03_olufunmilayo european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5464 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 26 enhancing financial resource management of families in economic recession: a case study of kaduna state olufunmilayo foluke alabi1 1 federal college of education, nigeria. e-mail: drfunmialabi@gmail.com received: 28/12/2020 accepted for publication: 23/08/2021 published: 12/11/2021 abstract families manage their financial resources before the economic recession. the current economic recession is already taking a toll on the family, particularly families in developing countries. the economic recession has impacted the family finances thereby creating challenges that may lead to family crises and instability. the enhancement of family financial resource management is a must for family survival. the general objective of the study was to investigate the financial resource management of the family in economic recession. specifically, the study, identified how families managed their financial resources in the period of economic recession, determined the impact of economic recession on family financial resources. the area of the study was kaduna state. the population consist the couple and their children. the sample of the study was made up of the couple and any child in the family that was not above 24 years. the sample size was 600 respondents selected from three local government areas using systematic random sampling. structured questionnaire was used for data collection and mean score was used for analysis. the result revealed that families enhance their financial support from children, family members, keeping livestock and return from pensions. it was further revealed that families manage their financial resources in economic recession through prudent financial plans, buying items in bulk and cutting down on luxury. the implication is that if families do not manage their family financial resources effectively during economic recession, they are likely to face the following challenges: poverty, health problems, inability to afford basic amenities, lack of education or poor education, and emotional stress. based on these findings, it was recommended among others that financial institutions should provide family with microfinance to enable them invest in their business. entrepreneurship education and home economics should be made compulsory at all levels of education in order to learn saleable skills that can enhance their finances and through these the impact of the financial challenges would be reduced. keywords: families; enhancement; financial resource management; economic recession 1. introduction the economic recession which began officially in december of 2007 had both direct and indirect effects on families. the direct effect on family life is loss of employment of parents. the global economic recession of 2007/2008 affected nigeria as a periphery economy that is dependent on the global trade (onwe & ezeadaobi 2019). the federal governments revenue is european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5464 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 27 over-dependent on crude oil, lives on foreign finished household’s electronics, military gargets, imported foods, clothes and cars (onwe & ezeadaobi 2019). there have been symptoms of economic recession in nigerian but it has become more evident during the covid -19 pandemic. the current economic recession in nigeria is due to the unexpected and sustained decline in oil prices and this was the most important cause of recession, but in 2020 public health crisis was the trigger of economic recession in the whole world and nigeria inclusive. the covid-19 pandemic has had far reaching effects on the global economy, this in turn affects the families ( ozili & arun 2020) the family is the smallest unit in the social structure of every society. it is often made up of persons united by marriage, blood or adoption, which may be characterized by common residence, economic corporation and it can be nuclear or extended ( alabi 2013, sociation 2010, & atti 2016). ikulayo (1999) noted that the family is a group consisting of two adults of both sexes who maintain a social approved sexual relationship and one or more children of their own or adopted ones. the family as a unit share resources, responsibility for decisions, values, goals and commitment to one another over time (christensen 1990). family is also viewed as a decision making unit that uses its human and material resources to meet its demands. the family also achieves its goals and responds to events through planning the use of its resources. deacon and firebaugh (2001) asserted that resources are available means (as in business) computable wealth (money, property and products). for family, one of the resources available is known as income or money. money management according to anyakoha and eluwa (2010) is an organized process of allocating and using money to achieve specific goals that are usually purchased with money. the family has the obligation to provide for both the fixed (electricity bills, water bills, house rent, school fees) and day to day expenses for food, clothes and medical bills for the members of the family. to fulfill these obligations resources are needed. resource management referred to the coordination of resources of an individual or organization through the process of planning, organizing, directing and controlling in other to attain individual or organizational objectives (rice and tucker 2005). resource management is the development and allocation of resources to meet family goals (mary and earl 2008). family financial resource management is a series of actions planned to balance income with expenditure and it includes planning, controlling and evaluating the use of money to meet family goals (nwankwo 2003). family resource management is the prudent planning, money savings, financial budgeting and effective coordination of financial resources in the family. before someone can even think about changing their financial behavior, they will experience a change process called consciousness raising (oneil & xiao 2012).this term means that they will begin to learn new facts, ideas and tips that support the idea of making a positive change, for example saving money and reducing debts (oneil & xiao 2012 ). the causes of decline in financial resources are attributed to unemployment, corruption in the society, greediness, low services and inflation (akinwumi 2008). it can also be attributed to poor management, inadequate financial control, inappropriate financial policy and high cost structure among others ( nickaf & opadeyi 2011). effective family resource management has the capacity of ameliorating challenges faced by families during economic recession. economic recession is a period of significant decline in economic activity/lasting more than a few months and there is a drop in the following five economic indicators: real gross domestic product, income, equipment, manufacturing and retail sales (bureau of economic research 2009).the nigerian economic crisis/recession resulting in the breakdown and decline in economic vigor has caused downsizing, mass unemployment, underemployment and bankruptcy (alabi 2013). the long term effects of economic downturn among families can negatively impact the educational and work outcome of next generations (haveman, heinric and smeeding 2011, irons 2009, vonwacher 2011). the experience of living on low income and poverty is almost overwhelmingly negative, impacting on adults and children’s lives in a variety of ways including loss of self-esteem and feelings of isolation and restricted opportunities and choices (udonwa & iyam 2018)., this places heavy demands on parents capacity, to manage everyday pressures under severe financial strain in their home (udonwa & iyam 2018). the covid -19 pandemic has had a far reaching effects on the already fragile nigerian economy and families, it affected the global travel businesses, national health care systems, food industry, events industry, education and global trade (ozili and arun 2020). the situation being experienced by families necessitates for good planning, effective management and reduction of expenses which is a clear indication that families need financial security. family financial security will contribute to their emotional stability; strengthen community and a nation better able to live a thriving economic legacy for future generations. financial security is the ability to meet future needs while keeping pace with day to day obligations (national initiative on financial security 2001).there are very few studies and research work on impact of economic recession on companies, how recession affected different aspect of the economy, like banking industry, textile industry and other establishments in nigeria ( chukwu, liman, enuelu & ehiaghe,2015). some other courtiers like usa have been able to carry out studies on families european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5464 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 28 struggle to afford food ((deparle 2010), increasing demands on food banks and charities (house committee on ways and means 2009). a research carried out on achieving family sustainable development through family financial management in kano state revealed that the strategy for financial management is to stress the need for effective cash management to family members, the mean score was 3.12 out of scale of 4 (ibrahim 2012). research on management of family finances in period of economic meltdown in benue state revealed that adequate financial budget is needed this had a mean of 2.73 out of a scale of 4, while prudent financial planning had 3.4, avoid unnecessary expenditure had 2.9, joint saving had 2.59, investment on business ventures 2.8 out of scale of 4 (ebeirim & ochai 2011). only very few studies have been carried out on family management of finances in nigeria. however the gap that has emerged from literature is the area of causes, challenges, impact, and ways of improving finances of workers and families in economic recession. research works are few in this area especially in developing countries. managing financial resources of families in economic meltdown has been studied in one state out of 36 states in nigeria but kaduna state not inclusive. furthermore no research has been carried out on enhancement of family financial resources in economic recession in kaduna state. it is against this background that the study sought to investigate the enhancement of financial resource management of families in period of economic recession. therefore, the research aim to determine resources available to the family in economic recession period, identified how families managed their financial resources in the period of economic recession, determine the impact of economic recession on family financial resources in kaduna state. the study answers the following research questions: what are the sources of income available to the families in economic recession in kaduna state, what are the ways of managing family financial resources during economic recession, what are the impact of economic recession on family financial resources, the answer to these questions should improve the existing practice though ameliorating the impact of the economic recession through enhancement of family financial resource management so as to have family stability. government and ngos should assist families with resources and economic relief packages to reduce the impact of economic recession. entrepreneurship education and subjects like home economics should be made compulsory for all students at all levels of the education in kaduna state, so that skills learnt can be used as a means of generating money. finance institutions should provide families with micro-finance to enable them invest in their businesses. the research will be structured to continue to in the next paragraph as follows; the review of the literature, followed by methodology, presentation of findings, discussion and finally conclusions. 2. literature review economic recession is a significant decline in economic activity spread across the economy lasting more than months normally visible to real gdp, real income, employment industrial production and wholesales-retail sales (national bureau of economic research 2020). economic recession is a period of economic slowdown featuring low output, illiquidity and unemployment. it is characterized by its length abnormal increases in unemployment, falls in the availability of credit shrinking output and investment, numerous bankruptcies, reduce amount trade and commerce, as well as highly volatile relative currency value fluctuation mostly devaluations and financial crises and bank failure (fapohunda 2012). opeyemi (2008) observed that there are cases of unemployment, retrenchments, downsizing and layoffs, which served as indications to a troubled economy. she further noted that individuals have nowhere to turn to except involving in misconduct and societal condemned activities such as militancy, armed robbery advanced fee fraud, ritual practices for fetish money among others. global recession has been a recurrent topic of debate over past decade reflecting the breath and severity of 2007-2009 global financial crises and the halting nature of the recovery and recently fears that the global economy was on down turn. further more in 2009 the interest was understandably focused on the severity of the global reaction and its devastation consequences (allen 2009). attention shifted to the signs of a flourishing global possibility in 2010 2011 but hopes that this would be sustained were soon curtailed by the possibility of another global recession due to the euro area debt crisis (alessandria, kabaski and midrigan (2010). in nigeria so any companies shut down, the textile sector laid off about 5,000 worker, peugeot automobile nigeria (pan) sacked 565 workers out of 753 workforce and placed the remaining staff on half salary. also the cadbury nigeria plc fired 300 staff while the banking sector seems to be worse hit (sanusi. l.s. 2010). financial pressure in the 2015 euro area eased in late 2012, but in 2015-2016 fears of a global recession reemerged partly because of financial market turbulence in china (bacchetta and van 2016). since mid 2018 concern about a global recession european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5464 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 29 have returned as the world economy experienced a synchronized slow down largely derived by extra ordinary weakness manufacturing among elevated trade tension and heighten the policy uncertainties ( cuba-borda,mechanick and raff 2018). recently the covid-19 pandemic and the lock down restrictions had negative socio economic consequences for all nations. the international labour organization (2010) revealed that as many as 51 million workers were fired in 2010 globally while 30 million more jobs are at risk. the united nations meanwhile predicts that 200 million workers mostly in developing economies could be pushed in to extreme poverty. massachusetts lost 150,000 jobs in two years after the official onset of the recession and unemployment more than doubled from 4.5% to 9.4% (schworm and unifoil 2010) job loss and unemployment has been especially high in occupations held by men and among those in the lower 30% of income distribution. 2.1 major causes of economic recession in any economy experiencing great depression, global economic recessions as drawn from great lesson depression of 1981, 1991, 2004, 2008-2009, includes the following: high inflation, a general rise in price of goods and services which leads to low purchasing power accumulation of debt services especially foreign debts high interest rate -discouraging investors fall in aggregate demand, fall in wages and income mass unemployment and general loss of confidence on the government due to economic indices global health crisis( onwe and eze 2019). 2.2 effect of economic recession recession results in higher unemployment lower wages and income. education, private companies, investments and economic opportunities are all likely to suffer in the current down turn and the effect will be long lived (www.epic.orgpublication). deidda (2015) found out that housing costs were a financial burden and were associated with economic hardship such as preventing families from spending money on healthcare, education, food and clothing. findings from these studies converge suggests that many families lived in a time of financial instability and were vulnerable to financial shock. changes in life circumstances can easily place households at risk of experiencing economic hardship, ranging from difficulty in covering basic needs to filing for bankruptcy (bauchet and evans 2019, deidda 2015, helfin 2016). economic hardship places stress on family relationship (masarik and conger 2017). 2.3 coping strategies coping strategies that families used varied tobe et al (2016) observed that families receiving counseling services also used faith to build support system and developed new relationships with others. reliance on family and relationships were observed among economically distressed families, strong family relationships helps to sustain those under emotional and financial stress among mid west families (tobe et al 2016, vesely et al 2015). families also coped financially by borrowing from payday loans, filling for bankruptcy, using government subsidies, changing jobs or savings for emergencies (gjertson 2016, lebert and voorpostel 2016). 2.4 the family stress model economic adversity has been associated with a range of child outcomes, including elevated risk for behavior problems (brooks-gunn& duncan 1997,evans & english,2002) reduce social competence( bolger, patterson, thompson,& kupersmidt, 1995), the family stress model(fsm) proposes that economic hardship leads economic pressure in the family. makers of hardship may include low income, negative financial events, high debts relative to assets, or whether a family meets governmental guidelines for defining poverty status( conger,et al 2010). pressure such as unmet material needs ( e.g inadequate food or clothing), the inability to pay bills or make ends meet, and having to cut back on unnecessary expenses are psychological manifestations and responses to economic hardship. these pressures are thought to place parents at increased risk of emotional european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5464 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 30 distress. the present study tested some of the predictions derived from the fsm to understand the impact of economic hardship on families and how to have effective family financial management. the current paper contribute to the body of literature by examining the impact of economic recession on families and enhancement of family resource management in kaduna state since no research on this topic has been carried out in this area in kaduna state. 3. methodology 3.1 research design and area of study the research design employed for this study was descriptive survey. this method according to osual (2011) is the best suited for collecting information from a large and small population located at different places in the area of the study. eboh (2009) also noted that descriptive study entails the systematic collection and presentation of data to give a clear picture of a particular situation. gall, gall and borg (2007), asserted that descriptive survey research design focused on people, facts about people, their beliefs, opinions, attitudes motivations and behaviors. the descriptive survey design is best suited for this study because it seeks the opinions of selected family members in this study. the area of the study was kaduna state. kaduna state was chosen for the study due to cases of family crises resulting from poor management of recourses in economic recession, coupled with the researcher’s familiarity with the area that could ease work for collection. 3.2 population of the study the population of the study comprised 3,300 respondents that are married and one adult child of the family that is 24 years and above from three senatorial zones of the state. available record from the national bureau of statistics (nbs) and annual abstract of statistics (2008). these people were selected since they have sufficient knowledge about the topic under investigation. therefore, they will be able to supply adequate information on the research instrument. 3.3 sample and sampling technique six hundred (600) respondents were selected from three local government areas (lgas) of kaduna state using systematic random sampling. one lga was randomly selected from each of the three senatorial zones in the state. from each of the lga, the selected family members include: three respondent’s husband, wife and a child not below 24 years. random sampling ensures that every unit in the study population has a known and equal chance (that is, equi-propability) of being included in the sample (eboh 2009). systematic random sampling is a variation of the simple random sampling, systematic random sampling is characterized by a random start, followed by a pre-determined or systematized order of selection (ebob 2009, osuala 2011). once the first unit has been selected (that is the random start) all the rest of the units for the sample are pre-determined ( ezeji 2010 ). it is probability sampling because the chance of selecting for each unit is known and the starting point is random. in systematic random sampling the count of units must be known ( eboh 2009). this is how total number of units in the sample frame (n) is divided by the units in the sample (n) to obtain sampling interval (k) rounded up to the nearest whole number k=n/n for example in this study 1100 families and sample of 200 was drawn then sampling interval k is 1100/200 = 5.5. the first unit from the population is selected randomly and then every 5th family unit on the list is selected using eboh (2009) formula. in this study after the first selected family, every fifth family was selected 600 respondents was attained. in systematic random sampling having a form of order in some way increases the sample efficiency. 3.4 research instruments the instrument for data collection was research questionnaire titled: enhancement of financial resource management of families during economic recession in kaduna state. for question one, the items were based on two point scale of available and not available. for research questions two, three and four, four point’s scale of strongly agreed (4), agreed (3), strongly disagreed (2), and disagreed (1). the instrument for the study was subjected to validation by three lecturers who were experts in the field. the experts were served with the copies of the instrument and were required to vet the items for appropriateness, adequacy and clarity in measuring what they are set to measure. the experts suggested areas for improvement of the instrument european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5464 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 31 towards meeting the purpose of the study. the observations and suggestions were used to improve the final copy of the instrument. testretest method was used to determine the reliability of the instrument. this method involves collecting data from the same individuals twice within a given space of time; this group was not part of the final respondents. a total of 30 respondents were involved and 30 copies of the instruments were administered to them twice at the interval of two weeks. reponses from the subjects were analyzed using spearman rank order to obtain the reliability coefficient of 0.80, 0.84, 0.78 and 0.93 thus the instrument was reliable. 3.5 data analysis a total number of 600 questionnaires were administered with the help of three research assistants. distribution and collection of questionnaire was by hand. the data from the questionnaire was analyzed using mean and standard deviation to answer the research questions through the use of spss package. the 4-point scale of response option of one, two, three and four were assigned value of strongly agreed (4), agreed (3), disagreed (2), strongly disagreed (1).the researcher used 2.5 as the level of acceptance which means that any item with mean of 2.5 and above was accepted while anyone which had a mean of below 2.5 was rejected. 590 questionnaires were completed and retrieved which was 93.3%. 4. findings of the study the following findings were made by the study based on the research questions: research question 1: what are the sources of income available to families in economic recession in kaduna state. research question 2: what are the impacts of economic recession on families in kaduna state. research question 3: what are the ways of managing family financial resources in economic recession. 1. five available source of financial resources of the family (see table 1 in appendix section) 2. ten ways families mange their financial resources in economic recession(see table 2 in appendix section) 3. ten impact of economic recession on family financial resources(see table 3 in appendix section) the study reveals that the response for the respondents on sources of finance available to the family are salary, return from stock investment, turnover from saving/contributions, turnover from livestock and return from pension. while there were no financial resource support from relatives, support from children, returns from rent from building and places of worships. the respondents agreed on nine items resources on ways of managing financial but disagreed on one way families manage their finances in economic recession. they practice financial budget, buying in bulk, prudent financial planning, cutting down luxuries, avoiding unnecessary expenditure, getting involved in joint account, engage in animal and food production, engage in small scale business and having financial accountability for the members of the family. families try to put in their best for survival but they find it difficult to follow and execute financial plans in recession period due to inflation. the study further revealed that the respondents agreed on all the impact of economic recession on the family. 5. discussion and further research based on the analysis of the data collected on enhancement of family financial resource management in economic recession. research question 1 which is: what are the sources of income available to the families in economic recession in kaduna state? in response to research question 1: five (5) items out of ten (10 items) were agreed on as sources of finance available to the family. the items agreed on are money from salary, return from stock investment, turnover from savings and contribution, turnover from pension and turnover from livestock. the items have a mean range of 2.50 to 3.47. this indicates that all those items are sources of family financial resource. this is in line with deacon and firebaugh (2001) who noted that earning salary is a source of income for a family. research question 2 sought answer on what are the ways of managing financial resources of families in economic recession in kaduna state. on ways of managing financial resources in economic recession, the respondents agreed on all the ways families’ manage their financial resources during economic recession. their responses includes: practicing financial budget, bulk buying when money is available, prudent spending, cutting down luxuries, window shop and avoid unnecessary european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5464 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 32 expenditure. they engage in animal production, engage in small scale business and making financial accountability to each member of the family this is in line with deacon and firebaugh (2001), that opines that family achieves its goals responds to events through planning the use of its resources and implementing the plans. stroud (2008) also opined that financial budget and effective planning reduce cost by avoiding waste in expenditures and giving up luxury items. the findings showed that when there is effective financial management family goals can be achieved and this is needed during economic recession. research question 3 is on what are the impacts of economic recession on families in kaduna state. it was revealed by the respondents that in economic recession, families experience poverty, ill health, inflation and inability to pay children’s’ school fees, adult family members delay or forgo academic pursuit, reduce income level leading to nutritional distress, financial hardship leading to harsh and inconsistent parenting, inability to meet economic needs and depending on other people for family needs. these findings are in line with opeyemi (2008) who observed that the influence of economic recession is attributed to unemployment, poverty and corruption in the society. this implies that economic recession influences the family financial resources and living conditions of the family is negatively affected. the study has provided the following suggestions for further research: a similar study should be carried out using other family members (adolescent ,elderly), some of the ways of managing finances can be applied to businesses either personal or group ventures. 6. conclusion this paper highlights aims to: determine resources available to the family in economic recession in kaduna state, identify how families manage their financial resources in economic recession, determine the impact of economic recession on families in kaduna state and the research questions on: what are the sources of income available for families, what are the impact of the economic recession on the families, what are the ways of managing family financial recourses in economic recession that guided the study. the study made use of related research work and literature as a guide in formulating the research questions for this study. it also made use of family stress model which confirmed that families feel the impact of the financial stress. the findings of this study revealed that economic recession can lead to, poverty, ill health, adult family members forgoing academic pursuit, emotional distress, inflation, inability to pay children school fees, loss of job, and hardship is the order of the day in economic recession therefore there is need for effective family financial management before and in the period of economic recession. it was further revealed that families have some ways to manage the challenges that affects the family but even with the management families still felt the impact. the study has implication for families, since during economic recession families feel the adverse effect. it is expected that when families are able to enhance their financial resource management they should not feel the adverse effects of the economic recession. there is also the need for inculcation of new skills on how to handle economic recession and to learn new skills for self reliance. improve creativity in schools and colleges on family financial resource management. the study will go a long way in assisting curriculum planners and teachers in getting information on causes, ways of enhancing financial management of families and the impact of economic recession. there by giving the students and families’ opportunities to learn how to cope. families will also learn and adopt skills of saving for emergency. families, government and marriage counselors can adopt the ways of managing family financial resources in economic recession the study covered only selected sample of the population which makes it a bit difficult to determine what the opinion of the other members of the family may be, other members of the family can be researched on by other researchers. in the research, methodology questionnaire was used to get responses, other researches can use both questionnaire and focus group discussion so as to double cross the respondents opinion. hypothesis was not used in this study but in further studies it can be incorporated. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5464 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 33 references alabi.o.f .(2013),strategies for improving the practices adopted by families in coping with selected family crises in kaduna state an unpublished phd thesis university of nigeria, nsukka. akinwumi, f.s. (2008), managing education in the era of economic reform: the nigerian experience. paper presented at national conference of education administration and planning association of nigeria. abuja, nigeria. allessandria.g. kabaski.p. and midrigan,v.(2010) the great trade collapse an inventory adjustment. imf economic review 5 (2) 254-294. allen,r.e(2009) financial crisis and recession in global economy.third edition. northampton edword elgar. anyakoha, e.u and eluwa, m. (2010), home management for schools and colleges onitsha; africana fep publishers ltd. atti,t. (2006). the concept of family demographic and genealogical perspectives. the official journal of north carolina. sociology association. bacchetta,p. and van.e (2016), the great recession: a self-fulfilling global panic american economic journal macroeconomics(ed) 4:177-194. bolge,k.e,peterson,e.j,thompso,w.w kupersmidt (1995), psychosocial adjustment among children experiencing persistent and intermittent family economic hardship. child development. 66: 107-1129 .(googl scholar) brook-gunn,j. & dunncan,g.j(1997). the effect of poverty on children. the future children: 7. 