id sid tid token lemma pos cjel-3603 1 1 microsoft microsoft PROPN cjel-3603 1 2 word word PROPN cjel-3603 1 3 monahan monahan PROPN cjel-3603 1 4 - - PUNCT cjel-3603 1 5 macro-[final macro-[final PROPN cjel-3603 1 6 6 6 NUM cjel-3603 1 7 - - SYM cjel-3603 1 8 20 20 NUM cjel-3603 1 9 ] ] PUNCT cjel-3603 1 10 monahan monahan PROPN cjel-3603 1 11 - - PUNCT cjel-3603 1 12 macro-[final macro-[final PROPN cjel-3603 1 13 6 6 NUM cjel-3603 1 14 - - SYM cjel-3603 1 15 20 20 NUM cjel-3603 1 16 ] ] PUNCT cjel-3603 1 17 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 1 18 do do AUX cjel-3603 1 19 not not PART cjel-3603 1 20 delete delete VERB cjel-3603 1 21 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 1 22 6/22/2015 6/22/2015 NUM cjel-3603 1 23 11:53 11:53 NUM cjel-3603 1 24 pm pm NOUN cjel-3603 1 25 359 359 NUM cjel-3603 1 26 the the DET cjel-3603 1 27 navigational navigational ADJ cjel-3603 1 28 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 1 29 : : PUNCT cjel-3603 1 30 the the DET cjel-3603 1 31 role role NOUN cjel-3603 1 32 of of ADP cjel-3603 1 33 a a DET cjel-3603 1 34 categorical categorical ADJ cjel-3603 1 35 exception exception NOUN cjel-3603 1 36 within within ADP cjel-3603 1 37 a a DET cjel-3603 1 38 system system NOUN cjel-3603 1 39 of of ADP cjel-3603 1 40 ad ad NOUN cjel-3603 1 41 - - PUNCT cjel-3603 1 42 hoc hoc X cjel-3603 1 43 review review NOUN cjel-3603 1 44 eileen eileen PROPN cjel-3603 1 45 monahan monahan PROPN cjel-3603 1 46 * * PROPN cjel-3603 1 47 i. i. PROPN cjel-3603 1 48 introduction introduction NOUN cjel-3603 1 49 .......................................................................... .......................................................................... PUNCT cjel-3603 1 50 359 359 NUM cjel-3603 1 51     SPACE cjel-3603 1 52 ii ii PROPN cjel-3603 1 53 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 2 1 background background NOUN cjel-3603 2 2 ......................................................................... ......................................................................... PUNCT cjel-3603 3 1 361 361 NUM cjel-3603 3 2     SPACE cjel-3603 3 3 a. a. NOUN cjel-3603 3 4 the the DET cjel-3603 3 5 navigational navigational ADJ cjel-3603 3 6 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 3 7 ............................................ ............................................ PUNCT cjel-3603 3 8 361 361 NUM cjel-3603 3 9     SPACE cjel-3603 3 10 i. i. NOUN cjel-3603 3 11 development development NOUN cjel-3603 3 12 of of ADP cjel-3603 3 13 the the DET cjel-3603 3 14 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 3 15 ....................................... ....................................... PUNCT cjel-3603 3 16 361 361 NUM cjel-3603 3 17     SPACE cjel-3603 3 18 ii ii NOUN cjel-3603 3 19 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 4 1 scope scope NOUN cjel-3603 4 2 of of ADP cjel-3603 4 3 the the DET cjel-3603 4 4 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 4 5 .................................................. .................................................. PUNCT cjel-3603 5 1 361 361 NUM cjel-3603 5 2     SPACE cjel-3603 5 3 b. b. NOUN cjel-3603 5 4 limits limit NOUN cjel-3603 5 5 on on ADP cjel-3603 5 6 the the DET cjel-3603 5 7 navigational navigational ADJ cjel-3603 5 8 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 5 9 ............................. ............................. PUNCT cjel-3603 5 10 363 363 NUM cjel-3603 5 11     SPACE cjel-3603 5 12 i. i. NOUN cjel-3603 5 13 high high ADJ cjel-3603 5 14 - - PUNCT cjel-3603 5 15 water water NOUN cjel-3603 5 16 mark mark NOUN cjel-3603 5 17 .......................................................... .......................................................... PUNCT cjel-3603 5 18 363 363 NUM cjel-3603 5 19     SPACE cjel-3603 5 20 ii ii NOUN cjel-3603 5 21 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 6 1 navigable navigable ADJ cjel-3603 6 2 waterways waterway NOUN cjel-3603 6 3 .................................................. .................................................. PUNCT cjel-3603 7 1 363 363 NUM cjel-3603 7 2     SPACE cjel-3603 7 3 iii iii NOUN cjel-3603 7 4 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 7 5 easement easement PROPN cjel-3603 7 6 ..................................................................... ..................................................................... PUNCT cjel-3603 7 7 364 364 NUM cjel-3603 7 8     SPACE cjel-3603 7 9 iv iv NUM cjel-3603 7 10 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 7 11 express express VERB cjel-3603 7 12 authorization authorization NOUN cjel-3603 7 13 ................................................. ................................................. PUNCT cjel-3603 8 1 365 365 NUM cjel-3603 8 2     SPACE cjel-3603 8 3 v. v. ADP cjel-3603 8 4 the the DET cjel-3603 8 5 purpose purpose NOUN cjel-3603 8 6 to to PART cjel-3603 8 7 aid aid VERB cjel-3603 8 8 in in ADP cjel-3603 8 9 navigation navigation NOUN cjel-3603 8 10 ................................ ................................ PUNCT cjel-3603 8 11 366 366 NUM cjel-3603 8 12     SPACE cjel-3603 8 13 iii iii NOUN cjel-3603 8 14 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 9 1 the the DET cjel-3603 9 2 failures failure NOUN cjel-3603 9 3 of of ADP cjel-3603 9 4 the the DET cjel-3603 9 5 navigational navigational ADJ cjel-3603 9 6 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 9 7 ..................... ..................... PUNCT cjel-3603 9 8 369 369 NUM cjel-3603 9 9     SPACE cjel-3603 9 10 a. a. NOUN cjel-3603 9 11 the the DET cjel-3603 9 12 common common ADJ cjel-3603 9 13 law law NOUN cjel-3603 9 14 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 9 15 ........................................... ........................................... PUNCT cjel-3603 9 16 369 369 NUM cjel-3603 9 17     SPACE cjel-3603 9 18 b. b. NOUN cjel-3603 10 1 the the DET cjel-3603 10 2 rivers river NOUN cjel-3603 10 3 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 10 4 harbors harbor NOUN cjel-3603 10 5 act act VERB cjel-3603 10 6 ............................................ ............................................ PUNCT cjel-3603 10 7 373 373 NUM cjel-3603 10 8     SPACE cjel-3603 10 9 iv iv NOUN cjel-3603 10 10 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 11 1 applying apply VERB cjel-3603 11 2 the the DET cjel-3603 11 3 penn penn PROPN cjel-3603 11 4 central central PROPN cjel-3603 11 5 test test NOUN cjel-3603 11 6 to to ADP cjel-3603 11 7 the the DET cjel-3603 11 8 navigational navigational ADJ cjel-3603 11 9 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 11 10 ............................................................................. ............................................................................. PUNCT cjel-3603 11 11 376 376 NUM cjel-3603 11 12     SPACE cjel-3603 11 13 a. a. NOUN cjel-3603 11 14 the the DET cjel-3603 11 15 penn penn PROPN cjel-3603 11 16 central central PROPN cjel-3603 11 17 test test NOUN cjel-3603 11 18 : : PUNCT cjel-3603 11 19 an an DET cjel-3603 11 20 ad ad NOUN cjel-3603 11 21 hoc hoc X cjel-3603 11 22 approach approach NOUN cjel-3603 11 23 ............... ............... PUNCT cjel-3603 11 24 377 377 NUM cjel-3603 11 25     SPACE cjel-3603 11 26 b. b. NOUN cjel-3603 12 1 the the DET cjel-3603 12 2 lucas lucas PROPN cjel-3603 12 3 exception exception PROPN cjel-3603 12 4 : : PUNCT cjel-3603 12 5 recognition recognition NOUN cjel-3603 12 6 of of ADP cjel-3603 12 7 categorical categorical ADJ cjel-3603 12 8 exceptions exception NOUN cjel-3603 12 9 ....................................................................... ....................................................................... PUNCT cjel-3603 13 1 378 378 NUM cjel-3603 13 2     SPACE cjel-3603 13 3 c. c. NOUN cjel-3603 13 4 the the DET cjel-3603 13 5 typical typical ADJ cjel-3603 13 6 takings taking NOUN cjel-3603 13 7 case case NOUN cjel-3603 13 8 ............................................... ............................................... PUNCT cjel-3603 13 9 379 379 NUM cjel-3603 13 10     SPACE cjel-3603 13 11 d. d. NOUN cjel-3603 13 12 reformulating reformulate VERB cjel-3603 13 13 the the DET cjel-3603 13 14 doctrine doctrine NOUN cjel-3603 13 15 ............................................. ............................................. PUNCT cjel-3603 13 16 380 380 NUM cjel-3603 13 17     SPACE cjel-3603 13 18 v. v. ADP cjel-3603 13 19 conclusion conclusion NOUN cjel-3603 13 20 ............................................................................ ............................................................................ PUNCT cjel-3603 13 21 384 384 NUM cjel-3603 13 22     SPACE cjel-3603 13 23 i. i. NOUN cjel-3603 13 24 introduction introduction NOUN cjel-3603 13 25 the the DET cjel-3603 13 26 fifth fifth ADJ cjel-3603 13 27 amendment amendment NOUN cjel-3603 13 28 to to ADP cjel-3603 13 29 the the DET cjel-3603 13 30 united united PROPN cjel-3603 13 31 states states PROPN cjel-3603 13 32 constitution constitution PROPN cjel-3603 13 33 provides provide VERB cjel-3603 13 34 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 13 35 in in ADP cjel-3603 13 36 part part NOUN cjel-3603 13 37 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 13 38 that that SCONJ cjel-3603 13 39 private private ADJ cjel-3603 13 40 property property NOUN cjel-3603 13 41 shall shall AUX cjel-3603 13 42 not not PART cjel-3603 13 43 “ " PUNCT cjel-3603 13 44 be be AUX cjel-3603 13 45 taken take VERB cjel-3603 13 46 for for ADP cjel-3603 13 47 * * PROPN cjel-3603 13 48 j.d j.d PROPN cjel-3603 13 49 . . PROPN cjel-3603 13 50 2015 2015 NUM cjel-3603 13 51 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 13 52 columbia columbia PROPN cjel-3603 13 53 law law PROPN cjel-3603 13 54 school school NOUN cjel-3603 13 55 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 14 1 the the DET cjel-3603 14 2 author author NOUN cjel-3603 14 3 wishes wish VERB cjel-3603 14 4 to to PART cjel-3603 14 5 thank thank VERB cjel-3603 14 6 professor professor PROPN cjel-3603 14 7 thomas thomas PROPN cjel-3603 14 8 merrill merrill PROPN cjel-3603 14 9 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 14 10 as as ADV cjel-3603 14 11 well well ADV cjel-3603 14 12 as as ADP cjel-3603 14 13 the the DET cjel-3603 14 14 cjel cjel ADJ cjel-3603 14 15 staff staff NOUN cjel-3603 14 16 for for ADP cjel-3603 14 17 their their PRON cjel-3603 14 18 careful careful ADJ cjel-3603 14 19 editorial editorial ADJ cjel-3603 14 20 work work NOUN cjel-3603 14 21 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 15 1 monahan monahan PROPN cjel-3603 15 2 - - PUNCT cjel-3603 15 3 macro-[final macro-[final PROPN cjel-3603 15 4 6 6 NUM cjel-3603 15 5 - - SYM cjel-3603 15 6 20 20 NUM cjel-3603 15 7 ] ] PUNCT cjel-3603 15 8 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 15 9 do do AUX cjel-3603 15 10 not not PART cjel-3603 15 11 delete delete VERB cjel-3603 15 12 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 15 13 6/22/2015 6/22/2015 NUM cjel-3603 15 14 11:53 11:53 NUM cjel-3603 15 15 pm pm NOUN cjel-3603 15 16 360 360 NUM cjel-3603 15 17 columbia columbia PROPN cjel-3603 15 18 journal journal PROPN cjel-3603 15 19 of of ADP cjel-3603 15 20 environmental environmental ADJ cjel-3603 15 21 law law NOUN cjel-3603 16 1 [ [ X cjel-3603 16 2 vol vol NOUN cjel-3603 16 3 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 17 1 40:2 40:2 NUM cjel-3603 17 2 public public ADJ cjel-3603 17 3 use use NOUN cjel-3603 17 4 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 17 5 without without ADP cjel-3603 17 6 just just ADV cjel-3603 17 7 compensation compensation NOUN cjel-3603 17 8 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 17 9 ”1 ”1 PUNCT cjel-3603 18 1 known know VERB cjel-3603 18 2 as as ADP cjel-3603 18 3 the the DET cjel-3603 18 4 takings taking NOUN cjel-3603 18 5 clause clause NOUN cjel-3603 18 6 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 18 7 this this DET cjel-3603 18 8 provision provision NOUN cjel-3603 18 9 limiting limit VERB cjel-3603 18 10 the the DET cjel-3603 18 11 government government NOUN cjel-3603 18 12 ’s ’s PART cjel-3603 18 13 sovereign sovereign ADJ cjel-3603 18 14 power power NOUN cjel-3603 18 15 of of ADP cjel-3603 18 16 eminent eminent ADJ cjel-3603 18 17 domain domain NOUN cjel-3603 18 18 may may AUX cjel-3603 18 19 appear appear VERB cjel-3603 18 20 to to PART cjel-3603 18 21 be be AUX cjel-3603 18 22 straightforward straightforward ADJ cjel-3603 18 23 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 18 24 but but CCONJ cjel-3603 18 25 in in ADP cjel-3603 18 26 practice practice NOUN cjel-3603 18 27 is be AUX cjel-3603 18 28 not not PART cjel-3603 18 29 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 19 1 several several ADJ cjel-3603 19 2 categorical categorical ADJ cjel-3603 19 3 exceptions exception NOUN cjel-3603 19 4 to to ADP cjel-3603 19 5 this this DET cjel-3603 19 6 requirement requirement NOUN cjel-3603 19 7 have have AUX cjel-3603 19 8 developed develop VERB cjel-3603 19 9 over over ADP cjel-3603 19 10 time time NOUN cjel-3603 19 11 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 20 1 one one NUM cjel-3603 20 2 such such ADJ cjel-3603 20 3 categorical categorical ADJ cjel-3603 20 4 exception exception NOUN cjel-3603 20 5 is be AUX cjel-3603 20 6 the the DET cjel-3603 20 7 navigational navigational ADJ cjel-3603 20 8 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 20 9 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 20 10 which which PRON cjel-3603 20 11 allows allow VERB cjel-3603 20 12 the the DET cjel-3603 20 13 federal federal ADJ cjel-3603 20 14 government government NOUN cjel-3603 20 15 to to PART cjel-3603 20 16 exercise exercise VERB cjel-3603 20 17 its its PRON cjel-3603 20 18 power power NOUN cjel-3603 20 19 to to PART cjel-3603 20 20 regulate regulate VERB cjel-3603 20 21 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 20 22 control control VERB cjel-3603 20 23 the the DET cjel-3603 20 24 nation nation NOUN cjel-3603 20 25 ’s ’s PART cjel-3603 20 26 navigable navigable ADJ cjel-3603 20 27 waterways waterway NOUN cjel-3603 20 28 without without ADP cjel-3603 20 29 paying pay VERB cjel-3603 20 30 compensation compensation NOUN cjel-3603 20 31 for for ADP cjel-3603 20 32 the the DET cjel-3603 20 33 resulting result VERB cjel-3603 20 34 economic economic ADJ cjel-3603 20 35 loss loss NOUN cjel-3603 20 36 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 21 1 this this DET cjel-3603 21 2 note note NOUN cjel-3603 21 3 will will AUX cjel-3603 21 4 argue argue VERB cjel-3603 21 5 that that SCONJ cjel-3603 21 6 the the DET cjel-3603 21 7 availability availability NOUN cjel-3603 21 8 of of ADP cjel-3603 21 9 such such DET cjel-3603 21 10 a a DET cjel-3603 21 11 blanket blanket NOUN cjel-3603 21 12 exception exception NOUN cjel-3603 21 13 is be AUX cjel-3603 21 14 unjustifiable unjustifiable ADJ cjel-3603 21 15 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 22 1 first first ADV cjel-3603 22 2 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 22 3 it it PRON cjel-3603 22 4 creates create VERB cjel-3603 22 5 perverse perverse ADJ cjel-3603 22 6 incentives incentive NOUN cjel-3603 22 7 for for SCONJ cjel-3603 22 8 the the DET cjel-3603 22 9 government government NOUN cjel-3603 22 10 to to PART cjel-3603 22 11 disproportionately disproportionately ADV cjel-3603 22 12 take take VERB cjel-3603 22 13 littoral littoral ADJ cjel-3603 22 14 land land NOUN cjel-3603 22 15 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 22 16 produces produce VERB cjel-3603 22 17 inequitable inequitable ADJ cjel-3603 22 18 results result NOUN cjel-3603 22 19 for for ADP cjel-3603 22 20 landowners landowner NOUN cjel-3603 22 21 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 23 1 second second ADJ cjel-3603 23 2 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 23 3 historically historically ADV cjel-3603 23 4 based base VERB cjel-3603 23 5 in in ADP cjel-3603 23 6 the the DET cjel-3603 23 7 federal federal ADJ cjel-3603 23 8 government government NOUN cjel-3603 23 9 ’s ’s PART cjel-3603 23 10 power power NOUN cjel-3603 23 11 over over ADP cjel-3603 23 12 interstate interstate PROPN cjel-3603 23 13 commerce commerce PROPN cjel-3603 23 14 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 23 15 the the DET cjel-3603 23 16 policy policy NOUN cjel-3603 23 17 justifications justification NOUN cjel-3603 23 18 for for ADP cjel-3603 23 19 the the DET cjel-3603 23 20 navigational navigational ADJ cjel-3603 23 21 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 23 22 are be AUX cjel-3603 23 23 no no ADV cjel-3603 23 24 longer long ADV cjel-3603 23 25 compelling compelling ADJ cjel-3603 23 26 in in ADP cjel-3603 23 27 our our PRON cjel-3603 23 28 modern modern ADJ cjel-3603 23 29 economy economy NOUN cjel-3603 23 30 where where SCONJ cjel-3603 23 31 waterways waterway NOUN cjel-3603 23 32 are be AUX cjel-3603 23 33 not not PART cjel-3603 23 34 the the DET cjel-3603 23 35 vital vital ADJ cjel-3603 23 36 highways highway NOUN cjel-3603 23 37 of of ADP cjel-3603 23 38 commerce commerce NOUN cjel-3603 23 39 they they PRON cjel-3603 23 40 once once ADV cjel-3603 23 41 were be AUX cjel-3603 23 42 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 24 1 therefore therefore ADV cjel-3603 24 2 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 24 3 the the DET cjel-3603 24 4 navigational navigational ADJ cjel-3603 24 5 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 24 6 should should AUX cjel-3603 24 7 not not PART cjel-3603 24 8 be be AUX cjel-3603 24 9 an an DET cjel-3603 24 10 absolute absolute ADJ cjel-3603 24 11 defense defense NOUN cjel-3603 24 12 to to ADP cjel-3603 24 13 taking take VERB cjel-3603 24 14 claims claim NOUN cjel-3603 24 15 anymore anymore ADV cjel-3603 24 16 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 25 1 instead instead ADV cjel-3603 25 2 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 25 3 such such ADJ cjel-3603 25 4 claims claim NOUN cjel-3603 25 5 should should AUX cjel-3603 25 6 be be AUX cjel-3603 25 7 analyzed analyze VERB cjel-3603 25 8 within within ADP cjel-3603 25 9 the the DET cjel-3603 25 10 fact fact NOUN cjel-3603 25 11 - - PUNCT cjel-3603 25 12 specific specific ADJ cjel-3603 25 13 framework framework NOUN cjel-3603 25 14 that that PRON cjel-3603 25 15 applies apply VERB cjel-3603 25 16 to to ADP cjel-3603 25 17 takings taking NOUN cjel-3603 25 18 that that PRON cjel-3603 25 19 occur occur VERB cjel-3603 25 20 on on ADP cjel-3603 25 21 land land NOUN cjel-3603 25 22 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 25 23 in in ADP cjel-3603 25 24 non non ADJ cjel-3603 25 25 - - ADJ cjel-3603 25 26 navigable navigable ADJ cjel-3603 25 27 waterways waterway NOUN cjel-3603 25 28 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 26 1 such such DET cjel-3603 26 2 an an DET cjel-3603 26 3 analysis analysis NOUN cjel-3603 26 4 can can AUX cjel-3603 26 5 limit limit VERB cjel-3603 26 6 the the DET cjel-3603 26 7 draconian draconian ADJ cjel-3603 26 8 nature nature NOUN cjel-3603 26 9 of of ADP cjel-3603 26 10 the the DET cjel-3603 26 11 current current ADJ cjel-3603 26 12 navigational navigational ADJ cjel-3603 26 13 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 26 14 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 26 15 encourage encourage VERB cjel-3603 26 16 the the DET cjel-3603 26 17 federal federal ADJ cjel-3603 26 18 government government NOUN cjel-3603 26 19 ’s ’s PART cjel-3603 26 20 equitable equitable ADJ cjel-3603 26 21 use use NOUN cjel-3603 26 22 thereof thereof ADV cjel-3603 26 23 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 27 1 part part NOUN cjel-3603 27 2 ii ii PROPN cjel-3603 27 3 of of ADP cjel-3603 27 4 this this DET cjel-3603 27 5 note note NOUN cjel-3603 27 6 will will AUX cjel-3603 27 7 discuss discuss VERB cjel-3603 27 8 how how SCONJ cjel-3603 27 9 the the DET cjel-3603 27 10 navigational navigational ADJ cjel-3603 27 11 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 27 12 emerged emerge VERB cjel-3603 27 13 from from ADP cjel-3603 27 14 the the DET cjel-3603 27 15 commerce commerce NOUN cjel-3603 27 16 clause clause NOUN cjel-3603 27 17 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 27 18 the the DET cjel-3603 27 19 different different ADJ cjel-3603 27 20 elements element NOUN cjel-3603 27 21 of of ADP cjel-3603 27 22 the the DET cjel-3603 27 23 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 27 24 that that PRON cjel-3603 27 25 have have AUX cjel-3603 27 26 developed develop VERB cjel-3603 27 27 over over ADP cjel-3603 27 28 time time NOUN cjel-3603 27 29 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 28 1 part part NOUN cjel-3603 28 2 iii iii PRON cjel-3603 28 3 will will AUX cjel-3603 28 4 describe describe VERB cjel-3603 28 5 the the DET cjel-3603 28 6 limits limit NOUN cjel-3603 28 7 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 28 8 faults fault NOUN cjel-3603 28 9 of of ADP cjel-3603 28 10 the the DET cjel-3603 28 11 application application NOUN cjel-3603 28 12 of of ADP cjel-3603 28 13 the the DET cjel-3603 28 14 navigational navigational ADJ cjel-3603 28 15 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 28 16 in in ADP cjel-3603 28 17 the the DET cjel-3603 28 18 takings taking NOUN cjel-3603 28 19 context context NOUN cjel-3603 28 20 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 29 1 part part NOUN cjel-3603 29 2 iv iv PRON cjel-3603 29 3 will will AUX cjel-3603 29 4 discuss discuss VERB cjel-3603 29 5 the the DET cjel-3603 29 6 ad ad NOUN cjel-3603 29 7 - - PUNCT cjel-3603 29 8 hoc hoc ADJ cjel-3603 29 9 analysis analysis NOUN cjel-3603 29 10 courts court NOUN cjel-3603 29 11 employ employ VERB cjel-3603 29 12 in in ADP cjel-3603 29 13 takings taking NOUN cjel-3603 29 14 cases case NOUN cjel-3603 29 15 where where SCONJ cjel-3603 29 16 the the DET cjel-3603 29 17 navigational navigational ADJ cjel-3603 29 18 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 29 19 is be AUX cjel-3603 29 20 not not PART cjel-3603 29 21 available available ADJ cjel-3603 29 22 as as ADP cjel-3603 29 23 a a DET cjel-3603 29 24 categorical categorical ADJ cjel-3603 29 25 defense defense NOUN cjel-3603 29 26 to to ADP cjel-3603 29 27 a a DET cjel-3603 29 28 taking taking NOUN cjel-3603 29 29 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 30 1 ultimately ultimately ADV cjel-3603 30 2 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 30 3 this this DET cjel-3603 30 4 note note NOUN cjel-3603 30 5 will will AUX cjel-3603 30 6 argue argue VERB cjel-3603 30 7 that that SCONJ cjel-3603 30 8 application application NOUN cjel-3603 30 9 of of ADP cjel-3603 30 10 this this DET cjel-3603 30 11 ad ad NOUN cjel-3603 30 12 - - PUNCT cjel-3603 30 13 hoc hoc X cjel-3603 30 14 review review NOUN cjel-3603 30 15 would would AUX cjel-3603 30 16 be be AUX cjel-3603 30 17 a a DET cjel-3603 30 18 more more ADV cjel-3603 30 19 appropriate appropriate ADJ cjel-3603 30 20 analytical analytical ADJ cjel-3603 30 21 tool tool NOUN cjel-3603 30 22 for for ADP cjel-3603 30 23 takings taking NOUN cjel-3603 30 24 claims claim NOUN cjel-3603 30 25 that that PRON cjel-3603 30 26 involve involve VERB cjel-3603 30 27 the the DET cjel-3603 30 28 government government NOUN cjel-3603 30 29 ’s ’s PART cjel-3603 30 30 power power NOUN cjel-3603 30 31 over over ADP cjel-3603 30 32 navigation navigation NOUN cjel-3603 30 33 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 31 1 1 1 X cjel-3603 31 2 . . X cjel-3603 31 3 u.s u.s PROPN cjel-3603 31 4 . . PROPN cjel-3603 31 5 const const PROPN cjel-3603 31 6 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 32 1 amend amend PROPN cjel-3603 32 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 33 1 v. v. ADP cjel-3603 33 2 monahan monahan PROPN cjel-3603 33 3 - - PUNCT cjel-3603 33 4 macro-[final macro-[final PROPN cjel-3603 33 5 6 6 NUM cjel-3603 33 6 - - SYM cjel-3603 33 7 20 20 NUM cjel-3603 33 8 ] ] PUNCT cjel-3603 33 9 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 33 10 do do AUX cjel-3603 33 11 not not PART cjel-3603 33 12 delete delete VERB cjel-3603 33 13 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 33 14 6/22/2015 6/22/2015 NUM cjel-3603 33 15 11:53 11:53 NUM cjel-3603 33 16 pm pm NOUN cjel-3603 33 17 2015 2015 NUM cjel-3603 33 18 ] ] PUNCT cjel-3603 33 19 the the DET cjel-3603 33 20 navigational navigational ADJ cjel-3603 33 21 servitude servitude ADJ cjel-3603 33 22 361 361 NUM cjel-3603 33 23 ii ii NOUN cjel-3603 33 24 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 33 25 background background PROPN cjel-3603 33 26 a. a. NOUN cjel-3603 34 1 the the DET cjel-3603 34 2 navigational navigational ADJ cjel-3603 34 3 servitude servitude ADJ cjel-3603 34 4 i. i. NOUN cjel-3603 34 5 development development NOUN cjel-3603 34 6 of of ADP cjel-3603 34 7 the the DET cjel-3603 34 8 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 34 9 although although SCONJ cjel-3603 34 10 the the DET cjel-3603 34 11 takings taking NOUN cjel-3603 34 12 clause clause NOUN cjel-3603 34 13 is be AUX cjel-3603 34 14 part part NOUN cjel-3603 34 15 of of ADP cjel-3603 34 16 the the DET cjel-3603 34 17 fifth fifth ADJ cjel-3603 34 18 amendment amendment NOUN cjel-3603 34 19 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 34 20 the the DET cjel-3603 34 21 navigational navigational ADJ cjel-3603 34 22 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 34 23 emerged emerge VERB cjel-3603 34 24 from from ADP cjel-3603 34 25 the the DET cjel-3603 34 26 commerce commerce NOUN cjel-3603 34 27 clause clause NOUN cjel-3603 34 28 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 34 29 which which PRON cjel-3603 34 30 is be AUX cjel-3603 34 31 found find VERB cjel-3603 34 32 in in ADP cjel-3603 34 33 article article NOUN cjel-3603 34 34 i i PRON cjel-3603 34 35 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 34 36 section section NOUN cjel-3603 34 37 8 8 NUM cjel-3603 34 38 of of ADP cjel-3603 34 39 the the DET cjel-3603 34 40 constitution constitution NOUN cjel-3603 34 41 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 35 1 the the DET cjel-3603 35 2 commerce commerce NOUN cjel-3603 35 3 clause clause NOUN cjel-3603 35 4 gives give VERB cjel-3603 35 5 to to PART cjel-3603 35 6 congress congress VERB cjel-3603 35 7 the the DET cjel-3603 35 8 power power NOUN cjel-3603 35 9 to to PART cjel-3603 35 10 “ " PUNCT cjel-3603 35 11 regulate regulate VERB cjel-3603 35 12 commerce commerce NOUN cjel-3603 35 13 with with ADP cjel-3603 35 14 foreign foreign ADJ cjel-3603 35 15 nations nation NOUN cjel-3603 35 16 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 35 17 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 35 18 among among ADP cjel-3603 35 19 the the DET cjel-3603 35 20 several several ADJ cjel-3603 35 21 states state NOUN cjel-3603 35 22 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 35 23 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 35 24 with with ADP cjel-3603 35 25 the the DET cjel-3603 35 26 indian indian ADJ cjel-3603 35 27 tribes tribe NOUN cjel-3603 35 28 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 35 29 ”2 ”2 PUNCT cjel-3603 36 1 in in ADP cjel-3603 36 2 1824 1824 NUM cjel-3603 36 3 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 36 4 the the DET cjel-3603 36 5 supreme supreme PROPN cjel-3603 36 6 court court PROPN cjel-3603 36 7 heard hear VERB cjel-3603 36 8 gibbons gibbon NOUN cjel-3603 36 9 v. v. ADP cjel-3603 36 10 ogden ogden PROPN cjel-3603 36 11 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 36 12 the the DET cjel-3603 36 13 case case NOUN cjel-3603 36 14 often often ADV cjel-3603 36 15 cited cite VERB cjel-3603 36 16 as as ADP cjel-3603 36 17 paving pave VERB cjel-3603 36 18 the the DET cjel-3603 36 19 way way NOUN cjel-3603 36 20 for for ADP cjel-3603 36 21 the the DET cjel-3603 36 22 development development NOUN cjel-3603 36 23 of of ADP cjel-3603 36 24 the the DET cjel-3603 36 25 navigational navigational ADJ cjel-3603 36 26 servitude.3 servitude.3 NOUN cjel-3603 36 27 in in ADP cjel-3603 36 28 this this DET cjel-3603 36 29 case case NOUN cjel-3603 36 30 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 36 31 the the DET cjel-3603 36 32 court court NOUN cjel-3603 36 33 held hold VERB cjel-3603 36 34 that that SCONJ cjel-3603 36 35 congress congress PROPN cjel-3603 36 36 ’ ' PUNCT cjel-3603 36 37 power power NOUN cjel-3603 36 38 to to PART cjel-3603 36 39 regulate regulate VERB cjel-3603 36 40 commerce commerce NOUN cjel-3603 36 41 among among ADP cjel-3603 36 42 the the DET cjel-3603 36 43 states state NOUN cjel-3603 36 44 gave give VERB cjel-3603 36 45 it it PRON cjel-3603 36 46 power power NOUN cjel-3603 36 47 over over ADP cjel-3603 36 48 the the DET cjel-3603 36 49 nation nation NOUN cjel-3603 36 50 ’s ’s PART cjel-3603 36 51 navigable navigable ADJ cjel-3603 37 1 waterways.4 waterways.4 SCONJ cjel-3603 37 2 gibbons gibbon NOUN cjel-3603 37 3 concerned concern VERB cjel-3603 37 4 a a DET cjel-3603 37 5 conflict conflict NOUN cjel-3603 37 6 between between ADP cjel-3603 37 7 state state NOUN cjel-3603 37 8 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 37 9 federal federal ADJ cjel-3603 37 10 laws law NOUN cjel-3603 37 11 regulating regulate VERB cjel-3603 37 12 steamships steamship NOUN cjel-3603 37 13 on on ADP cjel-3603 37 14 the the DET cjel-3603 37 15 hudson hudson PROPN cjel-3603 37 16 river river PROPN cjel-3603 37 17 in in ADP cjel-3603 37 18 new new ADJ cjel-3603 37 19 york.5 york.5 NOUN cjel-3603 37 20 the the DET cjel-3603 37 21 court court NOUN cjel-3603 37 22 invalidated invalidate VERB cjel-3603 37 23 a a DET cjel-3603 37 24 new new PROPN cjel-3603 37 25 york york PROPN cjel-3603 37 26 statute statute NOUN cjel-3603 37 27 that that PRON cjel-3603 37 28 created create VERB cjel-3603 37 29 a a DET cjel-3603 37 30 steamboat steamboat NOUN cjel-3603 37 31 monopoly monopoly NOUN cjel-3603 37 32 within within ADP cjel-3603 37 33 the the DET cjel-3603 37 34 state state NOUN cjel-3603 37 35 on on ADP cjel-3603 37 36 the the DET cjel-3603 37 37 grounds ground NOUN cjel-3603 37 38 that that SCONJ cjel-3603 37 39 it it PRON cjel-3603 37 40 contradicted contradict VERB cjel-3603 37 41 the the DET cjel-3603 37 42 federal federal ADJ cjel-3603 37 43 navigation navigation NOUN cjel-3603 37 44 act.6 act.6 PROPN cjel-3603 37 45 at at ADP cjel-3603 37 46 the the DET cjel-3603 37 47 time time NOUN cjel-3603 37 48 of of ADP cjel-3603 37 49 the the DET cjel-3603 37 50 decision decision NOUN cjel-3603 37 51 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 37 52 the the DET cjel-3603 37 53 court court NOUN cjel-3603 37 54 declared declare VERB cjel-3603 37 55 that that SCONJ cjel-3603 37 56 “ " PUNCT cjel-3603 37 57 [ [ X cjel-3603 37 58 a]ll a]ll PRON cjel-3603 37 59 america america PROPN cjel-3603 37 60 understands understand VERB cjel-3603 37 61 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 37 62 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 37 63 has have AUX cjel-3603 37 64 uniformly uniformly ADV cjel-3603 37 65 understood understand VERB cjel-3603 37 66 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 37 67 the the DET cjel-3603 37 68 word word NOUN cjel-3603 37 69 ‘ ' PUNCT cjel-3603 37 70 commerce commerce NOUN cjel-3603 37 71 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 37 72 ’ ' PUNCT cjel-3603 37 73 to to PART cjel-3603 37 74 comprehend comprehend VERB cjel-3603 37 75 navigation navigation NOUN cjel-3603 37 76 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 37 77 ”7 ”7 PUNCT cjel-3603 38 1 this this PRON cjel-3603 38 2 firmly firmly ADV cjel-3603 38 3 established establish VERB cjel-3603 38 4 that that SCONJ cjel-3603 38 5 power power NOUN cjel-3603 38 6 over over ADP cjel-3603 38 7 navigation navigation NOUN cjel-3603 38 8 was be AUX cjel-3603 38 9 essential essential ADJ cjel-3603 38 10 to to ADP cjel-3603 38 11 congress congress PROPN cjel-3603 38 12 ’ ' PUNCT cjel-3603 38 13 power power NOUN cjel-3603 38 14 over over ADP cjel-3603 38 15 commerce commerce NOUN cjel-3603 38 16 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 39 1 no no DET cjel-3603 39 2 takings taking NOUN cjel-3603 39 3 claims claim NOUN cjel-3603 39 4 or or CCONJ cjel-3603 39 5 property property NOUN cjel-3603 39 6 rights right NOUN cjel-3603 39 7 issues issue NOUN cjel-3603 39 8 were be AUX cjel-3603 39 9 raised raise VERB cjel-3603 39 10 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 40 1 ii ii X cjel-3603 40 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 41 1 scope scope NOUN cjel-3603 41 2 of of ADP cjel-3603 41 3 the the DET cjel-3603 41 4 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 41 5 this this DET cjel-3603 41 6 power power NOUN cjel-3603 41 7 over over ADP cjel-3603 41 8 navigation navigation NOUN cjel-3603 41 9 eventually eventually ADV cjel-3603 41 10 grew grow VERB cjel-3603 41 11 into into ADP cjel-3603 41 12 a a DET cjel-3603 41 13 property property NOUN cjel-3603 41 14 right right NOUN cjel-3603 41 15 to to ADP cjel-3603 41 16 which which PRON cjel-3603 41 17 all all DET cjel-3603 41 18 lands land NOUN cjel-3603 41 19 under under ADP cjel-3603 41 20 the the DET cjel-3603 41 21 high high ADJ cjel-3603 41 22 - - PUNCT cjel-3603 41 23 water water NOUN cjel-3603 41 24 line line NOUN cjel-3603 41 25 of of ADP cjel-3603 41 26 a a DET cjel-3603 41 27 navigable navigable ADJ cjel-3603 41 28 waterway waterway NOUN cjel-3603 41 29 are be AUX cjel-3603 41 30 subject subject ADJ cjel-3603 41 31 : : PUNCT cjel-3603 41 32 the the DET cjel-3603 41 33 navigational navigational ADJ cjel-3603 41 34 servitude.8 servitude.8 NOUN cjel-3603 41 35 2 2 NUM cjel-3603 41 36 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 41 37 u.s u.s PROPN cjel-3603 41 38 . . PROPN cjel-3603 41 39 const const PROPN cjel-3603 41 40 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 42 1 art art NOUN cjel-3603 42 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 43 1 i i PRON cjel-3603 43 2 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 43 3 § § PROPN cjel-3603 43 4 8 8 NUM cjel-3603 43 5 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 43 6 cl cl NOUN cjel-3603 43 7 . . NOUN cjel-3603 44 1 3 3 NUM cjel-3603 44 2 . . NOUN cjel-3603 44 3 3 3 NUM cjel-3603 44 4 . . X cjel-3603 45 1 gibbons gibbon NOUN cjel-3603 45 2 v. v. ADP cjel-3603 45 3 ogden ogden PROPN cjel-3603 45 4 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 45 5 22 22 NUM cjel-3603 45 6 u.s u.s PROPN cjel-3603 45 7 . . PROPN cjel-3603 45 8 1 1 NUM cjel-3603 45 9 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 45 10 1824 1824 NUM cjel-3603 45 11 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 45 12 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 46 1 4 4 X cjel-3603 46 2 . . X cjel-3603 47 1 i i PRON cjel-3603 47 2 d. d. PROPN cjel-3603 47 3 5 5 NUM cjel-3603 47 4 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 48 1 i i PRON cjel-3603 48 2 d. d. PROPN cjel-3603 48 3 6 6 NUM cjel-3603 48 4 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 49 1 i i PRON cjel-3603 49 2 d. d. PROPN cjel-3603 49 3 ; ; PUNCT cjel-3603 49 4 see see VERB cjel-3603 49 5 generally generally ADV cjel-3603 49 6 norman norman PROPN cjel-3603 49 7 r. r. PROPN cjel-3603 49 8 williams williams PROPN cjel-3603 49 9 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 49 10 the the DET cjel-3603 49 11 dormant dormant PROPN cjel-3603 49 12 commerce commerce PROPN cjel-3603 49 13 clause clause NOUN cjel-3603 49 14 : : PUNCT cjel-3603 49 15 why why SCONJ cjel-3603 49 16 gibbons gibbon NOUN cjel-3603 49 17 v. v. ADP cjel-3603 49 18 ogden ogden PROPN cjel-3603 49 19 should should AUX cjel-3603 49 20 be be AUX cjel-3603 49 21 restored restore VERB cjel-3603 49 22 to to ADP cjel-3603 49 23 the the DET cjel-3603 49 24 canon canon NOUN cjel-3603 49 25 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 49 26 49 49 NUM cjel-3603 49 27 st st PROPN cjel-3603 49 28 . . PROPN cjel-3603 49 29 louis louis PROPN cjel-3603 49 30 u. u. PROPN cjel-3603 49 31 l.j l.j PROPN cjel-3603 49 32 . . PROPN cjel-3603 49 33 817 817 NUM cjel-3603 49 34 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 49 35 820 820 NUM cjel-3603 49 36 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 49 37 2005 2005 NUM cjel-3603 49 38 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 49 39 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 50 1 7 7 X cjel-3603 50 2 . . X cjel-3603 50 3 gibbons gibbon NOUN cjel-3603 50 4 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 50 5 22 22 NUM cjel-3603 50 6 u.s u.s PROPN cjel-3603 50 7 . . PROPN cjel-3603 50 8 at at ADP cjel-3603 50 9 190 190 NUM cjel-3603 50 10 . . NOUN cjel-3603 50 11 8 8 NUM cjel-3603 50 12 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 50 13 united united PROPN cjel-3603 50 14 states states PROPN cjel-3603 50 15 v. v. ADP cjel-3603 50 16 30.54 30.54 NUM cjel-3603 50 17 acres acre NOUN cjel-3603 50 18 of of ADP cjel-3603 50 19 land land NOUN cjel-3603 50 20 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 50 21 90 90 NUM cjel-3603 50 22 f.3d f.3d NUM cjel-3603 50 23 790 790 NUM cjel-3603 50 24 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 50 25 793 793 NUM cjel-3603 50 26 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 50 27 3rd 3rd ADJ cjel-3603 50 28 cir cir NOUN cjel-3603 50 29 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 50 30 1996 1996 NUM cjel-3603 50 31 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 50 32 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 50 33 “ " PUNCT cjel-3603 50 34 but but CCONJ cjel-3603 50 35 the the DET cjel-3603 50 36 united united PROPN cjel-3603 50 37 states states PROPN cjel-3603 50 38 is be AUX cjel-3603 50 39 not not PART cjel-3603 50 40 constitutionally constitutionally ADV cjel-3603 50 41 required require VERB cjel-3603 50 42 to to PART cjel-3603 50 43 pay pay VERB cjel-3603 50 44 for for ADP cjel-3603 50 45 economic economic ADJ cjel-3603 50 46 losses loss NOUN cjel-3603 50 47 resulting result VERB cjel-3603 50 48 from from ADP cjel-3603 50 49 the the DET cjel-3603 50 50 exercise exercise NOUN cjel-3603 50 51 of of ADP cjel-3603 50 52 its its PRON cjel-3603 50 53 ‘ ' PUNCT cjel-3603 50 54 navigational navigational ADJ cjel-3603 50 55 ’ ' PUNCT cjel-3603 50 56 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 50 57 — — PUNCT cjel-3603 50 58 its its PRON cjel-3603 50 59 power power NOUN cjel-3603 50 60 to to PART cjel-3603 50 61 regulate regulate VERB cjel-3603 50 62 the the DET cjel-3603 50 63 use use NOUN cjel-3603 50 64 of of ADP cjel-3603 50 65 navigable navigable ADJ cjel-3603 50 66 monahan monahan PROPN cjel-3603 50 67 - - PUNCT cjel-3603 50 68 macro-[final macro-[final PROPN cjel-3603 50 69 6 6 NUM cjel-3603 50 70 - - SYM cjel-3603 50 71 20 20 NUM cjel-3603 50 72 ] ] PUNCT cjel-3603 50 73 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 50 74 do do AUX cjel-3603 50 75 not not PART cjel-3603 50 76 delete delete VERB cjel-3603 50 77 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 50 78 6/22/2015 6/22/2015 NUM cjel-3603 50 79 11:53 11:53 NUM cjel-3603 50 80 pm pm NOUN cjel-3603 50 81 362 362 NUM cjel-3603 50 82 columbia columbia PROPN cjel-3603 50 83 journal journal PROPN cjel-3603 50 84 of of ADP cjel-3603 50 85 environmental environmental ADJ cjel-3603 50 86 law law NOUN cjel-3603 51 1 [ [ X cjel-3603 51 2 vol vol NOUN cjel-3603 51 3 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 52 1 40:2 40:2 NUM cjel-3603 52 2 in in ADP cjel-3603 52 3 united united PROPN cjel-3603 52 4 states states PROPN cjel-3603 52 5 v. v. ADP cjel-3603 52 6 rands,9 rands,9 NOUN cjel-3603 52 7 the the DET cjel-3603 52 8 supreme supreme PROPN cjel-3603 52 9 court court PROPN cjel-3603 52 10 explained explain VERB cjel-3603 52 11 that that SCONJ cjel-3603 52 12 when when SCONJ cjel-3603 52 13 congress congress PROPN cjel-3603 52 14 exercises exercise VERB cjel-3603 52 15 its its PRON cjel-3603 52 16 right right NOUN cjel-3603 52 17 to to PART cjel-3603 52 18 regulate regulate VERB cjel-3603 52 19 navigation navigation NOUN cjel-3603 52 20 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 52 21 it it PRON cjel-3603 52 22 is be AUX cjel-3603 52 23 not not PART cjel-3603 52 24 an an DET cjel-3603 52 25 invasion invasion NOUN cjel-3603 52 26 of of ADP cjel-3603 52 27 any any DET cjel-3603 52 28 private private ADJ cjel-3603 52 29 property property NOUN cjel-3603 52 30 rights right NOUN cjel-3603 52 31 in in ADP cjel-3603 52 32 the the DET cjel-3603 52 33 stream stream NOUN cjel-3603 52 34 or or CCONJ cjel-3603 52 35 the the DET cjel-3603 52 36 lands land NOUN cjel-3603 52 37 underlying underlie VERB cjel-3603 52 38 it it PRON cjel-3603 52 39 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 52 40 for for SCONJ cjel-3603 52 41 the the DET cjel-3603 52 42 damage damage NOUN cjel-3603 52 43 sustained sustain VERB cjel-3603 52 44 does do AUX cjel-3603 52 45 not not PART cjel-3603 52 46 result result VERB cjel-3603 52 47 from from ADP cjel-3603 52 48 taking take VERB cjel-3603 52 49 property property NOUN cjel-3603 52 50 from from ADP cjel-3603 52 51 riparian riparian ADJ cjel-3603 52 52 owners owner NOUN cjel-3603 52 53 within within ADP cjel-3603 52 54 the the DET cjel-3603 52 55 meaning meaning NOUN cjel-3603 52 56 of of ADP cjel-3603 52 57 the the DET cjel-3603 52 58 fifth fifth ADJ cjel-3603 52 59 amendment amendment NOUN cjel-3603 52 60 but but CCONJ cjel-3603 52 61 from from ADP cjel-3603 52 62 the the DET cjel-3603 52 63 lawful lawful ADJ cjel-3603 52 64 exercise exercise NOUN cjel-3603 52 65 of of ADP cjel-3603 52 66 a a DET cjel-3603 52 67 power power NOUN cjel-3603 52 68 to to PART cjel-3603 52 69 which which PRON cjel-3603 52 70 the the DET cjel-3603 52 71 interests interest NOUN cjel-3603 52 72 of of ADP cjel-3603 52 73 riparian riparian ADJ cjel-3603 52 74 owners owner NOUN cjel-3603 52 75 have have AUX cjel-3603 52 76 always always ADV cjel-3603 52 77 been be AUX cjel-3603 52 78 subject subject ADJ cjel-3603 52 79 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 53 1 thus thus ADV cjel-3603 53 2 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 53 3 without without ADP cjel-3603 53 4 being be AUX cjel-3603 53 5 constitutionally constitutionally ADV cjel-3603 53 6 obligated obligate VERB cjel-3603 53 7 to to PART cjel-3603 53 8 pay pay VERB cjel-3603 53 9 compensation compensation NOUN cjel-3603 53 10 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 53 11 the the DET cjel-3603 53 12 united united PROPN cjel-3603 53 13 states states PROPN cjel-3603 53 14 may may AUX cjel-3603 53 15 change change VERB cjel-3603 53 16 the the DET cjel-3603 53 17 course course NOUN cjel-3603 53 18 of of ADP cjel-3603 53 19 a a DET cjel-3603 53 20 navigable navigable ADJ cjel-3603 53 21 stream stream NOUN cjel-3603 53 22 or or CCONJ cjel-3603 53 23 otherwise otherwise ADV cjel-3603 53 24 impair impair VERB cjel-3603 53 25 or or CCONJ cjel-3603 53 26 destroy destroy VERB cjel-3603 53 27 a a DET cjel-3603 53 28 riparian riparian ADJ cjel-3603 53 29 owner owner NOUN cjel-3603 53 30 ’s ’s PART cjel-3603 53 31 access access NOUN cjel-3603 53 32 to to ADP cjel-3603 53 33 navigable navigable ADJ cjel-3603 53 34 waters water NOUN cjel-3603 53 35 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 53 36 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 54 1 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 55 1 .10 .10 NUM cjel-3603 55 2 thus thus ADV cjel-3603 55 3 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 55 4 the the DET cjel-3603 55 5 navigational navigational ADJ cjel-3603 55 6 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 55 7 makes make VERB cjel-3603 55 8 all all DET cjel-3603 55 9 federal federal ADJ cjel-3603 55 10 actions action NOUN cjel-3603 55 11 affecting affect VERB cjel-3603 55 12 land land NOUN cjel-3603 55 13 under under ADP cjel-3603 55 14 the the DET cjel-3603 55 15 high high ADJ cjel-3603 55 16 - - PUNCT cjel-3603 55 17 water water NOUN cjel-3603 55 18 mark mark NOUN cjel-3603 55 19 immune immune ADJ cjel-3603 55 20 to to ADP cjel-3603 55 21 the the DET cjel-3603 55 22 just just ADJ cjel-3603 55 23 compensation compensation NOUN cjel-3603 55 24 requirements requirement NOUN cjel-3603 55 25 of of ADP cjel-3603 55 26 the the DET cjel-3603 55 27 takings taking NOUN cjel-3603 55 28 clause clause NOUN cjel-3603 55 29 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 56 1 no no DET cjel-3603 56 2 taking taking NOUN cjel-3603 56 3 can can AUX cjel-3603 56 4 occur occur VERB cjel-3603 56 5 because because SCONJ cjel-3603 56 6 the the DET cjel-3603 56 7 land land NOUN cjel-3603 56 8 below below ADP cjel-3603 56 9 the the DET cjel-3603 56 10 high high ADJ cjel-3603 56 11 - - PUNCT cjel-3603 56 12 water water NOUN cjel-3603 56 13 mark mark NOUN cjel-3603 56 14 has have AUX cjel-3603 56 15 always always ADV cjel-3603 56 16 been be AUX cjel-3603 56 17 held hold VERB cjel-3603 56 18 subject subject ADJ cjel-3603 56 19 to to ADP cjel-3603 56 20 this this DET cjel-3603 56 21 dominant dominant ADJ cjel-3603 56 22 servitude.11 servitude.11 NOUN cjel-3603 56 23 therefore therefore ADV cjel-3603 56 24 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 56 25 a a DET cjel-3603 56 26 private private ADJ cjel-3603 56 27 property property NOUN cjel-3603 56 28 owner owner NOUN cjel-3603 56 29 holds hold VERB cjel-3603 56 30 only only ADV cjel-3603 56 31 a a DET cjel-3603 56 32 “ " PUNCT cjel-3603 56 33 qualified qualified ADJ cjel-3603 56 34 title title NOUN cjel-3603 56 35 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 56 36 a a DET cjel-3603 56 37 bare bare ADJ cjel-3603 56 38 technical technical ADJ cjel-3603 56 39 title title NOUN cjel-3603 56 40 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 56 41 not not PART cjel-3603 56 42 at at ADP cjel-3603 56 43 his his PRON cjel-3603 56 44 absolute absolute ADJ cjel-3603 56 45 disposal disposal NOUN cjel-3603 56 46 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 56 47 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 57 1 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 58 1 but but CCONJ cjel-3603 58 2 to to PART cjel-3603 58 3 be be AUX cjel-3603 58 4 held hold VERB cjel-3603 58 5 at at ADP cjel-3603 58 6 all all DET cjel-3603 58 7 times time NOUN cjel-3603 58 8 subordinate subordinate ADJ cjel-3603 58 9 to to ADP cjel-3603 58 10 such such ADJ cjel-3603 58 11 use use NOUN cjel-3603 58 12 of of ADP cjel-3603 58 13 the the DET cjel-3603 58 14 submerged submerge VERB cjel-3603 58 15 lands land NOUN cjel-3603 58 16 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 58 17 of of ADP cjel-3603 58 18 the the DET cjel-3603 58 19 waters water NOUN cjel-3603 58 20 flowing flow VERB cjel-3603 58 21 over over ADP cjel-3603 58 22 them they PRON cjel-3603 58 23 as as SCONJ cjel-3603 58 24 may may AUX cjel-3603 58 25 be be AUX cjel-3603 58 26 consistent consistent ADJ cjel-3603 58 27 with with ADP cjel-3603 58 28 or or CCONJ cjel-3603 58 29 demanded demand VERB cjel-3603 58 30 by by ADP cjel-3603 58 31 the the DET cjel-3603 58 32 public public ADJ cjel-3603 58 33 right right NOUN cjel-3603 58 34 of of ADP cjel-3603 58 35 navigation navigation NOUN cjel-3603 58 36 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 59 1 ”12 ”12 PROPN cjel-3603 59 2 for for ADP cjel-3603 59 3 example example NOUN cjel-3603 59 4 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 59 5 when when SCONJ cjel-3603 59 6 the the DET cjel-3603 59 7 government government NOUN cjel-3603 59 8 constructs construct VERB cjel-3603 59 9 dikes dike NOUN cjel-3603 59 10 or or CCONJ cjel-3603 59 11 piers pier NOUN cjel-3603 59 12 upon upon SCONJ cjel-3603 59 13 submerged submerge VERB cjel-3603 59 14 land land NOUN cjel-3603 59 15 in in ADP cjel-3603 59 16 a a DET cjel-3603 59 17 navigable navigable ADJ cjel-3603 59 18 waterway waterway NOUN cjel-3603 59 19 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 59 20 the the DET cjel-3603 59 21 resulting result VERB cjel-3603 59 22 redirected redirect VERB cjel-3603 59 23 water water NOUN cjel-3603 59 24 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 59 25 silt silt NOUN cjel-3603 59 26 or or CCONJ cjel-3603 59 27 the the DET cjel-3603 59 28 physical physical ADJ cjel-3603 59 29 pier pier NOUN cjel-3603 59 30 might might AUX cjel-3603 59 31 cut cut VERB cjel-3603 59 32 off off ADP cjel-3603 59 33 the the DET cjel-3603 59 34 riparian riparian ADJ cjel-3603 59 35 owner owner NOUN cjel-3603 59 36 ’s ’s PART cjel-3603 59 37 access access NOUN cjel-3603 59 38 to to ADP cjel-3603 59 39 deep deep ADJ cjel-3603 59 40 water water NOUN cjel-3603 59 41 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 59 42 use use NOUN cjel-3603 59 43 of of ADP cjel-3603 59 44 the the DET cjel-3603 59 45 waterway.13 waterway.13 NOUN cjel-3603 59 46 while while SCONJ cjel-3603 59 47 the the DET cjel-3603 59 48 landowner landowner NOUN cjel-3603 59 49 loses lose VERB cjel-3603 59 50 both both DET cjel-3603 59 51 riparian riparian ADJ cjel-3603 59 52 rights right NOUN cjel-3603 59 53 of of ADP cjel-3603 59 54 water water NOUN cjel-3603 59 55 access access NOUN cjel-3603 59 56 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 59 57 any any DET cjel-3603 59 58 viable viable ADJ cjel-3603 59 59 economic economic ADJ cjel-3603 59 60 value value NOUN cjel-3603 59 61 in in ADP cjel-3603 59 62 the the DET cjel-3603 59 63 remaining remain VERB cjel-3603 59 64 dry dry ADJ cjel-3603 59 65 land land NOUN cjel-3603 59 66 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 59 67 no no DET cjel-3603 59 68 compensation compensation NOUN cjel-3603 59 69 is be AUX cjel-3603 59 70 due due ADJ cjel-3603 59 71 to to ADP cjel-3603 59 72 him.14 him.14 PROPN cjel-3603 59 73 waterways waterway NOUN cjel-3603 59 74 — — PUNCT cjel-3603 59 75 because because SCONJ cjel-3603 59 76 navigable navigable ADJ cjel-3603 59 77 waterways waterway NOUN cjel-3603 59 78 have have AUX cjel-3603 59 79 always always ADV cjel-3603 59 80 been be AUX cjel-3603 59 81 under under ADP cjel-3603 59 82 the the DET cjel-3603 59 83 exclusive exclusive ADJ cjel-3603 59 84 control control NOUN cjel-3603 59 85 of of ADP cjel-3603 59 86 the the DET cjel-3603 59 87 federal federal ADJ cjel-3603 59 88 government government NOUN cjel-3603 59 89 under under ADP cjel-3603 59 90 the the DET cjel-3603 59 91 commerce commerce NOUN cjel-3603 59 92 clause clause NOUN cjel-3603 59 93 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 59 94 ” " PUNCT cjel-3603 59 95 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 59 96 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 60 1 9 9 X cjel-3603 60 2 . . X cjel-3603 60 3 389 389 NUM cjel-3603 60 4 u.s u.s PROPN cjel-3603 60 5 . . PROPN cjel-3603 60 6 121 121 NUM cjel-3603 60 7 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 60 8 1967 1967 NUM cjel-3603 60 9 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 60 10 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 61 1 10 10 NUM cjel-3603 61 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 62 1 i i PRON cjel-3603 62 2 d. d. PROPN cjel-3603 62 3 at at ADP cjel-3603 62 4 123 123 NUM cjel-3603 62 5 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 62 6 internal internal ADJ cjel-3603 62 7 citations citation NOUN cjel-3603 62 8 omitted omit VERB cjel-3603 62 9 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 62 10 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 63 1 11 11 NUM cjel-3603 63 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 63 3 united united PROPN cjel-3603 63 4 states states PROPN cjel-3603 63 5 v. v. PROPN cjel-3603 63 6 cherokee cherokee PROPN cjel-3603 63 7 nation nation PROPN cjel-3603 63 8 of of ADP cjel-3603 63 9 okla okla PROPN cjel-3603 63 10 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 63 11 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 63 12 480 480 NUM cjel-3603 63 13 u.s u.s PROPN cjel-3603 63 14 . . PROPN cjel-3603 63 15 700 700 NUM cjel-3603 63 16 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 63 17 705 705 NUM cjel-3603 63 18 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 63 19 1987 1987 NUM cjel-3603 63 20 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 63 21 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 63 22 “ " PUNCT cjel-3603 63 23 the the DET cjel-3603 63 24 court court NOUN cjel-3603 63 25 did do AUX cjel-3603 63 26 not not PART cjel-3603 63 27 rely rely VERB cjel-3603 63 28 on on ADP cjel-3603 63 29 the the DET cjel-3603 63 30 particular particular ADJ cjel-3603 63 31 use use NOUN cjel-3603 63 32 to to PART cjel-3603 63 33 which which PRON cjel-3603 63 34 the the DET cjel-3603 63 35 private private ADJ cjel-3603 63 36 owners owner NOUN cjel-3603 63 37 put put VERB cjel-3603 63 38 the the DET cjel-3603 63 39 bed bed NOUN cjel-3603 63 40 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 63 41 but but CCONJ cjel-3603 63 42 rather rather ADV cjel-3603 63 43 observed observe VERB cjel-3603 63 44 that that SCONJ cjel-3603 63 45 their their PRON cjel-3603 63 46 very very ADJ cjel-3603 63 47 title title NOUN cjel-3603 63 48 to to ADP cjel-3603 63 49 the the DET cjel-3603 63 50 submerged submerge VERB cjel-3603 63 51 lands land NOUN cjel-3603 63 52 ‘ ' PUNCT cjel-3603 63 53 is be AUX cjel-3603 63 54 acquired acquire VERB cjel-3603 63 55 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 63 56 held hold VERB cjel-3603 63 57 subject subject NOUN cjel-3603 63 58 to to ADP cjel-3603 63 59 the the DET cjel-3603 63 60 power power NOUN cjel-3603 63 61 of of ADP cjel-3603 63 62 congress congress PROPN cjel-3603 63 63 to to PART cjel-3603 63 64 deepen deepen VERB cjel-3603 63 65 the the DET cjel-3603 63 66 water water NOUN cjel-3603 63 67 over over ADP cjel-3603 63 68 such such ADJ cjel-3603 63 69 lands land NOUN cjel-3603 63 70 or or CCONJ cjel-3603 63 71 to to PART cjel-3603 63 72 use use VERB cjel-3603 63 73 them they PRON cjel-3603 63 74 for for ADP cjel-3603 63 75 any any DET cjel-3603 63 76 structure structure NOUN cjel-3603 63 77 which which PRON cjel-3603 63 78 the the DET cjel-3603 63 79 interest interest NOUN cjel-3603 63 80 of of ADP cjel-3603 63 81 navigation navigation NOUN cjel-3603 63 82 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 63 83 in in ADP cjel-3603 63 84 its its PRON cjel-3603 63 85 judgment judgment NOUN cjel-3603 63 86 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 63 87 may may AUX cjel-3603 63 88 require require VERB cjel-3603 63 89 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 63 90 ’ ' PUNCT cjel-3603 64 1 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 64 2 citing cite VERB cjel-3603 64 3 lewis lewis PROPN cjel-3603 64 4 blue blue PROPN cjel-3603 64 5 point point PROPN cjel-3603 64 6 oyster oyster PROPN cjel-3603 64 7 cultivation cultivation PROPN cjel-3603 64 8 co. co. PROPN cjel-3603 65 1 v. v. ADP cjel-3603 65 2 briggs briggs PROPN cjel-3603 65 3 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 65 4 229 229 NUM cjel-3603 65 5 u.s u.s PROPN cjel-3603 65 6 . . PROPN cjel-3603 65 7 82 82 NUM cjel-3603 65 8 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 65 9 88 88 NUM cjel-3603 65 10 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 65 11 1913 1913 NUM cjel-3603 65 12 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 65 13 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 65 14 ” " PUNCT cjel-3603 65 15 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 65 16 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 66 1 12 12 NUM cjel-3603 66 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 