Microsoft Word - ETASR_V13_N2_pp10471-10477 Engineering, Technology & Applied Science Research Vol. 13, No. 2, 2023, 10471-10477 10471 www.etasr.com Zisopol et al.: A Theoretical-Experimental Study on the Influence of FDM Parameters on the … A Theoretical-Experimental Study on the Influence of FDM Parameters on the Dimensions of Cylindrical Spur Gears Made of PLA Dragos Gabriel Zisopol Mechanical Engineering Department, Petroleum-Gas University Ploiesti, Romania zisopol@zisopol.ro (corresponding author) Mihail Minescu Mechanical Engineering Department, Petroleum-Gas University Ploiesti, Romania mminescu@upg-ploiesti.ro Dragos Valentin Iacob Production Department, Marelli Ploiesti Romania, Romania dragoshicb@gmail.com Received: 29 January 2023 | Revised: 12 February 2023 | Accepted: 15 February 2023 ABSTRACT This paper presents the results of a theoretical-experimental study on the influence of FDM parameters (height of the deposited layer at one pass Hs and percentage of filling Pu) on the dimensions of cylindrical spur gears made of PLA (shaft diameter d and bore diameter D). In this context, we designed the 3D model of a cylindrical gear with module m= 1 and z= 60 spur teeth, which we used for FDM 3D printing of 27 PLA parts with different values of coating height deposited at a pitch Hs of 0.10, 0.15, 0.20mm and different values 50, 75, and 100% of filling percentage Pu. The 324 values obtained from measuring the diameters d and D of 27 cylindrical spur gears made of PLA and the calculated values of statistical indicators (arithmetic mean, standard deviation, dispersion) were used to determine the dimensional accuracy of the analyzed parts. The study results show that the percentage of filling has a greater influence than the shaft diameter on the dimensional accuracy of cylindrical spur gears made of PLA. Keywords-3D printing; FDM parameters; experimental test; spur gears I. INTRODUCTION Nowadays, production processes are undergoing transformations in terms of flexibilization according to market requirements, the main objective being to reduce costs in order to strengthen market position and maintain sustainable competitive advantage [12-17]. Additive manufacturing technologies are a viable solution for many industries such as automotive, aerospace, and defense due to advantages in comparison with formative and subtractive manufacturing technologies, e.g. the manufacturing costs are significantly reduced, complex geometries are achieved without special base and fixing elements, simplicity in use, material waste is negligible, use of bio materials, etc. [1, 6, 11]. Fused deposition modeling is one of the most popular manufacturing technologies due to its affordability, the wide range of materials used, and the possibility of customization for printed parts. However, this technology has certain limitations such as run time and surface quality. Depending on the field of use of the manufactured part, the limitations can be adjusted from the process parameters: the height of the layer deposited in one step, the filling percentage, the printing speed, etc. [9, 10]. The materials used for FDM are thermoplastics, the most popular among them being PLA (polylactic acid), ABS (acrylonitrile butadiene styrene), PET (polyethylene terephthalate), Nylon, and PC (polycarbonate) [3]. The study of the influence of 3D printing parameters has attracted the scientific interest. Authors in [1] showed a comparative study about dimensional accuracy from errors of FFF printed spur Engineering, Technology & Applied Science Research Vol. 13, No. 2, 2023, 10471-10477 10472 www.etasr.com Zisopol et al.: A Theoretical-Experimental Study on the Influence of FDM Parameters on the … gears using PLA and Nylon