55-75(google scholar) christensen, b.j (1990), utopia against the family. san francisco, ignatus press chukwu .b.a, liman, n.a, enudu.t.o & ehiaghe, a.f (2015),the effect of economic recession in textile manufacturing industries in nigeria. asian journal of business management.7,(#) 43-54. conger,r.d,conger.k.j,martin, m.(2010) socioeconomic status family processes and individual development. journal of marriage and family. 72,685-704. cuba-borda, b, mechanik,p.a and raff. a.( 2018),monitoring the world economy. a global conditions index. ifdp note june board of government of the federal reserve system washinton. dc deacon, l.u and firebaugh, a.d (2001), family resource management report: national center for family statistics. deidda, m. (2015), economic hardship, housing cost, boarding and tenure status evidence from eusilc. journal of family and economic issue 36(4), 35-56. deparle jason (2010), families struggle to afford food, survey finds.the new york times. the new york company, www.nytimes.com/ 2010/0/26us/26ffood.retrieved 25th july 2021. eboh, e.c (2009), social and economic research principles and methods.enugu, nigeria .african institute for applied economics. ebirim, u and ochai. g.o (2015), economic challenges and strategies for managing family resources in nigeria. developing country studies. 5(11), 1-5. ezeji.s.c.o.a (2010), basic principles of research in education. enugu, nigeria. cheston agency ltd. evans,g.w & english,k.(2002), the environment of poverty multiple psychological stress and socioemotional adjustment. child development.73,1238-1248.(googl scholar) fapounda,t.m. (2012),the global economic recession. impact and strategies for human resource management in nigeria. journal of economic and management sciences. 1(6), 7-12. gall, m.gall. j and borg.w.r (2007), educational research: an introduction. new york. usa. pearson education international publisher. gjertson, g., satajo, a., lucero, j., and cutsinge, j. (2016), adolescent neighborhood context and young adult-economic outcomes for low income african americans and latinos. journal of economics geography 16(2), 471-503. haveman, r.h, heinric, c.j and smeeding, t.m. (2011), jobs, skills and policy for lower wage workers. fast focus, 10, 16. house committee on ways and means.(2009), the increasing demand on food banks and charities on the frontline.house committee on ways and mean www.wayssand means .house.gov/press/practical.aspx.retrieved 25th july 2021. ibrahim, a.n.(2012). achieving family sustainable development through family financial management. nigerian journal of home economics. 3(2) 71-76. ikulayo, o.p.b (1999), family life and sex education, lagos. philche educational and consultancy services. internal labour organisation (2010), world empolyment .www.ilo.org/public/eglish bureau/info/pkils. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5464 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 34 irons, j. (2009), economic scarring: the long-term impacts of the recession. economic policy institute, washington, dc mary, w. and earl, w. (2008), family resource management and family business coming together in theory and research. journal of home management, (usa) vol 2, 223-234 masarik, a.s. and conger, r.d. (2017), stress and child development: a review of the family stress model current opinion on psychology 13, 85-90. www.doi.org/1016/jcopsy. retrieved on 15th march 2021. national bureau of economic and research (2009). the nber’ recession dating procedure. www.nber.org/cycles/sano&bcdc. retrieved 15th august 2019. national initiative (2001), issues in family financial management: policy-2 national bureau of statistic (2008) and annual abstract of statistics produced under the auspices of federal government economic reform and government project.nigeria. nickaf, m.s. and opadeyi, j.j. (2011), expanding entrepreneurship education in the n.c.e programme as a strategy for improving students interest in home economics as a life career. nigerian journal of home economics 6 (6) 12-125. nwankwo, f.o (2003), a practical guide to family financial. ughelli nigeria. eddy joe publishers oneill, b and xiao, j.j(2012), financial behaviours before and after the crisis: evidence from an online survey. journal of financial counceling and planning 23(!) 33-46. onwe,f. and eze,a.c ( 2019).the effect of recession on nigerian families and expected ways out for individual families. journal of social service and welfare. 1(2),32-37. opeyemi, m.g (2008), the restiveness of nigerian youth and the problem of unemployment in apleton centry croft, inc new york. osuala, e.c (2011), introduction to research methods. onitsha, nigeria africana feb publishers. ozili .p. and arun.t (2020), covid-19 pandemic and economic crisis. the nigerian experience and structure causes. www.research gate.net/publication. rice, b. and tucker (2005), children in food insufficient low income families’ prevalence health and nutritional status. arch pediats adoles, med, 2005, 176: 161 – 167. sanusi.s.l(2010). the nigerian banking industry what went wrong and the way forward. delivered at annual convention ceremony of bayero university, kano. held on 3(1) 2010. schworm,p. and uwilfoil. j.m.(2010) rising economic stress cited in domestic violence increase in boston globe. sociatio,t. (2010). the concept of family demographic and genealogical perspectives.the official journal of the association of the carolina sociological association,2(2) 1-9. soedlak,a.j.(2010). fouth national incidence study of child abuse and neglect (nis -4). report to congress 2010. u.s department of health and human services administration for children and families. washington .dc . stroud, j. (2008), women owe it to themselves to save for retirement. retrieved august 20, 2019 from www.stitoday.com/stitoday/ business/columnists.nsfijerrs-trovd/story/7486oa9b tobe, e., ames, b. and car olan, m. (2016), looking back the experience of four midest families after receiving foreclosure. journal of family and economic issue 37(3), 386-394. vesely, l.k., goodman, r.d., ewaida, m., and kearney, k.b. (2015), a better life? immigrant mothers experiences building economic security. journal of family and economic issue 36(4), 514-530. vonwacher, t. (2011), challenges for the u.s economic recovery. washington, d.c; testimony before the budget committee. retrieved july 11, 2019 from www.columbia.edu. retrieved 15th march 2021 udome,r.e & iyam, m.m, (2018).managing home finances and family standard of living: the case of parent in akwa ibom, nigeria. nigerian journal of home economics, 11(12) 118-124. www.epic.org.publication .retrieved 15th march 2021. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5464 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 35 appendix table 1: mean responses on sources of income available to the families in economic recession. source: author’s elaboration resources available to family members female family members male family members x1 sd remark x2 sd remark salary 3.46 0.92 available 3.27 0.90 available support from relatives 2.17 0.56 not available 2.16 0.55 not available occasional return from stock investment 2.50 0.90 available 2.56 0.90 available support from children 2.29 0.71 not available 2.16 0.55 not available return from rent from building 2.00 0.00 not available 2.17 0.56 not available turnover from business 3.19 0.98 available 3.67 0.95 available turnover from savings or contribution 3.01 0.81 available 3.47 0.92 available return from pension 2.61 0.93 available 2.60 0.92 available turnover from livestock 2.73 0.96 available 2.61 0.93 available place of worship 2.17 0.56 not available 2.16 0.55 not available european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5464 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 36 table 2: mean responses on ways of managing family financial resources in economic recession. ways of managing family financial resources female family member male family member x1 sd remark x2 sd remark able to follow and execute financial plans in recession time 2.00 0.00 agreed 2.17 0.56 disagreed practicing financial plans 2.64 0.81 agreed 2.56 0.80 agreed bulk buying when money is available 2.74 0.82 agreed 2.71 0.81 agreed prudent financial planning 3.66 0.95 agreed 3.47 0.92 agreed cutting down luxuries 3.46 0.95 agreed 3.47 0.92 agreed window shopping and avoid unnecessary expenditure 2.94 0.85 agreed 2.91 0.84 agreed get involve in joint account saving 2.66 0.81 agreed 2.97 0.85 agreed planning of income and expenditure 3.27 0.90 agreed 3.14 0.92 agreed engage in animal and food production 3.66 0.95 agreed 3.47 0.92 agreed engage in small scale business 2.66 0.81 agreed 2.56 0.80 agreed financial account ability from each member of the family who are of age 3.01 0.86 agreed 2.80 0.83 agreed source: author’s elaboration european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5464 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 37 table 3: mean response on impact of economic recession on family financial resources management. impact of economic recession on family finances mean response of female mean response of male x1 sd remark x2 sd remark poverty in the family 2.59 0.80 agreed 2.73 0.82 agreed problem of ill health 2.94 0.94 agreed 2.83 0.79 agreed inflation (i.e. things are expensive) 2.77 0.83 agreed 2.91 0.84 agreed inability to pay school fees of children on time 2.66 0.81 agreed 2.74 0.82 agreed job loss and inability to get jobs 3.44 0.92 agreed 3.66 0.92 agreed adult family members delay or forgo academic pursuit 3.04 0.86 agreed 2.59 0.80 agreed reduces income or slash in salary 2.80 0.83 agreed 2.73 0.82 agreed emotional distress that leads to harsh and inconsistent parenting 3.01 0.86 agreed 3.91 0.98 agreed inability to meet economic needs 3.66 0.95 agreed 3.43 0.92 agreed depending on others to help meet ones needs 3.01 0.86 agreed 3.41 0.92 agreed source: author’s elaboration 4915-article text-15065-1-11-20200717 european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/4915 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 53 social stock exchange between academics and practitioners' view davide calandra1 and matteo favareto*1 1 department of management, university of turin, italy. corresponding author: matteo.favareto@unito.it received: 15/06/2020 accepted for publication: 17/07/2020 published: 20/07/2020 abstract this paper aims to investigate social stock exchange (sse) as an alternative market considering both academics and practitioners’ view. sse is a platform typically used by social entrepreneurs to collect financial resources for measurable social or environmental projects. through the analysis of 12 scientific papers and 132 documents, websites, blogs and titles reviewed by experts, the authors identify the main themes strictly connected to sse. notably, based on the previous gap analysis, this paper reveals definitions and tools which social stock exchange could address. despite the potential importance of this alternative market, the study shows few sses. the discussion between academics and practitioners shows interest by social entrepreneurs in this investment vehicle, considering the debate under the accreditation and sectors. thus, the paper contributes theoretically and practically to the primary literature providing to overcome the lack of evidence on sse. this article concludes its journey suggesting a structured future research agenda. keywords: social stock exchange, social enterprises, impact investing, academics, practitioners 1. introduction social enterprises aim to deal, primarily, with social and environmental issues, seeking to improve the quality of life of society or groups of people (doherty et al., 2014; secinaro et al., 2019). as defined by bugg-levine et al. (2012) in the harvard business review, an increasing number of entrepreneurs and investors believe that social enterprises can generate attractive financial returns. therefore, the central role is assigned to the social entrepreneur, a direct link to attract financial capital on a large scale to carry out projects with positive social and environmental externalities (colasanti et al., 2020; mcwade, 2012). according to mendell & nogales (2009), social entrepreneurs seeking investment are confronted with outdated categories and schemes (e.g. the demand for more bank guarantees). therefore, as indicated by the same authors, a cultural adaptation is needed first of all of the financial communities and then of the legal, accounting and political communities at both national and international level. therefore, over the years, alternative financial institutions such as social stock exchange (sse) have emerged (galina et al., 2013; wendt, 2017). these institutions stand alongside social enterprises, to seek capital to finance their activities and investors who are willing to invest their money in projects with social and environmental outputs (calderini et al., 2018). besides, through the exchange of securities in specially created institutions, it is possible to maximise the social value of investments compared to private profit (pavlov, 2017). however, as pointed out by many authors, there is not yet a full consensus in the literature on the infrastructures, definitions and tools that sse can provide for entrepreneurs (mendell & nogales, 2009; pavlov, 2017; secinaro et al., 2019). although a nascent stream of literature is actively focusing on social social european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/4915 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 54 stock exchanges, at the moment, this area of research does not present a systematisation and comparison between what academics say and what professionals need. therefore, starting from this research issue, the paper will aim to understand and systematise the concept of the social stock exchange in theory and practice. in particular, researchers using a qualitative methodology of analysis will proceed to classify and extract, through academic and professional databases, information on the field of research investigated. the results obtained demonstrate some interesting elements. first, the definition of sse is still to be finalised. although there is agreement on the first version, deepening the analysis, it is possible to realise how many descriptions are present today. this substantial uncertainty in the literature is partly due to the situation of uncertainty, also at the level of professionals concerning sses around the world. the original plans for the constitution of the sse have undergone variations due to the lack of interest on the part of the stakeholders involved in the use of the instrument. in other cases, there is evidence of platforms that are not active. it shows uncertainty and lack of clarity on the use of sse definition, already "in the shadows" compared to the traditional stock exchange market. nevertheless, there are some successful cases in the world and this is driving the development of new platforms dedicated to impacting investing. secondly, content's speaking, the initial discussion of the professionals is based on being able to define standards for the operation of these platforms. that is to say, specify whom they are designed for, what are the entry requirements, what is the necessary documentation to submit in order to obtain accreditation and then maintain membership. at the level of practical results, the paper investigate the concept of social stock exchange analysing the most critical and successful models in the world such as the impact investment network (u.k.), the impact investment exchange (singapore) and the bolsa social (spain). the paper aims to contribute to the emerging literature on social stock exchanges and, more widely, to the tools that social entrepreneurs can use in their activities. the rest of the paper is organised as followed. the next paragraph will assess an in-depth literature review on the role of social enterprises and the need for sse. the third paragraph will analyse the method adopted by the researchers. additionally, the fourth paragraph will assess the main results for practitioners and academics. finally, the last section will discuss and conclude the paper. 2. literature review 2.1 social enterprises and the need for social stock exchange according to battilana & lee (2014), the theory of organisation has evolved by considering social enterprises (s.e.s) as a particular form of hybrid organisation. according to the analysis of the literature published in the academy of management, these enterprises combine both business and charitable organisational aspects. besides, these organisations often host projects of high social value (battilana & lee, 2014; galaskiewicz & barringer, 2012). for instance, these organisations could host microfinance organisations, sustainable food producers, labour companies and any other project of public importance. (biancone et al., 2020; dart, 2004; dees, 2018; mair, 2010; mauksch et al., 2017; steiner, 2016). additionally, s.e.s have been viewed as an innovative, and increasingly global, solution to bridge the service delivery gap of governments (agapitova et al., 2017). in a world filled with poverty, environmental degradation, and moral injustice, social enterprises offer a ray of hope. these organisations seek to achieve social missions through business ventures (smith et al., 2013). attracting investments seems to be one of the main problems of social entrepreneurs. at the same time, some investors are ready to invest their money, but they do need guarantees and want to be sure in economic and social effects of social enterprises (boguslavskaya & demushkina, 2013). that is why social stock exchanges appeared. sse serves as a mediator between social enterprises, that need funding, and investors who are willing to invest their money (boguslavskaya & demushkina, 2013; pavlov, 2017). the history of sse is not longer than 15 years; it is a new social and economic phenomenon which is rapidly developing around the world. these are platforms dedicated exclusively to organisations with a social mission & vision. according to boguslavskaya & demushkina (2013), pavlov (2017) and (2019), sses create multiple advantages either for investors or for social enterprises and the community. the same authors state that benefits designed for investors include: make the procedure of social-enterprise investment simpler (1), increase the european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/4915 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 55 transparency of social projects (2), help to save time and cost of project searching (3), reduce the financial and administrative expenses (4), provide objective information about social projects placed on the exchange (5), increase the social value of investments (6), enable to obtain not only the financial but also the social impact of investment (7). additionally, they specified some advantages that sses generate for social enterprises: create the opportunity to get investment (1), ensure stable functioning of the organisation (2), raise the value of their social activities (3), help to grow the company's value (4), increase company's recognisability and rating (5). the introduction of social stock exchanges would contribute to balancing the different interests of the subjects involved in the exchange, bringing them closer to those of the community. at the same time, it would give the possibility for the third sector to plan their activities carefully and to ration the available resources in a long-term perspective. investing ethically means using and managing its financial resources to promote the development of projects or work of an ethical and social nature (sparkes, 2001). sse investors are often driven by a goal that exceeds mere profit maximisation (battilana & lee, 2014; mendell & nogales, 2009). they are prepared to sacrifice part of their profit to fund organisations working for the community. in conclusion, sse can connect two worlds, finance and ethics, that always have been antithetical and meet the expectations of different stakeholders involved in wendt (2017). 3. methodology 3.1 review of scientific literature and practitioners' view to answer the research question, the researchers used the literature analysis approach. in particular, the method, applied rigorously, makes it possible to investigate the primary scientific studies on specific topics (paul & criado, 2020). therefore, the methodology used makes it possible to report all the research phases and to easily allow the analysis in different areas (massaro et al., 2016). the analysis was implemented using as keywords "social stock exchange" following the objective of the article. among the search criteria, we focused on english items that were inherent to the searched object. the authors used scopus and google scholar as databases. although in the social sciences scopus returns a convincing result (falagas et al., 2007; mongeon & paulhus, 2016), the reduced number of articles have prompted researchers to continue the analysis also on google scholar for a more accurate study of the topic. after an initial selection phase using databases, the researchers went on to consult the references of the articles found (i.e. snowball sampling) to increase further the sample being studied (biancone et al., 2019; lecy & beatty, 2012). further, the following search criteria were used: availability of the full text of the article (also by request to the author) (1), studies dealing with common stock exchange issues (2). moreover, to verify the opinions and practices of professionals, researchers used a measurement technique based on electronic periodicals, expertly revised titles, consumer magazines, newspapers, news and blogs (dal mas et al., 2019; massaro et al., 2018). therefore, ulrichsweb has been used to explore all data related to professionals (meeks, 2018). as soon as the scientific and academic sample was available, all authors independently developed the analysis by reading the titles and abstracts of both datasets. subsequently, through opinion sharing and conflict resolution, the researchers came up with a final sample of study (lecy & beatty, 2012). the results and method benefited from the prisma approach for the classification of results (liberati et al., 2009). figure 1 shows the research steps and the number of scientific articles that have been selected for the construction of the academic sample. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/4915 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 56 figure 1. the prisma flow source: authors' elaboration on liberati et al. (2009) for the selection of professional contributions, the researchers used the filter "reviewed by experts". compared to primary research with 7,728 results, the application of the screen allowed evaluating 1,637 results validated by experts in the field. after a careful selection, the researchers reached a final professional sample of 132 documents, websites, blogs and titles reviewed by experts. 3.2 content analysis subsequently, after obtaining the results, the researchers carried out the independent content analysis. the objective of this method is to provide a reading of the content of the elements by creating cognitive patterns (see categories) that allow the reader to visualise the items in a research flow (flick et al., 2004). according to elo & kyngäs (2008), content analysis can be inductive or deductive. in this case, the study uses a deductive method based on three phases: preparation, organisation, concluding remarks. the first step was the reading of academic and professional contributions. through the organisation phase, researchers built a matrix to test the paper's research question by identifying reading codes derived from the literature (dal mas et al., 2019; secinaro et al., 2019). the third step made it possible to validate and conclude the article. figure 2 shows the steps used for the analysis of social stock exchanges. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/4915 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 57 figure 2. the qualitative process of content analysis source: (elo & kyngäs, 2008) 4. results the following sub-paragraphs aim to specify the academic and practical results identified by the researchers. the variables under observation are definition (1), accreditation process (2), areas of activity of accredited members (3). european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/4915 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 58 4.1. practitioners' view on the social stock exchange the first variable under observation is the definition of social stock exchange according to the three models. analysing this variable, we want to highlight the functioning of the platforms to understand how the founders conceived them. we also want to go deeper into what is the mission and vision that they pursue. regarding the u.k. platform of the impact investment network (iin), it is a network of companies and investors pursuing a social purpose. the iin is the first u.k. organisation authorised to distribute the social stock exchange brand and its accreditation methodology. the iin aims to support companies, that join the network, to grow ethically and sustainably. once they have obtained accreditation to the system, companies have the opportunity to receive investments from the platform's partners; this can represent an essential boost for the development of projects with a high social impact. moreover, thanks to the partnership between iin and nex exchange, by joining the network companies can be listed on the segment of london stock exchange (lse) dedicated to organisations with high social impact, the nex exchange. analysing the singapore stock exchange model, called impact investment exchange (iix), first of all is necessary to highlight that it is a platform dedicated to social organisations. the initial press release indicates the date of conception, 2009. it was ideated to create more sustainable finance that takes a greater interest in socio-environmental issues. however, as can be seen from the analysis of specialist news, in practice it is an investment platform dedicated to organisations with a high social and environmental value; it helps them to obtain funding thanks to the network of over 1,000 investors with a social impact purpose. to date, the iix platform includes a specific section called impact partners, which represents the first point of encounter and contact between social impact companies and investors. it is a social crowdfunding platform, which was launched in 2011 and aimed to facilitate investments in social enterprises. basically, the impact partners platform should help potential investors to identify, assess and invest in social and environmental projects. the analysis of the results of the professionals has made possible, as well, to find out more about the social stock exchange in spain. bolsa social was born in 2014 and this is the first spanish crowdfunding platform dedicated to investors and companies with high social and environmental value. bolsa social's mission is to finance companies that have growth potential and generate a positive impact on society and the environment. the second variable under observation is the accreditation process that an organisation must follow in order to access to each platform. concerning social stock exchange in the u.k., the selection process starts directly on the iin website by filling in a form in which the companies insert general data of their organisation. the company will also have to demonstrate how its activities generate a positive and tangible social impact on the environment and the territory. if it meets this requirement, the organisation will be contacted by the iin business development team to discuss the objectives that the company intends to achieve through its impact activities. the team will also support the company and will help it to prepare the application. among the mandatory documents to be submitted there is the impact report; it is a document in which the company declares its social, ethical and environmental commitment. finally, it will have to prove to be an economically/financially solid organisation with good growth prospects. applications will be submitted to the impact admissions panel; this is an insitution composed of experts in social investment and impact reporting that has the task of assessing the suitability of candidates. if the application is successful, the company will obtain the accreditation to the platform. given the nature of the platform, each year, companies accredited to the iin must submit an impact report demonstrating their social commitment (otherwise they will be excluded from the platform). analysing the impact investment exchange and impact partners in singapore, organisations that want to become members must comply with the following criteria: core business criteria (1), investment readiness criteria (2). concerning the first criterion to be met, candidate companies must demonstrate that they are economically/financially solid and pursue a social mission. the second criterion requires the presentation of a business plan in which the company defines its strategic objectives and how it intends to create a positive and tangible social impact through its activities. this document must be accompanied by financial data (historical and prospective) that demonstrate the financial situation of the company. also, in the case of the ixx, the candidate companies must submit their impact report. