

































oQHmK2 j- Abbm2 k

L2rb

1M;BM22`BM; �M/ 1pQHmiBQM

1�`HB2` i?Bb v2�`- i?2 1M;BM22`BM; _2b2�`+? :`QmT U?2�/2/ mT
#v ai2p2 G�m7K�MMV ?2H/ � ǳ*QM72`2M+2 QM 1M;BM22`BM; �M/
GBpBM; avbi2KbXǴ h?2 bQ@+�HH2/ *1Ga +QM72`2M+2 #`Qm;?i iQ@
;2i?2` #BQHQ;Bbib �M/ 2M;BM22`b Q7 2p2`v bi`BT2 iQ b22 ?Qr i?2
/Bb+BTHBM2b KB;?i rQ`F iQ;2i?2`X

P7 BMi2`2bi- i?Bb ;`QmT Bb bQK2r?�i Q7 �M Qmi;`Qri? Q7 +QM72`@
2M+2b ?2H/ #v h?2 "Hvi? AMbiBimi2 Qp2` i?2 v2�`bX AM kyRk-
h?2 "Hvi? AMbiBimi2 ?2H/ �M BMi2`/Bb+BTHBM�`v +QM72`2M+2 �i
P`�H _Q#2`ib lMBp2`bBiv r?B+? #`Qm;?i iQ;2i?2` 2M;BM22`b rBi?
�+�/2KB+b Q7 K�Mv Qi?2` /Bb+BTHBM2b iQ /Bb+mbb ?Qr B/2�b-
�iiBim/2b- i2+?MB[m2b- �M/ r�vb Q7 i?BMFBM; 7`QK 2M;BM22`@
BM; KB;?i mb27mHHv #2M2}i Qi?2` �`2�b Q7 BM[mB`v- �M/ pB+2@
p2`b�X JQbi Q7 i?2 i�HFb 7`QK i?Bb +QM72`2M+2 �`2 biBHH �p�BH@
�#H2 QMHBM2 �i ?iiTb,ffrrrXvQmim#2X+QKfTH�vHBbi\HBbi4
SGjNk*d8k1ejj1R"e�X h?Bb +QM72`2M+2 T�T2`b 7`QK i?Bb +QM@
72`2M+2 r2`2 +QHH2+i2/ �M/ `2bmHi2/ BM i?2 #QQF 1M;BM22`BM;
�M/ i?2 lHiBK�i2, �M AMi2`/Bb+BTHBM�`v AMp2biB;�iBQM Q7 P`/2`
�M/ .2bB;M BM L�im`2 �M/ *`�7i UCX GX "�`iH2ii- >�HbK2`- �M/
>�HH- kyR9VX

� 72r v2�`b H�i2`- h?2 "Hvi? AMbiBimi2 /B/ � 7QHHQrmT QMHBM2
+QM72`2M+2 QM K2i?Q/QHQ;B+�H Bbbm2b i?�i bi2KK2/ 7`QK �M 2M@
;BM22`BM; pB2r Q7 i?2 rQ`H/- iBiH2/ i?2 �Hi2`M�iBp2b iQ J2i?Q/@
QHQ;B+�H L�im`�HBbK U�J@L�iV +QM72`2M+2X JQbi Q7 i?2 i�HFb
7`QK i?Bb +QM72`2M+2- iQQ- �`2 biBHH �p�BH�#H2 QMHBM2- �M/ +�M
#2 7QmM/ �i ?iiTb,ffrrrXvQmim#2X+QKfTH�vHBbi\HBbi4
SG37iAACd�Lw?hqDH:J_*HvsE.bAeohFd_X h?2 T�T2`b 7`QK
i?Bb +QM72`2M+2 r2`2 +QHH2+i2/ BMiQ i?2 pQHmK2 L�im`�HBbK �M/
Aib �Hi2`M�iBp2b BM a+B2MiB}+ J2i?Q/QHQ;B2b UCX GX "�`iH2ii �M/
>QHHQr�v- kyRdVX

�Hi?Qm;? i?2 H2�/2`b?BT Q7 i?2 1M;BM22`BM; _2b2�`+? :`QmT
r2`2 MQi T�`i Q7 i?2b2 +QM72`2M+2b- Km+? Q7 i?2 2�`Hv BMi2`2bi
�`QmM/ i?2b2 bm#D2+ib ;`2r Qmi Q7 i?2b2 +QM72`2M+2b- �M/ K�Mv
Q7 i?2 2�`Hv K2K#2`b Q7 i?2 1M;BM22`BM; _2b2�`+? :`QmT +�K2
Qmi Q7 i?2b2 irQ +QM72`2M+2bX AM/22/- b2p2`�H Q7 i?2 i�HFb ;Bp2M
�i i?2 *1Ga +QM72`2M+2 r2`2 Qmi;`Qri?b Q7 `2b2�`+? T`QD2+ib
r?B+? r2`2 T`2b2Mi2/ �i i?2 irQ 2�`Hv +QM72`2M+2bX q?BH2 h?2
"Hvi? AMbiBimi2 /B/ MQi T`2b2Mi �i i?2 *1Ga +QM72`2M+2- r2

�`2 TH2�b2/ iQ ?�p2 TH�v2/ � T�`i BM H�vBM; i?2 ;`QmM/rQ`F 7Q`
i?2b2 FBM/b Q7 BM[mB`B2b- +QM72`2M+2b- �M/ +QMp2`b�iBQMbX

