id	sid	tid	token	lemma	pos
cblr-5119	1	1	6_2019.3_estes	6_2019.3_estes	NUM
cblr-5119	1	2	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	1	3	do	do	AUX
cblr-5119	1	4	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	1	5	delete	delete	VERB
cblr-5119	1	6	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	1	7	12/26/2019	12/26/2019	NUM
cblr-5119	1	8	12:00	12:00	NUM
cblr-5119	1	9	am	am	NOUN
cblr-5119	1	10	may	may	AUX
cblr-5119	1	11	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	1	12	fourth	fourth	ADJ
cblr-5119	1	13	be	be	AUX
cblr-5119	1	14	with	with	ADP
cblr-5119	1	15	you	you	PRON
cblr-5119	1	16	:	:	PUNCT
cblr-5119	1	17	charting	chart	VERB
cblr-5119	1	18	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	1	19	future	future	NOUN
cblr-5119	1	20	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	1	21	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	1	22	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	1	23	under	under	ADP
cblr-5119	1	24	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	1	25	alien	alien	PROPN
cblr-5119	1	26	tort	tort	NOUN
cblr-5119	1	27	statute	statute	NOUN
cblr-5119	1	28	after	after	ADP
cblr-5119	1	29	jesner	jesner	PROPN
cblr-5119	1	30	v.	v.	PROPN
cblr-5119	1	31	arab	arab	PROPN
cblr-5119	1	32	bank	bank	PROPN
cblr-5119	1	33	benjamin	benjamin	PROPN
cblr-5119	1	34	estes	estes	PROPN
cblr-5119	1	35	*	*	PROPN
cblr-5119	1	36	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	1	37	alien	alien	PROPN
cblr-5119	1	38	tort	tort	NOUN
cblr-5119	1	39	statute	statute	NOUN
cblr-5119	1	40	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	1	41	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	1	42	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	1	43	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	1	44	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	1	45	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	1	46	has	have	AUX
cblr-5119	1	47	been	be	AUX
cblr-5119	1	48	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	1	49	subject	subject	NOUN
cblr-5119	1	50	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	1	51	much	much	ADJ
cblr-5119	1	52	curiosity	curiosity	NOUN
cblr-5119	1	53	ever	ever	ADV
cblr-5119	1	54	since	since	SCONJ
cblr-5119	1	55	it	it	PRON
cblr-5119	1	56	became	become	VERB
cblr-5119	1	57	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	1	58	conduit	conduit	NOUN
cblr-5119	1	59	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	1	60	human	human	ADJ
cblr-5119	1	61	rights	right	NOUN
cblr-5119	1	62	lawsuits	lawsuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	1	63	nearly	nearly	ADV
cblr-5119	1	64	40	40	NUM
cblr-5119	1	65	years	year	NOUN
cblr-5119	1	66	ago	ago	ADV
cblr-5119	1	67	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	2	1	many	many	ADJ
cblr-5119	2	2	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	2	3	these	these	DET
cblr-5119	2	4	lawsuits	lawsuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	2	5	have	have	AUX
cblr-5119	2	6	been	be	AUX
cblr-5119	2	7	directed	direct	VERB
cblr-5119	2	8	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	2	9	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	2	10	defendants	defendant	NOUN
cblr-5119	2	11	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	2	12	with	with	ADP
cblr-5119	2	13	businesses	business	NOUN
cblr-5119	2	14	around	around	ADP
cblr-5119	2	15	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	2	16	world	world	NOUN
cblr-5119	2	17	accused	accuse	VERB
cblr-5119	2	18	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	2	19	conscience	conscience	NOUN
cblr-5119	2	20	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-5119	2	21	shocking	shock	VERB
cblr-5119	2	22	behavior	behavior	NOUN
cblr-5119	2	23	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	3	1	however	however	ADV
cblr-5119	3	2	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	3	3	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	3	4	supreme	supreme	PROPN
cblr-5119	3	5	court	court	PROPN
cblr-5119	3	6	has	have	AUX
cblr-5119	3	7	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	3	8	recent	recent	ADJ
cblr-5119	3	9	years	year	NOUN
cblr-5119	3	10	restricted	restrict	VERB
cblr-5119	3	11	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	3	12	scope	scope	NOUN
cblr-5119	3	13	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	3	14	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	3	15	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	3	16	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	3	17	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	4	1	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	4	2	2013	2013	NUM
cblr-5119	4	3	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	4	4	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	4	5	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	4	6	held	hold	VERB
cblr-5119	4	7	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	4	8	kiobel	kiobel	PROPN
cblr-5119	4	9	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	4	10	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	4	11	presumption	presumption	NOUN
cblr-5119	4	12	against	against	ADP
cblr-5119	4	13	extraterritoriality	extraterritoriality	NOUN
cblr-5119	4	14	applies	apply	VERB
cblr-5119	4	15	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	4	16	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	4	17	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	4	18	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	4	19	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	4	20	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	4	21	2018	2018	NUM
cblr-5119	4	22	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	4	23	it	it	PRON
cblr-5119	4	24	held	hold	VERB
cblr-5119	4	25	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	4	26	jesner	jesner	NOUN
cblr-5119	4	27	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	4	28	foreign	foreign	ADJ
cblr-5119	4	29	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	4	30	can	can	AUX
cblr-5119	4	31	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	4	32	be	be	AUX
cblr-5119	4	33	sued	sue	VERB
cblr-5119	4	34	under	under	ADP
cblr-5119	4	35	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	4	36	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	4	37	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	5	1	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	5	2	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	5	3	wake	wake	NOUN
cblr-5119	5	4	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	5	5	these	these	DET
cblr-5119	5	6	developments	development	NOUN
cblr-5119	5	7	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	5	8	observers	observer	NOUN
cblr-5119	5	9	have	have	AUX
cblr-5119	5	10	questioned	question	VERB
cblr-5119	5	11	whether	whether	SCONJ
cblr-5119	5	12	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	5	13	statute	statute	NOUN
cblr-5119	5	14	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	5	15	vitality	vitality	NOUN
cblr-5119	5	16	is	be	AUX
cblr-5119	5	17	reaching	reach	VERB
cblr-5119	5	18	its	its	PRON
cblr-5119	5	19	end	end	NOUN
cblr-5119	5	20	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	6	1	this	this	DET
cblr-5119	6	2	note	note	NOUN
cblr-5119	6	3	charts	chart	VERB
cblr-5119	6	4	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	6	5	path	path	NOUN
cblr-5119	6	6	forward	forward	ADV
cblr-5119	6	7	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	6	8	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	6	9	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	6	10	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	7	1	after	after	ADP
cblr-5119	7	2	tracing	trace	VERB
cblr-5119	7	3	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	7	4	development	development	NOUN
cblr-5119	7	5	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	7	6	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	7	7	statute	statute	NOUN
cblr-5119	7	8	from	from	ADP
cblr-5119	7	9	its	its	PRON
cblr-5119	7	10	murky	murky	ADJ
cblr-5119	7	11	founding	found	VERB
cblr-5119	7	12	origins	origin	NOUN
cblr-5119	7	13	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	7	14	its	its	PRON
cblr-5119	7	15	modern	modern	ADJ
cblr-5119	7	16	incarnation	incarnation	NOUN
cblr-5119	7	17	as	as	ADP
cblr-5119	7	18	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	7	19	powerful	powerful	ADJ
cblr-5119	7	20	litigation	litigation	NOUN
cblr-5119	7	21	tool	tool	NOUN
cblr-5119	7	22	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	7	23	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	7	24	note	note	NOUN
cblr-5119	7	25	examines	examine	VERB
cblr-5119	7	26	how	how	SCONJ
cblr-5119	7	27	several	several	ADJ
cblr-5119	7	28	circuits	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	7	29	have	have	AUX
cblr-5119	7	30	analyzed	analyze	VERB
cblr-5119	7	31	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	7	32	issues	issue	NOUN
cblr-5119	7	33	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	7	34	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	7	35	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	7	36	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	7	37	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	7	38	presumption	presumption	NOUN
cblr-5119	7	39	against	against	ADP
cblr-5119	7	40	extraterritoriality	extraterritoriality	NOUN
cblr-5119	7	41	under	under	ADP
cblr-5119	7	42	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	7	43	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	7	44	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	8	1	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	8	2	note	note	NOUN
cblr-5119	8	3	ultimately	ultimately	ADV
cblr-5119	8	4	argues	argue	VERB
cblr-5119	8	5	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	8	6	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	8	7	fourth	fourth	ADJ
cblr-5119	8	8	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	8	9	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	8	10	approach	approach	NOUN
cblr-5119	8	11	provides	provide	VERB
cblr-5119	8	12	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	8	13	best	good	ADJ
cblr-5119	8	14	regime	regime	NOUN
cblr-5119	8	15	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	8	16	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	8	17	ats	at	NOUN
cblr-5119	8	18	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	8	19	light	light	NOUN
cblr-5119	8	20	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	8	21	jesner	jesner	NOUN
cblr-5119	8	22	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	8	23	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	8	24	other	other	ADJ
cblr-5119	8	25	considerations	consideration	NOUN
cblr-5119	8	26	that	that	PRON
cblr-5119	8	27	have	have	AUX
cblr-5119	8	28	long	long	ADV
cblr-5119	8	29	informed	inform	VERB
cblr-5119	8	30	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	8	31	cases	case	NOUN
cblr-5119	8	32	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	9	1	i.	i.	NOUN
cblr-5119	9	2	introduction	introduction	NOUN
cblr-5119	9	3	....................................................................	....................................................................	PUNCT
cblr-5119	9	4	1032	1032	NUM
cblr-5119	9	5	ii	ii	NOUN
cblr-5119	9	6	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	10	1	background	background	NOUN
cblr-5119	10	2	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	10	3	history	history	NOUN
cblr-5119	10	4	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	10	5	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	10	6	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	10	7	............................	............................	PUNCT
cblr-5119	10	8	1035	1035	NUM
cblr-5119	10	9	*	*	PUNCT
cblr-5119	10	10	j.d	j.d	PROPN
cblr-5119	10	11	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	10	12	candidate	candidate	PROPN
cblr-5119	10	13	2020	2020	NUM
cblr-5119	10	14	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	10	15	columbia	columbia	PROPN
cblr-5119	10	16	law	law	PROPN
cblr-5119	10	17	school	school	NOUN
cblr-5119	10	18	;	;	PUNCT
cblr-5119	10	19	b.a	b.a	PROPN
cblr-5119	10	20	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	10	21	2013	2013	NUM
cblr-5119	10	22	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	10	23	university	university	NOUN
cblr-5119	10	24	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	10	25	michigan	michigan	PROPN
cblr-5119	10	26	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	11	1	my	my	PRON
cblr-5119	11	2	deepest	deep	ADJ
cblr-5119	11	3	thanks	thank	NOUN
cblr-5119	11	4	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	11	5	professor	professor	PROPN
cblr-5119	11	6	george	george	PROPN
cblr-5119	11	7	bermann	bermann	PROPN
cblr-5119	11	8	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	11	9	his	his	PRON
cblr-5119	11	10	indispensable	indispensable	ADJ
cblr-5119	11	11	guidance	guidance	NOUN
cblr-5119	11	12	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	11	13	feedback	feedback	NOUN
cblr-5119	11	14	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	11	15	professor	professor	NOUN
cblr-5119	11	16	robert	robert	PROPN
cblr-5119	11	17	smit	smit	PROPN
cblr-5119	11	18	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	11	19	sharing	share	VERB
cblr-5119	11	20	his	his	PRON
cblr-5119	11	21	insight	insight	NOUN
cblr-5119	11	22	during	during	ADP
cblr-5119	11	23	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	11	24	topic	topic	NOUN
cblr-5119	11	25	formulation	formulation	NOUN
cblr-5119	11	26	process	process	NOUN
cblr-5119	11	27	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	12	1	finally	finally	ADV
cblr-5119	12	2	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	12	3	many	many	ADJ
cblr-5119	12	4	thanks	thank	NOUN
cblr-5119	12	5	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	12	6	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	12	7	editorial	editorial	ADJ
cblr-5119	12	8	board	board	NOUN
cblr-5119	12	9	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	12	10	staff	staff	NOUN
cblr-5119	12	11	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	12	12	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	12	13	columbia	columbia	PROPN
cblr-5119	12	14	business	business	PROPN
cblr-5119	12	15	law	law	PROPN
cblr-5119	12	16	review	review	NOUN
cblr-5119	12	17	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	12	18	their	their	PRON
cblr-5119	12	19	diligent	diligent	ADJ
cblr-5119	12	20	work	work	NOUN
cblr-5119	12	21	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	12	22	preparing	prepare	VERB
cblr-5119	12	23	this	this	DET
cblr-5119	12	24	note	note	NOUN
cblr-5119	12	25	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	12	26	publication	publication	NOUN
cblr-5119	12	27	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	13	1	6_2019.3_estes	6_2019.3_estes	NUM
cblr-5119	13	2	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	13	3	do	do	AUX
cblr-5119	13	4	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	13	5	delte	delte	VERB
cblr-5119	13	6	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	13	7	12/26/2019	12/26/2019	NUM
cblr-5119	13	8	12:00	12:00	NUM
cblr-5119	13	9	am	am	NOUN
cblr-5119	13	10	1032	1032	NUM
cblr-5119	13	11	columbia	columbia	PROPN
cblr-5119	13	12	business	business	NOUN
cblr-5119	13	13	law	law	PROPN
cblr-5119	13	14	review	review	NOUN
cblr-5119	13	15	[	[	X
cblr-5119	13	16	vol	vol	NOUN
cblr-5119	13	17	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	13	18	2019	2019	NUM
cblr-5119	13	19	a.	a.	NOUN
cblr-5119	13	20	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	13	21	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	13	22	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	13	23	enactment	enactment	NOUN
cblr-5119	13	24	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	13	25	dormancy	dormancy	NOUN
cblr-5119	13	26	.................	.................	PUNCT
cblr-5119	14	1	1035	1035	NUM
cblr-5119	14	2	b.	b.	X
cblr-5119	14	3	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	14	4	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	14	5	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	14	6	reawakening	reawakening	NOUN
cblr-5119	14	7	.....................................	.....................................	PUNCT
cblr-5119	14	8	1039	1039	NUM
cblr-5119	14	9	c.	c.	NOUN
cblr-5119	14	10	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	14	11	supreme	supreme	PROPN
cblr-5119	14	12	court	court	PROPN
cblr-5119	14	13	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	14	14	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	14	15	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	14	16	........................	........................	PUNCT
cblr-5119	14	17	1041	1041	NUM
cblr-5119	14	18	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-5119	14	19	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	14	20	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	14	21	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	14	22	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	14	23	:	:	PUNCT
cblr-5119	14	24	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	14	25	narrowing	narrowing	NOUN
cblr-5119	14	26	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	14	27	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	14	28	scope	scope	NOUN
cblr-5119	14	29	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	14	30	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	14	31	...............................................	...............................................	PUNCT
cblr-5119	14	32	1043	1043	NUM
cblr-5119	14	33	1	1	NUM
cblr-5119	14	34	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	15	1	kiobel	kiobel	PROPN
cblr-5119	15	2	v.	v.	ADP
cblr-5119	15	3	royal	royal	PROPN
cblr-5119	15	4	dutch	dutch	PROPN
cblr-5119	15	5	petroleum	petroleum	NOUN
cblr-5119	15	6	co	co	NOUN
cblr-5119	15	7	..............	..............	PROPN
cblr-5119	15	8	1043	1043	NUM
cblr-5119	15	9	2	2	NUM
cblr-5119	15	10	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	16	1	jesner	jesner	PROPN
cblr-5119	16	2	v.	v.	PROPN
cblr-5119	16	3	arab	arab	PROPN
cblr-5119	16	4	bank	bank	PROPN
cblr-5119	16	5	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	16	6	plc	plc	PROPN
cblr-5119	16	7	.............................	.............................	PUNCT
cblr-5119	16	8	1047	1047	NUM
cblr-5119	16	9	iii	iii	NOUN
cblr-5119	16	10	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	16	11	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	16	12	approaches	approach	NOUN
cblr-5119	16	13	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	16	14	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	16	15	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	16	16	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	16	17	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	16	18	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	16	19	presumption	presumption	NOUN
cblr-5119	16	20	against	against	ADP
cblr-5119	16	21	extraterritoriality	extraterritoriality	NOUN
cblr-5119	16	22	................	................	PUNCT
cblr-5119	16	23	1050	1050	NUM
cblr-5119	16	24	a.	a.	NOUN
cblr-5119	16	25	second	second	ADJ
cblr-5119	16	26	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	16	27	:	:	PUNCT
cblr-5119	16	28	categorically	categorically	ADV
cblr-5119	16	29	against	against	ADP
cblr-5119	16	30	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	16	31	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	16	32	.............................................................	.............................................................	PUNCT
cblr-5119	16	33	1051	1051	NUM
cblr-5119	16	34	b.	b.	PROPN
cblr-5119	16	35	fourth	fourth	ADJ
cblr-5119	16	36	circuit	circuit	PROPN
cblr-5119	16	37	:	:	PUNCT
cblr-5119	16	38	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	16	39	flexible	flexible	ADJ
cblr-5119	16	40	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	16	41	fact	fact	NOUN
cblr-5119	16	42	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-5119	16	43	based	base	VERB
cblr-5119	16	44	approach	approach	NOUN
cblr-5119	16	45	...........................................................................	...........................................................................	PUNCT
cblr-5119	16	46	1056	1056	NUM
cblr-5119	17	1	c.	c.	PROPN
cblr-5119	17	2	ninth	ninth	ADJ
cblr-5119	17	3	circuit	circuit	PROPN
cblr-5119	17	4	:	:	PUNCT
cblr-5119	17	5	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	17	6	semi	semi	ADJ
cblr-5119	17	7	-	-	ADJ
cblr-5119	17	8	restrictive	restrictive	ADJ
cblr-5119	17	9	conduct	conduct	NOUN
cblr-5119	17	10	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-5119	17	11	based	base	VERB
cblr-5119	17	12	approach	approach	NOUN
cblr-5119	17	13	............................................................	............................................................	PUNCT
cblr-5119	17	14	1059	1059	NUM
cblr-5119	17	15	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-5119	17	16	eleventh	eleventh	PROPN
cblr-5119	17	17	circuit	circuit	PROPN
cblr-5119	17	18	:	:	PUNCT
cblr-5119	17	19	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	17	20	restrictive	restrictive	ADJ
cblr-5119	17	21	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	17	22	conduct	conduct	NOUN
cblr-5119	17	23	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-5119	17	24	based	base	VERB
cblr-5119	17	25	approach	approach	NOUN
cblr-5119	17	26	............................................................	............................................................	PUNCT
cblr-5119	17	27	1063	1063	NUM
cblr-5119	17	28	e.	e.	PROPN
cblr-5119	17	29	d.c	d.c	PROPN
cblr-5119	17	30	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	17	31	circuit	circuit	PROPN
cblr-5119	17	32	:	:	PUNCT
cblr-5119	17	33	hinting	hint	VERB
cblr-5119	17	34	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	17	35	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	17	36	semi	semi	ADJ
cblr-5119	17	37	-	-	ADJ
cblr-5119	17	38	permissive	permissive	ADJ
cblr-5119	17	39	approach	approach	NOUN
cblr-5119	17	40	............................................................	............................................................	PUNCT
cblr-5119	17	41	1066	1066	NUM
cblr-5119	17	42	iv	iv	X
cblr-5119	17	43	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	18	1	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	18	2	supreme	supreme	PROPN
cblr-5119	18	3	court	court	PROPN
cblr-5119	18	4	should	should	AUX
cblr-5119	18	5	adopt	adopt	VERB
cblr-5119	18	6	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	18	7	fourth	fourth	ADJ
cblr-5119	18	8	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	18	9	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	18	10	regime	regime	NOUN
cblr-5119	18	11	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	18	12	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	18	13	ats	at	NOUN
cblr-5119	18	14	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	18	15	........................	........................	PUNCT
cblr-5119	18	16	1069	1069	NUM
cblr-5119	18	17	a.	a.	NOUN
cblr-5119	18	18	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	18	19	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	18	20	is	be	AUX
cblr-5119	18	21	appropriate	appropriate	ADJ
cblr-5119	18	22	given	give	VERB
cblr-5119	18	23	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	18	24	relevant	relevant	ADJ
cblr-5119	18	25	legal	legal	ADJ
cblr-5119	18	26	considerations	consideration	NOUN
cblr-5119	18	27	.........................	.........................	PUNCT
cblr-5119	18	28	1071	1071	NUM
cblr-5119	18	29	b.	b.	X
cblr-5119	19	1	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	19	2	fourth	fourth	ADJ
cblr-5119	19	3	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	19	4	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	19	5	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	19	6	regime	regime	NOUN
cblr-5119	19	7	best	well	ADV
cblr-5119	19	8	accommodates	accommodate	VERB
cblr-5119	19	9	all	all	DET
cblr-5119	19	10	stakeholders	stakeholder	NOUN
cblr-5119	19	11	.......................	.......................	PUNCT
cblr-5119	19	12	1075	1075	NUM
cblr-5119	19	13	c.	c.	NOUN
cblr-5119	19	14	adopting	adopt	VERB
cblr-5119	19	15	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	19	16	fourth	fourth	ADJ
cblr-5119	19	17	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	19	18	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	19	19	regime	regime	NOUN
cblr-5119	19	20	will	will	AUX
cblr-5119	19	21	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	19	22	inflame	inflame	VERB
cblr-5119	19	23	foreign	foreign	ADJ
cblr-5119	19	24	tensions	tension	NOUN
cblr-5119	19	25	..................................	..................................	PUNCT
cblr-5119	19	26	1078	1078	NUM
cblr-5119	19	27	v.	v.	ADP
cblr-5119	19	28	conclusion	conclusion	NOUN
cblr-5119	19	29	.....................................................................	.....................................................................	PUNCT
cblr-5119	19	30	1082	1082	NUM
cblr-5119	19	31	i.	i.	PROPN
cblr-5119	19	32	introduction	introduction	NOUN
cblr-5119	19	33	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	19	34	prospect	prospect	NOUN
cblr-5119	19	35	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	19	36	lawsuits	lawsuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	19	37	against	against	ADP
cblr-5119	19	38	companies	company	NOUN
cblr-5119	19	39	resulting	result	VERB
cblr-5119	19	40	from	from	ADP
cblr-5119	19	41	their	their	PRON
cblr-5119	19	42	business	business	NOUN
cblr-5119	19	43	operations	operation	NOUN
cblr-5119	19	44	is	be	AUX
cblr-5119	19	45	hardly	hardly	ADV
cblr-5119	19	46	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	19	47	novel	novel	ADJ
cblr-5119	19	48	development	development	NOUN
cblr-5119	19	49	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	20	1	but	but	CCONJ
cblr-5119	20	2	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	20	3	recent	recent	ADJ
cblr-5119	20	4	years	year	NOUN
cblr-5119	20	5	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	20	6	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	20	7	class	class	NOUN
cblr-5119	20	8	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	20	9	disputes	dispute	NOUN
cblr-5119	20	10	has	have	AUX
cblr-5119	20	11	arisen	arise	VERB
cblr-5119	20	12	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	20	13	response	response	NOUN
cblr-5119	20	14	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	20	15	international	international	ADJ
cblr-5119	20	16	business	business	NOUN
cblr-5119	20	17	activities	activity	NOUN
cblr-5119	20	18	that	that	PRON
cblr-5119	20	19	truly	truly	ADV
cblr-5119	20	20	shock	shock	VERB
cblr-5119	20	21	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	20	22	conscience	conscience	NOUN
cblr-5119	20	23	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	21	1	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	21	2	illustrate	illustrate	VERB
cblr-5119	21	3	:	:	PUNCT
cblr-5119	21	4	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	21	5	indonesia	indonesia	PROPN
cblr-5119	21	6	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	21	7	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	21	8	prominent	prominent	ADJ
cblr-5119	21	9	oil	oil	NOUN
cblr-5119	21	10	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	21	11	gas	gas	NOUN
cblr-5119	21	12	giant	giant	NOUN
cblr-5119	21	13	allegedly	allegedly	ADV
cblr-5119	21	14	aided	aid	VERB
cblr-5119	21	15	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	21	16	indonesian	indonesian	ADJ
cblr-5119	21	17	military	military	NOUN
cblr-5119	21	18	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	21	19	murdering	murder	VERB
cblr-5119	21	20	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	21	21	torturing	torture	VERB
cblr-5119	21	22	local	local	ADJ
cblr-5119	21	23	villagers	villager	NOUN
cblr-5119	21	24	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	21	25	order	order	NOUN
cblr-5119	21	26	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	21	27	protect	protect	VERB
cblr-5119	21	28	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	21	29	6_2019.3_estes	6_2019.3_este	NOUN
cblr-5119	21	30	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	21	31	do	do	AUX
cblr-5119	21	32	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	21	33	delete	delete	VERB
cblr-5119	21	34	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	21	35	12/26/2019	12/26/2019	NUM
cblr-5119	21	36	12:00	12:00	NUM
cblr-5119	21	37	am	be	AUX
cblr-5119	21	38	no	no	NOUN
cblr-5119	21	39	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	22	1	3:1031	3:1031	NUM
cblr-5119	22	2	]	]	X
cblr-5119	22	3	may	may	AUX
cblr-5119	22	4	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	22	5	fourth	fourth	ADJ
cblr-5119	22	6	be	be	AUX
cblr-5119	22	7	with	with	ADP
cblr-5119	22	8	you	you	PRON
cblr-5119	22	9	1033	1033	NUM
cblr-5119	22	10	company	company	NOUN
cblr-5119	22	11	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	22	12	natural	natural	ADJ
cblr-5119	22	13	gas	gas	NOUN
cblr-5119	22	14	extraction	extraction	NOUN
cblr-5119	22	15	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	22	16	processing	processing	NOUN
cblr-5119	22	17	facility;1	facility;1	NOUN
cblr-5119	22	18	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	22	19	colombia	colombia	PROPN
cblr-5119	22	20	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	22	21	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	22	22	supranational	supranational	ADJ
cblr-5119	22	23	coal	coal	NOUN
cblr-5119	22	24	company	company	NOUN
cblr-5119	22	25	allegedly	allegedly	ADV
cblr-5119	22	26	used	use	VERB
cblr-5119	22	27	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	22	28	local	local	ADJ
cblr-5119	22	29	paramilitary	paramilitary	ADJ
cblr-5119	22	30	organization	organization	NOUN
cblr-5119	22	31	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	22	32	carry	carry	VERB
cblr-5119	22	33	out	out	ADP
cblr-5119	22	34	extrajudicial	extrajudicial	ADJ
cblr-5119	22	35	killings	killing	NOUN
cblr-5119	22	36	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	22	37	war	war	NOUN
cblr-5119	22	38	crimes	crime	NOUN
cblr-5119	22	39	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	22	40	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	22	41	crimes	crime	NOUN
cblr-5119	22	42	against	against	ADP
cblr-5119	22	43	humanity	humanity	NOUN
cblr-5119	22	44	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	22	45	order	order	NOUN
cblr-5119	22	46	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	22	47	protect	protect	VERB
cblr-5119	22	48	its	its	PRON
cblr-5119	22	49	local	local	ADJ
cblr-5119	22	50	mining	mining	NOUN
cblr-5119	22	51	operation;2	operation;2	PROPN
cblr-5119	22	52	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	22	53	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	22	54	iraq	iraq	PROPN
cblr-5119	22	55	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	22	56	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	22	57	military	military	ADJ
cblr-5119	22	58	contractor	contractor	NOUN
cblr-5119	22	59	allegedly	allegedly	ADV
cblr-5119	22	60	helped	help	VERB
cblr-5119	22	61	torture	torture	VERB
cblr-5119	22	62	iraqi	iraqi	ADJ
cblr-5119	22	63	prisoners	prisoner	NOUN
cblr-5119	22	64	as	as	ADP
cblr-5119	22	65	part	part	NOUN
cblr-5119	22	66	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	22	67	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	22	68	globally	globally	ADV
cblr-5119	22	69	condemned	condemn	VERB
cblr-5119	22	70	abu	abu	PROPN
cblr-5119	22	71	ghraib	ghraib	PROPN
cblr-5119	22	72	prison	prison	NOUN
cblr-5119	22	73	scandal.3	scandal.3	PROPN
cblr-5119	22	74	these	these	PRON
cblr-5119	22	75	are	be	AUX
cblr-5119	22	76	just	just	ADV
cblr-5119	22	77	several	several	ADJ
cblr-5119	22	78	examples	example	NOUN
cblr-5119	22	79	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	22	80	lawsuits	lawsuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	22	81	that	that	PRON
cblr-5119	22	82	have	have	AUX
cblr-5119	22	83	proceeded	proceed	VERB
cblr-5119	22	84	under	under	ADP
cblr-5119	22	85	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	22	86	alien	alien	PROPN
cblr-5119	22	87	tort	tort	NOUN
cblr-5119	22	88	statute	statute	NOUN
cblr-5119	22	89	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	22	90	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	22	91	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	22	92	ats”)4	ats”)4	PROPN
cblr-5119	22	93	against	against	ADP
cblr-5119	22	94	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	22	95	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	23	1	once	once	ADV
cblr-5119	23	2	dormant	dormant	ADJ
cblr-5119	23	3	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	23	4	close	close	ADJ
cblr-5119	23	5	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	23	6	200	200	NUM
cblr-5119	23	7	years	year	NOUN
cblr-5119	23	8	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	23	9	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	23	10	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	23	11	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	23	12	also	also	ADV
cblr-5119	23	13	referred	refer	VERB
cblr-5119	23	14	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	23	15	as	as	ADP
cblr-5119	23	16	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	23	17	alien	alien	ADJ
cblr-5119	23	18	tort	tort	NOUN
cblr-5119	23	19	claims	claim	NOUN
cblr-5119	23	20	act	act	PROPN
cblr-5119	23	21	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	23	22	has	have	AUX
cblr-5119	23	23	been	be	AUX
cblr-5119	23	24	reinvigorated	reinvigorate	VERB
cblr-5119	23	25	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	23	26	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	23	27	modern	modern	ADJ
cblr-5119	23	28	era	era	NOUN
cblr-5119	23	29	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	24	1	foreign	foreign	ADJ
cblr-5119	24	2	victims	victim	NOUN
cblr-5119	24	3	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	24	4	egregious	egregious	ADJ
cblr-5119	24	5	human	human	ADJ
cblr-5119	24	6	rights	right	NOUN
cblr-5119	24	7	abuses	abuse	NOUN
cblr-5119	24	8	committed	commit	VERB
cblr-5119	24	9	abroad5	abroad5	PROPN
cblr-5119	24	10	have	have	AUX
cblr-5119	24	11	invoked	invoke	VERB
cblr-5119	24	12	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	24	13	statute	statute	NOUN
cblr-5119	24	14	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	24	15	order	order	NOUN
cblr-5119	24	16	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	24	17	sue	sue	VERB
cblr-5119	24	18	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	24	19	perpetrators	perpetrator	NOUN
cblr-5119	24	20	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	24	21	said	say	VERB
cblr-5119	24	22	abuses	abuse	NOUN
cblr-5119	24	23	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	24	24	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	24	25	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	24	26	federal	federal	ADJ
cblr-5119	24	27	courts	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	24	28	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	25	1	like	like	SCONJ
cblr-5119	25	2	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	25	3	suits	suit	NOUN
cblr-5119	25	4	referenced	reference	VERB
cblr-5119	25	5	above	above	ADV
cblr-5119	25	6	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	25	7	many	many	ADJ
cblr-5119	25	8	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	25	9	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	25	10	most	most	ADV
cblr-5119	25	11	high	high	ADJ
cblr-5119	25	12	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-5119	25	13	profile	profile	NOUN
cblr-5119	25	14	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	25	15	these	these	DET
cblr-5119	25	16	cases	case	NOUN
cblr-5119	25	17	involve	involve	VERB
cblr-5119	25	18	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	25	19	defendants	defendant	NOUN
cblr-5119	25	20	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	26	1	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	26	2	prospect	prospect	NOUN
cblr-5119	26	3	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	26	4	businesses	business	NOUN
cblr-5119	26	5	engaging	engage	VERB
cblr-5119	26	6	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	26	7	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	26	8	type	type	NOUN
cblr-5119	26	9	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	26	10	appalling	appalling	ADJ
cblr-5119	26	11	behavior	behavior	NOUN
cblr-5119	26	12	that	that	PRON
cblr-5119	26	13	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	26	14	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	26	15	contemplates	contemplate	VERB
cblr-5119	26	16	attracts	attract	VERB
cblr-5119	26	17	significant	significant	ADJ
cblr-5119	26	18	public	public	ADJ
cblr-5119	26	19	attention	attention	NOUN
cblr-5119	26	20	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	26	21	as	as	SCONJ
cblr-5119	26	22	does	do	VERB
cblr-5119	26	23	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	26	24	controversial	controversial	ADJ
cblr-5119	26	25	fact	fact	NOUN
cblr-5119	26	26	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	26	27	some	some	DET
cblr-5119	26	28	cases	case	NOUN
cblr-5119	26	29	have	have	AUX
cblr-5119	26	30	involved	involve	VERB
cblr-5119	26	31	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	26	32	foreign	foreign	ADJ
cblr-5119	26	33	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
cblr-5119	26	34	suing	sue	VERB
cblr-5119	26	35	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	26	36	foreign	foreign	ADJ
cblr-5119	26	37	corporation	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	26	38	over	over	ADP
cblr-5119	26	39	extraterritorial	extraterritorial	ADJ
cblr-5119	26	40	conduct	conduct	NOUN
cblr-5119	26	41	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	27	1	these	these	DET
cblr-5119	27	2	developments	development	NOUN
cblr-5119	27	3	render	render	VERB
cblr-5119	27	4	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	27	5	ats	at	NOUN
cblr-5119	27	6	an	an	DET
cblr-5119	27	7	intriguing	intriguing	ADJ
cblr-5119	27	8	subject	subject	NOUN
cblr-5119	27	9	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	28	1	this	this	PRON
cblr-5119	28	2	is	be	AUX
cblr-5119	28	3	especially	especially	ADV
cblr-5119	28	4	true	true	ADJ
cblr-5119	28	5	because	because	SCONJ
cblr-5119	28	6	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	28	7	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	28	8	stands	stand	VERB
cblr-5119	28	9	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	28	10	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	28	11	intersection	intersection	NOUN
cblr-5119	28	12	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	28	13	business	business	NOUN
cblr-5119	28	14	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	28	15	human	human	ADJ
cblr-5119	28	16	rights	right	NOUN
cblr-5119	28	17	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	28	18	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	28	19	rapidly	rapidly	ADV
cblr-5119	28	20	growing	grow	VERB
cblr-5119	28	21	legal	legal	ADJ
cblr-5119	28	22	field	field	NOUN
cblr-5119	28	23	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	28	24	study.6	study.6	NOUN
cblr-5119	28	25	however	however	ADV
cblr-5119	28	26	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	28	27	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	28	28	last	last	ADJ
cblr-5119	28	29	decade	decade	NOUN
cblr-5119	28	30	has	have	AUX
cblr-5119	28	31	seen	see	VERB
cblr-5119	28	32	significant	significant	ADJ
cblr-5119	28	33	pushback	pushback	NOUN
cblr-5119	28	34	on	on	ADP
cblr-5119	28	35	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	28	36	idea	idea	NOUN
cblr-5119	28	37	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	28	38	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	28	39	are	be	AUX
cblr-5119	28	40	liable	liable	ADJ
cblr-5119	28	41	under	under	ADP
cblr-5119	28	42	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	28	43	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	28	44	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	29	1	first	first	ADV
cblr-5119	29	2	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	29	3	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	29	4	1	1	NUM
cblr-5119	29	5	doe	doe	NOUN
cblr-5119	29	6	v.	v.	ADP
cblr-5119	29	7	exxon	exxon	PROPN
cblr-5119	29	8	mobil	mobil	PROPN
cblr-5119	29	9	corp	corp	PROPN
cblr-5119	29	10	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	29	11	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	29	12	654	654	NUM
cblr-5119	29	13	f.3d	f.3d	NUM
cblr-5119	29	14	11	11	NUM
cblr-5119	29	15	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	29	16	14–15	14–15	NUM
cblr-5119	29	17	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	29	18	d.c	d.c	PROPN
cblr-5119	29	19	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	29	20	cir	cir	PROPN
cblr-5119	29	21	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	29	22	2011	2011	NUM
cblr-5119	29	23	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	29	24	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	29	25	vacated	vacate	VERB
cblr-5119	29	26	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	29	27	527	527	NUM
cblr-5119	29	28	f.	f.	PROPN
cblr-5119	29	29	app’x	app’x	PROPN
cblr-5119	29	30	7	7	NUM
cblr-5119	29	31	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	29	32	d.c	d.c	PROPN
cblr-5119	29	33	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	29	34	cir	cir	PROPN
cblr-5119	29	35	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	29	36	2013	2013	NUM
cblr-5119	29	37	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	29	38	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	30	1	2	2	NUM
cblr-5119	30	2	romero	romero	PROPN
cblr-5119	30	3	v.	v.	PROPN
cblr-5119	30	4	drummond	drummond	PROPN
cblr-5119	30	5	co.	co.	PROPN
cblr-5119	30	6	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	30	7	552	552	NUM
cblr-5119	30	8	f.3d	f.3d	NUM
cblr-5119	30	9	1303	1303	NUM
cblr-5119	30	10	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	30	11	1308–09	1308–09	NUM
cblr-5119	30	12	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	30	13	11th	11th	ADJ
cblr-5119	30	14	cir	cir	NOUN
cblr-5119	30	15	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	30	16	2008	2008	NUM
cblr-5119	30	17	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	30	18	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	31	1	3	3	NUM
cblr-5119	31	2	al	al	PROPN
cblr-5119	31	3	shimari	shimari	PROPN
cblr-5119	31	4	v.	v.	ADP
cblr-5119	31	5	caci	caci	NOUN
cblr-5119	31	6	premier	premier	PROPN
cblr-5119	31	7	tech	tech	PROPN
cblr-5119	31	8	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	31	9	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	31	10	inc	inc	PROPN
cblr-5119	31	11	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	31	12	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	31	13	758	758	NUM
cblr-5119	31	14	f.3d	f.3d	NUM
cblr-5119	31	15	516	516	NUM
cblr-5119	31	16	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	31	17	520	520	NUM
cblr-5119	31	18	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	31	19	4th	4th	ADJ
cblr-5119	31	20	cir	cir	NOUN
cblr-5119	31	21	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	31	22	2014	2014	NUM
cblr-5119	31	23	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	31	24	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	32	1	4	4	NUM
cblr-5119	32	2	alien	alien	PROPN
cblr-5119	32	3	tort	tort	NOUN
cblr-5119	32	4	statute	statute	NOUN
cblr-5119	32	5	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	32	6	28	28	NUM
cblr-5119	32	7	u.s.c	u.s.c	ADJ
cblr-5119	32	8	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	33	1	§	§	PROPN
cblr-5119	33	2	1350	1350	NUM
cblr-5119	33	3	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	33	4	2012	2012	NUM
cblr-5119	33	5	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	33	6	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	34	1	5	5	NUM
cblr-5119	34	2	while	while	SCONJ
cblr-5119	34	3	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	34	4	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	34	5	does	do	AUX
cblr-5119	34	6	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	34	7	require	require	VERB
cblr-5119	34	8	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	34	9	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	34	10	underlying	underlie	VERB
cblr-5119	34	11	tort	tort	NOUN
cblr-5119	34	12	be	be	AUX
cblr-5119	34	13	committed	commit	VERB
cblr-5119	34	14	abroad	abroad	ADV
cblr-5119	34	15	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	34	16	it	it	PRON
cblr-5119	34	17	appears	appear	VERB
cblr-5119	34	18	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	34	19	there	there	PRON
cblr-5119	34	20	has	have	AUX
cblr-5119	34	21	been	be	AUX
cblr-5119	34	22	no	no	DET
cblr-5119	34	23	modern	modern	ADJ
cblr-5119	34	24	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	34	25	case	case	NOUN
cblr-5119	34	26	involving	involve	VERB
cblr-5119	34	27	only	only	ADV
cblr-5119	34	28	domestic	domestic	ADJ
cblr-5119	34	29	tortious	tortious	ADJ
cblr-5119	34	30	conduct	conduct	NOUN
cblr-5119	34	31	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	35	1	see	see	VERB
cblr-5119	35	2	gregory	gregory	PROPN
cblr-5119	35	3	h.	h.	PROPN
cblr-5119	35	4	fox	fox	PROPN
cblr-5119	35	5	&	&	CCONJ
cblr-5119	35	6	yunjoo	yunjoo	PROPN
cblr-5119	35	7	goze	goze	PROPN
cblr-5119	35	8	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	35	9	international	international	ADJ
cblr-5119	35	10	human	human	ADJ
cblr-5119	35	11	rights	right	NOUN
cblr-5119	35	12	litigation	litigation	NOUN
cblr-5119	35	13	after	after	ADP
cblr-5119	35	14	kiobel	kiobel	NOUN
cblr-5119	35	15	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	35	16	mich	mich	PROPN
cblr-5119	36	1	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	36	2	b.	b.	PROPN
cblr-5119	36	3	j.	j.	PROPN
cblr-5119	36	4	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	36	5	nov	nov	PROPN
cblr-5119	36	6	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	36	7	2013	2013	NUM
cblr-5119	36	8	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	36	9	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	36	10	45	45	NUM
cblr-5119	36	11	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	36	12	2013	2013	NUM
cblr-5119	36	13	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	36	14	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	36	15	describing	describe	VERB
cblr-5119	36	16	two	two	NUM
cblr-5119	36	17	classes	class	NOUN
cblr-5119	36	18	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	36	19	modern	modern	ADJ
cblr-5119	36	20	ats	at	NOUN
cblr-5119	36	21	cases	case	NOUN
cblr-5119	36	22	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	36	23	both	both	PRON
cblr-5119	36	24	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	36	25	which	which	PRON
cblr-5119	36	26	involve	involve	VERB
cblr-5119	36	27	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	36	28	least	least	ADJ
cblr-5119	36	29	some	some	DET
cblr-5119	36	30	extraterritorial	extraterritorial	ADJ
cblr-5119	36	31	conduct	conduct	NOUN
cblr-5119	36	32	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	36	33	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	37	1	6	6	NUM
cblr-5119	37	2	see	see	VERB
cblr-5119	37	3	jena	jena	PROPN
cblr-5119	37	4	martin	martin	PROPN
cblr-5119	37	5	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	37	6	business	business	NOUN
cblr-5119	37	7	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	37	8	human	human	ADJ
cblr-5119	37	9	rights	right	NOUN
cblr-5119	37	10	:	:	PUNCT
cblr-5119	37	11	what	what	PRON
cblr-5119	37	12	’s	’s	AUX
cblr-5119	37	13	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	37	14	board	board	NOUN
cblr-5119	37	15	got	get	VERB
cblr-5119	37	16	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	37	17	do	do	VERB
cblr-5119	37	18	with	with	ADP
cblr-5119	37	19	it	it	PRON
cblr-5119	37	20	?	?	PUNCT
cblr-5119	37	21	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	37	22	2013	2013	NUM
cblr-5119	37	23	u.	u.	PROPN
cblr-5119	37	24	ill	ill	PROPN
cblr-5119	37	25	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	38	1	l.	l.	PROPN
cblr-5119	38	2	rev	rev	PROPN
cblr-5119	38	3	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	38	4	959	959	NUM
cblr-5119	38	5	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	38	6	977	977	NUM
cblr-5119	38	7	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	38	8	2013	2013	NUM
cblr-5119	38	9	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	38	10	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	39	1	6_2019.3_estes	6_2019.3_estes	NUM
cblr-5119	39	2	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	39	3	do	do	AUX
cblr-5119	39	4	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	39	5	delte	delte	VERB
cblr-5119	39	6	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	39	7	12/26/2019	12/26/2019	NUM
cblr-5119	39	8	12:00	12:00	NUM
cblr-5119	39	9	am	am	NOUN
cblr-5119	39	10	1034	1034	NUM
cblr-5119	39	11	columbia	columbia	PROPN
cblr-5119	39	12	business	business	NOUN
cblr-5119	39	13	law	law	PROPN
cblr-5119	39	14	review	review	NOUN
cblr-5119	39	15	[	[	X
cblr-5119	39	16	vol	vol	NOUN
cblr-5119	39	17	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	39	18	2019	2019	NUM
cblr-5119	39	19	second	second	ADJ
cblr-5119	39	20	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	39	21	held	hold	VERB
cblr-5119	39	22	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	39	23	kiobel	kiobel	PROPN
cblr-5119	39	24	v.	v.	ADP
cblr-5119	39	25	royal	royal	PROPN
cblr-5119	39	26	dutch	dutch	PROPN
cblr-5119	39	27	petroleum	petroleum	PROPN
cblr-5119	39	28	co.	co.	PROPN
cblr-5119	39	29	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	39	30	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	39	31	can	can	AUX
cblr-5119	39	32	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	39	33	be	be	AUX
cblr-5119	39	34	sued	sue	VERB
cblr-5119	39	35	under	under	ADP
cblr-5119	39	36	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	39	37	ats.7	ats.7	PROPN
cblr-5119	39	38	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	39	39	supreme	supreme	PROPN
cblr-5119	39	40	court	court	PROPN
cblr-5119	39	41	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	39	42	grant	grant	NOUN
cblr-5119	39	43	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	39	44	certiorari	certiorari	NOUN
cblr-5119	39	45	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	39	46	that	that	DET
cblr-5119	39	47	case	case	NOUN
cblr-5119	39	48	was	be	AUX
cblr-5119	39	49	supposed	suppose	VERB
cblr-5119	39	50	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	39	51	decide	decide	VERB
cblr-5119	39	52	whether	whether	SCONJ
cblr-5119	39	53	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	39	54	categorically	categorically	ADV
cblr-5119	39	55	were	be	AUX
cblr-5119	39	56	or	or	CCONJ
cblr-5119	39	57	were	be	AUX
cblr-5119	39	58	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	39	59	liable	liable	ADJ
cblr-5119	39	60	under	under	ADP
cblr-5119	39	61	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	39	62	ats	at	NOUN
cblr-5119	39	63	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	39	64	but	but	CCONJ
cblr-5119	39	65	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	39	66	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	39	67	instead	instead	ADV
cblr-5119	39	68	held	hold	VERB
cblr-5119	39	69	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	39	70	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	39	71	presumption	presumption	NOUN
cblr-5119	39	72	against	against	ADP
cblr-5119	39	73	extraterritoriality	extraterritoriality	NOUN
cblr-5119	39	74	applies	apply	VERB
cblr-5119	39	75	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	39	76	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	39	77	ats.8	ats.8	PROPN
cblr-5119	39	78	this	this	PRON
cblr-5119	39	79	led	lead	VERB
cblr-5119	39	80	several	several	ADJ
cblr-5119	39	81	circuits	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	39	82	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	39	83	constrain	constrain	VERB
cblr-5119	39	84	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	39	85	conditions	condition	NOUN
cblr-5119	39	86	under	under	ADP
cblr-5119	39	87	which	which	PRON
cblr-5119	39	88	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
cblr-5119	39	89	could	could	AUX
cblr-5119	39	90	sue	sue	VERB
cblr-5119	39	91	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	39	92	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	40	1	then	then	ADV
cblr-5119	40	2	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	40	3	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	40	4	2018	2018	NUM
cblr-5119	40	5	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	40	6	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	40	7	supreme	supreme	PROPN
cblr-5119	40	8	court	court	PROPN
cblr-5119	40	9	again	again	ADV
cblr-5119	40	10	took	take	VERB
cblr-5119	40	11	up	up	ADP
cblr-5119	40	12	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	40	13	issue	issue	NOUN
cblr-5119	40	14	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	40	15	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	40	16	ats	at	NOUN
cblr-5119	40	17	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	40	18	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	40	19	jesner	jesner	PROPN
cblr-5119	40	20	v.	v.	PROPN
cblr-5119	40	21	arab	arab	PROPN
cblr-5119	40	22	bank	bank	PROPN
cblr-5119	40	23	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	40	24	plc	plc	PROPN
cblr-5119	40	25	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	40	26	only	only	ADV
cblr-5119	40	27	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	40	28	again	again	ADV
cblr-5119	40	29	avoid	avoid	VERB
cblr-5119	40	30	making	make	VERB
cblr-5119	40	31	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	40	32	categorical	categorical	ADJ
cblr-5119	40	33	ruling	ruling	NOUN
cblr-5119	40	34	on	on	ADP
cblr-5119	40	35	general	general	ADJ
cblr-5119	40	36	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	40	37	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	40	38	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	41	1	instead	instead	ADV
cblr-5119	41	2	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	41	3	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	41	4	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	41	5	held	hold	VERB
cblr-5119	41	6	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	41	7	foreign	foreign	ADJ
cblr-5119	41	8	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	41	9	were	be	AUX
cblr-5119	41	10	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	41	11	liable	liable	ADJ
cblr-5119	41	12	under	under	ADP
cblr-5119	41	13	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	41	14	ats.9	ats.9	NOUN
cblr-5119	41	15	while	while	SCONJ
cblr-5119	41	16	jesner	jesner	NOUN
cblr-5119	41	17	implicitly	implicitly	ADV
cblr-5119	41	18	recognized	recognize	VERB
cblr-5119	41	19	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	41	20	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	41	21	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	41	22	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	41	23	could	could	AUX
cblr-5119	41	24	continue	continue	VERB
cblr-5119	41	25	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	41	26	be	be	AUX
cblr-5119	41	27	sued	sue	VERB
cblr-5119	41	28	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	41	29	those	those	DET
cblr-5119	41	30	circuits	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	41	31	that	that	PRON
cblr-5119	41	32	recognize	recognize	VERB
cblr-5119	41	33	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	41	34	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	41	35	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	41	36	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	41	37	overall	overall	ADJ
cblr-5119	41	38	effect	effect	NOUN
cblr-5119	41	39	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	41	40	these	these	DET
cblr-5119	41	41	holdings	holding	NOUN
cblr-5119	41	42	has	have	AUX
cblr-5119	41	43	been	be	AUX
cblr-5119	41	44	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	41	45	significantly	significantly	ADV
cblr-5119	41	46	narrow	narrow	VERB
cblr-5119	41	47	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	41	48	scope	scope	NOUN
cblr-5119	41	49	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	41	50	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	41	51	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	41	52	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	42	1	with	with	ADP
cblr-5119	42	2	circuits	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	42	3	differing	differ	VERB
cblr-5119	42	4	on	on	ADP
cblr-5119	42	5	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	42	6	issues	issue	NOUN
cblr-5119	42	7	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	42	8	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	42	9	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	42	10	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	42	11	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	42	12	conditions	condition	NOUN
cblr-5119	42	13	necessary	necessary	ADJ
cblr-5119	42	14	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	42	15	rebut	rebut	VERB
cblr-5119	42	16	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	42	17	presumption	presumption	NOUN
cblr-5119	42	18	against	against	ADP
cblr-5119	42	19	extraterritoriality	extraterritoriality	NOUN
cblr-5119	42	20	as	as	SCONJ
cblr-5119	42	21	applied	apply	VERB
cblr-5119	42	22	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	42	23	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	42	24	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	42	25	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	42	26	present	present	ADJ
cblr-5119	42	27	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	42	28	future	future	NOUN
cblr-5119	42	29	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	42	30	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	42	31	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	42	32	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	42	33	’	'	PUNCT
cblr-5119	42	34	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	42	35	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	42	36	is	be	AUX
cblr-5119	42	37	uncertain	uncertain	ADJ
cblr-5119	42	38	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	43	1	this	this	DET
cblr-5119	43	2	note	note	NOUN
cblr-5119	43	3	argues	argue	VERB
cblr-5119	43	4	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	43	5	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	43	6	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	43	7	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	43	8	should	should	AUX
cblr-5119	43	9	be	be	AUX
cblr-5119	43	10	recognized	recognize	VERB
cblr-5119	43	11	as	as	ADP
cblr-5119	43	12	liable	liable	ADJ
cblr-5119	43	13	under	under	ADP
cblr-5119	43	14	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	43	15	ats	at	NOUN
cblr-5119	43	16	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	43	17	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	43	18	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	43	19	fourth	fourth	ADJ
cblr-5119	43	20	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	43	21	offers	offer	VERB
cblr-5119	43	22	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	43	23	most	most	ADV
cblr-5119	43	24	appropriate	appropriate	ADJ
cblr-5119	43	25	analytical	analytical	ADJ
cblr-5119	43	26	framework	framework	NOUN
cblr-5119	43	27	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	43	28	evaluate	evaluate	VERB
cblr-5119	43	29	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	43	30	ats	at	NOUN
cblr-5119	43	31	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	43	32	going	go	VERB
cblr-5119	43	33	forward	forward	ADV
cblr-5119	43	34	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	44	1	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	44	2	fourth	fourth	ADJ
cblr-5119	44	3	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	44	4	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	44	5	approach	approach	NOUN
cblr-5119	44	6	best	good	ADJ
cblr-5119	44	7	addresses	address	NOUN
cblr-5119	44	8	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	44	9	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	44	10	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	44	11	presumption	presumption	NOUN
cblr-5119	44	12	against	against	ADP
cblr-5119	44	13	exterritoriality	exterritoriality	NOUN
cblr-5119	44	14	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	44	15	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	44	16	concerns	concern	NOUN
cblr-5119	44	17	voiced	voice	VERB
cblr-5119	44	18	by	by	ADP
cblr-5119	44	19	jesner	jesner	NOUN
cblr-5119	44	20	while	while	SCONJ
cblr-5119	44	21	simultaneously	simultaneously	ADV
cblr-5119	44	22	holding	hold	VERB
cblr-5119	44	23	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	44	24	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	44	25	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	44	26	accountable	accountable	ADJ
cblr-5119	44	27	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	44	28	their	their	PRON
cblr-5119	44	29	complicity	complicity	NOUN
cblr-5119	44	30	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	44	31	inflicting	inflict	VERB
cblr-5119	44	32	human	human	ADJ
cblr-5119	44	33	rights	right	NOUN
cblr-5119	44	34	abuses	abuse	NOUN
cblr-5119	44	35	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	45	1	given	give	VERB
cblr-5119	45	2	7	7	NUM
cblr-5119	45	3	kiobel	kiobel	NOUN
cblr-5119	45	4	v.	v.	ADP
cblr-5119	45	5	royal	royal	PROPN
cblr-5119	45	6	dutch	dutch	PROPN
cblr-5119	45	7	petroleum	petroleum	PROPN
cblr-5119	45	8	co.	co.	PROPN
cblr-5119	45	9	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	45	10	621	621	NUM
cblr-5119	45	11	f.3d	f.3d	NUM
cblr-5119	45	12	111	111	NUM
cblr-5119	45	13	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	45	14	120	120	NUM
cblr-5119	45	15	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	45	16	2d	2d	NUM
cblr-5119	45	17	cir	cir	NOUN
cblr-5119	45	18	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	45	19	2010	2010	NUM
cblr-5119	45	20	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	45	21	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	45	22	aff’d	aff’d	VERB
cblr-5119	45	23	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	45	24	569	569	NUM
cblr-5119	45	25	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	45	26	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	45	27	108	108	NUM
cblr-5119	45	28	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	45	29	2013	2013	NUM
cblr-5119	45	30	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	45	31	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	46	1	8	8	NUM
cblr-5119	46	2	kiobel	kiobel	NOUN
cblr-5119	46	3	v.	v.	ADP
cblr-5119	46	4	royal	royal	PROPN
cblr-5119	46	5	dutch	dutch	PROPN
cblr-5119	46	6	petroleum	petroleum	PROPN
cblr-5119	46	7	co.	co.	PROPN
cblr-5119	46	8	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	46	9	569	569	NUM
cblr-5119	46	10	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	46	11	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	46	12	108	108	NUM
cblr-5119	46	13	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	46	14	124	124	NUM
cblr-5119	46	15	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	46	16	2013	2013	NUM
cblr-5119	46	17	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	46	18	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	47	1	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	47	2	presumption	presumption	NOUN
cblr-5119	47	3	against	against	ADP
cblr-5119	47	4	extraterritoriality	extraterritoriality	NOUN
cblr-5119	47	5	is	be	AUX
cblr-5119	47	6	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	47	7	canon	canon	NOUN
cblr-5119	47	8	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	47	9	statutory	statutory	ADJ
cblr-5119	47	10	construction	construction	NOUN
cblr-5119	47	11	whereby	whereby	SCONJ
cblr-5119	47	12	it	it	PRON
cblr-5119	47	13	is	be	AUX
cblr-5119	47	14	assumed	assume	VERB
cblr-5119	47	15	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	47	16	federal	federal	ADJ
cblr-5119	47	17	legislation	legislation	NOUN
cblr-5119	47	18	does	do	AUX
cblr-5119	47	19	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	47	20	reach	reach	VERB
cblr-5119	47	21	extraterritorial	extraterritorial	ADJ
cblr-5119	47	22	conduct	conduct	NOUN
cblr-5119	47	23	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	47	24	unless	unless	SCONJ
cblr-5119	47	25	it	it	PRON
cblr-5119	47	26	is	be	AUX
cblr-5119	47	27	clear	clear	ADJ
cblr-5119	47	28	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	47	29	congress	congress	PROPN
cblr-5119	47	30	intended	intend	VERB
cblr-5119	47	31	otherwise	otherwise	ADV
cblr-5119	47	32	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	48	1	morrison	morrison	PROPN
cblr-5119	48	2	v.	v.	PROPN
cblr-5119	48	3	nat’l	nat’l	PROPN
cblr-5119	48	4	australia	australia	PROPN
cblr-5119	48	5	bank	bank	PROPN
cblr-5119	48	6	ltd	ltd	PROPN
cblr-5119	48	7	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	48	8	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	48	9	561	561	NUM
cblr-5119	48	10	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	48	11	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	48	12	247	247	NUM
cblr-5119	48	13	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	48	14	255	255	NUM
cblr-5119	48	15	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	48	16	2010	2010	NUM
cblr-5119	48	17	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	48	18	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	49	1	9	9	NUM
cblr-5119	49	2	jesner	jesner	PROPN
cblr-5119	49	3	v.	v.	PROPN
cblr-5119	49	4	arab	arab	PROPN
cblr-5119	49	5	bank	bank	PROPN
cblr-5119	49	6	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	49	7	plc	plc	PROPN
cblr-5119	49	8	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	49	9	138	138	NUM
cblr-5119	49	10	s.	s.	PROPN
cblr-5119	49	11	ct	ct	PROPN
cblr-5119	49	12	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	49	13	1386	1386	NUM
cblr-5119	49	14	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	49	15	1407	1407	NUM
cblr-5119	49	16	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	49	17	2018	2018	NUM
cblr-5119	49	18	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	49	19	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	49	20	reasoning	reason	VERB
cblr-5119	49	21	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	49	22	foreign	foreign	ADJ
cblr-5119	49	23	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	49	24	being	be	AUX
cblr-5119	49	25	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	49	26	defendants	defendant	NOUN
cblr-5119	49	27	implicates	implicate	VERB
cblr-5119	49	28	unacceptable	unacceptable	ADJ
cblr-5119	49	29	foreign	foreign	ADJ
cblr-5119	49	30	relations	relation	NOUN
cblr-5119	49	31	problems	problem	NOUN
cblr-5119	49	32	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	49	33	courts	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	49	34	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	49	35	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	50	1	6_2019.3_estes	6_2019.3_estes	NUM
cblr-5119	50	2	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	50	3	do	do	AUX
cblr-5119	50	4	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	50	5	delete	delete	VERB
cblr-5119	50	6	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	50	7	12/26/2019	12/26/2019	NUM
cblr-5119	50	8	12:00	12:00	NUM
cblr-5119	50	9	am	be	AUX
cblr-5119	50	10	no	no	NOUN
cblr-5119	50	11	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	51	1	3:1031	3:1031	NUM
cblr-5119	51	2	]	]	X
cblr-5119	51	3	may	may	AUX
cblr-5119	51	4	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	51	5	fourth	fourth	ADJ
cblr-5119	51	6	be	be	AUX
cblr-5119	51	7	with	with	ADP
cblr-5119	51	8	you	you	PRON
cblr-5119	51	9	1035	1035	NUM
cblr-5119	51	10	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	51	11	prevalence	prevalence	NOUN
cblr-5119	51	12	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	51	13	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	51	14	cases	case	NOUN
cblr-5119	51	15	involving	involve	VERB
cblr-5119	51	16	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	51	17	defendants	defendant	NOUN
cblr-5119	51	18	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	51	19	this	this	DET
cblr-5119	51	20	accountability	accountability	NOUN
cblr-5119	51	21	fulfills	fulfill	VERB
cblr-5119	51	22	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	51	23	vital	vital	ADJ
cblr-5119	51	24	need	need	NOUN
cblr-5119	51	25	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	52	1	part	part	NOUN
cblr-5119	52	2	ii	ii	PROPN
cblr-5119	52	3	traces	trace	VERB
cblr-5119	52	4	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	52	5	history	history	NOUN
cblr-5119	52	6	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	52	7	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	52	8	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	52	9	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	52	10	from	from	ADP
cblr-5119	52	11	its	its	PRON
cblr-5119	52	12	origins	origin	NOUN
cblr-5119	52	13	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	52	14	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	52	15	late	late	ADJ
cblr-5119	52	16	18th	18th	ADJ
cblr-5119	52	17	century	century	NOUN
cblr-5119	52	18	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	52	19	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	52	20	modern	modern	ADJ
cblr-5119	52	21	proliferation	proliferation	NOUN
cblr-5119	52	22	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	52	23	lawsuits	lawsuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	52	24	filed	file	VERB
cblr-5119	52	25	against	against	ADP
cblr-5119	52	26	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	52	27	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	52	28	human	human	ADJ
cblr-5119	52	29	rights	right	NOUN
cblr-5119	52	30	abuses	abuse	NOUN
cblr-5119	52	31	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	52	32	focusing	focus	VERB
cblr-5119	52	33	most	most	ADV
cblr-5119	52	34	heavily	heavily	ADV
cblr-5119	52	35	on	on	ADP
cblr-5119	52	36	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	52	37	supreme	supreme	PROPN
cblr-5119	52	38	court	court	PROPN
cblr-5119	52	39	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	52	40	decisions	decision	NOUN
cblr-5119	52	41	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	52	42	kiobel	kiobel	NOUN
cblr-5119	52	43	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	52	44	jesner	jesner	PROPN
cblr-5119	52	45	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	53	1	part	part	NOUN
cblr-5119	53	2	iii	iii	PROPN
cblr-5119	53	3	examines	examine	VERB
cblr-5119	53	4	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	53	5	approaches	approach	NOUN
cblr-5119	53	6	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	53	7	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	53	8	second	second	ADJ
cblr-5119	53	9	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	53	10	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	53	11	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	53	12	fourth	fourth	ADJ
cblr-5119	53	13	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	53	14	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	53	15	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	53	16	ninth	ninth	ADJ
cblr-5119	53	17	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	53	18	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	53	19	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	53	20	eleventh	eleventh	ADJ
cblr-5119	53	21	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	53	22	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	53	23	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	53	24	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	53	25	d.c	d.c	PROPN
cblr-5119	53	26	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	53	27	circuit	circuit	PROPN
cblr-5119	53	28	have	have	AUX
cblr-5119	53	29	taken	take	VERB
cblr-5119	53	30	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	53	31	address	address	VERB
cblr-5119	53	32	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	53	33	issues	issue	NOUN
cblr-5119	53	34	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	53	35	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	53	36	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	53	37	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	53	38	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	53	39	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	53	40	conditions	condition	NOUN
cblr-5119	53	41	necessary	necessary	ADJ
cblr-5119	53	42	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	53	43	rebut	rebut	VERB
cblr-5119	53	44	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	53	45	presumption	presumption	NOUN
cblr-5119	53	46	against	against	ADP
cblr-5119	53	47	extraterritoriality	extraterritoriality	NOUN
cblr-5119	53	48	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	54	1	while	while	SCONJ
cblr-5119	54	2	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	54	3	circuits	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	54	4	’	'	PUNCT
cblr-5119	54	5	decisions	decision	NOUN
cblr-5119	54	6	predate	predate	VERB
cblr-5119	54	7	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	54	8	supreme	supreme	PROPN
cblr-5119	54	9	court	court	PROPN
cblr-5119	54	10	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	54	11	jesner	jesner	NOUN
cblr-5119	54	12	decision	decision	NOUN
cblr-5119	54	13	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	54	14	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	54	15	some	some	PRON
cblr-5119	54	16	even	even	ADV
cblr-5119	54	17	predate	predate	VERB
cblr-5119	54	18	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	54	19	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	54	20	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	54	21	kiobel	kiobel	PROPN
cblr-5119	54	22	opinion	opinion	NOUN
cblr-5119	54	23	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	54	24	their	their	PRON
cblr-5119	54	25	analyses	analysis	NOUN
cblr-5119	54	26	remain	remain	VERB
cblr-5119	54	27	salient	salient	ADJ
cblr-5119	54	28	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	54	29	addressing	address	VERB
cblr-5119	54	30	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	54	31	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	54	32	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	54	33	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	54	34	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	55	1	additionally	additionally	ADV
cblr-5119	55	2	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	55	3	it	it	PRON
cblr-5119	55	4	is	be	AUX
cblr-5119	55	5	necessary	necessary	ADJ
cblr-5119	55	6	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	55	7	consider	consider	VERB
cblr-5119	55	8	both	both	DET
cblr-5119	55	9	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	55	10	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	55	11	generally	generally	ADV
cblr-5119	55	12	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	55	13	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	55	14	somewhat	somewhat	ADV
cblr-5119	55	15	distinct	distinct	ADJ
cblr-5119	55	16	issue	issue	NOUN
cblr-5119	55	17	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	55	18	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	55	19	presumption	presumption	NOUN
cblr-5119	55	20	against	against	ADP
cblr-5119	55	21	extraterritoriality	extraterritoriality	NOUN
cblr-5119	55	22	because	because	SCONJ
cblr-5119	55	23	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	55	24	two	two	NUM
cblr-5119	55	25	issues	issue	NOUN
cblr-5119	55	26	are	be	AUX
cblr-5119	55	27	now	now	ADV
cblr-5119	55	28	linked	link	VERB
cblr-5119	55	29	under	under	ADP
cblr-5119	55	30	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	55	31	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	55	32	after	after	ADP
cblr-5119	55	33	kiobel	kiobel	NOUN
cblr-5119	55	34	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	55	35	jesner	jesner	PROPN
cblr-5119	55	36	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	56	1	part	part	NOUN
cblr-5119	56	2	iv	iv	NUM
cblr-5119	56	3	explains	explain	VERB
cblr-5119	56	4	why	why	SCONJ
cblr-5119	56	5	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	56	6	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	56	7	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	56	8	should	should	AUX
cblr-5119	56	9	continue	continue	VERB
cblr-5119	56	10	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	56	11	be	be	AUX
cblr-5119	56	12	liable	liable	ADJ
cblr-5119	56	13	under	under	ADP
cblr-5119	56	14	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	56	15	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	56	16	despite	despite	SCONJ
cblr-5119	56	17	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	56	18	judicial	judicial	ADJ
cblr-5119	56	19	caution	caution	NOUN
cblr-5119	56	20	urged	urge	VERB
cblr-5119	56	21	by	by	ADP
cblr-5119	56	22	kiobel	kiobel	NOUN
cblr-5119	56	23	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	56	24	jesner	jesner	NOUN
cblr-5119	56	25	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	56	26	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	56	27	why	why	SCONJ
cblr-5119	56	28	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	56	29	supreme	supreme	PROPN
cblr-5119	56	30	court	court	PROPN
cblr-5119	56	31	should	should	AUX
cblr-5119	56	32	adopt	adopt	VERB
cblr-5119	56	33	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	56	34	fourth	fourth	ADJ
cblr-5119	56	35	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	56	36	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	56	37	approach	approach	NOUN
cblr-5119	56	38	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	57	1	part	part	NOUN
cblr-5119	57	2	v	v	ADP
cblr-5119	57	3	offers	offer	VERB
cblr-5119	57	4	brief	brief	ADJ
cblr-5119	57	5	concluding	conclude	VERB
cblr-5119	57	6	thoughts	thought	NOUN
cblr-5119	57	7	on	on	ADP
cblr-5119	57	8	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	57	9	future	future	NOUN
cblr-5119	57	10	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	57	11	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	57	12	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	57	13	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	57	14	ii	ii	PROPN
cblr-5119	57	15	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	58	1	background	background	NOUN
cblr-5119	58	2	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	58	3	history	history	NOUN
cblr-5119	58	4	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	58	5	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	58	6	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	58	7	a.	a.	NOUN
cblr-5119	58	8	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	58	9	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	58	10	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	58	11	enactment	enactment	NOUN
cblr-5119	58	12	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	58	13	dormancy	dormancy	NOUN
cblr-5119	58	14	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	58	15	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	58	16	was	be	AUX
cblr-5119	58	17	originally	originally	ADV
cblr-5119	58	18	enacted	enact	VERB
cblr-5119	58	19	as	as	ADP
cblr-5119	58	20	part	part	NOUN
cblr-5119	58	21	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	58	22	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	58	23	judiciary	judiciary	PROPN
cblr-5119	58	24	act	act	PROPN
cblr-5119	58	25	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	58	26	1789.10	1789.10	NUM
cblr-5119	58	27	it	it	PRON
cblr-5119	58	28	currently	currently	ADV
cblr-5119	58	29	reads	read	VERB
cblr-5119	58	30	:	:	PUNCT
cblr-5119	58	31	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	58	32	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	58	33	district	district	NOUN
cblr-5119	58	34	courts	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	58	35	shall	shall	AUX
cblr-5119	58	36	have	have	VERB
cblr-5119	58	37	original	original	ADJ
cblr-5119	58	38	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NOUN
cblr-5119	58	39	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	58	40	any	any	DET
cblr-5119	58	41	civil	civil	ADJ
cblr-5119	58	42	action	action	NOUN
cblr-5119	58	43	by	by	ADP
cblr-5119	58	44	an	an	DET
cblr-5119	58	45	alien	alien	NOUN
cblr-5119	58	46	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	58	47	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	58	48	tort	tort	NOUN
cblr-5119	58	49	only	only	ADV
cblr-5119	58	50	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	58	51	committed	commit	VERB
cblr-5119	58	52	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	58	53	violation	violation	NOUN
cblr-5119	58	54	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	58	55	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	58	56	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	58	57	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	58	58	nations	nation	NOUN
cblr-5119	58	59	or	or	CCONJ
cblr-5119	58	60	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	58	61	treaty	treaty	NOUN
cblr-5119	58	62	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	58	63	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	58	64	united	united	PROPN
cblr-5119	58	65	states	states	PROPN
cblr-5119	58	66	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	59	1	”11	”11	PROPN
cblr-5119	60	1	because	because	SCONJ
cblr-5119	60	2	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	60	3	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	60	4	dearth	dearth	NOUN
cblr-5119	60	5	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	60	6	contemporaneous	contemporaneous	ADJ
cblr-5119	60	7	sources	source	NOUN
cblr-5119	60	8	explaining	explain	VERB
cblr-5119	60	9	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	60	10	provision	provision	NOUN
cblr-5119	60	11	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	60	12	purposes	purpose	NOUN
cblr-5119	60	13	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	60	14	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	60	15	because	because	SCONJ
cblr-5119	60	16	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	60	17	statute	statute	NOUN
cblr-5119	60	18	was	be	AUX
cblr-5119	60	19	rarely	rarely	ADV
cblr-5119	60	20	invoked	invoke	VERB
cblr-5119	60	21	until	until	SCONJ
cblr-5119	60	22	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	60	23	modern	modern	ADJ
cblr-5119	60	24	10	10	NUM
cblr-5119	60	25	judiciary	judiciary	PROPN
cblr-5119	60	26	act	act	NOUN
cblr-5119	60	27	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	60	28	1789	1789	NUM
cblr-5119	60	29	§	§	PROPN
cblr-5119	60	30	9	9	NUM
cblr-5119	60	31	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	60	32	1	1	NUM
cblr-5119	60	33	stat	stat	NOUN
cblr-5119	60	34	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	60	35	73	73	NUM
cblr-5119	60	36	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	60	37	76–77	76–77	NUM
cblr-5119	60	38	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	60	39	codified	codify	VERB
cblr-5119	60	40	as	as	SCONJ
cblr-5119	60	41	amended	amend	VERB
cblr-5119	60	42	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	60	43	28	28	NUM
cblr-5119	60	44	u.s.c	u.s.c	ADJ
cblr-5119	60	45	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	61	1	§	§	PROPN
cblr-5119	61	2	1350	1350	NUM
cblr-5119	61	3	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	61	4	2012	2012	NUM
cblr-5119	61	5	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	61	6	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	61	7	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	62	1	11	11	NUM
cblr-5119	62	2	alien	alien	PROPN
cblr-5119	62	3	tort	tort	NOUN
cblr-5119	62	4	statute	statute	NOUN
cblr-5119	62	5	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	62	6	28	28	NUM
cblr-5119	62	7	u.s.c	u.s.c	ADJ
cblr-5119	62	8	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	63	1	§	§	PROPN
cblr-5119	63	2	1350	1350	NUM
cblr-5119	63	3	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	63	4	2012	2012	NUM
cblr-5119	63	5	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	63	6	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	64	1	6_2019.3_estes	6_2019.3_estes	NUM
cblr-5119	64	2	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	64	3	do	do	AUX
cblr-5119	64	4	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	64	5	delte	delte	VERB
cblr-5119	64	6	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	64	7	12/26/2019	12/26/2019	NUM
cblr-5119	64	8	12:00	12:00	NUM
cblr-5119	64	9	am	am	NOUN
cblr-5119	64	10	1036	1036	NUM
cblr-5119	64	11	columbia	columbia	PROPN
cblr-5119	64	12	business	business	NOUN
cblr-5119	64	13	law	law	PROPN
cblr-5119	64	14	review	review	NOUN
cblr-5119	64	15	[	[	X
cblr-5119	64	16	vol	vol	NOUN
cblr-5119	64	17	.	.	NOUN
cblr-5119	64	18	2019	2019	NUM
cblr-5119	64	19	era	era	NOUN
cblr-5119	64	20	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	64	21	there	there	PRON
cblr-5119	64	22	is	be	VERB
cblr-5119	64	23	no	no	DET
cblr-5119	64	24	definitive	definitive	ADJ
cblr-5119	64	25	account	account	NOUN
cblr-5119	64	26	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	64	27	what	what	PRON
cblr-5119	64	28	motivated	motivate	VERB
cblr-5119	64	29	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	64	30	first	first	ADJ
cblr-5119	64	31	congress	congress	PROPN
cblr-5119	64	32	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	64	33	pass	pass	VERB
cblr-5119	64	34	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	64	35	statute	statute	NOUN
cblr-5119	64	36	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	64	37	what	what	PRON
cblr-5119	64	38	offenses	offense	NOUN
cblr-5119	64	39	it	it	PRON
cblr-5119	64	40	contemplated	contemplate	VERB
cblr-5119	64	41	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	65	1	this	this	PRON
cblr-5119	65	2	has	have	AUX
cblr-5119	65	3	rendered	render	VERB
cblr-5119	65	4	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	65	5	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	65	6	an	an	PRON
cblr-5119	65	7	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	65	8	an	an	PRON
cblr-5119	65	9	oft	oft	ADV
cblr-5119	65	10	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-5119	65	11	discussed	discuss	VERB
cblr-5119	65	12	but	but	CCONJ
cblr-5119	65	13	little	little	ADJ
cblr-5119	65	14	understood	understand	VERB
cblr-5119	65	15	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	65	16	law.12	law.12	PROPN
cblr-5119	65	17	however	however	ADV
cblr-5119	65	18	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	65	19	history	history	NOUN
cblr-5119	65	20	does	do	AUX
cblr-5119	65	21	provide	provide	VERB
cblr-5119	65	22	some	some	DET
cblr-5119	65	23	clues	clue	NOUN
cblr-5119	65	24	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	66	1	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	66	2	statute	statute	NOUN
cblr-5119	66	3	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	66	4	enactment	enactment	NOUN
cblr-5119	66	5	came	come	VERB
cblr-5119	66	6	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	66	7	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	66	8	wake	wake	NOUN
cblr-5119	66	9	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	66	10	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	66	11	articles	article	NOUN
cblr-5119	66	12	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	66	13	confederation	confederation	PROPN
cblr-5119	66	14	era	era	NOUN
cblr-5119	66	15	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	66	16	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	66	17	time	time	NOUN
cblr-5119	66	18	that	that	PRON
cblr-5119	66	19	saw	see	VERB
cblr-5119	66	20	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	66	21	rise	rise	NOUN
cblr-5119	66	22	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	66	23	international	international	ADJ
cblr-5119	66	24	tensions	tension	NOUN
cblr-5119	66	25	between	between	ADP
cblr-5119	66	26	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	66	27	burgeoning	burgeon	VERB
cblr-5119	66	28	united	united	PROPN
cblr-5119	66	29	states	states	PROPN
cblr-5119	66	30	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	66	31	foreign	foreign	ADJ
cblr-5119	66	32	powers	power	NOUN
cblr-5119	66	33	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	66	34	particularly	particularly	ADV
cblr-5119	66	35	great	great	ADJ
cblr-5119	66	36	britain.13	britain.13	NOUN
cblr-5119	66	37	these	these	DET
cblr-5119	66	38	tensions	tension	NOUN
cblr-5119	66	39	were	be	AUX
cblr-5119	66	40	largely	largely	ADV
cblr-5119	66	41	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	66	42	result	result	NOUN
cblr-5119	66	43	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	66	44	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	66	45	failure	failure	NOUN
cblr-5119	66	46	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	66	47	states	state	NOUN
cblr-5119	66	48	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	66	49	provide	provide	VERB
cblr-5119	66	50	appropriate	appropriate	ADJ
cblr-5119	66	51	redress	redress	NOUN
cblr-5119	66	52	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	66	53	violations	violation	NOUN
cblr-5119	66	54	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	66	55	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	66	56	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	66	57	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	66	58	nations	nation	NOUN
cblr-5119	66	59	committed	commit	VERB
cblr-5119	66	60	by	by	ADP
cblr-5119	66	61	them	they	PRON
cblr-5119	66	62	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	66	63	their	their	PRON
cblr-5119	66	64	citizens	citizen	NOUN
cblr-5119	66	65	against	against	ADP
cblr-5119	66	66	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	66	67	citizens	citizen	NOUN
cblr-5119	66	68	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	66	69	foreign	foreign	PROPN
cblr-5119	66	70	powers.14	powers.14	PROPN
cblr-5119	66	71	under	under	ADP
cblr-5119	66	72	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	66	73	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	66	74	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	66	75	nations	nation	NOUN
cblr-5119	66	76	as	as	SCONJ
cblr-5119	66	77	it	it	PRON
cblr-5119	66	78	existed	exist	VERB
cblr-5119	66	79	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	66	80	that	that	DET
cblr-5119	66	81	time	time	NOUN
cblr-5119	66	82	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	66	83	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	66	84	nation	nation	NOUN
cblr-5119	66	85	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-5119	66	86	state	state	NOUN
cblr-5119	66	87	had	have	VERB
cblr-5119	66	88	an	an	DET
cblr-5119	66	89	affirmative	affirmative	ADJ
cblr-5119	66	90	obligation	obligation	NOUN
cblr-5119	66	91	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	66	92	provide	provide	VERB
cblr-5119	66	93	redress	redress	NOUN
cblr-5119	66	94	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	66	95	certain	certain	ADJ
cblr-5119	66	96	harms	harm	NOUN
cblr-5119	66	97	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	66	98	its	its	PRON
cblr-5119	66	99	citizens	citizen	NOUN
cblr-5119	66	100	inflicted	inflict	VERB
cblr-5119	66	101	on	on	ADP
cblr-5119	66	102	citizens	citizen	NOUN
cblr-5119	66	103	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	66	104	another	another	DET
cblr-5119	66	105	nation	nation	NOUN
cblr-5119	66	106	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-5119	66	107	state.15	state.15	NOUN
cblr-5119	66	108	if	if	SCONJ
cblr-5119	66	109	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	66	110	state	state	NOUN
cblr-5119	66	111	failed	fail	VERB
cblr-5119	66	112	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	66	113	provide	provide	VERB
cblr-5119	66	114	redress	redress	NOUN
cblr-5119	66	115	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	66	116	it	it	PRON
cblr-5119	66	117	became	become	VERB
cblr-5119	66	118	responsible	responsible	ADJ
cblr-5119	66	119	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	66	120	those	those	DET
cblr-5119	66	121	harms	harm	NOUN
cblr-5119	66	122	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	66	123	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	66	124	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	66	125	state	state	NOUN
cblr-5119	66	126	which	which	PRON
cblr-5119	66	127	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	66	128	victim	victim	NOUN
cblr-5119	66	129	belonged	belong	VERB
cblr-5119	66	130	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	66	131	could	could	AUX
cblr-5119	66	132	have	have	AUX
cblr-5119	66	133	just	just	ADV
cblr-5119	66	134	cause	cause	VERB
cblr-5119	66	135	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	66	136	reprisals	reprisal	NOUN
cblr-5119	66	137	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	66	138	possibly	possibly	ADV
cblr-5119	66	139	including	include	VERB
cblr-5119	66	140	war.16	war.16	PROPN
cblr-5119	66	141	critically	critically	ADV
cblr-5119	66	142	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	66	143	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	66	144	mere	mere	ADJ
cblr-5119	66	145	intentional	intentional	ADJ
cblr-5119	66	146	infliction	infliction	NOUN
cblr-5119	66	147	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	66	148	injury	injury	NOUN
cblr-5119	66	149	upon	upon	SCONJ
cblr-5119	66	150	another	another	DET
cblr-5119	66	151	’s	’s	ADJ
cblr-5119	66	152	person	person	NOUN
cblr-5119	66	153	or	or	CCONJ
cblr-5119	66	154	property	property	NOUN
cblr-5119	66	155	sufficed	suffice	VERB
cblr-5119	66	156	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	66	157	violate	violate	VERB
cblr-5119	66	158	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	66	159	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	66	160	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	66	161	nations.17	nations.17	PROPN
cblr-5119	66	162	this	this	PRON
cblr-5119	66	163	meant	mean	VERB
cblr-5119	66	164	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	66	165	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	66	166	articles	article	NOUN
cblr-5119	66	167	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-5119	66	168	era	era	NOUN
cblr-5119	66	169	united	united	PROPN
cblr-5119	66	170	states	state	NOUN
cblr-5119	66	171	could	could	AUX
cblr-5119	66	172	have	have	AUX
cblr-5119	66	173	been	be	AUX
cblr-5119	66	174	deemed	deem	VERB
cblr-5119	66	175	responsible	responsible	ADJ
cblr-5119	66	176	every	every	DET
cblr-5119	66	177	time	time	NOUN
cblr-5119	66	178	one	one	NUM
cblr-5119	66	179	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	66	180	its	its	PRON
cblr-5119	66	181	states	state	NOUN
cblr-5119	66	182	refused	refuse	VERB
cblr-5119	66	183	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	66	184	provide	provide	VERB
cblr-5119	66	185	redress	redress	NOUN
cblr-5119	66	186	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	66	187	an	an	DET
cblr-5119	66	188	intentional	intentional	ADJ
cblr-5119	66	189	tort	tort	NOUN
cblr-5119	66	190	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	66	191	or	or	CCONJ
cblr-5119	66	192	any	any	DET
cblr-5119	66	193	other	other	ADJ
cblr-5119	66	194	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	66	195	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	66	196	nations	nation	NOUN
cblr-5119	66	197	violation	violation	NOUN
cblr-5119	66	198	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	66	199	suffered	suffer	VERB
cblr-5119	66	200	by	by	ADP
cblr-5119	66	201	an	an	DET
cblr-5119	66	202	alien	alien	NOUN
cblr-5119	66	203	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	67	1	again	again	ADV
cblr-5119	67	2	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	67	3	states	state	NOUN
cblr-5119	67	4	were	be	AUX
cblr-5119	67	5	indeed	indeed	ADV
cblr-5119	67	6	inflaming	inflame	VERB
cblr-5119	67	7	international	international	ADJ
cblr-5119	67	8	tensions	tension	NOUN
cblr-5119	67	9	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	67	10	this	this	DET
cblr-5119	67	11	way.18	way.18	NOUN
cblr-5119	67	12	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	67	13	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	67	14	young	young	ADJ
cblr-5119	67	15	nation	nation	NOUN
cblr-5119	67	16	coming	come	VERB
cblr-5119	67	17	off	off	ADP
cblr-5119	67	18	an	an	DET
cblr-5119	67	19	expensive	expensive	ADJ
cblr-5119	67	20	war	war	NOUN
cblr-5119	67	21	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	67	22	independence	independence	NOUN
cblr-5119	67	23	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	67	24	this	this	DET
cblr-5119	67	25	threat	threat	NOUN
cblr-5119	67	26	compounded	compound	VERB
cblr-5119	67	27	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	67	28	nation	nation	NOUN
cblr-5119	67	29	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	67	30	precarious	precarious	ADJ
cblr-5119	67	31	12	12	NUM
cblr-5119	67	32	thomas	thomas	PROPN
cblr-5119	67	33	h.	h.	PROPN
cblr-5119	67	34	lee	lee	PROPN
cblr-5119	67	35	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	67	36	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	67	37	safe	safe	ADJ
cblr-5119	67	38	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-5119	67	39	conduct	conduct	NOUN
cblr-5119	67	40	theory	theory	NOUN
cblr-5119	67	41	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	67	42	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	67	43	alien	alien	PROPN
cblr-5119	67	44	tort	tort	NOUN
cblr-5119	67	45	statute	statute	NOUN
cblr-5119	67	46	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	67	47	106	106	NUM
cblr-5119	67	48	colum	colum	NOUN
cblr-5119	67	49	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	68	1	l.	l.	PROPN
cblr-5119	68	2	rev	rev	PROPN
cblr-5119	68	3	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	68	4	830	830	NUM
cblr-5119	68	5	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	68	6	831	831	NUM
cblr-5119	68	7	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	68	8	2006	2006	NUM
cblr-5119	68	9	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	68	10	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	69	1	13	13	NUM
cblr-5119	69	2	anthony	anthony	PROPN
cblr-5119	69	3	j.	j.	PROPN
cblr-5119	69	4	bellia	bellia	PROPN
cblr-5119	69	5	jr	jr	PROPN
cblr-5119	69	6	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	69	7	&	&	CCONJ
cblr-5119	69	8	bradford	bradford	PROPN
cblr-5119	69	9	r.	r.	PROPN
cblr-5119	69	10	clark	clark	PROPN
cblr-5119	69	11	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	69	12	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	69	13	alien	alien	PROPN
cblr-5119	69	14	tort	tort	NOUN
cblr-5119	69	15	statute	statute	NOUN
cblr-5119	69	16	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	69	17	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	69	18	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	69	19	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	69	20	nations	nation	NOUN
cblr-5119	69	21	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	69	22	78	78	NUM
cblr-5119	69	23	u.	u.	NOUN
cblr-5119	69	24	chi	chi	PROPN
cblr-5119	69	25	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	70	1	l.	l.	PROPN
cblr-5119	70	2	rev	rev	PROPN
cblr-5119	70	3	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	70	4	445	445	NUM
cblr-5119	70	5	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	70	6	466	466	NUM
cblr-5119	70	7	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	70	8	2011	2011	NUM
cblr-5119	70	9	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	70	10	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	71	1	14	14	NUM
cblr-5119	72	1	i	i	PRON
cblr-5119	72	2	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-5119	72	3	15	15	NUM
cblr-5119	72	4	stephen	stephen	PROPN
cblr-5119	72	5	p.	p.	PROPN
cblr-5119	72	6	mulligan	mulligan	PROPN
cblr-5119	72	7	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	72	8	cong	cong	PROPN
cblr-5119	72	9	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	73	1	research	research	NOUN
cblr-5119	73	2	serv	serv	PROPN
cblr-5119	73	3	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	73	4	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	73	5	r44947	r44947	PROPN
cblr-5119	73	6	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	73	7	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	73	8	alien	alien	PROPN
cblr-5119	73	9	tort	tort	NOUN
cblr-5119	73	10	statute	statute	NOUN
cblr-5119	73	11	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	73	12	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	73	13	):	):	PUNCT
cblr-5119	73	14	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	73	15	primer	primer	NOUN
cblr-5119	73	16	4	4	NUM
cblr-5119	73	17	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	73	18	2018	2018	NUM
cblr-5119	73	19	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	73	20	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	73	21	https://crsreports.congress.gov/product/pdf/r/r44947	https://crsreports.congress.gov/product/pdf/r/r44947	PROPN
cblr-5119	74	1	[	[	X
cblr-5119	74	2	https://perma.cc/e584-x8u8	https://perma.cc/e584-x8u8	X
cblr-5119	74	3	]	]	X
cblr-5119	74	4	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	75	1	16	16	NUM
cblr-5119	75	2	bellia	bellia	PROPN
cblr-5119	75	3	jr	jr	PROPN
cblr-5119	75	4	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	75	5	&	&	CCONJ
cblr-5119	75	6	clark	clark	PROPN
cblr-5119	75	7	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	75	8	supra	supra	PROPN
cblr-5119	75	9	note	note	PROPN
cblr-5119	75	10	13	13	NUM
cblr-5119	75	11	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	75	12	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	75	13	476	476	NUM
cblr-5119	75	14	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	75	15	17	17	NUM
cblr-5119	76	1	i	i	PRON
cblr-5119	76	2	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-5119	76	3	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	76	4	448	448	NUM
cblr-5119	76	5	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	76	6	18	18	NUM
cblr-5119	77	1	i	i	PROPN
cblr-5119	77	2	d.	d.	NOUN
cblr-5119	77	3	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	77	4	466	466	NUM
cblr-5119	77	5	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	78	1	6_2019.3_estes	6_2019.3_estes	NUM
cblr-5119	78	2	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	78	3	do	do	AUX
cblr-5119	78	4	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	78	5	delete	delete	VERB
cblr-5119	78	6	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	78	7	12/26/2019	12/26/2019	NUM
cblr-5119	78	8	12:00	12:00	NUM
cblr-5119	78	9	am	be	AUX
cblr-5119	78	10	no	no	NOUN
cblr-5119	78	11	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	79	1	3:1031	3:1031	NUM
cblr-5119	79	2	]	]	X
cblr-5119	79	3	may	may	AUX
cblr-5119	79	4	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	79	5	fourth	fourth	ADJ
cblr-5119	79	6	be	be	AUX
cblr-5119	79	7	with	with	ADP
cblr-5119	79	8	you	you	PRON
cblr-5119	79	9	1037	1037	NUM
cblr-5119	79	10	position.19	position.19	NOUN
cblr-5119	79	11	however	however	ADV
cblr-5119	79	12	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	79	13	allowing	allow	VERB
cblr-5119	79	14	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	79	15	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	79	16	civil	civil	ADJ
cblr-5119	79	17	tort	tort	NOUN
cblr-5119	79	18	remedy	remedy	NOUN
cblr-5119	79	19	was	be	AUX
cblr-5119	79	20	an	an	DET
cblr-5119	79	21	accepted	accept	VERB
cblr-5119	79	22	means	means	NOUN
cblr-5119	79	23	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	79	24	providing	provide	VERB
cblr-5119	79	25	redress	redress	NOUN
cblr-5119	79	26	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	79	27	these	these	DET
cblr-5119	79	28	violations,20	violations,20	NOUN
cblr-5119	79	29	meaning	meaning	NOUN
cblr-5119	79	30	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	79	31	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	79	32	united	united	PROPN
cblr-5119	79	33	states	states	PROPN
cblr-5119	79	34	could	could	AUX
cblr-5119	79	35	discharge	discharge	VERB
cblr-5119	79	36	its	its	PRON
cblr-5119	79	37	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	79	38	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	79	39	nations	nation	NOUN
cblr-5119	79	40	obligations	obligation	NOUN
cblr-5119	79	41	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	79	42	avoid	avoid	VERB
cblr-5119	79	43	opening	open	VERB
cblr-5119	79	44	itself	itself	PRON
cblr-5119	79	45	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	79	46	foreign	foreign	ADJ
cblr-5119	79	47	retaliation	retaliation	NOUN
cblr-5119	79	48	by	by	ADP
cblr-5119	79	49	creating	create	VERB
cblr-5119	79	50	such	such	DET
cblr-5119	79	51	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	79	52	remedy	remedy	NOUN
cblr-5119	79	53	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	80	1	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	80	2	light	light	NOUN
cblr-5119	80	3	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	80	4	these	these	DET
cblr-5119	80	5	circumstances	circumstance	NOUN
cblr-5119	80	6	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	80	7	it	it	PRON
cblr-5119	80	8	is	be	AUX
cblr-5119	80	9	natural	natural	ADJ
cblr-5119	80	10	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	80	11	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	80	12	first	first	ADJ
cblr-5119	80	13	congress	congress	PROPN
cblr-5119	80	14	would	would	AUX
cblr-5119	80	15	want	want	VERB
cblr-5119	80	16	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	80	17	include	include	VERB
cblr-5119	80	18	such	such	DET
cblr-5119	80	19	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	80	20	civil	civil	ADJ
cblr-5119	80	21	tort	tort	NOUN
cblr-5119	80	22	provision	provision	NOUN
cblr-5119	80	23	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	80	24	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	80	25	judiciary	judiciary	NOUN
cblr-5119	80	26	act	act	NOUN
cblr-5119	80	27	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	80	28	1789	1789	NUM
cblr-5119	80	29	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	80	30	which	which	PRON
cblr-5119	80	31	created	create	VERB
cblr-5119	80	32	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	80	33	federal	federal	ADJ
cblr-5119	80	34	judiciary	judiciary	NOUN
cblr-5119	80	35	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	81	1	as	as	ADP
cblr-5119	81	2	such	such	ADJ
cblr-5119	81	3	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	81	4	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	81	5	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	81	6	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	81	7	is	be	AUX
cblr-5119	81	8	best	well	ADV
cblr-5119	81	9	understood	understand	VERB
cblr-5119	81	10	as	as	ADP
cblr-5119	81	11	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	81	12	self	self	NOUN
cblr-5119	81	13	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-5119	81	14	executing	execute	VERB
cblr-5119	81	15	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	81	16	failsafe	failsafe	ADJ
cblr-5119	81	17	measure	measure	NOUN
cblr-5119	81	18	that	that	PRON
cblr-5119	81	19	enabled	enable	VERB
cblr-5119	81	20	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	81	21	united	united	PROPN
cblr-5119	81	22	states	states	PROPN
cblr-5119	81	23	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	81	24	avoid	avoid	VERB
cblr-5119	81	25	responsibility	responsibility	NOUN
cblr-5119	81	26	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	81	27	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	81	28	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	81	29	nations	nation	NOUN
cblr-5119	81	30	violations	violation	NOUN
cblr-5119	81	31	by	by	ADP
cblr-5119	81	32	permitting	permit	VERB
cblr-5119	81	33	aliens	alien	NOUN
cblr-5119	81	34	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	81	35	sue	sue	VERB
cblr-5119	81	36	us	we	PRON
cblr-5119	82	1	[	[	X
cblr-5119	82	2	sic	sic	ADJ
cblr-5119	82	3	]	]	PUNCT
cblr-5119	82	4	citizens	citizen	NOUN
cblr-5119	82	5	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	82	6	intentional	intentional	ADJ
cblr-5119	82	7	torts	tort	NOUN
cblr-5119	82	8	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	82	9	federal	federal	ADJ
cblr-5119	82	10	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	82	11	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	83	1	”21	”21	PROPN
cblr-5119	83	2	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	83	3	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	83	4	filled	fill	VERB
cblr-5119	83	5	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	83	6	critical	critical	ADJ
cblr-5119	83	7	gap	gap	NOUN
cblr-5119	83	8	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	83	9	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	83	10	judiciary	judiciary	PROPN
cblr-5119	83	11	act	act	PROPN
cblr-5119	83	12	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	84	1	without	without	ADP
cblr-5119	84	2	it	it	PRON
cblr-5119	84	3	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	84	4	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	84	5	act	act	NOUN
cblr-5119	84	6	permitted	permit	VERB
cblr-5119	84	7	aliens	alien	NOUN
cblr-5119	84	8	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	84	9	sue	sue	VERB
cblr-5119	84	10	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	84	11	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	84	12	citizens	citizen	NOUN
cblr-5119	84	13	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	84	14	federal	federal	ADJ
cblr-5119	84	15	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	84	16	only	only	ADV
cblr-5119	84	17	if	if	SCONJ
cblr-5119	84	18	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	84	19	amount	amount	NOUN
cblr-5119	84	20	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	84	21	controversy	controversy	NOUN
cblr-5119	84	22	exceeded	exceed	VERB
cblr-5119	84	23	$	$	SYM
cblr-5119	84	24	500.22	500.22	NUM
cblr-5119	84	25	since	since	SCONJ
cblr-5119	84	26	most	most	ADJ
cblr-5119	84	27	intentional	intentional	ADJ
cblr-5119	84	28	tort	tort	NOUN
cblr-5119	84	29	claims	claim	NOUN
cblr-5119	84	30	did	do	AUX
cblr-5119	84	31	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	84	32	meet	meet	VERB
cblr-5119	84	33	this	this	DET
cblr-5119	84	34	requirement	requirement	NOUN
cblr-5119	84	35	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	84	36	many	many	ADJ
cblr-5119	84	37	intentional	intentional	ADJ
cblr-5119	84	38	torts	tort	NOUN
cblr-5119	84	39	committed	commit	VERB
cblr-5119	84	40	by	by	ADP
cblr-5119	84	41	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	84	42	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	84	43	citizens23	citizens23	PROPN
cblr-5119	84	44	against	against	ADP
cblr-5119	84	45	aliens	alien	NOUN
cblr-5119	84	46	would	would	AUX
cblr-5119	84	47	potentially	potentially	ADV
cblr-5119	84	48	go	go	VERB
cblr-5119	84	49	unredressed	unredressed	ADJ
cblr-5119	84	50	if	if	SCONJ
cblr-5119	84	51	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	84	52	ats	at	NOUN
cblr-5119	84	53	did	do	AUX
cblr-5119	84	54	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	84	55	exist	exist	VERB
cblr-5119	84	56	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	84	57	meaning	mean	VERB
cblr-5119	84	58	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	84	59	united	united	PROPN
cblr-5119	84	60	states	states	PROPN
cblr-5119	84	61	would	would	AUX
cblr-5119	84	62	potentially	potentially	ADV
cblr-5119	84	63	be	be	AUX
cblr-5119	84	64	responsible	responsible	ADJ
cblr-5119	84	65	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	84	66	many	many	ADJ
cblr-5119	84	67	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	84	68	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	84	69	nations	nation	NOUN
cblr-5119	84	70	violations	violation	NOUN
cblr-5119	84	71	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	85	1	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	85	2	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	85	3	meant	mean	VERB
cblr-5119	85	4	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	85	5	ensure	ensure	VERB
cblr-5119	85	6	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	85	7	this	this	PRON
cblr-5119	85	8	would	would	AUX
cblr-5119	85	9	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	85	10	be	be	AUX
cblr-5119	85	11	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	85	12	case.24	case.24	NOUN
cblr-5119	85	13	19	19	NUM
cblr-5119	85	14	see	see	VERB
cblr-5119	85	15	i	i	PRON
cblr-5119	85	16	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-5119	85	17	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	85	18	501–07	501–07	NUM
cblr-5119	85	19	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	85	20	describing	describe	VERB
cblr-5119	85	21	states	state	NOUN
cblr-5119	85	22	’	'	PUNCT
cblr-5119	85	23	insufficient	insufficient	ADJ
cblr-5119	85	24	attempts	attempt	NOUN
cblr-5119	85	25	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	85	26	provide	provide	VERB
cblr-5119	85	27	redress	redress	NOUN
cblr-5119	85	28	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	85	29	violations	violation	NOUN
cblr-5119	85	30	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	85	31	foreign	foreign	ADJ
cblr-5119	85	32	citizens	citizen	NOUN
cblr-5119	85	33	’	’	PART
cblr-5119	85	34	rights	right	NOUN
cblr-5119	85	35	inflicted	inflict	VERB
cblr-5119	85	36	by	by	ADP
cblr-5119	85	37	their	their	PRON
cblr-5119	85	38	citizens	citizen	NOUN
cblr-5119	85	39	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	85	40	contemporaneous	contemporaneous	ADJ
cblr-5119	85	41	observers	observer	NOUN
cblr-5119	85	42	’	’	PART
cblr-5119	85	43	concerns	concern	NOUN
cblr-5119	85	44	about	about	ADP
cblr-5119	85	45	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	85	46	possible	possible	ADJ
cblr-5119	85	47	repercussions	repercussion	NOUN
cblr-5119	85	48	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	85	49	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	85	50	inadequacy	inadequacy	NOUN
cblr-5119	85	51	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	85	52	these	these	DET
cblr-5119	85	53	attempts	attempt	NOUN
cblr-5119	85	54	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	85	55	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	86	1	20	20	NUM
cblr-5119	86	2	see	see	VERB
cblr-5119	86	3	i	i	PRON
cblr-5119	86	4	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-5119	86	5	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	86	6	483	483	NUM
cblr-5119	86	7	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	86	8	21	21	NUM
cblr-5119	87	1	i	i	PRON
cblr-5119	87	2	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-5119	87	3	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	87	4	454	454	NUM
cblr-5119	87	5	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	88	1	22	22	NUM
cblr-5119	88	2	judiciary	judiciary	PROPN
cblr-5119	88	3	act	act	NOUN
cblr-5119	88	4	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	88	5	1789	1789	NUM
cblr-5119	88	6	§	§	PROPN
cblr-5119	88	7	11	11	NUM
cblr-5119	88	8	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	88	9	1	1	NUM
cblr-5119	88	10	stat	stat	NOUN
cblr-5119	88	11	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	89	1	73	73	NUM
cblr-5119	89	2	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	89	3	78	78	NUM
cblr-5119	89	4	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	89	5	codified	codify	VERB
cblr-5119	89	6	as	as	SCONJ
cblr-5119	89	7	amended	amend	VERB
cblr-5119	89	8	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	89	9	28	28	NUM
cblr-5119	89	10	u.s.c	u.s.c	ADJ
cblr-5119	89	11	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	90	1	§	§	PROPN
cblr-5119	90	2	1332	1332	NUM
cblr-5119	90	3	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	90	4	2012	2012	NUM
cblr-5119	90	5	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	90	6	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	90	7	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	91	1	23	23	NUM
cblr-5119	92	1	as	as	ADP
cblr-5119	92	2	indicated	indicate	VERB
cblr-5119	92	3	supra	supra	NOUN
cblr-5119	92	4	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	92	5	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	92	6	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	92	7	time	time	NOUN
cblr-5119	92	8	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	92	9	its	its	PRON
cblr-5119	92	10	adoption	adoption	NOUN
cblr-5119	92	11	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	92	12	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	92	13	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	92	14	likely	likely	ADV
cblr-5119	92	15	contemplated	contemplate	VERB
cblr-5119	92	16	only	only	ADV
cblr-5119	92	17	defendants	defendant	NOUN
cblr-5119	92	18	that	that	PRON
cblr-5119	92	19	were	be	AUX
cblr-5119	92	20	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	92	21	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	92	22	nationals	national	NOUN
cblr-5119	92	23	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	92	24	since	since	SCONJ
cblr-5119	92	25	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	92	26	nation	nation	NOUN
cblr-5119	92	27	could	could	AUX
cblr-5119	92	28	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	92	29	be	be	AUX
cblr-5119	92	30	deemed	deem	VERB
cblr-5119	92	31	responsible	responsible	ADJ
cblr-5119	92	32	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	92	33	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	92	34	acts	act	NOUN
cblr-5119	92	35	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	92	36	non	non	NOUN
cblr-5119	92	37	-	-	NOUN
cblr-5119	92	38	nationals	national	NOUN
cblr-5119	92	39	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	93	1	yet	yet	ADV
cblr-5119	93	2	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	93	3	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	93	4	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	93	5	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	93	6	modern	modern	ADJ
cblr-5119	93	7	application	application	NOUN
cblr-5119	93	8	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	93	9	many	many	ADJ
cblr-5119	93	10	suits	suit	NOUN
cblr-5119	93	11	have	have	AUX
cblr-5119	93	12	involved	involve	VERB
cblr-5119	93	13	non	non	ADJ
cblr-5119	93	14	-	-	ADJ
cblr-5119	93	15	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	93	16	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	93	17	defendants	defendant	NOUN
cblr-5119	93	18	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	93	19	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	93	20	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	93	21	disconnect	disconnect	NOUN
cblr-5119	93	22	between	between	ADP
cblr-5119	93	23	that	that	DET
cblr-5119	93	24	fact	fact	NOUN
cblr-5119	93	25	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	93	26	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	93	27	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	93	28	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	93	29	original	original	ADJ
cblr-5119	93	30	understanding	understanding	NOUN
cblr-5119	93	31	is	be	AUX
cblr-5119	93	32	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	93	33	significant	significant	ADJ
cblr-5119	93	34	reason	reason	NOUN
cblr-5119	93	35	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	93	36	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	93	37	controversy	controversy	NOUN
cblr-5119	93	38	surrounding	surround	VERB
cblr-5119	93	39	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	93	40	statute	statute	NOUN
cblr-5119	93	41	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	93	42	use	use	NOUN
cblr-5119	93	43	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	94	1	but	but	CCONJ
cblr-5119	94	2	this	this	PRON
cblr-5119	94	3	also	also	ADV
cblr-5119	94	4	means	mean	VERB
cblr-5119	94	5	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	94	6	as	as	ADP
cblr-5119	94	7	discussed	discuss	VERB
cblr-5119	94	8	infra	infra	NOUN
cblr-5119	94	9	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	94	10	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	94	11	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	94	12	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	94	13	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	94	14	original	original	ADJ
cblr-5119	94	15	understanding	understanding	NOUN
cblr-5119	94	16	does	do	AUX
cblr-5119	94	17	comport	comport	VERB
cblr-5119	94	18	with	with	ADP
cblr-5119	94	19	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	94	20	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	94	21	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	94	22	being	be	AUX
cblr-5119	94	23	liable	liable	ADJ
cblr-5119	94	24	under	under	ADP
cblr-5119	94	25	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	94	26	statute	statute	NOUN
cblr-5119	94	27	going	go	VERB
cblr-5119	94	28	forward	forward	ADV
cblr-5119	94	29	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	95	1	24	24	NUM
cblr-5119	95	2	bellia	bellia	PROPN
cblr-5119	95	3	jr	jr	PROPN
cblr-5119	95	4	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	95	5	&	&	CCONJ
cblr-5119	95	6	clark	clark	PROPN
cblr-5119	95	7	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	95	8	supra	supra	PROPN
cblr-5119	95	9	note	note	PROPN
cblr-5119	95	10	13	13	NUM
cblr-5119	95	11	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	95	12	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	95	13	450	450	NUM
cblr-5119	95	14	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	96	1	6_2019.3_estes	6_2019.3_estes	NUM
cblr-5119	96	2	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	96	3	do	do	AUX
cblr-5119	96	4	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	96	5	delte	delte	VERB
cblr-5119	96	6	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	96	7	12/26/2019	12/26/2019	NUM
cblr-5119	96	8	12:00	12:00	NUM
cblr-5119	96	9	am	am	NOUN
cblr-5119	96	10	1038	1038	NUM
cblr-5119	96	11	columbia	columbia	PROPN
cblr-5119	96	12	business	business	NOUN
cblr-5119	96	13	law	law	PROPN
cblr-5119	96	14	review	review	NOUN
cblr-5119	96	15	[	[	X
cblr-5119	96	16	vol	vol	NOUN
cblr-5119	96	17	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	96	18	2019	2019	NUM
cblr-5119	96	19	despite	despite	SCONJ
