id sid tid token lemma pos dpj1-58 1 1 microsoft microsoft PROPN dpj1-58 1 2 word word NOUN dpj1-58 1 3 58-154-1-le.docx 58-154-1-le.docx PRON dpj1-58 1 4 dialogic dialogic ADJ dpj1-58 1 5 pedagogy pedagogy NOUN dpj1-58 1 6 : : PUNCT dpj1-58 1 7 an an DET dpj1-58 1 8 international international ADJ dpj1-58 1 9 online online ADJ dpj1-58 1 10 journal journal NOUN dpj1-58 1 11 | | ADV dpj1-58 1 12 http://dpj.pitt.edu http://dpj.pitt.edu X dpj1-58 2 1 doi doi NOUN dpj1-58 2 2 : : PUNCT dpj1-58 2 3 10.5195 10.5195 NUM dpj1-58 2 4 / / SYM dpj1-58 2 5 dpj.2013.58 dpj.2013.58 PROPN dpj1-58 2 6 | | ADJ dpj1-58 2 7 vol vol NOUN dpj1-58 2 8 . . PROPN dpj1-58 2 9 1 1 NUM dpj1-58 2 10 ( ( PUNCT dpj1-58 2 11 2013 2013 NUM dpj1-58 2 12 ) ) PUNCT dpj1-58 2 13 b9 b9 PROPN dpj1-58 2 14         SPACE dpj1-58 2 15 dialogic dialogic ADJ dpj1-58 2 16 approaches approach NOUN dpj1-58 2 17 to to ADP dpj1-58 2 18 the the DET dpj1-58 2 19 study study NOUN dpj1-58 2 20 of of ADP dpj1-58 2 21 subjectivity subjectivity NOUN dpj1-58 2 22 kathrin kathrin PROPN dpj1-58 2 23 otrel otrel PROPN dpj1-58 2 24 - - PUNCT dpj1-58 2 25 cass cass PROPN dpj1-58 2 26 , , PUNCT dpj1-58 2 27 aalborg aalborg PROPN dpj1-58 2 28 university university PROPN dpj1-58 2 29 , , PUNCT dpj1-58 2 30 denmark denmark NOUN dpj1-58 2 31 abstract abstract ADJ dpj1-58 2 32 book book NOUN dpj1-58 2 33 review review PROPN dpj1-58 2 34 : : PUNCT dpj1-58 3 1 sullivan sullivan PROPN dpj1-58 3 2 , , PUNCT dpj1-58 3 3 p. p. PROPN dpj1-58 3 4 ( ( PUNCT dpj1-58 3 5 2012 2012 NUM dpj1-58 3 6 ) ) PUNCT dpj1-58 3 7 . . PUNCT dpj1-58 4 1 qualitative qualitative ADJ dpj1-58 4 2 data datum NOUN dpj1-58 4 3 analysis analysis NOUN dpj1-58 4 4 : : PUNCT dpj1-58 4 5 using use VERB dpj1-58 4 6 a a DET dpj1-58 4 7 dialogic dialogic ADJ dpj1-58 4 8 approach approach NOUN dpj1-58 4 9 . . PUNCT dpj1-58 5 1 los los PROPN dpj1-58 5 2 angeles angeles PROPN dpj1-58 5 3 : : PUNCT dpj1-58 5 4 sage sage NOUN dpj1-58 5 5 publications publications PROPN dpj1-58 5 6 ltd ltd PROPN dpj1-58 5 7 . . PROPN dpj1-58 6 1 isbn isbn PROPN dpj1-58 6 2 978 978 NUM dpj1-58 6 3 - - SYM dpj1-58 6 4 1 1 NUM dpj1-58 6 5 - - PUNCT dpj1-58 6 6 84920 84920 NUM dpj1-58 6 7 - - PUNCT dpj1-58 6 8 609 609 NUM dpj1-58 6 9 - - SYM dpj1-58 6 10 9 9 NUM dpj1-58 6 11 paul paul PROPN dpj1-58 6 12 sullivan sullivan PROPN dpj1-58 6 13 prepared prepare VERB dpj1-58 6 14 his his PRON dpj1-58 6 15 book book NOUN dpj1-58 6 16 qualitative qualitative ADJ dpj1-58 6 17 data datum NOUN dpj1-58 6 18 analysis analysis NOUN dpj1-58 6 19 : : PUNCT dpj1-58 6 20 using use VERB dpj1-58 6 21 a a DET dpj1-58 6 22 dialogic dialogic ADJ dpj1-58 6 23 approach approach NOUN dpj1-58 6 24 for for ADP dpj1-58 6 25 social social ADJ dpj1-58 6 26 science science NOUN dpj1-58 6 27 researchers researcher NOUN dpj1-58 6 28 who who PRON dpj1-58 6 29 are be AUX dpj1-58 6 30 interested interested ADJ dpj1-58 6 31 in in ADP dpj1-58 6 32 qualitative qualitative ADJ dpj1-58 6 33 data datum NOUN dpj1-58 6 34 analysis analysis NOUN dpj1-58 6 35 and and CCONJ dpj1-58 6 36 who who PRON dpj1-58 6 37 have have VERB dpj1-58 6 38 an an DET dpj1-58 6 39 interest interest NOUN dpj1-58 6 40 in in ADP dpj1-58 6 41 a a DET dpj1-58 6 42 dialogical dialogical ADJ dpj1-58 6 43 approach approach NOUN dpj1-58 6 44 to to ADP dpj1-58 6 45 data datum NOUN dpj1-58 6 46 analysis analysis NOUN dpj1-58 6 47 . . PUNCT dpj1-58 7 1 the the DET dpj1-58 7 2 book book NOUN dpj1-58 7 3 is be AUX dpj1-58 7 4 in in ADP dpj1-58 7 5 essence essence NOUN dpj1-58 7 6 concerned concern VERB dpj1-58 7 7 with with ADP dpj1-58 7 8 the the DET dpj1-58 7 9 nature nature NOUN dpj1-58 7 10 of of ADP dpj1-58 7 11 subjectivity subjectivity NOUN dpj1-58 7 12 and and CCONJ dpj1-58 7 13 how how SCONJ dpj1-58 7 14 to to PART dpj1-58 7 15 make make VERB dpj1-58 7 16 sense sense NOUN dpj1-58 7 17 of of ADP dpj1-58 7 18 it it PRON dpj1-58 7 19 . . PUNCT dpj1-58 8 1 sullivan sullivan PROPN dpj1-58 8 2 explains explain VERB dpj1-58 8 3 that that SCONJ dpj1-58 8 4 from from ADP dpj1-58 8 5 a a DET dpj1-58 8 6 dialogic dialogic ADJ dpj1-58 8 7 position position NOUN dpj1-58 8 8 subjectivity subjectivity NOUN dpj1-58 8 9 can can AUX dpj1-58 8 10 be be AUX dpj1-58 8 11 seen see VERB dpj1-58 8 12 as as ADP dpj1-58 8 13 a a DET dpj1-58 8 14 conscious conscious ADJ dpj1-58 8 15 activity activity NOUN dpj1-58 8 16 where where SCONJ dpj1-58 8 17 the the DET dpj1-58 8 18 researcher researcher NOUN dpj1-58 8 19 anticipates anticipate VERB dpj1-58 8 20 the the DET dpj1-58 8 21 ideas idea NOUN dpj1-58 8 22 and and CCONJ dpj1-58 8 23 judgments judgment NOUN dpj1-58 8 24 expressed express VERB dpj1-58 8 25 through through ADP dpj1-58 8 26 dialogue dialogue NOUN dpj1-58 8 27 from from ADP dpj1-58 8 28 others other NOUN dpj1-58 8 29 by by ADP dpj1-58 8 30 drawing draw VERB dpj1-58 8 31 on on ADP dpj1-58 8 32 “ " PUNCT dpj1-58 8 33 a a DET dpj1-58 8 34 network network NOUN dpj1-58 8 35 of of ADP dpj1-58 8 36 history history NOUN dpj1-58 8 37 , , PUNCT dpj1-58 8 38 tradition tradition NOUN dpj1-58 8 39 and and CCONJ dpj1-58 8 40 power power NOUN dpj1-58 8 41 ” " PUNCT dpj1-58 8 42 ( ( PUNCT dpj1-58 8 43 p.44 p.44 NOUN dpj1-58 8 44 ) ) PUNCT dpj1-58 8 45 . . PUNCT