222	6	rule	rule	NOUN
cblr-1208	222	7	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	222	8	reason	reason	NOUN
cblr-1208	222	9	59	59	NUM
cblr-1208	222	10	for	for	ADP
cblr-1208	222	11	world.51	world.51	NOUN
cblr-1208	222	12	allowing	allow	VERB
cblr-1208	222	13	it	it	PRON
cblr-1208	222	14	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	222	15	do	do	VERB
cblr-1208	222	16	so	so	ADV
cblr-1208	222	17	would	would	AUX
cblr-1208	222	18	conflict	conflict	VERB
cblr-1208	222	19	with	with	ADP
cblr-1208	222	20	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	222	21	express	express	ADJ
cblr-1208	222	22	holding	holding	NOUN
cblr-1208	222	23	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	222	24	actavis	actavis	NOUN
cblr-1208	222	25	that	that	PRON
cblr-1208	222	26	reverse	reverse	VERB
cblr-1208	222	27	payment	payment	NOUN
cblr-1208	222	28	settlement	settlement	NOUN
cblr-1208	222	29	agreements	agreement	NOUN
cblr-1208	222	30	are	be	AUX
cblr-1208	222	31	not	not	PART
cblr-1208	222	32	subject	subject	ADJ
cblr-1208	222	33	to	to	ADP
cblr-1208	222	34	review	review	NOUN
cblr-1208	222	35	under	under	ADP
cblr-1208	222	36	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	222	37	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	222	38	quick	quick	ADJ
cblr-1208	222	39	look	look	NOUN
cblr-1208	222	40	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	222	41	test	test	NOUN
cblr-1208	222	42	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	222	43	which	which	DET
cblr-1208	222	44	shifts	shift	NOUN
cblr-1208	222	45	to	to	ADP
cblr-1208	222	46	defendants	defendant	NOUN
cblr-1208	222	47	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	222	48	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	222	49	first	first	ADJ
cblr-1208	222	50	instance	instance	NOUN
cblr-1208	222	51	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	222	52	burden	burden	NOUN
cblr-1208	222	53	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	222	54	proving	prove	VERB
cblr-1208	222	55	procompetitive	procompetitive	ADJ
cblr-1208	222	56	effects.52	effects.52	NOUN
cblr-1208	222	57	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	222	58	eagerness	eagerness	NOUN
cblr-1208	222	59	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	222	60	rely	rely	VERB
cblr-1208	222	61	on	on	ADP
cblr-1208	222	62	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	222	63	payment	payment	NOUN
cblr-1208	222	64	alone	alone	ADV
cblr-1208	222	65	rests	rest	VERB
cblr-1208	222	66	on	on	ADP
cblr-1208	222	67	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	222	68	faulty	faulty	ADJ
cblr-1208	222	69	assumption	assumption	NOUN
cblr-1208	222	70	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	222	71	it	it	PRON
cblr-1208	222	72	is	be	AUX
cblr-1208	222	73	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	222	74	reasonable	reasonable	ADJ
cblr-1208	222	75	proxy	proxy	NOUN
cblr-1208	222	76	for	for	ADP
cblr-1208	222	77	patent	patent	NOUN
cblr-1208	222	78	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	222	79	weakness	weakness	NOUN
cblr-1208	222	80	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	222	81	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	222	82	which	which	PRON
cblr-1208	222	83	itself	itself	PRON
cblr-1208	222	84	relies	rely	VERB
cblr-1208	222	85	on	on	ADP
cblr-1208	222	86	two	two	NUM
cblr-1208	222	87	underlying	underlie	VERB
cblr-1208	222	88	presumptions	presumption	NOUN
cblr-1208	222	89	:	:	PUNCT
cblr-1208	222	90	first	first	ADV
cblr-1208	222	91	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	222	92	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	222	93	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	222	94	patentee	patentee	NOUN
cblr-1208	222	95	would	would	AUX
cblr-1208	222	96	not	not	PART
cblr-1208	222	97	pay	pay	VERB
cblr-1208	222	98	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	222	99	money	money	NOUN
cblr-1208	222	100	unless	unless	SCONJ
cblr-1208	222	101	it	it	PRON
cblr-1208	222	102	expected	expect	VERB
cblr-1208	222	103	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	222	104	lose	lose	VERB
cblr-1208	222	105	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	222	106	patent	patent	NOUN
cblr-1208	222	107	case	case	NOUN
cblr-1208	222	108	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	222	109	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	222	110	second	second	ADJ
cblr-1208	222	111	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	222	112	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	222	113	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	222	114	federal	federal	ADJ
cblr-1208	222	115	judge	judge	NOUN
cblr-1208	222	116	presiding	preside	VERB
cblr-1208	222	117	over	over	ADP
cblr-1208	222	118	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	222	119	settled	settle	VERB
cblr-1208	222	120	paragraph	paragraph	NOUN
cblr-1208	222	121	iv	iv	NUM
cblr-1208	222	122	litigation	litigation	NOUN
cblr-1208	222	123	would	would	AUX
cblr-1208	222	124	have	have	AUX
cblr-1208	222	125	seen	see	VERB
cblr-1208	222	126	it	it	PRON
cblr-1208	222	127	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	222	128	same	same	ADJ
cblr-1208	222	129	way	way	NOUN
cblr-1208	222	130	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	223	1	because	because	SCONJ
cblr-1208	223	2	each	each	PRON
cblr-1208	223	3	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	223	4	these	these	DET
cblr-1208	223	5	assumptions	assumption	NOUN
cblr-1208	223	6	is	be	AUX
cblr-1208	223	7	flawed	flawed	ADJ
cblr-1208	223	8	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	223	9	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	223	10	presumptions	presumption	NOUN
cblr-1208	223	11	that	that	PRON
cblr-1208	223	12	professor	professor	NOUN
cblr-1208	223	13	carrier	carrier	NOUN
cblr-1208	223	14	layers	layer	NOUN
cblr-1208	223	15	on	on	ADP
cblr-1208	223	16	them	they	PRON
cblr-1208	223	17	are	be	AUX
cblr-1208	223	18	equally	equally	ADV
cblr-1208	223	19	flawed	flawed	ADJ
cblr-1208	223	20	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	224	1	as	as	SCONJ
cblr-1208	224	2	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	224	3	court	court	NOUN
cblr-1208	224	4	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	224	5	appeals	appeal	NOUN
cblr-1208	224	6	for	for	ADP
cblr-1208	224	7	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	224	8	third	third	ADJ
cblr-1208	224	9	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-1208	224	10	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	224	11	wellbutrin	wellbutrin	NOUN
cblr-1208	224	12	xl	xl	PROPN
cblr-1208	224	13	recognized	recognize	VERB
cblr-1208	224	14	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	224	15	risk	risk	NOUN
cblr-1208	224	16	aversion	aversion	NOUN
cblr-1208	224	17	makes	make	VERB
cblr-1208	224	18	it	it	PRON
cblr-1208	224	19	difficult	difficult	ADJ
cblr-1208	224	20	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	224	21	use	use	VERB
cblr-1208	224	22	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	224	23	size	size	NOUN
cblr-1208	224	24	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	224	25	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	224	26	reverse	reverse	ADJ
cblr-1208	224	27	payment	payment	NOUN
cblr-1208	224	28	as	as	ADP
cblr-1208	224	29	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	224	30	surrogate	surrogate	NOUN
cblr-1208	224	31	for	for	ADP
cblr-1208	224	32	patent	patent	NOUN
cblr-1208	224	33	strength.53	strength.53	NOUN
cblr-1208	224	34	this	this	PRON
cblr-1208	224	35	is	be	AUX
cblr-1208	224	36	because	because	SCONJ
cblr-1208	224	37	parties	party	NOUN
cblr-1208	224	38	may	may	AUX
cblr-1208	224	39	be	be	AUX
cblr-1208	224	40	willing	willing	ADJ
cblr-1208	224	41	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	224	42	accept	accept	VERB
cblr-1208	224	43	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	224	44	settlement	settlement	NOUN
cblr-1208	224	45	payoff	payoff	NOUN
cblr-1208	224	46	that	that	PRON
cblr-1208	224	47	is	be	AUX
cblr-1208	224	48	smaller	small	ADJ
cblr-1208	224	49	than	than	ADP
cblr-1208	224	50	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	224	51	expected	expect	VERB
cblr-1208	224	52	payoff	payoff	NOUN
cblr-1208	224	53	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	224	54	litigation	litigation	NOUN
cblr-1208	224	55	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	224	56	exchange	exchange	NOUN
cblr-1208	224	57	for	for	ADP
cblr-1208	224	58	certainty	certainty	NOUN
cblr-1208	224	59	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	225	1	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	225	2	wellbutrin	wellbutrin	PROPN
cblr-1208	225	3	xl	xl	PROPN
cblr-1208	225	4	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	225	5	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	225	6	court	court	NOUN
cblr-1208	225	7	cited	cite	VERB
cblr-1208	225	8	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	225	9	useful	useful	ADJ
cblr-1208	225	10	example	example	NOUN
cblr-1208	225	11	:	:	PUNCT
cblr-1208	225	12	consider	consider	VERB
cblr-1208	225	13	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	225	14	lottery	lottery	NOUN
cblr-1208	225	15	ticket	ticket	NOUN
cblr-1208	225	16	that	that	PRON
cblr-1208	225	17	has	have	VERB
cblr-1208	225	18	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	225	19	fifty	fifty	NUM
cblr-1208	225	20	percent	percent	NOUN
cblr-1208	225	21	chance	chance	NOUN
cblr-1208	225	22	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	225	23	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	225	24	$	$	SYM
cblr-1208	225	25	0	0	NUM
cblr-1208	225	26	payoff	payoff	NOUN
cblr-1208	225	27	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	225	28	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	225	29	fifty	fifty	NUM
cblr-1208	225	30	percent	percent	NOUN
cblr-1208	225	31	chance	chance	NOUN
cblr-1208	225	32	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	225	33	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	225	34	$	$	SYM
cblr-1208	225	35	100	100	NUM
cblr-1208	225	36	million	million	NUM
cblr-1208	225	37	payoff.54	payoff.54	NOUN
cblr-1208	225	38	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	225	39	expected	expect	VERB
cblr-1208	225	40	payoff	payoff	NOUN
cblr-1208	225	41	is	be	AUX
cblr-1208	225	42	$	$	SYM
cblr-1208	225	43	50	50	NUM
cblr-1208	225	44	million	million	NUM
cblr-1208	225	45	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	225	46	but	but	CCONJ
cblr-1208	225	47	most	most	ADJ
cblr-1208	225	48	people	people	NOUN
cblr-1208	225	49	would	would	AUX
cblr-1208	225	50	be	be	AUX
cblr-1208	225	51	willing	willing	ADJ
cblr-1208	225	52	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	225	53	accept	accept	VERB
cblr-1208	225	54	substantially	substantially	ADV
cblr-1208	225	55	less	less	ADJ
cblr-1208	225	56	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-1208	225	57	e.g.	e.g.	ADV
cblr-1208	225	58	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	225	59	$	$	SYM
cblr-1208	225	60	20	20	NUM
cblr-1208	225	61	million	million	NUM
cblr-1208	225	62	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-1208	225	63	for	for	ADP
cblr-1208	225	64	certainty	certainty	NOUN
cblr-1208	225	65	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	225	66	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	225	67	payoff.55	payoff.55	NOUN
cblr-1208	225	68	accepting	accept	VERB
cblr-1208	225	69	$	$	SYM
cblr-1208	225	70	20	20	NUM
cblr-1208	225	71	million	million	NUM
cblr-1208	225	72	—	—	PUNCT
cblr-1208	225	73	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	225	74	thus	thus	ADV
cblr-1208	225	75	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	225	76	paying	pay	VERB
cblr-1208	225	77	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	225	78	$	$	SYM
cblr-1208	225	79	30	30	NUM
cblr-1208	225	80	million	million	NUM
cblr-1208	225	81	for	for	ADP
cblr-1208	225	82	certainty	certainty	NOUN
cblr-1208	225	83	—	—	PUNCT
cblr-1208	225	84	does	do	AUX
cblr-1208	225	85	not	not	PART
cblr-1208	225	86	reflect	reflect	VERB
cblr-1208	225	87	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	225	88	belief	belief	NOUN
cblr-1208	225	89	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	225	90	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	225	91	$	$	SYM
cblr-1208	225	92	0	0	NUM
cblr-1208	225	93	payoff	payoff	NOUN
cblr-1208	225	94	is	be	AUX
cblr-1208	225	95	more	more	ADJ
cblr-1208	225	96	than	than	ADP
cblr-1208	225	97	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	225	98	fifty	fifty	NUM
cblr-1208	225	99	percent	percent	NOUN
cblr-1208	225	100	51	51	NUM
cblr-1208	225	101	as	as	ADP
cblr-1208	225	102	an	an	DET
cblr-1208	225	103	economic	economic	ADJ
cblr-1208	225	104	matter	matter	NOUN
cblr-1208	225	105	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	225	106	there	there	PRON
cblr-1208	225	107	is	be	VERB
cblr-1208	225	108	considerable	considerable	ADJ
cblr-1208	225	109	debate	debate	NOUN
cblr-1208	225	110	over	over	ADP
cblr-1208	225	111	whether	whether	SCONJ
cblr-1208	225	112	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	225	113	to	to	ADP
cblr-1208	225	114	what	what	DET
cblr-1208	225	115	degree	degree	NOUN
cblr-1208	225	116	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	225	117	rule	rule	NOUN
cblr-1208	225	118	prohibiting	prohibit	VERB
cblr-1208	225	119	reverse	reverse	ADJ
cblr-1208	225	120	payments	payment	NOUN
cblr-1208	225	121	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	225	122	excess	excess	NOUN
cblr-1208	225	123	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	225	124	avoided	avoid	VERB
cblr-1208	225	125	litigation	litigation	NOUN
cblr-1208	225	126	costs	cost	NOUN
cblr-1208	225	127	would	would	AUX
cblr-1208	225	128	restrict	restrict	VERB
cblr-1208	225	129	procompetitive	procompetitive	ADJ
cblr-1208	225	130	settlements	settlement	NOUN
cblr-1208	225	131	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	226	1	see	see	VERB
cblr-1208	226	2	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	226	3	e.g.	e.g.	ADV
cblr-1208	226	4	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	226	5	aaeron	aaeron	PROPN
cblr-1208	226	6	edlin	edlin	PROPN
cblr-1208	226	7	et	et	PROPN
cblr-1208	226	8	al	al	PROPN
cblr-1208	226	9	.	.	PROPN
cblr-1208	226	10	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	226	11	activating	activate	VERB
cblr-1208	226	12	actavis	actavis	NOUN
cblr-1208	226	13	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	226	14	28	28	NUM
cblr-1208	226	15	antitrust	antitrust	ADJ
cblr-1208	226	16	16	16	NUM
cblr-1208	226	17	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-1208	226	18	2013	2013	NUM
cblr-1208	226	19	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-1208	226	20	;	;	PUNCT
cblr-1208	226	21	barry	barry	PROPN
cblr-1208	226	22	c.	c.	PROPN
cblr-1208	226	23	harris	harris	PROPN
cblr-1208	226	24	et	et	PROPN
cblr-1208	226	25	al	al	PROPN
cblr-1208	226	26	.	.	PROPN
cblr-1208	226	27	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	226	28	activating	activate	VERB
cblr-1208	226	29	actavis	actavis	NOUN
cblr-1208	226	30	:	:	PUNCT
cblr-1208	226	31	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	226	32	more	more	ADV
cblr-1208	226	33	complete	complete	ADJ
cblr-1208	226	34	story	story	NOUN
cblr-1208	226	35	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	226	36	28	28	NUM
cblr-1208	226	37	antitrust	antitrust	ADJ
cblr-1208	226	38	83	83	NUM
cblr-1208	226	39	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-1208	226	40	2014	2014	NUM
cblr-1208	226	41	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-1208	226	42	;	;	PUNCT
cblr-1208	227	1	aaron	aaron	PROPN
cblr-1208	227	2	edlin	edlin	PROPN
cblr-1208	227	3	et	et	PROPN
cblr-1208	227	4	al	al	PROPN
cblr-1208	227	5	.	.	PROPN
cblr-1208	227	6	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	227	7	actavis	actavis	NOUN
cblr-1208	227	8	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	227	9	error	error	NOUN
cblr-1208	227	10	costs	cost	NOUN
cblr-1208	227	11	:	:	PUNCT
cblr-1208	227	12	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	227	13	reply	reply	NOUN
cblr-1208	227	14	to	to	ADP
cblr-1208	227	15	critics	critic	NOUN
cblr-1208	227	16	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	227	17	14	14	NUM
cblr-1208	227	18	antitrust	antitrust	ADJ
cblr-1208	227	19	source	source	NOUN
cblr-1208	227	20	1	1	NUM
cblr-1208	227	21	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-1208	227	22	2014	2014	NUM
cblr-1208	227	23	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-1208	227	24	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	228	1	52	52	NUM
cblr-1208	228	2	see	see	VERB
cblr-1208	228	3	actavis	actavis	PROPN
cblr-1208	228	4	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	228	5	133	133	NUM
cblr-1208	228	6	s.	s.	PROPN
cblr-1208	228	7	ct	ct	PROPN
cblr-1208	228	8	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	229	1	at	at	ADP
cblr-1208	229	2	2237	2237	NUM
cblr-1208	229	3	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	230	1	53	53	NUM
cblr-1208	230	2	see	see	VERB
cblr-1208	230	3	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	230	4	re	re	NOUN
cblr-1208	230	5	wellbutrin	wellbutrin	NOUN
cblr-1208	230	6	xl	xl	PROPN
cblr-1208	230	7	antitrust	antitrust	ADJ
cblr-1208	230	8	litig	litig	NOUN
cblr-1208	230	9	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	230	10	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	230	11	868	868	NUM
cblr-1208	230	12	f.3d	f.3d	NUM
cblr-1208	230	13	132	132	NUM
cblr-1208	230	14	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	230	15	168–69	168–69	NUM
cblr-1208	230	16	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-1208	230	17	3d	3d	PROPN
cblr-1208	230	18	cir	cir	NOUN
cblr-1208	230	19	.	.	PROPN
cblr-1208	230	20	2017	2017	NUM
cblr-1208	230	21	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-1208	230	22	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	231	1	54	54	NUM
cblr-1208	231	2	see	see	VERB
cblr-1208	231	3	i	i	PRON
cblr-1208	231	4	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-1208	231	5	at	at	ADP
cblr-1208	231	6	168	168	NUM
cblr-1208	231	7	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	232	1	55	55	NUM
cblr-1208	232	2	see	see	VERB
cblr-1208	232	3	i	i	PROPN
cblr-1208	232	4	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-1208	232	5	lecture_commentary_final	lecture_commentary_final	PROPN
cblr-1208	232	6	60	60	PROPN
cblr-1208	232	7	columbia	columbia	PROPN
cblr-1208	232	8	business	business	NOUN
cblr-1208	232	9	law	law	NOUN
cblr-1208	232	10	review	review	NOUN
cblr-1208	232	11	[	[	X
cblr-1208	232	12	vol	vol	NOUN
cblr-1208	232	13	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	232	14	2018	2018	NUM
cblr-1208	232	15	risk.56	risk.56	VERB
cblr-1208	232	16	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	232	17	lottery	lottery	NOUN
cblr-1208	232	18	example	example	NOUN
cblr-1208	232	19	—	—	PUNCT
cblr-1208	232	20	which	which	PRON
cblr-1208	232	21	presumes	presume	VERB
cblr-1208	232	22	perfect	perfect	ADJ
cblr-1208	232	23	information	information	NOUN
cblr-1208	232	24	—	—	PUNCT
cblr-1208	232	25	thus	thus	ADV
cblr-1208	232	26	shows	show	VERB
cblr-1208	232	27	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	232	28	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	232	29	size	size	NOUN
cblr-1208	232	30	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	232	31	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	232	32	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	232	33	payment	payment	NOUN
cblr-1208	232	34	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	232	35	does	do	AUX
cblr-1208	232	36	not	not	PART
cblr-1208	232	37	serve	serve	VERB
cblr-1208	232	38	as	as	ADP
cblr-1208	232	39	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	232	40	surrogate	surrogate	NOUN
cblr-1208	232	41	for	for	ADP
cblr-1208	232	42	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	232	43	but	but	CCONJ
cblr-1208	232	44	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-1208	232	45	for	for	ADP
cblr-1208	232	46	world	world	NOUN
cblr-1208	232	47	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	232	48	even	even	ADV
cblr-1208	232	49	if	if	SCONJ
cblr-1208	232	50	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	232	51	parties	party	NOUN
cblr-1208	232	52	accurately	accurately	ADV
cblr-1208	232	53	perceive	perceive	VERB
cblr-1208	232	54	patent	patent	NOUN
cblr-1208	232	55	strength	strength	NOUN
cblr-1208	232	56	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	233	1	professor	professor	NOUN
cblr-1208	233	2	carrier	carrier	NOUN
cblr-1208	233	3	describes	describe	VERB
cblr-1208	233	4	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	233	5	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	233	6	lottery	lottery	NOUN
cblr-1208	233	7	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	233	8	example	example	NOUN
cblr-1208	233	9	as	as	ADP
cblr-1208	233	10	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	233	11	resuscitat[ing	resuscitat[e	VERB
cblr-1208	233	12	]	]	PUNCT
cblr-1208	233	13	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	233	14	risk	risk	NOUN
cblr-1208	233	15	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-1208	233	16	aversion	aversion	NOUN
cblr-1208	233	17	defense	defense	NOUN
cblr-1208	233	18	rejected	reject	VERB
cblr-1208	233	19	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	233	20	actavis	actavis	NOUN
cblr-1208	233	21	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	234	1	”57	”57	PUNCT
cblr-1208	235	1	but	but	CCONJ
cblr-1208	235	2	whether	whether	SCONJ
cblr-1208	235	3	risk	risk	NOUN
cblr-1208	235	4	aversion	aversion	NOUN
cblr-1208	235	5	is	be	AUX
cblr-1208	235	6	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	235	7	justification	justification	NOUN
cblr-1208	235	8	or	or	CCONJ
cblr-1208	235	9	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	235	10	defense	defense	NOUN
cblr-1208	235	11	addresses	address	VERB
cblr-1208	235	12	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	235	13	point	point	NOUN
cblr-1208	235	14	different	different	ADJ
cblr-1208	235	15	from	from	ADP
cblr-1208	235	16	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	235	17	point	point	NOUN
cblr-1208	235	18	made	make	VERB
cblr-1208	235	19	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	235	20	wellbutrin	wellbutrin	NOUN
cblr-1208	235	21	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	235	22	here	here	ADV
cblr-1208	235	23	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	236	1	risk	risk	NOUN
cblr-1208	236	2	aversion	aversion	NOUN
cblr-1208	236	3	explains	explain	VERB
cblr-1208	236	4	why	why	SCONJ
cblr-1208	236	5	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	236	6	size	size	NOUN
cblr-1208	236	7	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	236	8	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	236	9	payment	payment	NOUN
cblr-1208	236	10	does	do	AUX
cblr-1208	236	11	not	not	PART
cblr-1208	236	12	necessarily	necessarily	ADV
cblr-1208	236	13	reflect	reflect	VERB
cblr-1208	236	14	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	236	15	patentee	patentee	NOUN
cblr-1208	236	16	’s	’s	PART
cblr-1208	236	17	view	view	NOUN
cblr-1208	236	18	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	236	19	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	236	20	strength	strength	NOUN
cblr-1208	236	21	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	236	22	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	236	23	patent.58	patent.58	NOUN
cblr-1208	236	24	accordingly	accordingly	ADV
