








































< Brabazon, Tara. “It’s the Cake Talking” 
Digest: a Journal of Foodways and Culture 4:1 (2015): n. pag.> © American Folklore Society 2015

It’s the Cake Talking
Theorizing the Recipe Memoir

By: Tara Brabazon

Recipes – captured on paper and in analogue mode - are frequently marked by residues 
from ingredients, cooking, experience and expertise.  Drips, drops, mistakes and 
successes leave their dregs on cookbooks and individual recipes.  In this article, I 
deploy unobtrusive research methods (Kellehear 1993), revealing a history of these 
residues.  When opening a recipe book, researchers can see which pages were 
(well) read and which were never opened.  Notes, additions and corrections can 
be tracked.  Digitization has transformed this process.  Mobile phone applications 
provide recipes and blogs sharing successes and failures.   It is – ironically – an 
undercooked genre but one that provides opportunities to renegotiate the relationship 
between family and popular culture, information literacy and food literacy.

The recipe memoir offers a window into an array of intricate social, cultural, gendered, 
classed, rural, regional and national histories.  As Clementi has shown, the recipe memoir 
may encase histories of migration and genocide (Clementi 2014).  Blogs publish recipes 
to track the movement “From Child to Chef” (Arrouze 2014).  Most frequently, the genre 
is used to understand a family as it moves through time and space, how continuities are 
bent, bruised and reshaped through changes to work, leisure and landscape (Ellsworth 
2010).  Recipe memoirs can, to cite Jane Dixon, “explain the production of tastes for 
foods and food practices” (2002:80).  Interdisciplinary innovations are also present.  
Diane Tye revealed Baking as Biography (2010).  It is  also history and historiography, 
geography and cultural geography.  It weaves through popular and unpopular culture.  
While expansive histories of the agrarian and industrial revolutions can be traced 
through ingredients and the recipes that fed the factories, the recipe memoir creates a 
tapestry of textures, stories, memories and tastes that are not definitive, causal or easily 
accessible for a researcher.  This emerging genre has profound potential to reveal the 
“lipstick traces” (Marcus 1989) – the ephemeral textures, colours and sounds - of culture.  

Greil Marcus’s evocative title, Lipstick Traces, has been summoned with intentionality 



< Brabazon, Tara. “It’s the Cake Talking” 
Digest: a Journal of Foodways and Culture 4:1 (2015): n. pag.> © American Folklore Society 2015

in this article.  Instead of asking E.H. Carr’s old question “What is History?” (1961), 
it is time to rephrase this enquiry in a way that captures the role of digitization 
in forgetting and remembering, while also acknowledging the insights of mobility 
studies (Urry 2007) and popular memory studies.   Greil Marcus captured the 
tone of this new enigmatic trajectory for history and for historians:

What is history, anyway?  Is history simply a matter of events that 
leave behind those things that can be weighed and measured: new 
institutions, new rulers, new winners, new losers, or is history also a 
matter of those things that seem to leave nothing behind, nothing but 
the mystery of spectral connections between people long separated by 
place and time. If the language they are speaking, the impulse they are 
voicing, has its own language, might it not tell a very different story 
from the one we’ve been hearing all our lives? (Marcus 1989: 6)

Recipe memoirs are an ideal space, place and genre to track and trace these “spectral 
connections” between people who may never have met, or who do not share the 
present.  Marcus has described chronology as “the way history is cheapened and 
restricted” (1995:5).  Every moment that passes sees the destruction of alternative views, 
interpretations and source material. The notion that historians make a past built on factual 
evidence that is a mirror of the time from which it emerges is delusional at best, and 
politically blind at worst. The disappearances of history, the source material that does not 
survive through time, results in a profound narrowing of the past realities that are possible 
to access.  Recipes – particularly in an era of digitization and applications – may be shared, 
but the diversity and localism of family memories through food is rarely captured.  Old 
cookbooks are discarded.  Houses are sold.  Families fragment.  Ingredients transform.

The recipe memoir prioritizes epistemological discussions about the nature of 
history and its relationship with folklore. The impact of women’s history and 
social history has changed the way historical methods are constituted.   The 
hierarchy of historical research has allowed the main sources of evidence to 
remain parliamentary papers, newspapers, journals of political organizations 
and diaries. Similarly, the research strategies through which these conventional 
sources are being accessed display little knowingness of contested subjectivities, 
multiple readerships or the complexity of text/context relationship.   

Greil Marcus showed the impact of dismissing this type of evidence, 
particularly for the marginalized and dispossessed:



< Brabazon, Tara. “It’s the Cake Talking” 
Digest: a Journal of Foodways and Culture 4:1 (2015): n. pag.> © American Folklore Society 2015

There are people who act and speak but whose gestures and words 
do not translate out of their moments – and this exclusion, the 
sweep of the broom of this dustbin, is a movement that in its way 
is far more violent than any toppling of statues (1995:17-18).