cblr-5119	96	20	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	96	21	vital	vital	ADJ
cblr-5119	96	22	role	role	NOUN
cblr-5119	96	23	it	it	PRON
cblr-5119	96	24	played	play	VERB
cblr-5119	96	25	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	96	26	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	96	27	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	96	28	was	be	AUX
cblr-5119	96	29	rarely	rarely	ADV
cblr-5119	96	30	invoked	invoke	VERB
cblr-5119	96	31	between	between	ADP
cblr-5119	96	32	1789	1789	NUM
cblr-5119	96	33	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	96	34	1980	1980	NUM
cblr-5119	96	35	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	97	1	district	district	NOUN
cblr-5119	97	2	courts	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	97	3	upheld	uphold	VERB
cblr-5119	97	4	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NOUN
cblr-5119	97	5	under	under	ADP
cblr-5119	97	6	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	97	7	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	97	8	only	only	ADV
cblr-5119	97	9	twice	twice	ADV
cblr-5119	97	10	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	97	11	that	that	DET
cblr-5119	97	12	period,25	period,25	NOUN
cblr-5119	97	13	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	97	14	rejected	reject	VERB
cblr-5119	97	15	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NOUN
cblr-5119	97	16	under	under	ADP
cblr-5119	97	17	it	it	PRON
cblr-5119	97	18	on	on	ADP
cblr-5119	97	19	about	about	ADV
cblr-5119	97	20	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	97	21	dozen	dozen	NOUN
cblr-5119	97	22	occasions.26	occasions.26	ADJ
cblr-5119	97	23	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	97	24	other	other	ADJ
cblr-5119	97	25	words	word	NOUN
cblr-5119	97	26	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	97	27	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	97	28	statute	statute	NOUN
cblr-5119	97	29	was	be	AUX
cblr-5119	97	30	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	97	31	essentially	essentially	ADV
cblr-5119	97	32	dormant	dormant	VERB
cblr-5119	97	33	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	97	34	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	97	35	nearly	nearly	ADV
cblr-5119	97	36	two	two	NUM
cblr-5119	97	37	hundred	hundred	NUM
cblr-5119	97	38	years.27	years.27	NOUN
cblr-5119	97	39	this	this	PRON
cblr-5119	97	40	is	be	AUX
cblr-5119	97	41	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	97	42	altogether	altogether	ADV
cblr-5119	97	43	surprising	surprising	ADJ
cblr-5119	97	44	given	give	VERB
cblr-5119	97	45	several	several	ADJ
cblr-5119	97	46	factors	factor	NOUN
cblr-5119	97	47	that	that	PRON
cblr-5119	97	48	limited	limit	VERB
cblr-5119	97	49	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	97	50	applicability	applicability	NOUN
cblr-5119	97	51	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	97	52	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	97	53	ats	at	NOUN
cblr-5119	97	54	:	:	PUNCT
cblr-5119	97	55	first	first	ADV
cblr-5119	97	56	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	97	57	while	while	SCONJ
cblr-5119	97	58	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	97	59	ats	at	NOUN
cblr-5119	97	60	as	as	ADP
cblr-5119	97	61	originally	originally	ADV
cblr-5119	97	62	understood	understand	VERB
cblr-5119	97	63	likely	likely	ADV
cblr-5119	97	64	did	do	AUX
cblr-5119	97	65	cover	cover	VERB
cblr-5119	97	66	intentional	intentional	ADJ
cblr-5119	97	67	torts	tort	NOUN
cblr-5119	97	68	committed	commit	VERB
cblr-5119	97	69	abroad	abroad	ADV
cblr-5119	97	70	by	by	ADP
cblr-5119	97	71	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	97	72	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	97	73	citizens	citizen	NOUN
cblr-5119	97	74	against	against	ADP
cblr-5119	97	75	aliens	alien	NOUN
cblr-5119	97	76	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	97	77	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	97	78	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	97	79	initial	initial	ADJ
cblr-5119	97	80	period	period	NOUN
cblr-5119	97	81	after	after	ADP
cblr-5119	97	82	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	97	83	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	97	84	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	97	85	enactment	enactment	NOUN
cblr-5119	97	86	it	it	PRON
cblr-5119	97	87	would	would	AUX
cblr-5119	97	88	have	have	AUX
cblr-5119	97	89	been	be	AUX
cblr-5119	97	90	exceedingly	exceedingly	ADV
cblr-5119	97	91	difficult	difficult	ADJ
cblr-5119	97	92	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	97	93	an	an	DET
cblr-5119	97	94	alien	alien	NOUN
cblr-5119	97	95	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	97	96	such	such	DET
cblr-5119	97	97	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	97	98	situation	situation	NOUN
cblr-5119	97	99	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	97	100	sue	sue	VERB
cblr-5119	97	101	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	97	102	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	97	103	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	97	104	federal	federal	PROPN
cblr-5119	97	105	court	court	PROPN
cblr-5119	97	106	due	due	ADP
cblr-5119	97	107	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	97	108	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	97	109	difficulty	difficulty	NOUN
cblr-5119	97	110	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	97	111	travel	travel	NOUN
cblr-5119	97	112	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	97	113	that	that	DET
cblr-5119	97	114	time	time	NOUN
cblr-5119	97	115	;	;	PUNCT
cblr-5119	97	116	second	second	X
cblr-5119	97	117	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	97	118	aliens	alien	NOUN
cblr-5119	97	119	who	who	PRON
cblr-5119	97	120	suffered	suffer	VERB
cblr-5119	97	121	harm	harm	NOUN
cblr-5119	97	122	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	97	123	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	97	124	united	united	PROPN
cblr-5119	97	125	states	states	PROPN
cblr-5119	97	126	often	often	ADV
cblr-5119	97	127	simply	simply	ADV
cblr-5119	97	128	left	leave	VERB
cblr-5119	97	129	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	97	130	country	country	NOUN
cblr-5119	97	131	instead	instead	ADV
cblr-5119	97	132	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	97	133	pursuing	pursue	VERB
cblr-5119	97	134	civil	civil	ADJ
cblr-5119	97	135	remedies	remedy	NOUN
cblr-5119	97	136	;	;	PUNCT
cblr-5119	97	137	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	97	138	third	third	ADJ
cblr-5119	97	139	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	97	140	tensions	tension	NOUN
cblr-5119	97	141	between	between	ADP
cblr-5119	97	142	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	97	143	united	united	PROPN
cblr-5119	97	144	states	states	PROPN
cblr-5119	97	145	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	97	146	great	great	ADJ
cblr-5119	97	147	britain	britain	PROPN
cblr-5119	97	148	soon	soon	ADV
cblr-5119	97	149	dissipated	dissipate	VERB
cblr-5119	97	150	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	97	151	meaning	mean	VERB
cblr-5119	97	152	british	british	ADJ
cblr-5119	97	153	aliens	alien	NOUN
cblr-5119	97	154	were	be	AUX
cblr-5119	97	155	far	far	ADV
cblr-5119	97	156	less	less	ADV
cblr-5119	97	157	likely	likely	ADJ
cblr-5119	97	158	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	97	159	be	be	AUX
cblr-5119	97	160	victims	victim	NOUN
cblr-5119	97	161	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	97	162	intentional	intentional	ADJ
cblr-5119	97	163	torts	tort	NOUN
cblr-5119	97	164	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	97	165	especially	especially	ADV
cblr-5119	97	166	since	since	SCONJ
cblr-5119	97	167	loyalists	loyalist	NOUN
cblr-5119	97	168	were	be	AUX
cblr-5119	97	169	increasingly	increasingly	ADV
cblr-5119	97	170	likely	likely	ADJ
cblr-5119	97	171	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	97	172	assimilate	assimilate	VERB
cblr-5119	97	173	into	into	ADP
cblr-5119	97	174	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	97	175	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	97	176	citizenship.28	citizenship.28	NOUN
cblr-5119	97	177	these	these	DET
cblr-5119	97	178	developments	development	NOUN
cblr-5119	97	179	served	serve	VERB
cblr-5119	97	180	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	97	181	remove	remove	VERB
cblr-5119	97	182	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	97	183	large	large	ADJ
cblr-5119	97	184	category	category	NOUN
cblr-5119	97	185	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	97	186	possible	possible	ADJ
cblr-5119	97	187	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
cblr-5119	97	188	from	from	ADP
cblr-5119	97	189	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	97	190	suits.29	suits.29	NOUN
cblr-5119	97	191	while	while	SCONJ
cblr-5119	97	192	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	97	193	lack	lack	NOUN
cblr-5119	97	194	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	97	195	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	97	196	cases	case	NOUN
cblr-5119	97	197	means	mean	VERB
cblr-5119	97	198	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	97	199	courts	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	97	200	never	never	ADV
cblr-5119	97	201	addressed	address	VERB
cblr-5119	97	202	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	97	203	possibility	possibility	NOUN
cblr-5119	97	204	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	97	205	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	97	206	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	97	207	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	97	208	there	there	PRON
cblr-5119	97	209	is	be	VERB
cblr-5119	97	210	reason	reason	NOUN
cblr-5119	97	211	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	97	212	believe	believe	VERB
cblr-5119	97	213	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	97	214	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	97	215	were	be	AUX
cblr-5119	97	216	indeed	indeed	ADV
cblr-5119	97	217	liable	liable	ADJ
cblr-5119	97	218	under	under	ADP
cblr-5119	97	219	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	97	220	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	97	221	from	from	ADP
cblr-5119	97	222	its	its	PRON
cblr-5119	97	223	beginning	beginning	NOUN
cblr-5119	97	224	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	98	1	first	first	ADV
cblr-5119	98	2	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	98	3	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	98	4	text	text	NOUN
cblr-5119	98	5	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	98	6	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	98	7	statute	statute	NOUN
cblr-5119	98	8	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	98	9	while	while	SCONJ
cblr-5119	98	10	expressly	expressly	ADV
cblr-5119	98	11	specifying	specify	VERB
cblr-5119	98	12	what	what	PRON
cblr-5119	98	13	type	type	NOUN
cblr-5119	98	14	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	98	15	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
cblr-5119	98	16	could	could	AUX
cblr-5119	98	17	sue	sue	VERB
cblr-5119	98	18	under	under	ADP
cblr-5119	98	19	it	it	PRON
cblr-5119	98	20	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	98	21	did	do	AUX
cblr-5119	98	22	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	98	23	distinguish	distinguish	VERB
cblr-5119	98	24	among	among	ADP
cblr-5119	98	25	possible	possible	ADJ
cblr-5119	98	26	defendants.30	defendants.30	NOUN
cblr-5119	98	27	second	second	ADV
cblr-5119	98	28	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	98	29	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	98	30	legal	legal	ADJ
cblr-5119	98	31	status	status	NOUN
cblr-5119	98	32	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	98	33	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	98	34	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	98	35	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	98	36	late	late	ADJ
cblr-5119	98	37	18th	18th	ADJ
cblr-5119	98	38	century	century	NOUN
cblr-5119	98	39	supports	support	VERB
cblr-5119	98	40	this	this	DET
cblr-5119	98	41	proposition	proposition	NOUN
cblr-5119	98	42	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	99	1	indeed	indeed	ADV
cblr-5119	99	2	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	99	3	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	99	4	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	99	5	recent	recent	ADJ
cblr-5119	99	6	decision	decision	NOUN
cblr-5119	99	7	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	99	8	d.c	d.c	PROPN
cblr-5119	99	9	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	99	10	circuit	circuit	PROPN
cblr-5119	99	11	panel	panel	NOUN
cblr-5119	99	12	noted	note	VERB
cblr-5119	99	13	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	99	14	:	:	PUNCT
cblr-5119	99	15	25	25	NUM
cblr-5119	99	16	alicia	alicia	PROPN
cblr-5119	99	17	pitts	pitt	NOUN
cblr-5119	99	18	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	99	19	comment	comment	NOUN
cblr-5119	99	20	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	99	21	avoiding	avoid	VERB
cblr-5119	99	22	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	99	23	alien	alien	ADJ
cblr-5119	99	24	tort	tort	NOUN
cblr-5119	99	25	statute	statute	NOUN
cblr-5119	99	26	:	:	PUNCT
cblr-5119	99	27	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	99	28	call	call	NOUN
cblr-5119	99	29	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	99	30	uniformity	uniformity	NOUN
cblr-5119	99	31	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	99	32	state	state	NOUN
cblr-5119	99	33	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	99	34	human	human	ADJ
cblr-5119	99	35	rights	right	NOUN
cblr-5119	99	36	litigation	litigation	NOUN
cblr-5119	99	37	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	99	38	71	71	NUM
cblr-5119	99	39	smu	smu	PROPN
cblr-5119	99	40	l.	l.	PROPN
cblr-5119	99	41	rev	rev	PROPN
cblr-5119	99	42	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	99	43	1209	1209	NUM
cblr-5119	99	44	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	99	45	1212	1212	NUM
cblr-5119	99	46	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	99	47	2018	2018	NUM
cblr-5119	99	48	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	99	49	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	99	50	citing	cite	VERB
cblr-5119	99	51	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	99	52	discussion	discussion	NOUN
cblr-5119	99	53	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	99	54	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	99	55	ats	at	NOUN
cblr-5119	99	56	’	'	PUNCT
cblr-5119	99	57	history	history	NOUN
cblr-5119	99	58	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	99	59	bolchos	bolchos	PROPN
cblr-5119	99	60	v.	v.	ADP
cblr-5119	99	61	darrel	darrel	PROPN
cblr-5119	99	62	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	99	63	3	3	NUM
cblr-5119	99	64	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	99	65	f.cas	f.cas	ADV
cblr-5119	99	66	810	810	NUM
cblr-5119	99	67	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	99	68	d.s.c	d.s.c	ADJ
cblr-5119	99	69	.	.	NOUN
cblr-5119	99	70	1795	1795	NUM
cblr-5119	99	71	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	99	72	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	99	73	no	no	INTJ
cblr-5119	99	74	.	.	NOUN
cblr-5119	99	75	1607	1607	NUM
cblr-5119	99	76	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	99	77	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	99	78	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	100	1	26	26	NUM
cblr-5119	100	2	lee	lee	PROPN
cblr-5119	100	3	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	100	4	supra	supra	PROPN
cblr-5119	100	5	note	note	PROPN
cblr-5119	100	6	12	12	NUM
cblr-5119	100	7	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	100	8	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	100	9	832–33	832–33	NUM
cblr-5119	100	10	n.6	n.6	SYM
cblr-5119	100	11	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	100	12	27	27	NUM
cblr-5119	100	13	i	i	PRON
cblr-5119	100	14	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-5119	100	15	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	100	16	832	832	NUM
cblr-5119	100	17	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	100	18	28	28	NUM
cblr-5119	100	19	bellia	bellia	PROPN
cblr-5119	100	20	jr	jr	PROPN
cblr-5119	100	21	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	100	22	&	&	CCONJ
cblr-5119	100	23	clark	clark	PROPN
cblr-5119	100	24	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	100	25	supra	supra	PROPN
cblr-5119	100	26	note	note	PROPN
cblr-5119	100	27	13	13	NUM
cblr-5119	100	28	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	100	29	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	100	30	525	525	NUM
cblr-5119	100	31	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	100	32	29	29	NUM
cblr-5119	101	1	i	i	PRON
cblr-5119	101	2	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-5119	101	3	30	30	NUM
cblr-5119	101	4	judiciary	judiciary	PROPN
cblr-5119	101	5	act	act	NOUN
cblr-5119	101	6	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	101	7	1789	1789	NUM
cblr-5119	101	8	§	§	PROPN
cblr-5119	101	9	9	9	NUM
cblr-5119	101	10	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	101	11	1	1	NUM
cblr-5119	101	12	stat	stat	NOUN
cblr-5119	101	13	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	102	1	73	73	NUM
cblr-5119	102	2	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	102	3	76–77	76–77	NUM
cblr-5119	102	4	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	102	5	codified	codify	VERB
cblr-5119	102	6	as	as	SCONJ
cblr-5119	102	7	amended	amend	VERB
cblr-5119	102	8	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	102	9	28	28	NUM
cblr-5119	102	10	u.s.c	u.s.c	ADJ
cblr-5119	102	11	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	103	1	§	§	PROPN
cblr-5119	103	2	1350	1350	NUM
cblr-5119	103	3	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	103	4	2012	2012	NUM
cblr-5119	103	5	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	103	6	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	103	7	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	104	1	6_2019.3_estes	6_2019.3_estes	NUM
cblr-5119	104	2	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	104	3	do	do	AUX
cblr-5119	104	4	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	104	5	delete	delete	VERB
cblr-5119	104	6	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	104	7	12/26/2019	12/26/2019	NUM
cblr-5119	104	8	12:00	12:00	NUM
cblr-5119	104	9	am	be	AUX
cblr-5119	104	10	no	no	NOUN
cblr-5119	104	11	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	105	1	3:1031	3:1031	NUM
cblr-5119	105	2	]	]	X
cblr-5119	105	3	may	may	AUX
cblr-5119	105	4	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	105	5	fourth	fourth	ADJ
cblr-5119	105	6	be	be	AUX
cblr-5119	105	7	with	with	ADP
cblr-5119	105	8	you	you	PRON
cblr-5119	105	9	1039	1039	NUM
cblr-5119	105	10	[	[	X
cblr-5119	105	11	b]y	b]y	X
cblr-5119	105	12	1789	1789	NUM
cblr-5119	105	13	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	105	14	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	105	15	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	105	16	tort	tort	NOUN
cblr-5119	105	17	was	be	AUX
cblr-5119	105	18	an	an	DET
cblr-5119	105	19	accepted	accepted	ADJ
cblr-5119	105	20	principle	principle	NOUN
cblr-5119	105	21	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	105	22	tort	tort	NOUN
cblr-5119	105	23	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	105	24	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	105	25	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	105	26	united	united	PROPN
cblr-5119	105	27	states	states	PROPN
cblr-5119	105	28	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	105	29	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	105	30	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	105	31	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	106	1	thus	thus	ADV
cblr-5119	106	2	it	it	PRON
cblr-5119	106	3	appears	appear	VERB
cblr-5119	106	4	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	106	5	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	106	6	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	106	7	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	106	8	1789	1789	NUM
cblr-5119	106	9	on	on	ADP
cblr-5119	106	10	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	106	11	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	106	12	was	be	AUX
cblr-5119	106	13	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	106	14	same	same	ADJ
cblr-5119	106	15	as	as	SCONJ
cblr-5119	106	16	it	it	PRON
cblr-5119	106	17	is	be	AUX
cblr-5119	106	18	today	today	NOUN
cblr-5119	106	19	:	:	PUNCT
cblr-5119	106	20	‘	'	PUNCT
cblr-5119	106	21	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	106	22	general	general	ADJ
cblr-5119	106	23	rule	rule	NOUN
cblr-5119	106	24	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	106	25	substantive	substantive	ADJ
cblr-5119	106	26	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	106	27	is	be	AUX
cblr-5119	106	28	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	106	29	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	106	30	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	106	31	like	like	ADP
cblr-5119	106	32	individuals	individual	NOUN
cblr-5119	106	33	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	106	34	are	be	AUX
cblr-5119	106	35	liable	liable	ADJ
cblr-5119	106	36	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	106	37	their	their	PRON
cblr-5119	106	38	torts.31	torts.31	NOUN
cblr-5119	106	39	under	under	ADP
cblr-5119	106	40	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	106	41	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	106	42	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	106	43	nations	nation	NOUN
cblr-5119	106	44	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	106	45	states	state	NOUN
cblr-5119	106	46	were	be	AUX
cblr-5119	106	47	responsible	responsible	ADJ
cblr-5119	106	48	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	106	49	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	106	50	violations	violation	NOUN
cblr-5119	106	51	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	106	52	their	their	PRON
cblr-5119	106	53	private	private	ADJ
cblr-5119	106	54	citizens,32	citizens,32	NOUN
cblr-5119	106	55	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	106	56	this	this	DET
cblr-5119	106	57	historical	historical	ADJ
cblr-5119	106	58	context	context	NOUN
cblr-5119	106	59	gives	give	VERB
cblr-5119	106	60	reason	reason	NOUN
cblr-5119	106	61	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	106	62	believe	believe	VERB
cblr-5119	106	63	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	106	64	their	their	PRON
cblr-5119	106	65	responsibility	responsibility	NOUN
cblr-5119	106	66	extended	extend	VERB
cblr-5119	106	67	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	106	68	their	their	PRON
cblr-5119	106	69	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	106	70	citizens	citizen	NOUN
cblr-5119	106	71	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	107	1	b.	b.	PROPN
cblr-5119	107	2	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	107	3	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	107	4	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	107	5	reawakening	reawakening	NOUN
cblr-5119	107	6	after	after	SCONJ
cblr-5119	107	7	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	107	8	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	107	9	had	have	AUX
cblr-5119	107	10	lain	lie	VERB
cblr-5119	107	11	dormant	dormant	VERB
cblr-5119	107	12	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	107	13	nearly	nearly	ADV
cblr-5119	107	14	200	200	NUM
cblr-5119	107	15	years	year	NOUN
cblr-5119	107	16	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	107	17	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	107	18	second	second	ADJ
cblr-5119	107	19	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	107	20	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	107	21	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	107	22	appeals	appeals	PROPN
cblr-5119	107	23	resuscitated	resuscitate	VERB
cblr-5119	107	24	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	107	25	statute	statute	NOUN
cblr-5119	107	26	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	107	27	1980	1980	NUM
cblr-5119	107	28	with	with	ADP
cblr-5119	107	29	its	its	PRON
cblr-5119	107	30	decision	decision	NOUN
cblr-5119	107	31	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	107	32	filartiga	filartiga	ADJ
cblr-5119	107	33	v.	v.	CCONJ
cblr-5119	107	34	pena	pena	NOUN
cblr-5119	107	35	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-5119	107	36	irala	irala	NOUN
cblr-5119	107	37	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	108	1	there	there	ADV
cblr-5119	108	2	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	108	3	paraguayan	paraguayan	ADJ
cblr-5119	108	4	citizens	citizen	NOUN
cblr-5119	108	5	joel	joel	PROPN
cblr-5119	108	6	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	108	7	dolly	dolly	ADV
cblr-5119	108	8	filartiga	filartiga	ADJ
cblr-5119	108	9	sued	sue	VERB
cblr-5119	108	10	americo	americo	PROPN
cblr-5119	108	11	norberto	norberto	VERB
cblr-5119	108	12	pena	pena	PROPN
cblr-5119	108	13	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-5119	108	14	irala	irala	NOUN
cblr-5119	108	15	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	108	16	also	also	ADV
cblr-5119	108	17	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	108	18	paraguayan	paraguayan	ADJ
cblr-5119	108	19	citizen	citizen	NOUN
cblr-5119	108	20	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	108	21	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	108	22	wrongful	wrongful	ADJ
cblr-5119	108	23	death	death	NOUN
cblr-5119	108	24	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	108	25	alleging	allege	VERB
cblr-5119	108	26	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	108	27	pena	pena	PROPN
cblr-5119	108	28	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-5119	108	29	irala	irala	PROPN
cblr-5119	108	30	had	have	AUX
cblr-5119	108	31	tortured	torture	VERB
cblr-5119	108	32	their	their	PRON
cblr-5119	108	33	family	family	NOUN
cblr-5119	108	34	member	member	NOUN
cblr-5119	108	35	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	108	36	death	death	NOUN
cblr-5119	108	37	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	108	38	paraguay	paraguay	NOUN
cblr-5119	108	39	when	when	SCONJ
cblr-5119	108	40	pena	pena	PROPN
cblr-5119	108	41	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-5119	108	42	irala	irala	PROPN
cblr-5119	108	43	was	be	AUX
cblr-5119	108	44	serving	serve	VERB
cblr-5119	108	45	as	as	ADP
cblr-5119	108	46	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	108	47	local	local	ADJ
cblr-5119	108	48	police	police	NOUN
cblr-5119	108	49	official.33	official.33	NOUN
cblr-5119	108	50	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	108	51	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	108	52	held	hold	VERB
cblr-5119	108	53	there	there	ADV
cblr-5119	108	54	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	108	55	statesponsored	statesponsore	VERB
cblr-5119	108	56	torture	torture	NOUN
cblr-5119	108	57	violated	violate	VERB
cblr-5119	108	58	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	108	59	newly	newly	ADV
cblr-5119	108	60	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-5119	108	61	recognized	recognize	VERB
cblr-5119	108	62	norm	norm	NOUN
cblr-5119	108	63	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	108	64	international	international	ADJ
cblr-5119	108	65	human	human	ADJ
cblr-5119	108	66	rights	right	NOUN
cblr-5119	108	67	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	108	68	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	108	69	it	it	PRON
cblr-5119	108	70	thus	thus	ADV
cblr-5119	108	71	constituted	constitute	VERB
cblr-5119	108	72	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	108	73	violation	violation	NOUN
cblr-5119	108	74	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	108	75	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	108	76	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	108	77	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	108	78	nations	nation	NOUN
cblr-5119	108	79	under	under	ADP
cblr-5119	108	80	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	108	81	ats.34	ats.34	NOUN
cblr-5119	108	82	this	this	DET
cblr-5119	108	83	finding	finding	NOUN
cblr-5119	108	84	allowed	allow	VERB
cblr-5119	108	85	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	108	86	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	108	87	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	108	88	exercise	exercise	VERB
cblr-5119	108	89	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NOUN
cblr-5119	108	90	over	over	ADP
cblr-5119	108	91	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	108	92	filartigas	filartigas	NOUN
cblr-5119	108	93	’	'	PUNCT
cblr-5119	108	94	claims	claim	NOUN
cblr-5119	108	95	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	109	1	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	109	2	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	109	3	made	make	VERB
cblr-5119	109	4	clear	clear	ADJ
cblr-5119	109	5	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	109	6	it	it	PRON
cblr-5119	109	7	had	have	VERB
cblr-5119	109	8	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	109	9	examine	examine	VERB
cblr-5119	109	10	international	international	ADJ
cblr-5119	109	11	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	109	12	based	base	VERB
cblr-5119	109	13	on	on	ADP
cblr-5119	109	14	how	how	SCONJ
cblr-5119	109	15	it	it	PRON
cblr-5119	109	16	had	have	AUX
cblr-5119	109	17	evolved	evolve	VERB
cblr-5119	109	18	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	109	19	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	109	20	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	109	21	how	how	SCONJ
cblr-5119	109	22	it	it	PRON
cblr-5119	109	23	existed	exist	VERB
cblr-5119	109	24	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	109	25	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	109	26	time	time	NOUN
cblr-5119	109	27	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	109	28	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	109	29	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	109	30	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	109	31	enactment.35	enactment.35	NOUN
cblr-5119	109	32	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	109	33	order	order	NOUN
cblr-5119	109	34	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	109	35	an	an	DET
cblr-5119	109	36	international	international	ADJ
cblr-5119	109	37	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	109	38	norm	norm	NOUN
cblr-5119	109	39	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	109	40	become	become	VERB
cblr-5119	109	41	binding	bind	VERB
cblr-5119	109	42	among	among	ADP
cblr-5119	109	43	all	all	DET
cblr-5119	109	44	nations	nation	NOUN
cblr-5119	109	45	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	109	46	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	109	47	norm	norm	NOUN
cblr-5119	109	48	must	must	AUX
cblr-5119	109	49	31	31	NUM
cblr-5119	109	50	doe	doe	NOUN
cblr-5119	109	51	v.	v.	ADP
cblr-5119	109	52	exxon	exxon	PROPN
cblr-5119	109	53	mobil	mobil	PROPN
cblr-5119	109	54	corp	corp	PROPN
cblr-5119	109	55	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	109	56	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	109	57	654	654	NUM
cblr-5119	109	58	f.3d	f.3d	NUM
cblr-5119	109	59	11	11	NUM
cblr-5119	109	60	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	109	61	47–48	47–48	NUM
cblr-5119	109	62	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	109	63	d.c	d.c	PROPN
cblr-5119	109	64	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	109	65	cir	cir	PROPN
cblr-5119	109	66	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	109	67	2011	2011	NUM
cblr-5119	109	68	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	109	69	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	109	70	vacated	vacate	VERB
cblr-5119	109	71	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	109	72	527	527	NUM
cblr-5119	109	73	f.	f.	PROPN
cblr-5119	109	74	app’x	app’x	PROPN
cblr-5119	109	75	7	7	NUM
cblr-5119	109	76	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	109	77	d.c	d.c	PROPN
cblr-5119	109	78	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	109	79	cir	cir	PROPN
cblr-5119	109	80	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	109	81	2013	2013	NUM
cblr-5119	109	82	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	109	83	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	109	84	citing	cite	VERB
cblr-5119	109	85	white	white	ADJ
cblr-5119	109	86	v.	v.	ADP
cblr-5119	109	87	cent	cent	NOUN
cblr-5119	109	88	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	110	1	dispensary	dispensary	PROPN
cblr-5119	110	2	&	&	CCONJ
cblr-5119	110	3	emergency	emergency	PROPN
cblr-5119	110	4	hosp	hosp	PROPN
cblr-5119	110	5	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	110	6	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	110	7	99	99	NUM
cblr-5119	110	8	f.2d	f.2d	NOUN
cblr-5119	110	9	355	355	NUM
cblr-5119	110	10	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	110	11	358	358	NUM
cblr-5119	110	12	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	110	13	d.c	d.c	PROPN
cblr-5119	110	14	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	110	15	cir	cir	PROPN
cblr-5119	110	16	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	110	17	1938	1938	NUM
cblr-5119	110	18	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	110	19	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	111	1	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	111	2	internal	internal	ADJ
cblr-5119	111	3	quotation	quotation	NOUN
cblr-5119	111	4	marks	mark	NOUN
cblr-5119	111	5	omitted	omit	VERB
cblr-5119	111	6	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	111	7	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	112	1	32	32	NUM
cblr-5119	112	2	bellia	bellia	PROPN
cblr-5119	112	3	jr	jr	PROPN
cblr-5119	112	4	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	112	5	&	&	CCONJ
cblr-5119	112	6	clark	clark	PROPN
cblr-5119	112	7	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	112	8	supra	supra	PROPN
cblr-5119	112	9	note	note	PROPN
cblr-5119	112	10	13	13	NUM
cblr-5119	112	11	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	112	12	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	112	13	478	478	NUM
cblr-5119	112	14	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	113	1	33	33	NUM
cblr-5119	113	2	filartiga	filartiga	ADJ
cblr-5119	113	3	v.	v.	ADP
cblr-5119	113	4	pena	pena	NOUN
cblr-5119	113	5	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-5119	113	6	irala	irala	NOUN
cblr-5119	113	7	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	113	8	630	630	NUM
cblr-5119	113	9	f.2d	f.2d	ADP
cblr-5119	113	10	876	876	NUM
cblr-5119	113	11	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	113	12	878	878	NUM
cblr-5119	113	13	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	113	14	2d	2d	NUM
cblr-5119	113	15	cir	cir	NOUN
cblr-5119	113	16	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	113	17	1980	1980	NUM
cblr-5119	113	18	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	113	19	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	114	1	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	114	2	dispute	dispute	NOUN
cblr-5119	114	3	can	can	AUX
cblr-5119	114	4	be	be	AUX
cblr-5119	114	5	categorized	categorize	VERB
cblr-5119	114	6	as	as	ADP
cblr-5119	114	7	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	114	8	foreign	foreign	ADJ
cblr-5119	114	9	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-5119	114	10	cubed	cube	VERB
cblr-5119	114	11	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	114	12	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	114	13	meaning	mean	VERB
cblr-5119	114	14	it	it	PRON
cblr-5119	114	15	involved	involve	VERB
cblr-5119	114	16	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	114	17	foreign	foreign	ADJ
cblr-5119	114	18	plaintiff(s	plaintiff(s	NOUN
cblr-5119	114	19	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	114	20	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	114	21	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	114	22	foreign	foreign	ADJ
cblr-5119	114	23	defendant	defendant	NOUN
cblr-5119	114	24	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	114	25	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	114	26	conduct	conduct	NOUN
cblr-5119	114	27	occurring	occur	VERB
cblr-5119	114	28	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	114	29	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	114	30	foreign	foreign	ADJ
cblr-5119	114	31	country	country	NOUN
cblr-5119	114	32	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	115	1	34	34	NUM
cblr-5119	116	1	i	i	PRON
cblr-5119	116	2	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-5119	116	3	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	116	4	880	880	NUM
cblr-5119	116	5	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	116	6	35	35	NUM
cblr-5119	117	1	i	i	PRON
cblr-5119	117	2	d.	d.	NOUN
cblr-5119	117	3	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	117	4	881	881	NUM
cblr-5119	117	5	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	118	1	6_2019.3_estes	6_2019.3_estes	NUM
cblr-5119	118	2	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	118	3	do	do	AUX
cblr-5119	118	4	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	118	5	delte	delte	VERB
cblr-5119	118	6	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	118	7	12/26/2019	12/26/2019	NUM
cblr-5119	118	8	12:00	12:00	NUM
cblr-5119	118	9	am	am	NOUN
cblr-5119	118	10	1040	1040	NUM
cblr-5119	118	11	columbia	columbia	PROPN
cblr-5119	118	12	business	business	NOUN
cblr-5119	118	13	law	law	PROPN
cblr-5119	118	14	review	review	NOUN
cblr-5119	118	15	[	[	X
cblr-5119	118	16	vol	vol	NOUN
cblr-5119	118	17	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	118	18	2019	2019	NUM
cblr-5119	118	19	command	command	NOUN
cblr-5119	118	20	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	118	21	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	118	22	general	general	ADJ
cblr-5119	118	23	assent	assent	NOUN
cblr-5119	118	24	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	118	25	civilized	civilized	ADJ
cblr-5119	118	26	nations	nation	NOUN
cblr-5119	118	27	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	119	1	”36	”36	ADJ
cblr-5119	119	2	torture	torture	NOUN
cblr-5119	119	3	had	have	AUX
cblr-5119	119	4	gained	gain	VERB
cblr-5119	119	5	this	this	DET
cblr-5119	119	6	status	status	NOUN
cblr-5119	119	7	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	119	8	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	119	9	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	119	10	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	119	11	view	view	NOUN
cblr-5119	119	12	because	because	SCONJ
cblr-5119	119	13	it	it	PRON
cblr-5119	119	14	found	find	VERB
cblr-5119	119	15	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	119	16	international	international	ADJ
cblr-5119	119	17	agreements	agreement	NOUN
cblr-5119	119	18	evinced	evince	VERB
cblr-5119	119	19	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	119	20	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	119	21	universal	universal	ADJ
cblr-5119	119	22	condemnation	condemnation	NOUN
cblr-5119	119	23	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	119	24	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	119	25	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	119	26	practice.37	practice.37	NOUN
cblr-5119	119	27	interestingly	interestingly	ADV
cblr-5119	119	28	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	119	29	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	119	30	closing	close	VERB
cblr-5119	119	31	its	its	PRON
cblr-5119	119	32	opinion	opinion	NOUN
cblr-5119	119	33	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	119	34	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	119	35	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	119	36	referred	refer	VERB
cblr-5119	119	37	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	119	38	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	119	39	most	most	ADV
cblr-5119	119	40	infamous	infamous	ADJ
cblr-5119	119	41	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	119	42	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	119	43	nations	nation	NOUN
cblr-5119	119	44	violators	violator	NOUN
cblr-5119	119	45	known	know	VERB
cblr-5119	119	46	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	119	47	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	119	48	late	late	ADJ
cblr-5119	119	49	18th	18th	ADJ
cblr-5119	119	50	century	century	NOUN
cblr-5119	119	51	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	119	52	declaring	declare	VERB
cblr-5119	119	53	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	119	54	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	119	55	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	119	56	torturer	torturer	NOUN
cblr-5119	119	57	has	have	AUX
cblr-5119	119	58	become	become	VERB
cblr-5119	119	59	like	like	ADP
cblr-5119	119	60	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	119	61	pirate	pirate	NOUN
cblr-5119	119	62	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	119	63	slave	slave	NOUN
cblr-5119	119	64	trader	trader	NOUN
cblr-5119	119	65	before	before	ADP
cblr-5119	119	66	him	he	PRON
cblr-5119	119	67	hostis	hostis	PROPN
cblr-5119	119	68	humani	humani	X
cblr-5119	119	69	generis	generis	PROPN
cblr-5119	119	70	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	119	71	an	an	DET
cblr-5119	119	72	enemy	enemy	NOUN
cblr-5119	119	73	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	119	74	all	all	DET
cblr-5119	119	75	mankind	mankind	NOUN
cblr-5119	119	76	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	120	1	”38	”38	NOUN
cblr-5119	120	2	this	this	DET
cblr-5119	120	3	one	one	NUM
cblr-5119	120	4	sentence	sentence	NOUN
cblr-5119	120	5	well	well	ADV
cblr-5119	120	6	illustrates	illustrate	VERB
cblr-5119	120	7	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	120	8	leap	leap	NOUN
cblr-5119	120	9	from	from	ADP
cblr-5119	120	10	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	120	11	cloudy	cloudy	ADJ
cblr-5119	120	12	origins	origin	NOUN
cblr-5119	120	13	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	120	14	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	120	15	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	120	16	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	120	17	its	its	PRON
cblr-5119	120	18	sudden	sudden	ADJ
cblr-5119	120	19	invocation	invocation	NOUN
cblr-5119	120	20	as	as	ADP
cblr-5119	120	21	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	120	22	tool	tool	NOUN
cblr-5119	120	23	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	120	24	fighting	fight	VERB
cblr-5119	120	25	human	human	ADJ
cblr-5119	120	26	rights	right	NOUN
cblr-5119	120	27	abuses	abuse	NOUN
cblr-5119	120	28	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	120	29	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	120	30	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	120	31	federal	federal	ADJ
cblr-5119	120	32	courts	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	120	33	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	121	1	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	121	2	second	second	ADJ
cblr-5119	121	3	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	121	4	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	121	5	decision	decision	NOUN
cblr-5119	121	6	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	121	7	filartiga	filartiga	ADJ
cblr-5119	121	8	spawned	spawn	VERB
cblr-5119	121	9	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	121	10	wave	wave	NOUN
cblr-5119	121	11	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	121	12	litigation.39	litigation.39	NOUN
cblr-5119	121	13	increasingly	increasingly	ADV
cblr-5119	121	14	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	121	15	beginning	begin	VERB
cblr-5119	121	16	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	121	17	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	121	18	mid-1990s	mid-1990	NOUN
cblr-5119	121	19	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	121	20	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	121	21	became	become	VERB
cblr-5119	121	22	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	121	23	focus	focus	NOUN
cblr-5119	121	24	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	121	25	this	this	DET
cblr-5119	121	26	litigation.40	litigation.40	PROPN
cblr-5119	121	27	human	human	ADJ
cblr-5119	121	28	rights	right	NOUN
cblr-5119	121	29	advocates	advocate	NOUN
cblr-5119	121	30	sued	sue	VERB
cblr-5119	121	31	multinationals	multinational	NOUN
cblr-5119	121	32	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	121	33	their	their	PRON
cblr-5119	121	34	alleged	allege	VERB
cblr-5119	121	35	complicity	complicity	NOUN
cblr-5119	121	36	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	121	37	abuses	abuse	NOUN
cblr-5119	121	38	committed	commit	VERB
cblr-5119	121	39	abroad	abroad	ADV
cblr-5119	121	40	as	as	ADP
cblr-5119	121	41	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	121	42	result	result	NOUN
cblr-5119	121	43	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	121	44	businesses	business	NOUN
cblr-5119	121	45	’	'	PUNCT
cblr-5119	121	46	joint	joint	ADJ
cblr-5119	121	47	projects	project	NOUN
cblr-5119	121	48	with	with	ADP
cblr-5119	121	49	host	host	NOUN
cblr-5119	121	50	governments.41	governments.41	NOUN
cblr-5119	121	51	naturally	naturally	ADV
cblr-5119	121	52	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	121	53	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	121	54	pushed	push	VERB
cblr-5119	121	55	back	back	ADV
cblr-5119	121	56	against	against	ADP
cblr-5119	121	57	this	this	DET
cblr-5119	121	58	development	development	NOUN
cblr-5119	121	59	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	121	60	arguing	argue	VERB
cblr-5119	121	61	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	121	62	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
cblr-5119	121	63	should	should	AUX
cblr-5119	121	64	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	121	65	be	be	AUX
cblr-5119	121	66	allowed	allow	VERB
cblr-5119	121	67	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	121	68	use	use	VERB
cblr-5119	121	69	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	121	70	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	121	71	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	121	72	assert	assert	VERB
cblr-5119	121	73	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NOUN
cblr-5119	121	74	over	over	ADP
cblr-5119	121	75	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	121	76	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	121	77	hold	hold	VERB
cblr-5119	121	78	them	they	PRON
cblr-5119	121	79	liable	liable	ADJ
cblr-5119	121	80	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	121	81	abuses	abuse	NOUN
cblr-5119	121	82	occurring	occur	VERB
cblr-5119	121	83	abroad.42	abroad.42	ADV
cblr-5119	121	84	36	36	NUM
cblr-5119	122	1	i	i	PROPN
cblr-5119	122	2	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-5119	122	3	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	122	4	881	881	NUM
cblr-5119	122	5	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	122	6	37	37	NUM
cblr-5119	123	1	i	i	PRON
cblr-5119	123	2	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-5119	123	3	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	123	4	880	880	NUM
cblr-5119	123	5	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	124	1	38	38	NUM
cblr-5119	124	2	i	i	PRON
cblr-5119	124	3	d.	d.	NOUN
cblr-5119	124	4	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	124	5	890	890	NUM
cblr-5119	124	6	.	.	NUM
cblr-5119	124	7	39	39	NUM
cblr-5119	124	8	joel	joel	PROPN
cblr-5119	124	9	slawotsky	slawotsky	PROPN
cblr-5119	124	10	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	124	11	are	be	AUX
cblr-5119	124	12	financial	financial	ADJ
cblr-5119	124	13	institutions	institution	NOUN
cblr-5119	124	14	liable	liable	ADJ
cblr-5119	124	15	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	124	16	financial	financial	ADJ
cblr-5119	124	17	crime	crime	NOUN
cblr-5119	124	18	under	under	ADP
cblr-5119	124	19	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	124	20	alien	alien	PROPN
cblr-5119	124	21	tort	tort	NOUN
cblr-5119	124	22	statute	statute	NOUN
cblr-5119	124	23	?	?	PROPN
cblr-5119	124	24	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	124	25	15	15	NUM
cblr-5119	124	26	u.	u.	PROPN
cblr-5119	124	27	pa	pa	PROPN
cblr-5119	124	28	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	124	29	j.	j.	PROPN
cblr-5119	124	30	bus	bus	PROPN
cblr-5119	124	31	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	125	1	l.	l.	PROPN
cblr-5119	125	2	957	957	NUM
cblr-5119	125	3	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	125	4	981	981	NUM
cblr-5119	125	5	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	125	6	2013	2013	NUM
cblr-5119	125	7	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	125	8	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	126	1	40	40	NUM
cblr-5119	126	2	fox	fox	PROPN
cblr-5119	126	3	&	&	CCONJ
cblr-5119	126	4	goze	goze	PROPN
cblr-5119	126	5	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	126	6	supra	supra	PROPN
cblr-5119	126	7	note	note	NOUN
cblr-5119	126	8	5	5	NUM
cblr-5119	126	9	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	126	10	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	126	11	45	45	NUM
cblr-5119	126	12	.	.	NOUN
cblr-5119	126	13	41	41	NUM
cblr-5119	126	14	lee	lee	PROPN
cblr-5119	126	15	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	126	16	supra	supra	PROPN
cblr-5119	126	17	note	note	PROPN
cblr-5119	126	18	12	12	NUM
cblr-5119	126	19	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	126	20	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	126	21	841	841	NUM
cblr-5119	126	22	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	127	1	42	42	NUM
cblr-5119	127	2	martin	martin	PROPN
cblr-5119	127	3	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	127	4	supra	supra	PROPN
cblr-5119	127	5	note	note	PROPN
cblr-5119	127	6	6	6	NUM
cblr-5119	127	7	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	127	8	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	127	9	961	961	NUM
cblr-5119	127	10	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	128	1	businesses	business	NOUN
cblr-5119	128	2	have	have	AUX
cblr-5119	128	3	mainly	mainly	ADV
cblr-5119	128	4	utilized	utilize	VERB
cblr-5119	128	5	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	128	6	arguments	argument	NOUN
cblr-5119	128	7	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	128	8	international	international	ADJ
cblr-5119	128	9	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	128	10	should	should	AUX
cblr-5119	128	11	control	control	VERB
cblr-5119	128	12	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	128	13	question	question	NOUN
cblr-5119	128	14	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	128	15	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	128	16	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	128	17	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	128	18	as	as	SCONJ
cblr-5119	128	19	it	it	PRON
cblr-5119	128	20	stands	stand	VERB
cblr-5119	128	21	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	128	22	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	128	23	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	128	24	is	be	AUX
cblr-5119	128	25	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	128	26	sufficiently	sufficiently	ADV
cblr-5119	128	27	recognized	recognize	VERB
cblr-5119	128	28	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	128	29	international	international	ADJ
cblr-5119	128	30	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	128	31	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	128	32	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	128	33	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	128	34	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	128	35	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	128	36	should	should	AUX
cblr-5119	128	37	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	128	38	reach	reach	VERB
cblr-5119	128	39	extraterritorial	extraterritorial	ADJ
cblr-5119	128	40	conduct	conduct	NOUN
cblr-5119	128	41	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	129	1	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	129	2	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	129	3	discussion	discussion	NOUN
cblr-5119	129	4	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	129	5	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	129	6	former	former	ADJ
cblr-5119	129	7	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	129	8	see	see	VERB
cblr-5119	129	9	generally	generally	ADV
cblr-5119	129	10	kiobel	kiobel	PROPN
cblr-5119	129	11	v.	v.	ADP
cblr-5119	129	12	royal	royal	PROPN
cblr-5119	129	13	dutch	dutch	PROPN
cblr-5119	129	14	petroleum	petroleum	PROPN
cblr-5119	129	15	co.	co.	PROPN
cblr-5119	129	16	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	129	17	621	621	NUM
cblr-5119	129	18	f.3d	f.3d	NUM
cblr-5119	129	19	111	111	NUM
cblr-5119	129	20	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	129	21	2d	2d	NUM
cblr-5119	129	22	cir	cir	NOUN
cblr-5119	129	23	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	129	24	2010	2010	NUM
cblr-5119	129	25	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	129	26	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	129	27	aff’d	aff’d	VERB
cblr-5119	129	28	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	129	29	569	569	NUM
cblr-5119	129	30	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	129	31	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	129	32	108	108	NUM
cblr-5119	129	33	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	129	34	2013	2013	NUM
cblr-5119	129	35	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	129	36	;	;	PUNCT
cblr-5119	129	37	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	129	38	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	129	39	discussion	discussion	NOUN
cblr-5119	129	40	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	129	41	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	129	42	latter	latter	ADJ
cblr-5119	129	43	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	129	44	see	see	VERB
cblr-5119	129	45	generally	generally	ADV
cblr-5119	129	46	kiobel	kiobel	PROPN
cblr-5119	129	47	v.	v.	ADP
cblr-5119	129	48	royal	royal	PROPN
cblr-5119	129	49	dutch	dutch	PROPN
cblr-5119	129	50	petroleum	petroleum	PROPN
cblr-5119	129	51	co.	co.	PROPN
cblr-5119	129	52	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	130	1	569	569	NUM
cblr-5119	130	2	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	130	3	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	130	4	108	108	NUM
cblr-5119	130	5	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	130	6	2013	2013	NUM
cblr-5119	130	7	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	130	8	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	131	1	6_2019.3_estes	6_2019.3_estes	NUM
cblr-5119	131	2	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	131	3	do	do	AUX
cblr-5119	131	4	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	131	5	delete	delete	VERB
cblr-5119	131	6	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	131	7	12/26/2019	12/26/2019	NUM
cblr-5119	131	8	12:00	12:00	NUM
cblr-5119	131	9	am	be	AUX
cblr-5119	131	10	no	no	NOUN
cblr-5119	131	11	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	132	1	3:1031	3:1031	NUM
cblr-5119	132	2	]	]	X
cblr-5119	132	3	may	may	AUX
cblr-5119	132	4	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	132	5	fourth	fourth	ADJ
cblr-5119	132	6	be	be	AUX
cblr-5119	132	7	with	with	ADP
cblr-5119	132	8	you	you	PRON
cblr-5119	132	9	1041	1041	NUM
cblr-5119	132	10	c.	c.	NOUN
cblr-5119	132	11	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	132	12	supreme	supreme	PROPN
cblr-5119	132	13	court	court	PROPN
cblr-5119	132	14	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	132	15	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	132	16	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	132	17	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	132	18	supreme	supreme	PROPN
cblr-5119	132	19	court	court	PROPN
cblr-5119	132	20	finally	finally	ADV
cblr-5119	132	21	weighed	weigh	VERB
cblr-5119	132	22	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	132	23	on	on	ADP
cblr-5119	132	24	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	132	25	ats	at	NOUN
cblr-5119	132	26	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	132	27	albeit	albeit	SCONJ
cblr-5119	132	28	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	132	29	on	on	ADP
cblr-5119	132	30	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	132	31	issue	issue	NOUN
cblr-5119	132	32	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	132	33	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	132	34	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	132	35	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	132	36	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	132	37	sosa	sosa	PROPN
cblr-5119	132	38	v.	v.	ADP
cblr-5119	132	39	alvarezmachain	alvarezmachain	PROPN
cblr-5119	132	40	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	133	1	disparate	disparate	ADJ
cblr-5119	133	2	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	133	3	regimes	regime	NOUN
cblr-5119	133	4	developed	develop	VERB
cblr-5119	133	5	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	133	6	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	133	7	wake	wake	NOUN
cblr-5119	133	8	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	133	9	this	this	DET
cblr-5119	133	10	ruling	ruling	NOUN
cblr-5119	133	11	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	133	12	reflecting	reflect	VERB
cblr-5119	133	13	its	its	PRON
cblr-5119	133	14	status	status	NOUN
cblr-5119	133	15	as	as	ADP
cblr-5119	133	16	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	133	17	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	133	18	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	133	19	model	model	NOUN
cblr-5119	133	20	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	133	21	clarity	clarity	NOUN
cblr-5119	133	22	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	134	1	”43	”43	PROPN
cblr-5119	134	2	nevertheless	nevertheless	ADV
cblr-5119	134	3	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	134	4	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	134	5	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	134	6	advanced	advance	VERB
cblr-5119	134	7	several	several	ADJ
cblr-5119	134	8	key	key	ADJ
cblr-5119	134	9	principles	principle	NOUN
cblr-5119	134	10	regarding	regard	VERB
cblr-5119	134	11	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	134	12	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	134	13	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	135	1	first	first	ADV
cblr-5119	135	2	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	135	3	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	135	4	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	135	5	held	hold	VERB
cblr-5119	135	6	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	135	7	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	135	8	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	135	9	is	be	AUX
cblr-5119	135	10	purely	purely	ADV
cblr-5119	135	11	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	135	12	jurisdictional	jurisdictional	ADJ
cblr-5119	135	13	statute	statute	NOUN
cblr-5119	135	14	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	135	15	does	do	AUX
cblr-5119	135	16	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	135	17	create	create	VERB
cblr-5119	135	18	any	any	DET
cblr-5119	135	19	new	new	ADJ
cblr-5119	135	20	causes	cause	NOUN
cblr-5119	135	21	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	135	22	action.44	action.44	NOUN
cblr-5119	135	23	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	135	24	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	135	25	same	same	ADJ
cblr-5119	135	26	time	time	NOUN
cblr-5119	135	27	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	135	28	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	135	29	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	135	30	recognized	recognize	VERB
cblr-5119	135	31	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	135	32	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	135	33	first	first	ADJ
cblr-5119	135	34	congress	congress	PROPN
cblr-5119	135	35	did	do	AUX
cblr-5119	135	36	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	135	37	intend	intend	VERB
cblr-5119	135	38	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	135	39	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	135	40	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	135	41	be	be	AUX
cblr-5119	135	42	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	135	43	dead	dead	ADJ
cblr-5119	135	44	letter	letter	NOUN
cblr-5119	135	45	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	135	46	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	135	47	it	it	PRON
cblr-5119	135	48	enacted	enact	VERB
cblr-5119	135	49	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	135	50	statute	statute	NOUN
cblr-5119	135	51	with	with	ADP
cblr-5119	135	52	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	135	53	understanding	understanding	NOUN
cblr-5119	135	54	that	that	PRON
cblr-5119	135	55	causes	cause	NOUN
cblr-5119	135	56	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	135	57	action	action	NOUN
cblr-5119	135	58	would	would	AUX
cblr-5119	135	59	be	be	AUX
cblr-5119	135	60	derived	derive	VERB
cblr-5119	135	61	from	from	ADP
cblr-5119	135	62	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	135	63	common	common	ADJ
cblr-5119	135	64	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	135	65	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	135	66	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	135	67	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	135	68	modest	modest	ADJ
cblr-5119	135	69	number	number	NOUN
cblr-5119	135	70	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	135	71	international	international	ADJ
cblr-5119	135	72	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	135	73	violations	violation	NOUN
cblr-5119	135	74	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	135	75	that	that	PRON
cblr-5119	135	76	could	could	AUX
cblr-5119	135	77	have	have	AUX
cblr-5119	135	78	resulted	result	VERB
cblr-5119	135	79	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	135	80	personal	personal	ADJ
cblr-5119	135	81	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	135	82	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	135	83	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	135	84	late	late	ADJ
cblr-5119	135	85	18th	18th	NOUN
cblr-5119	135	86	century.45	century.45	NOUN
cblr-5119	135	87	second	second	ADJ
cblr-5119	135	88	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	135	89	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	135	90	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	135	91	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	135	92	found	find	VERB
cblr-5119	135	93	no	no	DET
cblr-5119	135	94	basis	basis	NOUN
cblr-5119	135	95	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	135	96	suspect	suspect	VERB
cblr-5119	135	97	congress	congress	PROPN
cblr-5119	135	98	had	have	VERB
cblr-5119	135	99	any	any	DET
cblr-5119	135	100	examples	example	NOUN
cblr-5119	135	101	[	[	X
cblr-5119	135	102	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	135	103	torts	tort	NOUN
cblr-5119	135	104	]	]	PUNCT
cblr-5119	135	105	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	135	106	mind	mind	NOUN
cblr-5119	135	107	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	135	108	other	other	ADJ
cblr-5119	135	109	than	than	ADP
cblr-5119	135	110	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	135	111	narrow	narrow	ADJ
cblr-5119	135	112	set	set	NOUN
cblr-5119	135	113	identified	identify	VERB
cblr-5119	135	114	by	by	ADP
cblr-5119	135	115	william	william	PROPN
cblr-5119	135	116	blackstone	blackstone	PROPN
cblr-5119	135	117	:	:	PUNCT
cblr-5119	135	118	violation	violation	NOUN
cblr-5119	135	119	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	135	120	safe	safe	ADJ
cblr-5119	135	121	conducts	conduct	NOUN
cblr-5119	135	122	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	135	123	infringement	infringement	NOUN
cblr-5119	135	124	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	135	125	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	135	126	rights	right	NOUN
cblr-5119	135	127	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	135	128	ambassadors	ambassador	NOUN
cblr-5119	135	129	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	135	130	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	135	131	piracy.46	piracy.46	PROPN
cblr-5119	135	132	as	as	ADP
cblr-5119	135	133	such	such	ADJ
cblr-5119	135	134	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	135	135	courts	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	135	136	were	be	AUX
cblr-5119	135	137	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	135	138	continue	continue	VERB
cblr-5119	135	139	exercising	exercise	VERB
cblr-5119	135	140	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NOUN
cblr-5119	135	141	under	under	ADP
cblr-5119	135	142	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	135	143	ats	at	NOUN
cblr-5119	135	144	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	135	145	but	but	CCONJ
cblr-5119	135	146	only	only	ADV
cblr-5119	135	147	when	when	SCONJ
cblr-5119	135	148	claims	claim	NOUN
cblr-5119	135	149	involved	involve	VERB
cblr-5119	135	150	an	an	DET
cblr-5119	135	151	alleged	alleged	ADJ
cblr-5119	135	152	violation	violation	NOUN
cblr-5119	135	153	that	that	PRON
cblr-5119	135	154	rested	rest	VERB
cblr-5119	135	155	on	on	ADP
cblr-5119	135	156	an	an	DET
cblr-5119	135	157	international	international	ADJ
cblr-5119	135	158	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	135	159	norm	norm	NOUN
cblr-5119	135	160	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	135	161	accepted	accept	VERB
cblr-5119	135	162	by	by	ADP
cblr-5119	135	163	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	135	164	civilized	civilized	ADJ
cblr-5119	135	165	world	world	NOUN
cblr-5119	135	166	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	135	167	defined	define	VERB
cblr-5119	135	168	with	with	ADP
cblr-5119	135	169	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	135	170	specificity	specificity	NOUN
cblr-5119	135	171	comparable	comparable	ADJ
cblr-5119	135	172	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	135	173	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	135	174	features	feature	NOUN
cblr-5119	135	175	of”47	of”47	ADV
cblr-5119	135	176	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	135	177	three	three	NUM
cblr-5119	135	178	aforementioned	aforementioned	ADJ
cblr-5119	135	179	torts.48	torts.48	NOUN
cblr-5119	135	180	finally	finally	ADV
cblr-5119	135	181	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	135	182	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	135	183	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	135	184	expressly	expressly	ADV
cblr-5119	135	185	43	43	NUM
cblr-5119	135	186	bellia	bellia	NOUN
cblr-5119	135	187	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	135	188	jr	jr	PROPN
cblr-5119	135	189	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	135	190	&	&	CCONJ
cblr-5119	135	191	clark	clark	PROPN
cblr-5119	135	192	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	135	193	supra	supra	PROPN
cblr-5119	135	194	note	note	PROPN
cblr-5119	135	195	13	13	NUM
cblr-5119	135	196	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	135	197	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	135	198	458	458	NUM
cblr-5119	135	199	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	136	1	44	44	NUM
cblr-5119	136	2	sosa	sosa	PROPN
cblr-5119	136	3	v.	v.	PROPN
cblr-5119	136	4	alvarez	alvarez	PROPN
cblr-5119	136	5	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-5119	136	6	machain	machain	NOUN
cblr-5119	136	7	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	136	8	542	542	NUM
cblr-5119	136	9	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	136	10	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	136	11	692	692	NUM
cblr-5119	136	12	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	136	13	724	724	NUM
cblr-5119	136	14	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	136	15	2004	2004	NUM
cblr-5119	136	16	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	136	17	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	137	1	45	45	NUM
cblr-5119	138	1	i	i	PRON
cblr-5119	138	2	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-5119	138	3	46	46	NUM
cblr-5119	139	1	i	i	PRON
cblr-5119	139	2	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-5119	139	3	47	47	NUM
cblr-5119	140	1	i	i	PRON
cblr-5119	140	2	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-5119	140	3	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	140	4	725	725	NUM
cblr-5119	140	5	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	141	1	while	while	SCONJ
cblr-5119	141	2	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	141	3	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	141	4	did	do	AUX
cblr-5119	141	5	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	141	6	provide	provide	VERB
cblr-5119	141	7	precise	precise	ADJ
cblr-5119	141	8	guidance	guidance	NOUN
cblr-5119	141	9	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	141	10	how	how	SCONJ
cblr-5119	141	11	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	141	12	determine	determine	VERB
cblr-5119	141	13	whether	whether	SCONJ
cblr-5119	141	14	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	141	15	norm	norm	NOUN
cblr-5119	141	16	had	have	AUX
cblr-5119	141	17	become	become	AUX
cblr-5119	141	18	sufficiently	sufficiently	ADV
cblr-5119	141	19	accepted	accept	VERB
cblr-5119	141	20	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	141	21	specifically	specifically	ADV
cblr-5119	141	22	defined	define	VERB
cblr-5119	141	23	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	141	24	it	it	PRON
cblr-5119	141	25	did	do	AUX
cblr-5119	141	26	indicate	indicate	VERB
cblr-5119	141	27	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	141	28	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	141	29	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	141	30	conducting	conduct	VERB
cblr-5119	141	31	such	such	DET
cblr-5119	141	32	an	an	DET
cblr-5119	141	33	examination	examination	NOUN
cblr-5119	141	34	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	141	35	courts	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	141	36	should	should	AUX
cblr-5119	141	37	consult	consult	VERB
cblr-5119	141	38	treaties	treaty	NOUN
cblr-5119	141	39	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	141	40	international	international	ADJ
cblr-5119	141	41	agreements	agreement	NOUN
cblr-5119	141	42	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	141	43	nations	nation	NOUN
cblr-5119	141	44	’	'	PUNCT
cblr-5119	141	45	practices	practice	NOUN
cblr-5119	141	46	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	141	47	customs	custom	NOUN
cblr-5119	141	48	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	141	49	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	141	50	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	141	51	works	work	NOUN
cblr-5119	141	52	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	141	53	scholars	scholar	NOUN
cblr-5119	141	54	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	141	55	commentators	commentator	NOUN
cblr-5119	141	56	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	141	57	insofar	insofar	ADV
cblr-5119	141	58	as	as	SCONJ
cblr-5119	141	59	they	they	PRON
cblr-5119	141	60	explain	explain	VERB
cblr-5119	141	61	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	141	62	present	present	ADJ
cblr-5119	141	63	state	state	NOUN
cblr-5119	141	64	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	141	65	international	international	ADJ
cblr-5119	141	66	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	141	67	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	141	68	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	142	1	i	i	PRON
cblr-5119	142	2	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-5119	142	3	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	142	4	733–34	733–34	PROPN
cblr-5119	142	5	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	142	6	citing	cite	VERB
cblr-5119	142	7	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	142	8	paquete	paquete	PROPN
cblr-5119	142	9	habana	habana	PROPN
cblr-5119	142	10	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	142	11	175	175	NUM
cblr-5119	142	12	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	142	13	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	142	14	677	677	NUM
cblr-5119	142	15	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	142	16	700	700	NUM
cblr-5119	142	17	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	142	18	1900	1900	NUM
cblr-5119	142	19	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	142	20	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	142	21	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	143	1	48	48	NUM
cblr-5119	144	1	i	i	PRON
cblr-5119	144	2	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-5119	144	3	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	144	4	734	734	NUM
cblr-5119	144	5	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	145	1	as	as	SCONJ
cblr-5119	145	2	discussed	discuss	VERB
cblr-5119	145	3	supra	supra	NOUN
cblr-5119	145	4	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	145	5	there	there	PRON
cblr-5119	145	6	is	be	VERB
cblr-5119	145	7	evidence	evidence	NOUN
cblr-5119	145	8	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	145	9	suggest	suggest	VERB
cblr-5119	145	10	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	145	11	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	145	12	first	first	ADJ
cblr-5119	145	13	congress	congress	PROPN
cblr-5119	145	14	had	have	VERB
cblr-5119	145	15	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	145	16	far	far	ADV
cblr-5119	145	17	wider	wide	ADJ
cblr-5119	145	18	range	range	NOUN
cblr-5119	145	19	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	145	20	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	145	21	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	145	22	nations	nation	NOUN
cblr-5119	145	23	violations	violation	NOUN
cblr-5119	145	24	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	145	25	mind	mind	NOUN
cblr-5119	145	26	when	when	SCONJ
cblr-5119	145	27	it	it	PRON
cblr-5119	145	28	passed	pass	VERB
cblr-5119	145	29	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	145	30	ats	at	NOUN
cblr-5119	145	31	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	145	32	since	since	SCONJ
cblr-5119	145	33	any	any	DET
cblr-5119	145	34	intentional	intentional	ADJ
cblr-5119	145	35	tort	tort	NOUN
cblr-5119	145	36	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	145	37	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	145	38	person	person	NOUN
cblr-5119	145	39	or	or	CCONJ
cblr-5119	145	40	property	property	NOUN
cblr-5119	145	41	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	145	42	an	an	DET
cblr-5119	145	43	alien	alien	NOUN
cblr-5119	145	44	would	would	AUX
cblr-5119	145	45	amount	amount	VERB
cblr-5119	145	46	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	145	47	such	such	DET
cblr-5119	145	48	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	145	49	violation	violation	NOUN
cblr-5119	145	50	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	145	51	render	render	VERB
cblr-5119	145	52	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	145	53	united	united	PROPN
cblr-5119	145	54	states	states	PROPN
cblr-5119	145	55	6_2019.3_estes	6_2019.3_estes	NUM
cblr-5119	145	56	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	145	57	do	do	AUX
cblr-5119	145	58	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	145	59	delte	delte	VERB
cblr-5119	145	60	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	145	61	12/26/2019	12/26/2019	NUM
cblr-5119	145	62	12:00	12:00	NUM
cblr-5119	145	63	am	be	AUX
cblr-5119	145	64	1042	1042	NUM
cblr-5119	145	65	columbia	columbia	PROPN
cblr-5119	145	66	business	business	NOUN
cblr-5119	145	67	law	law	PROPN
cblr-5119	145	68	review	review	NOUN
cblr-5119	146	1	[	[	X
cblr-5119	146	2	vol	vol	NOUN
cblr-5119	146	3	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	146	4	2019	2019	NUM
cblr-5119	146	5	instructed	instruct	VERB
cblr-5119	146	6	lower	low	ADJ
cblr-5119	146	7	courts	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	146	8	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	146	9	be	be	AUX
cblr-5119	146	10	cautious	cautious	ADJ
cblr-5119	146	11	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	146	12	recognizing	recognize	VERB
cblr-5119	146	13	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	146	14	claims	claim	NOUN
cblr-5119	146	15	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	146	16	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	146	17	following	follow	VERB
cblr-5119	146	18	reasons	reason	NOUN
cblr-5119	146	19	:	:	PUNCT
cblr-5119	146	20	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	146	21	conception	conception	NOUN
cblr-5119	146	22	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	146	23	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	146	24	common	common	ADJ
cblr-5119	146	25	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	146	26	had	have	AUX
cblr-5119	146	27	changed	change	VERB
cblr-5119	146	28	drastically	drastically	ADV
cblr-5119	146	29	since	since	SCONJ
cblr-5119	146	30	1789	1789	NUM
cblr-5119	146	31	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	146	32	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	146	33	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	146	34	way	way	NOUN
cblr-5119	146	35	that	that	PRON
cblr-5119	146	36	called	call	VERB
cblr-5119	146	37	for	for	SCONJ
cblr-5119	146	38	judges	judge	NOUN
cblr-5119	146	39	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	146	40	be	be	AUX
cblr-5119	146	41	restrained	restrain	VERB
cblr-5119	146	42	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	146	43	their	their	PRON
cblr-5119	146	44	discretionary	discretionary	ADJ
cblr-5119	146	45	power	power	NOUN
cblr-5119	146	46	;	;	PUNCT
cblr-5119	146	47	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	146	48	federal	federal	ADJ
cblr-5119	146	49	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	146	50	general	general	ADJ
cblr-5119	146	51	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	146	52	common	common	ADJ
cblr-5119	146	53	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	146	54	no	no	ADV
cblr-5119	146	55	longer	long	ADV
cblr-5119	146	56	existed	exist	VERB
cblr-5119	146	57	;	;	PUNCT
cblr-5119	146	58	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	146	59	legislature	legislature	NOUN
cblr-5119	146	60	was	be	AUX
cblr-5119	146	61	better	well	ADV
cblr-5119	146	62	equipped	equip	VERB
cblr-5119	146	63	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	146	64	create	create	VERB
cblr-5119	146	65	private	private	ADJ
cblr-5119	146	66	rights	right	NOUN
cblr-5119	146	67	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	146	68	action	action	NOUN
cblr-5119	146	69	than	than	ADP
cblr-5119	146	70	courts	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	146	71	;	;	PUNCT
cblr-5119	146	72	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	146	73	possibility	possibility	NOUN
cblr-5119	146	74	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	146	75	adverse	adverse	ADJ
cblr-5119	146	76	foreign	foreign	ADJ
cblr-5119	146	77	policy	policy	NOUN
cblr-5119	146	78	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	146	79	foreign	foreign	ADJ
cblr-5119	146	80	relations	relation	NOUN
cblr-5119	146	81	consequences	consequence	NOUN
cblr-5119	146	82	;	;	PUNCT
cblr-5119	146	83	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	146	84	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	146	85	lack	lack	NOUN
cblr-5119	146	86	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	146	87	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	146	88	congressional	congressional	ADJ
cblr-5119	146	89	mandate	mandate	NOUN
cblr-5119	146	90	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	146	91	define	define	VERB
cblr-5119	146	92	new	new	ADJ
cblr-5119	146	93	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	146	94	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	146	95	nations	nations	PROPN
cblr-5119	146	96	violations.49	violations.49	PROPN
cblr-5119	146	97	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	146	98	sosa	sosa	PROPN
cblr-5119	146	99	court	court	PROPN
cblr-5119	146	100	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	146	101	brief	brief	ADJ
cblr-5119	146	102	reference	reference	NOUN
cblr-5119	146	103	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	146	104	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	146	105	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	146	106	became	become	VERB
cblr-5119	146	107	particularly	particularly	ADV
cblr-5119	146	108	controversial	controversial	ADJ
cblr-5119	146	109	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	147	1	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	147	2	footnote	footnote	NOUN
cblr-5119	147	3	20	20	NUM
cblr-5119	147	4	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	147	5	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	147	6	decision	decision	NOUN
cblr-5119	147	7	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	147	8	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	147	9	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	147	10	stated	state	VERB
cblr-5119	147	11	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	147	12	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	147	13	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	147	14	determining	determine	VERB
cblr-5119	147	15	whether	whether	SCONJ
cblr-5119	147	16	an	an	DET
cblr-5119	147	17	international	international	ADJ
cblr-5119	147	18	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	147	19	norm	norm	NOUN
cblr-5119	147	20	had	have	AUX
cblr-5119	147	21	become	become	AUX
cblr-5119	147	22	sufficiently	sufficiently	ADV
cblr-5119	147	23	accepted	accept	VERB
cblr-5119	147	24	so	so	ADV
cblr-5119	147	25	as	as	SCONJ
cblr-5119	147	26	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	147	27	support	support	VERB
cblr-5119	147	28	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	147	29	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NOUN
cblr-5119	147	30	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	147	31	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	147	32	[	[	X
cblr-5119	147	33	a	a	X
cblr-5119	147	34	]	]	X
cblr-5119	147	35	related	related	ADJ
cblr-5119	147	36	consideration	consideration	NOUN
cblr-5119	147	37	is	be	AUX
cblr-5119	147	38	whether	whether	SCONJ
cblr-5119	147	39	international	international	ADJ
cblr-5119	147	40	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	147	41	extends	extend	VERB
cblr-5119	147	42	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	147	43	scope	scope	NOUN
cblr-5119	147	44	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	147	45	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	147	46	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	147	47	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	147	48	violation	violation	NOUN
cblr-5119	147	49	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	147	50	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	147	51	given	give	VERB
cblr-5119	147	52	norm	norm	NOUN
cblr-5119	147	53	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	147	54	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	147	55	perpetrator	perpetrator	NOUN
cblr-5119	147	56	being	be	AUX
cblr-5119	147	57	sued	sue	VERB
cblr-5119	147	58	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	147	59	if	if	SCONJ
cblr-5119	147	60	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	147	61	defendant	defendant	NOUN
cblr-5119	147	62	is	be	AUX
cblr-5119	147	63	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	147	64	private	private	ADJ
cblr-5119	147	65	actor	actor	NOUN
cblr-5119	147	66	such	such	ADJ
cblr-5119	147	67	as	as	ADP
cblr-5119	147	68	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	147	69	corporation	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	147	70	or	or	CCONJ
cblr-5119	147	71	individual	individual	NOUN
cblr-5119	147	72	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	148	1	”50	”50	NOUN
cblr-5119	149	1	this	this	DET
cblr-5119	149	2	footnote	footnote	NOUN
cblr-5119	149	3	spawned	spawn	VERB
cblr-5119	149	4	two	two	NUM
cblr-5119	149	5	widely	widely	ADV
cblr-5119	149	6	variant	variant	ADJ
cblr-5119	149	7	interpretations	interpretation	NOUN
cblr-5119	149	8	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	150	1	under	under	ADP
cblr-5119	150	2	one	one	NUM
cblr-5119	150	3	interpretation	interpretation	NOUN
cblr-5119	150	4	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	150	5	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	150	6	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	150	7	was	be	AUX
cblr-5119	150	8	distinguishing	distinguish	VERB
cblr-5119	150	9	between	between	ADP
cblr-5119	150	10	international	international	ADJ
cblr-5119	150	11	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	150	12	offenses	offense	NOUN
cblr-5119	150	13	that	that	PRON
cblr-5119	150	14	require	require	VERB
cblr-5119	150	15	state	state	NOUN
cblr-5119	150	16	action	action	NOUN
cblr-5119	150	17	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	150	18	those	those	PRON
cblr-5119	150	19	that	that	PRON
cblr-5119	150	20	do	do	VERB
cblr-5119	150	21	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	150	22	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	150	23	implying	imply	VERB
cblr-5119	150	24	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	150	25	any	any	DET
cblr-5119	150	26	private	private	ADJ
cblr-5119	150	27	actor	actor	NOUN
cblr-5119	150	28	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	150	29	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	150	30	latter	latter	ADJ
cblr-5119	150	31	group	group	NOUN
cblr-5119	150	32	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	150	33	including	include	VERB
cblr-5119	150	34	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	150	35	corporation	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	150	36	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	150	37	would	would	AUX
cblr-5119	150	38	be	be	AUX
cblr-5119	150	39	capable	capable	ADJ
cblr-5119	150	40	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	150	41	committing	commit	VERB
cblr-5119	150	42	an	an	DET
cblr-5119	150	43	offense	offense	NOUN
cblr-5119	150	44	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	151	1	under	under	ADP
cblr-5119	151	2	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	151	3	other	other	ADJ
cblr-5119	151	4	interpretation	interpretation	NOUN
cblr-5119	151	5	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	151	6	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	151	7	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	151	8	was	be	AUX
cblr-5119	151	9	distinguishing	distinguish	VERB
cblr-5119	151	10	between	between	ADP
cblr-5119	151	11	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	151	12	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	151	13	individuals	individual	NOUN
cblr-5119	151	14	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	151	15	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	151	16	larger	large	ADJ
cblr-5119	151	17	category	category	NOUN
cblr-5119	151	18	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	151	19	private	private	ADJ
cblr-5119	151	20	actors	actor	NOUN
cblr-5119	151	21	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	152	1	under	under	ADP
cblr-5119	152	2	this	this	DET
cblr-5119	152	3	reading	reading	NOUN
cblr-5119	152	4	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	152	5	certain	certain	ADJ
cblr-5119	152	6	offenses	offense	NOUN
cblr-5119	152	7	could	could	AUX
cblr-5119	152	8	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	152	9	be	be	AUX
cblr-5119	152	10	committed	commit	VERB
cblr-5119	152	11	by	by	ADP
cblr-5119	152	12	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	152	13	under	under	ADP
cblr-5119	152	14	international	international	ADJ
cblr-5119	152	15	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	152	16	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	152	17	it	it	PRON
cblr-5119	152	18	is	be	AUX
cblr-5119	152	19	up	up	ADP
cblr-5119	152	20	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	152	21	courts	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	152	22	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	152	23	determine	determine	VERB
cblr-5119	152	24	that	that	DET
cblr-5119	152	25	issue	issue	NOUN
cblr-5119	152	26	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	152	27	any	any	DET
cblr-5119	152	28	given	give	VERB
cblr-5119	152	29	offense.51	offense.51	NOUN
cblr-5119	152	30	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	152	31	other	other	ADJ
cblr-5119	152	32	words	word	NOUN
cblr-5119	152	33	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	152	34	under	under	ADP
cblr-5119	152	35	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	152	36	former	former	ADJ
cblr-5119	152	37	interpretation	interpretation	NOUN
cblr-5119	152	38	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	152	39	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	152	40	are	be	AUX
cblr-5119	152	41	cognizable	cognizable	ADJ
cblr-5119	152	42	offenders	offender	NOUN
cblr-5119	152	43	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	152	44	any	any	DET
cblr-5119	152	45	norm	norm	NOUN
cblr-5119	152	46	that	that	PRON
cblr-5119	152	47	does	do	AUX
cblr-5119	152	48	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	152	49	require	require	VERB
cblr-5119	152	50	state	state	NOUN
cblr-5119	152	51	action	action	NOUN
cblr-5119	152	52	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	153	1	under	under	ADP
cblr-5119	153	2	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	153	3	latter	latter	ADJ
cblr-5119	153	4	interpretation	interpretation	NOUN
cblr-5119	153	5	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	153	6	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	153	7	might	might	AUX
cblr-5119	153	8	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	153	9	be	be	AUX
cblr-5119	153	10	cognizable	cognizable	ADJ
cblr-5119	153	11	offenders	offender	NOUN
cblr-5119	153	12	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	153	13	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	153	14	norm	norm	NOUN
cblr-5119	153	15	that	that	PRON
cblr-5119	153	16	does	do	AUX
cblr-5119	153	17	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	153	18	require	require	VERB
cblr-5119	153	19	responsible	responsible	ADJ
cblr-5119	153	20	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	153	21	it	it	PRON
cblr-5119	153	22	unless	unless	SCONJ
cblr-5119	153	23	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	153	24	country	country	NOUN
cblr-5119	153	25	provided	provide	VERB
cblr-5119	153	26	redress	redress	NOUN
cblr-5119	153	27	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	154	1	bellia	bellia	PROPN
cblr-5119	154	2	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	154	3	jr	jr	PROPN
cblr-5119	154	4	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	154	5	&	&	CCONJ
cblr-5119	154	6	clark	clark	PROPN
cblr-5119	154	7	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	154	8	supra	supra	PROPN
cblr-5119	154	9	note	note	PROPN
cblr-5119	154	10	13	13	NUM
cblr-5119	154	11	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	154	12	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	154	13	517–518	517–518	NUM
cblr-5119	154	14	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	155	1	but	but	CCONJ
cblr-5119	155	2	see	see	VERB
cblr-5119	155	3	lee	lee	PROPN
cblr-5119	155	4	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	155	5	supra	supra	PROPN
cblr-5119	155	6	note	note	PROPN
cblr-5119	155	7	12	12	NUM
cblr-5119	155	8	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	155	9	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	155	10	836	836	NUM
cblr-5119	155	11	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	155	12	arguing	argue	VERB
cblr-5119	155	13	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	155	14	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	155	15	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	155	16	was	be	AUX
cblr-5119	155	17	enacted	enact	VERB
cblr-5119	155	18	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	155	19	cover	cover	VERB
cblr-5119	155	20	only	only	ADJ
cblr-5119	155	21	violations	violation	NOUN
cblr-5119	155	22	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	155	23	safe	safe	ADJ
cblr-5119	155	24	conducts	conduct	NOUN
cblr-5119	155	25	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	155	26	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	155	27	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	155	28	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	155	29	redress	redress	VERB
cblr-5119	155	30	piracy	piracy	NOUN
cblr-5119	155	31	or	or	CCONJ
cblr-5119	155	32	infringements	infringement	NOUN
cblr-5119	155	33	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	155	34	ambassadorial	ambassadorial	ADJ
cblr-5119	155	35	rights	right	NOUN
cblr-5119	155	36	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	155	37	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	156	1	49	49	NUM
cblr-5119	156	2	sosa	sosa	PROPN
cblr-5119	156	3	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	156	4	542	542	NUM
cblr-5119	156	5	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	156	6	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	156	7	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	156	8	725–28	725–28	PROPN
cblr-5119	156	9	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	157	1	50	50	NUM
cblr-5119	157	2	i	i	PRON
cblr-5119	157	3	d.	d.	NOUN
cblr-5119	157	4	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	157	5	732	732	NUM
cblr-5119	157	6	n.20	n.20	NOUN
cblr-5119	157	7	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	157	8	emphasis	emphasis	NOUN
cblr-5119	157	9	added	add	VERB
cblr-5119	157	10	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	157	11	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	158	1	51	51	NUM
cblr-5119	158	2	see	see	VERB
cblr-5119	158	3	discussion	discussion	NOUN
cblr-5119	158	4	infra	infra	NOUN
cblr-5119	158	5	section	section	NOUN
cblr-5119	158	6	ii.d	ii.d	PRON
cblr-5119	158	7	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	159	1	6_2019.3_estes	6_2019.3_estes	NUM
cblr-5119	159	2	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	159	3	do	do	AUX
cblr-5119	159	4	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	159	5	delete	delete	VERB
cblr-5119	159	6	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	159	7	12/26/2019	12/26/2019	NUM
cblr-5119	159	8	12:00	12:00	NUM
cblr-5119	159	9	am	be	AUX
cblr-5119	159	10	no	no	NOUN
cblr-5119	159	11	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	160	1	3:1031	3:1031	NUM
cblr-5119	160	2	]	]	X
cblr-5119	160	3	may	may	AUX
cblr-5119	160	4	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	160	5	fourth	fourth	ADJ
cblr-5119	160	6	be	be	AUX
cblr-5119	160	7	with	with	ADP
cblr-5119	160	8	you	you	PRON
cblr-5119	160	9	1043	1043	NUM
cblr-5119	160	10	state	state	NOUN
cblr-5119	160	11	action	action	NOUN
cblr-5119	160	12	even	even	ADV
cblr-5119	160	13	if	if	SCONJ
cblr-5119	160	14	private	private	ADJ
cblr-5119	160	15	individuals	individual	NOUN
cblr-5119	160	16	are	be	AUX
cblr-5119	160	17	cognizable	cognizable	ADJ
cblr-5119	160	18	offenders	offender	NOUN
cblr-5119	160	19	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	161	1	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	161	2	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	161	3	years	year	NOUN
cblr-5119	161	4	before	before	ADP
cblr-5119	161	5	sosa	sosa	PROPN
cblr-5119	161	6	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	161	7	courts	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	161	8	recognized	recognize	VERB
cblr-5119	161	9	multiple	multiple	ADJ
cblr-5119	161	10	modern	modern	ADJ
cblr-5119	161	11	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-5119	161	12	day	day	NOUN
cblr-5119	161	13	international	international	ADJ
cblr-5119	161	14	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	161	15	violations	violation	NOUN
cblr-5119	161	16	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	161	17	be	be	AUX
cblr-5119	161	18	actionable	actionable	ADJ
cblr-5119	161	19	under	under	ADP
cblr-5119	161	20	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	161	21	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	161	22	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	161	23	including	include	VERB
cblr-5119	161	24	genocide	genocide	NOUN
cblr-5119	161	25	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	161	26	slave	slave	NOUN
cblr-5119	161	27	trading	trading	NOUN
cblr-5119	161	28	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	161	29	slavery	slavery	NOUN
cblr-5119	161	30	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	161	31	forced	force	VERB
cblr-5119	161	32	labor	labor	NOUN
cblr-5119	161	33	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	161	34	war	war	NOUN
cblr-5119	161	35	crimes	crime	NOUN
cblr-5119	161	36	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	161	37	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	161	38	torture.52	torture.52	NOUN
cblr-5119	161	39	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	161	40	these	these	PRON
cblr-5119	161	41	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	161	42	only	only	ADV
cblr-5119	161	43	torture	torture	NOUN
cblr-5119	161	44	required	require	VERB
cblr-5119	161	45	state	state	NOUN
cblr-5119	161	46	action	action	NOUN
cblr-5119	161	47	on	on	ADP
cblr-5119	161	48	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	161	49	part	part	NOUN
cblr-5119	161	50	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	161	51	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	161	52	defendant	defendant	NOUN
cblr-5119	161	53	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	161	54	order	order	NOUN
cblr-5119	161	55	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	161	56	be	be	AUX
cblr-5119	161	57	actionable.53	actionable.53	NOUN
cblr-5119	161	58	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	161	59	2013	2013	NUM
cblr-5119	161	60	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	161	61	thirty	thirty	NUM
cblr-5119	161	62	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-5119	161	63	three	three	NUM
cblr-5119	161	64	years	year	NOUN
cblr-5119	161	65	after	after	SCONJ
cblr-5119	161	66	filartiga	filartiga	ADJ
cblr-5119	161	67	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	161	68	nine	nine	NUM
cblr-5119	161	69	years	year	NOUN
cblr-5119	161	70	after	after	ADP
cblr-5119	161	71	sosa	sosa	PROPN
cblr-5119	161	72	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	161	73	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	161	74	supreme	supreme	PROPN
cblr-5119	161	75	court	court	PROPN
cblr-5119	161	76	finally	finally	ADV
cblr-5119	161	77	took	take	VERB
cblr-5119	161	78	on	on	ADP
cblr-5119	161	79	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	161	80	issue	issue	NOUN
cblr-5119	161	81	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	161	82	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	161	83	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	161	84	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	161	85	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	162	1	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-5119	162	2	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	162	3	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	162	4	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	162	5	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	162	6	:	:	PUNCT
cblr-5119	162	7	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	162	8	narrowing	narrowing	NOUN
cblr-5119	162	9	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	162	10	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	162	11	scope	scope	NOUN
cblr-5119	162	12	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	162	13	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	162	14	1	1	NUM
cblr-5119	162	15	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	163	1	kiobel	kiobel	PROPN
cblr-5119	163	2	v.	v.	ADP
cblr-5119	163	3	royal	royal	PROPN
cblr-5119	163	4	dutch	dutch	PROPN
cblr-5119	163	5	petroleum	petroleum	PROPN
cblr-5119	163	6	co.	co.	PROPN
cblr-5119	163	7	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	163	8	kiobel	kiobel	PROPN
cblr-5119	163	9	v.	v.	ADP
cblr-5119	163	10	royal	royal	PROPN
cblr-5119	163	11	dutch	dutch	PROPN
cblr-5119	163	12	petroleum	petroleum	PROPN
cblr-5119	163	13	co.	co.	PROPN
cblr-5119	163	14	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	163	15	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	163	16	kiobel	kiobel	VERB
cblr-5119	163	17	i	i	PRON
cblr-5119	163	18	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	163	19	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	163	20	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	163	21	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	163	22	second	second	ADJ
cblr-5119	163	23	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	163	24	held	hold	VERB
cblr-5119	163	25	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	163	26	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	163	27	categorically	categorically	ADV
cblr-5119	163	28	can	can	AUX
cblr-5119	163	29	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	163	30	be	be	AUX
cblr-5119	163	31	liable	liable	ADJ
cblr-5119	163	32	under	under	ADP
cblr-5119	163	33	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	163	34	ats.54	ats.54	NOUN
cblr-5119	163	35	this	this	PRON
cblr-5119	163	36	created	create	VERB
cblr-5119	163	37	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	163	38	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	163	39	split	split	NOUN
cblr-5119	163	40	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	163	41	as	as	SCONJ
cblr-5119	163	42	every	every	DET
cblr-5119	163	43	other	other	ADJ
cblr-5119	163	44	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	163	45	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	163	46	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	163	47	appeals	appeal	NOUN
cblr-5119	163	48	that	that	PRON
cblr-5119	163	49	had	have	AUX
cblr-5119	163	50	considered	consider	VERB
cblr-5119	163	51	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	163	52	issue	issue	NOUN
cblr-5119	163	53	had	have	VERB
cblr-5119	163	54	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	163	55	explicitly	explicitly	ADV
cblr-5119	163	56	or	or	CCONJ
cblr-5119	163	57	implicitly	implicitly	ADV
cblr-5119	163	58	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	163	59	ruled	rule	VERB
cblr-5119	163	60	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	163	61	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	163	62	could	could	AUX
cblr-5119	163	63	be	be	AUX
cblr-5119	163	64	held	hold	VERB
cblr-5119	163	65	liable	liable	ADJ
cblr-5119	163	66	under	under	ADP
cblr-5119	163	67	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	163	68	ats.55	ats.55	NOUN
cblr-5119	163	69	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	163	70	supreme	supreme	PROPN
cblr-5119	163	71	court	court	PROPN
cblr-5119	163	72	granted	grant	VERB
cblr-5119	163	73	certiorari	certiorari	NOUN
cblr-5119	163	74	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	163	75	response	response	NOUN
cblr-5119	163	76	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	163	77	kiobel	kiobel	VERB
cblr-5119	163	78	i	i	PRON
cblr-5119	163	79	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	163	80	answer	answer	VERB
cblr-5119	163	81	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	163	82	question	question	NOUN
cblr-5119	163	83	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	163	84	whether	whether	SCONJ
cblr-5119	163	85	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	163	86	could	could	AUX
cblr-5119	163	87	be	be	AUX
cblr-5119	163	88	liable	liable	ADJ
cblr-5119	163	89	under	under	ADP
cblr-5119	163	90	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	163	91	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	163	92	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	163	93	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	163	94	kiobel	kiobel	NOUN
cblr-5119	163	95	ii”),56	ii”),56	NOUN
cblr-5119	163	96	providing	provide	VERB
cblr-5119	163	97	hope	hope	NOUN
cblr-5119	163	98	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	163	99	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	163	100	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	163	101	would	would	AUX
cblr-5119	163	102	resolve	resolve	VERB
cblr-5119	163	103	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	163	104	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	163	105	split	split	NOUN
cblr-5119	163	106	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	164	1	however	however	ADV
cblr-5119	164	2	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	164	3	after	after	ADP
cblr-5119	164	4	oral	oral	ADJ
cblr-5119	164	5	argument	argument	NOUN
cblr-5119	164	6	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	164	7	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	164	8	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	164	9	instructed	instruct	VERB
cblr-5119	164	10	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	164	11	52	52	NUM
cblr-5119	164	12	andrew	andrew	PROPN
cblr-5119	164	13	clapham	clapham	PROPN
cblr-5119	164	14	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	164	15	human	human	ADJ
cblr-5119	164	16	rights	right	NOUN
cblr-5119	164	17	obligations	obligation	NOUN
cblr-5119	164	18	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	164	19	non	non	ADJ
cblr-5119	164	20	-	-	ADJ
cblr-5119	164	21	state	state	ADJ
cblr-5119	164	22	actors	actor	NOUN
cblr-5119	164	23	253	253	NUM
cblr-5119	164	24	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	164	25	2006	2006	NUM
cblr-5119	164	26	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	164	27	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	165	1	53	53	NUM
cblr-5119	165	2	i	i	PRON
cblr-5119	165	3	d.	d.	NOUN
cblr-5119	165	4	torture	torture	NOUN
cblr-5119	165	5	could	could	AUX
cblr-5119	165	6	also	also	ADV
cblr-5119	165	7	be	be	AUX
cblr-5119	165	8	actionable	actionable	ADJ
cblr-5119	165	9	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	165	10	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	165	11	absence	absence	NOUN
cblr-5119	165	12	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	165	13	state	state	NOUN
cblr-5119	165	14	action	action	NOUN
cblr-5119	165	15	if	if	SCONJ
cblr-5119	165	16	it	it	PRON
cblr-5119	165	17	was	be	AUX
cblr-5119	165	18	committed	commit	VERB
cblr-5119	165	19	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	165	20	pursuit	pursuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	165	21	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	165	22	genocide	genocide	NOUN
cblr-5119	165	23	or	or	CCONJ
cblr-5119	165	24	war	war	NOUN
cblr-5119	165	25	crimes	crime	NOUN
cblr-5119	165	26	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	166	1	i	i	PRON
cblr-5119	166	2	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-5119	166	3	congress	congress	PROPN
cblr-5119	166	4	spoke	speak	VERB
cblr-5119	166	5	directly	directly	ADV
cblr-5119	166	6	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	166	7	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	166	8	point	point	NOUN
cblr-5119	166	9	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	166	10	torture	torture	NOUN
cblr-5119	166	11	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	166	12	its	its	PRON
cblr-5119	166	13	enactment	enactment	NOUN
cblr-5119	166	14	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	166	15	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	166	16	torture	torture	NOUN
cblr-5119	166	17	victim	victim	NOUN
cblr-5119	166	18	protection	protection	PROPN
cblr-5119	166	19	act	act	NOUN
cblr-5119	166	20	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	166	21	1991	1991	NUM
cblr-5119	166	22	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	166	23	pub	pub	NOUN
cblr-5119	166	24	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	167	1	l.	l.	PROPN
cblr-5119	167	2	no	no	INTJ
cblr-5119	167	3	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	168	1	102	102	NUM
cblr-5119	168	2	-	-	SYM
cblr-5119	168	3	256	256	NUM
cblr-5119	168	4	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	168	5	106	106	NUM
cblr-5119	168	6	stat	stat	NOUN
cblr-5119	168	7	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	169	1	73	73	NUM
cblr-5119	169	2	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	169	3	1992	1992	NUM
cblr-5119	169	4	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	169	5	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	170	1	this	this	PRON
cblr-5119	170	2	led	lead	VERB
cblr-5119	170	3	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	170	4	questions	question	NOUN
cblr-5119	170	5	about	about	ADP
cblr-5119	170	6	whether	whether	SCONJ
cblr-5119	170	7	torture	torture	NOUN
cblr-5119	170	8	remained	remain	VERB
cblr-5119	170	9	actionable	actionable	ADJ
cblr-5119	170	10	under	under	ADP
cblr-5119	170	11	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	170	12	ats	at	NOUN
cblr-5119	170	13	or	or	CCONJ
cblr-5119	170	14	if	if	SCONJ
cblr-5119	170	15	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	170	16	tvpa	tvpa	NOUN
cblr-5119	170	17	preempted	preempt	VERB
cblr-5119	170	18	any	any	DET
cblr-5119	170	19	such	such	ADJ
cblr-5119	170	20	claims	claim	NOUN
cblr-5119	170	21	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	170	22	but	but	CCONJ
cblr-5119	170	23	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	170	24	tvpa	tvpa	NOUN
cblr-5119	170	25	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	170	26	legislative	legislative	ADJ
cblr-5119	170	27	history	history	NOUN
cblr-5119	170	28	supports	support	VERB
cblr-5119	170	29	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	170	30	proposition	proposition	NOUN
cblr-5119	170	31	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	170	32	congress	congress	PROPN
cblr-5119	170	33	intended	intend	VERB
cblr-5119	170	34	it	it	PRON
cblr-5119	170	35	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	170	36	supplement	supplement	VERB
cblr-5119	170	37	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	170	38	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	170	39	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	171	1	see	see	VERB
cblr-5119	171	2	kiobel	kiobel	PROPN
cblr-5119	171	3	v.	v.	ADP
cblr-5119	171	4	royal	royal	PROPN
cblr-5119	171	5	dutch	dutch	PROPN
cblr-5119	171	6	petroleum	petroleum	PROPN
cblr-5119	171	7	co.	co.	PROPN
cblr-5119	171	8	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	171	9	569	569	NUM
cblr-5119	171	10	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	171	11	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	171	12	108	108	NUM
cblr-5119	171	13	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	171	14	138	138	NUM
cblr-5119	171	15	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	171	16	2013	2013	NUM
cblr-5119	171	17	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	171	18	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	172	1	54	54	NUM
cblr-5119	172	2	kiobel	kiobel	NOUN
cblr-5119	172	3	v.	v.	ADP
cblr-5119	172	4	royal	royal	PROPN
cblr-5119	172	5	dutch	dutch	PROPN
cblr-5119	172	6	petroleum	petroleum	PROPN
cblr-5119	172	7	co.	co.	PROPN
cblr-5119	172	8	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	172	9	621	621	NUM
cblr-5119	172	10	f.3d	f.3d	NUM
cblr-5119	172	11	111	111	NUM
cblr-5119	172	12	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	172	13	145	145	NUM
cblr-5119	172	14	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	172	15	2d	2d	NUM
cblr-5119	172	16	cir	cir	NOUN
cblr-5119	172	17	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	172	18	2010	2010	NUM
cblr-5119	172	19	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	172	20	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	172	21	aff’d	aff’d	VERB
cblr-5119	172	22	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	172	23	569	569	NUM
cblr-5119	172	24	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	172	25	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	172	26	108	108	NUM
cblr-5119	172	27	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	172	28	2013	2013	NUM
cblr-5119	172	29	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	172	30	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	173	1	55	55	NUM
cblr-5119	173	2	mulligan	mulligan	NOUN
cblr-5119	173	3	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	173	4	supra	supra	PROPN
cblr-5119	173	5	note	note	PROPN
cblr-5119	173	6	15	15	NUM
cblr-5119	173	7	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	173	8	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	173	9	18	18	NUM
cblr-5119	173	10	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	174	1	56	56	NUM
cblr-5119	174	2	kiobel	kiobel	NOUN
cblr-5119	174	3	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	174	4	569	569	NUM
cblr-5119	174	5	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	174	6	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	174	7	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	174	8	114	114	NUM
cblr-5119	174	9	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	175	1	6_2019.3_estes	6_2019.3_estes	NUM
cblr-5119	175	2	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	175	3	do	do	AUX
cblr-5119	175	4	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	175	5	delte	delte	VERB
cblr-5119	175	6	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	175	7	12/26/2019	12/26/2019	NUM
cblr-5119	175	8	12:00	12:00	NUM
cblr-5119	175	9	am	be	AUX
cblr-5119	175	10	1044	1044	NUM
cblr-5119	175	11	columbia	columbia	PROPN
cblr-5119	175	12	business	business	PROPN
cblr-5119	175	13	law	law	PROPN
cblr-5119	175	14	review	review	NOUN
cblr-5119	176	1	[	[	X
cblr-5119	176	2	vol	vol	NOUN
cblr-5119	176	3	.	.	NOUN
cblr-5119	176	4	2019	2019	NUM
cblr-5119	176	5	parties	party	NOUN
cblr-5119	176	6	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	176	7	brief	brief	VERB
cblr-5119	176	8	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	176	9	question	question	NOUN
cblr-5119	176	10	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	176	11	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	176	12	[	[	X
cblr-5119	176	13	w]hether	w]hether	X
cblr-5119	176	14	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	176	15	under	under	ADP
cblr-5119	176	16	what	what	PRON
cblr-5119	176	17	circumstances	circumstance	NOUN
cblr-5119	176	18	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	176	19	[	[	X
cblr-5119	176	20	ats	at	NOUN
cblr-5119	176	21	]	]	PUNCT
cblr-5119	176	22	allows	allow	VERB
cblr-5119	176	23	courts	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	176	24	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	176	25	recognize	recognize	VERB
cblr-5119	176	26	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	176	27	cause	cause	NOUN
cblr-5119	176	28	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	176	29	action	action	NOUN
cblr-5119	176	30	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	176	31	violations	violation	NOUN
cblr-5119	176	32	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	176	33	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	176	34	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	176	35	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	176	36	nations	nation	NOUN
cblr-5119	176	37	occurring	occur	VERB
cblr-5119	176	38	within	within	ADP
cblr-5119	176	39	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	176	40	territory	territory	NOUN
cblr-5119	176	41	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	176	42	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	176	43	sovereign	sovereign	ADJ
cblr-5119	176	44	other	other	ADJ
cblr-5119	176	45	than	than	ADP
cblr-5119	176	46	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	176	47	united	united	PROPN
cblr-5119	176	48	states	states	PROPN
cblr-5119	176	49	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	177	1	”57	”57	PROPN
cblr-5119	177	2	ultimately	ultimately	ADV
cblr-5119	177	3	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	177	4	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	177	5	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	177	6	ruled	rule	VERB
cblr-5119	177	7	on	on	ADP
cblr-5119	177	8	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	177	9	basis	basis	NOUN
cblr-5119	177	10	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	177	11	that	that	DET
cblr-5119	177	12	question	question	NOUN
cblr-5119	177	13	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	177	14	holding	hold	VERB
cblr-5119	177	15	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	177	16	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	177	17	presumption	presumption	NOUN
cblr-5119	177	18	against	against	ADP
cblr-5119	177	19	extraterritoriality	extraterritoriality	NOUN
cblr-5119	177	20	applies	apply	VERB
cblr-5119	177	21	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	177	22	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	177	23	claims	claim	NOUN
cblr-5119	177	24	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	177	25	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	177	26	nothing	nothing	PRON
cblr-5119	177	27	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	177	28	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	177	29	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	177	30	rebuts	rebut	VERB
cblr-5119	177	31	this	this	DET
cblr-5119	177	32	presumption.58	presumption.58	PROPN
cblr-5119	177	33	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	177	34	presumption	presumption	NOUN
cblr-5119	177	35	against	against	ADP
cblr-5119	177	36	extraterritoriality	extraterritoriality	NOUN
cblr-5119	177	37	is	be	AUX
cblr-5119	177	38	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	177	39	canon	canon	NOUN
cblr-5119	177	40	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	177	41	construction	construction	NOUN
cblr-5119	177	42	whereby	whereby	SCONJ
cblr-5119	177	43	it	it	PRON
cblr-5119	177	44	is	be	AUX
cblr-5119	177	45	assumed	assume	VERB
cblr-5119	177	46	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	177	47	federal	federal	ADJ
cblr-5119	177	48	legislation	legislation	NOUN
cblr-5119	177	49	only	only	ADV
cblr-5119	177	50	applies	apply	VERB
cblr-5119	177	51	domestically	domestically	ADV
cblr-5119	177	52	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	177	53	does	do	AUX
cblr-5119	177	54	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	177	55	reach	reach	VERB
cblr-5119	177	56	extraterritorial	extraterritorial	ADJ
cblr-5119	177	57	conduct	conduct	NOUN
cblr-5119	177	58	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	177	59	unless	unless	SCONJ
cblr-5119	177	60	it	it	PRON
cblr-5119	177	61	is	be	AUX
cblr-5119	177	62	clear	clear	ADJ
cblr-5119	177	63	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	177	64	congress	congress	PROPN
cblr-5119	177	65	intended	intend	VERB
cblr-5119	177	66	otherwise.59	otherwise.59	PROPN
cblr-5119	177	67	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	177	68	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	177	69	words	word	NOUN
cblr-5119	177	70	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	177	71	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	177	72	supreme	supreme	PROPN
cblr-5119	177	73	court	court	PROPN
cblr-5119	177	74	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	177	75	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	177	76	canon	canon	NOUN
cblr-5119	177	77	demands	demand	VERB
cblr-5119	177	78	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	177	79	if	if	SCONJ
cblr-5119	177	80	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	177	81	statute	statute	NOUN
cblr-5119	177	82	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	177	83	gives	give	VERB
cblr-5119	177	84	no	no	DET
cblr-5119	177	85	clear	clear	ADJ
cblr-5119	177	86	indication	indication	NOUN
cblr-5119	177	87	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	177	88	an	an	DET
cblr-5119	177	89	extraterritorial	extraterritorial	ADJ
cblr-5119	177	90	application	application	NOUN
cblr-5119	177	91	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	177	92	it	it	PRON
cblr-5119	177	93	has	have	VERB
cblr-5119	177	94	none	none	NOUN
cblr-5119	177	95	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	178	1	”60	”60	PROPN
cblr-5119	178	2	while	while	SCONJ
cblr-5119	178	3	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	178	4	underlying	underlie	VERB
cblr-5119	178	5	principle	principle	NOUN
cblr-5119	178	6	has	have	VERB
cblr-5119	178	7	long	long	ADJ
cblr-5119	178	8	existed,61	existed,61	PROPN
cblr-5119	178	9	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	178	10	supreme	supreme	PROPN
cblr-5119	178	11	court	court	PROPN
cblr-5119	178	12	has	have	AUX
cblr-5119	178	13	invoked	invoke	VERB
cblr-5119	178	14	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	178	15	canon	canon	NOUN
cblr-5119	178	16	with	with	ADP
cblr-5119	178	17	increasing	increase	VERB
cblr-5119	178	18	frequency	frequency	NOUN
cblr-5119	178	19	over	over	ADP
cblr-5119	178	20	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	178	21	past	past	ADJ
