Microsoft Word - 69 2017.docx   Vol  5,  No  1  (2017)   ISSN  2167-­‐8677  (online)   DOI  10.5195/d3000.2017.69           http://dentistry3000.pitt.edu     New  articles  in  this  journal  are  licensed  under  a  Creative  Commons  Attribution  4.0  United  States  License.     This  journal  is  published  by  the  University  Library  System,  University  of  Pittsburgh  as  part  of  its  D-­‐Scribe  Digital  Publishing  Program  and  is  cosponored   by  the  University  of  Pittsburgh  Press.     Potential  inheritance  patterns  of  a  prothrombin  gene  mutation  in   a  23-­‐year-­‐old  female  and  ethical  considerations  of  a  positive   diagnosis:  a  case  report   Hannah  Brand1      1University  of  Pi.sburgh,  School  of  Dental  Medicine Abstract   Background:  Prothrombin,  also  called  Factor  II,  is  a  blood  clo4ng  protein  found  in  all  individuals  that  is  necessary  to   form  blood  clots.  In  most  individuals,  a  balance  between  bleeding  and  blood  clot  forma7on  occurs.  However,  in  indi-­‐ viduals  with  a  muta-on  in  the  prothrombin  gene,  the  balance  is  disrupted  due  to  excess  produc-on  of  prothrombin   which  leads  to  an  increase  in  blood  clot  forma2on  (1).   Inherited  predisposi2ons  to  blood  clot  forma2on  are  termed   hereditary   thrombophilia.  Prothrombin  G20210A  muta2ons  are  one  of   the  most   common  hereditary   gene  associa-­‐ !ons.  Case  Descrip+on:  This  report  examines  the  case  of  a  23-­‐year-­‐old  female  who  has  tested  posi/ve  for  the  pro-­‐ thrombin   gene  muta.on.   The   individual   has   an   extensive   history   of   blood   clots   including   8   deep   vein   thromboses   (DVTs),  4  pulmonary  embolisms  with  one  complete  infarc;on,  4  superficial  clots,  and  a  miscarried  pregnancy  a?ribut-­‐ ed  to  her  thrombophilia.  The  individual  has  a  significant  family  history  of  the  muta9on  and  takes  Coumadin  daily  for   preven&on  of  further  clots.  Prac%cal  and  Ethical  Implica%ons:  Despite  a  strong  familial  history  of  blood  clots  and  re-­‐ lated  hospitaliza-ons,  the  parents  of  the  case  individual  do  not  want  to  get  their  other  children  tested  for  the  muta-­‐ !on  for  fear  that  the  children  will  be  denied  insurance  coverage  in  their  futures.  The  case  individual  will  likely  con!n-­‐ ue  to  be  on  blood  thinners  indefinitely.  This  will  affect  many  aspects  of  her  life,  including  dental  treatment,  as  she  will   be  at  an  increased  risk  for  bleeding.     Cita%on:  Brand,  H.   (2017)  Poten&al   inheritance   pa#erns   of   a   prothrombin   gene   muta2on   in   a   23-­‐year-­‐old  female  and  ethical  considera0ons  of   a   posi've   diagnosis:   a   case   report.   Den$stry   3000.  1:a001  doi:10.5195/d3000.2017.69   Received:    May  4,  2017   Accepted:    May  9,  2017   Published:    June  9,  2017   Copyright:  ©2017  Brand,  H.  This   is  an  open  ac-­‐ cess  ar!cle   licensed  under  a  Crea!ve  Commons   A"ribu%on  Work  4.0  United  States  License.   Email:  hnb16@pi).edu   Introduction   Having  a  mutation  in  a   blood  clotting  gene  such  as  Pro-­‐ thrombin  G20210A,  means  that  an   individual  has  a  higher  tendency  to   form  blood  clots.  The  prothrombin   mutation  is  found  in  approximate-­‐ ly  2%  of  Caucasians  in  the  United   States  and  is  the  second  most   common  inherited  form  of  throm-­‐ bophilia  (2-­‐4).  Given  the  rarity  of   the  disease,  most  cases  are  inher-­‐ ited  as  heterozygous  prothrombin   mutations  as  it  is  not  likely  that   both  parents  would  possess  the   mutation,  and  in  heterozygous   cases,  only  one  copy  of  the  muta-­‐ tion  is  needed.  