To blandly place faith in the written document over the popular cultural trace is to 
perpetuate an inequality and oppression that is wide in its magnitude and dense in its 
consequences. Women, as much as indigenous and black communities, gays and lesbians, 
the working class and youth, have been sliced from time, space and historical evidence 
(Spivak 1988; hooks 1989).  To construct a history of the ephemeral – the shadows cast 
by “authoritative” source material - requires a range of interpretative techniques that 
are beyond the parameters of both history and cultural studies, but requires a nuanced 
dialogue between the two.  Through changing the genre, mode and modality, a new type 
of interpretation can emerge. The recipe memoir is radically contextual and profoundly 
interdisciplinary.  At its most basic, a recipe memoir requires an understanding of social 
history, oral history, family history, feminist theory, men’s studies, food studies, popular 
memory studies and – increasingly – internet studies.  But complex theorizations of 
globalization, industrialization, post-fordism, urbanity and sub/urbanity are also necessary.

These characteristics of the recipe memoir are emerging, even though the dissemination 
on and offline is diverse.  A recipe, often shared between the generations, is the key 
element.  Ingredients are listed and discussed.  Methods of preparation and serving are 
offered (Melissa’s Recipe Memoir 2014).  From this simple list of instructions, more complex 
meanings are revealed, accessing the social, cultural, sociological and sensory meanings 
encircling food.  Most significantly, they capture the memory – often a nostalgic memory 
– of a family and time that has passed.   Frequently, recipes provide a code to interpret 
the (social) semiotic system (Kress 2010) of a household, a marriage, children and a family.   
Community and family, popular culture and popular memory, dialogue and transform.

This article opens out the recipe memoir, demonstrating its potential in capturing 
diverse and often unwritten histories in new ways.  At its core is a recipe memoir 
from my family:  chocolate goo.  The narrative of this recipe is clear.  The history and 
historiography that punctuate this chronology are more complex.  The original recipe has 
been lost.  Digitization has enabled the survival of the original through pixels rather than 
pages.  Through an oral history interview – carried by a podcast  – the context around 
this recipe has been discovered, revealed, published and distributed (Brabazon 2014).

Where is the Goo?



< Brabazon, Tara. “It’s the Cake Talking” 
Digest: a Journal of Foodways and Culture 4:1 (2015): n. pag.> © American Folklore Society 2015

 Tara Brabazon: What does it taste like?

 Kevin Brabazon: Just like chocolate goo (Brabazon 2014).

The facts in this case seem clear.  In 1963, my brother Stephen Brabazon, at nine years 
of age, was taught how to swim by a neighbour.  Mrs. Smart, along with my parents 
and brother, lived in Yokine, a rapidly expanding Perth suburb geared for families.  To 
this day, the best known features of Yokine are its shopping centre and a golf club.  
Therefore, from this conventional – and indeed emerging – suburban life of Australia, a 
recipe was shared.  It was not passed from my grandparents, but through a neighbour.  

Therefore, this recipe memoir commences in suburban Perth.  The burgeoning 
suburbs have been “a problem” for urban planners and creative industries 
practitioners in Australia, but they are a conduit for a recipe memoir.  This 
undervalued genre is sourced from an undervalued location.  For example, 
Charles Landry was brought in by Form, the Perth-based not-for-profit 
organization, for a two year consultancy to provide “expert” commentary about 
the city’s future.  He presented a distinctive cultural mapping of the city:

Last weekend I criss-crossed over 350 kilometres of Perth from the 
Eastern suburbs to the Western in search of a speck of urbanity.  I do 
not denigrate the delights of suburbia, but Perth has 98% of it.  The 
suburban washes over metro Perth like an endless patina as the swathes 
of asphalt covered to get there dull the senses.  How about 80% suburbia 
and 20% of the truly urban to start with?  You see a touch in Subiaco, 
East Perth, Fremantle and Mount Lawley.  But where else? (2007)

Charles Landry moved from east to west looking for urbanity.  The suburbs he valued are 
affluent, older and gentrified.  Yokine is not listed.  The repercussion of such analytical 
attacks is that it perpetuates classism and inequality and demonizes the suburbs.  Over 
the last decade, the poorest of citizens have moved to the extremities of cities.  The 
affluent have clustered in the suburbs within a twenty minute car trip to the CBD.  The 
affluent and educated affirm the value of urbanity, while the majority of the population 
occupies the middle and outer suburbs.  Bernard Salt stated that “the problem I have 
is that city planning, and more often Australian culture, appears to be determined by 
those whose lives are based in the inner city, and not by the silent majority of average 
Australians who live in the suburban heartland.  Perhaps it’s time to listen to what the 
latter have to say about the kind of lifestyle they want to lead in suburbia” (2008:28).  The 



< Brabazon, Tara. “It’s the Cake Talking” 
Digest: a Journal of Foodways and Culture 4:1 (2015): n. pag.> © American Folklore Society 2015

texts that emerge from the suburbs – often also coded as feminine, popular cultural and 
ephemeral – are similarly discredited.  The recipe memoir is trapped in this discourse.

The suburbs frame family memories of food.  In the case of chocolate goo, the mode of 
transmission was my brother, who was so impressed by the “cake” that he transcribed 
the recipe to pass to his mother.  Here is a scanned copy of the original (See Figure 1).