cblr-1208	236	25	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	236	26	risk	risk	NOUN
cblr-1208	236	27	aversion	aversion	NOUN
cblr-1208	236	28	is	be	AUX
cblr-1208	236	29	relevant	relevant	ADJ
cblr-1208	236	30	because	because	SCONJ
cblr-1208	236	31	it	it	PRON
cblr-1208	236	32	negates	negate	VERB
cblr-1208	236	33	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	236	34	presumption	presumption	NOUN
cblr-1208	236	35	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	236	36	professor	professor	NOUN
cblr-1208	236	37	carrier	carrier	NOUN
cblr-1208	236	38	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	236	39	others	other	NOUN
cblr-1208	236	40	propose	propose	VERB
cblr-1208	236	41	be	be	AUX
cblr-1208	236	42	utilized	utilize	VERB
cblr-1208	236	43	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	236	44	satisfy	satisfy	VERB
cblr-1208	236	45	plaintiff	plaintiff	PROPN
cblr-1208	236	46	’s	’s	PART
cblr-1208	236	47	burden	burden	NOUN
cblr-1208	236	48	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	236	49	proving	prove	VERB
cblr-1208	236	50	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	236	51	generic	generic	ADJ
cblr-1208	236	52	entry	entry	NOUN
cblr-1208	236	53	would	would	AUX
cblr-1208	236	54	have	have	AUX
cblr-1208	236	55	taken	take	VERB
cblr-1208	236	56	place	place	NOUN
cblr-1208	236	57	earlier	early	ADV
cblr-1208	236	58	butfor	butfor	ADP
cblr-1208	236	59	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	236	60	parties	party	NOUN
cblr-1208	236	61	’	'	PUNCT
cblr-1208	236	62	settlement	settlement	NOUN
cblr-1208	236	63	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	237	1	nor	nor	CCONJ
cblr-1208	237	2	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	237	3	for	for	ADP
cblr-1208	237	4	that	that	DET
cblr-1208	237	5	matter	matter	NOUN
cblr-1208	237	6	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	237	7	does	do	VERB
cblr-1208	237	8	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	237	9	patentee	patentee	NOUN
cblr-1208	237	10	’s	’s	PART
cblr-1208	237	11	confidence	confidence	NOUN
cblr-1208	237	12	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	237	13	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	237	14	lack	lack	NOUN
cblr-1208	237	15	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	237	16	it	it	PRON
cblr-1208	237	17	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	237	18	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	237	19	its	its	PRON
cblr-1208	237	20	patent	patent	NOUN
cblr-1208	237	21	—	—	PUNCT
cblr-1208	237	22	even	even	ADV
cblr-1208	237	23	if	if	SCONJ
cblr-1208	237	24	it	it	PRON
cblr-1208	237	25	could	could	AUX
cblr-1208	237	26	be	be	AUX
cblr-1208	237	27	inferred	infer	VERB
cblr-1208	237	28	from	from	ADP
cblr-1208	237	29	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	237	30	payment	payment	NOUN
cblr-1208	237	31	—	—	PUNCT
cblr-1208	237	32	support	support	VERB
cblr-1208	237	33	any	any	DET
cblr-1208	237	34	inference	inference	NOUN
cblr-1208	237	35	as	as	ADP
cblr-1208	237	36	to	to	ADP
cblr-1208	237	37	what	what	PRON
cblr-1208	237	38	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	237	39	federal	federal	ADJ
cblr-1208	237	40	judge	judge	NOUN
cblr-1208	237	41	might	might	AUX
cblr-1208	237	42	have	have	AUX
cblr-1208	237	43	ruled	rule	VERB
cblr-1208	237	44	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	237	45	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	237	46	settled	settle	VERB
cblr-1208	237	47	paragraph	paragraph	NOUN
cblr-1208	237	48	iv	iv	NUM
cblr-1208	237	49	litigation	litigation	NOUN
cblr-1208	237	50	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	237	51	for	for	ADP
cblr-1208	237	52	reasons	reason	NOUN
cblr-1208	237	53	explained	explain	VERB
cblr-1208	237	54	below.59	below.59	VERB
cblr-1208	237	55	treating	treat	VERB
cblr-1208	237	56	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	237	57	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	237	58	large	large	ADJ
cblr-1208	237	59	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	237	60	payment	payment	NOUN
cblr-1208	237	61	as	as	ADP
cblr-1208	237	62	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	237	63	surrogate	surrogate	NOUN
cblr-1208	237	64	for	for	ADP
cblr-1208	237	65	anticompetitive	anticompetitive	ADJ
cblr-1208	237	66	effects	effect	NOUN
cblr-1208	237	67	thus	thus	ADV
cblr-1208	237	68	requires	require	VERB
cblr-1208	237	69	layers	layer	NOUN
cblr-1208	237	70	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	237	71	unsupportable	unsupportable	ADJ
cblr-1208	237	72	presumptions	presumption	NOUN
cblr-1208	237	73	that	that	PRON
cblr-1208	237	74	are	be	AUX
cblr-1208	237	75	intended	intend	VERB
cblr-1208	237	76	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	237	77	support	support	VERB
cblr-1208	237	78	two	two	NUM
cblr-1208	237	79	alternative	alternative	ADJ
cblr-1208	237	80	ultimate	ultimate	ADJ
cblr-1208	237	81	presumptions	presumption	NOUN
cblr-1208	237	82	at	at	ADP
cblr-1208	237	83	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	237	84	core	core	NOUN
cblr-1208	237	85	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	237	86	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	237	87	very	very	ADV
cblr-1208	237	88	first	first	ADJ
cblr-1208	237	89	step	step	NOUN
cblr-1208	237	90	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	237	91	rule	rule	NOUN
cblr-1208	237	92	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	237	93	reason	reason	NOUN
cblr-1208	237	94	inquiry	inquiry	NOUN
cblr-1208	237	95	—	—	PUNCT
cblr-1208	237	96	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	237	97	requirement	requirement	NOUN
cblr-1208	237	98	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	237	99	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	237	100	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
cblr-1208	237	101	establish	establish	VERB
cblr-1208	237	102	an	an	DET
cblr-1208	237	103	anticompetitive	anticompetitive	ADJ
cblr-1208	237	104	effect	effect	NOUN
cblr-1208	237	105	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	238	1	it	it	PRON
cblr-1208	238	2	presumes	presume	VERB
cblr-1208	238	3	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	238	4	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	238	5	without	without	ADP
cblr-1208	238	6	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	238	7	payment	payment	NOUN
cblr-1208	238	8	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	238	9	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	238	10	settlement	settlement	NOUN
cblr-1208	238	11	would	would	AUX
cblr-1208	238	12	still	still	ADV
cblr-1208	238	13	have	have	AUX
cblr-1208	238	14	occurred	occur	VERB
cblr-1208	238	15	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	238	16	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	238	17	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	238	18	it	it	PRON
cblr-1208	238	19	would	would	AUX
cblr-1208	238	20	have	have	AUX
cblr-1208	238	21	included	include	VERB
cblr-1208	238	22	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	238	23	term	term	NOUN
cblr-1208	238	24	for	for	ADP
cblr-1208	238	25	earlier	early	ADJ
cblr-1208	238	26	generic	generic	ADJ
cblr-1208	238	27	entry	entry	NOUN
cblr-1208	238	28	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	239	1	alternatively	alternatively	ADV
cblr-1208	239	2	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	239	3	it	it	PRON
cblr-1208	239	4	presumes	presume	VERB
cblr-1208	239	5	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	239	6	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	239	7	generic	generic	ADJ
cblr-1208	239	8	challenger	challenger	NOUN
cblr-1208	239	9	would	would	AUX
cblr-1208	239	10	have	have	AUX
cblr-1208	239	11	prevailed	prevail	VERB
cblr-1208	239	12	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	239	13	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	239	14	patent	patent	NOUN
cblr-1208	239	15	litigation	litigation	NOUN
cblr-1208	239	16	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	240	1	neither	neither	CCONJ
cblr-1208	240	2	ultimate	ultimate	ADJ
cblr-1208	240	3	presumption	presumption	NOUN
cblr-1208	240	4	is	be	AUX
cblr-1208	240	5	grounded	ground	VERB
cblr-1208	240	6	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	240	7	antitrust	antitrust	ADJ
cblr-1208	240	8	law	law	NOUN
cblr-1208	240	9	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	241	1	56	56	NUM
cblr-1208	241	2	see	see	VERB
cblr-1208	241	3	i	i	PRON
cblr-1208	241	4	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-1208	241	5	57	57	NUM
cblr-1208	241	6	see	see	NOUN
cblr-1208	241	7	carrier	carrier	NOUN
cblr-1208	241	8	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	241	9	supra	supra	PROPN
cblr-1208	241	10	note	note	NOUN
cblr-1208	241	11	27	27	NUM
cblr-1208	241	12	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	241	13	at	at	ADP
cblr-1208	241	14	40	40	NUM
cblr-1208	241	15	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	241	16	58	58	NUM
cblr-1208	241	17	see	see	VERB
cblr-1208	241	18	wellbutrin	wellbutrin	NOUN
cblr-1208	241	19	xl	xl	PROPN
cblr-1208	241	20	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	241	21	868	868	NUM
cblr-1208	241	22	f.3d	f.3d	NUM
cblr-1208	241	23	at	at	ADP
cblr-1208	241	24	168–69	168–69	PROPN
cblr-1208	241	25	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-1208	241	26	rejecting	reject	VERB
cblr-1208	241	27	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	241	28	argument	argument	NOUN
cblr-1208	241	29	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	241	30	size	size	NOUN
cblr-1208	241	31	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	241	32	payment	payment	NOUN
cblr-1208	241	33	is	be	AUX
cblr-1208	241	34	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	241	35	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	241	36	surrogate	surrogate	NOUN
cblr-1208	241	37	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	241	38	for	for	ADP
cblr-1208	241	39	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	241	40	patent	patent	NOUN
cblr-1208	241	41	’s	’s	PART
cblr-1208	241	42	weakness	weakness	NOUN
cblr-1208	241	43	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-1208	241	44	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	242	1	59	59	NUM
cblr-1208	242	2	see	see	VERB
cblr-1208	242	3	infra	infra	NOUN
cblr-1208	242	4	notes	note	VERB
cblr-1208	242	5	71–73	71–73	NUM
cblr-1208	242	6	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	242	7	accompanying	accompany	VERB
cblr-1208	242	8	text	text	NOUN
cblr-1208	242	9	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	243	1	lecture_commentary_final	lecture_commentary_final	ADJ
cblr-1208	244	1	no	no	INTJ
cblr-1208	244	2	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	245	1	1:45	1:45	NUM
cblr-1208	245	2	]	]	PUNCT
cblr-1208	245	3	commentary	commentary	NOUN
cblr-1208	245	4	:	:	PUNCT
cblr-1208	245	5	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	245	6	rule	rule	NOUN
cblr-1208	245	7	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	245	8	reason	reason	NOUN
cblr-1208	245	9	61	61	NUM
cblr-1208	245	10	v.	v.	ADP
cblr-1208	245	11	applying	apply	VERB
cblr-1208	245	12	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	245	13	rule	rule	NOUN
cblr-1208	245	14	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	245	15	reason	reason	NOUN
cblr-1208	245	16	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	245	17	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	245	18	reverse	reverse	VERB
cblr-1208	245	19	payment	payment	NOUN
cblr-1208	245	20	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	245	21	settlement	settlement	NOUN
cblr-1208	245	22	agreements	agreement	NOUN
cblr-1208	245	23	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	245	24	cases	case	NOUN
cblr-1208	245	25	following	follow	VERB
cblr-1208	245	26	actavis	actavis	NUM
cblr-1208	245	27	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	245	28	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
cblr-1208	245	29	seeking	seek	VERB
cblr-1208	245	30	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	245	31	establish	establish	VERB
cblr-1208	245	32	anticompetitive	anticompetitive	ADJ
cblr-1208	245	33	effects	effect	NOUN
cblr-1208	245	34	have	have	AUX
cblr-1208	245	35	offered	offer	VERB
cblr-1208	245	36	two	two	NUM
cblr-1208	245	37	principal	principal	NOUN
cblr-1208	245	38	but	but	CCONJ
cblr-1208	245	39	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-1208	245	40	for	for	ADP
cblr-1208	245	41	theories	theory	NOUN
cblr-1208	245	42	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	246	1	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	246	2	first	first	ADJ
cblr-1208	246	3	theory	theory	NOUN
cblr-1208	246	4	is	be	AUX
cblr-1208	246	5	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	246	6	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	246	7	absent	absent	ADJ
cblr-1208	246	8	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	246	9	reverse	reverse	ADJ
cblr-1208	246	10	payment	payment	NOUN
cblr-1208	246	11	settlement	settlement	NOUN
cblr-1208	246	12	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	246	13	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	246	14	parties	party	NOUN
cblr-1208	246	15	would	would	AUX
cblr-1208	246	16	have	have	AUX
cblr-1208	246	17	entered	enter	VERB
cblr-1208	246	18	into	into	ADP
cblr-1208	246	19	an	an	DET
cblr-1208	246	20	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	246	21	alternative	alternative	ADJ
cblr-1208	246	22	settlement	settlement	NOUN
cblr-1208	246	23	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	246	24	providing	provide	VERB
cblr-1208	246	25	for	for	ADP
cblr-1208	246	26	earlier	early	ADJ
cblr-1208	246	27	generic	generic	ADJ
cblr-1208	246	28	entry	entry	NOUN
cblr-1208	246	29	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	247	1	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	247	2	second	second	ADJ
cblr-1208	247	3	theory	theory	NOUN
cblr-1208	247	4	is	be	AUX
cblr-1208	247	5	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	247	6	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	247	7	absent	absent	ADJ
cblr-1208	247	8	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	247	9	reverse	reverse	ADJ
cblr-1208	247	10	payment	payment	NOUN
cblr-1208	247	11	settlement	settlement	NOUN
cblr-1208	247	12	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	247	13	there	there	PRON
cblr-1208	247	14	would	would	AUX
cblr-1208	247	15	have	have	AUX
cblr-1208	247	16	been	be	AUX
cblr-1208	247	17	no	no	DET
cblr-1208	247	18	settlement	settlement	NOUN
cblr-1208	247	19	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	247	20	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	247	21	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	247	22	generic	generic	ADJ
cblr-1208	247	23	firm	firm	NOUN
cblr-1208	247	24	would	would	AUX
cblr-1208	247	25	have	have	AUX
cblr-1208	247	26	prevailed	prevail	VERB
cblr-1208	247	27	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	247	28	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	247	29	underlying	underlie	VERB
cblr-1208	247	30	patent	patent	NOUN
cblr-1208	247	31	litigation	litigation	NOUN
cblr-1208	247	32	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	248	1	both	both	DET
cblr-1208	248	2	theories	theory	NOUN
cblr-1208	248	3	present	present	VERB
cblr-1208	248	4	challenges	challenge	NOUN
cblr-1208	248	5	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	249	1	a.	a.	NOUN
cblr-1208	249	2	but	but	CCONJ
cblr-1208	249	3	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-1208	249	4	for	for	ADP
cblr-1208	249	5	world	world	NOUN
cblr-1208	249	6	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	249	7	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	249	8	alternative	alternative	ADJ
cblr-1208	249	9	settlement	settlement	NOUN
cblr-1208	249	10	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	249	11	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	249	12	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	249	13	alternative	alternative	ADJ
cblr-1208	249	14	settlement	settlement	NOUN
cblr-1208	249	15	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	249	16	theory	theory	NOUN
cblr-1208	249	17	poses	pose	VERB
cblr-1208	249	18	both	both	CCONJ
cblr-1208	249	19	doctrinal	doctrinal	ADJ
cblr-1208	249	20	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	249	21	evidentiary	evidentiary	ADJ
cblr-1208	249	22	challenges	challenge	NOUN
cblr-1208	249	23	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	249	24	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	249	25	may	may	AUX
cblr-1208	249	26	not	not	PART
cblr-1208	249	27	provide	provide	VERB
cblr-1208	249	28	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	249	29	satisfactory	satisfactory	ADJ
cblr-1208	249	30	basis	basis	NOUN
cblr-1208	249	31	for	for	ADP
cblr-1208	249	32	evaluating	evaluate	VERB
cblr-1208	249	33	anticompetitive	anticompetitive	ADJ
cblr-1208	249	34	effects	effect	NOUN
cblr-1208	249	35	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	249	36	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	249	37	but	but	CCONJ
cblr-1208	249	38	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-1208	249	39	for	for	ADP
cblr-1208	249	40	world	world	NOUN
cblr-1208	249	41	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	250	1	as	as	SCONJ
cblr-1208	250	2	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	250	3	third	third	ADJ
cblr-1208	250	4	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-1208	250	5	explained	explain	VERB
cblr-1208	250	6	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	250	7	king	king	PROPN
cblr-1208	250	8	drug	drug	PROPN
cblr-1208	250	9	co.	co.	PROPN
cblr-1208	250	10	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	250	11	florence	florence	PROPN
cblr-1208	250	12	v.	v.	ADP
cblr-1208	250	13	smithkline	smithkline	PROPN
cblr-1208	250	14	beecham	beecham	PROPN
cblr-1208	250	15	corp	corp	PROPN
cblr-1208	250	16	.	.	PROPN
cblr-1208	250	17	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	250	18	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	250	19	actavis	actavis	PROPN
cblr-1208	250	20	does	do	AUX
cblr-1208	250	21	not	not	PART
cblr-1208	250	22	stand	stand	VERB
cblr-1208	250	23	for	for	ADP
cblr-1208	250	24	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	250	25	proposition	proposition	NOUN
cblr-1208	250	26	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	250	27	parties	party	NOUN
cblr-1208	250	28	must	must	AUX
cblr-1208	250	29	reach	reach	VERB
cblr-1208	250	30	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	250	31	most	most	ADV
cblr-1208	250	32	procompetitive	procompetitive	ADJ
cblr-1208	250	33	settlements	settlement	NOUN
cblr-1208	250	34	possible	possible	ADJ
cblr-1208	250	35	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	250	36	”60	”60	PROPN
cblr-1208	251	1	thus	thus	ADV
cblr-1208	251	2	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	251	3	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	251	4	comparison	comparison	NOUN
cblr-1208	251	5	between	between	ADP
cblr-1208	251	6	an	an	DET
cblr-1208	251	7	actual	actual	ADJ
cblr-1208	251	8	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	251	9	real	real	ADJ
cblr-1208	251	10	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-1208	251	11	world	world	NOUN
cblr-1208	251	12	settlement	settlement	NOUN
cblr-1208	251	13	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	251	14	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	251	15	hypothetical	hypothetical	ADJ
cblr-1208	251	16	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	251	17	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	251	18	alternative	alternative	ADJ
cblr-1208	251	19	settlement	settlement	NOUN
cblr-1208	251	20	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	251	21	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	251	22	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	251	23	but	but	CCONJ
cblr-1208	251	24	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-1208	251	25	for	for	ADP
cblr-1208	251	26	world	world	NOUN
cblr-1208	251	27	does	do	AUX
cblr-1208	251	28	not	not	PART
cblr-1208	251	29	contain	contain	VERB
cblr-1208	251	30	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	251	31	relevant	relevant	ADJ
cblr-1208	251	32	baseline	baseline	NOUN
cblr-1208	251	33	:	:	PUNCT
cblr-1208	252	1	[	[	X
cblr-1208	252	2	b]ecause	b]ecause	ADP
cblr-1208	252	3	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	252	4	relevant	relevant	ADJ
cblr-1208	252	5	baseline	baseline	NOUN
cblr-1208	252	6	is	be	AUX
cblr-1208	252	7	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	252	8	result	result	NOUN
cblr-1208	252	9	that	that	PRON
cblr-1208	252	10	would	would	AUX
cblr-1208	252	11	have	have	AUX
cblr-1208	252	12	occurred	occur	VERB
cblr-1208	252	13	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	252	14	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	252	15	absence	absence	NOUN
cblr-1208	252	16	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	252	17	any	any	DET
cblr-1208	252	18	agreement	agreement	NOUN
cblr-1208	252	19	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	252	20	it	it	PRON
cblr-1208	252	21	is	be	AUX
cblr-1208	252	22	not	not	PART
cblr-1208	252	23	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	252	24	cognizable	cognizable	ADJ
cblr-1208	252	25	harm	harm	NOUN
cblr-1208	252	26	simply	simply	ADV
cblr-1208	252	27	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	252	28	show	show	VERB
cblr-1208	252	29	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	252	30	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	252	31	parties	party	NOUN
cblr-1208	252	32	might	might	AUX
cblr-1208	252	33	have	have	AUX
cblr-1208	252	34	elected	elect	VERB
cblr-1208	252	35	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	252	36	different	different	ADJ
cblr-1208	252	37	settlement	settlement	NOUN
cblr-1208	252	38	agreement	agreement	NOUN
cblr-1208	252	39	more	more	ADV
cblr-1208	252	40	favorable	favorable	ADJ
cblr-1208	252	41	to	to	ADP
cblr-1208	252	42	competition	competition	NOUN
cblr-1208	252	43	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	252	44	consumers.61	consumers.61	NOUN
cblr-1208	252	45	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	252	46	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	252	47	view	view	NOUN
cblr-1208	252	48	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	252	49	courts	court	NOUN
cblr-1208	252	50	that	that	PRON
cblr-1208	252	51	follow	follow	VERB
cblr-1208	252	52	this	this	DET
cblr-1208	252	53	line	line	NOUN
cblr-1208	252	54	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	252	55	thought	thought	NOUN
cblr-1208	252	56	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	252	57	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	252	58	relevant	relevant	ADJ
cblr-1208	252	59	baseline	baseline	NOUN
cblr-1208	252	60	is	be	AUX
cblr-1208	252	61	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	252	62	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	252	63	level	level	NOUN
cblr-1208	252	64	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	252	65	competition	competition	NOUN
cblr-1208	252	66	that	that	PRON
cblr-1208	252	67	would	would	AUX
cblr-1208	252	68	have	have	VERB
cblr-1208	252	69	60	60	NUM
cblr-1208	252	70	king	king	NOUN
cblr-1208	252	71	drug	drug	PROPN
cblr-1208	252	72	co.	co.	PROPN
cblr-1208	252	73	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	252	74	florence	florence	PROPN
cblr-1208	252	75	v.	v.	ADP
cblr-1208	252	76	smithkline	smithkline	PROPN
