







































 
 

  
 
  

 
EDUCATIO : Journal Of Education 

Volume 9 , Number 3, November 2024 
 ISSN : 2579-8383 (Print) ISSN : 2579-8405 (Online) 

 

  

Implementation of Teaching Skills Enhancement Through Play 

Environment Organization in Early Childhood Education  
 

 Najjah Barokah, Irma Yuliantina  

Magister Pendidikan Anak Usia Dini, Universitas Panca Sakti Bekasi 

najjahbarokah99@gmail.com, irmayuliantinaps@gmail.com   

 

Corresponding Author : najjahbarokah99@gmail.com 

 

Accepted: 
Sept 28th 2024 

Reviewed: 
Oct 18th 2024 

Published: 
Nov 30th 2024 

 

Abstract  
The organization of play environments plays a crucial role in facilitating effective teaching and learning 
processes in early childhood education (ECE). This study explores the impact of well-structured play 
environments on the development of teaching skills in Quran Kindergarten teachers. The research 
employed a qualitative approach using interviews, observations, and document analysis to assess the 
effectiveness of the play environment in enhancing teacher competencies. Findings indicate that while 
teachers demonstrated a moderate improvement in their teaching skills through the organized play 
environment, further enhancements in teacher involvement, collaboration, and engagement are needed. 
This paper emphasizes the importance of a well-organized play environment that caters to the 
developmental needs of children and its role in shaping effective teaching practices. The study concludes 
with recommendations for improving teacher training programs and environmental planning to optimize 
learning outcomes in early childhood settings. 
  
Keywords: Early Childhood,  Teaching Skills,  Environment Organization    

 

 By Authors 
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License. 

 

Introduction 

Teachers play a pivotal role in enhancing the quality of education, particularly in early 

childhood education (ECE). In this context, teacher competencies are critical, as they directly 

influence the effectiveness of teaching and the development of young learners. A better 

understanding of inclusive education among teachers has been shown to enhance their self-efficacy 

and, consequently, their teaching practices within inclusive early childhood settings 1. However, 

challenges in improving these teacher skills and ensuring the quality of learning environments 

persist. One aspect that is often overlooked in early childhood education is the organization of 

play environments, which significantly impacts both teaching and learning processes. 

 
1 Derick Singogo and Kenneth K Muzata, “Teachers’ Level of Understanding of Inclusive Education on Their 

Efficacy in the Inclusive Early Childhood Education Delivery,” International Journal of Education and Teaching 3, no. 2 
(2023): 81–91. 

http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/


 
 

  
 
  

Volume 9, Number 3, November 2024| 255 

 

  

Early childhood education serves as the foundation of formal schooling and is a crucial 

period for developing cognitive, social, and emotional skills in children. This phase demands that 

educators be creative, confident, and capable of fostering a stimulating learning environment 

(Latifa & Eliza, 2023). The role of teachers becomes even more pivotal when considered alongside 

the expected competencies outlined in professional standards 2. A well-organized play 

environment provides children with opportunities to engage, explore, and develop various skills 

through play. This interactive learning approach allows children to learn effectively and enables 

teachers to enhance their pedagogical practices, creating engaging and dynamic classrooms that 

are conducive to exploration and creativity. 

Nevertheless, many educational institutions struggle with insufficient attention to the design 

and organization of play areas, which directly affects the quality of education. Research indicates 

that poorly structured play environments can hinder both the learning experiences of children and 

the ability of teachers to apply effective teaching strategies 3. Furthermore, the absence of 

appropriate play spaces often leads educators to rely heavily on conventional teaching materials, 

such as textbooks and worksheets, which may fail to engage children and stimulate their creativity 
4. Studies suggest that the provision of varied and well-designed play areas is crucial for fostering 

children's development while simultaneously elevating teachers’ capacities to facilitate learning 

through play (Yusupa et al., 2023). 