and authors in [11] showed a development of a prediction system for 3D printed part deformation using SLS technology. The novelty of this work consists in the theoretical- experimental determination of the influence of FDM parameters on the dimensions of cylindrical spur gears (shaft diameter d and bore diameter D) made of PLA. The greater influence between the two studied parameters Hs and Pu is found with statistical calculations following the measurements. II. 3D PRINTING OF CYLINDRICAL SPUR GEARS The quality of the parts manufactured additively by thermoplastic extrusion is influenced by the material type and the 3D printer used, [9, 10]. In this context, PLA filament with a diameter of 1.75mm (Verbatim brand) and the Creality CR-X 3D printer with a printing volume of 300×300×400mm and XY positioning accuracy of ±0.10mm were used to manufacture all cylindrical spur gears. Figure 1 shows the steps taken to perform the experimental study on the influence of FDM parameters on the dimensions of cylindrical spur gears Rd made of PLA. Fig. 1. Stages of the experimental study on the influence of FDM parameters on the dimensions of cylindrical spur gears fabricated from PLA. Using the Solidworks 2022 software, the 3D model of a cylindrical spur gear with module m=1 and z=60 was designed using the ToolBox function and was converted from SLD to STL format, [6, 7, 20]. The 3D model was the basis for the 2D drawing shown in Figure 2 of [6]. Using the STL format file, corresponding to the spur gear with spur teeth shown in Figure 2, and the Creality Slicer of the Creality CR-X 3D printer, we inserted the printing parameters shown in Table I and generated the G-Code file [6, 7]. The FDM 3D printing parameters of PLA spur gears (Rd) with module m= 1 and z= 60 spur teeth, shown in Table I, fall into two categories, constant parameters and variable parameters, [5-8]. We transferred the G-Code file to the Creality CR-X printer and fabricated 27 cylindrical gears Rd from PLA with modulus m= 1 and z= 60 spur teeth. Figure 3 shows the cylindrical toothed wheel Rd made of PLA with m= 1 and z= 60 in Creality Slicer, generated by using the height of the deposited layer at one pass Hs=0.10mm, filling percentage Pu= 50%, printing speed Vp=80mm/min, and filling pattern type line oriented at 45° [8]. TABLE I. PARAMETERS OF 3D FDM PRINTING OF Rd SPUR GEARS WITH m=1 AND z=60 Constant parameters Variable parameters Coding of the gear set Material Part orientation X, Y Temperature of the extruder, Te= 210°C Table temperature, Tb= 60°C Printing speed, Vp= 80mm/s Filling pattern - Lines 45° Height of the deposited layer Hs Filling Percentage Pu Rdi PLA (mm) (%) (i = 1… 9) (parts) 0.10 100 Rd1 3 75 Rd2 3 50 Rd3 3 0.15 100 Rd4 3 75 Rd5 3 50 Rd6 3 0.20 100 Rd7 3 75 Rd8 3 50 Rd9 3 The mass of the cylindrical gear with modulus m=1 and spur teeth z=60, shown in Figure 2, is 14g (equivalent to 4.957m of PLA filament) and its running time is 2 hours and 53 minutes. The G-Code file of the cylindrical gear shown in Figure 2 contains 108500 control lines [8]. Fig. 2. Rd PLA cylindrical gear with m=1 and z=60 spur teeth (Hs=0.10 mm, Pu=50%, Vp=80mm/min, 45° oriented line fill pattern) in Creality Slicer. III. DETERMINATION OF THE INFLUENCE OF FDM PARAMETERS ON THE DIMENSIONS OF SPUR GEARS MADE OF PLA A. Working Methodology For the experimental study we used 324 values obtained by measuring with a digital caliper the diameter of the shaft (d=62±0.1mm) and the diameter of the bore (D=20.2±0.1mm) of 27 cylindrical gears made of PLA, with m=1 and z=60, additively manufactured by thermoplastic extrusion (using the parameters in Table I). Each part was measured as shown in Figure 3. The 324 values are used to determine the arithmetic mean (1), standard deviation (2), and dispersion (3), corresponding to each set of cylindrical gears Rdi in PLA with m=1 and z=60 [1, 18, 19]: �̅ � ������...