 

Figure 1 - Chocolate Goo recipe, written by Stephen Brabazon, scanned by Kevin Brabazon

This recipe is now 51 years old.  This document captures a popular mode of “running 
writing” in the 1960s.  This “authenticity” feeds into Miller and Deutsch statement that 
“Evaluating primary sources is generally a matter of asking a number of questions.  The 
first question to ask is, is it genuine?  Is the document or artifact authentic?” (2009:85).  
In this case, with a digitized artifact, such a question is important.  Yet this scan has 
perpetuated browning and ageing paper, stains and also unidentified and recognized 
pencil marks logging information that is unclear in both original and purpose.  It holds 
an important role in the family for many reasons.  Firstly, Stephen, as a nine year 
old, enjoyed eating this cake.   Doris, Stephen’s mother, was having trouble finding 
food that he enjoyed.  As Doris stated, “He wouldn’t eat.  I was struggling to make 



< Brabazon, Tara. “It’s the Cake Talking” 
Digest: a Journal of Foodways and Culture 4:1 (2015): n. pag.> © American Folklore Society 2015

him eat” (Brabazon 2014).  She reported that he “came home and told me he’d got a 
recipe” (Brabazon 2014).  This movement of a recipe was remembered because it only 
happened once.  The idea that he would enjoy a food so much that he would copy it 
and pass it to his mother was rare.  This story also dipped into a history of childhood 
and food that is rarely discussed or textualized.  Often, the focus is on school food, 
empowered through institutionalization (Robert and Weaver-Hightower 2011).

 

 Figure 2 Chocolate Goo (Photograph by Kevin Brabazon)

These stories are often lost, unless an act of historical reclamation takes place.  Often new 
evidence has to be constructed in the present about the past, particularly through oral 
history.  Oral historiography is an inexact process, particularly with older interviewees, 
but beneficial in terms of evidence created and personal connections revealed (Ehlman, 
Ligon and Moriello 2014).  When accessed through media applications such as Skype, 
the mode of information captured, even when the interviewee and interviewer are 
geographically dispersed, is sensory, sensitive, affective and effective.  It can also be 
conflictual and incorrect.  Yet the errors are in themselves important.  Oral historiography 
demonstrates that all histories are histories of the present.  Jeff Miller and Jonathan 
Deutsch were incorrect to state that, “the novice food studies scholar working in a 
historical area needs to remember not to fall into the trap of presentism” (2009: 79).  
There is no method, mode or theory – with the exception of reified empiricism - to deny 
the current context of contemporary writing and interpretations of food, war, fashion 
or genocide.  Historians are managing the imperfect reference materials that have 



< Brabazon, Tara. “It’s the Cake Talking” 
Digest: a Journal of Foodways and Culture 4:1 (2015): n. pag.> © American Folklore Society 2015

survived into the present.  Most recipes, practices and behaviors are lost to written, 
let alone archived, records and can only be reclaimed imperfectly through men and 
women retelling their pasts and their family stories through the frame of the present.  
A fine example of this process is Michal Bosworth’s oral history, Emma (Ciccotosto and 
Bosworth 1990).  In this case, the life story of Emma Ciccotosto is punctuated by food, 
cooking and recipes.  She is not conveying “reality” to Michal Bosworth, but offering a 
subtle and moving refrain while retelling her life.  To pretend that such a past of food and 
family exists in a vacuum untroubled by the present is naïve empiricism.  All texts that 
survive are read through the present.  History is not “about” facts, but interpretation.  
The strength of my oral history podcast with my parents – although flawed in both 
technological and methodological terms – is that an array of early food behaviors in 
Western Australia were revealed, particularly encircling rural life during the depression.

While Stephen Brabazon was the conduit for sharing the recipe through a written 
document, and the context around it was gained through oral history interviews 
with his parents, the chocolate goo would have remained unmade if it was too 
complex or time consuming.  Both Doris and Kevin Brabazon were in full-time work 
in 1963.  Doris completed all the cooking, but her time was torn between household 
duties, family responsibilities and paid employment.  Jean-Louis Flandrin described 
this change as “over the past two centuries, women have had less time for these 
traditional responsibilities” (1999:436).  The notion of “traditional responsibilities” 
is indeed a traditional rather than a feminist ideology.  But the key point raised 
through the oral history with Kevin Brabazon was a recognition of the shifts in the 
behaviour of his mother (from the 1930s) and wife (from 1950).  His mother’s days 
were dominated by cooking.  His wife had to manage multiple responsibilities and a 
lack of time available for food preparation.  She was assisted through the management 
of this complex daily timetable by emerging domestic technology (Sheridan 2002).

The early 1960s was a pivot for many of these changes.  Yokine as a suburb was 
growing.  Further, 1963 was a special year, one that Kevin described as “the year of 
the Beatles” (Brabazon 2014).  Therefore, multiple popular cultural memory-triggers 
encircled this recipe.  But its simplicity is important because it connotes the changing 
priorities of femininity and shifts in the pattern of family life.  When prompted in 
a podcast, Doris could list the ingredients and methods without hesitation.   At the 
conclusion of her retelling of the recipe, Doris used the phrase “end of story” (Brabazon 
2014).  What she meant by this statement is that the cooking process was quick, simple 
and effective.  But the simplicity of this recipe is also the start of a different story.