cblr-1208	252	77	beecham	beecham	PROPN
cblr-1208	252	78	corp	corp	PROPN
cblr-1208	252	79	.	.	PROPN
cblr-1208	252	80	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	252	81	791	791	NUM
cblr-1208	252	82	f.3d	f.3d	NUM
cblr-1208	252	83	388	388	NUM
cblr-1208	252	84	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	252	85	408–09	408–09	NUM
cblr-1208	252	86	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-1208	252	87	3d	3d	PROPN
cblr-1208	252	88	cir	cir	NOUN
cblr-1208	252	89	.	.	PROPN
cblr-1208	252	90	2015	2015	NUM
cblr-1208	252	91	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-1208	252	92	;	;	PUNCT
cblr-1208	252	93	see	see	VERB
cblr-1208	252	94	also	also	ADV
cblr-1208	252	95	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	252	96	re	re	VERB
cblr-1208	252	97	cipro	cipro	ADJ
cblr-1208	252	98	cases	case	NOUN
cblr-1208	252	99	i	i	PRON
cblr-1208	252	100	&	&	CCONJ
cblr-1208	252	101	ii	ii	PROPN
cblr-1208	252	102	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	252	103	61	61	NUM
cblr-1208	252	104	cal	cal	NOUN
cblr-1208	252	105	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	253	1	4th	4th	ADJ
cblr-1208	253	2	116	116	NUM
cblr-1208	253	3	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	253	4	150	150	NUM
cblr-1208	253	5	n.10	n.10	ADP
cblr-1208	253	6	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-1208	253	7	2015	2015	NUM
cblr-1208	253	8	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-1208	253	9	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	254	1	61	61	NUM
cblr-1208	254	2	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	254	3	re	re	VERB
cblr-1208	254	4	cipro	cipro	ADJ
cblr-1208	254	5	cases	case	NOUN
cblr-1208	254	6	i	i	PRON
cblr-1208	254	7	&	&	CCONJ
cblr-1208	254	8	ii	ii	PROPN
cblr-1208	254	9	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	254	10	348	348	NUM
cblr-1208	254	11	p.3d	p.3d	SYM
cblr-1208	254	12	845	845	NUM
cblr-1208	254	13	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	254	14	864	864	NUM
cblr-1208	254	15	n.10	n.10	ADP
cblr-1208	254	16	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-1208	254	17	2015	2015	NUM
cblr-1208	254	18	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-1208	254	19	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	255	1	lecture_commentary_final	lecture_commentary_final	PROPN
cblr-1208	255	2	62	62	NUM
cblr-1208	255	3	columbia	columbia	PROPN
cblr-1208	255	4	business	business	NOUN
cblr-1208	255	5	law	law	PROPN
cblr-1208	255	6	review	review	NOUN
cblr-1208	255	7	[	[	X
cblr-1208	255	8	vol	vol	NOUN
cblr-1208	255	9	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	255	10	2018	2018	NUM
cblr-1208	255	11	obtained	obtain	VERB
cblr-1208	255	12	absent	absent	ADJ
cblr-1208	255	13	settlement	settlement	NOUN
cblr-1208	255	14	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	255	15	i.e.	i.e.	X
cblr-1208	255	16	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	255	17	if	if	SCONJ
cblr-1208	255	18	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	255	19	parties	party	NOUN
cblr-1208	255	20	had	have	AUX
cblr-1208	255	21	litigated	litigate	VERB
cblr-1208	255	22	validity	validity	NOUN
cblr-1208	255	23	/	/	SYM
cblr-1208	255	24	invalidity	invalidity	NOUN
cblr-1208	255	25	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	255	26	infringement	infringement	NOUN
cblr-1208	255	27	/	/	SYM
cblr-1208	255	28	noninfringement	noninfringement	NOUN
cblr-1208	255	29	to	to	ADP
cblr-1208	255	30	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	255	31	judicial	judicial	ADJ
cblr-1208	255	32	determination	determination	NOUN
cblr-1208	255	33	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	256	1	”62	”62	PROPN
cblr-1208	256	2	this	this	DET
cblr-1208	256	3	approach	approach	NOUN
cblr-1208	256	4	recognizes	recognize	VERB
cblr-1208	256	5	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	256	6	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	256	7	payment	payment	NOUN
cblr-1208	256	8	at	at	ADP
cblr-1208	256	9	issue	issue	NOUN
cblr-1208	256	10	is	be	AUX
cblr-1208	256	11	part	part	NOUN
cblr-1208	256	12	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	256	13	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	256	14	larger	large	ADJ
cblr-1208	256	15	procompetitive	procompetitive	ADJ
cblr-1208	256	16	settlement	settlement	NOUN
cblr-1208	256	17	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	256	18	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	256	19	properly	properly	ADV
cblr-1208	256	20	declines	decline	VERB
cblr-1208	256	21	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	256	22	impose	impose	VERB
cblr-1208	256	23	an	an	DET
cblr-1208	256	24	obligation	obligation	NOUN
cblr-1208	256	25	on	on	ADP
cblr-1208	256	26	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	256	27	parties	party	NOUN
cblr-1208	256	28	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	256	29	reach	reach	VERB
cblr-1208	256	30	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	256	31	most	most	ADV
cblr-1208	256	32	procompetitive	procompetitive	ADJ
cblr-1208	256	33	agreement	agreement	NOUN
cblr-1208	256	34	possible	possible	ADJ
cblr-1208	256	35	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	257	1	this	this	PRON
cblr-1208	257	2	brings	bring	VERB
cblr-1208	257	3	us	we	PRON
cblr-1208	257	4	back	back	ADV
cblr-1208	257	5	to	to	ADP
cblr-1208	257	6	william	william	PROPN
cblr-1208	257	7	howard	howard	PROPN
cblr-1208	257	8	taft	taft	PROPN
cblr-1208	257	9	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	257	10	addyston	addyston	PROPN
cblr-1208	257	11	pipe	pipe	NOUN
cblr-1208	257	12	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	258	1	if	if	SCONJ
cblr-1208	258	2	there	there	PRON
cblr-1208	258	3	is	be	VERB
cblr-1208	258	4	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	258	5	doctrinal	doctrinal	ADJ
cblr-1208	258	6	basis	basis	NOUN
cblr-1208	258	7	that	that	PRON
cblr-1208	258	8	might	might	AUX
cblr-1208	258	9	justify	justify	VERB
cblr-1208	258	10	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	258	11	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	258	12	alternative	alternative	ADJ
cblr-1208	258	13	settlement	settlement	NOUN
cblr-1208	258	14	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	258	15	theory	theory	NOUN
cblr-1208	258	16	—	—	PUNCT
cblr-1208	258	17	or	or	CCONJ
cblr-1208	258	18	anything	anything	PRON
cblr-1208	258	19	remotely	remotely	ADV
cblr-1208	258	20	like	like	ADP
cblr-1208	258	21	it	it	PRON
cblr-1208	258	22	—	—	PUNCT
cblr-1208	258	23	it	it	PRON
cblr-1208	258	24	may	may	AUX
cblr-1208	258	25	be	be	AUX
cblr-1208	258	26	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	258	27	ancillary	ancillary	ADJ
cblr-1208	258	28	restraint	restraint	NOUN
cblr-1208	258	29	doctrine	doctrine	NOUN
cblr-1208	258	30	first	first	ADV
cblr-1208	258	31	articulated	articulate	VERB
cblr-1208	258	32	by	by	ADP
cblr-1208	258	33	then	then	ADV
cblr-1208	258	34	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-1208	258	35	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-1208	258	36	judge	judge	NOUN
cblr-1208	258	37	taft	taft	NOUN
cblr-1208	258	38	:	:	PUNCT
cblr-1208	259	1	[	[	X
cblr-1208	259	2	n]o	n]o	ADJ
cblr-1208	259	3	conventional	conventional	ADJ
cblr-1208	259	4	restraint	restraint	NOUN
cblr-1208	259	5	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	259	6	trade	trade	NOUN
cblr-1208	259	7	can	can	AUX
cblr-1208	259	8	be	be	AUX
cblr-1208	259	9	enforced	enforce	VERB
cblr-1208	259	10	unless	unless	SCONJ
cblr-1208	259	11	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	259	12	covenant	covenant	NOUN
cblr-1208	259	13	embodying	embody	VERB
cblr-1208	259	14	it	it	PRON
cblr-1208	259	15	is	be	AUX
cblr-1208	259	16	merely	merely	ADV
cblr-1208	259	17	ancillary	ancillary	ADJ
cblr-1208	259	18	to	to	ADP
cblr-1208	259	19	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	259	20	main	main	ADJ
cblr-1208	259	21	purpose	purpose	NOUN
cblr-1208	259	22	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	259	23	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	259	24	lawful	lawful	ADJ
cblr-1208	259	25	contract	contract	NOUN
cblr-1208	259	26	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	259	27	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	259	28	necessary	necessary	ADJ
cblr-1208	259	29	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	259	30	protect	protect	VERB
cblr-1208	259	31	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	259	32	covenantee	covenantee	NOUN
cblr-1208	259	33	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	259	34	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	259	35	enjoyment	enjoyment	NOUN
cblr-1208	259	36	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	259	37	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	259	38	legitimate	legitimate	ADJ
cblr-1208	259	39	fruits	fruit	NOUN
cblr-1208	259	40	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	259	41	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	259	42	contract	contract	NOUN
cblr-1208	259	43	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	259	44	or	or	CCONJ
cblr-1208	259	45	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	259	46	protect	protect	VERB
cblr-1208	259	47	him	he	PRON
cblr-1208	259	48	from	from	ADP
cblr-1208	259	49	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	259	50	dangers	danger	NOUN
cblr-1208	259	51	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	259	52	an	an	DET
cblr-1208	259	53	unjust	unjust	ADJ
cblr-1208	259	54	use	use	NOUN
cblr-1208	259	55	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	259	56	those	those	DET
cblr-1208	259	57	fruits	fruit	NOUN
cblr-1208	259	58	by	by	ADP
cblr-1208	259	59	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	259	60	other	other	ADJ
cblr-1208	259	61	party.63	party.63	NOUN
cblr-1208	259	62	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	259	63	course	course	NOUN
cblr-1208	259	64	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	259	65	before	before	SCONJ
cblr-1208	259	66	one	one	PRON
cblr-1208	259	67	can	can	AUX
cblr-1208	259	68	determine	determine	VERB
cblr-1208	259	69	whether	whether	SCONJ
cblr-1208	259	70	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	259	71	restraint	restraint	NOUN
cblr-1208	259	72	is	be	AUX
cblr-1208	259	73	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	259	74	ancillary	ancillary	ADJ
cblr-1208	259	75	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	259	76	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	259	77	one	one	PRON
cblr-1208	259	78	must	must	AUX
cblr-1208	259	79	identify	identify	VERB
cblr-1208	259	80	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	259	81	restraint	restraint	NOUN
cblr-1208	259	82	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	260	1	presumably	presumably	ADV
cblr-1208	260	2	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	260	3	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
cblr-1208	260	4	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	260	5	so	so	ADV
cblr-1208	260	6	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-1208	260	7	called	call	VERB
cblr-1208	260	8	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	260	9	reverse	reverse	ADJ
cblr-1208	260	10	payment	payment	NOUN
cblr-1208	260	11	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	260	12	cases	case	NOUN
cblr-1208	260	13	would	would	AUX
cblr-1208	260	14	argue	argue	VERB
cblr-1208	260	15	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	260	16	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	260	17	restraint	restraint	NOUN
cblr-1208	260	18	is	be	AUX
cblr-1208	260	19	defined	define	VERB
cblr-1208	260	20	by	by	ADP
cblr-1208	260	21	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	260	22	period	period	NOUN
cblr-1208	260	23	before	before	ADP
cblr-1208	260	24	entry	entry	NOUN
cblr-1208	260	25	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	260	26	which	which	PRON
cblr-1208	260	27	they	they	PRON
cblr-1208	260	28	assume	assume	VERB
cblr-1208	260	29	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-1208	260	30	but	but	CCONJ
cblr-1208	260	31	at	at	ADP
cblr-1208	260	32	some	some	DET
cblr-1208	260	33	point	point	NOUN
cblr-1208	260	34	would	would	AUX
cblr-1208	260	35	have	have	VERB
cblr-1208	260	36	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	260	37	prove	prove	VERB
cblr-1208	260	38	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-1208	260	39	would	would	AUX
cblr-1208	260	40	have	have	AUX
cblr-1208	260	41	been	be	AUX
cblr-1208	260	42	shorter	short	ADJ
cblr-1208	260	43	but	but	CCONJ
cblr-1208	260	44	for	for	ADP
cblr-1208	260	45	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	260	46	payment	payment	NOUN
cblr-1208	260	47	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	261	1	or	or	CCONJ
cblr-1208	261	2	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	261	3	they	they	PRON
cblr-1208	261	4	could	could	AUX
cblr-1208	261	5	argue	argue	VERB
cblr-1208	261	6	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	261	7	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	261	8	mere	mere	ADJ
cblr-1208	261	9	presence	presence	NOUN
cblr-1208	261	10	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	261	11	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	261	12	payment	payment	NOUN
cblr-1208	261	13	itself	itself	PRON
cblr-1208	261	14	is	be	AUX
cblr-1208	261	15	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	261	16	restraint	restraint	NOUN
cblr-1208	261	17	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	262	1	either	either	DET
cblr-1208	262	2	way	way	NOUN
cblr-1208	262	3	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	262	4	whether	whether	SCONJ
cblr-1208	262	5	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	262	6	term	term	NOUN
cblr-1208	262	7	is	be	AUX
cblr-1208	262	8	ancillary	ancillary	ADJ
cblr-1208	262	9	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	262	10	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	262	11	thus	thus	ADV
cblr-1208	262	12	permissible	permissible	ADJ
cblr-1208	262	13	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	262	14	depends	depend	VERB
cblr-1208	262	15	on	on	ADP
cblr-1208	262	16	whether	whether	SCONJ
cblr-1208	262	17	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	262	18	challenged	challenge	VERB
cblr-1208	262	19	term	term	NOUN
cblr-1208	262	20	was	be	AUX
cblr-1208	262	21	necessary	necessary	ADJ
cblr-1208	262	22	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	262	23	achieve	achieve	VERB
cblr-1208	262	24	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	262	25	lawful	lawful	ADJ
cblr-1208	262	26	objectives	objective	NOUN
cblr-1208	262	27	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	262	28	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	262	29	agreement.64	agreement.64	NOUN
cblr-1208	262	30	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	262	31	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	262	32	context	context	NOUN
cblr-1208	262	33	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	262	34	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	262	35	patent	patent	NOUN
cblr-1208	262	36	settlement	settlement	NOUN
cblr-1208	262	37	agreement	agreement	NOUN
cblr-1208	262	38	involving	involve	VERB
cblr-1208	262	39	alleged	allege	VERB
cblr-1208	262	40	reverse	reverse	ADJ
cblr-1208	262	41	payments	payment	NOUN
cblr-1208	262	42	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	262	43	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	262	44	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
cblr-1208	262	45	’s	’s	PART
cblr-1208	262	46	burden	burden	NOUN
cblr-1208	262	47	would	would	AUX
cblr-1208	262	48	be	be	AUX
cblr-1208	262	49	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	262	50	show	show	VERB
cblr-1208	262	51	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	262	52	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	262	53	alleged	allege	VERB
cblr-1208	262	54	payment	payment	NOUN
cblr-1208	262	55	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-1208	262	56	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	262	57	entry	entry	NOUN
cblr-1208	262	58	date	date	NOUN
cblr-1208	262	59	agreement	agreement	NOUN
cblr-1208	262	60	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-1208	262	61	was	be	AUX
cblr-1208	262	62	not	not	PART
cblr-1208	262	63	62	62	NUM
cblr-1208	262	64	i	i	PRON
cblr-1208	262	65	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-1208	262	66	at	at	ADP
cblr-1208	262	67	864	864	NUM
cblr-1208	262	68	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	263	1	63	63	NUM
cblr-1208	263	2	united	united	PROPN
cblr-1208	263	3	states	states	PROPN
cblr-1208	263	4	v.	v.	ADP
cblr-1208	263	5	addyston	addyston	PROPN
cblr-1208	263	6	pipe	pipe	PROPN
cblr-1208	263	7	&	&	CCONJ
cblr-1208	263	8	steel	steel	PROPN
cblr-1208	263	9	co.	co.	PROPN
cblr-1208	263	10	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	263	11	85	85	NUM
cblr-1208	263	12	f.	f.	PROPN
cblr-1208	263	13	271	271	NUM
cblr-1208	263	14	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	263	15	272	272	NUM
cblr-1208	263	16	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-1208	263	17	6th	6th	ADJ
cblr-1208	263	18	cir	cir	NOUN
cblr-1208	263	19	.	.	PROPN
cblr-1208	263	20	1898	1898	NUM
cblr-1208	263	21	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-1208	263	22	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	263	23	aff’d	aff’d	VERB
cblr-1208	263	24	175	175	NUM
cblr-1208	263	25	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-1208	263	26	.	.	PROPN
cblr-1208	263	27	211	211	NUM
cblr-1208	263	28	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-1208	263	29	1899	1899	NUM
cblr-1208	263	30	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-1208	263	31	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	264	1	64	64	NUM
cblr-1208	264	2	see	see	VERB
cblr-1208	264	3	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	264	4	e.g.	e.g.	ADV
cblr-1208	264	5	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	264	6	broad	broad	ADJ
cblr-1208	264	7	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	265	1	music	music	NOUN
cblr-1208	265	2	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	265	3	inc	inc	PROPN
cblr-1208	265	4	.	.	PROPN
cblr-1208	265	5	v.	v.	PROPN
cblr-1208	265	6	columbia	columbia	PROPN
cblr-1208	265	7	broad	broad	PROPN
cblr-1208	265	8	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	266	1	sys	sys	PROPN
cblr-1208	266	2	.	.	PROPN
cblr-1208	266	3	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	266	4	441	441	NUM
cblr-1208	266	5	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-1208	266	6	.	.	PROPN
cblr-1208	266	7	1	1	NUM
cblr-1208	266	8	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	266	9	21	21	NUM
cblr-1208	266	10	–	–	PUNCT
cblr-1208	266	11	22	22	NUM
cblr-1208	266	12	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-1208	266	13	1979	1979	NUM
cblr-1208	266	14	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-1208	266	15	;	;	PUNCT
cblr-1208	266	16	polk	polk	PROPN
cblr-1208	266	17	bros	bros	PROPN
cblr-1208	266	18	.	.	PROPN
cblr-1208	266	19	inc	inc	PROPN
cblr-1208	266	20	.	.	PROPN
cblr-1208	267	1	v.	v.	ADP
cblr-1208	267	2	forest	forest	NOUN
cblr-1208	267	3	city	city	NOUN
cblr-1208	267	4	enters	enter	NOUN
cblr-1208	267	5	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	267	6	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	267	7	inc	inc	PROPN
cblr-1208	267	8	.	.	PROPN
cblr-1208	267	9	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	267	10	776	776	NUM
cblr-1208	267	11	f.2d	f.2d	ADP
cblr-1208	267	12	185	185	NUM
cblr-1208	267	13	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	267	14	189–90	189–90	NUM
cblr-1208	267	15	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-1208	267	16	7th	7th	ADJ
cblr-1208	267	17	cir	cir	NOUN
cblr-1208	267	18	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	267	19	1985	1985	NUM
cblr-1208	267	20	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-1208	267	21	;	;	PUNCT
cblr-1208	267	22	l.a	l.a	PROPN
cblr-1208	267	23	.	.	PROPN
cblr-1208	267	24	mem’l	mem’l	PROPN
cblr-1208	267	25	coliseum	coliseum	PROPN
cblr-1208	267	26	comm’n	comm’n	NOUN
cblr-1208	267	27	v.	v.	ADP
cblr-1208	267	28	nat’l	nat’l	PROPN
cblr-1208	267	29	football	football	NOUN
cblr-1208	267	30	league	league	NOUN
cblr-1208	267	31	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	267	32	726	726	NUM
cblr-1208	267	33	f.2d	f.2d	NUM
cblr-1208	267	34	1381	1381	NUM
cblr-1208	267	35	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	267	36	1395	1395	NUM
cblr-1208	267	37	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-1208	267	38	9th	9th	ADJ
cblr-1208	267	39	cir	cir	NOUN
cblr-1208	267	40	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	267	41	1984	1984	NUM
cblr-1208	267	42	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-1208	267	43	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	268	1	lecture_commentary_final	lecture_commentary_final	PROPN
cblr-1208	269	1	no	no	INTJ
cblr-1208	269	2	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	270	1	1:45	1:45	NUM
cblr-1208	270	2	]	]	PUNCT
cblr-1208	270	3	commentary	commentary	NOUN
cblr-1208	270	4	:	:	PUNCT
cblr-1208	270	5	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	270	6	rule	rule	NOUN
cblr-1208	270	7	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	270	8	reason	reason	NOUN
cblr-1208	270	9	63	63	NUM
cblr-1208	270	10	necessary	necessary	ADJ
cblr-1208	270	11	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	270	12	achieve	achieve	VERB
cblr-1208	270	13	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	270	14	settlement	settlement	NOUN
cblr-1208	270	15	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	270	16	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	270	17	presumptively	presumptively	ADV
cblr-1208	270	18	lawful	lawful	ADJ
cblr-1208	270	19	purpose	purpose	NOUN
cblr-1208	270	20	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	270	21	which	which	PRON
cblr-1208	270	22	was	be	AUX
cblr-1208	270	23	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	270	24	eliminate	eliminate	VERB
cblr-1208	270	25	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	270	26	uncertainty	uncertainty	NOUN
cblr-1208	270	27	as	as	ADP
cblr-1208	270	28	to	to	ADP
cblr-1208	270	29	whether	whether	SCONJ
cblr-1208	270	30	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	270	31	when	when	SCONJ
cblr-1208	270	32	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	270	33	existing	exist	VERB
cblr-1208	270	34	patent	patent	NOUN
cblr-1208	270	35	barrier	barrier	NOUN
cblr-1208	270	36	to	to	ADP
cblr-1208	270	37	entry	entry	NOUN
cblr-1208	270	38	would	would	AUX
cblr-1208	270	39	be	be	AUX
cblr-1208	270	40	lifted	lift	VERB
cblr-1208	270	41	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	270	42	as	as	ADV
cblr-1208	270	43	well	well	ADV
cblr-1208	270	44	as	as	ADP
cblr-1208	270	45	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	270	46	continuing	continue	VERB
cblr-1208	270	47	burden	burden	NOUN
cblr-1208	270	48	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	270	49	cost	cost	NOUN
cblr-1208	270	50	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	270	51	litigation	litigation	NOUN
cblr-1208	270	52	on	on	ADP
cblr-1208	270	53	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	270	54	parties	party	NOUN
cblr-1208	270	55	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	270	56	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	270	57	court	court	NOUN