1pQivT2b �M/ i?2 1M;BM22`BM; Q7
1pQHmiBQM

6`QK � /Bz2`2Mi �M;H2- Qi?2` `2b2�`+? ;`QmTb �`2 +QMbB/2`BM;
i?2 2M;BM22`BM; �TTHB+�iBQMb Q7 2pQHmiBQMX h?2 "BQ+QKTmi2
G�# 7`QK i?2 lMBp2`bBiv Q7 "`BbiQH Bb rQ`FBM; QM �M ǳ2M;BM22`@
BM; i?2Q`v Q7 2pQHmiBQMXǴ *�biH2- :`B2`bQM- �M/ :Q`Q+?QrbFB
UMX/XV T`QTQb2b i?�i- #2+�mb2 2pQHmiBQM Bb bQ /Bz2`2Mi 7`QK
�Mvi?BM; ?mK�Mb MQ`K�HHv /2bB;M- r2 M22/ � i?2Q`v Q7 2M;B@
M22`BM; r?B+? 2M+�TbmH�i2b i?2 r�v 2pQHmiBQM rQ`Fb bQ i?�i
2pQHpBM; bvbi2Kb +�M #2 BMi2;`�i2/ BMiQ 2M;BM22`BM; QM2bX

h?2v T`QTQb2 i?2 ǳ2pQivT2-Ǵ r?B+? Bb 2bb2MiB�HHv i`2�iBM; 2pQ@
HmiBQM�`v +�T�#BHBiv �b � T?2MQivT2X h?2v +QMbB/2` i?2 ǳ/2bB;M
ivT2Ǵ Q7 � bvbi2K iQ #2 � bBM;H2 bvbi2K i?�i 2tBbib �b 2M;B@
M22`2/- �M/ i?2 ǳ2pQivT2Ǵ +�Tim`2b i?2 2pQHmiBQM�`v /vM�KB+b
Q7 i?2 bvbi2KX

q?BH2 *�biH2- :`B2`bQM- �M/ :Q`Q+?QrbFB UMX/XV r�b T`BK�`@
BHv +QM+2`M2/ rBi? mbBM; #BQHQ;B+�H T`BM+BTH2b iQ #mBH/ MQM@
#BQHQ;B+�H bvbi2Kb- bBKBH�` B/2�b ?�p2 #22M T`2b2Mi2/ BM i?2
+QMi2ti Q7 #BQHQ;B+�H bvbi2Kb i?2Kb2Hp2bX *�TQ`�H2 UkyyeV
/2�Hi rBi? r?�i b?2 +�HH2/ i?2 ǳBKTHB+Bi ;2MQK2Ǵěi?2 b2i
Q7 �HH i?2 HBF2Hv 7mim`2 2pQHp�#H2 T�i?r�vb- r?B+? Bb `Qm;?Hv
2[mBp�H2Mi iQ i?2 ǳ2pQivT2XǴ CX "�`iH2ii- :��bi`�- �M/ L2K�iB
UkykyV TQBMi2/ Qmi i?�i i?Bb bQ`i Q7 TQi2MiB�HBiv +�M �+im�HHv
#2 K2�bm`2/ mbBM; �+iBp2 BM7Q`K�iBQM- �M/ T`QTQb2/ ?Qr i?Bb
BM7Q`K�iBQM +QmH/ #2 mb2/ BM 2M;BM22`BM; +QMi2tibX

q?BH2 i?2 ǳ2pQivT2Ǵ Bb MQi � #`�M/ M2r +QM+2Ti- i?2 +`2�iBQM
Q7 � bi�M/�`/Bx2/ i2`K 7Q` i?Bb MQiBQM +�M ?2HT iQ #2ii2` Q`B2Mi
7mim`2 BM[mB`B2bX

https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PL392C752E633E1B6A
https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PL392C752E633E1B6A
https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PL8ftIIJ7ANZhTWjlGMRClyXKDsI6VTk7R
https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PL8ftIIJ7ANZhTWjlGMRClyXKDsI6VTk7R


9y L2rb

h?2 S�bbBM; Q7 � :2M2`�iBQM

h?2 H�bi b2p2`�H KQMi?b ?�b ?2`�H/2/ i?2 /2�i?b Q7 K�Mv
T`QKBM2Mi b+B2MiBbib �M/ #BQHQ;Bbib- BM+Hm/BM;,

Ç _B+?�`/ G2rQMiBM URNkNĜkykRV, G2rQMiBM r�b � ;2M2iB@
+Bbi r?Q r�b Km+? KQ`2 BM imM2 rBi? ?Bb T?BHQbQT?B+�H
bB/2 i?�M K�Mv Q7 ?Bb +QHH2�;m2bX >2 MQi QMHv TBQM22`2/
i?2 �TTHB+�iBQM Q7 KQH2+mH�` #BQHQ;v iQ i?2 bim/v Q7 2pQ@
HmiBQM�`v /vM�KB+b- #mi �HbQ +QM+2`M2/ ?BKb2H7 rBi? i?2
T?BHQbQT?v Q7 b+B2M+2 �M/ Bib BMi2`b2+iBQM rBi? i?2 Tm#HB+
/B�HQ;m2X >Bb KQbi rB/2Hv@`2�/ rQ`F r�b � TQTmH�` `2pB2r
Q7 *�`H a�;�MǶb h?2 .2KQM@>�mMi2/ qQ`H/- iBiH2/ ǳ"BH@
HBQMb �M/ "BHHBQMb Q7 .2KQMbǴ UG2rQMiBM- RNNdVX >Qr@
2p2`- ?Bb KQbi H�biBM; +QMi`B#miBQM Bb HBF2Hv ?Bb +`BiB[m2
Q7 i?2 Qp2`Hv bBKTHBbiB+ `2H�iBQMb?BT #2ir22M �/�Ti�iBQM
�M/ M�im`�H b2H2+iBQM Q7i2M bm;;2bi2/ #v K�Mv #BQHQ;Bbib
UG2rQMiBM- RNd3VX �M Q#Bim�`v +�M #2 7QmM/ BM "`QrM
�M/ _Qb2 UkykRVX