< Brabazon, Tara. “It’s the Cake Talking” 
Digest: a Journal of Foodways and Culture 4:1 (2015): n. pag.> © American Folklore Society 2015

Making the story

Ingredients and preparation methods are not the end of a recipe memoir.  Food travels.  
Meanings change.  Also, naming protocols are significant.  The “goo” signifies that this 
foodstuff is not a cake, fudge or biscuit.  It has a texture similar to flapjacks, with coconut, 
rather than oats, providing the texture.  The ingredients are basic:  self-raising flour, 
cocoa, coconut, sugar, butter, eggs and vanilla essence.  These ingredients of baking have 
– outside of structural periods of scarcity like depression and wars – a wide and diverse 
availability. Most have a colonial origin (Nutzenadel and Trentmann 2008) and reached 
familiarity and entry into popular culture through baking cultures of the twentieth century.

Chocolate goo carries forward the histories of both chocolate and cake.  As Sarah Moss 
and Alexander Badenoch argued, “chocolate is complicated” (2009:7).  Theobroma 
cacao grows naturally within 20 degrees of the equator and below 300 metres in altitude 
(Moss and Badenoch 2009).  Therefore the nations that consume the most chocolate do 
not grow it.  Chocolate entered Europe through Spain, but in the 18th century it was 
consumed as a breakfast drink (Moss and Badenoch 2009: 41-42).  In 1828, chocolate 
transformed with the Van Houten press, selling machines to Cadbury in 1860, Fry 
and Sons in 1866 and Hershey in 1893.  The challenge with chocolate – in grasping 
both its history and present ideologies - is well revealed by Moss and Badenoch:

That ambiguity, or rather series of ambiguities, offers a good summation of 
many of the current places of chocolate in our lives and indeed throughout 
much of its history.  It remains a puzzling mixture between familiar and 
exotic, global and local, guilty pleasure and overlooked injustice (2009:119).

The question is what happens when chocolate is put into a cake.  The complexity 
intensifies.  The history of the cake is similarly convoluted.  As Nicola Humble argued, 
“Cakes are very strange things, producing a range of emotional responses far out of 
keeping with their culinary significance.  They are simultaneously utterly unnecessary and 
absolutely crucial” (2010:8).  Cake through its history has overlaying relationships with 
bread, biscuits, muffins and puddings.  Gingerbread, pancakes and oatcakes demonstrate 
the variations in the definitions of cake.  Teacakes are bread.  Tea Breads are cakes.  
The separation emerged in the 18th and 19th century, when yeasts were used in bread 
and cakes were raised through eggs, particularly beaten egg whites.  The chocolate goo 
recipe has a single beaten egg and no yeast.  It is part of a history of post-war baking 
which Humble revealed is when, “baking went down-market, becoming the province 
of popular women’s magazines and cookery pamphlets, which continued to place great 



< Brabazon, Tara. “It’s the Cake Talking” 
Digest: a Journal of Foodways and Culture 4:1 (2015): n. pag.> © American Folklore Society 2015

emphasis on the baking of cakes and biscuits long after more upmarket publications had 
ceased to do so” (2010: 6). The language is dismissive and pejorative.  When women and 
magazines popularized baking, the ‘upmarket’ chefs moved to more complex preparatory 
rituals.  But food has changed.  Baking has been revived.  Programs such as Ace of Cakes 
make cake construction edgy, risky, skillful and masculine.  Such a revival/reclamation 
shows that Doris Brabazon’s flippant “end of story” comment, which conveyed the 
ease at which the chocolate goo could be made, is not a strength within a particular 
gastronomic discourse.  Similarly Pinterest captures, and disseminates, pictures of 
perfectly formed baked delights.  Therefore social media has increased the performativity 
and mastery of baking.  It is removed from a domestic, every day, suburban practice.

Much has changed in the ideology of baking since 1930 (Tye 2010).  Indeed, when remaking 
this recipe, the ingredients display the marks of transforming food practices in the twenty 
first century: organic (Lyon 2006) and ecological. The eggs I used to remake the recipe 
were not laid by caged birds, but free range. Indeed, a QR code on the base of the package 
allows consumers to view live footage of satisfied and mobile chickens.  These eggs are 
then branded as “ecoeggs.”  For ten eggs, (not even a dozen), the retail price is A$6.89.

 

Figure 3 Ecoeggs (Photograph by Tara Brabazon)

Of all the ingredients in this recipe, the production and consumption of chicken and eggs 
have witnessed the greatest change (Ellis 2007).  Self-raising flour is seemingly straight 
forward.  However it now features two mitigating adjectives:  “unbleached” and “healthy.”  
It is also “vitamin enriched.”  For one kilogram, the supermarket price is A$3.28.



< Brabazon, Tara. “It’s the Cake Talking” 
Digest: a Journal of Foodways and Culture 4:1 (2015): n. pag.> © American Folklore Society 2015

Figure 4 The Healthy Baker (Photographed by Tara Brabazon)

Sugar is “low GI cane sugar.”  This sugar is “better for you.”  It is also not white.  White 
food, particularly sugar, activates a specific signifying system.  As Warren Belasco stated, 

Whiteness meant blandness.  The two main seasonings of white 
middle-class culture were white salt and sugar, with white 
saccharin making gains along with the other white powders that 
went into plastic foods and their wrappers (1989:49). 

