id sid tid token lemma pos cjel-3536 1 1 microsoft microsoft PROPN cjel-3536 1 2 word word PROPN cjel-3536 1 3 mank mank PROPN cjel-3536 1 4 - - PUNCT cjel-3536 1 5 macro-[final macro-[final PROPN cjel-3536 1 6 6 6 NUM cjel-3536 1 7 - - SYM cjel-3536 1 8 19 19 NUM cjel-3536 1 9 ] ] PUNCT cjel-3536 1 10 mank mank NOUN cjel-3536 1 11 - - PUNCT cjel-3536 1 12 macro-[final macro-[final PROPN cjel-3536 1 13 6 6 NUM cjel-3536 1 14 - - SYM cjel-3536 1 15 19 19 NUM cjel-3536 1 16 ] ] PUNCT cjel-3536 1 17 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 1 18 do do AUX cjel-3536 1 19 not not PART cjel-3536 1 20 delete delete VERB cjel-3536 1 21 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 2 1 6/22/2015 6/22/2015 NUM cjel-3536 2 2 11:45 11:45 NUM cjel-3536 2 3 pm pm NOUN cjel-3536 2 4 305 305 NUM cjel-3536 2 5 standing stand VERB cjel-3536 2 6 to to PART cjel-3536 2 7 view view VERB cjel-3536 2 8 other other ADJ cjel-3536 2 9 people people NOUN cjel-3536 2 10 ’s ’s PART cjel-3536 2 11 land land NOUN cjel-3536 2 12 : : PUNCT cjel-3536 2 13 the the DET cjel-3536 2 14 d.c d.c PROPN cjel-3536 2 15 . . PROPN cjel-3536 2 16 circuit circuit PROPN cjel-3536 2 17 ’s ’s PART cjel-3536 2 18 divided divide VERB cjel-3536 2 19 decision decision NOUN cjel-3536 2 20 in in ADP cjel-3536 2 21 sierra sierra PROPN cjel-3536 2 22 club club PROPN cjel-3536 2 23 v. v. PROPN cjel-3536 2 24 jewell jewell PROPN cjel-3536 2 25 bradford bradford PROPN cjel-3536 2 26 c. c. PROPN cjel-3536 2 27 mank mank PROPN cjel-3536 2 28 * * PROPN cjel-3536 2 29 i. i. PROPN cjel-3536 2 30 introduction introduction NOUN cjel-3536 2 31 .......................................................................... .......................................................................... PUNCT cjel-3536 3 1 306 306 NUM cjel-3536 3 2     SPACE cjel-3536 3 3 ii ii NOUN cjel-3536 3 4 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 3 5     SPACE cjel-3536 3 6 introduction introduction NOUN cjel-3536 3 7 to to ADP cjel-3536 3 8 article article PROPN cjel-3536 3 9 iii iii NUM cjel-3536 3 10 standing standing PROPN cjel-3536 3 11 .................................. .................................. PUNCT cjel-3536 3 12 307 307 NUM cjel-3536 3 13     SPACE cjel-3536 3 14 iii iii NOUN cjel-3536 3 15 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 3 16     SPACE cjel-3536 3 17 the the DET cjel-3536 3 18 d.c d.c PROPN cjel-3536 3 19 . . PROPN cjel-3536 3 20 circuit circuit PROPN cjel-3536 3 21 ’s ’s PART cjel-3536 3 22 divided divide VERB cjel-3536 3 23 decision decision NOUN cjel-3536 3 24 in in ADP cjel-3536 3 25 sierra sierra PROPN cjel-3536 3 26 club club PROPN cjel-3536 3 27 v. v. PROPN cjel-3536 3 28 jewell jewell PROPN cjel-3536 3 29 ................................................................................... ................................................................................... PUNCT cjel-3536 3 30 309 309 NUM cjel-3536 3 31     SPACE cjel-3536 3 32 a. a. NOUN cjel-3536 3 33     SPACE cjel-3536 3 34 the the DET cjel-3536 3 35 district district NOUN cjel-3536 3 36 court court NOUN cjel-3536 3 37 ’s ’s PART cjel-3536 3 38 decision decision NOUN cjel-3536 3 39 denying deny VERB cjel-3536 3 40 article article PROPN cjel-3536 3 41 iii iii NUM cjel-3536 3 42 standing standing PROPN cjel-3536 3 43 .......................................................................... .......................................................................... PUNCT cjel-3536 3 44 310 310 NUM cjel-3536 3 45     SPACE cjel-3536 3 46 b. b. PROPN cjel-3536 3 47     SPACE cjel-3536 3 48 the the DET cjel-3536 3 49 d.c d.c PROPN cjel-3536 3 50 . . PROPN cjel-3536 3 51 circuit circuit PROPN cjel-3536 3 52 ’s ’s PART cjel-3536 3 53 majority majority NOUN cjel-3536 3 54 opinion opinion NOUN cjel-3536 3 55 .............................. .............................. PUNCT cjel-3536 3 56 311 311 NUM cjel-3536 3 57     SPACE cjel-3536 3 58 * * PUNCT cjel-3536 3 59 james james PROPN cjel-3536 3 60 helmer helmer PROPN cjel-3536 3 61 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 3 62 jr jr PROPN cjel-3536 3 63 . . PROPN cjel-3536 3 64 professor professor PROPN cjel-3536 3 65 of of ADP cjel-3536 3 66 law law NOUN cjel-3536 3 67 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 3 68 university university PROPN cjel-3536 3 69 of of ADP cjel-3536 3 70 cincinnati cincinnati PROPN cjel-3536 3 71 college college PROPN cjel-3536 3 72 of of ADP cjel-3536 3 73 law law PROPN cjel-3536 3 74 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 3 75 p.o p.o PROPN cjel-3536 3 76 . . PROPN cjel-3536 3 77 box box PROPN cjel-3536 3 78 210040 210040 NUM cjel-3536 3 79 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 3 80 university university NOUN cjel-3536 3 81 of of ADP cjel-3536 3 82 cincinnati cincinnati PROPN cjel-3536 3 83 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 3 84 cincinnati cincinnati PROPN cjel-3536 3 85 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 3 86 ohio ohio PROPN cjel-3536 3 87 45221 45221 NUM cjel-3536 3 88 - - SYM cjel-3536 3 89 0040 0040 NUM cjel-3536 3 90 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 3 91 telephone telephone NOUN cjel-3536 3 92 513556 513556 NUM cjel-3536 3 93 - - SYM cjel-3536 3 94 0094 0094 NUM cjel-3536 3 95 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 3 96 fax fax NOUN cjel-3536 3 97 513 513 NUM cjel-3536 3 98 - - PUNCT cjel-3536 3 99 556 556 NUM cjel-3536 3 100 - - SYM cjel-3536 3 101 1236 1236 NUM cjel-3536 3 102 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 3 103 e e NOUN cjel-3536 3 104 - - NOUN cjel-3536 3 105 mail mail NOUN cjel-3536 3 106 : : PUNCT cjel-3536 3 107 brad.mank@uc.edu brad.mank@uc.edu X cjel-3536 3 108 all all DET cjel-3536 3 109 errors error NOUN cjel-3536 3 110 or or CCONJ cjel-3536 3 111 omissions omission NOUN cjel-3536 3 112 in in ADP cjel-3536 3 113 this this DET cjel-3536 3 114 essay essay NOUN cjel-3536 3 115 are be AUX cjel-3536 3 116 my my PRON cjel-3536 3 117 responsibility responsibility NOUN cjel-3536 3 118 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 4 1 this this DET cjel-3536 4 2 article article NOUN cjel-3536 4 3 is be AUX cjel-3536 4 4 one one NUM cjel-3536 4 5 of of ADP cjel-3536 4 6 a a DET cjel-3536 4 7 series series NOUN cjel-3536 4 8 of of ADP cjel-3536 4 9 explorations exploration NOUN cjel-3536 4 10 of of ADP cjel-3536 4 11 modern modern ADJ cjel-3536 4 12 standing standing NOUN cjel-3536 4 13 doctrines doctrine NOUN cjel-3536 4 14 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 5 1 the the DET cjel-3536 5 2 other other ADJ cjel-3536 5 3 pieces piece NOUN cjel-3536 5 4 are be AUX cjel-3536 5 5 1 1 NUM cjel-3536 5 6 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 5 7 should should AUX cjel-3536 5 8 states state NOUN cjel-3536 5 9 have have VERB cjel-3536 5 10 greater great ADJ cjel-3536 5 11 standing standing NOUN cjel-3536 5 12 rights right NOUN cjel-3536 5 13 than than ADP cjel-3536 5 14 ordinary ordinary ADJ cjel-3536 5 15 citizens citizen NOUN cjel-3536 5 16 ? ? PUNCT cjel-3536 5 17 : : PUNCT cjel-3536 6 1 massachusetts massachusetts PROPN cjel-3536 6 2 v. v. ADP cjel-3536 6 3 epa epa PROPN cjel-3536 6 4 ’s ’s PART cjel-3536 6 5 new new ADJ cjel-3536 6 6 standing standing NOUN cjel-3536 6 7 test test NOUN cjel-3536 6 8 for for ADP cjel-3536 6 9 states state NOUN cjel-3536 6 10 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 6 11 49 49 NUM cjel-3536 6 12 wm wm PROPN cjel-3536 6 13 . . PROPN cjel-3536 6 14 & & CCONJ cjel-3536 6 15 mary mary PROPN cjel-3536 6 16 l. l. PROPN cjel-3536 6 17 rev rev PROPN cjel-3536 6 18 . . PROPN cjel-3536 6 19 1701 1701 NUM cjel-3536 6 20 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 6 21 2008 2008 NUM cjel-3536 6 22 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 6 23 ; ; PUNCT cjel-3536 6 24 2 2 X cjel-3536 6 25 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 6 26 standing standing NOUN cjel-3536 6 27 and and CCONJ cjel-3536 6 28 future future ADJ cjel-3536 6 29 generations generation NOUN cjel-3536 6 30 : : PUNCT cjel-3536 6 31 does do AUX cjel-3536 6 32 massachusetts massachusetts PROPN cjel-3536 6 33 v. v. ADP cjel-3536 6 34 epa epa PROPN cjel-3536 6 35 open open ADJ cjel-3536 6 36 standing stand VERB cjel-3536 6 37 for for ADP cjel-3536 6 38 the the DET cjel-3536 6 39 unborn unborn ADJ cjel-3536 6 40 ? ? PUNCT cjel-3536 6 41 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 6 42 34 34 NUM cjel-3536 6 43 colum colum NOUN cjel-3536 6 44 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 7 1 j. j. PROPN cjel-3536 7 2 envtl envtl PROPN cjel-3536 7 3 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 8 1 l. l. PROPN cjel-3536 8 2 1 1 NUM cjel-3536 8 3 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 8 4 2009 2009 NUM cjel-3536 8 5 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 8 6 ; ; PUNCT cjel-3536 8 7 3 3 X cjel-3536 8 8 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 8 9 standing stand VERB cjel-3536 8 10 and and CCONJ cjel-3536 8 11 statistical statistical ADJ cjel-3536 8 12 persons person NOUN cjel-3536 8 13 : : PUNCT cjel-3536 8 14 a a DET cjel-3536 8 15 risk risk NOUN cjel-3536 8 16 - - PUNCT cjel-3536 8 17 based base VERB cjel-3536 8 18 approach approach NOUN cjel-3536 8 19 to to ADP cjel-3536 8 20 standing standing NOUN cjel-3536 8 21 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 8 22 36 36 NUM cjel-3536 8 23 ecology ecology NOUN cjel-3536 8 24 l.q l.q PROPN cjel-3536 8 25 . . PROPN cjel-3536 8 26 665 665 NUM cjel-3536 8 27 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 8 28 2009 2009 NUM cjel-3536 8 29 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 8 30 ; ; PUNCT cjel-3536 8 31 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 8 32 4 4 X cjel-3536 8 33 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 8 34 summers summer NOUN cjel-3536 8 35 v. v. ADP cjel-3536 8 36 earth earth PROPN cjel-3536 8 37 island island PROPN cjel-3536 8 38 institute institute PROPN cjel-3536 8 39 rejects reject VERB cjel-3536 8 40 probabilistic probabilistic ADJ cjel-3536 8 41 standing standing NOUN cjel-3536 8 42 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 8 43 but but CCONJ cjel-3536 8 44 a a DET cjel-3536 8 45 “ " PUNCT cjel-3536 8 46 realistic realistic ADJ cjel-3536 8 47 threat threat NOUN cjel-3536 8 48 ” " PUNCT cjel-3536 8 49 of of ADP cjel-3536 8 50 harm harm NOUN cjel-3536 8 51 is be AUX cjel-3536 8 52 a a DET cjel-3536 8 53 better well ADJ cjel-3536 8 54 standing stand VERB cjel-3536 8 55 test test NOUN cjel-3536 8 56 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 8 57 40 40 NUM cjel-3536 8 58 envtl envtl NOUN cjel-3536 8 59 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 9 1 l. l. PROPN cjel-3536 9 2 89 89 NUM cjel-3536 9 3 – – PUNCT cjel-3536 9 4 139 139 NUM cjel-3536 9 5 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 9 6 2010 2010 NUM cjel-3536 9 7 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 9 8 ; ; PUNCT cjel-3536 9 9 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 9 10 5 5 X cjel-3536 9 11 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 9 12 revisiting revisit VERB cjel-3536 9 13 the the DET cjel-3536 9 14 lyons lyons PROPN cjel-3536 9 15 den den PROPN cjel-3536 9 16 : : PUNCT cjel-3536 9 17 summers summer NOUN cjel-3536 9 18 v. v. ADP cjel-3536 9 19 earth earth PROPN cjel-3536 9 20 island island PROPN cjel-3536 9 21 institute institute PROPN cjel-3536 9 22 ’s ’s PART cjel-3536 9 23 misuse misuse NOUN cjel-3536 9 24 of of ADP cjel-3536 9 25 lyons lyon NOUN cjel-3536 9 26 ’ ' PUNCT cjel-3536 9 27 “ " PUNCT cjel-3536 9 28 realistic realistic ADJ cjel-3536 9 29 threat threat NOUN cjel-3536 9 30 ” " PUNCT cjel-3536 9 31 of of ADP cjel-3536 9 32 harm harm NOUN cjel-3536 9 33 standing stand VERB cjel-3536 9 34 test test NOUN cjel-3536 9 35 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 9 36 42 42 NUM cjel-3536 9 37 ariz ariz NOUN cjel-3536 9 38 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 10 1 st st PROPN cjel-3536 10 2 . . PROPN cjel-3536 10 3 l.j l.j PROPN cjel-3536 10 4 837 837 NUM cjel-3536 10 5 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 10 6 2010 2010 NUM cjel-3536 10 7 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 10 8 ; ; PUNCT cjel-3536 10 9 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 10 10 6 6 X cjel-3536 10 11 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 10 12 summers summer NOUN cjel-3536 10 13 v. v. ADP cjel-3536 10 14 earth earth PROPN cjel-3536 10 15 island island PROPN cjel-3536 10 16 institute institute PROPN cjel-3536 10 17 : : PUNCT cjel-3536 10 18 its its PRON cjel-3536 10 19 implications implication NOUN cjel-3536 10 20 for for ADP cjel-3536 10 21 future future ADJ cjel-3536 10 22 standing standing NOUN cjel-3536 10 23 decisions decision NOUN cjel-3536 10 24 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 10 25 40 40 NUM cjel-3536 10 26 envtl envtl NOUN cjel-3536 10 27 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 11 1 l. l. PROPN cjel-3536 11 2 rep rep PROPN cjel-3536 11 3 . . PROPN cjel-3536 11 4 10958–73 10958–73 PROPN cjel-3536 11 5 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 11 6 oct oct PROPN cjel-3536 11 7 . . PROPN cjel-3536 11 8 2010 2010 NUM cjel-3536 11 9 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 11 10 ; ; PUNCT cjel-3536 11 11 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 11 12 7 7 X cjel-3536 11 13 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 11 14 standing stand VERB cjel-3536 11 15 in in ADP cjel-3536 11 16 monsanto monsanto PROPN cjel-3536 11 17 co. co. PROPN cjel-3536 12 1 v. v. ADP cjel-3536 12 2 geertson geertson NOUN cjel-3536 12 3 seed seed NOUN cjel-3536 12 4 farms farm NOUN cjel-3536 12 5 : : PUNCT cjel-3536 12 6 using use VERB cjel-3536 12 7 economic economic ADJ cjel-3536 12 8 injury injury NOUN cjel-3536 12 9 as as ADP cjel-3536 12 10 a a DET cjel-3536 12 11 basis basis NOUN cjel-3536 12 12 for for ADP cjel-3536 12 13 standing stand VERB cjel-3536 12 14 when when SCONJ cjel-3536 12 15 environmental environmental ADJ cjel-3536 12 16 harm harm NOUN cjel-3536 12 17 is be AUX cjel-3536 12 18 difficult difficult ADJ cjel-3536 12 19 to to PART cjel-3536 12 20 prove prove VERB cjel-3536 12 21 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 12 22 115 115 NUM cjel-3536 12 23 penn penn PROPN cjel-3536 12 24 state state PROPN cjel-3536 12 25 l. l. PROPN cjel-3536 12 26 rev rev PROPN cjel-3536 12 27 . . PROPN cjel-3536 12 28 307 307 NUM cjel-3536 12 29 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 12 30 2010 2010 NUM cjel-3536 12 31 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 12 32 ; ; PUNCT cjel-3536 12 33 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 12 34 8) 8) NUM cjel-3536 12 35 informational informational ADJ cjel-3536 12 36 standing standing NOUN cjel-3536 12 37 after after ADP cjel-3536 12 38 summers summer NOUN cjel-3536 12 39 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 12 40 39 39 NUM cjel-3536 12 41 b.c b.c PROPN cjel-3536 12 42 . . PROPN cjel-3536 12 43 envtl envtl PROPN cjel-3536 12 44 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 13 1 aff aff PROPN cjel-3536 13 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 14 1 l. l. PROPN cjel-3536 14 2 rev rev PROPN cjel-3536 14 3 . . PROPN cjel-3536 14 4 1 1 NUM cjel-3536 14 5 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 14 6 2012 2012 NUM cjel-3536 14 7 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 14 8 ; ; PUNCT cjel-3536 14 9 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 14 10 9 9 X cjel-3536 14 11 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 14 12 reading read VERB cjel-3536 14 13 the the DET cjel-3536 14 14 standing stand VERB cjel-3536 14 15 tea tea NOUN cjel-3536 14 16 leaves leave NOUN cjel-3536 14 17 in in ADP cjel-3536 14 18 american american PROPN cjel-3536 14 19 electric electric PROPN cjel-3536 14 20 power power PROPN cjel-3536 14 21 v. v. PROPN cjel-3536 14 22 connecticut connecticut PROPN cjel-3536 14 23 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 14 24 46 46 NUM cjel-3536 14 25 u. u. ADV cjel-3536 14 26 rich rich PROPN cjel-3536 14 27 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 15 1 l. l. PROPN cjel-3536 15 2 rev rev PROPN cjel-3536 15 3 . . PROPN cjel-3536 16 1 543 543 NUM cjel-3536 16 2 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 16 3 2012 2012 NUM cjel-3536 16 4 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 16 5 ; ; PUNCT cjel-3536 16 6 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 16 7 10 10 X cjel-3536 16 8 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 16 9 judge judge NOUN cjel-3536 16 10 posner posner NOUN cjel-3536 16 11 ’s ’s PART cjel-3536 16 12 “ " PUNCT cjel-3536 16 13 practical practical ADJ cjel-3536 16 14 ” " PUNCT cjel-3536 16 15 theory theory NOUN cjel-3536 16 16 of of ADP cjel-3536 16 17 standing standing NOUN cjel-3536 16 18 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 16 19 50 50 NUM cjel-3536 16 20 hous hous ADJ cjel-3536 16 21 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 17 1 l. l. PROPN cjel-3536 17 2 rev rev PROPN cjel-3536 17 3 . . PROPN cjel-3536 17 4 71 71 NUM cjel-3536 17 5 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 17 6 2012 2012 NUM cjel-3536 17 7 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 17 8 ; ; PUNCT cjel-3536 17 9 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 17 10 11 11 X cjel-3536 17 11 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 17 12 standing stand VERB cjel-3536 17 13 for for ADP cjel-3536 17 14 private private ADJ cjel-3536 17 15 parties party NOUN cjel-3536 17 16 in in ADP cjel-3536 17 17 global global ADJ cjel-3536 17 18 warming warming NOUN cjel-3536 17 19 cases case NOUN cjel-3536 17 20 : : PUNCT cjel-3536 17 21 traceable traceable ADJ cjel-3536 17 22 standing stand VERB cjel-3536 17 23 causation causation NOUN cjel-3536 17 24 does do AUX cjel-3536 17 25 not not PART cjel-3536 17 26 require require VERB cjel-3536 17 27 proximate proximate NOUN cjel-3536 17 28 causation causation NOUN cjel-3536 17 29 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 17 30 2012 2012 NUM cjel-3536 17 31 mich mich PROPN cjel-3536 17 32 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 17 33 st st PROPN cjel-3536 17 34 . . PROPN cjel-3536 17 35 l. l. PROPN cjel-3536 17 36 rev rev PROPN cjel-3536 17 37 . . PROPN cjel-3536 17 38 869 869 NUM cjel-3536 17 39 ; ; PUNCT cjel-3536 17 40 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 17 41 12 12 NUM cjel-3536 17 42 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 17 43 is be AUX cjel-3536 17 44 prudential prudential PROPN cjel-3536 17 45 standing stand VERB cjel-3536 17 46 jurisdictional jurisdictional PROPN cjel-3536 17 47 ? ? PUNCT cjel-3536 17 48 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 17 49 64 64 NUM cjel-3536 17 50 case case NOUN cjel-3536 17 51 w. w. NOUN cjel-3536 17 52 res res PROPN cjel-3536 17 53 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 18 1 l. l. PROPN cjel-3536 18 2 rev rev PROPN cjel-3536 18 3 . . PROPN cjel-3536 19 1 413 413 NUM cjel-3536 19 2 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 19 3 2013 2013 NUM cjel-3536 19 4 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 19 5 ; ; PUNCT cjel-3536 19 6 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 19 7 13 13 X cjel-3536 19 8 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 19 9 clapper clapper NOUN cjel-3536 19 10 v. v. ADP cjel-3536 19 11 amnesty amnesty PROPN cjel-3536 19 12 international international ADJ cjel-3536 19 13 : : PUNCT cjel-3536 19 14 two two NUM cjel-3536 19 15 or or CCONJ cjel-3536 19 16 three three NUM cjel-3536 19 17 competing compete VERB cjel-3536 19 18 philosophies philosophy NOUN cjel-3536 19 19 of of ADP cjel-3536 19 20 standing standing ADJ cjel-3536 19 21 law law NOUN cjel-3536 19 22 ? ? PUNCT cjel-3536 19 23 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 19 24 81 81 NUM cjel-3536 19 25 tenn tenn PROPN cjel-3536 19 26 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 20 1 l. l. PROPN cjel-3536 20 2 rev rev PROPN cjel-3536 20 3 . . PROPN cjel-3536 20 4 211 211 NUM cjel-3536 20 5 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 20 6 2014 2014 NUM cjel-3536 20 7 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 20 8 ; ; PUNCT cjel-3536 20 9 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 20 10 14 14 X cjel-3536 20 11 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 20 12 no no DET cjel-3536 20 13 article article NOUN cjel-3536 20 14 iii iii NUM cjel-3536 20 15 standing stand VERB cjel-3536 20 16 for for ADP cjel-3536 20 17 private private ADJ cjel-3536 20 18 plaintiffs plaintiff NOUN cjel-3536 20 19 challenging challenge VERB cjel-3536 20 20 state state NOUN cjel-3536 20 21 greenhouse greenhouse NOUN cjel-3536 20 22 gas gas NOUN cjel-3536 20 23 regulations regulation NOUN cjel-3536 20 24 : : PUNCT cjel-3536 20 25 the the DET cjel-3536 20 26 ninth ninth ADJ cjel-3536 20 27 circuit circuit NOUN cjel-3536 20 28 ’s ’s PART cjel-3536 20 29 decision decision NOUN cjel-3536 20 30 in in ADP cjel-3536 20 31 washington washington PROPN cjel-3536 20 32 environmental environmental PROPN cjel-3536 20 33 council council PROPN cjel-3536 20 34 v. v. ADP cjel-3536 20 35 bellon bellon NOUN cjel-3536 20 36 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 20 37 63 63 NUM cjel-3536 20 38 am am NOUN cjel-3536 20 39 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 21 1 u. u. PROPN cjel-3536 21 2 l. l. PROPN cjel-3536 21 3 rev rev PROPN cjel-3536 21 4 . . PROPN cjel-3536 21 5 1525 1525 NUM cjel-3536 21 6 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 21 7 2014 2014 NUM cjel-3536 21 8 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 21 9 ; ; PUNCT cjel-3536 21 10 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 21 11 15 15 X cjel-3536 21 12 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 21 13 does do AUX cjel-3536 21 14 united united PROPN cjel-3536 21 15 states states PROPN cjel-3536 21 16 v. v. ADP cjel-3536 21 17 windsor windsor PROPN cjel-3536 21 18 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 21 19 the the DET cjel-3536 21 20 doma doma PROPN cjel-3536 21 21 case case NOUN cjel-3536 21 22 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 21 23 open open VERB cjel-3536 21 24 the the DET cjel-3536 21 25 door door NOUN cjel-3536 21 26 to to ADP cjel-3536 21 27 congressional congressional ADJ cjel-3536 21 28 standing standing NOUN cjel-3536 21 29 rights right NOUN cjel-3536 21 30 ? ? PUNCT cjel-3536 21 31 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 21 32 76 76 NUM cjel-3536 21 33 u. u. NOUN cjel-3536 21 34 pitt pitt PROPN cjel-3536 21 35 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 22 1 l. l. PROPN cjel-3536 22 2 rev rev PROPN cjel-3536 22 3 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 23 1 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 23 2 forthcoming forthcoming ADJ cjel-3536 23 3 2015 2015 NUM cjel-3536 23 4 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 23 5 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 24 1 mank mank PROPN cjel-3536 24 2 - - PUNCT cjel-3536 24 3 macro-[final macro-[final PROPN cjel-3536 24 4 6 6 NUM cjel-3536 24 5 - - SYM cjel-3536 24 6 19 19 NUM cjel-3536 24 7 ] ] PUNCT cjel-3536 24 8 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 24 9 do do AUX cjel-3536 24 10 not not PART cjel-3536 24 11 delete delete VERB cjel-3536 24 12 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 25 1 6/22/2015 6/22/2015 NUM cjel-3536 25 2 11:45 11:45 NUM cjel-3536 25 3 pm pm NOUN cjel-3536 25 4 306 306 NUM cjel-3536 25 5 columbia columbia PROPN cjel-3536 25 6 journal journal NOUN cjel-3536 25 7 of of ADP cjel-3536 25 8 environmental environmental ADJ cjel-3536 25 9 law law NOUN cjel-3536 26 1 [ [ X cjel-3536 26 2 vol vol NOUN cjel-3536 26 3 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 27 1 40:2 40:2 PROPN cjel-3536 27 2 c. c. PROPN cjel-3536 27 3     SPACE cjel-3536 27 4 judge judge PROPN cjel-3536 27 5 sentelle sentelle NOUN cjel-3536 27 6 ’s ’s PART cjel-3536 27 7 dissenting dissent VERB cjel-3536 27 8 opinion opinion NOUN cjel-3536 27 9 ............................. ............................. PUNCT cjel-3536 27 10 314 314 NUM cjel-3536 27 11     SPACE cjel-3536 27 12 iv iv NUM cjel-3536 27 13 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 27 14     SPACE cjel-3536 27 15 other other ADJ cjel-3536 27 16 decisions decision NOUN cjel-3536 27 17 finding find VERB cjel-3536 27 18 standing stand VERB cjel-3536 27 19 to to PART cjel-3536 27 20 sue sue VERB cjel-3536 27 21 to to PART cjel-3536 27 22 protect protect VERB cjel-3536 27 23 a a DET cjel-3536 27 24 right right NOUN cjel-3536 27 25 to to PART cjel-3536 27 26 view view VERB cjel-3536 27 27 other other ADJ cjel-3536 27 28 people people NOUN cjel-3536 27 29 ’s ’s PART cjel-3536 27 30 property property NOUN cjel-3536 27 31 .............................. .............................. PUNCT cjel-3536 28 1 315 315 NUM cjel-3536 28 2     SPACE cjel-3536 28 3 v. v. NOUN cjel-3536 28 4     SPACE cjel-3536 28 5 conclusion conclusion NOUN cjel-3536 28 6 : : PUNCT cjel-3536 28 7 how how SCONJ cjel-3536 28 8 the the DET cjel-3536 28 9 supreme supreme PROPN cjel-3536 28 10 court court PROPN cjel-3536 28 11 might might AUX cjel-3536 28 12 address address VERB cjel-3536 28 13 the the DET cjel-3536 28 14 issue issue NOUN cjel-3536 28 15 .............................................................................. .............................................................................. PUNCT cjel-3536 28 16 317 317 NUM cjel-3536 28 17     SPACE cjel-3536 28 18 i. i. NOUN cjel-3536 28 19 introduction introduction NOUN cjel-3536 28 20 in in ADP cjel-3536 28 21 its its PRON cjel-3536 28 22 divided divided ADJ cjel-3536 28 23 2014 2014 NUM cjel-3536 28 24 decision decision NOUN cjel-3536 28 25 in in ADP cjel-3536 28 26 sierra sierra PROPN cjel-3536 28 27 club club PROPN cjel-3536 29 1 v. v. ADP cjel-3536 29 2 jewell,1 jewell,1 PROPN cjel-3536 29 3 the the DET cjel-3536 29 4 u.s u.s PROPN cjel-3536 29 5 . . PROPN cjel-3536 29 6 court court PROPN cjel-3536 29 7 of of ADP cjel-3536 29 8 appeals appeal NOUN cjel-3536 29 9 for for ADP cjel-3536 29 10 the the DET cjel-3536 29 11 district district PROPN cjel-3536 29 12 of of ADP cjel-3536 29 13 columbia columbia PROPN cjel-3536 29 14 circuit circuit PROPN cjel-3536 29 15 held hold VERB cjel-3536 29 16 that that SCONJ cjel-3536 29 17 plaintiffs plaintiff NOUN cjel-3536 29 18 who who PRON cjel-3536 29 19 observe observe VERB cjel-3536 29 20 landscape landscape NOUN cjel-3536 29 21 have have AUX cjel-3536 29 22 article article PROPN cjel-3536 29 23 iii iii NUM cjel-3536 29 24 standing standing NOUN cjel-3536 29 25 to to PART cjel-3536 29 26 sue sue VERB cjel-3536 29 27 in in ADP cjel-3536 29 28 federal federal ADJ cjel-3536 29 29 court court NOUN cjel-3536 29 30 to to PART cjel-3536 29 31 protect protect VERB cjel-3536 29 32 those those DET cjel-3536 29 33 views view NOUN cjel-3536 29 34 even even ADV cjel-3536 29 35 if if SCONJ cjel-3536 29 36 they they PRON cjel-3536 29 37 have have VERB cjel-3536 29 38 no no DET cjel-3536 29 39 legal legal ADJ cjel-3536 29 40 right right NOUN cjel-3536 29 41 to to PART cjel-3536 29 42 physically physically ADV cjel-3536 29 43 enter enter VERB cjel-3536 29 44 the the DET cjel-3536 29 45 private private ADJ cjel-3536 29 46 property property NOUN cjel-3536 29 47 that that PRON cjel-3536 29 48 they they PRON cjel-3536 29 49 view view VERB cjel-3536 29 50 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 30 1 two two NUM cjel-3536 30 2 earlier early ADJ cjel-3536 30 3 decisions decision NOUN cjel-3536 30 4 had have AUX cjel-3536 30 5 reached reach VERB cjel-3536 30 6 similar similar ADJ cjel-3536 30 7 conclusions conclusion NOUN cjel-3536 30 8 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 30 9 but but CCONJ cjel-3536 30 10 have have AUX cjel-3536 30 11 had have VERB cjel-3536 30 12 little little ADJ cjel-3536 30 13 impact impact NOUN cjel-3536 30 14 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 31 1 the the DET cjel-3536 31 2 d.c d.c PROPN cjel-3536 31 3 . . PROPN cjel-3536 31 4 circuit circuit PROPN cjel-3536 31 5 ’s ’s PART cjel-3536 31 6 decision decision NOUN cjel-3536 31 7 could could AUX cjel-3536 31 8 significantly significantly ADV cjel-3536 31 9 enlarge enlarge VERB cjel-3536 31 10 the the DET cjel-3536 31 11 ability ability NOUN cjel-3536 31 12 for for SCONJ cjel-3536 31 13 plaintiffs plaintiff NOUN cjel-3536 31 14 to to PART cjel-3536 31 15 sue sue VERB cjel-3536 31 16 federal federal ADJ cjel-3536 31 17 agencies agency NOUN cjel-3536 31 18 or or CCONJ cjel-3536 31 19 private private ADJ cjel-3536 31 20 parties party NOUN cjel-3536 31 21 over over ADP cjel-3536 31 22 changes change NOUN cjel-3536 31 23 to to ADP cjel-3536 31 24 private private ADJ cjel-3536 31 25 lands land NOUN cjel-3536 31 26 that that SCONJ cjel-3536 31 27 the the DET cjel-3536 31 28 plaintiffs plaintiff NOUN cjel-3536 31 29 have have VERB cjel-3536 31 30 no no DET cjel-3536 31 31 right right NOUN cjel-3536 31 32 to to ADP cjel-3536 31 33 enter.2 enter.2 PROPN cjel-3536 31 34 because because SCONJ cjel-3536 31 35 the the DET cjel-3536 31 36 supreme supreme PROPN cjel-3536 31 37 court court PROPN cjel-3536 31 38 has have AUX cjel-3536 31 39 inconsistently inconsistently ADV cjel-3536 31 40 applied apply VERB cjel-3536 31 41 both both CCONJ cjel-3536 31 42 strict strict ADJ cjel-3536 31 43 and and CCONJ cjel-3536 31 44 liberal liberal ADJ cjel-3536 31 45 approaches approach NOUN cjel-3536 31 46 to to ADP cjel-3536 31 47 standing standing NOUN cjel-3536 31 48 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 31 49 it it PRON cjel-3536 31 50 is be AUX cjel-3536 31 51 difficult difficult ADJ cjel-3536 31 52 to to PART cjel-3536 31 53 predict predict VERB cjel-3536 31 54 how how SCONJ cjel-3536 31 55 it it PRON cjel-3536 31 56 would would AUX cjel-3536 31 57 decide decide VERB cjel-3536 31 58 this this DET cjel-3536 31 59 issue issue NOUN cjel-3536 31 60 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 32 1 if if SCONJ cjel-3536 32 2 it it PRON cjel-3536 32 3 addresses address VERB cjel-3536 32 4 whether whether SCONJ cjel-3536 32 5 plaintiffs plaintiff NOUN cjel-3536 32 6 must must AUX cjel-3536 32 7 have have VERB cjel-3536 32 8 a a DET cjel-3536 32 9 legal legal ADJ cjel-3536 32 10 interest interest NOUN cjel-3536 32 11 in in ADP cjel-3536 32 12 any any DET cjel-3536 32 13 property property NOUN cjel-3536 32 14 they they PRON cjel-3536 32 15 seek seek AUX cjel-3536 32 16 standing stand VERB cjel-3536 32 17 to to PART cjel-3536 32 18 protect protect VERB cjel-3536 32 19 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 32 20 the the DET cjel-3536 32 21 supreme supreme PROPN cjel-3536 32 22 court court PROPN cjel-3536 32 23 might might AUX cjel-3536 32 24 be be AUX cjel-3536 32 25 forced force VERB cjel-3536 32 26 to to PART cjel-3536 32 27 resolve resolve VERB cjel-3536 32 28 the the DET cjel-3536 32 29 contradictions contradiction NOUN cjel-3536 32 30 in in ADP cjel-3536 32 31 its its PRON cjel-3536 32 32 standing standing NOUN cjel-3536 32 33 doctrine doctrine NOUN cjel-3536 32 34 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 33 1 part part PROPN cjel-3536 33 2 ii ii PROPN cjel-3536 33 3 explains explain VERB cjel-3536 33 4 the the DET cjel-3536 33 5 basic basic ADJ cjel-3536 33 6 principles principle NOUN cjel-3536 33 7 of of ADP cjel-3536 33 8 constitutional constitutional ADJ cjel-3536 33 9 article article NOUN cjel-3536 33 10 iii iii NUM cjel-3536 33 11 standing standing PROPN cjel-3536 33 12 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 34 1 part part NOUN cjel-3536 34 2 iii iii NUM cjel-3536 34 3 addresses address NOUN cjel-3536 34 4 the the DET cjel-3536 34 5 district district NOUN cjel-3536 34 6 court court NOUN cjel-3536 34 7 ’s ’s PART cjel-3536 34 8 initial initial ADJ cjel-3536 34 9 decision decision NOUN cjel-3536 34 10 rejecting reject VERB cjel-3536 34 11 standing standing NOUN cjel-3536 34 12 and and CCONJ cjel-3536 34 13 the the DET cjel-3536 34 14 divided divided PROPN cjel-3536 34 15 d.c d.c PROPN cjel-3536 34 16 . . PROPN cjel-3536 34 17 circuit circuit PROPN cjel-3536 34 18 decision decision NOUN cjel-3536 34 19 finding find VERB cjel-3536 34 20 standing stand VERB cjel-3536 34 21 in in ADP cjel-3536 34 22 sierra sierra PROPN cjel-3536 34 23 club club PROPN cjel-3536 34 24 v. v. PROPN cjel-3536 34 25 jewell jewell PROPN cjel-3536 34 26 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 35 1 part part NOUN cjel-3536 35 2 iv iv NUM cjel-3536 35 3 examines examine VERB cjel-3536 35 4 two two NUM cjel-3536 35 5 prior prior ADJ cjel-3536 35 6 decisions decision NOUN cjel-3536 35 7 concluding conclude VERB cjel-3536 35 8 that that SCONJ cjel-3536 35 9 observers observer NOUN cjel-3536 35 10 have have AUX cjel-3536 35 11 standing stand VERB cjel-3536 35 12 to to PART cjel-3536 35 13 challenge challenge VERB cjel-3536 35 14 changes change NOUN cjel-3536 35 15 to to ADP cjel-3536 35 16 property property NOUN cjel-3536 35 17 they they PRON cjel-3536 35 18 do do AUX cjel-3536 35 19 not not PART cjel-3536 35 20 own own VERB cjel-3536 35 21 or or CCONJ cjel-3536 35 22 have have VERB cjel-3536 35 23 a a DET cjel-3536 35 24 right right NOUN cjel-3536 35 25 to to PART cjel-3536 35 26 enter enter VERB cjel-3536 35 27 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 36 1 part part NOUN cjel-3536 36 2 v v NOUN cjel-3536 36 3 discusses discuss VERB cjel-3536 36 4 how how SCONJ cjel-3536 36 5 the the DET cjel-3536 36 6 supreme supreme PROPN cjel-3536 36 7 court court PROPN cjel-3536 36 8 might might AUX cjel-3536 36 9 address address VERB cjel-3536 36 10 the the DET cjel-3536 36 11 issue issue NOUN cjel-3536 36 12 of of ADP cjel-3536 36 13 standing standing ADJ cjel-3536 36 14 rights right NOUN cjel-3536 36 15 for for ADP cjel-3536 36 16 those those PRON cjel-3536 36 17 who who PRON cjel-3536 36 18 view view VERB cjel-3536 36 19 private private ADJ cjel-3536 36 20 lands land NOUN cjel-3536 36 21 they they PRON cjel-3536 36 22 have have VERB cjel-3536 36 23 no no DET cjel-3536 36 24 right right NOUN cjel-3536 36 25 to to PART cjel-3536 36 26 enter enter VERB cjel-3536 36 27 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 37 1 1 1 X cjel-3536 37 2 . . X cjel-3536 38 1 764 764 NUM cjel-3536 38 2 f.3d f.3d NUM cjel-3536 38 3 1 1 NUM cjel-3536 38 4 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 38 5 d.c d.c PROPN cjel-3536 38 6 . . PROPN cjel-3536 38 7 cir cir PROPN cjel-3536 38 8 . . PROPN cjel-3536 38 9 2014 2014 NUM cjel-3536 38 10 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 38 11 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 39 1 judge judge PROPN cjel-3536 39 2 sentelle sentelle NOUN cjel-3536 39 3 dissented dissent VERB cjel-3536 39 4 from from ADP cjel-3536 39 5 the the DET cjel-3536 39 6 majority majority NOUN cjel-3536 39 7 opinion opinion NOUN cjel-3536 39 8 written write VERB cjel-3536 39 9 by by ADP cjel-3536 39 10 judge judge PROPN cjel-3536 39 11 srinivasan srinivasan PROPN cjel-3536 39 12 and and CCONJ cjel-3536 39 13 joined join VERB cjel-3536 39 14 by by ADP cjel-3536 39 15 judge judge PROPN cjel-3536 39 16 garland garland PROPN cjel-3536 39 17 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 40 1 i i PRON cjel-3536 40 2 d. d. PROPN cjel-3536 40 3 at at ADP cjel-3536 40 4 3 3 NUM cjel-3536 40 5 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 40 6 3–9 3–9 NUM cjel-3536 40 7 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 40 8 majority majority NOUN cjel-3536 40 9 opinion opinion NOUN cjel-3536 40 10 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 40 11 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 40 12 9–11 9–11 PROPN cjel-3536 40 13 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 40 14 sentelle sentelle NOUN cjel-3536 40 15 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 