Dermatology: Practical and Conceptual


DERMATOLOGY PRACTICAL & CONCEPTUAL
www.derm101.com

Observation  |  Dermatol Pract Concept 2014;4(2):9 45

Case report

A 44-year-old female patient presented to a dermatologist in 

Blanquefort, France for a routine check of her moles. There 

was no family or personal history of cutaneous malignancy 

and there was no history of any significant health problems 

or of any symptoms of disease. There had been a previous 

examination by the same dermatologist one year earlier, and 

nothing of concern had been noticed.

Examination revealed that the patient had skin of Fitz-

patrick photo-type 3, with multiple ephelides as evidence of 

previous sun exposure. On the skin over her right scapula 

a raised, smooth, shiny, yellow and skin-colored lesion was 

observed (Figure 1). A dermatoscopic examination was 

performed (Figure 2), and the lesion was noted to be struc-

tureless, predominantly yellow. There was evidence of light 

melanin pigmentation with some areas of structureless gray 

interspersed between the dominant yellow areas and present 

Non-choroidal yellow melanoma showing positive 
staining with Sudan Black consistent with the 

presence of lipofuscin: a case report
Marie Hélène Jegou Penouil1, Jean-Yves Gourhant2, Catherine Segretin3, 

David Weedon4, Cliff Rosendahl5

1 Cabinet de Dermatologie, Blanquefort, France

2 Centre de Dermatologie, Nemours, France

3 Cabinet d’anatomopathologie, Talence, France

4 Sullivan Nicolaides Pathology, Brisbane, Australia

6 School of Medicine, The University of Queensland, Australia

Keywords: dermatoscopy, dermoscopy, dermatopathology, yellow melanoma, hypomelanotic melanoma, lipofuscin, Sudan Black

Citation: Jegou Penouil MH, Gourhant J-Y, Segretin C, Weedon D, Rosendahl C. Non-choroidal yellow melanoma showing positive 
staining with Sudan Black consistent with the presence of lipofuscin: a case report. Dermatol Pract Concept. 2014;4(2):9. http://dx.doi.
org/10.5826/dpc.0402a09

Received: September 9, 2013; Accepted: October 8, 2013; Published: April 30, 2014

Copyright: ©2014 Jegou Penouil et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 
License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are 
credited.

Funding: None.

Competing interests: The authors have no conflicts of interest to disclose.

All authors have contributed significantly to this publication.

Corresponding author: Cliff Rosendahl, MBBS, PhD, PO Box 734, Capalaba, Queensland, 4157Australia. Tel. +61 7 3245 3011; Fax. +61 
7 3245 3022. Email: cliffrosendahl@bigpond.com

A case of a predominantly yellow primary superficial spreading melanoma arising on the back of a 
44-year-old woman is presented. Possible causes of the clinical and dermatoscopic yellow color are 
discussed. Staining with the histochemical stain, Sudan Black, revealed a differential uptake compared 
to a closely matched control melanoma. We speculate that the clinical and dermatoscopic yellow color 
could be due to the presence of increased amounts of the pigment lipofuscin, which is known to pro-
duce subtle orange color in some choroidal melanomas.

ABSTRACT

mailto:cliffrosendahl@bigpond.com


46 Observation  |  Dermatol Pract Concept 2014;4(2):9

6A), which was also verified by Masson Fontana stain that 

confirmed significant melanin extending to the base of the 

melanocytic proliferation. Evidence of a pre-existing nevus 

was present as a sheet of mature nevomelanocytes at the base 

of the lesion (Figure 6D). The diagnosis was rendered mela-

noma, superficial spreading subtype with a dominant nodule 

comprising the great majority of the lesion, Breslow thickness 

2.4 mm with 4 mitoses per high power field.

Following this, in an attempt to clarify the cause of yellow 

color, two further stains were performed.

A pearl’s stain confirmed the absence of hemosiderin.

To test for the presence of the pigment lipofuscin, new 

sections were cut from the paraffin block, five microns in 

thickness and stained with Sudan Black. When this appeared 

to stain heavily, new sections of the same thickness were also 

cut from the paraffin block of another melanoma as a control 

and stained with Sudan Black. The control melanoma was a 

heavily pigmented superficial spreading melanoma, also with 

a dominant (pigmented) nodule, with a Breslow thickness of 

2.2 mm, 2 mitoses per mm2, and no ulceration. Figure 7 is a 

composite image of both the melanoma reported here (upper 

image) and the control (lower image), both stained with Sudan 

Black. Both images are taken at with the same 4x objective 

and with identical exposure and white-balance settings. Apart 

from cropping and identical resizing for publication, there has 

been no photo manipulation. It can be seen that there is dif-

at one end of the lesion but not the other producing asym-

metry of color. Polymorphous linear vessels (serpentine, 

looped and curved) were arranged randomly and densely 

over the surface of the lesion and there were a small number 

of dot vessels.

