id	sid	tid	token	lemma	pos
cjal-3338	1	1	defensive	defensive	ADJ
cjal-3338	1	2	use	use	NOUN
cjal-3338	1	3	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	1	4	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	1	5	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	1	6	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	1	7	exonerate	exonerate	VERB
cjal-3338	1	8	accused	accuse	VERB
cjal-3338	1	9	acts	act	NOUN
cjal-3338	1	10	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	1	11	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cjal-3338	1	12	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	1	13	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	1	14	chinese	chinese	PROPN
cjal-3338	1	15	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	1	16	litigation	litigation	NOUN
cjal-3338	1	17	defensive	defensive	ADJ
cjal-3338	1	18	use	use	NOUN
cjal-3338	1	19	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	1	20	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	1	21	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	1	22	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	1	23	exonerate	exonerate	VERB
cjal-3338	1	24	accused	accuse	VERB
cjal-3338	1	25	acts	act	NOUN
cjal-3338	1	26	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	1	27	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cjal-3338	1	28	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	1	29	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	1	30	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	2	1	chinese	chinese	ADJ
cjal-3338	2	2	patent	patent	PROPN
cjal-3338	2	3	litigation	litigation	PROPN
cjal-3338	2	4	timothy	timothy	PROPN
cjal-3338	2	5	lau	lau	PROPN
cjal-3338	2	6	abstract	abstract	ADV
cjal-3338	2	7	it	it	PRON
cjal-3338	2	8	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	2	9	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	2	10	fundamental	fundamental	ADJ
cjal-3338	2	11	principle	principle	NOUN
cjal-3338	2	12	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	2	13	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	2	14	law	law	NOUN
cjal-3338	2	15	that	that	PRON
cjal-3338	2	16	no	no	DET
cjal-3338	2	17	one	one	NOUN
cjal-3338	2	18	may	may	AUX
cjal-3338	2	19	exclude	exclude	VERB
cjal-3338	2	20	with	with	ADP
cjal-3338	2	21	his	his	PRON
cjal-3338	2	22	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	2	23	what	what	PRON
cjal-3338	2	24	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	2	25	within	within	ADP
cjal-3338	2	26	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	2	27	scope	scope	NOUN
cjal-3338	2	28	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	2	29	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	2	30	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	2	31	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	2	32	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	3	1	this	this	DET
cjal-3338	3	2	article	article	NOUN
cjal-3338	3	3	focuses	focus	VERB
cjal-3338	3	4	on	on	ADP
cjal-3338	3	5	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	3	6	'	'	PUNCT
cjal-3338	3	7	practicing	practice	VERB
cjal-3338	3	8	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	3	9	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	3	10	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	3	11	'	'	PUNCT
cjal-3338	3	12	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	3	13	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	3	14	where	where	SCONJ
cjal-3338	3	15	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	3	16	defendant	defendant	NOUN
cjal-3338	3	17	defensively	defensively	ADV
cjal-3338	3	18	demonstrates	demonstrate	VERB
cjal-3338	3	19	that	that	SCONJ
cjal-3338	3	20	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	3	21	accused	accuse	VERB
cjal-3338	3	22	acts	act	NOUN
cjal-3338	3	23	fall	fall	VERB
cjal-3338	3	24	within	within	ADP
cjal-3338	3	25	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	3	26	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	3	27	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	3	28	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	3	29	therefore	therefore	ADV
cjal-3338	3	30	may	may	AUX
cjal-3338	3	31	be	be	AUX
cjal-3338	3	32	freely	freely	ADV
cjal-3338	3	33	practiced	practice	VERB
cjal-3338	3	34	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	3	35	as	as	SCONJ
cjal-3338	3	36	implemented	implement	VERB
cjal-3338	3	37	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	3	38	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cjal-3338	3	39	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	3	40	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	3	41	chinese	chinese	ADJ
cjal-3338	3	42	jurisprudence	jurisprudence	NOUN
cjal-3338	3	43	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	4	1	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	4	2	defendant	defendant	NOUN
cjal-3338	4	3	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	4	4	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cjal-3338	4	5	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	4	6	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	4	7	litigation	litigation	NOUN
cjal-3338	4	8	has	have	VERB
cjal-3338	4	9	no	no	DET
cjal-3338	4	10	recourse	recourse	NOUN
cjal-3338	4	11	to	to	ADP
cjal-3338	4	12	this	this	DET
cjal-3338	4	13	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	4	14	with	with	ADP
cjal-3338	4	15	respect	respect	NOUN
cjal-3338	4	16	to	to	ADP
cjal-3338	4	17	literal	literal	ADJ
cjal-3338	4	18	infringement	infringement	NOUN
cjal-3338	4	19	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	4	20	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	4	21	his	his	PRON
cjal-3338	4	22	options	option	NOUN
cjal-3338	4	23	with	with	ADP
cjal-3338	4	24	regard	regard	NOUN
cjal-3338	4	25	to	to	ADP
cjal-3338	4	26	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	4	27	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	4	28	defenses	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	4	29	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	4	30	limited	limit	VERB
cjal-3338	4	31	to	to	ADP
cjal-3338	4	32	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	4	33	offensive	offensive	ADJ
cjal-3338	4	34	variant	variant	NOUN
cjal-3338	4	35	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	4	36	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	4	37	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	4	38	invalidity	invalidity	NOUN
cjal-3338	4	39	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	5	1	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	5	2	contrast	contrast	NOUN
cjal-3338	5	3	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	5	4	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	5	5	defendant	defendant	NOUN
cjal-3338	5	6	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	5	7	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	5	8	chinese	chinese	ADJ
cjal-3338	5	9	infringement	infringement	NOUN
cjal-3338	5	10	suit	suit	NOUN
cjal-3338	5	11	may	may	AUX
cjal-3338	5	12	only	only	ADV
cjal-3338	5	13	invoke	invoke	VERB
cjal-3338	5	14	this	this	DET
cjal-3338	5	15	defensive	defensive	ADJ
cjal-3338	5	16	variant	variant	NOUN
cjal-3338	5	17	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	5	18	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	5	19	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	5	20	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	5	21	defenses	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	5	22	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	6	1	we	we	PRON
cjal-3338	6	2	explore	explore	VERB
cjal-3338	6	3	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	6	4	rationale	rationale	NOUN
cjal-3338	6	5	for	for	ADP
cjal-3338	6	6	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	6	7	against	against	ADP
cjal-3338	6	8	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	6	9	existence	existence	NOUN
cjal-3338	6	10	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	6	11	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	6	12	practicing	practice	VERB
cjal-3338	6	13	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	6	14	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	6	15	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	6	16	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	6	17	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	6	18	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	6	19	examine	examine	VERB
cjal-3338	6	20	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	6	21	peculiarities	peculiarity	NOUN
cjal-3338	6	22	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	6	23	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	6	24	chinese	chinese	ADJ
cjal-3338	6	25	approach	approach	NOUN
cjal-3338	6	26	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	6	27	tying	tie	VERB
cjal-3338	6	28	its	its	PRON
cjal-3338	6	29	practicing	practice	VERB
cjal-3338	6	30	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	6	31	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	6	32	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	6	33	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	6	34	to	to	ADP
cjal-3338	6	35	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	6	36	doctrine	doctrine	NOUN
cjal-3338	6	37	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	6	38	equivalents	equivalent	NOUN
cjal-3338	6	39	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	7	1	author	author	PROPN
cjal-3338	7	2	timothy	timothy	PROPN
cjal-3338	7	3	lau	lau	PROPN
cjal-3338	7	4	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	7	5	law	law	NOUN
cjal-3338	7	6	clerk	clerk	NOUN
cjal-3338	7	7	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	7	8	judge	judge	VERB
cjal-3338	7	9	raymond	raymond	PROPN
cjal-3338	7	10	c.	c.	PROPN
cjal-3338	7	11	clevenger	clevenger	PROPN
cjal-3338	7	12	iii	iii	PROPN
cjal-3338	7	13	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	7	14	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	7	15	united	united	PROPN
cjal-3338	7	16	states	states	PROPN
cjal-3338	7	17	court	court	PROPN
cjal-3338	7	18	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	7	19	appeals	appeal	NOUN
cjal-3338	7	20	for	for	ADP
cjal-3338	7	21	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	7	22	federal	federal	ADJ
cjal-3338	7	23	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cjal-3338	7	24	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	8	1	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	8	2	author	author	NOUN
cjal-3338	8	3	would	would	AUX
cjal-3338	8	4	like	like	VERB
cjal-3338	8	5	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	8	6	express	express	VERB
cjal-3338	8	7	his	his	PRON
cjal-3338	8	8	gratitude	gratitude	NOUN
cjal-3338	8	9	to	to	ADP
cjal-3338	8	10	professors	professor	NOUN
cjal-3338	8	11	mark	mark	VERB
cjal-3338	8	12	lemley	lemley	PROPN
cjal-3338	8	13	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	8	14	paul	paul	PROPN
cjal-3338	8	15	goldstein	goldstein	PROPN
cjal-3338	8	16	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	8	17	mei	mei	PROPN
cjal-3338	8	18	gechlik	gechlik	PROPN
cjal-3338	8	19	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	8	20	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	8	21	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	8	22	editors	editor	NOUN
cjal-3338	8	23	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	8	24	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	8	25	columbia	columbia	PROPN
cjal-3338	8	26	journal	journal	PROPN
cjal-3338	8	27	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	8	28	asian	asian	ADJ
cjal-3338	8	29	law	law	NOUN
cjal-3338	8	30	for	for	ADP
cjal-3338	8	31	their	their	PRON
cjal-3338	8	32	helpful	helpful	ADJ
cjal-3338	8	33	comments	comment	NOUN
cjal-3338	8	34	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	8	35	suggestions	suggestion	NOUN
cjal-3338	8	36	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	9	1	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	9	2	chinese	chinese	ADJ
cjal-3338	9	3	translations	translation	NOUN
cjal-3338	9	4	presented	present	VERB
cjal-3338	9	5	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	9	6	this	this	DET
cjal-3338	9	7	article	article	NOUN
cjal-3338	9	8	are	be	AUX
cjal-3338	9	9	those	those	PRON
cjal-3338	9	10	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	9	11	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	9	12	author	author	NOUN
cjal-3338	9	13	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	10	1	care	care	NOUN
cjal-3338	10	2	has	have	AUX
cjal-3338	10	3	been	be	AUX
cjal-3338	10	4	taken	take	VERB
cjal-3338	10	5	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	10	6	harmonize	harmonize	VERB
cjal-3338	10	7	word	word	NOUN
cjal-3338	10	8	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	10	9	language	language	NOUN
cjal-3338	10	10	choices	choice	NOUN
cjal-3338	10	11	with	with	ADP
cjal-3338	10	12	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	10	13	translations	translation	NOUN
cjal-3338	10	14	cited	cite	VERB
cjal-3338	10	15	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	10	16	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	10	17	footnotes	footnote	NOUN
cjal-3338	10	18	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	11	1	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	11	2	views	view	NOUN
cjal-3338	11	3	expressed	express	VERB
cjal-3338	11	4	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	11	5	this	this	DET
cjal-3338	11	6	article	article	NOUN
cjal-3338	11	7	are	be	AUX
cjal-3338	11	8	that	that	PRON
cjal-3338	11	9	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	11	10	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	11	11	author	author	NOUN
cjal-3338	11	12	alone	alone	ADV
cjal-3338	11	13	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	12	1	columbia	columbia	PROPN
cjal-3338	12	2	journal	journal	PROPN
cjal-3338	12	3	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	12	4	asian	asian	ADJ
cjal-3338	12	5	law	law	NOUN
cjal-3338	12	6	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	12	7	vol	vol	NOUN
cjal-3338	12	8	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	12	9	27	27	NUM
cjal-3338	12	10	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	12	11	no	no	INTJ
cjal-3338	12	12	.	.	NOUN
cjal-3338	12	13	1	1	NUM
cjal-3338	12	14	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	12	15	2o13	2o13	NUM
cjal-3338	12	16	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	12	17	introduction	introduction	NOUN
cjal-3338	12	18	54	54	NUM
cjal-3338	12	19	a.	a.	NOUN
cjal-3338	12	20	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	12	21	relationships	relationship	NOUN
cjal-3338	12	22	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	12	23	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	12	24	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	12	25	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	12	26	defenses	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	12	27	with	with	ADP
cjal-3338	12	28	other	other	ADJ
cjal-3338	12	29	doctrines	doctrine	NOUN
cjal-3338	12	30	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	12	31	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	12	32	law	law	NOUN
cjal-3338	12	33	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	12	34	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	12	35	scope	scope	NOUN
cjal-3338	12	36	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	12	37	this	this	DET
cjal-3338	12	38	article	article	NOUN
cjal-3338	12	39	54	54	NUM
cjal-3338	12	40	b.	b.	PROPN
cjal-3338	12	41	summary	summary	NOUN
cjal-3338	12	42	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	12	43	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	12	44	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cjal-3338	12	45	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	12	46	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	12	47	chinese	chinese	ADJ
cjal-3338	12	48	infringement	infringement	NOUN
cjal-3338	12	49	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	12	50	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	12	51	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	12	52	invalidity	invalidity	NOUN
cjal-3338	12	53	doctrines	doctrine	VERB
cjal-3338	12	54	56	56	NUM
cjal-3338	12	55	ii	ii	NOUN
cjal-3338	12	56	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	13	1	using	use	VERB
cjal-3338	13	2	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	13	3	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	13	4	defensively	defensively	ADV
cjal-3338	13	5	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	13	6	establish	establish	VERB
cjal-3338	13	7	entitlement	entitlement	NOUN
cjal-3338	13	8	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	13	9	practice	practice	VERB
cjal-3338	13	10	6o	6o	NUM
cjal-3338	13	11	a.	a.	NOUN
cjal-3338	13	12	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	13	13	practicing	practice	VERB
cjal-3338	13	14	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	13	15	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	13	16	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	13	17	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	13	18	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	13	19	unavailable	unavailable	ADJ
cjal-3338	13	20	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	13	21	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cjal-3338	13	22	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	13	23	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	13	24	litigation	litigation	PROPN
cjal-3338	13	25	6o	6o	PROPN
cjal-3338	13	26	b.	b.	X
cjal-3338	13	27	existing	exist	VERB
cjal-3338	13	28	technology	technology	NOUN
cjal-3338	13	29	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	13	30	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	13	31	chinese	chinese	ADJ
cjal-3338	13	32	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	13	33	infringement	infringement	NOUN
cjal-3338	13	34	litigation	litigation	NOUN
cjal-3338	13	35	62	62	NUM
cjal-3338	13	36	i.	i.	NOUN
cjal-3338	13	37	statutory	statutory	ADJ
cjal-3338	13	38	basis	basis	NOUN
cjal-3338	13	39	62	62	NUM
cjal-3338	13	40	2	2	NUM
cjal-3338	13	41	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	14	1	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	14	2	existing	exist	VERB
cjal-3338	14	3	technology	technology	NOUN
cjal-3338	14	4	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	14	5	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	14	6	practice	practice	NOUN
cjal-3338	14	7	63	63	NUM
cjal-3338	14	8	c.	c.	NOUN
cjal-3338	14	9	should	should	AUX
cjal-3338	14	10	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	14	11	united	united	PROPN
cjal-3338	14	12	states	states	PROPN
cjal-3338	14	13	adopt	adopt	VERB
cjal-3338	14	14	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	14	15	practicing	practice	VERB
cjal-3338	14	16	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	14	17	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	14	18	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	14	19	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	14	20	?	?	PUNCT
cjal-3338	15	1	68	68	NUM
cjal-3338	15	2	1	1	NUM
cjal-3338	15	3	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	16	1	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	16	2	federal	federal	ADJ
cjal-3338	16	3	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cjal-3338	16	4	's	's	PART
cjal-3338	16	5	justification	justification	NOUN
cjal-3338	16	6	against	against	ADP
cjal-3338	16	7	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	16	8	practicing	practice	VERB
cjal-3338	16	9	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	16	10	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	16	11	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	16	12	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	16	13	68	68	NUM
cjal-3338	16	14	2	2	NUM
cjal-3338	16	15	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	16	16	other	other	ADJ
cjal-3338	16	17	justifications	justification	NOUN
cjal-3338	16	18	against	against	ADP
cjal-3338	16	19	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	16	20	practicing	practice	VERB
cjal-3338	16	21	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	16	22	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	16	23	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	16	24	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	16	25	70	70	NUM
cjal-3338	16	26	3	3	NUM
cjal-3338	16	27	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	16	28	justifications	justification	NOUN
cjal-3338	16	29	for	for	ADP
cjal-3338	16	30	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	16	31	practicing	practice	VERB
cjal-3338	16	32	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	16	33	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	16	34	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	16	35	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	16	36	74	74	PROPN
cjal-3338	16	37	d.	d.	PROPN
cjal-3338	16	38	has	have	VERB
cjal-3338	16	39	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	16	40	chinese	chinese	PROPN
cjal-3338	16	41	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	16	42	law	law	NOUN
cjal-3338	16	43	structured	structure	VERB
cjal-3338	16	44	its	its	PRON
cjal-3338	16	45	existing	exist	VERB
cjal-3338	16	46	technology	technology	NOUN
cjal-3338	16	47	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	16	48	well	well	ADV
cjal-3338	16	49	?	?	PUNCT
cjal-3338	17	1	76	76	NUM
cjal-3338	17	2	conclusion	conclusion	NOUN
cjal-3338	17	3	defensive	defensive	ADJ
cjal-3338	17	4	use	use	NOUN
cjal-3338	17	5	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	17	6	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	17	7	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	17	8	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	17	9	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cjal-3338	17	10	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	17	11	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	17	12	chinese	chinese	ADJ
cjal-3338	17	13	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	17	14	litigation	litigation	NOUN
cjal-3338	17	15	53	53	NUM
cjal-3338	17	16	list	list	NOUN
cjal-3338	17	17	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	17	18	figures	figure	NOUN
cjal-3338	17	19	figure	figure	VERB
cjal-3338	17	20	1	1	NUM
cjal-3338	17	21	:	:	PUNCT
cjal-3338	17	22	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	17	23	generalized	generalized	ADJ
cjal-3338	17	24	view	view	NOUN
cjal-3338	17	25	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	17	26	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	17	27	law	law	NOUN
cjal-3338	17	28	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	18	1	figure	figure	NOUN
cjal-3338	18	2	2	2	NUM
cjal-3338	18	3	:	:	PUNCT
cjal-3338	18	4	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	18	5	figure	figure	NOUN
cjal-3338	18	6	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	18	7	cn	cn	PROPN
cjal-3338	18	8	95119389.9	95119389.9	NUM
cjal-3338	18	9	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	18	10	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	18	11	asserted	assert	VERB
cjal-3338	18	12	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	18	13	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	18	14	china	china	PROPN
cjal-3338	18	15	environmental	environmental	PROPN
cjal-3338	18	16	project	project	PROPN
cjal-3338	18	17	technology	technology	PROPN
cjal-3338	18	18	v.	v.	PROPN
cjal-3338	18	19	huayang	huayang	PROPN
cjal-3338	18	20	electric	electric	PROPN
cjal-3338	18	21	power	power	PROPN
cjal-3338	18	22	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	19	1	figure	figure	VERB
cjal-3338	19	2	3	3	NUM
cjal-3338	19	3	:	:	PUNCT
cjal-3338	19	4	figure	figure	NOUN
cjal-3338	19	5	5	5	NUM
cjal-3338	19	6	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	19	7	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cjal-3338	19	8	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	19	9	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	19	10	no	no	PROPN
cjal-3338	19	11	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	20	1	4,o85,194	4,o85,194	PROPN
cjal-3338	20	2	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	20	3	entitled	entitle	VERB
cjal-3338	20	4	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	20	5	waste	waste	NOUN
cjal-3338	20	6	flue	flue	NOUN
cjal-3338	20	7	gas	gas	NOUN
cjal-3338	20	8	desulfurizing	desulfurizing	NOUN
cjal-3338	20	9	method	method	NOUN
cjal-3338	20	10	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	20	11	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	20	12	figure	figure	VERB
cjal-3338	20	13	4	4	NUM
cjal-3338	20	14	:	:	PUNCT
cjal-3338	20	15	schematic	schematic	ADJ
cjal-3338	20	16	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	20	17	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	20	18	existing	exist	VERB
cjal-3338	20	19	technology	technology	NOUN
cjal-3338	20	20	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	20	21	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	20	22	chinese	chinese	ADJ
cjal-3338	20	23	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	20	24	law	law	NOUN
cjal-3338	20	25	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	21	1	54	54	NUM
cjal-3338	21	2	columbia	columbia	PROPN
cjal-3338	21	3	journal	journal	PROPN
cjal-3338	21	4	ofasian	ofasian	ADJ
cjal-3338	21	5	law	law	NOUN
cjal-3338	21	6	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	21	7	vol	vol	NOUN
cjal-3338	21	8	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	21	9	27	27	NUM
cjal-3338	21	10	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	21	11	no	no	INTJ
cjal-3338	21	12	.	.	NOUN
cjal-3338	21	13	1	1	NUM
cjal-3338	21	14	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	21	15	2o13	2o13	NUM
cjal-3338	21	16	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	21	17	i.	i.	NOUN
cjal-3338	21	18	introduction	introduction	NOUN
cjal-3338	21	19	a.	a.	NOUN
cjal-3338	21	20	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	21	21	relationships	relationship	NOUN
cjal-3338	21	22	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	21	23	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	21	24	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	21	25	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	21	26	defenses	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	21	27	with	with	ADP
cjal-3338	21	28	other	other	ADJ
cjal-3338	21	29	doctrines	doctrine	NOUN
cjal-3338	21	30	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	21	31	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	21	32	law	law	NOUN
cjal-3338	21	33	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	21	34	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	21	35	scope	scope	NOUN
cjal-3338	21	36	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	21	37	this	this	DET
cjal-3338	21	38	article	article	NOUN
cjal-3338	21	39	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	21	40	promote	promote	VERB
cjal-3338	21	41	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	21	42	creation	creation	NOUN
cjal-3338	21	43	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	21	44	disclosures	disclosure	NOUN
cjal-3338	21	45	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	21	46	inventions	invention	NOUN
cjal-3338	21	47	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	21	48	governments	government	NOUN
cjal-3338	21	49	grant	grant	VERB
cjal-3338	21	50	patents	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	21	51	to	to	ADP
cjal-3338	21	52	those	those	PRON
cjal-3338	21	53	who	who	PRON
cjal-3338	21	54	open	open	VERB
cjal-3338	21	55	up	up	ADP
cjal-3338	21	56	new	new	ADJ
cjal-3338	21	57	technological	technological	ADJ
cjal-3338	21	58	territory	territory	NOUN
cjal-3338	21	59	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	22	1	these	these	DET
cjal-3338	22	2	monopoly	monopoly	NOUN
cjal-3338	22	3	rights	right	NOUN
cjal-3338	22	4	allow	allow	VERB
cjal-3338	22	5	patentees	patentee	NOUN
cjal-3338	22	6	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	22	7	exclude	exclude	VERB
cjal-3338	22	8	infringers	infringer	NOUN
cjal-3338	22	9	through	through	ADP
cjal-3338	22	10	judicial	judicial	ADJ
cjal-3338	22	11	proceedings	proceeding	NOUN
cjal-3338	22	12	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	22	13	obtain	obtain	VERB
cjal-3338	22	14	damages	damage	NOUN
cjal-3338	22	15	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	22	16	injunctions	injunction	NOUN
cjal-3338	22	17	for	for	ADP
cjal-3338	22	18	intrusions	intrusion	NOUN
cjal-3338	22	19	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	22	20	'	'	PUNCT
cjal-3338	23	1	nonetheless	nonetheless	ADV
cjal-3338	23	2	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	23	3	basic	basic	ADJ
cjal-3338	23	4	fairness	fairness	NOUN
cjal-3338	23	5	dictates	dictate	VERB
cjal-3338	23	6	that	that	SCONJ
cjal-3338	23	7	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	23	8	rewards	reward	NOUN
cjal-3338	23	9	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	23	10	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	23	11	grants	grant	NOUN
cjal-3338	23	12	should	should	AUX
cjal-3338	23	13	be	be	AUX
cjal-3338	23	14	coextensive	coextensive	ADJ
cjal-3338	23	15	with	with	ADP
cjal-3338	23	16	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	23	17	scope	scope	NOUN
cjal-3338	23	18	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	23	19	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	23	20	inventions	invention	NOUN
cjal-3338	23	21	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	24	1	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	24	2	number	number	NOUN
cjal-3338	24	3	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	24	4	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	24	5	law	law	NOUN
cjal-3338	24	6	doctrines	doctrine	NOUN
cjal-3338	24	7	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	24	8	using	use	VERB
cjal-3338	24	9	comparisons	comparison	NOUN
cjal-3338	24	10	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	24	11	ascertain	ascertain	VERB
cjal-3338	24	12	what	what	PRON
cjal-3338	24	13	may	may	AUX
cjal-3338	24	14	be	be	AUX
cjal-3338	24	15	patented	patent	VERB
cjal-3338	24	16	or	or	CCONJ
cjal-3338	24	17	practiced	practice	VERB
cjal-3338	24	18	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	24	19	grow	grow	VERB
cjal-3338	24	20	out	out	ADP
cjal-3338	24	21	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	24	22	these	these	DET
cjal-3338	24	23	fundamental	fundamental	ADJ
cjal-3338	24	24	principles	principle	NOUN
cjal-3338	24	25	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	25	1	these	these	DET
cjal-3338	25	2	doctrines	doctrine	NOUN
cjal-3338	25	3	can	can	AUX
cjal-3338	25	4	be	be	AUX
cjal-3338	25	5	conceptualized	conceptualize	VERB
cjal-3338	25	6	along	along	ADP
cjal-3338	25	7	two	two	NUM
cjal-3338	25	8	dimensions	dimension	NOUN
cjal-3338	25	9	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	26	1	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	26	2	first	first	ADJ
cjal-3338	26	3	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	26	4	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	26	5	object	object	NOUN
cjal-3338	26	6	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	26	7	comparison	comparison	NOUN
cjal-3338	26	8	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	26	9	which	which	PRON
cjal-3338	26	10	could	could	AUX
cjal-3338	26	11	be	be	AUX
cjal-3338	26	12	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	26	13	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	26	14	claim	claim	NOUN
cjal-3338	26	15	or	or	CCONJ
cjal-3338	26	16	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	26	17	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	26	18	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	26	19	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	27	1	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	27	2	second	second	NOUN
cjal-3338	27	3	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	27	4	whether	whether	SCONJ
cjal-3338	27	5	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	27	6	doctrines	doctrine	NOUN
cjal-3338	27	7	are	be	AUX
cjal-3338	27	8	exclusive	exclusive	ADJ
cjal-3338	27	9	fences	fence	NOUN
cjal-3338	27	10	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	27	11	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	27	12	you	you	PRON
cjal-3338	27	13	shall	shall	AUX
cjal-3338	27	14	not	not	PART
cjal-3338	27	15	do	do	AUX
cjal-3338	27	16	x	x	NOUN
cjal-3338	27	17	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	27	18	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	27	19	or	or	CCONJ
cjal-3338	27	20	inclusive	inclusive	ADJ
cjal-3338	27	21	safe	safe	ADJ
cjal-3338	27	22	-	-	PUNCT
cjal-3338	27	23	harbors	harbor	NOUN
cjal-3338	27	24	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	27	25	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	27	26	you	you	PRON
cjal-3338	27	27	may	may	AUX
cjal-3338	27	28	do	do	AUX
cjal-3338	27	29	y	y	NOUN
cjal-3338	27	30	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	27	31	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	27	32	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	28	1	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	28	2	reader	reader	NOUN
cjal-3338	28	3	familiar	familiar	ADJ
cjal-3338	28	4	with	with	ADP
cjal-3338	28	5	western	western	ADJ
cjal-3338	28	6	law	law	NOUN
cjal-3338	28	7	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	28	8	familiar	familiar	ADJ
cjal-3338	28	9	with	with	ADP
cjal-3338	28	10	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	28	11	two	two	NUM
cjal-3338	28	12	key	key	ADJ
cjal-3338	28	13	questions	question	NOUN
cjal-3338	28	14	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	28	15	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	28	16	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	28	17	validity	validity	NOUN
cjal-3338	28	18	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	28	19	infringement	infringement	NOUN
cjal-3338	28	20	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	29	1	both	both	DET
cjal-3338	29	2	doctrines	doctrine	NOUN
cjal-3338	29	3	are	be	AUX
cjal-3338	29	4	exclusive	exclusive	ADJ
cjal-3338	29	5	walls	wall	NOUN
cjal-3338	29	6	:	:	PUNCT
cjal-3338	29	7	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	29	8	former	former	ADJ
cjal-3338	29	9	forbids	forbid	VERB
cjal-3338	29	10	patenting	patent	VERB
cjal-3338	29	11	within	within	ADP
cjal-3338	29	12	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	29	13	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	29	14	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	29	15	while	while	SCONJ
cjal-3338	29	16	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	29	17	latter	latter	NOUN
cjal-3338	29	18	forbids	forbid	VERB
cjal-3338	29	19	practicing	practice	VERB
cjal-3338	29	20	within	within	ADP
cjal-3338	29	21	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	29	22	scope	scope	NOUN
cjal-3338	29	23	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	29	24	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	29	25	claims	claim	NOUN
cjal-3338	29	26	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	30	1	however	however	ADV
cjal-3338	30	2	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	30	3	there	there	PRON
cjal-3338	30	4	is	be	VERB
cjal-3338	30	5	no	no	DET
cjal-3338	30	6	theoretical	theoretical	ADJ
cjal-3338	30	7	objection	objection	NOUN
cjal-3338	30	8	to	to	ADP
cjal-3338	30	9	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	30	10	existence	existence	NOUN
cjal-3338	30	11	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	30	12	inclusive	inclusive	ADJ
cjal-3338	30	13	walls	wall	NOUN
cjal-3338	30	14	around	around	ADP
cjal-3338	30	15	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	30	16	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	30	17	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	30	18	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	30	19	around	around	ADP
cjal-3338	30	20	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	30	21	claims	claim	NOUN
cjal-3338	30	22	as	as	ADV
cjal-3338	30	23	well	well	ADV
cjal-3338	30	24	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	31	1	these	these	DET
cjal-3338	31	2	doctrines	doctrine	NOUN
cjal-3338	31	3	that	that	PRON
cjal-3338	31	4	exclude	exclude	VERB
cjal-3338	31	5	/	/	SYM
cjal-3338	31	6	include	include	VERB
cjal-3338	31	7	based	base	VERB
cjal-3338	31	8	on	on	ADP
cjal-3338	31	9	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	31	10	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	31	11	/	/	SYM
cjal-3338	31	12	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	31	13	claims	claim	NOUN
cjal-3338	31	14	are	be	AUX
cjal-3338	31	15	summarized	summarize	VERB
cjal-3338	31	16	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	31	17	matrix	matrix	NOUN
cjal-3338	31	18	form	form	NOUN
cjal-3338	31	19	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	31	20	figure	figure	NOUN
cjal-3338	31	21	i.	i.	NOUN
cjal-3338	31	22	'	'	PART
cjal-3338	31	23	agreement	agreement	NOUN
cjal-3338	31	24	on	on	ADP
cjal-3338	31	25	trade	trade	NOUN
cjal-3338	31	26	-	-	PUNCT
cjal-3338	31	27	related	relate	VERB
cjal-3338	31	28	aspects	aspect	NOUN
cjal-3338	31	29	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	31	30	intellectual	intellectual	ADJ
cjal-3338	31	31	property	property	NOUN
cjal-3338	31	32	rights	right	NOUN
cjal-3338	31	33	[	[	X
cjal-3338	31	34	hereinafter	hereinafter	NOUN
cjal-3338	31	35	trips	trip	NOUN
cjal-3338	31	36	]	]	PUNCT
cjal-3338	31	37	arts	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	31	38	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	32	1	42	42	NUM
cjal-3338	32	2	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	32	3	44	44	NUM
cjal-3338	32	4	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	32	5	45	45	NUM
cjal-3338	32	6	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	32	7	apr	apr	PROPN
cjal-3338	32	8	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	32	9	15	15	NUM
cjal-3338	32	10	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	32	11	1994	1994	NUM
cjal-3338	32	12	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	33	1	33	33	NUM
cjal-3338	33	2	i.l.m	i.l.m	NOUN
cjal-3338	33	3	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	34	1	81	81	NUM
cjal-3338	34	2	defensive	defensive	ADJ
cjal-3338	34	3	use	use	NOUN
cjal-3338	34	4	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	34	5	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	34	6	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	34	7	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	34	8	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cjal-3338	34	9	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	34	10	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	34	11	chinese	chinese	PROPN
cjal-3338	34	12	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	34	13	litigation	litigation	PROPN
cjal-3338	34	14	55	55	NUM
cjal-3338	34	15	core	core	NOUN
cjal-3338	34	16	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	34	17	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	34	18	claim	claim	VERB
cjal-3338	34	19	11	11	NUM
cjal-3338	34	20	invalidity	invalidity	NOUN
cjal-3338	34	21	infringement	infringement	NOUN
cjal-3338	34	22	practicing	practice	VERB
cjal-3338	34	23	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	34	24	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	34	25	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	34	26	_	_	PUNCT
cjal-3338	35	1	j	j	PROPN
cjal-3338	36	1	right	right	ADJ
cjal-3338	36	2	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	36	3	practice	practice	VERB
cjal-3338	36	4	figure	figure	NOUN
cjal-3338	36	5	1	1	NUM
cjal-3338	36	6	:	:	PUNCT
cjal-3338	36	7	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	36	8	generalized	generalized	ADJ
cjal-3338	36	9	view	view	NOUN
cjal-3338	36	10	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	36	11	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	36	12	law	law	NOUN
cjal-3338	36	13	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	37	1	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	37	2	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	37	3	inner	inner	ADJ
cjal-3338	37	4	walls	wall	NOUN
cjal-3338	37	5	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	37	6	around	around	ADP
cjal-3338	37	7	each	each	DET
cjal-3338	37	8	core	core	NOUN
cjal-3338	37	9	are	be	AUX
cjal-3338	37	10	those	those	PRON
cjal-3338	37	11	that	that	PRON
cjal-3338	37	12	exclude	exclude	NOUN
cjal-3338	37	13	/	/	SYM
cjal-3338	37	14	include	include	VERB
cjal-3338	37	15	around	around	ADP
cjal-3338	37	16	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	37	17	exact	exact	ADJ
cjal-3338	37	18	bounds	bound	NOUN
cjal-3338	37	19	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	37	20	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	37	21	core	core	NOUN
cjal-3338	37	22	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	38	1	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	38	2	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	38	3	outer	outer	ADJ
cjal-3338	38	4	walls	wall	NOUN
cjal-3338	38	5	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	38	6	around	around	ADP
cjal-3338	38	7	each	each	DET
cjal-3338	38	8	core	core	NOUN
cjal-3338	38	9	are	be	AUX
cjal-3338	38	10	those	those	PRON
cjal-3338	38	11	that	that	PRON
cjal-3338	38	12	exclude	exclude	NOUN
cjal-3338	38	13	/	/	SYM
cjal-3338	38	14	include	include	VERB
cjal-3338	38	15	around	around	ADP
cjal-3338	38	16	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	38	17	certain	certain	ADJ
cjal-3338	38	18	reach	reach	NOUN
cjal-3338	38	19	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	38	20	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	38	21	core	core	NOUN
cjal-3338	38	22	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	39	1	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	39	2	two	two	NUM
cjal-3338	39	3	doctrines	doctrine	NOUN
cjal-3338	39	4	on	on	ADP
cjal-3338	39	5	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	39	6	left	left	ADJ
cjal-3338	39	7	column	column	NOUN
cjal-3338	39	8	are	be	AUX
cjal-3338	39	9	built	build	VERB
cjal-3338	39	10	around	around	ADP
cjal-3338	39	11	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	39	12	comparison	comparison	NOUN
cjal-3338	39	13	with	with	ADP
cjal-3338	39	14	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	39	15	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	39	16	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	39	17	:	:	PUNCT
cjal-3338	39	18	i	i	NOUN
cjal-3338	39	19	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	39	20	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	39	21	claim	claim	NOUN
cjal-3338	39	22	invalidity	invalidity	VERB
cjal-3338	39	23	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	39	24	defendant	defendant	NOUN
cjal-3338	39	25	offensively	offensively	ADV
cjal-3338	39	26	compares	compare	VERB
cjal-3338	39	27	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	39	28	claims	claim	NOUN
cjal-3338	39	29	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	39	30	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	39	31	asserted	assert	VERB
cjal-3338	39	32	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	39	33	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	39	34	relation	relation	NOUN
cjal-3338	39	35	to	to	ADP
cjal-3338	39	36	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	39	37	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	39	38	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	39	39	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	39	40	demonstrates	demonstrate	VERB
cjal-3338	39	41	that	that	SCONJ
cjal-3338	39	42	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	39	43	claims	claim	NOUN
cjal-3338	39	44	fall	fall	VERB
cjal-3338	39	45	within	within	ADP
cjal-3338	39	46	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	39	47	scope	scope	NOUN
cjal-3338	39	48	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	39	49	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	39	50	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	39	51	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	39	52	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	39	53	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	39	54	rule	rule	NOUN
cjal-3338	39	55	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	39	56	exclusion	exclusion	NOUN
cjal-3338	39	57	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	39	58	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	39	59	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	39	60	thereby	thereby	ADV
cjal-3338	39	61	proves	prove	VERB
cjal-3338	39	62	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	39	63	invalidity	invalidity	NOUN
cjal-3338	39	64	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	39	65	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	39	66	claims	claim	NOUN
cjal-3338	39	67	;	;	PUNCT
cjal-3338	39	68	or	or	CCONJ
cjal-3338	39	69	2	2	X
cjal-3338	39	70	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	39	71	practicing	practice	VERB
cjal-3338	39	72	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	39	73	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	39	74	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	39	75	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	39	76	defendant	defendant	NOUN
cjal-3338	39	77	defensively	defensively	ADV
cjal-3338	39	78	demonstrates	demonstrate	VERB
cjal-3338	39	79	that	that	SCONJ
cjal-3338	39	80	his	his	PRON
cjal-3338	39	81	accused	accuse	VERB
cjal-3338	39	82	acts	act	NOUN
cjal-3338	39	83	fall	fall	VERB
cjal-3338	39	84	within	within	ADP
cjal-3338	39	85	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	39	86	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	39	87	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	39	88	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	39	89	which	which	PRON
cjal-3338	39	90	therefore	therefore	ADV
cjal-3338	39	91	could	could	AUX
cjal-3338	39	92	not	not	PART
cjal-3338	39	93	have	have	AUX
cjal-3338	39	94	fallen	fall	VERB
cjal-3338	39	95	within	within	ADP
cjal-3338	39	96	any	any	DET
cjal-3338	39	97	valid	valid	ADJ
cjal-3338	39	98	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	39	99	grant	grant	NOUN
cjal-3338	39	100	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	40	1	that	that	PRON
cjal-3338	40	2	is	is	ADV
cjal-3338	40	3	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	40	4	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	40	5	accused	accuse	VERB
cjal-3338	40	6	acts	act	NOUN
cjal-3338	40	7	can	can	AUX
cjal-3338	40	8	be	be	AUX
cjal-3338	40	9	freely	freely	ADV
cjal-3338	40	10	practiced	practice	VERB
cjal-3338	40	11	as	as	ADP
cjal-3338	40	12	against	against	ADP
cjal-3338	40	13	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	40	14	patentee	patentee	NOUN
cjal-3338	40	15	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	40	16	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	40	17	rule	rule	NOUN
cjal-3338	40	18	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	40	19	inclusion	inclusion	NOUN
cjal-3338	40	20	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	40	21	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	41	1	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	41	2	two	two	NUM
cjal-3338	41	3	differ	differ	VERB
cjal-3338	41	4	on	on	ADP
cjal-3338	41	5	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	41	6	subject	subject	NOUN
cjal-3338	41	7	compared	compare	VERB
cjal-3338	41	8	to	to	ADP
cjal-3338	41	9	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	41	10	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	41	11	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	41	12	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	42	1	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	42	2	first	first	ADJ
cjal-3338	42	3	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	42	4	centered	center	VERB
cjal-3338	42	5	on	on	ADP
cjal-3338	42	6	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	42	7	claim	claim	NOUN
cjal-3338	42	8	scope	scope	NOUN
cjal-3338	42	9	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	42	10	while	while	SCONJ
cjal-3338	42	11	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	42	12	second	second	NOUN
cjal-3338	42	13	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	42	14	centered	center	VERB
cjal-3338	42	15	on	on	ADP
cjal-3338	42	16	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	42	17	accused	accuse	VERB
cjal-3338	42	18	acts	act	NOUN
cjal-3338	42	19	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	43	1	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	43	2	first	first	ADJ
cjal-3338	43	3	has	have	VERB
cjal-3338	43	4	an	an	DET
cjal-3338	43	5	offensive	offensive	ADJ
cjal-3338	43	6	character	character	NOUN
cjal-3338	43	7	that	that	SCONJ
cjal-3338	43	8	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	43	9	second	second	ADJ
cjal-3338	43	10	lacks	lack	VERB
cjal-3338	43	11	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	43	12	because	because	SCONJ
cjal-3338	43	13	successful	successful	ADJ
cjal-3338	43	14	invocation	invocation	NOUN
cjal-3338	43	15	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	43	16	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	43	17	first	first	ADJ
cjal-3338	43	18	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	43	19	means	mean	VERB
cjal-3338	43	20	that	that	SCONJ
cjal-3338	43	21	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	43	22	asserted	assert	VERB
cjal-3338	43	23	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	43	24	claim	claim	NOUN
cjal-3338	43	25	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	43	26	unenforceable	unenforceable	ADJ
cjal-3338	43	27	against	against	ADP
cjal-3338	43	28	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	43	29	world	world	NOUN
cjal-3338	43	30	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	43	31	not	not	PART
cjal-3338	43	32	just	just	ADV
cjal-3338	43	33	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	43	34	accused	accuse	VERB
cjal-3338	43	35	infringer	infringer	NOUN
cjal-3338	43	36	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	44	1	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	44	2	second	second	ADJ
cjal-3338	44	3	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	44	4	only	only	ADV
cjal-3338	44	5	exonerates	exonerate	VERB
cjal-3338	44	6	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	44	7	accused	accuse	VERB
cjal-3338	44	8	acts	act	NOUN
cjal-3338	44	9	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	44	10	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	44	11	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	44	12	claim	claim	NOUN
cjal-3338	44	13	survives	survive	VERB
cjal-3338	44	14	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	44	15	be	be	AUX
cjal-3338	44	16	used	use	VERB
cjal-3338	44	17	by	by	ADP
cjal-3338	44	18	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	44	19	patentee	patentee	NOUN
cjal-3338	44	20	against	against	ADP
cjal-3338	44	21	other	other	ADJ
cjal-3338	44	22	defendants	defendant	NOUN
cjal-3338	44	23	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	45	1	through	through	ADP
cjal-3338	45	2	these	these	DET
cjal-3338	45	3	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	45	4	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	45	5	defenses	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	45	6	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	45	7	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	45	8	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	45	9	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	45	10	takes	take	VERB
cjal-3338	45	11	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	45	12	central	central	ADJ
cjal-3338	45	13	role	role	NOUN
cjal-3338	45	14	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	45	15	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	45	16	law	law	NOUN
cjal-3338	45	17	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	46	1	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	46	2	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	46	3	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	46	4	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	46	5	within	within	ADP
cjal-3338	46	6	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	46	7	context	context	NOUN
cjal-3338	46	8	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	46	9	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	46	10	offensive	offensive	ADJ
cjal-3338	46	11	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	46	12	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	46	13	invalidity	invalidity	NOUN
cjal-3338	46	14	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	46	15	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	46	16	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	46	17	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	46	18	techiological	techiological	ADJ
cjal-3338	46	19	territory	territory	NOUN
cjal-3338	46	20	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	46	21	patentability	patentability	NOUN
cjal-3338	46	22	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	47	1	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	47	2	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	47	3	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	47	4	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	47	5	within	within	ADP
cjal-3338	47	6	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	47	7	context	context	NOUN
cjal-3338	47	8	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	47	9	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	47	10	defensive	defensive	ADJ
cjal-3338	47	11	practicing	practice	VERB
cjal-3338	47	12	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	47	13	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	47	14	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	47	15	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	47	16	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	47	17	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	47	18	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	47	19	technological	technological	ADJ
cjal-3338	47	20	commons	common	NOUN
cjal-3338	47	21	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	48	1	how	how	SCONJ
cjal-3338	48	2	courts	court	NOUN
cjal-3338	48	3	apply	apply	VERB
cjal-3338	48	4	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	48	5	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	48	6	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	48	7	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	48	8	critical	critical	ADJ
cjal-3338	48	9	to	to	ADP
cjal-3338	48	10	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	48	11	operation	operation	NOUN
cjal-3338	48	12	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	48	13	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	48	14	law	law	NOUN
cjal-3338	48	15	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	49	1	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	49	2	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	49	3	laws	law	NOUN
cjal-3338	49	4	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	49	5	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	49	6	united	united	PROPN
cjal-3338	49	7	states	states	PROPN
cjal-3338	49	8	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	49	9	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	49	10	people	people	NOUN
cjal-3338	49	11	's	's	PART
cjal-3338	49	12	republic	republic	NOUN
cjal-3338	49	13	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	49	14	china	china	PROPN
cjal-3338	49	15	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	49	16	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	49	17	china	china	PROPN
cjal-3338	49	18	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	49	19	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	49	20	are	be	AUX
cjal-3338	49	21	particularly	particularly	ADV
cjal-3338	49	22	suited	suit	VERB
cjal-3338	49	23	to	to	ADP
cjal-3338	49	24	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	49	25	study	study	NOUN
cjal-3338	49	26	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	49	27	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	49	28	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	49	29	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	49	30	defenses	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	49	31	from	from	ADP
cjal-3338	49	32	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	49	33	columbia	columbia	PROPN
cjal-3338	49	34	journal	journal	NOUN
cjal-3338	49	35	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	49	36	asian	asian	ADJ
cjal-3338	49	37	law	law	NOUN
cjal-3338	49	38	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	49	39	vol	vol	NOUN
cjal-3338	49	40	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	50	1	27	27	NUM
cjal-3338	50	2	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	50	3	no	no	INTJ
cjal-3338	50	4	.	.	NOUN
cjal-3338	50	5	1	1	NUM
cjal-3338	50	6	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	50	7	2o13	2o13	NUM
cjal-3338	50	8	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	50	9	comparative	comparative	ADJ
cjal-3338	50	10	angle	angle	NOUN
cjal-3338	50	11	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	50	12	because	because	SCONJ
cjal-3338	50	13	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	50	14	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	50	15	strong	strong	ADJ
cjal-3338	50	16	contrasts	contrast	NOUN
cjal-3338	50	17	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	50	18	local	local	ADJ
cjal-3338	50	19	assumptions	assumption	NOUN
cjal-3338	50	20	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	50	21	procedures	procedure	NOUN
cjal-3338	50	22	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	50	23	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	50	24	constitutional	constitutional	ADJ
cjal-3338	50	25	law	law	NOUN
cjal-3338	50	26	groundings	grounding	NOUN
cjal-3338	50	27	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	51	1	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	51	2	an	an	DET
cjal-3338	51	3	earlier	early	ADJ
cjal-3338	51	4	article,2	article,2	X
cjal-3338	51	5	we	we	PRON
cjal-3338	51	6	have	have	AUX
cjal-3338	51	7	discussed	discuss	VERB
cjal-3338	51	8	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	51	9	offensive	offensive	ADJ
cjal-3338	51	10	use	use	NOUN
cjal-3338	51	11	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	51	12	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	51	13	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	51	14	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	51	15	invalidate	invalidate	VERB
cjal-3338	51	16	patents	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	51	17	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	51	18	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cjal-3338	51	19	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	51	20	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	51	21	chinese	chinese	ADJ
cjal-3338	51	22	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	51	23	litigation	litigation	NOUN
cjal-3338	51	24	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	52	1	we	we	PRON
cjal-3338	52	2	have	have	AUX
cjal-3338	52	3	also	also	ADV
cjal-3338	52	4	explored	explore	VERB
cjal-3338	52	5	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	52	6	relationships	relationship	NOUN
cjal-3338	52	7	between	between	ADP
cjal-3338	52	8	these	these	DET
cjal-3338	52	9	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	52	10	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	52	11	invalidity	invalidity	NOUN
cjal-3338	52	12	doctrines	doctrine	NOUN
cjal-3338	52	13	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	52	14	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	52	15	infringement	infringement	NOUN
cjal-3338	52	16	doctrines	doctrine	NOUN
cjal-3338	52	17	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	53	1	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	53	2	this	this	DET
cjal-3338	53	3	companion	companion	NOUN
cjal-3338	53	4	article	article	NOUN
cjal-3338	53	5	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	53	6	we	we	PRON
cjal-3338	53	7	explore	explore	VERB
cjal-3338	53	8	how	how	SCONJ
cjal-3338	53	9	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	53	10	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	53	11	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	53	12	may	may	AUX
cjal-3338	53	13	be	be	AUX
cjal-3338	53	14	used	use	VERB
cjal-3338	53	15	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	53	16	defensively	defensively	ADV
cjal-3338	53	17	exonerate	exonerate	VERB
cjal-3338	53	18	accused	accuse	VERB
cjal-3338	53	19	acts	act	NOUN
cjal-3338	53	20	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	54	1	as	as	ADP
cjal-3338	54	2	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	54	3	matter	matter	NOUN
cjal-3338	54	4	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	54	5	general	general	ADJ
cjal-3338	54	6	principle	principle	NOUN
cjal-3338	54	7	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	54	8	one	one	NUM
cjal-3338	54	9	who	who	PRON
cjal-3338	54	10	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	54	11	practicing	practice	VERB
cjal-3338	54	12	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	54	13	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	54	14	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	54	15	should	should	AUX
cjal-3338	54	16	not	not	PART
cjal-3338	54	17	be	be	AUX
cjal-3338	54	18	liable	liable	ADJ
cjal-3338	54	19	for	for	ADP
cjal-3338	54	20	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	54	21	infringement	infringement	NOUN
cjal-3338	54	22	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	55	1	chinese	chinese	ADJ
cjal-3338	55	2	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	55	3	law	law	NOUN
cjal-3338	55	4	permits	permit	VERB
cjal-3338	55	5	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	55	6	defendant	defendant	NOUN
cjal-3338	55	7	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	55	8	demonstrate	demonstrate	VERB
cjal-3338	55	9	that	that	SCONJ
cjal-3338	55	10	his	his	PRON
cjal-3338	55	11	accused	accuse	VERB
cjal-3338	55	12	acts	act	NOUN
cjal-3338	55	13	falls	fall	VERB
cjal-3338	55	14	within	within	ADP
cjal-3338	55	15	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	55	16	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	55	17	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	55	18	as	as	ADP
cjal-3338	55	19	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	55	20	complete	complete	ADJ
cjal-3338	55	21	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	55	22	to	to	ADP
cjal-3338	55	23	claims	claim	NOUN
cjal-3338	55	24	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	55	25	infringement	infringement	NOUN
cjal-3338	55	26	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	56	1	however	however	ADV
cjal-3338	56	2	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	56	3	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cjal-3338	56	4	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	56	5	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	56	6	law	law	NOUN
cjal-3338	56	7	does	do	AUX
cjal-3338	56	8	not	not	PART
cjal-3338	56	9	permit	permit	VERB
cjal-3338	56	10	such	such	DET
cjal-3338	56	11	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	56	12	practicing	practice	VERB
cjal-3338	56	13	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	56	14	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	56	15	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	56	16	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	56	17	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	56	18	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	56	19	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	56	20	defendant	defendant	NOUN
cjal-3338	56	21	may	may	AUX
cjal-3338	56	22	only	only	ADV
cjal-3338	56	23	use	use	VERB
cjal-3338	56	24	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	56	25	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	56	26	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	56	27	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	56	28	invalidate	invalidate	VERB
cjal-3338	56	29	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	56	30	asserted	assert	VERB
cjal-3338	56	31	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	56	32	claims	claim	NOUN
cjal-3338	56	33	but	but	CCONJ
cjal-3338	56	34	not	not	PART
cjal-3338	56	35	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	56	36	exonerate	exonerate	VERB
cjal-3338	56	37	accused	accuse	VERB
cjal-3338	56	38	acts	act	NOUN
cjal-3338	56	39	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	57	1	we	we	PRON
cjal-3338	57	2	examine	examine	VERB
cjal-3338	57	3	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	57	4	chinese	chinese	ADJ
cjal-3338	57	5	application	application	NOUN
cjal-3338	57	6	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	57	7	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	57	8	existing	exist	VERB
cjal-3338	57	9	technology	technology	NOUN
cjal-3338	57	10	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	57	11	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	57	12	fj1	fj1	PROPN
cjal-3338	57	13	t	t	PROPN
cjal-3338	57	14	#	#	PROPN
cjal-3338	57	15	il	il	PROPN
cjal-3338	57	16	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	57	17	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	57	18	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	57	19	analyze	analyze	VERB
cjal-3338	57	20	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	57	21	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cjal-3338	57	22	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	57	23	rationale	rationale	NOUN
cjal-3338	57	24	for	for	ADP
cjal-3338	57	25	refusing	refuse	VERB
cjal-3338	57	26	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	57	27	use	use	NOUN
cjal-3338	57	28	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	57	29	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	57	30	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	57	31	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	58	1	b.	b.	PROPN
cjal-3338	58	2	summary	summary	NOUN
cjal-3338	58	3	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	58	4	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	58	5	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cjal-3338	58	6	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	58	7	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	58	8	chinese	chinese	ADJ
cjal-3338	58	9	infringement	infringement	NOUN
cjal-3338	58	10	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	58	11	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	58	12	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	58	13	invalidity	invalidity	NOUN
cjal-3338	58	14	doctrines	doctrine	NOUN
cjal-3338	58	15	this	this	DET
cjal-3338	58	16	article	article	NOUN
cjal-3338	58	17	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	58	18	best	well	ADV
cjal-3338	58	19	appreciated	appreciate	VERB
cjal-3338	58	20	with	with	ADP
cjal-3338	58	21	an	an	DET
cjal-3338	58	22	understanding	understanding	NOUN
cjal-3338	58	23	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	58	24	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	58	25	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cjal-3338	58	26	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	58	27	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	58	28	chinese	chinese	ADJ
cjal-3338	58	29	doctrines	doctrine	NOUN
cjal-3338	58	30	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	58	31	infringement	infringement	NOUN
cjal-3338	58	32	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	58	33	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	58	34	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	58	35	invalidity	invalidity	NOUN
cjal-3338	58	36	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	59	1	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	59	2	brief	brief	ADJ
cjal-3338	59	3	summary	summary	NOUN
cjal-3338	59	4	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	59	5	these	these	DET
cjal-3338	59	6	doctrines	doctrine	NOUN
cjal-3338	59	7	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	59	8	provided	provide	VERB
cjal-3338	59	9	here	here	ADV
cjal-3338	59	10	;	;	PUNCT
cjal-3338	59	11	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	59	12	reader	reader	NOUN
cjal-3338	59	13	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	59	14	directed	direct	VERB
cjal-3338	59	15	to	to	ADP
cjal-3338	59	16	our	our	PRON
cjal-3338	59	17	previous	previous	ADJ
cjal-3338	59	18	article	article	NOUN
cjal-3338	59	19	for	for	ADP
cjal-3338	59	20	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	59	21	thorough	thorough	ADJ
cjal-3338	59	22	discussion	discussion	NOUN
cjal-3338	59	23	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	60	1	4	4	NUM
cjal-3338	60	2	consistent	consistent	ADJ
cjal-3338	60	3	with	with	ADP
cjal-3338	60	4	international	international	ADJ
cjal-3338	60	5	practice	practice	NOUN
cjal-3338	60	6	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	60	7	'	'	PUNCT
cjal-3338	60	8	both	both	DET
cjal-3338	60	9	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cjal-3338	60	10	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	60	11	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	60	12	chinese	chinese	ADJ
cjal-3338	60	13	laws	law	NOUN
cjal-3338	60	14	bifurcate	bifurcate	VERB
cjal-3338	60	15	infringement	infringement	NOUN
cjal-3338	60	16	into	into	ADP
cjal-3338	60	17	literality	literality	NOUN
cjal-3338	60	18	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	60	19	equivalence	equivalence	NOUN
cjal-3338	60	20	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	61	1	under	under	ADP
cjal-3338	61	2	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cjal-3338	61	3	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	61	4	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	61	5	law	law	NOUN
cjal-3338	61	6	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	61	7	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	61	8	[	[	X
cjal-3338	61	9	t]o	t]o	NOUN
cjal-3338	61	10	establish	establish	VERB
cjal-3338	61	11	literal	literal	ADJ
cjal-3338	61	12	infringement	infringement	NOUN
cjal-3338	61	13	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	61	14	'	'	PUNCT
cjal-3338	61	15	every	every	DET
cjal-3338	61	16	limitation	limitation	NOUN
cjal-3338	61	17	set	set	VERB
cjal-3338	61	18	forth	forth	ADP
cjal-3338	61	19	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	61	20	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	61	21	claim	claim	NOUN
cjal-3338	61	22	must	must	AUX
cjal-3338	61	23	be	be	AUX
cjal-3338	61	24	found	find	VERB
cjal-3338	61	25	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	61	26	an	an	DET
cjal-3338	61	27	accused	accuse	VERB
cjal-3338	61	28	product	product	NOUN
cjal-3338	61	29	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	61	30	exactly	exactly	ADV
cjal-3338	61	31	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	62	1	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	62	2	'	'	PUNCT
cjal-3338	62	3	6	6	NUM
cjal-3338	62	4	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	62	5	determination	determination	NOUN
cjal-3338	62	6	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	62	7	equivalence	equivalence	NOUN
cjal-3338	62	8	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	62	9	based	base	VERB
cjal-3338	62	10	on	on	ADP
cjal-3338	62	11	whether	whether	SCONJ
cjal-3338	62	12	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	62	13	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	62	14	accused	accuse	VERB
cjal-3338	62	15	product	product	NOUN
cjal-3338	62	16	or	or	CCONJ
cjal-3338	62	17	process	process	NOUN
cjal-3338	62	18	contain[s	contain[	VERB
cjal-3338	62	19	]	]	PUNCT
cjal-3338	62	20	elements	element	NOUN
cjal-3338	62	21	identical	identical	ADJ
cjal-3338	62	22	or	or	CCONJ
cjal-3338	62	23	equivalent	equivalent	ADJ
cjal-3338	62	24	to	to	ADP
cjal-3338	62	25	each	each	DET
cjal-3338	62	26	claimed	claim	VERB
cjal-3338	62	27	element	element	NOUN
cjal-3338	62	28	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	63	1	"7	"7	ADJ
cjal-3338	63	2	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	63	3	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	63	4	element	element	NOUN
cjal-3338	63	5	-	-	PUNCT
cjal-3338	63	6	by	by	ADP
cjal-3338	63	7	-	-	PUNCT
cjal-3338	63	8	element	element	NOUN
cjal-3338	63	9	'	'	PUNCT
cjal-3338	63	10	timothy	timothy	PROPN
cjal-3338	63	11	lau	lau	PROPN
cjal-3338	63	12	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	63	13	offensive	offensive	ADJ
cjal-3338	63	14	use	use	NOUN
cjal-3338	63	15	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	63	16	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	63	17	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	63	18	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	63	19	invalidate	invalidate	VERB
cjal-3338	63	20	patents	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	63	21	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	63	22	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cjal-3338	63	23	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	63	24	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	63	25	chinese	chinese	ADJ
cjal-3338	63	26	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	63	27	litigation	litigation	NOUN
cjal-3338	63	28	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	63	29	30	30	NUM
cjal-3338	63	30	ucla	ucla	PROPN
cjal-3338	63	31	pac	pac	PROPN
cjal-3338	63	32	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	63	33	basin	basin	PROPN
cjal-3338	63	34	l.j	l.j	PROPN
cjal-3338	63	35	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	63	36	2	2	NUM
cjal-3338	63	37	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	63	38	2013	2013	NUM
cjal-3338	63	39	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	63	40	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	64	1	3	3	NUM
cjal-3338	64	2	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	64	3	existing	exist	VERB
cjal-3338	64	4	technology	technology	NOUN
cjal-3338	64	5	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	64	6	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	64	7	ritha	ritha	NOUN
cjal-3338	64	8	*	*	PUNCT
cjal-3338	64	9	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	64	10	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	64	11	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	64	12	chinese	chinese	ADJ
cjal-3338	64	13	term	term	NOUN
cjal-3338	64	14	-	-	PUNCT
cjal-3338	64	15	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	64	16	-	-	PUNCT
cjal-3338	64	17	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	64	18	for	for	ADP
cjal-3338	64	19	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	64	20	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	64	21	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	64	22	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	64	23	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	64	24	existing	exist	VERB
cjal-3338	64	25	technology	technology	NOUN
cjal-3338	64	26	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	64	27	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	64	28	correspondingly	correspondingly	ADV
cjal-3338	64	29	refers	refer	VERB
cjal-3338	64	30	to	to	ADP
cjal-3338	64	31	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	64	32	practicing	practice	VERB
cjal-3338	64	33	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	64	34	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	64	35	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	64	36	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	64	37	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	64	38	'	'	PUNCT
cjal-3338	65	1	lau	lau	PROPN
cjal-3338	65	2	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	65	3	supra	supra	PROPN
cjal-3338	65	4	note	note	NOUN
cjal-3338	65	5	2	2	NUM
cjal-3338	65	6	.	.	X
cjal-3338	66	1	for	for	ADP
cjal-3338	66	2	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	66	3	further	further	ADJ
cjal-3338	66	4	discussion	discussion	NOUN
cjal-3338	66	5	on	on	ADP
cjal-3338	66	6	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	66	7	differences	difference	NOUN