40 16 j. j. PROPN cjel-3536 40 17 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 40 18 dissenting dissent VERB cjel-3536 40 19 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 40 20 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 41 1 2 2 X cjel-3536 41 2 . . X cjel-3536 41 3 david david PROPN cjel-3536 41 4 laross laross PROPN cjel-3536 41 5 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 41 6 d.c d.c PROPN cjel-3536 41 7 . . PROPN cjel-3536 41 8 circuit circuit PROPN cjel-3536 41 9 decision decision NOUN cjel-3536 41 10 could could AUX cjel-3536 41 11 broaden broaden VERB cjel-3536 41 12 environmentalists environmentalist NOUN cjel-3536 41 13 ’ ' PUNCT cjel-3536 41 14 legal legal ADJ cjel-3536 41 15 standing standing NOUN cjel-3536 41 16 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 41 17 insideepa.com insideepa.com X cjel-3536 41 18 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 41 19 oct oct PROPN cjel-3536 41 20 . . PROPN cjel-3536 41 21 9 9 NUM cjel-3536 41 22 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 41 23 2014 2014 NUM cjel-3536 41 24 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 41 25 available available ADJ cjel-3536 41 26 at at ADP cjel-3536 41 27 http://insideepa.com/dailynews/dc-circuit-decision-could-broaden-environmentalists-legal-standing http://insideepa.com/dailynews/dc-circuit-decision-could-broaden-environmentalists-legal-standing NOUN cjel-3536 41 28 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 41 29 subscription subscription NOUN cjel-3536 41 30 required require VERB cjel-3536 41 31 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 41 32 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 42 1 mank mank PROPN cjel-3536 42 2 - - PUNCT cjel-3536 42 3 macro-[final macro-[final PROPN cjel-3536 42 4 6 6 NUM cjel-3536 42 5 - - SYM cjel-3536 42 6 19 19 NUM cjel-3536 42 7 ] ] PUNCT cjel-3536 42 8 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 42 9 do do AUX cjel-3536 42 10 not not PART cjel-3536 42 11 delete delete VERB cjel-3536 42 12 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 42 13 6/22/2015 6/22/2015 NUM cjel-3536 42 14 11:45 11:45 NUM cjel-3536 42 15 pm pm NOUN cjel-3536 42 16 2015 2015 NUM cjel-3536 42 17 ] ] PUNCT cjel-3536 42 18 standing stand VERB cjel-3536 42 19 to to PART cjel-3536 42 20 view view VERB cjel-3536 42 21 other other ADJ cjel-3536 42 22 people people NOUN cjel-3536 42 23 ’s ’s PART cjel-3536 42 24 land land NOUN cjel-3536 42 25 307 307 NUM cjel-3536 42 26 ii ii NOUN cjel-3536 42 27 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 43 1 introduction introduction NOUN cjel-3536 43 2 to to ADP cjel-3536 43 3 article article NOUN cjel-3536 43 4 iii iii NUM cjel-3536 43 5 standing3 standing3 ADJ cjel-3536 43 6 while while SCONJ cjel-3536 43 7 the the DET cjel-3536 43 8 constitution constitution NOUN cjel-3536 43 9 does do AUX cjel-3536 43 10 not not PART cjel-3536 43 11 expressly expressly ADV cjel-3536 43 12 require require VERB cjel-3536 43 13 that that SCONJ cjel-3536 43 14 each each DET cjel-3536 43 15 plaintiff plaintiff NOUN cjel-3536 43 16 prove prove VERB cjel-3536 43 17 standing stand VERB cjel-3536 43 18 to to PART cjel-3536 43 19 file file VERB cjel-3536 43 20 suit suit NOUN cjel-3536 43 21 in in ADP cjel-3536 43 22 federal federal ADJ cjel-3536 43 23 courts court NOUN cjel-3536 43 24 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 43 25 the the DET cjel-3536 43 26 supreme supreme PROPN cjel-3536 43 27 court court PROPN cjel-3536 43 28 has have AUX cjel-3536 43 29 interpreted interpret VERB cjel-3536 43 30 article article PROPN cjel-3536 43 31 iii iii PROPN cjel-3536 43 32 ’s ’s PART cjel-3536 43 33 limitation limitation NOUN cjel-3536 43 34 of of ADP cjel-3536 43 35 judicial judicial ADJ cjel-3536 43 36 authority authority NOUN cjel-3536 43 37 to to ADP cjel-3536 43 38 actual actual ADJ cjel-3536 43 39 “ " PUNCT cjel-3536 43 40 cases case NOUN cjel-3536 43 41 ” " PUNCT cjel-3536 43 42 and and CCONJ cjel-3536 43 43 “ " PUNCT cjel-3536 43 44 controversies controversy NOUN cjel-3536 43 45 ” " PUNCT cjel-3536 43 46 as as ADP cjel-3536 43 47 imposing impose VERB cjel-3536 43 48 standing standing NOUN cjel-3536 43 49 requirements.4 requirements.4 PROPN cjel-3536 43 50 the the DET cjel-3536 43 51 supreme supreme PROPN cjel-3536 43 52 court court PROPN cjel-3536 43 53 has have AUX cjel-3536 43 54 created create VERB cjel-3536 43 55 a a DET cjel-3536 43 56 three three NUM cjel-3536 43 57 - - PUNCT cjel-3536 43 58 pronged pronged ADJ cjel-3536 43 59 test test NOUN cjel-3536 43 60 for for ADP cjel-3536 43 61 constitutional constitutional ADJ cjel-3536 43 62 article article NOUN cjel-3536 43 63 iii iii NUM cjel-3536 43 64 standing standing NOUN cjel-3536 43 65 that that PRON cjel-3536 43 66 requires require VERB cjel-3536 43 67 a a DET cjel-3536 43 68 plaintiff plaintiff NOUN cjel-3536 43 69 to to PART cjel-3536 43 70 show show VERB cjel-3536 43 71 that that SCONJ cjel-3536 43 72 : : PUNCT cjel-3536 43 73 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 43 74 1 1 X cjel-3536 43 75 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 43 76 she she PRON cjel-3536 43 77 has have AUX cjel-3536 43 78 “ " PUNCT cjel-3536 43 79 suffered suffer VERB cjel-3536 43 80 an an DET cjel-3536 43 81 injury injury NOUN cjel-3536 43 82 - - PUNCT cjel-3536 43 83 in in ADP cjel-3536 43 84 - - PUNCT cjel-3536 43 85 fact fact NOUN cjel-3536 43 86 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 43 87 ” " PUNCT cjel-3536 43 88 which which PRON cjel-3536 43 89 is be AUX cjel-3536 43 90 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 43 91 a a NOUN cjel-3536 43 92 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 43 93 “ " PUNCT cjel-3536 43 94 concrete concrete ADJ cjel-3536 43 95 and and CCONJ cjel-3536 43 96 particularized particularize VERB cjel-3536 43 97 ” " PUNCT cjel-3536 43 98 and and CCONJ cjel-3536 43 99 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 43 100 b b NOUN cjel-3536 43 101 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 43 102 “ " PUNCT cjel-3536 43 103 actual actual ADJ cjel-3536 43 104 or or CCONJ cjel-3536 43 105 imminent imminent ADJ cjel-3536 43 106 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 43 107 not not PART cjel-3536 43 108 conjectural conjectural ADJ cjel-3536 43 109 or or CCONJ cjel-3536 43 110 hypothetical;”5 hypothetical;”5 PROPN cjel-3536 43 111 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 43 112 2 2 NUM cjel-3536 43 113 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 43 114 “ " PUNCT cjel-3536 43 115 there there ADV cjel-3536 44 1 [ [ X cjel-3536 44 2 is be AUX cjel-3536 44 3 ] ] PUNCT cjel-3536 44 4 a a DET cjel-3536 44 5 causal causal ADJ cjel-3536 44 6 connection connection NOUN cjel-3536 44 7 between between ADP cjel-3536 44 8 the the DET cjel-3536 44 9 injury injury NOUN cjel-3536 44 10 and and CCONJ cjel-3536 44 11 the the DET cjel-3536 44 12 conduct conduct NOUN cjel-3536 44 13 complained complain VERB cjel-3536 44 14 of of ADP cjel-3536 44 15 — — PUNCT cjel-3536 44 16 the the DET cjel-3536 44 17 injury injury NOUN cjel-3536 44 18 has have VERB cjel-3536 44 19 to to PART cjel-3536 44 20 be be AUX cjel-3536 44 21 fairly fairly ADV cjel-3536 44 22 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 44 23 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 44 24 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 45 1 trace[able trace[able NOUN cjel-3536 45 2 ] ] X cjel-3536 45 3 ” " PUNCT cjel-3536 45 4 to to ADP cjel-3536 45 5 the the DET cjel-3536 45 6 challenged challenge VERB cjel-3536 45 7 action action NOUN cjel-3536 45 8 of of ADP cjel-3536 45 9 the the DET cjel-3536 45 10 defendant defendant NOUN cjel-3536 45 11 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 45 12 and and CCONJ cjel-3536 45 13 not not PART cjel-3536 45 14 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 45 15 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 45 16 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 46 1 th[e th[e PROPN cjel-3536 46 2 ] ] PUNCT cjel-3536 46 3 result result VERB cjel-3536 47 1 [ [ X cjel-3536 47 2 of of ADP cjel-3536 47 3 ] ] PUNCT cjel-3536 47 4 the the DET cjel-3536 47 5 independent independent ADJ cjel-3536 47 6 action action NOUN cjel-3536 47 7 of of ADP cjel-3536 47 8 some some DET cjel-3536 47 9 third third ADJ cjel-3536 47 10 party party NOUN cjel-3536 47 11 not not PART cjel-3536 47 12 before before ADP cjel-3536 47 13 the the DET cjel-3536 47 14 court;”6 court;”6 PROPN cjel-3536 47 15 and and CCONJ cjel-3536 47 16 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 47 17 3 3 NUM cjel-3536 47 18 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 47 19 “ " PUNCT cjel-3536 47 20 it it PRON cjel-3536 47 21 [ [ X cjel-3536 47 22 is be AUX cjel-3536 47 23 ] ] X cjel-3536 47 24 likely likely ADV cjel-3536 47 25 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 47 26 as as SCONJ cjel-3536 47 27 opposed oppose VERB cjel-3536 47 28 to to PART cjel-3536 47 29 merely merely ADV cjel-3536 47 30 speculative speculative ADJ cjel-3536 47 31 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 47 32 that that SCONJ cjel-3536 47 33 the the DET cjel-3536 47 34 injury injury NOUN cjel-3536 47 35 will will AUX cjel-3536 47 36 be be AUX cjel-3536 47 37 redressed redress VERB cjel-3536 47 38 by by ADP cjel-3536 47 39 a a DET cjel-3536 47 40 favorable favorable ADJ cjel-3536 47 41 decision decision NOUN cjel-3536 47 42 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 47 43 ”7 ”7 PUNCT cjel-3536 48 1 a a DET cjel-3536 48 2 plaintiff plaintiff NOUN cjel-3536 48 3 bears bear VERB cjel-3536 48 4 the the DET cjel-3536 48 5 burden burden NOUN cjel-3536 48 6 of of ADP cjel-3536 48 7 proof proof NOUN cjel-3536 48 8 3 3 X cjel-3536 48 9 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 49 1 the the DET cjel-3536 49 2 discussion discussion NOUN cjel-3536 49 3 of of ADP cjel-3536 49 4 standing stand VERB cjel-3536 49 5 in in ADP cjel-3536 49 6 part part NOUN cjel-3536 49 7 ii ii PROPN cjel-3536 49 8 relies rely VERB cjel-3536 49 9 upon upon SCONJ cjel-3536 49 10 my my PRON cjel-3536 49 11 earlier early ADV cjel-3536 49 12 standing stand VERB cjel-3536 49 13 articles article NOUN cjel-3536 49 14 cited cite VERB cjel-3536 49 15 in in ADP cjel-3536 49 16 footnote footnote NOUN cjel-3536 49 17 * * PUNCT cjel-3536 49 18 . . PROPN cjel-3536 50 1 4 4 X cjel-3536 50 2 . . X cjel-3536 50 3 the the DET cjel-3536 50 4 constitutional constitutional ADJ cjel-3536 50 5 standing stand VERB cjel-3536 50 6 requirements requirement NOUN cjel-3536 50 7 are be AUX cjel-3536 50 8 derived derive VERB cjel-3536 50 9 from from ADP cjel-3536 50 10 article article PROPN cjel-3536 50 11 iii iii PROPN cjel-3536 50 12 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 50 13 section section NOUN cjel-3536 50 14 2 2 NUM cjel-3536 50 15 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 50 16 which which PRON cjel-3536 50 17 provides provide VERB cjel-3536 50 18 : : PUNCT cjel-3536 50 19 the the DET cjel-3536 50 20 judicial judicial ADJ cjel-3536 50 21 power power NOUN cjel-3536 50 22 shall shall AUX cjel-3536 50 23 extend extend VERB cjel-3536 50 24 to to ADP cjel-3536 50 25 all all DET cjel-3536 50 26 cases case NOUN cjel-3536 50 27 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 50 28 in in ADP cjel-3536 50 29 law law NOUN cjel-3536 50 30 and and CCONJ cjel-3536 50 31 equity equity NOUN cjel-3536 50 32 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 50 33 arising arise VERB cjel-3536 50 34 under under ADP cjel-3536 50 35 this this DET cjel-3536 50 36 constitution constitution NOUN cjel-3536 50 37 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 50 38 the the DET cjel-3536 50 39 laws law NOUN cjel-3536 50 40 of of ADP cjel-3536 50 41 the the DET cjel-3536 50 42 united united PROPN cjel-3536 50 43 states states PROPN cjel-3536 50 44 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 50 45 and and CCONJ cjel-3536 50 46 treaties treaty NOUN cjel-3536 50 47 made make VERB cjel-3536 50 48 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 50 49 or or CCONJ cjel-3536 50 50 which which PRON cjel-3536 50 51 shall shall AUX cjel-3536 50 52 be be AUX cjel-3536 50 53 made make VERB cjel-3536 50 54 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 50 55 under under ADP cjel-3536 50 56 their their PRON cjel-3536 50 57 authority;—to authority;—to ADJ cjel-3536 50 58 all all DET cjel-3536 50 59 cases case NOUN cjel-3536 50 60 affecting affect VERB cjel-3536 50 61 ambassadors ambassador NOUN cjel-3536 50 62 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 50 63 other other ADJ cjel-3536 50 64 public public ADJ cjel-3536 50 65 ministers minister NOUN cjel-3536 50 66 and and CCONJ cjel-3536 50 67 consuls;—to consuls;—to DET cjel-3536 50 68 all all DET cjel-3536 50 69 cases case NOUN cjel-3536 50 70 of of ADP cjel-3536 50 71 admiralty admiralty NOUN cjel-3536 50 72 and and CCONJ cjel-3536 50 73 maritime maritime NOUN cjel-3536 51 1 jurisdiction;—to jurisdiction;—to DET cjel-3536 51 2 controversies controversy NOUN cjel-3536 51 3 to to PART cjel-3536 51 4 which which PRON cjel-3536 51 5 the the DET cjel-3536 51 6 united united PROPN cjel-3536 51 7 states states PROPN cjel-3536 51 8 shall shall AUX cjel-3536 51 9 be be AUX cjel-3536 51 10 a a DET cjel-3536 51 11 party;—to party;—to ADJ cjel-3536 51 12 controversies controversy NOUN cjel-3536 51 13 between between ADP cjel-3536 51 14 two two NUM cjel-3536 51 15 or or CCONJ cjel-3536 51 16 more more ADJ cjel-3536 51 17 states;—between states;—between ADP cjel-3536 51 18 a a DET cjel-3536 51 19 state state NOUN cjel-3536 51 20 and and CCONJ cjel-3536 51 21 citizens citizen NOUN cjel-3536 51 22 of of ADP cjel-3536 51 23 another another DET cjel-3536 51 24 state state NOUN cjel-3536 51 25 ; ; PUNCT cjel-3536 51 26 between between ADP cjel-3536 51 27 citizens citizen NOUN cjel-3536 51 28 of of ADP cjel-3536 51 29 different different ADJ cjel-3536 51 30 states;—between states;—between ADP cjel-3536 51 31 citizens citizen NOUN cjel-3536 51 32 of of ADP cjel-3536 51 33 the the DET cjel-3536 51 34 same same ADJ cjel-3536 51 35 state state NOUN cjel-3536 51 36 claiming claim VERB cjel-3536 51 37 lands land NOUN cjel-3536 51 38 under under ADP cjel-3536 51 39 grants grant NOUN cjel-3536 51 40 of of ADP cjel-3536 51 41 different different ADJ cjel-3536 51 42 states state NOUN cjel-3536 51 43 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 51 44 and and CCONJ cjel-3536 51 45 between between ADP cjel-3536 51 46 a a DET cjel-3536 51 47 state state NOUN cjel-3536 51 48 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 51 49 or or CCONJ cjel-3536 51 50 the the DET cjel-3536 51 51 citizens citizen NOUN cjel-3536 51 52 thereof thereof ADV cjel-3536 51 53 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 51 54 and and CCONJ cjel-3536 51 55 foreign foreign ADJ cjel-3536 51 56 states state NOUN cjel-3536 51 57 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 51 58 citizens citizen NOUN cjel-3536 51 59 or or CCONJ cjel-3536 51 60 subjects subject NOUN cjel-3536 51 61 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 52 1 u.s u.s PROPN cjel-3536 52 2 . . PROPN cjel-3536 52 3 const const PROPN cjel-3536 52 4 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 52 5 art art NOUN cjel-3536 52 6 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 53 1 iii iii PROPN cjel-3536 53 2 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 53 3 § § PROPN cjel-3536 53 4 2 2 NUM cjel-3536 53 5 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 53 6 footnote footnote NOUN cjel-3536 53 7 omitted omit VERB cjel-3536 53 8 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 53 9 ; ; PUNCT cjel-3536 53 10 see see VERB cjel-3536 53 11 daimlerchrysler daimlerchrysler PROPN cjel-3536 53 12 corp corp PROPN cjel-3536 53 13 . . PROPN cjel-3536 53 14 v. v. PROPN cjel-3536 53 15 cuno cuno PROPN cjel-3536 53 16 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 53 17 547 547 NUM cjel-3536 53 18 u.s u.s PROPN cjel-3536 53 19 . . PROPN cjel-3536 53 20 332 332 NUM cjel-3536 53 21 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 53 22 340–41 340–41 NUM cjel-3536 53 23 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 53 24 2006 2006 NUM cjel-3536 53 25 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 53 26 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 53 27 explaining explain VERB cjel-3536 53 28 why why SCONJ cjel-3536 53 29 the the DET cjel-3536 53 30 supreme supreme PROPN cjel-3536 53 31 court court PROPN cjel-3536 53 32 infers infer NOUN cjel-3536 53 33 that that PRON cjel-3536 53 34 article article NOUN cjel-3536 53 35 iii iii PROPN cjel-3536 53 36 ’s ’s PART cjel-3536 53 37 case case NOUN cjel-3536 53 38 and and CCONJ cjel-3536 53 39 controversy controversy NOUN cjel-3536 53 40 requirement requirement NOUN cjel-3536 53 41 necessitates necessitate VERB cjel-3536 53 42 standing stand VERB cjel-3536 53 43 limitations limitation NOUN cjel-3536 53 44 and and CCONJ cjel-3536 53 45 clarifying clarify VERB cjel-3536 53 46 that that SCONJ cjel-3536 53 47 “ " PUNCT cjel-3536 53 48 [ [ X cjel-3536 53 49 i]f i]f ADP cjel-3536 53 50 a a DET cjel-3536 53 51 dispute dispute NOUN cjel-3536 53 52 is be AUX cjel-3536 53 53 not not PART cjel-3536 53 54 a a DET cjel-3536 53 55 proper proper ADJ cjel-3536 53 56 case case NOUN cjel-3536 53 57 or or CCONJ cjel-3536 53 58 controversy controversy NOUN cjel-3536 53 59 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 53 60 the the DET cjel-3536 53 61 courts court NOUN cjel-3536 53 62 have have VERB cjel-3536 53 63 no no DET cjel-3536 53 64 business business NOUN cjel-3536 53 65 deciding decide VERB cjel-3536 53 66 it it PRON cjel-3536 53 67 ” " PUNCT cjel-3536 53 68 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 53 69 ; ; PUNCT cjel-3536 53 70 see see VERB cjel-3536 53 71 generally generally ADV cjel-3536 53 72 michael michael PROPN cjel-3536 53 73 e. e. PROPN cjel-3536 53 74 solimine solimine PROPN cjel-3536 53 75 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 53 76 congress congress PROPN cjel-3536 53 77 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 53 78 separation separation NOUN cjel-3536 53 79 of of ADP cjel-3536 53 80 powers power NOUN cjel-3536 53 81 and and CCONJ cjel-3536 53 82 standing standing NOUN cjel-3536 53 83 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 53 84 59 59 NUM cjel-3536 53 85 case case NOUN cjel-3536 53 86 wes wes PROPN cjel-3536 53 87 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 54 1 res res PROPN cjel-3536 54 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 55 1 l. l. PROPN cjel-3536 55 2 rev rev PROPN cjel-3536 55 3 . . PROPN cjel-3536 55 4 1023 1023 NUM cjel-3536 55 5 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 55 6 1036–38 1036–38 NUM cjel-3536 55 7 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 55 8 2009 2009 NUM cjel-3536 55 9 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 55 10 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 55 11 discussing discuss VERB cjel-3536 55 12 a a DET cjel-3536 55 13 scholarly scholarly ADJ cjel-3536 55 14 debate debate NOUN cjel-3536 55 15 on on ADP cjel-3536 55 16 whether whether SCONJ cjel-3536 55 17 the the DET cjel-3536 55 18 framers framer NOUN cjel-3536 55 19 intended intend VERB cjel-3536 55 20 the the DET cjel-3536 55 21 constitution constitution NOUN cjel-3536 55 22 to to PART cjel-3536 55 23 require require VERB cjel-3536 55 24 standing stand VERB cjel-3536 55 25 to to PART cjel-3536 55 26 sue sue VERB cjel-3536 55 27 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 55 28 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 56 1 5 5 X cjel-3536 56 2 . . X cjel-3536 56 3 lujan lujan PROPN cjel-3536 56 4 v. v. ADP cjel-3536 56 5 defenders defender NOUN cjel-3536 56 6 of of ADP cjel-3536 56 7 wildlife wildlife NOUN cjel-3536 56 8 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 56 9 504 504 NUM cjel-3536 56 10 u.s u.s PROPN cjel-3536 56 11 . . PROPN cjel-3536 56 12 555 555 NUM cjel-3536 56 13 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 56 14 560 560 NUM cjel-3536 56 15 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 56 16 1992 1992 NUM cjel-3536 56 17 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 56 18 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 56 19 internal internal ADJ cjel-3536 56 20 quotation quotation NOUN cjel-3536 56 21 marks mark NOUN cjel-3536 56 22 and and CCONJ cjel-3536 56 23 citations citation NOUN cjel-3536 56 24 omitted omit VERB cjel-3536 56 25 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 56 26 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 57 1 6 6 X cjel-3536 57 2 . . X cjel-3536 58 1 i i PRON cjel-3536 58 2 d. d. PROPN cjel-3536 58 3 at at ADP cjel-3536 58 4 560–61 560–61 PROPN cjel-3536 58 5 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 58 6 internal internal ADJ cjel-3536 58 7 quotation quotation NOUN cjel-3536 58 8 marks mark NOUN cjel-3536 58 9 and and CCONJ cjel-3536 58 10 citations citation NOUN cjel-3536 58 11 omitted omit VERB cjel-3536 58 12 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 58 13 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 59 1 7 7 X cjel-3536 59 2 . . X cjel-3536 60 1 i i PRON cjel-3536 60 2 d. d. PROPN cjel-3536 60 3 at at ADP cjel-3536 60 4 561 561 NUM cjel-3536 60 5 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 60 6 internal internal ADJ cjel-3536 60 7 quotation quotation NOUN cjel-3536 60 8 marks mark NOUN cjel-3536 60 9 and and CCONJ cjel-3536 60 10 citations citation NOUN cjel-3536 60 11 omitted omit VERB cjel-3536 60 12 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 60 13 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 61 1 mank mank PROPN cjel-3536 61 2 - - PUNCT cjel-3536 61 3 macro-[final macro-[final PROPN cjel-3536 61 4 6 6 NUM cjel-3536 61 5 - - SYM cjel-3536 61 6 19 19 NUM cjel-3536 61 7 ] ] PUNCT cjel-3536 61 8 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 61 9 do do AUX cjel-3536 61 10 not not PART cjel-3536 61 11 delete delete VERB cjel-3536 61 12 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 62 1 6/22/2015 6/22/2015 NUM cjel-3536 62 2 11:45 11:45 NUM cjel-3536 62 3 pm pm NOUN cjel-3536 62 4 308 308 NUM cjel-3536 62 5 columbia columbia PROPN cjel-3536 62 6 journal journal PROPN cjel-3536 62 7 of of ADP cjel-3536 62 8 environmental environmental ADJ cjel-3536 62 9 law law NOUN cjel-3536 63 1 [ [ X cjel-3536 63 2 vol vol NOUN cjel-3536 63 3 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 64 1 40:2 40:2 NOUN cjel-3536 64 2 for for ADP cjel-3536 64 3 all all DET cjel-3536 64 4 three three NUM cjel-3536 64 5 elements.8 elements.8 PROPN cjel-3536 64 6 thus thus ADV cjel-3536 64 7 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 64 8 for for SCONJ cjel-3536 64 9 a a DET cjel-3536 64 10 federal federal ADJ cjel-3536 64 11 court court NOUN cjel-3536 64 12 to to PART cjel-3536 64 13 have have VERB cjel-3536 64 14 jurisdiction jurisdiction NOUN cjel-3536 64 15 over over ADP cjel-3536 64 16 a a DET cjel-3536 64 17 suit suit NOUN cjel-3536 64 18 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 64 19 at at ADP cjel-3536 64 20 least least ADV cjel-3536 64 21 one one NUM cjel-3536 64 22 plaintiff plaintiff NOUN cjel-3536 64 23 must must AUX cjel-3536 64 24 prove prove VERB cjel-3536 64 25 he he PRON cjel-3536 64 26 has have AUX cjel-3536 64 27 standing stand VERB cjel-3536 64 28 for for ADP cjel-3536 64 29 each each DET cjel-3536 64 30 form form NOUN cjel-3536 64 31 of of ADP cjel-3536 64 32 relief relief NOUN cjel-3536 64 33 sought.9 sought.9 VERB cjel-3536 64 34 federal federal ADJ cjel-3536 64 35 courts court NOUN cjel-3536 64 36 must must AUX cjel-3536 64 37 dismiss dismiss VERB cjel-3536 64 38 a a DET cjel-3536 64 39 case case NOUN cjel-3536 64 40 for for ADP cjel-3536 64 41 want want NOUN cjel-3536 64 42 of of ADP cjel-3536 64 43 jurisdiction jurisdiction NOUN cjel-3536 64 44 if if SCONJ cjel-3536 64 45 no no DET cjel-3536 64 46 plaintiff plaintiff NOUN cjel-3536 64 47 meets meet VERB cjel-3536 64 48 the the DET cjel-3536 64 49 constitutional constitutional ADJ cjel-3536 64 50 article article NOUN cjel-3536 64 51 iii iii X cjel-3536 64 52 standing standing PROPN cjel-3536 64 53 requirements.10 requirements.10 NOUN cjel-3536 64 54 as as SCONJ cjel-3536 64 55 indicated indicate VERB cjel-3536 64 56 above above ADV cjel-3536 64 57 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 64 58 standing standing NOUN cjel-3536 64 59 requirements requirement NOUN cjel-3536 64 60 reflect reflect VERB cjel-3536 64 61 core core ADJ cjel-3536 64 62 constitutional constitutional ADJ cjel-3536 64 63 principles principle NOUN cjel-3536 64 64 inferred infer VERB cjel-3536 64 65 from from ADP cjel-3536 64 66 article article PROPN cjel-3536 64 67 iii iii PROPN cjel-3536 64 68 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 65 1 for for ADP cjel-3536 65 2 example example NOUN cjel-3536 65 3 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 65 4 standing standing NOUN cjel-3536 65 5 doctrine doctrine NOUN cjel-3536 65 6 bars bar VERB cjel-3536 65 7 unconstitutional unconstitutional ADJ cjel-3536 65 8 advisory advisory ADJ cjel-3536 65 9 opinions.11 opinions.11 ADV cjel-3536 65 10 furthermore furthermore ADV cjel-3536 65 11 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 65 12 standing standing ADJ cjel-3536 65 13 requirements requirement NOUN cjel-3536 65 14 are be AUX cjel-3536 65 15 grounded ground VERB cjel-3536 65 16 in in ADP cjel-3536 65 17 separation separation NOUN cjel-3536 65 18 of of ADP cjel-3536 65 19 powers power NOUN cjel-3536 65 20 principles principle NOUN cjel-3536 65 21 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 65 22 which which PRON cjel-3536 65 23 establish establish VERB cjel-3536 65 24 the the DET cjel-3536 65 25 division division NOUN cjel-3536 65 26 of of ADP cjel-3536 65 27 powers power NOUN cjel-3536 65 28 between between ADP cjel-3536 65 29 the the DET cjel-3536 65 30 judiciary judiciary NOUN cjel-3536 65 31 and and CCONJ cjel-3536 65 32 political political ADJ cjel-3536 65 33 branches branch NOUN cjel-3536 65 34 of of ADP cjel-3536 65 35 government government NOUN cjel-3536 65 36 so so SCONJ cjel-3536 65 37 that that SCONJ cjel-3536 65 38 the the DET cjel-3536 65 39 “ " PUNCT cjel-3536 65 40 federal federal ADJ cjel-3536 65 41 judiciary judiciary NOUN cjel-3536 65 42 respects respect VERB cjel-3536 65 43 ‘ ' PUNCT cjel-3536 65 44 the the DET cjel-3536 65 45 proper proper ADJ cjel-3536 65 46 — — PUNCT cjel-3536 65 47 and and CCONJ cjel-3536 65 48 properly properly ADV cjel-3536 65 49 limited limited ADJ cjel-3536 65 50 — — PUNCT cjel-3536 65 51 role role NOUN cjel-3536 65 52 of of ADP cjel-3536 65 53 the the DET cjel-3536 65 54 courts court NOUN cjel-3536 65 55 in in ADP cjel-3536 65 56 a a DET cjel-3536 65 57 democratic democratic ADJ cjel-3536 65 58 society society NOUN cjel-3536 65 59 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 65 60 ’”12 ’”12 PUNCT cjel-3536 66 1 different different ADJ cjel-3536 66 2 justices justice NOUN cjel-3536 66 3 of of ADP cjel-3536 66 4 the the DET cjel-3536 66 5 supreme supreme PROPN cjel-3536 66 6 court court PROPN cjel-3536 66 7 have have AUX cjel-3536 66 8 disagreed disagree VERB cjel-3536 66 9 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 66 10 however however ADV cjel-3536 66 11 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 66 12 regarding regard VERB cjel-3536 66 13 the the DET cjel-3536 66 14 degree degree NOUN cjel-3536 66 15 to to PART cjel-3536 66 16 which which DET cjel-3536 66 17 separation separation NOUN cjel-3536 66 18 of of ADP cjel-3536 66 19 powers power NOUN cjel-3536 66 20 principles principle NOUN cjel-3536 66 21 limit limit VERB cjel-3536 66 22 congress congress PROPN cjel-3536 66 23 ’s ’s PART cjel-3536 66 24 authority authority NOUN cjel-3536 66 25 to to PART cjel-3536 66 26 authorize authorize VERB cjel-3536 66 27 standing stand VERB cjel-3536 66 28 to to PART cjel-3536 66 29 sue sue VERB cjel-3536 66 30 in in ADP cjel-3536 66 31 federal federal ADJ cjel-3536 66 32 courts court NOUN cjel-3536 66 33 for for ADP cjel-3536 66 34 private private ADJ cjel-3536 66 35 citizen citizen NOUN cjel-3536 66 36 suits suit NOUN cjel-3536 66 37 challenging challenge VERB cjel-3536 66 38 executive executive ADJ cjel-3536 66 39 branch branch NOUN cjel-3536 66 40 decisions.13 decisions.13 VERB cjel-3536 66 41 8 8 NUM cjel-3536 66 42 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 67 1 daimlerchrysler daimlerchrysler PROPN cjel-3536 67 2 corp corp PROPN cjel-3536 67 3 . . PROPN cjel-3536 67 4 v. v. PROPN cjel-3536 67 5 cuno cuno PROPN cjel-3536 67 6 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 67 7 547 547 NUM cjel-3536 67 8 u.s u.s PROPN cjel-3536 67 9 . . PROPN cjel-3536 67 10 332 332 NUM cjel-3536 67 11 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 67 12 342 342 NUM cjel-3536 67 13 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 67 14 2006 2006 NUM cjel-3536 67 15 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 67 16 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 67 17 stating state VERB cjel-3536 67 18 that that SCONJ cjel-3536 67 19 parties party NOUN cjel-3536 67 20 asserting assert VERB cjel-3536 67 21 federal federal ADJ cjel-3536 67 22 jurisdiction jurisdiction NOUN cjel-3536 67 23 must must AUX cjel-3536 67 24 “ " PUNCT cjel-3536 67 25 carry carry VERB cjel-3536 67 26 the the DET cjel-3536 67 27 burden burden NOUN cjel-3536 67 28 of of ADP cjel-3536 67 29 establishing establish VERB cjel-3536 67 30 their their PRON cjel-3536 67 31 standing standing NOUN cjel-3536 67 32 under under ADP cjel-3536 67 33 article article PROPN cjel-3536 67 34 iii iii NOUN cjel-3536 67 35 ” " PUNCT cjel-3536 67 36 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 67 37 ; ; PUNCT cjel-3536 67 38 lujan lujan VERB cjel-3536 67 39 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 67 40 504 504 NUM cjel-3536 67 41 u.s u.s PROPN cjel-3536 67 42 . . PROPN cjel-3536 67 43 at at ADP cjel-3536 67 44 561 561 NUM cjel-3536 67 45 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 67 46 same same ADJ cjel-3536 67 47 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 67 48 ; ; PUNCT cjel-3536 67 49 see see VERB cjel-3536 67 50 also also ADV cjel-3536 67 51 larry larry PROPN cjel-3536 67 52 w. w. PROPN cjel-3536 67 53 yackle yackle PROPN cjel-3536 67 54 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 67 55 federal federal ADJ cjel-3536 67 56 courts court NOUN cjel-3536 67 57 336 336 NUM cjel-3536 67 58 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 67 59 3d 3d NUM cjel-3536 67 60 ed ed NOUN cjel-3536 67 61 . . PROPN cjel-3536 67 62 2009 2009 NUM cjel-3536 67 63 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 67 64 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 67 65 adding add VERB cjel-3536 67 66 that that SCONJ cjel-3536 67 67 a a DET cjel-3536 67 68 plaintiff plaintiff NOUN cjel-3536 67 69 may may AUX cjel-3536 67 70 initially initially ADV cjel-3536 67 71 allege allege VERB cjel-3536 67 72 general general ADJ cjel-3536 67 73 facts fact NOUN cjel-3536 67 74 which which PRON cjel-3536 67 75 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 67 76 if if SCONJ cjel-3536 67 77 true true ADJ cjel-3536 67 78 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 67 79 would would AUX cjel-3536 67 80 establish establish VERB cjel-3536 67 81 the the DET cjel-3536 67 82 three three NUM cjel-3536 67 83 standing stand VERB cjel-3536 67 84 elements element NOUN cjel-3536 67 85 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 67 86 but but CCONJ cjel-3536 67 87 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 67 88 at at ADP cjel-3536 67 89 the the DET cjel-3536 67 90 summary summary NOUN cjel-3536 67 91 judgment judgment NOUN cjel-3536 67 92 stage stage NOUN cjel-3536 67 93 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 67 94 the the DET cjel-3536 67 95 plaintiff plaintiff NOUN cjel-3536 67 96 must must AUX cjel-3536 67 97 argue argue VERB cjel-3536 67 98 these these DET cjel-3536 67 99 facts fact NOUN cjel-3536 67 100 more more ADV cjel-3536 67 101 specifically specifically ADV cjel-3536 67 102 and and CCONJ cjel-3536 67 103 with with ADP cjel-3536 67 104 additional additional ADJ cjel-3536 67 105 support support NOUN cjel-3536 67 106 and and CCONJ cjel-3536 67 107 must must AUX cjel-3536 67 108 ultimately ultimately ADV cjel-3536 67 109 prove prove VERB cjel-3536 67 110 the the DET cjel-3536 67 111 existence existence NOUN cjel-3536 67 112 of of ADP cjel-3536 67 113 injury injury NOUN cjel-3536 67 114 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 67 115 causation causation NOUN cjel-3536 67 116 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 67 117 and and CCONJ cjel-3536 67 118 redressability redressability NOUN cjel-3536 67 119 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 67 120 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 68 1 9 9 X cjel-3536 68 2 . . X cjel-3536 68 3 see see PROPN cjel-3536 68 4 daimlerchrysler daimlerchrysler PROPN cjel-3536 68 5 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 68 6 547 547 NUM cjel-3536 68 7 u.s u.s PROPN cjel-3536 68 8 . . PROPN cjel-3536 68 9 at at ADP cjel-3536 68 10 351–52 351–52 PROPN cjel-3536 68 11 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 68 12 confirming confirm VERB cjel-3536 68 13 that that SCONJ cjel-3536 68 14 “ " PUNCT cjel-3536 68 15 a a DET cjel-3536 68 16 plaintiff plaintiff NOUN cjel-3536 68 17 must must AUX cjel-3536 68 18 demonstrate demonstrate VERB cjel-3536 68 19 standing stand VERB cjel-3536 68 20 separately separately ADV cjel-3536 68 21 for for ADP cjel-3536 68 22 each each DET cjel-3536 68 23 form form NOUN cjel-3536 68 24 of of ADP cjel-3536 68 25 relief relief NOUN cjel-3536 68 26 sought seek VERB cjel-3536 68 27 ” " PUNCT cjel-3536 68 28 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 68 29 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 68 30 quoting quote VERB cjel-3536 68 31 friends friend NOUN cjel-3536 68 32 of of ADP cjel-3536 68 33 the the DET cjel-3536 68 34 earth earth NOUN cjel-3536 68 35 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 68 36 inc inc PROPN cjel-3536 68 37 . . PROPN cjel-3536 69 1 v. v. PROPN cjel-3536 69 2 laidlaw laidlaw PROPN cjel-3536 69 3 envtl envtl PROPN cjel-3536 69 4 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 70 1 servs servs PROPN cjel-3536 70 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 71 1 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 71 2 toc toc PROPN cjel-3536 71 3 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 71 4 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 71 5 inc inc PROPN cjel-3536 71 6 . . PROPN cjel-3536 71 7 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 71 8 528 528 NUM cjel-3536 71 9 u.s u.s PROPN cjel-3536 71 10 . . PROPN cjel-3536 71 11 167 167 NUM cjel-3536 71 12 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 71 13 185 185 NUM cjel-3536 71 14 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 71 15 2000 2000 NUM cjel-3536 71 16 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 71 17 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 71 18 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 72 1 10 10 X cjel-3536 72 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 72 3 see see VERB cjel-3536 72 4 i i PRON cjel-3536 72 5 d. d. PROPN cjel-3536 72 6 at at ADP cjel-3536 72 7 340–41 340–41 PROPN cjel-3536 72 8 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 72 9 emphasizing emphasize VERB cjel-3536 72 10 the the DET cjel-3536 72 11 importance importance NOUN cjel-3536 72 12 of of ADP cjel-3536 72 13 the the DET cjel-3536 72 14 case case NOUN cjel-3536 72 15 or or CCONJ cjel-3536 72 16 controversy controversy NOUN cjel-3536 72 17 requirement requirement NOUN cjel-3536 72 18 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 72 19 ; ; PUNCT cjel-3536 72 