

































oQHmK2 j- Abbm2 R

Ab AM7Q`K�iBQM *QMi2Mi � aBM;H2- ai�iB+ Zm�MiBiv\ jN

i?2 }M�H Bbbm2 �//`2bb2/ ?2`2BM `2;�`/BM; *HmMMǶb +H�BK i?�i
Q#D2+iBp2 KQ`�HBiv 2tBbibX

*QM~B+i Oj, P#D2+iBp2 JQ`�HBiv Bb am#D2+iBp2

�++Q`/BM; iQ *HmMM- i?2 ;Q�H Q7 ?Bb rQ`F Bb iQ 2bi�#HBb? � bBK@
TH2 r�v 7Q` T2QTH2 iQ K�F2 KQ`�H +?QB+2b i?�i /Q MQi `2Hv QM
bQK2 /22THv 2bQi2`B+ T?BHQbQT?vX q?BH2 i?Bb ;Q�H Bb H�m/�#H2-
*HmMMǶb +H�BK iQ Q#D2+iBp2 KQ`�H `2�HBiv `2K�BMb 7`mbi`�iBM;Hv
bm#D2+iBp2X 1p2M B7 r2 ;`�Mi i?�i +QMb+BQmbM2bb Bb � 7mM/�@
K2Mi�H �tBQK �M/ i?�i KQ`�HBiv 2tBbib BM bQK2 M2Q@SH�iQMB+
7Q`K- i?Bb b�vb MQi?BM; �#Qmi ?Qr r2 b?QmH/ 2pBM+2 i?Bb mM@
Q#b2`p�#H2 KQ`�H `2�HKX >Qr /Q2b *HmMMǶb 7QmM/�iBQM�HBbK
bQHp2 i?2 BbfQm;?i T`Q#H2K\ *HmMM +QM+2/2b i?�i 2p2M ;Bp2M
?Bb #2HB27 BM �M Q#D2+iBp2 KQ`�H `2�HK- ǳi?2`2 Bb MQi � T?vbB+�H
BKT2`�iBp2 iQ �/?2`2 iQ Bi U98VXǴ AM i?2 2M/- *HmMMǶb KQ`�H@
Biv b22Kb HBF2 � T?BHQbQT?B+�HHv +QKTH2t p2`bBQM Q7 i?2 2[m�HHv
BKT`�+iB+�H KQ`�H i`QT2- ǵ7QHHQr vQm` ?2�`iXǶ

*HmMMǶb +H�BK iQ Q#D2+iBp2 KQ`�HBiv 2M/b BM � +QM7mbBM; bm#D2+@
iBpBivX >2 r`Bi2b- ǳA /QMǶi T`2b+`B#2 ?2`2 �Mv bT2+B}+ �+iBQMb
i?�i � ?mK�M b?QmH/ i�F2 iQ #2 KQ`�H Q` BKKQ`�HX aT2+B}+ �+@
iBQMb +�M �M/ b?QmH/ #2 bm#D2+iBp2 iQ 2�+? BM/BpB/m�H U99Ĝ98VXǴ
LQr iQ bm;;2bi i?�i KQ`�HBiv Bb Q#D2+iBp2- #mi �HH BM/BpB/m�H �+@
iBQMb �`2 bm#D2+iBp2 �M/ #2vQM/ Dm/;2K2Mi 7`QK Qi?2`b QMHv
#2;b i?2 [m2biBQM �#Qmi r?�i Bi K2�Mb iQ p�Hm2 HB72\ *HmMM
Bb �r�`2 i?�i ?Bb /m�HBbi KQ`�HBiv H2�/b iQ KQ`�H +QM7mbBQM �M/
H2�p2b QT2M i?2 �`;mK2Mi i?�i ǵKB;?i K�F2b `B;?iXǶ hQ 2p�/2
i?Bb HQQKBM; T`Q#H2K- ?2 �bb2`ib i?�i +QMb+BQmbM2bb Bb �M 2K2`@
;2Mi 7mM+iBQM Q7 2tBbi2M+2- #mi ?2 7�BHb iQ b?Qr ?Qr i?Bb +H�BK
HQ;B+�HHv mM/2`KBM2b i?2 ǵKB;?i K�F2b `B;?iǶ T?BHQbQT?vX 1p2M
rQ`b2- *HmMM �/KBib i?�i i�FBM; HB72 Bb mMDmbi- #mi #2HB2p2b ?Bb
QrM rBHHBM;M2bb iQ i�F2 � ?mK�M HB72 Bb pB`imQmbX >2 r`Bi2b-
ǳA ?�p2 MQ [m�HKb- MQ` /Q2b Kv KQ`�HBiv- rBi? i�FBM; � HB72 B7
i?�i HB72 Bb /2+B/BM; iQ /2bi`Qv Qi?2` HBp2b U98VXǴ "mi B7- �b ?2
+H�BKb- i?2`2 Bb MQ #�bBb iQ Dm/;2 i?2 +QMb+B2MiBQmb 7`22 KQ`�H
+?QB+2 Q7 �MQi?2` T2`bQM- QM r?�i 7QmM/�iBQMěQmibB/2 Q7 ?Bb
QrM bm#D2+iBp2 QTBMBQMě/Q2b *HmMM /2+B/2 Bi Bb `B;?i iQ 2M/
i?2 HB72 Q7 �MQi?2` T2`bQM\ J�v#2 i?2 T2`bQM *HmMM +?Qb2
iQ FBHH ?�/ � `2�bQM rBi?BM i?2B` QrM KBM/ i?�i DmbiB}2/ i?2B`
+?QB+2 iQ i�F2 � HB72X J�v#2 i?2v FBHH2/ BM i?2 ?QT2 i?�i i?2B`
�+i rQmH/ b2`p2 i?2 ?B;?2` pB`im2 Q7 T`Qi2+iBM; HBp2bX PM r?�i
;`QmM/ /Q2b *HmMM Dm/;2 i?2B` �+i �b �M 2pBH\ �M/ r?�i B7
Kv bm#D2+iBp2 KQ`�HBiv i2HHb K2 i?�i *HmMMǶb +?QB+2 iQ FBHH Bb
r`QM;\ q?�i rQmH/ F22T K2 7`QK +QMiBMmBM; i?Bb b�K2 +v@
+H2 Q7 pBQH2M+2\ >Qr +�M *HmMM +H�BK iQ T`2b2`p2 i?2 ;2M2`�H
T`BM+BTH2 Q7 HB72- rBi?Qmi T`Qi2+iBM; i?2 BM/BpB/m�H HB72 Q7 2�+?
T2`bQM\