cblr-1208	270	58	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	270	59	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	270	60	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	270	61	taxpayers.65	taxpayers.65	NOUN
cblr-1208	270	62	if	if	SCONJ
cblr-1208	270	63	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	270	64	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
cblr-1208	270	65	can	can	AUX
cblr-1208	270	66	not	not	PART
cblr-1208	270	67	meet	meet	VERB
cblr-1208	270	68	this	this	DET
cblr-1208	270	69	burden	burden	NOUN
cblr-1208	270	70	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	270	71	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	270	72	court	court	NOUN
cblr-1208	270	73	should	should	AUX
cblr-1208	270	74	grant	grant	VERB
cblr-1208	270	75	summary	summary	NOUN
cblr-1208	270	76	judgment	judgment	NOUN
cblr-1208	270	77	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	270	78	favor	favor	NOUN
cblr-1208	270	79	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	270	80	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	270	81	defendants	defendant	NOUN
cblr-1208	270	82	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	271	1	whether	whether	SCONJ
cblr-1208	271	2	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	271	3	payment	payment	NOUN
cblr-1208	271	4	was	be	AUX
cblr-1208	271	5	necessary	necessary	ADJ
cblr-1208	271	6	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	271	7	achieve	achieve	VERB
cblr-1208	271	8	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	271	9	lawful	lawful	ADJ
cblr-1208	271	10	objectives	objective	NOUN
cblr-1208	271	11	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	271	12	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	271	13	patent	patent	NOUN
cblr-1208	271	14	settlement	settlement	NOUN
cblr-1208	271	15	agreement	agreement	NOUN
cblr-1208	271	16	is	be	AUX
cblr-1208	271	17	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	271	18	question	question	NOUN
cblr-1208	271	19	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	271	20	fact	fact	NOUN
cblr-1208	271	21	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	272	1	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	272	2	third	third	ADJ
cblr-1208	272	3	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-1208	272	4	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	272	5	wellbutrin	wellbutrin	NOUN
cblr-1208	272	6	xl	xl	PROPN
cblr-1208	272	7	explained	explain	VERB
cblr-1208	272	8	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	272	9	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	272	10	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	272	11	withstand	withstand	VERB
cblr-1208	272	12	summary	summary	NOUN
cblr-1208	272	13	judgment	judgment	NOUN
cblr-1208	272	14	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	272	15	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	272	16	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
cblr-1208	272	17	must	must	AUX
cblr-1208	272	18	produce	produce	VERB
cblr-1208	272	19	evidence	evidence	NOUN
cblr-1208	272	20	from	from	ADP
cblr-1208	272	21	which	which	PRON
cblr-1208	272	22	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	272	23	reasonable	reasonable	ADJ
cblr-1208	272	24	jury	jury	NOUN
cblr-1208	272	25	could	could	AUX
cblr-1208	272	26	conclude	conclude	VERB
cblr-1208	272	27	that	that	PRON
cblr-1208	272	28	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	272	29	more	more	ADV
cblr-1208	272	30	likely	likely	ADJ
cblr-1208	272	31	than	than	ADP
cblr-1208	272	32	not	not	PART
cblr-1208	272	33	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	272	34	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	272	35	parties	party	NOUN
cblr-1208	272	36	would	would	AUX
cblr-1208	272	37	have	have	AUX
cblr-1208	272	38	reached	reach	VERB
cblr-1208	272	39	an	an	DET
cblr-1208	272	40	alternative	alternative	ADJ
cblr-1208	272	41	settlement	settlement	NOUN
cblr-1208	272	42	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	272	43	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	272	44	but	but	CCONJ
cblr-1208	272	45	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-1208	272	46	for	for	ADP
cblr-1208	272	47	world.66	world.66	NOUN
cblr-1208	272	48	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	272	49	practice	practice	NOUN
cblr-1208	272	50	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	272	51	even	even	ADV
cblr-1208	272	52	where	where	SCONJ
cblr-1208	272	53	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	272	54	evidence	evidence	NOUN
cblr-1208	272	55	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	272	56	settlement	settlement	NOUN
cblr-1208	272	57	discussions	discussion	NOUN
cblr-1208	272	58	is	be	AUX
cblr-1208	272	59	voluminous	voluminous	ADJ
cblr-1208	272	60	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	272	61	there	there	PRON
cblr-1208	272	62	may	may	AUX
cblr-1208	272	63	not	not	PART
cblr-1208	272	64	be	be	AUX
cblr-1208	272	65	evidence	evidence	NOUN
cblr-1208	272	66	that	that	PRON
cblr-1208	272	67	would	would	AUX
cblr-1208	272	68	permit	permit	VERB
cblr-1208	272	69	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	272	70	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
cblr-1208	272	71	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	272	72	meet	meet	VERB
cblr-1208	272	73	its	its	PRON
cblr-1208	272	74	burden	burden	NOUN
cblr-1208	272	75	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	273	1	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	273	2	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
cblr-1208	273	3	can	can	AUX
cblr-1208	273	4	not	not	PART
cblr-1208	273	5	meet	meet	VERB
cblr-1208	273	6	its	its	PRON
cblr-1208	273	7	burden	burden	NOUN
cblr-1208	273	8	merely	merely	ADV
cblr-1208	273	9	by	by	ADP
cblr-1208	273	10	showing	show	VERB
cblr-1208	273	11	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	273	12	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	273	13	parties	party	NOUN
cblr-1208	273	14	may	may	AUX
cblr-1208	273	15	have	have	AUX
cblr-1208	273	16	been	be	AUX
cblr-1208	273	17	able	able	ADJ
cblr-1208	273	18	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	273	19	reach	reach	VERB
cblr-1208	273	20	an	an	DET
cblr-1208	273	21	alternative	alternative	ADJ
cblr-1208	273	22	settlement.67	settlement.67	NOUN
cblr-1208	273	23	such	such	DET
cblr-1208	273	24	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	273	25	showing	showing	NOUN
cblr-1208	273	26	would	would	AUX
cblr-1208	273	27	simply	simply	ADV
cblr-1208	273	28	be	be	AUX
cblr-1208	273	29	too	too	ADV
cblr-1208	273	30	speculative	speculative	ADJ
cblr-1208	273	31	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	274	1	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	274	2	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	274	3	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	274	4	course	course	NOUN
cblr-1208	274	5	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	274	6	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	274	7	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
cblr-1208	274	8	can	can	AUX
cblr-1208	274	9	not	not	PART
cblr-1208	274	10	meet	meet	VERB
cblr-1208	274	11	its	its	PRON
cblr-1208	274	12	burden	burden	NOUN
cblr-1208	274	13	by	by	ADP
cblr-1208	274	14	showing	show	VERB
cblr-1208	274	15	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	274	16	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	274	17	absent	absent	ADJ
cblr-1208	274	18	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	274	19	payment	payment	NOUN
cblr-1208	274	20	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	274	21	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	274	22	parties	party	NOUN
cblr-1208	274	23	would	would	AUX
cblr-1208	274	24	have	have	AUX
cblr-1208	274	25	entered	enter	VERB
cblr-1208	274	26	into	into	ADP
cblr-1208	274	27	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	274	28	alternative	alternative	ADJ
cblr-1208	274	29	settlement	settlement	NOUN
cblr-1208	274	30	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	274	31	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	274	32	but	but	CCONJ
cblr-1208	274	33	without	without	ADP
cblr-1208	274	34	an	an	DET
cblr-1208	274	35	earlier	early	ADJ
cblr-1208	274	36	65	65	NUM
cblr-1208	274	37	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	274	38	court	court	NOUN
cblr-1208	274	39	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	274	40	one	one	NUM
cblr-1208	274	41	post	post	ADJ
cblr-1208	274	42	-	-	ADJ
cblr-1208	274	43	actavis	actavis	ADJ
cblr-1208	274	44	decision	decision	NOUN
cblr-1208	274	45	framed	frame	VERB
cblr-1208	274	46	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	274	47	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	274	48	alternative	alternative	ADJ
cblr-1208	274	49	settlement	settlement	NOUN
cblr-1208	274	50	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	274	51	scenario	scenario	NOUN
cblr-1208	274	52	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	274	53	similar	similar	ADJ
cblr-1208	274	54	terms	term	NOUN
cblr-1208	274	55	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	274	56	noting	note	VERB
cblr-1208	274	57	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	274	58	there	there	PRON
cblr-1208	274	59	may	may	AUX
cblr-1208	274	60	be	be	AUX
cblr-1208	274	61	injury	injury	NOUN
cblr-1208	274	62	to	to	ADP
cblr-1208	274	63	competition	competition	NOUN
cblr-1208	274	64	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	274	65	if	if	SCONJ
cblr-1208	274	66	there	there	PRON
cblr-1208	274	67	is	be	VERB
cblr-1208	274	68	evidence	evidence	NOUN
cblr-1208	274	69	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	274	70	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	274	71	but	but	CCONJ
cblr-1208	274	72	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-1208	274	73	for	for	ADP
cblr-1208	274	74	world	world	NOUN
cblr-1208	274	75	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	274	76	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	274	77	parties	party	NOUN
cblr-1208	274	78	would	would	AUX
cblr-1208	274	79	have	have	AUX
cblr-1208	274	80	reached	reach	VERB
cblr-1208	274	81	an	an	DET
cblr-1208	274	82	agreement	agreement	NOUN
cblr-1208	274	83	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	274	84	drop	drop	VERB
cblr-1208	274	85	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	274	86	patent	patent	NOUN
cblr-1208	274	87	litigation	litigation	NOUN
cblr-1208	274	88	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	274	89	exchange	exchange	NOUN
cblr-1208	274	90	for	for	ADP
cblr-1208	274	91	early	early	ADJ
cblr-1208	274	92	generic	generic	ADJ
cblr-1208	274	93	entry	entry	NOUN
cblr-1208	274	94	into	into	ADP
cblr-1208	274	95	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	274	96	market	market	NOUN
cblr-1208	274	97	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	274	98	without	without	ADP
cblr-1208	274	99	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	274	100	reverse	reverse	ADJ
cblr-1208	274	101	payment	payment	NOUN
cblr-1208	274	102	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	275	1	united	united	PROPN
cblr-1208	275	2	food	food	PROPN
cblr-1208	275	3	&	&	CCONJ
cblr-1208	275	4	commercial	commercial	ADJ
cblr-1208	275	5	workers	worker	NOUN
cblr-1208	275	6	local	local	ADJ
cblr-1208	275	7	1776	1776	NUM
cblr-1208	275	8	v.	v.	ADP
cblr-1208	275	9	teikoku	teikoku	PROPN
cblr-1208	275	10	pharma	pharma	PROPN
cblr-1208	275	11	usa	usa	PROPN
cblr-1208	275	12	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-1208	275	13	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	275	14	lidoderm	lidoderm	NOUN
cblr-1208	275	15	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	275	16	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-1208	275	17	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	275	18	no	no	INTJ
cblr-1208	275	19	.	.	NOUN
cblr-1208	275	20	14	14	NUM
cblr-1208	275	21	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-1208	275	22	md-02521	md-02521	NOUN
cblr-1208	275	23	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-1208	275	24	who	who	PRON
cblr-1208	275	25	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	275	26	2017	2017	NUM
cblr-1208	275	27	wl	wl	NOUN
cblr-1208	275	28	5068533	5068533	NUM
cblr-1208	275	29	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	275	30	at	at	ADP
cblr-1208	275	31	*	*	NUM
cblr-1208	275	32	10	10	NUM
cblr-1208	275	33	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-1208	275	34	n.d	n.d	PROPN
cblr-1208	275	35	.	.	PROPN
cblr-1208	275	36	cal	cal	PROPN
cblr-1208	275	37	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	276	1	nov	nov	PROPN
cblr-1208	276	2	.	.	PROPN
cblr-1208	276	3	3	3	NUM
cblr-1208	276	4	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	276	5	2017	2017	NUM
cblr-1208	276	6	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-1208	276	7	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	277	1	arnold	arnold	PROPN
cblr-1208	277	2	&	&	CCONJ
cblr-1208	277	3	porter	porter	PROPN
cblr-1208	277	4	is	be	AUX
cblr-1208	277	5	counsel	counsel	NOUN
cblr-1208	277	6	for	for	ADP
cblr-1208	277	7	one	one	NUM
cblr-1208	277	8	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	277	9	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	277	10	defendants	defendant	NOUN
cblr-1208	277	11	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	277	12	lidoderm	lidoderm	NOUN
cblr-1208	277	13	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	278	1	while	while	SCONJ
cblr-1208	278	2	this	this	DET
cblr-1208	278	3	article	article	NOUN
cblr-1208	278	4	notes	note	VERB
cblr-1208	278	5	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	278	6	lidoderm	lidoderm	NOUN
cblr-1208	278	7	court	court	NOUN
cblr-1208	278	8	’s	’s	PART
cblr-1208	278	9	holding	hold	VERB
cblr-1208	278	10	on	on	ADP
cblr-1208	278	11	summary	summary	NOUN
cblr-1208	278	12	judgment	judgment	NOUN
cblr-1208	278	13	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	278	14	as	as	SCONJ
cblr-1208	278	15	noted	note	VERB
cblr-1208	278	16	above	above	ADV
cblr-1208	278	17	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	278	18	this	this	DET
cblr-1208	278	19	article	article	NOUN
cblr-1208	278	20	represents	represent	VERB
cblr-1208	278	21	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	278	22	views	view	NOUN
cblr-1208	278	23	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	278	24	its	its	PRON
cblr-1208	278	25	authors	author	NOUN
cblr-1208	278	26	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	278	27	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	278	28	should	should	AUX
cblr-1208	278	29	not	not	PART
cblr-1208	278	30	be	be	AUX
cblr-1208	278	31	read	read	VERB
cblr-1208	278	32	as	as	ADP
cblr-1208	278	33	representing	represent	VERB
cblr-1208	278	34	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	278	35	views	view	NOUN
cblr-1208	278	36	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	278	37	any	any	DET
cblr-1208	278	38	other	other	ADJ
cblr-1208	278	39	person	person	NOUN
cblr-1208	278	40	or	or	CCONJ
cblr-1208	278	41	entity	entity	NOUN
cblr-1208	278	42	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	278	43	including	include	VERB
cblr-1208	278	44	arnold	arnold	PROPN
cblr-1208	278	45	&	&	CCONJ
cblr-1208	278	46	porter	porter	PROPN
cblr-1208	278	47	or	or	CCONJ
cblr-1208	278	48	any	any	PRON
cblr-1208	278	49	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	278	50	its	its	PRON
cblr-1208	278	51	clients	client	NOUN
cblr-1208	278	52	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	279	1	66	66	NUM
cblr-1208	279	2	see	see	VERB
cblr-1208	279	3	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	279	4	re	re	NOUN
cblr-1208	279	5	wellbutrin	wellbutrin	NOUN
cblr-1208	279	6	xl	xl	PROPN
cblr-1208	279	7	antitrust	antitrust	ADJ
cblr-1208	279	8	litig	litig	NOUN
cblr-1208	279	9	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	279	10	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	279	11	868	868	NUM
cblr-1208	279	12	f.3d	f.3d	NUM
cblr-1208	279	13	132	132	NUM
cblr-1208	279	14	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	279	15	167	167	NUM
cblr-1208	279	16	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-1208	279	17	3rd	3rd	ADJ
cblr-1208	279	18	cir	cir	NOUN
cblr-1208	279	19	.	.	PROPN
cblr-1208	279	20	2017	2017	NUM
cblr-1208	279	21	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-1208	279	22	;	;	PUNCT
cblr-1208	279	23	see	see	VERB
cblr-1208	279	24	also	also	ADV
cblr-1208	279	25	lidoderm	lidoderm	NOUN
cblr-1208	279	26	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	279	27	2017	2017	NUM
cblr-1208	279	28	wl	wl	NOUN
cblr-1208	279	29	5068533	5068533	NUM
cblr-1208	279	30	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	279	31	at	at	ADP
cblr-1208	279	32	*	*	NUM
cblr-1208	279	33	11	11	NUM
cblr-1208	279	34	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-1208	279	35	endorsing	endorse	VERB
cblr-1208	279	36	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	279	37	alternative	alternative	ADJ
cblr-1208	279	38	settlement	settlement	NOUN
cblr-1208	279	39	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	279	40	theory	theory	NOUN
cblr-1208	279	41	to	to	ADP
cblr-1208	279	42	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	279	43	extent	extent	NOUN
cblr-1208	279	44	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	279	45	it	it	PRON
cblr-1208	279	46	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	279	47	shows	show	NOUN
cblr-1208	279	48	but	but	CCONJ
cblr-1208	279	49	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-1208	279	50	for	for	ADP
cblr-1208	279	51	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	279	52	reverse	reverse	NOUN
cblr-1208	279	53	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-1208	279	54	payment	payment	NOUN
cblr-1208	279	55	agreement	agreement	NOUN
cblr-1208	279	56	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	279	57	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	279	58	parties	party	NOUN
cblr-1208	279	59	would	would	AUX
cblr-1208	279	60	have	have	AUX
cblr-1208	279	61	reached	reach	VERB
cblr-1208	279	62	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	279	63	settlement	settlement	NOUN
cblr-1208	279	64	that	that	PRON
cblr-1208	279	65	was	be	AUX
cblr-1208	279	66	still	still	ADV
cblr-1208	279	67	anticompetitive	anticompetitive	ADJ
cblr-1208	279	68	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	279	69	caused	cause	VERB
cblr-1208	279	70	unjustified	unjustified	ADJ
cblr-1208	279	71	harm	harm	NOUN
cblr-1208	279	72	to	to	ADP
cblr-1208	279	73	consumers	consumer	NOUN
cblr-1208	279	74	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	279	75	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-1208	279	76	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-1208	279	77	emphasis	emphasis	NOUN
cblr-1208	279	78	added	add	VERB
cblr-1208	279	79	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-1208	279	80	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	280	1	67	67	NUM
cblr-1208	280	2	see	see	VERB
cblr-1208	280	3	wellbutrin	wellbutrin	PROPN
cblr-1208	280	4	xl	xl	PROPN
cblr-1208	280	5	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	280	6	868	868	NUM
cblr-1208	280	7	f.3d	f.3d	NUM
cblr-1208	280	8	at	at	ADP
cblr-1208	280	9	167	167	NUM
cblr-1208	280	10	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	281	1	lecture_commentary_final	lecture_commentary_final	PROPN
cblr-1208	281	2	64	64	NUM
cblr-1208	281	3	columbia	columbia	PROPN
cblr-1208	281	4	business	business	NOUN
cblr-1208	281	5	law	law	PROPN
cblr-1208	281	6	review	review	NOUN
cblr-1208	281	7	[	[	X
cblr-1208	281	8	vol	vol	NOUN
cblr-1208	281	9	.	.	NOUN
cblr-1208	281	10	2018	2018	NUM
cblr-1208	281	11	entry	entry	NOUN
cblr-1208	281	12	date	date	NOUN
cblr-1208	281	13	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	282	1	under	under	ADP
cblr-1208	282	2	that	that	DET
cblr-1208	282	3	scenario	scenario	NOUN
cblr-1208	282	4	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	282	5	there	there	PRON
cblr-1208	282	6	would	would	AUX
cblr-1208	282	7	have	have	AUX
cblr-1208	282	8	been	be	AUX
cblr-1208	282	9	no	no	DET
cblr-1208	282	10	anticompetitive	anticompetitive	ADJ
cblr-1208	282	11	effect	effect	NOUN
cblr-1208	282	12	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	283	1	to	to	ADP
cblr-1208	283	2	date	date	NOUN
cblr-1208	283	3	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	283	4	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	283	5	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	283	6	limited	limited	ADJ
cblr-1208	283	7	set	set	NOUN
cblr-1208	283	8	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	283	9	cases	case	NOUN
cblr-1208	283	10	following	follow	VERB
cblr-1208	283	11	actavis	actavis	NUM
cblr-1208	283	12	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	283	13	there	there	PRON
cblr-1208	283	14	is	be	VERB
cblr-1208	283	15	no	no	DET
cblr-1208	283	16	reported	report	VERB
cblr-1208	283	17	example	example	NOUN
cblr-1208	283	18	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	283	19	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	283	20	case	case	NOUN
cblr-1208	283	21	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	283	22	which	which	PRON
cblr-1208	283	23	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	283	24	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
cblr-1208	283	25	has	have	AUX
cblr-1208	283	26	successfully	successfully	ADV
cblr-1208	283	27	proven	prove	VERB
cblr-1208	283	28	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	283	29	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	283	30	defendants	defendant	NOUN
cblr-1208	283	31	would	would	AUX
cblr-1208	283	32	have	have	AUX
cblr-1208	283	33	reached	reach	VERB
cblr-1208	283	34	an	an	DET
cblr-1208	283	35	alternative	alternative	ADJ
cblr-1208	283	36	settlement	settlement	NOUN
cblr-1208	283	37	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	283	38	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	283	39	but	but	CCONJ
cblr-1208	283	40	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-1208	283	41	for	for	ADP
cblr-1208	283	42	world.68	world.68	PROPN
cblr-1208	283	43	b.	b.	PROPN
cblr-1208	283	44	but	but	CCONJ
cblr-1208	283	45	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-1208	283	46	for	for	ADP
cblr-1208	283	47	world	world	NOUN
cblr-1208	283	48	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	283	49	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	283	50	no	no	DET
cblr-1208	283	51	settlement	settlement	NOUN
cblr-1208	283	52	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	283	53	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	283	54	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	283	55	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	283	56	no	no	DET
cblr-1208	283	57	settlement	settlement	NOUN
cblr-1208	283	58	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	283	59	scenario	scenario	NOUN
cblr-1208	283	60	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	283	61	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	283	62	underlying	underlie	VERB
cblr-1208	283	63	litigation	litigation	NOUN
cblr-1208	283	64	continues	continue	VERB
cblr-1208	283	65	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	284	1	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	284	2	this	this	DET
cblr-1208	284	3	scenario	scenario	NOUN
cblr-1208	284	4	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	284	5	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	284	6	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
cblr-1208	284	7	can	can	AUX
cblr-1208	284	8	show	show	VERB