Ç ai2p2M q2BM#2`; URNjjĜkykRV, q2BM#2`; Bb Q7i2M +QM@
bB/2`2/ i?2 ;`2�i2bi i?2Q`2iB+�H T?vbB+Bbi Q7 �HH iBK2- 2�`M@
BM; i?2 LQ#2H S`Bx2 BM RNdNX >2 mMB}2/ 2H2+i`QK�;M2iBbK
�M/ i?2 r2�F 7Q`+2 BM T?vbB+b BMiQ i?2 2H2+i`Qr2�F 7Q`+2
Uq2BM#2`;- RNedVX �M Q#Bim�`v +�M #2 7QmM/ BM :Bm/B+2
UkykRVX

Ç h?QK�b *�p�HB2`@aKBi? URN9kĜkykRV, *�p�HB2`@aKBi?
r�b � ?B;?Hv `2;�`/2/ i�tQMQKBbi r?Q Tmb?2/ 7Q`r�`/
GvMM J�`;mHBbǶ 2M/QbvK#BQiB+ i?2Q`vX >2 �`;m2/ 7Q` �
ǳKBiQ+?QM/`B�H@H�i2Ǵ KQ/2H- BM r?B+? i?2 2mF�`vQi2b /2@
p2HQT rBi?Qmi KBiQ+?QM/`B�- 2p2Mim�HHv 2M;mH}M; `2H2p�Mi
#�+i2`B� i?`Qm;? T?�;Q+viQbBb U*�p�HB2`@aKBi?- kyyec
�`+?B#�H/- kyR8c :`�v- kyRdVX �M Q#Bim�`v +�M #2 7QmM/
BM _B+?�`/b UkykRVX

Ç :BH#2`i G2pBM URNk9ĜkykRV, G2pBM r�b i?2 T`BM+BT�H BM@
p2biB;�iQ` 7Q` i?2 oBFBM; JBbbBQM G�#2H2/ _2H2�b2 2tT2`@
BK2Mi- r?B+?- i?Qm;? +QMi`Qp2`bB�H- ?2 #2HB2p2/ b?Qr2/
2pB/2M+2 i?�i i?2`2 r�b KB+`Q#B�H HB72 QM J�`b UG2pBM-
kyReVX >2 +QMiBMm2/ iQ TH�v � T`QKBM2Mi `QH2 BM i?2 }2H/
Q7 �bi`Q#BQHQ;v i?`Qm;?Qmi ?Bb HB72X

q?BH2 *"A /Q2b MQi MQ`K�HHv TQbi Q#Bim�`B2b- i?2 T�bbBM; Q7 bQ
K�Mv b2KBM�H b+B2MiBbib BM bm+? � b?Q`i T2`BQ/ b22K2/ MQi2@
rQ`i?vX

1pQHmiBQM�`v S`BK�HBiv Q7 i?2 "�+i2`B�H
6H�;2HHmK

PM2 Bbbm2 i?�i ?�b #22M +QMi2MiBQmb Qp2` i?2 T�bi 72r /2+�/2b
Bb r?2i?2` Q` MQi i?2 ~�;2HH�` KQiQ` 2pQHp2/ 7`QK i?2 hvT2
AAA b2+`2iQ`v bvbi2KX h?Bb ?�b bT�`F2/ /2#�i2 Qp2` i?2 v2�`b-
#mi Bi b22Kb i?�i i?Bb [m2biBQM Bb +QKBM; iQ � +HQb2 BM 7�pQ`
Q7 i?2 T`BK�HBiv Q7 i?2 ~�;2HHmKX h?Bb ?�b #22M +QM}`K2/
#v KmHiBTH2 bim/B2b- KQbi `2+2MiHv .2M; 2i �HX UkyRdV- .2MBb2-
�##v- �M/ _Q+?� UkykyV- �M/ *QH2K�M 2i �HX UkykRVX 1p2M
7Q`K2` pQ+�H +`BiB+b Q7 i?Bb B/2� US�HH2M �M/ J�ixF2- kyyeV �`2
MQr +QMpBM+2/ UJ�ixF2 2i �HX- kykRVX

q`BiBM; lbBM; UQMHvV uQm` AK�;BM�iBQM

� `2+2Mi T�T2` /2b+`B#2b �M �K�xBM; M2r i2+?MQHQ;v r?B+?
�HHQrb T�`�Hvx2/ T2QTH2 iQ r`Bi2 mbBM; i?2B` i?Qm;?ib �HQM2
UqBHH2ii 2i �HX- MX/XVX 1bb2MiB�HHv- BKTH�Mi2/ 2H2+i`Q/2b �H@
HQr � T2`bQM iQ bBKmH�i2 i?2 KQiQ` QmiTmi 7Q` ?�M/r`BiBM;X
h?Bb ǳ?�M/r`BiBM;Ǵ Bb i?2M mb2/ �b BMTmi iQ � M2m`�H M2irQ`F-
r?B+? /2+Q/2b i?2 ?�M/r`BiBM; BMiQ ivT2/ H2ii2`bX h?2 `2@
b2�`+? ;`QmT r�b �#H2 iQ �+?B2p2 Ny +?�`�+i2`b T2` KBMmi2-
r?B+? Bb +HQb2 iQ i?2 bT22/ �i r?B+? KQbi T2QTH2 i2ti URR8
+?�`�+i2`b T2` KBMmi2VX