The critique of this ideology emerged from the counterculture.  Brownness 
in rice, bread and sugar critiqued whiteness.  Class, food and culture became 
more complex.  Yet from the 1970s through to the present, science – or pseudo-
science – affirms low glycemic indices carried through the countercultural 
ideology of brownness.  The price for 750 grams of LoGiCane is A$3.57.

  
 
 
 
 
 
 



< Brabazon, Tara. “It’s the Cake Talking” 
Digest: a Journal of Foodways and Culture 4:1 (2015): n. pag.> © American Folklore Society 2015

 

Figure 5 Low GI (Photographed by Tara Brabazon)

Coconut is “fine” and “desiccated.”  The iconography of the coconuts are green 
even though the desiccation is white. For 250 grams, the cost is A$2.57.

 

Figure 6 Fine (Photographed by Tara Brabazon)

The cocoa powder is Dutch, with an array of languages and consumers featured 
on the reverse of the packaging. The heritage of Van Houten, as the first firm 
to build effective equipment for the manufacture of cocoa, is summoned.  This 
history is costly, with 250 grams requiring A$7.51 from the consumer.



< Brabazon, Tara. “It’s the Cake Talking” 
Digest: a Journal of Foodways and Culture 4:1 (2015): n. pag.> © American Folklore Society 2015

 

Figure 7 Cacao (Photograph by Tara Brabazon)

This is distinct from the other cheaper choice that was available.  Cadbury – as 
a brand (Bradley 2008) – is associated with packaged chocolate sweets and also 
the colour purple, which emerged in the packaging during the 1920s (Chrystal 
2012).  It is cheaper than Van Houten, with 250 grams costing A$5.90. 

  

Figure 8 Cadbury’s nostalgic purple (Photographed by Tara Brabazon)

No other languages are featured on the package.  Instead nineteenth 
century colonial iconography of gentrified ladies and gentlemen 
are the background for a colourized and intense cocoa.



< Brabazon, Tara. “It’s the Cake Talking” 
Digest: a Journal of Foodways and Culture 4:1 (2015): n. pag.> © American Folklore Society 2015

The Vanilla extract is ‘natural’ and, conversely, 
concentrated.  The price for 200ml is A$11.38.

 

Figure 9 ‘Natural’ (Photographed by Tara Brabazon)

Adjectival choice in food packaging walks the line between actuality and aspiration.  
Rachel Laudan offered a corrective to the celebration of the “fresh” and the “natural,” 
believing that these words until very recently were not trusted (2001).  Fresh food 
went bad.  Preserved food survived.  Similarly, butter is unsalted, natural and features 
“no artificial ingredients.”  This “natural” product – for 250 grams – costs A$3.76.

  

Figure 10 Unsalted butter (Photograph by Tara Brabazon)

 



< Brabazon, Tara. “It’s the Cake Talking” 
Digest: a Journal of Foodways and Culture 4:1 (2015): n. pag.> © American Folklore Society 2015

The changes between this recipe transcribed by Stephen Brabazon in 1963 and 
the ingredients prepared by his sister in 2015 capture the transformations to food 
production and consumption.  Choice has increased.  Information about those 
choices on food packaging has increased.  Yet taste is not measurable or verifiable, 
particularly when peppered with memory.  Is the resultant mixture any better 
than that cooked without the mitigating adjectives of low GI, eco and natural?

Figure 11 Mixing Goo (Photograph by Tara Brabazon)

What makes chocolate goo interesting in terms of cooking is that the 
resultant mixture is dry, only moistened and bound by an egg, butter 
and a trace of vanilla.  The texture of the coconut is visible.  

While the goo is simple to make, the deskilling of baking reduces the time and 
expense of making a cake even further.  There was a reason I placed the price 
in Australian dollars of these “authentic” ingredients. While readers may be 
operating in a different currency, these prices enable a direct comparison with 
the cheaper and quicker options available to buy a packaged chocolate cake.

  
 
 
 
 



< Brabazon, Tara. “It’s the Cake Talking” 
Digest: a Journal of Foodways and Culture 4:1 (2015): n. pag.> © American Folklore Society 2015

 

Figure 12 Deskilled cooking (Photograph by Tara Brabazon)

With the addition of one egg to this packet, a cake can be made.  The packet costs 
A$5.36 and is much cheaper than taking the time and effort to make a chocolate 
goo.  Further deskilling emerges through the purchase of a pre-made cake.  This 
situation is what Jean-Louis Flandrin described as “‘ready-to-eat’ industries” (1999: 
436).  These industries emerge from a modern food system where shortages are 
rare.  Variety and choice are common (Beardsworth and Keil 1997).  The sustainability 
of this system remains debatable, particularly with regard to health (Beardsworth 
and Keil 1997).  Felipe Fernandez-Armesto described part of this process as the 
“industrialization of chocolate” (2001: 224).  Convenience is an ideology that masks 
the separation in both time and geography between production and consumption.