cblr-1208	284	9	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	284	10	earlier	early	ADJ
cblr-1208	284	11	entry	entry	NOUN
cblr-1208	284	12	would	would	AUX
cblr-1208	284	13	have	have	AUX
cblr-1208	284	14	taken	take	VERB
cblr-1208	284	15	place	place	NOUN
cblr-1208	284	16	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	284	17	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	284	18	but	but	CCONJ
cblr-1208	284	19	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-1208	284	20	for	for	ADP
cblr-1208	284	21	world	world	NOUN
cblr-1208	284	22	only	only	ADV
cblr-1208	284	23	by	by	ADP
cblr-1208	284	24	showing	show	VERB
cblr-1208	284	25	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	284	26	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	284	27	alleged	allege	VERB
cblr-1208	284	28	generic	generic	PROPN
cblr-1208	284	29	infringer	infringer	NOUN
cblr-1208	284	30	would	would	AUX
cblr-1208	284	31	have	have	AUX
cblr-1208	284	32	won	win	VERB
cblr-1208	284	33	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	284	34	underlying	underlie	VERB
cblr-1208	284	35	patent	patent	NOUN
cblr-1208	284	36	litigation	litigation	NOUN
cblr-1208	284	37	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-1208	284	38	by	by	ADP
cblr-1208	284	39	invalidating	invalidate	VERB
cblr-1208	284	40	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	284	41	patent	patent	NOUN
cblr-1208	284	42	or	or	CCONJ
cblr-1208	284	43	showing	show	VERB
cblr-1208	284	44	non	non	ADJ
cblr-1208	284	45	-	-	NOUN
cblr-1208	284	46	infringement	infringement	NOUN
cblr-1208	284	47	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-1208	284	48	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	285	1	as	as	SCONJ
cblr-1208	285	2	noted	note	VERB
cblr-1208	285	3	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	285	4	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	285	5	but	but	CCONJ
cblr-1208	285	6	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-1208	285	7	for	for	ADP
cblr-1208	285	8	counterfactual	counterfactual	ADJ
cblr-1208	285	9	essential	essential	ADJ
cblr-1208	285	10	to	to	ADP
cblr-1208	285	11	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	285	12	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	285	13	no	no	DET
cblr-1208	285	14	settlement	settlement	NOUN
cblr-1208	285	15	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	285	16	scenario	scenario	NOUN
cblr-1208	285	17	is	be	AUX
cblr-1208	285	18	patent	patent	NOUN
cblr-1208	285	19	litigation	litigation	NOUN
cblr-1208	285	20	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	285	21	which	which	PRON
cblr-1208	285	22	either	either	CCONJ
cblr-1208	285	23	party	party	NOUN
cblr-1208	285	24	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	285	25	could	could	AUX
cblr-1208	285	26	realistically	realistically	ADV
cblr-1208	285	27	expect	expect	VERB
cblr-1208	285	28	success	success	NOUN
cblr-1208	285	29	on	on	ADP
cblr-1208	285	30	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	285	31	merits	merit	NOUN
cblr-1208	285	32	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	286	1	”69	”69	VERB
cblr-1208	286	2	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	286	3	supreme	supreme	PROPN
cblr-1208	286	4	court	court	PROPN
cblr-1208	286	5	appears	appear	VERB
cblr-1208	286	6	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	286	7	have	have	AUX
cblr-1208	286	8	been	be	AUX
cblr-1208	286	9	unanimous	unanimous	ADJ
cblr-1208	286	10	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	286	11	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	286	12	view	view	NOUN
cblr-1208	286	13	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	286	14	litigating	litigate	VERB
cblr-1208	286	15	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	286	16	settled	settle	VERB
cblr-1208	286	17	patent	patent	NOUN
cblr-1208	286	18	case	case	NOUN
cblr-1208	286	19	is	be	AUX
cblr-1208	286	20	not	not	PART
cblr-1208	286	21	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	286	22	correct	correct	ADJ
cblr-1208	286	23	path,70	path,70	NOUN
cblr-1208	286	24	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	286	25	for	for	ADP
cblr-1208	286	26	good	good	ADJ
cblr-1208	286	27	reason	reason	NOUN
cblr-1208	286	28	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	287	1	it	it	PRON
cblr-1208	287	2	is	be	AUX
cblr-1208	287	3	important	important	ADJ
cblr-1208	287	4	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	287	5	note	note	VERB
cblr-1208	287	6	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	287	7	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	287	8	question	question	NOUN
cblr-1208	287	9	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	287	10	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	287	11	subsequent	subsequent	ADJ
cblr-1208	287	12	antitrust	antitrust	ADJ
cblr-1208	287	13	case	case	NOUN
cblr-1208	287	14	is	be	AUX
cblr-1208	287	15	not	not	PART
cblr-1208	287	16	—	—	PUNCT
cblr-1208	287	17	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	287	18	should	should	AUX
cblr-1208	287	19	not	not	PART
cblr-1208	287	20	be	be	AUX
cblr-1208	287	21	—	—	PUNCT
cblr-1208	287	22	whether	whether	SCONJ
cblr-1208	287	23	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	287	24	patent	patent	NOUN
cblr-1208	287	25	is	be	AUX
cblr-1208	287	26	valid	valid	ADJ
cblr-1208	287	27	or	or	CCONJ
cblr-1208	287	28	infringed	infringe	VERB
cblr-1208	287	29	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	288	1	rather	rather	ADV
cblr-1208	288	2	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	288	3	it	it	PRON
cblr-1208	288	4	is	be	AUX
cblr-1208	288	5	whether	whether	SCONJ
cblr-1208	288	6	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	288	7	federal	federal	ADJ
cblr-1208	288	8	judge	judge	NOUN
cblr-1208	288	9	presiding	preside	VERB
cblr-1208	288	10	over	over	ADP
cblr-1208	288	11	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	288	12	settled	settle	VERB
cblr-1208	288	13	patent	patent	NOUN
cblr-1208	288	14	case	case	NOUN
cblr-1208	288	15	would	would	AUX
cblr-1208	288	16	have	have	VERB
cblr-1208	288	17	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	288	18	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	288	19	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	288	20	absence	absence	NOUN
cblr-1208	288	21	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	288	22	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	288	23	68	68	NUM
cblr-1208	288	24	in	in	ADV
cblr-1208	288	25	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	288	26	re	re	PROPN
cblr-1208	288	27	nexium	nexium	NOUN
cblr-1208	288	28	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-1208	288	29	esomeprazole	esomeprazole	PROPN
cblr-1208	288	30	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-1208	288	31	antitrust	antitrust	ADJ
cblr-1208	288	32	litigation	litigation	NOUN
cblr-1208	288	33	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	288	34	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	288	35	first	first	ADJ
cblr-1208	288	36	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-1208	288	37	held	hold	VERB
cblr-1208	288	38	explained	explain	VERB
cblr-1208	288	39	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	288	40	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	288	41	trial	trial	NOUN
cblr-1208	288	42	court	court	NOUN
cblr-1208	288	43	verdict	verdict	NOUN
cblr-1208	288	44	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	288	45	reflected	reflect	VERB
cblr-1208	288	46	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	288	47	jury	jury	NOUN
cblr-1208	288	48	’s	’s	PART
cblr-1208	288	49	finding	find	VERB
cblr-1208	288	50	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	288	51	[	[	X
cblr-1208	288	52	brand	brand	NOUN
cblr-1208	288	53	manufacturer	manufacturer	NOUN
cblr-1208	288	54	]	]	X
cblr-1208	289	1	astrazeneca	astrazeneca	NOUN
cblr-1208	289	2	would	would	AUX
cblr-1208	289	3	not	not	PART
cblr-1208	289	4	have	have	AUX
cblr-1208	289	5	agreed	agree	VERB
cblr-1208	289	6	to	to	ADP
cblr-1208	289	7	settlement	settlement	NOUN
cblr-1208	289	8	terms	term	NOUN
cblr-1208	289	9	with	with	ADP
cblr-1208	289	10	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	289	11	license	license	NOUN
cblr-1208	289	12	date	date	NOUN
cblr-1208	289	13	earlier	early	ADV
cblr-1208	289	14	than	than	ADP
cblr-1208	289	15	may	may	PROPN
cblr-1208	289	16	27	27	NUM
cblr-1208	289	17	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	289	18	2014	2014	NUM
cblr-1208	289	19	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	289	20	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	289	21	date	date	NOUN
cblr-1208	289	22	on	on	ADP
cblr-1208	289	23	which	which	PRON
cblr-1208	289	24	two	two	NUM
cblr-1208	289	25	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	289	26	its	its	PRON
cblr-1208	289	27	medical	medical	ADJ
cblr-1208	289	28	patents	patent	NOUN
cblr-1208	289	29	expired	expire	VERB
cblr-1208	289	30	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	289	31	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	290	1	842	842	NUM
cblr-1208	290	2	f.3d	f.3d	NUM
cblr-1208	290	3	34	34	NUM
cblr-1208	290	4	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	290	5	64	64	NUM
cblr-1208	290	6	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-1208	290	7	1st	1st	ADJ
cblr-1208	290	8	cir	cir	NOUN
cblr-1208	290	9	.	.	PROPN
cblr-1208	290	10	2016	2016	NUM
cblr-1208	290	11	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-1208	290	12	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	291	1	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	291	2	lidoderm	lidoderm	NOUN
cblr-1208	291	3	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	291	4	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	291	5	court	court	NOUN
cblr-1208	291	6	held	hold	VERB
cblr-1208	291	7	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	291	8	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
cblr-1208	291	9	’	'	PUNCT
cblr-1208	291	10	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	291	11	alternative	alternative	ADJ
cblr-1208	291	12	settlement	settlement	NOUN
cblr-1208	291	13	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	291	14	theory	theory	NOUN
cblr-1208	291	15	was	be	AUX
cblr-1208	291	16	legally	legally	ADV
cblr-1208	291	17	cognizable	cognizable	ADJ
cblr-1208	291	18	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	291	19	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	291	20	there	there	PRON
cblr-1208	291	21	was	be	VERB
cblr-1208	291	22	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
cblr-1208	291	23	evidence	evidence	NOUN
cblr-1208	291	24	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	291	25	deny	deny	VERB
cblr-1208	291	26	summary	summary	NOUN
cblr-1208	291	27	judgment	judgment	NOUN
cblr-1208	291	28	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	292	1	lidoderm	lidoderm	NOUN
cblr-1208	292	2	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	292	3	2017	2017	NUM
cblr-1208	292	4	wl	wl	NOUN
cblr-1208	292	5	5068533	5068533	NUM
cblr-1208	292	6	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	292	7	at	at	ADP
cblr-1208	292	8	*	*	PROPN
cblr-1208	292	9	10	10	NUM
cblr-1208	292	10	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	292	11	*	*	NOUN
cblr-1208	292	12	13	13	NUM
cblr-1208	292	13	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	293	1	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	293	2	lidoderm	lidoderm	NOUN
cblr-1208	293	3	case	case	NOUN
cblr-1208	293	4	settled	settle	VERB
cblr-1208	293	5	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	293	6	february	february	PROPN
cblr-1208	293	7	2018	2018	NUM
cblr-1208	293	8	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	293	9	shortly	shortly	ADV
cblr-1208	293	10	before	before	ADP
cblr-1208	293	11	trial	trial	NOUN
cblr-1208	293	12	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	294	1	69	69	NUM
cblr-1208	294	2	prof’l	prof’l	NOUN
cblr-1208	294	3	real	real	ADJ
cblr-1208	294	4	estate	estate	NOUN
cblr-1208	294	5	inv’rs	inv’rs	NOUN
cblr-1208	294	6	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	294	7	inc	inc	PROPN
cblr-1208	294	8	.	.	PROPN
cblr-1208	294	9	v.	v.	PROPN
cblr-1208	294	10	columbia	columbia	PROPN
cblr-1208	294	11	pictures	picture	NOUN
cblr-1208	294	12	indus	indus	PROPN
cblr-1208	294	13	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	294	14	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	294	15	508	508	NUM
cblr-1208	294	16	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-1208	294	17	.	.	PROPN
cblr-1208	294	18	49	49	NUM
cblr-1208	294	19	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	294	20	60	60	NUM
cblr-1208	294	21	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-1208	294	22	1993	1993	NUM
cblr-1208	294	23	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-1208	294	24	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	295	1	70	70	NUM
cblr-1208	295	2	actavis	actavi	NOUN
cblr-1208	295	3	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	295	4	133	133	NUM
cblr-1208	295	5	s.	s.	PROPN
cblr-1208	295	6	ct	ct	PROPN
cblr-1208	295	7	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	296	1	at	at	ADP
cblr-1208	296	2	2236–37	2236–37	NUM
cblr-1208	296	3	;	;	PUNCT
cblr-1208	296	4	i	i	PROPN
cblr-1208	296	5	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-1208	296	6	at	at	ADP
cblr-1208	296	7	2244	2244	NUM
cblr-1208	296	8	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-1208	296	9	roberts	roberts	PROPN
cblr-1208	296	10	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	296	11	c.j	c.j	PROPN
cblr-1208	296	12	.	.	PROPN
cblr-1208	296	13	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	296	14	dissenting	dissent	VERB
cblr-1208	296	15	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-1208	296	16	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	297	1	lecture_commentary_final	lecture_commentary_final	ADJ
cblr-1208	298	1	no	no	INTJ
cblr-1208	298	2	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	299	1	1:45	1:45	NUM
cblr-1208	299	2	]	]	PUNCT
cblr-1208	299	3	commentary	commentary	NOUN
cblr-1208	299	4	:	:	PUNCT
cblr-1208	299	5	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	299	6	rule	rule	NOUN
cblr-1208	299	7	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	299	8	reason	reason	NOUN
cblr-1208	299	9	65	65	NUM
cblr-1208	299	10	settlement	settlement	NOUN
cblr-1208	299	11	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	299	12	ultimately	ultimately	ADV
cblr-1208	299	13	found	find	VERB
cblr-1208	299	14	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	299	15	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	299	16	patent	patent	NOUN
cblr-1208	299	17	was	be	AUX
cblr-1208	299	18	invalid	invalid	ADJ
cblr-1208	299	19	or	or	CCONJ
cblr-1208	299	20	not	not	PART
cblr-1208	299	21	infringed.71	infringed.71	VERB
cblr-1208	299	22	attempting	attempt	VERB
cblr-1208	299	23	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	299	24	use	use	VERB
cblr-1208	299	25	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	299	26	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	299	27	large	large	ADJ
cblr-1208	299	28	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	299	29	payment	payment	NOUN
cblr-1208	299	30	as	as	ADP
cblr-1208	299	31	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	299	32	surrogate	surrogate	NOUN
cblr-1208	299	33	for	for	SCONJ
cblr-1208	299	34	who	who	PRON
cblr-1208	299	35	would	would	AUX
cblr-1208	299	36	have	have	AUX
cblr-1208	299	37	prevailed	prevail	VERB
cblr-1208	299	38	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	299	39	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	299	40	underlying	underlie	VERB
cblr-1208	299	41	litigation	litigation	NOUN
cblr-1208	299	42	is	be	AUX
cblr-1208	299	43	especially	especially	ADV
cblr-1208	299	44	problematic	problematic	ADJ
cblr-1208	299	45	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	300	1	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	300	2	payment	payment	NOUN
cblr-1208	300	3	does	do	AUX
cblr-1208	300	4	not	not	PART
cblr-1208	300	5	show	show	VERB
cblr-1208	300	6	who	who	PRON
cblr-1208	300	7	would	would	AUX
cblr-1208	300	8	have	have	AUX
cblr-1208	300	9	won	win	VERB
cblr-1208	300	10	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	300	11	litigation	litigation	NOUN
cblr-1208	300	12	;	;	PUNCT
cblr-1208	300	13	at	at	ADP
cblr-1208	300	14	most	most	ADJ
cblr-1208	300	15	it	it	PRON
cblr-1208	300	16	can	can	AUX
cblr-1208	300	17	be	be	AUX
cblr-1208	300	18	read	read	VERB
cblr-1208	300	19	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	300	20	suggest	suggest	VERB
cblr-1208	300	21	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	300	22	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	300	23	patentee	patentee	NOUN
cblr-1208	300	24	had	have	VERB
cblr-1208	300	25	less	less	ADJ
cblr-1208	300	26	confidence	confidence	NOUN
cblr-1208	300	27	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	300	28	what	what	PRON
cblr-1208	300	29	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	300	30	judge	judge	NOUN
cblr-1208	300	31	might	might	AUX
cblr-1208	300	32	do	do	AUX
cblr-1208	300	33	than	than	SCONJ
cblr-1208	300	34	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	300	35	absence	absence	NOUN
cblr-1208	300	36	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	300	37	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	300	38	payment	payment	NOUN
cblr-1208	300	39	would	would	AUX
cblr-1208	300	40	suggest	suggest	VERB
cblr-1208	300	41	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	300	42	if	if	SCONJ
cblr-1208	300	43	one	one	PRON
cblr-1208	300	44	ignores	ignore	VERB
cblr-1208	300	45	entirely	entirely	ADV
cblr-1208	300	46	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	300	47	risk	risk	NOUN
cblr-1208	300	48	aversion	aversion	NOUN
cblr-1208	300	49	issue	issue	NOUN
cblr-1208	300	50	described	describe	VERB
cblr-1208	300	51	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	300	52	wellbutrin	wellbutrin	PROPN
cblr-1208	300	53	xl	xl	PROPN
cblr-1208	300	54	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	300	55	above.72	above.72	PROPN
cblr-1208	300	56	but	but	CCONJ
cblr-1208	300	57	what	what	PRON
cblr-1208	300	58	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	300	59	patentee	patentee	NOUN
cblr-1208	300	60	fears	fear	NOUN
cblr-1208	300	61	is	be	AUX
cblr-1208	300	62	not	not	PART
cblr-1208	300	63	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	300	64	issue	issue	NOUN
cblr-1208	300	65	;	;	PUNCT
cblr-1208	300	66	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	300	67	issue	issue	NOUN
cblr-1208	300	68	is	be	AUX
cblr-1208	300	69	what	what	PRON
cblr-1208	300	70	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	300	71	judge	judge	NOUN
cblr-1208	300	72	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	300	73	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	300	74	underlying	underlie	VERB
cblr-1208	300	75	patent	patent	NOUN
cblr-1208	300	76	litigation	litigation	NOUN
cblr-1208	300	77	would	would	AUX
cblr-1208	300	78	have	have	AUX
cblr-1208	300	79	found	find	VERB
cblr-1208	300	80	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	301	1	we	we	PRON
cblr-1208	301	2	are	be	AUX
cblr-1208	301	3	aware	aware	ADJ
cblr-1208	301	4	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	301	5	no	no	DET
cblr-1208	301	6	legal	legal	ADJ
cblr-1208	301	7	foundation	foundation	NOUN
cblr-1208	301	8	for	for	ADP
cblr-1208	301	9	substituting	substitute	VERB
cblr-1208	301	10	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	301	11	party	party	NOUN
cblr-1208	301	12	’s	’s	PART
cblr-1208	301	13	risk	risk	NOUN
cblr-1208	301	14	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-1208	301	15	assessment	assessment	NOUN
cblr-1208	301	16	for	for	ADP
cblr-1208	301	17	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	301	18	judicial	judicial	ADJ
cblr-1208	301	19	outcome	outcome	NOUN
cblr-1208	301	20	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	302	1	moreover	moreover	ADV
cblr-1208	302	2	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	302	3	no	no	PRON
cblr-1208	302	4	later	later	ADV
cblr-1208	302	5	antitrust	antitrust	ADJ
cblr-1208	302	6	jury	jury	NOUN
cblr-1208	302	7	should	should	AUX
cblr-1208	302	8	be	be	AUX
cblr-1208	302	9	permitted	permit	VERB
cblr-1208	302	10	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	302	11	try	try	VERB
cblr-1208	302	12	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	302	13	intuit	intuit	VERB
cblr-1208	302	14	what	what	PRON
cblr-1208	302	15	that	that	DET
cblr-1208	302	16	federal	federal	ADJ
cblr-1208	302	17	judge	judge	NOUN
cblr-1208	302	18	would	would	AUX
cblr-1208	302	19	have	have	AUX
cblr-1208	302	20	done	do	VERB
cblr-1208	302	21	for	for	ADP
cblr-1208	302	22	two	two	NUM
cblr-1208	302	23	reasons	reason	NOUN
cblr-1208	302	24	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	303	1	first	first	ADV
cblr-1208	303	2	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	303	3	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	303	4	exercise	exercise	NOUN
cblr-1208	303	5	is	be	AUX
cblr-1208	303	6	inherently	inherently	ADV
cblr-1208	303	7	speculative	speculative	ADJ
cblr-1208	303	8	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	303	9	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	303	10	it	it	PRON
cblr-1208	303	11	inappropriately	inappropriately	ADV
cblr-1208	303	12	relies	rely	VERB
cblr-1208	303	13	on	on	ADP
cblr-1208	303	14	predictions	prediction	NOUN
cblr-1208	303	15	about	about	ADP
cblr-1208	303	16	potential	potential	ADJ
cblr-1208	303	17	judicial	judicial	ADJ
cblr-1208	303	18	outcomes.73	outcomes.73	NOUN
cblr-1208	303	19	second	second	ADV
cblr-1208	303	20	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	303	21	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	303	22	antitrust	antitrust	ADJ
cblr-1208	303	23	jury	jury	NOUN
cblr-1208	303	24	will	will	AUX
cblr-1208	303	25	have	have	VERB
cblr-1208	303	26	information	information	NOUN
cblr-1208	303	27	that	that	PRON
cblr-1208	303	28	would	would	AUX
cblr-1208	303	29	have	have	AUX
cblr-1208	303	30	been	be	AUX
cblr-1208	303	31	unavailable	unavailable	ADJ
cblr-1208	303	32	to	to	ADP
cblr-1208	303	33	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	303	34	judge	judge	NOUN
cblr-1208	303	35	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	303	36	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	303	37	underlying	underlie	VERB
cblr-1208	303	38	patent	patent	NOUN
cblr-1208	303	39	litigation	litigation	NOUN
cblr-1208	303	40	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	303	41	for	for	ADP
cblr-1208	303	42	good	good	ADJ
cblr-1208	303	43	reason	reason	NOUN
cblr-1208	303	44	—	—	PUNCT
cblr-1208	303	45	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	303	46	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	303	47	patent	patent	NOUN
cblr-1208	303	48	litigation	litigation	NOUN
cblr-1208	303	49	settled	settle	VERB
cblr-1208	303	50	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	303	51	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	303	52	on	on	ADP
cblr-1208	303	53	what	what	DET
cblr-1208	303	54	terms	term	NOUN
cblr-1208	303	55	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	304	1	because	because	SCONJ
cblr-1208	304	2	such	such	ADJ
cblr-1208	304	3	71	71	NUM
cblr-1208	304	4	hatch	hatch	NOUN
cblr-1208	304	5	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-1208	304	6	waxman	waxman	NOUN
cblr-1208	304	7	cases	case	NOUN
cblr-1208	304	8	involve	involve	VERB
cblr-1208	304	9	no	no	DET
cblr-1208	304	10	claims	claim	NOUN
cblr-1208	304	11	for	for	ADP