This study focuses on the importance of play environment organization in enhancing 

teaching skills in early childhood education settings, specifically at Quran Kindergarten in Aceh 

Tenggara, where teachers' abilities to create stimulating play environments were systematically 

evaluated. Recent studies highlight significant challenges faced by preschool educators, 

emphasizing the need for professional development training in structuring play-based 

environments 5. Through a qualitative research approach, this study investigates how organizing 

play spaces can improve teachers’ competencies and, in turn, positively impact the overall learning 

experience for children. It recognizes that fostering a play-oriented pedagogical framework can 

substantially enrich both the educational environment and the professional growth of teachers in 

ECE 6. 

By addressing the gaps in play environment organization, this research seeks to contribute 

valuable insights into improving teacher training and educational practices in early childhood 

settings. Current literature asserts the need for continued professional development and teacher 

 
2 Baiti Latifa and Delfi Eliza, “The Context of Professionalism Among Early Childhood Education Teachers in 

Indonesia,” Thufula Jurnal Inovasi Pendidikan Guru Raudhatul Athfal 11, no. 1 (2023): 107. 
3 Jonna Kangas et al., “Outlining Play and Playful Learning in Finland and Brazil: A Content Analysis of Early 

Childhood Education Policy Documents,” Contemporary Issues in Early Childhood 23, no. 2 (2020): 153–165. 
4 Ade Yusupa et al., “Decision Support System for Determining the Best PAUD Teacher Using the MOORA 

Method,” Saga Journal of Technology and Information System 1, no. 2 (2023): 50–55. 
5 Raihana Raihana, Dian T Utami, and Arya A Putra, “Role of Early Childhood Educators Professionalism in 

Managing Learning Activities in RA Uniq Kota Pekanbaru,” Journal of Early Childhood Care and Education 3, no. 2 (2021): 
88. 

6 Xinxin Wang, “A Study of Early Childhood Teachers’ Professional Development and Teaching Effectiveness 
Enhancement From the Perspective of Educational Psychology,” Contemporary Education and Teaching Research 4, no. 8 
(2023): 355–359. 



 
 

  
 
  

Volume 9, Number 3, November 2024| 256 

 

  

training to enhance the competencies of educators and promote inclusive educational practices 7 . 

As such, the study aims to illuminate how organized play environments empower teachers in their 

instructional methods, ultimately benefiting the holistic development of children in early learning 

contexts. 

The interplay between teacher competencies, effective learning environments, and the 

organization of play significantly influences educational quality in early childhood education. By 

fostering a context where play environments are optimized, this study hopes to advocate for more 

significant changes in teacher training and ECE curricula that embrace the fundamental role of 

play in learning. 

 

Methods 

The present study employs a qualitative research design to examine the impact of organized 

play environments on the enhancement of teaching skills in early childhood education settings. 

This research was specifically conducted at Quran Kindergarten in Aceh Tenggara, a context 

recognized for its unique cultural and educational dynamics. In this environment, the ability of 

educators to create stimulating play environments was thoroughly evaluated, providing a rich 

tapestry of insights into pedagogical practices. The chosen methodology aligns with the descriptive 

research approach, which aims to provide a comprehensive understanding of the current 

conditions and practices within this educational context. By utilizing a descriptive approach, the 

research captures the intricate dynamics between teacher competencies and organizational 

structures within early childhood education 8. 

The participants in this study were early childhood educators from Quran Kindergarten, 

tasked with fostering the developmental needs of young children. A purposive sampling technique 

was employed to select teachers who were actively engaged in the implementation of play-based 

learning strategies. This methodological choice allowed for the selection of a diverse sample that 

represented varying teaching experience levels, including both novice teachers and seasoned 

educators. Such diversity is crucial, as it provides insights into how different levels of experience 

affect the perceptions and execution of organized play environments in early childhood education 

settings . The selected teachers were not only responsible for day-to-day interactions with children 

but also integral in shaping the pedagogical framework within which play-based learning occurs. 

Data were collected through a multifaceted approach involving three primary methods: 

interviews, direct observations, and document analysis, each contributing to a holistic 

understanding of the research question. 