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/4915 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 59 as regards the process that a company must follow to become an accredited member, it consists of a series of steps that can be summarised as follows. first, the candidate will have to fill in an online form in which provides information about the company and details of the investment required. then there will be a screening process in order to evaluate the suitability of the candidate with the platform's mission. if the company pass this initial selection step, will be accepted as an accredited member. the impact partners team will prepare a technical description sheet of the company and its social project (which will then be visible to investors). the impact partners team will also facilitate matching between the accredited company and potential social investors. finally, analysing the case of the bolsa social, it is necessary to specify that can submit the applications only organisations that pursue a social mission/vision (for this reason is mandatory to present the impact report as a guarantee). besides, is fundamental being an economically/financially solid organisation with good growth prospects. as regards the process that a company must follow to access to bolsa social, it consists of a series of steps that can be summarised as follows. the selection process starts by filling in an online form in which the company presents to the bolsa social team, detailed information about its company, its business model and its current and prospective financial situation. bolsa social will carry out a screening of the applications received. once the selection process is over, the investment campaign will begin. each company sets itself a minimum and maximum capital target that it wants to achieve through the investment. the bolsa social team will publish detailed information about the company and the investment project on a dedicated page. bolsa social will also organise dedicated events to promote contacts between investors and companies. investors will be entitled to participate in the development of the project in which they have invested. they will also receive detailed information about the progress of the work. finally, the third variable analysed is related to the sectors of activity of accredited members on social stock exchanges. regarding the iin platform, it is possible to divide the accredited organisations into the following clusters of activities: reduction of harmful emissions, energy efficiency and recycling (1), consultancy/service delivery for social organisations (2), healthcare, social services, services for people with disabilities or dysfunctionality (3), innovative technologies serving the community (4), eco-homes and home repair (5), sustainable mobility (6). analysing the case of iix and impact partners platform, the accredited members are organisations belonging to the following areas of activity: industrial and rural development (1), innovative technologies serving the community (2), recycling and energy efficiency (3), social inclusion and services for people with low income or disabilities (4), education (5). in the case of bolsa social, the accredited organisations are active in the following sectors: services for people with disabilities or dysfunctionality (1), sustainable fashion (2), social inclusion (3), sustainable mobility (4), industrial and rural development (5), eco-homes (6), innovative technologies serving the community (7), production, responsible consumption and recycling (8). table 1 shows the practitioners' view by illustrating the results obtained from the study of the three variables considered. table 1. practitioners' view definition • the meeting point between companies with a social impact and investors • platforms dedicated to companies with a social mission and the promotion of their impact activities • securities trading and exchange platforms and social crowdfunding accreditation process organisations of different types and sizes may apply. a fundamental requirement is to be a solid organisation from an economic/financial point of view, with good growth prospects, and to have a social mission/vision. accredited members will obtain investments and will have to demonstrate how they can generate a positive and tangible european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/4915 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 60 social impact on the environment and the community. areas of activity of accredited members • health; • sustainable mobility; • energy efficiency and recycling; • education; • innovative technologies at the service of the community; • tourism and sustainable fashion; • industrial and rural development; • social integration. source: authors' elaboration 4.2. academics' view on the social stock exchange regarding the first variable, definition, according to (wendt, 2017), social stock exchange allows the democratisation of capital. in fact, social stock exchange can be defined as a meeting point between investors and social organisations (wendt, 2017). social stock exchanges promote the impact investing and give the possibility to social enterprises to pursue their social objective. according to the author, impact investing could be defined as a process by which investment managers screen, evaluate and monitor investments using environmental and social governance. as stated by bernardino et al. (2016) and moritz & block (2016), these platforms are similar to a social crowdfunding model. crowdfunding can support entrepreneurs for financing their projects; there are several motivations to choose these platforms. the most relevant is obviously to receive funding from the donors to attenuate a particular problem by displaying the main characteristics of the projects and the managerial structural schemes of support (such as a social organisation) for efficiency and sustainability (belleflamme et al., 2014; bernardino et al., 2016). as stated by bernardino et al. (2016) and moritz & block (2016), projects with a social or nonprofit oriented background have a higher probability of receiving funding from the crowdfunding. following dadush (2015), social stock exchanges should be platforms designed to connect investors with social businesses in need of capital. sse serves as a mediator between social enterprises that need funding and investors who are willing to invest their money. adhana (2020) defined social stock exchange as a platform on which social enterprises, volunteer groups and welfare organisations are listed so that they can raise capital for the welfare of the society and the disadvantaged. sse allows investors to buy shares in social enterprises vetted by an official exchange. these platforms would be created to serve the community, generating source from society and giving back to society in the form of welfare, upliftment through providing high infrastructures like roads, schools, hospitals. analysing the second variable, accreditation process, according to (chaturvedi et al., 2019) only social enterprises that have a track record of achieving measurable positive social and environmental impact are listed on the sse. to be accepted on sse, organisations need to comply impact and financial requirements. impact requirements relate to the preparation of an impact report for at least a year by the listing entity, obtaining an impact certification by an independent body at least a year prior to listing and ensuring the primacy of social/environmental mission. financial requirements would include meeting a minimum market capitalisation amount, publishing financial statements that meet specific specified standards at least a year before listing and demonstrating a financially sustainable business model (chaturvedi et al., 2019). also, dadush (2015) stated that social stock exchanges need to fix specific admissions criteria for social businesses wishing to transact on their platform. establishing requirements with which accredited members must comply to obtain and maintain their memberships, such as the production of financial and social reports. is fundamental that companies must have "social or environmental impact as a core aim". to satisfy this requirement, companies must submit a social impact report for review by the independent admissions panel composed of finance and impact-investing experts european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/4915 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 61 concerning the third variable under investigation, areas of activity of accredited members, as mentioned by pavlov (2017) accredited members, on platforms, have to be social organisations that pursue a social mission & vision. this means they have social ends (primary goal) which generate revenues (secondary purpose) from their activity, like mainstream businesses, and they reinvest them internally to grow as firms, reaching more people in need. these organisations are operating in different areas of business, but they must pursue a social objective (bernardino & freitas santos, 2016). analysing more specifically the sector of activities of social enterprises, on social stock exchanges, we can find different areas, such as food, security and agriculture (1), small business development (2), animal protection (3), education and health (4), environment and conservation (5), sustainable mobility (6), vulnerable people (7) (bandini, 2014; chaturvedi et al., 2019). table 2 shows the academics' view by illustrating the results obtained from the study of the three variables considered. table 2. academics' view definition • the democratisation of capital (wendt, 2017) • social crowdfunding (bernardino et al., 2016; moritz & block, 2016) • platform designed to connect investors with social businesses in need of capital (dadush, 2015) • the platform which allows investors to buy shares in social enterprises vetted by an official exchange (adhana, 2020) accreditation process • accreditation rules: impact and financial requirements (chaturvedi et al., 2019) • admissions criteria and requirements (dadush, 2015) areas of activity of accredited members • social mission & vision (pavlov, 2017) • social objective (bernardino & freitas santos, 2016) • the sector of activities of social enterprises on the social stock exchange (bandini, 2014; chaturvedi et al., 2019) source: authors' elaboration 5. discussion and conclusion the analysis of the literature of academics and professionals has made it possible to put together two visions into a single paper. this approach, according to romme et al. (2015), facilitates the dialogue between what is present in practice and what is studied by academics. mutual knowledge and common interest should facilitate the exchange of vision and contact between both realities. the paper is a connecting point by analysing the definitions, the process and the primary sectors. the analysis of the results poses some interesting reflections. first, despite the terminology, to date, social stock exchanges seem to be more similar to social crowdfunding platforms than real stock exchanges dedicated to buying and selling securities. the reference literature also confirms this with the contribution of bernardino et al. (2016). according to several experts, this is a necessary evolution of the instrument, in fact, in some cases, the original project, related to the creation of social stock exchanges, didn’t meet the interests of investors and social organisations. this reflection, therefore, opens the way for further research into why this model has not developed as much as the traditional market. additional research by academics on this point could be directed to the models we map in the analysis of the case studies and the variables that constitute them. also, a summary of the business models used could be beneficial to european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/4915 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 62 the creation of future models. finally, further research could be addressed in a comparison between social crowdfunding and social stock exchanges to investigate why the first one is more of interest to stakeholders. another significant result obtained concerns the terminology used. the analysis among practitioners and academics showed that the professional world had devoted more interest to sse than academics. as reported by romme et al. (2015), this may be due to the difference in benefits and the immediate need of practitioners to provide solutions to a practical problem. furthermore, the comparison between the two visions leads to the conclusion that sse is still too little known and exploited below their potential. also, on this point, further research elements can be followed in the future. first, researchers through specific theoretical frameworks such as stakeholder theory could verify the feasibility of the model. besides, further research could be repeated to see if there is an evolution of the terminology used today in the future. finally, the analysis of the academic and professional vision poses some points for reflection. the number of scientific contributions identified makes the sse a new tool that has been used less and less by entrepreneurs at the moment. moreover, the market is still not aware of its potential. also, there is the difficulty of intercepting the social investor, which is more easily reached through crowdfunding tools (moritz & block, 2016). finally, researchers indicate a strong information asymmetry on the use of sses, as well as the presence of a few companies accredited to the social network, can list within a segment dedicated to social. therefore, future studies may also focus on the legal and political aspects of sse. we believe that these elements can be developed in future studies to understand whether the instrument can also be relaunched by companies that own conventional stock exchanges. for the best of our knowledge, the paper contributes to the literature of the tools available to social entrepreneurs and provides an analysis of the research for sse (adhana, 2020; chaturvedi et al., 2019; pavlov, 2019). also, through the investigation of professionals, the paper highlights future challenges that professionals could solve to make sses platforms more attractive to investors and social enterprises. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/4915 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 63 references adhana, d. (2020). social stock exchange: an innovative financing platform for social enterprises in india. ssrn electronic journal. https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.3619235 agapitova, n., sanchez, b., & tinsley, e. (2017). government support to the social enterprise sector: comparative review of policy frameworks and tools. world bank group. https://www.innovationpolicyplatform.org/www.innovationpolicyplatform.org/system/files/se%20policy%20note_jun20/in dex.pdf bandini, c. (2014). social stock exchanges—innovative financing for international development. 24. battilana, j., & lee, m. (2014). advancing research on hybrid organizing – insights from the study of social enterprises. academy of management annals, 8(1), 397–441. https://doi.org/10.5465/19416520.2014.893615 belleflamme, p., lambert, t., & schwienbacher, a. (2014). crowdfunding: tapping the right crowd. journal of business venturing, 29(5), 585–609. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jbusvent.2013.07.003 bernardino, s., santos, j., & ribeiro, j. (2016). social crowdfunding: a new model for financing regional development ? journal of urban and regional analysis, 8, 97–115. bernardino, s. & freitas santos, j. (2016). financing social ventures by crowdfunding: the influence of entrepreneurs’ personality traits. the international journal of entrepreneurship and innovation, vol. 17(3) 173–183. biancone, p. p., secinaro, s., brescia, v., & calandra, d. (2019). data quality methods and applications in health care system: a systematic literature review. international journal of business and management, 14(4), p35. https://doi.org/10.5539/ijbm.v14n4p35 biancone, p., secinaro, s., brescia, v., & iannaci, d. (2020). business model innovation for sustainability and social impact. international journal of management sciences and business research, 9(5), 30–40. boguslavskaya, s., & demushkina, i. (2013). social stock exchange a new socio-economic phenomenon. riuess 2013. bugg-levine, a., kogut, b., & kulatilaka, n. (2012, gennaio 1). a new approach to funding social enterprises. harvard business review, january–february 2012. https://hbr.org/2012/01/a-new-approach-to-funding-social-enterprises calderini, m., chiodo, v., & michelucci, f. v. (2018). the social impact investment race: toward an interpretative framework. european business review, 30(1), 66–81. https://doi.org/10.1108/ebr-10-2016-0134 chaturvedi, s., sabyasachi, s., & arun s., n. (2019). social stock exchange for social enterprises and social incubators: an exploratory study for india | research and information system for developing countries. research and information system for developing countries. https://www.ris.org.in/social-stock-exchange-social-enterprises-and-social-incubatorsexploratory-study-india colasanti, n., frondizi, r., & meneguzzo, m. (2020). creating virtuous circles: worker-managed firms and local communities. piccola impresa / small business, 0(2), article 2. https://doi.org/10.14596/pisb.362 dadush, s. (2015). regulating social finance: can social stock exchanges meet the challenge? (ssrn scholarly paper id 2574921). social science research network. https://papers.ssrn.com/abstract=2574921 dal mas, f., massaro, m., lombardi, r., & garlatti, a. (2019). from output to outcome measures in the public sector: a structured literature review. international journal of organizational analysis, 27(5), 1631–1656. https://doi.org/10.1108/ijoa09-2018-1523 dart, r. (2004). the legitimacy of social enterprise. nonprofit management and leadership, 14(4), 411–424. https://doi.org/10.1002/nml.43 dees, j. g. (2018). the meaning of social entrepreneurship 1 , 2. in j. hamschmidt & m. pirson (a c. di), case studies in social entrepreneurship and sustainability (1o ed., pagg. 22–30). routledge. https://doi.org/10.4324/9781351278560-5 doherty, b., haugh, h., & lyon, f. (2014). social enterprises as hybrid organisations: a review and research agenda. international journal of management reviews, 16(4), 417–436. elo, s., & kyngäs, h. (2008). the qualitative content analysis process. journal of advanced nursing, 62(1), 107–115. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1365-2648.2007.04569.x falagas, m. e., pitsouni, e. i., malietzis, g. a., & pappas, g. (2007). comparison of pubmed, scopus, web of science, and google scholar: strengths and weaknesses. the faseb journal, 22(2), 338–342. https://doi.org/10.1096/fj.07-9492lsf flick, u., von kardoff, e., & steinke, i. (2004). a companion to qualitative research. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/4915 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 64 galaskiewicz, j., & barringer, s. n. (2012). social enterprises and social categories. in b. gidron & y. hasenfeld (a c. di), social enterprises: an organisational perspective (pagg. 47–70). palgrave macmillan uk. https://doi.org/10.1057/9781137035301_3 galina, s., rebehy, p., carvalho, l., & costa, m. (2013). determinants of attractiveness in social stock exchange. journal of management and sustainability, 3, 157. https://doi.org/10.5539/jms.v3n4p157 lecy, j. d., & beatty, k. e. (2012). representative literature reviews using constrained snowball sampling and citation network analysis (ssrn scholarly paper id 1992601). social science research network. https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.1992601 liberati, a., altman, d. g., tetzlaff, j., mulrow, c., gøtzsche, p. c., ioannidis, j. p. a., clarke, m., devereaux, p. j., kleijnen, j., & moher, d. (2009). the prisma statement for reporting systematic reviews and meta-analyses of studies that evaluate health care interventions: explanation and elaboration. plos medicine, 6(7), e1000100. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pmed.1000100 mair, j. (2010). social entrepreneurship: taking stock and looking ahead. working paper no. wp-888, 1–13. http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.1729642 massaro, m., dumay, j., & guthrie, j. (2016). on the shoulders of giants: undertaking a structured literature review in accounting. accounting auditing & accountability journal, 29(5), 767–801. https://doi.org/10.1108/aaaj-01-2015-193 massaro, maurizio, dumay, j., garlatti, a., & dal mas, f. (2018). practitioners’ views on intellectual capital and sustainability: from a performance-based to a worth-based perspective. journal of intellectual capital, 19(2), 367–386. https://doi.org/10.1108/jic-02-2017-0033 mauksch, s., dey, p., rowe, m., & teasdale, s. (2017). ethnographies of social enterprise. social enterprise journal, 13(02), 114–127. https://doi.org/10.1108/sej-03-2017-0019 mcwade, w. (2012). the role for social enterprises and social investors in the development struggle. journal of social entrepreneurship, 3(1), 96–112. https://doi.org/10.1080/19420676.2012.663783 meeks, k. (2018). ulrichsweb review. journal of electronic resources in medical libraries, 15(1), 26–35. https://doi.org/10.1080/15424065.2018.1432436 mendell, m., & nogales, r. (2009). social enterprises in oecd member countries: what are the financial streams? 89– 138. https://doi.org/10.1787/9789264055513-4-en mongeon, p., & paul-hus, a. (2016). the journal coverage of web of science and scopus: a comparative analysis. scientometrics, 106(1), 213–228. moritz, a., & block, j. h. (2016). crowdfunding: a literature review and research directions. in d. brüntje & o. gajda (a c. di), crowdfunding in europe: state of the art in theory and practice (pagg. 25–53). springer international publishing. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-18017-5_3 paul, j., & criado, a. r. (2020). the art of writing literature review: what do we know and what do we need to know? international business review, 29(4), 101717. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ibusrev.2020.101717 pavlov, r. (2017). social stock exchange as a factor of increasing the innovation potential of social enterprises. in ecie 2017 12th european conference on innovation and entrepreneurship. pavlov, r. (2019). determining the factors which deter the development of social entrepreneurship in russia. european conference on innovation and entrepreneurship. https://doi.org/doi:10.34190/ecie.19.096 romme, a. g. l., avenier, m.-j., denyer, d., hodgkinson, g. p., pandza, k., starkey, k., & worren, n. (2015). towards common ground and trading zones in management research and practice. british journal of management, 26(3), 544–559. https://doi.org/10.1111/1467-8551.12110 secinaro, s., corvo, l., brescia, v., & iannaci, d. (2019). hybrid organisations: a systematic review of the current literature. international business research, 12(11), p1. https://doi.org/10.5539/ibr.v12n11p1 smith, w., gonin, m., besharov, m. (2013). managing social-business tensions: a review and research agenda for social enterprise. business ethics quarterly 23:3, 407–442. sparkes, r. (2001). ethical investment: whose ethics, which investment? business ethics: a european review, 10(3), 194– 205. https://doi.org/10.1111/1467-8608.00233 steiner, a. (2016). the playground of the rich? growing social business in the 21st century. social enterprise journal, 12. https://doi.org/10.1108/sej-12-2015-0036 european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/4915 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 65 wendt, k. (2017). social stock exchanges—democratisation of capital investing for impact. ssrn electronic journal. https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.3021739 5_urmanaviciene european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5487published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 59 challenges of cross-sectoral collaboration of social enterprises in baltic states audrone urmanavičienė 1; katerina chantzi 1; and beverly tambari1 1 school of governance, law and society, social entrepreneurship ma study program, tallinn university corresponding author: audronė urmanavičienėaurmana@tlu.ee received: 30/12/2020 accepted for publication: 14/06/2021 published: 19/07/2021 abstract social enterprises are a new phenomenon in the baltic states. to create a substantial social impact in society and scale their business, social enterprises in baltic states need to create partnerships and collaborate with different sectors. by forming partnerships with different sectors, social enterprises can provide effective solutions to social problems. the aim of this article is to identify the main factors for social enterprises to create successful collaboration and partnerships with private, and public sector organisations. the methods of research are an analysis of scientific literature, social entrepreneurs’ interviews, content analysis. the study also analyzed the main obstacles for social enterprises to collaborate with different sectors. the empirical findings of the study disclosed how to improve partnerships development with private, and public sectors. following the theoretical and empirical research, the article suggests possible means of improving and developing partnerships. keywords: social enterprise, cross-sector collaboration, private sector partnerships, public sector partnerships 1. introduction in 2011, european commission launched the social business initiative that aims to introduce a short-term action plan to support the development of social enterprises, key stakeholders in the social economy and social innovation focusing on helping social enterprises to obtain funding, increase their visibility and make the legal environment friendlier for social enterprises. however, the different traditions, public policies, legal and institutional frameworks that each member of european union follows for its interior affairs, do not promote the visibility of social enterprises. it is also quite common that even social enterprises do not identify themselves as so. considering the country reports, it seems that since 2014, social enterprises gain more visibility and have grown in numbers (european commision, 2020). specifically, the social enterprise sector in baltic states is very young and is still in the stage of development. there are currently about 120-180 social enterprises in latvia (oborenko, rivza, zivitere, 2018), in estonia about 125 (reimann, 2019), in lithuania it is indicated that such enterprises, which have the status by law of a social enterprise, are 186 (pranskeviciute, okuneviciute nevarauskiene, 2018). these enterprises usually are small and medium-size enterprises, which lack resources (urmanavičienė, raišienė, 2017, urmanaviciene, 2020). for social enterprises as young companies, cross-sectoral cooperation is particularly important as it can help to mobilize resources, gain complementary capabilities, and capture synergies in order to grow and increase the social impact they generate (schirmer, cameron, 2012). collaboration with private and public sector organizations can provide access to the financial and other resources needed for sustainable growth of this young sector. partnerships with the ngo sector give the opportunity to social enterprises to widen their network, build trust and scale their social impact that can benefit the european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5487published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 60 organisations involved and the society. as most social enterprises originate from the ngo sector in the baltic states (safege, 2020), the collaboration between social enterprises and ngos as part of social enterprises’ cross sectoral collaboration will not be part of the scope of the study. collaboration with different sector organizations also help to generate new ideas, feasibility and design thinking. however, social entrepreneurs do not sufficiently exploit opportunities for cross-sector cooperation and struggle to establish and maintain a collaboration. scholars are seeking to understand and theorize social enterprise collaborations (schirmer, cameron, 2012, sakarya, bodur, yildirim-öktem, selekler-göksen, 2012, fu, 2019, weber, haugh, göbel & leonardy, 2021). however, in the baltics, the social enterprises scientific findings started arising after 2014 (european commission, 2018). researchers of the baltic states in the field of social enterprises focus mostly on the concept and social business models (urmanavičienė, 2019), which is why there is a significant lack of research of partnerships in the baltic states. this paper aims to fill the gap in literature by answering the following research questions: -which main challenges do social enterprises face when establishing collaborations with the private and public sector in the baltic states? -what are the benefits of collaborating with the private and public sector for the social enterprise and the private and public organisation respectively from the perspective of the social entrepreneurs? -what are the best practices for establishing and maintaining successful collaborations according to social entrepreneurs in the baltics? the methods of research are an analysis of scientific literature, social entrepreneurs interviews, content analysis. this paper is organized as follows: the first section with the title “cross sector collaboration between social enterprises and private sector” will present the literature analysis regarding the collaboration between social enterprises and private sector. the second section with title “cross sector collaboration between social enterprises and public sector” refers to the theoretical framework of cross sector collaboration between social enterprises and public sector. the third section of this paper will describe methodology adopted by the researchers, the characteristics of the sample and the data collection methodology. additionally, the following section will reveal the main results of study. finally, the last section will present discussion and conclude the paper”. 1.1 cross-sectoral collaboration between social enterprises and private sector cross-sector collaboration assists in bringing solutions to address complex challenges as various actors with different perspectives collaborate. barth et al. (2018) identifies the variety of cross-sector collaborations between social enterprises and different sectors (private, public, and so-called third sector) in europe by presenting case studies. from the cases presented, social enterprises can collaborate with private sector organizations in many ways. private sector can establish collaborations with social enterprises by offering funding, as infrastructure partners, shareholders, philanthropic investors, delivery partners and beneficiaries, investors building knowledge and providing support and help for interventions. the collaboration between social enterprises and the private sector is oriented mainly around mutual benefit. by collaborating with the private sector, social enterprises can benefit from the scale, the expertise in manufacturing and operations, financing (volkmann & tokarski, 2012) as well as in scalable and sustainable development (reporter, 2012). also, their collaboration offers access to finance and capital for specific projects and developments. so, collaboration enables some social enterprises to maximize their chances of obtaining financial resources by combining their social purpose with a private sector partner’s business skill. working collaborations with private sector partners can be a catalyst for change, providing the means for social enterprises to grow, restructure or reshape themselves going forward as the private sector enables prompt change. collaboration with the private sector, strengthen the social enterprises’ market position by making them more competitive in the market, build up their network, as social enterprises are searching and planning to create further partnerships to create new revenue streams and improve their scale as well as attract management commitment and advice from their commercial partners. having improved cash flow is an advantage and for that reason social enterprises set up contracts with the private sector to provide greater flexibility to forward, plan and underpin the sustainability of their businesses. many of these collaborations involve either fixed-term contracts, fixed-price contracts, or both. working with commercial partners encourages greater business involvement and investment in the local community (can, 2005) as the capital flows are invested in the development and improvement of the local community by supporting social enterprises to have an impact in the community by solving current social problems. it brings together stakeholders, raises awareness and provides opportunities for further european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5487published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 61 involvement and participation in the community. a great example that proves the impact that a collaboration with the private sector can benefit the social enterprise, is the case of generationsbrücke bridging generations (hereinafter referred to as gbd) in germany. their mission is to connect young children with the growing elderly population in nursing homes to promote social inclusion for the elderly while creating awareness for young children on the challenges of current and future demographic changes. by establishing a partnership with bmw foundation and the german caritas, gbd developed benefits in terms of increased outreach, visibility, and access to networks. drawing on the networks of its partner institutions was the multiplier that gbd needed to grow its intervention quickly. with the initial help of the bmw foundation, gbd started building a partnership with the german federal ministry for family affairs, which is one of their main financing partners. gbd has since then experienced significant growth and adoption throughout germany. to date, gbd has successfully established 75 partnerships in which approximately 4,000 children and eldercare institutions are engaged. at the same time, it continued and established partnerships with many important german players (barth et al. (2018). besides social enterprises, the private sector businesses gain great benefits by establishing cross-sector collaborations with social enterprises. through collaboration with social enterprises, corporations can have access to markets and supply lines, that without the local know-how and deep understanding of customer’s needs wouldn’t be easy to enter. corporations benefit as they offer their staff a greater sense of useful engagement such as contributing their skills to problems in their own community and increasing their reputation in society. establishing collaborations with social enterprises is a great way for corporations to engage corporate social responsibility initiatives as corporations are called to take action to prevent or mitigate the negative impact that may be caused by their operations (seferian, 2019). pepsico for example, supports e-coins in costa rica, a virtual e-currency that gives value to sustainability. it is granted in exchange for recoverable waste that is taken to recycle through a system of incentives that can be exchanged for discounts on products and services of participating businesses (e-coins). even though pepsico is listed among the top global polluters (greenpeace philippines, 2019), by supporting eco-sustainable projects they mitigate the negative impact that they cause by their operation and make a positive impact in the communities. furthermore, it enables them to form a strategic alliance with a social enterprise partner who can ‘speak the language’ of the market or communities they are trying to reach and offers potential csr spin-offs (can, 2005). the problems that a social enterprise tackles affect the society as a whole and the environment and can benefit not only the beneficiaries but also the corporations that support these initiatives, as by tackling some of these social or environmental issues, their customer base will grow, and they will be able to lead them to their commercial mission by providing them their services or products (seferian, 2019). for instance, pwc in netherlands, has launched the social impact lab – an annual challenge for start-ups with a social or environmental mission. 