id	sid	eid	entity	type
cjel-3571	1	1	151	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	1	2	lujan v. defenders	PERSON
cjel-3571	1	3	massachusetts	GPE
cjel-3571	1	4	epa	ORG
cjel-3571	1	5	iii standing devin mcdougall*	PERSON
cjel-3571	1	6	151 i.	PERSON
cjel-3571	1	7	152	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	1	8	iii standing	PERSON
cjel-3571	1	9	152	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	1	10	b. lujan	PERSON
cjel-3571	1	11	155 1	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	2	1	155 2	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	3	1	157	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	3	2	c. post-lujan	PERSON
cjel-3571	3	3	158 ii	QUANTITY
cjel-3571	4	1	massachusetts	GPE
cjel-3571	4	2	161	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	4	3	a. massachusetts	PERSON
cjel-3571	4	4	162	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	4	5	lujan	PERSON
cjel-3571	4	6	massachusetts	GPE
cjel-3571	4	7	164 iii	QUANTITY
cjel-3571	5	1	massachusetts	GPE
cjel-3571	5	2	168	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	5	3	supreme court	ORG
cjel-3571	5	4	168	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	5	5	u.s.	GPE
cjel-3571	5	6	172	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	6	1	175	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	6	2	iii standing	PERSON
cjel-3571	6	3	the supreme court	ORG
cjel-3571	6	4	2007	DATE
cjel-3571	6	5	2012	DATE
cjel-3571	6	6	columbia law school	ORG
cjel-3571	6	7	columbia journal of environmental law	ORG
cjel-3571	7	1	michael b. gerrard	PERSON
cjel-3571	8	1	peter strauss	PERSON
cjel-3571	8	2	jamal greene	PERSON
cjel-3571	8	3	bradford c. mank	ORG
cjel-3571	9	1	the columbia journal of environmental law	ORG
cjel-3571	9	2	martha rose	PERSON
cjel-3571	9	3	benjamin hendricks	PERSON
cjel-3571	9	4	michael kettler	PERSON
cjel-3571	9	5	briana dema	PERSON
cjel-3571	10	1	1	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	10	2	earth island	LOC
cjel-3571	10	3	555	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	10	4	488	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	10	5	2009	DATE
cjel-3571	10	6	152	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	10	7	columbia	ORG
cjel-3571	11	1	37:1	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	11	2	massachusetts	GPE
cjel-3571	11	3	epa	ORG
cjel-3571	12	1	massachusetts	GPE
cjel-3571	12	2	lujan v. defenders	PERSON
cjel-3571	13	1	massachusetts	GPE
cjel-3571	14	1	massachusetts	GPE
cjel-3571	15	1	massachusetts	GPE
cjel-3571	17	1	massachusetts	GPE
cjel-3571	19	1	massachusetts	GPE
cjel-3571	20	1	i. the lujan	PERSON
cjel-3571	20	2	a. article iii standing	PERSON
cjel-3571	21	1	massachusetts	GPE
cjel-3571	21	2	epa	ORG
cjel-3571	21	3	549	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	21	4	497	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	21	5	2007	DATE
cjel-3571	21	6	laidlaw envtl	PERSON
cjel-3571	22	1	servs.	ORG
cjel-3571	22	2	528	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	22	3	167	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	22	4	2000	DATE
cjel-3571	22	5	steel co.	ORG
cjel-3571	22	6	523	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	22	7	1998	DATE
cjel-3571	22	8	lujan v. defenders	PERSON
cjel-3571	22	9	504	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	22	10	555	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	22	11	1992	DATE
cjel-3571	22	12	lujan v. nat’l	PERSON
cjel-3571	22	13	fed’n	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	22	14	497	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	22	15	871	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	22	16	1990	DATE
cjel-3571	22	17	sierra club	ORG
cjel-3571	22	18	v. morton	PERSON
cjel-3571	22	19	405	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	22	20	727	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	22	21	1972	DATE
cjel-3571	23	1	2012	DATE
cjel-3571	23	2	massachusetts	GPE
cjel-3571	23	3	epa	ORG
cjel-3571	23	4	153	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	23	5	time.2 the supreme court	ORG
cjel-3571	23	6	two	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	23	7	first	ORDINAL
cjel-3571	23	8	the united states	GPE
cjel-3571	24	1	second	ORDINAL
cjel-3571	24	2	two	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	25	1	article iii	PERSON
cjel-3571	26	1	iii jurisprudence	PERSON
cjel-3571	27	1	article iii	PERSON
cjel-3571	27	2	the united states	GPE
cjel-3571	28	1	the united states	GPE
cjel-3571	28	2	2	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	28	3	422	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	28	4	490	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	28	5	498	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	28	6	1975	DATE
cjel-3571	29	1	erwin chemerinsky	PERSON
cjel-3571	30	1	60	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	30	2	3rd	ORDINAL
cjel-3571	31	1	2006	DATE
cjel-3571	33	1	3	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	33	2	christian	NORP
cjel-3571	35	1	church & state, inc.	ORG
cjel-3571	35	2	454	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	35	3	464	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	35	4	474	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	35	5	1982	DATE
cjel-3571	36	1	gladstone	ORG
cjel-3571	37	1	bellwood	GPE
cjel-3571	37	2	441	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	37	3	91	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	37	4	99–100	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	37	5	1979	DATE
cjel-3571	40	1	2	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	40	2	50	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	40	3	20	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	40	4	charles ala wright	PERSON
cjel-3571	40	5	mary kay kane	PERSON
cjel-3571	40	6	14 (2011	DATE
cjel-3571	41	1	lujan v. defend	PERSON
cjel-3571	41	2	504	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	41	3	u.s.	GPE
cjel-3571	41	4	560	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	42	1	6	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	42	2	1	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	42	3	5	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	43	1	prudential standing	ORG
cjel-3571	44	1	3	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	44	2	154	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	46	1	37:1	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	46	2	two	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	46	3	states;—between	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	48	1	base,”8	ORG
cjel-3571	48	2	three	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	48	3	the supreme court	ORG
cjel-3571	48	4	lujan	PERSON
cjel-3571	48	5	article iii standing claims.10 first	LAW
cjel-3571	49	1	”11	ORG
cjel-3571	49	2	second	ORDINAL
cjel-3571	51	1	third	ORDINAL
cjel-3571	51	2	three	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	51	3	one	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	52	1	this 7	DATE
cjel-3571	52	2	u.s.	GPE
cjel-3571	54	1	2	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	54	2	1	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	54	3	lujan v. defenders	PERSON
cjel-3571	54	4	504	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	54	5	u.s.	GPE
cjel-3571	54	6	560	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	56	1	8	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	57	1	william buzbee	PERSON