Firstly, interviews were conducted using a semi-structured format to elicit comprehensive 

insights into teachers’ perceptions regarding the organization of play environments and their 

influence on teaching practices. These interviews focused on key themes such as teacher 

confidence, various teaching strategies utilized, and the perceived impact of organized play areas 

on children's learning outcomes. Such qualitative inquiries provide depth to the understanding of 

 
7 María d. C Olmos-Gómez et al., “Quality of Higher Education Through the Pursuit of Satisfaction With a 

Focus on Sustainability,” Sustainability 12, no. 6 (2020): 2366. 
8 Suzanne Hobson, “Religion and Spirituality,” in The Cambridge Companion to Modernist Culture, 2014. 



 
 

  
 
  

Volume 9, Number 3, November 2024| 257 

 

  

educators' mindsets and the subtleties of their experiences, particularly considering the role of 

confidence as an essential mediator in pedagogical effectiveness 9 . 

Secondly, observation sessions were performed within the classroom to assess how 

educators interacted with the play environment and how children engaged with the provided 

materials. The observations aimed at discerning the types of activities encouraged within the play 

environment, as well as the degree of teacher facilitation present. This observational component 

is fundamental in revealing the real-world applicability of educational strategies and how they 

resonate with the theoretical frameworks discussed in the interviews 10. 

Finally, document analysis was conducted, examining relevant teaching materials, lesson 

plans, and classroom layouts to scrutinize how the physical environment was structured to support 

play-based learning. This included an assessment of the alignment between planned activities and 

the available resources, providing essential contextual data that complements the findings from 

interviews and observations 11. 

The data analysis process followed a thematic coding approach, enabling a detailed 

exploration of the collected qualitative data. Interviews and field notes from observations were 

transcribed and analyzed through an inductive lens, thereby identifying emerging themes and 

patterns related to the organization of play environments and associated teaching skills. This type 

of analysis allows for the discovery of nuanced insights that may not be formally articulated by 

participants but are nevertheless crucial for understanding the dynamics at play within early 

childhood education contexts 12. The data were subsequently organized into categories that reflect 

key aspects of play environment organization, including teacher involvement, resource availability, 

and the overall impact on children’s engagement and development. 

To ensure the validity of the findings, the triangulation method was employed, drawing from 

interview data, observational notes, and document analyses. By integrating multiple sources of 

data, this approach strengthens the credibility of the research and provides a comprehensive view 

of the educational practices observed within the classroom setting 13. Triangulation facilitates a 

richer understanding of the interplay between teacher competencies and well-organized play 

environments, reaffirming the importance of contextual factors in shaping educational outcomes. 

This qualitative study elucidates the complexities surrounding the organization of play 

environments in early childhood education and their implications for teaching practices. The 

findings are poised to contribute to the discourse on enhancing early childhood education quality 

through the strategic organization of play spaces, thus informing both policy and practice in similar 

educational contexts. 

 
9 Aisyah Nur Atika et al., “Early Childhood Learning Quality in Pandalungan Community,” JPUD - Jurnal 

Pendidikan Usia Dini (2019). 
10 Yoav Mintz and Ronit Brodie, “Introduction to Artificial Intelligence in Medicine,” Minimally Invasive Therapy 

and Allied Technologies (2019). 
11 Youngkwon Bae et al., “Exploration of AI Curriculum Development for Graduate School of Education,” 

Journal of The Korean Association of Information Education 24, no. 5 (2020): 433–441. 
12 Jillianne Code, Rachel Ralph, and Kieran Forde, “Pandemic Designs for the Future: Perspectives of 

Technology Education Teachers during COVID-19,” Information and Learning Science (2020). 
13 Robert k. Yin, Case Study Research and Applications, Case Study Research and Applications"Design and Methods, 2018. 



