Microsoft Word - ETASR_V12_N3_pp8542-8547


Engineering, Technology & Applied Science Research Vol. 12, No. 3, 2022, 8542-8547 8542 
 

www.etasr.com Navarro: Development of an Alumni Databank: The Case of Nueva Ecija University of Science and … 

 

Development of an Alumni Databank: The Case of 

Nueva Ecija University of Science and Technology 
 

Emmanuel Carlos Navarro 

College of Information and Communications Technology 
Nueva Ecija University of Science and Technology 

Cabanatuan, Philippines 

emmanuel.navarro@neust.edu.ph
 

Received: 6 January 2022 | Revised: 19 February 2022 | Accepted: 27 February 2022 

 

Abstract- The Nueva Ecija University of Science and Technology 
is the third oldest University in Nueva Ecija province. As the year 
progresses, the University keeps producing thousands of 

graduates during each academic year. An average of 4,737 

individuals graduated from different programs during the past 

five years. The University is obligated by the Commission on 

Higher Education to collect up-to-date data and information 

through the CHECK system. Unfortunately, the office of alumni 

affairs and placement, which is in charge to collect and manage 
the graduates' information, does not have an automated alumni 

database system. This paper presents the development of an 

alumni databank. The online database record management 

system for alumni considerably benefits the University's Alumni 

Affairs and Placement Office, particularly in tracing its 

graduates and managing graduates' profile information. It can 

manage alumni profiles, notify graduates of job advertisements, 

and is capable of generating statistical reports with data 

analytics. Security measures were also employed to protect 
against any potential system breach and unauthorized use. 

Keywords-alumni databank; electronic collection; analytics; 

higher education institution 

I. INTRODUCTION  

The Nueva Ecija University of Science and Technology 
(NEUST) is the third oldest school in the province of Nueva 
Ecija. Its academic mandate started in June 1908 in San Isidro, 
Nueva Ecija. Through the years, its name changed as more 
course offerings were introduced along with the increase of 
enrollees. It started providing vocational expertise as Wright 
Institute (1908-1928). In 1929, it was named Nueva Ecija 
Trade School (1929-1953) offering secondary education, then 
Central Luzon School of Arts and Trades (1953-1964), in 1964, 
it was promulgated as Central Luzon Polytechnic College 
(1964-1998) specializing in engineering courses, and in 1998 it 
started to be named Nueva Ecija University of Science and 
Technology [1]. The University produces thousands of 
graduates each academic year. A yearly average of 4,737 
individuals graduated from different programs in the past five 
years [2]. The University's graduates are deployed in various 
industries, promoting the University and allowing it to attract 
more students and maintain its competitiveness.  

The Commission on Higher Education (CHED) mandates 
that Higher Education Institutions, either private, local, or state 
Universities, to submit data/information [3, 4]. With this 
development, the University regularly collects and manages 
records of its graduates. Data collection is a fundamental step 
to take in each research study [5]. According to authors in [6], 
databases for alumni are vital to every learning institution. 
They emphasize the school's needs in collecting data and 
information to communicate, verify, archive, and research the 
alumni. Many studies show that most colleges and universities, 
either private or public, must have a management tool to 
protect, maintain, and record their data. Hence, Graduate 
Tracer Studies (GTS) are commonly becoming a regular 
practice worldwide [7]. Doing this data/information collection 
helps the University monitor the graduates' placement, their 
specific skill sets, and the industry qualifications requirements. 

NEUST regularly conducts tracer studies to follow-up on 
its graduates. The CHED per se has a Knowledge Management 
Division which is composed of three sections: Information 
Management, Knowledge Resource, and System Integration. 
Each section's primary purpose is to formulate, coordinate, and 
implement policies and guidelines related to higher education 
data collection, processing, and data banking through the 
Higher Education Management Information System (HEMIS) 
in all CHED offices and higher education institutions through 
the integration of CHED Electronic Collection and Knowledge 
System (CHECKS) [8]. Authors in [9], conducted a tracer 
study of Bachelor of Science in Information Technology 
(BSIT) graduates. They extracted BSIT graduates' data with 
personal information from the registrar's office of the campus 
using Google Forms [10]. After getting the list, the link 
https://tinyurl.com/bsit–tracer16–18 was disseminated to the 
CICT NEUSTSIC closed group. The authors in [11] undertook 
a survey with the help of some students and other faculty 
members of the College of Business Administration and 
Accountancy of their Academic Institution. Various means of 
data gathering were utilized, such as email and facebook 
messaging. The same instruments were used in the tracer study 
conducted in NEUST Atate Campus with a total of 118 
graduates, 65 of which were BSITs (27 graduates of the year 
2018 and 38 graduates of the year 2019), 24 were BSBAs 
(Batch 2018), and 29 were BSEntres (Batch 2019) [12]. 