Homozygous  muta-­‐ tions  are  thought  to  be  more  se-­‐ vere  than  heterozygous.  Being   heterozygous  for  the  mutation  in-­‐ creases  the  risk  of  a  blood  clot  by   2-­‐3  times,  versus  homozygous   where  the  risk  is  increased  by  as   much  as  50  times  (3).     The  most  common  compli-­‐ cation  of  having  a  prothrombin   gene  mutation  is  the  increased  risk   for  formation  of  a  deep  venous   thrombosis,  or  DVT.    Typically,   these  clots  form  in  the  leg,  but   have  the  potential  of  traveling   through  the  bloodstream  to  reach   the  lungs,  known  as  a  pulmonary   embolism,  or  to  the  brain,  a  cere-­‐ bral  embolism  (5).    Women  with   clotting  disorders  should  be  aware   that  oral  contraceptives,  hormone   therapy,  and  pregnancy  all  in-­‐ crease  the  risk  of  blood  clot  for-­‐ mation  (1).  The  prothrombin  mu-­‐ tation  has  been  suggested  to  lead   to  increased  pregnancy  complica-­‐ tions  as  well,  including  preeclamp-­‐ sia,  placental  abruption,  pregnan-­‐ cy  loss  in  all  trimesters,  and  still-­‐ birth  (1).  Other  factors  that  in-­‐ crease  the  risk  of  clot  formation   are  smoking,  being  overweight  or   obese,  being  immobile  for  long    Poten&al  inheritance  pa+erns  of  a  prothrombin  gene  muta3on  in  a  23-­‐year-­‐old  female  and  ethical  considera0ons  of  a  posi0ve  diagnosis:  a  case  report   Vol  5,  No  1  (2017)        DOI  10.5195/d3000.2017.69    http://dentistry3000.pitt.edu   periods  of  time,  and  infrequent   exercise  habits  (3).     While  refraining  from  the   aforementioned  risk  factors  can   sometimes  be  enough  to  prevent   the  formation  of  a  clot,  some  indi-­‐ viduals  with  the  prothrombin  mu-­‐ tation  still  develop  clots.  Warfarin,   an  antiplatelet  agent,  is  commonly   used  to  treat  these  patients.  War-­‐ farin  works  by  preventing  the   proper  functioning  of  Vitamin  K   during  the  formation  of  clots  (2,   6).  It  is  important  for  health  care   providers,  including  dentists,  to   take  medications  such  as  Warfarin   into  consideration  when  treating   patients  as  they  may  be  at  an  in-­‐ creased  risk  for  bleeding  (7).   The  goal  of  this  paper  is  to   report  the  case  of  a  23-­‐year-­‐old   female  with  an  extensive  history   of  clotting  issues  stemming  from  a   prothrombin  gene  mutation.  This   paper  will  cover  the  biological  and   ethical  concerns  related  to  a  posi-­‐ tive  diagnosis  of  a  clotting  disor-­‐ der.   Case  Presentation:     This  report  examines  the   case  of  a  23-­‐year-­‐old  female,   “Anne”  (the  individual’s  name  has   been  changed  to  protect  the  indi-­‐ vidual’s  identity).  Anne  has  a  per-­‐ sonal  and  familial  history  of  blood   clots.  Anne  has  had  8  DVTs,  4  pul-­‐ monary  embolisms  with  one  com-­‐ plete  infarction,  4  superficial  clots,   and  delivered  a  stillborn  baby  at  5   months.  Doctors  attributed  the   miscarriage  to  her  thrombophilia.     Anne’s  father  is  Caucasian   and  her  mother  is  half  Japanese   and  half  Caucasian.  Her  paternal   grandmother  and  grandmother’s   two  sisters  all  had  a  history  of   hospitalizations  due  to  blood  clots.   Her  father’s  sister  tested  positive   as  having  the  mutation  and  has   also  been  hospitalized  for  DVTs   and  pulmonary  embolisms.  