Immediate excision biopsy was performed. Dermatopa-

thologically (Figures 3-7) the lesion presented as a nodular, 

well circumscribed proliferation of melanocytes (Figure 3). 

There was a proliferation of cytologically abnormal mela-

nocytes and some confluent nests of melanocytes at the 

dermoepidermal junction (Figure 5), and the junctional prolif-

eration did extend beyond the dermal proliferation for more 

than three rete ridges at one location at the periphery of the 

nodular component. In the dermis sheets of abnormal mela-

nocytes, most as spindle cells (Figures 5, 6A & B) and others 

with plump oval nuclei, prominent nucleoli and abundant 

clear cytoplasm (Figure 6A, B, C, D), extended throughout 

the dermis with both nesting and evidence of melanin produc-

tion all the way to the base of the lesion (Figures 4 and 6). 

Melanin was seen on hemotoxylin and eosin staining (Figure 

Figure 1. Close-up image (Pentax DS camera, Pentax Ricoh, Tokyo, 

Japan) of a nodular lesion over the right scapular area of a 44-year-

old female patient. Irregular dominant yellow color is apparent. 

[Copyright: ©2014 Jegou Penouil et al.]

Figure 2. Dermatoscopy image (Heine delta 20 dermatoscope [He-

ine, Optotechnic, GmbH, Hersching, Germany] manually coupled to 

a Panasonic Lumix DMC ZX1 camera [Panasonic Corp., Kadoma, 

Japan]) of the lesion shown in Figure 1. The pattern is structureless, 

predominantly yellow, with an eccentric structureless pink area (upper 

pole of image) and evidence of light melanin pigmentation with some 

areas of structureless gray interspersed between the dominant yellow 

areas but absent at the upper pole of the image with resulting asymme-

try. Polymorphous linear vessels (serpentine, looped and curved) are ar-

ranged randomly and densely over the surface of the lesion. There are 

a small number of dot vessels. [Copyright: ©2014 Jegou Penouil et al.]

Figure 3. Dermatopathologic overview of the lesion shown in Fig-

ures 1 and 2. Significant nodular morphology is apparent although 

close examination of additional dermatopathology sections revealed 

that strict criteria for the classification as nodular subtype were not 

met. [Copyright: ©2014 Jegou Penouil et al.]



Observation  |  Dermatol Pract Concept 2014;4(2):9 47

[1], amelanotic/hypomelanotic melanomas (AHM) typically 

present with minimal clues due to melanin structures on 

which to base a diagnostic analysis [2]. The particular chal-

lenge, where a melanoma presents clinically as a hypomela-

notic nodule, has been described as that of evaluating a 

rapidly enlarging pink tumor [3]. The melanoma reported 

here was a hypopigmented superficial spreading melanoma 

ferential staining with Sudan Black in the upper image (case 

subject to this report) compared to the control.

Conclusions

While pigmented melanomas usually display dermatoscopic 

disorganization and clues related to their chaotic evolution 

Figure 4. Medium high power dermatopathologic view of the lesion 

shown in Figure 3. Nesting is apparent at the base of the lesion. 

[Copyright: ©2014 Jegou Penouil et al.]

Figure 5. Higher power dermatopathologic view of the lesion shown 

in Figure 3 showing a proliferation of melanocytes at the dermoepider-

mal junction both as single cells and confluent nests with some clefting. 

A limited amount of pagetoid spread is seen. Sheets of spindle-shaped 

cells fill the dermis. [Copyright: ©2014 Jegou Penouil et al.]

Figure 6. (A) Medium high power dermatopathologic view of the 

center of the lesion shown in Figure 3. Two distinct cell types are 

apparent, including spindle-shaped cells on one hand and cells with 

plump oval nuclei, prominent nucleoli and abundant clear cyto-

plasm (balloon cells) on the other. (B) High power view of spindle 

shaped cells and (C) balloon cells. (D) High power view of the base 

of the lesion shown in Figure 3. A sheet of mature nevomelanocytes 

can be seen beneath the nests of abnormal melanocytes, consistent 

with the contiguous presence of a nevus. [Copyright: ©2014 Jegou 

Penouil et al.]