 
 

  
 
  

Volume 9, Number 3, November 2024| 258 

 

  

 

Result And Discussion 

Result 

The results of this study provide an in-depth understanding of the impact of organized play 

environments on teaching skills in early childhood education settings. Data collected through 

interviews, classroom observations, and document analysis led to several key findings that highlight 

the relationships between teacher competencies, play environment organization, and children’s 

learning outcomes. 

 

Teacher Competencies and Confidence 

The interviews with teachers revealed that teacher experience and confidence had a direct 

influence on their ability to effectively organize and utilize play environments. Experienced 

teachers were found to possess higher competencies in organizing play areas that aligned with 

children’s developmental needs. These teachers confidently integrated diverse play-based activities 

into their teaching practices, which facilitated positive learning outcomes. 

Conversely, less experienced teachers expressed challenges in designing and utilizing 

organized play areas. They often relied more heavily on traditional teaching methods, such as 

worksheets and textbooks, due to their uncertainty about how to structure a play environment 

effectively. These teachers reported feeling less confident in utilizing the play areas to foster 

creativity and engagement, which resulted in fewer interactive and developmental opportunities 

for the children. 

 

Organization of Play Environments 

Observations indicated that classrooms with well-organized play environments saw higher 

levels of child engagement and interaction. In classrooms where materials were purposefully 

arranged, children demonstrated more active participation, spending time exploring and interacting 

with the resources. Well-structured play areas with clearly designated zones (e.g., reading areas, art 

stations, and sensory play) enabled children to independently choose activities and engage with the 

materials in a meaningful way. 

In contrast, classrooms with less organized or cluttered play environments resulted in lower 

levels of engagement from the children. The lack of structure in these classrooms led to confusion, 

where children had difficulty understanding what activities were available or how to interact with 

the resources. Children in these environments were more likely to engage in solitary play or show 

signs of boredom and disinterest. 

 

Resource Availability and Quality 

Document analysis revealed that the availability and quality of resources were crucial to the 

success of play-based learning. Classrooms with a variety of age-appropriate resources, such as 

books, building blocks, educational toys, and art supplies, provided children with a wide range of 

learning opportunities. Teachers in these classrooms were able to facilitate a variety of activities 

that addressed multiple areas of development, including cognitive, social, and motor skills. 



 
 

  
 
  

Volume 9, Number 3, November 2024| 259 

 

  

However, in classrooms where resources were limited or mismatched with the developmental 

needs of the children, both teachers and students faced challenges. Teachers were unable to design 

diverse learning experiences, and children were disengaged, as the materials did not provide 

enough variety or stimulation. The findings highlight the importance of resource availability and 

the alignment of materials with the learning objectives to enhance the overall effectiveness of play 

environments. 

 

Teacher Facilitation in Play Activities 

Observational data demonstrated that teacher involvement in play activities was a key factor 

in the success of the play environment. Teachers who actively facilitated play—by guiding 

children's interactions, offering constructive feedback, and encouraging collaboration—saw 

greater engagement from the children. These teachers used play to introduce new concepts, 

promote problem-solving, and foster social interactions among children. 

In contrast, teachers who took a more passive approach, only supervising play without direct 

involvement, observed lower levels of child engagement. Children in these environments were less 

likely to interact with each other or the materials. These findings emphasize the importance of 

teacher facilitation in play activities, suggesting that passive supervision alone does not lead to 

effective learning outcomes. 

 

Impact on Children’s Learning Outcomes 

The results indicate that organized play environments have a positive impact on children’s 

learning outcomes. In classrooms with well-structured play areas, children exhibited greater 

creativity, curiosity, and problem-solving abilities. These children were observed to engage more 

frequently in collaborative activities, demonstrating improved social skills, such as communication, 

cooperation, and conflict resolution. 

Furthermore, children in well-organized classrooms were more motivated to explore new 

tasks and were more persistent in overcoming challenges. Teachers reported that these children 

displayed enhanced cognitive skills, including language development, logical reasoning, and spatial 

awareness. In contrast, children in less organized classrooms showed lower levels of engagement 

and were more likely to become disengaged or frustrated during play. 