cjal-3338	66	8	between	between	ADP
cjal-3338	66	9	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	66	10	chinese	chinese	PROPN
cjal-3338	66	11	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	66	12	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cjal-3338	66	13	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	66	14	doctrines	doctrine	NOUN
cjal-3338	66	15	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	66	16	infringement	infringement	NOUN
cjal-3338	66	17	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	66	18	see	see	VERB
cjal-3338	66	19	patrick	patrick	PROPN
cjal-3338	66	20	king	king	PROPN
cjal-3338	66	21	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	66	22	timothy	timothy	PROPN
cjal-3338	66	23	lau	lau	PROPN
cjal-3338	66	24	&	&	CCONJ
cjal-3338	66	25	gautam	gautam	PROPN
cjal-3338	66	26	kene	kene	PROPN
cjal-3338	66	27	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	66	28	navigating	navigate	VERB
cjal-3338	66	29	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	66	30	shoals	shoal	NOUN
cjal-3338	66	31	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	66	32	joint	joint	ADJ
cjal-3338	66	33	infringement	infringement	NOUN
cjal-3338	66	34	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	66	35	indirect	indirect	ADJ
cjal-3338	66	36	infringement	infringement	NOUN
cjal-3338	66	37	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	66	38	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	66	39	territoriality	territoriality	NOUN
cjal-3338	66	40	doctrines	doctrine	NOUN
cjal-3338	66	41	:	:	PUNCT
cjal-3338	66	42	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	66	43	comparative	comparative	ADJ
cjal-3338	66	44	analysis	analysis	NOUN
cjal-3338	66	45	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	66	46	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	66	47	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	66	48	laws	law	NOUN
cjal-3338	66	49	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	66	50	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	66	51	people	people	NOUN
cjal-3338	66	52	's	's	PART
cjal-3338	66	53	republic	republic	NOUN
cjal-3338	66	54	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	66	55	china	china	PROPN
cjal-3338	66	56	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	66	57	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	66	58	united	united	PROPN
cjal-3338	66	59	states	states	PROPN
cjal-3338	66	60	ofamerica	ofamerica	PROPN
cjal-3338	66	61	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	66	62	25	25	NUM
cjal-3338	66	63	colum	colum	NOUN
cjal-3338	66	64	j.	j.	PROPN
cjal-3338	66	65	asian	asian	PROPN
cjal-3338	66	66	l.	l.	PROPN
cjal-3338	66	67	276	276	NUM
cjal-3338	66	68	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	66	69	2012	2012	NUM
cjal-3338	66	70	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	66	71	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	67	1	1	1	NUM
cjal-3338	67	2	see	see	VERB
cjal-3338	67	3	allan	allan	PROPN
cjal-3338	67	4	m.	m.	PROPN
cjal-3338	67	5	soobert	soobert	PROPN
cjal-3338	67	6	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	67	7	analyzing	analyze	VERB
cjal-3338	67	8	infringement	infringement	NOUN
cjal-3338	67	9	by	by	ADP
cjal-3338	67	10	equivalents	equivalent	NOUN
cjal-3338	67	11	:	:	PUNCT
cjal-3338	67	12	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	67	13	proposal	proposal	NOUN
cjal-3338	67	14	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	67	15	focus	focus	VERB
cjal-3338	67	16	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	67	17	scope	scope	NOUN
cjal-3338	67	18	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	67	19	international	international	ADJ
cjal-3338	67	20	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	67	21	protection	protection	NOUN
cjal-3338	67	22	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	67	23	22	22	NUM
cjal-3338	67	24	rutgers	rutgers	PROPN
cjal-3338	67	25	computer	computer	NOUN
cjal-3338	67	26	&	&	CCONJ
cjal-3338	67	27	tech	tech	PROPN
cjal-3338	67	28	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	68	1	l.j	l.j	PROPN
cjal-3338	68	2	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	68	3	189	189	NUM
cjal-3338	68	4	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	68	5	1996	1996	NUM
cjal-3338	68	6	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	68	7	for	for	ADP
cjal-3338	68	8	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	68	9	survey	survey	NOUN
cjal-3338	68	10	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	68	11	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	68	12	doctrine	doctrine	NOUN
cjal-3338	68	13	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	68	14	equivalents	equivalent	NOUN
cjal-3338	68	15	within	within	ADP
cjal-3338	68	16	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	68	17	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	68	18	laws	law	NOUN
cjal-3338	68	19	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	68	20	different	different	ADJ
cjal-3338	68	21	countries	country	NOUN
cjal-3338	68	22	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	69	1	6	6	NUM
cjal-3338	69	2	becton	becton	PROPN
cjal-3338	69	3	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	69	4	dickinson	dickinson	PROPN
cjal-3338	69	5	&	&	CCONJ
cjal-3338	69	6	co.	co.	PROPN
cjal-3338	69	7	v.	v.	PROPN
cjal-3338	69	8	tyco	tyco	PROPN
cjal-3338	69	9	healthcare	healthcare	PROPN
cjal-3338	69	10	grp	grp	PROPN
cjal-3338	69	11	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	69	12	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	69	13	616	616	NUM
cjal-3338	69	14	f.3	f.3	NOUN
cjal-3338	69	15	d	d	X
cjal-3338	69	16	1249	1249	NUM
cjal-3338	69	17	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	69	18	1253	1253	NUM
cjal-3338	69	19	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	69	20	fed	fed	PROPN
cjal-3338	69	21	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	69	22	cir	cir	PROPN
cjal-3338	69	23	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	69	24	2010	2010	NUM
cjal-3338	69	25	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	69	26	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	69	27	citation	citation	NOUN
cjal-3338	69	28	omitted	omit	VERB
cjal-3338	69	29	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	69	30	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	70	1	7	7	NUM
cjal-3338	70	2	warner	warner	PROPN
cjal-3338	70	3	-	-	PUNCT
cjal-3338	70	4	jenkinson	jenkinson	PROPN
cjal-3338	70	5	v.	v.	PROPN
cjal-3338	70	6	hilton	hilton	PROPN
cjal-3338	70	7	davis	davis	PROPN
cjal-3338	70	8	chem	chem	PROPN
cjal-3338	70	9	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	71	1	co.	co.	PROPN
cjal-3338	71	2	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	71	3	520	520	NUM
cjal-3338	71	4	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cjal-3338	71	5	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	71	6	17	17	NUM
cjal-3338	71	7	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	71	8	40	40	NUM
cjal-3338	71	9	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	71	10	1997	1997	NUM
cjal-3338	71	11	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	71	12	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	72	1	defensive	defensive	ADJ
cjal-3338	72	2	use	use	NOUN
cjal-3338	72	3	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	72	4	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	72	5	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	72	6	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	72	7	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cjal-3338	72	8	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	72	9	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	72	10	chinese	chinese	PROPN
cjal-3338	72	11	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	72	12	litigation	litigation	NOUN
cjal-3338	72	13	57	57	NUM
cjal-3338	72	14	comparison	comparison	NOUN
cjal-3338	72	15	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	72	16	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	72	17	accused	accuse	VERB
cjal-3338	72	18	product	product	NOUN
cjal-3338	72	19	with	with	ADP
cjal-3338	72	20	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	72	21	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	72	22	claim	claim	NOUN
cjal-3338	72	23	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	72	24	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cjal-3338	72	25	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	72	26	courts	court	NOUN
cjal-3338	72	27	may	may	AUX
cjal-3338	72	28	apply	apply	VERB
cjal-3338	72	29	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	72	30	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	72	31	triple	triple	ADJ
cjal-3338	72	32	identity	identity	NOUN
cjal-3338	72	33	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	72	34	test	test	NOUN
cjal-3338	72	35	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	72	36	that	that	ADV
cjal-3338	72	37	is	is	ADV
cjal-3338	72	38	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	72	39	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	72	40	whether	whether	SCONJ
cjal-3338	72	41	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	72	42	substitute	substitute	NOUN
cjal-3338	72	43	element	element	NOUN
cjal-3338	72	44	matches	match	VERB
cjal-3338	72	45	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	72	46	function	function	NOUN
cjal-3338	72	47	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	72	48	way	way	NOUN
cjal-3338	72	49	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	72	50	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	72	51	result	result	NOUN
cjal-3338	72	52	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	72	53	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	72	54	claimed	claim	VERB
cjal-3338	72	55	element	element	NOUN
cjal-3338	72	56	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	72	57	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	72	58	or	or	CCONJ
cjal-3338	72	59	alternatively	alternatively	ADV
cjal-3338	72	60	ask	ask	VERB
cjal-3338	72	61	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	72	62	whether	whether	SCONJ
cjal-3338	72	63	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	72	64	substitute	substitute	PROPN
cjal-3338	72	65	element	element	NOUN
cjal-3338	72	66	plays	play	VERB
cjal-3338	72	67	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	72	68	role	role	NOUN
cjal-3338	72	69	substantially	substantially	ADV
cjal-3338	72	70	different	different	ADJ
cjal-3338	72	71	from	from	ADP
cjal-3338	72	72	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	72	73	claimed	claim	VERB
cjal-3338	72	74	element	element	NOUN
cjal-3338	72	75	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	73	1	"8	"8	PROPN
cjal-3338	73	2	according	accord	VERB
cjal-3338	73	3	to	to	ADP
cjal-3338	73	4	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	73	5	judicial	judicial	ADJ
cjal-3338	73	6	explanations	explanation	NOUN
cjal-3338	73	7	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	73	8	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	73	9	chinese	chinese	ADJ
cjal-3338	73	10	supreme	supreme	PROPN
cjal-3338	73	11	people	people	PROPN
cjal-3338	73	12	's	's	PART
cjal-3338	73	13	court	court	NOUN
cjal-3338	73	14	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	73	15	infringement	infringement	NOUN
cjal-3338	73	16	includes	include	VERB
cjal-3338	73	17	literal	literal	ADJ
cjal-3338	73	18	9	9	NUM
cjal-3338	73	19	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	73	20	hfl	hfl	NOUN
cjal-3338	73	21	r-	r-	X
cjal-3338	73	22	]	]	PUNCT
cjal-3338	73	23	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	73	24	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	73	25	equivalent	equivalent	ADJ
cjal-3338	73	26	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	73	27	4	4	NUM
cjal-3338	73	28	[	[	NOUN
cjal-3338	73	29	]	]	X
cjal-3338	73	30	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	73	31	components	component	NOUN
cjal-3338	73	32	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	73	33	'	'	PUNCT
cjal-3338	74	1	°	°	PUNCT
cjal-3338	75	1	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	75	2	literal	literal	ADJ
cjal-3338	75	3	infringement	infringement	NOUN
cjal-3338	75	4	inquiry	inquiry	NOUN
cjal-3338	75	5	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	75	6	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	75	7	same	same	ADJ
cjal-3338	75	8	as	as	ADP
cjal-3338	75	9	that	that	PRON
cjal-3338	75	10	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	75	11	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	75	12	united	united	PROPN
cjal-3338	75	13	states	states	PROPN
cjal-3338	75	14	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	76	1	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	76	2	contrast	contrast	NOUN
cjal-3338	76	3	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	76	4	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	76	5	determining	determine	VERB
cjal-3338	76	6	equivalence	equivalence	NOUN
cjal-3338	76	7	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	76	8	chinese	chinese	ADJ
cjal-3338	76	9	people	people	NOUN
cjal-3338	76	10	's	's	PART
cjal-3338	76	11	courts	court	NOUN
cjal-3338	76	12	not	not	PART
cjal-3338	76	13	only	only	ADV
cjal-3338	76	14	apply	apply	VERB
cjal-3338	76	15	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	76	16	triple	triple	ADJ
cjal-3338	76	17	identity	identity	NOUN
cjal-3338	76	18	test	test	NOUN
cjal-3338	76	19	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	76	20	that	that	ADV
cjal-3338	76	21	is	is	ADV
cjal-3338	76	22	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	76	23	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	76	24	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	76	25	equivalent	equivalent	ADJ
cjal-3338	76	26	feature	feature	NOUN
cjal-3338	76	27	...	...	PUNCT
cjal-3338	76	28	uses	use	VERB
cjal-3338	76	29	basically	basically	ADV
cjal-3338	76	30	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	76	31	identical	identical	ADJ
cjal-3338	76	32	way	way	NOUN
cjal-3338	76	33	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	76	34	effectuates	effectuate	NOUN
cjal-3338	76	35	basically	basically	ADV
cjal-3338	76	36	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	76	37	identical	identical	ADJ
cjal-3338	76	38	function	function	NOUN
cjal-3338	76	39	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	76	40	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	76	41	accomplishes	accomplish	VERB
cjal-3338	76	42	basically	basically	ADV
cjal-3338	76	43	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	76	44	identical	identical	ADJ
cjal-3338	76	45	effect	effect	NOUN
cjal-3338	76	46	as	as	ADP
cjal-3338	76	47	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	76	48	claimed	claim	VERB
cjal-3338	76	49	technical	technical	ADJ
cjal-3338	76	50	feature	feature	NOUN
cjal-3338	76	51	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	76	52	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	76	53	but	but	CCONJ
cjal-3338	76	54	additionally	additionally	ADV
cjal-3338	76	55	impose	impose	VERB
cjal-3338	76	56	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	76	57	requirement	requirement	NOUN
cjal-3338	76	58	that	that	SCONJ
cjal-3338	76	59	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	76	60	equivalent	equivalent	ADJ
cjal-3338	76	61	feature	feature	NOUN
cjal-3338	76	62	be	be	VERB
cjal-3338	76	63	one	one	NUM
cjal-3338	76	64	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	76	65	'	'	PUNCT
cjal-3338	76	66	which	which	PRON
cjal-3338	76	67	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	76	68	person	person	NOUN
cjal-3338	76	69	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	76	70	ordinary	ordinary	ADJ
cjal-3338	76	71	skill	skill	NOUN
cjal-3338	76	72	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	76	73	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	76	74	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	76	75	would	would	AUX
cjal-3338	76	76	be	be	AUX
cjal-3338	76	77	able	able	ADJ
cjal-3338	76	78	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	76	79	conceive	conceive	VERB
cjal-3338	76	80	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	76	81	without	without	ADP
cjal-3338	76	82	inventive	inventive	ADJ
cjal-3338	76	83	labor	labor	NOUN
cjal-3338	76	84	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	76	85	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	76	86	i	i	NOUN
cjal-3338	76	87	_	_	PUNCT
cjal-3338	76	88	..	..	PUNCT
cjal-3338	76	89	m	m	X
cjal-3338	76	90	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	76	91	again	again	ADV
cjal-3338	76	92	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	76	93	consistent	consistent	ADJ
cjal-3338	76	94	with	with	ADP
cjal-3338	76	95	international	international	ADJ
cjal-3338	76	96	practice,'2	practice,'2	PROPN
cjal-3338	76	97	both	both	DET
cjal-3338	76	98	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cjal-3338	76	99	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	76	100	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	76	101	chinese	chinese	ADJ
cjal-3338	76	102	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	76	103	laws	law	NOUN
cjal-3338	76	104	bifurcate	bifurcate	VERB
cjal-3338	76	105	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	76	106	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	76	107	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	76	108	invalidity	invalidity	NOUN
cjal-3338	76	109	determination	determination	NOUN
cjal-3338	76	110	into	into	ADP
cjal-3338	76	111	novelty	novelty	NOUN
cjal-3338	76	112	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	76	113	obviousness	obviousness	NOUN
cjal-3338	76	114	/	/	SYM
cjal-3338	76	115	inventiveness	inventiveness	NOUN
cjal-3338	76	116	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	77	1	under	under	ADP
cjal-3338	77	2	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cjal-3338	77	3	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	77	4	law	law	PROPN
cjal-3338	77	5	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	77	6	invalidation	invalidation	NOUN
cjal-3338	77	7	on	on	ADP
cjal-3338	77	8	novelty	novelty	NOUN
cjal-3338	77	9	grounds	ground	NOUN
cjal-3338	77	10	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	77	11	requires	require	VERB
cjal-3338	77	12	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	77	13	presence	presence	NOUN
cjal-3338	77	14	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	77	15	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	77	16	single	single	ADJ
cjal-3338	77	17	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	77	18	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	77	19	disclosure	disclosure	NOUN
cjal-3338	77	20	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	77	21	all	all	DET
cjal-3338	77	22	elements	element	NOUN
cjal-3338	77	23	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	77	24	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	77	25	claimed	claim	VERB
cjal-3338	77	26	invention	invention	NOUN
cjal-3338	77	27	arranged	arrange	VERB
cjal-3338	77	28	as	as	ADP
cjal-3338	77	29	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	77	30	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	77	31	claim	claim	NOUN
cjal-3338	77	32	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	78	1	"'3	"'3	PUNCT
cjal-3338	78	2	where	where	SCONJ
cjal-3338	78	3	there	there	PRON
cjal-3338	78	4	is	be	VERB
cjal-3338	78	5	no	no	DET
cjal-3338	78	6	such	such	ADJ
cjal-3338	78	7	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	78	8	single	single	ADJ
cjal-3338	78	9	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	78	10	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	78	11	disclosure	disclosure	NOUN
cjal-3338	78	12	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	78	13	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	78	14	all	all	DET
cjal-3338	78	15	claim	claim	NOUN
cjal-3338	78	16	limitations	limitation	NOUN
cjal-3338	78	17	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	78	18	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	78	19	defendant	defendant	NOUN
cjal-3338	78	20	must	must	AUX
cjal-3338	78	21	resort	resort	VERB
cjal-3338	78	22	to	to	ADP
cjal-3338	78	23	obviousness	obviousness	NOUN
cjal-3338	78	24	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	78	25	establish	establish	VERB
cjal-3338	78	26	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	78	27	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	78	28	invalidity	invalidity	NOUN
cjal-3338	78	29	:	:	PUNCT
cjal-3338	78	30	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	78	31	scope	scope	NOUN
cjal-3338	78	32	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	78	33	content	content	NOUN
cjal-3338	78	34	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	78	35	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	78	36	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	78	37	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	78	38	are	be	AUX
cjal-3338	78	39	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	78	40	be	be	AUX
cjal-3338	78	41	determined	determine	VERB
cjal-3338	78	42	;	;	PUNCT
cjal-3338	78	43	differences	difference	NOUN
cjal-3338	78	44	between	between	ADP
cjal-3338	78	45	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	78	46	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	78	47	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	78	48	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	78	49	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	78	50	claims	claim	NOUN
cjal-3338	78	51	at	at	ADP
cjal-3338	78	52	issue	issue	NOUN
cjal-3338	78	53	are	be	AUX
cjal-3338	78	54	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	78	55	be	be	AUX
cjal-3338	78	56	ascertained	ascertain	VERB
cjal-3338	78	57	;	;	PUNCT
cjal-3338	78	58	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	78	59	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	78	60	level	level	NOUN
cjal-3338	78	61	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	78	62	ordinary	ordinary	ADJ
cjal-3338	78	63	skill	skill	NOUN
cjal-3338	78	64	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	78	65	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	78	66	pertinent	pertinent	ADJ
cjal-3338	78	67	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	78	68	resolved	resolve	VERB
cjal-3338	78	69	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	79	1	against	against	ADP
cjal-3338	79	2	this	this	DET
cjal-3338	79	3	background	background	NOUN
cjal-3338	79	4	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	79	5	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	79	6	obviousness	obviousness	NOUN
cjal-3338	79	7	or	or	CCONJ
cjal-3338	79	8	nonobviousness	nonobviousness	NOUN
cjal-3338	79	9	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	79	10	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	79	11	subject	subject	NOUN
cjal-3338	79	12	matter	matter	NOUN
cjal-3338	79	13	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	79	14	determined	determine	VERB
cjal-3338	79	15	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	80	1	'4	'4	PROPN
cjal-3338	80	2	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cjal-3338	80	3	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	80	4	courts	court	NOUN
cjal-3338	80	5	have	have	AUX
cjal-3338	80	6	held	hold	VERB
cjal-3338	80	7	that	that	SCONJ
cjal-3338	80	8	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	80	9	evidence	evidence	NOUN
cjal-3338	80	10	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	80	11	secondary	secondary	ADJ
cjal-3338	80	12	considerations	consideration	NOUN
cjal-3338	80	13	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	80	14	such	such	ADJ
cjal-3338	80	15	as	as	ADP
cjal-3338	80	16	commercial	commercial	ADJ
cjal-3338	80	17	success	success	NOUN
cjal-3338	80	18	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	80	19	long	long	ADV
cjal-3338	80	20	-	-	PUNCT
cjal-3338	80	21	felt	feel	VERB
cjal-3338	80	22	but	but	CCONJ
cjal-3338	80	23	unresolved	unresolved	ADJ
cjal-3338	80	24	need	need	NOUN
cjal-3338	80	25	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	80	26	failure	failure	NOUN
cjal-3338	80	27	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	80	28	others	other	NOUN
cjal-3338	80	29	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	80	30	copying	copying	NOUN
cjal-3338	80	31	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	80	32	8	8	NUM
cjal-3338	80	33	i	i	PROPN
cjal-3338	80	34	d.	d.	PROPN
cjal-3338	80	35	'	'	PUNCT
cjal-3338	80	36	technically	technically	ADV
cjal-3338	80	37	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	80	38	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	80	39	translation	translation	NOUN
cjal-3338	80	40	for	for	ADP
cjal-3338	80	41	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	80	42	*	*	NOUN
cjal-3338	80	43	h	h	NOUN
cjal-3338	80	44	]	]	X
cjal-3338	80	45	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	80	46	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	80	47	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	80	48	identical	identical	ADJ
cjal-3338	80	49	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	80	50	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	81	1	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	81	2	chinese	chinese	ADJ
cjal-3338	81	3	counterpart	counterpart	NOUN
cjal-3338	81	4	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	81	5	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	81	6	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cjal-3338	81	7	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	81	8	literal	literal	ADJ
cjal-3338	81	9	infringement	infringement	NOUN
cjal-3338	81	10	doctrine	doctrine	NOUN
cjal-3338	81	11	should	should	AUX
cjal-3338	81	12	therefore	therefore	ADV
cjal-3338	81	13	more	more	ADV
cjal-3338	81	14	properly	properly	ADV
cjal-3338	81	15	be	be	AUX
cjal-3338	81	16	translated	translate	VERB
cjal-3338	81	17	as	as	ADP
cjal-3338	81	18	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	81	19	identical	identical	ADJ
cjal-3338	81	20	infringement	infringement	NOUN
cjal-3338	81	21	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	81	22	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	82	1	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	82	2	words	word	NOUN
cjal-3338	82	3	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	82	4	literal	literal	ADJ
cjal-3338	82	5	infringement	infringement	NOUN
cjal-3338	82	6	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	82	7	are	be	AUX
cjal-3338	82	8	used	use	VERB
cjal-3338	82	9	here	here	ADV
cjal-3338	82	10	because	because	SCONJ
cjal-3338	82	11	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	82	12	use	use	NOUN
cjal-3338	82	13	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	82	14	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	82	15	literal	literal	ADJ
cjal-3338	82	16	infringement	infringement	NOUN
cjal-3338	82	17	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	82	18	has	have	AUX
cjal-3338	82	19	become	become	VERB
cjal-3338	82	20	entrenched	entrenched	ADJ
cjal-3338	82	21	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	82	22	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	82	23	legal	legal	ADJ
cjal-3338	82	24	literature	literature	NOUN
cjal-3338	82	25	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	83	1	'	'	PUNCT
cjal-3338	84	1	o	o	NOUN
cjal-3338	84	2	guanyu	guanyu	PROPN
cjal-3338	84	3	shenli	shenli	VERB
cjal-3338	84	4	zhuanli	zhuanli	PROPN
cjal-3338	84	5	jiufen	jiufen	PROPN
cjal-3338	84	6	anjian	anjian	ADJ
cjal-3338	84	7	shiyong	shiyong	ADJ
cjal-3338	84	8	falu	falu	PROPN
cjal-3338	84	9	wenti	wenti	X
cjal-3338	84	10	de	de	X
cjal-3338	84	11	ruogan	ruogan	PROPN
cjal-3338	84	12	guiding	guiding	NOUN
cjal-3338	84	13	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	84	14	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	84	15	-	-	PUNCT
cjal-3338	84	16	t-	t-	NOUN
cjal-3338	84	17	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	84	18	9	9	NUM
cjal-3338	84	19	-	-	PUNCT
cjal-3338	84	20	vd9	vd9	NOUN
cjal-3338	84	21	t3{i1jtm	t3{i1jtm	NOUN
cjal-3338	84	22	v*iai	v*iai	VERB
cjal-3338	84	23	mm	mm	PROPN
cjal-3338	84	24	j	j	PROPN
cjal-3338	84	25	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	85	1	[	[	X
cjal-3338	85	2	several	several	ADJ
cjal-3338	85	3	provisions	provision	NOUN
cjal-3338	85	4	on	on	ADP
cjal-3338	85	5	issues	issue	NOUN
cjal-3338	85	6	concerning	concern	VERB
cjal-3338	85	7	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	85	8	law	law	NOUN
cjal-3338	85	9	applicable	applicable	ADJ
cjal-3338	85	10	to	to	ADP
cjal-3338	85	11	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	85	12	adjudication	adjudication	NOUN
cjal-3338	85	13	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	85	14	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	85	15	disputes	dispute	NOUN
cjal-3338	85	16	]	]	PUNCT
cjal-3338	85	17	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	85	18	promulgated	promulgate	VERB
cjal-3338	85	19	by	by	ADP
cjal-3338	85	20	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	85	21	sup	sup	NOUN
cjal-3338	85	22	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	86	1	people	people	NOUN
cjal-3338	86	2	's	's	PART
cjal-3338	86	3	ct	ct	PROPN
cjal-3338	86	4	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	86	5	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	86	6	june	june	PROPN
cjal-3338	86	7	19	19	NUM
cjal-3338	86	8	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	86	9	2ooi	2ooi	NOUN
cjal-3338	86	10	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	86	11	effective	effective	ADJ
cjal-3338	86	12	july	july	PROPN
cjal-3338	86	13	1	1	NUM
cjal-3338	86	14	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	86	15	2001	2001	NUM
cjal-3338	86	16	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	86	17	2001	2001	NUM
cjal-3338	86	18	sup	sup	NOUN
cjal-3338	86	19	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	87	1	people	people	NOUN
cjal-3338	87	2	's	's	PART
cjal-3338	87	3	ct	ct	PROPN
cjal-3338	87	4	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	87	5	gaz	gaz	PROPN
cjal-3338	87	6	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	87	7	130	130	NUM
cjal-3338	87	8	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	87	9	china	china	PROPN
cjal-3338	87	10	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	88	1	[	[	X
cjal-3338	88	2	hereinafter	hereinafter	NOUN
cjal-3338	88	3	2001	2001	NUM
cjal-3338	88	4	judicial	judicial	ADJ
cjal-3338	88	5	explanations	explanation	NOUN
cjal-3338	88	6	]	]	PUNCT
cjal-3338	88	7	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	88	8	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	88	9	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	89	1	17	17	NUM
cjal-3338	89	2	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	90	1	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	90	2	i	i	PRON
cjal-3338	90	3	d.	d.	PROPN
cjal-3338	90	4	12	12	NUM
cjal-3338	90	5	trips	trip	NOUN
cjal-3338	90	6	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	90	7	supra	supra	PROPN
cjal-3338	90	8	note	note	VERB
cjal-3338	90	9	i	i	PROPN
cjal-3338	90	10	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	90	11	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	90	12	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	91	1	27	27	NUM
cjal-3338	91	2	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	92	1	'	'	NUM
cjal-3338	92	2	3	3	NUM
cjal-3338	92	3	connell	connell	NOUN
cjal-3338	92	4	v.	v.	ADP
cjal-3338	92	5	sears	sears	PROPN
cjal-3338	92	6	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	92	7	roebuck	roebuck	PROPN
cjal-3338	92	8	&	&	CCONJ
cjal-3338	92	9	co.	co.	PROPN
cjal-3338	92	10	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	92	11	722	722	NUM
cjal-3338	92	12	f.2d	f.2d	NOUN
cjal-3338	92	13	1542	1542	NUM
cjal-3338	92	14	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	92	15	1548	1548	NUM
cjal-3338	92	16	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	92	17	fed	fed	PROPN
cjal-3338	92	18	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	92	19	cir	cir	PROPN
cjal-3338	92	20	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	92	21	1984	1984	NUM
cjal-3338	92	22	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	92	23	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	93	1	'	'	PUNCT
cjal-3338	93	2	4	4	NUM
cjal-3338	93	3	graham	graham	PROPN
cjal-3338	93	4	v.	v.	PROPN
cjal-3338	93	5	john	john	PROPN
cjal-3338	93	6	deere	deere	PROPN
cjal-3338	93	7	co.	co.	PROPN
cjal-3338	93	8	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	93	9	383	383	NUM
cjal-3338	93	10	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cjal-3338	93	11	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	93	12	1	1	NUM
cjal-3338	93	13	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	93	14	17	17	NUM
cjal-3338	93	15	-	-	SYM
cjal-3338	93	16	18	18	NUM
cjal-3338	93	17	1966	1966	NUM
cjal-3338	93	18	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	93	19	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	94	1	58	58	NUM
cjal-3338	94	2	columbia	columbia	PROPN
cjal-3338	94	3	journal	journal	PROPN
cjal-3338	94	4	ofasian	ofasian	ADJ
cjal-3338	94	5	law	law	NOUN
cjal-3338	94	6	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	94	7	vol	vol	NOUN
cjal-3338	94	8	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	94	9	27	27	NUM
cjal-3338	94	10	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	94	11	no	no	INTJ
cjal-3338	94	12	.	.	NOUN
cjal-3338	94	13	1	1	NUM
cjal-3338	94	14	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	94	15	2o3	2o3	NUM
cjal-3338	94	16	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	94	17	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	94	18	unexpected	unexpected	ADJ
cjal-3338	94	19	results	result	NOUN
cjal-3338	94	20	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	94	21	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	94	22	probative	probative	ADJ
cjal-3338	94	23	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	94	24	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	94	25	obviousness	obviousness	ADJ
cjal-3338	94	26	analysis	analysis	NOUN
cjal-3338	94	27	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	95	1	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	95	2	'	'	PUNCT
cjal-3338	95	3	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	95	4	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	95	5	overall	overall	ADJ
cjal-3338	95	6	approach	approach	NOUN
cjal-3338	95	7	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	95	8	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	95	9	expansive	expansive	ADJ
cjal-3338	95	10	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	95	11	flexible	flexible	ADJ
cjal-3338	95	12	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	95	13	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	95	14	'	'	PUNCT
cjal-3338	95	15	6	6	NUM
cjal-3338	95	16	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	95	17	chinese	chinese	ADJ
cjal-3338	95	18	novelty	novelty	NOUN
cjal-3338	95	19	analysis	analysis	NOUN
cjal-3338	95	20	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	95	21	roughly	roughly	ADV
cjal-3338	95	22	similar	similar	ADJ
cjal-3338	95	23	to	to	ADP
cjal-3338	95	24	its	its	PRON
cjal-3338	95	25	american	american	ADJ
cjal-3338	95	26	counterpart	counterpart	NOUN
cjal-3338	95	27	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	96	1	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	96	2	people	people	NOUN
cjal-3338	96	3	's	's	PART
cjal-3338	96	4	courts	court	NOUN
cjal-3338	96	5	compare	compare	VERB
cjal-3338	96	6	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	96	7	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	96	8	claim	claim	NOUN
cjal-3338	96	9	with	with	ADP
cjal-3338	96	10	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	96	11	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	96	12	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	96	13	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	96	14	identify	identify	VERB
cjal-3338	96	15	differentiating	differentiate	VERB
cjal-3338	96	16	technical	technical	ADJ
cjal-3338	96	17	features	feature	NOUN
cjal-3338	96	18	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	96	19	ex	ex	NOUN
cjal-3338	96	20	1'1	1'1	NUM
cjal-3338	96	21	]	]	X
cjal-3338	96	22	l	l	NOUN
cjal-3338	96	23	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	96	24	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	97	1	lack	lack	NOUN
cjal-3338	97	2	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	97	3	novelty	novelty	NOUN
cjal-3338	97	4	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	97	5	established	establish	VERB
cjal-3338	97	6	by	by	ADP
cjal-3338	97	7	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	97	8	lack	lack	NOUN
cjal-3338	97	9	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	97	10	differentiating	differentiate	VERB
cjal-3338	97	11	technical	technical	ADJ
cjal-3338	97	12	features	feature	NOUN
cjal-3338	97	13	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	98	1	'	'	PUNCT
cjal-3338	98	2	7	7	NUM
cjal-3338	98	3	however	however	ADV
cjal-3338	98	4	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	98	5	chinese	chinese	ADJ
cjal-3338	98	6	people	people	NOUN
cjal-3338	98	7	's	's	PART
cjal-3338	98	8	courts	court	NOUN
cjal-3338	98	9	will	will	AUX
cjal-3338	98	10	not	not	PART
cjal-3338	98	11	find	find	VERB
cjal-3338	98	12	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	98	13	differentiating	differentiate	VERB
cjal-3338	98	14	technical	technical	ADJ
cjal-3338	98	15	feature	feature	NOUN
cjal-3338	98	16	where	where	SCONJ
cjal-3338	98	17	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	98	18	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	98	19	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	98	20	has	have	VERB
cjal-3338	98	21	disclosures	disclosure	NOUN
cjal-3338	98	22	similar	similar	ADJ
cjal-3338	98	23	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	98	24	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	98	25	structure	structure	NOUN
cjal-3338	98	26	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	98	27	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	98	28	a	a	NOUN
cjal-3338	98	29	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	98	30	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	98	31	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	98	32	technical	technical	ADJ
cjal-3338	98	33	effects	effect	NOUN
cjal-3338	98	34	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	98	35	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	98	36	r	r	NOUN
cjal-3338	98	37	i	i	PRON
cjal-3338	98	38	kw	kw	VERB
cjal-3338	98	39	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	98	40	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	98	41	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	98	42	technical	technical	ADJ
cjal-3338	98	43	problem	problem	NOUN
cjal-3338	98	44	solved	solve	VERB
cjal-3338	98	45	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	98	46	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	98	47	s	s	NOUN
cjal-3338	98	48	;	;	PUNCT
cjal-3338	98	49	m	m	VERB
cjal-3338	98	50	4	4	NUM
cjal-3338	98	51	*	*	NUM
cjal-3338	98	52	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	98	53	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	98	54	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	98	55	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	98	56	role	role	NOUN
cjal-3338	98	57	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	98	58	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	98	59	f$ffl	f$ffl	NOUN
cjal-3338	98	60	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	98	61	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	98	62	mirroring	mirror	VERB
cjal-3338	98	63	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	98	64	equivalence	equivalence	NOUN
cjal-3338	98	65	test	test	NOUN
cjal-3338	98	66	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	98	67	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	98	68	way	way	NOUN
cjal-3338	98	69	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	98	70	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	98	71	f	f	X
cjal-3338	98	72	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	98	73	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	98	74	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	98	75	function	function	NOUN
cjal-3338	98	76	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	98	77	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	98	78	vjfj	vjfj	PROPN
cjal-3338	98	79	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	98	80	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	98	81	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	98	82	effect	effect	NOUN
cjal-3338	98	83	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	98	84	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	98	85	a'a	a'a	NOUN
cjal-3338	98	86	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	98	87	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	99	1	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	99	2	chinese	chinese	ADJ
cjal-3338	99	3	novelty	novelty	NOUN
cjal-3338	99	4	doctrine	doctrine	NOUN
cjal-3338	99	5	therefore	therefore	ADV
cjal-3338	99	6	extends	extend	VERB
cjal-3338	99	7	beyond	beyond	ADP
cjal-3338	99	8	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	99	9	literal	literal	ADJ
cjal-3338	99	10	scope	scope	NOUN
cjal-3338	99	11	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	99	12	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	99	13	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	99	14	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	99	15	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	100	1	under	under	ADP
cjal-3338	100	2	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	100	3	chinese	chinese	PROPN
cjal-3338	100	4	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	100	5	law	law	NOUN
cjal-3338	100	6	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	100	7	for	for	ADP
cjal-3338	100	8	an	an	DET
cjal-3338	100	9	invention	invention	NOUN
cjal-3338	100	10	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	100	11	have	have	AUX
cjal-3338	100	12	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	100	13	requisite	requisite	ADJ
cjal-3338	100	14	inventiveness	inventiveness	NOUN
cjal-3338	100	15	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	100	16	it	it	PRON
cjal-3338	100	17	must	must	AUX
cjal-3338	100	18	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	100	19	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	100	20	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	100	21	comparison	comparison	NOUN
cjal-3338	100	22	to	to	ADP
cjal-3338	100	23	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	100	24	existing	exist	VERB
cjal-3338	100	25	technology	technology	NOUN
cjal-3338	100	26	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	100	27	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	100	28	possess	possess	NOUN
cjal-3338	100	29	:	:	PUNCT
cjal-3338	100	30	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	100	31	i	i	NOUN
cjal-3338	100	32	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	100	33	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	100	34	prominent	prominent	ADJ
cjal-3338	100	35	substantive	substantive	ADJ
cjal-3338	100	36	features	feature	NOUN
cjal-3338	100	37	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	100	38	;	;	PUNCT
cjal-3338	100	39	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	100	40	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	100	41	2	2	X
cjal-3338	100	42	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	100	43	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	100	44	notable	notable	ADJ
cjal-3338	100	45	improvement	improvement	NOUN
cjal-3338	100	46	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	101	1	..	..	PUNCT
cjal-3338	102	1	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	102	2	inquiry	inquiry	NOUN
cjal-3338	102	3	for	for	ADP
cjal-3338	102	4	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	102	5	first	first	ADJ
cjal-3338	102	6	prong	prong	NOUN
cjal-3338	102	7	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	102	8	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	102	9	substantive	substantive	ADJ
cjal-3338	102	10	features	feature	NOUN
cjal-3338	102	11	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	102	12	follows	follow	VERB
cjal-3338	102	13	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	102	14	general	general	ADJ
cjal-3338	102	15	framework	framework	NOUN
cjal-3338	102	16	as	as	ADP
cjal-3338	102	17	articulated	articulate	VERB
cjal-3338	102	18	below	below	ADV
cjal-3338	102	19	by	by	ADP
cjal-3338	102	20	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	102	21	beijing	beijing	PROPN
cjal-3338	102	22	high	high	PROPN
cjal-3338	102	23	people	people	NOUN
cjal-3338	102	24	's	's	PART
cjal-3338	102	25	court	court	NOUN
cjal-3338	102	26	:	:	PUNCT
cjal-3338	102	27	when	when	SCONJ
cjal-3338	102	28	determining	determine	VERB
cjal-3338	102	29	whether	whether	SCONJ
cjal-3338	102	30	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	102	31	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	102	32	claim	claim	NOUN
cjal-3338	102	33	possesses	possess	VERB
cjal-3338	102	34	inventiveness	inventiveness	NOUN
cjal-3338	102	35	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	102	36	[	[	X
cjal-3338	102	37	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	102	38	people	people	NOUN
cjal-3338	102	39	's	's	PART
cjal-3338	102	40	court	court	NOUN
cjal-3338	102	41	]	]	PUNCT
cjal-3338	102	42	should	should	AUX
cjal-3338	102	43	compare	compare	VERB
cjal-3338	102	44	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	102	45	claimed	claim	VERB
cjal-3338	102	46	technical	technical	ADJ
cjal-3338	102	47	solution	solution	NOUN
cjal-3338	102	48	with	with	ADP
cjal-3338	102	49	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	102	50	most	most	ADJ
cjal-3338	102	51	proximate	proximate	VERB
cjal-3338	102	52	existing	exist	VERB
cjal-3338	102	53	technology	technology	NOUN
cjal-3338	102	54	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	102	55	alid	alid	ADJ
cjal-3338	102	56	w)w	w)w	ADJ
cjal-3338	102	57	f'r	f'r	PROPN
cjal-3338	102	58	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	102	59	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	102	60	identify	identify	VERB
cjal-3338	102	61	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	102	62	differentiating	differentiate	VERB
cjal-3338	102	63	technical	technical	ADJ
cjal-3338	102	64	features	feature	NOUN
cjal-3338	102	65	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	102	66	i	i	PRON
cjal-3338	102	67	m1j4a	m1j4a	X
cjal-3338	102	68	*	*	NOUN
cjal-3338	102	69	*	*	PUNCT
cjal-3338	102	70	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	102	71	between	between	ADP
cjal-3338	102	72	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	102	73	two	two	NUM
cjal-3338	102	74	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	102	75	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	102	76	determine	determine	VERB
cjal-3338	102	77	whether	whether	SCONJ
cjal-3338	102	78	or	or	CCONJ
cjal-3338	102	79	not	not	PART
cjal-3338	102	80	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	102	81	existing	exist	VERB
cjal-3338	102	82	technology	technology	NOUN
cjal-3338	102	83	as	as	ADP
cjal-3338	102	84	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	102	85	whole	whole	ADJ
cjal-3338	102	86	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	102	87	.#_k-	.#_k-	PUNCT
cjal-3338	102	88	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	102	89	provides	provide	VERB
cjal-3338	102	90	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	102	91	suggestion	suggestion	NOUN
cjal-3338	102	92	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	102	93	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	102	94	t	t	NOUN
cjal-3338	102	95	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	102	96	for	for	ADP
cjal-3338	102	97	applying	apply	VERB
cjal-3338	102	98	these	these	DET
cjal-3338	102	99	differentiating	differentiate	VERB
cjal-3338	102	100	technical	technical	ADJ
cjal-3338	102	101	features	feature	NOUN
cjal-3338	102	102	to	to	ADP
cjal-3338	102	103	this	this	PRON
cjal-3338	102	104	most	most	ADJ
cjal-3338	102	105	proximate	proximate	VERB
cjal-3338	102	106	existing	exist	VERB
cjal-3338	102	107	technology	technology	NOUN
cjal-3338	102	108	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	102	109	order	order	NOUN
cjal-3338	102	110	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	102	111	solve	solve	VERB
cjal-3338	102	112	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	102	113	present	present	ADJ
cjal-3338	102	114	technical	technical	ADJ
cjal-3338	102	115	problem	problem	NOUN
cjal-3338	102	116	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	102	117	wa	wa	NOUN
cjal-3338	102	118	-	-	NOUN
cjal-3338	102	119	aly	aly	NOUN
cjal-3338	102	120	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	102	121	s	s	PART
cjal-3338	102	122	ruiz	ruiz	NOUN
cjal-3338	102	123	v.	v.	ADP
cjal-3338	102	124	ab	ab	PROPN
cjal-3338	102	125	chance	chance	PROPN
cjal-3338	102	126	co.	co.	PROPN
cjal-3338	102	127	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	102	128	234	234	NUM
cjal-3338	102	129	f.3d	f.3d	NUM
cjal-3338	102	130	654	654	NUM
cjal-3338	102	131	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	102	132	66o	66o	NUM
cjal-3338	102	133	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	102	134	fed	fed	PROPN
cjal-3338	102	135	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	102	136	cir	cir	PROPN
cjal-3338	102	137	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	102	138	2000	2000	NUM
cjal-3338	102	139	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	102	140	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	103	1	t6	t6	PROPN
cjal-3338	103	2	ksr	ksr	PROPN
cjal-3338	103	3	int'l	int'l	PROPN
cjal-3338	103	4	co.	co.	PROPN
cjal-3338	103	5	v.	v.	PROPN
cjal-3338	103	6	teleflex	teleflex	PROPN
cjal-3338	103	7	inc	inc	PROPN
cjal-3338	103	8	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	103	9	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	103	10	550	550	NUM
cjal-3338	103	11	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cjal-3338	103	12	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	103	13	398	398	NUM
cjal-3338	103	14	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	103	15	419	419	NUM
cjal-3338	103	16	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	103	17	2007	2007	NUM
cjal-3338	103	18	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	103	19	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	104	1	'	'	PUNCT
cjal-3338	104	2	7	7	NUM
cjal-3338	104	3	see	see	VERB
cjal-3338	104	4	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	104	5	e.g.	e.g.	ADV
cjal-3338	104	6	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	104	7	zhangqiu	zhangqiu	PROPN
cjal-3338	104	8	riyue	riyue	PROPN
cjal-3338	104	9	huagong	huagong	PROPN
cjal-3338	105	1	youxian	youxian	PROPN
cjal-3338	105	2	gongsi	gongsi	PROPN
cjal-3338	105	3	yu	yu	PROPN
cjal-3338	105	4	guojia	guojia	PROPN
cjal-3338	105	5	zhishi	zhishi	PROPN
cjal-3338	105	6	chanquan	chanquan	PROPN
cjal-3338	105	7	ju	ju	PROPN
cjal-3338	105	8	zhuanli	zhuanli	PROPN
cjal-3338	105	9	fushen	fushen	PROPN
cjal-3338	105	10	weiyuan	weiyuan	PROPN
cjal-3338	105	11	hui	hui	PROPN
cjal-3338	105	12	zhuanli	zhuanli	PROPN
cjal-3338	105	13	quan	quan	PROPN
cjal-3338	105	14	wuxiao	wuxiao	VERB
cjal-3338	105	15	xingzheng	xingzheng	PROPN
cjal-3338	105	16	jiufen	jiufen	PROPN
cjal-3338	105	17	yian	yian	PROPN
cjal-3338	105	18	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	105	19	ifcel	ifcel	NOUN
cjal-3338	105	20	fl	fl	NUM
cjal-3338	105	21	4li	4li	PROPN
cjal-3338	105	22	ii	ii	PROPN
cjal-3338	106	1	[	[	X
cjal-3338	106	2	i	i	PRON
cjal-3338	106	3	ij	ij	X
cjal-3338	106	4	]	]	PUNCT
cjal-3338	106	5	flj	flj	PROPN
cjal-3338	106	6	~q	~q	PUNCT
cjal-3338	106	7	-[zhangqiu	-[zhangqiu	PROPN
cjal-3338	106	8	riyue	riyue	PROPN
cjal-3338	106	9	chem	chem	NOUN
cjal-3338	106	10	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	107	1	indus	indus	PROPN
cjal-3338	107	2	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	108	1	co.	co.	PROPN
cjal-3338	108	2	v.	v.	ADP
cjal-3338	108	3	st	st	PROPN
cjal-3338	108	4	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	108	5	intell	intell	PROPN
cjal-3338	108	6	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	109	1	prop	prop	NOUN
cjal-3338	109	2	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	110	1	office	office	NOUN
cjal-3338	110	2	pat	pat	PROPN
cjal-3338	110	3	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	111	1	reexamination	reexamination	PROPN
cjal-3338	111	2	bd	bd	PROPN
cjal-3338	111	3	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	111	4	]	]	PUNCT
cjal-3338	112	1	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	112	2	beijing	beijing	PROPN
cjal-3338	112	3	high	high	PROPN
cjal-3338	112	4	people	people	NOUN
cjal-3338	112	5	's	's	PART
cjal-3338	112	6	ct	ct	NOUN
cjal-3338	112	7	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	112	8	2008	2008	NUM
cjal-3338	112	9	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	112	10	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	112	11	china	china	PROPN
cjal-3338	112	12	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	112	13	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	112	14	available	available	ADJ
cjal-3338	112	15	at	at	ADP
cjal-3338	112	16	http://ipr.court.gov.cn/bj/zlq/2oo8o5/	http://ipr.court.gov.cn/bj/zlq/2oo8o5/	PUNCT
cjal-3338	112	17	t20o80	t20o80	PROPN
cjal-3338	112	18	523o	523o	NOUN
cjal-3338	112	19	9	9	NUM
cjal-3338	112	20	725.html	725.html	NUM
cjal-3338	112	21	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	113	1	'	'	PUNCT
cjal-3338	113	2	7	7	NUM
cjal-3338	113	3	zhangqiu	zhangqiu	PROPN
cjal-3338	113	4	riyue	riyue	PROPN
cjal-3338	113	5	huagong	huagong	PROPN
cjal-3338	113	6	youxian	youxian	PROPN
cjal-3338	113	7	gongsi	gongsi	PROPN
cjal-3338	113	8	yu	yu	PROPN
cjal-3338	113	9	guojia	guojia	PROPN
cjal-3338	113	10	zhishi	zhishi	PROPN
cjal-3338	113	11	chanquan	chanquan	PROPN
cjal-3338	113	12	ju	ju	PROPN
cjal-3338	113	13	zhuanli	zhuanli	PROPN
cjal-3338	113	14	fushen	fushen	PROPN
cjal-3338	113	15	weiyuan	weiyuan	PROPN
cjal-3338	113	16	hui	hui	PROPN
cjal-3338	113	17	zhuanli	zhuanli	PROPN
cjal-3338	113	18	quan	quan	PROPN
cjal-3338	113	19	wuxiao	wuxiao	VERB
cjal-3338	113	20	xingzheng	xingzheng	PROPN
cjal-3338	113	21	jiufen	jiufen	PROPN
cjal-3338	113	22	yian	yian	PROPN
cjal-3338	113	23	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	113	24	'	'	PUNCT
cjal-3338	113	25	*	*	PUNCT
cjal-3338	114	1	_	_	PUNCT
cjal-3338	114	2	h	h	NOUN
cjal-3338	114	3	h	h	NOUN
cjal-3338	114	4	fl	fl	INTJ
cjal-3338	114	5	tt11	tt11	PROPN
cjal-3338	114	6	pr	pr	X
cjal-3338	114	7	.[h	.[h	PUNCT
cjal-3338	115	1	ij	ij	INTJ
cjal-3338	115	2	nyw	nyw	NOUN
cjal-3338	115	3	fi	fi	NOUN
cjal-3338	115	4	e---	e---	NOUN
cjal-3338	115	5	*	*	PUNCT
cjal-3338	115	6	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	116	1	[	[	X
cjal-3338	116	2	zhangqiu	zhangqiu	PROPN
cjal-3338	116	3	riyue	riyue	PROPN
cjal-3338	116	4	chem	chem	PROPN
cjal-3338	116	5	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	116	6	indus	indus	PROPN
cjal-3338	116	7	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	117	1	co.	co.	PROPN
cjal-3338	117	2	v.	v.	ADP
cjal-3338	117	3	st	st	PROPN
cjal-3338	117	4	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	117	5	intell	intell	PROPN
cjal-3338	117	6	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	118	1	prop	prop	NOUN
cjal-3338	118	2	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	119	1	office	office	NOUN
cjal-3338	119	2	pat	pat	PROPN
cjal-3338	119	3	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	120	1	reexamination	reexamination	PROPN
cjal-3338	120	2	bd	bd	PROPN
cjal-3338	120	3	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	120	4	]	]	PUNCT
cjal-3338	121	1	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	121	2	beijing	beijing	PROPN
cjal-3338	121	3	high	high	PROPN
cjal-3338	121	4	people	people	NOUN
cjal-3338	121	5	's	's	PART
cjal-3338	121	6	ct	ct	NOUN
cjal-3338	121	7	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	121	8	2oo8	2oo8	NUM
cjal-3338	121	9	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	121	10	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	121	11	china	china	PROPN
cjal-3338	121	12	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	121	13	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	121	14	available	available	ADJ
cjal-3338	121	15	at	at	ADP
cjal-3338	121	16	http://ipr.court.gov.cn/bj/zlq/2oo8o5/t2oo8o523io9	http://ipr.court.gov.cn/bj/zlq/2oo8o5/t2oo8o523io9	PROPN
cjal-3338	121	17	725	725	NUM
cjal-3338	121	18	.html	.html	NOUN
cjal-3338	121	19	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	122	1	18	18	NUM
cjal-3338	122	2	zhuanli	zhuanli	NOUN
cjal-3338	122	3	fa	fa	PROPN
cjal-3338	122	4	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	122	5	-vij9	-vij9	PROPN
cjal-3338	122	6	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	123	1	[	[	X
cjal-3338	123	2	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	123	3	law	law	NOUN
cjal-3338	123	4	]	]	PUNCT
cjal-3338	123	5	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	123	6	promulgated	promulgate	VERB
cjal-3338	123	7	by	by	ADP
cjal-3338	123	8	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	123	9	standing	standing	NOUN
cjal-3338	123	10	comm	comm	NOUN
cjal-3338	123	11	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	124	1	nat'l	nat'l	NOUN
cjal-3338	124	2	people	people	NOUN
cjal-3338	124	3	's	's	PART
cjal-3338	124	4	cong	cong	NOUN
cjal-3338	124	5	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	124	6	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	124	7	mar	mar	PROPN
cjal-3338	124	8	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	124	9	12	12	NUM
cjal-3338	124	10	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	124	11	1984	1984	NUM
cjal-3338	124	12	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	124	13	amended	amend	VERB
cjal-3338	124	14	dec	dec	PROPN
cjal-3338	124	15	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	124	16	27	27	NUM
cjal-3338	124	17	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	124	18	2008	2008	NUM
cjal-3338	124	19	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	124	20	effective	effective	ADJ
cjal-3338	124	21	oct	oct	PROPN
cjal-3338	124	22	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	124	23	1	1	NUM
cjal-3338	124	24	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	124	25	2009	2009	NUM
cjal-3338	124	26	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	124	27	2009	2009	NUM
cjal-3338	124	28	standing	standing	NOUN
cjal-3338	124	29	comm	comm	NOUN
cjal-3338	124	30	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	125	1	nat'l	nat'l	NOUN
cjal-3338	125	2	peoples	people	NOUN
cjal-3338	125	3	cong	cong	VERB
cjal-3338	125	4	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	126	1	gaz	gaz	PROPN
cjal-3338	126	2	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	127	1	27	27	NUM
cjal-3338	127	2	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	127	3	china	china	PROPN
cjal-3338	127	4	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	128	1	[	[	X
cjal-3338	128	2	hereinafter	hereinafter	NOUN
cjal-3338	128	3	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	128	4	law	law	NOUN
cjal-3338	128	5	]	]	PUNCT
cjal-3338	128	6	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	128	7	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	129	1	22	22	NUM
cjal-3338	129	2	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	129	3	translated	translate	VERB
cjal-3338	129	4	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	129	5	http://www.wipo.int/wipolex/en/details.jsp?id=5484	http://www.wipo.int/wipolex/en/details.jsp?id=5484	NOUN
cjal-3338	129	6	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	130	1	it	it	PRON
cjal-3338	130	2	should	should	AUX
cjal-3338	130	3	be	be	AUX
cjal-3338	130	4	noted	note	VERB
cjal-3338	130	5	that	that	SCONJ
cjal-3338	130	6	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	130	7	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	130	8	law	law	NOUN
cjal-3338	130	9	imposes	impose	VERB
cjal-3338	130	10	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	130	11	lower	low	ADJ
cjal-3338	130	12	requirement	requirement	NOUN
cjal-3338	130	13	for	for	ADP
cjal-3338	130	14	patentability	patentability	NOUN
cjal-3338	130	15	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	130	16	utility	utility	NOUN
cjal-3338	130	17	models	model	NOUN
cjal-3338	130	18	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	130	19	which	which	PRON
cjal-3338	130	20	need	need	VERB
cjal-3338	130	21	only	only	ADV
cjal-3338	130	22	possess	possess	VERB
cjal-3338	130	23	:	:	PUNCT
cjal-3338	130	24	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	130	25	i	i	NOUN
cjal-3338	130	26	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	131	1	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	131	2	substantive	substantive	ADJ
cjal-3338	131	3	features	feature	NOUN
cjal-3338	131	4	;	;	PUNCT
cjal-3338	131	5	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	131	6	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	131	7	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	131	8	2	2	NUM
cjal-3338	131	9	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	131	10	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	131	11	improvement	improvement	NOUN
cjal-3338	131	12	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	131	13	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	131	14	defensive	defensive	ADJ
cjal-3338	131	15	use	use	NOUN
cjal-3338	131	16	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	131	17	priorart	priorart	NOUN
cjal-3338	131	18	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	131	19	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cjal-3338	131	20	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	131	21	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	131	22	chinese	chinese	PROPN
cjal-3338	131	23	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	131	24	litigation	litigation	PROPN
cjal-3338	131	25	59	59	NUM
cjal-3338	131	26	j4	j4	PROPN
cjal-3338	131	27	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	131	28	*	*	NOUN
cjal-3338	131	29	j1	j1	PROPN
cjal-3338	131	30	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	131	31	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	132	1	if	if	SCONJ
cjal-3338	132	2	there	there	PRON
cjal-3338	132	3	is	be	VERB
cjal-3338	132	4	such	such	DET
cjal-3338	132	5	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	132	6	suggestion	suggestion	NOUN
cjal-3338	132	7	present	present	ADJ
cjal-3338	132	8	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	132	9	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	132	10	existing	exist	VERB
cjal-3338	132	11	technology	technology	NOUN
cjal-3338	132	12	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	132	13	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	132	14	[	[	X
cjal-3338	132	15	claimed	claim	VERB
cjal-3338	132	16	]	]	X
cjal-3338	132	17	technological	technological	ADJ
cjal-3338	132	18	solution	solution	NOUN
cjal-3338	132	19	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	132	20	obvious	obvious	ADJ
cjal-3338	132	21	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	132	22	'	'	PUNCT
cjal-3338	133	1	9	9	NUM
cjal-3338	133	2	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	133	3	second	second	ADJ
cjal-3338	133	4	prong	prong	NOUN
cjal-3338	133	5	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	133	6	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	133	7	chinese	chinese	ADJ
cjal-3338	133	8	inventiveness	inventiveness	NOUN
cjal-3338	133	9	inquiry	inquiry	NOUN
cjal-3338	133	10	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	133	11	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	133	12	improvement	improvement	NOUN
cjal-3338	133	13	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	133	14	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	133	15	concerned	concern	VERB
cjal-3338	133	16	with	with	ADP
cjal-3338	133	17	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	133	18	difference	difference	NOUN
cjal-3338	133	19	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	133	20	technical	technical	ADJ
cjal-3338	133	21	effect	effect	NOUN
cjal-3338	133	22	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	133	23	*	*	NOUN
cjal-3338	133	24	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	133	25	between	between	ADP
cjal-3338	133	26	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	133	27	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	133	28	claim	claim	NOUN
cjal-3338	133	29	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	133	30	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	133	31	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	133	32	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	133	33	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	134	1	improvement	improvement	NOUN
cjal-3338	134	2	has	have	VERB
cjal-3338	134	3	no	no	DET
cjal-3338	134	4	counterpart	counterpart	NOUN
cjal-3338	134	5	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	134	6	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	134	7	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cjal-3338	134	8	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	134	9	obviousness	obviousness	PROPN
cjal-3338	134	10	determination.2	determination.2	PROPN
cjal-3338	134	11	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	134	12	it	it	PRON
cjal-3338	134	13	should	should	AUX
cjal-3338	134	14	be	be	AUX
cjal-3338	134	15	noted	note	VERB
cjal-3338	134	16	that	that	SCONJ
cjal-3338	134	17	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	134	18	doctrines	doctrine	NOUN
cjal-3338	134	19	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	134	20	novelty	novelty	NOUN
cjal-3338	134	21	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	134	22	inventiveness	inventiveness	NOUN
cjal-3338	134	23	are	be	AUX
cjal-3338	134	24	not	not	PART
cjal-3338	134	25	invoked	invoke	VERB
cjal-3338	134	26	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	134	27	chinese	chinese	ADJ
cjal-3338	134	28	civil	civil	ADJ
cjal-3338	134	29	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	134	30	litigation	litigation	NOUN
cjal-3338	134	31	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	135	1	rather	rather	ADV
cjal-3338	135	2	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	135	3	they	they	PRON
cjal-3338	135	4	are	be	AUX
cjal-3338	135	5	only	only	ADV
cjal-3338	135	6	applicable	applicable	ADJ
cjal-3338	135	7	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	135	8	administrative	administrative	ADJ
cjal-3338	135	9	litigation	litigation	NOUN
cjal-3338	135	10	challenging	challenge	VERB
cjal-3338	135	11	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	135	12	decisions	decision	NOUN
cjal-3338	135	13	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	135	14	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	135	15	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	135	16	reexamination	reexamination	PROPN
cjal-3338	135	17	board	board	NOUN
cjal-3338	135	18	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	136	1	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	136	2	'	'	PUNCT
cjal-3338	136	3	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	136	4	people	people	NOUN
cjal-3338	136	5	's	's	PART
cjal-3338	136	6	courts	court	NOUN
cjal-3338	136	7	can	can	AUX
cjal-3338	136	8	only	only	ADV
cjal-3338	136	9	render	render	VERB
cjal-3338	136	10	judgment	judgment	NOUN
cjal-3338	136	11	concerning	concern	VERB
cjal-3338	136	12	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	136	13	correctness	correctness	NOUN
cjal-3338	136	14	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	136	15	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	136	16	application	application	NOUN
cjal-3338	136	17	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	136	18	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	136	19	law	law	NOUN
cjal-3338	136	20	by	by	ADP
cjal-3338	136	21	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	136	22	board	board	NOUN
cjal-3338	136	23	;	;	PUNCT
cjal-3338	136	24	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	136	25	declaration	declaration	NOUN
cjal-3338	136	26	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	136	27	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	136	28	validity	validity	NOUN
cjal-3338	136	29	or	or	CCONJ
cjal-3338	136	30	invalidity	invalidity	NOUN
cjal-3338	136	31	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	136	32	not	not	PART
cjal-3338	136	33	an	an	DET
cjal-3338	136	34	available	available	ADJ
cjal-3338	136	35	remedy.22	remedy.22	NOUN
cjal-3338	136	36	practicing	practice	VERB
cjal-3338	136	37	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	136	38	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	136	39	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	136	40	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	136	41	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	136	42	defensive	defensive	ADJ
cjal-3338	136	43	variant	variant	NOUN
cjal-3338	136	44	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	136	45	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	136	46	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	136	47	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	136	48	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	136	49	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	136	50	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	136	51	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	136	52	only	only	ADJ
cjal-3338	136	53	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	136	54	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	136	55	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	136	56	available	available	ADJ
cjal-3338	136	57	to	to	ADP
cjal-3338	136	58	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	136	59	defendant	defendant	NOUN
cjal-3338	136	60	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	136	61	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	136	62	chinese	chinese	ADJ
cjal-3338	136	63	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	136	64	infringement	infringement	NOUN
cjal-3338	136	65	dispute.23	dispute.23	PROPN
cjal-3338	136	66	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cjal-3338	136	67	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	136	68	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	136	69	law	law	NOUN
cjal-3338	136	70	recognizes	recognize	VERB
cjal-3338	136	71	an	an	DET
cjal-3338	136	72	exact	exact	ADJ
cjal-3338	136	73	linkage	linkage	NOUN
cjal-3338	136	74	between	between	ADP
cjal-3338	136	75	novelty	novelty	NOUN
cjal-3338	136	76	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	136	77	literal	literal	ADJ
cjal-3338	136	78	infringement	infringement	NOUN
cjal-3338	136	79	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	136	80	that	that	ADV
cjal-3338	136	81	is	is	ADV
cjal-3338	136	82	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	136	83	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	136	84	that	that	PRON
cjal-3338	136	85	which	which	PRON
cjal-3338	136	86	would	would	AUX
cjal-3338	136	87	literally	literally	ADV
cjal-3338	136	88	infringe	infringe	VERB
cjal-3338	136	89	if	if	SCONJ
cjal-3338	136	90	later	later	ADV
cjal-3338	136	91	anticipates	anticipate	VERB
cjal-3338	136	92	if	if	SCONJ
cjal-3338	136	93	earlier	early	ADV
cjal-3338	136	94	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	136	95	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	136	96	'	'	PUNCT
cjal-3338	136	97	however	however	ADV
cjal-3338	136	98	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	136	99	it	it	PRON
cjal-3338	136	100	rejects	reject	VERB
cjal-3338	136	101	any	any	DET
cjal-3338	136	102	connection	connection	NOUN
cjal-3338	136	103	between	between	ADP
cjal-3338	136	104	equivalence	equivalence	NOUN
cjal-3338	136	105	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	136	106	19	19	NUM
cjal-3338	136	107	supoer	supoer	PROPN
cjal-3338	136	108	jituan	jituan	PROPN
cjal-3338	136	109	youxian	youxian	PROPN
cjal-3338	136	110	gongsi	gongsi	PROPN
cjal-3338	136	111	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	136	112	zhejiang	zhejiang	PROPN
cjal-3338	136	113	sheng	sheng	PROPN
cjal-3338	136	114	supoer	supoer	PROPN
cjal-3338	136	115	gufen	gufen	NOUN
cjal-3338	136	116	youxian	youxian	PROPN
cjal-3338	136	117	gongsi	gongsi	PROPN
cjal-3338	136	118	yu	yu	PROPN
cjal-3338	136	119	fang	fang	PROPN
cjal-3338	136	120	zhanchong	zhanchong	PROPN
cjal-3338	136	121	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	136	122	guojia	guojia	PROPN
cjal-3338	136	123	zhishi	zhishi	PROPN
cjal-3338	136	124	chanquan	chanquan	PROPN
cjal-3338	136	125	ju	ju	PROPN
cjal-3338	136	126	zhuanli	zhuanli	PROPN
cjal-3338	136	127	fushen	fushen	PROPN
cjal-3338	136	128	weiyuan	weiyuan	PROPN
cjal-3338	136	129	hui	hui	PROPN
cjal-3338	136	130	zhuanli	zhuanli	PROPN
cjal-3338	136	131	wuxiao	wuxiao	VERB
cjal-3338	136	132	xingzheng	xingzheng	PROPN
cjal-3338	136	133	jiufen	jiufen	PROPN
cjal-3338	136	134	an	an	DET
cjal-3338	136	135	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	136	136	x	x	NOUN
cjal-3338	136	137	'	'	NUM
cjal-3338	136	138	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	136	139	t	t	PROPN
cjal-3338	136	140	-	-	PUNCT
cjal-3338	136	141	ip	ip	NOUN
cjal-3338	136	142	1	1	NUM
cjal-3338	136	143	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	136	144	xi	xi	PROPN
cjal-3338	136	145	m/1a*i	m/1a*i	PROPN
cjal-3338	136	146	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	136	147	-1	-1	ADP
cjal-3338	136	148	4	4	X
cjal-3338	136	149	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	136	150	-7'a	-7'a	NOUN
cjal-3338	136	151	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	136	152	i	i	PRON
cjal-3338	137	1	i	i	VERB
cjal-3338	137	2	m	m	VERB
cjal-3338	137	3	j	j	PROPN
cjal-3338	137	4	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	137	5	l	l	PROPN
cjal-3338	137	6	&	&	CCONJ
cjal-3338	137	7	#	#	NOUN
cjal-3338	137	8	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	138	1	[	[	X
cjal-3338	138	2	supor	supor	NOUN
cjal-3338	138	3	grp	grp	PROPN
cjal-3338	138	4	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	139	1	v.	v.	PROPN
cjal-3338	139	2	fang	fang	PROPN
cjal-3338	139	3	zhanchong	zhanchong	PROPN
cjal-3338	139	4	]	]	X
cjal-3338	139	5	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	139	6	beijing	beijing	PROPN
cjal-3338	139	7	high	high	PROPN
cjal-3338	139	8	people	people	NOUN
cjal-3338	139	9	's	's	PART
cjal-3338	139	10	ct	ct	NOUN
cjal-3338	139	11	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	139	12	2008	2008	NUM
cjal-3338	139	13	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	139	14	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	139	15	china	china	PROPN
cjal-3338	139	16	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	139	17	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	139	18	available	available	ADJ
cjal-3338	139	19	at	at	ADP
cjal-3338	139	20	http://ipr.court.gov.cn/bj/zlq/	http://ipr.court.gov.cn/bj/zlq/	PROPN
cjal-3338	139	21	zoo8o4	zoo8o4	NOUN
cjal-3338	139	22	/	/	SYM
cjal-3338	139	23	t2oo8o418_109579.html	t2oo8o418_109579.html	PROPN
cjal-3338	139	24	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	139	25	20	20	NUM
cjal-3338	139	26	china	china	PROPN
cjal-3338	139	27	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	139	28	not	not	PART
cjal-3338	139	29	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	139	30	only	only	ADJ
cjal-3338	139	31	country	country	NOUN
cjal-3338	139	32	whose	whose	DET
cjal-3338	139	33	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	139	34	law	law	NOUN
cjal-3338	139	35	insists	insist	VERB
cjal-3338	139	36	on	on	ADP
cjal-3338	139	37	improvement	improvement	NOUN
cjal-3338	139	38	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	140	1	for	for	ADP
cjal-3338	140	2	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	140	3	discussion	discussion	NOUN
cjal-3338	140	4	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	140	5	how	how	SCONJ
cjal-3338	140	6	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	140	7	corresponding	corresponding	ADJ