*Q``2+iBM; JBb+QM+2TiBQMb �#Qmi
�#BQ;2M2bBb

avMi?2iB+ +?2KBbi C�K2b hQm` `2+2MiHv Tmi iQ;2i?2` � pB/2Q
b2`B2b +Q``2+iBM; +QKKQM KBbi�F2b �#Qmi �#BQ;2M2bBb UhQm`-
kykRVX h?Bb pB/2Q b2`B2b +Qp2`b rB/2bT`2�/ +QM7mbBQM �#Qmi
�#BQ;2M2bBb 7`QK Q`/BM�`v BM/BpB/m�Hb- i?2 K2/B�- �M/ 2p2M T`Q@
72bbBQM�HbX hQm` T`2b2Mib K�Mv Bbbm2b i?�i �`2 MQi �/2[m�i2Hv
Tm#HB+Bx2/ �#Qmi �#BQ;2M2bBb `2b2�`+?- 7Q+mbBM; 2bT2+B�HHv QM
irQ Bbbm2bX

h?2 }`bi Bb i?2 T`2p�H2M+2 Q7 mbBM; +?2KB+�Hb i?�i �`2 QMHv
7QmM/ rBi?BM #BQHQ;v iQ T2`7Q`K �#BQ;2M2bBb +?2KB+�H i�bFbX
6`QK � bvMi?2iB+ +?2KBbi`v T2`bT2+iBp2- bBM+2 i?2b2 `2�+iBQMb
rQmH/ ?�p2 iQ Q++m` QmibB/2 i?2 +QMi2ti Q7 #BQHQ;v- mbBM;
#BQHQ;B+�HHv@/2`Bp2/ +?2KB+�Hb- r?BH2 Bi K�v �HHQr i?2 `2�+iBQM
iQ rQ`F- T`2p2Mib bim/B2b 7`QK �+im�HHv /Bb+Qp2`BM; Km+? �#Qmi
�#BQ;2M2bBbX

h?2 b2+QM/ Bb i?2 T`Q#H2K Q7 mbBM; � ǳ`2H�v bvMi?2bBbXǴ P7i2M@
iBK2b BM �#BQ;2M2bBb bim/B2b- `2�+iBQMb rBHH `2bmHi BM � KBtim`2
Q7 � p�`B2iv Q7 +QKTQmM/bX h?Bb p�`B2iv Q7 +QKTQmM/b rBHH



oQHmK2 j- Abbm2 k

9R

i?2M T`2p2Mi 7mim`2 `2�+iBQMb 7`QK ;QBM; 7Q`r�`/X h?2`27Q`2-
`�i?2` i?�M mbBM; i?2 T`Q/m+ib Q7 i?2 T`2pBQmb `2�+iBQM iQ ;Q
BMiQ i?2 M2ti `2�+iBQM- i?2 /2bB`2/ BbQH�i2/ 2M/@T`Q/m+i Bb Tm`@
+?�b2/ Tm`2 �M/ i?2M /BHmi2/ iQ i?2 T`QT2` +QM+2Mi`�iBQMb T`BQ`
iQ i?2 M2ti `2�+iBQMX

h?2b2 irQ 72�im`2b �`2 bm`T`BbBM;Hv +QKKQM BM �#BQ;2M2bBb `2@
b2�`+?- �M/ +�HH BMiQ [m2biBQM Km+? Q7 i?2 +?2KB+�H +H�BKb 7Q`
�#BQ;2M2bBb `2b2�`+? �#Qmi r?�i +QmH/ ?�p2 #22M bvMi?2bBx2/
�#BQiB+�HHv QM i?2 2�`Hv 2�`i?X

h?2 a+B2M+2 Q7 *QMb2Mbmb@6Q`KBM;

h?2 �JAah�. H�# 7`QK >�`p2v Jm// *QHH2;2 BM *�HB7Q`MB�
b?Qrb i?�i � ǳ+QMb2MbmbǴ Bb QMHv p�HB/ 7Q` #2HB2pBM; � T`QQ7
B7 i?2 +QMb2Mbmb r�b 7Q`K2/ #v T2QTH2 r?Qb2 i?BMFBM; r�b
BM/2T2M/2Mi U�HH2M- G�v- �M/ JQMi�Ƣ2x- kykyVX h?�i Bb- B7
KmHiBTH2 2tT2`ib +�K2 iQ i?2 b�K2 +QM+HmbBQM BM/2T2M/2MiHv-
i?2M i?2 +QMb2Mbmb ?�b � Km+? ?B;?2` T`Q#�#BHBiv Q7 #2BM;
i`m2X >Qr2p2`- B7 i?Qb2 b�K2 2tT2`ib r2`2 +Q2`+2/- Q` 2p2M
BM~m2M+2/ #v i?2 T`BQ` B/2� Q7 � +QMb2Mbmb- i?2M i?2 2TBbi2KB+
p�Hm2 Q7 ?�pBM; � +QMb2Mbmb b?`BMFb [mB+FHvX