20 laidlaw laidlaw PROPN cjel-3536 72 21 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 72 22 528 528 NUM cjel-3536 72 23 u.s u.s PROPN cjel-3536 72 24 . . PROPN cjel-3536 72 25 at at ADP cjel-3536 72 26 180 180 NUM cjel-3536 72 27 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 72 28 adding add VERB cjel-3536 72 29 that that SCONJ cjel-3536 72 30 courts court NOUN cjel-3536 72 31 have have VERB cjel-3536 72 32 an an DET cjel-3536 72 33 affirmative affirmative ADJ cjel-3536 72 34 duty duty NOUN cjel-3536 72 35 at at ADP cjel-3536 72 36 the the DET cjel-3536 72 37 outset outset NOUN cjel-3536 72 38 of of ADP cjel-3536 72 39 the the DET cjel-3536 72 40 litigation litigation NOUN cjel-3536 72 41 to to PART cjel-3536 72 42 ensure ensure VERB cjel-3536 72 43 that that SCONJ cjel-3536 72 44 litigants litigant NOUN cjel-3536 72 45 satisfy satisfy VERB cjel-3536 72 46 all all DET cjel-3536 72 47 article article PROPN cjel-3536 72 48 iii iii NUM cjel-3536 72 49 standing standing PROPN cjel-3536 72 50 requirements requirement NOUN cjel-3536 72 51 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 72 52 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 73 1 11 11 NUM cjel-3536 73 2 . . X cjel-3536 73 3 see see VERB cjel-3536 73 4 chafin chafin PROPN cjel-3536 73 5 v. v. ADP cjel-3536 73 6 chafin chafin PROPN cjel-3536 73 7 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 73 8 133 133 NUM cjel-3536 73 9 s. s. PROPN cjel-3536 73 10 ct ct PROPN cjel-3536 73 11 . . PROPN cjel-3536 73 12 1017 1017 NUM cjel-3536 73 13 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 73 14 1023 1023 NUM cjel-3536 73 15 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 73 16 2013 2013 NUM cjel-3536 73 17 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 73 18 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 73 19 “ " PUNCT cjel-3536 73 20 article article NOUN cjel-3536 73 21 iii iii NUM cjel-3536 73 22 of of ADP cjel-3536 73 23 the the DET cjel-3536 73 24 constitution constitution NOUN cjel-3536 73 25 restricts restrict VERB cjel-3536 73 26 the the DET cjel-3536 73 27 power power NOUN cjel-3536 73 28 of of ADP cjel-3536 73 29 federal federal ADJ cjel-3536 73 30 courts court NOUN cjel-3536 73 31 to to ADP cjel-3536 73 32 ‘ ' PUNCT cjel-3536 73 33 cases case NOUN cjel-3536 73 34 ’ ' PUNCT cjel-3536 73 35 and and CCONJ cjel-3536 73 36 ‘ ' PUNCT cjel-3536 73 37 controversies controversy NOUN cjel-3536 73 38 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 73 39 ’ ' PUNCT cjel-3536 74 1 accordingly accordingly ADV cjel-3536 74 2 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 74 3 [ [ X cjel-3536 74 4 t]o t]o NOUN cjel-3536 74 5 invoke invoke VERB cjel-3536 74 6 the the DET cjel-3536 74 7 jurisdiction jurisdiction NOUN cjel-3536 74 8 of of ADP cjel-3536 74 9 a a DET cjel-3536 74 10 federal federal ADJ cjel-3536 74 11 court court NOUN cjel-3536 74 12 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 74 13 a a DET cjel-3536 74 14 litigant litigant NOUN cjel-3536 74 15 must must AUX cjel-3536 74 16 have have AUX cjel-3536 74 17 suffered suffer VERB cjel-3536 74 18 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 74 19 or or CCONJ cjel-3536 74 20 be be AUX cjel-3536 74 21 threatened threaten VERB cjel-3536 74 22 with with ADP cjel-3536 74 23 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 74 24 an an DET cjel-3536 74 25 actual actual ADJ cjel-3536 74 26 injury injury NOUN cjel-3536 74 27 traceable traceable ADJ cjel-3536 74 28 to to ADP cjel-3536 74 29 the the DET cjel-3536 74 30 defendant defendant NOUN cjel-3536 74 31 and and CCONJ cjel-3536 74 32 likely likely ADJ cjel-3536 74 33 to to PART cjel-3536 74 34 be be AUX cjel-3536 74 35 redressed redress VERB cjel-3536 74 36 by by ADP cjel-3536 74 37 a a DET cjel-3536 74 38 favorable favorable ADJ cjel-3536 74 39 judicial judicial ADJ cjel-3536 74 40 decision decision NOUN cjel-3536 74 41 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 75 1 federal federal ADJ cjel-3536 75 2 courts court NOUN cjel-3536 75 3 may may AUX cjel-3536 75 4 not not PART cjel-3536 75 5 decide decide VERB cjel-3536 75 6 questions question NOUN cjel-3536 75 7 that that PRON cjel-3536 75 8 can can AUX cjel-3536 75 9 not not PART cjel-3536 75 10 affect affect VERB cjel-3536 75 11 the the DET cjel-3536 75 12 rights right NOUN cjel-3536 75 13 of of ADP cjel-3536 75 14 litigants litigant NOUN cjel-3536 75 15 in in ADP cjel-3536 75 16 the the DET cjel-3536 75 17 case case NOUN cjel-3536 75 18 before before ADP cjel-3536 75 19 them they PRON cjel-3536 75 20 or or CCONJ cjel-3536 75 21 give give VERB cjel-3536 75 22 opinion[s opinion[ NOUN cjel-3536 75 23 ] ] PUNCT cjel-3536 75 24 advising advise VERB cjel-3536 75 25 what what PRON cjel-3536 75 26 the the DET cjel-3536 75 27 law law NOUN cjel-3536 75 28 would would AUX cjel-3536 75 29 be be AUX cjel-3536 75 30 upon upon SCONJ cjel-3536 75 31 a a DET cjel-3536 75 32 hypothetical hypothetical ADJ cjel-3536 75 33 state state NOUN cjel-3536 75 34 of of ADP cjel-3536 75 35 facts fact NOUN cjel-3536 75 36 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 75 37 ” " PUNCT cjel-3536 75 38 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 75 39 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 75 40 internal internal ADJ cjel-3536 75 41 quotation quotation NOUN cjel-3536 75 42 marks mark NOUN cjel-3536 75 43 and and CCONJ cjel-3536 75 44 citations citation NOUN cjel-3536 75 45 omitted omit VERB cjel-3536 75 46 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 75 47 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 76 1 12 12 NUM cjel-3536 76 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 76 3 daimlerchrysler daimlerchrysler PROPN cjel-3536 76 4 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 76 5 547 547 NUM cjel-3536 76 6 u.s u.s PROPN cjel-3536 76 7 . . PROPN cjel-3536 76 8 at at ADP cjel-3536 76 9 341 341 NUM cjel-3536 76 10 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 76 11 quoting quote VERB cjel-3536 76 12 allen allen PROPN cjel-3536 76 13 v. v. PROPN cjel-3536 76 14 wright wright PROPN cjel-3536 76 15 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 76 16 468 468 NUM cjel-3536 76 17 u.s u.s PROPN cjel-3536 76 18 . . PROPN cjel-3536 76 19 737 737 NUM cjel-3536 76 20 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 76 21 750 750 NUM cjel-3536 76 22 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 76 23 1984 1984 NUM cjel-3536 76 24 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 76 25 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 76 26 partially partially ADV cjel-3536 76 27 abrogated abrogate VERB cjel-3536 76 28 by by ADP cjel-3536 76 29 lexmark lexmark NOUN cjel-3536 76 30 int’l int’l NUM cjel-3536 76 31 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 76 32 inc inc PROPN cjel-3536 76 33 . . PROPN cjel-3536 76 34 v. v. ADP cjel-3536 76 35 static static ADJ cjel-3536 76 36 control control PROPN cjel-3536 76 37 components component NOUN cjel-3536 76 38 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 76 39 inc inc PROPN cjel-3536 76 40 . . PROPN cjel-3536 76 41 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 76 42 134 134 NUM cjel-3536 76 43 s. s. PROPN cjel-3536 76 44 ct ct PROPN cjel-3536 76 45 . . PROPN cjel-3536 76 46 1377 1377 NUM cjel-3536 76 47 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 76 48 2014 2014 NUM cjel-3536 76 49 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 76 50 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 77 1 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 77 2 internal internal ADJ cjel-3536 77 3 quotation quotation NOUN cjel-3536 77 4 marks mark NOUN cjel-3536 77 5 omitted omit VERB cjel-3536 77 6 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 77 7 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 78 1 13 13 NUM cjel-3536 78 2 . . X cjel-3536 78 3 compare compare PROPN cjel-3536 78 4 lujan lujan NOUN cjel-3536 78 5 v. v. ADP cjel-3536 78 6 defenders defender NOUN cjel-3536 78 7 of of ADP cjel-3536 78 8 wildlife wildlife NOUN cjel-3536 78 9 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 78 10 504 504 NUM cjel-3536 78 11 u.s u.s PROPN cjel-3536 78 12 . . PROPN cjel-3536 78 13 555 555 NUM cjel-3536 78 14 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 78 15 573–78 573–78 NUM cjel-3536 78 16 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 78 17 1992 1992 NUM cjel-3536 78 18 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 78 19 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 78 20 majority majority NOUN cjel-3536 78 21 opinion opinion NOUN cjel-3536 78 22 of of ADP cjel-3536 78 23 justice justice PROPN cjel-3536 78 24 scalia scalia PROPN cjel-3536 78 25 concluding conclude VERB cjel-3536 78 26 that that SCONJ cjel-3536 78 27 articles article NOUN cjel-3536 78 28 ii ii PROPN cjel-3536 78 29 and and CCONJ cjel-3536 78 30 iii iii NUM cjel-3536 78 31 of of ADP cjel-3536 78 32 the the DET cjel-3536 78 33 constitution constitution NOUN cjel-3536 78 34 limit limit NOUN cjel-3536 78 35 mank mank PROPN cjel-3536 78 36 - - PUNCT cjel-3536 78 37 macro-[final macro-[final PROPN cjel-3536 78 38 6 6 NUM cjel-3536 78 39 - - SYM cjel-3536 78 40 19 19 NUM cjel-3536 78 41 ] ] PUNCT cjel-3536 78 42 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 78 43 do do AUX cjel-3536 78 44 not not PART cjel-3536 78 45 delete delete VERB cjel-3536 78 46 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 79 1 6/22/2015 6/22/2015 NUM cjel-3536 79 2 11:45 11:45 NUM cjel-3536 79 3 pm pm NOUN cjel-3536 79 4 2015 2015 NUM cjel-3536 79 5 ] ] PUNCT cjel-3536 79 6 standing stand VERB cjel-3536 79 7 to to PART cjel-3536 79 8 view view VERB cjel-3536 79 9 other other ADJ cjel-3536 79 10 people people NOUN cjel-3536 79 11 ’s ’s PART cjel-3536 79 12 land land NOUN cjel-3536 79 13 309 309 NUM cjel-3536 79 14 iii iii NOUN cjel-3536 79 15 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 80 1 the the DET cjel-3536 80 2 d.c d.c PROPN cjel-3536 80 3 . . PROPN cjel-3536 80 4 circuit circuit PROPN cjel-3536 80 5 ’s ’s PART cjel-3536 80 6 divided divide VERB cjel-3536 80 7 decision decision NOUN cjel-3536 80 8 in in ADP cjel-3536 80 9 sierra sierra PROPN cjel-3536 80 10 club club PROPN cjel-3536 80 11 v. v. PROPN cjel-3536 80 12 jewell jewell PROPN cjel-3536 80 13 the the DET cjel-3536 80 14 litigation litigation NOUN cjel-3536 80 15 in in ADP cjel-3536 80 16 the the DET cjel-3536 80 17 d.c d.c PROPN cjel-3536 80 18 . . PROPN cjel-3536 80 19 circuit circuit PROPN cjel-3536 80 20 involved involve VERB cjel-3536 80 21 efforts effort NOUN cjel-3536 80 22 by by ADP cjel-3536 80 23 plaintiffs plaintiff NOUN cjel-3536 80 24 to to PART cjel-3536 80 25 preserve preserve VERB cjel-3536 80 26 blair blair PROPN cjel-3536 80 27 mountain mountain PROPN cjel-3536 80 28 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 80 29 west west PROPN cjel-3536 80 30 virginia virginia PROPN cjel-3536 80 31 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 80 32 which which PRON cjel-3536 80 33 in in ADP cjel-3536 80 34 1921 1921 NUM cjel-3536 80 35 was be AUX cjel-3536 80 36 the the DET cjel-3536 80 37 site site NOUN cjel-3536 80 38 of of ADP cjel-3536 80 39 the the DET cjel-3536 80 40 largest large ADJ cjel-3536 80 41 armed armed ADJ cjel-3536 80 42 confrontation confrontation NOUN cjel-3536 80 43 in in ADP cjel-3536 80 44 u.s u.s PROPN cjel-3536 80 45 . . PROPN cjel-3536 80 46 history history NOUN cjel-3536 80 47 between between ADP cjel-3536 80 48 labor labor NOUN cjel-3536 80 49 unions union NOUN cjel-3536 80 50 representing represent VERB cjel-3536 80 51 coal coal NOUN cjel-3536 80 52 miners miner NOUN cjel-3536 80 53 and and CCONJ cjel-3536 80 54 coal coal NOUN cjel-3536 80 55 companies company NOUN cjel-3536 80 56 that that PRON cjel-3536 80 57 hired hire VERB cjel-3536 80 58 3,000 3,000 NUM cjel-3536 80 59 armed armed ADJ cjel-3536 80 60 men man NOUN cjel-3536 80 61 to to PART cjel-3536 80 62 protect protect VERB cjel-3536 80 63 their their PRON cjel-3536 80 64 property property NOUN cjel-3536 80 65 interests interest NOUN cjel-3536 80 66 from from ADP cjel-3536 80 67 the the DET cjel-3536 80 68 miners.14 miners.14 NOUN cjel-3536 80 69 after after ADP cjel-3536 80 70 several several ADJ cjel-3536 80 71 days day NOUN cjel-3536 80 72 of of ADP cjel-3536 80 73 gunfire gunfire NOUN cjel-3536 80 74 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 80 75 president president PROPN cjel-3536 80 76 harding harding PROPN cjel-3536 80 77 sent send VERB cjel-3536 80 78 federal federal ADJ cjel-3536 80 79 troops troop NOUN cjel-3536 80 80 to to PART cjel-3536 80 81 end end VERB cjel-3536 80 82 the the DET cjel-3536 80 83 fighting fighting NOUN cjel-3536 80 84 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 80 85 and and CCONJ cjel-3536 80 86 the the DET cjel-3536 80 87 coal coal NOUN cjel-3536 80 88 miners miner NOUN cjel-3536 80 89 surrendered.15 surrendered.15 PROPN cjel-3536 80 90 in in ADP cjel-3536 80 91 recent recent ADJ cjel-3536 80 92 years year NOUN cjel-3536 80 93 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 80 94 several several ADJ cjel-3536 80 95 environmental environmental ADJ cjel-3536 80 96 and and CCONJ cjel-3536 80 97 historical historical ADJ cjel-3536 80 98 preservation preservation NOUN cjel-3536 80 99 organizations organization NOUN cjel-3536 80 100 sought seek VERB cjel-3536 80 101 to to PART cjel-3536 80 102 protect protect VERB cjel-3536 80 103 for for ADP cjel-3536 80 104 the the DET cjel-3536 80 105 battlefield battlefield NOUN cjel-3536 80 106 from from ADP cjel-3536 80 107 surface surface NOUN cjel-3536 80 108 coal coal NOUN cjel-3536 80 109 mining mining NOUN cjel-3536 80 110 by by ADP cjel-3536 80 111 having have VERB cjel-3536 80 112 it it PRON cjel-3536 80 113 listed list VERB cjel-3536 80 114 in in ADP cjel-3536 80 115 the the DET cjel-3536 80 116 national national ADJ cjel-3536 80 117 register register NOUN cjel-3536 80 118 of of ADP cjel-3536 80 119 historic historic ADJ cjel-3536 80 120 places.16 places.16 PROPN cjel-3536 80 121 in in ADP cjel-3536 80 122 2009 2009 NUM cjel-3536 80 123 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 80 124 the the DET cjel-3536 80 125 federal federal ADJ cjel-3536 80 126 government government NOUN cjel-3536 80 127 briefly briefly ADV cjel-3536 80 128 listed list VERB cjel-3536 80 129 the the DET cjel-3536 80 130 battlefield battlefield NOUN cjel-3536 80 131 in in ADP cjel-3536 80 132 the the DET cjel-3536 80 133 register register NOUN cjel-3536 80 134 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 80 135 but but CCONJ cjel-3536 80 136 within within ADP cjel-3536 80 137 days day NOUN cjel-3536 80 138 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 80 139 the the DET cjel-3536 80 140 keeper keeper NOUN cjel-3536 80 141 of of ADP cjel-3536 80 142 the the DET cjel-3536 80 143 register register NOUN cjel-3536 80 144 removed remove VERB cjel-3536 80 145 the the DET cjel-3536 80 146 battlefield battlefield NOUN cjel-3536 80 147 after after ADP cjel-3536 80 148 concluding conclude VERB cjel-3536 80 149 that that SCONJ cjel-3536 80 150 the the DET cjel-3536 80 151 desires desire NOUN cjel-3536 80 152 of of ADP cjel-3536 80 153 area area NOUN cjel-3536 80 154 property property NOUN cjel-3536 80 155 owners owner NOUN cjel-3536 80 156 had have AUX cjel-3536 80 157 not not PART cjel-3536 80 158 been be AUX cjel-3536 80 159 accurately accurately ADV cjel-3536 80 160 reflected reflect VERB cjel-3536 80 161 in in ADP cjel-3536 80 162 the the DET cjel-3536 80 163 nomination nomination NOUN cjel-3536 80 164 process.17 process.17 PROPN cjel-3536 80 165 the the DET cjel-3536 80 166 plaintiff plaintiff NOUN cjel-3536 80 167 organizations organization NOUN cjel-3536 80 168 sued sue VERB cjel-3536 80 169 in in ADP cjel-3536 80 170 federal federal ADJ cjel-3536 80 171 district district NOUN cjel-3536 80 172 court court NOUN cjel-3536 80 173 challenging challenge VERB cjel-3536 80 174 the the DET cjel-3536 80 175 battlefield battlefield NOUN cjel-3536 80 176 ’s ’s PART cjel-3536 80 177 removal removal NOUN cjel-3536 80 178 from from ADP cjel-3536 80 179 the the DET cjel-3536 80 180 register.18 register.18 NOUN cjel-3536 80 181 the the DET cjel-3536 80 182 district district NOUN cjel-3536 80 183 court court NOUN cjel-3536 80 184 granted grant VERB cjel-3536 80 185 summary summary NOUN cjel-3536 80 186 judgment judgment NOUN cjel-3536 80 187 against against ADP cjel-3536 80 188 the the DET cjel-3536 80 189 plaintiffs plaintiff NOUN cjel-3536 80 190 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 80 191 holding hold VERB cjel-3536 80 192 that that SCONJ cjel-3536 80 193 they they PRON cjel-3536 80 194 lacked lack VERB cjel-3536 80 195 article article PROPN cjel-3536 80 196 iii iii NUM cjel-3536 80 197 standing standing NOUN cjel-3536 80 198 because because SCONJ cjel-3536 80 199 they they PRON cjel-3536 80 200 failed fail VERB cjel-3536 80 201 to to PART cjel-3536 80 202 demonstrate demonstrate VERB cjel-3536 80 203 the the DET cjel-3536 80 204 necessary necessary ADJ cjel-3536 80 205 injury injury NOUN cjel-3536 80 206 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 80 207 causation causation NOUN cjel-3536 80 208 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 80 209 and and CCONJ cjel-3536 80 210 redressability.19 redressability.19 NOUN cjel-3536 80 211 in in ADP cjel-3536 80 212 the the DET cjel-3536 80 213 majority majority NOUN cjel-3536 80 214 opinion opinion NOUN cjel-3536 80 215 written write VERB cjel-3536 80 216 by by ADP cjel-3536 80 217 judge judge PROPN cjel-3536 80 218 srinivasan srinivasan NOUN cjel-3536 80 219 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 80 220 the the DET cjel-3536 80 221 d.c d.c PROPN cjel-3536 80 222 . . PROPN cjel-3536 80 223 circuit circuit PROPN cjel-3536 80 224 reversed reverse VERB cjel-3536 80 225 the the DET cjel-3536 80 226 congress congress PROPN cjel-3536 80 227 ’s ’s PART cjel-3536 80 228 authority authority NOUN cjel-3536 80 229 to to PART cjel-3536 80 230 authorize authorize VERB cjel-3536 80 231 citizen citizen NOUN cjel-3536 80 232 suits suit NOUN cjel-3536 80 233 by by ADP cjel-3536 80 234 any any DET cjel-3536 80 235 person person NOUN cjel-3536 80 236 lacking lack VERB cjel-3536 80 237 a a DET cjel-3536 80 238 concrete concrete ADJ cjel-3536 80 239 injury injury NOUN cjel-3536 80 240 and and CCONJ cjel-3536 80 241 citing cite VERB cjel-3536 80 242 several several ADJ cjel-3536 80 243 recent recent ADJ cjel-3536 80 244 supreme supreme PROPN cjel-3536 80 245 court court NOUN cjel-3536 80 246 decisions decision NOUN cjel-3536 80 247 for for ADP cjel-3536 80 248 support support NOUN cjel-3536 80 249 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 80 250 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 80 251 with with ADP cjel-3536 80 252 lujan lujan PROPN cjel-3536 80 253 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 81 1 504 504 NUM cjel-3536 81 2 u.s u.s PROPN cjel-3536 81 3 . . PROPN cjel-3536 81 4 at at ADP cjel-3536 81 5 580 580 NUM cjel-3536 81 6 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 81 7 kennedy kennedy PROPN cjel-3536 81 8 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 81 9 j. j. PROPN cjel-3536 81 10 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 81 11 concurring concur VERB cjel-3536 81 12 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 81 13 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 81 14 “ " PUNCT cjel-3536 81 15 congress congress PROPN cjel-3536 81 16 has have VERB cjel-3536 81 17 the the DET cjel-3536 81 18 power power NOUN cjel-3536 81 19 to to PART cjel-3536 81 20 define define VERB cjel-3536 81 21 injuries injury NOUN cjel-3536 81 22 and and CCONJ cjel-3536 81 23 articulate articulate ADJ cjel-3536 81 24 chains chain NOUN cjel-3536 81 25 of of ADP cjel-3536 81 26 causation causation NOUN cjel-3536 81 27 that that PRON cjel-3536 81 28 will will AUX cjel-3536 81 29 give give VERB cjel-3536 81 30 rise rise NOUN cjel-3536 81 31 to to ADP cjel-3536 81 32 a a DET cjel-3536 81 33 case case NOUN cjel-3536 81 34 or or CCONJ cjel-3536 81 35 controversy controversy NOUN cjel-3536 81 36 where where SCONJ cjel-3536 81 37 none none NOUN cjel-3536 81 38 existed exist VERB cjel-3536 81 39 before before ADV cjel-3536 81 40 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 81 41 ” " PUNCT cjel-3536 81 42 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 81 43 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 81 44 and and CCONJ cjel-3536 81 45 lujan lujan VERB cjel-3536 81 46 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 81 47 504 504 NUM cjel-3536 81 48 u.s u. NOUN cjel-3536 81 49 . . PROPN cjel-3536 81 50 at at ADP cjel-3536 81 51 602 602 NUM cjel-3536 81 52 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 81 53 blackmun blackmun PROPN cjel-3536 81 54 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 81 55 j. j. PROPN cjel-3536 81 56 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 81 57 dissenting dissent VERB cjel-3536 81 58 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 81 59 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 81 60 arguing argue VERB cjel-3536 81 61 that that SCONJ cjel-3536 81 62 the the DET cjel-3536 81 63 “ " PUNCT cjel-3536 81 64 principal principal ADJ cjel-3536 81 65 effect effect NOUN cjel-3536 81 66 ” " PUNCT cjel-3536 81 67 of of ADP cjel-3536 81 68 the the DET cjel-3536 81 69 majority majority NOUN cjel-3536 81 70 ’s ’s PART cjel-3536 81 71 approach approach NOUN cjel-3536 81 72 to to ADP cjel-3536 81 73 standing standing NOUN cjel-3536 81 74 was be AUX cjel-3536 81 75 “ " PUNCT cjel-3536 81 76 to to PART cjel-3536 81 77 transfer transfer VERB cjel-3536 81 78 power power NOUN cjel-3536 81 79 into into ADP cjel-3536 81 80 the the DET cjel-3536 81 81 hands hand NOUN cjel-3536 81 82 of of ADP cjel-3536 81 83 the the DET cjel-3536 81 84 executive executive NOUN cjel-3536 81 85 at at ADP cjel-3536 81 86 the the DET cjel-3536 81 87 expense expense NOUN cjel-3536 81 88 — — PUNCT cjel-3536 81 89 not not PART cjel-3536 81 90 of of ADP cjel-3536 81 91 the the DET cjel-3536 81 92 courts court NOUN cjel-3536 81 93 — — PUNCT cjel-3536 81 94 but but CCONJ cjel-3536 81 95 of of ADP cjel-3536 81 96 congress congress PROPN cjel-3536 81 97 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 81 98 from from ADP cjel-3536 81 99 which which PRON cjel-3536 81 100 that that SCONJ cjel-3536 81 101 power power NOUN cjel-3536 81 102 originates originate NOUN cjel-3536 81 103 and and CCONJ cjel-3536 81 104 emanates emanate NOUN cjel-3536 81 105 ” " PUNCT cjel-3536 81 106 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 81 107 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 82 1 see see VERB cjel-3536 82 2 generally generally ADV cjel-3536 82 3 heather heather PROPN cjel-3536 82 4 elliott elliott PROPN cjel-3536 82 5 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 82 6 the the DET cjel-3536 82 7 functions function NOUN cjel-3536 82 8 of of ADP cjel-3536 82 9 standing standing NOUN cjel-3536 82 10 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 82 11 61 61 NUM cjel-3536 82 12 stan stan NOUN cjel-3536 82 13 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 83 1 l. l. PROPN cjel-3536 83 2 rev rev PROPN cjel-3536 83 3 . . PROPN cjel-3536 83 4 459 459 NUM cjel-3536 83 5 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 83 6 496 496 NUM cjel-3536 83 7 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 83 8 2008 2008 NUM cjel-3536 83 9 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 83 10 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 83 11 suggesting suggest VERB cjel-3536 83 12 the the DET cjel-3536 83 13 “ " PUNCT cjel-3536 83 14 disagreement disagreement NOUN cjel-3536 83 15 ” " PUNCT cjel-3536 83 16 is be AUX cjel-3536 83 17 “ " PUNCT cjel-3536 83 18 [ [ X cjel-3536 83 19 u]nsurprising u]nsurprise VERB cjel-3536 83 20 [ [ X cjel-3536 83 21 ] ] X cjel-3536 83 22 ” " PUNCT cjel-3536 83 23 and and CCONJ cjel-3536 83 24 arguing argue VERB cjel-3536 83 25 that that SCONJ cjel-3536 83 26 courts court NOUN cjel-3536 83 27 should should AUX cjel-3536 83 28 not not PART cjel-3536 83 29 use use VERB cjel-3536 83 30 standing standing ADJ cjel-3536 83 31 doctrine doctrine NOUN cjel-3536 83 32 “ " PUNCT cjel-3536 83 33 as as ADP cjel-3536 83 34 a a DET cjel-3536 83 35 backdoor backdoor NOUN cjel-3536 83 36 way way NOUN cjel-3536 83 37 to to PART cjel-3536 83 38 limit limit VERB cjel-3536 83 39 congress congress PROPN cjel-3536 83 40 ’s ’s PART cjel-3536 83 41 legislative legislative ADJ cjel-3536 83 42 power power NOUN cjel-3536 83 43 ” " PUNCT cjel-3536 83 44 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 83 45 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 84 1 14 14 NUM cjel-3536 84 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 85 1 sierra sierra PROPN cjel-3536 85 2 club club PROPN cjel-3536 85 3 v. v. PROPN cjel-3536 85 4 jewell jewell PROPN cjel-3536 85 5 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 85 6 764 764 NUM cjel-3536 85 7 f.3d f.3d NUM cjel-3536 85 8 1 1 NUM cjel-3536 85 9 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 85 10 3 3 NUM cjel-3536 85 11 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 85 12 d.c d.c PROPN cjel-3536 85 13 . . PROPN cjel-3536 85 14 cir cir PROPN cjel-3536 85 15 . . PROPN cjel-3536 85 16 2014 2014 NUM cjel-3536 85 17 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 85 18 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 86 1 15 15 X cjel-3536 86 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 87 1 i i PRON cjel-3536 87 2 d. d. PROPN cjel-3536 87 3 16 16 NUM cjel-3536 87 4 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 88 1 i i PRON cjel-3536 88 2 d. d. PROPN cjel-3536 88 3 17 17 NUM cjel-3536 88 4 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 89 1 i i PRON cjel-3536 89 2 d. d. PROPN cjel-3536 89 3 18 18 NUM cjel-3536 89 4 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 90 1 i i PRON cjel-3536 90 2 d. d. PROPN cjel-3536 90 3 19 19 NUM cjel-3536 90 4 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 91 1 i i PRON cjel-3536 91 2 d. d. PROPN cjel-3536 91 3 at at ADP cjel-3536 91 4 3–4 3–4 NUM cjel-3536 91 5 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 91 6 mank mank PROPN cjel-3536 91 7 - - PUNCT cjel-3536 91 8 macro-[final macro-[final PROPN cjel-3536 91 9 6 6 NUM cjel-3536 91 10 - - SYM cjel-3536 91 11 19 19 NUM cjel-3536 91 12 ] ] PUNCT cjel-3536 91 13 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 91 14 do do AUX cjel-3536 91 15 not not PART cjel-3536 91 16 delete delete VERB cjel-3536 91 17 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 92 1 6/22/2015 6/22/2015 NUM cjel-3536 92 2 11:45 11:45 NUM cjel-3536 92 3 pm pm PROPN cjel-3536 92 4 310 310 NUM cjel-3536 92 5 columbia columbia PROPN cjel-3536 92 6 journal journal PROPN cjel-3536 92 7 of of ADP cjel-3536 92 8 environmental environmental ADJ cjel-3536 92 9 law law NOUN cjel-3536 93 1 [ [ X cjel-3536 93 2 vol vol NOUN cjel-3536 93 3 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 94 1 40:2 40:2 NUM cjel-3536 94 2 lower low ADJ cjel-3536 94 3 court court NOUN cjel-3536 94 4 ’s ’s PART cjel-3536 94 5 decision decision NOUN cjel-3536 95 1 and and CCONJ cjel-3536 96 1 held hold VERB cjel-3536 96 2 that that SCONJ cjel-3536 96 3 the the DET cjel-3536 96 4 plaintiffs plaintiff NOUN cjel-3536 96 5 had have AUX cjel-3536 96 6 standing stand VERB cjel-3536 96 7 to to PART cjel-3536 96 8 challenge challenge VERB cjel-3536 96 9 the the DET cjel-3536 96 10 keeper keeper NOUN cjel-3536 96 11 ’s ’s PART cjel-3536 96 12 decision.20 decision.20 PROPN cjel-3536 96 13 judge judge PROPN cjel-3536 96 14 sentelle sentelle NOUN cjel-3536 96 15 dissented dissent VERB cjel-3536 96 16 and and CCONJ cjel-3536 96 17 argued argue VERB cjel-3536 96 18 that that SCONJ cjel-3536 96 19 the the DET cjel-3536 96 20 plaintiffs plaintiff NOUN cjel-3536 96 21 did do AUX cjel-3536 96 22 not not PART cjel-3536 96 23 have have AUX cjel-3536 96 24 standing stand VERB cjel-3536 96 25 because because SCONJ cjel-3536 96 26 they they PRON cjel-3536 96 27 did do AUX cjel-3536 96 28 not not PART cjel-3536 96 29 have have VERB cjel-3536 96 30 a a DET cjel-3536 96 31 “ " PUNCT cjel-3536 96 32 legally legally ADV cjel-3536 96 33 protected protect VERB cjel-3536 96 34 interest interest NOUN cjel-3536 96 35 ” " PUNCT cjel-3536 96 36 in in ADP cjel-3536 96 37 viewing view VERB cjel-3536 96 38 property property NOUN cjel-3536 96 39 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 96 40 nor nor CCONJ cjel-3536 96 41 a a DET cjel-3536 96 42 legal legal ADJ cjel-3536 96 43 right right NOUN cjel-3536 96 44 to to ADP cjel-3536 96 45 access.21 access.21 PROPN cjel-3536 96 46 a. a. NOUN cjel-3536 96 47 the the DET cjel-3536 96 48 district district NOUN cjel-3536 96 49 court court NOUN cjel-3536 96 50 ’s ’s PART cjel-3536 96 51 decision decision NOUN cjel-3536 96 52 denying deny VERB cjel-3536 96 53 article article PROPN cjel-3536 96 54 iii iii NUM cjel-3536 96 55 standing stand VERB cjel-3536 96 56 the the DET cjel-3536 96 57 district district NOUN cjel-3536 96 58 court court NOUN cjel-3536 96 59 held hold VERB cjel-3536 96 60 that that SCONJ cjel-3536 96 61 the the DET cjel-3536 96 62 plaintiffs plaintiff NOUN cjel-3536 96 63 failed fail VERB cjel-3536 96 64 to to PART cjel-3536 96 65 establish establish VERB cjel-3536 96 66 any any PRON cjel-3536 96 67 of of ADP cjel-3536 96 68 the the DET cjel-3536 96 69 three three NUM cjel-3536 96 70 requirements requirement NOUN cjel-3536 96 71 for for ADP cjel-3536 96 72 standing standing NOUN cjel-3536 96 73 : : PUNCT cjel-3536 96 74 injury injury NOUN cjel-3536 96 75 in in ADP cjel-3536 96 76 fact fact NOUN cjel-3536 96 77 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 96 78 causation causation NOUN cjel-3536 96 79 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 96 80 or or CCONJ cjel-3536 96 81 redressability.22 redressability.22 NOUN cjel-3536 96 82 first first ADV cjel-3536 96 83 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 96 84 the the DET cjel-3536 96 85 court court NOUN cjel-3536 96 86 concluded conclude VERB cjel-3536 96 87 that that SCONJ cjel-3536 96 88 the the DET cjel-3536 96 89 plaintiffs plaintiff NOUN cjel-3536 96 90 did do AUX cjel-3536 96 91 not not PART cjel-3536 96 92 prove prove VERB cjel-3536 96 93 that that SCONJ cjel-3536 96 94 the the DET cjel-3536 96 95 alleged allege VERB cjel-3536 96 96 injury injury NOUN cjel-3536 96 97 was be AUX cjel-3536 96 98 “ " PUNCT cjel-3536 96 99 actual actual ADJ cjel-3536 96 100 or or CCONJ cjel-3536 96 101 imminent imminent ADJ cjel-3536 96 102 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 97 1 ”23 ”23 ADV cjel-3536 97 2 while while SCONJ cjel-3536 97 3 “ " PUNCT cjel-3536 97 4 a a DET cjel-3536 97 5 considerable considerable ADJ cjel-3536 97 6 amount amount NOUN cjel-3536 97 7 of of ADP cjel-3536 97 8 the the DET cjel-3536 97 9 battlefield battlefield NOUN cjel-3536 97 10 [ [ X cjel-3536 97 11 wa]s wa]s PROPN cjel-3536 97 12 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 97 13 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 97 14 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 98 1 currently currently ADV cjel-3536 98 2 subject subject ADJ cjel-3536 98 3 to to ADP cjel-3536 98 4 surface surface NOUN cjel-3536 98 5 mining mining NOUN cjel-3536 98 6 permits permit NOUN cjel-3536 98 7 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 98 8 ” " PUNCT cjel-3536 98 9 the the DET cjel-3536 98 10 court court NOUN cjel-3536 98 11 determined determine VERB cjel-3536 98 12 that that SCONJ cjel-3536 98 13 there there PRON cjel-3536 98 14 was be VERB cjel-3536 98 15 no no DET cjel-3536 98 16 actual actual ADJ cjel-3536 98 17 or or CCONJ cjel-3536 98 18 imminent imminent ADJ cjel-3536 98 19 injury injury NOUN cjel-3536 98 20 because because SCONJ cjel-3536 98 21 the the DET cjel-3536 98 22 coal coal NOUN cjel-3536 98 23 companies company NOUN cjel-3536 98 24 had have VERB cjel-3536 98 25 yet yet ADV cjel-3536 98 26 to to PART cjel-3536 98 27 mine mine VERB cjel-3536 98 28 the the DET cjel-3536 98 29 battlefield battlefield NOUN cjel-3536 98 30 under under ADP cjel-3536 98 31 their their PRON cjel-3536 98 32 existing exist VERB cjel-3536 98 33 permits permit NOUN cjel-3536 98 34 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 98 35 which which PRON cjel-3536 98 36 in in ADP cjel-3536 98 37 some some DET cjel-3536 98 38 cases case NOUN cjel-3536 98 39 had have AUX cjel-3536 98 40 been be AUX cjel-3536 98 41 dormant dormant ADJ cjel-3536 98 42 for for ADP cjel-3536 98 43 several several ADJ cjel-3536 98 44 years year NOUN cjel-3536 98 45 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 98 46 and and CCONJ cjel-3536 98 47 it it PRON cjel-3536 98 48 was be AUX cjel-3536 98 49 unclear unclear ADJ cjel-3536 98 50 whether whether SCONJ cjel-3536 98 51 they they PRON cjel-3536 98 52 would would AUX cjel-3536 98 53 mine mine VERB cjel-3536 98 54 the the DET cjel-3536 98 55 land land NOUN cjel-3536 98 56 in in ADP cjel-3536 98 57 the the DET cjel-3536 98 58 near near ADJ cjel-3536 98 59 future.24 future.24 NOUN cjel-3536 98 60 because because SCONJ cjel-3536 98 61 it it PRON cjel-3536 98 62 found find VERB cjel-3536 98 63 that that SCONJ cjel-3536 98 64 there there PRON cjel-3536 98 65 was be VERB cjel-3536 98 66 no no DET cjel-3536 98 67 actual actual ADJ cjel-3536 98 68 or or CCONJ cjel-3536 98 69 imminent imminent ADJ cjel-3536 98 70 injury injury NOUN cjel-3536 98 71 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 98 72 the the DET cjel-3536 98 73 district district NOUN cjel-3536 98 74 court court NOUN cjel-3536 98 75 did do AUX cjel-3536 98 76 not not PART cjel-3536 98 77 discuss discuss VERB cjel-3536 98 78 whether whether SCONJ cjel-3536 98 79 viewing view VERB cjel-3536 98 80 another another DET cjel-3536 98 81 person person NOUN cjel-3536 98 82 ’s ’s PART cjel-3536 98 83 property property NOUN cjel-3536 98 84 could could AUX cjel-3536 98 85 constitute constitute VERB cjel-3536 98 86 an an DET cjel-3536 98 87 injury injury NOUN cjel-3536 98 88 sufficient sufficient ADJ cjel-3536 98 89 for for ADP cjel-3536 98 90 article article NOUN cjel-3536 98 91 iii iii NUM cjel-3536 98 92 standing.25 standing.25 PROPN cjel-3536 98 93 second second PROPN cjel-3536 98 94 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 98 95 the the DET cjel-3536 98 96 court court NOUN cjel-3536 98 97 reasoned reason VERB cjel-3536 98 98 that that SCONJ cjel-3536 98 99 the the DET cjel-3536 98 100 plaintiffs plaintiff NOUN cjel-3536 98 101 failed fail VERB cjel-3536 98 102 to to PART cjel-3536 98 103 prove prove VERB cjel-3536 98 104 standing stand VERB cjel-3536 98 105 causation causation NOUN cjel-3536 98 106 because because SCONJ cjel-3536 98 107 their their PRON cjel-3536 98 108 concerns concern NOUN cjel-3536 98 109 about about ADP cjel-3536 98 110 the the DET cjel-3536 98 111 mining mining NOUN cjel-3536 98 112 of of ADP cjel-3536 98 113 the the DET cjel-3536 98 114 battlefield battlefield NOUN cjel-3536 98 115 depended depend VERB cjel-3536 98 116 on on ADP cjel-3536 98 117 “ " PUNCT cjel-3536 98 118 speculative speculative ADJ cjel-3536 98 119 predictions prediction NOUN cjel-3536 98 120 about about ADP cjel-3536 98 121 the the DET cjel-3536 98 122 actions action NOUN cjel-3536 98 123 of of ADP cjel-3536 98 124 third third ADJ cjel-3536 98 125 parties party NOUN cjel-3536 98 126 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 98 127 the the DET cjel-3536 98 128 coal coal NOUN cjel-3536 98 129 mining mining NOUN cjel-3536 98 130 companies company NOUN cjel-3536 98 131 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 98 132 ” " PUNCT cjel-3536 98 133 and and CCONJ cjel-3536 98 134 not not PART cjel-3536 98 135 on on ADP cjel-3536 98 136 the the DET cjel-3536 98 137 actions action NOUN cjel-3536 98 138 of of ADP cjel-3536 98 139 the the DET cjel-3536 98 140 government government NOUN cjel-3536 98 141 defendant.26 defendant.26 