Here Be Dogs: Documenting the visual culture of the Czech Indie scene Michal Nanoru The eye has always been suspect in rock culture, after all, visually, rock often borders on the inauthentic ... It was here-in its visual presentation-that rock often most explicitly manifested its resistance to the dominant culture, but also its sympathies with the business of entertainment. (Grossberg 1993:195) For Saturday Night Live he wore the same clothes from the previous two days: a pair of Converse tennis shoes, jeans with big holes in the knees, a T-shirt advertising an obscure band, and a Mister Rogers style cardigan sweater. He hadn't washed his hair for a week, but had dyed it with strawberry Kool-Aid, which made his blond locks look like they'd been matted with dried blood. Never before in the history oflive television had a performer put so little care into his appearance or hygiene, or so it seemed. Kurt was a complicated, contradictory misanthrope, and what at times ap­ peared to be an accidental revolution showed hints of careful orchestration ... He obsessively-and compulsively-planned every musical or career direction, writing ideas out in his journals years before he executed them, yet when he was bestowed the honors he had sought, he acted as if it were an inconvenience to get out of bed. (Cross 2001:2) In May 2011 I went to an opening party at the Tony Shafrazi Gallery in New York City, where Hollywood stars and celebrities, including Mickey Rourke, Quincy Jones, and Naomi Campbell mingled near amish-mash of Eastern European -related artworks, including Robert Crumb's comic book rendition of Kafka's Metamorphosis, Vladimir Tatlin's statue "Monument to the Third International;' and an exhibition called Revolutionary Film Posters, a trove of Russian constructivist imagery from between the wars. I It was a bizarre sight for me, a person who grew up in 1980s Czechoslovalda, a satellite nation in the Soviet Bloc. In the 1980s, Czechoslovak cultural policy, theoretically and declaratively (if not always in practice) respected the norms of socialist realism, and it was in the name of the very ideals promoted by these posters that Western popular culture (and Kafka, for that matter) were banned as "bourgeois" and "decadent" imperialist propaganda. Here in the spectacle of a Chelsea gallery, the stars of Hollywood - the most visible exponent of American capitalism-celebrated the repurposing of political propaganda Current Musicology, No. 91 (Spring 201 1) © 2011 by the Trustees of Columbia University in the City of New York 49 50 Current Musicology into aesthetic objects, as if theatrically reasserting capitalism's victory over the ideologies of the Soviet Bloc. This victory is not always that absolute in the former Czechoslovakia, and although its been more than twenty years since the ideologies were officially abandoned, the impact of their pre-1989 influence can still be traced in many areas oflife in the Central European region. My aim here is to confront some of the issues raised by the above situation, especially attitudes towards art, fashion, and popular culture in the context of post-totalitarian Czech Republic. My focus will be the relationship of members of the 1990s and contemporary Czech independent music scenes to visual presentation of their own and others' musical objects and performances. As a cornerstone I am going to use Zde jsou psi/Here Be Dogs, a Czech/ English book about visual culture of Czech independent music scenes that I edited in 2010. (Fellow Czech journalist Martina Overstreet served as a producer for the book). The book features thirty-two musical projects now active in the Czech Republic, each introduced by a) a studio portrait of its personnel by the photographer Adam Holy, b) a representative set of the project's visual communications-costumes, album covers, booklets, flyers, posters, documentary and promotional photographs, video projections used during performances, merchandise, banner ads, computer wallpapers, buddy icons, etc., and c) a short text written by a third party author familiar with the Czech music scene. The image of the visually compelling part of the indie scene is complemented by Dusan Tomanek's documentary photographs, which were taken of Czech audiences in the past four years at festivals, clubs, and various other venues. My experiences as pop music critic, editor of two independent arts and culture publications, and advocate for popular music studies within Czech media studies at Prague's Charles University informed my enthusiasm for the topic and allowed me to foresee the obstacles in the production and reception of this project in the Czech cultural space. There were several. The book packed more than forty names in its colophon, with some ninety members of bands (plus their designers and photographers), and sold out its initial run of a thousand copies. As such it became a useful indicator of positions on the role of the image in the indie music sphere. I began research for the book in 2009 by examining more than 300 contemporary Czech acts that had at least some web presence, and my col­ leagues Martina Overstreet and Marie Hladikova also conducted a similar scope of research. Most bands