LQp2H "�+i2`B�H 1pQHp2/ QM i?2 aT�+2
ai�iBQM

_2b2�`+? ?�b bi�`i2/ iQ #2 /QM2 QM i?2 2z2+i Q7 bT�+2 i`�p2H iQ
2pQHmiBQMX _2+2MiHv- 7Qm` MQp2H bi`�BMb Q7 J2i?vHQ#�+i2`B�+2�2
?�p2 #22M 7QmM/ QM i?2 AMi2`M�iBQM�H aT�+2 ai�iBQM U"BDH�MB-
aBM;?- 2i �HX- kykRVX h?2b2 �`2 #2BM; M�K2/ �7i2` �DK�H E?�M-
� `2MQrM2/ AM/B�M b+B2MiBbi �M/ #BQ/Bp2`bBiv bT2+B�HBbiX AM �M@
Qi?2` �`iB+H2- i?2 �mi?Q`b ?�p2 /Bb+mbb2/ i?2 T`2b2Mi �M/ 7mim`2
Q7 bT�+2 KB+`Q#BQHQ;v U"BDH�MB- ai2T?2Mb- 2i �HX- MX/XVX

1pQHmiBQM �M/ h2H2QMQKv

� `2+2Mi +QM72`2M+2 r�b ?2H/ #v i?2 GBMM�2�M aQ+B2iv Q7
GQM/QM +�HH2/ 1pQHmiBQM ǵPM Sm`TQb2Ƕ, h2H2QMQKv BM GBp@
BM; avbi2KbX h?Bb +QM72`2M+2 /Bb+mbb2/ i?2 `QH2b Q7 BM@
i2MiBQM�HBiv BM 2pQHmiBQM- �M/ ?Qr i?Bb �z2+ib 2pQHmiBQM@
�`v i?2Q`v �b � r?QH2X o�`BQmb �bT2+ib Q7 i2H2QMQKv �M/
i2H2QHQ;v r2`2 /Bb+mbb2/ #v � p�`B2iv Q7 `2MQrM2/ b+?QH@
�`b- BM+Hm/BM; S2i2` *Q`MBM;- _B+?�`/ o�M2@q`B;?i- aim@
�`i E�mzK�M- 1m;2M2 EQQMBM- 1p� C�#HQMF�- �M/ b2p@
2`�H Qi?2`bX oB/2Qb Q7 i?2 +QM72`2M+2 �`2 �p�BH�#H2 QM
i?2 GBMM�2�M aQ+B2iv uQmhm#2 +?�MM2H QM i?2 TH�vHBbi 7Q`

i?2 +QM72`2M+2 �i ?iiTb,ffrrrXvQmim#2X+QKfTH�vHBbi\
HBbi4SG;o>Rm68GEolDL�r6BwE2h.ywK6o�a9v/X h?2 "Hvi?
AMbiBim2 T�`iB+BT�i2/ BM i?2 +QM72`2M+2- ;BpBM; � b?Q`i �M�HvbBb
/m`BM; i?2 `272`22/ +QKK2Mi�`v b2bbBQM �M/ i�FBM; T�`i i?2
i?2 /Bb+mbbBQM b2bbBQMX

1tT2`BK2Mi�H _2bmHib

� M2r DQm`M�H 7`QK *�K#`B/;2 lMBp2`bBiv S`2bb r�b H�mM+?2/
H�bi v2�` +�HH2/ i?2 CQm`M�H Q7 1tT2`BK2Mi�H _2bmHibX h?2 B/2�
#2?BM/ i?Bb DQm`M�H Bb iQ `2+Q`/ 2tT2`BK2Mib i?�i ?�p2 H2bb
ǳbiQ`vǴ iQ i?2KX h?2 �BK Q7 i?Bb DQm`M�H Bb iQ bmTTQ`i `2b2�`+?
;`QmTb /QBM; `2THB+�iBQM 2tT2`BK2Mib Q` r?Q r�Mi iQ Tm#HBb?
2tT2`BK2Mi�H `2bmHib i?�i /QMǶi M2+2bb�`BHv ?�p2 � bm``QmM/BM;
i?2Q`vX h?2 DQm`M�H rBHH �HbQ Tm#HBb? M2;�iBp2 Q` BM+QM+HmbBp2
`2bmHibX

hvTB+�HHv- DQm`M�Hb �`2 #B�b2/ iQr�`/b `2bmHib i?�i �`2 U�V TQbB@
iBp2- U#V MQp2H- �M/ U+V �ii�+?2/ iQ �M mM/2`HvBM; i?2Q`vX >Qr@
2p2`- i?Bb /Q2b BM 7�+i #B�b i?2 QmiTmi Q7 DQm`M�HbX h?2 ;Q�H Q7
i?2 M2r DQm`M�H Bb iQ +QK#�i i?Bb #B�b #v T`QpB/BM; �M QmiH2i
7Q` 2tT2`BK2Mi�H bim/B2b i?�i /QMǶi ivTB+�HHv ǳ}i BMǴ BM i?Bb r�vX
h?2 r2#bBi2 7Q` i?2 DQm`M�H +�M #2 7QmM/ �i ?iiTb,ffrrrX
+�K#`B/;2XQ`;f+Q`2fDQm`M�Hbf2tT2`BK2Mi�H@`2bmHibX