dpj1-58 9 1 through through ADP dpj1-58 9 2 this this DET dpj1-58 9 3 sullivan sullivan NOUN dpj1-58 9 4 ( ( PUNCT dpj1-58 9 5 referring refer VERB dpj1-58 9 6 to to ADP dpj1-58 9 7 gee gee PROPN dpj1-58 9 8 , , PUNCT dpj1-58 9 9 2005 2005 NUM dpj1-58 9 10 ) ) PUNCT dpj1-58 9 11 emphasizes emphasize VERB dpj1-58 9 12 the the DET dpj1-58 9 13 importance importance NOUN dpj1-58 9 14 for for SCONJ dpj1-58 9 15 the the DET dpj1-58 9 16 qualitative qualitative ADJ dpj1-58 9 17 researcher researcher NOUN dpj1-58 9 18 to to PART dpj1-58 9 19 view view VERB dpj1-58 9 20 discourse discourse NOUN dpj1-58 9 21 as as ADP dpj1-58 9 22 language language NOUN dpj1-58 9 23 in in ADP dpj1-58 9 24 action action NOUN dpj1-58 9 25 . . PUNCT dpj1-58 10 1 sullivan sullivan PROPN dpj1-58 10 2 writes write VERB dpj1-58 10 3 that that SCONJ dpj1-58 10 4 the the DET dpj1-58 10 5 dialogical dialogical ADJ dpj1-58 10 6 approach approach NOUN dpj1-58 10 7 ‘ ' PUNCT dpj1-58 10 8 provides provide VERB dpj1-58 10 9 tools tool NOUN dpj1-58 10 10 for for ADP dpj1-58 10 11 the the DET dpj1-58 10 12 methodological methodological ADJ dpj1-58 10 13 analysis analysis NOUN dpj1-58 10 14 of of ADP dpj1-58 10 15 subjectivity subjectivity NOUN dpj1-58 10 16 , , PUNCT dpj1-58 10 17 being be AUX dpj1-58 10 18 theorized theorize VERB dpj1-58 10 19 as as ADP dpj1-58 10 20 the the DET dpj1-58 10 21 changing change VERB dpj1-58 10 22 and and CCONJ dpj1-58 10 23 responding respond VERB dpj1-58 10 24 to to ADP dpj1-58 10 25 others other NOUN dpj1-58 10 26 ’ ' PUNCT dpj1-58 10 27 ( ( PUNCT dpj1-58 10 28 p.4 p.4 X dpj1-58 10 29 ) ) PUNCT dpj1-58 10 30 and and CCONJ dpj1-58 10 31 that that SCONJ dpj1-58 10 32 by by ADP dpj1-58 10 33 using use VERB dpj1-58 10 34 bakhtin bakhtin NOUN dpj1-58 10 35 ’s ’s PART dpj1-58 10 36 ideas idea NOUN dpj1-58 10 37 discourse discourse PROPN dpj1-58 10 38 can can AUX dpj1-58 10 39 be be AUX dpj1-58 10 40 viewed view VERB dpj1-58 10 41 as as ADP dpj1-58 10 42 “ " PUNCT dpj1-58 10 43 embodied embody VERB dpj1-58 10 44 subjectivity subjectivity NOUN dpj1-58 10 45 ” " PUNCT dpj1-58 10 46 ( ( PUNCT dpj1-58 10 47 p.44 p.44 NOUN dpj1-58 10 48 ) ) PUNCT dpj1-58 10 49 and and CCONJ dpj1-58 10 50 the the DET dpj1-58 10 51 conscious conscious ADJ dpj1-58 10 52 act act NOUN dpj1-58 10 53 of of ADP dpj1-58 10 54 anticipation anticipation NOUN dpj1-58 10 55 and and CCONJ dpj1-58 10 56 judgment judgment NOUN dpj1-58 10 57 . . PUNCT dpj1-58 11 1 sullivan sullivan PROPN dpj1-58 11 2 declares declare VERB dpj1-58 11 3 at at ADP dpj1-58 11 4 the the DET dpj1-58 11 5 very very ADV dpj1-58 11 6 beginning beginning NOUN dpj1-58 11 7 clearly clearly ADV dpj1-58 11 8 his his PRON dpj1-58 11 9 position position NOUN dpj1-58 11 10 and and CCONJ dpj1-58 11 11 particular particular ADJ dpj1-58 11 12 interest interest NOUN dpj1-58 11 13 in in ADP dpj1-58 11 14 michael michael PROPN dpj1-58 11 15 bakhtin bakhtin PROPN dpj1-58 11 16 ’s ’s PART dpj1-58 11 17 dialogic dialogic ADJ dpj1-58 11 18 ideas idea NOUN dpj1-58 11 19 and and CCONJ dpj1-58 11 20 how how SCONJ dpj1-58 11 21 they they PRON dpj1-58 11 22 shape shape VERB dpj1-58 11 23 qualitative qualitative ADJ dpj1-58 11 24 methodologies methodology NOUN dpj1-58 11 25 . . PUNCT dpj1-58 12 1 however however ADV dpj1-58 12 2 , , PUNCT dpj1-58 12 3 sullivan sullivan PROPN dpj1-58 12 4 states state VERB dpj1-58 12 5 that that SCONJ dpj1-58 12 6 bakhtin bakhtin NOUN dpj1-58 12 7 ’s ’s PART dpj1-58 12 8 ideas idea NOUN dpj1-58 12 9 can can AUX dpj1-58 12 10 be be AUX dpj1-58 12 11 at at ADP dpj1-58 12 12 times time NOUN dpj1-58 12 13 difficult difficult ADJ dpj1-58 12 14 to to PART dpj1-58 12 15 use use VERB dpj1-58 12 16 in in ADP dpj1-58 12 17 qualitative qualitative ADJ dpj1-58 12 18 methodology methodology NOUN dpj1-58 12 19 and and CCONJ dpj1-58 12 20 that that SCONJ dpj1-58 12 21 the the DET dpj1-58 12 22 aim aim NOUN dpj1-58 12 23 of of ADP dpj1-58 12 24 this this DET dpj1-58 12 25 book book NOUN dpj1-58 12 26 to to PART dpj1-58 12 27 give give VERB dpj1-58 12 28 ‘ ' PUNCT dpj1-58 12 29 dialogue dialogue NOUN dpj1-58 12 30 ’ ' PUNCT dpj1-58 12 31 a a DET dpj1-58 12 32 methodology methodology NOUN dpj1-58 12 33 and and CCONJ dpj1-58 12 34 place place NOUN dpj1-58 12 35 of of ADP dpj1-58 12 36 its its PRON dpj1-58 12 37 own own ADJ dpj1-58 12 38 within within ADP dpj1-58 12 39 the the DET dpj1-58 12 40 qualitative qualitative ADJ dpj1-58 12 41 paradigm paradigm NOUN dpj1-58 12 42 . . PUNCT dpj1-58 13 1 he he PRON dpj1-58 13 2 writes write VERB dpj1-58 13 3 that that SCONJ dpj1-58 13 4 he he PRON dpj1-58 13 5 sees see VERB dpj1-58 13 6 three three NUM dpj1-58 13 7 key key ADJ dpj1-58 13 8 contributions contribution NOUN dpj1-58 13 9 coming come VERB dpj1-58 13 10 from from ADP dpj1-58 13 11 bakhtin bakhtin NOUN dpj1-58 13 12 ’s ’s PART dpj1-58 13 13 work work NOUN dpj1-58 13 14 : : PUNCT dpj1-58 13 15 first first ADV dpj1-58 13 16 , , PUNCT dpj1-58 13 17 the the DET dpj1-58 13 18 ‘ ' PUNCT dpj1-58 13 19 existential existential ADJ dpj1-58 13 20 existence existence NOUN dpj1-58 13 21 on on ADP dpj1-58 13 22 a a DET dpj1-58 13 23 needy needy ADJ dpj1-58 13 24 self self NOUN dpj1-58 13 25 ‘ ' PUNCT dpj1-58 13 26 ( ( PUNCT dpj1-58 