 

Figure 13 Pre-made,  pre-bought chocolate cake (Photograph by Tara Brabazon)



< Brabazon, Tara. “It’s the Cake Talking” 
Digest: a Journal of Foodways and Culture 4:1 (2015): n. pag.> © American Folklore Society 2015

This 500 gram cake costs A$5.00.  The plastic container is removed and it can be served.  
This mode of convenience has a context.  The changes to work, families and femininity 
are mapped over the transformations in production, shopping, storage and baking.  

Digital goo

Our generation, like those that went before, must learn 
how to manage the relationship between past and present, 
tradition and change (Flandrin and Massimo 1996: 553).

This analogue history of recipe survival has been enabled through digitization.  It 
was shared between neighbours six years before I was born. The original piece of 
paper has been lost.  The entire cookbook in which the piece of paper was placed 
is lost.  Before it was either misplaced or displaced, I had asked Kevin to scan this 
recipe.  I was in the United Kingdom teaching a first year course in 2008 titled 
Creative Industries.  Evaluating Charles Leadbeater’s Living on Thin Air, I wanted 
to demonstrate the value of ideas rather than products.  Therefore I used the 
chocolate goo recipe to teach this principle.  Here is an extract from the lecture.

The new knowledge economy is not based around the creation of ideas, 

	 but	the	commodification	of	ideas.		

Leadbeater	explains	this	idea	through	the	example	of	the	chocolate	cake.

 We are going to take some time here with the chocolate cake, 

	 	 Because	if	you	get	this	–	the	rest	of	the	course	is	a	piece	of	cake.

Leadbeater made the following statement

Think	of	the	world	as	divided	up	into	chocolate	cakes	and	chocolate-cake	recipes.		A	
chocolate	cake	is	what	economists	call	a	rival	good:	if	I	eat	it	you	cannot.		A	chocolate	
cake is like most products of the industrial economy: cars, houses, computers, personal 
stereos … The chocolate-cake recipe is like many of the products of the knowledge 
economy.	Software,	digital	codes	and	genetic	information	are	all	like	powerful	recipes	
which	control	how	hardware	–	computers	and	bodies	–	work.		We	are	moving	into	
an	economy	where	the	greatest	value	is	in	the	recipes,	rather	than	the	cakes.

So	a	chocolate	cake	can	be	sold	only	once.



< Brabazon, Tara. “It’s the Cake Talking” 
Digest: a Journal of Foodways and Culture 4:1 (2015): n. pag.> © American Folklore Society 2015

	 But	the	recipe	can	be	commodified	and	sold	over	and	over	again.		

Here for example is my mother’s famous recipe for the best chocolate cake in the world

 In the family – we call it ‘chocolate goo’

	 	 It	is	a	combination	of	cake	and	fudge.

	 	 	 It	is	magnificent.

	 I	am	sharing	this	with	all	of	you	today.

  But once we’ve eaten the cake, it is gone

	 	 	 and	you	will	have	no	idea	how	it	is	made.

	 It	is	a	Brabazon	secret.

But if I sold you the recipe for it 

	 that	is	the	real	value	of	the	cake.

So	intellectual	property	rights	and	copyrights	

over fashion designs, lyrics, music, writing and images 

are	where	the	money	can	be	made.		

These	are	issues	of	law,	not	creativity.		

Therefore, even within this early modelling of creative industries, the product – the 
goo – has a singular value.  The recipe has the lasting value.  For students, this was 
a tangible strategy to teach the primary principle of creative industries: the value of 
ideas, not products.  This article demonstrates the movement of ideas more widely than 
can be expressed in a particular model for economic development. Configuring a recipe 
memoir creates a textured history that moves beyond undulations of continuing and 
change, and into popular memory.  Parts of the past jut and transform into our present.

 

Because Kevin was in Western Australia and I was living and working in the south east 
of England, digitization was the only strategy to move this recipe between countries. 
Now this scan, and the podcast about this recipe, is all that remains of this moment of 
food memory.  This recipe memoir also moves from analogue to digital platforms.  From 



< Brabazon, Tara. “It’s the Cake Talking” 
Digest: a Journal of Foodways and Culture 4:1 (2015): n. pag.> © American Folklore Society 2015

these residues, a lipstick trace of the past is assembled.  This personal narrative delves 
into transformations of rurality, urbanity, femininity and work.  Sidney Mintz stated 
that “we need to know more than we do about the history and sociology of our own 
food practices” (2006:3).  Similarly, there is a necessity to understand the relationship 
between food and memory, taste and knowledge.   A recipe memoir allows scholars to, 
as Michael Carolan suggested, enter “into the subjects of food and food politics by way 
of the lived experience” (2011:7).  Such an analysis is even more important with dessert.  
As Michael Krondl revealed, “when you talk about dessert you step away from analyzing 
basic human needs to a conversation about culture” (2011:3).  Chocolate goo is the 
start of this conversation about how Western Australian food moved and moves beyond 
the state, and from analogue to digital platforms.  Whether authentic, eco or healthy, 
a chocolate trace of suburban history is carried in, on and through a recipe memoir.

 



< Brabazon, Tara. “It’s the Cake Talking” 
Digest: a Journal of Foodways and Culture 4:1 (2015): n. pag.> © American Folklore Society 2015

References Cited

AArrouze, Eric. 2014. Child to Chef. http://childtochef.
com/ (accessed on January 10, 2015).