>mK�M@:2M2`�i2/ J�+?BM2 G2�`MBM;
JQ/2Hb

"Hvi? AMbiBimi2 `2b2�`+?2` 1`B+ >QHHQr�v ?�b /QM2 [mBi2 � #Bi
Q7 rQ`F rBi? ?mK�M@BM@i?2@HQQT K�+?BM2 H2�`MBM;- r?B+? ?2
i2`Kb ǳBK�;BM�iBQM b�KTHBM;Ǵ r?2`2 ?mK�Mb T�`iB+BT�i2 BM
#mBH/BM; K�+?BM2 H2�`MBM; KQ/2Hb U>QHHQr�v- kyRdc >QHHQr�v-
MX/Xc >QHHQr�v �M/ J�`Fb AA- kyReVX _2+2MiHv- �MQi?2` `2@
b2�`+?2` ?�b #2;mM /2p2HQTBM; iQQHb iQ 7�+BHBi�i2 BK�;BM�iBQM
b�KTHBM; rBi? i?2 ǳ?mK�M H2�`MǴ T`QD2+i Uq�`K2`/�K- kykyVX
h?Bb BM+Hm/2b � iQQH i?�i H2ib T2QTH2 /`�r ;`QmTb �`QmM/
/�i�b2ib- �M/ i?2 /`�rBM;b ;2i +QMp2`i2/ BMiQ K�+?BM2 H2�`M@
BM; KQ/2HbX q2 �`2 2t+Bi2/ i?�i KQ`2 T2QTH2 �`2 `2+Q;MBxBM;
i?2 p�Hm2 Q7 BK�;BM�iBQM b�KTHBM; �M/ Bib `QH2 BM i?2 K�+?BM2
H2�`MBM; 2+Qbvbi2KX

� /2KQMbi`�iBQM Q7 i?2 iQQH +�M #2 7QmM/ �i ?iiTb,
ffFQ�MBM;X;Bi?m#XBQf?mK�M@H2�`MfOBMi2`�+iBp2@
/`�rBM;bX

https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLgVH1uF5LKVUjNAwFiZKeTD0ZmFVaS4yd
https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLgVH1uF5LKVUjNAwFiZKeTD0ZmFVaS4yd
https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/experimental-results
https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/experimental-results
https://koaning.github.io/human-learn/#interactive-drawings
https://koaning.github.io/human-learn/#interactive-drawings
https://koaning.github.io/human-learn/#interactive-drawings


9k L2rb

_272`2M+2b

�HH2M- C- * G�v- �M/ : . JQMi�Ƣ2x UkykyVX ǳ� *�bi`Q *QMb2M@
bmb, lM/2`bi�M/BM; i?2 _QH2 Q7 .2T2M/2M+2 BM *QMb2Mbmb
6Q`K�iBQMǴX AM, S`Q+22/BM;b Q7 i?2 kyky h`mi? �M/ h`mbi
PMHBM2- TTX RkĜkyX m`H, ?iiTb,ffrrrX+bX?K+X2/mf
�KQMi�M2xfT/7bf�HH2M@ kyky@ +�bi`Q@ +QMb2MbmbX
T/7X

�`+?B#�H/- C J UkyR8VX AM, *m``2Mi "BQHQ;v k8- _NRRĜ_NkRX
/QB, RyXRyRefDX+m#XkyR8XydXy88X

"�`iH2ii- C- G :��bi`�- �M/ . L2K�iB UkykyVX ǳ>vT2``2�H LmK@
#2`b 7Q` AM}MBi2 .Bp2`;2Mi a2`B2bǴX AM, *QKKmMB+�iBQMb Q7
i?2 "Hvi? AMbiBimi2 kXR- TTX dĜR8X

"�`iH2ii- C G- . >�HbK2`- �M/ J _ >�HH UkyR9VX 1M;BM22`BM;
�M/ i?2 lHiBK�i2, �M AMi2`/Bb+BTHBM�`v AMp2biB;�iBQM Q7 P`@
/2` �M/ .2bB;M BM L�im`2 �M/ *`�7iX "Hvi? AMbiBimi2 S`2bbX

"�`iH2ii- C G �M/ 1 >QHHQr�v UkyRdVX L�im`�HBbK �M/ Aib �Hi2`@
M�iBp2b BM a+B2MiB}+ J2i?Q/QHQ;B2bX "Hvi? AMbiBimi2 S`2bbX

"BDH�MB- a- L E aBM;?- 2i �HX UkykRVX ǳJ2i?vHQ#�+i2`BmK �DK�HBB
bTX MQpX- AbQH�i2/ 6`QK i?2 AMi2`M�iBQM�H aT�+2 ai�iBQMǴX
AM, 6`QMiB2`b BM JB+`Q#BQHQ;v Rk- TTX RĜR9X /QB, RyXjj3Nf
7KB+#XkykRXejNjNeX

"BDH�MB- a- 1 ai2T?2Mb- 2i �HX UMX/XVX ǳ�/p�M+2b BM bT�+2 KB@
+`Q#BQHQ;vǴX AM, Ba+B2M+2 k9X8 UVX /QB, RyXRyRefDXBb+BX
kykRXRykjN8X

"`QrM- � �M/ a _Qb2 UkykRVX ǳ_B+?�`/ G2rQMiBM Q#Bim�`vǴX
AM, h?2 :m�`/B�MX m`H, ?iiTb,ffrrrXi?2;m�`/B�MX
+QK f b+B2M+2 f kykR f DmH f k3 f `B+?�`/ @ H2rQMiBM @
Q#Bim�`vX

*�TQ`�H2- G > UkyyeVX h?2 AKTHB+Bi :2MQK2X Pt7Q`/ lMBp2`bBiv
S`2bbX

*�biH2- a .- * a :`B2`bQM- �M/ h 1 :Q`Q+?QrbFB UMX/XVX ǳhQ@
r�`/b �M 2M;BM22`BM; i?2Q`v Q7 2pQHmiBQMǴX AM, L�im`2 *QK@
KmMB+�iBQMb RkXjjke UVX /QB, RyXRyj3fb9R9ed@ ykR@
kj8dj@jX