67 1 scranton scranton PROPN cjel-3603 67 2 v. v. PROPN cjel-3603 67 3 wheeler wheeler PROPN cjel-3603 67 4 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 67 5 179 179 NUM cjel-3603 67 6 u.s u.s PROPN cjel-3603 67 7 . . PROPN cjel-3603 67 8 141 141 NUM cjel-3603 67 9 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 67 10 163 163 NUM cjel-3603 67 11 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 67 12 1900 1900 NUM cjel-3603 67 13 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 67 14 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 68 1 13 13 NUM cjel-3603 68 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 69 1 i i PRON cjel-3603 69 2 d. d. PROPN cjel-3603 69 3 14 14 NUM cjel-3603 69 4 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 70 1 i i PRON cjel-3603 70 2 d. d. PROPN cjel-3603 70 3 monahan monahan PROPN cjel-3603 70 4 - - PUNCT cjel-3603 70 5 macro-[final macro-[final PROPN cjel-3603 70 6 6 6 NUM cjel-3603 70 7 - - SYM cjel-3603 70 8 20 20 NUM cjel-3603 70 9 ] ] PUNCT cjel-3603 70 10 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 70 11 do do AUX cjel-3603 70 12 not not PART cjel-3603 70 13 delete delete VERB cjel-3603 70 14 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 70 15 6/22/2015 6/22/2015 NUM cjel-3603 70 16 11:53 11:53 NUM cjel-3603 70 17 pm pm NOUN cjel-3603 70 18 2015 2015 NUM cjel-3603 70 19 ] ] PUNCT cjel-3603 70 20 the the DET cjel-3603 70 21 navigational navigational ADJ cjel-3603 70 22 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 70 23 363 363 NUM cjel-3603 70 24 similarly similarly ADV cjel-3603 70 25 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 70 26 when when SCONJ cjel-3603 70 27 federal federal ADJ cjel-3603 70 28 dredging dredging NOUN cjel-3603 70 29 destroys destroy VERB cjel-3603 70 30 oyster oyster NOUN cjel-3603 70 31 beds15 beds15 NOUN cjel-3603 70 32 or or CCONJ cjel-3603 70 33 mineral mineral NOUN cjel-3603 70 34 deposits deposit NOUN cjel-3603 70 35 in in ADP cjel-3603 70 36 the the DET cjel-3603 70 37 streambed,16 streambed,16 NOUN cjel-3603 70 38 no no DET cjel-3603 70 39 compensation compensation NOUN cjel-3603 70 40 is be AUX cjel-3603 70 41 due due ADJ cjel-3603 70 42 to to ADP cjel-3603 70 43 owners owner NOUN cjel-3603 70 44 of of ADP cjel-3603 70 45 the the DET cjel-3603 70 46 commercial commercial ADJ cjel-3603 70 47 oyster oyster NOUN cjel-3603 70 48 beds bed NOUN cjel-3603 70 49 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 71 1 thus thus ADV cjel-3603 71 2 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 71 3 the the DET cjel-3603 71 4 navigational navigational ADJ cjel-3603 71 5 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 71 6 serves serve VERB cjel-3603 71 7 as as ADP cjel-3603 71 8 a a DET cjel-3603 71 9 powerful powerful ADJ cjel-3603 71 10 exception exception NOUN cjel-3603 71 11 to to ADP cjel-3603 71 12 the the DET cjel-3603 71 13 takings taking NOUN cjel-3603 71 14 clause clause NOUN cjel-3603 71 15 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 72 1 b. b. PROPN cjel-3603 72 2 limits limit NOUN cjel-3603 72 3 on on ADP cjel-3603 72 4 the the DET cjel-3603 72 5 navigational navigational ADJ cjel-3603 72 6 servitude servitude ADJ cjel-3603 72 7 i. i. PROPN cjel-3603 72 8 high high ADJ cjel-3603 72 9 - - PUNCT cjel-3603 72 10 water water NOUN cjel-3603 72 11 mark mark NOUN cjel-3603 72 12 the the DET cjel-3603 72 13 navigational navigational ADJ cjel-3603 72 14 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 72 15 is be AUX cjel-3603 72 16 not not PART cjel-3603 72 17 without without ADP cjel-3603 72 18 its its PRON cjel-3603 72 19 limits.17 limits.17 NOUN cjel-3603 72 20 first first ADV cjel-3603 72 21 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 72 22 the the DET cjel-3603 72 23 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 72 24 is be AUX cjel-3603 72 25 physically physically ADV cjel-3603 72 26 limited limit VERB cjel-3603 72 27 to to ADP cjel-3603 72 28 the the DET cjel-3603 72 29 “ " PUNCT cjel-3603 72 30 stream stream NOUN cjel-3603 72 31 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 72 32 the the DET cjel-3603 72 33 stream stream NOUN cjel-3603 72 34 bed bed NOUN cjel-3603 72 35 below below ADP cjel-3603 72 36 ordinary ordinary ADJ cjel-3603 72 37 high high ADJ cjel-3603 72 38 - - PUNCT cjel-3603 72 39 water water NOUN cjel-3603 72 40 mark mark NOUN cjel-3603 72 41 ” " PUNCT cjel-3603 72 42 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 72 43 “ " PUNCT cjel-3603 72 44 does do AUX cjel-3603 72 45 not not PART cjel-3603 72 46 extend extend VERB cjel-3603 72 47 beyond beyond ADP cjel-3603 72 48 the the DET cjel-3603 72 49 high high ADJ cjel-3603 72 50 - - PUNCT cjel-3603 72 51 water water NOUN cjel-3603 72 52 mark mark NOUN cjel-3603 72 53 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 73 1 ”18 ”18 NOUN cjel-3603 73 2 any any DET cjel-3603 73 3 lands land NOUN cjel-3603 73 4 located locate VERB cjel-3603 73 5 above above ADP cjel-3603 73 6 the the DET cjel-3603 73 7 high high ADJ cjel-3603 73 8 - - PUNCT cjel-3603 73 9 water water NOUN cjel-3603 73 10 mark mark NOUN cjel-3603 73 11 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 73 12 “ " PUNCT cjel-3603 73 13 fast fast ADJ cjel-3603 73 14 lands land NOUN cjel-3603 73 15 ” " PUNCT cjel-3603 73 16 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 73 17 are be AUX cjel-3603 73 18 still still ADV cjel-3603 73 19 subject subject ADJ cjel-3603 73 20 to to ADP cjel-3603 73 21 the the DET cjel-3603 73 22 takings taking NOUN cjel-3603 73 23 clause.19 clause.19 NOUN cjel-3603 73 24 for for ADP cjel-3603 73 25 example example NOUN cjel-3603 73 26 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 73 27 if if SCONJ cjel-3603 73 28 such such ADJ cjel-3603 73 29 fast fast ADJ cjel-3603 73 30 lands land NOUN cjel-3603 73 31 are be AUX cjel-3603 73 32 flooded flood VERB cjel-3603 73 33 as as ADP cjel-3603 73 34 a a DET cjel-3603 73 35 result result NOUN cjel-3603 73 36 of of ADP cjel-3603 73 37 the the DET cjel-3603 73 38 federal federal ADJ cjel-3603 73 39 government government NOUN cjel-3603 73 40 ’s ’s PART cjel-3603 73 41 navigational navigational ADJ cjel-3603 73 42 improvements improvement NOUN cjel-3603 73 43 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 73 44 the the DET cjel-3603 73 45 property property NOUN cjel-3603 73 46 owner owner NOUN cjel-3603 73 47 must must AUX cjel-3603 73 48 be be AUX cjel-3603 73 49 compensated compensate VERB cjel-3603 73 50 for for ADP cjel-3603 73 51 the the DET cjel-3603 73 52 loss loss NOUN cjel-3603 73 53 of of ADP cjel-3603 73 54 those those DET cjel-3603 73 55 lands land NOUN cjel-3603 73 56 above above ADP cjel-3603 73 57 the the DET cjel-3603 73 58 high high ADJ cjel-3603 73 59 - - PUNCT cjel-3603 73 60 water water NOUN cjel-3603 73 61 mark.20 mark.20 NOUN cjel-3603 73 62 such such ADJ cjel-3603 73 63 flooding flooding NOUN cjel-3603 73 64 has have AUX cjel-3603 73 65 long long ADV cjel-3603 73 66 been be AUX cjel-3603 73 67 recognized recognize VERB cjel-3603 73 68 as as ADP cjel-3603 73 69 constituting constitute VERB cjel-3603 73 70 a a DET cjel-3603 73 71 taking.21 taking.21 NOUN cjel-3603 73 72 however however ADV cjel-3603 73 73 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 73 74 disputes dispute NOUN cjel-3603 73 75 often often ADV cjel-3603 73 76 arise arise VERB cjel-3603 73 77 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 73 78 especially especially ADV cjel-3603 73 79 in in ADP cjel-3603 73 80 areas area NOUN cjel-3603 73 81 with with ADP cjel-3603 73 82 wetlands wetland NOUN cjel-3603 73 83 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 73 84 over over ADP cjel-3603 73 85 the the DET cjel-3603 73 86 extent extent NOUN cjel-3603 73 87 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 73 88 boundaries boundary NOUN cjel-3603 73 89 of of ADP cjel-3603 73 90 navigable navigable ADJ cjel-3603 73 91 waterways waterway NOUN cjel-3603 73 92 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 73 93 over over ADP cjel-3603 73 94 the the DET cjel-3603 73 95 location location NOUN cjel-3603 73 96 of of ADP cjel-3603 73 97 the the DET cjel-3603 73 98 high high ADJ cjel-3603 73 99 - - PUNCT cjel-3603 73 100 water water NOUN cjel-3603 73 101 mark.22 mark.22 PROPN cjel-3603 73 102 ii ii PROPN cjel-3603 73 103 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 74 1 navigable navigable ADJ cjel-3603 74 2 waterways waterway NOUN cjel-3603 74 3 the the DET cjel-3603 74 4 navigational navigational ADJ cjel-3603 74 5 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 74 6 is be AUX cjel-3603 74 7 further far ADV cjel-3603 74 8 geographically geographically ADV cjel-3603 74 9 limited limited ADJ cjel-3603 74 10 to to ADP cjel-3603 74 11 only only ADV cjel-3603 74 12 “ " PUNCT cjel-3603 74 13 navigable navigable ADJ cjel-3603 74 14 ” " PUNCT cjel-3603 74 15 waterways waterway NOUN cjel-3603 74 16 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 75 1 originally originally ADV cjel-3603 75 2 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 75 3 courts court NOUN cjel-3603 75 4 applied apply VERB cjel-3603 75 5 a a DET cjel-3603 75 6 15 15 NUM cjel-3603 75 7 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 76 1 briggs briggs PROPN cjel-3603 76 2 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 76 3 229 229 NUM cjel-3603 76 4 u.s u.s PROPN cjel-3603 76 5 . . PROPN cjel-3603 76 6 82 82 NUM cjel-3603 76 7 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 76 8 16 16 NUM cjel-3603 76 9 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 77 1 cherokee cherokee PROPN cjel-3603 77 2 nation nation PROPN cjel-3603 77 3 of of ADP cjel-3603 77 4 okla okla PROPN cjel-3603 77 5 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 77 6 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 77 7 480 480 NUM cjel-3603 77 8 u.s u.s PROPN cjel-3603 77 9 . . PROPN cjel-3603 77 10 at at ADP cjel-3603 77 11 700 700 NUM cjel-3603 77 12 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 77 13 17 17 NUM cjel-3603 77 14 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 78 1 see see VERB cjel-3603 78 2 generally generally ADV cjel-3603 78 3 genevieve genevieve PROPN cjel-3603 78 4 pisarski pisarski PROPN cjel-3603 78 5 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 78 6 testing test VERB cjel-3603 78 7 the the DET cjel-3603 78 8 limits limit NOUN cjel-3603 78 9 of of ADP cjel-3603 78 10 the the DET cjel-3603 78 11 federal federal ADJ cjel-3603 78 12 navigational navigational ADJ cjel-3603 78 13 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 78 14 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 78 15 2 2 NUM cjel-3603 78 16 ocean ocean NOUN cjel-3603 78 17 & & CCONJ cjel-3603 78 18 coastal coastal PROPN cjel-3603 78 19 l.j l.j PROPN cjel-3603 78 20 . . PROPN cjel-3603 78 21 313 313 NUM cjel-3603 78 22 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 78 23 1997 1997 NUM cjel-3603 78 24 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 78 25 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 78 26 discussing discuss VERB cjel-3603 78 27 the the DET cjel-3603 78 28 various various ADJ cjel-3603 78 29 limitations limitation NOUN cjel-3603 78 30 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 78 31 qualifications qualification NOUN cjel-3603 78 32 of of ADP cjel-3603 78 33 the the DET cjel-3603 78 34 navigational navigational ADJ cjel-3603 78 35 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 78 36 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 78 37 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 79 1 18 18 NUM cjel-3603 79 2 . . X cjel-3603 79 3 united united PROPN cjel-3603 79 4 states states PROPN cjel-3603 79 5 v. v. ADP cjel-3603 79 6 rands rand NOUN cjel-3603 79 7 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 79 8 389 389 NUM cjel-3603 79 9 u.s u.s PROPN cjel-3603 79 10 . . PROPN cjel-3603 79 11 121 121 NUM cjel-3603 79 12 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 79 13 123 123 NUM cjel-3603 79 14 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 79 15 1967 1967 NUM cjel-3603 79 16 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 79 17 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 80 1 19 19 NUM cjel-3603 80 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 81 1 i i PRON cjel-3603 81 2 d. d. PROPN cjel-3603 81 3 20 20 NUM cjel-3603 81 4 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 82 1 confederated confederate VERB cjel-3603 82 2 tribes tribe NOUN cjel-3603 82 3 of of ADP cjel-3603 82 4 colville colville PROPN cjel-3603 82 5 reservation reservation PROPN cjel-3603 82 6 v. v. ADP cjel-3603 82 7 united united PROPN cjel-3603 82 8 states states PROPN cjel-3603 82 9 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 82 10 964 964 NUM cjel-3603 82 11 f.2d f.2d NOUN cjel-3603 82 12 1102 1102 NUM cjel-3603 82 13 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 82 14 1105 1105 NUM cjel-3603 82 15 n.5 n.5 X cjel-3603 82 16 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 82 17 fed fed PROPN cjel-3603 82 18 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 82 19 cir cir PROPN cjel-3603 82 20 . . PROPN cjel-3603 82 21 1992 1992 NUM cjel-3603 82 22 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 82 23 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 82 24 “ " PUNCT cjel-3603 82 25 ‘ ' PUNCT cjel-3603 82 26 fast fast ADJ cjel-3603 82 27 ’ ' PUNCT cjel-3603 82 28 lands land NOUN cjel-3603 82 29 are be AUX cjel-3603 82 30 those those PRON cjel-3603 82 31 above above ADP cjel-3603 82 32 the the DET cjel-3603 82 33 high high ADJ cjel-3603 82 34 water water NOUN cjel-3603 82 35 mark mark NOUN cjel-3603 82 36 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 82 37 which which PRON cjel-3603 82 38 when when SCONJ cjel-3603 82 39 flooded flood VERB cjel-3603 82 40 are be AUX cjel-3603 82 41 considered consider VERB cjel-3603 82 42 a a DET cjel-3603 82 43 taking taking NOUN cjel-3603 82 44 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 82 45 subject subject VERB cjel-3603 82 46 to to ADP cjel-3603 82 47 just just ADV cjel-3603 82 48 compensation compensation NOUN cjel-3603 82 49 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 82 50 ” " PUNCT cjel-3603 82 51 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 82 52 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 83 1 21 21 NUM cjel-3603 83 2 . . X cjel-3603 84 1 see see VERB cjel-3603 84 2 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 84 3 e.g. e.g. ADV cjel-3603 84 4 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 84 5 gibson gibson PROPN cjel-3603 84 6 v. v. PROPN cjel-3603 84 7 united united PROPN cjel-3603 84 8 states states PROPN cjel-3603 84 9 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 84 10 166 166 NUM cjel-3603 84 11 u.s u.s PROPN cjel-3603 84 12 . . PROPN cjel-3603 84 13 269 269 NUM cjel-3603 84 14 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 84 15 1987 1987 NUM cjel-3603 84 16 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 84 17 ; ; PUNCT cjel-3603 84 18 see see VERB cjel-3603 84 19 also also ADV cjel-3603 84 20 pumpelly pumpelly ADV cjel-3603 84 21 v. v. ADP cjel-3603 84 22 green green PROPN cjel-3603 84 23 bay bay PROPN cjel-3603 84 24 co. co. PROPN cjel-3603 84 25 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 84 26 80 80 NUM cjel-3603 84 27 u.s u.s PROPN cjel-3603 84 28 . . PROPN cjel-3603 84 29 166 166 NUM cjel-3603 84 30 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 84 31 1871 1871 NUM cjel-3603 84 32 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 84 33 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 85 1 22 22 NUM cjel-3603 85 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 86 1 see see VERB cjel-3603 86 2 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 86 3 e.g. e.g. ADV cjel-3603 86 4 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 86 5 palm palm NOUN cjel-3603 86 6 beach beach PROPN cjel-3603 86 7 isles isles PROPN cjel-3603 86 8 assocs assocs PROPN cjel-3603 86 9 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 87 1 v. v. PROPN cjel-3603 87 2 united united PROPN cjel-3603 87 3 states states PROPN cjel-3603 87 4 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 87 5 208 208 NUM cjel-3603 87 6 f.3d f.3d NUM cjel-3603 87 7 1374 1374 NUM cjel-3603 87 8 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 87 9 fed fed PROPN cjel-3603 87 10 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 87 11 cir cir PROPN cjel-3603 87 12 . . PROPN cjel-3603 87 13 2000 2000 NUM cjel-3603 87 14 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 88 1 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 88 2 finding find VERB cjel-3603 88 3 that that SCONJ cjel-3603 88 4 although although SCONJ cjel-3603 88 5 the the DET cjel-3603 88 6 depth depth NOUN cjel-3603 88 7 of of ADP cjel-3603 88 8 water water NOUN cjel-3603 88 9 over over ADP cjel-3603 88 10 the the DET cjel-3603 88 11 land land NOUN cjel-3603 88 12 in in ADP cjel-3603 88 13 question question NOUN cjel-3603 88 14 could could AUX cjel-3603 88 15 not not PART cjel-3603 88 16 support support VERB cjel-3603 88 17 navigation navigation NOUN cjel-3603 88 18 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 88 19 because because SCONJ cjel-3603 88 20 the the DET cjel-3603 88 21 larger large ADJ cjel-3603 88 22 lake lake NOUN cjel-3603 88 23 worth worth ADJ cjel-3603 88 24 as as ADP cjel-3603 88 25 a a DET cjel-3603 88 26 whole whole NOUN cjel-3603 88 27 was be AUX cjel-3603 88 28 navigable navigable ADJ cjel-3603 88 29 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 88 30 the the DET cjel-3603 88 31 submerged submerge VERB cjel-3603 88 32 land land NOUN cjel-3603 88 33 in in ADP cjel-3603 88 34 question question NOUN cjel-3603 88 35 was be AUX cjel-3603 88 36 subject subject ADJ cjel-3603 88 37 to to ADP cjel-3603 88 38 the the DET cjel-3603 88 39 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 88 40 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 88 41 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 88 42 abrogated abrogate VERB cjel-3603 88 43 by by ADP cjel-3603 88 44 bass bass NOUN cjel-3603 88 45 enters enter NOUN cjel-3603 88 46 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 89 1 prod prod PROPN cjel-3603 89 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 89 3 co. co. PROPN cjel-3603 90 1 v. v. ADP cjel-3603 90 2 united united PROPN cjel-3603 90 3 states states PROPN cjel-3603 90 4 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 90 5 381 381 NUM cjel-3603 90 6 f.3d f.3d NUM cjel-3603 90 7 1360 1360 NUM cjel-3603 90 8 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 90 9 1369–70 1369–70 NUM cjel-3603 90 10 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 90 11 fed fed PROPN cjel-3603 90 12 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 90 13 cir cir PROPN cjel-3603 90 14 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 90 15 2004 2004 NUM cjel-3603 90 16 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 90 17 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 91 1 monahan monahan PROPN cjel-3603 91 2 - - PUNCT cjel-3603 91 3 macro-[final macro-[final PROPN cjel-3603 91 4 6 6 NUM cjel-3603 91 5 - - SYM cjel-3603 91 6 20 20 NUM cjel-3603 91 7 ] ] PUNCT cjel-3603 91 8 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 91 9 do do AUX cjel-3603 91 10 not not PART cjel-3603 91 11 delete delete VERB cjel-3603 91 12 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 91 13 6/22/2015 6/22/2015 NUM cjel-3603 91 14 11:53 11:53 NUM cjel-3603 91 15 pm pm NOUN cjel-3603 91 16 364 364 NUM cjel-3603 91 17 columbia columbia PROPN cjel-3603 91 18 journal journal PROPN cjel-3603 91 19 of of ADP cjel-3603 91 20 environmental environmental ADJ cjel-3603 91 21 law law NOUN cjel-3603 91 22 [ [ X cjel-3603 91 23 vol vol NOUN cjel-3603 91 24 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 92 1 40:2 40:2 NOUN cjel-3603 92 2 strict strict ADJ cjel-3603 92 3 “ " PUNCT cjel-3603 92 4 navigable navigable ADJ cjel-3603 92 5 in in ADP cjel-3603 92 6 fact fact NOUN cjel-3603 92 7 ” " PUNCT cjel-3603 92 8 test test NOUN cjel-3603 92 9 developed develop VERB cjel-3603 92 10 in in ADP cjel-3603 92 11 the the DET cjel-3603 92 12 daniel daniel PROPN cjel-3603 92 13 ball.23 ball.23 PROPN cjel-3603 92 14 rivers river NOUN cjel-3603 92 15 “ " PUNCT cjel-3603 92 16 are be AUX cjel-3603 92 17 navigable navigable ADJ cjel-3603 92 18 in in ADP cjel-3603 92 19 fact fact NOUN cjel-3603 92 20 when when SCONJ cjel-3603 92 21 they they PRON cjel-3603 92 22 are be AUX cjel-3603 92 23 used use VERB cjel-3603 92 24 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 92 25 or or CCONJ cjel-3603 92 26 are be AUX cjel-3603 92 27 susceptible susceptible ADJ cjel-3603 92 28 of of ADP cjel-3603 92 29 being be AUX cjel-3603 92 30 used use VERB cjel-3603 92 31 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 92 32 in in ADP cjel-3603 92 33 their their PRON cjel-3603 92 34 ordinary ordinary ADJ cjel-3603 92 35 condition condition NOUN cjel-3603 92 36 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 92 37 as as SCONJ cjel-3603 92 38 highways highway NOUN cjel-3603 92 39 for for ADP cjel-3603 92 40 commerce commerce NOUN cjel-3603 92 41 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 92 42 over over SCONJ cjel-3603 92 43 which which DET cjel-3603 92 44 trade trade NOUN cjel-3603 92 45 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 92 46 travel travel NOUN cjel-3603 92 47 are be AUX cjel-3603 92 48 or or CCONJ cjel-3603 92 49 may may AUX cjel-3603 92 50 be be AUX cjel-3603 92 51 conducted conduct VERB cjel-3603 92 52 in in ADP cjel-3603 92 53 the the DET cjel-3603 92 54 customary customary ADJ cjel-3603 92 55 modes mode NOUN cjel-3603 92 56 of of ADP cjel-3603 92 57 trade trade NOUN cjel-3603 92 58 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 92 59 travel travel NOUN cjel-3603 92 60 on on ADP cjel-3603 92 61 water water NOUN cjel-3603 92 62 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 93 1 ”24 ”24 VERB cjel-3603 93 2 however however ADV cjel-3603 93 3 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 93 4 over over ADP cjel-3603 93 5 time time NOUN cjel-3603 93 6 this this DET cjel-3603 93 7 test test NOUN cjel-3603 93 8 was be AUX cjel-3603 93 9 relaxed relax VERB cjel-3603 93 10 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 93 11 the the DET cjel-3603 93 12 definition definition NOUN cjel-3603 93 13 of of ADP cjel-3603 93 14 a a DET cjel-3603 93 15 navigable navigable ADJ cjel-3603 93 16 waterway waterway NOUN cjel-3603 93 17 expanded expand VERB cjel-3603 93 18 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 94 1 today today NOUN cjel-3603 94 2 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 94 3 for for ADP cjel-3603 94 4 purposes purpose NOUN cjel-3603 94 5 of of ADP cjel-3603 94 6 the the DET cjel-3603 94 7 navigational navigational ADJ cjel-3603 94 8 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 94 9 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 94 10 the the DET cjel-3603 94 11 term term NOUN cjel-3603 94 12 “ " PUNCT cjel-3603 94 13 navigable navigable ADJ cjel-3603 94 14 waterway waterway NOUN cjel-3603 94 15 ” " PUNCT cjel-3603 94 16 encompasses encompass VERB cjel-3603 94 17 non non ADJ cjel-3603 94 18 - - ADJ cjel-3603 94 19 navigable navigable ADJ cjel-3603 94 20 tributaries tributary NOUN cjel-3603 94 21 to to ADP cjel-3603 94 22 navigable navigable ADJ cjel-3603 94 23 waterways;25 waterways;25 NOUN cjel-3603 94 24 waters water VERB cjel-3603 94 25 that that SCONJ cjel-3603 94 26 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 94 27 though though SCONJ cjel-3603 94 28 once once ADV cjel-3603 94 29 navigable navigable ADJ cjel-3603 94 30 in in ADP cjel-3603 94 31 fact fact NOUN cjel-3603 94 32 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 94 33 are be AUX cjel-3603 94 34 no no ADV cjel-3603 94 35 longer long ADV cjel-3603 94 36 navigable;26 navigable;26 NOUN cjel-3603 94 37 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 94 38 waters water NOUN cjel-3603 94 39 which which PRON cjel-3603 94 40 may may AUX cjel-3603 94 41 become become VERB cjel-3603 94 42 navigable navigable ADJ cjel-3603 94 43 after after ADP cjel-3603 94 44 reasonable reasonable ADJ cjel-3603 94 45 improvements.27 improvements.27 PROPN cjel-3603 94 46 however however ADV cjel-3603 94 47 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 94 48 this this DET cjel-3603 94 49 expansion expansion NOUN cjel-3603 94 50 has have AUX cjel-3603 94 51 not not PART cjel-3603 94 52 extended extend VERB cjel-3603 94 53 the the DET cjel-3603 94 54 navigational navigational ADJ cjel-3603 94 55 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 94 56 to to ADP cjel-3603 94 57 private private ADJ cjel-3603 94 58 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 94 59 nonnavigable nonnavigable ADJ cjel-3603 94 60 waterways waterway NOUN cjel-3603 94 61 that that SCONJ cjel-3603 94 62 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 94 63 through through ADP cjel-3603 94 64 private private ADJ cjel-3603 94 65 dredging dredging NOUN cjel-3603 94 66 efforts effort NOUN cjel-3603 94 67 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 94 68 have have AUX cjel-3603 94 69 become become VERB cjel-3603 94 70 connected connected ADJ cjel-3603 94 71 to to ADP cjel-3603 94 72 navigable navigable ADJ cjel-3603 94 73 waterways.28 waterways.28 PROPN cjel-3603 94 74 iii iii PROPN cjel-3603 94 75 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 95 1 easement easement PROPN cjel-3603 95 2 the the DET cjel-3603 95 3 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 95 4 is be AUX cjel-3603 95 5 also also ADV cjel-3603 95 6 limited limit VERB cjel-3603 95 7 in in ADP cjel-3603 95 8 that that SCONJ cjel-3603 95 9 it it PRON cjel-3603 95 10 is be AUX cjel-3603 95 11 an an DET cjel-3603 95 12 easement easement NOUN cjel-3603 95 13 only only ADV cjel-3603 95 14 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 96 1 as as ADP cjel-3603 96 2 such such ADJ cjel-3603 96 3 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 96 4 it it PRON cjel-3603 96 5 “ " PUNCT cjel-3603 96 6 does do AUX cjel-3603 96 7 not not PART cjel-3603 96 8 destroy destroy VERB cjel-3603 96 9 or or CCONJ cjel-3603 96 10 exclude exclude VERB cjel-3603 96 11 all all DET cjel-3603 96 12 property property NOUN cjel-3603 96 13 rights right NOUN cjel-3603 96 14 in in ADP cjel-3603 96 15 the the DET cjel-3603 96 16 beds bed NOUN cjel-3603 96 17 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 96 18 banks bank NOUN cjel-3603 96 19 of of ADP cjel-3603 96 20 navigable navigable ADJ cjel-3603 96 21 streams stream NOUN cjel-3603 96 22 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 97 1 ”29 ”29 AUX cjel-3603 97 2 the the DET cjel-3603 97 3 rights right NOUN cjel-3603 97 4 of of ADP cjel-3603 97 5 the the DET cjel-3603 97 6 titleholder titleholder NOUN cjel-3603 97 7 of of ADP cjel-3603 97 8 the the DET cjel-3603 97 9 submerged submerge VERB cjel-3603 97 10 lands land NOUN cjel-3603 97 11 “ " PUNCT cjel-3603 97 12 continue continue VERB cjel-3603 97 13 to to PART cjel-3603 97 14 exist exist VERB cjel-3603 97 15 but but CCONJ cjel-3603 97 16 are be AUX cjel-3603 97 17 held hold VERB cjel-3603 97 18 subject subject ADJ cjel-3603 97 19 to to ADP cjel-3603 97 20 the the DET cjel-3603 97 21 governmental governmental ADJ cjel-3603 97 22 power power NOUN cjel-3603 97 23 in in ADP cjel-3603 97 24 the the DET cjel-3603 97 25 nature nature NOUN cjel-3603 97 26 of of ADP cjel-3603 97 27 an an DET cjel-3603 97 28 easement easement NOUN cjel-3603 97 29 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 98 1 ”30 ”30 PUNCT cjel-3603 98 2 thus thus ADV cjel-3603 98 3 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 98 4 even even ADV cjel-3603 98 5 when when SCONJ cjel-3603 98 6 the the DET cjel-3603 98 7 government government NOUN cjel-3603 98 8 is be AUX cjel-3603 98 9 exercising exercise VERB cjel-3603 98 10 the the DET cjel-3603 98 11 navigational navigational ADJ cjel-3603 98 12 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 98 13 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 98 14 the the DET cjel-3603 98 15 private private ADJ cjel-3603 98 16 landowner landowner NOUN cjel-3603 98 17 retains retain VERB cjel-3603 98 18 full full ADJ cjel-3603 98 19 title title NOUN cjel-3603 98 20 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 99 1 when when SCONJ cjel-3603 99 2 the the DET cjel-3603 99 3 government government NOUN cjel-3603 99 4 stops stop VERB cjel-3603 99 5 exercising exercise VERB cjel-3603 99 6 its its PRON cjel-3603 99 7 easement easement NOUN cjel-3603 99 8 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 99 9 control control NOUN cjel-3603 99 10 of of ADP cjel-3603 99 11 the the DET cjel-3603 99 12 submerged submerge VERB cjel-3603 99 13 lands land NOUN cjel-3603 99 14 reverts revert VERB cjel-3603 99 15 back back ADV cjel-3603 99 16 to to ADP cjel-3603 99 17 the the DET cjel-3603 99 18 private private ADJ cjel-3603 99 19 23 23 NUM cjel-3603 99 20 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 100 1 the the DET cjel-3603 100 2 daniel daniel PROPN cjel-3603 100 3 ball ball PROPN cjel-3603 100 4 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 100 5 77 77 NUM cjel-3603 100 6 u.s u.s PROPN cjel-3603 100 7 . . PROPN cjel-3603 100 8 557 557 NUM cjel-3603 100 9 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 100 10 563 563 NUM cjel-3603 100 11 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 100 12 1870 1870 NUM cjel-3603 100 13 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 100 14 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 100 15 superseded supersede VERB cjel-3603 100 16 by by ADP cjel-3603 100 17 statute statute PROPN cjel-3603 100 18 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 100 19 clean clean ADJ cjel-3603 100 20 water water PROPN cjel-3603 100 21 act act NOUN cjel-3603 100 22 of of ADP cjel-3603 100 23 1972 1972 NUM cjel-3603 100 24 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 100 25 pub pub NOUN cjel-3603 100 26 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 101 1 l. l. PROPN cjel-3603 101 2 no no INTJ cjel-3603 101 3 . . PROPN cjel-3603 102 1 92 92 NUM cjel-3603 102 2 - - SYM cjel-3603 102 3 500 500 NUM cjel-3603 102 4 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 102 5 86 86 NUM cjel-3603 102 6 stat stat NOUN cjel-3603 102 7 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 103 1 816 816 NUM cjel-3603 103 2 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 103 3 as as SCONJ cjel-3603 103 4 recognized recognize VERB cjel-3603 103 5 in in ADP cjel-3603 103 6 rapanos rapanos PROPN cjel-3603 103 7 v. v. ADP cjel-3603 103 8 united united PROPN cjel-3603 103 9 states states PROPN cjel-3603 103 10 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 104 1 547 547 NUM cjel-3603 104 2 u.s u.s PROPN cjel-3603 104 3 . . PROPN cjel-3603 104 4 715 715 NUM cjel-3603 104 5 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 104 6 723–24 723–24 NUM cjel-3603 104 7 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 104 8 2006 2006 NUM cjel-3603 104 9 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 104 10 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 105 1 24 24 NUM cjel-3603 105 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 106 1 i i PRON cjel-3603 106 2 d. d. PROPN cjel-3603 106 3 ; ; PUNCT cjel-3603 106 4 see see VERB cjel-3603 106 5 also also ADV cjel-3603 106 6 united unite VERB cjel-3603 106 7 states states PROPN cjel-3603 106 8 v. v. ADP cjel-3603 106 9 cress cress NOUN cjel-3603 106 10 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 107 1 243 243 NUM cjel-3603 107 2 u.s u.s PROPN cjel-3603 107 3 . . PROPN cjel-3603 107 4 316 316 NUM cjel-3603 107 5 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 107 6 326 326 NUM cjel-3603 107 7 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 107 8 1917 1917 NUM cjel-3603 107 9 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 107 10 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 107 11 applying apply VERB cjel-3603 107 12 the the DET cjel-3603 107 13 navigable navigable ADJ cjel-3603 107 14 in in ADP cjel-3603 107 15 fact fact NOUN cjel-3603 107 16 test test NOUN cjel-3603 107 17 to to PART cjel-3603 107 18 find find VERB cjel-3603 107 19 that that SCONJ cjel-3603 107 20 the the DET cjel-3603 107 21 cumberland cumberland PROPN cjel-3603 107 22 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 107 23 kentucky kentucky PROPN cjel-3603 107 24 rivers river NOUN cjel-3603 107 25 were be AUX cjel-3603 107 26 navigable navigable ADJ cjel-3603 107 27 waters water NOUN cjel-3603 107 28 of of ADP cjel-3603 107 29 the the DET cjel-3603 107 30 united united PROPN cjel-3603 107 31 states states PROPN cjel-3603 107 32 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 107 33 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 108 1 25 25 NUM cjel-3603 108 2 . . X cjel-3603 109 1 see see VERB cjel-3603 109 2 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 109 3 e.g. e.g. ADV cjel-3603 109 4 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 109 5 united united PROPN cjel-3603 109 6 states states PROPN cjel-3603 109 7 v. v. ADP cjel-3603 109 8 grand grand PROPN cjel-3603 109 9 river river PROPN cjel-3603 109 10 dam dam PROPN cjel-3603 109 11 auth auth NOUN cjel-3603 109 12 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 109 13 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 109 14 363 363 NUM cjel-3603 109 15 u.s u.s PROPN cjel-3603 109 16 . . PROPN cjel-3603 109 17 229 229 NUM cjel-3603 109 18 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 109 19 232 232 NUM cjel-3603 109 20 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 109 21 1960 1960 NUM cjel-3603 109 22 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 109 23 ; ; PUNCT cjel-3603 109 24 oklahoma oklahoma PROPN cjel-3603 109 25 ex ex PROPN cjel-3603 109 26 rel rel PROPN cjel-3603 109 27 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 110 1 phillips phillips PROPN cjel-3603 110 2 v. v. ADP cjel-3603 110 3 guy guy PROPN cjel-3603 110 4 f. f. PROPN cjel-3603 110 5 atkinson atkinson PROPN cjel-3603 110 6 co. co. PROPN cjel-3603 110 7 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 110 8 313 313 NUM cjel-3603 110 9 u.s u.s PROPN cjel-3603 110 10 . . PROPN cjel-3603 110 11 508 508 NUM cjel-3603 110 12 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 110 13 525–26 525–26 NUM cjel-3603 110 14 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 110 15 1941 1941 NUM cjel-3603 110 16 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 110 17 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 111 1 26 26 NUM cjel-3603 111 2 . . X cjel-3603 112 1 see see VERB cjel-3603 112 2 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 112 3 e.g. e.g. ADV cjel-3603 112 4 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 112 5 arizona arizona PROPN cjel-3603 112 6 v. v. PROPN cjel-3603 112 7 california california PROPN cjel-3603 112 8 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 112 9 283 283 NUM cjel-3603 112 10 u.s u.s PROPN cjel-3603 112 11 . . PROPN cjel-3603 112 12 423 423 NUM cjel-3603 112 13 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 112 14 453–54 453–54 NUM cjel-3603 112 15 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 112 16 1931 1931 NUM cjel-3603 112 17 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 112 18 ; ; PUNCT cjel-3603 113 1 econ econ X cjel-3603 113 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 114 1 light light PROPN cjel-3603 114 2 & & CCONJ cjel-3603 114 3 power power PROPN cjel-3603 114 4 co. co. PROPN cjel-3603 114 5 v. v. PROPN cjel-3603 114 6 united united PROPN cjel-3603 114 7 states states PROPN cjel-3603 114 8 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 114 9 256 256 NUM cjel-3603 114 10 u.s u.s PROPN cjel-3603 114 11 . . PROPN cjel-3603 114 12 113 113 NUM cjel-3603 114 13 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 114 14 122–23 122–23 NUM cjel-3603 114 15 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 114 16 1921 1921 NUM cjel-3603 114 17 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 114 18 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 115 1 27 27 NUM cjel-3603 115 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 115 3 united united PROPN cjel-3603 115 4 states states PROPN cjel-3603 115 5 v. v. PROPN cjel-3603 115 6 appalachian appalachian PROPN cjel-3603 115 7 elec elec PROPN cjel-3603 115 8 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 115 9 power power PROPN cjel-3603 115 10 co. co. PROPN cjel-3603 115 11 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 115 12 311 311 NUM cjel-3603 115 13 u.s u.s PROPN cjel-3603 115 14 . . PROPN cjel-3603 115 15 377 377 NUM cjel-3603 115 16 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 115 17 408 408 NUM cjel-3603 115 18 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 115 19 1940 1940 NUM cjel-3603 115 20 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 115 21 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 115 22 superseded supersede VERB cjel-3603 115 23 by by ADP cjel-3603 115 24 statute statute PROPN cjel-3603 115 25 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 115 26 clean clean ADJ cjel-3603 115 27 water water PROPN cjel-3603 115 28 act act NOUN cjel-3603 115 29 of of ADP cjel-3603 115 30 1972 1972 NUM cjel-3603 115 31 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 115 32 pub pub NOUN cjel-3603 115 33 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 116 1 l. l. PROPN cjel-3603 116 2 no no INTJ cjel-3603 116 3 . . PROPN cjel-3603 117 1 92 92 NUM cjel-3603 117 2 - - SYM cjel-3603 117 3 500 500 NUM cjel-3603 117 4 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 117 5 86 86 NUM cjel-3603 117 6 stat stat NOUN cjel-3603 117 7 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 118 1 816 816 NUM cjel-3603 118 2 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 118 3 as as SCONJ cjel-3603 118 4 recognized recognize VERB cjel-3603 118 5 in in ADP cjel-3603 118 6 rapanos rapanos PROPN cjel-3603 118 7 v. v. ADP cjel-3603 118 8 united united PROPN cjel-3603 118 9 states states PROPN cjel-3603 118 10 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 119 1 547 547 NUM cjel-3603 119 2 u.s u.s PROPN cjel-3603 119 3 . . PROPN cjel-3603 119 4 715 715 NUM cjel-3603 119 5 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 119 6 723–24 723–24 NUM cjel-3603 119 7 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 119 8 2006 2006 NUM cjel-3603 119 9 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 119 10 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 120 1 28 28 NUM cjel-3603 120 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 121 1 kaiser kaiser PROPN cjel-3603 121 2 aetna aetna PROPN cjel-3603 121 3 v. v. PROPN cjel-3603 121 4 united united PROPN cjel-3603 121 5 states states PROPN cjel-3603 121 6 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 121 7 444 444 NUM cjel-3603 121 8 u.s u.s PROPN cjel-3603 121 9 . . PROPN cjel-3603 121 10 164 164 NUM cjel-3603 121 11 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 121 12 173 173 NUM cjel-3603 121 13 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 121 14 1979 1979 NUM cjel-3603 121 15 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 121 16 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 122 1 29 29 NUM cjel-3603 122 2 . . X cjel-3603 123 1 pub pub NOUN cjel-3603 123 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 124 1 util util PROPN cjel-3603 124 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 124 3 dist dist NOUN cjel-3603 124 4 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 125 1 no no INTJ cjel-3603 125 2 . . NOUN cjel-3603 125 3 1 1 NUM cjel-3603 125 4 of of ADP cjel-3603 125 5 pend pend PROPN cjel-3603 125 6 oreille oreille PROPN cjel-3603 125 7 cnty cnty PROPN cjel-3603 125 8 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 126 1 v. v. ADP cjel-3603 126 2 city city PROPN cjel-3603 126 3 of of ADP cjel-3603 126 4 seattle seattle PROPN cjel-3603 126 5 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 126 6 382 382 NUM cjel-3603 126 7 f.2d f.2d NOUN cjel-3603 126 8 666 666 NUM cjel-3603 126 9 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 126 10 669 669 NUM cjel-3603 126 11 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 126 12 9th 9th ADJ cjel-3603 126 13 cir cir NOUN cjel-3603 126 14 . . PROPN cjel-3603 126 15 1967 1967 NUM cjel-3603 126 16 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 126 17 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 127 1 30 30 NUM cjel-3603 127 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 128 1 i i PRON cjel-3603 128 2 d. d. PROPN cjel-3603 128 3 monahan monahan PROPN cjel-3603 128 4 - - PUNCT cjel-3603 128 5 macro-[final macro-[final PROPN cjel-3603 128 6 6 6 NUM cjel-3603 128 7 - - SYM cjel-3603 128 8 20 20 NUM cjel-3603 128 9 ] ] PUNCT cjel-3603 128 10 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 128 11 do do AUX cjel-3603 128 12 not not PART cjel-3603 128 13 delete delete VERB cjel-3603 128 14 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 128 15 6/22/2015 6/22/2015 NUM cjel-3603 128 16 11:53 11:53 NUM cjel-3603 128 17 pm pm NOUN cjel-3603 128 18 2015 2015 NUM cjel-3603 128 19 ] ] PUNCT cjel-3603 128 20 the the DET cjel-3603 128 21 navigational navigational ADJ cjel-3603 128 22 servitude servitude ADJ cjel-3603 128 23 365 365 NUM cjel-3603 128 24 landowner landowner NOUN cjel-3603 128 25 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 129 1 by by ADP cjel-3603 129 2 contrast contrast NOUN cjel-3603 129 3 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 129 4 if if SCONJ cjel-3603 129 5 the the DET cjel-3603 129 6 government government NOUN cjel-3603 129 7 wanted want VERB cjel-3603 129 8 not not PART cjel-3603 129 9 only only ADV cjel-3603 129 10 to to PART cjel-3603 129 11 exercise exercise VERB cjel-3603 129 12 its its PRON cjel-3603 129 13 easement easement NOUN cjel-3603 129 14 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 129 15 but but CCONJ cjel-3603 129 16 also also ADV cjel-3603 129 17 to to PART cjel-3603 129 18 acquire acquire VERB cjel-3603 129 19 full full ADJ cjel-3603 129 20 title title NOUN cjel-3603 129 21 in in ADP cjel-3603 129 22 fee fee NOUN cjel-3603 129 23 to to ADP cjel-3603 129 24 the the DET cjel-3603 129 25 submerged submerge VERB cjel-3603 129 26 riverbeds riverbed NOUN cjel-3603 129 27 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 129 28 a a DET cjel-3603 129 29 condemnation condemnation NOUN cjel-3603 129 30 proceeding proceeding NOUN cjel-3603 129 31 would would AUX cjel-3603 129 32 be be AUX cjel-3603 129 33 necessary necessary ADJ cjel-3603 129 34 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 129 35 along along ADP cjel-3603 129 36 with with ADP cjel-3603 129 37 the the DET cjel-3603 129 38 payment payment NOUN cjel-3603 129 39 of of ADP cjel-3603 129 40 just just ADJ cjel-3603 129 41 compensation compensation NOUN cjel-3603 129 42 to to ADP cjel-3603 129 43 the the DET cjel-3603 129 44 private private ADJ cjel-3603 129 45 landowner.31 landowner.31 PROPN cjel-3603 129 46 iv iv ADP cjel-3603 129 47 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 129 48 express express VERB cjel-3603 129 49 authorization authorization NOUN cjel-3603 129 50 for for SCONJ cjel-3603 129 51 the the DET cjel-3603 129 52 federal federal ADJ cjel-3603 129 53 government government NOUN cjel-3603 129 54 to to PART cjel-3603 129 55 exercise exercise VERB cjel-3603 129 56 this this DET cjel-3603 129 57 power power NOUN cjel-3603 129 58 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 129 59 it it PRON cjel-3603 129 60 must must AUX cjel-3603 129 61 have have VERB cjel-3603 129 62 an an DET cjel-3603 129 63 express express ADJ cjel-3603 129 64 authorization.32 authorization.32 NOUN cjel-3603 129 65 such such DET cjel-3603 129 66 an an DET cjel-3603 129 67 authorization authorization NOUN cjel-3603 129 68 has have AUX cjel-3603 129 69 been be AUX cjel-3603 129 70 found find VERB cjel-3603 129 71 to to PART cjel-3603 129 72 be be AUX cjel-3603 129 73 present present ADJ cjel-3603 129 74 in in ADP cjel-3603 129 75 many many ADJ cjel-3603 129 76 cases case NOUN cjel-3603 129 77 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 130 1 for for ADP cjel-3603 130 2 instance instance NOUN cjel-3603 130 3 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 130 4 in in ADP cjel-3603 130 5 united united PROPN cjel-3603 130 6 states states PROPN cjel-3603 130 7 v. v. ADP cjel-3603 130 8 chandler chandler PROPN cjel-3603 130 9 - - PUNCT cjel-3603 130 10 dunbar dunbar PROPN cjel-3603 130 11 water water PROPN cjel-3603 130 12 power power PROPN cjel-3603 130 13 co. co. PROPN cjel-3603 130 14 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 130 15 the the DET cjel-3603 130 16 supreme supreme PROPN cjel-3603 130 17 court court PROPN cjel-3603 130 18 considered consider VERB cjel-3603 130 19 the the DET cjel-3603 130 20 act act NOUN cjel-3603 130 21 of of ADP cjel-3603 130 22 march march PROPN cjel-3603 130 23 3 3 NUM cjel-3603 130 24 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 130 25 1909 1909 NUM cjel-3603 130 26 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 130 27 which which PRON cjel-3603 130 28 forbade forbid VERB cjel-3603 130 29 the the DET cjel-3603 130 30 construction construction NOUN cjel-3603 130 31 of of ADP cjel-3603 130 32 any any DET cjel-3603 130 33 dam dam NOUN cjel-3603 130 34 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 130 35 pier pier NOUN cjel-3603 130 36 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 130 37 or or CCONJ cjel-3603 130 38 breakwater breakwater NOUN cjel-3603 130 39 on on ADP cjel-3603 130 40 the the DET cjel-3603 130 41 st st PROPN cjel-3603 130 42 . . PROPN cjel-3603 130 43 marys marys PROPN cjel-3603 130 44 river.33 river.33 VERB cjel-3603 130 45 the the DET cjel-3603 130 46 court court NOUN cjel-3603 130 47 concluded conclude VERB cjel-3603 130 48 that that SCONJ cjel-3603 130 49 the the DET cjel-3603 130 50 language language NOUN cjel-3603 130 51 of of ADP cjel-3603 130 52 the the DET cjel-3603 130 53 act act NOUN cjel-3603 130 54 “ " PUNCT cjel-3603 130 55 authorized authorize VERB cjel-3603 130 56 the the DET cjel-3603 130 57 exercise exercise NOUN cjel-3603 130 58 of of ADP cjel-3603 130 59 the the DET cjel-3603 130 60 dominant dominant ADJ cjel-3603 130 61 right right NOUN cjel-3603 130 62 of of ADP cjel-3603 130 63 the the DET cjel-3603 130 64 united united PROPN cjel-3603 130 65 states states PROPN cjel-3603 130 66 to to PART cjel-3603 130 67 take take VERB cjel-3603 130 68 all all PRON cjel-3603 130 69 of of ADP cjel-3603 130 70 a a DET cjel-3603 130 71 navigable navigable ADJ cjel-3603 130 72 river river NOUN cjel-3603 130 73 ’s ’s PART cjel-3603 130 74 flow flow NOUN cjel-3603 130 75 for for ADP cjel-3603 130 76 purposes purpose NOUN cjel-3603 130 77 of of ADP cjel-3603 130 78 interstate interstate ADJ cjel-3603 130 79 commerce commerce NOUN cjel-3603 130 80 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 131 1 ”34 ”34 PROPN cjel-3603 132 1 furthermore furthermore ADV cjel-3603 132 2 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 132 3 if if SCONJ cjel-3603 132 4 congress congress PROPN cjel-3603 132 5 intends intend VERB cjel-3603 132 6 to to PART cjel-3603 132 7 confer confer VERB cjel-3603 132 8 the the DET cjel-3603 132 9 authority authority NOUN cjel-3603 132 10 to to PART cjel-3603 132 11 exercise exercise VERB cjel-3603 132 12 the the DET cjel-3603 132 13 navigational navigational ADJ cjel-3603 132 14 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 132 15 on on ADP cjel-3603 132 16 non non ADJ cjel-3603 132 17 - - ADJ cjel-3603 132 18 federal federal ADJ cjel-3603 132 19 parties party NOUN cjel-3603 132 20 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 132 21 it it PRON cjel-3603 132 22 must must AUX cjel-3603 132 23 do do VERB cjel-3603 132 24 so so ADV cjel-3603 132 25 expressly expressly ADV cjel-3603 132 26 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 133 1 for for ADP cjel-3603 133 2 instance instance NOUN cjel-3603 133 3 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 133 4 multiple multiple ADJ cjel-3603 133 5 cases case NOUN cjel-3603 133 6 have have AUX cjel-3603 133 7 found find VERB cjel-3603 133 8 that that SCONJ cjel-3603 133 9 the the DET cjel-3603 133 10 federal federal ADJ cjel-3603 133 11 power power PROPN cjel-3603 133 12 act act PROPN cjel-3603 133 13 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 133 14 “ " PUNCT cjel-3603 133 15 fpa”)35 fpa”)35 PROPN cjel-3603 133 16 does do AUX cjel-3603 133 17 not not PART cjel-3603 133 18 confer confer VERB cjel-3603 133 19 the the DET cjel-3603 133 20 authority authority NOUN cjel-3603 133 21 to to PART cjel-3603 133 22 exercise exercise VERB cjel-3603 133 23 the the DET cjel-3603 133 24 navigational navigational ADJ cjel-3603 133 25 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 133 26 upon upon SCONJ cjel-3603 133 27 parties party NOUN cjel-3603 133 28 that that PRON cjel-3603 133 29 obtain obtain VERB cjel-3603 133 30 permits permit NOUN cjel-3603 133 31 to to PART cjel-3603 133 32 build build VERB cjel-3603 133 33 on on ADP cjel-3603 133 34 navigable navigable ADJ cjel-3603 133 35 waterways waterway NOUN cjel-3603 133 36 under under ADP cjel-3603 133 37 the the DET cjel-3603 133 38 fpa.36 fpa.36 NOUN cjel-3603 133 39 although although SCONJ cjel-3603 133 40 in in ADP cjel-3603 133 41 passing pass VERB cjel-3603 133 42 the the DET cjel-3603 133 43 fpa fpa PROPN cjel-3603 133 44 congress congress PROPN cjel-3603 133 45 had have VERB cjel-3603 133 46 the the DET cjel-3603 133 47 ability ability NOUN cjel-3603 133 48 to to PART cjel-3603 133 49 “ " PUNCT cjel-3603 133 50 vest vest VERB cjel-3603 133 51 any any DET cjel-3603 133 52 portion portion NOUN cjel-3603 133 53 of of ADP cjel-3603 133 54 its its PRON cjel-3603 133 55 sovereign sovereign ADJ cjel-3603 133 56 power power NOUN cjel-3603 133 57 in in ADP cjel-3603 133 58 the the DET cjel-3603 133 59 permittee permittee NOUN cjel-3603 133 60 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 133 61 ” " PUNCT cjel-3603 133 62 31 31 NUM cjel-3603 133 63 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 134 1 see see VERB cjel-3603 134 2 united united PROPN cjel-3603 134 3 states states PROPN cjel-3603 134 4 v. v. ADP cjel-3603 134 5 11.48 11.48 NUM cjel-3603 134 6 acres acre NOUN cjel-3603 134 7 of of ADP cjel-3603 134 8 land land NOUN cjel-3603 134 9 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 134 10 212 212 NUM cjel-3603 134 11 f.2d f.2d SYM cjel-3603 134 12 853 853 NUM cjel-3603 134 13 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 134 14 855 855 NUM cjel-3603 134 15 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 134 16 5th 5th ADJ cjel-3603 134 17 cir cir NOUN cjel-3603 134 18 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 134 19 1954 1954 NUM cjel-3603 134 20 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 135 1 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 135 2 “ " PUNCT cjel-3603 135 3 [ [ X cjel-3603 135 4 a]ppellee a]ppellee X cjel-3603 135 5 ’s ’s PART cjel-3603 135 6 riparian riparian ADJ cjel-3603 135 7 rights right NOUN cjel-3603 135 8 were be AUX cjel-3603 135 9 not not PART cjel-3603 135 10 simply simply ADV cjel-3603 135 11 subjected subject VERB cjel-3603 135 12 to to ADP cjel-3603 135 13 the the DET cjel-3603 135 14 government government NOUN cjel-3603 135 15 ’s ’s PART cjel-3603 135 16 dominant dominant ADJ cjel-3603 135 17 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 135 18 over over ADP cjel-3603 135 19 navigable navigable ADJ cjel-3603 135 20 waters water NOUN cjel-3603 135 21 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 135 22 but but CCONJ cjel-3603 135 23 those those DET cjel-3603 135 24 rights right NOUN cjel-3603 135 25 were be AUX cjel-3603 135 26 permanently permanently ADV cjel-3603 135 27 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 135 28 irrevocably irrevocably ADV cjel-3603 135 29 taken take VERB cjel-3603 135 30 by by ADP cjel-3603 135 31 the the DET cjel-3603 135 32 united united PROPN cjel-3603 135 33 states states PROPN cjel-3603 135 34 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 136 1 for for ADP cjel-3603 136 2 such such ADJ cjel-3603 136 3 taking take VERB cjel-3603 136 4 the the DET cjel-3603 136 5 fifth fifth ADJ cjel-3603 136 6 amendment amendment NOUN cjel-3603 136 7 guaranteed guarantee VERB cjel-3603 136 8 to to ADP cjel-3603 136 9 the the DET cjel-3603 136 10 appellee appellee NOUN cjel-3603 136 11 the the DET cjel-3603 136 12 right right NOUN cjel-3603 136 13 to to ADP cjel-3603 136 14 just just ADV cjel-3603 136 15 compensation compensation NOUN cjel-3603 136 16 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 136 17 ” " PUNCT cjel-3603 136 18 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 136 19 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 137 1 32 32 NUM cjel-3603 137 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 138 1 pub pub NOUN cjel-3603 138 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 139 1 util util PROPN cjel-3603 139 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 139 3 dist dist NOUN cjel-3603 139 4 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 140 1 no no INTJ cjel-3603 140 2 . . NOUN cjel-3603 140 3 1 1 NUM cjel-3603 140 4 of of ADP cjel-3603 140 5 pend pend PROPN cjel-3603 140 6 oreille oreille PROPN cjel-3603 140 7 cnty cnty PROPN cjel-3603 140 8 . . PROPN cjel-3603 140 9 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 140 10 382 382 NUM cjel-3603 140 11 f.2d f.2d X cjel-3603 140 12 at at ADP cjel-3603 140 13 670 670 NUM cjel-3603 140 14 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 141 1 33 33 NUM cjel-3603 141 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 142 1 united united PROPN cjel-3603 142 2 states states PROPN cjel-3603 142 3 v. v. ADP cjel-3603 142 4 chandler chandler PROPN cjel-3603 142 5 - - PUNCT cjel-3603 142 6 dunbar dunbar PROPN cjel-3603 142 7 water water PROPN cjel-3603 142 8 power power PROPN cjel-3603 142 9 co. co. PROPN cjel-3603 142 10 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 142 11 229 229 NUM cjel-3603 142 12 u.s u.s PROPN cjel-3603 142 13 . . PROPN cjel-3603 142 14 53 53 NUM cjel-3603 142 15 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 142 16 1913 1913 NUM cjel-3603 142 17 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 142 18 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 143 1 34 34 NUM cjel-3603 143 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 143 3 fed fed PROPN cjel-3603 143 4 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 144 1 power power NOUN cjel-3603 144 2 comm’n comm’n NOUN cjel-3603 144 3 v. v. ADP cjel-3603 144 4 niagara niagara PROPN cjel-3603 144 5 mohawk mohawk PROPN cjel-3603 144 6 power power PROPN cjel-3603 144 7 corp corp PROPN cjel-3603 144 8 . . PROPN cjel-3603 144 9 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 144 10 347 347 NUM cjel-3603 144 11 u.s u.s AUX cjel-3603 144 12 . . PROPN cjel-3603 144 13 239 239 NUM cjel-3603 144 14 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 144 15 249 249 NUM cjel-3603 144 16 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 144 17 1954 1954 NUM cjel-3603 144 18 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 144 19 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 144 20 citing cite VERB cjel-3603 144 21 chandler chandler NOUN cjel-3603 144 22 - - PUNCT cjel-3603 144 23 dunbar dunbar PROPN cjel-3603 144 24 water water PROPN cjel-3603 144 25 power power PROPN cjel-3603 144 26 co. co. PROPN cjel-3603 144 27 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 144 28 229 229 NUM cjel-3603 144 29 u.s u.s PROPN cjel-3603 144 30 . . PROPN cjel-3603 144 31 at at ADP cjel-3603 144 32 56 56 NUM cjel-3603 144 33 n.