ADJ cjel-3536 98 142 third third ADJ cjel-3536 98 143 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 98 144 although although SCONJ cjel-3536 98 145 federal federal ADJ cjel-3536 98 146 and and CCONJ cjel-3536 98 147 west west PROPN cjel-3536 98 148 virginia virginia PROPN cjel-3536 98 149 mining mining NOUN cjel-3536 98 150 law law NOUN cjel-3536 98 151 generally generally ADV cjel-3536 98 152 imposes impose VERB cjel-3536 98 153 prohibitions prohibition NOUN cjel-3536 98 154 on on ADP cjel-3536 98 155 surface surface NOUN cjel-3536 98 156 mining mining NOUN cjel-3536 98 157 on on ADP cjel-3536 98 158 property property NOUN cjel-3536 98 159 listed list VERB cjel-3536 98 160 in in ADP cjel-3536 98 161 the the DET cjel-3536 98 162 register,27 register,27 PROPN cjel-3536 98 163 the the DET cjel-3536 98 164 court court NOUN cjel-3536 98 165 concluded conclude VERB cjel-3536 98 166 that that SCONJ cjel-3536 98 167 a a DET cjel-3536 98 168 favorable favorable ADJ cjel-3536 98 169 court court NOUN cjel-3536 98 170 ruling ruling NOUN cjel-3536 98 171 requiring require VERB cjel-3536 98 172 the the DET cjel-3536 98 173 battlefield battlefield NOUN cjel-3536 98 174 to to PART cjel-3536 98 175 be be AUX cjel-3536 98 176 listed list VERB cjel-3536 98 177 would would AUX cjel-3536 98 178 not not PART cjel-3536 98 179 redress redress VERB cjel-3536 98 180 their their PRON cjel-3536 98 181 potential potential ADJ cjel-3536 98 182 injury injury NOUN cjel-3536 98 183 because because SCONJ cjel-3536 98 184 such such ADJ cjel-3536 98 185 prohibitions prohibition NOUN cjel-3536 98 186 contained contain VERB cjel-3536 98 187 an an DET cjel-3536 98 188 20 20 NUM cjel-3536 98 189 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 99 1 i i PRON cjel-3536 99 2 d. d. PROPN cjel-3536 99 3 at at ADP cjel-3536 99 4 3 3 NUM cjel-3536 99 5 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 99 6 5–9 5–9 NUM cjel-3536 99 7 . . NOUN cjel-3536 99 8 21 21 NUM cjel-3536 99 9 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 100 1 i i PRON cjel-3536 100 2 d. d. PROPN cjel-3536 100 3 at at ADP cjel-3536 100 4 9–11 9–11 PROPN cjel-3536 100 5 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 100 6 sentelle sentelle NOUN cjel-3536 100 7 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 100 8 j. j. PROPN cjel-3536 100 9 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 100 10 dissenting dissent VERB cjel-3536 100 11 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 100 12 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 100 13 quoting quote VERB cjel-3536 100 14 lujan lujan PROPN cjel-3536 100 15 v. v. ADP cjel-3536 100 16 defenders defender NOUN cjel-3536 100 17 of of ADP cjel-3536 100 18 wildlife wildlife NOUN cjel-3536 100 19 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 100 20 504 504 NUM cjel-3536 100 21 u.s u.s PROPN cjel-3536 100 22 . . PROPN cjel-3536 100 23 555 555 NUM cjel-3536 100 24 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 100 25 560 560 NUM cjel-3536 100 26 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 100 27 1992 1992 NUM cjel-3536 100 28 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 100 29 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 100 30 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 101 1 22 22 NUM cjel-3536 101 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 102 1 sierra sierra PROPN cjel-3536 102 2 club club PROPN cjel-3536 102 3 v. v. PROPN cjel-3536 102 4 salazar salazar PROPN cjel-3536 102 5 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 102 6 894 894 NUM cjel-3536 102 7 f. f. PROPN cjel-3536 102 8 supp supp PROPN cjel-3536 102 9 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 103 1 2d 2d PROPN cjel-3536 103 2 97 97 NUM cjel-3536 103 3 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 103 4 110–14 110–14 NUM cjel-3536 103 5 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 103 6 d.d.c d.d.c PROPN cjel-3536 103 7 . . PROPN cjel-3536 103 8 2012 2012 NUM cjel-3536 103 9 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 103 10 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 104 1 23 23 NUM cjel-3536 104 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 105 1 i i PRON cjel-3536 105 2 d. d. PROPN cjel-3536 105 3 at at ADP cjel-3536 105 4 110 110 NUM cjel-3536 105 5 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 105 6 internal internal ADJ cjel-3536 105 7 quotation quotation NOUN cjel-3536 105 8 marks mark NOUN cjel-3536 105 9 omitted omit VERB cjel-3536 105 10 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 105 11 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 106 1 24 24 NUM cjel-3536 106 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 107 1 i i PRON cjel-3536 107 2 d. d. PROPN cjel-3536 107 3 at at ADP cjel-3536 107 4 110–12 110–12 PROPN cjel-3536 107 5 . . PROPN cjel-3536 108 1 25 25 NUM cjel-3536 108 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 109 1 i i PRON cjel-3536 109 2 d. d. PROPN cjel-3536 109 3 26 26 NUM cjel-3536 109 4 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 110 1 i i PRON cjel-3536 110 2 d. d. PROPN cjel-3536 110 3 at at ADP cjel-3536 110 4 113 113 NUM cjel-3536 110 5 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 110 6 27 27 NUM cjel-3536 110 7 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 111 1 i i PRON cjel-3536 111 2 d. d. PROPN cjel-3536 111 3 at at ADP cjel-3536 111 4 114 114 NUM cjel-3536 111 5 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 111 6 citing cite VERB cjel-3536 111 7 30 30 NUM cjel-3536 111 8 u.s.c u.s.c ADJ cjel-3536 111 9 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 112 1 § § PROPN cjel-3536 112 2 1272(e)(3 1272(e)(3 NUM cjel-3536 112 3 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 112 4 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 112 5 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 113 1 mank mank PROPN cjel-3536 113 2 - - PUNCT cjel-3536 113 3 macro-[final macro-[final PROPN cjel-3536 113 4 6 6 NUM cjel-3536 113 5 - - SYM cjel-3536 113 6 19 19 NUM cjel-3536 113 7 ] ] PUNCT cjel-3536 113 8 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 113 9 do do AUX cjel-3536 113 10 not not PART cjel-3536 113 11 delete delete VERB cjel-3536 113 12 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 113 13 6/22/2015 6/22/2015 NUM cjel-3536 113 14 11:45 11:45 NUM cjel-3536 113 15 pm pm NOUN cjel-3536 113 16 2015 2015 NUM cjel-3536 113 17 ] ] PUNCT cjel-3536 113 18 standing stand VERB cjel-3536 113 19 to to PART cjel-3536 113 20 view view VERB cjel-3536 113 21 other other ADJ cjel-3536 113 22 people people NOUN cjel-3536 113 23 ’s ’s PART cjel-3536 113 24 land land NOUN cjel-3536 113 25 311 311 NUM cjel-3536 113 26 exemption exemption NOUN cjel-3536 113 27 for for ADP cjel-3536 113 28 permits permit NOUN cjel-3536 113 29 with with ADP cjel-3536 113 30 valid valid ADJ cjel-3536 113 31 existing exist VERB cjel-3536 113 32 rights.28 rights.28 NOUN cjel-3536 113 33 the the DET cjel-3536 113 34 district district NOUN cjel-3536 113 35 court court NOUN cjel-3536 113 36 reasoned reason VERB cjel-3536 113 37 that that SCONJ cjel-3536 113 38 the the DET cjel-3536 113 39 coal coal NOUN cjel-3536 113 40 companies company NOUN cjel-3536 113 41 probably probably ADV cjel-3536 113 42 had have VERB cjel-3536 113 43 valid valid ADJ cjel-3536 113 44 existing exist VERB cjel-3536 113 45 rights right NOUN cjel-3536 113 46 because because SCONJ cjel-3536 113 47 their their PRON cjel-3536 113 48 permits permit NOUN cjel-3536 113 49 had have AUX cjel-3536 113 50 been be AUX cjel-3536 113 51 acquired acquire VERB cjel-3536 113 52 before before ADP cjel-3536 113 53 the the DET cjel-3536 113 54 historic historic ADJ cjel-3536 113 55 district district NOUN cjel-3536 113 56 ’s ’s PART cjel-3536 113 57 inclusion inclusion NOUN cjel-3536 113 58 in in ADP cjel-3536 113 59 the the DET cjel-3536 113 60 national national ADJ cjel-3536 113 61 register register NOUN cjel-3536 113 62 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 113 63 and and CCONJ cjel-3536 113 64 therefore therefore ADV cjel-3536 113 65 “ " PUNCT cjel-3536 113 66 surface surface NOUN cjel-3536 113 67 mining mining NOUN cjel-3536 113 68 would would AUX cjel-3536 113 69 be be AUX cjel-3536 113 70 permitted permit VERB cjel-3536 113 71 on on ADP cjel-3536 113 72 the the DET cjel-3536 113 73 blair blair PROPN cjel-3536 113 74 mountain mountain PROPN cjel-3536 113 75 battlefield battlefield NOUN cjel-3536 113 76 ” " PUNCT cjel-3536 113 77 even even ADV cjel-3536 113 78 if if SCONJ cjel-3536 113 79 the the DET cjel-3536 113 80 keeper keeper NOUN cjel-3536 113 81 relisted reliste VERB cjel-3536 113 82 the the DET cjel-3536 113 83 battlefield.29 battlefield.29 NOUN cjel-3536 113 84 because because SCONJ cjel-3536 113 85 the the DET cjel-3536 113 86 plaintiffs plaintiff NOUN cjel-3536 113 87 had have AUX cjel-3536 113 88 failed fail VERB cjel-3536 113 89 to to PART cjel-3536 113 90 establish establish VERB cjel-3536 113 91 article article PROPN cjel-3536 113 92 iii iii PROPN cjel-3536 113 93 standing standing PROPN cjel-3536 113 94 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 113 95 the the DET cjel-3536 113 96 district district NOUN cjel-3536 113 97 court court NOUN cjel-3536 113 98 granted grant VERB cjel-3536 113 99 the the DET cjel-3536 113 100 defendants defendant NOUN cjel-3536 113 101 ’ ' PUNCT cjel-3536 113 102 motion motion NOUN cjel-3536 113 103 for for ADP cjel-3536 113 104 summary summary NOUN cjel-3536 114 1 judgment.30 judgment.30 PROPN cjel-3536 114 2 b. b. PROPN cjel-3536 114 3 the the DET cjel-3536 114 4 d.c d.c PROPN cjel-3536 114 5 . . PROPN cjel-3536 114 6 circuit circuit PROPN cjel-3536 114 7 ’s ’s PART cjel-3536 114 8 majority majority NOUN cjel-3536 114 9 opinion opinion NOUN cjel-3536 114 10 a a DET cjel-3536 114 11 majority majority NOUN cjel-3536 114 12 of of ADP cjel-3536 114 13 the the DET cjel-3536 114 14 d.c d.c PROPN cjel-3536 114 15 . . PROPN cjel-3536 114 16 circuit circuit PROPN cjel-3536 114 17 panel panel NOUN cjel-3536 114 18 concluded conclude VERB cjel-3536 114 19 that that SCONJ cjel-3536 114 20 the the DET cjel-3536 114 21 plaintiffs plaintiff NOUN cjel-3536 114 22 had have AUX cjel-3536 114 23 established establish VERB cjel-3536 114 24 article article NOUN cjel-3536 114 25 iii iii NUM cjel-3536 114 26 standing standing PROPN cjel-3536 114 27 and and CCONJ cjel-3536 114 28 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 114 29 therefore therefore ADV cjel-3536 114 30 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 114 31 reversed reverse VERB cjel-3536 114 32 the the DET cjel-3536 114 33 judgment judgment NOUN cjel-3536 114 34 of of ADP cjel-3536 114 35 the the DET cjel-3536 114 36 lower low ADJ cjel-3536 114 37 court.31 court.31 NOUN cjel-3536 115 1 the the DET cjel-3536 115 2 d.c d.c PROPN cjel-3536 115 3 . . PROPN cjel-3536 115 4 circuit circuit PROPN cjel-3536 115 5 determined determine VERB cjel-3536 115 6 that that SCONJ cjel-3536 115 7 the the DET cjel-3536 115 8 plaintiffs plaintiff NOUN cjel-3536 115 9 ’ ’ PART cjel-3536 115 10 aesthetic aesthetic ADJ cjel-3536 115 11 interest interest NOUN cjel-3536 115 12 in in ADP cjel-3536 115 13 viewing view VERB cjel-3536 115 14 of of ADP cjel-3536 115 15 the the DET cjel-3536 115 16 battlefield battlefield NOUN cjel-3536 115 17 constituted constitute VERB cjel-3536 115 18 a a DET cjel-3536 115 19 concrete concrete ADJ cjel-3536 115 20 and and CCONJ cjel-3536 115 21 particularized particularize VERB cjel-3536 115 22 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 115 23 and and CCONJ cjel-3536 115 24 actual actual ADJ cjel-3536 115 25 or or CCONJ cjel-3536 115 26 imminent imminent ADJ cjel-3536 115 27 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 115 28 injury.32 injury.32 VERB cjel-3536 115 29 the the DET cjel-3536 115 30 court court NOUN cjel-3536 115 31 observed observe VERB cjel-3536 115 32 that that SCONJ cjel-3536 115 33 supreme supreme PROPN cjel-3536 115 34 court court PROPN cjel-3536 115 35 and and CCONJ cjel-3536 115 36 d.c d.c PROPN cjel-3536 115 37 . . PROPN cjel-3536 115 38 circuit circuit PROPN cjel-3536 115 39 precedent precedent NOUN cjel-3536 115 40 clearly clearly ADV cjel-3536 115 41 established establish VERB cjel-3536 115 42 that that SCONJ cjel-3536 115 43 the the DET cjel-3536 115 44 purely purely ADV cjel-3536 115 45 aesthetic aesthetic ADJ cjel-3536 115 46 interests interest NOUN cjel-3536 115 47 of of ADP cjel-3536 115 48 a a DET cjel-3536 115 49 plaintiff plaintiff NOUN cjel-3536 115 50 in in ADP cjel-3536 115 51 viewing view VERB cjel-3536 115 52 property property NOUN cjel-3536 115 53 or or CCONJ cjel-3536 115 54 animals animal NOUN cjel-3536 115 55 are be AUX cjel-3536 115 56 sufficient sufficient ADJ cjel-3536 115 57 for for ADP cjel-3536 115 58 standing stand VERB cjel-3536 115 59 injury.33 injury.33 PROPN cjel-3536 115 60 several several ADJ cjel-3536 115 61 members member NOUN cjel-3536 115 62 of of ADP cjel-3536 115 63 the the DET cjel-3536 115 64 plaintiff plaintiff NOUN cjel-3536 115 65 organizations organization NOUN cjel-3536 115 66 submitted submit VERB cjel-3536 115 67 declarations declaration NOUN cjel-3536 115 68 stating state VERB cjel-3536 115 69 that that SCONJ cjel-3536 115 70 their their PRON cjel-3536 115 71 enjoyment enjoyment NOUN cjel-3536 115 72 of of ADP cjel-3536 115 73 viewing view VERB cjel-3536 115 74 the the DET cjel-3536 115 75 battlefield battlefield NOUN cjel-3536 115 76 would would AUX cjel-3536 115 77 be be AUX cjel-3536 115 78 diminished diminish VERB cjel-3536 115 79 if if SCONJ cjel-3536 115 80 the the DET cjel-3536 115 81 coal coal NOUN cjel-3536 115 82 companies company NOUN cjel-3536 115 83 mined mine VERB cjel-3536 115 84 the the DET cjel-3536 115 85 site.34 site.34 NOUN cjel-3536 115 86 amicus amicus PROPN cjel-3536 115 87 west west PROPN cjel-3536 115 88 virginia virginia PROPN cjel-3536 115 89 coal coal PROPN cjel-3536 115 90 association association NOUN cjel-3536 115 91 argued argue VERB cjel-3536 115 92 that that SCONJ cjel-3536 115 93 the the DET cjel-3536 115 94 plaintiffs plaintiff NOUN cjel-3536 115 95 could could AUX cjel-3536 115 96 not not PART cjel-3536 115 97 show show VERB cjel-3536 115 98 an an DET cjel-3536 115 99 injury injury NOUN cjel-3536 115 100 in in ADP cjel-3536 115 101 fact fact NOUN cjel-3536 115 102 because because SCONJ cjel-3536 115 103 the the DET cjel-3536 115 104 individuals individual NOUN cjel-3536 115 105 whose whose DET cjel-3536 115 106 interests interest NOUN cjel-3536 115 107 would would AUX cjel-3536 115 108 be be AUX cjel-3536 115 109 injured injure VERB cjel-3536 115 110 by by ADP cjel-3536 115 111 mining mining NOUN cjel-3536 115 112 of of ADP cjel-3536 115 113 the the DET cjel-3536 115 114 battlefield battlefield NOUN cjel-3536 115 115 owned own VERB cjel-3536 115 116 no no DET cjel-3536 115 117 legal legal ADJ cjel-3536 115 118 right right NOUN cjel-3536 115 119 to to PART cjel-3536 115 120 enter enter VERB cjel-3536 115 121 the the DET cjel-3536 115 122 battlefield battlefield NOUN cjel-3536 115 123 area.35 area.35 NOUN cjel-3536 115 124 the the DET cjel-3536 115 125 d.c d.c PROPN cjel-3536 115 126 . . PROPN cjel-3536 115 127 circuit circuit PROPN cjel-3536 115 128 acknowledged acknowledge VERB cjel-3536 115 129 that that SCONJ cjel-3536 115 130 the the DET cjel-3536 115 131 plaintiffs plaintiff NOUN cjel-3536 115 132 had have AUX cjel-3536 115 133 submitted submit VERB cjel-3536 115 134 no no DET cjel-3536 115 135 evidence evidence NOUN cjel-3536 115 136 that that SCONJ cjel-3536 115 137 they they PRON cjel-3536 115 138 “ " PUNCT cjel-3536 115 139 possess[ed possess[ed PROPN cjel-3536 115 140 ] ] PUNCT cjel-3536 115 141 any any DET cjel-3536 115 142 legal legal ADJ cjel-3536 115 143 entitlement entitlement NOUN cjel-3536 115 144 to to PART cjel-3536 115 145 set set VERB cjel-3536 115 146 foot foot NOUN cjel-3536 115 147 on on ADP cjel-3536 115 148 the the DET cjel-3536 115 149 privately privately ADV cjel-3536 115 150 owned own VERB cjel-3536 115 151 property property NOUN cjel-3536 115 152 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 115 153 ” " PUNCT cjel-3536 115 154 although although SCONJ cjel-3536 115 155 in in ADP cjel-3536 115 156 the the DET cjel-3536 115 157 past past ADJ cjel-3536 115 158 several several ADJ cjel-3536 115 159 members member NOUN cjel-3536 115 160 had have AUX cjel-3536 115 161 frequently frequently ADV cjel-3536 115 162 visited visit VERB cjel-3536 115 163 28 28 NUM cjel-3536 115 164 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 116 1 i i PRON cjel-3536 116 2 d. d. PROPN cjel-3536 116 3 29 29 NUM cjel-3536 116 4 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 117 1 i i PRON cjel-3536 117 2 d. d. PROPN cjel-3536 117 3 30 30 NUM cjel-3536 117 4 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 118 1 i i PRON cjel-3536 118 2 d. d. PROPN cjel-3536 118 3 31 31 NUM cjel-3536 118 4 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 119 1 sierra sierra PROPN cjel-3536 119 2 club club PROPN cjel-3536 119 3 v. v. PROPN cjel-3536 119 4 jewell jewell PROPN cjel-3536 119 5 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 119 6 764 764 NUM cjel-3536 119 7 f.3d f.3d NUM cjel-3536 119 8 1 1 NUM cjel-3536 119 9 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 119 10 5–9 5–9 PROPN cjel-3536 119 11 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 119 12 d.c d.c PROPN cjel-3536 119 13 . . PROPN cjel-3536 119 14 cir cir PROPN cjel-3536 119 15 . . PROPN cjel-3536 119 16 2014 2014 NUM cjel-3536 119 17 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 119 18 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 120 1 32 32 NUM cjel-3536 120 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 121 1 i i PRON cjel-3536 121 2 d. d. VERB cjel-3536 121 3 at at ADP cjel-3536 121 4 5–7 5–7 NUM cjel-3536 121 5 . . PROPN cjel-3536 122 1 33 33 NUM cjel-3536 122 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 123 1 i i PRON cjel-3536 123 2 d. d. PROPN cjel-3536 123 3 at at ADP cjel-3536 123 4 5 5 NUM cjel-3536 123 5 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 123 6 “ " PUNCT cjel-3536 123 7 the the DET cjel-3536 123 8 supreme supreme PROPN cjel-3536 123 9 court court PROPN cjel-3536 123 10 has have AUX cjel-3536 123 11 recognized recognize VERB cjel-3536 123 12 that that DET cjel-3536 123 13 harm harm NOUN cjel-3536 123 14 to to ADP cjel-3536 123 15 ‘ ' PUNCT cjel-3536 123 16 the the DET cjel-3536 123 17 mere mere ADJ cjel-3536 123 18 esthetic esthetic ADJ cjel-3536 123 19 interests interest NOUN cjel-3536 123 20 of of ADP cjel-3536 123 21 the the DET cjel-3536 123 22 plaintiff plaintiff NOUN cjel-3536 123 23 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 123 24 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 124 1 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 125 1 will will AUX cjel-3536 125 2 suffice suffice VERB cjel-3536 125 3 ’ ' PUNCT cjel-3536 125 4 to to PART cjel-3536 125 5 establish establish VERB cjel-3536 125 6 a a DET cjel-3536 125 7 concrete concrete ADJ cjel-3536 125 8 and and CCONJ cjel-3536 125 9 particularized particularized ADJ cjel-3536 125 10 injury injury NOUN cjel-3536 125 11 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 125 12 ” " PUNCT cjel-3536 125 13 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 125 14 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 125 15 quoting quote VERB cjel-3536 125 16 summers summer NOUN cjel-3536 125 17 v. v. ADP cjel-3536 125 18 earth earth PROPN cjel-3536 125 19 island island NOUN cjel-3536 125 20 inst inst PROPN cjel-3536 125 21 . . PROPN cjel-3536 125 22 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 125 23 555 555 NUM cjel-3536 125 24 u.s u.s PROPN cjel-3536 125 25 . . PROPN cjel-3536 125 26 488 488 NUM cjel-3536 125 27 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 125 28 494 494 NUM cjel-3536 125 29 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 125 30 2009 2009 NUM cjel-3536 125 31 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 125 32 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 125 33 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 126 1 34 34 NUM cjel-3536 126 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 127 1 i i PRON cjel-3536 127 2 d. d. PROPN cjel-3536 127 3 at at ADP cjel-3536 127 4 5–6 5–6 NUM cjel-3536 127 5 . . PROPN cjel-3536 127 6 35 35 NUM cjel-3536 127 7 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 128 1 i i PRON cjel-3536 128 2 d. d. PROPN cjel-3536 128 3 at at ADP cjel-3536 128 4 6 6 NUM cjel-3536 128 5 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 128 6 mank mank NOUN cjel-3536 128 7 - - PUNCT cjel-3536 128 8 macro-[final macro-[final PROPN cjel-3536 128 9 6 6 NUM cjel-3536 128 10 - - SYM cjel-3536 128 11 19 19 NUM cjel-3536 128 12 ] ] PUNCT cjel-3536 128 13 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 128 14 do do AUX cjel-3536 128 15 not not PART cjel-3536 128 16 delete delete VERB cjel-3536 128 17 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 129 1 6/22/2015 6/22/2015 NUM cjel-3536 129 2 11:45 11:45 NUM cjel-3536 129 3 pm pm NOUN cjel-3536 129 4 312 312 NUM cjel-3536 129 5 columbia columbia PROPN cjel-3536 129 6 journal journal PROPN cjel-3536 129 7 of of ADP cjel-3536 129 8 environmental environmental ADJ cjel-3536 129 9 law law NOUN cjel-3536 130 1 [ [ X cjel-3536 130 2 vol vol NOUN cjel-3536 130 3 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 131 1 40:2 40:2 NOUN cjel-3536 131 2 the the DET cjel-3536 131 3 site.36 site.36 NOUN cjel-3536 131 4 however however ADV cjel-3536 131 5 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 131 6 the the DET cjel-3536 131 7 d.c d.c PROPN cjel-3536 131 8 . . PROPN cjel-3536 131 9 circuit circuit PROPN cjel-3536 131 10 concluded conclude VERB cjel-3536 131 11 that that SCONJ cjel-3536 131 12 it it PRON cjel-3536 131 13 was be AUX cjel-3536 131 14 irrelevant irrelevant ADJ cjel-3536 131 15 whether whether SCONJ cjel-3536 131 16 they they PRON cjel-3536 131 17 could could AUX cjel-3536 131 18 physically physically ADV cjel-3536 131 19 enter enter VERB cjel-3536 131 20 the the DET cjel-3536 131 21 battlefield battlefield NOUN cjel-3536 131 22 because because SCONJ cjel-3536 131 23 they they PRON cjel-3536 131 24 could could AUX cjel-3536 131 25 view view VERB cjel-3536 131 26 it it PRON cjel-3536 131 27 from from ADP cjel-3536 131 28 public public ADJ cjel-3536 131 29 roads road NOUN cjel-3536 131 30 or or CCONJ cjel-3536 131 31 surrounding surround VERB cjel-3536 131 32 areas area NOUN cjel-3536 131 33 without without ADP cjel-3536 131 34 committing commit VERB cjel-3536 131 35 a a DET cjel-3536 131 36 trespass.37 trespass.37 NOUN cjel-3536 131 37 because because SCONJ cjel-3536 131 38 they they PRON cjel-3536 131 39 could could AUX cjel-3536 131 40 view view VERB cjel-3536 131 41 the the DET cjel-3536 131 42 property property NOUN cjel-3536 131 43 from from ADP cjel-3536 131 44 public public ADJ cjel-3536 131 45 lands land NOUN cjel-3536 131 46 or or CCONJ cjel-3536 131 47 surrounding surround VERB cjel-3536 131 48 areas area NOUN cjel-3536 131 49 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 131 50 the the DET cjel-3536 131 51 court court NOUN cjel-3536 131 52 reasoned reason VERB cjel-3536 131 53 that that SCONJ cjel-3536 131 54 the the DET cjel-3536 131 55 plaintiffs plaintiff NOUN cjel-3536 131 56 did do AUX cjel-3536 131 57 not not PART cjel-3536 131 58 need need VERB cjel-3536 131 59 a a DET cjel-3536 131 60 legal legal ADJ cjel-3536 131 61 interest interest NOUN cjel-3536 131 62 in in ADP cjel-3536 131 63 entering enter VERB cjel-3536 131 64 the the DET cjel-3536 131 65 battlefield battlefield NOUN cjel-3536 131 66 to to PART cjel-3536 131 67 have have VERB cjel-3536 131 68 a a DET cjel-3536 131 69 cognizable cognizable ADJ cjel-3536 131 70 standing standing NOUN cjel-3536 131 71 interest interest NOUN cjel-3536 131 72 in in ADP cjel-3536 131 73 viewing view VERB cjel-3536 131 74 the the DET cjel-3536 131 75 site.38 site.38 NOUN cjel-3536 131 76 “ " PUNCT cjel-3536 131 77 accordingly accordingly ADV cjel-3536 131 78 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 131 79 there there ADV cjel-3536 132 1 [ [ X cjel-3536 132 2 wa]s wa]s ADJ cjel-3536 132 3 no no DET cjel-3536 132 4 reason reason NOUN cjel-3536 132 5 that that SCONJ cjel-3536 132 6 the the DET cjel-3536 132 7 cognizability cognizability NOUN cjel-3536 132 8 of of ADP cjel-3536 132 9 aesthetic aesthetic ADJ cjel-3536 132 10 and and CCONJ cjel-3536 132 11 associated associated ADJ cjel-3536 132 12 interests interest NOUN cjel-3536 132 13 in in ADP cjel-3536 132 14 a a DET cjel-3536 132 15 particular particular ADJ cjel-3536 132 16 site site NOUN cjel-3536 132 17 could could AUX cjel-3536 132 18 turn turn VERB cjel-3536 132 19 on on ADP cjel-3536 132 20 owning own VERB cjel-3536 132 21 a a DET cjel-3536 132 22 legal legal ADJ cjel-3536 132 23 right right NOUN cjel-3536 132 24 to to PART cjel-3536 132 25 enter enter VERB cjel-3536 132 26 or or CCONJ cjel-3536 132 27 view view VERB cjel-3536 132 28 the the DET cjel-3536 132 29 property property NOUN cjel-3536 132 30 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 133 1 ”39 ”39 PROPN cjel-3536 133 2 the the DET cjel-3536 133 3 d.c d.c PROPN cjel-3536 133 4 . . PROPN cjel-3536 133 5 circuit circuit PROPN cjel-3536 133 6 relied rely VERB cjel-3536 133 7 on on ADP cjel-3536 133 8 circuit circuit NOUN cjel-3536 133 9 precedent precedent NOUN cjel-3536 133 10 and and CCONJ cjel-3536 133 11 a a DET cjel-3536 133 12 ninth ninth ADJ cjel-3536 133 13 circuit circuit NOUN cjel-3536 133 14 decision decision NOUN cjel-3536 133 15 supporting support VERB cjel-3536 133 16 its its PRON cjel-3536 133 17 position position NOUN cjel-3536 133 18 that that SCONJ cjel-3536 133 19 a a DET cjel-3536 133 20 standing standing NOUN cjel-3536 133 21 injury injury NOUN cjel-3536 133 22 may may AUX cjel-3536 133 23 result result VERB cjel-3536 133 24 from from ADP cjel-3536 133 25 government government NOUN cjel-3536 133 26 actions action NOUN cjel-3536 133 27 that that PRON cjel-3536 133 28 could could AUX cjel-3536 133 29 interfere interfere VERB cjel-3536 133 30 with with ADP cjel-3536 133 31 aesthetic aesthetic ADJ cjel-3536 133 32 viewing viewing NOUN cjel-3536 133 33 of of ADP cjel-3536 133 34 another another DET cjel-3536 133 35 person person NOUN cjel-3536 133 36 ’s ’s PART cjel-3536 133 37 property.40 property.40 NOUN cjel-3536 133 38 in in ADP cjel-3536 133 39 a a DET cjel-3536 133 40 1988 1988 NUM cjel-3536 133 41 d.c d.c PROPN cjel-3536 133 42 . . PROPN cjel-3536 133 43 circuit circuit PROPN cjel-3536 133 44 decision decision NOUN cjel-3536 133 45 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 133 46 the the DET cjel-3536 133 47 court court NOUN cjel-3536 133 48 had have AUX cjel-3536 133 49 found find VERB cjel-3536 133 50 a a DET cjel-3536 133 51 standing standing ADJ cjel-3536 133 52 injury injury NOUN cjel-3536 133 53 by by ADP cjel-3536 133 54 “ " PUNCT cjel-3536 133 55 rely[ing rely[e VERB cjel-3536 133 56 ] ] PUNCT cjel-3536 133 57 solely solely ADV cjel-3536 133 58 on on ADP cjel-3536 133 59 impairment impairment NOUN cjel-3536 133 60 of of ADP cjel-3536 133 61 the the DET cjel-3536 133 62 affiant affiant NOUN cjel-3536 133 63 ’s ’s PART cjel-3536 133 64 ability ability NOUN cjel-3536 133 65 to to PART cjel-3536 133 66 enjoy enjoy VERB cjel-3536 133 67 the the DET cjel-3536 133 68 ‘ ' PUNCT cjel-3536 133 69 natural natural ADJ cjel-3536 133 70 vistas vista NOUN cjel-3536 133 71 ’ ' PUNCT cjel-3536 133 72 of of ADP cjel-3536 133 73 the the DET cjel-3536 133 74 nearby nearby ADJ cjel-3536 133 75 hills hill NOUN cjel-3536 133 76 from from ADP cjel-3536 133 77 her her PRON cjel-3536 133 78 own own ADJ cjel-3536 133 79 home home NOUN cjel-3536 133 80 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 133 81 regardless regardless ADV cjel-3536 133 82 of of ADP cjel-3536 133 83 the the DET cjel-3536 133 84 absence absence NOUN cjel-3536 133 85 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 133 86 or or CCONJ cjel-3536 133 87 existence existence NOUN cjel-3536 133 88 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 133 89 of of ADP cjel-3536 133 90 any any DET cjel-3536 133 91 legal legal ADJ cjel-3536 133 92 right right NOUN cjel-3536 133 93 on on ADP cjel-3536 133 94 her her PRON cjel-3536 133 95 part part NOUN cjel-3536 133 96 to to PART cjel-3536 133 97 view view VERB cjel-3536 133 98 or or CCONJ cjel-3536 133 99 make make VERB cjel-3536 133 100 an an DET cjel-3536 133 101 entry entry NOUN cjel-3536 133 102 onto onto ADP cjel-3536 133 103 the the DET cjel-3536 133 104 nearby nearby ADJ cjel-3536 133 105 hills hill NOUN cjel-3536 133 106 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 134 1 ”41 ”41 PROPN cjel-3536 134 2 in in ADP cjel-3536 134 3 its its PRON cjel-3536 134 4 2001 2001 NUM cjel-3536 134 5 decision decision NOUN cjel-3536 134 6 cantrell cantrell PROPN cjel-3536 134 7 v. v. ADP cjel-3536 134 8 city city NOUN cjel-3536 134 9 of of ADP cjel-3536 134 10 long long ADJ cjel-3536 134 11 beach beach NOUN cjel-3536 134 12 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 134 13 the the DET cjel-3536 134 14 ninth ninth ADJ cjel-3536 134 15 circuit circuit NOUN cjel-3536 134 16 declared declare VERB cjel-3536 134 17 that that SCONJ cjel-3536 134 18 “ " PUNCT cjel-3536 134 19 [ [ X cjel-3536 134 20 i]f i]f ADP cjel-3536 134 21 an an DET cjel-3536 134 22 area area NOUN cjel-3536 134 23 can can AUX cjel-3536 134 24 be be AUX cjel-3536 134 25 observed observe VERB cjel-3536 134 26 and and CCONJ cjel-3536 134 27 enjoyed enjoy VERB cjel-3536 134 28 from from ADP cjel-3536 134 29 adjacent adjacent ADJ cjel-3536 134 30 land land NOUN cjel-3536 134 31 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 134 32 plaintiffs plaintiff NOUN cjel-3536 134 33 need need AUX cjel-3536 134 34 not not PART cjel-3536 134 35 physically physically ADV cjel-3536 134 36 enter enter VERB cjel-3536 134 37 the the DET cjel-3536 134 38 affected affected ADJ cjel-3536 134 39 area area NOUN cjel-3536 134 40 to to PART cjel-3536 134 41 establish establish VERB cjel-3536 134 42 an an DET cjel-3536 134 43 injury injury NOUN cjel-3536 134 44 in in ADP cjel-3536 134 45 fact fact NOUN cjel-3536 134 46 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 135 1 ”42 ”42 VERB cjel-3536 135 2 the the DET cjel-3536 135 3 d.c d.c PROPN cjel-3536 135 4 . . PROPN cjel-3536 135 5 circuit circuit PROPN cjel-3536 135 6 adopted adopt VERB cjel-3536 135 7 the the DET cjel-3536 135 8 cantrell cantrell PROPN cjel-3536 135 9 decision decision NOUN cjel-3536 135 10 ’s ’s PART cjel-3536 135 11 position position NOUN cjel-3536 135 12 that that SCONJ cjel-3536 135 13 plaintiffs plaintiff NOUN cjel-3536 135 14 who who PRON cjel-3536 135 15 view view VERB cjel-3536 135 16 another another DET cjel-3536 135 17 person person NOUN cjel-3536 135 18 ’s ’s PART cjel-3536 135 19 property property NOUN cjel-3536 135 20 may may AUX cjel-3536 135 21 have have AUX cjel-3536 135 22 standing.43 standing.43 NOUN cjel-3536 135 23 even even ADV cjel-3536 135 24 though though SCONJ cjel-3536 135 25 there there PRON cjel-3536 135 26 was be VERB cjel-3536 135 27 as as ADV cjel-3536 135 28 yet yet ADV cjel-3536 135 29 no no DET cjel-3536 135 30 surface surface NOUN cjel-3536 135 31 mining mining NOUN cjel-3536 135 32 at at ADP cjel-3536 135 33 the the DET cjel-3536 135 34 battlefield battlefield NOUN cjel-3536 135 35 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 135 36 the the DET cjel-3536 135 37 d.c d.c PROPN cjel-3536 135 38 . . PROPN cjel-3536 135 39 circuit circuit PROPN cjel-3536 135 40 concluded conclude VERB cjel-3536 135 41 that that SCONJ cjel-3536 135 42 the the DET cjel-3536 135 43 plaintiffs plaintiff NOUN cjel-3536 135 44 had have AUX cjel-3536 135 45 demonstrated demonstrate VERB cjel-3536 135 46 an an DET cjel-3536 135 47 “ " PUNCT cjel-3536 135 48 actual actual ADJ cjel-3536 135 49 or or CCONJ cjel-3536 135 50 imminent imminent ADJ cjel-3536 135 51 ” " PUNCT cjel-3536 135 52 standing standing NOUN cjel-3536 135 53 injury injury NOUN cjel-3536 135 54 by by ADP cjel-3536 135 55 showing show VERB cjel-3536 135 56 that that SCONJ cjel-3536 135 57 there there PRON cjel-3536 135 58 was be VERB cjel-3536 135 59 a a DET cjel-3536 135 60 “ " PUNCT cjel-3536 135 61 substantial substantial ADJ cjel-3536 135 62 probability probability NOUN cjel-3536 135 63 ” " PUNCT cjel-3536 135 64 of of ADP cjel-3536 135 65 mining mining NOUN cjel-3536 135 66 at at ADP cjel-3536 135 67 the the DET cjel-3536 135 68 site site NOUN cjel-3536 135 69 in in ADP cjel-3536 135 70 the the DET cjel-3536 135 71 near near ADJ cjel-3536 135 72 future.44 future.44 NOUN cjel-3536 135 73 in in ADP cjel-3536 135 74 reaching reach VERB cjel-3536 135 75 its its PRON cjel-3536 135 76 conclusion conclusion NOUN cjel-3536 135 77 that that SCONJ cjel-3536 135 78 36 36 NUM cjel-3536 135 79 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 136 1 i i PRON cjel-3536 136 2 d. d. PROPN cjel-3536 136 3 37 37 NUM cjel-3536 136 4 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 137 1 i i PRON cjel-3536 137 2 d. d. PROPN cjel-3536 137 3 38 38 NUM cjel-3536 137 4 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 138 1 i i PRON cjel-3536 138 2 d. d. PROPN cjel-3536 138 3 39 39 NUM cjel-3536 138 4 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 139 1 i i PRON cjel-3536 139 2 d. d. PROPN cjel-3536 139 3 40 40 NUM cjel-3536 139 4 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 140 1 i i PRON cjel-3536 140 2 d. d. PROPN cjel-3536 140 3 at at ADP cjel-3536 140 4 6–7 6–7 NUM cjel-3536 140 5 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 140 6 41 41 NUM cjel-3536 140 7 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 141 1 i i PRON cjel-3536 141 2 d. d. PROPN cjel-3536 141 3 at at ADP cjel-3536 141 4 6 6 NUM cjel-3536 141 5 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 141 6 quoting quote VERB cjel-3536 141 7 nat’l nat’l NUM cjel-3536 141 8 wildlife wildlife NOUN cjel-3536 141 9 fed’n fed’n NOUN cjel-3536 141 10 v. v. ADP cjel-3536 141 11 hodel hodel PROPN cjel-3536 141 12 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 141 13 839 839 NUM cjel-3536 141 14 f.2d f.2d ADP cjel-3536 141 15 694 694 NUM cjel-3536 141 16 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 141 17 714 714 NUM cjel-3536 141 18 - - SYM cjel-3536 141 19 15 15 NUM cjel-3536 141 20 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 141 21 d.c d.c PROPN cjel-3536 141 22 . . PROPN cjel-3536 141 23 cir cir PROPN cjel-3536 141 24 . . PROPN cjel-3536 141 25 1988 1988 NUM cjel-3536 141 26 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 141 27 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 141 28 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 142 1 42 42 NUM cjel-3536 142 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 143 1 241 241 NUM cjel-3536 143 2 f.3d f.3d NUM cjel-3536 143 3 674 674 NUM cjel-3536 143 4 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 143 5 681 681 NUM cjel-3536 143 6 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 143 7 9th 9th ADJ cjel-3536 143 8 cir cir NOUN cjel-3536 143 9 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 143 10 2001 2001 NUM cjel-3536 143 11 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 143 12 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 144 1 part part NOUN cjel-3536 144 2 iv iv PRON cjel-3536 144 3 will will AUX cjel-3536 144 4 further far ADV cjel-3536 144 5 discuss discuss VERB cjel-3536 144 6 the the DET cjel-3536 144 7 cantrell cantrell PROPN cjel-3536 144 8 decision decision NOUN cjel-3536 144 9 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 145 1 43 43 NUM cjel-3536 145 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 146 1 jewell jewell PROPN cjel-3536 146 2 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 146 3 764 764 NUM cjel-3536 146 4 f.3d f.3d NUM cjel-3536 146 5 at at ADP cjel-3536 146 6 6–7 6–7 NUM