*�p�HB2`@aKBi?- h UkyyeVX ǳP`B;BM Q7 JBiQ+?QM/`B� #v AMi`�+2H@
HmH�` 1MbH�p2K2Mi Q7 � S?QiQbvMi?2iB+ Sm`TH2 "�+i2`BmKǴX
AM, S`Q+22/BM;b Q7 i?2 _Qv�H aQ+B2iv " kdj- TTX RN9jĜ
RN8kX /QB, RyXRyN3f`bT#XkyyeXj8jRX

*QH2K�M- : � 2i �HX UkykRVX ǳ� `QQi2/ T?vHQ;2Mv `2bQHp2b 2�`Hv
#�+i2`B�H 2pQHmiBQMǴX AM, a+B2M+2 jdkXe89kX /QB, RyXRRkef
b+B2M+2X�#2y8RRX

.2M;- q 2i �HX UkyRdVX ǳ�bb2K#Hv- bi`m+im`2- 7mM+iBQM �M/ `2;@
mH�iBQM Q7 ivT2 AAA b2+`2iBQM bvbi2KbǴX AM, L�im`2 _2pB2rb
JB+`Q#BQHQ;v R8- TTX jkjĜjjdX

.2MBb2- _- a a �##v- �M/ 1 S * _Q+?� UkykyVX ǳh?2 1pQHmiBQM
Q7 S`Qi2BM a2+`2iBQM avbi2Kb #v *Q@QTiBQM �M/ hBMF2`BM;
Q7 *2HHmH�` J�+?BM2`B2bǴX AM, h`2M/b BM JB+`Q#BQHQ;v k3X8-
TTX jdkĜj3eX /QB, RyXRyRefDXiBKXkykyXyRXyy8X

:Bm/B+2- : UkykRVX ǳai2p2M q2BM#2`; RNjjĜkykRǴX AM, *1_L
*Qm`B2`X m`H, ?iiTb,ff+2`M+Qm`B2`X+QKf�fbi2p2M@
r2BM#2`;@RNjj@kykRfX

:`�v- J q UkyRdVX ǳGvMM J�`;mHBb �M/ i?2 2M/QbvK#BQMi
?vTQi?2bBb, 8y v2�`b H�i2`ǴX AM, JQH2+mH�` "BQHQ;v Q7 i?2
*2HH k3XRy- TTX Rk38ĜRk3dX /QB, RyXRyNRfK#+X1Re@yd@
y8yNX

>QHHQr�v- 1 UkyRdVX ǳAK�;BM�iBQM a�KTHBM;ǴX AM, L�im`�HBbK
�M/ Aib �Hi2`M�iBp2b BM a+B2MiB}+ J2i?Q/QHQ;B2bX 1/X #v C
G "�`iH2ii �M/ 1 >QHHQr�vX "Hvi? AMbiBimi2 S`2bb- TTX RdNĜ
RN3X

>QHHQr�v- 1 UMX/XVX ǳAKT`QpBM; s:"QQbi rBi? AK�;BM�iBQM
a�KTHBM;ǴX AM, *QKKmMB+�iBQMb Q7 i?2 "Hvi? AMbiBimi2 kXR
UV- TTX jĜeX /QB, RyXjjyR9fBbbMXke9y@ 8e8kXkXRX
?QHHQr�vXRX

>QHHQr�v- 1 �M/ _ C J�`Fb AA UkyReVX ǳ>B;? .BK2MbBQM�H >m@
K�M :mB/2/ J�+?BM2 G2�`MBM;ǴX AM, �`sBp ReyNXyyNy9X
m`H, ?iiTb,ff�`tBpXQ`;f�#bfReyNXyyNy9X

G2pBM- : o UkyReVX ǳh?2 *�b2 7Q` 1ti�Mi GB72 QM J�`b �M/
Bib SQbbB#H2 .2i2+iBQM #v i?2 oBFBM; G�#2H2/ _2H2�b2 1t@
T2`BK2MiǴX AM, �bi`Q#BQHQ;v ReXRy- TTX dN3Ĝ3RyX /QB, RyX
Ry3Nf�biXkyR8XR9e9X

G2rQMiBM- _ URNd3VX AM, a+B2MiB}+ �K2`B+�M kjNXj- TTX kRkĜ
kR3X /QB, RyXRyj3fb+B2MiB7B+�K2`B+�MyNd3@kRkX

G2rQMiBM- _ URNNdVX ǳ"BHHBQMb �M/ "BHHBQMb Q7 .2KQMbǴX AM,
L2r uQ`F _2pB2r Q7 "QQFbX m`H, ?iiTb , f f rrr X
Mv#QQFbX+QKf�`iB+H2bfRNNdfyRfyNf#BHHBQMb@�M/@
#BHHBQMb@Q7@/2KQMbfX

J�ixF2- L C 2i �HX UkykRVX ǳ6H�;2HH�` 2tTQ`i �TT�`�imb �M/
�hS bvMi?2i�b2, >QKQHQ;v 2pB/2M+2/ #v bvMi2Mv T`2/�i@
BM; i?2 G�bi lMBp2`b�H *QKKQM �M+2biQ`ǴX AM, "BQ1bb�vb
9jXdX /QB, RyXRyykf#B2bXkykRyyyy9X