† n.† NOUN cjel-3603 144 34 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 144 35 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 145 1 35 35 NUM cjel-3603 145 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 146 1 federal federal PROPN cjel-3603 146 2 power power PROPN cjel-3603 146 3 act act PROPN cjel-3603 146 4 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 146 5 16 16 NUM cjel-3603 146 6 u.s.c u.s.c ADJ cjel-3603 146 7 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 147 1 § § PROPN cjel-3603 147 2 § § PROPN cjel-3603 147 3 791a–828c 791a–828c NUM cjel-3603 147 4 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 147 5 2012 2012 NUM cjel-3603 147 6 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 147 7 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 148 1 36 36 NUM cjel-3603 148 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 149 1 see see VERB cjel-3603 149 2 niagara niagara PROPN cjel-3603 149 3 mohawk mohawk PROPN cjel-3603 149 4 power power PROPN cjel-3603 149 5 corp corp PROPN cjel-3603 149 6 . . PROPN cjel-3603 149 7 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 149 8 347 347 NUM cjel-3603 149 9 u.s u.s PROPN cjel-3603 149 10 . . PROPN cjel-3603 149 11 at at ADP cjel-3603 149 12 250 250 NUM cjel-3603 149 13 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 149 14 holding hold VERB cjel-3603 149 15 that that SCONJ cjel-3603 149 16 the the DET cjel-3603 149 17 federal federal ADJ cjel-3603 149 18 power power NOUN cjel-3603 149 19 act act NOUN cjel-3603 149 20 should should AUX cjel-3603 149 21 not not PART cjel-3603 149 22 be be AUX cjel-3603 149 23 given give VERB cjel-3603 149 24 the the DET cjel-3603 149 25 same same ADJ cjel-3603 149 26 “ " PUNCT cjel-3603 149 27 drastic drastic ADJ cjel-3603 149 28 effect effect NOUN cjel-3603 149 29 ” " PUNCT cjel-3603 149 30 of of ADP cjel-3603 149 31 the the DET cjel-3603 149 32 act act NOUN cjel-3603 149 33 of of ADP cjel-3603 149 34 march march PROPN cjel-3603 149 35 3 3 NUM cjel-3603 149 36 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 149 37 1909 1909 NUM cjel-3603 149 38 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 149 39 ; ; PUNCT cjel-3603 150 1 pub pub NOUN cjel-3603 150 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 150 3 util util PROPN cjel-3603 150 4 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 150 5 dist dist NOUN cjel-3603 150 6 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 151 1 no no INTJ cjel-3603 151 2 . . NOUN cjel-3603 151 3 1 1 NUM cjel-3603 151 4 of of ADP cjel-3603 151 5 pend pend PROPN cjel-3603 151 6 oreille oreille PROPN cjel-3603 151 7 cnty cnty PROPN cjel-3603 151 8 . . PROPN cjel-3603 151 9 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 151 10 382 382 NUM cjel-3603 151 11 f.2d f.2d NOUN cjel-3603 151 12 at at ADP cjel-3603 151 13 673 673 NUM cjel-3603 151 14 ; ; PUNCT cjel-3603 151 15 united united PROPN cjel-3603 151 16 states states PROPN cjel-3603 151 17 v. v. ADP cjel-3603 151 18 cent cent NOUN cjel-3603 151 19 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 152 1 stockholder stockholder PROPN cjel-3603 152 2 ’s ’s PART cjel-3603 152 3 corp corp PROPN cjel-3603 152 4 . . PROPN cjel-3603 152 5 of of ADP cjel-3603 152 6 vallejo vallejo PROPN cjel-3603 152 7 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 152 8 52 52 NUM cjel-3603 152 9 f.2d f.2d NOUN cjel-3603 152 10 322 322 NUM cjel-3603 152 11 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 152 12 332 332 NUM cjel-3603 152 13 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 152 14 9th 9th ADJ cjel-3603 152 15 cir cir NOUN cjel-3603 152 16 . . PROPN cjel-3603 152 17 1931 1931 NUM cjel-3603 152 18 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 152 19 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 152 20 “ " PUNCT cjel-3603 152 21 [ [ X cjel-3603 152 22 i]n i]n NOUN cjel-3603 152 23 so so ADV cjel-3603 152 24 far far ADV cjel-3603 152 25 as as SCONJ cjel-3603 152 26 the the DET cjel-3603 152 27 project project NOUN cjel-3603 152 28 of of ADP cjel-3603 152 29 the the DET cjel-3603 152 30 permittee permittee NOUN cjel-3603 152 31 is be AUX cjel-3603 152 32 in in ADP cjel-3603 152 33 aid aid NOUN cjel-3603 152 34 of of ADP cjel-3603 152 35 navigation navigation NOUN cjel-3603 152 36 it it PRON cjel-3603 152 37 is be AUX cjel-3603 152 38 not not PART cjel-3603 152 39 clothed clothe VERB cjel-3603 152 40 with with ADP cjel-3603 152 41 any any PRON cjel-3603 152 42 of of ADP cjel-3603 152 43 the the DET cjel-3603 152 44 sovereign sovereign ADJ cjel-3603 152 45 rights right NOUN cjel-3603 152 46 of of ADP cjel-3603 152 47 the the DET cjel-3603 152 48 united united PROPN cjel-3603 152 49 states states PROPN cjel-3603 152 50 to to PART cjel-3603 152 51 control control VERB cjel-3603 152 52 the the DET cjel-3603 152 53 navigation navigation NOUN cjel-3603 152 54 of of ADP cjel-3603 152 55 the the DET cjel-3603 152 56 stream stream NOUN cjel-3603 152 57 which which PRON cjel-3603 152 58 may may AUX cjel-3603 152 59 be be AUX cjel-3603 152 60 in in ADP cjel-3603 152 61 conflict conflict NOUN cjel-3603 152 62 with with ADP cjel-3603 152 63 the the DET cjel-3603 152 64 riparian riparian ADJ cjel-3603 152 65 rights right NOUN cjel-3603 152 66 of of ADP cjel-3603 152 67 the the DET cjel-3603 152 68 property property NOUN cjel-3603 152 69 owners owner NOUN cjel-3603 152 70 to to PART cjel-3603 152 71 recover recover VERB cjel-3603 152 72 damages damage NOUN cjel-3603 152 73 for for ADP cjel-3603 152 74 losses loss NOUN cjel-3603 152 75 of of ADP cjel-3603 152 76 property property NOUN cjel-3603 152 77 due due ADP cjel-3603 152 78 to to ADP cjel-3603 152 79 such such ADJ cjel-3603 152 80 dam dam NOUN cjel-3603 152 81 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 152 82 ” " PUNCT cjel-3603 152 83 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 152 84 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 153 1 monahan monahan PROPN cjel-3603 153 2 - - PUNCT cjel-3603 153 3 macro-[final macro-[final PROPN cjel-3603 153 4 6 6 NUM cjel-3603 153 5 - - SYM cjel-3603 153 6 20 20 NUM cjel-3603 153 7 ] ] PUNCT cjel-3603 153 8 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 153 9 do do AUX cjel-3603 153 10 not not PART cjel-3603 153 11 delete delete VERB cjel-3603 153 12 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 153 13 6/22/2015 6/22/2015 NUM cjel-3603 153 14 11:53 11:53 NUM cjel-3603 153 15 pm pm NOUN cjel-3603 153 16 366 366 NUM cjel-3603 153 17 columbia columbia PROPN cjel-3603 153 18 journal journal PROPN cjel-3603 153 19 of of ADP cjel-3603 153 20 environmental environmental ADJ cjel-3603 153 21 law law NOUN cjel-3603 154 1 [ [ X cjel-3603 154 2 vol vol NOUN cjel-3603 154 3 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 155 1 40:2 40:2 NUM cjel-3603 155 2 courts court NOUN cjel-3603 155 3 have have AUX cjel-3603 155 4 determined determine VERB cjel-3603 155 5 that that SCONJ cjel-3603 155 6 “ " PUNCT cjel-3603 155 7 it it PRON cjel-3603 155 8 was be AUX cjel-3603 155 9 not not PART cjel-3603 155 10 the the DET cjel-3603 155 11 intention intention NOUN cjel-3603 155 12 of of ADP cjel-3603 155 13 the the DET cjel-3603 155 14 government government NOUN cjel-3603 155 15 so so SCONJ cjel-3603 155 16 to to PART cjel-3603 155 17 do do AUX cjel-3603 155 18 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 155 19 ”37 ”37 PUNCT cjel-3603 156 1 thus thus ADV cjel-3603 156 2 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 156 3 when when SCONJ cjel-3603 156 4 a a DET cjel-3603 156 5 permittee permittee NOUN cjel-3603 156 6 interferes interfere VERB cjel-3603 156 7 with with ADP cjel-3603 156 8 state state NOUN cjel-3603 156 9 - - PUNCT cjel-3603 156 10 recognized recognize VERB cjel-3603 156 11 property property NOUN cjel-3603 156 12 rights right NOUN cjel-3603 156 13 of of ADP cjel-3603 156 14 other other ADJ cjel-3603 156 15 landowners landowner NOUN cjel-3603 156 16 for for ADP cjel-3603 156 17 which which PRON cjel-3603 156 18 the the DET cjel-3603 156 19 federal federal ADJ cjel-3603 156 20 government government NOUN cjel-3603 156 21 would would AUX cjel-3603 156 22 be be AUX cjel-3603 156 23 immune immune ADJ cjel-3603 156 24 from from ADP cjel-3603 156 25 paying pay VERB cjel-3603 156 26 compensation compensation NOUN cjel-3603 156 27 due due ADP cjel-3603 156 28 to to ADP cjel-3603 156 29 the the DET cjel-3603 156 30 navigational navigational ADJ cjel-3603 156 31 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 156 32 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 156 33 no no DET cjel-3603 156 34 such such ADJ cjel-3603 156 35 defense defense NOUN cjel-3603 156 36 is be AUX cjel-3603 156 37 available available ADJ cjel-3603 156 38 to to ADP cjel-3603 156 39 the the DET cjel-3603 156 40 permittee.38 permittee.38 NOUN cjel-3603 156 41 unable unable ADJ cjel-3603 156 42 to to PART cjel-3603 156 43 avail avail VERB cjel-3603 156 44 itself itself PRON cjel-3603 156 45 of of ADP cjel-3603 156 46 the the DET cjel-3603 156 47 navigational navigational ADJ cjel-3603 156 48 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 156 49 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 156 50 the the DET cjel-3603 156 51 permittee permittee NOUN cjel-3603 156 52 must must AUX cjel-3603 156 53 pay pay VERB cjel-3603 156 54 compensation compensation NOUN cjel-3603 156 55 although although SCONJ cjel-3603 156 56 the the DET cjel-3603 156 57 federal federal ADJ cjel-3603 156 58 government government NOUN cjel-3603 156 59 would would AUX cjel-3603 156 60 not.39 not.39 VERB cjel-3603 156 61 v. v. ADP cjel-3603 156 62 the the DET cjel-3603 156 63 purpose purpose NOUN cjel-3603 156 64 to to PART cjel-3603 156 65 aid aid VERB cjel-3603 156 66 in in ADP cjel-3603 156 67 navigation navigation NOUN cjel-3603 156 68 a a DET cjel-3603 156 69 more more ADV cjel-3603 156 70 complex complex ADJ cjel-3603 156 71 limitation limitation NOUN cjel-3603 156 72 on on ADP cjel-3603 156 73 the the DET cjel-3603 156 74 navigational navigational ADJ cjel-3603 156 75 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 156 76 is be AUX cjel-3603 156 77 the the DET cjel-3603 156 78 requirement requirement NOUN cjel-3603 156 79 that that SCONJ cjel-3603 156 80 the the DET cjel-3603 156 81 government government NOUN cjel-3603 156 82 ’s ’s PART cjel-3603 156 83 actions action NOUN cjel-3603 156 84 have have AUX cjel-3603 156 85 a a DET cjel-3603 156 86 purpose purpose NOUN cjel-3603 156 87 to to PART cjel-3603 156 88 aid aid VERB cjel-3603 156 89 in in ADP cjel-3603 156 90 navigation.40 navigation.40 NOUN cjel-3603 156 91 because because SCONJ cjel-3603 156 92 the the DET cjel-3603 156 93 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 156 94 is be AUX cjel-3603 156 95 a a DET cjel-3603 156 96 result result NOUN cjel-3603 156 97 of of ADP cjel-3603 156 98 the the DET cjel-3603 156 99 federal federal ADJ cjel-3603 156 100 government government NOUN cjel-3603 156 101 ’s ’s PART cjel-3603 156 102 ability ability NOUN cjel-3603 156 103 to to PART cjel-3603 156 104 regulate regulate VERB cjel-3603 156 105 navigation navigation NOUN cjel-3603 156 106 as as ADP cjel-3603 156 107 an an DET cjel-3603 156 108 instrumentality instrumentality NOUN cjel-3603 156 109 of of ADP cjel-3603 156 110 interstate interstate PROPN cjel-3603 156 111 commerce commerce PROPN cjel-3603 156 112 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 156 113 the the DET cjel-3603 156 114 government government NOUN cjel-3603 156 115 ’s ’s PART cjel-3603 156 116 actions action NOUN cjel-3603 156 117 must must AUX cjel-3603 156 118 have have VERB cjel-3603 156 119 a a DET cjel-3603 156 120 purpose purpose NOUN cjel-3603 156 121 to to PART cjel-3603 156 122 aid aid VERB cjel-3603 156 123 in in ADP cjel-3603 156 124 navigation navigation NOUN cjel-3603 156 125 to to PART cjel-3603 156 126 qualify qualify VERB cjel-3603 156 127 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 157 1 the the DET cjel-3603 157 2 purpose purpose NOUN cjel-3603 157 3 to to PART cjel-3603 157 4 aid aid VERB cjel-3603 157 5 in in ADP cjel-3603 157 6 navigation navigation NOUN cjel-3603 157 7 has have AUX cjel-3603 157 8 been be AUX cjel-3603 157 9 interpreted interpret VERB cjel-3603 157 10 broadly broadly ADV cjel-3603 157 11 by by ADP cjel-3603 157 12 courts court NOUN cjel-3603 157 13 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 158 1 the the DET cjel-3603 158 2 supreme supreme PROPN cjel-3603 158 3 court court PROPN cjel-3603 158 4 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 158 5 in in ADP cjel-3603 158 6 united united PROPN cjel-3603 158 7 states states PROPN cjel-3603 158 8 v. v. PROPN cjel-3603 158 9 appalachian appalachian PROPN cjel-3603 158 10 elec elec PROPN cjel-3603 158 11 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 158 12 power power PROPN cjel-3603 158 13 co. co. PROPN cjel-3603 158 14 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 158 15 described describe VERB cjel-3603 158 16 the the DET cjel-3603 158 17 vast vast ADJ cjel-3603 158 18 reach reach NOUN cjel-3603 158 19 of of ADP cjel-3603 158 20 the the DET cjel-3603 158 21 term term NOUN cjel-3603 158 22 “ " PUNCT cjel-3603 158 23 navigability navigability NOUN cjel-3603 158 24 ” " PUNCT cjel-3603 158 25 : : PUNCT cjel-3603 158 26 navigability navigability NOUN cjel-3603 158 27 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 158 28 in in ADP cjel-3603 158 29 the the DET cjel-3603 158 30 sense sense NOUN cjel-3603 158 31 just just ADV cjel-3603 158 32 stated state VERB cjel-3603 158 33 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 158 34 [ [ X cjel-3603 158 35 operation operation NOUN cjel-3603 158 36 of of ADP cjel-3603 158 37 boats boat NOUN cjel-3603 158 38 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 158 39 improvement improvement NOUN cjel-3603 158 40 of of ADP cjel-3603 158 41 the the DET cjel-3603 158 42 waterway waterway NOUN cjel-3603 158 43 itself itself PRON cjel-3603 158 44 ] ] PUNCT cjel-3603 158 45 is be AUX cjel-3603 158 46 but but CCONJ cjel-3603 158 47 a a DET cjel-3603 158 48 part part NOUN cjel-3603 158 49 of of ADP cjel-3603 158 50 this this DET cjel-3603 158 51 whole whole NOUN cjel-3603 158 52 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 159 1 flood flood NOUN cjel-3603 159 2 protection protection PROPN cjel-3603 159 3 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 159 4 watershed watershe VERB cjel-3603 159 5 development development NOUN cjel-3603 159 6 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 159 7 recovery recovery NOUN cjel-3603 159 8 of of ADP cjel-3603 159 9 the the DET cjel-3603 159 10 cost cost NOUN cjel-3603 159 11 of of ADP cjel-3603 159 12 improvements improvement NOUN cjel-3603 159 13 through through ADP cjel-3603 159 14 utilization utilization NOUN cjel-3603 159 15 of of ADP cjel-3603 159 16 power power NOUN cjel-3603 159 17 are be AUX cjel-3603 159 18 likewise likewise ADV cjel-3603 159 19 parts part NOUN cjel-3603 159 20 of of ADP cjel-3603 159 21 commerce commerce NOUN cjel-3603 159 22 control control NOUN cjel-3603 159 23 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 159 24 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 159 25 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 159 26 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 160 1 the the DET cjel-3603 160 2 point point NOUN cjel-3603 160 3 is be AUX cjel-3603 160 4 that that SCONJ cjel-3603 160 5 navigable navigable ADJ cjel-3603 160 6 waters water NOUN cjel-3603 160 7 are be AUX cjel-3603 160 8 37 37 NUM cjel-3603 160 9 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 161 1 pub pub NOUN cjel-3603 161 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 162 1 util util PROPN cjel-3603 162 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 162 3 dist dist NOUN cjel-3603 162 4 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 163 1 no no INTJ cjel-3603 163 2 . . NOUN cjel-3603 163 3 1 1 NUM cjel-3603 163 4 of of ADP cjel-3603 163 5 pend pend PROPN cjel-3603 163 6 oreille oreille PROPN cjel-3603 163 7 cnty cnty PROPN cjel-3603 163 8 . . PROPN cjel-3603 163 9 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 163 10 382 382 NUM cjel-3603 163 11 f.2d f.2d NOUN cjel-3603 163 12 at at ADP cjel-3603 163 13 671 671 NUM cjel-3603 163 14 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 163 15 citing cite VERB cjel-3603 163 16 cent cent NOUN cjel-3603 163 17 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 164 1 stockholder stockholder PROPN cjel-3603 164 2 ’s ’s PART cjel-3603 164 3 corp corp PROPN cjel-3603 164 4 . . PROPN cjel-3603 164 5 of of ADP cjel-3603 164 6 vallejo vallejo PROPN cjel-3603 164 7 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 164 8 52 52 NUM cjel-3603 164 9 f.2d f.2d NOUN cjel-3603 164 10 at at ADP cjel-3603 164 11 332 332 NUM cjel-3603 164 12 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 164 13 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 165 1 38 38 NUM cjel-3603 165 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 166 1 see see VERB cjel-3603 166 2 i i PRON cjel-3603 166 3 d. d. PROPN cjel-3603 166 4 at at ADP cjel-3603 166 5 670 670 NUM cjel-3603 166 6 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 166 7 “ " PUNCT cjel-3603 166 8 [ [ X cjel-3603 166 9 b]eyond b]eyond ADP cjel-3603 166 10 mere mere ADJ cjel-3603 166 11 silence silence NOUN cjel-3603 166 12 as as ADP cjel-3603 166 13 to to ADP cjel-3603 166 14 such such ADJ cjel-3603 166 15 legislative legislative ADJ cjel-3603 166 16 intent intent NOUN cjel-3603 166 17 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 166 18 the the DET cjel-3603 166 19 language language NOUN cjel-3603 166 20 in in ADP cjel-3603 166 21 the the DET cjel-3603 166 22 power power NOUN cjel-3603 166 23 act act NOUN cjel-3603 166 24 has have AUX cjel-3603 166 25 been be AUX cjel-3603 166 26 interpreted interpret VERB cjel-3603 166 27 to to PART cjel-3603 166 28 constitute constitute VERB cjel-3603 166 29 an an DET cjel-3603 166 30 express express ADJ cjel-3603 166 31 denial denial NOUN cjel-3603 166 32 of of ADP cjel-3603 166 33 the the DET cjel-3603 166 34 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 166 35 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 166 36 ” " PUNCT cjel-3603 166 37 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 166 38 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 167 1 39 39 NUM cjel-3603 167 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 168 1 i i PRON cjel-3603 168 2 d. d. PROPN cjel-3603 168 3 at at ADP cjel-3603 168 4 672 672 NUM cjel-3603 168 5 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 168 6 “ " PUNCT cjel-3603 168 7 seattle seattle NOUN cjel-3603 168 8 as as ADP cjel-3603 168 9 licensee licensee PROPN cjel-3603 168 10 of of ADP cjel-3603 168 11 fpc fpc PROPN cjel-3603 168 12 may may AUX cjel-3603 168 13 not not PART cjel-3603 168 14 assert assert VERB cjel-3603 168 15 the the DET cjel-3603 168 16 government government NOUN cjel-3603 168 17 ’s ’s PART cjel-3603 168 18 dominant dominant ADJ cjel-3603 168 19 navigational navigational ADJ cjel-3603 168 20 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 168 21 ; ; PUNCT cjel-3603 168 22 that that SCONJ cjel-3603 168 23 if if SCONJ cjel-3603 168 24 shorelands shoreland NOUN cjel-3603 168 25 are be AUX cjel-3603 168 26 necessary necessary ADJ cjel-3603 168 27 to to ADP cjel-3603 168 28 its its PRON cjel-3603 168 29 projects project NOUN cjel-3603 168 30 they they PRON cjel-3603 168 31 must must AUX cjel-3603 168 32 be be AUX cjel-3603 168 33 taken take VERB cjel-3603 168 34 in in ADP cjel-3603 168 35 the the DET cjel-3603 168 36 constitutional constitutional ADJ cjel-3603 168 37 sense sense NOUN cjel-3603 168 38 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 168 39 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 168 40 compensation compensation NOUN cjel-3603 168 41 for for ADP cjel-3603 168 42 the the DET cjel-3603 168 43 taking taking NOUN cjel-3603 168 44 must must AUX cjel-3603 168 45 follow follow VERB cjel-3603 168 46 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 168 47 ” " PUNCT cjel-3603 168 48 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 168 49 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 169 1 40 40 NUM cjel-3603 169 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 170 1 see see VERB cjel-3603 170 2 scranton scranton PROPN cjel-3603 170 3 v. v. PROPN cjel-3603 170 4 wheeler wheeler NOUN cjel-3603 170 5 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 170 6 179 179 NUM cjel-3603 170 7 u.s u.s PROPN cjel-3603 170 8 . . PROPN cjel-3603 170 9 141 141 NUM cjel-3603 170 10 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 170 11 145 145 NUM cjel-3603 170 12 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 170 13 1900 1900 NUM cjel-3603 170 14 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 170 15 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 170 16 discussing discuss VERB cjel-3603 170 17 the the DET cjel-3603 170 18 “ " PUNCT cjel-3603 170 19 right right NOUN cjel-3603 170 20 of of ADP cjel-3603 170 21 congress congress PROPN cjel-3603 170 22 to to PART cjel-3603 170 23 regulate regulate VERB cjel-3603 170 24 commerce commerce NOUN cjel-3603 170 25 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 170 26 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 170 27 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 170 28 as as ADP cjel-3603 170 29 an an DET cjel-3603 170 30 incident incident NOUN cjel-3603 170 31 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 170 32 navigation navigation NOUN cjel-3603 170 33 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 170 34 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 170 35 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 170 36 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 170 37 ” " PUNCT cjel-3603 170 38 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 170 39 ; ; PUNCT cjel-3603 170 40 united united PROPN cjel-3603 170 41 states states PROPN cjel-3603 170 42 v. v. ADP cjel-3603 170 43 gerlach gerlach PROPN cjel-3603 170 44 live live VERB cjel-3603 170 45 stock stock PROPN cjel-3603 170 46 co. co. PROPN cjel-3603 170 47 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 170 48 339 339 NUM cjel-3603 170 49 u.s u.s PROPN cjel-3603 170 50 . . PROPN cjel-3603 170 51 725 725 NUM cjel-3603 170 52 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 170 53 737 737 NUM cjel-3603 170 54 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 170 55 1950 1950 NUM cjel-3603 170 56 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 170 57 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 170 58 “ " PUNCT cjel-3603 170 59 [ [ X cjel-3603 170 60 t]his t]his ADP cjel-3603 170 61 court court NOUN cjel-3603 170 62 has have AUX cjel-3603 170 63 never never ADV cjel-3603 170 64 permitted permit VERB cjel-3603 170 65 the the DET cjel-3603 170 66 government government NOUN cjel-3603 170 67 to to PART cjel-3603 170 68 pervert pervert VERB cjel-3603 170 69 its its PRON cjel-3603 170 70 navigation navigation NOUN cjel-3603 170 71 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 170 72 into into ADP cjel-3603 170 73 a a DET cjel-3603 170 74 right right NOUN cjel-3603 170 75 to to PART cjel-3603 170 76 destroy destroy VERB cjel-3603 170 77 riparian riparian ADJ cjel-3603 170 78 interests interest NOUN cjel-3603 170 79 without without ADP cjel-3603 170 80 reimbursement reimbursement NOUN cjel-3603 170 81 where where SCONJ cjel-3603 170 82 no no DET cjel-3603 170 83 navigation navigation NOUN cjel-3603 170 84 purpose purpose NOUN cjel-3603 170 85 existed exist VERB cjel-3603 170 86 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 170 87 ” " PUNCT cjel-3603 170 88 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 170 89 ; ; PUNCT cjel-3603 170 90 see see VERB cjel-3603 170 91 also also ADV cjel-3603 170 92 port port NOUN cjel-3603 170 93 of of ADP cjel-3603 170 94 seattle seattle PROPN cjel-3603 170 95 v. v. PROPN cjel-3603 170 96 oregon oregon PROPN cjel-3603 170 97 & & CCONJ cjel-3603 170 98 w. w. PROPN cjel-3603 170 99 r. r. PROPN cjel-3603 170 100 co. co. PROPN cjel-3603 170 101 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 170 102 255 255 NUM cjel-3603 170 103 u.s u.s PROPN cjel-3603 170 104 . . PROPN cjel-3603 170 105 56 56 NUM cjel-3603 170 106 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 170 107 63 63 NUM cjel-3603 170 108 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 170 109 1921 1921 NUM cjel-3603 170 110 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 170 111 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 170 112 “ " PUNCT cjel-3603 170 113 the the DET cjel-3603 170 114 right right NOUN cjel-3603 170 115 of of ADP cjel-3603 170 116 the the DET cjel-3603 170 117 united united PROPN cjel-3603 170 118 states states PROPN cjel-3603 170 119 in in ADP cjel-3603 170 120 the the DET cjel-3603 170 121 navigable navigable ADJ cjel-3603 170 122 waters water NOUN cjel-3603 170 123 within within ADP cjel-3603 170 124 the the DET cjel-3603 170 125 several several ADJ cjel-3603 170 126 states state NOUN cjel-3603 170 127 is be AUX cjel-3603 170 128 limited limit VERB cjel-3603 170 129 to to ADP cjel-3603 170 130 the the DET cjel-3603 170 131 control control NOUN cjel-3603 170 132 thereof thereof ADV cjel-3603 170 133 for for ADP cjel-3603 170 134 purposes purpose NOUN cjel-3603 170 135 of of ADP cjel-3603 170 136 navigation navigation NOUN cjel-3603 170 137 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 170 138 ” " PUNCT cjel-3603 170 139 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 170 140 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 171 1 monahan monahan PROPN cjel-3603 171 2 - - PUNCT cjel-3603 171 3 macro-[final macro-[final PROPN cjel-3603 171 4 6 6 NUM cjel-3603 171 5 - - SYM cjel-3603 171 6 20 20 NUM cjel-3603 171 7 ] ] PUNCT cjel-3603 171 8 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 171 9 do do AUX cjel-3603 171 10 not not PART cjel-3603 171 11 delete delete VERB cjel-3603 171 12 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 171 13 6/22/2015 6/22/2015 NUM cjel-3603 171 14 11:53 11:53 NUM cjel-3603 171 15 pm pm NOUN cjel-3603 171 16 2015 2015 NUM cjel-3603 171 17 ] ] PUNCT cjel-3603 171 18 the the DET cjel-3603 171 19 navigational navigational ADJ cjel-3603 171 20 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 171 21 367 367 NUM cjel-3603 171 22 subject subject NOUN cjel-3603 171 23 to to ADP cjel-3603 171 24 national national ADJ cjel-3603 171 25 planning planning NOUN cjel-3603 171 26 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 171 27 control control NOUN cjel-3603 171 28 in in ADP cjel-3603 171 29 the the DET cjel-3603 171 30 broad broad ADJ cjel-3603 171 31 regulation regulation NOUN cjel-3603 171 32 of of ADP cjel-3603 171 33 commerce commerce NOUN cjel-3603 171 34 granted grant VERB cjel-3603 171 35 the the DET cjel-3603 171 36 federal federal ADJ cjel-3603 171 37 government.41 government.41 PROPN cjel-3603 171 38 thus thus ADV cjel-3603 171 39 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 171 40 projects project NOUN cjel-3603 171 41 such such ADJ cjel-3603 171 42 as as ADP cjel-3603 171 43 the the DET cjel-3603 171 44 building building NOUN cjel-3603 171 45 of of ADP cjel-3603 171 46 dams42 dams42 NOUN cjel-3603 171 47 are be AUX cjel-3603 171 48 almost almost ADV cjel-3603 171 49 always always ADV cjel-3603 171 50 found find VERB cjel-3603 171 51 to to PART cjel-3603 171 52 be be AUX cjel-3603 171 53 a a DET cjel-3603 171 54 valid valid ADJ cjel-3603 171 55 use use NOUN cjel-3603 171 56 of of ADP cjel-3603 171 57 the the DET cjel-3603 171 58 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 171 59 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 171 60 even even ADV cjel-3603 171 61 if if SCONJ cjel-3603 171 62 not not PART cjel-3603 171 63 strictly strictly ADV cjel-3603 171 64 or or CCONJ cjel-3603 171 65 primarily primarily ADV cjel-3603 171 66 done do VERB cjel-3603 171 67 to to ADP cjel-3603 171 68 further far ADV cjel-3603 171 69 navigation.43 navigation.43 ADJ cjel-3603 171 70 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 171 71 although although SCONJ cjel-3603 171 72 “ " PUNCT cjel-3603 171 73 [ [ X cjel-3603 171 74 t]he t]he ADJ cjel-3603 171 75 precedents precedent NOUN cjel-3603 171 76 clearly clearly ADV cjel-3603 171 77 establish establish VERB cjel-3603 171 78 that that SCONJ cjel-3603 171 79 the the DET cjel-3603 171 80 government government NOUN cjel-3603 171 81 ’s ’s PART cjel-3603 171 82 purpose purpose NOUN cjel-3603 171 83 must must AUX cjel-3603 171 84 be be AUX cjel-3603 171 85 related relate VERB cjel-3603 171 86 to to ADP cjel-3603 171 87 navigation navigation NOUN cjel-3603 171 88 if if SCONJ cjel-3603 171 89 it it PRON cjel-3603 171 90 wishes wish VERB cjel-3603 171 91 to to PART cjel-3603 171 92 avoid avoid VERB cjel-3603 171 93 paying pay VERB cjel-3603 171 94 compensation compensation NOUN cjel-3603 171 95 for for ADP cjel-3603 171 96 the the DET cjel-3603 171 97 regulation regulation NOUN cjel-3603 171 98 or or CCONJ cjel-3603 171 99 control control NOUN cjel-3603 171 100 of of ADP cjel-3603 171 101 private private ADJ cjel-3603 171 102 property,”44 property,”44 NOUN cjel-3603 171 103 the the DET cjel-3603 171 104 determination determination NOUN cjel-3603 171 105 of of ADP cjel-3603 171 106 a a DET cjel-3603 171 107 purpose purpose NOUN cjel-3603 171 108 to to PART cjel-3603 171 109 improve improve VERB cjel-3603 171 110 navigation navigation NOUN cjel-3603 171 111 “ " PUNCT cjel-3603 171 112 is be AUX cjel-3603 171 113 a a DET cjel-3603 171 114 matter matter NOUN cjel-3603 171 115 entirely entirely ADV cjel-3603 171 116 within within ADP cjel-3603 171 117 the the DET cjel-3603 171 118 broad broad ADJ cjel-3603 171 119 discretion discretion NOUN cjel-3603 171 120 of of ADP cjel-3603 171 121 the the DET cjel-3603 171 122 legislative legislative ADJ cjel-3603 171 123 branch branch NOUN cjel-3603 171 124 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 172 1 ”45 ”45 PROPN cjel-3603 172 2 the the DET cjel-3603 172 3 supreme supreme PROPN cjel-3603 172 4 court court PROPN cjel-3603 172 5 has have AUX cjel-3603 172 6 directed direct VERB cjel-3603 172 7 courts court NOUN cjel-3603 172 8 not not PART cjel-3603 172 9 to to PART cjel-3603 172 10 “ " PUNCT cjel-3603 172 11 substitute substitute VERB cjel-3603 172 12 their their PRON cjel-3603 172 13 judgments judgment NOUN cjel-3603 172 14 for for ADP cjel-3603 172 15 congressional congressional ADJ cjel-3603 172 16 decisions decision NOUN cjel-3603 172 17 on on ADP cjel-3603 172 18 what what PRON cjel-3603 172 19 is be AUX cjel-3603 172 20 or or CCONJ cjel-3603 172 21 is be AUX cjel-3603 172 22 not not PART cjel-3603 172 23 necessary necessary ADJ cjel-3603 172 24 for for ADP cjel-3603 172 25 the the DET cjel-3603 172 26 improvement improvement NOUN cjel-3603 172 27 or or CCONJ cjel-3603 172 28 protection protection NOUN cjel-3603 172 29 of of ADP cjel-3603 172 30 navigation navigation NOUN cjel-3603 172 31 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 173 1 ”46 ”46 VERB cjel-3603 173 2 this this DET cjel-3603 173 3 deference deference NOUN cjel-3603 173 4 suggests suggest VERB cjel-3603 173 5 that that SCONJ cjel-3603 173 6 judicial judicial ADJ cjel-3603 173 7 review review NOUN cjel-3603 173 8 of of ADP cjel-3603 173 9 the the DET cjel-3603 173 10 navigational navigational ADJ cjel-3603 173 11 purpose purpose NOUN cjel-3603 173 12 provides provide VERB cjel-3603 173 13 at at ADP cjel-3603 173 14 best good ADJ cjel-3603 173 15 a a DET cjel-3603 173 16 very very ADV cjel-3603 173 17 weak weak ADJ cjel-3603 173 18 check check NOUN cjel-3603 173 19 on on ADP cjel-3603 173 20 the the DET cjel-3603 173 21 broad broad ADJ cjel-3603 173 22 power power NOUN cjel-3603 173 23 of of ADP cjel-3603 173 24 the the DET cjel-3603 173 25 navigational navigational ADJ cjel-3603 173 26 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 173 27 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 174 1 despite despite SCONJ cjel-3603 174 2 the the DET cjel-3603 174 3 breadth breadth NOUN cjel-3603 174 4 of of ADP cjel-3603 174 5 this this DET cjel-3603 174 6 test test NOUN cjel-3603 174 7 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 174 8 the the DET cjel-3603 174 9 courts court NOUN cjel-3603 174 10 have have AUX cjel-3603 174 11 disagreed disagree VERB cjel-3603 174 12 on on ADP cjel-3603 174 13 where where SCONJ cjel-3603 174 14 the the DET cjel-3603 174 15 outer outer ADJ cjel-3603 174 16 limits limit NOUN cjel-3603 174 17 lie lie VERB cjel-3603 174 18 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 175 1 an an DET cjel-3603 175 2 interesting interesting ADJ cjel-3603 175 3 exception exception NOUN cjel-3603 175 4 to to ADP cjel-3603 175 5 the the DET cjel-3603 175 6 generally generally ADV cjel-3603 175 7 deferential deferential ADJ cjel-3603 175 8 interpretation interpretation NOUN cjel-3603 175 9 of of ADP cjel-3603 175 10 the the DET cjel-3603 175 11 purpose purpose NOUN cjel-3603 175 12 to to PART cjel-3603 175 13 aid aid VERB cjel-3603 175 14 in in ADP cjel-3603 175 15 navigation navigation NOUN cjel-3603 175 16 can can AUX cjel-3603 175 17 be be AUX cjel-3603 175 18 found find VERB cjel-3603 175 19 in in ADP cjel-3603 175 20 the the DET cjel-3603 175 21 context context NOUN cjel-3603 175 22 of of ADP cjel-3603 175 23 ecological ecological ADJ cjel-3603 175 24 conservation conservation NOUN cjel-3603 175 25 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 176 1 in in ADP cjel-3603 176 2 palm palm PROPN cjel-3603 176 3 beach beach PROPN cjel-3603 176 4 isles isles PROPN cjel-3603 176 5 associates associates PROPN cjel-3603 176 6 v. v. PROPN cjel-3603 176 7 united united PROPN cjel-3603 176 8 states states PROPN cjel-3603 176 9 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 176 10 the the DET cjel-3603 176 11 federal federal ADJ cjel-3603 176 12 circuit circuit NOUN cjel-3603 176 13 denied deny VERB cjel-3603 176 14 the the DET cjel-3603 176 15 government government NOUN cjel-3603 176 16 ’s ’s PART cjel-3603 176 17 use use NOUN cjel-3603 176 18 of of ADP cjel-3603 176 19 the the DET cjel-3603 176 20 41 41 NUM cjel-3603 176 21 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 177 1 united united PROPN cjel-3603 177 2 states states PROPN cjel-3603 177 3 v. v. PROPN cjel-3603 177 4 appalachian appalachian PROPN cjel-3603 177 5 elec elec PROPN cjel-3603 177 6 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 177 7 power power PROPN cjel-3603 177 8 co. co. PROPN cjel-3603 177 9 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 177 10 311 311 NUM cjel-3603 177 11 u.s u.s PROPN cjel-3603 177 12 . . PROPN cjel-3603 177 13 377 377 NUM cjel-3603 177 14 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 177 15 426–27 426–27 NUM cjel-3603 177 16 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 177 17 1940 1940 NUM cjel-3603 177 18 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 177 19 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 177 20 superseded supersede VERB cjel-3603 177 21 by by ADP cjel-3603 177 22 statute statute PROPN cjel-3603 177 23 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 177 24 clean clean ADJ cjel-3603 177 25 water water PROPN cjel-3603 177 26 act act NOUN cjel-3603 177 27 of of ADP cjel-3603 177 28 1972 1972 NUM cjel-3603 177 29 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 177 30 pub pub NOUN cjel-3603 177 31 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 178 1 l. l. PROPN cjel-3603 178 2 no no INTJ cjel-3603 178 3 . . PROPN cjel-3603 179 1 92 92 NUM cjel-3603 179 2 - - SYM cjel-3603 179 3 500 500 NUM cjel-3603 179 4 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 179 5 86 86 NUM cjel-3603 179 6 stat stat NOUN cjel-3603 179 7 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 180 1 816 816 NUM cjel-3603 180 2 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 180 3 as as SCONJ cjel-3603 180 4 recognized recognize VERB cjel-3603 180 5 in in ADP cjel-3603 180 6 rapanos rapanos PROPN cjel-3603 180 7 v. v. ADP cjel-3603 180 8 united united PROPN cjel-3603 180 9 states states PROPN cjel-3603 180 10 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 181 1 547 547 NUM cjel-3603 181 2 u.s u.s PROPN cjel-3603 181 3 . . PROPN cjel-3603 181 4 715 715 NUM cjel-3603 181 5 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 181 6 723–24 723–24 NUM cjel-3603 181 7 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 181 8 2006 2006 NUM cjel-3603 181 9 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 181 10 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 182 1 42 42 NUM cjel-3603 182 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 183 1 oklahoma oklahoma PROPN cjel-3603 183 2 ex ex PROPN cjel-3603 183 3 rel rel PROPN cjel-3603 183 4 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 184 1 phillips phillips PROPN cjel-3603 184 2 v. v. ADP cjel-3603 184 3 guy guy PROPN cjel-3603 184 4 f. f. PROPN cjel-3603 184 5 atkinson atkinson PROPN cjel-3603 184 6 co. co. PROPN cjel-3603 184 7 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 184 8 313 313 NUM cjel-3603 184 9 u.s u.s PROPN cjel-3603 184 10 . . PROPN cjel-3603 184 11 508 508 NUM cjel-3603 184 12 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 184 13 516 516 NUM cjel-3603 184 14 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 184 15 1941 1941 NUM cjel-3603 184 16 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 184 17 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 184 18 “ " PUNCT cjel-3603 184 19 we we PRON cjel-3603 184 20 are be AUX cjel-3603 184 21 of of ADP cjel-3603 184 22 the the DET cjel-3603 184 23 view view NOUN cjel-3603 184 24 that that SCONJ cjel-3603 184 25 the the DET cjel-3603 184 26 denison denison PROPN cjel-3603 184 27 dam dam PROPN cjel-3603 184 28 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 184 29 reservoir reservoir PROPN cjel-3603 184 30 project project NOUN cjel-3603 184 31 is be AUX cjel-3603 184 32 a a DET cjel-3603 184 33 valid valid ADJ cjel-3603 184 34 exercise exercise NOUN cjel-3603 184 35 of of ADP cjel-3603 184 36 the the DET cjel-3603 184 37 commerce commerce NOUN cjel-3603 184 38 power power NOUN cjel-3603 184 39 by by ADP cjel-3603 184 40 congress congress PROPN cjel-3603 184 41 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 184 42 ” " PUNCT cjel-3603 184 43 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 184 44 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 185 1 43 43 NUM cjel-3603 185 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 186 1 see see VERB cjel-3603 186 2 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 186 3 e.g. e.g. ADV cjel-3603 186 4 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 186 5 united united PROPN cjel-3603 186 6 states states PROPN cjel-3603 186 7 v. v. PROPN cjel-3603 186 8 commodore commodore PROPN cjel-3603 186 9 park park PROPN cjel-3603 186 10 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 186 11 324 324 NUM cjel-3603 186 12 u.s u.s PROPN cjel-3603 186 13 . . PROPN cjel-3603 186 14 386 386 NUM cjel-3603 186 15 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 186 16 393 393 NUM cjel-3603 186 17 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 186 18 1945 1945 NUM cjel-3603 186 19 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 186 20 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 186 21 “ " PUNCT cjel-3603 186 22 there there PRON cjel-3603 186 23 is be VERB cjel-3603 186 24 power power NOUN cjel-3603 186 25 to to PART cjel-3603 186 26 block block VERB cjel-3603 186 27 navigation navigation NOUN cjel-3603 186 28 at at ADP cjel-3603 186 29 one one NUM cjel-3603 186 30 place place NOUN cjel-3603 186 31 to to PART cjel-3603 186 32 foster foster VERB cjel-3603 186 33 it it PRON cjel-3603 186 34 at at ADP cjel-3603 186 35 another another PRON cjel-3603 186 36 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 187 1 whether whether SCONJ cjel-3603 187 2 this this DET cjel-3603 187 3 blocking blocking NOUN cjel-3603 187 4 be be AUX cjel-3603 187 5 done do VERB cjel-3603 187 6 by by ADP cjel-3603 187 7 altering alter VERB cjel-3603 187 8 the the DET cjel-3603 187 9 stream stream NOUN cjel-3603 187 10 ’s ’s PART cjel-3603 187 11 course course NOUN cjel-3603 187 12 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 187 13 by by ADP cjel-3603 187 14 lighthouses lighthouse NOUN cjel-3603 187 15 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 187 16 jetties jetty NOUN cjel-3603 187 17 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 187 18 piers pier NOUN cjel-3603 187 19 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 187 20 or or CCONJ cjel-3603 187 21 a a DET cjel-3603 187 22 dam dam NOUN cjel-3603 187 23 made make VERB cjel-3603 187 24 of of ADP cjel-3603 187 25 dredged dredge VERB cjel-3603 187 26 material material NOUN cjel-3603 187 27 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 187 28 the the DET cjel-3603 187 29 government government NOUN cjel-3603 187 30 ’s ’s PART cjel-3603 187 31 power power NOUN cjel-3603 187 32 is be AUX cjel-3603 187 33 the the DET cjel-3603 187 34 same same ADJ cjel-3603 187 35 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 187 36 in in ADP cjel-3603 187 37 the the DET cjel-3603 187 38 instant instant ADJ cjel-3603 187 39 case case NOUN cjel-3603 187 40 is be AUX cjel-3603 187 41 derived derive VERB cjel-3603 187 42 from from ADP cjel-3603 187 43 the the DET cjel-3603 187 44 same same ADJ cjel-3603 187 45 source source NOUN cjel-3603 187 46 — — PUNCT cjel-3603 187 47 its its PRON cjel-3603 187 48 authority authority NOUN cjel-3603 187 49 to to PART cjel-3603 187 50 regulate regulate VERB cjel-3603 187 51 commerce commerce NOUN cjel-3603 187 52 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 187 53 ” " PUNCT cjel-3603 187 54 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 187 55 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 187 56 internal internal ADJ cjel-3603 187 57 citations citation NOUN cjel-3603 187 58 omitted omit VERB cjel-3603 187 59 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 187 60 ; ; PUNCT cjel-3603 187 61 arizona arizona PROPN cjel-3603 187 62 v. v. PROPN cjel-3603 187 63 california california PROPN cjel-3603 187 64 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 187 65 283 283 NUM cjel-3603 187 66 u.s u.s PROPN cjel-3603 187 67 . . PROPN cjel-3603 187 68 423 423 NUM cjel-3603 187 69 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 187 70 456 456 NUM cjel-3603 187 71 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 187 72 1931 1931 NUM cjel-3603 187 73 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 187 74 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 187 75 “ " PUNCT cjel-3603 187 76 [ [ X cjel-3603 187 77 t]he t]he ADV cjel-3603 187 78 fact fact NOUN cjel-3603 187 79 that that SCONJ cjel-3603 187 80 purposes purpose NOUN cjel-3603 187 81 other other ADJ cjel-3603 187 82 than than ADP cjel-3603 187 83 navigation navigation NOUN cjel-3603 187 84 will will AUX cjel-3603 187 85 also also ADV cjel-3603 187 86 be be AUX cjel-3603 187 87 served serve VERB cjel-3603 187 88 could could AUX cjel-3603 187 89 not not PART cjel-3603 187 90 invalidate invalidate VERB cjel-3603 187 91 the the DET cjel-3603 187 92 exercise exercise NOUN cjel-3603 187 93 of of ADP cjel-3603 187 94 the the DET cjel-3603 187 95 authority authority NOUN cjel-3603 187 96 conferred confer VERB cjel-3603 187 97 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 187 98 even even ADV cjel-3603 187 99 if if SCONJ cjel-3603 187 100 those those DET cjel-3603 187 101 other other ADJ cjel-3603 187 102 purposes purpose NOUN cjel-3603 187 103 would would AUX cjel-3603 187 104 not not PART cjel-3603 187 105 alone alone ADV cjel-3603 187 106 have have AUX cjel-3603 187 107 justified justify VERB cjel-3603 187 108 an an DET cjel-3603 187 109 exercise exercise NOUN cjel-3603 187 110 of of ADP cjel-3603 187 111 congressional congressional ADJ cjel-3603 187 112 power power NOUN cjel-3603 187 113 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 187 114 ” " PUNCT cjel-3603 187 115 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 187 116 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 188 1 44 44 NUM cjel-3603 188 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 188 3 palm palm PROPN cjel-3603 188 4 beach beach PROPN cjel-3603 188 5 isles isles PROPN cjel-3603 188 6 assocs assocs PROPN cjel-3603 188 7 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 189 1 v. v. PROPN cjel-3603 189 2 united united PROPN cjel-3603 189 3 states states PROPN cjel-3603 189 4 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 189 5 208 208 NUM cjel-3603 189 6 f.3d f.3d NUM cjel-3603 189 7 1374 1374 NUM cjel-3603 189 8 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 189 9 1384 1384 NUM cjel-3603 189 10 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 189 11 fed fed PROPN cjel-3603 189 12 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 189 13 cir cir PROPN cjel-3603 189 14 . . PROPN cjel-3603 189 15 2000 2000 NUM cjel-3603 189 16 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 189 17 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 189 18 abrogated abrogate VERB cjel-3603 189 19 by by ADP cjel-3603 189 20 bass bass NOUN cjel-3603 189 21 enters enter NOUN cjel-3603 189 22 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 190 1 prod prod PROPN cjel-3603 190 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 190 3 co. co. PROPN cjel-3603 191 1 v. v. ADP cjel-3603 191 2 united united PROPN cjel-3603 191 3 states states PROPN cjel-3603 191 4 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 191 5 381 381 NUM cjel-3603 191 6 f.3d f.3d NUM cjel-3603 191 7 1360 1360 NUM cjel-3603 191 8 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 191 9 1369–70 1369–70 NUM cjel-3603 191 10 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 191 11 fed fed PROPN cjel-3603 191 12 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 191 13 cir cir PROPN cjel-3603 191 14 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 191 15 2004 2004 NUM cjel-3603 191 16 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 191 17 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 192 1 45 45 NUM cjel-3603 192 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 192 3 mildenberger mildenberger PROPN cjel-3603 192 4 v. v. PROPN cjel-3603 192 5 united united PROPN cjel-3603 192 6 states states PROPN cjel-3603 192 7 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 192 8 91 91 NUM cjel-3603 192 9 fed feed VERB cjel-3603 192 10 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 193 1 cl cl NOUN cjel-3603 193 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 194 1 217 217 NUM cjel-3603 194 2 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 194 3 248 248 NUM cjel-3603 194 4 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 194 5 fed fed PROPN cjel-3603 194 6 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 195 1 cl cl NOUN cjel-3603 195 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 196 1 2010 2010 NUM cjel-3603 196 2 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 196 3 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 197 1 46 46 NUM cjel-3603 197 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 198 1 united united PROPN cjel-3603 198 2 states states PROPN cjel-3603 198 3 v. v. ADP cjel-3603 198 4 twin twin PROPN cjel-3603 198 5 city city PROPN cjel-3603 198 6 power power PROPN cjel-3603 198 7 co. co. PROPN cjel-3603 198 8 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 198 9 350 350 NUM cjel-3603 198 10 u.s u.s PROPN cjel-3603 198 11 . . PROPN cjel-3603 198 12 222 222 NUM cjel-3603 198 13 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 198 14 260 260 NUM cjel-3603 198 15 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 198 16 1956 1956 NUM cjel-3603 198 17 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 198 18 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 199 1 monahan monahan PROPN cjel-3603 199 2 - - PUNCT cjel-3603 199 3 macro-[final macro-[final PROPN cjel-3603 199 4 6 6 NUM cjel-3603 199 5 - - SYM cjel-3603 199 6 20 20 NUM cjel-3603 199 7 ] ] PUNCT cjel-3603 199 8 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 199 9 do do AUX cjel-3603 199 10 not not PART cjel-3603 199 11 delete delete VERB cjel-3603 199 12 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 199 13 6/22/2015 6/22/2015 NUM cjel-3603 199 14 11:53 11:53 NUM cjel-3603 199 15 pm pm NOUN cjel-3603 199 16 368 368 NUM cjel-3603 199 17 columbia columbia PROPN cjel-3603 199 18 journal journal PROPN cjel-3603 199 19 of of ADP cjel-3603 199 20 environmental environmental ADJ cjel-3603 199 21 law law NOUN cjel-3603 199 22 [ [ X cjel-3603 199 23 vol vol NOUN cjel-3603 199 24 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 200 1 40:2 40:2 NUM cjel-3603 200 2 navigational navigational ADJ cjel-3603 200 3 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 200 4 as as ADP cjel-3603 200 5 an an DET cjel-3603 200 6 absolute absolute ADJ cjel-3603 200 7 defense defense NOUN cjel-3603 200 8 to to ADP cjel-3603 200 9 a a DET cjel-3603 200 10 regulatory regulatory ADJ cjel-3603 200 11 takings taking NOUN cjel-3603 200 12 claim.47 claim.47 NOUN cjel-3603 200 13 the the DET cjel-3603 200 14 army army NOUN cjel-3603 200 15 corps corps PROPN cjel-3603 200 16 of of ADP cjel-3603 200 17 engineers engineer NOUN cjel-3603 200 18 denied deny VERB cjel-3603 200 19 a a DET cjel-3603 200 20 private private ADJ cjel-3603 200 21 land land NOUN cjel-3603 200 22 owner owner NOUN cjel-3603 200 23 ’s ’s PART cjel-3603 200 24 application application NOUN cjel-3603 200 25 for for ADP cjel-3603 200 26 a a DET cjel-3603 200 27 dredge dredge NOUN cjel-3603 200 28 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 200 29 fill fill NOUN cjel-3603 200 30 permit permit NOUN cjel-3603 200 31 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 200 32 citing cite VERB cjel-3603 200 33 environmental environmental ADJ cjel-3603 200 34 concerns concern NOUN cjel-3603 200 35 including include VERB cjel-3603 200 36 requirements requirement NOUN cjel-3603 200 37 of of ADP cjel-3603 200 38 the the DET cjel-3603 200 39 clean clean PROPN cjel-3603 200 40 water water PROPN cjel-3603 200 41 act act PROPN cjel-3603 200 42 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 201 1 the the DET cjel-3603 201 2 court court NOUN cjel-3603 201 3 held hold VERB cjel-3603 201 4 that that SCONJ cjel-3603 201 5 the the DET cjel-3603 201 6 government government NOUN cjel-3603 201 7 could could AUX cjel-3603 201 8 not not PART cjel-3603 201 9 invoke invoke VERB cjel-3603 201 10 the the DET cjel-3603 201 11 navigational navigational ADJ cjel-3603 201 12 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 201 13 for for ADP cjel-3603 201 14 this this DET cjel-3603 201 15 environmental environmental ADJ cjel-3603 201 16 purpose purpose NOUN cjel-3603 201 17 alone alone ADV cjel-3603 201 18 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 202 1 citing cite VERB cjel-3603 202 2 a a DET cjel-3603 202 3 lack lack NOUN cjel-3603 202 4 of of ADP cjel-3603 202 5 evidence evidence NOUN cjel-3603 202 6 of of ADP cjel-3603 202 7 a a DET cjel-3603 202 8 navigational navigational ADJ cjel-3603 202 9 purpose purpose NOUN cjel-3603 202 10 in in ADP cjel-3603 202 11 denying deny VERB cjel-3603 202 12 the the DET cjel-3603 202 13 permit permit NOUN cjel-3603 202 14 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 202 15 the the DET cjel-3603 202 16 federal federal ADJ cjel-3603 202 17 circuit circuit NOUN cjel-3603 202 18 remanded remand VERB cjel-3603 202 19 the the DET cjel-3603 202 20 case case NOUN cjel-3603 202 21 for for ADP cjel-3603 202 22 further further ADJ cjel-3603 202 23 fact fact NOUN cjel-3603 202 24 finding find VERB cjel-3603 202 25 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 203 1 although although SCONJ cjel-3603 203 2 on on ADP cjel-3603 203 3 remand remand NOUN cjel-3603 203 4 the the DET cjel-3603 203 5 court court NOUN cjel-3603 203 6 of of ADP cjel-3603 203 7 federal federal ADJ cjel-3603 203 8 claims claim NOUN cjel-3603 203 9 found find VERB cjel-3603 203 10 that that SCONJ cjel-3603 203 11 the the DET cjel-3603 203 12 corps corps NOUN cjel-3603 203 13 did do AUX cjel-3603 203 14 have have VERB cjel-3603 203 15 a a DET cjel-3603 203 16 sufficient sufficient ADJ cjel-3603 203 17 navigational navigational ADJ cjel-3603 203 18 purpose purpose NOUN cjel-3603 203 19 in in ADP cjel-3603 203 20 denying deny VERB cjel-3603 203 21 the the DET cjel-3603 203 22 permit permit NOUN cjel-3603 203 23 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 203 24 the the DET cjel-3603 203 25 federal federal ADJ cjel-3603 203 26 circuit circuit NOUN cjel-3603 203 27 made make VERB cjel-3603 203 28 it it PRON cjel-3603 203 29 clear clear ADJ cjel-3603 203 30 that that SCONJ cjel-3603 203 31 such such DET cjel-3603 203 32 a a DET cjel-3603 203 33 purpose purpose NOUN cjel-3603 203 34 was be AUX cjel-3603 203 35 necessary necessary ADJ cjel-3603 203 36 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 203 37 concerns concern NOUN cjel-3603 203 38 over over ADP cjel-3603 203 39 conservation conservation NOUN cjel-3603 203 40 alone alone ADV cjel-3603 203 41 would would AUX cjel-3603 203 42 not not PART cjel-3603 203 43 allow allow VERB cjel-3603 203 44 the the DET cjel-3603 203 45 government government NOUN cjel-3603 203 46 to to PART cjel-3603 203 47 invoke invoke VERB cjel-3603 203 48 the the DET cjel-3603 203 49 servitude.48 servitude.48 NOUN cjel-3603 203 50 this this DET cjel-3603 203 51 narrowing narrowing NOUN cjel-3603 203 52 of of ADP cjel-3603 203 53 the the DET cjel-3603 203 54 navigational navigational ADJ cjel-3603 203 55 purpose purpose NOUN cjel-3603 203 56 stands stand VERB cjel-3603 203 57 in in ADP cjel-3603 203 58 contrast contrast NOUN cjel-3603 203 59 to to ADP cjel-3603 203 60 the the DET cjel-3603 203 61 fifth fifth ADJ cjel-3603 203 62 circuit circuit NOUN cjel-3603 203 63 ’s ’s PART cjel-3603 203 64 1970 1970 NUM cjel-3603 203 65 ruling ruling NOUN cjel-3603 203 66 in in ADP cjel-3603 203 67 zabel zabel PROPN cjel-3603 203 68 v. v. ADP cjel-3603 203 69 tabb.49 tabb.49 PROPN cjel-3603 203 70 in in ADP cjel-3603 203 71 zabel zabel NOUN cjel-3603 203 72 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 203 73 denial denial NOUN cjel-3603 203 74 of of ADP cjel-3603 203 75 a a DET cjel-3603 203 76 dredge dredge NOUN cjel-3603 203 77 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 203 78 fill fill NOUN cjel-3603 203 79 permit permit NOUN cjel-3603 203 80 was be AUX cjel-3603 203 81 similarly similarly ADV cjel-3603 203 82 challenged challenge VERB cjel-3603 203 83 as as ADP cjel-3603 203 84 an an DET cjel-3603 203 85 uncompensated uncompensated ADJ cjel-3603 203 86 taking taking NOUN cjel-3603 203 87 