I researched got by with the default page settings on MySpace, or a profile on its Czech counterpart, WVlTw.bandzone. cz. The thirty-two projects included in the book represent only a minority of bands, with our primary criteria being that those selected showed interesting approaches to their visual presentation or at least showed interest in visual Michal Nanoru presentation. They were singled out as exemplary and the introductory text of the book served as defense of such interests. The authors featured in the book come from very different backgrounds: they are graphic deSigners, artists, curators, critics, art theorists, and fellow musicians. I state in the book's introduction: "Our texts were written by experts, however they are experts on something else. We haven't found an expert on the visual part of indie bands" (Nanoru and Overstreet 2010:234) There are several reasons for this. The book, with its documentary ambition, originated partly as a reaction to the vacuum in contemporary Czech writing about popular music in its institutional framework and social context. The study of popular music had a strong tradition in the Czech scientific milieu throughout the second half of the twentieth century, but after the 1989 Velvet Revolution no one was able to meaningfully build on it and develop it further. 2 Books devoted to popular music (other than popular biographies and interviews with artists) are virtually nonexistent, and those that do exist focus on the history of popular music before 1989 (Kotek 1990, 1998; Matzner, Polednak, and Wasserberger 1990; Doruzka 1991). These works also use visual materials strictly for illustration. The post-revolutionary change of priorities, the transformation of funding for the sciences, and the somewhat unchallenged division of high and low art prevented wider attention to contemporary popular music in the country's musicological research departments. In catching up with what was being neglected for the forty years under Soviet command, popular music fell behind. The humanities and social sciences departments are not particularly qUick to adopt popular music studies into their curricula either-my attempts to implement it into media and communications studies program at the Faculty of Social Sciences of Charles University were met with skepticism. The increasing influence of British cultural studies in Czech university classrooms that would suggest the possibility of future changes to this situation has not so far resulted in many publications or conference papers on popular music. More activity can be seen coming from indepen­ dent enthusiasts than from scholars; for instance the first serious book on the history of black popular music, Hudba ohne: Radikalni cerna hudba od jazzu po hip hop a dale [Fire Music: A radical black music from jazz to hip­ hop and further], was written by a younger music journalist Karel Vesely and published in December 2010 by BiggBoss, a record label specializing in hip-hop. The hardcore/DIY scene put its lyrics into a compendium in 2009, but that was it; the editor and publisher Tomas Weiss gathered the verses without context or any introductory text. There is, however, a body of literature dealing with pre-1989 "parallel culture;' or "the underground" as it is was called in the Czech context (Pilar 1999; Hlavsa and Pelc 2001; 51 52 Current Musicology Jirous 2008; Machovec 2008). Here Be Dogs picks up from these histories, exploring subsequent generations of musicians and fan cultures while dif­ ferentiating between the social conditions of the past and post -89 times.3 The lack of relevant Czech literature, together with the fact that the Czech indie scene often follows popular culture developments in the West (especially in Britain and the United States) also leads me to the use of works published in these countries in this article. Perhaps the main reason for the lack of interest in the visual culture of in die outside Czech academia, and the reason some bands declined to be included in the book, is the precariousness of the suggestion that indie bands market themselves not so dissimilarly from commercially oriented musical enterprises, or the suggestion that members of the bands would stylize themselves. In my experience working in and writing about the independent scene, and especially putting together Here Be Dogs, contemporary Czech indie bands often refuse to acknowledge the role of graphic and product deSign, of on-stage or off-stage clothes and accessories, and/or performance, or at least they avoid openly discussing it. Their members claim they don't feel confident in the areas of visual representation, or don't care about them, often also suggesting that showing too much preoccupation with polishing visuals could or should have direct consequences for their credibility. I will go more deeply into in die ethics and definition of indie later, but here I want to suggest that both scholar Wendy Fonarow (2006) and music journalist Michael Azerrad's work on indie ethics and discourse work well in my analysis, as Fonarow dissects British indie as a symbolic system with particular focus on the questions of authenticity. Throughout the article I'm going to adhere to her