cjel-3536 146 7 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 146 8 44 44 NUM cjel-3536 146 9 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 147 1 i i PRON cjel-3536 147 2 d. d. PROPN cjel-3536 147 3 at at ADP cjel-3536 147 4 7 7 NUM cjel-3536 147 5 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 147 6 mank mank PROPN cjel-3536 147 7 - - PUNCT cjel-3536 147 8 macro-[final macro-[final PROPN cjel-3536 147 9 6 6 NUM cjel-3536 147 10 - - SYM cjel-3536 147 11 19 19 NUM cjel-3536 147 12 ] ] PUNCT cjel-3536 147 13 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 147 14 do do AUX cjel-3536 147 15 not not PART cjel-3536 147 16 delete delete VERB cjel-3536 147 17 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 148 1 6/22/2015 6/22/2015 NUM cjel-3536 148 2 11:45 11:45 NUM cjel-3536 148 3 pm pm NOUN cjel-3536 148 4 2015 2015 NUM cjel-3536 148 5 ] ] PUNCT cjel-3536 148 6 standing stand VERB cjel-3536 148 7 to to PART cjel-3536 148 8 view view VERB cjel-3536 148 9 other other ADJ cjel-3536 148 10 people people NOUN cjel-3536 148 11 ’s ’s PART cjel-3536 148 12 land land NOUN cjel-3536 148 13 313 313 NUM cjel-3536 148 14 there there PRON cjel-3536 148 15 was be VERB cjel-3536 148 16 a a DET cjel-3536 148 17 substantial substantial ADJ cjel-3536 148 18 probability probability NOUN cjel-3536 148 19 ” " PUNCT cjel-3536 148 20 of of ADP cjel-3536 148 21 mining mining NOUN cjel-3536 148 22 at at ADP cjel-3536 148 23 the the DET cjel-3536 148 24 site site NOUN cjel-3536 148 25 in in ADP cjel-3536 148 26 the the DET cjel-3536 148 27 near near ADJ cjel-3536 148 28 future future NOUN cjel-3536 148 29 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 148 30 the the DET cjel-3536 148 31 court court NOUN cjel-3536 148 32 observed observe VERB cjel-3536 148 33 that that SCONJ cjel-3536 148 34 “ " PUNCT cjel-3536 148 35 coal coal NOUN cjel-3536 148 36 companies company NOUN cjel-3536 148 37 have have AUX cjel-3536 148 38 mined mine VERB cjel-3536 148 39 in in ADP cjel-3536 148 40 the the DET cjel-3536 148 41 vicinity vicinity NOUN cjel-3536 148 42 of of ADP cjel-3536 148 43 the the DET cjel-3536 148 44 battlefield battlefield NOUN cjel-3536 148 45 under under ADP cjel-3536 148 46 permits permit NOUN cjel-3536 148 47 that that PRON cjel-3536 148 48 encompass encompass VERB cjel-3536 148 49 the the DET cjel-3536 148 50 battlefield battlefield NOUN cjel-3536 148 51 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 149 1 ”45 ”45 PROPN cjel-3536 149 2 additionally additionally ADV cjel-3536 149 3 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 149 4 the the DET cjel-3536 149 5 plaintiffs plaintiff NOUN cjel-3536 149 6 had have AUX cjel-3536 149 7 demonstrated demonstrate VERB cjel-3536 149 8 that that SCONJ cjel-3536 149 9 two two NUM cjel-3536 149 10 active active ADJ cjel-3536 149 11 permits permit NOUN cjel-3536 149 12 encompassed encompass VERB cjel-3536 149 13 the the DET cjel-3536 149 14 battlefield battlefield NOUN cjel-3536 149 15 area area NOUN cjel-3536 149 16 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 149 17 and and CCONJ cjel-3536 149 18 introduced introduce VERB cjel-3536 149 19 a a DET cjel-3536 149 20 report report NOUN cjel-3536 149 21 showing show VERB cjel-3536 149 22 that that SCONJ cjel-3536 149 23 surface surface NOUN cjel-3536 149 24 mining mining NOUN cjel-3536 149 25 was be AUX cjel-3536 149 26 moving move VERB cjel-3536 149 27 closer close ADV cjel-3536 149 28 to to ADP cjel-3536 149 29 the the DET cjel-3536 149 30 site.46 site.46 PROPN cjel-3536 149 31 the the DET cjel-3536 149 32 government government NOUN cjel-3536 149 33 did do AUX cjel-3536 149 34 not not PART cjel-3536 149 35 challenge challenge VERB cjel-3536 149 36 the the DET cjel-3536 149 37 plaintiffs plaintiff NOUN cjel-3536 149 38 ’ ' PUNCT cjel-3536 149 39 report.47 report.47 PROPN cjel-3536 149 40 while while SCONJ cjel-3536 149 41 the the DET cjel-3536 149 42 district district NOUN cjel-3536 149 43 court court NOUN cjel-3536 149 44 had have AUX cjel-3536 149 45 concluded conclude VERB cjel-3536 149 46 that that SCONJ cjel-3536 149 47 mining mining NOUN cjel-3536 149 48 on on ADP cjel-3536 149 49 the the DET cjel-3536 149 50 battlefield battlefield NOUN cjel-3536 149 51 in in ADP cjel-3536 149 52 the the DET cjel-3536 149 53 near near ADJ cjel-3536 149 54 future future NOUN cjel-3536 149 55 was be AUX cjel-3536 149 56 speculative speculative ADJ cjel-3536 149 57 because because SCONJ cjel-3536 149 58 the the DET cjel-3536 149 59 permits permit NOUN cjel-3536 149 60 to to PART cjel-3536 149 61 mine mine VERB cjel-3536 149 62 the the DET cjel-3536 149 63 site site NOUN cjel-3536 149 64 had have AUX cjel-3536 149 65 remained remain VERB cjel-3536 149 66 dormant dormant ADJ cjel-3536 149 67 for for ADP cjel-3536 149 68 over over ADP cjel-3536 149 69 ten ten NUM cjel-3536 149 70 years year NOUN cjel-3536 149 71 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 149 72 the the DET cjel-3536 149 73 d.c d.c PROPN cjel-3536 149 74 . . PROPN cjel-3536 149 75 circuit circuit PROPN cjel-3536 149 76 observed observe VERB cjel-3536 149 77 that that SCONJ cjel-3536 149 78 a a DET cjel-3536 149 79 letter letter NOUN cjel-3536 149 80 from from ADP cjel-3536 149 81 the the DET cjel-3536 149 82 coal coal NOUN cjel-3536 149 83 companies company NOUN cjel-3536 149 84 ’ ’ PART cjel-3536 149 85 attorney attorney NOUN cjel-3536 149 86 objecting object VERB cjel-3536 149 87 to to ADP cjel-3536 149 88 the the DET cjel-3536 149 89 listing listing NOUN cjel-3536 149 90 of of ADP cjel-3536 149 91 the the DET cjel-3536 149 92 battlefield battlefield NOUN cjel-3536 149 93 in in ADP cjel-3536 149 94 the the DET cjel-3536 149 95 register register NOUN cjel-3536 149 96 had have AUX cjel-3536 149 97 stated state VERB cjel-3536 149 98 that that SCONJ cjel-3536 149 99 the the DET cjel-3536 149 100 companies company NOUN cjel-3536 149 101 planned plan VERB cjel-3536 149 102 to to PART cjel-3536 149 103 mine mine VERB cjel-3536 149 104 the the DET cjel-3536 149 105 site site NOUN cjel-3536 149 106 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 149 107 and and CCONJ cjel-3536 149 108 concluded conclude VERB cjel-3536 149 109 that that SCONJ cjel-3536 149 110 there there PRON cjel-3536 149 111 was be VERB cjel-3536 149 112 therefore therefore ADV cjel-3536 149 113 a a DET cjel-3536 149 114 “ " PUNCT cjel-3536 149 115 substantial substantial ADJ cjel-3536 149 116 probability probability NOUN cjel-3536 149 117 ” " PUNCT cjel-3536 149 118 of of ADP cjel-3536 149 119 mining mining NOUN cjel-3536 149 120 at at ADP cjel-3536 149 121 that that DET cjel-3536 149 122 location.48 location.48 NOUN cjel-3536 149 123 accordingly accordingly ADV cjel-3536 149 124 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 149 125 the the DET cjel-3536 149 126 d.c d.c PROPN cjel-3536 149 127 . . PROPN cjel-3536 149 128 circuit circuit PROPN cjel-3536 149 129 held hold VERB cjel-3536 149 130 that that SCONJ cjel-3536 149 131 the the DET cjel-3536 149 132 plaintiffs plaintiff NOUN cjel-3536 149 133 had have AUX cjel-3536 149 134 established establish VERB cjel-3536 149 135 “ " PUNCT cjel-3536 149 136 that that SCONJ cjel-3536 149 137 its its PRON cjel-3536 149 138 injury injury NOUN cjel-3536 149 139 is be AUX cjel-3536 149 140 ‘ ' PUNCT cjel-3536 149 141 actual actual ADJ cjel-3536 149 142 or or CCONJ cjel-3536 149 143 imminent imminent ADJ cjel-3536 149 144 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 149 145 not not PART cjel-3536 149 146 conjectural conjectural ADJ cjel-3536 149 147 or or CCONJ cjel-3536 149 148 hypothetical hypothetical ADJ cjel-3536 149 149 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 149 150 ’”49 ’”49 PUNCT cjel-3536 150 1 next next ADV cjel-3536 150 2 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 150 3 the the DET cjel-3536 150 4 d.c d.c PROPN cjel-3536 150 5 . . PROPN cjel-3536 150 6 circuit circuit PROPN cjel-3536 150 7 concluded conclude VERB cjel-3536 150 8 that that SCONJ cjel-3536 150 9 the the DET cjel-3536 150 10 plaintiffs plaintiff NOUN cjel-3536 150 11 met meet VERB cjel-3536 150 12 the the DET cjel-3536 150 13 second second ADJ cjel-3536 150 14 and and CCONJ cjel-3536 150 15 third third ADJ cjel-3536 150 16 parts part NOUN cjel-3536 150 17 of of ADP cjel-3536 150 18 the the DET cjel-3536 150 19 standing standing ADJ cjel-3536 150 20 test test NOUN cjel-3536 150 21 : : PUNCT cjel-3536 150 22 causation causation NOUN cjel-3536 150 23 and and CCONJ cjel-3536 150 24 redressability.50 redressability.50 PROPN cjel-3536 150 25 the the DET cjel-3536 150 26 court court NOUN cjel-3536 150 27 observed observe VERB cjel-3536 150 28 that that SCONJ cjel-3536 150 29 the the DET cjel-3536 150 30 causation causation NOUN cjel-3536 150 31 and and CCONJ cjel-3536 150 32 redressability redressability NOUN cjel-3536 150 33 issues issue NOUN cjel-3536 150 34 overlapped overlap VERB cjel-3536 150 35 because because SCONJ cjel-3536 150 36 both both PRON cjel-3536 150 37 depended depend VERB cjel-3536 150 38 upon upon SCONJ cjel-3536 150 39 whether whether SCONJ cjel-3536 150 40 inclusion inclusion NOUN cjel-3536 150 41 in in ADP cjel-3536 150 42 the the DET cjel-3536 150 43 register register NOUN cjel-3536 150 44 would would AUX cjel-3536 150 45 protect protect VERB cjel-3536 150 46 the the DET cjel-3536 150 47 battlefield battlefield NOUN cjel-3536 150 48 from from ADP cjel-3536 150 49 surface surface NOUN cjel-3536 150 50 mining.51 mining.51 PRON cjel-3536 150 51 the the DET cjel-3536 150 52 district district NOUN cjel-3536 150 53 court court NOUN cjel-3536 150 54 concluded conclude VERB cjel-3536 150 55 that that SCONJ cjel-3536 150 56 the the DET cjel-3536 150 57 plaintiffs plaintiff NOUN cjel-3536 150 58 had have AUX cjel-3536 150 59 failed fail VERB cjel-3536 150 60 to to PART cjel-3536 150 61 establish establish VERB cjel-3536 150 62 standing standing NOUN cjel-3536 150 63 causation causation NOUN cjel-3536 150 64 and and CCONJ cjel-3536 150 65 redressability redressability NOUN cjel-3536 150 66 because because SCONJ cjel-3536 150 67 it it PRON cjel-3536 150 68 thought think VERB cjel-3536 150 69 it it PRON cjel-3536 150 70 probable probable ADJ cjel-3536 150 71 under under ADP cjel-3536 150 72 west west PROPN cjel-3536 150 73 virginia virginia PROPN cjel-3536 150 74 law law PROPN cjel-3536 150 75 that that PRON cjel-3536 150 76 surface surface NOUN cjel-3536 150 77 mining mining NOUN cjel-3536 150 78 would would AUX cjel-3536 150 79 continue continue VERB cjel-3536 150 80 even even ADV cjel-3536 150 81 if if SCONJ cjel-3536 150 82 the the DET cjel-3536 150 83 battlefield battlefield NOUN cjel-3536 150 84 were be AUX cjel-3536 150 85 relisted.52 relisted.52 NOUN cjel-3536 150 86 however however ADV cjel-3536 150 87 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 150 88 the the DET cjel-3536 150 89 d.c d.c PROPN cjel-3536 150 90 . . PROPN cjel-3536 150 91 circuit circuit PROPN cjel-3536 150 92 agreed agree VERB cjel-3536 150 93 with with ADP cjel-3536 150 94 the the DET cjel-3536 150 95 plaintiffs plaintiff NOUN cjel-3536 150 96 ’ ' PUNCT cjel-3536 150 97 argument argument NOUN cjel-3536 150 98 that that SCONJ cjel-3536 150 99 “ " PUNCT cjel-3536 150 100 even even ADV cjel-3536 150 101 if if SCONJ cjel-3536 150 102 surface surface NOUN cjel-3536 150 103 mining mining NOUN cjel-3536 150 104 could could AUX cjel-3536 150 105 continue continue VERB cjel-3536 150 106 upon upon SCONJ cjel-3536 150 107 a a DET cjel-3536 150 108 relisting relisting NOUN cjel-3536 150 109 of of ADP cjel-3536 150 110 the the DET cjel-3536 150 111 battlefield battlefield NOUN cjel-3536 150 112 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 150 113 west west PROPN cjel-3536 150 114 virginia virginia PROPN cjel-3536 150 115 law law PROPN cjel-3536 150 116 affords afford VERB cjel-3536 150 117 additional additional ADJ cjel-3536 150 118 protections protection NOUN cjel-3536 150 119 to to ADP cjel-3536 150 120 places place NOUN cjel-3536 150 121 listed list VERB cjel-3536 150 122 in in ADP cjel-3536 150 123 the the DET cjel-3536 150 124 register register NOUN cjel-3536 150 125 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 150 126 ” " PUNCT cjel-3536 150 127 including include VERB cjel-3536 150 128 a a DET cjel-3536 150 129 duty duty NOUN cjel-3536 150 130 to to PART cjel-3536 150 131 minimize minimize VERB cjel-3536 150 132 any any DET cjel-3536 150 133 impacts impact NOUN cjel-3536 150 134 from from ADP cjel-3536 150 135 surface surface NOUN cjel-3536 150 136 mining mining NOUN cjel-3536 150 137 45 45 NUM cjel-3536 150 138 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 151 1 i i PRON cjel-3536 151 2 d. d. PROPN cjel-3536 151 3 46 46 NUM cjel-3536 151 4 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 152 1 i i PRON cjel-3536 152 2 d. d. PROPN cjel-3536 152 3 47 47 NUM cjel-3536 152 4 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 153 1 i i PRON cjel-3536 153 2 d. d. PROPN cjel-3536 153 3 48 48 NUM cjel-3536 153 4 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 154 1 i i PRON cjel-3536 154 2 d. d. PROPN cjel-3536 154 3 at at ADP cjel-3536 154 4 7–8 7–8 PROPN cjel-3536 154 5 . . PROPN cjel-3536 154 6 49 49 NUM cjel-3536 154 7 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 155 1 i i PRON cjel-3536 155 2 d. d. PROPN cjel-3536 155 3 at at ADP cjel-3536 155 4 8 8 NUM cjel-3536 155 5 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 155 6 quoting quote VERB cjel-3536 155 7 friends friend NOUN cjel-3536 155 8 of of ADP cjel-3536 155 9 the the DET cjel-3536 155 10 earth earth NOUN cjel-3536 155 11 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 155 12 inc inc PROPN cjel-3536 155 13 . . PROPN cjel-3536 156 1 v. v. PROPN cjel-3536 156 2 laidlaw laidlaw PROPN cjel-3536 156 3 envtl envtl PROPN cjel-3536 156 4 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 157 1 servs servs PROPN cjel-3536 157 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 158 1 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 158 2 toc toc PROPN cjel-3536 158 3 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 158 4 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 158 5 inc inc PROPN cjel-3536 158 6 . . PROPN cjel-3536 158 7 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 158 8 528 528 NUM cjel-3536 158 9 u.s u.s PROPN cjel-3536 158 10 . . PROPN cjel-3536 158 11 167 167 NUM cjel-3536 158 12 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 158 13 180 180 NUM cjel-3536 158 14 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 158 15 2000 2000 NUM cjel-3536 158 16 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 158 17 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 158 18 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 159 1 50 50 NUM cjel-3536 159 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 160 1 i i PRON cjel-3536 160 2 d. d. PROPN cjel-3536 160 3 at at ADP cjel-3536 160 4 8–9 8–9 PROPN cjel-3536 160 5 . . PROPN cjel-3536 160 6 51 51 NUM cjel-3536 160 7 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 161 1 i i PRON cjel-3536 161 2 d. d. PROPN cjel-3536 161 3 52 52 NUM cjel-3536 161 4 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 162 1 i i PRON cjel-3536 162 2 d. d. PROPN cjel-3536 162 3 mank mank PROPN cjel-3536 162 4 - - PUNCT cjel-3536 162 5 macro-[final macro-[final PROPN cjel-3536 162 6 6 6 NUM cjel-3536 162 7 - - SYM cjel-3536 162 8 19 19 NUM cjel-3536 162 9 ] ] PUNCT cjel-3536 162 10 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 162 11 do do AUX cjel-3536 162 12 not not PART cjel-3536 162 13 delete delete VERB cjel-3536 162 14 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 163 1 6/22/2015 6/22/2015 NUM cjel-3536 163 2 11:45 11:45 NUM cjel-3536 163 3 pm pm PROPN cjel-3536 163 4 314 314 NUM cjel-3536 163 5 columbia columbia PROPN cjel-3536 163 6 journal journal PROPN cjel-3536 163 7 of of ADP cjel-3536 163 8 environmental environmental ADJ cjel-3536 163 9 law law NOUN cjel-3536 164 1 [ [ X cjel-3536 164 2 vol vol NOUN cjel-3536 164 3 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 165 1 40:2 40:2 NOUN cjel-3536 165 2 on on ADP cjel-3536 165 3 the the DET cjel-3536 165 4 landscape landscape NOUN cjel-3536 165 5 of of ADP cjel-3536 165 6 a a DET cjel-3536 165 7 protected protect VERB cjel-3536 165 8 site.53 site.53 NOUN cjel-3536 165 9 while while SCONJ cjel-3536 165 10 there there PRON cjel-3536 165 11 was be VERB cjel-3536 165 12 some some DET cjel-3536 165 13 dispute dispute NOUN cjel-3536 165 14 about about ADP cjel-3536 165 15 whether whether SCONJ cjel-3536 165 16 the the DET cjel-3536 165 17 duty duty NOUN cjel-3536 165 18 of of ADP cjel-3536 165 19 minimization minimization NOUN cjel-3536 165 20 only only ADV cjel-3536 165 21 applied apply VERB cjel-3536 165 22 to to ADP cjel-3536 165 23 initial initial ADJ cjel-3536 165 24 as as SCONJ cjel-3536 165 25 opposed oppose VERB cjel-3536 165 26 to to ADP cjel-3536 165 27 renewed renew VERB cjel-3536 165 28 permits permit NOUN cjel-3536 165 29 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 165 30 the the DET cjel-3536 165 31 d.c d.c PROPN cjel-3536 165 32 . . PROPN cjel-3536 165 33 circuit circuit PROPN cjel-3536 165 34 “ " PUNCT cjel-3536 165 35 conclude[d conclude[d PROPN cjel-3536 165 36 ] ] PUNCT cjel-3536 165 37 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 165 38 however however ADV cjel-3536 165 39 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 166 1 that that SCONJ cjel-3536 166 2 for for ADP cjel-3536 166 3 purposes purpose NOUN cjel-3536 166 4 of of ADP cjel-3536 166 5 demonstrating demonstrate VERB cjel-3536 166 6 causation causation NOUN cjel-3536 166 7 and and CCONJ cjel-3536 166 8 redressability redressability NOUN cjel-3536 166 9 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 166 10 there there ADV cjel-3536 166 11 [ [ X cjel-3536 166 12 wa]s wa]s PROPN cjel-3536 166 13 an an DET cjel-3536 166 14 adequate adequate ADJ cjel-3536 166 15 possibility possibility NOUN cjel-3536 166 16 that that SCONJ cjel-3536 166 17 the the DET cjel-3536 166 18 regulation regulation NOUN cjel-3536 166 19 would would AUX cjel-3536 166 20 apply apply VERB cjel-3536 166 21 to to ADP cjel-3536 166 22 renewals renewal NOUN cjel-3536 166 23 of of ADP cjel-3536 166 24 those those DET cjel-3536 166 25 permits permit NOUN cjel-3536 166 26 and and CCONJ cjel-3536 166 27 not not PART cjel-3536 166 28 only only ADV cjel-3536 166 29 to to ADP cjel-3536 166 30 the the DET cjel-3536 166 31 initial initial ADJ cjel-3536 166 32 applications application NOUN cjel-3536 166 33 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 166 34 ”54 ”54 VERB cjel-3536 166 35 because because SCONJ cjel-3536 166 36 the the DET cjel-3536 166 37 plaintiffs plaintiff NOUN cjel-3536 166 38 raised raise VERB cjel-3536 166 39 a a DET cjel-3536 166 40 “ " PUNCT cjel-3536 166 41 non non ADJ cjel-3536 166 42 - - ADJ cjel-3536 166 43 frivolous frivolous ADJ cjel-3536 166 44 ” " PUNCT cjel-3536 166 45 interpretation interpretation NOUN cjel-3536 166 46 of of ADP cjel-3536 166 47 west west PROPN cjel-3536 166 48 virginia virginia PROPN cjel-3536 166 49 law law PROPN cjel-3536 166 50 suggesting suggest VERB cjel-3536 166 51 that that SCONJ cjel-3536 166 52 mining mining NOUN cjel-3536 166 53 companies company NOUN cjel-3536 166 54 would would AUX cjel-3536 166 55 have have VERB cjel-3536 166 56 a a DET cjel-3536 166 57 duty duty NOUN cjel-3536 166 58 to to PART cjel-3536 166 59 minimize minimize VERB cjel-3536 166 60 harm harm NOUN cjel-3536 166 61 at at ADP cjel-3536 166 62 the the DET cjel-3536 166 63 battlefield battlefield NOUN cjel-3536 166 64 if if SCONJ cjel-3536 166 65 it it PRON cjel-3536 166 66 was be AUX cjel-3536 166 67 listed list VERB cjel-3536 166 68 on on ADP cjel-3536 166 69 the the DET cjel-3536 166 70 register register NOUN cjel-3536 166 71 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 166 72 the the DET cjel-3536 166 73 d.c d.c PROPN cjel-3536 166 74 . . PROPN cjel-3536 166 75 circuit circuit PROPN cjel-3536 166 76 determined determine VERB cjel-3536 166 77 that that SCONJ cjel-3536 166 78 their their PRON cjel-3536 166 79 argument argument NOUN cjel-3536 166 80 was be AUX cjel-3536 166 81 sufficient sufficient ADJ cjel-3536 166 82 “ " PUNCT cjel-3536 166 83 to to PART cjel-3536 166 84 establish establish VERB cjel-3536 166 85 causation causation NOUN cjel-3536 166 86 and and CCONJ cjel-3536 166 87 redressability redressability NOUN cjel-3536 166 88 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 167 1 ”55 ”55 PROPN cjel-3536 167 2 accordingly accordingly ADV cjel-3536 167 3 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 167 4 the the DET cjel-3536 167 5 d.c d.c PROPN cjel-3536 167 6 . . PROPN cjel-3536 167 7 circuit circuit PROPN cjel-3536 167 8 held hold VERB cjel-3536 167 9 that that SCONJ cjel-3536 167 10 the the DET cjel-3536 167 11 plaintiffs plaintiff NOUN cjel-3536 167 12 had have AUX cjel-3536 167 13 demonstrated demonstrate VERB cjel-3536 167 14 article article PROPN cjel-3536 167 15 iii iii NUM cjel-3536 167 16 standing standing NOUN cjel-3536 167 17 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 167 18 and and CCONJ cjel-3536 167 19 reversed reverse VERB cjel-3536 167 20 the the DET cjel-3536 167 21 judgment judgment NOUN cjel-3536 167 22 of of ADP cjel-3536 167 23 the the DET cjel-3536 167 24 district district NOUN cjel-3536 167 25 court court NOUN cjel-3536 167 26 and and CCONJ cjel-3536 167 27 remanded remand VERB cjel-3536 167 28 the the DET cjel-3536 167 29 case case NOUN cjel-3536 167 30 for for ADP cjel-3536 167 31 further further ADJ cjel-3536 167 32 proceedings.56 proceedings.56 PROPN cjel-3536 167 33 c. c. PROPN cjel-3536 167 34 judge judge PROPN cjel-3536 167 35 sentelle sentelle NOUN cjel-3536 167 36 ’s ’s PART cjel-3536 167 37 dissenting dissent VERB cjel-3536 167 38 opinion opinion NOUN cjel-3536 167 39 in in ADP cjel-3536 167 40 his his PRON cjel-3536 167 41 dissenting dissent VERB cjel-3536 167 42 opinion opinion NOUN cjel-3536 167 43 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 167 44 judge judge NOUN cjel-3536 167 45 sentelle sentelle NOUN cjel-3536 167 46 argued argue VERB cjel-3536 167 47 that that SCONJ cjel-3536 167 48 plaintiffs plaintiff NOUN cjel-3536 167 49 must must AUX cjel-3536 167 50 have have VERB cjel-3536 167 51 a a DET cjel-3536 167 52 legal legal ADJ cjel-3536 167 53 interest interest NOUN cjel-3536 167 54 to to PART cjel-3536 167 55 enter enter VERB cjel-3536 167 56 a a DET cjel-3536 167 57 parcel parcel NOUN cjel-3536 167 58 of of ADP cjel-3536 167 59 property property NOUN cjel-3536 167 60 to to PART cjel-3536 167 61 establish establish VERB cjel-3536 167 62 standing.57 standing.57 PROPN cjel-3536 167 63 while while SCONJ cjel-3536 167 64 noting note VERB cjel-3536 167 65 that that SCONJ cjel-3536 167 66 the the DET cjel-3536 167 67 majority majority NOUN cjel-3536 167 68 opinion opinion NOUN cjel-3536 167 69 was be AUX cjel-3536 167 70 correct correct ADJ cjel-3536 167 71 that that SCONJ cjel-3536 167 72 a a DET cjel-3536 167 73 mere mere ADJ cjel-3536 167 74 aesthetic aesthetic ADJ cjel-3536 167 75 injury injury NOUN cjel-3536 167 76 may may AUX cjel-3536 167 77 suffice suffice VERB cjel-3536 167 78 to to PART cjel-3536 167 79 establish establish VERB cjel-3536 167 80 a a DET cjel-3536 167 81 concrete concrete ADJ cjel-3536 167 82 and and CCONJ cjel-3536 167 83 particularized particularized ADJ cjel-3536 167 84 injury injury NOUN cjel-3536 167 85 for for ADP cjel-3536 167 86 article article PROPN cjel-3536 167 87 iii iii NUM cjel-3536 167 88 standing standing NOUN cjel-3536 167 89 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 167 90 he he PRON cjel-3536 167 91 contended contend VERB cjel-3536 167 92 that that SCONJ cjel-3536 167 93 “ " PUNCT cjel-3536 167 94 this this PRON cjel-3536 167 95 does do AUX cjel-3536 167 96 not not PART cjel-3536 167 97 establish establish VERB cjel-3536 167 98 that that SCONJ cjel-3536 167 99 the the DET cjel-3536 167 100 legally legally ADV cjel-3536 167 101 protected protect VERB cjel-3536 167 102 aesthetic aesthetic ADJ cjel-3536 167 103 interest interest NOUN cjel-3536 167 104 of of ADP cjel-3536 167 105 would would AUX cjel-3536 167 106 - - PUNCT cjel-3536 167 107 be be AUX cjel-3536 167 108 plaintiffs plaintiff NOUN cjel-3536 167 109 encompasses encompass VERB cjel-3536 167 110 the the DET cjel-3536 167 111 legally legally ADV cjel-3536 167 112 protected protect VERB cjel-3536 167 113 right right ADV cjel-3536 167 114 to to PART cjel-3536 167 115 peer peer VERB cjel-3536 167 116 into into ADP cjel-3536 167 117 the the DET cjel-3536 167 118 property property NOUN cjel-3536 167 119 of of ADP cjel-3536 167 120 others other NOUN cjel-3536 167 121 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 168 1 ”58 ”58 PROPN cjel-3536 168 2 additionally additionally ADV cjel-3536 168 3 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 168 4 although although SCONJ cjel-3536 168 5 the the DET cjel-3536 168 6 majority majority NOUN cjel-3536 168 7 demonstrated demonstrate VERB cjel-3536 168 8 from from ADP cjel-3536 168 9 precedent precedent NOUN cjel-3536 168 10 that that SCONJ cjel-3536 168 11 a a DET cjel-3536 168 12 defendant defendant NOUN cjel-3536 168 13 ’s ’s PART cjel-3536 168 14 injury injury NOUN cjel-3536 168 15 to to ADP cjel-3536 168 16 flora flora NOUN cjel-3536 168 17 or or CCONJ cjel-3536 168 18 fauna fauna NOUN cjel-3536 168 19 that that PRON cjel-3536 168 20 harms harm VERB cjel-3536 168 21 a a DET cjel-3536 168 22 plaintiff plaintiff NOUN cjel-3536 168 23 ’s ’s PART cjel-3536 168 24 aesthetic aesthetic ADJ cjel-3536 168 25 interests interest NOUN cjel-3536 168 26 may may AUX cjel-3536 168 27 constitute constitute VERB cjel-3536 168 28 a a DET cjel-3536 168 29 standing standing ADJ cjel-3536 168 30 injury injury NOUN cjel-3536 168 31 in in ADP cjel-3536 168 32 some some DET cjel-3536 168 33 circumstances circumstance NOUN cjel-3536 168 34 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 168 35 judge judge NOUN cjel-3536 168 36 sentelle sentelle NOUN cjel-3536 168 37 reasoned reason VERB cjel-3536 168 38 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 168 39 “ " PUNCT cjel-3536 168 40 nonetheless nonetheless ADV cjel-3536 168 41 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 168 42 none none NOUN cjel-3536 168 43 of of ADP cjel-3536 168 44 these these DET cjel-3536 168 45 cases case NOUN cjel-3536 168 46 would would AUX cjel-3536 168 47 lead lead VERB cjel-3536 168 48 me i PRON cjel-3536 168 49 to to PART cjel-3536 168 50 suppose suppose VERB cjel-3536 168 51 that that SCONJ cjel-3536 168 52 my my PRON cjel-3536 168 53 neighbor neighbor NOUN cjel-3536 168 54 has have VERB cjel-3536 168 55 a a DET cjel-3536 168 56 legally legally ADV cjel-3536 168 57 protected protect VERB cjel-3536 168 58 right right ADV cjel-3536 168 59 that that SCONJ cjel-3536 168 60 i i PRON cjel-3536 168 61 have have AUX cjel-3536 168 62 invaded invade VERB cjel-3536 168 63 when when SCONJ cjel-3536 168 64 i i PRON cjel-3536 168 65 trim trim VERB cjel-3536 168 66 the the DET cjel-3536 168 67 grass grass NOUN cjel-3536 168 68 and and CCONJ cjel-3536 168 69 behead behead VERB cjel-3536 168 70 the the DET cjel-3536 168 71 53 53 NUM cjel-3536 168 72 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 169 1 i i PRON cjel-3536 169 2 d. d. PROPN cjel-3536 169 3 54 54 NUM cjel-3536 169 4 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 170 1 i i PRON cjel-3536 170 2 d. d. PROPN cjel-3536 170 3 55 55 NUM cjel-3536 170 4 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 171 1 i i PRON cjel-3536 171 2 d. d. PROPN cjel-3536 171 3 at at ADP cjel-3536 171 4 8–9 8–9 PROPN cjel-3536 171 5 . . PROPN cjel-3536 171 6 56 56 NUM cjel-3536 171 7 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 172 1 i i PRON cjel-3536 172 2 d. d. PROPN cjel-3536 172 3 at at ADP cjel-3536 172 4 3 3 NUM cjel-3536 172 5 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 172 6 5–9 5–9 NUM cjel-3536 172 7 . . NOUN cjel-3536 172 8 57 57 NUM cjel-3536 172 9 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 173 1 i i PRON cjel-3536 173 2 d. d. PROPN cjel-3536 173 3 at at ADP cjel-3536 173 4 9–11 9–11 PROPN cjel-3536 173 5 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 173 6 sentelle sentelle NOUN cjel-3536 173 7 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 173 8 j. j. PROPN cjel-3536 173 9 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 173 10 dissenting dissent VERB cjel-3536 173 11 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 173 12 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 174 1 58 58 NUM cjel-3536 174 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 175 1 i i PRON cjel-3536 175 2 d. d. PROPN cjel-3536 175 3 at at ADP cjel-3536 175 4 10 10 NUM cjel-3536 175 5 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 175 6 mank mank PROPN cjel-3536 175 7 - - PUNCT cjel-3536 175 8 macro-[final macro-[final PROPN cjel-3536 175 9 6 6 NUM cjel-3536 175 10 - - SYM cjel-3536 175 11 19 19 NUM cjel-3536 175 12 ] ] PUNCT cjel-3536 175 13 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 175 14 do do AUX cjel-3536 175 15 not not PART cjel-3536 175 16 delete delete VERB cjel-3536 175 17 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 176 1 6/22/2015 6/22/2015 NUM cjel-3536 176 2 11:45 11:45 NUM cjel-3536 176 3 pm pm NOUN cjel-3536 176 4 2015 2015 NUM cjel-3536 176 5 ] ] PUNCT cjel-3536 176 6 standing stand VERB cjel-3536 176 7 to to PART cjel-3536 176 8 view view VERB cjel-3536 176 9 other other ADJ cjel-3536 176 10 people people NOUN cjel-3536 176 11 ’s ’s PART cjel-3536 176 12 land land NOUN cjel-3536 176 13 315 315 NUM cjel-3536 176 14 clovers clover NOUN cjel-3536 176 15 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 176 16 which which PRON cjel-3536 176 17 he he PRON cjel-3536 176 18 enjoys enjoy VERB cjel-3536 176 19 viewing view VERB cjel-3536 176 20 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 177 1 ”59 ”59 ADJ cjel-3536 177 2 because because SCONJ cjel-3536 177 3 the the DET cjel-3536 177 4 plaintiffs plaintiff NOUN cjel-3536 177 5 lacked lack VERB cjel-3536 177 6 any any DET cjel-3536 177 7 legal legal ADJ cjel-3536 177 8 entitlement entitlement NOUN cjel-3536 177 9 to to PART cjel-3536 177 10 enter enter VERB cjel-3536 177 11 the the DET cjel-3536 177 12 battlefield battlefield NOUN cjel-3536 177 13 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 177 14 he he PRON cjel-3536 177 15 maintained maintain VERB cjel-3536 177 16 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 177 17 “ " PUNCT cjel-3536 177 18 neither neither CCONJ cjel-3536 177 19 have have AUX cjel-3536 177 20 they they PRON cjel-3536 177 21 put put VERB cjel-3536 177 22 forth forth ADP cjel-3536 177 23 any any DET cjel-3536 177 24 evidence evidence NOUN cjel-3536 177 25 of of ADP cjel-3536 177 26 any any DET cjel-3536 177 27 legal legal ADJ cjel-3536 177 28 entitlement entitlement NOUN cjel-3536 177 29 to to PART cjel-3536 177 30 view view VERB cjel-3536 177 31 that that DET cjel-3536 177 32 property property NOUN cjel-3536 177 33 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 178 1 ”60 ”60 PROPN cjel-3536 179 1 since since SCONJ cjel-3536 179 2 the the DET cjel-3536 179 3 supreme supreme PROPN cjel-3536 179 4 court court PROPN cjel-3536 179 5 in in ADP cjel-3536 179 6 its its PRON cjel-3536 179 7 1992 1992 NUM cjel-3536 179 8 decision decision NOUN cjel-3536 179 9 lujan lujan NOUN cjel-3536 179 10 v. v. ADP cjel-3536 179 11 defenders defender NOUN cjel-3536 179 12 of of ADP cjel-3536 179 13 wildlife wildlife NOUN cjel-3536 179 14 required require VERB cjel-3536 179 15 “ " PUNCT cjel-3536 179 16 parties party NOUN cjel-3536 179 17 invoking invoke VERB cjel-3536 179 18 federal federal ADJ cjel-3536 179 19 jurisdiction jurisdiction NOUN cjel-3536 179 20 [ [ X cjel-3536 179 21 to to PART cjel-3536 179 22 ] ] PUNCT cjel-3536 179 23 bear bear VERB cjel-3536 179 24 the the DET cjel-3536 179 25 burden burden NOUN cjel-3536 179 26 of of ADP cjel-3536 179 27 establishing establish VERB cjel-3536 179 28 an an DET cjel-3536 179 29 “ " PUNCT cjel-3536 179 30 invasion invasion NOUN cjel-3536 179 31 of of ADP cjel-3536 179 32 a a DET cjel-3536 179 33 legally legally ADV cjel-3536 179 34 protected protect VERB cjel-3536 179 35 interest interest NOUN cjel-3536 179 36 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 179 37 ” " PUNCT cjel-3536 179 38 judge judge NOUN cjel-3536 179 39 sentelle sentelle NOUN cjel-3536 179 40 reasoned reason VERB cjel-3536 179 41 that that SCONJ cjel-3536 179 42 the the DET cjel-3536 179 43 plaintiffs plaintiff NOUN cjel-3536 179 44 had have AUX cjel-3536 179 45 failed fail VERB cjel-3536 179 46 to to PART cjel-3536 179 47 establish establish VERB cjel-3536 179 48 a a DET cjel-3536 179 49 standing standing NOUN cjel-3536 179 50 injury injury NOUN cjel-3536 179 51 because because SCONJ cjel-3536 179 52 they they PRON cjel-3536 179 53 “ " PUNCT cjel-3536 179 54 offered offer VERB cjel-3536 179 55 nothing nothing PRON cjel-3536 179 56 to to PART cjel-3536 179 57 establish establish VERB cjel-3536 179 58 the the DET cjel-3536 179 59 invasion invasion NOUN cjel-3536 179 60 of of ADP cjel-3536 179 61 any any DET cjel-3536 179 62 such such ADJ cjel-3536 179 63 interest interest NOUN cjel-3536 179 64 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 180 1 ”61 ”61 NOUN cjel-3536 180 2 accordingly accordingly ADV cjel-3536 180 3 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 180 4 he he PRON cjel-3536 180 5 concluded conclude VERB cjel-3536 180 6 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 180 7 “ " PUNCT cjel-3536 180 8 the the DET cjel-3536 180 9 dismissal dismissal NOUN cjel-3536 180 10 of of ADP cjel-3536 180 11 this this DET cjel-3536 180 12 action action NOUN cjel-3536 180 13 should should AUX cjel-3536 180 14 be be AUX cjel-3536 180 15 affirmed affirm VERB cjel-3536 180 16 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 181 1 ”62 ”62 PROPN cjel-3536 181 2 iv iv PROPN cjel-3536 181 3 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 182 1 other other ADJ cjel-3536 182 2 decisions decision NOUN cjel-3536 182 3 finding find VERB cjel-3536 182 4 standing stand VERB cjel-3536 182 5 to to PART cjel-3536 182 6 sue sue VERB cjel-3536 182 7 to to PART cjel-3536 182 8 protect protect VERB cjel-3536 182 9 a a DET cjel-3536 182 10 right right NOUN cjel-3536 182 11 to to PART cjel-3536 182 12 view view VERB cjel-3536 182 13 other other ADJ cjel-3536 182 14 people people NOUN cjel-3536 182 15 ’s ’s PART cjel-3536 182 16 property property NOUN cjel-3536 182 17 in in ADP cjel-3536 182 18 its its PRON cjel-3536 182 19 2001 2001 NUM cjel-3536 182 20 decision decision NOUN cjel-3536 182 21 cantrell cantrell PROPN cjel-3536 182 22 v. v. ADP cjel-3536 182 23 city city NOUN cjel-3536 182 24 of of ADP cjel-3536 182 25 long long ADJ cjel-3536 182 26 beach beach NOUN cjel-3536 182 27 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 182 28 the the DET cjel-3536 182 29 ninth ninth ADJ cjel-3536 182 30 circuit circuit NOUN cjel-3536 182 31 held hold VERB cjel-3536 182 32 that that SCONJ cjel-3536 182 33 birdwatchers birdwatcher NOUN cjel-3536 182 34 who who PRON cjel-3536 182 35 had have VERB cjel-3536 182 36 no no DET cjel-3536 182 37 right right NOUN cjel-3536 182 38 to to PART cjel-3536 182 39 enter enter VERB cjel-3536 182 40 a a DET cjel-3536 182 41 property property NOUN cjel-3536 182 42 owned own VERB cjel-3536 182 43 by by ADP cjel-3536 182 44 the the DET cjel-3536 182 45 u.s u.s PROPN cjel-3536 182 46 . . PROPN cjel-3536 182 47 navy navy PROPN cjel-3536 182 48 had have AUX cjel-3536 182 49 standing stand VERB cjel-3536 182 50 to to PART cjel-3536 182 51 sue sue VERB cjel-3536 182 52 to to PART cjel-3536 182 53 protect protect VERB cjel-3536 182 54 their their PRON cjel-3536 182 55 right right NOUN cjel-3536 182 56 to to PART cjel-3536 182 57 view view VERB cjel-3536 182 58 birds bird NOUN cjel-3536 182 59 on on ADP cjel-3536 182 60 that that DET cjel-3536 182 61 property.63 property.63 