cblr-1208	304	12	damages	damage	NOUN
cblr-1208	304	13	because	because	SCONJ
cblr-1208	304	14	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	304	15	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	304	16	act	act	NOUN
cblr-1208	304	17	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	304	18	infringement	infringement	NOUN
cblr-1208	304	19	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	304	20	is	be	AUX
cblr-1208	304	21	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	304	22	statutory	statutory	ADJ
cblr-1208	304	23	fiction	fiction	NOUN
cblr-1208	304	24	—	—	PUNCT
cblr-1208	304	25	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	304	26	filing	filing	NOUN
cblr-1208	304	27	or	or	CCONJ
cblr-1208	304	28	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	304	29	paragraph	paragraph	NOUN
cblr-1208	304	30	iv	iv	NUM
cblr-1208	304	31	certification	certification	NOUN
cblr-1208	304	32	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	305	1	see	see	VERB
cblr-1208	305	2	actavis	actavis	PROPN
cblr-1208	305	3	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	305	4	133	133	NUM
cblr-1208	305	5	s.	s.	PROPN
cblr-1208	305	6	ct	ct	PROPN
cblr-1208	305	7	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	306	1	at	at	ADP
cblr-1208	306	2	2228	2228	NUM
cblr-1208	306	3	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-1208	306	4	citing	cite	VERB
cblr-1208	306	5	35	35	NUM
cblr-1208	306	6	u.s.c	u.s.c	ADJ
cblr-1208	306	7	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	307	1	§	§	PROPN
cblr-1208	307	2	271(e)(2)(a	271(e)(2)(a	PROPN
cblr-1208	307	3	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-1208	307	4	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-1208	307	5	;	;	PUNCT
cblr-1208	307	6	senju	senju	PROPN
cblr-1208	307	7	pharm	pharm	PROPN
cblr-1208	307	8	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	308	1	co.	co.	PROPN
cblr-1208	309	1	v.	v.	ADP
cblr-1208	309	2	apotex	apotex	PROPN
cblr-1208	309	3	inc	inc	PROPN
cblr-1208	309	4	.	.	PROPN
cblr-1208	309	5	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	309	6	746	746	NUM
cblr-1208	309	7	f.3d	f.3d	NUM
cblr-1208	309	8	1344	1344	NUM
cblr-1208	309	9	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	309	10	1350	1350	NUM
cblr-1208	309	11	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-1208	309	12	fed	fed	PROPN
cblr-1208	309	13	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	309	14	cir	cir	PROPN
cblr-1208	309	15	.	.	PROPN
cblr-1208	309	16	2014	2014	NUM
cblr-1208	309	17	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-1208	309	18	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	310	1	they	they	PRON
cblr-1208	310	2	are	be	AUX
cblr-1208	310	3	therefore	therefore	ADV
cblr-1208	310	4	ordinarily	ordinarily	ADV
cblr-1208	310	5	tried	try	VERB
cblr-1208	310	6	to	to	ADP
cblr-1208	310	7	judges	judge	NOUN
cblr-1208	310	8	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	311	1	see	see	VERB
cblr-1208	311	2	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	311	3	e.g.	e.g.	ADV
cblr-1208	311	4	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	311	5	novartis	novartis	PROPN
cblr-1208	311	6	pharm	pharm	PROPN
cblr-1208	311	7	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	312	1	corp	corp	PROPN
cblr-1208	312	2	.	.	PROPN
cblr-1208	313	1	v.	v.	PROPN
cblr-1208	313	2	roxane	roxane	PROPN
cblr-1208	313	3	labs	labs	PROPN
cblr-1208	313	4	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	313	5	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	313	6	inc	inc	PROPN
cblr-1208	313	7	.	.	PROPN
cblr-1208	313	8	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	313	9	no	no	INTJ
cblr-1208	313	10	.	.	NOUN
cblr-1208	313	11	08	08	NUM
cblr-1208	313	12	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-1208	313	13	cv-3853	cv-3853	PROPN
cblr-1208	313	14	dmc	dmc	NOUN
cblr-1208	313	15	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	313	16	2009	2009	NUM
cblr-1208	313	17	wl	wl	NOUN
cblr-1208	313	18	1140440	1140440	NUM
cblr-1208	313	19	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	313	20	at	at	ADP
cblr-1208	313	21	*	*	NOUN
cblr-1208	313	22	1	1	NUM
cblr-1208	313	23	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-1208	313	24	d.n.j	d.n.j	PROPN
cblr-1208	313	25	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	313	26	apr	apr	PROPN
cblr-1208	313	27	.	.	PROPN
cblr-1208	313	28	28	28	NUM
cblr-1208	313	29	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	313	30	2009	2009	NUM
cblr-1208	313	31	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-1208	313	32	;	;	PUNCT
cblr-1208	313	33	biovail	biovail	NOUN
cblr-1208	313	34	labs	labs	PROPN
cblr-1208	313	35	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	313	36	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	313	37	inc	inc	PROPN
cblr-1208	313	38	.	.	PROPN
cblr-1208	314	1	v.	v.	PROPN
cblr-1208	314	2	torpharm	torpharm	PROPN
cblr-1208	314	3	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	314	4	inc	inc	PROPN
cblr-1208	314	5	.	.	PROPN
cblr-1208	314	6	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	315	1	no	no	INTJ
cblr-1208	315	2	.	.	NOUN
cblr-1208	315	3	01	01	NUM
cblr-1208	316	1	c	c	NOUN
cblr-1208	316	2	9008	9008	NUM
cblr-1208	316	3	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	316	4	2002	2002	NUM
cblr-1208	316	5	wl	wl	NOUN
cblr-1208	316	6	1732372	1732372	NUM
cblr-1208	316	7	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	316	8	at	at	ADP
cblr-1208	316	9	*	*	NOUN
cblr-1208	316	10	2	2	NUM
cblr-1208	316	11	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-1208	316	12	n.d	n.d	PROPN
cblr-1208	316	13	.	.	PROPN
cblr-1208	316	14	ill	ill	PROPN
cblr-1208	316	15	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	316	16	july	july	PROPN
cblr-1208	316	17	25	25	NUM
cblr-1208	316	18	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	316	19	2002	2002	NUM
cblr-1208	316	20	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-1208	316	21	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	317	1	as	as	ADP
cblr-1208	317	2	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	317	3	result	result	NOUN
cblr-1208	317	4	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	317	5	any	any	DET
cblr-1208	317	6	approach	approach	NOUN
cblr-1208	317	7	that	that	PRON
cblr-1208	317	8	involves	involve	VERB
cblr-1208	317	9	an	an	DET
cblr-1208	317	10	antitrust	antitrust	ADJ
cblr-1208	317	11	jury	jury	NOUN
cblr-1208	317	12	later	later	ADV
cblr-1208	317	13	making	make	VERB
cblr-1208	317	14	its	its	PRON
cblr-1208	317	15	own	own	ADJ
cblr-1208	317	16	determinations	determination	NOUN
cblr-1208	317	17	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	317	18	validity	validity	NOUN
cblr-1208	317	19	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	317	20	infringement	infringement	NOUN
cblr-1208	317	21	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	317	22	rather	rather	ADV
cblr-1208	317	23	than	than	ADP
cblr-1208	317	24	confining	confine	VERB
cblr-1208	317	25	itself	itself	PRON
cblr-1208	317	26	to	to	ADP
cblr-1208	317	27	deciding	decide	VERB
cblr-1208	317	28	what	what	PRON
cblr-1208	317	29	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	317	30	patent	patent	NOUN
cblr-1208	317	31	litigation	litigation	NOUN
cblr-1208	317	32	judge	judge	NOUN
cblr-1208	317	33	would	would	AUX
cblr-1208	317	34	have	have	AUX
cblr-1208	317	35	done	do	VERB
cblr-1208	317	36	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	317	37	risks	risk	NOUN
cblr-1208	317	38	migrating	migrating	NOUN
cblr-1208	317	39	infringement	infringement	NOUN
cblr-1208	317	40	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	317	41	validity	validity	NOUN
cblr-1208	317	42	determinations	determination	NOUN
cblr-1208	317	43	originally	originally	ADV
cblr-1208	317	44	committed	commit	VERB
cblr-1208	317	45	to	to	ADP
cblr-1208	317	46	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	317	47	judge	judge	NOUN
cblr-1208	317	48	to	to	ADP
cblr-1208	317	49	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	317	50	later	later	ADJ
cblr-1208	317	51	antitrust	antitrust	ADJ
cblr-1208	317	52	jury	jury	NOUN
cblr-1208	317	53	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	318	1	patent	patent	NOUN
cblr-1208	318	2	owners	owner	NOUN
cblr-1208	318	3	settling	settle	VERB
cblr-1208	318	4	paragraph	paragraph	NOUN
cblr-1208	318	5	iv	iv	NUM
cblr-1208	318	6	cases	case	NOUN
cblr-1208	318	7	would	would	AUX
cblr-1208	318	8	thus	thus	ADV
cblr-1208	318	9	have	have	VERB
cblr-1208	318	10	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	318	11	consider	consider	VERB
cblr-1208	318	12	whether	whether	SCONJ
cblr-1208	318	13	they	they	PRON
cblr-1208	318	14	want	want	VERB
cblr-1208	318	15	their	their	PRON
cblr-1208	318	16	patents	patent	NOUN
cblr-1208	318	17	tested	test	VERB
cblr-1208	318	18	by	by	ADP
cblr-1208	318	19	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	318	20	judge	judge	NOUN
cblr-1208	318	21	or	or	CCONJ
cblr-1208	318	22	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	318	23	jury	jury	NOUN
cblr-1208	318	24	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	318	25	deciding	decide	VERB
cblr-1208	318	26	whether	whether	SCONJ
cblr-1208	318	27	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	318	28	settle	settle	VERB
cblr-1208	318	29	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	318	30	paragraph	paragraph	NOUN
cblr-1208	318	31	iv	iv	NUM
cblr-1208	318	32	case	case	NOUN
cblr-1208	318	33	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	318	34	putting	put	VERB
cblr-1208	318	35	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	318	36	new	new	ADJ
cblr-1208	318	37	risk	risk	NOUN
cblr-1208	318	38	factor	factor	NOUN
cblr-1208	318	39	into	into	ADP
cblr-1208	318	40	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	318	41	settlement	settlement	NOUN
cblr-1208	318	42	calculus	calculus	NOUN
cblr-1208	318	43	with	with	ADP
cblr-1208	318	44	unknown	unknown	ADJ
cblr-1208	318	45	consequences	consequence	NOUN
cblr-1208	318	46	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	319	1	72	72	NUM
cblr-1208	319	2	see	see	VERB
cblr-1208	319	3	supra	supra	PROPN
cblr-1208	319	4	notes	note	VERB
cblr-1208	319	5	53–58	53–58	PROPN
cblr-1208	319	6	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	319	7	accompanying	accompany	VERB
cblr-1208	319	8	text	text	NOUN
cblr-1208	319	9	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	320	1	73	73	NUM
cblr-1208	320	2	see	see	VERB
cblr-1208	320	3	joshua	joshua	PROPN
cblr-1208	320	4	b.	b.	PROPN
cblr-1208	320	5	fishman	fishman	PROPN
cblr-1208	320	6	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	320	7	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	320	8	circular	circular	ADJ
cblr-1208	320	9	logic	logic	NOUN
cblr-1208	320	10	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	320	11	actavis	actavi	NOUN
cblr-1208	320	12	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	320	13	66	66	NUM
cblr-1208	320	14	am	am	NOUN
cblr-1208	320	15	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	321	1	u.	u.	PROPN
cblr-1208	321	2	l.	l.	PROPN
cblr-1208	321	3	rev	rev	PROPN
cblr-1208	321	4	.	.	PROPN
cblr-1208	321	5	91	91	NUM
cblr-1208	321	6	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	321	7	96	96	NUM
cblr-1208	321	8	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-1208	321	9	2016	2016	NUM
cblr-1208	321	10	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-1208	321	11	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	322	1	lecture_commentary_final	lecture_commentary_final	PROPN
cblr-1208	322	2	66	66	NUM
cblr-1208	322	3	columbia	columbia	PROPN
cblr-1208	322	4	business	business	NOUN
cblr-1208	322	5	law	law	PROPN
cblr-1208	322	6	review	review	NOUN
cblr-1208	322	7	[	[	X
cblr-1208	322	8	vol	vol	NOUN
cblr-1208	322	9	.	.	NOUN
cblr-1208	322	10	2018	2018	NUM
cblr-1208	322	11	information	information	NOUN
cblr-1208	322	12	is	be	AUX
cblr-1208	322	13	recognized	recognize	VERB
cblr-1208	322	14	as	as	ADP
cblr-1208	322	15	prejudicial	prejudicial	ADJ
cblr-1208	322	16	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	322	17	had	have	VERB
cblr-1208	322	18	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	322	19	settlement	settlement	NOUN
cblr-1208	322	20	negotiations	negotiation	NOUN
cblr-1208	322	21	failed	fail	VERB
cblr-1208	322	22	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	322	23	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	322	24	litigation	litigation	NOUN
cblr-1208	322	25	proceeded	proceed	VERB
cblr-1208	322	26	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	322	27	such	such	ADJ
cblr-1208	322	28	evidence	evidence	NOUN
cblr-1208	322	29	would	would	AUX
cblr-1208	322	30	ordinarily	ordinarily	ADV
cblr-1208	322	31	be	be	AUX
cblr-1208	322	32	precluded	preclude	VERB
cblr-1208	322	33	from	from	ADP
cblr-1208	322	34	trial	trial	NOUN
cblr-1208	322	35	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	322	36	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	322	37	patent	patent	NOUN
cblr-1208	322	38	litigation	litigation	NOUN
cblr-1208	322	39	under	under	ADP
cblr-1208	322	40	federal	federal	ADJ
cblr-1208	322	41	rule	rule	NOUN
cblr-1208	322	42	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	322	43	evidence	evidence	NOUN
cblr-1208	322	44	408	408	NUM
cblr-1208	322	45	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	323	1	consequently	consequently	ADV
cblr-1208	323	2	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	323	3	there	there	PRON
cblr-1208	323	4	is	be	VERB
cblr-1208	323	5	no	no	DET
cblr-1208	323	6	way	way	NOUN
cblr-1208	323	7	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	323	8	reconstruct	reconstruct	VERB
cblr-1208	323	9	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	323	10	but	but	CCONJ
cblr-1208	323	11	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-1208	323	12	for	for	ADP
cblr-1208	323	13	world	world	NOUN
cblr-1208	323	14	as	as	SCONJ
cblr-1208	323	15	it	it	PRON
cblr-1208	323	16	would	would	AUX
cblr-1208	323	17	have	have	AUX
cblr-1208	323	18	existed	exist	VERB
cblr-1208	323	19	—	—	PUNCT
cblr-1208	323	20	i.e.	i.e.	X
cblr-1208	323	21	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	323	22	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	323	23	mind	mind	NOUN
cblr-1208	323	24	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	323	25	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	323	26	federal	federal	ADJ
cblr-1208	323	27	judge	judge	NOUN
cblr-1208	323	28	deciding	decide	VERB
cblr-1208	323	29	validity	validity	NOUN
cblr-1208	323	30	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	323	31	infringement	infringement	NOUN
cblr-1208	323	32	based	base	VERB
cblr-1208	323	33	on	on	ADP
cblr-1208	323	34	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	323	35	evidentiary	evidentiary	ADJ
cblr-1208	323	36	record	record	NOUN
cblr-1208	323	37	available	available	ADJ
cblr-1208	323	38	at	at	ADP
cblr-1208	323	39	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	323	40	time	time	NOUN
cblr-1208	323	41	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	323	42	paragraph	paragraph	NOUN
cblr-1208	323	43	iv	iv	NUM
cblr-1208	323	44	litigation	litigation	NOUN
cblr-1208	323	45	would	would	AUX
cblr-1208	323	46	have	have	AUX
cblr-1208	323	47	been	be	AUX
cblr-1208	323	48	tried	try	VERB
cblr-1208	323	49	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	324	1	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	324	2	proffered	proffered	ADJ
cblr-1208	324	3	alternatives	alternative	NOUN
cblr-1208	324	4	to	to	ADP
cblr-1208	324	5	litigating	litigate	VERB
cblr-1208	324	6	what	what	PRON
cblr-1208	324	7	would	would	AUX
cblr-1208	324	8	have	have	AUX
cblr-1208	324	9	happened	happen	VERB
cblr-1208	324	10	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	324	11	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	324	12	underlying	underlie	VERB
cblr-1208	324	13	patent	patent	NOUN
cblr-1208	324	14	case	case	NOUN
cblr-1208	324	15	are	be	AUX
cblr-1208	324	16	thus	thus	ADV
cblr-1208	324	17	entirely	entirely	ADV
cblr-1208	324	18	unsatisfying	unsatisfying	ADJ
cblr-1208	324	19	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	325	1	as	as	ADP
cblr-1208	325	2	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	325	3	result	result	NOUN
cblr-1208	325	4	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	325	5	if	if	SCONJ
cblr-1208	325	6	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	325	7	evidence	evidence	NOUN
cblr-1208	325	8	at	at	ADP
cblr-1208	325	9	trial	trial	NOUN
cblr-1208	325	10	shows	show	VERB
cblr-1208	325	11	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	325	12	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	325	13	absent	absent	ADJ
cblr-1208	325	14	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	325	15	challenged	challenge	VERB
cblr-1208	325	16	payment	payment	NOUN
cblr-1208	325	17	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	325	18	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	325	19	settlement	settlement	NOUN
cblr-1208	325	20	would	would	AUX
cblr-1208	325	21	not	not	PART
cblr-1208	325	22	have	have	AUX
cblr-1208	325	23	happened	happen	VERB
cblr-1208	325	24	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	325	25	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	325	26	court	court	NOUN
cblr-1208	325	27	should	should	AUX
cblr-1208	325	28	grant	grant	VERB
cblr-1208	325	29	summary	summary	NOUN
cblr-1208	325	30	judgment	judgment	NOUN
cblr-1208	325	31	for	for	ADP
cblr-1208	325	32	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	325	33	defendant(s	defendant(s	PROPN
cblr-1208	325	34	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-1208	325	35	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	326	1	fortunately	fortunately	ADV
cblr-1208	326	2	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	326	3	courts	court	NOUN
cblr-1208	326	4	have	have	VERB
cblr-1208	326	5	to	to	ADP
cblr-1208	326	6	date	date	NOUN
cblr-1208	326	7	largely	largely	ADV
cblr-1208	326	8	rejected	reject	VERB
cblr-1208	326	9	efforts	effort	NOUN
cblr-1208	326	10	by	by	ADP
cblr-1208	326	11	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
cblr-1208	326	12	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	326	13	use	use	VERB
cblr-1208	326	14	payment	payment	NOUN
cblr-1208	326	15	as	as	ADP
cblr-1208	326	16	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	326	17	proxy	proxy	NOUN
cblr-1208	326	18	for	for	ADP
cblr-1208	326	19	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	326	20	patent	patent	NOUN
cblr-1208	326	21	’s	’s	PART
cblr-1208	326	22	weakness	weakness	NOUN
cblr-1208	326	23	or	or	CCONJ
cblr-1208	326	24	as	as	ADP
cblr-1208	326	25	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	326	26	prediction	prediction	NOUN
cblr-1208	326	27	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	326	28	what	what	PRON
cblr-1208	326	29	would	would	AUX
cblr-1208	326	30	have	have	AUX
cblr-1208	326	31	happened	happen	VERB
cblr-1208	326	32	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	326	33	any	any	PRON
cblr-1208	326	34	earlier	early	ADJ
cblr-1208	326	35	paragraph	paragraph	NOUN
cblr-1208	326	36	iv	iv	NUM
cblr-1208	326	37	litigation	litigation	NOUN
cblr-1208	326	38	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	327	1	but	but	CCONJ
cblr-1208	327	2	how	how	SCONJ
cblr-1208	327	3	they	they	PRON
cblr-1208	327	4	have	have	AUX
cblr-1208	327	5	done	do	VERB
cblr-1208	327	6	so	so	ADV
cblr-1208	327	7	has	have	AUX
cblr-1208	327	8	been	be	AUX
cblr-1208	327	9	imperfect	imperfect	ADJ
cblr-1208	327	10	at	at	ADP
cblr-1208	327	11	best	well	ADV
cblr-1208	327	12	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	328	1	some	some	PRON
cblr-1208	328	2	have	have	AUX
cblr-1208	328	3	required	require	VERB
cblr-1208	328	4	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	328	5	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
cblr-1208	328	6	introduce	introduce	VERB
cblr-1208	328	7	some	some	DET
cblr-1208	328	8	evidence	evidence	NOUN
cblr-1208	328	9	on	on	ADP
cblr-1208	328	10	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	328	11	merits	merit	NOUN
cblr-1208	328	12	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	328	13	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	328	14	underlying	underlie	VERB
cblr-1208	328	15	patent	patent	NOUN
cblr-1208	328	16	litigation	litigation	NOUN
cblr-1208	328	17	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	329	1	for	for	ADP
cblr-1208	329	2	example	example	NOUN
cblr-1208	329	3	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	329	4	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	329	5	wellbutrin	wellbutrin	NOUN
cblr-1208	329	6	xl,74	xl,74	PUNCT
cblr-1208	330	1	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	330	2	district	district	NOUN
cblr-1208	330	3	court	court	NOUN
cblr-1208	330	4	explained	explain	VERB
cblr-1208	330	5	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	330	6	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	330	7	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	330	8	existence	existence	NOUN
cblr-1208	330	9	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	330	10	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	330	11	valid	valid	ADJ
cblr-1208	330	12	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	330	13	uninfringed	uninfringed	ADJ
cblr-1208	330	14	patent	patent	NOUN
cblr-1208	330	15	would	would	AUX
cblr-1208	330	16	interfere	interfere	VERB
cblr-1208	330	17	with	with	ADP
cblr-1208	330	18	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	330	19	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
cblr-1208	330	20	’	'	PUNCT
cblr-1208	330	21	chain	chain	NOUN
cblr-1208	330	22	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	330	23	causation	causation	NOUN
cblr-1208	330	24	:	:	PUNCT
cblr-1208	330	25	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	330	26	valid	valid	ADJ
cblr-1208	330	27	patent	patent	NOUN
cblr-1208	330	28	independently	independently	ADV
cblr-1208	330	29	precludes	preclude	VERB
cblr-1208	330	30	competition	competition	NOUN
cblr-1208	330	31	apart	apart	ADV
cblr-1208	330	32	from	from	ADP
cblr-1208	330	33	any	any	DET
cblr-1208	330	34	agreement	agreement	NOUN
cblr-1208	330	35	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	330	36	an	an	DET
cblr-1208	330	37	‘	'	PUNCT
cblr-1208	330	38	at	at	ADP
cblr-1208	330	39	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-1208	330	40	risk	risk	NOUN
cblr-1208	330	41	’	'	PUNCT
cblr-1208	330	42	launch	launch	NOUN
cblr-1208	330	43	is	be	AUX
cblr-1208	330	44	unlawful	unlawful	ADJ
cblr-1208	330	45	absent	absent	ADJ
cblr-1208	330	46	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	330	47	later	later	ADJ
cblr-1208	330	48	finding	finding	NOUN
cblr-1208	330	49	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	330	50	patent	patent	NOUN
cblr-1208	330	51	invalidity	invalidity	NOUN
cblr-1208	330	52	or	or	CCONJ
cblr-1208	330	53	non	non	ADJ
cblr-1208	330	54	-	-	NOUN
cblr-1208	330	55	infringement	infringement	NOUN
cblr-1208	330	56	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	330	57	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	331	1	without	without	ADP
cblr-1208	331	2	evidence	evidence	NOUN
cblr-1208	331	3	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	331	4	show	show	VERB
cblr-1208	331	5	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	331	6	patents	patent	NOUN
cblr-1208	331	7	would	would	AUX
cblr-1208	331	8	have	have	AUX
cblr-1208	331	9	been	be	AUX
cblr-1208	331	10	declared	declare	VERB
cblr-1208	331	11	invalid	invalid	ADJ
cblr-1208	331	12	or	or	CCONJ