understanding of indie as an ideology, an ethos revolving round the idea of creative and sometimes political autonomy, rather than as a mode of distribution or a genre definition. Azerrad's book Our Band Could Be Your Life (2001), an account of the emergence of the American indie scene in the 1980s, inspired and strengthened ethic codes of the Czech in die scene in the 2000s. Copies of Our Band Could Be Your Life has circulated in the scene and on one occasion it was handed to me by a member of the Czech promoter team and record label Silver Rocket as "the Scriptures:' Fonarow writes that "the indie community has an elaborate discourse concerning what constitutes 'authentic' music:' (2006:188) and indeed, following Azerrad, the Czech indie scene currently screens its members for excess with puritanical consistency under the gUiding principle that "the in die underground made a modest way of life not just attractive but a downright moral imperative" (Azerrad 2001 :6). Openness about one's sartorial choices and general consideration of appearance is considered contradictory to pure artistic intention and, in many cases, attracts criticism, Michal Nanoru often leading to the collective hypocrisy of stylizing one's act only to hide the embarrassing fact of such vanity. Overstreet discussed the communication with the musicians in Here Be Dogs as being fraught with anxiety about even the term 'indie': "Bands were bothered by the term 'indie' and they understood 'style' as something superficial that might compromise their deep and serious creations. When I started using the words 'club scene' instead of 'indie' and 'your visual expression, which might also include clothes; everyone was much happier:' (Email correspondence, Nanoru, June 29, 2011)4 The leader of one band was asked whether their fans could be photographed for the book: I don't like the idea anyway. Personally, rather than some hipster poseurs, I would prefer photos of keyboards we use, and stuff, and guitars. Make great photos of them, because for us as a band they are quite a bit more substantial than a bunch of dumb trendy girls that let themselves be entertained by [pop singer 1 Peter Nagy on Sunday and by us on Monday. Sorry. And thanks very much. (Anonymous email correspondence, Overstreet, June 9, 2010)5 Expressions of reservations towards style and issues of appearance can, to some extent, be found in most alternativelindie music scenes (see Fox 1987; Muggleton 2000; Gelder 2007; Greif201O), but a scene in a post-communist country like the Czech Republic has its specifics, some of them stemming far before the 1989 revolution. I therefore begin my article with a brief historical exploration, which exposes the tendencies that have shaped and intensified the Czech independent scene's perspective-especially the unusually strong legacies of 1960s American counterculture and 1980s Czech folk singers, both of which were relished as a oppositional forces under Communism. From there I approach indie as a moral system and demonstrate how it is now used for policing in the Czech indie scene, using voices heard during the making of and in Here Be Dogs. Particularly the uneasy relationship of Southern-Bohemian band Sunshine with the punk/hardcore scene it came from is introduced to point to the in die scenes' quest for authenticity as the primarily criteria for exclusion. Then I'm going to investigate the complex ways in which in die as a Western concept is adopted in a context of post­ communist country, by both the older and the newest generation. The quest for authenticity in the context of the Czech independent scene is complicated by the complex information interchange between the sources in the centers that determine global popular culture and their local counterparts in the periphery that-to a certain extent-make the Czech independent artists dependent on whatever information can travel through the traditional and often mainstream media and, more recently, via blogs and social media in affiliated communities. The aforementioned generational change then 53 54 Current Musicology represents the increased attention that in the past two years gained artists in their early or mid-twenties, whose bands often come from art school and/ or regional backgrounds. Such new bands bring important value changes into the Czech in die discourse, whether concerning more open attitudes towards bands' presentation or their position within the global music scene. I conclude with examination of Here Be Dogs's reception and its possible implications for the development of visual culture of Czech independent music culture. The 19805: Laying ground for indie There are three periods in the twentieth century during which information was flowing with a relative lack of restriction in and out of Czechoslovakia/ Czech Republic. The first was the First Republic, from the founding of Czechoslovakia in 1918 to the Nazi occupation in 1938; the second was circa 1963 to 1968, when the relaxation of Soviet grip, and subsequent attempts at system reform, allowed for an economic and cultural "Prague Spring:' which was followed by Soviet occupation and a harsh crackdown on civil society, a time called Normalization; and the