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 204 1 however however ADV cjel-3603 204 2 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 204 3 in in ADP cjel-3603 204 4 that that DET cjel-3603 204 5 case case NOUN cjel-3603 204 6 the the DET cjel-3603 204 7 court court NOUN cjel-3603 204 8 quickly quickly ADV cjel-3603 204 9 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 204 10 summarily summarily ADV cjel-3603 204 11 dismissed dismiss VERB cjel-3603 204 12 such such DET cjel-3603 204 13 an an DET cjel-3603 204 14 argument argument NOUN cjel-3603 204 15 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 205 1 the the DET cjel-3603 205 2 fifth fifth ADJ cjel-3603 205 3 circuit circuit NOUN cjel-3603 205 4 reasoned reason VERB cjel-3603 205 5 that that SCONJ cjel-3603 205 6 the the DET cjel-3603 205 7 submerged submerge VERB cjel-3603 205 8 land land NOUN cjel-3603 205 9 in in ADP cjel-3603 205 10 question question NOUN cjel-3603 205 11 was be AUX cjel-3603 205 12 subject subject ADJ cjel-3603 205 13 to to ADP cjel-3603 205 14 the the DET cjel-3603 205 15 federal federal ADJ cjel-3603 205 16 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 205 17 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 206 1 however however ADV cjel-3603 206 2 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 206 3 the the DET cjel-3603 206 4 court court NOUN cjel-3603 206 5 began begin VERB cjel-3603 206 6 its its PRON cjel-3603 206 7 analysis analysis NOUN cjel-3603 206 8 of of ADP cjel-3603 206 9 congress congress PROPN cjel-3603 206 10 ’ ' PUNCT cjel-3603 206 11 authority authority NOUN cjel-3603 206 12 over over ADP cjel-3603 206 13 the the DET cjel-3603 206 14 waterway waterway NOUN cjel-3603 206 15 not not PART cjel-3603 206 16 with with ADP cjel-3603 206 17 a a DET cjel-3603 206 18 discussion discussion NOUN cjel-3603 206 19 of of ADP cjel-3603 206 20 the the DET cjel-3603 206 21 navigational navigational ADJ cjel-3603 206 22 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 206 23 as as SCONJ cjel-3603 206 24 developed develop VERB cjel-3603 206 25 by by ADP cjel-3603 206 26 federal federal ADJ cjel-3603 206 27 courts court NOUN cjel-3603 206 28 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 206 29 but but CCONJ cjel-3603 206 30 by by ADP cjel-3603 206 31 going go VERB cjel-3603 206 32 back back ADV cjel-3603 206 33 to to ADP cjel-3603 206 34 the the DET cjel-3603 206 35 commerce commerce NOUN cjel-3603 206 36 clause.50 clause.50 PROPN cjel-3603 206 37 citing cite VERB cjel-3603 206 38 the the DET cjel-3603 206 39 commerce commerce NOUN cjel-3603 206 40 clause clause NOUN cjel-3603 206 41 ’s ’s PART cjel-3603 206 42 “ " PUNCT cjel-3603 206 43 expansive expansive ADJ cjel-3603 206 44 reach reach NOUN cjel-3603 206 45 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 206 46 ” " PUNCT cjel-3603 206 47 the the DET cjel-3603 206 48 court court NOUN cjel-3603 206 49 noted note VERB cjel-3603 206 50 that that SCONJ cjel-3603 206 51 dredge dredge NOUN cjel-3603 206 52 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 206 53 fill fill VERB cjel-3603 206 54 projects project NOUN cjel-3603 206 55 potentially potentially ADV cjel-3603 206 56 have have VERB cjel-3603 206 57 a a DET cjel-3603 206 58 “ " PUNCT cjel-3603 206 59 substantial substantial ADJ cjel-3603 206 60 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 206 61 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 206 62 in in ADP cjel-3603 206 63 some some DET cjel-3603 206 64 areas area NOUN cjel-3603 206 65 a a DET cjel-3603 206 66 devastating devastating ADJ cjel-3603 206 67 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 206 68 effect effect NOUN cjel-3603 206 69 on on ADP cjel-3603 206 70 interstate interstate PROPN cjel-3603 206 71 commerce commerce NOUN cjel-3603 206 72 ” " PUNCT cjel-3603 206 73 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 206 74 congress congress PROPN cjel-3603 206 75 therefore therefore ADV cjel-3603 206 76 had have VERB cjel-3603 206 77 “ " PUNCT cjel-3603 206 78 the the DET cjel-3603 206 79 power power NOUN cjel-3603 206 80 to to ADP cjel-3603 206 81 47 47 NUM cjel-3603 206 82 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 207 1 see see VERB cjel-3603 207 2 palm palm PROPN cjel-3603 207 3 beach beach PROPN cjel-3603 207 4 isles isles PROPN cjel-3603 207 5 assocs assocs PROPN cjel-3603 207 6 . . PROPN cjel-3603 207 7 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 207 8 208 208 NUM cjel-3603 207 9 f.3d f.3d NUM cjel-3603 207 10 at at ADP cjel-3603 207 11 1384–85 1384–85 NOUN cjel-3603 207 12 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 208 1 48 48 NUM cjel-3603 208 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 209 1 see see VERB cjel-3603 209 2 palm palm PROPN cjel-3603 209 3 beach beach PROPN cjel-3603 209 4 isles isles PROPN cjel-3603 209 5 assocs assocs PROPN cjel-3603 209 6 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 210 1 v. v. PROPN cjel-3603 210 2 united united PROPN cjel-3603 210 3 states states PROPN cjel-3603 210 4 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 210 5 58 58 NUM cjel-3603 210 6 fed fed PROPN cjel-3603 210 7 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 211 1 cl cl NOUN cjel-3603 211 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 212 1 657 657 NUM cjel-3603 212 2 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 212 3 686 686 NUM cjel-3603 212 4 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 212 5 2003 2003 NUM cjel-3603 212 6 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 212 7 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 212 8 “ " PUNCT cjel-3603 212 9 after after ADP cjel-3603 212 10 further further ADJ cjel-3603 212 11 discovery discovery NOUN cjel-3603 212 12 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 212 13 a a DET cjel-3603 212 14 hearing hearing NOUN cjel-3603 212 15 upon upon SCONJ cjel-3603 212 16 remand remand NOUN cjel-3603 212 17 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 212 18 this this DET cjel-3603 212 19 court court NOUN cjel-3603 212 20 finds find VERB cjel-3603 212 21 that that DET cjel-3603 212 22 defendant defendant NOUN cjel-3603 212 23 has have AUX cjel-3603 212 24 demonstrated demonstrate VERB cjel-3603 212 25 a a DET cjel-3603 212 26 bona bona ADJ cjel-3603 212 27 fide fide ADJ cjel-3603 212 28 federal federal ADJ cjel-3603 212 29 navigational navigational ADJ cjel-3603 212 30 purpose purpose NOUN cjel-3603 212 31 in in ADP cjel-3603 212 32 the the DET cjel-3603 212 33 permit permit NOUN cjel-3603 212 34 denial denial NOUN cjel-3603 212 35 as as ADP cjel-3603 212 36 to to ADP cjel-3603 212 37 plaintiffs plaintiff NOUN cjel-3603 212 38 ’ ' PUNCT cjel-3603 212 39 49.3 49.3 NUM cjel-3603 212 40 submerged submerge VERB cjel-3603 212 41 acres acre NOUN cjel-3603 212 42 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 213 1 therefore therefore ADV cjel-3603 213 2 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 213 3 as as ADP cjel-3603 213 4 to to ADP cjel-3603 213 5 the the DET cjel-3603 213 6 49.3 49.3 NUM cjel-3603 213 7 acres acre NOUN cjel-3603 213 8 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 213 9 the the DET cjel-3603 213 10 permit permit NOUN cjel-3603 213 11 denial denial NOUN cjel-3603 213 12 by by ADP cjel-3603 213 13 the the DET cjel-3603 213 14 corps corps NOUN cjel-3603 213 15 did do AUX cjel-3603 213 16 not not PART cjel-3603 213 17 constitute constitute VERB cjel-3603 213 18 a a DET cjel-3603 213 19 compensable compensable ADJ cjel-3603 213 20 regulatory regulatory ADJ cjel-3603 213 21 taking taking NOUN cjel-3603 213 22 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 213 23 ” " PUNCT cjel-3603 213 24 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 213 25 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 213 26 internal internal ADJ cjel-3603 213 27 citation citation NOUN cjel-3603 213 28 omitted omit VERB cjel-3603 213 29 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 213 30 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 213 31 aff’d aff’d VERB cjel-3603 213 32 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 213 33 122 122 NUM cjel-3603 213 34 fed feed VERB cjel-3603 213 35 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 214 1 app’x app’x PROPN cjel-3603 214 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 215 1 517 517 NUM cjel-3603 215 2 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 215 3 2005 2005 NUM cjel-3603 215 4 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 215 5 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 216 1 see see VERB cjel-3603 216 2 also also ADV cjel-3603 216 3 benjamin benjamin PROPN cjel-3603 216 4 longstreth longstreth PROPN cjel-3603 216 5 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 216 6 protecting protect VERB cjel-3603 216 7 “ " PUNCT cjel-3603 216 8 the the DET cjel-3603 216 9 wastes waste NOUN cjel-3603 216 10 of of ADP cjel-3603 216 11 the the DET cjel-3603 216 12 foreshore foreshore NOUN cjel-3603 216 13 ” " PUNCT cjel-3603 216 14 : : PUNCT cjel-3603 216 15 the the DET cjel-3603 216 16 federal federal ADJ cjel-3603 216 17 navigational navigational ADJ cjel-3603 216 18 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 216 19 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 216 20 its its PRON cjel-3603 216 21 origins origin NOUN cjel-3603 216 22 in in ADP cjel-3603 216 23 state state NOUN cjel-3603 216 24 public public ADJ cjel-3603 216 25 trust trust NOUN cjel-3603 216 26 doctrine doctrine NOUN cjel-3603 216 27 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 216 28 102 102 NUM cjel-3603 216 29 colum colum NOUN cjel-3603 216 30 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 217 1 l. l. PROPN cjel-3603 217 2 rev rev PROPN cjel-3603 217 3 . . PROPN cjel-3603 218 1 471 471 NUM cjel-3603 218 2 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 218 3 2002 2002 NUM cjel-3603 218 4 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 218 5 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 218 6 discussing discuss VERB cjel-3603 218 7 the the DET cjel-3603 218 8 possibility possibility NOUN cjel-3603 218 9 of of ADP cjel-3603 218 10 expanding expand VERB cjel-3603 218 11 the the DET cjel-3603 218 12 navigational navigational ADJ cjel-3603 218 13 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 218 14 to to PART cjel-3603 218 15 include include VERB cjel-3603 218 16 government government NOUN cjel-3603 218 17 regulation regulation NOUN cjel-3603 218 18 of of ADP cjel-3603 218 19 waterways waterway NOUN cjel-3603 218 20 for for ADP cjel-3603 218 21 conservation conservation NOUN cjel-3603 218 22 purposes purpose NOUN cjel-3603 218 23 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 218 24 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 219 1 49 49 NUM cjel-3603 219 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 220 1 zabel zabel PROPN cjel-3603 220 2 v. v. PROPN cjel-3603 220 3 tabb tabb PROPN cjel-3603 220 4 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 220 5 430 430 NUM cjel-3603 220 6 f.2d f.2d SYM cjel-3603 220 7 199 199 NUM cjel-3603 220 8 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 220 9 5th 5th ADJ cjel-3603 220 10 cir cir NOUN cjel-3603 220 11 . . PROPN cjel-3603 220 12 1970 1970 NUM cjel-3603 220 13 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 220 14 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 221 1 50 50 NUM cjel-3603 221 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 222 1 i i PRON cjel-3603 222 2 d. d. PROPN cjel-3603 222 3 at at ADP cjel-3603 222 4 203 203 NUM cjel-3603 222 5 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 223 1 monahan monahan PROPN cjel-3603 223 2 - - PUNCT cjel-3603 223 3 macro-[final macro-[final PROPN cjel-3603 223 4 6 6 NUM cjel-3603 223 5 - - SYM cjel-3603 223 6 20 20 NUM cjel-3603 223 7 ] ] PUNCT cjel-3603 223 8 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 223 9 do do AUX cjel-3603 223 10 not not PART cjel-3603 223 11 delete delete VERB cjel-3603 223 12 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 223 13 6/22/2015 6/22/2015 NUM cjel-3603 223 14 11:53 11:53 NUM cjel-3603 223 15 pm pm NOUN cjel-3603 223 16 2015 2015 NUM cjel-3603 223 17 ] ] PUNCT cjel-3603 223 18 the the DET cjel-3603 223 19 navigational navigational ADJ cjel-3603 223 20 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 223 21 369 369 NUM cjel-3603 223 22 regulate regulate VERB cjel-3603 223 23 such such ADJ cjel-3603 223 24 projects project NOUN cjel-3603 223 25 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 223 26 ”51 ”51 PROPN cjel-3603 223 27 while while SCONJ cjel-3603 223 28 numerous numerous ADJ cjel-3603 223 29 cases case NOUN cjel-3603 223 30 also also ADV cjel-3603 223 31 find find VERB cjel-3603 223 32 that that SCONJ cjel-3603 223 33 the the DET cjel-3603 223 34 commerce commerce NOUN cjel-3603 223 35 clause clause NOUN cjel-3603 223 36 permits permit VERB cjel-3603 223 37 congress congress PROPN cjel-3603 223 38 to to PART cjel-3603 223 39 regulate regulate VERB cjel-3603 223 40 navigable navigable ADJ cjel-3603 223 41 waterways waterway NOUN cjel-3603 223 42 for for ADP cjel-3603 223 43 the the DET cjel-3603 223 44 purpose purpose NOUN cjel-3603 223 45 of of ADP cjel-3603 223 46 environmental environmental ADJ cjel-3603 223 47 conservation,52 conservation,52 PROPN cjel-3603 223 48 zabel zabel PROPN cjel-3603 223 49 goes go VERB cjel-3603 223 50 beyond beyond ADP cjel-3603 223 51 this this PRON cjel-3603 223 52 to to PART cjel-3603 223 53 expand expand VERB cjel-3603 223 54 the the DET cjel-3603 223 55 navigational navigational ADJ cjel-3603 223 56 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 223 57 to to ADP cjel-3603 223 58 the the DET cjel-3603 223 59 full full ADJ cjel-3603 223 60 reaches reach NOUN cjel-3603 223 61 of of ADP cjel-3603 223 62 congress congress PROPN cjel-3603 223 63 ’ ' PUNCT cjel-3603 223 64 commerce commerce PROPN cjel-3603 223 65 clause clause NOUN cjel-3603 223 66 power.53 power.53 NOUN cjel-3603 223 67 in in ADP cjel-3603 223 68 so so ADV cjel-3603 223 69 doing do VERB cjel-3603 223 70 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 223 71 the the DET cjel-3603 223 72 zabel zabel PROPN cjel-3603 223 73 court court PROPN cjel-3603 223 74 removed remove VERB cjel-3603 223 75 all all DET cjel-3603 223 76 limitations limitation NOUN cjel-3603 223 77 from from ADP cjel-3603 223 78 the the DET cjel-3603 223 79 navigational navigational ADJ cjel-3603 223 80 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 223 81 except except SCONJ cjel-3603 223 82 for for ADP cjel-3603 223 83 the the DET cjel-3603 223 84 wickard wickard NOUN cjel-3603 223 85 v. v. PROPN cjel-3603 223 86 filburn filburn NOUN cjel-3603 223 87 requirement requirement NOUN cjel-3603 223 88 that that SCONJ cjel-3603 223 89 the the DET cjel-3603 223 90 activity activity NOUN cjel-3603 223 91 being be AUX cjel-3603 223 92 regulated regulate VERB cjel-3603 223 93 have have VERB cjel-3603 223 94 a a DET cjel-3603 223 95 substantial substantial ADJ cjel-3603 223 96 effect effect NOUN cjel-3603 223 97 on on ADP cjel-3603 223 98 interstate interstate ADJ cjel-3603 223 99 commerce.54 commerce.54 NOUN cjel-3603 223 100 while while SCONJ cjel-3603 223 101 this this PRON cjel-3603 223 102 is be AUX cjel-3603 223 103 an an DET cjel-3603 223 104 intriguing intriguing ADJ cjel-3603 223 105 expansion expansion NOUN cjel-3603 223 106 of of ADP cjel-3603 223 107 the the DET cjel-3603 223 108 navigational navigational ADJ cjel-3603 223 109 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 223 110 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 223 111 as as SCONJ cjel-3603 223 112 can can AUX cjel-3603 223 113 been be AUX cjel-3603 223 114 seen see VERB cjel-3603 223 115 more more ADV cjel-3603 223 116 recently recently ADV cjel-3603 223 117 in in ADP cjel-3603 223 118 palm palm PROPN cjel-3603 223 119 beach beach PROPN cjel-3603 223 120 isles isles PROPN cjel-3603 223 121 associates associates PROPN cjel-3603 223 122 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 223 123 other other ADJ cjel-3603 223 124 federal federal ADJ cjel-3603 223 125 courts court NOUN cjel-3603 223 126 have have AUX cjel-3603 223 127 not not PART cjel-3603 223 128 yet yet ADV cjel-3603 223 129 accepted accept VERB cjel-3603 223 130 it it PRON cjel-3603 223 131 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 224 1 iii iii X cjel-3603 224 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 225 1 the the DET cjel-3603 225 2 failures failure NOUN cjel-3603 225 3 of of ADP cjel-3603 225 4 the the DET cjel-3603 225 5 navigational navigational ADJ cjel-3603 225 6 servitude servitude ADJ cjel-3603 225 7 a. a. NOUN cjel-3603 225 8 the the DET cjel-3603 225 9 common common ADJ cjel-3603 225 10 law law NOUN cjel-3603 225 11 servitude servitude VERB cjel-3603 225 12 the the DET cjel-3603 225 13 navigational navigational ADJ cjel-3603 225 14 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 225 15 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 225 16 the the DET cjel-3603 225 17 takings taking NOUN cjel-3603 225 18 clause clause NOUN cjel-3603 225 19 stem stem VERB cjel-3603 225 20 from from ADP cjel-3603 225 21 two two NUM cjel-3603 225 22 separate separate ADJ cjel-3603 225 23 constitutional constitutional ADJ cjel-3603 225 24 foundations foundation NOUN cjel-3603 225 25 : : PUNCT cjel-3603 225 26 the the DET cjel-3603 225 27 commerce commerce NOUN cjel-3603 225 28 clause clause NOUN cjel-3603 225 29 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 225 30 the the DET cjel-3603 225 31 fifth fifth ADJ cjel-3603 225 32 amendment amendment NOUN cjel-3603 225 33 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 226 1 it it PRON cjel-3603 226 2 is be AUX cjel-3603 226 3 therefore therefore ADV cjel-3603 226 4 not not PART cjel-3603 226 5 surprising surprising ADJ cjel-3603 226 6 that that SCONJ cjel-3603 226 7 they they PRON cjel-3603 226 8 are be AUX cjel-3603 226 9 premised premise VERB cjel-3603 226 10 on on ADP cjel-3603 226 11 different different ADJ cjel-3603 226 12 underlying underlying ADJ cjel-3603 226 13 policy policy NOUN cjel-3603 226 14 rationales rationale NOUN cjel-3603 226 15 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 227 1 the the DET cjel-3603 227 2 navigational navigational ADJ cjel-3603 227 3 servitude servitude ADJ cjel-3603 227 4 places place NOUN cjel-3603 227 5 navigable navigable ADJ cjel-3603 227 6 waterways waterway NOUN cjel-3603 227 7 under under ADP cjel-3603 227 8 the the DET cjel-3603 227 9 ultimate ultimate ADJ cjel-3603 227 10 control control NOUN cjel-3603 227 11 of of ADP cjel-3603 227 12 the the DET cjel-3603 227 13 federal federal ADJ cjel-3603 227 14 government government NOUN cjel-3603 227 15 so so SCONJ cjel-3603 227 16 that that SCONJ cjel-3603 227 17 it it PRON cjel-3603 227 18 may may AUX cjel-3603 227 19 effectively effectively ADV cjel-3603 227 20 regulate regulate VERB cjel-3603 227 21 interstate interstate ADJ cjel-3603 227 22 commerce commerce NOUN cjel-3603 227 23 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 228 1 the the DET cjel-3603 228 2 takings taking NOUN cjel-3603 228 3 clause clause NOUN cjel-3603 228 4 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 228 5 on on ADP cjel-3603 228 6 the the DET cjel-3603 228 7 other other ADJ cjel-3603 228 8 hand hand NOUN cjel-3603 228 9 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 228 10 has have AUX cjel-3603 228 11 traditionally traditionally ADV cjel-3603 228 12 been be AUX cjel-3603 228 13 described describe VERB cjel-3603 228 14 by by ADP cjel-3603 228 15 courts court NOUN cjel-3603 228 16 as as ADP cjel-3603 228 17 a a DET cjel-3603 228 18 way way NOUN cjel-3603 228 19 of of ADP cjel-3603 228 20 stopping stop VERB cjel-3603 228 21 the the DET cjel-3603 228 22 government government NOUN cjel-3603 228 23 “ " PUNCT cjel-3603 228 24 from from ADP cjel-3603 228 25 forcing force VERB cjel-3603 228 26 some some DET cjel-3603 228 27 people people NOUN cjel-3603 228 28 alone alone ADJ cjel-3603 228 29 to to PART cjel-3603 228 30 bear bear VERB cjel-3603 228 31 public public ADJ cjel-3603 228 32 burdens burden NOUN cjel-3603 228 33 which which PRON cjel-3603 228 34 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 228 35 in in ADP cjel-3603 228 36 all all DET cjel-3603 228 37 fairness fairness NOUN cjel-3603 228 38 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 228 39 justice justice NOUN cjel-3603 228 40 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 228 41 should should AUX cjel-3603 228 42 be be AUX cjel-3603 228 43 borne bear VERB cjel-3603 228 44 by by ADP cjel-3603 228 45 the the DET cjel-3603 228 46 public public NOUN cjel-3603 228 47 as as ADP cjel-3603 228 48 a a DET cjel-3603 228 49 whole whole NOUN cjel-3603 228 50 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 229 1 ”55 ”55 PROPN cjel-3603 229 2 however however ADV cjel-3603 229 3 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 229 4 as as SCONJ cjel-3603 229 5 can can AUX cjel-3603 229 6 be be AUX cjel-3603 229 7 seen see VERB cjel-3603 229 8 in in ADP cjel-3603 229 9 cases case NOUN cjel-3603 229 10 such such ADJ cjel-3603 229 11 as as ADP cjel-3603 229 12 rands rand NOUN cjel-3603 229 13 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 229 14 use use NOUN cjel-3603 229 15 of of ADP cjel-3603 229 16 the the DET cjel-3603 229 17 navigational navigational ADJ cjel-3603 229 18 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 229 19 can can AUX cjel-3603 229 20 do do VERB cjel-3603 229 21 just just ADV cjel-3603 229 22 that that PRON cjel-3603 229 23 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 230 1 this this DET cjel-3603 230 2 result result NOUN cjel-3603 230 3 is be AUX cjel-3603 230 4 not not PART cjel-3603 230 5 only only ADV cjel-3603 230 6 inequitable inequitable ADJ cjel-3603 230 7 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 230 8 but but CCONJ cjel-3603 230 9 inefficient inefficient ADJ cjel-3603 230 10 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 230 11 inconsistent inconsistent ADJ cjel-3603 230 12 with with ADP cjel-3603 230 13 the the DET cjel-3603 230 14 takings taking NOUN cjel-3603 230 15 clause clause NOUN cjel-3603 230 16 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 231 1 in in ADP cjel-3603 231 2 rands rand NOUN cjel-3603 231 3 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 231 4 the the DET cjel-3603 231 5 government government NOUN cjel-3603 231 6 took take VERB cjel-3603 231 7 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 231 8 through through ADP cjel-3603 231 9 condemnation condemnation NOUN cjel-3603 231 10 proceedings proceeding NOUN cjel-3603 231 11 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 231 12 riparian riparian ADJ cjel-3603 231 13 land land NOUN cjel-3603 231 14 for for ADP cjel-3603 231 15 a a DET cjel-3603 231 16 port port NOUN cjel-3603 231 17 site site NOUN cjel-3603 231 18 on on ADP cjel-3603 231 19 the the DET cjel-3603 231 20 columbia columbia PROPN cjel-3603 231 21 51 51 NUM cjel-3603 231 22 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 232 1 i i PRON cjel-3603 232 2 d. d. PROPN cjel-3603 232 3 at at ADP cjel-3603 232 4 203–04 203–04 NUM cjel-3603 232 5 . . PROPN cjel-3603 233 1 52 52 NUM cjel-3603 233 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 234 1 see see VERB cjel-3603 234 2 united united PROPN cjel-3603 234 3 states states PROPN cjel-3603 234 4 v. v. ADP cjel-3603 234 5 byrd byrd PROPN cjel-3603 234 6 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 234 7 609 609 NUM cjel-3603 234 8 f.2d f.2d NOUN cjel-3603 234 9 1204 1204 NUM cjel-3603 234 10 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 234 11 7th 7th ADJ cjel-3603 234 12 cir cir NOUN cjel-3603 234 13 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 234 14 1979 1979 NUM cjel-3603 234 15 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 234 16 ; ; PUNCT cjel-3603 234 17 leslie leslie PROPN cjel-3603 234 18 salt salt PROPN cjel-3603 234 19 co. co. PROPN cjel-3603 234 20 v. v. ADP cjel-3603 234 21 froehlke froehlke NOUN cjel-3603 234 22 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 234 23 578 578 NUM cjel-3603 234 24 f.2d f.2d X cjel-3603 234 25 742 742 NUM cjel-3603 234 26 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 234 27 9th 9th ADJ cjel-3603 234 28 cir cir NOUN cjel-3603 234 29 . . PROPN cjel-3603 234 30 1978 1978 NUM cjel-3603 234 31 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 234 32 ; ; PUNCT cjel-3603 234 33 united united PROPN cjel-3603 234 34 states states PROPN cjel-3603 234 35 v. v. PROPN cjel-3603 234 36 holland holland PROPN cjel-3603 234 37 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 234 38 373 373 NUM cjel-3603 234 39 f. f. PROPN cjel-3603 234 40 supp supp PROPN cjel-3603 234 41 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 235 1 665 665 NUM cjel-3603 235 2 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 235 3 m.d m.d PROPN cjel-3603 235 4 . . PROPN cjel-3603 235 5 fla fla PROPN cjel-3603 235 6 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 235 7 1974 1974 NUM cjel-3603 235 8 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 235 9 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 236 1 53 53 NUM cjel-3603 236 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 236 3 zabel zabel PROPN cjel-3603 236 4 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 236 5 430 430 NUM cjel-3603 236 6 f.2d f.2d NOUN cjel-3603 236 7 at at ADP cjel-3603 236 8 215 215 NUM cjel-3603 236 9 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 236 10 describing describe VERB cjel-3603 236 11 the the DET cjel-3603 236 12 submerged submerge VERB cjel-3603 236 13 lands land NOUN cjel-3603 236 14 as as ADP cjel-3603 236 15 being be AUX cjel-3603 236 16 subject subject ADJ cjel-3603 236 17 to to ADP cjel-3603 236 18 a a DET cjel-3603 236 19 “ " PUNCT cjel-3603 236 20 paramount paramount ADJ cjel-3603 236 21 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 236 22 ” " PUNCT cjel-3603 236 23 that that PRON cjel-3603 236 24 is be AUX cjel-3603 236 25 “ " PUNCT cjel-3603 236 26 an an DET cjel-3603 236 27 incident incident NOUN cjel-3603 236 28 of of ADP cjel-3603 236 29 power power NOUN cjel-3603 236 30 incident incident NOUN cjel-3603 236 31 to to ADP cjel-3603 236 32 the the DET cjel-3603 236 33 commerce commerce NOUN cjel-3603 236 34 clause clause NOUN cjel-3603 236 35 ” " PUNCT cjel-3603 236 36 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 236 37 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 237 1 54 54 NUM cjel-3603 237 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 238 1 wickard wickard PROPN cjel-3603 238 2 v. v. ADP cjel-3603 238 3 filburn filburn NOUN cjel-3603 238 4 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 238 5 317 317 NUM cjel-3603 238 6 u.s u.s PROPN cjel-3603 238 7 . . PROPN cjel-3603 238 8 111 111 NUM cjel-3603 238 9 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 238 10 1942 1942 NUM cjel-3603 238 11 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 238 12 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 239 1 55 55 NUM cjel-3603 239 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 240 1 armstrong armstrong PROPN cjel-3603 240 2 v. v. PROPN cjel-3603 240 3 united united PROPN cjel-3603 240 4 states states PROPN cjel-3603 240 5 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 240 6 364 364 NUM cjel-3603 240 7 u.s u.s PROPN cjel-3603 240 8 . . PROPN cjel-3603 240 9 40 40 NUM cjel-3603 240 10 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 240 11 49 49 NUM cjel-3603 240 12 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 240 13 1960 1960 NUM cjel-3603 240 14 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 240 15 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 241 1 monahan monahan PROPN cjel-3603 241 2 - - PUNCT cjel-3603 241 3 macro-[final macro-[final PROPN cjel-3603 241 4 6 6 NUM cjel-3603 241 5 - - SYM cjel-3603 241 6 20 20 NUM cjel-3603 241 7 ] ] PUNCT cjel-3603 241 8 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 241 9 do do AUX cjel-3603 241 10 not not PART cjel-3603 241 11 delete delete VERB cjel-3603 241 12 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 241 13 6/22/2015 6/22/2015 NUM cjel-3603 241 14 11:53 11:53 NUM cjel-3603 241 15 pm pm NOUN cjel-3603 241 16 370 370 NUM cjel-3603 241 17 columbia columbia PROPN cjel-3603 241 18 journal journal PROPN cjel-3603 241 19 of of ADP cjel-3603 241 20 environmental environmental ADJ cjel-3603 241 21 law law NOUN cjel-3603 242 1 [ [ X cjel-3603 242 2 vol vol NOUN cjel-3603 242 3 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 243 1 40:2 40:2 NOUN cjel-3603 243 2 river.56 river.56 VERB cjel-3603 243 3 the the DET cjel-3603 243 4 government government NOUN cjel-3603 243 5 argued argue VERB cjel-3603 243 6 that that SCONJ cjel-3603 243 7 the the DET cjel-3603 243 8 compensable compensable ADJ cjel-3603 243 9 value value NOUN cjel-3603 243 10 of of ADP cjel-3603 243 11 the the DET cjel-3603 243 12 land land NOUN cjel-3603 243 13 did do AUX cjel-3603 243 14 not not PART cjel-3603 243 15 include include VERB cjel-3603 243 16 its its PRON cjel-3603 243 17 value value NOUN cjel-3603 243 18 as as ADP cjel-3603 243 19 a a DET cjel-3603 243 20 port port NOUN cjel-3603 243 21 site site NOUN cjel-3603 243 22 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 243 23 thus thus ADV cjel-3603 243 24 was be AUX cjel-3603 243 25 about about ADV cjel-3603 243 26 one one NUM cjel-3603 243 27 - - PUNCT cjel-3603 243 28 fifth fifth NOUN cjel-3603 243 29 the the DET cjel-3603 243 30 claimed claimed ADJ cjel-3603 243 31 economic economic ADJ cjel-3603 243 32 value value NOUN cjel-3603 243 33 of of ADP cjel-3603 243 34 the the DET cjel-3603 243 35 land.57 land.57 NOUN cjel-3603 243 36 this this PRON cjel-3603 243 37 was be AUX cjel-3603 243 38 because because SCONJ cjel-3603 243 39 the the DET cjel-3603 243 40 economic economic ADJ cjel-3603 243 41 value value NOUN cjel-3603 243 42 necessarily necessarily ADV cjel-3603 243 43 included include VERB cjel-3603 243 44 the the DET cjel-3603 243 45 riparian riparian ADJ cjel-3603 243 46 owner owner NOUN cjel-3603 243 47 ’s ’s PART cjel-3603 243 48 ability ability NOUN cjel-3603 243 49 to to PART cjel-3603 243 50 access access VERB cjel-3603 243 51 the the DET cjel-3603 243 52 columbia columbia PROPN cjel-3603 243 53 river river PROPN cjel-3603 243 54 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 244 1 since since SCONJ cjel-3603 244 2 this this DET cjel-3603 244 3 right right NOUN cjel-3603 244 4 of of ADP cjel-3603 244 5 access access NOUN cjel-3603 244 6 could could AUX cjel-3603 244 7 be be AUX cjel-3603 244 8 abridged abridge VERB cjel-3603 244 9 without without ADP cjel-3603 244 10 compensation compensation NOUN cjel-3603 244 11 through through ADP cjel-3603 244 12 use use NOUN cjel-3603 244 13 of of ADP cjel-3603 244 14 the the DET cjel-3603 244 15 navigational navigational ADJ cjel-3603 244 16 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 244 17 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 244 18 the the DET cjel-3603 244 19 court court NOUN cjel-3603 244 20 reasoned reason VERB cjel-3603 244 21 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 244 22 the the DET cjel-3603 244 23 government government NOUN cjel-3603 244 24 could could AUX cjel-3603 244 25 also also ADV cjel-3603 244 26 “ " PUNCT cjel-3603 244 27 disregard disregard VERB cjel-3603 244 28 the the DET cjel-3603 244 29 value value NOUN cjel-3603 244 30 arising arise VERB cjel-3603 244 31 from from ADP cjel-3603 244 32 this this DET cjel-3603 244 33 same same ADJ cjel-3603 244 34 fact fact NOUN cjel-3603 244 35 of of ADP cjel-3603 244 36 riparian riparian ADJ cjel-3603 244 37 location location NOUN cjel-3603 244 38 in in ADP cjel-3603 244 39 compensating compensate VERB cjel-3603 244 40 the the DET cjel-3603 244 41 owner owner NOUN cjel-3603 244 42 when when SCONJ cjel-3603 244 43 fast fast ADJ cjel-3603 244 44 lands land NOUN cjel-3603 244 45 are be AUX cjel-3603 244 46 appropriated appropriate VERB cjel-3603 244 47 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 245 1 ”58 ”58 PROPN cjel-3603 245 2 in in ADP cjel-3603 245 3 effect effect NOUN cjel-3603 245 4 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 245 5 the the DET cjel-3603 245 6 extra extra ADJ cjel-3603 245 7 value value NOUN cjel-3603 245 8 of of ADP cjel-3603 245 9 the the DET cjel-3603 245 10 land land NOUN cjel-3603 245 11 was be AUX cjel-3603 245 12 something something PRON cjel-3603 245 13 to to PART cjel-3603 245 14 which which PRON cjel-3603 245 15 the the DET cjel-3603 245 16 riparian riparian ADJ cjel-3603 245 17 landowner landowner NOUN cjel-3603 245 18 had have VERB cjel-3603 245 19 no no DET cjel-3603 245 20 right right NOUN cjel-3603 245 21 since since SCONJ cjel-3603 245 22 it it PRON cjel-3603 245 23 “ " PUNCT cjel-3603 245 24 does do AUX cjel-3603 245 25 not not PART cjel-3603 245 26 ‘ ' PUNCT cjel-3603 245 27 inhere inhere VERB cjel-3603 245 28 in in ADP cjel-3603 245 29 these these DET cjel-3603 245 30 parcels parcel NOUN cjel-3603 245 31 as as ADP cjel-3603 245 32 upland upland NOUN cjel-3603 245 33 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 245 34 ’ ' PUNCT cjel-3603 245 35 but but CCONJ cjel-3603 245 36 depends depend VERB cjel-3603 245 37 on on ADP cjel-3603 245 38 use use NOUN cjel-3603 245 39 of of ADP cjel-3603 245 40 the the DET cjel-3603 245 41 water”—a water”—a NOUN cjel-3603 245 42 use use VERB cjel-3603 245 43 that that SCONJ cjel-3603 245 44 the the DET cjel-3603 245 45 riparian riparian ADJ cjel-3603 245 46 owner owner NOUN cjel-3603 245 47 is be AUX cjel-3603 245 48 not not PART cjel-3603 245 49 guaranteed guarantee VERB cjel-3603 245 50 thanks thank NOUN cjel-3603 245 51 to to ADP cjel-3603 245 52 the the DET cjel-3603 245 53 navigational navigational ADJ cjel-3603 245 54 servitude.59 servitude.59 NOUN cjel-3603 245 55 the the DET cjel-3603 245 56 practical practical ADJ cjel-3603 245 57 result result NOUN cjel-3603 245 58 of of ADP cjel-3603 245 59 rands rand NOUN cjel-3603 245 60 was be AUX cjel-3603 245 61 that that SCONJ cjel-3603 245 62 the the DET cjel-3603 245 63 government government NOUN cjel-3603 245 64 was be AUX cjel-3603 245 65 able able ADJ cjel-3603 245 66 to to PART cjel-3603 245 67 acquire acquire VERB cjel-3603 245 68 land land NOUN cjel-3603 245 69 for for ADP cjel-3603 245 70 public public ADJ cjel-3603 245 71 use use NOUN cjel-3603 245 72 at at ADP cjel-3603 245 73 one one NUM cjel-3603 245 74 - - PUNCT cjel-3603 245 75 fifth fifth NOUN cjel-3603 245 76 the the DET cjel-3603 245 77 market market NOUN cjel-3603 245 78 rate rate NOUN cjel-3603 245 79 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 246 1 such such DET cjel-3603 246 2 an an DET cjel-3603 246 3 action action NOUN cjel-3603 246 4 goes go VERB cjel-3603 246 5 against against ADP cjel-3603 246 6 the the DET cjel-3603 246 7 stated state VERB cjel-3603 246 8 equity equity NOUN cjel-3603 246 9 goals goal NOUN cjel-3603 246 10 of of ADP cjel-3603 246 11 the the DET cjel-3603 246 12 takings taking NOUN cjel-3603 246 13 clause clause NOUN cjel-3603 246 14 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 246 15 places place VERB cjel-3603 246 16 a a DET cjel-3603 246 17 heavy heavy ADJ cjel-3603 246 18 burden burden NOUN cjel-3603 246 19 on on ADP cjel-3603 246 20 the the DET cjel-3603 246 21 riparian riparian ADJ cjel-3603 246 22 landowner landowner NOUN cjel-3603 246 23 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 247 1 a a DET cjel-3603 247 2 closer close ADJ cjel-3603 247 3 look look NOUN cjel-3603 247 4 at at ADP cjel-3603 247 5 the the DET cjel-3603 247 6 facts fact NOUN cjel-3603 247 7 of of ADP cjel-3603 247 8 rands rand NOUN cjel-3603 247 9 exposes expose VERB cjel-3603 247 10 just just ADV cjel-3603 247 11 how how SCONJ cjel-3603 247 12 troubling troubling ADJ cjel-3603 247 13 this this DET cjel-3603 247 14 result result NOUN cjel-3603 247 15 is be AUX cjel-3603 247 16 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 248 1 at at ADP cjel-3603 248 2 the the DET cjel-3603 248 3 time time NOUN cjel-3603 248 4 of of ADP cjel-3603 248 5 the the DET cjel-3603 248 6 condemnation condemnation NOUN cjel-3603 248 7 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 248 8 the the DET cjel-3603 248 9 landowner landowner NOUN cjel-3603 248 10 was be AUX cjel-3603 248 11 leasing lease VERB cjel-3603 248 12 the the DET cjel-3603 248 13 land land NOUN cjel-3603 248 14 to to ADP cjel-3603 248 15 the the DET cjel-3603 248 16 state state NOUN cjel-3603 248 17 of of ADP cjel-3603 248 18 oregon oregon PROPN cjel-3603 248 19 with with ADP cjel-3603 248 20 an an DET cjel-3603 248 21 option option NOUN cjel-3603 248 22 to to PART cjel-3603 248 23 purchase.60 purchase.60 VERB cjel-3603 248 24 however however ADV cjel-3603 248 25 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 248 26 the the DET cjel-3603 248 27 land land NOUN cjel-3603 248 28 was be AUX cjel-3603 248 29 condemned condemn VERB cjel-3603 248 30 by by ADP cjel-3603 248 31 the the DET cjel-3603 248 32 united united PROPN cjel-3603 248 33 states states PROPN cjel-3603 248 34 at at ADP cjel-3603 248 35 the the DET cjel-3603 248 36 deeply deeply ADV cjel-3603 248 37 discounted discount VERB cjel-3603 248 38 price price NOUN cjel-3603 248 39 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 248 40 then then ADV cjel-3603 248 41 ultimately ultimately ADV cjel-3603 248 42 conveyed convey VERB cjel-3603 248 43 to to ADP cjel-3603 248 44 the the DET cjel-3603 248 45 state state NOUN cjel-3603 248 46 of of ADP cjel-3603 248 47 oregon oregon PROPN cjel-3603 248 48 at at ADP cjel-3603 248 49 “ " PUNCT cjel-3603 248 50 considerably considerably ADV cjel-3603 248 51 less less ADJ cjel-3603 248 52 than than ADP cjel-3603 248 53 the the DET cjel-3603 248 54 option option NOUN cjel-3603 248 55 price price NOUN cjel-3603 248 56 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 249 1 ”61 ”61 NOUN cjel-3603 249 2 through through ADP cjel-3603 249 3 use use NOUN cjel-3603 249 4 of of ADP cjel-3603 249 5 the the DET cjel-3603 249 6 navigational navigational ADJ cjel-3603 249 7 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 249 8 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 249 9 oregon oregon PROPN cjel-3603 249 10 obtained obtain VERB cjel-3603 249 11 the the DET cjel-3603 249 12 land land NOUN cjel-3603 249 13 at at ADP cjel-3603 249 14 a a DET cjel-3603 249 15 far far ADV cjel-3603 249 16 better well ADJ cjel-3603 249 17 price price NOUN cjel-3603 249 18 than than SCONJ cjel-3603 249 19 if if SCONJ cjel-3603 249 20 it it PRON cjel-3603 249 21 had have AUX cjel-3603 249 22 exercised exercise VERB cjel-3603 249 23 the the DET cjel-3603 249 24 option option NOUN cjel-3603 249 25 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 250 1 if if SCONJ cjel-3603 250 2 this this DET cjel-3603 250 3 parcel parcel NOUN cjel-3603 250 4 of of ADP cjel-3603 250 5 land land NOUN cjel-3603 250 6 had have AUX cjel-3603 250 7 not not PART cjel-3603 250 8 been be AUX cjel-3603 250 9 adjacent adjacent ADJ cjel-3603 250 10 to to ADP cjel-3603 250 11 the the DET cjel-3603 250 12 columbia columbia PROPN cjel-3603 250 13 river river PROPN cjel-3603 250 14 but but CCONJ cjel-3603 250 15 instead instead ADV cjel-3603 250 16 was be AUX cjel-3603 250 17 adjacent adjacent ADJ cjel-3603 250 18 to to ADP cjel-3603 250 19 a a DET cjel-3603 250 20 major major ADJ cjel-3603 250 21 highway highway NOUN cjel-3603 250 22 or or CCONJ cjel-3603 250 23 a a DET cjel-3603 250 24 mineral mineral NOUN cjel-3603 250 25 deposit deposit NOUN cjel-3603 250 26 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 250 27 the the DET cjel-3603 250 28 added add VERB cjel-3603 250 29 value value NOUN cjel-3603 250 30 derived derive VERB cjel-3603 250 31 from from ADP cjel-3603 250 32 its its PRON cjel-3603 250 33 location location NOUN cjel-3603 250 34 would would AUX cjel-3603 250 35 be be AUX cjel-3603 250 36 reflected reflect VERB cjel-3603 250 37 in in ADP cjel-3603 250 38 the the DET cjel-3603 250 39 fair fair ADJ cjel-3603 250 40 market market NOUN cjel-3603 250 41 value value NOUN cjel-3603 250 42 of of ADP cjel-3603 250 43 the the DET cjel-3603 250 44 property property NOUN cjel-3603 250 45 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 250 46 would would AUX cjel-3603 250 47 be be AUX cjel-3603 250 48 taken take VERB cjel-3603 250 49 into into ADP cjel-3603 250 50 consideration consideration NOUN cjel-3603 250 51 for for ADP cjel-3603 250 52 calculating calculate VERB cjel-3603 250 53 just just ADV cjel-3603 250 54 56 56 NUM cjel-3603 250 55 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 251 1 united united PROPN cjel-3603 251 2 states states PROPN cjel-3603 251 3 v. v. ADP cjel-3603 251 4 rands rand NOUN cjel-3603 251 5 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 251 6 389 389 NUM cjel-3603 251 7 u.s u.s PROPN cjel-3603 251 8 . . PROPN cjel-3603 251 9 121 121 NUM cjel-3603 251 10 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 251 11 121–22 121–22 NUM cjel-3603 251 12 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 251 13 1967 1967 NUM cjel-3603 251 14 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 251 15 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 252 1 57 57 NUM cjel-3603 252 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 253 1 i i PRON cjel-3603 253 2 d. d. PROPN cjel-3603 253 3 at at ADP cjel-3603 253 4 122 122 NUM cjel-3603 253 5 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 254 1 58 58 NUM cjel-3603 254 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 255 1 i i PRON cjel-3603 255 2 d. d. PROPN cjel-3603 255 3 at at ADP cjel-3603 255 4 123–24 123–24 PROPN cjel-3603 255 5 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 255 6 citing cite VERB cjel-3603 255 7 united united PROPN cjel-3603 255 8 states states PROPN cjel-3603 255 9 v. v. PROPN cjel-3603 255 10 va va PROPN cjel-3603 255 11 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 255 12 elec elec PROPN cjel-3603 255 13 . . PROPN cjel-3603 255 14 & & CCONJ cjel-3603 255 15 power power PROPN cjel-3603 255 16 co. co. PROPN cjel-3603 255 17 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 255 18 365 365 NUM cjel-3603 255 19 u.s u.s PROPN cjel-3603 255 20 . . PROPN cjel-3603 255 21 624 624 NUM cjel-3603 255 22 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 255 23 629 629 NUM cjel-3603 255 24 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 255 25 1961 1961 NUM cjel-3603 255 26 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 255 27 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 255 28 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 256 1 59 59 NUM cjel-3603 256 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 257 1 i i PRON cjel-3603 257 2 d. d. PROPN cjel-3603 257 3 at at ADP cjel-3603 257 4 124 124 NUM cjel-3603 257 5 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 257 6 citing cite VERB cjel-3603 257 7 united united PROPN cjel-3603 257 8 states states PROPN cjel-3603 257 9 v. v. ADP cjel-3603 257 10 chandler chandler PROPN cjel-3603 257 11 - - PUNCT cjel-3603 257 12 dunbar dunbar PROPN cjel-3603 257 13 water water PROPN cjel-3603 257 14 power power PROPN cjel-3603 257 15 co. co. PROPN cjel-3603 257 16 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 257 17 229 229 NUM cjel-3603 257 18 u.s u.s PROPN cjel-3603 257 19 . . PROPN cjel-3603 257 20 53 53 NUM cjel-3603 257 21 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 257 22 76 76 NUM cjel-3603 257 23 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 257 24 1913 1913 NUM cjel-3603 257 25 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 257 26 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 257 27 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 258 1 60 60 NUM cjel-3603 258 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 259 1 i i PRON cjel-3603 259 2 d. d. PROPN cjel-3603 259 3 at at ADP cjel-3603 259 4 122 122 NUM cjel-3603 259 5 . . PROPN cjel-3603 259 6 61 61 NUM cjel-3603 259 7 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 260 1 i i PRON cjel-3603 260 2 d. d. PROPN cjel-3603 260 3 monahan monahan PROPN cjel-3603 260 4 - - PUNCT cjel-3603 260 5 macro-[final macro-[final PROPN cjel-3603 260 6 6 6 NUM cjel-3603 260 7 - - SYM cjel-3603 260 8 20 20 NUM cjel-3603 260 9 ] ] PUNCT cjel-3603 260 10 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 260 11 do do AUX cjel-3603 260 12 not not PART cjel-3603 260 13 delete delete VERB cjel-3603 260 14 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 260 15 6/22/2015 6/22/2015 NUM cjel-3603 260 16 11:53 11:53 NUM cjel-3603 260 17 pm pm NOUN cjel-3603 260 18 2015 2015 NUM cjel-3603 260 19 ] ] PUNCT cjel-3603 260 20 the the DET cjel-3603 260 21 navigational navigational ADJ cjel-3603 260 22 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 260 23 371 371 NUM cjel-3603 260 24 compensation.62 compensation.62 NOUN cjel-3603 260 25 in in ADP cjel-3603 260 26 the the DET cjel-3603 260 27 open open ADJ cjel-3603 260 28 market market NOUN cjel-3603 260 29 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 260 30 a a DET cjel-3603 260 31 purchaser purchaser NOUN cjel-3603 260 32 would would AUX cjel-3603 260 33 likely likely ADV cjel-3603 260 34 have have VERB cjel-3603 260 35 to to PART cjel-3603 260 36 pay pay VERB cjel-3603 260 37 a a DET cjel-3603 260 38 price price NOUN cjel-3603 260 39 much much ADV cjel-3603 260 40 closer close ADJ cjel-3603 260 41 to to ADP cjel-3603 260 42 the the DET cjel-3603 260 43 option option NOUN cjel-3603 260 44 price price NOUN cjel-3603 260 45 in in ADP cjel-3603 260 46 order order NOUN cjel-3603 260 47 to to PART cjel-3603 260 48 fairly fairly ADV cjel-3603 260 49 acquire acquire VERB cjel-3603 260 50 the the DET cjel-3603 260 51 parcel parcel NOUN cjel-3603 260 52 of of ADP cjel-3603 260 53 land land NOUN cjel-3603 260 54 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 261 1 the the DET cjel-3603 261 2 large large ADJ cjel-3603 261 3 discrepancy discrepancy NOUN cjel-3603 261 4 between between ADP cjel-3603 261 5 the the DET cjel-3603 261 6 option option NOUN cjel-3603 261 7 price price NOUN cjel-3603 261 8 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 261 9 the the DET cjel-3603 261 10 one one NUM cjel-3603 261 11 - - PUNCT cjel-3603 261 12 fifth fifth NOUN cjel-3603 261 13 received receive VERB cjel-3603 261 14 demonstrates demonstrate VERB cjel-3603 261 15 the the DET cjel-3603 261 16 draconian draconian ADJ cjel-3603 261 17 effect effect NOUN cjel-3603 261 18 of of ADP cjel-3603 261 19 the the DET cjel-3603 261 20 navigational navigational ADJ cjel-3603 261 21 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 261 22 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 262 1 this this DET cjel-3603 262 2 effect effect NOUN cjel-3603 262 3 is be AUX cjel-3603 262 4 not not PART cjel-3603 262 5 only only ADV cjel-3603 262 6 harsh harsh ADJ cjel-3603 262 7 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 262 8 but but CCONJ cjel-3603 262 9 inequitable inequitable ADJ cjel-3603 262 10 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 263 1 riparian riparian ADJ cjel-3603 263 2 owners owner NOUN cjel-3603 263 3 bear bear VERB cjel-3603 263 4 the the DET cjel-3603 263 5 burden burden NOUN cjel-3603 263 6 of of ADP cjel-3603 263 7 the the DET cjel-3603 263 8 public public ADJ cjel-3603 263 9 benefit benefit NOUN cjel-3603 263 10 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 263 11 receive receive VERB cjel-3603 263 12 less less ADJ cjel-3603 263 13 money money NOUN cjel-3603 263 14 for for ADP cjel-3603 263 15 their their PRON cjel-3603 263 16 condemned condemn VERB cjel-3603 263 17 properties property NOUN cjel-3603 263 18 than than ADP cjel-3603 263 19 other other ADJ cjel-3603 263 20 landowners landowner NOUN cjel-3603 263 21 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 264 1 this this DET cjel-3603 264 2 result result NOUN cjel-3603 264 3 also also ADV cjel-3603 264 4 contradicts contradict VERB cjel-3603 264 5 the the DET cjel-3603 264 6 efficiency efficiency NOUN cjel-3603 264 7 goals goal NOUN cjel-3603 264 8 of of ADP cjel-3603 264 9 the the DET cjel-3603 264 10 takings taking NOUN cjel-3603 264 11 clause clause NOUN cjel-3603 264 12 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 265 1 by by ADP cjel-3603 265 2 invoking invoke VERB cjel-3603 265 3 the the DET cjel-3603 265 4 navigational navigational ADJ cjel-3603 265 5 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 265 6 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 265 7 taking take VERB cjel-3603 265 8 riparian riparian ADJ cjel-3603 265 9 land land NOUN cjel-3603 265 10 becomes become VERB cjel-3603 265 11 less less ADV cjel-3603 265 12 expensive expensive ADJ cjel-3603 265 13 than than ADP cjel-3603 265 14 taking take VERB cjel-3603 265 15 non non ADJ cjel-3603 265 16 - - ADJ cjel-3603 265 17 riparian riparian ADJ cjel-3603 265 18 land land NOUN cjel-3603 265 19 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 266 1 thus thus ADV cjel-3603 266 2 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 266 3 riparian riparian ADJ cjel-3603 266 4 land land NOUN cjel-3603 266 5 may may AUX cjel-3603 266 6 become become VERB cjel-3603 266 7 more more ADV cjel-3603 266 8 attractive attractive ADJ cjel-3603 266 9 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 266 10 incentivizing incentivize VERB cjel-3603 266 11 the the DET cjel-3603 266 12 government government NOUN cjel-3603 266 13 to to PART cjel-3603 266 14 take take VERB cjel-3603 266 15 it it PRON cjel-3603 266 16 over over ADP cjel-3603 266 17 other other ADJ cjel-3603 266 18 land.63 land.63 NOUN cjel-3603 266 19 such such ADJ cjel-3603 266 20 inefficiency inefficiency NOUN cjel-3603 266 21 is be AUX cjel-3603 266 22 economically economically ADV cjel-3603 266 23 detrimental detrimental ADJ cjel-3603 266 24 because because SCONJ cjel-3603 266 25 it it PRON cjel-3603 266 26 can can AUX cjel-3603 266 27 result result VERB cjel-3603 266 28 in in ADP cjel-3603 266 29 a a DET cjel-3603 266 30 misallocation misallocation NOUN cjel-3603 266 31 of of ADP cjel-3603 266 32 resources.64 resources.64 NOUN cjel-3603 266 33 this this PRON cjel-3603 266 34 can can AUX cjel-3603 266 35 also also ADV cjel-3603 266 36 create create VERB cjel-3603 266 37 an an DET cjel-3603 266 38 incentive incentive NOUN cjel-3603 266 39 to to PART cjel-3603 266 40 take take VERB cjel-3603 266 41 property property NOUN cjel-3603 266 42 under under ADP cjel-3603 266 43 the the DET cjel-3603 266 44 navigational navigational ADJ cjel-3603 266 45 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 266 46 as as SCONJ cjel-3603 266 47 opposed oppose VERB cjel-3603 266 48 to to ADP cjel-3603 266 49 other other ADJ cjel-3603 266 50 regulatory regulatory ADJ cjel-3603 266 51 or or CCONJ cjel-3603 266 52 police police NOUN cjel-3603 266 53 powers.65 powers.65 NOUN cjel-3603 266 54 for for ADP cjel-3603 266 55 instance instance NOUN cjel-3603 266 56 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 266 57 in in ADP cjel-3603 266 58 united united PROPN cjel-3603 266 59 states states PROPN cjel-3603 266 60 v. v. ADP cjel-3603 266 61 412.715 412.715 NUM cjel-3603 266 62 acres acre NOUN cjel-3603 266 63 of of ADP cjel-3603 266 64 land land NOUN cjel-3603 266 65 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 266 66 the the DET cjel-3603 266 67 united united PROPN cjel-3603 266 68 states states PROPN cjel-3603 266 69 sought seek VERB cjel-3603 266 70 to to PART cjel-3603 266 71 condemn condemn VERB cjel-3603 266 72 a a DET cjel-3603 266 73 large large ADJ cjel-3603 266 74 parcel parcel NOUN cjel-3603 266 75 of of ADP cjel-3603 266 76 land land NOUN cjel-3603 266 77 in in ADP cjel-3603 266 78 california california PROPN cjel-3603 266 79 for for ADP cjel-3603 266 80 use use NOUN cjel-3603 266 81 as as ADP cjel-3603 266 82 a a DET cjel-3603 266 83 naval naval ADJ cjel-3603 266 84 fuel fuel NOUN cjel-3603 266 85 supply supply NOUN cjel-3603 266 86 depot depot NOUN cjel-3603 266 87 under under ADP cjel-3603 266 88 its its PRON cjel-3603 266 89 power power NOUN cjel-3603 266 90 to to PART cjel-3603 266 91 maintain maintain VERB cjel-3603 266 92 a a DET cjel-3603 266 93 navy navy NOUN cjel-3603 266 94 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 266 95 not not PART cjel-3603 266 96 under under ADP cjel-3603 266 97 the the DET cjel-3603 266 98 navigational navigational ADJ cjel-3603 266 99 servitude.66 servitude.66 NOUN cjel-3603 266 100 while while SCONJ cjel-3603 266 101 the the DET cjel-3603 266 102 government government NOUN cjel-3603 266 103 agreed agree VERB cjel-3603 266 104 to to PART cjel-3603 266 105 pay pay VERB cjel-3603 266 106 just just ADV cjel-3603 266 107 compensation compensation NOUN cjel-3603 266 108 for for ADP cjel-3603 266 109 all all DET cjel-3603 266 110 fast fast ADJ cjel-3603 266 111 lands land NOUN cjel-3603 266 112 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 266 113 it it PRON cjel-3603 266 114 invoked invoke VERB cjel-3603 266 115 the the DET cjel-3603 266 116 navigational navigational ADJ cjel-3603 266 117 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 266 118 to to PART cjel-3603 266 119 claim claim VERB cjel-3603 266 120 that that SCONJ cjel-3603 266 121 compensation compensation NOUN cjel-3603 266 122 for for ADP cjel-3603 266 123 any any DET cjel-3603 266 124 submerged submerge VERB cjel-3603 266 125 lands land NOUN cjel-3603 266 126 was be AUX cjel-3603 266 127 not not PART cjel-3603 266 128 required.67 required.67 VERB cjel-3603 266 129 the the DET cjel-3603 266 130 62 62 NUM cjel-3603 266 131 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 267 1 united united PROPN cjel-3603 267 2 states states PROPN cjel-3603 267 3 v. v. PROPN cjel-3603 267 4 miller miller PROPN cjel-3603 267 5 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 267 6 317 317 NUM cjel-3603 267 7 u.s u.s PROPN cjel-3603 267 8 . . PROPN cjel-3603 267 9 369 369 NUM cjel-3603 267 10 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 267 11 374 374 NUM cjel-3603 267 12 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 267 13 1943 1943 NUM cjel-3603 267 14 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 267 15 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 267 16 noting note VERB cjel-3603 267 17 that that SCONJ cjel-3603 267 18 in in ADP cjel-3603 267 19 calculating calculate VERB cjel-3603 267 20 just just ADV cjel-3603 267 21 compensation compensation NOUN cjel-3603 267 22 for for ADP cjel-3603 267 23 takings taking NOUN cjel-3603 267 24 claims claim NOUN cjel-3603 267 25 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 267 26 courts court NOUN cjel-3603 267 27 have have AUX cjel-3603 267 28 adopted adopt VERB cjel-3603 267 29 the the DET cjel-3603 267 30 concept concept NOUN cjel-3603 267 31 of of ADP cjel-3603 267 32 market market NOUN cjel-3603 267 33 value value NOUN cjel-3603 267 34 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 267 35 or or CCONJ cjel-3603 267 36 what what DET cjel-3603 267 37 price price NOUN cjel-3603 267 38 “ " PUNCT cjel-3603 267 39 it it PRON cjel-3603 267 40 fairly fairly ADV cjel-3603 267 41 may may AUX cjel-3603 267 42 be be AUX cjel-3603 267 43 believed believe VERB cjel-3603 267 44 that that SCONJ cjel-3603 267 45 a a DET cjel-3603 267 46 purchaser purchaser NOUN cjel-3603 267 47 in in ADP cjel-3603 267 48 fair fair ADJ cjel-3603 267 49 market market NOUN cjel-3603 