cblr-5119	178	22	thirty	thirty	NUM
cblr-5119	178	23	years.62	years.62	NOUN
cblr-5119	178	24	as	as	SCONJ
cblr-5119	178	25	applied	apply	VERB
cblr-5119	178	26	57	57	NUM
cblr-5119	178	27	i	i	PROPN
cblr-5119	178	28	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-5119	178	29	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	178	30	alteration	alteration	NOUN
cblr-5119	178	31	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	178	32	original	original	ADJ
cblr-5119	178	33	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	178	34	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	179	1	58	58	NUM
cblr-5119	180	1	i	i	PRON
cblr-5119	180	2	d.	d.	VERB
cblr-5119	180	3	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	180	4	124	124	NUM
cblr-5119	180	5	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	181	1	59	59	NUM
cblr-5119	181	2	morrison	morrison	PROPN
cblr-5119	181	3	v.	v.	PROPN
cblr-5119	181	4	nat’l	nat’l	PROPN
cblr-5119	181	5	australia	australia	PROPN
cblr-5119	181	6	bank	bank	PROPN
cblr-5119	181	7	ltd	ltd	PROPN
cblr-5119	181	8	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	181	9	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	181	10	561	561	NUM
cblr-5119	181	11	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	181	12	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	181	13	247	247	NUM
cblr-5119	181	14	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	181	15	255	255	NUM
cblr-5119	181	16	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	181	17	2010	2010	NUM
cblr-5119	181	18	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	181	19	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	182	1	60	60	NUM
cblr-5119	183	1	i	i	PRON
cblr-5119	183	2	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-5119	183	3	61	61	NUM
cblr-5119	183	4	american	american	PROPN
cblr-5119	183	5	banana	banana	PROPN
cblr-5119	183	6	co.	co.	PROPN
cblr-5119	183	7	v.	v.	ADP
cblr-5119	183	8	united	united	PROPN
cblr-5119	183	9	fruit	fruit	PROPN
cblr-5119	183	10	co.	co.	PROPN
cblr-5119	183	11	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	183	12	213	213	NUM
cblr-5119	183	13	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	183	14	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	183	15	347	347	NUM
cblr-5119	183	16	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	183	17	357	357	NUM
cblr-5119	183	18	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	183	19	1909	1909	NUM
cblr-5119	183	20	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	183	21	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	183	22	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	183	23	[	[	X
cblr-5119	183	24	various	various	ADJ
cblr-5119	183	25	]	]	PUNCT
cblr-5119	183	26	considerations	consideration	NOUN
cblr-5119	183	27	would	would	AUX
cblr-5119	183	28	lead	lead	VERB
cblr-5119	183	29	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	183	30	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	183	31	case	case	NOUN
cblr-5119	183	32	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	183	33	doubt	doubt	NOUN
cblr-5119	183	34	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	183	35	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	183	36	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	183	37	construction	construction	NOUN
cblr-5119	183	38	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	183	39	any	any	DET
cblr-5119	183	40	statute	statute	NOUN
cblr-5119	183	41	as	as	SCONJ
cblr-5119	183	42	intended	intend	VERB
cblr-5119	183	43	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	183	44	be	be	AUX
cblr-5119	183	45	confined	confine	VERB
cblr-5119	183	46	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	183	47	its	its	PRON
cblr-5119	183	48	operation	operation	NOUN
cblr-5119	183	49	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	183	50	effect	effect	NOUN
cblr-5119	183	51	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	183	52	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	183	53	territorial	territorial	ADJ
cblr-5119	183	54	limits	limit	NOUN
cblr-5119	183	55	over	over	ADP
cblr-5119	183	56	which	which	PRON
cblr-5119	183	57	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	183	58	lawmaker	lawmaker	NOUN
cblr-5119	183	59	has	have	VERB
cblr-5119	183	60	general	general	ADJ
cblr-5119	183	61	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	183	62	legitimate	legitimate	ADJ
cblr-5119	183	63	power	power	NOUN
cblr-5119	183	64	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	183	65	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	183	66	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	183	67	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	184	1	62	62	NUM
cblr-5119	184	2	note	note	NOUN
cblr-5119	184	3	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	184	4	clarifying	clarify	VERB
cblr-5119	184	5	kiobel	kiobel	PROPN
cblr-5119	184	6	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	184	7	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	184	8	touch	touch	NOUN
cblr-5119	184	9	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	184	10	concern	concern	NOUN
cblr-5119	184	11	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	184	12	test	test	NOUN
cblr-5119	184	13	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	184	14	130	130	NUM
cblr-5119	184	15	harv	harv	NOUN
cblr-5119	184	16	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	185	1	l.	l.	PROPN
cblr-5119	185	2	rev	rev	PROPN
cblr-5119	185	3	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	185	4	1902	1902	NUM
cblr-5119	185	5	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	185	6	1906	1906	NUM
cblr-5119	185	7	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	185	8	2017	2017	NUM
cblr-5119	185	9	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	185	10	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	186	1	relatedly	relatedly	ADV
cblr-5119	186	2	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	186	3	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	186	4	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	186	5	has	have	AUX
cblr-5119	186	6	increasingly	increasingly	ADV
cblr-5119	186	7	limited	limit	VERB
cblr-5119	186	8	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	186	9	extraterritorial	extraterritorial	ADJ
cblr-5119	186	10	application	application	NOUN
cblr-5119	186	11	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	186	12	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	186	13	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	186	14	federal	federal	ADJ
cblr-5119	186	15	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	186	16	through	through	ADP
cblr-5119	186	17	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	186	18	series	series	NOUN
cblr-5119	186	19	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	186	20	cases	case	NOUN
cblr-5119	186	21	over	over	ADP
cblr-5119	186	22	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	186	23	past	past	ADJ
cblr-5119	186	24	15	15	NUM
cblr-5119	186	25	years	year	NOUN
cblr-5119	186	26	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	186	27	which	which	PRON
cblr-5119	186	28	includes	include	VERB
cblr-5119	186	29	kiobel	kiobel	PROPN
cblr-5119	186	30	ii	ii	PROPN
cblr-5119	186	31	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	187	1	see	see	VERB
cblr-5119	187	2	f.	f.	PROPN
cblr-5119	187	3	hoffmann	hoffmann	PROPN
cblr-5119	187	4	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-5119	187	5	la	la	PROPN
cblr-5119	187	6	roche	roche	PROPN
cblr-5119	187	7	ltd	ltd	PROPN
cblr-5119	187	8	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	188	1	v.	v.	ADP
cblr-5119	188	2	empagran	empagran	PROPN
cblr-5119	188	3	s.a	s.a	PROPN
cblr-5119	188	4	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	188	5	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	188	6	542	542	NUM
cblr-5119	188	7	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	188	8	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	188	9	155	155	NUM
cblr-5119	188	10	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	188	11	164–65	164–65	NUM
cblr-5119	188	12	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	188	13	2004	2004	NUM
cblr-5119	188	14	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	188	15	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	188	16	holding	hold	VERB
cblr-5119	188	17	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	188	18	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	188	19	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	188	20	antitrust	antitrust	ADJ
cblr-5119	188	21	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	188	22	does	do	AUX
cblr-5119	188	23	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	188	24	apply	apply	VERB
cblr-5119	188	25	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	188	26	foreign	foreign	ADJ
cblr-5119	188	27	price	price	NOUN
cblr-5119	188	28	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-5119	188	29	fixing	fix	VERB
cblr-5119	188	30	activity	activity	NOUN
cblr-5119	188	31	where	where	SCONJ
cblr-5119	188	32	foreign	foreign	ADJ
cblr-5119	188	33	injuries	injury	NOUN
cblr-5119	188	34	are	be	AUX
cblr-5119	188	35	independent	independent	ADJ
cblr-5119	188	36	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	188	37	any	any	DET
cblr-5119	188	38	domestic	domestic	ADJ
cblr-5119	188	39	injuries	injury	NOUN
cblr-5119	188	40	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	188	41	;	;	PUNCT
cblr-5119	188	42	morrison	morrison	PROPN
cblr-5119	188	43	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	188	44	561	561	NUM
cblr-5119	188	45	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	188	46	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	188	47	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	188	48	266–67	266–67	NUM
cblr-5119	188	49	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	188	50	rejecting	reject	VERB
cblr-5119	188	51	extraterritorial	extraterritorial	ADJ
cblr-5119	188	52	application	application	NOUN
cblr-5119	188	53	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	188	54	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	188	55	federal	federal	ADJ
cblr-5119	188	56	securities	security	NOUN
cblr-5119	188	57	statute	statute	NOUN
cblr-5119	188	58	because	because	SCONJ
cblr-5119	188	59	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	188	60	statute	statute	NOUN
cblr-5119	188	61	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	188	62	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	188	63	focus	focus	NOUN
cblr-5119	188	64	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	188	65	centered	center	VERB
cblr-5119	188	66	on	on	ADP
cblr-5119	188	67	domestic	domestic	ADJ
cblr-5119	188	68	conduct	conduct	NOUN
cblr-5119	188	69	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	188	70	;	;	PUNCT
cblr-5119	188	71	rjr	rjr	PROPN
cblr-5119	188	72	nabisco	nabisco	PROPN
cblr-5119	188	73	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	188	74	inc	inc	PROPN
cblr-5119	188	75	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	188	76	v.	v.	PROPN
cblr-5119	188	77	european	european	PROPN
cblr-5119	188	78	community	community	PROPN
cblr-5119	188	79	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	188	80	136	136	NUM
cblr-5119	188	81	s.	s.	PROPN
cblr-5119	188	82	ct	ct	PROPN
cblr-5119	188	83	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	188	84	2090	2090	NUM
cblr-5119	188	85	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	188	86	2101	2101	NUM
cblr-5119	188	87	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	188	88	2016	2016	NUM
cblr-5119	188	89	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	188	90	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	188	91	introducing	introduce	VERB
cblr-5119	188	92	two	two	NUM
cblr-5119	188	93	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-5119	188	94	prong	prong	NOUN
cblr-5119	188	95	test	test	NOUN
cblr-5119	188	96	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	188	97	allowing	allow	VERB
cblr-5119	188	98	application	application	NOUN
cblr-5119	188	99	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	188	100	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	188	101	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	188	102	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	188	103	when	when	SCONJ
cblr-5119	188	104	foreign	foreign	ADJ
cblr-5119	188	105	conduct	conduct	NOUN
cblr-5119	188	106	is	be	AUX
cblr-5119	188	107	involved	involve	VERB
cblr-5119	188	108	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	188	109	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	189	1	morrison	morrison	PROPN
cblr-5119	189	2	has	have	AUX
cblr-5119	189	3	led	lead	VERB
cblr-5119	189	4	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	189	5	courts	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	189	6	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	189	7	some	some	DET
cblr-5119	189	8	contexts	contexts	NOUN
cblr-5119	189	9	applying	apply	VERB
cblr-5119	189	10	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	189	11	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	189	12	focus	focus	NOUN
cblr-5119	189	13	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	189	14	test	test	NOUN
cblr-5119	189	15	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	189	16	deciding	decide	VERB
cblr-5119	189	17	whether	whether	SCONJ
cblr-5119	189	18	extraterritorial	extraterritorial	ADJ
cblr-5119	189	19	application	application	NOUN
cblr-5119	189	20	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	189	21	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	189	22	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	189	23	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	189	24	is	be	AUX
cblr-5119	189	25	proper	proper	ADJ
cblr-5119	189	26	by	by	ADP
cblr-5119	189	27	examining	examine	VERB
cblr-5119	189	28	whether	whether	SCONJ
cblr-5119	189	29	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	189	30	statute	statute	NOUN
cblr-5119	189	31	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	189	32	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	189	33	focus	focus	NOUN
cblr-5119	189	34	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	189	35	is	be	AUX
cblr-5119	189	36	on	on	ADP
cblr-5119	189	37	exterritorial	exterritorial	ADJ
cblr-5119	189	38	conduct	conduct	NOUN
cblr-5119	189	39	or	or	CCONJ
cblr-5119	189	40	domestic	domestic	ADJ
cblr-5119	189	41	conduct	conduct	NOUN
cblr-5119	189	42	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	190	1	see	see	VERB
cblr-5119	190	2	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	190	3	e.g.	e.g.	ADV
cblr-5119	190	4	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	190	5	doe	doe	NOUN
cblr-5119	190	6	v.	v.	ADP
cblr-5119	190	7	nestle	nestle	PROPN
cblr-5119	190	8	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	190	9	s.a	s.a	PROPN
cblr-5119	190	10	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	190	11	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	190	12	906	906	NUM
cblr-5119	190	13	f.3d	f.3d	NUM
cblr-5119	190	14	1120	1120	NUM
cblr-5119	190	15	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	190	16	1125	1125	NUM
cblr-5119	190	17	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	190	18	9th	9th	ADJ
cblr-5119	190	19	cir	cir	NOUN
cblr-5119	190	20	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	190	21	2018	2018	NUM
cblr-5119	190	22	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	190	23	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	191	1	6_2019.3_estes	6_2019.3_estes	NUM
cblr-5119	191	2	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	191	3	do	do	AUX
cblr-5119	191	4	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	191	5	delete	delete	VERB
cblr-5119	191	6	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	191	7	12/26/2019	12/26/2019	NUM
cblr-5119	191	8	12:00	12:00	NUM
cblr-5119	191	9	am	be	AUX
cblr-5119	191	10	no	no	NOUN
cblr-5119	191	11	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	192	1	3:1031	3:1031	NUM
cblr-5119	192	2	]	]	X
cblr-5119	192	3	may	may	AUX
cblr-5119	192	4	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	192	5	fourth	fourth	ADJ
cblr-5119	192	6	be	be	AUX
cblr-5119	192	7	with	with	ADP
cblr-5119	192	8	you	you	PRON
cblr-5119	192	9	1045	1045	NUM
cblr-5119	192	10	by	by	ADP
cblr-5119	192	11	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	192	12	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	192	13	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	192	14	kiobel	kiobel	PROPN
cblr-5119	192	15	ii	ii	PROPN
cblr-5119	192	16	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	192	17	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	192	18	presumption	presumption	NOUN
cblr-5119	192	19	meant	mean	VERB
cblr-5119	192	20	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	192	21	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	192	22	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	192	23	order	order	NOUN
cblr-5119	192	24	for	for	SCONJ
cblr-5119	192	25	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
cblr-5119	192	26	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	192	27	successfully	successfully	ADV
cblr-5119	192	28	obtain	obtain	VERB
cblr-5119	192	29	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NOUN
cblr-5119	192	30	under	under	ADP
cblr-5119	192	31	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	192	32	ats	at	NOUN
cblr-5119	192	33	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	192	34	they	they	PRON
cblr-5119	192	35	would	would	AUX
cblr-5119	192	36	have	have	VERB
cblr-5119	192	37	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	192	38	show	show	VERB
cblr-5119	192	39	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	192	40	their	their	PRON
cblr-5119	192	41	claims	claim	NOUN
cblr-5119	192	42	touched	touch	VERB
cblr-5119	192	43	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	192	44	concerned	concern	VERB
cblr-5119	192	45	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	192	46	territory	territory	NOUN
cblr-5119	192	47	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	192	48	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	192	49	united	united	PROPN
cblr-5119	192	50	states	states	PROPN
cblr-5119	192	51	with	with	ADP
cblr-5119	192	52	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
cblr-5119	192	53	force	force	NOUN
cblr-5119	192	54	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	192	55	displace	displace	VERB
cblr-5119	192	56	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	192	57	presumption,63	presumption,63	NOUN
cblr-5119	192	58	thereby	thereby	ADV
cblr-5119	192	59	announcing	announce	VERB
cblr-5119	192	60	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	192	61	new	new	ADJ
cblr-5119	192	62	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	192	63	touch	touch	NOUN
cblr-5119	192	64	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	192	65	concern	concern	NOUN
cblr-5119	192	66	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	192	67	test	test	NOUN
cblr-5119	192	68	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	192	69	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	192	70	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	192	71	context.64	context.64	NOUN
cblr-5119	192	72	as	as	ADV
cblr-5119	192	73	far	far	ADV
cblr-5119	192	74	as	as	ADP
cblr-5119	192	75	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	192	76	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	192	77	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	192	78	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	192	79	only	only	ADJ
cblr-5119	192	80	principle	principle	NOUN
cblr-5119	192	81	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	192	82	kiobel	kiobel	PROPN
cblr-5119	192	83	ii	ii	PROPN
cblr-5119	192	84	court	court	PROPN
cblr-5119	192	85	announced	announce	VERB
cblr-5119	192	86	was	be	AUX
cblr-5119	192	87	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	192	88	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	192	89	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	192	90	mere	mere	ADJ
cblr-5119	192	91	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	192	92	presence	presence	NOUN
cblr-5119	192	93	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	192	94	does	do	AUX
cblr-5119	192	95	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	192	96	suffice	suffice	VERB
cblr-5119	192	97	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	192	98	rebut	rebut	VERB
cblr-5119	192	99	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	192	100	presumption.65	presumption.65	NOUN
cblr-5119	192	101	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	192	102	holding	hold	VERB
cblr-5119	192	103	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	192	104	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	192	105	presumption	presumption	NOUN
cblr-5119	192	106	against	against	ADP
cblr-5119	192	107	extraterritoriality	extraterritoriality	NOUN
cblr-5119	192	108	applies	apply	VERB
cblr-5119	192	109	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	192	110	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	192	111	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	192	112	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	192	113	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	192	114	majority	majority	NOUN
cblr-5119	192	115	based	base	VERB
cblr-5119	192	116	its	its	PRON
cblr-5119	192	117	reasoning	reasoning	NOUN
cblr-5119	192	118	on	on	ADP
cblr-5119	192	119	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	192	120	original	original	ADJ
cblr-5119	192	121	understanding	understanding	NOUN
cblr-5119	192	122	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	192	123	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	192	124	ats	at	NOUN
cblr-5119	192	125	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	192	126	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	192	127	way	way	NOUN
cblr-5119	192	128	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	192	129	which	which	PRON
cblr-5119	192	130	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	192	131	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	192	132	had	have	AUX
cblr-5119	192	133	previously	previously	ADV
cblr-5119	192	134	interpreted	interpret	VERB
cblr-5119	192	135	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	192	136	understanding	understanding	NOUN
cblr-5119	192	137	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	192	138	sosa.66	sosa.66	NOUN
cblr-5119	192	139	as	as	SCONJ
cblr-5119	192	140	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	192	141	sosa	sosa	PROPN
cblr-5119	192	142	court	court	PROPN
cblr-5119	192	143	had	have	AUX
cblr-5119	192	144	focused	focus	VERB
cblr-5119	192	145	on	on	ADP
cblr-5119	192	146	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	192	147	three	three	NUM
cblr-5119	192	148	contemporaneous	contemporaneous	ADJ
cblr-5119	192	149	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	192	150	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	192	151	nations	nation	NOUN
cblr-5119	192	152	violations	violation	NOUN
cblr-5119	192	153	identified	identify	VERB
cblr-5119	192	154	by	by	ADP
cblr-5119	192	155	blackstone	blackstone	NOUN
cblr-5119	192	156	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	192	157	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	192	158	kiobel	kiobel	PROPN
cblr-5119	192	159	ii	ii	PROPN
cblr-5119	192	160	court	court	PROPN
cblr-5119	192	161	also	also	ADV
cblr-5119	192	162	relied	rely	VERB
cblr-5119	192	163	heavily	heavily	ADV
cblr-5119	192	164	on	on	ADP
cblr-5119	192	165	those	those	DET
cblr-5119	192	166	violations	violation	NOUN
cblr-5119	192	167	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	192	168	finding	find	VERB
cblr-5119	192	169	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	192	170	they	they	PRON
cblr-5119	192	171	contemplated	contemplate	VERB
cblr-5119	192	172	conduct	conduct	NOUN
cblr-5119	192	173	occurring	occur	VERB
cblr-5119	192	174	solely	solely	ADV
cblr-5119	192	175	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	192	176	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	192	177	united	united	PROPN
cblr-5119	192	178	states.67	states.67	PROPN
cblr-5119	192	179	although	although	SCONJ
cblr-5119	192	180	piracy	piracy	NOUN
cblr-5119	192	181	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	192	182	one	one	NUM
cblr-5119	192	183	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	192	184	blackstone	blackstone	NOUN
cblr-5119	192	185	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	192	186	identified	identify	VERB
cblr-5119	192	187	violations	violation	NOUN
cblr-5119	192	188	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	192	189	involved	involve	VERB
cblr-5119	192	190	conduct	conduct	NOUN
cblr-5119	192	191	occurring	occur	VERB
cblr-5119	192	192	outside	outside	ADP
cblr-5119	192	193	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	192	194	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	192	195	united	united	PROPN
cblr-5119	192	196	states	states	PROPN
cblr-5119	192	197	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	192	198	pirates	pirate	NOUN
cblr-5119	192	199	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	192	200	were	be	AUX
cblr-5119	192	201	fair	fair	ADJ
cblr-5119	192	202	game	game	NOUN
cblr-5119	192	203	wherever	wherever	SCONJ
cblr-5119	192	204	found	find	VERB
cblr-5119	192	205	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	192	206	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	192	207	meaning	mean	VERB
cblr-5119	192	208	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	192	209	exercising	exercise	VERB
cblr-5119	192	210	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NOUN
cblr-5119	192	211	over	over	ADP
cblr-5119	192	212	piracyrelated	piracyrelate	VERB
cblr-5119	192	213	claims	claim	NOUN
cblr-5119	192	214	did	do	AUX
cblr-5119	192	215	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	192	216	raise	raise	VERB
cblr-5119	192	217	much	much	ADJ
cblr-5119	192	218	potential	potential	NOUN
cblr-5119	192	219	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	192	220	foreign	foreign	ADJ
cblr-5119	192	221	relations	relation	NOUN
cblr-5119	192	222	conflicts.68	conflicts.68	NOUN
cblr-5119	192	223	finally	finally	ADV
cblr-5119	192	224	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	192	225	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	192	226	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	192	227	pointed	point	VERB
cblr-5119	192	228	out	out	ADP
cblr-5119	192	229	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	192	230	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	192	231	first	first	ADJ
cblr-5119	192	232	congress	congress	PROPN
cblr-5119	192	233	enacted	enact	VERB
cblr-5119	192	234	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	192	235	ats	at	NOUN
cblr-5119	192	236	with	with	ADP
cblr-5119	192	237	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	192	238	view	view	NOUN
cblr-5119	192	239	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	192	240	reducing	reduce	VERB
cblr-5119	192	241	conflicts	conflict	NOUN
cblr-5119	192	242	with	with	ADP
cblr-5119	192	243	foreign	foreign	ADJ
cblr-5119	192	244	powers	power	NOUN
cblr-5119	192	245	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	193	1	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	193	2	majority	majority	NOUN
cblr-5119	193	3	opined	opine	VERB
cblr-5119	193	4	that	that	PRON
cblr-5119	193	5	extraterritorial	extraterritorial	ADJ
cblr-5119	193	6	application	application	NOUN
cblr-5119	193	7	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	193	8	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	193	9	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	193	10	would	would	AUX
cblr-5119	193	11	have	have	VERB
cblr-5119	193	12	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	193	13	opposite	opposite	ADJ
cblr-5119	193	14	effect	effect	NOUN
cblr-5119	193	15	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	193	16	since	since	SCONJ
cblr-5119	193	17	it	it	PRON
cblr-5119	193	18	would	would	AUX
cblr-5119	193	19	potentially	potentially	ADV
cblr-5119	193	20	infringe	infringe	VERB
cblr-5119	193	21	on	on	ADP
cblr-5119	193	22	other	other	ADJ
cblr-5119	193	23	nations	nation	NOUN
cblr-5119	193	24	’	'	PUNCT
cblr-5119	193	25	sovereignty	sovereignty	NOUN
cblr-5119	193	26	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	193	27	cause	cause	VERB
cblr-5119	193	28	other	other	ADJ
cblr-5119	193	29	nations	nation	NOUN
cblr-5119	193	30	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	193	31	react	react	VERB
cblr-5119	193	32	by	by	ADP
cblr-5119	193	33	haling	hale	VERB
cblr-5119	193	34	63	63	NUM
cblr-5119	193	35	kiobel	kiobel	NOUN
cblr-5119	193	36	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	193	37	569	569	NUM
cblr-5119	193	38	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	193	39	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	193	40	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	193	41	124–25	124–25	NUM
cblr-5119	193	42	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	194	1	64	64	NUM
cblr-5119	194	2	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	194	3	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	194	4	did	do	AUX
cblr-5119	194	5	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	194	6	provide	provide	VERB
cblr-5119	194	7	guidance	guidance	NOUN
cblr-5119	194	8	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	194	9	how	how	SCONJ
cblr-5119	194	10	courts	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	194	11	should	should	AUX
cblr-5119	194	12	apply	apply	VERB
cblr-5119	194	13	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	194	14	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	194	15	touch	touch	NOUN
cblr-5119	194	16	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	194	17	concern	concern	NOUN
cblr-5119	194	18	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	194	19	test	test	NOUN
cblr-5119	194	20	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	194	21	future	future	ADJ
cblr-5119	194	22	cases	case	NOUN
cblr-5119	194	23	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	194	24	which	which	PRON
cblr-5119	194	25	left	leave	VERB
cblr-5119	194	26	courts	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	194	27	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	194	28	develop	develop	VERB
cblr-5119	194	29	their	their	PRON
cblr-5119	194	30	own	own	ADJ
cblr-5119	194	31	methodologies	methodology	NOUN
cblr-5119	194	32	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	194	33	as	as	ADP
cblr-5119	194	34	discussed	discuss	VERB
cblr-5119	194	35	infra	infra	NOUN
cblr-5119	194	36	part	part	NOUN
cblr-5119	194	37	iii	iii	PROPN
cblr-5119	194	38	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	194	39	65	65	NUM
cblr-5119	194	40	kiobel	kiobel	NOUN
cblr-5119	194	41	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	194	42	569	569	NUM
cblr-5119	194	43	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	194	44	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	194	45	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	194	46	125	125	NUM
cblr-5119	194	47	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	195	1	66	66	NUM
cblr-5119	196	1	i	i	PRON
cblr-5119	196	2	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-5119	196	3	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	196	4	116–17	116–17	NUM
cblr-5119	196	5	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	196	6	discussing	discuss	VERB
cblr-5119	196	7	sosa	sosa	PROPN
cblr-5119	196	8	v.	v.	PROPN
cblr-5119	196	9	alvarez	alvarez	PROPN
cblr-5119	196	10	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-5119	196	11	machain	machain	NOUN
cblr-5119	196	12	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	196	13	542	542	NUM
cblr-5119	196	14	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	196	15	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	196	16	692	692	NUM
cblr-5119	196	17	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	196	18	2004	2004	NUM
cblr-5119	196	19	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	196	20	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	196	21	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	197	1	67	67	NUM
cblr-5119	198	1	i	i	PRON
cblr-5119	198	2	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-5119	198	3	68	68	NUM
cblr-5119	199	1	i	i	PRON
cblr-5119	199	2	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-5119	199	3	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	199	4	119–22	119–22	PROPN
cblr-5119	199	5	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	200	1	6_2019.3_estes	6_2019.3_estes	NUM
cblr-5119	200	2	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	200	3	do	do	AUX
cblr-5119	200	4	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	200	5	delte	delte	VERB
cblr-5119	200	6	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	200	7	12/26/2019	12/26/2019	NUM
cblr-5119	200	8	12:00	12:00	NUM
cblr-5119	200	9	am	am	NOUN
cblr-5119	200	10	1046	1046	NUM
cblr-5119	200	11	columbia	columbia	PROPN
cblr-5119	200	12	business	business	NOUN
cblr-5119	200	13	law	law	PROPN
cblr-5119	200	14	review	review	NOUN
cblr-5119	200	15	[	[	X
cblr-5119	200	16	vol	vol	NOUN
cblr-5119	200	17	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	200	18	2019	2019	NUM
cblr-5119	200	19	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	200	20	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	200	21	citizens	citizen	NOUN
cblr-5119	200	22	into	into	ADP
cblr-5119	200	23	their	their	PRON
cblr-5119	200	24	courts	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	200	25	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	200	26	violations	violation	NOUN
cblr-5119	200	27	occurring	occur	VERB
cblr-5119	200	28	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	200	29	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	200	30	united	united	PROPN
cblr-5119	200	31	states.69	states.69	PROPN
cblr-5119	200	32	given	give	VERB
cblr-5119	200	33	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	200	34	facts	fact	NOUN
cblr-5119	200	35	before	before	ADP
cblr-5119	200	36	it	it	PRON
cblr-5119	200	37	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	200	38	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	200	39	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	200	40	affirmed	affirm	VERB
cblr-5119	200	41	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	200	42	second	second	ADJ
cblr-5119	200	43	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	200	44	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	200	45	dismissal	dismissal	NOUN
cblr-5119	200	46	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	200	47	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	200	48	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
cblr-5119	200	49	’	'	PUNCT
cblr-5119	200	50	claims	claim	NOUN
cblr-5119	200	51	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	200	52	finding	find	VERB
cblr-5119	200	53	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	200	54	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	200	55	claims	claim	NOUN
cblr-5119	200	56	did	do	AUX
cblr-5119	200	57	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	200	58	touch	touch	VERB
cblr-5119	200	59	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	200	60	concern	concern	NOUN
cblr-5119	200	61	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	200	62	united	united	PROPN
cblr-5119	200	63	states	states	PROPN
cblr-5119	200	64	with	with	ADP
cblr-5119	200	65	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
cblr-5119	200	66	force	force	NOUN
cblr-5119	200	67	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	200	68	displace	displace	VERB
cblr-5119	200	69	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	200	70	presumption	presumption	NOUN
cblr-5119	200	71	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	200	72	warrant	warrant	VERB
cblr-5119	200	73	jurisdiction.70	jurisdiction.70	ADJ
cblr-5119	200	74	none	none	NOUN
cblr-5119	200	75	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	200	76	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	200	77	parties	party	NOUN
cblr-5119	200	78	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	200	79	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	200	80	case	case	NOUN
cblr-5119	200	81	were	be	AUX
cblr-5119	200	82	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	200	83	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	200	84	nationals	national	NOUN
cblr-5119	200	85	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	201	1	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	201	2	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
cblr-5119	201	3	were	be	AUX
cblr-5119	201	4	nigerian	nigerian	ADJ
cblr-5119	201	5	nationals	national	NOUN
cblr-5119	201	6	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	201	7	had	have	AUX
cblr-5119	201	8	sued	sue	VERB
cblr-5119	201	9	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	201	10	dutch	dutch	ADJ
cblr-5119	201	11	holding	hold	VERB
cblr-5119	201	12	company	company	NOUN
cblr-5119	201	13	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	201	14	an	an	DET
cblr-5119	201	15	english	english	ADJ
cblr-5119	201	16	holding	hold	VERB
cblr-5119	201	17	company	company	NOUN
cblr-5119	201	18	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	201	19	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	201	20	their	their	PRON
cblr-5119	201	21	joint	joint	ADJ
cblr-5119	201	22	subsidiary	subsidiary	NOUN
cblr-5119	201	23	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	201	24	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	201	25	nigerian	nigerian	ADJ
cblr-5119	201	26	corporation	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	201	27	involved	involve	VERB
cblr-5119	201	28	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	201	29	oil	oil	NOUN
cblr-5119	201	30	production	production	NOUN
cblr-5119	201	31	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	201	32	nigeria	nigeria	PROPN
cblr-5119	201	33	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	202	1	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	202	2	defendants	defendant	NOUN
cblr-5119	202	3	allegedly	allegedly	ADV
cblr-5119	202	4	aided	aid	VERB
cblr-5119	202	5	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	202	6	abetted	abet	VERB
cblr-5119	202	7	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	202	8	nigerian	nigerian	ADJ
cblr-5119	202	9	military	military	NOUN
cblr-5119	202	10	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	202	11	police	police	NOUN
cblr-5119	202	12	forces	force	NOUN
cblr-5119	202	13	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	202	14	their	their	PRON
cblr-5119	202	15	commission	commission	NOUN
cblr-5119	202	16	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	202	17	extrajudicial	extrajudicial	ADJ
cblr-5119	202	18	killings	killing	NOUN
cblr-5119	202	19	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	202	20	crimes	crime	NOUN
cblr-5119	202	21	against	against	ADP
cblr-5119	202	22	humanity	humanity	NOUN
cblr-5119	202	23	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	202	24	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	202	25	torture	torture	NOUN
cblr-5119	202	26	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	202	27	among	among	ADP
cblr-5119	202	28	other	other	ADJ
cblr-5119	202	29	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	202	30	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	202	31	nations	nation	NOUN
cblr-5119	202	32	violations	violation	NOUN
cblr-5119	202	33	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	202	34	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	202	35	response	response	NOUN
cblr-5119	202	36	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	202	37	local	local	ADJ
cblr-5119	202	38	residents	resident	NOUN
cblr-5119	202	39	protesting	protest	VERB
cblr-5119	202	40	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	202	41	environmental	environmental	ADJ
cblr-5119	202	42	effects	effect	NOUN
cblr-5119	202	43	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	202	44	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	202	45	nigerian	nigerian	ADJ
cblr-5119	202	46	subsidiary	subsidiary	NOUN
cblr-5119	202	47	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	202	48	oil	oil	NOUN
cblr-5119	202	49	activities.71	activities.71	NOUN
cblr-5119	202	50	all	all	DET
cblr-5119	202	51	alleged	alleged	ADJ
cblr-5119	202	52	conduct	conduct	NOUN
cblr-5119	202	53	occurred	occur	VERB
cblr-5119	202	54	outside	outside	ADP
cblr-5119	202	55	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	202	56	united	united	PROPN
cblr-5119	202	57	states	states	PROPN
cblr-5119	202	58	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	202	59	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	202	60	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	202	61	defendants	defendant	NOUN
cblr-5119	202	62	’	'	PUNCT
cblr-5119	202	63	only	only	ADV
cblr-5119	202	64	connection	connection	NOUN
cblr-5119	202	65	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	202	66	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	202	67	united	united	PROPN
cblr-5119	202	68	states	states	PROPN
cblr-5119	202	69	was	be	AUX
cblr-5119	202	70	their	their	PRON
cblr-5119	202	71	listing	listing	NOUN
cblr-5119	202	72	on	on	ADP
cblr-5119	202	73	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	202	74	new	new	PROPN
cblr-5119	202	75	york	york	PROPN
cblr-5119	202	76	stock	stock	PROPN
cblr-5119	202	77	exchange	exchange	PROPN
cblr-5119	202	78	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	202	79	their	their	PRON
cblr-5119	202	80	maintaining	maintain	VERB
cblr-5119	202	81	an	an	DET
cblr-5119	202	82	affiliated	affiliated	ADJ
cblr-5119	202	83	office	office	NOUN
cblr-5119	202	84	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	202	85	new	new	PROPN
cblr-5119	202	86	york	york	PROPN
cblr-5119	202	87	whose	whose	DET
cblr-5119	202	88	sole	sole	ADJ
cblr-5119	202	89	purpose	purpose	NOUN
cblr-5119	202	90	was	be	AUX
cblr-5119	202	91	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	202	92	explain	explain	VERB
cblr-5119	202	93	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	202	94	defendants	defendant	NOUN
cblr-5119	202	95	’	'	PUNCT
cblr-5119	202	96	business	business	NOUN
cblr-5119	202	97	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	202	98	investors.72	investors.72	VERB
cblr-5119	202	99	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	202	100	these	these	DET
cblr-5119	202	101	circumstances	circumstance	NOUN
cblr-5119	202	102	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	202	103	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	202	104	presumption	presumption	NOUN
cblr-5119	202	105	against	against	ADP
cblr-5119	202	106	extraterritoriality	extraterritoriality	NOUN
cblr-5119	202	107	prevented	prevent	VERB
cblr-5119	202	108	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	202	109	exercise	exercise	NOUN
cblr-5119	202	110	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	202	111	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	202	112	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NOUN
cblr-5119	202	113	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	203	1	justice	justice	NOUN
cblr-5119	203	2	breyer	breyer	PROPN
cblr-5119	203	3	wrote	write	VERB
cblr-5119	203	4	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	203	5	concurring	concurring	NOUN
cblr-5119	203	6	opinion	opinion	NOUN
cblr-5119	203	7	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	203	8	which	which	PRON
cblr-5119	203	9	he	he	PRON
cblr-5119	203	10	stated	state	VERB
cblr-5119	203	11	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	203	12	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	203	13	guided	guide	VERB
cblr-5119	203	14	by	by	ADP
cblr-5119	203	15	international	international	ADJ
cblr-5119	203	16	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	203	17	principles	principle	NOUN
cblr-5119	203	18	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	203	19	he	he	PRON
cblr-5119	203	20	would	would	AUX
cblr-5119	203	21	have	have	VERB
cblr-5119	203	22	courts	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	203	23	exercise	exercise	VERB
cblr-5119	203	24	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	203	25	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NOUN
cblr-5119	203	26	when	when	SCONJ
cblr-5119	203	27	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	203	28	1	1	X
cblr-5119	203	29	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	203	30	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	203	31	alleged	alleged	ADJ
cblr-5119	203	32	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	203	33	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	203	34	nations	nation	NOUN
cblr-5119	203	35	violation	violation	NOUN
cblr-5119	203	36	occurred	occur	VERB
cblr-5119	203	37	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	203	38	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	203	39	united	united	PROPN
cblr-5119	203	40	states	states	PROPN
cblr-5119	203	41	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	203	42	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	203	43	2	2	X
cblr-5119	203	44	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	203	45	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	203	46	defendant	defendant	NOUN
cblr-5119	203	47	was	be	AUX
cblr-5119	203	48	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	203	49	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	203	50	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	203	51	national	national	PROPN
cblr-5119	203	52	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	203	53	or	or	CCONJ
cblr-5119	203	54	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	203	55	3	3	X
cblr-5119	203	56	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	203	57	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	203	58	alleged	allege	VERB
cblr-5119	203	59	conduct	conduct	NOUN
cblr-5119	203	60	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	203	61	substantially	substantially	ADV
cblr-5119	203	62	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	203	63	adversely	adversely	ADV
cblr-5119	203	64	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	203	65	affected	affect	VERB
cblr-5119	203	66	an	an	DET
cblr-5119	203	67	important	important	ADJ
cblr-5119	203	68	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	203	69	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	203	70	interest	interest	NOUN
cblr-5119	203	71	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	203	72	including	include	VERB
cblr-5119	203	73	an	an	DET
cblr-5119	203	74	interest	interest	NOUN
cblr-5119	203	75	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	203	76	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	203	77	preventing	prevent	VERB
cblr-5119	203	78	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	203	79	united	united	PROPN
cblr-5119	203	80	states	states	PROPN
cblr-5119	203	81	from	from	ADP
cblr-5119	203	82	becoming	become	VERB
cblr-5119	203	83	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	203	84	safe	safe	ADJ
cblr-5119	203	85	harbor	harbor	NOUN
cblr-5119	203	86	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	203	87	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	203	88	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	204	1	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	204	2	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	204	3	torturer	torturer	NOUN
cblr-5119	204	4	or	or	CCONJ
cblr-5119	204	5	other	other	ADJ
cblr-5119	204	6	common	common	ADJ
cblr-5119	204	7	enemy	enemy	NOUN
cblr-5119	204	8	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	204	9	mankind	mankind	NOUN
cblr-5119	204	10	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	205	1	”73	”73	PROPN
cblr-5119	205	2	however	however	ADV
cblr-5119	205	3	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	205	4	justice	justice	NOUN
cblr-5119	205	5	breyer	breyer	NOUN
cblr-5119	205	6	69	69	NUM
cblr-5119	206	1	i	i	PRON
cblr-5119	206	2	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-5119	206	3	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	206	4	124	124	NUM
cblr-5119	206	5	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	207	1	70	70	NUM
cblr-5119	208	1	i	i	PRON
cblr-5119	208	2	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-5119	208	3	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	208	4	124–25	124–25	NUM
cblr-5119	208	5	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	209	1	71	71	NUM
cblr-5119	210	1	i	i	PRON
cblr-5119	210	2	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-5119	210	3	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	210	4	111–14	111–14	NUM
cblr-5119	210	5	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	211	1	72	72	NUM
cblr-5119	212	1	i	i	PRON
cblr-5119	212	2	d.	d.	NOUN
cblr-5119	212	3	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	212	4	139–40	139–40	PROPN
cblr-5119	212	5	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	212	6	breyer	breyer	NOUN
cblr-5119	212	7	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	212	8	j.	j.	PROPN
cblr-5119	212	9	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	212	10	concurring	concur	VERB
cblr-5119	212	11	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	212	12	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	213	1	73	73	NUM
cblr-5119	214	1	i	i	PRON
cblr-5119	214	2	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-5119	214	3	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	214	4	127	127	NUM
cblr-5119	214	5	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	215	1	6_2019.3_estes	6_2019.3_estes	NUM
cblr-5119	215	2	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	215	3	do	do	AUX
cblr-5119	215	4	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	215	5	delete	delete	VERB
cblr-5119	215	6	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	215	7	12/26/2019	12/26/2019	NUM
cblr-5119	215	8	12:00	12:00	NUM
cblr-5119	215	9	am	be	AUX
cblr-5119	215	10	no	no	NOUN
cblr-5119	215	11	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	216	1	3:1031	3:1031	NUM
cblr-5119	216	2	]	]	X
cblr-5119	216	3	may	may	AUX
cblr-5119	216	4	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	216	5	fourth	fourth	ADJ
cblr-5119	216	6	be	be	AUX
cblr-5119	216	7	with	with	ADP
cblr-5119	216	8	you	you	PRON
cblr-5119	216	9	1047	1047	NUM
cblr-5119	216	10	concurred	concur	VERB
cblr-5119	216	11	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	216	12	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	216	13	judgment	judgment	NOUN
cblr-5119	216	14	because	because	SCONJ
cblr-5119	216	15	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	216	16	facts	fact	NOUN
cblr-5119	216	17	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	216	18	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	216	19	case	case	NOUN
cblr-5119	216	20	met	meet	VERB
cblr-5119	216	21	none	none	NOUN
cblr-5119	216	22	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	216	23	those	those	DET
cblr-5119	216	24	three	three	NUM
cblr-5119	216	25	conditions.74	conditions.74	ADJ
cblr-5119	216	26	while	while	SCONJ
cblr-5119	216	27	kiobel	kiobel	PROPN
cblr-5119	216	28	ii	ii	PROPN
cblr-5119	216	29	announced	announce	VERB
cblr-5119	216	30	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	216	31	novel	novel	ADJ
cblr-5119	216	32	standard	standard	NOUN
cblr-5119	216	33	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	216	34	courts	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	216	35	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	216	36	evaluating	evaluate	VERB
cblr-5119	216	37	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	216	38	claims	claim	NOUN
cblr-5119	216	39	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	216	40	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	216	41	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	216	42	offered	offer	VERB
cblr-5119	216	43	no	no	DET
cblr-5119	216	44	real	real	ADJ
cblr-5119	216	45	guidance	guidance	NOUN
cblr-5119	216	46	as	as	ADP
cblr-5119	216	47	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	216	48	how	how	SCONJ
cblr-5119	216	49	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	216	50	conduct	conduct	VERB
cblr-5119	216	51	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	216	52	new	new	ADJ
cblr-5119	216	53	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	216	54	touch	touch	NOUN
cblr-5119	216	55	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	216	56	concern	concern	NOUN
cblr-5119	216	57	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	216	58	test	test	NOUN
cblr-5119	216	59	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	216	60	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	216	61	it	it	PRON
cblr-5119	216	62	only	only	ADV
cblr-5119	216	63	addressed	address	VERB
cblr-5119	216	64	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	216	65	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	216	66	by	by	ADP
cblr-5119	216	67	stating	state	VERB
cblr-5119	216	68	that	that	DET
cblr-5119	216	69	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	216	70	presence	presence	NOUN
cblr-5119	216	71	alone	alone	ADV
cblr-5119	216	72	is	be	AUX
cblr-5119	216	73	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	216	74	enough	enough	ADJ
cblr-5119	216	75	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	216	76	rebut	rebut	VERB
cblr-5119	216	77	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	216	78	presumption	presumption	NOUN
cblr-5119	216	79	against	against	ADP
cblr-5119	216	80	extraterritoriality	extraterritoriality	NOUN
cblr-5119	216	81	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	217	1	this	this	PRON
cblr-5119	217	2	led	lead	VERB
cblr-5119	217	3	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	217	4	district	district	NOUN
cblr-5119	217	5	courts	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	217	6	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	217	7	courts	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	217	8	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	217	9	appeals	appeal	NOUN
cblr-5119	217	10	applying	apply	VERB
cblr-5119	217	11	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	217	12	touch	touch	NOUN
cblr-5119	217	13	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	217	14	concern	concern	NOUN
cblr-5119	217	15	test	test	NOUN
cblr-5119	217	16	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	217	17	myriad	myriad	ADJ
cblr-5119	217	18	ways	way	NOUN
cblr-5119	217	19	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	217	20	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	217	21	ensuing	ensue	VERB
cblr-5119	217	22	years.75	years.75	NOUN
cblr-5119	217	23	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	217	24	issue	issue	NOUN
cblr-5119	217	25	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	217	26	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	217	27	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	217	28	also	also	ADV
cblr-5119	217	29	remained	remain	VERB
cblr-5119	217	30	unsettled	unsettled	ADJ
cblr-5119	217	31	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	217	32	though	though	SCONJ
cblr-5119	217	33	by	by	ADP
cblr-5119	217	34	refusing	refuse	VERB
cblr-5119	217	35	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	217	36	rule	rule	VERB
cblr-5119	217	37	on	on	ADP
cblr-5119	217	38	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	217	39	issue	issue	NOUN
cblr-5119	217	40	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	217	41	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	217	42	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	217	43	implicitly	implicitly	ADV
cblr-5119	217	44	indicated	indicate	VERB
cblr-5119	217	45	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	217	46	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	217	47	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	217	48	least	least	ADJ
cblr-5119	217	49	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	217	50	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	217	51	time	time	NOUN
cblr-5119	217	52	being	being	NOUN
cblr-5119	217	53	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	217	54	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	217	55	could	could	AUX
cblr-5119	217	56	be	be	AUX
cblr-5119	217	57	liable	liable	ADJ
cblr-5119	217	58	under	under	ADP
cblr-5119	217	59	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	217	60	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	217	61	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	217	62	except	except	SCONJ
cblr-5119	217	63	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	217	64	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	217	65	second	second	ADJ
cblr-5119	217	66	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	217	67	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	217	68	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	218	1	2	2	X
cblr-5119	218	2	.	.	X
cblr-5119	218	3	jesner	jesner	PROPN
cblr-5119	218	4	v.	v.	PROPN
cblr-5119	218	5	arab	arab	PROPN
cblr-5119	218	6	bank	bank	PROPN
cblr-5119	218	7	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	218	8	plc	plc	PROPN
cblr-5119	218	9	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	218	10	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	218	11	once	once	ADV
cblr-5119	218	12	again	again	ADV
cblr-5119	218	13	granted	grant	VERB
cblr-5119	218	14	certiorari	certiorari	NOUN
cblr-5119	218	15	on	on	ADP
cblr-5119	218	16	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	218	17	issue	issue	NOUN
cblr-5119	218	18	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	218	19	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	218	20	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	218	21	under	under	ADP
cblr-5119	218	22	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	218	23	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	218	24	only	only	ADV
cblr-5119	218	25	five	five	NUM
cblr-5119	218	26	years	year	NOUN
cblr-5119	218	27	later	later	ADV
cblr-5119	218	28	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	218	29	jesner	jesner	PROPN
cblr-5119	218	30	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	219	1	there	there	ADV
cblr-5119	219	2	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	219	3	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	219	4	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
cblr-5119	219	5	alleged	allege	VERB
cblr-5119	219	6	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	219	7	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	219	8	defendant	defendant	NOUN
cblr-5119	219	9	bank	bank	PROPN
cblr-5119	219	10	maintained	maintain	VERB
cblr-5119	219	11	accounts	account	NOUN
cblr-5119	219	12	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	219	13	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	219	14	middle	middle	PROPN
cblr-5119	219	15	east	east	PROPN
cblr-5119	219	16	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	219	17	terrorists	terrorist	NOUN
cblr-5119	219	18	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	219	19	helped	help	VERB
cblr-5119	219	20	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	219	21	compensate	compensate	VERB
cblr-5119	219	22	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	219	23	family	family	NOUN
cblr-5119	219	24	members	member	NOUN
cblr-5119	219	25	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	219	26	suicide	suicide	NOUN
cblr-5119	219	27	bombers	bomber	NOUN
cblr-5119	219	28	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	219	29	thus	thus	ADV
cblr-5119	219	30	aiding	aid	VERB
cblr-5119	219	31	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	219	32	abetting	abet	VERB
cblr-5119	219	33	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	219	34	injuries	injury	NOUN
cblr-5119	219	35	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	219	36	killings	killing	NOUN
cblr-5119	219	37	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	219	38	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	219	39	captures	capture	NOUN
cblr-5119	219	40	inflicted	inflict	VERB
cblr-5119	219	41	by	by	ADP
cblr-5119	219	42	terrorists	terrorist	NOUN
cblr-5119	219	43	on	on	ADP
cblr-5119	219	44	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	219	45	plaintiffs.76	plaintiffs.76	NOUN
cblr-5119	219	46	as	as	ADV
cblr-5119	219	47	far	far	ADV
cblr-5119	219	48	as	as	ADP
cblr-5119	219	49	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	219	50	nexus	nexus	NOUN
cblr-5119	219	51	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	219	52	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	219	53	united	united	PROPN
cblr-5119	219	54	states	states	PROPN
cblr-5119	219	55	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	219	56	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	219	57	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
cblr-5119	219	58	alleged	allege	VERB
cblr-5119	219	59	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	219	60	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	219	61	defendant	defendant	NOUN
cblr-5119	219	62	used	use	VERB
cblr-5119	219	63	its	its	PRON
cblr-5119	219	64	new	new	PROPN
cblr-5119	219	65	york	york	PROPN
cblr-5119	219	66	branch	branch	NOUN
cblr-5119	219	67	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	219	68	clear	clear	ADJ
cblr-5119	219	69	dollar	dollar	NOUN
cblr-5119	219	70	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-5119	219	71	denominated	denominate	VERB
cblr-5119	219	72	transactions	transaction	NOUN
cblr-5119	219	73	that	that	PRON
cblr-5119	219	74	benefited	benefit	VERB
cblr-5119	219	75	terrorists	terrorist	NOUN
cblr-5119	219	76	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	219	77	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	219	78	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	219	79	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	219	80	defendant	defendant	NOUN
cblr-5119	219	81	also	also	ADV
cblr-5119	219	82	used	use	VERB
cblr-5119	219	83	that	that	DET
cblr-5119	219	84	branch	branch	NOUN
cblr-5119	219	85	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	219	86	transfer	transfer	VERB
cblr-5119	219	87	funds	fund	NOUN
cblr-5119	219	88	from	from	ADP
cblr-5119	219	89	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	219	90	texas	texas	NOUN
cblr-5119	219	91	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-5119	219	92	based	base	VERB
cblr-5119	219	93	charity	charity	NOUN
cblr-5119	219	94	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	219	95	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	219	96	accounts	account	NOUN
cblr-5119	219	97	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	219	98	terrorist	terrorist	NOUN
cblr-5119	219	99	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-5119	219	100	affiliated	affiliate	VERB
cblr-5119	219	101	charities	charity	NOUN
cblr-5119	219	102	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	219	103	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	219	104	middle	middle	ADJ
cblr-5119	219	105	east.77	east.77	PROPN
cblr-5119	219	106	writing	writing	NOUN
cblr-5119	219	107	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	219	108	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	219	109	5–4	5–4	NOUN
cblr-5119	219	110	plurality	plurality	NOUN
cblr-5119	219	111	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	219	112	justice	justice	PROPN
cblr-5119	219	113	kennedy	kennedy	PROPN
cblr-5119	219	114	framed	frame	VERB
cblr-5119	219	115	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	219	116	issue	issue	NOUN
cblr-5119	219	117	as	as	ADP
cblr-5119	219	118	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	219	119	whether	whether	SCONJ
cblr-5119	219	120	common	common	ADJ
cblr-5119	219	121	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-5119	219	122	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	219	123	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	219	124	under	under	ADP
cblr-5119	219	125	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	219	126	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	219	127	74	74	NUM
cblr-5119	219	128	i	i	PRON
cblr-5119	219	129	d.	d.	NOUN
cblr-5119	219	130	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	219	131	139–40	139–40	NUM
cblr-5119	219	132	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	220	1	75	75	NUM
cblr-5119	220	2	ursula	ursula	PROPN
cblr-5119	220	3	tracy	tracy	PROPN
cblr-5119	220	4	doyle	doyle	PROPN
cblr-5119	220	5	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	220	6	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	220	7	evidence	evidence	NOUN
cblr-5119	220	8	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	220	9	things	thing	NOUN
cblr-5119	220	10	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	220	11	seen	see	VERB
cblr-5119	220	12	:	:	PUNCT
cblr-5119	220	13	divining	divine	VERB
cblr-5119	220	14	balancing	balance	VERB
cblr-5119	220	15	factors	factor	NOUN
cblr-5119	220	16	from	from	ADP
cblr-5119	220	17	kiobel	kiobel	PROPN
cblr-5119	220	18	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	220	19	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	220	20	touch	touch	NOUN
cblr-5119	220	21	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	220	22	concern	concern	NOUN
cblr-5119	220	23	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	220	24	test	test	NOUN
cblr-5119	220	25	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	220	26	66	66	NUM
cblr-5119	220	27	hastings	hastings	PROPN
cblr-5119	220	28	l.j	l.j	PROPN
cblr-5119	220	29	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	220	30	443	443	NUM
cblr-5119	220	31	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	220	32	455–56	455–56	NOUN
cblr-5119	220	33	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	220	34	2015	2015	NUM
cblr-5119	220	35	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	220	36	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	221	1	76	76	NUM
cblr-5119	221	2	jesner	jesner	PROPN
cblr-5119	221	3	v.	v.	PROPN
cblr-5119	221	4	arab	arab	PROPN
cblr-5119	221	5	bank	bank	PROPN
cblr-5119	221	6	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	221	7	plc	plc	PROPN
cblr-5119	221	8	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	221	9	138	138	NUM
cblr-5119	221	10	s.	s.	PROPN
cblr-5119	221	11	ct	ct	PROPN
cblr-5119	221	12	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	221	13	1386	1386	NUM
cblr-5119	221	14	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	221	15	1394	1394	NUM
cblr-5119	221	16	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	221	17	2018	2018	NUM
cblr-5119	221	18	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	221	19	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	222	1	77	77	NUM
cblr-5119	223	1	i	i	PRON
cblr-5119	223	2	d.	d.	NOUN
cblr-5119	223	3	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	223	4	1394–95	1394–95	NUM
cblr-5119	223	5	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	224	1	6_2019.3_estes	6_2019.3_estes	NUM
cblr-5119	224	2	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	224	3	do	do	AUX
cblr-5119	224	4	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	224	5	delte	delte	VERB
cblr-5119	224	6	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	224	7	12/26/2019	12/26/2019	NUM
cblr-5119	224	8	12:00	12:00	NUM
cblr-5119	224	9	am	be	AUX
cblr-5119	224	10	1048	1048	NUM
cblr-5119	224	11	columbia	columbia	PROPN
cblr-5119	224	12	business	business	NOUN
cblr-5119	224	13	law	law	PROPN
cblr-5119	224	14	review	review	NOUN
cblr-5119	224	15	[	[	X
cblr-5119	224	16	vol	vol	NOUN
cblr-5119	224	17	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	224	18	2019	2019	NUM
cblr-5119	224	19	extends	extend	VERB
cblr-5119	224	20	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	224	21	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	224	22	foreign	foreign	ADJ
cblr-5119	224	23	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	224	24	defendant”,78	defendant”,78	NOUN
cblr-5119	224	25	rather	rather	ADV
cblr-5119	224	26	than	than	ADP
cblr-5119	224	27	addressing	address	VERB
cblr-5119	224	28	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	224	29	issue	issue	NOUN
cblr-5119	224	30	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	224	31	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	224	32	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	224	33	generally	generally	ADV
cblr-5119	224	34	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	225	1	justice	justice	PROPN
cblr-5119	225	2	kennedy	kennedy	PROPN
cblr-5119	225	3	characterized	characterize	VERB
cblr-5119	225	4	sosa	sosa	PROPN
cblr-5119	225	5	as	as	ADP
cblr-5119	225	6	mandating	mandate	VERB
cblr-5119	225	7	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	225	8	two	two	NUM
cblr-5119	225	9	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-5119	225	10	question	question	NOUN
cblr-5119	225	11	test	test	NOUN
cblr-5119	225	12	:	:	PUNCT
cblr-5119	225	13	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	225	14	1	1	X
cblr-5119	225	15	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	225	16	whether	whether	SCONJ
cblr-5119	225	17	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	225	18	allegedly	allegedly	ADV
cblr-5119	225	19	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-5119	225	20	violated	violate	VERB
cblr-5119	225	21	international	international	ADJ
cblr-5119	225	22	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	225	23	norm	norm	NOUN
cblr-5119	225	24	is	be	AUX
cblr-5119	225	25	sufficiently	sufficiently	ADV
cblr-5119	225	26	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	225	27	specific	specific	ADJ
cblr-5119	225	28	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	225	29	universal	universal	ADJ
cblr-5119	225	30	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	225	31	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	225	32	obligatory	obligatory	ADJ
cblr-5119	225	33	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	225	34	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	225	35	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	225	36	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	225	37	2	2	X
cblr-5119	225	38	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	225	39	whether	whether	SCONJ
cblr-5119	225	40	judicial	judicial	ADJ
cblr-5119	225	41	caution	caution	NOUN
cblr-5119	225	42	mandates	mandate	VERB
cblr-5119	225	43	dismissal	dismissal	NOUN
cblr-5119	225	44	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	225	45	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	225	46	absence	absence	NOUN
cblr-5119	225	47	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	225	48	authorization	authorization	NOUN
cblr-5119	225	49	by	by	ADP
cblr-5119	225	50	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	225	51	political	political	ADJ
cblr-5119	225	52	branches.79	branches.79	VERB
cblr-5119	225	53	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	225	54	second	second	ADJ
cblr-5119	225	55	question	question	NOUN
cblr-5119	225	56	ultimately	ultimately	ADV
cblr-5119	225	57	proved	prove	VERB
cblr-5119	225	58	determinative	determinative	ADJ
cblr-5119	225	59	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	225	60	as	as	SCONJ
cblr-5119	225	61	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	225	62	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	225	63	held	hold	VERB
cblr-5119	225	64	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	225	65	foreign	foreign	ADJ
cblr-5119	225	66	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	225	67	could	could	AUX
cblr-5119	225	68	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	225	69	be	be	AUX
cblr-5119	225	70	defendants	defendant	NOUN
cblr-5119	225	71	under	under	ADP
cblr-5119	225	72	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	225	73	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	225	74	due	due	ADP
cblr-5119	225	75	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	225	76	foreign	foreign	ADJ
cblr-5119	225	77	policy	policy	NOUN
cblr-5119	225	78	concerns.80	concerns.80	NOUN
cblr-5119	226	1	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	226	2	plurality	plurality	NOUN
cblr-5119	226	3	echoed	echo	VERB
cblr-5119	226	4	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	226	5	concern	concern	NOUN
cblr-5119	226	6	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	226	7	kiobel	kiobel	PROPN
cblr-5119	226	8	ii	ii	PROPN
cblr-5119	226	9	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	226	10	holding	hold	VERB
cblr-5119	226	11	otherwise	otherwise	ADV
cblr-5119	226	12	could	could	AUX
cblr-5119	226	13	result	result	VERB
cblr-5119	226	14	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	226	15	other	other	ADJ
cblr-5119	226	16	nations	nation	NOUN
cblr-5119	226	17	haling	hale	VERB
cblr-5119	226	18	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	226	19	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	226	20	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	226	21	into	into	ADP
cblr-5119	226	22	their	their	PRON
cblr-5119	226	23	courts	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	226	24	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	226	25	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	226	26	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	226	27	nations	nation	NOUN
cblr-5119	226	28	violations	violation	NOUN
cblr-5119	226	29	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	227	1	it	it	PRON
cblr-5119	227	2	stated	state	VERB
cblr-5119	227	3	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	227	4	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	227	5	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	227	6	cautionary	cautionary	ADJ
cblr-5119	227	7	language	language	NOUN
cblr-5119	227	8	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	227	9	sosa	sosa	PROPN
cblr-5119	227	10	would	would	AUX
cblr-5119	227	11	be	be	AUX
cblr-5119	227	12	little	little	ADV
cblr-5119	227	13	more	more	ADJ
cblr-5119	227	14	than	than	ADP
cblr-5119	227	15	empty	empty	ADJ
cblr-5119	227	16	rhetoric	rhetoric	NOUN
cblr-5119	227	17	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	227	18	if	if	SCONJ
cblr-5119	227	19	foreign	foreign	ADJ
cblr-5119	227	20	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	227	21	faced	face	VERB
cblr-5119	227	22	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	227	23	liability.81	liability.81	PROPN
cblr-5119	227	24	under	under	ADP
cblr-5119	227	25	this	this	DET
cblr-5119	227	26	view	view	NOUN
cblr-5119	227	27	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	227	28	imposing	impose	VERB
cblr-5119	227	29	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	227	30	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	227	31	on	on	ADP
cblr-5119	227	32	foreign	foreign	ADJ
cblr-5119	227	33	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	227	34	could	could	AUX
cblr-5119	227	35	result	result	VERB
cblr-5119	227	36	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	227	37	significant	significant	ADJ
cblr-5119	227	38	international	international	ADJ
cblr-5119	227	39	friction	friction	NOUN
cblr-5119	227	40	with	with	ADP
cblr-5119	227	41	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	227	42	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	227	43	’	'	PUNCT
cblr-5119	227	44	home	home	NOUN
cblr-5119	227	45	nations	nation	NOUN
cblr-5119	227	46	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	227	47	reinforcing	reinforce	VERB
cblr-5119	227	48	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	227	49	need	need	NOUN
cblr-5119	227	50	for	for	SCONJ
cblr-5119	227	51	courts	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	227	52	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	227	53	defer	defer	VERB
cblr-5119	227	54	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	227	55	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	227	56	political	political	ADJ
cblr-5119	227	57	branches	branch	NOUN
cblr-5119	227	58	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	227	59	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	227	60	area	area	NOUN
cblr-5119	227	61	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	227	62	foreign	foreign	ADJ
cblr-5119	227	63	relations	relation	NOUN
cblr-5119	227	64	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	227	65	since	since	SCONJ
cblr-5119	227	66	that	that	PRON
cblr-5119	227	67	is	be	AUX
cblr-5119	227	68	traditionally	traditionally	ADV
cblr-5119	227	69	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	227	70	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	227	71	judiciary	judiciary	NOUN
cblr-5119	227	72	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	227	73	province.82	province.82	PROPN
cblr-5119	227	74	justice	justice	PROPN
cblr-5119	227	75	kennedy	kennedy	PROPN
cblr-5119	227	76	reached	reach	VERB
cblr-5119	227	77	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	227	78	second	second	ADJ
cblr-5119	227	79	sosa	sosa	PROPN
cblr-5119	227	80	question	question	NOUN
cblr-5119	227	81	because	because	SCONJ
cblr-5119	227	82	there	there	PRON
cblr-5119	227	83	was	be	VERB
cblr-5119	227	84	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	227	85	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
cblr-5119	227	86	doubt	doubt	NOUN
cblr-5119	227	87	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	227	88	on	on	ADP
cblr-5119	227	89	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	227	90	first	first	ADJ
cblr-5119	227	91	question	question	NOUN
cblr-5119	227	92	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	227	93	merit	merit	NOUN
cblr-5119	227	94	doing	do	VERB
cblr-5119	227	95	so	so	ADV
cblr-5119	227	96	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	227	97	but	but	CCONJ
cblr-5119	227	98	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	227	99	his	his	PRON
cblr-5119	227	100	discussion	discussion	NOUN
cblr-5119	227	101	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	227	102	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	227	103	first	first	ADJ
cblr-5119	227	104	question	question	NOUN
cblr-5119	227	105	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	227	106	he	he	PRON
cblr-5119	227	107	seemed	seem	VERB
cblr-5119	227	108	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	227	109	indicate	indicate	VERB
cblr-5119	227	110	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	227	111	he	he	PRON
cblr-5119	227	112	sided	side	VERB
cblr-5119	227	113	with	with	ADP
cblr-5119	227	114	kiobel	kiobel	PROPN
cblr-5119	227	115	i	i	PRON
cblr-5119	227	116	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	227	117	though	though	SCONJ
cblr-5119	227	118	this	this	DET
cblr-5119	227	119	part	part	NOUN
cblr-5119	227	120	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	227	121	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	227	122	opinion	opinion	NOUN
cblr-5119	227	123	did	do	AUX
cblr-5119	227	124	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	227	125	carry	carry	VERB
cblr-5119	227	126	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	227	127	majority	majority	NOUN
cblr-5119	227	128	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	227	129	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	227	130	court).83	court).83	PROPN
cblr-5119	227	131	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	227	132	kiobel	kiobel	PROPN
cblr-5119	227	133	i	i	PRON
cblr-5119	227	134	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	227	135	writing	write	VERB
cblr-5119	227	136	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	227	137	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	227	138	second	second	ADJ
cblr-5119	227	139	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	227	140	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	227	141	judge	judge	PROPN
cblr-5119	227	142	cabranes	cabrane	NOUN
cblr-5119	227	143	interpreted	interpret	VERB
cblr-5119	227	144	international	international	ADJ
cblr-5119	227	145	law	law	PROPN
cblr-5119	227	146	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	227	147	sosa	sosa	PROPN
cblr-5119	227	148	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	227	149	footnote	footnote	VERB
cblr-5119	227	150	20	20	NUM
cblr-5119	227	151	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	227	152	mean	mean	VERB
cblr-5119	227	153	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	227	154	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	227	155	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	227	156	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	227	157	could	could	AUX
cblr-5119	227	158	only	only	ADV
cblr-5119	227	159	exist	exist	VERB
cblr-5119	227	160	if	if	SCONJ
cblr-5119	227	161	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	227	162	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	227	163	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	227	164	human	human	ADJ
cblr-5119	227	165	rights	right	NOUN
cblr-5119	227	166	violations	violation	NOUN
cblr-5119	227	167	was	be	AUX
cblr-5119	227	168	itself	itself	PRON
cblr-5119	227	169	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	227	170	universally	universally	ADV
cblr-5119	227	171	recognized	recognize	VERB
cblr-5119	227	172	norm	norm	NOUN
cblr-5119	227	173	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	227	174	international	international	PROPN
cblr-5119	227	175	law.84	law.84	PROPN
cblr-5119	227	176	justice	justice	PROPN
cblr-5119	227	177	kennedy	kennedy	PROPN
cblr-5119	227	178	did	do	AUX
cblr-5119	227	179	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	227	180	decide	decide	VERB
cblr-5119	227	181	78	78	NUM
cblr-5119	228	1	i	i	PRON
cblr-5119	228	2	d.	d.	NOUN
cblr-5119	228	3	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	228	4	1398	1398	NUM
cblr-5119	228	5	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	228	6	emphasis	emphasis	NOUN
cblr-5119	228	7	added	add	VERB
cblr-5119	228	8	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	228	9	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	229	1	79	79	NUM
cblr-5119	230	1	i	i	PRON
cblr-5119	230	2	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-5119	230	3	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	230	4	1399	1399	NUM
cblr-5119	230	5	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	230	6	quoting	quote	VERB
cblr-5119	230	7	sosa	sosa	PROPN
cblr-5119	230	8	v.	v.	PROPN
cblr-5119	230	9	alvarez	alvarez	PROPN
cblr-5119	230	10	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-5119	230	11	machain	machain	NOUN
cblr-5119	230	12	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	230	13	542	542	NUM
cblr-5119	230	14	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	230	15	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	230	16	692	692	NUM
cblr-5119	230	17	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	230	18	2004	2004	NUM
cblr-5119	230	19	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	230	20	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	231	1	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	231	2	internal	internal	ADJ
cblr-5119	231	3	quotation	quotation	NOUN
cblr-5119	231	4	marks	mark	NOUN
cblr-5119	231	5	omitted	omit	VERB
cblr-5119	231	6	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	231	7	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	232	1	80	80	NUM
cblr-5119	233	1	i	i	PRON
cblr-5119	233	2	d.	d.	NOUN
cblr-5119	233	3	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	233	4	1407	1407	NUM
cblr-5119	233	5	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	234	1	81	81	NUM
cblr-5119	235	1	i	i	PRON
cblr-5119	235	2	d.	d.	NOUN
cblr-5119	235	3	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	235	4	1405–07	1405–07	NUM
cblr-5119	235	5	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	236	1	82	82	NUM
cblr-5119	237	1	i	i	PRON
cblr-5119	237	2	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-5119	237	3	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	237	4	1406	1406	NUM
cblr-5119	237	5	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	238	1	83	83	NUM
cblr-5119	239	1	i	i	PRON
cblr-5119	239	2	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-5119	239	3	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	239	4	1399–1402	1399–1402	NUM
cblr-5119	239	5	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	240	1	84	84	NUM
cblr-5119	240	2	kiobel	kiobel	NOUN
cblr-5119	240	3	v.	v.	ADP
cblr-5119	240	4	royal	royal	PROPN
cblr-5119	240	5	dutch	dutch	PROPN
cblr-5119	240	6	petroleum	petroleum	PROPN
cblr-5119	240	7	co.	co.	PROPN
cblr-5119	240	8	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	240	9	621	621	NUM
cblr-5119	240	10	f.3d	f.3d	NUM
cblr-5119	240	11	111	111	NUM
cblr-5119	240	12	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	240	13	120	120	NUM
cblr-5119	240	14	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	240	15	2d	2d	NUM
cblr-5119	240	16	cir	cir	NOUN
cblr-5119	240	17	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	240	18	2010	2010	NUM
cblr-5119	240	19	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	240	20	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	240	21	aff’d	aff’d	VERB
cblr-5119	240	22	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	240	23	569	569	NUM
cblr-5119	240	24	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	240	25	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	240	26	108	108	NUM
cblr-5119	240	27	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	240	28	2013	2013	NUM
cblr-5119	240	29	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	240	30	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	241	1	6_2019.3_estes	6_2019.3_estes	NUM
cblr-5119	241	2	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	241	3	do	do	AUX
cblr-5119	241	4	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	241	5	delete	delete	VERB
cblr-5119	241	6	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	241	7	12/26/2019	12/26/2019	NUM
cblr-5119	241	8	12:00	12:00	NUM
cblr-5119	241	9	am	be	AUX
cblr-5119	241	10	no	no	NOUN
cblr-5119	241	11	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	242	1	3:1031	3:1031	NUM
cblr-5119	242	2	]	]	X
cblr-5119	242	3	may	may	AUX
cblr-5119	242	4	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	242	5	fourth	fourth	ADJ
cblr-5119	242	6	be	be	AUX
cblr-5119	242	7	with	with	ADP
cblr-5119	242	8	you	you	PRON
cblr-5119	242	9	1049	1049	NUM
cblr-5119	242	10	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	242	11	issue	issue	NOUN
cblr-5119	242	12	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	242	13	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	242	14	he	he	PRON
cblr-5119	242	15	acknowledged	acknowledge	VERB
cblr-5119	242	16	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	242	17	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	242	18	considerable	considerable	ADJ
cblr-5119	242	19	force	force	NOUN
cblr-5119	242	20	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	242	21	weight	weight	NOUN
cblr-5119	242	22	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	242	23	behind	behind	ADP
cblr-5119	242	24	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	242	25	position	position	NOUN
cblr-5119	242	26	taken	take	VERB
cblr-5119	242	27	by	by	ADP
cblr-5119	242	28	judge	judge	NOUN
cblr-5119	242	29	leval	leval	PROPN
cblr-5119	242	30	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	242	31	concurrence	concurrence	NOUN
cblr-5119	242	32	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	242	33	kiobel	kiobel	PROPN
cblr-5119	242	34	i.	i.	PROPN
cblr-5119	242	35	there	there	ADV
cblr-5119	242	36	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	242	37	judge	judge	NOUN
cblr-5119	242	38	leval	leval	PROPN
cblr-5119	242	39	argued	argue	VERB
cblr-5119	242	40	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	242	41	international	international	ADJ
cblr-5119	242	42	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	242	43	only	only	ADV
cblr-5119	242	44	governed	govern	VERB
cblr-5119	242	45	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	242	46	substance	substance	NOUN
cblr-5119	242	47	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	242	48	its	its	PRON
cblr-5119	242	49	violations	violation	NOUN
cblr-5119	242	50	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	242	51	left	leave	VERB
cblr-5119	242	52	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	242	53	questions	question	NOUN
cblr-5119	242	54	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	242	55	remedies	remedy	NOUN
cblr-5119	242	56	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	242	57	enforcement	enforcement	NOUN
cblr-5119	242	58	—	—	PUNCT
cblr-5119	242	59	including	include	VERB
cblr-5119	242	60	whether	whether	SCONJ
cblr-5119	242	61	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	242	62	could	could	AUX
cblr-5119	242	63	be	be	AUX
cblr-5119	242	64	liable	liable	ADJ
cblr-5119	242	65	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	242	66	said	say	VERB
cblr-5119	242	67	violations	violation	NOUN
cblr-5119	242	68	—	—	PUNCT
cblr-5119	242	69	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	242	70	nations	nation	NOUN
cblr-5119	242	71	themselves.85	themselves.85	VERB
cblr-5119	242	72	however	however	ADV
cblr-5119	242	73	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	242	74	justice	justice	PROPN
cblr-5119	242	75	kennedy	kennedy	PROPN
cblr-5119	242	76	went	go	VERB
cblr-5119	242	77	on	on	ADP
cblr-5119	242	78	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	242	79	rely	rely	VERB
cblr-5119	242	80	heavily	heavily	ADV
cblr-5119	242	81	on	on	ADP
cblr-5119	242	82	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	242	83	same	same	ADJ
cblr-5119	242	84	arguments	argument	NOUN
cblr-5119	242	85	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	242	86	sources	source	NOUN
cblr-5119	242	87	that	that	PRON
cblr-5119	242	88	judge	judge	NOUN
cblr-5119	242	89	cabranes	cabrane	NOUN
cblr-5119	242	90	used	use	VERB
cblr-5119	242	91	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	242	92	kiobel	kiobel	PROPN
cblr-5119	242	93	i.86	i.86	PROPN
cblr-5119	242	94	justice	justice	PROPN
cblr-5119	242	95	kennedy	kennedy	PROPN
cblr-5119	242	96	even	even	ADV
cblr-5119	242	97	expressly	expressly	ADV
cblr-5119	242	98	stated	state	VERB
cblr-5119	242	99	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	242	100	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	242	101	[	[	X
cblr-5119	242	102	i]t	i]t	X
cblr-5119	242	103	does	do	AUX
cblr-5119	242	104	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	242	105	follow	follow	VERB
cblr-5119	242	106	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	242	107	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	242	108	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	243	1	that	that	PRON
cblr-5119	243	2	current	current	ADJ
cblr-5119	243	3	principles	principle	NOUN
cblr-5119	243	4	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	243	5	international	international	ADJ
cblr-5119	243	6	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	243	7	extend	extend	VERB
cblr-5119	243	8	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	243	9	—	—	PUNCT
cblr-5119	243	10	civil	civil	ADJ
cblr-5119	243	11	or	or	CCONJ
cblr-5119	243	12	criminal	criminal	ADJ
cblr-5119	243	13	—	—	PUNCT
cblr-5119	243	14	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	243	15	human	human	ADJ
cblr-5119	243	16	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-5119	243	17	rights	right	NOUN
cblr-5119	243	18	violations	violation	NOUN
cblr-5119	243	19	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	243	20	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	243	21	or	or	CCONJ
cblr-5119	243	22	other	other	ADJ
cblr-5119	243	23	artificial	artificial	ADJ
cblr-5119	243	24	entities	entity	NOUN
cblr-5119	243	25	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	244	1	”87	”87	PROPN
cblr-5119	244	2	it	it	PRON
cblr-5119	244	3	seems	seem	VERB
cblr-5119	244	4	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	244	5	then	then	ADV
cblr-5119	244	6	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	244	7	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	244	8	justice	justice	PROPN
cblr-5119	244	9	kennedy	kennedy	PROPN
cblr-5119	244	10	believed	believe	VERB
cblr-5119	244	11	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	244	12	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	244	13	order	order	NOUN
cblr-5119	244	14	for	for	SCONJ
cblr-5119	244	15	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	244	16	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	244	17	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	244	18	exist	exist	VERB
cblr-5119	244	19	under	under	ADP
cblr-5119	244	20	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	244	21	ats	at	NOUN
cblr-5119	244	22	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	244	23	that	that	DET
cblr-5119	244	24	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	244	25	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	244	26	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	244	27	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	244	28	just	just	ADV
cblr-5119	244	29	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	244	30	underlying	underlying	ADJ
cblr-5119	244	31	substantive	substantive	ADJ
cblr-5119	244	32	offense	offense	NOUN
cblr-5119	244	33	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	244	34	must	must	AUX
cblr-5119	244	35	represent	represent	VERB
cblr-5119	244	36	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	244	37	universally	universally	ADV
cblr-5119	244	38	accepted	accept	VERB
cblr-5119	244	39	international	international	ADJ
cblr-5119	244	40	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	244	41	norm	norm	NOUN
cblr-5119	244	42	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	245	1	since	since	SCONJ
cblr-5119	245	2	that	that	PRON
cblr-5119	245	3	is	be	AUX
cblr-5119	245	4	currently	currently	ADV
cblr-5119	245	5	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	245	6	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	245	7	case	case	NOUN
cblr-5119	245	8	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	245	9	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	245	10	should	should	AUX
cblr-5119	245	11	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	245	12	be	be	AUX
cblr-5119	245	13	liable	liable	ADJ
cblr-5119	245	14	under	under	ADP
cblr-5119	245	15	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	245	16	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	245	17	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	245	18	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	245	19	justice	justice	PROPN
cblr-5119	245	20	kennedy	kennedy	PROPN
cblr-5119	245	21	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	245	22	view.88	view.88	PROPN
cblr-5119	245	23	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	245	24	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	245	25	forceful	forceful	ADJ
cblr-5119	245	26	dissent	dissent	NOUN
cblr-5119	245	27	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	245	28	justice	justice	PROPN
cblr-5119	245	29	sotomayor	sotomayor	PROPN
cblr-5119	245	30	adopted	adopt	VERB
cblr-5119	245	31	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	245	32	similar	similar	ADJ
cblr-5119	245	33	position	position	NOUN
cblr-5119	245	34	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	245	35	judge	judge	VERB
cblr-5119	245	36	leval	leval	PROPN
cblr-5119	245	37	’s	’s	ADV
cblr-5119	245	38	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	245	39	arguing	argue	VERB
cblr-5119	245	40	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	245	41	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	245	42	plurality	plurality	NOUN
cblr-5119	245	43	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	245	44	fundamentally	fundamentally	ADV
cblr-5119	245	45	misconceive[d	misconceive[d	X
cblr-5119	245	46	]	]	PUNCT
cblr-5119	245	47	how	how	SCONJ
cblr-5119	245	48	international	international	ADJ
cblr-5119	245	49	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	245	50	works	work	VERB
cblr-5119	245	51	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	245	52	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	245	53	thus	thus	ADV
cblr-5119	245	54	incorrectly	incorrectly	ADV
cblr-5119	245	55	analyzed	analyze	VERB
cblr-5119	245	56	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	245	57	first	first	ADJ
cblr-5119	245	58	sosa	sosa	PROPN
cblr-5119	245	59	question	question	NOUN
cblr-5119	245	60	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	245	61	since	since	SCONJ
cblr-5119	245	62	international	international	ADJ
cblr-5119	245	63	consensus	consensus	NOUN
cblr-5119	245	64	was	be	AUX
cblr-5119	245	65	only	only	ADV
cblr-5119	245	66	required	require	VERB
cblr-5119	245	67	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	245	68	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	245	69	relevant	relevant	ADJ
cblr-5119	245	70	substantive	substantive	ADJ
cblr-5119	245	71	conduct	conduct	NOUN
cblr-5119	245	72	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	245	73	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	245	74	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	245	75	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	245	76	mechanisms	mechanism	NOUN
cblr-5119	245	77	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	245	78	enforcement	enforcement	NOUN
cblr-5119	245	79	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	246	1	”89	”89	PROPN
cblr-5119	246	2	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	246	3	responding	respond	VERB
cblr-5119	246	4	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	246	5	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	246	6	plurality	plurality	NOUN
cblr-5119	246	7	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	246	8	deference	deference	NOUN
cblr-5119	246	9	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	246	10	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	246	11	political	political	ADJ
cblr-5119	246	12	branches	branch	NOUN
cblr-5119	246	13	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	246	14	light	light	NOUN
cblr-5119	246	15	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	246	16	foreign	foreign	ADJ
cblr-5119	246	17	policy	policy	NOUN
cblr-5119	246	18	concerns	concern	NOUN
cblr-5119	246	19	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	246	20	justice	justice	PROPN
cblr-5119	246	21	sotomayor	sotomayor	PROPN
cblr-5119	246	22	pointed	point	VERB
cblr-5119	246	23	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	246	24	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	246	25	executive	executive	ADJ
cblr-5119	246	26	branch	branch	NOUN
cblr-5119	246	27	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	246	28	submission	submission	NOUN
cblr-5119	246	29	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	246	30	briefs	brief	NOUN
cblr-5119	246	31	arguing	argue	VERB
cblr-5119	246	32	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	246	33	favor	favor	NOUN
cblr-5119	246	34	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	246	35	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	246	36	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	246	37	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	246	38	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	246	39	present	present	ADJ
cblr-5119	246	40	case	case	NOUN
cblr-5119	246	41	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	246	42	kiobel	kiobel	PROPN
cblr-5119	246	43	ii	ii	PROPN
cblr-5119	246	44	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	246	45	as	as	ADV
cblr-5119	246	46	well	well	ADV
cblr-5119	246	47	as	as	ADP
cblr-5119	246	48	congress	congress	PROPN
cblr-5119	246	49	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	246	50	failure	failure	NOUN
cblr-5119	246	51	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	246	52	85	85	NUM
cblr-5119	246	53	jesner	jesner	NOUN
cblr-5119	246	54	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	246	55	138	138	NUM
cblr-5119	246	56	s.	s.	PROPN
cblr-5119	246	57	ct	ct	PROPN
cblr-5119	246	58	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	247	1	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	247	2	1396	1396	NUM
cblr-5119	247	3	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	247	4	discussing	discuss	VERB
cblr-5119	247	5	kiobel	kiobel	PROPN
cblr-5119	247	6	v.	v.	ADP
cblr-5119	247	7	royal	royal	PROPN
cblr-5119	247	8	dutch	dutch	PROPN
cblr-5119	247	9	petroleum	petroleum	PROPN
cblr-5119	247	10	co.	co.	PROPN
cblr-5119	247	11	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	247	12	621	621	NUM
cblr-5119	247	13	f.3d	f.3d	NUM
cblr-5119	247	14	111	111	NUM
cblr-5119	247	15	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	247	16	120	120	NUM
cblr-5119	247	17	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	247	18	2d	2d	NUM
cblr-5119	247	19	cir	cir	NOUN
cblr-5119	247	20	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	247	21	2010	2010	NUM
cblr-5119	247	22	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	247	23	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	247	24	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	248	1	86	86	NUM
cblr-5119	249	1	i	i	PRON
cblr-5119	249	2	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-5119	249	3	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	249	4	1400–02	1400–02	NUM
cblr-5119	249	5	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	250	1	87	87	NUM
cblr-5119	251	1	i	i	PRON
cblr-5119	251	2	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-5119	251	3	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	251	4	1400	1400	NUM
cblr-5119	251	5	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	252	1	88	88	NUM
cblr-5119	252	2	while	while	SCONJ
cblr-5119	252	3	it	it	PRON
cblr-5119	252	4	is	be	AUX
cblr-5119	252	5	unclear	unclear	ADJ
cblr-5119	253	1	if	if	SCONJ
cblr-5119	253	2	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	253	3	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	253	4	has	have	AUX
cblr-5119	253	5	attained	attain	VERB
cblr-5119	253	6	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	253	7	status	status	NOUN
cblr-5119	253	8	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	253	9	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	253	10	universally	universally	ADV
cblr-5119	253	11	accepted	accept	VERB
cblr-5119	253	12	international	international	ADJ
cblr-5119	253	13	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	253	14	norm	norm	NOUN
cblr-5119	253	15	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	253	16	there	there	PRON
cblr-5119	253	17	is	be	VERB
cblr-5119	253	18	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	253	19	growing	grow	VERB
cblr-5119	253	20	movement	movement	NOUN
cblr-5119	253	21	toward	toward	ADP
cblr-5119	253	22	recognizing	recognize	VERB
cblr-5119	253	23	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	253	24	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	253	25	on	on	ADP
cblr-5119	253	26	an	an	DET
cblr-5119	253	27	international	international	ADJ
cblr-5119	253	28	level	level	NOUN
cblr-5119	253	29	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	253	30	at	at	ADV
cblr-5119	253	31	least	least	ADJ
cblr-5119	253	32	as	as	SCONJ
cblr-5119	253	33	it	it	PRON
cblr-5119	253	34	regards	regard	VERB
cblr-5119	253	35	human	human	ADJ
cblr-5119	253	36	rights	right	NOUN
cblr-5119	253	37	violations	violation	NOUN
cblr-5119	253	38	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	254	1	see	see	VERB
cblr-5119	254	2	discussion	discussion	NOUN
cblr-5119	254	3	infra	infra	NOUN
cblr-5119	254	4	section	section	NOUN
cblr-5119	254	5	iv.a	iv.a	VERB
cblr-5119	254	6	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	255	1	89	89	NUM
cblr-5119	255	2	jesner	jesner	NOUN
cblr-5119	255	3	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	255	4	138	138	NUM
cblr-5119	255	5	s.	s.	PROPN
cblr-5119	255	6	ct	ct	PROPN
cblr-5119	255	7	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	256	1	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	256	2	1419–20	1419–20	NUM
cblr-5119	256	3	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	256	4	sotomayor	sotomayor	PROPN
cblr-5119	256	5	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	256	6	j.	j.	PROPN
cblr-5119	256	7	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	256	8	dissenting	dissent	VERB
cblr-5119	256	9	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	256	10	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	257	1	6_2019.3_estes	6_2019.3_estes	NUM
cblr-5119	257	2	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	257	3	do	do	AUX
cblr-5119	257	4	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	257	5	delte	delte	VERB
cblr-5119	257	6	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	257	7	12/26/2019	12/26/2019	NUM
cblr-5119	257	8	12:00	12:00	NUM
cblr-5119	257	9	am	be	AUX
cblr-5119	257	10	1050	1050	NUM
cblr-5119	257	11	columbia	columbia	PROPN
cblr-5119	257	12	business	business	NOUN
cblr-5119	257	13	law	law	PROPN
cblr-5119	257	14	review	review	NOUN
cblr-5119	257	15	[	[	X
cblr-5119	257	16	vol	vol	NOUN
cblr-5119	257	17	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	257	18	2019	2019	NUM
cblr-5119	257	19	amend	amend	VERB
cblr-5119	257	20	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	257	21	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	257	22	despite	despite	SCONJ
cblr-5119	257	23	scores	score	NOUN
cblr-5119	257	24	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	257	25	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	257	26	being	be	AUX
cblr-5119	257	27	sued	sue	VERB
cblr-5119	257	28	under	under	ADP
cblr-5119	257	29	it	it	PRON
cblr-5119	257	30	since	since	SCONJ
cblr-5119	257	31	filartiga.90	filartiga.90	PROPN
cblr-5119	257	32	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	257	33	closing	closing	NOUN
cblr-5119	257	34	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	257	35	justice	justice	PROPN
cblr-5119	257	36	sotomayor	sotomayor	PROPN
cblr-5119	257	37	referenced	reference	VERB
cblr-5119	257	38	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	257	39	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	257	40	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	257	41	original	original	ADJ
cblr-5119	257	42	purpose	purpose	NOUN
cblr-5119	257	43	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	257	44	stating	state	VERB
cblr-5119	257	45	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	257	46	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	257	47	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	257	48	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	257	49	decision	decision	NOUN
cblr-5119	257	50	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	257	51	undermines	undermine	VERB
cblr-5119	257	52	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	257	53	system	system	NOUN
cblr-5119	257	54	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	257	55	accountability	accountability	NOUN
cblr-5119	257	56	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	257	57	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	257	58	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-5119	257	59	ofnations	ofnation	NOUN
cblr-5119	257	60	violations	violation	NOUN
cblr-5119	257	61	that	that	PRON
cblr-5119	257	62	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	257	63	first	first	ADJ
cblr-5119	257	64	congress	congress	PROPN
cblr-5119	257	65	endeavored	endeavor	VERB
cblr-5119	257	66	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	257	67	impose	impose	VERB
cblr-5119	257	68	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	258	1	”91	”91	NOUN
cblr-5119	258	2	after	after	ADP
cblr-5119	258	3	jesner	jesner	NOUN
cblr-5119	258	4	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	258	5	foreign	foreign	ADJ
cblr-5119	258	6	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	258	7	can	can	AUX
cblr-5119	258	8	no	no	ADV
cblr-5119	258	9	longer	long	ADV
cblr-5119	258	10	be	be	AUX
cblr-5119	258	11	sued	sue	VERB
cblr-5119	258	12	under	under	ADP
cblr-5119	258	13	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	258	14	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	258	15	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	258	16	removing	remove	VERB
cblr-5119	258	17	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	258	18	foreign	foreign	ADJ
cblr-5119	258	19	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-5119	258	20	cubed	cube	VERB
cblr-5119	258	21	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	258	22	cases92	cases92	NOUN
cblr-5119	258	23	from	from	ADP
cblr-5119	258	24	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	258	25	statute	statute	NOUN
cblr-5119	258	26	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	258	27	ambit	ambit	NOUN
cblr-5119	258	28	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	259	1	this	this	PRON
cblr-5119	259	2	led	lead	VERB
cblr-5119	259	3	some	some	DET
cblr-5119	259	4	observers	observer	NOUN
cblr-5119	259	5	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	259	6	wonder	wonder	VERB
cblr-5119	259	7	whether	whether	SCONJ
cblr-5119	259	8	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	259	9	ats	at	NOUN
cblr-5119	259	10	would	would	AUX
cblr-5119	259	11	still	still	ADV
cblr-5119	259	12	be	be	AUX
cblr-5119	259	13	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	259	14	viable	viable	ADJ
cblr-5119	259	15	tool	tool	NOUN
cblr-5119	259	16	going	go	VERB
cblr-5119	259	17	forward	forward	ADV
cblr-5119	259	18	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	259	19	victims	victim	NOUN
cblr-5119	259	20	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	259	21	human	human	ADJ
cblr-5119	259	22	rights	right	NOUN
cblr-5119	259	23	abuses	abuse	NOUN
cblr-5119	259	24	suffered	suffer	VERB
cblr-5119	259	25	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	259	26	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	259	27	hands	hand	NOUN
cblr-5119	259	28	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	259	29	corporations.93	corporations.93	NOUN
cblr-5119	259	30	but	but	CCONJ
cblr-5119	259	31	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	259	32	supreme	supreme	PROPN
cblr-5119	259	33	court	court	PROPN
cblr-5119	259	34	still	still	ADV
cblr-5119	259	35	has	have	AUX
cblr-5119	259	36	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	259	37	affirmatively	affirmatively	ADV
cblr-5119	259	38	stated	state	VERB
cblr-5119	259	39	whether	whether	SCONJ
cblr-5119	259	40	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	259	41	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	259	42	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	259	43	are	be	AUX
cblr-5119	259	44	or	or	CCONJ
cblr-5119	259	45	are	be	AUX
cblr-5119	259	46	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	259	47	liable	liable	ADJ
cblr-5119	259	48	under	under	ADP
cblr-5119	259	49	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	259	50	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	259	51	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	259	52	nor	nor	CCONJ
cblr-5119	259	53	has	have	AUX
cblr-5119	259	54	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	259	55	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	259	56	addressed	address	VERB
cblr-5119	259	57	how	how	SCONJ
cblr-5119	259	58	lower	low	ADJ
cblr-5119	259	59	courts	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	259	60	should	should	AUX
cblr-5119	259	61	conduct	conduct	VERB
cblr-5119	259	62	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	259	63	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	259	64	touch	touch	NOUN
cblr-5119	259	65	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	259	66	concern	concern	NOUN
cblr-5119	259	67	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	259	68	test	test	NOUN
cblr-5119	259	69	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	259	70	rebutting	rebut	VERB
cblr-5119	259	71	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	259	72	presumption	presumption	NOUN
cblr-5119	259	73	against	against	ADP
cblr-5119	259	74	extraterritoriality	extraterritoriality	NOUN
cblr-5119	259	75	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	259	76	whether	whether	SCONJ
cblr-5119	259	77	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	259	78	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	259	79	defendants	defendant	NOUN
cblr-5119	259	80	or	or	CCONJ
cblr-5119	259	81	non	non	ADJ
cblr-5119	259	82	-	-	ADJ
cblr-5119	259	83	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	259	84	defendants	defendant	NOUN
cblr-5119	259	85	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	260	1	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	260	2	circuits	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	260	3	have	have	AUX
cblr-5119	260	4	reacted	react	VERB
cblr-5119	260	5	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	260	6	these	these	DET
cblr-5119	260	7	issues	issue	NOUN
cblr-5119	260	8	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	260	9	various	various	ADJ
cblr-5119	260	10	ways	way	NOUN
cblr-5119	260	11	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	261	1	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	261	2	most	most	ADV
cblr-5119	261	3	notable	notable	ADJ
cblr-5119	261	4	examples	example	NOUN
cblr-5119	261	5	are	be	AUX
cblr-5119	261	6	discussed	discuss	VERB
cblr-5119	261	7	below	below	ADV
cblr-5119	261	8	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	262	1	iii	iii	X
cblr-5119	262	2	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	262	3	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	262	4	approaches	approach	NOUN
cblr-5119	262	5	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	262	6	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	262	7	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	262	8	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	262	9	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	262	10	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	262	11	presumption	presumption	NOUN
cblr-5119	262	12	against	against	ADP
cblr-5119	262	13	extraterritoriality	extraterritoriality	NOUN
cblr-5119	262	14	five	five	NUM
cblr-5119	262	15	circuits	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	262	16	have	have	AUX
cblr-5119	262	17	developed	develop	VERB
cblr-5119	262	18	noteworthy	noteworthy	ADJ
cblr-5119	262	19	jurisprudence	jurisprudence	NOUN
cblr-5119	262	20	surrounding	surround	VERB
cblr-5119	262	21	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	262	22	ats	at	NOUN
cblr-5119	262	23	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	262	24	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	262	25	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	262	26	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	262	27	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	262	28	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	262	29	presumption	presumption	NOUN
cblr-5119	262	30	against	against	ADP
cblr-5119	262	31	extraterritoriality	extraterritoriality	NOUN
cblr-5119	262	32	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	263	1	their	their	PRON
cblr-5119	263	2	approaches	approach	NOUN
cblr-5119	263	3	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	263	4	these	these	DET
cblr-5119	263	5	jurisdictional	jurisdictional	ADJ
cblr-5119	263	6	issues	issue	NOUN
cblr-5119	263	7	range	range	VERB
cblr-5119	263	8	from	from	ADP
cblr-5119	263	9	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	263	10	most	most	ADV
cblr-5119	263	11	restrictive	restrictive	ADJ
cblr-5119	263	12	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	263	13	second	second	ADJ
cblr-5119	263	14	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	263	15	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	263	16	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	263	17	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	263	18	least	least	ADV
cblr-5119	263	19	restrictive	restrictive	ADJ
cblr-5119	263	20	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	263	21	fourth	fourth	ADJ
cblr-5119	263	22	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	263	23	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	263	24	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	264	1	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	264	2	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	264	3	second	second	ADJ
cblr-5119	264	4	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	264	5	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	264	6	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	264	7	are	be	AUX
cblr-5119	264	8	categorially	categorially	ADV
cblr-5119	264	9	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	264	10	liable	liable	ADJ
cblr-5119	264	11	under	under	ADP
cblr-5119	264	12	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	264	13	90	90	NUM
cblr-5119	264	14	i	i	PRON
cblr-5119	264	15	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-5119	264	16	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	264	17	1431–32	1431–32	NUM
cblr-5119	264	18	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	265	1	91	91	NUM
cblr-5119	266	1	i	i	PRON
cblr-5119	266	2	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-5119	266	3	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	266	4	1437	1437	NUM
cblr-5119	266	5	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	267	1	92	92	NUM
cblr-5119	267	2	recall	recall	VERB
cblr-5119	267	3	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	267	4	definition	definition	NOUN
cblr-5119	267	5	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	267	6	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	267	7	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	267	8	foreign	foreign	ADJ
cblr-5119	267	9	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-5119	267	10	cubed	cube	VERB
cblr-5119	267	11	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	267	12	case	case	NOUN
cblr-5119	267	13	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	267	14	n.33	n.33	PRON
cblr-5119	267	15	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	268	1	while	while	SCONJ
cblr-5119	268	2	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	268	3	term	term	NOUN
cblr-5119	268	4	was	be	AUX
cblr-5119	268	5	originally	originally	ADV
cblr-5119	268	6	defined	define	VERB
cblr-5119	268	7	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	268	8	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	268	9	securities	security	NOUN
cblr-5119	268	10	context	context	NOUN
cblr-5119	268	11	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	268	12	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	268	13	cases	case	NOUN
cblr-5119	268	14	provide	provide	VERB
cblr-5119	268	15	an	an	DET
cblr-5119	268	16	apt	apt	ADJ
cblr-5119	268	17	analogy	analogy	NOUN
cblr-5119	268	18	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	269	1	see	see	VERB
cblr-5119	269	2	morrison	morrison	PROPN
cblr-5119	269	3	v.	v.	PROPN
cblr-5119	269	4	nat’l	nat’l	PROPN
cblr-5119	269	5	australia	australia	PROPN
cblr-5119	269	6	bank	bank	PROPN
cblr-5119	269	7	ltd	ltd	PROPN
cblr-5119	269	8	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	269	9	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	269	10	561	561	NUM
cblr-5119	269	11	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	269	12	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	269	13	247	247	NUM
cblr-5119	269	14	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	269	15	283	283	NUM
cblr-5119	269	16	n.11	n.11	NOUN
cblr-5119	269	17	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	269	18	2010	2010	NUM
cblr-5119	269	19	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	269	20	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	269	21	breyer	breyer	NOUN
cblr-5119	269	22	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	269	23	j.	j.	PROPN
cblr-5119	269	24	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	269	25	concurring	concur	VERB
cblr-5119	269	26	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	269	27	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	270	1	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	270	2	course	course	NOUN
cblr-5119	270	3	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	270	4	since	since	SCONJ
cblr-5119	270	5	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	270	6	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
cblr-5119	270	7	must	must	AUX
cblr-5119	270	8	be	be	AUX
cblr-5119	270	9	aliens	alien	NOUN
cblr-5119	270	10	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	270	11	there	there	PRON
cblr-5119	270	12	will	will	AUX
cblr-5119	270	13	always	always	ADV
cblr-5119	270	14	be	be	AUX
cblr-5119	270	15	at	at	ADV
cblr-5119	270	16	least	least	ADJ
cblr-5119	270	17	one	one	NUM
cblr-5119	270	18	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	270	19	f	f	NOUN
cblr-5119	270	20	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	270	21	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	270	22	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	270	23	cases	case	NOUN
cblr-5119	270	24	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	271	1	93	93	NUM
cblr-5119	271	2	see	see	VERB
cblr-5119	271	3	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	271	4	e.g.	e.g.	ADV
cblr-5119	271	5	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	271	6	samuel	samuel	PROPN
cblr-5119	271	7	moyn	moyn	PROPN
cblr-5119	271	8	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	271	9	time	time	NOUN
cblr-5119	271	10	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	271	11	pivot	pivot	NOUN
cblr-5119	271	12	?	?	PUNCT
cblr-5119	272	1	thoughts	thought	NOUN
cblr-5119	272	2	on	on	ADP
cblr-5119	272	3	jesner	jesner	PROPN
cblr-5119	272	4	v.	v.	PROPN
cblr-5119	272	5	arab	arab	PROPN
cblr-5119	272	6	bank	bank	PROPN
cblr-5119	272	7	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	272	8	lawfare	lawfare	PROPN
cblr-5119	272	9	inst	inst	PROPN
cblr-5119	272	10	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	273	1	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	273	2	apr	apr	PROPN
cblr-5119	273	3	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	273	4	25	25	NUM
cblr-5119	273	5	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	273	6	2018	2018	NUM
cblr-5119	273	7	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	273	8	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	273	9	https://www.lawfareblog.com/timepivot-thoughts-jesner-v-arab-bank	https://www.lawfareblog.com/timepivot-thoughts-jesner-v-arab-bank	VERB