13 27 p.14 p.14 X dpj1-58 13 28 ) ) PUNCT dpj1-58 13 29 , , PUNCT dpj1-58 13 30 which which PRON dpj1-58 13 31 refers refer VERB dpj1-58 13 32 to to ADP dpj1-58 13 33 the the DET dpj1-58 13 34 notion notion NOUN dpj1-58 13 35 that that SCONJ dpj1-58 13 36 both both CCONJ dpj1-58 13 37 the the DET dpj1-58 13 38 researcher researcher NOUN dpj1-58 13 39 as as ADV dpj1-58 13 40 well well ADV dpj1-58 13 41 as as ADP dpj1-58 13 42 the the DET dpj1-58 13 43 participant participant NOUN dpj1-58 13 44 bring bring VERB dpj1-58 13 45 attitudes attitude NOUN dpj1-58 13 46 of of ADP dpj1-58 13 47 trust trust NOUN dpj1-58 13 48 and and CCONJ dpj1-58 13 49 suspicion suspicion NOUN dpj1-58 13 50 to to ADP dpj1-58 13 51 the the DET dpj1-58 13 52 interpretation interpretation NOUN dpj1-58 13 53 of of ADP dpj1-58 13 54 text text NOUN dpj1-58 13 55 material material NOUN dpj1-58 13 56 and and CCONJ dpj1-58 13 57 with with ADP dpj1-58 13 58 this this PRON dpj1-58 13 59 , , PUNCT dpj1-58 13 60 bakhtin bakhtin NOUN dpj1-58 13 61 is be AUX dpj1-58 13 62 positioning position VERB dpj1-58 13 63 the the DET dpj1-58 13 64 participant participant NOUN dpj1-58 13 65 as as ADP dpj1-58 13 66 being be AUX dpj1-58 13 67 a a DET dpj1-58 13 68 valid valid ADJ dpj1-58 13 69 knower knower NOUN dpj1-58 13 70 , , PUNCT dpj1-58 13 71 capable capable ADJ dpj1-58 13 72 of of ADP dpj1-58 13 73 interpreting interpret VERB dpj1-58 13 74 his his PRON dpj1-58 13 75 own own ADJ dpj1-58 13 76 data datum NOUN dpj1-58 13 77 but but CCONJ dpj1-58 13 78 also also ADV dpj1-58 13 79 that that SCONJ dpj1-58 13 80 there there PRON dpj1-58 13 81 are be VERB dpj1-58 13 82 more more ADJ dpj1-58 13 83 interpretations interpretation NOUN dpj1-58 13 84 to to ADP dpj1-58 13 85 the the DET dpj1-58 13 86 same same ADJ dpj1-58 13 87 experience experience NOUN dpj1-58 13 88 and and CCONJ dpj1-58 13 89 that that SCONJ dpj1-58 13 90 a a DET dpj1-58 13 91 dialogic dialogic ADJ dpj1-58 13 92 approach approach NOUN dpj1-58 13 93 to to ADP dpj1-58 13 94 analysis analysis NOUN dpj1-58 13 95 uncovers uncover NOUN dpj1-58 13 96 not not PART dpj1-58 13 97 the the DET dpj1-58 13 98 truth truth NOUN dpj1-58 13 99 but but CCONJ dpj1-58 13 100 rather rather ADV dpj1-58 13 101 the the DET dpj1-58 13 102 possibilities possibility NOUN dpj1-58 13 103 of of ADP dpj1-58 13 104 truths truth NOUN dpj1-58 13 105 . . PUNCT dpj1-58 14 1 second second ADJ dpj1-58 14 2 , , PUNCT dpj1-58 14 3 bakhtin bakhtin NOUN dpj1-58 14 4 ’s ’s PART dpj1-58 14 5 ‘ ' PUNCT dpj1-58 14 6 emphasis emphasis NOUN dpj1-58 14 7 on on ADP dpj1-58 14 8 ‘ ' PUNCT dpj1-58 14 9 truth truth NOUN dpj1-58 14 10 ’ ' PUNCT dpj1-58 14 11 as as ADP dpj1-58 14 12 ‘ ' PUNCT dpj1-58 14 13 pravda pravda NOUN dpj1-58 14 14 ’ ' PUNCT dpj1-58 14 15 in in ADP dpj1-58 14 16 a a DET dpj1-58 14 17 dialogical dialogical ADJ dpj1-58 14 18 approach approach NOUN dpj1-58 14 19 ’ ' PUNCT dpj1-58 14 20 ( ( PUNCT dpj1-58 14 21 p.15 p.15 NOUN dpj1-58 14 22 ) ) PUNCT dpj1-58 14 23 which which PRON dpj1-58 14 24 refers refer VERB dpj1-58 14 25 to to ADP dpj1-58 14 26 someone someone PRON dpj1-58 14 27 ’s ’s PART dpj1-58 14 28 vested vested ADJ dpj1-58 14 29 interest interest NOUN dpj1-58 14 30 in in ADP dpj1-58 14 31 their their PRON dpj1-58 14 32 belief belief NOUN dpj1-58 14 33 and and CCONJ dpj1-58 14 34 that that SCONJ dpj1-58 14 35 beliefs belief NOUN dpj1-58 14 36 can can AUX dpj1-58 14 37 be be AUX dpj1-58 14 38 so so ADV dpj1-58 14 39 strong strong ADJ dpj1-58 14 40 that that SCONJ dpj1-58 14 41 they they PRON dpj1-58 14 42 become become VERB dpj1-58 14 43 truth truth NOUN dpj1-58 14 44 and and CCONJ dpj1-58 14 45 be be AUX dpj1-58 14 46 embodied embody VERB dpj1-58 14 47 by by ADP dpj1-58 14 48 a a DET dpj1-58 14 49 person person NOUN dpj1-58 14 50 . . PUNCT dpj1-58 15 1 third third ADJ dpj1-58 15 2 , , PUNCT dpj1-58 15 3 the the DET dpj1-58 15 4 idea idea NOUN dpj1-58 15 5 that that SCONJ dpj1-58 15 6 ‘ ' PUNCT dpj1-58 15 7 otherness otherness NOUN dpj1-58 15 8 and and CCONJ dpj1-58 15 9 mystery mystery NOUN dpj1-58 15 10 can can AUX dpj1-58 15 11 be be AUX dpj1-58 15 12 built build VERB dpj1-58 15 13 into into ADP dpj1-58 15 14 the the DET dpj1-58 15 15 fabric fabric NOUN dpj1-58 15 16 of of ADP dpj1-58 15 17 talk talk NOUN dpj1-58 15 18 ’ ' PUNCT dpj1-58 15 19 emphasizes emphasize VERB dpj1-58 15 20 bakhtin bakhtin NOUN dpj1-58 15 21 ’s ’s PART dpj1-58 15 22 discussion discussion NOUN dpj1-58 15 23 about about ADP dpj1-58 15 24 anticipated anticipate VERB dpj1-58 15 25 responses response NOUN dpj1-58 15 26 delineating delineate VERB dpj1-58 15 27 boundaries boundary NOUN dpj1-58 15 28 between between ADP dpj1-58 15 29 the the DET dpj1-58 15 30 self self NOUN dpj1-58 15 31 and and CCONJ dpj1-58 15 32 other other ADJ dpj1-58 15 33 . . PUNCT dpj1-58 16 1 i i PRON dpj1-58 16 2 enjoyed enjoy VERB dpj1-58 16 3 reading read VERB dpj1-58 16 4 sullivan sullivan PROPN dpj1-58 16 5 ’s ’s PART dpj1-58 16 6 description description NOUN dpj1-58 16 7 of of ADP dpj1-58 16 8 dialogic dialogic ADJ dpj1-58 16 9 analysis analysis NOUN dpj1-58 16 10 because because SCONJ dpj1-58 16 11 he he PRON dpj1-58 16 12 contrasts contrast VERB dpj1-58 16 13 its its PRON dpj1-58 16 14 philosophical