267 50 conditions condition NOUN cjel-3603 267 51 would would AUX cjel-3603 267 52 have have AUX cjel-3603 267 53 given give VERB cjel-3603 267 54 ” " PUNCT cjel-3603 267 55 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 267 56 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 268 1 63 63 NUM cjel-3603 268 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 268 3 see see VERB cjel-3603 268 4 generally generally ADV cjel-3603 268 5 richard richard PROPN cjel-3603 268 6 a. a. NOUN cjel-3603 268 7 posner posner NOUN cjel-3603 268 8 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 268 9 economic economic ADJ cjel-3603 268 10 analysis analysis NOUN cjel-3603 268 11 of of ADP cjel-3603 268 12 law law NOUN cjel-3603 268 13 58 58 NUM cjel-3603 268 14 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 268 15 4th 4th ADJ cjel-3603 268 16 ed ed NOUN cjel-3603 268 17 . . PROPN cjel-3603 268 18 1992 1992 NUM cjel-3603 268 19 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 268 20 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 268 21 arguing argue VERB cjel-3603 268 22 that that SCONJ cjel-3603 268 23 the the DET cjel-3603 268 24 compensation compensation NOUN cjel-3603 268 25 requirement requirement NOUN cjel-3603 268 26 prevents prevent VERB cjel-3603 268 27 the the DET cjel-3603 268 28 government government NOUN cjel-3603 268 29 from from ADP cjel-3603 268 30 ignoring ignore VERB cjel-3603 268 31 costs cost NOUN cjel-3603 268 32 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 268 33 overusing overuse VERB cjel-3603 268 34 the the DET cjel-3603 268 35 taking taking NOUN cjel-3603 268 36 power power NOUN cjel-3603 268 37 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 268 38 ; ; PUNCT cjel-3603 268 39 see see VERB cjel-3603 268 40 also also ADV cjel-3603 268 41 william william PROPN cjel-3603 268 42 a. a. PROPN cjel-3603 268 43 fischel fischel PROPN cjel-3603 268 44 & & CCONJ cjel-3603 268 45 perry perry PROPN cjel-3603 268 46 shapiro shapiro PROPN cjel-3603 268 47 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 268 48 takings taking NOUN cjel-3603 268 49 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 268 50 insurance insurance NOUN cjel-3603 268 51 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 268 52 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 268 53 michelman michelman NOUN cjel-3603 268 54 : : PUNCT cjel-3603 268 55 comments comment NOUN cjel-3603 268 56 on on ADP cjel-3603 268 57 economic economic ADJ cjel-3603 268 58 interpretations interpretation NOUN cjel-3603 268 59 of of ADP cjel-3603 268 60 “ " PUNCT cjel-3603 268 61 just just ADV cjel-3603 268 62 compensation compensation NOUN cjel-3603 268 63 ” " PUNCT cjel-3603 268 64 law law NOUN cjel-3603 268 65 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 268 66 17 17 NUM cjel-3603 268 67 j. j. PROPN cjel-3603 268 68 legal legal ADJ cjel-3603 268 69 stud stud NOUN cjel-3603 268 70 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 269 1 269 269 NUM cjel-3603 269 2 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 269 3 269–70 269–70 NUM cjel-3603 269 4 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 269 5 1988 1988 NUM cjel-3603 269 6 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 269 7 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 269 8 summarizing summarize VERB cjel-3603 269 9 the the DET cjel-3603 269 10 “ " PUNCT cjel-3603 269 11 conventional conventional ADJ cjel-3603 269 12 economic economic ADJ cjel-3603 269 13 wisdom wisdom NOUN cjel-3603 269 14 ” " PUNCT cjel-3603 269 15 that that SCONJ cjel-3603 269 16 “ " PUNCT cjel-3603 269 17 [ [ X cjel-3603 269 18 t]he t]he ADJ cjel-3603 269 19 compensation compensation NOUN cjel-3603 269 20 requirement requirement NOUN cjel-3603 269 21 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 269 22 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 270 1 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 270 2 serves serve VERB cjel-3603 270 3 the the DET cjel-3603 270 4 dual dual ADJ cjel-3603 270 5 purpose purpose NOUN cjel-3603 270 6 of of ADP cjel-3603 270 7 disciplining discipline VERB cjel-3603 270 8 the the DET cjel-3603 270 9 power power NOUN cjel-3603 270 10 of of ADP cjel-3603 270 11 the the DET cjel-3603 270 12 state state NOUN cjel-3603 270 13 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 270 14 which which PRON cjel-3603 270 15 would would AUX cjel-3603 270 16 otherwise otherwise ADV cjel-3603 270 17 overexpand overexpand VERB cjel-3603 270 18 unless unless SCONJ cjel-3603 270 19 made make VERB cjel-3603 270 20 to to PART cjel-3603 270 21 pay pay VERB cjel-3603 270 22 for for ADP cjel-3603 270 23 the the DET cjel-3603 270 24 resources resource NOUN cjel-3603 270 25 that that PRON cjel-3603 270 26 it it PRON cjel-3603 270 27 consumes consume VERB cjel-3603 270 28 ” " PUNCT cjel-3603 270 29 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 270 30 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 271 1 64 64 NUM cjel-3603 271 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 272 1 see see VERB cjel-3603 272 2 michael michael PROPN cjel-3603 272 3 a. a. PROPN cjel-3603 272 4 heller heller PROPN cjel-3603 272 5 & & CCONJ cjel-3603 272 6 james james PROPN cjel-3603 272 7 e. e. PROPN cjel-3603 272 8 krier krier PROPN cjel-3603 272 9 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 272 10 deterrence deterrence NOUN cjel-3603 272 11 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 272 12 distribution distribution NOUN cjel-3603 272 13 in in ADP cjel-3603 272 14 the the DET cjel-3603 272 15 law law NOUN cjel-3603 272 16 of of ADP cjel-3603 272 17 takings taking NOUN cjel-3603 272 18 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 272 19 112 112 NUM cjel-3603 272 20 harv harv NOUN cjel-3603 272 21 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 273 1 l. l. PROPN cjel-3603 273 2 rev rev PROPN cjel-3603 273 3 . . PROPN cjel-3603 273 4 997 997 NUM cjel-3603 273 5 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 273 6 999 999 NUM cjel-3603 273 7 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 273 8 1999 1999 NUM cjel-3603 273 9 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 273 10 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 274 1 65 65 NUM cjel-3603 274 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 274 3 eva eva PROPN cjel-3603 274 4 h. h. PROPN cjel-3603 274 5 morreale morreale PROPN cjel-3603 274 6 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 274 7 federal federal ADJ cjel-3603 274 8 power power NOUN cjel-3603 274 9 in in ADP cjel-3603 274 10 western western ADJ cjel-3603 274 11 waters water NOUN cjel-3603 274 12 : : PUNCT cjel-3603 274 13 the the DET cjel-3603 274 14 navigation navigation NOUN cjel-3603 274 15 power power NOUN cjel-3603 274 16 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 274 17 the the DET cjel-3603 274 18 rule rule NOUN cjel-3603 274 19 of of ADP cjel-3603 274 20 no no DET cjel-3603 274 21 compensation compensation NOUN cjel-3603 274 22 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 274 23 3 3 NUM cjel-3603 274 24 nat nat NOUN cjel-3603 274 25 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 275 1 resources resource NOUN cjel-3603 275 2 j. j. PROPN cjel-3603 275 3 1 1 NUM cjel-3603 275 4 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 275 5 1963–1964 1963–1964 NUM cjel-3603 275 6 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 275 7 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 276 1 66 66 NUM cjel-3603 276 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 277 1 united united PROPN cjel-3603 277 2 states states PROPN cjel-3603 277 3 v. v. ADP cjel-3603 277 4 412.715 412.715 NUM cjel-3603 277 5 acres acre NOUN cjel-3603 277 6 of of ADP cjel-3603 277 7 land land NOUN cjel-3603 277 8 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 277 9 53 53 NUM cjel-3603 277 10 f. f. PROPN cjel-3603 277 11 supp supp PROPN cjel-3603 277 12 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 278 1 143 143 NUM cjel-3603 278 2 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 278 3 n.d n.d PROPN cjel-3603 278 4 . . PROPN cjel-3603 278 5 cal cal PROPN cjel-3603 278 6 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 278 7 1943 1943 NUM cjel-3603 278 8 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 278 9 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 279 1 67 67 NUM cjel-3603 279 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 280 1 i i PRON cjel-3603 280 2 d. d. PROPN cjel-3603 280 3 at at ADP cjel-3603 280 4 145 145 NUM cjel-3603 280 5 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 280 6 “ " PUNCT cjel-3603 280 7 in in ADP cjel-3603 280 8 view view NOUN cjel-3603 280 9 of of ADP cjel-3603 280 10 the the DET cjel-3603 280 11 fact fact NOUN cjel-3603 280 12 that that SCONJ cjel-3603 280 13 certain certain ADJ cjel-3603 280 14 portions portion NOUN cjel-3603 280 15 of of ADP cjel-3603 280 16 the the DET cjel-3603 280 17 lands land NOUN cjel-3603 280 18 named name VERB cjel-3603 280 19 in in ADP cjel-3603 280 20 the the DET cjel-3603 280 21 above above ADJ cjel-3603 280 22 mentioned mention VERB cjel-3603 280 23 condemnation condemnation NOUN cjel-3603 280 24 proceedings proceeding NOUN cjel-3603 280 25 are be AUX cjel-3603 280 26 situated situate VERB cjel-3603 280 27 below below ADP cjel-3603 280 28 the the DET cjel-3603 280 29 mean mean ADJ cjel-3603 280 30 high high PROPN cjel-3603 280 31 water water PROPN cjel-3603 280 32 monahan monahan PROPN cjel-3603 280 33 - - PUNCT cjel-3603 280 34 macro-[final macro-[final PROPN cjel-3603 280 35 6 6 NUM cjel-3603 280 36 - - SYM cjel-3603 280 37 20 20 NUM cjel-3603 280 38 ] ] PUNCT cjel-3603 280 39 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 280 40 do do AUX cjel-3603 280 41 not not PART cjel-3603 280 42 delete delete VERB cjel-3603 280 43 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 280 44 6/22/2015 6/22/2015 NUM cjel-3603 280 45 11:53 11:53 NUM cjel-3603 280 46 pm pm NOUN cjel-3603 280 47 372 372 NUM cjel-3603 280 48 columbia columbia PROPN cjel-3603 280 49 journal journal PROPN cjel-3603 280 50 of of ADP cjel-3603 280 51 environmental environmental ADJ cjel-3603 280 52 law law NOUN cjel-3603 281 1 [ [ X cjel-3603 281 2 vol vol NOUN cjel-3603 281 3 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 282 1 40:2 40:2 NOUN cjel-3603 282 2 landowners landowner NOUN cjel-3603 282 3 claimed claim VERB cjel-3603 282 4 “ " PUNCT cjel-3603 282 5 such such ADJ cjel-3603 282 6 use use NOUN cjel-3603 282 7 of of ADP cjel-3603 282 8 the the DET cjel-3603 282 9 lands land NOUN cjel-3603 282 10 [ [ X cjel-3603 282 11 was be AUX cjel-3603 282 12 ] ] PUNCT cjel-3603 282 13 a a DET cjel-3603 282 14 taking taking NOUN cjel-3603 282 15 of of ADP cjel-3603 282 16 private private ADJ cjel-3603 282 17 property property NOUN cjel-3603 282 18 for for ADP cjel-3603 282 19 public public ADJ cjel-3603 282 20 use use NOUN cjel-3603 282 21 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 282 22 for for ADP cjel-3603 282 23 which which PRON cjel-3603 282 24 compensation compensation NOUN cjel-3603 282 25 must must AUX cjel-3603 282 26 be be AUX cjel-3603 282 27 paid pay VERB cjel-3603 282 28 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 282 29 ”68 ”68 NOUN cjel-3603 283 1 the the DET cjel-3603 283 2 court court NOUN cjel-3603 283 3 recognized recognize VERB cjel-3603 283 4 the the DET cjel-3603 283 5 overall overall ADJ cjel-3603 283 6 validity validity NOUN cjel-3603 283 7 of of ADP cjel-3603 283 8 the the DET cjel-3603 283 9 navigational navigational ADJ cjel-3603 283 10 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 283 11 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 283 12 stating state VERB cjel-3603 283 13 that that SCONJ cjel-3603 283 14 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 283 15 unquestionably unquestionably ADV cjel-3603 283 16 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 283 17 the the DET cjel-3603 283 18 government government NOUN cjel-3603 283 19 may may AUX cjel-3603 283 20 “ " PUNCT cjel-3603 283 21 deepen deepen VERB cjel-3603 283 22 channels channel NOUN cjel-3603 283 23 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 283 24 widen widen VERB cjel-3603 283 25 streams stream NOUN cjel-3603 283 26 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 283 27 erect erect ADJ cjel-3603 283 28 lighthouses lighthouse NOUN cjel-3603 283 29 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 283 30 build build VERB cjel-3603 283 31 bridges bridge NOUN cjel-3603 283 32 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 283 33 construct construct VERB cjel-3603 283 34 dams dam NOUN cjel-3603 283 35 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 283 36 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 283 37 make make VERB cjel-3603 283 38 similar similar ADJ cjel-3603 283 39 improvements improvement NOUN cjel-3603 283 40 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 283 41 without without ADP cjel-3603 283 42 compensating compensate VERB cjel-3603 283 43 the the DET cjel-3603 283 44 owners owner NOUN cjel-3603 283 45 of of ADP cjel-3603 283 46 land land NOUN cjel-3603 283 47 subject subject ADJ cjel-3603 283 48 to to ADP cjel-3603 283 49 the the DET cjel-3603 283 50 navigation navigation NOUN cjel-3603 283 51 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 283 52 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 284 1 ”69 ”69 VERB cjel-3603 284 2 however however ADV cjel-3603 284 3 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 284 4 it it PRON cjel-3603 284 5 found find VERB cjel-3603 284 6 that that SCONJ cjel-3603 284 7 the the DET cjel-3603 284 8 naval naval ADJ cjel-3603 284 9 project project NOUN cjel-3603 284 10 in in ADP cjel-3603 284 11 question question NOUN cjel-3603 284 12 was be AUX cjel-3603 284 13 not not PART cjel-3603 284 14 one one NUM cjel-3603 284 15 undertaken undertake VERB cjel-3603 284 16 to to PART cjel-3603 284 17 aid aid VERB cjel-3603 284 18 or or CCONJ cjel-3603 284 19 enhance enhance VERB cjel-3603 284 20 navigation navigation NOUN cjel-3603 284 21 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 285 1 instead instead ADV cjel-3603 285 2 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 285 3 in in ADP cjel-3603 285 4 acquiring acquire VERB cjel-3603 285 5 the the DET cjel-3603 285 6 land land NOUN cjel-3603 285 7 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 285 8 excluding exclude VERB cjel-3603 285 9 the the DET cjel-3603 285 10 public public NOUN cjel-3603 285 11 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 285 12 the the DET cjel-3603 285 13 government government NOUN cjel-3603 285 14 had have AUX cjel-3603 285 15 acted act VERB cjel-3603 285 16 not not PART cjel-3603 285 17 “ " PUNCT cjel-3603 285 18 under under ADP cjel-3603 285 19 its its PRON cjel-3603 285 20 power power NOUN cjel-3603 285 21 to to PART cjel-3603 285 22 improve improve VERB cjel-3603 285 23 navigation navigation NOUN cjel-3603 285 24 as as ADP cjel-3603 285 25 a a DET cjel-3603 285 26 public public ADJ cjel-3603 285 27 utility utility NOUN cjel-3603 285 28 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 285 29 but but CCONJ cjel-3603 285 30 under under ADP cjel-3603 285 31 its its PRON cjel-3603 285 32 constitutional constitutional ADJ cjel-3603 285 33 power power NOUN cjel-3603 285 34 to to PART cjel-3603 285 35 maintain maintain VERB cjel-3603 285 36 a a DET cjel-3603 285 37 navy navy NOUN cjel-3603 285 38 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 286 1 ”70 ”70 PUNCT cjel-3603 286 2 therefore therefore ADV cjel-3603 286 3 the the DET cjel-3603 286 4 actions action NOUN cjel-3603 286 5 of of ADP cjel-3603 286 6 the the DET cjel-3603 286 7 government government NOUN cjel-3603 286 8 in in ADP cjel-3603 286 9 this this DET cjel-3603 286 10 instance instance NOUN cjel-3603 286 11 were be AUX cjel-3603 286 12 subject subject ADJ cjel-3603 286 13 to to ADP cjel-3603 286 14 the the DET cjel-3603 286 15 takings taking NOUN cjel-3603 286 16 clause clause NOUN cjel-3603 286 17 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 287 1 as as ADP cjel-3603 287 2 a a DET cjel-3603 287 3 result result NOUN cjel-3603 287 4 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 287 5 the the DET cjel-3603 287 6 government government NOUN cjel-3603 287 7 needed need VERB cjel-3603 287 8 to to PART cjel-3603 287 9 pay pay VERB cjel-3603 287 10 just just ADV cjel-3603 287 11 compensation compensation NOUN cjel-3603 287 12 for for ADP cjel-3603 287 13 the the DET cjel-3603 287 14 submerged submerge VERB cjel-3603 287 15 lands land NOUN cjel-3603 287 16 taken.71 taken.71 VERB cjel-3603 287 17 however however ADV cjel-3603 287 18 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 287 19 if if SCONJ cjel-3603 287 20 the the DET cjel-3603 287 21 court court NOUN cjel-3603 287 22 had have AUX cjel-3603 287 23 found find VERB cjel-3603 287 24 that that SCONJ cjel-3603 287 25 the the DET cjel-3603 287 26 same same ADJ cjel-3603 287 27 actions action NOUN cjel-3603 287 28 had have AUX cjel-3603 287 29 been be AUX cjel-3603 287 30 an an DET cjel-3603 287 31 exercise exercise NOUN cjel-3603 287 32 of of ADP cjel-3603 287 33 the the DET cjel-3603 287 34 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 287 35 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 287 36 no no DET cjel-3603 287 37 such such ADJ cjel-3603 287 38 payment payment NOUN cjel-3603 287 39 would would AUX cjel-3603 287 40 have have AUX cjel-3603 287 41 been be AUX cjel-3603 287 42 necessary necessary ADJ cjel-3603 287 43 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 288 1 a a DET cjel-3603 288 2 possible possible ADJ cjel-3603 288 3 justification justification NOUN cjel-3603 288 4 for for ADP cjel-3603 288 5 the the DET cjel-3603 288 6 inequitable inequitable ADJ cjel-3603 288 7 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 288 8 inefficient inefficient ADJ cjel-3603 288 9 results result NOUN cjel-3603 288 10 of of ADP cjel-3603 288 11 the the DET cjel-3603 288 12 navigational navigational ADJ cjel-3603 288 13 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 288 14 may may AUX cjel-3603 288 15 be be AUX cjel-3603 288 16 mitigated mitigate VERB cjel-3603 288 17 by by ADP cjel-3603 288 18 the the DET cjel-3603 288 19 “ " PUNCT cjel-3603 288 20 notice notice NOUN cjel-3603 288 21 theory theory NOUN cjel-3603 288 22 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 289 1 ”72 ”72 PROPN cjel-3603 290 1 while while SCONJ cjel-3603 290 2 the the DET cjel-3603 290 3 supreme supreme PROPN cjel-3603 290 4 court court PROPN cjel-3603 290 5 has have AUX cjel-3603 290 6 not not PART cjel-3603 290 7 laid lay VERB cjel-3603 290 8 out out ADP cjel-3603 290 9 a a DET cjel-3603 290 10 fully fully ADV cjel-3603 290 11 developed develop VERB cjel-3603 290 12 notice notice NOUN cjel-3603 290 13 theory theory NOUN cjel-3603 290 14 for for ADP cjel-3603 290 15 the the DET cjel-3603 290 16 navigational navigational ADJ cjel-3603 290 17 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 290 18 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 290 19 it it PRON cjel-3603 290 20 has have AUX cjel-3603 290 21 clearly clearly ADV cjel-3603 290 22 established establish VERB cjel-3603 290 23 that that SCONJ cjel-3603 290 24 all all PRON cjel-3603 290 25 submerged submerged ADJ cjel-3603 290 26 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 290 27 riparian riparian ADJ cjel-3603 290 28 lands land NOUN cjel-3603 290 29 have have AUX cjel-3603 290 30 long long ADV cjel-3603 290 31 been be AUX cjel-3603 290 32 limited limit VERB cjel-3603 290 33 by by ADP cjel-3603 290 34 the the DET cjel-3603 290 35 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 290 36 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 290 37 “ " PUNCT cjel-3603 290 38 [ [ X cjel-3603 290 39 t]here t]here NOUN cjel-3603 290 40 thus thus ADV cjel-3603 290 41 has have AUX cjel-3603 290 42 been be AUX cjel-3603 290 43 ample ample ADJ cjel-3603 290 44 notice notice NOUN cjel-3603 290 45 over over ADP cjel-3603 290 46 the the DET cjel-3603 290 47 years year NOUN cjel-3603 290 48 that that SCONJ cjel-3603 290 49 such such ADJ cjel-3603 290 50 property property NOUN cjel-3603 290 51 is be AUX cjel-3603 290 52 subject subject ADJ cjel-3603 290 53 to to ADP cjel-3603 290 54 a a DET cjel-3603 290 55 dominant dominant ADJ cjel-3603 290 56 public public ADJ cjel-3603 290 57 interest interest NOUN cjel-3603 290 58 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 291 1 ”73 ”73 PROPN cjel-3603 291 2 critics critic NOUN cjel-3603 291 3 point point VERB cjel-3603 291 4 out out ADP cjel-3603 291 5 that that SCONJ cjel-3603 291 6 such such DET cjel-3603 291 7 a a DET cjel-3603 291 8 theory theory NOUN cjel-3603 291 9 is be AUX cjel-3603 291 10 flawed flawed ADJ cjel-3603 291 11 due due ADP cjel-3603 291 12 to to ADP cjel-3603 291 13 the the DET cjel-3603 291 14 vast vast ADJ cjel-3603 291 15 expansion expansion NOUN cjel-3603 291 16 of of ADP cjel-3603 291 17 the the DET cjel-3603 291 18 role role NOUN cjel-3603 291 19 of of ADP cjel-3603 291 20 the the DET cjel-3603 291 21 federal federal ADJ cjel-3603 291 22 government government NOUN cjel-3603 291 23 in in ADP cjel-3603 291 24 development development NOUN cjel-3603 291 25 projects project NOUN cjel-3603 291 26 on on ADP cjel-3603 291 27 navigable navigable ADJ cjel-3603 291 28 waterways waterway NOUN cjel-3603 291 29 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 291 30 such such ADJ cjel-3603 291 31 as as ADP cjel-3603 291 32 dams dam NOUN cjel-3603 291 33 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 291 34 as as ADV cjel-3603 291 35 well well ADV cjel-3603 291 36 as as ADP cjel-3603 291 37 the the DET cjel-3603 291 38 expansion expansion NOUN cjel-3603 291 39 of of ADP cjel-3603 291 40 the the DET cjel-3603 291 41 line line NOUN cjel-3603 291 42 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 291 43 this this DET cjel-3603 291 44 department department NOUN cjel-3603 291 45 intends intend VERB cjel-3603 291 46 to to PART cjel-3603 291 47 exercise exercise VERB cjel-3603 291 48 on on ADP cjel-3603 291 49 behalf behalf NOUN cjel-3603 291 50 of of ADP cjel-3603 291 51 the the DET cjel-3603 291 52 united united PROPN cjel-3603 291 53 states states PROPN cjel-3603 291 54 the the DET cjel-3603 291 55 right right NOUN cjel-3603 291 56 to to PART cjel-3603 291 57 use use VERB cjel-3603 291 58 the the DET cjel-3603 291 59 land land NOUN cjel-3603 291 60 in in ADP cjel-3603 291 61 the the DET cjel-3603 291 62 exercise exercise NOUN cjel-3603 291 63 of of ADP cjel-3603 291 64 the the DET cjel-3603 291 65 sovereign sovereign ADJ cjel-3603 291 66 power power NOUN cjel-3603 291 67 of of ADP cjel-3603 291 68 the the DET cjel-3603 291 69 united united PROPN cjel-3603 291 70 states states PROPN cjel-3603 291 71 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 291 72 ” " PUNCT cjel-3603 291 73 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 291 74 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 292 1 68 68 NUM cjel-3603 292 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 293 1 i i PRON cjel-3603 293 2 d. d. PROPN cjel-3603 293 3 at at ADP cjel-3603 293 4 148 148 NUM cjel-3603 293 5 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 294 1 69 69 NUM cjel-3603 294 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 295 1 i i PRON cjel-3603 295 2 d. d. PROPN cjel-3603 295 3 70 70 NUM cjel-3603 295 4 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 296 1 i i PRON cjel-3603 296 2 d. d. PROPN cjel-3603 296 3 at at ADP cjel-3603 296 4 149 149 NUM cjel-3603 296 5 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 297 1 71 71 NUM cjel-3603 297 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 298 1 i i PRON cjel-3603 298 2 d. d. PROPN cjel-3603 298 3 72 72 NUM cjel-3603 298 4 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 299 1 morreale morreale PROPN cjel-3603 299 2 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 299 3 supra supra PROPN cjel-3603 299 4 note note PROPN cjel-3603 299 5 65 65 NUM cjel-3603 299 6 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 299 7 at at ADP cjel-3603 299 8 23–25 23–25 NUM cjel-3603 299 9 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 299 10 discussing discuss VERB cjel-3603 299 11 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 299 12 criticizing criticize VERB cjel-3603 299 13 a a DET cjel-3603 299 14 possible possible ADJ cjel-3603 299 15 “ " PUNCT cjel-3603 299 16 notice notice NOUN cjel-3603 299 17 theory theory NOUN cjel-3603 299 18 ” " PUNCT cjel-3603 299 19 justification justification NOUN cjel-3603 299 20 for for ADP cjel-3603 299 21 the the DET cjel-3603 299 22 rule rule NOUN cjel-3603 299 23 of of ADP cjel-3603 299 24 no no DET cjel-3603 299 25 compensation compensation NOUN cjel-3603 299 26 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 299 27 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 300 1 73 73 NUM cjel-3603 300 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 301 1 united united PROPN cjel-3603 301 2 states states PROPN cjel-3603 301 3 v. v. ADP cjel-3603 301 4 kan kan PROPN cjel-3603 301 5 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 302 1 city city PROPN cjel-3603 302 2 life life PROPN cjel-3603 302 3 ins ins PROPN cjel-3603 302 4 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 303 1 co co NOUN cjel-3603 303 2 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 303 3 339 339 NUM cjel-3603 303 4 u.s u.s PROPN cjel-3603 303 5 . . PROPN cjel-3603 303 6 799 799 NUM cjel-3603 303 7 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 303 8 808 808 NUM cjel-3603 303 9 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 303 10 1950 1950 NUM cjel-3603 303 11 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 303 12 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 304 1 monahan monahan PROPN cjel-3603 304 2 - - PUNCT cjel-3603 304 3 macro-[final macro-[final PROPN cjel-3603 304 4 6 6 NUM cjel-3603 304 5 - - SYM cjel-3603 304 6 20 20 NUM cjel-3603 304 7 ] ] PUNCT cjel-3603 304 8 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 304 9 do do AUX cjel-3603 304 10 not not PART cjel-3603 304 11 delete delete VERB cjel-3603 304 12 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 304 13 6/22/2015 6/22/2015 NUM cjel-3603 304 14 11:53 11:53 NUM cjel-3603 304 15 pm pm NOUN cjel-3603 304 16 2015 2015 NUM cjel-3603 304 17 ] ] PUNCT cjel-3603 304 18 the the DET cjel-3603 304 19 navigational navigational ADJ cjel-3603 304 20 servitude servitude ADJ cjel-3603 304 21 373 373 NUM cjel-3603 304 22 number number NOUN cjel-3603 304 23 of of ADP cjel-3603 304 24 waterways waterway NOUN cjel-3603 304 25 covered cover VERB cjel-3603 304 26 by by ADP cjel-3603 304 27 the the DET cjel-3603 304 28 term term NOUN cjel-3603 304 29 “ " PUNCT cjel-3603 304 30 navigable navigable ADJ cjel-3603 304 31 ” " PUNCT cjel-3603 304 32 since since SCONJ cjel-3603 304 33 the the DET cjel-3603 304 34 inception inception NOUN cjel-3603 304 35 of of ADP cjel-3603 304 36 the the DET cjel-3603 304 37 servitude.74 servitude.74 VERB cjel-3603 304 38 a a DET cjel-3603 304 39 separate separate ADJ cjel-3603 304 40 flaw flaw NOUN cjel-3603 304 41 with with ADP cjel-3603 304 42 perpetuation perpetuation NOUN cjel-3603 304 43 of of ADP cjel-3603 304 44 the the DET cjel-3603 304 45 navigational navigational ADJ cjel-3603 304 46 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 304 47 is be AUX cjel-3603 304 48 that that SCONJ cjel-3603 304 49 its its PRON cjel-3603 304 50 underlying underlie VERB cjel-3603 304 51 rationale rationale NOUN cjel-3603 304 52 may may AUX cjel-3603 304 53 no no ADV cjel-3603 304 54 longer long ADV cjel-3603 304 55 be be AUX cjel-3603 304 56 valid valid ADJ cjel-3603 304 57 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 305 1 unlike unlike ADP cjel-3603 305 2 at at ADP cjel-3603 305 3 the the DET cjel-3603 305 4 time time NOUN cjel-3603 305 5 of of ADP cjel-3603 305 6 ogden ogden PROPN cjel-3603 305 7 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 305 8 americans americans PROPN cjel-3603 305 9 no no ADV cjel-3603 305 10 longer long ADV cjel-3603 305 11 understand understand VERB cjel-3603 305 12 commerce commerce NOUN cjel-3603 305 13 to to PART cjel-3603 305 14 include include VERB cjel-3603 305 15 navigation navigation NOUN cjel-3603 305 16 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 306 1 once once ADV cjel-3603 306 2 the the DET cjel-3603 306 3 public public ADJ cjel-3603 306 4 highways highway NOUN cjel-3603 306 5 of of ADP cjel-3603 306 6 commerce commerce PROPN cjel-3603 306 7 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 306 8 large large ADJ cjel-3603 306 9 rivers river NOUN cjel-3603 306 10 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 306 11 watercourses watercourse NOUN cjel-3603 306 12 are be AUX cjel-3603 306 13 now now ADV cjel-3603 306 14 valued value VERB cjel-3603 306 15 mostly mostly ADV cjel-3603 306 16 for for ADP cjel-3603 306 17 their their PRON cjel-3603 306 18 environmental environmental ADJ cjel-3603 306 19 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 306 20 recreational recreational ADJ cjel-3603 306 21 uses.75 uses.75 NOUN cjel-3603 306 22 also also ADV cjel-3603 306 23 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 306 24 this this DET cjel-3603 306 25 exception exception NOUN cjel-3603 306 26 to to ADP cjel-3603 306 27 the the DET cjel-3603 306 28 takings taking NOUN cjel-3603 306 29 clause clause NOUN cjel-3603 306 30 has have AUX cjel-3603 306 31 not not PART cjel-3603 306 32 been be AUX cjel-3603 306 33 extended extend VERB cjel-3603 306 34 to to ADP cjel-3603 306 35 any any DET cjel-3603 306 36 other other ADJ cjel-3603 306 37 instrumentality instrumentality NOUN cjel-3603 306 38 of of ADP cjel-3603 306 39 commerce.76 commerce.76 PROPN cjel-3603 306 40 while while SCONJ cjel-3603 306 41 rivers river NOUN cjel-3603 306 42 were be AUX cjel-3603 306 43 once once ADV cjel-3603 306 44 a a DET cjel-3603 306 45 vital vital ADJ cjel-3603 306 46 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 306 47 primary primary ADJ cjel-3603 306 48 means mean NOUN cjel-3603 306 49 of of ADP cjel-3603 306 50 commerce commerce NOUN cjel-3603 306 51 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 306 52 other other ADJ cjel-3603 306 53 arteries artery NOUN cjel-3603 306 54 of of ADP cjel-3603 306 55 commerce commerce NOUN cjel-3603 306 56 have have AUX cjel-3603 306 57 emerged emerge VERB cjel-3603 306 58 over over ADP cjel-3603 306 59 time time NOUN cjel-3603 306 60 that that PRON cjel-3603 306 61 are be AUX cjel-3603 306 62 perhaps perhaps ADV cjel-3603 306 63 more more ADV cjel-3603 306 64 important important ADJ cjel-3603 306 65 to to ADP cjel-3603 306 66 our our PRON cjel-3603 306 67 modern modern ADJ cjel-3603 306 68 society society NOUN cjel-3603 306 69 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 307 1 however however ADV cjel-3603 307 2 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 307 3 no no DET cjel-3603 307 4 dominant dominant ADJ cjel-3603 307 5 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 307 6 has have AUX cjel-3603 307 7 been be AUX cjel-3603 307 8 extended extend VERB cjel-3603 307 9 to to ADP cjel-3603 307 10 the the DET cjel-3603 307 11 federal federal ADJ cjel-3603 307 12 government government NOUN cjel-3603 307 13 for for ADP cjel-3603 307 14 highways highway NOUN cjel-3603 307 15 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 307 16 phone phone NOUN cjel-3603 307 17 lines line NOUN cjel-3603 307 18 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 307 19 or or CCONJ cjel-3603 307 20 air air NOUN cjel-3603 307 21 space.77 space.77 AUX cjel-3603 307 22 the the DET cjel-3603 307 23 navigational navigational ADJ cjel-3603 307 24 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 307 25 endures endure VERB cjel-3603 307 26 as as ADP cjel-3603 307 27 a a DET cjel-3603 307 28 vestigial vestigial ADJ cjel-3603 307 29 reminder reminder NOUN cjel-3603 307 30 of of ADP cjel-3603 307 31 the the DET cjel-3603 307 32 past past ADJ cjel-3603 307 33 importance importance NOUN cjel-3603 307 34 of of ADP cjel-3603 307 35 waterways waterway NOUN cjel-3603 307 36 in in ADP cjel-3603 307 37 commerce commerce PROPN cjel-3603 307 38 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 308 1 however however ADV cjel-3603 308 2 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 308 3 commerce commerce NOUN cjel-3603 308 4 no no ADV cjel-3603 308 5 longer long ADV cjel-3603 308 6 requires require VERB cjel-3603 308 7 a a DET cjel-3603 308 8 strong strong ADJ cjel-3603 308 9 federal federal ADJ cjel-3603 308 10 authority authority NOUN cjel-3603 308 11 over over ADP cjel-3603 308 12 the the DET cjel-3603 308 13 nation nation NOUN cjel-3603 308 14 ’s ’s PART cjel-3603 308 15 waterways waterway NOUN cjel-3603 308 16 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 309 1 the the DET cjel-3603 309 2 historical historical ADJ cjel-3603 309 3 need need NOUN cjel-3603 309 4 for for ADP cjel-3603 309 5 the the DET cjel-3603 309 6 navigational navigational ADJ cjel-3603 309 7 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 309 8 can can AUX cjel-3603 309 9 no no ADV cjel-3603 309 10 longer long ADV cjel-3603 309 11 justify justify VERB cjel-3603 309 12 this this DET cjel-3603 309 13 large large ADJ cjel-3603 309 14 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 309 15 glaring glaring ADJ cjel-3603 309 16 exception exception NOUN cjel-3603 309 17 to to ADP cjel-3603 309 18 the the DET cjel-3603 309 19 takings taking NOUN cjel-3603 309 20 clause clause NOUN cjel-3603 309 21 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 310 1 b. b. PROPN cjel-3603 311 1 the the DET cjel-3603 311 2 rivers river NOUN cjel-3603 311 3 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 311 4 harbors harbor NOUN cjel-3603 311 5 act act VERB cjel-3603 311 6 proponents proponent NOUN cjel-3603 311 7 of of ADP cjel-3603 311 8 the the DET cjel-3603 311 9 navigational navigational ADJ cjel-3603 311 10 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 311 11 often often ADV cjel-3603 311 12 point point VERB cjel-3603 311 13 to to ADP cjel-3603 311 14 the the DET cjel-3603 311 15 rivers river NOUN cjel-3603 311 16 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 311 17 harbors harbor NOUN cjel-3603 311 18 act act VERB cjel-3603 311 19 as as ADP cjel-3603 311 20 solving solve VERB cjel-3603 311 21 some some PRON cjel-3603 311 22 of of ADP cjel-3603 311 23 the the DET cjel-3603 311 24 potential potential ADJ cjel-3603 311 25 inequities inequity NOUN cjel-3603 311 26 addressed address VERB cjel-3603 311 27 above above ADV cjel-3603 311 28 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 312 1 in in ADP cjel-3603 312 2 fact fact NOUN cjel-3603 312 3 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 312 4 congress congress PROPN cjel-3603 312 5 enacted enact VERB cjel-3603 312 6 section section NOUN cjel-3603 312 7 111 111 NUM cjel-3603 312 8 of of ADP cjel-3603 312 9 the the DET cjel-3603 312 10 act act NOUN cjel-3603 312 11 in in ADP cjel-3603 312 12 direct direct ADJ cjel-3603 312 13 response response NOUN cjel-3603 312 14 to to ADP cjel-3603 312 15 the the DET cjel-3603 312 16 harshness harshness NOUN cjel-3603 312 17 of of ADP cjel-3603 312 18 the the DET cjel-3603 312 19 outcome outcome NOUN cjel-3603 312 20 in in ADP cjel-3603 312 21 rands.78 rands.78 PROPN cjel-3603 312 22 while while SCONJ cjel-3603 312 23 it it PRON cjel-3603 312 24 may may AUX cjel-3603 312 25 appear appear VERB cjel-3603 312 26 to to PART cjel-3603 312 27 address address VERB cjel-3603 312 28 the the DET cjel-3603 312 29 many many ADJ cjel-3603 312 30 74 74 NUM cjel-3603 312 31 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 313 1 see see VERB cjel-3603 313 2 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 313 3 e.g. e.g. ADV cjel-3603 313 4 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 313 5 morreale morreale NOUN cjel-3603 313 6 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 313 7 supra supra PROPN cjel-3603 313 8 note note PROPN cjel-3603 313 9 65 65 NUM cjel-3603 313 10 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 313 11 at at ADP cjel-3603 313 12 24–25 24–25 NUM cjel-3603 313 13 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 313 14 “ " PUNCT cjel-3603 313 15 finally finally ADV cjel-3603 313 16 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 313 17 the the DET cjel-3603 313 18 notice notice NOUN cjel-3603 313 19 theory theory NOUN cjel-3603 313 20 fails fail VERB cjel-3603 313 21 to to PART cjel-3603 313 22 take take VERB cjel-3603 313 23 account account NOUN cjel-3603 313 24 of of ADP cjel-3603 313 25 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 313 26 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 313 27 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 314 1 the the DET cjel-3603 314 2 expansion expansion NOUN cjel-3603 314 3 of of ADP cjel-3603 314 4 the the DET cjel-3603 314 5 word word NOUN cjel-3603 314 6 ‘ ' PUNCT cjel-3603 314 7 navigable navigable ADJ cjel-3603 314 8 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 314 9 ’ ' PUNCT cjel-3603 315 1 today today NOUN cjel-3603 315 2 that that SCONJ cjel-3603 315 3 expansion expansion NOUN cjel-3603 315 4 subjects subject NOUN cjel-3603 315 5 streams stream VERB cjel-3603 315 6 to to ADP cjel-3603 315 7 federal federal ADJ cjel-3603 315 8 control control NOUN cjel-3603 315 9 which which PRON cjel-3603 315 10 not not PART cjel-3603 315 11 long long ADV cjel-3603 315 12 ago ago ADV cjel-3603 315 13 would would AUX cjel-3603 315 14 have have AUX cjel-3603 315 15 been be AUX cjel-3603 315 16 treated treat VERB cjel-3603 315 17 as as ADP cjel-3603 315 18 nonnavigable nonnavigable ADJ cjel-3603 315 19 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 315 20 thus thus ADV cjel-3603 315 21 as as ADP cjel-3603 315 22 immune immune ADJ cjel-3603 315 23 from from ADP cjel-3603 315 24 the the DET cjel-3603 315 25 dominant dominant ADJ cjel-3603 315 26 federal federal ADJ cjel-3603 315 27 power power NOUN cjel-3603 315 28 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 316 1 to to PART cjel-3603 316 2 justify justify VERB cjel-3603 316 3 the the DET cjel-3603 316 4 no no DET cjel-3603 316 5 compensation compensation NOUN cjel-3603 316 6 rule rule NOUN cjel-3603 316 7 by by ADP cjel-3603 316 8 the the DET cjel-3603 316 9 idea idea NOUN cjel-3603 316 10 of of ADP cjel-3603 316 11 notice notice NOUN cjel-3603 316 12 of of ADP cjel-3603 316 13 a a DET cjel-3603 316 14 paramount paramount ADJ cjel-3603 316 15 federal federal ADJ cjel-3603 316 16 right right NOUN cjel-3603 316 17 in in ADP cjel-3603 316 18 navigable navigable ADJ cjel-3603 316 19 streams stream NOUN cjel-3603 316 20 would would AUX cjel-3603 316 21 require require VERB cjel-3603 316 22 that that DET cjel-3603 316 23 navigability navigability NOUN cjel-3603 316 24 be be AUX cjel-3603 316 25 defined define VERB cjel-3603 316 26 as as ADP cjel-3603 316 27 of of ADP cjel-3603 316 28 the the DET cjel-3603 316 29 time time NOUN cjel-3603 316 30 the the DET cjel-3603 316 31 private private ADJ cjel-3603 316 32 right right NOUN cjel-3603 316 33 in in ADP cjel-3603 316 34 question question NOUN cjel-3603 316 35 was be AUX cjel-3603 316 36 acquired acquire VERB cjel-3603 316 37 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 316 38 ” " PUNCT cjel-3603 316 39 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 316 40 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 317 1 75 75 NUM cjel-3603 317 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 318 1 see see VERB cjel-3603 318 2 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 318 3 e.g. e.g. ADV cjel-3603 318 4 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 318 5 brown brown ADJ cjel-3603 318 6 v. v. ADP cjel-3603 318 7 chadbourne chadbourne PROPN cjel-3603 318 8 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 318 9 31 31 NUM cjel-3603 318 10 me i PRON cjel-3603 318 11 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 319 1 9 9 NUM cjel-3603 319 2 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 319 3 21 21 NUM cjel-3603 319 4 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 319 5 1849 1849 NUM cjel-3603 319 6 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 319 7 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 319 8 discussing discuss VERB cjel-3603 319 9 the the DET cjel-3603 319 10 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 319 11 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 319 12 its its PRON cjel-3603 319 13 application application NOUN cjel-3603 319 14 to to ADP cjel-3603 319 15 “ " PUNCT cjel-3603 319 16 those those DET cjel-3603 319 17 rivers river NOUN cjel-3603 319 18 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 319 19 which which DET cjel-3603 319 20 nature nature NOUN cjel-3603 319 21 has have AUX cjel-3603 319 22 plainly plainly ADV cjel-3603 319 23 declared declare VERB cjel-3603 319 24 to to PART cjel-3603 319 25 be be AUX cjel-3603 319 26 public public ADJ cjel-3603 319 27 highways highway NOUN cjel-3603 319 28 ” " PUNCT cjel-3603 319 29 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 319 30 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 320 1 76 76 NUM cjel-3603 320 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 321 1 morreale morreale PROPN cjel-3603 321 2 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 321 3 supra supra PROPN cjel-3603 321 4 note note PROPN cjel-3603 321 5 65 65 NUM cjel-3603 321 6 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 321 7 at at ADP cjel-3603 321 8 31 31 NUM cjel-3603 321 9 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 322 1 77 77 NUM cjel-3603 322 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 323 1 i i PRON cjel-3603 323 2 d. d. PROPN cjel-3603 323 3 78 78 NUM cjel-3603 323 4 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 324 1 33 33 NUM cjel-3603 324 2 u.s.c.a u.s.c.a PROPN cjel-3603 324 3 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 324 4 § § PROPN cjel-3603 324 5 595a 595a PROPN cjel-3603 324 6 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 324 7 2012 2012 NUM cjel-3603 324 8 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 324 9 ; ; PUNCT cjel-3603 324 10 see see VERB cjel-3603 324 11 alan alan PROPN cjel-3603 324 12 t. t. PROPN cjel-3603 324 13 ackerman ackerman PROPN cjel-3603 324 14 & & CCONJ cjel-3603 324 15 noah noah PROPN cjel-3603 324 16 eliezer eliezer PROPN cjel-3603 324 17 yanich yanich PROPN cjel-3603 324 18 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 324 19 just just ADV cjel-3603 324 20 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 324 21 unjust unjust ADJ cjel-3603 324 22 compensation compensation NOUN cjel-3603 324 23 : : PUNCT cjel-3603 324 24 the the DET cjel-3603 324 25 future future NOUN cjel-3603 324 26 of of ADP cjel-3603 324 27 the the DET cjel-3603 324 28 navigational navigational ADJ cjel-3603 324 29 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 324 30 in in ADP cjel-3603 324 31 condemnation condemnation NOUN cjel-3603 324 32 monahan monahan PROPN cjel-3603 324 33 - - PUNCT cjel-3603 324 34 macro-[final macro-[final PROPN cjel-3603 324 35 6 6 NUM cjel-3603 324 36 - - SYM cjel-3603 324 37 20 20 NUM cjel-3603 324 38 ] ] PUNCT cjel-3603 324 39 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 324 40 do do AUX cjel-3603 324 41 not not PART cjel-3603 324 42 delete delete VERB cjel-3603 324 43 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 325 1 6/22/2015 6/22/2015 NUM cjel-3603 325 2 11:53 11:53 NUM cjel-3603 325 3 pm pm NOUN cjel-3603 325 4 374 374 NUM cjel-3603 325 5 columbia columbia PROPN cjel-3603 325 6 journal journal PROPN cjel-3603 325 7 of of ADP cjel-3603 325 8 environmental environmental ADJ cjel-3603 325 9 law law NOUN cjel-3603 325 10 [ [ X cjel-3603 325 11 vol vol NOUN cjel-3603 325 12 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 326 1 40:2 40:2 NUM cjel-3603 326 2 problems problem NOUN cjel-3603 326 3 created create VERB cjel-3603 326 4 by by ADP cjel-3603 326 5 the the DET cjel-3603 326 6 navigational navigational ADJ cjel-3603 326 7 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 326 8 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 326 9 in in ADP cjel-3603 326 10 reality reality NOUN cjel-3603 326 11 it it PRON cjel-3603 326 12 serves serve VERB cjel-3603 326 13 a a DET cjel-3603 326 14 limited limited ADJ cjel-3603 326 15 purpose.79 purpose.79 NOUN cjel-3603 326 16 it it PRON cjel-3603 326 17 provides provide VERB cjel-3603 326 18 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 326 19 in in ADP cjel-3603 326 20 relevant relevant ADJ cjel-3603 326 21 part part NOUN cjel-3603 326 22 : : PUNCT cjel-3603 326 23 in in ADP cjel-3603 326 24 all all DET cjel-3603 326 25 cases case NOUN cjel-3603 326 26 where where SCONJ cjel-3603 326 27 real real ADJ cjel-3603 326 28 property property NOUN cjel-3603 326 29 shall shall AUX cjel-3603 326 30 be be AUX cjel-3603 326 31 taken take VERB cjel-3603 326 32 by by ADP cjel-3603 326 33 the the DET cjel-3603 326 34 united united PROPN cjel-3603 326 35 states states PROPN cjel-3603 326 36 for for ADP cjel-3603 326 37 the the DET cjel-3603 326 38 public public ADJ cjel-3603 326 39 use use NOUN cjel-3603 326 40 in in ADP cjel-3603 326 41 connection connection NOUN cjel-3603 326 42 with with ADP cjel-3603 326 43 any any DET cjel-3603 326 44 improvement improvement NOUN cjel-3603 326 45 of of ADP cjel-3603 326 46 rivers river NOUN cjel-3603 326 47 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 326 48 harbors harbor NOUN cjel-3603 326 49 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 326 50 canals canal NOUN cjel-3603 326 51 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 326 52 or or CCONJ cjel-3603 326 53 waterways waterway NOUN cjel-3603 326 54 of of ADP cjel-3603 326 55 the the DET cjel-3603 326 56 united united PROPN cjel-3603 326 57 states states PROPN cjel-3603 326 58 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 326 59 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 326 60 in in ADP cjel-3603 326 61 all all DET cjel-3603 326 62 condemnation condemnation NOUN cjel-3603 326 63 proceedings proceeding NOUN cjel-3603 326 64 by by ADP cjel-3603 326 65 the the DET cjel-3603 326 66 united united PROPN cjel-3603 326 67 states states PROPN cjel-3603 326 68 to to PART cjel-3603 326 69 acquire acquire VERB cjel-3603 326 70 lands land NOUN cjel-3603 326 71 or or CCONJ cjel-3603 326 72 easements easement NOUN cjel-3603 326 73 for for ADP cjel-3603 326 74 such such ADJ cjel-3603 326 75 improvements improvement NOUN cjel-3603 326 76 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 326 77 the the DET cjel-3603 326 78 compensation compensation NOUN cjel-3603 326 79 to to PART cjel-3603 326 80 be be AUX cjel-3603 326 81 paid pay VERB cjel-3603 326 82 for for ADP cjel-3603 326 83 real real ADJ cjel-3603 326 84 property property NOUN cjel-3603 326 85 taken take VERB cjel-3603 326 86 by by ADP cjel-3603 326 87 the the DET cjel-3603 326 88 united united PROPN cjel-3603 326 89 states states PROPN cjel-3603 326 90 above above ADP cjel-3603 326 91 the the DET cjel-3603 326 92 normal normal ADJ cjel-3603 326 93 high high ADJ cjel-3603 326 94 water water NOUN cjel-3603 326 95 mark mark NOUN cjel-3603 326 96 of of ADP cjel-3603 326 97 navigable navigable ADJ cjel-3603 326 98 waters water NOUN cjel-3603 326 99 of of ADP cjel-3603 326 100 the the DET cjel-3603 326 101 united united PROPN cjel-3603 326 102 states states PROPN cjel-3603 326 103 shall shall AUX cjel-3603 326 104 be be AUX cjel-3603 326 105 the the DET cjel-3603 326 106 fair fair ADJ cjel-3603 326 107 market market NOUN cjel-3603 326 108 value value NOUN cjel-3603 326 109 of of ADP cjel-3603 326 110 such such ADJ cjel-3603 326 111 real real ADJ cjel-3603 326 112 property property NOUN cjel-3603 326 113 based base VERB cjel-3603 326 114 upon upon SCONJ cjel-3603 326 115 all all DET cjel-3603 326 116 uses use NOUN cjel-3603 326 117 to to PART cjel-3603 326 118 which which PRON cjel-3603 326 119 such such ADJ cjel-3603 326 120 real real ADJ cjel-3603 326 121 property property NOUN cjel-3603 326 122 may may AUX cjel-3603 326 123 reasonably reasonably ADV cjel-3603 326 124 be be AUX cjel-3603 326 125 put put VERB cjel-3603 326 126 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 326 127 including include VERB cjel-3603 326 128 it it PRON cjel-3603 326 129 highest high ADJ cjel-3603 326 130 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 326 131 best good ADJ cjel-3603 326 132 use use NOUN cjel-3603 326 133 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 326 134 any any PRON cjel-3603 326 135 of of ADP cjel-3603 326 136 which which PRON cjel-3603 326 137 uses use VERB cjel-3603 326 138 may may AUX cjel-3603 326 139 be be AUX cjel-3603 326 140 dependent dependent ADJ cjel-3603 326 141 upon upon SCONJ cjel-3603 326 142 access access NOUN cjel-3603 326 143 to to ADP cjel-3603 326 144 or or CCONJ cjel-3603 326 145 utilization utilization NOUN cjel-3603 326 146 of of ADP cjel-3603 326 147 such such ADJ cjel-3603 326 148 navigable navigable ADJ cjel-3603 326 149 waters.80 waters.80 NOUN cjel-3603 326 150 thus thus ADV cjel-3603 326 151 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 326 152 when when SCONJ cjel-3603 326 153 fast fast ADJ cjel-3603 326 154 lands land NOUN cjel-3603 326 155 are be AUX cjel-3603 326 156 taken take VERB cjel-3603 326 157 in in ADP cjel-3603 326 158 connection connection NOUN cjel-3603 326 159 with with ADP cjel-3603 326 160 a a DET cjel-3603 326 161 navigation navigation NOUN cjel-3603 326 162 project project NOUN cjel-3603 326 163 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 326 164 the the DET cjel-3603 326 165 compensation compensation NOUN cjel-3603 326 166 paid pay VERB cjel-3603 326 167 must must AUX cjel-3603 326 168 include include VERB cjel-3603 326 169 the the DET cjel-3603 326 170 value value NOUN cjel-3603 326 171 added add VERB cjel-3603 326 172 to to ADP cjel-3603 326 173 the the DET cjel-3603 326 174 land land NOUN cjel-3603 326 175 by by ADP cjel-3603 326 176 the the DET cjel-3603 326 177 access access NOUN cjel-3603 326 178 to to ADP cjel-3603 326 179 or or CCONJ cjel-3603 326 180 use use NOUN cjel-3603 326 181 of of ADP cjel-3603 326 182 the the DET cjel-3603 326 183 waterway waterway NOUN cjel-3603 326 184 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 327 1 the the DET cjel-3603 327 2 first first ADJ cjel-3603 327 3 limitation limitation NOUN cjel-3603 327 4 of of ADP cjel-3603 327 5 section section NOUN cjel-3603 327 6 111 111 NUM cjel-3603 327 7 is be AUX cjel-3603 327 8 that that SCONJ cjel-3603 327 9 it it PRON cjel-3603 327 10 only only ADV cjel-3603 327 11 applies apply VERB cjel-3603 327 12 in in ADP cjel-3603 327 13 “ " PUNCT cjel-3603 327 14 cases case NOUN cjel-3603 327 15 where where SCONJ cjel-3603 327 16 real real ADJ cjel-3603 327 17 property property NOUN cjel-3603 327 18 shall shall AUX cjel-3603 327 19 be be AUX cjel-3603 327 20 taken take VERB cjel-3603 327 21 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 327 22 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 327 23 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 328 1 .”81 .”81 PROPN cjel-3603 329 1 thus thus ADV cjel-3603 329 2 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 329 3 the the DET cjel-3603 329 4 first first ADJ cjel-3603 329 5 hurdle hurdle NOUN cjel-3603 329 6 for for ADP cjel-3603 329 7 landowners landowner NOUN cjel-3603 329 8 remains remain VERB cjel-3603 329 9 the the DET cjel-3603 329 10 need need NOUN cjel-3603 329 11 to to PART cjel-3603 329 12 prove prove VERB cjel-3603 329 13 that that SCONJ cjel-3603 329 14 there there PRON cjel-3603 329 15 has have AUX cjel-3603 329 16 in in ADP cjel-3603 329 17 fact fact NOUN cjel-3603 329 18 been be AUX cjel-3603 329 19 a a DET cjel-3603 329 20 taking.82 taking.82 NOUN cjel-3603 329 21 in in ADP cjel-3603 329 22 certain certain ADJ cjel-3603 329 23 cases case NOUN cjel-3603 329 24 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 329 25 such such ADJ cjel-3603 329 26 as as ADP cjel-3603 329 27 rands rand NOUN cjel-3603 329 28 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 329 29 where where SCONJ cjel-3603 329 30 there there PRON cjel-3603 329 31 is be VERB cjel-3603 329 32 a a DET cjel-3603 329 33 direct direct ADJ cjel-3603 329 34 condemnation condemnation NOUN cjel-3603 329 35 proceeding proceeding NOUN cjel-3603 329 36 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 329 37 this this PRON cjel-3603 329 38 may may AUX cjel-3603 329 39 be be AUX cjel-3603 329 40 a a DET cjel-3603 329 41 straightforward straightforward ADJ cjel-3603 329 42 task.83 task.83 NOUN cjel-3603 329 43 once once SCONJ cjel-3603 329 44 the the DET cjel-3603 329 45 taking taking NOUN cjel-3603 329 46 of of ADP cjel-3603 329 47 the the DET cjel-3603 329 48 entire entire ADJ cjel-3603 329 49 property property NOUN cjel-3603 329 50 has have AUX cjel-3603 329 51 been be AUX cjel-3603 329 52 established establish VERB cjel-3603 329 53 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 329 54 the the DET cjel-3603 329 55 statute statute NOUN cjel-3603 329 56 is be AUX cjel-3603 329 57 then then ADV cjel-3603 329 58 triggered trigger VERB cjel-3603 329 59 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 329 60 the the DET cjel-3603 329 61 value value NOUN cjel-3603 329 62 of of ADP cjel-3603 329 63 the the DET cjel-3603 329 64 land land NOUN cjel-3603 329 65 derived derive VERB cjel-3603 329 66 from from ADP cjel-3603 329 67 its its PRON cjel-3603 329 68 proximity proximity NOUN cjel-3603 329 69 to to ADP cjel-3603 329 70 the the DET cjel-3603 329 71 waterway waterway NOUN cjel-3603 329 72 will will AUX cjel-3603 329 73 not not PART cjel-3603 329 74 be be AUX cjel-3603 329 75 deducted deduct VERB cjel-3603 329 76 from from ADP cjel-3603 329 77 the the DET cjel-3603 329 78 equation.84 equation.84 PROPN cjel-3603 329 79 however however ADV cjel-3603 329 80 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 329 81 cases case NOUN cjel-3603 329 82 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 329 83 34 34 NUM cjel-3603 329 84 u. u. PROPN cjel-3603 329 85 mich mich PROPN cjel-3603 329 86 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 330 1 j.l j.l PROPN cjel-3603 330 2 . . PROPN cjel-3603 330 3 reform reform PROPN cjel-3603 330 4 573 573 NUM cjel-3603 330 5 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 330 6 2001 2001 NUM cjel-3603 330 7 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 330 8 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 330 9 discussing discuss VERB cjel-3603 330 10 section section NOUN cjel-3603 330 11 111 111 NUM cjel-3603 330 12 of of ADP cjel-3603 330 13 the the DET cjel-3603 330 14 rivers river NOUN cjel-3603 330 15 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 330 16 harbors harbor NOUN cjel-3603 330 17 act act VERB cjel-3603 330 18 as as ADP cjel-3603 330 19 a a DET cjel-3603 330 20 congressional congressional ADJ cjel-3603 330 21 response response NOUN cjel-3603 330 22 to to ADP cjel-3603 330 23 united united PROPN cjel-3603 330 24 states states PROPN cjel-3603 330 25 v. v. ADP cjel-3603 330 26 rands rand NOUN cjel-3603 330 27 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 330 28 389 389 NUM cjel-3603 330 29 u.s u.s PROPN cjel-3603 330 30 . . PROPN cjel-3603 330 31 121 121 NUM cjel-3603 330 32 