*QM+HmbBQM

h?Bb �`iB+H2 Qz2`2/ � #`B27 +`BiB[m2 Q7 *HmMMǶb 7QmM/�iBQM�HBbK
r?B+? ;`QmM/b KQ`�H /2+BbBQM K�FBM; BM r?�i ?2 +�HHb i?2 i?`22
7mM/�K2Mi�H �tBQKb Q7 2tBbi2M+2- +QMb+BQmbM2bb- �M/ B/2MiBivX
Ai b?Qr2/ ?Qr ?Bb +QKKBiK2Mi iQ M2Q@SH�iQMBbK- Q` TQbbB#Hv
T�Mi?2BbK- +`2�i2b �i H2�bi i?`22 BM+Q?2`2M+B2b r?2`2BM � T`BQ`B
Bb � TQbi2`BQ`B- BM/BpB/m�HBiv Bb �M BHHmbBQM- �M/ Q#D2+iBp2 KQ`�HBiv
Bb bm#D2+iBp2X 6Q` *HmMMǶb KQ`�H T?BHQbQT?v iQ Qz2` T`�+iB+�H
p�Hm2- i?2b2 BMi2`M�H +QM~B+ib Kmbi #2 `2bQHp2/X

*HmMM- J UkyRNVX ǳ�tBQKb Q7 JQ`�HBivǴX AM, *QKKmMB+�iBQMb
Q7 i?2 "Hvi? AMbiBimi2 RXR- TTX 9jĜ98X /QB, RyXjjyR9f
BbbMXke9y@8e8kXRXRX+HmMMXRX

Ab AM7Q`K�iBQM *QMi2Mi � aBM;H2- ai�iB+
Zm�MiBiv\
CQ`;2 62`M�M/2x
.PA, RyXjjyR9fBbbMXke9y@8e8kXjXRX72`M�M/2xXR

AM7Q`K�iBQM Bb BMbiBM+iBp2Hv �M/ +QKKQMHv `2;�`/2/ �b � bBM;H2-
bi�iB+ 2MiBivX 6Q` 2t�KTH2- mTQM H2�`MBM; i?�i ǵ?2` M�K2 Bb am@
b�MǶ r2 rQmH/ b�v i?�i r2 ?�p2 ǵ�+[mB`2/ BM7Q`K�iBQMǶX h�F2M
i?�i r�v- �M BMbi�M+2 Q7 BM7Q`K�iBQM M�im`�HHv H2�/b iQ � bBM@
;H2- bi�iB+ [m�MiBiv Q7 BM7Q`K�iBQMX h?mb- B7 �bF2/ ?Qr Km+?
BM7Q`K�iBQM Bb +QMi�BM2/ BM H2�`MBM; i?�i � ~BT Q7 � 7�B` +QBM
vB2H/2/ � ǵ?2�/bǶ- i?2 ivTB+�H �Mbr2` Bb ǵR #Bi Q7 BM7Q`K�iBQMǶ
U! log2