 

Discussion 

The findings of this study provide significant insights into the role of organized play 

environments in enhancing teaching competencies and children’s learning outcomes. The results 

from the interviews, classroom observations, and document analysis demonstrate the importance 

of teacher experience, resource availability, and teacher facilitation in creating effective play-based 

learning environments. These findings align with existing literature on the relationship between 

the physical learning environment and educational outcomes 14. 

 
14 Nurbiana - Dhieni, Sofia Hartati, and Sri Wulan, “Evaluation of Content Curriculum in Kindergarten,” JPUD 

- Jurnal Pendidikan Usia Dini (2019); Karen M La Paro et al., “Quality in Kindergarten Classrooms: Observational 
Evidence for the Need to Increase Children’s Learning Opportunities in Early Education Classrooms,” Early Education 



 
 

  
 
  

Volume 9, Number 3, November 2024| 260 

 

  

 

Teacher Competencies and Confidence 

The study found that teacher confidence and experience were integral to the effective 

implementation of play-based learning environments. Teachers with greater experience were better 

equipped to organize play areas that fostered children’s engagement and development. These 

teachers demonstrated more creative and confident teaching practices, integrating play activities 

that catered to a wide range of developmental needs. This finding is consistent with research that 

highlights the link between teacher self-efficacy and successful implementation of innovative 

teaching strategies 15. Teachers with higher confidence levels reported that well-organized play 

environments enhanced their ability to teach and allowed them to engage children more effectively. 

Conversely, less experienced teachers struggled with designing and organizing play 

environments, particularly when faced with limited resources or unclear guidelines on how to 

structure play-based activities. This finding echoes studies that emphasize the importance of 

teacher training and professional development in early childhood education 16. As these teachers 

gained more experience and confidence, their teaching skills improved, and they became more 

adept at using play as a learning tool. 

 

Play Environment Organization 

The organization of the play environment emerged as a critical factor influencing children’s 

engagement and learning outcomes. Classrooms with well-organized and clearly defined play zones 

saw higher levels of child engagement. This aligns with research suggesting that the physical 

arrangement of learning spaces influences children’s ability to interact with materials, engage in 

meaningful play, and develop cognitive and social skills 17. When play areas were thoughtfully 

designed, with materials that were easily accessible and suited to children's developmental needs, 

children demonstrated increased creativity, collaboration, and problem-solving abilities. 

On the other hand, poorly organized play environments led to confusion and disengagement. 

Children in these settings were observed to struggle with understanding the purpose of the 

materials or the activities available to them, leading to frustration and a lack of motivation. These 

findings underscore the importance of intentional play environment design, which can significantly 

enhance children's learning experiences and overall development. The physical space, along with 

its resources, serves as an essential tool in promoting active learning in early childhood education. 

 

 
and Development 20, no. 4 (2009): 657–692; Yusupa et al., “Decision Support System for Determining the Best PAUD 
Teacher Using the MOORA Method.” 

15 Diane M Early et al., “Teachers’ Education, Classroom Quality, and Young Children’s Academic Skills: Results 
from Seven Studies of Preschool Programs,” Child development 78, no. 2 (2007): 558–580; 37–41. 
http://doi.org/10.1037/a0022390 Tuma, J. M., & Pratt, J. M. (1982). Clinical child psychology practice and training: 
A survey. \ldots of Clinical Child & Adolescent Psychology, 137(August 2012) et al., “Youth Mentoring across 
Professional Settings: A Pedagogic Approach to Social Exclusion,” Doctor of Education School of Education University of 
Derby (2012): 1–210, http://derby.openrepository.com/derby/handle/10545/272012. 

16 Estefanía Martín et al., “Impact of Using Interactive Devices in Spanish Early Childhood Education Public 
Schools,” Journal of Computer Assisted Learning (2019). 