cblr-5119	273	10	[	[	X
cblr-5119	273	11	https://perma.cc/c5jl-9978	https://perma.cc/c5jl-9978	X
cblr-5119	273	12	]	]	PUNCT
cblr-5119	273	13	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	274	1	6_2019.3_estes	6_2019.3_estes	NUM
cblr-5119	274	2	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	274	3	do	do	AUX
cblr-5119	274	4	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	274	5	delete	delete	VERB
cblr-5119	274	6	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	274	7	12/26/2019	12/26/2019	NUM
cblr-5119	274	8	12:00	12:00	NUM
cblr-5119	274	9	am	be	AUX
cblr-5119	274	10	no	no	NOUN
cblr-5119	274	11	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	275	1	3:1031	3:1031	NUM
cblr-5119	275	2	]	]	X
cblr-5119	275	3	may	may	AUX
cblr-5119	275	4	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	275	5	fourth	fourth	ADJ
cblr-5119	275	6	be	be	AUX
cblr-5119	275	7	with	with	ADP
cblr-5119	275	8	you	you	PRON
cblr-5119	275	9	1051	1051	NUM
cblr-5119	275	10	ats	at	NOUN
cblr-5119	275	11	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	275	12	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	275	13	for	for	SCONJ
cblr-5119	275	14	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	275	15	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
cblr-5119	275	16	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	275	17	rebut	rebut	VERB
cblr-5119	275	18	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	275	19	presumption	presumption	NOUN
cblr-5119	275	20	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	275	21	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	275	22	suit	suit	NOUN
cblr-5119	275	23	against	against	ADP
cblr-5119	275	24	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	275	25	natural	natural	ADJ
cblr-5119	275	26	person	person	NOUN
cblr-5119	275	27	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	275	28	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	275	29	alleged	alleged	ADJ
cblr-5119	275	30	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	275	31	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	275	32	nations	nation	NOUN
cblr-5119	275	33	violation	violation	NOUN
cblr-5119	275	34	must	must	AUX
cblr-5119	275	35	have	have	AUX
cblr-5119	275	36	occurred	occur	VERB
cblr-5119	275	37	on	on	ADP
cblr-5119	275	38	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	275	39	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	275	40	soil.94	soil.94	PROPN
cblr-5119	275	41	conversely	conversely	ADV
cblr-5119	275	42	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	275	43	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	275	44	can	can	AUX
cblr-5119	275	45	be	be	AUX
cblr-5119	275	46	liable	liable	ADJ
cblr-5119	275	47	under	under	ADP
cblr-5119	275	48	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	275	49	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	275	50	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	275	51	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	275	52	other	other	ADJ
cblr-5119	275	53	circuits	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	275	54	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	276	1	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	276	2	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	276	3	fourth	fourth	ADJ
cblr-5119	276	4	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	276	5	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	276	6	there	there	PRON
cblr-5119	276	7	has	have	AUX
cblr-5119	276	8	been	be	AUX
cblr-5119	276	9	little	little	ADJ
cblr-5119	276	10	analysis	analysis	NOUN
cblr-5119	276	11	regarding	regard	VERB
cblr-5119	276	12	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	276	13	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	276	14	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	276	15	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	276	16	courts	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	276	17	have	have	AUX
cblr-5119	276	18	employed	employ	VERB
cblr-5119	276	19	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	276	20	relatively	relatively	ADV
cblr-5119	276	21	flexible	flexible	ADJ
cblr-5119	276	22	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	276	23	factbased	factbased	ADJ
cblr-5119	276	24	analysis	analysis	NOUN
cblr-5119	276	25	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	276	26	rebutting	rebut	VERB
cblr-5119	276	27	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	276	28	presumption.95	presumption.95	NOUN
cblr-5119	276	29	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	276	30	ninth	ninth	ADJ
cblr-5119	276	31	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	276	32	has	have	AUX
cblr-5119	276	33	adopted	adopt	VERB
cblr-5119	276	34	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	276	35	unique	unique	ADJ
cblr-5119	276	36	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	276	37	offense	offense	NOUN
cblr-5119	276	38	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-5119	276	39	by	by	ADP
cblr-5119	276	40	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-5119	276	41	offense	offense	NOUN
cblr-5119	276	42	methodology	methodology	NOUN
cblr-5119	276	43	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	276	44	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	276	45	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	276	46	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	276	47	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	276	48	semi	semi	ADJ
cblr-5119	276	49	-	-	ADJ
cblr-5119	276	50	restrictive	restrictive	ADJ
cblr-5119	276	51	approach	approach	NOUN
cblr-5119	276	52	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	276	53	rebutting	rebut	VERB
cblr-5119	276	54	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	276	55	presumption	presumption	NOUN
cblr-5119	276	56	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	276	57	whereby	whereby	SCONJ
cblr-5119	276	58	at	at	ADV
cblr-5119	276	59	least	least	ADJ
cblr-5119	276	60	some	some	PRON
cblr-5119	276	61	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	276	62	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	276	63	conduct	conduct	NOUN
cblr-5119	276	64	relevant	relevant	ADJ
cblr-5119	276	65	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	276	66	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	276	67	claim	claim	NOUN
cblr-5119	276	68	must	must	AUX
cblr-5119	276	69	have	have	AUX
cblr-5119	276	70	occurred	occur	VERB
cblr-5119	276	71	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	276	72	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	276	73	united	united	PROPN
cblr-5119	276	74	states.96	states.96	PROPN
cblr-5119	276	75	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	276	76	eleventh	eleventh	ADJ
cblr-5119	276	77	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	276	78	has	have	AUX
cblr-5119	276	79	also	also	ADV
cblr-5119	276	80	taken	take	VERB
cblr-5119	276	81	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	276	82	semirestrictive	semirestrictive	ADJ
cblr-5119	276	83	approach	approach	NOUN
cblr-5119	276	84	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	276	85	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	276	86	presumption	presumption	NOUN
cblr-5119	276	87	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	276	88	which	which	PRON
cblr-5119	276	89	involves	involve	VERB
cblr-5119	276	90	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	276	91	two	two	NUM
cblr-5119	276	92	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-5119	276	93	part	part	NOUN
cblr-5119	276	94	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	276	95	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	276	96	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	276	97	focus	focus	NOUN
cblr-5119	276	98	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	276	99	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	276	100	conduct	conduct	VERB
cblr-5119	276	101	analysis	analysis	NOUN
cblr-5119	276	102	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	276	103	albeit	albeit	SCONJ
cblr-5119	276	104	with	with	ADP
cblr-5119	276	105	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	276	106	greater	great	ADJ
cblr-5119	276	107	emphasis	emphasis	NOUN
cblr-5119	276	108	on	on	ADP
cblr-5119	276	109	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	276	110	latter.97	latter.97	NOUN
cblr-5119	276	111	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	276	112	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	276	113	d.c	d.c	PROPN
cblr-5119	276	114	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	276	115	circuit	circuit	PROPN
cblr-5119	276	116	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	276	117	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	276	118	have	have	AUX
cblr-5119	276	119	been	be	AUX
cblr-5119	276	120	held	hold	VERB
cblr-5119	276	121	categorically	categorically	ADV
cblr-5119	276	122	liable	liable	ADJ
cblr-5119	276	123	under	under	ADP
cblr-5119	276	124	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	276	125	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	276	126	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	277	1	while	while	SCONJ
cblr-5119	277	2	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	277	3	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	277	4	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	277	5	jurisprudence	jurisprudence	NOUN
cblr-5119	277	6	surrounding	surround	VERB
cblr-5119	277	7	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	277	8	presumption	presumption	NOUN
cblr-5119	277	9	remains	remain	VERB
cblr-5119	277	10	somewhat	somewhat	ADV
cblr-5119	277	11	unclear	unclear	ADJ
cblr-5119	277	12	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	277	13	it	it	PRON
cblr-5119	277	14	seems	seem	VERB
cblr-5119	277	15	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	277	16	be	be	AUX
cblr-5119	277	17	less	less	ADV
cblr-5119	277	18	restrictive	restrictive	ADJ
cblr-5119	277	19	than	than	ADP
cblr-5119	277	20	most	most	ADJ
cblr-5119	277	21	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	277	22	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	277	23	other	other	ADJ
cblr-5119	277	24	circuits	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	277	25	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	278	1	98	98	NUM
cblr-5119	278	2	however	however	ADV
cblr-5119	278	3	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	278	4	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	278	5	recent	recent	ADJ
cblr-5119	278	6	district	district	NOUN
cblr-5119	278	7	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	278	8	decision	decision	NOUN
cblr-5119	278	9	has	have	AUX
cblr-5119	278	10	clouded	cloud	VERB
cblr-5119	278	11	these	these	DET
cblr-5119	278	12	issues.99	issues.99	NOUN
cblr-5119	278	13	thus	thus	ADV
cblr-5119	278	14	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	278	15	it	it	PRON
cblr-5119	278	16	appears	appear	VERB
cblr-5119	278	17	so	so	ADV
cblr-5119	278	18	far	far	ADV
cblr-5119	278	19	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	278	20	jesner	jesner	PROPN
cblr-5119	278	21	has	have	AUX
cblr-5119	278	22	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	278	23	significantly	significantly	ADV
cblr-5119	278	24	affected	affect	VERB
cblr-5119	278	25	any	any	DET
cblr-5119	278	26	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	278	27	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	278	28	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	278	29	regime	regime	NOUN
cblr-5119	278	30	as	as	SCONJ
cblr-5119	278	31	applied	apply	VERB
cblr-5119	278	32	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	278	33	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	278	34	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	278	35	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	278	36	defendants	defendant	NOUN
cblr-5119	278	37	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	279	1	each	each	DET
cblr-5119	279	2	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	279	3	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	279	4	approach	approach	NOUN
cblr-5119	279	5	is	be	AUX
cblr-5119	279	6	examined	examine	VERB
cblr-5119	279	7	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	279	8	greater	great	ADJ
cblr-5119	279	9	detail	detail	NOUN
cblr-5119	279	10	below	below	ADV
cblr-5119	279	11	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	280	1	a.	a.	NOUN
cblr-5119	280	2	second	second	PROPN
cblr-5119	280	3	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	280	4	:	:	PUNCT
cblr-5119	280	5	categorically	categorically	ADV
cblr-5119	280	6	against	against	ADP
cblr-5119	280	7	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	280	8	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	280	9	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	280	10	second	second	ADJ
cblr-5119	280	11	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	280	12	is	be	AUX
cblr-5119	280	13	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	280	14	lone	lone	ADJ
cblr-5119	280	15	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	280	16	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	280	17	hold	hold	VERB
cblr-5119	280	18	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	280	19	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	280	20	are	be	AUX
cblr-5119	280	21	categorically	categorically	ADV
cblr-5119	280	22	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	280	23	liable	liable	ADJ
cblr-5119	280	24	under	under	ADP
cblr-5119	280	25	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	280	26	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	280	27	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	281	1	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	281	2	second	second	ADJ
cblr-5119	281	3	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	281	4	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	281	5	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	281	6	appeals	appeals	PROPN
cblr-5119	281	7	adopted	adopt	VERB
cblr-5119	281	8	this	this	DET
cblr-5119	281	9	position	position	NOUN
cblr-5119	281	10	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	281	11	kiobel	kiobel	PROPN
cblr-5119	281	12	i	i	PRON
cblr-5119	281	13	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	281	14	2010.100	2010.100	PROPN
cblr-5119	281	15	judge	judge	NOUN
cblr-5119	281	16	cabranes	cabrane	NOUN
cblr-5119	281	17	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	281	18	writing	write	VERB
cblr-5119	281	19	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	281	20	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	281	21	majority	majority	NOUN
cblr-5119	281	22	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	281	23	94	94	NUM
cblr-5119	281	24	see	see	VERB
cblr-5119	281	25	discussion	discussion	NOUN
cblr-5119	281	26	infra	infra	NOUN
cblr-5119	281	27	section	section	NOUN
cblr-5119	281	28	iii.a	iii.a	PROPN
cblr-5119	281	29	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	282	1	95	95	NUM
cblr-5119	282	2	see	see	VERB
cblr-5119	282	3	discussion	discussion	NOUN
cblr-5119	282	4	infra	infra	NOUN
cblr-5119	282	5	section	section	NOUN
cblr-5119	282	6	iii.b	iii.b	PROPN
cblr-5119	282	7	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	283	1	96	96	NUM
cblr-5119	283	2	see	see	VERB
cblr-5119	283	3	discussion	discussion	NOUN
cblr-5119	283	4	infra	infra	NOUN
cblr-5119	283	5	section	section	NOUN
cblr-5119	283	6	iii.c	iii.c	PROPN
cblr-5119	283	7	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	284	1	97	97	NUM
cblr-5119	284	2	see	see	VERB
cblr-5119	284	3	discussion	discussion	NOUN
cblr-5119	284	4	infra	infra	NOUN
cblr-5119	284	5	section	section	NOUN
cblr-5119	284	6	iii.d	iii.d	PROPN
cblr-5119	284	7	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	285	1	98	98	NUM
cblr-5119	285	2	see	see	VERB
cblr-5119	285	3	discussion	discussion	NOUN
cblr-5119	285	4	infra	infra	NOUN
cblr-5119	285	5	section	section	NOUN
cblr-5119	285	6	iii.e	iii.e	NOUN
cblr-5119	285	7	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	286	1	99	99	NUM
cblr-5119	286	2	doe	doe	NOUN
cblr-5119	286	3	v.	v.	ADP
cblr-5119	286	4	exxon	exxon	PROPN
cblr-5119	286	5	mobil	mobil	PROPN
cblr-5119	286	6	corp	corp	PROPN
cblr-5119	286	7	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	286	8	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	286	9	391	391	NUM
cblr-5119	286	10	f.	f.	PROPN
cblr-5119	286	11	supp	supp	PROPN
cblr-5119	286	12	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	287	1	3d	3d	PROPN
cblr-5119	287	2	76	76	NUM
cblr-5119	287	3	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	287	4	84–85	84–85	NUM
cblr-5119	287	5	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	287	6	d.d.c	d.d.c	PROPN
cblr-5119	287	7	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	287	8	2019	2019	NUM
cblr-5119	287	9	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	287	10	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	288	1	100	100	NUM
cblr-5119	288	2	kiobel	kiobel	NOUN
cblr-5119	288	3	v.	v.	ADP
cblr-5119	288	4	royal	royal	PROPN
cblr-5119	288	5	dutch	dutch	PROPN
cblr-5119	288	6	petroleum	petroleum	PROPN
cblr-5119	288	7	co.	co.	PROPN
cblr-5119	288	8	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	288	9	621	621	NUM
cblr-5119	288	10	f.3d	f.3d	NUM
cblr-5119	288	11	111	111	NUM
cblr-5119	288	12	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	288	13	148–49	148–49	NUM
cblr-5119	288	14	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	288	15	2d	2d	NUM
cblr-5119	288	16	cir	cir	NOUN
cblr-5119	288	17	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	288	18	2010	2010	NUM
cblr-5119	288	19	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	288	20	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	288	21	aff’d	aff’d	VERB
cblr-5119	288	22	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	288	23	569	569	NUM
cblr-5119	288	24	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	288	25	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	288	26	108	108	NUM
cblr-5119	288	27	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	288	28	2013	2013	NUM
cblr-5119	288	29	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	288	30	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	289	1	6_2019.3_estes	6_2019.3_estes	NUM
cblr-5119	289	2	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	289	3	do	do	AUX
cblr-5119	289	4	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	289	5	delte	delte	VERB
cblr-5119	289	6	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	289	7	12/26/2019	12/26/2019	NUM
cblr-5119	289	8	12:00	12:00	NUM
cblr-5119	289	9	am	am	NOUN
cblr-5119	289	10	1052	1052	NUM
cblr-5119	289	11	columbia	columbia	PROPN
cblr-5119	289	12	business	business	NOUN
cblr-5119	289	13	law	law	PROPN
cblr-5119	289	14	review	review	NOUN
cblr-5119	289	15	[	[	X
cblr-5119	289	16	vol	vol	NOUN
cblr-5119	289	17	.	.	NOUN
cblr-5119	289	18	2019	2019	NUM
cblr-5119	289	19	largely	largely	ADV
cblr-5119	289	20	based	base	VERB
cblr-5119	289	21	his	his	PRON
cblr-5119	289	22	decision	decision	NOUN
cblr-5119	289	23	on	on	ADP
cblr-5119	289	24	his	his	PRON
cblr-5119	289	25	interpretation	interpretation	NOUN
cblr-5119	289	26	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	289	27	footnote	footnote	NOUN
cblr-5119	289	28	20	20	NUM
cblr-5119	289	29	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	289	30	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	289	31	sosa	sosa	PROPN
cblr-5119	289	32	decision.101	decision.101	PROPN
cblr-5119	289	33	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	289	34	his	his	PRON
cblr-5119	289	35	view	view	NOUN
cblr-5119	289	36	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	289	37	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	289	38	order	order	NOUN
cblr-5119	289	39	for	for	SCONJ
cblr-5119	289	40	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	289	41	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	289	42	be	be	AUX
cblr-5119	289	43	liable	liable	ADJ
cblr-5119	289	44	under	under	ADP
cblr-5119	289	45	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	289	46	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	289	47	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	289	48	international	international	ADJ
cblr-5119	289	49	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	289	50	must	must	AUX
cblr-5119	289	51	recognize	recognize	VERB
cblr-5119	289	52	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	289	53	liability.102	liability.102	NOUN
cblr-5119	289	54	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	289	55	other	other	ADJ
cblr-5119	289	56	words	word	NOUN
cblr-5119	289	57	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	289	58	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	289	59	availability	availability	NOUN
cblr-5119	289	60	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	289	61	general	general	ADJ
cblr-5119	289	62	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	289	63	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	289	64	has	have	VERB
cblr-5119	289	65	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	289	66	represent	represent	VERB
cblr-5119	289	67	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	289	68	specific	specific	ADJ
cblr-5119	289	69	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	289	70	universal	universal	ADJ
cblr-5119	289	71	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	289	72	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	289	73	obligatory	obligatory	ADJ
cblr-5119	289	74	norm.103	norm.103	NOUN
cblr-5119	289	75	if	if	SCONJ
cblr-5119	289	76	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	289	77	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	289	78	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	289	79	violations	violation	NOUN
cblr-5119	289	80	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	289	81	international	international	ADJ
cblr-5119	289	82	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	289	83	has	have	AUX
cblr-5119	289	84	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	289	85	attained	attain	VERB
cblr-5119	289	86	near	near	ADP
cblr-5119	289	87	complete	complete	ADJ
cblr-5119	289	88	acceptance	acceptance	NOUN
cblr-5119	289	89	among	among	ADP
cblr-5119	289	90	civilized	civilized	ADJ
cblr-5119	289	91	nations	nation	NOUN
cblr-5119	289	92	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	289	93	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	289	94	could	could	AUX
cblr-5119	289	95	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	289	96	face	face	VERB
cblr-5119	289	97	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	289	98	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	289	99	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	290	1	judge	judge	PROPN
cblr-5119	290	2	cabranes	cabrane	NOUN
cblr-5119	290	3	indeed	indeed	ADV
cblr-5119	290	4	concluded	conclude	VERB
cblr-5119	290	5	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	290	6	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	290	7	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	290	8	had	have	AUX
cblr-5119	290	9	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	290	10	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	290	11	attained	attain	VERB
cblr-5119	290	12	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	290	13	discernible	discernible	ADJ
cblr-5119	290	14	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	290	15	much	much	ADV
cblr-5119	290	16	less	less	ADV
cblr-5119	290	17	universal	universal	ADJ
cblr-5119	290	18	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	290	19	acceptance	acceptance	NOUN
cblr-5119	290	20	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	290	21	internationally	internationally	ADV
cblr-5119	290	22	after	after	ADP
cblr-5119	290	23	surveying	survey	VERB
cblr-5119	290	24	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	290	25	number	number	NOUN
cblr-5119	290	26	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	290	27	international	international	ADJ
cblr-5119	290	28	tribunals	tribunal	NOUN
cblr-5119	290	29	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	290	30	treaties	treaty	NOUN
cblr-5119	290	31	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	290	32	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	290	33	scholarly	scholarly	ADJ
cblr-5119	290	34	works	work	NOUN
cblr-5119	290	35	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	290	36	such	such	ADJ
cblr-5119	290	37	as	as	ADP
cblr-5119	290	38	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	290	39	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NOUN
cblr-5119	290	40	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	290	41	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	290	42	nuremberg	nuremberg	PROPN
cblr-5119	290	43	tribunals	tribunal	NOUN
cblr-5119	290	44	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	290	45	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	290	46	international	international	ADJ
cblr-5119	290	47	criminal	criminal	ADJ
cblr-5119	290	48	court.104	court.104	PROPN
cblr-5119	290	49	judge	judge	PROPN
cblr-5119	290	50	cabranes	cabrane	NOUN
cblr-5119	290	51	also	also	ADV
cblr-5119	290	52	carefully	carefully	ADV
cblr-5119	290	53	pointed	point	VERB
cblr-5119	290	54	out	out	ADP
cblr-5119	290	55	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	290	56	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	290	57	fact	fact	NOUN
cblr-5119	290	58	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	290	59	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	290	60	norm	norm	NOUN
cblr-5119	290	61	existing	exist	VERB
cblr-5119	290	62	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	290	63	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	290	64	domestic	domestic	ADJ
cblr-5119	290	65	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	290	66	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	290	67	nearly	nearly	ADV
cblr-5119	290	68	all	all	PRON
cblr-5119	290	69	nations	nation	NOUN
cblr-5119	290	70	was	be	AUX
cblr-5119	290	71	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	290	72	dispositive	dispositive	ADJ
cblr-5119	290	73	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	291	1	that	that	PRON
cblr-5119	291	2	is	be	AUX
cblr-5119	291	3	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	291	4	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	291	5	be	be	AUX
cblr-5119	291	6	part	part	NOUN
cblr-5119	291	7	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	291	8	customary	customary	ADJ
cblr-5119	291	9	international	international	ADJ
cblr-5119	291	10	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	291	11	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	291	12	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	291	13	norm	norm	NOUN
cblr-5119	291	14	had	have	VERB
cblr-5119	291	15	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	291	16	be	be	AUX
cblr-5119	291	17	one	one	NUM
cblr-5119	291	18	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	291	19	true	true	ADJ
cblr-5119	291	20	international	international	ADJ
cblr-5119	291	21	concern.105	concern.105	NOUN
cblr-5119	291	22	finally	finally	ADV
cblr-5119	291	23	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	291	24	while	while	SCONJ
cblr-5119	291	25	judge	judge	NOUN
cblr-5119	291	26	cabranes	cabrane	NOUN
cblr-5119	291	27	acknowledged	acknowledge	VERB
cblr-5119	291	28	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	291	29	international	international	ADJ
cblr-5119	291	30	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	291	31	allows	allow	VERB
cblr-5119	291	32	101	101	NUM
cblr-5119	291	33	i	i	PROPN
cblr-5119	291	34	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-5119	291	35	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	291	36	128	128	NUM
cblr-5119	291	37	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	291	38	citing	cite	VERB
cblr-5119	291	39	sosa	sosa	PROPN
cblr-5119	291	40	v.	v.	PROPN
cblr-5119	291	41	alvarez	alvarez	PROPN
cblr-5119	291	42	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-5119	291	43	machain	machain	NOUN
cblr-5119	291	44	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	291	45	542	542	NUM
cblr-5119	291	46	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	291	47	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	291	48	692	692	NUM
cblr-5119	291	49	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	291	50	732	732	NUM
cblr-5119	291	51	n.20	n.20	NOUN
cblr-5119	291	52	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	291	53	2004	2004	NUM
cblr-5119	291	54	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	291	55	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	291	56	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	292	1	footnote	footnote	VERB
cblr-5119	292	2	20	20	NUM
cblr-5119	292	3	itself	itself	PRON
cblr-5119	292	4	reads	read	VERB
cblr-5119	292	5	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	292	6	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	292	7	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	292	8	related	related	ADJ
cblr-5119	292	9	consideration	consideration	NOUN
cblr-5119	292	10	is	be	AUX
cblr-5119	292	11	whether	whether	SCONJ
cblr-5119	292	12	international	international	ADJ
cblr-5119	292	13	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	292	14	extends	extend	VERB
cblr-5119	292	15	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	292	16	scope	scope	NOUN
cblr-5119	292	17	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	292	18	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	292	19	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	292	20	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	292	21	violation	violation	NOUN
cblr-5119	292	22	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	292	23	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	292	24	given	give	VERB
cblr-5119	292	25	norm	norm	NOUN
cblr-5119	292	26	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	292	27	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	292	28	perpetrator	perpetrator	NOUN
cblr-5119	292	29	being	be	AUX
cblr-5119	292	30	sued	sue	VERB
cblr-5119	292	31	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	292	32	if	if	SCONJ
cblr-5119	292	33	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	292	34	defendant	defendant	NOUN
cblr-5119	292	35	is	be	AUX
cblr-5119	292	36	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	292	37	private	private	ADJ
cblr-5119	292	38	actor	actor	NOUN
cblr-5119	292	39	such	such	ADJ
cblr-5119	292	40	as	as	ADP
cblr-5119	292	41	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	292	42	corporation	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	292	43	or	or	CCONJ
cblr-5119	292	44	individual	individual	NOUN
cblr-5119	292	45	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	292	46	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	293	1	sosa	sosa	PROPN
cblr-5119	293	2	v.	v.	PROPN
cblr-5119	293	3	alvarez	alvarez	PROPN
cblr-5119	293	4	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-5119	293	5	machain	machain	NOUN
cblr-5119	293	6	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	293	7	542	542	NUM
cblr-5119	293	8	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	293	9	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	293	10	692	692	NUM
cblr-5119	293	11	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	293	12	732	732	NUM
cblr-5119	293	13	n.20	n.20	NOUN
cblr-5119	293	14	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	293	15	2004	2004	NUM
cblr-5119	293	16	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	293	17	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	294	1	102	102	NUM
cblr-5119	294	2	kiobel	kiobel	NOUN
cblr-5119	294	3	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	294	4	621	621	NUM
cblr-5119	294	5	f.3d	f.3d	NUM
cblr-5119	294	6	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	294	7	128–29	128–29	NUM
cblr-5119	294	8	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	294	9	103	103	NUM
cblr-5119	295	1	i	i	PRON
cblr-5119	295	2	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-5119	295	3	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	295	4	131	131	NUM
cblr-5119	295	5	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	295	6	quoting	quote	VERB
cblr-5119	295	7	sosa	sosa	PROPN
cblr-5119	295	8	v.	v.	PROPN
cblr-5119	295	9	alvarez	alvarez	PROPN
cblr-5119	295	10	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-5119	295	11	machain	machain	NOUN
cblr-5119	295	12	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	295	13	542	542	NUM
cblr-5119	295	14	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	295	15	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	295	16	692	692	NUM
cblr-5119	295	17	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	295	18	732	732	NUM
cblr-5119	295	19	n.20	n.20	NOUN
cblr-5119	295	20	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	295	21	2004	2004	NUM
cblr-5119	295	22	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	295	23	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	296	1	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	296	2	internal	internal	ADJ
cblr-5119	296	3	quotation	quotation	NOUN
cblr-5119	296	4	marks	mark	NOUN
cblr-5119	296	5	omitted	omit	VERB
cblr-5119	296	6	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	296	7	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	297	1	104	104	NUM
cblr-5119	297	2	see	see	VERB
cblr-5119	297	3	i	i	PRON
cblr-5119	297	4	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-5119	297	5	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	297	6	132–45	132–45	NUM
cblr-5119	297	7	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	298	1	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	298	2	nuremberg	nuremberg	PROPN
cblr-5119	298	3	tribunals	tribunal	NOUN
cblr-5119	298	4	had	have	VERB
cblr-5119	298	5	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NOUN
cblr-5119	298	6	only	only	ADV
cblr-5119	298	7	over	over	ADP
cblr-5119	298	8	natural	natural	ADJ
cblr-5119	298	9	persons	person	NOUN
cblr-5119	298	10	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	298	11	even	even	ADV
cblr-5119	298	12	though	though	SCONJ
cblr-5119	298	13	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	298	14	were	be	AUX
cblr-5119	298	15	implicated	implicate	VERB
cblr-5119	298	16	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	298	17	wrongdoing	wrongdoing	NOUN
cblr-5119	298	18	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	298	19	connection	connection	NOUN
cblr-5119	298	20	with	with	ADP
cblr-5119	298	21	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	298	22	nazi	nazi	ADJ
cblr-5119	298	23	regime	regime	NOUN
cblr-5119	298	24	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	299	1	i	i	PRON
cblr-5119	299	2	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-5119	299	3	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	299	4	133–34	133–34	PROPN
cblr-5119	299	5	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	300	1	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	300	2	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	300	3	discussion	discussion	NOUN
cblr-5119	300	4	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	300	5	why	why	SCONJ
cblr-5119	300	6	judge	judge	NOUN
cblr-5119	300	7	cabranes	cabrane	VERB
cblr-5119	300	8	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	300	9	evaluation	evaluation	NOUN
cblr-5119	300	10	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	300	11	what	what	PRON
cblr-5119	300	12	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	300	13	nuremberg	nuremberg	PROPN
cblr-5119	300	14	tribunals	tribunal	NOUN
cblr-5119	300	15	stand	stand	VERB
cblr-5119	300	16	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	300	17	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	300	18	international	international	ADJ
cblr-5119	300	19	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	300	20	jurisprudence	jurisprudence	NOUN
cblr-5119	300	21	may	may	AUX
cblr-5119	300	22	be	be	AUX
cblr-5119	300	23	incorrect	incorrect	ADJ
cblr-5119	300	24	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	300	25	see	see	VERB
cblr-5119	300	26	jonathan	jonathan	PROPN
cblr-5119	300	27	kolieb	kolieb	PROPN
cblr-5119	300	28	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	300	29	through	through	ADP
cblr-5119	300	30	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	300	31	looking	look	VERB
cblr-5119	300	32	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-5119	300	33	glass	glass	NOUN
cblr-5119	300	34	:	:	PUNCT
cblr-5119	300	35	nuremberg	nuremberg	PROPN
cblr-5119	300	36	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	300	37	confusing	confusing	ADJ
cblr-5119	300	38	legacy	legacy	NOUN
cblr-5119	300	39	on	on	ADP
cblr-5119	300	40	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	300	41	accountability	accountability	NOUN
cblr-5119	300	42	under	under	ADP
cblr-5119	300	43	international	international	ADJ
cblr-5119	300	44	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	300	45	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	300	46	32	32	NUM
cblr-5119	300	47	am	am	NOUN
cblr-5119	300	48	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	301	1	u.	u.	VERB
cblr-5119	301	2	int’l	int’l	NUM
cblr-5119	301	3	l.	l.	PROPN
cblr-5119	301	4	rev	rev	PROPN
cblr-5119	301	5	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	301	6	569	569	NUM
cblr-5119	301	7	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	301	8	578–80	578–80	PROPN
cblr-5119	301	9	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	301	10	2017	2017	NUM
cblr-5119	301	11	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	301	12	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	302	1	more	more	ADV
cblr-5119	302	2	recently	recently	ADV
cblr-5119	302	3	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	302	4	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	302	5	international	international	ADJ
cblr-5119	302	6	criminal	criminal	ADJ
cblr-5119	302	7	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	302	8	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	302	9	whose	whose	DET
cblr-5119	302	10	charter	charter	NOUN
cblr-5119	302	11	was	be	AUX
cblr-5119	302	12	passed	pass	VERB
cblr-5119	302	13	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	302	14	1998	1998	NUM
cblr-5119	302	15	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	302	16	was	be	AUX
cblr-5119	302	17	also	also	ADV
cblr-5119	302	18	granted	grant	VERB
cblr-5119	302	19	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NOUN
cblr-5119	302	20	only	only	ADV
cblr-5119	302	21	over	over	ADP
cblr-5119	302	22	natural	natural	ADJ
cblr-5119	302	23	persons	person	NOUN
cblr-5119	302	24	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	302	25	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	302	26	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	302	27	proposal	proposal	NOUN
cblr-5119	302	28	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	302	29	include	include	VERB
cblr-5119	302	30	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NOUN
cblr-5119	302	31	over	over	ADP
cblr-5119	302	32	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	302	33	was	be	AUX
cblr-5119	302	34	expressly	expressly	ADV
cblr-5119	302	35	rejected	reject	VERB
cblr-5119	302	36	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	303	1	kiobel	kiobel	PROPN
cblr-5119	303	2	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	303	3	621	621	NUM
cblr-5119	303	4	f.3d	f.3d	NUM
cblr-5119	303	5	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	303	6	136–37	136–37	NOUN
cblr-5119	303	7	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	304	1	105	105	NUM
cblr-5119	304	2	kiobel	kiobel	NOUN
cblr-5119	304	3	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	304	4	621	621	NUM
cblr-5119	304	5	f.3d	f.3d	NUM
cblr-5119	304	6	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	304	7	118	118	NUM
cblr-5119	304	8	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	305	1	6_2019.3_estes	6_2019.3_estes	NUM
cblr-5119	305	2	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	305	3	do	do	AUX
cblr-5119	305	4	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	305	5	delete	delete	VERB
cblr-5119	305	6	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	305	7	12/26/2019	12/26/2019	NUM
cblr-5119	305	8	12:00	12:00	NUM
cblr-5119	305	9	am	be	AUX
cblr-5119	305	10	no	no	NOUN
cblr-5119	305	11	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	306	1	3:1031	3:1031	NUM
cblr-5119	306	2	]	]	X
cblr-5119	306	3	may	may	AUX
cblr-5119	306	4	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	306	5	fourth	fourth	ADJ
cblr-5119	306	6	be	be	AUX
cblr-5119	306	7	with	with	ADP
cblr-5119	306	8	you	you	PRON
cblr-5119	306	9	1053	1053	NUM
cblr-5119	306	10	individual	individual	ADJ
cblr-5119	306	11	states	state	NOUN
cblr-5119	306	12	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	306	13	determine	determine	VERB
cblr-5119	306	14	remedies	remedy	NOUN
cblr-5119	306	15	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	306	16	violations	violation	NOUN
cblr-5119	306	17	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	306	18	he	he	PRON
cblr-5119	306	19	emphasized	emphasize	VERB
cblr-5119	306	20	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	306	21	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	306	22	question	question	NOUN
cblr-5119	306	23	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	306	24	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	306	25	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	306	26	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	306	27	class	class	NOUN
cblr-5119	306	28	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	306	29	defendants	defendant	NOUN
cblr-5119	306	30	—	—	PUNCT
cblr-5119	306	31	here	here	ADV
cblr-5119	306	32	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	306	33	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	306	34	—	—	PUNCT
cblr-5119	306	35	is	be	AUX
cblr-5119	306	36	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	306	37	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	306	38	remedial	remedial	ADJ
cblr-5119	306	39	question.106	question.106	NOUN
cblr-5119	306	40	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	306	41	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	306	42	concurring	concurring	NOUN
cblr-5119	306	43	opinion	opinion	NOUN
cblr-5119	306	44	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	306	45	judge	judge	NOUN
cblr-5119	306	46	leval	leval	PROPN
cblr-5119	306	47	sharply	sharply	ADV
cblr-5119	306	48	disagreed	disagree	VERB
cblr-5119	306	49	with	with	ADP
cblr-5119	306	50	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	306	51	majority	majority	NOUN
cblr-5119	306	52	on	on	ADP
cblr-5119	306	53	nearly	nearly	ADV
cblr-5119	306	54	all	all	PRON
cblr-5119	306	55	fronts	front	NOUN
cblr-5119	306	56	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	307	1	most	most	ADV
cblr-5119	307	2	importantly	importantly	ADV
cblr-5119	307	3	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	307	4	he	he	PRON
cblr-5119	307	5	interpreted	interpret	VERB
cblr-5119	307	6	sosa	sosa	PROPN
cblr-5119	307	7	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	307	8	footnote	footnote	VERB
cblr-5119	307	9	20	20	NUM
cblr-5119	307	10	differently	differently	ADV
cblr-5119	307	11	than	than	ADP
cblr-5119	307	12	judge	judge	NOUN
cblr-5119	307	13	cabranes.107	cabranes.107	NOUN
cblr-5119	307	14	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	307	15	his	his	PRON
cblr-5119	307	16	view	view	NOUN
cblr-5119	307	17	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	307	18	rather	rather	ADV
cblr-5119	307	19	than	than	ADP
cblr-5119	307	20	drawing	draw	VERB
cblr-5119	307	21	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	307	22	distinction	distinction	NOUN
cblr-5119	307	23	between	between	ADP
cblr-5119	307	24	individuals	individual	NOUN
cblr-5119	307	25	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	307	26	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	307	27	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	307	28	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	307	29	footnote	footnote	NOUN
cblr-5119	307	30	drew	draw	VERB
cblr-5119	307	31	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	307	32	distinction	distinction	NOUN
cblr-5119	307	33	between	between	ADP
cblr-5119	307	34	state	state	NOUN
cblr-5119	307	35	actors	actor	NOUN
cblr-5119	307	36	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	307	37	private	private	ADJ
cblr-5119	307	38	actors.108	actors.108	ADV
cblr-5119	307	39	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	307	40	examining	examine	VERB
cblr-5119	307	41	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	307	42	certain	certain	ADJ
cblr-5119	307	43	offense	offense	NOUN
cblr-5119	307	44	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	307	45	courts	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	307	46	had	have	VERB
cblr-5119	307	47	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	307	48	determine	determine	VERB
cblr-5119	307	49	if	if	SCONJ
cblr-5119	307	50	it	it	PRON
cblr-5119	307	51	was	be	AUX
cblr-5119	307	52	one	one	NUM
cblr-5119	307	53	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	307	54	international	international	ADJ
cblr-5119	307	55	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	307	56	would	would	AUX
cblr-5119	307	57	apply	apply	VERB
cblr-5119	307	58	only	only	ADV
cblr-5119	307	59	against	against	ADP
cblr-5119	307	60	states	state	NOUN
cblr-5119	307	61	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	307	62	or	or	CCONJ
cblr-5119	307	63	against	against	ADP
cblr-5119	307	64	both	both	DET
cblr-5119	307	65	states	state	NOUN
cblr-5119	307	66	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	307	67	private	private	ADJ
cblr-5119	307	68	actors	actor	NOUN
cblr-5119	307	69	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	308	1	if	if	SCONJ
cblr-5119	308	2	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	308	3	latter	latter	ADJ
cblr-5119	308	4	was	be	AUX
cblr-5119	308	5	true	true	ADJ
cblr-5119	308	6	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	308	7	then	then	ADV
cblr-5119	308	8	individuals	individual	NOUN
cblr-5119	308	9	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	308	10	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	308	11	would	would	AUX
cblr-5119	308	12	be	be	AUX
cblr-5119	308	13	liable	liable	ADJ
cblr-5119	308	14	;	;	PUNCT
cblr-5119	308	15	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	308	16	two	two	NUM
cblr-5119	308	17	categories	category	NOUN
cblr-5119	308	18	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	308	19	private	private	ADJ
cblr-5119	308	20	defendant	defendant	NOUN
cblr-5119	308	21	would	would	AUX
cblr-5119	308	22	be	be	AUX
cblr-5119	308	23	treated	treat	VERB
cblr-5119	308	24	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	308	25	same	same	ADJ
cblr-5119	308	26	under	under	ADP
cblr-5119	308	27	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	308	28	ats	at	NOUN
cblr-5119	308	29	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	308	30	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	308	31	differently.109	differently.109	VERB
cblr-5119	308	32	further	far	ADV
cblr-5119	308	33	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	308	34	judge	judge	NOUN
cblr-5119	308	35	leval	leval	PROPN
cblr-5119	308	36	stated	state	VERB
cblr-5119	308	37	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	308	38	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	308	39	international	international	ADJ
cblr-5119	308	40	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	308	41	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	308	42	takes	take	VERB
cblr-5119	308	43	no	no	DET
cblr-5119	308	44	position	position	NOUN
cblr-5119	308	45	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	308	46	on	on	ADP
cblr-5119	308	47	whether	whether	SCONJ
cblr-5119	308	48	civil	civil	ADJ
cblr-5119	308	49	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	308	50	should	should	AUX
cblr-5119	308	51	exist	exist	VERB
cblr-5119	308	52	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	308	53	violations	violation	NOUN
cblr-5119	308	54	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	308	55	its	its	PRON
cblr-5119	308	56	norms	norm	NOUN
cblr-5119	308	57	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	308	58	leaves	leave	VERB
cblr-5119	308	59	that	that	DET
cblr-5119	308	60	question	question	NOUN
cblr-5119	308	61	up	up	ADP
cblr-5119	308	62	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	308	63	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	308	64	domestic	domestic	ADJ
cblr-5119	308	65	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	308	66	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	308	67	individual	individual	ADJ
cblr-5119	308	68	states	state	NOUN
cblr-5119	308	69	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	309	1	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	309	2	its	its	PRON
cblr-5119	309	3	part	part	NOUN
cblr-5119	309	4	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	309	5	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	309	6	united	united	PROPN
cblr-5119	309	7	states	states	PROPN
cblr-5119	309	8	spoke	speak	VERB
cblr-5119	309	9	on	on	ADP
cblr-5119	309	10	that	that	DET
cblr-5119	309	11	question	question	NOUN
cblr-5119	309	12	by	by	ADP
cblr-5119	309	13	enacting	enact	VERB
cblr-5119	309	14	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	309	15	ats	at	NOUN
cblr-5119	309	16	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	309	17	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	309	18	since	since	SCONJ
cblr-5119	309	19	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	309	20	are	be	AUX
cblr-5119	309	21	liable	liable	ADJ
cblr-5119	309	22	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	309	23	tort	tort	NOUN
cblr-5119	309	24	generally	generally	ADV
cblr-5119	309	25	under	under	ADP
cblr-5119	309	26	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	309	27	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	309	28	domestic	domestic	ADJ
cblr-5119	309	29	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	309	30	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	309	31	they	they	PRON
cblr-5119	309	32	should	should	AUX
cblr-5119	309	33	be	be	AUX
cblr-5119	309	34	similarly	similarly	ADV
cblr-5119	309	35	liable	liable	ADJ
cblr-5119	309	36	under	under	ADP
cblr-5119	309	37	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	309	38	ats.110	ats.110	PROPN
cblr-5119	309	39	judge	judge	PROPN
cblr-5119	309	40	leval	leval	PROPN
cblr-5119	309	41	further	far	ADV
cblr-5119	309	42	attacked	attack	VERB
cblr-5119	309	43	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	309	44	majority	majority	NOUN
cblr-5119	309	45	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	309	46	argument	argument	NOUN
cblr-5119	309	47	by	by	ADP
cblr-5119	309	48	discussing	discuss	VERB
cblr-5119	309	49	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	309	50	relation	relation	NOUN
cblr-5119	309	51	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	309	52	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	309	53	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	309	54	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	309	55	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	309	56	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	309	57	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	309	58	natural	natural	ADJ
cblr-5119	309	59	persons	person	NOUN
cblr-5119	309	60	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	310	1	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	310	2	majority	majority	NOUN
cblr-5119	310	3	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	310	4	reasoning	reasoning	NOUN
cblr-5119	310	5	implied	imply	VERB
cblr-5119	310	6	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	310	7	international	international	ADJ
cblr-5119	310	8	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	310	9	needs	need	VERB
cblr-5119	310	10	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	310	11	recognize	recognize	VERB
cblr-5119	310	12	human	human	ADJ
cblr-5119	310	13	rights	right	NOUN
cblr-5119	310	14	civil	civil	ADJ
cblr-5119	310	15	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	310	16	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	310	17	natural	natural	ADJ
cblr-5119	310	18	persons	person	NOUN
cblr-5119	310	19	as	as	ADP
cblr-5119	310	20	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	310	21	universally	universally	ADV
cblr-5119	310	22	accepted	accept	VERB
cblr-5119	310	23	norm	norm	NOUN
cblr-5119	310	24	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	310	25	order	order	NOUN
cblr-5119	310	26	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	310	27	natural	natural	ADJ
cblr-5119	310	28	persons	person	NOUN
cblr-5119	310	29	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	310	30	be	be	AUX
cblr-5119	310	31	liable	liable	ADJ
cblr-5119	310	32	under	under	ADP
cblr-5119	310	33	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	310	34	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	310	35	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	311	1	although	although	SCONJ
cblr-5119	311	2	no	no	DET
cblr-5119	311	3	such	such	ADJ
cblr-5119	311	4	universally	universally	ADV
cblr-5119	311	5	accepted	accept	VERB
cblr-5119	311	6	norm	norm	NOUN
cblr-5119	311	7	then	then	ADV
cblr-5119	311	8	existed	exist	VERB
cblr-5119	311	9	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	311	10	second	second	ADJ
cblr-5119	311	11	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	311	12	precedent	precedent	NOUN
cblr-5119	311	13	nevertheless	nevertheless	ADV
cblr-5119	311	14	expressly	expressly	ADV
cblr-5119	311	15	recognized	recognize	VERB
cblr-5119	311	16	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	311	17	106	106	NUM
cblr-5119	312	1	i	i	PRON
cblr-5119	312	2	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-5119	312	3	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	312	4	147–48	147–48	NUM
cblr-5119	312	5	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	313	1	107	107	NUM
cblr-5119	313	2	judge	judge	NOUN
cblr-5119	313	3	leval	leval	NOUN
cblr-5119	313	4	agreed	agree	VERB
cblr-5119	313	5	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	313	6	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	313	7	complaint	complaint	NOUN
cblr-5119	313	8	should	should	AUX
cblr-5119	313	9	be	be	AUX
cblr-5119	313	10	dismissed	dismiss	VERB
cblr-5119	313	11	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	313	12	but	but	CCONJ
cblr-5119	313	13	only	only	ADV
cblr-5119	313	14	because	because	SCONJ
cblr-5119	313	15	it	it	PRON
cblr-5119	313	16	failed	fail	VERB
cblr-5119	313	17	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	313	18	satisfy	satisfy	VERB
cblr-5119	313	19	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	313	20	pleading	pleading	NOUN
cblr-5119	313	21	standard	standard	NOUN
cblr-5119	313	22	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	313	23	aiding	aid	VERB
cblr-5119	313	24	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	313	25	abetting	abet	VERB
cblr-5119	313	26	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	313	27	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	314	1	i	i	PRON
cblr-5119	314	2	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-5119	314	3	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	314	4	188	188	NUM
cblr-5119	314	5	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	314	6	leval	leval	NOUN
cblr-5119	314	7	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	314	8	j.	j.	PROPN
cblr-5119	314	9	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	314	10	concurring	concur	VERB
cblr-5119	314	11	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	314	12	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	315	1	108	108	NUM
cblr-5119	316	1	i	i	PRON
cblr-5119	316	2	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-5119	316	3	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	316	4	165	165	NUM
cblr-5119	316	5	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	317	1	109	109	NUM
cblr-5119	318	1	i	i	PROPN
cblr-5119	318	2	d.	d.	NOUN
cblr-5119	318	3	110	110	NUM
cblr-5119	319	1	i	i	PRON
cblr-5119	319	2	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-5119	319	3	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	319	4	152	152	NUM
cblr-5119	319	5	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	320	1	6_2019.3_estes	6_2019.3_estes	NUM
cblr-5119	320	2	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	320	3	do	do	AUX
cblr-5119	320	4	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	320	5	delte	delte	VERB
cblr-5119	320	6	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	320	7	12/26/2019	12/26/2019	NUM
cblr-5119	320	8	12:00	12:00	NUM
cblr-5119	320	9	am	be	AUX
cblr-5119	320	10	1054	1054	NUM
cblr-5119	320	11	columbia	columbia	PROPN
cblr-5119	320	12	business	business	NOUN
cblr-5119	320	13	law	law	PROPN
cblr-5119	320	14	review	review	NOUN
cblr-5119	321	1	[	[	X
cblr-5119	321	2	vol	vol	NOUN
cblr-5119	321	3	.	.	NOUN
cblr-5119	321	4	2019	2019	NUM
cblr-5119	321	5	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	321	6	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	321	7	natural	natural	ADJ
cblr-5119	321	8	persons.111	persons.111	NOUN
cblr-5119	321	9	judge	judge	NOUN
cblr-5119	321	10	leval	leval	NOUN
cblr-5119	321	11	also	also	ADV
cblr-5119	321	12	criticized	criticize	VERB
cblr-5119	321	13	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	321	14	majority	majority	NOUN
cblr-5119	321	15	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	321	16	examination	examination	NOUN
cblr-5119	321	17	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	321	18	international	international	ADJ
cblr-5119	321	19	criminal	criminal	ADJ
cblr-5119	321	20	tribunals	tribunal	NOUN
cblr-5119	321	21	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	322	1	judge	judge	PROPN
cblr-5119	322	2	leval	leval	PROPN
cblr-5119	322	3	argued	argue	VERB
cblr-5119	322	4	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	322	5	such	such	ADJ
cblr-5119	322	6	criminal	criminal	ADJ
cblr-5119	322	7	tribunals	tribunal	NOUN
cblr-5119	322	8	did	do	AUX
cblr-5119	322	9	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	322	10	cover	cover	VERB
cblr-5119	322	11	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	322	12	because	because	SCONJ
cblr-5119	322	13	imposing	impose	VERB
cblr-5119	322	14	criminal	criminal	ADJ
cblr-5119	322	15	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	322	16	on	on	ADP
cblr-5119	322	17	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	322	18	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	322	19	which	which	PRON
cblr-5119	322	20	are	be	AUX
cblr-5119	322	21	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	322	22	fictitious	fictitious	ADJ
cblr-5119	322	23	juridical	juridical	ADJ
cblr-5119	322	24	entit[ies	entit[ie	NOUN
cblr-5119	322	25	]	]	PUNCT
cblr-5119	322	26	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	322	27	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	322	28	could	could	AUX
cblr-5119	322	29	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	322	30	serve	serve	VERB
cblr-5119	322	31	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	322	32	punitive	punitive	ADJ
cblr-5119	322	33	objectives	objective	NOUN
cblr-5119	322	34	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	322	35	criminal	criminal	ADJ
cblr-5119	322	36	punishment	punishment	NOUN
cblr-5119	322	37	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	322	38	whereas	whereas	SCONJ
cblr-5119	322	39	imposing	impose	VERB
cblr-5119	322	40	civil	civil	ADJ
cblr-5119	322	41	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	322	42	on	on	ADP
cblr-5119	322	43	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	322	44	did	do	AUX
cblr-5119	322	45	serve	serve	VERB
cblr-5119	322	46	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	322	47	objectives	objective	NOUN
cblr-5119	322	48	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	322	49	civil	civil	ADJ
cblr-5119	322	50	liability.112	liability.112	PROPN
cblr-5119	322	51	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	322	52	this	this	DET
cblr-5119	322	53	reason	reason	NOUN
cblr-5119	322	54	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	322	55	criminal	criminal	ADJ
cblr-5119	322	56	tribunals	tribunal	NOUN
cblr-5119	322	57	’	'	PUNCT
cblr-5119	322	58	lack	lack	NOUN
cblr-5119	322	59	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	322	60	criminal	criminal	ADJ
cblr-5119	322	61	prosecution	prosecution	NOUN
cblr-5119	322	62	said	say	VERB
cblr-5119	322	63	nothing	nothing	PRON
cblr-5119	322	64	about	about	ADP
cblr-5119	322	65	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	322	66	potential	potential	NOUN
cblr-5119	322	67	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	322	68	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	322	69	’	'	PUNCT
cblr-5119	322	70	civil	civil	ADJ
cblr-5119	322	71	liability.113	liability.113	ADJ
cblr-5119	322	72	judge	judge	NOUN
cblr-5119	322	73	leval	leval	PROPN
cblr-5119	322	74	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	322	75	overall	overall	ADJ
cblr-5119	322	76	position	position	NOUN
cblr-5119	322	77	is	be	AUX
cblr-5119	322	78	summed	sum	VERB
cblr-5119	322	79	up	up	ADP
cblr-5119	322	80	thusly	thusly	ADV
cblr-5119	322	81	:	:	PUNCT
cblr-5119	322	82	because	because	SCONJ
cblr-5119	322	83	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	322	84	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	322	85	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	322	86	nations	nation	NOUN
cblr-5119	322	87	leaves	leave	VERB
cblr-5119	322	88	each	each	DET
cblr-5119	322	89	nation	nation	NOUN
cblr-5119	322	90	free	free	ADJ
cblr-5119	322	91	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	322	92	determine	determine	VERB
cblr-5119	322	93	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	322	94	itself	itself	PRON
cblr-5119	322	95	whether	whether	SCONJ
cblr-5119	322	96	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	322	97	impose	impose	VERB
cblr-5119	322	98	civil	civil	ADJ
cblr-5119	322	99	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	322	100	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	322	101	such	such	ADJ
cblr-5119	322	102	violations	violation	NOUN
cblr-5119	322	103	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	322	104	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	322	105	norms	norm	NOUN
cblr-5119	322	106	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	322	107	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	322	108	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	322	109	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	322	110	nations	nation	NOUN
cblr-5119	322	111	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	322	112	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	322	113	because	because	SCONJ
cblr-5119	322	114	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	322	115	united	united	PROPN
cblr-5119	322	116	states	state	NOUN
cblr-5119	322	117	by	by	ADP
cblr-5119	322	118	enacting	enact	VERB
cblr-5119	322	119	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	322	120	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	322	121	has	have	AUX
cblr-5119	322	122	opted	opt	VERB
cblr-5119	322	123	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	322	124	civil	civil	ADJ
cblr-5119	322	125	tort	tort	NOUN
cblr-5119	322	126	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	322	127	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	322	128	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	322	129	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	322	130	courts	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	322	131	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	322	132	as	as	ADP
cblr-5119	322	133	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	322	134	matter	matter	NOUN
cblr-5119	322	135	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	322	136	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	322	137	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	322	138	law	law	PROPN
cblr-5119	322	139	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	322	140	entertain	entertain	VERB
cblr-5119	322	141	suits	suit	NOUN
cblr-5119	322	142	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	322	143	compensatory	compensatory	ADJ
cblr-5119	322	144	damages	damage	NOUN
cblr-5119	322	145	under	under	ADP
cblr-5119	322	146	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	322	147	ats	at	NOUN
cblr-5119	322	148	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	322	149	violations	violation	NOUN
cblr-5119	322	150	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	322	151	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	322	152	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	322	153	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	322	154	nations	nation	NOUN
cblr-5119	322	155	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	323	1	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	323	2	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	323	3	confers	confer	NOUN
cblr-5119	323	4	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NOUN
cblr-5119	323	5	by	by	ADP
cblr-5119	323	6	virtue	virtue	NOUN
cblr-5119	323	7	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	323	8	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	323	9	defendant	defendant	NOUN
cblr-5119	323	10	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	323	11	violation	violation	NOUN
cblr-5119	323	12	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	323	13	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	323	14	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	323	15	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	323	16	nations	nation	NOUN
cblr-5119	323	17	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	324	1	damages	damage	NOUN
cblr-5119	324	2	are	be	AUX
cblr-5119	324	3	properly	properly	ADV
cblr-5119	324	4	awarded	award	VERB
cblr-5119	324	5	under	under	ADP
cblr-5119	324	6	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	324	7	ats	at	NOUN
cblr-5119	324	8	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	324	9	because	because	SCONJ
cblr-5119	324	10	any	any	DET
cblr-5119	324	11	rule	rule	NOUN
cblr-5119	324	12	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	324	13	international	international	ADJ
cblr-5119	324	14	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	324	15	imposes	impose	VERB
cblr-5119	324	16	damages	damage	NOUN
cblr-5119	324	17	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	324	18	but	but	CCONJ
cblr-5119	324	19	because	because	SCONJ
cblr-5119	324	20	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	324	21	united	united	PROPN
cblr-5119	324	22	states	states	PROPN
cblr-5119	324	23	has	have	AUX
cblr-5119	324	24	exercised	exercise	VERB
cblr-5119	324	25	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	324	26	option	option	NOUN
cblr-5119	324	27	left	leave	VERB
cblr-5119	324	28	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	324	29	it	it	PRON
cblr-5119	324	30	by	by	ADP
cblr-5119	324	31	international	international	ADJ
cblr-5119	324	32	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	324	33	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	324	34	allow	allow	VERB
cblr-5119	324	35	civil	civil	ADJ
cblr-5119	324	36	suits	suit	NOUN
cblr-5119	324	37	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	325	1	nothing	nothing	PRON
cblr-5119	325	2	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	325	3	international	international	ADJ
cblr-5119	325	4	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	325	5	bars	bar	NOUN
cblr-5119	325	6	such	such	DET
cblr-5119	325	7	an	an	DET
cblr-5119	325	8	award	award	NOUN
cblr-5119	325	9	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	325	10	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	326	1	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	326	2	.114	.114	NUM
cblr-5119	327	1	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	327	2	second	second	ADJ
cblr-5119	327	3	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	327	4	has	have	AUX
cblr-5119	327	5	indicated	indicate	VERB
cblr-5119	327	6	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	327	7	it	it	PRON
cblr-5119	327	8	is	be	AUX
cblr-5119	327	9	open	open	ADJ
cblr-5119	327	10	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	327	11	rethinking	rethink	VERB
cblr-5119	327	12	its	its	PRON
cblr-5119	327	13	position	position	NOUN
cblr-5119	327	14	on	on	ADP
cblr-5119	327	15	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	327	16	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	327	17	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	327	18	due	due	ADP
cblr-5119	327	19	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	327	20	its	its	PRON
cblr-5119	327	21	status	status	NOUN
cblr-5119	327	22	as	as	ADP
cblr-5119	327	23	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	327	24	only	only	ADJ
cblr-5119	327	25	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	327	26	that	that	PRON
cblr-5119	327	27	forecloses	foreclose	VERB
cblr-5119	327	28	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	327	29	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	327	30	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	327	31	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	327	32	kiobel	kiobel	PROPN
cblr-5119	327	33	ii	ii	PROPN
cblr-5119	327	34	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	327	35	implicit	implicit	ADJ
cblr-5119	327	36	acknowledgement	acknowledgement	NOUN
cblr-5119	327	37	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	327	38	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	327	39	could	could	AUX
cblr-5119	327	40	be	be	AUX
cblr-5119	327	41	liable	liable	ADJ
cblr-5119	327	42	under	under	ADP
cblr-5119	327	43	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	327	44	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	327	45	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	328	1	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	328	2	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	328	3	re	re	PROPN
cblr-5119	328	4	arab	arab	PROPN
cblr-5119	328	5	bank	bank	PROPN
cblr-5119	328	6	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	328	7	plc	plc	PROPN
cblr-5119	328	8	alien	alien	PROPN
cblr-5119	328	9	tort	tort	PROPN
cblr-5119	328	10	statute	statute	NOUN
cblr-5119	328	11	litigation	litigation	NOUN
cblr-5119	328	12	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	328	13	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	328	14	precursor	precursor	NOUN
cblr-5119	328	15	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	328	16	jesner	jesner	PROPN
cblr-5119	328	17	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	328	18	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	328	19	second	second	ADJ
cblr-5119	328	20	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	328	21	acknowledged	acknowledge	VERB
cblr-5119	328	22	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	328	23	its	its	PRON
cblr-5119	328	24	decision	decision	NOUN
cblr-5119	328	25	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	328	26	kiobel	kiobel	PROPN
cblr-5119	328	27	i	i	PRON
cblr-5119	328	28	holding	hold	VERB
cblr-5119	328	29	both	both	CCONJ
cblr-5119	328	30	foreign	foreign	ADJ
cblr-5119	328	31	111	111	NUM
cblr-5119	328	32	i	i	PROPN
cblr-5119	328	33	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-5119	328	34	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	328	35	152–53	152–53	PROPN
cblr-5119	328	36	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	329	1	112	112	NUM
cblr-5119	330	1	i	i	PRON
cblr-5119	330	2	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-5119	330	3	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	330	4	152	152	NUM
cblr-5119	330	5	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	330	6	170	170	NUM
cblr-5119	330	7	.	.	NOUN
cblr-5119	330	8	113	113	NUM
cblr-5119	331	1	i	i	PRON
cblr-5119	331	2	d.	d.	VERB
cblr-5119	331	3	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	331	4	170–72	170–72	NUM
cblr-5119	331	5	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	332	1	114	114	NUM
cblr-5119	333	1	i	i	PRON
cblr-5119	333	2	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-5119	333	3	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	333	4	183–84	183–84	NOUN
cblr-5119	333	5	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	334	1	6_2019.3_estes	6_2019.3_estes	NUM
cblr-5119	334	2	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	334	3	do	do	AUX
cblr-5119	334	4	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	334	5	delete	delete	VERB
cblr-5119	334	6	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	334	7	12/26/2019	12/26/2019	NUM
cblr-5119	334	8	12:00	12:00	NUM
cblr-5119	334	9	am	be	AUX
cblr-5119	334	10	no	no	NOUN
cblr-5119	334	11	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	335	1	3:1031	3:1031	NUM
cblr-5119	335	2	]	]	X
cblr-5119	335	3	may	may	AUX
cblr-5119	335	4	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	335	5	fourth	fourth	ADJ
cblr-5119	335	6	be	be	AUX
cblr-5119	335	7	with	with	ADP
cblr-5119	335	8	you	you	PRON
cblr-5119	335	9	1055	1055	NUM
cblr-5119	335	10	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	335	11	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	335	12	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	335	13	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	335	14	immune	immune	ADJ
cblr-5119	335	15	from	from	ADP
cblr-5119	335	16	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	335	17	suits	suit	NOUN
cblr-5119	335	18	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	335	19	now	now	ADV
cblr-5119	335	20	appears	appear	VERB
cblr-5119	335	21	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	335	22	swim	swim	VERB
cblr-5119	335	23	alone	alone	ADJ
cblr-5119	335	24	against	against	ADP
cblr-5119	335	25	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	335	26	tide	tide	NOUN
cblr-5119	335	27	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	335	28	”115	”115	PUNCT
cblr-5119	336	1	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	336	2	addition	addition	NOUN
cblr-5119	336	3	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	336	4	foreclosing	foreclose	VERB
cblr-5119	336	5	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	336	6	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	336	7	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	336	8	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	336	9	second	second	ADJ
cblr-5119	336	10	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	336	11	has	have	AUX
cblr-5119	336	12	taken	take	VERB
cblr-5119	336	13	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	336	14	restrictive	restrictive	ADJ
cblr-5119	336	15	approach	approach	NOUN
cblr-5119	336	16	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	336	17	displacing	displace	VERB
cblr-5119	336	18	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	336	19	presumption	presumption	NOUN
cblr-5119	336	20	against	against	ADP
cblr-5119	336	21	extraterritoriality	extraterritoriality	NOUN
cblr-5119	336	22	as	as	SCONJ
cblr-5119	336	23	applied	apply	VERB
cblr-5119	336	24	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	336	25	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	336	26	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	336	27	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	337	1	this	this	PRON
cblr-5119	337	2	was	be	AUX
cblr-5119	337	3	first	first	ADV
cblr-5119	337	4	seen	see	VERB
cblr-5119	337	5	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	337	6	mastafa	mastafa	PROPN
cblr-5119	337	7	v.	v.	ADP
cblr-5119	337	8	chevron	chevron	PROPN
cblr-5119	337	9	corp.116	corp.116	PROPN
cblr-5119	337	10	there	there	ADV
cblr-5119	337	11	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	337	12	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	337	13	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
cblr-5119	337	14	accused	accuse	VERB
cblr-5119	337	15	defendants	defendant	NOUN
cblr-5119	337	16	chevron	chevron	PROPN
cblr-5119	337	17	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	337	18	bnp	bnp	PROPN
cblr-5119	337	19	paribas	paribas	PROPN
cblr-5119	337	20	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	337	21	aiding	aid	VERB
cblr-5119	337	22	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	337	23	abetting	abet	VERB
cblr-5119	337	24	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	337	25	torture	torture	NOUN
cblr-5119	337	26	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	337	27	iraqi	iraqi	ADJ
cblr-5119	337	28	citizens	citizen	NOUN
cblr-5119	337	29	under	under	ADP
cblr-5119	337	30	saddam	saddam	PROPN
cblr-5119	337	31	hussein	hussein	PROPN
cblr-5119	337	32	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	337	33	regime	regime	NOUN
cblr-5119	337	34	by	by	ADP
cblr-5119	337	35	knowingly	knowingly	ADV
cblr-5119	337	36	helping	help	VERB
cblr-5119	337	37	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	337	38	provide	provide	VERB
cblr-5119	337	39	illicit	illicit	ADJ
cblr-5119	337	40	payments	payment	NOUN
cblr-5119	337	41	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	337	42	iraq	iraq	PROPN
cblr-5119	337	43	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	337	44	exchange	exchange	NOUN
cblr-5119	337	45	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	337	46	oil.117	oil.117	ADJ
cblr-5119	337	47	writing	writing	NOUN
cblr-5119	337	48	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	337	49	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	337	50	majority	majority	NOUN
cblr-5119	337	51	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	337	52	judge	judge	PROPN
cblr-5119	337	53	cabranes	cabrane	NOUN
cblr-5119	337	54	emphasized	emphasize	VERB
cblr-5119	337	55	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	337	56	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	337	57	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	337	58	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	337	59	inquiry	inquiry	NOUN
cblr-5119	337	60	must	must	AUX
cblr-5119	337	61	concentrate	concentrate	VERB
cblr-5119	337	62	on	on	ADP
cblr-5119	337	63	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	337	64	defendant	defendant	NOUN
cblr-5119	337	65	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	337	66	relevant	relevant	ADJ
cblr-5119	337	67	conduct	conduct	NOUN
cblr-5119	337	68	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	337	69	which	which	PRON
cblr-5119	337	70	translates	translate	VERB
cblr-5119	337	71	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	337	72	an	an	DET
cblr-5119	337	73	evaluation	evaluation	NOUN
cblr-5119	337	74	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	337	75	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	337	76	sufficiency	sufficiency	NOUN
cblr-5119	337	77	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	337	78	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	337	79	case	case	NOUN
cblr-5119	337	80	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	337	81	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	337	82	domestic	domestic	ADJ
cblr-5119	337	83	contacts	contact	NOUN
cblr-5119	337	84	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	338	1	”118	”118	PUNCT
cblr-5119	338	2	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	338	3	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	338	4	took	take	VERB
cblr-5119	338	5	guidance	guidance	NOUN
cblr-5119	338	6	from	from	ADP
cblr-5119	338	7	morrison119	morrison119	PROPN
cblr-5119	338	8	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	338	9	reaching	reach	VERB
cblr-5119	338	10	this	this	DET
cblr-5119	338	11	point	point	NOUN
cblr-5119	338	12	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	338	13	finding	find	VERB
cblr-5119	338	14	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	338	15	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	338	16	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	338	17	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	338	18	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	338	19	focus	focus	NOUN
cblr-5119	338	20	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	338	21	is	be	AUX
cblr-5119	338	22	on	on	ADP
cblr-5119	338	23	conduct	conduct	NOUN
cblr-5119	338	24	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	338	25	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	338	26	location	location	NOUN
cblr-5119	338	27	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	338	28	that	that	DET
cblr-5119	338	29	conduct.120	conduct.120	NOUN
cblr-5119	338	30	critically	critically	ADV
cblr-5119	338	31	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	338	32	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	338	33	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	338	34	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	338	35	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	338	36	view	view	NOUN
cblr-5119	338	37	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	338	38	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	338	39	only	only	ADJ
cblr-5119	338	40	relevant	relevant	ADJ
cblr-5119	338	41	conduct	conduct	NOUN
cblr-5119	338	42	was	be	AUX
cblr-5119	338	43	that	that	PRON
cblr-5119	338	44	which	which	PRON
cblr-5119	338	45	actually	actually	ADV
cblr-5119	338	46	constituted	constitute	VERB
cblr-5119	338	47	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	338	48	or	or	CCONJ
cblr-5119	338	49	aided	aid	VERB
cblr-5119	338	50	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	338	51	abetted	abet	VERB
cblr-5119	338	52	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	338	53	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	338	54	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	338	55	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	338	56	nations	nation	NOUN
cblr-5119	338	57	violation.121	violation.121	VERB
cblr-5119	338	58	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	338	59	other	other	ADJ
cblr-5119	338	60	words	word	NOUN
cblr-5119	338	61	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	338	62	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	338	63	only	only	ADJ
cblr-5119	338	64	way	way	NOUN
cblr-5119	338	65	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	338	66	overcome	overcome	VERB
cblr-5119	338	67	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	338	68	presumption	presumption	NOUN
cblr-5119	338	69	against	against	ADP
cblr-5119	338	70	extraterritoriality	extraterritoriality	NOUN
cblr-5119	338	71	is	be	AUX
cblr-5119	338	72	if	if	SCONJ
cblr-5119	338	73	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	338	74	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	338	75	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	338	76	nations	nation	NOUN
cblr-5119	338	77	violation	violation	NOUN
cblr-5119	338	78	occurred	occur	VERB
cblr-5119	338	79	on	on	ADP
cblr-5119	338	80	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	338	81	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	338	82	soil	soil	NOUN
cblr-5119	338	83	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	339	1	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	339	2	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	339	3	also	also	ADV
cblr-5119	339	4	held	hold	VERB
cblr-5119	339	5	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	339	6	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	339	7	defendant	defendant	NOUN
cblr-5119	339	8	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	339	9	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	339	10	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	339	11	citizenship	citizenship	NOUN
cblr-5119	339	12	is	be	AUX
cblr-5119	339	13	completely	completely	ADV
cblr-5119	339	14	irrelevant	irrelevant	ADJ
cblr-5119	339	15	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	339	16	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	339	17	touch	touch	NOUN
cblr-5119	339	18	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-5119	339	19	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	339	20	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-5119	339	21	concern	concern	NOUN
cblr-5119	339	22	inquiry.122	inquiry.122	NOUN
cblr-5119	339	23	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	339	24	majority	majority	NOUN
cblr-5119	339	25	framed	frame	VERB
cblr-5119	339	26	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	339	27	touch	touch	NOUN
cblr-5119	339	28	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-5119	339	29	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	339	30	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-5119	339	31	concern	concern	NOUN
cblr-5119	339	32	inquiry	inquiry	NOUN
cblr-5119	339	33	as	as	ADP
cblr-5119	339	34	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	339	35	first	first	ADJ
cblr-5119	339	36	part	part	NOUN
cblr-5119	339	37	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	339	38	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	339	39	two	two	NUM
cblr-5119	339	40	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-5119	339	41	part	part	NOUN
cblr-5119	339	42	test	test	NOUN
cblr-5119	339	43	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	339	44	displacing	displace	VERB
cblr-5119	339	45	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	339	46	presumption	presumption	NOUN
cblr-5119	339	47	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	339	48	with	with	ADP
cblr-5119	339	49	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	339	50	second	second	ADJ
cblr-5119	339	51	115	115	NUM
cblr-5119	339	52	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	339	53	re	re	PROPN
cblr-5119	339	54	arab	arab	PROPN
cblr-5119	339	55	bank	bank	PROPN
cblr-5119	339	56	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	339	57	plc	plc	PROPN
cblr-5119	339	58	alien	alien	PROPN
cblr-5119	339	59	tort	tort	PROPN
cblr-5119	339	60	statute	statute	NOUN
cblr-5119	339	61	litig	litig	PROPN
cblr-5119	339	62	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	339	63	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	339	64	808	808	NUM
cblr-5119	339	65	f.3d	f.3d	NUM
cblr-5119	339	66	144	144	NUM
cblr-5119	339	67	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	339	68	151	151	NUM
cblr-5119	339	69	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	339	70	2d	2d	NUM
cblr-5119	339	71	cir	cir	NOUN
cblr-5119	339	72	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	339	73	2015	2015	NUM
cblr-5119	339	74	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	339	75	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	339	76	aff’d	aff’d	X
cblr-5119	339	77	sub	sub	PROPN
cblr-5119	339	78	nom	nom	PROPN
cblr-5119	339	79	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	339	80	jesner	jesner	PROPN
cblr-5119	339	81	v.	v.	PROPN
cblr-5119	339	82	arab	arab	PROPN
cblr-5119	339	83	bank	bank	PROPN
cblr-5119	339	84	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	339	85	plc	plc	PROPN
cblr-5119	339	86	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	339	87	138	138	NUM
cblr-5119	339	88	s.	s.	PROPN
cblr-5119	339	89	ct	ct	PROPN
cblr-5119	339	90	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	339	91	1386	1386	NUM
cblr-5119	339	92	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	339	93	2018	2018	NUM
cblr-5119	339	94	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	339	95	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	340	1	116	116	NUM
cblr-5119	340	2	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	340	3	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	340	4	took	take	VERB
cblr-5119	340	5	this	this	DET
cblr-5119	340	6	opportunity	opportunity	NOUN
cblr-5119	340	7	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	340	8	interpret	interpret	VERB
cblr-5119	340	9	kiobel	kiobel	PROPN
cblr-5119	340	10	ii	ii	PROPN
cblr-5119	340	11	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	340	12	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	340	13	presumption	presumption	NOUN
cblr-5119	340	14	against	against	ADP
cblr-5119	340	15	extraterritoriality	extraterritoriality	NOUN
cblr-5119	340	16	even	even	ADV
cblr-5119	340	17	though	though	SCONJ
cblr-5119	340	18	it	it	PRON
cblr-5119	340	19	could	could	AUX
cblr-5119	340	20	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	340	21	exercise	exercise	VERB
cblr-5119	340	22	subject	subject	ADJ
cblr-5119	340	23	matter	matter	NOUN
cblr-5119	340	24	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NOUN
cblr-5119	340	25	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	340	26	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	340	27	case	case	NOUN
cblr-5119	340	28	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	340	29	since	since	SCONJ
cblr-5119	340	30	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	340	31	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	340	32	defendants	defendant	NOUN
cblr-5119	340	33	were	be	AUX
cblr-5119	340	34	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	340	35	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	341	1	mastafa	mastafa	PROPN
cblr-5119	341	2	v.	v.	PROPN
cblr-5119	341	3	chevron	chevron	PROPN
cblr-5119	341	4	corp	corp	PROPN
cblr-5119	341	5	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	341	6	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	341	7	770	770	NUM
cblr-5119	341	8	f.3d	f.3d	NUM
cblr-5119	341	9	170	170	NUM
cblr-5119	341	10	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	341	11	178–79	178–79	PROPN
cblr-5119	341	12	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	341	13	2d	2d	NUM
cblr-5119	341	14	cir	cir	NOUN
cblr-5119	341	15	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	341	16	2014	2014	NUM
cblr-5119	341	17	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	341	18	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	342	1	117	117	NUM
cblr-5119	343	1	i	i	PROPN
cblr-5119	343	2	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-5119	343	3	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	343	4	174–76	174–76	NUM
cblr-5119	343	5	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	344	1	118	118	NUM
cblr-5119	345	1	i	i	NOUN
cblr-5119	345	2	d.	d.	NOUN
cblr-5119	345	3	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	345	4	182	182	NUM
cblr-5119	345	5	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	346	1	119	119	NUM
cblr-5119	346	2	see	see	VERB
cblr-5119	346	3	supra	supra	PROPN
cblr-5119	346	4	note	note	PROPN
cblr-5119	346	5	62	62	NUM
cblr-5119	346	6	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	346	7	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	346	8	longer	long	ADJ
cblr-5119	346	9	discussion	discussion	NOUN
cblr-5119	346	10	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	346	11	morrison	morrison	PROPN
cblr-5119	346	12	infra	infra	NOUN
cblr-5119	346	13	section	section	NOUN
cblr-5119	346	14	iii.c	iii.c	PROPN
cblr-5119	346	15	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	346	16	120	120	NUM
cblr-5119	346	17	mastafa	mastafa	NOUN
cblr-5119	346	18	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	346	19	770	770	NUM
cblr-5119	346	20	f.3d	f.3d	NUM
cblr-5119	346	21	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	346	22	185	185	NUM
cblr-5119	346	23	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	346	24	121	121	NUM
cblr-5119	347	1	i	i	PRON
cblr-5119	347	2	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-5119	347	3	122	122	NUM
cblr-5119	348	1	i	i	PRON
cblr-5119	348	2	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-5119	348	3	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	348	4	188	188	NUM
cblr-5119	348	5	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	349	1	6_2019.3_estes	6_2019.3_estes	NUM
cblr-5119	349	2	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	349	3	do	do	AUX
cblr-5119	349	4	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	349	5	delte	delte	VERB
cblr-5119	349	6	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	349	7	12/26/2019	12/26/2019	NUM
cblr-5119	349	8	12:00	12:00	NUM
cblr-5119	349	9	am	am	PROPN
cblr-5119	350	1	1056	1056	NUM
cblr-5119	350	2	columbia	columbia	PROPN
cblr-5119	350	3	business	business	NOUN
cblr-5119	350	4	law	law	PROPN
cblr-5119	350	5	review	review	NOUN
cblr-5119	350	6	[	[	X
cblr-5119	350	7	vol	vol	NOUN
cblr-5119	350	8	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	350	9	2019	2019	NUM
cblr-5119	350	10	part	part	NOUN
cblr-5119	350	11	being	be	AUX
cblr-5119	350	12	an	an	DET
cblr-5119	350	13	early	early	ADJ
cblr-5119	350	14	evaluation	evaluation	NOUN
cblr-5119	350	15	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	350	16	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	350	17	merits	merit	NOUN
cblr-5119	350	18	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	350	19	determine	determine	VERB
cblr-5119	350	20	whether	whether	SCONJ
cblr-5119	350	21	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	350	22	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
cblr-5119	350	23	had	have	AUX
cblr-5119	350	24	sufficiently	sufficiently	ADV
cblr-5119	350	25	pled	plead	VERB
cblr-5119	350	26	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	350	27	true	true	ADJ
cblr-5119	350	28	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	350	29	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	350	30	nations	nation	NOUN
cblr-5119	350	31	violation.123	violation.123	NOUN
cblr-5119	350	32	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	350	33	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	350	34	case	case	NOUN
cblr-5119	350	35	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	350	36	hand	hand	NOUN
cblr-5119	350	37	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	350	38	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	350	39	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	350	40	ruled	rule	VERB
cblr-5119	350	41	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	350	42	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	350	43	complaint	complaint	NOUN
cblr-5119	350	44	failed	fail	VERB
cblr-5119	350	45	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	350	46	rebut	rebut	VERB
cblr-5119	350	47	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	350	48	presumption	presumption	NOUN
cblr-5119	350	49	against	against	ADP
cblr-5119	350	50	extraterritoriality.124	extraterritoriality.124	NOUN
cblr-5119	350	51	although	although	SCONJ
cblr-5119	350	52	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	350	53	complaint	complaint	NOUN
cblr-5119	350	54	facially	facially	ADV
cblr-5119	350	55	appeared	appear	VERB
cblr-5119	350	56	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	350	57	sufficiently	sufficiently	ADV
cblr-5119	350	58	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	350	59	touch	touch	NOUN
cblr-5119	350	60	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	350	61	concern	concern	NOUN
cblr-5119	350	62	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	350	63	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	350	64	united	united	PROPN
cblr-5119	350	65	states	states	PROPN
cblr-5119	350	66	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	350	67	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	350	68	alleged	allege	VERB
cblr-5119	350	69	conduct	conduct	NOUN
cblr-5119	350	70	did	do	AUX
cblr-5119	350	71	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	350	72	itself	itself	PRON
cblr-5119	350	73	constitute	constitute	VERB
cblr-5119	350	74	either	either	CCONJ
cblr-5119	350	75	intentional	intentional	ADJ
cblr-5119	350	76	or	or	CCONJ
cblr-5119	350	77	knowing	know	VERB
cblr-5119	350	78	aiding	aid	VERB
cblr-5119	350	79	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	350	80	abetting	abet	VERB
cblr-5119	350	81	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	350	82	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	350	83	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	350	84	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	350	85	nations	nation	NOUN
cblr-5119	350	86	violation	violation	NOUN
cblr-5119	350	87	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	350	88	thus	thus	ADV
cblr-5119	350	89	failing	fail	VERB
cblr-5119	350	90	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	350	91	second	second	ADJ
cblr-5119	350	92	prong	prong	NOUN
cblr-5119	350	93	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	350	94	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	350	95	test.125	test.125	NOUN
cblr-5119	350	96	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	350	97	fact	fact	NOUN
cblr-5119	350	98	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	350	99	two	two	NUM
cblr-5119	350	100	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	350	101	—	—	PUNCT
cblr-5119	350	102	one	one	NUM
cblr-5119	350	103	being	be	AUX
cblr-5119	350	104	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	350	105	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	350	106	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	350	107	corporation	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	350	108	—	—	PUNCT
cblr-5119	350	109	undertaking	undertake	VERB
cblr-5119	350	110	domestic	domestic	ADJ
cblr-5119	350	111	activities	activity	NOUN
cblr-5119	350	112	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	350	113	knowingly	knowingly	ADV
cblr-5119	350	114	aid	aid	VERB
cblr-5119	350	115	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	350	116	foreign	foreign	ADJ
cblr-5119	350	117	regime	regime	NOUN
cblr-5119	350	118	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	350	119	alleged	alleged	ADJ
cblr-5119	350	120	torture	torture	NOUN
cblr-5119	350	121	did	do	AUX
cblr-5119	350	122	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	350	123	rebut	rebut	VERB
cblr-5119	350	124	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	350	125	presumption	presumption	NOUN
cblr-5119	350	126	illustrates	illustrate	VERB
cblr-5119	350	127	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	350	128	restrictiveness	restrictiveness	NOUN
cblr-5119	350	129	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	350	130	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	350	131	second	second	ADJ
cblr-5119	350	132	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	350	133	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	350	134	approach	approach	NOUN
cblr-5119	350	135	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	350	136	granting	grant	VERB
cblr-5119	350	137	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	350	138	jurisdiction.126	jurisdiction.126	PROPN
cblr-5119	350	139	b.	b.	PROPN
cblr-5119	350	140	fourth	fourth	PROPN
cblr-5119	350	141	circuit	circuit	PROPN
cblr-5119	350	142	:	:	PUNCT
cblr-5119	350	143	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	350	144	flexible	flexible	ADJ
cblr-5119	350	145	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	350	146	fact	fact	NOUN
cblr-5119	350	147	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-5119	350	148	based	base	VERB
cblr-5119	350	149	approach	approach	NOUN
cblr-5119	350	150	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	350	151	fourth	fourth	ADJ
cblr-5119	350	152	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	350	153	has	have	AUX
cblr-5119	350	154	taken	take	VERB
cblr-5119	350	155	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	350	156	simple	simple	ADJ
cblr-5119	350	157	approach	approach	NOUN
cblr-5119	350	158	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	350	159	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	350	160	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	350	161	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	350	162	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	350	163	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	350	164	most	most	ADV
cblr-5119	350	165	liberal	liberal	ADJ
cblr-5119	350	166	approach	approach	NOUN
cblr-5119	350	167	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	350	168	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	350	169	presumption	presumption	NOUN
cblr-5119	350	170	against	against	ADP
cblr-5119	350	171	extraterritoriality	extraterritoriality	NOUN
cblr-5119	350	172	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	351	1	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	351	2	fourth	fourth	ADJ
cblr-5119	351	3	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	351	4	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	351	5	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	351	6	appeals	appeals	PROPN
cblr-5119	351	7	addressed	address	VERB
cblr-5119	351	8	these	these	DET
cblr-5119	351	9	issues	issue	NOUN
cblr-5119	351	10	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	351	11	al	al	PROPN
cblr-5119	351	12	shimari	shimari	PROPN
cblr-5119	351	13	v.	v.	ADP
cblr-5119	351	14	caci	caci	PROPN
cblr-5119	351	15	premier	premier	PROPN
cblr-5119	351	16	technology	technology	PROPN
cblr-5119	351	17	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	351	18	inc	inc	PROPN
cblr-5119	351	19	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	351	20	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	351	21	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	351	22	which	which	PRON
cblr-5119	351	23	victims	victim	NOUN
cblr-5119	351	24	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	351	25	alleged	alleged	ADJ
cblr-5119	351	26	abuse	abuse	NOUN
cblr-5119	351	27	from	from	ADP
cblr-5119	351	28	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	351	29	abu	abu	PROPN
cblr-5119	351	30	ghraib	ghraib	PROPN
cblr-5119	351	31	prison	prison	NOUN
cblr-5119	351	32	incident	incident	PROPN
cblr-5119	351	33	sued	sue	VERB
cblr-5119	351	34	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	351	35	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	351	36	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	351	37	military	military	ADJ
cblr-5119	351	38	contractor	contractor	NOUN
cblr-5119	351	39	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	351	40	torture	torture	NOUN
cblr-5119	351	41	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	351	42	war	war	NOUN
cblr-5119	351	43	crimes	crime	NOUN
cblr-5119	351	44	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	351	45	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	351	46	cruel	cruel	ADJ
cblr-5119	351	47	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	351	48	inhuman	inhuman	ADJ
cblr-5119	351	49	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	351	50	or	or	CCONJ
cblr-5119	351	51	degrading	degrade	VERB
cblr-5119	351	52	treatment	treatment	NOUN
cblr-5119	351	53	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	351	54	specifically	specifically	ADV
cblr-5119	351	55	alleging	allege	VERB
cblr-5119	351	56	actionable	actionable	ADJ
cblr-5119	351	57	behavior	behavior	NOUN
cblr-5119	351	58	by	by	ADP
cblr-5119	351	59	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	351	60	management	management	NOUN
cblr-5119	351	61	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	351	62	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	351	63	united	united	PROPN
cblr-5119	351	64	states	states	PROPN
cblr-5119	351	65	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	351	66	by	by	ADP
cblr-5119	351	67	employees	employee	NOUN
cblr-5119	351	68	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	351	69	iraq.127	iraq.127	PRON
cblr-5119	351	70	123	123	NUM
cblr-5119	351	71	i	i	PRON
cblr-5119	351	72	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-5119	351	73	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	351	74	186	186	NUM
cblr-5119	351	75	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	352	1	124	124	NUM
cblr-5119	353	1	i	i	PRON
cblr-5119	353	2	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-5119	353	3	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	353	4	192	192	NUM
cblr-5119	353	5	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	354	1	125	125	NUM
cblr-5119	354	2	i	i	PRON
cblr-5119	354	3	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-5119	354	4	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	354	5	192–94	192–94	NUM
cblr-5119	354	6	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	355	1	chevron	chevron	PROPN
cblr-5119	355	2	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	355	3	bnp	bnp	PROPN
cblr-5119	355	4	allegedly	allegedly	ADV
cblr-5119	355	5	helped	help	VERB
cblr-5119	355	6	fund	fund	VERB
cblr-5119	355	7	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	355	8	torture	torture	NOUN
cblr-5119	355	9	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	355	10	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	355	11	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
cblr-5119	355	12	through	through	ADP
cblr-5119	355	13	domestic	domestic	ADJ
cblr-5119	355	14	purchases	purchase	NOUN
cblr-5119	355	15	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	355	16	financing	financing	NOUN
cblr-5119	355	17	transactions	transaction	NOUN
cblr-5119	355	18	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	355	19	chevron	chevron	NOUN
cblr-5119	355	20	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	355	21	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	355	22	domestic	domestic	ADJ
cblr-5119	355	23	payments	payment	NOUN
cblr-5119	355	24	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	355	25	financing	financing	NOUN
cblr-5119	355	26	arrangements	arrangement	NOUN
cblr-5119	355	27	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	355	28	bnp	bnp	PROPN
cblr-5119	355	29	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	355	30	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	356	1	i	i	PRON
cblr-5119	356	2	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-5119	356	3	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	356	4	191	191	NUM
cblr-5119	356	5	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	357	1	126	126	NUM
cblr-5119	357	2	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	357	3	second	second	ADJ
cblr-5119	357	4	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	357	5	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	357	6	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	357	7	appeals	appeals	PROPN
cblr-5119	357	8	has	have	AUX
cblr-5119	357	9	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	357	10	yet	yet	ADV
cblr-5119	357	11	addressed	address	VERB
cblr-5119	357	12	jesner	jesner	NOUN
cblr-5119	357	13	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	358	1	127	127	NUM
cblr-5119	358	2	al	al	PROPN
cblr-5119	358	3	shimari	shimari	PROPN
cblr-5119	358	4	v.	v.	ADP
cblr-5119	358	5	caci	caci	NOUN
cblr-5119	358	6	premier	premier	PROPN
cblr-5119	358	7	tech	tech	PROPN
cblr-5119	358	8	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	358	9	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	358	10	inc	inc	PROPN
cblr-5119	358	11	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	358	12	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	358	13	758	758	NUM
cblr-5119	358	14	f.3d	f.3d	NUM
cblr-5119	358	15	516	516	NUM
cblr-5119	358	16	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	358	17	521–22	521–22	PROPN
cblr-5119	358	18	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	358	19	4th	4th	ADJ
cblr-5119	358	20	cir	cir	NOUN
cblr-5119	358	21	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	358	22	2014	2014	NUM
cblr-5119	358	23	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	358	24	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	359	1	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	359	2	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
cblr-5119	359	3	alleged	allege	VERB
cblr-5119	359	4	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	359	5	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	359	6	defendant	defendant	NOUN
cblr-5119	359	7	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	359	8	managers	manager	NOUN
cblr-5119	359	9	ignored	ignore	VERB
cblr-5119	359	10	reports	report	NOUN
cblr-5119	359	11	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	359	12	abuse	abuse	NOUN
cblr-5119	359	13	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	359	14	abu	abu	PROPN
cblr-5119	359	15	ghraib	ghraib	PROPN
cblr-5119	359	16	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	359	17	attempted	attempt	VERB
cblr-5119	359	18	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	359	19	cover	cover	VERB
cblr-5119	359	20	it	it	PRON
cblr-5119	359	21	up	up	ADP
cblr-5119	359	22	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	359	23	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	359	24	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	359	25	defendant	defendant	NOUN
cblr-5119	359	26	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	359	27	site	site	NOUN
cblr-5119	359	28	manager	manager	NOUN
cblr-5119	359	29	reviewed	review	VERB
cblr-5119	359	30	reports	report	NOUN
cblr-5119	359	31	raising	raise	VERB
cblr-5119	359	32	potential	potential	ADJ
cblr-5119	359	33	abuse	abuse	NOUN
cblr-5119	359	34	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	359	35	that	that	PRON
cblr-5119	359	36	said	say	VERB
cblr-5119	359	37	manager	manager	NOUN
cblr-5119	359	38	had	have	VERB
cblr-5119	359	39	daily	daily	ADJ
cblr-5119	359	40	contact	contact	NOUN
cblr-5119	359	41	with	with	ADP
cblr-5119	359	42	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	359	43	corporation	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	359	44	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	359	45	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	359	46	united	united	PROPN
cblr-5119	359	47	states	states	PROPN
cblr-5119	359	48	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	359	49	sent	send	VERB
cblr-5119	359	50	weekly	weekly	ADJ
cblr-5119	359	51	reports	report	NOUN
cblr-5119	359	52	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	359	53	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	359	54	executive	executive	ADJ
cblr-5119	359	55	team	team	NOUN
cblr-5119	359	56	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	359	57	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	359	58	united	united	PROPN
cblr-5119	359	59	states	states	PROPN
cblr-5119	359	60	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	359	61	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	359	62	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	359	63	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	359	64	6_2019.3_estes	6_2019.3_este	NOUN
cblr-5119	359	65	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	359	66	do	do	AUX
cblr-5119	359	67	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	359	68	delete	delete	VERB
cblr-5119	359	69	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	359	70	12/26/2019	12/26/2019	NUM
cblr-5119	359	71	12:00	12:00	NUM
cblr-5119	359	72	am	be	AUX
cblr-5119	359	73	no	no	NOUN
cblr-5119	359	74	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	360	1	3:1031	3:1031	NUM
cblr-5119	360	2	]	]	X
cblr-5119	360	3	may	may	AUX
cblr-5119	360	4	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	360	5	fourth	fourth	ADJ
cblr-5119	360	6	be	be	AUX
cblr-5119	360	7	with	with	ADP
cblr-5119	360	8	you	you	PRON
cblr-5119	360	9	1057	1057	NUM
cblr-5119	360	10	by	by	ADP
cblr-5119	360	11	hearing	hear	VERB
cblr-5119	360	12	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	360	13	case	case	NOUN
cblr-5119	360	14	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	360	15	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	360	16	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	360	17	implicitly	implicitly	ADV
cblr-5119	360	18	recognized	recognize	VERB
cblr-5119	360	19	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	360	20	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	360	21	could	could	AUX
cblr-5119	360	22	be	be	AUX
cblr-5119	360	23	liable	liable	ADJ
cblr-5119	360	24	under	under	ADP
cblr-5119	360	25	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	360	26	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	360	27	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	361	1	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	361	2	only	only	ADJ
cblr-5119	361	3	published	publish	VERB
cblr-5119	361	4	discussion	discussion	NOUN
cblr-5119	361	5	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	361	6	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	361	7	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	361	8	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	361	9	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	361	10	litigation	litigation	NOUN
cblr-5119	361	11	came	come	VERB
cblr-5119	361	12	on	on	ADP
cblr-5119	361	13	remand	remand	NOUN
cblr-5119	361	14	three	three	NUM
cblr-5119	361	15	years	year	NOUN
cblr-5119	361	16	later	later	ADV
cblr-5119	361	17	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	361	18	when	when	SCONJ
cblr-5119	361	19	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	361	20	district	district	NOUN
cblr-5119	361	21	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	361	22	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	361	23	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	361	24	eastern	eastern	ADJ
cblr-5119	361	25	district	district	PROPN
cblr-5119	361	26	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	361	27	virginia	virginia	PROPN
cblr-5119	361	28	simply	simply	ADV
cblr-5119	361	29	mentioned	mention	VERB
cblr-5119	361	30	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	361	31	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	361	32	footnote	footnote	NOUN
cblr-5119	361	33	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	361	34	it	it	PRON
cblr-5119	361	35	had	have	AUX
cblr-5119	361	36	decided	decide	VERB
cblr-5119	361	37	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	361	38	an	an	DET
cblr-5119	361	39	earlier	early	ADJ
cblr-5119	361	40	ruling	ruling	NOUN
cblr-5119	361	41	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	361	42	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	361	43	were	be	AUX
cblr-5119	361	44	subject	subject	ADJ
cblr-5119	361	45	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	361	46	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	361	47	liability.128	liability.128	PROPN
cblr-5119	361	48	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	361	49	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	361	50	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	361	51	appeals	appeal	NOUN
cblr-5119	361	52	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	361	53	however	however	ADV
cblr-5119	361	54	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	361	55	addressed	address	VERB
cblr-5119	361	56	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	361	57	presumption	presumption	NOUN
cblr-5119	361	58	against	against	ADP
cblr-5119	361	59	extraterritoriality	extraterritoriality	NOUN
cblr-5119	361	60	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	361	61	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	361	62	touch	touch	NOUN
cblr-5119	361	63	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-5119	361	64	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	361	65	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-5119	361	66	concern	concern	NOUN
cblr-5119	361	67	test	test	NOUN
cblr-5119	361	68	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	361	69	length	length	NOUN
cblr-5119	361	70	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	361	71	its	its	PRON
cblr-5119	361	72	decision	decision	NOUN
cblr-5119	361	73	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	362	1	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	362	2	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	362	3	framed	frame	VERB
cblr-5119	362	4	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	362	5	inquiry	inquiry	NOUN
cblr-5119	362	6	as	as	ADP
cblr-5119	362	7	requiring	require	VERB
cblr-5119	362	8	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	362	9	factbased	factbased	ADJ
cblr-5119	362	10	analysis	analysis	NOUN
cblr-5119	362	11	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	362	12	determine	determine	VERB
cblr-5119	362	13	whether	whether	SCONJ
cblr-5119	362	14	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	362	15	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
cblr-5119	362	16	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	362	17	claim	claim	NOUN
cblr-5119	362	18	as	as	ADP
cblr-5119	362	19	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	362	20	whole	whole	NOUN
cblr-5119	362	21	touched	touch	VERB
cblr-5119	362	22	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	362	23	concerned	concern	VERB
cblr-5119	362	24	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	362	25	united	united	PROPN
cblr-5119	362	26	states	states	PROPN
cblr-5119	362	27	with	with	ADP
cblr-5119	362	28	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
cblr-5119	362	29	force	force	NOUN
cblr-5119	362	30	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	362	31	displace	displace	VERB
cblr-5119	362	32	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	362	33	presumption	presumption	NOUN
cblr-5119	362	34	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	362	35	pointing	point	VERB
cblr-5119	362	36	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	362	37	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	362	38	supreme	supreme	PROPN
cblr-5119	362	39	court	court	PROPN
cblr-5119	362	40	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	362	41	specific	specific	ADJ
cblr-5119	362	42	use	use	NOUN
cblr-5119	362	43	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	362	44	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	362	45	term	term	NOUN
cblr-5119	362	46	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	362	47	claim	claim	NOUN
cblr-5119	362	48	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	362	49	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	362	50	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	362	51	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	362	52	merely	merely	ADV
cblr-5119	362	53	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	362	54	conduct	conduct	VERB
cblr-5119	362	55	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	362	56	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	362	57	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	362	58	kiobel	kiobel	PROPN
cblr-5119	362	59	ii.129	ii.129	PROPN
cblr-5119	362	60	this	this	PRON
cblr-5119	362	61	would	would	AUX
cblr-5119	362	62	include	include	VERB
cblr-5119	362	63	an	an	DET
cblr-5119	362	64	examination	examination	NOUN
cblr-5119	362	65	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	362	66	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	362	67	all	all	DET
cblr-5119	362	68	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	362	69	facts	fact	NOUN
cblr-5119	362	70	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	362	71	associated	associate	VERB
cblr-5119	362	72	with	with	ADP
cblr-5119	362	73	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	362	74	claim	claim	NOUN
cblr-5119	362	75	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	362	76	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	362	77	including	include	VERB
cblr-5119	362	78	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	362	79	parties	party	NOUN
cblr-5119	362	80	’	’	PART
cblr-5119	362	81	identities	identity	NOUN
cblr-5119	362	82	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	362	83	their	their	PRON
cblr-5119	362	84	relationship	relationship	NOUN
cblr-5119	362	85	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	362	86	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	362	87	causes	cause	NOUN
cblr-5119	362	88	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	362	89	action	action	NOUN
cblr-5119	362	90	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	362	91	”130	”130	PROPN
cblr-5119	363	1	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	363	2	key	key	ADJ
cblr-5119	363	3	consequence	consequence	NOUN
cblr-5119	363	4	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	363	5	this	this	DET
cblr-5119	363	6	principle	principle	NOUN
cblr-5119	363	7	is	be	AUX
cblr-5119	363	8	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	363	9	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	363	10	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	363	11	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	363	12	inquiry	inquiry	NOUN
cblr-5119	363	13	goes	go	VERB
cblr-5119	363	14	beyond	beyond	ADP
cblr-5119	363	15	mere	mere	ADJ
cblr-5119	363	16	tortious	tortious	ADJ
cblr-5119	363	17	conduct	conduct	NOUN
cblr-5119	363	18	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	364	1	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	364	2	other	other	ADJ
cblr-5119	364	3	words	word	NOUN
cblr-5119	364	4	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	364	5	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	364	6	conduct	conduct	NOUN
cblr-5119	364	7	constituting	constitute	VERB
cblr-5119	364	8	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	364	9	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	364	10	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	364	11	nations	nation	NOUN
cblr-5119	364	12	violation	violation	NOUN
cblr-5119	364	13	need	need	AUX
cblr-5119	364	14	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	364	15	occur	occur	VERB
cblr-5119	364	16	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	364	17	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	364	18	united	united	PROPN
cblr-5119	364	19	states	states	PROPN
cblr-5119	364	20	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	364	21	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	364	22	presumption	presumption	NOUN
cblr-5119	364	23	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	364	24	be	be	AUX
cblr-5119	364	25	displaced	displace	VERB
cblr-5119	364	26	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	364	27	as	as	ADV
cblr-5119	364	28	long	long	ADV
cblr-5119	364	29	as	as	SCONJ
cblr-5119	364	30	there	there	PRON
cblr-5119	364	31	were	be	VERB
cblr-5119	364	32	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
cblr-5119	364	33	connections	connection	NOUN
cblr-5119	364	34	among	among	ADP
cblr-5119	364	35	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	364	36	defendant	defendant	NOUN
cblr-5119	364	37	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	364	38	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	364	39	alleged	allege	VERB