�� (1) Engineering, Technology & Applied Science Research Vol. 13, No. 2, 2023, 10471-10477 10473 www.etasr.com Zisopol et al.: A Theoretical-Experimental Study on the Influence of FDM Parameters on the … � � �∑��� ��̅�� (2) �� � � ∑��� − �̅�� (3) A set of cylindrical gears Rdi made of PLA, with m=1 and z=60, contains 3 parts characterized by the same 3D printing parameters (see Table I). Two sets of measurements were performed for each part, resulting in 12 values - 6 values for shaft diameter d and 6 values for bore diameter D, as shown in Figure 3. Fig. 3. Measuring points of the diameters of cylindrical gears Rd made of PLA with modulus m=1 and spur teeth z=60. B. Results The 324 values resulting from the measurement of the diameters of the 27 cylindrical gears Rd made of PLA, additively manufactured by thermoplastic extrusion, are graphically represented in Figures 4-21. Tables II-XIX show the results obtained from the calculation of statistical indicators arithmetic mean, standard deviation, and dispersion. The variation of the values of the arithmetic means �̅ of the shaft diameter d for each set of Rdi gears (i= 1...9) is shown in Figure 23. The variation of the values of the arithmetic means �̅ of the bore diameter D for each set of gears Rdi (i= 1...9) is shown in Figure 22. Fig. 4. Values of shaft diameter d for gear set Rd1.(Hs = 0.10mm, Pu= 100%). TABLE II. VALUES OF THE STATISTICAL INDICATORS FOR THE SET OF SPUR WHEELS RD1 Variable parameters Mean �� Standard Deviation � Dispersion �� Hs= 0.10mm, Pu=100% mm mm mm 61.95 0.086 0.007 Fig. 5. Values of shaft diameter d for gear set Rd2. (Hs= 0.10mm, Pu= 75%). TABLE III. VALUES OF STATISTICAL INDICATORS FOR THE SET OF SPUR GEARS RD2 Variable Parameters Mean �� Standard Deviation � Dispersion �� Hs= 0.10mm, Pu=75% mm mm mm 61.95 0.093 0.009 Fig. 6. Values of shaft diameter d for gear set Rd3. (Hs= 0.10mm, Pu= 50%). TABLE IV. VALUES OF STATISTICAL INDICATORS FOR THE SET OF SPUR GEARS RD3 Variable parameters Mean �� Standard Deviation � Dispersion �� Hs= 0.10mm, Pu=50% mm mm mm 61.99 0.111 0.012 Fig. 7. Values of shaft diameter d for spur gear set Rd4. (Hs= 0.15mm, Pu= 100%). TABLE V. VALUES OF STATISTICAL INDICATORS FOR THE SET OF SPUR GEARS RD4 Variable parameters Mean �� Standard Deviation � Dispersion �� Hs= 0.15mm, Pu=100% mm mm mm 61.98 0.070 0.005 Engineering, Technology & Applied Science Research Vol. 13, No. 2, 2023, 10471-10477 10474 www.etasr.com Zisopol et al.: A Theoretical-Experimental Study on the Influence of FDM Parameters on the … Fig. 8. Values of shaft diameter d for spur gear set Rd5. (Hs= 0.15mm, Pu= 75%). TABLE VI. VALUES OF STATISTICAL INDICATORS FOR THE SET OF SPUR GEARS RD5 Variable parameters Mean �� Standard Deviation � Dispersion �� Hs= 0.15mm, Pu=75% mm mm mm 62 0.047 0.002 Fig. 9. Values of shaft diameter d for spur gear set Rd6. (Hs= 0.15mm, Pu= 50%). TABLE VII. VALUES OF STATISTICAL INDICATORS FOR THE SET OF SPUR GEARS RD6 Variable parameters Mean �� Standard Deviation � Dispersion �� Hs= 0.15mm, Pu=50% mm mm mm 61.99 0.063 0.004 Fig. 10. Values of shaft diameter d for spur gear set Rd7. (Hs= 0.20mm, Pu= 100%). TABLE VIII. VALUES OF STATISTICAL INDICATORS FOR THE SET OF SPUR GEARS RD7 Variable parameters Mean �� Standard Deviation � Dispersion �� Hs= 0.20mm, Pu=100% mm mm mm 61.96 0.062 0.004 Fig. 11. Values of shaft diameter d for spur gear dințate Rd8. (Hs= 0.20mm, Pu= 75%). TABLE IX. VALUES OF STATISTICAL INDICATORS FOR THE SET OF SPUR GEARS RD8 Variable parameters Mean �� Standard Deviation � Dispersion �� Hs= 