Figure 7. (Upper image) Dermatopathologic view of the lesion shown 

in Figure 3 stained with Sudan Black. (Lower image) Dermatopatho-

logic image of a control melanoma of similar Breslow thickness and 

mitotic rate but with heavy melanin pigmentation. Both lesions had 5 

micron thick sections stained with Sudan Black and the images were 

taken with the same exposure and white-balance settings. There has 

been no photo manipulation apart from cropping and identical resiz-

ing for publication. The case being reported here (upper image) is 

seen to stain differentially consistent with the possible presence of the 

pigment lipofuscin. [Copyright: ©2014 Jegou Penouil et al.]



48 Observation  |  Dermatol Pract Concept 2014;4(2):9

[15]. Sebum consists primarily of a complex mixture of lipids 

[17]. Ideally staining for lipids is performed on fresh unfixed 

tissue with stains such as Oil Red O. In this case all tissue had 

been fixed in formalin and blocked in paraffin.

Subtle orange pigment, attributed to the pigment lipofus-

cin, a derived lipid which is an accumulation of lysosomes 

[18], is described as one of the features that can help differ-

entiate choroidal melanoma from choroidal nevus [19]. The 

histochemical stain Sudan Black can be used on formalin-

fixed, paraffin-processed tissue to detect some phospholids 

and also lipofuscin [18]. The melanoma reported here showed 

significant staining with Sudan Black compared to staining 

by a similar but deeply pigmented melanoma. This increased 

staining was present in varying intensity and uneven distri-

bution throughout the dermal component of the melanoma 

consistent with the uneven presence of dermatoscopic struc-

tureless yellow (Figure 2).

The possible presence of the pigment lipofuscin in this 

melanoma is supported by positive staining by Sudan Black, 

and we speculate that the structureless yellow color displayed 

clinically and dermatoscopically may be due to the pigment 

lipofuscin, a pigment which has been previously described as 

a clue to choroidal melanoma.

References

1. Rosendahl C, Cameron A, McColl I, Wilkinson D. Dermatoscopy 

in routine practice—“Chaos and Clues.” Aust Fam Physician. 

2012 Jul;41(7):482–7.

2. Chamberlain AJ, Fritschi L, Kelly JW. Nodular melanoma: pa-

tients’ perceptions of presenting features and implications for 

earlier detection. J Am Acad Dermatol. 2003 May;48(5):694–701.

3. Moloney FJ, Menzies SW. Key points in the dermoscopic diagnosis 

of hypomelanotic melanoma and nodular melanoma. J Dermatol. 

2011 Jan;38(1):10–5.

4. Steglich RB, Meotti CD, Ferreira MS, Lovatto L, de Carvalho 

AVE, de Castro CGC. Dermoscopic clues in the diagnosis of 

amelanotic and hypomelanotic malignant melanoma. An Bras 

Dermatol. 2012 Dec;87(6):920–3.

5. Kittler H. Dermatoscopy: introduction of a new algorithmic 

method based on pattern analysis for diagnosis of pigmented skin 

lesions. Dermatopathology: Practical & Conceptual 2007;13:3.

6. Kittler H, Rosendahl C, Cameron A, Tschandl P. Dermatoscopy. 

Vienna, Austria: facultas.wuv, 2011.

7. Menzies SW, Kreusch J, Byth K, et al. Dermoscopic evaluation of 

amelanotic and hypomelanotic melanoma. Arch Dermatol. 2008 

Sep;144(9):1120–7.

8. Rosendahl C, Tschandl P, Cameron A, Kittler H. Diagnostic ac-

curacy of dermatoscopy for melanocytic and nonmelanocytic pig-

mented lesions. J Am Acad Dermatol. 2011 Jun;64(6):1068–73.

9. Berk DR, Bayliss SJ. Milia: a review and classification. J Am Acad 

Dermatol. 2008 Dec;59(6):1050–63.

10. Changchien L, Dusza SW, Agero ALC, et al. Age- and site-specific 

variation in the dermoscopic patterns of congenital melanocytic 

nevi: an aid to accurate classification and assessment of melano-

cytic nevi. Arch Dermatol. 2007 Aug;143(8):1007–14.