cblr-1208	331	13	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	331	14	an	an	DET
cblr-1208	331	15	at	at	ADP
cblr-1208	331	16	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-1208	331	17	risk	risk	NOUN
cblr-1208	331	18	launch	launch	NOUN
cblr-1208	331	19	would	would	AUX
cblr-1208	331	20	not	not	PART
cblr-1208	331	21	have	have	AUX
cblr-1208	331	22	infringed	infringe	VERB
cblr-1208	331	23	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	331	24	patents	patent	NOUN
cblr-1208	331	25	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	331	26	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	331	27	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	331	28	patent	patent	NOUN
cblr-1208	331	29	served	serve	VERB
cblr-1208	331	30	as	as	ADP
cblr-1208	331	31	an	an	DET
cblr-1208	331	32	independent	independent	ADJ
cblr-1208	331	33	regulatory	regulatory	ADJ
cblr-1208	331	34	bar	bar	NOUN
cblr-1208	331	35	to	to	ADP
cblr-1208	331	36	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	331	37	generic	generic	ADJ
cblr-1208	331	38	’s	’s	PART
cblr-1208	331	39	launch	launch	NOUN
cblr-1208	331	40	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	332	1	”75	”75	PROPN
cblr-1208	332	2	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	332	3	third	third	ADJ
cblr-1208	332	4	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-1208	332	5	affirmed	affirm	VERB
cblr-1208	332	6	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	332	7	making	make	VERB
cblr-1208	332	8	clear	clear	ADJ
cblr-1208	332	9	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	332	10	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	332	11	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	332	12	order	order	NOUN
cblr-1208	332	13	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	332	14	evaluate	evaluate	VERB
cblr-1208	332	15	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	332	16	merit	merit	NOUN
cblr-1208	332	17	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	332	18	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	332	19	litigation	litigation	NOUN
cblr-1208	332	20	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-1208	332	21	based	base	VERB
cblr-1208	332	22	scenario	scenario	NOUN
cblr-1208	332	23	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	332	24	we	we	PRON
cblr-1208	332	25	must	must	AUX
cblr-1208	332	26	74	74	NUM
cblr-1208	332	27	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	332	28	re	re	NOUN
cblr-1208	332	29	wellbutrin	wellbutrin	NOUN
cblr-1208	332	30	xl	xl	PROPN
cblr-1208	332	31	antitrust	antitrust	ADJ
cblr-1208	332	32	litig	litig	NOUN
cblr-1208	332	33	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	333	1	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	333	2	133	133	NUM
cblr-1208	333	3	f.	f.	PROPN
cblr-1208	333	4	supp	supp	PROPN
cblr-1208	333	5	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	334	1	3d	3d	NUM
cblr-1208	334	2	734	734	NUM
cblr-1208	334	3	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	334	4	764	764	NUM
cblr-1208	334	5	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-1208	334	6	e.d	e.d	PROPN
cblr-1208	334	7	.	.	PROPN
cblr-1208	334	8	pa	pa	PROPN
cblr-1208	334	9	.	.	PROPN
cblr-1208	334	10	2015	2015	NUM
cblr-1208	334	11	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-1208	334	12	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-1208	334	13	internal	internal	ADJ
cblr-1208	334	14	quotation	quotation	NOUN
cblr-1208	334	15	marks	mark	NOUN
cblr-1208	334	16	omitted	omit	VERB
cblr-1208	334	17	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-1208	334	18	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	335	1	75	75	NUM
cblr-1208	336	1	i	i	PRON
cblr-1208	336	2	d.	d.	NOUN
cblr-1208	336	3	at	at	ADP
cblr-1208	336	4	767	767	NUM
cblr-1208	336	5	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	337	1	lecture_commentary_final	lecture_commentary_final	ADJ
cblr-1208	338	1	no	no	INTJ
cblr-1208	338	2	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	339	1	1:45	1:45	NUM
cblr-1208	339	2	]	]	PUNCT
cblr-1208	339	3	commentary	commentary	NOUN
cblr-1208	339	4	:	:	PUNCT
cblr-1208	339	5	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	339	6	rule	rule	NOUN
cblr-1208	339	7	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	339	8	reason	reason	NOUN
cblr-1208	339	9	67	67	NUM
cblr-1208	339	10	consider	consider	VERB
cblr-1208	339	11	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	339	12	substance	substance	NOUN
cblr-1208	339	13	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	339	14	that	that	DET
cblr-1208	339	15	underlying	underlie	VERB
cblr-1208	339	16	litigation	litigation	NOUN
cblr-1208	339	17	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	340	1	”76	”76	PROPN
cblr-1208	340	2	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	340	3	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	340	4	footnote	footnote	NOUN
cblr-1208	340	5	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	340	6	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	340	7	court	court	NOUN
cblr-1208	340	8	addressed	address	VERB
cblr-1208	340	9	justice	justice	NOUN
cblr-1208	340	10	breyer	breyer	NOUN
cblr-1208	340	11	’s	’s	PART
cblr-1208	340	12	commentary	commentary	NOUN
cblr-1208	340	13	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	340	14	it	it	PRON
cblr-1208	340	15	normally	normally	ADV
cblr-1208	340	16	will	will	AUX
cblr-1208	340	17	not	not	PART
cblr-1208	340	18	be	be	AUX
cblr-1208	340	19	necessary	necessary	ADJ
cblr-1208	340	20	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	340	21	litigate	litigate	VERB
cblr-1208	340	22	patent	patent	NOUN
cblr-1208	340	23	validity	validity	NOUN
cblr-1208	340	24	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	340	25	answer	answer	VERB
cblr-1208	340	26	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	340	27	antitrust	antitrust	ADJ
cblr-1208	340	28	question	question	NOUN
cblr-1208	340	29	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	340	30	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	340	31	which	which	PRON
cblr-1208	340	32	chief	chief	ADJ
cblr-1208	340	33	justice	justice	NOUN
cblr-1208	340	34	roberts	roberts	PROPN
cblr-1208	340	35	had	have	AUX
cblr-1208	340	36	criticized	criticize	VERB
cblr-1208	340	37	as	as	ADP
cblr-1208	340	38	implausible	implausible	ADJ
cblr-1208	340	39	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	341	1	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	341	2	court	court	NOUN
cblr-1208	341	3	observed	observe	VERB
cblr-1208	341	4	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	341	5	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	341	6	present	present	ADJ
cblr-1208	341	7	case	case	NOUN
cblr-1208	341	8	appeared	appear	VERB
cblr-1208	341	9	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	341	10	vindicate	vindicate	VERB
cblr-1208	341	11	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	341	12	chief	chief	ADJ
cblr-1208	341	13	justice	justice	NOUN
cblr-1208	341	14	’s	’s	PART
cblr-1208	341	15	analysis	analysis	NOUN
cblr-1208	341	16	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	341	17	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	341	18	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	341	19	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	341	20	we	we	PRON
cblr-1208	341	21	can	can	AUX
cblr-1208	341	22	not	not	PART
cblr-1208	341	23	resolve	resolve	VERB
cblr-1208	341	24	this	this	DET
cblr-1208	341	25	aspect	aspect	NOUN
cblr-1208	341	26	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	341	27	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	341	28	case	case	NOUN
cblr-1208	341	29	without	without	ADP
cblr-1208	341	30	considering	consider	VERB
cblr-1208	341	31	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	341	32	merits	merit	NOUN
cblr-1208	341	33	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	341	34	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	341	35	underlying	underlie	VERB
cblr-1208	341	36	patent	patent	NOUN
cblr-1208	341	37	case	case	NOUN
cblr-1208	341	38	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	342	1	”77	”77	NOUN
cblr-1208	343	1	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	343	2	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	343	3	re	re	PROPN
cblr-1208	343	4	nexium	nexium	NOUN
cblr-1208	343	5	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-1208	343	6	esomeprazole	esomeprazole	PROPN
cblr-1208	343	7	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-1208	343	8	antitrust	antitrust	ADJ
cblr-1208	343	9	litigation	litigation	NOUN
cblr-1208	343	10	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	343	11	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	343	12	court	court	NOUN
cblr-1208	343	13	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	343	14	appeals	appeal	NOUN
cblr-1208	343	15	for	for	ADP
cblr-1208	343	16	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	343	17	first	first	ADJ
cblr-1208	343	18	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-1208	343	19	likewise	likewise	ADV
cblr-1208	343	20	rejected	reject	VERB
cblr-1208	343	21	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
cblr-1208	343	22	’	'	PUNCT
cblr-1208	343	23	argument	argument	NOUN
cblr-1208	343	24	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	343	25	they	they	PRON
cblr-1208	343	26	should	should	AUX
cblr-1208	343	27	not	not	PART
cblr-1208	343	28	have	have	AUX
cblr-1208	343	29	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	343	30	prove	prove	VERB
cblr-1208	343	31	invalidity	invalidity	NOUN
cblr-1208	343	32	or	or	CCONJ
cblr-1208	343	33	non	non	NOUN
cblr-1208	343	34	-	-	NOUN
cblr-1208	343	35	infringement	infringement	NOUN
cblr-1208	343	36	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	343	37	pursue	pursue	VERB
cblr-1208	343	38	an	an	DET
cblr-1208	343	39	at	at	ADP
cblr-1208	343	40	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-1208	343	41	risk	risk	NOUN
cblr-1208	343	42	launch	launch	NOUN
cblr-1208	343	43	theory.78	theory.78	NOUN
cblr-1208	343	44	there	there	ADV
cblr-1208	343	45	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	343	46	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	343	47	court	court	NOUN
cblr-1208	343	48	explained	explain	VERB
cblr-1208	343	49	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	343	50	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
cblr-1208	343	51	failed	fail	VERB
cblr-1208	343	52	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	343	53	provide	provide	VERB
cblr-1208	343	54	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
cblr-1208	343	55	evidence	evidence	NOUN
cblr-1208	343	56	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	343	57	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	343	58	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	343	59	brand	brand	NOUN
cblr-1208	343	60	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-1208	343	61	name	name	NOUN
cblr-1208	343	62	’s	’s	PART
cblr-1208	343	63	patents	patent	NOUN
cblr-1208	343	64	would	would	AUX
cblr-1208	343	65	have	have	AUX
cblr-1208	343	66	been	be	AUX
cblr-1208	343	67	declared	declare	VERB
cblr-1208	343	68	invalid	invalid	ADJ
cblr-1208	343	69	or	or	CCONJ
cblr-1208	343	70	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	343	71	an	an	DET
cblr-1208	343	72	‘	'	PUNCT
cblr-1208	343	73	at	at	ADP
cblr-1208	343	74	risk	risk	NOUN
cblr-1208	343	75	’	'	PUNCT
cblr-1208	343	76	launch	launch	NOUN
cblr-1208	343	77	would	would	AUX
cblr-1208	343	78	not	not	PART
cblr-1208	343	79	have	have	AUX
cblr-1208	343	80	infringed	infringe	VERB
cblr-1208	343	81	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	343	82	patents	patent	NOUN
cblr-1208	343	83	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	343	84	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	343	85	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	343	86	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	343	87	without	without	ADP
cblr-1208	343	88	such	such	ADJ
cblr-1208	343	89	evidence	evidence	NOUN
cblr-1208	343	90	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	343	91	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	343	92	patent	patent	NOUN
cblr-1208	343	93	served	serve	VERB
cblr-1208	343	94	as	as	ADP
cblr-1208	343	95	an	an	DET
cblr-1208	343	96	independent	independent	ADJ
cblr-1208	343	97	regulatory	regulatory	ADJ
cblr-1208	343	98	bar	bar	NOUN
cblr-1208	343	99	to	to	ADP
cblr-1208	343	100	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	343	101	generic	generic	ADJ
cblr-1208	343	102	’s	’s	PART
cblr-1208	343	103	launch	launch	NOUN
cblr-1208	343	104	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	344	1	”79	”79	PROPN
cblr-1208	344	2	thus	thus	ADV
cblr-1208	344	3	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	344	4	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
cblr-1208	344	5	could	could	AUX
cblr-1208	344	6	not	not	PART
cblr-1208	344	7	establish	establish	VERB
cblr-1208	344	8	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	344	9	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	344	10	challenged	challenge	VERB
cblr-1208	344	11	settlement	settlement	NOUN
cblr-1208	344	12	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	344	13	rather	rather	ADV
cblr-1208	344	14	than	than	ADP
cblr-1208	344	15	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	344	16	legitimate	legitimate	ADJ
cblr-1208	344	17	operation	operation	NOUN
cblr-1208	344	18	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	344	19	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	344	20	patents	patent	NOUN
cblr-1208	344	21	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	344	22	caused	cause	VERB
cblr-1208	344	23	their	their	PRON
cblr-1208	344	24	alleged	allege	VERB
cblr-1208	344	25	injuries.80	injuries.80	NOUN
cblr-1208	344	26	more	more	ADV
cblr-1208	344	27	recently	recently	ADV
cblr-1208	344	28	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	344	29	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	344	30	lidoderm	lidoderm	NOUN
cblr-1208	344	31	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	344	32	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	344	33	court	court	NOUN
cblr-1208	344	34	held	hold	VERB
cblr-1208	344	35	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	344	36	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	344	37	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
cblr-1208	344	38	must	must	AUX
cblr-1208	344	39	provide	provide	VERB
cblr-1208	344	40	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	344	41	some	some	DET
cblr-1208	344	42	evidence	evidence	NOUN
cblr-1208	344	43	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	344	44	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	344	45	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	344	46	generic	generic	PROPN
cblr-1208	344	47	could	could	AUX
cblr-1208	344	48	have	have	AUX
cblr-1208	344	49	won	win	VERB
cblr-1208	344	50	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	344	51	patent	patent	NOUN
cblr-1208	345	1	litigation.81	litigation.81	NOUN
cblr-1208	345	2	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	345	3	court	court	NOUN
cblr-1208	345	4	observed	observe	VERB
cblr-1208	345	5	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	345	6	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	345	7	some	some	DET
cblr-1208	345	8	76	76	NUM
cblr-1208	345	9	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	345	10	re	re	PROPN
cblr-1208	345	11	wellbutrin	wellbutrin	NOUN
cblr-1208	345	12	xl	xl	PROPN
cblr-1208	345	13	antitrust	antitrust	ADJ
cblr-1208	345	14	litig	litig	NOUN
cblr-1208	345	15	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	345	16	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	345	17	868	868	NUM
cblr-1208	345	18	f.3d	f.3d	NUM
cblr-1208	345	19	132	132	NUM
cblr-1208	345	20	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	345	21	167	167	NUM
cblr-1208	345	22	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-1208	345	23	3d	3d	PROPN
cblr-1208	345	24	cir	cir	NOUN
cblr-1208	345	25	.	.	PROPN
cblr-1208	345	26	2017	2017	NUM
cblr-1208	345	27	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-1208	345	28	;	;	PUNCT
cblr-1208	345	29	see	see	VERB
cblr-1208	345	30	also	also	ADV
cblr-1208	345	31	apotex	apotex	PROPN
cblr-1208	345	32	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	345	33	inc	inc	PROPN
cblr-1208	345	34	.	.	PROPN
cblr-1208	346	1	v.	v.	ADP
cblr-1208	346	2	cephalon	cephalon	PROPN
cblr-1208	346	3	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	346	4	inc	inc	PROPN
cblr-1208	346	5	.	.	PROPN
cblr-1208	346	6	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	346	7	255	255	NUM
cblr-1208	346	8	f.	f.	PROPN
cblr-1208	346	9	supp	supp	PROPN
cblr-1208	346	10	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	347	1	3d	3d	PROPN
cblr-1208	347	2	604	604	NUM
cblr-1208	347	3	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	347	4	614	614	NUM
cblr-1208	347	5	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-1208	347	6	e.d	e.d	PROPN
cblr-1208	347	7	.	.	PROPN
cblr-1208	347	8	pa	pa	PROPN
cblr-1208	347	9	.	.	PROPN
cblr-1208	347	10	2017	2017	NUM
cblr-1208	347	11	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-1208	347	12	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-1208	347	13	explaining	explain	VERB
cblr-1208	347	14	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	347	15	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	347	16	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	347	17	clear	clear	ADJ
cblr-1208	347	18	import	import	NOUN
cblr-1208	347	19	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	347	20	nexium	nexium	NOUN
cblr-1208	347	21	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	347	22	wellbutrin	wellbutrin	NOUN
cblr-1208	348	1	[	[	X
cblr-1208	348	2	xl]is	xl]is	PROPN
cblr-1208	348	3	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	348	4	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	348	5	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
cblr-1208	348	6	must	must	AUX
cblr-1208	348	7	offer	offer	VERB
cblr-1208	348	8	some	some	DET
cblr-1208	348	9	evidence	evidence	NOUN
cblr-1208	348	10	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	348	11	non	non	ADJ
cblr-1208	348	12	-	-	NOUN
cblr-1208	348	13	infringement	infringement	NOUN
cblr-1208	348	14	or	or	CCONJ
cblr-1208	348	15	patent	patent	NOUN
cblr-1208	348	16	invalidity	invalidity	NOUN
cblr-1208	348	17	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	348	18	order	order	NOUN
cblr-1208	348	19	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	348	20	proceed	proceed	VERB
cblr-1208	348	21	on	on	ADP
cblr-1208	348	22	an	an	DET
cblr-1208	348	23	at	at	ADP
cblr-1208	348	24	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-1208	348	25	risk	risk	NOUN
cblr-1208	348	26	launch	launch	NOUN
cblr-1208	348	27	theory	theory	NOUN
cblr-1208	348	28	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	348	29	causation	causation	NOUN
cblr-1208	348	30	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	348	31	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-1208	348	32	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	349	1	77	77	NUM
cblr-1208	350	1	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	350	2	re	re	PROPN
cblr-1208	350	3	wellbutrin	wellbutrin	PROPN
cblr-1208	350	4	xl	xl	PROPN
cblr-1208	350	5	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	350	6	868	868	NUM
cblr-1208	350	7	f.3d	f.3d	NUM
cblr-1208	350	8	at	at	ADP
cblr-1208	350	9	167	167	NUM
cblr-1208	350	10	n.58	n.58	PROPN
cblr-1208	350	11	.	.	PROPN
cblr-1208	350	12	78	78	NUM
cblr-1208	350	13	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	350	14	re	re	PROPN
cblr-1208	350	15	nexium	nexium	NOUN
cblr-1208	350	16	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-1208	350	17	esomeprazole	esomeprazole	PROPN
cblr-1208	350	18	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-1208	350	19	litig	litig	NOUN
cblr-1208	350	20	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	351	1	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	351	2	842	842	NUM
cblr-1208	351	3	f.3d	f.3d	NUM
cblr-1208	351	4	34	34	NUM
cblr-1208	351	5	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	351	6	62–64	62–64	NUM
cblr-1208	351	7	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-1208	351	8	1st	1st	ADJ
cblr-1208	351	9	cir	cir	NOUN
cblr-1208	351	10	.	.	PROPN
cblr-1208	351	11	2016	2016	NUM
cblr-1208	351	12	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-1208	351	13	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	352	1	79	79	NUM
cblr-1208	352	2	see	see	VERB
cblr-1208	352	3	i	i	PRON
cblr-1208	352	4	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-1208	352	5	at	at	ADP
cblr-1208	352	6	63	63	NUM
cblr-1208	352	7	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-1208	352	8	internal	internal	ADJ
cblr-1208	352	9	quotation	quotation	NOUN
cblr-1208	352	10	marks	mark	NOUN
cblr-1208	352	11	omitted	omit	VERB
cblr-1208	352	12	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-1208	352	13	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	353	1	80	80	NUM
cblr-1208	353	2	see	see	VERB
cblr-1208	353	3	i	i	PRON
cblr-1208	353	4	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-1208	353	5	81	81	NUM
cblr-1208	353	6	lidoderm	lidoderm	NOUN
cblr-1208	353	7	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	353	8	no	no	INTJ
cblr-1208	353	9	.	.	NOUN
cblr-1208	353	10	14	14	NUM
cblr-1208	353	11	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-1208	353	12	md-02521	md-02521	NOUN
cblr-1208	353	13	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-1208	353	14	who	who	PRON
cblr-1208	353	15	2017	2017	NUM
cblr-1208	353	16	wl	wl	NOUN
cblr-1208	353	17	5068533	5068533	NUM
cblr-1208	353	18	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	353	19	at	at	ADP
cblr-1208	353	20	*	*	NOUN
cblr-1208	353	21	5	5	NUM
cblr-1208	353	22	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-1208	353	23	n.d	n.d	PROPN
cblr-1208	353	24	.	.	PROPN
cblr-1208	353	25	cal	cal	PROPN
cblr-1208	353	26	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	354	1	nov	nov	PROPN
cblr-1208	354	2	.	.	PROPN
cblr-1208	354	3	3	3	NUM
cblr-1208	354	4	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	354	5	2017	2017	NUM
cblr-1208	354	6	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-1208	354	7	;	;	PUNCT
cblr-1208	354	8	see	see	VERB
cblr-1208	354	9	also	also	ADV
cblr-1208	354	10	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	354	11	re	re	NOUN
cblr-1208	354	12	solodyn	solodyn	NOUN
cblr-1208	354	13	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-1208	354	14	minocycline	minocycline	ADJ
cblr-1208	354	15	hydrochloride	hydrochloride	NOUN
cblr-1208	354	16	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-1208	354	17	antitrust	antitrust	ADJ
cblr-1208	354	18	litig	litig	NOUN
cblr-1208	354	19	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	355	1	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	355	2	no	no	INTJ
cblr-1208	355	3	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	356	1	cv	cv	PROPN
cblr-1208	356	2	14	14	NUM
cblr-1208	356	3	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-1208	356	4	md-02503	md-02503	NOUN
cblr-1208	356	5	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	356	6	2018	2018	NUM
cblr-1208	356	7	wl	wl	NOUN
cblr-1208	356	8	563144	563144	NUM
cblr-1208	356	9	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	356	10	at	at	ADP
cblr-1208	356	11	*	*	NUM
cblr-1208	356	12	14	14	NUM
cblr-1208	356	13	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-1208	356	14	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-1208	356	15	mass	mass	PROPN