cjel-3571	57	2	laidlaw	GPE
cjel-3571	57	3	200	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	57	4	205	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	57	5	richard lazarus & oliver a. houck eds.	ORG
cjel-3571	57	6	2005	DATE
cjel-3571	58	1	9	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	59	1	american	NORP
cjel-3571	60	1	one	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	60	2	the last half of the twentieth century	DATE
cjel-3571	61	1	peter l. strauss et al	PERSON
cjel-3571	61	2	byse	PERSON
cjel-3571	61	3	1126	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	61	4	10th	ORDINAL
cjel-3571	61	5	2003	DATE
cjel-3571	61	6	joseph vining	PERSON
cjel-3571	61	7	55	DATE
cjel-3571	61	8	1978	DATE
cjel-3571	61	9	abram chayes	PERSON
cjel-3571	61	10	89	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	62	1	l. rev	PERSON
cjel-3571	62	2	1281	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	62	3	1290	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	62	4	1976	DATE
cjel-3571	63	1	the nineteenth century	DATE
cjel-3571	64	1	steven l. winter	PERSON
cjel-3571	64	2	40	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	65	1	l. rev	PERSON
cjel-3571	65	2	1371	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	65	3	1377	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	65	4	1988	DATE
cjel-3571	66	1	10	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	66	2	lujan v. defenders	PERSON
cjel-3571	66	3	504	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	66	4	u.s.	GPE
cjel-3571	66	5	560–61	DATE
cjel-3571	66	6	three	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	67	1	11	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	68	1	d.	NORP
cjel-3571	68	2	560	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	68	3	13	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	69	1	12	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	71	1	steel co.	ORG
cjel-3571	71	2	523	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	71	3	u.s. 83	DATE
cjel-3571	71	4	103	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	71	5	1998	DATE
cjel-3571	71	6	article iii’s	PERSON
cjel-3571	72	1	supra	PERSON
cjel-3571	72	2	2	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	72	3	63	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	72	4	wright & kane	ORG
cjel-3571	72	5	supra	PERSON
cjel-3571	72	6	3	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	72	7	14	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	73	1	15	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	74	1	wright & kane	ORG
cjel-3571	74	2	supra	PERSON
cjel-3571	74	3	3	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	74	4	14	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	75	1	2012	DATE
cjel-3571	75	2	massachusetts	GPE
cjel-3571	75	3	epa	ORG
cjel-3571	75	4	155	PRODUCT
cjel-3571	75	5	lujan	PERSON
cjel-3571	75	6	massachusetts	GPE
cjel-3571	76	1	b. lujan	PERSON
cjel-3571	76	2	1	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	78	1	the united states	GPE
cjel-3571	78	2	eighth	ORDINAL
cjel-3571	78	3	the supreme court	ORG
cjel-3571	79	1	injury.19	LOC
cjel-3571	79	2	16	DATE
cjel-3571	80	1	1–3	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	80	2	lujan v. defenders	PERSON
cjel-3571	80	3	504	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	80	4	555	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	80	5	1992	DATE
cjel-3571	80	6	90-1424	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	80	7	1991	DATE
cjel-3571	80	8	577004	DATE
cjel-3571	80	9	1–3	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	80	10	lujan v.	PERSON
cjel-3571	80	11	504	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	80	12	u.s.	GPE
cjel-3571	80	13	559	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	84	1	16 u.s.c	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	85	1	1536(a)(2	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	85	2	2006	DATE
cjel-3571	86	1	17	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	87	1	v. lujan	PERSON
cjel-3571	87	2	911	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	87	3	117	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	87	4	122	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	87	5	8th	ORDINAL
cjel-3571	87	6	1990	DATE
cjel-3571	89	1	su mary	PERSON
cjel-3571	89	2	504	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	89	3	u.s.	GPE
cjel-3571	89	4	18	DATE
cjel-3571	90	1	560	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	90	2	iii standing	PERSON
cjel-3571	91	1	555	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	91	2	1992	DATE
cjel-3571	92	1	19	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	93	1	562	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	94	1	20	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	95	1	571–73	DATE
cjel-3571	95	2	7(a)(2	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	95	3	156	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	95	4	columbia journal of environmental	ORG
cjel-3571	97	1	37:1	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	100	1	the lujan court	ORG
cjel-3571	111	1	22	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	112	1	578	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	112	2	21	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	113	1	572	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	113	2	23	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	113	3	lujan	PERSON
cjel-3571	113	4	article iii	PERSON
cjel-3571	113	5	91	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	114	1	l. rev	PERSON
cjel-3571	114	2	163	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	114	3	225	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	114	4	1992	DATE
cjel-3571	116	1	24	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	116	2	lujan v. defenders	PERSON
cjel-3571	116	3	504	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	116	4	u.s.	GPE
cjel-3571	116	5	572	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	117	1	seven	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	117	2	seven	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	118	1	bradford c. mank	ORG
cjel-3571	118	2	massachusetts	GPE
cjel-3571	118	3	epa	ORG
cjel-3571	118	4	34	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	119	1	j. envtl	PERSON
cjel-3571	120	1	l. 1,	PERSON
cjel-3571	120	2	35	DATE
cjel-3571	120	3	2009	DATE
cjel-3571	120	4	robert a. weinstock	PERSON
cjel-3571	120	5	109	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	121	1	l. rev	PERSON
cjel-3571	121	2	798	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	121	3	824	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	121	4	2009	DATE
cjel-3571	121	5	kimberly n. brown	PERSON
cjel-3571	121	6	68	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	121	7	md	GPE
cjel-3571	122	1	l. rev	PERSON
cjel-3571	122	2	221	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	122	3	231	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	122	4	2008	DATE
cjel-3571	122	5	bradford c. mank	ORG
cjel-3571	123	1	massachusetts	GPE
cjel-3571	123	2	epa	ORG
cjel-3571	123	3	49	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	123	4	mary l. rev	PERSON
cjel-3571	123	5	1701	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	123	6	1716	DATE
cjel-3571	123	7	2008	DATE
cjel-3571	123	8	brian j. gatchel	PERSON
cjel-3571	123	9	lujan v.	PERSON
cjel-3571	123	10	11	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	123	11	j. land use & envtl	ORG