NOUN cjel-3536 182 62 similar similar ADJ cjel-3536 182 63 to to ADP cjel-3536 182 64 the the DET cjel-3536 182 65 views view NOUN cjel-3536 182 66 of of ADP cjel-3536 182 67 judge judge NOUN cjel-3536 182 68 sentelle sentelle NOUN cjel-3536 182 69 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 182 70 the the DET cjel-3536 182 71 district district NOUN cjel-3536 182 72 court court NOUN cjel-3536 182 73 decision decision NOUN cjel-3536 182 74 in in ADP cjel-3536 182 75 cantrell cantrell PROPN cjel-3536 182 76 had have AUX cjel-3536 182 77 denied deny VERB cjel-3536 182 78 standing stand VERB cjel-3536 182 79 because because SCONJ cjel-3536 182 80 the the DET cjel-3536 182 81 court court NOUN cjel-3536 182 82 reasoned reason VERB cjel-3536 182 83 that that SCONJ cjel-3536 182 84 the the DET cjel-3536 182 85 plaintiffs plaintiff NOUN cjel-3536 182 86 had have VERB cjel-3536 182 87 no no DET cjel-3536 182 88 legally legally ADV cjel-3536 182 89 protected protect VERB cjel-3536 182 90 interest interest NOUN cjel-3536 182 91 in in ADP cjel-3536 182 92 the the DET cjel-3536 182 93 naval naval ADJ cjel-3536 182 94 station station NOUN cjel-3536 182 95 property property NOUN cjel-3536 182 96 and and CCONJ cjel-3536 182 97 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 182 98 therefore therefore ADV cjel-3536 182 99 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 182 100 no no ADV cjel-3536 182 101 right right NOUN cjel-3536 182 102 to to PART cjel-3536 182 103 view view VERB cjel-3536 182 104 birds bird NOUN cjel-3536 182 105 on on ADP cjel-3536 182 106 the the DET cjel-3536 182 107 property.64 property.64 NOUN cjel-3536 182 108 however however ADV cjel-3536 182 109 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 182 110 the the DET cjel-3536 182 111 ninth ninth ADJ cjel-3536 182 112 circuit circuit NOUN cjel-3536 182 113 disagreed disagree VERB cjel-3536 182 114 with with ADP cjel-3536 182 115 the the DET cjel-3536 182 116 district district NOUN cjel-3536 182 117 court court NOUN cjel-3536 182 118 and and CCONJ cjel-3536 182 119 concluded conclude VERB cjel-3536 182 120 : : PUNCT cjel-3536 183 1 [ [ X cjel-3536 183 2 w]e w]e NOUN cjel-3536 183 3 have have AUX cjel-3536 183 4 never never ADV cjel-3536 183 5 required require VERB cjel-3536 183 6 a a DET cjel-3536 183 7 plaintiff plaintiff NOUN cjel-3536 183 8 to to PART cjel-3536 183 9 show show VERB cjel-3536 183 10 that that SCONJ cjel-3536 183 11 he he PRON cjel-3536 183 12 has have VERB cjel-3536 183 13 a a DET cjel-3536 183 14 right right NOUN cjel-3536 183 15 of of ADP cjel-3536 183 16 access access NOUN cjel-3536 183 17 to to ADP cjel-3536 183 18 the the DET cjel-3536 183 19 site site NOUN cjel-3536 183 20 on on ADP cjel-3536 183 21 which which PRON cjel-3536 183 22 the the DET cjel-3536 183 23 challenged challenge VERB cjel-3536 183 24 activity activity NOUN cjel-3536 183 25 is be AUX cjel-3536 183 26 occurring occur VERB cjel-3536 183 27 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 183 28 or or CCONJ cjel-3536 183 29 that that SCONJ cjel-3536 183 30 he he PRON cjel-3536 183 31 has have VERB cjel-3536 183 32 an an DET cjel-3536 183 33 absolute absolute ADJ cjel-3536 183 34 right right NOUN cjel-3536 183 35 to to PART cjel-3536 183 36 enjoy enjoy VERB cjel-3536 183 37 the the DET cjel-3536 183 38 aesthetic aesthetic ADJ cjel-3536 183 39 or or CCONJ cjel-3536 183 40 recreational recreational ADJ cjel-3536 183 41 activities activity NOUN cjel-3536 183 42 that that PRON cjel-3536 183 43 form form VERB cjel-3536 183 44 the the DET cjel-3536 183 45 basis basis NOUN cjel-3536 183 46 of of ADP cjel-3536 183 47 his his PRON cjel-3536 183 48 concrete concrete ADJ cjel-3536 183 49 interest interest NOUN cjel-3536 183 50 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 184 1 if if SCONJ cjel-3536 184 2 an an DET cjel-3536 184 3 area area NOUN cjel-3536 184 4 can can AUX cjel-3536 184 5 be be AUX cjel-3536 184 6 observed observe VERB cjel-3536 184 7 and and CCONJ cjel-3536 184 8 enjoyed enjoy VERB cjel-3536 184 9 from from ADP cjel-3536 184 10 adjacent adjacent ADJ cjel-3536 184 11 land land NOUN cjel-3536 184 12 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 184 13 59 59 NUM cjel-3536 184 14 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 185 1 i i PRON cjel-3536 185 2 d. d. PROPN cjel-3536 185 3 60 60 NUM cjel-3536 185 4 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 186 1 i i PRON cjel-3536 186 2 d. d. PROPN cjel-3536 186 3 61 61 NUM cjel-3536 186 4 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 187 1 i i PRON cjel-3536 187 2 d. d. PROPN cjel-3536 187 3 at at ADP cjel-3536 187 4 10–11 10–11 PROPN cjel-3536 187 5 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 187 6 quoting quote VERB cjel-3536 187 7 lujan lujan PROPN cjel-3536 187 8 v. v. ADP cjel-3536 187 9 defenders defender NOUN cjel-3536 187 10 of of ADP cjel-3536 187 11 wildlife wildlife NOUN cjel-3536 187 12 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 187 13 504 504 NUM cjel-3536 187 14 u.s u.s PROPN cjel-3536 187 15 . . PROPN cjel-3536 187 16 555 555 NUM cjel-3536 187 17 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 187 18 560 560 NUM cjel-3536 187 19 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 187 20 1992 1992 NUM cjel-3536 187 21 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 187 22 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 187 23 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 188 1 in in ADP cjel-3536 188 2 a a DET cjel-3536 188 3 footnote footnote NOUN cjel-3536 188 4 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 188 5 judge judge NOUN cjel-3536 188 6 sentelle sentelle NOUN cjel-3536 188 7 argued argue VERB cjel-3536 188 8 that that SCONJ cjel-3536 188 9 a a DET cjel-3536 188 10 plaintiff plaintiff NOUN cjel-3536 188 11 must must AUX cjel-3536 188 12 have have VERB cjel-3536 188 13 a a DET cjel-3536 188 14 “ " PUNCT cjel-3536 188 15 legally legally ADV cjel-3536 188 16 protected protect VERB cjel-3536 188 17 interest interest NOUN cjel-3536 188 18 ” " PUNCT cjel-3536 188 19 to to PART cjel-3536 188 20 have have AUX cjel-3536 188 21 standing stand VERB cjel-3536 188 22 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 188 23 and and CCONJ cjel-3536 188 24 that that SCONJ cjel-3536 188 25 the the DET cjel-3536 188 26 majority majority NOUN cjel-3536 188 27 ’s ’s PART cjel-3536 188 28 reliance reliance NOUN cjel-3536 188 29 on on ADP cjel-3536 188 30 cases case NOUN cjel-3536 188 31 using use VERB cjel-3536 188 32 the the DET cjel-3536 188 33 term term NOUN cjel-3536 188 34 “ " PUNCT cjel-3536 188 35 cognizable cognizable ADJ cjel-3536 188 36 interests interest NOUN cjel-3536 188 37 ” " PUNCT cjel-3536 188 38 did do AUX cjel-3536 188 39 not not PART cjel-3536 188 40 change change VERB cjel-3536 188 41 the the DET cjel-3536 188 42 fundamental fundamental ADJ cjel-3536 188 43 requirement requirement NOUN cjel-3536 188 44 of of ADP cjel-3536 188 45 a a DET cjel-3536 188 46 legal legal ADJ cjel-3536 188 47 interest interest NOUN cjel-3536 188 48 for for ADP cjel-3536 188 49 standing stand VERB cjel-3536 188 50 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 189 1 i i PRON cjel-3536 189 2 d. d. PROPN cjel-3536 189 3 at at ADP cjel-3536 189 4 10 10 NUM cjel-3536 189 5 n.1 n.1 NOUN cjel-3536 189 6 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 190 1 62 62 NUM cjel-3536 190 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 191 1 i i PRON cjel-3536 191 2 d. d. PROPN cjel-3536 191 3 at at ADP cjel-3536 191 4 11 11 NUM cjel-3536 191 5 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 191 6 63 63 NUM cjel-3536 191 7 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 192 1 241 241 NUM cjel-3536 192 2 f.3d f.3d NUM cjel-3536 192 3 674 674 NUM cjel-3536 192 4 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 192 5 680–82 680–82 NUM cjel-3536 192 6 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 192 7 9th 9th ADJ cjel-3536 192 8 cir cir NOUN cjel-3536 192 9 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 192 10 2001 2001 NUM cjel-3536 192 11 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 192 12 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 193 1 64 64 NUM cjel-3536 193 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 194 1 i i PRON cjel-3536 194 2 d. d. PROPN cjel-3536 194 3 at at ADP cjel-3536 194 4 681 681 NUM cjel-3536 194 5 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 195 1 mank mank PROPN cjel-3536 195 2 - - PUNCT cjel-3536 195 3 macro-[final macro-[final PROPN cjel-3536 195 4 6 6 NUM cjel-3536 195 5 - - SYM cjel-3536 195 6 19 19 NUM cjel-3536 195 7 ] ] PUNCT cjel-3536 195 8 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 195 9 do do AUX cjel-3536 195 10 not not PART cjel-3536 195 11 delete delete VERB cjel-3536 195 12 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 196 1 6/22/2015 6/22/2015 NUM cjel-3536 196 2 11:45 11:45 NUM cjel-3536 196 3 pm pm NOUN cjel-3536 196 4 316 316 NUM cjel-3536 196 5 columbia columbia PROPN cjel-3536 196 6 journal journal PROPN cjel-3536 196 7 of of ADP cjel-3536 196 8 environmental environmental ADJ cjel-3536 196 9 law law NOUN cjel-3536 197 1 [ [ X cjel-3536 197 2 vol vol NOUN cjel-3536 197 3 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 198 1 40:2 40:2 NOUN cjel-3536 198 2 plaintiffs plaintiff NOUN cjel-3536 198 3 need need AUX cjel-3536 198 4 not not PART cjel-3536 198 5 physically physically ADV cjel-3536 198 6 enter enter VERB cjel-3536 198 7 the the DET cjel-3536 198 8 affected affected ADJ cjel-3536 198 9 area area NOUN cjel-3536 198 10 to to PART cjel-3536 198 11 establish establish VERB cjel-3536 198 12 an an DET cjel-3536 198 13 injury injury NOUN cjel-3536 198 14 in in ADP cjel-3536 198 15 fact.65 fact.65 PROPN cjel-3536 198 16 the the DET cjel-3536 198 17 ninth ninth ADJ cjel-3536 198 18 circuit circuit NOUN cjel-3536 198 19 based base VERB cjel-3536 198 20 this this DET cjel-3536 198 21 conclusion conclusion NOUN cjel-3536 198 22 on on ADP cjel-3536 198 23 its its PRON cjel-3536 198 24 interpretation interpretation NOUN cjel-3536 198 25 of of ADP cjel-3536 198 26 the the DET cjel-3536 198 27 supreme supreme PROPN cjel-3536 198 28 court court PROPN cjel-3536 198 29 ’s ’s PART cjel-3536 198 30 decision decision NOUN cjel-3536 198 31 in in ADP cjel-3536 198 32 friends friend NOUN cjel-3536 198 33 of of ADP cjel-3536 198 34 the the DET cjel-3536 198 35 earth earth NOUN cjel-3536 198 36 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 198 37 inc inc PROPN cjel-3536 198 38 . . PROPN cjel-3536 199 1 v. v. PROPN cjel-3536 199 2 laidlaw laidlaw PROPN cjel-3536 199 3 environmental environmental PROPN cjel-3536 199 4 services service NOUN cjel-3536 199 5 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 199 6 toc toc PROPN cjel-3536 199 7 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 199 8 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 199 9 inc.66 inc.66 ADP cjel-3536 199 10 the the DET cjel-3536 199 11 ninth ninth ADJ cjel-3536 199 12 circuit circuit NOUN cjel-3536 199 13 explained explain VERB cjel-3536 199 14 : : PUNCT cjel-3536 199 15 for for ADP cjel-3536 199 16 example example NOUN cjel-3536 199 17 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 199 18 the the DET cjel-3536 199 19 plaintiffs plaintiff NOUN cjel-3536 199 20 in in ADP cjel-3536 199 21 laidlaw laidlaw PROPN cjel-3536 199 22 had have AUX cjel-3536 199 23 used use VERB cjel-3536 199 24 specific specific ADJ cjel-3536 199 25 areas area NOUN cjel-3536 199 26 in in ADP cjel-3536 199 27 and and CCONJ cjel-3536 199 28 around around ADP cjel-3536 199 29 a a DET cjel-3536 199 30 river river NOUN cjel-3536 199 31 to to PART cjel-3536 199 32 picnic picnic NOUN cjel-3536 199 33 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 199 34 birdwatch birdwatch NOUN cjel-3536 199 35 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 199 36 walk walk VERB cjel-3536 199 37 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 199 38 and and CCONJ cjel-3536 199 39 swim swim VERB cjel-3536 199 40 but but CCONJ cjel-3536 199 41 alleged allege VERB cjel-3536 199 42 that that SCONJ cjel-3536 199 43 they they PRON cjel-3536 199 44 would would AUX cjel-3536 199 45 no no ADV cjel-3536 199 46 longer long ADV cjel-3536 199 47 be be AUX cjel-3536 199 48 able able ADJ cjel-3536 199 49 to to PART cjel-3536 199 50 do do VERB cjel-3536 199 51 so so ADV cjel-3536 199 52 because because SCONJ cjel-3536 199 53 the the DET cjel-3536 199 54 river river NOUN cjel-3536 199 55 had have AUX cjel-3536 199 56 been be AUX cjel-3536 199 57 polluted pollute VERB cjel-3536 199 58 by by ADP cjel-3536 199 59 the the DET cjel-3536 199 60 discharges discharge NOUN cjel-3536 199 61 from from ADP cjel-3536 199 62 the the DET cjel-3536 199 63 defendant defendant NOUN cjel-3536 199 64 ’s ’s PART cjel-3536 199 65 facility facility NOUN cjel-3536 199 66 upstream upstream NOUN cjel-3536 199 67 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 199 68 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 199 69 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 200 1 .in .in PUNCT cjel-3536 200 2 finding find VERB cjel-3536 200 3 that that SCONJ cjel-3536 200 4 the the DET cjel-3536 200 5 plaintiffs plaintiff NOUN cjel-3536 200 6 had have AUX cjel-3536 200 7 established establish VERB cjel-3536 200 8 an an DET cjel-3536 200 9 injury injury NOUN cjel-3536 200 10 in in ADP cjel-3536 200 11 fact fact NOUN cjel-3536 200 12 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 200 13 the the DET cjel-3536 200 14 laidlaw laidlaw PROPN cjel-3536 200 15 court court NOUN cjel-3536 200 16 did do AUX cjel-3536 200 17 not not PART cjel-3536 200 18 state state VERB cjel-3536 200 19 that that DET cjel-3536 200 20 actual actual ADJ cjel-3536 200 21 use use NOUN cjel-3536 200 22 of of ADP cjel-3536 200 23 the the DET cjel-3536 200 24 river river NOUN cjel-3536 200 25 by by ADP cjel-3536 200 26 swimming swimming NOUN cjel-3536 200 27 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 200 28 wading wading NOUN cjel-3536 200 29 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 200 30 or or CCONJ cjel-3536 200 31 boating boating NOUN cjel-3536 200 32 was be AUX cjel-3536 200 33 necessary necessary ADJ cjel-3536 200 34 to to PART cjel-3536 200 35 establish establish VERB cjel-3536 200 36 standing standing NOUN cjel-3536 200 37 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 200 38 and and CCONJ cjel-3536 200 39 drew draw VERB cjel-3536 200 40 no no DET cjel-3536 200 41 distinction distinction NOUN cjel-3536 200 42 between between ADP cjel-3536 200 43 such such ADJ cjel-3536 200 44 activities activity NOUN cjel-3536 200 45 and and CCONJ cjel-3536 200 46 enjoying enjoy VERB cjel-3536 200 47 the the DET cjel-3536 200 48 river river NOUN cjel-3536 200 49 from from ADP cjel-3536 200 50 the the DET cjel-3536 200 51 surrounding surround VERB cjel-3536 200 52 land land NOUN cjel-3536 200 53 by by ADP cjel-3536 200 54 hiking hiking NOUN cjel-3536 200 55 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 200 56 camping camping NOUN cjel-3536 200 57 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 200 58 picnicking picnicking NOUN cjel-3536 200 59 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 200 60 and and CCONJ cjel-3536 200 61 driving drive VERB cjel-3536 200 62 near near ADP cjel-3536 200 63 the the DET cjel-3536 200 64 river.67 river.67 NOUN cjel-3536 200 65 the the DET cjel-3536 200 66 cantrell cantrell PROPN cjel-3536 200 67 decision decision NOUN cjel-3536 200 68 reasoned reason VERB cjel-3536 200 69 : : PUNCT cjel-3536 200 70 “ " PUNCT cjel-3536 200 71 the the DET cjel-3536 200 72 plaintiffs plaintiff NOUN cjel-3536 200 73 have have AUX cjel-3536 200 74 alleged allege VERB cjel-3536 200 75 a a DET cjel-3536 200 76 concrete concrete ADJ cjel-3536 200 77 aesthetic aesthetic ADJ cjel-3536 200 78 injury injury NOUN cjel-3536 200 79 because because SCONJ cjel-3536 200 80 they they PRON cjel-3536 200 81 assert assert VERB cjel-3536 200 82 that that SCONJ cjel-3536 200 83 their their PRON cjel-3536 200 84 ability ability NOUN cjel-3536 200 85 to to PART cjel-3536 200 86 view view VERB cjel-3536 200 87 the the DET cjel-3536 200 88 birds bird NOUN cjel-3536 200 89 and and CCONJ cjel-3536 200 90 their their PRON cjel-3536 200 91 habitat habitat NOUN cjel-3536 200 92 from from ADP cjel-3536 200 93 the the DET cjel-3536 200 94 publicly publicly ADV cjel-3536 200 95 accessible accessible ADJ cjel-3536 200 96 areas area NOUN cjel-3536 200 97 surrounding surround VERB cjel-3536 200 98 the the DET cjel-3536 200 99 station station NOUN cjel-3536 200 100 will will AUX cjel-3536 200 101 be be AUX cjel-3536 200 102 drastically drastically ADV cjel-3536 200 103 limited limit VERB cjel-3536 200 104 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 200 105 if if SCONJ cjel-3536 200 106 not not PART cjel-3536 200 107 destroyed destroy VERB cjel-3536 200 108 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 200 109 by by ADP cjel-3536 200 110 the the DET cjel-3536 200 111 navy navy PROPN cjel-3536 200 112 ’s ’s PART cjel-3536 200 113 actions action NOUN cjel-3536 200 114 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 201 1 ”68 ”68 PROPN cjel-3536 201 2 thus thus ADV cjel-3536 201 3 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 201 4 “ " PUNCT cjel-3536 201 5 the the DET cjel-3536 201 6 birdwatchers birdwatcher NOUN cjel-3536 201 7 have have AUX cjel-3536 201 8 shown show VERB cjel-3536 201 9 a a DET cjel-3536 201 10 concrete concrete ADJ cjel-3536 201 11 and and CCONJ cjel-3536 201 12 particularized particularized ADJ cjel-3536 201 13 interest interest NOUN cjel-3536 201 14 in in ADP cjel-3536 201 15 observing observe VERB cjel-3536 201 16 the the DET cjel-3536 201 17 birds bird NOUN cjel-3536 201 18 and and CCONJ cjel-3536 201 19 their their PRON cjel-3536 201 20 habitat habitat NOUN cjel-3536 201 21 from from ADP cjel-3536 201 22 land land NOUN cjel-3536 201 23 adjacent adjacent ADJ cjel-3536 201 24 to to ADP cjel-3536 201 25 the the DET cjel-3536 201 26 station station NOUN cjel-3536 201 27 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 201 28 and and CCONJ cjel-3536 201 29 therefore therefore ADV cjel-3536 201 30 have have VERB cjel-3536 201 31 satisfied satisfied ADJ cjel-3536 201 32 article article NOUN cjel-3536 201 33 iii‘s iii‘s ADP cjel-3536 201 34 injury injury NOUN cjel-3536 201 35 in in ADP cjel-3536 201 36 fact fact NOUN cjel-3536 201 37 requirement requirement NOUN cjel-3536 201 38 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 202 1 ”69 ”69 VERB cjel-3536 202 2 the the DET cjel-3536 202 3 ninth ninth ADJ cjel-3536 202 4 circuit circuit NOUN cjel-3536 202 5 ’s ’s PART cjel-3536 202 6 reasoning reasoning NOUN cjel-3536 202 7 was be AUX cjel-3536 202 8 followed follow VERB cjel-3536 202 9 in in ADP cjel-3536 202 10 a a DET cjel-3536 202 11 west west PROPN cjel-3536 202 12 virginia virginia PROPN cjel-3536 202 13 district district PROPN cjel-3536 202 14 court court NOUN cjel-3536 202 15 decision decision NOUN cjel-3536 202 16 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 203 1 in in ADP cjel-3536 203 2 its its PRON cjel-3536 203 3 2014 2014 NUM cjel-3536 203 4 decision decision NOUN cjel-3536 203 5 ohio ohio PROPN cjel-3536 203 6 valley valley PROPN cjel-3536 203 7 environmental environmental ADJ cjel-3536 203 8 coalition coalition PROPN cjel-3536 203 9 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 203 10 inc inc PROPN cjel-3536 203 11 . . PROPN cjel-3536 204 1 v. v. ADP cjel-3536 204 2 consol consol NOUN cjel-3536 204 3 of of ADP cjel-3536 204 4 kentucky kentucky PROPN cjel-3536 204 5 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 204 6 inc inc PROPN cjel-3536 204 7 . . PROPN cjel-3536 204 8 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 204 9 the the DET cjel-3536 204 10 u.s u.s PROPN cjel-3536 204 11 . . PROPN cjel-3536 204 12 district district PROPN cjel-3536 204 13 court court NOUN cjel-3536 204 14 for for ADP cjel-3536 204 15 the the DET cjel-3536 204 16 district district NOUN cjel-3536 204 17 of of ADP cjel-3536 204 18 west west PROPN cjel-3536 204 19 virginia virginia PROPN cjel-3536 204 20 relied rely VERB cjel-3536 204 21 on on ADP cjel-3536 204 22 cantrell cantrell PROPN cjel-3536 204 23 and and CCONJ cjel-3536 204 24 a a DET cjel-3536 204 25 similar similar ADJ cjel-3536 204 26 california california PROPN cjel-3536 204 27 district district NOUN cjel-3536 204 28 court court NOUN cjel-3536 204 29 decision decision NOUN cjel-3536 204 30 in in ADP cjel-3536 204 31 concluding conclude VERB cjel-3536 204 32 that that SCONJ cjel-3536 204 33 whether whether SCONJ cjel-3536 204 34 a a DET cjel-3536 204 35 plaintiff plaintiff NOUN cjel-3536 204 36 has have AUX cjel-3536 204 37 a a DET cjel-3536 204 38 legal legal ADJ cjel-3536 204 39 right right NOUN cjel-3536 204 40 to to PART cjel-3536 204 41 enter enter VERB cjel-3536 204 42 property property NOUN cjel-3536 204 43 does do AUX cjel-3536 204 44 not not PART cjel-3536 204 45 necessarily necessarily ADV cjel-3536 204 46 affect affect VERB cjel-3536 204 47 his his PRON cjel-3536 204 48 standing standing NOUN cjel-3536 204 49 to to PART cjel-3536 204 50 view view VERB cjel-3536 204 51 that that SCONJ cjel-3536 204 52 65 65 NUM cjel-3536 204 53 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 205 1 i i PRON cjel-3536 205 2 d. d. PROPN cjel-3536 205 3 66 66 NUM cjel-3536 205 4 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 206 1 i i PRON cjel-3536 206 2 d. d. PROPN cjel-3536 206 3 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 206 4 discussing discuss VERB cjel-3536 206 5 friends friend NOUN cjel-3536 206 6 of of ADP cjel-3536 206 7 the the DET cjel-3536 206 8 earth earth NOUN cjel-3536 206 9 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 206 10 inc inc PROPN cjel-3536 206 11 . . PROPN cjel-3536 207 1 v. v. PROPN cjel-3536 207 2 laidlaw laidlaw PROPN cjel-3536 207 3 envtl envtl PROPN cjel-3536 207 4 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 208 1 servs servs PROPN cjel-3536 208 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 209 1 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 209 2 toc toc PROPN cjel-3536 209 3 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 209 4 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 209 5 inc inc PROPN cjel-3536 209 6 . . PROPN cjel-3536 209 7 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 209 8 528 528 NUM cjel-3536 209 9 u.s u.s PROPN cjel-3536 209 10 . . PROPN cjel-3536 209 11 167 167 NUM cjel-3536 209 12 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 209 13 181–82 181–82 NUM cjel-3536 209 14 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 209 15 2000 2000 NUM cjel-3536 209 16 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 209 17 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 209 18 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 210 1 67 67 NUM cjel-3536 210 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 211 1 i i PRON cjel-3536 211 2 d. d. PROPN cjel-3536 211 3 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 211 4 discussing discuss VERB cjel-3536 211 5 friends friend NOUN cjel-3536 211 6 of of ADP cjel-3536 211 7 the the DET cjel-3536 211 8 earth earth NOUN cjel-3536 211 9 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 211 10 528 528 NUM cjel-3536 211 11 u.s u.s PROPN cjel-3536 211 12 . . PROPN cjel-3536 211 13 at at ADP cjel-3536 211 14 181–82 181–82 NOUN cjel-3536 211 15 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 211 16 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 212 1 68 68 NUM cjel-3536 212 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 213 1 i i PRON cjel-3536 213 2 d. d. PROPN cjel-3536 213 3 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 213 4 emphasis emphasis NOUN cjel-3536 213 5 in in ADP cjel-3536 213 6 original original ADJ cjel-3536 213 7 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 213 8 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 214 1 69 69 NUM cjel-3536 214 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 215 1 i i PRON cjel-3536 215 2 d. d. PROPN cjel-3536 215 3 at at ADP cjel-3536 215 4 682 682 NUM cjel-3536 215 5 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 216 1 mank mank NOUN cjel-3536 216 2 - - PUNCT cjel-3536 216 3 macro-[final macro-[final PROPN cjel-3536 216 4 6 6 NUM cjel-3536 216 5 - - SYM cjel-3536 216 6 19 19 NUM cjel-3536 216 7 ] ] PUNCT cjel-3536 216 8 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 216 9 do do AUX cjel-3536 216 10 not not PART cjel-3536 216 11 delete delete VERB cjel-3536 216 12 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 216 13 6/22/2015 6/22/2015 NUM cjel-3536 216 14 11:45 11:45 NUM cjel-3536 216 15 pm pm NOUN cjel-3536 216 16 2015 2015 NUM cjel-3536 216 17 ] ] PUNCT cjel-3536 216 18 standing stand VERB cjel-3536 216 19 to to PART cjel-3536 216 20 view view VERB cjel-3536 216 21 other other ADJ cjel-3536 216 22 people people NOUN cjel-3536 216 23 ’s ’s PART cjel-3536 216 24 land land NOUN cjel-3536 216 25 317 317 NUM cjel-3536 216 26 property.70 property.70 NOUN cjel-3536 216 27 the the DET cjel-3536 216 28 district district NOUN cjel-3536 216 29 court court NOUN cjel-3536 216 30 stated state VERB cjel-3536 216 31 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 216 32 “ " PUNCT cjel-3536 216 33 even even ADV cjel-3536 216 34 if if SCONJ cjel-3536 216 35 ms ms PROPN cjel-3536 216 36 . . PROPN cjel-3536 216 37 branham branham PROPN cjel-3536 216 38 were be AUX cjel-3536 216 39 not not PART cjel-3536 216 40 able able ADJ cjel-3536 216 41 to to PART cjel-3536 216 42 access access VERB cjel-3536 216 43 any any PRON cjel-3536 216 44 of of ADP cjel-3536 216 45 the the DET cjel-3536 216 46 affected affected ADJ cjel-3536 216 47 area area NOUN cjel-3536 216 48 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 216 49 it it PRON cjel-3536 216 50 is be AUX cjel-3536 216 51 not not PART cjel-3536 216 52 necessarily necessarily ADV cjel-3536 216 53 true true ADJ cjel-3536 216 54 that that SCONJ cjel-3536 216 55 the the DET cjel-3536 216 56 lack lack NOUN cjel-3536 216 57 of of ADP cjel-3536 216 58 access access NOUN cjel-3536 216 59 would would AUX cjel-3536 216 60 foreclose foreclose VERB cjel-3536 216 61 standing standing NOUN cjel-3536 216 62 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 217 1 ”71 ”71 PROPN cjel-3536 217 2 the the DET cjel-3536 217 3 court court NOUN cjel-3536 217 4 concluded conclude VERB cjel-3536 217 5 that that SCONJ cjel-3536 217 6 ms ms PROPN cjel-3536 217 7 . . PROPN cjel-3536 217 8 branham branham PROPN cjel-3536 217 9 ’s ’s PART cjel-3536 217 10 interest interest NOUN cjel-3536 217 11 in in ADP cjel-3536 217 12 viewing view VERB cjel-3536 217 13 at at ADP cjel-3536 217 14 least least ADJ cjel-3536 217 15 a a PRON cjel-3536 217 16 portion portion NOUN cjel-3536 217 17 of of ADP cjel-3536 217 18 the the DET cjel-3536 217 19 property property NOUN cjel-3536 217 20 at at ADP cjel-3536 217 21 issue issue NOUN cjel-3536 217 22 was be AUX cjel-3536 217 23 sufficient sufficient ADJ cjel-3536 217 24 to to PART cjel-3536 217 25 give give VERB cjel-3536 217 26 the the DET cjel-3536 217 27 plaintiff plaintiff NOUN cjel-3536 217 28 organizations organization NOUN cjel-3536 217 29 to to PART cjel-3536 217 30 which which PRON cjel-3536 217 31 she she PRON cjel-3536 217 32 belonged belong VERB cjel-3536 217 33 standing stand VERB cjel-3536 217 34 to to PART cjel-3536 217 35 sue sue VERB cjel-3536 217 36 even even ADV cjel-3536 217 37 though though SCONJ cjel-3536 217 38 there there PRON cjel-3536 217 39 was be VERB cjel-3536 217 40 some some DET cjel-3536 217 41 dispute dispute NOUN cjel-3536 217 42 as as ADP cjel-3536 217 43 to to ADP cjel-3536 217 44 which which PRON cjel-3536 217 45 lands land VERB cjel-3536 217 46 she she PRON cjel-3536 217 47 could could AUX cjel-3536 217 48 access access VERB cjel-3536 217 49 or or CCONJ cjel-3536 217 50 view.72 view.72 NOUN cjel-3536 217 51 v. v. ADP cjel-3536 217 52 conclusion conclusion NOUN cjel-3536 217 53 : : PUNCT cjel-3536 217 54 how how SCONJ cjel-3536 217 55 the the DET cjel-3536 217 56 supreme supreme PROPN cjel-3536 217 57 court court PROPN cjel-3536 217 58 might might AUX cjel-3536 217 59 address address VERB cjel-3536 217 60 the the DET cjel-3536 217 61 issue issue NOUN cjel-3536 217 62 it it PRON cjel-3536 217 63 is be AUX cjel-3536 217 64 difficult difficult ADJ cjel-3536 217 65 to to PART cjel-3536 217 66 predict predict VERB cjel-3536 217 67 how how SCONJ cjel-3536 217 68 the the DET cjel-3536 217 69 supreme supreme PROPN cjel-3536 217 70 court court PROPN cjel-3536 217 71 might might AUX cjel-3536 217 72 address address VERB cjel-3536 217 73 the the DET cjel-3536 217 74 question question NOUN cjel-3536 217 75 of of ADP cjel-3536 217 76 whether whether SCONJ cjel-3536 217 77 a a DET cjel-3536 217 78 plaintiff plaintiff NOUN cjel-3536 217 79 may may AUX cjel-3536 217 80 have have AUX cjel-3536 217 81 standing stand VERB cjel-3536 217 82 to to PART cjel-3536 217 83 view view VERB cjel-3536 217 84 property property NOUN cjel-3536 217 85 that that PRON cjel-3536 217 86 it it PRON cjel-3536 217 87 may may AUX cjel-3536 217 88 not not PART cjel-3536 217 89 legally legally ADV cjel-3536 217 90 enter enter VERB cjel-3536 217 91 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 218 1 the the DET cjel-3536 218 2 court court NOUN cjel-3536 218 3 has have AUX cjel-3536 218 4 sometimes sometimes ADV cjel-3536 218 5 applied apply VERB cjel-3536 218 6 standing standing NOUN cjel-3536 218 7 criteria criterion NOUN cjel-3536 218 8 more more ADV cjel-3536 218 9 strictly strictly ADV cjel-3536 218 10 and and CCONJ cjel-3536 218 11 sometimes sometimes ADV cjel-3536 218 12 more more ADV cjel-3536 218 13 loosely loosely ADV cjel-3536 218 14 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 219 1 in in ADP cjel-3536 219 2 its its PRON cjel-3536 219 3 lujan lujan NOUN cjel-3536 219 4 decision decision NOUN cjel-3536 219 5 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 219 6 the the DET cjel-3536 219 7 court court NOUN cjel-3536 219 8 emphasized emphasize VERB cjel-3536 219 9 a a DET cjel-3536 219 10 strict strict ADJ cjel-3536 219 11 application application NOUN cjel-3536 219 12 of of ADP cjel-3536 219 13 the the DET cjel-3536 219 14 three three NUM cjel-3536 219 15 - - PUNCT cjel-3536 219 16 part part NOUN cjel-3536 219 17 standing stand VERB cjel-3536 219 18 test test NOUN cjel-3536 219 19 discussed discuss VERB cjel-3536 219 20 in in ADP cjel-3536 219 21 part part NOUN cjel-3536 219 22 ii.73 ii.73 ADV cjel-3536 219 23 specifically specifically ADV cjel-3536 219 24 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 219 25 lujan lujan NOUN cjel-3536 219 26 imposed impose VERB cjel-3536 219 27 more more ADV cjel-3536 219 28 stringent stringent ADJ cjel-3536 219 29 standing standing NOUN cjel-3536 219 30 requirements requirement NOUN cjel-3536 219 31 on on ADP cjel-3536 219 32 private private ADJ cjel-3536 219 33 litigants litigant NOUN cjel-3536 219 34 challenging challenge VERB cjel-3536 219 35 government government NOUN cjel-3536 219 36 regulation regulation NOUN cjel-3536 219 37 of of ADP cjel-3536 219 38 third third ADJ cjel-3536 219 39 parties party NOUN cjel-3536 219 40 than than ADP cjel-3536 219 41 on on ADP cjel-3536 219 42 parties party NOUN cjel-3536 219 43 directly directly ADV cjel-3536 219 44 challenging challenge VERB cjel-3536 219 45 government government NOUN cjel-3536 219 46 regulation regulation NOUN cjel-3536 219 47 that that PRON cjel-3536 219 48 allegedly allegedly ADV cjel-3536 219 49 directly directly ADV cjel-3536 219 50 injured injure VERB cjel-3536 219 51 them.74 them.74 PROPN cjel-3536 219 52 however however ADV cjel-3536 219 53 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 219 54 the the DET cjel-3536 219 55 court court NOUN cjel-3536 219 56 partially partially ADV cjel-3536 219 57 softened soften VERB cjel-3536 219 58 lujan lujan PROPN cjel-3536 219 59 ’s ’s PART cjel-3536 219 60 strict strict ADJ cjel-3536 219 61 approach approach NOUN cjel-3536 219 62 to to ADP cjel-3536 219 63 standing stand VERB cjel-3536 219 64 in in ADP cjel-3536 219 65 certain certain ADJ cjel-3536 219 66 environmental environmental ADJ cjel-3536 219 67 cases case NOUN cjel-3536 219 68 by by ADP cjel-3536 219 69 subsequently subsequently ADV cjel-3536 219 70 70 70 NUM cjel-3536 219 71 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 220 1 no no INTJ cjel-3536 220 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 221 1 2:13 2:13 NUM cjel-3536 221 2 - - SYM cjel-3536 221 3 5005 5005 NUM cjel-3536 221 4 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 221 5 2014 2014 NUM cjel-3536 221 6 wl wl NOUN cjel-3536 221 7 1761938 1761938 NUM cjel-3536 221 8 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 221 9 at at ADP cjel-3536 221 10 * * NUM cjel-3536 221 11 14 14 NUM cjel-3536 221 12 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 221 13 s.d.w s.d.w NOUN cjel-3536 221 14 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 221 15 va va PROPN cjel-3536 221 16 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 221 17 apr apr PROPN cjel-3536 221 18 . . PROPN cjel-3536 221 19 30 30 NUM cjel-3536 221 20 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 221 21 2014 2014 NUM cjel-3536 221 22 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 221 23 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 221 24 citing cite VERB cjel-3536 221 25 cantrell cantrell PROPN cjel-3536 221 26 v. v. ADP cjel-3536 221 27 city city PROPN cjel-3536 221 28 of of ADP cjel-3536 221 29 long long ADJ cjel-3536 221 30 beach beach NOUN cjel-3536 221 31 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 221 32 241 241 NUM cjel-3536 221 33 f.3d f.3d NUM cjel-3536 221 34 674 674 NUM cjel-3536 221 35 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 221 36 681 681 NUM cjel-3536 221 37 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 221 38 9th 9th ADJ cjel-3536 221 39 cir cir NOUN cjel-3536 221 40 . . PROPN cjel-3536 221 41 2001 2001 NUM cjel-3536 221 42 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 221 43 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 221 44 “ " PUNCT cjel-3536 221 45 [ [ X cjel-3536 221 46 w]e w]e NOUN cjel-3536 221 47 have have AUX cjel-3536 221 48 never never ADV cjel-3536 221 49 required require VERB cjel-3536 221 50 a a DET cjel-3536 221 51 plaintiff plaintiff NOUN cjel-3536 221 52 to to PART cjel-3536 221 53 show show VERB cjel-3536 221 54 that that SCONJ cjel-3536 221 55 he he PRON cjel-3536 221 56 has have VERB cjel-3536 221 57 a a DET cjel-3536 221 58 right right NOUN cjel-3536 221 59 of of ADP cjel-3536 221 60 access access NOUN cjel-3536 221 61 to to ADP cjel-3536 221 62 the the DET cjel-3536 221 63 site site NOUN cjel-3536 221 64 on on ADP cjel-3536 221 65 which which PRON cjel-3536 221 66 the the DET cjel-3536 221 67 challenged challenge VERB cjel-3536 221 68 activity activity NOUN cjel-3536 221 69 is be AUX cjel-3536 221 70 occurring occur VERB cjel-3536 221 71 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 221 72 or or CCONJ cjel-3536 221 73 that that SCONJ cjel-3536 221 74 he he PRON cjel-3536 221 75 has have VERB cjel-3536 221 76 an an DET cjel-3536 221 77 absolute absolute ADJ cjel-3536 221 78 right right NOUN cjel-3536 221 79 to to PART cjel-3536 221 80 enjoy enjoy VERB cjel-3536 221 81 the the DET cjel-3536 221 82 aesthetic aesthetic ADJ cjel-3536 221 83 or or CCONJ cjel-3536 221 84 recreational recreational ADJ cjel-3536 221 85 activities activity NOUN cjel-3536 221 86 that that PRON cjel-3536 221 87 form form VERB cjel-3536 221 88 the the DET cjel-3536 221 89 basis basis NOUN cjel-3536 221 90 of of ADP cjel-3536 221 91 his his PRON cjel-3536 221 92 concrete concrete ADJ cjel-3536 221 93 interest interest NOUN cjel-3536 221 94 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 222 1 if if SCONJ cjel-3536 222 2 an an DET cjel-3536 222 3 area area NOUN cjel-3536 222 4 can