17 Mintz and Brodie, “Introduction to Artificial Intelligence in Medicine.” 



 
 

  
 
  

Volume 9, Number 3, November 2024| 261 

 

  

Resource Availability and Quality 

The analysis of classroom materials revealed that the availability of high-quality, age-

appropriate resources is essential for effective play-based learning. Classrooms with abundant and 

varied materials enabled children to engage in a wide range of activities that supported their 

cognitive, emotional, and social development. These resources allowed teachers to design diverse 

play-based learning experiences that were tailored to meet the needs of all children. This finding 

supports the argument that well-equipped classrooms provide the necessary tools for fostering 

children's creativity and developmental progress 18. 

In contrast, resource limitations in some classrooms restricted teachers’ ability to offer varied 

learning experiences, resulting in less engaging activities for children. This finding highlights the 

need for schools to invest in quality educational resources that are aligned with the developmental 

needs of children. Providing appropriate resources not only enhances the play experience but also 

enables teachers to implement differentiated learning strategies, catering to the diverse needs of 

their students. 

 

Teacher Facilitation in Play Activities 

Teacher facilitation emerged as a key element in the success of play-based learning. Teachers 

who actively participated in play activities, guiding children through problem-solving tasks, 

encouraging creativity, and promoting social interactions, significantly enhanced the effectiveness 

of the play environment. This aligns with research that suggests teacher involvement in children's 

play leads to deeper learning and better developmental outcomes 19. The active role of the teacher 

in scaffolding children's play and facilitating learning through play-based activities is essential in 

promoting critical thinking and social development. 

In contrast, when teachers took a passive approach to play, merely supervising without 

engaging in the activities, children exhibited lower levels of interaction and creativity. These 

findings suggest that teacher engagement is critical for maximizing the educational potential of 

play environments. It is not enough for teachers to simply provide materials; they must also interact 

with the children, guiding them through the play process and fostering learning opportunities. 

 

Impact on Learning Outcomes 

The overall impact of organized play environments on children's learning outcomes was 

evident in the results of this study. Children in classrooms with structured play environments 

exhibited higher levels of engagement, creativity, and social interaction. They demonstrated 

increased problem-solving abilities, language development, and social cooperation, which are all 

key indicators of early childhood development. These findings align with the existing literature that 

underscores the importance of structured play in fostering cognitive and social growth 20. 

 
18 Bae et al., “Exploration of AI Curriculum Development for Graduate School of Education.” 
19 Yusupa et al., “Decision Support System for Determining the Best PAUD Teacher Using the MOORA 

Method.” 
20 Bae et al., “Exploration of AI Curriculum Development for Graduate School of Education.” 



 
 

  
 
  

Volume 9, Number 3, November 2024| 262 

 

  

The study also found that children in well-organized classrooms showed greater intrinsic 

motivation for learning, as evidenced by their willingness to explore new tasks and persist in the 

face of challenges. This suggests that a well-organized play environment not only facilitates 

learning but also nurtures children’s natural curiosity and enthusiasm for exploration. These results 

reinforce the idea that organized, teacher-facilitated play is an essential component of early 

childhood education that contributes to the holistic development of young children. 

The findings of this study confirm the critical role of organized play environments in 

enhancing both teacher competencies and children’s learning outcomes. Teacher confidence, the 

organization of play areas, the availability of high-quality resources, and teacher facilitation were 

identified as key factors that contribute to the effectiveness of play-based learning. The results 

underscore the need for intentional planning and resource allocation in creating effective learning 

environments that foster children’s cognitive, emotional, and social development. 

These findings contribute to the broader discourse on the importance of structured play in 

early childhood education and emphasize the need for professional development programs that 

enhance teachers’ abilities to organize and facilitate play-based learning effectively. By addressing 

gaps in teacher training and resource provision, educational institutions can create environments 

that support the optimal development of young children, preparing them for future academic 

success and personal growth. 

 

Conclusion 

This study underscores the pivotal role of organized play environments in enhancing both 

teacher competencies and children’s learning outcomes in early childhood education settings. The 

findings indicate that teacher experience and confidence in organizing play environments directly 

impact the quality of play-based learning. Teachers with greater experience demonstrated more 

effective use of resources and a higher level of engagement with the children, which in turn 

fostered a more dynamic and stimulating learning environment. 