Corresponding author: Emmanuel C. Navarro



Engineering, Technology & Applied Science Research Vol. 12, No. 3, 2022, 8542-8547 8543 
 

www.etasr.com Navarro: Development of an Alumni Databank: The Case of Nueva Ecija University of Science and … 

 

In NEUST, the Alumni Affairs and Placement Office does 
not maintain an automated alumni database system to keep 
relevant data of the University graduates. Instead, they still 
collect, process and file alumni data manually, which is 
tedious. The difficulty of Alumni Affairs and Placement Office 
starts when the graduates receive their diploma and other vital 
records from the University. Obtaining data from them 
becomes more challenging due to the lack of communication, 
changes of personal information, and lack of pertinent linkage 
to them. Thus, it takes some time to generate timely and 
reliable reports. To address these concerns, the development of 
an NEUST-SIC alumni databank is timely and relevant to the 
needs of the University. The developed Alumni Databank 
intends to establish a network between the graduates and the 
Alumni Affairs and Placement Office. The provision of 
analytics allows the information to be processed quickly, 
enables clarity of communication, and focuses on further 
analysis [13]. The printable reports are inclusive of graduates' 
total number and employability and are filtered according to 
gender and course. The Alumni Databank is deemed necessary 
to know and assess the graduates' present status [14] and for the 
University to have an alumni record repository.  

II. OBJECTIVES 

The greatest assets of any academic institution are the 
product of its labor, the alumni. For this reason, the objective of 
this study is to develop the NUEST-San Isidro Campus Alumni 
Databank, with the function to collect graduates' information 
that will help track their updated information as professionals 
and present a way to connect them to the University after 
graduation. Furthermore, this study aims to design an online 
database record of alumni, that is able to notify graduates for 
job advertisements, post future University activities, and 
capable of report generation with data analytics. It also adheres 
to demand technology that provides various services for storage 
and data availability from any place and at any time [15]. 

III. METHODOLOGY  

This study used development research, a powerful method 
in the development of instructional technology. According to 
[16], the systematic review of designing, developing, and 
evaluating instructional programs, processes, and products 
must meet internal consistency and effectiveness criteria. The 
Technology Acceptance Model (TAM) was applied. Authors in 
[17] define the TAM as an information technology framework 
for understanding users' adoption and use of emerging 
technologies, particularly in the workplace environment. If a 
user perceives a technology as easy to use and perceives it as 
useful to his needs, chances are he will accept it [18]. 

 

 
Fig. 1.  TAM. 

TAM is an information system theory used to look at 
technology at work, which deals with user acceptability 
behavior. According to [19], the perceived usefulness defines 
the degree to which a person believes that the system's use will 
improve his performance. However, perceived ease of use 
refers to the degree to which a person believes that the system's 
service will be effortless. Authors in [20] stated that Perceived 
Usefulness (PU) and Perceived Ease of Use (PEOU) impact a 
person's state of mind toward utilizing a specific tool. The 
TAM models' primary goal is to determine the dominant use to 
accept or not to accept new systems, technology, instruments, 
or devices. It intends to utilize by controlling the individual's 
personality toward using a specific means. 

IV. ALUMNI DATABANK DESIGN AND LIMITATIONS DURING 
THE DEVELOPMENT PROCESS 

The NEUST San Isidro Campus Alumni Databank was 
developed for only the NEUST San Isidro Campus. The data 
were gathered through online interviews conducted with the 
campus alumni coordinator. Further references were taken 
from the mandates of the CHED relevant to the graduate tracer 
studies, which were taken online. System Development Life 
Cycle (SDLC) was used in the development process. 
According to [21], a conceptual model includes policies and 
procedures for developing or altering systems throughout their 
cycle. Authors in [22] determined that SDLC is a mechanism 
used to produce deliverable systems and a vital instrument that 
aids in effective and efficient information systems. Authors in 
[23] explained that the lifecycle of an information system 
passes through various phases, starting with its conception 
down to the stage when it is no longer available for use. Figure 
2 depicts the typical development phases followed 
systematically with tasks such as planning, analysis, design, 
implementation, and maintenance required to accomplish new 
or modified information systems. 