can AUX cjel-3536 222 5 be be AUX cjel-3536 222 6 observed observe VERB cjel-3536 222 7 and and CCONJ cjel-3536 222 8 enjoyed enjoy VERB cjel-3536 222 9 from from ADP cjel-3536 222 10 adjacent adjacent ADJ cjel-3536 222 11 land land NOUN cjel-3536 222 12 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 222 13 plaintiffs plaintiff NOUN cjel-3536 222 14 need need AUX cjel-3536 222 15 not not PART cjel-3536 222 16 physically physically ADV cjel-3536 222 17 enter enter VERB cjel-3536 222 18 the the DET cjel-3536 222 19 affected affected ADJ cjel-3536 222 20 area area NOUN cjel-3536 222 21 to to PART cjel-3536 222 22 establish establish VERB cjel-3536 222 23 an an DET cjel-3536 222 24 injury injury NOUN cjel-3536 222 25 in in ADP cjel-3536 222 26 fact fact NOUN cjel-3536 222 27 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 222 28 ” " PUNCT cjel-3536 222 29 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 222 30 ; ; PUNCT cjel-3536 222 31 soda soda NOUN cjel-3536 222 32 mountain mountain NOUN cjel-3536 222 33 wilderness wilderness NOUN cjel-3536 222 34 council council PROPN cjel-3536 222 35 v. v. PROPN cjel-3536 222 36 norton norton PROPN cjel-3536 222 37 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 222 38 424 424 NUM cjel-3536 222 39 f. f. PROPN cjel-3536 222 40 supp supp PROPN cjel-3536 222 41 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 223 1 2d 2d NOUN cjel-3536 223 2 1241 1241 NUM cjel-3536 223 3 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 223 4 1256 1256 NUM cjel-3536 223 5 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 223 6 e.d e.d PROPN cjel-3536 223 7 . . PROPN cjel-3536 223 8 cal cal PROPN cjel-3536 223 9 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 224 1 2006 2006 NUM cjel-3536 224 2 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 224 3 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 224 4 “ " PUNCT cjel-3536 224 5 the the DET cjel-3536 224 6 plaintiffs plaintiff NOUN cjel-3536 224 7 have have AUX cjel-3536 224 8 standing stand VERB cjel-3536 224 9 because because SCONJ cjel-3536 224 10 the the DET cjel-3536 224 11 proposed propose VERB cjel-3536 224 12 action action NOUN cjel-3536 224 13 may may AUX cjel-3536 224 14 affect affect VERB cjel-3536 224 15 the the DET cjel-3536 224 16 manner manner NOUN cjel-3536 224 17 in in ADP cjel-3536 224 18 which which PRON cjel-3536 224 19 the the DET cjel-3536 224 20 private private ADJ cjel-3536 224 21 lands land NOUN cjel-3536 224 22 are be AUX cjel-3536 224 23 managed manage VERB cjel-3536 224 24 in in ADP cjel-3536 224 25 the the DET cjel-3536 224 26 future future NOUN cjel-3536 224 27 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 224 28 a a DET cjel-3536 224 29 cognizable cognizable ADJ cjel-3536 224 30 interest interest NOUN cjel-3536 224 31 despite despite SCONJ cjel-3536 224 32 the the DET cjel-3536 224 33 plaintiffs plaintiff NOUN cjel-3536 224 34 lack lack NOUN cjel-3536 224 35 of of ADP cjel-3536 224 36 a a DET cjel-3536 224 37 right right NOUN cjel-3536 224 38 to to PART cjel-3536 224 39 access access VERB cjel-3536 224 40 to to ADP cjel-3536 224 41 the the DET cjel-3536 224 42 land land NOUN cjel-3536 224 43 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 225 1 the the DET cjel-3536 225 2 declarations declaration NOUN cjel-3536 225 3 submitted submit VERB cjel-3536 225 4 by by ADP cjel-3536 225 5 plaintiffs plaintiff NOUN cjel-3536 225 6 demonstrate demonstrate VERB cjel-3536 225 7 that that SCONJ cjel-3536 225 8 at at ADV cjel-3536 225 9 least least ADJ cjel-3536 225 10 some some PRON cjel-3536 225 11 of of ADP cjel-3536 225 12 the the DET cjel-3536 225 13 organizations organization NOUN cjel-3536 225 14 ’ ' PUNCT cjel-3536 225 15 members member NOUN cjel-3536 225 16 regularly regularly ADV cjel-3536 225 17 travel travel VERB cjel-3536 225 18 to to ADP cjel-3536 225 19 the the DET cjel-3536 225 20 edges edge NOUN cjel-3536 225 21 of of ADP cjel-3536 225 22 the the DET cjel-3536 225 23 public public ADJ cjel-3536 225 24 property property NOUN cjel-3536 225 25 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 225 26 ” " PUNCT cjel-3536 225 27 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 225 28 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 225 29 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 226 1 71 71 NUM cjel-3536 226 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 227 1 i i PRON cjel-3536 227 2 d. d. PROPN cjel-3536 227 3 72 72 NUM cjel-3536 227 4 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 228 1 i i PRON cjel-3536 228 2 d. d. PROPN cjel-3536 228 3 at at ADP cjel-3536 228 4 11–14 11–14 NUM cjel-3536 228 5 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 229 1 73 73 NUM cjel-3536 229 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 230 1 504 504 NUM cjel-3536 230 2 u.s u.s PROPN cjel-3536 230 3 . . PROPN cjel-3536 230 4 555 555 NUM cjel-3536 230 5 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 230 6 560–61 560–61 NUM cjel-3536 230 7 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 230 8 1992 1992 NUM cjel-3536 230 9 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 230 10 ; ; PUNCT cjel-3536 230 11 mank mank NOUN cjel-3536 230 12 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 230 13 no no DET cjel-3536 230 14 article article NOUN cjel-3536 230 15 iii iii PROPN cjel-3536 230 16 standing standing PROPN cjel-3536 230 17 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 230 18 supra supra PROPN cjel-3536 230 19 note note NOUN cjel-3536 230 20 * * NOUN cjel-3536 230 21 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 230 22 at at ADP cjel-3536 230 23 1534 1534 NUM cjel-3536 230 24 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 230 25 1581 1581 NUM cjel-3536 230 26 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 230 27 discussing discuss VERB cjel-3536 230 28 lujan lujan NOUN cjel-3536 230 29 ’s ’s PART cjel-3536 230 30 strict strict ADJ cjel-3536 230 31 three three NUM cjel-3536 230 32 - - PUNCT cjel-3536 230 33 part part NOUN cjel-3536 230 34 standing standing ADJ cjel-3536 230 35 test test NOUN cjel-3536 230 36 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 230 37 ; ; PUNCT cjel-3536 230 38 supra supra PROPN cjel-3536 230 39 part part PROPN cjel-3536 230 40 ii ii PROPN cjel-3536 230 41 . . PROPN cjel-3536 230 42 74 74 NUM cjel-3536 230 43 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 231 1 lujan lujan PROPN cjel-3536 231 2 v. v. ADP cjel-3536 231 3 defenders defender NOUN cjel-3536 231 4 of of ADP cjel-3536 231 5 wildlife wildlife NOUN cjel-3536 231 6 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 231 7 504 504 NUM cjel-3536 231 8 u.s u.s PROPN cjel-3536 231 9 . . PROPN cjel-3536 231 10 555 555 NUM cjel-3536 231 11 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 231 12 561–62 561–62 NUM cjel-3536 231 13 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 231 14 1992 1992 NUM cjel-3536 231 15 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 231 16 ; ; PUNCT cjel-3536 231 17 mank mank NOUN cjel-3536 231 18 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 231 19 no no DET cjel-3536 231 20 article article NOUN cjel-3536 231 21 iii iii PROPN cjel-3536 231 22 standing standing PROPN cjel-3536 231 23 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 231 24 supra supra PROPN cjel-3536 231 25 note note NOUN cjel-3536 231 26 * * NOUN cjel-3536 231 27 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 231 28 at at ADP cjel-3536 231 29 1581 1581 NUM cjel-3536 231 30 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 232 1 mank mank NOUN cjel-3536 232 2 - - PUNCT cjel-3536 232 3 macro-[final macro-[final PROPN cjel-3536 232 4 6 6 NUM cjel-3536 232 5 - - SYM cjel-3536 232 6 19 19 NUM cjel-3536 232 7 ] ] PUNCT cjel-3536 232 8 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 232 9 do do AUX cjel-3536 232 10 not not PART cjel-3536 232 11 delete delete VERB cjel-3536 232 12 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 232 13 6/22/2015 6/22/2015 NUM cjel-3536 232 14 11:45 11:45 NUM cjel-3536 232 15 pm pm NOUN cjel-3536 232 16 318 318 NUM cjel-3536 232 17 columbia columbia PROPN cjel-3536 232 18 journal journal PROPN cjel-3536 232 19 of of ADP cjel-3536 232 20 environmental environmental ADJ cjel-3536 232 21 law law NOUN cjel-3536 232 22 [ [ X cjel-3536 232 23 vol vol NOUN cjel-3536 232 24 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 233 1 40:2 40:2 NUM cjel-3536 233 2 holding hold VERB cjel-3536 233 3 in in ADP cjel-3536 233 4 laidlaw laidlaw PROPN cjel-3536 233 5 that that SCONJ cjel-3536 233 6 plaintiffs plaintiff NOUN cjel-3536 233 7 who who PRON cjel-3536 233 8 avoid avoid VERB cjel-3536 233 9 recreational recreational ADJ cjel-3536 233 10 or or CCONJ cjel-3536 233 11 aesthetic aesthetic ADJ cjel-3536 233 12 activities activity NOUN cjel-3536 233 13 because because SCONJ cjel-3536 233 14 of of ADP cjel-3536 233 15 “ " PUNCT cjel-3536 233 16 reasonable reasonable ADJ cjel-3536 233 17 concerns concern NOUN cjel-3536 233 18 ” " PUNCT cjel-3536 233 19 about about ADP cjel-3536 233 20 pollution pollution NOUN cjel-3536 233 21 have have VERB cjel-3536 233 22 a a DET cjel-3536 233 23 sufficient sufficient ADJ cjel-3536 233 24 injury injury NOUN cjel-3536 233 25 for for ADP cjel-3536 233 26 article article NOUN cjel-3536 233 27 iii iii NUM cjel-3536 233 28 standing stand VERB cjel-3536 233 29 even even ADV cjel-3536 233 30 if if SCONJ cjel-3536 233 31 they they PRON cjel-3536 233 32 can can AUX cjel-3536 233 33 not not PART cjel-3536 233 34 prove prove VERB cjel-3536 233 35 actual actual ADJ cjel-3536 233 36 harm harm NOUN cjel-3536 233 37 to to ADP cjel-3536 233 38 themselves themselves PRON cjel-3536 233 39 or or CCONJ cjel-3536 233 40 the the DET cjel-3536 233 41 environment.75 environment.75 ADJ cjel-3536 233 42 christopher christopher PROPN cjel-3536 233 43 warshaw warshaw PROPN cjel-3536 233 44 and and CCONJ cjel-3536 233 45 gregory gregory PROPN cjel-3536 233 46 e. e. PROPN cjel-3536 233 47 wannier wannier PROPN cjel-3536 233 48 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 233 49 in in ADP cjel-3536 233 50 a a DET cjel-3536 233 51 quantitative quantitative ADJ cjel-3536 233 52 analysis analysis NOUN cjel-3536 233 53 of of ADP cjel-3536 233 54 1,935 1,935 NUM cjel-3536 233 55 lower low ADJ cjel-3536 233 56 court court NOUN cjel-3536 233 57 opinions opinion NOUN cjel-3536 233 58 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 233 59 demonstrated demonstrate VERB cjel-3536 233 60 that that SCONJ cjel-3536 233 61 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 233 62 because because SCONJ cjel-3536 233 63 of of ADP cjel-3536 233 64 laidlaw laidlaw NOUN cjel-3536 233 65 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 233 66 most most ADV cjel-3536 233 67 lower low ADJ cjel-3536 233 68 courts court NOUN cjel-3536 233 69 currently currently ADV cjel-3536 233 70 do do AUX cjel-3536 233 71 not not PART cjel-3536 233 72 actually actually ADV cjel-3536 233 73 apply apply VERB cjel-3536 233 74 more more ADV cjel-3536 233 75 stringent stringent ADJ cjel-3536 233 76 standing standing NOUN cjel-3536 233 77 requirements requirement NOUN cjel-3536 233 78 to to ADP cjel-3536 233 79 private private ADJ cjel-3536 233 80 litigants litigant NOUN cjel-3536 233 81 challenging challenge VERB cjel-3536 233 82 government government NOUN cjel-3536 233 83 regulation regulation NOUN cjel-3536 233 84 of of ADP cjel-3536 233 85 third third ADJ cjel-3536 233 86 parties party NOUN cjel-3536 233 87 than than ADP cjel-3536 233 88 to to ADP cjel-3536 233 89 litigants litigant NOUN cjel-3536 233 90 directly directly ADV cjel-3536 233 91 challenging challenge VERB cjel-3536 233 92 government government NOUN cjel-3536 233 93 regulation regulation NOUN cjel-3536 233 94 that that PRON cjel-3536 233 95 allegedly allegedly ADV cjel-3536 233 96 directly directly ADV cjel-3536 233 97 injures injure VERB cjel-3536 233 98 them.76 them.76 PRON cjel-3536 233 99 thus thus ADV cjel-3536 233 100 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 233 101 it it PRON cjel-3536 233 102 is be AUX cjel-3536 233 103 not not PART cjel-3536 233 104 surprising surprising ADJ cjel-3536 233 105 that that SCONJ cjel-3536 233 106 the the DET cjel-3536 233 107 ninth ninth ADJ cjel-3536 233 108 circuit circuit NOUN cjel-3536 233 109 in in ADP cjel-3536 233 110 cantrell cantrell PROPN cjel-3536 233 111 relied rely VERB cjel-3536 233 112 upon upon SCONJ cjel-3536 233 113 laidlaw laidlaw PROPN cjel-3536 233 114 when when SCONJ cjel-3536 233 115 concluding conclude VERB cjel-3536 233 116 that that SCONJ cjel-3536 233 117 a a DET cjel-3536 233 118 plaintiff plaintiff NOUN cjel-3536 233 119 may may AUX cjel-3536 233 120 have have AUX cjel-3536 233 121 standing stand VERB cjel-3536 233 122 to to PART cjel-3536 233 123 challenge challenge VERB cjel-3536 233 124 a a DET cjel-3536 233 125 defendant defendant NOUN cjel-3536 233 126 ’s ’s PART cjel-3536 233 127 actions action NOUN cjel-3536 233 128 harming harm VERB cjel-3536 233 129 the the DET cjel-3536 233 130 plaintiff plaintiff NOUN cjel-3536 233 131 ’s ’s PART cjel-3536 233 132 aesthetic aesthetic ADJ cjel-3536 233 133 views view NOUN cjel-3536 233 134 of of ADP cjel-3536 233 135 a a DET cjel-3536 233 136 property property NOUN cjel-3536 233 137 even even ADV cjel-3536 233 138 if if SCONJ cjel-3536 233 139 the the DET cjel-3536 233 140 plaintiff plaintiff NOUN cjel-3536 233 141 does do AUX cjel-3536 233 142 not not PART cjel-3536 233 143 have have VERB cjel-3536 233 144 a a DET cjel-3536 233 145 right right NOUN cjel-3536 233 146 to to PART cjel-3536 233 147 enter enter VERB cjel-3536 233 148 that that DET cjel-3536 233 149 property.77 property.77 NOUN cjel-3536 233 150 because because SCONJ cjel-3536 233 151 the the DET cjel-3536 233 152 supreme supreme PROPN cjel-3536 233 153 court court PROPN cjel-3536 233 154 ’s ’s PART cjel-3536 233 155 standing stand VERB cjel-3536 233 156 jurisprudence jurisprudence NOUN cjel-3536 233 157 contains contain VERB cjel-3536 233 158 both both CCONJ cjel-3536 233 159 strict strict ADJ cjel-3536 233 160 and and CCONJ cjel-3536 233 161 liberal liberal ADJ cjel-3536 233 162 interpretations,78 interpretations,78 NOUN cjel-3536 233 163 it it PRON cjel-3536 233 164 is be AUX cjel-3536 233 165 difficult difficult ADJ cjel-3536 233 166 to to PART cjel-3536 233 167 predict predict VERB cjel-3536 233 168 how how SCONJ cjel-3536 233 169 it it PRON cjel-3536 233 170 would would AUX cjel-3536 233 171 decide decide VERB cjel-3536 233 172 whether whether SCONJ cjel-3536 233 173 a a DET cjel-3536 233 174 plaintiff plaintiff NOUN cjel-3536 233 175 has have AUX cjel-3536 233 176 standing stand VERB cjel-3536 233 177 to to PART cjel-3536 233 178 challenge challenge VERB cjel-3536 233 179 actions action NOUN cjel-3536 233 180 affecting affect VERB cjel-3536 233 181 the the DET cjel-3536 233 182 aesthetic aesthetic ADJ cjel-3536 233 183 views view NOUN cjel-3536 233 184 of of ADP cjel-3536 233 185 a a DET cjel-3536 233 186 property property NOUN cjel-3536 233 187 he he PRON cjel-3536 233 188 or or CCONJ cjel-3536 233 189 she she PRON cjel-3536 233 190 does do AUX cjel-3536 233 191 not not PART cjel-3536 233 192 have have VERB cjel-3536 233 193 a a DET cjel-3536 233 194 legal legal ADJ cjel-3536 233 195 right right NOUN cjel-3536 233 196 to to PART cjel-3536 233 197 enter enter VERB cjel-3536 233 198 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 234 1 the the DET cjel-3536 234 2 court court NOUN cjel-3536 234 3 could could AUX cjel-3536 234 4 rely rely VERB cjel-3536 234 5 upon upon SCONJ cjel-3536 234 6 lujan lujan NOUN cjel-3536 234 7 ’s ’s PART cjel-3536 234 8 definition definition NOUN cjel-3536 234 9 of of ADP cjel-3536 234 10 an an DET cjel-3536 234 11 injury injury NOUN cjel-3536 234 12 in in ADP cjel-3536 234 13 fact fact NOUN cjel-3536 234 14 as as ADP cjel-3536 234 15 “ " PUNCT cjel-3536 234 16 an an DET cjel-3536 234 17 invasion invasion NOUN cjel-3536 234 18 of of ADP cjel-3536 234 19 a a DET cjel-3536 234 20 legally legally ADV cjel-3536 234 21 protected protect VERB cjel-3536 234 22 interest interest NOUN cjel-3536 234 23 ” " PUNCT cjel-3536 234 24 to to PART cjel-3536 234 25 require require VERB cjel-3536 234 26 that that SCONJ cjel-3536 234 27 a a DET cjel-3536 234 28 plaintiff plaintiff NOUN cjel-3536 234 29 must must AUX cjel-3536 234 30 have have VERB cjel-3536 234 31 a a DET cjel-3536 234 32 “ " PUNCT cjel-3536 234 33 legal legal ADJ cjel-3536 234 34 interest interest NOUN cjel-3536 234 35 ” " PUNCT cjel-3536 234 36 in in ADP cjel-3536 234 37 any any DET cjel-3536 234 38 property property NOUN cjel-3536 234 39 it it PRON cjel-3536 234 40 seeks seek VERB cjel-3536 234 41 standing stand VERB cjel-3536 234 42 to to ADP cjel-3536 234 43 protect.79 protect.79 NOUN cjel-3536 234 44 judge judge NOUN cjel-3536 234 45 sentelle sentelle NOUN cjel-3536 234 46 ’s ’s PART cjel-3536 234 47 dissenting dissent VERB cjel-3536 234 48 opinion opinion NOUN cjel-3536 234 49 relied rely VERB cjel-3536 234 50 upon upon SCONJ cjel-3536 234 51 lujan lujan NOUN cjel-3536 234 52 ’s ’s PART cjel-3536 234 53 ” " PUNCT cjel-3536 234 54 legally legally ADV cjel-3536 234 55 protected protect VERB cjel-3536 234 56 interest interest NOUN cjel-3536 234 57 ” " PUNCT cjel-3536 234 58 language language NOUN cjel-3536 234 59 in in ADP cjel-3536 234 60 arguing argue VERB cjel-3536 234 61 that that SCONJ cjel-3536 234 62 plaintiffs plaintiff NOUN cjel-3536 234 63 must must AUX cjel-3536 234 64 have have VERB cjel-3536 234 65 a a DET cjel-3536 234 66 legal legal ADJ cjel-3536 234 67 interest interest NOUN cjel-3536 234 68 in in ADP cjel-3536 234 69 the the DET cjel-3536 234 70 land land NOUN cjel-3536 234 71 they they PRON cjel-3536 234 72 seek seek VERB cjel-3536 234 73 75 75 NUM cjel-3536 234 74 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 234 75 528 528 NUM cjel-3536 234 76 u.s u.s PROPN cjel-3536 234 77 . . PROPN cjel-3536 234 78 167 167 NUM cjel-3536 234 79 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 234 80 181–86 181–86 NUM cjel-3536 234 81 ; ; PUNCT cjel-3536 234 82 christopher christopher PROPN cjel-3536 234 83 warshaw warshaw PROPN cjel-3536 234 84 & & CCONJ cjel-3536 234 85 gregory gregory PROPN cjel-3536 234 86 e. e. PROPN cjel-3536 234 87 wannier wannier PROPN cjel-3536 234 88 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 234 89 business business NOUN cjel-3536 234 90 as as ADP cjel-3536 234 91 usual usual ADJ cjel-3536 234 92 ? ? PUNCT cjel-3536 235 1 analyzing analyze VERB cjel-3536 235 2 the the DET cjel-3536 235 3 development development NOUN cjel-3536 235 4 of of ADP cjel-3536 235 5 environmental environmental ADJ cjel-3536 235 6 standing standing NOUN cjel-3536 235 7 doctrine doctrine NOUN cjel-3536 235 8 since since SCONJ cjel-3536 235 9 1976 1976 NUM cjel-3536 235 10 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 235 11 5 5 NUM cjel-3536 235 12 harv harv NOUN cjel-3536 235 13 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 236 1 l. l. PROPN cjel-3536 236 2 & & CCONJ cjel-3536 236 3 pol’y pol’y NOUN cjel-3536 236 4 rev rev PROPN cjel-3536 236 5 . . PROPN cjel-3536 236 6 289 289 NUM cjel-3536 236 7 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 236 8 289–322 289–322 NUM cjel-3536 236 9 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 236 10 2011 2011 NUM cjel-3536 236 11 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 236 12 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 236 13 empirical empirical ADJ cjel-3536 236 14 analysis analysis NOUN cjel-3536 236 15 of of ADP cjel-3536 236 16 1935 1935 NUM cjel-3536 236 17 lower low ADJ cjel-3536 236 18 court court NOUN cjel-3536 236 19 cases case NOUN cjel-3536 236 20 found find VERB cjel-3536 236 21 that that SCONJ cjel-3536 236 22 justice justice PROPN cjel-3536 236 23 scalia scalia PROPN cjel-3536 236 24 ’s ’s PART cjel-3536 236 25 two two NUM cjel-3536 236 26 lujan lujan NOUN cjel-3536 236 27 decisions decision NOUN cjel-3536 236 28 led lead VERB cjel-3536 236 29 to to ADP cjel-3536 236 30 more more ADJ cjel-3536 236 31 dismissal dismissal NOUN cjel-3536 236 32 of of ADP cjel-3536 236 33 environmentalist environmentalist ADJ cjel-3536 236 34 citizen citizen NOUN cjel-3536 236 35 suits suit NOUN cjel-3536 236 36 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 236 37 but but CCONJ cjel-3536 236 38 that that SCONJ cjel-3536 236 39 subsequent subsequent ADJ cjel-3536 236 40 laidlaw laidlaw PROPN cjel-3536 236 41 decision decision NOUN cjel-3536 236 42 reversed reverse VERB cjel-3536 236 43 that that DET cjel-3536 236 44 trend trend NOUN cjel-3536 236 45 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 236 46 ; ; PUNCT cjel-3536 236 47 mank mank NOUN cjel-3536 236 48 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 236 49 no no DET cjel-3536 236 50 article article NOUN cjel-3536 236 51 iii iii PROPN cjel-3536 236 52 standing standing PROPN cjel-3536 236 53 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 236 54 supra supra PROPN cjel-3536 236 55 note note NOUN cjel-3536 236 56 * * NOUN cjel-3536 236 57 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 236 58 at at ADP cjel-3536 236 59 1534 1534 NUM cjel-3536 236 60 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 236 61 1581–82 1581–82 NUM cjel-3536 236 62 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 236 63 contrasting contrast VERB cjel-3536 236 64 lujan lujan NOUN cjel-3536 236 65 and and CCONJ cjel-3536 236 66 laidlaw laidlaw PROPN cjel-3536 236 67 decisions decision NOUN cjel-3536 236 68 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 236 69 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 237 1 76 76 NUM cjel-3536 237 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 238 1 see see VERB cjel-3536 238 2 generally generally ADV cjel-3536 238 3 warshaw warshaw ADJ cjel-3536 238 4 & & CCONJ cjel-3536 238 5 wannier wannier NOUN cjel-3536 238 6 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 238 7 supra supra PROPN cjel-3536 238 8 note note NOUN cjel-3536 238 9 75 75 NUM cjel-3536 238 10 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 238 11 at at ADP cjel-3536 238 12 289–322 289–322 NUM cjel-3536 238 13 ; ; PUNCT cjel-3536 238 14 mank mank NOUN cjel-3536 238 15 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 238 16 no no DET cjel-3536 238 17 article article NOUN cjel-3536 238 18 iii iii PROPN cjel-3536 238 19 standing standing PROPN cjel-3536 238 20 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 238 21 supra supra PROPN cjel-3536 238 22 note note NOUN cjel-3536 238 23 * * NOUN cjel-3536 238 24 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 238 25 at at ADP cjel-3536 238 26 1581–82 1581–82 NUM cjel-3536 238 27 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 238 28 discussing discuss VERB cjel-3536 238 29 warshaw warshaw NOUN cjel-3536 238 30 & & CCONJ cjel-3536 238 31 wannier wannier NOUN cjel-3536 238 32 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 238 33 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 239 1 77 77 NUM cjel-3536 239 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 240 1 cantrell cantrell PROPN cjel-3536 240 2 v. v. ADP cjel-3536 240 3 city city PROPN cjel-3536 240 4 of of ADP cjel-3536 240 5 long long ADJ cjel-3536 240 6 beach beach NOUN cjel-3536 240 7 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 240 8 241 241 NUM cjel-3536 240 9 f.3d f.3d NUM cjel-3536 240 10 674 674 NUM cjel-3536 240 11 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 240 12 681 681 NUM cjel-3536 240 13 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 240 14 9th 9th NOUN cjel-3536 240 15 cir.2001 cir.2001 NOUN cjel-3536 240 16 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 240 17 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 240 18 discussing discuss VERB cjel-3536 240 19 laidlaw laidlaw NOUN cjel-3536 240 20 decision decision NOUN cjel-3536 240 21 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 240 22 ; ; PUNCT cjel-3536 240 23 supra supra PROPN cjel-3536 240 24 part part PROPN cjel-3536 240 25 iv iv X cjel-3536 240 26 . . PROPN cjel-3536 240 27 78 78 NUM cjel-3536 240 28 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 241 1 see see VERB cjel-3536 241 2 mank mank NOUN cjel-3536 241 3 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 241 4 no no DET cjel-3536 241 5 article article NOUN cjel-3536 241 6 iii iii NUM cjel-3536 241 7 standing stand VERB cjel-3536 241 8 for for ADP cjel-3536 241 9 private private ADJ cjel-3536 241 10 plaintiffs plaintiff NOUN cjel-3536 241 11 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 241 12 supra supra PROPN cjel-3536 241 13 note note NOUN cjel-3536 241 14 * * NOUN cjel-3536 241 15 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 241 16 at at ADP cjel-3536 241 17 1534 1534 NUM cjel-3536 241 18 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 241 19 1581–82 1581–82 NUM cjel-3536 241 20 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 241 21 contrasting contrast VERB cjel-3536 241 22 lujan lujan NOUN cjel-3536 241 23 and and CCONJ cjel-3536 241 24 laidlaw laidlaw PROPN cjel-3536 241 25 decisions decision NOUN cjel-3536 241 26 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 241 27 ; ; PUNCT cjel-3536 241 28 see see VERB cjel-3536 241 29 generally generally ADV cjel-3536 241 30 warshaw warshaw ADJ cjel-3536 241 31 & & CCONJ cjel-3536 241 32 wannier wannier NOUN cjel-3536 241 33 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 241 34 supra supra PROPN cjel-3536 241 35 note note NOUN cjel-3536 241 36 75 75 NUM cjel-3536 241 37 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 241 38 at at ADP cjel-3536 241 39 289–322 289–322 NUM cjel-3536 241 40 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 241 41 same same ADJ cjel-3536 241 42 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 241 43 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 242 1 79 79 NUM cjel-3536 242 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 243 1 see see VERB cjel-3536 243 2 lujan lujan NOUN cjel-3536 243 3 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 243 4 504 504 NUM cjel-3536 243 5 u.s u.s PROPN cjel-3536 243 6 . . PROPN cjel-3536 243 7 at at ADP cjel-3536 243 8 560 560 NUM cjel-3536 243 9 ; ; PUNCT cjel-3536 243 10 supra supra PROPN cjel-3536 243 11 part part PROPN cjel-3536 243 12 iii.c iii.c PROPN cjel-3536 243 13 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 243 14 mank mank PROPN cjel-3536 243 15 - - PUNCT cjel-3536 243 16 macro-[final macro-[final PROPN cjel-3536 243 17 6 6 NUM cjel-3536 243 18 - - SYM cjel-3536 243 19 19 19 NUM cjel-3536 243 20 ] ] PUNCT cjel-3536 243 21 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 243 22 do do AUX cjel-3536 243 23 not not PART cjel-3536 243 24 delete delete VERB cjel-3536 243 25 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 244 1 6/22/2015 6/22/2015 NUM cjel-3536 244 2 11:45 11:45 NUM cjel-3536 244 3 pm pm NOUN cjel-3536 244 4 2015 2015 NUM cjel-3536 244 5 ] ] PUNCT cjel-3536 244 6 standing stand VERB cjel-3536 244 7 to to PART cjel-3536 244 8 view view VERB cjel-3536 244 9 other other ADJ cjel-3536 244 10 people people NOUN cjel-3536 244 11 ’s ’s PART cjel-3536 244 12 land land NOUN cjel-3536 244 13 319 319 NUM cjel-3536 244 14 standing stand VERB cjel-3536 244 15 to to PART cjel-3536 244 16 view.80 view.80 VERB cjel-3536 244 17 yet yet ADV cjel-3536 244 18 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 244 19 as as SCONJ cjel-3536 244 20 the the DET cjel-3536 244 21 ninth ninth ADJ cjel-3536 244 22 circuit circuit NOUN cjel-3536 244 23 correctly correctly ADV cjel-3536 244 24 observed observe VERB cjel-3536 244 25 in in ADP cjel-3536 244 26 its its PRON cjel-3536 244 27 cantrell cantrell NOUN cjel-3536 244 28 decision decision NOUN cjel-3536 244 29 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 244 30 the the DET cjel-3536 244 31 court court NOUN cjel-3536 244 32 in in ADP cjel-3536 244 33 laidlaw laidlaw PROPN cjel-3536 244 34 appeared appear VERB cjel-3536 244 35 to to PART cjel-3536 244 36 be be AUX cjel-3536 244 37 unconcerned unconcerned ADJ cjel-3536 244 38 with with ADP cjel-3536 244 39 whether whether SCONJ cjel-3536 244 40 the the DET cjel-3536 244 41 plaintiffs plaintiff NOUN cjel-3536 244 42 in in ADP cjel-3536 244 43 that that DET cjel-3536 244 44 case case NOUN cjel-3536 244 45 owned own VERB cjel-3536 244 46 any any PRON cjel-3536 244 47 of of ADP cjel-3536 244 48 the the DET cjel-3536 244 49 river river NOUN cjel-3536 244 50 area area NOUN cjel-3536 245 1 they they PRON cjel-3536 245 2 viewed.81 viewed.81 INTJ cjel-3536 245 3 there there PRON cjel-3536 245 4 are be VERB cjel-3536 245 5 competing compete VERB cjel-3536 245 6 and and CCONJ cjel-3536 245 7 contrasting contrast VERB cjel-3536 245 8 policy policy NOUN cjel-3536 245 9 arguments argument NOUN cjel-3536 245 10 for for ADP cjel-3536 245 11 both both CCONJ cjel-3536 245 12 broad broad ADJ cjel-3536 245 13 and and CCONJ cjel-3536 245 14 narrow narrow ADJ cjel-3536 245 15 standing standing NOUN cjel-3536 245 16 for for ADP cjel-3536 245 17 plaintiffs plaintiff NOUN cjel-3536 245 18 who who PRON cjel-3536 245 19 seek seek VERB cjel-3536 245 20 standing stand VERB cjel-3536 245 21 to to PART cjel-3536 245 22 sue sue VERB cjel-3536 245 23 to to PART cjel-3536 245 24 protect protect VERB cjel-3536 245 25 their their PRON cjel-3536 245 26 aesthetic aesthetic ADJ cjel-3536 245 27 interests interest NOUN cjel-3536 245 28 in in ADP cjel-3536 245 29 viewing view VERB cjel-3536 245 30 lands land NOUN cjel-3536 245 31 they they PRON cjel-3536 245 32 can can AUX cjel-3536 245 33 not not PART cjel-3536 245 34 enter enter VERB cjel-3536 245 35 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 246 1 environmentalists environmentalist NOUN cjel-3536 246 2 and and CCONJ cjel-3536 246 3 nature nature NOUN cjel-3536 246 4 observers observer NOUN cjel-3536 246 5 seeking seek VERB cjel-3536 246 6 to to PART cjel-3536 246 7 protect protect VERB cjel-3536 246 8 beautiful beautiful ADJ cjel-3536 246 9 areas area NOUN cjel-3536 246 10 such such ADJ cjel-3536 246 11 as as ADP cjel-3536 246 12 blair blair PROPN cjel-3536 246 13 mountain mountain PROPN cjel-3536 246 14 would would AUX cjel-3536 246 15 usually usually ADV cjel-3536 246 16 advocate advocate VERB cjel-3536 246 17 for for ADP cjel-3536 246 18 broad broad ADJ cjel-3536 246 19 standing standing NOUN cjel-3536 246 20 rights right NOUN cjel-3536 246 21 for for ADP cjel-3536 246 22 plaintiffs plaintiff NOUN cjel-3536 246 23 who who PRON cjel-3536 246 24 sue sue VERB cjel-3536 246 25 to to PART cjel-3536 246 26 protect protect VERB cjel-3536 246 27 their their PRON cjel-3536 246 28 aesthetic aesthetic ADJ cjel-3536 246 29 interests interest NOUN cjel-3536 246 30 in in ADP cjel-3536 246 31 lands land NOUN cjel-3536 246 32 they they PRON cjel-3536 246 33 can can AUX cjel-3536 246 34 not not PART cjel-3536 246 35 physically physically ADV cjel-3536 246 36 access.82 access.82 VERB cjel-3536 246 37 the the DET cjel-3536 246 38 d.c d.c PROPN cjel-3536 246 39 . . PROPN cjel-3536 246 40 circuit circuit PROPN cjel-3536 246 41 decision decision NOUN cjel-3536 246 42 in in ADP cjel-3536 246 43 sierra sierra PROPN cjel-3536 246 44 club club PROPN cjel-3536 246 45 v. v. PROPN cjel-3536 246 46 jewell jewell PROPN cjel-3536 246 47 and and CCONJ cjel-3536 246 48 the the DET cjel-3536 246 49 ninth ninth ADJ cjel-3536 246 50 circuit circuit NOUN cjel-3536 246 51 decision decision NOUN cjel-3536 246 52 in in ADP cjel-3536 246 53 cantrell cantrell PROPN cjel-3536 246 54 marshalled marshal VERB cjel-3536 246 55 strong strong ADJ cjel-3536 246 56 precedent precedent NOUN cjel-3536 246 57 for for ADP cjel-3536 246 58 recognizing recognize VERB cjel-3536 246 59 standing stand VERB cjel-3536 246 60 for for ADP cjel-3536 246 61 nature nature NOUN cjel-3536 246 62 observers observer NOUN cjel-3536 246 63 because because SCONJ cjel-3536 246 64 of of ADP cjel-3536 246 65 a a DET cjel-3536 246 66 strong strong ADJ cjel-3536 246 67 public public ADJ cjel-3536 246 68 interest interest NOUN cjel-3536 246 69 in in ADP cjel-3536 246 70 preserving preserve VERB cjel-3536 246 71 aesthetic aesthetic ADJ cjel-3536 246 72 beauty beauty NOUN cjel-3536 246 73 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 246 74 even even ADV cjel-3536 246 75 where where SCONJ cjel-3536 246 76 the the DET cjel-3536 246 77 public public NOUN cjel-3536 246 78 has have VERB cjel-3536 246 79 no no DET cjel-3536 246 80 right right NOUN cjel-3536 246 81 to to PART cjel-3536 246 82 enter enter VERB cjel-3536 246 83 the the DET cjel-3536 246 84 property property NOUN cjel-3536 246 85 at at ADP cjel-3536 246 86 issue.83 issue.83 ADV cjel-3536 246 87 these these DET cjel-3536 246 88 two two NUM cjel-3536 246 89 cases case NOUN cjel-3536 246 90 place place VERB cjel-3536 246 91 more more ADJ cjel-3536 246 92 weight weight NOUN cjel-3536 246 93 on on ADP cjel-3536 246 94 giving give VERB cjel-3536 246 95 the the DET cjel-3536 246 96 public public ADJ cjel-3536 246 97 access access NOUN cjel-3536 246 98 to to ADP cjel-3536 246 99 aesthetic aesthetic ADJ cjel-3536 246 100 beauty beauty NOUN cjel-3536 246 101 than than ADP cjel-3536 246 102 on on ADP cjel-3536 246 103 the the DET cjel-3536 246 104 property property NOUN cjel-3536 246 105 rights right NOUN cjel-3536 246 106 of of ADP cjel-3536 246 107 the the DET cjel-3536 246 108 landowners landowner NOUN cjel-3536 246 109 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 247 1 however however ADV cjel-3536 247 2 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 247 3 property property NOUN cjel-3536 247 4 rights right NOUN cjel-3536 247 5 advocates advocate VERB cjel-3536 247 6 such such ADJ cjel-3536 247 7 as as ADP cjel-3536 247 8 judge judge NOUN cjel-3536 247 9 sentelle sentelle NOUN cjel-3536 247 10 would would AUX cjel-3536 247 11 argue argue VERB cjel-3536 247 12 that that SCONJ cjel-3536 247 13 only only ADV cjel-3536 247 14 those those PRON cjel-3536 247 15 with with ADP cjel-3536 247 16 a a DET cjel-3536 247 17 legal legal ADJ cjel-3536 247 18 interest interest NOUN cjel-3536 247 19 in in ADP cjel-3536 247 20 entering enter VERB cjel-3536 247 21 a a DET cjel-3536 247 22 property property NOUN cjel-3536 247 23 should should AUX cjel-3536 247 24 have have VERB cjel-3536 247 25 a a DET cjel-3536 247 26 standing stand VERB cjel-3536 247 27 right right NOUN cjel-3536 247 28 to to PART cjel-3536 247 29 sue sue VERB cjel-3536 247 30 to to PART cjel-3536 247 31 protect protect VERB cjel-3536 247 32 it it PRON cjel-3536 247 33 because because SCONJ cjel-3536 247 34 a a DET cjel-3536 247 35 land land NOUN cjel-3536 247 36 owner owner NOUN cjel-3536 247 37 ’s ’s PART cjel-3536 247 38 interest interest NOUN cjel-3536 247 39 in in ADP cjel-3536 247 40 managing manage VERB cjel-3536 247 41 his his PRON cjel-3536 247 42 property property NOUN cjel-3536 247 43 as as SCONJ cjel-3536 247 44 he he PRON cjel-3536 247 45 sees see VERB cjel-3536 247 46 fit fit ADJ cjel-3536 247 47 outweighs outweigh NOUN cjel-3536 247 48 any any DET cjel-3536 247 49 public public ADJ cjel-3536 247 50 interest interest NOUN cjel-3536 247 51 in in ADP cjel-3536 247 52 its its PRON cjel-3536 247 53 aesthetic aesthetic ADJ cjel-3536 247 54 beauty beauty NOUN cjel-3536 247 55 for for ADP cjel-3536 247 56 public public ADJ cjel-3536 247 57 viewers viewer NOUN cjel-3536 247 58 who who PRON cjel-3536 247 59 lack lack VERB cjel-3536 247 60 access access NOUN cjel-3536 247 61 rights right NOUN cjel-3536 247 62 to to ADP cjel-3536 247 63 the the DET cjel-3536 247 64 property.84 property.84 NOUN cjel-3536 247 65 if if SCONJ cjel-3536 247 66 the the DET cjel-3536 247 67 supreme supreme PROPN cjel-3536 247 68 court court PROPN cjel-3536 247 69 addresses address NOUN cjel-3536 247 70 whether whether SCONJ cjel-3536 247 71 plaintiffs plaintiff NOUN cjel-3536 247 72 must must AUX cjel-3536 247 73 have have VERB cjel-3536 247 74 a a DET cjel-3536 247 75 legal legal ADJ cjel-3536 247 76 interest interest