cjel-3571	124	1	l. 75,	PERSON
cjel-3571	124	2	91	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	124	3	1995	DATE
cjel-3571	125	1	2012	DATE
cjel-3571	125	2	massachusetts	GPE
cjel-3571	125	3	epa	ORG
cjel-3571	125	4	157	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	125	5	three	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	125	6	1	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	126	1	1	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	127	1	2	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	128	1	3	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	129	1	lujan	PERSON
cjel-3571	129	2	3	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	129	3	1	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	129	4	1	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	129	5	2	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	133	1	2	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	134	1	25	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	135	1	lujan v.	PERSON
cjel-3571	135	2	504	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	135	3	u.s.	GPE
cjel-3571	135	4	560–61	DATE
cjel-3571	135	5	the years	DATE
cjel-3571	135	6	three	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	136	1	first	ORDINAL
cjel-3571	136	2	fact’—an	GPE
cjel-3571	138	1	second	ORDINAL
cjel-3571	139	1	third	ORDINAL
cjel-3571	141	1	26	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	142	1	572	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	143	1	27	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	144	1	562	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	144	2	158	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	146	1	37:1	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	147	1	the lujan court	ORG
cjel-3571	149	1	nepa	PERSON
cjel-3571	149	2	the lujan court	ORG
cjel-3571	150	1	nepa	PERSON
cjel-3571	152	1	c. post-lujan	PERSON
cjel-3571	152	2	lujan	PERSON
cjel-3571	152	3	1992	DATE
cjel-3571	152	4	the supreme court	ORG
cjel-3571	152	5	massachusetts	GPE
cjel-3571	152	6	2007	DATE
cjel-3571	152	7	supreme court	ORG
cjel-3571	152	8	iii standing	PERSON
cjel-3571	152	9	28	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	153	1	573	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	153	2	29	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	154	1	571–73	DATE
cjel-3571	155	1	30	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	157	1	laidlaw envtl	PERSON
cjel-3571	158	1	servs.	ORG
cjel-3571	158	2	528	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	158	3	167	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	158	4	180	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	158	5	fec v. akins	ORG
cjel-3571	158	6	524	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	158	7	11	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	158	8	23–26	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	158	9	1998	DATE
cjel-3571	158	10	steel co.	ORG
cjel-3571	158	11	523	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	158	12	u.s. 83	DATE
cjel-3571	158	13	105	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	158	14	1998	DATE
cjel-3571	158	15	bennett v. spear	PERSON
cjel-3571	158	16	520	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	158	17	u.s.	GPE
cjel-3571	158	18	154	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	158	19	167–69 (1997	DATE
cjel-3571	159	1	31	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	160	1	supreme court	ORG
cjel-3571	160	2	october 2011	DATE
cjel-3571	160	3	massachusetts	GPE
cjel-3571	160	4	epa	ORG
cjel-3571	161	1	one 2009 2012	DATE
cjel-3571	161	2	massachusetts	GPE
cjel-3571	161	3	epa	ORG
cjel-3571	161	4	159	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	161	5	fifteen-year	DATE
cjel-3571	161	6	massachusetts	GPE
cjel-3571	162	1	steel co.	ORG
cjel-3571	162	2	lujan nepa	PERSON
cjel-3571	162	3	nepa	PERSON
cjel-3571	162	4	lujan nepa	PERSON
cjel-3571	162	5	lujan nepa	PERSON
cjel-3571	162	6	the sierra club	ORG
cjel-3571	162	7	the united states	GPE
cjel-3571	162	8	cbe	PERSON
cjel-3571	162	9	supreme court	ORG
cjel-3571	163	1	earth island	LOC
cjel-3571	163	2	555	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	163	3	488	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	163	4	496–97	DATE
cjel-3571	163	5	2009	DATE
cjel-3571	164	1	scalia	PERSON
cjel-3571	164	2	justice thomas	PERSON
cjel-3571	166	1	parma city sch	GPE
cjel-3571	166	2	dist.	PERSON
cjel-3571	167	1	550	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	167	2	516	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	167	3	537	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	167	4	2007	DATE
cjel-3571	167	5	scalia & thomas	ORG
cjel-3571	167	6	jj.	PERSON
cjel-3571	168	1	article iii	PERSON
cjel-3571	170	1	32	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	171	1	steel co.	ORG
cjel-3571	171	2	523	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	171	3	u.s.	GPE
cjel-3571	171	4	86	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	171	5	42 u.s.c	MONEY
cjel-3571	172	1	11001– 11050	DATE
cjel-3571	172	2	2006	DATE
cjel-3571	173	1	33	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	174	1	steel co.	ORG
cjel-3571	174	2	523	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	174	3	u.s.	GPE
cjel-3571	174	4	104–05	DATE
cjel-3571	177	1	lujan v. defenders	PERSON
cjel-3571	177	2	504	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	177	3	u.s.	GPE
cjel-3571	177	4	572	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	177	5	160	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	177	6	columbia journal of environmental	ORG
cjel-3571	179	1	37:1	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	182	1	cbe	PERSON
cjel-3571	182	2	cbe	PERSON
cjel-3571	184	1	third	ORDINAL
cjel-3571	185	1	1998	DATE
cjel-3571	185	2	fec v. akins	ORG
cjel-3571	185	3	nepa	PERSON
cjel-3571	185	4	the akins court	ORG
cjel-3571	185	5	34	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	185	6	lujan v. defenders	PERSON
cjel-3571	185	7	504	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	185	8	u.s.	GPE
cjel-3571	185	9	572	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	185	10	35	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	186	1	amici	PERSON
cjel-3571	186	2	council, inc.	ORG
cjel-3571	186	3	sierra club	ORG
cjel-3571	186	4	united states public interest research group	ORG
cjel-3571	186	5	earth	LOC
cjel-3571	186	6	atlantic	LOC
cjel-3571	186	7	amici	PERSON
cjel-3571	186	8	18	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	186	9	steel co.	ORG
cjel-3571	186	10	523	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	186	11	1998	DATE
cjel-3571	186	12	96-643	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	186	13	1997	DATE
cjel-3571	186	14	351 05	QUANTITY
cjel-3571	186	15	18	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	187	1	1 36	DATE
cjel-3571	187	2	steel co.	ORG
cjel-3571	187	3	523	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	187	4	u.s.	GPE
cjel-3571	187	5	84	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	187	6	37	DATE
cjel-3571	188	1	fec v. akins	ORG
cjel-3571	188	2	524	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	188	3	21	DATE
cjel-3571	188	4	1998	DATE
cjel-3571	189	1	38	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	190	1	16	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	190	2	2	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	191	1	431–55	DATE