 

 
Fig. 2.  Information system life cycle. 

The development starts with the planning phase where the 
researcher understands the problem and identifies and lays 
down possible threats and project constraints that may hinder 
the integration. In addition to that, a Gantt chart was created to 
monitor the progress of the project. The context diagram, 
drawn in Figure 3, defines and identifies the extreme 
boundaries and course of information of the entire system.      

 



Engineering, Technology & Applied Science Research Vol. 12, No. 3, 2022, 8542-8547 8544 
 

www.etasr.com Navarro: Development of an Alumni Databank: The Case of Nueva Ecija University of Science and … 

 

 
Fig. 3.  Context diagram. 

 
Fig. 4.  Level 1 representation of the DFD processes. 

The analysis phase included the detailed examination of 
collected data and user needs. In this way, processes can be 
tailored to fit any desired process [24]. This study dissected the 
collected data in multiple analyses to solve issues and come up 
with accurate and appropriate findings. Authors in [25] stated 
that one of the prerequisites for each computer system is the 
assurance of data integrity. By this process, the system will 
make sure that no changes are made in the database while in 
operation. This study follows three comprehensive stages of 
data analysis motivated by [26] which breaks down that data 
analysis covers everything from reading the source method of 
data collection to the creation and visualization of the extracted 
data. The evaluation was first. This stage helps determine and 
characterize the information of collected data to provide an 
outcome to achieve a goal. Secondly, the cleaning stages 
classified the information belonging to its entities. This 
eliminates duplications, irrelevant data, white spaces, and not 
valuable records. The output of this process is data integrity. 
Lastly, the summarizing stage assures that the collected data 
are reliable and rich in information, which is the basis for 
formulating data-driven decisions.  

The design phase included designing the application, the 
database, and the user interface. This stage shows the way the 
system was conceptualized and ensures that the requirements 
have been met. Several software engineering diagrams were 

made to recognize users' roles and the workflow processes of 
the developed system. Figure 4 illustrates the technical drawing 
showing how the developed Alumni Databank system worked.   

The implementation phase started with coding and a series 
of tests to evaluate the system’s functionality and usability. 
Lastly, the integration of the developed system into its new 
environment was conducted. Features of the developed system 
are limited only to graduates' online registration, posting of job 
fairs, and NEUST alumni-related activities, and organization 
job hiring. The alumni coordinator of the said campus is the 
one who will maintain and manage the Alumni Databank 
system. The use-case diagram in Figure 5 shows the distinct 
function and role of the user to the developed system. In this 
case, it describes the system's capability and how a particular 
user will utilize it.  

 

 
Fig. 5.  Use-case diagram. 

A. Database Modeling 

The representation of database modeling in information 
systems is a conceptual way to describe the data structure, 
which is required in database management. In this way, the 
data collection will be easy to organize, manage, maintain, 
protect, and provide access to as a computerized database. 
There are a lot of structure diagrams in designing a database. 
One of the most frequently used and applied in this study in 
illustrating the relationships of different entities to each other 
within the system is the Entity Relationship Diagram (ERD) 
(Figure 6). The presented database schema identifies the 
relationships and attributes in each entity, e.g. users related to 
alumni, works, and education belong to the same class. In this 
case, the values recorded to alumni, works, and education are 
also recorded to the users. The values from the users are all 
recorded to the alumni, works, and education. The primary 
purpose of the ERD of the Alumni Databank is to visualize the 
physical database which is helpful in identifying mistakes and 
design flaws that allow necessary adjustments. Data entries 
have to be performed by the end-users who are the alumni and 
the Alumni personnel. 

B. Security 

The developed Alumni Databank incorporates protective 
measures and protocols to protect the information and limit the 



Engineering, Technology & Applied Science Research Vol. 12, No. 3, 2022, 8542-8547 8545 
 

www.etasr.com Navarro: Development of an Alumni Databank: The Case of Nueva Ecija University of Science and … 

 

possibility of data breach. To ensure the integrity and security 
of the system, the Alumni Databank has a user maintenance 
that allows two kinds of accounts that can be used to access the 
system. The "Admin Account," is the alumni coordinator, has 
complete control and responsibility for managing the system, 
and uses all the available functionalities, and the "End-user 
Account" with limited access and designated for the university 
graduates. Authentication features were used as the first line of 
protection. Only users with authorized username and password 
can access it. Also, the system administrator may check all the 
registered users which will serve as a countercheck for bogus 
accounts. 