Anne   reported  that  her  father  tested   negative  for  the  mutation  and  that   her  father  was  not  a  carrier,  but  it   is  likely  that  he  was  a  heterozy-­‐ gous  carrier  for  the  trait.  Anne’s   aunt  with  a  history  of  blood  clots   and  Anne  herself  tested  positive   as  homozygous  recessive  for  the   trait.  Given  that  many  individuals   who  are  heterozygous  for  the  trait   never  form  blood  clots  and  that   heterozygous  individuals  are  only   at  2-­‐3  times  higher  risk,  it  is  plau-­‐ sible  to  think  that  Anne’s  parents   are  carriers  of  the  trait.  The  exten-­‐ sive  history  of  blood  clots  and  em-­‐ bolisms  in  Anne’s  family  suggest   that  Anne  is  homozygous  for  the   trait,  as  increased  likelihood  of   developing  clots,  up  to  50  times,   and  increased  severity  are  report-­‐ ed  with  homozygous  cases  (3).  A   hypothetical  pedigree  has  been   proposed  (see  Figure  1).   Discussion:   Being  diagnosed  with  a  clotting   disorder  like  a  prothrombin  muta-­‐ tion  has  many  implications  that   can  last  a  lifetime.  Individuals  with   such  mutations  are  at  increased   risk  for  clotting  without  medica-­‐ tion,  and  are  at  increased  risk  for   bleeding  if  on  blood  thinners  such   as  Warfarin  (2).  Because  factors   such  as  smoking  and  hormonal   birth  control  significantly  increase   one’s  risk  for  developing  a  clot,  it   is  advised  that  individuals  with   clotting  disorders  abstain  from   them.     Anne  has  3  siblings  from   the  same  parents.  It  is  possible   that  her  siblings  may  also  carry  the   mutation.  Anne  has  an  older    Poten&al  inheritance  pa+erns  of  a  prothrombin  gene  muta3on  in  a  23-­‐year-­‐old  female  and  ethical  considera0ons  of  a  posi0ve  diagnosis:  a  case  report   Vol  5,  No  1  (2017)        DOI  10.5195/d3000.2017.69    http://dentistry3000.pitt.edu   brother,  26,  who  is  on  his  own   health  insurance  plan.  Her  two   younger  sisters,  16  and  12,  are  still   on  their  parents’  health  insurance   plan.  Anne’s  dad  is  unsure  wheth-­‐ er  he  wants  to  have  the  younger   daughters  tested  for  the  mutation.   While  he  feels  it  would  be  benefi-­‐ cial  to  know  if  they  have  the  muta-­‐ tion  to  better  watch  for  symptoms   and  avoid  risk  factors,  he  fears  a   positive  diagnosis  may  lead  to  a   lifetime  of  insurance  denial  and   anxiety  related  to  the  condition.   The  Genetic  Information  Nondis-­‐ crimination  Act  (GINA)  prohibits   employers  and  health  care  provid-­‐ ers  from  discriminating  against   individuals  because  of  genetic  in-­‐ formation  (8).  It  is  unknown  if  the   father  is  unaware  of  this  act,  is   afraid  that  this  regulation  could  be   overturned  in  the  future,  or  fears   that  employers  and  providers  do   not  always  abide  by  this  law.     When  seeking  medical  care   and  attention,  patients  with  clot-­‐ ting  disorders  should  alert  their   providers  of  their  condition  and  of   the  medications  they  are  taking.   Dentists  treating  patients  on  War-­‐ farin  should  be  careful  to  watch   for  excessive  bleeding,  though   medication  adjustments  are  rarely   warranted  (2).  One  could  also   raise  the  question  of  if  a  patient   presents  to  a  dentist  with  a  clot-­‐ ting  disorder  and  a  positive  history   of  smoking  and/or  hormonal  birth   control,  is  it  the  obligation  of  the   dentist  to  advise  the  patients  of   the  risks  for  increased  clotting   when  taking  such  substances?   