! 1
2
"
= 1 #BiVX

a2�bQM2/ BM7Q`K�iBQM i?2Q`Bbib �`2- Q7 +Qm`b2- �r�`2 i?�i i?2`2
Bb KQ`2 iQ Bi i?�M i?�iX u2i 2p2M i?Qb2 BM/BpB/m�Hb mbm�HHv QT@
2`�i2 rBi?BM � T�`�/B;K i?�i Bb KQbi Q7i2M MQi �b +QKT`2?2M@
bBp2 �b Bi M22/b iQ #2 iQ �//`2bb i?2 7mHH BM7Q`K�iBQM TB+im`2X
h?mb- ǵR #BiǶ K2`2Hv BM/B+�i2b i?2 MmK#2` Q7 TQbbB#H2 bi�i2b
U21 = 2 bi�i2bVX �HQM2- i?Bb MmK#2` Bb BM/Bz2`2Mi `2;�`/BM;
/22T2`- bB;MB}+�Mi �bT2+ib Q7 BM7Q`K�iBQM bm+? �b K2�MBM;X

h?2`2 Bb �M �ii`B#mi2 �#Qmi BM7Q`K�iBQM i?�i Bb 2p2M KQ`2 7mM@
/�K2Mi�H i?�M i?Qb2 +QMbB/2`�iBQMbX A �K bT2+B}+�HHv `272``BM;
iQ i?2 7�+i i?�i #27Q`2 BM7Q`K�iBQM K�v #2 K2�bm`2/ Bi Kmbi
}`bi K�MB72bi �b � bT2+B}+ FBM/ Q7 BM7Q`K�iBQM- �M/ i?�i K�M@
B72bi�iBQM �Hr�vb Q++m`b rBi?BM � }t2/ +QMi2tiX A7 �Mv +`BiB+�H
2H2K2Mi Q7 i?2 +QMi2ti Bb +?�M;2/- i?2 BM7Q`K�iBQM i?�i Bb

https://doi.org/10.33014/issn.2640-5652.1.1.clunn.1
https://doi.org/10.33014/issn.2640-5652.1.1.clunn.1
https://dx.doi.org/10.33014/issn.2640-5652.3.1.fernandez.1


9y G2ii2`b �M/ LQi2b

6B;m`2 R, � i`�MbKBii2` 2KBib � bB;M�H i?�i Bb `2+2Bp2/
BM /Bz2`2Mi r�vb #v /Bz2`2Mi 2MiBiB2b

K�MB72bi2/ �HbQ +?�M;2bX h?2 BKTHB+�iBQM Q7 i?�i Bb bB;MB}@
+�Mi, BM7Q`K�iBQM Bb MQi � bBM;H2- bi�iB+ 2MiBiv #mi BMbi2�/ Bb
� p�`B�#H2- /vM�KB+ 2MiBiv i?�i �+[mB`2b }t2/ /2}MBiBQM QMHv
rBi?BM � +QMi2tiX

G2i mb r�HF i?`Qm;? � i?Qm;?i 2tT2`BK2Mi iQ BHHmbi`�i2 bQK2
Q7 i?�iX _272` iQ 6B;m`2 RX

AK�;BM2 � `QQK i?�i +QMi�BMb }p2 K�i2`B�H 2MiBiB2b, URV �
rQQ/2M +?�B`c UkV � k@r22F@QH/ #�#v- UjV � j@v2�`@QH/ /Q;- U9V
�M 1M;HBb?@bT2�FBM; �/mHi- �M/ U8V �M �/mHi *?BM2b2 7�`K2`
rBi? MQ +QKT`2?2MbBQM Q7 i?2 1M;HBb? H�M;m�;2X 1�+? Q7 i?Qb2
2MiBiB2b Bb +�HH2/ � `2+2Bp2` UQ7 bB;M�HbVX

� T2`bQM- r?QK r2 rBHH `272` iQ �b i?2 i`�MbKBii2`- Bb #`Qm;?i
BMiQ i?Bb `QQK �M/ bT2�Fb i?2 b2Mi2M+2, ǳ_�Bb2 vQm` `B;?i
?�M/XǴ h?�i bTQF2M b2Mi2M+2 Bb i?2 bB;M�HX