cjel-3571	191	2	2006	DATE
cjel-3571	192	1	2012	DATE
cjel-3571	192	2	massachusetts	GPE
cjel-3571	192	3	epa	ORG
cjel-3571	192	4	161	PRODUCT
cjel-3571	192	5	fact.39	GPE
cjel-3571	192	6	lujan	PERSON
cjel-3571	192	7	not.40 akins	PERSON
cjel-3571	192	8	massachusetts	GPE
cjel-3571	192	9	akins	PERSON
cjel-3571	192	10	lujan	GPE
cjel-3571	192	11	massachusetts	GPE
cjel-3571	194	1	massachusetts	GPE
cjel-3571	194	2	the supreme court	ORG
cjel-3571	194	3	lujan	PERSON
cjel-3571	194	4	39	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	195	1	fec v. akins	ORG
cjel-3571	195	2	524	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	195	3	u.s.	GPE
cjel-3571	195	4	21	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	195	5	40	DATE
cjel-3571	196	1	the american bar association	ORG
cjel-3571	198	1	54	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	199	1	l. rev	PERSON
cjel-3571	199	2	17	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	199	3	55	DATE
cjel-3571	199	4	2002	DATE
cjel-3571	201	1	54–55	DATE
cjel-3571	201	2	24	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	201	3	231	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	201	4	lujan	PERSON
cjel-3571	201	5	lujan	PERSON
cjel-3571	201	6	r. sunstein	PERSON
cjel-3571	201	7	147	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	201	8	l. rev	PERSON
cjel-3571	201	9	613	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	201	10	616	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	201	11	1999	DATE
cjel-3571	202	1	41	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	203	1	fec v. akins	ORG
cjel-3571	203	2	524	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	203	3	u.s.	GPE
cjel-3571	203	4	21	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	203	5	lujan v. defenders	PERSON
cjel-3571	203	6	504	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	203	7	555	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	203	8	573	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	203	9	1992	DATE
cjel-3571	204	1	lujan	PERSON
cjel-3571	204	2	kennedy	PERSON
cjel-3571	204	3	souter	PERSON
cjel-3571	204	4	congress	ORG
cjel-3571	204	5	congress	ORG
cjel-3571	205	1	579	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	205	2	kennedy & souter	ORG
cjel-3571	205	3	jj.	PERSON
cjel-3571	205	4	congress	ORG
cjel-3571	207	1	162	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	208	1	37:1	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	208	2	lujan	PERSON
cjel-3571	208	3	massachusetts	GPE
cjel-3571	209	1	massachusetts	GPE
cjel-3571	210	1	a. massachusetts	PERSON
cjel-3571	210	2	lujan	PERSON
cjel-3571	210	3	iii standing	PERSON
cjel-3571	210	4	massachusetts	GPE
cjel-3571	210	5	d.c.	GPE
cjel-3571	210	6	the environmental protection agency	ORG
cjel-3571	210	7	epa	ORG
cjel-3571	210	8	the clean air	LAW
cjel-3571	210	9	the d.c. circuit	ORG
cjel-3571	210	10	epa	ORG
cjel-3571	210	11	the supreme court	ORG
cjel-3571	210	12	certiorari.45	ORG
cjel-3571	210	13	the supreme court	ORG
cjel-3571	210	14	1	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	210	15	massachusetts	GPE
cjel-3571	210	16	2	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	210	17	claim.48	ORG
cjel-3571	210	18	quoting lujan	PERSON
cjel-3571	210	19	congress	ORG
cjel-3571	211	1	42	DATE
cjel-3571	212	1	massachusetts	GPE
cjel-3571	212	2	epa	ORG
cjel-3571	212	3	549	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	212	4	497	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	212	5	516–17	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	212	6	2007	DATE
cjel-3571	213	1	43	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	214	1	massachusetts	GPE
cjel-3571	214	2	epa	ORG
cjel-3571	214	3	415	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	214	4	50	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	214	5	54	DATE
cjel-3571	214	6	d.c	GPE
cjel-3571	214	7	2005	DATE
cjel-3571	214	8	549	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	214	9	497	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	214	10	2007	DATE
cjel-3571	215	1	44	DATE
cjel-3571	216	1	massachusetts	GPE
cjel-3571	216	2	epa	ORG
cjel-3571	216	3	549	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	216	4	u.s.	GPE
cjel-3571	216	5	514	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	216	6	45	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	217	1	massachusetts	GPE
cjel-3571	217	2	epa	ORG
cjel-3571	217	3	548	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	217	4	903	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	217	5	2006	DATE
cjel-3571	218	1	46	DATE
cjel-3571	219	1	only one	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	220	1	massachusetts	GPE
cjel-3571	220	2	epa	ORG
cjel-3571	220	3	549	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	220	4	u.s.	GPE
cjel-3571	220	5	518	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	220	6	only one	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	221	1	massachusetts	GPE
cjel-3571	222	1	521	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	222	2	massachusetts	GPE
cjel-3571	223	1	epa	ORG
cjel-3571	223	2	massachusetts	GPE
cjel-3571	224	1	epa	ORG
cjel-3571	226	1	47	DATE
cjel-3571	227	1	517–18	DATE
cjel-3571	227	2	48	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	228	1	1	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	228	2	49	DATE
cjel-3571	229	1	massachusetts	GPE
cjel-3571	229	2	epa	ORG
cjel-3571	229	3	549	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	229	4	u.s.	GPE
cjel-3571	229	5	517–18	DATE
cjel-3571	230	1	2012	DATE
cjel-3571	230	2	massachusetts	GPE
cjel-3571	230	3	epa	ORG
cjel-3571	230	4	163	PRODUCT
cjel-3571	231	1	congress	ORG
cjel-3571	232	1	epa	ORG
cjel-3571	233	1	42 u.s.c	QUANTITY
cjel-3571	234	1	7607(b)(1	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	235	1	congress	ORG
cjel-3571	236	1	42	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	237	1	congress	ORG
cjel-3571	240	1	the supreme court	ORG
cjel-3571	240	2	epa	ORG
cjel-3571	240	3	massachusetts	GPE
cjel-3571	240	4	50	DATE
cjel-3571	241	1	516	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	242	1	51	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	242	2	42	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	243	1	7607	DATE
cjel-3571	243	2	2006	DATE
cjel-3571	243	3	52	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	244	1	massachusetts	GPE
cjel-3571	244	2	epa	ORG
cjel-3571	244	3	549	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	244	4	u.s.	GPE
cjel-3571	244	5	520	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	244	6	53	DATE
cjel-3571	245	1	42 u.s.c	QUANTITY
cjel-3571	246	1	7607	DATE
cjel-3571	246	2	2006	DATE
cjel-3571	248	1	jerry l. mashaw	PERSON
cjel-3571	248	2	richard a. merrill &	PERSON
cjel-3571	248	3	peter m. shane	PERSON
cjel-3571	248	4	american	NORP
cjel-3571	248	5	1111	DATE
cjel-3571	248	6	6th	ORDINAL
cjel-3571	248	7	2009	DATE
cjel-3571	248	8	stevens	PERSON
cjel-3571	248	9	massachusetts	GPE
cjel-3571	248	10	the clean air act	LAW
cjel-3571	249	1	justice stevens	PERSON
cjel-3571	249	2	42 u.s.c	PERCENT
cjel-3571	251	1	the clean air act’s	LAW
cjel-3571	251	2	epa	ORG
cjel-3571	252	1	jonathan h. adler	PERSON
cjel-3571	252	2	59	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	252	3	w. res	PERSON
cjel-3571	253	1	l. rev	PERSON
cjel-3571	253	2	1061	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	253	3	1076	DATE
cjel-3571	253	4	2009	DATE