cblr-5119	364	40	violations	violation	NOUN
cblr-5119	364	41	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	364	42	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	364	43	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	364	44	united	united	PROPN
cblr-5119	364	45	states	states	PROPN
cblr-5119	364	46	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	365	1	this	this	PRON
cblr-5119	365	2	represents	represent	VERB
cblr-5119	365	3	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	365	4	sharp	sharp	ADJ
cblr-5119	365	5	departure	departure	NOUN
cblr-5119	365	6	from	from	ADP
cblr-5119	365	7	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	365	8	other	other	ADJ
cblr-5119	365	9	circuits	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	365	10	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	366	1	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	366	2	defendant	defendant	NOUN
cblr-5119	366	3	claimed	claim	VERB
cblr-5119	366	4	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	366	5	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	366	6	ats	at	NOUN
cblr-5119	366	7	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	366	8	under	under	ADP
cblr-5119	366	9	kiobel	kiobel	PROPN
cblr-5119	366	10	ii	ii	PROPN
cblr-5119	366	11	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	366	12	did	do	AUX
cblr-5119	366	13	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	366	14	cover	cover	VERB
cblr-5119	366	15	cases	case	NOUN
cblr-5119	366	16	where	where	SCONJ
cblr-5119	366	17	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	366	18	alleged	allege	VERB
cblr-5119	366	19	tortious	tortious	ADJ
cblr-5119	366	20	conduct	conduct	NOUN
cblr-5119	366	21	occurred	occur	VERB
cblr-5119	366	22	abroad	abroad	ADV
cblr-5119	366	23	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	366	24	but	but	CCONJ
cblr-5119	366	25	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	366	26	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	366	27	expressly	expressly	ADV
cblr-5119	366	28	rejected	reject	VERB
cblr-5119	366	29	this	this	DET
cblr-5119	366	30	argument.131	argument.131	PROPN
cblr-5119	366	31	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	366	32	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	366	33	reasoned	reason	VERB
cblr-5119	366	34	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	366	35	kiobel	kiobel	PROPN
cblr-5119	366	36	ii	ii	PROPN
cblr-5119	366	37	could	could	AUX
cblr-5119	366	38	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	366	39	stand	stand	VERB
cblr-5119	366	40	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	366	41	that	that	DET
cblr-5119	366	42	proposition	proposition	NOUN
cblr-5119	366	43	because	because	SCONJ
cblr-5119	366	44	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	366	45	concurrence	concurrence	NOUN
cblr-5119	366	46	written	write	VERB
cblr-5119	366	47	by	by	ADP
cblr-5119	366	48	justice	justice	PROPN
cblr-5119	366	49	alito	alito	PROPN
cblr-5119	366	50	took	take	VERB
cblr-5119	366	51	that	that	DET
cblr-5119	366	52	very	very	ADJ
cblr-5119	366	53	position	position	NOUN
cblr-5119	366	54	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	366	55	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	366	56	majority	majority	NOUN
cblr-5119	366	57	expressly	expressly	ADV
cblr-5119	366	58	did	do	AUX
cblr-5119	366	59	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	366	60	defendant	defendant	VERB
cblr-5119	366	61	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	366	62	vice	vice	NOUN
cblr-5119	366	63	president	president	NOUN
cblr-5119	366	64	traveled	travel	VERB
cblr-5119	366	65	regularly	regularly	ADV
cblr-5119	366	66	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	366	67	iraq	iraq	PROPN
cblr-5119	366	68	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	366	69	knew	know	VERB
cblr-5119	366	70	about	about	ADP
cblr-5119	366	71	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	366	72	company	company	NOUN
cblr-5119	366	73	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	366	74	operations	operation	NOUN
cblr-5119	366	75	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	366	76	abu	abu	PROPN
cblr-5119	366	77	ghraib	ghraib	PROPN
cblr-5119	366	78	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	367	1	i	i	PRON
cblr-5119	367	2	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-5119	367	3	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	367	4	522	522	NUM
cblr-5119	367	5	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	368	1	128	128	NUM
cblr-5119	368	2	al	al	PROPN
cblr-5119	368	3	shimari	shimari	PROPN
cblr-5119	368	4	v.	v.	ADP
cblr-5119	368	5	caci	caci	NOUN
cblr-5119	368	6	premier	premier	PROPN
cblr-5119	368	7	tech	tech	PROPN
cblr-5119	368	8	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	368	9	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	368	10	inc	inc	PROPN
cblr-5119	368	11	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	368	12	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	368	13	263	263	NUM
cblr-5119	368	14	f.	f.	PROPN
cblr-5119	368	15	supp	supp	PROPN
cblr-5119	368	16	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	369	1	3d	3d	NUM
cblr-5119	369	2	595	595	NUM
cblr-5119	369	3	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	369	4	599	599	NUM
cblr-5119	369	5	n.4	n.4	SYM
cblr-5119	369	6	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	369	7	e.d	e.d	PROPN
cblr-5119	369	8	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	369	9	va	va	PROPN
cblr-5119	369	10	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	369	11	2017	2017	NUM
cblr-5119	369	12	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	369	13	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	370	1	129	129	NUM
cblr-5119	370	2	al	al	PROPN
cblr-5119	370	3	shimari	shimari	NOUN
cblr-5119	370	4	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	370	5	758	758	NUM
cblr-5119	370	6	f.3d	f.3d	NUM
cblr-5119	370	7	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	370	8	527	527	NUM
cblr-5119	370	9	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	370	10	discussing	discuss	VERB
cblr-5119	370	11	kiobel	kiobel	PROPN
cblr-5119	370	12	v.	v.	ADP
cblr-5119	370	13	royal	royal	PROPN
cblr-5119	370	14	dutch	dutch	PROPN
cblr-5119	370	15	petroleum	petroleum	PROPN
cblr-5119	370	16	co.	co.	PROPN
cblr-5119	370	17	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	370	18	569	569	NUM
cblr-5119	370	19	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	370	20	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	370	21	108	108	NUM
cblr-5119	370	22	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	370	23	124–25	124–25	X
cblr-5119	370	24	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	370	25	2013	2013	NUM
cblr-5119	370	26	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	370	27	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	370	28	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	371	1	130	130	NUM
cblr-5119	372	1	i	i	PRON
cblr-5119	372	2	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-5119	372	3	131	131	NUM
cblr-5119	373	1	i	i	PRON
cblr-5119	373	2	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-5119	373	3	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	373	4	528	528	NUM
cblr-5119	373	5	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	374	1	6_2019.3_estes	6_2019.3_estes	NUM
cblr-5119	374	2	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	374	3	do	do	AUX
cblr-5119	374	4	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	374	5	delte	delte	VERB
cblr-5119	374	6	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	374	7	12/26/2019	12/26/2019	NUM
cblr-5119	374	8	12:00	12:00	NUM
cblr-5119	374	9	am	be	AUX
cblr-5119	375	1	1058	1058	NUM
cblr-5119	375	2	columbia	columbia	PROPN
cblr-5119	375	3	business	business	NOUN
cblr-5119	375	4	law	law	PROPN
cblr-5119	375	5	review	review	NOUN
cblr-5119	375	6	[	[	X
cblr-5119	375	7	vol	vol	NOUN
cblr-5119	375	8	.	.	NOUN
cblr-5119	375	9	2019	2019	NUM
cblr-5119	375	10	adopt	adopt	NOUN
cblr-5119	375	11	it.132	it.132	PROPN
cblr-5119	375	12	instead	instead	ADV
cblr-5119	375	13	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	375	14	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	375	15	close	close	ADJ
cblr-5119	375	16	examination	examination	NOUN
cblr-5119	375	17	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	375	18	all	all	DET
cblr-5119	375	19	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	375	20	facts	fact	NOUN
cblr-5119	375	21	associated	associate	VERB
cblr-5119	375	22	with	with	ADP
cblr-5119	375	23	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	375	24	claim	claim	NOUN
cblr-5119	375	25	could	could	AUX
cblr-5119	375	26	still	still	ADV
cblr-5119	375	27	reveal	reveal	VERB
cblr-5119	375	28	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
cblr-5119	375	29	connections	connection	NOUN
cblr-5119	375	30	with	with	ADP
cblr-5119	375	31	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	375	32	united	united	PROPN
cblr-5119	375	33	states	states	PROPN
cblr-5119	375	34	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	375	35	rebut	rebut	VERB
cblr-5119	375	36	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	375	37	presumption	presumption	NOUN
cblr-5119	375	38	against	against	ADP
cblr-5119	375	39	extraterritoriality	extraterritoriality	NOUN
cblr-5119	375	40	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	375	41	even	even	ADV
cblr-5119	375	42	if	if	SCONJ
cblr-5119	375	43	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	375	44	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	375	45	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	375	46	nations	nation	NOUN
cblr-5119	375	47	violation	violation	NOUN
cblr-5119	375	48	occurred	occur	VERB
cblr-5119	375	49	extraterritorially	extraterritorially	ADV
cblr-5119	375	50	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	376	1	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	376	2	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	376	3	fourth	fourth	ADJ
cblr-5119	376	4	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	376	5	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	376	6	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	376	7	appeals	appeal	NOUN
cblr-5119	376	8	’	'	PUNCT
cblr-5119	376	9	view	view	NOUN
cblr-5119	376	10	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	376	11	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	376	12	mechanically	mechanically	ADV
cblr-5119	376	13	applying	apply	VERB
cblr-5119	376	14	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	376	15	presumption	presumption	NOUN
cblr-5119	376	16	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	376	17	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	377	1	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	378	1	would	would	AUX
cblr-5119	378	2	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	378	3	advance	advance	VERB
cblr-5119	378	4	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	378	5	purposes	purpose	NOUN
cblr-5119	378	6	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	378	7	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	378	8	presumption	presumption	NOUN
cblr-5119	378	9	[	[	X
cblr-5119	378	10	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	378	11	]	]	X
cblr-5119	378	12	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	378	13	which	which	PRON
cblr-5119	378	14	include	include	VERB
cblr-5119	378	15	allowing	allow	VERB
cblr-5119	378	16	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	378	17	extraterritorial	extraterritorial	ADJ
cblr-5119	378	18	application	application	NOUN
cblr-5119	378	19	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	378	20	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	378	21	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	378	22	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	378	23	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	378	24	those	those	DET
cblr-5119	378	25	cases	case	NOUN
cblr-5119	378	26	where	where	SCONJ
cblr-5119	378	27	doing	do	VERB
cblr-5119	378	28	so	so	ADV
cblr-5119	378	29	is	be	AUX
cblr-5119	378	30	appropriate.133	appropriate.133	VERB
cblr-5119	378	31	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	378	32	articulating	articulate	VERB
cblr-5119	378	33	its	its	PRON
cblr-5119	378	34	holistic	holistic	ADJ
cblr-5119	378	35	standard	standard	NOUN
cblr-5119	378	36	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	378	37	rebutting	rebut	VERB
cblr-5119	378	38	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	378	39	presumption	presumption	NOUN
cblr-5119	378	40	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	378	41	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	378	42	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	378	43	also	also	ADV
cblr-5119	378	44	downplayed	downplay	VERB
cblr-5119	378	45	any	any	DET
cblr-5119	378	46	potential	potential	ADJ
cblr-5119	378	47	negative	negative	ADJ
cblr-5119	378	48	foreign	foreign	ADJ
cblr-5119	378	49	policy	policy	NOUN
cblr-5119	378	50	consequences	consequence	NOUN
cblr-5119	378	51	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	379	1	it	it	PRON
cblr-5119	379	2	pointed	point	VERB
cblr-5119	379	3	out	out	ADP
cblr-5119	379	4	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	379	5	all	all	DET
cblr-5119	379	6	defendants	defendant	NOUN
cblr-5119	379	7	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	379	8	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	379	9	present	present	ADJ
cblr-5119	379	10	case	case	NOUN
cblr-5119	379	11	were	be	AUX
cblr-5119	379	12	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	379	13	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	379	14	citizens	citizen	NOUN
cblr-5119	379	15	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	379	16	so	so	SCONJ
cblr-5119	379	17	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	379	18	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	379	19	would	would	AUX
cblr-5119	379	20	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	379	21	have	have	VERB
cblr-5119	379	22	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	379	23	hale	hale	VERB
cblr-5119	379	24	foreign	foreign	ADJ
cblr-5119	379	25	nationals	national	NOUN
cblr-5119	379	26	into	into	ADP
cblr-5119	379	27	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	379	28	united	united	PROPN
cblr-5119	379	29	states.134	states.134	PROPN
cblr-5119	379	30	it	it	PRON
cblr-5119	379	31	also	also	ADV
cblr-5119	379	32	noted	note	VERB
cblr-5119	379	33	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	379	34	it	it	PRON
cblr-5119	379	35	was	be	AUX
cblr-5119	379	36	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	379	37	interfering	interfere	VERB
cblr-5119	379	38	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	379	39	foreign	foreign	ADJ
cblr-5119	379	40	policy	policy	NOUN
cblr-5119	379	41	because	because	SCONJ
cblr-5119	379	42	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	379	43	political	political	ADJ
cblr-5119	379	44	branches	branch	NOUN
cblr-5119	379	45	had	have	AUX
cblr-5119	379	46	made	make	VERB
cblr-5119	379	47	clear	clear	ADJ
cblr-5119	379	48	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	379	49	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	379	50	united	united	PROPN
cblr-5119	379	51	states	states	PROPN
cblr-5119	379	52	did	do	AUX
cblr-5119	379	53	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	379	54	tolerate	tolerate	VERB
cblr-5119	379	55	torture.135	torture.135	NOUN
cblr-5119	379	56	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	379	57	al	al	PROPN
cblr-5119	379	58	shimari	shimari	PROPN
cblr-5119	379	59	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	379	60	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	379	61	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	379	62	ruled	rule	VERB
cblr-5119	379	63	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	379	64	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	379	65	presumption	presumption	NOUN
cblr-5119	379	66	against	against	ADP
cblr-5119	379	67	extraterritoriality	extraterritoriality	NOUN
cblr-5119	379	68	was	be	AUX
cblr-5119	379	69	displaced	displace	VERB
cblr-5119	379	70	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	379	71	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	379	72	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	379	73	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	379	74	thus	thus	ADV
cblr-5119	379	75	had	have	VERB
cblr-5119	379	76	subject	subject	ADJ
cblr-5119	379	77	matter	matter	NOUN
cblr-5119	379	78	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NOUN
cblr-5119	379	79	under	under	ADP
cblr-5119	379	80	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	379	81	ats.136	ats.136	NOUN
cblr-5119	379	82	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	379	83	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	379	84	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	379	85	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	379	86	view	view	NOUN
cblr-5119	379	87	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	379	88	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	379	89	following	follow	VERB
cblr-5119	379	90	facts	fact	NOUN
cblr-5119	379	91	served	serve	VERB
cblr-5119	379	92	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	379	93	touch	touch	VERB
cblr-5119	379	94	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	379	95	concern	concern	NOUN
cblr-5119	379	96	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	379	97	united	united	PROPN
cblr-5119	379	98	states	states	PROPN
cblr-5119	379	99	with	with	ADP
cblr-5119	379	100	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
cblr-5119	379	101	force	force	NOUN
cblr-5119	379	102	:	:	PUNCT
cblr-5119	379	103	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	379	104	defendant	defendant	NOUN
cblr-5119	379	105	corporation	corporation	PROPN
cblr-5119	379	106	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	379	107	its	its	PRON
cblr-5119	379	108	employees	employee	NOUN
cblr-5119	379	109	were	be	AUX
cblr-5119	379	110	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	379	111	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	379	112	citizens	citizen	NOUN
cblr-5119	379	113	;	;	PUNCT
cblr-5119	379	114	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	379	115	defendant	defendant	NOUN
cblr-5119	379	116	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	379	117	contract	contract	NOUN
cblr-5119	379	118	with	with	ADP
cblr-5119	379	119	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	379	120	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	379	121	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	379	122	government	government	NOUN
cblr-5119	379	123	was	be	AUX
cblr-5119	379	124	executed	execute	VERB
cblr-5119	379	125	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	379	126	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	379	127	united	united	PROPN
cblr-5119	379	128	states	states	PROPN
cblr-5119	379	129	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	379	130	required	require	VERB
cblr-5119	379	131	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	379	132	defendant	defendant	NOUN
cblr-5119	379	133	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	379	134	employees	employee	NOUN
cblr-5119	379	135	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	379	136	procure	procure	VERB
cblr-5119	379	137	security	security	NOUN
cblr-5119	379	138	clearances	clearance	NOUN
cblr-5119	379	139	from	from	ADP
cblr-5119	379	140	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	379	141	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	379	142	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	379	143	government	government	NOUN
cblr-5119	379	144	;	;	PUNCT
cblr-5119	379	145	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	379	146	defendant	defendant	NOUN
cblr-5119	379	147	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	379	148	u.s.-based	u.s.-based	ADJ
cblr-5119	379	149	managers	manager	NOUN
cblr-5119	379	150	allegedly	allegedly	ADV
cblr-5119	379	151	tacitly	tacitly	ADV
cblr-5119	379	152	approved	approve	VERB
cblr-5119	379	153	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	379	154	attempted	attempt	VERB
cblr-5119	379	155	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	379	156	cover	cover	VERB
cblr-5119	379	157	up	up	ADP
cblr-5119	379	158	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	379	159	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	379	160	implicitly	implicitly	ADV
cblr-5119	379	161	encouraged	encourage	VERB
cblr-5119	379	162	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	379	163	torture	torture	NOUN
cblr-5119	379	164	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	379	165	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	379	166	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
cblr-5119	379	167	;	;	PUNCT
cblr-5119	379	168	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	379	169	congress	congress	PROPN
cblr-5119	379	170	had	have	AUX
cblr-5119	379	171	made	make	VERB
cblr-5119	379	172	clear	clear	ADJ
cblr-5119	379	173	its	its	PRON
cblr-5119	379	174	intention	intention	NOUN
cblr-5119	379	175	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	379	176	hold	hold	VERB
cblr-5119	379	177	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	379	178	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	379	179	citizens	citizen	NOUN
cblr-5119	379	180	accountable	accountable	ADJ
cblr-5119	379	181	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	379	182	torture	torture	NOUN
cblr-5119	379	183	committed	commit	VERB
cblr-5119	379	184	abroad.137	abroad.137	NOUN
cblr-5119	379	185	while	while	SCONJ
cblr-5119	379	186	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	379	187	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	379	188	did	do	AUX
cblr-5119	379	189	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	379	190	decide	decide	VERB
cblr-5119	379	191	what	what	DET
cblr-5119	379	192	type	type	NOUN
cblr-5119	379	193	or	or	CCONJ
cblr-5119	379	194	number	number	NOUN
cblr-5119	379	195	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	379	196	domestic	domestic	ADJ
cblr-5119	379	197	connections	connection	NOUN
cblr-5119	379	198	would	would	AUX
cblr-5119	379	199	be	be	AUX
cblr-5119	379	200	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
cblr-5119	379	201	going	go	VERB
cblr-5119	379	202	forward	forward	ADV
cblr-5119	379	203	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	379	204	its	its	PRON
cblr-5119	379	205	analysis	analysis	NOUN
cblr-5119	379	206	shows	show	VERB
cblr-5119	379	207	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	379	208	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	379	209	fourth	fourth	ADJ
cblr-5119	379	210	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	379	211	has	have	AUX
cblr-5119	379	212	adopted	adopt	VERB
cblr-5119	379	213	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	379	214	flexible	flexible	ADJ
cblr-5119	379	215	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	379	216	132	132	NUM
cblr-5119	379	217	i	i	PROPN
cblr-5119	379	218	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-5119	379	219	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	379	220	527–28	527–28	PROPN
cblr-5119	379	221	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	380	1	133	133	NUM
cblr-5119	380	2	i	i	PRON
cblr-5119	380	3	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-5119	380	4	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	380	5	529	529	NUM
cblr-5119	380	6	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	381	1	134	134	NUM
cblr-5119	382	1	i	i	PRON
cblr-5119	382	2	d.	d.	NOUN
cblr-5119	382	3	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	382	4	530	530	NUM
cblr-5119	382	5	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	383	1	135	135	NUM
cblr-5119	384	1	i	i	NOUN
cblr-5119	384	2	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-5119	384	3	136	136	NUM
cblr-5119	385	1	i	i	PRON
cblr-5119	385	2	d.	d.	VERB
cblr-5119	385	3	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	385	4	530–31	530–31	PROPN
cblr-5119	385	5	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	386	1	137	137	NUM
cblr-5119	387	1	i	i	PROPN
cblr-5119	387	2	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-5119	387	3	6_2019.3_estes	6_2019.3_estes	NUM
cblr-5119	387	4	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	387	5	do	do	AUX
cblr-5119	387	6	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	387	7	delete	delete	VERB
cblr-5119	387	8	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	387	9	12/26/2019	12/26/2019	NUM
cblr-5119	387	10	12:00	12:00	NUM
cblr-5119	387	11	am	be	AUX
cblr-5119	387	12	no	no	NOUN
cblr-5119	387	13	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	388	1	3:1031	3:1031	NUM
cblr-5119	388	2	]	]	X
cblr-5119	388	3	may	may	AUX
cblr-5119	388	4	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	388	5	fourth	fourth	ADJ
cblr-5119	388	6	be	be	AUX
cblr-5119	388	7	with	with	ADP
cblr-5119	388	8	you	you	PRON
cblr-5119	388	9	1059	1059	NUM
cblr-5119	388	10	fact	fact	NOUN
cblr-5119	388	11	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-5119	388	12	based	base	VERB
cblr-5119	388	13	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	388	14	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	388	15	thus	thus	ADV
cblr-5119	388	16	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	388	17	relatively	relatively	ADV
cblr-5119	388	18	liberal	liberal	ADJ
cblr-5119	388	19	regime	regime	NOUN
cblr-5119	388	20	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	388	21	displacing	displace	VERB
cblr-5119	388	22	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	388	23	presumption	presumption	NOUN
cblr-5119	388	24	against	against	ADP
cblr-5119	388	25	extraterritoriality	extraterritoriality	NOUN
cblr-5119	388	26	under	under	ADP
cblr-5119	388	27	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	388	28	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	388	29	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	389	1	early	early	ADJ
cblr-5119	389	2	indications	indication	NOUN
cblr-5119	389	3	are	be	AUX
cblr-5119	389	4	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	389	5	jesner	jesner	NOUN
cblr-5119	389	6	will	will	AUX
cblr-5119	389	7	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	389	8	alter	alter	VERB
cblr-5119	389	9	that	that	DET
cblr-5119	389	10	regime	regime	NOUN
cblr-5119	389	11	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	390	1	after	after	ADP
cblr-5119	390	2	jesner	jesner	PROPN
cblr-5119	390	3	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	390	4	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	390	5	district	district	NOUN
cblr-5119	390	6	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	390	7	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	390	8	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	390	9	eastern	eastern	ADJ
cblr-5119	390	10	district	district	PROPN
cblr-5119	390	11	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	390	12	virginia	virginia	PROPN
cblr-5119	390	13	rejected	reject	VERB
cblr-5119	390	14	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	390	15	al	al	PROPN
cblr-5119	390	16	shimari	shimari	PROPN
cblr-5119	390	17	defendants	defendant	NOUN
cblr-5119	390	18	’	'	PUNCT
cblr-5119	390	19	argument	argument	NOUN
cblr-5119	390	20	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	390	21	allowing	allow	VERB
cblr-5119	390	22	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	390	23	litigation	litigation	NOUN
cblr-5119	390	24	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	390	25	proceed	proceed	VERB
cblr-5119	390	26	would	would	AUX
cblr-5119	390	27	result	result	VERB
cblr-5119	390	28	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	390	29	improper	improper	ADJ
cblr-5119	390	30	judicial	judicial	ADJ
cblr-5119	390	31	interference	interference	NOUN
cblr-5119	390	32	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	390	33	foreign	foreign	ADJ
cblr-5119	390	34	policy.138	policy.138	PROPN
cblr-5119	390	35	it	it	PRON
cblr-5119	390	36	relied	rely	VERB
cblr-5119	390	37	on	on	ADP
cblr-5119	390	38	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	390	39	fourth	fourth	ADJ
cblr-5119	390	40	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	390	41	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	390	42	reasoning	reasoning	NOUN
cblr-5119	390	43	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	390	44	its	its	PRON
cblr-5119	390	45	2014	2014	NUM
cblr-5119	390	46	decision	decision	NOUN
cblr-5119	390	47	referenced	reference	VERB
cblr-5119	390	48	above	above	ADV
cblr-5119	390	49	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	390	50	stated	state	VERB
cblr-5119	390	51	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	390	52	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	390	53	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
cblr-5119	390	54	’	’	PART
cblr-5119	390	55	suit	suit	NOUN
cblr-5119	390	56	was	be	AUX
cblr-5119	390	57	consistent	consistent	ADJ
cblr-5119	390	58	with	with	ADP
cblr-5119	390	59	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	390	60	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	390	61	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	390	62	purpose	purpose	NOUN
cblr-5119	390	63	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	390	64	providing	provide	VERB
cblr-5119	390	65	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	390	66	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	390	67	federal	federal	ADJ
cblr-5119	390	68	forum	forum	NOUN
cblr-5119	390	69	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	390	70	tort	tort	NOUN
cblr-5119	390	71	suits	suit	NOUN
cblr-5119	390	72	by	by	ADP
cblr-5119	390	73	aliens	alien	NOUN
cblr-5119	390	74	against	against	ADP
cblr-5119	390	75	americans	americans	PROPN
cblr-5119	390	76	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	390	77	international	international	ADJ
cblr-5119	390	78	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	390	79	violations	violation	NOUN
cblr-5119	390	80	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	390	81	”139	”139	PUNCT
cblr-5119	391	1	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	391	2	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	391	3	explicitly	explicitly	ADV
cblr-5119	391	4	distinguished	distinguish	VERB
cblr-5119	391	5	jesner	jesner	PROPN
cblr-5119	391	6	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	391	7	reasoning	reason	VERB
cblr-5119	391	8	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	391	9	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	391	10	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	391	11	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	391	12	concerns	concern	NOUN
cblr-5119	391	13	there	there	ADV
cblr-5119	391	14	stemmed	stem	VERB
cblr-5119	391	15	from	from	ADP
cblr-5119	391	16	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	391	17	fact	fact	NOUN
cblr-5119	391	18	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	391	19	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	391	20	defendant	defendant	NOUN
cblr-5119	391	21	was	be	AUX
cblr-5119	391	22	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	391	23	foreign	foreign	ADJ
cblr-5119	391	24	corporation	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	391	25	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	391	26	which	which	PRON
cblr-5119	391	27	is	be	AUX
cblr-5119	391	28	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	391	29	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	391	30	case	case	NOUN
cblr-5119	391	31	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	391	32	al	al	PROPN
cblr-5119	391	33	shimari.140	shimari.140	PROPN
cblr-5119	391	34	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	391	35	district	district	NOUN
cblr-5119	391	36	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	391	37	could	could	AUX
cblr-5119	391	38	have	have	AUX
cblr-5119	391	39	read	read	VERB
cblr-5119	391	40	jesner	jesner	NOUN
cblr-5119	391	41	as	as	ADP
cblr-5119	391	42	requiring	require	VERB
cblr-5119	391	43	caution	caution	NOUN
cblr-5119	391	44	before	before	ADP
cblr-5119	391	45	exercising	exercise	VERB
cblr-5119	391	46	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	391	47	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NOUN
cblr-5119	391	48	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	391	49	general	general	ADJ
cblr-5119	391	50	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	392	1	instead	instead	ADV
cblr-5119	392	2	it	it	PRON
cblr-5119	392	3	chose	choose	VERB
cblr-5119	392	4	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	392	5	narrow	narrow	ADJ
cblr-5119	392	6	reading	reading	NOUN
cblr-5119	392	7	largely	largely	ADV
cblr-5119	392	8	cabining	cabin	VERB
cblr-5119	392	9	jesner	jesner	PROPN
cblr-5119	392	10	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	392	11	analysis	analysis	NOUN
cblr-5119	392	12	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	392	13	foreign	foreign	ADJ
cblr-5119	392	14	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	392	15	defendants	defendant	NOUN
cblr-5119	392	16	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	392	17	potentially	potentially	ADV
cblr-5119	392	18	signaling	signal	VERB
cblr-5119	392	19	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	392	20	it	it	PRON
cblr-5119	392	21	will	will	AUX
cblr-5119	392	22	take	take	VERB
cblr-5119	392	23	another	another	DET
cblr-5119	392	24	adverse	adverse	ADJ
cblr-5119	392	25	supreme	supreme	PROPN
cblr-5119	392	26	court	court	PROPN
cblr-5119	392	27	decision	decision	NOUN
cblr-5119	392	28	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	392	29	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	392	30	fourth	fourth	ADJ
cblr-5119	392	31	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	392	32	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	392	33	modify	modify	VERB
cblr-5119	392	34	its	its	PRON
cblr-5119	392	35	approach	approach	NOUN
cblr-5119	392	36	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	392	37	even	even	ADV
cblr-5119	392	38	as	as	SCONJ
cblr-5119	392	39	other	other	ADJ
cblr-5119	392	40	circuits	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	392	41	may	may	AUX
cblr-5119	392	42	come	come	VERB
cblr-5119	392	43	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	392	44	see	see	VERB
cblr-5119	392	45	jesner	jesner	NOUN
cblr-5119	392	46	differently	differently	ADV
cblr-5119	392	47	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	393	1	this	this	PRON
cblr-5119	393	2	all	all	PRON
cblr-5119	393	3	leaves	leave	VERB
cblr-5119	393	4	no	no	DET
cblr-5119	393	5	reason	reason	NOUN
cblr-5119	393	6	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	393	7	believe	believe	VERB
cblr-5119	393	8	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	393	9	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	393	10	fourth	fourth	ADJ
cblr-5119	393	11	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	393	12	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	393	13	flexible	flexible	ADJ
cblr-5119	393	14	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	393	15	regime	regime	NOUN
cblr-5119	393	16	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	393	17	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	393	18	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	393	19	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	393	20	will	will	AUX
cblr-5119	393	21	be	be	AUX
cblr-5119	393	22	affected	affect	VERB
cblr-5119	393	23	by	by	ADP
cblr-5119	393	24	jesner	jesner	PROPN
cblr-5119	393	25	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	394	1	c.	c.	PROPN
cblr-5119	394	2	ninth	ninth	ADJ
cblr-5119	394	3	circuit	circuit	PROPN
cblr-5119	394	4	:	:	PUNCT
cblr-5119	394	5	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	394	6	semi	semi	ADJ
cblr-5119	394	7	-	-	ADJ
cblr-5119	394	8	restrictive	restrictive	ADJ
cblr-5119	394	9	conduct	conduct	NOUN
cblr-5119	394	10	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-5119	394	11	based	base	VERB
cblr-5119	394	12	approach	approach	NOUN
cblr-5119	394	13	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	394	14	ninth	ninth	ADJ
cblr-5119	394	15	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	394	16	has	have	AUX
cblr-5119	394	17	taken	take	VERB
cblr-5119	394	18	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	394	19	unique	unique	ADJ
cblr-5119	394	20	approach	approach	NOUN
cblr-5119	394	21	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	394	22	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	394	23	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	394	24	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	394	25	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	394	26	semi	semi	ADJ
cblr-5119	394	27	-	-	ADJ
cblr-5119	394	28	restrictive	restrictive	ADJ
cblr-5119	394	29	approach	approach	NOUN
cblr-5119	394	30	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	394	31	displacing	displace	VERB
cblr-5119	394	32	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	394	33	presumption	presumption	NOUN
cblr-5119	394	34	against	against	ADP
cblr-5119	394	35	extraterritoriality	extraterritoriality	NOUN
cblr-5119	394	36	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	395	1	regarding	regard	VERB
cblr-5119	395	2	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	395	3	former	former	ADJ
cblr-5119	395	4	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	395	5	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	395	6	ninth	ninth	ADJ
cblr-5119	395	7	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	395	8	court	court	PROPN
cblr-5119	395	9	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	395	10	appeals	appeals	PROPN
cblr-5119	395	11	adopted	adopt	VERB
cblr-5119	395	12	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	395	13	norm	norm	NOUN
cblr-5119	395	14	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-5119	395	15	by	by	ADP
cblr-5119	395	16	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-5119	395	17	norm	norm	NOUN
cblr-5119	395	18	approach	approach	NOUN
cblr-5119	395	19	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	395	20	sarei	sarei	PROPN
cblr-5119	395	21	v.	v.	PROPN
cblr-5119	395	22	rio	rio	PROPN
cblr-5119	395	23	tinto	tinto	PROPN
cblr-5119	395	24	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	395	25	plc	plc	PROPN
cblr-5119	395	26	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	396	1	under	under	ADP
cblr-5119	396	2	this	this	DET
cblr-5119	396	3	view	view	NOUN
cblr-5119	396	4	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	396	5	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	396	6	each	each	DET
cblr-5119	396	7	substantive	substantive	ADJ
cblr-5119	396	8	offense	offense	NOUN
cblr-5119	396	9	raised	raise	VERB
cblr-5119	396	10	under	under	ADP
cblr-5119	396	11	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	396	12	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	396	13	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	396	14	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	396	15	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	396	16	must	must	AUX
cblr-5119	396	17	examine	examine	VERB
cblr-5119	396	18	international	international	ADJ
cblr-5119	396	19	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	396	20	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	396	21	determine	determine	VERB
cblr-5119	396	22	whether	whether	SCONJ
cblr-5119	396	23	that	that	DET
cblr-5119	396	24	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	396	25	can	can	AUX
cblr-5119	396	26	hold	hold	VERB
cblr-5119	396	27	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	396	28	liable	liable	ADJ
cblr-5119	396	29	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	396	30	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	396	31	specific	specific	ADJ
cblr-5119	396	32	138	138	NUM
cblr-5119	396	33	al	al	PROPN
cblr-5119	396	34	shimari	shimari	PROPN
cblr-5119	396	35	v.	v.	ADP
cblr-5119	396	36	caci	caci	NOUN
cblr-5119	396	37	premier	premier	PROPN
cblr-5119	396	38	tech	tech	PROPN
cblr-5119	396	39	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	396	40	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	396	41	inc	inc	PROPN
cblr-5119	396	42	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	396	43	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	396	44	320	320	NUM
cblr-5119	396	45	f.	f.	PROPN
cblr-5119	396	46	supp	supp	PROPN
cblr-5119	396	47	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	397	1	3d	3d	PROPN
cblr-5119	397	2	781	781	NUM
cblr-5119	397	3	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	397	4	785	785	NUM
cblr-5119	397	5	–	–	PUNCT
cblr-5119	397	6	86	86	NUM
cblr-5119	397	7	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	397	8	e.d	e.d	PROPN
cblr-5119	397	9	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	397	10	va	va	PROPN
cblr-5119	397	11	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	397	12	2018	2018	NUM
cblr-5119	397	13	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	397	14	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	398	1	139	139	NUM
cblr-5119	399	1	i	i	PRON
cblr-5119	399	2	d.	d.	NOUN
cblr-5119	399	3	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	399	4	785	785	NUM
cblr-5119	399	5	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	399	6	787	787	NUM
cblr-5119	399	7	.	.	X
cblr-5119	400	1	140	140	NUM
cblr-5119	400	2	i	i	PRON
cblr-5119	400	3	d.	d.	VERB
cblr-5119	400	4	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	400	5	787–88	787–88	NUM
cblr-5119	400	6	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	401	1	6_2019.3_estes	6_2019.3_estes	NUM
cblr-5119	401	2	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	401	3	do	do	AUX
cblr-5119	401	4	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	401	5	delte	delte	VERB
cblr-5119	401	6	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	401	7	12/26/2019	12/26/2019	NUM
cblr-5119	401	8	12:00	12:00	NUM
cblr-5119	401	9	am	am	NOUN
cblr-5119	401	10	1060	1060	NUM
cblr-5119	401	11	columbia	columbia	PROPN
cblr-5119	401	12	business	business	NOUN
cblr-5119	401	13	law	law	PROPN
cblr-5119	401	14	review	review	NOUN
cblr-5119	401	15	[	[	X
cblr-5119	401	16	vol	vol	NOUN
cblr-5119	401	17	.	.	NOUN
cblr-5119	401	18	2019	2019	NUM
cblr-5119	401	19	offense.141	offense.141	NOUN
cblr-5119	401	20	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	401	21	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	401	22	based	base	VERB
cblr-5119	401	23	its	its	PRON
cblr-5119	401	24	analysis	analysis	NOUN
cblr-5119	401	25	on	on	ADP
cblr-5119	401	26	its	its	PRON
cblr-5119	401	27	interpretation	interpretation	NOUN
cblr-5119	401	28	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	401	29	sosa	sosa	PROPN
cblr-5119	401	30	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	401	31	footnote	footnote	VERB
cblr-5119	401	32	20	20	NUM
cblr-5119	401	33	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	401	34	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	401	35	it	it	PRON
cblr-5119	401	36	effectively	effectively	ADV
cblr-5119	401	37	represents	represent	VERB
cblr-5119	401	38	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	401	39	middle	middle	ADJ
cblr-5119	401	40	approach	approach	NOUN
cblr-5119	401	41	between	between	ADP
cblr-5119	401	42	judge	judge	PROPN
cblr-5119	401	43	cabranes	cabrane	NOUN
cblr-5119	401	44	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	401	45	position	position	NOUN
cblr-5119	401	46	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	401	47	judge	judge	PROPN
cblr-5119	401	48	leval	leval	PROPN
cblr-5119	401	49	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	401	50	position	position	NOUN
cblr-5119	401	51	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	401	52	kiobel	kiobel	PROPN
cblr-5119	401	53	i.	i.	PROPN
cblr-5119	401	54	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	401	55	ninth	ninth	ADJ
cblr-5119	401	56	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	401	57	identified	identify	VERB
cblr-5119	401	58	three	three	NUM
cblr-5119	401	59	distinct	distinct	ADJ
cblr-5119	401	60	categories	category	NOUN
cblr-5119	401	61	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	401	62	would	would	AUX
cblr-5119	401	63	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-5119	401	64	be	be	AUX
cblr-5119	401	65	violators	violator	NOUN
cblr-5119	401	66	:	:	PUNCT
cblr-5119	401	67	state	state	NOUN
cblr-5119	401	68	actors	actor	NOUN
cblr-5119	401	69	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	401	70	private	private	ADJ
cblr-5119	401	71	individuals	individual	NOUN
cblr-5119	401	72	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	401	73	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	401	74	private	private	ADJ
cblr-5119	401	75	groups	group	NOUN
cblr-5119	401	76	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	402	1	theoretically	theoretically	ADV
cblr-5119	402	2	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	402	3	there	there	PRON
cblr-5119	402	4	are	be	VERB
cblr-5119	402	5	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	402	6	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	402	7	nations	nation	NOUN
cblr-5119	402	8	violations	violation	NOUN
cblr-5119	402	9	under	under	ADP
cblr-5119	402	10	which	which	PRON
cblr-5119	402	11	state	state	NOUN
cblr-5119	402	12	actors	actor	NOUN
cblr-5119	402	13	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	402	14	private	private	ADJ
cblr-5119	402	15	individuals	individual	NOUN
cblr-5119	402	16	can	can	AUX
cblr-5119	402	17	be	be	AUX
cblr-5119	402	18	liable	liable	ADJ
cblr-5119	402	19	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	402	20	but	but	CCONJ
cblr-5119	402	21	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	402	22	can	can	AUX
cblr-5119	402	23	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	402	24	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	403	1	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	403	2	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	403	3	pointed	point	VERB
cblr-5119	403	4	out	out	ADP
cblr-5119	403	5	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	403	6	though	though	ADV
cblr-5119	403	7	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	403	8	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	403	9	there	there	PRON
cblr-5119	403	10	are	be	VERB
cblr-5119	403	11	also	also	ADV
cblr-5119	403	12	substantive	substantive	ADJ
cblr-5119	403	13	international	international	ADJ
cblr-5119	403	14	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	403	15	norms	norm	NOUN
cblr-5119	403	16	that	that	PRON
cblr-5119	403	17	are	be	AUX
cblr-5119	403	18	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	403	19	universal	universal	ADJ
cblr-5119	403	20	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	403	21	absolute	absolute	ADJ
cblr-5119	403	22	[	[	X
cblr-5119	403	23	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	403	24	]	]	X
cblr-5119	403	25	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	403	26	meaning	mean	VERB
cblr-5119	403	27	they	they	PRON
cblr-5119	403	28	apply	apply	VERB
cblr-5119	403	29	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	403	30	all	all	DET
cblr-5119	403	31	actors	actor	NOUN
cblr-5119	403	32	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	403	33	including	include	VERB
cblr-5119	403	34	corporations.142	corporations.142	PRON
cblr-5119	403	35	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	403	36	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	403	37	also	also	ADV
cblr-5119	403	38	stated	state	VERB
cblr-5119	403	39	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	403	40	international	international	ADJ
cblr-5119	403	41	precedent	precedent	NOUN
cblr-5119	403	42	enforcing	enforce	VERB
cblr-5119	403	43	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	403	44	norm	norm	NOUN
cblr-5119	403	45	against	against	ADP
cblr-5119	403	46	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	403	47	need	need	AUX
cblr-5119	403	48	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	403	49	exist	exist	VERB
cblr-5119	403	50	for	for	SCONJ
cblr-5119	403	51	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	403	52	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	403	53	be	be	AUX
cblr-5119	403	54	liable	liable	ADJ
cblr-5119	403	55	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	403	56	that	that	DET
cblr-5119	403	57	norm	norm	NOUN
cblr-5119	403	58	under	under	ADP
cblr-5119	403	59	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	403	60	ats,143	ats,143	NOUN
cblr-5119	403	61	thus	thus	ADV
cblr-5119	403	62	refuting	refute	VERB
cblr-5119	403	63	judge	judge	NOUN
cblr-5119	403	64	cabranes	cabrane	NOUN
cblr-5119	403	65	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	403	66	reasoning	reasoning	NOUN
cblr-5119	403	67	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	403	68	kiobel	kiobel	PROPN
cblr-5119	403	69	i.	i.	PROPN
cblr-5119	403	70	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	403	71	ninth	ninth	ADJ
cblr-5119	403	72	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	403	73	court	court	PROPN
cblr-5119	403	74	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	403	75	appeals	appeals	PROPN
cblr-5119	403	76	reaffirmed	reaffirm	VERB
cblr-5119	403	77	these	these	DET
cblr-5119	403	78	principles	principle	NOUN
cblr-5119	403	79	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	403	80	doe	doe	NOUN
cblr-5119	403	81	i	i	PROPN
cblr-5119	403	82	v.	v.	PROPN
cblr-5119	403	83	nestle	nestle	PROPN
cblr-5119	403	84	usa	usa	PROPN
cblr-5119	403	85	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	403	86	inc	inc	PROPN
cblr-5119	403	87	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	404	1	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	404	2	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	404	3	nestle	nestle	PROPN
cblr-5119	404	4	i	i	NOUN
cblr-5119	404	5	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	404	6	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	404	7	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	404	8	which	which	PRON
cblr-5119	404	9	was	be	AUX
cblr-5119	404	10	decided	decide	VERB
cblr-5119	404	11	after	after	ADP
cblr-5119	404	12	kiobel	kiobel	PROPN
cblr-5119	404	13	ii	ii	PROPN
cblr-5119	404	14	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	404	15	144	144	NUM
cblr-5119	404	16	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	404	17	that	that	DET
cblr-5119	404	18	case	case	NOUN
cblr-5119	404	19	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	404	20	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	404	21	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	404	22	clarified	clarify	VERB
cblr-5119	404	23	its	its	PRON
cblr-5119	404	24	view	view	NOUN
cblr-5119	404	25	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	404	26	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	404	27	sources	source	NOUN
cblr-5119	404	28	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	404	29	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	404	30	that	that	PRON
cblr-5119	404	31	control	control	VERB
cblr-5119	404	32	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	404	33	issue	issue	NOUN
cblr-5119	404	34	:	:	PUNCT
cblr-5119	404	35	international	international	ADJ
cblr-5119	404	36	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	404	37	controls	control	VERB
cblr-5119	404	38	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	404	39	nature	nature	NOUN
cblr-5119	404	40	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	404	41	scope	scope	NOUN
cblr-5119	404	42	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	404	43	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	404	44	substantive	substantive	ADJ
cblr-5119	404	45	norm	norm	NOUN
cblr-5119	404	46	underlying	underlie	VERB
cblr-5119	404	47	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	404	48	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
cblr-5119	404	49	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	404	50	claim	claim	NOUN
cblr-5119	404	51	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	404	52	while	while	SCONJ
cblr-5119	404	53	domestic	domestic	ADJ
cblr-5119	404	54	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	404	55	controls	control	VERB
cblr-5119	404	56	specific	specific	ADJ
cblr-5119	404	57	questions	question	NOUN
cblr-5119	404	58	relating	relate	VERB
cblr-5119	404	59	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	404	60	recovery	recovery	NOUN
cblr-5119	404	61	from	from	ADP
cblr-5119	404	62	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	404	63	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	404	64	defendant.145	defendant.145	NOUN
cblr-5119	404	65	applying	apply	VERB
cblr-5119	404	66	its	its	PRON
cblr-5119	404	67	approach	approach	NOUN
cblr-5119	404	68	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	404	69	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	404	70	norms	norm	NOUN
cblr-5119	404	71	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	404	72	issue	issue	NOUN
cblr-5119	404	73	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	404	74	these	these	DET
cblr-5119	404	75	two	two	NUM
cblr-5119	404	76	cases	case	NOUN
cblr-5119	404	77	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	404	78	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	404	79	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	404	80	ruled	rule	VERB
cblr-5119	404	81	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	404	82	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	404	83	were	be	AUX
cblr-5119	404	84	liable	liable	ADJ
cblr-5119	404	85	under	under	ADP
cblr-5119	404	86	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	404	87	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	404	88	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	404	89	genocide	genocide	NOUN
cblr-5119	404	90	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	404	91	war	war	NOUN
cblr-5119	404	92	crimes,146	crimes,146	NOUN
cblr-5119	404	93	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	404	94	slavery.147	slavery.147	PROPN
cblr-5119	404	95	regarding	regard	VERB
cblr-5119	404	96	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	404	97	first	first	ADJ
cblr-5119	404	98	two	two	NUM
cblr-5119	404	99	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	404	100	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	404	101	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	404	102	found	find	VERB
cblr-5119	404	103	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	404	104	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	404	105	applicability	applicability	NOUN
cblr-5119	404	106	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	404	107	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	404	108	norms	norm	NOUN
cblr-5119	404	109	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	404	110	genocide	genocide	NOUN
cblr-5119	404	111	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	404	112	war	war	NOUN
cblr-5119	404	113	crimes	crime	NOUN
cblr-5119	404	114	turns	turn	VERB
cblr-5119	404	115	on	on	ADP
cblr-5119	404	116	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	404	117	identity	identity	NOUN
cblr-5119	404	118	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	404	119	victims	victim	NOUN
cblr-5119	404	120	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	404	121	meaning	mean	VERB
cblr-5119	404	122	all	all	DET
cblr-5119	404	123	types	type	NOUN
cblr-5119	404	124	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	404	125	perpetrators	perpetrator	NOUN
cblr-5119	404	126	are	be	AUX
cblr-5119	404	127	cognizable	cognizable	ADJ
cblr-5119	404	128	141	141	NUM
cblr-5119	404	129	sarei	sarei	NOUN
cblr-5119	404	130	v.	v.	PROPN
cblr-5119	404	131	rio	rio	PROPN
cblr-5119	404	132	tinto	tinto	PROPN
cblr-5119	404	133	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	404	134	plc	plc	PROPN
cblr-5119	404	135	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	404	136	671	671	NUM
cblr-5119	404	137	f.3d	f.3d	NUM
cblr-5119	404	138	736	736	NUM
cblr-5119	404	139	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	404	140	747–48	747–48	NUM
cblr-5119	404	141	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	404	142	9th	9th	ADJ
cblr-5119	404	143	cir	cir	NOUN
cblr-5119	404	144	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	404	145	2011	2011	NUM
cblr-5119	404	146	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	404	147	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	404	148	judgment	judgment	NOUN
cblr-5119	404	149	vacated	vacate	VERB
cblr-5119	404	150	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	404	151	569	569	NUM
cblr-5119	404	152	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	404	153	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	404	154	945	945	NUM
cblr-5119	404	155	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	404	156	2013	2013	NUM
cblr-5119	404	157	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	404	158	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	405	1	142	142	NUM
cblr-5119	406	1	i	i	PRON
cblr-5119	406	2	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-5119	406	3	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	406	4	759–60	759–60	PROPN
cblr-5119	406	5	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	407	1	143	143	NUM
cblr-5119	408	1	i	i	PRON
cblr-5119	408	2	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-5119	408	3	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	408	4	760–61	760–61	NUM
cblr-5119	408	5	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	409	1	144	144	NUM
cblr-5119	409	2	doe	doe	NOUN
cblr-5119	409	3	i	i	PRON
cblr-5119	409	4	v.	v.	PROPN
cblr-5119	409	5	nestle	nestle	PROPN
cblr-5119	409	6	usa	usa	PROPN
cblr-5119	409	7	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	409	8	inc	inc	PROPN
cblr-5119	409	9	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	409	10	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	409	11	nestle	nestle	PROPN
cblr-5119	409	12	i	i	PROPN
cblr-5119	409	13	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	409	14	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	409	15	766	766	NUM
cblr-5119	409	16	f.3d	f.3d	NUM
cblr-5119	409	17	1013	1013	NUM
cblr-5119	409	18	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	409	19	1022	1022	NUM
cblr-5119	409	20	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	409	21	9th	9th	ADJ
cblr-5119	409	22	cir	cir	NOUN
cblr-5119	409	23	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	409	24	2014	2014	NUM
cblr-5119	409	25	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	409	26	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	410	1	145	145	NUM
cblr-5119	411	1	i	i	PRON
cblr-5119	411	2	d.	d.	NOUN
cblr-5119	411	3	146	146	NUM
cblr-5119	411	4	sarei	sarei	NOUN
cblr-5119	411	5	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	411	6	671	671	NUM
cblr-5119	411	7	f.3d	f.3d	NUM
cblr-5119	411	8	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	411	9	760	760	NUM
cblr-5119	411	10	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	411	11	765	765	NUM
cblr-5119	411	12	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	412	1	147	147	NUM
cblr-5119	412	2	nestle	nestle	PROPN
cblr-5119	412	3	i	i	PRON
cblr-5119	412	4	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	412	5	766	766	NUM
cblr-5119	412	6	f.3d	f.3d	NUM
cblr-5119	412	7	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	412	8	1022	1022	NUM
cblr-5119	412	9	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	413	1	6_2019.3_estes	6_2019.3_estes	NUM
cblr-5119	413	2	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	413	3	do	do	AUX
cblr-5119	413	4	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	413	5	delete	delete	VERB
cblr-5119	413	6	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	413	7	12/26/2019	12/26/2019	NUM
cblr-5119	413	8	12:00	12:00	NUM
cblr-5119	413	9	am	be	AUX
cblr-5119	413	10	no	no	NOUN
cblr-5119	413	11	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	414	1	3:1031	3:1031	NUM
cblr-5119	414	2	]	]	X
cblr-5119	414	3	may	may	AUX
cblr-5119	414	4	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	414	5	fourth	fourth	ADJ
cblr-5119	414	6	be	be	AUX
cblr-5119	414	7	with	with	ADP
cblr-5119	414	8	you	you	PRON
cblr-5119	414	9	1061	1061	NUM
cblr-5119	414	10	defendants.148	defendants.148	NOUN
cblr-5119	414	11	regarding	regard	VERB
cblr-5119	414	12	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	414	13	latter	latter	ADJ
cblr-5119	414	14	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	414	15	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	414	16	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	414	17	found	find	VERB
cblr-5119	414	18	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	414	19	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	414	20	norm	norm	NOUN
cblr-5119	414	21	behind	behind	ADP
cblr-5119	414	22	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	414	23	prohibition	prohibition	NOUN
cblr-5119	414	24	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	414	25	slavery	slavery	NOUN
cblr-5119	414	26	applies	apply	VERB
cblr-5119	414	27	both	both	PRON
cblr-5119	414	28	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	414	29	state	state	NOUN
cblr-5119	414	30	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	414	31	private	private	ADJ
cblr-5119	414	32	actors	actor	NOUN
cblr-5119	414	33	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	414	34	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	414	35	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	414	36	no	no	DET
cblr-5119	414	37	rule	rule	NOUN
cblr-5119	414	38	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	414	39	international	international	ADJ
cblr-5119	414	40	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	414	41	exempts	exempt	VERB
cblr-5119	414	42	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	414	43	from	from	ADP
cblr-5119	414	44	liability.149	liability.149	NOUN
cblr-5119	414	45	while	while	SCONJ
cblr-5119	414	46	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	414	47	ninth	ninth	ADJ
cblr-5119	414	48	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	414	49	has	have	AUX
cblr-5119	414	50	left	leave	VERB
cblr-5119	414	51	open	open	ADJ
cblr-5119	414	52	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	414	53	possibility	possibility	NOUN
cblr-5119	414	54	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	414	55	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	414	56	norm	norm	NOUN
cblr-5119	414	57	could	could	AUX
cblr-5119	414	58	apply	apply	VERB
cblr-5119	414	59	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	414	60	private	private	ADJ
cblr-5119	414	61	individuals	individual	NOUN
cblr-5119	414	62	but	but	CCONJ
cblr-5119	414	63	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	414	64	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	414	65	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	414	66	these	these	DET
cblr-5119	414	67	examples	example	NOUN
cblr-5119	414	68	illustrate	illustrate	VERB
cblr-5119	414	69	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	414	70	this	this	PRON
cblr-5119	414	71	is	be	AUX
cblr-5119	414	72	unlikely	unlikely	ADJ
cblr-5119	414	73	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	414	74	ever	ever	ADV
cblr-5119	414	75	occur	occur	VERB
cblr-5119	414	76	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	414	77	since	since	SCONJ
cblr-5119	414	78	international	international	ADJ
cblr-5119	414	79	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	414	80	generally	generally	ADV
cblr-5119	414	81	has	have	VERB
cblr-5119	414	82	no	no	DET
cblr-5119	414	83	principles	principle	NOUN
cblr-5119	414	84	expressly	expressly	ADV
cblr-5119	414	85	exempting	exempt	VERB
cblr-5119	414	86	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	414	87	from	from	ADP
cblr-5119	414	88	being	be	AUX
cblr-5119	414	89	cognizable	cognizable	ADJ
cblr-5119	414	90	perpetrators	perpetrator	NOUN
cblr-5119	414	91	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	414	92	heinous	heinous	ADJ
cblr-5119	414	93	offenses	offense	NOUN
cblr-5119	414	94	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	415	1	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	415	2	nestle	nestle	PROPN
cblr-5119	415	3	i	i	PRON
cblr-5119	415	4	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	415	5	also	also	ADV
cblr-5119	415	6	briefly	briefly	ADV
cblr-5119	415	7	touched	touch	VERB
cblr-5119	415	8	on	on	ADP
cblr-5119	415	9	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	415	10	presumption	presumption	NOUN
cblr-5119	415	11	against	against	ADP
cblr-5119	415	12	extraterritoriality	extraterritoriality	NOUN
cblr-5119	415	13	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	415	14	including	include	VERB
cblr-5119	415	15	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	415	16	relevance	relevance	NOUN
cblr-5119	415	17	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	415	18	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	415	19	morrison	morrison	PROPN
cblr-5119	415	20	test	test	NOUN
cblr-5119	415	21	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	415	22	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	415	23	touch	touch	NOUN
cblr-5119	415	24	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-5119	415	25	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	415	26	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-5119	415	27	concern	concern	NOUN
cblr-5119	415	28	test	test	NOUN
cblr-5119	415	29	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	416	1	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	416	2	morrison	morrison	PROPN
cblr-5119	416	3	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	416	4	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	416	5	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	416	6	employed	employ	VERB
cblr-5119	416	7	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	416	8	two	two	NUM
cblr-5119	416	9	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-5119	416	10	step	step	NOUN
cblr-5119	416	11	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	416	12	focus	focus	NOUN
cblr-5119	416	13	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	416	14	test	test	NOUN
cblr-5119	416	15	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	416	16	assess	assess	VERB
cblr-5119	416	17	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	416	18	presumption	presumption	NOUN
cblr-5119	416	19	against	against	ADP
cblr-5119	416	20	extraterritoriality	extraterritoriality	NOUN
cblr-5119	416	21	as	as	SCONJ
cblr-5119	416	22	applied	apply	VERB
cblr-5119	416	23	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	416	24	section	section	NOUN
cblr-5119	416	25	10(b	10(b	NUM
cblr-5119	416	26	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	416	27	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	416	28	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	416	29	securities	security	NOUN
cblr-5119	416	30	exchange	exchange	PROPN
cblr-5119	416	31	act.150	act.150	VERB
cblr-5119	416	32	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	416	33	first	first	ADJ
cblr-5119	416	34	step	step	NOUN
cblr-5119	416	35	asks	ask	VERB
cblr-5119	416	36	whether	whether	SCONJ
cblr-5119	416	37	there	there	PRON
cblr-5119	416	38	is	be	VERB
cblr-5119	416	39	an	an	DET
cblr-5119	416	40	indication	indication	NOUN
cblr-5119	416	41	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	416	42	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	416	43	statute	statute	NOUN
cblr-5119	416	44	is	be	AUX
cblr-5119	416	45	meant	mean	VERB
cblr-5119	416	46	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	416	47	apply	apply	VERB
cblr-5119	416	48	extraterritorially.151	extraterritorially.151	NOUN
cblr-5119	416	49	if	if	SCONJ
cblr-5119	416	50	there	there	PRON
cblr-5119	416	51	is	be	VERB
cblr-5119	416	52	no	no	DET
cblr-5119	416	53	such	such	ADJ
cblr-5119	416	54	indication	indication	NOUN
cblr-5119	416	55	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	416	56	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	416	57	second	second	ADJ
cblr-5119	416	58	step	step	NOUN
cblr-5119	416	59	asks	ask	VERB
cblr-5119	416	60	what	what	PRON
cblr-5119	416	61	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	416	62	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	416	63	focus	focus	NOUN
cblr-5119	416	64	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	416	65	congressional	congressional	ADJ
cblr-5119	416	66	concern	concern	NOUN
cblr-5119	416	67	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	416	68	is	be	AUX
cblr-5119	416	69	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	416	70	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	416	71	statute	statute	NOUN
cblr-5119	416	72	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	416	73	whether	whether	SCONJ
cblr-5119	416	74	that	that	DET
cblr-5119	416	75	focus	focus	NOUN
cblr-5119	416	76	is	be	AUX
cblr-5119	416	77	on	on	ADP
cblr-5119	416	78	domestic	domestic	ADJ
cblr-5119	416	79	or	or	CCONJ
cblr-5119	416	80	extraterritorial	extraterritorial	ADJ
cblr-5119	416	81	conduct.152	conduct.152	NOUN
cblr-5119	416	82	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	416	83	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	416	84	nestle	nestle	PROPN
cblr-5119	416	85	i	i	PROPN
cblr-5119	416	86	court	court	PROPN
cblr-5119	416	87	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	416	88	view	view	NOUN
cblr-5119	416	89	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	416	90	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	416	91	morrison	morrison	PROPN
cblr-5119	416	92	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	416	93	focus	focus	NOUN
cblr-5119	416	94	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	416	95	test	test	NOUN
cblr-5119	416	96	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	416	97	was	be	AUX
cblr-5119	416	98	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	416	99	most	most	ADJ
cblr-5119	416	100	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	416	101	informative	informative	ADJ
cblr-5119	416	102	precedent	precedent	NOUN
cblr-5119	416	103	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	416	104	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	416	105	determining	determine	VERB
cblr-5119	416	106	how	how	SCONJ
cblr-5119	416	107	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	416	108	carry	carry	VERB
cblr-5119	416	109	out	out	ADP
cblr-5119	416	110	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	416	111	kiobel	kiobel	PROPN
cblr-5119	416	112	ii	ii	PROPN
cblr-5119	416	113	touch	touch	NOUN
cblr-5119	416	114	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-5119	416	115	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	416	116	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-5119	416	117	concern	concern	NOUN
cblr-5119	416	118	test.153	test.153	VERB
cblr-5119	416	119	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	416	120	ninth	ninth	ADJ
cblr-5119	416	121	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	416	122	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	416	123	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	416	124	appeals	appeals	PROPN
cblr-5119	416	125	addressed	address	VERB
cblr-5119	416	126	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	416	127	presumption	presumption	NOUN
cblr-5119	416	128	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	416	129	ats	at	NOUN
cblr-5119	416	130	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	416	131	more	more	ADJ
cblr-5119	416	132	length	length	NOUN
cblr-5119	416	133	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	416	134	mujica	mujica	PROPN
cblr-5119	416	135	v.	v.	PROPN
cblr-5119	416	136	airscan	airscan	PROPN
cblr-5119	416	137	inc	inc	PROPN
cblr-5119	416	138	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	417	1	there	there	ADV
cblr-5119	417	2	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	417	3	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	417	4	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	417	5	seemed	seem	VERB
cblr-5119	417	6	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	417	7	adopt	adopt	VERB
cblr-5119	417	8	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	417	9	position	position	NOUN
cblr-5119	417	10	somewhere	somewhere	ADV
cblr-5119	417	11	between	between	ADP
cblr-5119	417	12	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	417	13	second	second	ADJ
cblr-5119	417	14	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	417	15	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	417	16	fourth	fourth	ADJ
cblr-5119	417	17	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	417	18	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	418	1	while	while	SCONJ
cblr-5119	418	2	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	418	3	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	418	4	did	do	AUX
cblr-5119	418	5	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	418	6	state	state	VERB
cblr-5119	418	7	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	418	8	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	418	9	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	418	10	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	418	11	nations	nation	NOUN
cblr-5119	418	12	violation	violation	NOUN
cblr-5119	418	13	needs	need	VERB
cblr-5119	418	14	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	418	15	occur	occur	VERB
cblr-5119	418	16	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	418	17	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	418	18	united	united	PROPN
cblr-5119	418	19	states	states	PROPN
cblr-5119	418	20	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	418	21	satisfy	satisfy	VERB
cblr-5119	418	22	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	418	23	touch	touch	NOUN
cblr-5119	418	24	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-5119	418	25	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	418	26	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-5119	418	27	concern	concern	NOUN
cblr-5119	418	28	test	test	NOUN
cblr-5119	418	29	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	418	30	it	it	PRON
cblr-5119	418	31	did	do	AUX
cblr-5119	418	32	indicate	indicate	VERB
cblr-5119	418	33	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	418	34	at	at	ADV
cblr-5119	418	35	least	least	ADJ
cblr-5119	418	36	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	418	37	some	some	PRON
cblr-5119	418	38	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	418	39	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	418	40	conduct	conduct	NOUN
cblr-5119	418	41	relevant	relevant	ADJ
cblr-5119	418	42	148	148	NUM
cblr-5119	418	43	sarei	sarei	NOUN
cblr-5119	418	44	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	418	45	671	671	NUM
cblr-5119	418	46	f.3d	f.3d	NUM
cblr-5119	418	47	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	418	48	764–765	764–765	PROPN
cblr-5119	418	49	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	418	50	noting	note	VERB
cblr-5119	418	51	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	418	52	genocide	genocide	PROPN
cblr-5119	418	53	convention	convention	PROPN
cblr-5119	418	54	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	418	55	common	common	ADJ
cblr-5119	418	56	article	article	NOUN
cblr-5119	418	57	iii	iii	NUM
cblr-5119	418	58	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	418	59	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	418	60	geneva	geneva	PROPN
cblr-5119	418	61	conventions	convention	NOUN
cblr-5119	418	62	focus	focus	VERB
cblr-5119	418	63	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	418	64	on	on	ADP
cblr-5119	418	65	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	418	66	specific	specific	ADJ
cblr-5119	418	67	identity	identity	NOUN
cblr-5119	418	68	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	418	69	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	418	70	victims	victim	NOUN
cblr-5119	418	71	rather	rather	ADV
cblr-5119	418	72	than	than	ADP
cblr-5119	418	73	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	418	74	identity	identity	NOUN
cblr-5119	418	75	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	418	76	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	418	77	perpetrators	perpetrator	NOUN
cblr-5119	418	78	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	418	79	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	418	80	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	419	1	149	149	NUM
cblr-5119	419	2	nestle	nestle	PROPN
cblr-5119	419	3	i	i	PRON
cblr-5119	419	4	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	419	5	766	766	NUM
cblr-5119	419	6	f.3d	f.3d	NUM
cblr-5119	419	7	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	419	8	1022	1022	NUM
cblr-5119	419	9	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	420	1	150	150	NUM
cblr-5119	420	2	morrison	morrison	PROPN
cblr-5119	420	3	v.	v.	PROPN
cblr-5119	420	4	nat’l	nat’l	PROPN
cblr-5119	420	5	australia	australia	PROPN
cblr-5119	420	6	bank	bank	PROPN
cblr-5119	420	7	ltd	ltd	PROPN
cblr-5119	420	8	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	420	9	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	420	10	561	561	NUM
cblr-5119	420	11	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	420	12	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	420	13	247	247	NUM
cblr-5119	420	14	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	420	15	265–70	265–70	PROPN
cblr-5119	420	16	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	420	17	2010	2010	NUM
cblr-5119	420	18	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	420	19	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	421	1	151	151	NUM
cblr-5119	421	2	i	i	PRON
cblr-5119	421	3	d.	d.	VERB
cblr-5119	421	4	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	421	5	260–61	260–61	PROPN
cblr-5119	421	6	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	422	1	152	152	NUM
cblr-5119	423	1	i	i	PRON
cblr-5119	423	2	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-5119	423	3	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	423	4	266	266	NUM
cblr-5119	423	5	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	423	6	quoting	quote	VERB
cblr-5119	423	7	equal	equal	ADJ
cblr-5119	423	8	emp	emp	NOUN
cblr-5119	423	9	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	424	1	opportunity	opportunity	NOUN
cblr-5119	424	2	comm’n	comm’n	NOUN
cblr-5119	424	3	v.	v.	ADP
cblr-5119	424	4	arabian	arabian	ADJ
cblr-5119	424	5	am	be	AUX
cblr-5119	424	6	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	424	7	oil	oil	PROPN
cblr-5119	424	8	co.	co.	PROPN
cblr-5119	424	9	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	424	10	499	499	NUM
cblr-5119	424	11	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	424	12	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	424	13	244	244	NUM
cblr-5119	424	14	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	424	15	1991	1991	NUM
cblr-5119	424	16	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	424	17	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	425	1	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	425	2	internal	internal	ADJ
cblr-5119	425	3	quotation	quotation	NOUN
cblr-5119	425	4	marks	mark	NOUN
cblr-5119	425	5	omitted	omit	VERB
cblr-5119	425	6	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	425	7	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	426	1	153	153	NUM
cblr-5119	426	2	nestle	nestle	PROPN
cblr-5119	426	3	i	i	PRON
cblr-5119	426	4	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	426	5	766	766	NUM
cblr-5119	426	6	f.3d	f.3d	NUM
cblr-5119	426	7	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	426	8	1028	1028	NUM
cblr-5119	426	9	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	427	1	6_2019.3_estes	6_2019.3_estes	NUM
cblr-5119	427	2	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	427	3	do	do	AUX
cblr-5119	427	4	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	427	5	delte	delte	VERB
cblr-5119	427	6	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	427	7	12/26/2019	12/26/2019	NUM
cblr-5119	427	8	12:00	12:00	NUM
cblr-5119	427	9	am	am	PROPN
cblr-5119	427	10	1062	1062	NUM
cblr-5119	427	11	columbia	columbia	PROPN
cblr-5119	427	12	business	business	NOUN
cblr-5119	427	13	law	law	PROPN
cblr-5119	427	14	review	review	NOUN
cblr-5119	427	15	[	[	X
cblr-5119	427	16	vol	vol	NOUN
cblr-5119	427	17	.	.	NOUN
cblr-5119	427	18	2019	2019	NUM
cblr-5119	427	19	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	427	20	[	[	X
cblr-5119	427	21	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	427	22	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
cblr-5119	427	23	’	'	PUNCT
cblr-5119	427	24	]	]	PUNCT
cblr-5119	427	25	claims	claim	NOUN
cblr-5119	427	26	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	427	27	does	do	AUX
cblr-5119	427	28	need	need	VERB
cblr-5119	427	29	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	427	30	occur	occur	VERB
cblr-5119	427	31	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	427	32	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	427	33	united	united	PROPN
cblr-5119	427	34	states	states	PROPN
cblr-5119	427	35	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	427	36	”154	”154	PROPN
cblr-5119	428	1	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	428	2	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	428	3	also	also	ADV
cblr-5119	428	4	implied	imply	VERB
cblr-5119	428	5	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	428	6	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	428	7	direct	direct	ADJ
cblr-5119	428	8	connection	connection	NOUN
cblr-5119	428	9	between	between	ADP
cblr-5119	428	10	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	428	11	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	428	12	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	428	13	conduct	conduct	NOUN
cblr-5119	428	14	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	428	15	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	428	16	violations	violation	NOUN
cblr-5119	428	17	that	that	PRON
cblr-5119	428	18	occurred	occur	VERB
cblr-5119	428	19	abroad	abroad	ADV
cblr-5119	428	20	is	be	AUX
cblr-5119	428	21	necessary.155	necessary.155	NOUN
cblr-5119	428	22	however	however	ADV
cblr-5119	428	23	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	428	24	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	428	25	ninth	ninth	ADJ
cblr-5119	428	26	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	428	27	changed	change	VERB
cblr-5119	428	28	course	course	ADV
cblr-5119	428	29	later	later	ADV
cblr-5119	428	30	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	428	31	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	428	32	nestle	nestle	PROPN
cblr-5119	428	33	litigation	litigation	NOUN
cblr-5119	428	34	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	428	35	doe	doe	NOUN
cblr-5119	428	36	v.	v.	ADP
cblr-5119	428	37	nestle	nestle	PROPN
cblr-5119	428	38	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	428	39	s.a	s.a	PROPN
cblr-5119	428	40	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	429	1	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	429	2	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	429	3	nestle	nestle	PROPN
cblr-5119	429	4	ii	ii	PROPN
cblr-5119	429	5	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	429	6	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	430	1	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	430	2	decided	decide	VERB
cblr-5119	430	3	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	430	4	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	430	5	morrison	morrison	PROPN
cblr-5119	430	6	focus	focus	PROPN
cblr-5119	430	7	test	test	NOUN
cblr-5119	430	8	did	do	AUX
cblr-5119	430	9	apply	apply	VERB
cblr-5119	430	10	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	430	11	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	430	12	claims	claim	NOUN
cblr-5119	430	13	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	430	14	thereby	thereby	ADV
cblr-5119	430	15	abrogating	abrogate	VERB
cblr-5119	430	16	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	430	17	touch	touch	NOUN
cblr-5119	430	18	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-5119	430	19	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	430	20	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-5119	430	21	concern	concern	NOUN
cblr-5119	430	22	test.156	test.156	NOUN
cblr-5119	430	23	it	it	PRON
cblr-5119	430	24	did	do	VERB
cblr-5119	430	25	so	so	ADV
cblr-5119	430	26	as	as	ADP
cblr-5119	430	27	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	430	28	result	result	NOUN
cblr-5119	430	29	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	430	30	rjr	rjr	PROPN
cblr-5119	430	31	nabisco	nabisco	PROPN
cblr-5119	430	32	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	430	33	inc	inc	PROPN
cblr-5119	430	34	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	431	1	v.	v.	PROPN
cblr-5119	431	2	european	european	PROPN
cblr-5119	431	3	community	community	PROPN
cblr-5119	431	4	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	432	1	there	there	ADV
cblr-5119	432	2	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	432	3	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	432	4	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	432	5	applied	apply	VERB
cblr-5119	432	6	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	432	7	morrison	morrison	PROPN
cblr-5119	432	8	focus	focus	NOUN
cblr-5119	432	9	test	test	NOUN
cblr-5119	432	10	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	432	11	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	432	12	racketeer	racketeer	NOUN
cblr-5119	432	13	influenced	influence	VERB
cblr-5119	432	14	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	432	15	corrupt	corrupt	ADJ
cblr-5119	432	16	organizations	organization	NOUN
cblr-5119	432	17	act	act	VERB
cblr-5119	432	18	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	432	19	stated	state	VERB
cblr-5119	432	20	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	432	21	kiobel	kiobel	PROPN
cblr-5119	432	22	ii	ii	PROPN
cblr-5119	432	23	also	also	ADV
cblr-5119	432	24	required	require	VERB
cblr-5119	432	25	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	432	26	two	two	NUM
cblr-5119	432	27	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-5119	432	28	step	step	NOUN
cblr-5119	432	29	framework	framework	NOUN
cblr-5119	432	30	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	432	31	analyzing	analyze	VERB
cblr-5119	432	32	extraterritoriality.157	extraterritoriality.157	NOUN
cblr-5119	432	33	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	432	34	nestle	nestle	PROPN
cblr-5119	432	35	ii	ii	PROPN
cblr-5119	432	36	court	court	PROPN
cblr-5119	432	37	took	take	VERB
cblr-5119	432	38	this	this	PRON
cblr-5119	432	39	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	432	40	mean	mean	VERB
cblr-5119	432	41	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	432	42	it	it	PRON
cblr-5119	432	43	should	should	AUX
cblr-5119	432	44	analyze	analyze	VERB
cblr-5119	432	45	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	432	46	claims	claim	NOUN
cblr-5119	432	47	using	use	VERB
cblr-5119	432	48	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	432	49	morrison	morrison	PROPN
cblr-5119	432	50	focus	focus	NOUN
cblr-5119	432	51	test	test	NOUN
cblr-5119	432	52	going	go	VERB
cblr-5119	432	53	forward	forward	ADV
cblr-5119	432	54	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	433	1	it	it	PRON
cblr-5119	433	2	then	then	ADV
cblr-5119	433	3	described	describe	VERB
cblr-5119	433	4	how	how	SCONJ
cblr-5119	433	5	kiobel	kiobel	PROPN
cblr-5119	433	6	ii	ii	PROPN
cblr-5119	433	7	had	have	AUX
cblr-5119	433	8	already	already	ADV
cblr-5119	433	9	answered	answer	VERB
cblr-5119	433	10	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	433	11	first	first	ADJ
cblr-5119	433	12	step	step	NOUN
cblr-5119	433	13	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	433	14	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	433	15	focus	focus	NOUN
cblr-5119	433	16	test	test	NOUN
cblr-5119	433	17	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	433	18	since	since	SCONJ
cblr-5119	433	19	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	433	20	supreme	supreme	PROPN
cblr-5119	433	21	court	court	PROPN
cblr-5119	433	22	there	there	ADV
cblr-5119	433	23	found	find	VERB
cblr-5119	433	24	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	433	25	nothing	nothing	PRON
cblr-5119	433	26	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	433	27	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	433	28	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	433	29	rebutted	rebut	VERB
cblr-5119	433	30	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	433	31	presumption	presumption	NOUN
cblr-5119	433	32	against	against	ADP
cblr-5119	433	33	extraterritoriality.158	extraterritoriality.158	PROPN
cblr-5119	433	34	next	next	ADV
cblr-5119	433	35	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	433	36	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	433	37	nestle	nestle	PROPN
cblr-5119	433	38	ii	ii	PROPN
cblr-5119	433	39	court	court	PROPN
cblr-5119	433	40	interpreted	interpret	VERB
cblr-5119	433	41	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	433	42	focus	focus	NOUN
cblr-5119	433	43	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-5119	433	44	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	433	45	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-5119	433	46	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	433	47	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-5119	433	48	statute	statute	NOUN
cblr-5119	433	49	step	step	NOUN
cblr-5119	433	50	as	as	ADP
cblr-5119	433	51	asking	ask	VERB
cblr-5119	433	52	if	if	SCONJ
cblr-5119	433	53	there	there	PRON
cblr-5119	433	54	was	be	VERB
cblr-5119	433	55	any	any	DET
cblr-5119	433	56	domestic	domestic	ADJ
cblr-5119	433	57	conduct	conduct	NOUN
cblr-5119	433	58	relevant	relevant	ADJ
cblr-5119	433	59	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	433	60	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	433	61	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
cblr-5119	433	62	’	'	PUNCT
cblr-5119	433	63	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	433	64	claims.159	claims.159	VERB
cblr-5119	433	65	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	433	66	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	433	67	found	find	VERB
cblr-5119	433	68	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	433	69	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	433	70	defendants	defendant	NOUN
cblr-5119	433	71	’	’	PART
cblr-5119	433	72	funding	funding	NOUN
cblr-5119	433	73	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	433	74	child	child	NOUN
cblr-5119	433	75	slavery	slavery	NOUN
cblr-5119	433	76	practices	practice	NOUN
cblr-5119	433	77	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	433	78	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	433	79	ivory	ivory	PROPN
cblr-5119	433	80	coast	coast	PROPN
cblr-5119	433	81	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	433	82	combined	combine	VERB
cblr-5119	433	83	with	with	ADP
cblr-5119	433	84	their	their	PRON
cblr-5119	433	85	practice	practice	NOUN
cblr-5119	433	86	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	433	87	sending	send	VERB
cblr-5119	433	88	employees	employee	NOUN
cblr-5119	433	89	from	from	ADP
cblr-5119	433	90	their	their	PRON
cblr-5119	433	91	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	433	92	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	433	93	headquarters	headquarters	PROPN
cblr-5119	433	94	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	433	95	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	433	96	ivory	ivory	PROPN
cblr-5119	433	97	coast	coast	PROPN
cblr-5119	433	98	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	433	99	inspect	inspect	VERB
cblr-5119	433	100	operations	operation	NOUN
cblr-5119	433	101	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	433	102	report	report	VERB
cblr-5119	433	103	back	back	ADP
cblr-5119	433	104	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	433	105	was	be	AUX
cblr-5119	433	106	sufficiently	sufficiently	ADV
cblr-5119	433	107	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	433	108	relevant	relevant	ADJ
cblr-5119	433	109	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	433	110	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	433	111	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	433	112	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	433	113	focus	focus	NOUN
cblr-5119	433	114	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	433	115	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	433	116	satisfy	satisfy	VERB
cblr-5119	433	117	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	433	118	morrison	morrison	PROPN
cblr-5119	433	119	test.160	test.160	PROPN
cblr-5119	433	120	despite	despite	SCONJ
cblr-5119	433	121	employing	employ	VERB
cblr-5119	433	122	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	433	123	different	different	ADJ
cblr-5119	433	124	test	test	NOUN
cblr-5119	433	125	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	433	126	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	433	127	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	433	128	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	433	129	approach	approach	NOUN
cblr-5119	433	130	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	433	131	nestle	nestle	PROPN
cblr-5119	433	132	ii	ii	PROPN
cblr-5119	433	133	was	be	AUX
cblr-5119	433	134	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	433	135	ultimately	ultimately	ADV
cblr-5119	433	136	dissimilar	dissimilar	ADJ
cblr-5119	433	137	from	from	ADP
cblr-5119	433	138	mujica	mujica	PROPN
cblr-5119	433	139	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	433	140	meaning	mean	VERB
cblr-5119	433	141	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	433	142	ninth	ninth	ADJ
cblr-5119	433	143	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	433	144	remains	remain	VERB
cblr-5119	433	145	somewhere	somewhere	ADV
cblr-5119	433	146	between	between	ADP
cblr-5119	433	147	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	433	148	second	second	ADJ
cblr-5119	433	149	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	433	150	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	433	151	fourth	fourth	ADJ
cblr-5119	433	152	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	433	153	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	433	154	terms	term	NOUN
cblr-5119	433	155	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	433	156	restrictiveness	restrictiveness	NOUN
cblr-5119	433	157	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	434	1	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	434	2	mujica	mujica	PROPN
cblr-5119	434	3	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	434	4	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	434	5	victims	victim	NOUN
cblr-5119	434	6	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	434	7	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	434	8	bombing	bombing	NOUN
cblr-5119	434	9	raid	raid	NOUN
cblr-5119	434	10	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	434	11	colombia	colombia	PROPN
cblr-5119	434	12	accused	accuse	VERB
cblr-5119	434	13	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	434	14	154	154	NUM
cblr-5119	434	15	mujica	mujica	PROPN
cblr-5119	434	16	v.	v.	PROPN
cblr-5119	434	17	airscan	airscan	PROPN
cblr-5119	434	18	inc	inc	PROPN
cblr-5119	434	19	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	434	20	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	434	21	771	771	NUM
cblr-5119	434	22	f.3d	f.3d	NUM
cblr-5119	434	23	580	580	NUM
cblr-5119	434	24	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	434	25	595	595	NUM
cblr-5119	434	26	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	434	27	9th	9th	ADJ
cblr-5119	434	28	cir	cir	NOUN
cblr-5119	434	29	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	434	30	2014	2014	NUM
cblr-5119	434	31	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	434	32	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	435	1	155	155	NUM
cblr-5119	436	1	i	i	PRON
cblr-5119	436	2	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-5119	436	3	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	436	4	592	592	NUM
cblr-5119	436	5	n.6	n.6	NOUN
cblr-5119	436	6	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	437	1	156	156	NUM
cblr-5119	437	2	doe	doe	NOUN
cblr-5119	437	3	v.	v.	ADP
cblr-5119	437	4	nestle	nestle	PROPN
cblr-5119	437	5	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	437	6	s.a	s.a	PROPN
cblr-5119	437	7	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	437	8	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	437	9	nestle	nestle	PROPN
cblr-5119	437	10	ii	ii	PROPN
cblr-5119	437	11	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	437	12	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	437	13	906	906	NUM
cblr-5119	437	14	f.3d	f.3d	NUM
cblr-5119	437	15	1120	1120	NUM
cblr-5119	437	16	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	437	17	1125	1125	NUM
cblr-5119	437	18	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	437	19	9th	9th	ADJ
cblr-5119	437	20	cir	cir	NOUN
cblr-5119	437	21	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	437	22	2018	2018	NUM
cblr-5119	437	23	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	437	24	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	438	1	157	157	NUM
cblr-5119	438	2	rjr	rjr	PROPN
cblr-5119	438	3	nabisco	nabisco	PROPN
cblr-5119	438	4	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	438	5	inc	inc	PROPN
cblr-5119	438	6	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	438	7	v.	v.	PROPN
cblr-5119	438	8	european	european	PROPN
cblr-5119	438	9	community	community	PROPN
cblr-5119	438	10	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	438	11	136	136	NUM
cblr-5119	438	12	s.	s.	PROPN
cblr-5119	438	13	ct	ct	PROPN
cblr-5119	438	14	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	438	15	2090	2090	NUM
cblr-5119	438	16	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	438	17	2101	2101	NUM
cblr-5119	438	18	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	438	19	2016	2016	NUM
cblr-5119	438	20	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	438	21	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	439	1	158	158	NUM
cblr-5119	439	2	nestle	nestle	PROPN
cblr-5119	439	3	ii	ii	PROPN
cblr-5119	439	4	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	439	5	906	906	NUM
cblr-5119	439	6	f.3d	f.3d	NUM
cblr-5119	439	7	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	439	8	1125	1125	NUM
cblr-5119	439	9	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	440	1	159	159	NUM
cblr-5119	440	2	i	i	PRON
cblr-5119	440	3	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-5119	440	4	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	440	5	1125–26	1125–26	NUM
cblr-5119	440	6	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	441	1	160	160	NUM
cblr-5119	441	2	i	i	PRON
cblr-5119	441	3	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-5119	441	4	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	441	5	1126	1126	NUM
cblr-5119	441	6	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	442	1	6_2019.3_estes	6_2019.3_estes	NUM
cblr-5119	442	2	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	442	3	do	do	AUX
cblr-5119	442	4	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	442	5	delete	delete	VERB
cblr-5119	442	6	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	442	7	12/26/2019	12/26/2019	NUM
cblr-5119	442	8	12:00	12:00	NUM
cblr-5119	442	9	am	be	AUX
cblr-5119	442	10	no	no	NOUN
cblr-5119	442	11	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	443	1	3:1031	3:1031	NUM
cblr-5119	443	2	]	]	X
cblr-5119	443	3	may	may	AUX
cblr-5119	443	4	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	443	5	fourth	fourth	ADJ
cblr-5119	443	6	be	be	AUX
cblr-5119	443	7	with	with	ADP
cblr-5119	443	8	you	you	PRON
cblr-5119	443	9	1063	1063	NUM
cblr-5119	443	10	defendant	defendant	NOUN
cblr-5119	443	11	oil	oil	NOUN
cblr-5119	443	12	company	company	NOUN
cblr-5119	443	13	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	443	14	defendant	defendant	NOUN
cblr-5119	443	15	security	security	NOUN
cblr-5119	443	16	company	company	NOUN
cblr-5119	443	17	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	443	18	both	both	PRON
cblr-5119	443	19	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	443	20	which	which	PRON
cblr-5119	443	21	were	be	AUX
cblr-5119	443	22	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	443	23	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	443	24	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	443	25	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	443	26	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	443	27	helping	help	VERB
cblr-5119	443	28	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	443	29	colombian	colombian	ADJ
cblr-5119	443	30	military	military	NOUN
cblr-5119	443	31	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	443	32	carry	carry	VERB
cblr-5119	443	33	out	out	ADP
cblr-5119	443	34	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	443	35	raid	raid	NOUN
cblr-5119	443	36	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	443	37	order	order	NOUN
cblr-5119	443	38	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	443	39	protect	protect	VERB
cblr-5119	443	40	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	443	41	oil	oil	NOUN
cblr-5119	443	42	company	company	NOUN
cblr-5119	443	43	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	443	44	colombian	colombian	ADJ
cblr-5119	443	45	pipeline.161	pipeline.161	ADP
cblr-5119	443	46	there	there	PRON
cblr-5119	443	47	were	be	VERB
cblr-5119	443	48	no	no	DET
cblr-5119	443	49	allegations	allegation	NOUN
cblr-5119	443	50	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	443	51	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	443	52	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	443	53	conduct	conduct	NOUN
cblr-5119	443	54	other	other	ADJ
cblr-5119	443	55	than	than	ADP
cblr-5119	443	56	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	443	57	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
cblr-5119	443	58	’	'	PUNCT
cblr-5119	443	59	speculation	speculation	NOUN
cblr-5119	443	60	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	443	61	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	443	62	defendants	defendant	NOUN
cblr-5119	443	63	concluded	conclude	VERB
cblr-5119	443	64	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	443	65	contract	contract	NOUN
cblr-5119	443	66	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	443	67	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	443	68	united	united	PROPN
cblr-5119	443	69	states.162	states.162	PROPN
cblr-5119	443	70	this	this	DET
cblr-5119	443	71	minimal	minimal	ADJ
cblr-5119	443	72	alleged	allege	VERB
cblr-5119	443	73	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	443	74	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	443	75	conduct	conduct	NOUN
cblr-5119	443	76	failed	fail	VERB
cblr-5119	443	77	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	443	78	displace	displace	VERB
cblr-5119	443	79	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	443	80	presumption	presumption	NOUN
cblr-5119	443	81	against	against	ADP
cblr-5119	443	82	extraterritoriality.163	extraterritoriality.163	PROPN
cblr-5119	443	83	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	443	84	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	443	85	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	443	86	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	443	87	analysis	analysis	NOUN
cblr-5119	443	88	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	443	89	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	443	90	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
cblr-5119	443	91	’	’	PART
cblr-5119	443	92	allegations	allegation	NOUN
cblr-5119	443	93	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	443	94	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	443	95	oil	oil	NOUN
cblr-5119	443	96	company	company	NOUN
cblr-5119	443	97	allowed	allow	VERB
cblr-5119	443	98	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	443	99	security	security	NOUN
cblr-5119	443	100	company	company	NOUN
cblr-5119	443	101	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	443	102	colombian	colombian	ADJ
cblr-5119	443	103	military	military	NOUN
cblr-5119	443	104	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	443	105	use	use	VERB
cblr-5119	443	106	its	its	PRON
cblr-5119	443	107	facility	facility	NOUN
cblr-5119	443	108	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	443	109	plan	plan	VERB
cblr-5119	443	110	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	443	111	raid	raid	NOUN
cblr-5119	443	112	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	443	113	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	443	114	several	several	ADJ
cblr-5119	443	115	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	443	116	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	443	117	security	security	NOUN
cblr-5119	443	118	company	company	NOUN
cblr-5119	443	119	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	443	120	employees	employee	NOUN
cblr-5119	443	121	piloted	pilot	VERB
cblr-5119	443	122	one	one	NUM
cblr-5119	443	123	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	443	124	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	443	125	planes	plane	NOUN
cblr-5119	443	126	that	that	PRON
cblr-5119	443	127	participated	participate	VERB
cblr-5119	443	128	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	443	129	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	443	130	raid	raid	NOUN
cblr-5119	443	131	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	443	132	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	443	133	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	443	134	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	443	135	security	security	NOUN
cblr-5119	443	136	company	company	NOUN
cblr-5119	443	137	helped	help	VERB
cblr-5119	443	138	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	443	139	colombian	colombian	ADJ
cblr-5119	443	140	military	military	NOUN
cblr-5119	443	141	plan	plan	VERB
cblr-5119	443	142	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	443	143	raid	raid	NOUN
cblr-5119	443	144	were	be	AUX
cblr-5119	443	145	insufficient	insufficient	ADJ
cblr-5119	443	146	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	443	147	displace	displace	VERB
cblr-5119	443	148	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	443	149	presumption.164	presumption.164	NOUN
cblr-5119	443	150	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	443	151	both	both	DET
cblr-5119	443	152	cases	case	NOUN
cblr-5119	443	153	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	443	154	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	443	155	ninth	ninth	ADJ
cblr-5119	443	156	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	443	157	placed	place	VERB
cblr-5119	443	158	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	443	159	greater	great	ADJ
cblr-5119	443	160	emphasis	emphasis	NOUN
cblr-5119	443	161	on	on	ADP
cblr-5119	443	162	conduct	conduct	NOUN
cblr-5119	443	163	than	than	ADP
cblr-5119	443	164	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	443	165	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	443	166	fourth	fourth	ADJ
cblr-5119	443	167	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	443	168	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	443	169	where	where	SCONJ
cblr-5119	443	170	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	443	171	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	443	172	relied	rely	VERB
cblr-5119	443	173	on	on	ADP
cblr-5119	443	174	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	443	175	more	more	ADV
cblr-5119	443	176	tangential	tangential	ADJ
cblr-5119	443	177	facts	fact	NOUN
cblr-5119	443	178	underlying	underlie	VERB
cblr-5119	443	179	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	443	180	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
cblr-5119	443	181	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	443	182	claim	claim	NOUN
cblr-5119	443	183	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	444	1	under	under	ADP
cblr-5119	444	2	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	444	3	fourth	fourth	ADJ
cblr-5119	444	4	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	444	5	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	444	6	more	more	ADV
cblr-5119	444	7	general	general	ADJ
cblr-5119	444	8	claim	claim	NOUN
cblr-5119	444	9	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-5119	444	10	based	base	VERB
cblr-5119	444	11	approach	approach	NOUN
cblr-5119	444	12	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	444	13	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	444	14	uncredited	uncredited	ADJ
cblr-5119	444	15	actions	action	NOUN
cblr-5119	444	16	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	444	17	mujica	mujica	PROPN
cblr-5119	444	18	could	could	AUX
cblr-5119	444	19	be	be	AUX
cblr-5119	444	20	considered	consider	VERB
cblr-5119	444	21	as	as	ADP
cblr-5119	444	22	part	part	NOUN
cblr-5119	444	23	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	444	24	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	444	25	calculus	calculus	NOUN
cblr-5119	444	26	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	444	27	displacing	displace	VERB
cblr-5119	444	28	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	444	29	presumption	presumption	NOUN
cblr-5119	444	30	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	445	1	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	445	2	they	they	PRON
cblr-5119	445	3	were	be	AUX
cblr-5119	445	4	irrelevant	irrelevant	ADJ
cblr-5119	445	5	here	here	ADV
cblr-5119	445	6	illustrates	illustrate	VERB
cblr-5119	445	7	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	445	8	more	more	ADV
cblr-5119	445	9	restrictive	restrictive	ADJ
cblr-5119	445	10	nature	nature	NOUN
cblr-5119	445	11	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	445	12	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	445	13	ninth	ninth	ADJ
cblr-5119	445	14	circuit	circuit	PROPN
cblr-5119	445	15	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	445	16	conduct	conduct	NOUN
cblr-5119	445	17	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-5119	445	18	based	base	VERB
cblr-5119	445	19	approach.165	approach.165	PROPN
cblr-5119	445	20	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-5119	445	21	eleventh	eleventh	PROPN
cblr-5119	445	22	circuit	circuit	PROPN
cblr-5119	445	23	:	:	PUNCT
cblr-5119	445	24	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	445	25	restrictive	restrictive	ADJ
cblr-5119	445	26	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	445	27	conduct	conduct	NOUN
cblr-5119	445	28	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-5119	445	29	based	base	VERB
cblr-5119	445	30	approach	approach	NOUN
cblr-5119	445	31	like	like	ADP
cblr-5119	445	32	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	445	33	fourth	fourth	ADJ
cblr-5119	445	34	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	445	35	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	445	36	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	445	37	eleventh	eleventh	ADJ
cblr-5119	445	38	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	445	39	has	have	AUX
cblr-5119	445	40	recognized	recognize	VERB
cblr-5119	445	41	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	445	42	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	445	43	without	without	ADP
cblr-5119	445	44	much	much	ADJ
cblr-5119	445	45	analysis	analysis	NOUN
cblr-5119	445	46	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	445	47	whereas	whereas	SCONJ
cblr-5119	445	48	its	its	PRON
cblr-5119	445	49	semi	semi	ADJ
cblr-5119	445	50	-	-	ADJ
cblr-5119	445	51	restrictive	restrictive	ADJ
cblr-5119	445	52	approach	approach	NOUN
cblr-5119	445	53	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	445	54	displacing	displace	VERB
cblr-5119	445	55	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	445	56	presumption	presumption	NOUN
cblr-5119	445	57	against	against	ADP
cblr-5119	445	58	extraterritoriality	extraterritoriality	NOUN
cblr-5119	445	59	approximates	approximate	VERB
cblr-5119	445	60	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	445	61	ninth	ninth	ADJ
cblr-5119	445	62	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	445	63	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	445	64	161	161	NUM
cblr-5119	445	65	mujica	mujica	PROPN
cblr-5119	445	66	v.	v.	PROPN
cblr-5119	445	67	airscan	airscan	PROPN
cblr-5119	445	68	inc	inc	PROPN
cblr-5119	445	69	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	445	70	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	445	71	771	771	NUM
cblr-5119	445	72	f.3d	f.3d	NUM
cblr-5119	445	73	580	580	NUM
cblr-5119	445	74	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	445	75	584–85	584–85	NUM
cblr-5119	445	76	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	445	77	9th	9th	ADJ
cblr-5119	445	78	cir	cir	NOUN
cblr-5119	445	79	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	445	80	2014	2014	NUM
cblr-5119	445	81	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	445	82	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	446	1	162	162	NUM
cblr-5119	447	1	i	i	PRON
cblr-5119	447	2	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-5119	447	3	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	447	4	592	592	NUM
cblr-5119	447	5	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	448	1	163	163	NUM
cblr-5119	449	1	i	i	PRON
cblr-5119	449	2	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-5119	449	3	164	164	NUM
cblr-5119	450	1	i	i	PROPN
cblr-5119	450	2	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-5119	450	3	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	450	4	585	585	NUM
cblr-5119	450	5	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	450	6	592	592	NUM
cblr-5119	450	7	.	.	NUM
cblr-5119	450	8	165	165	NUM
cblr-5119	450	9	it	it	PRON
cblr-5119	450	10	appears	appear	VERB
cblr-5119	450	11	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	450	12	jesner	jesner	NOUN
cblr-5119	450	13	will	will	AUX
cblr-5119	450	14	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	450	15	affect	affect	VERB
cblr-5119	450	16	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	450	17	ninth	ninth	ADJ
cblr-5119	450	18	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	450	19	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	450	20	approach	approach	NOUN
cblr-5119	450	21	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	450	22	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	450	23	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	450	24	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	450	25	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	450	26	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	450	27	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	450	28	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	451	1	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	451	2	nestle	nestle	PROPN
cblr-5119	451	3	ii	ii	PROPN
cblr-5119	451	4	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	451	5	which	which	PRON
cblr-5119	451	6	was	be	AUX
cblr-5119	451	7	decided	decide	VERB
cblr-5119	451	8	after	after	ADP
cblr-5119	451	9	jesner	jesner	PROPN
cblr-5119	451	10	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	451	11	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	451	12	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	451	13	expressly	expressly	ADV
cblr-5119	451	14	stated	state	VERB
cblr-5119	451	15	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	451	16	jesner	jesner	PROPN
cblr-5119	451	17	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	451	18	holding	holding	NOUN
cblr-5119	451	19	was	be	AUX
cblr-5119	451	20	limited	limit	VERB
cblr-5119	451	21	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	451	22	foreign	foreign	ADJ
cblr-5119	451	23	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	451	24	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	451	25	it	it	PRON
cblr-5119	451	26	thereby	thereby	ADV
cblr-5119	451	27	affirmed	affirm	VERB
cblr-5119	451	28	its	its	PRON
cblr-5119	451	29	holding	holding	NOUN
cblr-5119	451	30	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	451	31	nestle	nestle	PROPN
cblr-5119	451	32	i	i	PRON
cblr-5119	451	33	as	as	SCONJ
cblr-5119	451	34	applied	apply	VERB
cblr-5119	451	35	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	451	36	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	451	37	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	451	38	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	451	39	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	452	1	nestle	nestle	PROPN
cblr-5119	452	2	ii	ii	PROPN
cblr-5119	452	3	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	452	4	906	906	NUM
cblr-5119	452	5	f.3d	f.3d	NUM
cblr-5119	452	6	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	452	7	1124	1124	NUM
cblr-5119	452	8	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	453	1	6_2019.3_estes	6_2019.3_estes	NUM
cblr-5119	453	2	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	453	3	do	do	AUX
cblr-5119	453	4	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	453	5	delte	delte	VERB
cblr-5119	453	6	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	453	7	12/26/2019	12/26/2019	NUM
cblr-5119	453	8	12:00	12:00	NUM
cblr-5119	453	9	am	am	NOUN
cblr-5119	453	10	1064	1064	NUM
cblr-5119	453	11	columbia	columbia	PROPN
cblr-5119	453	12	business	business	NOUN
cblr-5119	453	13	law	law	PROPN
cblr-5119	453	14	review	review	NOUN
cblr-5119	453	15	[	[	X
cblr-5119	453	16	vol	vol	NOUN
cblr-5119	453	17	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	453	18	2019	2019	NUM
cblr-5119	453	19	approach	approach	NOUN
cblr-5119	453	20	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	454	1	regarding	regard	VERB
cblr-5119	454	2	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	454	3	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	454	4	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	454	5	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	454	6	eleventh	eleventh	ADJ
cblr-5119	454	7	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	454	8	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	454	9	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	454	10	appeals	appeal	NOUN
cblr-5119	454	11	granted	grant	VERB
cblr-5119	454	12	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NOUN
cblr-5119	454	13	under	under	ADP
cblr-5119	454	14	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	454	15	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	454	16	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	454	17	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	454	18	torture	torture	NOUN
cblr-5119	454	19	claim	claim	NOUN
cblr-5119	454	20	against	against	ADP
cblr-5119	454	21	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	454	22	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	454	23	defendant	defendant	NOUN
cblr-5119	454	24	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	454	25	2005	2005	NUM
cblr-5119	454	26	without	without	ADP
cblr-5119	454	27	elaborating	elaborate	VERB
cblr-5119	454	28	on	on	ADP
cblr-5119	454	29	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	454	30	issue.166	issue.166	ADJ
cblr-5119	454	31	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	454	32	eleventh	eleventh	ADJ
cblr-5119	454	33	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	454	34	developed	develop	VERB
cblr-5119	454	35	its	its	PRON
cblr-5119	454	36	test	test	NOUN
cblr-5119	454	37	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	454	38	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	454	39	presumption	presumption	NOUN
cblr-5119	454	40	against	against	ADP
cblr-5119	454	41	extraterritoriality	extraterritoriality	NOUN
cblr-5119	454	42	as	as	SCONJ
cblr-5119	454	43	applied	apply	VERB
cblr-5119	454	44	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	454	45	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	454	46	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	454	47	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	454	48	doe	doe	NOUN
cblr-5119	454	49	v.	v.	ADP
cblr-5119	454	50	drummond	drummond	PROPN
cblr-5119	454	51	co.	co.	PROPN
cblr-5119	454	52	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	454	53	inc	inc	PROPN
cblr-5119	454	54	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	455	1	there	there	ADV
cblr-5119	455	2	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	455	3	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	455	4	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
cblr-5119	455	5	—	—	PUNCT
cblr-5119	455	6	colombian	colombian	ADJ
cblr-5119	455	7	victims	victim	NOUN
cblr-5119	455	8	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	455	9	alleged	allege	VERB
cblr-5119	455	10	extrajudicial	extrajudicial	ADJ
cblr-5119	455	11	killings	killing	NOUN
cblr-5119	455	12	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	455	13	war	war	NOUN
cblr-5119	455	14	crimes	crime	NOUN
cblr-5119	455	15	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	455	16	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	455	17	crimes	crime	NOUN
cblr-5119	455	18	against	against	ADP
cblr-5119	455	19	humanity	humanity	NOUN
cblr-5119	455	20	carried	carry	VERB
cblr-5119	455	21	out	out	ADP
cblr-5119	455	22	by	by	ADP
cblr-5119	455	23	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	455	24	colombian	colombian	ADJ
cblr-5119	455	25	paramilitary	paramilitary	ADJ
cblr-5119	455	26	group	group	NOUN
cblr-5119	455	27	—	—	PUNCT
cblr-5119	455	28	sued	sue	VERB
cblr-5119	455	29	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	455	30	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	455	31	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	455	32	coal	coal	NOUN
cblr-5119	455	33	mining	mining	NOUN
cblr-5119	455	34	company	company	NOUN
cblr-5119	455	35	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	455	36	its	its	PRON
cblr-5119	455	37	subsidiary	subsidiary	NOUN