0.20mm, Pu=75% mm mm mm 62.02 0.113 0.013 Fig. 12. Values of shaft diameter d for spur gear set Rd9. Hs= 0.20mm, Pu= 50%). TABLE X. VALUES OF STATISTICAL INDICATORS FOR THE SET OF SPUR GEARS RD9 Variable parameters Mean �� Standard Deviation � Dispersion �� Hs= 0.20mm, Pu=50% mm mm mm 61.95 0.061 0.004 Fig. 13. Values of bore diameter D for spur gear set Rd1. (Hs= 0.10mm, Pu= 100%). TABLE XI. VALUES OF STATISTICAL INDICATORS FOR THE SET OF SPUR GEARS RD1 Variable parameters Mean �� Standard Deviation � Dispersion �� Hs= 0.10 mm, Pu=100% mm mm mm 20.29 0.058 0.003 Engineering, Technology & Applied Science Research Vol. 13, No. 2, 2023, 10471-10477 10475 www.etasr.com Zisopol et al.: A Theoretical-Experimental Study on the Influence of FDM Parameters on the … Fig. 14. Values of bore diameter D for spur gear set Rd2. (Hs= 0.10mm, Pu= 75%). TABLE XII. VALUES OF STATISTICAL INDICATORS FOR THE SET OF SPUR GEARS RD2 Variable parameters Mean �� Standard Deviation � Dispersion �� Hs= 0.10mm, Pu=75% mm mm mm 20.32 0.077 0.066 Fig. 15. Values of bore diameter D for spur gear set Rd3. (Hs= 0.10mm, Pu= 50%). TABLE XIII. VALUES OF STATISTICAL INDICATORS FOR THE SET OF SPUR GEARS RD3 Variable parameters Mean �� Standard Deviation � Dispersion �� Hs= 0.10mm, Pu=50% mm mm mm 20.25 0.117 0.014 Fig. 16. Values of bore diameter D for spur gear set Rd4. (Hs= 0.15mm, Pu= 100%). TABLE XIV. VALUES OF STATISTICAL INDICATORS FOR THE SET OF SPUR GEARS RD4 Variable parameters Mean �� Standard Deviation � Dispersion �� Hs= 0.15mm, Pu=100% mm mm mm 20.28 0.091 0.008 Fig. 17. Values of bore diameter D for spur gear set Rd5. (Hs= 0.15mm, Pu= 75%). TABLE XV. VALUES OF STATISTICAL INDICATORS FOR THE SET OF SPUR GEARS RD5 Variable parameters Mean �� Standard Deviation � Dispersion �� Hs= 0.15mm, Pu=75% mm mm mm 20.31 0.088 0.008 Fig. 18. Values of bore diameter D for spur gear Rd6. (Hs= 0.15mm, Pu= 50%). TABLE XVI. VALUES OF STATISTICAL INDICATORS FOR THE SET OF SPUR GEARS RD6 Variable parameters Mean �� Standard Deviation � Dispersion �� Hs= 0.15mm, Pu=50% mm mm mm 20.29 0.068 0.005 Fig. 19. Values of bore diameter D for spur gear set Rd7. (Hs= 0.20mm, Pu= 100%). TABLE XVII. VALUES OF STATISTICAL INDICATORS FOR THE SET OF SPUR GEARS RD7 Variable parameters Mean �� Standard Deviation � Dispersion �� Hs= 0.20mm, Pu=100% mm mm mm 20.07 0.152 0.023 Engineering, Technology & Applied Science Research Vol. 13, No. 2, 2023, 10471-10477 10476 www.etasr.com Zisopol et al.: A Theoretical-Experimental Study on the Influence of FDM Parameters on the … Fig. 20. Values of bore diameter D for spur gear set Rd8. (Hs= 0.20mm, Pu= 75%). TABLE XVIII. VALUES OF STATISTICAL INDICATORS FOR THE SET OF SPUR GEARS RD8 Variable parameters Mean �� Standard Deviation � Dispersion �� Hs= 0.20mm, Pu=75% mm mm mm 20.13 0.120 0.014 Fig. 21. Values of bore diameter D for spur gear set Rd9. (Hs= 0.20mm, Pu= 50%). TABLE XIX. VALUES OF STATISTICAL INDICATORS FOR THE SET OF SPUR GEARS RD9 Variable parameters Mean �� Standard Deviation � Dispersion �� Hs= 0.20mm, Pu=50% mm mm mm 20.13 0.130 0.017 Using the values of the arithmetic means �̅ of the shaft diameter d and of the bore diameter D (see Tables II-XIX) for each set of gears Rdi (i=1...9), the graphs in Figure 22 and 23 were constructed, respectively. Fig. 22. Variation of the arithmetic mean values �̅ of the shaft diameter d for each set of gears Rdi (i=1...9). Fig. 23. Variation of the arithmetic mean values �̅ of the bore diameter for each set of gears Rdi (i= 1...9). C. Disscusion The study was carried out using the 162 values resulting from the measurement with the digital caliper of the shaft diameter d=62±0.1mm (see Figure 3) and the 162 values resulting from the measurement with the same instrument