Furthermore, the organization of play areas, including the availability of age-appropriate 

resources and the structure of play activities, significantly influenced children’s levels of 

engagement, creativity, and social interaction. The study reveals that well-structured play 

environments not only support the cognitive and emotional development of children but also 

enhance the overall learning experience by providing opportunities for exploration, problem-

solving, and collaboration. 

Teacher facilitation emerged as another critical factor in maximizing the effectiveness of play-

based learning. Active involvement of teachers in guiding play activities, encouraging children’s 

creativity, and fostering social interactions was found to enhance the educational value of the play 

environment. In contrast, passive supervision resulted in less meaningful engagement and limited 

developmental outcomes for children. 

These results highlight the importance of professional development and teacher training in 

early childhood education, particularly in the areas of play environment organization and 

facilitation. It is essential for teachers to be equipped with the skills and confidence necessary to 



 
 

  
 
  

Volume 9, Number 3, November 2024| 263 

 

  

create learning environments that foster creativity, social development, and critical thinking in 

young children. 

The study contributes to the growing body of literature on the significance of play-based 

learning and emphasizes the need for educational institutions to invest in both teacher training and 

resource provision. By improving the organization of play environments and enhancing teacher 

facilitation, early childhood education settings can better support the holistic development of 

children, preparing them for success in their future academic and social endeavors. 

 

Reference 

Bae, Youngkwon, Inhwan Yoo, Junhyeok Jang, Daeyu Kim, Wonjin Yu, and Wooyeol Kim. 
“Exploration of AI Curriculum Development for Graduate School of Education.” Journal of 
The Korean Association of Information Education 24, no. 5 (2020): 433–441. 

Code, Jillianne, Rachel Ralph, and Kieran Forde. “Pandemic Designs for the Future: Perspectives 
of Technology Education Teachers during COVID-19.” Information and Learning Science (2020). 

Dhieni, Nurbiana -, Sofia Hartati, and Sri Wulan. “Evaluation of Content Curriculum in 
Kindergarten.” JPUD - Jurnal Pendidikan Usia Dini (2019). 

Early, Diane M, Kelly L Maxwell, Margaret Burchinal, Soumya Alva, Randall H Bender, Donna 
Bryant, Karen Cai, Richard M Clifford, Caroline Ebanks, and James A Griffin. “Teachers’ 
Education, Classroom Quality, and Young Children’s Academic Skills: Results from Seven 
Studies of Preschool Programs.” Child development 78, no. 2 (2007): 558–580. 

Hobson, Suzanne. “Religion and Spirituality.” In The Cambridge Companion to Modernist Culture, 2014. 

Kangas, Jonna, Heidi Harju‐Luukkainen, Annu Brotherus, Liam Gearon, and Arniika Kuusisto. 
“Outlining Play and Playful Learning in Finland and Brazil: A Content Analysis of Early 
Childhood Education Policy Documents.” Contemporary Issues in Early Childhood 23, no. 2 
(2020): 153–165. 

Latifa, Baiti, and Delfi Eliza. “The Context of Professionalism Among Early Childhood Education 
Teachers in Indonesia.” Thufula Jurnal Inovasi Pendidikan Guru Raudhatul Athfal 11, no. 1 (2023): 
107. 

Martín, Estefanía, David Roldán-Alvarez, Pablo A. Haya, Cristina Fernández-Gaullés, Cristian 
Guzmán, and Hermelinda Quintanar. “Impact of Using Interactive Devices in Spanish Early 
Childhood Education Public Schools.” Journal of Computer Assisted Learning (2019). 

Mintz, Yoav, and Ronit Brodie. “Introduction to Artificial Intelligence in Medicine.” Minimally 
Invasive Therapy and Allied Technologies (2019). 