cjel-3571	254	1	congress	ORG
cjel-3571	254	2	epa	ORG
cjel-3571	255	1	tyler welti	PERSON
cjel-3571	255	2	massachusetts	GPE
cjel-3571	255	3	epa	ORG
cjel-3571	255	4	94	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	256	1	l. rev	PERSON
cjel-3571	256	2	1751, 1765 (	DATE
cjel-3571	256	3	2008	DATE
cjel-3571	256	4	section 7607(b	LAW
cjel-3571	257	1	epa	ORG
cjel-3571	257	2	ronald a. cass	PERSON
cjel-3571	257	3	massachusetts	GPE
cjel-3571	257	4	epa	ORG
cjel-3571	257	5	93	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	258	1	l. rev	PERSON
cjel-3571	259	1	75	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	259	2	2007	DATE
cjel-3571	259	3	42 u.s.c	QUANTITY
cjel-3571	260	1	epa	ORG
cjel-3571	260	2	164	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	262	1	37:1	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	262	2	second	ORDINAL
cjel-3571	262	3	massachusetts	GPE
cjel-3571	262	4	lujan	PERSON
cjel-3571	263	1	nepa	PERSON
cjel-3571	263	2	eis requirement.56	PERSON
cjel-3571	264	1	massachusetts	GPE
cjel-3571	265	1	”57 b.	PERSON
cjel-3571	265	2	massachusetts	GPE
cjel-3571	265	3	the supreme court’s	ORG
cjel-3571	265	4	massachusetts	GPE
cjel-3571	265	5	massachusetts	GPE
cjel-3571	265	6	lujan	PERSON
cjel-3571	266	1	two	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	266	2	massachusetts	GPE
cjel-3571	266	3	two	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	267	1	lujan	PERSON
cjel-3571	267	2	massachusetts	GPE
cjel-3571	268	1	54	DATE
cjel-3571	269	1	adler	PERSON
cjel-3571	269	2	supra	PERSON
cjel-3571	269	3	53	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	269	4	1076	DATE
cjel-3571	269	5	the clean air act	LAW
cjel-3571	270	1	massachusetts	GPE
cjel-3571	270	2	epa	ORG
cjel-3571	270	3	the clean air	LAW
cjel-3571	270	4	u.s.	GPE
cjel-3571	270	5	the d.c. circuit	ORG
cjel-3571	270	6	daniel a. farber	PERSON
cjel-3571	270	7	55	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	270	8	ucla l. rev	PERSON
cjel-3571	270	9	1505	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	270	10	1524	DATE
cjel-3571	270	11	2008	DATE
cjel-3571	271	1	55	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	272	1	supra	PERSON
cjel-3571	272	2	i.c.	PERSON
cjel-3571	272	3	56	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	273	1	nicholas a. fromherz &	PERSON
cjel-3571	273	2	joseph w.	PERSON
cjel-3571	273	3	massachusetts	GPE
cjel-3571	273	4	epa	ORG
cjel-3571	273	5	29	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	273	6	stan	PERSON
cjel-3571	274	1	envtl	NORP
cjel-3571	275	1	l.j. 130	PERSON
cjel-3571	275	2	146	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	275	3	2010	DATE
cjel-3571	276	1	one	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	276	2	nepa	PERSON
cjel-3571	278	1	57	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	279	1	mashaw et al.	PERSON
cjel-3571	279	2	53	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	279	3	1111	DATE
cjel-3571	280	1	58	DATE
cjel-3571	281	1	pierre j. schlag	PERSON
cjel-3571	281	2	33	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	281	3	ucla l. rev	PERSON
cjel-3571	281	4	379	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	281	5	1985	DATE
cjel-3571	282	1	2012	DATE
cjel-3571	282	2	massachusetts	GPE
cjel-3571	282	3	epa	ORG
cjel-3571	282	4	165	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	282	5	lujan	PERSON
cjel-3571	282	6	massachusetts	GPE
cjel-3571	283	1	two	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	283	2	two	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	284	1	first	ORDINAL
cjel-3571	284	2	eighth	ORDINAL
cjel-3571	285	1	eighth	ORDINAL
cjel-3571	285	2	two	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	285	3	first	ORDINAL
cjel-3571	285	4	7(a)(2	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	285	5	second	ORDINAL
cjel-3571	285	6	16	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	286	1	two	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	288	1	nepa	PERSON
cjel-3571	288	2	eis	ORG
cjel-3571	288	3	two	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	289	1	nepa	PERSON
cjel-3571	289	2	59	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	290	1	lujan v. defenders	PERSON
cjel-3571	290	2	504	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	290	3	555	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	290	4	571–72	DATE
cjel-3571	290	5	1992	DATE
cjel-3571	290	6	the united states	GPE
cjel-3571	292	1	16 u.s.c	MONEY
cjel-3571	294	1	eighth	ORDINAL
cjel-3571	294	2	7(a)(2	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	297	1	60	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	298	1	572	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	298	2	61	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	299	1	571–72	DATE
cjel-3571	299	2	62	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	300	1	572	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	301	1	one	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	301	2	many years	DATE
cjel-3571	302	1	166	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	302	2	columbia journal of environmental	ORG
cjel-3571	304	1	37:1	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	304	2	42	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	305	1	two	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	305	2	massachusetts	GPE
cjel-3571	307	1	congress	ORG
cjel-3571	308	1	epa	ORG
cjel-3571	310	1	massachusetts	GPE
cjel-3571	314	1	63	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	314	2	42	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	315	1	4332(c	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	315	2	2006	DATE
cjel-3571	317	1	64	DATE
cjel-3571	318	1	davis v. mineta	PERSON
cjel-3571	318	2	302	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	318	3	1111	DATE
cjel-3571	318	4	10th	ORDINAL
cjel-3571	318	5	2002	DATE
cjel-3571	319	1	nepa	PERSON
cjel-3571	319	2	calvert cliffs	PERSON
cjel-3571	320	1	u.s.	GPE
cjel-3571	320	2	atomic energy comm’n	ORG
cjel-3571	320	3	449	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	320	4	1109	DATE
cjel-3571	320	5	1115	DATE
cjel-3571	320	6	d.c	GPE
cjel-3571	320	7	cir	ORG
cjel-3571	320	8	1971	DATE
cjel-3571	320	9	section 102	LAW
cjel-3571	320	10	nepa	PERSON
cjel-3571	321	1	richard lazarus	PERSON
cjel-3571	321	2	81	DATE
cjel-3571	321	3	2004	DATE
cjel-3571	321	4	dan tarlock	PERSON
cjel-3571	321	5	calvert cliffs	PERSON
cjel-3571	321	6	8	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	321	7	77	DATE
cjel-3571	321	8	97–100	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	321	9	65	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	322	1	massachusetts	GPE
cjel-3571	322	2	epa	ORG
cjel-3571	322	3	549	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	322	4	497	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	322	5	516–17	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	322	6	520	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	322	7	2007	DATE
cjel-3571	323	1	66	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	324	1	42	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	325	1	7601(b)(1	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	325	2	2006	DATE
cjel-3571	326	1	67	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	327	1	massachusetts	GPE
cjel-3571	327	2	epa	ORG
cjel-3571	327	3	549	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	327	4	u.s.	GPE