philosophical ADJ dpj1-58 16 15 and and CCONJ dpj1-58 16 16 methodological methodological ADJ dpj1-58 16 17 underpinnings underpinning NOUN dpj1-58 16 18 with with ADP dpj1-58 16 19 other other ADJ dpj1-58 16 20 methods method NOUN dpj1-58 16 21 of of ADP dpj1-58 16 22 discourse discourse NOUN dpj1-58 16 23 analysis analysis NOUN dpj1-58 16 24 . . PUNCT dpj1-58 17 1 but but CCONJ dpj1-58 17 2 more more ADJ dpj1-58 17 3 than than ADP dpj1-58 17 4 that that PRON dpj1-58 17 5 sullivan sullivan PROPN dpj1-58 17 6 issn issn PROPN dpj1-58 17 7 : : PUNCT dpj1-58 17 8 2325 2325 NUM dpj1-58 17 9 - - SYM dpj1-58 17 10 3290 3290 NUM dpj1-58 17 11 ( ( PUNCT dpj1-58 17 12 online online ADJ dpj1-58 17 13 ) ) PUNCT dpj1-58 17 14 dialogic dialogic ADJ dpj1-58 17 15 approaches approach NOUN dpj1-58 17 16 to to ADP dpj1-58 17 17 the the DET dpj1-58 17 18 study study NOUN dpj1-58 17 19 of of ADP dpj1-58 17 20 subjectivity subjectivity NOUN dpj1-58 17 21 kathrin kathrin PROPN dpj1-58 17 22 otrel otrel PROPN dpj1-58 17 23 - - PUNCT dpj1-58 17 24 cass cass PROPN dpj1-58 17 25 dialogic dialogic ADJ dpj1-58 17 26 pedagogy pedagogy NOUN dpj1-58 17 27 : : PUNCT dpj1-58 17 28 an an DET dpj1-58 17 29 international international ADJ dpj1-58 17 30 online online ADJ dpj1-58 17 31 journal journal NOUN dpj1-58 17 32 | | ADV dpj1-58 17 33 http://dpj.pitt.edu http://dpj.pitt.edu X dpj1-58 17 34 doi doi NOUN dpj1-58 17 35 : : PUNCT dpj1-58 17 36 10.5195 10.5195 NUM dpj1-58 17 37 / / SYM dpj1-58 17 38 dpj.2013.58 dpj.2013.58 PROPN dpj1-58 17 39 | | ADJ dpj1-58 17 40 vol vol NOUN dpj1-58 17 41 . . PROPN dpj1-58 17 42 1 1 NUM dpj1-58 17 43 ( ( PUNCT dpj1-58 17 44 2013 2013 NUM dpj1-58 17 45 ) ) PUNCT dpj1-58 17 46 b10 b10 PROPN dpj1-58 17 47 cross cros NOUN dpj1-58 17 48 - - NOUN dpj1-58 17 49 examines examine NOUN dpj1-58 17 50 through through ADP dpj1-58 17 51 this this PRON dpj1-58 17 52 the the DET dpj1-58 17 53 dialogic dialogic ADJ dpj1-58 17 54 approach approach NOUN dpj1-58 17 55 to to PART dpj1-58 17 56 make make VERB dpj1-58 17 57 an an DET dpj1-58 17 58 argument argument NOUN dpj1-58 17 59 for for SCONJ dpj1-58 17 60 it it PRON dpj1-58 17 61 to to PART dpj1-58 17 62 be be AUX dpj1-58 17 63 used use VERB dpj1-58 17 64 in in ADP dpj1-58 17 65 the the DET dpj1-58 17 66 analysis analysis NOUN dpj1-58 17 67 of of ADP dpj1-58 17 68 discourse discourse NOUN dpj1-58 17 69 . . PUNCT dpj1-58 18 1 i i PRON dpj1-58 18 2 was be AUX dpj1-58 18 3 drawn draw VERB dpj1-58 18 4 to to ADP dpj1-58 18 5 paul paul PROPN dpj1-58 18 6 sullivan sullivan PROPN dpj1-58 18 7 ’s ’s PART dpj1-58 18 8 book book NOUN dpj1-58 18 9 because because SCONJ dpj1-58 18 10 he he PRON dpj1-58 18 11 starts start VERB dpj1-58 18 12 by by ADP dpj1-58 18 13 reminding remind VERB dpj1-58 18 14 the the DET dpj1-58 18 15 reader reader NOUN dpj1-58 18 16 of of ADP dpj1-58 18 17 the the DET dpj1-58 18 18 importance importance NOUN dpj1-58 18 19 of of ADP dpj1-58 18 20 the the DET dpj1-58 18 21 philosophical philosophical ADJ dpj1-58 18 22 framework framework NOUN dpj1-58 18 23 a a DET dpj1-58 18 24 researcher researcher NOUN dpj1-58 18 25 needs need VERB dpj1-58 18 26 to to PART dpj1-58 18 27 uncover uncover VERB dpj1-58 18 28 truth truth NOUN dpj1-58 18 29 and and CCONJ dpj1-58 18 30 its its PRON dpj1-58 18 31 interconnectedness interconnectedness NOUN dpj1-58 18 32 with with ADP dpj1-58 18 33 research research NOUN dpj1-58 18 34 methods method NOUN dpj1-58 18 35 and and CCONJ dpj1-58 18 36 analysis analysis NOUN dpj1-58 18 37 procedures procedure NOUN dpj1-58 18 38 . . PUNCT dpj1-58 19 1 all all DET dpj1-58 19 2 researchers researcher NOUN dpj1-58 19 3 interested interested ADJ dpj1-58 19 4 in in ADP dpj1-58 19 5 dialogue dialogue NOUN dpj1-58 19 6 and and CCONJ dpj1-58 19 7 discourse discourse NOUN dpj1-58 19 8 are be AUX dpj1-58 19 9 eager eager ADJ dpj1-58 19 10 to to PART dpj1-58 19 11 collect collect VERB dpj1-58 19 12 data datum NOUN dpj1-58 19 13 in in ADP dpj1-58 19 14 the the DET dpj1-58 19 15 search search NOUN dpj1-58 19 16 for for ADP dpj1-58 19 17 answers answer NOUN dpj1-58 19 18 but but CCONJ dpj1-58 19 19 but but CCONJ dpj1-58 19 20 not not PART dpj1-58 19 21 seldom seldom ADV dpj1-58 19 22 overlook overlook VERB dpj1-58 19 23 how how SCONJ dpj1-58 19 24 much much ADJ dpj1-58 19 25 can can AUX dpj1-58 19 26 be be AUX dpj1-58 19 27 gained gain VERB dpj1-58 19 28 by by ADP dpj1-58 19 29 finding find VERB dpj1-58 19 30 out out ADP dpj1-58 19 31 how how SCONJ dpj1-58 19 32 different different ADJ dpj1-58 19 33 theories theory NOUN dpj1-58 19 34 of of ADP dpj1-58 19 35 knowledge knowledge NOUN dpj1-58 19 36 shape shape NOUN dpj1-58 19 37 research research NOUN dpj1-58 19 38 findings finding NOUN dpj1-58 19 39 . . PUNCT dpj1-58 20 1 sullivan sullivan PROPN dpj1-58 20 2 reminds remind VERB dpj1-58 20 3 us we PRON dpj1-58 20 4 that that SCONJ dpj1-58 20 5 ‘ ' PUNCT dpj1-58 20 6 by by ADP dpj1-58 20 7 looking look VERB dpj1-58 20 8 at at ADP dpj1-58 20 9 the the DET dpj1-58 20 10 methodological methodological ADJ dpj1-58 20 11 ‘ ' PUNCT dpj1-58 20 12 practices practice NOUN dpj1-58 20 13 ’ ' PUNCT dpj1-58 20 14 , , PUNCT dpj1-58 20 15 we we PRON dpj1-58 20 16 can can AUX dpj1-58 20 17 more more