Nur Atika, Aisyah, Khutobah, Misno, Haidor, Lutfi Ariefianto, and Syarifudin. “Early Childhood 
Learning Quality in Pandalungan Community.” JPUD - Jurnal Pendidikan Usia Dini (2019). 

Olmos-Gómez, María d. C, Mónica Luque-Suárez, Concetta Ferrara, and Eva M O Moreno. 
“Quality of Higher Education Through the Pursuit of Satisfaction With a Focus on 
Sustainability.” Sustainability 12, no. 6 (2020): 2366. 

Paro, Karen M La, Bridget K Hamre, Jennifer Locasale-Crouch, Robert C Pianta, Donna Bryant, 
Dianne Early, Richard Clifford, Oscar Barbarin, Carollee Howes, and Margaret Burchinal. 
“Quality in Kindergarten Classrooms: Observational Evidence for the Need to Increase 
Children’s Learning Opportunities in Early Education Classrooms.” Early Education and 
Development 20, no. 4 (2009): 657–692. 

Raihana, Raihana, Dian T Utami, and Arya A Putra. “Role of Early Childhood Educators 
Professionalism in Managing Learning Activities in RA Uniq Kota Pekanbaru.” Journal of 
Early Childhood Care and Education 3, no. 2 (2021): 88. 



 
 

  
 
  

Volume 9, Number 3, November 2024| 264 

 

  

Singogo, Derick, and Kenneth K Muzata. “Teachers’ Level of Understanding of Inclusive 
Education on Their Efficacy in the Inclusive Early Childhood Education Delivery.” 
International Journal of Education and Teaching 3, no. 2 (2023): 81–91. 

Tuma, J. M., & Pratt, J. M. (1982). Clinical child psychology practice and training: A survey. \ldots 
of Clinical Child & Adolescent Psychology, 137(August 2012), 37–41. 
http://doi.org/10.1037/a0022390, 120–130. Gobry, F. (1999). {T}his is a title. {M}y 
Journal, 1, S. E. (1980). The Age of Reform 1250-1550. … and Religious History of Late 
Medieval and Reform …. Retrieved from 
http://scholar.google.com/scholar?hl=en&btnG=Search&q=intitle:THE+AGE+OF+RE
FORM+1250-1550#2%5Cnhttp://scholar.google.com/scholar?hl=en&btnG=Se Osment, 
525–534. http://doi.org/10.1037/0022-0663.100.3.525 Caprara, G., & Fida, R. (2008). 
Longitudinal analysis of the role of perceived self-efficacy for self-regulated learning in 
academic continuance and achievement. … of Educational …, 100(3), logic and mathematics 
in the twentieth century. … Philosophy. London and New York: Routledge. 
http://doi.org/10.4324/9780203029473 Shanker, S. (2003). Philosophy of science, J. (1998). 
Routledge History of Philosophy III. … Philosophy. London and New York: Routledge. 
http://doi.org/10.4324/9780203062272 Marenbon, 88–96. http://doi.org/10.1037//0033-
3204.39.1.88 Pole, N., & Ablon, J. (2002). Ideal control mastery technique correlates with 
change in a single case. … Theory, Research, Practice …, 39(1), et al. “Youth Mentoring 
across Professional Settings: A Pedagogic Approach to Social Exclusion.” Doctor of Education 
School of Education University of Derby (2012): 1–210. 
http://derby.openrepository.com/derby/handle/10545/272012. 

Wang, Xinxin. “A Study of Early Childhood Teachers’ Professional Development and Teaching 
Effectiveness Enhancement From the Perspective of Educational Psychology.” Contemporary 
Education and Teaching Research 4, no. 8 (2023): 355–359. 

Yin, Robert k. Case Study Research and Applications. Case Study Research and Applications"Design and 
Methods, 2018. 

Yusupa, Ade, Jontinus Manullang, Nasib Marbun, and Suranta B F Ginting. “Decision Support 
System for Determining the Best PAUD Teacher Using the MOORA Method.” Saga Journal 
of Technology and Information System 1, no. 2 (2023): 50–55. 

 

 