cjel-3571	327	5	516	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	327	6	68	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	328	1	521	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	328	2	69	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	329	1	517	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	330	1	70	DATE
cjel-3571	331	1	534	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	331	2	epa	ORG
cjel-3571	335	1	42 u.s.c	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	336	1	7607(d)(9)(a	DATE
cjel-3571	336	2	2006	DATE
cjel-3571	337	1	2012	DATE
cjel-3571	337	2	massachusetts	GPE
cjel-3571	337	3	epa 167   	ORG
cjel-3571	337	4	lujan	PERSON
cjel-3571	337	5	massachusetts	GPE
cjel-3571	338	1	justice holmes	ORG
cjel-3571	338	2	justice cardozo	PERSON
cjel-3571	338	3	nepa	PERSON
cjel-3571	338	4	epa	ORG
cjel-3571	338	5	epa	ORG
cjel-3571	339	1	the supreme court	ORG
cjel-3571	339	2	massachusetts	GPE
cjel-3571	339	3	massachusetts	GPE
cjel-3571	340	1	massachusetts	GPE
cjel-3571	342	1	the “massachusetts	ORG
cjel-3571	343	1	2	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	343	2	lujan	PERSON
cjel-3571	343	3	massachusetts	GPE
cjel-3571	343	4	71	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	344	1	schlag	NORP
cjel-3571	344	2	58	DATE
cjel-3571	344	3	381–83	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	344	4	72	DATE
cjel-3571	345	1	pokora	GPE
cjel-3571	345	2	wabash ry.	PERSON
cjel-3571	345	3	292	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	345	4	u.s.	GPE
cjel-3571	345	5	105–06	DATE
cjel-3571	345	6	1934	DATE
cjel-3571	345	7	balt.	ORG
cjel-3571	347	1	ohio	GPE
cjel-3571	347	2	r.r.	ORG
cjel-3571	348	1	goodman	ORG
cjel-3571	348	2	275	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	348	3	u.s.	GPE
cjel-3571	348	4	66	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	348	5	69–70	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	348	6	1927	DATE
cjel-3571	348	7	marc a. franklin	PERSON
cjel-3571	348	8	robert l. rabin &	PERSON
cjel-3571	348	9	michael d. green	PERSON
cjel-3571	348	10	60–66	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	348	11	8th	ORDINAL
cjel-3571	348	12	2006	DATE
cjel-3571	349	1	73	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	350	1	mashaw et al.	PERSON
cjel-3571	350	2	53	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	350	3	1111	DATE
cjel-3571	350	4	54	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	350	5	1554	DATE
cjel-3571	350	6	massachusetts	GPE
cjel-3571	350	7	epa	ORG
cjel-3571	351	1	168	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	353	1	37:1	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	353	2	2	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	353	3	lujan	GPE
cjel-3571	353	4	massachusetts lujan lujan’s	PERSON
cjel-3571	353	5	nepa	PERSON
cjel-3571	353	6	massachusetts i.	PERSON
cjel-3571	353	7	1	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	353	8	nepa	ORG
cjel-3571	353	9	2	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	354	1	16	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	355	1	42	DATE
cjel-3571	356	1	recognition	PERSON
cjel-3571	357	1	2	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	357	2	lujan	PERSON
cjel-3571	357	3	massachusetts	GPE
cjel-3571	359	1	massachusetts	GPE
cjel-3571	359	2	lujan	PERSON
cjel-3571	359	3	rights.74 iii	PERSON
cjel-3571	360	1	the massachusetts modification a.	ORG
cjel-3571	360	2	the supreme court	ORG
cjel-3571	360	3	massachusetts	GPE
cjel-3571	360	4	the supreme court	ORG
cjel-3571	360	5	74	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	361	1	massachusetts	GPE
cjel-3571	361	2	epa	ORG
cjel-3571	361	3	549	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	361	4	u.s.	GPE
cjel-3571	361	5	518	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	361	6	520	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	362	1	2012	DATE
cjel-3571	362	2	massachusetts	GPE
cjel-3571	362	3	epa	ORG
cjel-3571	362	4	169	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	362	5	the supreme court	ORG
cjel-3571	362	6	massachusetts	GPE
cjel-3571	365	1	massachusetts	GPE
cjel-3571	365	2	fifteen years	DATE
cjel-3571	365	3	the supreme court	ORG
cjel-3571	366	1	the supreme court	ORG
cjel-3571	366	2	massachusetts	GPE
cjel-3571	367	1	massachusetts	GPE
cjel-3571	367	2	institute.76	GPE
cjel-3571	367	3	1992	DATE
cjel-3571	367	4	u.s.	GPE
cjel-3571	367	5	75	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	368	1	earth island	LOC
cjel-3571	368	2	555	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	368	3	488	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	368	4	496–97	DATE
cjel-3571	368	5	2009	DATE
cjel-3571	369	1	76	DATE
cjel-3571	370	1	d.	NORP
cjel-3571	370	2	supreme court	ORG
cjel-3571	370	3	american electric power co.	ORG
cjel-3571	370	4	connecticut	GPE
cjel-3571	371	1	one	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	371	2	eight	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	371	3	the supreme court	ORG
cjel-3571	372	1	131	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	372	2	s. ct	PERSON
cjel-3571	372	3	2527	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	372	4	2535	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	372	5	2011	DATE
cjel-3571	373	1	four	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	373	2	massachusetts	GPE
cjel-3571	373	3	epa	ORG
cjel-3571	373	4	massachusetts	GPE
cjel-3571	373	5	epa	ORG
cjel-3571	373	6	549	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	373	7	u.s.	GPE
cjel-3571	373	8	520–26	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	374	1	four	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	374	2	massachusetts	GPE
cjel-3571	374	3	epa	ORG
cjel-3571	374	4	549	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	374	5	u.s.	GPE
cjel-3571	374	6	535	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	375	1	second	ORDINAL
cjel-3571	376	1	nye v. united states	PERSON
cjel-3571	376	2	313	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	376	3	33, 44	DATE
cjel-3571	378	1	daniel a. farber	PERSON
cjel-3571	378	2	american	NORP
cjel-3571	378	3	121	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	378	4	yale l.j.	PERSON
cjel-3571	379	1	121	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	379	2	2011	DATE
cjel-3571	379	3	michael b. gerrard	PERSON
cjel-3571	379	4	121	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	379	5	l.j.	ORG
cjel-3571	380	1	135	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	380	2	2011	DATE
cjel-3571	381	1	77	DATE
cjel-3571	382	1	earth island	LOC
cjel-3571	382	2	555	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	382	3	u.s.	GPE
cjel-3571	382	4	496	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	382	5	78	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	383	1	forest department	ORG
cjel-3571	383	2	1993	DATE
cjel-3571	385	1	102-381	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	385	2	322	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	385	3	106	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	386	1	1374	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	386	2	1419–20	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	386	3	1992	DATE
cjel-3571	387	1	earth island	LOC
cjel-3571	387	2	170	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	387	3	columbia	ORG
cjel-3571	388	1	37:1	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	388	2	less than 250 acres	QUANTITY
cjel-3571	388	3	impact.80	ORG
cjel-3571	388	4	usfs	ORG
cjel-3571	388	5	238-acre	QUANTITY