Beardsworth, Alan and Teresa Keil. 1997. Sociology	on	the	Menu:	An	
Invitation	to	the	Study	of	Food	and	Society. London:  Routledge.

Belasco, Warren. 1989. Appetite	for	Change.	How	the	Counterculture	
took	on	the	Food	Industry,	1966-1988. New York:  Pantheon.

Brabazon, Tara. 2005. From	Revolution	to	Revelation. Aldershot:  Ashgate.

Brabazon, Tara. 2014. An Oral History of Western Australian Food with Kevin 
and Doris Brabazon. Tara Brabazon’s podcast. Libsyn. http://traffic.libsyn.
com/tarabrabazon/An_oral_history_of_Western_Australian_food_with_
Doris_and_Kevin_Brabazon.mp3 (accessed on January 10, 2015).

Bradley, John. 2008. Cadbury	Purple	Reign:		The	Story	behind	
Chocolate’s	Best-Loved	Brand. Chichester:  John Wiley.

Bredekamp, Horst. 2003.  A Neglected Tradition?  Art History as Bildwissenschaft. 

Critical	Inquiry 29: 418-428.

Carolan, Michael. 2011. Embodied	Food	Politics. Farnham:  Ashgate. 

Carr, E.H. 1961.  What is history?  London:  Macmillan.

Ciccotoisto, Emma and Bosworth, Michal. 1990. Emma:	A	Translated	Life. Fremantle:  

Fremantle Arts Centre.

Clementi, Federica. 2014. Natalia Ginzburg, Clara Sereni and Lia 
Levi: Jewish Italian Women Recapturing Cities, Families and National 
Memories. European	Journal	of	Women’s	Studies 21.2: 132-147.

Chrystal, Paul. 2012. Cadbury	&	Fry	through	Time. Stroud:  Amberley Publishing. 

Dixon, Jane. 2002. The	Changing	Chicken:		Chooks,	Cooks	
and	Culinary	Culture. Sydney:  UNSW Press. 

Ehlman, Katie, Mary Ligon  and Gabriele Moriello. 2014. The Impact 
of Intergenerational Oral History on Perceived Generativity in Older 



< Brabazon, Tara. “It’s the Cake Talking” 
Digest: a Journal of Foodways and Culture 4:1 (2015): n. pag.> © American Folklore Society 2015

Adults. Journal	of	Intergenerational	Relationships 12.1: 40-53

Ellis, Hattie. 2007. Planet	Chicken:		The	Shameful	Story	of	the	
Bird	on	your	Plate. London:  Hodder and Stoughton. 

Ellsworth, Phoebe. 2010. Eating	in	St.	Helena	-	A	Recipe	Memoir:	
A	Generation’s	Family	Favorites. Napa:  CreateSpace.

Fernandez-Armesto, Felipe. 2001. Food:		A	History. London:  Macmillan.

Flandrin, Jean-Louis and Montanari, Massimo. 1996. Food:		A	Culinary	History	
from	Antiquity	to	the	Present. New York:  Columbia University Press.

Flandrin, Jean-Louis. 1999. Food:		A	Culinary	History	from	Antiquity	
to	the	Present. New York:  Columbia University Press.

Hopler, Jay. 2002. Watching the Detectives. Journal	of	Social	History Winter: 455-466.

Humble, Nicola. 2010. Cake:		A	Global	History. London: Reaktion Books.

Kellehear, Allan. 1993. The	Unobtrusive	Researcher:		A	
Guide	to	Methods. Sydney: Allen & Unwin.

Kneafsey, Moya, Rosie Cox, Lewis Holloway, Elizabeth Dowler, 
Laura Venn and Helena Tuomainen. 2008. Reconnecting	Consumers,	
Producers	and	Food:	Exploring	Alternatives. New York: Berg.

Kress, Gunther. 2010. Multimodality:		A	Social	Semiotic	Approach	
to	Contemporary	Communication. London:  Routledge.

Krondl, Michael. 2011. Sweet	Invention:		A	History	of	
Dessert. Chicago: Chicago Review Press.

Landry, Charles. 2007. City Thinking can Develop the Full Picture 
of Perth.” The	West	Australian.  February 24: 5

Laudan, Rachel. 2001. A Plea for Culinary Modernism: Why We Should 
Love New, Fast Processed Food. Gastronomica February: 36-44.

Leadbeater, Charles. 2000. Living	on	Thin	Air:		The	New	Economy. London:  Penguin. 

Lyon, Kristen. 2006. Environmental Values and Food Choices:  Views from 
Australian Organic Food Consumers. Journal	of	Australian	Studies 87: 155-166.



< Brabazon, Tara. “It’s the Cake Talking” 
Digest: a Journal of Foodways and Culture 4:1 (2015): n. pag.> © American Folklore Society 2015

Marcus, Griel. 1989. Lipstick Traces. London: Secker and Warburg. 

---. 1995. The Dustbin of History. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.

Melissa’s Recipe Memoir. 2014. http://melissasrecipmemoir.
blogspot.com.au/ (accessed on January 10, 2015).