Based  on  current  literature  report-­‐ ing  the  significantly  heightened   risks  of  clotting  with  these  agents,   it  is  reasonable  to  think  that  a   dentist  should  bare  this  responsi-­‐ bility.  The  dentist  should  also   counsel  the  parents  on  the  pros   and  cons  of  having  the  other  sib-­‐ lings  tested  given  the  potential   severity  of  the  disease,  while  ulti-­‐ mately  leaving  the  decision  to  the   family.     Conclusion     Anne’s  medical  and  familial   history  of  blood  clots  show  the   need  for  awareness  of  this  disor-­‐ der  and  the  importance  of  under-­‐ standing  modes  of  genetic  inher-­‐ itance  for  determining  the  risk  for   other  family  members.  Individuals   with  clotting  disorders  should  be   advised  to  abstain  from  factors   that  increase  the  risk  for  clotting,   including  smoking  and  hormonal   birth  control.  While  it  may  be  con-­‐ sidered  beneficial  to  know  one’s   status  regarding  the  mutation  to   increase  awareness  and  avoid   triggering  factors,  the  current   state  of  health  care  policy  in  the   United  States  may  discourage  in-­‐ dividuals  from  getting  tested  for   fear  of  insurance  denial  or  em-­‐ ployment  discrimination.  It  is  up  to   the  individual  and  their  family  to   make  these  decisions,  but  regard-­‐ less  of  the  decision  made,  dentists   and  health  care  providers  have   professional  and  ethical  obliga-­‐ tions  to  be  aware  of  and  prepared   for  any  potential  complications   that  may  arise  during  treatment.   References   1. Prothrombin  20210  Mutation   (Factor  II  Mutation);  Varga   EA,  Moll  S;  Circulation;  2004,   July;110(3):e15-­‐8.  PMID:   15262854.   2. Yagiela,  Dowd,  Johnson,  et  al   (2011)  Pharmacology  and   Therapeutics  for  Dentistry.   St.  Louis:  Mosby  Elsevier.  504   p.     3. Lentz,  SR;  University  of  Iowa   Hospitals  and  Clinics;  2005.   [cited  2017  Mar  15].  Availa-­‐ ble  from   https://www.healthcare.uio wa.edu/labs/lentz/Informati on_For_Patients/PDF/Prothr om-­‐ bin%20Gene%20Mutation% 20Brochure.pdf   4. Homozygotes  for  prothrom-­‐ bin  gene  20210  A  allele  in  a   thrombophilic  family  without   clinical  manifestations  of  ve-­‐ nous  thromboembolism;  Sou-­‐ to  JC,  Mateo  J,  Soria  JM,  et  al.;   Haematologica;  1999;   84(7):627-­‐32.  PMID:   10406905.   5. Genetics  Home  Reference;   National  Institute  of  Health;   U.S.  National  Library  of  Medi-­‐ cine;  2008.  [cited  2017  Mar   26].  Available  from   https://ghr.nlm.nih.gov/cond ition/prothrombin-­‐ thrombophilia#inheritance    Poten&al  inheritance  pa+erns  of  a  prothrombin  gene  muta3on  in  a  23-­‐year-­‐old  female  and  ethical  considera0ons  of  a  posi0ve  diagnosis:  a  case  report   Vol  5,  No  1  (2017)        DOI  10.5195/d3000.2017.69    http://dentistry3000.pitt.edu   6. Anticoagulants;  The  Johns   Hopkins  Lupus  Center;  2017.   [cited  2017  Mar  26].  Availa-­‐ ble  from   https://www.hopkinslupus.o rg/lupus-­‐ treatment/common-­‐ medications-­‐ conditions/anticoagulants/   7. Anticoagulant  and  Antiplate-­‐ let  Medications  and  Dental   Procedures;  The  American   Dental  Association;  2015.   [cited  2017  Mar  28]  Available   from   http://www.ada.org/en/me mber-­‐center/oral-­‐health-­‐ topics/anticoagulant-­‐ antiplatelet-­‐medications-­‐ and-­‐dental-­‐   8. Genetic  Information  Nondis-­‐ crimination  Act;  U.S.  Depart-­‐ ment  of  Health  and  Human   Services;  2017.  [cited  2017   Mar  28].  Available  from   https://www.hhs.gov/hipaa/ for-­‐professionals/special-­‐ topics/genetic-­‐ information/index.html