100weeks, a social enterprise that fights against extreme poverty in africa by supporting women with microfinancing services, using an innovative technology and data-based business model, has won the pwc netherlands social impact lab award in 2016 and pwc pledged to support them for 24 months by offering their expertise. pwc offered numerous hours of professional services to 100weeks across the service lines of core audit, accounting advice, financial consulting, deals, digital, legal and tax (pricewaterhousecoopers, 2019). as with every collaboration and partnership, the relationship between social enterprises and private sector involves potential risks and challenges. social entrepreneurs should examine each collaboration with potential private sector partners by the criteria “cost and benefit” as they invest substantial time, energy, and resources into establishing relationships, which at the end do not necessarily contribute to creating social impact or to scaling a social innovation. the cost of maintaining the partnership must be analysed accurately. furthermore, for social enterprises, the social aims are primacy and collaboration with private sector partners should be assured that it won’t compromise the organisation’s social purpose. the comparability of the values of the involved organizations influences the success of a collaboration as well as the communication style should be compatible and not lead to misunderstandings that can affect the outcomes of the collaboration (can, 2005). there is always the risk that the other organization is using the know-how for its own gain; for example, using information of beneficiaries to market additional services or products which are not part of a collaboration. in order to achieve a successful partnership with the private sector, the social entrepreneur should be aware of cultural differences and ensure the outcomes of the collaboration by written agreements with defined deadlines and deliverables, including clear expectation management. in order to gain any business confidence, the social entrepreneur should be able to speak a business language and present a professional image (can, 2005). business leaders said the social enterprises most able to pitch a clear, concise and persuasive business case were the social enterprises with whom they would most readily partner (volkmann & tokarski, 2012). european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5487published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 62 cross-sector collaboration between social enterprises and private sector enterprises provides mutual benefit to the organisations involved as they work in a complementary way. in other words, social enterprises benefit from the expertise, the networking, and the finance that corporations and private sector can offer to them, to achieve their social mission easier than if they were acting individually. similarly, the private sector benefits from the knowledge regarding customer needs, access new markets where the corporation language does not apply and needs different treatment and facilitates the corporations to give back to the society by promoting csr policies. as in every collaboration, so that in cross-sector collaboration there are potential risks and challenges. the stakeholders have different goals and expectations from the collaboration they are establishing, and it should be clear why they are collaborating and what should be the outcomes for each side. the collaboration should be evaluated according to the balance between cost and benefit to identify if the collaboration is worth establishing and the expectations should be clear from the beginning so neither the social aim from the social enterprise’s side, nor the profits and the status from the private sector’s side will be harmed. 1.2 cross-sectoral collaboration between social enterprises and public sector cross sector collaboration between social enterprises and the public sector aims to solve social issues. the collaboration between social enterprises and the public sector is characterized by a mutual goal to provide goods or services (public sector) and to solve a social issue within the state or municipality (social enterprise). social enterprises' main goal is to make a social impact however, they need partnerships or collaborations to facilitate the actualization of their goals. establishing collaboration with the public sector is a gradual process with certain prerequisites the social enterprise must follow. this chapter analyzes the forms of collaboration between social enterprises and the public sector and the tools of collaboration such as public procurements, contractual agreements and delegation agreements. and the challenges associated with establishing collaboration with the public sector and the benefits of the collaboration. social enterprises contribute to economic growth and the growth of the european economy is dependent on its “ability to support the growth of enterprises” (bovis, 2015). collaboration between the social enterprise and the public sector can be in the form of long term contractual agreement. the social enterprise and the public sector share resources and risks proportionately (volkmann & tokarski, 2012). the basis for establishing contractual agreement is to provide better services for the citizens and individuals in certain social groups. the social enterprise and public sector can also collaborate even if there is no mutual interest directly related to a particular social issue the public sector would have it’s goals to achieve and the social enterprise would have their goals to achieve (volkmann & tokarski, 2012). an example of this kind of collaboration exists with discovering hands and the public health insurance company (volkmann & tokarski, 2012). discovering hands is an organization located in germany that creates social impact by providing services that contribute to the early detection of breast cancer. they collaborate with public health insurance companies by contractual agreement. the terms of the collaboration require that the public health insurance company covers the bills of the clients registered with the insurance company at a cheap rate, encouraging more women to get access to quality service at low cost. the benefit for the public health insurance company is they are able to acquire more customers to register for their service. social enterprises can also be owned by the public sector. when the social enterprise is owned by the government, the government recruits the services of the social enterprise for any project that will be carried out. such social enterprise usually gets first consideration when services are required. however, the government owned social enterprise can form some partnerships with either the private sector or the third sector depending on the project or service that is needed. government owned social enterprises are also referred to as state owned enterprises. these enterprises are under significant sector of the municipality and contribute to the economy of the state or country examples are electricity providing organisations which are responsible for train/ railway services within the municipality. social enterprise and the public sector initiate and establish collaboration by public procurement. public procurement is the process of purchasing goods or services between the public sector and social enterprises. the government makes provision regarding public procurements in their national budget. in the national budgets, public procurements account for an important share of national budgets (oecd/eu, 2019). public procurement is a means of revenue generation for social enterprises that european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5487published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 63 have a goal for making social impact and provide services in a cost-efficient manner (oecd/eu, 2019). public procurement is regulated by state laws and policy. the laws regulate the actions of municipalities (bovis, 2015). in germany, public procurement is acquired by social enterprises through the process of bidding. the body in charge are referred to as contracting authorities which are required to “split contracts” to smaller sub-contracts to allow smes bid for a position (bovis, 2015). the procurement process is orientated on mutual benefit for the social enterprise and the public sector. the public sector solves a social issue, and the social enterprise generates revenue. social enterprises have an edge over the public sector in relation to having access and full knowledge of some of the social issues individuals are facing within a society. with this knowledge they can create and render services that are innovative and efficient to solve these social issues. the public sector purchases the innovative products that are made available by the social enterprise to solve social issues through the procurement process. the financial resources acquired through the public sector purchase is used to keep the social enterprise financially sustainable and also the social enterprise can grow their market and customer base and generate more revenue. social enterprises establish collaboration with the public sector by bidding for government contracts for the purpose of executing specific projects. the contracts are made available by the public sector however, getting the right to execute the project attached to the contract requires the process of bidding. bidding for a contract by a social enterprise means that several social enterprises put in an application(bid) to be picked for collaboration and project execution within a country or specific municipality. contracts for the purpose of collaboration are done in accordance with the public procurement procedures within a state or under the requirements or directives put in place by the european union directive for contracting authorities and public institutions. contracts are usually issued or approved by a contracting authority to social enterprises. social enterprises seeking contracts have to go through the bidding process, the outcome could be that the contract could be given to a particular social enterprise for execution, or it can be split into several sub-contracts and divided among the bidders (trybus & andrecka, 2017). contractual relationships between the public sector and social enterprises can either be vertical or horizontal (lyon, 2009). lyon explains that vertical form exists between the commissioners of the contract and the enterprise that delivers the goods and services, and the horizontal exists between the two parties providing the service (lyon, 2009). furthermore, lyon (2009) identifies the two kinds of contractual agreements that exist between the public sector and a social enterprise. the contracts could be informal with no legally binding agreement. or could be formal with a legally binding agreement based on the european union procurement rules. the public sector and social enterprises contractual agreement benefit social enterprises because, when social enterprises are able to acquire long term contracts to render services to the public sector, financial revenue is constantly generated for the social enterprise. also, long term collaboration with the public sector improves the image and validity of the social enterprise. increased validity creates legitimacy and more opportunities for investors and funding for the social enterprise. with any collaboration, the partnership between social enterprises and the public sector has challenges. the challenges related to obtaining public procurement for social enterprises are lack of clarity concerning a public service (oecd/eu, 2019). the challenge with clarity is due to a lack of legal framework and policies that give legitimacy to social enterprises and the service they provide (reimann, 2019). when there is lack of recognition in a state for a new social enterprise, the public sector or potential collaborator may find it difficult to fully understand their purpose and what kind of service the social enterprises claim to provide. additionally, the smaller the social enterprise the lower the possibility of winning a bid for a contract compared to a higher more recognized social enterprise. also, social enterprises face challenges with contracting authorities. contracting authorities not recruiting the services of small and new social enterprises (oecd/eu, 2019). contracts awarded to the small social enterprises compared to the high enterprises are relatively low. (oecd/eu, 2019), therefore this creates an imbalance as most of the contracting is directed towards larger more established social enterprises. social enterprises also face the challenge of the possibility of contract termination from the contracting authority due to non-compliance to the clauses that are stipulated in the contract document (oecd/eu, 2019). the clause may be passed into the procurement specifications by the municipality. social enterprises need to take into consideration the clauses when bidding for a contract or rendering services through the procurement process. when the clauses are not met the process of collaboration and rendering of service to the public sector can be terminated. the termination can result in a loss of revenue for the social enterprise. the clauses are criteria for defining the nature of the product or service required by the public sector. an example is the specification of the individuals or groups that the product or service is directed at certain social groups (oecd/eu, 2019). when the social enterprises bidding for a contract to establish collaboration with the public sector meet the requirements and follow the guidelines for the clauses provided then they can proceed to bid. an agreement made by the social enterprises and european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5487published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 64 the public sector to collaborate is referred to as a service agreement or a delegation agreement. service agreement means that the social enterprise has a contract to carry out a particular project or provide a particular service based on what is required by the municipality for the recipients at a particular time. the second form of agreement is the delegation agreement. a delegation agreement between the social enterprise and the public sector means that and the social enterprise has a longer-term agreement to provide long term service to a particular area or particular recipients. cross-sector collaboration between the public sector and social enterprises provides mutual benefit to the public sector and to the social enterprise. social enterprises gain financial benefit from the public procurement process when the public sector purchases the goods and services they render. and the public sector benefits from the collaboration by having access to innovative service and ideas that can be used to meet social issues and improve legitimacy and trust with the recipients of the service. also, the collaborative process enables the social enterprise to achieve their goals and vision which is social impact. cross sectoral collaboration with the public sector has potential challenges for social enterprise. challenges such as lack legitimacy despite the services they provide. new social enterprises face the legitimacy challenge as the service they provide may not be viewed as relevant or beneficial. as a result, the challenge of being overlooked when contracts are awarded for project execution occurs. also challenges related to loss of revenue due to contract termination. a social enterprise that has been allocated a contract to execute a project through collaboration with the public sector has to follow the regulations binding the contract. non-compliance results in collaboration being terminated and difficulty regaining the trust of the public sector for future collaborations. the collaboration with the public sector will create opportunities for social enterprises to expand and grow while creating and offering solutions to societal issues. 2. methodology the aim of this research is to identify the main factors for social enterprises to create successful collaboration and partnerships with private, and public sectors by focusing on the challenges that social enterprises face in their collaboration with the private and public sector. to answer these questions, a qualitative research approach was followed. qualitative research was considered as suitable for the research as it focuses on the exploration and the understanding of the meaning that individuals ascribe to a certain problem (creswell, 2014). furthermore, a qualitative research approach facilitates inductive analysis that allows to focus on the meaning that the participants give to their experience, interpret their insights, and reach general conclusions from particulars (creswell, 2014). for this research, semi-structured qualitative interviews have been used via videoconferencing. qualitative interviews is a tool that elicits views and opinions from the participants (creswell, 2014) and seeks for meaning of central themes of the subjects’ lived world. in addition, it gives the possibility to the researcher to register and interpret the meaning not only of what is said, but also in the way that is said and register the reactions of the subjects. 2.1 sampling and data collection the paper is built on the analysis of scientific literature regarding the benefits and the challenges that cross-sectoral collaboration between social enterprises with private, public and third sector has and an empirical analysis of social entrepreneurs in baltic states. the study was conducted by using a sample of estonian, latvian, and lithuanian social enterprises as baltic states are the focus of this research. semi-structured interviews with social enterprises’ representatives were conducted to identify the differences between the three countries and the social enterprises’ cross-sectoral collaboration. the social enterprises’ representatives were invited to discuss about: • their collaboration with private, public (the motives that led them to establish collaboration with the specific sector, the benefits that they gain by collaborating with this sector, their strategic partners, and the most important partners they have from this sector, the goal of the collaboration and the initiators of this collaboration) • challenges for establishing and maintaining the collaboration with private, public or third sector (what they had to invest to establish/maintain the collaboration, what were the challenges that they had to overcome to establish a collaboration, if they were any obstacles that prevented them from having a successful collaboration or partnership with the private, public or third sector. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5487published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 65 • best practices and recommendations for young social entrepreneurs that will help social entrepreneurs to establish successful partnerships with the private/public/third sector. a total of 7 experts were interviewed, 4 of them with 20 to 40 minutes interviews via video conferencing and 3 of them conducted via email communication. table 1 gives more information about the interviewees. most of the social enterprises interviewed have past and active projects in more than one sector. however, we have focused only in one sector to be analysed per interview. the selection of the enterprises was done with the following criteria: • the social enterprises fulfil the prerequisites that the european commission social enterprise definition has “social enterprises are those type of businesses that the social or societal objective of the common good is the reason for the commercial activity, often in the form of a high level of social innovation, those whose profits are mainly reinvested to achieve this social objective and those where the method of organization or the ownership system reflects the enterprise's mission, using democratic or participatory principles or focusing on social justice“. • are part of their national social enterprise network. • have at least one cross-sectoral collaboration either with private, public or third sector. table 1: description of companies that participate in the research company’s name interviewee’s name position held in the company countr y crosssectoral collaboration found ed in edumus maria rahamägi ceo estonia private sector 2018 tagasi kooli teibi torm ceo estonia private sector 2012 visas iespējas gustavs mārtiņš upmanis ceo latvia private sector 2018 miesto laboratorija goda sosnovskiene ceo/ manager lithuani a private sector 2015 samaritan association of latvia andris berzins ceo/ manager latvia public sector 1992 communicare norman vester ceo estonia public sector 2019 socialinis taksi solveiga ratkevičiūtė ceo lithuani a public sector 2013 source: authors’ elaboration. (all the interviews were recorded with permission and subsequently transcribed for data analysis) european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5487published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 66 3. empirical findings the aim of the study is to find out the main challenges that social enterprises face to establish collaborations with the private and public sectors and the benefits of collaborating with them and to reveal the best practices for establishing a successful collaboration in the baltic states. firstly, the study presents findings about se partnerships with the private sector. secondly, findings about se partnerships with the public sector. finally, the study will provide the discussion based on the empirical findings 3.1 cross-sectoral collaboration between social enterprises and the private sector the collaboration between the private sector and social enterprises differs from country to country regarding the form of cooperation and the reasons that both parties come to an agreement to collaborate. in every form of collaboration, there are challenges for the social entrepreneur that can be classified in three different stages: • challenges prior to the collaboration; • challenges in the initial stage of the collaboration • challenges for maintaining the collaboration. the following table 2, describes the ways in which social enterprises collaborate with the private sector per country, the establishing factors that led to this collaboration for both parties as well as the challenges that the social entrepreneur faces in the 3 stages (prior to the collaboration, during the initial stage of the collaboration and challenges that he/she faces during the collaboration for maintaining it). table 2: empirical findings for the collaboration between social enterprises and private sector social enterprise forms of cooperation establishing factors challenges estonia edumus financial support and human resources. private company: -support an initiative that will benefit the social enterprise, their organisation and the society as a whole -increase the employees’ engagement level in society. social enterprise: funds. -human resources. -free marketing. prior: -find the right partners to establish collaboration to meet the social enterprise’s needs and goals. -ensure that the company will be financially sustainable in the near future and will not be constantly asking for financial support. maintaining stage: -keep them interested and encourage them to continue further with the project. -provide reports about what has been done and what is going to happen in the future. -keep reminding the benefits of the collaboration. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5487published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 67 estonia tagasi kooli strategic partnership based on financial support (but also marketing, communication support, legal support, usage of company’s resources e.g. buildings or advertisement spots). private company: -communication. -employees involvement and engagement. -contribution to the society. social enterprise: -funds. -human resources. -legal and communication support. -marketing support. -advertisement. prior: -find partners that address the topic in their agenda and scr policies. -get in contact with someone from the communication or scr department to test if the goals are matching. -get in contact with people who are on the boards as they are decision makers. -make a concrete, clear and interesting offer to them. -have established prior collaboration with the public or third sector to ensure trust. initial stage: -devote time and effort to gain trust. maintaining stage: -keep them involved, interested and informed. latvia visas iespējas provide services to companies, corporations and private organisations. and establish a relationship “business as usual” with them, as a service provider (social enterprise) and a client (private company). private company: socially beneficial image and marketing bonuses as they communicate the message locally and globally that they support social enterprises. social enterprise: credibility. -legitimacy. -marketing. prior: -get as much recognition as possible from other organisations (public or third sector) so that the social enterprise can use it in its marketing communication. -place the societal cause as a baseline for the collaboration. -invest time to talk with different companies and establish yourself in the environment. lithuania miesto laboratorija providing expertise, skills or products without asking something in return (this mostly happens in collaborations with small companies that private company: contribution to the local society by helping a local cause. social enterprise: prior: -make research in advance to find companies that match with the social enterprise’s goals. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5487published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 68 the owners can easily make personal decisions compared with big companies). -resources that are needed. -make a proposal that will be interesting and beneficial for both parties. initial stage: -be responsive and responsible in communication to ensure trust. maintaining stage: -being responsible and holding a good collaboration for the future deals that may come up for other social enterprises in the future. source: authors’ elaboration the key findings of the study regarding the challenges that the social entrepreneur needs to overcome can be divided in three chronicle stages: before establishing the collaboration, the initial stage of the collaboration and the continuance of the collaboration. before establishing the collaboration, the social entrepreneur needs to make a research and find those companies that are meeting his/her goals and create a proposal for them that would be interesting and beneficial for both sides. it is important to identify what motivates the potential partner to work with them. there are organisations that have certain corporate social responsibility agenda and focus on specific goals and would like to increase their positive impact in certain areas, organisations that focus on the social enterprises’ societal goal and do not seek to gain anything additional, just only to help them in their goal and organisations that look for long term partnerships and prefer to maintain a client-customer relationship. especially, in cases when the social entrepreneur asks for financial support, the offer needs to be very concrete and clear, time based and offer to the company something more than just communication. social enterprises receive a variety of different benefits from the private sector according to their demands. their benefits can be either financial support, access to expertise (lawyers, marketers, communicators) and human resources (people that volunteer from the company), products (supplies that they need for a certain goal) or even access resources of the company (offer free usage of company’s space to place social enterprise’s advertisements). apart from the importance of the proposal from the social entrepreneur’s side and the type of assistance he/she asks for, it is quite crucial to communicate and approach people who have decision making power in the organisation, so they can easily communicate their goal, their proposal and their request for collaboration and get clear answers. it was underlined that prior collaboration with ngos, public organisations can help the social entrepreneur to make a successful collaboration with the private sector as it gives recognition, validity, and credibility to the social enterprise. also, an established collaboration between private sector and social enterprise, gives credibility and legitimacy to the social enterprise and can be beneficial for the scalability of the enterprise. for initiating but also continuing the collaboration, the social entrepreneur needs to look and be trustworthy and maintain reliable communication and be responsible for the tasks that he/she needs to deliver to gain their trust and have a smooth collaboration. especially in the initial stage, the social entrepreneur needs to invest time and effort to report everything to the company regarding financing, planning, and project management. as the time passes and the trust is gradually gained, it is important to keep the interest up the motivation of the company to be involved and informed about the social enterprise’s progress. analysing the differences between the three countries and the social enterprise ecosystem, it can be concluded that each country presents some differences regarding the reasons that lead them to establish collaboration with the private sector and simultaneously the challenges that they face. specifically, in estonia, social enterprises seek to build collaborations with the european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5487published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 69 private sector to access capital and expertise and the main challenges that they face towards this, is how to make a clear proposal that helps them achieve their goal and be attractive for their partner and how they can maintain the collaborations. in latvia, social enterprises seek for scalability, legitimacy and validity from the private sector and their main challenge is how to help their partners to access markets and supply lines, that without the social enterprises’ know-how and deep understanding of customer’s needs wouldn’t be easy to enter. in lithuania, social entrepreneurs’ main challenge is how to create mutually beneficial collaborations, as mainly their collaboration with the private sector is characterized by philanthropic investments or services based on expertise or products instead of funding. to conclude, the social entrepreneurs recommend to the upcoming and fellow social entrepreneurs to invest their time and effort to search for partners from the private sector and seek for those organisations that fits their needs and match their goals. they need to make a clear and structured proposal that is based on mutual benefit and present it to people with decision making power within the organisation. furthermore, they need to invest time and effort to gain their trust and it is highly recommended to have prior recommendations from ngos and public authorities that previously have worked with. once the collaboration starts, the social entrepreneur needs to maintain the communication with the private sector company and encourage them and motivate them to stay informed about the social enterprise and its achievements. as social entrepreneurship is a quite recent sector, to gain more recognition and establish itself in the market, each social entrepreneur should act keeping in mind that he/she represents the whole social enterprise ecosystem and one bad experience from one organisation can cause a negative answer for collaboration for another social enterprise in the future. 