cjal-3338	140	8	requirement	requirement	NOUN
cjal-3338	140	9	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	140	10	improvement	improvement	NOUN
cjal-3338	140	11	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	140	12	indian	indian	ADJ
cjal-3338	140	13	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	140	14	law	law	NOUN
cjal-3338	140	15	affects	affect	VERB
cjal-3338	140	16	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	140	17	pharmaceutical	pharmaceutical	NOUN
cjal-3338	140	18	industries	industry	NOUN
cjal-3338	140	19	inside	inside	ADP
cjal-3338	140	20	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	140	21	outside	outside	ADP
cjal-3338	140	22	india	india	PROPN
cjal-3338	140	23	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	140	24	see	see	VERB
cjal-3338	140	25	vikas	vikas	PROPN
cjal-3338	140	26	bajaj	bajaj	PROPN
cjal-3338	140	27	&	&	CCONJ
cjal-3338	140	28	andrew	andrew	PROPN
cjal-3338	140	29	pollock	pollock	PROPN
cjal-3338	140	30	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	140	31	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	140	32	v.	v.	ADP
cjal-3338	140	33	patient	patient	PROPN
cjal-3338	140	34	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	140	35	n.y	n.y	PROPN
cjal-3338	140	36	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	140	37	times	times	PROPN
cjal-3338	140	38	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	140	39	mar	mar	PROPN
cjal-3338	140	40	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	140	41	7	7	NUM
cjal-3338	140	42	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	140	43	2012	2012	NUM
cjal-3338	140	44	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	140	45	at	at	ADP
cjal-3338	140	46	bi	bi	NOUN
cjal-3338	140	47	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	140	48	21	21	NUM
cjal-3338	140	49	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	140	50	law	law	NOUN
cjal-3338	140	51	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	140	52	supra	supra	PROPN
cjal-3338	140	53	note	note	PROPN
cjal-3338	140	54	18	18	NUM
cjal-3338	140	55	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	140	56	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	140	57	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	141	1	46	46	NUM
cjal-3338	141	2	.	.	X
cjal-3338	141	3	22	22	NUM
cjal-3338	141	4	rugao	rugao	ADV
cjal-3338	141	5	shi	shi	PROPN
cjal-3338	141	6	aijike	aijike	PROPN
cjal-3338	141	7	fangzhi	fangzhi	PROPN
cjal-3338	141	8	jixie	jixie	PROPN
cjal-3338	141	9	youxian	youxian	PROPN
cjal-3338	141	10	gongsi	gongsi	PROPN
cjal-3338	141	11	su	su	PROPN
cjal-3338	141	12	guojia	guojia	PROPN
cjal-3338	141	13	zhishi	zhishi	PROPN
cjal-3338	141	14	chanquan	chanquan	PROPN
cjal-3338	141	15	ju	ju	PROPN
cjal-3338	141	16	zhuanli	zhuanli	PROPN
cjal-3338	141	17	fushen	fushen	PROPN
cjal-3338	141	18	weiyuan	weiyuan	PROPN
cjal-3338	141	19	hui	hui	PROPN
cjal-3338	141	20	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	141	21	disanren	disanren	PROPN
cjal-3338	141	22	wang	wang	PROPN
cjal-3338	141	23	yushan	yushan	PROPN
cjal-3338	141	24	shiyong	shiyong	PROPN
cjal-3338	142	1	xinxing	xinxing	PROPN
cjal-3338	142	2	zhuanli	zhuanli	PROPN
cjal-3338	142	3	wuxiao	wuxiao	VERB
cjal-3338	142	4	jiufen	jiufen	NOUN
cjal-3338	142	5	tishenan	tishenan	NOUN
cjal-3338	142	6	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	142	7	me	i	PRON
cjal-3338	142	8	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	142	9	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	143	1	i4	i4	PROPN
cjal-3338	143	2	p-	p-	X
cjal-3338	144	1	[	[	X
cjal-3338	144	2	[	[	PUNCT
cjal-3338	144	3	i	i	PRON
cjal-3338	144	4	i	i	PRON
cjal-3338	144	5	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	144	6	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	144	7	_	_	PUNCT
cjal-3338	144	8	_	_	PUNCT
cjal-3338	144	9	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	144	10	tth	tth	NOUN
cjal-3338	144	11	_	_	NOUN
cjal-3338	144	12	-j	-j	PUNCT
cjal-3338	144	13	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	145	1	[	[	X
cjal-3338	145	2	rugao	rugao	ADJ
cjal-3338	145	3	city	city	NOUN
cjal-3338	145	4	a.j.q	a.j.q	PROPN
cjal-3338	145	5	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	146	1	textile	textile	PROPN
cjal-3338	146	2	mach	mach	PROPN
cjal-3338	146	3	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	147	1	co.	co.	PROPN
cjal-3338	147	2	v.	v.	ADP
cjal-3338	147	3	st	st	PROPN
cjal-3338	147	4	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	147	5	intell	intell	PROPN
cjal-3338	147	6	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	148	1	prop	prop	NOUN
cjal-3338	148	2	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	149	1	office	office	NOUN
cjal-3338	149	2	pat	pat	PROPN
cjal-3338	149	3	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	150	1	reexamination	reexamination	PROPN
cjal-3338	150	2	bd	bd	PROPN
cjal-3338	150	3	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	150	4	]	]	PUNCT
cjal-3338	151	1	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	151	2	sup	sup	NOUN
cjal-3338	151	3	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	152	1	people	people	NOUN
cjal-3338	152	2	's	's	PART
cjal-3338	152	3	ct	ct	NOUN
cjal-3338	152	4	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	152	5	2007	2007	NUM
cjal-3338	152	6	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	152	7	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	152	8	china	china	PROPN
cjal-3338	152	9	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	152	10	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	152	11	available	available	ADJ
cjal-3338	152	12	at	at	ADP
cjal-3338	152	13	http://www.legaldaily.com.cn/misc/20o8-i/17/content-982987.htm	http://www.legaldaily.com.cn/misc/20o8-i/17/content-982987.htm	PROPN
cjal-3338	152	14	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	153	1	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	153	2	decision	decision	NOUN
cjal-3338	153	3	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	153	4	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	153	5	typical	typical	ADJ
cjal-3338	153	6	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	153	7	case	case	NOUN
cjal-3338	153	8	number	number	NOUN
cjal-3338	153	9	47	47	NUM
cjal-3338	153	10	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	153	11	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	153	12	2oo8	2oo8	NUM
cjal-3338	153	13	list	list	NOUN
cjal-3338	153	14	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	153	15	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	153	16	top	top	ADJ
cjal-3338	153	17	io	io	NOUN
cjal-3338	153	18	cases	case	NOUN
cjal-3338	153	19	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	153	20	50	50	NUM
cjal-3338	153	21	typical	typical	ADJ
cjal-3338	153	22	cases	case	NOUN
cjal-3338	153	23	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	153	24	judicial	judicial	ADJ
cjal-3338	153	25	protection	protection	NOUN
cjal-3338	153	26	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	153	27	intellectual	intellectual	ADJ
cjal-3338	153	28	property	property	NOUN
cjal-3338	153	29	rights	right	NOUN
cjal-3338	153	30	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	153	31	china	china	PROPN
cjal-3338	153	32	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	153	33	promulgated	promulgate	VERB
cjal-3338	153	34	by	by	ADP
cjal-3338	153	35	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	153	36	supreme	supreme	PROPN
cjal-3338	153	37	people	people	PROPN
cjal-3338	153	38	's	's	PART
cjal-3338	153	39	court	court	NOUN
cjal-3338	153	40	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	154	1	zuigao	zuigao	PROPN
cjal-3338	154	2	renmen	renmen	PROPN
cjal-3338	154	3	fayuan	fayuan	PROPN
cjal-3338	154	4	guanyu	guanyu	VERB
cjal-3338	154	5	fabu	fabu	PROPN
cjal-3338	154	6	2oo8	2oo8	NUM
cjal-3338	154	7	nian	nian	ADJ
cjal-3338	154	8	zhongguo	zhongguo	PROPN
cjal-3338	154	9	zhishi	zhishi	PROPN
cjal-3338	154	10	chanquan	chanquan	PROPN
cjal-3338	154	11	sifa	sifa	PROPN
cjal-3338	154	12	baohu	baohu	PROPN
cjal-3338	154	13	i0	i0	PROPN
cjal-3338	154	14	da	da	PROPN
cjal-3338	154	15	anjian	anjian	PROPN
cjal-3338	155	1	he	he	PRON
cjal-3338	155	2	50	50	NUM
cjal-3338	155	3	jian	jian	PROPN
cjal-3338	155	4	dianxing	dianxe	VERB
cjal-3338	155	5	anjian	anjian	PROPN
cjal-3338	155	6	de	de	X
cjal-3338	155	7	tongbao	tongbao	X
cjal-3338	155	8	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	155	9	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	155	10	i4	i4	PROPN
cjal-3338	155	11	%	%	NOUN
cjal-3338	155	12	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	155	13	\.	\.	PROPN
cjal-3338	155	14	k	k	PROPN
cjal-3338	155	15	2008	2008	NUM
cjal-3338	155	16	ifr	ifr	PROPN
cjal-3338	155	17	w0i+v	w0i+v	PROPN
cjal-3338	155	18	1	1	NUM
cjal-3338	155	19	mp	mp	PROPN
cjal-3338	155	20	10	10	NUM
cjal-3338	155	21	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	156	1	f	f	PROPN
cjal-3338	156	2	q5	q5	PROPN
cjal-3338	156	3	0	0	PROPN
cjal-3338	156	4	#	#	SYM
cjal-3338	156	5	va	va	PROPN
cjal-3338	156	6	p.m	p.m	PROPN
cjal-3338	156	7	1	1	NUM
cjal-3338	156	8	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	157	1	[	[	X
cjal-3338	157	2	circular	circular	NOUN
cjal-3338	157	3	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	157	4	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	157	5	supreme	supreme	PROPN
cjal-3338	157	6	people	people	PROPN
cjal-3338	157	7	's	's	PART
cjal-3338	157	8	court	court	NOUN
cjal-3338	157	9	concerning	concern	VERB
cjal-3338	157	10	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	157	11	top	top	ADJ
cjal-3338	157	12	io	io	PROPN
cjal-3338	157	13	cases	case	NOUN
cjal-3338	157	14	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	157	15	5o	5o	NUM
cjal-3338	157	16	typical	typical	ADJ
cjal-3338	157	17	cases	case	NOUN
cjal-3338	157	18	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	157	19	judicial	judicial	ADJ
cjal-3338	157	20	protection	protection	NOUN
cjal-3338	157	21	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	157	22	intellectual	intellectual	ADJ
cjal-3338	157	23	property	property	NOUN
cjal-3338	157	24	rights	right	NOUN
cjal-3338	157	25	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	157	26	china	china	PROPN
cjal-3338	157	27	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	157	28	2008	2008	NUM
cjal-3338	157	29	]	]	PUNCT
cjal-3338	157	30	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	157	31	promulgated	promulgate	VERB
cjal-3338	157	32	by	by	ADP
cjal-3338	157	33	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	157	34	sup	sup	NOUN
cjal-3338	157	35	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	158	1	people	people	NOUN
cjal-3338	158	2	's	's	PART
cjal-3338	158	3	ct	ct	PROPN
cjal-3338	158	4	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	158	5	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	158	6	apr	apr	PROPN
cjal-3338	158	7	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	158	8	21	21	NUM
cjal-3338	158	9	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	158	10	2009	2009	NUM
cjal-3338	158	11	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	158	12	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	158	13	available	available	ADJ
cjal-3338	158	14	at	at	ADP
cjal-3338	158	15	http://www.court.gov.cn/xwzx/rdzt/zscq/jdal/2oo	http://www.court.gov.cn/xwzx/rdzt/zscq/jdal/2oo	PROPN
cjal-3338	158	16	4	4	NUM
cjal-3338	158	17	/po2oo	/po2oo	SYM
cjal-3338	158	18	4zo	4zo	NOUN
cjal-3338	158	19	5	5	NUM
cjal-3338	158	20	9n	9n	NUM
cjal-3338	158	21	7	7	NUM
cjal-3338	158	22	6	6	NUM
cjal-3338	158	23	4	4	NUM
cjal-3338	158	24	17	17	NUM
cjal-3338	158	25	5	5	NUM
cjal-3338	158	26	9	9	NUM
cjal-3338	158	27	9	9	NUM
cjal-3338	158	28	.doc	.doc	NOUN
cjal-3338	158	29	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	159	1	23	23	NUM
cjal-3338	159	2	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	159	3	law	law	NOUN
cjal-3338	159	4	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	159	5	supra	supra	PROPN
cjal-3338	159	6	note	note	PROPN
cjal-3338	159	7	18	18	NUM
cjal-3338	159	8	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	159	9	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	159	10	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	160	1	62	62	NUM
cjal-3338	160	2	.	.	X
cjal-3338	161	1	24	24	NUM
cjal-3338	161	2	bristol	bristol	PROPN
cjal-3338	161	3	-	-	PUNCT
cjal-3338	161	4	myers	myers	PROPN
cjal-3338	161	5	squibb	squibb	PROPN
cjal-3338	161	6	co.	co.	PROPN
cjal-3338	161	7	v.	v.	ADP
cjal-3338	161	8	ben	ben	PROPN
cjal-3338	161	9	venue	venue	PROPN
cjal-3338	161	10	labs	labs	PROPN
cjal-3338	161	11	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	161	12	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	161	13	inc	inc	PROPN
cjal-3338	161	14	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	161	15	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	161	16	246	246	NUM
cjal-3338	161	17	f.3d	f.3d	NUM
cjal-3338	161	18	1368	1368	NUM
cjal-3338	161	19	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	161	20	1378	1378	NUM
cjal-3338	161	21	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	161	22	fed	fed	PROPN
cjal-3338	161	23	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	161	24	cir	cir	PROPN
cjal-3338	161	25	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	161	26	2001	2001	NUM
cjal-3338	161	27	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	161	28	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	162	1	6o	6o	PROPN
cjal-3338	162	2	columbia	columbia	PROPN
cjal-3338	162	3	journal	journal	PROPN
cjal-3338	162	4	ofasian	ofasian	ADJ
cjal-3338	162	5	law	law	NOUN
cjal-3338	162	6	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	162	7	vol	vol	NOUN
cjal-3338	162	8	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	162	9	27	27	NUM
cjal-3338	162	10	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	162	11	no	no	INTJ
cjal-3338	162	12	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	163	1	i	i	PRON
cjal-3338	163	2	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	163	3	2o13	2o13	NUM
cjal-3338	163	4	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	163	5	obviousness	obviousness	NOUN
cjal-3338	163	6	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	163	7	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	163	8	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	163	9	federal	federal	ADJ
cjal-3338	163	10	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cjal-3338	163	11	has	have	AUX
cjal-3338	163	12	held	hold	VERB
cjal-3338	163	13	that	that	SCONJ
cjal-3338	163	14	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	163	15	[	[	X
cjal-3338	163	16	the	the	X
cjal-3338	163	17	]	]	X
cjal-3338	163	18	two	two	NUM
cjal-3338	163	19	legal	legal	ADJ
cjal-3338	163	20	principles	principle	NOUN
cjal-3338	163	21	[	[	X
cjal-3338	163	22	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	163	23	obviousness	obviousness	NOUN
cjal-3338	163	24	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	163	25	equivalence	equivalence	NOUN
cjal-3338	163	26	]	]	PUNCT
cjal-3338	163	27	require	require	VERB
cjal-3338	163	28	different	different	ADJ
cjal-3338	163	29	analytical	analytical	ADJ
cjal-3338	163	30	frameworks	framework	NOUN
cjal-3338	163	31	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	164	1	"25	"25	PROPN
cjal-3338	164	2	chinese	chinese	PROPN
cjal-3338	164	3	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	164	4	law	law	NOUN
cjal-3338	164	5	does	do	AUX
cjal-3338	164	6	not	not	PART
cjal-3338	164	7	explicitly	explicitly	ADV
cjal-3338	164	8	acknowledge	acknowledge	VERB
cjal-3338	164	9	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	164	10	linkages	linkage	NOUN
cjal-3338	164	11	between	between	ADP
cjal-3338	164	12	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	164	13	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	164	14	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	164	15	invalidity	invalidity	NOUN
cjal-3338	164	16	doctrines	doctrine	NOUN
cjal-3338	164	17	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	164	18	novelty	novelty	NOUN
cjal-3338	164	19	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	164	20	inventiveness	inventiveness	NOUN
cjal-3338	164	21	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	164	22	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	164	23	infringement	infringement	NOUN
cjal-3338	164	24	doctrines	doctrine	NOUN
cjal-3338	164	25	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	164	26	literality	literality	NOUN
cjal-3338	164	27	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	164	28	equivalence	equivalence	NOUN
cjal-3338	164	29	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	164	30	but	but	CCONJ
cjal-3338	164	31	they	they	PRON
cjal-3338	164	32	enjoy	enjoy	VERB
cjal-3338	164	33	de	de	X
cjal-3338	164	34	facto	facto	X
cjal-3338	164	35	recognition	recognition	NOUN
cjal-3338	164	36	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	165	1	as	as	SCONJ
cjal-3338	165	2	stated	state	VERB
cjal-3338	165	3	above	above	ADV
cjal-3338	165	4	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	165	5	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	165	6	chinese	chinese	ADJ
cjal-3338	165	7	novelty	novelty	NOUN
cjal-3338	165	8	test	test	NOUN
cjal-3338	165	9	incorporates	incorporate	VERB
cjal-3338	165	10	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	165	11	test	test	NOUN
cjal-3338	165	12	similar	similar	ADJ
cjal-3338	165	13	to	to	ADP
cjal-3338	165	14	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	165	15	equivalence	equivalence	NOUN
cjal-3338	165	16	triple	triple	ADJ
cjal-3338	165	17	identity	identity	NOUN
cjal-3338	165	18	test	test	NOUN
cjal-3338	165	19	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	166	1	therefore	therefore	ADV
cjal-3338	166	2	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	166	3	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	166	4	reach	reach	NOUN
cjal-3338	166	5	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	166	6	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	166	7	novelty	novelty	NOUN
cjal-3338	166	8	doctrine	doctrine	NOUN
cjal-3338	166	9	from	from	ADP
cjal-3338	166	10	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	166	11	core	core	NOUN
cjal-3338	166	12	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	166	13	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	166	14	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	166	15	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	166	16	greater	great	ADJ
cjal-3338	166	17	than	than	ADP
cjal-3338	166	18	that	that	PRON
cjal-3338	166	19	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	166	20	literality	literality	NOUN
cjal-3338	166	21	from	from	ADP
cjal-3338	166	22	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	166	23	core	core	NOUN
cjal-3338	166	24	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	166	25	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	166	26	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	166	27	claim	claim	NOUN
cjal-3338	166	28	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	166	29	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	166	30	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	166	31	unlike	unlike	ADP
cjal-3338	166	32	their	their	PRON
cjal-3338	166	33	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cjal-3338	166	34	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	166	35	counterparts	counterpart	NOUN
cjal-3338	166	36	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	166	37	these	these	DET
cjal-3338	166	38	doctrines	doctrine	NOUN
cjal-3338	166	39	are	be	AUX
cjal-3338	166	40	not	not	PART
cjal-3338	166	41	exactly	exactly	ADV
cjal-3338	166	42	linked	link	VERB
cjal-3338	166	43	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	167	1	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	167	2	chinese	chinese	ADJ
cjal-3338	167	3	equivalence	equivalence	NOUN
cjal-3338	167	4	doctrine	doctrine	NOUN
cjal-3338	167	5	incorporates	incorporate	VERB
cjal-3338	167	6	an	an	DET
cjal-3338	167	7	element	element	NOUN
cjal-3338	167	8	that	that	SCONJ
cjal-3338	167	9	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	167	10	equivalent	equivalent	ADJ
cjal-3338	167	11	feature	feature	NOUN
cjal-3338	167	12	be	be	VERB
cjal-3338	167	13	one	one	NUM
cjal-3338	167	14	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	167	15	which	which	PRON
cjal-3338	167	16	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	167	17	person	person	NOUN
cjal-3338	167	18	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	167	19	ordinary	ordinary	ADJ
cjal-3338	167	20	skill	skill	NOUN
cjal-3338	167	21	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	167	22	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	167	23	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	167	24	would	would	AUX
cjal-3338	167	25	be	be	AUX
cjal-3338	167	26	able	able	ADJ
cjal-3338	167	27	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	167	28	conceive	conceive	VERB
cjal-3338	167	29	without	without	ADP
cjal-3338	167	30	inventive	inventive	ADJ
cjal-3338	167	31	labor	labor	NOUN
cjal-3338	167	32	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	167	33	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	168	1	6	6	NUM
cjal-3338	168	2	thus	thus	ADV
cjal-3338	168	3	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	168	4	equivalence	equivalence	NOUN
cjal-3338	168	5	shares	share	NOUN
cjal-3338	168	6	component	component	NOUN
cjal-3338	168	7	tests	test	NOUN
cjal-3338	168	8	with	with	ADP
cjal-3338	168	9	inventiveness	inventiveness	NOUN
cjal-3338	168	10	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	168	11	but	but	CCONJ
cjal-3338	168	12	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	168	13	linkage	linkage	NOUN
cjal-3338	168	14	between	between	ADP
cjal-3338	168	15	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	168	16	two	two	NUM
cjal-3338	168	17	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	168	18	not	not	PART
cjal-3338	168	19	exact	exact	ADJ
cjal-3338	168	20	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	169	1	chinese	chinese	ADJ
cjal-3338	169	2	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	169	3	law	law	NOUN
cjal-3338	169	4	does	do	AUX
cjal-3338	169	5	not	not	PART
cjal-3338	169	6	require	require	VERB
cjal-3338	169	7	accused	accuse	VERB
cjal-3338	169	8	acts	act	NOUN
cjal-3338	169	9	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	169	10	have	have	VERB
cjal-3338	169	11	improvement	improvement	NOUN
cjal-3338	169	12	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	169	13	escape	escape	VERB
cjal-3338	169	14	infringement	infringement	NOUN
cjal-3338	169	15	by	by	ADP
cjal-3338	169	16	equivalence	equivalence	NOUN
cjal-3338	169	17	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	169	18	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	169	19	so	so	ADV
cjal-3338	169	20	inventiveness	inventiveness	NOUN
cjal-3338	169	21	imposes	impose	VERB
cjal-3338	169	22	more	more	ADJ
cjal-3338	169	23	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	169	24	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	169	25	burden	burden	NOUN
cjal-3338	169	26	on	on	ADP
cjal-3338	169	27	one	one	NUM
cjal-3338	169	28	seeking	seek	VERB
cjal-3338	169	29	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	169	30	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	169	31	than	than	ADP
cjal-3338	169	32	equivalence	equivalence	NOUN
cjal-3338	169	33	imposes	impose	VERB
cjal-3338	169	34	on	on	ADP
cjal-3338	169	35	one	one	NUM
cjal-3338	169	36	seeking	seek	VERB
cjal-3338	169	37	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	169	38	avoid	avoid	VERB
cjal-3338	169	39	infringement	infringement	NOUN
cjal-3338	169	40	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	170	1	ii	ii	PROPN
cjal-3338	170	2	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	171	1	using	use	VERB
cjal-3338	171	2	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	171	3	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	171	4	defensively	defensively	ADV
cjal-3338	171	5	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	171	6	establish	establish	VERB
cjal-3338	171	7	entitlement	entitlement	NOUN
cjal-3338	171	8	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	171	9	practice	practice	VERB
cjal-3338	171	10	litigation	litigation	NOUN
cjal-3338	171	11	a.	a.	NOUN
cjal-3338	171	12	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	171	13	practicing	practice	VERB
cjal-3338	171	14	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	171	15	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	171	16	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	171	17	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	171	18	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	171	19	unavailable	unavailable	ADJ
cjal-3338	171	20	against	against	ADP
cjal-3338	171	21	claims	claim	NOUN
cjal-3338	171	22	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	171	23	literal	literal	ADJ
cjal-3338	171	24	infringement	infringement	NOUN
cjal-3338	171	25	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	171	26	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cjal-3338	171	27	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	171	28	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	171	29	litigation	litigation	NOUN
cjal-3338	171	30	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	171	31	2002	2002	NUM
cjal-3338	171	32	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	171	33	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	171	34	federal	federal	ADJ
cjal-3338	171	35	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cjal-3338	171	36	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	171	37	tate	tate	NOUN
cjal-3338	171	38	access	access	NOUN
cjal-3338	171	39	floors	floor	NOUN
cjal-3338	171	40	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	171	41	inc	inc	PROPN
cjal-3338	171	42	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	172	1	v.	v.	ADP
cjal-3338	172	2	interface	interface	NOUN
cjal-3338	172	3	architectural	architectural	ADJ
cjal-3338	172	4	resources	resource	NOUN
cjal-3338	172	5	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	172	6	inc	inc	PROPN
cjal-3338	172	7	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	172	8	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	172	9	crystallized	crystallize	VERB
cjal-3338	172	10	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	172	11	principle	principle	NOUN
cjal-3338	172	12	that	that	SCONJ
cjal-3338	172	13	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	172	14	there	there	PRON
cjal-3338	172	15	is	be	VERB
cjal-3338	172	16	no	no	DET
cjal-3338	172	17	'	'	PUNCT
cjal-3338	172	18	practicing	practice	VERB
cjal-3338	172	19	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	172	20	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	172	21	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	172	22	'	'	PUNCT
cjal-3338	172	23	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	172	24	to	to	ADP
cjal-3338	172	25	literal	literal	ADJ
cjal-3338	172	26	infringement	infringement	NOUN
cjal-3338	172	27	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	172	28	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	173	1	27	27	NUM
cjal-3338	173	2	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	173	3	one	one	NUM
cjal-3338	173	4	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	173	5	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	173	6	string	string	NOUN
cjal-3338	173	7	citations	citation	NOUN
cjal-3338	173	8	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	173	9	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	173	10	tate	tate	PROPN
cjal-3338	173	11	access	access	PROPN
cjal-3338	173	12	floor	floor	PROPN
cjal-3338	173	13	court	court	NOUN
cjal-3338	173	14	wrote	write	VERB
cjal-3338	173	15	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	173	16	however	however	ADV
cjal-3338	173	17	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	173	18	that	that	SCONJ
cjal-3338	173	19	if	if	SCONJ
cjal-3338	173	20	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	173	21	infringement	infringement	NOUN
cjal-3338	173	22	theory	theory	NOUN
cjal-3338	173	23	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	173	24	based	base	VERB
cjal-3338	173	25	on	on	ADP
cjal-3338	173	26	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	173	27	doctrine	doctrine	NOUN
cjal-3338	173	28	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	173	29	equivalents	equivalent	NOUN
cjal-3338	173	30	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	173	31	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	173	32	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	173	33	defendant	defendant	NOUN
cjal-3338	173	34	would	would	AUX
cjal-3338	173	35	have	have	AUX
cjal-3338	173	36	had	have	VERB
cjal-3338	173	37	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	173	38	'	'	PUNCT
cjal-3338	173	39	complete	complete	ADJ
cjal-3338	173	40	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	173	41	'	'	PUNCT
cjal-3338	173	42	if	if	SCONJ
cjal-3338	173	43	practicing	practice	VERB
cjal-3338	173	44	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	173	45	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	173	46	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	173	47	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	173	48	because	because	SCONJ
cjal-3338	173	49	'	'	PUNCT
cjal-3338	173	50	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	173	51	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	173	52	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	173	53	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	173	54	prosecution	prosecution	NOUN
cjal-3338	173	55	history	history	NOUN
cjal-3338	173	56	estoppel	estoppel	NOUN
cjal-3338	173	57	provide	provide	VERB
cjal-3338	173	58	independent	independent	ADJ
cjal-3338	173	59	'	'	PUNCT
cjal-3338	173	60	policy	policy	NOUN
cjal-3338	173	61	oriented	orient	VERB
cjal-3338	173	62	'	'	PUNCT
cjal-3338	173	63	limitations	limitation	NOUN
cjal-3338	173	64	on	on	ADP
cjal-3338	173	65	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	173	66	doctrine	doctrine	NOUN
cjal-3338	173	67	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	173	68	equivalents	equivalent	NOUN
cjal-3338	173	69	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	174	1	''"s	''"s	PUNCT
cjal-3338	175	1	as	as	SCONJ
cjal-3338	175	2	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	175	3	federal	federal	ADJ
cjal-3338	175	4	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cjal-3338	175	5	clarified	clarify	VERB
cjal-3338	175	6	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	175	7	2009	2009	NUM
cjal-3338	175	8	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	175	9	this	this	PRON
cjal-3338	175	10	25	25	NUM
cjal-3338	175	11	siemens	siemen	NOUN
cjal-3338	175	12	med	me	VERB
cjal-3338	175	13	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	176	1	solutions	solutions	PROPN
cjal-3338	176	2	usa	usa	PROPN
cjal-3338	176	3	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	176	4	inc	inc	PROPN
cjal-3338	176	5	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	177	1	v.	v.	ADP
cjal-3338	177	2	saint	saint	PROPN
cjal-3338	177	3	-	-	PUNCT
cjal-3338	177	4	gobain	gobain	PROPN
cjal-3338	177	5	ceramics	ceramic	NOUN
cjal-3338	177	6	&	&	CCONJ
cjal-3338	177	7	plastics	plastics	PROPN
cjal-3338	177	8	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	177	9	inc	inc	PROPN
cjal-3338	177	10	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	177	11	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	177	12	637	637	NUM
cjal-3338	177	13	f.3d	f.3d	NUM
cjal-3338	177	14	1269	1269	NUM
cjal-3338	177	15	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	177	16	1282	1282	NUM
cjal-3338	177	17	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	177	18	fed	fed	PROPN
cjal-3338	177	19	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	177	20	cir	cir	PROPN
cjal-3338	177	21	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	177	22	2011	2011	NUM
cjal-3338	177	23	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	177	24	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	177	25	reh'g	reh'g	NOUN
cjal-3338	177	26	den	den	NOUN
cjal-3338	177	27	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	178	1	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	178	2	647	647	NUM
cjal-3338	178	3	f.	f.	NOUN
cjal-3338	178	4	3d	3d	NUM
cjal-3338	178	5	1373	1373	NUM
cjal-3338	178	6	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	178	7	fed	fed	PROPN
cjal-3338	178	8	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	178	9	cir	cir	PROPN
cjal-3338	178	10	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	179	1	2011	2011	NUM
cjal-3338	179	2	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	180	1	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	180	2	cert	cert	PROPN
cjal-3338	180	3	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	180	4	denied	deny	VERB
cjal-3338	180	5	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	180	6	132	132	NUM
cjal-3338	180	7	s.	s.	PROPN
cjal-3338	180	8	ct	ct	PROPN
cjal-3338	180	9	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	180	10	2679	2679	NUM
cjal-3338	180	11	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	180	12	2012	2012	NUM
cjal-3338	180	13	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	180	14	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	181	1	26	26	NUM
cjal-3338	181	2	2001	2001	NUM
cjal-3338	181	3	judicial	judicial	ADJ
cjal-3338	181	4	explanations	explanation	NOUN
cjal-3338	181	5	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	181	6	supra	supra	PROPN
cjal-3338	181	7	note	note	PROPN
cjal-3338	181	8	io	io	PROPN
cjal-3338	181	9	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	181	10	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	181	11	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	182	1	17	17	NUM
cjal-3338	182	2	.	.	X
cjal-3338	182	3	27	27	NUM
cjal-3338	182	4	tate	tate	NOUN
cjal-3338	182	5	access	access	NOUN
cjal-3338	182	6	floors	floor	NOUN
cjal-3338	182	7	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	182	8	inc	inc	PROPN
cjal-3338	182	9	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	182	10	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	182	11	279	279	NUM
cjal-3338	182	12	f.3	f.3	NOUN
cjal-3338	182	13	d	d	X
cjal-3338	182	14	1357	1357	NUM
cjal-3338	182	15	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	182	16	1365	1365	NUM
cjal-3338	182	17	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	182	18	fed	fed	PROPN
cjal-3338	182	19	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	182	20	cir	cir	PROPN
cjal-3338	182	21	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	182	22	2002	2002	NUM
cjal-3338	182	23	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	182	24	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	182	25	emphasis	emphasis	NOUN
cjal-3338	182	26	added	add	VERB
cjal-3338	182	27	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	182	28	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	183	1	see	see	VERB
cjal-3338	183	2	also	also	ADV
cjal-3338	183	3	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	183	4	re	re	VERB
cjal-3338	183	5	omeprazole	omeprazole	ADJ
cjal-3338	183	6	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	183	7	litig	litig	NOUN
cjal-3338	183	8	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	184	1	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	185	1	536	536	NUM
cjal-3338	185	2	f.3d	f.3d	NUM
cjal-3338	185	3	1361	1361	NUM
cjal-3338	185	4	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	185	5	1377	1377	NUM
cjal-3338	186	1	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	186	2	fed	fed	PROPN
cjal-3338	186	3	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	186	4	cir	cir	PROPN
cjal-3338	186	5	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	186	6	2008	2008	NUM
cjal-3338	186	7	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	187	1	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	187	2	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	187	3	[	[	X
cjal-3338	187	4	it	it	PRON
cjal-3338	187	5	]	]	PUNCT
cjal-3338	187	6	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	187	7	well	well	ADV
cjal-3338	187	8	established	establish	VERB
cjal-3338	187	9	...	...	PUNCT
cjal-3338	187	10	that	that	SCONJ
cjal-3338	187	11	'	'	AUX
cjal-3338	187	12	practicing	practice	VERB
cjal-3338	187	13	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	187	14	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	187	15	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	187	16	'	'	PUNCT
cjal-3338	187	17	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	187	18	not	not	PART
cjal-3338	187	19	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	187	20	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	187	21	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	187	22	infringement	infringement	NOUN
cjal-3338	187	23	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	187	24	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	187	25	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	187	26	quoting	quote	VERB
cjal-3338	187	27	tate	tate	PROPN
cjal-3338	187	28	access	access	NOUN
cjal-3338	187	29	floors	floor	NOUN
cjal-3338	187	30	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	187	31	inc	inc	PROPN
cjal-3338	187	32	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	188	1	v.	v.	ADP
cjal-3338	188	2	interface	interface	PROPN
cjal-3338	188	3	architectural	architectural	ADJ
cjal-3338	188	4	res	re	NOUN
cjal-3338	188	5	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	188	6	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	188	7	inc	inc	PROPN
cjal-3338	188	8	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	188	9	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	188	10	279	279	NUM
cjal-3338	188	11	f.3d	f.3d	NUM
cjal-3338	188	12	1357	1357	NUM
cjal-3338	188	13	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	188	14	1365	1365	NUM
cjal-3338	188	15	-	-	SYM
cjal-3338	188	16	1369	1369	NUM
cjal-3338	188	17	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	188	18	fed	fed	PROPN
cjal-3338	188	19	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	188	20	cir	cir	PROPN
cjal-3338	188	21	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	188	22	2002	2002	NUM
cjal-3338	188	23	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	188	24	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	189	1	;	;	PUNCT
cjal-3338	189	2	zenith	zenith	PROPN
cjal-3338	189	3	elec	elec	PROPN
cjal-3338	189	4	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	189	5	corp	corp	PROPN
cjal-3338	189	6	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	189	7	v.	v.	ADP
cjal-3338	189	8	pdi	pdi	PROPN
cjal-3338	189	9	commc'n	commc'n	PROPN
cjal-3338	189	10	sys	sys	PROPN
cjal-3338	189	11	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	189	12	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	189	13	522	522	NUM
cjal-3338	189	14	f.	f.	NOUN
cjal-3338	189	15	3d	3d	PROPN
cjal-3338	189	16	1348	1348	NUM
cjal-3338	189	17	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	189	18	1363	1363	NUM
cjal-3338	189	19	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	189	20	fed	fed	PROPN
cjal-3338	189	21	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	189	22	cir	cir	PROPN
cjal-3338	189	23	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	189	24	2008	2008	NUM
cjal-3338	189	25	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	189	26	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	189	27	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	189	28	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	189	29	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	189	30	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	189	31	noninfringement	noninfringement	NOUN
cjal-3338	189	32	can	can	AUX
cjal-3338	189	33	not	not	PART
cjal-3338	189	34	be	be	AUX
cjal-3338	189	35	proved	prove	VERB
cjal-3338	189	36	by	by	ADP
cjal-3338	189	37	comparing	compare	VERB
cjal-3338	189	38	an	an	DET
cjal-3338	189	39	accused	accuse	VERB
cjal-3338	189	40	product	product	NOUN
cjal-3338	189	41	to	to	ADP
cjal-3338	189	42	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	189	43	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	189	44	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	189	45	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	190	1	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	190	2	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	190	3	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	191	1	2	2	NUM
cjal-3338	191	2	8	8	NUM
cjal-3338	191	3	i	i	PRON
cjal-3338	191	4	d.	d.	NOUN
cjal-3338	191	5	at	at	ADP
cjal-3338	191	6	1367	1367	NUM
cjal-3338	191	7	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	191	8	citing	cite	VERB
cjal-3338	191	9	sextant	sextant	ADJ
cjal-3338	191	10	avionique	avionique	NOUN
cjal-3338	191	11	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	191	12	s.a	s.a	PROPN
cjal-3338	191	13	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	192	1	v.	v.	ADP
cjal-3338	192	2	analog	analog	PROPN
cjal-3338	192	3	devices	devices	PROPN
cjal-3338	192	4	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	192	5	inc	inc	PROPN
cjal-3338	192	6	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	192	7	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	192	8	172	172	NUM
cjal-3338	192	9	f.3d	f.3d	NUM
cjal-3338	192	10	817	817	NUM
cjal-3338	192	11	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	192	12	827	827	NUM
cjal-3338	192	13	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	192	14	fed	fed	PROPN
cjal-3338	192	15	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	192	16	cir	cir	PROPN
cjal-3338	192	17	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	192	18	1999	1999	NUM
cjal-3338	192	19	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	193	1	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	193	2	emphasis	emphasis	NOUN
cjal-3338	193	3	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	193	4	original	original	ADJ
cjal-3338	193	5	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	193	6	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	193	7	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	194	1	defensive	defensive	ADJ
cjal-3338	194	2	use	use	NOUN
cjal-3338	194	3	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	194	4	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	194	5	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	194	6	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	194	7	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cjal-3338	194	8	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	194	9	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	194	10	chinese	chinese	ADJ
cjal-3338	194	11	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	194	12	litigation	litigation	PROPN
cjal-3338	194	13	61	61	NUM
cjal-3338	194	14	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	194	15	to	to	ADP
cjal-3338	194	16	equivalents	equivalent	NOUN
cjal-3338	194	17	infringement	infringement	NOUN
cjal-3338	194	18	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	194	19	also	also	ADV
cjal-3338	194	20	known	know	VERB
cjal-3338	194	21	as	as	ADP
cjal-3338	194	22	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	194	23	ensnarement	ensnarement	NOUN
cjal-3338	194	24	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	194	25	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	194	26	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	194	27	bars	bar	VERB
cjal-3338	194	28	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	194	29	patentee	patentee	NOUN
cjal-3338	194	30	from	from	ADP
cjal-3338	194	31	asserting	assert	VERB
cjal-3338	194	32	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	194	33	scope	scope	NOUN
cjal-3338	194	34	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	194	35	equivalency	equivalency	NOUN
cjal-3338	194	36	that	that	PRON
cjal-3338	194	37	would	would	AUX
cjal-3338	194	38	encompass	encompass	VERB
cjal-3338	194	39	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	194	40	or	or	CCONJ
cjal-3338	194	41	ensnare	ensnare	VERB
cjal-3338	194	42	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	194	43	'	'	PUNCT
cjal-3338	194	44	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	194	45	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	194	46	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	194	47	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	195	1	"'2	"'2	PUNCT
cjal-3338	195	2	9	9	NUM
cjal-3338	195	3	such	such	DET
cjal-3338	195	4	an	an	DET
cjal-3338	195	5	exception	exception	NOUN
cjal-3338	195	6	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	195	7	because	because	SCONJ
cjal-3338	195	8	it	it	PRON
cjal-3338	195	9	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	195	10	applicable	applicable	ADJ
cjal-3338	195	11	only	only	ADV
cjal-3338	195	12	against	against	ADP
cjal-3338	195	13	equivalents	equivalent	NOUN
cjal-3338	195	14	infringement	infringement	NOUN
cjal-3338	195	15	theories	theory	NOUN
cjal-3338	195	16	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	195	17	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	195	18	rarely	rarely	ADV
cjal-3338	195	19	invoked.3	invoked.3	NOUN
cjal-3338	195	20	°	°	NOUN
cjal-3338	195	21	as	as	SCONJ
cjal-3338	195	22	john	john	PROPN
cjal-3338	195	23	allison	allison	PROPN
cjal-3338	195	24	has	have	AUX
cjal-3338	195	25	pointed	point	VERB
cjal-3338	195	26	out	out	ADP
cjal-3338	195	27	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	195	28	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	195	29	2007	2007	NUM
cjal-3338	195	30	empirical	empirical	ADJ
cjal-3338	195	31	study	study	NOUN
cjal-3338	195	32	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	195	33	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	195	34	[	[	X
cjal-3338	195	35	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	195	36	]	]	X
cjal-3338	195	37	doctrine	doctrine	NOUN
cjal-3338	195	38	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	195	39	equivalents	equivalent	NOUN
cjal-3338	195	40	was	be	AUX
cjal-3338	195	41	largely	largely	ADV
cjal-3338	195	42	dead	dead	ADJ
cjal-3338	195	43	by	by	ADP
cjal-3338	195	44	1998	1998	NUM
cjal-3338	195	45	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	196	1	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	196	2	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	196	3	'	'	PUNCT
cjal-3338	196	4	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	196	5	exception	exception	NOUN
cjal-3338	196	6	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	196	7	if	if	SCONJ
cjal-3338	196	8	it	it	PRON
cjal-3338	196	9	still	still	ADV
cjal-3338	196	10	exists	exist	VERB
cjal-3338	196	11	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	196	12	might	might	AUX
cjal-3338	196	13	as	as	ADV
cjal-3338	196	14	well	well	ADV
cjal-3338	196	15	be	be	AUX
cjal-3338	196	16	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	196	17	dead	dead	ADJ
cjal-3338	196	18	letter	letter	NOUN
cjal-3338	196	19	because	because	SCONJ
cjal-3338	196	20	equivalence	equivalence	NOUN
cjal-3338	196	21	has	have	AUX
cjal-3338	196	22	itself	itself	PRON
cjal-3338	196	23	gone	go	VERB
cjal-3338	196	24	out	out	ADP
cjal-3338	196	25	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	196	26	fashion	fashion	NOUN
cjal-3338	196	27	;	;	PUNCT
cjal-3338	196	28	for	for	ADP
cjal-3338	196	29	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	196	30	remainder	remainder	NOUN
cjal-3338	196	31	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	196	32	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	196	33	discussion	discussion	NOUN
cjal-3338	196	34	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	196	35	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	196	36	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	196	37	practicing	practice	VERB
cjal-3338	196	38	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	196	39	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	196	40	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	196	41	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	196	42	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	196	43	will	will	AUX
cjal-3338	196	44	be	be	AUX
cjal-3338	196	45	treated	treat	VERB
cjal-3338	196	46	as	as	SCONJ
cjal-3338	196	47	though	though	SCONJ
cjal-3338	196	48	it	it	PRON
cjal-3338	196	49	does	do	AUX
cjal-3338	196	50	not	not	PART
cjal-3338	196	51	exist	exist	VERB
cjal-3338	196	52	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	196	53	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cjal-3338	196	54	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	196	55	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	196	56	law	law	NOUN
cjal-3338	196	57	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	197	1	32	32	NUM
cjal-3338	197	2	29	29	NUM
cjal-3338	197	3	depuy	depuy	PROPN
cjal-3338	197	4	spine	spine	NOUN
cjal-3338	197	5	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	197	6	inc	inc	PROPN
cjal-3338	197	7	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	197	8	v.	v.	PROPN
cjal-3338	197	9	medtronic	medtronic	ADJ
cjal-3338	197	10	sofamor	sofamor	PROPN
cjal-3338	197	11	danek	danek	PROPN
cjal-3338	197	12	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	197	13	inc	inc	PROPN
cjal-3338	197	14	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	197	15	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	197	16	567	567	NUM
cjal-3338	197	17	f.3d	f.3d	NUM
cjal-3338	197	18	1314	1314	NUM
cjal-3338	197	19	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	197	20	1323	1323	NUM
cjal-3338	197	21	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	197	22	fed	fed	PROPN
cjal-3338	197	23	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	197	24	cir	cir	PROPN
cjal-3338	197	25	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	197	26	2009	2009	NUM
cjal-3338	197	27	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	197	28	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	197	29	citing	cite	VERB
cjal-3338	197	30	wilson	wilson	PROPN
cjal-3338	197	31	sporting	sporting	NOUN
cjal-3338	197	32	goods	goods	PROPN
cjal-3338	197	33	co.	co.	PROPN
cjal-3338	197	34	v.	v.	ADP
cjal-3338	197	35	david	david	PROPN
cjal-3338	197	36	geoffrey	geoffrey	PROPN
cjal-3338	197	37	&	&	CCONJ
cjal-3338	197	38	assoc	assoc	PROPN
cjal-3338	197	39	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	197	40	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	197	41	904	904	NUM
cjal-3338	197	42	f.2d	f.2d	ADP
cjal-3338	197	43	677	677	NUM
cjal-3338	197	44	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	197	45	683	683	NUM
cjal-3338	197	46	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	197	47	fed	fed	PROPN
cjal-3338	197	48	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	197	49	cir	cir	PROPN
cjal-3338	197	50	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	197	51	199o	199o	NUM
cjal-3338	197	52	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	197	53	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	197	54	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	198	1	30	30	NUM
cjal-3338	198	2	to	to	ADP
cjal-3338	198	3	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	198	4	best	good	ADJ
cjal-3338	198	5	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	198	6	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	198	7	author	author	NOUN
cjal-3338	198	8	's	's	PART
cjal-3338	198	9	knowledge	knowledge	NOUN
cjal-3338	198	10	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	198	11	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	198	12	federal	federal	ADJ
cjal-3338	198	13	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cjal-3338	198	14	has	have	AUX
cjal-3338	198	15	addressed	address	VERB
cjal-3338	198	16	this	this	DET
cjal-3338	198	17	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	198	18	only	only	ADV
cjal-3338	198	19	once	once	ADV
cjal-3338	198	20	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	198	21	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	198	22	nonprecedential	nonprecedential	ADJ
cjal-3338	198	23	opinion	opinion	NOUN
cjal-3338	198	24	since	since	SCONJ
cjal-3338	198	25	2010	2010	NUM
cjal-3338	198	26	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	199	1	icon	icon	PROPN
cjal-3338	199	2	health	health	PROPN
cjal-3338	199	3	&	&	CCONJ
cjal-3338	199	4	fitness	fitness	PROPN
cjal-3338	199	5	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	199	6	inc	inc	PROPN
cjal-3338	199	7	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	200	1	v.	v.	ADP
cjal-3338	200	2	octane	octane	PROPN
cjal-3338	200	3	fitness	fitness	PROPN
cjal-3338	200	4	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	200	5	llc	llc	PROPN
cjal-3338	200	6	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	200	7	496	496	NUM
cjal-3338	200	8	f.	f.	PROPN
cjal-3338	200	9	app'x	app'x	PROPN
cjal-3338	200	10	57	57	NUM
cjal-3338	200	11	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	200	12	65	65	NUM
cjal-3338	200	13	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	200	14	fed	fed	PROPN
cjal-3338	200	15	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	200	16	cir	cir	PROPN
cjal-3338	200	17	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	200	18	2012	2012	NUM
cjal-3338	200	19	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	201	1	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	201	2	rev'd	rev'd	VERB
cjal-3338	201	3	on	on	ADP
cjal-3338	201	4	other	other	ADJ
cjal-3338	201	5	grounds	ground	NOUN
cjal-3338	201	6	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	201	7	134	134	NUM
cjal-3338	201	8	s.	s.	PROPN
cjal-3338	201	9	ct	ct	PROPN
cjal-3338	201	10	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	201	11	1749	1749	NUM
cjal-3338	201	12	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	201	13	2014	2014	NUM
cjal-3338	201	14	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	201	15	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	202	1	3	3	X
cjal-3338	202	2	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	202	3	john	john	PROPN
cjal-3338	202	4	r.	r.	PROPN
cjal-3338	202	5	allison	allison	PROPN
cjal-3338	202	6	&	&	CCONJ
cjal-3338	202	7	mark	mark	PROPN
cjal-3338	202	8	a.	a.	PROPN
cjal-3338	202	9	lemley	lemley	PROPN
cjal-3338	202	10	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	202	11	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	202	12	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	202	13	unnoticed	unnoticed	ADJ
cjal-3338	202	14	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	202	15	demise	demise	NOUN
cjal-3338	202	16	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	202	17	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	202	18	doctrine	doctrine	NOUN
cjal-3338	202	19	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	202	20	equivalents	equivalent	NOUN
cjal-3338	202	21	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	202	22	59	59	NUM
cjal-3338	202	23	stan	stan	PROPN
cjal-3338	202	24	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	203	1	l.	l.	PROPN
cjal-3338	203	2	rev	rev	PROPN
cjal-3338	203	3	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	203	4	955	955	NUM
cjal-3338	203	5	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	203	6	976	976	NUM
cjal-3338	203	7	-	-	SYM
cjal-3338	203	8	977	977	NUM
cjal-3338	203	9	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	203	10	2007	2007	NUM
cjal-3338	203	11	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	203	12	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	204	1	32	32	NUM
cjal-3338	205	1	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	205	2	position	position	NOUN
cjal-3338	205	3	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	205	4	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	205	5	federal	federal	ADJ
cjal-3338	205	6	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cjal-3338	205	7	with	with	ADP
cjal-3338	205	8	regards	regard	NOUN
cjal-3338	205	9	to	to	ADP
cjal-3338	205	10	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	205	11	practicing	practice	VERB
cjal-3338	205	12	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	205	13	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	205	14	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	205	15	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	205	16	becomes	become	VERB
cjal-3338	205	17	more	more	ADV
cjal-3338	205	18	muddled	muddled	ADJ
cjal-3338	205	19	when	when	SCONJ
cjal-3338	205	20	indirect	indirect	ADJ
cjal-3338	205	21	infringement	infringement	NOUN
cjal-3338	205	22	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	205	23	considered	consider	VERB
cjal-3338	205	24	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	206	1	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	206	2	kinetic	kinetic	PROPN
cjal-3338	206	3	concepts	concepts	PROPN
cjal-3338	206	4	inc	inc	PROPN
cjal-3338	206	5	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	206	6	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	206	7	v.	v.	ADP
cjal-3338	206	8	blue	blue	ADJ
cjal-3338	206	9	sky	sky	PROPN
cjal-3338	206	10	medical	medical	PROPN
cjal-3338	206	11	group	group	PROPN
cjal-3338	206	12	inc	inc	PROPN
cjal-3338	206	13	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	206	14	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	206	15	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	206	16	federal	federal	ADJ
cjal-3338	206	17	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cjal-3338	206	18	stated	state	VERB
cjal-3338	206	19	that	that	SCONJ
cjal-3338	206	20	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	206	21	[	[	X
cjal-3338	206	22	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	206	23	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
cjal-3338	206	24	]	]	PUNCT
cjal-3338	206	25	may	may	AUX
cjal-3338	206	26	be	be	AUX
cjal-3338	206	27	correct	correct	ADJ
cjal-3338	206	28	that	that	SCONJ
cjal-3338	206	29	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	206	30	practicing	practice	VERB
cjal-3338	206	31	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	206	32	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	206	33	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	206	34	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	206	35	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	206	36	not	not	PART
cjal-3338	206	37	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	206	38	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	206	39	to	to	ADP
cjal-3338	206	40	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	206	41	infringement	infringement	NOUN
cjal-3338	206	42	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	207	1	however	however	ADV
cjal-3338	207	2	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	207	3	it	it	PRON
cjal-3338	207	4	does	do	AUX
cjal-3338	207	5	not	not	PART
cjal-3338	207	6	follow	follow	VERB
cjal-3338	207	7	that	that	SCONJ
cjal-3338	207	8	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	207	9	defendant	defendant	NOUN
cjal-3338	207	10	's	's	PART
cjal-3338	207	11	belief	belief	NOUN
cjal-3338	207	12	that	that	SCONJ
cjal-3338	207	13	it	it	PRON
cjal-3338	207	14	can	can	AUX
cjal-3338	207	15	freely	freely	ADV
cjal-3338	207	16	practice	practice	VERB
cjal-3338	207	17	inventions	invention	NOUN
cjal-3338	207	18	found	find	VERB
cjal-3338	207	19	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	207	20	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	207	21	public	public	ADJ
cjal-3338	207	22	domain	domain	NOUN
cjal-3338	207	23	can	can	AUX
cjal-3338	207	24	not	not	PART
cjal-3338	207	25	support	support	VERB
cjal-3338	207	26	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	207	27	jury	jury	NOUN
cjal-3338	207	28	's	's	PART
cjal-3338	207	29	finding	finding	NOUN
cjal-3338	207	30	that	that	SCONJ
cjal-3338	207	31	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	207	32	intent	intent	NOUN
cjal-3338	207	33	required	require	VERB
cjal-3338	207	34	for	for	ADP
cjal-3338	207	35	induced	induced	ADJ
cjal-3338	207	36	infringement	infringement	NOUN
cjal-3338	207	37	was	be	AUX
cjal-3338	207	38	lacking	lack	VERB
cjal-3338	207	39	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	208	1	kinetic	kinetic	PROPN
cjal-3338	208	2	concepts	concepts	PROPN
cjal-3338	208	3	inc	inc	PROPN
cjal-3338	209	1	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	209	2	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	209	3	v.	v.	ADP
cjal-3338	209	4	blue	blue	ADJ
cjal-3338	209	5	sky	sky	NOUN
cjal-3338	209	6	med	med	PROPN
cjal-3338	209	7	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	210	1	grp	grp	PROPN
cjal-3338	210	2	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	210	3	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	210	4	554	554	NUM
cjal-3338	210	5	f.3d	f.3d	NUM
cjal-3338	210	6	1o0	1o0	NUM
cjal-3338	210	7	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	210	8	1025	1025	NUM
cjal-3338	210	9	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	210	10	fed	fed	PROPN
cjal-3338	210	11	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	210	12	cir	cir	PROPN
cjal-3338	210	13	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	210	14	2009	2009	NUM
cjal-3338	210	15	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	210	16	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	210	17	citation	citation	NOUN
cjal-3338	210	18	omitted	omit	VERB
cjal-3338	210	19	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	210	20	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	211	1	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	211	2	subject	subject	NOUN
cjal-3338	211	3	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	211	4	indirect	indirect	ADJ
cjal-3338	211	5	infringement	infringement	NOUN
cjal-3338	211	6	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	211	7	beyond	beyond	ADP
cjal-3338	211	8	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	211	9	scope	scope	NOUN
cjal-3338	211	10	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	211	11	this	this	DET
cjal-3338	211	12	article	article	NOUN
cjal-3338	211	13	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	212	1	6z	6z	PROPN
cjal-3338	212	2	columbia	columbia	PROPN
cjal-3338	212	3	journal	journal	PROPN
cjal-3338	212	4	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	212	5	asian	asian	ADJ
cjal-3338	212	6	law	law	NOUN
cjal-3338	212	7	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	212	8	vol	vol	NOUN
cjal-3338	212	9	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	213	1	27	27	NUM
cjal-3338	213	2	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	213	3	no	no	INTJ
cjal-3338	213	4	.	.	NOUN
cjal-3338	213	5	1	1	NUM
cjal-3338	213	6	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	213	7	2o13	2o13	NUM
cjal-3338	213	8	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	213	9	b.	b.	NOUN
cjal-3338	213	10	existing	exist	VERB
cjal-3338	213	11	technology	technology	NOUN
cjal-3338	213	12	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	213	13	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	213	14	chinese	chinese	ADJ
cjal-3338	213	15	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	213	16	infringement	infringement	NOUN
cjal-3338	213	17	litigation	litigation	NOUN
cjal-3338	213	18	1	1	NUM
cjal-3338	213	19	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	213	20	statutory	statutory	ADJ
cjal-3338	213	21	basis	basis	NOUN
cjal-3338	213	22	unlike	unlike	ADP
cjal-3338	213	23	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	213	24	united	united	PROPN
cjal-3338	213	25	states	states	PROPN
cjal-3338	213	26	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	213	27	china	china	PROPN
cjal-3338	213	28	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	213	29	one	one	NUM
cjal-3338	213	30	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	213	31	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	213	32	countries	country	NOUN
cjal-3338	213	33	that	that	PRON
cjal-3338	213	34	does	do	AUX
cjal-3338	213	35	offer	offer	VERB
cjal-3338	213	36	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	213	37	practicing	practice	VERB
cjal-3338	213	38	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	213	39	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	213	40	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	213	41	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	213	42	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	213	43	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	213	44	law.33	law.33	NOUN
cjal-3338	213	45	article	article	NOUN
cjal-3338	213	46	sixty	sixty	NUM
cjal-3338	213	47	two	two	NUM
cjal-3338	213	48	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	213	49	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	213	50	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	213	51	law	law	NOUN
cjal-3338	213	52	explicitly	explicitly	ADV
cjal-3338	213	53	makes	make	VERB
cjal-3338	213	54	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	213	55	existing	exist	VERB
cjal-3338	213	56	technology	technology	NOUN
cjal-3338	213	57	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	213	58	available	available	ADJ
cjal-3338	213	59	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	213	60	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	213	61	infringement	infringement	NOUN
cjal-3338	213	62	litigation	litigation	NOUN
cjal-3338	213	63	:	:	PUNCT
cjal-3338	213	64	article	article	NOUN
cjal-3338	213	65	sixty	sixty	NUM
cjal-3338	213	66	two	two	NUM
cjal-3338	213	67	when	when	SCONJ
cjal-3338	213	68	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	213	69	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	213	70	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	213	71	infringement	infringement	NOUN
cjal-3338	213	72	dispute	dispute	VERB
cjal-3338	213	73	an	an	DET
cjal-3338	213	74	accused	accuse	VERB
cjal-3338	213	75	infringer	infringer	NOUN
cjal-3338	213	76	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	213	77	able	able	ADJ
cjal-3338	213	78	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	213	79	demonstrate	demonstrate	VERB
cjal-3338	213	80	that	that	SCONJ
cjal-3338	213	81	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	213	82	technology	technology	NOUN
cjal-3338	213	83	or	or	CCONJ
cjal-3338	213	84	design	design	NOUN
cjal-3338	213	85	he	he	PRON
cjal-3338	213	86	practices	practice	VERB
cjal-3338	213	87	belongs	belong	VERB
cjal-3338	213	88	to	to	ADP
cjal-3338	213	89	existing	exist	VERB
cjal-3338	213	90	technology	technology	NOUN
cjal-3338	213	91	or	or	CCONJ
cjal-3338	213	92	existing	exist	VERB
cjal-3338	213	93	designs	design	NOUN
cjal-3338	213	94	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	213	95	such	such	ADJ
cjal-3338	213	96	technology	technology	NOUN
cjal-3338	213	97	or	or	CCONJ
cjal-3338	213	98	design	design	NOUN
cjal-3338	213	99	shall	shall	AUX
cjal-3338	213	100	not	not	PART
cjal-3338	213	101	constitute	constitute	VERB
cjal-3338	213	102	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	213	103	infringement.3	infringement.3	PROPN
cjal-3338	213	104	4	4	NUM
cjal-3338	213	105	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	213	106	supreme	supreme	PROPN
cjal-3338	213	107	people	people	PROPN
cjal-3338	213	108	's	's	PART
cjal-3338	213	109	court	court	NOUN
cjal-3338	213	110	further	far	ADV
cjal-3338	213	111	clarified	clarify	VERB
cjal-3338	213	112	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	213	113	nature	nature	NOUN
cjal-3338	213	114	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	213	115	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	213	116	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	213	117	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	213	118	article	article	NOUN
cjal-3338	213	119	fourteen	fourteen	NUM
cjal-3338	213	120	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	213	121	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	213	122	2oo	2oo	ADJ
cjal-3338	213	123	judicial	judicial	ADJ
cjal-3338	213	124	explanations	explanation	NOUN
cjal-3338	213	125	:	:	PUNCT
cjal-3338	213	126	33	33	NUM
cjal-3338	213	127	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	213	128	practicing	practice	VERB
cjal-3338	213	129	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	213	130	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	213	131	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	213	132	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	213	133	can	can	AUX
cjal-3338	213	134	be	be	AUX
cjal-3338	213	135	structured	structure	VERB
cjal-3338	213	136	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	213	137	many	many	ADJ
cjal-3338	213	138	different	different	ADJ
cjal-3338	213	139	ways	way	NOUN
cjal-3338	213	140	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	214	1	for	for	ADP
cjal-3338	214	2	example	example	NOUN
cjal-3338	214	3	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	214	4	south	south	PROPN
cjal-3338	214	5	korea	korea	PROPN
cjal-3338	214	6	also	also	ADV
cjal-3338	214	7	has	have	VERB
cjal-3338	214	8	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	214	9	practicing	practice	VERB
cjal-3338	214	10	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	214	11	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	214	12	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	214	13	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	214	14	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	214	15	but	but	CCONJ
cjal-3338	214	16	it	it	PRON
cjal-3338	214	17	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	214	18	invoked	invoke	VERB
cjal-3338	214	19	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	214	20	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	214	21	form	form	NOUN
cjal-3338	214	22	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	214	23	administration	administration	NOUN
cjal-3338	214	24	adjudicative	adjudicative	NOUN
cjal-3338	214	25	called	call	VERB
cjal-3338	214	26	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	214	27	trial	trial	NOUN
cjal-3338	214	28	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	214	29	confirm	confirm	VERB
cjal-3338	214	30	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	214	31	scope	scope	NOUN
cjal-3338	214	32	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	214	33	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	214	34	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	214	35	right	right	NOUN
cjal-3338	214	36	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	215	1	sang	sing	VERB
cjal-3338	215	2	jo	jo	PROPN
cjal-3338	215	3	jong	jong	PROPN
cjal-3338	215	4	provides	provide	VERB
cjal-3338	215	5	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	215	6	following	follow	VERB
cjal-3338	215	7	explanation	explanation	NOUN
cjal-3338	215	8	:	:	PUNCT
cjal-3338	215	9	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	215	10	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	215	11	trial	trial	NOUN
cjal-3338	215	12	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	215	13	confirm	confirm	VERB
cjal-3338	215	14	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	215	15	scope	scope	NOUN
cjal-3338	215	16	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	215	17	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	215	18	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	215	19	right	right	NOUN
cjal-3338	215	20	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	215	21	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	215	22	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	215	23	quasi	quasi	ADJ
cjal-3338	215	24	-	-	ADJ
cjal-3338	215	25	judicial	judicial	ADJ
cjal-3338	215	26	trial	trial	NOUN
cjal-3338	215	27	where	where	SCONJ
cjal-3338	215	28	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	215	29	[	[	X
cjal-3338	215	30	intellectual	intellectual	ADJ
cjal-3338	215	31	property	property	NOUN
cjal-3338	215	32	tribunal	tribunal	NOUN
cjal-3338	215	33	]	]	PUNCT
cjal-3338	215	34	determines	determine	VERB
cjal-3338	215	35	whether	whether	SCONJ
cjal-3338	215	36	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	215	37	allegedly	allegedly	ADV
cjal-3338	215	38	infringing	infringe	VERB
cjal-3338	215	39	product	product	NOUN
cjal-3338	215	40	falls	fall	VERB
cjal-3338	215	41	under	under	ADP
cjal-3338	215	42	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	215	43	scope	scope	NOUN
cjal-3338	215	44	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	215	45	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	215	46	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	215	47	right	right	NOUN
cjal-3338	215	48	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	215	49	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	215	50	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	215	51	right	right	ADJ
cjal-3338	215	52	dispute	dispute	NOUN
cjal-3338	215	53	....	....	PUNCT
cjal-3338	216	1	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	216	2	trial	trial	NOUN
cjal-3338	216	3	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	216	4	confirm	confirm	VERB
cjal-3338	216	5	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	216	6	scope	scope	NOUN
cjal-3338	216	7	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	216	8	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	216	9	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	216	10	right	right	NOUN
cjal-3338	216	11	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	216	12	similar	similar	ADJ
cjal-3338	216	13	to	to	ADP
cjal-3338	216	14	any	any	DET
cjal-3338	216	15	other	other	ADJ
cjal-3338	216	16	confirmation	confirmation	NOUN
cjal-3338	216	17	trial	trial	NOUN
cjal-3338	216	18	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	216	19	feststellungsklage	feststellungsklage	NOUN
cjal-3338	216	20	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	216	21	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	216	22	has	have	VERB
cjal-3338	216	23	both	both	CCONJ
cjal-3338	216	24	an	an	DET
cjal-3338	216	25	active	active	ADJ
cjal-3338	216	26	confirmation	confirmation	NOUN
cjal-3338	216	27	trial	trial	NOUN
cjal-3338	216	28	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	216	29	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	216	30	passive	passive	ADJ
cjal-3338	216	31	confirmation	confirmation	NOUN
cjal-3338	216	32	trial	trial	NOUN
cjal-3338	216	33	;	;	PUNCT
cjal-3338	216	34	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	216	35	former	former	NOUN
cjal-3338	216	36	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	216	37	where	where	SCONJ
cjal-3338	216	38	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	216	39	patentee	patentee	NOUN
cjal-3338	216	40	actively	actively	ADV
cjal-3338	216	41	sets	set	VERB
cjal-3338	216	42	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	216	43	scope	scope	NOUN
cjal-3338	216	44	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	216	45	their	their	PRON
cjal-3338	216	46	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	216	47	right	right	NOUN
cjal-3338	216	48	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	216	49	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	216	50	later	later	NOUN
cjal-3338	216	51	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	216	52	where	where	SCONJ
cjal-3338	216	53	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	216	54	opposing	opposing	ADJ
cjal-3338	216	55	interested	interested	ADJ
cjal-3338	216	56	party	party	NOUN
cjal-3338	216	57	requests	request	NOUN
cjal-3338	216	58	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	216	59	confirmation	confirmation	NOUN
cjal-3338	216	60	on	on	ADP
cjal-3338	216	61	their	their	PRON
cjal-3338	216	62	working	working	NOUN
cjal-3338	216	63	method	method	NOUN
cjal-3338	216	64	's	's	PART
cjal-3338	216	65	non	non	NOUN
cjal-3338	216	66	-	-	NOUN
cjal-3338	216	67	infringement	infringement	NOUN
cjal-3338	216	68	...	...	PUNCT
cjal-3338	216	69	...	...	PUNCT
cjal-3338	217	1	an	an	DET
cjal-3338	217	2	interesting	interesting	ADJ
cjal-3338	217	3	point	point	NOUN
cjal-3338	217	4	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	217	5	that	that	SCONJ
cjal-3338	217	6	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	217	7	court	court	NOUN
cjal-3338	217	8	denies	deny	VERB
cjal-3338	217	9	that	that	SCONJ
cjal-3338	217	10	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	217	11	defendant	defendant	NOUN
cjal-3338	217	12	's	's	PART
cjal-3338	217	13	invention	invention	NOUN
cjal-3338	217	14	lies	lie	VERB
cjal-3338	217	15	within	within	ADP
cjal-3338	217	16	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	217	17	scope	scope	NOUN