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 330 33 1967 1967 NUM cjel-3603 330 34 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 330 35 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 330 36 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 330 37 calling call VERB cjel-3603 330 38 for for ADP cjel-3603 330 39 further further ADJ cjel-3603 330 40 legislative legislative ADJ cjel-3603 330 41 intervention intervention NOUN cjel-3603 330 42 to to PART cjel-3603 330 43 abolish abolish VERB cjel-3603 330 44 the the DET cjel-3603 330 45 navigational navigational ADJ cjel-3603 330 46 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 330 47 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 330 48 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 331 1 79 79 NUM cjel-3603 331 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 332 1 see see VERB cjel-3603 332 2 ackerman ackerman PROPN cjel-3603 332 3 & & CCONJ cjel-3603 332 4 yanich yanich PROPN cjel-3603 332 5 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 332 6 supra supra PROPN cjel-3603 332 7 note note NOUN cjel-3603 332 8 78 78 NUM cjel-3603 332 9 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 333 1 80 80 NUM cjel-3603 333 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 334 1 33 33 NUM cjel-3603 334 2 u.s.c.a u.s.c.a PROPN cjel-3603 334 3 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 334 4 § § PROPN cjel-3603 334 5 595a 595a PROPN cjel-3603 334 6 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 334 7 2012 2012 NUM cjel-3603 334 8 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 334 9 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 335 1 81 81 NUM cjel-3603 335 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 336 1 i i PRON cjel-3603 336 2 d. d. PROPN cjel-3603 336 3 82 82 NUM cjel-3603 336 4 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 337 1 united united PROPN cjel-3603 337 2 states states PROPN cjel-3603 337 3 v. v. ADP cjel-3603 337 4 30.54 30.54 NUM cjel-3603 337 5 acres acre NOUN cjel-3603 337 6 of of ADP cjel-3603 337 7 land land NOUN cjel-3603 337 8 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 337 9 90 90 NUM cjel-3603 337 10 f.3d f.3d NUM cjel-3603 337 11 790 790 NUM cjel-3603 337 12 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 337 13 796 796 NUM cjel-3603 337 14 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 337 15 3d 3d PROPN cjel-3603 337 16 cir cir NOUN cjel-3603 337 17 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 337 18 1996 1996 NUM cjel-3603 337 19 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 337 20 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 337 21 “ " PUNCT cjel-3603 337 22 the the DET cjel-3603 337 23 legislative legislative ADJ cjel-3603 337 24 history history NOUN cjel-3603 337 25 of of ADP cjel-3603 337 26 section section NOUN cjel-3603 337 27 111 111 NUM cjel-3603 337 28 indicates indicate VERB cjel-3603 337 29 that that SCONJ cjel-3603 337 30 congress congress PROPN cjel-3603 337 31 intended intend VERB cjel-3603 337 32 to to PART cjel-3603 337 33 modify modify VERB cjel-3603 337 34 the the DET cjel-3603 337 35 rule rule NOUN cjel-3603 337 36 of of ADP cjel-3603 337 37 united united PROPN cjel-3603 337 38 states states PROPN cjel-3603 337 39 v. v. ADP cjel-3603 337 40 rands rand NOUN cjel-3603 337 41 only only ADV cjel-3603 337 42 to to ADP cjel-3603 337 43 the the DET cjel-3603 337 44 extent extent NOUN cjel-3603 337 45 of of ADP cjel-3603 337 46 paying pay VERB cjel-3603 337 47 full full ADJ cjel-3603 337 48 compensation compensation NOUN cjel-3603 337 49 based base VERB cjel-3603 337 50 on on ADP cjel-3603 337 51 riparian riparian ADJ cjel-3603 337 52 location location NOUN cjel-3603 337 53 in in ADP cjel-3603 337 54 cases case NOUN cjel-3603 337 55 of of ADP cjel-3603 337 56 actual actual ADJ cjel-3603 337 57 acquisition acquisition NOUN cjel-3603 337 58 of of ADP cjel-3603 337 59 above above ADP cjel-3603 337 60 the the DET cjel-3603 337 61 high high ADJ cjel-3603 337 62 - - PUNCT cjel-3603 337 63 water water NOUN cjel-3603 337 64 mark mark NOUN cjel-3603 337 65 real real ADJ cjel-3603 337 66 property property NOUN cjel-3603 337 67 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 337 68 ” " PUNCT cjel-3603 337 69 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 337 70 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 338 1 83 83 NUM cjel-3603 338 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 339 1 united united PROPN cjel-3603 339 2 states states PROPN cjel-3603 339 3 v. v. ADP cjel-3603 339 4 rands rand NOUN cjel-3603 339 5 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 339 6 389 389 NUM cjel-3603 339 7 u.s u.s PROPN cjel-3603 339 8 . . PROPN cjel-3603 339 9 121 121 NUM cjel-3603 339 10 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 339 11 1967 1967 NUM cjel-3603 339 12 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 339 13 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 340 1 84 84 NUM cjel-3603 340 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 341 1 see see VERB cjel-3603 341 2 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 341 3 e.g. e.g. ADV cjel-3603 341 4 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 341 5 united united PROPN cjel-3603 341 6 states states PROPN cjel-3603 341 7 v. v. PROPN cjel-3603 341 8 967,905 967,905 NUM cjel-3603 341 9 acres acre NOUN cjel-3603 341 10 of of ADP cjel-3603 341 11 land land NOUN cjel-3603 341 12 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 341 13 447 447 NUM cjel-3603 341 14 f.2d f.2d NOUN cjel-3603 341 15 764 764 NUM cjel-3603 341 16 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 341 17 771 771 NUM cjel-3603 341 18 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 341 19 8th 8th ADJ cjel-3603 341 20 cir cir NOUN cjel-3603 341 21 . . PROPN cjel-3603 341 22 1971 1971 NUM cjel-3603 341 23 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 341 24 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 341 25 “ " PUNCT cjel-3603 341 26 since since SCONJ cjel-3603 341 27 the the DET cjel-3603 341 28 taking taking NOUN cjel-3603 341 29 involved involve VERB cjel-3603 341 30 in in ADP cjel-3603 341 31 this this DET cjel-3603 341 32 case case NOUN cjel-3603 341 33 was be AUX cjel-3603 341 34 a a DET cjel-3603 341 35 total total ADJ cjel-3603 341 36 taking taking NOUN cjel-3603 341 37 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 341 38 we we PRON cjel-3603 341 39 think think VERB cjel-3603 341 40 that that SCONJ cjel-3603 341 41 section section NOUN cjel-3603 341 42 111 111 NUM cjel-3603 341 43 of of ADP cjel-3603 341 44 the the DET cjel-3603 341 45 act act NOUN cjel-3603 341 46 is be AUX cjel-3603 341 47 applicable applicable ADJ cjel-3603 341 48 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 341 49 should should AUX cjel-3603 341 50 be be AUX cjel-3603 341 51 followed follow VERB cjel-3603 341 52 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 341 53 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 341 54 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 341 55 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 342 1 that that PRON cjel-3603 342 2 means mean VERB cjel-3603 342 3 that that SCONJ cjel-3603 342 4 the the DET cjel-3603 342 5 [ [ X cjel-3603 342 6 appellees appellee NOUN cjel-3603 342 7 ’ ' PUNCT cjel-3603 342 8 ] ] PUNCT cjel-3603 342 9 lands land NOUN cjel-3603 342 10 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 342 11 the the DET cjel-3603 342 12 fixed fix VERB cjel-3603 342 13 improvements improvement NOUN cjel-3603 342 14 thereon thereon NOUN cjel-3603 342 15 are be AUX cjel-3603 342 16 to to PART cjel-3603 342 17 be be AUX cjel-3603 342 18 valued value VERB cjel-3603 342 19 as as ADP cjel-3603 342 20 riparian riparian PROPN cjel-3603 342 21 monahan monahan PROPN cjel-3603 342 22 - - PUNCT cjel-3603 342 23 macro-[final macro-[final PROPN cjel-3603 342 24 6 6 NUM cjel-3603 342 25 - - SYM cjel-3603 342 26 20 20 NUM cjel-3603 342 27 ] ] PUNCT cjel-3603 342 28 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 342 29 do do AUX cjel-3603 342 30 not not PART cjel-3603 342 31 delete delete VERB cjel-3603 342 32 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 342 33 6/22/2015 6/22/2015 NUM cjel-3603 342 34 11:53 11:53 NUM cjel-3603 342 35 pm pm NOUN cjel-3603 342 36 2015 2015 NUM cjel-3603 342 37 ] ] PUNCT cjel-3603 342 38 the the DET cjel-3603 342 39 navigational navigational ADJ cjel-3603 342 40 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 342 41 375 375 NUM cjel-3603 342 42 in in ADP cjel-3603 342 43 cases case NOUN cjel-3603 342 44 where where SCONJ cjel-3603 342 45 it it PRON cjel-3603 342 46 is be AUX cjel-3603 342 47 unresolved unresolved ADJ cjel-3603 342 48 whether whether SCONJ cjel-3603 342 49 a a DET cjel-3603 342 50 taking taking NOUN cjel-3603 342 51 has have AUX cjel-3603 342 52 occurred occur VERB cjel-3603 342 53 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 342 54 section section NOUN cjel-3603 342 55 111 111 NUM cjel-3603 342 56 does do AUX cjel-3603 342 57 not not PART cjel-3603 342 58 provide provide VERB cjel-3603 342 59 assistance assistance NOUN cjel-3603 342 60 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 343 1 moreover moreover ADV cjel-3603 343 2 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 343 3 courts court NOUN cjel-3603 343 4 have have AUX cjel-3603 343 5 shown show VERB cjel-3603 343 6 that that SCONJ cjel-3603 343 7 they they PRON cjel-3603 343 8 are be AUX cjel-3603 343 9 unwilling unwilling ADJ cjel-3603 343 10 to to PART cjel-3603 343 11 extend extend VERB cjel-3603 343 12 section section NOUN cjel-3603 343 13 111 111 NUM cjel-3603 343 14 beyond beyond ADP cjel-3603 343 15 the the DET cjel-3603 343 16 very very ADV cjel-3603 343 17 specific specific ADJ cjel-3603 343 18 situation situation NOUN cjel-3603 343 19 encountered encounter VERB cjel-3603 343 20 in in ADP cjel-3603 343 21 rands.85 rands.85 NOUN cjel-3603 343 22 the the DET cjel-3603 343 23 second second ADJ cjel-3603 343 24 limitation limitation NOUN cjel-3603 343 25 is be AUX cjel-3603 343 26 that that SCONJ cjel-3603 343 27 section section NOUN cjel-3603 343 28 111 111 NUM cjel-3603 343 29 retains retain VERB cjel-3603 343 30 the the DET cjel-3603 343 31 harsh harsh ADJ cjel-3603 343 32 rands rand NOUN cjel-3603 343 33 rule rule VERB cjel-3603 343 34 for for ADP cjel-3603 343 35 calculating calculate VERB cjel-3603 343 36 severance severance NOUN cjel-3603 343 37 damages damage NOUN cjel-3603 343 38 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 344 1 it it PRON cjel-3603 344 2 states state VERB cjel-3603 344 3 : : PUNCT cjel-3603 344 4 in in ADP cjel-3603 344 5 cases case NOUN cjel-3603 344 6 of of ADP cjel-3603 344 7 partial partial ADJ cjel-3603 344 8 takings taking NOUN cjel-3603 344 9 of of ADP cjel-3603 344 10 real real ADJ cjel-3603 344 11 property property NOUN cjel-3603 344 12 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 344 13 no no DET cjel-3603 344 14 depreciation depreciation NOUN cjel-3603 344 15 in in ADP cjel-3603 344 16 the the DET cjel-3603 344 17 value value NOUN cjel-3603 344 18 of of ADP cjel-3603 344 19 any any DET cjel-3603 344 20 remaining remain VERB cjel-3603 344 21 real real ADJ cjel-3603 344 22 property property NOUN cjel-3603 344 23 shall shall AUX cjel-3603 344 24 be be AUX cjel-3603 344 25 recognized recognize VERB cjel-3603 344 26 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 344 27 no no DET cjel-3603 344 28 compensation compensation NOUN cjel-3603 344 29 shall shall AUX cjel-3603 344 30 be be AUX cjel-3603 344 31 paid pay VERB cjel-3603 344 32 for for ADP cjel-3603 344 33 any any DET cjel-3603 344 34 damages damage NOUN cjel-3603 344 35 to to ADP cjel-3603 344 36 such such ADJ cjel-3603 344 37 remaining remain VERB cjel-3603 344 38 real real ADJ cjel-3603 344 39 property property NOUN cjel-3603 344 40 which which PRON cjel-3603 344 41 result result VERB cjel-3603 344 42 from from ADP cjel-3603 344 43 loss loss NOUN cjel-3603 344 44 of of ADP cjel-3603 344 45 or or CCONJ cjel-3603 344 46 reduction reduction NOUN cjel-3603 344 47 of of ADP cjel-3603 344 48 access access NOUN cjel-3603 344 49 from from ADP cjel-3603 344 50 such such ADJ cjel-3603 344 51 remaining remain VERB cjel-3603 344 52 real real ADJ cjel-3603 344 53 property property NOUN cjel-3603 344 54 to to ADP cjel-3603 344 55 such such ADJ cjel-3603 344 56 navigable navigable ADJ cjel-3603 344 57 waters water NOUN cjel-3603 344 58 because because SCONJ cjel-3603 344 59 of of ADP cjel-3603 344 60 the the DET cjel-3603 344 61 taking taking NOUN cjel-3603 344 62 of of ADP cjel-3603 344 63 real real ADJ cjel-3603 344 64 property property NOUN cjel-3603 344 65 or or CCONJ cjel-3603 344 66 the the DET cjel-3603 344 67 purposes purpose NOUN cjel-3603 344 68 for for ADP cjel-3603 344 69 which which PRON cjel-3603 344 70 such such ADJ cjel-3603 344 71 real real ADJ cjel-3603 344 72 property property NOUN cjel-3603 344 73 is be AUX cjel-3603 344 74 taken.86 taken.86 NOUN cjel-3603 344 75 thus thus ADV cjel-3603 344 76 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 344 77 in in ADP cjel-3603 344 78 cases case NOUN cjel-3603 344 79 where where SCONJ cjel-3603 344 80 the the DET cjel-3603 344 81 government government NOUN cjel-3603 344 82 condemns condemn VERB cjel-3603 344 83 only only ADJ cjel-3603 344 84 part part NOUN cjel-3603 344 85 of of ADP cjel-3603 344 86 the the DET cjel-3603 344 87 riparian riparian ADJ cjel-3603 344 88 land land NOUN cjel-3603 344 89 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 344 90 section section NOUN cjel-3603 344 91 111 111 NUM cjel-3603 344 92 applies apply VERB cjel-3603 344 93 to to ADP cjel-3603 344 94 that that DET cjel-3603 344 95 land land NOUN cjel-3603 344 96 taken take VERB cjel-3603 344 97 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 344 98 allowing allow VERB cjel-3603 344 99 the the DET cjel-3603 344 100 value value NOUN cjel-3603 344 101 derived derive VERB cjel-3603 344 102 from from ADP cjel-3603 344 103 water water NOUN cjel-3603 344 104 access access NOUN cjel-3603 344 105 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 344 106 use use NOUN cjel-3603 344 107 to to PART cjel-3603 344 108 be be AUX cjel-3603 344 109 included include VERB cjel-3603 344 110 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 344 111 but but CCONJ cjel-3603 344 112 does do AUX cjel-3603 344 113 not not PART cjel-3603 344 114 apply apply VERB cjel-3603 344 115 to to ADP cjel-3603 344 116 the the DET cjel-3603 344 117 land land NOUN cjel-3603 344 118 that that PRON cjel-3603 344 119 remains remain VERB cjel-3603 344 120 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 345 1 the the DET cjel-3603 345 2 landowner landowner NOUN cjel-3603 345 3 is be AUX cjel-3603 345 4 left leave VERB cjel-3603 345 5 with with ADP cjel-3603 345 6 land land NOUN cjel-3603 345 7 that that PRON cjel-3603 345 8 is be AUX cjel-3603 345 9 now now ADV cjel-3603 345 10 worth worth ADJ cjel-3603 345 11 much much ADV cjel-3603 345 12 less less ADJ cjel-3603 345 13 since since SCONJ cjel-3603 345 14 it it PRON cjel-3603 345 15 has have AUX cjel-3603 345 16 been be AUX cjel-3603 345 17 cut cut VERB cjel-3603 345 18 off off ADP cjel-3603 345 19 from from ADP cjel-3603 345 20 the the DET cjel-3603 345 21 valuable valuable ADJ cjel-3603 345 22 water water NOUN cjel-3603 345 23 source source NOUN cjel-3603 345 24 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 345 25 but but CCONJ cjel-3603 345 26 is be AUX cjel-3603 345 27 in in ADP cjel-3603 345 28 no no DET cjel-3603 345 29 way way NOUN cjel-3603 345 30 compensated compensate VERB cjel-3603 345 31 for for ADP cjel-3603 345 32 the the DET cjel-3603 345 33 difference.87 difference.87 NOUN cjel-3603 345 34 therefore therefore ADV cjel-3603 345 35 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 345 36 the the DET cjel-3603 345 37 second second ADJ cjel-3603 345 38 half half NOUN cjel-3603 345 39 of of ADP cjel-3603 345 40 section section NOUN cjel-3603 345 41 111 111 NUM cjel-3603 345 42 limits limit NOUN cjel-3603 345 43 the the DET cjel-3603 345 44 purported purport VERB cjel-3603 345 45 generosity generosity NOUN cjel-3603 345 46 of of ADP cjel-3603 345 47 the the DET cjel-3603 345 48 first first ADJ cjel-3603 345 49 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 346 1 it it PRON cjel-3603 346 2 carves carve VERB cjel-3603 346 3 out out ADP cjel-3603 346 4 severance severance NOUN cjel-3603 346 5 damages damage NOUN cjel-3603 346 6 in in ADP cjel-3603 346 7 the the DET cjel-3603 346 8 case case NOUN cjel-3603 346 9 of of ADP cjel-3603 346 10 partial partial ADJ cjel-3603 346 11 takings taking NOUN cjel-3603 346 12 from from ADP cjel-3603 346 13 the the DET cjel-3603 346 14 general general ADJ cjel-3603 346 15 rule rule NOUN cjel-3603 346 16 that that DET cjel-3603 346 17 proximity proximity NOUN cjel-3603 346 18 to to ADP cjel-3603 346 19 a a DET cjel-3603 346 20 waterway waterway NOUN cjel-3603 346 21 may may AUX cjel-3603 346 22 be be AUX cjel-3603 346 23 used use VERB cjel-3603 346 24 in in ADP cjel-3603 346 25 the the DET cjel-3603 346 26 calculation calculation NOUN cjel-3603 346 27 of of ADP cjel-3603 346 28 just just ADJ cjel-3603 346 29 compensation compensation NOUN cjel-3603 346 30 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 347 1 partial partial ADJ cjel-3603 347 2 takings taking NOUN cjel-3603 347 3 are be AUX cjel-3603 347 4 takings taking NOUN cjel-3603 347 5 in in ADP cjel-3603 347 6 which which PRON cjel-3603 347 7 the the DET cjel-3603 347 8 government government NOUN cjel-3603 347 9 does do AUX cjel-3603 347 10 not not PART cjel-3603 347 11 condemn condemn VERB cjel-3603 347 12 an an DET cjel-3603 347 13 entire entire ADJ cjel-3603 347 14 parcel parcel NOUN cjel-3603 347 15 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 347 16 but but CCONJ cjel-3603 347 17 only only ADV cjel-3603 347 18 the the DET cjel-3603 347 19 part part NOUN cjel-3603 347 20 it it PRON cjel-3603 347 21 needs.88 needs.88 VERB cjel-3603 347 22 traditionally traditionally ADV cjel-3603 347 23 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 347 24 in in ADP cjel-3603 347 25 calculating calculate VERB cjel-3603 347 26 the the DET cjel-3603 347 27 amount amount NOUN cjel-3603 347 28 of of ADP cjel-3603 347 29 compensation compensation NOUN cjel-3603 347 30 owed owe VERB cjel-3603 347 31 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 347 32 the the DET cjel-3603 347 33 value value NOUN cjel-3603 347 34 of of ADP cjel-3603 347 35 the the DET cjel-3603 347 36 part part NOUN cjel-3603 347 37 actually actually ADV cjel-3603 347 38 taken take VERB cjel-3603 347 39 “ " PUNCT cjel-3603 347 40 is be AUX cjel-3603 347 41 not not PART cjel-3603 347 42 the the DET cjel-3603 347 43 sole sole ADJ cjel-3603 347 44 measure measure NOUN cjel-3603 347 45 of of ADP cjel-3603 347 46 lands land NOUN cjel-3603 347 47 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 347 48 that that SCONJ cjel-3603 347 49 their their PRON cjel-3603 347 50 access access NOUN cjel-3603 347 51 to to ADP cjel-3603 347 52 the the DET cjel-3603 347 53 lake lake NOUN cjel-3603 347 54 is be AUX cjel-3603 347 55 to to PART cjel-3603 347 56 be be AUX cjel-3603 347 57 taken take VERB cjel-3603 347 58 into into ADP cjel-3603 347 59 consideration consideration NOUN cjel-3603 347 60 in in ADP cjel-3603 347 61 fixing fix VERB cjel-3603 347 62 their their PRON cjel-3603 347 63 value value NOUN cjel-3603 347 64 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 347 65 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 347 66 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 348 1 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 348 2 ” " PUNCT cjel-3603 349 1 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 349 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 350 1 85 85 NUM cjel-3603 350 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 351 1 see see VERB cjel-3603 351 2 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 351 3 e.g. e.g. ADV cjel-3603 351 4 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 351 5 united united PROPN cjel-3603 351 6 states states PROPN cjel-3603 351 7 v. v. ADP cjel-3603 351 8 30.54 30.54 NUM cjel-3603 351 9 acres acre NOUN cjel-3603 351 10 of of ADP cjel-3603 351 11 land land NOUN cjel-3603 351 12 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 351 13 90 90 NUM cjel-3603 351 14 f.3d f.3d NUM cjel-3603 351 15 790 790 NUM cjel-3603 351 16 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 351 17 796 796 NUM cjel-3603 351 18 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 351 19 3d 3d PROPN cjel-3603 351 20 cir cir NOUN cjel-3603 351 21 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 351 22 1996 1996 NUM cjel-3603 351 23 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 351 24 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 351 25 “ " PUNCT cjel-3603 351 26 congress congress PROPN cjel-3603 351 27 did do AUX cjel-3603 351 28 not not PART cjel-3603 351 29 express express VERB cjel-3603 351 30 an an DET cjel-3603 351 31 intent intent NOUN cjel-3603 351 32 to to PART cjel-3603 351 33 abolish abolish VERB cjel-3603 351 34 the the DET cjel-3603 351 35 navigational navigational ADJ cjel-3603 351 36 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 351 37 or or CCONJ cjel-3603 351 38 to to PART cjel-3603 351 39 provide provide VERB cjel-3603 351 40 compensation compensation NOUN cjel-3603 351 41 for for ADP cjel-3603 351 42 all all DET cjel-3603 351 43 economic economic ADJ cjel-3603 351 44 losses loss NOUN cjel-3603 351 45 occasioned occasion VERB cjel-3603 351 46 by by ADP cjel-3603 351 47 regulation regulation NOUN cjel-3603 351 48 of of ADP cjel-3603 351 49 navigable navigable ADJ cjel-3603 351 50 waterways waterway NOUN cjel-3603 351 51 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 351 52 ” " PUNCT cjel-3603 351 53 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 351 54 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 352 1 86 86 NUM cjel-3603 352 2 . . X cjel-3603 353 1 33 33 NUM cjel-3603 353 2 u.s.c.a u.s.c.a PROPN cjel-3603 353 3 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 353 4 § § PROPN cjel-3603 353 5 595a 595a PROPN cjel-3603 353 6 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 353 7 2012 2012 NUM cjel-3603 353 8 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 353 9 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 354 1 87 87 NUM cjel-3603 354 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 355 1 see see VERB cjel-3603 355 2 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 355 3 e.g. e.g. ADV cjel-3603 355 4 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 355 5 united united PROPN cjel-3603 355 6 states states PROPN cjel-3603 355 7 v. v. ADP cjel-3603 355 8 13.20 13.20 NUM cjel-3603 355 9 acres acre NOUN cjel-3603 355 10 of of ADP cjel-3603 355 11 land land NOUN cjel-3603 355 12 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 355 13 629 629 NUM cjel-3603 355 14 f. f. PROPN cjel-3603 355 15 supp supp PROPN cjel-3603 355 16 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 356 1 242 242 NUM cjel-3603 356 2 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 356 3 247 247 NUM cjel-3603 356 4 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 356 5 e.d e.d PROPN cjel-3603 356 6 . . PROPN cjel-3603 356 7 wash wash NOUN cjel-3603 356 8 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 356 9 1986 1986 NUM cjel-3603 356 10 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 357 1 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 357 2 awarding award VERB cjel-3603 357 3 just just ADV cjel-3603 357 4 compensation compensation NOUN cjel-3603 357 5 including include VERB cjel-3603 357 6 the the DET cjel-3603 357 7 “ " PUNCT cjel-3603 357 8 current current ADJ cjel-3603 357 9 market market NOUN cjel-3603 357 10 value value NOUN cjel-3603 357 11 of of ADP cjel-3603 357 12 the the DET cjel-3603 357 13 condemned condemn VERB cjel-3603 357 14 parcels parcel NOUN cjel-3603 357 15 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 357 16 taking take VERB cjel-3603 357 17 into into ADP cjel-3603 357 18 consideration consideration NOUN cjel-3603 357 19 the the DET cjel-3603 357 20 access access NOUN cjel-3603 357 21 to to ADP cjel-3603 357 22 lake lake PROPN cjel-3603 357 23 roosevelt roosevelt PROPN cjel-3603 357 24 ” " PUNCT cjel-3603 357 25 but but CCONJ cjel-3603 357 26 declaring declare VERB cjel-3603 357 27 that that SCONJ cjel-3603 357 28 “ " PUNCT cjel-3603 357 29 no no DET cjel-3603 357 30 severance severance NOUN cjel-3603 357 31 damages damage NOUN cjel-3603 357 32 may may AUX cjel-3603 357 33 be be AUX cjel-3603 357 34 awarded award VERB cjel-3603 357 35 for for ADP cjel-3603 357 36 loss loss NOUN cjel-3603 357 37 of of ADP cjel-3603 357 38 access access NOUN cjel-3603 357 39 from from ADP cjel-3603 357 40 the the DET cjel-3603 357 41 remaining remain VERB cjel-3603 357 42 lands land NOUN cjel-3603 357 43 to to ADP cjel-3603 357 44 the the DET cjel-3603 357 45 water water NOUN cjel-3603 357 46 ” " PUNCT cjel-3603 357 47 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 357 48 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 358 1 88 88 NUM cjel-3603 358 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 359 1 see see VERB cjel-3603 359 2 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 359 3 e.g. e.g. ADV cjel-3603 359 4 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 359 5 bauman bauman PROPN cjel-3603 359 6 v. v. PROPN cjel-3603 359 7 ross ross PROPN cjel-3603 359 8 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 359 9 167 167 NUM cjel-3603 359 10 u.s u.s PROPN cjel-3603 359 11 . . PROPN cjel-3603 359 12 548 548 NUM cjel-3603 359 13 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 359 14 1897 1897 NUM cjel-3603 359 15 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 359 16 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 360 1 monahan monahan PROPN cjel-3603 360 2 - - PUNCT cjel-3603 360 3 macro-[final macro-[final PROPN cjel-3603 360 4 6 6 NUM cjel-3603 360 5 - - SYM cjel-3603 360 6 20 20 NUM cjel-3603 360 7 ] ] PUNCT cjel-3603 360 8 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 360 9 do do AUX cjel-3603 360 10 not not PART cjel-3603 360 11 delete delete VERB cjel-3603 360 12 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 360 13 6/22/2015 6/22/2015 NUM cjel-3603 360 14 11:53 11:53 NUM cjel-3603 360 15 pm pm NOUN cjel-3603 360 16 376 376 NUM cjel-3603 360 17 columbia columbia PROPN cjel-3603 360 18 journal journal PROPN cjel-3603 360 19 of of ADP cjel-3603 360 20 environmental environmental ADJ cjel-3603 360 21 law law NOUN cjel-3603 361 1 [ [ X cjel-3603 361 2 vol vol NOUN cjel-3603 361 3 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 362 1 40:2 40:2 NOUN cjel-3603 362 2 the the DET cjel-3603 362 3 compensation compensation NOUN cjel-3603 362 4 or or CCONJ cjel-3603 362 5 damages damage NOUN cjel-3603 362 6 to to PART cjel-3603 362 7 be be AUX cjel-3603 362 8 paid pay VERB cjel-3603 362 9 to to ADP cjel-3603 362 10 the the DET cjel-3603 362 11 owner owner NOUN cjel-3603 362 12 ; ; PUNCT cjel-3603 362 13 but but CCONJ cjel-3603 362 14 the the DET cjel-3603 362 15 incidental incidental ADJ cjel-3603 362 16 injury injury NOUN cjel-3603 362 17 or or CCONJ cjel-3603 362 18 benefit benefit VERB cjel-3603 362 19 to to ADP cjel-3603 362 20 the the DET cjel-3603 362 21 part part NOUN cjel-3603 362 22 not not PART cjel-3603 362 23 taken take VERB cjel-3603 362 24 is be AUX cjel-3603 362 25 also also ADV cjel-3603 362 26 to to PART cjel-3603 362 27 be be AUX cjel-3603 362 28 considered consider VERB cjel-3603 362 29 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 363 1 ”89 ”89 PROPN cjel-3603 363 2 thus thus ADV cjel-3603 363 3 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 363 4 if if SCONJ cjel-3603 363 5 “ " PUNCT cjel-3603 363 6 the the DET cjel-3603 363 7 part part NOUN cjel-3603 363 8 not not PART cjel-3603 363 9 taken take VERB cjel-3603 363 10 is be AUX cjel-3603 363 11 left leave VERB cjel-3603 363 12 in in ADP cjel-3603 363 13 such such ADJ cjel-3603 363 14 shape shape NOUN cjel-3603 363 15 or or CCONJ cjel-3603 363 16 condition condition NOUN cjel-3603 363 17 as as SCONJ cjel-3603 363 18 to to PART cjel-3603 363 19 be be AUX cjel-3603 363 20 in in ADP cjel-3603 363 21 itself itself PRON cjel-3603 363 22 of of ADP cjel-3603 363 23 less less ADJ cjel-3603 363 24 value value NOUN cjel-3603 363 25 than than ADP cjel-3603 363 26 before before ADV cjel-3603 363 27 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 363 28 the the DET cjel-3603 363 29 owner owner NOUN cjel-3603 363 30 is be AUX cjel-3603 363 31 entitled entitle VERB cjel-3603 363 32 to to ADP cjel-3603 363 33 additional additional ADJ cjel-3603 363 34 damages damage NOUN cjel-3603 363 35 on on ADP cjel-3603 363 36 that that DET cjel-3603 363 37 account account NOUN cjel-3603 363 38 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 364 1 ”90 ”90 PUNCT cjel-3603 364 2 severance severance NOUN cjel-3603 364 3 damages damage NOUN cjel-3603 364 4 can can AUX cjel-3603 364 5 be be AUX cjel-3603 364 6 an an DET cjel-3603 364 7 important important ADJ cjel-3603 364 8 portion portion NOUN cjel-3603 364 9 of of ADP cjel-3603 364 10 the the DET cjel-3603 364 11 total total ADJ cjel-3603 364 12 amount amount NOUN cjel-3603 364 13 of of ADP cjel-3603 364 14 compensation.91 compensation.91 NOUN cjel-3603 364 15 the the DET cjel-3603 364 16 decision decision NOUN cjel-3603 364 17 over over ADP cjel-3603 364 18 how how SCONJ cjel-3603 364 19 to to PART cjel-3603 364 20 parcel parcel VERB cjel-3603 364 21 out out ADP cjel-3603 364 22 land land NOUN cjel-3603 364 23 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 364 24 how how SCONJ cjel-3603 364 25 much much ADJ cjel-3603 364 26 land land NOUN cjel-3603 364 27 to to PART cjel-3603 364 28 take take VERB cjel-3603 364 29 is be AUX cjel-3603 364 30 wholly wholly ADV cjel-3603 364 31 up up ADP cjel-3603 364 32 to to ADP cjel-3603 364 33 the the DET cjel-3603 364 34 discretion discretion NOUN cjel-3603 364 35 of of ADP cjel-3603 364 36 the the DET cjel-3603 364 37 government government NOUN cjel-3603 364 38 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 365 1 such such DET cjel-3603 365 2 a a DET cjel-3603 365 3 compensation compensation NOUN cjel-3603 365 4 structure structure NOUN cjel-3603 365 5 could could AUX cjel-3603 365 6 lead lead VERB cjel-3603 365 7 to to ADP cjel-3603 365 8 the the DET cjel-3603 365 9 same same ADJ cjel-3603 365 10 harmful harmful ADJ cjel-3603 365 11 incentives incentive NOUN cjel-3603 365 12 identified identify VERB cjel-3603 365 13 above above ADV cjel-3603 365 14 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 366 1 moreover moreover ADV cjel-3603 366 2 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 366 3 the the DET cjel-3603 366 4 categorical categorical ADJ cjel-3603 366 5 treatment treatment NOUN cjel-3603 366 6 of of ADP cjel-3603 366 7 the the DET cjel-3603 366 8 navigational navigational ADJ cjel-3603 366 9 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 366 10 means mean VERB cjel-3603 366 11 that that SCONJ cjel-3603 366 12 most most ADJ cjel-3603 366 13 cases case NOUN cjel-3603 366 14 will will AUX cjel-3603 366 15 not not PART cjel-3603 366 16 reach reach VERB cjel-3603 366 17 the the DET cjel-3603 366 18 damages damage NOUN cjel-3603 366 19 computation computation NOUN cjel-3603 366 20 stage stage NOUN cjel-3603 366 21 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 366 22 thus thus ADV cjel-3603 366 23 will will AUX cjel-3603 366 24 not not PART cjel-3603 366 25 receive receive VERB cjel-3603 366 26 the the DET cjel-3603 366 27 protection protection NOUN cjel-3603 366 28 of of ADP cjel-3603 366 29 section section NOUN cjel-3603 366 30 111.92 111.92 NUM cjel-3603 366 31 specifically specifically ADV cjel-3603 366 32 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 366 33 since since SCONJ cjel-3603 366 34 the the DET cjel-3603 366 35 landowners landowner NOUN cjel-3603 366 36 will will AUX cjel-3603 366 37 rarely rarely ADV cjel-3603 366 38 be be AUX cjel-3603 366 39 able able ADJ cjel-3603 366 40 to to PART cjel-3603 366 41 prove prove VERB cjel-3603 366 42 a a DET cjel-3603 366 43 taking taking NOUN cjel-3603 366 44 occurred occur VERB cjel-3603 366 45 once once ADV cjel-3603 366 46 the the DET cjel-3603 366 47 navigational navigational ADJ cjel-3603 366 48 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 366 49 has have AUX cjel-3603 366 50 been be AUX cjel-3603 366 51 invoked invoke VERB cjel-3603 366 52 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 366 53 they they PRON cjel-3603 366 54 will will AUX cjel-3603 366 55 not not PART cjel-3603 366 56 proceed proceed VERB cjel-3603 366 57 past past ADP cjel-3603 366 58 the the DET cjel-3603 366 59 opening opening NOUN cjel-3603 366 60 of of ADP cjel-3603 366 61 section section NOUN cjel-3603 366 62 111 111 NUM cjel-3603 366 63 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 367 1 while while SCONJ cjel-3603 367 2 section section NOUN cjel-3603 367 3 111 111 NUM cjel-3603 367 4 helps help VERB cjel-3603 367 5 in in ADP cjel-3603 367 6 computing compute VERB cjel-3603 367 7 just just ADV cjel-3603 367 8 compensation compensation NOUN cjel-3603 367 9 in in ADP cjel-3603 367 10 a a DET cjel-3603 367 11 straightforward straightforward ADJ cjel-3603 367 12 condemnation condemnation NOUN cjel-3603 367 13 of of ADP cjel-3603 367 14 land land NOUN cjel-3603 367 15 adjacent adjacent ADJ cjel-3603 367 16 to to ADP cjel-3603 367 17 a a DET cjel-3603 367 18 navigable navigable ADJ cjel-3603 367 19 waterway waterway NOUN cjel-3603 367 20 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 367 21 it it PRON cjel-3603 367 22 does do AUX cjel-3603 367 23 not not PART cjel-3603 367 24 reach reach VERB cjel-3603 367 25 the the DET cjel-3603 367 26 vast vast ADJ cjel-3603 367 27 majority majority NOUN cjel-3603 367 28 of of ADP cjel-3603 367 29 cases case NOUN cjel-3603 367 30 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 367 31 therefore therefore ADV cjel-3603 367 32 inadequately inadequately ADV cjel-3603 367 33 addresses address VERB cjel-3603 367 34 the the DET cjel-3603 367 35 inequities inequity NOUN cjel-3603 367 36 the the DET cjel-3603 367 37 navigational navigational ADJ cjel-3603 367 38 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 367 39 creates create VERB cjel-3603 367 40 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 368 1 iv iv X cjel-3603 368 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 368 3 applying apply VERB cjel-3603 368 4 the the DET cjel-3603 368 5 penn penn PROPN cjel-3603 368 6 central central PROPN cjel-3603 368 7 test test NOUN cjel-3603 368 8 to to ADP cjel-3603 368 9 the the DET cjel-3603 368 10 navigational navigational ADJ cjel-3603 368 11 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 368 12 as as SCONJ cjel-3603 368 13 discussed discuss VERB cjel-3603 368 14 above above ADV cjel-3603 368 15 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 368 16 the the DET cjel-3603 368 17 navigational navigational ADJ cjel-3603 368 18 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 368 19 has have AUX cjel-3603 368 20 long long ADV cjel-3603 368 21 been be AUX cjel-3603 368 22 a a DET cjel-3603 368 23 blanket blanket NOUN cjel-3603 368 24 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 368 25 categorical categorical ADJ cjel-3603 368 26 exception exception NOUN cjel-3603 368 27 to to ADP cjel-3603 368 28 the the DET cjel-3603 368 29 takings taking NOUN cjel-3603 368 30 clause clause NOUN cjel-3603 368 31 ’s ’s PART cjel-3603 368 32 requirement requirement NOUN cjel-3603 368 33 of of ADP cjel-3603 368 34 just just ADJ cjel-3603 368 35 compensation compensation NOUN cjel-3603 368 36 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 369 1 however however ADV cjel-3603 369 2 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 369 3 this this DET cjel-3603 369 4 exception exception NOUN cjel-3603 369 5 has have AUX cjel-3603 369 6 created create VERB cjel-3603 369 7 results result NOUN cjel-3603 369 8 that that PRON cjel-3603 369 9 are be AUX cjel-3603 369 10 inequitable inequitable ADJ cjel-3603 369 11 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 369 12 inefficient inefficient ADJ cjel-3603 369 13 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 369 14 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 369 15 inconsistent inconsistent ADJ cjel-3603 369 16 with with ADP cjel-3603 369 17 the the DET cjel-3603 369 18 policies policy NOUN cjel-3603 369 19 underlying underlie VERB cjel-3603 369 20 the the DET cjel-3603 369 21 takings taking NOUN cjel-3603 369 22 clause clause NOUN cjel-3603 369 23 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 370 1 these these DET cjel-3603 370 2 results result NOUN cjel-3603 370 3 can can AUX cjel-3603 370 4 be be AUX cjel-3603 370 5 avoided avoid VERB cjel-3603 370 6 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 370 7 more more ADV cjel-3603 370 8 equitable equitable ADJ cjel-3603 370 9 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 370 10 rational rational ADJ cjel-3603 370 11 outcomes outcome NOUN cjel-3603 370 12 are be AUX cjel-3603 370 13 possible possible ADJ cjel-3603 370 14 if if SCONJ cjel-3603 370 15 the the DET cjel-3603 370 16 navigational navigational ADJ cjel-3603 370 17 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 370 18 is be AUX cjel-3603 370 19 seen see VERB cjel-3603 370 20 not not PART cjel-3603 370 21 89 89 NUM cjel-3603 370 22 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 371 1 i i PRON cjel-3603 371 2 d. d. PROPN cjel-3603 371 3 at at ADP cjel-3603 371 4 574 574 NUM cjel-3603 371 5 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 372 1 90 90 NUM cjel-3603 372 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 373 1 i i PRON cjel-3603 373 2 d. d. PROPN cjel-3603 373 3 91 91 NUM cjel-3603 373 4 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 374 1 in in ADP cjel-3603 374 2 practice practice NOUN cjel-3603 374 3 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 374 4 to to PART cjel-3603 374 5 calculate calculate VERB cjel-3603 374 6 these these DET cjel-3603 374 7 severance severance NOUN cjel-3603 374 8 damages damage NOUN cjel-3603 374 9 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 374 10 courts court NOUN cjel-3603 374 11 determine determine VERB cjel-3603 374 12 the the DET cjel-3603 374 13 “ " PUNCT cjel-3603 374 14 difference difference NOUN cjel-3603 374 15 between between ADP cjel-3603 374 16 the the DET cjel-3603 374 17 value value NOUN cjel-3603 374 18 of of ADP cjel-3603 374 19 the the DET cjel-3603 374 20 [ [ X cjel-3603 374 21 entire entire ADJ cjel-3603 374 22 ] ] PUNCT cjel-3603 374 23 tract tract NOUN cjel-3603 374 24 before before ADP cjel-3603 374 25 the the DET cjel-3603 374 26 taking taking NOUN cjel-3603 374 27 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 374 28 its its PRON cjel-3603 374 29 value value NOUN cjel-3603 374 30 after after ADP cjel-3603 374 31 the the DET cjel-3603 374 32 taking taking NOUN cjel-3603 374 33 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 374 34 ” " PUNCT cjel-3603 375 1 united united PROPN cjel-3603 375 2 states states PROPN cjel-3603 375 3 v. v. ADP cjel-3603 375 4 8.41 8.41 NUM cjel-3603 375 5 acres acre NOUN cjel-3603 375 6 of of ADP cjel-3603 375 7 land land NOUN cjel-3603 375 8 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 375 9 783 783 NUM cjel-3603 375 10 f.2d f.2d NOUN cjel-3603 375 11 1256 1256 NUM cjel-3603 375 12 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 375 13 1257 1257 NUM cjel-3603 375 14 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 375 15 5th 5th ADJ cjel-3603 375 16 cir cir NOUN cjel-3603 375 17 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 375 18 1986 1986 NUM cjel-3603 375 19 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 375 20 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 376 1 92 92 NUM cjel-3603 376 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 377 1 see see VERB cjel-3603 377 2 ackerman ackerman PROPN cjel-3603 377 3 & & CCONJ cjel-3603 377 4 yanich yanich PROPN cjel-3603 377 5 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 377 6 supra supra PROPN cjel-3603 377 7 note note NOUN cjel-3603 377 8 78 78 NUM cjel-3603 377 9 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 377 10 at at ADP cjel-3603 377 11 607–12 607–12 PROPN cjel-3603 377 12 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 377 13 discussing discuss VERB cjel-3603 377 14 how how SCONJ cjel-3603 377 15 the the DET cjel-3603 377 16 court court NOUN cjel-3603 377 17 in in ADP cjel-3603 377 18 united united PROPN cjel-3603 377 19 states states PROPN cjel-3603 377 20 v. v. ADP cjel-3603 377 21 30.54 30.54 NUM cjel-3603 377 22 acres acre NOUN cjel-3603 377 23 of of ADP cjel-3603 377 24 land land NOUN cjel-3603 377 25 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 377 26 90 90 NUM cjel-3603 377 27 f.3d f.3d NUM cjel-3603 377 28 790 790 NUM cjel-3603 377 29 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 377 30 3d 3d PROPN cjel-3603 377 31 cir cir NOUN cjel-3603 377 32 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 377 33 1996 1996 NUM cjel-3603 377 34 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 377 35 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 377 36 rejected reject VERB cjel-3603 377 37 an an DET cjel-3603 377 38 argument argument NOUN cjel-3603 377 39 that that SCONJ cjel-3603 377 40 a a DET cjel-3603 377 41 regulatory regulatory ADJ cjel-3603 377 42 taking taking NOUN cjel-3603 377 43 could could AUX cjel-3603 377 44 qualify qualify VERB cjel-3603 377 45 as as ADP cjel-3603 377 46 a a DET cjel-3603 377 47 taking taking NOUN cjel-3603 377 48 under under ADP cjel-3603 377 49 section section NOUN cjel-3603 377 50 111 111 NUM cjel-3603 377 51 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 377 52 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 378 1 monahan monahan PROPN cjel-3603 378 2 - - PUNCT cjel-3603 378 3 macro-[final macro-[final PROPN cjel-3603 378 4 6 6 NUM cjel-3603 378 5 - - SYM cjel-3603 378 6 20 20 NUM cjel-3603 378 7 ] ] PUNCT cjel-3603 378 8 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 378 9 do do AUX cjel-3603 378 10 not not PART cjel-3603 378 11 delete delete VERB cjel-3603 378 12 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 378 13 6/22/2015 6/22/2015 NUM cjel-3603 378 14 11:53 11:53 NUM cjel-3603 378 15 pm pm NOUN cjel-3603 378 16 2015 2015 NUM cjel-3603 378 17 ] ] PUNCT cjel-3603 378 18 the the DET cjel-3603 378 19 navigational navigational ADJ cjel-3603 378 20 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 378 21 377 377 NUM cjel-3603 378 22 as as ADP cjel-3603 378 23 a a DET cjel-3603 378 24 complete complete ADJ cjel-3603 378 25 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 378 26 absolute absolute ADJ cjel-3603 378 27 defense defense NOUN cjel-3603 378 28 to to ADP cjel-3603 378 29 takings taking NOUN cjel-3603 378 30 claims claim NOUN cjel-3603 378 31 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 378 32 but but CCONJ cjel-3603 378 33 as as ADP cjel-3603 378 34 one one NUM cjel-3603 378 35 of of ADP cjel-3603 378 36 many many ADJ cjel-3603 378 37 factors factor NOUN cjel-3603 378 38 in in ADP cjel-3603 378 39 an an DET cjel-3603 378 40 ad ad NOUN cjel-3603 378 41 - - PUNCT cjel-3603 378 42 hoc hoc ADJ cjel-3603 378 43 analysis analysis NOUN cjel-3603 378 44 of of ADP cjel-3603 378 45 those those DET cjel-3603 378 46 claims claim NOUN cjel-3603 378 47 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 379 1 a. a. PROPN cjel-3603 380 1 the the DET cjel-3603 380 2 penn penn PROPN cjel-3603 380 3 central central PROPN cjel-3603 380 4 test test NOUN cjel-3603 380 5 : : PUNCT cjel-3603 380 6 an an DET cjel-3603 380 7 ad ad NOUN cjel-3603 380 8 hoc hoc X cjel-3603 380 9 approach approach NOUN cjel-3603 380 10 in in ADP cjel-3603 380 11 penn penn PROPN cjel-3603 380 12 central central PROPN cjel-3603 380 13 transportation transportation PROPN cjel-3603 380 14 co. co. PROPN cjel-3603 380 15 v. v. ADP cjel-3603 380 16 city city PROPN cjel-3603 380 17 of of ADP cjel-3603 380 18 new new PROPN cjel-3603 380 19 york york PROPN cjel-3603 380 20 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 380 21 the the DET cjel-3603 380 22 supreme supreme PROPN cjel-3603 380 23 court court PROPN cjel-3603 380 24 established establish VERB cjel-3603 380 25 a a DET cjel-3603 380 26 framework framework NOUN cjel-3603 380 27 for for ADP cjel-3603 380 28 evaluating evaluate VERB cjel-3603 380 29 takings taking NOUN cjel-3603 380 30 cases case NOUN cjel-3603 380 31 where where SCONJ cjel-3603 380 32 there there PRON cjel-3603 380 33 was be VERB cjel-3603 380 34 no no DET cjel-3603 380 35 permanent permanent ADJ cjel-3603 380 36 physical physical ADJ cjel-3603 380 37 occupation occupation NOUN cjel-3603 380 38 of of ADP cjel-3603 380 39 the the DET cjel-3603 380 40 property.93 property.93 PROPN cjel-3603 380 41 at at ADP cjel-3603 380 42 issue issue NOUN cjel-3603 380 43 in in ADP cjel-3603 380 44 the the DET cjel-3603 380 45 case case NOUN cjel-3603 380 46 was be AUX cjel-3603 380 47 new new PROPN cjel-3603 380 48 york york PROPN cjel-3603 380 49 city city PROPN cjel-3603 380 50 ’s ’s PART cjel-3603 380 51 landmarks landmark NOUN cjel-3603 380 52 preservation preservation NOUN cjel-3603 380 53 law law NOUN cjel-3603 380 54 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 380 55 the the DET cjel-3603 380 56 restrictions restriction NOUN cjel-3603 380 57 it it PRON cjel-3603 380 58 placed place VERB cjel-3603 380 59 on on ADP cjel-3603 380 60 development development NOUN cjel-3603 380 61 of of ADP cjel-3603 380 62 grand grand ADJ cjel-3603 380 63 central central ADJ cjel-3603 380 64 terminal.94 terminal.94 NOUN cjel-3603 380 65 while while SCONJ cjel-3603 380 66 zoning zoning NOUN cjel-3603 380 67 laws law NOUN cjel-3603 380 68 had have AUX cjel-3603 380 69 long long ADV cjel-3603 380 70 been be AUX cjel-3603 380 71 considered consider VERB cjel-3603 380 72 a a DET cjel-3603 380 73 part part NOUN cjel-3603 380 74 of of ADP cjel-3603 380 75 state state NOUN cjel-3603 380 76 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 380 77 local local ADJ cjel-3603 380 78 governments government NOUN cjel-3603 380 79 ’ ’ PART cjel-3603 380 80 police police NOUN cjel-3603 380 81 power power NOUN cjel-3603 380 82 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 380 83 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 380 84 thus thus ADV cjel-3603 380 85 a a DET cjel-3603 380 86 categorical categorical ADJ cjel-3603 380 87 exception exception NOUN cjel-3603 380 88 to to ADP cjel-3603 380 89 takings,95 takings,95 NOUN cjel-3603 380 90 the the DET cjel-3603 380 91 court court NOUN cjel-3603 380 92 recognized recognize VERB cjel-3603 380 93 that that SCONJ cjel-3603 380 94 overall overall ADJ cjel-3603 380 95 it it PRON cjel-3603 380 96 “ " PUNCT cjel-3603 380 97 quite quite ADV cjel-3603 380 98 simply simply ADV cjel-3603 380 99 [ [ X cjel-3603 380 100 ] ] X cjel-3603 380 101 has have AUX cjel-3603 380 102 been be AUX cjel-3603 380 103 unable unable ADJ cjel-3603 380 104 to to PART cjel-3603 380 105 develop develop VERB cjel-3603 380 106 any any DET cjel-3603 380 107 ‘ ' PUNCT cjel-3603 380 108 set set ADJ cjel-3603 380 109 formula formula NOUN cjel-3603 380 110 ’ ' PUNCT cjel-3603 380 111 for for ADP cjel-3603 380 112 determining determine VERB cjel-3603 380 113 when when SCONJ cjel-3603 380 114 ‘ ' PUNCT cjel-3603 380 115 justice justice NOUN cjel-3603 380 116 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 380 117 fairness fairness NOUN cjel-3603 380 118 ’ ' PUNCT cjel-3603 380 119 require require VERB cjel-3603 380 120 that that SCONJ cjel-3603 380 121 economic economic ADJ cjel-3603 380 122 injuries injury NOUN cjel-3603 380 123 caused cause VERB cjel-3603 380 124 by by ADP cjel-3603 380 125 public public ADJ cjel-3603 380 126 action action NOUN cjel-3603 380 127 be be AUX cjel-3603 380 128 compensated compensate VERB cjel-3603 380 129 by by ADP cjel-3603 380 130 the the DET cjel-3603 380 131 government government NOUN cjel-3603 380 132 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 380 133 rather rather ADV cjel-3603 380 134 than than ADP cjel-3603 380 135 remain remain VERB cjel-3603 380 136 disproportionately disproportionately ADV cjel-3603 380 137 concentrated concentrate VERB cjel-3603 380 138 on on ADP cjel-3603 380 139 a a DET cjel-3603 380 140 few few ADJ cjel-3603 380 141 persons person NOUN cjel-3603 380 142 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 381 1 ”96 ”96 ADV cjel-3603 381 2 instead instead ADV cjel-3603 381 3 of of ADP cjel-3603 381 4 using use VERB cjel-3603 381 5 a a DET cjel-3603 381 6 categorical categorical ADJ cjel-3603 381 7 approach approach NOUN cjel-3603 381 8 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 381 9 the the DET cjel-3603 381 10 court court NOUN cjel-3603 381 11 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 381 12 by by ADP cjel-3603 381 13 looking look VERB cjel-3603 381 14 at at ADP cjel-3603 381 15 many many ADJ cjel-3603 381 16 takings taking NOUN cjel-3603 381 17 cases case NOUN cjel-3603 381 18 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 381 19 distilled distil VERB cjel-3603 381 20 the the DET cjel-3603 381 21 elements element NOUN cjel-3603 381 22 to to PART cjel-3603 381 23 be be AUX cjel-3603 381 24 weighed weigh VERB cjel-3603 381 25 in in ADP cjel-3603 381 26 an an DET cjel-3603 381 27 ad ad NOUN cjel-3603 381 28 - - PUNCT cjel-3603 381 29 hoc hoc VERB cjel-3603 381 30 takings taking NOUN cjel-3603 381 31 analysis.97 analysis.97 VERB cjel-3603 381 32 the the DET cjel-3603 381 33 ad ad NOUN cjel-3603 381 34 - - PUNCT cjel-3603 381 35 hoc hoc ADJ cjel-3603 381 36 analysis analysis NOUN cjel-3603 381 37 of of ADP cjel-3603 381 38 penn penn PROPN cjel-3603 381 39 central central PROPN cjel-3603 381 40 looks look VERB cjel-3603 381 41 at at ADP cjel-3603 381 42 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 381 43 1 1 X cjel-3603 381 44 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 381 45 the the DET cjel-3603 381 46 economic economic ADJ cjel-3603 381 47 impact impact NOUN cjel-3603 381 48 of of ADP cjel-3603 381 49 the the DET cjel-3603 381 50 government government NOUN cjel-3603 381 51 ’s ’s PART cjel-3603 381 52 action action NOUN cjel-3603 381 53 ; ; PUNCT cjel-3603 381 54 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 381 55 2 2 X cjel-3603 381 56 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 381 57 its its PRON cjel-3603 381 58 interference interference NOUN cjel-3603 381 59 with with ADP cjel-3603 381 60 reasonable reasonable ADJ cjel-3603 381 61 investment investment NOUN cjel-3603 381 62 backed back VERB cjel-3603 381 63 expectations expectation NOUN cjel-3603 381 64 ; ; PUNCT cjel-3603 381 65 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 381 66 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 381 67 3 3 X cjel-3603 381 68 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 381 69 the the DET cjel-3603 381 70 character character NOUN cjel-3603 381 71 of of ADP cjel-3603 381 72 the the DET cjel-3603 381 73 government government NOUN cjel-3603 381 74 action.98 action.98 NOUN cjel-3603 381 75 the the DET cjel-3603 381 76 court court NOUN cjel-3603 381 77 then then ADV cjel-3603 381 78 went go VERB cjel-3603 381 79 on on ADP cjel-3603 381 80 to to PART cjel-3603 381 81 apply apply VERB cjel-3603 381 82 this this DET cjel-3603 381 83 analysis analysis NOUN cjel-3603 381 84 to to ADP cjel-3603 381 85 the the DET cjel-3603 381 86 landmark landmark NOUN cjel-3603 381 87 regulations regulation NOUN cjel-3603 381 88 at at ADP cjel-3603 381 89 issue issue NOUN cjel-3603 381 90 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 381 91 found find VERB cjel-3603 381 92 that that SCONJ cjel-3603 381 93 they they PRON cjel-3603 381 94 were be AUX cjel-3603 381 95 not not PART cjel-3603 381 96 a a DET cjel-3603 381 97 taking taking NOUN cjel-3603 381 98 but but CCONJ cjel-3603 381 99 a a DET cjel-3603 381 100 permissible permissible ADJ cjel-3603 381 101 use use NOUN cjel-3603 381 102 of of ADP cjel-3603 381 103 the the DET cjel-3603 381 104 police police NOUN cjel-3603 381 105 power.99 power.99 NOUN cjel-3603 381 106 first first ADV cjel-3603 381 107 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 381 108 the the DET cjel-3603 381 109 court court NOUN cjel-3603 381 110 found find VERB cjel-3603 381 111 that that SCONJ cjel-3603 381 112 the the DET cjel-3603 381 113 government government NOUN cjel-3603 381 114 ’s ’s PART cjel-3603 381 115 landmark landmark PROPN cjel-3603 381 116 designation designation NOUN cjel-3603 381 117 “ " PUNCT cjel-3603 381 118 does do AUX cjel-3603 381 119 not not PART cjel-3603 381 120 interfere interfere VERB cjel-3603 381 121 in in ADP cjel-3603 381 122 any any DET cjel-3603 381 123 way way NOUN cjel-3603 381 124 with with ADP cjel-3603 381 125 the the DET cjel-3603 381 126 present present ADJ cjel-3603 381 127 uses use NOUN cjel-3603 381 128 of of ADP cjel-3603 381 129 the the DET cjel-3603 381 130 terminal terminal NOUN cjel-3603 381 131 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 381 132 ”100 ”100 PUNCT cjel-3603 382 1 therefore therefore ADV cjel-3603 382 2 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 382 3 the the DET cjel-3603 382 4 current current ADJ cjel-3603 382 5 economic economic ADJ cjel-3603 382 6 impact impact NOUN cjel-3603 382 7 was be AUX cjel-3603 382 8 minimal minimal ADJ cjel-3603 382 9 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 383 1 second second ADJ cjel-3603 383 2 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 383 3 the the DET cjel-3603 383 4 railroad railroad NOUN cjel-3603 383 5 terminal terminal NOUN cjel-3603 383 6 would would AUX cjel-3603 383 7 continue continue VERB cjel-3603 383 8 to to PART cjel-3603 383 9 operate operate VERB cjel-3603 383 10 as as SCONJ cjel-3603 383 11 it it PRON cjel-3603 383 12 had have VERB cjel-3603 383 13 “ " PUNCT cjel-3603 383 14 for for ADP cjel-3603 383 15 the the DET cjel-3603 383 16 past past ADJ cjel-3603 383 17 65 65 NUM cjel-3603 383 18 years year NOUN cjel-3603 383 19 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 383 20 ” " PUNCT cjel-3603 383 21 so so CCONJ cjel-3603 383 22 the the DET cjel-3603 383 23 governmental governmental ADJ cjel-3603 383 24 action action NOUN cjel-3603 383 25 did do AUX cjel-3603 383 26 “ " PUNCT cjel-3603 383 27 not not PART cjel-3603 383 28 interfere interfere VERB cjel-3603 383 29 with with ADP cjel-3603 383 30 what what PRON cjel-3603 383 31 must must AUX cjel-3603 383 32 be be AUX cjel-3603 383 33 93 93 NUM cjel-3603 383 34 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 384 1 penn penn PROPN cjel-3603 384 2 cent cent PROPN cjel-3603 384 3 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 385 1 transp transp PROPN cjel-3603 385 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 386 1 co. co. PROPN cjel-3603 386 2 v. v. ADP cjel-3603 386 3 city city PROPN cjel-3603 386 4 of of ADP cjel-3603 386 5 new new PROPN cjel-3603 386 6 york york PROPN cjel-3603 386 7 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 386 8 438 438 NUM cjel-3603 386 9 u.s u.s PROPN cjel-3603 386 10 . . PROPN cjel-3603 386 11 104 104 NUM cjel-3603 386 12 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 