cblr-5119	455	38	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	455	39	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	455	40	several	several	ADJ
cblr-5119	455	41	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	455	42	officers	officer	NOUN
cblr-5119	455	43	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	456	1	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	456	2	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
cblr-5119	456	3	alleged	allege	VERB
cblr-5119	456	4	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	456	5	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	456	6	defendants	defendant	NOUN
cblr-5119	456	7	orchestrated	orchestrate	VERB
cblr-5119	456	8	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	456	9	paramilitary	paramilitary	NOUN
cblr-5119	456	10	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	456	11	actions	action	NOUN
cblr-5119	456	12	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	456	13	order	order	NOUN
cblr-5119	456	14	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	456	15	protect	protect	VERB
cblr-5119	456	16	their	their	PRON
cblr-5119	456	17	mining	mining	NOUN
cblr-5119	456	18	operations	operation	NOUN
cblr-5119	456	19	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	456	20	colombia.167	colombia.167	ADP
cblr-5119	456	21	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	456	22	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	456	23	announced	announce	VERB
cblr-5119	456	24	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	456	25	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	456	26	factintensive	factintensive	ADJ
cblr-5119	456	27	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	456	28	standard	standard	NOUN
cblr-5119	456	29	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	456	30	analyzing	analyze	VERB
cblr-5119	456	31	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	456	32	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	456	33	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	456	34	presumption	presumption	NOUN
cblr-5119	456	35	:	:	PUNCT
cblr-5119	456	36	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	456	37	[	[	X
cblr-5119	456	38	d]isplacement	d]isplacement	NOUN
cblr-5119	456	39	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	456	40	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	456	41	presumption	presumption	NOUN
cblr-5119	456	42	will	will	AUX
cblr-5119	456	43	be	be	AUX
cblr-5119	456	44	warranted	warrant	VERB
cblr-5119	456	45	if	if	SCONJ
cblr-5119	456	46	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	456	47	claims	claim	NOUN
cblr-5119	456	48	have	have	VERB
cblr-5119	456	49	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	456	50	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	456	51	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	456	52	focus	focus	NOUN
cblr-5119	456	53	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	456	54	adequate	adequate	ADJ
cblr-5119	456	55	relevant	relevant	ADJ
cblr-5119	456	56	conduct	conduct	NOUN
cblr-5119	456	57	occurs	occur	VERB
cblr-5119	456	58	within	within	ADP
cblr-5119	456	59	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	456	60	united	united	PROPN
cblr-5119	456	61	states	states	PROPN
cblr-5119	456	62	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	456	63	”168	”168	PUNCT
cblr-5119	457	1	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	457	2	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	457	3	elaborated	elaborate	VERB
cblr-5119	457	4	by	by	ADP
cblr-5119	457	5	pointing	point	VERB
cblr-5119	457	6	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	457	7	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	457	8	importance	importance	NOUN
cblr-5119	457	9	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	457	10	locating	locate	VERB
cblr-5119	457	11	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	457	12	conduct	conduct	NOUN
cblr-5119	457	13	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	457	14	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	457	15	directly	directly	ADV
cblr-5119	457	16	or	or	CCONJ
cblr-5119	457	17	secondarily	secondarily	ADV
cblr-5119	457	18	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	457	19	resulted	result	VERB
cblr-5119	457	20	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	457	21	international	international	ADJ
cblr-5119	457	22	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	457	23	violations.169	violations.169	NOUN
cblr-5119	457	24	it	it	PRON
cblr-5119	457	25	also	also	ADV
cblr-5119	457	26	required	require	VERB
cblr-5119	457	27	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	457	28	allegations	allegation	NOUN
cblr-5119	457	29	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	457	30	meet	meet	VERB
cblr-5119	457	31	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	457	32	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	457	33	minimum	minimum	ADJ
cblr-5119	457	34	factual	factual	ADJ
cblr-5119	457	35	predicate	predicate	NOUN
cblr-5119	457	36	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	457	37	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	457	38	warrant	warrant	VERB
cblr-5119	457	39	exterritorial	exterritorial	ADJ
cblr-5119	457	40	application	application	NOUN
cblr-5119	457	41	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	457	42	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	457	43	ats.170	ats.170	NOUN
cblr-5119	457	44	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	457	45	eleventh	eleventh	ADJ
cblr-5119	457	46	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	457	47	noted	note	VERB
cblr-5119	457	48	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	457	49	both	both	DET
cblr-5119	457	50	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	457	51	defendant	defendant	NOUN
cblr-5119	457	52	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	457	53	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	457	54	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	457	55	citizenship	citizenship	NOUN
cblr-5119	457	56	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	457	57	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	457	58	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	457	59	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	457	60	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	457	61	interests	interest	NOUN
cblr-5119	457	62	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	457	63	triggered	trigger	VERB
cblr-5119	457	64	by	by	ADP
cblr-5119	457	65	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	457	66	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
cblr-5119	457	67	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	457	68	claim	claim	NOUN
cblr-5119	457	69	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	457	70	here	here	ADV
cblr-5119	457	71	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	457	72	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	457	73	defendants	defendant	NOUN
cblr-5119	457	74	allegedly	allegedly	ADV
cblr-5119	457	75	funding	fund	VERB
cblr-5119	457	76	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	457	77	retaining	retain	VERB
cblr-5119	457	78	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	457	79	u.s.-designated	u.s.-designated	ADJ
cblr-5119	457	80	terrorist	terrorist	ADJ
cblr-5119	457	81	organization	organization	NOUN
cblr-5119	457	82	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	457	83	were	be	AUX
cblr-5119	457	84	relevant	relevant	ADJ
cblr-5119	457	85	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	457	86	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	457	87	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	457	88	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	457	89	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	457	90	focus	focus	NOUN
cblr-5119	457	91	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	457	92	part	part	NOUN
cblr-5119	457	93	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	457	94	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	457	95	standard	standard	NOUN
cblr-5119	457	96	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	457	97	but	but	CCONJ
cblr-5119	457	98	also	also	ADV
cblr-5119	457	99	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	457	100	neither	neither	DET
cblr-5119	457	101	factor	factor	NOUN
cblr-5119	457	102	was	be	AUX
cblr-5119	457	103	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
cblr-5119	457	104	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	457	105	even	even	ADV
cblr-5119	457	106	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	457	107	combination	combination	NOUN
cblr-5119	457	108	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	457	109	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	457	110	rebut	rebut	VERB
cblr-5119	457	111	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	457	112	166	166	NUM
cblr-5119	457	113	see	see	NOUN
cblr-5119	457	114	aldana	aldana	PROPN
cblr-5119	457	115	v.	v.	ADP
cblr-5119	457	116	del	del	PROPN
cblr-5119	457	117	monte	monte	PROPN
cblr-5119	457	118	fresh	fresh	ADJ
cblr-5119	457	119	produce	produce	NOUN
cblr-5119	457	120	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	457	121	n.a	n.a	PROPN
cblr-5119	457	122	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	457	123	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	457	124	inc	inc	PROPN
cblr-5119	457	125	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	457	126	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	457	127	416	416	NUM
cblr-5119	457	128	f.3d	f.3d	NUM
cblr-5119	457	129	1242	1242	NUM
cblr-5119	457	130	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	457	131	1254	1254	NUM
cblr-5119	457	132	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	457	133	11th	11th	ADJ
cblr-5119	457	134	cir	cir	NOUN
cblr-5119	457	135	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	457	136	2005	2005	NUM
cblr-5119	457	137	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	457	138	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	458	1	on	on	ADP
cblr-5119	458	2	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	458	3	basis	basis	NOUN
cblr-5119	458	4	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	458	5	that	that	DET
cblr-5119	458	6	case	case	NOUN
cblr-5119	458	7	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	458	8	when	when	SCONJ
cblr-5119	458	9	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	458	10	defendant	defendant	NOUN
cblr-5119	458	11	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	458	12	romero	romero	PROPN
cblr-5119	458	13	v.	v.	PROPN
cblr-5119	458	14	drummond	drummond	PROPN
cblr-5119	458	15	argued	argue	VERB
cblr-5119	458	16	several	several	ADJ
cblr-5119	458	17	years	year	NOUN
cblr-5119	458	18	later	later	ADV
cblr-5119	458	19	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	458	20	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	458	21	should	should	AUX
cblr-5119	458	22	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	458	23	be	be	AUX
cblr-5119	458	24	liable	liable	ADJ
cblr-5119	458	25	under	under	ADP
cblr-5119	458	26	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	458	27	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	458	28	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	458	29	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	458	30	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	458	31	simply	simply	ADV
cblr-5119	458	32	stated	state	VERB
cblr-5119	458	33	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	458	34	it	it	PRON
cblr-5119	458	35	was	be	AUX
cblr-5119	458	36	bound	bind	VERB
cblr-5119	458	37	by	by	ADP
cblr-5119	458	38	its	its	PRON
cblr-5119	458	39	precedent	precedent	NOUN
cblr-5119	458	40	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	459	1	romero	romero	PROPN
cblr-5119	459	2	v.	v.	PROPN
cblr-5119	459	3	drummond	drummond	PROPN
cblr-5119	459	4	co.	co.	PROPN
cblr-5119	459	5	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	459	6	552	552	NUM
cblr-5119	459	7	f.3d	f.3d	NUM
cblr-5119	459	8	1303	1303	NUM
cblr-5119	459	9	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	459	10	1315	1315	NUM
cblr-5119	459	11	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	459	12	11th	11th	ADJ
cblr-5119	459	13	cir	cir	NOUN
cblr-5119	459	14	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	459	15	2008	2008	NUM
cblr-5119	459	16	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	459	17	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	460	1	167	167	NUM
cblr-5119	460	2	doe	doe	NOUN
cblr-5119	460	3	v.	v.	ADP
cblr-5119	460	4	drummond	drummond	PROPN
cblr-5119	460	5	co.	co.	PROPN
cblr-5119	460	6	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	460	7	782	782	NUM
cblr-5119	460	8	f.3d	f.3d	NUM
cblr-5119	460	9	576	576	NUM
cblr-5119	460	10	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	460	11	579–80	579–80	PROPN
cblr-5119	460	12	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	460	13	11th	11th	ADJ
cblr-5119	460	14	cir	cir	NOUN
cblr-5119	460	15	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	460	16	2015	2015	NUM
cblr-5119	460	17	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	460	18	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	461	1	168	168	NUM
cblr-5119	462	1	i	i	PRON
cblr-5119	462	2	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-5119	462	3	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	462	4	592	592	NUM
cblr-5119	462	5	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	463	1	169	169	NUM
cblr-5119	464	1	i	i	PRON
cblr-5119	464	2	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-5119	464	3	170	170	NUM
cblr-5119	465	1	i	i	PRON
cblr-5119	465	2	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-5119	465	3	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	465	4	593	593	NUM
cblr-5119	465	5	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	465	6	quoting	quote	VERB
cblr-5119	465	7	baloco	baloco	PROPN
cblr-5119	465	8	v.	v.	PROPN
cblr-5119	465	9	drummond	drummond	PROPN
cblr-5119	465	10	co.	co.	PROPN
cblr-5119	465	11	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	465	12	767	767	NUM
cblr-5119	465	13	f.3d	f.3d	NUM
cblr-5119	465	14	1229	1229	NUM
cblr-5119	465	15	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	465	16	11th	11th	ADJ
cblr-5119	465	17	cir	cir	NOUN
cblr-5119	465	18	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	465	19	2014	2014	NUM
cblr-5119	465	20	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	465	21	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	466	1	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	466	2	internal	internal	ADJ
cblr-5119	466	3	quotation	quotation	NOUN
cblr-5119	466	4	marks	mark	NOUN
cblr-5119	466	5	omitted	omit	VERB
cblr-5119	466	6	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	466	7	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	467	1	6_2019.3_estes	6_2019.3_estes	NUM
cblr-5119	467	2	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	467	3	do	do	AUX
cblr-5119	467	4	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	467	5	delete	delete	VERB
cblr-5119	467	6	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	467	7	12/26/2019	12/26/2019	NUM
cblr-5119	467	8	12:00	12:00	NUM
cblr-5119	467	9	am	be	AUX
cblr-5119	467	10	no	no	NOUN
cblr-5119	467	11	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	468	1	3:1031	3:1031	NUM
cblr-5119	468	2	]	]	X
cblr-5119	468	3	may	may	AUX
cblr-5119	468	4	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	468	5	fourth	fourth	ADJ
cblr-5119	468	6	be	be	AUX
cblr-5119	468	7	with	with	ADP
cblr-5119	468	8	you	you	PRON
cblr-5119	468	9	1065	1065	NUM
cblr-5119	468	10	presumption.171	presumption.171	NOUN
cblr-5119	468	11	this	this	PRON
cblr-5119	468	12	reveals	reveal	VERB
cblr-5119	468	13	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	468	14	while	while	SCONJ
cblr-5119	468	15	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	468	16	standard	standard	NOUN
cblr-5119	468	17	does	do	AUX
cblr-5119	468	18	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	468	19	on	on	ADP
cblr-5119	468	20	its	its	PRON
cblr-5119	468	21	face	face	NOUN
cblr-5119	468	22	appear	appear	VERB
cblr-5119	468	23	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	468	24	privilege	privilege	VERB
cblr-5119	468	25	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	468	26	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	468	27	adequate	adequate	ADJ
cblr-5119	468	28	relevant	relevant	ADJ
cblr-5119	468	29	conduct	conduct	NOUN
cblr-5119	468	30	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	468	31	prong	prong	NOUN
cblr-5119	468	32	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	468	33	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	468	34	reality	reality	NOUN
cblr-5119	468	35	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	468	36	that	that	DET
cblr-5119	468	37	prong	prong	NOUN
cblr-5119	468	38	requires	require	VERB
cblr-5119	468	39	more	more	ADJ
cblr-5119	468	40	than	than	ADP
cblr-5119	468	41	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	468	42	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	468	43	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	468	44	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	468	45	focus	focus	NOUN
cblr-5119	468	46	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	468	47	prong.172	prong.172	NOUN
cblr-5119	468	48	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	468	49	wit	wit	NOUN
cblr-5119	468	50	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	468	51	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	468	52	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	468	53	labeled	label	VERB
cblr-5119	468	54	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	468	55	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	468	56	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	468	57	conduct	conduct	NOUN
cblr-5119	468	58	inquiry	inquiry	NOUN
cblr-5119	468	59	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	468	60	key	key	NOUN
cblr-5119	468	61	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	468	62	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	468	63	intimated	intimate	VERB
cblr-5119	468	64	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	468	65	it	it	PRON
cblr-5119	468	66	represents	represent	VERB
cblr-5119	468	67	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	468	68	stricter	strict	ADJ
cblr-5119	468	69	test.173	test.173	NOUN
cblr-5119	468	70	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	468	71	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	468	72	appeared	appear	VERB
cblr-5119	468	73	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	468	74	soften	soften	VERB
cblr-5119	468	75	that	that	DET
cblr-5119	468	76	stance	stance	NOUN
cblr-5119	468	77	elsewhere	elsewhere	ADV
cblr-5119	468	78	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	468	79	its	its	PRON
cblr-5119	468	80	opinion	opinion	NOUN
cblr-5119	468	81	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	468	82	stating	state	VERB
cblr-5119	468	83	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	468	84	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	468	85	conduct	conduct	NOUN
cblr-5119	468	86	factor	factor	NOUN
cblr-5119	468	87	was	be	AUX
cblr-5119	468	88	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	468	89	weighty	weighty	ADJ
cblr-5119	468	90	but	but	CCONJ
cblr-5119	468	91	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	468	92	dispositive”174	dispositive”174	ADV
cblr-5119	468	93	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	468	94	holding	hold	VERB
cblr-5119	468	95	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	468	96	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	468	97	place	place	NOUN
cblr-5119	468	98	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	468	99	mere	mere	ADJ
cblr-5119	468	100	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	468	101	decisionmaking	decisionmaking	NOUN
cblr-5119	468	102	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	468	103	could	could	AUX
cblr-5119	468	104	factor	factor	VERB
cblr-5119	468	105	into	into	ADP
cblr-5119	468	106	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	468	107	conduct	conduct	NOUN
cblr-5119	468	108	inquiry.175	inquiry.175	PROPN
cblr-5119	468	109	however	however	ADV
cblr-5119	468	110	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	468	111	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	468	112	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	468	113	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	468	114	analysis	analysis	NOUN
cblr-5119	468	115	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	468	116	decision	decision	NOUN
cblr-5119	468	117	reinforce	reinforce	VERB
cblr-5119	468	118	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	468	119	idea	idea	NOUN
cblr-5119	468	120	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	468	121	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	468	122	conduct	conduct	NOUN
cblr-5119	468	123	inquiry	inquiry	NOUN
cblr-5119	468	124	represents	represent	VERB
cblr-5119	468	125	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	468	126	high	high	ADJ
cblr-5119	468	127	bar	bar	NOUN
cblr-5119	468	128	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	469	1	it	it	PRON
cblr-5119	469	2	seemed	seem	VERB
cblr-5119	469	3	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	469	4	imply	imply	VERB
cblr-5119	469	5	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	469	6	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	469	7	inquiry	inquiry	NOUN
cblr-5119	469	8	called	call	VERB
cblr-5119	469	9	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	469	10	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	469	11	balancing	balance	VERB
cblr-5119	469	12	test	test	NOUN
cblr-5119	469	13	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	469	14	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	469	15	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	469	16	sufficiency	sufficiency	NOUN
cblr-5119	469	17	test	test	NOUN
cblr-5119	469	18	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	470	1	while	while	SCONJ
cblr-5119	470	2	acknowledging	acknowledge	VERB
cblr-5119	470	3	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	470	4	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	470	5	defendants	defendant	NOUN
cblr-5119	470	6	made	make	VERB
cblr-5119	470	7	key	key	ADJ
cblr-5119	470	8	decisions	decision	NOUN
cblr-5119	470	9	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	470	10	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	470	11	united	united	PROPN
cblr-5119	470	12	states	states	PROPN
cblr-5119	470	13	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	470	14	this	this	DET
cblr-5119	470	15	fact	fact	NOUN
cblr-5119	470	16	did	do	AUX
cblr-5119	470	17	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	470	18	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	470	19	outweigh	outweigh	VERB
cblr-5119	470	20	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	470	21	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	470	22	alleged	allege	VERB
cblr-5119	470	23	extraterritorial	extraterritorial	ADJ
cblr-5119	470	24	conduct	conduct	NOUN
cblr-5119	470	25	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	470	26	including	include	VERB
cblr-5119	470	27	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	470	28	actual	actual	ADJ
cblr-5119	470	29	funding	funding	NOUN
cblr-5119	470	30	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	470	31	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	470	32	paramilitary	paramilitary	ADJ
cblr-5119	470	33	group	group	NOUN
cblr-5119	470	34	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	470	35	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	470	36	planning	planning	NOUN
cblr-5119	470	37	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	470	38	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	470	39	operation.176	operation.176	NOUN
cblr-5119	470	40	notably	notably	ADV
cblr-5119	470	41	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	470	42	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	470	43	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	470	44	acknowledged	acknowledge	VERB
cblr-5119	470	45	one	one	NUM
cblr-5119	470	46	such	such	ADJ
cblr-5119	470	47	decision	decision	NOUN
cblr-5119	470	48	:	:	PUNCT
cblr-5119	470	49	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	470	50	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	470	51	defendant	defendant	NOUN
cblr-5119	470	52	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	470	53	president	president	NOUN
cblr-5119	470	54	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	470	55	agreed	agree	VERB
cblr-5119	470	56	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	470	57	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	470	58	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	470	59	plan	plan	NOUN
cblr-5119	470	60	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	470	61	murder	murder	VERB
cblr-5119	470	62	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	470	63	victims	victim	NOUN
cblr-5119	470	64	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	470	65	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	470	66	operation.177	operation.177	PROPN
cblr-5119	470	67	however	however	ADV
cblr-5119	470	68	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	470	69	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	470	70	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	470	71	stated	state	VERB
cblr-5119	470	72	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	470	73	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	470	74	mere	mere	ADJ
cblr-5119	470	75	consent	consent	NOUN
cblr-5119	470	76	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	470	77	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	470	78	international	international	ADJ
cblr-5119	470	79	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	470	80	violations	violation	NOUN
cblr-5119	470	81	did	do	AUX
cblr-5119	470	82	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	470	83	suffice	suffice	VERB
cblr-5119	470	84	as	as	ADP
cblr-5119	470	85	conduct	conduct	NOUN
cblr-5119	470	86	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	470	87	displace	displace	VERB
cblr-5119	470	88	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	470	89	presumption	presumption	NOUN
cblr-5119	470	90	because	because	SCONJ
cblr-5119	470	91	it	it	PRON
cblr-5119	470	92	was	be	AUX
cblr-5119	470	93	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	470	94	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	470	95	directed	direct	VERB
cblr-5119	470	96	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	470	97	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	470	98	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	470	99	international	international	ADJ
cblr-5119	470	100	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	470	101	violations.178	violations.178	ADP
cblr-5119	470	102	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	470	103	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	470	104	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	470	105	opinion	opinion	NOUN
cblr-5119	470	106	is	be	AUX
cblr-5119	470	107	largely	largely	ADV
cblr-5119	470	108	unclear	unclear	ADJ
cblr-5119	470	109	regarding	regard	VERB
cblr-5119	470	110	what	what	PRON
cblr-5119	470	111	will	will	AUX
cblr-5119	470	112	suffice	suffice	VERB
cblr-5119	470	113	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	470	114	displace	displace	VERB
cblr-5119	470	115	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	470	116	presumption	presumption	NOUN
cblr-5119	470	117	going	go	VERB
cblr-5119	470	118	forward	forward	ADV
cblr-5119	470	119	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	470	120	but	but	CCONJ
cblr-5119	470	121	it	it	PRON
cblr-5119	470	122	does	do	AUX
cblr-5119	470	123	indicate	indicate	VERB
cblr-5119	470	124	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	470	125	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
cblr-5119	470	126	will	will	AUX
cblr-5119	470	127	face	face	VERB
cblr-5119	470	128	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	470	129	high	high	ADJ
cblr-5119	470	130	bar	bar	NOUN
cblr-5119	470	131	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	471	1	if	if	SCONJ
cblr-5119	471	2	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	471	3	inquiry	inquiry	NOUN
cblr-5119	471	4	indeed	indeed	ADV
cblr-5119	471	5	involves	involve	VERB
cblr-5119	471	6	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	471	7	balancing	balancing	NOUN
cblr-5119	471	8	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	471	9	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	471	10	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	471	11	conduct	conduct	NOUN
cblr-5119	471	12	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	471	13	extraterritorial	extraterritorial	ADJ
cblr-5119	471	14	conduct	conduct	NOUN
cblr-5119	471	15	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	471	16	few	few	ADJ
cblr-5119	471	17	claims	claim	NOUN
cblr-5119	471	18	are	be	AUX
cblr-5119	471	19	likely	likely	ADJ
cblr-5119	471	20	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	471	21	succeed	succeed	VERB
cblr-5119	471	22	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	471	23	given	give	VERB
cblr-5119	471	24	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	471	25	even	even	ADV
cblr-5119	471	26	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	471	27	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	471	28	cases	case	NOUN
cblr-5119	471	29	where	where	SCONJ
cblr-5119	471	30	significant	significant	ADJ
cblr-5119	471	31	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	471	32	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	471	33	conduct	conduct	NOUN
cblr-5119	471	34	is	be	AUX
cblr-5119	471	35	alleged	allege	VERB
cblr-5119	471	36	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	471	37	there	there	PRON
cblr-5119	471	38	is	be	VERB
cblr-5119	471	39	likely	likely	ADJ
cblr-5119	471	40	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	471	41	be	be	AUX
cblr-5119	471	42	even	even	ADV
cblr-5119	471	43	greater	great	ADJ
cblr-5119	471	44	extraterritorial	extraterritorial	ADJ
cblr-5119	471	45	171	171	NUM
cblr-5119	472	1	i	i	PROPN
cblr-5119	472	2	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-5119	472	3	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	472	4	595–97	595–97	NUM
cblr-5119	472	5	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	473	1	172	172	NUM
cblr-5119	474	1	i	i	PRON
cblr-5119	474	2	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-5119	474	3	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	474	4	592	592	NUM
cblr-5119	474	5	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	475	1	173	173	NUM
cblr-5119	476	1	i	i	PRON
cblr-5119	476	2	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-5119	476	3	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	476	4	597	597	NUM
cblr-5119	476	5	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	476	6	174	174	NUM
cblr-5119	477	1	i	i	PRON
cblr-5119	477	2	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-5119	477	3	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	477	4	593	593	NUM
cblr-5119	477	5	n.24	n.24	NOUN
cblr-5119	477	6	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	477	7	175	175	NUM
cblr-5119	478	1	i	i	PRON
cblr-5119	478	2	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-5119	478	3	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	478	4	597	597	NUM
cblr-5119	478	5	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	479	1	176	176	NUM
cblr-5119	480	1	i	i	PRON
cblr-5119	480	2	d.	d.	VERB
cblr-5119	480	3	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	480	4	598	598	NUM
cblr-5119	480	5	.	.	NUM
cblr-5119	480	6	177	177	NUM
cblr-5119	481	1	i	i	PRON
cblr-5119	481	2	d.	d.	VERB
cblr-5119	481	3	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	481	4	599	599	NUM
cblr-5119	481	5	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	481	6	178	178	NUM
cblr-5119	482	1	i	i	PRON
cblr-5119	482	2	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-5119	482	3	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	482	4	599–600	599–600	NUM
cblr-5119	482	5	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	483	1	6_2019.3_estes	6_2019.3_estes	NUM
cblr-5119	483	2	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	483	3	do	do	AUX
cblr-5119	483	4	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	483	5	delte	delte	VERB
cblr-5119	483	6	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	483	7	12/26/2019	12/26/2019	NUM
cblr-5119	483	8	12:00	12:00	NUM
cblr-5119	483	9	am	am	PROPN
cblr-5119	484	1	1066	1066	NUM
cblr-5119	484	2	columbia	columbia	PROPN
cblr-5119	484	3	business	business	NOUN
cblr-5119	484	4	law	law	PROPN
cblr-5119	484	5	review	review	NOUN
cblr-5119	484	6	[	[	X
cblr-5119	484	7	vol	vol	NOUN
cblr-5119	484	8	.	.	NOUN
cblr-5119	484	9	2019	2019	NUM
cblr-5119	484	10	conduct	conduct	NOUN
cblr-5119	484	11	alleged	allege	VERB
cblr-5119	484	12	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	485	1	179	179	NUM
cblr-5119	485	2	even	even	ADV
cblr-5119	485	3	if	if	SCONJ
cblr-5119	485	4	there	there	PRON
cblr-5119	485	5	is	be	VERB
cblr-5119	485	6	no	no	DET
cblr-5119	485	7	balancing	balancing	NOUN
cblr-5119	485	8	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	485	9	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	485	10	eleventh	eleventh	ADJ
cblr-5119	485	11	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	485	12	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	485	13	approach	approach	NOUN
cblr-5119	485	14	still	still	ADV
cblr-5119	485	15	appears	appear	VERB
cblr-5119	485	16	restrictive	restrictive	ADJ
cblr-5119	485	17	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	486	1	while	while	SCONJ
cblr-5119	486	2	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	486	3	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	486	4	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	486	5	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	486	6	focus	focus	NOUN
cblr-5119	486	7	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	486	8	portion	portion	NOUN
cblr-5119	486	9	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	486	10	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	486	11	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	486	12	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	486	13	standard	standard	PROPN
cblr-5119	486	14	aligns	align	VERB
cblr-5119	486	15	with	with	ADP
cblr-5119	486	16	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	486	17	more	more	ADV
cblr-5119	486	18	lenient	lenient	ADJ
cblr-5119	486	19	fourth	fourth	ADJ
cblr-5119	486	20	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	486	21	approach	approach	NOUN
cblr-5119	486	22	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	486	23	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	486	24	primacy	primacy	NOUN
cblr-5119	486	25	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	486	26	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	486	27	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	486	28	conduct	conduct	NOUN
cblr-5119	486	29	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	486	30	portion	portion	NOUN
cblr-5119	486	31	indicates	indicate	VERB
cblr-5119	486	32	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	486	33	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	486	34	eleventh	eleventh	ADJ
cblr-5119	486	35	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	486	36	is	be	AUX
cblr-5119	486	37	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	486	38	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	486	39	practice	practice	NOUN
cblr-5119	486	40	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	486	41	aligned	align	VERB
cblr-5119	486	42	with	with	ADP
cblr-5119	486	43	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	486	44	less	less	ADV
cblr-5119	486	45	forgiving	forgiving	ADJ
cblr-5119	486	46	ninth	ninth	ADJ
cblr-5119	486	47	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	486	48	approach	approach	NOUN
cblr-5119	486	49	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	487	1	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	487	2	fact	fact	NOUN
cblr-5119	487	3	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	487	4	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	487	5	eleventh	eleventh	ADJ
cblr-5119	487	6	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	487	7	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	487	8	approach	approach	NOUN
cblr-5119	487	9	appears	appear	VERB
cblr-5119	487	10	even	even	ADV
cblr-5119	487	11	more	more	ADV
cblr-5119	487	12	restrictive	restrictive	ADJ
cblr-5119	487	13	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	487	14	considering	consider	VERB
cblr-5119	487	15	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	487	16	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	487	17	unlike	unlike	ADP
cblr-5119	487	18	mujica	mujica	PROPN
cblr-5119	487	19	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	487	20	there	there	PRON
cblr-5119	487	21	was	be	VERB
cblr-5119	487	22	cognizable	cognizable	ADJ
cblr-5119	487	23	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	487	24	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	487	25	conduct	conduct	NOUN
cblr-5119	487	26	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	487	27	drummond	drummond	PROPN
cblr-5119	487	28	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	487	29	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	487	30	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	487	31	still	still	ADV
cblr-5119	487	32	deemed	deem	VERB
cblr-5119	487	33	it	it	PRON
cblr-5119	487	34	insufficient	insufficient	ADJ
cblr-5119	487	35	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	488	1	180	180	NUM
cblr-5119	488	2	however	however	ADV
cblr-5119	488	3	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	488	4	this	this	PRON
cblr-5119	488	5	is	be	AUX
cblr-5119	488	6	still	still	ADV
cblr-5119	488	7	less	less	ADV
cblr-5119	488	8	restrictive	restrictive	ADJ
cblr-5119	488	9	than	than	ADP
cblr-5119	488	10	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	488	11	second	second	ADJ
cblr-5119	488	12	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	488	13	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	488	14	which	which	PRON
cblr-5119	488	15	requires	require	VERB
cblr-5119	488	16	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	488	17	actual	actual	ADJ
cblr-5119	488	18	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	488	19	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	488	20	nations	nation	NOUN
cblr-5119	488	21	violation	violation	NOUN
cblr-5119	488	22	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	488	23	occur	occur	VERB
cblr-5119	488	24	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	488	25	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	488	26	united	united	PROPN
cblr-5119	488	27	states.181	states.181	PROPN
cblr-5119	488	28	e.	e.	PROPN
cblr-5119	488	29	d.c	d.c	PROPN
cblr-5119	488	30	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	488	31	circuit	circuit	PROPN
cblr-5119	488	32	:	:	PUNCT
cblr-5119	488	33	hinting	hint	VERB
cblr-5119	488	34	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	488	35	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	488	36	semi	semi	ADJ
cblr-5119	488	37	-	-	ADJ
cblr-5119	488	38	permissive	permissive	ADJ
cblr-5119	488	39	approach	approach	NOUN
cblr-5119	488	40	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	488	41	d.c	d.c	PROPN
cblr-5119	488	42	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	488	43	circuit	circuit	PROPN
cblr-5119	488	44	has	have	AUX
cblr-5119	488	45	held	hold	VERB
cblr-5119	488	46	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	488	47	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	488	48	are	be	AUX
cblr-5119	488	49	categorically	categorically	ADV
cblr-5119	488	50	liable	liable	ADJ
cblr-5119	488	51	under	under	ADP
cblr-5119	488	52	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	488	53	ats	at	NOUN
cblr-5119	488	54	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	488	55	whereas	whereas	SCONJ
cblr-5119	488	56	its	its	PRON
cblr-5119	488	57	approach	approach	NOUN
cblr-5119	488	58	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	488	59	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	488	60	presumption	presumption	NOUN
cblr-5119	488	61	against	against	ADP
cblr-5119	488	62	extraterritoriality	extraterritoriality	NOUN
cblr-5119	488	63	is	be	AUX
cblr-5119	488	64	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	488	65	entirely	entirely	ADV
cblr-5119	488	66	clear	clear	ADJ
cblr-5119	488	67	but	but	CCONJ
cblr-5119	488	68	seems	seem	VERB
cblr-5119	488	69	more	more	ADV
cblr-5119	488	70	liberal	liberal	ADJ
cblr-5119	488	71	than	than	ADP
cblr-5119	488	72	restrictive	restrictive	ADJ
cblr-5119	488	73	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	489	1	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	489	2	d.c	d.c	PROPN
cblr-5119	489	3	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	489	4	circuit	circuit	PROPN
cblr-5119	489	5	ruled	rule	VERB
cblr-5119	489	6	on	on	ADP
cblr-5119	489	7	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	489	8	former	former	ADJ
cblr-5119	489	9	issue	issue	NOUN
cblr-5119	489	10	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	489	11	doe	doe	NOUN
cblr-5119	489	12	v.	v.	CCONJ
cblr-5119	489	13	exxon	exxon	PROPN
cblr-5119	489	14	mobil	mobil	PROPN
cblr-5119	489	15	corp	corp	PROPN
cblr-5119	489	16	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	490	1	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	490	2	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	490	3	exxon	exxon	PROPN
cblr-5119	490	4	i	i	PROPN
cblr-5119	490	5	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	490	6	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	490	7	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	490	8	where	where	SCONJ
cblr-5119	490	9	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	490	10	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	490	11	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	490	12	analysis	analysis	NOUN
cblr-5119	490	13	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	490	14	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	490	15	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	490	16	tracks	track	NOUN
cblr-5119	490	17	that	that	PRON
cblr-5119	490	18	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	490	19	judge	judge	NOUN
cblr-5119	490	20	leval	leval	PROPN
cblr-5119	490	21	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	490	22	kiobel	kiobel	PROPN
cblr-5119	490	23	i.	i.	PROPN
cblr-5119	490	24	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	490	25	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	490	26	drew	draw	VERB
cblr-5119	490	27	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	490	28	distinction	distinction	NOUN
cblr-5119	490	29	between	between	ADP
cblr-5119	490	30	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	490	31	substantive	substantive	ADJ
cblr-5119	490	32	norms	norm	NOUN
cblr-5119	490	33	that	that	PRON
cblr-5119	490	34	support	support	VERB
cblr-5119	490	35	causes	cause	NOUN
cblr-5119	490	36	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	490	37	action	action	NOUN
cblr-5119	490	38	under	under	ADP
cblr-5119	490	39	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	490	40	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	490	41	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	490	42	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	490	43	remedies	remedy	NOUN
cblr-5119	490	44	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	490	45	violation	violation	NOUN
cblr-5119	490	46	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	490	47	those	those	DET
cblr-5119	490	48	norms	norm	NOUN
cblr-5119	490	49	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	491	1	it	it	PRON
cblr-5119	491	2	explained	explain	VERB
cblr-5119	491	3	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	491	4	courts	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	491	5	must	must	AUX
cblr-5119	491	6	refer	refer	VERB
cblr-5119	491	7	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	491	8	federal	federal	ADJ
cblr-5119	491	9	common	common	ADJ
cblr-5119	491	10	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	491	11	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	491	12	which	which	PRON
cblr-5119	491	13	supports	support	VERB
cblr-5119	491	14	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	491	15	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	491	16	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	491	17	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	491	18	remedial	remedial	ADJ
cblr-5119	491	19	questions	question	NOUN
cblr-5119	491	20	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	491	21	because	because	SCONJ
cblr-5119	491	22	such	such	ADJ
cblr-5119	491	23	questions	question	NOUN
cblr-5119	491	24	are	be	AUX
cblr-5119	491	25	outside	outside	ADP
cblr-5119	491	26	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	491	27	scope	scope	NOUN
cblr-5119	491	28	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	491	29	customary	customary	ADJ
cblr-5119	491	30	international	international	ADJ
cblr-5119	491	31	law.182	law.182	NOUN
cblr-5119	491	32	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	491	33	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	491	34	also	also	ADV
cblr-5119	491	35	looked	look	VERB
cblr-5119	491	36	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	491	37	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	491	38	context	context	NOUN
cblr-5119	491	39	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	491	40	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	491	41	179	179	NUM
cblr-5119	491	42	see	see	NOUN
cblr-5119	491	43	fox	fox	PROPN
cblr-5119	491	44	&	&	CCONJ
cblr-5119	491	45	goze	goze	PROPN
cblr-5119	491	46	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	491	47	supra	supra	PROPN
cblr-5119	491	48	note	note	NOUN
cblr-5119	491	49	5	5	NUM
cblr-5119	491	50	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	491	51	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	491	52	45	45	NUM
cblr-5119	491	53	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	491	54	describing	describe	VERB
cblr-5119	491	55	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	491	56	two	two	NUM
cblr-5119	491	57	classes	class	NOUN
cblr-5119	491	58	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	491	59	modern	modern	ADJ
cblr-5119	491	60	ats	at	NOUN
cblr-5119	491	61	cases	case	NOUN
cblr-5119	491	62	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	491	63	both	both	PRON
cblr-5119	491	64	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	491	65	which	which	PRON
cblr-5119	491	66	impliedly	impliedly	ADV
cblr-5119	491	67	involve	involve	VERB
cblr-5119	491	68	significant	significant	ADJ
cblr-5119	491	69	extraterritorial	extraterritorial	ADJ
cblr-5119	491	70	conduct	conduct	NOUN
cblr-5119	491	71	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	491	72	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	492	1	180	180	NUM
cblr-5119	492	2	see	see	VERB
cblr-5119	492	3	doe	doe	NOUN
cblr-5119	492	4	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	492	5	782	782	NUM
cblr-5119	492	6	f.3d	f.3d	NUM
cblr-5119	492	7	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	492	8	597–98	597–98	NUM
cblr-5119	492	9	;	;	PUNCT
cblr-5119	492	10	mujica	mujica	PROPN
cblr-5119	492	11	v.	v.	PROPN
cblr-5119	492	12	airscan	airscan	PROPN
cblr-5119	492	13	inc	inc	PROPN
cblr-5119	492	14	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	492	15	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	492	16	771	771	NUM
cblr-5119	492	17	f.3d	f.3d	NUM
cblr-5119	492	18	580	580	NUM
cblr-5119	492	19	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	492	20	592	592	NUM
cblr-5119	492	21	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	492	22	9th	9th	ADJ
cblr-5119	492	23	cir	cir	NOUN
cblr-5119	492	24	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	492	25	2014	2014	NUM
cblr-5119	492	26	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	492	27	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	492	28	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	492	29	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	492	30	allegations	allegation	NOUN
cblr-5119	492	31	that	that	PRON
cblr-5119	492	32	form	form	VERB
cblr-5119	492	33	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	492	34	basis	basis	NOUN
cblr-5119	492	35	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	492	36	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
cblr-5119	492	37	’	'	PUNCT
cblr-5119	492	38	claims	claim	VERB
cblr-5119	492	39	exclusively	exclusively	ADV
cblr-5119	492	40	concern	concern	NOUN
cblr-5119	492	41	conduct	conduct	NOUN
cblr-5119	492	42	that	that	PRON
cblr-5119	492	43	occurred	occur	VERB
cblr-5119	492	44	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	492	45	colombia	colombia	PROPN
cblr-5119	492	46	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	492	47	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	492	48	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	492	49	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	493	1	181	181	NUM
cblr-5119	493	2	as	as	ADP
cblr-5119	493	3	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	493	4	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	493	5	second	second	ADJ
cblr-5119	493	6	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	493	7	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	493	8	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	493	9	eleventh	eleventh	ADJ
cblr-5119	493	10	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	493	11	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	493	12	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	493	13	appeals	appeals	PROPN
cblr-5119	493	14	has	have	AUX
cblr-5119	493	15	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	493	16	yet	yet	ADV
cblr-5119	493	17	addressed	address	VERB
cblr-5119	493	18	jesner	jesner	NOUN
cblr-5119	493	19	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	494	1	182	182	NUM
cblr-5119	494	2	doe	doe	NOUN
cblr-5119	494	3	v.	v.	ADP
cblr-5119	494	4	exxon	exxon	PROPN
cblr-5119	494	5	mobil	mobil	PROPN
cblr-5119	494	6	corp	corp	PROPN
cblr-5119	494	7	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	494	8	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	494	9	654	654	NUM
cblr-5119	494	10	f.3d	f.3d	NUM
cblr-5119	494	11	11	11	NUM
cblr-5119	494	12	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	494	13	41–42	41–42	NUM
cblr-5119	494	14	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	494	15	d.c	d.c	PROPN
cblr-5119	494	16	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	494	17	cir	cir	PROPN
cblr-5119	494	18	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	494	19	2011	2011	NUM
cblr-5119	494	20	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	494	21	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	494	22	vacated	vacate	VERB
cblr-5119	494	23	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	494	24	527	527	NUM
cblr-5119	494	25	f.	f.	PROPN
cblr-5119	494	26	app’x	app’x	PROPN
cblr-5119	494	27	7	7	NUM
cblr-5119	494	28	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	494	29	d.c	d.c	PROPN
cblr-5119	494	30	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	494	31	cir	cir	PROPN
cblr-5119	494	32	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	494	33	2013	2013	NUM
cblr-5119	494	34	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	494	35	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	495	1	while	while	SCONJ
cblr-5119	495	2	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	495	3	d.c	d.c	PROPN
cblr-5119	495	4	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	495	5	circuit	circuit	PROPN
cblr-5119	495	6	court	court	PROPN
cblr-5119	495	7	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	495	8	appeals	appeal	NOUN
cblr-5119	495	9	later	later	ADV
cblr-5119	495	10	vacated	vacate	VERB
cblr-5119	495	11	this	this	DET
cblr-5119	495	12	judgment	judgment	NOUN
cblr-5119	495	13	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	495	14	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	495	15	opinion	opinion	NOUN
cblr-5119	495	16	remains	remain	VERB
cblr-5119	495	17	relevant	relevant	ADJ
cblr-5119	495	18	as	as	ADP
cblr-5119	495	19	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	495	20	only	only	ADJ
cblr-5119	495	21	occasion	occasion	NOUN
cblr-5119	495	22	on	on	ADP
cblr-5119	495	23	which	which	PRON
cblr-5119	495	24	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	495	25	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	495	26	has	have	AUX
cblr-5119	495	27	analyzed	analyze	VERB
cblr-5119	495	28	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	495	29	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	495	30	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	496	1	6_2019.3_estes	6_2019.3_estes	NUM
cblr-5119	496	2	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	496	3	do	do	AUX
cblr-5119	496	4	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	496	5	delete	delete	VERB
cblr-5119	496	6	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	496	7	12/26/2019	12/26/2019	NUM
cblr-5119	496	8	12:00	12:00	NUM
cblr-5119	496	9	am	be	AUX
cblr-5119	496	10	no	no	NOUN
cblr-5119	496	11	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	497	1	3:1031	3:1031	NUM
cblr-5119	497	2	]	]	X
cblr-5119	497	3	may	may	AUX
cblr-5119	497	4	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	497	5	fourth	fourth	ADJ
cblr-5119	497	6	be	be	AUX
cblr-5119	497	7	with	with	ADP
cblr-5119	497	8	you	you	PRON
cblr-5119	497	9	1067	1067	NUM
cblr-5119	497	10	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	497	11	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	497	12	enactment	enactment	NOUN
cblr-5119	497	13	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	498	1	congress	congress	PROPN
cblr-5119	498	2	passed	pass	VERB
cblr-5119	498	3	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	498	4	ats	at	NOUN
cblr-5119	498	5	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	498	6	help	help	VERB
cblr-5119	498	7	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	498	8	united	united	PROPN
cblr-5119	498	9	states	states	PROPN
cblr-5119	498	10	avoid	avoid	VERB
cblr-5119	498	11	foreign	foreign	ADJ
cblr-5119	498	12	entanglements	entanglement	NOUN
cblr-5119	498	13	resulting	result	VERB
cblr-5119	498	14	from	from	ADP
cblr-5119	498	15	aliens	alien	NOUN
cblr-5119	498	16	lacking	lack	VERB
cblr-5119	498	17	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	498	18	remedy	remedy	NOUN
cblr-5119	498	19	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	498	20	torts	tort	NOUN
cblr-5119	498	21	committed	commit	VERB
cblr-5119	498	22	against	against	ADP
cblr-5119	498	23	them	they	PRON
cblr-5119	498	24	by	by	ADP
cblr-5119	498	25	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	498	26	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	498	27	citizens	citizen	NOUN
cblr-5119	498	28	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	499	1	it	it	PRON
cblr-5119	499	2	would	would	AUX
cblr-5119	499	3	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	499	4	make	make	VERB
cblr-5119	499	5	sense	sense	NOUN
cblr-5119	499	6	for	for	SCONJ
cblr-5119	499	7	congress	congress	PROPN
cblr-5119	499	8	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	499	9	risk	risk	VERB
cblr-5119	499	10	any	any	DET
cblr-5119	499	11	entanglements	entanglement	NOUN
cblr-5119	499	12	by	by	ADP
cblr-5119	499	13	keeping	keep	VERB
cblr-5119	499	14	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	499	15	immune	immune	ADJ
cblr-5119	499	16	from	from	ADP
cblr-5119	499	17	such	such	ADJ
cblr-5119	499	18	suits	suit	NOUN
cblr-5119	499	19	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	499	20	especially	especially	ADV
cblr-5119	499	21	since	since	SCONJ
cblr-5119	499	22	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	499	23	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	499	24	was	be	AUX
cblr-5119	499	25	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	499	26	recognized	recognize	VERB
cblr-5119	499	27	principle	principle	NOUN
cblr-5119	499	28	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	499	29	tort	tort	NOUN
cblr-5119	499	30	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	499	31	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	499	32	that	that	DET
cblr-5119	499	33	time.183	time.183	NOUN
cblr-5119	499	34	regarding	regard	VERB
cblr-5119	499	35	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	499	36	presumption	presumption	NOUN
cblr-5119	499	37	against	against	ADP
cblr-5119	499	38	extraterritoriality	extraterritoriality	NOUN
cblr-5119	499	39	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	499	40	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	499	41	district	district	NOUN
cblr-5119	499	42	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	499	43	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	499	44	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	499	45	district	district	PROPN
cblr-5119	499	46	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	499	47	columbia	columbia	PROPN
cblr-5119	499	48	addressed	address	VERB
cblr-5119	499	49	it	it	PRON
cblr-5119	499	50	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	499	51	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	499	52	same	same	ADJ
cblr-5119	499	53	litigation	litigation	NOUN
cblr-5119	499	54	on	on	ADP
cblr-5119	499	55	remand	remand	NOUN
cblr-5119	499	56	three	three	NUM
cblr-5119	499	57	years	year	NOUN
cblr-5119	499	58	later	later	ADV
cblr-5119	499	59	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	499	60	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	499	61	exxon	exxon	PROPN
cblr-5119	499	62	ii	ii	PROPN
cblr-5119	499	63	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	499	64	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	499	65	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	500	1	although	although	SCONJ
cblr-5119	500	2	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	500	3	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	500	4	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	500	5	discussion	discussion	NOUN
cblr-5119	500	6	can	can	AUX
cblr-5119	500	7	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	500	8	be	be	AUX
cblr-5119	500	9	considered	consider	VERB
cblr-5119	500	10	authoritative	authoritative	ADJ
cblr-5119	500	11	since	since	SCONJ
cblr-5119	500	12	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	500	13	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	500	14	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	500	15	appeals	appeals	PROPN
cblr-5119	500	16	has	have	AUX
cblr-5119	500	17	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	500	18	endorsed	endorse	VERB
cblr-5119	500	19	it	it	PRON
cblr-5119	500	20	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	500	21	it	it	PRON
cblr-5119	500	22	stands	stand	VERB
cblr-5119	500	23	as	as	ADP
cblr-5119	500	24	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	500	25	only	only	ADJ
cblr-5119	500	26	example	example	NOUN
cblr-5119	500	27	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	500	28	date	date	NOUN
cblr-5119	500	29	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	500	30	this	this	DET
cblr-5119	500	31	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	500	32	taking	take	VERB
cblr-5119	500	33	on	on	ADP
cblr-5119	500	34	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	500	35	issue	issue	NOUN
cblr-5119	500	36	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	501	1	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	501	2	case	case	NOUN
cblr-5119	501	3	involved	involve	VERB
cblr-5119	501	4	allegations	allegation	NOUN
cblr-5119	501	5	made	make	VERB
cblr-5119	501	6	by	by	ADP
cblr-5119	501	7	indonesian	indonesian	ADJ
cblr-5119	501	8	nationals	national	NOUN
cblr-5119	501	9	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	501	10	indonesian	indonesian	ADJ
cblr-5119	501	11	soldiers	soldier	NOUN
cblr-5119	501	12	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	501	13	hired	hire	VERB
cblr-5119	501	14	by	by	ADP
cblr-5119	501	15	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	501	16	four	four	NUM
cblr-5119	501	17	defendant	defendant	NOUN
cblr-5119	501	18	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	501	19	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	501	20	protect	protect	VERB
cblr-5119	501	21	their	their	PRON
cblr-5119	501	22	natural	natural	ADJ
cblr-5119	501	23	gas	gas	NOUN
cblr-5119	501	24	field	field	NOUN
cblr-5119	501	25	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	501	26	inflicted	inflict	VERB
cblr-5119	501	27	severe	severe	ADJ
cblr-5119	501	28	injuries	injury	NOUN
cblr-5119	501	29	on	on	ADP
cblr-5119	501	30	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	501	31	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
cblr-5119	501	32	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	501	33	some	some	PRON
cblr-5119	501	34	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	501	35	which	which	PRON
cblr-5119	501	36	resulted	result	VERB
cblr-5119	501	37	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	501	38	deaths	death	NOUN
cblr-5119	501	39	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	502	1	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	502	2	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
cblr-5119	502	3	accused	accuse	VERB
cblr-5119	502	4	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	502	5	defendants	defendant	NOUN
cblr-5119	502	6	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	502	7	several	several	ADJ
cblr-5119	502	8	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	502	9	which	which	PRON
cblr-5119	502	10	were	be	AUX
cblr-5119	502	11	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	502	12	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	502	13	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	502	14	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	502	15	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	502	16	providing	provide	VERB
cblr-5119	502	17	material	material	NOUN
cblr-5119	502	18	support	support	NOUN
cblr-5119	502	19	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	502	20	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	502	21	soldiers.184	soldiers.184	NOUN
cblr-5119	502	22	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	502	23	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	502	24	examined	examine	VERB
cblr-5119	502	25	how	how	SCONJ
cblr-5119	502	26	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	502	27	second	second	ADJ
cblr-5119	502	28	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	502	29	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	502	30	fourth	fourth	ADJ
cblr-5119	502	31	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	502	32	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	502	33	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	502	34	eleventh	eleventh	ADJ
cblr-5119	502	35	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	502	36	had	have	AUX
cblr-5119	502	37	handled	handle	VERB
cblr-5119	502	38	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	502	39	presumption	presumption	NOUN
cblr-5119	502	40	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	502	41	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	502	42	touch	touch	NOUN
cblr-5119	502	43	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-5119	502	44	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	502	45	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-5119	502	46	concern	concern	NOUN
cblr-5119	502	47	test	test	NOUN
cblr-5119	502	48	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	502	49	ultimately	ultimately	ADV
cblr-5119	502	50	concluded	conclude	VERB
cblr-5119	502	51	based	base	VERB
cblr-5119	502	52	on	on	ADP
cblr-5119	502	53	those	those	DET
cblr-5119	502	54	examples	example	NOUN
cblr-5119	502	55	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	502	56	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	502	57	defendant	defendant	NOUN
cblr-5119	502	58	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	502	59	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	502	60	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	502	61	citizenship	citizenship	NOUN
cblr-5119	502	62	alone	alone	ADV
cblr-5119	502	63	could	could	AUX
cblr-5119	502	64	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	502	65	displace	displace	VERB
cblr-5119	502	66	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	502	67	presumption	presumption	NOUN
cblr-5119	502	68	but	but	CCONJ
cblr-5119	502	69	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	502	70	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	502	71	presumption	presumption	NOUN
cblr-5119	502	72	could	could	AUX
cblr-5119	502	73	be	be	AUX
cblr-5119	502	74	displaced	displace	VERB
cblr-5119	502	75	if	if	SCONJ
cblr-5119	502	76	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
cblr-5119	502	77	alleged	allege	VERB
cblr-5119	502	78	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
cblr-5119	502	79	u.s.-based	u.s.-based	ADJ
cblr-5119	502	80	conduct.185	conduct.185	NOUN
cblr-5119	502	81	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	502	82	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	502	83	was	be	AUX
cblr-5119	502	84	clear	clear	ADJ
cblr-5119	502	85	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	502	86	if	if	SCONJ
cblr-5119	502	87	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	502	88	conduct	conduct	NOUN
cblr-5119	502	89	itself	itself	PRON
cblr-5119	502	90	constituted	constitute	VERB
cblr-5119	502	91	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	502	92	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	502	93	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	502	94	nations	nation	NOUN
cblr-5119	502	95	violation	violation	NOUN
cblr-5119	502	96	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	502	97	that	that	PRON
cblr-5119	502	98	would	would	AUX
cblr-5119	502	99	suffice	suffice	VERB
cblr-5119	502	100	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	502	101	displace	displace	VERB
cblr-5119	502	102	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	502	103	183	183	NUM
cblr-5119	502	104	see	see	NOUN
cblr-5119	502	105	i	i	PROPN
cblr-5119	502	106	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-5119	502	107	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	502	108	43–47	43–47	NUM
cblr-5119	502	109	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	502	110	discussing	discuss	VERB
cblr-5119	502	111	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	502	112	legislative	legislative	ADJ
cblr-5119	502	113	history	history	NOUN
cblr-5119	502	114	behind	behind	ADP
cblr-5119	502	115	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	502	116	ats	at	NOUN
cblr-5119	502	117	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	502	118	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	503	1	perhaps	perhaps	ADV
cblr-5119	503	2	because	because	SCONJ
cblr-5119	503	3	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	503	4	exxon	exxon	PROPN
cblr-5119	503	5	i	i	PRON
cblr-5119	503	6	defendant	defendant	NOUN
cblr-5119	503	7	relied	rely	VERB
cblr-5119	503	8	on	on	ADP
cblr-5119	503	9	kiobel	kiobel	PROPN
cblr-5119	503	10	i	i	PRON
cblr-5119	503	11	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	503	12	much	much	ADJ
cblr-5119	503	13	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	503	14	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	503	15	exxon	exxon	PROPN
cblr-5119	503	16	i	i	PROPN
cblr-5119	503	17	court	court	PROPN
cblr-5119	503	18	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	503	19	reasoning	reasoning	NOUN
cblr-5119	503	20	paralleled	parallel	VERB
cblr-5119	503	21	that	that	PRON
cblr-5119	503	22	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	503	23	judge	judge	PROPN
cblr-5119	503	24	leval	leval	PROPN
cblr-5119	503	25	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	503	26	kiobel	kiobel	PROPN
cblr-5119	503	27	i	i	PRON
cblr-5119	503	28	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	503	29	as	as	SCONJ
cblr-5119	503	30	did	do	VERB
cblr-5119	503	31	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	503	32	exxon	exxon	PROPN
cblr-5119	503	33	i	i	PROPN
cblr-5119	503	34	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	503	35	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	503	36	conclusion	conclusion	NOUN
cblr-5119	503	37	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	504	1	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	504	2	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	504	3	explained	explain	VERB
cblr-5119	504	4	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	504	5	kiobel	kiobel	NOUN
cblr-5119	504	6	i	i	PRON
cblr-5119	504	7	incorrectly	incorrectly	ADV
cblr-5119	504	8	concluded	conclude	VERB
cblr-5119	504	9	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	504	10	international	international	ADJ
cblr-5119	504	11	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	504	12	did	do	AUX
cblr-5119	504	13	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	504	14	recognize	recognize	VERB
cblr-5119	504	15	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	504	16	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	504	17	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	504	18	international	international	ADJ
cblr-5119	504	19	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	504	20	violations	violation	NOUN
cblr-5119	504	21	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	504	22	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	504	23	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	504	24	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	504	25	domestic	domestic	ADJ
cblr-5119	504	26	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	504	27	controlled	control	VERB
cblr-5119	504	28	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	504	29	issue	issue	NOUN
cblr-5119	504	30	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	504	31	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	504	32	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	504	33	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	504	34	adhering	adhere	VERB
cblr-5119	504	35	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	504	36	federal	federal	ADJ
cblr-5119	504	37	common	common	ADJ
cblr-5119	504	38	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	504	39	principles	principle	NOUN
cblr-5119	504	40	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	504	41	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	504	42	were	be	AUX
cblr-5119	504	43	categorically	categorically	ADV
cblr-5119	504	44	liable	liable	ADJ
cblr-5119	504	45	under	under	ADP
cblr-5119	504	46	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	504	47	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	504	48	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	505	1	i	i	PRON
cblr-5119	505	2	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-5119	505	3	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	505	4	50–51	50–51	NUM
cblr-5119	505	5	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	505	6	57	57	NUM
cblr-5119	505	7	.	.	X
cblr-5119	506	1	184	184	NUM
cblr-5119	506	2	doe	doe	NOUN
cblr-5119	506	3	v.	v.	ADP
cblr-5119	506	4	exxon	exxon	PROPN
cblr-5119	506	5	mobil	mobil	PROPN
cblr-5119	506	6	corp	corp	PROPN
cblr-5119	506	7	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	506	8	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	506	9	69	69	NUM
cblr-5119	506	10	f.	f.	PROPN
cblr-5119	506	11	supp	supp	PROPN
cblr-5119	506	12	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	507	1	3d	3d	PROPN
cblr-5119	507	2	75	75	NUM
cblr-5119	507	3	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	507	4	83–84	83–84	NOUN
cblr-5119	507	5	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	507	6	d.d.c	d.d.c	PROPN
cblr-5119	507	7	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	507	8	2014	2014	NUM
cblr-5119	507	9	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	507	10	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	508	1	185	185	NUM
cblr-5119	509	1	i	i	PRON
cblr-5119	509	2	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-5119	509	3	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	509	4	95–96	95–96	NUM
cblr-5119	509	5	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	510	1	6_2019.3_estes	6_2019.3_estes	NUM
cblr-5119	510	2	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	510	3	do	do	AUX
cblr-5119	510	4	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	510	5	delte	delte	VERB
cblr-5119	510	6	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	510	7	12/26/2019	12/26/2019	NUM
cblr-5119	510	8	12:00	12:00	NUM
cblr-5119	510	9	am	am	NOUN
cblr-5119	511	1	1068	1068	NUM
cblr-5119	511	2	columbia	columbia	PROPN
cblr-5119	511	3	business	business	NOUN
cblr-5119	511	4	law	law	PROPN
cblr-5119	511	5	review	review	NOUN
cblr-5119	511	6	[	[	X
cblr-5119	511	7	vol	vol	NOUN
cblr-5119	511	8	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	511	9	2019	2019	NUM
cblr-5119	511	10	presumption.186	presumption.186	VERB
cblr-5119	511	11	however	however	ADV
cblr-5119	511	12	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	511	13	it	it	PRON
cblr-5119	511	14	did	do	AUX
cblr-5119	511	15	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	511	16	shed	shed	VERB
cblr-5119	511	17	much	much	ADJ
cblr-5119	511	18	light	light	NOUN
cblr-5119	511	19	on	on	ADP
cblr-5119	511	20	what	what	DET
cblr-5119	511	21	conduct	conduct	NOUN
cblr-5119	511	22	below	below	ADP
cblr-5119	511	23	that	that	DET
cblr-5119	511	24	marker	marker	NOUN
cblr-5119	511	25	would	would	AUX
cblr-5119	511	26	suffice	suffice	VERB
cblr-5119	511	27	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	512	1	despite	despite	SCONJ
cblr-5119	512	2	this	this	PRON
cblr-5119	512	3	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	512	4	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	512	5	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	512	6	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	512	7	evaluation	evaluation	NOUN
cblr-5119	512	8	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	512	9	certain	certain	ADJ
cblr-5119	512	10	conduct	conduct	NOUN
cblr-5119	512	11	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	512	12	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	512	13	decision	decision	NOUN
cblr-5119	512	14	may	may	AUX
cblr-5119	512	15	be	be	AUX
cblr-5119	512	16	instructive	instructive	ADJ
cblr-5119	512	17	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	513	1	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	513	2	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
cblr-5119	513	3	alleged	allege	VERB
cblr-5119	513	4	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	513	5	one	one	NUM
cblr-5119	513	6	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	513	7	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	513	8	defendants	defendant	NOUN
cblr-5119	513	9	provided	provide	VERB
cblr-5119	513	10	material	material	NOUN
cblr-5119	513	11	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	513	12	monetary	monetary	ADJ
cblr-5119	513	13	support	support	NOUN
cblr-5119	513	14	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	513	15	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	513	16	indonesian	indonesian	ADJ
cblr-5119	513	17	security	security	NOUN
cblr-5119	513	18	force	force	NOUN
cblr-5119	513	19	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	513	20	but	but	CCONJ
cblr-5119	513	21	it	it	PRON
cblr-5119	513	22	was	be	AUX
cblr-5119	513	23	unclear	unclear	ADJ
cblr-5119	513	24	if	if	SCONJ
cblr-5119	513	25	that	that	DET
cblr-5119	513	26	support	support	NOUN
cblr-5119	513	27	came	come	VERB
cblr-5119	513	28	from	from	ADP
cblr-5119	513	29	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	513	30	united	united	PROPN
cblr-5119	513	31	states.187	states.187	PROPN
cblr-5119	513	32	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	513	33	opinion	opinion	NOUN
cblr-5119	513	34	seems	seem	VERB
cblr-5119	513	35	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	513	36	imply	imply	VERB
cblr-5119	513	37	that	that	PRON
cblr-5119	513	38	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	513	39	if	if	SCONJ
cblr-5119	513	40	said	say	VERB
cblr-5119	513	41	support	support	NOUN
cblr-5119	513	42	did	do	AUX
cblr-5119	513	43	come	come	VERB
cblr-5119	513	44	from	from	ADP
cblr-5119	513	45	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	513	46	united	united	PROPN
cblr-5119	513	47	states	states	PROPN
cblr-5119	513	48	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	513	49	this	this	PRON
cblr-5119	513	50	could	could	AUX
cblr-5119	513	51	weigh	weigh	VERB
cblr-5119	513	52	toward	toward	ADP
cblr-5119	513	53	displacing	displace	VERB
cblr-5119	513	54	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	513	55	presumption	presumption	NOUN
cblr-5119	513	56	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	514	1	188	188	NUM
cblr-5119	514	2	this	this	PRON
cblr-5119	514	3	would	would	AUX
cblr-5119	514	4	potentially	potentially	ADV
cblr-5119	514	5	align	align	VERB
cblr-5119	514	6	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	514	7	d.c	d.c	PROPN
cblr-5119	514	8	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	514	9	circuit	circuit	PROPN
cblr-5119	514	10	with	with	ADP
cblr-5119	514	11	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	514	12	ninth	ninth	ADJ
cblr-5119	514	13	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	514	14	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	514	15	which	which	PRON
cblr-5119	514	16	requires	require	VERB
cblr-5119	514	17	some	some	DET
cblr-5119	514	18	relevant	relevant	ADJ
cblr-5119	514	19	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	514	20	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	514	21	conduct	conduct	NOUN
cblr-5119	514	22	under	under	ADP
cblr-5119	514	23	mujica	mujica	PROPN
cblr-5119	514	24	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	514	25	nestle	nestle	PROPN
cblr-5119	514	26	ii.189	ii.189	PROPN
cblr-5119	514	27	186	186	NUM
cblr-5119	514	28	i	i	PROPN
cblr-5119	514	29	d.	d.	NOUN
cblr-5119	514	30	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	514	31	95	95	NUM
cblr-5119	514	32	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	514	33	stating	state	VERB
cblr-5119	514	34	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	514	35	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	514	36	when	when	SCONJ
cblr-5119	514	37	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
cblr-5119	514	38	allege	allege	VERB
cblr-5119	514	39	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	514	40	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	514	41	based	base	VERB
cblr-5119	514	42	conduct	conduct	NOUN
cblr-5119	514	43	itself	itself	PRON
cblr-5119	514	44	constituting	constitute	VERB
cblr-5119	514	45	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	514	46	violation	violation	NOUN
cblr-5119	514	47	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	514	48	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	514	49	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	514	50	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	514	51	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	514	52	presumption	presumption	NOUN
cblr-5119	514	53	against	against	ADP
cblr-5119	514	54	extraterritoriality	extraterritoriality	NOUN
cblr-5119	514	55	is	be	AUX
cblr-5119	514	56	no	no	DET
cblr-5119	514	57	obstacle	obstacle	NOUN
cblr-5119	514	58	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	514	59	consideration	consideration	NOUN
cblr-5119	514	60	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	514	61	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	514	62	claims	claim	NOUN
cblr-5119	514	63	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	514	64	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	514	65	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	515	1	187	187	NUM
cblr-5119	516	1	i	i	PRON
cblr-5119	516	2	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-5119	516	3	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	516	4	96	96	NUM
cblr-5119	516	5	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	517	1	188	188	NUM
cblr-5119	517	2	see	see	VERB
cblr-5119	517	3	i	i	PRON
cblr-5119	517	4	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-5119	517	5	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	517	6	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	517	7	specifically	specifically	ADV
cblr-5119	517	8	identified	identify	VERB
cblr-5119	517	9	this	this	DET
cblr-5119	517	10	conduct	conduct	NOUN
cblr-5119	517	11	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	517	12	stated	state	VERB
cblr-5119	517	13	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	517	14	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	517	15	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
cblr-5119	517	16	neglected	neglect	VERB
cblr-5119	517	17	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	517	18	say	say	VERB
cblr-5119	517	19	whether	whether	SCONJ
cblr-5119	517	20	it	it	PRON
cblr-5119	517	21	occurred	occur	VERB
cblr-5119	517	22	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	517	23	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	517	24	united	united	PROPN
cblr-5119	517	25	states	states	PROPN
cblr-5119	517	26	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	517	27	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	517	28	then	then	ADV
cblr-5119	517	29	decided	decide	VERB
cblr-5119	517	30	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	517	31	allow	allow	VERB
cblr-5119	517	32	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	517	33	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
cblr-5119	517	34	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	517	35	amend	amend	VERB
cblr-5119	517	36	their	their	PRON
cblr-5119	517	37	complaint	complaint	NOUN
cblr-5119	517	38	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	518	1	it	it	PRON
cblr-5119	518	2	follows	follow	VERB
cblr-5119	518	3	from	from	ADP
cblr-5119	518	4	this	this	PRON
cblr-5119	518	5	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	518	6	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	518	7	conduct	conduct	NOUN
cblr-5119	518	8	could	could	AUX
cblr-5119	518	9	be	be	AUX
cblr-5119	518	10	relevant	relevant	ADJ
cblr-5119	518	11	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	518	12	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	518	13	presumption	presumption	NOUN
cblr-5119	518	14	analysis	analysis	NOUN
cblr-5119	518	15	if	if	SCONJ
cblr-5119	518	16	it	it	PRON
cblr-5119	518	17	indeed	indeed	ADV
cblr-5119	518	18	occurred	occur	VERB
cblr-5119	518	19	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	518	20	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	518	21	united	united	PROPN
cblr-5119	518	22	states	states	PROPN
cblr-5119	518	23	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	519	1	189	189	NUM
cblr-5119	519	2	like	like	ADP
cblr-5119	519	3	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	519	4	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	519	5	ninth	ninth	ADJ
cblr-5119	519	6	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	519	7	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	519	8	it	it	PRON
cblr-5119	519	9	appears	appear	VERB
cblr-5119	519	10	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	519	11	jesner	jesner	NOUN
cblr-5119	519	12	will	will	AUX
cblr-5119	519	13	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	519	14	affect	affect	VERB
cblr-5119	519	15	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	519	16	d.c	d.c	PROPN
cblr-5119	519	17	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	519	18	circuit	circuit	PROPN
cblr-5119	519	19	court	court	PROPN
cblr-5119	519	20	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	519	21	appeals	appeal	NOUN
cblr-5119	519	22	’	'	PUNCT
cblr-5119	519	23	approach	approach	NOUN
cblr-5119	519	24	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	519	25	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	519	26	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	519	27	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	519	28	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	519	29	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	519	30	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	519	31	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	519	32	though	though	SCONJ
cblr-5119	519	33	this	this	PRON
cblr-5119	519	34	is	be	AUX
cblr-5119	519	35	less	less	ADV
cblr-5119	519	36	clear	clear	ADJ
cblr-5119	519	37	than	than	ADP
cblr-5119	519	38	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	519	39	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	519	40	ninth	ninth	ADJ
cblr-5119	519	41	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	519	42	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	520	1	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	520	2	kaplan	kaplan	PROPN
cblr-5119	520	3	v.	v.	PROPN
cblr-5119	520	4	central	central	PROPN
cblr-5119	520	5	bank	bank	PROPN
cblr-5119	520	6	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	520	7	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	520	8	republic	republic	NOUN
cblr-5119	520	9	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	520	10	iran	iran	PROPN
cblr-5119	520	11	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	520	12	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	520	13	d.c	d.c	PROPN
cblr-5119	520	14	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	520	15	circuit	circuit	PROPN
cblr-5119	520	16	court	court	PROPN
cblr-5119	520	17	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	520	18	appeals	appeal	NOUN
cblr-5119	520	19	specifically	specifically	ADV
cblr-5119	520	20	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	520	21	repeatedly	repeatedly	ADV
cblr-5119	520	22	referred	refer	VERB
cblr-5119	520	23	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	520	24	jesner	jesner	VERB
cblr-5119	520	25	as	as	ADP
cblr-5119	520	26	addressing	address	VERB
cblr-5119	520	27	only	only	ADV
cblr-5119	520	28	foreign	foreign	ADJ
cblr-5119	520	29	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	520	30	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	520	31	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	520	32	albeit	albeit	SCONJ
cblr-5119	520	33	while	while	SCONJ
cblr-5119	520	34	discussing	discuss	VERB
cblr-5119	520	35	an	an	DET
cblr-5119	520	36	ancillary	ancillary	ADJ
cblr-5119	520	37	issue	issue	NOUN
cblr-5119	520	38	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	521	1	kaplan	kaplan	PROPN
cblr-5119	521	2	v.	v.	PROPN
cblr-5119	521	3	cent	cent	PROPN
cblr-5119	521	4	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	522	1	bank	bank	PROPN
cblr-5119	522	2	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	522	3	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	522	4	islamic	islamic	PROPN
cblr-5119	522	5	republic	republic	PROPN
cblr-5119	522	6	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	522	7	iran	iran	PROPN
cblr-5119	522	8	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	522	9	896	896	NUM
cblr-5119	522	10	f.3d	f.3d	NUM
cblr-5119	522	11	501	501	NUM
cblr-5119	522	12	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	522	13	515–16	515–16	NOUN
cblr-5119	522	14	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	522	15	d.c	d.c	PROPN
cblr-5119	522	16	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	522	17	cir	cir	PROPN
cblr-5119	522	18	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	522	19	2018	2018	NUM
cblr-5119	522	20	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	522	21	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	523	1	however	however	ADV
cblr-5119	523	2	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	523	3	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	523	4	recent	recent	ADJ
cblr-5119	523	5	d.c	d.c	PROPN
cblr-5119	523	6	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	523	7	district	district	PROPN
cblr-5119	523	8	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	523	9	decision	decision	NOUN
cblr-5119	523	10	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	523	11	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	523	12	exxon	exxon	PROPN
cblr-5119	523	13	litigation	litigation	PROPN
cblr-5119	523	14	has	have	AUX
cblr-5119	523	15	clouded	cloud	VERB
cblr-5119	523	16	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	523	17	picture	picture	NOUN
cblr-5119	523	18	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	524	1	despite	despite	SCONJ
cblr-5119	524	2	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	524	3	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	524	4	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	524	5	appeals	appeal	NOUN
cblr-5119	524	6	’	'	PUNCT
cblr-5119	524	7	assertion	assertion	NOUN
cblr-5119	524	8	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	524	9	jesner	jesner	PROPN
cblr-5119	524	10	addressed	address	VERB
cblr-5119	524	11	only	only	ADV
cblr-5119	524	12	foreign	foreign	ADJ
cblr-5119	524	13	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	524	14	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	524	15	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	524	16	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	524	17	district	district	NOUN
cblr-5119	524	18	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	524	19	concluded	conclude	VERB
cblr-5119	524	20	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	524	21	it	it	PRON
cblr-5119	524	22	was	be	AUX
cblr-5119	524	23	appropriate	appropriate	ADJ
cblr-5119	524	24	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	524	25	re	re	VERB
cblr-5119	524	26	-	-	VERB
cblr-5119	524	27	examine	examine	VERB
cblr-5119	524	28	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	524	29	defendant	defendant	NOUN
cblr-5119	524	30	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	524	31	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	524	32	corporation	corporation	PROPN
cblr-5119	524	33	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	524	34	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	524	35	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	524	36	because	because	SCONJ
cblr-5119	524	37	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	524	38	jesner	jesner	PROPN
cblr-5119	524	39	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	525	1	doe	doe	NOUN
cblr-5119	525	2	v.	v.	CCONJ
cblr-5119	525	3	exxon	exxon	PROPN
cblr-5119	525	4	mobil	mobil	PROPN
cblr-5119	525	5	corp	corp	PROPN
cblr-5119	525	6	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	525	7	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	525	8	391	391	NUM
cblr-5119	525	9	f.	f.	PROPN
cblr-5119	525	10	supp	supp	PROPN
cblr-5119	525	11	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	526	1	3d	3d	PROPN
cblr-5119	526	2	76	76	NUM
cblr-5119	526	3	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	526	4	84–85	84–85	NUM
cblr-5119	526	5	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	526	6	d.d.c	d.d.c	PROPN
cblr-5119	526	7	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	526	8	2019	2019	NUM
cblr-5119	526	9	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	526	10	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	527	1	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	527	2	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	527	3	analyzed	analyze	VERB
cblr-5119	527	4	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	527	5	defendant	defendant	NOUN
cblr-5119	527	6	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	527	7	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	527	8	using	use	VERB
cblr-5119	527	9	two	two	NUM
cblr-5119	527	10	separate	separate	ADJ
cblr-5119	527	11	lines	line	NOUN
cblr-5119	527	12	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	527	13	inquiry	inquiry	NOUN
cblr-5119	527	14	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	527	15	without	without	ADP
cblr-5119	527	16	stating	state	VERB
cblr-5119	527	17	which	which	DET
cblr-5119	527	18	line	line	NOUN
cblr-5119	527	19	was	be	AUX
cblr-5119	527	20	determinative	determinative	ADJ
cblr-5119	527	21	:	:	PUNCT
cblr-5119	527	22	one	one	NUM
cblr-5119	527	23	based	base	VERB
cblr-5119	527	24	on	on	ADP
cblr-5119	527	25	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	527	26	portion	portion	NOUN
cblr-5119	527	27	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	527	28	jesner	jesner	NOUN
cblr-5119	527	29	that	that	PRON
cblr-5119	527	30	received	receive	VERB
cblr-5119	527	31	five	five	NUM
cblr-5119	527	32	votes	vote	NOUN
cblr-5119	527	33	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	527	34	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	527	35	one	one	NUM
cblr-5119	527	36	based	base	VERB
cblr-5119	527	37	on	on	ADP
cblr-5119	527	38	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	527	39	jesner	jesner	NOUN
cblr-5119	527	40	plurality	plurality	NOUN
cblr-5119	527	41	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	527	42	approach	approach	NOUN
cblr-5119	527	43	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	528	1	i	i	PRON
cblr-5119	528	2	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-5119	528	3	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	528	4	85	85	NUM
cblr-5119	528	5	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	529	1	under	under	ADP
cblr-5119	529	2	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	529	3	first	first	ADJ
cblr-5119	529	4	line	line	NOUN
cblr-5119	529	5	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	529	6	inquiry	inquiry	NOUN
cblr-5119	529	7	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	529	8	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	529	9	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	529	10	declined	decline	VERB
cblr-5119	529	11	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	529	12	recognize	recognize	VERB
cblr-5119	529	13	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	529	14	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	529	15	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	529	16	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	529	17	because	because	SCONJ
cblr-5119	529	18	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	529	19	present	present	ADJ
cblr-5119	529	20	case	case	NOUN
cblr-5119	529	21	had	have	AUX
cblr-5119	529	22	caused	cause	VERB
cblr-5119	529	23	significant	significant	ADJ
cblr-5119	529	24	diplomatic	diplomatic	ADJ
cblr-5119	529	25	strife	strife	NOUN
cblr-5119	529	26	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	529	27	as	as	SCONJ
cblr-5119	529	28	evidenced	evidence	VERB
cblr-5119	529	29	by	by	ADP
cblr-5119	529	30	various	various	ADJ
cblr-5119	529	31	filings	filing	NOUN
cblr-5119	529	32	from	from	ADP
cblr-5119	529	33	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	529	34	executive	executive	ADJ
cblr-5119	529	35	branch	branch	NOUN
cblr-5119	529	36	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	529	37	indonesia	indonesia	PROPN
cblr-5119	529	38	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	530	1	i	i	PRON
cblr-5119	530	2	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-5119	530	3	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	530	4	85–87	85–87	NUM
cblr-5119	530	5	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	531	1	under	under	ADP
cblr-5119	531	2	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	531	3	second	second	ADJ
cblr-5119	531	4	line	line	NOUN
cblr-5119	531	5	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	531	6	inquiry	inquiry	NOUN
cblr-5119	531	7	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	531	8	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	531	9	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	531	10	examined	examine	VERB
cblr-5119	531	11	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	531	12	two	two	NUM
cblr-5119	531	13	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-5119	531	14	part	part	NOUN
cblr-5119	531	15	test	test	NOUN
cblr-5119	531	16	that	that	PRON
cblr-5119	531	17	sosa	sosa	PROPN
cblr-5119	531	18	ostensibly	ostensibly	ADV
cblr-5119	531	19	mandated	mandate	VERB
cblr-5119	531	20	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	532	1	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	532	2	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	532	3	first	first	ADJ
cblr-5119	532	4	step	step	NOUN
cblr-5119	532	5	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	532	6	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	532	7	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	532	8	found	find	VERB
cblr-5119	532	9	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	532	10	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	532	11	could	could	AUX
cblr-5119	532	12	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	532	13	be	be	AUX
cblr-5119	532	14	liable	liable	ADJ
cblr-5119	532	15	under	under	ADP
cblr-5119	532	16	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	532	17	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	532	18	because	because	SCONJ
cblr-5119	532	19	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	532	20	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	532	21	is	be	AUX
cblr-5119	532	22	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	532	23	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	532	24	specific	specific	ADJ
cblr-5119	532	25	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	532	26	universal	universal	ADJ
cblr-5119	532	27	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	532	28	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	532	29	obligatory	obligatory	ADJ
cblr-5119	532	30	norm	norm	NOUN
cblr-5119	532	31	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	532	32	international	international	ADJ
cblr-5119	532	33	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	532	34	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	533	1	i	i	PRON
cblr-5119	533	2	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-5119	533	3	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	533	4	87–91	87–91	NUM
cblr-5119	533	5	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	534	1	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	534	2	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	534	3	second	second	ADJ
cblr-5119	534	4	step	step	NOUN
cblr-5119	534	5	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	534	6	6_2019.3_estes	6_2019.3_estes	NUM
cblr-5119	534	7	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	534	8	do	do	AUX
cblr-5119	534	9	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	534	10	delete	delete	VERB
cblr-5119	534	11	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	534	12	12/26/2019	12/26/2019	NUM
cblr-5119	534	13	12:00	12:00	NUM
cblr-5119	534	14	am	be	AUX
cblr-5119	534	15	no	no	NOUN
cblr-5119	534	16	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	535	1	3:1031	3:1031	NUM
cblr-5119	535	2	]	]	X
cblr-5119	535	3	may	may	AUX
cblr-5119	535	4	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	535	5	fourth	fourth	ADJ
cblr-5119	535	6	be	be	AUX
cblr-5119	535	7	with	with	ADP
cblr-5119	535	8	you	you	PRON
cblr-5119	535	9	1069	1069	NUM
cblr-5119	535	10	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	535	11	above	above	ADJ
cblr-5119	535	12	discussion	discussion	NOUN
cblr-5119	535	13	illustrates	illustrate	VERB
cblr-5119	535	14	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	535	15	circuits	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	535	16	’	'	PUNCT
cblr-5119	535	17	varying	vary	VERB
cblr-5119	535	18	approaches	approach	NOUN
cblr-5119	535	19	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	535	20	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	535	21	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	535	22	under	under	ADP
cblr-5119	535	23	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	535	24	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	535	25	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	535	26	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	535	27	requirements	requirement	NOUN
cblr-5119	535	28	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	535	29	rebutting	rebut	VERB
cblr-5119	535	30	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	535	31	presumption	presumption	NOUN
cblr-5119	535	32	against	against	ADP
cblr-5119	535	33	extraterritoriality	extraterritoriality	NOUN
cblr-5119	535	34	as	as	SCONJ
cblr-5119	535	35	applied	apply	VERB
cblr-5119	535	36	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	535	37	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	535	38	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	535	39	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	536	1	it	it	PRON
cblr-5119	536	2	also	also	ADV
cblr-5119	536	3	reveals	reveal	VERB
cblr-5119	536	4	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	536	5	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	536	6	among	among	ADP
cblr-5119	536	7	those	those	DET
cblr-5119	536	8	circuits	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	536	9	that	that	PRON
cblr-5119	536	10	have	have	AUX
cblr-5119	536	11	addressed	address	VERB
cblr-5119	536	12	jesner	jesner	NOUN
cblr-5119	536	13	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	536	14	courts	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	536	15	are	be	AUX
cblr-5119	536	16	largely	largely	ADV
cblr-5119	536	17	hewing	hew	VERB
cblr-5119	536	18	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	536	19	jesner	jesner	PROPN
cblr-5119	536	20	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	536	21	narrow	narrow	ADJ
cblr-5119	536	22	holding	hold	VERB
cblr-5119	536	23	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	536	24	foreign	foreign	ADJ
cblr-5119	536	25	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	536	26	are	be	AUX
cblr-5119	536	27	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	536	28	liable	liable	ADJ
cblr-5119	536	29	under	under	ADP
cblr-5119	536	30	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	536	31	ats	at	NOUN
cblr-5119	536	32	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	536	33	are	be	AUX
cblr-5119	536	34	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	536	35	using	use	VERB
cblr-5119	536	36	jesner	jesner	NOUN
cblr-5119	536	37	as	as	ADP
cblr-5119	536	38	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	536	39	reason	reason	NOUN
cblr-5119	536	40	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	536	41	alter	alter	VERB
cblr-5119	536	42	their	their	PRON
cblr-5119	536	43	approaches	approach	NOUN
cblr-5119	536	44	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	536	45	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	536	46	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	536	47	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	536	48	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	537	1	going	go	VERB
cblr-5119	537	2	forward	forward	ADV
cblr-5119	537	3	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	537	4	this	this	DET
cblr-5119	537	5	development	development	NOUN
cblr-5119	537	6	indicates	indicate	VERB
cblr-5119	537	7	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	537	8	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	537	9	circuits	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	537	10	will	will	AUX
cblr-5119	537	11	likely	likely	ADV
cblr-5119	537	12	still	still	ADV
cblr-5119	537	13	be	be	AUX
cblr-5119	537	14	using	use	VERB
cblr-5119	537	15	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	537	16	analytical	analytical	ADJ
cblr-5119	537	17	regimes	regime	NOUN
cblr-5119	537	18	described	describe	VERB
cblr-5119	537	19	above	above	ADP
cblr-5119	537	20	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	537	21	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	537	22	cases	case	NOUN
cblr-5119	537	23	involving	involve	VERB
cblr-5119	537	24	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	537	25	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	537	26	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	537	27	defendants	defendant	NOUN
cblr-5119	537	28	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	538	1	iv	iv	X
cblr-5119	538	2	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	539	1	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	539	2	supreme	supreme	PROPN
cblr-5119	539	3	court	court	PROPN
cblr-5119	539	4	should	should	AUX
cblr-5119	539	5	adopt	adopt	VERB
cblr-5119	539	6	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	539	7	fourth	fourth	ADJ
cblr-5119	539	8	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	539	9	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	539	10	regime	regime	NOUN
cblr-5119	539	11	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	539	12	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	539	13	ats	at	NOUN
cblr-5119	539	14	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	539	15	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	539	16	fourth	fourth	ADJ
cblr-5119	539	17	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	539	18	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	539	19	approach	approach	NOUN
cblr-5119	539	20	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	539	21	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	539	22	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	539	23	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	539	24	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	539	25	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	539	26	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	539	27	presumption	presumption	NOUN
cblr-5119	539	28	against	against	ADP
cblr-5119	539	29	extraterritoriality	extraterritoriality	NOUN
cblr-5119	539	30	under	under	ADP
cblr-5119	539	31	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	539	32	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	539	33	should	should	AUX
cblr-5119	539	34	be	be	AUX
cblr-5119	539	35	adopted	adopt	VERB
cblr-5119	539	36	by	by	ADP
cblr-5119	539	37	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	539	38	supreme	supreme	PROPN
cblr-5119	539	39	court	court	PROPN
cblr-5119	539	40	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	540	1	legal	legal	ADJ
cblr-5119	540	2	considerations	consideration	NOUN
cblr-5119	540	3	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	540	4	policy	policy	NOUN
cblr-5119	540	5	considerations	consideration	NOUN
cblr-5119	540	6	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	540	7	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	540	8	foreign	foreign	ADJ
cblr-5119	540	9	relations	relation	NOUN
cblr-5119	540	10	considerations	consideration	NOUN
cblr-5119	540	11	all	all	PRON
cblr-5119	540	12	argue	argue	VERB
cblr-5119	540	13	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	540	14	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	540	15	widest	wide	ADJ
cblr-5119	540	16	possible	possible	ADJ
cblr-5119	540	17	application	application	NOUN
cblr-5119	540	18	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	540	19	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	540	20	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	540	21	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	540	22	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	540	23	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	541	1	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	541	2	this	this	DET
cblr-5119	541	3	light	light	NOUN
cblr-5119	541	4	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	541	5	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	541	6	fourth	fourth	ADJ
cblr-5119	541	7	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	541	8	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	541	9	approach	approach	NOUN
cblr-5119	541	10	is	be	AUX
cblr-5119	541	11	ideal	ideal	ADJ
cblr-5119	541	12	because	because	SCONJ
cblr-5119	541	13	it	it	PRON
cblr-5119	541	14	involves	involve	VERB
cblr-5119	541	15	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	541	16	most	most	ADV
cblr-5119	541	17	liberal	liberal	ADJ
cblr-5119	541	18	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	541	19	flexible	flexible	ADJ
cblr-5119	541	20	regime190	regime190	PROPN
cblr-5119	541	21	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	541	22	deciding	decide	VERB
cblr-5119	541	23	when	when	SCONJ
cblr-5119	541	24	claims	claim	NOUN
cblr-5119	541	25	against	against	ADP
cblr-5119	541	26	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	541	27	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	541	28	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	541	29	should	should	AUX
cblr-5119	541	30	overcome	overcome	VERB
cblr-5119	541	31	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	541	32	presumption	presumption	NOUN
cblr-5119	541	33	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	541	34	while	while	SCONJ
cblr-5119	541	35	simultaneously	simultaneously	ADV
cblr-5119	541	36	allowing	allow	VERB
cblr-5119	541	37	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	541	38	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
cblr-5119	541	39	safeguards	safeguard	NOUN
cblr-5119	541	40	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	541	41	prevent	prevent	VERB
cblr-5119	541	42	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	541	43	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	541	44	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	541	45	overapplication.191	overapplication.191	NOUN
cblr-5119	541	46	unlike	unlike	ADP
cblr-5119	541	47	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	541	48	other	other	ADJ
cblr-5119	541	49	circuits	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	541	50	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	541	51	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	541	52	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	541	53	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	541	54	found	find	VERB
cblr-5119	541	55	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	541	56	allowing	allow	VERB
cblr-5119	541	57	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	541	58	case	case	NOUN
cblr-5119	541	59	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	541	60	proceed	proceed	VERB
cblr-5119	541	61	would	would	AUX
cblr-5119	541	62	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	541	63	be	be	AUX
cblr-5119	541	64	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	541	65	proper	proper	ADJ
cblr-5119	541	66	exercise	exercise	NOUN
cblr-5119	541	67	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	541	68	judicial	judicial	ADJ
cblr-5119	541	69	discretion	discretion	NOUN
cblr-5119	541	70	due	due	ADP
cblr-5119	541	71	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	541	72	foreign	foreign	ADJ
cblr-5119	541	73	policy	policy	NOUN
cblr-5119	541	74	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	541	75	separation	separation	NOUN
cblr-5119	541	76	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	541	77	powers	power	NOUN
cblr-5119	541	78	concerns	concern	NOUN
cblr-5119	541	79	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	542	1	i	i	PRON
cblr-5119	542	2	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-5119	542	3	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	542	4	91–93	91–93	NUM
cblr-5119	542	5	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	543	1	should	should	AUX
cblr-5119	543	2	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	543	3	d.c	d.c	PROPN
cblr-5119	543	4	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	543	5	circuit	circuit	PROPN
cblr-5119	543	6	court	court	PROPN
cblr-5119	543	7	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	543	8	appeals	appeal	NOUN
cblr-5119	543	9	adopt	adopt	VERB
cblr-5119	543	10	either	either	ADV
cblr-5119	543	11	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	543	12	these	these	DET
cblr-5119	543	13	approaches	approach	NOUN
cblr-5119	543	14	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	543	15	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	543	16	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	543	17	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	543	18	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	543	19	regime	regime	NOUN
cblr-5119	543	20	would	would	AUX
cblr-5119	543	21	become	become	VERB
cblr-5119	543	22	much	much	ADV
cblr-5119	543	23	more	more	ADV
cblr-5119	543	24	restrictive	restrictive	ADJ
cblr-5119	543	25	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	543	26	especially	especially	ADV
cblr-5119	543	27	if	if	SCONJ
cblr-5119	543	28	it	it	PRON
cblr-5119	543	29	adopts	adopt	VERB
cblr-5119	543	30	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	543	31	second	second	ADJ
cblr-5119	543	32	line	line	NOUN
cblr-5119	543	33	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	543	34	inquiry	inquiry	NOUN
cblr-5119	543	35	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	544	1	190	190	NUM
cblr-5119	544	2	see	see	NOUN
cblr-5119	544	3	note	note	NOUN
cblr-5119	544	4	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	544	5	supra	supra	PROPN
cblr-5119	544	6	note	note	PROPN
cblr-5119	544	7	62	62	NUM
cblr-5119	544	8	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	544	9	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	544	10	1919	1919	NUM
cblr-5119	544	11	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	545	1	191	191	NUM
cblr-5119	545	2	some	some	PRON
cblr-5119	545	3	have	have	AUX
cblr-5119	545	4	argued	argue	VERB
cblr-5119	545	5	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	545	6	an	an	DET
cblr-5119	545	7	even	even	ADV
cblr-5119	545	8	more	more	ADV
cblr-5119	545	9	forgiving	forgiving	ADJ
cblr-5119	545	10	regime	regime	NOUN
cblr-5119	545	11	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	545	12	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	545	13	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	545	14	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	545	15	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	546	1	see	see	VERB
cblr-5119	546	2	kiobel	kiobel	PROPN
cblr-5119	546	3	v.	v.	ADP
cblr-5119	546	4	royal	royal	PROPN
cblr-5119	546	5	dutch	dutch	PROPN
cblr-5119	546	6	petroleum	petroleum	PROPN
cblr-5119	546	7	co.	co.	PROPN
cblr-5119	546	8	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	546	9	569	569	NUM
cblr-5119	546	10	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	546	11	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	546	12	108	108	NUM
cblr-5119	546	13	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	546	14	127	127	NUM
cblr-5119	546	15	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	546	16	2013	2013	NUM
cblr-5119	546	17	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	546	18	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	546	19	breyer	breyer	NOUN
cblr-5119	546	20	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	546	21	j.	j.	PROPN
cblr-5119	546	22	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	546	23	concurring	concur	VERB
cblr-5119	546	24	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	546	25	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	546	26	arguing	argue	VERB
cblr-5119	546	27	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	546	28	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	546	29	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NOUN
cblr-5119	546	30	when	when	SCONJ
cblr-5119	546	31	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	546	32	alleged	allege	VERB
cblr-5119	546	33	tort	tort	NOUN
cblr-5119	546	34	occurs	occur	VERB
cblr-5119	546	35	on	on	ADP
cblr-5119	546	36	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	546	37	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	546	38	soil	soil	NOUN
cblr-5119	546	39	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	546	40	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	546	41	defendant	defendant	NOUN
cblr-5119	546	42	is	be	AUX
cblr-5119	546	43	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	546	44	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	546	45	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	546	46	national	national	PROPN
cblr-5119	546	47	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	546	48	or	or	CCONJ
cblr-5119	546	49	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	546	50	defendant	defendant	NOUN
cblr-5119	546	51	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	546	52	conduct	conduct	NOUN
cblr-5119	546	53	substantially	substantially	ADV
cblr-5119	546	54	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	546	55	adversely	adversely	ADV
cblr-5119	546	56	affects	affect	VERB
cblr-5119	546	57	an	an	DET
cblr-5119	546	58	important	important	ADJ
cblr-5119	546	59	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	546	60	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	546	61	6_2019.3_estes	6_2019.3_estes	NUM
cblr-5119	546	62	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	546	63	do	do	AUX
cblr-5119	546	64	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	546	65	delte	delte	VERB
cblr-5119	546	66	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	547	1	12/26/2019	12/26/2019	NUM
cblr-5119	547	2	12:00	12:00	NUM
cblr-5119	547	3	am	am	NOUN
cblr-5119	547	4	1070	1070	NUM
cblr-5119	547	5	columbia	columbia	PROPN
cblr-5119	547	6	business	business	NOUN
cblr-5119	547	7	law	law	PROPN
cblr-5119	547	8	review	review	NOUN
cblr-5119	547	9	[	[	X
cblr-5119	547	10	vol	vol	NOUN
cblr-5119	547	11	.	.	NOUN
cblr-5119	547	12	2019	2019	NUM
cblr-5119	547	13	fourth	fourth	ADJ
cblr-5119	547	14	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	547	15	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	547	16	regime	regime	NOUN
cblr-5119	547	17	calls	call	VERB
cblr-5119	547	18	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	547	19	examining	examine	VERB
cblr-5119	547	20	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	547	21	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
cblr-5119	547	22	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	547	23	claim	claim	NOUN
cblr-5119	547	24	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	547	25	its	its	PRON
cblr-5119	547	26	entirety	entirety	NOUN
cblr-5119	547	27	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	547	28	does	do	AUX
cblr-5119	547	29	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	547	30	require	require	VERB
cblr-5119	547	31	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	547	32	certain	certain	ADJ
cblr-5119	547	33	amount	amount	NOUN
cblr-5119	547	34	or	or	CCONJ
cblr-5119	547	35	type	type	NOUN
cblr-5119	547	36	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	547	37	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	547	38	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	547	39	conduct	conduct	NOUN
cblr-5119	547	40	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	548	1	this	this	DET
cblr-5119	548	2	framework	framework	NOUN
cblr-5119	548	3	is	be	AUX
cblr-5119	548	4	successful	successful	ADJ
cblr-5119	548	5	because	because	SCONJ
cblr-5119	548	6	it	it	PRON
cblr-5119	548	7	sets	set	VERB
cblr-5119	548	8	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	548	9	realistic	realistic	ADJ
cblr-5119	548	10	bar	bar	NOUN
cblr-5119	548	11	for	for	SCONJ
cblr-5119	548	12	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
cblr-5119	548	13	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	548	14	meet	meet	VERB
cblr-5119	548	15	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	548	16	touch	touch	NOUN
cblr-5119	548	17	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-5119	548	18	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	548	19	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-5119	548	20	concern	concern	NOUN
cblr-5119	548	21	requirement	requirement	NOUN
cblr-5119	548	22	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	548	23	ensuring	ensure	VERB
cblr-5119	548	24	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	548	25	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	548	26	presumption	presumption	NOUN
cblr-5119	548	27	remains	remain	VERB
cblr-5119	548	28	merely	merely	ADV
cblr-5119	548	29	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	548	30	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	548	31	presumption	presumption	NOUN
cblr-5119	548	32	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	548	33	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	548	34	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	548	35	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	548	36	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	548	37	tool	tool	NOUN
cblr-5119	548	38	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	548	39	courts	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	548	40	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	548	41	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	548	42	use	use	VERB
cblr-5119	548	43	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	548	44	mechanically	mechanically	ADV
cblr-5119	548	45	dismiss	dismiss	VERB
cblr-5119	548	46	claims	claim	NOUN
cblr-5119	548	47	involving	involve	VERB
cblr-5119	548	48	allegations	allegation	NOUN
cblr-5119	548	49	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	548	50	heinous	heinous	ADJ
cblr-5119	548	51	conduct	conduct	NOUN
cblr-5119	548	52	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	549	1	yet	yet	CCONJ
cblr-5119	549	2	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	549	3	framework	framework	NOUN
cblr-5119	549	4	also	also	ADV
cblr-5119	549	5	provides	provide	VERB
cblr-5119	549	6	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
cblr-5119	549	7	flexibility	flexibility	NOUN
cblr-5119	549	8	for	for	SCONJ
cblr-5119	549	9	courts	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	549	10	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	549	11	dismiss	dismiss	VERB
cblr-5119	549	12	claims	claim	NOUN
cblr-5119	549	13	that	that	PRON
cblr-5119	549	14	should	should	AUX
cblr-5119	549	15	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	549	16	rebut	rebut	VERB