cjal-3338	217	18	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	217	19	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	217	20	plaintifj	plaintifj	NOUN
cjal-3338	217	21	's	's	PART
cjal-3338	217	22	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	218	1	right	right	NOUN
cjal-3338	218	2	not	not	PART
cjal-3338	218	3	because	because	SCONJ
cjal-3338	218	4	it	it	PRON
cjal-3338	218	5	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	218	6	identical	identical	ADJ
cjal-3338	218	7	or	or	CCONJ
cjal-3338	218	8	easily	easily	ADV
cjal-3338	218	9	created	create	VERB
cjal-3338	218	10	from	from	ADP
cjal-3338	218	11	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	218	12	publicly	publicly	ADV
cjal-3338	218	13	known	know	VERB
cjal-3338	218	14	or	or	CCONJ
cjal-3338	218	15	worked	work	VERB
cjal-3338	218	16	invention	invention	NOUN
cjal-3338	218	17	or	or	CCONJ
cjal-3338	218	18	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	218	19	itself	itself	PRON
cjal-3338	218	20	invalid	invalid	ADJ
cjal-3338	218	21	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	218	22	but	but	CCONJ
cjal-3338	218	23	upon	upon	SCONJ
cjal-3338	218	24	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	218	25	argument	argument	NOUN
cjal-3338	218	26	that	that	SCONJ
cjal-3338	218	27	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	218	28	defendant	defendant	NOUN
cjal-3338	218	29	's	's	PART
cjal-3338	218	30	invention	invention	NOUN
cjal-3338	218	31	merely	merely	ADV
cjal-3338	218	32	utilizes	utilize	VERB
cjal-3338	218	33	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	218	34	publicly	publicly	ADV
cjal-3338	218	35	known	know	VERB
cjal-3338	218	36	or	or	CCONJ
cjal-3338	218	37	worked	work	VERB
cjal-3338	218	38	invention	invention	NOUN
cjal-3338	218	39	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	219	1	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	219	2	other	other	ADJ
cjal-3338	219	3	words	word	NOUN
cjal-3338	219	4	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	219	5	although	although	SCONJ
cjal-3338	219	6	you	you	PRON
cjal-3338	219	7	can	can	AUX
cjal-3338	219	8	not	not	PART
cjal-3338	219	9	invalidate	invalidate	VERB
cjal-3338	219	10	an	an	DET
cjal-3338	219	11	invention	invention	NOUN
cjal-3338	219	12	lacking	lack	VERB
cjal-3338	219	13	inventive	inventive	ADJ
cjal-3338	219	14	step	step	NOUN
cjal-3338	219	15	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	219	16	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	219	17	trial	trial	NOUN
cjal-3338	219	18	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	219	19	confirm	confirm	VERB
cjal-3338	219	20	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	219	21	scope	scope	NOUN
cjal-3338	219	22	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	219	23	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	219	24	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	219	25	right	right	NOUN
cjal-3338	219	26	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	219	27	unlike	unlike	ADP
cjal-3338	219	28	an	an	DET
cjal-3338	219	29	invalidation	invalidation	NOUN
cjal-3338	219	30	trial	trial	NOUN
cjal-3338	219	31	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	219	32	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	219	33	you	you	PRON
cjal-3338	219	34	can	can	AUX
cjal-3338	219	35	confirm	confirm	VERB
cjal-3338	219	36	that	that	SCONJ
cjal-3338	219	37	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	219	38	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	219	39	claim	claim	NOUN
cjal-3338	219	40	that	that	PRON
cjal-3338	219	41	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	219	42	easily	easily	ADV
cjal-3338	219	43	created	create	VERB
cjal-3338	219	44	from	from	ADP
cjal-3338	219	45	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	219	46	publicly	publicly	ADV
cjal-3338	219	47	known	know	VERB
cjal-3338	219	48	or	or	CCONJ
cjal-3338	219	49	worked	work	VERB
cjal-3338	219	50	invention	invention	NOUN
cjal-3338	219	51	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	219	52	does	do	AUX
cjal-3338	219	53	not	not	PART
cjal-3338	219	54	lie	lie	VERB
cjal-3338	219	55	within	within	ADP
cjal-3338	219	56	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	219	57	scope	scope	NOUN
cjal-3338	219	58	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	219	59	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	219	60	right	right	NOUN
cjal-3338	219	61	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	219	62	question	question	NOUN
cjal-3338	219	63	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	220	1	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	220	2	important	important	ADJ
cjal-3338	220	3	question	question	NOUN
cjal-3338	220	4	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	220	5	whether	whether	SCONJ
cjal-3338	220	6	this	this	DET
cjal-3338	220	7	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	220	8	publicly	publicly	ADV
cjal-3338	220	9	known	know	VERB
cjal-3338	220	10	or	or	CCONJ
cjal-3338	220	11	worked	work	VERB
cjal-3338	220	12	invention	invention	NOUN
cjal-3338	220	13	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	220	14	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	220	15	can	can	AUX
cjal-3338	220	16	also	also	ADV
cjal-3338	220	17	be	be	AUX
cjal-3338	220	18	used	use	VERB
cjal-3338	220	19	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	220	20	civil	civil	ADJ
cjal-3338	220	21	or	or	CCONJ
cjal-3338	220	22	criminal	criminal	ADJ
cjal-3338	220	23	suits	suit	NOUN
cjal-3338	220	24	as	as	SCONJ
cjal-3338	220	25	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	220	26	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	220	27	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	220	28	trial	trial	NOUN
cjal-3338	220	29	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	220	30	confirm	confirm	VERB
cjal-3338	220	31	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	220	32	scope	scope	NOUN
cjal-3338	220	33	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	220	34	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	220	35	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	220	36	right	right	NOUN
cjal-3338	220	37	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	221	1	sang	sing	VERB
cjal-3338	221	2	jo	jo	PROPN
cjal-3338	221	3	jong	jong	PROPN
cjal-3338	221	4	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	221	5	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	221	6	litigation	litigation	NOUN
cjal-3338	221	7	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	221	8	korea	korea	PROPN
cjal-3338	221	9	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	221	10	6	6	NUM
cjal-3338	221	11	j.	j.	PROPN
cjal-3338	221	12	korean	korean	PROPN
cjal-3338	221	13	l.	l.	PROPN
cjal-3338	221	14	201	201	NUM
cjal-3338	221	15	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	221	16	205	205	NUM
cjal-3338	221	17	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	221	18	2007	2007	NUM
cjal-3338	221	19	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	221	20	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	221	21	citation	citation	NOUN
cjal-3338	221	22	omitted	omit	VERB
cjal-3338	221	23	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	221	24	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	221	25	emphasis	emphasis	NOUN
cjal-3338	221	26	added	add	VERB
cjal-3338	221	27	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	221	28	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	222	1	34	34	NUM
cjal-3338	222	2	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	222	3	law	law	NOUN
cjal-3338	222	4	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	222	5	supra	supra	PROPN
cjal-3338	222	6	note	note	PROPN
cjal-3338	222	7	18	18	NUM
cjal-3338	222	8	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	222	9	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	222	10	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	223	1	62	62	NUM
cjal-3338	223	2	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	224	1	defensive	defensive	ADJ
cjal-3338	224	2	use	use	NOUN
cjal-3338	224	3	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	224	4	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	224	5	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	224	6	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	224	7	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cjal-3338	224	8	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	224	9	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	224	10	chinese	chinese	ADJ
cjal-3338	224	11	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	224	12	litigation	litigation	NOUN
cjal-3338	224	13	63	63	NUM
cjal-3338	224	14	article	article	NOUN
cjal-3338	224	15	fourteen	fourteen	NUM
cjal-3338	224	16	where	where	SCONJ
cjal-3338	224	17	all	all	DET
cjal-3338	224	18	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	224	19	technical	technical	ADJ
cjal-3338	224	20	features	feature	NOUN
cjal-3338	224	21	accused	accuse	VERB
cjal-3338	224	22	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	224	23	falling	fall	VERB
cjal-3338	224	24	within	within	ADP
cjal-3338	224	25	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	224	26	protective	protective	ADJ
cjal-3338	224	27	scope	scope	NOUN
cjal-3338	224	28	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	224	29	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	224	30	rights	right	NOUN
cjal-3338	224	31	are	be	AUX
cjal-3338	224	32	identical	identical	ADJ
cjal-3338	224	33	to	to	ADP
cjal-3338	224	34	or	or	CCONJ
cjal-3338	224	35	not	not	PART
cjal-3338	224	36	substantively	substantively	ADV
cjal-3338	224	37	different	different	ADJ
cjal-3338	224	38	from	from	ADP
cjal-3338	224	39	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	224	40	corresponding	correspond	VERB
cjal-3338	224	41	features	feature	NOUN
cjal-3338	224	42	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	224	43	an	an	DET
cjal-3338	224	44	existing	exist	VERB
cjal-3338	224	45	technical	technical	ADJ
cjal-3338	224	46	solution	solution	NOUN
cjal-3338	224	47	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	224	48	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	224	49	people	people	NOUN
cjal-3338	224	50	's	's	PART
cjal-3338	224	51	court	court	NOUN
cjal-3338	224	52	shall	shall	AUX
cjal-3338	224	53	find	find	VERB
cjal-3338	224	54	that	that	SCONJ
cjal-3338	224	55	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	224	56	technology	technology	NOUN
cjal-3338	224	57	practiced	practice	VERB
cjal-3338	224	58	by	by	ADP
cjal-3338	224	59	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	224	60	accused	accuse	VERB
cjal-3338	224	61	infringer	infringer	NOUN
cjal-3338	224	62	belongs	belong	VERB
cjal-3338	224	63	to	to	ADP
cjal-3338	224	64	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	224	65	existing	exist	VERB
cjal-3338	224	66	technology	technology	NOUN
cjal-3338	224	67	set	set	VERB
cjal-3338	224	68	forth	forth	ADP
cjal-3338	224	69	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	224	70	article	article	NOUN
cjal-3338	224	71	sixty	sixty	NUM
cjal-3338	224	72	two	two	NUM
cjal-3338	224	73	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	224	74	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	224	75	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	224	76	law	law	NOUN
cjal-3338	224	77	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	224	78	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	225	1	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	225	2	language	language	NOUN
cjal-3338	225	3	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	225	4	technical	technical	ADJ
cjal-3338	225	5	features	feature	NOUN
cjal-3338	225	6	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	225	7	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	226	1	identical	identical	ADJ
cjal-3338	226	2	to	to	ADP
cjal-3338	226	3	or	or	CCONJ
cjal-3338	226	4	not	not	PART
cjal-3338	226	5	substantively	substantively	ADV
cjal-3338	226	6	different	different	ADJ
cjal-3338	226	7	from	from	ADP
cjal-3338	226	8	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	226	9	corresponding	correspond	VERB
cjal-3338	226	10	features	feature	NOUN
cjal-3338	226	11	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	226	12	an	an	DET
cjal-3338	226	13	existing	exist	VERB
cjal-3338	226	14	technical	technical	ADJ
cjal-3338	226	15	solution	solution	NOUN
cjal-3338	226	16	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	226	17	states	state	VERB
cjal-3338	226	18	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	226	19	direct	direct	ADJ
cjal-3338	226	20	linkage	linkage	NOUN
cjal-3338	226	21	between	between	ADP
cjal-3338	226	22	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	226	23	standards	standard	NOUN
cjal-3338	226	24	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	226	25	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	226	26	existing	exist	VERB
cjal-3338	226	27	technology	technology	NOUN
cjal-3338	226	28	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	226	29	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	226	30	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	226	31	standards	standard	NOUN
cjal-3338	226	32	for	for	ADP
cjal-3338	226	33	literal	literal	ADJ
cjal-3338	226	34	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	226	35	equivalents	equivalent	NOUN
cjal-3338	226	36	infringement	infringement	NOUN
cjal-3338	226	37	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	227	1	2	2	X
cjal-3338	227	2	.	.	X
cjal-3338	227	3	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	227	4	existing	exist	VERB
cjal-3338	227	5	technology	technology	NOUN
cjal-3338	227	6	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	227	7	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	227	8	practice	practice	NOUN
cjal-3338	227	9	as	as	SCONJ
cjal-3338	227	10	expected	expect	VERB
cjal-3338	227	11	from	from	ADP
cjal-3338	227	12	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	227	13	language	language	NOUN
cjal-3338	227	14	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	227	15	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	227	16	2010	2010	NUM
cjal-3338	227	17	judicial	judicial	ADJ
cjal-3338	227	18	explanations	explanation	NOUN
cjal-3338	227	19	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	227	20	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	227	21	existing	exist	VERB
cjal-3338	227	22	technology	technology	NOUN
cjal-3338	227	23	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	227	24	closely	closely	ADV
cjal-3338	227	25	tracks	track	VERB
cjal-3338	227	26	literality	literality	NOUN
cjal-3338	227	27	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	227	28	equivalence	equivalence	NOUN
cjal-3338	227	29	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	227	30	includes	include	VERB
cjal-3338	227	31	all	all	PRON
cjal-3338	227	32	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	227	33	their	their	PRON
cjal-3338	227	34	subtests	subtest	NOUN
cjal-3338	227	35	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	228	1	6	6	NUM
cjal-3338	228	2	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	228	3	denying	deny	VERB
cjal-3338	228	4	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	228	5	retrial	retrial	NOUN
cjal-3338	228	6	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	228	7	strix	strix	PROPN
cjal-3338	228	8	v.	v.	ADP
cjal-3338	228	9	ningbo	ningbo	PROPN
cjal-3338	228	10	sunlight	sunlight	NOUN
cjal-3338	228	11	electrical	electrical	ADJ
cjal-3338	228	12	appliance	appliance	NOUN
cjal-3338	228	13	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	228	14	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	228	15	supreme	supreme	PROPN
cjal-3338	228	16	people	people	PROPN
cjal-3338	228	17	's	's	PART
cjal-3338	228	18	court	court	NOUN
cjal-3338	228	19	stated	state	VERB
cjal-3338	228	20	:	:	PUNCT
cjal-3338	228	21	guanyu	guanyu	PROPN
cjal-3338	228	22	shenli	shenli	VERB
cjal-3338	228	23	qinfan	qinfan	PROPN
cjal-3338	228	24	zhuanli	zhuanli	PROPN
cjal-3338	228	25	quan	quan	PROPN
cjal-3338	229	1	jiufen	jiufen	PROPN
cjal-3338	229	2	anjian	anjian	PROPN
cjal-3338	229	3	yingyong	yingyong	NOUN
cjal-3338	229	4	falu	falu	PROPN
cjal-3338	229	5	ruogan	ruogan	VERB
cjal-3338	229	6	wenti	wenti	PROPN
cjal-3338	229	7	di	di	X
cjal-3338	229	8	jieshi	jieshi	PROPN
cjal-3338	229	9	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	229	10	-f	-f	NUM
cjal-3338	229	11	l	l	NOUN
cjal-3338	230	1	[	[	X
cjal-3338	230	2	explanations	explanation	NOUN
cjal-3338	230	3	on	on	ADP
cjal-3338	230	4	several	several	ADJ
cjal-3338	230	5	issues	issue	NOUN
cjal-3338	230	6	concerning	concern	VERB
cjal-3338	230	7	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	230	8	law	law	NOUN
cjal-3338	230	9	appropriate	appropriate	ADJ
cjal-3338	230	10	for	for	ADP
cjal-3338	230	11	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	230	12	adjudication	adjudication	NOUN
cjal-3338	230	13	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	230	14	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	230	15	rights	right	NOUN
cjal-3338	230	16	infringement	infringement	NOUN
cjal-3338	230	17	disputes	dispute	NOUN
cjal-3338	230	18	]	]	PUNCT
cjal-3338	230	19	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	230	20	promulgated	promulgate	VERB
cjal-3338	230	21	by	by	ADP
cjal-3338	230	22	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	230	23	sup	sup	NOUN
cjal-3338	230	24	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	231	1	people	people	NOUN
cjal-3338	231	2	's	's	PART
cjal-3338	231	3	ct	ct	PROPN
cjal-3338	231	4	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	231	5	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	231	6	dec	dec	PROPN
cjal-3338	231	7	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	231	8	21	21	NUM
cjal-3338	231	9	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	231	10	2009	2009	NUM
cjal-3338	231	11	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	231	12	effective	effective	ADJ
cjal-3338	231	13	jan	jan	PROPN
cjal-3338	231	14	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	231	15	1	1	NUM
cjal-3338	231	16	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	231	17	2o10	2o10	VERB
cjal-3338	231	18	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	231	19	2010	2010	NUM
cjal-3338	231	20	sup	sup	NOUN
cjal-3338	231	21	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	232	1	people	people	NOUN
cjal-3338	232	2	's	's	PART
cjal-3338	232	3	ct	ct	PROPN
cjal-3338	232	4	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	232	5	gaz	gaz	PROPN
cjal-3338	232	6	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	232	7	5	5	NUM
cjal-3338	232	8	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	232	9	china	china	PROPN
cjal-3338	232	10	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	232	11	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	232	12	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	232	13	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	233	1	14	14	NUM
cjal-3338	233	2	.	.	NUM
cjal-3338	233	3	36	36	NUM
cjal-3338	233	4	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	233	5	an	an	DET
cjal-3338	233	6	article	article	NOUN
cjal-3338	233	7	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	233	8	china	china	PROPN
cjal-3338	233	9	law	law	PROPN
cjal-3338	233	10	&	&	CCONJ
cjal-3338	233	11	practice	practice	NOUN
cjal-3338	233	12	titled	title	VERB
cjal-3338	233	13	prior	prior	ADV
cjal-3338	233	14	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	233	15	defence	defence	NOUN
cjal-3338	233	16	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	233	17	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	233	18	litigation	litigation	NOUN
cjal-3338	233	19	:	:	PUNCT
cjal-3338	233	20	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	233	21	legal	legal	ADJ
cjal-3338	233	22	quagmire	quagmire	NOUN
cjal-3338	233	23	?	?	PUNCT
cjal-3338	233	24	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	233	25	fang	fang	PROPN
cjal-3338	233	26	qi	qi	PROPN
cjal-3338	233	27	suggests	suggest	VERB
cjal-3338	233	28	that	that	SCONJ
cjal-3338	233	29	there	there	PRON
cjal-3338	233	30	has	have	AUX
cjal-3338	233	31	been	be	AUX
cjal-3338	233	32	no	no	DET
cjal-3338	233	33	clear	clear	ADJ
cjal-3338	233	34	standard	standard	NOUN
cjal-3338	233	35	for	for	ADP
cjal-3338	233	36	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	233	37	existing	exist	VERB
cjal-3338	233	38	technology	technology	NOUN
cjal-3338	233	39	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	233	40	:	:	PUNCT
cjal-3338	233	41	despite	despite	SCONJ
cjal-3338	233	42	these	these	DET
cjal-3338	233	43	three	three	NUM
cjal-3338	233	44	different	different	ADJ
cjal-3338	233	45	standards	standard	NOUN
cjal-3338	233	46	[	[	X
cjal-3338	233	47	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	233	48	novelty	novelty	NOUN
cjal-3338	233	49	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	233	50	infringement	infringement	NOUN
cjal-3338	233	51	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	233	52	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	233	53	inventiveness	inventiveness	NOUN
cjal-3338	233	54	]	]	X
cjal-3338	233	55	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	233	56	for	for	ADP
cjal-3338	233	57	some	some	DET
cjal-3338	233	58	reason	reason	NOUN
cjal-3338	233	59	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	233	60	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	233	61	supreme	supreme	PROPN
cjal-3338	233	62	people	people	PROPN
cjal-3338	233	63	's	's	PART
cjal-3338	233	64	court	court	NOUN
cjal-3338	233	65	created	create	VERB
cjal-3338	233	66	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	233	67	new	new	ADJ
cjal-3338	233	68	[	[	X
cjal-3338	233	69	standard	standard	NOUN
cjal-3338	233	70	]	]	PUNCT
cjal-3338	233	71	for	for	ADP
cjal-3338	233	72	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	233	73	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	233	74	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	233	75	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	234	1	[	[	X
cjal-3338	234	2	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	234	3	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	234	4	2010	2010	NUM
cjal-3338	234	5	judicial	judicial	ADJ
cjal-3338	234	6	explanations	explanation	NOUN
cjal-3338	234	7	]	]	PUNCT
cjal-3338	234	8	:	:	PUNCT
cjal-3338	234	9	not	not	PART
cjal-3338	234	10	substantially	substantially	ADV
cjal-3338	234	11	different	different	ADJ
cjal-3338	234	12	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	235	1	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	235	2	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	235	3	past	past	ADJ
cjal-3338	235	4	two	two	NUM
cjal-3338	235	5	years	year	NOUN
cjal-3338	235	6	since	since	SCONJ
cjal-3338	235	7	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	235	8	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	235	9	law	law	NOUN
cjal-3338	235	10	was	be	AUX
cjal-3338	235	11	amended	amend	VERB
cjal-3338	235	12	[	[	PUNCT
cjal-3338	235	13	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	235	14	2009	2009	NUM
cjal-3338	235	15	]	]	PUNCT
cjal-3338	235	16	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	235	17	it	it	PRON
cjal-3338	235	18	appears	appear	VERB
cjal-3338	235	19	courts	court	NOUN
cjal-3338	235	20	have	have	AUX
cjal-3338	235	21	not	not	PART
cjal-3338	235	22	come	come	VERB
cjal-3338	235	23	to	to	ADP
cjal-3338	235	24	an	an	DET
cjal-3338	235	25	agreement	agreement	NOUN
cjal-3338	235	26	for	for	ADP
cjal-3338	235	27	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	235	28	criterion	criterion	NOUN
cjal-3338	235	29	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	235	30	determine	determine	VERB
cjal-3338	235	31	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	235	32	level	level	NOUN
cjal-3338	235	33	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	235	34	variation	variation	NOUN
cjal-3338	235	35	that	that	PRON
cjal-3338	235	36	falls	fall	VERB
cjal-3338	235	37	under	under	ADP
cjal-3338	235	38	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	235	39	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	235	40	not	not	PART
cjal-3338	235	41	-	-	PUNCT
cjal-3338	235	42	substantively	substantively	ADV
cjal-3338	235	43	--	--	PUNCT
cjal-3338	235	44	different	different	ADJ
cjal-3338	235	45	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	235	46	test	test	NOUN
cjal-3338	235	47	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	236	1	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	236	2	decided	decide	VERB
cjal-3338	236	3	cases	case	NOUN
cjal-3338	236	4	generally	generally	ADV
cjal-3338	236	5	fall	fall	VERB
cjal-3338	236	6	into	into	ADP
cjal-3338	236	7	three	three	NUM
cjal-3338	236	8	categories	category	NOUN
cjal-3338	236	9	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	237	1	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	237	2	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	237	3	first	first	ADJ
cjal-3338	237	4	group	group	NOUN
cjal-3338	237	5	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	237	6	courts	court	NOUN
cjal-3338	237	7	literally	literally	ADV
cjal-3338	237	8	followed	follow	VERB
cjal-3338	237	9	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	237	10	novelty	novelty	NOUN
cjal-3338	237	11	standard	standard	NOUN
cjal-3338	237	12	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	237	13	reasoned	reason	VERB
cjal-3338	237	14	that	that	SCONJ
cjal-3338	237	15	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	237	16	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	237	17	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	237	18	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	237	19	requires	require	VERB
cjal-3338	237	20	that	that	SCONJ
cjal-3338	237	21	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	237	22	technical	technical	ADJ
cjal-3338	237	23	features	feature	NOUN
cjal-3338	237	24	be	be	AUX
cjal-3338	237	25	derived	derive	VERB
cjal-3338	237	26	from	from	ADP
cjal-3338	237	27	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	237	28	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	237	29	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	237	30	directly	directly	ADV
cjal-3338	237	31	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	237	32	undoubtedly	undoubtedly	ADV
cjal-3338	237	33	by	by	ADP
cjal-3338	237	34	persons	person	NOUN
cjal-3338	237	35	skilled	skilled	ADJ
cjal-3338	237	36	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	237	37	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	237	38	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	237	39	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	238	1	courts	court	NOUN
cjal-3338	238	2	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	238	3	some	some	DET
cjal-3338	238	4	other	other	ADJ
cjal-3338	238	5	cases	case	NOUN
cjal-3338	238	6	instead	instead	ADV
cjal-3338	238	7	read	read	VERB
cjal-3338	238	8	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	238	9	not	not	PART
cjal-3338	238	10	substantively	substantively	ADV
cjal-3338	238	11	different	different	ADJ
cjal-3338	238	12	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	238	13	as	as	ADV
cjal-3338	238	14	identical	identical	ADJ
cjal-3338	238	15	to	to	ADP
cjal-3338	238	16	equivalents	equivalent	NOUN
cjal-3338	238	17	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	238	18	apply	apply	VERB
cjal-3338	238	19	directly	directly	ADV
cjal-3338	238	20	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	238	21	standard	standard	NOUN
cjal-3338	238	22	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	238	23	comparison	comparison	NOUN
cjal-3338	238	24	as	as	ADP
cjal-3338	238	25	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	238	26	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	238	27	doctrine	doctrine	NOUN
cjal-3338	238	28	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	238	29	equivalents	equivalent	NOUN
cjal-3338	238	30	to	to	ADP
cjal-3338	238	31	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	238	32	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	238	33	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	238	34	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	238	35	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	239	1	there	there	PRON
cjal-3338	239	2	is	be	VERB
cjal-3338	239	3	still	still	ADV
cjal-3338	239	4	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	239	5	third	third	ADJ
cjal-3338	239	6	group	group	NOUN
cjal-3338	239	7	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	239	8	cases	case	NOUN
cjal-3338	239	9	where	where	SCONJ
cjal-3338	239	10	courts	court	NOUN
cjal-3338	239	11	believe	believe	VERB
cjal-3338	239	12	that	that	SCONJ
cjal-3338	239	13	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	239	14	not	not	PART
cjal-3338	239	15	-	-	PUNCT
cjal-3338	239	16	substantively	substantively	ADV
cjal-3338	239	17	-	-	PUNCT
cjal-3338	239	18	different	different	ADJ
cjal-3338	239	19	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	239	20	applies	apply	VERB
cjal-3338	239	21	even	even	ADV
cjal-3338	239	22	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	239	23	greater	great	ADJ
cjal-3338	239	24	degree	degree	NOUN
cjal-3338	239	25	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	239	26	variation	variation	NOUN
cjal-3338	239	27	than	than	ADP
cjal-3338	239	28	equivalents	equivalent	NOUN
cjal-3338	239	29	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	239	30	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	239	31	actually	actually	ADV
cjal-3338	239	32	close	close	ADJ
cjal-3338	239	33	to	to	ADP
cjal-3338	239	34	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	239	35	inventiveness	inventiveness	NOUN
cjal-3338	239	36	standard	standard	NOUN
cjal-3338	239	37	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	240	1	thus	thus	ADV
cjal-3338	240	2	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	240	3	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	240	4	these	these	DET
cjal-3338	240	5	cases	case	NOUN
cjal-3338	240	6	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	240	7	courts	court	NOUN
cjal-3338	240	8	ruled	rule	VERB
cjal-3338	240	9	that	that	SCONJ
cjal-3338	240	10	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	240	11	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	240	12	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	240	13	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	240	14	only	only	ADV
cjal-3338	240	15	requires	require	VERB
cjal-3338	240	16	that	that	SCONJ
cjal-3338	240	17	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	240	18	allegedly	allegedly	ADV
cjal-3338	240	19	infringing	infringe	VERB
cjal-3338	240	20	technical	technical	ADJ
cjal-3338	240	21	features	feature	NOUN
cjal-3338	240	22	64	64	NUM
cjal-3338	240	23	columbia	columbia	PROPN
cjal-3338	240	24	journal	journal	PROPN
cjal-3338	240	25	ofasian	ofasian	ADJ
cjal-3338	240	26	law	law	NOUN
cjal-3338	240	27	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	240	28	vol	vol	NOUN
cjal-3338	240	29	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	240	30	27	27	NUM
cjal-3338	240	31	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	240	32	no	no	INTJ
cjal-3338	240	33	.	.	NOUN
cjal-3338	240	34	1	1	NUM
cjal-3338	240	35	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	240	36	2013	2013	NUM
cjal-3338	240	37	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	240	38	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	240	39	existing	exist	VERB
cjal-3338	240	40	technology	technology	NOUN
cjal-3338	240	41	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	240	42	only	only	ADV
cjal-3338	240	43	inquires	inquire	VERB
cjal-3338	240	44	into	into	ADP
cjal-3338	240	45	whether	whether	SCONJ
cjal-3338	240	46	all	all	DET
cjal-3338	240	47	those	those	DET
cjal-3338	240	48	technical	technical	ADJ
cjal-3338	240	49	features	feature	NOUN
cjal-3338	240	50	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	240	51	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	240	52	accused	accuse	VERB
cjal-3338	240	53	product	product	NOUN
cjal-3338	240	54	accused	accuse	VERB
cjal-3338	240	55	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	240	56	falling	fall	VERB
cjal-3338	240	57	within	within	ADP
cjal-3338	240	58	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	240	59	protective	protective	ADJ
cjal-3338	240	60	scope	scope	NOUN
cjal-3338	240	61	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	240	62	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	240	63	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	240	64	rights	right	NOUN
cjal-3338	240	65	are	be	AUX
cjal-3338	240	66	identical	identical	ADJ
cjal-3338	240	67	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	240	68	1fl	1fl	NOUN
cjal-3338	240	69	m	m	NOUN
cjal-3338	240	70	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	240	71	or	or	CCONJ
cjal-3338	240	72	equivalent	equivalent	ADJ
cjal-3338	240	73	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	240	74	w	w	NOUN
cjal-3338	240	75	m	m	PROPN
cjal-3338	240	76	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	240	77	to	to	ADP
cjal-3338	240	78	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	240	79	corresponding	corresponding	ADJ
cjal-3338	240	80	technical	technical	ADJ
cjal-3338	240	81	features	feature	NOUN
cjal-3338	240	82	already	already	ADV
cjal-3338	240	83	disclosed	disclose	VERB
cjal-3338	240	84	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	240	85	other	other	ADJ
cjal-3338	240	86	existing	exist	VERB
cjal-3338	240	87	technical	technical	ADJ
cjal-3338	240	88	solutions.37	solutions.37	NOUN
cjal-3338	240	89	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	240	90	china	china	PROPN
cjal-3338	240	91	environmental	environmental	PROPN
cjal-3338	240	92	project	project	PROPN
cjal-3338	240	93	technology	technology	PROPN
cjal-3338	240	94	v.	v.	PROPN
cjal-3338	240	95	huayang	huayang	PROPN
cjal-3338	240	96	electric	electric	PROPN
cjal-3338	240	97	power	power	PROPN
cjal-3338	240	98	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	240	99	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	240	100	supreme	supreme	PROPN
cjal-3338	240	101	people	people	PROPN
cjal-3338	240	102	's	's	PART
cjal-3338	240	103	court	court	NOUN
cjal-3338	240	104	considered	consider	VERB
cjal-3338	240	105	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	240	106	arguments	argument	NOUN
cjal-3338	240	107	by	by	ADP
cjal-3338	240	108	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	240	109	appellants	appellant	NOUN
cjal-3338	240	110	that	that	SCONJ
cjal-3338	240	111	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	240	112	accused	accuse	VERB
cjal-3338	240	113	desulfurization	desulfurization	NOUN
cjal-3338	240	114	method	method	NOUN
cjal-3338	240	115	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	240	116	aeration	aeration	NOUN
cjal-3338	240	117	device	device	NOUN
cjal-3338	240	118	they	they	PRON
cjal-3338	240	119	practiced	practice	VERB
cjal-3338	240	120	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	240	121	their	their	PRON
cjal-3338	240	122	power	power	NOUN
cjal-3338	240	123	plant	plant	NOUN
cjal-3338	240	124	belonged	belong	VERB
cjal-3338	240	125	to	to	ADP
cjal-3338	240	126	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	240	127	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	240	128	art.3	art.3	PROPN
cjal-3338	240	129	can	can	AUX
cjal-3338	240	130	be	be	AUX
cjal-3338	240	131	obtained	obtain	VERB
cjal-3338	240	132	by	by	ADP
cjal-3338	240	133	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	240	134	persons	person	NOUN
cjal-3338	240	135	skilled	skilled	ADJ
cjal-3338	240	136	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	240	137	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	240	138	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	240	139	without	without	ADP
cjal-3338	240	140	inventive	inventive	ADJ
cjal-3338	240	141	work	work	NOUN
cjal-3338	240	142	based	base	VERB
cjal-3338	240	143	on	on	ADP
cjal-3338	240	144	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	240	145	teachings	teaching	NOUN
cjal-3338	240	146	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	240	147	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	240	148	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	240	149	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	240	150	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	241	1	fang	fang	PROPN
cjal-3338	241	2	qi	qi	PROPN
cjal-3338	241	3	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	241	4	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	241	5	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	241	6	defence	defence	NOUN
cjal-3338	241	7	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	241	8	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	241	9	litigation	litigation	NOUN
cjal-3338	241	10	:	:	PUNCT
cjal-3338	241	11	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	241	12	legal	legal	ADJ
cjal-3338	241	13	quagmire	quagmire	NOUN
cjal-3338	241	14	?	?	PUNCT
cjal-3338	241	15	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	241	16	25	25	NUM
cjal-3338	241	17	china	china	PROPN
cjal-3338	241	18	l.	l.	PROPN
cjal-3338	241	19	&	&	CCONJ
cjal-3338	241	20	prac	prac	PROPN
cjal-3338	241	21	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	242	1	16	16	NUM
cjal-3338	242	2	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	242	3	18	18	NUM
cjal-3338	242	4	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	242	5	2012	2012	NUM
cjal-3338	242	6	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	242	7	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	243	1	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	243	2	author	author	NOUN
cjal-3338	243	3	does	do	AUX
cjal-3338	243	4	not	not	PART
cjal-3338	243	5	agree	agree	VERB
cjal-3338	243	6	with	with	ADP
cjal-3338	243	7	qi	qi	PROPN
cjal-3338	243	8	's	's	PART
cjal-3338	243	9	[	[	X
cjal-3338	243	10	i	i	PRON
cjal-3338	243	11	am	be	AUX
cjal-3338	243	12	frankly	frankly	ADV
cjal-3338	243	13	not	not	PART
cjal-3338	243	14	certain	certain	ADJ
cjal-3338	243	15	which	which	PRON
cjal-3338	243	16	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	243	17	his	his	PRON
cjal-3338	243	18	last	last	ADJ
cjal-3338	243	19	name	name	NOUN
cjal-3338	243	20	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	243	21	]	]	PUNCT
cjal-3338	244	1	statement	statement	NOUN
cjal-3338	244	2	that	that	SCONJ
cjal-3338	244	3	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	244	4	standard	standard	NOUN
cjal-3338	244	5	for	for	ADP
cjal-3338	244	6	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	244	7	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	244	8	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	244	9	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	244	10	set	set	VERB
cjal-3338	244	11	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	244	12	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	244	13	supreme	supreme	PROPN
cjal-3338	244	14	people	people	PROPN
cjal-3338	244	15	's	's	PART
cjal-3338	244	16	court	court	NOUN
cjal-3338	244	17	's	's	PART
cjal-3338	244	18	2010	2010	NUM
cjal-3338	244	19	judicial	judicial	ADJ
cjal-3338	244	20	explanations	explanation	NOUN
cjal-3338	244	21	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	244	22	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	244	23	new	new	ADJ
cjal-3338	244	24	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	244	25	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	245	1	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	245	2	explanations	explanation	NOUN
cjal-3338	245	3	appear	appear	VERB
cjal-3338	245	4	clear	clear	ADJ
cjal-3338	245	5	about	about	ADP
cjal-3338	245	6	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	245	7	connection	connection	NOUN
cjal-3338	245	8	between	between	ADP
cjal-3338	245	9	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	245	10	existing	exist	VERB
cjal-3338	245	11	technology	technology	NOUN
cjal-3338	245	12	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	245	13	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	245	14	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	245	15	doctrine	doctrine	NOUN
cjal-3338	245	16	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	245	17	equivalents	equivalent	NOUN
cjal-3338	245	18	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	246	1	as	as	ADP
cjal-3338	246	2	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	246	3	remainder	remainder	NOUN
cjal-3338	246	4	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	246	5	this	this	DET
cjal-3338	246	6	section	section	NOUN
cjal-3338	246	7	shows	show	VERB
cjal-3338	246	8	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	246	9	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	246	10	supreme	supreme	PROPN
cjal-3338	246	11	people	people	PROPN
cjal-3338	246	12	's	's	PART
cjal-3338	246	13	court	court	NOUN
cjal-3338	246	14	itself	itself	PRON
cjal-3338	246	15	consistently	consistently	ADV
cjal-3338	246	16	uses	use	VERB
cjal-3338	246	17	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	246	18	equivalence	equivalence	NOUN
cjal-3338	246	19	standard	standard	NOUN
cjal-3338	246	20	when	when	SCONJ
cjal-3338	246	21	applying	apply	VERB
cjal-3338	246	22	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	246	23	existing	exist	VERB
cjal-3338	246	24	technology	technology	NOUN
cjal-3338	246	25	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	246	26	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	246	27	china	china	PROPN
cjal-3338	246	28	environmental	environmental	PROPN
cjal-3338	246	29	project	project	PROPN
cjal-3338	246	30	technology	technology	PROPN
cjal-3338	246	31	v.	v.	PROPN
cjal-3338	246	32	huayang	huayang	PROPN
cjal-3338	246	33	electric	electric	PROPN
cjal-3338	246	34	power	power	PROPN
cjal-3338	246	35	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	246	36	infra	infra	NOUN
cjal-3338	246	37	note	note	VERB
cjal-3338	246	38	38	38	NUM
cjal-3338	246	39	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	247	1	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	247	2	importance	importance	NOUN
cjal-3338	247	3	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	247	4	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	247	5	case	case	NOUN
cjal-3338	247	6	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	247	7	highlighted	highlight	VERB
cjal-3338	247	8	by	by	ADP
cjal-3338	247	9	its	its	PRON
cjal-3338	247	10	designation	designation	NOUN
cjal-3338	247	11	as	as	ADP
cjal-3338	247	12	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	247	13	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	247	14	top	top	ADJ
cjal-3338	247	15	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	247	16	case	case	NOUN
cjal-3338	247	17	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	247	18	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	247	19	2009	2009	NUM
cjal-3338	247	20	list	list	NOUN
cjal-3338	247	21	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	247	22	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	247	23	top	top	ADJ
cjal-3338	247	24	io	io	NOUN
cjal-3338	247	25	cases	case	NOUN
cjal-3338	247	26	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	247	27	50	50	NUM
cjal-3338	247	28	typical	typical	ADJ
cjal-3338	247	29	cases	case	NOUN
cjal-3338	247	30	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	247	31	judicial	judicial	ADJ
cjal-3338	247	32	protection	protection	NOUN
cjal-3338	247	33	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	247	34	intellectual	intellectual	ADJ
cjal-3338	247	35	property	property	NOUN
cjal-3338	247	36	rights	right	NOUN
cjal-3338	247	37	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	247	38	china	china	PROPN
cjal-3338	247	39	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	247	40	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	248	1	short	short	ADJ
cjal-3338	248	2	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	248	3	an	an	DET
cjal-3338	248	4	article	article	NOUN
cjal-3338	248	5	enshrined	enshrine	VERB
cjal-3338	248	6	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	248	7	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	248	8	judicial	judicial	ADJ
cjal-3338	248	9	explanation	explanation	NOUN
cjal-3338	248	10	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	248	11	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	248	12	case	case	NOUN
cjal-3338	248	13	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	248	14	as	as	ADV
cjal-3338	248	15	authoritative	authoritative	ADJ
cjal-3338	248	16	as	as	ADP
cjal-3338	248	17	anything	anything	PRON
cjal-3338	248	18	one	one	PRON
cjal-3338	248	19	could	could	AUX
cjal-3338	248	20	find	find	VERB
cjal-3338	248	21	from	from	ADP
cjal-3338	248	22	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	248	23	people	people	NOUN
cjal-3338	248	24	's	's	PART
cjal-3338	248	25	courts	court	NOUN
cjal-3338	248	26	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	249	1	qi	qi	PROPN
cjal-3338	249	2	may	may	AUX
cjal-3338	249	3	be	be	AUX
cjal-3338	249	4	correct	correct	ADJ
cjal-3338	249	5	that	that	SCONJ
cjal-3338	249	6	different	different	ADJ
cjal-3338	249	7	people	people	NOUN
cjal-3338	249	8	's	's	PART
cjal-3338	249	9	courts	court	NOUN
cjal-3338	249	10	may	may	AUX
cjal-3338	249	11	deviate	deviate	VERB
cjal-3338	249	12	from	from	ADP
cjal-3338	249	13	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	249	14	standard	standard	NOUN
cjal-3338	249	15	applied	apply	VERB
cjal-3338	249	16	by	by	ADP
cjal-3338	249	17	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	249	18	supreme	supreme	PROPN
cjal-3338	249	19	people	people	PROPN
cjal-3338	249	20	's	's	PART
cjal-3338	249	21	court	court	NOUN
cjal-3338	249	22	;	;	PUNCT
cjal-3338	249	23	but	but	CCONJ
cjal-3338	249	24	since	since	SCONJ
cjal-3338	249	25	he	he	PRON
cjal-3338	249	26	does	do	AUX
cjal-3338	249	27	not	not	PART
cjal-3338	249	28	provide	provide	VERB
cjal-3338	249	29	any	any	DET
cjal-3338	249	30	citation	citation	NOUN
cjal-3338	249	31	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	249	32	support	support	NOUN
cjal-3338	249	33	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	249	34	his	his	PRON
cjal-3338	249	35	contention	contention	NOUN
cjal-3338	249	36	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	249	37	his	his	PRON
cjal-3338	249	38	assertions	assertion	NOUN
cjal-3338	249	39	are	be	AUX
cjal-3338	249	40	impossible	impossible	ADJ
cjal-3338	249	41	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	249	42	verify	verify	VERB
cjal-3338	249	43	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	250	1	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	251	1	sheteli	sheteli	PROPN
cjal-3338	251	2	kesi	kesi	PROPN
cjal-3338	251	3	youxian	youxian	PROPN
cjal-3338	251	4	gongsi	gongsi	PROPN
cjal-3338	251	5	su	su	PROPN
cjal-3338	251	6	ningbo	ningbo	PROPN
cjal-3338	251	7	shenglida	shenglida	PROPN
cjal-3338	251	8	dianqi	dianqi	VERB
cjal-3338	251	9	zhizao	zhizao	PROPN
cjal-3338	251	10	youxian	youxian	PROPN
cjal-3338	251	11	gongsi	gongsi	PROPN
cjal-3338	251	12	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	251	13	huapu	huapu	ADJ
cjal-3338	251	14	chaoshi	chaoshi	PROPN
cjal-3338	251	15	youxian	youxian	PROPN
cjal-3338	251	16	gongsi	gongsi	PROPN
cjal-3338	251	17	qinfan	qinfan	PROPN
cjal-3338	251	18	faming	fame	VERB
cjal-3338	251	19	zhuanli	zhuanli	PROPN
cjal-3338	251	20	quan	quan	PROPN
cjal-3338	252	1	jiufen	jiufen	PROPN
cjal-3338	252	2	shenching	shenching	PROPN
cjal-3338	252	3	zaishen	zaishen	ADV
cjal-3338	252	4	an	an	DET
cjal-3338	252	5	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	252	6	1,dim	1,dim	NUM
cjal-3338	252	7	[	[	PUNCT
cjal-3338	252	8	ea	ea	NOUN
cjal-3338	252	9	-1	-1	PROPN
cjal-3338	252	10	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	252	11	f	f	PROPN
cjal-3338	253	1	~	~	X
cjal-3338	253	2	t	t	X
cjal-3338	253	3	lj	lj	NOUN
cjal-3338	253	4	q	q	NOUN
cjal-3338	253	5	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	254	1	[	[	X
cjal-3338	254	2	strix	strix	PROPN
cjal-3338	254	3	ltd	ltd	PROPN
cjal-3338	254	4	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	255	1	v.	v.	CCONJ
cjal-3338	255	2	ningbo	ningbo	PROPN
cjal-3338	255	3	sunlight	sunlight	PROPN
cjal-3338	255	4	elec	elec	PROPN
cjal-3338	255	5	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	255	6	appliance	appliance	PROPN
cjal-3338	255	7	co.	co.	PROPN
cjal-3338	255	8	]	]	X
cjal-3338	255	9	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	255	10	sup	sup	NOUN
cjal-3338	255	11	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	256	1	people	people	NOUN
cjal-3338	256	2	's	's	PART
cjal-3338	256	3	ct	ct	NOUN
cjal-3338	256	4	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	256	5	2007	2007	NUM
cjal-3338	256	6	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	256	7	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	256	8	china	china	PROPN
cjal-3338	256	9	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	256	10	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	256	11	available	available	ADJ
cjal-3338	256	12	at	at	ADP
cjal-3338	256	13	http://www.chinaiprlaw.cn/file/oo8o41712898.html	http://www.chinaiprlaw.cn/file/oo8o41712898.html	PROPN
cjal-3338	256	14	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	257	1	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	257	2	decision	decision	NOUN
cjal-3338	257	3	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	257	4	ranked	rank	VERB
cjal-3338	257	5	as	as	ADP
cjal-3338	257	6	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	257	7	typical	typical	ADJ
cjal-3338	257	8	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	257	9	case	case	NOUN
cjal-3338	257	10	number	number	NOUN
cjal-3338	257	11	i	i	PRON
cjal-3338	257	12	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	257	13	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	257	14	2oo8	2oo8	NUM
cjal-3338	257	15	list	list	NOUN
cjal-3338	257	16	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	257	17	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	257	18	top	top	ADJ
cjal-3338	257	19	io	io	NOUN
cjal-3338	257	20	cases	case	NOUN
cjal-3338	257	21	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	257	22	5o	5o	NUM
cjal-3338	257	23	typical	typical	ADJ
cjal-3338	257	24	cases	case	NOUN
cjal-3338	257	25	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	257	26	judicial	judicial	ADJ
cjal-3338	257	27	protection	protection	NOUN
cjal-3338	257	28	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	257	29	intellectual	intellectual	ADJ
cjal-3338	257	30	property	property	NOUN
cjal-3338	257	31	rights	right	NOUN
cjal-3338	257	32	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	257	33	china	china	PROPN
cjal-3338	257	34	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	257	35	promulgated	promulgate	VERB
cjal-3338	257	36	by	by	ADP
cjal-3338	257	37	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	257	38	supreme	supreme	PROPN
cjal-3338	257	39	people	people	PROPN
cjal-3338	257	40	's	's	PART
cjal-3338	257	41	court	court	NOUN
cjal-3338	257	42	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	258	1	see	see	VERB
cjal-3338	258	2	supra	supra	PROPN
cjal-3338	258	3	note	note	PROPN
cjal-3338	258	4	22	22	NUM
cjal-3338	258	5	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	259	1	38	38	NUM
cjal-3338	259	2	wuhan	wuhan	PROPN
cjal-3338	259	3	jingyuan	jingyuan	PROPN
cjal-3338	259	4	huanjing	huanje	VERB
cjal-3338	259	5	gongcheng	gongcheng	PROPN
cjal-3338	259	6	youxian	youxian	PROPN
cjal-3338	259	7	gongsi	gongsi	PROPN
cjal-3338	259	8	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	259	9	riben	riben	VERB
cjal-3338	259	10	fushi	fushi	PROPN
cjal-3338	259	11	huashui	huashui	PROPN
cjal-3338	259	12	gongye	gongye	PROPN
cjal-3338	259	13	zhushi	zhushi	PROPN
cjal-3338	259	14	huishe	huishe	PROPN
cjal-3338	259	15	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	259	16	huayang	huayang	PROPN
cjal-3338	259	17	dianye	dianye	PROPN
cjal-3338	260	1	youxian	youxian	PROPN
cjal-3338	260	2	gongsi	gongsi	PROPN
cjal-3338	260	3	qinfan	qinfan	PROPN
cjal-3338	260	4	faming	fame	VERB
cjal-3338	260	5	zhuanli	zhuanli	PROPN
cjal-3338	260	6	quan	quan	PROPN
cjal-3338	260	7	jiufen	jiufen	PROPN
cjal-3338	260	8	yian	yian	PROPN
cjal-3338	260	9	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	260	10	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	260	11	0	0	NUM
cjal-3338	260	12	_	_	NOUN
cjal-3338	260	13	--4j-1	--4j-1	PUNCT
cjal-3338	260	14	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	261	1	h	h	PROPN
cjal-3338	261	2	fli	fli	PROPN
cjal-3338	261	3	k	k	PROPN
cjal-3338	261	4	-_ta	-_ta	PROPN
cjal-3338	261	5	zt4-	zt4-	NUM
cjal-3338	261	6	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	261	7	{	{	PUNCT
cjal-3338	261	8	[	[	X
cjal-3338	261	9	3iih	3iih	NOUN
cjal-3338	261	10	w~~'t~	w~~'t~	NOUN
cjal-3338	261	11	'	'	PART
cjal-3338	261	12	]	]	PUNCT
cjal-3338	262	1	[	[	X
cjal-3338	262	2	ir	ir	INTJ
cjal-3338	262	3	t)j+1	t)j+1	NOUN
cjal-3338	262	4	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	263	1	[	[	X
cjal-3338	263	2	china	china	PROPN
cjal-3338	263	3	envtl	envtl	PROPN
cjal-3338	263	4	project	project	PROPN
cjal-3338	263	5	tech	tech	PROPN
cjal-3338	263	6	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	263	7	inc	inc	PROPN
cjal-3338	263	8	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	264	1	v.	v.	PROPN
cjal-3338	264	2	huayang	huayang	PROPN
cjal-3338	264	3	elec	elec	PROPN
cjal-3338	264	4	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	264	5	power	power	PROPN
cjal-3338	264	6	co.	co.	PROPN
cjal-3338	264	7	]	]	X
cjal-3338	264	8	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	264	9	sup	sup	NOUN
cjal-3338	264	10	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	265	1	people	people	NOUN
cjal-3338	265	2	's	's	PART
cjal-3338	265	3	ct	ct	NOUN
cjal-3338	265	4	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	265	5	2009	2009	NUM
cjal-3338	265	6	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	265	7	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	265	8	china	china	PROPN
cjal-3338	265	9	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	265	10	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	265	11	available	available	ADJ
cjal-3338	265	12	at	at	ADP
cjal-3338	265	13	http://ipr.court.gov.cn/sdjdws/2o1o4/t2ollo4i398892.html	http://ipr.court.gov.cn/sdjdws/2o1o4/t2ollo4i398892.html	PROPN
cjal-3338	265	14	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	266	1	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	266	2	decision	decision	NOUN
cjal-3338	266	3	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	266	4	ranked	rank	VERB
cjal-3338	266	5	as	as	ADP
cjal-3338	266	6	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	266	7	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	266	8	top	top	ADJ
cjal-3338	266	9	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	266	10	case	case	NOUN
cjal-3338	266	11	number	number	NOUN
cjal-3338	266	12	3	3	NUM
cjal-3338	266	13	on	on	ADP
cjal-3338	266	14	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	266	15	2009	2009	NUM
cjal-3338	266	16	list	list	NOUN
cjal-3338	266	17	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	266	18	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	266	19	top	top	ADJ
cjal-3338	266	20	io	io	NOUN
cjal-3338	266	21	cases	case	NOUN
cjal-3338	266	22	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	266	23	50	50	NUM
cjal-3338	266	24	typical	typical	ADJ
cjal-3338	266	25	cases	case	NOUN
cjal-3338	266	26	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	266	27	judicial	judicial	ADJ
cjal-3338	266	28	protection	protection	NOUN
cjal-3338	266	29	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	266	30	intellectual	intellectual	ADJ
cjal-3338	266	31	property	property	NOUN
cjal-3338	266	32	rights	right	NOUN
cjal-3338	266	33	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	266	34	china	china	PROPN
cjal-3338	266	35	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	266	36	promulgated	promulgate	VERB
cjal-3338	266	37	by	by	ADP
cjal-3338	266	38	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	266	39	supreme	supreme	PROPN
cjal-3338	266	40	people	people	PROPN
cjal-3338	266	41	's	's	PART
cjal-3338	266	42	court	court	NOUN
cjal-3338	266	43	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	267	1	auigao	auigao	PROPN
cjal-3338	267	2	renmen	renmen	PROPN
cjal-3338	267	3	fayuan	fayuan	PROPN
cjal-3338	267	4	guanyu	guanyu	VERB
cjal-3338	267	5	fabu	fabu	PROPN
cjal-3338	267	6	2oo9	2oo9	NUM
cjal-3338	267	7	nian	nian	ADJ
cjal-3338	267	8	zhongguo	zhongguo	PROPN
cjal-3338	267	9	fayuan	fayuan	PROPN
cjal-3338	267	10	zhishi	zhishi	PROPN
cjal-3338	267	11	chanquan	chanquan	PROPN
cjal-3338	267	12	sifa	sifa	PROPN
cjal-3338	267	13	baohu	baohu	PROPN
cjal-3338	267	14	1o	1o	PROPN
cjal-3338	267	15	dai	dai	PROPN
cjal-3338	267	16	anjian	anjian	PROPN
cjal-3338	267	17	he	he	PRON
cjal-3338	267	18	50	50	NUM
cjal-3338	267	19	jian	jian	NOUN
cjal-3338	267	20	dianxing	dianxe	VERB
cjal-3338	267	21	anli	anli	PROPN
cjal-3338	267	22	di	di	PROPN
cjal-3338	267	23	tongzhi	tongzhi	PROPN
cjal-3338	267	24	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	267	25	&	&	CCONJ
cjal-3338	267	26	iak	iak	PROPN
cjal-3338	267	27	8r	8r	NUM
cjal-3338	267	28	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	267	29	-tf[r	-tf[r	PROPN
cjal-3338	267	30	2009	2009	NUM
cjal-3338	267	31	ifr	ifr	NOUN
cjal-3338	267	32	mr	mr	PROPN
cjal-3338	267	33	1	1	NUM
cjal-3338	267	34	r	r	NOUN
cjal-3338	267	35	i'v48	i'v48	NOUN
cjal-3338	267	36	m	m	PROPN
cjal-3338	267	37	10	10	NUM
cjal-3338	267	38	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	267	39	04fi	04fi	NOUN
cjal-3338	267	40	50	50	NUM
cjal-3338	267	41	4lam	4lam	NUM
cjal-3338	267	42	inm	inm	NOUN
cjal-3338	267	43	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	268	1	[	[	X
cjal-3338	268	2	circular	circular	NOUN
cjal-3338	268	3	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	268	4	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	268	5	supreme	supreme	ADJ
cjal-3338	268	6	defensive	defensive	ADJ
cjal-3338	268	7	use	use	NOUN
cjal-3338	268	8	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	268	9	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	268	10	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	268	11	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	268	12	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cjal-3338	268	13	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	268	14	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	268	15	chinese	chinese	PROPN
cjal-3338	268	16	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	268	17	litigation	litigation	PROPN
cjal-3338	268	18	65	65	NUM
cjal-3338	268	19	waslig	waslig	PROPN
cjal-3338	268	20	tower	tower	NOUN
cjal-3338	268	21	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	268	22	seawater	seawater	NOUN
cjal-3338	268	23	absorbs	absorb	VERB
cjal-3338	268	24	so	so	SCONJ
cjal-3338	268	25	_	_	NOUN
cjal-3338	268	26	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	268	27	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	268	28	stack2	stack2	PROPN
cjal-3338	268	29	seawater	seawater	NOUN
cjal-3338	268	30	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	268	31	not	not	PART
cjal-3338	268	32	mixed	mixed	ADJ
cjal-3338	268	33	aeration	aeration	NOUN
cjal-3338	268	34	mixed	mixed	ADJ
cjal-3338	268	35	seawater	seawater	NOUN
cjal-3338	268	36	with	with	ADP
cjal-3338	268	37	so2	so2	PROPN
cjal-3338	268	38	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	268	39	entrance	entrance	NOUN
cjal-3338	268	40	chaiutel	chaiutel	NOUN
cjal-3338	268	41	discharge	discharge	NOUN
cjal-3338	268	42	figure	figure	NOUN
cjal-3338	268	43	2	2	NUM
cjal-3338	268	44	:	:	PUNCT
cjal-3338	268	45	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	268	46	figure	figure	NOUN
cjal-3338	268	47	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	268	48	cn	cn	PROPN
cjal-3338	268	49	95119389.9	95119389.9	NUM
cjal-3338	268	50	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	268	51	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	268	52	asserted	assert	VERB
cjal-3338	268	53	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	268	54	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	268	55	china	china	PROPN
cjal-3338	268	56	environmental	environmental	PROPN
cjal-3338	268	57	project	project	PROPN
cjal-3338	268	58	technology	technology	PROPN
cjal-3338	268	59	v.	v.	PROPN
cjal-3338	268	60	huayang	huayang	PROPN
cjal-3338	268	61	electric	electric	PROPN
cjal-3338	268	62	power	power	PROPN
cjal-3338	268	63	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	268	64	illustrating	illustrate	VERB
cjal-3338	268	65	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	268	66	structure	structure	NOUN
cjal-3338	268	67	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	268	68	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	268	69	claimed	claim	VERB
cjal-3338	268	70	smoke	smoke	NOUN
cjal-3338	268	71	desulfurization	desulfurization	NOUN
cjal-3338	268	72	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	268	73	aeration	aeration	NOUN
cjal-3338	268	74	device	device	NOUN
cjal-3338	268	75	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	269	1	3	3	X
cjal-3338	269	2	'	'	PART
cjal-3338	269	3	english	english	ADJ
cjal-3338	269	4	labels	label	NOUN
cjal-3338	269	5	are	be	AUX
cjal-3338	269	6	provided	provide	VERB
cjal-3338	269	7	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	269	8	aid	aid	VERB
cjal-3338	269	9	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	269	10	understanding	understanding	NOUN
cjal-3338	269	11	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	270	1	s02	s02	PROPN
cjal-3338	270	2	rich	rich	ADJ
cjal-3338	270	3	air	air	NOUN
cjal-3338	270	4	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	270	5	introduced	introduce	VERB
cjal-3338	270	6	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	270	7	from	from	ADP
cjal-3338	270	8	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	270	9	combustion	combustion	NOUN
cjal-3338	270	10	engine	engine	NOUN
cjal-3338	270	11	5	5	NUM
cjal-3338	270	12	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	270	13	which	which	PRON
cjal-3338	270	14	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	270	15	then	then	ADV
cjal-3338	270	16	mixed	mix	VERB
cjal-3338	270	17	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	270	18	with	with	ADP
cjal-3338	270	19	seawater	seawater	NOUN
cjal-3338	270	20	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	270	21	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	270	22	washing	washing	NOUN
cjal-3338	270	23	tower	tower	NOUN
cjal-3338	270	24	3	3	NUM
cjal-3338	270	25	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	271	1	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	271	2	s02	s02	PROPN
cjal-3338	271	3	-	-	PUNCT
cjal-3338	271	4	rich	rich	ADJ
cjal-3338	271	5	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	271	6	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	271	7	therefore	therefore	ADV
cjal-3338	271	8	acidic	acidic	ADJ
cjal-3338	271	9	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	271	10	seawater	seawater	NOUN
cjal-3338	271	11	from	from	ADP
cjal-3338	271	12	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	271	13	washing	washing	NOUN
cjal-3338	271	14	tower	tower	NOUN
cjal-3338	271	15	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	271	16	then	then	ADV
cjal-3338	271	17	aerated	aerate	VERB
cjal-3338	271	18	with	with	ADP
cjal-3338	271	19	s02	s02	ADJ
cjal-3338	271	20	-	-	PUNCT
cjal-3338	271	21	poor	poor	ADJ
cjal-3338	271	22	seawater	seawater	NOUN
cjal-3338	271	23	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	271	24	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	271	25	aeration	aeration	NOUN
cjal-3338	271	26	tank	tank	NOUN
cjal-3338	271	27	6	6	NUM
cjal-3338	271	28	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	272	1	as	as	SCONJ
cjal-3338	272	2	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	272	3	infringement	infringement	VERB
cjal-3338	272	4	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	272	5	claim	claim	NOUN
cjal-3338	272	6	one	one	NUM
cjal-3338	272	7	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	272	8	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	272	9	asserted	asserted	ADJ
cjal-3338	272	10	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	272	11	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	272	12	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	272	13	supreme	supreme	PROPN
cjal-3338	272	14	people	people	PROPN
cjal-3338	272	15	's	's	PART
cjal-3338	272	16	court	court	NOUN
cjal-3338	272	17	first	first	ADV
cjal-3338	272	18	dismissed	dismiss	VERB
cjal-3338	272	19	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	272	20	process	process	NOUN
cjal-3338	272	21	diagram	diagram	NOUN
cjal-3338	272	22	from	from	ADP
cjal-3338	272	23	an	an	DET
cjal-3338	272	24	indian	indian	ADJ
cjal-3338	272	25	power	power	NOUN
cjal-3338	272	26	plant	plant	NOUN
cjal-3338	272	27	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	272	28	appellants	appellant	NOUN
cjal-3338	272	29	submitted	submit	VERB
cjal-3338	272	30	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	272	31	which	which	PRON
cjal-3338	272	32	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	272	33	appellants	appellant	NOUN
cjal-3338	272	34	admitted	admit	VERB
cjal-3338	272	35	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	272	36	did	do	AUX
cjal-3338	272	37	not	not	PART
cjal-3338	272	38	disclose	disclose	VERB
cjal-3338	272	39	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	272	40	[	[	X
cjal-3338	272	41	claimed	claim	VERB
cjal-3338	272	42	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	272	43	infringing	infringe	VERB
cjal-3338	272	44	]	]	PUNCT
cjal-3338	272	45	ratio	ratio	NOUN
cjal-3338	272	46	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	272	47	air	air	NOUN
cjal-3338	272	48	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	272	49	seawater	seawater	NOUN
cjal-3338	272	50	mix	mix	NOUN
cjal-3338	272	51	as	as	ADV
cjal-3338	272	52	well	well	ADV
cjal-3338	272	53	as	as	ADP
cjal-3338	272	54	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	272	55	aeration	aeration	NOUN
cjal-3338	272	56	time	time	NOUN
cjal-3338	272	57	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	272	58	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	273	1	then	then	ADV
cjal-3338	273	2	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	273	3	applying	apply	VERB
cjal-3338	273	4	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	273	5	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	273	6	which	which	PRON
cjal-3338	273	7	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	273	8	person	person	NOUN
cjal-3338	273	9	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	273	10	ordinary	ordinary	ADJ
cjal-3338	273	11	skill	skill	NOUN
cjal-3338	273	12	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	273	13	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	273	14	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	273	15	would	would	AUX
cjal-3338	273	16	be	be	AUX
cjal-3338	273	17	able	able	ADJ
cjal-3338	273	18	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	273	19	conceive	conceive	VERB
cjal-3338	273	20	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	273	21	without	without	ADP
cjal-3338	273	22	inventive	inventive	ADJ
cjal-3338	273	23	labor	labor	NOUN
cjal-3338	273	24	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	273	25	prong	prong	NOUN
cjal-3338	273	26	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	273	27	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	273	28	chinese	chinese	ADJ
cjal-3338	273	29	doctrine	doctrine	NOUN
cjal-3338	273	30	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	273	31	people	people	NOUN
cjal-3338	273	32	's	's	PART
cjal-3338	273	33	court	court	NOUN
cjal-3338	273	34	concerning	concern	VERB
cjal-3338	273	35	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	273	36	top	top	ADJ
cjal-3338	273	37	io	io	NOUN
cjal-3338	273	38	cases	case	NOUN
cjal-3338	273	39	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	273	40	50	50	NUM
cjal-3338	273	41	typical	typical	ADJ
cjal-3338	273	42	cases	case	NOUN
cjal-3338	273	43	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	273	44	judicial	judicial	ADJ
cjal-3338	273	45	protection	protection	NOUN
cjal-3338	273	46	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	273	47	intellectual	intellectual	ADJ
cjal-3338	273	48	property	property	NOUN
cjal-3338	273	49	rights	right	NOUN
cjal-3338	273	50	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	273	51	chinese	chinese	ADJ
cjal-3338	273	52	courts	court	NOUN
cjal-3338	273	53	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	273	54	2009	2009	NUM
cjal-3338	273	55	]	]	PUNCT
cjal-3338	273	56	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	273	57	promulgated	promulgate	VERB
cjal-3338	273	58	by	by	ADP
cjal-3338	273	59	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	273	60	sup	sup	NOUN
cjal-3338	273	61	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	274	1	people	people	NOUN
cjal-3338	274	2	's	's	PART
cjal-3338	274	3	ct	ct	PROPN
cjal-3338	274	4	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	274	5	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	274	6	apr	apr	PROPN
cjal-3338	274	7	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	274	8	14	14	NUM
cjal-3338	274	9	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	274	10	2oo	2oo	NOUN
cjal-3338	274	11	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	274	12	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	274	13	available	available	ADJ
cjal-3338	274	14	at	at	ADP
cjal-3338	274	15	http://www.court.gov.cn/xwzx/rdzt/zscq/jdal/2o0o	http://www.court.gov.cn/xwzx/rdzt/zscq/jdal/2o0o	ADV
cjal-3338	274	16	4	4	NUM
cjal-3338	274	17	/po2ono	/po2ono	SYM
cjal-3338	274	18	4	4	NUM
cjal-3338	274	19	2o5671	2o5671	NOUN
cjal-3338	274	20	43135	43135	NUM
cjal-3338	274	21	866	866	NUM
cjal-3338	274	22	.doc	.doc	NOUN
cjal-3338	274	23	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	275	1	39	39	NUM
cjal-3338	276	1	i	i	PRON
cjal-3338	276	2	d.	d.	PROPN
cjal-3338	276	3	coabustion	coabustion	PROPN
cjal-3338	276	4	en.6ne	en.6ne	PROPN
cjal-3338	276	5	66	66	NUM
cjal-3338	276	6	columbia	columbia	PROPN
cjal-3338	276	7	journal	journal	PROPN
cjal-3338	276	8	ofasian	ofasian	ADJ
cjal-3338	276	9	law	law	NOUN
cjal-3338	276	10	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	276	11	vol	vol	NOUN
cjal-3338	276	12	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	276	13	27	27	NUM
cjal-3338	276	14	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	276	15	no	no	INTJ
cjal-3338	276	16	.	.	NOUN
cjal-3338	276	17	1	1	NUM
cjal-3338	276	18	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	276	19	2o3	2o3	NUM
cjal-3338	276	20	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	276	21	equivalents	equivalent	NOUN
cjal-3338	276	22	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	276	23	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	276	24	context	context	NOUN
cjal-3338	276	25	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	276	26	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	276	27	existing	exist	VERB
cjal-3338	276	28	technology	technology	NOUN
cjal-3338	276	29	defense,4	defense,4	NOUN
cjal-3338	276	30	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	276	31	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	276	32	supreme	supreme	PROPN
cjal-3338	276	33	people	people	PROPN
cjal-3338	276	34	's	's	PART
cjal-3338	276	35	court	court	NOUN
cjal-3338	276	36	dismissed	dismiss	VERB
cjal-3338	276	37	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	276	38	appellant	appellant	NOUN
cjal-3338	276	39	's	's	PART
cjal-3338	276	40	argument	argument	NOUN
cjal-3338	276	41	that	that	PRON
cjal-3338	276	42	figure	figure	VERB
cjal-3338	276	43	5	5	NUM
cjal-3338	276	44	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	276	45	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cjal-3338	276	46	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	276	47	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	276	48	no	no	PROPN
cjal-3338	276	49	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	277	1	4,o85,194	4,o85,194	PROPN
cjal-3338	277	2	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	277	3	reproduced	reproduce	VERB
cjal-3338	277	4	below	below	ADV
cjal-3338	277	5	as	as	ADP
cjal-3338	277	6	figure	figure	NOUN
cjal-3338	277	7	3	3	NUM
cjal-3338	277	8	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	277	9	supplied	supply	VERB
cjal-3338	277	10	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	277	11	requisite	requisite	ADJ
cjal-3338	277	12	knowledge	knowledge	NOUN
cjal-3338	277	13	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	277	14	calculate	calculate	VERB
cjal-3338	277	15	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	277	16	ratio	ratio	NOUN
cjal-3338	277	17	:	:	PUNCT
cjal-3338	277	18	•	•	ADP
cjal-3338	277	19	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	277	20	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	278	1	because	because	SCONJ
cjal-3338	278	2	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	278	3	ratio	ratio	NOUN
cjal-3338	278	4	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	278	5	air	air	NOUN
cjal-3338	278	6	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	278	7	seawater	seawater	NOUN
cjal-3338	278	8	mix	mix	NOUN
cjal-3338	278	9	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	278	10	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	278	11	aeration	aeration	NOUN
cjal-3338	278	12	time	time	NOUN
cjal-3338	278	13	claimed	claim	VERB
cjal-3338	278	14	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	278	15	this	this	DET
cjal-3338	278	16	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	278	17	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	278	18	determined	determine	VERB
cjal-3338	278	19	by	by	ADP
cjal-3338	278	20	multiple	multiple	ADJ
cjal-3338	278	21	factors	factor	NOUN
cjal-3338	278	22	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	278	23	concert	concert	NOUN
cjal-3338	278	24	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	278	25	therefore	therefore	ADV
cjal-3338	278	26	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	278	27	even	even	ADV
cjal-3338	278	28	with	with	ADP
cjal-3338	278	29	figure	figure	NOUN
cjal-3338	278	30	5	5	NUM
cjal-3338	278	31	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	278	32	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cjal-3338	278	33	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	278	34	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	278	35	no	no	PROPN
cjal-3338	278	36	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	279	1	4,o85,194	4,o85,194	PROPN
cjal-3338	279	2	taken	take	VERB
cjal-3338	279	3	into	into	ADP
cjal-3338	279	4	consideration	consideration	NOUN
cjal-3338	279	5	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	279	6	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	279	7	[	[	NOUN
cjal-3338	279	8	appellants	appellant	NOUN
cjal-3338	279	9	]	]	PUNCT
cjal-3338	279	10	still	still	ADV
cjal-3338	279	11	has	have	AUX
cjal-3338	279	12	not	not	PART
cjal-3338	279	13	proven	prove	VERB
cjal-3338	279	14	that	that	SCONJ
cjal-3338	279	15	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	279	16	aforementioned	aforementioned	ADJ
cjal-3338	279	17	ratio	ratio	NOUN
cjal-3338	279	18	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	279	19	time	time	NOUN
cjal-3338	279	20	parameters	parameter	NOUN
cjal-3338	279	21	can	can	AUX
cjal-3338	279	22	be	be	AUX
cjal-3338	279	23	arrived	arrive	VERB
cjal-3338	279	24	at	at	ADP
cjal-3338	279	25	without	without	ADP
cjal-3338	279	26	inventive	inventive	ADJ
cjal-3338	279	27	labor	labor	NOUN
cjal-3338	279	28	by	by	ADP
cjal-3338	279	29	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	279	30	person	person	NOUN
cjal-3338	279	31	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	279	32	ordinary	ordinary	ADJ
cjal-3338	279	33	skill	skill	NOUN
cjal-3338	279	34	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	279	35	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	279	36	art.4	art.4	PROPN
cjal-3338	279	37	'	'	PUNCT
cjal-3338	279	38	under	under	ADP
cjal-3338	279	39	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	279	40	chinese	chinese	ADJ
cjal-3338	279	41	standard	standard	NOUN
cjal-3338	279	42	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	279	43	inventiveness	inventiveness	NOUN
cjal-3338	279	44	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	279	45	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	279	46	fact	fact	NOUN
cjal-3338	279	47	that	that	SCONJ
cjal-3338	279	48	obtaining	obtain	VERB