386 13 1978 1978 NUM cjel-3603 386 14 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 386 15 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 387 1 94 94 NUM cjel-3603 387 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 388 1 i i PRON cjel-3603 388 2 d. d. PROPN cjel-3603 388 3 95 95 NUM cjel-3603 388 4 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 389 1 see see VERB cjel-3603 389 2 village village NOUN cjel-3603 389 3 of of ADP cjel-3603 389 4 euclid euclid PROPN cjel-3603 389 5 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 389 6 ohio ohio PROPN cjel-3603 389 7 v. v. PROPN cjel-3603 389 8 ambler ambler PROPN cjel-3603 389 9 realty realty PROPN cjel-3603 389 10 co. co. PROPN cjel-3603 389 11 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 389 12 272 272 NUM cjel-3603 389 13 u.s u.s PROPN cjel-3603 389 14 . . PROPN cjel-3603 389 15 365 365 NUM cjel-3603 389 16 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 389 17 1926 1926 NUM cjel-3603 389 18 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 389 19 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 390 1 96 96 NUM cjel-3603 390 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 391 1 penn penn PROPN cjel-3603 391 2 cent cent PROPN cjel-3603 391 3 . . PROPN cjel-3603 391 4 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 391 5 438 438 NUM cjel-3603 391 6 u.s u.s PROPN cjel-3603 391 7 . . PROPN cjel-3603 392 1 at at ADP cjel-3603 392 2 124 124 NUM cjel-3603 392 3 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 392 4 citation citation NOUN cjel-3603 392 5 omitted omit VERB cjel-3603 392 6 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 392 7 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 393 1 97 97 NUM cjel-3603 393 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 394 1 i i PRON cjel-3603 394 2 d. d. PROPN cjel-3603 394 3 98 98 NUM cjel-3603 394 4 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 395 1 i i PRON cjel-3603 395 2 d. d. PROPN cjel-3603 395 3 99 99 NUM cjel-3603 395 4 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 396 1 i i PRON cjel-3603 396 2 d. d. PROPN cjel-3603 396 3 at at ADP cjel-3603 396 4 138 138 NUM cjel-3603 396 5 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 396 6 see see VERB cjel-3603 396 7 generally generally ADV cjel-3603 396 8 david david PROPN cjel-3603 396 9 a. a. PROPN cjel-3603 396 10 dana dana PROPN cjel-3603 396 11 & & CCONJ cjel-3603 396 12 thomas thomas PROPN cjel-3603 396 13 w. w. PROPN cjel-3603 396 14 merrill merrill PROPN cjel-3603 396 15 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 396 16 property property NOUN cjel-3603 396 17 : : PUNCT cjel-3603 396 18 takings taking NOUN cjel-3603 396 19 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 396 20 2002 2002 NUM cjel-3603 396 21 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 396 22 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 397 1 100 100 NUM cjel-3603 397 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 398 1 penn penn PROPN cjel-3603 398 2 cent cent PROPN cjel-3603 398 3 . . PROPN cjel-3603 398 4 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 398 5 438 438 NUM cjel-3603 398 6 u.s u.s PROPN cjel-3603 398 7 . . PROPN cjel-3603 398 8 at at ADP cjel-3603 398 9 136 136 NUM cjel-3603 398 10 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 399 1 monahan monahan PROPN cjel-3603 399 2 - - PUNCT cjel-3603 399 3 macro-[final macro-[final PROPN cjel-3603 399 4 6 6 NUM cjel-3603 399 5 - - SYM cjel-3603 399 6 20 20 NUM cjel-3603 399 7 ] ] PUNCT cjel-3603 399 8 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 399 9 do do AUX cjel-3603 399 10 not not PART cjel-3603 399 11 delete delete VERB cjel-3603 399 12 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 399 13 6/22/2015 6/22/2015 NUM cjel-3603 399 14 11:53 11:53 NUM cjel-3603 399 15 pm pm NOUN cjel-3603 399 16 378 378 NUM cjel-3603 399 17 columbia columbia PROPN cjel-3603 399 18 journal journal PROPN cjel-3603 399 19 of of ADP cjel-3603 399 20 environmental environmental ADJ cjel-3603 399 21 law law NOUN cjel-3603 399 22 [ [ X cjel-3603 399 23 vol vol NOUN cjel-3603 399 24 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 400 1 40:2 40:2 NUM cjel-3603 400 2 regarded regard VERB cjel-3603 400 3 as as ADP cjel-3603 400 4 penn penn PROPN cjel-3603 400 5 central central PROPN cjel-3603 400 6 ’s ’s PART cjel-3603 400 7 primary primary ADJ cjel-3603 400 8 expectation expectation NOUN cjel-3603 400 9 concerning concern VERB cjel-3603 400 10 the the DET cjel-3603 400 11 use use NOUN cjel-3603 400 12 of of ADP cjel-3603 400 13 the the DET cjel-3603 400 14 parcel parcel NOUN cjel-3603 400 15 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 401 1 ”101 ”101 PRON cjel-3603 402 1 not not PART cjel-3603 402 2 only only ADV cjel-3603 402 3 did do AUX cjel-3603 402 4 the the DET cjel-3603 402 5 designation designation NOUN cjel-3603 402 6 allow allow VERB cjel-3603 402 7 the the DET cjel-3603 402 8 terminal terminal NOUN cjel-3603 402 9 to to PART cjel-3603 402 10 continue continue VERB cjel-3603 402 11 to to PART cjel-3603 402 12 operate operate VERB cjel-3603 402 13 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 402 14 but but CCONJ cjel-3603 402 15 the the DET cjel-3603 402 16 landowners landowner NOUN cjel-3603 402 17 were be AUX cjel-3603 402 18 also also ADV cjel-3603 402 19 able able ADJ cjel-3603 402 20 to to PART cjel-3603 402 21 “ " PUNCT cjel-3603 402 22 obtain obtain VERB cjel-3603 402 23 a a DET cjel-3603 402 24 ‘ ' PUNCT cjel-3603 402 25 reasonable reasonable ADJ cjel-3603 402 26 return return NOUN cjel-3603 402 27 ’ ' PUNCT cjel-3603 402 28 ” " PUNCT cjel-3603 402 29 on on ADP cjel-3603 402 30 investment.102 investment.102 NUM cjel-3603 402 31 finally finally ADV cjel-3603 402 32 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 402 33 the the DET cjel-3603 402 34 governmental governmental ADJ cjel-3603 402 35 action action NOUN cjel-3603 402 36 “ " PUNCT cjel-3603 402 37 not not PART cjel-3603 402 38 only only ADV cjel-3603 402 39 permit[ted permit[te VERB cjel-3603 402 40 ] ] PUNCT cjel-3603 402 41 reasonable reasonable ADJ cjel-3603 402 42 beneficial beneficial ADJ cjel-3603 402 43 use use NOUN cjel-3603 402 44 of of ADP cjel-3603 402 45 the the DET cjel-3603 402 46 landmark landmark NOUN cjel-3603 402 47 site site NOUN cjel-3603 402 48 but but CCONJ cjel-3603 402 49 also also ADV cjel-3603 402 50 afford[ed afford[ed PROPN cjel-3603 402 51 ] ] PUNCT cjel-3603 402 52 appellants appellant NOUN cjel-3603 402 53 opportunities opportunity NOUN cjel-3603 402 54 further far ADV cjel-3603 402 55 to to PART cjel-3603 402 56 enhance enhance VERB cjel-3603 402 57 not not PART cjel-3603 402 58 only only ADV cjel-3603 402 59 the the DET cjel-3603 402 60 terminal terminal ADJ cjel-3603 402 61 site site NOUN cjel-3603 402 62 proper proper ADJ cjel-3603 402 63 but but CCONJ cjel-3603 402 64 also also ADV cjel-3603 402 65 other other ADJ cjel-3603 402 66 properties property NOUN cjel-3603 402 67 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 402 68 ”103 ”103 PUNCT cjel-3603 402 69 instead instead ADV cjel-3603 402 70 of of ADP cjel-3603 402 71 quickly quickly ADV cjel-3603 402 72 dismissing dismiss VERB cjel-3603 402 73 the the DET cjel-3603 402 74 case case NOUN cjel-3603 402 75 by by ADP cjel-3603 402 76 shoehorning shoehorn VERB cjel-3603 402 77 it it PRON cjel-3603 402 78 into into ADP cjel-3603 402 79 a a DET cjel-3603 402 80 single single ADJ cjel-3603 402 81 categorical categorical ADJ cjel-3603 402 82 exception exception NOUN cjel-3603 402 83 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 402 84 the the DET cjel-3603 402 85 court court NOUN cjel-3603 402 86 was be AUX cjel-3603 402 87 able able ADJ cjel-3603 402 88 to to PART cjel-3603 402 89 address address VERB cjel-3603 402 90 the the DET cjel-3603 402 91 various various ADJ cjel-3603 402 92 goals goal NOUN cjel-3603 402 93 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 402 94 consequences consequence NOUN cjel-3603 402 95 of of ADP cjel-3603 402 96 the the DET cjel-3603 402 97 governmental governmental ADJ cjel-3603 402 98 actions action NOUN cjel-3603 402 99 in in ADP cjel-3603 402 100 question question NOUN cjel-3603 402 101 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 403 1 b. b. VERB cjel-3603 404 1 the the DET cjel-3603 404 2 lucas lucas PROPN cjel-3603 404 3 exception exception PROPN cjel-3603 404 4 : : PUNCT cjel-3603 404 5 recognition recognition NOUN cjel-3603 404 6 of of ADP cjel-3603 404 7 categorical categorical ADJ cjel-3603 404 8 exceptions exception NOUN cjel-3603 404 9 in in ADP cjel-3603 404 10 lucas lucas PROPN cjel-3603 404 11 v. v. PROPN cjel-3603 404 12 south south PROPN cjel-3603 404 13 carolina carolina PROPN cjel-3603 404 14 coastal coastal PROPN cjel-3603 404 15 council council PROPN cjel-3603 404 16 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 404 17 the the DET cjel-3603 404 18 supreme supreme PROPN cjel-3603 404 19 court court PROPN cjel-3603 404 20 held hold VERB cjel-3603 404 21 “ " PUNCT cjel-3603 404 22 categorical categorical ADJ cjel-3603 404 23 treatment treatment NOUN cjel-3603 404 24 [ [ X cjel-3603 404 25 of of ADP cjel-3603 404 26 a a DET cjel-3603 404 27 potential potential ADJ cjel-3603 404 28 taking taking NOUN cjel-3603 404 29 ] ] PUNCT cjel-3603 404 30 appropriate appropriate ADJ cjel-3603 404 31 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 404 32 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 404 33 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 405 1 where where SCONJ cjel-3603 405 2 regulation regulation NOUN cjel-3603 405 3 denies deny VERB cjel-3603 405 4 all all DET cjel-3603 405 5 economically economically ADV cjel-3603 405 6 beneficial beneficial ADJ cjel-3603 405 7 or or CCONJ cjel-3603 405 8 productive productive ADJ cjel-3603 405 9 use use NOUN cjel-3603 405 10 ” " PUNCT cjel-3603 405 11 to to ADP cjel-3603 405 12 the the DET cjel-3603 405 13 landowner.104 landowner.104 PROPN cjel-3603 405 14 in in ADP cjel-3603 405 15 these these DET cjel-3603 405 16 cases case NOUN cjel-3603 405 17 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 405 18 the the DET cjel-3603 405 19 government government NOUN cjel-3603 405 20 almost almost ADV cjel-3603 405 21 inevitably inevitably ADV cjel-3603 405 22 must must AUX cjel-3603 405 23 compensate compensate VERB cjel-3603 405 24 the the DET cjel-3603 405 25 landowner landowner NOUN cjel-3603 405 26 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 406 1 however however ADV cjel-3603 406 2 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 406 3 the the DET cjel-3603 406 4 court court NOUN cjel-3603 406 5 in in ADP cjel-3603 406 6 lucas lucas PROPN cjel-3603 406 7 also also ADV cjel-3603 406 8 noted note VERB cjel-3603 406 9 that that SCONJ cjel-3603 406 10 this this DET cjel-3603 406 11 categorical categorical ADJ cjel-3603 406 12 approach approach NOUN cjel-3603 406 13 would would AUX cjel-3603 406 14 be be AUX cjel-3603 406 15 inapplicable inapplicable ADJ cjel-3603 406 16 “ " PUNCT cjel-3603 406 17 if if SCONJ cjel-3603 406 18 the the DET cjel-3603 406 19 logically logically ADV cjel-3603 406 20 antecedent antecedent NOUN cjel-3603 406 21 inquiry inquiry NOUN cjel-3603 406 22 into into ADP cjel-3603 406 23 the the DET cjel-3603 406 24 nature nature NOUN cjel-3603 406 25 of of ADP cjel-3603 406 26 the the DET cjel-3603 406 27 owner owner NOUN cjel-3603 406 28 ’s ’s PART cjel-3603 406 29 estate estate NOUN cjel-3603 406 30 shows show VERB cjel-3603 406 31 that that SCONJ cjel-3603 406 32 the the DET cjel-3603 406 33 proscribed proscribe VERB cjel-3603 406 34 use use NOUN cjel-3603 406 35 interests interest NOUN cjel-3603 406 36 were be AUX cjel-3603 406 37 not not PART cjel-3603 406 38 part part NOUN cjel-3603 406 39 of of ADP cjel-3603 406 40 his his PRON cjel-3603 406 41 title title NOUN cjel-3603 406 42 to to PART cjel-3603 406 43 begin begin VERB cjel-3603 406 44 with with ADP cjel-3603 406 45 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 406 46 ”105 ”105 ADJ cjel-3603 406 47 the the DET cjel-3603 406 48 court court NOUN cjel-3603 406 49 then then ADV cjel-3603 406 50 explicitly explicitly ADV cjel-3603 406 51 cited cite VERB cjel-3603 406 52 the the DET cjel-3603 406 53 navigational navigational ADJ cjel-3603 406 54 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 406 55 as as ADP cjel-3603 406 56 an an DET cjel-3603 406 57 example example NOUN cjel-3603 406 58 of of ADP cjel-3603 406 59 a a DET cjel-3603 406 60 valid valid ADJ cjel-3603 406 61 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 406 62 “ " PUNCT cjel-3603 406 63 pre pre ADJ cjel-3603 406 64 - - ADJ cjel-3603 406 65 existing existing ADJ cjel-3603 406 66 limitation limitation NOUN cjel-3603 406 67 upon upon SCONJ cjel-3603 406 68 the the DET cjel-3603 406 69 land land NOUN cjel-3603 406 70 owner owner NOUN cjel-3603 406 71 ’s ’s PART cjel-3603 406 72 title title NOUN cjel-3603 406 73 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 407 1 ”106 ”106 PUNCT cjel-3603 408 1 once once SCONJ cjel-3603 408 2 it it PRON cjel-3603 408 3 is be AUX cjel-3603 408 4 found find VERB cjel-3603 408 5 that that SCONJ cjel-3603 408 6 the the DET cjel-3603 408 7 landowner landowner NOUN cjel-3603 408 8 did do AUX cjel-3603 408 9 not not PART cjel-3603 408 10 have have VERB cjel-3603 408 11 a a DET cjel-3603 408 12 property property NOUN cjel-3603 408 13 right right NOUN cjel-3603 408 14 in in ADP cjel-3603 408 15 what what PRON cjel-3603 408 16 was be AUX cjel-3603 408 17 allegedly allegedly ADV cjel-3603 408 18 taken take VERB cjel-3603 408 19 — — PUNCT cjel-3603 408 20 because because SCONJ cjel-3603 408 21 it it PRON cjel-3603 408 22 was be AUX cjel-3603 408 23 always always ADV cjel-3603 408 24 subject subject ADJ cjel-3603 408 25 to to ADP cjel-3603 408 26 the the DET cjel-3603 408 27 navigational navigational ADJ cjel-3603 408 28 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 408 29 — — PUNCT cjel-3603 408 30 the the DET cjel-3603 408 31 analysis analysis NOUN cjel-3603 408 32 ends end VERB cjel-3603 408 33 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 408 34 no no DET cjel-3603 408 35 taking taking NOUN cjel-3603 408 36 can can AUX cjel-3603 408 37 be be AUX cjel-3603 408 38 found find VERB cjel-3603 408 39 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 409 1 101 101 NUM cjel-3603 409 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 410 1 i i PRON cjel-3603 410 2 d. d. PROPN cjel-3603 410 3 102 102 NUM cjel-3603 410 4 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 411 1 i i PRON cjel-3603 411 2 d. d. PROPN cjel-3603 411 3 103 103 NUM cjel-3603 411 4 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 412 1 i i PRON cjel-3603 412 2 d. d. PROPN cjel-3603 412 3 at at ADP cjel-3603 412 4 138 138 NUM cjel-3603 412 5 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 413 1 104 104 NUM cjel-3603 413 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 414 1 lucas lucas PROPN cjel-3603 414 2 v. v. PROPN cjel-3603 414 3 s.c s.c PROPN cjel-3603 414 4 . . PROPN cjel-3603 414 5 coastal coastal PROPN cjel-3603 414 6 council council PROPN cjel-3603 414 7 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 414 8 505 505 NUM cjel-3603 414 9 u.s u.s PROPN cjel-3603 414 10 . . PROPN cjel-3603 414 11 1003 1003 NUM cjel-3603 414 12 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 414 13 1015 1015 NUM cjel-3603 414 14 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 414 15 1992 1992 NUM cjel-3603 414 16 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 414 17 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 415 1 105 105 NUM cjel-3603 415 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 416 1 i i PRON cjel-3603 416 2 d. d. PROPN cjel-3603 416 3 at at ADP cjel-3603 416 4 1027 1027 NUM cjel-3603 416 5 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 417 1 106 106 NUM cjel-3603 417 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 418 1 i i PRON cjel-3603 418 2 d. d. PROPN cjel-3603 418 3 at at ADP cjel-3603 418 4 1028–29 1028–29 NUM cjel-3603 418 5 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 419 1 monahan monahan PROPN cjel-3603 419 2 - - PUNCT cjel-3603 419 3 macro-[final macro-[final PROPN cjel-3603 419 4 6 6 NUM cjel-3603 419 5 - - SYM cjel-3603 419 6 20 20 NUM cjel-3603 419 7 ] ] PUNCT cjel-3603 419 8 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 419 9 do do AUX cjel-3603 419 10 not not PART cjel-3603 419 11 delete delete VERB cjel-3603 419 12 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 419 13 6/22/2015 6/22/2015 NUM cjel-3603 419 14 11:53 11:53 NUM cjel-3603 419 15 pm pm NOUN cjel-3603 419 16 2015 2015 NUM cjel-3603 419 17 ] ] PUNCT cjel-3603 419 18 the the DET cjel-3603 419 19 navigational navigational ADJ cjel-3603 419 20 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 419 21 379 379 NUM cjel-3603 419 22 c. c. NOUN cjel-3603 419 23 the the DET cjel-3603 419 24 typical typical ADJ cjel-3603 419 25 takings taking NOUN cjel-3603 419 26 case case NOUN cjel-3603 419 27 under under ADP cjel-3603 419 28 the the DET cjel-3603 419 29 current current ADJ cjel-3603 419 30 takings taking NOUN cjel-3603 419 31 clause clause NOUN cjel-3603 419 32 framework framework NOUN cjel-3603 419 33 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 419 34 the the DET cjel-3603 419 35 initial initial ADJ cjel-3603 419 36 step step NOUN cjel-3603 419 37 is be AUX cjel-3603 419 38 to to PART cjel-3603 419 39 determine determine VERB cjel-3603 419 40 if if SCONJ cjel-3603 419 41 the the DET cjel-3603 419 42 plaintiff plaintiff NOUN cjel-3603 419 43 has have VERB cjel-3603 419 44 a a DET cjel-3603 419 45 property property NOUN cjel-3603 419 46 right.107 right.107 ADP cjel-3603 419 47 such such DET cjel-3603 419 48 a a DET cjel-3603 419 49 property property NOUN cjel-3603 419 50 right right NOUN cjel-3603 419 51 is be AUX cjel-3603 419 52 not not PART cjel-3603 419 53 created create VERB cjel-3603 419 54 by by ADP cjel-3603 419 55 the the DET cjel-3603 419 56 constitution constitution NOUN cjel-3603 419 57 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 419 58 but but CCONJ cjel-3603 419 59 is be AUX cjel-3603 419 60 defined define VERB cjel-3603 419 61 by by ADP cjel-3603 419 62 reference reference NOUN cjel-3603 419 63 to to ADP cjel-3603 419 64 “ " PUNCT cjel-3603 419 65 ‘ ' PUNCT cjel-3603 419 66 existing exist VERB cjel-3603 419 67 rules rule NOUN cjel-3603 419 68 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 419 69 understandings understanding NOUN cjel-3603 419 70 ’ ' PUNCT cjel-3603 419 71 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 419 72 ‘ ' PUNCT cjel-3603 419 73 background background NOUN cjel-3603 419 74 principles principle NOUN cjel-3603 419 75 ’ ' PUNCT cjel-3603 419 76 derived derive VERB cjel-3603 419 77 from from ADP cjel-3603 419 78 an an DET cjel-3603 419 79 independent independent ADJ cjel-3603 419 80 source source NOUN cjel-3603 419 81 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 419 82 such such ADJ cjel-3603 419 83 as as ADP cjel-3603 419 84 state state NOUN cjel-3603 419 85 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 419 86 federal federal ADJ cjel-3603 419 87 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 419 88 or or CCONJ cjel-3603 419 89 common common ADJ cjel-3603 419 90 law law NOUN cjel-3603 419 91 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 419 92 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 419 93 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 420 1 .”108 .”108 PUNCT cjel-3603 421 1 this this PRON cjel-3603 421 2 is be AUX cjel-3603 421 3 where where SCONJ cjel-3603 421 4 the the DET cjel-3603 421 5 lucas lucas PROPN cjel-3603 421 6 analysis analysis NOUN cjel-3603 421 7 of of ADP cjel-3603 421 8 the the DET cjel-3603 421 9 navigational navigational ADJ cjel-3603 421 10 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 421 11 is be AUX cjel-3603 421 12 often often ADV cjel-3603 421 13 invoked invoke VERB cjel-3603 421 14 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 421 15 leading lead VERB cjel-3603 421 16 to to ADP cjel-3603 421 17 dismissal dismissal NOUN cjel-3603 421 18 of of ADP cjel-3603 421 19 the the DET cjel-3603 421 20 case case NOUN cjel-3603 421 21 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 422 1 if if SCONJ cjel-3603 422 2 a a DET cjel-3603 422 3 case case NOUN cjel-3603 422 4 moves move VERB cjel-3603 422 5 beyond beyond ADP cjel-3603 422 6 this this DET cjel-3603 422 7 stage stage NOUN cjel-3603 422 8 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 422 9 the the DET cjel-3603 422 10 next next ADJ cjel-3603 422 11 question question NOUN cjel-3603 422 12 is be AUX cjel-3603 422 13 whether whether SCONJ cjel-3603 422 14 or or CCONJ cjel-3603 422 15 not not PART cjel-3603 422 16 there there PRON cjel-3603 422 17 has have AUX cjel-3603 422 18 been be AUX cjel-3603 422 19 a a DET cjel-3603 422 20 taking.109 taking.109 VERB cjel-3603 422 21 there there PRON cjel-3603 422 22 are be VERB cjel-3603 422 23 two two NUM cjel-3603 422 24 different different ADJ cjel-3603 422 25 ways way NOUN cjel-3603 422 26 that that PRON cjel-3603 422 27 a a DET cjel-3603 422 28 taking taking NOUN cjel-3603 422 29 can can AUX cjel-3603 422 30 then then ADV cjel-3603 422 31 be be AUX cjel-3603 422 32 shown show VERB cjel-3603 422 33 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 423 1 either either CCONJ cjel-3603 423 2 a a DET cjel-3603 423 3 landowner landowner NOUN cjel-3603 423 4 can can AUX cjel-3603 423 5 meet meet VERB cjel-3603 423 6 the the DET cjel-3603 423 7 lucas lucas PROPN cjel-3603 423 8 test test NOUN cjel-3603 423 9 by by ADP cjel-3603 423 10 showing show VERB cjel-3603 423 11 that that SCONJ cjel-3603 423 12 he he PRON cjel-3603 423 13 or or CCONJ cjel-3603 423 14 she she PRON cjel-3603 423 15 has have AUX cjel-3603 423 16 been be AUX cjel-3603 423 17 denied deny VERB cjel-3603 423 18 all all DET cjel-3603 423 19 economically economically ADV cjel-3603 423 20 beneficial beneficial ADJ cjel-3603 423 21 or or CCONJ cjel-3603 423 22 productive productive ADJ cjel-3603 423 23 use use NOUN cjel-3603 423 24 of of ADP cjel-3603 423 25 the the DET cjel-3603 423 26 land land NOUN cjel-3603 423 27 as as ADP cjel-3603 423 28 a a DET cjel-3603 423 29 result result NOUN cjel-3603 423 30 of of ADP cjel-3603 423 31 the the DET cjel-3603 423 32 government government NOUN cjel-3603 423 33 ’s ’s PART cjel-3603 423 34 actions,110 actions,110 PROPN cjel-3603 423 35 or or CCONJ cjel-3603 423 36 he he PRON cjel-3603 423 37 or or CCONJ cjel-3603 423 38 she she PRON cjel-3603 423 39 can can AUX cjel-3603 423 40 prevail prevail VERB cjel-3603 423 41 under under ADP cjel-3603 423 42 the the DET cjel-3603 423 43 adhoc adhoc NOUN cjel-3603 423 44 determination determination NOUN cjel-3603 423 45 set set VERB cjel-3603 423 46 forth forth ADP cjel-3603 423 47 in in ADP cjel-3603 423 48 penn penn PROPN cjel-3603 423 49 central.111 central.111 VERB cjel-3603 423 50 the the DET cjel-3603 423 51 takings taking NOUN cjel-3603 423 52 analysis analysis NOUN cjel-3603 423 53 established establish VERB cjel-3603 423 54 in in ADP cjel-3603 423 55 lucas lucas PROPN cjel-3603 423 56 was be AUX cjel-3603 423 57 used use VERB cjel-3603 423 58 in in ADP cjel-3603 423 59 united united PROPN cjel-3603 423 60 states states PROPN cjel-3603 423 61 v. v. ADP cjel-3603 423 62 30.54 30.54 NUM cjel-3603 423 63 acres acre NOUN cjel-3603 423 64 of of ADP cjel-3603 423 65 land land NOUN cjel-3603 423 66 to to PART cjel-3603 423 67 hold hold VERB cjel-3603 423 68 that that SCONJ cjel-3603 423 69 even even ADV cjel-3603 423 70 if if SCONJ cjel-3603 423 71 the the DET cjel-3603 423 72 government government NOUN cjel-3603 423 73 ’s ’s PART cjel-3603 423 74 actions action NOUN cjel-3603 423 75 deprived deprive VERB cjel-3603 423 76 the the DET cjel-3603 423 77 landowners landowner NOUN cjel-3603 423 78 of of ADP cjel-3603 423 79 all all DET cjel-3603 423 80 economically economically ADV cjel-3603 423 81 reasonable reasonable ADJ cjel-3603 423 82 use use NOUN cjel-3603 423 83 of of ADP cjel-3603 423 84 their their PRON cjel-3603 423 85 land land NOUN cjel-3603 423 86 there there PRON cjel-3603 423 87 could could AUX cjel-3603 423 88 be be AUX cjel-3603 423 89 no no DET cjel-3603 423 90 taking taking NOUN cjel-3603 423 91 since since SCONJ cjel-3603 423 92 the the DET cjel-3603 423 93 land land NOUN cjel-3603 423 94 had have AUX cjel-3603 423 95 always always ADV cjel-3603 423 96 been be AUX cjel-3603 423 97 “ " PUNCT cjel-3603 423 98 subject subject ADJ cjel-3603 423 99 to to ADP cjel-3603 423 100 the the DET cjel-3603 423 101 navigational navigational ADJ cjel-3603 423 102 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 423 103 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 423 104 the the DET cjel-3603 423 105 possibility possibility NOUN cjel-3603 423 106 that that SCONJ cjel-3603 423 107 the the DET cjel-3603 423 108 government government NOUN cjel-3603 423 109 might might AUX cjel-3603 423 110 exercise exercise VERB cjel-3603 423 111 the the DET cjel-3603 423 112 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 423 113 to to PART cjel-3603 423 114 prohibit prohibit VERB cjel-3603 423 115 their their PRON cjel-3603 423 116 use use NOUN cjel-3603 423 117 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 424 1 exercise exercise NOUN cjel-3603 424 2 of of ADP cjel-3603 424 3 the the DET cjel-3603 424 4 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 424 5 did do VERB cjel-3603 424 6 nothing nothing PRON cjel-3603 424 7 more more ADJ cjel-3603 424 8 than than SCONJ cjel-3603 424 9 realize realize VERB cjel-3603 424 10 a a DET cjel-3603 424 11 limitation limitation NOUN cjel-3603 424 12 always always ADV cjel-3603 424 13 inherent inherent ADJ cjel-3603 424 14 in in ADP cjel-3603 424 15 the the DET cjel-3603 424 16 landowners landowner NOUN cjel-3603 424 17 ’ ’ PART cjel-3603 424 18 title title NOUN cjel-3603 424 19 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 424 20 ”112 ”112 PROPN cjel-3603 424 21 in in ADP cjel-3603 424 22 this this DET cjel-3603 424 23 case case NOUN cjel-3603 424 24 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 424 25 the the DET cjel-3603 424 26 landowners landowner NOUN cjel-3603 424 27 had have AUX cjel-3603 424 28 operated operate VERB cjel-3603 424 29 a a DET cjel-3603 424 30 coal coal NOUN cjel-3603 424 31 loading loading NOUN cjel-3603 424 32 facility facility NOUN cjel-3603 424 33 on on ADP cjel-3603 424 34 a a DET cjel-3603 424 35 tract tract NOUN cjel-3603 424 36 of of ADP cjel-3603 424 37 land land NOUN cjel-3603 424 38 along along ADP cjel-3603 424 39 the the DET cjel-3603 424 40 monongahela monongahela PROPN cjel-3603 424 41 river river NOUN cjel-3603 424 42 since since SCONJ cjel-3603 424 43 1914.113 1914.113 NUM cjel-3603 424 44 at at ADP cjel-3603 424 45 this this DET cjel-3603 424 46 facility facility NOUN cjel-3603 424 47 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 424 48 coal coal NOUN cjel-3603 424 49 was be AUX cjel-3603 424 50 loaded load VERB cjel-3603 424 51 into into ADP cjel-3603 424 52 barges barge NOUN cjel-3603 424 53 on on ADP cjel-3603 424 54 the the DET cjel-3603 424 55 river river NOUN cjel-3603 424 56 using use VERB cjel-3603 424 57 “ " PUNCT cjel-3603 424 58 a a DET cjel-3603 424 59 coal coal NOUN cjel-3603 424 60 tipple tipple NOUN cjel-3603 424 61 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 424 62 grounded ground VERB cjel-3603 424 63 on on ADP cjel-3603 424 64 the the DET cjel-3603 424 65 property property NOUN cjel-3603 424 66 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 425 1 [ [ X cjel-3603 425 2 that that PRON cjel-3603 425 3 ] ] PUNCT cjel-3603 425 4 extended extend VERB cjel-3603 425 5 107 107 NUM cjel-3603 425 6 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 426 1 see see VERB cjel-3603 426 2 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 426 3 e.g. e.g. ADV cjel-3603 426 4 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 426 5 arctic arctic ADJ cjel-3603 426 6 king king NOUN cjel-3603 426 7 fisheries fisheries PROPN cjel-3603 426 8 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 426 9 inc inc PROPN cjel-3603 426 10 . . PROPN cjel-3603 426 11 v. v. PROPN cjel-3603 426 12 united united PROPN cjel-3603 426 13 states states PROPN cjel-3603 426 14 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 426 15 59 59 NUM cjel-3603 426 16 fed feed VERB cjel-3603 426 17 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 427 1 cl cl NOUN cjel-3603 427 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 428 1 360 360 NUM cjel-3603 428 2 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 428 3 370 370 NUM cjel-3603 428 4 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 428 5 fed fed PROPN cjel-3603 428 6 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 429 1 cl cl NOUN cjel-3603 429 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 429 3 2004 2004 NUM cjel-3603 429 4 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 429 5 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 430 1 108 108 NUM cjel-3603 430 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 431 1 maritrans maritrans PROPN cjel-3603 431 2 inc inc PROPN cjel-3603 431 3 . . PROPN cjel-3603 431 4 v. v. PROPN cjel-3603 431 5 united united PROPN cjel-3603 431 6 states states PROPN cjel-3603 431 7 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 431 8 342 342 NUM cjel-3603 431 9 f.3d f.3d NUM cjel-3603 431 10 1344 1344 NUM cjel-3603 431 11 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 431 12 1352 1352 NUM cjel-3603 431 13 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 431 14 fed fed PROPN cjel-3603 431 15 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 431 16 cir cir PROPN cjel-3603 431 17 . . PROPN cjel-3603 431 18 2003 2003 NUM cjel-3603 431 19 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 431 20 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 431 21 citing cite VERB cjel-3603 431 22 lucas lucas NOUN cjel-3603 431 23 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 431 24 505 505 NUM cjel-3603 431 25 u.s u.s PROPN cjel-3603 431 26 . . PROPN cjel-3603 431 27 at at ADP cjel-3603 431 28 1030 1030 NUM cjel-3603 431 29 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 431 30 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 432 1 109 109 NUM cjel-3603 432 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 432 3 see see VERB cjel-3603 432 4 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 432 5 e.g. e.g. ADV cjel-3603 432 6 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 432 7 mildenberger mildenberger PROPN cjel-3603 432 8 v. v. PROPN cjel-3603 432 9 united united PROPN cjel-3603 432 10 states states PROPN cjel-3603 432 11 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 432 12 643 643 NUM cjel-3603 432 13 f.3d f.3d NUM cjel-3603 432 14 938 938 NUM cjel-3603 432 15 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 432 16 fed fed PROPN cjel-3603 432 17 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 432 18 cir cir PROPN cjel-3603 432 19 . . PROPN cjel-3603 432 20 2011 2011 NUM cjel-3603 432 21 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 432 22 ; ; PUNCT cjel-3603 432 23 arctic arctic ADJ cjel-3603 432 24 king king NOUN cjel-3603 432 25 fisheries fisheries PROPN cjel-3603 432 26 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 432 27 inc inc PROPN cjel-3603 432 28 . . PROPN cjel-3603 432 29 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 432 30 59 59 NUM cjel-3603 432 31 fed feed VERB cjel-3603 432 32 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 433 1 cl cl NOUN cjel-3603 433 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 434 1 at at ADP cjel-3603 434 2 373–86 373–86 NUM cjel-3603 434 3 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 435 1 110 110 NUM cjel-3603 435 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 435 3 lucas lucas PROPN cjel-3603 435 4 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 435 5 505 505 NUM cjel-3603 435 6 u.s u.s PROPN cjel-3603 435 7 . . PROPN cjel-3603 435 8 at at ADP cjel-3603 435 9 1027–30 1027–30 NUM cjel-3603 435 10 ; ; PUNCT cjel-3603 435 11 see see VERB cjel-3603 435 12 also also ADV cjel-3603 435 13 palm palm NOUN cjel-3603 435 14 beach beach PROPN cjel-3603 435 15 isles isles PROPN cjel-3603 435 16 assocs assocs PROPN cjel-3603 435 17 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 436 1 v. v. PROPN cjel-3603 436 2 united united PROPN cjel-3603 436 3 states states PROPN cjel-3603 436 4 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 436 5 208 208 NUM cjel-3603 436 6 f.3d f.3d NUM cjel-3603 436 7 1374 1374 NUM cjel-3603 436 8 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 436 9 1379 1379 NUM cjel-3603 436 10 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 436 11 fed fed PROPN cjel-3603 436 12 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 436 13 cir cir PROPN cjel-3603 436 14 . . PROPN cjel-3603 436 15 2000 2000 NUM cjel-3603 436 16 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 436 17 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 436 18 abrogated abrogate VERB cjel-3603 436 19 by by ADP cjel-3603 436 20 bass bass NOUN cjel-3603 436 21 enters enter NOUN cjel-3603 436 22 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 437 1 prod prod PROPN cjel-3603 437 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 437 3 co. co. PROPN cjel-3603 438 1 v. v. ADP cjel-3603 438 2 united united PROPN cjel-3603 438 3 states states PROPN cjel-3603 438 4 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 438 5 381 381 NUM cjel-3603 438 6 f.3d f.3d NUM cjel-3603 438 7 1360 1360 NUM cjel-3603 438 8 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 438 9 1369–70 1369–70 NUM cjel-3603 438 10 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 438 11 fed fed PROPN cjel-3603 438 12 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 438 13 cir cir PROPN cjel-3603 438 14 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 438 15 2004 2004 NUM cjel-3603 438 16 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 438 17 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 439 1 111 111 NUM cjel-3603 439 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 440 1 penn penn PROPN cjel-3603 440 2 cent cent PROPN cjel-3603 440 3 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 441 1 transp transp PROPN cjel-3603 441 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 442 1 co. co. PROPN cjel-3603 442 2 v. v. ADP cjel-3603 442 3 city city PROPN cjel-3603 442 4 of of ADP cjel-3603 442 5 new new PROPN cjel-3603 442 6 york york PROPN cjel-3603 442 7 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 442 8 438 438 NUM cjel-3603 442 9 u.s u.s PROPN cjel-3603 442 10 . . PROPN cjel-3603 442 11 104 104 NUM cjel-3603 442 12 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 442 13 124 124 NUM cjel-3603 442 14 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 442 15 1978 1978 NUM cjel-3603 442 16 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 442 17 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 443 1 112 112 NUM cjel-3603 443 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 444 1 united united PROPN cjel-3603 444 2 states states PROPN cjel-3603 444 3 v. v. ADP cjel-3603 444 4 30.54 30.54 NUM cjel-3603 444 5 acres acre NOUN cjel-3603 444 6 of of ADP cjel-3603 444 7 land land NOUN cjel-3603 444 8 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 444 9 90 90 NUM cjel-3603 444 10 f.3d f.3d NUM cjel-3603 444 11 790 790 NUM cjel-3603 444 12 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 444 13 795 795 NUM cjel-3603 444 14 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 444 15 3d 3d NUM cjel-3603 444 16 cir cir NOUN cjel-3603 444 17 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 444 18 1996 1996 NUM cjel-3603 444 19 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 444 20 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 445 1 113 113 NUM cjel-3603 445 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 446 1 i i PRON cjel-3603 446 2 d. d. PROPN cjel-3603 446 3 at at ADP cjel-3603 446 4 792 792 NUM cjel-3603 446 5 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 447 1 monahan monahan PROPN cjel-3603 447 2 - - PUNCT cjel-3603 447 3 macro-[final macro-[final PROPN cjel-3603 447 4 6 6 NUM cjel-3603 447 5 - - SYM cjel-3603 447 6 20 20 NUM cjel-3603 447 7 ] ] PUNCT cjel-3603 447 8 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 447 9 do do AUX cjel-3603 447 10 not not PART cjel-3603 447 11 delete delete VERB cjel-3603 447 12 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 447 13 6/22/2015 6/22/2015 NUM cjel-3603 447 14 11:53 11:53 NUM cjel-3603 447 15 pm pm NOUN cjel-3603 447 16 380 380 NUM cjel-3603 447 17 columbia columbia PROPN cjel-3603 447 18 journal journal PROPN cjel-3603 447 19 of of ADP cjel-3603 447 20 environmental environmental ADJ cjel-3603 447 21 law law NOUN cjel-3603 447 22 [ [ X cjel-3603 447 23 vol vol NOUN cjel-3603 447 24 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 448 1 40:2 40:2 NUM cjel-3603 448 2 approximately approximately ADV cjel-3603 448 3 one one NUM cjel-3603 448 4 hundred hundred NUM cjel-3603 448 5 feet foot NOUN cjel-3603 448 6 into into ADP cjel-3603 448 7 the the PRON cjel-3603 448 8 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 448 9 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 448 10 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 449 1 [ [ X cjel-3603 449 2 r]iver r]iver PROPN cjel-3603 449 3 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 449 4 ”114 ”114 PUNCT cjel-3603 449 5 in in ADP cjel-3603 449 6 1992 1992 NUM cjel-3603 449 7 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 449 8 the the DET cjel-3603 449 9 united united PROPN cjel-3603 449 10 states states PROPN cjel-3603 449 11 acquired acquire VERB cjel-3603 449 12 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 449 13 paid pay VERB cjel-3603 449 14 for for ADP cjel-3603 449 15 just just ADV cjel-3603 449 16 30.54 30.54 NUM cjel-3603 449 17 of of ADP cjel-3603 449 18 the the DET cjel-3603 449 19 landowners landowner NOUN cjel-3603 449 20 ’ ' PUNCT cjel-3603 449 21 over over ADP cjel-3603 449 22 132 132 NUM cjel-3603 449 23 acres acre NOUN cjel-3603 449 24 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 449 25 which which PRON cjel-3603 449 26 was be AUX cjel-3603 449 27 used use VERB cjel-3603 449 28 in in ADP cjel-3603 449 29 constructing construct VERB cjel-3603 449 30 a a DET cjel-3603 449 31 dam dam NOUN cjel-3603 449 32 on on ADP cjel-3603 449 33 the the DET cjel-3603 449 34 river.115 river.115 NOUN cjel-3603 449 35 the the DET cjel-3603 449 36 government government NOUN cjel-3603 449 37 did do AUX cjel-3603 449 38 not not PART cjel-3603 449 39 acquire acquire VERB cjel-3603 449 40 the the DET cjel-3603 449 41 remaining remain VERB cjel-3603 449 42 land land NOUN cjel-3603 449 43 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 449 44 facility facility NOUN cjel-3603 449 45 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 449 46 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 449 47 tipple tipple NOUN cjel-3603 449 48 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 449 49 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 449 50 the the DET cjel-3603 449 51 army army NOUN cjel-3603 449 52 corps corps PROPN cjel-3603 449 53 of of ADP cjel-3603 449 54 engineers engineer NOUN cjel-3603 449 55 subsequently subsequently ADV cjel-3603 449 56 prohibited prohibit VERB cjel-3603 449 57 the the DET cjel-3603 449 58 coal coal NOUN cjel-3603 449 59 loading loading NOUN cjel-3603 449 60 operation operation NOUN cjel-3603 449 61 all all DET cjel-3603 449 62 together.116 together.116 ADP cjel-3603 449 63 the the DET cjel-3603 449 64 corps corps NOUN cjel-3603 449 65 claimed claim VERB cjel-3603 449 66 that that SCONJ cjel-3603 449 67 the the DET cjel-3603 449 68 tipple tipple NOUN cjel-3603 449 69 ’s ’s PART cjel-3603 449 70 close close ADJ cjel-3603 449 71 proximity proximity NOUN cjel-3603 449 72 to to ADP cjel-3603 449 73 the the DET cjel-3603 449 74 dam dam NOUN cjel-3603 449 75 posed pose VERB cjel-3603 449 76 a a DET cjel-3603 449 77 safety safety NOUN cjel-3603 449 78 hazard hazard NOUN cjel-3603 449 79 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 449 80 a a DET cjel-3603 449 81 hazard hazard NOUN cjel-3603 449 82 to to AUX cjel-3603 449 83 navigation.117 navigation.117 NUM cjel-3603 449 84 the the DET cjel-3603 449 85 court court NOUN cjel-3603 449 86 found find VERB cjel-3603 449 87 that that SCONJ cjel-3603 449 88 the the DET cjel-3603 449 89 corps corp NOUN cjel-3603 449 90 ’ ' PUNCT cjel-3603 449 91 decision decision NOUN cjel-3603 449 92 was be AUX cjel-3603 449 93 not not PART cjel-3603 449 94 a a DET cjel-3603 449 95 taking taking NOUN cjel-3603 449 96 — — PUNCT cjel-3603 449 97 rather rather ADV cjel-3603 449 98 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 449 99 it it PRON cjel-3603 449 100 was be AUX cjel-3603 449 101 merely merely ADV cjel-3603 449 102 an an DET cjel-3603 449 103 exercise exercise NOUN cjel-3603 449 104 of of ADP cjel-3603 449 105 the the DET cjel-3603 449 106 navigational navigational ADJ cjel-3603 449 107 servitude.118 servitude.118 PRON cjel-3603 449 108 d. d. PROPN cjel-3603 449 109 reformulating reformulate VERB cjel-3603 449 110 the the DET cjel-3603 449 111 doctrine doctrine NOUN cjel-3603 449 112 draconian draconian ADJ cjel-3603 449 113 results result NOUN cjel-3603 449 114 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 449 115 such such ADJ cjel-3603 449 116 as as ADP cjel-3603 449 117 those those PRON cjel-3603 449 118 in in ADP cjel-3603 449 119 30.54 30.54 NUM cjel-3603 449 120 acres acre NOUN cjel-3603 449 121 of of ADP cjel-3603 449 122 land land NOUN cjel-3603 449 123 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 449 124 rands rand NOUN cjel-3603 449 125 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 449 126 can can AUX cjel-3603 449 127 be be AUX cjel-3603 449 128 avoided avoid VERB cjel-3603 449 129 by by ADP cjel-3603 449 130 viewing view VERB cjel-3603 449 131 the the DET cjel-3603 449 132 navigational navigational ADJ cjel-3603 449 133 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 449 134 not not PART cjel-3603 449 135 as as ADP cjel-3603 449 136 an an DET cjel-3603 449 137 absolute absolute ADJ cjel-3603 449 138 bar bar NOUN cjel-3603 449 139 to to ADP cjel-3603 449 140 the the DET cjel-3603 449 141 takings taking NOUN cjel-3603 449 142 claims claim NOUN cjel-3603 449 143 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 449 144 but but CCONJ cjel-3603 449 145 as as ADP cjel-3603 449 146 one one NUM cjel-3603 449 147 factor factor NOUN cjel-3603 449 148 in in ADP cjel-3603 449 149 an an DET cjel-3603 449 150 ad ad NOUN cjel-3603 449 151 - - PUNCT cjel-3603 449 152 hoc hoc ADJ cjel-3603 449 153 analysis analysis NOUN cjel-3603 449 154 of of ADP cjel-3603 449 155 a a DET cjel-3603 449 156 takings taking NOUN cjel-3603 449 157 claim claim NOUN cjel-3603 449 158 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 450 1 to to PART cjel-3603 450 2 do do VERB cjel-3603 450 3 this this PRON cjel-3603 450 4 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 450 5 courts court NOUN cjel-3603 450 6 must must AUX cjel-3603 450 7 move move VERB cjel-3603 450 8 away away ADV cjel-3603 450 9 from from ADP cjel-3603 450 10 the the DET cjel-3603 450 11 lucas lucas NOUN cjel-3603 450 12 analysis analysis NOUN cjel-3603 450 13 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 450 14 toward toward ADP cjel-3603 450 15 the the DET cjel-3603 450 16 adhoc adhoc PROPN cjel-3603 450 17 penn penn PROPN cjel-3603 450 18 central central ADJ cjel-3603 450 19 analysis,119 analysis,119 PROPN cjel-3603 450 20 while while SCONJ cjel-3603 450 21 also also ADV cjel-3603 450 22 embracing embrace VERB cjel-3603 450 23 the the DET cjel-3603 450 24 words word NOUN cjel-3603 450 25 in in ADP cjel-3603 450 26 kaiser kaiser PROPN cjel-3603 450 27 aetna aetna PROPN cjel-3603 450 28 that that SCONJ cjel-3603 450 29 the the DET cjel-3603 450 30 supreme supreme PROPN cjel-3603 450 31 court court PROPN cjel-3603 450 32 “ " PUNCT cjel-3603 450 33 has have AUX cjel-3603 450 34 never never ADV cjel-3603 450 35 held hold VERB cjel-3603 450 36 that that SCONJ cjel-3603 450 37 the the DET cjel-3603 450 38 navigational navigational ADJ cjel-3603 450 39 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 450 40 creates create VERB cjel-3603 450 41 a a DET cjel-3603 450 42 blanket blanket NOUN cjel-3603 450 43 exception exception NOUN cjel-3603 450 44 to to ADP cjel-3603 450 45 the the DET cjel-3603 450 46 takings taking NOUN cjel-3603 450 47 clause clause NOUN cjel-3603 450 48 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 450 49 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 450 50 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 451 1 .”120 .”120 PUNCT cjel-3603 452 1 in in ADP cjel-3603 452 2 kaiser kaiser PROPN cjel-3603 452 3 aetna aetna PROPN cjel-3603 452 4 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 452 5 decided decide VERB cjel-3603 452 6 shortly shortly ADV cjel-3603 452 7 after after ADP cjel-3603 452 8 penn penn PROPN cjel-3603 452 9 central central PROPN cjel-3603 452 10 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 452 11 the the DET cjel-3603 452 12 court court NOUN cjel-3603 452 13 looked look VERB cjel-3603 452 14 at at ADP cjel-3603 452 15 many many ADJ cjel-3603 452 16 factors factor NOUN cjel-3603 452 17 in in ADP cjel-3603 452 18 deciding decide VERB cjel-3603 452 19 that that SCONJ cjel-3603 452 20 the the DET cjel-3603 452 21 government government NOUN cjel-3603 452 22 ’s ’s PART cjel-3603 452 23 actions action NOUN cjel-3603 452 24 amounted amount VERB cjel-3603 452 25 to to ADP cjel-3603 452 26 a a DET cjel-3603 452 27 taking.121 taking.121 NOUN cjel-3603 452 28 this this DET cjel-3603 452 29 analysis analysis NOUN cjel-3603 452 30 allowed allow VERB cjel-3603 452 31 the the DET cjel-3603 452 32 court court NOUN cjel-3603 452 33 to to PART cjel-3603 452 34 consider consider VERB cjel-3603 452 35 the the DET cjel-3603 452 36 context context NOUN cjel-3603 452 37 in in ADP cjel-3603 452 38 which which PRON cjel-3603 452 39 the the DET cjel-3603 452 40 navigational navigational ADJ cjel-3603 452 41 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 452 42 was be AUX cjel-3603 452 43 being be AUX cjel-3603 452 44 exercised exercise VERB cjel-3603 452 45 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 453 1 specifically specifically ADV cjel-3603 453 2 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 453 3 the the DET cjel-3603 453 4 waterway waterway NOUN cjel-3603 453 5 in in ADP cjel-3603 453 6 question question NOUN cjel-3603 453 7 was be AUX cjel-3603 453 8 not not PART cjel-3603 453 9 always always ADV cjel-3603 453 10 subject subject ADJ cjel-3603 453 11 to to ADP cjel-3603 453 12 the the DET cjel-3603 453 13 navigational navigational ADJ cjel-3603 453 14 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 453 15 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 453 16 but but CCONJ cjel-3603 453 17 instead instead ADV cjel-3603 453 18 was be AUX cjel-3603 453 19 a a DET cjel-3603 453 20 private private ADJ cjel-3603 453 21 pond pond NOUN cjel-3603 453 22 that that SCONJ cjel-3603 453 23 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 453 24 through through ADP cjel-3603 453 25 the the DET cjel-3603 453 26 landowners landowner NOUN cjel-3603 453 27 ’ ’ PART cjel-3603 453 28 dredging dredging NOUN cjel-3603 453 29 efforts effort NOUN cjel-3603 453 30 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 453 31 became become VERB cjel-3603 453 32 connected connected ADJ cjel-3603 453 33 to to ADP cjel-3603 453 34 navigable navigable ADJ cjel-3603 453 35 waterways.122 waterways.122 PROPN cjel-3603 453 36 by by ADP cjel-3603 453 37 attempting attempt VERB cjel-3603 453 38 to to PART cjel-3603 453 39 create create VERB cjel-3603 453 40 a a DET cjel-3603 453 41 public public ADJ cjel-3603 453 42 right right NOUN cjel-3603 453 43 of of ADP cjel-3603 453 44 access access NOUN cjel-3603 453 45 to to ADP cjel-3603 453 46 the the DET cjel-3603 453 47 waterway waterway NOUN cjel-3603 453 48 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 453 49 the the DET cjel-3603 453 50 government government NOUN cjel-3603 453 51 went go VERB cjel-3603 453 52 “ " PUNCT cjel-3603 453 53 so so ADV cjel-3603 453 54 far far ADV cjel-3603 453 55 beyond beyond ADP cjel-3603 453 56 ordinary ordinary ADJ cjel-3603 453 57 114 114 NUM cjel-3603 453 58 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 454 1 i i PRON cjel-3603 454 2 d. d. PROPN cjel-3603 454 3 115 115 NUM cjel-3603 454 4 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 455 1 i i PRON cjel-3603 455 2 d. d. PROPN cjel-3603 455 3 116 116 NUM cjel-3603 455 4 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 456 1 i i PRON cjel-3603 456 2 d. d. PROPN cjel-3603 456 3 at at ADP cjel-3603 456 4 792–93 792–93 PROPN cjel-3603 456 5 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 457 1 117 117 NUM cjel-3603 457 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 458 1 i i PRON cjel-3603 458 2 d. d. PROPN cjel-3603 458 3 at at ADP cjel-3603 458 4 793 793 NUM cjel-3603 458 5 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 458 6 118 118 NUM cjel-3603 458 7 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 459 1 i i PRON cjel-3603 459 2 d. d. PROPN cjel-3603 459 3 at at ADP cjel-3603 459 4 795 795 NUM cjel-3603 459 5 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 460 1 119 119 NUM cjel-3603 460 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 460 3 penn penn PROPN cjel-3603 460 4 cent cent PROPN cjel-3603 460 5 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 461 1 transp transp PROPN cjel-3603 461 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 462 1 co. co. PROPN cjel-3603 462 2 v. v. ADP cjel-3603 462 3 city city PROPN cjel-3603 462 4 of of ADP cjel-3603 462 5 new new PROPN cjel-3603 462 6 york york PROPN cjel-3603 462 7 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 462 8 438 438 NUM cjel-3603 462 9 u.s u.s PROPN cjel-3603 462 10 . . PROPN cjel-3603 462 11 104 104 NUM cjel-3603 462 12 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 462 13 124 124 NUM cjel-3603 462 14 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 462 15 1978 1978 NUM cjel-3603 462 16 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 462 17 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 463 1 120 120 NUM cjel-3603 463 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 464 1 kaiser kaiser PROPN cjel-3603 464 2 aetna aetna PROPN cjel-3603 464 3 v. v. PROPN cjel-3603 464 4 united united PROPN cjel-3603 464 5 states states PROPN cjel-3603 464 6 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 464 7 444 444 NUM cjel-3603 464 8 u.s u.s PROPN cjel-3603 464 9 . . PROPN cjel-3603 464 10 164 164 NUM cjel-3603 464 11 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 464 12 172 172 NUM cjel-3603 464 13 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 464 14 1979 1979 NUM cjel-3603 464 15 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 464 16 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 465 1 121 121 NUM cjel-3603 465 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 466 1 i i PRON cjel-3603 466 2 d. d. PROPN cjel-3603 466 3 at at ADP cjel-3603 466 4 178 178 NUM cjel-3603 466 5 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 466 6 “ " PUNCT cjel-3603 466 7 more more ADJ cjel-3603 466 8 than than ADP cjel-3603 466 9 one one NUM cjel-3603 466 10 factor factor NOUN cjel-3603 466 11 contributes contribute VERB cjel-3603 466 12 to to ADP cjel-3603 466 13 this this DET cjel-3603 466 14 result result NOUN cjel-3603 466 15 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 466 16 ” " PUNCT cjel-3603 466 17 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 466 18 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 467 1 122 122 NUM cjel-3603 467 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 468 1 i i PRON cjel-3603 468 2 d. d. PROPN cjel-3603 468 3 at at ADP cjel-3603 468 4 166–70 166–70 PROPN cjel-3603 468 5 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 469 1 monahan monahan PROPN cjel-3603 469 2 - - PUNCT cjel-3603 469 3 macro-[final macro-[final PROPN cjel-3603 469 4 6 6 NUM cjel-3603 469 5 - - SYM cjel-3603 469 6 20 20 NUM cjel-3603 469 7 ] ] PUNCT cjel-3603 469 8 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 469 9 do do AUX cjel-3603 469 10 not not PART cjel-3603 469 11 delete delete VERB cjel-3603 469 12 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 469 13 6/22/2015 6/22/2015 NUM cjel-3603 469 14 11:53 11:53 NUM cjel-3603 469 15 pm pm NOUN cjel-3603 469 16 2015 2015 NUM cjel-3603 469 17 ] ] PUNCT cjel-3603 469 18 the the DET cjel-3603 469 19 navigational navigational ADJ cjel-3603 469 20 servitude servitude ADJ cjel-3603 469 21 381 381 NUM cjel-3603 469 22 regulation regulation NOUN cjel-3603 469 23 or or CCONJ cjel-3603 469 24 improvement improvement NOUN cjel-3603 469 25 for for ADP cjel-3603 469 26 navigation navigation NOUN cjel-3603 469 27 as as SCONJ cjel-3603 469 28 to to PART cjel-3603 469 29 amount amount VERB cjel-3603 469 30 to to ADP cjel-3603 469 31 a a DET cjel-3603 469 32 taking taking NOUN cjel-3603 469 33 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 469 34 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 469 35 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 470 1 .”123 .”123 PUNCT cjel-3603 471 1 several several ADJ cjel-3603 471 2 courts court NOUN cjel-3603 471 3 have have AUX cjel-3603 471 4 followed follow VERB cjel-3603 471 5 the the DET cjel-3603 471 6 ruling ruling NOUN cjel-3603 471 7 in in ADP cjel-3603 471 8 kaiser kaiser PROPN cjel-3603 471 9 aetna aetna PROPN cjel-3603 471 10 by by ADP cjel-3603 471 11 not not PART cjel-3603 471 12 allowing allow VERB cjel-3603 471 13 the the DET cjel-3603 471 14 government government NOUN cjel-3603 471 15 to to PART cjel-3603 471 16 invoke invoke VERB cjel-3603 471 17 the the DET cjel-3603 471 18 navigational navigational ADJ cjel-3603 471 19 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 471 20 as as ADP cjel-3603 471 21 a a DET cjel-3603 471 22 complete complete ADJ cjel-3603 471 23 defense defense NOUN cjel-3603 471 24 to to ADP cjel-3603 471 25 a a DET cjel-3603 471 26 takings taking NOUN cjel-3603 471 27 claim.124 claim.124 NOUN cjel-3603 471 28 for for ADP cjel-3603 471 29 example example NOUN cjel-3603 471 30 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 471 31 in in ADP cjel-3603 471 32 laney laney PROPN cjel-3603 471 33 v. v. PROPN cjel-3603 471 34 united united PROPN cjel-3603 471 35 states states PROPN cjel-3603 471 36 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 471 37 the the DET cjel-3603 471 38 u.s u.s PROPN cjel-3603 471 39 . . PROPN cjel-3603 471 40 army army PROPN cjel-3603 471 41 corps corps PROPN cjel-3603 471 42 of of ADP cjel-3603 471 43 engineers engineer NOUN cjel-3603 471 44 denied deny VERB cjel-3603 471 45 an an DET cjel-3603 471 46 application application NOUN cjel-3603 471 47 by by ADP cjel-3603 471 48 a a DET cjel-3603 471 49 landowner landowner NOUN cjel-3603 471 50 to to PART cjel-3603 471 51 build build VERB cjel-3603 471 52 a a DET cjel-3603 471 53 concrete concrete ADJ cjel-3603 471 54 pier