ADV dpj1-58 20 18 clearly clearly ADV dpj1-58 20 19 delineate delineate VERB dpj1-58 20 20 the the DET dpj1-58 20 21 contours contours NOUN dpj1-58 20 22 of of ADP dpj1-58 20 23 a a DET dpj1-58 20 24 method method NOUN dpj1-58 20 25 ’ ' PUNCT dpj1-58 20 26 ( ( PUNCT dpj1-58 20 27 p.6 p.6 NOUN dpj1-58 20 28 ) ) PUNCT dpj1-58 20 29 . . PUNCT dpj1-58 21 1 he he PRON dpj1-58 21 2 is be AUX dpj1-58 21 3 making make VERB dpj1-58 21 4 this this DET dpj1-58 21 5 point point NOUN dpj1-58 21 6 throughout throughout ADP dpj1-58 21 7 the the DET dpj1-58 21 8 book book NOUN dpj1-58 21 9 by by ADP dpj1-58 21 10 discussing discuss VERB dpj1-58 21 11 how how SCONJ dpj1-58 21 12 other other ADJ dpj1-58 21 13 methodological methodological ADJ dpj1-58 21 14 positions position NOUN dpj1-58 21 15 such such ADJ dpj1-58 21 16 as as ADP dpj1-58 21 17 grounded ground VERB dpj1-58 21 18 theory theory NOUN dpj1-58 21 19 , , PUNCT dpj1-58 21 20 discourse discourse NOUN dpj1-58 21 21 analyses analysis NOUN dpj1-58 21 22 , , PUNCT dpj1-58 21 23 phenomenological phenomenological ADJ dpj1-58 21 24 analyses analysis NOUN dpj1-58 21 25 or or CCONJ dpj1-58 21 26 narrative narrative NOUN dpj1-58 21 27 analyses analysis NOUN dpj1-58 21 28 shape shape VERB dpj1-58 21 29 the the DET dpj1-58 21 30 nature nature NOUN dpj1-58 21 31 of of ADP dpj1-58 21 32 meaning mean VERB dpj1-58 21 33 making making NOUN dpj1-58 21 34 of of ADP dpj1-58 21 35 language language NOUN dpj1-58 21 36 in in ADP dpj1-58 21 37 action action NOUN dpj1-58 21 38 and and CCONJ dpj1-58 21 39 contrasts contrast VERB dpj1-58 21 40 it it PRON dpj1-58 21 41 with with ADP dpj1-58 21 42 the the DET dpj1-58 21 43 contribution contribution NOUN dpj1-58 21 44 a a DET dpj1-58 21 45 dialogical dialogical ADJ dpj1-58 21 46 approach approach NOUN dpj1-58 21 47 can can AUX dpj1-58 21 48 make make VERB dpj1-58 21 49 . . PUNCT dpj1-58 22 1 i i PRON dpj1-58 22 2 found find VERB dpj1-58 22 3 also also ADV dpj1-58 22 4 that that SCONJ dpj1-58 22 5 sullivan sullivan PROPN dpj1-58 22 6 exemplifies exemplify VERB dpj1-58 22 7 his his PRON dpj1-58 22 8 approach approach NOUN dpj1-58 22 9 to to ADP dpj1-58 22 10 dialogism dialogism NOUN dpj1-58 22 11 by by ADP dpj1-58 22 12 applying apply VERB dpj1-58 22 13 it it PRON dpj1-58 22 14 to to ADP dpj1-58 22 15 his his PRON dpj1-58 22 16 own own ADJ dpj1-58 22 17 writing writing NOUN dpj1-58 22 18 in in ADP dpj1-58 22 19 this this DET dpj1-58 22 20 book book NOUN dpj1-58 22 21 , , PUNCT dpj1-58 22 22 drawing draw VERB dpj1-58 22 23 attention attention NOUN dpj1-58 22 24 to to ADP dpj1-58 22 25 the the DET dpj1-58 22 26 conflicts conflict NOUN dpj1-58 22 27 , , PUNCT dpj1-58 22 28 judgments judgment NOUN dpj1-58 22 29 and and CCONJ dpj1-58 22 30 interpretative interpretative ADJ dpj1-58 22 31 activities activity NOUN dpj1-58 22 32 in in ADP dpj1-58 22 33 the the DET dpj1-58 22 34 use use NOUN dpj1-58 22 35 , , PUNCT dpj1-58 22 36 capture capture NOUN dpj1-58 22 37 and and CCONJ dpj1-58 22 38 analysis analysis NOUN dpj1-58 22 39 of of ADP dpj1-58 22 40 language language NOUN dpj1-58 22 41 . . PUNCT dpj1-58 23 1 he he PRON dpj1-58 23 2 practices practice VERB dpj1-58 23 3 dialogism dialogism NOUN dpj1-58 23 4 by by ADP dpj1-58 23 5 interacting interact VERB dpj1-58 23 6 with with ADP dpj1-58 23 7 the the DET dpj1-58 23 8 ideas idea NOUN dpj1-58 23 9 he he PRON dpj1-58 23 10 draws draw VERB dpj1-58 23 11 on on ADP dpj1-58 23 12 and and CCONJ dpj1-58 23 13 reviewing review VERB dpj1-58 23 14 them they PRON dpj1-58 23 15 critically critically ADV dpj1-58 23 16 . . PUNCT dpj1-58 24 1 when when SCONJ dpj1-58 24 2 he he PRON dpj1-58 24 3 provides provide VERB dpj1-58 24 4 the the DET dpj1-58 24 5 reader reader NOUN dpj1-58 24 6 with with ADP dpj1-58 24 7 pragmatic pragmatic ADJ dpj1-58 24 8 and and CCONJ dpj1-58 24 9 concrete concrete ADJ dpj1-58 24 10 examples example NOUN dpj1-58 24 11 , , PUNCT dpj1-58 24 12 he he PRON dpj1-58 24 13 uses use VERB dpj1-58 24 14 them they PRON dpj1-58 24 15 to to PART dpj1-58 24 16 explore explore VERB dpj1-58 24 17 theoretical theoretical ADJ dpj1-58 24 18 aspects aspect NOUN dpj1-58 24 19 that that PRON dpj1-58 24 20 shape shape VERB dpj1-58 24 21 the the DET dpj1-58 24 22 data data NOUN dpj1-58 24 23 analysis analysis NOUN dpj1-58 24 24 , , PUNCT dpj1-58 24 25 echoing echo VERB dpj1-58 24 26 his his PRON dpj1-58 24 27 appreciation appreciation NOUN dpj1-58 24 28 for for ADP dpj1-58 24 29 bakhtin bakhtin NOUN dpj1-58 24 30 ’s ’s PART dpj1-58 24 31 focus focus NOUN dpj1-58 24 32 on on ADP dpj1-58 24 33 practical practical ADJ dpj1-58 24 34 and and CCONJ dpj1-58 24 35 usable usable ADJ dpj1-58 24 36 theories theory NOUN dpj1-58 24 37 . . PUNCT dpj1-58 25 1 sullivan sullivan PROPN dpj1-58 25 2 spends spend VERB dpj1-58 25 3 time time NOUN dpj1-58 25 4 drawing draw VERB dpj1-58 25 5 attention attention NOUN dpj1-58 25 6 to to ADP dpj1-58 25 7 different different ADJ dpj1-58 25 8 analytical analytical ADJ dpj1-58 25 9 methods method NOUN dpj1-58 25 10 including include VERB dpj1-58 25 11 grounded ground VERB dpj1-58 25 12 theory theory NOUN dpj1-58 25 13 , , PUNCT dpj1-58 25 14 discourse discourse NOUN dpj1-58 25 15 analysis analysis NOUN dpj1-58 25 16 , , PUNCT dpj1-58 25 17 narrative narrative ADJ dpj1-58 25 18 analysis analysis NOUN dpj1-58 25 19 and and CCONJ dpj1-58 25 20 phenomenological phenomenological ADJ dpj1-58 25 21 analysis analysis NOUN dpj1-58 25 22 being be AUX dpj1-58 25 23 mindful mindful ADJ dpj1-58 25 24 of of ADP dpj1-58 25 25 the the DET dpj1-58 25 26 various various ADJ dpj1-58 25 27 traditions tradition NOUN dpj1-58 25 28 and and CCONJ dpj1-58 25 29 their their PRON dpj1-58 25 30 analytical analytical ADJ dpj1-58 25 31 elements element NOUN dpj1-58 25 32 they they PRON dpj1-58 25 33 bring bring VERB dpj1-58 25 34 to to ADP dpj1-58 25 35 the the DET dpj1-58 25 36 analysis analysis NOUN dpj1-58 25 37 of of ADP dpj1-58 25 38 dialogue dialogue NOUN dpj1-58 25 39 . . PUNCT dpj1-58 26 1 this this PRON dpj1-58 26 2 is be AUX dpj1-58 26 3 important important ADJ dpj1-58 26 4 because because SCONJ dpj1-58 26 5 it it PRON dpj1-58 26 6 creates create VERB dpj1-58 26 7 the the DET dpj1-58 26 8 argument argument NOUN dpj1-58 26 9 why why SCONJ dpj1-58 26 10 a a DET dpj1-58 26 11 dialogic dialogic ADJ dpj1-58 26 12 approach approach NOUN dpj1-58 26 13 to to ADP dpj1-58 26 14 data datum NOUN dpj1-58 26 15 analysis analysis NOUN dpj1-58 26 16 is be AUX dpj1-58 26 17 different different ADJ dpj1-58 26 18 but but CCONJ dpj1-58 26 19 also also ADV dpj1-58 26 20 how how SCONJ dpj1-58 26 21 it it PRON dpj1-58 26 22 is be AUX dpj1-58 26 23 influenced influence VERB dpj1-58 26 24 by by ADP dpj1-58 26 25 those those DET dpj1-58 26 26 traditions tradition NOUN dpj1-58 26 27 and and CCONJ dpj1-58 26 28 where where SCONJ dpj1-58 26 29 it it PRON dpj1-58 26 30 can can AUX dpj1-58 26 31 add add VERB dpj1-58 26 32 new new ADJ dpj1-58 26 33 insights insight NOUN dpj1-58 26 34 into into ADP dpj1-58 26 35 the the DET dpj1-58 26 36 analysis analysis NOUN dpj1-58 26 37 of of ADP dpj1-58 26 38 discourse discourse NOUN dpj1-58 26 39 . . PUNCT dpj1-58 27 1 the the DET dpj1-58 27 2 book book NOUN dpj1-58 27 3 allows allow VERB dpj1-58 27 4 the the DET dpj1-58 27 5 readers reader NOUN dpj1-58 27 6 to to PART dpj1-58 27 7 examine examine VERB dpj1-58 27 8 their their PRON dpj1-58 27 9 own own ADJ dpj1-58 27 10 positions position NOUN dpj1-58 27 11 on on ADP dpj1-58 27 12 the the DET dpj1-58 27 13 nature nature NOUN dpj1-58 27 14 of of ADP dpj1-58 27 15 dialogue dialogue NOUN dpj1-58 27 16 , , PUNCT dpj1-58 27 17 their their PRON dpj1-58 27 18 struggles struggle NOUN dpj1-58 27 19 to to PART dpj1-58 27 20 identify identify VERB dpj1-58 27 21 intimate intimate ADJ dpj1-58 27 22 , , PUNCT dpj1-58 27 23 emotional emotional ADJ dpj1-58 27 24 encounters encounter NOUN dpj1-58 27 25 in in ADP dpj1-58 27 26 language language NOUN dpj1-58 27 27 and and CCONJ dpj1-58 27 28 shows show VERB dpj1-58 27 29 ways way NOUN dpj1-58 27 30 to to PART dpj1-58 27 31 uncover uncover VERB dpj1-58 27 32 transformations transformation NOUN dpj1-58 27 33 . . PUNCT dpj1-58 28 1 sullivan sullivan PROPN dpj1-58 28 2 achieves achieve VERB dpj1-58 28 3 this this PRON dpj1-58 28 4 by by ADP dpj1-58 28 5 sharing share VERB dpj1-58 28 6 his his PRON dpj1-58 28 7 own own ADJ dpj1-58 28 8 struggles struggle NOUN dpj1-58 28 9 and and CCONJ dpj1-58 28 10 challenges challenge NOUN dpj1-58 28 11 for for ADP dpj1-58 28 12 instance instance NOUN dpj1-58 28 13 by by ADP dpj1-58 28 14 reflecting reflect VERB dpj1-58 28 15 “ " PUNCT dpj1-58 28 16 … … PUNCT dpj1-58 28 17 i i PRON dpj1-58 28 18 was be AUX dpj1-58 28 19 unsure unsure ADJ dpj1-58 28 20 what what PRON dpj1-58 28 21 the the DET dpj1-58 28 22 overview overview NOUN dpj1-58 28 23 was be AUX dpj1-58 28 24 or or CCONJ dpj1-58 28 25 what what PRON dpj1-58 28 26 the the DET dpj1-58 28 27 specific specific ADJ dpj1-58 28 28 questions question NOUN dpj1-58 28 29 would would AUX dpj1-58 28 30 be be AUX dpj1-58 28 31 ” " PUNCT dpj1-58 28 32 ( ( PUNCT dpj1-58 28 33 p.83 p.83 PROPN dpj1-58 28 34 ) ) PUNCT dpj1-58 28 35 , , PUNCT dpj1-58 28 36 when when SCONJ dpj1-58 28 37 he he PRON dpj1-58 28 38 is be AUX dpj1-58 28 39 writing write VERB dpj1-58 28 40 on on ADP dpj1-58 28 41 the the DET dpj1-58 28 42 presentation presentation NOUN dpj1-58 28 43 of of ADP dpj1-58 28 44 a a DET dpj1-58 28 45 summary summary NOUN dpj1-58 28 46 of of ADP dpj1-58 28 47 the the DET dpj1-58 28 48 overview overview NOUN dpj1-58 28 49 of of ADP dpj1-58 28 50 the the DET dpj1-58 28 51 analysis analysis NOUN dpj1-58 28 52 . . PUNCT dpj1-58 29 1 sullivan sullivan NOUN dpj1-58 29 2 encourages encourage VERB dpj1-58 29 3 his his PRON dpj1-58 29 4 audience audience NOUN dpj1-58 29 5 as as ADV dpj1-58 29 6 well well ADV dpj1-58 29 7 to to PART dpj1-58 29 8 develop develop VERB dpj1-58 29 9 their their PRON dpj1-58 29 10 own own ADJ dpj1-58 29 11 voice voice NOUN dpj1-58 29 12 through through ADP dpj1-58 29 13 the the DET dpj1-58 29 14 joint joint ADJ dpj1-58 29 15 creation creation NOUN dpj1-58 29 16 between between ADP dpj1-58 29 17 theory theory NOUN dpj1-58 29 18 and and CCONJ dpj1-58 29 19 data datum NOUN dpj1-58 29 20 . . PUNCT dpj1-58 30 1 sullivan sullivan NOUN dpj1-58 30 2 is be AUX dpj1-58 30 3 not not PART dpj1-58 30 4 uncritical uncritical ADJ dpj1-58 30 5 about about ADP dpj1-58 30 6 the the DET dpj1-58 30 7 