cblr-5119	549	17	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	549	18	presumption	presumption	NOUN
cblr-5119	549	19	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	550	1	holding	hold	VERB
cblr-5119	550	2	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	550	3	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	550	4	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	550	5	liable	liable	ADJ
cblr-5119	550	6	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	550	7	general	general	ADJ
cblr-5119	550	8	comports	comport	VERB
cblr-5119	550	9	with	with	ADP
cblr-5119	550	10	both	both	CCONJ
cblr-5119	550	11	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	550	12	original	original	ADJ
cblr-5119	550	13	understanding	understanding	NOUN
cblr-5119	550	14	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	550	15	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	550	16	ats,192	ats,192	NOUN
cblr-5119	550	17	which	which	PRON
cblr-5119	550	18	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	550	19	supreme	supreme	PROPN
cblr-5119	550	20	court	court	PROPN
cblr-5119	550	21	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	550	22	federal	federal	ADJ
cblr-5119	550	23	courts	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	550	24	have	have	AUX
cblr-5119	550	25	relied	rely	VERB
cblr-5119	550	26	on	on	ADP
cblr-5119	550	27	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	550	28	their	their	PRON
cblr-5119	550	29	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	550	30	jurisprudence,193	jurisprudence,193	PROPN
cblr-5119	550	31	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	550	32	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	550	33	modern	modern	ADJ
cblr-5119	550	34	conception	conception	NOUN
cblr-5119	550	35	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	550	36	international	international	ADJ
cblr-5119	550	37	law.194	law.194	NOUN
cblr-5119	550	38	if	if	SCONJ
cblr-5119	550	39	federal	federal	ADJ
cblr-5119	550	40	common	common	ADJ
cblr-5119	550	41	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	550	42	provides	provide	VERB
cblr-5119	550	43	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	550	44	rule	rule	NOUN
cblr-5119	550	45	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	550	46	decision	decision	NOUN
cblr-5119	550	47	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	550	48	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	550	49	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	550	50	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	550	51	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	550	52	under	under	ADP
cblr-5119	550	53	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	550	54	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	550	55	clearly	clearly	ADV
cblr-5119	550	56	should	should	AUX
cblr-5119	550	57	exist	exist	VERB
cblr-5119	550	58	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	550	59	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	550	60	even	even	ADV
cblr-5119	550	61	if	if	SCONJ
cblr-5119	550	62	customary	customary	ADJ
cblr-5119	550	63	international	international	ADJ
cblr-5119	550	64	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	550	65	provides	provide	VERB
cblr-5119	550	66	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	550	67	rule	rule	NOUN
cblr-5119	550	68	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	550	69	decision	decision	NOUN
cblr-5119	550	70	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	550	71	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	550	72	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	550	73	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	550	74	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	550	75	still	still	ADV
cblr-5119	550	76	may	may	AUX
cblr-5119	550	77	be	be	AUX
cblr-5119	550	78	appropriate	appropriate	ADJ
cblr-5119	550	79	given	give	VERB
cblr-5119	550	80	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	550	81	strong	strong	ADJ
cblr-5119	550	82	argument	argument	NOUN
cblr-5119	550	83	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	550	84	international	international	ADJ
cblr-5119	550	85	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	550	86	now	now	ADV
cblr-5119	550	87	recognizes	recognize	VERB
cblr-5119	550	88	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	550	89	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	550	90	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	550	91	human	human	ADJ
cblr-5119	550	92	rights	right	NOUN
cblr-5119	550	93	violations	violation	NOUN
cblr-5119	550	94	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	551	1	195	195	NUM
cblr-5119	551	2	adopting	adopt	VERB
cblr-5119	551	3	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	551	4	most	most	ADV
cblr-5119	551	5	flexible	flexible	ADJ
cblr-5119	551	6	regime	regime	NOUN
cblr-5119	551	7	possible	possible	ADJ
cblr-5119	551	8	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	551	9	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	551	10	ats	at	NOUN
cblr-5119	551	11	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	551	12	will	will	AUX
cblr-5119	551	13	ensure	ensure	VERB
cblr-5119	551	14	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	551	15	continued	continued	ADJ
cblr-5119	551	16	propagation	propagation	NOUN
cblr-5119	551	17	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	551	18	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	551	19	important	important	ADJ
cblr-5119	551	20	message	message	NOUN
cblr-5119	551	21	that	that	PRON
cblr-5119	551	22	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	551	23	united	united	PROPN
cblr-5119	551	24	states	states	PROPN
cblr-5119	551	25	will	will	AUX
cblr-5119	551	26	hold	hold	VERB
cblr-5119	551	27	its	its	PRON
cblr-5119	551	28	businesses	business	NOUN
cblr-5119	551	29	accountable	accountable	ADJ
cblr-5119	551	30	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	551	31	their	their	PRON
cblr-5119	551	32	egregious	egregious	ADJ
cblr-5119	551	33	conduct	conduct	NOUN
cblr-5119	551	34	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	551	35	will	will	AUX
cblr-5119	551	36	provide	provide	VERB
cblr-5119	551	37	victims	victim	NOUN
cblr-5119	551	38	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	551	39	any	any	DET
cblr-5119	551	40	abuses	abuse	NOUN
cblr-5119	551	41	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	551	42	opportunity	opportunity	NOUN
cblr-5119	551	43	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	551	44	receive	receive	VERB
cblr-5119	551	45	justice	justice	NOUN
cblr-5119	551	46	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	551	47	compensation	compensation	NOUN
cblr-5119	551	48	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	552	1	doing	do	VERB
cblr-5119	552	2	so	so	ADV
cblr-5119	552	3	could	could	AUX
cblr-5119	552	4	even	even	ADV
cblr-5119	552	5	have	have	VERB
cblr-5119	552	6	positive	positive	ADJ
cblr-5119	552	7	interest	interest	NOUN
cblr-5119	552	8	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	552	9	;	;	PUNCT
cblr-5119	552	10	doyle	doyle	NOUN
cblr-5119	552	11	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	552	12	supra	supra	PROPN
cblr-5119	552	13	note	note	NOUN
cblr-5119	552	14	75	75	NUM
cblr-5119	552	15	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	552	16	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	552	17	468	468	NUM
cblr-5119	552	18	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	552	19	proposing	propose	VERB
cblr-5119	552	20	test	test	NOUN
cblr-5119	552	21	where	where	SCONJ
cblr-5119	552	22	defendant	defendant	NOUN
cblr-5119	552	23	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	552	24	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	552	25	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	552	26	nationality	nationality	NOUN
cblr-5119	552	27	would	would	AUX
cblr-5119	552	28	be	be	AUX
cblr-5119	552	29	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
cblr-5119	552	30	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	552	31	displace	displace	VERB
cblr-5119	552	32	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	552	33	presumption	presumption	NOUN
cblr-5119	552	34	against	against	ADP
cblr-5119	552	35	extraterritoriality	extraterritoriality	NOUN
cblr-5119	552	36	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	552	37	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	553	1	192	192	NUM
cblr-5119	553	2	bellia	bellia	PROPN
cblr-5119	553	3	jr	jr	PROPN
cblr-5119	553	4	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	553	5	&	&	CCONJ
cblr-5119	553	6	clark	clark	PROPN
cblr-5119	553	7	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	553	8	supra	supra	PROPN
cblr-5119	553	9	note	note	PROPN
cblr-5119	553	10	13	13	NUM
cblr-5119	553	11	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	553	12	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	553	13	476–77	476–77	NOUN
cblr-5119	553	14	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	553	15	discussing	discuss	VERB
cblr-5119	553	16	leading	lead	VERB
cblr-5119	553	17	18th	18th	ADJ
cblr-5119	553	18	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-5119	553	19	century	century	NOUN
cblr-5119	553	20	treatise	treatise	NOUN
cblr-5119	553	21	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	553	22	explaining	explain	VERB
cblr-5119	553	23	how	how	SCONJ
cblr-5119	553	24	states	state	NOUN
cblr-5119	553	25	were	be	AUX
cblr-5119	553	26	obligated	obligate	VERB
cblr-5119	553	27	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	553	28	provide	provide	VERB
cblr-5119	553	29	redress	redress	NOUN
cblr-5119	553	30	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	553	31	harms	harm	NOUN
cblr-5119	553	32	their	their	PRON
cblr-5119	553	33	nationals	national	NOUN
cblr-5119	553	34	committed	commit	VERB
cblr-5119	553	35	against	against	ADP
cblr-5119	553	36	foreign	foreign	ADJ
cblr-5119	553	37	citizens	citizen	NOUN
cblr-5119	553	38	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	553	39	;	;	PUNCT
cblr-5119	553	40	doe	doe	NOUN
cblr-5119	553	41	v.	v.	CCONJ
cblr-5119	553	42	exxon	exxon	PROPN
cblr-5119	553	43	mobil	mobil	PROPN
cblr-5119	553	44	corp	corp	PROPN
cblr-5119	553	45	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	553	46	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	553	47	654	654	NUM
cblr-5119	553	48	f.3d	f.3d	NUM
cblr-5119	553	49	11	11	NUM
cblr-5119	553	50	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	553	51	45–47	45–47	NUM
cblr-5119	553	52	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	553	53	d.c	d.c	PROPN
cblr-5119	553	54	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	553	55	cir	cir	PROPN
cblr-5119	553	56	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	553	57	2011	2011	NUM
cblr-5119	553	58	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	553	59	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	553	60	vacated	vacate	VERB
cblr-5119	553	61	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	553	62	527	527	NUM
cblr-5119	553	63	f.	f.	PROPN
cblr-5119	553	64	app’x	app’x	PROPN
cblr-5119	553	65	7	7	NUM
cblr-5119	553	66	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	553	67	d.c	d.c	PROPN
cblr-5119	553	68	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	553	69	cir	cir	PROPN
cblr-5119	553	70	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	553	71	2013	2013	NUM
cblr-5119	553	72	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	554	1	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	554	2	explaining	explain	VERB
cblr-5119	554	3	how	how	SCONJ
cblr-5119	554	4	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	554	5	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	554	6	was	be	AUX
cblr-5119	554	7	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	554	8	recognized	recognize	VERB
cblr-5119	554	9	principle	principle	NOUN
cblr-5119	554	10	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	554	11	tort	tort	NOUN
cblr-5119	554	12	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	554	13	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	554	14	time	time	NOUN
cblr-5119	554	15	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	554	16	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	554	17	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	554	18	enactment	enactment	NOUN
cblr-5119	554	19	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	554	20	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	555	1	193	193	NUM
cblr-5119	555	2	see	see	VERB
cblr-5119	555	3	sosa	sosa	PROPN
cblr-5119	555	4	v.	v.	PROPN
cblr-5119	555	5	alvarez	alvarez	PROPN
cblr-5119	555	6	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-5119	555	7	machain	machain	NOUN
cblr-5119	555	8	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	555	9	542	542	NUM
cblr-5119	555	10	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	555	11	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	555	12	692	692	NUM
cblr-5119	555	13	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	555	14	718–25	718–25	NUM
cblr-5119	555	15	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	555	16	2004	2004	NUM
cblr-5119	555	17	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	555	18	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	556	1	194	194	NUM
cblr-5119	556	2	see	see	VERB
cblr-5119	556	3	clapham	clapham	NOUN
cblr-5119	556	4	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	556	5	supra	supra	PROPN
cblr-5119	556	6	note	note	NOUN
cblr-5119	556	7	52	52	NUM
cblr-5119	556	8	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	556	9	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	556	10	195–96	195–96	NUM
cblr-5119	556	11	;	;	PUNCT
cblr-5119	556	12	jan	jan	PROPN
cblr-5119	556	13	wouters	wouters	PROPN
cblr-5119	556	14	&	&	CCONJ
cblr-5119	556	15	leen	leen	PROPN
cblr-5119	556	16	chanet	chanet	PROPN
cblr-5119	556	17	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	556	18	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	556	19	human	human	ADJ
cblr-5119	556	20	rights	right	NOUN
cblr-5119	556	21	responsibility	responsibility	NOUN
cblr-5119	556	22	:	:	PUNCT
cblr-5119	556	23	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	556	24	european	european	PROPN
cblr-5119	556	25	perspective	perspective	NOUN
cblr-5119	556	26	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	556	27	6	6	NUM
cblr-5119	556	28	nw	nw	X
cblr-5119	556	29	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	556	30	u.	u.	PROPN
cblr-5119	556	31	j.	j.	PROPN
cblr-5119	556	32	int’l	int’l	NUM
cblr-5119	556	33	hum	hum	NOUN
cblr-5119	556	34	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	557	1	rts	rt	NOUN
cblr-5119	557	2	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	558	1	264–66	264–66	NUM
cblr-5119	558	2	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	558	3	2008	2008	NUM
cblr-5119	558	4	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	558	5	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	559	1	195	195	NUM
cblr-5119	559	2	see	see	VERB
cblr-5119	559	3	clapham	clapham	NOUN
cblr-5119	559	4	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	559	5	supra	supra	PROPN
cblr-5119	559	6	note	note	NOUN
cblr-5119	559	7	52	52	NUM
cblr-5119	559	8	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	559	9	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	559	10	251	251	NUM
cblr-5119	559	11	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	560	1	6_2019.3_estes	6_2019.3_estes	NUM
cblr-5119	560	2	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	560	3	do	do	AUX
cblr-5119	560	4	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	560	5	delete	delete	VERB
cblr-5119	560	6	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	560	7	12/26/2019	12/26/2019	NUM
cblr-5119	560	8	12:00	12:00	NUM
cblr-5119	560	9	am	be	AUX
cblr-5119	560	10	no	no	NOUN
cblr-5119	560	11	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	561	1	3:1031	3:1031	NUM
cblr-5119	561	2	]	]	X
cblr-5119	561	3	may	may	AUX
cblr-5119	561	4	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	561	5	fourth	fourth	ADJ
cblr-5119	561	6	be	be	AUX
cblr-5119	561	7	with	with	ADP
cblr-5119	561	8	you	you	PRON
cblr-5119	561	9	1071	1071	NUM
cblr-5119	561	10	effects	effect	NOUN
cblr-5119	561	11	on	on	ADP
cblr-5119	561	12	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	561	13	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	561	14	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	561	15	business	business	NOUN
cblr-5119	561	16	community	community	NOUN
cblr-5119	561	17	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	561	18	terms	term	NOUN
cblr-5119	561	19	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	561	20	encouraging	encourage	VERB
cblr-5119	561	21	more	more	ADV
cblr-5119	561	22	robust	robust	ADJ
cblr-5119	561	23	oversight.196	oversight.196	NOUN
cblr-5119	561	24	finally	finally	ADV
cblr-5119	561	25	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	561	26	using	use	VERB
cblr-5119	561	27	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	561	28	fourth	fourth	ADJ
cblr-5119	561	29	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	561	30	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	561	31	regime	regime	NOUN
cblr-5119	561	32	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	561	33	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	561	34	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	561	35	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	561	36	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	561	37	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	561	38	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	561	39	presumption	presumption	NOUN
cblr-5119	561	40	will	will	AUX
cblr-5119	561	41	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	561	42	result	result	VERB
cblr-5119	561	43	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	561	44	foreign	foreign	ADJ
cblr-5119	561	45	entanglements	entanglement	NOUN
cblr-5119	561	46	or	or	CCONJ
cblr-5119	561	47	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	561	48	judiciary	judiciary	NOUN
cblr-5119	561	49	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	561	50	improper	improper	ADJ
cblr-5119	561	51	involvement	involvement	NOUN
cblr-5119	561	52	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	561	53	foreign	foreign	ADJ
cblr-5119	561	54	affairs	affair	NOUN
cblr-5119	561	55	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	562	1	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	562	2	fact	fact	NOUN
cblr-5119	562	3	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	562	4	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	562	5	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	562	6	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	562	7	judiciary	judiciary	PROPN
cblr-5119	562	8	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	562	9	failure	failure	NOUN
cblr-5119	562	10	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	562	11	exercise	exercise	VERB
cblr-5119	562	12	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NOUN
cblr-5119	562	13	over	over	ADP
cblr-5119	562	14	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	562	15	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	562	16	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	562	17	under	under	ADP
cblr-5119	562	18	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	562	19	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	562	20	could	could	AUX
cblr-5119	562	21	cause	cause	VERB
cblr-5119	562	22	strife	strife	NOUN
cblr-5119	562	23	with	with	ADP
cblr-5119	562	24	foreign	foreign	ADJ
cblr-5119	562	25	countries	country	NOUN
cblr-5119	562	26	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	563	1	this	this	PRON
cblr-5119	563	2	is	be	AUX
cblr-5119	563	3	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	563	4	opposite	opposite	NOUN
cblr-5119	563	5	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	563	6	what	what	PRON
cblr-5119	563	7	congress	congress	PROPN
cblr-5119	563	8	intended	intend	VERB
cblr-5119	563	9	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	563	10	passing	pass	VERB
cblr-5119	563	11	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	563	12	statute.197	statute.197	NOUN
cblr-5119	563	13	examining	examine	VERB
cblr-5119	563	14	how	how	SCONJ
cblr-5119	563	15	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	563	16	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	563	17	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	563	18	human	human	ADJ
cblr-5119	563	19	rights	right	NOUN
cblr-5119	563	20	abuses	abuse	NOUN
cblr-5119	563	21	is	be	AUX
cblr-5119	563	22	being	be	AUX
cblr-5119	563	23	handled	handle	VERB
cblr-5119	563	24	elsewhere	elsewhere	ADV
cblr-5119	563	25	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	563	26	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	563	27	world	world	NOUN
cblr-5119	563	28	bolsters	bolster	VERB
cblr-5119	563	29	this	this	DET
cblr-5119	563	30	last	last	ADJ
cblr-5119	563	31	point	point	NOUN
cblr-5119	563	32	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	564	1	a.	a.	NOUN
cblr-5119	564	2	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	564	3	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	564	4	is	be	AUX
cblr-5119	564	5	appropriate	appropriate	ADJ
cblr-5119	564	6	given	give	VERB
cblr-5119	564	7	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	564	8	relevant	relevant	ADJ
cblr-5119	564	9	legal	legal	ADJ
cblr-5119	564	10	considerations	consideration	NOUN
cblr-5119	564	11	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	564	12	inquiry	inquiry	NOUN
cblr-5119	564	13	into	into	ADP
cblr-5119	564	14	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	564	15	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	564	16	under	under	ADP
cblr-5119	564	17	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	564	18	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	564	19	has	have	AUX
cblr-5119	564	20	largely	largely	ADV
cblr-5119	564	21	been	be	AUX
cblr-5119	564	22	defined	define	VERB
cblr-5119	564	23	by	by	ADP
cblr-5119	564	24	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	564	25	differing	differ	VERB
cblr-5119	564	26	opinions	opinion	NOUN
cblr-5119	564	27	written	write	VERB
cblr-5119	564	28	by	by	ADP
cblr-5119	564	29	judge	judge	PROPN
cblr-5119	564	30	cabranes	cabrane	NOUN
cblr-5119	564	31	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	564	32	arguing	argue	VERB
cblr-5119	564	33	against	against	ADP
cblr-5119	564	34	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	564	35	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	564	36	because	because	SCONJ
cblr-5119	564	37	customary	customary	ADJ
cblr-5119	564	38	international	international	ADJ
cblr-5119	564	39	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	564	40	controlled	control	VERB
cblr-5119	564	41	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	564	42	issue	issue	NOUN
cblr-5119	564	43	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	564	44	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	564	45	judge	judge	NOUN
cblr-5119	564	46	leval	leval	PROPN
cblr-5119	564	47	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	564	48	arguing	argue	VERB
cblr-5119	564	49	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	564	50	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	564	51	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	564	52	because	because	SCONJ
cblr-5119	564	53	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	564	54	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	564	55	domestic	domestic	ADJ
cblr-5119	564	56	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	564	57	controlled	control	VERB
cblr-5119	564	58	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	564	59	issue	issue	NOUN
cblr-5119	564	60	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	564	61	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	564	62	kiobel	kiobel	PROPN
cblr-5119	564	63	i.198	i.198	PROPN
cblr-5119	564	64	justice	justice	PROPN
cblr-5119	564	65	kennedy	kennedy	PROPN
cblr-5119	564	66	confirmed	confirm	VERB
cblr-5119	564	67	as	as	ADV
cblr-5119	564	68	much	much	ADV
cblr-5119	564	69	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	564	70	without	without	ADP
cblr-5119	564	71	settling	settle	VERB
cblr-5119	564	72	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	564	73	issue	issue	NOUN
cblr-5119	564	74	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	564	75	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	564	76	his	his	PRON
cblr-5119	564	77	plurality	plurality	NOUN
cblr-5119	564	78	opinion	opinion	NOUN
cblr-5119	564	79	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	564	80	jesner.199	jesner.199	PROPN
cblr-5119	564	81	while	while	SCONJ
cblr-5119	564	82	it	it	PRON
cblr-5119	564	83	would	would	AUX
cblr-5119	564	84	be	be	AUX
cblr-5119	564	85	desirable	desirable	ADJ
cblr-5119	564	86	for	for	SCONJ
cblr-5119	564	87	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	564	88	supreme	supreme	PROPN
cblr-5119	564	89	court	court	PROPN
cblr-5119	564	90	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	564	91	rule	rule	VERB
cblr-5119	564	92	definitively	definitively	ADV
cblr-5119	564	93	on	on	ADP
cblr-5119	564	94	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	564	95	issue	issue	NOUN
cblr-5119	564	96	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	564	97	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	564	98	reality	reality	NOUN
cblr-5119	564	99	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	564	100	either	either	DET
cblr-5119	564	101	viewpoint	viewpoint	NOUN
cblr-5119	564	102	leads	lead	VERB
cblr-5119	564	103	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	564	104	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	564	105	conclusion	conclusion	NOUN
cblr-5119	564	106	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	564	107	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	564	108	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	564	109	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	564	110	should	should	AUX
cblr-5119	564	111	be	be	AUX
cblr-5119	564	112	liable	liable	ADJ
cblr-5119	564	113	under	under	ADP
cblr-5119	564	114	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	564	115	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	564	116	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	565	1	there	there	PRON
cblr-5119	565	2	is	be	VERB
cblr-5119	565	3	strong	strong	ADJ
cblr-5119	565	4	support	support	NOUN
cblr-5119	565	5	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	565	6	judge	judge	NOUN
cblr-5119	565	7	leval	leval	PROPN
cblr-5119	565	8	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	565	9	position	position	NOUN
cblr-5119	565	10	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	565	11	customary	customary	ADJ
cblr-5119	565	12	international	international	ADJ
cblr-5119	565	13	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	565	14	leaves	leave	VERB
cblr-5119	565	15	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	565	16	question	question	NOUN
cblr-5119	565	17	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	565	18	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	565	19	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	565	20	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	565	21	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	565	22	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	565	23	domestic	domestic	ADJ
cblr-5119	565	24	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	565	25	because	because	SCONJ
cblr-5119	565	26	it	it	PRON
cblr-5119	565	27	is	be	AUX
cblr-5119	565	28	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	565	29	matter	matter	NOUN
cblr-5119	565	30	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	565	31	remedy	remedy	NOUN
cblr-5119	565	32	or	or	CCONJ
cblr-5119	565	33	enforcement	enforcement	NOUN
cblr-5119	565	34	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	566	1	customary	customary	ADJ
cblr-5119	566	2	international	international	ADJ
cblr-5119	566	3	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	566	4	generally	generally	ADV
cblr-5119	566	5	does	do	AUX
cblr-5119	566	6	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	566	7	establish	establish	VERB
cblr-5119	566	8	ways	way	NOUN
cblr-5119	566	9	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	566	10	redress	redress	NOUN
cblr-5119	566	11	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	566	12	international	international	ADJ
cblr-5119	566	13	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	566	14	violations.200	violations.200	PROPN
cblr-5119	566	15	instead	instead	ADV
cblr-5119	566	16	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	566	17	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	566	18	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	566	19	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	566	20	nations	nation	NOUN
cblr-5119	566	21	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	566	22	customary	customary	ADJ
cblr-5119	566	23	international	international	ADJ
cblr-5119	566	24	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	566	25	leave	leave	VERB
cblr-5119	566	26	most	most	ADV
cblr-5119	566	27	remedial	remedial	ADJ
cblr-5119	566	28	196	196	NUM
cblr-5119	566	29	see	see	VERB
cblr-5119	566	30	martin	martin	PROPN
cblr-5119	566	31	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	566	32	supra	supra	PROPN
cblr-5119	566	33	note	note	NOUN
cblr-5119	566	34	6	6	NUM
cblr-5119	566	35	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	566	36	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	566	37	991–92	991–92	NUM
cblr-5119	566	38	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	566	39	197	197	NUM
cblr-5119	566	40	jesner	jesner	PROPN
cblr-5119	566	41	v.	v.	ADP
cblr-5119	566	42	arab	arab	PROPN
cblr-5119	566	43	bank	bank	PROPN
cblr-5119	566	44	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	566	45	plc	plc	PROPN
cblr-5119	566	46	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	566	47	138	138	NUM
cblr-5119	566	48	s.	s.	PROPN
cblr-5119	566	49	ct	ct	PROPN
cblr-5119	566	50	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	566	51	1386	1386	NUM
cblr-5119	566	52	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	566	53	1397	1397	NUM
cblr-5119	566	54	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	566	55	2018	2018	NUM
cblr-5119	566	56	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	566	57	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	566	58	discussing	discuss	VERB
cblr-5119	566	59	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	566	60	legislative	legislative	ADJ
cblr-5119	566	61	history	history	NOUN
cblr-5119	566	62	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	566	63	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	566	64	ats	at	NOUN
cblr-5119	566	65	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	566	66	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	567	1	198	198	NUM
cblr-5119	567	2	see	see	VERB
cblr-5119	567	3	discussion	discussion	NOUN
cblr-5119	567	4	supra	supra	PROPN
cblr-5119	567	5	section	section	PROPN
cblr-5119	567	6	iii.a	iii.a	PROPN
cblr-5119	567	7	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	568	1	199	199	NUM
cblr-5119	568	2	see	see	NOUN
cblr-5119	568	3	discussion	discussion	NOUN
cblr-5119	568	4	supra	supra	PROPN
cblr-5119	568	5	section	section	PROPN
cblr-5119	568	6	ii.d.2	ii.d.2	PROPN
cblr-5119	568	7	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	569	1	200	200	NUM
cblr-5119	569	2	michael	michael	PROPN
cblr-5119	569	3	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-5119	569	4	ramsey	ramsey	PROPN
cblr-5119	569	5	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	569	6	international	international	ADJ
cblr-5119	569	7	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	569	8	limits	limit	NOUN
cblr-5119	569	9	on	on	ADP
cblr-5119	569	10	investor	investor	NOUN
cblr-5119	569	11	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	569	12	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	569	13	human	human	ADJ
cblr-5119	569	14	rights	right	NOUN
cblr-5119	569	15	litigation	litigation	NOUN
cblr-5119	569	16	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	569	17	50	50	NUM
cblr-5119	569	18	harv	harv	NOUN
cblr-5119	569	19	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	570	1	int’l	int’l	PRON
cblr-5119	570	2	l.j	l.j	PROPN
cblr-5119	570	3	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	570	4	271	271	NUM
cblr-5119	570	5	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	570	6	297–98	297–98	NUM
cblr-5119	570	7	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	570	8	2009	2009	NUM
cblr-5119	570	9	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	570	10	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	571	1	6_2019.3_estes	6_2019.3_estes	NUM
cblr-5119	571	2	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	571	3	do	do	AUX
cblr-5119	571	4	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	571	5	delte	delte	VERB
cblr-5119	571	6	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	571	7	12/26/2019	12/26/2019	NUM
cblr-5119	571	8	12:00	12:00	NUM
cblr-5119	571	9	am	be	AUX
cblr-5119	571	10	1072	1072	NUM
cblr-5119	571	11	columbia	columbia	PROPN
cblr-5119	571	12	business	business	NOUN
cblr-5119	571	13	law	law	PROPN
cblr-5119	571	14	review	review	NOUN
cblr-5119	571	15	[	[	X
cblr-5119	571	16	vol	vol	NOUN
cblr-5119	571	17	.	.	NOUN
cblr-5119	571	18	2019	2019	NUM
cblr-5119	571	19	issues	issue	NOUN
cblr-5119	571	20	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	571	21	including	include	VERB
cblr-5119	571	22	whether	whether	SCONJ
cblr-5119	571	23	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	571	24	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	571	25	is	be	AUX
cblr-5119	571	26	available	available	ADJ
cblr-5119	571	27	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	571	28	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	571	29	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	571	30	discretion	discretion	NOUN
cblr-5119	571	31	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	571	32	individual	individual	ADJ
cblr-5119	571	33	states.201	states.201	NOUN
cblr-5119	571	34	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	571	35	supreme	supreme	PROPN
cblr-5119	571	36	court	court	PROPN
cblr-5119	571	37	appeared	appear	VERB
cblr-5119	571	38	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	571	39	agree	agree	VERB
cblr-5119	571	40	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	571	41	sosa	sosa	PROPN
cblr-5119	571	42	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	571	43	confirming	confirm	VERB
cblr-5119	571	44	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	571	45	federal	federal	ADJ
cblr-5119	571	46	courts	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	571	47	can	can	AUX
cblr-5119	571	48	create	create	VERB
cblr-5119	571	49	private	private	ADJ
cblr-5119	571	50	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	571	51	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	571	52	as	as	ADP
cblr-5119	571	53	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	571	54	matter	matter	NOUN
cblr-5119	571	55	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	571	56	federal	federal	ADJ
cblr-5119	571	57	common	common	ADJ
cblr-5119	571	58	law.202	law.202	NOUN
cblr-5119	571	59	it	it	PRON
cblr-5119	571	60	follows	follow	VERB
cblr-5119	571	61	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	571	62	federal	federal	ADJ
cblr-5119	571	63	courts	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	571	64	must	must	AUX
cblr-5119	571	65	refer	refer	VERB
cblr-5119	571	66	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	571	67	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	571	68	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	571	69	domestic	domestic	ADJ
cblr-5119	571	70	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	571	71	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	571	72	answer	answer	VERB
cblr-5119	571	73	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	571	74	question	question	NOUN
cblr-5119	571	75	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	571	76	whether	whether	SCONJ
cblr-5119	571	77	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	571	78	are	be	AUX
cblr-5119	571	79	liable	liable	ADJ
cblr-5119	571	80	under	under	ADP
cblr-5119	571	81	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	571	82	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	571	83	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	571	84	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	571	85	federal	federal	ADJ
cblr-5119	571	86	common	common	ADJ
cblr-5119	571	87	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	571	88	clearly	clearly	ADV
cblr-5119	571	89	recognizes	recognize	VERB
cblr-5119	571	90	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	571	91	liability.203	liability.203	NOUN
cblr-5119	571	92	however	however	ADV
cblr-5119	571	93	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	571	94	even	even	ADV
cblr-5119	571	95	if	if	SCONJ
cblr-5119	571	96	customary	customary	ADJ
cblr-5119	571	97	international	international	ADJ
cblr-5119	571	98	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	571	99	governs	govern	VERB
cblr-5119	571	100	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	571	101	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	571	102	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	571	103	there	there	PRON
cblr-5119	571	104	is	be	VERB
cblr-5119	571	105	strong	strong	ADJ
cblr-5119	571	106	reason	reason	NOUN
cblr-5119	571	107	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	571	108	find	find	VERB
cblr-5119	571	109	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	571	110	judge	judge	NOUN
cblr-5119	571	111	cabranes	cabrane	NOUN
cblr-5119	571	112	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	571	113	analysis	analysis	NOUN
cblr-5119	571	114	was	be	AUX
cblr-5119	571	115	faulty	faulty	ADJ
cblr-5119	571	116	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	571	117	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	571	118	international	international	ADJ
cblr-5119	571	119	practice	practice	NOUN
cblr-5119	571	120	does	do	AUX
cblr-5119	571	121	support	support	VERB
cblr-5119	571	122	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	571	123	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	571	124	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	572	1	judge	judge	PROPN
cblr-5119	572	2	cabranes	cabrane	NOUN
cblr-5119	572	3	looked	look	VERB
cblr-5119	572	4	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	572	5	sources	source	NOUN
cblr-5119	572	6	such	such	ADJ
cblr-5119	572	7	as	as	ADP
cblr-5119	572	8	international	international	ADJ
cblr-5119	572	9	tribunals	tribunal	NOUN
cblr-5119	572	10	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	572	11	international	international	ADJ
cblr-5119	572	12	treaties	treaty	NOUN
cblr-5119	572	13	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	572	14	determining	determine	VERB
cblr-5119	572	15	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	572	16	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	572	17	were	be	AUX
cblr-5119	572	18	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	572	19	subjects	subject	NOUN
cblr-5119	572	20	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	572	21	international	international	ADJ
cblr-5119	572	22	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	572	23	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	572	24	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	572	25	there	there	PRON
cblr-5119	572	26	was	be	VERB
cblr-5119	572	27	no	no	DET
cblr-5119	572	28	international	international	ADJ
cblr-5119	572	29	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	572	30	norm	norm	NOUN
cblr-5119	572	31	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	572	32	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	572	33	liability.204	liability.204	NOUN
cblr-5119	572	34	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	572	35	example	example	NOUN
cblr-5119	572	36	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	572	37	he	he	PRON
cblr-5119	572	38	pointed	point	VERB
cblr-5119	572	39	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	572	40	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	572	41	lack	lack	NOUN
cblr-5119	572	42	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	572	43	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	572	44	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	572	45	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	572	46	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	572	47	post	post	ADJ
cblr-5119	572	48	-	-	ADJ
cblr-5119	572	49	world	world	ADJ
cblr-5119	572	50	war	war	PROPN
cblr-5119	572	51	ii	ii	PROPN
cblr-5119	572	52	nuremberg	nuremberg	PROPN
cblr-5119	572	53	trials	trial	NOUN
cblr-5119	572	54	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	572	55	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	572	56	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	572	57	lack	lack	NOUN
cblr-5119	572	58	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	572	59	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	572	60	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	572	61	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	572	62	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	572	63	rome	rome	PROPN
cblr-5119	572	64	statute	statute	NOUN
cblr-5119	572	65	establishing	establish	VERB
cblr-5119	572	66	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	572	67	international	international	ADJ
cblr-5119	572	68	criminal	criminal	ADJ
cblr-5119	572	69	court.205	court.205	X
cblr-5119	572	70	nuremberg	nuremberg	PROPN
cblr-5119	572	71	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	572	72	though	though	ADV
cblr-5119	572	73	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	572	74	is	be	AUX
cblr-5119	572	75	better	well	ADV
cblr-5119	572	76	read	read	VERB
cblr-5119	572	77	as	as	ADP
cblr-5119	572	78	representing	represent	VERB
cblr-5119	572	79	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	572	80	step	step	NOUN
cblr-5119	572	81	toward	toward	ADP
cblr-5119	572	82	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	572	83	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	572	84	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	573	1	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	573	2	trials	trial	NOUN
cblr-5119	573	3	represented	represent	VERB
cblr-5119	573	4	an	an	DET
cblr-5119	573	5	expansion	expansion	NOUN
cblr-5119	573	6	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	573	7	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	573	8	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	573	9	human	human	ADJ
cblr-5119	573	10	rights	right	NOUN
cblr-5119	573	11	abuses	abuse	NOUN
cblr-5119	573	12	from	from	ADP
cblr-5119	573	13	nations	nation	NOUN
cblr-5119	573	14	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	573	15	private	private	ADJ
cblr-5119	573	16	actors	actor	NOUN
cblr-5119	573	17	generally	generally	ADV
cblr-5119	573	18	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	573	19	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	573	20	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	573	21	there	there	PRON
cblr-5119	573	22	were	be	VERB
cblr-5119	573	23	still	still	ADV
cblr-5119	573	24	implicated	implicate	VERB
cblr-5119	573	25	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	573	26	wrongdoing	wrongdoing	NOUN
cblr-5119	573	27	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	573	28	leading	lead	VERB
cblr-5119	573	29	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	573	30	punishment	punishment	NOUN
cblr-5119	573	31	such	such	ADJ
cblr-5119	573	32	as	as	ADP
cblr-5119	573	33	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	573	34	dissolution	dissolution	NOUN
cblr-5119	573	35	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	573	36	i.g	i.g	PROPN
cblr-5119	573	37	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	573	38	farben	farben	PROPN
cblr-5119	573	39	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	573	40	criminal	criminal	ADJ
cblr-5119	573	41	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	573	42	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	573	43	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	573	44	employees	employee	NOUN
cblr-5119	573	45	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	573	46	implicated	implicated	ADJ
cblr-5119	573	47	corporations.206	corporations.206	NOUN
cblr-5119	573	48	these	these	DET
cblr-5119	573	49	developments	development	NOUN
cblr-5119	573	50	illustrate	illustrate	VERB
cblr-5119	573	51	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	573	52	shift	shift	NOUN
cblr-5119	573	53	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	573	54	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	573	55	international	international	ADJ
cblr-5119	573	56	community	community	NOUN
cblr-5119	573	57	toward	toward	ADP
cblr-5119	573	58	recognizing	recognize	VERB
cblr-5119	573	59	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	573	60	responsibility	responsibility	NOUN
cblr-5119	573	61	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	573	62	wrongdoing	wrongdoing	NOUN
cblr-5119	573	63	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	573	64	reveal	reveal	VERB
cblr-5119	573	65	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	573	66	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	573	67	shift	shift	NOUN
cblr-5119	573	68	began	begin	VERB
cblr-5119	573	69	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	573	70	significant	significant	ADJ
cblr-5119	573	71	time	time	NOUN
cblr-5119	573	72	ago.207	ago.207	NOUN
cblr-5119	573	73	thus	thus	ADV
cblr-5119	573	74	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	573	75	citing	cite	VERB
cblr-5119	573	76	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	573	77	nuremberg	nuremberg	PROPN
cblr-5119	573	78	trials	trial	NOUN
cblr-5119	573	79	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	573	80	201	201	NUM
cblr-5119	573	81	doe	doe	NOUN
cblr-5119	573	82	v.	v.	ADP
cblr-5119	573	83	exxon	exxon	PROPN
cblr-5119	573	84	mobil	mobil	PROPN
cblr-5119	573	85	corp	corp	PROPN
cblr-5119	573	86	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	573	87	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	573	88	654	654	NUM
cblr-5119	573	89	f.3d	f.3d	NUM
cblr-5119	573	90	11	11	NUM
cblr-5119	573	91	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	573	92	41–42	41–42	NUM
cblr-5119	573	93	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	573	94	d.c	d.c	PROPN
cblr-5119	573	95	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	573	96	cir	cir	PROPN
cblr-5119	573	97	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	573	98	2011	2011	NUM
cblr-5119	573	99	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	573	100	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	573	101	vacated	vacate	VERB
cblr-5119	573	102	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	573	103	527	527	NUM
cblr-5119	573	104	f.	f.	PROPN
cblr-5119	573	105	app’x	app’x	PROPN
cblr-5119	573	106	7	7	NUM
cblr-5119	573	107	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	573	108	d.c	d.c	PROPN
cblr-5119	573	109	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	573	110	cir	cir	PROPN
cblr-5119	573	111	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	573	112	2013	2013	NUM
cblr-5119	573	113	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	573	114	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	574	1	202	202	NUM
cblr-5119	574	2	sosa	sosa	PROPN
cblr-5119	574	3	v.	v.	PROPN
cblr-5119	574	4	alvarez	alvarez	PROPN
cblr-5119	574	5	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-5119	574	6	machain	machain	NOUN
cblr-5119	574	7	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	574	8	542	542	NUM
cblr-5119	574	9	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	574	10	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	574	11	692	692	NUM
cblr-5119	574	12	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	574	13	724–25	724–25	NUM
cblr-5119	574	14	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	574	15	2004	2004	NUM
cblr-5119	574	16	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	574	17	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	574	18	emphasis	emphasis	NOUN
cblr-5119	574	19	added	add	VERB
cblr-5119	574	20	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	574	21	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	575	1	203	203	NUM
cblr-5119	575	2	doe	doe	NOUN
cblr-5119	575	3	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	575	4	654	654	NUM
cblr-5119	575	5	f.3d	f.3d	NUM
cblr-5119	575	6	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	575	7	57	57	NUM
cblr-5119	575	8	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	575	9	204	204	NUM
cblr-5119	575	10	kiobel	kiobel	NOUN
cblr-5119	575	11	v.	v.	ADP
cblr-5119	575	12	royal	royal	PROPN
cblr-5119	575	13	dutch	dutch	PROPN
cblr-5119	575	14	petroleum	petroleum	PROPN
cblr-5119	575	15	co.	co.	PROPN
cblr-5119	575	16	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	575	17	621	621	NUM
cblr-5119	575	18	f.3d	f.3d	NUM
cblr-5119	575	19	111	111	NUM
cblr-5119	575	20	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	575	21	132–41	132–41	NUM
cblr-5119	575	22	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	575	23	145	145	NUM
cblr-5119	575	24	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	575	25	2d	2d	NUM
cblr-5119	575	26	cir	cir	NOUN
cblr-5119	575	27	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	575	28	2010	2010	NUM
cblr-5119	575	29	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	575	30	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	575	31	aff’d	aff’d	VERB
cblr-5119	575	32	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	575	33	569	569	NUM
cblr-5119	575	34	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	575	35	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	575	36	108	108	NUM
cblr-5119	575	37	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	575	38	2013	2013	NUM
cblr-5119	575	39	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	575	40	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	576	1	205	205	NUM
cblr-5119	577	1	i	i	PRON
cblr-5119	577	2	d.	d.	NOUN
cblr-5119	577	3	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	577	4	133–37	133–37	NUM
cblr-5119	577	5	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	578	1	206	206	NUM
cblr-5119	578	2	kolieb	kolieb	PROPN
cblr-5119	578	3	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	578	4	supra	supra	PROPN
cblr-5119	578	5	note	note	NOUN
cblr-5119	578	6	104	104	NUM
cblr-5119	578	7	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	578	8	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	578	9	588–594	588–594	NUM
cblr-5119	578	10	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	578	11	207	207	NUM
cblr-5119	579	1	i	i	PRON
cblr-5119	579	2	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-5119	579	3	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	579	4	592	592	NUM
cblr-5119	579	5	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	580	1	6_2019.3_estes	6_2019.3_estes	NUM
cblr-5119	580	2	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	580	3	do	do	AUX
cblr-5119	580	4	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	580	5	delete	delete	VERB
cblr-5119	580	6	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	580	7	12/26/2019	12/26/2019	NUM
cblr-5119	580	8	12:00	12:00	NUM
cblr-5119	580	9	am	be	AUX
cblr-5119	580	10	no	no	NOUN
cblr-5119	580	11	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	581	1	3:1031	3:1031	NUM
cblr-5119	581	2	]	]	X
cblr-5119	581	3	may	may	AUX
cblr-5119	581	4	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	581	5	fourth	fourth	ADJ
cblr-5119	581	6	be	be	AUX
cblr-5119	581	7	with	with	ADP
cblr-5119	581	8	you	you	PRON
cblr-5119	581	9	1073	1073	NUM
cblr-5119	581	10	immunize	immunize	NOUN
cblr-5119	581	11	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	581	12	from	from	ADP
cblr-5119	581	13	international	international	ADJ
cblr-5119	581	14	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	581	15	goes	go	VERB
cblr-5119	581	16	against	against	ADP
cblr-5119	581	17	what	what	PRON
cblr-5119	581	18	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	581	19	trials	trial	NOUN
cblr-5119	581	20	stand	stand	VERB
cblr-5119	581	21	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	581	22	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	581	23	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	581	24	evolution	evolution	NOUN
cblr-5119	581	25	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	581	26	international	international	ADJ
cblr-5119	581	27	practice.208	practice.208	NOUN
cblr-5119	581	28	regarding	regard	VERB
cblr-5119	581	29	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	581	30	rome	rome	PROPN
cblr-5119	581	31	statute	statute	NOUN
cblr-5119	581	32	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	581	33	while	while	SCONJ
cblr-5119	581	34	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	581	35	proposal	proposal	NOUN
cblr-5119	581	36	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	581	37	include	include	VERB
cblr-5119	581	38	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	581	39	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	581	40	was	be	AUX
cblr-5119	581	41	rejected	reject	VERB
cblr-5119	581	42	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	581	43	this	this	PRON
cblr-5119	581	44	was	be	AUX
cblr-5119	581	45	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	581	46	due	due	ADJ
cblr-5119	581	47	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	581	48	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	581	49	insuperable	insuperable	ADJ
cblr-5119	581	50	objections	objection	NOUN
cblr-5119	581	51	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	581	52	principle	principle	NOUN
cblr-5119	581	53	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	581	54	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	581	55	but	but	CCONJ
cblr-5119	581	56	rather	rather	ADV
cblr-5119	581	57	because	because	SCONJ
cblr-5119	581	58	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	581	59	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	581	60	technical	technical	ADJ
cblr-5119	581	61	complexities	complexity	NOUN
cblr-5119	581	62	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	581	63	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	581	64	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	581	65	time	time	NOUN
cblr-5119	581	66	constraints	constraint	NOUN
cblr-5119	581	67	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	581	68	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	581	69	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	582	1	.”209	.”209	VERB
cblr-5119	583	1	several	several	ADJ
cblr-5119	583	2	countries	country	NOUN
cblr-5119	583	3	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	583	4	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	583	5	fact	fact	NOUN
cblr-5119	583	6	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	583	7	have	have	AUX
cblr-5119	583	8	allowed	allow	VERB
cblr-5119	583	9	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	583	10	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	583	11	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	583	12	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	583	13	incorporating	incorporate	VERB
cblr-5119	583	14	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	583	15	rome	rome	PROPN
cblr-5119	583	16	statute	statute	NOUN
cblr-5119	583	17	into	into	ADP
cblr-5119	583	18	their	their	PRON
cblr-5119	583	19	domestic	domestic	ADJ
cblr-5119	583	20	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	583	21	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	583	22	including	include	VERB
cblr-5119	583	23	australia	australia	PROPN
cblr-5119	583	24	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	583	25	canada	canada	PROPN
cblr-5119	583	26	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	583	27	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	583	28	france.210	france.210	VERB
cblr-5119	583	29	this	this	DET
cblr-5119	583	30	weighs	weigh	NOUN
cblr-5119	583	31	against	against	ADP
cblr-5119	583	32	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	583	33	rome	rome	PROPN
cblr-5119	583	34	statute	statute	NOUN
cblr-5119	583	35	serving	serve	VERB
cblr-5119	583	36	as	as	ADP
cblr-5119	583	37	evidence	evidence	NOUN
cblr-5119	583	38	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	583	39	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	583	40	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	583	41	is	be	AUX
cblr-5119	583	42	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	583	43	recognized	recognize	VERB
cblr-5119	583	44	internationally	internationally	ADV
cblr-5119	583	45	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	584	1	all	all	PRON
cblr-5119	584	2	told	tell	VERB
cblr-5119	584	3	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	584	4	there	there	PRON
cblr-5119	584	5	is	be	VERB
cblr-5119	584	6	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	584	7	growing	grow	VERB
cblr-5119	584	8	sense	sense	NOUN
cblr-5119	584	9	internationally	internationally	ADV
cblr-5119	584	10	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	584	11	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	584	12	are	be	AUX
cblr-5119	584	13	subjects	subject	NOUN
cblr-5119	584	14	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	584	15	international	international	ADJ
cblr-5119	584	16	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	584	17	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	584	18	with	with	ADP
cblr-5119	584	19	attendant	attendant	NOUN
cblr-5119	584	20	obligations.211	obligations.211	PRON
cblr-5119	584	21	this	this	PRON
cblr-5119	584	22	is	be	AUX
cblr-5119	584	23	especially	especially	ADV
cblr-5119	584	24	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	584	25	case	case	NOUN
cblr-5119	584	26	when	when	SCONJ
cblr-5119	584	27	it	it	PRON
cblr-5119	584	28	comes	come	VERB
cblr-5119	584	29	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	584	30	human	human	ADJ
cblr-5119	584	31	rights	right	NOUN
cblr-5119	584	32	compliance.212	compliance.212	VERB
cblr-5119	584	33	there	there	ADV
cblr-5119	584	34	are	be	AUX
cblr-5119	584	35	many	many	ADJ
cblr-5119	584	36	examples	example	NOUN
cblr-5119	584	37	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	584	38	treaties	treaty	NOUN
cblr-5119	584	39	today	today	NOUN
cblr-5119	584	40	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	584	41	demand	demand	VERB
cblr-5119	584	42	action	action	NOUN
cblr-5119	584	43	against	against	ADP
cblr-5119	584	44	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	584	45	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	584	46	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	584	47	that	that	PRON
cblr-5119	584	48	leave	leave	VERB
cblr-5119	584	49	actual	actual	ADJ
cblr-5119	584	50	enforcement	enforcement	NOUN
cblr-5119	584	51	against	against	ADP
cblr-5119	584	52	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	584	53	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	584	54	signatory	signatory	NOUN
cblr-5119	584	55	states	state	NOUN
cblr-5119	584	56	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	584	57	which	which	PRON
cblr-5119	584	58	essentially	essentially	ADV
cblr-5119	584	59	mimics	mimic	VERB
cblr-5119	584	60	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	584	61	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	584	62	regime).213	regime).213	NOUN
cblr-5119	584	63	this	this	PRON
cblr-5119	584	64	leads	lead	VERB
cblr-5119	584	65	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	584	66	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	584	67	conclusion	conclusion	NOUN
cblr-5119	584	68	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	584	69	:	:	PUNCT
cblr-5119	584	70	[	[	X
cblr-5119	584	71	t]here	t]here	NOUN
cblr-5119	584	72	is	be	AUX
cblr-5119	584	73	certainly	certainly	ADV
cblr-5119	584	74	room	room	NOUN
cblr-5119	584	75	today	today	NOUN
cblr-5119	584	76	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	584	77	reverse	reverse	VERB
cblr-5119	584	78	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	584	79	assumption	assumption	NOUN
cblr-5119	584	80	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	584	81	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	584	82	have	have	AUX
cblr-5119	584	83	absolutely	absolutely	ADV
cblr-5119	584	84	no	no	PRON
cblr-5119	584	85	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	584	86	under	under	ADP
cblr-5119	584	87	general	general	ADJ
cblr-5119	584	88	international	international	ADJ
cblr-5119	584	89	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	584	90	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	585	1	although	although	SCONJ
cblr-5119	585	2	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	585	3	jurisdictional	jurisdictional	ADJ
cblr-5119	585	4	possibilities	possibility	NOUN
cblr-5119	585	5	are	be	AUX
cblr-5119	585	6	limited	limit	VERB
cblr-5119	585	7	under	under	ADP
cblr-5119	585	8	existing	exist	VERB
cblr-5119	585	9	international	international	ADJ
cblr-5119	585	10	tribunals	tribunal	NOUN
cblr-5119	585	11	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	585	12	where	where	SCONJ
cblr-5119	585	13	national	national	ADJ
cblr-5119	585	14	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	585	15	allows	allow	VERB
cblr-5119	585	16	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	585	17	claims	claim	NOUN
cblr-5119	585	18	based	base	VERB
cblr-5119	585	19	on	on	ADP
cblr-5119	585	20	violations	violation	NOUN
cblr-5119	585	21	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	585	22	international	international	ADJ
cblr-5119	585	23	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	585	24	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	585	25	it	it	PRON
cblr-5119	585	26	is	be	AUX
cblr-5119	585	27	becoming	become	VERB
cblr-5119	585	28	clear	clear	ADJ
cblr-5119	585	29	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	585	30	international	international	ADJ
cblr-5119	585	31	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	585	32	obligates	obligate	VERB
cblr-5119	585	33	non	non	ADJ
cblr-5119	585	34	-	-	NOUN
cblr-5119	585	35	state	state	ADJ
cblr-5119	585	36	actors.214	actors.214	NOUN
cblr-5119	585	37	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	585	38	last	last	ADJ
cblr-5119	585	39	part	part	NOUN
cblr-5119	585	40	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	585	41	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	585	42	above	above	ADJ
cblr-5119	585	43	passage	passage	NOUN
cblr-5119	585	44	describes	describe	VERB
cblr-5119	585	45	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	585	46	operation	operation	NOUN
cblr-5119	585	47	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	585	48	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	585	49	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	585	50	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	585	51	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	585	52	regime	regime	NOUN
cblr-5119	585	53	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	586	1	additionally	additionally	ADV
cblr-5119	586	2	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	586	3	even	even	ADV
cblr-5119	586	4	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	586	5	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	586	6	absence	absence	NOUN
cblr-5119	586	7	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	586	8	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	586	9	specific	specific	ADJ
cblr-5119	586	10	provision	provision	NOUN
cblr-5119	586	11	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	586	12	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	586	13	human	human	ADJ
cblr-5119	586	14	rights	right	NOUN
cblr-5119	586	15	treaty	treaty	NOUN
cblr-5119	586	16	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	586	17	international	international	ADJ
cblr-5119	586	18	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	586	19	208	208	NUM
cblr-5119	586	20	i	i	PRON
cblr-5119	586	21	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-5119	586	22	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	586	23	595	595	NUM
cblr-5119	586	24	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	587	1	209	209	NUM
cblr-5119	587	2	olivier	olivier	PROPN
cblr-5119	587	3	de	de	X
cblr-5119	587	4	schutter	schutter	NOUN
cblr-5119	587	5	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	587	6	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	587	7	accountability	accountability	NOUN
cblr-5119	587	8	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	587	9	multinationals	multinational	NOUN
cblr-5119	587	10	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	587	11	human	human	ADJ
cblr-5119	587	12	rights	right	NOUN
cblr-5119	587	13	violations	violation	NOUN
cblr-5119	587	14	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	587	15	european	european	ADJ
cblr-5119	587	16	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	587	17	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	587	18	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	587	19	non	non	ADJ
cblr-5119	587	20	-	-	ADJ
cblr-5119	587	21	state	state	ADJ
cblr-5119	587	22	actors	actor	NOUN
cblr-5119	587	23	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	587	24	human	human	ADJ
cblr-5119	587	25	rights	right	NOUN
cblr-5119	587	26	227	227	NUM
cblr-5119	587	27	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	587	28	232	232	NUM
cblr-5119	587	29	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	587	30	philip	philip	PROPN
cblr-5119	587	31	alston	alston	PROPN
cblr-5119	587	32	ed	ed	PROPN
cblr-5119	587	33	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	587	34	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	587	35	2005	2005	NUM
cblr-5119	587	36	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	587	37	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	588	1	210	210	NUM
cblr-5119	588	2	kolieb	kolieb	ADJ
cblr-5119	588	3	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	588	4	supra	supra	PROPN
cblr-5119	588	5	note	note	PROPN
cblr-5119	588	6	104	104	NUM
cblr-5119	588	7	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	588	8	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	588	9	600	600	NUM
cblr-5119	588	10	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	588	11	211	211	NUM
cblr-5119	588	12	clapham	clapham	NOUN
cblr-5119	588	13	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	588	14	supra	supra	PROPN
cblr-5119	588	15	note	note	NOUN
cblr-5119	588	16	52	52	NUM
cblr-5119	588	17	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	588	18	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	588	19	195	195	NUM
cblr-5119	588	20	.	.	NOUN
cblr-5119	588	21	212	212	NUM
cblr-5119	588	22	wouters	wouter	NOUN
cblr-5119	588	23	&	&	CCONJ
cblr-5119	588	24	chanet	chanet	NOUN
cblr-5119	588	25	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	588	26	supra	supra	PROPN
cblr-5119	588	27	note	note	NOUN
cblr-5119	588	28	194	194	NUM
cblr-5119	588	29	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	588	30	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	588	31	264–66	264–66	NUM
cblr-5119	588	32	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	588	33	213	213	NUM
cblr-5119	588	34	see	see	VERB
cblr-5119	588	35	clapham	clapham	NOUN
cblr-5119	588	36	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	588	37	supra	supra	PROPN
cblr-5119	588	38	note	note	NOUN
cblr-5119	588	39	52	52	NUM
cblr-5119	588	40	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	588	41	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	588	42	247–51	247–51	NOUN
cblr-5119	588	43	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	589	1	214	214	NUM
cblr-5119	589	2	i	i	PRON
cblr-5119	589	3	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-5119	589	4	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	589	5	251	251	NUM
cblr-5119	589	6	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	590	1	6_2019.3_estes	6_2019.3_estes	NUM
cblr-5119	590	2	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	590	3	do	do	AUX
cblr-5119	590	4	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	590	5	delte	delte	VERB
cblr-5119	590	6	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	590	7	12/26/2019	12/26/2019	NUM
cblr-5119	590	8	12:00	12:00	NUM
cblr-5119	590	9	am	am	PROPN
cblr-5119	590	10	1074	1074	NUM
cblr-5119	590	11	columbia	columbia	PROPN
cblr-5119	590	12	business	business	NOUN
cblr-5119	590	13	law	law	PROPN
cblr-5119	590	14	review	review	NOUN
cblr-5119	590	15	[	[	X
cblr-5119	590	16	vol	vol	NOUN
cblr-5119	590	17	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	590	18	2019	2019	NUM
cblr-5119	590	19	effectively	effectively	ADV
cblr-5119	590	20	imposes	impose	VERB
cblr-5119	590	21	obligations	obligation	NOUN
cblr-5119	590	22	on	on	ADP
cblr-5119	590	23	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	590	24	through	through	ADP
cblr-5119	590	25	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	590	26	obligations	obligation	NOUN
cblr-5119	590	27	imposed	impose	VERB
cblr-5119	590	28	on	on	ADP
cblr-5119	590	29	states	state	NOUN
cblr-5119	590	30	that	that	PRON
cblr-5119	590	31	fail	fail	VERB
cblr-5119	590	32	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	590	33	redress	redress	VERB
cblr-5119	590	34	their	their	PRON
cblr-5119	590	35	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	590	36	’	'	PUNCT
cblr-5119	590	37	violations.215	violations.215	VERB
cblr-5119	590	38	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	590	39	broadest	broad	ADJ
cblr-5119	590	40	view	view	NOUN
cblr-5119	590	41	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	590	42	this	this	PRON
cblr-5119	590	43	would	would	AUX
cblr-5119	590	44	extend	extend	VERB
cblr-5119	590	45	states	state	NOUN
cblr-5119	590	46	’	'	PUNCT
cblr-5119	590	47	obligations	obligation	NOUN
cblr-5119	590	48	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	590	49	regulating	regulate	VERB
cblr-5119	590	50	their	their	PRON
cblr-5119	590	51	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	590	52	’	'	PUNCT
cblr-5119	590	53	activity	activity	NOUN
cblr-5119	590	54	wherever	wherever	SCONJ
cblr-5119	590	55	it	it	PRON
cblr-5119	590	56	takes	take	VERB
cblr-5119	590	57	place	place	NOUN
cblr-5119	590	58	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	590	59	including	include	VERB
cblr-5119	590	60	extraterritorially.216	extraterritorially.216	NUM
cblr-5119	590	61	this	this	DET
cblr-5119	590	62	all	all	DET
cblr-5119	590	63	points	point	NOUN
cblr-5119	590	64	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	590	65	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	590	66	conclusion	conclusion	NOUN
cblr-5119	590	67	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	590	68	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	590	69	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	590	70	has	have	AUX
cblr-5119	590	71	indeed	indeed	ADV
cblr-5119	590	72	ripened	ripen	VERB
cblr-5119	590	73	into	into	ADP
cblr-5119	590	74	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	590	75	norm	norm	NOUN
cblr-5119	590	76	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	590	77	customary	customary	ADJ
cblr-5119	590	78	international	international	ADJ
cblr-5119	590	79	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	590	80	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	590	81	or	or	CCONJ
cblr-5119	590	82	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	590	83	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	590	84	very	very	ADV
cblr-5119	590	85	least	least	ADJ
cblr-5119	590	86	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	590	87	customary	customary	ADJ
cblr-5119	590	88	international	international	ADJ
cblr-5119	590	89	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	590	90	recognizes	recognize	VERB
cblr-5119	590	91	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	590	92	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	590	93	much	much	ADV
cblr-5119	590	94	more	more	ADJ
cblr-5119	590	95	than	than	ADP
cblr-5119	590	96	judge	judge	NOUN
cblr-5119	590	97	cabranes	cabrane	NOUN
cblr-5119	590	98	indicated	indicate	VERB
cblr-5119	590	99	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	590	100	kiobel	kiobel	PROPN
cblr-5119	590	101	i.	i.	NOUN
cblr-5119	590	102	even	even	ADV
cblr-5119	590	103	under	under	ADP
cblr-5119	590	104	his	his	PRON
cblr-5119	590	105	analytical	analytical	ADJ
cblr-5119	590	106	framework	framework	NOUN
cblr-5119	590	107	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	590	108	there	there	PRON
cblr-5119	590	109	is	be	VERB
cblr-5119	590	110	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	590	111	strong	strong	ADJ
cblr-5119	590	112	argument	argument	NOUN
cblr-5119	590	113	today	today	NOUN
cblr-5119	590	114	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	590	115	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	590	116	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	590	117	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	590	118	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	590	119	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	590	120	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	590	121	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	590	122	nations	nation	NOUN
cblr-5119	590	123	violations	violation	NOUN
cblr-5119	590	124	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	591	1	thus	thus	ADV
cblr-5119	591	2	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	591	3	whether	whether	SCONJ
cblr-5119	591	4	one	one	NUM
cblr-5119	591	5	views	view	VERB
cblr-5119	591	6	federal	federal	ADJ
cblr-5119	591	7	common	common	ADJ
cblr-5119	591	8	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	591	9	or	or	CCONJ
cblr-5119	591	10	customary	customary	ADJ
cblr-5119	591	11	international	international	ADJ
cblr-5119	591	12	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	591	13	as	as	ADP
cblr-5119	591	14	supplying	supply	VERB
cblr-5119	591	15	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	591	16	rule	rule	NOUN
cblr-5119	591	17	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	591	18	decision	decision	NOUN
cblr-5119	591	19	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	591	20	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	591	21	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	591	22	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	591	23	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	591	24	outcome	outcome	NOUN
cblr-5119	591	25	is	be	AUX
cblr-5119	591	26	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	591	27	same	same	ADJ
cblr-5119	591	28	:	:	PUNCT
cblr-5119	591	29	it	it	PRON
cblr-5119	591	30	is	be	AUX
cblr-5119	591	31	appropriate	appropriate	ADJ
cblr-5119	591	32	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	591	33	hold	hold	VERB
cblr-5119	591	34	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	591	35	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	591	36	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	591	37	liable	liable	ADJ
cblr-5119	591	38	under	under	ADP
cblr-5119	591	39	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	591	40	ats	at	NOUN
cblr-5119	591	41	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	591	42	as	as	SCONJ
cblr-5119	591	43	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	591	44	fourth	fourth	ADJ
cblr-5119	591	45	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	591	46	does	do	VERB
cblr-5119	591	47	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	592	1	further	far	ADV
cblr-5119	592	2	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	592	3	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	592	4	fourth	fourth	ADJ
cblr-5119	592	5	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	592	6	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	592	7	liberal	liberal	ADJ
cblr-5119	592	8	regime	regime	NOUN
cblr-5119	592	9	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	592	10	displacing	displace	VERB
cblr-5119	592	11	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	592	12	presumption	presumption	NOUN
cblr-5119	592	13	against	against	ADP
cblr-5119	592	14	extraterritoriality	extraterritoriality	NOUN
cblr-5119	592	15	best	good	ADJ
cblr-5119	592	16	captures	capture	VERB
cblr-5119	592	17	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	592	18	scope	scope	NOUN
cblr-5119	592	19	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	592	20	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	592	21	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	592	22	as	as	SCONJ
cblr-5119	592	23	it	it	PRON
cblr-5119	592	24	was	be	AUX
cblr-5119	592	25	originally	originally	ADV
cblr-5119	592	26	understood	understand	VERB
cblr-5119	592	27	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	593	1	modern	modern	ADJ
cblr-5119	593	2	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	593	3	jurisprudence	jurisprudence	NOUN
cblr-5119	593	4	pre	pre	NOUN
cblr-5119	593	5	-	-	ADJ
cblr-5119	593	6	jesner	jesner	NOUN
cblr-5119	593	7	was	be	AUX
cblr-5119	593	8	overbroad	overbroad	NOUN
cblr-5119	593	9	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	593	10	allowing	allow	VERB
cblr-5119	593	11	claims	claim	NOUN
cblr-5119	593	12	against	against	ADP
cblr-5119	593	13	foreign	foreign	ADJ
cblr-5119	593	14	defendants	defendant	NOUN
cblr-5119	593	15	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	593	16	including	include	VERB
cblr-5119	593	17	foreign	foreign	ADJ
cblr-5119	593	18	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	593	19	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	593	20	because	because	SCONJ
cblr-5119	593	21	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	593	22	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	593	23	was	be	AUX
cblr-5119	593	24	intended	intend	VERB
cblr-5119	593	25	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	593	26	redress	redress	VERB
cblr-5119	593	27	only	only	ADV
cblr-5119	593	28	harms	harm	NOUN
cblr-5119	593	29	caused	cause	VERB
cblr-5119	593	30	by	by	ADP
cblr-5119	593	31	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	593	32	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	593	33	citizens	citizen	NOUN
cblr-5119	593	34	or	or	CCONJ
cblr-5119	593	35	nationals.217	nationals.217	NUM
cblr-5119	593	36	meanwhile	meanwhile	ADV
cblr-5119	593	37	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	593	38	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	593	39	jurisprudence	jurisprudence	NOUN
cblr-5119	593	40	was	be	AUX
cblr-5119	593	41	underinclusive	underinclusive	ADJ
cblr-5119	593	42	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	593	43	sosa	sosa	PROPN
cblr-5119	593	44	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	593	45	limiting	limiting	NOUN
cblr-5119	593	46	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	593	47	substantive	substantive	ADJ
cblr-5119	593	48	claims	claim	NOUN
cblr-5119	593	49	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	593	50	universally	universally	ADV
cblr-5119	593	51	accepted	accept	VERB
cblr-5119	593	52	international	international	ADJ
cblr-5119	593	53	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	593	54	norms	norm	NOUN
cblr-5119	593	55	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	593	56	because	because	SCONJ
cblr-5119	593	57	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	593	58	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	593	59	was	be	AUX
cblr-5119	593	60	intended	intend	VERB
cblr-5119	593	61	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	593	62	cover	cover	VERB
cblr-5119	593	63	any	any	DET
cblr-5119	593	64	intentional	intentional	ADJ
cblr-5119	593	65	tort	tort	NOUN
cblr-5119	593	66	committed	commit	VERB
cblr-5119	593	67	by	by	ADP
cblr-5119	593	68	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	593	69	private	private	ADJ
cblr-5119	593	70	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	593	71	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	593	72	citizen	citizen	NOUN
cblr-5119	593	73	against	against	ADP
cblr-5119	593	74	an	an	DET
cblr-5119	593	75	alien.218	alien.218	NOUN
cblr-5119	593	76	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	593	77	overbroadness	overbroadness	NOUN
cblr-5119	593	78	concern	concern	NOUN
cblr-5119	593	79	is	be	AUX
cblr-5119	593	80	irrelevant	irrelevant	ADJ
cblr-5119	593	81	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	593	82	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	593	83	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	593	84	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	593	85	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	593	86	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	593	87	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	593	88	adopting	adopt	VERB
cblr-5119	593	89	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	593	90	most	most	ADV
cblr-5119	593	91	forgiving	forgiving	ADJ
cblr-5119	593	92	regime	regime	NOUN
cblr-5119	593	93	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	593	94	displacing	displace	VERB
cblr-5119	593	95	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	593	96	presumption	presumption	NOUN
cblr-5119	593	97	helps	help	VERB
cblr-5119	593	98	counteract	counteract	VERB
cblr-5119	593	99	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	593	100	narrowing	narrowing	NOUN
cblr-5119	593	101	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	593	102	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	593	103	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	593	104	that	that	PRON
cblr-5119	593	105	has	have	AUX
cblr-5119	593	106	occurred	occur	VERB
cblr-5119	593	107	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	593	108	modern	modern	ADJ
cblr-5119	593	109	times	time	NOUN
cblr-5119	593	110	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	594	1	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	594	2	all	all	DET
cblr-5119	594	3	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	594	4	circuits	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	594	5	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	594	6	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	594	7	fourth	fourth	ADJ
cblr-5119	594	8	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	594	9	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	594	10	approach	approach	NOUN
cblr-5119	594	11	is	be	AUX
cblr-5119	594	12	as	as	ADV
cblr-5119	594	13	close	close	ADJ
cblr-5119	594	14	as	as	ADP
cblr-5119	594	15	possible	possible	ADJ
cblr-5119	594	16	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	594	17	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	594	18	original	original	ADJ
cblr-5119	594	19	understanding	understanding	NOUN
cblr-5119	594	20	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	594	21	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	594	22	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	594	23	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	595	1	this	this	PRON
cblr-5119	595	2	is	be	AUX
cblr-5119	595	3	critical	critical	ADJ
cblr-5119	595	4	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	595	5	since	since	SCONJ
cblr-5119	595	6	215	215	NUM
cblr-5119	595	7	de	de	NOUN
cblr-5119	595	8	schutter	schutter	NOUN
cblr-5119	595	9	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	595	10	supra	supra	PROPN
cblr-5119	595	11	note	note	NOUN
cblr-5119	595	12	209	209	NUM
cblr-5119	595	13	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	595	14	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	595	15	234–35	234–35	NUM
cblr-5119	595	16	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	596	1	while	while	SCONJ
cblr-5119	596	2	this	this	PRON
cblr-5119	596	3	does	do	AUX
cblr-5119	596	4	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	596	5	constitute	constitute	VERB
cblr-5119	596	6	direct	direct	ADJ
cblr-5119	596	7	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	596	8	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	596	9	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	596	10	it	it	PRON
cblr-5119	596	11	is	be	AUX
cblr-5119	596	12	still	still	ADV
cblr-5119	596	13	evidence	evidence	NOUN
cblr-5119	596	14	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	596	15	international	international	ADJ
cblr-5119	596	16	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	596	17	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	596	18	increasing	increase	VERB
cblr-5119	596	19	recognition	recognition	NOUN
cblr-5119	596	20	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	596	21	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	596	22	wrongdoing	wrongdoing	NOUN
cblr-5119	596	23	merits	merit	VERB
cblr-5119	596	24	civil	civil	ADJ
cblr-5119	596	25	redress	redress	NOUN
cblr-5119	596	26	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	597	1	216	216	NUM
cblr-5119	598	1	i	i	PRON
cblr-5119	598	2	d.	d.	NOUN
cblr-5119	598	3	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	598	4	235	235	NUM
cblr-5119	598	5	.	.	NOUN
cblr-5119	598	6	217	217	NUM
cblr-5119	598	7	bellia	bellia	NOUN
cblr-5119	598	8	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	598	9	jr	jr	PROPN
cblr-5119	598	10	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	598	11	&	&	CCONJ
cblr-5119	598	12	clark	clark	PROPN
cblr-5119	598	13	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	598	14	supra	supra	PROPN
cblr-5119	598	15	note	note	PROPN
cblr-5119	598	16	13	13	NUM
cblr-5119	598	17	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	598	18	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	598	19	454	454	NUM
cblr-5119	598	20	.	.	NOUN
cblr-5119	598	21	218	218	NUM
cblr-5119	599	1	i	i	PRON
cblr-5119	599	2	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-5119	599	3	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	599	4	542–43	542–43	NUM
cblr-5119	599	5	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	600	1	6_2019.3_estes	6_2019.3_estes	NUM
cblr-5119	600	2	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	600	3	do	do	AUX
cblr-5119	600	4	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	600	5	delete	delete	VERB
cblr-5119	600	6	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	600	7	12/26/2019	12/26/2019	NUM
cblr-5119	600	8	12:00	12:00	NUM
cblr-5119	600	9	am	be	AUX
cblr-5119	600	10	no	no	NOUN
cblr-5119	600	11	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	601	1	3:1031	3:1031	NUM
cblr-5119	601	2	]	]	X
cblr-5119	601	3	may	may	AUX
cblr-5119	601	4	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	601	5	fourth	fourth	ADJ
cblr-5119	601	6	be	be	AUX
cblr-5119	601	7	with	with	ADP
cblr-5119	601	8	you	you	PRON
cblr-5119	601	9	1075	1075	NUM
cblr-5119	601	10	modern	modern	ADJ
cblr-5119	601	11	courts	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	601	12	have	have	AUX
cblr-5119	601	13	sought	seek	VERB
cblr-5119	601	14	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	601	15	analyze	analyze	VERB
cblr-5119	601	16	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	601	17	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	601	18	through	through	ADP
cblr-5119	601	19	its	its	PRON
cblr-5119	601	20	original	original	ADJ
cblr-5119	601	21	understanding	understanding	NOUN
cblr-5119	601	22	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	602	1	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	602	2	total	total	NOUN
cblr-5119	602	3	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	602	4	then	then	ADV
cblr-5119	602	5	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	602	6	applying	apply	VERB
cblr-5119	602	7	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	602	8	fourth	fourth	ADJ
cblr-5119	602	9	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	602	10	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	602	11	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	602	12	regime	regime	NOUN
cblr-5119	602	13	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	602	14	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	602	15	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	602	16	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	602	17	is	be	AUX
cblr-5119	602	18	fully	fully	ADV
cblr-5119	602	19	compatible	compatible	ADJ
cblr-5119	602	20	with	with	ADP
cblr-5119	602	21	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	602	22	legal	legal	ADJ
cblr-5119	602	23	principles	principle	NOUN
cblr-5119	602	24	already	already	ADV
cblr-5119	602	25	established	establish	VERB
cblr-5119	602	26	by	by	ADP
cblr-5119	602	27	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	602	28	jurisprudence	jurisprudence	NOUN
cblr-5119	602	29	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	603	1	b.	b.	PROPN
cblr-5119	604	1	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	604	2	fourth	fourth	ADJ
cblr-5119	604	3	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	604	4	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	604	5	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	604	6	regime	regime	NOUN
cblr-5119	604	7	best	well	ADV
cblr-5119	604	8	accommodates	accommodate	VERB
cblr-5119	604	9	all	all	DET
cblr-5119	604	10	stakeholders	stakeholder	NOUN
cblr-5119	604	11	adopting	adopt	VERB
cblr-5119	604	12	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	604	13	fourth	fourth	ADJ
cblr-5119	604	14	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	604	15	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	604	16	flexible	flexible	ADJ
cblr-5119	604	17	regime	regime	NOUN
cblr-5119	604	18	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	604	19	displacing	displace	VERB
cblr-5119	604	20	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	604	21	presumption	presumption	NOUN
cblr-5119	604	22	against	against	ADP
cblr-5119	604	23	extraterritoriality	extraterritoriality	NOUN
cblr-5119	604	24	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	604	25	holding	hold	VERB
cblr-5119	604	26	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	604	27	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	604	28	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	604	29	liable	liable	ADJ
cblr-5119	604	30	under	under	ADP
cblr-5119	604	31	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	604	32	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	604	33	will	will	AUX
cblr-5119	604	34	best	well	ADV
cblr-5119	604	35	address	address	VERB
cblr-5119	604	36	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	604	37	interests	interest	NOUN
cblr-5119	604	38	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	604	39	businesses	business	NOUN
cblr-5119	604	40	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	604	41	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
cblr-5119	604	42	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	604	43	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	604	44	others	other	NOUN
cblr-5119	604	45	affected	affect	VERB
cblr-5119	604	46	by	by	ADP
cblr-5119	604	47	possible	possible	ADJ
cblr-5119	604	48	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	604	49	cases	case	NOUN
cblr-5119	604	50	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	605	1	naturally	naturally	ADV
cblr-5119	605	2	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	605	3	imposing	impose	VERB
cblr-5119	605	4	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	605	5	regime	regime	NOUN
cblr-5119	605	6	that	that	PRON
cblr-5119	605	7	is	be	AUX
cblr-5119	605	8	strictest	strict	ADJ
cblr-5119	605	9	on	on	ADP
cblr-5119	605	10	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	605	11	defendants	defendant	NOUN
cblr-5119	605	12	raises	raise	VERB
cblr-5119	605	13	concerns	concern	NOUN
cblr-5119	605	14	about	about	ADP
cblr-5119	605	15	harmful	harmful	ADJ
cblr-5119	605	16	effects	effect	NOUN
cblr-5119	605	17	on	on	ADP
cblr-5119	605	18	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	605	19	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	605	20	businesses	business	NOUN
cblr-5119	605	21	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	606	1	it	it	PRON
cblr-5119	606	2	may	may	AUX
cblr-5119	606	3	be	be	AUX
cblr-5119	606	4	argued	argue	VERB
cblr-5119	606	5	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	606	6	too	too	ADV
cblr-5119	606	7	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	606	8	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	606	9	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	606	10	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	606	11	businesses	business	NOUN
cblr-5119	606	12	could	could	AUX
cblr-5119	606	13	be	be	AUX
cblr-5119	606	14	discouraged	discourage	VERB
cblr-5119	606	15	from	from	ADP
cblr-5119	606	16	investing	invest	VERB
cblr-5119	606	17	or	or	CCONJ
cblr-5119	606	18	operating	operate	VERB
cblr-5119	606	19	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	606	20	other	other	ADJ
cblr-5119	606	21	countries	country	NOUN
cblr-5119	606	22	if	if	SCONJ
cblr-5119	606	23	they	they	PRON
cblr-5119	606	24	can	can	AUX
cblr-5119	606	25	face	face	VERB
cblr-5119	606	26	potentially	potentially	ADV
cblr-5119	606	27	greater	great	ADJ
cblr-5119	606	28	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	606	29	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	606	30	their	their	PRON
cblr-5119	606	31	actions	action	NOUN
cblr-5119	606	32	abroad	abroad	ADV
cblr-5119	606	33	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	607	1	however	however	ADV
cblr-5119	607	2	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	607	3	imposing	impose	VERB
cblr-5119	607	4	such	such	DET
cblr-5119	607	5	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	607	6	regime	regime	NOUN
cblr-5119	607	7	should	should	AUX
cblr-5119	607	8	only	only	ADV
cblr-5119	607	9	discourage	discourage	VERB
cblr-5119	607	10	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	607	11	type	type	NOUN
cblr-5119	607	12	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	607	13	heinous	heinous	ADJ
cblr-5119	607	14	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	607	15	unconscionable	unconscionable	ADJ
cblr-5119	607	16	behavior	behavior	NOUN
cblr-5119	607	17	that	that	PRON
cblr-5119	607	18	gives	give	VERB
cblr-5119	607	19	rise	rise	NOUN
cblr-5119	607	20	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	607	21	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	607	22	claims	claim	NOUN
cblr-5119	607	23	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	608	1	if	if	SCONJ
cblr-5119	608	2	some	some	DET
cblr-5119	608	3	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	608	4	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	608	5	businesses	business	NOUN
cblr-5119	608	6	feel	feel	VERB
cblr-5119	608	7	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	608	8	they	they	PRON
cblr-5119	608	9	can	can	AUX
cblr-5119	608	10	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	608	11	aid	aid	VERB
cblr-5119	608	12	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	608	13	country	country	NOUN
cblr-5119	608	14	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	608	15	economy	economy	NOUN
cblr-5119	608	16	without	without	ADP
cblr-5119	608	17	de	de	X
cblr-5119	608	18	facto	facto	X
cblr-5119	608	19	immunity	immunity	NOUN
cblr-5119	608	20	from	from	ADP
cblr-5119	608	21	human	human	ADJ
cblr-5119	608	22	rights	right	NOUN
cblr-5119	608	23	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	608	24	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	608	25	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	608	26	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	608	27	should	should	AUX
cblr-5119	608	28	serve	serve	VERB
cblr-5119	608	29	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	608	30	discourage	discourage	VERB
cblr-5119	608	31	such	such	ADJ
cblr-5119	608	32	businesses	business	NOUN
cblr-5119	608	33	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	609	1	society	society	NOUN
cblr-5119	609	2	would	would	AUX
cblr-5119	609	3	be	be	AUX
cblr-5119	609	4	better	well	ADJ
cblr-5119	609	5	off	off	ADP
cblr-5119	609	6	forgoing	forgo	VERB
cblr-5119	609	7	their	their	PRON
cblr-5119	609	8	investment	investment	NOUN
cblr-5119	609	9	if	if	SCONJ
cblr-5119	609	10	it	it	PRON
cblr-5119	609	11	also	also	ADV
cblr-5119	609	12	means	mean	VERB
cblr-5119	609	13	forgoing	forgo	VERB
cblr-5119	609	14	their	their	PRON
cblr-5119	609	15	participation	participation	NOUN
cblr-5119	609	16	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	609	17	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	609	18	commission	commission	NOUN
cblr-5119	609	19	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	609	20	universally	universally	ADV
cblr-5119	609	21	condemned	condemn	VERB
cblr-5119	609	22	crimes	crime	NOUN
cblr-5119	609	23	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	610	1	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	610	2	fourth	fourth	ADJ
cblr-5119	610	3	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	610	4	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	610	5	flexible	flexible	ADJ
cblr-5119	610	6	regime	regime	NOUN
cblr-5119	610	7	also	also	ADV
cblr-5119	610	8	comports	comport	VERB
cblr-5119	610	9	with	with	ADP
cblr-5119	610	10	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	610	11	current	current	ADJ
cblr-5119	610	12	climate	climate	NOUN
cblr-5119	610	13	surrounding	surround	VERB
cblr-5119	610	14	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	610	15	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	610	16	human	human	ADJ
cblr-5119	610	17	rights	right	NOUN
cblr-5119	610	18	:	:	PUNCT
cblr-5119	610	19	businesses	business	NOUN
cblr-5119	610	20	are	be	AUX
cblr-5119	610	21	expected	expect	VERB
cblr-5119	610	22	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	610	23	respect	respect	VERB
cblr-5119	610	24	human	human	ADJ
cblr-5119	610	25	rights	right	NOUN
cblr-5119	610	26	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	610	27	even	even	ADV
cblr-5119	610	28	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	610	29	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	610	30	absence	absence	NOUN
cblr-5119	610	31	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	610	32	government	government	NOUN
cblr-5119	610	33	regulation,219	regulation,219	PROPN
cblr-5119	610	34	meaning	mean	VERB
cblr-5119	610	35	allowing	allow	VERB
cblr-5119	610	36	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	610	37	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	610	38	widest	wide	ADJ
cblr-5119	610	39	possible	possible	ADJ
cblr-5119	610	40	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	610	41	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	610	42	is	be	AUX
cblr-5119	610	43	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	610	44	necessarily	necessarily	ADV
cblr-5119	610	45	out	out	ADP
cblr-5119	610	46	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	610	47	sync	sync	NOUN
cblr-5119	610	48	with	with	ADP
cblr-5119	610	49	their	their	PRON
cblr-5119	610	50	existing	exist	VERB
cblr-5119	610	51	social	social	ADJ
cblr-5119	610	52	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	610	53	legal	legal	ADJ
cblr-5119	610	54	burdens	burden	NOUN
cblr-5119	610	55	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	611	1	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	611	2	business	business	NOUN
cblr-5119	611	3	lobby	lobby	NOUN
cblr-5119	611	4	itself	itself	PRON
cblr-5119	611	5	has	have	AUX
cblr-5119	611	6	begun	begin	VERB
cblr-5119	611	7	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	611	8	acknowledge	acknowledge	VERB
cblr-5119	611	9	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	611	10	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	611	11	must	must	AUX
cblr-5119	611	12	be	be	AUX
cblr-5119	611	13	accountable	accountable	ADJ
cblr-5119	611	14	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	611	15	abuses	abuse	NOUN
cblr-5119	611	16	that	that	PRON
cblr-5119	611	17	occur	occur	VERB
cblr-5119	611	18	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	611	19	developing	develop	VERB
cblr-5119	611	20	countries,220	countries,220	NOUN
cblr-5119	611	21	which	which	PRON
cblr-5119	611	22	is	be	AUX
cblr-5119	611	23	where	where	SCONJ
cblr-5119	611	24	most	most	ADJ
cblr-5119	611	25	modern	modern	ADJ
cblr-5119	611	26	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	611	27	claims	claim	NOUN
cblr-5119	611	28	against	against	ADP
cblr-5119	611	29	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	611	30	219	219	NUM
cblr-5119	611	31	martin	martin	PROPN
cblr-5119	611	32	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	611	33	supra	supra	PROPN
cblr-5119	611	34	note	note	PROPN
cblr-5119	611	35	6	6	NUM
cblr-5119	611	36	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	611	37	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	611	38	991	991	NUM
cblr-5119	611	39	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	611	40	internal	internal	ADJ
cblr-5119	611	41	quotation	quotation	NOUN
cblr-5119	611	42	marks	mark	NOUN
cblr-5119	611	43	omitted	omit	VERB
cblr-5119	611	44	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	611	45	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	612	1	220	220	NUM
cblr-5119	612	2	i	i	PRON
cblr-5119	612	3	d.	d.	PROPN
cblr-5119	612	4	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	612	5	961	961	NUM
cblr-5119	612	6	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	613	1	6_2019.3_estes	6_2019.3_estes	NUM
cblr-5119	613	2	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	613	3	do	do	AUX
cblr-5119	613	4	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	613	5	delte	delte	VERB
cblr-5119	613	6	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	613	7	12/26/2019	12/26/2019	NUM
cblr-5119	613	8	12:00	12:00	NUM
cblr-5119	613	9	am	am	NOUN
cblr-5119	614	1	1076	1076	NUM
cblr-5119	614	2	columbia	columbia	PROPN
cblr-5119	614	3	business	business	NOUN
cblr-5119	614	4	law	law	PROPN
cblr-5119	614	5	review	review	NOUN
cblr-5119	614	6	[	[	X
cblr-5119	614	7	vol	vol	NOUN
cblr-5119	614	8	.	.	NOUN
cblr-5119	614	9	2019	2019	NUM
cblr-5119	614	10	are	be	AUX
cblr-5119	614	11	derived	derive	VERB
cblr-5119	614	12	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	615	1	221	221	NUM
cblr-5119	615	2	this	this	PRON
cblr-5119	615	3	is	be	AUX
cblr-5119	615	4	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	615	5	least	least	ADJ
cblr-5119	615	6	partly	partly	ADV
cblr-5119	615	7	evidenced	evidence	VERB
cblr-5119	615	8	by	by	ADP
cblr-5119	615	9	businesses	business	NOUN
cblr-5119	615	10	voluntarily	voluntarily	ADV
cblr-5119	615	11	agreeing	agree	VERB
cblr-5119	615	12	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	615	13	road	road	NOUN
cblr-5119	615	14	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-5119	615	15	test	test	NOUN
cblr-5119	615	16	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	615	17	united	united	PROPN
cblr-5119	615	18	nations	nations	PROPN
cblr-5119	615	19	’	'	PUNCT
cblr-5119	615	20	norms	norm	NOUN
cblr-5119	615	21	on	on	ADP
cblr-5119	615	22	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	615	23	responsibilities	responsibility	NOUN
cblr-5119	615	24	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	615	25	transnational	transnational	ADJ
cblr-5119	615	26	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	615	27	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	615	28	other	other	ADJ
cblr-5119	615	29	business	business	NOUN
cblr-5119	615	30	enterprises	enterprise	NOUN
cblr-5119	615	31	with	with	ADP
cblr-5119	615	32	regard	regard	NOUN
cblr-5119	615	33	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	615	34	human	human	ADJ
cblr-5119	615	35	rights	right	NOUN
cblr-5119	615	36	when	when	SCONJ
cblr-5119	615	37	they	they	PRON
cblr-5119	615	38	were	be	AUX
cblr-5119	615	39	first	first	ADV
cblr-5119	615	40	adopted	adopt	VERB
cblr-5119	615	41	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	615	42	2003.222	2003.222	NUM
cblr-5119	615	43	as	as	SCONJ
cblr-5119	615	44	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	615	45	increasingly	increasingly	ADV
cblr-5119	615	46	profess	profess	VERB
cblr-5119	615	47	their	their	PRON
cblr-5119	615	48	commitment	commitment	NOUN
cblr-5119	615	49	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	615	50	protecting	protect	VERB
cblr-5119	615	51	human	human	ADJ
cblr-5119	615	52	rights	right	NOUN
cblr-5119	615	53	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	615	54	they	they	PRON
cblr-5119	615	55	are	be	AUX
cblr-5119	615	56	increasingly	increasingly	ADV
cblr-5119	615	57	unable	unable	ADJ
cblr-5119	615	58	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	615	59	explain	explain	VERB
cblr-5119	615	60	away	away	ADP
cblr-5119	615	61	abuses	abuse	NOUN
cblr-5119	615	62	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	615	63	they	they	PRON
cblr-5119	615	64	commit	commit	VERB
cblr-5119	615	65	due	due	ADP
cblr-5119	615	66	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	615	67	their	their	PRON
cblr-5119	615	68	failure	failure	NOUN
cblr-5119	615	69	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	615	70	monitor	monitor	VERB
cblr-5119	615	71	their	their	PRON
cblr-5119	615	72	own	own	ADJ
cblr-5119	615	73	operations.223	operations.223	NOUN
cblr-5119	615	74	it	it	PRON
cblr-5119	615	75	follows	follow	VERB
cblr-5119	615	76	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	615	77	imposition	imposition	NOUN
cblr-5119	615	78	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	615	79	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	615	80	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	615	81	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	615	82	even	even	ADV
cblr-5119	615	83	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	615	84	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	615	85	most	most	ADV
cblr-5119	615	86	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
cblr-5119	615	87	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-5119	615	88	friendly	friendly	ADJ
cblr-5119	615	89	form	form	NOUN
cblr-5119	615	90	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	615	91	is	be	AUX
cblr-5119	615	92	increasingly	increasingly	ADV
cblr-5119	615	93	justifiable	justifiable	ADJ
cblr-5119	615	94	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	616	1	finally	finally	ADV
cblr-5119	616	2	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	616	3	greater	great	ADJ
cblr-5119	616	4	scrutiny	scrutiny	NOUN
cblr-5119	616	5	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	616	6	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	616	7	’	'	PUNCT
cblr-5119	616	8	human	human	ADJ
cblr-5119	616	9	rights	right	NOUN
cblr-5119	616	10	practices	practice	NOUN
cblr-5119	616	11	could	could	AUX
cblr-5119	616	12	also	also	ADV
cblr-5119	616	13	prove	prove	VERB
cblr-5119	616	14	beneficial	beneficial	ADJ
cblr-5119	616	15	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	616	16	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	616	17	themselves	themselves	PRON
cblr-5119	616	18	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	617	1	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	617	2	human	human	ADJ
cblr-5119	617	3	rights	right	NOUN
cblr-5119	617	4	abuses	abuse	NOUN
cblr-5119	617	5	often	often	ADV
cblr-5119	617	6	trigger	trigger	VERB
cblr-5119	617	7	significant	significant	ADJ
cblr-5119	617	8	backlash	backlash	NOUN
cblr-5119	617	9	from	from	ADP
cblr-5119	617	10	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	617	11	public	public	NOUN
cblr-5119	617	12	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	617	13	which	which	PRON
cblr-5119	617	14	could	could	AUX
cblr-5119	617	15	lead	lead	VERB
cblr-5119	617	16	shareholders	shareholder	NOUN
cblr-5119	617	17	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	617	18	investors	investor	NOUN
cblr-5119	617	19	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	617	20	withdraw	withdraw	VERB
cblr-5119	617	21	from	from	ADP
cblr-5119	617	22	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	617	23	offending	offend	VERB
cblr-5119	617	24	organizations.224	organizations.224	NUM
cblr-5119	617	25	greater	great	ADJ
cblr-5119	617	26	ats	at	NOUN
cblr-5119	617	27	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	617	28	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	617	29	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	617	30	its	its	PRON
cblr-5119	617	31	potential	potential	ADJ
cblr-5119	617	32	deterrent	deterrent	NOUN
cblr-5119	617	33	effect	effect	NOUN
cblr-5119	617	34	on	on	ADP
cblr-5119	617	35	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	617	36	misbehavior	misbehavior	NOUN
cblr-5119	617	37	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	617	38	could	could	AUX
cblr-5119	617	39	lead	lead	VERB
cblr-5119	617	40	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	617	41	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	617	42	reduction	reduction	NOUN
cblr-5119	617	43	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	617	44	human	human	ADJ
cblr-5119	617	45	rights	right	NOUN
cblr-5119	617	46	abuses	abuse	NOUN
cblr-5119	617	47	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	617	48	thereby	thereby	ADV
cblr-5119	617	49	preventing	prevent	VERB
cblr-5119	617	50	shareholder	shareholder	NOUN
cblr-5119	617	51	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	617	52	investor	investor	NOUN
cblr-5119	617	53	departures	departure	NOUN
cblr-5119	617	54	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	618	1	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	618	2	terms	term	NOUN
cblr-5119	618	3	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	618	4	legal	legal	ADJ
cblr-5119	618	5	certainty	certainty	NOUN
cblr-5119	618	6	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	618	7	because	because	SCONJ
cblr-5119	618	8	all	all	DET
cblr-5119	618	9	circuits	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	618	10	except	except	SCONJ
cblr-5119	618	11	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	618	12	second	second	ADJ
cblr-5119	618	13	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	618	14	have	have	AUX
cblr-5119	618	15	recognized	recognize	VERB
cblr-5119	618	16	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	618	17	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	618	18	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	618	19	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	618	20	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	618	21	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	618	22	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	618	23	are	be	AUX
cblr-5119	618	24	already	already	ADV
cblr-5119	618	25	on	on	ADP
cblr-5119	618	26	notice	notice	NOUN
cblr-5119	618	27	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	618	28	they	they	PRON
cblr-5119	618	29	are	be	AUX
cblr-5119	618	30	subject	subject	ADJ
cblr-5119	618	31	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	618	32	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	618	33	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	618	34	their	their	PRON
cblr-5119	618	35	human	human	ADJ
cblr-5119	618	36	rights	right	NOUN
cblr-5119	618	37	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-5119	618	38	related	relate	VERB
cblr-5119	618	39	behavior.225	behavior.225	NOUN
cblr-5119	618	40	even	even	ADV
cblr-5119	618	41	so	so	ADV
cblr-5119	618	42	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	618	43	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	618	44	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	618	45	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	618	46	continue	continue	VERB
cblr-5119	618	47	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	618	48	enjoy	enjoy	VERB
cblr-5119	618	49	meaningful	meaningful	ADJ
cblr-5119	618	50	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	618	51	safeguards	safeguard	NOUN
cblr-5119	618	52	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	619	1	first	first	ADV
cblr-5119	619	2	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	619	3	even	even	ADV
cblr-5119	619	4	with	with	ADP
cblr-5119	619	5	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	619	6	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	619	7	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	619	8	expansion	expansion	NOUN
cblr-5119	619	9	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	619	10	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	619	11	modern	modern	ADJ
cblr-5119	619	12	era	era	NOUN
cblr-5119	619	13	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	619	14	only	only	ADV
cblr-5119	619	15	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	619	16	limited	limited	ADJ
cblr-5119	619	17	number	number	NOUN
cblr-5119	619	18	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	619	19	substantive	substantive	ADJ
cblr-5119	619	20	offenses	offense	NOUN
cblr-5119	619	21	remain	remain	VERB
cblr-5119	619	22	actionable	actionable	ADJ
cblr-5119	619	23	under	under	ADP
cblr-5119	619	24	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	619	25	statute.226	statute.226	NOUN
cblr-5119	619	26	second	second	ADJ
cblr-5119	619	27	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	619	28	businesses	business	NOUN
cblr-5119	619	29	221	221	NUM
cblr-5119	619	30	see	see	VERB
cblr-5119	619	31	fox	fox	PROPN
cblr-5119	619	32	&	&	CCONJ
cblr-5119	619	33	goze	goze	PROPN
cblr-5119	619	34	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	619	35	supra	supra	PROPN
cblr-5119	619	36	note	note	NOUN
cblr-5119	619	37	5	5	NUM
cblr-5119	619	38	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	619	39	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	619	40	45	45	NUM
cblr-5119	619	41	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	619	42	generally	generally	ADV
cblr-5119	619	43	describing	describe	VERB
cblr-5119	619	44	modern	modern	ADJ
cblr-5119	619	45	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	619	46	claims	claim	NOUN
cblr-5119	619	47	against	against	ADP
cblr-5119	619	48	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	619	49	as	as	ADP
cblr-5119	619	50	involving	involve	VERB
cblr-5119	619	51	business	business	NOUN
cblr-5119	619	52	activities	activity	NOUN
cblr-5119	619	53	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	619	54	developing	develop	VERB
cblr-5119	619	55	countries	country	NOUN
cblr-5119	619	56	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	619	57	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	620	1	222	222	NUM
cblr-5119	620	2	david	david	PROPN
cblr-5119	620	3	weissbrodt	weissbrodt	PROPN
cblr-5119	620	4	&	&	CCONJ
cblr-5119	620	5	muria	muria	PROPN
cblr-5119	620	6	kruger	kruger	PROPN
cblr-5119	620	7	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	620	8	norms	norm	VERB
cblr-5119	620	9	on	on	ADP
cblr-5119	620	10	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	620	11	responsibilities	responsibility	NOUN
cblr-5119	620	12	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	620	13	transnational	transnational	ADJ
cblr-5119	620	14	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	620	15	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	620	16	other	other	ADJ
cblr-5119	620	17	business	business	NOUN
cblr-5119	620	18	enterprises	enterprise	NOUN
cblr-5119	620	19	with	with	ADP
cblr-5119	620	20	regard	regard	NOUN
cblr-5119	620	21	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	620	22	human	human	ADJ
cblr-5119	620	23	rights	right	NOUN
cblr-5119	620	24	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	620	25	97	97	NUM
cblr-5119	620	26	am	am	NOUN
cblr-5119	620	27	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	621	1	j.	j.	PROPN
cblr-5119	621	2	int’l	int’l	PROPN
cblr-5119	621	3	l.	l.	PROPN
cblr-5119	621	4	901	901	NUM
cblr-5119	621	5	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	621	6	907	907	NUM
cblr-5119	621	7	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	621	8	2003	2003	NUM
cblr-5119	621	9	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	621	10	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	622	1	223	223	NUM
cblr-5119	622	2	martin	martin	PROPN
cblr-5119	622	3	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	622	4	supra	supra	PROPN
cblr-5119	622	5	note	note	NOUN
cblr-5119	622	6	6	6	NUM
cblr-5119	622	7	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	622	8	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	622	9	998	998	NUM
cblr-5119	622	10	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	623	1	224	224	NUM
cblr-5119	623	2	i	i	PRON
cblr-5119	623	3	d.	d.	VERB
cblr-5119	623	4	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	623	5	963–64	963–64	PROPN
cblr-5119	623	6	;	;	PUNCT
cblr-5119	623	7	see	see	VERB
cblr-5119	623	8	also	also	ADV
cblr-5119	623	9	wouters	wouter	NOUN
cblr-5119	623	10	&	&	CCONJ
cblr-5119	623	11	chanet	chanet	NOUN
cblr-5119	623	12	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	623	13	supra	supra	PROPN
cblr-5119	623	14	note	note	NOUN
cblr-5119	623	15	194	194	NUM
cblr-5119	623	16	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	623	17	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	623	18	269	269	NUM
cblr-5119	623	19	.	.	NOUN
cblr-5119	623	20	225	225	NUM
cblr-5119	623	21	even	even	ADV
cblr-5119	623	22	were	be	AUX
cblr-5119	623	23	this	this	PRON
cblr-5119	623	24	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	623	25	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	623	26	case	case	NOUN
cblr-5119	623	27	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	623	28	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	623	29	offenses	offense	NOUN
cblr-5119	623	30	cognizable	cognizable	ADJ
cblr-5119	623	31	under	under	ADP
cblr-5119	623	32	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	623	33	ats	at	NOUN
cblr-5119	623	34	are	be	AUX
cblr-5119	623	35	so	so	ADV
cblr-5119	623	36	egregious	egregious	ADJ
cblr-5119	623	37	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	623	38	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	623	39	should	should	AUX
cblr-5119	623	40	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	623	41	need	need	VERB
cblr-5119	623	42	such	such	ADJ
cblr-5119	623	43	notice	notice	NOUN
cblr-5119	623	44	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	623	45	order	order	NOUN
cblr-5119	623	46	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	623	47	refrain	refrain	VERB
cblr-5119	623	48	from	from	ADP
cblr-5119	623	49	unconscionable	unconscionable	ADJ
cblr-5119	623	50	behavior	behavior	NOUN
cblr-5119	623	51	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	624	1	226	226	NUM
cblr-5119	624	2	clapham	clapham	NOUN
cblr-5119	624	3	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	624	4	supra	supra	PROPN
cblr-5119	624	5	note	note	NOUN
cblr-5119	624	6	52	52	NUM
cblr-5119	624	7	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	624	8	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	624	9	253	253	NUM
cblr-5119	624	10	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	625	1	6_2019.3_estes	6_2019.3_estes	NUM
cblr-5119	625	2	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	625	3	do	do	AUX
cblr-5119	625	4	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	625	5	delete	delete	VERB
cblr-5119	625	6	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	625	7	12/26/2019	12/26/2019	NUM
cblr-5119	625	8	12:00	12:00	NUM
cblr-5119	625	9	am	be	AUX
cblr-5119	625	10	no	no	NOUN
cblr-5119	625	11	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	626	1	3:1031	3:1031	NUM
cblr-5119	626	2	]	]	X
cblr-5119	626	3	may	may	AUX
cblr-5119	626	4	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	626	5	fourth	fourth	ADJ
cblr-5119	626	6	be	be	AUX
cblr-5119	626	7	with	with	ADP
cblr-5119	626	8	you	you	PRON
cblr-5119	626	9	1077	1077	NUM
cblr-5119	626	10	remain	remain	AUX
cblr-5119	626	11	protected	protect	VERB
cblr-5119	626	12	by	by	ADP
cblr-5119	626	13	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	626	14	common	common	ADJ
cblr-5119	626	15	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	626	16	doctrine	doctrine	NOUN
cblr-5119	626	17	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	626	18	forum	forum	PROPN
cblr-5119	626	19	non	non	PROPN
cblr-5119	626	20	conveniens	conveniens	PROPN
cblr-5119	626	21	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	627	1	by	by	ADP
cblr-5119	627	2	invoking	invoke	VERB
cblr-5119	627	3	forum	forum	PROPN
cblr-5119	627	4	non	non	PROPN
cblr-5119	627	5	conveniens	conveniens	PROPN
cblr-5119	627	6	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	627	7	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	627	8	federal	federal	ADJ
cblr-5119	627	9	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	627	10	may	may	AUX
cblr-5119	627	11	dismiss	dismiss	VERB
cblr-5119	627	12	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	627	13	suit	suit	NOUN
cblr-5119	627	14	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	627	15	its	its	PRON
cblr-5119	627	16	discretion	discretion	NOUN
cblr-5119	627	17	if	if	SCONJ
cblr-5119	627	18	an	an	DET
cblr-5119	627	19	adequate	adequate	ADJ
cblr-5119	627	20	alternative	alternative	ADJ
cblr-5119	627	21	forum	forum	NOUN
cblr-5119	627	22	is	be	AUX
cblr-5119	627	23	available	available	ADJ
cblr-5119	627	24	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	627	25	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	627	26	balance	balance	NOUN
cblr-5119	627	27	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	627	28	relevant	relevant	ADJ
cblr-5119	627	29	private	private	ADJ
cblr-5119	627	30	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	627	31	public	public	ADJ
cblr-5119	627	32	interests	interest	NOUN
cblr-5119	627	33	favors	favor	VERB
cblr-5119	627	34	dismissal.227	dismissal.227	PROPN
cblr-5119	627	35	given	give	VERB
cblr-5119	627	36	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	627	37	significant	significant	ADJ
cblr-5119	627	38	amount	amount	NOUN
cblr-5119	627	39	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	627	40	extraterritorial	extraterritorial	ADJ
cblr-5119	627	41	conduct	conduct	NOUN
cblr-5119	627	42	that	that	PRON
cblr-5119	627	43	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	627	44	cases	case	NOUN
cblr-5119	627	45	involve	involve	VERB
cblr-5119	627	46	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	627	47	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	627	48	possible	possible	ADJ
cblr-5119	627	49	availability	availability	NOUN