pier NOUN cjel-3603 471 55 on on ADP cjel-3603 471 56 his his PRON cjel-3603 471 57 island island NOUN cjel-3603 472 1 property.125 property.125 NOUN cjel-3603 472 2 such such DET cjel-3603 472 3 a a DET cjel-3603 472 4 pier pier NOUN cjel-3603 472 5 would would AUX cjel-3603 472 6 be be AUX cjel-3603 472 7 the the DET cjel-3603 472 8 landowner landowner NOUN cjel-3603 472 9 ’s ’s PART cjel-3603 472 10 only only ADJ cjel-3603 472 11 means mean NOUN cjel-3603 472 12 of of ADP cjel-3603 472 13 accessing access VERB cjel-3603 472 14 the the DET cjel-3603 472 15 island island NOUN cjel-3603 472 16 ’s ’s PART cjel-3603 472 17 fast fast ADJ cjel-3603 472 18 lands.126 lands.126 NOUN cjel-3603 472 19 the the DET cjel-3603 472 20 court court NOUN cjel-3603 472 21 rejected reject VERB cjel-3603 472 22 the the DET cjel-3603 472 23 government government NOUN cjel-3603 472 24 ’s ’s PART cjel-3603 472 25 “ " PUNCT cjel-3603 472 26 boldly boldly ADV cjel-3603 472 27 assert[ed assert[ed VERB cjel-3603 472 28 ] ] PUNCT cjel-3603 472 29 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 472 30 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 472 31 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 473 1 right right ADJ cjel-3603 473 2 pursuant pursuant ADV cjel-3603 473 3 to to ADP cjel-3603 473 4 the the DET cjel-3603 473 5 navigational navigational ADJ cjel-3603 473 6 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 473 7 to to PART cjel-3603 473 8 prevent prevent VERB cjel-3603 473 9 any any DET cjel-3603 473 10 use use NOUN cjel-3603 473 11 whatsoever whatsoever ADV cjel-3603 473 12 of of ADP cjel-3603 473 13 the the DET cjel-3603 473 14 island island NOUN cjel-3603 473 15 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 473 16 through through ADP cjel-3603 473 17 its its PRON cjel-3603 473 18 control control NOUN cjel-3603 473 19 over over ADP cjel-3603 473 20 the the DET cjel-3603 473 21 only only ADJ cjel-3603 473 22 possible possible ADJ cjel-3603 473 23 means mean NOUN cjel-3603 473 24 of of ADP cjel-3603 473 25 access access NOUN cjel-3603 473 26 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 473 27 ”127 ”127 PUNCT cjel-3603 474 1 indeed indeed ADV cjel-3603 474 2 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 474 3 the the DET cjel-3603 474 4 court court NOUN cjel-3603 474 5 reasoned reason VERB cjel-3603 474 6 that that SCONJ cjel-3603 474 7 if if SCONJ cjel-3603 474 8 allowed allow VERB cjel-3603 474 9 to to PART cjel-3603 474 10 use use VERB cjel-3603 474 11 the the DET cjel-3603 474 12 navigational navigational ADJ cjel-3603 474 13 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 474 14 in in ADP cjel-3603 474 15 this this DET cjel-3603 474 16 way way NOUN cjel-3603 474 17 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 474 18 the the DET cjel-3603 474 19 government government NOUN cjel-3603 474 20 could could AUX cjel-3603 474 21 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 474 22 in in ADP cjel-3603 474 23 the the DET cjel-3603 474 24 name name NOUN cjel-3603 474 25 of of ADP cjel-3603 474 26 navigation navigation NOUN cjel-3603 474 27 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 474 28 block block VERB cjel-3603 474 29 all all DET cjel-3603 474 30 access access NOUN cjel-3603 474 31 to to ADP cjel-3603 474 32 islands island NOUN cjel-3603 474 33 located locate VERB cjel-3603 474 34 totally totally ADV cjel-3603 474 35 within within ADP cjel-3603 474 36 navigable navigable ADJ cjel-3603 474 37 waterways.128 waterways.128 NOUN cjel-3603 474 38 as as ADP cjel-3603 474 39 a a DET cjel-3603 474 40 result result NOUN cjel-3603 474 41 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 474 42 the the DET cjel-3603 474 43 government government NOUN cjel-3603 474 44 could could AUX cjel-3603 474 45 condemn condemn VERB cjel-3603 474 46 islands island NOUN cjel-3603 474 47 for for ADP cjel-3603 474 48 use use NOUN cjel-3603 474 49 as as ADP cjel-3603 474 50 scenic scenic ADJ cjel-3603 474 51 preserves preserve NOUN cjel-3603 474 52 without without ADP cjel-3603 474 53 paying pay VERB cjel-3603 474 54 the the DET cjel-3603 474 55 required require VERB cjel-3603 474 56 just just ADV cjel-3603 474 57 compensation.129 compensation.129 PROPN cjel-3603 474 58 the the DET cjel-3603 474 59 court court NOUN cjel-3603 474 60 of of ADP cjel-3603 474 61 claims claim NOUN cjel-3603 474 62 was be AUX cjel-3603 474 63 unwilling unwilling ADJ cjel-3603 474 64 to to PART cjel-3603 474 65 allow allow VERB cjel-3603 474 66 such such ADJ cjel-3603 474 67 takings taking NOUN cjel-3603 474 68 to to PART cjel-3603 474 69 occur occur VERB cjel-3603 474 70 without without ADP cjel-3603 474 71 compensation compensation NOUN cjel-3603 474 72 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 474 73 even even ADV cjel-3603 474 74 in in ADP cjel-3603 474 75 the the DET cjel-3603 474 76 face face NOUN cjel-3603 474 77 of of ADP cjel-3603 474 78 the the DET cjel-3603 474 79 navigational navigational ADJ cjel-3603 474 80 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 474 81 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 475 1 if if SCONJ cjel-3603 475 2 more more ADJ cjel-3603 475 3 courts court NOUN cjel-3603 475 4 embraced embrace VERB cjel-3603 475 5 the the DET cjel-3603 475 6 language language NOUN cjel-3603 475 7 of of ADP cjel-3603 475 8 kaiser kaiser PROPN cjel-3603 475 9 aetna aetna PROPN cjel-3603 475 10 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 475 11 the the DET cjel-3603 475 12 navigational navigational ADJ cjel-3603 475 13 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 475 14 could could AUX cjel-3603 475 15 be be AUX cjel-3603 475 16 reined rein VERB cjel-3603 475 17 in in ADP cjel-3603 475 18 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 475 19 used use VERB cjel-3603 475 20 more more ADV cjel-3603 475 21 appropriately appropriately ADV cjel-3603 475 22 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 476 1 by by ADP cjel-3603 476 2 not not PART cjel-3603 476 3 viewing view VERB cjel-3603 476 4 it it PRON cjel-3603 476 5 as as ADP cjel-3603 476 6 a a DET cjel-3603 476 7 blanket blanket NOUN cjel-3603 476 8 exception exception NOUN cjel-3603 476 9 to to ADP cjel-3603 476 10 the the DET cjel-3603 476 11 takings taking NOUN cjel-3603 476 12 clause clause NOUN cjel-3603 476 13 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 476 14 use use NOUN cjel-3603 476 15 of of ADP cjel-3603 476 16 the the DET cjel-3603 476 17 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 476 18 could could AUX cjel-3603 476 19 then then ADV cjel-3603 476 20 be be AUX cjel-3603 476 21 analyzed analyze VERB cjel-3603 476 22 in in ADP cjel-3603 476 23 a a DET cjel-3603 476 24 more more ADV cjel-3603 476 25 nuanced nuanced ADJ cjel-3603 476 26 way way NOUN cjel-3603 476 27 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 477 1 further far ADV cjel-3603 477 2 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 477 3 the the DET cjel-3603 477 4 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 477 5 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 477 6 the the DET cjel-3603 477 7 power power NOUN cjel-3603 477 8 of of ADP cjel-3603 477 9 the the DET cjel-3603 477 10 federal federal ADJ cjel-3603 477 11 government government NOUN cjel-3603 477 12 to to PART cjel-3603 477 13 regulate regulate VERB cjel-3603 477 14 navigation navigation NOUN cjel-3603 477 15 as as ADP cjel-3603 477 16 part part NOUN cjel-3603 477 17 of of ADP cjel-3603 477 18 its its PRON cjel-3603 477 19 power power NOUN cjel-3603 477 20 over over ADP cjel-3603 477 21 commerce commerce NOUN cjel-3603 477 22 would would AUX cjel-3603 477 23 easily easily ADV cjel-3603 477 24 fall fall VERB cjel-3603 477 25 into into ADP cjel-3603 477 26 the the DET cjel-3603 477 27 holistic holistic ADJ cjel-3603 477 28 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 477 29 context context VERB cjel-3603 477 30 specific specific ADJ cjel-3603 477 31 framework framework NOUN cjel-3603 477 32 of of ADP cjel-3603 477 33 penn penn PROPN cjel-3603 477 34 central central PROPN cjel-3603 477 35 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 478 1 123 123 NUM cjel-3603 478 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 479 1 i i PRON cjel-3603 479 2 d. d. PROPN cjel-3603 479 3 at at ADP cjel-3603 479 4 178 178 NUM cjel-3603 479 5 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 480 1 124 124 NUM cjel-3603 480 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 481 1 see see VERB cjel-3603 481 2 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 481 3 e.g. e.g. ADV cjel-3603 481 4 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 481 5 fla fla PROPN cjel-3603 481 6 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 482 1 rock rock PROPN cjel-3603 482 2 indus indus PROPN cjel-3603 482 3 . . PROPN cjel-3603 482 4 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 482 5 inc inc PROPN cjel-3603 482 6 . . PROPN cjel-3603 483 1 v. v. PROPN cjel-3603 483 2 united united PROPN cjel-3603 483 3 states states PROPN cjel-3603 483 4 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 483 5 791 791 NUM cjel-3603 483 6 f.2d f.2d ADP cjel-3603 483 7 893 893 NUM cjel-3603 483 8 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 483 9 900 900 NUM cjel-3603 483 10 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 483 11 fed fed PROPN cjel-3603 483 12 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 483 13 cir cir PROPN cjel-3603 483 14 . . PROPN cjel-3603 483 15 1986 1986 NUM cjel-3603 483 16 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 484 1 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 484 2 “ " PUNCT cjel-3603 484 3 [ [ X cjel-3603 484 4 t]he t]he ADJ cjel-3603 484 5 effect effect NOUN cjel-3603 484 6 of of ADP cjel-3603 484 7 kaiser kaiser PROPN cjel-3603 484 8 aetna aetna PROPN cjel-3603 484 9 v. v. PROPN cjel-3603 484 10 united united PROPN cjel-3603 484 11 states states PROPN cjel-3603 484 12 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 484 13 444 444 NUM cjel-3603 484 14 u.s u.s PROPN cjel-3603 484 15 . . PROPN cjel-3603 484 16 164 164 NUM cjel-3603 484 17 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 484 18 1979 1979 NUM cjel-3603 484 19 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 484 20 is be AUX cjel-3603 484 21 that that SCONJ cjel-3603 484 22 “ " PUNCT cjel-3603 484 23 the the DET cjel-3603 484 24 old old ADJ cjel-3603 484 25 ‘ ' PUNCT cjel-3603 484 26 navigation navigation NOUN cjel-3603 484 27 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 484 28 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 484 29 ’ ' PUNCT cjel-3603 484 30 often often ADV cjel-3603 484 31 used use VERB cjel-3603 484 32 to to PART cjel-3603 484 33 excuse excuse VERB cjel-3603 484 34 what what PRON cjel-3603 484 35 looked look VERB cjel-3603 484 36 suspiciously suspiciously ADV cjel-3603 484 37 like like ADP cjel-3603 484 38 takings taking NOUN cjel-3603 484 39 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 484 40 is be AUX cjel-3603 484 41 no no ADV cjel-3603 484 42 longer long ADV cjel-3603 484 43 available available ADJ cjel-3603 484 44 for for ADP cjel-3603 484 45 that that DET cjel-3603 484 46 duty duty NOUN cjel-3603 484 47 in in ADP cjel-3603 484 48 regulatory regulatory ADJ cjel-3603 484 49 takings taking NOUN cjel-3603 484 50 cases case NOUN cjel-3603 484 51 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 484 52 ” " PUNCT cjel-3603 484 53 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 484 54 ; ; PUNCT cjel-3603 485 1 laney laney PROPN cjel-3603 485 2 v. v. PROPN cjel-3603 485 3 united united PROPN cjel-3603 485 4 states states PROPN cjel-3603 485 5 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 485 6 228 228 NUM cjel-3603 485 7 ct ct NOUN cjel-3603 485 8 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 485 9 cl cl NOUN cjel-3603 485 10 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 486 1 519 519 NUM cjel-3603 486 2 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 486 3 525–26 525–26 NUM cjel-3603 486 4 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 486 5 ct ct PROPN cjel-3603 486 6 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 486 7 cl cl NOUN cjel-3603 486 8 . . PROPN cjel-3603 486 9 1981 1981 NUM cjel-3603 486 10 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 486 11 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 486 12 kaiser kaiser PROPN cjel-3603 486 13 aetna aetna PROPN cjel-3603 486 14 “ " PUNCT cjel-3603 486 15 is be AUX cjel-3603 486 16 helpful helpful ADJ cjel-3603 486 17 in in ADP cjel-3603 486 18 its its PRON cjel-3603 486 19 indication indication NOUN cjel-3603 486 20 that that SCONJ cjel-3603 486 21 there there PRON cjel-3603 486 22 is be VERB cjel-3603 486 23 no no DET cjel-3603 486 24 special special ADJ cjel-3603 486 25 mystique mystique NOUN cjel-3603 486 26 in in ADP cjel-3603 486 27 exercise exercise NOUN cjel-3603 486 28 of of ADP cjel-3603 486 29 the the DET cjel-3603 486 30 navigation navigation NOUN cjel-3603 486 31 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 486 32 that that PRON cjel-3603 486 33 permits permit VERB cjel-3603 486 34 uncompensated uncompensated ADJ cjel-3603 486 35 takings taking NOUN cjel-3603 486 36 when when SCONJ cjel-3603 486 37 compensation compensation NOUN cjel-3603 486 38 would would AUX cjel-3603 486 39 be be AUX cjel-3603 486 40 required require VERB cjel-3603 486 41 in in ADP cjel-3603 486 42 other other ADJ cjel-3603 486 43 contexts contexts NOUN cjel-3603 486 44 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 486 45 ” " PUNCT cjel-3603 486 46 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 486 47 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 487 1 125 125 NUM cjel-3603 487 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 488 1 laney laney PROPN cjel-3603 488 2 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 488 3 228 228 NUM cjel-3603 488 4 ct ct NOUN cjel-3603 488 5 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 488 6 cl cl NOUN cjel-3603 488 7 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 489 1 at at ADP cjel-3603 489 2 521 521 NUM cjel-3603 489 3 . . NOUN cjel-3603 489 4 126 126 NUM cjel-3603 489 5 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 490 1 i i PRON cjel-3603 490 2 d. d. PROPN cjel-3603 490 3 at at ADP cjel-3603 490 4 525 525 NUM cjel-3603 490 5 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 491 1 127 127 NUM cjel-3603 491 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 492 1 i i PRON cjel-3603 492 2 d. d. PROPN cjel-3603 492 3 at at ADP cjel-3603 492 4 522 522 NUM cjel-3603 492 5 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 493 1 128 128 NUM cjel-3603 493 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 494 1 i i PRON cjel-3603 494 2 d. d. PROPN cjel-3603 494 3 at at ADP cjel-3603 494 4 523 523 NUM cjel-3603 494 5 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 495 1 129 129 NUM cjel-3603 495 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 496 1 i i PRON cjel-3603 496 2 d. d. PROPN cjel-3603 496 3 at at ADP cjel-3603 496 4 526 526 NUM cjel-3603 496 5 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 497 1 monahan monahan PROPN cjel-3603 497 2 - - PUNCT cjel-3603 497 3 macro-[final macro-[final PROPN cjel-3603 497 4 6 6 NUM cjel-3603 497 5 - - SYM cjel-3603 497 6 20 20 NUM cjel-3603 497 7 ] ] PUNCT cjel-3603 497 8 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 497 9 do do AUX cjel-3603 497 10 not not PART cjel-3603 497 11 delete delete VERB cjel-3603 497 12 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 497 13 6/22/2015 6/22/2015 NUM cjel-3603 497 14 11:53 11:53 NUM cjel-3603 497 15 pm pm NOUN cjel-3603 497 16 382 382 NUM cjel-3603 497 17 columbia columbia PROPN cjel-3603 497 18 journal journal PROPN cjel-3603 497 19 of of ADP cjel-3603 497 20 environmental environmental ADJ cjel-3603 497 21 law law NOUN cjel-3603 497 22 [ [ X cjel-3603 497 23 vol vol NOUN cjel-3603 497 24 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 498 1 40:2 40:2 NOUN cjel-3603 498 2 for for ADP cjel-3603 498 3 example example NOUN cjel-3603 498 4 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 498 5 if if SCONJ cjel-3603 498 6 the the DET cjel-3603 498 7 third third ADJ cjel-3603 498 8 circuit circuit NOUN cjel-3603 498 9 in in ADP cjel-3603 498 10 30.54 30.54 NUM cjel-3603 498 11 acres acre NOUN cjel-3603 498 12 of of ADP cjel-3603 498 13 land land NOUN cjel-3603 498 14 had have AUX cjel-3603 498 15 not not PART cjel-3603 498 16 treated treat VERB cjel-3603 498 17 the the DET cjel-3603 498 18 navigational navigational ADJ cjel-3603 498 19 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 498 20 as as ADP cjel-3603 498 21 an an DET cjel-3603 498 22 absolute absolute ADJ cjel-3603 498 23 defense defense NOUN cjel-3603 498 24 to to ADP cjel-3603 498 25 takings taking NOUN cjel-3603 498 26 claims claim NOUN cjel-3603 498 27 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 498 28 it it PRON cjel-3603 498 29 could could AUX cjel-3603 498 30 have have AUX cjel-3603 498 31 proceeded proceed VERB cjel-3603 498 32 to to ADP cjel-3603 498 33 an an DET cjel-3603 498 34 analysis analysis NOUN cjel-3603 498 35 of of ADP cjel-3603 498 36 the the DET cjel-3603 498 37 facts fact NOUN cjel-3603 498 38 under under ADP cjel-3603 498 39 this this DET cjel-3603 498 40 framework framework NOUN cjel-3603 498 41 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 499 1 the the DET cjel-3603 499 2 court court NOUN cjel-3603 499 3 could could AUX cjel-3603 499 4 look look VERB cjel-3603 499 5 at at ADP cjel-3603 499 6 the the DET cjel-3603 499 7 economic economic ADJ cjel-3603 499 8 impact impact NOUN cjel-3603 499 9 of of ADP cjel-3603 499 10 the the DET cjel-3603 499 11 corps corp NOUN cjel-3603 499 12 ’ ' PUNCT cjel-3603 499 13 ruling ruling NOUN cjel-3603 499 14 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 499 15 see see VERB cjel-3603 499 16 if if SCONJ cjel-3603 499 17 it it PRON cjel-3603 499 18 truly truly ADV cjel-3603 499 19 deprived deprive VERB cjel-3603 499 20 the the DET cjel-3603 499 21 remaining remain VERB cjel-3603 499 22 land land NOUN cjel-3603 499 23 of of ADP cjel-3603 499 24 all all DET cjel-3603 499 25 economically economically ADV cjel-3603 499 26 viable viable ADJ cjel-3603 499 27 use use NOUN cjel-3603 499 28 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 500 1 further far ADV cjel-3603 500 2 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 500 3 the the DET cjel-3603 500 4 court court NOUN cjel-3603 500 5 would would AUX cjel-3603 500 6 be be AUX cjel-3603 500 7 able able ADJ cjel-3603 500 8 to to PART cjel-3603 500 9 make make VERB cjel-3603 500 10 inquiries inquiry NOUN cjel-3603 500 11 into into ADP cjel-3603 500 12 whether whether SCONJ cjel-3603 500 13 the the DET cjel-3603 500 14 corps corp NOUN cjel-3603 500 15 ’ ' PUNCT cjel-3603 500 16 actions action NOUN cjel-3603 500 17 interfered interfere VERB cjel-3603 500 18 with with ADP cjel-3603 500 19 reasonable reasonable ADJ cjel-3603 500 20 investment investment NOUN cjel-3603 500 21 - - PUNCT cjel-3603 500 22 backed back VERB cjel-3603 500 23 expectations expectation NOUN cjel-3603 500 24 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 501 1 penn penn PROPN cjel-3603 501 2 central central PROPN cjel-3603 501 3 itself itself PRON cjel-3603 501 4 mentions mention VERB cjel-3603 501 5 navigational navigational ADJ cjel-3603 501 6 servitude servitude ADJ cjel-3603 501 7 cases case NOUN cjel-3603 501 8 in in ADP cjel-3603 501 9 its its PRON cjel-3603 501 10 discussion discussion NOUN cjel-3603 501 11 of of ADP cjel-3603 501 12 reasonable reasonable ADJ cjel-3603 501 13 expectations.130 expectations.130 NOUN cjel-3603 501 14 the the DET cjel-3603 501 15 notice notice NOUN cjel-3603 501 16 theory theory NOUN cjel-3603 501 17 could could AUX cjel-3603 501 18 then then ADV cjel-3603 501 19 come come VERB cjel-3603 501 20 into into ADP cjel-3603 501 21 the the DET cjel-3603 501 22 fact fact NOUN cjel-3603 501 23 - - PUNCT cjel-3603 501 24 specific specific ADJ cjel-3603 501 25 consideration consideration NOUN cjel-3603 501 26 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 502 1 this this DET cjel-3603 502 2 approach approach NOUN cjel-3603 502 3 would would AUX cjel-3603 502 4 balance balance VERB cjel-3603 502 5 the the DET cjel-3603 502 6 interests interest NOUN cjel-3603 502 7 of of ADP cjel-3603 502 8 both both CCONJ cjel-3603 502 9 the the DET cjel-3603 502 10 government government NOUN cjel-3603 502 11 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 502 12 affected affected ADJ cjel-3603 502 13 parties party NOUN cjel-3603 502 14 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 503 1 first first ADV cjel-3603 503 2 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 503 3 it it PRON cjel-3603 503 4 would would AUX cjel-3603 503 5 permit permit VERB cjel-3603 503 6 courts court NOUN cjel-3603 503 7 to to PART cjel-3603 503 8 review review VERB cjel-3603 503 9 the the DET cjel-3603 503 10 reasonableness reasonableness NOUN cjel-3603 503 11 of of ADP cjel-3603 503 12 the the DET cjel-3603 503 13 government government NOUN cjel-3603 503 14 ’s ’s PART cjel-3603 503 15 assertion assertion NOUN cjel-3603 503 16 of of ADP cjel-3603 503 17 the the DET cjel-3603 503 18 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 503 19 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 504 1 second second ADV cjel-3603 504 2 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 504 3 it it PRON cjel-3603 504 4 would would AUX cjel-3603 504 5 still still ADV cjel-3603 504 6 take take VERB cjel-3603 504 7 the the DET cjel-3603 504 8 navigational navigational ADJ cjel-3603 504 9 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 504 10 ’s ’s PART cjel-3603 504 11 long long ADJ cjel-3603 504 12 history history NOUN cjel-3603 504 13 into into ADP cjel-3603 504 14 account account NOUN cjel-3603 504 15 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 504 16 which which PRON cjel-3603 504 17 would would AUX cjel-3603 504 18 serve serve VERB cjel-3603 504 19 to to PART cjel-3603 504 20 prevent prevent VERB cjel-3603 504 21 the the DET cjel-3603 504 22 floodgates floodgate NOUN cjel-3603 504 23 from from ADP cjel-3603 504 24 opening open VERB cjel-3603 504 25 too too ADV cjel-3603 504 26 wide wide ADV cjel-3603 504 27 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 505 1 thus thus ADV cjel-3603 505 2 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 505 3 the the DET cjel-3603 505 4 navigational navigational ADJ cjel-3603 505 5 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 505 6 would would AUX cjel-3603 505 7 survive survive VERB cjel-3603 505 8 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 505 9 remain remain VERB cjel-3603 505 10 a a DET cjel-3603 505 11 powerful powerful ADJ cjel-3603 505 12 tool tool NOUN cjel-3603 505 13 for for ADP cjel-3603 505 14 the the DET cjel-3603 505 15 federal federal ADJ cjel-3603 505 16 government government NOUN cjel-3603 505 17 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 506 1 last last ADJ cjel-3603 506 2 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 506 3 an an DET cjel-3603 506 4 analysis analysis NOUN cjel-3603 506 5 of of ADP cjel-3603 506 6 the the DET cjel-3603 506 7 nature nature NOUN cjel-3603 506 8 of of ADP cjel-3603 506 9 the the DET cjel-3603 506 10 government government NOUN cjel-3603 506 11 ’s ’s PART cjel-3603 506 12 action action NOUN cjel-3603 506 13 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 506 14 such such ADJ cjel-3603 506 15 as as ADP cjel-3603 506 16 that that PRON cjel-3603 506 17 in in ADP cjel-3603 506 18 kaiser kaiser PROPN cjel-3603 506 19 aetna aetna PROPN cjel-3603 506 20 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 506 21 would would AUX cjel-3603 506 22 ensure ensure VERB cjel-3603 506 23 room room NOUN cjel-3603 506 24 for for ADP cjel-3603 506 25 consideration consideration NOUN cjel-3603 506 26 of of ADP cjel-3603 506 27 equity equity NOUN cjel-3603 506 28 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 506 29 fairness fairness NOUN cjel-3603 506 30 concerns concern NOUN cjel-3603 506 31 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 507 1 use use NOUN cjel-3603 507 2 of of ADP cjel-3603 507 3 this this DET cjel-3603 507 4 factor factor NOUN cjel-3603 507 5 would would AUX cjel-3603 507 6 allow allow VERB cjel-3603 507 7 courts court NOUN cjel-3603 507 8 to to PART cjel-3603 507 9 curtail curtail VERB cjel-3603 507 10 federal federal ADJ cjel-3603 507 11 abuse abuse NOUN cjel-3603 507 12 of of ADP cjel-3603 507 13 the the DET cjel-3603 507 14 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 507 15 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 508 1 under under ADP cjel-3603 508 2 such such DET cjel-3603 508 3 a a DET cjel-3603 508 4 framework framework NOUN cjel-3603 508 5 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 508 6 the the DET cjel-3603 508 7 navigational navigational ADJ cjel-3603 508 8 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 508 9 can can AUX cjel-3603 508 10 become become VERB cjel-3603 508 11 more more ADV cjel-3603 508 12 like like ADP cjel-3603 508 13 the the DET cjel-3603 508 14 other other ADJ cjel-3603 508 15 regulatory regulatory ADJ cjel-3603 508 16 powers power NOUN cjel-3603 508 17 of of ADP cjel-3603 508 18 the the DET cjel-3603 508 19 federal federal ADJ cjel-3603 508 20 government government NOUN cjel-3603 508 21 : : PUNCT cjel-3603 508 22 powerful powerful ADJ cjel-3603 508 23 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 508 24 rational rational ADJ cjel-3603 508 25 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 508 26 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 508 27 equitable equitable ADJ cjel-3603 508 28 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 509 1 the the DET cjel-3603 509 2 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 509 3 would would AUX cjel-3603 509 4 be be AUX cjel-3603 509 5 subject subject ADJ cjel-3603 509 6 to to ADP cjel-3603 509 7 the the DET cjel-3603 509 8 same same ADJ cjel-3603 509 9 judicial judicial ADJ cjel-3603 509 10 review review NOUN cjel-3603 509 11 as as ADP cjel-3603 509 12 other other ADJ cjel-3603 509 13 government government NOUN cjel-3603 509 14 actions action NOUN cjel-3603 509 15 that that PRON cjel-3603 509 16 interfere interfere VERB cjel-3603 509 17 with with ADP cjel-3603 509 18 private private ADJ cjel-3603 509 19 property property NOUN cjel-3603 509 20 rights right NOUN cjel-3603 509 21 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 510 1 the the DET cjel-3603 510 2 navigational navigational ADJ cjel-3603 510 3 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 510 4 would would AUX cjel-3603 510 5 no no ADV cjel-3603 510 6 longer long ADV cjel-3603 510 7 be be AUX cjel-3603 510 8 a a DET cjel-3603 510 9 magic magic ADJ cjel-3603 510 10 talisman talisman NOUN cjel-3603 510 11 to to PART cjel-3603 510 12 rid rid VERB cjel-3603 510 13 the the DET cjel-3603 510 14 federal federal ADJ cjel-3603 510 15 government government NOUN cjel-3603 510 16 of of ADP cjel-3603 510 17 its its PRON cjel-3603 510 18 obligation obligation NOUN cjel-3603 510 19 to to PART cjel-3603 510 20 pay pay VERB cjel-3603 510 21 just just ADV cjel-3603 510 22 compensation compensation NOUN cjel-3603 510 23 for for ADP cjel-3603 510 24 the the DET cjel-3603 510 25 taking taking NOUN cjel-3603 510 26 of of ADP cjel-3603 510 27 private private ADJ cjel-3603 510 28 property property NOUN cjel-3603 510 29 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 511 1 130 130 NUM cjel-3603 511 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 512 1 penn penn PROPN cjel-3603 512 2 cent cent PROPN cjel-3603 512 3 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 513 1 transp transp PROPN cjel-3603 513 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 514 1 co. co. PROPN cjel-3603 514 2 v. v. ADP cjel-3603 514 3 city city PROPN cjel-3603 514 4 of of ADP cjel-3603 514 5 new new PROPN cjel-3603 514 6 york york PROPN cjel-3603 514 7 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 514 8 438 438 NUM cjel-3603 514 9 u.s u.s PROPN cjel-3603 514 10 . . PROPN cjel-3603 514 11 104 104 NUM cjel-3603 514 12 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 514 13 124–25 124–25 X cjel-3603 514 14 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 514 15 citing cite VERB cjel-3603 514 16 united united PROPN cjel-3603 514 17 states states PROPN cjel-3603 514 18 v. v. ADP cjel-3603 514 19 willow willow PROPN cjel-3603 514 20 river river PROPN cjel-3603 514 21 power power PROPN cjel-3603 514 22 co. co. PROPN cjel-3603 514 23 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 514 24 324 324 NUM cjel-3603 514 25 u.s u.s PROPN cjel-3603 514 26 . . PROPN cjel-3603 514 27 499 499 NUM cjel-3603 514 28 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 514 29 1945 1945 NUM cjel-3603 514 30 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 514 31 ; ; PUNCT cjel-3603 514 32 united united PROPN cjel-3603 514 33 states states PROPN cjel-3603 514 34 v. v. ADP cjel-3603 514 35 chandler chandler PROPN cjel-3603 514 36 - - PUNCT cjel-3603 514 37 dunbar dunbar PROPN cjel-3603 514 38 water water PROPN cjel-3603 514 39 power power PROPN cjel-3603 514 40 co. co. PROPN cjel-3603 514 41 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 514 42 229 229 NUM cjel-3603 514 43 u.s u.s PROPN cjel-3603 514 44 . . PROPN cjel-3603 514 45 53 53 NUM cjel-3603 514 46 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 514 47 1913 1913 NUM cjel-3603 514 48 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 514 49 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 514 50 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 515 1 although although SCONJ cjel-3603 515 2 the the DET cjel-3603 515 3 court court NOUN cjel-3603 515 4 mentions mention VERB cjel-3603 515 5 these these DET cjel-3603 515 6 cases case NOUN cjel-3603 515 7 as as ADP cjel-3603 515 8 ones one NOUN cjel-3603 515 9 where where SCONJ cjel-3603 515 10 the the DET cjel-3603 515 11 governmental governmental ADJ cjel-3603 515 12 action action NOUN cjel-3603 515 13 “ " PUNCT cjel-3603 515 14 did do AUX cjel-3603 515 15 not not PART cjel-3603 515 16 interfere interfere VERB cjel-3603 515 17 with with ADP cjel-3603 515 18 interests interest NOUN cjel-3603 515 19 that that PRON cjel-3603 515 20 were be AUX cjel-3603 515 21 sufficiently sufficiently ADV cjel-3603 515 22 bound bind VERB cjel-3603 515 23 up up ADP cjel-3603 515 24 with with ADP cjel-3603 515 25 the the DET cjel-3603 515 26 reasonable reasonable ADJ cjel-3603 515 27 expectations expectation NOUN cjel-3603 515 28 of of ADP cjel-3603 515 29 the the DET cjel-3603 515 30 claimant claimant NOUN cjel-3603 515 31 to to PART cjel-3603 515 32 constitute constitute VERB cjel-3603 515 33 ‘ ' PUNCT cjel-3603 515 34 property property NOUN cjel-3603 515 35 ’ ' PUNCT cjel-3603 515 36 for for ADP cjel-3603 515 37 fifth fifth ADJ cjel-3603 515 38 amendment amendment NOUN cjel-3603 515 39 purposes purpose NOUN cjel-3603 515 40 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 515 41 ” " PUNCT cjel-3603 515 42 this this PRON cjel-3603 515 43 does do AUX cjel-3603 515 44 not not PART cjel-3603 515 45 necessarily necessarily ADV cjel-3603 515 46 deny deny VERB cjel-3603 515 47 any any DET cjel-3603 515 48 interests interest NOUN cjel-3603 515 49 subject subject ADJ cjel-3603 515 50 to to ADP cjel-3603 515 51 the the DET cjel-3603 515 52 navigational navigational ADJ cjel-3603 515 53 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 515 54 from from ADP cjel-3603 515 55 being be AUX cjel-3603 515 56 considered consider VERB cjel-3603 515 57 a a DET cjel-3603 515 58 property property NOUN cjel-3603 515 59 right right NOUN cjel-3603 515 60 for for ADP cjel-3603 515 61 fifth fifth ADJ cjel-3603 515 62 amendment amendment NOUN cjel-3603 515 63 purposes purpose NOUN cjel-3603 515 64 in in ADP cjel-3603 515 65 the the DET cjel-3603 515 66 future future NOUN cjel-3603 515 67 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 516 1 i i PRON cjel-3603 516 2 d. d. PROPN cjel-3603 516 3 monahan monahan PROPN cjel-3603 516 4 - - PUNCT cjel-3603 516 5 macro-[final macro-[final PROPN cjel-3603 516 6 6 6 NUM cjel-3603 516 7 - - SYM cjel-3603 516 8 20 20 NUM cjel-3603 516 9 ] ] PUNCT cjel-3603 516 10 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 516 11 do do AUX cjel-3603 516 12 not not PART cjel-3603 516 13 delete delete VERB cjel-3603 516 14 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 516 15 6/22/2015 6/22/2015 NUM cjel-3603 516 16 11:53 11:53 NUM cjel-3603 516 17 pm pm NOUN cjel-3603 516 18 2015 2015 NUM cjel-3603 516 19 ] ] PUNCT cjel-3603 516 20 the the DET cjel-3603 516 21 navigational navigational ADJ cjel-3603 516 22 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 516 23 383 383 NUM cjel-3603 516 24 another another DET cjel-3603 516 25 example example NOUN cjel-3603 516 26 of of ADP cjel-3603 516 27 how how SCONJ cjel-3603 516 28 this this DET cjel-3603 516 29 analysis analysis NOUN cjel-3603 516 30 would would AUX cjel-3603 516 31 be be AUX cjel-3603 516 32 beneficial beneficial ADJ cjel-3603 516 33 can can AUX cjel-3603 516 34 be be AUX cjel-3603 516 35 found find VERB cjel-3603 516 36 in in ADP cjel-3603 516 37 allen allen PROPN cjel-3603 516 38 gun gun PROPN cjel-3603 516 39 club club PROPN cjel-3603 516 40 v. v. PROPN cjel-3603 516 41 united united PROPN cjel-3603 516 42 states.131 states.131 PROPN cjel-3603 516 43 in in ADP cjel-3603 516 44 this this DET cjel-3603 516 45 case case NOUN cjel-3603 516 46 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 516 47 the the DET cjel-3603 516 48 u.s u.s PROPN cjel-3603 516 49 . . PROPN cjel-3603 516 50 army army PROPN cjel-3603 516 51 corps corps PROPN cjel-3603 516 52 of of ADP cjel-3603 516 53 engineers engineer NOUN cjel-3603 516 54 dredged dredge VERB cjel-3603 516 55 a a DET cjel-3603 516 56 channel channel NOUN cjel-3603 516 57 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 516 58 used use VERB cjel-3603 516 59 the the DET cjel-3603 516 60 excavated excavate VERB cjel-3603 516 61 material material NOUN cjel-3603 516 62 to to PART cjel-3603 516 63 build build VERB cjel-3603 516 64 a a DET cjel-3603 516 65 dike dike NOUN cjel-3603 516 66 on on ADP cjel-3603 516 67 the the DET cjel-3603 516 68 landowner landowner NOUN cjel-3603 516 69 ’s ’s PART cjel-3603 516 70 submerged submerge VERB cjel-3603 516 71 land.132 land.132 NOUN cjel-3603 516 72 this this PRON cjel-3603 516 73 caused cause VERB cjel-3603 516 74 a a DET cjel-3603 516 75 delta delta NOUN cjel-3603 516 76 to to PART cjel-3603 516 77 form form VERB cjel-3603 516 78 in in ADP cjel-3603 516 79 the the DET cjel-3603 516 80 bay bay NOUN cjel-3603 516 81 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 516 82 filled fill VERB cjel-3603 516 83 in in ADP cjel-3603 516 84 the the DET cjel-3603 516 85 submerged submerge VERB cjel-3603 516 86 land land NOUN cjel-3603 516 87 until until SCONJ cjel-3603 516 88 it it PRON cjel-3603 516 89 was be AUX cjel-3603 516 90 too too ADV cjel-3603 516 91 dry dry ADJ cjel-3603 516 92 for for ADP cjel-3603 516 93 fishing fishing NOUN cjel-3603 516 94 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 516 95 duck duck NOUN cjel-3603 516 96 hunting hunting NOUN cjel-3603 516 97 — — PUNCT cjel-3603 516 98 for for ADP cjel-3603 516 99 which which PRON cjel-3603 516 100 the the DET cjel-3603 516 101 land land NOUN cjel-3603 516 102 was be AUX cjel-3603 516 103 being be AUX cjel-3603 516 104 used use VERB cjel-3603 516 105 — — PUNCT cjel-3603 516 106 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 516 107 too too ADV cjel-3603 516 108 wet wet ADJ cjel-3603 516 109 for for ADP cjel-3603 516 110 agriculture.133 agriculture.133 NOUN cjel-3603 516 111 before before ADP cjel-3603 516 112 the the DET cjel-3603 516 113 dredging dredging NOUN cjel-3603 516 114 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 516 115 excavation excavation NOUN cjel-3603 516 116 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 516 117 the the DET cjel-3603 516 118 bay bay NOUN cjel-3603 516 119 was be AUX cjel-3603 516 120 mostly mostly ADV cjel-3603 516 121 covered cover VERB cjel-3603 516 122 with with ADP cjel-3603 516 123 a a DET cjel-3603 516 124 depth depth NOUN cjel-3603 516 125 of of ADP cjel-3603 516 126 water water NOUN cjel-3603 516 127 about about ADV cjel-3603 516 128 five five NUM cjel-3603 516 129 to to PART cjel-3603 516 130 six six NUM cjel-3603 516 131 feet foot NOUN cjel-3603 516 132 that that PRON cjel-3603 516 133 could could AUX cjel-3603 516 134 support support VERB cjel-3603 516 135 moderate moderate ADJ cjel-3603 516 136 - - PUNCT cjel-3603 516 137 sized sized ADJ cjel-3603 516 138 watercraft.134 watercraft.134 NOUN cjel-3603 516 139 this this PRON cjel-3603 516 140 allowed allow VERB cjel-3603 516 141 the the DET cjel-3603 516 142 plaintiffs plaintiff NOUN cjel-3603 516 143 to to PART cjel-3603 516 144 use use VERB cjel-3603 516 145 the the DET cjel-3603 516 146 land land NOUN cjel-3603 516 147 for for ADP cjel-3603 516 148 a a DET cjel-3603 516 149 successful successful ADJ cjel-3603 516 150 fishing fishing NOUN cjel-3603 516 151 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 516 152 hunting hunt VERB cjel-3603 516 153 business business NOUN cjel-3603 516 154 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 517 1 however however ADV cjel-3603 517 2 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 517 3 since since SCONJ cjel-3603 517 4 the the DET cjel-3603 517 5 construction construction NOUN cjel-3603 517 6 of of ADP cjel-3603 517 7 the the DET cjel-3603 517 8 dike dike NOUN cjel-3603 517 9 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 517 10 the the DET cjel-3603 517 11 resulting result VERB cjel-3603 517 12 “ " PUNCT cjel-3603 517 13 delta delta NOUN cjel-3603 517 14 forming form VERB cjel-3603 517 15 effect effect NOUN cjel-3603 517 16 ” " PUNCT cjel-3603 517 17 caused cause VERB cjel-3603 517 18 the the DET cjel-3603 517 19 plaintiff plaintiff NOUN cjel-3603 517 20 to to PART cjel-3603 517 21 lose lose VERB cjel-3603 517 22 “ " PUNCT cjel-3603 517 23 a a DET cjel-3603 517 24 substantial substantial ADJ cjel-3603 517 25 part part NOUN cjel-3603 517 26 of of ADP cjel-3603 517 27 its its PRON cjel-3603 517 28 land land NOUN cjel-3603 517 29 as as ADP cjel-3603 517 30 concern[ed concern[ed PROPN cjel-3603 517 31 ] ] PUNCT cjel-3603 517 32 its its PRON cjel-3603 517 33 use use NOUN cjel-3603 517 34 for for ADP cjel-3603 517 35 duck duck NOUN cjel-3603 517 36 hunting hunting NOUN cjel-3603 517 37 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 517 38 fishing fishing NOUN cjel-3603 517 39 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 517 40 which which PRON cjel-3603 517 41 appear[ed appear[ed PROPN cjel-3603 517 42 ] ] PUNCT cjel-3603 517 43 to to PART cjel-3603 517 44 be be AUX cjel-3603 517 45 the the DET cjel-3603 517 46 highest high ADJ cjel-3603 517 47 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 517 48 best good ADJ cjel-3603 517 49 use use NOUN cjel-3603 517 50 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 517 51 ”135 ”135 PUNCT cjel-3603 518 1 if if SCONJ cjel-3603 518 2 the the DET cjel-3603 518 3 land land NOUN cjel-3603 518 4 in in ADP cjel-3603 518 5 question question NOUN cjel-3603 518 6 had have AUX cjel-3603 518 7 been be AUX cjel-3603 518 8 above above ADP cjel-3603 518 9 the the DET cjel-3603 518 10 highwater highwater PROPN cjel-3603 518 11 mark mark NOUN cjel-3603 518 12 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 518 13 destruction destruction NOUN cjel-3603 518 14 of of ADP cjel-3603 518 15 the the DET cjel-3603 518 16 land land NOUN cjel-3603 518 17 ’s ’s PART cjel-3603 518 18 ability ability NOUN cjel-3603 518 19 to to PART cjel-3603 518 20 be be AUX cjel-3603 518 21 used use VERB cjel-3603 518 22 for for ADP cjel-3603 518 23 its its PRON cjel-3603 518 24 highest high ADJ cjel-3603 518 25 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 518 26 best good ADJ cjel-3603 518 27 use use NOUN cjel-3603 518 28 would would AUX cjel-3603 518 29 present present VERB cjel-3603 518 30 a a DET cjel-3603 518 31 strong strong ADJ cjel-3603 518 32 case case NOUN cjel-3603 518 33 for for ADP cjel-3603 518 34 compensation compensation NOUN cjel-3603 518 35 pursuant pursuant ADJ cjel-3603 518 36 to to ADP cjel-3603 518 37 the the DET cjel-3603 518 38 takings taking NOUN cjel-3603 518 39 clause clause NOUN cjel-3603 518 40 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 519 1 by by ADP cjel-3603 519 2 disallowing disallow VERB cjel-3603 519 3 the the DET cjel-3603 519 4 navigational navigational ADJ cjel-3603 519 5 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 519 6 to to PART cjel-3603 519 7 act act VERB cjel-3603 519 8 as as ADP cjel-3603 519 9 an an DET cjel-3603 519 10 absolute absolute ADJ cjel-3603 519 11 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 519 12 blanket blanket VERB cjel-3603 519 13 exception exception NOUN cjel-3603 519 14 to to ADP cjel-3603 519 15 a a DET cjel-3603 519 16 takings taking NOUN cjel-3603 519 17 claim claim NOUN cjel-3603 519 18 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 519 19 cases case NOUN cjel-3603 519 20 such such ADJ cjel-3603 519 21 as as ADP cjel-3603 519 22 allen allen PROPN cjel-3603 519 23 gun gun NOUN cjel-3603 519 24 club club NOUN cjel-3603 519 25 would would AUX cjel-3603 519 26 permit permit VERB cjel-3603 519 27 landowners landowner NOUN cjel-3603 519 28 to to PART cjel-3603 519 29 submit submit VERB cjel-3603 519 30 evidence evidence NOUN cjel-3603 519 31 showing show VERB cjel-3603 519 32 that that SCONJ cjel-3603 519 33 the the DET cjel-3603 519 34 governmental governmental ADJ cjel-3603 519 35 action action NOUN cjel-3603 519 36 denied deny VERB cjel-3603 519 37 the the DET cjel-3603 519 38 land land NOUN cjel-3603 519 39 its its PRON cjel-3603 519 40 prior prior ADJ cjel-3603 519 41 economically economically ADV cjel-3603 519 42 beneficial beneficial ADJ cjel-3603 519 43 use use NOUN cjel-3603 519 44 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 520 1 if if SCONJ cjel-3603 520 2 this this DET cjel-3603 520 3 deprivation deprivation NOUN cjel-3603 520 4 were be AUX cjel-3603 520 5 found find VERB cjel-3603 520 6 to to PART cjel-3603 520 7 be be AUX cjel-3603 520 8 insufficient insufficient ADJ cjel-3603 520 9 to to PART cjel-3603 520 10 rise rise VERB cjel-3603 520 11 to to ADP cjel-3603 520 12 the the DET cjel-3603 520 13 standards standard NOUN cjel-3603 520 14 of of ADP cjel-3603 520 15 lucas lucas NOUN cjel-3603 520 16 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 520 17 then then ADV cjel-3603 520 18 the the DET cjel-3603 520 19 analysis analysis NOUN cjel-3603 520 20 would would AUX cjel-3603 520 21 continue continue VERB cjel-3603 520 22 using use VERB cjel-3603 520 23 the the DET cjel-3603 520 24 ad ad NOUN cjel-3603 520 25 - - PUNCT cjel-3603 520 26 hoc hoc X cjel-3603 520 27 review review NOUN cjel-3603 520 28 of of ADP cjel-3603 520 29 penn penn PROPN cjel-3603 520 30 central central PROPN cjel-3603 520 31 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 521 1 instead instead ADV cjel-3603 521 2 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 521 3 courts court NOUN cjel-3603 521 4 are be AUX cjel-3603 521 5 refusing refuse VERB cjel-3603 521 6 to to PART cjel-3603 521 7 recognize recognize VERB cjel-3603 521 8 a a DET cjel-3603 521 9 legitimate legitimate ADJ cjel-3603 521 10 property property NOUN cjel-3603 521 11 right right ADV cjel-3603 521 12 merely merely ADV cjel-3603 521 13 because because SCONJ cjel-3603 521 14 it it PRON cjel-3603 521 15 is be AUX cjel-3603 521 16 subject subject ADJ cjel-3603 521 17 to to ADP cjel-3603 521 18 a a DET cjel-3603 521 19 navigational navigational ADJ cjel-3603 521 20 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 521 21 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 521 22 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 521 23 are be AUX cjel-3603 521 24 therefore therefore ADV cjel-3603 521 25 prematurely prematurely ADV cjel-3603 521 26 ending end VERB cjel-3603 521 27 the the DET cjel-3603 521 28 takings taking NOUN cjel-3603 521 29 analysis.136 analysis.136 NOUN cjel-3603 521 30 131 131 NUM cjel-3603 521 31 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 522 1 allen allen PROPN cjel-3603 522 2 gun gun PROPN cjel-3603 522 3 club club PROPN cjel-3603 522 4 v. v. PROPN cjel-3603 522 5 united united PROPN cjel-3603 522 6 states states PROPN cjel-3603 522 7 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 522 8 180 180 NUM cjel-3603 522 9 ct ct NOUN cjel-3603 522 10 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 523 1 cl cl NOUN cjel-3603 523 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 524 1 423 423 NUM cjel-3603 524 2 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 524 3 ct ct PROPN cjel-3603 524 4 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 524 5 cl cl NOUN cjel-3603 524 6 . . PROPN cjel-3603 524 7 1967 1967 NUM cjel-3603 524 8 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 524 9 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 525 1 132 132 NUM cjel-3603 525 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 526 1 i i PRON cjel-3603 526 2 d. d. PROPN cjel-3603 526 3 at at ADP cjel-3603 526 4 425 425 NUM cjel-3603 526 5 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 527 1 133 133 NUM cjel-3603 527 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 528 1 i i PRON cjel-3603 528 2 d. d. VERB cjel-3603 528 3 at at ADP cjel-3603 528 4 427–28 427–28 PROPN cjel-3603 528 5 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 529 1 134 134 NUM cjel-3603 529 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 530 1 i i PRON cjel-3603 530 2 d. d. PROPN cjel-3603 530 3 at at ADP cjel-3603 530 4 426 426 NUM cjel-3603 530 5 . . PROPN cjel-3603 530 6 135 135 NUM cjel-3603 530 7 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 531 1 i i PRON cjel-3603 531 2 d. d. VERB cjel-3603 531 3 at at ADP cjel-3603 531 4 427–28 427–28 PROPN cjel-3603 531 5 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 532 1 136 136 NUM cjel-3603 532 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 533 1 see see VERB cjel-3603 533 2 pub pub NOUN cjel-3603 533 3 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 534 1 util util PROPN cjel-3603 534 2 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 534 3 dist dist NOUN cjel-3603 534 4 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 535 1 no no INTJ cjel-3603 535 2 . . NOUN cjel-3603 535 3 1 1 NUM cjel-3603 535 4 of of ADP cjel-3603 535 5 pend pend PROPN cjel-3603 535 6 oreille oreille PROPN cjel-3603 535 7 cnty cnty PROPN cjel-3603 535 8 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 536 1 v. v. ADP cjel-3603 536 2 city city PROPN cjel-3603 536 3 of of ADP cjel-3603 536 4 seattle seattle PROPN cjel-3603 536 5 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 536 6 382 382 NUM cjel-3603 536 7 f.2d f.2d NOUN cjel-3603 536 8 666 666 NUM cjel-3603 536 9 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 536 10 669 669 NUM cjel-3603 536 11 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 536 12 9th 9th ADJ cjel-3603 536 13 cir cir NOUN cjel-3603 536 14 . . PROPN cjel-3603 536 15 1967 1967 NUM cjel-3603 536 16 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 537 1 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 537 2 “ " PUNCT cjel-3603 537 3 [ [ X cjel-3603 537 4 t]he t]he ADV cjel-3603 537 5 navigational navigational ADJ cjel-3603 537 6 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 537 7 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 537 8 by by ADP cjel-3603 537 9 its its PRON cjel-3603 537 10 nature nature NOUN cjel-3603 537 11 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 537 12 does do AUX cjel-3603 537 13 not not PART cjel-3603 537 14 destroy destroy VERB cjel-3603 537 15 or or CCONJ cjel-3603 537 16 exclude exclude VERB cjel-3603 537 17 all all DET cjel-3603 537 18 property property NOUN cjel-3603 537 19 rights right NOUN cjel-3603 537 20 in in ADP cjel-3603 537 21 the the DET cjel-3603 537 22 beds bed NOUN cjel-3603 537 23 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 537 24 banks bank NOUN cjel-3603 537 25 of of ADP cjel-3603 537 26 navigable navigable ADJ cjel-3603 537 27 streams stream NOUN cjel-3603 537 28 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 538 1 such such ADJ cjel-3603 538 2 rights right NOUN cjel-3603 538 3 continue continue VERB cjel-3603 538 4 to to PART cjel-3603 538 5 exist exist VERB cjel-3603 538 6 but but CCONJ cjel-3603 538 7 are be AUX cjel-3603 538 8 held hold VERB cjel-3603 538 9 subject subject ADJ cjel-3603 538 10 to to ADP cjel-3603 538 11 the the DET cjel-3603 538 12 governmental governmental ADJ cjel-3603 538 13 power power NOUN cjel-3603 538 14 in in ADP cjel-3603 538 15 the the DET cjel-3603 538 16 nature nature NOUN cjel-3603 538 17 of of ADP cjel-3603 538 18 an an DET cjel-3603 538 19 easement easement NOUN cjel-3603 538 20 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 538 21 ” " PUNCT cjel-3603 538 22 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 538 23 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 539 1 monahan monahan PROPN cjel-3603 539 2 - - PUNCT cjel-3603 539 3 macro-[final macro-[final PROPN cjel-3603 539 4 6 6 NUM cjel-3603 539 5 - - SYM cjel-3603 539 6 20 20 NUM cjel-3603 539 7 ] ] PUNCT cjel-3603 539 8 ( ( PUNCT cjel-3603 539 9 do do AUX cjel-3603 539 10 not not PART cjel-3603 539 11 delete delete VERB cjel-3603 539 12 ) ) PUNCT cjel-3603 539 13 6/22/2015 6/22/2015 NUM cjel-3603 539 14 11:53 11:53 NUM cjel-3603 539 15 pm pm NOUN cjel-3603 539 16 384 384 NUM cjel-3603 539 17 columbia columbia PROPN cjel-3603 539 18 journal journal PROPN cjel-3603 539 19 of of ADP cjel-3603 539 20 environmental environmental ADJ cjel-3603 539 21 law law NOUN cjel-3603 539 22 [ [ X cjel-3603 539 23 vol vol NOUN cjel-3603 539 24 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 540 1 40:2 40:2 NUM cjel-3603 540 2 v. v. ADP cjel-3603 540 3 conclusion conclusion NOUN cjel-3603 540 4 the the DET cjel-3603 540 5 takings taking NOUN cjel-3603 540 6 clause clause NOUN cjel-3603 540 7 has have AUX cjel-3603 540 8 resulted result VERB cjel-3603 540 9 in in ADP cjel-3603 540 10 a a DET cjel-3603 540 11 complex complex ADJ cjel-3603 540 12 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 540 13 inconsistent inconsistent ADJ cjel-3603 540 14 body body NOUN cjel-3603 540 15 of of ADP cjel-3603 540 16 law law NOUN cjel-3603 540 17 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 541 1 while while SCONJ cjel-3603 541 2 the the DET cjel-3603 541 3 supreme supreme PROPN cjel-3603 541 4 court court PROPN cjel-3603 541 5 has have AUX cjel-3603 541 6 recognized recognize VERB cjel-3603 541 7 that that SCONJ cjel-3603 541 8 takings taking NOUN cjel-3603 541 9 claims claim NOUN cjel-3603 541 10 require require VERB cjel-3603 541 11 a a DET cjel-3603 541 12 nuanced nuanced ADJ cjel-3603 541 13 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 541 14 factspecific factspecific ADJ cjel-3603 541 15 analysis analysis NOUN cjel-3603 541 16 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 541 17 categorical categorical ADJ cjel-3603 541 18 exceptions exception NOUN cjel-3603 541 19 to to ADP cjel-3603 541 20 such such DET cjel-3603 541 21 an an DET cjel-3603 541 22 analysis analysis NOUN cjel-3603 541 23 still still ADV cjel-3603 541 24 exist exist VERB cjel-3603 541 25 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 542 1 the the DET cjel-3603 542 2 navigational navigational ADJ cjel-3603 542 3 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 542 4 remains remain VERB cjel-3603 542 5 one one NUM cjel-3603 542 6 such such ADJ cjel-3603 542 7 vast vast ADJ cjel-3603 542 8 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 542 9 powerful powerful ADJ cjel-3603 542 10 categorical categorical ADJ cjel-3603 542 11 exception exception NOUN cjel-3603 542 12 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 543 1 however however ADV cjel-3603 543 2 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 543 3 by by ADP cjel-3603 543 4 recognizing recognize VERB cjel-3603 543 5 its its PRON cjel-3603 543 6 historical historical ADJ cjel-3603 543 7 underpinnings underpinning NOUN cjel-3603 543 8 in in ADP cjel-3603 543 9 the the DET cjel-3603 543 10 commerce commerce NOUN cjel-3603 543 11 clause clause NOUN cjel-3603 543 12 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 543 13 this this DET cjel-3603 543 14 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 543 15 can can AUX cjel-3603 543 16 be be AUX cjel-3603 543 17 seen see VERB cjel-3603 543 18 as as ADP cjel-3603 543 19 an an DET cjel-3603 543 20 exercise exercise NOUN cjel-3603 543 21 of of ADP cjel-3603 543 22 governmental governmental ADJ cjel-3603 543 23 power power NOUN cjel-3603 543 24 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 544 1 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 544 2 like like ADP cjel-3603 544 3 any any DET cjel-3603 544 4 other other ADJ cjel-3603 544 5 exercise exercise NOUN cjel-3603 544 6 of of ADP cjel-3603 544 7 power power NOUN cjel-3603 544 8 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 544 9 it it PRON cjel-3603 544 10 should should AUX cjel-3603 544 11 be be AUX cjel-3603 544 12 subject subject ADJ cjel-3603 544 13 to to ADP cjel-3603 544 14 the the DET cjel-3603 544 15 ad ad NOUN cjel-3603 544 16 - - PUNCT cjel-3603 544 17 hoc hoc X cjel-3603 544 18 penn penn NOUN cjel-3603 544 19 central central ADJ cjel-3603 544 20 test test NOUN cjel-3603 544 21 . . PUNCT cjel-3603 545 1 by by ADP cjel-3603 545 2 refusing refuse VERB cjel-3603 545 3 to to PART cjel-3603 545 4 allow allow VERB cjel-3603 545 5 the the DET cjel-3603 545 6 servitude servitude NOUN cjel-3603 545 7 to to PART cjel-3603 545 8 be be AUX cjel-3603 545 9 a a DET cjel-3603 545 10 blanket blanket NOUN cjel-3603 545 11 exception exception NOUN cjel-3603 545 12 to to ADP cjel-3603 545 13 the the DET cjel-3603 545 14 takings taking NOUN cjel-3603 545 15 clause clause NOUN cjel-3603 545 16 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 545 17 the the DET cjel-3603 545 18 federal federal ADJ cjel-3603 545 19 government government NOUN cjel-3603 545 20 will will AUX cjel-3603 545 21 still still ADV cjel-3603 545 22 be be AUX cjel-3603 545 23 able able ADJ cjel-3603 545 24 to to PART cjel-3603 545 25 obtain obtain VERB cjel-3603 545 26 land land NOUN cjel-3603 545 27 for for ADP cjel-3603 545 28 public public ADJ cjel-3603 545 29 purposes purpose NOUN cjel-3603 545 30 , , PUNCT cjel-3603 545 31 but but CCONJ cjel-3603 545 32 will will AUX cjel-3603 545 33 be be AUX cjel-3603 545 34 forced force VERB cjel-3603 545 35 to to PART cjel-3603 545 36 do do VERB cjel-3603 545 37 so so ADV cjel-3603 545 38 in in ADP cjel-3603 545 39 a a DET cjel-3603 545 40 more more ADV cjel-3603 545 41 equitable equitable ADJ cjel-3603 545 42 and and CCONJ cjel-3603 545 43 just just ADV cjel-3603 545 44 way way ADV cjel-3603 545 45 consistent consistent ADJ cjel-3603 545 46 with with ADP cjel-3603 545 47 the the DET cjel-3603 545 48 policy policy NOUN cjel-3603 545 49 considerations consideration NOUN cjel-3603 545 50 underlying underlie VERB cjel-3603 545 51 the the DET cjel-3603 545 52 takings taking NOUN cjel-3603 545 53 clause clause NOUN cjel-3603 545 54 . . PUNCT