dialogical dialogical ADJ dpj1-58 30 8 approach approach NOUN dpj1-58 30 9 to to ADP dpj1-58 30 10 qualitative qualitative ADJ dpj1-58 30 11 analysis analysis NOUN dpj1-58 30 12 . . PUNCT dpj1-58 31 1 while while SCONJ dpj1-58 31 2 he he PRON dpj1-58 31 3 draws draw VERB dpj1-58 31 4 attention attention NOUN dpj1-58 31 5 to to ADP dpj1-58 31 6 its its PRON dpj1-58 31 7 strengths strength NOUN dpj1-58 31 8 he he PRON dpj1-58 31 9 also also ADV dpj1-58 31 10 explains explain VERB dpj1-58 31 11 that that SCONJ dpj1-58 31 12 it it PRON dpj1-58 31 13 may may AUX dpj1-58 31 14 be be AUX dpj1-58 31 15 used use VERB dpj1-58 31 16 in in ADP dpj1-58 31 17 addition addition NOUN dpj1-58 31 18 to to ADP dpj1-58 31 19 other other ADJ dpj1-58 31 20 approaches approach NOUN dpj1-58 31 21 to to PART dpj1-58 31 22 gain gain VERB dpj1-58 31 23 new new ADJ dpj1-58 31 24 and and CCONJ dpj1-58 31 25 different different ADJ dpj1-58 31 26 insights insight NOUN dpj1-58 31 27 . . PUNCT dpj1-58 32 1 he he PRON dpj1-58 32 2 describes describe VERB dpj1-58 32 3 that that SCONJ dpj1-58 32 4 the the DET dpj1-58 32 5 dialogic dialogic ADJ dpj1-58 32 6 approach approach NOUN dpj1-58 32 7 has have VERB dpj1-58 32 8 optimistic optimistic ADJ dpj1-58 32 9 views view NOUN dpj1-58 32 10 of of ADP dpj1-58 32 11 conscious conscious ADJ dpj1-58 32 12 awareness awareness NOUN dpj1-58 32 13 and and CCONJ dpj1-58 32 14 potential potential ADJ dpj1-58 32 15 flaws flaw NOUN dpj1-58 32 16 in in ADP dpj1-58 32 17 how how SCONJ dpj1-58 32 18 power power NOUN dpj1-58 32 19 relations relation NOUN dpj1-58 32 20 are be AUX dpj1-58 32 21 perceived perceive VERB dpj1-58 32 22 ( ( PUNCT dpj1-58 32 23 p.62 p.62 NOUN dpj1-58 32 24 ) ) PUNCT dpj1-58 32 25 . . PUNCT dpj1-58 33 1 however however ADV dpj1-58 33 2 he he PRON dpj1-58 33 3 reflects reflect VERB dpj1-58 33 4 also also ADV dpj1-58 33 5 to to PART dpj1-58 33 6 say say VERB dpj1-58 33 7 that that SCONJ dpj1-58 33 8 its its PRON dpj1-58 33 9 particular particular ADJ dpj1-58 33 10 suitability suitability NOUN dpj1-58 33 11 lies lie VERB dpj1-58 33 12 in in ADP dpj1-58 33 13 making make VERB dpj1-58 33 14 sense sense NOUN dpj1-58 33 15 of of ADP dpj1-58 33 16 subjectivity subjectivity NOUN dpj1-58 33 17 , , PUNCT dpj1-58 33 18 lived live VERB dpj1-58 33 19 experiences experience NOUN dpj1-58 33 20 and and CCONJ dpj1-58 33 21 authorship authorship NOUN dpj1-58 33 22 . . PUNCT dpj1-58 34 1 at at ADP dpj1-58 34 2 the the DET dpj1-58 34 3 end end NOUN dpj1-58 34 4 of of ADP dpj1-58 34 5 the the DET dpj1-58 34 6 book book NOUN dpj1-58 34 7 sullivan sullivan PROPN dpj1-58 34 8 reflects reflect VERB dpj1-58 34 9 on on ADP dpj1-58 34 10 theory theory NOUN dpj1-58 34 11 and and CCONJ dpj1-58 34 12 applications application NOUN dpj1-58 34 13 and and CCONJ dpj1-58 34 14 his his PRON dpj1-58 34 15 proposed propose VERB dpj1-58 34 16 ways way NOUN dpj1-58 34 17 forward forward ADV dpj1-58 34 18 . . PUNCT dpj1-58 35 1 he he PRON dpj1-58 35 2 also also ADV dpj1-58 35 3 reminds remind VERB dpj1-58 35 4 the the DET dpj1-58 35 5 reader reader NOUN dpj1-58 35 6 to to PART dpj1-58 35 7 take take VERB dpj1-58 35 8 note note NOUN dpj1-58 35 9 of of ADP dpj1-58 35 10 his his PRON dpj1-58 35 11 position position NOUN dpj1-58 35 12 and and CCONJ dpj1-58 35 13 the the DET dpj1-58 35 14 theoretical theoretical ADJ dpj1-58 35 15 ideas idea NOUN dpj1-58 35 16 that that PRON dpj1-58 35 17 have have AUX dpj1-58 35 18 influenced influence VERB dpj1-58 35 19 his his PRON dpj1-58 35 20 thinking thinking NOUN dpj1-58 35 21 . . PUNCT dpj1-58 36 1 he he PRON dpj1-58 36 2 exemplifies exemplify VERB dpj1-58 36 3 here here ADV dpj1-58 36 4 again again ADV dpj1-58 36 5 bakhtin bakhtin NOUN dpj1-58 36 6 ’s ’s PART dpj1-58 36 7 ideas idea NOUN dpj1-58 36 8 he he PRON dpj1-58 36 9 referred refer VERB dpj1-58 36 10 to to ADP dpj1-58 36 11 at at ADP dpj1-58 36 12 the the DET dpj1-58 36 13 beginning beginning NOUN dpj1-58 36 14 of of ADP dpj1-58 36 15 the the DET dpj1-58 36 16 book book NOUN dpj1-58 36 17 that that PRON dpj1-58 36 18 ‘ ' PUNCT dpj1-58 36 19 ideas idea NOUN dpj1-58 36 20 are be AUX dpj1-58 36 21 lived live VERB dpj1-58 36 22 rather rather ADV dpj1-58 36 23 than than ADP dpj1-58 36 24 abstract abstract ADJ dpj1-58 36 25 and and CCONJ dpj1-58 36 26 full full ADJ dpj1-58 36 27 of of ADP dpj1-58 36 28 personal personal ADJ dpj1-58 36 29 values value NOUN dpj1-58 36 30 and and CCONJ dpj1-58 36 31 judgments judgment NOUN dpj1-58 36 32 ’ ' PUNCT dpj1-58 36 33 ( ( PUNCT dpj1-58 36 34 p.5 p.5 NOUN dpj1-58 36 35 ) ) PUNCT dpj1-58 36 36 . . PUNCT dpj1-58 37 1 i i PRON dpj1-58 37 2 appreciated appreciate VERB dpj1-58 37 3 the the DET dpj1-58 37 4 book book NOUN dpj1-58 37 5 ’s ’s PART dpj1-58 37 6 pragmatic pragmatic ADJ dpj1-58 37 7 yet yet CCONJ dpj1-58 37 8 highly highly ADV dpj1-58 37 9 theoretical theoretical ADJ dpj1-58 37 10 and and CCONJ dpj1-58 37 11 critical critical ADJ dpj1-58 37 12 approach approach NOUN dpj1-58 37 13 to to ADP dpj1-58 37 14 the the DET dpj1-58 37 15 topic topic NOUN dpj1-58 37 16 . . PUNCT dpj1-58 38 1 i i PRON dpj1-58 38 2 believe believe VERB dpj1-58 38 3 this this DET dpj1-58 38 4 book book NOUN dpj1-58 38 5 can can AUX dpj1-58 38 6 be be AUX