last came in the 1990s, following the Velvet Revolution in 1989. In retrospect, the movements defining the cultural atmosphere of these eras, much debated and celebrated in the wake of the post -1989 reconstituted democracy, correspond to the idealism of interwar modernist avant-gardes (attempts at art as inseparable from the praxis oflife, and art in the service of public good), the liberating sixties, and the 1990s, which saw a revisitation of sixties countercultural ideals with the ethos of the Pacific Northwest "grunge" rock scene. The early 1990s hippie revival was a wider process seen as a reaction to the Reagan-Thatcher eras in the West (from acid house to Madchester to techno, see for example Smith 1992; Reynolds 1998), but in the Czech Republic, the sixties were revived in bookstores, record stores, and in the media by way of a publishing frenzy that was stirred by those who remem­ bered the last days of relative freedom in the 1960s, and by a general hunger for everything that had been long forbidden. In the early 1990s, formerly banned books and LPs were being released and re-released in large num­ bers' and classic 1960s films enjoyed renewed premiers with unparalleled audience turn outs. Then, as "Europe fell in love with the idea of sweaty, flannel-wearing, blue-collar lumberjacks with screaming guitars rocking out in the wilds of the Pacific Northwest" (McMurray 2011:ix), grunge became the first "credible" major Western musical happening to hit Czech popular music culture without censorship. The public theater of Kurt Cobain's never-resolved conflict between the DIY ethics of 1980s punk, "the desire Michal Nanoru to rail against the dark milieu of the post -hippie early '70s and the calcified world of contemporary corporate rock" (ibid.:viii), and the demands of mainstream success and major label pressure, were important parts of the Czech fascination with grunge. Cobain, as much as the Czech president Vaclav Havel and many others on the turbulent threshold of the 1990s, went sWiftly from being a dissident to being a commander in chief, blurring the barrier between the underground and the establishment. Devotion to the ideas of 1960s was not exclusive to the post-revolu­ tionary release. Frozen by the 1968 cutting of ties with developments in the West, the Czech underground movement of the 1970s and 1980s organized itself around the legacy of the Beats and the 1960s counterculture. Jachym Topol, a member of the youngest underground generation, calls the Beats their "prototypes" (Topol 2011). The greatest source of inspiration for the emblematic band of the underground, the Plastic People of the Universe, was the Velvet Underground, followed closely by the Mothers of Invention and the Fugs. Books by the Beats and associated writers circulated in samizdat, publications reproduced in small numbers on typewriters or mimeographs and passed from reader to reader, and translations of the Beats' poetry and prose still enjoy great response in the Czech Republic. The poet Egon Bondy, one of the central figures of the Czech underground, was named the "The No.1 Czech beatnik" (Blumfeld 1992)6 and poets Jan Hane, Milan Koch, Zuzana Trojanova, Svatava Antosova, Vaclav Hrabe, and later Petr Placak and Jachym Topol also drew inspiration for their literature as well as outsider lifestyle from the Beats. For the non-academic public in the early 1990s, Lou Reed, Frank Zappa, and Allan Ginsberg remained as cultural icons (see on this Pilar 1999, Janousek 2008, Armand 2010). The discourse of "the underground" itself was adopted from the West, but its form intensified under the totalitarian condition. In the first account of the underground literature, Underground, literary historian Martin Pilar quotes Canadian Paul Wilson, who at the very beginning of the 1970s performed with the germinal Czech underground band Plastic People of the Universe. Wilson remembers how, in the Czech environment, he began to perceive American avant-garde rock quite differently: "Filled with heavy dumplings, sauerkraut and beer, I comfortably sat back and listened to the Velvet Underground, Captain Beefheart and the Doors and the Fugs, and as I listened, I felt the depth of the music, which I did never feel before, as if I first heard it with the Czech ears" (Pilar 1999:25)? Pilar sees causes of this transformation and the strong effect the 1950s and 1960s American counterculture had on its Czech counterpart in the "lack of intellectual pluralism and free thought, which in the Central European context has always been very difficult to promote" (ibid.). 55 56 Current Musicology Singer-songwriters were a substantial influence on the overall Czech cultural atmosphere of 1980s and 1990s. Since the late 1970s, they had been more or less tolerated by the regime. They played at summer folk festivals, and, in the second half of the 1980s, recorded for the state record label Panton. Rock bands, whether "alternative" (those who preferred to play legally, when possible) or the more radical "underground" (who preferred to have no contact with the establishment, Chadima 1992: 10) however, had more public scrutiny. While even banned songwriters (such as Vladimir Merta, Vlastimil Trdn