of the bore diameter D= 20.2±0.1 mm (see Figure 3) of the 27 cylindrical spur gears made of PLA, with modulus m= 1 and spur teeth z= 60, additively manufactured by thermoplastic extrusion (using the parameters in Table I), certify the significant influence on their dimensions of the height of the layer deposited at one pass Hs and the percentage of filling Pu. In this context, analyzing the graphs in Figures 4-23 and the result summary in Tables II-XIX the following results are issued: 1) For Shaft Diameter d= 62±0.1mm The best values were obtained by measuring the set of spur gears Rd5 (Hs= 0.15mm, Pu= 75%), the calculated mean being �̅= 62mm and dispersion ��= 0.002 (see Figure 9 and Table VI). The largest deviations were obtained in the measurement of the spur gear set Rd2 (Hs= 0.10mm, Pu= 75%), the calculated mean average being �̅= 61.95mm, and dispersion ��= 0.0087 (see Figure 5 and Table III); 100% of the values obtained in the measurement of the spur gear set Rdi (i= 1...9) are within the tolerance of ±0.10mm, the best values being obtained for 3D printing with the height of the deposited layer at a pitch Hs= 0.15mm (see Figure 22). 2) For Bore Diameter D= 20.2±0.1mm: The best values were obtained in the measurement of the spur gear set Rd3 (Hs= 0.10mm, Pu= 50%), the calculated mean being �̅ = 20.25mm, and dispersion � � = 0.014 (see Figure 15 and Table XIII). The largest deviations were obtained in the measurement of the spur gear set Rd7 (Hs= 0.20mm, Pu = 100%), the calculated average being �̅ = 20.07mm, and dispersion ��= 0.023 (see Figure 19 and Table XVII). Only 66.6% of the values obtained in the measurement of the spur gear set Rdi (i= 1...9) fall within the tolerance of ±0.10mm, very close to the upper and lower limits (see Figure 23). Engineering, Technology & Applied Science Research Vol. 13, No. 2, 2023, 10471-10477 10477 www.etasr.com Zisopol et al.: A Theoretical-Experimental Study on the Influence of FDM Parameters on the … IV. CONCLUSIONS The current paper presents the results of a theoretical- experimental study on the influence of FDM parameters (height of the deposited layer at one pass Hs and percentage of filling Pu) on the dimensions (shaft diameter d and bore diameter D) of cylindrical spur gears made of PLA. Cylindrical spur gears were printed on Creality CR-X 3D printer using PLA filament - Verbatim brand. Regarding the shaft diameter d, all values obtained in the measurement of FDM 3D printed spur gears are within the required tolerance of ±0.10 mm. Regarding the bore diameter D, one third of the measued values were outside the tolerance limits. The difference between the extreme values of the arithmetic mean is 0.25mm. The theoretical-experimental study demonstrates that of the two FDM parameters analyzed, the Pu filling percentage has a greater influence on the dimensional accuracy of spur gears made of PLA. The results of the study are useful for optimizing FDM parameters for additive manufacturing of PLA spur gears by thermoplastic extrusion within specified dimensional tolerances. The study can be extrapolated to other types of materials used in additive manufacturing technologies. REFERENCES [1] I. Buj-Corral and E. E. Zayas-Figueras, "Comparative study about dimensional accuracy and form errors of FFF printed spur gears using PLA and Nylon," Polymer Testing, vol. 117, Jan. 2023, Art. no. 107862, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.polymertesting.2022.107862. [2] M. M. Hanon, L. Zsidai, and Q. Ma, "Accuracy investigation of 3D printed PLA with various process parameters and different colors," Materials Today: Proceedings, vol. 42, pp. 3089–3096, Jan. 2021, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.matpr.2020.12.1246. [3] D.G. Zisopol, I. Nae, A. I. Portoaca, and