1p2`v 2MiBiv- 2p2`v `2+2Bp2`- BM i?2 `QQK `2+2Bp2b i?�i bB;M�HX
q?2M �Mv K�i2`B�H 2MiBiv `2+2Bp2b � bB;M�H i?2`2 Bb � `2+2Bp2`@
bB;M�H BMi2`�+iBQM- BX2X- i?2 K�i2`B�H 2MiBiv U`2+2Bp2`V `2+2BpBM;
� bB;M�H BMi2`�+ib rBi? i?2 bB;M�HX �HH BMi2`�+iBQMb +�mb2 �
i`�Mb7Q`K�iBQM iQ i?2 2MiBiB2b BMpQHp2/X

q?2M i?�i bB;M�H@`2+2Bp2` BMi2`�+iBQM Q++m`b- i?2 bB;M�H rBHH
�Hr�vb K�MB72bi �b BM7Q`K�iBQM iQ i?2 `2+2Bp2`X h?2 bB;MB}+�Mi
TQBMi Bb i?�i i?2 bT2+B}+ ivT2 Q7 BM7Q`K�iBQM i?�i Bb K�MB72bi2/
7Q` 2�+? Q7 i?Qb2 `2+2Bp2`b rBHH #2 /Bz2`2MiX h?mb- r?BH2 i?2
ǵ`2+2Bp2/ BM7Q`K�iBQMǶ Ui?2 BM7Q`K�iBQM i?�i Bběi?2 `2+2Bp2/
bB;M�HV Bb i?2 b�K2- i?2 BM7Q`K�iBQM i?�i Bb K�MB72bi2/ Ui?2

BM7Q`K�iBQM i?�i #2+QK2bV 7Q` 2�+? `2+2Bp2` Bb /Bz2`2MiX

6Q` i?2 rQQ/2M +?�B`- i?2 bB;M�H +�mb2b � T?vbB+�H 2z2+i UKQ/@
mH�i2/ �B` r�p2b BKT�+iBM; i?2 K�i2`B�HVX h?�i Bb � FBM/ Q7
BM7Q`K�iBQM +�HH2/ Tm`2Hv K�i2`B�H BM7Q`K�iBQMX h?2`2 Bb MQi
2p2M � TQbbB#BHBiv 7Q` �Mv Qi?2` FBM/ Q7 BM7Q`K�iBQM iQ #2 K�M@
B72bi2/ 7Q` i?2 rQQ/2M +?�B`X

6Q` i?2 k@r22F@QH/@#�#v- i?2 bB;M�H �HbQ +�mb2b � T?vbB+�H 27@
72+iX AM �//BiBQM- �MQi?2` FBM/ Q7 BM7Q`K�iBQM- +�HH2/ K�i2`B�H
�bbQ+B�iBp2 BM7Q`K�iBQM- Bb TQbbB#H2X h?2 i?B`/ FBM/ Q7 BM7Q`@
K�iBQM- +�HH2/ MQMK�i2`B�H �bbQ+B�iBp2 BM7Q`K�iBQM- Bb MQi v2i
TQbbB#H2 �i i?Bb bi�;2 Q7 i?2 #�#vǶb HB72 �Hi?Qm;? i?2 +�T�#BH@
Biv 7Q` i?�i FBM/ Q7 BM7Q`K�iBQM iQ K�MB72bi 2tBbib BM i?2 #�#vX
h?�i FBM/ Q7 K�MB72bi�iBQM Bb r?�i K�F2b TQbbB#H2 7Q`K�HfbvM@
i�+iB+ bi`m+im`2 �M/ �#bi`�+i b2K�MiB+ +QMi2MiX

6Q` i?2 j@v2�`@QH/ /Q;- i?2 bB;M�H �HbQ +�mb2b � T?vbB+�H 2z2+iX
AM �//BiBQM- K�i2`B�H �bbQ+B�iBp2 BM7Q`K�iBQM Bb TQbbB#H2X 6Q`
BMbi�M+2- i?2 /Q; K�v ?�p2 #22M i`�BM2/ iQ `�Bb2 Bib `B;?i T�r
mTQM ?2�`BM; i?2 bQmM/ ǳ_�Bb2 vQm` `B;?i ?�M/XǴ h?2 i?B`/
FBM/ Q7 BM7Q`K�iBQM UMQMK�i2`B�H �bbQ+B�iBp2 BM7Q`K�iBQMV rBHH
M2p2` #2 TQbbB#H2 7Q` i?2 /Q; bBM+2 i?2 +�T�#BHBiv 7Q` i?�i FBM/
Q7 BM7Q`K�iBQM Bb �#b2Mi BM /Q;bX