cjal-3338	279	49	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	279	50	claimed	claim	VERB
cjal-3338	279	51	species	specie	NOUN
cjal-3338	279	52	requires	require	VERB
cjal-3338	279	53	varying	vary	VERB
cjal-3338	279	54	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	279	55	wide	wide	ADJ
cjal-3338	279	56	range	range	NOUN
cjal-3338	279	57	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	279	58	parameters	parameter	NOUN
cjal-3338	279	59	indicates	indicate	VERB
cjal-3338	279	60	that	that	SCONJ
cjal-3338	279	61	obtaining	obtain	VERB
cjal-3338	279	62	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	279	63	claimed	claim	VERB
cjal-3338	279	64	species	specie	NOUN
cjal-3338	279	65	requires	require	VERB
cjal-3338	279	66	inventive	inventive	ADJ
cjal-3338	279	67	labor.4	labor.4	NOUN
cjal-3338	279	68	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	279	69	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	279	70	supreme	supreme	PROPN
cjal-3338	279	71	people	people	PROPN
cjal-3338	279	72	's	's	PART
cjal-3338	279	73	court	court	NOUN
cjal-3338	279	74	's	's	PART
cjal-3338	279	75	analysis	analysis	NOUN
cjal-3338	279	76	seen	see	VERB
cjal-3338	279	77	above	above	ADP
cjal-3338	279	78	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	279	79	where	where	SCONJ
cjal-3338	279	80	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	279	81	fact	fact	NOUN
cjal-3338	279	82	that	that	SCONJ
cjal-3338	279	83	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	279	84	technical	technical	ADJ
cjal-3338	279	85	feature	feature	NOUN
cjal-3338	279	86	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	279	87	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	279	88	accused	accuse	VERB
cjal-3338	279	89	technical	technical	ADJ
cjal-3338	279	90	solution	solution	NOUN
cjal-3338	279	91	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	279	92	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	279	93	determined	determine	VERB
cjal-3338	279	94	by	by	ADP
cjal-3338	279	95	multiple	multiple	ADJ
cjal-3338	279	96	factors	factor	NOUN
cjal-3338	279	97	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	279	98	concert	concert	NOUN
cjal-3338	279	99	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	279	100	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	279	101	eh	eh	INTJ
cjal-3338	279	102	it	it	PRON
cjal-3338	279	103	'	'	VERB
cjal-3338	279	104	i	i	PRON
cjal-3338	279	105	*	*	NOUN
cjal-3338	279	106	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	279	107	ita	ita	PROPN
cjal-3338	279	108	&	&	CCONJ
cjal-3338	279	109	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	279	110	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	279	111	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	279	112	taken	take	VERB
cjal-3338	279	113	as	as	ADP
cjal-3338	279	114	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	279	115	sign	sign	NOUN
cjal-3338	279	116	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	279	117	inventive	inventive	ADJ
cjal-3338	279	118	labor	labor	NOUN
cjal-3338	279	119	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	279	120	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	279	121	entirely	entirely	ADV
cjal-3338	279	122	consistent	consistent	ADJ
cjal-3338	279	123	with	with	ADP
cjal-3338	279	124	this	this	DET
cjal-3338	279	125	component	component	NOUN
cjal-3338	279	126	test	test	NOUN
cjal-3338	279	127	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	279	128	inventiveness	inventiveness	NOUN
cjal-3338	279	129	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	280	1	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	280	2	oo	oo	INTJ
cjal-3338	280	3	0a	0a	NUM
cjal-3338	280	4	2	2	NUM
cjal-3338	280	5	50	50	NUM
cjal-3338	280	6	01	01	NUM
cjal-3338	280	7	0	0	NUM
cjal-3338	280	8	5	5	NUM
cjal-3338	280	9	10	10	NUM
cjal-3338	280	10	gair	gair	NOUN
cjal-3338	280	11	/l	/l	PUNCT
cjal-3338	281	1	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	281	2	-1	-1	INTJ
cjal-3338	281	3	figure	figure	VERB
cjal-3338	281	4	3	3	NUM
cjal-3338	281	5	:	:	PUNCT
cjal-3338	281	6	figure	figure	NOUN
cjal-3338	281	7	5	5	NUM
cjal-3338	281	8	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	281	9	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cjal-3338	281	10	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	281	11	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	281	12	no	no	PROPN
cjal-3338	281	13	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	282	1	4,o85,194	4,o85,194	PROPN
cjal-3338	282	2	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	282	3	entitled	entitle	VERB
cjal-3338	282	4	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	282	5	waste	waste	NOUN
cjal-3338	282	6	flue	flue	NOUN
cjal-3338	282	7	gas	gas	NOUN
cjal-3338	282	8	desulfurizing	desulfurizing	NOUN
cjal-3338	282	9	method	method	NOUN
cjal-3338	282	10	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	282	11	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	282	12	which	which	PRON
cjal-3338	282	13	according	accord	VERB
cjal-3338	282	14	to	to	ADP
cjal-3338	282	15	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	282	16	40	40	NUM
cjal-3338	282	17	2001	2001	NUM
cjal-3338	282	18	judicial	judicial	ADJ
cjal-3338	282	19	explanations	explanation	NOUN
cjal-3338	282	20	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	282	21	supra	supra	PROPN
cjal-3338	282	22	note	note	PROPN
cjal-3338	282	23	lo	lo	PROPN
cjal-3338	282	24	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	282	25	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	282	26	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	283	1	17	17	NUM
cjal-3338	283	2	.	.	NOUN
cjal-3338	283	3	4	4	NUM
cjal-3338	283	4	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	283	5	china	china	PROPN
cjal-3338	283	6	envtl	envtl	PROPN
cjal-3338	283	7	project	project	PROPN
cjal-3338	283	8	tech	tech	PROPN
cjal-3338	283	9	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	283	10	inc	inc	PROPN
cjal-3338	283	11	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	283	12	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	283	13	supra	supra	PROPN
cjal-3338	283	14	note	note	VERB
cjal-3338	283	15	38	38	NUM
cjal-3338	283	16	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	284	1	4see	4see	NUM
cjal-3338	284	2	zhangqiu	zhangqiu	PROPN
cjal-3338	284	3	riyue	riyue	PROPN
cjal-3338	284	4	huagong	huagong	PROPN
cjal-3338	284	5	youxian	youxian	PROPN
cjal-3338	284	6	gongsi	gongsi	PROPN
cjal-3338	284	7	yu	yu	PROPN
cjal-3338	284	8	guojia	guojia	PROPN
cjal-3338	284	9	zhishi	zhishi	PROPN
cjal-3338	284	10	chanquan	chanquan	PROPN
cjal-3338	284	11	ju	ju	PROPN
cjal-3338	284	12	zhuanli	zhuanli	PROPN
cjal-3338	284	13	fushen	fushen	PROPN
cjal-3338	284	14	weiyuan	weiyuan	PROPN
cjal-3338	284	15	hui	hui	PROPN
cjal-3338	284	16	zhuanli	zhuanli	PROPN
cjal-3338	284	17	quan	quan	PROPN
cjal-3338	284	18	wuxiao	wuxiao	VERB
cjal-3338	284	19	xingzheng	xingzheng	PROPN
cjal-3338	284	20	jiufen	jiufen	PROPN
cjal-3338	284	21	yian	yian	PROPN
cjal-3338	284	22	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	284	23	_	_	PUNCT
cjal-3338	284	24	ft	ft	PART
cjal-3338	284	25	h	h	PROPN
cjal-3338	284	26	p	p	PROPN
cjal-3338	284	27	fti	fti	PROPN
cjal-3338	284	28	-	-	PUNCT
cjal-3338	284	29	ilt3	ilt3	PROPN
cjal-3338	284	30	wi	wi	PROPN
cjal-3338	285	1	_	_	PROPN
cjal-3338	285	2	?	?	PUNCT
cjal-3338	286	1	4	4	NUM
cjal-3338	286	2	:	:	PUNCT
cjal-3338	286	3	-	-	PUNCT
cjal-3338	286	4	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	287	1	[	[	X
cjal-3338	287	2	zhangqiu	zhangqiu	PROPN
cjal-3338	287	3	riyue	riyue	PROPN
cjal-3338	287	4	chem	chem	PROPN
cjal-3338	287	5	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	287	6	indus	indus	PROPN
cjal-3338	287	7	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	288	1	co.	co.	PROPN
cjal-3338	288	2	v.	v.	ADP
cjal-3338	288	3	st	st	PROPN
cjal-3338	288	4	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	288	5	intell	intell	PROPN
cjal-3338	288	6	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	289	1	prop	prop	NOUN
cjal-3338	289	2	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	290	1	office	office	NOUN
cjal-3338	290	2	pat	pat	PROPN
cjal-3338	290	3	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	291	1	reexamination	reexamination	PROPN
cjal-3338	291	2	bd	bd	PROPN
cjal-3338	291	3	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	291	4	]	]	PUNCT
cjal-3338	292	1	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	292	2	beijing	beijing	PROPN
cjal-3338	292	3	high	high	PROPN
cjal-3338	292	4	people	people	NOUN
cjal-3338	292	5	's	's	PART
cjal-3338	292	6	ct	ct	NOUN
cjal-3338	292	7	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	292	8	2oo8	2oo8	NUM
cjal-3338	292	9	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	292	10	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	292	11	china	china	PROPN
cjal-3338	292	12	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	292	13	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	292	14	available	available	ADJ
cjal-3338	292	15	at	at	ADP
cjal-3338	292	16	http://ipr.court.gov.cn/bj/zlq/2oo8o5/t2oo8o523109725	http://ipr.court.gov.cn/bj/zlq/2oo8o5/t2oo8o523109725	PROPN
cjal-3338	292	17	.html	.html	PUNCT
cjal-3338	292	18	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	293	1	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	293	2	more	more	ADV
cjal-3338	293	3	detailed	detailed	ADJ
cjal-3338	293	4	discussion	discussion	NOUN
cjal-3338	293	5	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	293	6	this	this	DET
cjal-3338	293	7	doctrine	doctrine	NOUN
cjal-3338	293	8	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	293	9	provided	provide	VERB
cjal-3338	293	10	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	293	11	our	our	PRON
cjal-3338	293	12	earlier	early	ADJ
cjal-3338	293	13	article	article	NOUN
cjal-3338	293	14	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	294	1	see	see	VERB
cjal-3338	294	2	lau	lau	PROPN
cjal-3338	294	3	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	294	4	supra	supra	PROPN
cjal-3338	294	5	note	note	NOUN
cjal-3338	294	6	2	2	NUM
cjal-3338	294	7	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	294	8	defensive	defensive	ADJ
cjal-3338	294	9	use	use	NOUN
cjal-3338	294	10	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	294	11	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	294	12	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	294	13	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	294	14	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cjal-3338	294	15	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	294	16	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	294	17	chinese	chinese	PROPN
cjal-3338	294	18	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	294	19	litigation	litigation	NOUN
cjal-3338	294	20	67	67	NUM
cjal-3338	294	21	appellants	appellant	NOUN
cjal-3338	294	22	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	294	23	china	china	PROPN
cjal-3338	294	24	environmental	environmental	PROPN
cjal-3338	294	25	project	project	PROPN
cjal-3338	294	26	technology	technology	PROPN
cjal-3338	294	27	v.	v.	PROPN
cjal-3338	294	28	huayang	huayang	PROPN
cjal-3338	294	29	electric	electric	PROPN
cjal-3338	294	30	power	power	PROPN
cjal-3338	294	31	demonstrated	demonstrate	VERB
cjal-3338	294	32	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	294	33	ratio	ratio	NOUN
cjal-3338	294	34	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	294	35	air	air	NOUN
cjal-3338	294	36	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	294	37	seawater	seawater	NOUN
cjal-3338	294	38	mixing	mixing	NOUN
cjal-3338	294	39	ratio	ratio	NOUN
cjal-3338	294	40	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	295	1	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	295	2	supreme	supreme	PROPN
cjal-3338	295	3	people	people	PROPN
cjal-3338	295	4	's	's	PART
cjal-3338	295	5	court	court	NOUN
cjal-3338	295	6	also	also	ADV
cjal-3338	295	7	rejected	reject	VERB
cjal-3338	295	8	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	295	9	appellant	appellant	NOUN
cjal-3338	295	10	's	's	PART
cjal-3338	295	11	existing	exist	VERB
cjal-3338	295	12	technology	technology	NOUN
cjal-3338	295	13	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	295	14	against	against	ADP
cjal-3338	295	15	infringement	infringement	NOUN
cjal-3338	295	16	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	295	17	claim	claim	NOUN
cjal-3338	295	18	five	five	NUM
cjal-3338	295	19	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	295	20	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	295	21	asserted	asserted	ADJ
cjal-3338	295	22	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	295	23	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	296	1	applying	apply	VERB
cjal-3338	296	2	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	296	3	triple	triple	ADJ
cjal-3338	296	4	identity	identity	NOUN
cjal-3338	296	5	test	test	NOUN
cjal-3338	296	6	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	296	7	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	296	8	equivalence	equivalence	NOUN
cjal-3338	296	9	to	to	ADP
cjal-3338	296	10	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	296	11	existing	exist	VERB
cjal-3338	296	12	technology	technology	NOUN
cjal-3338	296	13	inquiry	inquiry	NOUN
cjal-3338	296	14	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	296	15	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	296	16	supreme	supreme	PROPN
cjal-3338	296	17	people	people	PROPN
cjal-3338	296	18	's	's	PART
cjal-3338	296	19	court	court	NOUN
cjal-3338	296	20	looked	look	VERB
cjal-3338	296	21	to	to	ADP
cjal-3338	296	22	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	296	23	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	296	24	function	function	NOUN
cjal-3338	296	25	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	296	26	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	296	27	vjj	vjj	NOUN
cjal-3338	296	28	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	296	29	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	296	30	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	296	31	effect	effect	NOUN
cjal-3338	296	32	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	296	33	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	296	34	wz	wz	PROPN
cjal-3338	296	35	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	296	36	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	296	37	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	296	38	technical	technical	ADJ
cjal-3338	296	39	feature	feature	NOUN
cjal-3338	296	40	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	296	41	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	296	42	accused	accuse	VERB
cjal-3338	296	43	technical	technical	ADJ
cjal-3338	296	44	solution	solution	NOUN
cjal-3338	296	45	:	:	PUNCT
cjal-3338	297	1	[	[	X
cjal-3338	297	2	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	297	3	process	process	NOUN
cjal-3338	297	4	diagram	diagram	NOUN
cjal-3338	297	5	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	297	6	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	297	7	indian	indian	ADJ
cjal-3338	297	8	power	power	NOUN
cjal-3338	297	9	plant	plant	NOUN
cjal-3338	297	10	introduced	introduce	VERB
cjal-3338	297	11	as	as	ADP
cjal-3338	297	12	evidence	evidence	NOUN
cjal-3338	297	13	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	297	14	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	297	15	existing	exist	VERB
cjal-3338	297	16	technology	technology	NOUN
cjal-3338	297	17	by	by	ADP
cjal-3338	297	18	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	297	19	appellants	appellant	NOUN
cjal-3338	297	20	]	]	PUNCT
cjal-3338	297	21	shows	show	VERB
cjal-3338	297	22	that	that	SCONJ
cjal-3338	297	23	[	[	X
cjal-3338	297	24	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	297	25	this	this	DET
cjal-3338	297	26	indian	indian	ADJ
cjal-3338	297	27	power	power	NOUN
cjal-3338	297	28	plant	plant	NOUN
cjal-3338	297	29	]	]	PUNCT
cjal-3338	297	30	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	297	31	acidic	acidic	ADJ
cjal-3338	297	32	seawater	seawater	NOUN
cjal-3338	297	33	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	297	34	introduced	introduce	VERB
cjal-3338	297	35	from	from	ADP
cjal-3338	297	36	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	297	37	top	top	ADJ
cjal-3338	297	38	side	side	NOUN
cjal-3338	297	39	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	297	40	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	297	41	mixing	mix	VERB
cjal-3338	297	42	area	area	NOUN
cjal-3338	297	43	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	297	44	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	297	45	pure	pure	ADJ
cjal-3338	297	46	seawater	seawater	NOUN
cjal-3338	297	47	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	297	48	introduced	introduce	VERB
cjal-3338	297	49	from	from	ADP
cjal-3338	297	50	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	297	51	reservoir	reservoir	NOUN
cjal-3338	297	52	on	on	ADP
cjal-3338	297	53	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	297	54	left	left	NOUN
cjal-3338	297	55	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	297	56	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	297	57	top	top	ADJ
cjal-3338	297	58	side	side	NOUN
cjal-3338	297	59	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	297	60	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	297	61	mixing	mixing	NOUN
cjal-3338	297	62	area	area	NOUN
cjal-3338	297	63	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	298	1	as	as	ADP
cjal-3338	298	2	[	[	X
cjal-3338	298	3	one	one	NUM
cjal-3338	298	4	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	298	5	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	298	6	appellants	appellant	NOUN
cjal-3338	298	7	]	]	PUNCT
cjal-3338	298	8	maintained	maintain	VERB
cjal-3338	298	9	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	298	10	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	298	11	first	first	ADJ
cjal-3338	298	12	instance	instance	NOUN
cjal-3338	298	13	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	298	14	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	298	15	acidic	acidic	ADJ
cjal-3338	298	16	seawater	seawater	NOUN
cjal-3338	298	17	[	[	PUNCT
cjal-3338	298	18	as	as	SCONJ
cjal-3338	298	19	practiced	practice	VERB
cjal-3338	298	20	by	by	ADP
cjal-3338	298	21	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	298	22	appellants	appellant	NOUN
cjal-3338	298	23	]	]	PUNCT
cjal-3338	298	24	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	298	25	introduced	introduce	VERB
cjal-3338	298	26	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	298	27	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	298	28	bottom	bottom	ADJ
cjal-3338	298	29	side	side	NOUN
cjal-3338	298	30	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	298	31	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	298	32	mixing	mix	VERB
cjal-3338	298	33	area	area	NOUN
cjal-3338	298	34	which	which	PRON
cjal-3338	298	35	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	298	36	layered	layer	VERB
cjal-3338	298	37	over	over	ADP
cjal-3338	298	38	by	by	ADP
cjal-3338	298	39	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	298	40	pure	pure	ADJ
cjal-3338	298	41	sea	sea	NOUN
cjal-3338	298	42	water	water	NOUN
cjal-3338	299	1	[	[	X
cjal-3338	299	2	on	on	ADP
cjal-3338	299	3	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	299	4	top	top	ADJ
cjal-3338	299	5	side	side	NOUN
cjal-3338	299	6	]	]	PUNCT
cjal-3338	299	7	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	299	8	so	so	SCONJ
cjal-3338	299	9	as	as	SCONJ
cjal-3338	299	10	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	299	11	ensure	ensure	VERB
cjal-3338	299	12	atmospheric	atmospheric	ADJ
cjal-3338	299	13	isolation	isolation	NOUN
cjal-3338	299	14	when	when	SCONJ
cjal-3338	299	15	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	299	16	seawater	seawater	NOUN
cjal-3338	299	17	mix	mix	NOUN
cjal-3338	299	18	together	together	ADV
cjal-3338	299	19	..	..	PUNCT
cjal-3338	300	1	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	300	2	fact	fact	NOUN
cjal-3338	300	3	that	that	SCONJ
cjal-3338	300	4	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	300	5	acidic	acidic	ADJ
cjal-3338	300	6	seawater	seawater	NOUN
cjal-3338	300	7	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	300	8	introduced	introduce	VERB
cjal-3338	300	9	into	into	ADP
cjal-3338	300	10	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	300	11	top	top	ADJ
cjal-3338	300	12	side	side	NOUN
cjal-3338	300	13	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	300	14	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	300	15	mixing	mix	VERB
cjal-3338	300	16	area	area	NOUN
cjal-3338	300	17	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	300	18	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	300	19	[	[	X
cjal-3338	300	20	indian	indian	ADJ
cjal-3338	300	21	power	power	NOUN
cjal-3338	300	22	plant	plant	NOUN
cjal-3338	300	23	]	]	PUNCT
cjal-3338	300	24	means	mean	VERB
cjal-3338	300	25	that	that	SCONJ
cjal-3338	300	26	[	[	X
cjal-3338	300	27	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	300	28	indian	indian	ADJ
cjal-3338	300	29	power	power	NOUN
cjal-3338	300	30	plant	plant	NOUN
cjal-3338	300	31	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	300	32	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	300	33	accused	accuse	VERB
cjal-3338	300	34	technical	technical	ADJ
cjal-3338	300	35	solution	solution	NOUN
cjal-3338	300	36	]	]	PUNCT
cjal-3338	300	37	are	be	AUX
cjal-3338	300	38	obviously	obviously	ADV
cjal-3338	300	39	different	different	ADJ
cjal-3338	300	40	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	300	41	function	function	NOUN
cjal-3338	300	42	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	300	43	effect.43	effect.43	NOUN
cjal-3338	300	44	as	as	SCONJ
cjal-3338	300	45	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	300	46	supreme	supreme	PROPN
cjal-3338	300	47	people	people	PROPN
cjal-3338	300	48	's	's	PART
cjal-3338	300	49	court	court	NOUN
cjal-3338	300	50	's	's	PART
cjal-3338	300	51	analysis	analysis	NOUN
cjal-3338	300	52	demonstrates	demonstrate	VERB
cjal-3338	300	53	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	300	54	all	all	DET
cjal-3338	300	55	prongs	prong	NOUN
cjal-3338	300	56	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	300	57	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	300	58	literal	literal	ADJ
cjal-3338	300	59	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	300	60	equivalents	equivalent	NOUN
cjal-3338	300	61	infringement	infringement	NOUN
cjal-3338	300	62	inquiries	inquiry	NOUN
cjal-3338	300	63	are	be	AUX
cjal-3338	300	64	incorporated	incorporate	VERB
cjal-3338	300	65	into	into	ADP
cjal-3338	300	66	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	300	67	existing	exist	VERB
cjal-3338	300	68	technology	technology	NOUN
cjal-3338	300	69	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	300	70	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	301	1	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	301	2	because	because	SCONJ
cjal-3338	301	3	some	some	PRON
cjal-3338	301	4	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	301	5	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	301	6	inventiveness	inventiveness	NOUN
cjal-3338	301	7	tests	test	NOUN
cjal-3338	301	8	are	be	AUX
cjal-3338	301	9	shared	share	VERB
cjal-3338	301	10	with	with	ADP
cjal-3338	301	11	equivalence	equivalence	NOUN
cjal-3338	301	12	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	301	13	certain	certain	ADJ
cjal-3338	301	14	concepts	concept	NOUN
cjal-3338	301	15	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	301	16	inventiveness	inventiveness	NOUN
cjal-3338	301	17	are	be	AUX
cjal-3338	301	18	applied	apply	VERB
cjal-3338	301	19	to	to	ADP
cjal-3338	301	20	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	301	21	existing	exist	VERB
cjal-3338	301	22	technology	technology	NOUN
cjal-3338	301	23	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	301	24	as	as	ADV
cjal-3338	301	25	well	well	ADV
cjal-3338	301	26	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	302	1	these	these	DET
cjal-3338	302	2	tests	test	NOUN
cjal-3338	302	3	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	302	4	standards	standard	NOUN
cjal-3338	302	5	from	from	ADP
cjal-3338	302	6	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	302	7	infringement	infringement	NOUN
cjal-3338	302	8	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	302	9	inventiveness	inventiveness	NOUN
cjal-3338	302	10	doctrines	doctrine	NOUN
cjal-3338	302	11	appear	appear	VERB
cjal-3338	302	12	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	302	13	be	be	AUX
cjal-3338	302	14	adopted	adopt	VERB
cjal-3338	302	15	within	within	ADP
cjal-3338	302	16	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	302	17	existing	exist	VERB
cjal-3338	302	18	technology	technology	NOUN
cjal-3338	302	19	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	302	20	without	without	ADP
cjal-3338	302	21	modification	modification	NOUN
cjal-3338	302	22	or	or	CCONJ
cjal-3338	302	23	adjustment	adjustment	NOUN
cjal-3338	302	24	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	303	1	c.	c.	PROPN
cjal-3338	303	2	should	should	AUX
cjal-3338	303	3	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	303	4	united	united	PROPN
cjal-3338	303	5	states	states	PROPN
cjal-3338	303	6	adopt	adopt	VERB
cjal-3338	303	7	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	303	8	practicing	practice	VERB
cjal-3338	303	9	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	303	10	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	303	11	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	303	12	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	303	13	?	?	PUNCT
cjal-3338	304	1	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	304	2	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	304	3	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	304	4	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	304	5	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	304	6	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	304	7	principle	principle	NOUN
cjal-3338	304	8	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	304	9	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	304	10	domain	domain	NOUN
cjal-3338	304	11	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	304	12	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	304	13	public	public	NOUN
cjal-3338	304	14	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	305	1	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	305	2	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cjal-3338	305	3	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	305	4	supreme	supreme	PROPN
cjal-3338	305	5	court	court	PROPN
cjal-3338	305	6	itself	itself	PRON
cjal-3338	305	7	has	have	AUX
cjal-3338	305	8	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	305	9	dicta	dicta	PROPN
cjal-3338	305	10	stated	state	VERB
cjal-3338	305	11	that	that	SCONJ
cjal-3338	305	12	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	305	13	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	305	14	once	once	SCONJ
cjal-3338	305	15	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	305	16	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	305	17	or	or	CCONJ
cjal-3338	305	18	copyright	copyright	NOUN
cjal-3338	305	19	monopoly	monopoly	NOUN
cjal-3338	305	20	has	have	AUX
cjal-3338	305	21	expired	expire	VERB
cjal-3338	305	22	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	305	23	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	305	24	public	public	NOUN
cjal-3338	305	25	may	may	AUX
cjal-3338	305	26	use	use	VERB
cjal-3338	305	27	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	305	28	invention	invention	NOUN
cjal-3338	305	29	or	or	CCONJ
cjal-3338	305	30	work	work	VERB
cjal-3338	305	31	at	at	ADP
cjal-3338	305	32	will	will	NOUN
cjal-3338	305	33	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	305	34	without	without	ADP
cjal-3338	305	35	attribution	attribution	NOUN
cjal-3338	305	36	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	305	37	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	306	1	anyone	anyone	PRON
cjal-3338	306	2	should	should	AUX
cjal-3338	306	3	be	be	AUX
cjal-3338	306	4	able	able	ADJ
cjal-3338	306	5	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	306	6	practice	practice	VERB
cjal-3338	306	7	what	what	PRON
cjal-3338	306	8	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	306	9	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	306	10	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	306	11	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	306	12	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	306	13	;	;	PUNCT
cjal-3338	306	14	why	why	SCONJ
cjal-3338	306	15	not	not	PART
cjal-3338	306	16	permit	permit	VERB
cjal-3338	306	17	it	it	PRON
cjal-3338	306	18	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	306	19	be	be	AUX
cjal-3338	306	20	an	an	DET
cjal-3338	306	21	affirmative	affirmative	ADJ
cjal-3338	306	22	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	306	23	?	?	PUNCT
cjal-3338	307	1	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	307	2	this	this	DET
cjal-3338	307	3	section	section	NOUN
cjal-3338	307	4	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	307	5	we	we	PRON
cjal-3338	307	6	explain	explain	VERB
cjal-3338	307	7	why	why	SCONJ
cjal-3338	307	8	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cjal-3338	307	9	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	307	10	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	307	11	law	law	NOUN
cjal-3338	307	12	should	should	AUX
cjal-3338	307	13	incorporate	incorporate	VERB
cjal-3338	307	14	such	such	DET
cjal-3338	307	15	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	307	16	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	307	17	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	307	18	examining	examine	VERB
cjal-3338	307	19	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	307	20	on	on	ADP
cjal-3338	307	21	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	307	22	way	way	NOUN
cjal-3338	307	23	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	307	24	justifications	justification	NOUN
cjal-3338	307	25	for	for	ADP
cjal-3338	307	26	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	307	27	against	against	ADP
cjal-3338	307	28	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	307	29	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	307	30	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	308	1	1	1	X
cjal-3338	308	2	.	.	X
cjal-3338	308	3	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	308	4	federal	federal	ADJ
cjal-3338	308	5	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cjal-3338	308	6	's	's	PART
cjal-3338	308	7	justification	justification	NOUN
cjal-3338	308	8	against	against	ADP
cjal-3338	308	9	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	308	10	practicing	practice	VERB
cjal-3338	308	11	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	308	12	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	308	13	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	308	14	defense	defense	PROPN
cjal-3338	308	15	china	china	PROPN
cjal-3338	308	16	envtl	envtl	PROPN
cjal-3338	308	17	project	project	PROPN
cjal-3338	308	18	tech	tech	PROPN
cjal-3338	308	19	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	309	1	inc	inc	PROPN
cjal-3338	309	2	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	309	3	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	309	4	supra	supra	PROPN
cjal-3338	309	5	note	note	VERB
cjal-3338	309	6	38	38	NUM
cjal-3338	309	7	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	310	1	columbia	columbia	PROPN
cjal-3338	310	2	journal	journal	PROPN
cjal-3338	310	3	ofasian	ofasian	ADJ
cjal-3338	310	4	law	law	NOUN
cjal-3338	310	5	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	310	6	vol	vol	NOUN
cjal-3338	310	7	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	310	8	27	27	NUM
cjal-3338	310	9	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	310	10	no	no	INTJ
cjal-3338	310	11	.	.	NOUN
cjal-3338	310	12	1	1	NUM
cjal-3338	310	13	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	310	14	2013	2013	NUM
cjal-3338	310	15	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	310	16	we	we	PRON
cjal-3338	310	17	begin	begin	VERB
cjal-3338	310	18	by	by	ADP
cjal-3338	310	19	confronting	confront	VERB
cjal-3338	310	20	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	310	21	federal	federal	ADJ
cjal-3338	310	22	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cjal-3338	310	23	's	's	PART
cjal-3338	310	24	justification	justification	NOUN
cjal-3338	310	25	for	for	ADP
cjal-3338	310	26	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	310	27	lack	lack	NOUN
cjal-3338	310	28	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	310	29	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	310	30	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	310	31	practicing	practice	VERB
cjal-3338	310	32	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	310	33	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	310	34	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	310	35	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	310	36	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	310	37	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	310	38	articulated	articulate	VERB
cjal-3338	310	39	as	as	SCONJ
cjal-3338	310	40	follows	follow	VERB
cjal-3338	310	41	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	310	42	tate	tate	NOUN
cjal-3338	310	43	access	access	NOUN
cjal-3338	310	44	floors	floor	NOUN
cjal-3338	310	45	v.	v.	ADP
cjal-3338	310	46	interface	interface	NOUN
cjal-3338	310	47	architectural	architectural	ADJ
cjal-3338	310	48	resources	resource	NOUN
cjal-3338	310	49	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	310	50	our	our	PRON
cjal-3338	310	51	law	law	NOUN
cjal-3338	310	52	requires	require	VERB
cjal-3338	310	53	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	310	54	challengers	challenger	NOUN
cjal-3338	310	55	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	310	56	prove	prove	VERB
cjal-3338	310	57	invalidity	invalidity	NOUN
cjal-3338	310	58	by	by	ADP
cjal-3338	310	59	clear	clear	ADJ
cjal-3338	310	60	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	310	61	convincing	convincing	ADJ
cjal-3338	310	62	evidence	evidence	NOUN
cjal-3338	310	63	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	311	1	where	where	SCONJ
cjal-3338	311	2	an	an	DET
cjal-3338	311	3	accused	accuse	VERB
cjal-3338	311	4	infringer	infringer	NOUN
cjal-3338	311	5	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	311	6	clearly	clearly	ADV
cjal-3338	311	7	practicing	practice	VERB
cjal-3338	311	8	only	only	ADV
cjal-3338	311	9	that	that	PRON
cjal-3338	311	10	which	which	PRON
cjal-3338	311	11	was	be	AUX
cjal-3338	311	12	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	311	13	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	311	14	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	311	15	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	311	16	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	311	17	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	311	18	nothing	nothing	PRON
cjal-3338	311	19	more	more	ADJ
cjal-3338	311	20	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	311	21	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	311	22	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	311	23	patentee	patentee	NOUN
cjal-3338	311	24	's	's	PART
cjal-3338	311	25	proffered	proffered	ADJ
cjal-3338	311	26	construction	construction	NOUN
cjal-3338	311	27	reads	read	VERB
cjal-3338	311	28	on	on	ADP
cjal-3338	311	29	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	311	30	accused	accuse	VERB
cjal-3338	311	31	device	device	NOUN
cjal-3338	311	32	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	311	33	meeting	meet	VERB
cjal-3338	311	34	this	this	DET
cjal-3338	311	35	burden	burden	NOUN
cjal-3338	311	36	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	311	37	proof	proof	NOUN
cjal-3338	311	38	should	should	AUX
cjal-3338	311	39	not	not	PART
cjal-3338	311	40	prove	prove	VERB
cjal-3338	311	41	difficult	difficult	ADJ
cjal-3338	311	42	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	312	1	nevertheless	nevertheless	ADV
cjal-3338	312	2	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	312	3	accused	accuse	VERB
cjal-3338	312	4	infringers	infringer	NOUN
cjal-3338	312	5	are	be	AUX
cjal-3338	312	6	not	not	PART
cjal-3338	312	7	free	free	ADJ
cjal-3338	312	8	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	312	9	flout	flout	VERB
cjal-3338	312	10	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	312	11	requirement	requirement	NOUN
cjal-3338	312	12	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	312	13	proving	prove	VERB
cjal-3338	312	14	invalidity	invalidity	NOUN
cjal-3338	312	15	by	by	ADP
cjal-3338	312	16	clear	clear	ADJ
cjal-3338	312	17	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	312	18	convincing	convincing	ADJ
cjal-3338	312	19	evidence	evidence	NOUN
cjal-3338	312	20	by	by	ADP
cjal-3338	312	21	asserting	assert	VERB
cjal-3338	312	22	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	312	23	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	312	24	practicing	practice	VERB
cjal-3338	312	25	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	312	26	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	312	27	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	312	28	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	312	29	to	to	ADP
cjal-3338	312	30	literal	literal	ADJ
cjal-3338	312	31	infringement	infringement	NOUN
cjal-3338	312	32	under	under	ADP
cjal-3338	312	33	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	312	34	less	less	ADV
cjal-3338	312	35	stringent	stringent	ADJ
cjal-3338	312	36	preponderance	preponderance	NOUN
cjal-3338	312	37	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	312	38	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	312	39	evidence	evidence	NOUN
cjal-3338	312	40	standard	standard	NOUN
cjal-3338	312	41	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	312	42	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	313	1	taken	take	VERB
cjal-3338	313	2	at	at	ADP
cjal-3338	313	3	face	face	NOUN
cjal-3338	313	4	value	value	NOUN
cjal-3338	313	5	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	313	6	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	313	7	federal	federal	ADJ
cjal-3338	313	8	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cjal-3338	313	9	's	's	PART
cjal-3338	313	10	language	language	NOUN
cjal-3338	313	11	points	point	NOUN
cjal-3338	313	12	to	to	ADP
cjal-3338	313	13	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	313	14	concern	concern	NOUN
cjal-3338	313	15	that	that	SCONJ
cjal-3338	313	16	infringers	infringer	NOUN
cjal-3338	313	17	can	can	AUX
cjal-3338	313	18	circumvent	circumvent	VERB
cjal-3338	313	19	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	313	20	heightened	heightened	ADJ
cjal-3338	313	21	burden	burden	NOUN
cjal-3338	313	22	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	313	23	proof	proof	NOUN
cjal-3338	313	24	for	for	ADP
cjal-3338	313	25	invalidity	invalidity	NOUN
cjal-3338	313	26	by	by	ADP
cjal-3338	313	27	demonstrating	demonstrate	VERB
cjal-3338	313	28	that	that	SCONJ
cjal-3338	313	29	they	they	PRON
cjal-3338	313	30	are	be	AUX
cjal-3338	313	31	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	313	32	practicing	practice	VERB
cjal-3338	313	33	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	313	34	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	313	35	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	313	36	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	313	37	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	314	1	but	but	CCONJ
cjal-3338	314	2	such	such	DET
cjal-3338	314	3	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	314	4	literal	literal	ADJ
cjal-3338	314	5	reading	reading	NOUN
cjal-3338	314	6	should	should	AUX
cjal-3338	314	7	give	give	VERB
cjal-3338	314	8	us	we	PRON
cjal-3338	314	9	pause	pause	NOUN
cjal-3338	314	10	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	315	1	there	there	PRON
cjal-3338	315	2	is	be	VERB
cjal-3338	315	3	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	315	4	first	first	ADV
cjal-3338	315	5	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	315	6	all	all	PRON
cjal-3338	315	7	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	315	8	no	no	DET
cjal-3338	315	9	reason	reason	NOUN
cjal-3338	315	10	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	315	11	equate	equate	VERB
cjal-3338	315	12	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	315	13	practicing	practice	VERB
cjal-3338	315	14	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	315	15	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	315	16	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	315	17	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	315	18	with	with	ADP
cjal-3338	315	19	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	315	20	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	315	21	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	315	22	invalidity	invalidity	NOUN
cjal-3338	315	23	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	315	24	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	316	1	as	as	SCONJ
cjal-3338	316	2	we	we	PRON
cjal-3338	316	3	have	have	AUX
cjal-3338	316	4	seen	see	VERB
cjal-3338	316	5	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	316	6	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	316	7	example	example	NOUN
cjal-3338	316	8	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	316	9	chinese	chinese	ADJ
cjal-3338	316	10	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	316	11	law	law	NOUN
cjal-3338	316	12	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	316	13	it	it	PRON
cjal-3338	316	14	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	316	15	possible	possible	ADJ
cjal-3338	316	16	to	to	ADP
cjal-3338	316	17	structure	structure	NOUN
cjal-3338	316	18	practicing	practice	VERB
cjal-3338	316	19	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	316	20	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	316	21	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	316	22	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	316	23	be	be	AUX
cjal-3338	316	24	an	an	DET
cjal-3338	316	25	entirely	entirely	ADV
cjal-3338	316	26	separate	separate	ADJ
cjal-3338	316	27	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	316	28	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	317	1	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	317	2	indeed	indeed	ADV
cjal-3338	317	3	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	317	4	letting	let	VERB
cjal-3338	317	5	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	317	6	defendant	defendant	NOUN
cjal-3338	317	7	prevail	prevail	VERB
cjal-3338	317	8	on	on	ADP
cjal-3338	317	9	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	317	10	basis	basis	NOUN
cjal-3338	317	11	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	317	12	practicing	practice	VERB
cjal-3338	317	13	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	317	14	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	317	15	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	317	16	does	do	AUX
cjal-3338	317	17	not	not	PART
cjal-3338	317	18	logically	logically	ADV
cjal-3338	317	19	mean	mean	VERB
cjal-3338	317	20	that	that	SCONJ
cjal-3338	317	21	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	317	22	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	317	23	becomes	become	VERB
cjal-3338	317	24	unenforceable	unenforceable	ADJ
cjal-3338	317	25	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	318	1	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	318	2	be	be	AUX
cjal-3338	318	3	sure	sure	ADJ
cjal-3338	318	4	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	318	5	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	318	6	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	318	7	trial	trial	NOUN
cjal-3338	318	8	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	318	9	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	318	10	patentee	patentee	NOUN
cjal-3338	318	11	must	must	AUX
cjal-3338	318	12	have	have	AUX
cjal-3338	318	13	argued	argue	VERB
cjal-3338	318	14	that	that	SCONJ
cjal-3338	318	15	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	318	16	defendant	defendant	NOUN
cjal-3338	318	17	's	's	PART
cjal-3338	318	18	accused	accuse	VERB
cjal-3338	318	19	acts	act	NOUN
cjal-3338	318	20	fall	fall	VERB
cjal-3338	318	21	within	within	ADP
cjal-3338	318	22	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	318	23	scope	scope	NOUN
cjal-3338	318	24	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	318	25	his	his	PRON
cjal-3338	318	26	claims	claim	NOUN
cjal-3338	318	27	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	319	1	if	if	SCONJ
cjal-3338	319	2	these	these	PRON
cjal-3338	319	3	accused	accuse	VERB
cjal-3338	319	4	acts	act	NOUN
cjal-3338	319	5	do	do	AUX
cjal-3338	319	6	fall	fall	VERB
cjal-3338	319	7	within	within	ADP
cjal-3338	319	8	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	319	9	scope	scope	NOUN
cjal-3338	319	10	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	319	11	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	319	12	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	319	13	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	319	14	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	319	15	patentee	patentee	NOUN
cjal-3338	319	16	's	's	PART
cjal-3338	319	17	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	319	18	claims	claim	NOUN
cjal-3338	319	19	would	would	AUX
cjal-3338	319	20	be	be	AUX
cjal-3338	319	21	invalid	invalid	ADJ
cjal-3338	319	22	if	if	SCONJ
cjal-3338	319	23	they	they	PRON
cjal-3338	319	24	actually	actually	ADV
cjal-3338	319	25	read	read	VERB
cjal-3338	319	26	on	on	ADP
cjal-3338	319	27	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	319	28	accused	accuse	VERB
cjal-3338	319	29	acts	act	NOUN
cjal-3338	319	30	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	320	1	but	but	CCONJ
cjal-3338	320	2	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	320	3	patentee	patentee	NOUN
cjal-3338	320	4	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	320	5	not	not	PART
cjal-3338	320	6	bound	bind	VERB
cjal-3338	320	7	by	by	ADP
cjal-3338	320	8	this	this	DET
cjal-3338	320	9	position	position	NOUN
cjal-3338	320	10	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	320	11	all	all	DET
cjal-3338	320	12	future	future	ADJ
cjal-3338	320	13	litigation	litigation	NOUN
cjal-3338	320	14	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	320	15	precisely	precisely	ADV
cjal-3338	320	16	because	because	SCONJ
cjal-3338	320	17	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	320	18	judgment	judgment	NOUN
cjal-3338	320	19	about	about	ADP
cjal-3338	320	20	practicing	practice	VERB
cjal-3338	320	21	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	320	22	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	320	23	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	320	24	does	do	AUX
cjal-3338	320	25	not	not	PART
cjal-3338	320	26	rest	rest	VERB
cjal-3338	320	27	on	on	ADP
cjal-3338	320	28	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	320	29	decision	decision	NOUN
cjal-3338	320	30	about	about	ADP
cjal-3338	320	31	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	320	32	scope	scope	NOUN
cjal-3338	320	33	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	320	34	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	320	35	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	320	36	claims	claim	VERB
cjal-3338	320	37	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	321	1	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	321	2	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cjal-3338	321	3	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	321	4	supreme	supreme	PROPN
cjal-3338	321	5	court	court	PROPN
cjal-3338	321	6	has	have	AUX
cjal-3338	321	7	stated	state	VERB
cjal-3338	321	8	that	that	SCONJ
cjal-3338	321	9	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	321	10	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	321	11	considering	consider	VERB
cjal-3338	321	12	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	321	13	application	application	NOUN
cjal-3338	321	14	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	321	15	judicial	judicial	ADJ
cjal-3338	321	16	estoppel	estoppel	NOUN
cjal-3338	321	17	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	321	18	which	which	PRON
cjal-3338	321	19	would	would	AUX
cjal-3338	321	20	bind	bind	VERB
cjal-3338	321	21	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	321	22	litigant	litigant	NOUN
cjal-3338	321	23	to	to	ADP
cjal-3338	321	24	his	his	PRON
cjal-3338	321	25	initial	initial	ADJ
cjal-3338	321	26	position	position	NOUN
cjal-3338	321	27	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	321	28	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	321	29	courts	court	NOUN
cjal-3338	321	30	regularly	regularly	ADV
cjal-3338	321	31	inquire	inquire	VERB
cjal-3338	321	32	whether	whether	SCONJ
cjal-3338	321	33	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	321	34	party	party	NOUN
cjal-3338	321	35	has	have	AUX
cjal-3338	321	36	succeeded	succeed	VERB
cjal-3338	321	37	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	321	38	persuading	persuade	VERB
cjal-3338	321	39	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	321	40	court	court	NOUN
cjal-3338	321	41	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	321	42	accept	accept	VERB
cjal-3338	321	43	that	that	DET
cjal-3338	321	44	party	party	NOUN
cjal-3338	321	45	's	's	PART
cjal-3338	321	46	earlier	early	ADJ
cjal-3338	321	47	position	position	NOUN
cjal-3338	321	48	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	321	49	so	so	SCONJ
cjal-3338	321	50	that	that	SCONJ
cjal-3338	321	51	judicial	judicial	ADJ
cjal-3338	321	52	acceptance	acceptance	NOUN
cjal-3338	321	53	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	321	54	an	an	DET
cjal-3338	321	55	inconsistent	inconsistent	ADJ
cjal-3338	321	56	position	position	NOUN
cjal-3338	321	57	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	321	58	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	321	59	later	later	ADJ
cjal-3338	321	60	proceeding	proceeding	NOUN
cjal-3338	321	61	would	would	AUX
cjal-3338	321	62	create	create	VERB
cjal-3338	321	63	'	'	PUNCT
cjal-3338	321	64	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	321	65	perception	perception	NOUN
cjal-3338	321	66	that	that	SCONJ
cjal-3338	321	67	either	either	CCONJ
cjal-3338	321	68	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	321	69	first	first	ADJ
cjal-3338	321	70	or	or	CCONJ
cjal-3338	321	71	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	321	72	second	second	ADJ
cjal-3338	321	73	court	court	NOUN
cjal-3338	321	74	was	be	AUX
cjal-3338	321	75	misled	mislead	VERB
cjal-3338	321	76	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	321	77	"'45	"'45	NOUN
cjal-3338	321	78	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	321	79	performing	perform	VERB
cjal-3338	321	80	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	321	81	practicing	practicing	NOUN
cjal-3338	321	82	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	321	83	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	321	84	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	321	85	inquiry	inquiry	NOUN
cjal-3338	321	86	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	321	87	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	321	88	court	court	NOUN
cjal-3338	321	89	has	have	AUX
cjal-3338	321	90	performed	perform	VERB
cjal-3338	321	91	no	no	DET
cjal-3338	321	92	analysis	analysis	NOUN
cjal-3338	321	93	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	321	94	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	321	95	scope	scope	NOUN
cjal-3338	321	96	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	321	97	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	321	98	claims	claim	NOUN
cjal-3338	321	99	at	at	ADV
cjal-3338	321	100	all	all	ADV
cjal-3338	321	101	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	322	1	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	322	2	patentee	patentee	NOUN
cjal-3338	322	3	therefore	therefore	ADV
cjal-3338	322	4	can	can	AUX
cjal-3338	322	5	claim	claim	VERB
cjal-3338	322	6	no	no	DET
cjal-3338	322	7	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	322	8	success	success	NOUN
cjal-3338	322	9	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	322	10	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	322	11	persuading	persuade	VERB
cjal-3338	322	12	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	322	13	tribunal	tribunal	NOUN
cjal-3338	322	14	about	about	ADP
cjal-3338	322	15	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	322	16	scope	scope	NOUN
cjal-3338	322	17	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	322	18	his	his	PRON
cjal-3338	322	19	claim	claim	NOUN
cjal-3338	322	20	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	323	1	as	as	SCONJ
cjal-3338	323	2	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	323	3	supreme	supreme	PROPN
cjal-3338	323	4	court	court	PROPN
cjal-3338	323	5	noted	note	VERB
cjal-3338	323	6	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	323	7	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	323	8	[	[	X
cjal-3338	323	9	aibsent	aibsent	NOUN
cjal-3338	323	10	success	success	NOUN
cjal-3338	323	11	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	323	12	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	323	13	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	323	14	proceeding	proceeding	NOUN
cjal-3338	323	15	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	323	16	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	323	17	party	party	NOUN
cjal-3338	323	18	's	's	PART
cjal-3338	323	19	later	later	ADJ
cjal-3338	323	20	inconsistent	inconsistent	ADJ
cjal-3338	323	21	position	position	NOUN
cjal-3338	323	22	introduces	introduce	VERB
cjal-3338	323	23	no	no	DET
cjal-3338	323	24	'	'	NOUN
cjal-3338	323	25	risk	risk	NOUN
cjal-3338	323	26	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	323	27	inconsistent	inconsistent	ADJ
cjal-3338	323	28	court	court	NOUN
cjal-3338	323	29	determinations	determination	NOUN
cjal-3338	323	30	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	323	31	'	'	PUNCT
cjal-3338	323	32	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	323	33	thus	thus	ADV
cjal-3338	323	34	poses	pose	VERB
cjal-3338	323	35	little	little	ADJ
cjal-3338	323	36	threat	threat	NOUN
cjal-3338	323	37	to	to	ADP
cjal-3338	323	38	judicial	judicial	ADJ
cjal-3338	323	39	integrity	integrity	NOUN
cjal-3338	323	40	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	323	41	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	324	1	6	6	NUM
cjal-3338	324	2	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	324	3	patentee	patentee	NOUN
cjal-3338	324	4	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	324	5	free	free	ADJ
cjal-3338	324	6	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	324	7	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	324	8	future	future	ADJ
cjal-3338	324	9	litigation	litigation	NOUN
cjal-3338	324	10	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	324	11	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	324	12	change	change	VERB
cjal-3338	324	13	his	his	PRON
cjal-3338	324	14	position	position	NOUN
cjal-3338	324	15	about	about	ADP
cjal-3338	324	16	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	324	17	scope	scope	NOUN
cjal-3338	324	18	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	324	19	his	his	PRON
cjal-3338	324	20	claims	claim	NOUN
cjal-3338	324	21	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	325	1	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	325	2	aggressively	aggressively	ADV
cjal-3338	325	3	equating	equate	VERB
cjal-3338	325	4	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	325	5	practicing	practicing	NOUN
cjal-3338	325	6	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	325	7	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	325	8	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	325	9	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	325	10	with	with	ADP
cjal-3338	325	11	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	325	12	invalidity	invalidity	NOUN
cjal-3338	325	13	defenses	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	325	14	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	325	15	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	325	16	federal	federal	ADJ
cjal-3338	325	17	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cjal-3338	325	18	's	's	PART
cjal-3338	325	19	position	position	NOUN
cjal-3338	325	20	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	325	21	tate	tate	NOUN
cjal-3338	325	22	access	access	NOUN
cjal-3338	325	23	floors	floor	NOUN
cjal-3338	325	24	can	can	AUX
cjal-3338	325	25	44	44	NUM
cjal-3338	325	26	tate	tate	NOUN
cjal-3338	325	27	access	access	NOUN
cjal-3338	325	28	floors	floor	NOUN
cjal-3338	325	29	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	325	30	inc	inc	PROPN
cjal-3338	325	31	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	326	1	v.	v.	PROPN
cjal-3338	326	2	interface	interface	PROPN
cjal-3338	326	3	archit	archit	PROPN
cjal-3338	326	4	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	327	1	res	re	NOUN
cjal-3338	327	2	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	327	3	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	327	4	inc	inc	PROPN
cjal-3338	327	5	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	327	6	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	327	7	279	279	NUM
cjal-3338	327	8	f.3d	f.3d	NUM
cjal-3338	327	9	1357	1357	NUM
cjal-3338	327	10	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	327	11	1367	1367	NUM
cjal-3338	327	12	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	328	1	fed	fed	PROPN
cjal-3338	328	2	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	328	3	cir	cir	PROPN
cjal-3338	328	4	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	328	5	2002	2002	NUM
cjal-3338	328	6	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	328	7	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	329	1	4new	4new	PROPN
cjal-3338	329	2	hampshire	hampshire	PROPN
cjal-3338	329	3	v.	v.	PROPN
cjal-3338	329	4	maine	maine	PROPN
cjal-3338	329	5	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	329	6	532	532	NUM
cjal-3338	329	7	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cjal-3338	329	8	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	329	9	742	742	NUM
cjal-3338	329	10	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	329	11	750	750	NUM
cjal-3338	329	12	-	-	SYM
cjal-3338	329	13	751	751	NUM
cjal-3338	329	14	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	329	15	2001	2001	NUM
cjal-3338	329	16	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	329	17	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	329	18	quoting	quote	VERB
cjal-3338	329	19	edwards	edwards	PROPN
cjal-3338	329	20	v.	v.	PROPN
cjal-3338	329	21	aetna	aetna	PROPN
cjal-3338	329	22	life	life	PROPN
cjal-3338	329	23	insurance	insurance	PROPN
cjal-3338	329	24	co.	co.	PROPN
cjal-3338	329	25	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	329	26	69o	69o	NUM
cjal-3338	329	27	f.2d	f.2d	ADP
cjal-3338	329	28	595	595	NUM
cjal-3338	329	29	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	329	30	599	599	NUM
cjal-3338	329	31	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	329	32	6th	6th	ADJ
cjal-3338	329	33	cir	cir	NOUN
cjal-3338	329	34	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	329	35	1982	1982	NUM
cjal-3338	329	36	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	329	37	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	329	38	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	330	1	46	46	NUM
cjal-3338	331	1	i	i	PRON
cjal-3338	331	2	d.	d.	PROPN
cjal-3338	331	3	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	331	4	citation	citation	NOUN
cjal-3338	331	5	omitted	omit	VERB
cjal-3338	331	6	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	331	7	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	332	1	defensive	defensive	ADJ
cjal-3338	332	2	use	use	NOUN
cjal-3338	332	3	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	332	4	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	332	5	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	332	6	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	332	7	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cjal-3338	332	8	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	332	9	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	332	10	chinese	chinese	PROPN
cjal-3338	332	11	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	332	12	litigation	litigation	NOUN
cjal-3338	332	13	69	69	NUM
cjal-3338	332	14	hardly	hardly	ADV
cjal-3338	332	15	be	be	AUX
cjal-3338	332	16	reconciled	reconcile	VERB
cjal-3338	332	17	with	with	ADP
cjal-3338	332	18	its	its	PRON
cjal-3338	332	19	position	position	NOUN
cjal-3338	332	20	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	332	21	siemens	siemens	PROPN
cjal-3338	332	22	medical	medical	ADJ
cjal-3338	332	23	solutions	solution	NOUN
cjal-3338	332	24	discussed	discuss	VERB
cjal-3338	332	25	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	332	26	our	our	PRON
cjal-3338	332	27	previous	previous	ADJ
cjal-3338	332	28	article.47	article.47	NOUN
cjal-3338	332	29	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	332	30	have	have	AUX
cjal-3338	332	31	reached	reach	VERB
cjal-3338	332	32	its	its	PRON
cjal-3338	332	33	conclusion	conclusion	NOUN
cjal-3338	332	34	that	that	SCONJ
cjal-3338	332	35	asserting	assert	VERB
cjal-3338	332	36	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	332	37	practicing	practice	VERB
cjal-3338	332	38	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	332	39	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	332	40	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	332	41	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	332	42	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	332	43	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	332	44	[	[	X
cjal-3338	332	45	flouting	flout	VERB
cjal-3338	332	46	]	]	PUNCT
cjal-3338	332	47	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	332	48	requirement	requirement	NOUN
cjal-3338	332	49	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	332	50	proving	prove	VERB
cjal-3338	332	51	invalidity	invalidity	NOUN
cjal-3338	332	52	by	by	ADP
cjal-3338	332	53	clear	clear	ADJ
cjal-3338	332	54	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	332	55	convincing	convincing	ADJ
cjal-3338	332	56	evidence	evidence	NOUN
cjal-3338	332	57	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	332	58	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	332	59	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	332	60	federal	federal	ADJ
cjal-3338	332	61	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cjal-3338	332	62	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	332	63	tate	tate	NOUN
cjal-3338	332	64	access	access	NOUN
cjal-3338	332	65	floors	floor	NOUN
cjal-3338	332	66	must	must	AUX
cjal-3338	332	67	have	have	AUX
cjal-3338	332	68	concluded	conclude	VERB
cjal-3338	332	69	that	that	SCONJ
cjal-3338	332	70	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	332	71	practicing	practice	VERB
cjal-3338	332	72	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	332	73	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	332	74	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	332	75	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	332	76	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	332	77	tantamount	tantamount	ADJ
cjal-3338	332	78	to	to	ADP
cjal-3338	332	79	an	an	DET
cjal-3338	332	80	invalidity	invalidity	NOUN
cjal-3338	332	81	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	332	82	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	333	1	8	8	NUM
cjal-3338	334	1	but	but	CCONJ
cjal-3338	334	2	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	334	3	siemens	siemens	PROPN
cjal-3338	334	4	medical	medical	ADJ
cjal-3338	334	5	solutions	solution	NOUN
cjal-3338	334	6	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	334	7	where	where	SCONJ
cjal-3338	334	8	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	334	9	patentee	patentee	NOUN
cjal-3338	334	10	seeks	seek	VERB
cjal-3338	334	11	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	334	12	exclude	exclude	VERB
cjal-3338	334	13	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	334	14	defendant	defendant	NOUN
cjal-3338	334	15	by	by	ADP
cjal-3338	334	16	equivalence	equivalence	NOUN
cjal-3338	334	17	from	from	ADP
cjal-3338	334	18	territory	territory	NOUN
cjal-3338	334	19	covered	cover	VERB
cjal-3338	334	20	by	by	ADP
cjal-3338	334	21	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	334	22	defendant	defendant	NOUN
cjal-3338	334	23	's	's	PART
cjal-3338	334	24	separate	separate	ADJ
cjal-3338	334	25	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	334	26	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	334	27	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	334	28	court	court	NOUN
cjal-3338	334	29	refused	refuse	VERB
cjal-3338	334	30	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	334	31	import	import	VERB
cjal-3338	334	32	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	334	33	higher	high	ADJ
cjal-3338	334	34	evidentiary	evidentiary	ADJ
cjal-3338	334	35	standard	standard	NOUN
cjal-3338	334	36	for	for	ADP
cjal-3338	334	37	invalidity	invalidity	NOUN
cjal-3338	334	38	into	into	ADP
cjal-3338	334	39	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	334	40	equivalence	equivalence	NOUN
cjal-3338	334	41	determination	determination	NOUN
cjal-3338	334	42	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	335	1	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	335	2	reaching	reach	VERB
cjal-3338	335	3	this	this	DET
cjal-3338	335	4	conclusion	conclusion	NOUN
cjal-3338	335	5	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	335	6	six	six	NUM
cjal-3338	335	7	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	335	8	eleven	eleven	NUM
cjal-3338	335	9	judges	judge	NOUN
cjal-3338	335	10	concluded	conclude	VERB
cjal-3338	335	11	that	that	SCONJ
cjal-3338	335	12	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	335	13	invocation	invocation	NOUN
cjal-3338	335	14	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	335	15	an	an	DET
cjal-3338	335	16	equivalence	equivalence	NOUN
cjal-3338	335	17	theory	theory	NOUN
cjal-3338	335	18	against	against	ADP
cjal-3338	335	19	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	335	20	accused	accuse	VERB
cjal-3338	335	21	acts	act	NOUN
cjal-3338	335	22	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	335	23	not	not	PART
cjal-3338	335	24	tantamount	tantamount	ADJ
cjal-3338	335	25	to	to	ADP
cjal-3338	335	26	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	335	27	invalidation	invalidation	NOUN
cjal-3338	335	28	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	335	29	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	335	30	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	335	31	over	over	ADP
cjal-3338	335	32	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	335	33	same	same	ADJ
cjal-3338	335	34	accused	accuse	VERB
cjal-3338	335	35	acts	act	NOUN
cjal-3338	335	36	on	on	ADP
cjal-3338	335	37	obviousness	obviousness	ADJ
cjal-3338	335	38	grounds	ground	NOUN
cjal-3338	335	39	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	335	40	but	but	CCONJ
cjal-3338	335	41	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	335	42	merely	merely	ADV
cjal-3338	335	43	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	335	44	assertion	assertion	NOUN
cjal-3338	335	45	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	335	46	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	335	47	right	right	NOUN
cjal-3338	335	48	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	335	49	exclude	exclude	VERB
cjal-3338	335	50	over	over	ADP
cjal-3338	335	51	what	what	PRON
cjal-3338	335	52	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	335	53	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	335	54	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	335	55	effect	effect	NOUN
cjal-3338	335	56	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	335	57	dominant	dominant	ADJ
cjal-3338	335	58	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	335	59	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	336	1	49	49	NUM
cjal-3338	337	1	this	this	DET
cjal-3338	337	2	outcome	outcome	NOUN
cjal-3338	337	3	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	337	4	all	all	DET
cjal-3338	337	5	the	the	PRON
cjal-3338	337	6	more	more	ADV
cjal-3338	337	7	surprising	surprising	ADJ
cjal-3338	337	8	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	337	9	when	when	SCONJ
cjal-3338	337	10	one	one	PRON
cjal-3338	337	11	considers	consider	VERB
cjal-3338	337	12	that	that	SCONJ
cjal-3338	337	13	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	337	14	practicing	practice	VERB
cjal-3338	337	15	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	337	16	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	337	17	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	337	18	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	337	19	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	337	20	strictly	strictly	ADV
cjal-3338	337	21	focused	focus	VERB
cjal-3338	337	22	on	on	ADP
cjal-3338	337	23	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	337	24	accused	accuse	VERB
cjal-3338	337	25	acts	act	NOUN
cjal-3338	337	26	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	337	27	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	337	28	requires	require	VERB
cjal-3338	337	29	no	no	DET
cjal-3338	337	30	claim	claim	NOUN
cjal-3338	337	31	construction	construction	NOUN
cjal-3338	337	32	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	337	33	no	no	DET
cjal-3338	337	34	infringement	infringement	NOUN
cjal-3338	337	35	analysis	analysis	NOUN
cjal-3338	337	36	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	337	37	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	337	38	no	no	DET
cjal-3338	337	39	adjudication	adjudication	NOUN
cjal-3338	337	40	over	over	ADP
cjal-3338	337	41	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	337	42	merits	merit	NOUN
cjal-3338	337	43	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	337	44	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	337	45	asserted	asserted	ADJ
cjal-3338	337	46	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	337	47	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	338	1	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	338	2	contrast	contrast	NOUN
cjal-3338	338	3	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	338	4	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	338	5	siemens	siemens	PROPN
cjal-3338	338	6	medical	medical	ADJ
cjal-3338	338	7	solutions	solution	NOUN
cjal-3338	338	8	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	338	9	where	where	SCONJ
cjal-3338	338	10	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	338	11	accused	accuse	VERB
cjal-3338	338	12	activities	activity	NOUN
cjal-3338	338	13	are	be	AUX
cjal-3338	338	14	covered	cover	VERB
cjal-3338	338	15	by	by	ADP
cjal-3338	338	16	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	338	17	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	338	18	separate	separate	ADJ
cjal-3338	338	19	from	from	ADP
cjal-3338	338	20	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	338	21	asserted	asserted	ADJ
cjal-3338	338	22	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	338	23	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	338	24	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	338	25	same	same	ADJ
cjal-3338	338	26	accused	accuse	VERB
cjal-3338	338	27	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	338	28	separately	separately	ADV
cjal-3338	338	29	patented	patented	ADJ
cjal-3338	338	30	acts	act	NOUN
cjal-3338	338	31	are	be	AUX
cjal-3338	338	32	analyzed	analyze	VERB
cjal-3338	338	33	using	use	VERB
cjal-3338	338	34	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	338	35	triple	triple	ADJ
cjal-3338	338	36	identity	identity	NOUN
cjal-3338	338	37	test	test	NOUN
cjal-3338	338	38	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	338	39	equivalence	equivalence	NOUN
cjal-3338	338	40	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	338	41	that	that	ADV
cjal-3338	338	42	is	is	ADV
cjal-3338	338	43	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	338	44	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	338	45	whether	whether	SCONJ
cjal-3338	338	46	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	338	47	substitute	substitute	NOUN
cjal-3338	338	48	element	element	NOUN
cjal-3338	338	49	matches	match	VERB
cjal-3338	338	50	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	338	51	function	function	NOUN
cjal-3338	338	52	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	338	53	way	way	NOUN
cjal-3338	338	54	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	338	55	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	338	56	result	result	NOUN
cjal-3338	338	57	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	338	58	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	338	59	[	[	X
cjal-3338	338	60	asserted	assert	VERB
cjal-3338	338	61	]	]	PUNCT
cjal-3338	338	62	claimed	claim	VERB
cjal-3338	338	63	element	element	NOUN
cjal-3338	338	64	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	339	1	"50	"50	PROPN
cjal-3338	339	2	because	because	SCONJ
cjal-3338	339	3	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	339	4	asserted	assert	VERB
cjal-3338	339	5	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	339	6	itself	itself	PRON
cjal-3338	339	7	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	339	8	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	339	9	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	339	10	to	to	ADP
cjal-3338	339	11	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	339	12	defendant	defendant	NOUN
cjal-3338	339	13	's	's	PART
cjal-3338	339	14	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	339	15	over	over	ADP
cjal-3338	339	16	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	339	17	accused	accuse	VERB
cjal-3338	339	18	acts	act	NOUN
cjal-3338	339	19	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	339	20	this	this	DET
cjal-3338	339	21	equivalence	equivalence	NOUN
cjal-3338	339	22	analysis	analysis	NOUN
cjal-3338	339	23	will	will	AUX
cjal-3338	339	24	by	by	ADP
cjal-3338	339	25	its	its	PRON
cjal-3338	339	26	nature	nature	NOUN
cjal-3338	339	27	compare	compare	VERB
cjal-3338	339	28	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	339	29	defendant	defendant	NOUN
cjal-3338	339	30	's	's	PART
cjal-3338	339	31	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	339	32	to	to	ADP
cjal-3338	339	33	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	339	34	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	339	35	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	339	36	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	340	1	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	340	2	relation	relation	NOUN
cjal-3338	340	3	to	to	ADP
cjal-3338	340	4	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	340	5	'	'	PUNCT
cjal-3338	340	6	practicing	practice	VERB
cjal-3338	340	7	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	340	8	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	340	9	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	340	10	'	'	PUNCT
cjal-3338	340	11	defence	defence	NOUN
cjal-3338	340	12	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	340	13	which	which	PRON
cjal-3338	340	14	requires	require	VERB
cjal-3338	340	15	no	no	DET
cjal-3338	340	16	analysis	analysis	NOUN
cjal-3338	340	17	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	340	18	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	340	19	asserted	asserted	ADJ
cjal-3338	340	20	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	340	21	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	340	22	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	340	23	equivalence	equivalence	NOUN