NOUN cjel-3536 247 77 in in ADP cjel-3536 247 78 any any DET cjel-3536 247 79 property property NOUN cjel-3536 247 80 they they PRON cjel-3536 247 81 seek seek AUX cjel-3536 247 82 standing stand VERB cjel-3536 247 83 to to PART cjel-3536 247 84 protect protect VERB cjel-3536 247 85 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 247 86 it it PRON cjel-3536 247 87 might might AUX cjel-3536 247 88 be be AUX cjel-3536 247 89 forced force VERB cjel-3536 247 90 to to PART cjel-3536 247 91 face face VERB cjel-3536 247 92 the the DET cjel-3536 247 93 contradictions contradiction NOUN cjel-3536 247 94 or or CCONJ cjel-3536 247 95 tensions tension NOUN cjel-3536 247 96 between between ADP cjel-3536 247 97 lujan lujan PROPN cjel-3536 247 98 ’s ’s PART cjel-3536 247 99 strict strict ADJ cjel-3536 247 100 approach approach NOUN cjel-3536 247 101 to to ADP cjel-3536 247 102 standing standing NOUN cjel-3536 247 103 and and CCONJ cjel-3536 247 104 laidlaw laidlaw PROPN cjel-3536 247 105 ’s ’s PART cjel-3536 247 106 more more ADV cjel-3536 247 107 lenient lenient ADJ cjel-3536 247 108 approach.85 approach.85 PROPN cjel-3536 247 109 justice justice PROPN cjel-3536 247 110 kennedy kennedy PROPN cjel-3536 247 111 has have AUX cjel-3536 247 112 often often ADV cjel-3536 247 113 been be AUX cjel-3536 247 114 the the DET cjel-3536 247 115 swing swing NOUN cjel-3536 247 116 vote vote NOUN cjel-3536 247 117 in in ADP cjel-3536 247 118 standing standing ADJ cjel-3536 247 119 cases case NOUN cjel-3536 247 120 on on ADP cjel-3536 247 121 the the DET cjel-3536 247 122 current current ADJ cjel-3536 247 123 court.86 court.86 NOUN cjel-3536 247 124 notably notably ADV cjel-3536 247 125 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 247 126 he he PRON cjel-3536 247 127 filed file VERB cjel-3536 247 128 80 80 NUM cjel-3536 247 129 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 248 1 sierra sierra PROPN cjel-3536 248 2 club club PROPN cjel-3536 248 3 v. v. PROPN cjel-3536 248 4 jewell jewell PROPN cjel-3536 248 5 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 248 6 764 764 NUM cjel-3536 248 7 f.3d f.3d NUM cjel-3536 248 8 1 1 NUM cjel-3536 248 9 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 248 10 10–11 10–11 NUM cjel-3536 248 11 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 248 12 d.c d.c PROPN cjel-3536 248 13 . . PROPN cjel-3536 248 14 cir cir PROPN cjel-3536 248 15 . . PROPN cjel-3536 248 16 2014 2014 NUM cjel-3536 248 17 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 248 18 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 248 19 sentelle sentelle NOUN cjel-3536 248 20 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 248 21 j. j. PROPN cjel-3536 248 22 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 248 23 dissenting dissent VERB cjel-3536 248 24 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 248 25 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 248 26 quoting quote VERB cjel-3536 248 27 lujan lujan NOUN cjel-3536 248 28 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 248 29 504 504 NUM cjel-3536 248 30 u.s u.s PROPN cjel-3536 248 31 . . PROPN cjel-3536 248 32 at at ADP cjel-3536 248 33 560 560 NUM cjel-3536 248 34 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 248 35 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 249 1 81 81 NUM cjel-3536 249 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 250 1 cantrell cantrell PROPN cjel-3536 250 2 v. v. ADP cjel-3536 250 3 city city PROPN cjel-3536 250 4 of of ADP cjel-3536 250 5 long long ADJ cjel-3536 250 6 beach beach NOUN cjel-3536 250 7 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 250 8 241 241 NUM cjel-3536 250 9 f.3d f.3d NUM cjel-3536 250 10 674 674 NUM cjel-3536 250 11 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 250 12 681 681 NUM cjel-3536 250 13 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 250 14 9th 9th NOUN cjel-3536 250 15 cir.2001 cir.2001 NOUN cjel-3536 250 16 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 250 17 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 250 18 discussing discuss VERB cjel-3536 250 19 laidlaw laidlaw NOUN cjel-3536 250 20 decision decision NOUN cjel-3536 250 21 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 250 22 ; ; PUNCT cjel-3536 250 23 supra supra PROPN cjel-3536 250 24 part part PROPN cjel-3536 250 25 iv iv PROPN cjel-3536 250 26 . . PROPN cjel-3536 250 27 82 82 NUM cjel-3536 250 28 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 251 1 see see VERB cjel-3536 251 2 supra supra PROPN cjel-3536 251 3 part part NOUN cjel-3536 251 4 iii.b iii.b PROPN cjel-3536 251 5 and and CCONJ cjel-3536 251 6 part part NOUN cjel-3536 251 7 iv iv NUM cjel-3536 251 8 . . PROPN cjel-3536 251 9 83 83 NUM cjel-3536 251 10 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 252 1 i i PRON cjel-3536 252 2 d. d. PROPN cjel-3536 252 3 84 84 NUM cjel-3536 252 4 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 253 1 see see VERB cjel-3536 253 2 part part NOUN cjel-3536 253 3 iii.c iii.c NOUN cjel-3536 253 4 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 253 5 85 85 NUM cjel-3536 253 6 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 254 1 see see VERB cjel-3536 254 2 mank mank NOUN cjel-3536 254 3 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 254 4 no no DET cjel-3536 254 5 article article NOUN cjel-3536 254 6 iii iii PROPN cjel-3536 254 7 standing standing PROPN cjel-3536 254 8 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 254 9 supra supra PROPN cjel-3536 254 10 note note NOUN cjel-3536 254 11 * * NOUN cjel-3536 254 12 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 254 13 at at ADP cjel-3536 254 14 1534 1534 NUM cjel-3536 254 15 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 254 16 1581–82 1581–82 NUM cjel-3536 254 17 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 254 18 contrasting contrast VERB cjel-3536 254 19 lujan lujan NOUN cjel-3536 254 20 and and CCONJ cjel-3536 254 21 laidlaw laidlaw PROPN cjel-3536 254 22 decisions decision NOUN cjel-3536 254 23 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 254 24 ; ; PUNCT cjel-3536 254 25 see see VERB cjel-3536 254 26 generally generally ADV cjel-3536 254 27 warshaw warshaw ADJ cjel-3536 254 28 & & CCONJ cjel-3536 254 29 wannier wannier NOUN cjel-3536 254 30 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 254 31 supra supra PROPN cjel-3536 254 32 note note NOUN cjel-3536 254 33 76 76 NUM cjel-3536 254 34 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 254 35 at at ADP cjel-3536 254 36 289–322 289–322 NUM cjel-3536 254 37 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 254 38 same same ADJ cjel-3536 254 39 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 254 40 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 255 1 86 86 NUM cjel-3536 255 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 255 3 mank mank PROPN cjel-3536 255 4 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 255 5 clapper clapper NOUN cjel-3536 255 6 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 255 7 supra supra PROPN cjel-3536 255 8 note note PROPN cjel-3536 255 9 * * NOUN cjel-3536 255 10 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 255 11 at at ADP cjel-3536 255 12 215–16 215–16 PROPN cjel-3536 255 13 n.20 n.20 ADP cjel-3536 255 14 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 255 15 mank mank PROPN cjel-3536 255 16 - - PUNCT cjel-3536 255 17 macro-[final macro-[final PROPN cjel-3536 255 18 6 6 NUM cjel-3536 255 19 - - SYM cjel-3536 255 20 19 19 NUM cjel-3536 255 21 ] ] PUNCT cjel-3536 255 22 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 255 23 do do AUX cjel-3536 255 24 not not PART cjel-3536 255 25 delete delete VERB cjel-3536 255 26 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 256 1 6/22/2015 6/22/2015 NUM cjel-3536 256 2 11:45 11:45 NUM cjel-3536 256 3 pm pm NOUN cjel-3536 256 4 320 320 NUM cjel-3536 256 5 columbia columbia PROPN cjel-3536 256 6 journal journal PROPN cjel-3536 256 7 of of ADP cjel-3536 256 8 environmental environmental ADJ cjel-3536 256 9 law law NOUN cjel-3536 257 1 [ [ X cjel-3536 257 2 vol vol NOUN cjel-3536 257 3 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 258 1 40:2 40:2 NUM cjel-3536 258 2 concurring concur VERB cjel-3536 258 3 opinions opinion NOUN cjel-3536 258 4 in in ADP cjel-3536 258 5 both both CCONJ cjel-3536 258 6 the the DET cjel-3536 258 7 lujan lujan NOUN cjel-3536 258 8 and and CCONJ cjel-3536 258 9 laidlaw laidlaw PROPN cjel-3536 258 10 decisions decision NOUN cjel-3536 258 11 ; ; PUNCT cjel-3536 258 12 accordingly accordingly ADV cjel-3536 258 13 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 258 14 justice justice PROPN cjel-3536 258 15 kennedy kennedy PROPN cjel-3536 258 16 might might AUX cjel-3536 258 17 the the DET cjel-3536 258 18 justice justice NOUN cjel-3536 258 19 who who PRON cjel-3536 258 20 resolves resolve VERB cjel-3536 258 21 the the DET cjel-3536 258 22 tensions tension NOUN cjel-3536 258 23 between between ADP cjel-3536 258 24 the the DET cjel-3536 258 25 two two NUM cjel-3536 258 26 decisions.87 decisions.87 NOUN cjel-3536 258 27 by by ADP cjel-3536 258 28 contrast contrast NOUN cjel-3536 258 29 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 258 30 justice justice PROPN cjel-3536 258 31 scalia scalia PROPN cjel-3536 258 32 has have AUX cjel-3536 258 33 usually usually ADV cjel-3536 258 34 sought seek VERB cjel-3536 258 35 to to PART cjel-3536 258 36 narrow narrow VERB cjel-3536 258 37 standing standing NOUN cjel-3536 258 38 rights right NOUN cjel-3536 258 39 in in ADP cjel-3536 258 40 cases case NOUN cjel-3536 258 41 in in ADP cjel-3536 258 42 which which PRON cjel-3536 258 43 private private ADJ cjel-3536 258 44 citizen citizen NOUN cjel-3536 258 45 suits suit NOUN cjel-3536 258 46 seek seek VERB cjel-3536 258 47 to to PART cjel-3536 258 48 challenge challenge VERB cjel-3536 258 49 the the DET cjel-3536 258 50 government government NOUN cjel-3536 258 51 ’s ’s PART cjel-3536 258 52 alleged allege VERB cjel-3536 258 53 under under NOUN cjel-3536 258 54 - - PUNCT cjel-3536 258 55 enforcement enforcement NOUN cjel-3536 258 56 or or CCONJ cjel-3536 258 57 non non ADJ cjel-3536 258 58 - - NOUN cjel-3536 258 59 enforcement enforcement NOUN cjel-3536 258 60 of of ADP cjel-3536 258 61 federal federal ADJ cjel-3536 258 62 statutes statute NOUN cjel-3536 258 63 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 258 64 notably notably ADV cjel-3536 258 65 environmental environmental ADJ cjel-3536 258 66 laws.88 laws.88 PROPN cjel-3536 258 67 on on ADP cjel-3536 258 68 the the DET cjel-3536 258 69 other other ADJ cjel-3536 258 70 hand hand NOUN cjel-3536 258 71 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 258 72 justice justice NOUN cjel-3536 258 73 breyer breyer NOUN cjel-3536 258 74 ’s ’s PART cjel-3536 258 75 probabilistic probabilistic ADJ cjel-3536 258 76 approach approach NOUN cjel-3536 258 77 to to ADP cjel-3536 258 78 standing standing NOUN cjel-3536 258 79 has have AUX cjel-3536 258 80 sought seek VERB cjel-3536 258 81 to to PART cjel-3536 258 82 expand expand VERB cjel-3536 258 83 standing standing NOUN cjel-3536 258 84 rights right NOUN cjel-3536 258 85 in in ADP cjel-3536 258 86 such such ADJ cjel-3536 258 87 cases.89 cases.89 NOUN cjel-3536 258 88 a a DET cjel-3536 258 89 future future ADJ cjel-3536 258 90 majority majority NOUN cjel-3536 258 91 in in ADP cjel-3536 258 92 an an DET cjel-3536 258 93 aesthetic aesthetic ADJ cjel-3536 258 94 preservation preservation NOUN cjel-3536 258 95 case case NOUN cjel-3536 258 96 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 258 97 however however ADV cjel-3536 258 98 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 258 99 might might AUX cjel-3536 258 100 cite cite VERB cjel-3536 258 101 either either CCONJ cjel-3536 258 102 the the DET cjel-3536 258 103 lujan lujan NOUN cjel-3536 258 104 or or CCONJ cjel-3536 258 105 laidlaw laidlaw PROPN cjel-3536 258 106 decisions decision NOUN cjel-3536 258 107 and and CCONJ cjel-3536 258 108 ignore ignore VERB cjel-3536 258 109 the the DET cjel-3536 258 110 others other NOUN cjel-3536 258 111 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 258 112 because because SCONJ cjel-3536 258 113 that that PRON cjel-3536 258 114 would would AUX cjel-3536 258 115 be be AUX cjel-3536 258 116 easier easy ADJ cjel-3536 258 117 than than ADP cjel-3536 258 118 addressing address VERB cjel-3536 258 119 those those DET cjel-3536 258 120 contradictions contradiction NOUN cjel-3536 258 121 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 259 1 furthermore furthermore ADV cjel-3536 259 2 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 259 3 some some PRON cjel-3536 259 4 argue argue VERB cjel-3536 259 5 that that SCONJ cjel-3536 259 6 the the DET cjel-3536 259 7 d.c d.c PROPN cjel-3536 259 8 . . PROPN cjel-3536 259 9 circuit circuit PROPN cjel-3536 259 10 ’s ’s PART cjel-3536 259 11 recent recent ADJ cjel-3536 259 12 decision decision NOUN cjel-3536 259 13 approving approve VERB cjel-3536 259 14 broader broad ADJ cjel-3536 259 15 standing stand VERB cjel-3536 259 16 in in ADP cjel-3536 259 17 the the DET cjel-3536 259 18 blair blair PROPN cjel-3536 259 19 mountain mountain PROPN cjel-3536 259 20 case case NOUN cjel-3536 259 21 is be AUX cjel-3536 259 22 the the DET cjel-3536 259 23 result result NOUN cjel-3536 259 24 of of ADP cjel-3536 259 25 president president PROPN cjel-3536 259 26 obama obama PROPN cjel-3536 259 27 ’s ’s PART cjel-3536 259 28 recent recent ADJ cjel-3536 259 29 appointments appointment NOUN cjel-3536 259 30 to to ADP cjel-3536 259 31 that that DET cjel-3536 259 32 circuit circuit NOUN cjel-3536 259 33 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 259 34 including include VERB cjel-3536 259 35 judge judge NOUN cjel-3536 259 36 srinivasan srinivasan NOUN cjel-3536 259 37 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 259 38 which which PRON cjel-3536 259 39 shifted shift VERB cjel-3536 259 40 that that DET cjel-3536 259 41 circuit circuit NOUN cjel-3536 259 42 to to ADP cjel-3536 259 43 a a DET cjel-3536 259 44 more more ADV cjel-3536 259 45 liberal liberal ADJ cjel-3536 259 46 approach approach NOUN cjel-3536 259 47 with with ADP cjel-3536 259 48 regard regard NOUN cjel-3536 259 49 to to ADP cjel-3536 259 50 standing stand VERB cjel-3536 259 51 when when SCONJ cjel-3536 259 52 these these DET cjel-3536 259 53 appointments appointment NOUN cjel-3536 259 54 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 259 55 in in ADP cjel-3536 259 56 combination combination NOUN cjel-3536 259 57 with with ADP cjel-3536 259 58 prior prior ADJ cjel-3536 259 59 appointments appointment NOUN cjel-3536 259 60 by by ADP cjel-3536 259 61 president president PROPN cjel-3536 259 62 clinton clinton PROPN cjel-3536 259 63 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 259 64 gave give VERB cjel-3536 259 65 judges judge NOUN cjel-3536 259 66 87 87 NUM cjel-3536 259 67 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 260 1 friends friend NOUN cjel-3536 260 2 of of ADP cjel-3536 260 3 the the DET cjel-3536 260 4 earth earth NOUN cjel-3536 260 5 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 260 6 inc inc PROPN cjel-3536 260 7 . . PROPN cjel-3536 261 1 v. v. PROPN cjel-3536 261 2 laidlaw laidlaw PROPN cjel-3536 261 3 envtl envtl PROPN cjel-3536 261 4 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 262 1 servs servs PROPN cjel-3536 262 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 263 1 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 263 2 toc toc PROPN cjel-3536 263 3 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 263 4 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 263 5 inc inc PROPN cjel-3536 263 6 . . PROPN cjel-3536 263 7 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 263 8 528 528 NUM cjel-3536 263 9 u.s u.s PROPN cjel-3536 263 10 . . PROPN cjel-3536 263 11 167 167 NUM cjel-3536 263 12 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 263 13 197 197 NUM cjel-3536 263 14 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 263 15 2000 2000 NUM cjel-3536 263 16 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 263 17 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 263 18 kennedy kennedy PROPN cjel-3536 263 19 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 263 20 j. j. PROPN cjel-3536 263 21 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 263 22 concurring concurring NOUN cjel-3536 263 23 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 263 24 ; ; PUNCT cjel-3536 263 25 lujan lujan VERB cjel-3536 263 26 v. v. ADP cjel-3536 263 27 defenders defender NOUN cjel-3536 263 28 of of ADP cjel-3536 263 29 wildlife wildlife NOUN cjel-3536 263 30 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 263 31 504 504 NUM cjel-3536 263 32 u.s u.s PROPN cjel-3536 263 33 . . PROPN cjel-3536 263 34 555 555 NUM cjel-3536 263 35 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 263 36 579–81 579–81 NUM cjel-3536 263 37 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 263 38 1992 1992 NUM cjel-3536 263 39 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 263 40 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 263 41 kennedy kennedy PROPN cjel-3536 263 42 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 263 43 j. j. PROPN cjel-3536 263 44 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 263 45 concurring concur VERB cjel-3536 263 46 in in ADP cjel-3536 263 47 part part NOUN cjel-3536 263 48 and and CCONJ cjel-3536 263 49 concurring concur VERB cjel-3536 263 50 in in ADP cjel-3536 263 51 the the DET cjel-3536 263 52 judgment judgment NOUN cjel-3536 263 53 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 263 54 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 264 1 88 88 NUM cjel-3536 264 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 265 1 see see VERB cjel-3536 265 2 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 265 3 e.g. e.g. ADV cjel-3536 265 4 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 265 5 summers summer NOUN cjel-3536 265 6 v. v. ADP cjel-3536 265 7 earth earth PROPN cjel-3536 265 8 island island NOUN cjel-3536 265 9 inst inst PROPN cjel-3536 265 10 . . PROPN cjel-3536 265 11 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 265 12 555 555 NUM cjel-3536 265 13 u.s u.s PROPN cjel-3536 265 14 . . PROPN cjel-3536 265 15 488 488 NUM cjel-3536 265 16 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 265 17 492–94 492–94 NOUN cjel-3536 265 18 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 265 19 496–500 496–500 NUM cjel-3536 265 20 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 265 21 2009 2009 NUM cjel-3536 265 22 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 265 23 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 265 24 rejecting reject VERB cjel-3536 265 25 probabilistic probabilistic ADJ cjel-3536 265 26 proof proof NOUN cjel-3536 265 27 of of ADP cjel-3536 265 28 standing standing ADJ cjel-3536 265 29 injury injury NOUN cjel-3536 265 30 in in ADP cjel-3536 265 31 case case NOUN cjel-3536 265 32 alleging allege VERB cjel-3536 265 33 that that SCONJ cjel-3536 265 34 the the DET cjel-3536 265 35 forest forest NOUN cjel-3536 265 36 service service NOUN cjel-3536 265 37 ’s ’s PART cjel-3536 265 38 sales sale NOUN cjel-3536 265 39 of of ADP cjel-3536 265 40 timber timber NOUN cjel-3536 265 41 from from ADP cjel-3536 265 42 government government NOUN cjel-3536 265 43 lands land NOUN cjel-3536 265 44 failed fail VERB cjel-3536 265 45 to to PART cjel-3536 265 46 protect protect VERB cjel-3536 265 47 the the DET cjel-3536 265 48 public public ADJ cjel-3536 265 49 interest interest NOUN cjel-3536 265 50 in in ADP cjel-3536 265 51 accessing access VERB cjel-3536 265 52 and and CCONJ cjel-3536 265 53 enjoying enjoy VERB cjel-3536 265 54 those those DET cjel-3536 265 55 lands land NOUN cjel-3536 265 56 and and CCONJ cjel-3536 265 57 demanding demand VERB cjel-3536 265 58 that that SCONJ cjel-3536 265 59 environmental environmental ADJ cjel-3536 265 60 plaintiffs plaintiff NOUN cjel-3536 265 61 demonstrate demonstrate VERB cjel-3536 265 62 a a DET cjel-3536 265 63 specific specific ADJ cjel-3536 265 64 time time NOUN cjel-3536 265 65 and and CCONJ cjel-3536 265 66 place place NOUN cjel-3536 265 67 where where SCONJ cjel-3536 265 68 they they PRON cjel-3536 265 69 suffer suffer VERB cjel-3536 265 70 a a DET cjel-3536 265 71 concrete concrete ADJ cjel-3536 265 72 injury injury NOUN cjel-3536 265 73 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 265 74 ; ; PUNCT cjel-3536 265 75 lujan lujan VERB cjel-3536 265 76 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 265 77 504 504 NUM cjel-3536 265 78 u.s u.s PROPN cjel-3536 265 79 . . PROPN cjel-3536 265 80 at at ADP cjel-3536 265 81 573–78 573–78 NUM cjel-3536 265 82 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 265 83 concluding conclude VERB cjel-3536 265 84 that that SCONJ cjel-3536 265 85 articles article NOUN cjel-3536 265 86 ii ii PROPN cjel-3536 265 87 and and CCONJ cjel-3536 265 88 iii iii NUM cjel-3536 265 89 of of ADP cjel-3536 265 90 the the DET cjel-3536 265 91 constitution constitution NOUN cjel-3536 265 92 limit limit NOUN cjel-3536 265 93 congress congress PROPN cjel-3536 265 94 ’s ’s PART cjel-3536 265 95 authority authority NOUN cjel-3536 265 96 to to PART cjel-3536 265 97 authorize authorize VERB cjel-3536 265 98 citizen citizen NOUN cjel-3536 265 99 suits suit NOUN cjel-3536 265 100 by by ADP cjel-3536 265 101 any any DET cjel-3536 265 102 person person NOUN cjel-3536 265 103 lacking lack VERB cjel-3536 265 104 a a DET cjel-3536 265 105 concrete concrete ADJ cjel-3536 265 106 injury injury NOUN cjel-3536 265 107 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 265 108 requiring require VERB cjel-3536 265 109 environmental environmental ADJ cjel-3536 265 110 plaintiffs plaintiff NOUN cjel-3536 265 111 to to PART cjel-3536 265 112 demonstrate demonstrate VERB cjel-3536 265 113 a a DET cjel-3536 265 114 specific specific ADJ cjel-3536 265 115 injury injury NOUN cjel-3536 265 116 for for ADP cjel-3536 265 117 standing standing NOUN cjel-3536 265 118 and and CCONJ cjel-3536 265 119 thus thus ADV cjel-3536 265 120 rejecting reject VERB cjel-3536 265 121 environmental environmental ADJ cjel-3536 265 122 suit suit NOUN cjel-3536 265 123 alleging allege VERB cjel-3536 265 124 potential potential ADJ cjel-3536 265 125 future future ADJ cjel-3536 265 126 harm harm NOUN cjel-3536 265 127 to to ADP cjel-3536 265 128 plaintiffs plaintiff NOUN cjel-3536 265 129 ’ ' PUNCT cjel-3536 265 130 aesthetic aesthetic ADJ cjel-3536 265 131 interest interest NOUN cjel-3536 265 132 in in ADP cjel-3536 265 133 viewing view VERB cjel-3536 265 134 endangered endangered ADJ cjel-3536 265 135 species specie NOUN cjel-3536 265 136 in in ADP cjel-3536 265 137 foreign foreign ADJ cjel-3536 265 138 countries country NOUN cjel-3536 265 139 at at ADP cjel-3536 265 140 some some DET cjel-3536 265 141 possible possible ADJ cjel-3536 265 142 future future ADJ cjel-3536 265 143 time time NOUN cjel-3536 265 144 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 265 145 ; ; PUNCT cjel-3536 265 146 mank mank NOUN cjel-3536 265 147 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 265 148 clapper clapper NOUN cjel-3536 265 149 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 265 150 supra supra PROPN cjel-3536 265 151 note note PROPN cjel-3536 265 152 * * NOUN cjel-3536 265 153 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 265 154 at at ADP cjel-3536 265 155 240–49 240–49 NUM cjel-3536 265 156 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 265 157 discussing discuss VERB cjel-3536 265 158 justice justice PROPN cjel-3536 265 159 scalia scalia PROPN cjel-3536 265 160 ’s ’s PART cjel-3536 265 161 strict strict ADJ cjel-3536 265 162 separation separation NOUN cjel-3536 265 163 of of ADP cjel-3536 265 164 powers power NOUN cjel-3536 265 165 approach approach VERB cjel-3536 265 166 to to ADP cjel-3536 265 167 standing stand VERB cjel-3536 265 168 in in ADP cjel-3536 265 169 general general ADJ cjel-3536 265 170 and and CCONJ cjel-3536 265 171 in in ADP cjel-3536 265 172 summers summer NOUN cjel-3536 265 173 and and CCONJ cjel-3536 265 174 lujan lujan NOUN cjel-3536 265 175 decisions decision NOUN cjel-3536 265 176 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 265 177 ; ; PUNCT cjel-3536 265 178 see see VERB cjel-3536 265 179 also also ADV cjel-3536 265 180 andrew andrew PROPN cjel-3536 265 181 c. c. PROPN cjel-3536 265 182 sand sand NOUN cjel-3536 265 183 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 265 184 standing stand VERB cjel-3536 265 185 uncertainty uncertainty NOUN cjel-3536 265 186 : : PUNCT cjel-3536 265 187 an an DET cjel-3536 265 188 expected expect VERB cjel-3536 265 189 - - PUNCT cjel-3536 265 190 value value NOUN cjel-3536 265 191 standard standard NOUN cjel-3536 265 192 for for ADP cjel-3536 265 193 fear fear NOUN cjel-3536 265 194 - - PUNCT cjel-3536 265 195 based base VERB cjel-3536 265 196 injury injury NOUN cjel-3536 265 197 in in ADP cjel-3536 265 198 clapper clapper NOUN cjel-3536 265 199 v. v. ADP cjel-3536 265 200 amnesty amnesty PROPN cjel-3536 265 201 international international PROPN cjel-3536 265 202 usa usa PROPN cjel-3536 265 203 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 265 204 113 113 NUM cjel-3536 265 205 mich mich X cjel-3536 265 206 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 266 1 l. l. PROPN cjel-3536 266 2 rev rev VERB cjel-3536 266 3 711 711 NUM cjel-3536 266 4 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 266 5 2015 2015 NUM cjel-3536 266 6 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 266 7 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 266 8 discussing discuss VERB cjel-3536 266 9 justice justice PROPN cjel-3536 266 10 scalia scalia PROPN cjel-3536 266 11 ’s ’s PART cjel-3536 266 12 stringent stringent ADJ cjel-3536 266 13 approach approach NOUN cjel-3536 266 14 to to ADP cjel-3536 266 15 standing stand VERB cjel-3536 266 16 in in ADP cjel-3536 266 17 fearbased fearbase VERB cjel-3536 266 18 and and CCONJ cjel-3536 266 19 environmental environmental ADJ cjel-3536 266 20 cases case NOUN cjel-3536 266 21 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 266 22 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 267 1 89 89 NUM cjel-3536 267 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 268 1 see see VERB cjel-3536 268 2 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 268 3 e.g. e.g. ADV cjel-3536 268 4 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 268 5 summers summer NOUN cjel-3536 268 6 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 268 7 555 555 NUM cjel-3536 268 8 u.s u.s PROPN cjel-3536 268 9 . . PROPN cjel-3536 268 10 at at ADP cjel-3536 268 11 505–10 505–10 PROPN cjel-3536 268 12 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 268 13 breyer breyer NOUN cjel-3536 268 14 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 268 15 j. j. PROPN cjel-3536 268 16 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 268 17 dissenting dissent VERB cjel-3536 268 18 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 268 19 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 268 20 proposing propose VERB cjel-3536 268 21 “ " PUNCT cjel-3536 268 22 realistic realistic ADJ cjel-3536 268 23 threat threat NOUN cjel-3536 268 24 ” " PUNCT cjel-3536 268 25 and and CCONJ cjel-3536 268 26 probabilistic probabilistic ADJ cjel-3536 268 27 approach approach NOUN cjel-3536 268 28 to to ADP cjel-3536 268 29 standing standing NOUN cjel-3536 268 30 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 268 31 ; ; PUNCT cjel-3536 268 32 mank mank NOUN cjel-3536 268 33 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 268 34 clapper clapper NOUN cjel-3536 268 35 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 268 36 supra supra PROPN cjel-3536 268 37 note note PROPN cjel-3536 268 38 * * NOUN cjel-3536 268 39 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 268 40 at at ADP cjel-3536 268 41 236–40 236–40 NUM cjel-3536 268 42 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 268 43 249–54 249–54 NUM cjel-3536 268 44 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 268 45 discussing discuss VERB cjel-3536 268 46 justice justice NOUN cjel-3536 268 47 breyer breyer NOUN cjel-3536 268 48 ’s ’s PART cjel-3536 268 49 probabilistic probabilistic ADJ cjel-3536 268 50 approach approach NOUN cjel-3536 268 51 to to ADP cjel-3536 268 52 standing stand VERB cjel-3536 268 53 in in ADP cjel-3536 268 54 general general ADJ cjel-3536 268 55 and and CCONJ cjel-3536 268 56 in in ADP cjel-3536 268 57 summers summer NOUN cjel-3536 268 58 and and CCONJ cjel-3536 268 59 clapper clapper NOUN cjel-3536 268 60 decisions decision NOUN cjel-3536 268 61 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 268 62 ; ; PUNCT cjel-3536 268 63 sand sand NOUN cjel-3536 268 64 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 268 65 supra supra PROPN cjel-3536 268 66 note note NOUN cjel-3536 268 67 89 89 NUM cjel-3536 268 68 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 268 69 discussing discuss VERB cjel-3536 268 70 justice justice NOUN cjel-3536 268 71 breyer breyer NOUN cjel-3536 268 72 ’s ’s PART cjel-3536 268 73 liberal liberal ADJ cjel-3536 268 74 approach approach NOUN cjel-3536 268 75 to to ADP cjel-3536 268 76 standing stand VERB cjel-3536 268 77 in in ADP cjel-3536 268 78 fear fear NOUN cjel-3536 268 79 - - PUNCT cjel-3536 268 80 based base VERB cjel-3536 268 81 and and CCONJ cjel-3536 268 82 environmental environmental ADJ cjel-3536 268 83 cases case NOUN cjel-3536 268 84 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 268 85 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 269 1 mank mank PROPN cjel-3536 269 2 - - PUNCT cjel-3536 269 3 macro-[final macro-[final PROPN cjel-3536 269 4 6 6 NUM cjel-3536 269 5 - - SYM cjel-3536 269 6 19 19 NUM cjel-3536 269 7 ] ] PUNCT cjel-3536 269 8 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 269 9 do do AUX cjel-3536 269 10 not not PART cjel-3536 269 11 delete delete VERB cjel-3536 269 12 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 269 13 6/22/2015 6/22/2015 NUM cjel-3536 269 14 11:45 11:45 NUM cjel-3536 269 15 pm pm NOUN cjel-3536 269 16 2015 2015 NUM cjel-3536 269 17 ] ] PUNCT cjel-3536 269 18 standing stand VERB cjel-3536 269 19 to to PART cjel-3536 269 20 view view VERB cjel-3536 269 21 other other ADJ cjel-3536 269 22 people people NOUN cjel-3536 269 23 ’s ’s PART cjel-3536 269 24 land land NOUN cjel-3536 269 25 321 321 NUM cjel-3536 269 26 appointed appoint VERB cjel-3536 269 27 by by ADP cjel-3536 269 28 democratic democratic ADJ cjel-3536 269 29 presidents president NOUN cjel-3536 269 30 a a DET cjel-3536 269 31 majority majority NOUN cjel-3536 269 32 on on ADP cjel-3536 269 33 the the DET cjel-3536 269 34 circuit.90 circuit.90 NOUN cjel-3536 269 35 accordingly accordingly ADV cjel-3536 269 36 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 269 37 how how SCONJ cjel-3536 269 38 the the DET cjel-3536 269 39 court court NOUN cjel-3536 269 40 addresses address VERB cjel-3536 269 41 the the DET cjel-3536 269 42 issue issue NOUN cjel-3536 269 43 might might AUX cjel-3536 269 44 depend depend VERB cjel-3536 269 45 upon upon SCONJ cjel-3536 269 46 future future ADJ cjel-3536 269 47 presidential presidential ADJ cjel-3536 269 48 appointments appointment NOUN cjel-3536 269 49 to to ADP cjel-3536 269 50 the the DET cjel-3536 269 51 court court NOUN cjel-3536 269 52 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 269 53 and and CCONJ cjel-3536 269 54 the the DET cjel-3536 269 55 effect effect NOUN cjel-3536 269 56 these these DET cjel-3536 269 57 appointments appointment NOUN cjel-3536 269 58 have have VERB cjel-3536 269 59 in in ADP cjel-3536 269 60 shifting shift VERB cjel-3536 269 61 it it PRON cjel-3536 269 62 towards towards ADP cjel-3536 269 63 either either CCONJ cjel-3536 269 64 the the DET cjel-3536 269 65 environmentalist environmentalist NOUN cjel-3536 269 66 or or CCONJ cjel-3536 269 67 property property NOUN cjel-3536 269 68 rights right NOUN cjel-3536 269 69 perspectives perspective NOUN cjel-3536 269 70 on on ADP cjel-3536 269 71 standing stand VERB cjel-3536 269 72 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 270 1 90 90 NUM cjel-3536 270 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3536 270 3 laross laross NOUN cjel-3536 270 4 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 270 5 supra supra PROPN cjel-3536 270 6 note note NOUN cjel-3536 270 7 2 2 NUM cjel-3536 270 8 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 270 9 discussing discuss VERB cjel-3536 270 10 concerns concern NOUN cjel-3536 270 11 of of ADP cjel-3536 270 12 “ " PUNCT cjel-3536 270 13 industry industry NOUN cjel-3536 270 14 attorney attorney NOUN cjel-3536 270 15 ” " PUNCT cjel-3536 270 16 and and CCONJ cjel-3536 270 17 “ " PUNCT cjel-3536 270 18 conservatives conservative NOUN cjel-3536 270 19 ” " PUNCT cjel-3536 270 20 that that PRON cjel-3536 270 21 president president PROPN cjel-3536 270 22 obama obama PROPN cjel-3536 270 23 ’s ’s PART cjel-3536 270 24 recent recent ADJ cjel-3536 270 25 appointments appointment NOUN cjel-3536 270 26 to to ADP cjel-3536 270 27 d.c d.c PROPN cjel-3536 270 28 . . PROPN cjel-3536 270 29 circuit circuit PROPN cjel-3536 270 30 have have AUX cjel-3536 270 31 shifted shift VERB cjel-3536 270 32 that that DET cjel-3536 270 33 court court NOUN cjel-3536 270 34 to to ADP cjel-3536 270 35 the the DET cjel-3536 270 36 left left NOUN cjel-3536 270 37 in in ADP cjel-3536 270 38 general general ADJ cjel-3536 270 39 and and CCONJ cjel-3536 270 40 especially especially ADV cjel-3536 270 41 to to ADP cjel-3536 270 42 more more ADV cjel-3536 270 43 liberalized liberalized ADJ cjel-3536 270 44 standing standing NOUN cjel-3536 270 45 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 270 46 ; ; PUNCT cjel-3536 270 47 see see VERB cjel-3536 270 48 generally generally ADV cjel-3536 270 49 jeffrey jeffrey PROPN cjel-3536 270 50 toobin toobin PROPN cjel-3536 270 51 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 270 52 the the DET cjel-3536 270 53 obama obama PROPN cjel-3536 270 54 brief brief NOUN cjel-3536 270 55 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 270 56 the the DET cjel-3536 270 57 new new ADJ cjel-3536 270 58 yorker yorker PROPN cjel-3536 270 59 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 270 60 oct oct PROPN cjel-3536 270 61 . . PROPN cjel-3536 270 62 27 27 NUM cjel-3536 270 63 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 270 64 2014 2014 NUM cjel-3536 270 65 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 270 66 at at ADP cjel-3536 270 67 24 24 NUM cjel-3536 270 68 , , PUNCT cjel-3536 270 69 available available ADJ cjel-3536 270 70 at at ADP cjel-3536 270 71 http://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2014/10/27/obama-brief http://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2014/10/27/obama-brief PROPN cjel-3536 271 1 [ [ X cjel-3536 271 2 http:// http:// PROPN cjel-3536 271 3 perma.cc/6dfz-6999 perma.cc/6dfz-6999 NOUN cjel-3536 271 4 ] ] PUNCT cjel-3536 271 5 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3536 271 6 arguing argue VERB cjel-3536 271 7 that that SCONJ cjel-3536 271 8 president president PROPN cjel-3536 271 9 obama obama PROPN cjel-3536 271 10 ’s ’s PART cjel-3536 271 11 recent recent ADJ cjel-3536 271 12 appointments appointment NOUN cjel-3536 271 13 to to ADP cjel-3536 271 14 d.c d.c PROPN cjel-3536 271 15 . . PROPN cjel-3536 271 16 circuit circuit PROPN cjel-3536 271 17 have have AUX cjel-3536 271 18 shifted shift VERB cjel-3536 271 19 that that DET cjel-3536 271 20 court court NOUN cjel-3536 271 21 to to ADP cjel-3536 271 22 the the DET cjel-3536 271 23 left left NOUN cjel-3536 271 24 in in ADP cjel-3536 271 25 general general ADJ cjel-3536 271 26 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3536 271 27 . . PUNCT