S�HH2M- J C �M/ L C J�ixF2 UkyyeVX ǳ6`QK h?2 P`B;BM Q7
aT2+B2b iQ i?2 Q`B;BM Q7 #�+i2`B�H ~�;2HH�ǴX AM, L�im`2 _2@
pB2rb JB+`Q#BQHQ;v 9XRy- TTX d39ĜdNyX /QB, RyXRyj3f
M`KB+`QR9NjX

_B+?�`/b- h UkykRVX ǳh?QK�b *�p�HB2`@aKBi? URN9kĜkykRVǴX
AM, L�im`2 8Nj- TX RNyX /QB, RyXRyj3f/9R83e@ ykR@
yRk8y@RX

hQm`- C UkykRVX �//`2bbBM; �#BQ;2M2bBb �M/ *QKKQM JBb+QM@
+2TiBQMbX m`H, ?iiTb,ffrrrXvQmim#2X+QKfTH�vHBbi\
HBbi4SGAGqm/rn39ikh>"pCw6vmG�y[ptr`A".`X

q�`K2`/�K- o . UkykyVX >mK�M G2�`M, J�+?BM2 G2�`MBM;
KQ/2Hb b?QmH/ TH�v #v i?2 `mH2b- HBi2`�HHvX m`H, ?iiTb,
ff;Bi?m#X+QKfFQ�MBM;f?mK�M@H2�`MX

q2BM#2`;- a URNedVX ǳ� JQ/2H Q7 G2TiQMbǴX AM, S?vbB+�H _2@
pB2r G2ii2`b RNXkR- TTX Rke9ĜRkeeX /QB, Ry X RRyj f
S?vb_2pG2iiXRNXRke9X

qBHH2ii- 6 _ 2i �HX UMX/XVX ǳ>B;?@T2`7Q`K�M+2 #`�BM@iQ@i2ti
+QKKmMB+�iBQM pB� ?�M/r`BiBM;ǴX AM, L�im`2 8Nj UV-
TTX k9NĜk89X /QB, RyXRyj3fb9R83e@ykR@yj8ye@kX

https://www.cs.hmc.edu/~montanez/pdfs/allen-2020-castro-consensus.pdf
https://www.cs.hmc.edu/~montanez/pdfs/allen-2020-castro-consensus.pdf
https://www.cs.hmc.edu/~montanez/pdfs/allen-2020-castro-consensus.pdf
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cub.2015.07.055
https://doi.org/10.3389/fmicb.2021.639396
https://doi.org/10.3389/fmicb.2021.639396
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.isci.2021.102395
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.isci.2021.102395
https://www.theguardian.com/science/2021/jul/28/richard-lewontin-obituary
https://www.theguardian.com/science/2021/jul/28/richard-lewontin-obituary
https://www.theguardian.com/science/2021/jul/28/richard-lewontin-obituary
https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-021-23573-3
https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-021-23573-3
https://doi.org/10.1098/rspb.2006.3531
https://doi.org/10.1126/science.abe0511
https://doi.org/10.1126/science.abe0511
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tim.2020.01.005
https://cerncourier.com/a/steven-weinberg-1933-2021/
https://cerncourier.com/a/steven-weinberg-1933-2021/
https://doi.org/10.1091/mbc.E16-07-0509
https://doi.org/10.1091/mbc.E16-07-0509
https://doi.org/10.33014/issn.2640-5652.2.1.holloway.1
https://doi.org/10.33014/issn.2640-5652.2.1.holloway.1
https://arxiv.org/abs/1609.00904
https://doi.org/10.1089/ast.2015.1464
https://doi.org/10.1089/ast.2015.1464
https://doi.org/10.1038/scientificamerican0978-212
https://www.nybooks.com/articles/1997/01/09/billions-and-billions-of-demons/
https://www.nybooks.com/articles/1997/01/09/billions-and-billions-of-demons/
https://www.nybooks.com/articles/1997/01/09/billions-and-billions-of-demons/
https://doi.org/10.1002/bies.202100004
https://doi.org/10.1038/nrmicro1493
https://doi.org/10.1038/nrmicro1493
https://doi.org/10.1038/d41586-021-01250-1
https://doi.org/10.1038/d41586-021-01250-1
https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLILWudw_84t2THBvJZFyuLA0qvxwrIBDr
https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLILWudw_84t2THBvJZFyuLA0qvxwrIBDr
https://github.com/koaning/human-learn
https://github.com/koaning/human-learn
https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevLett.19.1264
https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevLett.19.1264
https://doi.org/10.1038/s41586-021-03506-2

	About This Journal
	The Purpose of the Journal
	Paper Submission Policies
	Other Journal Content

	From the Editors
	Eugenio DarbesioEugenio DarbesioA Corollary of the Conant-Ashby Theorem Applied to Abiogenesis
	Robert SheldonRobert SheldonComets, Water, and Big Bang Nucleosynthesis
	Introduction
	Benefits of a Magnetized Big Bang and Dark Matter Comets
	Consequences of Primordial Comets
	Analysis
	Conclusions
	Acknowledgments

	Robert J Marks IIRobert J Marks IISolution of the Grazing Goat Problem: A Conflict between Beauty and Pragmatism
	Background
	Grazing Goat Problem Solution
	Grazing Goat Problem Inversion
	Final Thought

	Letters and Notes
	Eric Holloway2D Puzzle Visualizations of Boolean Formulae
	Jonathan BartlettThe Products of Hyperreal Series and the Limitations of Cauchy Products
	Tom and Elizabeth SiewertFollowing the Science

	News