cblr-5119	627	50	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	627	51	fora	forum	NOUN
cblr-5119	627	52	where	where	SCONJ
cblr-5119	627	53	said	say	VERB
cblr-5119	627	54	conduct	conduct	NOUN
cblr-5119	627	55	occurs	occur	VERB
cblr-5119	627	56	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	627	57	forum	forum	PROPN
cblr-5119	627	58	non	non	PROPN
cblr-5119	627	59	conveniens	convenien	NOUN
cblr-5119	627	60	would	would	AUX
cblr-5119	627	61	seem	seem	VERB
cblr-5119	627	62	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	627	63	be	be	AUX
cblr-5119	627	64	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	627	65	very	very	ADV
cblr-5119	627	66	meaningful	meaningful	ADJ
cblr-5119	627	67	safeguard	safeguard	NOUN
cblr-5119	627	68	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	627	69	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	627	70	defendants.228	defendants.228	PROPN
cblr-5119	627	71	third	third	ADV
cblr-5119	627	72	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	627	73	as	as	SCONJ
cblr-5119	627	74	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	627	75	supreme	supreme	PROPN
cblr-5119	627	76	court	court	PROPN
cblr-5119	627	77	did	do	VERB
cblr-5119	627	78	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	627	79	jesner	jesner	NOUN
cblr-5119	627	80	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	627	81	any	any	DET
cblr-5119	627	82	federal	federal	ADJ
cblr-5119	627	83	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	627	84	would	would	AUX
cblr-5119	627	85	be	be	AUX
cblr-5119	627	86	able	able	ADJ
cblr-5119	627	87	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	627	88	dismiss	dismiss	VERB
cblr-5119	627	89	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	627	90	case	case	NOUN
cblr-5119	627	91	if	if	SCONJ
cblr-5119	627	92	it	it	PRON
cblr-5119	627	93	happened	happen	VERB
cblr-5119	627	94	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	627	95	implicate	implicate	VERB
cblr-5119	627	96	serious	serious	ADJ
cblr-5119	627	97	foreign	foreign	ADJ
cblr-5119	627	98	relations	relation	NOUN
cblr-5119	627	99	concerns	concern	NOUN
cblr-5119	627	100	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	628	1	lastly	lastly	ADV
cblr-5119	628	2	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	628	3	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	628	4	course	course	NOUN
cblr-5119	628	5	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	628	6	there	there	PRON
cblr-5119	628	7	is	be	VERB
cblr-5119	628	8	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	628	9	presumption	presumption	NOUN
cblr-5119	628	10	against	against	ADP
cblr-5119	628	11	extraterritoriality	extraterritoriality	NOUN
cblr-5119	628	12	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	629	1	while	while	SCONJ
cblr-5119	629	2	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	629	3	fourth	fourth	ADJ
cblr-5119	629	4	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	629	5	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	629	6	regime	regime	NOUN
cblr-5119	629	7	is	be	AUX
cblr-5119	629	8	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	629	9	most	most	ADV
cblr-5119	629	10	liberal	liberal	ADJ
cblr-5119	629	11	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	629	12	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	629	13	circuits	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	629	14	when	when	SCONJ
cblr-5119	629	15	it	it	PRON
cblr-5119	629	16	comes	come	VERB
cblr-5119	629	17	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	629	18	displacing	displace	VERB
cblr-5119	629	19	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	629	20	presumption	presumption	NOUN
cblr-5119	629	21	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	629	22	it	it	PRON
cblr-5119	629	23	still	still	ADV
cblr-5119	629	24	carries	carry	VERB
cblr-5119	629	25	plenty	plenty	NOUN
cblr-5119	629	26	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	629	27	flexibility	flexibility	NOUN
cblr-5119	629	28	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	629	29	decline	decline	VERB
cblr-5119	629	30	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NOUN
cblr-5119	629	31	whenever	whenever	SCONJ
cblr-5119	629	32	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	629	33	claim	claim	NOUN
cblr-5119	629	34	does	do	AUX
cblr-5119	629	35	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	629	36	sufficiently	sufficiently	ADV
cblr-5119	629	37	touch	touch	VERB
cblr-5119	629	38	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	629	39	concern	concern	NOUN
cblr-5119	629	40	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	629	41	united	united	PROPN
cblr-5119	629	42	states	states	PROPN
cblr-5119	629	43	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	630	1	with	with	ADP
cblr-5119	630	2	all	all	DET
cblr-5119	630	3	these	these	DET
cblr-5119	630	4	safeguards	safeguard	NOUN
cblr-5119	630	5	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	630	6	place	place	NOUN
cblr-5119	630	7	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	630	8	there	there	PRON
cblr-5119	630	9	should	should	AUX
cblr-5119	630	10	be	be	AUX
cblr-5119	630	11	no	no	DET
cblr-5119	630	12	concern	concern	NOUN
cblr-5119	630	13	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	630	14	adopting	adopt	VERB
cblr-5119	630	15	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	630	16	fourth	fourth	ADJ
cblr-5119	630	17	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	630	18	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	630	19	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	630	20	regime	regime	NOUN
cblr-5119	630	21	will	will	AUX
cblr-5119	630	22	unduly	unduly	ADV
cblr-5119	630	23	burden	burden	VERB
cblr-5119	630	24	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	630	25	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	630	26	businesses	business	NOUN
cblr-5119	630	27	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	631	1	incorporating	incorporate	VERB
cblr-5119	631	2	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	631	3	most	most	ADV
cblr-5119	631	4	liberal	liberal	ADJ
cblr-5119	631	5	possible	possible	ADJ
cblr-5119	631	6	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	631	7	regime	regime	NOUN
cblr-5119	631	8	will	will	AUX
cblr-5119	631	9	also	also	ADV
cblr-5119	631	10	ensure	ensure	VERB
cblr-5119	631	11	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	631	12	victims	victim	NOUN
cblr-5119	631	13	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	631	14	human	human	ADJ
cblr-5119	631	15	rights	right	NOUN
cblr-5119	631	16	abuses	abuse	NOUN
cblr-5119	631	17	committed	commit	VERB
cblr-5119	631	18	by	by	ADP
cblr-5119	631	19	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	631	20	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	631	21	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	631	22	have	have	VERB
cblr-5119	631	23	access	access	NOUN
cblr-5119	631	24	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	631	25	meaningful	meaningful	ADJ
cblr-5119	631	26	civil	civil	ADJ
cblr-5119	631	27	recourse	recourse	NOUN
cblr-5119	631	28	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	632	1	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	632	2	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	632	3	has	have	AUX
cblr-5119	632	4	developed	develop	VERB
cblr-5119	632	5	into	into	ADP
cblr-5119	632	6	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	632	7	notable	notable	ADJ
cblr-5119	632	8	tool	tool	NOUN
cblr-5119	632	9	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	632	10	providing	provide	VERB
cblr-5119	632	11	redress	redress	NOUN
cblr-5119	632	12	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	632	13	human	human	ADJ
cblr-5119	632	14	rights	right	NOUN
cblr-5119	632	15	abuses	abuse	NOUN
cblr-5119	632	16	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	632	17	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	632	18	alien	alien	ADJ
cblr-5119	632	19	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
cblr-5119	632	20	should	should	AUX
cblr-5119	632	21	continue	continue	VERB
cblr-5119	632	22	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	632	23	be	be	AUX
cblr-5119	632	24	able	able	ADJ
cblr-5119	632	25	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	632	26	rely	rely	VERB
cblr-5119	632	27	on	on	ADP
cblr-5119	632	28	it	it	PRON
cblr-5119	632	29	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	633	1	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	633	2	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	633	3	is	be	AUX
cblr-5119	633	4	often	often	ADV
cblr-5119	633	5	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	633	6	only	only	ADJ
cblr-5119	633	7	avenue	avenue	NOUN
cblr-5119	633	8	available	available	ADJ
cblr-5119	633	9	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	633	10	alien	alien	ADJ
cblr-5119	633	11	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
cblr-5119	633	12	due	due	ADP
cblr-5119	633	13	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	633	14	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	633	15	inadequacy	inadequacy	NOUN
cblr-5119	633	16	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	633	17	their	their	PRON
cblr-5119	633	18	own	own	ADJ
cblr-5119	633	19	countries	country	NOUN
cblr-5119	633	20	’	'	PUNCT
cblr-5119	633	21	legal	legal	ADJ
cblr-5119	633	22	systems	system	NOUN
cblr-5119	633	23	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	633	24	or	or	CCONJ
cblr-5119	633	25	local	local	ADJ
cblr-5119	633	26	authorities	authority	NOUN
cblr-5119	633	27	’	'	PUNCT
cblr-5119	633	28	failure	failure	NOUN
cblr-5119	633	29	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	633	30	penalize	penalize	VERB
cblr-5119	633	31	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	633	32	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	633	33	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	633	34	over	over	ADP
cblr-5119	633	35	fears	fear	NOUN
cblr-5119	633	36	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	633	37	losing	lose	VERB
cblr-5119	633	38	much	much	ADV
cblr-5119	633	39	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-5119	633	40	needed	need	VERB
cblr-5119	633	41	investment.229	investment.229	NOUN
cblr-5119	633	42	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
cblr-5119	633	43	also	also	ADV
cblr-5119	633	44	can	can	AUX
cblr-5119	633	45	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	633	46	rely	rely	VERB
cblr-5119	633	47	on	on	ADP
cblr-5119	633	48	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	633	49	selfgovernance	selfgovernance	NOUN
cblr-5119	633	50	alone	alone	ADJ
cblr-5119	633	51	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	633	52	protection	protection	NOUN
cblr-5119	633	53	from	from	ADP
cblr-5119	633	54	human	human	ADJ
cblr-5119	633	55	rights	right	NOUN
cblr-5119	633	56	abuses	abuse	NOUN
cblr-5119	633	57	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	634	1	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	634	2	all	all	DET
cblr-5119	634	3	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	634	4	will	will	AUX
cblr-5119	634	5	sufficiently	sufficiently	ADV
cblr-5119	634	6	modify	modify	VERB
cblr-5119	634	7	their	their	PRON
cblr-5119	634	8	behavior	behavior	NOUN
cblr-5119	634	9	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	634	10	prevent	prevent	VERB
cblr-5119	634	11	abuses	abuse	NOUN
cblr-5119	634	12	because	because	SCONJ
cblr-5119	634	13	it	it	PRON
cblr-5119	634	14	is	be	AUX
cblr-5119	634	15	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	634	16	necessarily	necessarily	ADV
cblr-5119	634	17	profitable	profitable	ADJ
cblr-5119	634	18	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	634	19	do	do	VERB
cblr-5119	634	20	227	227	NUM
cblr-5119	634	21	restatement	restatement	NOUN
cblr-5119	634	22	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	634	23	fourth	fourth	ADJ
cblr-5119	634	24	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	634	25	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	634	26	foreign	foreign	ADJ
cblr-5119	634	27	relations	relation	NOUN
cblr-5119	634	28	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	634	29	§	§	NOUN
cblr-5119	634	30	424	424	NUM
cblr-5119	634	31	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	634	32	2018	2018	NUM
cblr-5119	634	33	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	634	34	;	;	PUNCT
cblr-5119	634	35	see	see	VERB
cblr-5119	634	36	also	also	ADV
cblr-5119	634	37	piper	piper	NOUN
cblr-5119	634	38	aircraft	aircraft	PROPN
cblr-5119	634	39	co.	co.	PROPN
cblr-5119	635	1	v.	v.	ADP
cblr-5119	635	2	reyno	reyno	NOUN
cblr-5119	635	3	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	635	4	454	454	NUM
cblr-5119	635	5	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	635	6	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	635	7	235	235	NUM
cblr-5119	635	8	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	635	9	1981	1981	NUM
cblr-5119	635	10	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	635	11	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	636	1	228	228	NUM
cblr-5119	636	2	see	see	VERB
cblr-5119	636	3	kiobel	kiobel	PROPN
cblr-5119	636	4	v.	v.	ADP
cblr-5119	636	5	royal	royal	PROPN
cblr-5119	636	6	dutch	dutch	PROPN
cblr-5119	636	7	petroleum	petroleum	PROPN
cblr-5119	636	8	co.	co.	PROPN
cblr-5119	636	9	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	636	10	569	569	NUM
cblr-5119	636	11	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	636	12	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	636	13	108	108	NUM
cblr-5119	636	14	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	636	15	139	139	NUM
cblr-5119	636	16	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	636	17	2013	2013	NUM
cblr-5119	636	18	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	636	19	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	636	20	breyer	breyer	NOUN
cblr-5119	636	21	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	636	22	j.	j.	PROPN
cblr-5119	636	23	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	636	24	concurring	concur	VERB
cblr-5119	636	25	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	636	26	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	636	27	discussing	discuss	VERB
cblr-5119	636	28	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	636	29	preferred	preferred	ADJ
cblr-5119	636	30	jurisdictional	jurisdictional	ADJ
cblr-5119	636	31	understanding	understanding	NOUN
cblr-5119	636	32	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	636	33	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	636	34	ats	at	NOUN
cblr-5119	636	35	which	which	PRON
cblr-5119	636	36	would	would	AUX
cblr-5119	636	37	rely	rely	VERB
cblr-5119	636	38	on	on	ADP
cblr-5119	636	39	courts	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	636	40	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	636	41	invoke	invoke	VERB
cblr-5119	636	42	forum	forum	PROPN
cblr-5119	636	43	non	non	PROPN
cblr-5119	636	44	conveniens	convenien	NOUN
cblr-5119	636	45	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	636	46	decline	decline	VERB
cblr-5119	636	47	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NOUN
cblr-5119	636	48	when	when	SCONJ
cblr-5119	636	49	appropriate	appropriate	ADJ
cblr-5119	636	50	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	636	51	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	637	1	229	229	NUM
cblr-5119	637	2	clapham	clapham	NOUN
cblr-5119	637	3	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	637	4	supra	supra	PROPN
cblr-5119	637	5	note	note	NOUN
cblr-5119	637	6	52	52	NUM
cblr-5119	637	7	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	637	8	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	637	9	238	238	NUM
cblr-5119	637	10	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	638	1	6_2019.3_estes	6_2019.3_estes	NUM
cblr-5119	638	2	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	638	3	do	do	AUX
cblr-5119	638	4	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	638	5	delte	delte	VERB
cblr-5119	638	6	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	638	7	12/26/2019	12/26/2019	NUM
cblr-5119	638	8	12:00	12:00	NUM
cblr-5119	638	9	am	be	AUX
cblr-5119	639	1	1078	1078	NUM
cblr-5119	639	2	columbia	columbia	PROPN
cblr-5119	639	3	business	business	NOUN
cblr-5119	639	4	law	law	PROPN
cblr-5119	639	5	review	review	NOUN
cblr-5119	639	6	[	[	X
cblr-5119	639	7	vol	vol	NOUN
cblr-5119	639	8	.	.	NOUN
cblr-5119	639	9	2019	2019	NUM
cblr-5119	639	10	so,230	so,230	ADJ
cblr-5119	639	11	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	639	12	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	639	13	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	639	14	social	social	ADJ
cblr-5119	639	15	responsibility	responsibility	NOUN
cblr-5119	639	16	movement	movement	NOUN
cblr-5119	639	17	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	639	18	which	which	PRON
cblr-5119	639	19	encourages	encourage	VERB
cblr-5119	639	20	businesses	business	NOUN
cblr-5119	639	21	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	639	22	adopt	adopt	VERB
cblr-5119	639	23	socially	socially	ADV
cblr-5119	639	24	conscious	conscious	ADJ
cblr-5119	639	25	practices	practice	NOUN
cblr-5119	639	26	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	639	27	is	be	AUX
cblr-5119	639	28	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	639	29	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	639	30	proper	proper	ADJ
cblr-5119	639	31	solution	solution	NOUN
cblr-5119	639	32	because	because	SCONJ
cblr-5119	639	33	it	it	PRON
cblr-5119	639	34	is	be	AUX
cblr-5119	639	35	entirely	entirely	ADV
cblr-5119	639	36	voluntary.231	voluntary.231	VERB
cblr-5119	639	37	it	it	PRON
cblr-5119	639	38	also	also	ADV
cblr-5119	639	39	does	do	AUX
cblr-5119	639	40	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	639	41	appear	appear	VERB
cblr-5119	639	42	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	639	43	state	state	NOUN
cblr-5119	639	44	courts	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	639	45	would	would	AUX
cblr-5119	639	46	provide	provide	VERB
cblr-5119	639	47	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
cblr-5119	639	48	relief	relief	NOUN
cblr-5119	639	49	as	as	ADP
cblr-5119	639	50	an	an	DET
cblr-5119	639	51	alternative	alternative	ADJ
cblr-5119	639	52	option	option	NOUN
cblr-5119	639	53	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	640	1	232	232	NUM
cblr-5119	641	1	nor	nor	CCONJ
cblr-5119	641	2	would	would	AUX
cblr-5119	641	3	it	it	PRON
cblr-5119	641	4	be	be	AUX
cblr-5119	641	5	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
cblr-5119	641	6	for	for	SCONJ
cblr-5119	641	7	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
cblr-5119	641	8	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	641	9	sue	sue	VERB
cblr-5119	641	10	officers	officer	NOUN
cblr-5119	641	11	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	641	12	directors	director	NOUN
cblr-5119	641	13	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	641	14	or	or	CCONJ
cblr-5119	641	15	employees	employee	NOUN
cblr-5119	641	16	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	641	17	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	641	18	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	641	19	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	641	20	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	641	21	their	their	PRON
cblr-5119	641	22	individual	individual	ADJ
cblr-5119	641	23	capacities	capacity	NOUN
cblr-5119	641	24	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	641	25	as	as	SCONJ
cblr-5119	641	26	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	641	27	offenses	offense	NOUN
cblr-5119	641	28	cognizable	cognizable	ADJ
cblr-5119	641	29	under	under	ADP
cblr-5119	641	30	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	641	31	ats	at	NOUN
cblr-5119	641	32	—	—	PUNCT
cblr-5119	641	33	e.g.	e.g.	ADV
cblr-5119	641	34	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	641	35	genocide	genocide	NOUN
cblr-5119	641	36	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	641	37	war	war	NOUN
cblr-5119	641	38	crimes	crime	NOUN
cblr-5119	641	39	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	641	40	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	641	41	crimes	crime	NOUN
cblr-5119	641	42	against	against	ADP
cblr-5119	641	43	humanity	humanity	NOUN
cblr-5119	641	44	—	—	PUNCT
cblr-5119	641	45	necessarily	necessarily	ADV
cblr-5119	641	46	contemplate	contemplate	VERB
cblr-5119	641	47	collective	collective	ADJ
cblr-5119	641	48	action.233	action.233	NOUN
cblr-5119	641	49	overall	overall	ADV
cblr-5119	641	50	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	641	51	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	641	52	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	641	53	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	641	54	history	history	NOUN
cblr-5119	641	55	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	641	56	jesner	jesner	PROPN
cblr-5119	641	57	reinforce	reinforce	VERB
cblr-5119	641	58	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	641	59	need	need	NOUN
cblr-5119	641	60	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	641	61	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	641	62	significant	significant	ADJ
cblr-5119	641	63	accountability	accountability	NOUN
cblr-5119	641	64	mechanism.234	mechanism.234	NOUN
cblr-5119	641	65	beyond	beyond	ADP
cblr-5119	641	66	that	that	PRON
cblr-5119	641	67	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	641	68	they	they	PRON
cblr-5119	641	69	reinforce	reinforce	VERB
cblr-5119	641	70	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	641	71	need	need	NOUN
cblr-5119	641	72	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	641	73	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	641	74	flexible	flexible	ADJ
cblr-5119	641	75	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	641	76	federal	federal	ADJ
cblr-5119	641	77	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	641	78	legal	legal	ADJ
cblr-5119	641	79	framework	framework	NOUN
cblr-5119	641	80	holding	hold	VERB
cblr-5119	641	81	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	641	82	as	as	ADP
cblr-5119	641	83	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	641	84	whole	whole	NOUN
cblr-5119	641	85	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	641	86	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	641	87	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	641	88	their	their	PRON
cblr-5119	641	89	individual	individual	ADJ
cblr-5119	641	90	agents	agent	NOUN
cblr-5119	641	91	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	641	92	liable	liable	ADJ
cblr-5119	641	93	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	642	1	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	642	2	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	642	3	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	642	4	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	642	5	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	642	6	fourth	fourth	ADJ
cblr-5119	642	7	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	642	8	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	642	9	regime	regime	NOUN
cblr-5119	642	10	specifically	specifically	ADV
cblr-5119	642	11	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	642	12	meets	meet	VERB
cblr-5119	642	13	this	this	DET
cblr-5119	642	14	standard	standard	NOUN
cblr-5119	642	15	without	without	ADP
cblr-5119	642	16	unduly	unduly	ADV
cblr-5119	642	17	harming	harm	VERB
cblr-5119	642	18	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	642	19	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	642	20	businesses	business	NOUN
cblr-5119	642	21	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	643	1	c.	c.	NOUN
cblr-5119	643	2	adopting	adopt	VERB
cblr-5119	643	3	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	643	4	fourth	fourth	ADJ
cblr-5119	643	5	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	643	6	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	643	7	regime	regime	NOUN
cblr-5119	643	8	will	will	AUX
cblr-5119	643	9	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	643	10	inflame	inflame	VERB
cblr-5119	643	11	foreign	foreign	ADJ
cblr-5119	643	12	tensions	tension	NOUN
cblr-5119	643	13	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	643	14	jesner	jesner	PROPN
cblr-5119	643	15	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	643	16	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	643	17	supreme	supreme	PROPN
cblr-5119	643	18	court	court	PROPN
cblr-5119	643	19	based	base	VERB
cblr-5119	643	20	its	its	PRON
cblr-5119	643	21	ruling	ruling	NOUN
cblr-5119	643	22	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	643	23	foreign	foreign	ADJ
cblr-5119	643	24	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	643	25	could	could	AUX
cblr-5119	643	26	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	643	27	be	be	AUX
cblr-5119	643	28	liable	liable	ADJ
cblr-5119	643	29	under	under	ADP
cblr-5119	643	30	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	643	31	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	643	32	on	on	ADP
cblr-5119	643	33	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	643	34	principle	principle	NOUN
cblr-5119	643	35	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	643	36	judicial	judicial	ADJ
cblr-5119	643	37	caution	caution	NOUN
cblr-5119	643	38	mandates	mandate	VERB
cblr-5119	643	39	abstention	abstention	NOUN
cblr-5119	643	40	from	from	ADP
cblr-5119	643	41	hearing	hear	VERB
cblr-5119	643	42	cases	case	NOUN
cblr-5119	643	43	that	that	PRON
cblr-5119	643	44	raise	raise	VERB
cblr-5119	643	45	foreign	foreign	ADJ
cblr-5119	643	46	policy	policy	NOUN
cblr-5119	643	47	problems.235	problems.235	NOUN
cblr-5119	643	48	however	however	ADV
cblr-5119	643	49	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	643	50	imposing	impose	VERB
cblr-5119	643	51	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	643	52	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	643	53	on	on	ADP
cblr-5119	643	54	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	643	55	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	643	56	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	643	57	will	will	AUX
cblr-5119	643	58	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	643	59	cause	cause	VERB
cblr-5119	643	60	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	643	61	foreign	foreign	ADJ
cblr-5119	643	62	relations	relation	NOUN
cblr-5119	643	63	issues	issue	NOUN
cblr-5119	643	64	that	that	PRON
cblr-5119	643	65	are	be	AUX
cblr-5119	643	66	associated	associate	VERB
cblr-5119	643	67	with	with	ADP
cblr-5119	643	68	imposing	impose	VERB
cblr-5119	643	69	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	643	70	on	on	ADP
cblr-5119	643	71	foreign	foreign	ADJ
cblr-5119	643	72	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	643	73	or	or	CCONJ
cblr-5119	643	74	persons	person	NOUN
cblr-5119	643	75	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	644	1	it	it	PRON
cblr-5119	644	2	is	be	AUX
cblr-5119	644	3	generally	generally	ADV
cblr-5119	644	4	understood	understand	VERB
cblr-5119	644	5	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	644	6	nations	nation	NOUN
cblr-5119	644	7	have	have	VERB
cblr-5119	644	8	prescriptive	prescriptive	ADJ
cblr-5119	644	9	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NOUN
cblr-5119	644	10	over	over	ADP
cblr-5119	644	11	their	their	PRON
cblr-5119	644	12	nationals	national	NOUN
cblr-5119	644	13	’	'	PUNCT
cblr-5119	644	14	activities	activity	NOUN
cblr-5119	644	15	whether	whether	SCONJ
cblr-5119	644	16	they	they	PRON
cblr-5119	644	17	occur	occur	VERB
cblr-5119	644	18	within	within	ADP
cblr-5119	644	19	national	national	ADJ
cblr-5119	644	20	230	230	NUM
cblr-5119	644	21	wouters	wouter	NOUN
cblr-5119	644	22	&	&	CCONJ
cblr-5119	644	23	chanet	chanet	NOUN
cblr-5119	644	24	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	644	25	supra	supra	PROPN
cblr-5119	644	26	note	note	NOUN
cblr-5119	644	27	194	194	NUM
cblr-5119	644	28	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	644	29	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	644	30	281	281	NUM
cblr-5119	644	31	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	644	32	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	644	33	[	[	X
cblr-5119	644	34	i]t	i]t	PROPN
cblr-5119	644	35	has	have	AUX
cblr-5119	644	36	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	644	37	been	be	AUX
cblr-5119	644	38	proven	prove	VERB
cblr-5119	644	39	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	644	40	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	644	41	responsibility	responsibility	NOUN
cblr-5119	644	42	will	will	AUX
cblr-5119	644	43	generally	generally	ADV
cblr-5119	644	44	make	make	VERB
cblr-5119	644	45	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	644	46	company	company	NOUN
cblr-5119	644	47	more	more	ADV
cblr-5119	644	48	profitable	profitable	ADJ
cblr-5119	644	49	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	645	1	thus	thus	ADV
cblr-5119	645	2	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	645	3	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	646	1	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	647	1	an	an	DET
cblr-5119	647	2	appropriate	appropriate	ADJ
cblr-5119	647	3	regulatory	regulatory	ADJ
cblr-5119	647	4	framework	framework	NOUN
cblr-5119	647	5	is	be	AUX
cblr-5119	647	6	needed	need	VERB
cblr-5119	647	7	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	647	8	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	647	9	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	647	10	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	648	1	231	231	NUM
cblr-5119	648	2	joe	joe	PROPN
cblr-5119	648	3	lodico	lodico	PROPN
cblr-5119	648	4	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	648	5	note	note	NOUN
cblr-5119	648	6	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	648	7	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	648	8	aiding	aiding	NOUN
cblr-5119	648	9	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	648	10	abetting	abet	VERB
cblr-5119	648	11	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	648	12	under	under	ADP
cblr-5119	648	13	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	648	14	alien	alien	ADJ
cblr-5119	648	15	tort	tort	NOUN
cblr-5119	648	16	statute	statute	NOUN
cblr-5119	648	17	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	648	18	30	30	NUM
cblr-5119	648	19	j.	j.	PROPN
cblr-5119	648	20	l.	l.	PROPN
cblr-5119	648	21	&	&	CCONJ
cblr-5119	648	22	com	com	PROPN
cblr-5119	648	23	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	648	24	117	117	NUM
cblr-5119	648	25	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	648	26	133	133	NUM
cblr-5119	648	27	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	648	28	2012	2012	NUM
cblr-5119	648	29	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	648	30	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	649	1	232	232	NUM
cblr-5119	649	2	doyle	doyle	NOUN
cblr-5119	649	3	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	649	4	supra	supra	PROPN
cblr-5119	649	5	note	note	NOUN
cblr-5119	649	6	75	75	NUM
cblr-5119	649	7	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	649	8	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	649	9	453–54	453–54	PROPN
cblr-5119	649	10	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	649	11	233	233	NUM
cblr-5119	649	12	kolieb	kolieb	ADJ
cblr-5119	649	13	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	649	14	supra	supra	PROPN
cblr-5119	649	15	note	note	NOUN
cblr-5119	649	16	104	104	NUM
cblr-5119	649	17	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	649	18	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	649	19	575	575	NUM
cblr-5119	649	20	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	649	21	234	234	NUM
cblr-5119	649	22	over	over	ADP
cblr-5119	649	23	250	250	NUM
cblr-5119	649	24	firms	firm	NOUN
cblr-5119	649	25	have	have	AUX
cblr-5119	649	26	been	be	AUX
cblr-5119	649	27	implicated	implicate	VERB
cblr-5119	649	28	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	649	29	egregious	egregious	ADJ
cblr-5119	649	30	conduct	conduct	NOUN
cblr-5119	649	31	as	as	ADP
cblr-5119	649	32	part	part	NOUN
cblr-5119	649	33	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	649	34	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	649	35	suits	suit	NOUN
cblr-5119	649	36	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	650	1	doyle	doyle	PROPN
cblr-5119	650	2	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	650	3	supra	supra	PROPN
cblr-5119	650	4	note	note	NOUN
cblr-5119	650	5	75	75	NUM
cblr-5119	650	6	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	650	7	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	650	8	450–51	450–51	X
cblr-5119	650	9	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	651	1	235	235	NUM
cblr-5119	651	2	jesner	jesner	PROPN
cblr-5119	651	3	v.	v.	PROPN
cblr-5119	651	4	arab	arab	PROPN
cblr-5119	651	5	bank	bank	PROPN
cblr-5119	651	6	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	651	7	plc	plc	PROPN
cblr-5119	651	8	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	651	9	138	138	NUM
cblr-5119	651	10	s.	s.	PROPN
cblr-5119	651	11	ct	ct	PROPN
cblr-5119	651	12	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	651	13	1386	1386	NUM
cblr-5119	651	14	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	651	15	1405–07	1405–07	NUM
cblr-5119	651	16	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	651	17	2018	2018	NUM
cblr-5119	651	18	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	651	19	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	652	1	6_2019.3_estes	6_2019.3_estes	NUM
cblr-5119	652	2	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	652	3	do	do	AUX
cblr-5119	652	4	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	652	5	delete	delete	VERB
cblr-5119	652	6	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	652	7	12/26/2019	12/26/2019	NUM
cblr-5119	652	8	12:00	12:00	NUM
cblr-5119	652	9	am	be	AUX
cblr-5119	652	10	no	no	NOUN
cblr-5119	652	11	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	653	1	3:1031	3:1031	NUM
cblr-5119	653	2	]	]	X
cblr-5119	653	3	may	may	AUX
cblr-5119	653	4	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	653	5	fourth	fourth	ADJ
cblr-5119	653	6	be	be	AUX
cblr-5119	653	7	with	with	ADP
cblr-5119	653	8	you	you	PRON
cblr-5119	653	9	1079	1079	NUM
cblr-5119	653	10	territory	territory	NOUN
cblr-5119	653	11	or	or	CCONJ
cblr-5119	653	12	outside	outside	ADP
cblr-5119	653	13	it.236	it.236	PROPN
cblr-5119	653	14	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	653	15	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	653	16	modern	modern	ADJ
cblr-5119	653	17	era	era	NOUN
cblr-5119	653	18	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	653	19	such	such	ADJ
cblr-5119	653	20	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NOUN
cblr-5119	653	21	includes	include	VERB
cblr-5119	653	22	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	653	23	nation	nation	NOUN
cblr-5119	653	24	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	653	25	corporations.237	corporations.237	PROPN
cblr-5119	653	26	this	this	PRON
cblr-5119	653	27	comports	comport	VERB
cblr-5119	653	28	with	with	ADP
cblr-5119	653	29	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	653	30	obligations	obligation	NOUN
cblr-5119	653	31	imposed	impose	VERB
cblr-5119	653	32	on	on	ADP
cblr-5119	653	33	nations	nation	NOUN
cblr-5119	653	34	that	that	PRON
cblr-5119	653	35	fail	fail	VERB
cblr-5119	653	36	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	653	37	redress	redress	VERB
cblr-5119	653	38	their	their	PRON
cblr-5119	653	39	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	653	40	’	'	PUNCT
cblr-5119	653	41	violations	violation	NOUN
cblr-5119	653	42	:	:	PUNCT
cblr-5119	653	43	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	653	44	broadest	broad	ADJ
cblr-5119	653	45	view	view	NOUN
cblr-5119	653	46	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	653	47	international	international	ADJ
cblr-5119	653	48	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	653	49	today	today	NOUN
cblr-5119	653	50	holds	hold	VERB
cblr-5119	653	51	that	that	PRON
cblr-5119	653	52	said	say	VERB
cblr-5119	653	53	obligations	obligation	NOUN
cblr-5119	653	54	encompass	encompass	VERB
cblr-5119	653	55	regulating	regulate	VERB
cblr-5119	653	56	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	653	57	’	'	PUNCT
cblr-5119	653	58	activities	activity	NOUN
cblr-5119	653	59	wherever	wherever	SCONJ
cblr-5119	653	60	they	they	PRON
cblr-5119	653	61	take	take	VERB
cblr-5119	653	62	place.238	place.238	PROPN
cblr-5119	653	63	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	653	64	european	european	PROPN
cblr-5119	653	65	commission	commission	PROPN
cblr-5119	653	66	has	have	AUX
cblr-5119	653	67	agreed	agree	VERB
cblr-5119	653	68	with	with	ADP
cblr-5119	653	69	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	653	70	above	above	ADJ
cblr-5119	653	71	jurisdictional	jurisdictional	ADJ
cblr-5119	653	72	stance	stance	NOUN
cblr-5119	653	73	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	653	74	supporting	support	VERB
cblr-5119	653	75	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	653	76	united	united	PROPN
cblr-5119	653	77	states	states	PROPN
cblr-5119	653	78	’	'	PUNCT
cblr-5119	653	79	ability	ability	NOUN
cblr-5119	653	80	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	653	81	establish	establish	VERB
cblr-5119	653	82	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	653	83	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NOUN
cblr-5119	653	84	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	653	85	all	all	DET
cblr-5119	653	86	torts	tort	NOUN
cblr-5119	653	87	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	653	88	violation	violation	NOUN
cblr-5119	653	89	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	653	90	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	653	91	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	653	92	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	653	93	nations	nation	NOUN
cblr-5119	653	94	when	when	SCONJ
cblr-5119	653	95	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	653	96	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	653	97	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	653	98	national	national	PROPN
cblr-5119	653	99	is	be	AUX
cblr-5119	653	100	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	653	101	defendant.239	defendant.239	NOUN
cblr-5119	653	102	this	this	PRON
cblr-5119	653	103	indicates	indicate	VERB
cblr-5119	653	104	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	653	105	other	other	ADJ
cblr-5119	653	106	nations	nation	NOUN
cblr-5119	653	107	will	will	AUX
cblr-5119	653	108	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	653	109	protest	protest	VERB
cblr-5119	653	110	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	653	111	united	united	PROPN
cblr-5119	653	112	states	states	PROPN
cblr-5119	653	113	’	’	PART
cblr-5119	653	114	decision	decision	NOUN
cblr-5119	653	115	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	653	116	establish	establish	VERB
cblr-5119	653	117	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NOUN
cblr-5119	653	118	over	over	ADP
cblr-5119	653	119	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	653	120	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	653	121	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	653	122	under	under	ADP
cblr-5119	653	123	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	653	124	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	653	125	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	653	126	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	653	127	same	same	ADJ
cblr-5119	653	128	way	way	NOUN
cblr-5119	653	129	that	that	PRON
cblr-5119	653	130	they	they	PRON
cblr-5119	653	131	could	could	AUX
cblr-5119	653	132	protest	protest	VERB
cblr-5119	653	133	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	653	134	united	united	PROPN
cblr-5119	653	135	states	states	PROPN
cblr-5119	653	136	establishing	establish	VERB
cblr-5119	653	137	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NOUN
cblr-5119	653	138	over	over	ADP
cblr-5119	653	139	their	their	PRON
cblr-5119	653	140	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	653	141	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	654	1	haling	hale	VERB
cblr-5119	654	2	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	654	3	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	654	4	businesses	business	NOUN
cblr-5119	654	5	into	into	ADP
cblr-5119	654	6	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	654	7	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	654	8	courts	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	654	9	should	should	AUX
cblr-5119	654	10	thus	thus	ADV
cblr-5119	654	11	represent	represent	VERB
cblr-5119	654	12	an	an	DET
cblr-5119	654	13	uncontroversial	uncontroversial	ADJ
cblr-5119	654	14	practice	practice	NOUN
cblr-5119	654	15	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	654	16	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	654	17	far	far	ADJ
cblr-5119	654	18	cry	cry	NOUN
cblr-5119	654	19	from	from	ADP
cblr-5119	654	20	haling	hale	VERB
cblr-5119	654	21	foreign	foreign	ADJ
cblr-5119	654	22	businesses	business	NOUN
cblr-5119	654	23	into	into	ADP
cblr-5119	654	24	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	654	25	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	654	26	courts	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	654	27	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	654	28	even	even	ADV
cblr-5119	654	29	when	when	SCONJ
cblr-5119	654	30	extraterritorial	extraterritorial	ADJ
cblr-5119	654	31	conduct	conduct	NOUN
cblr-5119	654	32	is	be	AUX
cblr-5119	654	33	involved	involve	VERB
cblr-5119	654	34	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	655	1	with	with	ADP
cblr-5119	655	2	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	655	3	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	655	4	extending	extend	VERB
cblr-5119	655	5	only	only	ADV
cblr-5119	655	6	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	655	7	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	655	8	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	655	9	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	655	10	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	655	11	other	other	ADJ
cblr-5119	655	12	countries	country	NOUN
cblr-5119	655	13	are	be	AUX
cblr-5119	655	14	unlikely	unlikely	ADJ
cblr-5119	655	15	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	655	16	retaliate	retaliate	VERB
cblr-5119	655	17	against	against	ADP
cblr-5119	655	18	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	655	19	litigation	litigation	NOUN
cblr-5119	655	20	by	by	ADP
cblr-5119	655	21	attempting	attempt	VERB
cblr-5119	655	22	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	655	23	bring	bring	VERB
cblr-5119	655	24	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	655	25	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	655	26	parties	party	NOUN
cblr-5119	655	27	into	into	ADP
cblr-5119	655	28	their	their	PRON
cblr-5119	655	29	courts	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	655	30	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	655	31	thereby	thereby	ADV
cblr-5119	655	32	allaying	allay	VERB
cblr-5119	655	33	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	655	34	specific	specific	ADJ
cblr-5119	655	35	concern	concern	NOUN
cblr-5119	655	36	that	that	PRON
cblr-5119	655	37	justice	justice	PROPN
cblr-5119	655	38	kennedy	kennedy	PROPN
cblr-5119	655	39	pointed	point	VERB
cblr-5119	655	40	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	655	41	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	655	42	jesner	jesner	NOUN
cblr-5119	655	43	as	as	ADP
cblr-5119	655	44	cautioning	caution	VERB
cblr-5119	655	45	against	against	ADP
cblr-5119	655	46	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	655	47	liability.240	liability.240	NOUN
cblr-5119	655	48	there	there	PRON
cblr-5119	655	49	is	be	VERB
cblr-5119	655	50	also	also	ADV
cblr-5119	655	51	no	no	DET
cblr-5119	655	52	reason	reason	NOUN
cblr-5119	655	53	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	655	54	believe	believe	VERB
cblr-5119	655	55	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	655	56	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	655	57	political	political	ADJ
cblr-5119	655	58	branches	branch	NOUN
cblr-5119	655	59	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	655	60	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	655	61	which	which	PRON
cblr-5119	655	62	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	655	63	judiciary	judiciary	NOUN
cblr-5119	655	64	is	be	AUX
cblr-5119	655	65	expected	expect	VERB
cblr-5119	655	66	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	655	67	defer	defer	VERB
cblr-5119	655	68	when	when	SCONJ
cblr-5119	655	69	cases	case	NOUN
cblr-5119	655	70	could	could	AUX
cblr-5119	655	71	raise	raise	VERB
cblr-5119	655	72	sensitive	sensitive	ADJ
cblr-5119	655	73	foreign	foreign	ADJ
cblr-5119	655	74	relations	relation	NOUN
cblr-5119	655	75	concerns	concern	NOUN
cblr-5119	655	76	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	655	77	would	would	AUX
cblr-5119	655	78	take	take	VERB
cblr-5119	655	79	issue	issue	NOUN
cblr-5119	655	80	with	with	ADP
cblr-5119	655	81	federal	federal	ADJ
cblr-5119	655	82	courts	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	655	83	continuing	continue	VERB
cblr-5119	655	84	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	655	85	exercise	exercise	VERB
cblr-5119	655	86	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	655	87	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NOUN
cblr-5119	655	88	over	over	ADP
cblr-5119	655	89	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	655	90	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	655	91	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	655	92	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	656	1	congress	congress	PROPN
cblr-5119	656	2	expressly	expressly	ADV
cblr-5119	656	3	contemplated	contemplate	VERB
cblr-5119	656	4	international	international	ADJ
cblr-5119	656	5	issues	issue	NOUN
cblr-5119	656	6	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	656	7	enacting	enact	VERB
cblr-5119	656	8	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	656	9	ats	at	NOUN
cblr-5119	656	10	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	656	11	as	as	ADP
cblr-5119	656	12	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	656	13	236	236	NUM
cblr-5119	656	14	restatement	restatement	NOUN
cblr-5119	656	15	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	656	16	third	third	ADJ
cblr-5119	656	17	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	656	18	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	656	19	foreign	foreign	ADJ
cblr-5119	656	20	relations	relation	NOUN
cblr-5119	656	21	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	656	22	§	§	PROPN
cblr-5119	656	23	402	402	NUM
cblr-5119	656	24	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	656	25	1987	1987	NUM
cblr-5119	656	26	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	656	27	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	657	1	this	this	PRON
cblr-5119	657	2	also	also	ADV
cblr-5119	657	3	comports	comport	VERB
cblr-5119	657	4	with	with	ADP
cblr-5119	657	5	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	657	6	original	original	ADJ
cblr-5119	657	7	understanding	understanding	NOUN
cblr-5119	657	8	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	657	9	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	657	10	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	657	11	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	658	1	under	under	ADP
cblr-5119	658	2	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	658	3	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	658	4	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	658	5	nations	nation	NOUN
cblr-5119	658	6	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	658	7	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	658	8	nation	nation	NOUN
cblr-5119	658	9	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-5119	658	10	state	state	NOUN
cblr-5119	658	11	was	be	AUX
cblr-5119	658	12	responsible	responsible	ADJ
cblr-5119	658	13	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	658	14	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	658	15	harms	harm	NOUN
cblr-5119	658	16	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	658	17	its	its	PRON
cblr-5119	658	18	citizens	citizen	NOUN
cblr-5119	658	19	no	no	ADV
cblr-5119	658	20	matter	matter	ADV
cblr-5119	658	21	where	where	SCONJ
cblr-5119	658	22	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	658	23	harm	harm	NOUN
cblr-5119	658	24	occurred	occur	VERB
cblr-5119	658	25	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	659	1	bellia	bellia	PROPN
cblr-5119	659	2	jr	jr	PROPN
cblr-5119	659	3	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	659	4	&	&	CCONJ
cblr-5119	659	5	clark	clark	PROPN
cblr-5119	659	6	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	659	7	supra	supra	PROPN
cblr-5119	659	8	note	note	PROPN
cblr-5119	659	9	13	13	NUM
cblr-5119	659	10	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	659	11	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	659	12	473	473	NUM
cblr-5119	659	13	.	.	NOUN
cblr-5119	659	14	237	237	NUM
cblr-5119	659	15	ramsey	ramsey	NOUN
cblr-5119	659	16	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	659	17	supra	supra	PROPN
cblr-5119	659	18	note	note	VERB
cblr-5119	659	19	200	200	NUM
cblr-5119	659	20	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	659	21	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	659	22	292–93	292–93	NUM
cblr-5119	659	23	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	660	1	238	238	NUM
cblr-5119	660	2	de	de	NOUN
cblr-5119	660	3	schutter	schutter	NOUN
cblr-5119	660	4	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	660	5	supra	supra	PROPN
cblr-5119	660	6	note	note	NOUN
cblr-5119	660	7	209	209	NUM
cblr-5119	660	8	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	660	9	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	660	10	233–35	233–35	NUM
cblr-5119	660	11	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	660	12	emphasis	emphasis	NOUN
cblr-5119	660	13	added	add	VERB
cblr-5119	660	14	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	660	15	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	661	1	239	239	NUM
cblr-5119	661	2	brief	brief	NOUN
cblr-5119	661	3	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	661	4	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	661	5	european	european	PROPN
cblr-5119	661	6	commission	commission	PROPN
cblr-5119	661	7	as	as	ADP
cblr-5119	661	8	amicus	amicus	NOUN
cblr-5119	661	9	curiae	curiae	NOUN
cblr-5119	661	10	supporting	support	VERB
cblr-5119	661	11	neither	neither	CCONJ
cblr-5119	661	12	party	party	NOUN
cblr-5119	661	13	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	661	14	sosa	sosa	PROPN
cblr-5119	661	15	v.	v.	PROPN
cblr-5119	661	16	alvarez	alvarez	PROPN
cblr-5119	661	17	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-5119	661	18	machain	machain	NOUN
cblr-5119	661	19	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	661	20	542	542	NUM
cblr-5119	661	21	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	661	22	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	661	23	692	692	NUM
cblr-5119	661	24	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	661	25	2004	2004	NUM
cblr-5119	661	26	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	661	27	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	661	28	no	no	INTJ
cblr-5119	661	29	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	662	1	03–339	03–339	PROPN
cblr-5119	662	2	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	662	3	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	662	4	2004	2004	NUM
cblr-5119	662	5	wl	wl	X
cblr-5119	662	6	177036	177036	NUM
cblr-5119	662	7	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	662	8	*	*	PROPN
cblr-5119	662	9	6	6	NUM
cblr-5119	662	10	.	.	NOUN
cblr-5119	662	11	240	240	NUM
cblr-5119	662	12	jesner	jesner	NOUN
cblr-5119	662	13	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	662	14	138	138	NUM
cblr-5119	662	15	s.	s.	PROPN
cblr-5119	662	16	ct	ct	PROPN
cblr-5119	662	17	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	663	1	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	663	2	1405–07	1405–07	NUM
cblr-5119	663	3	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	664	1	6_2019.3_estes	6_2019.3_estes	NUM
cblr-5119	664	2	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	664	3	do	do	AUX
cblr-5119	664	4	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	664	5	delte	delte	VERB
cblr-5119	664	6	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	664	7	12/26/2019	12/26/2019	NUM
cblr-5119	664	8	12:00	12:00	NUM
cblr-5119	664	9	am	am	NOUN
cblr-5119	665	1	1080	1080	NUM
cblr-5119	665	2	columbia	columbia	PROPN
cblr-5119	665	3	business	business	NOUN
cblr-5119	665	4	law	law	PROPN
cblr-5119	665	5	review	review	NOUN
cblr-5119	665	6	[	[	X
cblr-5119	665	7	vol	vol	NOUN
cblr-5119	665	8	.	.	NOUN
cblr-5119	665	9	2019	2019	NUM
cblr-5119	665	10	statute	statute	NOUN
cblr-5119	665	11	implicates	implicate	VERB
cblr-5119	665	12	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	665	13	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	665	14	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	665	15	nations	nation	NOUN
cblr-5119	665	16	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	665	17	requires	require	VERB
cblr-5119	665	18	alien	alien	PROPN
cblr-5119	665	19	plaintiffs.241	plaintiffs.241	PROPN
cblr-5119	665	20	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	665	21	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	665	22	political	political	ADJ
cblr-5119	665	23	branches	branch	NOUN
cblr-5119	665	24	have	have	AUX
cblr-5119	665	25	chosen	choose	VERB
cblr-5119	665	26	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	665	27	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	665	28	amend	amend	VERB
cblr-5119	665	29	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	665	30	ats	at	NOUN
cblr-5119	665	31	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	665	32	any	any	DET
cblr-5119	665	33	meaningful	meaningful	ADJ
cblr-5119	665	34	way	way	NOUN
cblr-5119	665	35	since	since	SCONJ
cblr-5119	665	36	1789	1789	NUM
cblr-5119	665	37	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	665	38	despite	despite	SCONJ
cblr-5119	665	39	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	665	40	many	many	ADJ
cblr-5119	665	41	ats	at	NOUN
cblr-5119	665	42	cases	case	NOUN
cblr-5119	665	43	that	that	PRON
cblr-5119	665	44	involved	involve	VERB
cblr-5119	665	45	foreign	foreign	ADJ
cblr-5119	665	46	defendants	defendant	NOUN
cblr-5119	665	47	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	665	48	foreign	foreign	ADJ
cblr-5119	665	49	conduct	conduct	NOUN
cblr-5119	665	50	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	665	51	signals	signal	VERB
cblr-5119	665	52	their	their	PRON
cblr-5119	665	53	tacit	tacit	ADJ
cblr-5119	665	54	approval	approval	NOUN
cblr-5119	665	55	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	665	56	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	665	57	previous	previous	ADJ
cblr-5119	665	58	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	665	59	regime	regime	NOUN
cblr-5119	665	60	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	665	61	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	665	62	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	665	63	very	very	ADV
cblr-5119	665	64	least	least	ADJ
cblr-5119	665	65	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	666	1	given	give	VERB
cblr-5119	666	2	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	666	3	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	666	4	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	666	5	branches	branch	NOUN
cblr-5119	666	6	have	have	VERB
cblr-5119	666	7	scant	scant	ADJ
cblr-5119	666	8	reason	reason	NOUN
cblr-5119	666	9	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	666	10	disapprove	disapprove	VERB
cblr-5119	666	11	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	666	12	courts	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	666	13	continuing	continue	VERB
cblr-5119	666	14	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	666	15	hold	hold	VERB
cblr-5119	666	16	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	666	17	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	666	18	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	666	19	liable	liable	VERB
cblr-5119	666	20	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	667	1	as	as	ADP
cblr-5119	667	2	evidence	evidence	NOUN
cblr-5119	667	3	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	667	4	this	this	PRON
cblr-5119	667	5	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	667	6	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	667	7	executive	executive	ADJ
cblr-5119	667	8	branch	branch	NOUN
cblr-5119	667	9	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	667	10	under	under	ADP
cblr-5119	667	11	two	two	NUM
cblr-5119	667	12	different	different	ADJ
cblr-5119	667	13	administrations	administration	NOUN
cblr-5119	667	14	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	667	15	differing	differ	VERB
cblr-5119	667	16	party	party	NOUN
cblr-5119	667	17	affiliation	affiliation	NOUN
cblr-5119	667	18	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	667	19	expressed	express	VERB
cblr-5119	667	20	its	its	PRON
cblr-5119	667	21	support	support	NOUN
cblr-5119	667	22	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	667	23	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	667	24	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	667	25	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	667	26	both	both	DET
cblr-5119	667	27	kiobel	kiobel	PROPN
cblr-5119	667	28	ii	ii	PROPN
cblr-5119	667	29	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	667	30	jesner.242	jesner.242	NOUN
cblr-5119	667	31	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	667	32	any	any	DET
cblr-5119	667	33	event	event	NOUN
cblr-5119	667	34	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	667	35	under	under	ADP
cblr-5119	667	36	sosa	sosa	PROPN
cblr-5119	667	37	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	667	38	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	667	39	extent	extent	NOUN
cblr-5119	667	40	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	667	41	courts	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	667	42	’	'	PUNCT
cblr-5119	667	43	deference	deference	NOUN
cblr-5119	667	44	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	667	45	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	667	46	political	political	ADJ
cblr-5119	667	47	branches	branch	NOUN
cblr-5119	667	48	over	over	ADP
cblr-5119	667	49	foreign	foreign	ADJ
cblr-5119	667	50	relations	relation	NOUN
cblr-5119	667	51	implications	implication	NOUN
cblr-5119	667	52	should	should	AUX
cblr-5119	667	53	be	be	AUX
cblr-5119	667	54	determined	determine	VERB
cblr-5119	667	55	on	on	ADP
cblr-5119	667	56	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	667	57	case	case	NOUN
cblr-5119	667	58	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-5119	667	59	by	by	ADP
cblr-5119	667	60	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-5119	667	61	case	case	NOUN
cblr-5119	667	62	basis.243	basis.243	NOUN
cblr-5119	667	63	thus	thus	ADV
cblr-5119	667	64	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	667	65	even	even	ADV
cblr-5119	667	66	under	under	ADP
cblr-5119	667	67	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	667	68	fourth	fourth	ADJ
cblr-5119	667	69	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	667	70	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	667	71	liberal	liberal	ADJ
cblr-5119	667	72	regime	regime	NOUN
cblr-5119	667	73	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	667	74	courts	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	667	75	can	can	AUX
cblr-5119	667	76	continue	continue	VERB
cblr-5119	667	77	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	667	78	expressly	expressly	ADV
cblr-5119	667	79	recognize	recognize	VERB
cblr-5119	667	80	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	667	81	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	667	82	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	667	83	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	667	84	while	while	SCONJ
cblr-5119	667	85	retaining	retain	VERB
cblr-5119	667	86	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	667	87	option	option	NOUN
cblr-5119	667	88	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	667	89	defer	defer	VERB
cblr-5119	667	90	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	667	91	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	667	92	political	political	ADJ
cblr-5119	667	93	branches	branch	NOUN
cblr-5119	667	94	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	667	95	dismiss	dismiss	VERB
cblr-5119	667	96	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	667	97	case	case	NOUN
cblr-5119	667	98	when	when	SCONJ
cblr-5119	667	99	doing	do	VERB
cblr-5119	667	100	so	so	ADV
cblr-5119	667	101	is	be	AUX
cblr-5119	667	102	warranted	warrant	VERB
cblr-5119	667	103	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	668	1	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	668	2	argument	argument	NOUN
cblr-5119	668	3	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	668	4	declining	decline	VERB
cblr-5119	668	5	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	668	6	exercise	exercise	VERB
cblr-5119	668	7	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	668	8	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NOUN
cblr-5119	668	9	because	because	SCONJ
cblr-5119	668	10	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	668	11	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	668	12	desire	desire	NOUN
cblr-5119	668	13	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	668	14	avoid	avoid	VERB
cblr-5119	668	15	foreign	foreign	ADJ
cblr-5119	668	16	entanglements	entanglement	NOUN
cblr-5119	668	17	falls	fall	VERB
cblr-5119	668	18	flat	flat	ADJ
cblr-5119	668	19	when	when	SCONJ
cblr-5119	668	20	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	668	21	category	category	NOUN
cblr-5119	668	22	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	668	23	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	668	24	defendants	defendant	NOUN
cblr-5119	668	25	is	be	AUX
cblr-5119	668	26	limited	limit	VERB
cblr-5119	668	27	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	668	28	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	668	29	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	668	30	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	668	31	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	669	1	if	if	SCONJ
cblr-5119	669	2	anything	anything	PRON
cblr-5119	669	3	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	669	4	failing	fail	VERB
cblr-5119	669	5	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	669	6	hold	hold	VERB
cblr-5119	669	7	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	669	8	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	669	9	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	669	10	liable	liable	ADJ
cblr-5119	669	11	going	go	VERB
cblr-5119	669	12	forward	forward	ADV
cblr-5119	669	13	could	could	AUX
cblr-5119	669	14	cause	cause	VERB
cblr-5119	669	15	tensions	tension	NOUN
cblr-5119	669	16	with	with	ADP
cblr-5119	669	17	foreign	foreign	ADJ
cblr-5119	669	18	countries	country	NOUN
cblr-5119	669	19	where	where	SCONJ
cblr-5119	669	20	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	669	21	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	669	22	businesses	business	NOUN
cblr-5119	669	23	operate	operate	VERB
cblr-5119	669	24	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	670	1	it	it	PRON
cblr-5119	670	2	is	be	AUX
cblr-5119	670	3	easy	easy	ADJ
cblr-5119	670	4	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	670	5	imagine	imagine	VERB
cblr-5119	670	6	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	670	7	country	country	NOUN
cblr-5119	670	8	becoming	become	VERB
cblr-5119	670	9	upset	upset	ADJ
cblr-5119	670	10	because	because	SCONJ
cblr-5119	670	11	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	670	12	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	670	13	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	670	14	corporation	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	670	15	inflicted	inflict	VERB
cblr-5119	670	16	serious	serious	ADJ
cblr-5119	670	17	human	human	ADJ
cblr-5119	670	18	rights	right	NOUN
cblr-5119	670	19	abuses	abuse	NOUN
cblr-5119	670	20	on	on	ADP
cblr-5119	670	21	its	its	PRON
cblr-5119	670	22	nationals	national	NOUN
cblr-5119	670	23	but	but	CCONJ
cblr-5119	670	24	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	670	25	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	670	26	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	670	27	federal	federal	PROPN
cblr-5119	670	28	court	court	PROPN
cblr-5119	670	29	then	then	ADV
cblr-5119	670	30	refused	refuse	VERB
cblr-5119	670	31	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	670	32	hear	hear	VERB
cblr-5119	670	33	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	670	34	subsequent	subsequent	ADJ
cblr-5119	670	35	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	670	36	suit	suit	NOUN
cblr-5119	670	37	against	against	ADP
cblr-5119	670	38	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	670	39	corporation.244	corporation.244	NOUN
cblr-5119	670	40	this	this	PRON
cblr-5119	670	41	would	would	AUX
cblr-5119	670	42	be	be	AUX
cblr-5119	670	43	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	670	44	perverse	perverse	ADJ
cblr-5119	670	45	result	result	NOUN
cblr-5119	670	46	under	under	ADP
cblr-5119	670	47	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	670	48	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	670	49	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	670	50	given	give	VERB
cblr-5119	670	51	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	670	52	its	its	PRON
cblr-5119	670	53	legislative	legislative	ADJ
cblr-5119	670	54	purpose	purpose	NOUN
cblr-5119	670	55	was	be	AUX
cblr-5119	670	56	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	670	57	help	help	VERB
cblr-5119	670	58	avoid	avoid	VERB
cblr-5119	670	59	strife	strife	NOUN
cblr-5119	670	60	between	between	ADP
cblr-5119	670	61	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	670	62	united	united	PROPN
cblr-5119	670	63	states	states	PROPN
cblr-5119	670	64	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	670	65	foreign	foreign	ADJ
cblr-5119	670	66	powers.245	powers.245	NOUN
cblr-5119	670	67	even	even	ADV
cblr-5119	670	68	if	if	SCONJ
cblr-5119	670	69	such	such	ADJ
cblr-5119	670	70	scenarios	scenario	NOUN
cblr-5119	670	71	do	do	AUX
cblr-5119	670	72	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	670	73	occur	occur	VERB
cblr-5119	670	74	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	670	75	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	670	76	larger	large	ADJ
cblr-5119	670	77	point	point	NOUN
cblr-5119	670	78	is	be	AUX
cblr-5119	670	79	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	670	80	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	670	81	241	241	NUM
cblr-5119	670	82	judiciary	judiciary	PROPN
cblr-5119	670	83	act	act	PROPN
cblr-5119	670	84	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	670	85	1789	1789	NUM
cblr-5119	670	86	§	§	PROPN
cblr-5119	670	87	9	9	NUM
cblr-5119	670	88	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	670	89	1	1	NUM
cblr-5119	670	90	stat	stat	NOUN
cblr-5119	670	91	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	671	1	73	73	NUM
cblr-5119	671	2	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	671	3	76–77	76–77	NUM
cblr-5119	671	4	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	671	5	codified	codify	VERB
cblr-5119	671	6	as	as	SCONJ
cblr-5119	671	7	amended	amend	VERB
cblr-5119	671	8	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	671	9	28	28	NUM
cblr-5119	671	10	u.s.c	u.s.c	ADJ
cblr-5119	671	11	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	672	1	§	§	PROPN
cblr-5119	672	2	1350	1350	NUM
cblr-5119	672	3	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	672	4	2012	2012	NUM
cblr-5119	672	5	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	672	6	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	672	7	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	673	1	242	242	NUM
cblr-5119	673	2	jesner	jesner	NOUN
cblr-5119	673	3	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	673	4	138	138	NUM
cblr-5119	673	5	s.	s.	PROPN
cblr-5119	673	6	ct	ct	PROPN
cblr-5119	673	7	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	674	1	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	674	2	1431	1431	NUM
cblr-5119	674	3	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	674	4	sotomayor	sotomayor	PROPN
cblr-5119	674	5	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	674	6	j.	j.	PROPN
cblr-5119	674	7	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	674	8	dissenting	dissent	VERB
cblr-5119	674	9	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	674	10	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	675	1	243	243	NUM
cblr-5119	675	2	clapham	clapham	NOUN
cblr-5119	675	3	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	675	4	supra	supra	PROPN
cblr-5119	675	5	note	note	NOUN
cblr-5119	675	6	52	52	NUM
cblr-5119	675	7	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	675	8	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	675	9	445	445	NUM
cblr-5119	675	10	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	676	1	244	244	NUM
cblr-5119	676	2	abdullahi	abdullahi	NUM
cblr-5119	676	3	v.	v.	ADP
cblr-5119	676	4	pfizer	pfizer	PROPN
cblr-5119	676	5	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	676	6	inc	inc	PROPN
cblr-5119	676	7	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	676	8	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	676	9	562	562	NUM
cblr-5119	676	10	f.3d	f.3d	NUM
cblr-5119	676	11	163	163	NUM
cblr-5119	676	12	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	676	13	187	187	NUM
cblr-5119	676	14	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	676	15	2d	2d	NUM
cblr-5119	676	16	cir	cir	NOUN
cblr-5119	676	17	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	676	18	2009	2009	NUM
cblr-5119	676	19	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	676	20	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	676	21	finding	find	VERB
cblr-5119	676	22	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	676	23	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	676	24	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	676	25	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	676	26	defendant	defendant	NOUN
cblr-5119	676	27	conducting	conduct	VERB
cblr-5119	676	28	human	human	ADJ
cblr-5119	676	29	experimentation	experimentation	NOUN
cblr-5119	676	30	abroad	abroad	ADV
cblr-5119	676	31	without	without	ADP
cblr-5119	676	32	obtaining	obtain	VERB
cblr-5119	676	33	consent	consent	NOUN
cblr-5119	676	34	had	have	VERB
cblr-5119	676	35	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	676	36	potential	potential	NOUN
cblr-5119	676	37	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	676	38	cause	cause	VERB
cblr-5119	676	39	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	676	40	substantial	substantial	ADJ
cblr-5119	676	41	antiamerican	antiamerican	ADJ
cblr-5119	676	42	animus	animus	NOUN
cblr-5119	676	43	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	676	44	hostility	hostility	NOUN
cblr-5119	676	45	”	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	676	46	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	676	47	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	677	1	245	245	NUM
cblr-5119	677	2	kiobel	kiobel	NOUN
cblr-5119	677	3	v.	v.	ADP
cblr-5119	677	4	royal	royal	PROPN
cblr-5119	677	5	dutch	dutch	PROPN
cblr-5119	677	6	petroleum	petroleum	PROPN
cblr-5119	677	7	co.	co.	PROPN
cblr-5119	677	8	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	677	9	569	569	NUM
cblr-5119	677	10	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	677	11	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	677	12	108	108	NUM
cblr-5119	677	13	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	677	14	115–17	115–17	NUM
cblr-5119	677	15	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	677	16	2013	2013	NUM
cblr-5119	677	17	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	677	18	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	678	1	6_2019.3_estes	6_2019.3_estes	NUM
cblr-5119	678	2	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	678	3	do	do	AUX
cblr-5119	678	4	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	678	5	delete	delete	VERB
cblr-5119	678	6	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	678	7	12/26/2019	12/26/2019	NUM
cblr-5119	678	8	12:00	12:00	NUM
cblr-5119	678	9	am	be	AUX
cblr-5119	678	10	no	no	NOUN
cblr-5119	678	11	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	679	1	3:1031	3:1031	NUM
cblr-5119	679	2	]	]	X
cblr-5119	679	3	may	may	AUX
cblr-5119	679	4	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	679	5	fourth	fourth	ADJ
cblr-5119	679	6	be	be	AUX
cblr-5119	679	7	with	with	ADP
cblr-5119	679	8	you	you	PRON
cblr-5119	679	9	1081	1081	NUM
cblr-5119	679	10	converse	converse	NOUN
cblr-5119	679	11	—	—	PUNCT
cblr-5119	679	12	foreign	foreign	ADJ
cblr-5119	679	13	countries	country	NOUN
cblr-5119	679	14	becoming	become	VERB
cblr-5119	679	15	upset	upset	ADJ
cblr-5119	679	16	because	because	SCONJ
cblr-5119	679	17	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	679	18	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	679	19	does	do	AUX
cblr-5119	679	20	exercise	exercise	VERB
cblr-5119	679	21	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	679	22	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NOUN
cblr-5119	679	23	—	—	PUNCT
cblr-5119	679	24	is	be	AUX
cblr-5119	679	25	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	679	26	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	679	27	serious	serious	ADJ
cblr-5119	679	28	concern	concern	NOUN
cblr-5119	679	29	when	when	SCONJ
cblr-5119	679	30	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	679	31	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	679	32	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	679	33	are	be	AUX
cblr-5119	679	34	defendants	defendant	NOUN
cblr-5119	679	35	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	680	1	as	as	ADV
cblr-5119	680	2	long	long	ADV
cblr-5119	680	3	as	as	SCONJ
cblr-5119	680	4	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	680	5	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	680	6	retains	retain	VERB
cblr-5119	680	7	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	680	8	force	force	NOUN
cblr-5119	680	9	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	680	10	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	680	11	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	680	12	then	then	ADV
cblr-5119	680	13	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	680	14	it	it	PRON
cblr-5119	680	15	would	would	AUX
cblr-5119	680	16	be	be	AUX
cblr-5119	680	17	inappropriate	inappropriate	ADJ
cblr-5119	680	18	for	for	SCONJ
cblr-5119	680	19	courts	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	680	20	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	680	21	foreclose	foreclose	VERB
cblr-5119	680	22	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	680	23	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NOUN
cblr-5119	680	24	over	over	ADP
cblr-5119	680	25	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	680	26	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	680	27	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	680	28	due	due	ADP
cblr-5119	680	29	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	680	30	foreign	foreign	ADJ
cblr-5119	680	31	policy	policy	NOUN
cblr-5119	680	32	concerns	concern	NOUN
cblr-5119	680	33	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	681	1	an	an	DET
cblr-5119	681	2	examination	examination	NOUN
cblr-5119	681	3	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	681	4	how	how	SCONJ
cblr-5119	681	5	certain	certain	ADJ
cblr-5119	681	6	parts	part	NOUN
cblr-5119	681	7	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	681	8	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	681	9	international	international	ADJ
cblr-5119	681	10	community	community	NOUN
cblr-5119	681	11	are	be	AUX
cblr-5119	681	12	viewing	view	VERB
cblr-5119	681	13	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	681	14	intersection	intersection	NOUN
cblr-5119	681	15	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	681	16	business	business	NOUN
cblr-5119	681	17	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	681	18	human	human	ADJ
cblr-5119	681	19	rights	right	NOUN
cblr-5119	681	20	further	far	ADV
cblr-5119	681	21	illustrates	illustrate	VERB
cblr-5119	681	22	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	681	23	foreign	foreign	ADJ
cblr-5119	681	24	countries	country	NOUN
cblr-5119	681	25	are	be	AUX
cblr-5119	681	26	unlikely	unlikely	ADJ
cblr-5119	681	27	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	681	28	protest	protest	VERB
cblr-5119	681	29	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	681	30	relaxed	relaxed	ADJ
cblr-5119	681	31	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	681	32	regime	regime	NOUN
cblr-5119	681	33	focused	focus	VERB
cblr-5119	681	34	only	only	ADV
cblr-5119	681	35	on	on	ADP
cblr-5119	681	36	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	681	37	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	681	38	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	681	39	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	682	1	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	682	2	united	united	PROPN
cblr-5119	682	3	nations	nations	PROPN
cblr-5119	682	4	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	682	5	advised	advise	VERB
cblr-5119	682	6	by	by	ADP
cblr-5119	682	7	professor	professor	PROPN
cblr-5119	682	8	john	john	PROPN
cblr-5119	682	9	ruggie	ruggie	PROPN
cblr-5119	682	10	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	682	11	has	have	AUX
cblr-5119	682	12	issued	issue	VERB
cblr-5119	682	13	guiding	guide	VERB
cblr-5119	682	14	principles	principle	NOUN
cblr-5119	682	15	on	on	ADP
cblr-5119	682	16	business	business	NOUN
cblr-5119	682	17	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	682	18	human	human	ADJ
cblr-5119	682	19	rights	right	NOUN
cblr-5119	682	20	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	682	21	which	which	PRON
cblr-5119	682	22	“	"	PUNCT
cblr-5119	682	23	have	have	AUX
cblr-5119	682	24	received	receive	VERB
cblr-5119	682	25	widespread	widespread	ADJ
cblr-5119	682	26	commendation	commendation	NOUN
cblr-5119	682	27	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	682	28	acceptance	acceptance	NOUN
cblr-5119	682	29	by	by	ADP
cblr-5119	682	30	stakeholders	stakeholder	NOUN
cblr-5119	682	31	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	682	32	including	include	VERB
cblr-5119	682	33	national	national	ADJ
cblr-5119	682	34	governments	government	NOUN
cblr-5119	682	35	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	682	36	civil	civil	ADJ
cblr-5119	682	37	society	society	NOUN
cblr-5119	682	38	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	682	39	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	682	40	businesses	business	NOUN
cblr-5119	682	41	themselves	themselves	PRON
cblr-5119	682	42	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	683	1	”246	”246	PUNCT
cblr-5119	683	2	additionally	additionally	ADV
cblr-5119	683	3	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	683	4	while	while	SCONJ
cblr-5119	683	5	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	683	6	eu	eu	PROPN
cblr-5119	683	7	has	have	AUX
cblr-5119	683	8	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	683	9	yet	yet	ADV
cblr-5119	683	10	passed	pass	VERB
cblr-5119	683	11	similar	similar	ADJ
cblr-5119	683	12	legislation	legislation	NOUN
cblr-5119	683	13	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	683	14	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	683	15	european	european	ADJ
cblr-5119	683	16	parliament	parliament	PROPN
cblr-5119	683	17	has	have	AUX
cblr-5119	683	18	long	long	ADV
cblr-5119	683	19	envisioned	envision	VERB
cblr-5119	683	20	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	683	21	regulatory	regulatory	ADJ
cblr-5119	683	22	mechanism	mechanism	NOUN
cblr-5119	683	23	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	683	24	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	683	25	social	social	ADJ
cblr-5119	683	26	responsibility	responsibility	NOUN
cblr-5119	683	27	that	that	PRON
cblr-5119	683	28	imposes	impose	VERB
cblr-5119	683	29	civil	civil	ADJ
cblr-5119	683	30	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	683	31	on	on	ADP
cblr-5119	683	32	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	683	33	domiciled	domicile	VERB
cblr-5119	683	34	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	683	35	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	683	36	eu;247	eu;247	NOUN
cblr-5119	683	37	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	683	38	other	other	ADJ
cblr-5119	683	39	words	word	NOUN
cblr-5119	683	40	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	683	41	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	683	42	system	system	NOUN
cblr-5119	683	43	analogous	analogous	ADJ
cblr-5119	683	44	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	683	45	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	683	46	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	683	47	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	683	48	being	be	AUX
cblr-5119	683	49	liable	liable	ADJ
cblr-5119	683	50	under	under	ADP
cblr-5119	683	51	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	683	52	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	683	53	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	684	1	but	but	CCONJ
cblr-5119	684	2	even	even	ADV
cblr-5119	684	3	without	without	ADP
cblr-5119	684	4	such	such	DET
cblr-5119	684	5	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	684	6	mechanism	mechanism	NOUN
cblr-5119	684	7	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	684	8	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	684	9	eu	eu	PROPN
cblr-5119	684	10	’s	’s	PROPN
cblr-5119	684	11	general	general	ADJ
cblr-5119	684	12	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NOUN
cblr-5119	684	13	rules	rule	VERB
cblr-5119	684	14	themselves	themselves	PRON
cblr-5119	684	15	seem	seem	VERB
cblr-5119	684	16	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	684	17	allow	allow	VERB
cblr-5119	684	18	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	684	19	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	684	20	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-5119	684	21	like	like	ADJ
cblr-5119	684	22	suits	suit	NOUN
cblr-5119	684	23	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	685	1	under	under	ADP
cblr-5119	685	2	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	685	3	brussels	brussels	PROPN
cblr-5119	685	4	i	i	PRON
cblr-5119	685	5	regulation	regulation	VERB
cblr-5119	685	6	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	685	7	eu	eu	PROPN
cblr-5119	685	8	member	member	NOUN
cblr-5119	685	9	state	state	NOUN
cblr-5119	685	10	courts	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	685	11	have	have	VERB
cblr-5119	685	12	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NOUN
cblr-5119	685	13	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	685	14	hear	hear	VERB
cblr-5119	685	15	civil	civil	ADJ
cblr-5119	685	16	claims	claim	NOUN
cblr-5119	685	17	against	against	ADP
cblr-5119	685	18	eu	eu	PROPN
cblr-5119	685	19	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-5119	685	20	based	base	VERB
cblr-5119	685	21	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	685	22	even	even	ADV
cblr-5119	685	23	when	when	SCONJ
cblr-5119	685	24	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	685	25	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
cblr-5119	685	26	is	be	AUX
cblr-5119	685	27	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	685	28	domiciled	domicile	VERB
cblr-5119	685	29	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	685	30	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	685	31	eu	eu	PROPN
cblr-5119	685	32	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	685	33	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	685	34	injuries	injury	NOUN
cblr-5119	685	35	occurred	occur	VERB
cblr-5119	685	36	outside	outside	ADP
cblr-5119	685	37	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	685	38	eu.248	eu.248	PROPN
cblr-5119	685	39	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	685	40	fact	fact	NOUN
cblr-5119	685	41	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	685	42	this	this	DET
cblr-5119	685	43	jurisdictional	jurisdictional	ADJ
cblr-5119	685	44	regime	regime	NOUN
cblr-5119	685	45	is	be	AUX
cblr-5119	685	46	more	more	ADV
cblr-5119	685	47	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
cblr-5119	685	48	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-5119	685	49	friendly	friendly	ADJ
cblr-5119	685	50	than	than	ADP
cblr-5119	685	51	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	685	52	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	685	53	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	685	54	multiple	multiple	ADJ
cblr-5119	685	55	246	246	NUM
cblr-5119	685	56	doyle	doyle	NOUN
cblr-5119	685	57	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	685	58	supra	supra	PROPN
cblr-5119	685	59	note	note	NOUN
cblr-5119	685	60	75	75	NUM
cblr-5119	685	61	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	685	62	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	685	63	449	449	NUM
cblr-5119	685	64	.	.	NOUN
cblr-5119	685	65	247	247	NUM
cblr-5119	685	66	wouters	wouter	NOUN
cblr-5119	685	67	&	&	CCONJ
cblr-5119	685	68	chanet	chanet	NOUN
cblr-5119	685	69	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	685	70	supra	supra	PROPN
cblr-5119	685	71	note	note	NOUN
cblr-5119	685	72	194	194	NUM
cblr-5119	685	73	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	685	74	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	685	75	302	302	NUM
cblr-5119	685	76	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	685	77	248	248	NUM
cblr-5119	685	78	see	see	VERB
cblr-5119	685	79	case	case	NOUN
cblr-5119	685	80	c-412/98	c-412/98	PROPN
cblr-5119	685	81	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	685	82	grp	grp	NOUN
cblr-5119	685	83	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	686	1	josi	josi	PROPN
cblr-5119	686	2	reinsurance	reinsurance	PROPN
cblr-5119	686	3	co.	co.	PROPN
cblr-5119	686	4	sa	sa	PROPN
cblr-5119	686	5	v.	v.	ADP
cblr-5119	686	6	universal	universal	PROPN
cblr-5119	686	7	gen	gen	PROPN
cblr-5119	686	8	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	686	9	ins	ins	PROPN
cblr-5119	686	10	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	686	11	co.	co.	PROPN
cblr-5119	686	12	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	686	13	ugic	ugic	NOUN
cblr-5119	686	14	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	686	15	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	686	16	2000	2000	NUM
cblr-5119	686	17	e.c.r	e.c.r	X
cblr-5119	686	18	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	687	1	i-5925	i-5925	PROPN
cblr-5119	687	2	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	687	3	ruling	rule	VERB
cblr-5119	687	4	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	687	5	brussels	brussels	PROPN
cblr-5119	688	1	i	i	PRON
cblr-5119	688	2	regulation	regulation	VERB
cblr-5119	688	3	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	688	4	mandatory	mandatory	ADJ
cblr-5119	688	5	jurisdictional	jurisdictional	ADJ
cblr-5119	688	6	rules	rule	NOUN
cblr-5119	688	7	applied	apply	VERB
cblr-5119	688	8	when	when	SCONJ
cblr-5119	688	9	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	688	10	defendant	defendant	NOUN
cblr-5119	688	11	has	have	VERB
cblr-5119	688	12	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	688	13	domicile	domicile	NOUN
cblr-5119	688	14	or	or	CCONJ
cblr-5119	688	15	seat	seat	NOUN
cblr-5119	688	16	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	688	17	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	688	18	member	member	NOUN
cblr-5119	688	19	state	state	NOUN
cblr-5119	688	20	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	688	21	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	688	22	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
cblr-5119	688	23	is	be	AUX
cblr-5119	688	24	domiciled	domicile	VERB
cblr-5119	688	25	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	688	26	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	688	27	non	non	ADJ
cblr-5119	688	28	-	-	ADJ
cblr-5119	688	29	member	member	ADJ
cblr-5119	688	30	state	state	NOUN
cblr-5119	688	31	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	688	32	;	;	PUNCT
cblr-5119	688	33	see	see	AUX
cblr-5119	688	34	also	also	ADV
cblr-5119	688	35	case	case	VERB
cblr-5119	688	36	c-281/02	c-281/02	PROPN
cblr-5119	688	37	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	688	38	andrew	andrew	PROPN
cblr-5119	688	39	owusu	owusu	PROPN
cblr-5119	688	40	v.	v.	PROPN
cblr-5119	688	41	n.b	n.b	PROPN
cblr-5119	688	42	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	688	43	jackson	jackson	PROPN
cblr-5119	688	44	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	688	45	2005	2005	NUM
cblr-5119	688	46	e.c.r	e.c.r	X
cblr-5119	688	47	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	689	1	i-1383	i-1383	PROPN
cblr-5119	689	2	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	689	3	ruling	rule	VERB
cblr-5119	689	4	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	689	5	forum	forum	PROPN
cblr-5119	689	6	non	non	PROPN
cblr-5119	689	7	conveniens	convenien	NOUN
cblr-5119	689	8	will	will	AUX
cblr-5119	689	9	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	689	10	bar	bar	VERB
cblr-5119	689	11	adjudication	adjudication	NOUN
cblr-5119	689	12	under	under	ADP
cblr-5119	689	13	brussels	brussels	PROPN
cblr-5119	689	14	i	i	PRON
cblr-5119	689	15	regulation	regulation	NOUN
cblr-5119	689	16	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	689	17	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	690	1	while	while	SCONJ
cblr-5119	690	2	these	these	DET
cblr-5119	690	3	cases	case	NOUN
cblr-5119	690	4	did	do	AUX
cblr-5119	690	5	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	690	6	address	address	VERB
cblr-5119	690	7	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	690	8	defendants	defendant	NOUN
cblr-5119	690	9	specifically	specifically	ADV
cblr-5119	690	10	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	690	11	their	their	PRON
cblr-5119	690	12	rulings	ruling	NOUN
cblr-5119	690	13	still	still	ADV
cblr-5119	690	14	apply	apply	VERB
cblr-5119	690	15	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	690	16	such	such	ADJ
cblr-5119	690	17	defendants	defendant	NOUN
cblr-5119	690	18	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	691	1	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	691	2	further	further	ADJ
cblr-5119	691	3	analysis	analysis	NOUN
cblr-5119	691	4	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	691	5	see	see	VERB
cblr-5119	691	6	wouters	wouter	NOUN
cblr-5119	691	7	&	&	CCONJ
cblr-5119	691	8	chanet	chanet	NOUN
cblr-5119	691	9	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	691	10	supra	supra	PROPN
cblr-5119	691	11	note	note	NOUN
cblr-5119	691	12	194	194	NUM
cblr-5119	691	13	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	691	14	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	691	15	294–303	294–303	NUM
cblr-5119	691	16	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	692	1	6_2019.3_estes	6_2019.3_estes	NUM
cblr-5119	692	2	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	692	3	do	do	AUX
cblr-5119	692	4	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	692	5	delte	delte	VERB
cblr-5119	692	6	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	692	7	12/26/2019	12/26/2019	NUM
cblr-5119	692	8	12:00	12:00	NUM
cblr-5119	692	9	am	am	PROPN
cblr-5119	693	1	1082	1082	NUM
cblr-5119	693	2	columbia	columbia	PROPN
cblr-5119	693	3	business	business	NOUN
cblr-5119	693	4	law	law	PROPN
cblr-5119	693	5	review	review	NOUN
cblr-5119	693	6	[	[	X
cblr-5119	693	7	vol	vol	NOUN
cblr-5119	693	8	.	.	NOUN
cblr-5119	693	9	2019	2019	NUM
cblr-5119	693	10	ways.249	ways.249	NOUN
cblr-5119	693	11	finally	finally	ADV
cblr-5119	693	12	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	693	13	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	693	14	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	693	15	different	different	ADJ
cblr-5119	693	16	context	context	NOUN
cblr-5119	693	17	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	693	18	some	some	DET
cblr-5119	693	19	governments	government	NOUN
cblr-5119	693	20	are	be	AUX
cblr-5119	693	21	now	now	ADV
cblr-5119	693	22	linking	link	VERB
cblr-5119	693	23	companies	company	NOUN
cblr-5119	693	24	’	'	PUNCT
cblr-5119	693	25	export	export	NOUN
cblr-5119	693	26	credit	credit	NOUN
cblr-5119	693	27	guarantees	guarantee	NOUN
cblr-5119	693	28	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	693	29	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	693	30	potential	potential	ADJ
cblr-5119	693	31	human	human	ADJ
cblr-5119	693	32	rights	right	NOUN
cblr-5119	693	33	impacts	impact	NOUN
cblr-5119	693	34	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	693	35	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	693	36	company	company	NOUN
cblr-5119	693	37	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	693	38	specific	specific	ADJ
cblr-5119	693	39	project.250	project.250	NOUN
cblr-5119	693	40	while	while	SCONJ
cblr-5119	693	41	it	it	PRON
cblr-5119	693	42	can	can	AUX
cblr-5119	693	43	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	693	44	be	be	AUX
cblr-5119	693	45	said	say	VERB
cblr-5119	693	46	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	693	47	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	693	48	rest	rest	NOUN
cblr-5119	693	49	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	693	50	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	693	51	world	world	NOUN
cblr-5119	693	52	is	be	AUX
cblr-5119	693	53	rushing	rush	VERB
cblr-5119	693	54	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	693	55	enact	enact	VERB
cblr-5119	693	56	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	693	57	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	693	58	regimes	regime	NOUN
cblr-5119	693	59	similar	similar	ADJ
cblr-5119	693	60	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	693	61	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	693	62	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	693	63	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	693	64	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	693	65	growing	grow	VERB
cblr-5119	693	66	international	international	ADJ
cblr-5119	693	67	trend	trend	NOUN
cblr-5119	693	68	toward	toward	ADP
cblr-5119	693	69	nations	nation	NOUN
cblr-5119	693	70	holding	hold	VERB
cblr-5119	693	71	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	693	72	accountable	accountable	ADJ
cblr-5119	693	73	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	693	74	human	human	ADJ
cblr-5119	693	75	rights	right	NOUN
cblr-5119	693	76	abuses	abuse	NOUN
cblr-5119	693	77	nevertheless	nevertheless	ADV
cblr-5119	693	78	indicates	indicate	VERB
cblr-5119	693	79	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	693	80	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	693	81	global	global	ADJ
cblr-5119	693	82	community	community	NOUN
cblr-5119	693	83	would	would	AUX
cblr-5119	693	84	take	take	VERB
cblr-5119	693	85	no	no	DET
cblr-5119	693	86	issue	issue	NOUN
cblr-5119	693	87	with	with	ADP
cblr-5119	693	88	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	693	89	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	693	90	courts	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	693	91	imposing	impose	VERB
cblr-5119	693	92	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	693	93	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	693	94	on	on	ADP
cblr-5119	693	95	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	693	96	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	693	97	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	693	98	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	694	1	adopting	adopt	VERB
cblr-5119	694	2	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	694	3	fourth	fourth	ADJ
cblr-5119	694	4	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	694	5	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	694	6	flexible	flexible	ADJ
cblr-5119	694	7	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	694	8	factbased	factbased	ADJ
cblr-5119	694	9	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	694	10	framework	framework	NOUN
cblr-5119	694	11	would	would	AUX
cblr-5119	694	12	re	re	VERB
cblr-5119	694	13	-	-	VERB
cblr-5119	694	14	align	align	VERB
cblr-5119	694	15	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	694	16	united	united	PROPN
cblr-5119	694	17	states	states	PROPN
cblr-5119	694	18	with	with	ADP
cblr-5119	694	19	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	694	20	global	global	ADJ
cblr-5119	694	21	trend	trend	NOUN
cblr-5119	694	22	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	694	23	with	with	ADP
cblr-5119	694	24	nary	nary	DET
cblr-5119	694	25	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	694	26	hint	hint	NOUN
cblr-5119	694	27	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	694	28	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	694	29	foreign	foreign	ADJ
cblr-5119	694	30	policy	policy	NOUN
cblr-5119	694	31	concerns	concern	NOUN
cblr-5119	694	32	central	central	ADJ
cblr-5119	694	33	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	694	34	jesner	jesner	VERB
cblr-5119	694	35	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	695	1	v.	v.	ADP
cblr-5119	695	2	conclusion	conclusion	NOUN
cblr-5119	695	3	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	695	4	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	695	5	has	have	AUX
cblr-5119	695	6	had	have	VERB
cblr-5119	695	7	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	695	8	rollercoaster	rollercoaster	NOUN
cblr-5119	695	9	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	695	10	an	an	DET
cblr-5119	695	11	existence	existence	NOUN
cblr-5119	695	12	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	696	1	from	from	ADP
cblr-5119	696	2	serving	serve	VERB
cblr-5119	696	3	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	696	4	critical	critical	ADJ
cblr-5119	696	5	function	function	NOUN
cblr-5119	696	6	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	696	7	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	696	8	young	young	ADJ
cblr-5119	696	9	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	696	10	vulnerable	vulnerable	ADJ
cblr-5119	696	11	nation	nation	NOUN
cblr-5119	696	12	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	696	13	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	696	14	disappearing	disappear	VERB
cblr-5119	696	15	into	into	ADP
cblr-5119	696	16	irrelevance	irrelevance	NOUN
cblr-5119	696	17	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	696	18	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	696	19	being	be	AUX
cblr-5119	696	20	revived	revive	VERB
cblr-5119	696	21	with	with	ADP
cblr-5119	696	22	an	an	DET
cblr-5119	696	23	entirely	entirely	ADV
cblr-5119	696	24	modern	modern	ADJ
cblr-5119	696	25	sheen	sheen	NOUN
cblr-5119	696	26	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	696	27	to	to	AUX
cblr-5119	696	28	now	now	ADV
cblr-5119	696	29	being	be	AUX
cblr-5119	696	30	slowly	slowly	ADV
cblr-5119	696	31	pushed	push	VERB
cblr-5119	696	32	aside	aside	ADV
cblr-5119	696	33	again	again	ADV
cblr-5119	696	34	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	696	35	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	696	36	statute	statute	NOUN
cblr-5119	696	37	has	have	AUX
cblr-5119	696	38	been	be	AUX
cblr-5119	696	39	defined	define	VERB
cblr-5119	696	40	by	by	ADP
cblr-5119	696	41	instability	instability	NOUN
cblr-5119	696	42	more	more	ADJ
cblr-5119	696	43	than	than	ADP
cblr-5119	696	44	anything	anything	PRON
cblr-5119	696	45	else	else	ADV
cblr-5119	696	46	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	697	1	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	697	2	supreme	supreme	PROPN
cblr-5119	697	3	court	court	PROPN
cblr-5119	697	4	did	do	VERB
cblr-5119	697	5	little	little	ADJ
cblr-5119	697	6	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	697	7	curb	curb	VERB
cblr-5119	697	8	this	this	PRON
cblr-5119	697	9	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	697	10	jesner	jesner	NOUN
cblr-5119	697	11	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	698	1	while	while	SCONJ
cblr-5119	698	2	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	698	3	court	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	698	4	provided	provide	VERB
cblr-5119	698	5	certainty	certainty	NOUN
cblr-5119	698	6	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	698	7	terms	term	NOUN
cblr-5119	698	8	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	698	9	removing	remove	VERB
cblr-5119	698	10	foreign	foreign	ADJ
cblr-5119	698	11	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	698	12	from	from	ADP
cblr-5119	698	13	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	698	14	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	698	15	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	698	16	ambit	ambit	NOUN
cblr-5119	698	17	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	698	18	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	698	19	ruling	ruling	NOUN
cblr-5119	698	20	only	only	ADV
cblr-5119	698	21	raised	raise	VERB
cblr-5119	698	22	more	more	ADJ
cblr-5119	698	23	uncertainty	uncertainty	NOUN
cblr-5119	698	24	about	about	ADP
cblr-5119	698	25	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	698	26	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	698	27	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	698	28	viability	viability	NOUN
cblr-5119	698	29	going	go	VERB
cblr-5119	698	30	forward	forward	ADV
cblr-5119	698	31	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	699	1	while	while	SCONJ
cblr-5119	699	2	some	some	PRON
cblr-5119	699	3	would	would	AUX
cblr-5119	699	4	welcome	welcome	VERB
cblr-5119	699	5	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	699	6	ats	at	NOUN
cblr-5119	699	7	receding	recede	VERB
cblr-5119	699	8	into	into	ADP
cblr-5119	699	9	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	699	10	background	background	NOUN
cblr-5119	699	11	again	again	ADV
cblr-5119	699	12	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	699	13	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	699	14	reality	reality	NOUN
cblr-5119	699	15	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	699	16	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	699	17	law	law	NOUN
cblr-5119	699	18	has	have	AUX
cblr-5119	699	19	served	serve	VERB
cblr-5119	699	20	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	699	21	momentous	momentous	ADJ
cblr-5119	699	22	function	function	NOUN
cblr-5119	699	23	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	699	24	scores	score	NOUN
cblr-5119	699	25	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	699	26	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
cblr-5119	699	27	can	can	AUX
cblr-5119	699	28	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	699	29	be	be	AUX
cblr-5119	699	30	brushed	brush	VERB
cblr-5119	699	31	aside	aside	ADV
cblr-5119	699	32	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	700	1	victims	victim	NOUN
cblr-5119	700	2	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	700	3	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	700	4	most	most	ADV
cblr-5119	700	5	unimaginable	unimaginable	ADJ
cblr-5119	700	6	horrors	horror	NOUN
cblr-5119	700	7	that	that	SCONJ
cblr-5119	700	8	human	human	ADJ
cblr-5119	700	9	society	society	NOUN
cblr-5119	700	10	is	be	AUX
cblr-5119	700	11	capable	capable	ADJ
cblr-5119	700	12	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	700	13	inflicting	inflict	VERB
cblr-5119	700	14	have	have	AUX
cblr-5119	700	15	been	be	AUX
cblr-5119	700	16	able	able	ADJ
cblr-5119	700	17	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	700	18	achieve	achieve	VERB
cblr-5119	700	19	some	some	DET
cblr-5119	700	20	sense	sense	NOUN
cblr-5119	700	21	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	700	22	justice	justice	NOUN
cblr-5119	700	23	through	through	ADP
cblr-5119	700	24	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	700	25	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	700	26	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	701	1	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	701	2	importance	importance	NOUN
cblr-5119	701	3	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	701	4	that	that	PRON
cblr-5119	701	5	can	can	AUX
cblr-5119	701	6	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	701	7	be	be	AUX
cblr-5119	701	8	overstated	overstate	VERB
cblr-5119	701	9	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	701	10	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	701	11	unless	unless	SCONJ
cblr-5119	701	12	or	or	CCONJ
cblr-5119	701	13	until	until	SCONJ
cblr-5119	701	14	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	701	15	statute	statute	NOUN
cblr-5119	701	16	is	be	AUX
cblr-5119	701	17	amended	amend	VERB
cblr-5119	701	18	or	or	CCONJ
cblr-5119	701	19	repealed	repeal	VERB
cblr-5119	701	20	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	701	21	courts	court	NOUN
cblr-5119	701	22	should	should	AUX
cblr-5119	701	23	feel	feel	VERB
cblr-5119	701	24	duty	duty	NOUN
cblr-5119	701	25	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-5119	701	26	bound	bind	VERB
cblr-5119	701	27	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	701	28	maintain	maintain	VERB
cblr-5119	701	29	its	its	PRON
cblr-5119	701	30	vitality	vitality	NOUN
cblr-5119	701	31	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	701	32	especially	especially	ADV
cblr-5119	701	33	when	when	SCONJ
cblr-5119	701	34	it	it	PRON
cblr-5119	701	35	comes	come	VERB
cblr-5119	701	36	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	701	37	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	701	38	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	701	39	which	which	PRON
cblr-5119	701	40	are	be	AUX
cblr-5119	701	41	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	701	42	most	most	ADV
cblr-5119	701	43	significant	significant	ADJ
cblr-5119	701	44	type	type	NOUN
cblr-5119	701	45	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	701	46	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	701	47	defendant	defendant	NOUN
cblr-5119	701	48	today	today	NOUN
cblr-5119	701	49	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	702	1	249	249	NUM
cblr-5119	702	2	wouters	wouter	NOUN
cblr-5119	702	3	&	&	CCONJ
cblr-5119	702	4	chanet	chanet	NOUN
cblr-5119	702	5	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	702	6	supra	supra	PROPN
cblr-5119	702	7	note	note	NOUN
cblr-5119	702	8	194	194	NUM
cblr-5119	702	9	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	702	10	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	702	11	301–02	301–02	NUM
cblr-5119	702	12	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	703	1	250	250	NUM
cblr-5119	703	2	clapham	clapham	NOUN
cblr-5119	703	3	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	703	4	supra	supra	PROPN
cblr-5119	703	5	note	note	NOUN
cblr-5119	703	6	52	52	NUM
cblr-5119	703	7	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	703	8	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	703	9	197	197	NUM
cblr-5119	703	10	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	703	11	6_2019.3_estes	6_2019.3_estes	NUM
cblr-5119	703	12	(	(	PUNCT
cblr-5119	703	13	do	do	AUX
cblr-5119	703	14	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	703	15	delete	delete	VERB
cblr-5119	703	16	)	)	PUNCT
cblr-5119	703	17	12/26/2019	12/26/2019	NUM
cblr-5119	703	18	12:00	12:00	NUM
cblr-5119	703	19	am	be	AUX
cblr-5119	703	20	no	no	NOUN
cblr-5119	703	21	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	704	1	3:1031	3:1031	NUM
cblr-5119	704	2	]	]	X
cblr-5119	704	3	may	may	AUX
cblr-5119	704	4	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	704	5	fourth	fourth	ADJ
cblr-5119	704	6	be	be	AUX
cblr-5119	704	7	with	with	ADP
cblr-5119	704	8	you	you	PRON
cblr-5119	704	9	1083	1083	NUM
cblr-5119	704	10	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	704	11	that	that	DET
cblr-5119	704	12	end	end	NOUN
cblr-5119	704	13	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	704	14	adopting	adopt	VERB
cblr-5119	704	15	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	704	16	fourth	fourth	ADJ
cblr-5119	704	17	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	704	18	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	704	19	flexible	flexible	ADJ
cblr-5119	704	20	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	704	21	allencompassing	allencompasse	VERB
cblr-5119	704	22	test	test	NOUN
cblr-5119	704	23	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	704	24	overcoming	overcome	VERB
cblr-5119	704	25	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	704	26	presumption	presumption	NOUN
cblr-5119	704	27	against	against	ADP
cblr-5119	704	28	extraterritoriality	extraterritoriality	NOUN
cblr-5119	704	29	as	as	SCONJ
cblr-5119	704	30	it	it	PRON
cblr-5119	704	31	regards	regard	VERB
cblr-5119	704	32	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	704	33	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	704	34	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	704	35	defendants	defendant	NOUN
cblr-5119	704	36	is	be	AUX
cblr-5119	704	37	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	704	38	best	good	ADJ
cblr-5119	704	39	way	way	NOUN
cblr-5119	704	40	forward	forward	ADV
cblr-5119	704	41	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	704	42	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	704	43	supreme	supreme	PROPN
cblr-5119	704	44	court	court	PROPN
cblr-5119	704	45	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	704	46	its	its	PRON
cblr-5119	704	47	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	704	48	jurisprudence	jurisprudence	NOUN
cblr-5119	704	49	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	705	1	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	705	2	near	near	ADJ
cblr-5119	705	3	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-5119	705	4	unanimity	unanimity	NOUN
cblr-5119	705	5	among	among	ADP
cblr-5119	705	6	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	705	7	circuits	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	705	8	as	as	ADP
cblr-5119	705	9	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	705	10	whether	whether	SCONJ
cblr-5119	705	11	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	705	12	can	can	AUX
cblr-5119	705	13	be	be	AUX
cblr-5119	705	14	liable	liable	ADJ
cblr-5119	705	15	under	under	ADP
cblr-5119	705	16	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	705	17	statute	statute	NOUN
cblr-5119	705	18	should	should	AUX
cblr-5119	705	19	essentially	essentially	ADV
cblr-5119	705	20	settle	settle	VERB
cblr-5119	705	21	that	that	DET
cblr-5119	705	22	issue	issue	NOUN
cblr-5119	705	23	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	705	24	but	but	CCONJ
cblr-5119	705	25	even	even	ADV
cblr-5119	705	26	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	705	27	second	second	ADJ
cblr-5119	705	28	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	705	29	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	705	30	analytical	analytical	ADJ
cblr-5119	705	31	lens	lens	NOUN
cblr-5119	705	32	now	now	ADV
cblr-5119	705	33	supports	support	VERB
cblr-5119	705	34	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	705	35	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	705	36	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	705	37	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	706	1	additionally	additionally	ADV
cblr-5119	706	2	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	706	3	applying	apply	VERB
cblr-5119	706	4	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	706	5	most	most	ADV
cblr-5119	706	6	liberal	liberal	ADJ
cblr-5119	706	7	possible	possible	ADJ
cblr-5119	706	8	regime	regime	NOUN
cblr-5119	706	9	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	706	10	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	706	11	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	706	12	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	706	13	liability	liability	NOUN
cblr-5119	706	14	best	well	ADV
cblr-5119	706	15	comports	comport	VERB
cblr-5119	706	16	with	with	ADP
cblr-5119	706	17	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	706	18	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	706	19	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	706	20	original	original	ADJ
cblr-5119	706	21	understanding	understanding	NOUN
cblr-5119	706	22	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	706	23	which	which	PRON
cblr-5119	706	24	envisioned	envision	VERB
cblr-5119	706	25	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	706	26	far	far	ADV
cblr-5119	706	27	wider	wide	ADJ
cblr-5119	706	28	range	range	NOUN
cblr-5119	706	29	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	706	30	actionable	actionable	ADJ
cblr-5119	706	31	conduct	conduct	NOUN
cblr-5119	706	32	than	than	SCONJ
cblr-5119	706	33	is	be	AUX
cblr-5119	706	34	currently	currently	ADV
cblr-5119	706	35	recognized	recognize	VERB
cblr-5119	706	36	under	under	ADP
cblr-5119	706	37	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	706	38	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	706	39	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	707	1	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	707	2	fourth	fourth	ADJ
cblr-5119	707	3	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	707	4	approach	approach	NOUN
cblr-5119	707	5	does	do	VERB
cblr-5119	707	6	no	no	DET
cblr-5119	707	7	damage	damage	NOUN
cblr-5119	707	8	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	707	9	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	707	10	presumption	presumption	NOUN
cblr-5119	707	11	against	against	ADP
cblr-5119	707	12	extraterritoriality	extraterritoriality	NOUN
cblr-5119	707	13	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	707	14	which	which	PRON
cblr-5119	707	15	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	707	16	despite	despite	SCONJ
cblr-5119	707	17	how	how	SCONJ
cblr-5119	707	18	other	other	ADJ
cblr-5119	707	19	circuits	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	707	20	have	have	AUX
cblr-5119	707	21	interpreted	interpret	VERB
cblr-5119	707	22	kiobel	kiobel	PROPN
cblr-5119	707	23	ii	ii	PROPN
cblr-5119	707	24	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	707	25	does	do	AUX
cblr-5119	707	26	not	not	PART
cblr-5119	707	27	require	require	VERB
cblr-5119	707	28	a	a	DET
cblr-5119	707	29	significant	significant	ADJ
cblr-5119	707	30	amount	amount	NOUN
cblr-5119	707	31	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	707	32	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	707	33	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	707	34	conduct	conduct	NOUN
cblr-5119	707	35	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	707	36	order	order	NOUN
cblr-5119	707	37	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	707	38	be	be	AUX
cblr-5119	707	39	displaced	displace	VERB
cblr-5119	707	40	under	under	ADP
cblr-5119	707	41	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	707	42	touch	touch	NOUN
cblr-5119	707	43	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-5119	707	44	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	707	45	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-5119	707	46	concern	concern	NOUN
cblr-5119	707	47	test	test	NOUN
cblr-5119	707	48	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	708	1	further	far	ADV
cblr-5119	708	2	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	708	3	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	708	4	approach	approach	NOUN
cblr-5119	708	5	is	be	AUX
cblr-5119	708	6	hardly	hardly	ADV
cblr-5119	708	7	unfair	unfair	ADJ
cblr-5119	708	8	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	708	9	businesses	business	NOUN
cblr-5119	708	10	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	708	11	which	which	PRON
cblr-5119	708	12	are	be	AUX
cblr-5119	708	13	already	already	ADV
cblr-5119	708	14	expected	expect	VERB
cblr-5119	708	15	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	708	16	respect	respect	VERB
cblr-5119	708	17	human	human	ADJ
cblr-5119	708	18	rights	right	NOUN
cblr-5119	708	19	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	708	20	which	which	PRON
cblr-5119	708	21	still	still	ADV
cblr-5119	708	22	have	have	VERB
cblr-5119	708	23	many	many	ADJ
cblr-5119	708	24	built	build	VERB
cblr-5119	708	25	-	-	PUNCT
cblr-5119	708	26	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	708	27	advantages	advantage	NOUN
cblr-5119	708	28	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	708	29	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	708	30	suits	suit	NOUN
cblr-5119	708	31	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	708	32	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	708	33	it	it	PRON
cblr-5119	708	34	simultaneously	simultaneously	ADV
cblr-5119	708	35	provides	provide	VERB
cblr-5119	708	36	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	708	37	best	good	ADJ
cblr-5119	708	38	avenue	avenue	NOUN
cblr-5119	708	39	to	to	ADP
cblr-5119	708	40	justice	justice	NOUN
cblr-5119	708	41	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	708	42	compensation	compensation	NOUN
cblr-5119	708	43	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	708	44	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
cblr-5119	708	45	injured	injure	VERB
cblr-5119	708	46	by	by	ADP
cblr-5119	708	47	egregious	egregious	ADJ
cblr-5119	708	48	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	708	49	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	708	50	corporate	corporate	ADJ
cblr-5119	708	51	misconduct	misconduct	NOUN
cblr-5119	708	52	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	709	1	most	most	ADV
cblr-5119	709	2	importantly	importantly	ADV
cblr-5119	709	3	given	give	VERB
cblr-5119	709	4	jesner	jesner	NOUN
cblr-5119	709	5	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	709	6	holding	hold	VERB
cblr-5119	709	7	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	709	8	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	709	9	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	709	10	liable	liable	ADJ
cblr-5119	709	11	under	under	ADP
cblr-5119	709	12	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	709	13	fourth	fourth	ADJ
cblr-5119	709	14	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	709	15	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	709	16	approach	approach	NOUN
cblr-5119	709	17	fails	fail	VERB
cblr-5119	709	18	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	709	19	raise	raise	VERB
cblr-5119	709	20	foreign	foreign	ADJ
cblr-5119	709	21	relations	relation	NOUN
cblr-5119	709	22	issues	issue	NOUN
cblr-5119	709	23	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	709	24	any	any	DET
cblr-5119	709	25	legitimate	legitimate	ADJ
cblr-5119	709	26	magnitude	magnitude	NOUN
cblr-5119	709	27	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	710	1	congress	congress	PROPN
cblr-5119	710	2	enacted	enact	VERB
cblr-5119	710	3	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	710	4	ats	at	NOUN
cblr-5119	710	5	with	with	ADP
cblr-5119	710	6	an	an	DET
cblr-5119	710	7	eye	eye	NOUN
cblr-5119	710	8	toward	toward	ADP
cblr-5119	710	9	stable	stable	ADJ
cblr-5119	710	10	international	international	ADJ
cblr-5119	710	11	relations	relation	NOUN
cblr-5119	710	12	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	710	13	commerce	commerce	NOUN
cblr-5119	710	14	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	710	15	and	and	CCONJ
cblr-5119	710	16	it	it	PRON
cblr-5119	710	17	will	will	AUX
cblr-5119	710	18	continue	continue	VERB
cblr-5119	710	19	to	to	PART
cblr-5119	710	20	be	be	AUX
cblr-5119	710	21	defined	define	VERB
cblr-5119	710	22	by	by	ADP
cblr-5119	710	23	those	those	DET
cblr-5119	710	24	concerns	concern	NOUN
cblr-5119	710	25	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	710	26	with	with	ADP
cblr-5119	710	27	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cblr-5119	710	28	.	.	PROPN
cblr-5119	710	29	corporations	corporation	NOUN
cblr-5119	710	30	now	now	ADV
cblr-5119	710	31	at	at	ADP
cblr-5119	710	32	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	710	33	forefront	forefront	NOUN
cblr-5119	710	34	.	.	PUNCT
cblr-5119	711	1	while	while	SCONJ
cblr-5119	711	2	uncertainty	uncertainty	NOUN
cblr-5119	711	3	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	711	4	as	as	ADP
cblr-5119	711	5	ever	ever	ADV
cblr-5119	711	6	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	711	7	shrouds	shroud	VERB
cblr-5119	711	8	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	711	9	statute	statute	NOUN
cblr-5119	711	10	in	in	ADP
cblr-5119	711	11	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	711	12	wake	wake	NOUN
cblr-5119	711	13	of	of	ADP
cblr-5119	711	14	jesner	jesner	NOUN
cblr-5119	711	15	,	,	PUNCT
cblr-5119	711	16	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	711	17	fourth	fourth	ADJ
cblr-5119	711	18	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cblr-5119	711	19	has	have	AUX
cblr-5119	711	20	charted	chart	VERB
cblr-5119	711	21	an	an	DET
cblr-5119	711	22	ideal	ideal	ADJ
cblr-5119	711	23	path	path	NOUN
cblr-5119	711	24	for	for	ADP
cblr-5119	711	25	the	the	DET
cblr-5119	711	26	ats	ats	PROPN
cblr-5119	711	27	’s	’s	PART
cblr-5119	711	28	future	future	NOUN
cblr-5119	711	29	.	.	PUNCT