cjal-3338	340	24	analysis	analysis	NOUN
cjal-3338	340	25	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	340	26	siemens	siemens	PROPN
cjal-3338	340	27	medical	medical	ADJ
cjal-3338	340	28	solutions	solution	NOUN
cjal-3338	340	29	comes	come	VERB
cjal-3338	340	30	far	far	ADV
cjal-3338	340	31	closer	close	ADV
cjal-3338	340	32	to	to	ADP
cjal-3338	340	33	being	be	AUX
cjal-3338	340	34	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	340	35	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	340	36	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	340	37	challenge	challenge	NOUN
cjal-3338	340	38	over	over	ADP
cjal-3338	340	39	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	340	40	validity	validity	NOUN
cjal-3338	340	41	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	340	42	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	340	43	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	340	44	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	341	1	moreover	moreover	ADV
cjal-3338	341	2	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	341	3	if	if	SCONJ
cjal-3338	341	4	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	341	5	federal	federal	ADJ
cjal-3338	341	6	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cjal-3338	341	7	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	341	8	truly	truly	ADV
cjal-3338	341	9	concerned	concerned	ADJ
cjal-3338	341	10	with	with	ADP
cjal-3338	341	11	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	341	12	flouting	flouting	NOUN
cjal-3338	341	13	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	341	14	evidentiary	evidentiary	ADJ
cjal-3338	341	15	standards	standard	NOUN
cjal-3338	341	16	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	341	17	it	it	PRON
cjal-3338	341	18	very	very	ADV
cjal-3338	341	19	well	well	ADV
cjal-3338	341	20	can	can	AUX
cjal-3338	341	21	impose	impose	VERB
cjal-3338	341	22	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	341	23	requirement	requirement	NOUN
cjal-3338	341	24	that	that	SCONJ
cjal-3338	341	25	practicing	practice	VERB
cjal-3338	341	26	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	341	27	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	341	28	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	341	29	be	be	AUX
cjal-3338	341	30	proved	prove	VERB
cjal-3338	341	31	by	by	ADP
cjal-3338	341	32	clear	clear	ADJ
cjal-3338	341	33	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	341	34	convincing	convincing	ADJ
cjal-3338	341	35	evidence	evidence	NOUN
cjal-3338	341	36	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	342	1	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	342	2	therasense	therasense	PROPN
cjal-3338	342	3	inc	inc	PROPN
cjal-3338	342	4	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	343	1	v.	v.	PROPN
cjal-3338	343	2	becton	becton	PROPN
cjal-3338	343	3	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	343	4	dickinson	dickinson	PROPN
cjal-3338	343	5	&	&	CCONJ
cjal-3338	343	6	co.	co.	PROPN
cjal-3338	343	7	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	343	8	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	343	9	court	court	NOUN
cjal-3338	343	10	has	have	AUX
cjal-3338	343	11	demonstrated	demonstrate	VERB
cjal-3338	343	12	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	343	13	willingness	willingness	NOUN
cjal-3338	343	14	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	343	15	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	343	16	tighten	tighten	VERB
cjal-3338	343	17	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	343	18	standards	standard	NOUN
cjal-3338	343	19	for	for	ADP
cjal-3338	343	20	finding	find	VERB
cjal-3338	343	21	both	both	CCONJ
cjal-3338	343	22	intent	intent	NOUN
cjal-3338	343	23	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	343	24	materiality	materiality	NOUN
cjal-3338	343	25	[	[	X
cjal-3338	343	26	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	343	27	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	343	28	inequitable	inequitable	ADJ
cjal-3338	343	29	conduct	conduct	NOUN
cjal-3338	343	30	invalidity	invalidity	NOUN
cjal-3338	343	31	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	343	32	]	]	PUNCT
cjal-3338	343	33	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	343	34	order	order	NOUN
cjal-3338	343	35	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	343	36	redirect	redirect	VERB
cjal-3338	343	37	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	343	38	doctrine	doctrine	NOUN
cjal-3338	343	39	that	that	PRON
cjal-3338	343	40	has	have	AUX
cjal-3338	343	41	been	be	AUX
cjal-3338	343	42	overused	overuse	VERB
cjal-3338	343	43	to	to	ADP
cjal-3338	343	44	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	343	45	detriment	detriment	NOUN
cjal-3338	343	46	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	343	47	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	343	48	public	public	NOUN
cjal-3338	343	49	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	343	50	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	344	1	'	'	PUNCT
cjal-3338	344	2	rather	rather	ADV
cjal-3338	344	3	than	than	ADP
cjal-3338	344	4	foreclosing	foreclose	VERB
cjal-3338	344	5	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	344	6	practicing	practice	VERB
cjal-3338	344	7	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	344	8	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	344	9	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	344	10	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	344	11	altogether	altogether	ADV
cjal-3338	344	12	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	344	13	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	344	14	court	court	NOUN
cjal-3338	344	15	could	could	AUX
cjal-3338	344	16	use	use	VERB
cjal-3338	344	17	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	344	18	same	same	ADJ
cjal-3338	344	19	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	344	20	7	7	NUM
cjal-3338	344	21	see	see	NOUN
cjal-3338	344	22	lau	lau	PROPN
cjal-3338	344	23	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	344	24	supra	supra	PROPN
cjal-3338	344	25	note	note	NOUN
cjal-3338	344	26	2	2	NUM
cjal-3338	344	27	.	.	SYM
cjal-3338	344	28	48	48	NUM
cjal-3338	344	29	tate	tate	NOUN
cjal-3338	344	30	access	access	NOUN
cjal-3338	344	31	floors	floor	NOUN
cjal-3338	344	32	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	344	33	279	279	NUM
cjal-3338	344	34	f.3	f.3	NOUN
cjal-3338	344	35	d	d	NOUN
cjal-3338	344	36	at	at	ADP
cjal-3338	344	37	1367	1367	NUM
cjal-3338	344	38	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	344	39	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	345	1	siemens	siemens	PROPN
cjal-3338	345	2	med	med	PROPN
cjal-3338	345	3	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	346	1	solutions	solutions	PROPN
cjal-3338	346	2	usa	usa	PROPN
cjal-3338	346	3	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	346	4	inc	inc	PROPN
cjal-3338	346	5	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	347	1	v.	v.	ADP
cjal-3338	347	2	saint	saint	PROPN
cjal-3338	347	3	-	-	PUNCT
cjal-3338	347	4	gobain	gobain	PROPN
cjal-3338	347	5	ceramics	ceramic	NOUN
cjal-3338	347	6	&	&	CCONJ
cjal-3338	347	7	plastics	plastics	PROPN
cjal-3338	347	8	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	347	9	inc	inc	PROPN
cjal-3338	347	10	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	347	11	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	347	12	647	647	NUM
cjal-3338	347	13	f.3d	f.3d	NUM
cjal-3338	347	14	1373	1373	NUM
cjal-3338	347	15	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	347	16	1375	1375	NUM
cjal-3338	347	17	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	347	18	fed	fed	PROPN
cjal-3338	347	19	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	347	20	cir	cir	PROPN
cjal-3338	347	21	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	347	22	2o11	2o11	PROPN
cjal-3338	347	23	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	347	24	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	347	25	per	per	ADP
cjal-3338	347	26	curiam	curiam	NOUN
cjal-3338	347	27	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	347	28	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	347	29	cert	cert	PROPN
cjal-3338	347	30	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	348	1	denied	deny	VERB
cjal-3338	348	2	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	348	3	132	132	NUM
cjal-3338	348	4	s.	s.	PROPN
cjal-3338	348	5	ct	ct	PROPN
cjal-3338	348	6	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	348	7	2679	2679	NUM
cjal-3338	348	8	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	348	9	2012	2012	NUM
cjal-3338	348	10	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	348	11	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	349	1	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	349	2	lourie	lourie	NOUN
cjal-3338	349	3	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	349	4	i.	i.	NOUN
cjal-3338	349	5	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	349	6	concurring	concur	VERB
cjal-3338	349	7	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	349	8	denial	denial	NOUN
cjal-3338	349	9	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	349	10	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	349	11	petition	petition	NOUN
cjal-3338	349	12	for	for	ADP
cjal-3338	349	13	rehearing	rehear	VERB
cjal-3338	349	14	en	en	ADP
cjal-3338	349	15	banc	banc	NOUN
cjal-3338	349	16	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	349	17	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	350	1	s	s	X
cjal-3338	350	2	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	350	3	warner	warner	PROPN
cjal-3338	350	4	-	-	PUNCT
cjal-3338	350	5	jenkinson	jenkinson	PROPN
cjal-3338	350	6	co.	co.	PROPN
cjal-3338	350	7	v.	v.	ADP
cjal-3338	350	8	hilton	hilton	PROPN
cjal-3338	350	9	davis	davis	PROPN
cjal-3338	350	10	chem	chem	PROPN
cjal-3338	350	11	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	351	1	co.	co.	PROPN
cjal-3338	351	2	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	351	3	520	520	NUM
cjal-3338	351	4	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cjal-3338	351	5	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	351	6	17	17	NUM
cjal-3338	351	7	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	351	8	40	40	NUM
cjal-3338	351	9	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	351	10	1997	1997	NUM
cjal-3338	351	11	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	351	12	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	351	13	emphasis	emphasis	NOUN
cjal-3338	351	14	added	add	VERB
cjal-3338	351	15	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	351	16	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	352	1	s	s	X
cjal-3338	352	2	'	'	PUNCT
cjal-3338	352	3	therasense	therasense	PROPN
cjal-3338	352	4	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	352	5	inc	inc	PROPN
cjal-3338	352	6	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	353	1	v.	v.	PROPN
cjal-3338	353	2	becton	becton	PROPN
cjal-3338	353	3	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	353	4	dickinson	dickinson	PROPN
cjal-3338	353	5	&	&	CCONJ
cjal-3338	353	6	co.	co.	PROPN
cjal-3338	353	7	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	353	8	649	649	NUM
cjal-3338	353	9	f.3	f.3	NOUN
cjal-3338	353	10	d	d	X
cjal-3338	353	11	1276	1276	NUM
cjal-3338	353	12	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	353	13	129o	129o	PROPN
cjal-3338	353	14	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	353	15	fed	fed	PROPN
cjal-3338	353	16	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	353	17	cir	cir	PROPN
cjal-3338	353	18	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	353	19	2011	2011	NUM
cjal-3338	353	20	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	354	1	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	354	2	en	en	X
cjal-3338	354	3	banc	banc	PROPN
cjal-3338	354	4	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	354	5	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	355	1	columbia	columbia	PROPN
cjal-3338	355	2	journal	journal	PROPN
cjal-3338	355	3	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	355	4	asian	asian	ADJ
cjal-3338	355	5	law	law	NOUN
cjal-3338	355	6	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	355	7	vol	vol	NOUN
cjal-3338	355	8	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	355	9	27	27	NUM
cjal-3338	355	10	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	355	11	no	no	INTJ
cjal-3338	355	12	.	.	NOUN
cjal-3338	355	13	1	1	NUM
cjal-3338	355	14	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	355	15	2o13	2o13	NUM
cjal-3338	355	16	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	355	17	solution	solution	NOUN
cjal-3338	355	18	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	355	19	ratcheting	ratchet	VERB
cjal-3338	355	20	up	up	ADP
cjal-3338	355	21	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	355	22	evidentiary	evidentiary	ADJ
cjal-3338	355	23	standard	standard	NOUN
cjal-3338	355	24	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	355	25	correct	correct	VERB
cjal-3338	355	26	for	for	ADP
cjal-3338	355	27	possible	possible	ADJ
cjal-3338	355	28	abuses	abuse	NOUN
cjal-3338	355	29	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	356	1	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	356	2	federal	federal	ADJ
cjal-3338	356	3	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cjal-3338	356	4	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	356	5	reaching	reach	VERB
cjal-3338	356	6	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	356	7	outcome	outcome	NOUN
cjal-3338	356	8	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	356	9	tate	tate	NOUN
cjal-3338	356	10	access	access	NOUN
cjal-3338	356	11	floors	floor	NOUN
cjal-3338	356	12	must	must	AUX
cjal-3338	356	13	have	have	AUX
cjal-3338	356	14	been	be	AUX
cjal-3338	356	15	aware	aware	ADJ
cjal-3338	356	16	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	356	17	this	this	DET
cjal-3338	356	18	possibility	possibility	NOUN
cjal-3338	356	19	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	357	1	2	2	X
cjal-3338	357	2	.	.	X
cjal-3338	357	3	other	other	ADJ
cjal-3338	357	4	justifications	justification	NOUN
cjal-3338	357	5	against	against	ADP
cjal-3338	357	6	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	357	7	practicing	practice	VERB
cjal-3338	357	8	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	357	9	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	357	10	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	357	11	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	357	12	therefore	therefore	ADV
cjal-3338	357	13	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	357	14	we	we	PRON
cjal-3338	357	15	would	would	AUX
cjal-3338	357	16	have	have	VERB
cjal-3338	357	17	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	357	18	search	search	VERB
cjal-3338	357	19	elsewhere	elsewhere	ADV
cjal-3338	357	20	for	for	ADP
cjal-3338	357	21	an	an	DET
cjal-3338	357	22	explanation	explanation	NOUN
cjal-3338	357	23	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	357	24	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	357	25	federal	federal	ADJ
cjal-3338	357	26	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cjal-3338	357	27	's	's	PART
cjal-3338	357	28	foreclosure	foreclosure	NOUN
cjal-3338	357	29	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	357	30	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	357	31	practicing	practice	VERB
cjal-3338	357	32	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	357	33	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	357	34	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	357	35	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	357	36	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	358	1	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	358	2	what	what	PRON
cjal-3338	358	3	may	may	AUX
cjal-3338	358	4	be	be	AUX
cjal-3338	358	5	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	358	6	true	true	ADJ
cjal-3338	358	7	driving	drive	VERB
cjal-3338	358	8	force	force	NOUN
cjal-3338	358	9	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	358	10	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	358	11	policy	policy	NOUN
cjal-3338	358	12	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	358	13	compel	compel	VERB
cjal-3338	358	14	defendants	defendant	NOUN
cjal-3338	358	15	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	358	16	invalidate	invalidate	VERB
cjal-3338	358	17	patents	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	358	18	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	358	19	rather	rather	ADV
cjal-3338	358	20	than	than	ADP
cjal-3338	358	21	ring	re	VERB
cjal-3338	358	22	fence	fence	NOUN
cjal-3338	358	23	their	their	PRON
cjal-3338	358	24	activities	activity	NOUN
cjal-3338	358	25	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	358	26	with	with	ADP
cjal-3338	358	27	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	358	28	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	358	29	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	358	30	they	they	PRON
cjal-3338	358	31	find	find	VERB
cjal-3338	358	32	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	359	1	there	there	PRON
cjal-3338	359	2	may	may	AUX
cjal-3338	359	3	be	be	AUX
cjal-3338	359	4	good	good	ADJ
cjal-3338	359	5	reason	reason	NOUN
cjal-3338	359	6	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	359	7	do	do	VERB
cjal-3338	359	8	so	so	ADV
cjal-3338	359	9	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	360	1	as	as	SCONJ
cjal-3338	360	2	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	360	3	supreme	supreme	PROPN
cjal-3338	360	4	court	court	PROPN
cjal-3338	360	5	has	have	AUX
cjal-3338	360	6	stated	state	VERB
cjal-3338	360	7	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	360	8	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	360	9	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	360	10	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	360	11	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	360	12	an	an	DET
cjal-3338	360	13	exception	exception	NOUN
cjal-3338	360	14	to	to	ADP
cjal-3338	360	15	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	360	16	general	general	ADJ
cjal-3338	360	17	rule	rule	NOUN
cjal-3338	360	18	against	against	ADP
cjal-3338	360	19	monopolies	monopoly	NOUN
cjal-3338	360	20	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	360	21	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	360	22	to	to	ADP
cjal-3338	360	23	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	360	24	right	right	NOUN
cjal-3338	360	25	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	360	26	access	access	VERB
cjal-3338	360	27	to	to	ADP
cjal-3338	360	28	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	360	29	free	free	ADJ
cjal-3338	360	30	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	360	31	open	open	ADJ
cjal-3338	360	32	market	market	NOUN
cjal-3338	360	33	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	360	34	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	360	35	whose	whose	DET
cjal-3338	360	36	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	360	37	far	far	ADV
cjal-3338	360	38	-	-	PUNCT
cjal-3338	360	39	reaching	reach	VERB
cjal-3338	360	40	social	social	ADJ
cjal-3338	360	41	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	360	42	economic	economic	ADJ
cjal-3338	360	43	consequences	consequence	NOUN
cjal-3338	360	44	...	...	PUNCT
cjal-3338	360	45	give	give	VERB
cjal-3338	360	46	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	360	47	public	public	NOUN
cjal-3338	360	48	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	360	49	paramount	paramount	ADJ
cjal-3338	360	50	interest	interest	NOUN
cjal-3338	360	51	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	360	52	seeing	see	VERB
cjal-3338	360	53	that	that	SCONJ
cjal-3338	360	54	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	360	55	monopolies	monopoly	NOUN
cjal-3338	360	56	..	..	PUNCT
cjal-3338	360	57	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	360	58	are	be	AUX
cjal-3338	360	59	kept	keep	VERB
cjal-3338	360	60	within	within	ADP
cjal-3338	360	61	their	their	PRON
cjal-3338	360	62	legitimate	legitimate	ADJ
cjal-3338	360	63	scope	scope	NOUN
cjal-3338	360	64	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	360	65	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	361	1	5	5	NUM
cjal-3338	361	2	if	if	SCONJ
cjal-3338	361	3	defendants	defendant	NOUN
cjal-3338	361	4	have	have	VERB
cjal-3338	361	5	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	361	6	embark	embark	VERB
cjal-3338	361	7	on	on	ADP
cjal-3338	361	8	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	361	9	search	search	NOUN
cjal-3338	361	10	for	for	ADP
cjal-3338	361	11	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	361	12	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	361	13	as	as	ADP
cjal-3338	361	14	part	part	NOUN
cjal-3338	361	15	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	361	16	their	their	PRON
cjal-3338	361	17	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	361	18	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	361	19	it	it	PRON
cjal-3338	361	20	may	may	AUX
cjal-3338	361	21	be	be	AUX
cjal-3338	361	22	more	more	ADV
cjal-3338	361	23	beneficial	beneficial	ADJ
cjal-3338	361	24	to	to	ADP
cjal-3338	361	25	society	society	NOUN
cjal-3338	361	26	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	361	27	make	make	VERB
cjal-3338	361	28	them	they	PRON
cjal-3338	361	29	hunt	hunt	VERB
cjal-3338	361	30	for	for	ADP
cjal-3338	361	31	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	361	32	best	good	ADJ
cjal-3338	361	33	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	361	34	that	that	PRON
cjal-3338	361	35	invalidates	invalidate	VERB
cjal-3338	361	36	patents	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	361	37	rather	rather	ADV
cjal-3338	361	38	than	than	ADP
cjal-3338	361	39	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	361	40	best	good	ADJ
cjal-3338	361	41	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	361	42	that	that	PRON
cjal-3338	361	43	exonerates	exonerate	VERB
cjal-3338	361	44	their	their	PRON
cjal-3338	361	45	actions	action	NOUN
cjal-3338	361	46	from	from	ADP
cjal-3338	361	47	infringement	infringement	NOUN
cjal-3338	361	48	liability	liability	NOUN
cjal-3338	361	49	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	362	1	this	this	PRON
cjal-3338	362	2	would	would	AUX
cjal-3338	362	3	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	362	4	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	362	5	principle	principle	NOUN
cjal-3338	362	6	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	362	7	free	free	VERB
cjal-3338	362	8	up	up	ADP
cjal-3338	362	9	more	more	ADV
cjal-3338	362	10	technological	technological	ADJ
cjal-3338	362	11	territory	territory	NOUN
cjal-3338	362	12	for	for	ADP
cjal-3338	362	13	public	public	ADJ
cjal-3338	362	14	use	use	NOUN
cjal-3338	362	15	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	363	1	viewed	view	VERB
cjal-3338	363	2	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	363	3	this	this	DET
cjal-3338	363	4	light	light	NOUN
cjal-3338	363	5	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	363	6	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	363	7	above	above	ADV
cjal-3338	363	8	stated	stated	ADJ
cjal-3338	363	9	contradiction	contradiction	NOUN
cjal-3338	363	10	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	363	11	tate	tate	NOUN
cjal-3338	363	12	access	access	NOUN
cjal-3338	363	13	floors	floor	NOUN
cjal-3338	363	14	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	363	15	siemens	siemens	PROPN
cjal-3338	363	16	medical	medical	ADJ
cjal-3338	363	17	solutions	solution	NOUN
cjal-3338	363	18	seems	seem	VERB
cjal-3338	363	19	less	less	ADV
cjal-3338	363	20	jarring	jarring	ADJ
cjal-3338	363	21	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	364	1	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	364	2	tate	tate	PROPN
cjal-3338	364	3	access	access	NOUN
cjal-3338	364	4	floors	floor	NOUN
cjal-3338	364	5	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	364	6	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	364	7	federal	federal	ADJ
cjal-3338	364	8	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cjal-3338	364	9	can	can	AUX
cjal-3338	364	10	be	be	AUX
cjal-3338	364	11	seen	see	VERB
cjal-3338	364	12	as	as	ADP
cjal-3338	364	13	compelling	compel	VERB
cjal-3338	364	14	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	364	15	defendant	defendant	NOUN
cjal-3338	364	16	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	364	17	search	search	VERB
cjal-3338	364	18	for	for	ADP
cjal-3338	364	19	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	364	20	better	well	ADV
cjal-3338	364	21	tasked	task	VERB
cjal-3338	364	22	for	for	ADP
cjal-3338	364	23	invalidation	invalidation	NOUN
cjal-3338	364	24	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	365	1	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	365	2	siemens	siemens	PROPN
cjal-3338	365	3	medical	medical	ADJ
cjal-3338	365	4	solutions	solution	NOUN
cjal-3338	365	5	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	365	6	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	365	7	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
cjal-3338	365	8	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	365	9	seeking	seek	VERB
cjal-3338	365	10	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	365	11	establish	establish	VERB
cjal-3338	365	12	equivalence	equivalence	NOUN
cjal-3338	365	13	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	365	14	unlikely	unlikely	ADJ
cjal-3338	365	15	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	365	16	be	be	AUX
cjal-3338	365	17	conducting	conduct	VERB
cjal-3338	365	18	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	365	19	type	type	NOUN
cjal-3338	365	20	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	365	21	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	365	22	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	365	23	search	search	NOUN
cjal-3338	365	24	that	that	PRON
cjal-3338	365	25	can	can	AUX
cjal-3338	365	26	be	be	AUX
cjal-3338	365	27	directed	direct	VERB
cjal-3338	365	28	towards	towards	ADP
cjal-3338	365	29	invalidation	invalidation	NOUN
cjal-3338	365	30	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	365	31	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	365	32	defendant	defendant	NOUN
cjal-3338	365	33	's	's	PART
cjal-3338	365	34	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	365	35	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	366	1	it	it	PRON
cjal-3338	366	2	does	do	AUX
cjal-3338	366	3	not	not	PART
cjal-3338	366	4	seem	seem	VERB
cjal-3338	366	5	quite	quite	ADV
cjal-3338	366	6	right	right	ADJ
cjal-3338	366	7	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	366	8	force	force	VERB
cjal-3338	366	9	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	366	10	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
cjal-3338	366	11	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	366	12	do	do	VERB
cjal-3338	366	13	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	366	14	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	366	15	-	-	PUNCT
cjal-3338	366	16	invalidating	invalidate	VERB
cjal-3338	366	17	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	366	18	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	366	19	search	search	NOUN
cjal-3338	366	20	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	366	21	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	366	22	course	course	NOUN
cjal-3338	366	23	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	366	24	proving	prove	VERB
cjal-3338	366	25	infringement	infringement	NOUN
cjal-3338	366	26	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	367	1	this	this	DET
cjal-3338	367	2	argument	argument	NOUN
cjal-3338	367	3	however	however	ADV
cjal-3338	367	4	fails	fail	VERB
cjal-3338	367	5	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	367	6	take	take	VERB
cjal-3338	367	7	into	into	ADP
cjal-3338	367	8	account	account	NOUN
cjal-3338	367	9	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	367	10	practicalities	practicality	NOUN
cjal-3338	367	11	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	367	12	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	367	13	trials	trial	NOUN
cjal-3338	367	14	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	368	1	it	it	PRON
cjal-3338	368	2	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	368	3	well	well	ADV
cjal-3338	368	4	known	know	VERB
cjal-3338	368	5	that	that	SCONJ
cjal-3338	368	6	vast	vast	ADJ
cjal-3338	368	7	majority	majority	NOUN
cjal-3338	368	8	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	368	9	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	368	10	disputes	dispute	NOUN
cjal-3338	368	11	are	be	AUX
cjal-3338	368	12	settled	settle	VERB
cjal-3338	368	13	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	369	1	as	as	SCONJ
cjal-3338	369	2	jay	jay	PROPN
cjal-3338	369	3	kesan	kesan	PROPN
cjal-3338	369	4	's	's	PART
cjal-3338	369	5	empirical	empirical	ADJ
cjal-3338	369	6	study	study	NOUN
cjal-3338	369	7	shows	show	NOUN
cjal-3338	369	8	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	369	9	only	only	ADV
cjal-3338	369	10	some	some	DET
cjal-3338	369	11	15	15	NUM
cjal-3338	369	12	%	%	NOUN
cjal-3338	369	13	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	369	14	all	all	DET
cjal-3338	369	15	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cjal-3338	369	16	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	369	17	cases	case	NOUN
cjal-3338	369	18	terminated	terminate	VERB
cjal-3338	369	19	through	through	ADP
cjal-3338	369	20	some	some	DET
cjal-3338	369	21	resolution	resolution	NOUN
cjal-3338	369	22	on	on	ADP
cjal-3338	369	23	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	369	24	merits	merit	NOUN
cjal-3338	369	25	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	369	26	including	include	VERB
cjal-3338	369	27	summary	summary	NOUN
cjal-3338	369	28	dispositions	disposition	NOUN
cjal-3338	369	29	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	369	30	trials.53	trials.53	VERB
cjal-3338	369	31	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	369	32	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	369	33	defendants	defendant	NOUN
cjal-3338	369	34	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	369	35	for	for	ADP
cjal-3338	369	36	various	various	ADJ
cjal-3338	369	37	factors	factor	NOUN
cjal-3338	369	38	such	such	ADJ
cjal-3338	369	39	as	as	ADP
cjal-3338	369	40	high	high	ADJ
cjal-3338	369	41	costs	cost	NOUN
cjal-3338	369	42	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	369	43	generally	generally	ADV
cjal-3338	369	44	do	do	AUX
cjal-3338	369	45	not	not	PART
cjal-3338	369	46	litigate	litigate	VERB
cjal-3338	369	47	to	to	ADP
cjal-3338	369	48	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	369	49	point	point	NOUN
cjal-3338	369	50	where	where	SCONJ
cjal-3338	369	51	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	369	52	validity	validity	NOUN
cjal-3338	369	53	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	369	54	adjudicated	adjudicate	VERB
cjal-3338	369	55	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	370	1	indeed	indeed	ADV
cjal-3338	370	2	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	370	3	kesan	kesan	PROPN
cjal-3338	370	4	's	's	PART
cjal-3338	370	5	study	study	NOUN
cjal-3338	370	6	shows	show	VERB
cjal-3338	370	7	that	that	SCONJ
cjal-3338	370	8	cases	case	NOUN
cjal-3338	370	9	where	where	SCONJ
cjal-3338	370	10	claims	claim	NOUN
cjal-3338	370	11	were	be	AUX
cjal-3338	370	12	invalidated	invalidated	ADJ
cjal-3338	370	13	constitute	constitute	VERB
cjal-3338	370	14	only	only	ADV
cjal-3338	370	15	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	370	16	small	small	ADJ
cjal-3338	370	17	subset	subset	NOUN
cjal-3338	370	18	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	370	19	roughly	roughly	ADV
cjal-3338	370	20	2.3	2.3	NUM
cjal-3338	370	21	%	%	NOUN
cjal-3338	370	22	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	370	23	all	all	DET
cjal-3338	370	24	cases	case	NOUN
cjal-3338	370	25	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	370	26	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	371	1	consequently	consequently	ADV
cjal-3338	371	2	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	371	3	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	371	4	technological	technological	ADJ
cjal-3338	371	5	territory	territory	NOUN
cjal-3338	371	6	for	for	ADP
cjal-3338	371	7	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	371	8	public	public	NOUN
cjal-3338	371	9	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	371	10	practice	practice	VERB
cjal-3338	371	11	that	that	SCONJ
cjal-3338	371	12	defendants	defendant	NOUN
cjal-3338	371	13	have	have	AUX
cjal-3338	371	14	freed	free	VERB
cjal-3338	371	15	up	up	ADP
cjal-3338	371	16	through	through	ADP
cjal-3338	371	17	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	371	18	invalidation	invalidation	NOUN
cjal-3338	371	19	does	do	AUX
cjal-3338	371	20	not	not	PART
cjal-3338	371	21	actually	actually	ADV
cjal-3338	371	22	amount	amount	VERB
cjal-3338	371	23	to	to	ADP
cjal-3338	371	24	much	much	ADJ
cjal-3338	371	25	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	372	1	having	have	VERB
cjal-3338	372	2	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	372	3	practicing	practice	VERB
cjal-3338	372	4	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	372	5	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	372	6	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	372	7	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	372	8	may	may	AUX
cjal-3338	372	9	actually	actually	ADV
cjal-3338	372	10	increase	increase	VERB
cjal-3338	372	11	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	372	12	number	number	NOUN
cjal-3338	372	13	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	372	14	cases	case	NOUN
cjal-3338	372	15	adjudicated	adjudicate	VERB
cjal-3338	372	16	to	to	ADP
cjal-3338	372	17	final	final	ADJ
cjal-3338	372	18	merits	merit	NOUN
cjal-3338	372	19	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	373	1	after	after	ADV
cjal-3338	373	2	all	all	ADV
cjal-3338	373	3	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	373	4	if	if	SCONJ
cjal-3338	373	5	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	373	6	defendant	defendant	NOUN
cjal-3338	373	7	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	373	8	truly	truly	ADV
cjal-3338	373	9	5	5	NUM
cjal-3338	373	10	'	'	PART
cjal-3338	373	11	precision	precision	NOUN
cjal-3338	373	12	instrument	instrument	NOUN
cjal-3338	373	13	mfg	mfg	PROPN
cjal-3338	373	14	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	373	15	co.	co.	PROPN
cjal-3338	374	1	v.	v.	ADP
cjal-3338	374	2	auto	auto	PROPN
cjal-3338	374	3	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	375	1	maint	maint	PROPN
cjal-3338	375	2	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	376	1	mach	mach	PROPN
cjal-3338	376	2	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	377	1	co.	co.	PROPN
cjal-3338	377	2	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	377	3	324	324	NUM
cjal-3338	377	4	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cjal-3338	377	5	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	377	6	8o6	8o6	NUM
cjal-3338	377	7	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	377	8	816	816	NUM
cjal-3338	377	9	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	377	10	1945	1945	NUM
cjal-3338	377	11	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	377	12	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	378	1	53	53	NUM
cjal-3338	378	2	jay	jay	PROPN
cjal-3338	378	3	p.	p.	PROPN
cjal-3338	378	4	kesan	kesan	PROPN
cjal-3338	378	5	&	&	CCONJ
cjal-3338	378	6	gwendolyn	gwendolyn	PROPN
cjal-3338	378	7	g.	g.	PROPN
cjal-3338	378	8	ball	ball	PROPN
cjal-3338	378	9	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	378	10	how	how	SCONJ
cjal-3338	378	11	are	be	AUX
cjal-3338	378	12	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	378	13	cases	case	NOUN
cjal-3338	378	14	resolved	resolve	VERB
cjal-3338	378	15	?	?	PUNCT
cjal-3338	379	1	an	an	DET
cjal-3338	379	2	empirical	empirical	ADJ
cjal-3338	379	3	examination	examination	NOUN
cjal-3338	379	4	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	379	5	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	379	6	adjudication	adjudication	NOUN
cjal-3338	379	7	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	379	8	settlement	settlement	NOUN
cjal-3338	379	9	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	379	10	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	379	11	disputes	dispute	NOUN
cjal-3338	379	12	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	379	13	84	84	NUM
cjal-3338	379	14	wash	wash	NOUN
cjal-3338	379	15	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	380	1	u.	u.	PROPN
cjal-3338	380	2	l.	l.	PROPN
cjal-3338	380	3	rev	rev	PROPN
cjal-3338	380	4	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	380	5	237	237	NUM
cjal-3338	380	6	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	380	7	271	271	NUM
cjal-3338	380	8	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	380	9	2oo6	2oo6	NUM
cjal-3338	380	10	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	380	11	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	381	1	14	14	NUM
cjal-3338	382	1	i	i	PRON
cjal-3338	382	2	d.	d.	PROPN
cjal-3338	382	3	at	at	ADP
cjal-3338	382	4	276	276	NUM
cjal-3338	382	5	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	383	1	defensive	defensive	ADJ
cjal-3338	383	2	use	use	NOUN
cjal-3338	383	3	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	383	4	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	383	5	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	383	6	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	383	7	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cjal-3338	383	8	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	383	9	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	383	10	chinese	chinese	ADJ
cjal-3338	383	11	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	383	12	litigation	litigation	NOUN
cjal-3338	383	13	71	71	NUM
cjal-3338	383	14	practicing	practice	VERB
cjal-3338	383	15	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	383	16	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	383	17	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	384	1	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	384	2	he	he	PRON
cjal-3338	384	3	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	384	4	very	very	ADV
cjal-3338	384	5	likely	likely	ADJ
cjal-3338	384	6	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	384	7	know	know	VERB
cjal-3338	384	8	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	384	9	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	384	10	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	384	11	pieces	piece	NOUN
cjal-3338	384	12	he	he	PRON
cjal-3338	384	13	has	have	AUX
cjal-3338	384	14	practiced	practice	VERB
cjal-3338	384	15	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	385	1	therefore	therefore	ADV
cjal-3338	385	2	proving	prove	VERB
cjal-3338	385	3	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	385	4	practice	practice	NOUN
cjal-3338	385	5	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	385	6	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	385	7	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	385	8	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	385	9	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	385	10	requires	require	VERB
cjal-3338	385	11	easy	easy	ADJ
cjal-3338	385	12	discovery	discovery	NOUN
cjal-3338	385	13	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	386	1	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	386	2	defendant	defendant	NOUN
cjal-3338	386	3	can	can	AUX
cjal-3338	386	4	supply	supply	VERB
cjal-3338	386	5	all	all	DET
cjal-3338	386	6	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	386	7	information	information	NOUN
cjal-3338	386	8	by	by	ADP
cjal-3338	386	9	himself	himself	PRON
cjal-3338	386	10	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	386	11	which	which	PRON
cjal-3338	386	12	he	he	PRON
cjal-3338	386	13	can	can	AUX
cjal-3338	386	14	readily	readily	ADV
cjal-3338	386	15	find	find	VERB
cjal-3338	386	16	by	by	ADP
cjal-3338	386	17	looking	look	VERB
cjal-3338	386	18	up	up	ADP
cjal-3338	386	19	his	his	PRON
cjal-3338	386	20	old	old	ADJ
cjal-3338	386	21	lab	lab	NOUN
cjal-3338	386	22	notebooks	notebook	NOUN
cjal-3338	386	23	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	387	1	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	387	2	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	387	3	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	387	4	also	also	ADV
cjal-3338	387	5	conducive	conducive	ADJ
cjal-3338	387	6	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	387	7	summary	summary	NOUN
cjal-3338	387	8	resolution	resolution	NOUN
cjal-3338	387	9	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	387	10	since	since	SCONJ
cjal-3338	387	11	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	387	12	tribunal	tribunal	NOUN
cjal-3338	387	13	need	need	AUX
cjal-3338	387	14	only	only	ADV
cjal-3338	387	15	decide	decide	VERB
cjal-3338	387	16	whether	whether	SCONJ
cjal-3338	387	17	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	387	18	documentation	documentation	NOUN
cjal-3338	387	19	supplied	supply	VERB
cjal-3338	387	20	by	by	ADP
cjal-3338	387	21	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	387	22	defendant	defendant	NOUN
cjal-3338	387	23	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	387	24	if	if	SCONJ
cjal-3338	387	25	they	they	PRON
cjal-3338	387	26	qualify	qualify	VERB
cjal-3338	387	27	as	as	ADP
cjal-3338	387	28	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	387	29	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	387	30	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	387	31	allows	allow	VERB
cjal-3338	387	32	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	387	33	defendant	defendant	NOUN
cjal-3338	387	34	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	387	35	practice	practice	VERB
cjal-3338	387	36	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	387	37	accused	accuse	VERB
cjal-3338	387	38	acts	act	NOUN
cjal-3338	387	39	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	388	1	moreover	moreover	ADV
cjal-3338	388	2	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	388	3	unlike	unlike	ADP
cjal-3338	388	4	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	388	5	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	388	6	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	388	7	invalidity	invalidity	NOUN
cjal-3338	388	8	judgment	judgment	NOUN
cjal-3338	388	9	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	388	10	which	which	PRON
cjal-3338	388	11	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	388	12	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	388	13	once	once	ADV
cjal-3338	388	14	secured	secure	VERB
cjal-3338	388	15	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	388	16	benefits	benefit	NOUN
cjal-3338	388	17	everyone,"55	everyone,"55	ADV
cjal-3338	388	18	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	388	19	successful	successful	ADJ
cjal-3338	388	20	practicing	practice	VERB
cjal-3338	388	21	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	388	22	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	388	23	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	388	24	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	388	25	immunizes	immunize	VERB
cjal-3338	388	26	only	only	ADV
cjal-3338	388	27	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	388	28	defendant	defendant	NOUN
cjal-3338	388	29	's	's	PART
cjal-3338	388	30	accused	accuse	VERB
cjal-3338	388	31	acts	act	NOUN
cjal-3338	388	32	itself	itself	PRON
cjal-3338	388	33	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	389	1	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	389	2	defendant	defendant	NOUN
cjal-3338	389	3	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	389	4	far	far	ADV
cjal-3338	389	5	less	less	ADV
cjal-3338	389	6	worried	worried	ADJ
cjal-3338	389	7	with	with	ADP
cjal-3338	389	8	helping	help	VERB
cjal-3338	389	9	his	his	PRON
cjal-3338	389	10	competitors	competitor	NOUN
cjal-3338	389	11	by	by	ADP
cjal-3338	389	12	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	389	13	successful	successful	ADJ
cjal-3338	389	14	invalidity	invalidity	NOUN
cjal-3338	389	15	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	389	16	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	390	1	because	because	SCONJ
cjal-3338	390	2	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	390	3	defendant	defendant	NOUN
cjal-3338	390	4	can	can	AUX
cjal-3338	390	5	recycle	recycle	VERB
cjal-3338	390	6	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	390	7	same	same	ADJ
cjal-3338	390	8	argument	argument	NOUN
cjal-3338	390	9	whenever	whenever	SCONJ
cjal-3338	390	10	accused	accuse	VERB
cjal-3338	390	11	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	390	12	infringement	infringement	NOUN
cjal-3338	390	13	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	390	14	this	this	DET
cjal-3338	390	15	immunity	immunity	NOUN
cjal-3338	390	16	he	he	PRON
cjal-3338	390	17	obtains	obtain	VERB
cjal-3338	390	18	exists	exist	NOUN
cjal-3338	390	19	against	against	ADP
cjal-3338	390	20	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	390	21	world.56	world.56	NOUN
cjal-3338	390	22	with	with	ADP
cjal-3338	390	23	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	390	24	availability	availability	NOUN
cjal-3338	390	25	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	390	26	this	this	DET
cjal-3338	390	27	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	390	28	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	390	29	defendants	defendant	NOUN
cjal-3338	390	30	are	be	AUX
cjal-3338	390	31	far	far	ADV
cjal-3338	390	32	likelier	likeli	ADJ
cjal-3338	390	33	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	390	34	litigate	litigate	VERB
cjal-3338	390	35	to	to	ADP
cjal-3338	390	36	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	390	37	merits	merit	NOUN
cjal-3338	390	38	than	than	SCONJ
cjal-3338	390	39	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	390	40	settle	settle	VERB
cjal-3338	390	41	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	391	1	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	391	2	practicing	practice	VERB
cjal-3338	391	3	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	391	4	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	391	5	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	391	6	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	391	7	can	can	AUX
cjal-3338	391	8	therefore	therefore	ADV
cjal-3338	391	9	have	have	VERB
cjal-3338	391	10	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	391	11	positive	positive	ADJ
cjal-3338	391	12	consequence	consequence	NOUN
cjal-3338	391	13	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	391	14	terms	term	NOUN
cjal-3338	391	15	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	391	16	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	391	17	territory	territory	NOUN
cjal-3338	391	18	defendants	defendant	NOUN
cjal-3338	391	19	can	can	AUX
cjal-3338	391	20	open	open	VERB
cjal-3338	391	21	to	to	ADP
cjal-3338	391	22	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	391	23	public	public	NOUN
cjal-3338	391	24	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	392	1	by	by	ADP
cjal-3338	392	2	demonstrating	demonstrate	VERB
cjal-3338	392	3	at	at	ADP
cjal-3338	392	4	court	court	NOUN
cjal-3338	392	5	that	that	SCONJ
cjal-3338	392	6	their	their	PRON
cjal-3338	392	7	acts	act	NOUN
cjal-3338	392	8	are	be	AUX
cjal-3338	392	9	practicing	practice	VERB
cjal-3338	392	10	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	392	11	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	392	12	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	392	13	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	392	14	defendants	defendant	NOUN
cjal-3338	392	15	have	have	AUX
cjal-3338	392	16	opened	open	VERB
cjal-3338	392	17	up	up	ADP
cjal-3338	392	18	their	their	PRON
cjal-3338	392	19	own	own	ADJ
cjal-3338	392	20	accused	accuse	VERB
cjal-3338	392	21	acts	act	NOUN
cjal-3338	392	22	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	392	23	be	be	AUX
cjal-3338	392	24	practiced	practice	VERB
cjal-3338	392	25	by	by	ADP
cjal-3338	392	26	all	all	DET
cjal-3338	392	27	others	other	NOUN
cjal-3338	392	28	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	392	29	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	392	30	public	public	NOUN
cjal-3338	392	31	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	393	1	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	393	2	be	be	AUX
cjal-3338	393	3	sure	sure	ADJ
cjal-3338	393	4	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	393	5	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	393	6	territory	territory	NOUN
cjal-3338	393	7	opened	open	VERB
cjal-3338	393	8	up	up	ADP
cjal-3338	393	9	by	by	ADP
cjal-3338	393	10	each	each	DET
cjal-3338	393	11	successful	successful	ADJ
cjal-3338	393	12	practicing	practice	VERB
cjal-3338	393	13	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	393	14	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	393	15	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	393	16	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	393	17	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	393	18	narrower	narrow	ADJ
cjal-3338	393	19	than	than	ADP
cjal-3338	393	20	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	393	21	territory	territory	NOUN
cjal-3338	393	22	opened	open	VERB
cjal-3338	393	23	by	by	ADP
cjal-3338	393	24	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	393	25	successful	successful	ADJ
cjal-3338	393	26	invalidity	invalidity	NOUN
cjal-3338	393	27	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	393	28	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	394	1	but	but	CCONJ
cjal-3338	394	2	if	if	SCONJ
cjal-3338	394	3	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	394	4	availability	availability	NOUN
cjal-3338	394	5	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	394	6	this	this	DET
cjal-3338	394	7	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	394	8	encourages	encourage	VERB
cjal-3338	394	9	more	more	ADJ
cjal-3338	394	10	defendants	defendant	NOUN
cjal-3338	394	11	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	394	12	litigate	litigate	VERB
cjal-3338	394	13	rather	rather	ADV
cjal-3338	394	14	than	than	ADP
cjal-3338	394	15	settle	settle	VERB
cjal-3338	394	16	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	394	17	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	394	18	amount	amount	NOUN
cjal-3338	394	19	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	394	20	technological	technological	ADJ
cjal-3338	394	21	territory	territory	NOUN
cjal-3338	394	22	freed	free	VERB
cjal-3338	394	23	up	up	ADP
cjal-3338	394	24	for	for	ADP
cjal-3338	394	25	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	394	26	public	public	NOUN
cjal-3338	394	27	through	through	ADP
cjal-3338	394	28	practicing	practice	VERB
cjal-3338	394	29	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	394	30	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	394	31	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	394	32	defenses	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	394	33	may	may	AUX
cjal-3338	394	34	collectively	collectively	ADV
cjal-3338	394	35	end	end	VERB
cjal-3338	394	36	up	up	ADP
cjal-3338	394	37	being	be	AUX
cjal-3338	394	38	larger	large	ADJ
cjal-3338	394	39	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	395	1	another	another	DET
cjal-3338	395	2	argument	argument	NOUN
cjal-3338	395	3	against	against	ADP
cjal-3338	395	4	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	395	5	practicing	practice	VERB
cjal-3338	395	6	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	395	7	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	395	8	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	395	9	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	395	10	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	395	11	that	that	SCONJ
cjal-3338	395	12	it	it	PRON
cjal-3338	395	13	may	may	AUX
cjal-3338	395	14	stunt	stunt	VERB
cjal-3338	395	15	technical	technical	ADJ
cjal-3338	395	16	innovation	innovation	NOUN
cjal-3338	395	17	by	by	ADP
cjal-3338	395	18	encouraging	encourage	VERB
cjal-3338	395	19	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	395	20	reuse	reuse	NOUN
cjal-3338	395	21	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	395	22	old	old	ADJ
cjal-3338	395	23	solutions	solution	NOUN
cjal-3338	395	24	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	396	1	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	396	2	principle	principle	NOUN
cjal-3338	396	3	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	396	4	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	396	5	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	396	6	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	396	7	invalidity	invalidity	NOUN
cjal-3338	396	8	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	396	9	can	can	AUX
cjal-3338	396	10	ensure	ensure	VERB
cjal-3338	396	11	that	that	SCONJ
cjal-3338	396	12	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	396	13	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	396	14	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	396	15	be	be	AUX
cjal-3338	396	16	freely	freely	ADV
cjal-3338	396	17	practiced	practice	VERB
cjal-3338	396	18	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	397	1	but	but	CCONJ
cjal-3338	397	2	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	397	3	engineer	engineer	NOUN
cjal-3338	397	4	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	397	5	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	397	6	laboratory	laboratory	NOUN
cjal-3338	397	7	or	or	CCONJ
cjal-3338	397	8	shop	shop	NOUN
cjal-3338	397	9	designing	design	VERB
cjal-3338	397	10	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	397	11	new	new	ADJ
cjal-3338	397	12	product	product	NOUN
cjal-3338	397	13	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	397	14	unlikely	unlikely	ADJ
cjal-3338	397	15	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	397	16	know	know	VERB
cjal-3338	397	17	whether	whether	SCONJ
cjal-3338	397	18	some	some	DET
cjal-3338	397	19	existing	exist	VERB
cjal-3338	397	20	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	397	21	claim	claim	NOUN
cjal-3338	397	22	reads	read	VERB
cjal-3338	397	23	on	on	ADP
cjal-3338	397	24	what	what	PRON
cjal-3338	397	25	he	he	PRON
cjal-3338	397	26	aims	aim	VERB
cjal-3338	397	27	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	397	28	practice	practice	VERB
cjal-3338	397	29	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	397	30	whether	whether	SCONJ
cjal-3338	397	31	he	he	PRON
cjal-3338	397	32	can	can	AUX
cjal-3338	397	33	invalidate	invalidate	VERB
cjal-3338	397	34	such	such	DET
cjal-3338	397	35	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	397	36	claim	claim	NOUN
cjal-3338	397	37	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	398	1	he	he	PRON
cjal-3338	398	2	does	do	AUX
cjal-3338	398	3	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	398	4	however	however	ADV
cjal-3338	398	5	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	398	6	know	know	VERB
cjal-3338	398	7	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	398	8	sources	source	NOUN
cjal-3338	398	9	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	398	10	information	information	NOUN
cjal-3338	398	11	that	that	PRON
cjal-3338	398	12	inform	inform	VERB
cjal-3338	398	13	his	his	PRON
cjal-3338	398	14	design	design	NOUN
cjal-3338	398	15	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	399	1	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	399	2	availability	availability	NOUN
cjal-3338	399	3	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	399	4	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	399	5	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	399	6	increases	increase	VERB
cjal-3338	399	7	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	399	8	certainty	certainty	NOUN
cjal-3338	399	9	to	to	ADP
cjal-3338	399	10	such	such	DET
cjal-3338	399	11	an	an	DET
cjal-3338	399	12	engineer	engineer	NOUN
cjal-3338	399	13	that	that	PRON
cjal-3338	399	14	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	399	15	if	if	SCONJ
cjal-3338	399	16	his	his	PRON
cjal-3338	399	17	sources	source	NOUN
cjal-3338	399	18	were	be	AUX
cjal-3338	399	19	old	old	ADJ
cjal-3338	399	20	enough	enough	ADV
cjal-3338	399	21	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	399	22	be	be	AUX
cjal-3338	399	23	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	399	24	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	399	25	to	to	ADP
cjal-3338	399	26	unexpired	unexpired	ADJ
cjal-3338	399	27	patents	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	399	28	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	399	29	he	he	PRON
cjal-3338	399	30	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	399	31	practicing	practice	VERB
cjal-3338	399	32	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	399	33	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	399	34	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	399	35	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	399	36	therefore	therefore	ADV
cjal-3338	399	37	can	can	AUX
cjal-3338	399	38	not	not	PART
cjal-3338	399	39	infringe	infringe	VERB
cjal-3338	399	40	patents	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	399	41	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	400	1	consequently	consequently	ADV
cjal-3338	400	2	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	400	3	for	for	ADP
cjal-3338	400	4	businesses	business	NOUN
cjal-3338	400	5	encountering	encounter	VERB
cjal-3338	400	6	problems	problem	NOUN
cjal-3338	400	7	that	that	PRON
cjal-3338	400	8	have	have	AUX
cjal-3338	400	9	long	long	ADV
cjal-3338	400	10	been	be	AUX
cjal-3338	400	11	solved	solve	VERB
cjal-3338	400	12	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	400	13	hitting	hit	VERB
cjal-3338	400	14	old	old	ADJ
cjal-3338	400	15	textbooks	textbook	NOUN
cjal-3338	400	16	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	400	17	copy	copy	VERB
cjal-3338	400	18	old	old	ADJ
cjal-3338	400	19	answers	answer	NOUN
cjal-3338	400	20	may	may	AUX
cjal-3338	400	21	provide	provide	VERB
cjal-3338	400	22	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	400	23	more	more	ADV
cjal-3338	400	24	economic	economic	ADJ
cjal-3338	400	25	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	400	26	liability	liability	NOUN
cjal-3338	400	27	-	-	PUNCT
cjal-3338	400	28	proof	proof	ADJ
cjal-3338	400	29	option	option	NOUN
cjal-3338	400	30	than	than	ADP
cjal-3338	400	31	improvisation	improvisation	NOUN
cjal-3338	400	32	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	400	33	innovation	innovation	NOUN
cjal-3338	400	34	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	401	1	that	that	PRON
cjal-3338	401	2	could	could	AUX
cjal-3338	401	3	be	be	AUX
cjal-3338	401	4	costly	costly	ADJ
cjal-3338	401	5	to	to	ADP
cjal-3338	401	6	society	society	NOUN
cjal-3338	401	7	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	402	1	computer	computer	NOUN
cjal-3338	402	2	algorithms	algorithm	NOUN
cjal-3338	402	3	already	already	ADV
cjal-3338	402	4	written	write	VERB
cjal-3338	402	5	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	402	6	solve	solve	VERB
cjal-3338	402	7	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	402	8	problem	problem	NOUN
cjal-3338	402	9	may	may	AUX
cjal-3338	402	10	not	not	PART
cjal-3338	402	11	get	get	AUX
cjal-3338	402	12	optimized	optimize	VERB
cjal-3338	402	13	;	;	PUNCT
cjal-3338	402	14	chemical	chemical	NOUN
cjal-3338	402	15	formulas	formula	NOUN
cjal-3338	402	16	known	know	VERB
cjal-3338	402	17	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	402	18	achieve	achieve	VERB
cjal-3338	402	19	an	an	DET
cjal-3338	402	20	outcome	outcome	NOUN
cjal-3338	402	21	acceptably	acceptably	ADV
cjal-3338	402	22	well	well	ADV
cjal-3338	402	23	will	will	AUX
cjal-3338	402	24	not	not	PART
cjal-3338	402	25	be	be	AUX
cjal-3338	402	26	retested	reteste	VERB
cjal-3338	402	27	or	or	CCONJ
cjal-3338	402	28	substituted	substitute	VERB
cjal-3338	402	29	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	403	1	dynamism	dynamism	NOUN
cjal-3338	403	2	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	403	3	technological	technological	ADJ
cjal-3338	403	4	development	development	NOUN
cjal-3338	403	5	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	403	6	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	403	7	objective	objective	NOUN
cjal-3338	403	8	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	403	9	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	403	10	well	well	ADV
cjal-3338	403	11	-	-	PUNCT
cjal-3338	403	12	functioning	function	VERB
cjal-3338	403	13	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	403	14	51	51	NUM
cjal-3338	403	15	joseph	joseph	PROPN
cjal-3338	403	16	s.	s.	PROPN
cjal-3338	403	17	miller	miller	PROPN
cjal-3338	403	18	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	403	19	joint	joint	ADJ
cjal-3338	403	20	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	403	21	or	or	CCONJ
cjal-3338	403	22	research	research	NOUN
cjal-3338	403	23	joint	joint	ADJ
cjal-3338	403	24	venture	venture	NOUN
cjal-3338	403	25	?	?	PUNCT
cjal-3338	404	1	reassessing	reassess	VERB
cjal-3338	404	2	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	404	3	patentchallenge	patentchallenge	NOUN
cjal-3338	404	4	-	-	PUNCT
cjal-3338	404	5	bloc	bloc	NOUN
cjal-3338	404	6	's	's	PART
cjal-3338	404	7	antitrust	antitrust	ADJ
cjal-3338	404	8	status	status	NOUN
cjal-3338	404	9	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	404	10	2o	2o	PROPN
cjal-3338	404	11	stan	stan	PROPN
cjal-3338	404	12	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	405	1	tech	tech	PROPN
cjal-3338	405	2	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	406	1	l.	l.	PROPN
cjal-3338	406	2	rev	rev	PROPN
cjal-3338	406	3	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	406	4	5	5	NUM
cjal-3338	406	5	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	406	6	2011	2011	NUM
cjal-3338	406	7	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	406	8	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	407	1	56	56	NUM
cjal-3338	407	2	subject	subject	NOUN
cjal-3338	407	3	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	407	4	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	407	5	course	course	NOUN
cjal-3338	407	6	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	407	7	to	to	ADP
cjal-3338	407	8	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	407	9	timestamp	timestamp	NOUN
cjal-3338	407	10	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	407	11	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	407	12	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	407	13	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	407	14	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	407	15	defendant	defendant	NOUN
cjal-3338	407	16	used	use	VERB
cjal-3338	407	17	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	407	18	establishing	establish	VERB
cjal-3338	407	19	his	his	PRON
cjal-3338	407	20	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	407	21	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	408	1	columbia	columbia	PROPN
cjal-3338	408	2	journal	journal	PROPN
cjal-3338	408	3	ofasian	ofasian	ADJ
cjal-3338	408	4	law	law	NOUN
cjal-3338	408	5	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	408	6	vol	vol	NOUN
cjal-3338	408	7	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	408	8	27	27	NUM
cjal-3338	408	9	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	408	10	no	no	INTJ
cjal-3338	408	11	.	.	NOUN
cjal-3338	408	12	1	1	NUM
cjal-3338	408	13	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	408	14	2o13	2o13	NUM
cjal-3338	408	15	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	408	16	system	system	NOUN
cjal-3338	408	17	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	409	1	it	it	PRON
cjal-3338	409	2	ought	ought	AUX
cjal-3338	409	3	not	not	PART
cjal-3338	409	4	be	be	AUX
cjal-3338	409	5	discouraged	discourage	VERB
cjal-3338	409	6	by	by	ADP
cjal-3338	409	7	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	409	8	provision	provision	NOUN
cjal-3338	409	9	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	409	10	easy	easy	ADJ
cjal-3338	409	11	escapes	escape	NOUN
cjal-3338	409	12	for	for	ADP
cjal-3338	409	13	those	those	PRON
cjal-3338	409	14	who	who	PRON
cjal-3338	409	15	work	work	VERB
cjal-3338	409	16	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	409	17	fear	fear	NOUN
cjal-3338	409	18	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	409	19	infringement	infringement	NOUN
cjal-3338	409	20	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	410	1	appealing	appeal	VERB
cjal-3338	410	2	though	though	SCONJ
cjal-3338	410	3	this	this	DET
cjal-3338	410	4	argument	argument	NOUN
cjal-3338	410	5	may	may	AUX
cjal-3338	410	6	seem	seem	VERB
cjal-3338	410	7	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	410	8	it	it	PRON
cjal-3338	410	9	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	410	10	not	not	PART
cjal-3338	410	11	very	very	ADV
cjal-3338	410	12	convincing	convincing	ADJ
cjal-3338	410	13	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	411	1	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	411	2	fear	fear	NOUN
cjal-3338	411	3	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	411	4	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	411	5	infringement	infringement	NOUN
cjal-3338	411	6	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
cjal-3338	411	7	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	411	8	drive	drive	VERB
cjal-3338	411	9	businesses	business	NOUN
cjal-3338	411	10	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	411	11	reuse	reuse	VERB
cjal-3338	411	12	old	old	ADJ
cjal-3338	411	13	solutions	solution	NOUN
cjal-3338	411	14	may	may	AUX
cjal-3338	411	15	also	also	ADV
cjal-3338	411	16	drive	drive	VERB
cjal-3338	411	17	businesses	business	NOUN
cjal-3338	411	18	not	not	PART
cjal-3338	411	19	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	411	20	develop	develop	VERB
cjal-3338	411	21	products	product	NOUN
cjal-3338	411	22	altogether	altogether	ADV
cjal-3338	411	23	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	412	1	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	412	2	as	as	ADV
cjal-3338	412	3	many	many	ADJ
cjal-3338	412	4	observers	observer	NOUN
cjal-3338	412	5	have	have	AUX
cjal-3338	412	6	noted	note	VERB
cjal-3338	412	7	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	412	8	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	412	9	thickets	thicket	NOUN
cjal-3338	412	10	have	have	AUX
cjal-3338	412	11	developed	develop	VERB
cjal-3338	412	12	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	412	13	many	many	ADJ
cjal-3338	412	14	industries	industry	NOUN
cjal-3338	412	15	that	that	PRON
cjal-3338	412	16	have	have	VERB
cjal-3338	412	17	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	412	18	possibility	possibility	NOUN
cjal-3338	412	19	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	412	20	choking	choke	VERB
cjal-3338	412	21	off	off	ADP
cjal-3338	412	22	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	412	23	production	production	NOUN
cjal-3338	412	24	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	412	25	new	new	ADJ
cjal-3338	412	26	products	product	NOUN
cjal-3338	412	27	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	412	28	entrance	entrance	NOUN
cjal-3338	412	29	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	412	30	new	new	ADJ
cjal-3338	412	31	market	market	NOUN
cjal-3338	412	32	participants	participant	NOUN
cjal-3338	412	33	who	who	PRON
cjal-3338	412	34	do	do	AUX
cjal-3338	412	35	not	not	PART
cjal-3338	412	36	have	have	VERB
cjal-3338	412	37	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	412	38	portfolios	portfolio	NOUN
cjal-3338	412	39	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	412	40	their	their	PRON
cjal-3338	412	41	own.57	own.57	NOUN
cjal-3338	412	42	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	412	43	navigating	navigate	VERB
cjal-3338	412	44	through	through	ADP
cjal-3338	412	45	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	412	46	thickets	thicket	NOUN
cjal-3338	412	47	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	412	48	an	an	DET
cjal-3338	412	49	innovator	innovator	NOUN
cjal-3338	412	50	simply	simply	ADV
cjal-3338	412	51	can	can	AUX
cjal-3338	412	52	not	not	PART
cjal-3338	412	53	be	be	AUX
cjal-3338	412	54	certain	certain	ADJ
cjal-3338	412	55	what	what	DET
cjal-3338	412	56	component	component	NOUN
cjal-3338	412	57	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	412	58	his	his	PRON
cjal-3338	412	59	new	new	ADJ
cjal-3338	412	60	product	product	NOUN
cjal-3338	412	61	may	may	AUX
cjal-3338	412	62	be	be	AUX
cjal-3338	412	63	read	read	VERB
cjal-3338	412	64	on	on	ADP
cjal-3338	412	65	by	by	ADP
cjal-3338	412	66	what	what	PRON
cjal-3338	412	67	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	412	68	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	413	1	therefore	therefore	ADV
cjal-3338	413	2	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	413	3	he	he	PRON
cjal-3338	413	4	has	have	VERB
cjal-3338	413	5	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	413	6	run	run	VERB
cjal-3338	413	7	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	413	8	risk	risk	NOUN
cjal-3338	413	9	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	413	10	having	have	VERB
cjal-3338	413	11	all	all	PRON
cjal-3338	413	12	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	413	13	his	his	PRON
cjal-3338	413	14	inventive	inventive	ADJ
cjal-3338	413	15	efforts	effort	NOUN
cjal-3338	413	16	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	413	17	investments	investment	NOUN
cjal-3338	413	18	wasted	waste	VERB
cjal-3338	413	19	because	because	SCONJ
cjal-3338	413	20	some	some	DET
cjal-3338	413	21	component	component	NOUN
cjal-3338	413	22	that	that	PRON
cjal-3338	413	23	was	be	AUX
cjal-3338	413	24	not	not	PART
cjal-3338	413	25	even	even	ADV
cjal-3338	413	26	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	413	27	focus	focus	NOUN
cjal-3338	413	28	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	413	29	his	his	PRON
cjal-3338	413	30	attention	attention	NOUN
cjal-3338	413	31	was	be	AUX
cjal-3338	413	32	read	read	VERB
cjal-3338	413	33	on	on	ADP
cjal-3338	413	34	by	by	ADP
cjal-3338	413	35	some	some	DET
cjal-3338	413	36	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	413	37	he	he	PRON
cjal-3338	413	38	never	never	ADV
cjal-3338	413	39	knew	know	VERB
cjal-3338	413	40	about	about	ADP
cjal-3338	413	41	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	414	1	this	this	PRON
cjal-3338	414	2	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	414	3	where	where	SCONJ
cjal-3338	414	4	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	414	5	practicing	practice	VERB
cjal-3338	414	6	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	414	7	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	414	8	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	414	9	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	414	10	may	may	AUX
cjal-3338	414	11	be	be	AUX
cjal-3338	414	12	useful	useful	ADJ
cjal-3338	414	13	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	415	1	as	as	SCONJ
cjal-3338	415	2	isaac	isaac	PROPN
cjal-3338	415	3	newton	newton	PROPN
cjal-3338	415	4	wrote	write	VERB
cjal-3338	415	5	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	415	6	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	415	7	[	[	X
cjal-3338	415	8	i]f	i]f	X
cjal-3338	415	9	i	i	PRON
cjal-3338	415	10	have	have	AUX
cjal-3338	415	11	seen	see	VERB
cjal-3338	415	12	further	far	ADV
cjal-3338	415	13	it	it	PRON
cjal-3338	415	14	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	415	15	by	by	ADP
cjal-3338	415	16	standing	stand	VERB
cjal-3338	415	17	on	on	ADP
cjal-3338	415	18	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	415	19	shoulders	shoulder	NOUN
cjal-3338	415	20	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	415	21	giants	giant	NOUN
cjal-3338	415	22	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	415	23	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	416	1	newton	newton	PROPN
cjal-3338	416	2	's	's	PART
cjal-3338	416	3	statement	statement	NOUN
cjal-3338	416	4	concerns	concern	VERB
cjal-3338	416	5	basic	basic	ADJ
cjal-3338	416	6	scientific	scientific	ADJ
cjal-3338	416	7	research	research	NOUN
cjal-3338	416	8	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	416	9	not	not	PART
cjal-3338	416	10	technological	technological	ADJ
cjal-3338	416	11	innovation	innovation	NOUN
cjal-3338	416	12	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	416	13	but	but	CCONJ
cjal-3338	416	14	it	it	PRON
cjal-3338	416	15	captures	capture	VERB
cjal-3338	416	16	one	one	NUM
cjal-3338	416	17	key	key	ADJ
cjal-3338	416	18	insight	insight	NOUN
cjal-3338	416	19	about	about	ADP
cjal-3338	416	20	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	416	21	development	development	NOUN
cjal-3338	416	22	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	416	23	knowledge	knowledge	NOUN
cjal-3338	416	24	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	417	1	technical	technical	ADJ
cjal-3338	417	2	problems	problem	NOUN
cjal-3338	417	3	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	417	4	circumstances	circumstance	NOUN
cjal-3338	417	5	may	may	AUX
cjal-3338	417	6	be	be	AUX
cjal-3338	417	7	new	new	ADJ
cjal-3338	417	8	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	418	1	but	but	CCONJ
cjal-3338	418	2	they	they	PRON
cjal-3338	418	3	can	can	AUX
cjal-3338	418	4	all	all	ADV
cjal-3338	418	5	be	be	AUX
cjal-3338	418	6	broken	break	VERB
cjal-3338	418	7	down	down	ADP
cjal-3338	418	8	into	into	ADP
cjal-3338	418	9	simpler	simple	ADJ
cjal-3338	418	10	problems	problem	NOUN
cjal-3338	418	11	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	418	12	many	many	ADJ
cjal-3338	418	13	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	418	14	which	which	PRON
cjal-3338	418	15	have	have	AUX
cjal-3338	418	16	already	already	ADV
cjal-3338	418	17	been	be	AUX
cjal-3338	418	18	solved	solve	VERB
cjal-3338	418	19	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	419	1	one	one	PRON
cjal-3338	419	2	may	may	AUX
cjal-3338	419	3	be	be	AUX
cjal-3338	419	4	innovating	innovate	VERB
cjal-3338	419	5	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	419	6	response	response	NOUN
cjal-3338	419	7	to	to	ADP
cjal-3338	419	8	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	419	9	new	new	ADJ
cjal-3338	419	10	challenge	challenge	NOUN
cjal-3338	419	11	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	419	12	but	but	CCONJ
cjal-3338	419	13	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	419	14	doing	do	VERB
cjal-3338	419	15	so	so	ADV
cjal-3338	419	16	one	one	PRON
cjal-3338	419	17	may	may	AUX
cjal-3338	419	18	reuse	reuse	VERB
cjal-3338	419	19	old	old	ADJ
cjal-3338	419	20	answers	answer	NOUN
cjal-3338	419	21	to	to	AUX
cjal-3338	419	22	component	component	NOUN
cjal-3338	419	23	questions	question	NOUN
cjal-3338	419	24	that	that	PRON
cjal-3338	419	25	have	have	AUX
cjal-3338	419	26	been	be	AUX
cjal-3338	419	27	previously	previously	ADV
cjal-3338	419	28	solved	solve	VERB
cjal-3338	419	29	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	420	1	as	as	SCONJ
cjal-3338	420	2	seen	see	VERB
cjal-3338	420	3	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	420	4	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	420	5	above	above	ADJ
cjal-3338	420	6	quote	quote	NOUN
cjal-3338	420	7	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	420	8	even	even	ADV
cjal-3338	420	9	newton	newton	PROPN
cjal-3338	420	10	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	420	11	hardly	hardly	ADV
cjal-3338	420	12	known	know	VERB
cjal-3338	420	13	for	for	ADP
cjal-3338	420	14	charity	charity	NOUN
cjal-3338	420	15	to	to	ADP
cjal-3338	420	16	his	his	PRON
cjal-3338	420	17	scientific	scientific	ADJ
cjal-3338	420	18	colleagues	colleague	NOUN
cjal-3338	420	19	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	420	20	acknowledged	acknowledge	VERB