3.2 cross-sectoral collaboration between social enterprises and the public sector the collaboration between the public sector and social enterprises occurs in stages. the collaboration is based on establishing factors that the public sector and social enterprise take into consideration before collaborating. the collaborative stages present some challenges for the social enterprises and the challenges can be divided into three stages. the stage prior to collaboration with the public sector, the initial stages of public sector and social enterprise collaboration, and the third stage the maintaining stage after collaboration has been established. table 3: empirical findings for the collaboration between social enterprises and public sector. social enterprise forms of cooperation establishing factors challenges estonia communicare -providing services based on long term contract basis. public sector: -providing support for a particular social group within the municipality. social enterprise: -funding and long term partnership through contracts. prior: -making research to find key stakeholders in the public sector for the purpose of collaboration. initial-stage: -time spent building trust and legitimacy with the public sector. maintaining-stage: maintaining trust, continuous communication to ensure european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5487published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 70 continuous long term collaboration. latvia latvijas samariesu apvieniba -providing services through delegation agreements and contracts. public sector -co-operation with social enterprises to solve social problems within the municipality. social enterprise -social impact. funding. prior stage; competition between social enterprises to acquire contracts. maintaining-stage; creating delegation agreements to continue to provide services on a long term contract basis. lithuania social taksi -selling services to the public sector. public sector -solving the problem associated with a particular social group. social enterprise -funding. -creating social impact through collaboration with the public sector. prior: -establishing contact with the public sector. -convincing the potential partners on the importance of the service being offered. maintaining-stage: competition against local organizations. convincing the public sector on the relevance of continuous funding through purchasing services. changes in the political spectrum may affect collaboration. source: authors’ elaboration. the findings of the empirical research show that each social enterprise presents differences regarding the reasons for establishing and maintaining collaboration with the public sector and the challenges that they face. in latvia the main challenge is competition. competition exists between social enterprises bidding for the procurement process to establish collaboration with the public sector. in estonia, the main challenge is time invested in the process of identifying the key stakeholders in the public sector for collaboration and making a proposal on the services they provide and why the service is needed to the public sector. in lithuania, the main challenge is proving validity. there is a lack of validation from the public sector when there is a european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5487published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 71 change in the political spectrum, due to the possibility the importance or need for the services provided by the social enterprise is deemed non-essential. social enterprises are an essential part of the economic growth of any country in which they exist. the older the social enterprise, the better chances of establishing collaboration. as a result, the owners are able to provide recommendations for new social enterprises that intend to establish collaboration. the ceo latvijas samariesu apvieniba (lv) suggests that when a social enterprise is new, the one of the main goals should be not to lose focus of their social aim and social idea or place emphasis only on marketing their products and services. social enterprise should function in a manner that shows balance. when there is a balance between achieving social impact and establishing collaboration through providing goods and services to the public sector social enterprises are more successful. also, with the challenges that social enterprises encounter with collaboration, social enterprises must remain optimistic and work with each other under the social enterprise network. as a new social enterprise, it is important to be registered under the social enterprise network established within the state/country. registration enables small social enterprises to acquire recognition and legitimacy from the public sector therefore increasing the opportunities to establish collaboration. collaboration with the public sector for social enterprises takes time to establish. the ceo/ owner communicare (est) suggests consistent and continuous marketing for new social enterprises. social enterprises should make use of all forms of advertising including social media, the importance of this form of brand marketing is to increase visibility. the public sector before making a final decision to collaborate with a social enterprise that is new is conducting background checks to see what services/ project have been executed successfully. making this information available online increases the possibility of establishing collaboration with the public sector also the managers and ceos of new social enterprises need to grow their network with key individuals within the municipality, creating a network of significant individuals increases the possibility of being recommended to the public sector when there is a need for a particular service or product. in the baltic states (estonia, latvia and lithuania) there is an organized social enterprise body that advocates and promotes the needs and the importance of social enterprises in solving problems within the state. however, a small social enterprise needs to put in the extra effort and time to be able to establish partnership with the public sector and be taken seriously. 4. discussion and conclusion cross sector collaboration for social enterprises with the private and public sector is a means for development for social enterprises as it allows them to scale their social impact and be economically sufficient. with the support of their partners, social enterprises can create effective solutions to the social problems they are addressing and contribute positively to the economic and social development of the local society. especially in the baltic states, that social entrepreneurship is a relatively new field, establishing cross collaboration with the private and the public sector is a driver for development, improvement, success, and business establishment for social enterprises. it is revealed that social enterprises cross collaboration is a form of collaboration that benefits equally both parties regardless the type of organisation (public, private). specifically, while collaborating with the private sector, social enterprises get access to financial resources, networks, expertise, gain credibility and legitimacy and it is a great way for them to market themselves and their services/products. on the other hand, as social corporate responsibility, sustainable development, and contribution to the local society become more and more popular among corporations and small and medium enterprises, the collaboration with social enterprises gives the opportunity to the private sector to contribute to the development of the local society, to increase its social image and reputation and engage its employees to take action and contribute positively to the development of the society. similarly, while collaborating with the public sector, social enterprises get access to funding, and it is a great opportunity for them to scale their social impact. also, the collaboration with the public sector is characterized by long term agreements that allow the social enterprises to sustain financially and organise their activities and resources without being insecure about having insufficient funds to operate, the financial security allows them to focus on their main activities and scaling their social impact. despite social enterprises, the public institutions benefit from their collaboration with social enterprises as they can provide to their citizens quality services and products and solve the problems that occur in their local community. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5487published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 72 despite the differences that the private and public sector may have in their organisational structure and operational functions, social enterprises seem to face similar challenges to establish and to maintain collaborations with any of the two sectors. the evidence from this study suggests that there are 3 different types of challenges that the social enterprises face to establish and maintain their collaboration with the private and public sector according to time criterion: prior to collaboration, initial stage of collaboration, and during the collaboration (maintaining stage). the study found that in the prior stage, social entrepreneurs face difficulties to identify the key contacts within the organisations (private or public) to start the collaboration. the competition is quite high, as there are many other providers and stronger competitors, so that social enterprises need to offer something that the others do not offer and to know the organisations’ needs, values and their social aims and interests. when the collaboration has officially started, the social entrepreneur faces different types of challenges regulated with spending time and efforts to ensure and gain the collaborator’s trust through frequent communication and detailed and analytical reports. despite the value that trust has at first place, it needs to be maintained and developed throughout the collaboration so that it can be further extended once their type of collaboration officially ends. the social entrepreneur needs to keep the collaborators involved and informed so that they will not lose interest, they can maintain their professional relationship and extend it if required regardless of the existing competition. from empirical research, interviewees gave their insights and suggestions of best practices for social entrepreneurs that can apply in these 3 stages so that they can enhance their results and establish successful and meaningful collaborations with the private and public sector. following again the scheme of the three stages, social entrepreneurs need prior to collaboration to find key persons within the organisations that have decision making power, and make to them a clear, interesting, and mutually beneficial proposal considering the organisations’ needs and goals without compromising their societal goal. one key aspect regarding this stage is to pitch the proposal to the organisations’ decision makers. interestingly, prior collaboration with the public sector (or third sector) gives trustworthiness and credibility to the social enterprise to establish collaboration with the private sector, as well as prior collaboration with the private sector gives a competitive advantage for a successful collaboration with the public sector, as it gives credibility and legitimacy regarding their operations. prior collaborations show professionalism, trustworthiness, network, and credibility to the social enterprise, increasing the possibilities of a successful deal. this practice confirms the importance that cross sector collaboration has for social enterprises and how the correlation between the two sectors can be beneficial for the success of the social enterprise’s upcoming collaborations. furthermore, in the initial stage of the collaboration, by devoting time and effort to communicate, be responsible and responsible while communicating, engage and involve their collaborators and keep reminding them the benefits of their collaboration and build a trustworthy relationship that can allow them to maintain and extend their collaboration further (third stage). as the director of miesto laboratorija, goda sosnovskiene, mentioned in her interview, “i am not just responsible for my enterprise but for the future deals for them (partners) as well. it is very important for social enterprises to understand that if you will do the deal fine, then other social enterprises will approach this company that it is more likely that they will have a positive answer and potential collaboration. you are doing a deal and you are responsible not only for yourself but also for the future”. that is a fundamental aspect that social entrepreneurs should take into consideration while searching for potential partners that they need to act responsibly and that with every collaboration and contact they represent the whole social enterprise ecosystem and by making successful deals, they facilitate the growth of social entrepreneurship and strengthen the cross-sector collaboration which is crucial for the development of this field. the evidence from the study suggests that there are no significant differences on the challenges that social enterprises face to establish collaboration with the private sector or public in baltic countries. however, it is important to highlight that in estonia and lithuania, social enterprises are more dependent on the changes that happen in the political spectrum, as they need to re-submit their offers and start the collaboration from the beginning if there are changes in the government. this study has gone some way towards enhancing understanding of the challenges that social enterprises face to establish and to maintain cross sector collaboration with the private and public sector and to reveal some practices that can help social entrepreneurs have adopted to overcome them. the study findings might be useful for any social enterprise that aims to overcome the obstacles they face and enhance their current and future collaborations. the methodological choices were constrained by limited sample size, but empirical research results are promising and should be validated by a larger sample size and even beyond the regional limits. it is beyond the scope of this research to analyse the challenges that social enterprises face to establish and to maintain cross sector collaboration with the third sector, but it can be considered as a very important aspect of cross sector collaboration for future research to have a better understanding of how social enterprises operate with each sector and provide social entrepreneurs with a toolkit of best practices that will allow them to increase their social impact. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5487published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 73 references alter, k. (2007). social enterprise typology. virtue ventures llc. retrieved march 25, 2021 from https://www.academia.edu/5249856/social_enterprise_typology_updated_november_27_2007_kim_alter_virtue_ven tures_llc alter, s.k. (2006). "social enterprise models and their mission and money relationships", in nicholls, a. (ed.), social entrepreneurship. new models of sustainable social change, oxford university press, oxford, pp. 205-232 barth, b., c. f. (2018). cross-sector collaboration for better social outcomes. berlin: european venture philanthropy association bovis, c. (2015). european procurement & public private partnership law review (editorial: building social value in public procurement) (no. 4 (2015) ed., vol. 10). lexxion verlagsgesellschaft mbh, 227-230. https://doi.org/10.2307/26695060 can, c. a. (2005). match winners. a guide to commercial collaborations between social enterprise and private sector business. community action network (can). retrieved january 2, 2021 from https://s3-apsoutheast2.amazonaws.com/www.yooyahcloud.com/mosscommunications/nexgk/social_enterprise_mag.pdf čižikienė, j., & čižikaitė, a. (2013). socialinių įmonių plėtros kryptys lietuvoje. kaimo raidos kryptys žinių visuomenėje, 17–27 creswell, j. w. (2014). research design: qualitative, quantitative and mixed methods approaches (4th ed.). thousand oaks, ca: sage de malsche, n. (2016). social entrepreneurship. reset. retrieved march 25, 2021 from https://en.reset.org/knowledge/social-entrepreneurship-07042016 dobele, l. (2016). the legal framework and support instruments for social entrepreneurship development in latvia. in the innovative content of caritative social work, vol. 4 (p. 234–246). rīga, latvia: latvia christian academy. european commision. (2020). social enterprises and their ecosystems in europe – comparative synthesis report. retrieved march 25, 2021 from http://www.socialenterprisebsr.net/wp-content/uploads/2020/11/social-enterprises-and-theirecosystems-in-europe.-comparative-synthesis-report.-executive-summary.pdf. european commision. (2021). social enterprises. internal market, industry, entrepreneurship and small and medium enterprises. retrieved february 19, 2021, from https://ec.europa.eu/growth/sectors/socialeconomy/enterprises_nl#:~:text=what%20are%20social%20enterprises%3f,for%20their%20owners%20or%20sharehold ers evans, r., raudsaar, m., līcīte-ķurbe, l., butkevičienė, e., erpf, p., urmanavičienė, a., & raišienė, a. g. (2021). 15 social enterprises in rural areas. social enterprise in central and eastern europe: theory, models and practice, 252. fu, j. s. (2019). cross-sector social partnerships for social entrepreneurship organizing. in academy of management proceedings (vol. 2019, no. 1, p. 11977). briarcliff manor, ny 10510: academy of management greblikaitė, j., gerulaitienė, n., žiukaitė, z., & garcia-machado, j. j. (2017). social economy: the potential and challenges of social enterprises in lithuania. european integration studies, (11), 53–64 greblikaitė, j., rakštys, r., & caruso, d. (2017). social entrepreneurship in rural development of lithuania. management theory and studies for rural business and infrastructure development, 39 (2), 157–165 greenpeace philippines. (2019, october 23). coca-cola, nestlé and pepsico named top plastic polluters for the second year in a row [press release]. retrieved march 6, 2021 from https://www.greenpeace.org/philippines/press/3647/coca-cola-nestleand-pepsico-named-top-plastic-polluters-for-the-second-year-in-a-row/ līcīte, l. european commission (2018) social enterprises and their ecosystems in europe. updated country report: latvia. luxembourg: publications office of the european union. retrieved march 25, 2021 from http://www.lm.gov.lv/upload/socialais_zinojums/social-enterprises-and-their-ecosystems-in-europe.-country-reportlatvia-4.pdf lyon, f. (2009). social enterprises, cooperation and competition in delivery of public services. review paper, third sector research centre (tsrc) and centre for enterprise and economic development research (ceedr), middlesex university. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5487published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 74 oborenko, z., rivža, b., & živitere, m. (2018). potential of non-governmental organisations in social entrepreneurship from the perspective of a regional city. in 10th international scientific conference “business and management 2018” proceedings oecd/eu (2019), "boosting social entrepreneurship and social enterprise development in lithuania: in-depth policy review", oecd local economic and employment development (leed) papers, no. 2019/02, oecd publishing, paris, https://doi.org/10.1787/502fc6ef-en pranskeviciute, i., okuneviciute nevarauskiene, l. (2018), “social enterprises and their ecosystems in europe: country report lithuania”, luxembourg: publications office of the european union, pp. 79-82. pricewaterhousecoopers. (2019). building the capacity and impact of social enterprises. pwc. retrieved february 25, 2021 from https://www.pwc.com/gx/en/about/stories-from-across-the-world/building-the-capacity-and-impact-of-socialenterprises-in-europe.html raišienė, a. g., & urmanavičienė, a. (2017). mission drift in a hybrid organization: how can social business combine its dual goals?. ekonomski vjesnik/econviews-review of contemporary business, entrepreneurship and economic issues, 30 (2), 301–310. raudsaar, m., & kaseorg, m. (2013). an exploration of social entrepreneurship in estonia. international journal of business and management studies, 2 (2), 19–29. reimann, k-l., (2019). social enterprises and their ecosystems in europe country report : estonia. report, retrieved january 25, 2021 from https://ec.europa.eu/social/blobservlet?docid=21574&langid=en reporter, g. s. (2012). social enterprise can benefit from private sector help. the guardian. retrieved march 5, 2021 from https://www.theguardian.com/social-enterprise-network/2012/dec/06/social-enterprise-private-sector-help-skills safege baltija. (2020). state of play of the social entrepreneurship sector report of the interreg v-a latvia-lithuania cross border cooperation programme region. retrieved march 25, 2021 from: https://www.interregeurope.eu/fileadmin/user_upload/tx_tevprojects/library/file_1612881495.pdf sakarya, s., bodur, m., yildirim-öktem, ö., & selekler-göksen, n. (2012). social alliances: business and social enterprise collaboration for social transformation. journal of business research, 65(12), 1710-1720. sannikova, a., & brante, i. (2018). development of social entrepreneurship in latvia. business, management and education, 16, 147–159. schirmer, h., & cameron, h. (2012). collaborations and partnerships. in social entrepreneurship and social business (pp. 83101). gabler verlag. seferian, n (2019). the difference—and relationship—between corporate social responsibility and social entrepreneurship. social innovation academy. retrieved janurary 25, 2021 from http://www.socialinnovationacademy.eu/the-differenceand-relationship-between-corporate-social-responsibility-and-socialentrepreneurship/?fbclid=iwar3fsc1twetnsqf6tqhijgehivdnamtvlzkamzvbfjphh2k0pzvlgwiu_ou selsky, j. w. (2005). cross-sector partnerships to address social issues: challenges to theory and practice. journal of management 31(6), 1–25. trybus, m., & andrecka, m. (2017). favouring small and medium sized enterprises with directive 2014/24/eu? european procurement & public private partnership law review, 12(3), 224–238. https://doi.org/10.21552/epppl/2017/3/6 urmanavičienė, a. (2019). užimtumo srityje veikiančių socialinių įmonių kuriamo socialinio poveikio vertinimo įgyvendinimas baltijos šalyse (doctoral dissertation, mykolo romerio universitetas). retrieved march 25, 2021 from: https://repository.mruni.eu/handle/007/10513/browse?type=author&value=urmanavi%c4%8dien%c4%97%2c+audron %c4%97 urmanaviciene, a. (2020). wises’ social impact measurement in the baltic states. european journal of social impact and circular economy, 1(2), 48-75. https://doi.org/10.13135/2704-9906/5091 vijsel, a. v. v. d. (2014, july 14). the challenge of the social partnership. the broker. retrieved january 25, 2021 from https://www.thebrokeronline.eu/the-challenge-of-the-social-partnership-d40/ volkmann, c. k., tokarski, k. o., & ernst, k. (2012). social entrepreneurship and social business: an introduction and discussion with case studies (2012th ed.). gabler verlag. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-8349-7093-0_10 waddock, s. a. (1988). building successful partnerships. sloan management review summer, 17–23. weber, c., haugh, h., göbel, m., & leonardy, h. (2021). pathways to lasting cross-sector social collaboration: a configurational study. journal of business ethics, 1-27. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5487published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 75 wei-skillern, j., austin, j. e., leonard, h., & stevenson, h. (2007). entrepreneurship in the social sector. los angeles: sage publications. zeyen, a., & beckmann, m. (2018). social entrepreneurship and business ethics: understanding the contribution and normative ambivalence of purpose-driven venturing. routledge. 4562-article text-14394-1-9-20200612 european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/4562 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 38 the impact of stimulating the development of human capital on economic development latif zeynalli phd student azerbaijan state oil and industry university, azerbaijan, baku e-mail: latif.zeynalli@gmail.com received: 25/05/2020 revised: 07/06/2020 accepted for publication: 09/06/2020 published abstract human capital is a significant ingredient of economic development. today, the concepts of human capital have been defined as the knowledge, skill, creativity, and health of the individual. the long-run impact of human capital on the current innovation and economic development is still a question. therefore, the interest in research to explore the contribution of human capital in economic growth increased. the production and processing of knowledge are directly related to scientific and healthy workflow. educated and healthy people are one of the most critical factors in the models, namely the power of human capital, the development of the economy. in this study, the author uses a qualitative methodology. the investigation shows that the most crucial difference between developed and underdeveloped countries is the level of economic development. the biggest obstacle to the development of underdeveloped countries is low education level, lack of health conditions and brain drain. these factors prevent the accumulation of human capital in underdeveloped countries and cause waste of resources in the country. considering these factors, the primary purpose of the study is to study the impact of human capital development on economic development in azerbaijan. keywords: human capital, economic development, sustainable economic development, human capital index, knowledge economy, education european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/4562 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 39 1 introduction in the contemporary world, human capital is undoubtedly considered one of the main factors affecting the sustainable economic development of each country. the rapid development of human capital has particular importance for countries like, which aims to form a competitive structure for its economy to meet requirements of today's global competition and bring the welfare of society to high standards of living. human capital is an economic value that embodies people's competency, knowledge, skills, social and other qualities. human capital development benefits a country directly and indirectly. the direct way is when people are educated, healthy and self-confident, while the indirect way is through economic development, the labor market, international economic relations and so on. in the middle of the last century, the idea of having "more territory" in international politics was replaced by the idea of having "better and better quality human capital" human capital was originally defined as ‘[...] knowledge, skills, attitudes, aptitudes, and other acquired traits contributing to production’. this definition is broader than just educational attainment, as it includes any productive skills or capabilities of individuals, not just those that are formally taught (muhammad ali, et.al.,2018) human capital plays as the primary factor for the investment abroad implying that venture capital is a strict process of establishing the perimeter for choosing the right criteria for investments and what will include into it (vahid jafari-sadeghi, et.al., 2018). the human capital assumes the prevailing special weight in the structure of commonwealth. human capital wealth is defined as the labour force. in other words, human capital wealth is an asset that generates a stream of future economic benefits (earnings) (adalat muradov et.al., 2019). human capital is the sum of investments in knowledge and skills that can benefit an individual's future activities (zeynalli.l.v, 2017). nowadays, effective functioning of the economy in a nation is directly related to human capital development. a concept of human capital includes the elements of human knowledge, skills, ability and health. emergence of the human capital concept has brought about the concept of knowledge economy. knowledge economy is considered an advanced stage of hightech and innovation-driven economy. the experience of developed countries shows that the main factor behind today’s economic achievements is not just natural resources, but innovations based on human knowledge and abilities. theoretical and practical propositions of representatives of institutional, neoclassical, neo-keynesian and other economic schools are based on development of the human capital concept. t.schultz, g.becker, s.kuznets, e.denison, r.slow, c.kendrick, s.fabrikant, i.fisher, r.lukas and many well-known economists put a lot of effort to develop this concept. g.becker has rendered great services in developing human capital theory, and defined human capital as the source of knowledge, skills and motivations.(капелюшников р.и, 1993) human capital, as viewed by economists, involves a process of investment that enhances human labor productivity by means of advances in knowledge and its applications. it specifically involves investment expenditures on education, training, health, nutrition, and related factors that increase the productivity of the labor force. nobel laureate t. w. schultz was one of the first economists to identify the deficiency of the standard neoclassical production function in neglecting the critical role of european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/4562 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 40 human capital. (schultz.t, 1956) t. schultz, another figure known for his human capital theory, suggests that human capital encapsulates a combination of knowledge, skills, relationships and professionalism that humans can fully realize and avail of resources existent in society. they are related to intelligence, health, knowledge, quality work and quality of life. (schultz.t, 1968) he attributed to investments in human capital not only direct expenditures on education in secondary and higher education institutions, but also self-learning, work experience as well as expenditures on health, education and science. t. schultz paid attention to education than display of other forms of human abilities and therefore called for studying this phenomenon in the context of form and sources of human capital. (schultz.t, 1964) nowadays, the content of human capital concept is formed by a set of knowledge, skills, habits and abilities that are used to meet various needs of an individual and society. thus, s. fischer, r. dornbusch and r. shmalenzi consider human capital as a measure of human ability to earn income (s. fisher, et.al.,1998). the united nations development program defines human capital as a set of individual qualities, such as skills, knowledge, social attributes as well as creative imagination, capable of performing labor activity to create economic value (müəlliflik hüququ bmt-nin i̇nkişaf proqramı, 2013). thus, human capital is an intense productive factor for development of society and the economy. it implies to creative professionals, intelligence, knowledge, quality and higher labour productivity as well as high quality of well-being. the bearers of human capital are people who remain competitive (or able to meet competition) with their mental, psychological, intellectual, cultural, creative and professional abilities as well as high quality of life. the factors forming human capital are as follows: § knowledge; § skills; § competences; § creativity (abilities); § health; § ethics (norms of cultural behavior and system of values); § level of well-being. these factors form human creative energy. use of human creative energy for personal interests (benefits) as well as the benefit of society depends on the existing environment. in other words, every human being can be competent and creative, but use of creative energy, whether positively or negatively, is directly dependent on working environment, incentives in society and opportunities available around. formation of human capital in a nation assumes to ensure that every citizen has adequate knowledge, skills, competence, health and all other necessary qualities. meanwhile, human capital on the national level is perceived as competitive and highly productive knowledge accumulated in all areas of society and economy, innovation system, intellectual capital and innovation technologies, creative and innovative labor resources as well as quality of well-being in society. they all together ensure competitive edge for a nation and its economy in international arena. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/4562 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 41 human capital on the national level is formed by means of investments in upbringing, education, culture, health care and safety, professional development, science, knowledge and intellectual growth, entrepreneurial skills, innovations and enhancing quality of human well-being. (becker g.s, 1962) development of human capital is conditioned as follows: § attainment of required knowledge, skills, competence and creative abilities is dependent on quality, accessibility, continuity and target-oriented nature of education in a nation; § state of health and labour ability hinges on quality and accessibility of country’s health care system; § ethics or behavioral culture depend on outlook and system of values that are largely and systematically promoted in the country according to studies conducted by the world bank, 16 percent of today’s economic growth in the world comes from physical capital, 20 percent from natural resources and 64 percent from human capital. according to studies conducted in western countries, returns on investments in human capital are two times greater than other types of investment in developed countries. (maryam ebrahimi, 2020) this fact explicitly shows the role of human capital in the development of society. nowadays, competition for quality human capital is heightened in the world and human capital is the cornerstone of the global innovation development. at present, human capital is the main component of national wealth and remains a major driving force for economic growth in the world. achievements of scientific and technological progress, organization of labour and its cultural emergence and productivity depend on the quality of human capital. human capital is country's most valuable wealth. being healthy, educated and experienced contributes to the long-term development of an individual and society. country’s future is dependent on talent, skills, and professional experience of its population. human capital is the economic value embodying competences, knowledge and skills, social and other qualities. (müəlliflik hüququ bmt-nin i̇nkişaf proqramı, 2013) human capital theory suggests that people want to be compensated for their human capital investments, assuming that people seek to maximize their economic benefits over their life-time. accordingly, human capital theory was originally developed to explain variations in financial returns of employees. applied to entrepreneurship this means that entrepreneurs strive to receive financial returns from their venturing activities relative to their human capital investments. therefore, entrepreneurs' human capital should be positively associated with a preference for venture scale and growth (unger, j. m., et.al.,2011) in the developed countries capital investments in human capital are admitted as the most effective expenditures for society which quickly covering itself on account of returns. human capital is considered as one of the factors strengthening the economic potential and the economic growth in generally. in this type of approach the development is not only measured through increasing the economic growth rate, but also through human capital investment and reduction of poverty (becker g.s., 2009) european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/4562 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 42 2 literature review 2.1 human capital and economic development human capital is a broad concept which identifies human characteristics which can be acquired, and which increase income. it is commonly taken to include peoples’ knowledge and skills, acquired partly through education, but can also include their strength and vitality, which are dependent on their health and nutrition. human capital theory focuses on health and education as inputs to economic production. this is in contrast to the concept of human development which views health and education as intrinsically valuable outcomes to be placed alongside economic production as measures of human welfare. (simon appleton& francis teal, et.al.,1998) robert e lucas conducted a study “on the mechanics of economic development” and states that the factors behind the economic growth is the human capital accumulation rate, in which both the economic growth and human capital accumulation rate is proportional to each other since, human capital levies externalities on production. the economic growth rate is proportionally more than the increase in the accumulation rates of human capital, thus, constructing increasing return to scale. he further explains satisfactorily the rich countries growth but does not explain the poverty traps countries (zia ur rehman, et.al., 2018). the modern economy is the most knowledge based, therefore, the human capital based on knowledge and skills, is a leader of the national wealth. in order to develop the human capital from the “potential” state to the state of “the cost of creating added value”, the state should have special programs and effective management system. human capital is a cost that brings benefit (mayis g. gulaliyev, et.al, 2019). modern economists are of the view that natural resources play an important role in the economic development of a country. a country which has abundant natural resources is in a position to develop more rapidly than a country that is deficient in such resources. however, the presence of abundant resources is not a sufficient enough condition to explain all aspects of economic growth. economies are created and managed by people. these people must be capable of performing the duties required to create such an economy. matters of economic growth and decline hinge on the population. this is called human capital, and to truly understand the world, we must understand the role that populations play in an economy's growth or decline. human capital is the fundamental source of economic growth. it is a source of both increased productivity and technological advancement. in fact, the major difference between the developed and developing countries is the rate of progress in human capital. the underdeveloped countries need human capital to staff new and expanding government services to introduce new systems of land use and new methods of agriculture, to develop new means of communication to carry forward industrialization and to build the education system. since 2005, leading international organizations and a number of research centres have undertaken a number of serious investigations and prepared reports in order to increase attention to effective use of azerbaijan's oil and gas revenues, diversification of the country's economy and human capital development. the world bank's document "azerbaijan country economic memorandum: a new silk road – export-led diversification" describes the steps needed to develop human capital in the country. in the document, the world bank european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/4562 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 43 recommended that the government of azerbaijan should pay more attention to issues such as deepening of reforms in the education and healthcare systems, greater investment in these areas, adaptation of the education system to labour market requirements and strengthening of social security and employment services. (world bank, 2009) the "azerbaijan 2020: look to the future" development concept, approved by a decree of the president of the republic of azerbaijan dated 29 december 2012, stated that one of the most important challenges of our time was "to lay the foundation of transition from a traditional economy to a knowledge-based economy and prioritize appropriate human capital development, which is essential for it". section 7 of the concept was called "human capital development and establishing an effective social security system". the document stated that "providing the population with quality health and education services in the field of human capital development is part of the concept and access to these services for various social groups, including lowincome families and poorer citizens, is a key strategic line." [2] another document reflecting the state policy in the field of human capital development is the strategic road map on the national economic prospects of the republic of azerbaijan, which was approved by a decree of the president of the republic of azerbaijan dated 6 december 2016. one of the four strategic goals outlined in this document is related to human capital development: "as an integral part of the efforts to achieve competitive, inclusive and sustainable economic goals, the third goal is to accelerate human capital development." accordingly, the third strategic goal in the document is to develop human capital. it emphasizes that, as an integral part of reforms in the field of economic transformation in azerbaijan, comprehensive measures will be taken to ensure continuity in human capital development, raise labour productivity and increase the role of knowledge in economic development. [4] the strategic road map on vocational education and training development in the republic of azerbaijan was approved by a decree of the president of the republic of azerbaijan dated 6 december 2016. despite the emphasis on human capital development in both key strategic documents, their approaches and targets for human capital development are quite different. if the development concept focuses on 5 aspects of human capital development, the strategic road map focuses exclusively on improving education, as well as stimulating investment in research and development. 3 methodology of research human capital, innovation and economic development are rather large and vague ideas whose measurement has to be specified in greater detail. the human capital data used in this study come from different sources. starting in 2005, azerbaijan has generated large oil revenues. according to the data of the state oil fund of the republic of azerbaijan covering the period of 20002017, the fund received a total of $138.1 billion, of which $102.3 billion (or 74.0%) was funneled to various projects related to the country's economic development (both through the state budget and funded directly by the fund). during this period, the state budget revenues and expenditures increased rapidly: state budget expenditures increased from azn 2.1 billion in 2005 to azn 22.7 billion, in other words, more than 10 times in 2018. accordingly, the amount of funds allocated from the state budget for education, health care, social protection, and social security as well as culture has seen a dramatic increase. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/4562 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 44 one of the main tasks in public administration is to ensure the development of individuals and the whole society as the most important strategic resource with strong potential and creative abilities. to achieve it, the government should develop and implement a consistent and rational policy. this policy should cover all the elements that make up human capital, reflect specific goals and objectives for each element, and ensure consistency of the indicators and incorporate mechanisms for their implementation. the main source of data for this study are from the human capital report of the world economic forum and the human development report of the united nations development program was used. this study pays special attention to the indicators reflected in the human capital report of azerbaijan for 2016. in particular, the human capital report of the world economic forum compared azerbaijan with other countries on the basis of 0-14 age group, 15-24 age group, 25-54 age group, 55-64 age group and over 65 age group. in addition, comparison of azerbaijan’s per capita gdp data on indicators of selected countries and country group and azerbaijan’s hdi trends based on consistent time series data and new goalposts were highlighted. in essence, the study did not use time series data for analysis. 4 results and discussions the impact of stimulating human capital development on economic development has been discussed from the perspective of developing and developing countries. according to the human capital report of the world economic forum, the indicators of the human capital index of 43 countries were obtained and compared. first, this section reflects the human capital index of azerbaijan in 2016, as well as the score and level of the 5 group of indicators shown in table 1 below. table 1. azerbaijan's human capital value index for 2016 human capital index 0-14 age group 15-24 age group 25-54 age group 55-64 age group over 65 age group sc or e le ve l sc or e l e ve l sc or e le ve l sc or e le ve l sc or e le ve l sc or e le ve l azerbaijan 70.72 54 83.18 68 61.65 87 66.66 48 78.85 24 60.93 50 source: wef, human capital report. (2016) as it has seen azerbaijan is 54. next place the general scope of human capital index score in 2016. it ranks 68th in the age group 0-14, 87th in the age group 15-24, 48th for the age group 25-54, 24th for the age group 55-64, and 50th for the age of 65 years. as it will be recalled, it is possible to make regional comparisons in the human capital index. human capital index ranking of countries in the region found that europe and central asia, from azerbaijan in this respect are shown in table 2. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/4562 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 45 table 2. ranking of the countries in europe and central asia region in terms of human capital index values in 2016 number hci rank countries hci 1 1 finland 85.86 2 2 norway 84.64 3 3 switzerland 84.61 4 5 sweden 83.29 5 7 denmark 82.47 6 8 netherlands 82.18 7 10 belgium 81.59 8 11 germany 81.55 9 12 austria 81.52 10 14 ireland 80.79 11 15 estonia 80.63 12 16 slovenia 80.33 13 17 france 80.32 14 19 united kingdom 80.04 15 20 iceland 79.74 16 21 lithuania 79.34 17 22 luxembourg 79.28 18 25 czech republic 78.45 19 26 ukraine 78.42 20 27 latvia 78.13 21 28 russian federation 77.86 22 29 kazakhstan 77.57 23 30 poland 77.34 24 31 cyprus 76.97 25 33 hungary 76.36 26 34 italy 75.85 27 35 malta 75.66 28 37 armenia 75.39 29 38 romania 74.99 30 39 croatia 74.99 31 40 slovak republic 74.94 32 41 portugal 74.39 33 43 bulgaria 73.66 34 44 greece 73.64 35 45 spain 72.79 36 47 kyrgyz republic 72.35 37 54 azerbaijan 70.72 38 57 serbia 70.54 39 58 tajikistan 70.53 40 59 macedonia, fyr 70.01 41 63 moldova 69.67 42 70 albania 68.23 43 73 turkey 67.57 source: wef, human capital report. (2016) when the countries in the europe and central asia region are ranked according to their general index values, the first five; finland, norway, switzerland, sweden and denmark. 37 out of 43 countries in this region azerbaijan is located next. according european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/4562 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 46 to these indicators, the human capital index in azerbaijan is lower than in europe and central asia and is ahead of only 6 countries in the human capital index. this situation shows us that our country is weak in general in terms of manpower training in this region. it is possible to say that our country is in the middle of the 130 countries examined from the point of view of all these. in this respect, azerbaijan will create a focus on education and employment elements of human capital will be in the interest of the country. table 3 shows the first 15 countries according to the human capital index of the 0-14 age group. table 3. top 15 countries in terms of human capital index of the 0-14 age group for 2016 number countries score 1 finland 98.17 2 cuba 96.87 3 barbados 95.92 4 ireland 95.87 5 singapore 95.81 6 japan 95.78 7 switzerland 95.76 8 belgium 95.29 9 new zealand 95.20 10 estonia 95.09 11 norway 94.69 12 iceland 93.85 13 canada 93.46 14 sweden 93.25 15 france 93.07 source: wef, human capital report. (2016) in the values of the human capital index calculated for the age group of 0-14, the first five countries are as follows; finland, cuba, barbados, ireland and singapore. the 15th is france. accordingly, azerbaijan is ranked 68th in this category with 83.18 scores. table 4 shows the first 15 countries in terms of human capital index calculated according to 15-24 age group. table 4. top 15 countries in terms of human capital index of the 15-24 age group for 2016 number countries score 1 finland 85.35 2 norway 84.72 3 netherlands 83.70 4 switzerland 83.34 5 australia 82.56 6 austria 82.41 7 new zealand 82.25 8 denmark 81.89 9 sweden 81.03 10 germany 79.78 11 iceland 79.63 12 slovenia 79.13 13 belgium 78.25 european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/4562 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 47 14 russian federation 78.21 15 ukraine 78.04 source: wef, human capital report. (2016) in the values of the human capital index calculated for the age group of 15-24, the first five countries are as follows; finland, norway, netherlands, switzerland and australia. the 15th is ukraine. accordingly, azerbaijan is ranked 87th in this category with 61.67 scores. table 5. top 15 countries in terms of human capital index of the 25-54 age group for 2016 number countries score 1 finland 81.24 2 switzerland 80.51 3 sweden 80.17 4 norway 80.11 5 japan 79.13 6 singapore 78.70 7 germany 78.39 8 denmark 78.17 9 canada 77.61 10 netherlands 77.58 11 belgium 77.55 12 france 77.32 13 luxembourg 77.24 14 united kingdom 76.78 15 austria 76.75 source: wef, human capital report. (2016) in the values of the human capital index calculated for the age group of 25-54, the first five countries are as follows; finland, switzerland, sweden, norway and japan. the 15th is austria. accordingly, azerbaijan is ranked 48th in this category with 66.66 scores. table 6. top 15 countries in terms of human capital index of the 56-64 age group for 2016 number countries score 1 japan 85.72 2 new zealand 85.70 3 norway 85.34 4 sweden 84.58 5 canada 84.22 6 denmark 83.99 7 finland 83.90 8 switzerland 83.54 9 germany 83.31 10 estonia 82.98 11 armenia 81.84 12 lithuania 81.24 13 netherlands 81.06 european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/4562 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 48 14 kazakhstan 80.95 15 australia 80.85 source: wef, human capital report. (2016) in the values of the human capital index calculated for the age group of 56-64, the first five countries are as follows; japan, new zealand, norway, sweden and canada. the 15th is australia. accordingly, azerbaijan is ranked 24th in this category with 78.85 scores. table 7. top 15 countries in terms of human capital index of the 65 and over age group for 2016 number countries score 1 japan 75.61 2 norway 74.53 3 new zealand 74.07 4 denmark 74.04 5 armenia 74.01 6 germany 73.54 7 switzerland 73.28 8 canada 73.05 9 finland 72.95 10 ukraine 72.21 11 latvia 72.10 12 austria 72.00 13 estonia 71.77 14 slovenia 71.39 15 russian federation 71.14 source: wef, human capital report. (2016) in the values of the human capital index calculated for the age group of 56-64, the first five countries are as follows; japan, norway, new zealand, denmark and armenia. the 15th is russian federation. accordingly, azerbaijan is ranked 50th in this category with 60.93 scores. table 8. comparison of azerbaijan's per capita gdp data on indicators of selected countries and country group. countries gross national income (gni) per capita. ($) azerbaijan 15,751 turkey 23,500 russian federation 23,843 kazakhstan 22,054 kyrgyz republic 3,113 tajikistan 3,164 estonia 27,645 latvia 23,685 lithuania 26,884 ukraine 7,593 belarus 15,765 european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/4562 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 49 georgia 8,785 armenia 8,350 uzbekistan 6,135 turkmenistan 14,890 source: human development report. (2016) as can be seen from the table, azerbaijan has a leading position in the caucasus region. it lags behind only 6 countries on the same indicator. according to the table, average per capita income is 15,410 usa dollars. in this regard, per capita income in azerbaijan is 2.2% higher than the average. according to the report, this figure is kyrgyz republic, with the lowest per capita income of $ 3113. table 9: azerbaijan’s hdi trends based on consistent time series data and new goalposts life expectancy at birth expected years of schooling mean years of schooling gni per capita (2011 ppp$) hdi value 1995 65.3 10.0 10.2 3,387 0.612 2000 66.8 10.4 10.6 4,314 0.640 2005 68.8 10.7 10.7 6,940 0.679 2010 71.0 11.7 10.7 15,246 0.740 2015 71.9 12.7 10.7 16,334 0.758 2016 72.0 12.7 10.7 15,751 0.757 2017 72.1 12.7 10.7 15,600 0.757 source: http://hdr.undp.org/sites/all/themes/hdr_theme/country-notes/aze.pdf azerbaijan’s hdi value for 2017 is 0.757— which put the country in the high human development category—positioning it at 80 out of 189 countries and territories. the rank is shared with lebanon and the former yugoslav republic of macedonia. between 1995 and 2017, azerbaijan’s hdi value increased from 0.612 to 0.757, an increase of 23.7 percent. table a reviews azerbaijan’s progress in each of the hdi indicators. between 1990 and 2017, azerbaijan’s life expectancy at birth increased by 7.3 years, mean years of schooling increased by 0.5 years and expected years of schooling increased by 2.0 years. azerbaijan’s gni per capita increased by about 79.2 percent between 1990 and 2017. table 10: human development index for azerbaijan years health index education index hdi 1995 0.696 0.618 0.612 2000 0.719 0.640 0.640 2005 0.750 0.652 0.679 2010 0.784 0.681 0.740 2011 0.789 0.684 0.741 2012 0.792 0.689 0.745 european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/4562 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 50 2013 0.795 0.698 0.752 2014 0.797 0.709 0.758 2015 0.799 0.709 0.758 2016 0.800 0.709 0.757 2017 0.802 0.709 0.757 source: human development reports. the development of human capital index of azerbaijan is examined in table 10, the respectively, there is a 1.2-fold increase in education and health indices, and a 23.7% increase in the hdi. according to the world bank report, azerbaijan's human capital index rose from 0.56 to 0.60 from 2012 to 2017. azerbaijan's human capital index in 2017 was lower than the average figure of regional countries, but was slightly higher than the average figure of countries with similar income. according to the report, if children born in azerbaijan today benefit from full education and full health, 60 per cent will be productive and 98 out of every 100 children will be able to live to be 5. a 4year-old child in azerbaijan can complete an average of 11.6 years of education by the age of 18. children in azerbaijan are expected to complete 11.6 years of pre-school, primary, secondary and full secondary education by 18. however, when the school education process is adapted to the quality of learning, it is only 8.8 years. according to the report, 2.8 years are missing in learning. the assessment of pupils' learning quality is slightly below average in azerbaijan. according to the human capital index, pupils' learning quality was rated at 472 points. boys were rated at 466 points and girls at 479 points for the quality of education they receive here. it should be noted that in this scale, 625 indicates the highest achievement and 300 the minimum achievement. as for the longevity of people, 87% of 15-year-olds in azerbaijan will live to be 60. this figure is 83% for boys and 92% for girls. the statistics shown are the means of evaluating the lethal and non-lethal health effects if a child born today ages in the current conditions. moreover, the human capital index shows that 18 out of every 100 children born in azerbaijan are short and are at risk of mental and physical restraint, which may continue throughout their lifetime. 5 conclusion the most important difference between developed and underdeveloped countries is the level of economic development. the biggest obstacle to the development of underdeveloped countries is low education level, lack of health conditions and brain drain. these factors prevent the accumulation of human capital in underdeveloped countries and cause waste of resources in the country. in societies with healthy individuals, the production of information and the effective use of information increases the level of economic development with a high level of education. the high level of knowledge and skills of labor force increases productivity while accelerating technological development and this increases factor productivity. therefore, human capital plays the most important role in economic development. review of azerbaijan's human capital index is very low as a result of the scope of the europe and central asia. 37 out of 43 countries. nevertheless, azerbaijan has a leading position in european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/4562 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 51 the caucasus in terms of per capita income. thus, per capita income in azerbaijan is $ 15,751, almost twice as high as in georgia and armenia. this study examined the relationship between economic development and human capital in azernaijan. according to the world bank report, azerbaijan's human capital index rose from 0.56 to 0.60 from 2012 to 2017. although, azerbaijan’s hdi value for 2017 is 0.757— which put the country in the high human development category—positioning it at 80 out of 189 countries and territories. in azernaijan, economic development, human capital affects positively. economic development leads to positive changes in human capital in the short and long term. human capital has a positive impact on economic development in the long run. human capital plays an important role in the long-term development of society. increasing the perception of education and health of the society gives the country an advantage in achieving development goals. however, the stability of economic development will also have a positive impact on human capital. references 1. adalat muradov, yadulla hasanli, fargana musayeva (2019) estimation of the education influence on the population income.37th international scientific conference on economic and social development – “socio economic problems of sustainable development” – baku,14-15february,592-601 2. azərbaycan 2020: gələcəyə baxış i̇nkişaf konsepsiyası. azərbaycan respublikası prezidentinin 2012-ci il 29 dekabr tarixli fərmanı ilə təsdiq edilib 3. azərbaycan respublikası dövlət neft fondunun hesabat məlumatları. https://www.oilfund.az/report-andstatistics/report-archive] 4. azərbaycan respublikasının milli iqtisadiyyat perspektivi üzrə strateji yol xəritəsi. azərbaycan respublikası prezidentinin 2016-cı il 6 dekabr tarixli fərmanı ilə təsdiq edilib 5. becker, g. (2009). human capital: a theoretical and empirical analysis, with special reference to education. university of chicago press. retrieved. https://econpapers.repec.org/bookchap/nbrnberch/3733.htm 6. becker g.s. (1962) investment in human capital: a theoretical analysis// journal of political economy.supplement. oct. 7. human development report, 2016 8. inequalities in human development in the 21st century briefing note for countries on the 2019 human development report http://hdr.undp.org/sites/all/themes/hdr_theme/country-notes/aze.pdf 9. капелюшников р.и. (1993) экономический подход гэри беккера к человеческому поведению. сша: экономика, политика, идеология, № 11, с. 17–32 10. maryam ebrahimi (2020) qualitative exploration of grounded theory in organizational research, igi global, may 15, 2020 business & economics 251 page european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/4562 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 52 11. mayis g. gulaliyev, rashad s. muradov, leyla a. hajiyeva, hijran r. muradova,konul a. aghayeva, elnur s. aliyev (2019) study of human capital development, economic indicators and environmental quality, ekoloji 28(107): 495503 12. muhammad ali, abiodun egbetokun, manzoor hussain memon (2018) human capital, social capabilities and economic growth, economies 2018, 6, 2; 2-19 13. müəlliflik hüququ bmt-nin i̇nkişaf proqramı, 2013. i̇nsan i̇nkişafı bakı s.36 14. s. fisher, r. dornbusch, r. shmalenzi (1998) economy per.s english. co 2nd ed. m.delo, 864 p. 15. schultz.t.w, 1956. "reflections on agricultural production, output, and supply," journal of farm economics 38: 748-62 16. shultz t. (1964) investment in human capital. economic growin – an american problem. euglewood cliffs 17. shultz t. (1968) human capital international encyclopedia of the social sciences. n.y., vol 6 18. simon appleton, francis teal (1998) human capital and economic development 19. unger, j. m., rauch, a., frese, m., & rosenbusch, n. (2011). human capital and entrepreneurial success: a metaanalytical review. journal of business venturing, 26(3), 341-358. 20. vahid jafari-sadeghi, salman kimiagari, paolo pietro biancone (2018) level of education and knowledge, foresight competency and international entrepreneurship a study of human capital determinants in the european countries, european business review vol. 32 no. 1, 2020 pp. 46-68 21. wef, human capital report, 2016 22. world bank (2009) azerbaijan country economic memorandum new silk road: export-led diversification. 23. zeynalli.l. v (2017) the basic definitions and approaches for human capital. amea i̇qtisadiyyat i̇nstitutu. “elmi əsərlər” -№3, 101-107 http://economics.com.az/images/fotos/elmi_eserler_pdf/2017_3/15zeynalli_l.pdf 24. zia ur rehman, muhammad tariq, muhammad azam khan (2018) the role of human capital in economic development in the selected central asian countries, the dialogue volume xiii number 3, 236-244 4293-article text-14972-1-9-20200708-2 european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/4293 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 66 assessment of women empowerment of hindu religion: case of rural bangladesh kamrun nahar1, afrina khan2, sajedul islam khan3, aditi chakrovorty4, arifin sultana5* 1department of sociology, national institute of textile engineering and research, dhaka, bangladesh 2department of sociology, university of dhaka, dhaka, bangladesh 3department of sociology, bangladesh university, dhaka, bangladesh 4the east asia study center, university of dhaka, bangladesh 5*department of psychology, national university, gazipur, bangladesh *corresponding author e-mail: sultana.psychology@yahoo.com received: 27/02/2020 revised: 07/07/2020 accepted for publication: 07/07/2020 published: 20/07/2020 abstract women empowerment and equality are the concerning issue all over the world. the aim of this paper is to identify the real condition of hindu women in society according to their religion. qualitative approach focusing case study has been conducted in koil village under bogura district of bangladesh. an attempt has been made in this study to highlight on the nature of hindu women’s rights to inheritance. hindu women face various difficulties in their way of life since traditional values are deeply rooted in their life. this study reveals that hindu women are deprived from their rights due to traditional social culture, ignorance, unawareness, and unemployment. government should consider this issue with the view that they are a significant part of population; hence a duty of care and essential obligation must be there. keywords: constitutional right, women empowerment, poverty, inequality, inheritance 1. introduction hindu women’s life is bounded by their religious norms and traditional systems. most of the respondents knew about the inheritance rights but they cannot and do not claim for it. they are depended on their family and especially husband (jinnah, 2013). hindu women in koil village go through their general understanding of inheritance system. in spite of having some knowledge of rights, they do not claim (agarwal, 2009). they think that their present situation is pleasant enough to lead their life that’s why rarely they raise their voice against any injustices done to them (zahur, 2016). they are peace loving women and they want to be so without conflicting with the traditional rules (sarker & jie, 2017). whatever happens to them, they consider it natural. dowry given to daughters during marriage is considered their custom and it has become natural to them. they cannot think of their daughter’s marriage without dowry. their perception of traditional inheritance system has european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/4293 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 67 deep roots to their socialization process (sarker, 2019c). they consider their traditional inheritance system as customary laws and it cannot be denied or changed so easily (sarker & sultana, 2017). it was found that there is middle class value among the respondents and they know about the inheritance system but do not implement the rights (sarker, bingxin, sultana, & prodhan, 2017). middle class family gives emphasize on cultural norms and hindu women in koil village do it as well (dejaeghere & lee, 2011). they are concerned about their traditional rules and they think constitutional rights should be applied but none is concerned enough to take initiatives. patriarchal structure is dominant in hindu society and patriarchal domination keeps hindu women silent and they do not claim for their equal rights (sarker, 2016). if they do, they think they can hardly achieve their rights. moni and sumaiya (2013) argues that hindu women face more discrimination than men because of three unequal treatments: as member of a patriarchal society, as member of a patriarchal family and as a member of a patriarchal nationality (sarker, ali, & islam, 2015). they also state that besides constitutional denial, minority women are also deprived of beneficial personal laws. hindu women do not get any right from their customary law; rather they suffer from discrimination (adams, 2015). women had no right in ancestral property and married women had no right in father’s property or on dwelling home. in case of property rights of women, laws were biased towards men. there was no equal treatment or equal distribution of property to females. they were just mere survivors. bangladesh has always been a male dominant country where rights of women have been neglected. along with these lines, hindu women in koil village do not claim for their rights to inheritance for several reasons. therefore, this study is intended to identify the empowerment of hindu women. 2. methodology 2.1 research design qualitative method has been adopted for exploring in-depth discussion about the topic. we used qualitative methodology because we want to interpret the topic indepth. moreover, we wanted to see the social condition from respondent’s perspectives. 2.2 data collection our study site is a village named koil in bogra district in bangladesh. to conduct my research, we need details information about my topic. we think i will get details information easily since all of my participants were villagers of my own area and they will help me a lot. the study population of my research is married women of koil village in bogra district. it is not possible for me to collect information from the entire married female of koil village. that’s why sampling is inevitable. we used convenience sampling under nonprobability sampling to get details information about my topic. the sample size was 16. to collect the data we used mobile recorder, paper and pen. semi structured interview schedule was followed to collect data. data collection is an important part of research. since this research is based on qualitative method, interview method was selected for data collection. within interview method, semi-structured interview was applied for data collection. along with interview, direct observation was also applied. 2.3 data processing and analysis we collected information in bengali language for the convenience of my respondents. we recorded the data on my mobile and for my academic purposes, we transcribed those data. then we translated them in english language. we read these translations again and again and tried to make summary of the writings. then data has been analyzed according to objectives. 2.4 afraid of breaking relationship women want to own land but they do not want to inherit it because women who state that they do not wish to inherit land are primarily afraid of straining relationships with their families or being rejected by their communities. in the absence of a will, when the hindu succession amendment act is applicable, women are generally forced to give up their share in favor of their brothers for various reasons (sarker, wu, & hossin, 2019). one of the main reasons is the fear of breaking familial bonds. mahmud et al. (2012) states that women often have to forgo their claims with regard to agricultural land to ensure the support of their natal family in case they encounter marital problems or their marriages breakup, even though such support may not actually materialize. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/4293 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 68 kalpana karmakar (25) argued that “if they claim for their rights, their brothers misbehave with them and do not want to give them any share.” 2.5 dowry hindu women do not claim for their property rights since they are given with bequest during their marriage. in many cases, parents sell their daughter’s share of property to provide marital cost. that’s why women do not claim for their rights. singh k, (2012) reported that there exists the customary and traditional belief that after marriage a girl belongs to her husband’s family and not to her natal family (nasrin, sarker, & huda, 2019). namita karmakar (35) argued that “hindu groom’s family owns 8 -9 lakh tk. during marriage and bride’s family provides it that’s why i want to distribute property in accordance with traditional system. in many cases bride’s family spend 2 bigha lands for daughter’s marriage and in such case, it is valueless to demand for further property rights. if my daughter gets married without such bequest or dowry then i could think of giving her a share of property.” she further told that since daughters are provided with bequest, boys should have more share of property and hence she does not accept equal rights for property. 2.6 traditional systems hindu women do not claim for their equal rights since traditional system is deeply rooted in their society. it is not their tradition to claim for paternal property. srimati dulali karmakar (25) told that “hindu women do not claim for their equal rights because of traditional system which is going on.” conversely, there are also some situations in which hindu women claim for their rights. these are extreme cases in which hindu women cannot but claim for their rights (sarker, 2019b). in most of the cases, poverty forces hindu women to claim for their rights (patel, 2006). in case of abandonment of wife by their husband, hindu women claim for their rights to inheritance. in this way, they want to secure their position in society and find a way of earning. sonali karmakar (26) wished to claim for her rights to inheritance because she is left in her father’s house and had to earn by her own to lead her life (sarker et al., 2019). namita karmakar (35) told that many women claim for their equal rights if their economic condition of in law’s house is miserable. in this case, poverty is the main reason for claiming equal rights to inheritance rather than awareness. sonali karmakar (26) faces problems since she is bound to live in her father’s house after marriage. she told that “if husband is addicted to drugs and do not work for family; hindu women cannot do anything to survive and claim for their rights to inheritance.” in case of husband’s disability, hindu women search for income and they think if they could have property from father, their life would have been different. in such cases, hindu women claim for their rights. rupali karmakar (28) described her situation this way “hindu women do not claim for their equal rights because of traditional system which is going on and if father had little property and husband is unable to work, hindu women face severe problems. they cannot do anything to develop their condition.” from these discussions, it is found that, hindu women generally do not claim for their rights to inheritance because of traditional systems and even if they do, it is because of poverty or any other cause rather than their awareness about legal rights to inheritance (sarker, rahman, cao, & xu, 2019). 3. problems faced by hindu women for inheritance rights most of the hindu women interviewed reported that they did not face any problems for rights to inheritance since they conformed to traditional system of inheritance. although the traditional system of inheritance is itself a problem in present time, most of the respondent cannot recognize the situation (sarker, islam, ali, et al., 2019). due to lack of knowledge, hindu women do not understand their problems rather they stick to old traditional system of inheritance. the ownership of property reduces women’s vulnerability to and enhances their ability to deal with the domestic violence (guhathakurta, 2012). in sri lanka, the study highlights notions of patriarchy and social norms that operate in the context of the sri lankan society, making women passive subjects to the violence inflicted on them. lack of political will of the state government is clearly visible as there is hardly any pro-active effort on their part to enforce women’s right to inheritance and succession european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/4293 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 69 (khan, sarker, huda, nurullah, & zaman, 2018). in contrast, what is striking is that women universally expressed the desire to own land, implying that they fully recognize the value of land and property for their wellbeing. their lack of action to claim is partly due to their ignorance of law, but more importantly perhaps out of their belief in the same patriarchal practices and lack of social support system that is needed in order to help them come forward (rahman et al., 2018). barriers that women face in inheriting land and property are: gender discriminatory practices such as dowry being considered a ‘one time settlement’ to women; insufficient knowledge of the hindu succession act and its 2005 amendment; women’s reluctance to enforce their land ownership rights; and, lack of proactive implementation of the law by revenue department officers who tended to follow the department requirements which were not necessarily in compliance with the provisions of the hindu succession amendment act 2005. lack of assets enhances vulnerability and poverty and those women who do not own any assets are subject to violence, threats of violence and allocation inequalities within the household. in contrast, those who owned both land and house reported considerably less violence. the study found that one respondent named sonali karmakar (26) was bound to abandon her husband since he was addicted to drugs. in this case, that hindu woman has no other source of earning and survives by tailor. she leads a miserable life and wished to have rights to inheritance. in another case sondha rani karmakar (42), reported that her father had huge number of property and she did not get anything. this woman had to take care for her father but could not achieve anything. she also wished for equal rights to inheritance since daughters do care for their parents. kalpana karmakar (26) also reported of having possibility of misbehave if hindu women claim for their rights. since traditional systems are deeply rooted in hindu women’s life, they cannot but face problem. 3.1 rights of hindu women and application of rights it was found that there is positive co-relation between the educational level and hindu women’s understanding of the rights to inheritance. the study indicates that the higher the educational level, the better the knowledge and understanding of inheritance rights. women aged between25-40 were more likely educated than those of older women. literate women were more likely to be aware of their rights and wanted to distribute property equally (sarker, wu, shouse, & ma, 2019). hindu women generally do not claim for their rights to inheritance. most of the respondents recognized their rights to inheritance but cannot claim for it. hindu women have to be pleased with what they were given during their marriage. if hindu women claim for their inheritance rights, they cannot achieve it because of their traditional system of inheritance (schuler, lenzi, badal, & nazneen, 2018). many women argued that hindu women do not claim for their rights but they should. rights to inheritance are granted by the constitution but it is not socially approved in hindu society. as surochi karmakar (35) quoted that “they have to be pleased with the inheritance system that is going on because if they claim for their rights, they do not get anything. they are bound to accept the traditional inheritance system”. srimati adori rani karmakar (26) argued in the same manner that “constitutional rights do not get that much importance in hindu society and that’s why women cannot demand for their rights to inheritance.” although most of the respondents favor constitutional rights to inheritance, they do so because constitution is also undeniable and as government has granted it, they accept it. srimati adori rani karmakar (26) further argued that “constitutional rights to inheritance as granted by government is also important and cannot be denied.” this statement also indicates that in many cases, hindu women are bound to accept constitutional rights although it contrasts to their traditional systems. in this case, their roots stick to the traditional understanding of inheritance system. although many women wanted to distribute their property equally, it is a debate that how much effective their action will be. since traditional rules have become deeply rooted to hindu women’s life, hindu women cannot implement their wishes (sarker, wu, alam, & islam, 2019). men in hindu family are not concerned about women’s equal rights. even if they know about constitutional rights, they are indifferent to implement the laws since this will decrease their power to own property exclusively (mahmud et al., 2012). this indicates the patriarchal social structure that dominates over women’s life. patriarchal social structure as emphasized by radical feminists is also responsible for women’s deprivation of rights to inheritance (sarker et al., 2020). with the increasing importance of education and rising awareness among hindu women, this situation is changing day by day in a very slow motion. 3.2 application of constitutional rights at the heart of hindu society, there is predominance of traditional rules and customs. although the constitution of bangladesh grants equal rights to inheritance to every citizen, in hindu society there is little application of it. traditional system is so deeply rooted in hindu society that in every aspect of their life, it has profound implication. most of the respondents accepted constitutional rights but there is little application of it in their daily lives. in hindu society, european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/4293 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 70 constitutional rights are not being applied because of traditional rules; what is going on from ancient time is going on till today. women are dominated in our society and in case of hindu women, this situation is severe (patel, 2006). hindu women cannot do anything to change their rights. as we know from the theory of radical feminism, patriarchal social structure exploit women and in case of hindu women, this is practically applicable. men household of hindu family do not realize women’s rights to inheritance rather they make maximum use of their paternal property exclusively. from the ancient period women are found to be dependent on their male counterpart. since then they have been deprived of the right to property of their father and husband (waheed, sayeed, & mujtaba, 2014). they remain dependent on father during their childhood, on husband in youth and on son in old age. traditional rules are so deeply involved in hindu society that it is very difficult to apply constitutional laws. as one respondent named srimati adori rani karmakar (26) told that ‘traditional system is deeply rooted in hindu society that’s why constitutional right is not being applied in their society.’ 3.3 inheritance situation of hindu women in most of the cases socio-economic background played an important role to the rights of inheritance. most of the hindu women did not get any share from their parents. hindu women in koil village, who were interviewed, know about their inheritance rights that are traditionally going on. although they know about their constitutional rights, they seem to be unaware. traditional system of inheritance gives priority to men possession over property and daughter does not get any share of property (uddin, 2015). there are several reasons for which constitutional inheritance system cannot achieve importance. these are: 3.3.1 domination of traditional system hindu society is based on their religious values. religious values and norms shape the life of hindu women in koil village. in hindu religion, law is considered as a branch of dharma. hindu women do not get any right from their customary law; rather, they suffer from discrimination. traditional system of inheritance gives priority to men possession over property and daughter does not get any share of property. most of the respondents said that in hindu society, women do not get share of paternal property because it has become their tradition (sultana & subedi, 2016). although they acknowledge that women should be given their rights, most of the women are pleased with their traditional system. there were found three kinds of explanation regarding traditional system of inheritance. these are: even in case that parent own lots of property, women do not get anything because of their traditional culture. hindus considered their law to have come from god. law as understood by the hindus is a branch of religion, which is not subject to any modification or alteration. holding such view, they prefer to apply traditional law in all personal matters, which does not give much concentration on woman’s right (mohsin, 2004). daughters are bound to live their life with their in-law’s house and they cannot demand from their father’s property even if father owns lots of property. hindu daughters do not have rights to inheritance. kalpana rani karmakar (30) told that ‘hindu women do not get any share of their paternal property even in case that their parents have lots of property. they have to be pleased with their fatherin law’s property.’ another respondent named rina rani karmakar (30) told that ‘she did not get any property from her parents because there is no tradition of distributing property among daughters in their society.’ another explanation for traditional system of inheritance is that if parents do not have son, then daughter gets little share of paternal property. as one respondent named dipali rani karmakar (40) told that, ‘hindu women get little share of their paternal property if they do not have brothers. she got little share of paternal property (2 decimal) since she does not have brother.’ another respondent srimati dulali rani karmakar (26) told that ‘in the hindu community, if mother owns property then daughters get share of it and if father owns property then sons get share of it. she herself did not get any share of parental property.’ being the absolute owner, a woman can dispose of stridhana at her pleasure. but in respect of other property she is merely a qualified owner and enjoys a very limited right. surochi rani karmakar (50) described the same situation and told that ‘daughters generally do not get share of their father’s property but if mother owns property, daughters can demand on that property to some extent.’ this situation is further described by another respondent named sonali karmakar (26), ‘if father wishes to distribute property to daughter then they can have property and if mother owns property, they can have rights to mother’s property in their society’ another explanation of traditional system of inheritance is that, if parents distribute property among daughters and sons intentionally, daughters can have a share of parental property. even when the women receive land in inheritance, it is invariably much less than an equal share. most hindus in india and nepal and muslims in india, pakistan and bangladesh are governed by patrilineal kinship systems. as social identity is secured from the father, a son is a permanent member of the european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/4293 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 71 natal household and a daughter is considered transient. she has moral rights to periodic gifts but largely denied inheritance, seen as a dependent of her husband. one respondent named namita karmakar (35) argued the situation this way, ‘daughters do not insist on their parents for having share of property. she did not get any share of paternal property till now and there is little hope to get but if parents give her a share intentionally then she can have’. although constitution of bangladesh grants rights to inheritance irrespective of religion and cast, hindu women do not get their right in koil village. kalpana karmakar (30) argued that, “hindu women do not get rights to own paternal property and even if they have rights, they are not given any share of property.” 3.3.2 prevalence of dowry in the hindu community, there is prevalence of dowry. although dowry is prohibited in our country, it is still going on in hindu society. it is deeply rooted in their customs and hence it has become their law. dowry has become their traditional rule that hinders hindu women’s rights to inheritance. dowry has important impact on the understanding of hindu women’s rights to inheritance. in the study, it was found that dowry has replaced the rights to inheritance. hindu parents are bound to provide dowry in their daughter’s marriage and groom’s family receive it. in many cases, dowry seems to have replaced the present inheritance system. one respondent named adori rani karmakar (25) describes the situation arguing that ‘i did not get any share of my paternal property since my parents sold my share of property during marriage to provide marital dowry. for this reason, i will not get any share of my paternal property.’ most of the women interviewed reported that since daughters are given marital gifts, it is valueless to demand for their property rights. to get married of their daughters seem to be very important to hindu people. it has become a social practice that at the wedding of a daughter the father had to spend a lot of money and huge gifts in the form of ornaments and furniture. all such things are presumed to be given her in lieu of property (sarker, 2019a). to provide daughter with property might cause the loss of ancestral property as she goes to other family; such attitude of hindu society is also responsible for exclusion of women from their right to inheritance. one respondent surochi karmakar (50) described the situation arguing that ‘in accordance to their religion, daughters mostly get their paternal resources during marriage and after giving birth to 1st child. parents fulfill their duty during these periods and daughters generally do not get share of their father’s property but if mother owns property, daughters can demand on that property to some extent’ it was found that hindu groom’s family owns 8 9 lakh tk. during marriage and bride’s family provides it that’s why hindu women wanted to distribute property in accordance with traditional system. in many cases bride’s family spend 2 bigha lands for daughter’s marriage and in such cases, it is valueless to demand for further property rights. namita karmakar (35) described the situation arguing that ‘if my daughter gets married without such bequest or dowry then i could think of giving her a share of property’. another respondent ashalata karmakar (50) described the same situation this way ‘hindu women’s parents get their girls married and it is the most important duty to be done to their daughters. i did not get any share of property from my parents. she told in the same manner what her parents did to her that “my property would be distributed between my sons and daughters would not get any share.” 3.3.3 development of inheritance system most of the respondents accepted and supported hindu women’s rights to inheritance as granted by the constitution of bangladesh. many women could not tell about how to develop inheritance rights because of their lack of education and knowledge about rights. few women, who were educated and had knowledge about the constitutional rights, could tell about the development of inheritance rights (white, 2009). all of them asked about the development of inheritance rights told that they will distribute their property equally between their son and daughter to develop the inheritance rights. this reflects the idea that nowadays hindu women are being aware of their rights and they are being influenced by constitutional rights. to develop inheritance rights, awareness must be raised among hindu women. kalpana karmakar (30) told in the same manner that, ‘constitutional rights are not socially recognized in their society’. she further told that “government cannot do anything unless parents themselves acknowledge equal rights”. from above these findings it is clear that radical feminism, liberal theory and structural marxism are relevant in this study. these theories have profound implications in this study. traditional systems along with patriarchal social structures are largely responsible for women’s deprivation. as being the minority, hindu women lack voices to establish their rights in society (sourav, 2015). in order for their rights to be established, social recognition is inevitable. the whole social structure has to realize hindu women’s rights to inheritance. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/4293 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 72 4. conclusion in this century when women in the world are enjoying all sorts of civil and political rights and economic, social and cultural rights the states are adopting laws to remove gender discrimination and inequality, a hindu woman must be provided with the exclusive right to inheritance. no civilization can prosper without ensuring the rights of women. most of the problems that are associated with hindu women’s rights to inheritance are rooted in their traditional system and religious values. if enough steps are taken to aware hindu women about their rights to inheritance, they can enjoy their rights. the women belonging to other religion like the muslim enjoy their property exclusively, though the share in inheritance is less than their male counterpart. the national development of the country cannot be achieved leaving a large number of people, like hindu women behind. in order to ensure their active participation in every aspect of national life, the hindu women should be given exclusive right to property, which will ensure development and social security. it should be realized by the mass people in bangladesh that without having any property right a hindu woman has no room in the society. government should consider this issue with the view that they are a significant part of population; hence a duty of care and essential obligation must be there. references adams, n. (2015). religion and women’s empowerment in bangladesh. retrieved from https://pdfs.semanticscholar.org/5da6/79657cee0ba4391d45a0f1ff168f7176c3f5.pdf agarwal, b. (2009). hindu women’s property rights in rural india: law, labour and culture in action. asian journal of criminology, 4(2), 189–192. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11417-008-9063-2 dejaeghere, j., & lee, s. k. (2011). what matters for marginalized girls and boys in bangladesh: a capabilities approach for understanding educational well-being and empowerment. research in comparative and international education, 6(1), 27–42. https://doi.org/10.2304/rcie.2011.6.1.27 guhathakurta, m. (2012). amidst the winds of change: the hindu minority in bangladesh. south asian history and culture, 3(2), 288–301. https://doi.org/10.1080/19472498.2012.664434 jinnah, s. i. m. (2013). land and property rights of rural women in bangladesh. retrieved from https://www.ohchr.org/documents/hrbodies/cedaw/ruralwomen/cdabangladesh.pdf khan, s. i., sarker, m. n. i., huda, n., nurullah, a. b. m., & zaman, m. r. (2018). assessment of new urban poverty of vulnerable urban dwellers in the context of sub-urbanization in bangladesh. the journal of social sciences research, 4(10), 184–193. https://doi.org/10.32861/journal.7.410.184.183 mahmud, s., shah, n. m., & becker, s. (2012). measurement of women’s empowerment in rural bangladesh. world development, 40(3), 610–619. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.worlddev.2011.08.003 mohsin, a. (2004). religion, politics, and security: the case of bangladesh. religious radicalism and security in south asia, 467–488. retrieved from http://books.google.com/books?id=5dycaaaacaaj moni, r. j., & sumaiya, t. (2013). scoping study on women and land rights in bangladesh. retrieved from http://www.angoc.org/wpcontent/uploads/2014/07/bd final scoping study on women.pdf nasrin, m., sarker, m. n. i., & huda, n. (2019). determinants of health care seeking behavior of pregnant slums dwellers in bangladesh. medical science, 23(95), 35–41. patel, r. (2006). hindu women’s property rights in india: a critical appraisal. third world quarterly, 27(7), 1255–1268. https://doi.org/10.1080/01436590600933453 rahman, m. z., sarker, m. n. i., huda, n., islam khan, s., a. b. m., n., & zaman, m. r. (2018). assessment of socio-economic and sexual vulnerability of tea workers in bangladesh. the journal of social sciences research, 4(11), 229–240. https://doi.org/10.32861/jssr.411.229.240 sarker, m. n. i. (2016). poverty of island char dwellers in bangladesh. retrieved from http://www.anchor-publishing.com/ebook/318628/poverty-of-island-char-dwellers-in-bangladesh sarker, m. n. i. (2019a). administrative resilience: potential approach for disaster management. in a. farazmand (ed.), global encyclopedia of public administration, public policy, and governance (pp. 1–5). https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-31816-5_3868-1 european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/4293 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 73 sarker, m. n. i. (2019b). public administration as a professional practice. in a. farazmand (ed.), global encyclopedia ofpublic administration, public policy, and governance (pp. 1–6). https://doi.org/https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-31816-5_3853-1 sarker, m. n. i. (2019c). public administration as an academic discipline and social science. in a. farazmand (ed.), global encyclopedia ofpublic administration, public policy, and governance (pp. 1–8). https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-31816-5_3856-1 sarker, m. n. i., ali, m. a., & islam, m. s. (2015). causes and possible solutions of poverty perceived by char dwellers in bangladesh. international journal of natural and social sciences, 2(21), 37–41. sarker, m. n. i., bingxin, y., sultana, a., & prodhan, a. s. (2017). problems and challenges of public administration in bangladesh: pathway to sustainable development. international journal of public administration and policy research, 3(1), 16–25. sarker, m. n. i., cao, q., wu, m., hossin, m. a., alam, g. m., & shouse, r. c. (2019). vulnerability and livelihood resilience in the face of natural disaster : a critical conceptual review. applied ecology and environmental research, 17(6), 12769–12785. https://doi.org/10.15666/aeer/1706_1276912785 sarker, m. n. i., islam, m. s., ali, m. a., islam, m. s., salam, m. a., & mahmud, s. m. h. (2019). promoting digital agriculture through big data for sustainable farm management. international journal of innovation and applied studies, 25(4), 1235–1240. sarker, m. n. i., & jie, z. (2017). social security for vulnerable groups in bangladesh on government perspective: contribution of research leader. journal of public policy and administration, 1(1), 1–9. https://doi.org/10.11648/j.jppa.20170101.11 sarker, m. n. i., rahman, m. z., cao, q., & xu, z. (2019). impact of small entrepreneurship on poverty alleviation and sustainable livelihood of street vendors. international journal of innovation and applied studies, 25(4), 1241–1254. sarker, m. n. i., & sultana, a. (2017). an investigation into the status of riverbank (char) women dwellers in bangladesh. international journal of rural development, environment and health research, 1(1), 86–92. sarker, m. n. i., wu, m., alam, g. m., & islam, m. s. (2019). role of climate smart agriculture in promoting sustainable agriculture : a systematic literature review. international journal of agricultural resources governance and ecology, 15(2), 1–15. sarker, m. n. i., wu, m., & hossin, m. a. (2019). economic effect of school dropout in bangladesh. international journal of information and education technology, 9(2), 136–142. https://doi.org/10.18178/ijiet.2019.9.2.1188 sarker, m. n. i., wu, m., shouse, r. c., & ma, c. (2019). administrative resilience and adaptive capacity of administrative system: a critical conceptual review. in j. et al. xu (ed.), lecture notes on multidisciplinary industrial engineering (pp. 1–13). https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-21255-1_55 sarker, m. n. i., bo, y. huq, m. e. & kamruzzaman, m. m. (2020). climate change adaptation and resilience through big data. international journal of advanced computer science and applications, 11(3), 533-539. https://doi.org/10.14569/ijacsa.2020.0110368. schuler, s. r., lenzi, r., badal, s. h., & nazneen, s. (2018). men’s perspectives on women’s empowerment and intimate partner violence in rural bangladesh. culture, health and sexuality, 20(1), 113–127. https://doi.org/10.1080/13691058.2017.1332391 sourav, r. i. (2015). unjust land right of women in bangladesh. international research journal of interdisciplinary & multidisciplinary studies, 1(3), 5–13. sultana, h., & subedi, d. b. (2016). caste system and resistance: the case of untouchable hindu sweepers in bangladesh. international journal of politics, culture and society, 29(1), 19–32. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10767-015-9202-6 uddin, e. (2015). ethnic disparity in family socioeconomic status in bangladesh: implication for family welfare policy practice. global social welfare, 2(1), 29–38. https://doi.org/10.1007/s40609-014-0021-x waheed, a., sayeed, a., & mujtaba, s. i. (2014). empowerment of muslim women in islam: a sociological analysis. bangladesh e-journal of sociology, 11(july), 27–29. white, s. c. (2009). religions and development research programme domains of contestation : women ’ s empowerment and islam in bangladesh. development. zahur, m. (2016). hindu women’s property rights: bangladesh perspective. brac university journal, xi(1), 79–87. 5084-article text-17116-3-11-20210206 http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi:10.13135/2704-9906/5084 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 internationallicense 1 good governance: the impact on the performance of tunisian listed companies ammar samout1, boutheina marnissi2 1department of management science, faculty of economics and management of sfax-tunisia 2laboratory of epidemiology and veterinary microbiology, institute pasteur of tunis, university tunis el manar, tunis, tunisia e-mail: boutheinamarnissi90@gmail.com received: 12/09/2020 revised: 09/11/2020 accepted for publication: 15/11/2020 published: 08/03/2021 abstract the purpose of our research is to study the impact of governance tools on tunisian company performance. empirical verification conducted by an expert panel composed of 100 tunisian companies listed on the tunis stock exchange. the observation period is 10 years, from 2008 to 2018. it shows that the composition of the board of directors, the remuneration system, shareholders and information disclosure on the performance of these banks which have a positive impact. on the other hand, for the two performance indicators (roe and roa), the age of the company is not important. keywords: governance; performance; director board 1. introduction governance is a concept that has evolved a lot since the emergency of 1980s, and on the other hand the debates around this issue of the interests involved.even in political science the first classical essays on the subject says about the concept centered on two main components: law then order, governance today addresses issues related to the mechanisms necessary to negotiate the various interests of society by the way the broad notion covers the different ways in which individuals and groups organize themselves to achieve common goals. the literature is full of works attempted to test the effect of governance on performance and most of these works show that governance has a significant effect on the performance of the company and on its http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi:10.13135/2704-9906/5084 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 internationallicense 2 value in the market, and this for different contexts and performance indicators.among these studies we can cite that of widodo, ds, silitonga, p., & ali, h. (2020)), coffey, b., bush, j., mumaw, l., de kleyn, l., furlong, c., & cretney, r. (2020) and beshi, t. d., & kaur, r. (2020).most governance studies ignored governance issues at the level of listed companies mainly in emerging countries (sajko, m., boone, c., & wernicke, g. 2017). however, this theme is important for several reasons. listed companies occupy a preponderant role in the economies of countries.they are a major component of any national economy. the change of the international context following globalization, liberalization, deregulation of financial systems, the adoption of new technologies affects the functioning of these type of business.the business sector has a big role in the economic and social development of our country. its direct involvement in the implementation of public sector strategies justifies the strengthening of corporate governance practices with a view to greater efficiency and performance. despite structural changes in the financial system in tunisia which have strengthened the role of the financial market from 1990s, listed companies still remain also the main focus of economic development. in view of all these considerations, it is interesting to conduct a study developed within the framework of listed companies. our work is inspired by research related to corporate governance and proposing several control mechanisms to improve performance (widodo, d. s., silitonga, p., & ali, h. (2020) and hutahayan, b. (2020)).our ambition in this research to determine the effect of governance on the performance of listed companies.from this perspective, as part of the research, we will try to provide answers to the following question« will the governance improve the performance of tunisian listed companies? ». 