cblr-1208	356	16	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	357	1	jan	jan	PROPN
cblr-1208	357	2	.	.	PROPN
cblr-1208	357	3	25	25	NUM
cblr-1208	357	4	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	357	5	2018	2018	NUM
cblr-1208	357	6	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-1208	357	7	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-1208	357	8	same	same	ADJ
cblr-1208	357	9	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-1208	357	10	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	358	1	like	like	ADP
cblr-1208	358	2	other	other	ADJ
cblr-1208	358	3	courts	court	NOUN
cblr-1208	358	4	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	358	5	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	358	6	courts	court	NOUN
cblr-1208	358	7	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	358	8	lidoderm	lidoderm	NOUN
cblr-1208	358	9	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	358	10	lecture_commentary_final	lecture_commentary_final	PROPN
cblr-1208	358	11	68	68	NUM
cblr-1208	358	12	columbia	columbia	PROPN
cblr-1208	358	13	business	business	NOUN
cblr-1208	358	14	law	law	NOUN
cblr-1208	358	15	review	review	NOUN
cblr-1208	358	16	[	[	X
cblr-1208	358	17	vol	vol	NOUN
cblr-1208	358	18	.	.	NOUN
cblr-1208	358	19	2018	2018	NUM
cblr-1208	358	20	evidence	evidence	NOUN
cblr-1208	358	21	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	358	22	is	be	AUX
cblr-1208	358	23	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	358	24	not	not	PART
cblr-1208	358	25	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	358	26	same	same	ADJ
cblr-1208	358	27	as	as	ADP
cblr-1208	358	28	requiring	require	VERB
cblr-1208	358	29	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
cblr-1208	358	30	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	358	31	prove	prove	VERB
cblr-1208	358	32	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	358	33	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	358	34	generic	generic	ADJ
cblr-1208	358	35	defendant	defendant	NOUN
cblr-1208	358	36	would	would	AUX
cblr-1208	358	37	have	have	AUX
cblr-1208	358	38	won	win	VERB
cblr-1208	358	39	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	358	40	only	only	ADV
cblr-1208	358	41	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	358	42	it	it	PRON
cblr-1208	358	43	could	could	AUX
cblr-1208	358	44	have	have	VERB
cblr-1208	358	45	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	359	1	”82	”82	VERB
cblr-1208	359	2	that	that	DET
cblr-1208	359	3	observation	observation	NOUN
cblr-1208	359	4	may	may	AUX
cblr-1208	359	5	have	have	AUX
cblr-1208	359	6	addressed	address	VERB
cblr-1208	359	7	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	359	8	court	court	NOUN
cblr-1208	359	9	’s	’s	PART
cblr-1208	359	10	valid	valid	ADJ
cblr-1208	359	11	concern	concern	NOUN
cblr-1208	359	12	about	about	ADP
cblr-1208	359	13	litigating	litigate	VERB
cblr-1208	359	14	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	359	15	patent	patent	NOUN
cblr-1208	359	16	case,83	case,83	NOUN
cblr-1208	359	17	but	but	CCONJ
cblr-1208	359	18	it	it	PRON
cblr-1208	359	19	also	also	ADV
cblr-1208	359	20	reveals	reveal	VERB
cblr-1208	359	21	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	359	22	flaw	flaw	NOUN
cblr-1208	359	23	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	359	24	adopting	adopt	VERB
cblr-1208	359	25	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	359	26	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	359	27	some	some	DET
cblr-1208	359	28	evidence	evidence	NOUN
cblr-1208	359	29	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	359	30	standard	standard	NOUN
cblr-1208	359	31	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	360	1	as	as	SCONJ
cblr-1208	360	2	noted	note	VERB
cblr-1208	360	3	above	above	ADV
cblr-1208	360	4	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	360	5	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	360	6	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	360	7	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	360	8	no	no	DET
cblr-1208	360	9	settlement	settlement	NOUN
cblr-1208	360	10	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	360	11	scenario	scenario	NOUN
cblr-1208	360	12	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	360	13	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	360	14	some	some	DET
cblr-1208	360	15	evidence	evidence	NOUN
cblr-1208	360	16	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	360	17	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	360	18	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	360	19	generic	generic	ADJ
cblr-1208	360	20	defendant	defendant	NOUN
cblr-1208	360	21	could	could	AUX
cblr-1208	360	22	have	have	AUX
cblr-1208	360	23	won	win	VERB
cblr-1208	360	24	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	360	25	patent	patent	NOUN
cblr-1208	360	26	litigation	litigation	NOUN
cblr-1208	360	27	is	be	AUX
cblr-1208	360	28	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	360	29	starting	starting	NOUN
cblr-1208	360	30	point	point	NOUN
cblr-1208	360	31	for	for	ADP
cblr-1208	360	32	analysis	analysis	NOUN
cblr-1208	360	33	—	—	PUNCT
cblr-1208	360	34	absent	absent	ADJ
cblr-1208	360	35	proof	proof	NOUN
cblr-1208	360	36	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	360	37	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	360	38	litigation	litigation	NOUN
cblr-1208	360	39	was	be	AUX
cblr-1208	360	40	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	360	41	sham	sham	NOUN
cblr-1208	360	42	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	360	43	either	either	CCONJ
cblr-1208	360	44	party	party	NOUN
cblr-1208	360	45	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	360	46	could	could	AUX
cblr-1208	360	47	realistically	realistically	ADV
cblr-1208	360	48	expect	expect	VERB
cblr-1208	360	49	success	success	NOUN
cblr-1208	360	50	on	on	ADP
cblr-1208	360	51	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	360	52	merits	merit	NOUN
cblr-1208	360	53	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	360	54	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	360	55	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	360	56	underlying	underlie	VERB
cblr-1208	360	57	patent	patent	NOUN
cblr-1208	360	58	case.84	case.84	PROPN
cblr-1208	360	59	thus	thus	ADV
cblr-1208	360	60	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	360	61	requiring	require	VERB
cblr-1208	360	62	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	360	63	some	some	DET
cblr-1208	360	64	evidence	evidence	NOUN
cblr-1208	360	65	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	360	66	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	360	67	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	360	68	generic	generic	PROPN
cblr-1208	360	69	could	could	AUX
cblr-1208	360	70	have	have	AUX
cblr-1208	360	71	won	win	VERB
cblr-1208	360	72	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	360	73	patent	patent	NOUN
cblr-1208	360	74	litigation	litigation	NOUN
cblr-1208	360	75	—	—	PUNCT
cblr-1208	360	76	i.e.	i.e.	X
cblr-1208	360	77	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	360	78	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	360	79	mere	mere	ADJ
cblr-1208	360	80	possibility	possibility	NOUN
cblr-1208	360	81	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	360	82	generic	generic	ADJ
cblr-1208	360	83	entry	entry	NOUN
cblr-1208	360	84	—	—	PUNCT
cblr-1208	360	85	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	360	86	stand	stand	VERB
cblr-1208	360	87	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	360	88	for	for	ADP
cblr-1208	360	89	proving	prove	VERB
cblr-1208	360	90	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	360	91	existence	existence	NOUN
cblr-1208	360	92	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	360	93	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	360	94	but	but	CCONJ
cblr-1208	360	95	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-1208	360	96	for	for	ADP
cblr-1208	360	97	world	world	NOUN
cblr-1208	360	98	by	by	ADP
cblr-1208	360	99	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	360	100	preponderance	preponderance	NOUN
cblr-1208	360	101	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	360	102	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	360	103	evidence	evidence	NOUN
cblr-1208	360	104	is	be	AUX
cblr-1208	360	105	tantamount	tantamount	ADJ
cblr-1208	360	106	to	to	ADP
cblr-1208	360	107	requiring	require	VERB
cblr-1208	360	108	no	no	DET
cblr-1208	360	109	evidence	evidence	NOUN
cblr-1208	360	110	at	at	ADV
cblr-1208	360	111	all	all	ADV
cblr-1208	360	112	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	361	1	these	these	DET
cblr-1208	361	2	courts	court	NOUN
cblr-1208	361	3	were	be	AUX
cblr-1208	361	4	correct	correct	ADJ
cblr-1208	361	5	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	361	6	concluding	conclude	VERB
cblr-1208	361	7	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	361	8	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	361	9	reverse	reverse	ADJ
cblr-1208	361	10	payment	payment	NOUN
cblr-1208	361	11	alone	alone	ADV
cblr-1208	361	12	can	can	AUX
cblr-1208	361	13	not	not	PART
cblr-1208	361	14	be	be	AUX
cblr-1208	361	15	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	361	16	proxy	proxy	NOUN
cblr-1208	361	17	for	for	ADP
cblr-1208	361	18	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	361	19	likely	likely	ADJ
cblr-1208	361	20	outcome	outcome	NOUN
cblr-1208	361	21	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	361	22	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	361	23	underlying	underlie	VERB
cblr-1208	361	24	patent	patent	NOUN
cblr-1208	361	25	case	case	NOUN
cblr-1208	361	26	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	362	1	however	however	ADV
cblr-1208	362	2	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	362	3	their	their	PRON
cblr-1208	362	4	willingness	willingness	NOUN
cblr-1208	362	5	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	362	6	consider	consider	VERB
cblr-1208	362	7	evidence	evidence	NOUN
cblr-1208	362	8	as	as	ADP
cblr-1208	362	9	to	to	ADP
cblr-1208	362	10	validity	validity	NOUN
cblr-1208	362	11	or	or	CCONJ
cblr-1208	362	12	infringement	infringement	NOUN
cblr-1208	362	13	invites	invite	VERB
cblr-1208	362	14	similar	similar	ADJ
cblr-1208	362	15	shortcuts	shortcut	NOUN
cblr-1208	362	16	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-1208	362	17	risks	risk	NOUN
cblr-1208	362	18	imposing	impose	VERB
cblr-1208	362	19	later	later	ADJ
cblr-1208	362	20	judgments	judgment	NOUN
cblr-1208	362	21	as	as	ADP
cblr-1208	362	22	to	to	ADP
cblr-1208	362	23	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	362	24	patent	patent	NOUN
cblr-1208	362	25	’s	’s	PART
cblr-1208	362	26	strength	strength	NOUN
cblr-1208	362	27	on	on	ADP
cblr-1208	362	28	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	362	29	relevant	relevant	ADJ
cblr-1208	362	30	question	question	NOUN
cblr-1208	362	31	—	—	PUNCT
cblr-1208	362	32	namely	namely	ADV
cblr-1208	362	33	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	362	34	what	what	PRON
cblr-1208	362	35	would	would	AUX
cblr-1208	362	36	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	362	37	judge	judge	NOUN
cblr-1208	362	38	have	have	AUX
cblr-1208	362	39	done	do	VERB
cblr-1208	362	40	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	362	41	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	362	42	underlying	underlie	VERB
cblr-1208	362	43	paragraph	paragraph	NOUN
cblr-1208	362	44	iv	iv	NUM
cblr-1208	362	45	litigation	litigation	NOUN
cblr-1208	362	46	—	—	PUNCT
cblr-1208	362	47	thus	thus	ADV
cblr-1208	362	48	reflecting	reflect	VERB
cblr-1208	362	49	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	362	50	lack	lack	NOUN
cblr-1208	362	51	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	362	52	focus	focus	NOUN
cblr-1208	362	53	on	on	ADP
cblr-1208	362	54	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	362	55	inherent	inherent	ADJ
cblr-1208	362	56	speculative	speculative	ADJ
cblr-1208	362	57	-	-	ADJ
cblr-1208	362	58	ness	ness	ADJ
cblr-1208	362	59	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	362	60	attempting	attempt	VERB
cblr-1208	362	61	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	362	62	construct	construct	VERB
cblr-1208	362	63	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	362	64	but	but	CCONJ
cblr-1208	362	65	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-1208	362	66	for	for	ADP
cblr-1208	362	67	world	world	NOUN
cblr-1208	362	68	around	around	ADP
cblr-1208	362	69	an	an	DET
cblr-1208	362	70	underlying	underlying	ADJ
cblr-1208	362	71	settled	settle	VERB
cblr-1208	362	72	litigation	litigation	NOUN
cblr-1208	362	73	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	363	1	for	for	ADP
cblr-1208	363	2	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	363	3	reasons	reason	NOUN
cblr-1208	363	4	provided	provide	VERB
cblr-1208	363	5	above	above	ADV
cblr-1208	363	6	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	363	7	courts	court	NOUN
cblr-1208	363	8	should	should	AUX
cblr-1208	363	9	not	not	PART
cblr-1208	363	10	permit	permit	VERB
cblr-1208	363	11	parties	party	NOUN
cblr-1208	363	12	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	363	13	or	or	CCONJ
cblr-1208	363	14	juries	jury	NOUN
cblr-1208	363	15	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	363	16	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	363	17	speculate	speculate	VERB
cblr-1208	363	18	as	as	ADP
cblr-1208	363	19	to	to	ADP
cblr-1208	363	20	what	what	PRON
cblr-1208	363	21	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	363	22	federal	federal	ADJ
cblr-1208	363	23	judge	judge	NOUN
cblr-1208	363	24	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	363	25	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	363	26	prior	prior	ADJ
cblr-1208	363	27	litigation	litigation	NOUN
cblr-1208	363	28	would	would	AUX
cblr-1208	363	29	have	have	AUX
cblr-1208	363	30	decided	decide	VERB
cblr-1208	363	31	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	364	1	solodyn	solodyn	NOUN
cblr-1208	364	2	did	do	AUX
cblr-1208	364	3	not	not	PART
cblr-1208	364	4	ground	ground	VERB
cblr-1208	364	5	their	their	PRON
cblr-1208	364	6	analyses	analysis	NOUN
cblr-1208	364	7	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	364	8	application	application	NOUN
cblr-1208	364	9	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	364	10	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	364	11	rule	rule	NOUN
cblr-1208	364	12	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	364	13	reason	reason	NOUN
cblr-1208	364	14	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	364	15	focusing	focus	VERB
cblr-1208	364	16	instead	instead	ADV
cblr-1208	364	17	on	on	ADP
cblr-1208	364	18	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	364	19	causation	causation	NOUN
cblr-1208	364	20	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	364	21	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-1208	365	1	i	i	PRON
cblr-1208	365	2	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-1208	365	3	82	82	NUM
cblr-1208	366	1	i	i	PRON
cblr-1208	366	2	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-1208	366	3	at	at	ADP
cblr-1208	366	4	*	*	NUM
cblr-1208	366	5	4	4	NUM
cblr-1208	366	6	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-1208	366	7	emphasis	emphasis	NOUN
cblr-1208	366	8	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	366	9	original	original	ADJ
cblr-1208	366	10	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-1208	366	11	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	367	1	83	83	NUM
cblr-1208	367	2	see	see	VERB
cblr-1208	367	3	i	i	PRON
cblr-1208	367	4	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-1208	367	5	at	at	ADP
cblr-1208	367	6	*	*	PROPN
cblr-1208	367	7	5	5	NUM
cblr-1208	367	8	.	.	SYM
cblr-1208	367	9	84	84	NUM
cblr-1208	367	10	prof’l	prof’l	NOUN
cblr-1208	367	11	real	real	ADJ
cblr-1208	367	12	estate	estate	NOUN
cblr-1208	367	13	inv’rs	inv’rs	NOUN
cblr-1208	367	14	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	367	15	inc	inc	PROPN
cblr-1208	367	16	.	.	PROPN
cblr-1208	367	17	v.	v.	PROPN
cblr-1208	367	18	columbia	columbia	PROPN
cblr-1208	367	19	pictures	picture	NOUN
cblr-1208	367	20	indus	indus	PROPN
cblr-1208	367	21	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	367	22	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	367	23	508	508	NUM
cblr-1208	367	24	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-1208	367	25	.	.	PROPN
cblr-1208	367	26	49	49	NUM
cblr-1208	367	27	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	367	28	60	60	NUM
cblr-1208	367	29	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-1208	367	30	1993	1993	NUM
cblr-1208	367	31	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-1208	367	32	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	368	1	lecture_commentary_final	lecture_commentary_final	PROPN
cblr-1208	369	1	no	no	INTJ
cblr-1208	369	2	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	370	1	1:45	1:45	NUM
cblr-1208	370	2	]	]	PUNCT
cblr-1208	370	3	commentary	commentary	NOUN
cblr-1208	370	4	:	:	PUNCT
cblr-1208	370	5	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	370	6	rule	rule	NOUN
cblr-1208	370	7	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	370	8	reason	reason	NOUN
cblr-1208	370	9	69	69	NUM
cblr-1208	370	10	vi	vi	NOUN
cblr-1208	370	11	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	370	12	conclusion	conclusion	NOUN
cblr-1208	370	13	if	if	SCONJ
cblr-1208	370	14	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	370	15	case	case	NOUN
cblr-1208	370	16	law	law	NOUN
cblr-1208	370	17	since	since	SCONJ
cblr-1208	370	18	actavis	actavis	PROPN
cblr-1208	370	19	has	have	AUX
cblr-1208	370	20	made	make	VERB
cblr-1208	370	21	anything	anything	PRON
cblr-1208	370	22	clear	clear	ADJ
cblr-1208	370	23	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	370	24	it	it	PRON
cblr-1208	370	25	is	be	AUX
cblr-1208	370	26	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	370	27	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	370	28	decision	decision	NOUN
cblr-1208	370	29	generated	generate	VERB
cblr-1208	370	30	more	more	ADJ
cblr-1208	370	31	questions	question	NOUN
cblr-1208	370	32	than	than	SCONJ
cblr-1208	370	33	it	it	PRON
cblr-1208	370	34	answered	answer	VERB
cblr-1208	370	35	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	371	1	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	371	2	actavis	actavis	ADJ
cblr-1208	371	3	holdings	holding	NOUN
cblr-1208	371	4	on	on	ADP
cblr-1208	371	5	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	371	6	motion	motion	NOUN
cblr-1208	371	7	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	371	8	dismiss	dismiss	VERB
cblr-1208	371	9	at	at	ADP
cblr-1208	371	10	issue	issue	NOUN
cblr-1208	371	11	are	be	AUX
cblr-1208	371	12	clear	clear	ADJ
cblr-1208	371	13	—	—	PUNCT
cblr-1208	371	14	no	no	PRON
cblr-1208	371	15	per	per	X
cblr-1208	371	16	se	se	X
cblr-1208	371	17	rules	rule	NOUN
cblr-1208	371	18	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	371	19	no	no	DET
cblr-1208	371	20	quick	quick	ADJ
cblr-1208	371	21	looks	look	NOUN
cblr-1208	371	22	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	371	23	no	no	DET
cblr-1208	371	24	presumptions	presumption	NOUN
cblr-1208	371	25	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	372	1	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	372	2	majority	majority	NOUN
cblr-1208	372	3	’s	’s	PART
cblr-1208	372	4	commentary	commentary	NOUN
cblr-1208	372	5	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	372	6	while	while	SCONJ
cblr-1208	372	7	meant	mean	VERB
cblr-1208	372	8	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	372	9	respond	respond	VERB
cblr-1208	372	10	to	to	ADP
cblr-1208	372	11	risks	risk	NOUN
cblr-1208	372	12	identified	identify	VERB
cblr-1208	372	13	by	by	ADP
cblr-1208	372	14	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	372	15	dissent	dissent	NOUN
cblr-1208	372	16	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	372	17	makes	make	VERB
cblr-1208	372	18	for	for	ADP
cblr-1208	372	19	interesting	interesting	ADJ
cblr-1208	372	20	intra	intra	ADJ
cblr-1208	372	21	-	-	ADJ
cblr-1208	372	22	judicial	judicial	ADJ
cblr-1208	372	23	debate	debate	NOUN
cblr-1208	372	24	but	but	CCONJ
cblr-1208	372	25	does	do	AUX
cblr-1208	372	26	not	not	PART
cblr-1208	372	27	support	support	VERB
cblr-1208	372	28	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	372	29	subsequent	subsequent	ADJ
cblr-1208	372	30	efforts	effort	NOUN
cblr-1208	372	31	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	372	32	undermine	undermine	VERB
cblr-1208	372	33	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	372	34	court	court	NOUN
cblr-1208	372	35	’s	’s	PART
cblr-1208	372	36	clear	clear	ADJ
cblr-1208	372	37	holdings	holding	NOUN
cblr-1208	372	38	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	373	1	to	to	ADP
cblr-1208	373	2	date	date	NOUN
cblr-1208	373	3	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	373	4	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	373	5	lower	low	ADJ
cblr-1208	373	6	courts	court	NOUN
cblr-1208	373	7	have	have	AUX
cblr-1208	373	8	largely	largely	ADV
cblr-1208	373	9	rejected	reject	VERB
cblr-1208	373	10	those	those	DET
cblr-1208	373	11	efforts	effort	NOUN
cblr-1208	373	12	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	374	1	but	but	CCONJ
cblr-1208	374	2	it	it	PRON
cblr-1208	374	3	is	be	AUX
cblr-1208	374	4	likely	likely	ADJ
cblr-1208	374	5	only	only	ADV
cblr-1208	374	6	a	a	DET
cblr-1208	374	7	matter	matter	NOUN
cblr-1208	374	8	of	of	ADP
cblr-1208	374	9	time	time	NOUN
cblr-1208	374	10	before	before	SCONJ
cblr-1208	374	11	more	more	ADJ
cblr-1208	374	12	courts	court	NOUN
cblr-1208	374	13	succumb	succumb	VERB
cblr-1208	374	14	to	to	ADP
cblr-1208	374	15	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	374	16	temptation	temptation	NOUN
cblr-1208	374	17	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	374	18	use	use	VERB
cblr-1208	374	19	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	374	20	shortcuts	shortcut	NOUN
cblr-1208	374	21	that	that	PRON
cblr-1208	374	22	actavis	actavis	PROPN
cblr-1208	374	23	rejected	reject	VERB
cblr-1208	374	24	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-1208	375	1	accordingly	accordingly	ADV
cblr-1208	375	2	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-1208	375	3	it	it	PRON
cblr-1208	375	4	is	be	AUX
cblr-1208	375	5	unlikely	unlikely	ADJ
cblr-1208	375	6	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-1208	375	7	actavis	actavis	PROPN
cblr-1208	375	8	will	will	AUX
cblr-1208	375	9	be	be	AUX
cblr-1208	375	10	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	375	11	final	final	ADJ
cblr-1208	375	12	opportunity	opportunity	NOUN
cblr-1208	375	13	for	for	SCONJ
cblr-1208	375	14	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	375	15	supreme	supreme	PROPN
cblr-1208	375	16	court	court	PROPN
cblr-1208	375	17	to	to	PART
cblr-1208	375	18	address	address	VERB
cblr-1208	375	19	challenges	challenge	NOUN
cblr-1208	375	20	to	to	ADP
cblr-1208	375	21	patent	patent	NOUN
cblr-1208	375	22	settlement	settlement	NOUN
cblr-1208	375	23	agreements	agreement	NOUN
cblr-1208	375	24	in	in	ADP
cblr-1208	375	25	the	the	DET
cblr-1208	375	26	hatch	hatch	NOUN
cblr-1208	375	27	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-1208	375	28	waxman	waxman	PROPN
cblr-1208	375	29	context	context	NOUN
cblr-1208	375	30	.	.	PUNCT