dpj1-58 38 7 very very ADV dpj1-58 38 8 useful useful ADJ dpj1-58 38 9 for for ADP dpj1-58 38 10 social social ADJ dpj1-58 38 11 science science NOUN dpj1-58 38 12 researchers researcher NOUN dpj1-58 38 13 who who PRON dpj1-58 38 14 are be AUX dpj1-58 38 15 interested interested ADJ dpj1-58 38 16 in in ADP dpj1-58 38 17 the the DET dpj1-58 38 18 qualitative qualitative ADJ dpj1-58 38 19 analysis analysis NOUN dpj1-58 38 20 of of ADP dpj1-58 38 21 dialogue dialogue NOUN dpj1-58 38 22 . . PUNCT dpj1-58 39 1 sullivan sullivan PROPN dpj1-58 39 2 skillfully skillfully ADV dpj1-58 39 3 provides provide VERB dpj1-58 39 4 the the DET dpj1-58 39 5 reader reader NOUN dpj1-58 39 6 with with ADP dpj1-58 39 7 tools tool NOUN dpj1-58 39 8 both both CCONJ dpj1-58 39 9 ontological ontological ADJ dpj1-58 39 10 and and CCONJ dpj1-58 39 11 pragmatic pragmatic ADJ dpj1-58 39 12 . . PUNCT dpj1-58 40 1 he he PRON dpj1-58 40 2 uses use VERB dpj1-58 40 3 an an DET dpj1-58 40 4 aesthetic aesthetic ADJ dpj1-58 40 5 approach approach NOUN dpj1-58 40 6 to to PART dpj1-58 40 7 discourse discourse NOUN dpj1-58 40 8 that that PRON dpj1-58 40 9 emphasizes emphasize VERB dpj1-58 40 10 how how SCONJ dpj1-58 40 11 ‘ ' PUNCT dpj1-58 40 12 discourse discourse NOUN dpj1-58 40 13 can can AUX dpj1-58 40 14 shapes shape VERB dpj1-58 40 15 selves self NOUN dpj1-58 40 16 and and CCONJ dpj1-58 40 17 how how SCONJ dpj1-58 40 18 selves self NOUN dpj1-58 40 19 can can AUX dpj1-58 40 20 respond respond VERB dpj1-58 40 21 to to ADP dpj1-58 40 22 this this DET dpj1-58 40 23 shaping shaping NOUN dpj1-58 40 24 ’ ' PUNCT dpj1-58 40 25 ( ( PUNCT dpj1-58 40 26 p.43 p.43 NOUN dpj1-58 40 27 ) ) PUNCT dpj1-58 40 28 and and CCONJ dpj1-58 40 29 builds build VERB dpj1-58 40 30 on on ADP dpj1-58 40 31 bakhtin bakhtin NOUN dpj1-58 40 32 ’s ’s PART dpj1-58 40 33 ideas idea NOUN dpj1-58 40 34 of of ADP dpj1-58 40 35 how how SCONJ dpj1-58 40 36 identity identity NOUN dpj1-58 40 37 is be AUX dpj1-58 40 38 shaped shape VERB dpj1-58 40 39 by by ADP dpj1-58 40 40 both both CCONJ dpj1-58 40 41 the the DET dpj1-58 40 42 anticipation anticipation NOUN dpj1-58 40 43 of of ADP dpj1-58 40 44 what what PRON dpj1-58 40 45 is be AUX dpj1-58 40 46 to to PART dpj1-58 40 47 be be AUX dpj1-58 40 48 expected expect VERB dpj1-58 40 49 and and CCONJ dpj1-58 40 50 how how SCONJ dpj1-58 40 51 this this PRON dpj1-58 40 52 shapes shape VERB dpj1-58 40 53 the the DET dpj1-58 40 54 ‘ ' PUNCT dpj1-58 40 55 authoring authoring NOUN dpj1-58 40 56 of of ADP dpj1-58 40 57 our our PRON dpj1-58 40 58 own own ADJ dpj1-58 40 59 identity identity NOUN dpj1-58 40 60 ’ ' PUNCT dpj1-58 40 61 ( ( PUNCT dpj1-58 40 62 p.3 p.3 NOUN dpj1-58 40 63 ) ) PUNCT dpj1-58 40 64 . . PUNCT dpj1-58 41 1 dialogic dialogic ADJ dpj1-58 41 2 approaches approach NOUN dpj1-58 41 3 to to ADP dpj1-58 41 4 the the DET dpj1-58 41 5 study study NOUN dpj1-58 41 6 of of ADP dpj1-58 41 7 subjectivity subjectivity NOUN dpj1-58 41 8 kathrin kathrin PROPN dpj1-58 41 9 otrel otrel PROPN dpj1-58 41 10 - - PUNCT dpj1-58 41 11 cass cass PROPN dpj1-58 41 12 dialogic dialogic ADJ dpj1-58 41 13 pedagogy pedagogy NOUN dpj1-58 41 14 : : PUNCT dpj1-58 41 15 an an DET dpj1-58 41 16 international international ADJ dpj1-58 41 17 online online ADJ dpj1-58 41 18 journal journal NOUN dpj1-58 41 19 | | ADV dpj1-58 41 20 http://dpj.pitt.edu http://dpj.pitt.edu X dpj1-58 41 21 doi doi NOUN dpj1-58 41 22 : : PUNCT dpj1-58 41 23 10.5195 10.5195 NUM dpj1-58 41 24 / / SYM dpj1-58 41 25 dpj.2013.58 dpj.2013.58 PROPN dpj1-58 41 26 | | ADJ dpj1-58 41 27 vol vol NOUN dpj1-58 41 28 . . PROPN dpj1-58 41 29 1 1 NUM dpj1-58 41 30 ( ( PUNCT dpj1-58 41 31 2013 2013 NUM dpj1-58 41 32 ) ) PUNCT dpj1-58 41 33 b11 b11 NOUN dpj1-58 41 34 articles article NOUN dpj1-58 41 35 in in ADP dpj1-58 41 36 this this DET dpj1-58 41 37 journal journal NOUN dpj1-58 41 38 are be AUX dpj1-58 41 39 licensed license VERB dpj1-58 41 40 under under ADP dpj1-58 41 41 a a DET dpj1-58 41 42 creative creative ADJ dpj1-58 41 43 commons common NOUN dpj1-58 41 44 attribution attribution NOUN dpj1-58 41 45 3.0 3.0 NUM dpj1-58 41 46 united unite VERB dpj1-58 41 47 states states PROPN dpj1-58 41 48 license license NOUN dpj1-58 41 49 . . PUNCT dpj1-58 42 1 this this DET dpj1-58 42 2 journal journal NOUN dpj1-58 42 3 is be AUX dpj1-58 42 4 published publish VERB dpj1-58 42 5 by by ADP dpj1-58 42 6 the the DET dpj1-58 42 7 university university NOUN dpj1-58 42 8 library library NOUN dpj1-58 42 9 system system NOUN dpj1-58 42 10 , , PUNCT dpj1-58 42 11 university university NOUN dpj1-58 42 12 of of ADP dpj1-58 42 13 pittsburgh pittsburgh PROPN dpj1-58 42 14 as as ADP dpj1-58 42 15 part part NOUN dpj1-58 42 16 of of ADP dpj1-58 42 17 its its PRON dpj1-58 42 18 d d NOUN dpj1-58 42 19 - - PUNCT dpj1-58 42 20 scribe scribe VERB dpj1-58 42 21 digital digital ADJ dpj1-58 42 22 publishing publishing NOUN dpj1-58 42 23 program program NOUN dpj1-58 42 24 and and CCONJ dpj1-58 42 25 is be AUX dpj1-58 42 26 cosponsored cosponsor VERB dpj1-58 42 27 by by ADP dpj1-58 42 28 the the DET dpj1-58 42 29 university university PROPN dpj1-58 42 30 of of ADP dpj1-58 42 31 pittsburgh pittsburgh PROPN dpj1-58 42 32 press press NOUN dpj1-58 42 33 . . PUNCT