I. Ramadan, "A Theoretical and Experimental Research on the Influence of FDM Parameters on Tensile Strength and Hardness of Parts Made of Polylactic Acid", Engineering, Technology & Applied Science Research, vol. 11, no. 4, pp. 7458–7463, Aug. 2021, https://doi.org/10.48084/etasr.4311. [4] D. G. Zisopol, I. Nae, A. I. Portoaca, and I. Ramadan, "A Statistical Approach of the Flexural Strength of PLA and ABS 3D Printed Parts," Engineering, Technology & Applied Science Research, vol. 12, no. 2, pp. 8248–8252, Apr. 2022, https://doi.org/10.48084/etasr.4739. [5] D. G. Zisopol, I. Nae, and A. I. Portoaca, "Compression Behavior of FFF Printed Parts Obtained by Varying Layer Height and Infill Percentage," Engineering, Technology & Applied Science Research, vol. 12, no. 6, pp. 9747–9751, Dec. 2022, https://doi.org/10.48084/etasr.5488. [6] D. G. Zisopol, D. V. Iacob, and A. I. Portoaca, "A Theoretical- Experimental Study of the Influence of FDM Parameters on PLA Spur Gear Stiffness," Engineering, Technology & Applied Science Research, vol. 12, no. 5, pp. 9329–9335, Oct. 2022, https://doi.org/10.48084/ etasr.5183. [7] "3D CAD Design Software," SOLIDWORKS. https://www. solidworks.com/home-page-2021. [8] "3D printing software of Creality Cloud," Creality Cloud. https://www.crealitycloud.com/software-firmware/software?type=8. [9] D. G. Zisopol, A. I. Portoaca, I. Nae, and I. Ramadan, "A Comparative Analysis of the Mechanical Properties of Annealed PLA," Engineering, Technology & Applied Science Research, vol. 12, no. 4, pp. 8978–8981, Aug. 2022, https://doi.org/10.48084/etasr.5123. [10] A. Portoaca, I. Nae, D. G. Zisopol, and I. Ramadan, "Studies on the influence of FFF parameters on the tensile properties of samples made of ABS," IOP Conference Series: Materials Science and Engineering, vol. 1235, no. 1, Nov. 2022, Art. no. 012008, https://doi.org/10.1088/1757- 899X/1235/1/012008. [11] H. S. Park, N. H. Tran, V. T. Hoang, and V. H. Bui, "Development of a Prediction System for 3D Printed Part Deformation," Engineering, Technology & Applied Science Research, vol. 12, no. 6, pp. 9450–9457, Dec. 2022, https://doi.org/10.48084/etasr.5257. [12] M. Minescu and D. Zisopol, Sudarea țevilor şi fitingurilor din polietilenă de înaltă densitate (HDPE Pipe & Fittings Welding). Ploiesti, Romania: UPG Ploieşti Publishing House, 2021. [13] D. Zisopol and A. Dumitrescu, Ecotehnologie. Studii de caz. Ploiesti, Romania: UPG Ploieşti Publishing House, 2021. [14] D. G. Zisopol, A. Dumitrescu, C. N. Trifan, Ecotehnologie: Noţiuni teoretice, aplicaţii şi studii de caz, Ploiesti, Romania: UPG Ploieşti Publishing House, 2010. [15] D. G. Zisopol, M. J. Săvulescu, Bazele tehnologiei, Ploiesti, Romania: UPG Ploieşti Publishing House, 2003. [16] D. G. Zisopol, Tehnologii industriale și de construcții. Aplicații practice și studii de caz, Ploiesti, Romania: UPG Ploieşti Publishing House, 2003. [17] M. J. Săvulescu, D. G. Zisopol, Tehnologii industriale şi de construcţii, Ploiesti, Romania: UPG Ploieşti Publishing House, 2002. [18] D. G. Zisopol, Ingineria valorii, Ploiesti, Romania: UPG Ploieşti Publishing House, 2004. [19] T. A. Cojoianu, "Studiu comparativ privind influența parametrilor tehnologiei de fabricație aditivă prin extrudarea PLA și ABS asupra abaterilor dimensionale ale roților dințate cilindrice și rigidității angrenării acestora," M.S. thesis, Petroleum-Gas University, Ploiesti, Romania, 2022. [20] D. V. Iacob, "Măsurarea rigidității angrenării roților dințate fabricate din PLA, folosite la antrenarea cuțitului unității de tăiere a mașinii pentru fabricarea corpurilor radiatoarelor auto", M.S. thesis, Petroleum-Gas University, Ploiesti, Romania, 2022.