cjel-3571	388	6	82	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	388	7	application.85	ORG
cjel-3571	388	8	ninth	ORDINAL
cjel-3571	388	9	ninth	ORDINAL
cjel-3571	388	10	the supreme court	ORG
cjel-3571	389	1	the supreme court	ORG
cjel-3571	389	2	iii standing	PERSON
cjel-3571	389	3	ninth	ORDINAL
cjel-3571	389	4	555	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	389	5	u.s.	GPE
cjel-3571	389	6	490	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	389	7	79	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	390	1	earth island	LOC
cjel-3571	390	2	555	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	390	3	u.s.	GPE
cjel-3571	390	4	490	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	390	5	80	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	391	1	d.	NORP
cjel-3571	391	2	491	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	392	1	82	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	393	1	81	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	394	1	83	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	394	2	earth island	LOC
cjel-3571	395	1	v. pengilly	PERSON
cjel-3571	395	2	376	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	395	3	f. supp	PERSON
cjel-3571	396	1	2d 994	DATE
cjel-3571	396	2	999	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	396	3	e.d. cal	ORG
cjel-3571	396	4	2005	DATE
cjel-3571	397	1	84	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	398	1	earth island	LOC
cjel-3571	398	2	555	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	398	3	u.s.	GPE
cjel-3571	398	4	492	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	398	5	85	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	398	6	earth island	LOC
cjel-3571	399	1	v. pengilly	PERSON
cjel-3571	399	2	376	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	399	3	f. supp	PERSON
cjel-3571	400	1	2d	DATE
cjel-3571	400	2	1011	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	401	1	86	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	402	1	earth island	LOC
cjel-3571	402	2	555	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	402	3	u.s.	GPE
cjel-3571	402	4	488	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	402	5	earth island	LOC
cjel-3571	403	1	v. ruthenbeck	PERSON
cjel-3571	403	2	490	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	403	3	687	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	403	4	690	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	403	5	9th	ORDINAL
cjel-3571	403	6	2007	DATE
cjel-3571	403	7	earth island	LOC
cjel-3571	403	8	555	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	403	9	488	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	403	10	2009	DATE
cjel-3571	404	1	2012	DATE
cjel-3571	404	2	massachusetts	GPE
cjel-3571	404	3	epa	ORG
cjel-3571	404	4	171	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	404	5	one	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	404	6	lujan	PERSON
cjel-3571	404	7	1	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	404	8	lujan	PERSON
cjel-3571	404	9	3	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	404	10	iii standing	PERSON
cjel-3571	404	11	iii standing	PERSON
cjel-3571	405	1	lujan	GPE
cjel-3571	406	1	”92	GPE
cjel-3571	406	2	massachusetts	GPE
cjel-3571	407	1	massachusetts	GPE
cjel-3571	407	2	harms.93	NORP
cjel-3571	407	3	87	DATE
cjel-3571	408	1	earth island	LOC
cjel-3571	408	2	555	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	408	3	u.s.	GPE
cjel-3571	408	4	500–01	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	408	5	88	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	409	1	494	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	409	2	89	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	410	1	495–96	DATE
cjel-3571	411	1	bradford c. mank	ORG
cjel-3571	411	2	40	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	412	1	10958	DATE
cjel-3571	412	2	2010	DATE
cjel-3571	412	3	maria banda	PERSON
cjel-3571	412	4	earth island institute	LOC
cjel-3571	412	5	34	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	413	1	envtl	NORP
cjel-3571	414	1	l. rev	PERSON
cjel-3571	414	2	321	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	414	3	323–26	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	414	4	2010	DATE
cjel-3571	414	5	michelle fon	PERSON
cjel-3571	414	6	anne lee	PERSON
cjel-3571	414	7	37	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	414	8	381	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	414	9	383	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	414	10	2010	DATE
cjel-3571	415	1	90	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	416	1	earth island	LOC
cjel-3571	416	2	555	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	416	3	u.s.	GPE
cjel-3571	416	4	496	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	416	5	iii standing	PERSON
cjel-3571	417	1	91	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	418	1	488	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	419	1	92	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	420	1	earth island	LOC
cjel-3571	420	2	555	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	420	3	u.s.	GPE
cjel-3571	420	4	497	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	420	5	93	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	421	1	488–501	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	422	1	justice kennedy	PERSON
cjel-3571	422	2	lujan	PERSON
cjel-3571	422	3	congress	ORG
cjel-3571	422	4	congress	ORG
cjel-3571	423	1	501	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	423	2	kennedy	PERSON
cjel-3571	423	3	j.	PERSON
cjel-3571	424	1	stevens	PERSON
cjel-3571	424	2	172	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	426	1	37:1	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	426	2	u.s.	GPE
cjel-3571	426	3	u.s.	GPE
cjel-3571	426	4	massachusetts	GPE
cjel-3571	427	1	late 2011	DATE
cjel-3571	427	2	only two	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	427	3	nrdc	ORG
cjel-3571	427	4	epa	ORG
cjel-3571	427	5	ninth	ORDINAL
cjel-3571	427	6	north carolina	GPE
cjel-3571	427	7	epa	ORG
cjel-3571	427	8	nrdc	ORG
cjel-3571	427	9	epa	ORG
cjel-3571	427	10	massachusetts	GPE
cjel-3571	427	11	north carolina	GPE
cjel-3571	427	12	epa	ORG
cjel-3571	427	13	litigants.97	PERSON
cjel-3571	427	14	nrdc v. epa,98 the plaintiffs	ORG
cjel-3571	427	15	connecticut	GPE
cjel-3571	427	16	new york	GPE
cjel-3571	427	17	epa	ORG
cjel-3571	427	18	ninth	ORDINAL
cjel-3571	427	19	massachusetts	GPE
cjel-3571	427	20	epa	ORG
cjel-3571	428	1	massachusetts	GPE
cjel-3571	428	2	epa	ORG
cjel-3571	428	3	ginsburg	GPE
cjel-3571	428	4	massachusetts	GPE
cjel-3571	428	5	congress	ORG
cjel-3571	429	1	502–05	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	429	2	j.	PERSON
cjel-3571	430	1	massachusetts	GPE
cjel-3571	430	2	massachusetts	GPE
cjel-3571	431	1	d.	NORP
cjel-3571	431	2	i.c	PERSON
cjel-3571	432	1	l 94	DATE
cjel-3571	434	1	epa	ORG
cjel-3571	434	2	542	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	434	3	1235	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	434	4	1246	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	434	5	9th	ORDINAL
cjel-3571	434	6	2008	DATE
cjel-3571	435	1	massachusetts	GPE
cjel-3571	436	1	95	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	437	1	north carolina	GPE
cjel-3571	437	2	epa	ORG
cjel-3571	437	3	587	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	437	4	422	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	437	5	426	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	437	6	d.c	GPE