6Q` i?2 1M;HBb?@bT2�FBM; �/mHi- i?2 bB;M�H �HbQ +�mb2b � T?vb@
B+�H 2z2+iX AM �//BiBQM- K�i2`B�H �bbQ+B�iBp2 BM7Q`K�iBQM �M/
MQMK�i2`B�H �bbQ+B�iBp2 BM7Q`K�iBQM rBHH #2 K�MB72bi2/ 7Q` i?Bb
BM/BpB/m�HX h?2 `2bmHi UB7 ?2fb?2 +?QQb2b iQ /Q bQV rBHH #2 i?2
BM/BpB/m�H `�BbBM; i?2 `B;?i ?�M/X

6Q` i?2 �/mHi *?BM2b2 7�`K2` ?�pBM; MQ +QKT`2?2MbBQM Q7 i?2
1M;HBb? H�M;m�;2- i?2 bB;M�H �HbQ +�mb2b � T?vbB+�H 2z2+iX J�@
i2`B�H �bbQ+B�iBp2 BM7Q`K�iBQM �M/ MQMK�i2`B�H �bbQ+B�iBp2 BM@
7Q`K�iBQM �`2 TQbbB#H2 Ui?2 +�T�#BHBiv Bb i?2`2V #mi rBHH MQi #2
K�MB72bi2/ 7Q` i?Bb BM/BpB/m�HX h?2 `2bmHi Bb i?�i i?Bb *?BM2b2
7�`K2` rBHH KQbi HBF2Hv MQi `�Bb2 ?Bb `B;?i ?�M/X

h?2 ;2M2`�H B/2� Bb i?�i i?2 FBM/ Q7 BM7Q`K�iBQM i?�i K�v #2
K�MB72bi2/- �M/ mHiBK�i2Hv Bb K�MB72bi2/- 7Q` �M 2MiBiv Ui?2 `2@
+2Bp2`V rBHH /2T2M/ QM r?�i Bb +�HH2/ i?2 +QKT`2?2MbBp2 +QMi2ti
�i i?2 iBK2 i?�i � bB;M�H BMi2`�+ib rBi? i?�i 2MiBivX �Hi2`M�@
iBp2Hv- r?2M � bB;M�H BMi2`�+ib rBi? � `2+2Bp2` Bi K�MB72bib BM
/Bz2`2Mi r�vb /2T2M/BM; QM i?2 +QKT`2?2MbBp2 +QMi2tiX

h?mb- i?2 T`QtBK�i2 +�mb2ěi?2 bB;M�H Ui?2 ǵBbǶ Q7 bQK2
BM7Q`K�iBQMVě/Q2b MQi K�MB72bi �b BM7Q`K�iBQM U#2+QK2 BM@
7Q`K�iBQMV BM � bBM;H2- bi�iB+ �M/ mMp�`vBM; r�vX h?�i Bb i?2
#�bBb 7Q` bi�iBM; i?�i BM7Q`K�iBQM MQi bQ Km+? Bb bQK2i?BM; #mi
`�i?2` #2+QK2b bQK2i?BM;X 6m`i?2`KQ`2- i?Bb T?2MQK2MQM
�Hr�vb ?�TT2Mb 7Q` �HH 2MiBiB2b U�HH `2+2Bp2`bVěHBpBM; Q` MQM@
HBpBM;c M�im`�H Q` �`iB}+B�H Ui2+?MQHQ;B+�HVX


	About This Journal
	The Purpose of the Journal
	Paper Submission Policies
	Other Journal Content

	From the Editors
	Sam S Rakover and Baruch CahlonSam S Rakover and Baruch CahlonWhen is Explanation Transitive? A Methodological Note
	Introduction
	Explanatory-transitivity
	Discussion
	Acknowledgments

	Robert J. Marks IIRobert J. Marks IITiling Efflorescence of Expanding Kernels in a Fixed Periodic Array: Generalizing the Flower-Of-Life
	Introduction
	Other Expanding Kernels 
	Properties of Expanding Kernels of Varying Periodicity
	 Analysis
	Conclusions
	Appendices

	Letters and Notes
	Eric HollowayDeciding a Bitstring of 1s is Non-Random is Impossible in General
	Jonathan BartlettProving the Derivative of sin(x) Using the Pythagorean Theorem and the Unit Circle
	J R MillerA Response to Clunn's Axioms of Morality
	Jorge FernandezIs Information Content a Single, Static Quantity?

	News