(SSM) with a dominant nodule, which was notable because 

of its dominant structureless yellow color. In one series of 

four cases of AHM with dermatoscopic images, all cases had 

significant pink or red color and none had any yellow color 

[4]. Although this lesion fulfilled the definition of AHM, 

according to revised pattern analysis (RPA), the presence of 

any pigment should lead to a diagnostic analysis based on 

pigmented structures [5,6]. Applying the RPA algorithmic 

method for pigmented lesions, “Chaos and Clues” [1] this 

lesion was asymmetric by color and therefore was regarded 

as exhibiting chaos (defined as asymmetry of structure and/

or color), and it had the clue of blue or gray structures so 

excision biopsy was indicated. In addition to these pigment 

clues, there were vascular dermatoscopic clues including an 

eccentric structurless pink area (Figure 2 upper pole) and a 

random arrangement of polymorphous vessels. Both milky 

red pink areas and linear irregular vessels are described as 

clues to AHM by Menzies et al. [7], and an eccentric struc-

tureless area (any color except skin color, including pink) 

and polymorphous vessels have been evaluated as clues to 

malignancy in RPA [8].

Dermatoscopic yellow color has also been attributed to 

keratin as seen in seborrheic keratosis [9] and congenital type 

nevus [10]. In a study of 400 BCCs Bellucci et al. found that 

10% displayed yellow structures either as milia-like cysts 

(7.75%) or lobular structures (4.2%) [11], also presumably 

due to keratin. There was no accumulation of keratin to 

explain the yellow color in the melanoma reported here.

Structureless dermatoscopic yellow color has also been 

attributed to ulceration with surface serum exudate [6], and 

dermatoscopic structureless yellow color was described in the 

first case report of a balloon cell melanoma (BCM) with der-

matoscopy [12], being attributed by the authors to ulceration. 

Considering the possibility that it may actually have been 

the balloon cells that caused the yellow color, the only other 

reported BSM with dermatoscopic images was a partially pig-

mented lesion with a dominant structureless white area and 

without any yellow color [13]. The case we report here did 

have two cell populations, including one with large cells with 

vacuolated cytoplasm resembling balloon cells (Figures 6 A, 

C, D), but it did not meet the criteria for diagnosis as a BCM 

which requires that the melanoma contain more than 50% of 

balloon cells, [14] and in fact the sheets of balloon cells were 

only present focally. With respect to ulceration as a reported 

cause of structureless yellow in one melanoma [12], there was 

no evidence of ulceration either clinically, dermatoscopically 

or dermatopathologically in the case reported here.

Another published cause of dermatoscopic yellow is the 

presence of sebaceous structures in sebaceous hyperplasia 

[15], nevus sebaceous and sebaceous adenoma [16]. Bryden 

et al. attributed the yellow color in sebaceous hyperplasia to 

sebum accumulation by proliferation of sebaceous glands 



Observation  |  Dermatol Pract Concept 2014;4(2):9 49

15. Bryden AM, Dawe RS, Fleming C. Dermatoscopic features 

of benign sebaceous proliferation. Clin Exp Dermatol. 2004 

Nov;29(6):676–7.

16. Enei ML, Paschoal FM, Valdés G, Valdés R. Basal cell carcinoma 

appearing in a facial nevus sebaceous of Jadassohn: dermoscopic 

features. An Bras Dermatol. 2012 Aug;87(4):640-2.

17. McMahon A, Lu H, Butovich IA. The spectrophotometric sulfo-

phospho-vanillin assessment of total lipids in human meibomian 

gland secretions. Lipids. 2013 May;48(5):513–25.

18. Bancroft J, Stevens A. Bancroft’s Theory and Practice of Histologi-

cal Techniques. 2nd ed. Edinburgh: Churchill Livingstone, 2012.

19. Shields CL, Furuta M, Berman EL, et al. Choroidal nevus transfor-

mation into melanoma: analysis of 2514 consecutive cases. Arch 

Ophthalmol. 2009;127(8):981-7.

11. Bellucci C, Arginelli F, Bassoli S, Magnoni C, Seidenari S. Der-

moscopic yellow structures in basal cell carcinoma. J Eur Acad 

Dermatol Venereol. Epub 2013 Jan 18.

12. Inskip M, Magee J, Barksdale S, Weedon D, Rosendahl C. Balloon 

cell melanoma in primary care practice: a case report. Dermatol 

Pract Concept. 2013;3(3):6.

13. Maher J, Cameron A, Wallace S, Acosta-Rojas R, Weedon D, 

Rosendahl C. Balloon cell melanoma: a case report with polar-

ized and non-polarized dermatoscopy and dermatopathology. 

Dermatol Pract Conc. (in press)

14. Kao GF, Helwig EB, Graham JH. Balloon cell malignant mela-

noma of the skin. A clinicopathologic study of 34 cases with histo-

chemical, immunohistochemical, and ultrastructural observations. 

Cancer. 1992 Jun 15;69(12):2942–52.