 

 
Fig. 6.  An example ERD used in the development of the Alumni 

Databank. 

V. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION 

The Alumni Databank system was developed in order to 
help the Alumni Affairs and Placement Office of NEUST to 

collect data and locate the graduate's whereabouts and have 
updated information about them. Figure 7 presents the system’s 
architecture design. An internet connection is required to 
facilitate communication between the alumni and the 
developed Alumni Databank [27]. The front-end of the system 
was developed using HTML5 for the web structures, CSS3 for 
design, and JavaScript for the system's functional behavior. 
JQuery was also used for a more graphical representation of 
tables. Bootstrap 4.1.3, an open-source front-end toolkit, was 
used to make the web application responsive [28] and 
Fontawesome Webfont icons provided the visual icons. Using 
these front-end utilities, the Alumni Databank system was 
developed. Back-end development refers to the server-side of 
an application [29], which means users cannot see how the 
back-end works. However, this code integrates the system 
between its database to the browser. To make this integration 
possible, PHP 7.3.4-2 [30] was used. MariaDB Ver 15.1 
Distrib 10.3.23 was used for defining the database structure 
along with MySQL Workbench and Sublime Text3 for coding. 

 

 
Fig. 7.  Web application architecture of the Alumni Databank. 

Tracking graduate whereabouts is significant for Higher 
Education Institutions (HEIs). Moreso, the integration of 
industry 4.0 in the education system impacts strategic 
leadership [31] and transforms data-driven operations. The 
Alumni Databank is designed to keep the graduate's records of 
NEUST - San Isidro Campus and of the University as a whole. 
Figures 8 and 9 show the reports through a bar chart, the 
graduates per year and per course. The assigned campus alumni 
coordinator will have access to maintain and manage the 
system, while only administrators and coordinators have full 
access to the Alumni Databank. The end-users' privileges 
include creating and updating their profiles and browsing 
posted job advertisements and announcements.  

Figure 10 displays the announcement module wherein the 
administrators and coordinators can manage the creation of job 
advertisements and University-related activity announcements. 
Only the administrator and the system developer can access the 
system database backup, access the graduate's lists and 
information, generate reports, and have the privilege to modify 
the system if there will be any change request. 



Engineering, Technology & Applied Science Research Vol. 12, No. 3, 2022, 8542-8547 8546 
 

www.etasr.com Navarro: Development of an Alumni Databank: The Case of Nueva Ecija University of Science and … 

 

 
Fig. 8.  Graduate reports per year. 

 
Fig. 9.  Graduate reports per course. 

 
Fig. 10.  Job advertisement, University related activity announcement page. 

The developed Alumni Databank establishes a network 
between the graduates and the Alumni Affairs and Placement 
Office. It considerably benefited the Office, particularly in 
tracing its graduates and managing their profiled information. 
With the existing system of graduates tracing, the office staff in 
charge encounters difficulties in merely looking for them via 
social media platforms, not to mention the limited data 

available. Some graduates who are not active in social media or 
whose profile is different from their actual names are not 
tracked at all. Thus, the preparation of needed reports takes a 
lot of time and is prone for being incomplete, and is less 
reliable. This system would make it easier to prepare the 
documentation required by the CHED by establishing a 
standard communication gateway with graduates to collect 
their information after graduation. Compared to the manual 
system, obtaining data from them is no longer tedious since 
graduates themselves may update their personal information 
like contact numbers, address, and pertinent linkage to them 
can be acquired, tasks which were previously difficult to 
perform. The needed reports can easily be generated, printed or 
downloaded in PDF format by authorized system users. Data 
analytics was also integrated for a visual presentation of reports 
which have been more useful as compared to traditional reports 
created with the manual system. 

VI. CONCLUSION 

The repository of alumni record management for NEUST 
San Isidro Campus, was developed with the following 
functionalities: online registration, posting job opportunities 
offered by the University and other job advertisements from 
partner agencies. Reports with analytics were provided 
inclusive of generation of graduates statistics, employability 
and graduates aggregated according to their gender. The 
developed system was able to produce printable reports of 
alumni records with some data analytics. For further 
improvement in the future, the following recommendations are 
hereby given: 

• Integration of the Alumni Databank system to the 
University system for full utilization in the NEUST - San 
Isidro Campus. 