cjal-3338	420	21	that	that	SCONJ
cjal-3338	420	22	his	his	PRON
cjal-3338	420	23	novel	novel	NOUN
cjal-3338	420	24	discoveries	discovery	NOUN
cjal-3338	420	25	were	be	AUX
cjal-3338	420	26	built	build	VERB
cjal-3338	420	27	on	on	ADP
cjal-3338	420	28	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	420	29	work	work	NOUN
cjal-3338	420	30	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	420	31	his	his	PRON
cjal-3338	420	32	predecessors	predecessor	NOUN
cjal-3338	420	33	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	421	1	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	421	2	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cjal-3338	421	3	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	421	4	supreme	supreme	PROPN
cjal-3338	421	5	court	court	PROPN
cjal-3338	421	6	itself	itself	PRON
cjal-3338	421	7	also	also	ADV
cjal-3338	421	8	recognizes	recognize	VERB
cjal-3338	421	9	that	that	SCONJ
cjal-3338	421	10	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	421	11	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	421	12	inventions	invention	NOUN
cjal-3338	421	13	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	421	14	most	most	ADJ
cjal-3338	421	15	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	421	16	if	if	SCONJ
cjal-3338	421	17	not	not	PART
cjal-3338	421	18	all	all	PRON
cjal-3338	421	19	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	421	20	instances	instance	NOUN
cjal-3338	421	21	rely	rely	VERB
cjal-3338	421	22	upon	upon	SCONJ
cjal-3338	421	23	building	build	VERB
cjal-3338	421	24	blocks	block	NOUN
cjal-3338	421	25	long	long	ADV
cjal-3338	421	26	since	since	SCONJ
cjal-3338	421	27	uncovered	uncover	VERB
cjal-3338	421	28	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	421	29	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	421	30	claimed	claim	VERB
cjal-3338	421	31	discoveries	discovery	NOUN
cjal-3338	421	32	almost	almost	ADV
cjal-3338	421	33	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	421	34	necessity	necessity	NOUN
cjal-3338	421	35	will	will	AUX
cjal-3338	421	36	be	be	AUX
cjal-3338	421	37	combinations	combination	NOUN
cjal-3338	421	38	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	421	39	what	what	PRON
cjal-3338	421	40	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	421	41	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	421	42	some	some	DET
cjal-3338	421	43	sense	sense	NOUN
cjal-3338	421	44	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	421	45	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	421	46	already	already	ADV
cjal-3338	421	47	known	know	VERB
cjal-3338	421	48	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	421	49	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	422	1	58	58	NUM
cjal-3338	422	2	few	few	ADJ
cjal-3338	422	3	innovate	innovate	VERB
cjal-3338	422	4	answers	answer	NOUN
cjal-3338	422	5	on	on	ADP
cjal-3338	422	6	every	every	DET
cjal-3338	422	7	single	single	ADJ
cjal-3338	422	8	component	component	NOUN
cjal-3338	422	9	questions	question	NOUN
cjal-3338	422	10	on	on	ADP
cjal-3338	422	11	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	422	12	way	way	NOUN
cjal-3338	422	13	to	to	ADP
cjal-3338	422	14	reaching	reach	VERB
cjal-3338	422	15	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	422	16	new	new	ADJ
cjal-3338	422	17	answer	answer	NOUN
cjal-3338	422	18	to	to	ADP
cjal-3338	422	19	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	422	20	new	new	ADJ
cjal-3338	422	21	question	question	NOUN
cjal-3338	422	22	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	423	1	that	that	PRON
cjal-3338	423	2	would	would	AUX
cjal-3338	423	3	be	be	AUX
cjal-3338	423	4	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	423	5	if	if	SCONJ
cjal-3338	423	6	anything	anything	PRON
cjal-3338	423	7	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	423	8	completely	completely	ADV
cjal-3338	423	9	wasteful	wasteful	ADJ
cjal-3338	423	10	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	424	1	with	with	ADP
cjal-3338	424	2	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	424	3	availability	availability	NOUN
cjal-3338	424	4	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	424	5	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	424	6	practicing	practice	VERB
cjal-3338	424	7	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	424	8	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	424	9	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	424	10	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	424	11	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	424	12	an	an	DET
cjal-3338	424	13	innovator	innovator	NOUN
cjal-3338	424	14	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	424	15	developing	develop	VERB
cjal-3338	424	16	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	424	17	new	new	ADJ
cjal-3338	424	18	product	product	NOUN
cjal-3338	424	19	can	can	AUX
cjal-3338	424	20	calibrate	calibrate	VERB
cjal-3338	424	21	his	his	PRON
cjal-3338	424	22	risk	risk	NOUN
cjal-3338	424	23	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	424	24	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	424	25	infringement	infringement	NOUN
cjal-3338	424	26	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	425	1	he	he	PRON
cjal-3338	425	2	can	can	AUX
cjal-3338	425	3	elect	elect	VERB
cjal-3338	425	4	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	425	5	practice	practice	VERB
cjal-3338	425	6	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	425	7	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	425	8	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	425	9	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	425	10	dealing	deal	VERB
cjal-3338	425	11	with	with	ADP
cjal-3338	425	12	all	all	DET
cjal-3338	425	13	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	425	14	component	component	NOUN
cjal-3338	425	15	problems	problem	NOUN
cjal-3338	425	16	that	that	PRON
cjal-3338	425	17	are	be	AUX
cjal-3338	425	18	not	not	PART
cjal-3338	425	19	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	425	20	key	key	ADJ
cjal-3338	425	21	focus	focus	NOUN
cjal-3338	425	22	on	on	ADP
cjal-3338	425	23	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	425	24	product	product	NOUN
cjal-3338	425	25	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	425	26	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	425	27	therefore	therefore	ADV
cjal-3338	425	28	risk	risk	NOUN
cjal-3338	425	29	infringement	infringement	NOUN
cjal-3338	425	30	only	only	ADV
cjal-3338	425	31	on	on	ADP
cjal-3338	425	32	those	those	DET
cjal-3338	425	33	features	feature	NOUN
cjal-3338	425	34	where	where	SCONJ
cjal-3338	425	35	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	425	36	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	425	37	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	425	38	does	do	AUX
cjal-3338	425	39	not	not	PART
cjal-3338	425	40	reach	reach	VERB
cjal-3338	425	41	or	or	CCONJ
cjal-3338	425	42	where	where	SCONJ
cjal-3338	425	43	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	425	44	new	new	ADJ
cjal-3338	425	45	solution	solution	NOUN
cjal-3338	425	46	may	may	AUX
cjal-3338	425	47	indeed	indeed	ADV
cjal-3338	425	48	prove	prove	VERB
cjal-3338	425	49	better	well	ADV
cjal-3338	425	50	than	than	ADP
cjal-3338	425	51	old	old	ADJ
cjal-3338	425	52	ones.59	ones.59	VERB
cjal-3338	425	53	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	425	54	barriers	barrier	NOUN
cjal-3338	425	55	to	to	ADP
cjal-3338	425	56	navigating	navigate	VERB
cjal-3338	425	57	through	through	ADP
cjal-3338	425	58	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	425	59	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	425	60	thicket	thicket	NOUN
cjal-3338	425	61	becomes	become	VERB
cjal-3338	425	62	much	much	ADV
cjal-3338	425	63	lower	low	ADJ
cjal-3338	425	64	when	when	SCONJ
cjal-3338	425	65	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	425	66	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	425	67	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	425	68	can	can	AUX
cjal-3338	425	69	be	be	AUX
cjal-3338	425	70	used	use	VERB
cjal-3338	425	71	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	425	72	serve	serve	VERB
cjal-3338	425	73	as	as	ADP
cjal-3338	425	74	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	425	75	metaphorical	metaphorical	ADJ
cjal-3338	425	76	pathway	pathway	NOUN
cjal-3338	425	77	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	425	78	safety	safety	NOUN
cjal-3338	425	79	that	that	PRON
cjal-3338	425	80	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	425	81	innovator	innovator	NOUN
cjal-3338	425	82	can	can	AUX
cjal-3338	425	83	wander	wander	VERB
cjal-3338	425	84	off	off	ADP
cjal-3338	425	85	into	into	ADP
cjal-3338	425	86	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	425	87	bushes	bush	NOUN
cjal-3338	425	88	when	when	SCONJ
cjal-3338	425	89	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	425	90	where	where	SCONJ
cjal-3338	425	91	he	he	PRON
cjal-3338	425	92	so	so	ADV
cjal-3338	425	93	chooses	choose	VERB
cjal-3338	425	94	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	426	1	this	this	DET
cjal-3338	426	2	resulting	result	VERB
cjal-3338	426	3	increase	increase	NOUN
cjal-3338	426	4	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	426	5	innovation	innovation	NOUN
cjal-3338	426	6	may	may	AUX
cjal-3338	426	7	well	well	ADV
cjal-3338	426	8	balance	balance	VERB
cjal-3338	426	9	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	426	10	increased	increase	VERB
cjal-3338	426	11	copying	copying	NOUN
cjal-3338	426	12	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	426	13	old	old	ADJ
cjal-3338	426	14	solutions	solution	NOUN
cjal-3338	426	15	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	426	16	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	427	1	see	see	VERB
cjal-3338	427	2	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	427	3	e.g.	e.g.	ADV
cjal-3338	427	4	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	427	5	michael	michael	PROPN
cjal-3338	427	6	a.	a.	PROPN
cjal-3338	427	7	heller	heller	PROPN
cjal-3338	427	8	&	&	CCONJ
cjal-3338	427	9	rebecca	rebecca	PROPN
cjal-3338	427	10	s.	s.	PROPN
cjal-3338	427	11	eisenberg	eisenberg	PROPN
cjal-3338	427	12	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	427	13	can	can	AUX
cjal-3338	427	14	patents	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	427	15	deter	deter	VERB
cjal-3338	427	16	innovation	innovation	NOUN
cjal-3338	427	17	?	?	PUNCT
cjal-3338	428	1	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	428	2	anti	anti	NOUN
cjal-3338	428	3	-	-	NOUN
cjal-3338	428	4	commons	common	NOUN
cjal-3338	428	5	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	428	6	biomedical	biomedical	ADJ
cjal-3338	428	7	research	research	NOUN
cjal-3338	428	8	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	428	9	28o	28o	NOUN
cjal-3338	428	10	science	science	NOUN
cjal-3338	428	11	698	698	NUM
cjal-3338	428	12	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	428	13	1998	1998	NUM
cjal-3338	428	14	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	428	15	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	429	1	58	58	NUM
cjal-3338	429	2	ksr	ksr	PROPN
cjal-3338	429	3	int'l	int'l	PROPN
cjal-3338	429	4	co.	co.	PROPN
cjal-3338	429	5	v.	v.	PROPN
cjal-3338	429	6	teleflex	teleflex	PROPN
cjal-3338	429	7	inc	inc	PROPN
cjal-3338	429	8	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	429	9	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	429	10	550	550	NUM
cjal-3338	429	11	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cjal-3338	429	12	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	429	13	398	398	NUM
cjal-3338	429	14	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	429	15	418	418	NUM
cjal-3338	429	16	-	-	SYM
cjal-3338	429	17	419	419	NUM
cjal-3338	429	18	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	429	19	2007	2007	NUM
cjal-3338	429	20	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	429	21	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	430	1	'	'	PUNCT
cjal-3338	430	2	9and	9and	PROPN
cjal-3338	430	3	if	if	SCONJ
cjal-3338	430	4	all	all	DET
cjal-3338	430	5	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	430	6	component	component	NOUN
cjal-3338	430	7	questions	question	NOUN
cjal-3338	430	8	have	have	VERB
cjal-3338	430	9	old	old	ADJ
cjal-3338	430	10	answers	answer	NOUN
cjal-3338	430	11	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	430	12	then	then	ADV
cjal-3338	430	13	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	430	14	innovator	innovator	NOUN
cjal-3338	430	15	who	who	PRON
cjal-3338	430	16	chooses	choose	VERB
cjal-3338	430	17	these	these	DET
cjal-3338	430	18	old	old	ADJ
cjal-3338	430	19	answers	answer	NOUN
cjal-3338	430	20	manageably	manageably	ADV
cjal-3338	430	21	risks	risk	VERB
cjal-3338	430	22	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	430	23	infringement	infringement	NOUN
cjal-3338	430	24	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	430	25	only	only	ADV
cjal-3338	430	26	one	one	NUM
cjal-3338	430	27	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	430	28	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	430	29	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	430	30	covering	cover	VERB
cjal-3338	430	31	his	his	PRON
cjal-3338	430	32	precise	precise	ADJ
cjal-3338	430	33	selection	selection	NOUN
cjal-3338	430	34	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	430	35	answers	answer	NOUN
cjal-3338	430	36	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	431	1	defensive	defensive	ADJ
cjal-3338	431	2	use	use	NOUN
cjal-3338	431	3	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	431	4	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	431	5	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	431	6	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	431	7	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cjal-3338	431	8	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	431	9	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	431	10	chinese	chinese	PROPN
cjal-3338	431	11	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	431	12	litigation	litigation	PROPN
cjal-3338	431	13	3	3	X
cjal-3338	431	14	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	431	15	justifications	justification	NOUN
cjal-3338	431	16	for	for	ADP
cjal-3338	431	17	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	431	18	practicing	practice	VERB
cjal-3338	431	19	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	431	20	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	431	21	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	431	22	defense6o	defense6o	VERB
cjal-3338	431	23	an	an	DET
cjal-3338	431	24	analysis	analysis	NOUN
cjal-3338	431	25	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	431	26	possible	possible	ADJ
cjal-3338	431	27	justifications	justification	NOUN
cjal-3338	431	28	against	against	ADP
cjal-3338	431	29	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	431	30	practicing	practice	VERB
cjal-3338	431	31	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	431	32	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	431	33	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	431	34	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	431	35	shows	show	VERB
cjal-3338	431	36	that	that	SCONJ
cjal-3338	431	37	very	very	ADV
cjal-3338	431	38	little	little	ADJ
cjal-3338	431	39	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	431	40	convincing	convincing	ADJ
cjal-3338	431	41	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	432	1	we	we	PRON
cjal-3338	432	2	have	have	AUX
cjal-3338	432	3	also	also	ADV
cjal-3338	432	4	come	come	VERB
cjal-3338	432	5	upon	upon	SCONJ
cjal-3338	432	6	some	some	DET
cjal-3338	432	7	justifications	justification	NOUN
cjal-3338	432	8	for	for	ADP
cjal-3338	432	9	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	432	10	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	432	11	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	432	12	such	such	ADJ
cjal-3338	432	13	as	as	ADP
cjal-3338	432	14	its	its	PRON
cjal-3338	432	15	ability	ability	NOUN
cjal-3338	432	16	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	432	17	help	help	VERB
cjal-3338	432	18	guide	guide	VERB
cjal-3338	432	19	inventors	inventor	NOUN
cjal-3338	432	20	through	through	ADP
cjal-3338	432	21	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	432	22	thickets	thicket	NOUN
cjal-3338	432	23	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	433	1	but	but	CCONJ
cjal-3338	433	2	more	more	ADJ
cjal-3338	433	3	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	433	4	indeed	indeed	ADV
cjal-3338	433	5	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	433	6	can	can	AUX
cjal-3338	433	7	be	be	AUX
cjal-3338	433	8	said	say	VERB
cjal-3338	433	9	for	for	ADP
cjal-3338	433	10	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	433	11	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	433	12	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	434	1	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	434	2	best	good	ADJ
cjal-3338	434	3	justification	justification	NOUN
cjal-3338	434	4	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	434	5	already	already	ADV
cjal-3338	434	6	alluded	allude	VERB
cjal-3338	434	7	to	to	ADP
cjal-3338	434	8	above	above	ADV
cjal-3338	434	9	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	434	10	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	434	11	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	434	12	improvement	improvement	NOUN
cjal-3338	434	13	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	434	14	judicial	judicial	ADJ
cjal-3338	434	15	economy	economy	NOUN
cjal-3338	434	16	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	434	17	vigor	vigor	NOUN
cjal-3338	434	18	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	435	1	adjudication	adjudication	NOUN
cjal-3338	435	2	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	435	3	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	435	4	practicing	practice	VERB
cjal-3338	435	5	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	435	6	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	435	7	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	435	8	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	435	9	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	435	10	fundamentally	fundamentally	ADV
cjal-3338	435	11	easy	easy	ADJ
cjal-3338	435	12	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	436	1	it	it	PRON
cjal-3338	436	2	requires	require	VERB
cjal-3338	436	3	understanding	understand	VERB
cjal-3338	436	4	only	only	ADV
cjal-3338	436	5	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	436	6	accused	accuse	VERB
cjal-3338	436	7	device	device	NOUN
cjal-3338	436	8	or	or	CCONJ
cjal-3338	436	9	acts	act	NOUN
cjal-3338	436	10	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	436	11	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	436	12	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	436	13	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	436	14	that	that	PRON
cjal-3338	436	15	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	436	16	defendant	defendant	NOUN
cjal-3338	436	17	points	point	VERB
cjal-3338	436	18	to	to	ADP
cjal-3338	436	19	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	437	1	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	437	2	accused	accuse	VERB
cjal-3338	437	3	device	device	NOUN
cjal-3338	437	4	or	or	CCONJ
cjal-3338	437	5	act	act	NOUN
cjal-3338	437	6	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	437	7	something	something	PRON
cjal-3338	437	8	put	put	VERB
cjal-3338	437	9	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	437	10	actual	actual	ADJ
cjal-3338	437	11	practice	practice	NOUN
cjal-3338	437	12	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	437	13	which	which	PRON
cjal-3338	437	14	could	could	AUX
cjal-3338	437	15	either	either	CCONJ
cjal-3338	437	16	be	be	AUX
cjal-3338	437	17	brought	bring	VERB
cjal-3338	437	18	to	to	ADP
cjal-3338	437	19	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	437	20	court	court	NOUN
cjal-3338	437	21	6o	6o	NOUN
cjal-3338	437	22	interestingly	interestingly	ADV
cjal-3338	437	23	enough	enough	ADV
cjal-3338	437	24	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	437	25	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	437	26	primary	primary	ADJ
cjal-3338	437	27	justification	justification	NOUN
cjal-3338	437	28	for	for	ADP
cjal-3338	437	29	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	437	30	chinese	chinese	ADJ
cjal-3338	437	31	existing	exist	VERB
cjal-3338	437	32	technology	technology	NOUN
cjal-3338	437	33	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	437	34	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	437	35	not	not	PART
cjal-3338	437	36	applicable	applicable	ADJ
cjal-3338	437	37	to	to	ADP
cjal-3338	437	38	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cjal-3338	437	39	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	437	40	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	437	41	law	law	NOUN
cjal-3338	437	42	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	438	1	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	438	2	supreme	supreme	PROPN
cjal-3338	438	3	people	people	PROPN
cjal-3338	438	4	's	's	PART
cjal-3338	438	5	court	court	NOUN
cjal-3338	438	6	provides	provide	VERB
cjal-3338	438	7	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	438	8	following	follow	VERB
cjal-3338	438	9	explanation	explanation	NOUN
cjal-3338	438	10	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	438	11	which	which	PRON
cjal-3338	438	12	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	438	13	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	438	14	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	438	15	context	context	NOUN
cjal-3338	438	16	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	438	17	design	design	NOUN
cjal-3338	438	18	patents	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	438	19	but	but	CCONJ
cjal-3338	438	20	which	which	PRON
cjal-3338	438	21	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	438	22	more	more	ADV
cjal-3338	438	23	generally	generally	ADV
cjal-3338	438	24	applicable	applicable	ADJ
cjal-3338	438	25	:	:	PUNCT
cjal-3338	438	26	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	438	27	law	law	NOUN
cjal-3338	438	28	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	438	29	effect	effect	NOUN
cjal-3338	438	30	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	438	31	this	this	DET
cjal-3338	438	32	country	country	NOUN
cjal-3338	438	33	uses	use	VERB
cjal-3338	438	34	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	438	35	model	model	NOUN
cjal-3338	438	36	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	438	37	separately	separately	ADV
cjal-3338	438	38	conducting	conduct	VERB
cjal-3338	438	39	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	438	40	procedures	procedure	NOUN
cjal-3338	438	41	for	for	ADP
cjal-3338	438	42	determining	determine	VERB
cjal-3338	438	43	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	438	44	validity	validity	NOUN
cjal-3338	438	45	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	438	46	those	those	PRON
cjal-3338	438	47	for	for	ADP
cjal-3338	438	48	determining	determine	VERB
cjal-3338	438	49	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	438	50	infringement	infringement	NOUN
cjal-3338	438	51	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	439	1	it	it	PRON
cjal-3338	439	2	would	would	AUX
cjal-3338	439	3	cause	cause	VERB
cjal-3338	439	4	an	an	DET
cjal-3338	439	5	imbalance	imbalance	NOUN
cjal-3338	439	6	between	between	ADP
cjal-3338	439	7	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	439	8	protective	protective	ADJ
cjal-3338	439	9	scope	scope	NOUN
cjal-3338	439	10	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	439	11	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	439	12	design	design	NOUN
cjal-3338	439	13	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	439	14	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	439	15	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	439	16	patentee	patentee	NOUN
cjal-3338	439	17	's	's	PART
cjal-3338	439	18	creative	creative	ADJ
cjal-3338	439	19	contribution	contribution	NOUN
cjal-3338	439	20	if	if	SCONJ
cjal-3338	439	21	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	439	22	accused	accuse	VERB
cjal-3338	439	23	infringer	infringer	NOUN
cjal-3338	439	24	were	be	AUX
cjal-3338	439	25	not	not	PART
cjal-3338	439	26	permitted	permit	VERB
cjal-3338	439	27	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	439	28	maintain	maintain	VERB
cjal-3338	439	29	an	an	DET
cjal-3338	439	30	existing	exist	VERB
cjal-3338	439	31	design	design	NOUN
cjal-3338	439	32	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	439	33	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	439	34	civil	civil	ADJ
cjal-3338	439	35	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	439	36	litigation	litigation	NOUN
cjal-3338	439	37	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	439	38	if	if	SCONJ
cjal-3338	439	39	accused	accuse	VERB
cjal-3338	439	40	products	product	NOUN
cjal-3338	439	41	that	that	PRON
cjal-3338	439	42	belong	belong	VERB
cjal-3338	439	43	to	to	ADP
cjal-3338	439	44	existing	exist	VERB
cjal-3338	439	45	design	design	NOUN
cjal-3338	439	46	are	be	AUX
cjal-3338	439	47	still	still	ADV
cjal-3338	439	48	adjudged	adjudge	VERB
cjal-3338	439	49	as	as	ADP
cjal-3338	439	50	infringing	infringe	VERB
cjal-3338	439	51	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	439	52	asserted	asserted	ADJ
cjal-3338	439	53	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	439	54	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	440	1	zhushi	zhushi	PROPN
cjal-3338	440	2	huishe	huishe	PROPN
cjal-3338	440	3	puli	puli	PROPN
cjal-3338	440	4	sitong	sitong	PROPN
cjal-3338	440	5	yu	yu	PROPN
cjal-3338	440	6	zhejiang	zhejiang	PROPN
cjal-3338	440	7	hangtingdun	hangtingdun	AUX
cjal-3338	440	8	gongniu	gongniu	VERB
cjal-3338	440	9	xiangjiao	xiangjiao	PROPN
cjal-3338	440	10	youxian	youxian	PROPN
cjal-3338	440	11	gongsi	gongsi	PROPN
cjal-3338	440	12	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	440	13	beijing	beijing	PROPN
cjal-3338	440	14	banglexin	banglexin	PROPN
cjal-3338	440	15	luntai	luntai	PROPN
cjal-3338	440	16	youxian	youxian	PROPN
cjal-3338	440	17	gongsi	gongsi	PROPN
cjal-3338	440	18	qinfan	qinfan	PROPN
cjal-3338	440	19	zhuanli	zhuanli	PROPN
cjal-3338	440	20	quan	quan	PROPN
cjal-3338	441	1	jiufen	jiufen	PROPN
cjal-3338	441	2	yian	yian	PROPN
cjal-3338	441	3	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	441	4	4*n±ff11	4*n±ff11	NUM
cjal-3338	441	5	[	[	X
cjal-3338	441	6	bridgestone	bridgestone	PROPN
cjal-3338	441	7	corp	corp	PROPN
cjal-3338	441	8	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	442	1	v.	v.	PROPN
cjal-3338	442	2	zhejiang	zhejiang	PROPN
cjal-3338	442	3	huntington	huntington	PROPN
cjal-3338	442	4	bull	bull	PROPN
cjal-3338	442	5	rubber	rubber	PROPN
cjal-3338	442	6	co.	co.	PROPN
cjal-3338	442	7	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	442	8	ltd	ltd	PROPN
cjal-3338	442	9	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	442	10	]	]	X
cjal-3338	443	1	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	443	2	sup.people	sup.people	PROPN
cjal-3338	443	3	's	's	PART
cjal-3338	443	4	ct	ct	NOUN
cjal-3338	443	5	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	443	6	2011	2011	NUM
cjal-3338	443	7	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	443	8	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	443	9	emphasis	emphasis	NOUN
cjal-3338	443	10	added	add	VERB
cjal-3338	443	11	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	443	12	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	443	13	available	available	ADJ
cjal-3338	443	14	at	at	ADP
cjal-3338	443	15	http://ipr.court.gov.cn/zgrmfy/2o12o7/	http://ipr.court.gov.cn/zgrmfy/2o12o7/	PROPN
cjal-3338	443	16	t2012o718_149633.html	t2012o718_149633.html	PUNCT
cjal-3338	443	17	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	444	1	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	444	2	contrast	contrast	NOUN
cjal-3338	444	3	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	444	4	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cjal-3338	444	5	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	444	6	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	444	7	law	law	NOUN
cjal-3338	444	8	explicitly	explicitly	ADV
cjal-3338	444	9	allows	allow	VERB
cjal-3338	444	10	courts	court	NOUN
cjal-3338	444	11	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	444	12	invalidate	invalidate	VERB
cjal-3338	444	13	patents	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	444	14	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	444	15	civil	civil	ADJ
cjal-3338	444	16	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	444	17	litigation	litigation	NOUN
cjal-3338	444	18	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	445	1	see	see	VERB
cjal-3338	445	2	microsoft	microsoft	PROPN
cjal-3338	445	3	corp	corp	PROPN
cjal-3338	445	4	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	446	1	v.	v.	PROPN
cjal-3338	446	2	i4	i4	PROPN
cjal-3338	446	3	i	i	PROPN
cjal-3338	446	4	ltd	ltd	PROPN
cjal-3338	446	5	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	446	6	p'ship	p'ship	PROPN
cjal-3338	446	7	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	447	1	131	131	NUM
cjal-3338	447	2	s.	s.	PROPN
cjal-3338	447	3	ct	ct	PROPN
cjal-3338	447	4	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	447	5	2238	2238	NUM
cjal-3338	447	6	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	447	7	2242	2242	NUM
cjal-3338	447	8	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	447	9	2011	2011	NUM
cjal-3338	447	10	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	447	11	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	447	12	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	447	13	among	among	ADP
cjal-3338	447	14	other	other	ADJ
cjal-3338	447	15	defenses	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	447	16	under	under	ADP
cjal-3338	447	17	§	§	PROPN
cjal-3338	447	18	282	282	NUM
cjal-3338	447	19	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	447	20	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	447	21	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	447	22	act	act	NOUN
cjal-3338	447	23	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	447	24	1952	1952	NUM
cjal-3338	447	25	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	447	26	1952	1952	NUM
cjal-3338	447	27	act	act	PROPN
cjal-3338	447	28	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	447	29	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	447	30	an	an	DET
cjal-3338	447	31	alleged	allege	VERB
cjal-3338	447	32	infringer	infringer	NOUN
cjal-3338	447	33	may	may	AUX
cjal-3338	447	34	assert	assert	VERB
cjal-3338	447	35	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	447	36	invalidity	invalidity	NOUN
cjal-3338	447	37	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	447	38	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	447	39	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	447	40	-	-	PUNCT
cjal-3338	447	41	that	that	ADV
cjal-3338	447	42	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	447	43	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	447	44	he	he	PRON
cjal-3338	447	45	may	may	AUX
cjal-3338	447	46	attempt	attempt	VERB
cjal-3338	447	47	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	447	48	prove	prove	VERB
cjal-3338	447	49	that	that	SCONJ
cjal-3338	447	50	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	447	51	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	447	52	never	never	ADV
cjal-3338	447	53	should	should	AUX
cjal-3338	447	54	have	have	AUX
cjal-3338	447	55	issued	issue	VERB
cjal-3338	447	56	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	447	57	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	447	58	first	first	ADJ
cjal-3338	447	59	place	place	NOUN
cjal-3338	447	60	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	448	1	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	448	2	defendant	defendant	NOUN
cjal-3338	448	3	may	may	AUX
cjal-3338	448	4	argue	argue	VERB
cjal-3338	448	5	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	448	6	for	for	ADP
cjal-3338	448	7	instance	instance	NOUN
cjal-3338	448	8	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	448	9	that	that	SCONJ
cjal-3338	448	10	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	448	11	claimed	claim	VERB
cjal-3338	448	12	invention	invention	NOUN
cjal-3338	448	13	was	be	AUX
cjal-3338	448	14	obvious	obvious	ADJ
cjal-3338	448	15	at	at	ADP
cjal-3338	448	16	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	448	17	time	time	NOUN
cjal-3338	448	18	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	448	19	thus	thus	ADV
cjal-3338	448	20	that	that	SCONJ
cjal-3338	448	21	one	one	NUM
cjal-3338	448	22	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	448	23	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	448	24	conditions	condition	NOUN
cjal-3338	448	25	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	448	26	patentability	patentability	NOUN
cjal-3338	448	27	was	be	AUX
cjal-3338	448	28	lacking	lack	VERB
cjal-3338	448	29	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	448	30	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	448	31	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	448	32	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	449	1	bridgestone	bridgestone	PROPN
cjal-3338	449	2	v.	v.	ADP
cjal-3338	449	3	huntington	huntington	PROPN
cjal-3338	449	4	bull	bull	PROPN
cjal-3338	449	5	rubber	rubber	NOUN
cjal-3338	449	6	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	449	7	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	449	8	typical	typical	ADJ
cjal-3338	449	9	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	449	10	case	case	NOUN
cjal-3338	449	11	number	number	NOUN
cjal-3338	449	12	4	4	NUM
cjal-3338	449	13	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	449	14	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	449	15	2011	2011	NUM
cjal-3338	449	16	list	list	NOUN
cjal-3338	449	17	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	449	18	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	449	19	top	top	ADJ
cjal-3338	449	20	io	io	NOUN
cjal-3338	449	21	cases	case	NOUN
cjal-3338	449	22	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	449	23	5o	5o	NUM
cjal-3338	449	24	typical	typical	ADJ
cjal-3338	449	25	cases	case	NOUN
cjal-3338	449	26	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	449	27	judicial	judicial	ADJ
cjal-3338	449	28	protection	protection	NOUN
cjal-3338	449	29	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	449	30	intellectual	intellectual	ADJ
cjal-3338	449	31	property	property	NOUN
cjal-3338	449	32	rights	right	NOUN
cjal-3338	449	33	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	449	34	chinese	chinese	ADJ
cjal-3338	449	35	courts	court	NOUN
cjal-3338	449	36	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	449	37	promulgated	promulgate	VERB
cjal-3338	449	38	by	by	ADP
cjal-3338	449	39	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	449	40	supreme	supreme	PROPN
cjal-3338	449	41	people	people	PROPN
cjal-3338	449	42	's	's	PART
cjal-3338	449	43	court	court	NOUN
cjal-3338	449	44	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	450	1	zuigao	zuigao	PROPN
cjal-3338	450	2	renmen	renmen	PROPN
cjal-3338	450	3	fayuan	fayuan	PROPN
cjal-3338	450	4	bangongting	bangongte	VERB
cjal-3338	450	5	guanyu	guanyu	PROPN
cjal-3338	450	6	yinfa	yinfa	NOUN
cjal-3338	450	7	2011	2011	NUM
cjal-3338	450	8	nian	nian	ADJ
cjal-3338	450	9	zhongguo	zhongguo	PROPN
cjal-3338	450	10	fayuan	fayuan	PROPN
cjal-3338	450	11	zhishi	zhishi	PROPN
cjal-3338	450	12	chanquan	chanquan	PROPN
cjal-3338	450	13	sifa	sifa	PROPN
cjal-3338	450	14	baohu	baohu	PROPN
cjal-3338	450	15	lo	lo	PROPN
cjal-3338	450	16	dai	dai	PROPN
cjal-3338	450	17	anjian	anjian	PROPN
cjal-3338	450	18	he	he	PRON
cjal-3338	450	19	50	50	NUM
cjal-3338	450	20	jian	jian	NOUN
cjal-3338	450	21	dianxing	dianxe	VERB
cjal-3338	450	22	anjian	anjian	ADJ
cjal-3338	450	23	anli	anli	PROPN
cjal-3338	450	24	di	di	PROPN
cjal-3338	450	25	tongzhi	tongzhi	PROPN
cjal-3338	450	26	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	450	27	_	_	PUNCT
cjal-3338	450	28	onfjr	onfjr	NOUN
cjal-3338	450	29	2011	2011	NUM
cjal-3338	450	30	]	]	X
cjal-3338	450	31	p	p	X
cjal-3338	450	32	10	10	NUM
cjal-3338	450	33	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	450	34	y9449	y9449	NOUN
cjal-3338	450	35	50	50	NUM
cjal-3338	450	36	4i#alwjl	4i#alwjl	NUM
cjal-3338	450	37	ja	ja	PROPN
cjal-3338	450	38	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	451	1	[	[	X
cjal-3338	451	2	circular	circular	NOUN
cjal-3338	451	3	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	451	4	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	451	5	supreme	supreme	PROPN
cjal-3338	451	6	people	people	PROPN
cjal-3338	451	7	's	's	PART
cjal-3338	451	8	court	court	NOUN
cjal-3338	451	9	general	general	ADJ
cjal-3338	451	10	office	office	NOUN
cjal-3338	451	11	concerning	concern	VERB
cjal-3338	451	12	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	451	13	top	top	ADJ
cjal-3338	451	14	io	io	NOUN
cjal-3338	451	15	cases	case	NOUN
cjal-3338	451	16	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	451	17	50	50	NUM
cjal-3338	451	18	typical	typical	ADJ
cjal-3338	451	19	cases	case	NOUN
cjal-3338	451	20	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	451	21	judicial	judicial	ADJ
cjal-3338	451	22	protection	protection	NOUN
cjal-3338	451	23	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	451	24	intellectual	intellectual	ADJ
cjal-3338	451	25	property	property	NOUN
cjal-3338	451	26	rights	right	NOUN
cjal-3338	451	27	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	451	28	chinese	chinese	ADJ
cjal-3338	451	29	courts	court	NOUN
cjal-3338	451	30	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	451	31	2011	2011	NUM
cjal-3338	451	32	]	]	PUNCT
cjal-3338	451	33	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	451	34	promulgated	promulgate	VERB
cjal-3338	451	35	by	by	ADP
cjal-3338	451	36	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	451	37	sup	sup	NOUN
cjal-3338	451	38	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	452	1	people	people	NOUN
cjal-3338	452	2	's	's	PART
cjal-3338	452	3	ct	ct	PROPN
cjal-3338	452	4	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	452	5	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	452	6	apr	apr	PROPN
cjal-3338	452	7	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	452	8	18	18	NUM
cjal-3338	452	9	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	452	10	2012	2012	NUM
cjal-3338	452	11	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	452	12	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	452	13	available	available	ADJ
cjal-3338	452	14	at	at	ADP
cjal-3338	452	15	http://rmfyb.chinacourt.org/paper/page//2o012-o4/8/o2/2o12o	http://rmfyb.chinacourt.org/paper/page//2o012-o4/8/o2/2o12o	X
cjal-3338	452	16	418o2-pdf.pdf	418o2-pdf.pdf	NUM
cjal-3338	452	17	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	452	18	74	74	NUM
cjal-3338	452	19	columbia	columbia	PROPN
cjal-3338	452	20	journal	journal	NOUN
cjal-3338	452	21	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	452	22	asian	asian	ADJ
cjal-3338	452	23	law	law	NOUN
cjal-3338	452	24	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	452	25	vol	vol	NOUN
cjal-3338	452	26	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	452	27	27	27	NUM
cjal-3338	452	28	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	452	29	no	no	INTJ
cjal-3338	452	30	.	.	NOUN
cjal-3338	452	31	1	1	NUM
cjal-3338	452	32	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	452	33	2013	2013	NUM
cjal-3338	452	34	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	452	35	or	or	CCONJ
cjal-3338	452	36	which	which	PRON
cjal-3338	452	37	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	452	38	court	court	NOUN
cjal-3338	452	39	can	can	AUX
cjal-3338	452	40	observe	observe	VERB
cjal-3338	452	41	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	452	42	person	person	NOUN
cjal-3338	452	43	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	453	1	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	453	2	court	court	NOUN
cjal-3338	453	3	can	can	AUX
cjal-3338	453	4	develop	develop	VERB
cjal-3338	453	5	its	its	PRON
cjal-3338	453	6	comprehension	comprehension	NOUN
cjal-3338	453	7	through	through	ADP
cjal-3338	453	8	interacting	interact	VERB
cjal-3338	453	9	with	with	ADP
cjal-3338	453	10	or	or	CCONJ
cjal-3338	453	11	touching	touch	VERB
cjal-3338	453	12	it	it	PRON
cjal-3338	453	13	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	454	1	comparing	compare	VERB
cjal-3338	454	2	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	454	3	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	454	4	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	454	5	with	with	ADP
cjal-3338	454	6	this	this	DET
cjal-3338	454	7	accused	accuse	VERB
cjal-3338	454	8	device	device	NOUN
cjal-3338	454	9	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	454	10	not	not	PART
cjal-3338	454	11	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	454	12	difficult	difficult	ADJ
cjal-3338	454	13	task	task	NOUN
cjal-3338	454	14	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	455	1	if	if	SCONJ
cjal-3338	455	2	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	455	3	defendant	defendant	NOUN
cjal-3338	455	4	really	really	ADV
cjal-3338	455	5	did	do	AUX
cjal-3338	455	6	practice	practice	VERB
cjal-3338	455	7	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	455	8	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	455	9	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	455	10	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	455	11	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	455	12	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	455	13	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	455	14	pieces	piece	NOUN
cjal-3338	455	15	he	he	PRON
cjal-3338	455	16	brings	bring	VERB
cjal-3338	455	17	to	to	ADP
cjal-3338	455	18	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	455	19	attention	attention	NOUN
cjal-3338	455	20	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	455	21	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	455	22	court	court	NOUN
cjal-3338	455	23	are	be	AUX
cjal-3338	455	24	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	455	25	actual	actual	ADJ
cjal-3338	455	26	basis	basis	NOUN
cjal-3338	455	27	on	on	ADP
cjal-3338	455	28	which	which	PRON
cjal-3338	455	29	he	he	PRON
cjal-3338	455	30	developed	develop	VERB
cjal-3338	455	31	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	455	32	accused	accuse	VERB
cjal-3338	455	33	device	device	NOUN
cjal-3338	455	34	or	or	CCONJ
cjal-3338	455	35	acts	act	NOUN
cjal-3338	455	36	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	456	1	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	456	2	intellectual	intellectual	ADJ
cjal-3338	456	3	distance	distance	NOUN
cjal-3338	456	4	between	between	ADP
cjal-3338	456	5	these	these	DET
cjal-3338	456	6	pieces	piece	NOUN
cjal-3338	456	7	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	456	8	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	456	9	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	456	10	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	456	11	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	456	12	accused	accuse	VERB
cjal-3338	456	13	device	device	NOUN
cjal-3338	456	14	or	or	CCONJ
cjal-3338	456	15	acts	act	NOUN
cjal-3338	456	16	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	456	17	something	something	PRON
cjal-3338	456	18	that	that	PRON
cjal-3338	456	19	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	456	20	defendant	defendant	NOUN
cjal-3338	456	21	himself	himself	PRON
cjal-3338	456	22	can	can	AUX
cjal-3338	456	23	explain	explain	VERB
cjal-3338	456	24	to	to	ADP
cjal-3338	456	25	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	456	26	court	court	NOUN
cjal-3338	456	27	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	456	28	which	which	PRON
cjal-3338	456	29	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	456	30	court	court	NOUN
cjal-3338	456	31	can	can	AUX
cjal-3338	456	32	evaluate	evaluate	VERB
cjal-3338	456	33	for	for	ADP
cjal-3338	456	34	credibility	credibility	NOUN
cjal-3338	456	35	or	or	CCONJ
cjal-3338	456	36	for	for	ADP
cjal-3338	456	37	compliance	compliance	NOUN
cjal-3338	456	38	with	with	ADP
cjal-3338	456	39	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	456	40	legal	legal	ADJ
cjal-3338	456	41	standards	standard	NOUN
cjal-3338	456	42	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	457	1	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	457	2	contrast	contrast	NOUN
cjal-3338	457	3	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	457	4	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	457	5	intellectual	intellectual	ADJ
cjal-3338	457	6	distance	distance	NOUN
cjal-3338	457	7	between	between	ADP
cjal-3338	457	8	pieces	piece	NOUN
cjal-3338	457	9	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	457	10	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	457	11	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	457	12	cited	cite	VERB
cjal-3338	457	13	against	against	ADP
cjal-3338	457	14	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	457	15	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	457	16	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	457	17	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	457	18	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	457	19	itself	itself	PRON
cjal-3338	457	20	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	457	21	likely	likely	ADJ
cjal-3338	457	22	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	457	23	be	be	AUX
cjal-3338	457	24	significantly	significantly	ADV
cjal-3338	457	25	greater	great	ADJ
cjal-3338	457	26	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	458	1	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	458	2	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	458	3	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	458	4	cited	cite	VERB
cjal-3338	458	5	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	458	6	unlikely	unlikely	ADJ
cjal-3338	458	7	something	something	PRON
cjal-3338	458	8	that	that	PRON
cjal-3338	458	9	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	458	10	patentee	patentee	NOUN
cjal-3338	458	11	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	458	12	aware	aware	ADJ
cjal-3338	458	13	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	458	14	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	458	15	much	much	ADV
cjal-3338	458	16	less	less	ADJ
cjal-3338	458	17	something	something	PRON
cjal-3338	458	18	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	458	19	patentee	patentee	NOUN
cjal-3338	458	20	based	base	VERB
cjal-3338	458	21	his	his	PRON
cjal-3338	458	22	invention	invention	NOUN
cjal-3338	458	23	on	on	ADP
cjal-3338	458	24	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	459	1	there	there	PRON
cjal-3338	459	2	will	will	AUX
cjal-3338	459	3	necessarily	necessarily	ADV
cjal-3338	459	4	exist	exist	VERB
cjal-3338	459	5	incompatibilities	incompatibility	NOUN
cjal-3338	459	6	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	459	7	such	such	ADJ
cjal-3338	459	8	as	as	ADP
cjal-3338	459	9	differences	difference	NOUN
cjal-3338	459	10	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	459	11	terminology	terminology	NOUN
cjal-3338	459	12	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	459	13	implementation	implementation	NOUN
cjal-3338	459	14	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	459	15	or	or	CCONJ
cjal-3338	459	16	conceptualization	conceptualization	NOUN
cjal-3338	459	17	that	that	PRON
cjal-3338	459	18	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	459	19	court	court	NOUN
cjal-3338	459	20	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	459	21	asked	ask	VERB
cjal-3338	459	22	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	459	23	bridge	bridge	VERB
cjal-3338	459	24	when	when	SCONJ
cjal-3338	459	25	evaluating	evaluate	VERB
cjal-3338	459	26	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	459	27	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	459	28	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	459	29	invalidity	invalidity	NOUN
cjal-3338	459	30	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	459	31	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	460	1	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	460	2	amount	amount	NOUN
cjal-3338	460	3	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	460	4	mental	mental	ADJ
cjal-3338	460	5	gymnastics	gymnastic	NOUN
cjal-3338	460	6	required	require	VERB
cjal-3338	460	7	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	460	8	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	460	9	court	court	NOUN
cjal-3338	460	10	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	460	11	most	most	ADV
cjal-3338	460	12	likely	likely	ADV
cjal-3338	460	13	not	not	PART
cjal-3338	460	14	trained	train	VERB
cjal-3338	460	15	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	460	16	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	460	17	technical	technical	ADJ
cjal-3338	460	18	arts	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	460	19	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	460	20	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	460	21	therefore	therefore	ADV
cjal-3338	460	22	significantly	significantly	ADV
cjal-3338	460	23	higher	high	ADJ
cjal-3338	460	24	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	460	25	adjudicating	adjudicate	VERB
cjal-3338	460	26	an	an	DET
cjal-3338	460	27	invalidity	invalidity	NOUN
cjal-3338	460	28	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	460	29	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	461	1	it	it	PRON
cjal-3338	461	2	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	461	3	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	461	4	fundamental	fundamental	ADJ
cjal-3338	461	5	principle	principle	NOUN
cjal-3338	461	6	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	461	7	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	461	8	law	law	NOUN
cjal-3338	461	9	that	that	PRON
cjal-3338	461	10	no	no	DET
cjal-3338	461	11	one	one	NOUN
cjal-3338	461	12	can	can	AUX
cjal-3338	461	13	infringe	infringe	VERB
cjal-3338	461	14	by	by	ADP
cjal-3338	461	15	practicing	practice	VERB
cjal-3338	461	16	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	461	17	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	461	18	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	461	19	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	462	1	there	there	PRON
cjal-3338	462	2	is	be	VERB
cjal-3338	462	3	no	no	DET
cjal-3338	462	4	reason	reason	NOUN
cjal-3338	462	5	not	not	PART
cjal-3338	462	6	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	462	7	'	'	PUNCT
cjal-3338	462	8	allow	allow	VERB
cjal-3338	462	9	courts	court	NOUN
cjal-3338	462	10	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	462	11	dispose	dispose	VERB
cjal-3338	462	12	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	462	13	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	462	14	cases	case	NOUN
cjal-3338	462	15	on	on	ADP
cjal-3338	462	16	this	this	DET
cjal-3338	462	17	easy	easy	ADJ
cjal-3338	462	18	ground	ground	NOUN
cjal-3338	462	19	when	when	SCONJ
cjal-3338	462	20	it	it	PRON
cjal-3338	462	21	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	462	22	not	not	PART
cjal-3338	462	23	conceptually	conceptually	ADV
cjal-3338	462	24	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	462	25	conflict	conflict	NOUN
cjal-3338	462	26	with	with	ADP
cjal-3338	462	27	first	first	ADJ
cjal-3338	462	28	principles	principle	NOUN
cjal-3338	462	29	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	463	1	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	463	2	successful	successful	ADJ
cjal-3338	463	3	practicing	practice	VERB
cjal-3338	463	4	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	463	5	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	463	6	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	463	7	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	463	8	also	also	ADV
cjal-3338	463	9	dispenses	dispense	VERB
cjal-3338	463	10	with	with	ADP
cjal-3338	463	11	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	463	12	need	need	NOUN
cjal-3338	463	13	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	463	14	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	463	15	court	court	NOUN
cjal-3338	463	16	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	463	17	understand	understand	VERB
cjal-3338	463	18	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	463	19	asserted	assert	VERB
cjal-3338	463	20	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	463	21	at	at	ADV
cjal-3338	463	22	all	all	ADV
cjal-3338	463	23	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	464	1	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	464	2	primary	primary	ADJ
cjal-3338	464	3	benefit	benefit	NOUN
cjal-3338	464	4	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	464	5	that	that	SCONJ
cjal-3338	464	6	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	464	7	court	court	NOUN
cjal-3338	464	8	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	464	9	saved	save	VERB
cjal-3338	464	10	from	from	ADP
cjal-3338	464	11	claim	claim	NOUN
cjal-3338	464	12	construction	construction	NOUN
cjal-3338	464	13	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	465	1	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	465	2	problems	problem	NOUN
cjal-3338	465	3	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	465	4	claim	claim	NOUN
cjal-3338	465	5	construction	construction	NOUN
cjal-3338	465	6	are	be	AUX
cjal-3338	465	7	well	well	ADV
cjal-3338	465	8	known	know	VERB
cjal-3338	465	9	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	466	1	as	as	ADP
cjal-3338	466	2	dan	dan	PROPN
cjal-3338	466	3	burk	burk	PROPN
cjal-3338	466	4	summarizes	summarizes	PROPN
cjal-3338	466	5	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	466	6	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	466	7	law	law	NOUN
cjal-3338	466	8	has	have	AUX
cjal-3338	466	9	provided	provide	VERB
cjal-3338	466	10	none	none	NOUN
cjal-3338	466	11	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	466	12	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	466	13	certainty	certainty	NOUN
cjal-3338	466	14	associated	associate	VERB
cjal-3338	466	15	with	with	ADP
cjal-3338	466	16	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	466	17	definition	definition	NOUN
cjal-3338	466	18	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	466	19	boundaries	boundary	NOUN
cjal-3338	466	20	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	466	21	real	real	ADJ
cjal-3338	466	22	property	property	NOUN
cjal-3338	466	23	law	law	NOUN
cjal-3338	466	24	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	467	1	literally	literally	ADV
cjal-3338	467	2	every	every	DET
cjal-3338	467	3	case	case	NOUN
cjal-3338	467	4	involves	involve	VERB
cjal-3338	467	5	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	467	6	fight	fight	NOUN
cjal-3338	467	7	over	over	ADP
cjal-3338	467	8	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	467	9	meaning	meaning	NOUN
cjal-3338	467	10	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	467	11	multiple	multiple	ADJ
cjal-3338	467	12	terms	term	NOUN
cjal-3338	467	13	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	467	14	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	467	15	not	not	PART
cjal-3338	467	16	just	just	ADV
cjal-3338	467	17	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	467	18	complex	complex	ADJ
cjal-3338	467	19	technical	technical	ADJ
cjal-3338	467	20	ones	one	NOUN
cjal-3338	467	21	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	468	1	recent	recent	ADJ
cjal-3338	468	2	federal	federal	ADJ
cjal-3338	468	3	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cjal-3338	468	4	cases	case	NOUN
cjal-3338	468	5	have	have	AUX
cjal-3338	468	6	had	have	VERB
cjal-3338	468	7	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	468	8	decide	decide	VERB
cjal-3338	468	9	plausible	plausible	ADJ
cjal-3338	468	10	disagreements	disagreement	NOUN
cjal-3338	468	11	over	over	ADP
cjal-3338	468	12	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	468	13	meanings	meaning	NOUN
cjal-3338	468	14	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	468	15	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	468	16	words	word	NOUN
cjal-3338	468	17	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	468	18	a	a	PRON
cjal-3338	468	19	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	468	20	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	468	21	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	468	22	or	or	CCONJ
cjal-3338	468	23	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	468	24	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	468	25	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	468	26	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	468	27	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	468	28	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	468	29	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	468	30	including	include	VERB
cjal-3338	468	31	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	468	32	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	468	33	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	468	34	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	468	35	through	through	ADP
cjal-3338	468	36	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	468	37	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	468	38	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	468	39	name	name	VERB
cjal-3338	468	40	but	but	CCONJ
cjal-3338	468	41	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	468	42	few	few	ADJ
cjal-3338	468	43	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	469	1	claim	claim	NOUN
cjal-3338	469	2	construction	construction	NOUN
cjal-3338	469	3	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	469	4	sufficiently	sufficiently	ADV
cjal-3338	469	5	uncertain	uncertain	ADJ
cjal-3338	469	6	that	that	SCONJ
cjal-3338	469	7	many	many	ADJ
cjal-3338	469	8	parties	party	NOUN
cjal-3338	469	9	do	do	AUX
cjal-3338	469	10	n't	not	PART
cjal-3338	469	11	settle	settle	VERB
cjal-3338	469	12	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	469	13	case	case	NOUN
cjal-3338	469	14	until	until	SCONJ
cjal-3338	469	15	after	after	SCONJ
cjal-3338	469	16	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	469	17	court	court	NOUN
cjal-3338	469	18	has	have	AUX
cjal-3338	469	19	construed	construe	VERB
cjal-3338	469	20	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	469	21	claims	claim	NOUN
cjal-3338	469	22	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	469	23	because	because	SCONJ
cjal-3338	469	24	there	there	PRON
cjal-3338	469	25	is	be	VERB
cjal-3338	469	26	no	no	DET
cjal-3338	469	27	baseline	baseline	NOUN
cjal-3338	469	28	for	for	ADP
cjal-3338	469	29	agreement	agreement	NOUN
cjal-3338	469	30	on	on	ADP
cjal-3338	469	31	what	what	PRON
cjal-3338	469	32	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	469	33	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	469	34	might	might	AUX
cjal-3338	469	35	possibly	possibly	ADV
cjal-3338	469	36	cover	cover	VERB
cjal-3338	469	37	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	470	1	even	even	ADV
cjal-3338	470	2	after	after	ADP
cjal-3338	470	3	claim	claim	NOUN
cjal-3338	470	4	construction	construction	NOUN
cjal-3338	470	5	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	470	6	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	470	7	meaning	meaning	NOUN
cjal-3338	470	8	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	470	9	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	470	10	claims	claim	NOUN
cjal-3338	470	11	remains	remain	VERB
cjal-3338	470	12	uncertain	uncertain	ADJ
cjal-3338	470	13	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	470	14	not	not	PART
cjal-3338	470	15	only	only	ADV
cjal-3338	470	16	because	because	SCONJ
cjal-3338	470	17	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	470	18	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	470	19	very	very	ADV
cjal-3338	470	20	real	real	ADJ
cjal-3338	470	21	prospect	prospect	NOUN
cjal-3338	470	22	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	470	23	reversal	reversal	NOUN
cjal-3338	470	24	on	on	ADP
cjal-3338	470	25	appeal	appeal	NOUN
cjal-3338	470	26	but	but	CCONJ
cjal-3338	470	27	also	also	ADV
cjal-3338	470	28	because	because	SCONJ
cjal-3338	470	29	lawyers	lawyer	NOUN
cjal-3338	470	30	immediately	immediately	ADV
cjal-3338	470	31	begin	begin	VERB
cjal-3338	470	32	fighting	fight	VERB
cjal-3338	470	33	about	about	ADP
cjal-3338	470	34	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	470	35	meaning	meaning	NOUN
cjal-3338	470	36	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	470	37	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	470	38	words	word	NOUN
cjal-3338	470	39	used	use	VERB
cjal-3338	470	40	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	470	41	construe	construe	VERB
cjal-3338	470	42	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	470	43	words	word	NOUN
cjal-3338	470	44	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	470	45	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	470	46	claims.6	claims.6	PROPN
cjal-3338	470	47	1	1	NUM
cjal-3338	470	48	there	there	PRON
cjal-3338	470	49	is	be	VERB
cjal-3338	470	50	no	no	DET
cjal-3338	470	51	clearer	clear	ADJ
cjal-3338	470	52	sign	sign	NOUN
cjal-3338	470	53	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	470	54	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	470	55	practical	practical	ADJ
cjal-3338	470	56	difficulties	difficulty	NOUN
cjal-3338	470	57	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	470	58	claim	claim	NOUN
cjal-3338	470	59	construction	construction	NOUN
cjal-3338	470	60	than	than	ADP
cjal-3338	470	61	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	470	62	existence	existence	NOUN
cjal-3338	470	63	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	470	64	doctrines	doctrine	NOUN
cjal-3338	470	65	from	from	ADP
cjal-3338	470	66	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	470	67	federal	federal	ADJ
cjal-3338	470	68	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cjal-3338	470	69	concerning	concern	VERB
cjal-3338	470	70	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	470	71	construction	construction	NOUN
cjal-3338	470	72	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	470	73	claim	claim	NOUN
cjal-3338	470	74	constructions	construction	NOUN
cjal-3338	470	75	devised	devise	VERB
cjal-3338	470	76	by	by	ADP
cjal-3338	470	77	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	470	78	district	district	NOUN
cjal-3338	470	79	courts	court	NOUN
cjal-3338	470	80	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	471	1	62	62	NUM
cjal-3338	471	2	all	all	PRON
cjal-3338	471	3	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	471	4	this	this	PRON
cjal-3338	471	5	does	do	AUX
cjal-3338	471	6	not	not	PART
cjal-3338	471	7	improve	improve	VERB
cjal-3338	471	8	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	471	9	quality	quality	NOUN
cjal-3338	471	10	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	471	11	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	471	12	adjudication	adjudication	NOUN
cjal-3338	471	13	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	471	14	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	471	15	if	if	SCONJ
cjal-3338	471	16	anything	anything	PRON
cjal-3338	471	17	harms	harm	VERB
cjal-3338	471	18	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	471	19	dignity	dignity	NOUN
cjal-3338	471	20	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	471	21	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	471	22	courts	court	NOUN
cjal-3338	471	23	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	472	1	courts	court	NOUN
cjal-3338	472	2	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	472	3	litigants	litigant	NOUN
cjal-3338	472	4	simply	simply	ADV
cjal-3338	472	5	should	should	AUX
cjal-3338	472	6	not	not	PART
cjal-3338	472	7	be	be	AUX
cjal-3338	472	8	required	require	VERB
cjal-3338	472	9	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	472	10	invest	invest	VERB
cjal-3338	472	11	time	time	NOUN
cjal-3338	472	12	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	472	13	attention	attention	NOUN
cjal-3338	472	14	battling	battle	VERB
cjal-3338	472	15	over	over	ADP
cjal-3338	472	16	words	word	NOUN
cjal-3338	472	17	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	472	18	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	472	19	claim	claim	NOUN
cjal-3338	472	20	if	if	SCONJ
cjal-3338	472	21	there	there	PRON
cjal-3338	472	22	can	can	AUX
cjal-3338	472	23	be	be	AUX
cjal-3338	472	24	other	other	ADJ
cjal-3338	472	25	6	6	NUM
cjal-3338	472	26	'	'	PUNCT
cjal-3338	472	27	dan	dan	PROPN
cjal-3338	472	28	l.	l.	PROPN
cjal-3338	472	29	burk	burk	PROPN
cjal-3338	472	30	&	&	CCONJ
cjal-3338	472	31	mark	mark	PROPN
cjal-3338	472	32	a.	a.	PROPN
cjal-3338	472	33	lemley	lemley	PROPN
cjal-3338	472	34	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	472	35	fence	fence	NOUN
cjal-3338	472	36	posts	post	NOUN
cjal-3338	472	37	or	or	CCONJ
cjal-3338	472	38	sign	sign	VERB
cjal-3338	472	39	posts	post	NOUN
cjal-3338	472	40	?	?	PUNCT
cjal-3338	473	1	rethinking	rethink	VERB
cjal-3338	473	2	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	473	3	claim	claim	NOUN
cjal-3338	473	4	construction	construction	NOUN
cjal-3338	473	5	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	473	6	157	157	NUM
cjal-3338	473	7	u.	u.	NOUN
cjal-3338	473	8	pa	pa	PROPN
cjal-3338	473	9	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	473	10	l.	l.	PROPN
cjal-3338	473	11	rev	rev	PROPN
cjal-3338	473	12	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	473	13	1743	1743	NUM
cjal-3338	473	14	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	473	15	1744	1744	NUM
cjal-3338	473	16	-	-	SYM
cjal-3338	473	17	1745	1745	NUM
cjal-3338	473	18	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	473	19	2009	2009	NUM
cjal-3338	473	20	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	473	21	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	473	22	citation	citation	NOUN
cjal-3338	473	23	omitted	omit	VERB
cjal-3338	473	24	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	473	25	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	474	1	6	6	NUM
cjal-3338	474	2	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	474	3	cordis	cordis	PROPN
cjal-3338	474	4	corp	corp	PROPN
cjal-3338	474	5	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	474	6	v.	v.	PROPN
cjal-3338	474	7	boston	boston	PROPN
cjal-3338	474	8	sci	sci	PROPN
cjal-3338	474	9	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	474	10	corp	corp	PROPN
cjal-3338	474	11	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	474	12	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	474	13	658	658	NUM
cjal-3338	474	14	f.3d	f.3d	NUM
cjal-3338	474	15	1347	1347	NUM
cjal-3338	474	16	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	474	17	1356	1356	NUM
cjal-3338	474	18	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	474	19	fed	fed	PROPN
cjal-3338	474	20	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	474	21	cir	cir	PROPN
cjal-3338	474	22	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	474	23	2011	2011	NUM
cjal-3338	474	24	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	474	25	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	475	1	defensive	defensive	ADJ
cjal-3338	475	2	use	use	NOUN
cjal-3338	475	3	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	475	4	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	475	5	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	475	6	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	475	7	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cjal-3338	475	8	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	475	9	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	475	10	chinese	chinese	ADJ
cjal-3338	475	11	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	475	12	litigation	litigation	NOUN
cjal-3338	475	13	75	75	NUM
cjal-3338	475	14	ways	way	NOUN
cjal-3338	475	15	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	475	16	adjudicating	adjudicate	VERB
cjal-3338	475	17	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	475	18	merits	merit	NOUN
cjal-3338	475	19	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	475	20	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	475	21	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	475	22	case	case	NOUN
cjal-3338	475	23	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	476	1	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	476	2	practicing	practice	VERB
cjal-3338	476	3	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	476	4	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	476	5	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	476	6	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	476	7	could	could	AUX
cjal-3338	476	8	improve	improve	VERB
cjal-3338	476	9	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	476	10	current	current	ADJ
cjal-3338	476	11	state	state	NOUN
cjal-3338	476	12	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	476	13	affairs	affair	NOUN
cjal-3338	476	14	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	477	1	d.	d.	PROPN
cjal-3338	477	2	has	have	VERB
cjal-3338	477	3	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	477	4	chinese	chinese	PROPN
cjal-3338	477	5	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	477	6	law	law	NOUN
cjal-3338	477	7	structured	structure	VERB
cjal-3338	477	8	its	its	PRON
cjal-3338	477	9	existing	exist	VERB
cjal-3338	477	10	technology	technology	NOUN
cjal-3338	477	11	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	477	12	well	well	ADV
cjal-3338	477	13	?	?	PUNCT
cjal-3338	478	1	having	having	AUX
cjal-3338	478	2	concluded	conclude	VERB
cjal-3338	478	3	that	that	SCONJ
cjal-3338	478	4	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	478	5	united	united	PROPN
cjal-3338	478	6	states	states	PROPN
cjal-3338	478	7	would	would	AUX
cjal-3338	478	8	benefit	benefit	VERB
cjal-3338	478	9	from	from	ADP
cjal-3338	478	10	an	an	DET
cjal-3338	478	11	introduction	introduction	NOUN
cjal-3338	478	12	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	478	13	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	478	14	practicing	practice	VERB
cjal-3338	478	15	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	478	16	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	478	17	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	478	18	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	478	19	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	478	20	we	we	PRON
cjal-3338	478	21	turn	turn	VERB
cjal-3338	478	22	our	our	PRON
cjal-3338	478	23	attention	attention	NOUN
cjal-3338	478	24	to	to	ADP
cjal-3338	478	25	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	478	26	chinese	chinese	ADJ
cjal-3338	478	27	implementation	implementation	NOUN
cjal-3338	478	28	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	478	29	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	478	30	existing	exist	VERB
cjal-3338	478	31	technology	technology	NOUN
cjal-3338	478	32	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	478	33	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	478	34	analyze	analyze	VERB
cjal-3338	478	35	its	its	PRON
cjal-3338	478	36	merits	merit	NOUN
cjal-3338	478	37	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	479	1	being	be	AUX
cjal-3338	479	2	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	479	3	doctrine	doctrine	NOUN
cjal-3338	479	4	that	that	PRON
cjal-3338	479	5	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	479	6	involved	involve	VERB
cjal-3338	479	7	with	with	ADP
cjal-3338	479	8	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	479	9	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	479	10	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	479	11	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	479	12	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	479	13	existing	exist	VERB
cjal-3338	479	14	technology	technology	NOUN
cjal-3338	479	15	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	479	16	should	should	AUX
cjal-3338	479	17	be	be	AUX
cjal-3338	479	18	connected	connect	VERB
cjal-3338	479	19	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	479	20	some	some	DET
cjal-3338	479	21	way	way	NOUN
cjal-3338	479	22	with	with	ADP
cjal-3338	479	23	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	479	24	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	479	25	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	479	26	invalidity	invalidity	NOUN
cjal-3338	479	27	doctrines	doctrine	NOUN
cjal-3338	479	28	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	480	1	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	480	2	as	as	SCONJ
cjal-3338	480	3	we	we	PRON
cjal-3338	480	4	have	have	AUX
cjal-3338	480	5	concluded	conclude	VERB
cjal-3338	480	6	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	480	7	our	our	PRON
cjal-3338	480	8	earlier	early	ADJ
cjal-3338	480	9	article	article	NOUN
cjal-3338	480	10	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	480	11	there	there	PRON
cjal-3338	480	12	ought	ought	AUX
cjal-3338	480	13	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	480	14	be	be	AUX
cjal-3338	480	15	links	link	NOUN
cjal-3338	480	16	between	between	ADP
cjal-3338	480	17	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	480	18	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	480	19	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	480	20	invalidity	invalidity	NOUN
cjal-3338	480	21	doctrines	doctrine	NOUN
cjal-3338	480	22	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	480	23	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	480	24	infringement	infringement	NOUN
cjal-3338	480	25	doctrines	doctrine	NOUN
cjal-3338	480	26	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	481	1	there	there	PRON
cjal-3338	481	2	are	be	VERB
cjal-3338	481	3	therefore	therefore	ADV
cjal-3338	481	4	several	several	ADJ
cjal-3338	481	5	possibilities	possibility	NOUN
cjal-3338	481	6	that	that	PRON
cjal-3338	481	7	chinese	chinese	ADJ
cjal-3338	481	8	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	481	9	law	law	NOUN
cjal-3338	481	10	could	could	AUX
cjal-3338	481	11	take	take	VERB
cjal-3338	481	12	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	481	13	structure	structure	VERB
cjal-3338	481	14	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	481	15	existing	exist	VERB
cjal-3338	481	16	technology	technology	NOUN
cjal-3338	481	17	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	481	18	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	482	1	as	as	SCONJ
cjal-3338	482	2	we	we	PRON
cjal-3338	482	3	have	have	AUX
cjal-3338	482	4	seen	see	VERB
cjal-3338	482	5	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	482	6	china	china	PROPN
cjal-3338	482	7	environmental	environmental	PROPN
cjal-3338	482	8	project	project	PROPN
cjal-3338	482	9	technology	technology	NOUN
cjal-3338	482	10	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	482	11	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	482	12	supreme	supreme	PROPN
cjal-3338	482	13	people	people	PROPN
cjal-3338	482	14	's	's	PART
cjal-3338	482	15	court	court	NOUN
cjal-3338	482	16	requires	require	VERB
cjal-3338	482	17	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	482	18	defendant	defendant	NOUN
cjal-3338	482	19	who	who	PRON
cjal-3338	482	20	asserts	assert	VERB
cjal-3338	482	21	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	482	22	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	482	23	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	482	24	demonstrate	demonstrate	VERB
cjal-3338	482	25	that	that	SCONJ
cjal-3338	482	26	he	he	PRON
cjal-3338	482	27	has	have	AUX
cjal-3338	482	28	not	not	PART
cjal-3338	482	29	exceeded	exceed	VERB
cjal-3338	482	30	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	482	31	range	range	NOUN