cjel-3571	437	7	cir	ORG
cjel-3571	437	8	2009	DATE
cjel-3571	438	1	96	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	439	1	104	ORG
cjel-3571	440	1	97	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	441	1	107	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	442	1	98	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	443	1	epa	ORG
cjel-3571	443	2	542	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	443	3	1235	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	443	4	the clean water act	LAW
cjel-3571	443	5	epa	ORG
cjel-3571	443	6	epa	ORG
cjel-3571	444	1	99	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	445	1	1241	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	446	1	100	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	446	2	31	DATE
cjel-3571	447	1	epa	ORG
cjel-3571	447	2	542	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	447	3	1235	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	447	4	9th	ORDINAL
cjel-3571	447	5	2008	DATE
cjel-3571	447	6	07-55183	DATE
cjel-3571	447	7	07-55261	DATE
cjel-3571	447	8	2007	DATE
cjel-3571	447	9	4559423	DATE
cjel-3571	447	10	31	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	447	11	2012	DATE
cjel-3571	447	12	massachusetts	GPE
cjel-3571	447	13	epa	ORG
cjel-3571	447	14	173	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	449	1	ninth	ORDINAL
cjel-3571	450	1	epa	ORG
cjel-3571	451	1	the supreme court	ORG
cjel-3571	452	1	massachusetts	GPE
cjel-3571	452	2	epa	ORG
cjel-3571	452	3	549	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	452	4	497	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	452	5	2007	DATE
cjel-3571	452	6	lujan	PERSON
cjel-3571	452	7	504	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	452	8	u.s.	GPE
cjel-3571	452	9	572	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	453	1	lujan	PERSON
cjel-3571	454	1	504	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	454	2	u.s.	GPE
cjel-3571	454	3	573 n.8	QUANTITY
cjel-3571	454	4	massachusetts	GPE
cjel-3571	454	5	epa	ORG
cjel-3571	454	6	ninth	ORDINAL
cjel-3571	454	7	massachusetts	GPE
cjel-3571	455	1	massachusetts	GPE
cjel-3571	456	1	massachusetts	GPE
cjel-3571	456	2	101	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	457	1	d.	NORP
cjel-3571	457	2	102	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	459	1	epa	ORG
cjel-3571	459	2	542	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	459	3	1244–49	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	459	4	103	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	460	1	1246	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	461	1	174	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	462	1	37:1	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	463	1	ninth	ORDINAL
cjel-3571	463	2	d.c.	GPE
cjel-3571	463	3	massachusetts	GPE
cjel-3571	463	4	massachusetts	GPE
cjel-3571	463	5	2009	DATE
cjel-3571	463	6	massachusetts	GPE
cjel-3571	463	7	massachusetts	GPE
cjel-3571	463	8	north carolina	GPE
cjel-3571	463	9	epa	ORG
cjel-3571	463	10	42	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	464	1	7607(b)(1	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	464	2	north carolina	GPE
cjel-3571	465	1	massachusetts	GPE
cjel-3571	465	2	epa	ORG
cjel-3571	465	3	549	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	465	4	u.s.	GPE
cjel-3571	465	5	520	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	467	1	518.106	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	467	2	massachusetts	GPE
cjel-3571	467	3	42	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	469	1	north carolina’s	GPE
cjel-3571	469	2	104	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	470	1	d.	NORP
cjel-3571	470	2	massachusetts	GPE
cjel-3571	470	3	ninth	ORDINAL
cjel-3571	470	4	only one	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	471	1	1248	DATE
cjel-3571	473	1	massachusetts	GPE
cjel-3571	473	2	epa	ORG
cjel-3571	473	3	549	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	473	4	497	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	473	5	518	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	473	6	2007	DATE
cjel-3571	474	1	massachusetts	GPE
cjel-3571	474	2	the supreme court	ORG
cjel-3571	474	3	massachusetts	GPE
cjel-3571	475	1	massachusetts	GPE
cjel-3571	475	2	epa	ORG
cjel-3571	475	3	549	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	475	4	u.s.	GPE
cjel-3571	475	5	518–21	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	475	6	105	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	476	1	north carolina	GPE
cjel-3571	476	2	epa	ORG
cjel-3571	476	3	587	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	476	4	422	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	476	5	426	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	476	6	d.c	GPE
cjel-3571	476	7	cir	ORG
cjel-3571	476	8	2009	DATE
cjel-3571	476	9	ctr	GPE
cjel-3571	477	1	u.s. dep’t	GPE
cjel-3571	477	2	563	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	477	3	466	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	477	4	476–77	DATE
cjel-3571	477	5	d.c.	GPE
cjel-3571	477	6	cir	ORG
cjel-3571	477	7	2009	DATE
cjel-3571	477	8	106	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	478	1	north carolina	GPE
cjel-3571	478	2	epa	ORG
cjel-3571	478	3	587	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	478	4	426	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	478	5	107	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	479	1	several months earlier	DATE
cjel-3571	479	2	2009	DATE
cjel-3571	481	1	563	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	481	2	475–79	DATE
cjel-3571	482	1	massachusetts	GPE
cjel-3571	482	2	massachusetts	GPE
cjel-3571	483	1	476–77	DATE
cjel-3571	484	1	2012	DATE
cjel-3571	484	2	massachusetts	GPE
cjel-3571	484	3	epa	ORG
cjel-3571	484	4	175	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	484	5	massachusetts	GPE
cjel-3571	485	1	massachusetts	GPE
cjel-3571	486	1	massachusetts	GPE
cjel-3571	487	1	lujan	PERSON
cjel-3571	491	1	john m. harlan	PERSON
cjel-3571	492	1	”108	ORG
cjel-3571	492	2	john roberts	PERSON
cjel-3571	492	3	massachusetts	GPE
cjel-3571	492	4	epa	ORG
cjel-3571	493	1	”109	PERSON
cjel-3571	496	1	479	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	497	1	lujan	PERSON
cjel-3571	497	2	massachusetts	GPE
cjel-3571	497	3	the lujan/massachusetts	ORG
cjel-3571	498	1	d.	NORP
cjel-3571	498	2	108	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	499	1	flast v. cohen	PERSON
cjel-3571	499	2	392	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	499	3	83	DATE
cjel-3571	499	4	129	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	499	5	1968	DATE
cjel-3571	499	6	harlan	PERSON
cjel-3571	499	7	j.	PERSON
cjel-3571	500	1	109	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	500	2	massachusetts	GPE
cjel-3571	500	3	epa	ORG
cjel-3571	500	4	549	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	500	5	497	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	500	6	547	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	500	7	2007	DATE
cjel-3571	500	8	c.j.	GPE
cjel-3571	501	1	110	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	502	1	william a. fletcher	PERSON
cjel-3571	502	2	98	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	502	3	yale l.j	PERSON
cjel-3571	502	4	221	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	502	5	221	CARDINAL
cjel-3571	502	6	1988	DATE