• Considering the said system implementation as a 
benchmark in aligning the inputs and processes of the 
NEUST, the said system can also be utilized in other 
Colleges/Campuses. 

• The University Management of Information System (MIS) 
may integrate the Alumni Databank system to the 
University Portal for deployment.  

• The Alumni Affairs and Placement Office director, the Vice 
President for Academic Affairs, the Vice President for 
Research, Extension and Training office, and all Alumni 
Coordinator per Colleges/Campuses in cooperation of the 
Deans and Directors may provide a set of guidelines 
regarding the system use prior to implementation. 

REFERENCES 

[1] "Historical Background," Nueva Ecija University of Science and 

Technology, Jun. 07, 2020. https://neust.edu.ph/historical-background/ 
(accessed Mar. 29, 2022). 

[2] "2020 Higher Education Facts and Figures," CHED. 

https://ched.gov.ph/2020-higher-education-facts-and-figures/ (accessed 
Mar. 29, 2022). 

[3] "2012 CHED Memorandum Orders," CHED. https://ched.gov.ph/2012-

ched-memorandum-orders/ (accessed Mar. 29, 2022). 

[4] "2014 CHED Memorandum Orders," CHED. https://ched.gov.ph/2014-

ched-memorandum-orders/ (accessed Mar. 29, 2022). 



Engineering, Technology & Applied Science Research Vol. 12, No. 3, 2022, 8542-8547 8547 
 

www.etasr.com Navarro: Development of an Alumni Databank: The Case of Nueva Ecija University of Science and … 

 

[5] "How to Collect Data for Research Project," Sep. 16, 2021. 
https://papersowl.com/blog/how-to-collect-data-for-research (accessed 

Mar. 29, 2022). 

[6] J. Etcuban and D. Durano, "Development of an Alumni Database for a 
University," IAMURE International Journal of Multidisciplinary 

Research, vol. 12, pp. 109–128, Jan. 2015, https://doi.org/10.7718/ 
iamure.v12i1.953. 

[7] E. O. Badiru and M. Wahome, "Conducting Graduate Tracer Studies for 

Quality Assurance in East African Universities: A Focus on Graduate 
Students Voices on Quality Culture," Journal of Education and Practice, 

vol. 7, no. 6, pp. 174–181, 2016. 

[8] "Knowledge Management Division," CHED. https://ched.gov.ph/ 

ched/official-organization-structure/office-planning-research-
knowledge-management-oprkm/knowledge-management-division/ 

(accessed Mar. 29, 2022). 

[9] J. C. Mina, E. J. G. Reyes, and R. F. Salas, "A Tracer Study of Bachelor 
of Science in Information Technology(BSIT) Graduates of Nueva Ecija 

University of Science and Technology (NEUST), San Isidro Campus," 
International Journal of English Literature and Social Sciences, vol. 5, 

no. 4, pp. 1337–1344, 2020. 

[10] "Google Forms: Free Online Form Creator." https://www.google.com/ 
forms/about/ (accessed Mar. 29, 2022). 

[11] R. Calma and M. Clarin, "A Tracer Study of the Bachelor of Science in 

Business Administration (BSBA) Graduates of an Academic Institution 
from 2016 to 2018," May 2020. [Online]. Available: https://www. 

researchgate.net/publication/341342842_A_Tracer_Study_of_the_Bache
lor_of_Science_in_Business_Administration_BSBA_Graduates_of_an_

Academic_Institution_from_2016_to_2018/references. 

[12] R. P. Corpuz, "Tracer Study of Nueva Ecija University of Science and 
Technology Graduates (Atate Campus)," International Journal of 

English Literature and Social Sciences, vol. 5, no. 2, pp. 434–440, 2020. 

[13] "Graphical Analysis | Continuous Improvement Toolkit." https:// 
citoolkit.com/articles/graphical-analysis/ (accessed Mar. 29, 2022). 

[14] B. C. Lunar, "Employment Status of the Graduates of De La Salle Lipa’s 
Certificate in Medical Transcription Program: A Tracer Survey and an 

Assessment," International Journal of Advanced Engineering, 
Management and Science, vol. 2, no. 6, Art. no. 239528, Jun. 2016. 