cjal-3338	482	32	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	482	33	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	482	34	triple	triple	ADJ
cjal-3338	482	35	identity	identity	NOUN
cjal-3338	482	36	test	test	NOUN
cjal-3338	482	37	from'the	from'the	DET
cjal-3338	482	38	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	482	39	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	482	40	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	482	41	that	that	SCONJ
cjal-3338	482	42	he	he	PRON
cjal-3338	482	43	has	have	AUX
cjal-3338	482	44	not	not	PART
cjal-3338	482	45	performed	perform	VERB
cjal-3338	482	46	inventive	inventive	ADJ
cjal-3338	482	47	labor	labor	NOUN
cjal-3338	482	48	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	482	49	obtaining	obtain	VERB
cjal-3338	482	50	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	482	51	accused	accuse	VERB
cjal-3338	482	52	device	device	NOUN
cjal-3338	482	53	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	482	54	acts	act	NOUN
cjal-3338	482	55	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	483	1	63	63	NUM
cjal-3338	483	2	this	this	PRON
cjal-3338	483	3	gives	give	VERB
cjal-3338	483	4	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	483	5	existing	exist	VERB
cjal-3338	483	6	technology	technology	NOUN
cjal-3338	483	7	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	483	8	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	483	9	exact	exact	ADJ
cjal-3338	483	10	same	same	ADJ
cjal-3338	483	11	range	range	NOUN
cjal-3338	483	12	around	around	ADP
cjal-3338	483	13	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	483	14	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	483	15	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	483	16	as	as	ADP
cjal-3338	483	17	equivalence	equivalence	NOUN
cjal-3338	483	18	possesses	possess	VERB
cjal-3338	483	19	around	around	ADP
cjal-3338	483	20	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	483	21	asserted	asserted	ADJ
cjal-3338	483	22	claim	claim	NOUN
cjal-3338	483	23	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	484	1	it	it	PRON
cjal-3338	484	2	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	484	3	easy	easy	ADJ
cjal-3338	484	4	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	484	5	understand	understand	VERB
cjal-3338	484	6	why	why	SCONJ
cjal-3338	484	7	chinese	chinese	ADJ
cjal-3338	484	8	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	484	9	law	law	NOUN
cjal-3338	484	10	hitches	hitch	VERB
cjal-3338	484	11	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	484	12	existing	exist	VERB
cjal-3338	484	13	technology	technology	NOUN
cjal-3338	484	14	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	484	15	with	with	ADP
cjal-3338	484	16	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	484	17	doctrines	doctrine	NOUN
cjal-3338	484	18	that	that	PRON
cjal-3338	484	19	extend	extend	VERB
cjal-3338	484	20	from	from	ADP
cjal-3338	484	21	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	484	22	core	core	NOUN
cjal-3338	484	23	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	484	24	inventiveness	inventiveness	NOUN
cjal-3338	484	25	or	or	CCONJ
cjal-3338	484	26	equivalence	equivalence	NOUN
cjal-3338	484	27	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	484	28	as	as	SCONJ
cjal-3338	484	29	opposed	oppose	VERB
cjal-3338	484	30	to	to	ADP
cjal-3338	484	31	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	484	32	doctrines	doctrine	NOUN
cjal-3338	484	33	protecting	protect	VERB
cjal-3338	484	34	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	484	35	core	core	NOUN
cjal-3338	484	36	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	484	37	novelty	novelty	NOUN
cjal-3338	484	38	or	or	CCONJ
cjal-3338	484	39	literality	literality	NOUN
cjal-3338	484	40	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	485	1	rare	rare	ADJ
cjal-3338	485	2	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	485	3	it	it	PRON
cjal-3338	485	4	that	that	SCONJ
cjal-3338	485	5	someone	someone	PRON
cjal-3338	485	6	introduces	introduce	VERB
cjal-3338	485	7	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	485	8	product	product	NOUN
cjal-3338	485	9	into	into	ADP
cjal-3338	485	10	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	485	11	market	market	NOUN
cjal-3338	485	12	that	that	PRON
cjal-3338	485	13	exactly	exactly	ADV
cjal-3338	485	14	practices	practice	VERB
cjal-3338	485	15	what	what	PRON
cjal-3338	485	16	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	485	17	disclosed	disclose	VERB
cjal-3338	485	18	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	485	19	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	485	20	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	485	21	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	485	22	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	485	23	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	485	24	rarer	rarer	ADV
cjal-3338	485	25	still	still	ADV
cjal-3338	485	26	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	485	27	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	485	28	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
cjal-3338	485	29	who	who	PRON
cjal-3338	485	30	wastes	waste	VERB
cjal-3338	485	31	money	money	NOUN
cjal-3338	485	32	litigating	litigate	VERB
cjal-3338	485	33	against	against	ADP
cjal-3338	485	34	such	such	DET
cjal-3338	485	35	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	485	36	defendant	defendant	NOUN
cjal-3338	485	37	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	486	1	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	486	2	make	make	VERB
cjal-3338	486	3	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	486	4	existing	exist	VERB
cjal-3338	486	5	technology	technology	NOUN
cjal-3338	486	6	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	486	7	meaningful	meaningful	ADJ
cjal-3338	486	8	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	486	9	such	such	ADJ
cjal-3338	486	10	as	as	ADP
cjal-3338	486	11	allowing	allow	VERB
cjal-3338	486	12	it	it	PRON
cjal-3338	486	13	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	486	14	be	be	AUX
cjal-3338	486	15	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	486	16	guide	guide	NOUN
cjal-3338	486	17	through	through	ADP
cjal-3338	486	18	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	486	19	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	486	20	thicket	thicket	NOUN
cjal-3338	486	21	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	486	22	there	there	PRON
cjal-3338	486	23	has	have	VERB
cjal-3338	486	24	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	486	25	be	be	AUX
cjal-3338	486	26	some	some	DET
cjal-3338	486	27	latitude	latitude	NOUN
cjal-3338	486	28	for	for	ADP
cjal-3338	486	29	defendants	defendant	NOUN
cjal-3338	486	30	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	486	31	practice	practice	VERB
cjal-3338	486	32	some	some	DET
cjal-3338	486	33	distance	distance	NOUN
cjal-3338	486	34	away	away	ADV
cjal-3338	486	35	from	from	ADP
cjal-3338	486	36	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	486	37	core	core	NOUN
cjal-3338	486	38	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	486	39	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	486	40	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	486	41	art.6	art.6	PROPN
cjal-3338	486	42	63	63	NUM
cjal-3338	486	43	china	china	PROPN
cjal-3338	486	44	env't	env't	PROPN
cjal-3338	486	45	project	project	NOUN
cjal-3338	486	46	tech	tech	PROPN
cjal-3338	486	47	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	486	48	inc	inc	PROPN
cjal-3338	486	49	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	487	1	v.	v.	PROPN
cjal-3338	487	2	huayang	huayang	PROPN
cjal-3338	487	3	elec	elec	PROPN
cjal-3338	487	4	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	487	5	power	power	PROPN
cjal-3338	487	6	co.	co.	PROPN
cjal-3338	487	7	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	487	8	supra	supra	PROPN
cjal-3338	487	9	note	note	PROPN
cjal-3338	487	10	38	38	NUM
cjal-3338	487	11	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	488	1	64	64	NUM
cjal-3338	488	2	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	488	3	helpful	helpful	ADJ
cjal-3338	488	4	comparison	comparison	NOUN
cjal-3338	488	5	may	may	AUX
cjal-3338	488	6	be	be	AUX
cjal-3338	488	7	drawn	draw	VERB
cjal-3338	488	8	to	to	ADP
cjal-3338	488	9	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	488	10	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cjal-3338	488	11	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	488	12	practicing	practice	VERB
cjal-3338	488	13	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	488	14	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	488	15	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	488	16	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	488	17	to	to	ADP
cjal-3338	488	18	equivalents	equivalent	NOUN
cjal-3338	488	19	infringement	infringement	NOUN
cjal-3338	488	20	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	489	1	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	489	2	federal	federal	ADJ
cjal-3338	489	3	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cjal-3338	489	4	has	have	AUX
cjal-3338	489	5	explicitly	explicitly	ADV
cjal-3338	489	6	connected	connect	VERB
cjal-3338	489	7	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	489	8	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	489	9	to	to	ADP
cjal-3338	489	10	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	489	11	invalidity	invalidity	NOUN
cjal-3338	489	12	doctrines	doctrine	NOUN
cjal-3338	489	13	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	489	14	not	not	PART
cjal-3338	489	15	to	to	ADP
cjal-3338	489	16	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	489	17	infringement	infringement	NOUN
cjal-3338	489	18	doctrines	doctrine	NOUN
cjal-3338	489	19	as	as	ADP
cjal-3338	489	20	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	489	21	chinese	chinese	ADJ
cjal-3338	489	22	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	489	23	law	law	NOUN
cjal-3338	489	24	:	:	PUNCT
cjal-3338	489	25	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	489	26	helpful	helpful	ADJ
cjal-3338	489	27	first	first	ADJ
cjal-3338	489	28	step	step	NOUN
cjal-3338	489	29	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	489	30	an	an	DET
cjal-3338	489	31	ensnarement	ensnarement	NOUN
cjal-3338	489	32	analysis	analysis	NOUN
cjal-3338	489	33	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	489	34	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	489	35	construct	construct	VERB
cjal-3338	489	36	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	489	37	hypothetical	hypothetical	ADJ
cjal-3338	489	38	claim	claim	NOUN
cjal-3338	489	39	that	that	SCONJ
cjal-3338	489	40	literally	literally	ADV
cjal-3338	489	41	covers	cover	VERB
cjal-3338	489	42	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	489	43	accused	accuse	VERB
cjal-3338	489	44	device	device	NOUN
cjal-3338	489	45	....	....	PUNCT
cjal-3338	490	1	next	next	ADV
cjal-3338	490	2	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	490	3	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	490	4	district	district	NOUN
cjal-3338	490	5	court	court	NOUN
cjal-3338	490	6	must	must	AUX
cjal-3338	490	7	assess	assess	VERB
cjal-3338	490	8	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	490	9	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	490	10	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	490	11	introduced	introduce	VERB
cjal-3338	490	12	by	by	ADP
cjal-3338	490	13	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	490	14	accused	accuse	VERB
cjal-3338	490	15	infringer	infringer	NOUN
cjal-3338	490	16	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	490	17	determine	determine	VERB
cjal-3338	490	18	whether	whether	SCONJ
cjal-3338	490	19	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	490	20	patentee	patentee	NOUN
cjal-3338	490	21	has	have	AUX
cjal-3338	490	22	carried	carry	VERB
cjal-3338	490	23	its	its	PRON
cjal-3338	490	24	burden	burden	NOUN
cjal-3338	490	25	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	490	26	persuading	persuade	VERB
cjal-3338	490	27	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	490	28	court	court	NOUN
cjal-3338	490	29	that	that	SCONJ
cjal-3338	490	30	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	490	31	hypothetical	hypothetical	ADJ
cjal-3338	490	32	claim	claim	NOUN
cjal-3338	490	33	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	490	34	patentable	patentable	ADJ
cjal-3338	490	35	over	over	ADP
cjal-3338	490	36	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	490	37	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	490	38	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	490	39	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	491	1	ultimately	ultimately	ADV
cjal-3338	491	2	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	491	3	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	491	4	[	[	X
cjal-3338	491	5	i]f	i]f	ADP
cjal-3338	491	6	such	such	DET
cjal-3338	491	7	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	491	8	claim	claim	NOUN
cjal-3338	491	9	would	would	AUX
cjal-3338	491	10	be	be	AUX
cjal-3338	491	11	unpatentable	unpatentable	ADJ
cjal-3338	491	12	under	under	ADP
cjal-3338	491	13	35	35	NUM
cjal-3338	491	14	u.s.c	u.s.c	NOUN
cjal-3338	491	15	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	492	1	§	§	PROPN
cjal-3338	492	2	§	§	PROPN
cjal-3338	492	3	1o2	1o2	NUM
cjal-3338	492	4	or	or	CCONJ
cjal-3338	492	5	103	103	NUM
cjal-3338	492	6	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	492	7	then	then	ADV
cjal-3338	492	8	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	492	9	patentee	patentee	NOUN
cjal-3338	492	10	has	have	AUX
cjal-3338	492	11	overreached	overreach	VERB
cjal-3338	492	12	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	492	13	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	492	14	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	492	15	accused	accuse	VERB
cjal-3338	492	16	device	device	NOUN
cjal-3338	492	17	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	492	18	noninfringing	noninfringe	VERB
cjal-3338	492	19	as	as	ADP
cjal-3338	492	20	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	492	21	matter	matter	NOUN
cjal-3338	492	22	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	492	23	law	law	NOUN
cjal-3338	492	24	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	492	25	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	493	1	depuy	depuy	PROPN
cjal-3338	493	2	spine	spine	PROPN
cjal-3338	493	3	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	493	4	inc	inc	PROPN
cjal-3338	493	5	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	493	6	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	493	7	567	567	NUM
cjal-3338	493	8	f.3d	f.3d	NUM
cjal-3338	493	9	at	at	ADP
cjal-3338	493	10	1324	1324	NUM
cjal-3338	493	11	-	-	SYM
cjal-3338	493	12	25	25	NUM
cjal-3338	493	13	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	493	14	citation	citation	NOUN
cjal-3338	493	15	omitted	omit	VERB
cjal-3338	493	16	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	493	17	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	494	1	but	but	CCONJ
cjal-3338	494	2	like	like	ADP
cjal-3338	494	3	its	its	PRON
cjal-3338	494	4	chinese	chinese	ADJ
cjal-3338	494	5	counterpart	counterpart	NOUN
cjal-3338	494	6	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	494	7	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	494	8	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cjal-3338	494	9	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	494	10	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	494	11	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	494	12	linked	link	VERB
cjal-3338	494	13	to	to	ADP
cjal-3338	494	14	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	494	15	doctrine	doctrine	NOUN
cjal-3338	494	16	that	that	PRON
cjal-3338	494	17	extend	extend	VERB
cjal-3338	494	18	from	from	ADP
cjal-3338	494	19	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	494	20	core	core	NOUN
cjal-3338	494	21	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	494	22	obviousness	obviousness	NOUN
cjal-3338	494	23	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	494	24	codified	codify	VERB
cjal-3338	494	25	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	494	26	35	35	NUM
cjal-3338	494	27	u.s.c	u.s.c	NOUN
cjal-3338	494	28	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	495	1	§	§	PROPN
cjal-3338	495	2	103	103	NUM
cjal-3338	495	3	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	495	4	76	76	NUM
cjal-3338	495	5	columbia	columbia	PROPN
cjal-3338	495	6	journal	journal	PROPN
cjal-3338	495	7	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	495	8	asian	asian	ADJ
cjal-3338	495	9	law	law	NOUN
cjal-3338	495	10	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	495	11	vol	vol	NOUN
cjal-3338	495	12	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	495	13	27	27	NUM
cjal-3338	495	14	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	495	15	no	no	INTJ
cjal-3338	495	16	.	.	NOUN
cjal-3338	495	17	1	1	NUM
cjal-3338	495	18	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	495	19	2013	2013	NUM
cjal-3338	495	20	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	495	21	cu	cu	PROPN
cjal-3338	495	22	d	d	PROPN
cjal-3338	495	23	e	e	X
cjal-3338	495	24	f	f	X
cjal-3338	495	25	0	0	PROPN
cjal-3338	495	26	la	la	PROPN
cjal-3338	495	27	o	o	PROPN
cjal-3338	495	28	a	a	X
cjal-3338	495	29	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	495	30	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	495	31	core	core	NOUN
cjal-3338	495	32	b	b	X
cjal-3338	495	33	-	-	PUNCT
cjal-3338	495	34	reach	reach	VERB
cjal-3338	495	35	from	from	ADP
cjal-3338	495	36	core	core	NOUN
cjal-3338	495	37	c	c	PROPN
cjal-3338	495	38	figure	figure	NOUN
cjal-3338	495	39	4	4	NUM
cjal-3338	495	40	:	:	PUNCT
cjal-3338	495	41	schematic	schematic	ADJ
cjal-3338	495	42	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	495	43	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	495	44	existing	exist	VERB
cjal-3338	495	45	technology	technology	NOUN
cjal-3338	495	46	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	495	47	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	495	48	chinese	chinese	ADJ
cjal-3338	495	49	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	495	50	law	law	NOUN
cjal-3338	495	51	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	496	1	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	496	2	diagram	diagram	NOUN
cjal-3338	496	3	assumes	assume	VERB
cjal-3338	496	4	that	that	SCONJ
cjal-3338	496	5	there	there	PRON
cjal-3338	496	6	is	be	VERB
cjal-3338	496	7	some	some	DET
cjal-3338	496	8	correlation	correlation	NOUN
cjal-3338	496	9	between	between	ADP
cjal-3338	496	10	technological	technological	ADJ
cjal-3338	496	11	level	level	NOUN
cjal-3338	496	12	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	496	13	inventive	inventive	ADJ
cjal-3338	496	14	labor	labor	NOUN
cjal-3338	496	15	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	496	16	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	496	17	therefore	therefore	ADV
cjal-3338	496	18	segment	segment	PROPN
cjal-3338	496	19	ce	ce	PROPN
cjal-3338	496	20	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	496	21	drawn	draw	VERB
cjal-3338	496	22	diagonally	diagonally	ADV
cjal-3338	496	23	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	497	1	but	but	CCONJ
cjal-3338	497	2	linking	link	VERB
cjal-3338	497	3	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	497	4	existing	exist	VERB
cjal-3338	497	5	technology	technology	NOUN
cjal-3338	497	6	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	497	7	with	with	ADP
cjal-3338	497	8	equivalence	equivalence	NOUN
cjal-3338	497	9	as	as	SCONJ
cjal-3338	497	10	opposed	oppose	VERB
cjal-3338	497	11	to	to	ADP
cjal-3338	497	12	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	497	13	invalidity	invalidity	NOUN
cjal-3338	497	14	doctrines	doctrine	NOUN
cjal-3338	497	15	creates	create	VERB
cjal-3338	497	16	some	some	DET
cjal-3338	497	17	oddities	oddity	NOUN
cjal-3338	497	18	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	497	19	as	as	SCONJ
cjal-3338	497	20	figure	figure	NOUN
cjal-3338	497	21	4	4	NUM
cjal-3338	497	22	illustrates	illustrate	NOUN
cjal-3338	497	23	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	498	1	area	area	NOUN
cjal-3338	498	2	aced	ace	VERB
cjal-3338	498	3	marks	mark	VERB
cjal-3338	498	4	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	498	5	areas	area	NOUN
cjal-3338	498	6	where	where	SCONJ
cjal-3338	498	7	defendants	defendant	NOUN
cjal-3338	498	8	are	be	AUX
cjal-3338	498	9	protected	protect	VERB
cjal-3338	498	10	by	by	ADP
cjal-3338	498	11	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	498	12	existing	exist	VERB
cjal-3338	498	13	technology	technology	NOUN
cjal-3338	498	14	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	498	15	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	499	1	this	this	PRON
cjal-3338	499	2	includes	include	VERB
cjal-3338	499	3	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	499	4	area	area	NOUN
cjal-3338	499	5	exactly	exactly	ADV
cjal-3338	499	6	within	within	ADP
cjal-3338	499	7	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	499	8	core	core	NOUN
cjal-3338	499	9	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	499	10	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	499	11	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	499	12	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	499	13	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	499	14	area	area	NOUN
cjal-3338	499	15	abed	abe	VERB
cjal-3338	499	16	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	499	17	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	499	18	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	499	19	area	area	NOUN
cjal-3338	499	20	covered	cover	VERB
cjal-3338	499	21	by	by	ADP
cjal-3338	499	22	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	499	23	triple	triple	ADJ
cjal-3338	499	24	identity	identity	NOUN
cjal-3338	499	25	test	test	NOUN
cjal-3338	499	26	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	499	27	inventive	inventive	ADJ
cjal-3338	499	28	labor	labor	NOUN
cjal-3338	499	29	tests	test	NOUN
cjal-3338	499	30	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	499	31	area	area	NOUN
cjal-3338	499	32	bce	bce	PROPN
cjal-3338	499	33	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	500	1	but	but	CCONJ
cjal-3338	500	2	this	this	DET
cjal-3338	500	3	area	area	NOUN
cjal-3338	500	4	does	do	AUX
cjal-3338	500	5	not	not	PART
cjal-3338	500	6	fully	fully	ADV
cjal-3338	500	7	cover	cover	VERB
cjal-3338	500	8	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	500	9	area	area	NOUN
cjal-3338	500	10	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	500	11	unpatentability	unpatentability	NOUN
cjal-3338	500	12	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	501	1	after	after	ADV
cjal-3338	501	2	all	all	ADV
cjal-3338	501	3	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	501	4	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	501	5	overcome	overcome	VERB
cjal-3338	501	6	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	501	7	inventiveness	inventiveness	NOUN
cjal-3338	501	8	hurdle	hurdle	NOUN
cjal-3338	501	9	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	501	10	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	501	11	patentee	patentee	NOUN
cjal-3338	501	12	must	must	AUX
cjal-3338	501	13	prove	prove	VERB
cjal-3338	501	14	improvement	improvement	NOUN
cjal-3338	501	15	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	501	16	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	501	17	no	no	DET
cjal-3338	501	18	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	501	19	may	may	AUX
cjal-3338	501	20	fall	fall	VERB
cjal-3338	501	21	below	below	ADP
cjal-3338	501	22	segment	segment	NOUN
cjal-3338	501	23	df	df	PROPN
cjal-3338	501	24	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	502	1	not	not	PART
cjal-3338	502	2	incorporating	incorporate	VERB
cjal-3338	502	3	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	502	4	improvement	improvement	NOUN
cjal-3338	502	5	test	test	NOUN
cjal-3338	502	6	within	within	ADP
cjal-3338	502	7	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	502	8	existing	exist	VERB
cjal-3338	502	9	technology	technology	NOUN
cjal-3338	502	10	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	502	11	means	mean	VERB
cjal-3338	502	12	that	that	SCONJ
cjal-3338	502	13	there	there	PRON
cjal-3338	502	14	exists	exist	VERB
cjal-3338	502	15	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	502	16	zone	zone	NOUN
cjal-3338	502	17	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	502	18	area	area	NOUN
cjal-3338	502	19	cef	cef	PROPN
cjal-3338	502	20	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	502	21	that	that	PRON
cjal-3338	502	22	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	502	23	within	within	ADP
cjal-3338	502	24	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	502	25	zone	zone	NOUN
cjal-3338	502	26	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	502	27	unpatentability	unpatentability	NOUN
cjal-3338	502	28	but	but	CCONJ
cjal-3338	502	29	not	not	PART
cjal-3338	502	30	covered	cover	VERB
cjal-3338	502	31	by	by	ADP
cjal-3338	502	32	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	502	33	existing	exist	VERB
cjal-3338	502	34	technology	technology	NOUN
cjal-3338	502	35	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	502	36	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	503	1	6	6	NUM
cjal-3338	503	2	'	'	PUNCT
cjal-3338	503	3	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	503	4	chinese	chinese	ADJ
cjal-3338	503	5	existing	exist	VERB
cjal-3338	503	6	technology	technology	NOUN
cjal-3338	503	7	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	503	8	therefore	therefore	ADV
cjal-3338	503	9	does	do	AUX
cjal-3338	503	10	not	not	PART
cjal-3338	503	11	determine	determine	VERB
cjal-3338	503	12	noninfringement	noninfringement	NOUN
cjal-3338	503	13	based	base	VERB
cjal-3338	503	14	on	on	ADP
cjal-3338	503	15	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	503	16	idea	idea	NOUN
cjal-3338	503	17	that	that	SCONJ
cjal-3338	503	18	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	503	19	accused	accuse	VERB
cjal-3338	503	20	device	device	NOUN
cjal-3338	503	21	practices	practice	NOUN
cjal-3338	503	22	what	what	PRON
cjal-3338	503	23	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	503	24	not	not	PART
cjal-3338	503	25	patentable	patentable	ADJ
cjal-3338	503	26	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	504	1	what	what	PRON
cjal-3338	504	2	it	it	PRON
cjal-3338	504	3	does	do	AUX
cjal-3338	504	4	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	504	5	establish	establish	VERB
cjal-3338	504	6	entitlement	entitlement	NOUN
cjal-3338	504	7	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	504	8	practice	practice	VERB
cjal-3338	504	9	within	within	ADP
cjal-3338	504	10	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	504	11	radius	radius	NOUN
cjal-3338	504	12	around	around	ADP
cjal-3338	504	13	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	504	14	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	504	15	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	504	16	core	core	NOUN
cjal-3338	504	17	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	505	1	such	such	DET
cjal-3338	505	2	an	an	DET
cjal-3338	505	3	apparent	apparent	ADJ
cjal-3338	505	4	oversight	oversight	NOUN
cjal-3338	505	5	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	505	6	most	most	ADV
cjal-3338	505	7	likely	likely	ADJ
cjal-3338	505	8	by	by	ADP
cjal-3338	505	9	design	design	NOUN
cjal-3338	505	10	than	than	ADP
cjal-3338	505	11	by	by	ADP
cjal-3338	505	12	omission	omission	NOUN
cjal-3338	505	13	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	505	14	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	505	15	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	505	16	practicalities	practicality	NOUN
cjal-3338	505	17	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	505	18	adjudication	adjudication	NOUN
cjal-3338	505	19	provide	provide	VERB
cjal-3338	505	20	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	505	21	likeliest	likeli	ADJ
cjal-3338	505	22	explanation	explanation	NOUN
cjal-3338	505	23	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	506	1	section	section	NOUN
cjal-3338	506	2	b.2	b.2	NOUN
cjal-3338	506	3	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	506	4	has	have	AUX
cjal-3338	506	5	referred	refer	VERB
cjal-3338	506	6	to	to	ADP
cjal-3338	506	7	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	506	8	following	follow	VERB
cjal-3338	506	9	statement	statement	NOUN
cjal-3338	506	10	from	from	ADP
cjal-3338	506	11	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	506	12	supreme	supreme	PROPN
cjal-3338	506	13	people	people	PROPN
cjal-3338	506	14	's	's	PART
cjal-3338	506	15	court	court	NOUN
cjal-3338	506	16	about	about	ADP
cjal-3338	506	17	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	506	18	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	506	19	:	:	PUNCT
cjal-3338	506	20	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	506	21	existing	exist	VERB
cjal-3338	506	22	technology	technology	NOUN
cjal-3338	506	23	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	506	24	only	only	ADV
cjal-3338	506	25	inquires	inquire	VERB
cjal-3338	506	26	into	into	ADP
cjal-3338	506	27	whether	whether	SCONJ
cjal-3338	506	28	all	all	DET
cjal-3338	506	29	those	those	DET
cjal-3338	506	30	technical	technical	ADJ
cjal-3338	506	31	features	feature	NOUN
cjal-3338	506	32	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	506	33	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	506	34	accused	accuse	VERB
cjal-3338	506	35	product	product	NOUN
cjal-3338	506	36	accused	accuse	VERB
cjal-3338	506	37	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	506	38	falling	fall	VERB
cjal-3338	506	39	within	within	ADP
cjal-3338	506	40	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	506	41	protective	protective	ADJ
cjal-3338	506	42	scope	scope	NOUN
cjal-3338	506	43	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	506	44	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	506	45	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	506	46	rights	right	NOUN
cjal-3338	506	47	are	be	AUX
cjal-3338	506	48	identical	identical	ADJ
cjal-3338	506	49	or	or	CCONJ
cjal-3338	506	50	equivalent	equivalent	ADJ
cjal-3338	506	51	to	to	ADP
cjal-3338	506	52	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	506	53	corresponding	corresponding	ADJ
cjal-3338	506	54	technical	technical	ADJ
cjal-3338	506	55	features	feature	NOUN
cjal-3338	506	56	already	already	ADV
cjal-3338	506	57	disclosed	disclose	VERB
cjal-3338	506	58	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	506	59	other	other	ADJ
cjal-3338	506	60	existing	exist	VERB
cjal-3338	506	61	technical	technical	ADJ
cjal-3338	506	62	solutions.66	solutions.66	NOUN
cjal-3338	506	63	65	65	NUM
cjal-3338	506	64	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	506	65	reader	reader	NOUN
cjal-3338	506	66	comparing	compare	VERB
cjal-3338	506	67	figure	figure	NOUN
cjal-3338	506	68	4	4	NUM
cjal-3338	506	69	with	with	ADP
cjal-3338	506	70	figure	figure	NOUN
cjal-3338	506	71	4	4	NUM
cjal-3338	506	72	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	506	73	our	our	PRON
cjal-3338	506	74	earlier	early	ADJ
cjal-3338	506	75	article	article	NOUN
cjal-3338	506	76	would	would	AUX
cjal-3338	506	77	note	note	VERB
cjal-3338	506	78	that	that	PRON
cjal-3338	506	79	zone	zone	PROPN
cjal-3338	506	80	cef	cef	PROPN
cjal-3338	506	81	has	have	VERB
cjal-3338	506	82	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	506	83	similar	similar	ADJ
cjal-3338	506	84	nature	nature	NOUN
cjal-3338	506	85	to	to	ADP
cjal-3338	506	86	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	506	87	patentee	patentee	NOUN
cjal-3338	506	88	tax	tax	NOUN
cjal-3338	506	89	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	507	1	see	see	VERB
cjal-3338	507	2	lau	lau	PROPN
cjal-3338	507	3	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	507	4	supra	supra	PROPN
cjal-3338	507	5	note	note	NOUN
cjal-3338	507	6	2	2	NUM
cjal-3338	507	7	.	.	SYM
cjal-3338	507	8	66	66	NUM
cjal-3338	507	9	strix	strix	PROPN
cjal-3338	507	10	ltd	ltd	PROPN
cjal-3338	507	11	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	508	1	v.	v.	CCONJ
cjal-3338	508	2	ningbo	ningbo	PROPN
cjal-3338	508	3	sunlight	sunlight	PROPN
cjal-3338	508	4	elec	elec	PROPN
cjal-3338	508	5	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	508	6	appliance	appliance	PROPN
cjal-3338	508	7	co.	co.	PROPN
cjal-3338	508	8	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	509	1	supra	supra	PROPN
cjal-3338	509	2	note	note	PROPN
cjal-3338	509	3	37	37	NUM
cjal-3338	509	4	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	510	1	defensive	defensive	ADJ
cjal-3338	510	2	use	use	NOUN
cjal-3338	510	3	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	510	4	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	510	5	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	510	6	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	510	7	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cjal-3338	510	8	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	510	9	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	510	10	chinese	chinese	PROPN
cjal-3338	510	11	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	510	12	litigation	litigation	NOUN
cjal-3338	510	13	77	77	NUM
cjal-3338	510	14	clumsy	clumsy	ADJ
cjal-3338	510	15	as	as	SCONJ
cjal-3338	510	16	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	510	17	translated	translate	VERB
cjal-3338	510	18	language	language	NOUN
cjal-3338	510	19	may	may	AUX
cjal-3338	510	20	seem	seem	VERB
cjal-3338	510	21	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	510	22	there	there	PRON
cjal-3338	510	23	are	be	VERB
cjal-3338	510	24	two	two	NUM
cjal-3338	510	25	insights	insight	NOUN
cjal-3338	510	26	that	that	PRON
cjal-3338	510	27	can	can	AUX
cjal-3338	510	28	be	be	AUX
cjal-3338	510	29	derived	derive	VERB
cjal-3338	510	30	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	511	1	first	first	ADV
cjal-3338	511	2	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	511	3	only	only	ADV
cjal-3338	511	4	those	those	DET
cjal-3338	511	5	technical	technical	ADJ
cjal-3338	511	6	features	feature	NOUN
cjal-3338	511	7	accused	accuse	VERB
cjal-3338	511	8	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	511	9	falling	fall	VERB
cjal-3338	511	10	within	within	ADP
cjal-3338	511	11	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	511	12	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	511	13	scope	scope	NOUN
cjal-3338	511	14	are	be	AUX
cjal-3338	511	15	considered	consider	VERB
cjal-3338	511	16	against	against	ADP
cjal-3338	511	17	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	511	18	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	511	19	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	511	20	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	512	1	this	this	DET
cjal-3338	512	2	statement	statement	NOUN
cjal-3338	512	3	reflects	reflect	VERB
cjal-3338	512	4	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	512	5	recognition	recognition	NOUN
cjal-3338	512	6	that	that	SCONJ
cjal-3338	512	7	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	512	8	most	most	ADJ
cjal-3338	512	9	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	512	10	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	512	11	time	time	NOUN
cjal-3338	512	12	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	512	13	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	512	14	accused	accuse	VERB
cjal-3338	512	15	device	device	NOUN
cjal-3338	512	16	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	512	17	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	512	18	species	species	NOUN
cjal-3338	512	19	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	512	20	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	512	21	genus	genus	NOUN
cjal-3338	512	22	that	that	PRON
cjal-3338	512	23	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	512	24	asserted	asserted	ADJ
cjal-3338	512	25	claim	claim	NOUN
cjal-3338	512	26	allegedly	allegedly	ADV
cjal-3338	512	27	covers	cover	VERB
cjal-3338	512	28	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	513	1	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	513	2	accused	accuse	VERB
cjal-3338	513	3	device	device	NOUN
cjal-3338	513	4	likely	likely	ADV
cjal-3338	513	5	has	have	VERB
cjal-3338	513	6	additional	additional	ADJ
cjal-3338	513	7	technical	technical	ADJ
cjal-3338	513	8	features	feature	NOUN
cjal-3338	513	9	that	that	PRON
cjal-3338	513	10	qualifies	qualify	VERB
cjal-3338	513	11	it	it	PRON
cjal-3338	513	12	for	for	ADP
cjal-3338	513	13	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	513	14	environment	environment	NOUN
cjal-3338	513	15	it	it	PRON
cjal-3338	513	16	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	513	17	designed	design	VERB
cjal-3338	513	18	for	for	ADP
cjal-3338	513	19	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	513	20	which	which	PRON
cjal-3338	513	21	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	513	22	unlikely	unlikely	ADJ
cjal-3338	513	23	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	513	24	exact	exact	ADJ
cjal-3338	513	25	same	same	ADJ
cjal-3338	513	26	as	as	ADP
cjal-3338	513	27	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	513	28	problem	problem	NOUN
cjal-3338	513	29	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	513	30	patentee	patentee	NOUN
cjal-3338	513	31	was	be	AUX
cjal-3338	513	32	trying	try	VERB
cjal-3338	513	33	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	513	34	solve	solve	VERB
cjal-3338	513	35	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	514	1	second	second	ADV
cjal-3338	514	2	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	514	3	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	514	4	application	application	NOUN
cjal-3338	514	5	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	514	6	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	514	7	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	514	8	equivalent	equivalent	ADJ
cjal-3338	514	9	to	to	ADP
cjal-3338	514	10	"	"	PUNCT
cjal-3338	514	11	standard	standard	PROPN
cjal-3338	514	12	requires	require	VERB
cjal-3338	514	13	comparison	comparison	NOUN
cjal-3338	514	14	with	with	ADP
cjal-3338	514	15	possibly	possibly	ADV
cjal-3338	514	16	more	more	ADJ
cjal-3338	514	17	than	than	ADP
cjal-3338	514	18	one	one	NUM
cjal-3338	514	19	technical	technical	ADJ
cjal-3338	514	20	solution	solution	NOUN
cjal-3338	514	21	from	from	ADP
cjal-3338	514	22	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	514	23	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	514	24	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	514	25	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	515	1	it	it	PRON
cjal-3338	515	2	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	515	3	unlikely	unlikely	ADJ
cjal-3338	515	4	that	that	SCONJ
cjal-3338	515	5	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	515	6	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
cjal-3338	515	7	will	will	AUX
cjal-3338	515	8	ever	ever	ADV
cjal-3338	515	9	assert	assert	VERB
cjal-3338	515	10	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	515	11	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	515	12	against	against	ADP
cjal-3338	515	13	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	515	14	defendant	defendant	NOUN
cjal-3338	515	15	who	who	PRON
cjal-3338	515	16	actually	actually	ADV
cjal-3338	515	17	can	can	AUX
cjal-3338	515	18	argue	argue	VERB
cjal-3338	515	19	that	that	SCONJ
cjal-3338	515	20	he	he	PRON
cjal-3338	515	21	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	515	22	practicing	practice	VERB
cjal-3338	515	23	something	something	PRON
cjal-3338	515	24	within	within	ADP
cjal-3338	515	25	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	515	26	exact	exact	ADJ
cjal-3338	515	27	disclosure	disclosure	NOUN
cjal-3338	515	28	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	515	29	one	one	NUM
cjal-3338	515	30	piece	piece	NOUN
cjal-3338	515	31	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	515	32	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	515	33	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	515	34	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	516	1	rather	rather	ADV
cjal-3338	516	2	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	516	3	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	516	4	defendant	defendant	NOUN
cjal-3338	516	5	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	516	6	likely	likely	ADJ
cjal-3338	516	7	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	516	8	have	have	AUX
cjal-3338	516	9	done	do	VERB
cjal-3338	516	10	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	516	11	bit	bit	NOUN
cjal-3338	516	12	more	more	ADJ
cjal-3338	516	13	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	516	14	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	516	15	even	even	ADV
cjal-3338	516	16	if	if	SCONJ
cjal-3338	516	17	he	he	PRON
cjal-3338	516	18	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	516	19	not	not	PART
cjal-3338	516	20	practicing	practice	VERB
cjal-3338	516	21	outside	outside	ADP
cjal-3338	516	22	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	516	23	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	516	24	realm	realm	NOUN
cjal-3338	516	25	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	516	26	inventiveness	inventiveness	NOUN
cjal-3338	516	27	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	516	28	light	light	NOUN
cjal-3338	516	29	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	516	30	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	516	31	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	516	32	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	516	33	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	516	34	has	have	AUX
cjal-3338	516	35	at	at	ADV
cjal-3338	516	36	least	least	ADJ
cjal-3338	516	37	practiced	practice	VERB
cjal-3338	516	38	something	something	PRON
cjal-3338	516	39	sufficiently	sufficiently	ADV
cjal-3338	516	40	different	different	ADJ
cjal-3338	516	41	that	that	SCONJ
cjal-3338	516	42	multiple	multiple	ADJ
cjal-3338	516	43	pieces	piece	NOUN
cjal-3338	516	44	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	516	45	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	516	46	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	516	47	have	have	VERB
cjal-3338	516	48	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	516	49	be	be	AUX
cjal-3338	516	50	used	use	VERB
cjal-3338	516	51	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	516	52	bridge	bridge	VERB
cjal-3338	516	53	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	516	54	differences	difference	NOUN
cjal-3338	516	55	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	517	1	if	if	SCONJ
cjal-3338	517	2	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	517	3	existing	exist	VERB
cjal-3338	517	4	technology	technology	NOUN
cjal-3338	517	5	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	517	6	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	517	7	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	517	8	mirror	mirror	VERB
cjal-3338	517	9	inventiveness	inventiveness	NOUN
cjal-3338	517	10	rather	rather	ADV
cjal-3338	517	11	than	than	ADP
cjal-3338	517	12	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	517	13	equivalence	equivalence	NOUN
cjal-3338	517	14	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	517	15	then	then	ADV
cjal-3338	517	16	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	517	17	people	people	NOUN
cjal-3338	517	18	's	's	PART
cjal-3338	517	19	courts	court	NOUN
cjal-3338	517	20	will	will	AUX
cjal-3338	517	21	have	have	VERB
cjal-3338	517	22	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	517	23	look	look	VERB
cjal-3338	517	24	into	into	ADP
cjal-3338	517	25	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	517	26	improvement	improvement	NOUN
cjal-3338	517	27	provided	provide	VERB
cjal-3338	517	28	by	by	ADP
cjal-3338	517	29	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	517	30	accused	accuse	VERB
cjal-3338	517	31	product	product	NOUN
cjal-3338	517	32	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	518	1	but	but	CCONJ
cjal-3338	518	2	this	this	DET
cjal-3338	518	3	improvement	improvement	NOUN
cjal-3338	518	4	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	518	5	not	not	PART
cjal-3338	518	6	measured	measure	VERB
cjal-3338	518	7	based	base	VERB
cjal-3338	518	8	on	on	ADP
cjal-3338	518	9	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	518	10	entire	entire	ADJ
cjal-3338	518	11	product	product	NOUN
cjal-3338	518	12	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	518	13	but	but	CCONJ
cjal-3338	518	14	only	only	ADV
cjal-3338	518	15	with	with	ADP
cjal-3338	518	16	regard	regard	NOUN
cjal-3338	518	17	to	to	ADP
cjal-3338	518	18	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	518	19	accused	accuse	VERB
cjal-3338	518	20	technical	technical	ADJ
cjal-3338	518	21	features	feature	NOUN
cjal-3338	518	22	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	518	23	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	518	24	accused	accuse	VERB
cjal-3338	518	25	product	product	NOUN
cjal-3338	518	26	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	519	1	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	519	2	other	other	ADJ
cjal-3338	519	3	words	word	NOUN
cjal-3338	519	4	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	519	5	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	519	6	people	people	NOUN
cjal-3338	519	7	's	's	PART
cjal-3338	519	8	court	court	NOUN
cjal-3338	519	9	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	519	10	making	make	VERB
cjal-3338	519	11	this	this	DET
cjal-3338	519	12	determination	determination	NOUN
cjal-3338	519	13	will	will	AUX
cjal-3338	519	14	have	have	VERB
cjal-3338	519	15	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	519	16	ask	ask	VERB
cjal-3338	519	17	how	how	SCONJ
cjal-3338	519	18	this	this	DET
cjal-3338	519	19	subset	subset	NOUN
cjal-3338	519	20	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	519	21	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	519	22	technical	technical	ADJ
cjal-3338	519	23	features	feature	NOUN
cjal-3338	519	24	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	519	25	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	519	26	accused	accuse	VERB
cjal-3338	519	27	product	product	NOUN
cjal-3338	519	28	provides	provide	VERB
cjal-3338	519	29	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	519	30	technical	technical	ADJ
cjal-3338	519	31	benefit	benefit	NOUN
cjal-3338	519	32	above	above	ADP
cjal-3338	519	33	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	519	34	combination	combination	NOUN
cjal-3338	519	35	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	519	36	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	519	37	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	519	38	pieces	piece	NOUN
cjal-3338	519	39	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	520	1	therefore	therefore	ADV
cjal-3338	520	2	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	520	3	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	520	4	people	people	NOUN
cjal-3338	520	5	's	's	PART
cjal-3338	520	6	court	court	NOUN
cjal-3338	520	7	must	must	AUX
cjal-3338	520	8	first	first	ADV
cjal-3338	520	9	conceptually	conceptually	ADV
cjal-3338	520	10	piece	piece	VERB
cjal-3338	520	11	together	together	ADV
cjal-3338	520	12	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	520	13	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	520	14	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	520	15	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	520	16	then	then	ADV
cjal-3338	520	17	mentally	mentally	ADV
cjal-3338	520	18	dissect	dissect	VERB
cjal-3338	520	19	out	out	ADP
cjal-3338	520	20	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	520	21	accused	accuse	VERB
cjal-3338	520	22	technical	technical	ADJ
cjal-3338	520	23	features	feature	NOUN
cjal-3338	520	24	from	from	ADP
cjal-3338	520	25	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	520	26	accused	accuse	VERB
cjal-3338	520	27	product	product	NOUN
cjal-3338	520	28	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	520	29	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	520	30	then	then	ADV
cjal-3338	520	31	compare	compare	VERB
cjal-3338	520	32	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	520	33	two	two	NUM
cjal-3338	520	34	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	521	1	this	this	PRON
cjal-3338	521	2	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	521	3	not	not	PART
cjal-3338	521	4	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	521	5	simple	simple	ADJ
cjal-3338	521	6	exercise	exercise	NOUN
cjal-3338	521	7	for	for	ADP
cjal-3338	521	8	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	521	9	people	people	NOUN
cjal-3338	521	10	's	's	PART
cjal-3338	521	11	court	court	NOUN
cjal-3338	521	12	that	that	PRON
cjal-3338	521	13	may	may	AUX
cjal-3338	521	14	be	be	AUX
cjal-3338	521	15	dealing	deal	VERB
cjal-3338	521	16	with	with	ADP
cjal-3338	521	17	technology	technology	NOUN
cjal-3338	521	18	it	it	PRON
cjal-3338	521	19	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	521	20	unfamiliar	unfamiliar	ADJ
cjal-3338	521	21	with	with	ADP
cjal-3338	521	22	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	522	1	moreover	moreover	ADV
cjal-3338	522	2	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	522	3	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	522	4	litigants	litigant	NOUN
cjal-3338	522	5	are	be	AUX
cjal-3338	522	6	also	also	ADV
cjal-3338	522	7	put	put	VERB
cjal-3338	522	8	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	522	9	an	an	DET
cjal-3338	522	10	awkward	awkward	ADJ
cjal-3338	522	11	position	position	NOUN
cjal-3338	522	12	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	523	1	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	523	2	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
cjal-3338	523	3	has	have	VERB
cjal-3338	523	4	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	523	5	praise	praise	VERB
cjal-3338	523	6	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	523	7	product	product	NOUN
cjal-3338	523	8	he	he	PRON
cjal-3338	523	9	accuses	accuse	VERB
cjal-3338	523	10	by	by	ADP
cjal-3338	523	11	arguing	argue	VERB
cjal-3338	523	12	that	that	SCONJ
cjal-3338	523	13	it	it	PRON
cjal-3338	523	14	provides	provide	VERB
cjal-3338	523	15	improvement	improvement	NOUN
cjal-3338	523	16	beyond	beyond	ADP
cjal-3338	523	17	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	523	18	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	523	19	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	523	20	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	523	21	while	while	SCONJ
cjal-3338	523	22	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	523	23	defendant	defendant	NOUN
cjal-3338	523	24	has	have	VERB
cjal-3338	523	25	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	523	26	criticize	criticize	VERB
cjal-3338	523	27	his	his	PRON
cjal-3338	523	28	own	own	ADJ
cjal-3338	523	29	product	product	NOUN
cjal-3338	523	30	by	by	ADP
cjal-3338	523	31	doing	do	VERB
cjal-3338	523	32	just	just	ADV
cjal-3338	523	33	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	523	34	opposite.6	opposite.6	NOUN
cjal-3338	523	35	7	7	NUM
cjal-3338	523	36	seen	see	VERB
cjal-3338	523	37	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	523	38	that	that	DET
cjal-3338	523	39	light	light	NOUN
cjal-3338	523	40	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	523	41	omitting	omit	VERB
cjal-3338	523	42	an	an	DET
cjal-3338	523	43	improvement	improvement	NOUN
cjal-3338	523	44	prong	prong	NOUN
cjal-3338	523	45	from	from	ADP
cjal-3338	523	46	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	523	47	existing	exist	VERB
cjal-3338	523	48	technology	technology	NOUN
cjal-3338	523	49	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	523	50	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	523	51	channeling	channel	VERB
cjal-3338	523	52	defendants	defendant	NOUN
cjal-3338	523	53	who	who	PRON
cjal-3338	523	54	need	need	VERB
cjal-3338	523	55	this	this	DET
cjal-3338	523	56	prong	prong	NOUN
cjal-3338	523	57	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	523	58	rely	rely	VERB
cjal-3338	523	59	on	on	ADP
cjal-3338	523	60	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	523	61	noninfringement	noninfringement	NOUN
cjal-3338	523	62	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	523	63	may	may	AUX
cjal-3338	523	64	ease	ease	VERB
cjal-3338	523	65	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	523	66	difficulties	difficulty	NOUN
cjal-3338	523	67	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	523	68	adjudication	adjudication	NOUN
cjal-3338	523	69	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	524	1	conclusion	conclusion	NOUN
cjal-3338	524	2	there	there	PRON
cjal-3338	524	3	are	be	VERB
cjal-3338	524	4	two	two	NUM
cjal-3338	524	5	forms	form	NOUN
cjal-3338	524	6	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	524	7	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	524	8	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	524	9	defenses	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	524	10	that	that	PRON
cjal-3338	524	11	may	may	AUX
cjal-3338	524	12	be	be	AUX
cjal-3338	524	13	used	use	VERB
cjal-3338	524	14	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	524	15	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	524	16	litigation	litigation	NOUN
cjal-3338	524	17	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	525	1	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	525	2	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	525	3	offensive	offensive	ADJ
cjal-3338	525	4	variant	variant	NOUN
cjal-3338	525	5	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	525	6	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	525	7	defendant	defendant	NOUN
cjal-3338	525	8	uses	use	VERB
cjal-3338	525	9	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	525	10	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	525	11	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	525	12	to	to	ADP
cjal-3338	525	13	67this	67this	DET
cjal-3338	525	14	dynamic	dynamic	NOUN
cjal-3338	525	15	can	can	AUX
cjal-3338	525	16	be	be	AUX
cjal-3338	525	17	observed	observe	VERB
cjal-3338	525	18	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	525	19	depuy	depuy	NOUN
cjal-3338	525	20	spine	spine	PROPN
cjal-3338	525	21	v.	v.	PROPN
cjal-3338	525	22	medtronic	medtronic	ADJ
cjal-3338	525	23	sofamor	sofamor	PROPN
cjal-3338	525	24	danek	danek	ADV
cjal-3338	525	25	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	525	26	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	525	27	federal	federal	ADJ
cjal-3338	525	28	circuit	circuit	NOUN
cjal-3338	525	29	case	case	NOUN
cjal-3338	525	30	applying	apply	VERB
cjal-3338	525	31	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	525	32	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cjal-3338	525	33	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	525	34	practicing	practice	VERB
cjal-3338	525	35	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	525	36	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	525	37	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	525	38	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	525	39	to	to	ADP
cjal-3338	525	40	equivalents	equivalent	NOUN
cjal-3338	525	41	infringement	infringement	NOUN
cjal-3338	525	42	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	525	43	where	where	SCONJ
cjal-3338	525	44	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	525	45	defendant	defendant	NOUN
cjal-3338	525	46	attempted	attempt	VERB
cjal-3338	525	47	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	525	48	prove	prove	VERB
cjal-3338	525	49	his	his	PRON
cjal-3338	525	50	accused	accuse	VERB
cjal-3338	525	51	device	device	NOUN
cjal-3338	525	52	was	be	AUX
cjal-3338	525	53	noninfringing	noninfringe	VERB
cjal-3338	525	54	by	by	ADP
cjal-3338	525	55	arguing	argue	VERB
cjal-3338	525	56	that	that	SCONJ
cjal-3338	525	57	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	525	58	device	device	NOUN
cjal-3338	525	59	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	525	60	as	as	SCONJ
cjal-3338	525	61	described	describe	VERB
cjal-3338	525	62	by	by	ADP
cjal-3338	525	63	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	525	64	hypothetical	hypothetical	ADJ
cjal-3338	525	65	claim	claim	NOUN
cjal-3338	525	66	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	525	67	was	be	AUX
cjal-3338	525	68	obvious	obvious	ADJ
cjal-3338	525	69	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	525	70	view	view	NOUN
cjal-3338	525	71	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	525	72	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	525	73	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	525	74	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	525	75	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	526	1	567	567	NUM
cjal-3338	526	2	f.3d	f.3d	NUM
cjal-3338	526	3	at	at	ADP
cjal-3338	526	4	1324	1324	NUM
cjal-3338	526	5	-	-	SYM
cjal-3338	526	6	29	29	NUM
cjal-3338	526	7	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	527	1	78	78	NUM
cjal-3338	527	2	columbia	columbia	PROPN
cjal-3338	527	3	journal	journal	NOUN
cjal-3338	527	4	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	527	5	asian	asian	ADJ
cjal-3338	527	6	law	law	NOUN
cjal-3338	527	7	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	527	8	vol	vol	NOUN
cjal-3338	527	9	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	527	10	27	27	NUM
cjal-3338	527	11	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	527	12	no	no	INTJ
cjal-3338	527	13	.	.	NOUN
cjal-3338	527	14	1	1	NUM
cjal-3338	527	15	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	527	16	2o3	2o3	NUM
cjal-3338	527	17	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	527	18	invalidate	invalidate	VERB
cjal-3338	527	19	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	527	20	asserted	asserted	ADJ
cjal-3338	527	21	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	527	22	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	528	1	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	528	2	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	528	3	defensive	defensive	ADJ
cjal-3338	528	4	variant	variant	NOUN
cjal-3338	528	5	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	528	6	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	528	7	defendant	defendant	NOUN
cjal-3338	528	8	demonstrates	demonstrate	VERB
cjal-3338	528	9	his	his	PRON
cjal-3338	528	10	entitlement	entitlement	NOUN
cjal-3338	528	11	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	528	12	practice	practice	VERB
cjal-3338	528	13	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	528	14	accused	accuse	VERB
cjal-3338	528	15	acts	act	NOUN
cjal-3338	528	16	by	by	ADP
cjal-3338	528	17	showing	show	VERB
cjal-3338	528	18	that	that	SCONJ
cjal-3338	528	19	these	these	DET
cjal-3338	528	20	acts	act	NOUN
cjal-3338	528	21	belong	belong	VERB
cjal-3338	528	22	to	to	ADP
cjal-3338	528	23	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	528	24	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	528	25	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	528	26	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	529	1	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	529	2	this	this	DET
cjal-3338	529	3	article	article	NOUN
cjal-3338	529	4	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	529	5	we	we	PRON
cjal-3338	529	6	have	have	AUX
cjal-3338	529	7	examined	examine	VERB
cjal-3338	529	8	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	529	9	use	use	NOUN
cjal-3338	529	10	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	529	11	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	529	12	defensive	defensive	ADJ
cjal-3338	529	13	variant	variant	NOUN
cjal-3338	529	14	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	529	15	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	529	16	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	529	17	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	529	18	defenses	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	529	19	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	529	20	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cjal-3338	529	21	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	529	22	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	529	23	chinese	chinese	ADJ
cjal-3338	529	24	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	529	25	litigation	litigation	NOUN
cjal-3338	529	26	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	530	1	we	we	PRON
cjal-3338	530	2	have	have	AUX
cjal-3338	530	3	also	also	ADV
cjal-3338	530	4	discussed	discuss	VERB
cjal-3338	530	5	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	530	6	absence	absence	NOUN
cjal-3338	530	7	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	530	8	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	530	9	practicing	practice	VERB
cjal-3338	530	10	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	530	11	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	530	12	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	530	13	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	530	14	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	530	15	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	530	16	defensive	defensive	ADJ
cjal-3338	530	17	form	form	NOUN
cjal-3338	530	18	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	530	19	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	530	20	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	530	21	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	530	22	defenses	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	530	23	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	530	24	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	530	25	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cjal-3338	530	26	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	530	27	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	530	28	law	law	NOUN
cjal-3338	530	29	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	531	1	we	we	PRON
cjal-3338	531	2	looked	look	VERB
cjal-3338	531	3	into	into	ADP
cjal-3338	531	4	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	531	5	chinese	chinese	ADJ
cjal-3338	531	6	implementation	implementation	NOUN
cjal-3338	531	7	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	531	8	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	531	9	existing	exist	VERB
cjal-3338	531	10	technology	technology	NOUN
cjal-3338	531	11	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	531	12	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	531	13	as	as	SCONJ
cjal-3338	531	14	applied	apply	VERB
cjal-3338	531	15	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	531	16	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	531	17	infringement	infringement	NOUN
cjal-3338	531	18	disputes	dispute	NOUN
cjal-3338	531	19	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	532	1	we	we	PRON
cjal-3338	532	2	concluded	conclude	VERB
cjal-3338	532	3	that	that	SCONJ
cjal-3338	532	4	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	532	5	united	united	PROPN
cjal-3338	532	6	states	states	PROPN
cjal-3338	532	7	would	would	AUX
cjal-3338	532	8	benefit	benefit	VERB
cjal-3338	532	9	from	from	ADP
cjal-3338	532	10	an	an	DET
cjal-3338	532	11	introduction	introduction	NOUN
cjal-3338	532	12	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	532	13	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	532	14	practicing	practice	VERB
cjal-3338	532	15	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	532	16	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	532	17	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	532	18	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	532	19	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	532	20	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	532	21	that	that	SCONJ
cjal-3338	532	22	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	532	23	chinese	chinese	ADJ
cjal-3338	532	24	linkage	linkage	NOUN
cjal-3338	532	25	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	532	26	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	532	27	existing	exist	VERB
cjal-3338	532	28	technology	technology	NOUN
cjal-3338	532	29	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	532	30	with	with	ADP
cjal-3338	532	31	equivalence	equivalence	NOUN
cjal-3338	532	32	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	532	33	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	532	34	well	well	ADV
cjal-3338	532	35	-	-	PUNCT
cjal-3338	532	36	calibrated	calibrate	VERB
cjal-3338	532	37	approach	approach	NOUN
cjal-3338	532	38	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	533	1	this	this	DET
cjal-3338	533	2	article	article	NOUN
cjal-3338	533	3	concludes	conclude	VERB
cjal-3338	533	4	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	533	5	study	study	NOUN
cjal-3338	533	6	started	start	VERB
cjal-3338	533	7	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	533	8	our	our	PRON
cjal-3338	533	9	earlier	early	ADJ
cjal-3338	533	10	article	article	NOUN
cjal-3338	533	11	into	into	ADP
cjal-3338	533	12	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	533	13	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	533	14	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	533	15	defenses	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	533	16	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	533	17	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	533	18	litigation	litigation	NOUN
cjal-3338	533	19	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	534	1	however	however	ADV
cjal-3338	534	2	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	534	3	as	as	SCONJ
cjal-3338	534	4	figure	figure	NOUN
cjal-3338	534	5	i	i	PRON
cjal-3338	534	6	shows	show	VERB
cjal-3338	534	7	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	534	8	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	534	9	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	534	10	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	534	11	defenses	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	534	12	are	be	AUX
cjal-3338	534	13	only	only	ADV
cjal-3338	534	14	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	534	15	portion	portion	NOUN
cjal-3338	534	16	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	534	17	an	an	DET
cjal-3338	534	18	interconnected	interconnected	ADJ
cjal-3338	534	19	web	web	NOUN
cjal-3338	534	20	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	534	21	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	534	22	law	law	NOUN
cjal-3338	534	23	doctrines	doctrine	NOUN
cjal-3338	534	24	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	535	1	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	535	2	particular	particular	ADJ
cjal-3338	535	3	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	535	4	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	535	5	doctrines	doctrine	NOUN
cjal-3338	535	6	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	535	7	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	535	8	user	user	NOUN
cjal-3338	535	9	rights	right	NOUN
cjal-3338	535	10	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	535	11	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	535	12	exhaustion	exhaustion	NOUN
cjal-3338	535	13	are	be	AUX
cjal-3338	535	14	naturally	naturally	ADV
cjal-3338	535	15	suited	suit	VERB
cjal-3338	535	16	as	as	ADP
cjal-3338	535	17	an	an	DET
cjal-3338	535	18	extension	extension	NOUN
cjal-3338	535	19	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	535	20	this	this	DET
cjal-3338	535	21	current	current	ADJ
cjal-3338	535	22	study	study	NOUN
cjal-3338	535	23	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	536	1	both	both	DET
cjal-3338	536	2	doctrines	doctrine	NOUN
cjal-3338	536	3	are	be	AUX
cjal-3338	536	4	fundamentally	fundamentally	ADV
cjal-3338	536	5	allied	ally	VERB
cjal-3338	536	6	with	with	ADP
cjal-3338	536	7	practicing	practice	VERB
cjal-3338	536	8	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	536	9	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	536	10	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	536	11	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	536	12	in	in	SCONJ
cjal-3338	536	13	that	that	SCONJ
cjal-3338	536	14	all	all	DET
cjal-3338	536	15	three	three	NUM
cjal-3338	536	16	defenses	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	536	17	are	be	AUX
cjal-3338	536	18	doctrines	doctrine	NOUN
cjal-3338	536	19	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	536	20	inclusion	inclusion	NOUN
cjal-3338	536	21	built	build	VERB
cjal-3338	536	22	on	on	ADP
cjal-3338	536	23	similar	similar	ADJ
cjal-3338	536	24	concepts	concept	NOUN
cjal-3338	536	25	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	536	26	fairness	fairness	NOUN
cjal-3338	536	27	that	that	SCONJ
cjal-3338	536	28	one	one	NOUN
cjal-3338	536	29	is	be	AUX
cjal-3338	536	30	fairly	fairly	ADV
cjal-3338	536	31	entitled	entitle	VERB
cjal-3338	536	32	to	to	ADP
cjal-3338	536	33	practice	practice	VERB
cjal-3338	536	34	based	base	VERB
cjal-3338	536	35	on	on	ADP
cjal-3338	536	36	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	536	37	use	use	NOUN
cjal-3338	536	38	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	536	39	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	536	40	purchase	purchase	NOUN
cjal-3338	536	41	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	536	42	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	536	43	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	536	44	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	536	45	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	537	1	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	537	2	course	course	NOUN
cjal-3338	537	3	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	537	4	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	537	5	three	three	NUM
cjal-3338	537	6	doctrines	doctrine	NOUN
cjal-3338	537	7	serve	serve	VERB
cjal-3338	537	8	very	very	ADV
cjal-3338	537	9	different	different	ADJ
cjal-3338	537	10	policy	policy	NOUN
cjal-3338	537	11	objectives	objective	NOUN
cjal-3338	537	12	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	537	13	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	537	14	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	537	15	definitions	definition	NOUN
cjal-3338	537	16	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	537	17	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	537	18	use	use	NOUN
cjal-3338	537	19	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	537	20	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	537	21	purchase	purchase	NOUN
cjal-3338	537	22	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	537	23	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	537	24	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	537	25	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	537	26	have	have	VERB
cjal-3338	537	27	important	important	ADJ
cjal-3338	537	28	substantive	substantive	ADJ
cjal-3338	537	29	differences	difference	NOUN
cjal-3338	537	30	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	538	1	tests	test	NOUN
cjal-3338	538	2	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	538	3	inquiries	inquiry	NOUN
cjal-3338	538	4	that	that	PRON
cjal-3338	538	5	may	may	AUX
cjal-3338	538	6	be	be	AUX
cjal-3338	538	7	useful	useful	ADJ
cjal-3338	538	8	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	538	9	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	538	10	context	context	NOUN
cjal-3338	538	11	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	538	12	one	one	NUM
cjal-3338	538	13	may	may	AUX
cjal-3338	538	14	not	not	PART
cjal-3338	538	15	be	be	AUX
cjal-3338	538	16	easily	easily	ADV
cjal-3338	538	17	transferred	transfer	VERB
cjal-3338	538	18	to	to	ADP
cjal-3338	538	19	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	538	20	other	other	ADJ
cjal-3338	538	21	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	539	1	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	539	2	comparative	comparative	ADJ
cjal-3338	539	3	approach	approach	NOUN
cjal-3338	539	4	used	use	VERB
cjal-3338	539	5	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	539	6	this	this	DET
cjal-3338	539	7	study	study	NOUN
cjal-3338	539	8	could	could	AUX
cjal-3338	539	9	be	be	AUX
cjal-3338	539	10	employed	employ	VERB
cjal-3338	539	11	to	to	PART
cjal-3338	539	12	investigate	investigate	VERB
cjal-3338	539	13	these	these	DET
cjal-3338	539	14	doctrines	doctrine	NOUN
cjal-3338	539	15	and	and	CCONJ
cjal-3338	539	16	their	their	PRON
cjal-3338	539	17	relationships	relationship	NOUN
cjal-3338	539	18	with	with	ADP
cjal-3338	539	19	other	other	ADJ
cjal-3338	539	20	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	539	21	law	law	NOUN
cjal-3338	539	22	doctrines	doctrine	NOUN
cjal-3338	539	23	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	540	1	6	6	NUM
cjal-3338	540	2	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	540	3	conclusion	conclusion	NOUN
cjal-3338	540	4	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	540	5	this	this	DET
cjal-3338	540	6	exploration	exploration	NOUN
cjal-3338	540	7	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	540	8	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	540	9	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	540	10	art	art	NOUN
cjal-3338	540	11	defenses	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	540	12	should	should	AUX
cjal-3338	540	13	only	only	ADV
cjal-3338	540	14	be	be	AUX
cjal-3338	540	15	viewed	view	VERB
cjal-3338	540	16	as	as	ADP
cjal-3338	540	17	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	540	18	component	component	NOUN
cjal-3338	540	19	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	540	20	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	540	21	broader	broad	ADJ
cjal-3338	540	22	investigation	investigation	NOUN
cjal-3338	540	23	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	540	24	patent	patent	NOUN
cjal-3338	540	25	law	law	NOUN
cjal-3338	540	26	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	541	1	6	6	NUM
cjal-3338	541	2	indeed	indeed	ADV
cjal-3338	541	3	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	541	4	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	541	5	uspto	uspto	NOUN
cjal-3338	541	6	has	have	AUX
cjal-3338	541	7	used	use	VERB
cjal-3338	541	8	a	a	DET
cjal-3338	541	9	comparative	comparative	ADJ
cjal-3338	541	10	law	law	NOUN
cjal-3338	541	11	approach	approach	NOUN
cjal-3338	541	12	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	541	13	its	its	PRON
cjal-3338	541	14	brief	brief	ADJ
cjal-3338	541	15	survey	survey	NOUN
cjal-3338	541	16	of	of	ADP
cjal-3338	541	17	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	541	18	user	user	NOUN
cjal-3338	541	19	rights	right	NOUN
cjal-3338	541	20	in	in	ADP
cjal-3338	541	21	its	its	PRON
cjal-3338	541	22	report	report	NOUN
cjal-3338	541	23	to	to	ADP
cjal-3338	541	24	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	541	25	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cjal-3338	541	26	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	541	27	congress	congress	PROPN
cjal-3338	541	28	.	.	PUNCT
cjal-3338	542	1	u.s	u.s	PROPN
cjal-3338	542	2	.	.	PROPN
cjal-3338	542	3	patent	patent	PROPN
cjal-3338	542	4	&	&	CCONJ
cjal-3338	542	5	trademark	trademark	PROPN
cjal-3338	542	6	office	office	NOUN
cjal-3338	542	7	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	542	8	report	report	NOUN
cjal-3338	542	9	on	on	ADP
cjal-3338	542	10	the	the	DET
cjal-3338	542	11	prior	prior	ADJ
cjal-3338	542	12	user	user	NOUN
cjal-3338	542	13	rights	right	NOUN
cjal-3338	542	14	defense	defense	NOUN
cjal-3338	542	15	22	22	NUM
cjal-3338	542	16	-	-	SYM
cjal-3338	542	17	28	28	NUM
cjal-3338	542	18	(	(	PUNCT
cjal-3338	542	19	2012	2012	NUM
cjal-3338	542	20	)	)	PUNCT
cjal-3338	542	21	,	,	PUNCT
cjal-3338	542	22	available	available	ADJ
cjal-3338	542	23	at	at	ADP
cjal-3338	542	24	http://www.uspto.gov/aiaimplementation/2012olo3-pur-report.pdf	http://www.uspto.gov/aiaimplementation/2012olo3-pur-report.pdf	PROPN
cjal-3338	542	25	.	.	PUNCT