Memoir.com. 2014. Recipe memoirs. http://writeyourmemoir.com/
tag/recipe-memoirs/ (accessed on January 10, 2015).

Miller, Jeff and Jonathan Deutsch. 2009. Food	Studies:	An	
Introduction	to	Research	Methods. New York:  Berg. 

Mintz, Sidney. 2006. Food at Moderate Speeds. In Fast	Food	/	Slow	Food:		The	Cultural	
Economy	of	the	Global	Food	System, ed. Richard Wilk, 2-12.  Lanham:  Altamira Press.

Moss, Sarah and Alexander Badenoch. 2009. Chocolate:	
A	Global	History. London:  Reaktion. 

Nutzenadel, Alexander and Frank Trentmann. 2008. Introduction:  Mapping Food and 
Globalization. In Food	and	Globalization:	Consumption,	Markets	and	Politics	in	the	
Modern	World, eds. Alexander Nutzenadel and Frank Trentmann, 1-20.  Berg: New York.

Robert, Sarah and Marcus Weaver-Hightower. 2011. School	Food	Politics:		The	Complex	
Ecology	of	Hunger	and	Feeding	in	Schools	around	the	World. New York: Peter Lang.

Rousseau, Signe. 2012. Food	Media:	Celebrity	Chefs	and	the	
Politics	of	Everyday	Interference. London:  Berg.

Salt, Bernard. 2009. It’s time for the Burbs to be Heard. The	Australia. August 13: 27-28.

Spivak, Gayatri Chakravorty. 1988. “Can the Subaltern Speak? “In 	Marxism	
and	the	Interpretation	of	Culture,  ed. Cary Nelson and Lawrence 
Grossberg, 271-313.  Urbana: University of Illinois Press.

hooks, bell. 1989. Talking Back. Boston: South End Press.

Tye, Diane. 2010. Baking	as	Biography:	A	Life	Story	in	Recipes. 
Montreal: McGill Queens University Press.



< Brabazon, Tara. “It’s the Cake Talking” 
Digest: a Journal of Foodways and Culture 4:1 (2015): n. pag.> © American Folklore Society 2015

Urry, John. 2007. Mobilities. Cambridge: Polity.

Yokine. 2014. City of Stirling. http://www.stirling.wa.gov.au/About-the-city/Suburbs/Pages/
Yokine.aspx  (accessed on January 11, 2015). 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 



< Brabazon, Tara. “It’s the Cake Talking” 
Digest: a Journal of Foodways and Culture 4:1 (2015): n. pag.> © American Folklore Society 2015

Notes

1 A key genre of the website Memoir.com are recipe memoirs.  Please 
refer to http://writeyourmemoir.com/tag/recipe-memoirs/

2 For a discussion of how popular memory studies intervene in theorizations 
of history, particularly when attended by Cultural Studies, see my 
monograph T. Brabazon, From Revolution to Revelation (2005).

3 Importantly though, hierarchies of “evidence” still exist, even in social history. 
Jay Hopler, when researching the literature of contractual murder, tells of her 
relationship with pulp fiction: “the stories themselves were shallow and formulaic; 
the characters were cardboard cut-outs that meandered from one almost-sexual 
encounter to another and, no matter what the plot was or where the story was set, 
someone inevitably ended up unconscious in an alley behind some strip bar or juke 
joint …  The Mammoth Book of Pulp Fiction confirmed what I had always suspected – 
pulp fiction was worthless” (2002:460). She later realized that by moving away from 
text-based models of literary criticism and granting the audience of these books 
a context and space through Cultural Studies methods, the genre gained meaning 
in a particular time and place. Hopler’s article is an outstanding “journey piece,” 
capturing how even the most liberal of social historians were able to discount 
“evidence” because a history degree provides few skills in audience analysis. 

4 Even when utilizing photographic and filmic sources, a notion of cultural 
value is deployed in a way that excludes other ways of reading visual 
culture. For example, please refer to Horst Bredekamp (2003).  This 
research, while appearing to incorporate a wide range of visual culture, 
offers singular readings of “art,” wherever it may be found.

5 Managing nostalgia in recipe memoirs is important.  When summoning a recipe 
a particular version of family, home, femininity and masculinity can follow.  
Moya Kneafsey, Rosie Cox, Lewis Holloway, Elizabeth Dowler, Laura Venn and 
Helena Tuomainen warned that, “Nostalgia is a powerful emotion, which can be 
tapped into successfully by marketers seeking to capitalize on our capacity for 
idealizing the past,” from “Contextualizing ‘alternative’ food relationships,” in 
Reconnecting Consumers, Producers and Food: Exploring Alternatives (2008:310).  



< Brabazon, Tara. “It’s the Cake Talking” 
Digest: a Journal of Foodways and Culture 4:1 (2015): n. pag.> © American Folklore Society 2015

6 Podcasts are an under-discussed element of food media.  While blogging 
and – to a lesser extent – Twitter are discussed in the literature, the 
relationship between sonic media and food, and podcasting and food, are 
rarely mentioned.  For example, please refer to Signe Rousseau’s Food 
Media:Celebrity Chefs and the Politics of Everyday Interference (2012).