[15] M. F. Hyder, S. Tooba, and Waseemullah, "Performance Evaluation of 

RSA-based Secure Cloud Storage Protocol using OpenStack," 
Engineering, Technology & Applied Science Research, vol. 11, no. 4, 

pp. 7321–7325, Aug. 2021, https://doi.org/10.48084/etasr.4220. 

[16] R. C. Richey, Developmental Research: The Definition and Scope. 
Washington, DC, USA: ERIC, 1994. 

[17] J. D. Portz et al., "Using the Technology Acceptance Model to Explore 

User Experience, Intent to Use, and Use Behavior of a Patient Portal 
Among Older Adults With Multiple Chronic Conditions: Descriptive 

Qualitative Study," Journal of Medical Internet Research, vol. 21, no. 4, 
Apr. 2019, Art. no. e11604, https://doi.org/10.2196/11604. 

[18] Q. Ma and L. Liu, "The Technology Acceptance Model: A Meta-

Analysis of Empirical Findings," Journal of Organizational and End 
User Computing, vol. 16, no. 1, pp. 59–72, Jan. 2004, https://doi.org/ 

10.4018/joeuc.2004010104. 

[19] F. D. Davis, "Perceived Usefulness, Perceived Ease of Use, and User 
Acceptance of Information Technology," MIS Quarterly, vol. 13, no. 3, 

pp. 319–340, 1989, https://doi.org/10.2307/249008. 

[20] A. L. S. Hoong, L. S. Thi, and M. H. Lin, "Affective Technology 

Acceptance Model: Extending Technology Acceptance Model with 
Positive and Negative Affect," in Knowledge Management Strategies 

and Applications, London, UK: IntechOpen, 2017, pp. 147–165. 

[21] "SDLC Tutorial." https://www.tutorialspoint.com/sdlc/index.htm 
(accessed Mar. 29, 2022). 

[22] F. Yakubu, B. I. Ahmad, O. M. Omowumi, and M. A. Mngohol, 

"Process and Database Modelling of a University Bursary System: A 
Perspective of Cash Office," International Journal of Computer Science 

Issues, vol. 8, no. 4, pp. 555–560, 2011. 

[23] S. Cohen, D. Dori, and U. de Haan, "A Software System Development 
Life Cycle Model for Improved Stakeholders’ Communication and 

Collaboration," International Journal of Computers Communications & 
Control, vol. 5, no. 1, pp. 20–41, Mar. 2010. 

[24] A. Jones, "ISO 12207 Software life cycle processes — fit for purpose?," 

Software Quality Journal, vol. 5, no. 4, pp. 243–253, Dec. 1996, 
https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00209183. 

[25] M. Widera, J. Wrobel, A. Widera, and A. Matonia, "A method of 

ensuring data integrity in a data stream management system," Journal of 
Medical Informatics & Technologies, vol. 8, pp. 141–148, 2004. 

[26] "The Three Stages of Data Analysis: Evaluating Raw Data — 
Methodspace." https://www.methodspace.com/blog/three-stages-data-

analysis-evaluating-raw-data (accessed Mar. 29, 2022). 

[27] M. C. Lam, M. Ayob, J. Y. Lee, N. Abdullah, F. A. Hamzah, and S. S. 
M. Zahir, "Mobile-based Hospital Bed Management with Near Field 

Communication Technology : A Case Study," Engineering, Technology 
& Applied Science Research, vol. 10, no. 3, pp. 5706–5712, Jun. 2020, 

https://doi.org/10.48084/etasr.3527. 

[28] M. Jacob and T. Otto, "Bootstrap V.5.0." https://getbootstrap.com/ 
docs/5.0/getting-started/introduction/ (accessed Mar. 29, 2022). 

[29] "Front End Development vs Back End Development: Where to Start?," 

Course Report. https://www.coursereport.com/blog/front-end-
development-vs-back-end-development-where-to-start (accessed Mar. 

29, 2022). 

[30] "PHP: Hypertext Preprocessor." https://www.php.net/ (accessed Mar. 29, 
2022). 

[31] M. F. Mubarak, F. A. Shaikh, M. Mubarik, K. A. Samo, and S. Mastoi, 

"The impact of digital transformation on business performance: a study 
of Pakistani SMEs," Engineering Technology & Applied Science 

Research, vol. 9, no. 6, pp. 5056–5061, 2019, https://doi.org/10.48084/ 
etasr.3201.