ADJUNCT EDITORS: GENERAL EDITING: BUSINESS MANAGER: REPORTS: L. Michael Griffel, associate editor Mary Obe1kevich, associate editor 0 r-CI''jt\:", if f} Margaret R. Griffel, associate editor Bar.barGJ.MisholY"assista.,IlJ Stephen Willis, assistant editor associate editor Jay Rahn, assistant editor-domestic Emmanuel Leemans, assistant editor-foreign ARTICLES: Isabelle Emerson, associate editor ,.Judith Gaull, assistant editor DISSERTATIONS: Josephine M. Cooper, associate editor Susan Testa, assistant editor BIBLIOGRAPHICA: Shai Bursztyn, associate editor Lillian S. Fraker, assistant editor SECRETARY: Virginia Papper FACULTY ADVISOR: Denis Stevens Copyright © 1969, Department of Music Columbia University, New York Printed in Great Britain '7 fll!lfrld .. kl,.'1 $rDWh. Ut1fv'€r>i, Hl.Ay .. C1 7 . U .... CORRESPONDING EDITORS Domestic "--""Raymond Kelton Boston University, Boston, Mass. H f' ,-6aniel L. .. Fa .. .. University, Waltham, Mass. --. It 1\""7 .• Bryn Mawr College I .... (' Carnegie-Mellon University-t<.'4WI];1)"l ::. -. '¥ -' • '. D. Dinwiddie Case Western Reserve University, Cleveland, Ohio ""'7-Gary L. Zeller Catholic University of America, Washington, D.C. -""Stuart Chasnoff City University ofN ew York, Brooklyn College, Brooklyn, N.Y. DAm 2 fI!!!J)li:Jt.ilj/;;Ser ,City University of New York, City College, New York, N.Y. M r -roJrs. College, Flushing, N.Y. rr' . tir' ,.. 1'-11 (),g oJ ... iA IV elVl .. or U-l •. ,,1"3 Q';Jh()(' lilA lallll@tie od'!el 'uruverslty, Ifhaca, 1'1.. • We'lner _ <;;('0:;11 - Dartmouth College, Hanover,-N,H. AparTtrI./l"t BJ. '3 -Lucy Dyal Florida State University, Tallahassee, Fla. 1.<-. /)f} bVQ.O el'\ 'Gb '. Camb.ridge, c. 3$"t kh I ... Michael Williams' \!ndlana Uruverslty, Bloommgton, Ind. I'> ex; 0.... _ William Penn/Michigan State University, East Lansing, Mich. ----:J. Theodore Johnson New York University, New York, N.Y. NortJ! Texas State University, Denton,Tex. ;-Howell Price Ohio State University, Columbus, Ohio - No It l'\>\ q lrk,'ngland University of ZUrich, ZUrich, Switzerland Uppsala University, Uppsala, Sweden Westf'alische Wilhelms University, Miinster, Germany Communications to the corresponding editors should be addressed care of the music department of the university unless otherwise noted. PUBLISHED The Music Department UNDER THE AEGIS OF COLUMBIA UNIVERSITY New York .. ,'( BEA FRIEDLAND JOHN M. JENNINGS FREDERICK RIMMER GERALD ABRAHAM FRIEDRICH BLUME KENNETH COOPER WINTON DEAN VINCENT DUCKLES OTIS FELLOWS DONALD JAY GROUT DANIEL HEARTZ EGON KENTON JENS PETER LARSEN JAN LARuE MARIA RIKA MANIATES 7 REPORTS From the Domestic Editors: Events on Campuses Corresponding 14 American 27 New York: Ph.D. Program in Music- ology at CUNY From the Foreign Corresponding Editors: 35 New Zealand: Music in the Universities 39 Glasgow: Scottish Music Archive 42 Announcements 43 Letters 47 49 52 65 73 81 84 88 92 96 105 113 117 ARTICLES I8th-century Studies In Honor of Paul Henry Lang Foreword 18th-century Music and the Problems of its History Musicology in German Universities Il teatro aUa moda, or A Safe and Easy Method of Producing Baroque Operas According to Modern Practice Handel and Keiser: Further Borrowings Thoughts 011 Writing a Comprehensive History of 18th-century Music Paul Henry Lang: an Enlightened Critic of the French Enlightenment Some Desiderata and Goals for the Study of 18th-century Italian 'Opera Approaching a History of 18th-century Music The Music of the 18th Century: a Retrospective View A Challenge to Musicology: the Vien- nese Classical School The Mapping of Musical Classicism, a Little-known and Dangerous Period Sonate, que me veux-tu?: the Enigma of French Musical Aesthetics in the 18th Century ALFRED MANN WILLIAM J. MITCHELL LEONARD G. RATNER ALEXANDER L. RINGER DENIS STEVENS J. A. WESTRUP WALTER WIORA 141 Artist and Teacher 147 Giuseppe Sarti and Mozart's Quartet, K. 421 154 Approaches to Musical Historiography of the 18th Century 158 Mozart and the J osephian Era: Some Socio-Economic Notes on Musica1 Change 166 Utrecht: Class of '52 169 Aspects of the 18th Century 174 Zur Stellung Bachs on Weltbild der Goethezeit 178 Bach's Place in the World-view of the Goethe Era NEAL ZASLAW 183 Handel and Leclair DISSERTATIONS THEODORE KARP 193 'Finn Mathiassen The Style of the Early Motet CHESTER FANNING SMITH 197 Leon Crickmore C. P. E. Bach: Six HarpsiChord Con- certos Jane R. Stevens The Keyboard Concertos of C. P. E. Bach MARK DEVOTO 200 Laurence David Berman The Evolution of Tonal Thinking in the Works of Claude Debussy J. E. MADDRELL 209 Ernest H. Sanders Medieval English Polyphony and its Significance for the Contin