2. review of literature and formulation of research hypotheses a large amount of literature attempts to examine the impact of governance on performance, and most of the work in society shows that governance has a significant impact on company performance and its value in the market, as well as different environments and performance indicators. http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi:10.13135/2704-9906/5084 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 internationallicense 3 e. schiehll (2004) established the relationship between company performance and the four attributes of corporate governance structure:board composition, management participation, incentive compensation and major shareholder participation. the work carried out by horstmeyer and wells (2017) suggests that the effects of good governance also depend on the economic conditions characterizing a sector. shareholder rights are maximized when the sector is booming, and appear significantly less important when economic conditions are bad.bauer et al. (2008) used data provided by the international governance indicators (gmi). the japanese companies in the sample are classified according to six governance dimensions. the author analyzes the impact of governance quality on its performance. using the total index shows that companies with higher governance levels outperform other companies at rate of 15% each year.evenly, recent work by horstmeyer and wells (2017) suggests that the effects of good governance also depend on the economic conditions characterizing a sector. shareholder rights are maximized when the sector is booming, and appear much less important when economic conditions are bad. we must also take into account the stage reached by the company in its life cycle. thus, a mature listed company needs more supervision and control: in this case, it could be shown that a reduced board of directors is better suited. otherwise, a younger company will be able to benefit more from the advice of its board, which will therefore be all the more effective as its members will be more numerous.black, jang, and kim (2003) showed in their sample of 526 south korean companies that they developed an index based on the governance review of the korea stock exchange.an increase of 10 points in the governance index resulted in a 65% increase in the tobin index « q » and a market booking rate of 13%. they also found that any improvement in governance practices would result in a 47% increase in tobin’s « qvalue » and a 96% increase in market/book value.from the other side, chong and lopez-de-silanes (2007) believe that governance will definitely affect the operating performance of the companies studied, but this impact is far less than the impact on the market value of these companies. finally, bauer et al. (2003) confirmed that governance is positively correlated with the profitability and market value of european companies in the research. but it is negatively correlated with operational performance.in addition to that, gruszczynski (2005) tested the existence of this link in a polish language environment. http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi:10.13135/2704-9906/5084 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 internationallicense 4 his research shows that there is a significant correlation between the calculated governance scores and the financial performance of the polish companies studied.otherwise, bauer et al. (2008) studied the relationship between governance quality and japanese company performance. they set out to develop a total index covering six aspects of governance. so, the results of this study show that companies with the best governance perform 15% better than other companies each year.furthermore, mohamed, basuony, and badawi (2013) studied the impact of corporate governance on the financial and stock market performance of 88 non-financial companies listed on the egyptian stock exchange egx100 index.the study prove that there are about three governance mechanisms studied ownership structure, board composition and audit quality.we incorporate control variables into the analysis and we enumerate: the company size, age, department and financial structure.the financial performance is evaluated through roe and roa and also through q's stock market performance. according to al-ahdal, wm, alsamhi, mh, tabash, mi, & farhan, nh (2020), corporate governance plays a critical role in creating a corporate culture of awareness and transparency. in this context, the study by these authors provides a brief overview of the history of corporate governance mechanisms in india and in the gulf corporation council (gcc) countries, the corporate legal system and established supervisory policies. by the indian governments and the gcc. in addition, this study analyzes the impact of corporate governance mechanisms on the financial performance of indian and gcc listed companies. the study uses a sample of 53 listed non-financial companies from india and 53 listed non-financial companies from gcc countries for the period 2009-2016. the results revealed that the responsibility of the board of directors (ba) and the audit committee (ac) have an insignificant impact on the performance of companies as measured by roe and tobin's q. furthermore, fictitious country results show that indian companies outperform those in the gulf countries in terms of corporate governance practices and financial performance. according to these authors this research is seen as a battery of further research and studies, particularly in listed companies in india and in the gcc in the context of corporate governance and financial performance. at the national level, madhar, s. (2016) studied the relationship between governance and performance by studying 46 moroccan issuers between the end of 2012 and the end of 2014. the author developed a grid of 31 governance guidelines that mainly cover board practices and shareholder rights. in order to http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi:10.13135/2704-9906/5084 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 internationallicense 5 hypothesis 2: the higher the governance’s score related to the compensation policy, the higher the company's financial grow and the stock market performance increase. measure the performance of the companies in the sample, it prefers financial and stock market indicators, especially turnover, ebitda and net profit margin.based on the results of these studies, our research will first try to study the correlation between the governance index published on the canadian globe and mail website and performance indicators.therefore, we will test the hypothesis to study this correlation as follows: the general hypothesis: companies with higher governance scores will have better performance. since the governance indicator we use is composed of 4 sub-indexes, we will test the impact of each sub-index on performance. the composition and performance of the director board:the board of directors is considered to be one of the main means to correct the defects of managers (widodo, d. s., silitonga, p., & ali, h. (2020), garcia, a. s., & orsato, r. j. (2020) and f. adjaoud et al. (2007)). this is how hermalin and weisbach (2000) describe it as the "heart of governance". the size of the board of directors is also seen as a variable that may have a significant impact on its effectiveness (p. andré and e. schiehll 2004). according to the results of yermack(1996) and s. bahagat and black (2002), this effect is negative because the board loses its effectiveness as the size of the board increases.in contrast to these results, the results of godard (2001) show that the size of the board has no effect on the performance of french companies and it has nothing to do with the performance indicators used.yermack (1996) also showed a negative correlation between the size of the board of directors and the value of the company, because of communication difficulties and the high cost of joint decision-making.through these studies, we can draw the following first hypothesis: hypothesis 1: the higher the governance’s score related to board composition, the higher the company's financial and stock market performance increase salary system and performance:widodo, d. s., silitonga, p., & ali, h. (2020), srivastava, a., & bhatia, s. (2020) and p. andré and e. schiehll (2004) believe that company performance will be related to the relative importance of long-term incentive compensation, such as cash dividends and the grant of stock options. therefore, our second assumption is: http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi:10.13135/2704-9906/5084 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 internationallicense 6 hypothesis 3: the higher the governance’s score related to respect for shareholder rights, the higher the company's financial and stock market performance increase. shareholder rights and company performance: gompers, ischii, and metrick (2003), esposito, p., & dicorato, s. l. (2020) and horstmeyer, d., & wells, k. (2017) show that the company with the strongest shareholder rights has higher value, higher profits, higher sales growth, and more and lower capital expenditures. therefore, the third research hypothesis can be as follows: disclosure and performance: the increase in information disclosure has led to lower agency costs and therefore increased company value (f. adjaoud, d. zeghal and s. andaleeb (2007),beshi, t. d., & kaur, r. (2020) and çelik, ş., & güleç, t. c. (2020)) therefore, we can state the last hypothesis of the study as follows: 3. research methodology in this case, we propose a choice of methods that can verify the research hypothesis.firstly, we expose our research samples. secondly, we developed the variables held within the framework of this research. 3.1. framework of research the purpose of this study is to evaluate the impact of good governance on the performance of listed companies. therefore, we take 130 listed companies in tunisia as a sample.the sample covers companies belonging to three different sectors: the industrial, commercial and service sector.these samples held can better consider the impact of governance on performance. therefore, the research interval is 30 years, from 1990 to 2019 according to financial information collected from the bank’s annual activity report, aptbef’s annual report, bvmt’s guidelines, and documents from the financial market committee (cmf). 3.2. the variable research in the following, we introduce the variable used to evaluate the structure of the board of directors and measure bank performance. a) variables that depend on company performance our goal is to study the effect of explanatory (exogenous) variables on performance. performance is an endogenous or explanatory variable. hypothesis 4: the higher the governance’s score related to disclosure, the higher the company’s financial and stock market performance increase http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi:10.13135/2704-9906/5084 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 internationallicense 7 performance can be measured by using market indicators of stock market prices (price-tobook ratio, price-earnings ratio, total shareholder return, etc.) or roe or roa type accounting indicators. in our research, we use the ratio of return on assets (roa) to return on equity (roe) roa (return on assets) economic performance: this ratio is also called the earning rate of permanent capital because it represents the ability of the capital to create a certain level of operating profit to compare the result with the method to achieve the goal. roa = capital used = equity + lmt debts the financial performance of the return on equity (roe):this ratio is also called the return on equity, which represents the ability of shareholders to invest in equity to generate profit roe = net income/equity b) independent variables we try to identify the most important variables that describe corporate governance. regarding to the characteristics of the board, we selected 4 variables -the composition of the board of directors; -equity and compensation; -shareholder rights; -information disclosure. four characteristics constitute the four sub-indices of our global governance index c) control variables if we want to verify the impact of governance mechanisms on bank performance, we must consider other variables to draw conclusions, especially: company size: introduce variables of scale to achieve economies of scale or diseconomies of scale. smirlok (1985), akhavein, etc (1997) , guan (2003) and çelik, ş., & güleç, t. c. (2020)found a positive and significant relationship between bank scale and performance. company age (age): company age is usually regarded as a variable that has a very important impact on performance. generally speaking, the company age variable is represented by the logarithm of the number of years of operation (brown and caylor (2006), ben cheikh and zarai(2008) and al-gamrh, b., ismail, k. n. i. k., ahsan, t., & alquhaif, a. (2020)). therefore, we have one independent variable, two dependent variables and one control variable. therefore, we have two models: http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi:10.13135/2704-9906/5084 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 internationallicense 8 model 1 : roai,t = β0 + + β1 govi,t+ β2 agei,t + + β3 t i,t+ εi,t model 2 : roei,t = β0 + + β1 govi,t+ β2 agei,t + + β3 t i,t+ εi,t with gov: the governance index, t: the size of the company, age: the age of the company dt: the company's debt, β0: the constant and 𝛆 the errorterm table 1: variable choice’s variable signification measure roa return on assets net income / total assets roe return on equity net income / equity gov corporate governance this index looks at four important characteristics of the board of directors, namely: the composition of the board of directors; shareholding and compensation; the rights of shareholders; disclosure of information. age company age log (number of years) t size of the company log (book value of total assets) source: personal design next, we continue to conduct econometric research, through which we try to test whetherthere is a connection between performance indicators (roe and roa) and the governance of tunisian listed companies. we try to test the hypothesis that corporate governance has a positive impact on financial and market performance, and observe under what conditions this impact will occur. 4. interpretation of the results and discussion 4.1 descriptive statistics table (2) illustrates the mean, standard deviation and mean of the variables considered in our study.the table also confirms the average age of 10 years. in 100 companies, the average age of shareholders' equity is 1.35. for div, the average value of this variable is 8.4. therefore, the average values of roa and roe are 0.90 and 10.6, respectively. http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi:10.13135/2704-9906/5084 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 internationallicense 9 table 2: descriptive statistics. medium median minimum maximum standard deviation roa 0,90 0,82 0,20 1,55 0,35 roe 10,62 10,88 1,95 17,50 3,84 ca 11,57 11.25 8,10 15,30 1,70 sr 4,50 2,14 1,49 5,61 1,12 div 8,48 8,10 3,35 12,22 1,08 sc 2,85 2,90 0,7 5,42 1,66 t 8,40 8,05 5,51 12,60 1,85 age 10,40 10,13 3,50 20,5 3,15 source: eviews 9 4.2. study of the effect of performance on governance using the global governance index the low r2 in table 3 indicates that the explanatory power of our model is moderate so, the results that come from our estimates can be interpreted as follows: > the effect of the total assets variable (t) is positive and is statistically significant given that the probability associated with this variable is 0.050, or equal to 0.05. the sign associated with its parameter indicates that an increase in total assets has a positive impact on the roa and the roe. > the impact of the governance index (gov) variable is positive and statistically significant given that the t-stat is lower than that of the table of at the 5% threshold. the sign associated with its parameter indicates that the increase in the governance index influences the roe and roa. > the impact of the variable age is positive given its coefficient of 0.008 for roa and 0.007 for roe. it is statically insignificant in view of the student statistic calculated lower than that of the table. table 3: study of the effect of performance on governance (global index) variables roe roa constant 8.356*** (4.452) 7.569*** (2.851) age 0.008 (0.036) 0.007 (0.019) t 6.054*** (1.548) 3.128** (1.323) gov 0.325 (0.245) 0.435 (0.685) r2 number of observation 0.502 100 0.523 100 source: eviews 9 the values in brackets represent the standard errors * significant at the 10% level, ** significant at the 5% level, *** significant at the 1% level. http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi:10.13135/2704-9906/5084 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 internationallicense 10 4.3. study of the effect of performance on governance using the sub-indices making up the global governance index. the decomposition of the governance index consists of replacing this index with its four sub-indices (bc, sc, sr, and div) in the three performance equations. the estimated models, in this step, are as follows: 𝑴𝒐𝒅el 3 ∶ roe = 𝑐𝑡𝑒+ 𝛼1 𝐵𝐶 + 𝛼2 𝑆𝐶 + 𝛼3 𝑆𝑅 + 𝛼4 𝐷𝐼𝑉 + 𝛽1 𝑇 + 𝛽2 𝐴𝐺𝐸 + 𝜀𝑖 𝑴𝒐𝒅el 4 ∶𝑅𝑂𝐴 = 𝑐𝑡𝑒 + 𝛼1 𝐵𝐶 + 𝛼2 𝑆𝐶 + 𝛼3 𝑆𝑅 + 𝛼4 𝐷𝐼𝑉 + 𝛽1 𝑇 + 𝛽2 𝐴𝐺𝐸 + 𝜀𝑖 where 𝑖=1 100 designates companies ; bc: the composition of the board of directors; sc: shareholding and compensation; sr: shareholder rights; div: information disclosure. t: size ; age: age of company ; c : constant ; and 𝜺 : standard error the various estimates indicate that the sub-indices have a significant impact on financial performance. therefore, our hypothesis has been verified for model 3 and model 4. table 4: expressive study of expression form variable roe roa constant 6.324** (3.511) 7.133** (3.220) bc sc sr div 0.125* (0.052) 0.241* (0.068) 0.189* (0.034) 0.518 (1.021) 0.425 (0.085) 0.324* (0.088) 0.225* (0.043) 0.125* (0.214) age 0.005 (0.0326) 0.0065 (0.0121) t 5.522*** (1.254) 4.225** (1.113) r2 number of observation 0.48 100 0.502 100 source: eviews 9 http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi:10.13135/2704-9906/5084 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 internationallicense 11 the value in parentheses indicates the standard error *significant at the 10% level*significant at the 5% level*significant at the 1% level*** it is important to note that the low value of r2 in table 4 indicates that the explanatory power of our model is moderate. the results that come from our estimates can be interpreted as follows: > the effect of the total assets variable (t) is positive and is statistically significant given that the probability associated with this variable is 0.050, or equal to 0.05. the sign associated with its parameter indicates that an increase in total assets has a positive impact on the roa and the roe. > the impact of the variable on the composition of the board of directors is positive and statistically significant given that the t-stat is lower than that of the table of at the 5% threshold. the sign associated with its parameter indicates that the composition of the board of directors influences the roe and roa. > the impact of the shareholding and compensation variable is positive and statistically significant given that the t-stat is lower than that of the table of at the 5% threshold. the sign associated with its parameter indicates that the composition of the board of directors influences the roe and roa. > the impact of the shareholder rights variable is positive and statistically significant given that the tstat is lower than that of the table of at the 5% threshold. the sign associated with its parameter indicates that the composition of the board of directors influences the roe and roa. > the impact of the variable information disclosure is positive and statistically significant given that the t-stat is lower than that of the table of at the 5% level. the sign associated with its parameter indicates that the composition of the board of directors influences the roe and roa. > the impact of the variable age is positive given its coefficient of 0.008 for roa and 0.007 for roe. it is statically insignificant in view of the student statistic calculated lower than that of the table. 5. discussion the relationship between governance and economic performance has long remained the subject of much controversy between different schools of economic thought. indeed, according to our estimates, governance has a positively significant effect on the performance of listed companies for the 4 models. for model 1 and 2 then, we noticed that according to various estimates, governance has an impact on financial and economic performance. in fact, the gov variable is very important in the first of two models. http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi:10.13135/2704-9906/5084 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 internationallicense 12 therefore, our general hypothesis has been verified. this result is the same as the research direction of gruszczynski (2005), which reveals the positive relationship between governance index and performance in the polish language environment. the total assets variable (t) is positive and significant in the two equations using roe (6.054 ***) and roa (3.128 **). this is consistent with our assumption that size has a positive effect on financial performance. several authors have found similar results such as beshi, t. d., & kaur, r. (2020), durnev and kim (2003), bohren , odegaard (2001) , f. adjaoud, d. zeghal and s. andaleeb (2007) who find in different contexts of positive association between size and performance. the table bellow shows that any financial performance indicator prove the variable age is not important where (roe is 0.004, roa is 0.008). this result doesn’t match our expectations and results in other circumstances and other authors. for example, ben cheikh and zarai (2008) found that in the tunisian context, the age variable has a significant impact on a company's stock market performance (mtb) and accounting performance (roa) (with a 1% threshold). their results are also consistent with those of cameron and whitten (1981). shortly, using the total sample and the overall governance index can confirm our general assumptions about the impact of governance on performance. therefore, the breakdown of governance indicators will allow us to test the effectiveness of each governance sub-index that is evaluated against these two performance indicators. for model 3 and 4 in both models, the estimated coefficients of variables related to board composition are positive and significant. our research results are consistent with the literature review we have developed. the size of the board is also seen as a variable that may have a significant impact on its effectiveness (widodo, d. s., silitonga, p., & ali, h. (2020), p. andré and e. schiehll (2004) and al-gamrh, b., ismail, k. n. i. k., ahsan, t., &alquhaif, a. (2020)). as for the variable "shareholding and compensation", the results showed a positive and significant impact on the economic performance of tunisian companies. this result is consistent with the results observed by widodo, d. s., silitonga, p., & ali, h. (2020) ,hergli et al. (2007) and p. biancone, s secinaro, v brescia (2018), who argued that moderate executive compensation related to company performance (accounting or market value related) is a factor that has a positive impact on company value. regarding to the variable "shareholder rights", the results show that it has a positive and significant impact on the economic performance of tunisian companies. http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi:10.13135/2704-9906/5084 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 internationallicense 13 this result is consistent with the results found by coffey, b., bush, j., mumaw, l., de kleyn, l., furlong, c., & cretney, r. (2020) and gompers, ischii, and metrick (2003), which indicate that the company with the strongest shareholder rights has greater value, higher profits, and stronger sales growth. as for the effect of the variable "information disclosure" on the performance of companies, the results reveal a positive and significant impact on the economic performance of tunisian companies. this result is consistent with the results observed by r. bauer and al (2008), in the japanese context, who found that information disclosure is one of the most determining factors of performance. the total assets variable (t) is positive and significant in the two equations that using roe (5.522 ***) and roa (4.225 **). this is consistent with our assumption that size has a positive effect on financial performance. the age variable is not important for financial performance indicators (roe is 0.005, roa is 0.0065). 6. conclusion to conclude this research aims to study the relationship between corporate governance and performance in tunisia.it aimed also to determine corporate governance practices in the algerian context based on the criterion of performance.we tried to take a critical look at the quality of corporate governance while analyzing the impact of the governance index on performance to verify whether governance really has an effect on performance.indeed, the analysis of this relationship is based on the implementation and study of several statistical tests as well as the use of multiple linear regressions the first contribution of this study to the scientific literature is a complete and well-argued econometric analysis of the existing relationship between governance and performance.the analysis of this relationship relies on the implementation and study of several statistical tests as well as the multiple linear regressions.the results of econometric tests confirm the theories. moreover, this study finds a significant relationship between the governance index, total assets and economic and financial performance. this study has some gaps that need to be addressed. the first limitation relates to the relatively small size of our sample. the second limitation concerns the small number of factors likely to explain the level of performance of companies.nevertheless, it can be considered as a starting point for further research. finally, there is two main research perspectives can be outlined. the first is to add other governance variables. the second would be to carry out a comparison with what is practiced in other countries and in particular emerging countries. http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi:10.13135/2704-9906/5084 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 internationallicense 14 references adjaoud, f., mamoghli, c., siala, f. (2007). la réputation de l’audit externe et les mécanismes de gouvernement d’entreprise : interactions et effet sur la performance. 28éme congrès de l’association francophone de comptabilité. adjaoud, f., zeghal, d., andaleeb, s. (2007). the effect of board’s quality on performance: a study of canadian firms. journal compilation, 15(4). al-ahdal, w. m., alsamhi, m. h., tabash, m. i., & farhan, n. h. (2020). the impact of corporate governance on financial performance of indian and gcc listed firms: an empirical investigation. research in international business and finance, 51, 101083. al-gamrh, b., ismail, k. n. i. k., ahsan, t., & alquhaif, a. (2020). investment opportunities, corporate governance quality, and firm performance in the uae. journal of accounting in emerging economies. andré, p., schiehll,e. (2004). systèmes de gouvernance, actionnaires dominants et performance future des entreprises. finance contrôle stratégie, 7(2), 165 –193. andres, p., azofra, v. et lopez, f. (2005). corporate boards in oecd countries: size, composition,functioning and effectiveness. blackwell publishing ltd., 13(2). bahagat, s. et black (2001). the non-correlation between board independence and long term firm performance. journal of corporation law, 231-274. bauer, r., frijns, b., otten, r. et tourani-rad, a. (2008). the impact of corporate governance on corporate performance: evidence from japan. pacific-basin finance journal, 16, 236–251. belghith, i. (2008). taxonomie de conseils d’administration et performance ; effet médiateur de l’enracinement et du conflit cognitif dans le cas des établissements hôteliers en tunisie : proposition d’un cadre théorique. journée rochelaise de recherche sur le tourisme groupe sup de co larochelle. ben cheikh, s., zarai, m, a. (2008). importance des facteurs organisationnels sur le pouvoir managérial et la performance de la firme. colloque international fiscalité droit gestion. beshi, t. d., & kaur, r. (2020). public trust in local government: explaining the role of good governance practices. public organization review, 20(2), 337-350. biancone p., secinaro s., brescia v. (2017). the popular financial reporting and gender accountability, the integrated approach in municipalities and public bodies. biancone p., secinaro s., brescia v., iannaci d. (2018).communication and data processing in local public group: transparency and accountability. http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi:10.13135/2704-9906/5084 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 internationallicense 15 biancone p., secinaro s., brescia v. (2018).the innovation of local public-sector companies: processing big data for transparency and accountability. biancone p., secinaro s., radwan m., kamal m. (2019). halal tourism: an opportunity for the global tourism industry. black, b., jang, h. et kim, w. (2005). does corporate governance affect firms' market values? evidence from korea. working papern86/2005 çelik, ş., & güleç, t. c. (2020). corporate governance and performance. in corporate governance models and applications in developing economies, igi global, 162-191. charreaux, g. (1996). vers une théorie du gouvernement des entreprises. chapitre 15, in g. charreaux (ed.): le gouvernement des entreprises, économica. chatelin, c., trébucq, s. (2003). stabilité et évolution du cadre conceptuel en gouvernance d’entreprise: un essai de synthèse. communication pour les neuvièmes journées d’histoire de la comptabilité et du management. coffey, b., bush, j., mumaw, l., de kleyn, l., furlong, c., & cretney, r. (2020). towards good governance of urban greening: insights from four initiatives in melbourne, australia. australian geographer, 1-16. durnev, a., kim, e. h. (2003). to steal or not to steal: firm attributes, legal environnement, and valuation. current draft. esposito, p., & dicorato, s. l. (2020). sustainable development, governance and performance measurement in public private partnerships (ppps): a methodological proposal. sustainability, 12(14), 5696. galander, a., walgenbach, p., rost, k. (2015). a social norm perspective on corporate governance soft law. corporate governance: the international journal of business in society 15(1), 31-51. garcia, a. s., & orsato, r. j. (2020). testing the institutional difference hypothesis: a study about environmental, social, governance, and financial performance. business strategy and the environment. godard, l. (2001). la taille du conseil d’administration: déterminants et impact sur la performance. cahier du fargo n° 1010702, juillet2001. gompers, p.a., ischii, j.l., metrick, a. (2003). corporate governance and equityprices. quarterly journal of economics, 118(1). hansen, b.e. (2000). sample splitting and threshold estimation. econometrica, 68, 575-603. hergli, m., bellalah,m., abdennadher, n. (2007). gouvernance d'entreprise et valeurs de marché en tunisie. 4th international finance conference, hammamat,tunis. horstmeyer, d., & wells, k. (2017). when do governance mechanisms matter most? http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi:10.13135/2704-9906/5084 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 internationallicense 16 hutahayan, b. (2020). factors affecting good governance of performance management. in facing global digital revolution: proceedings of the 1st international conference on economics, management, and accounting (bes 2019), july 10, 2019, semarang, indonesia (p. 207). routledge. mejdoub, i. (2008). mécanismes de gouvernance et performance financière des entreprises : un état de l’art. 7èmecolloque international de la recherche en sciences de gestion. hôtel le royal. naciri, a. (2006). traité de gouvernance corporative. les presses de l’université laval. peter, k. shapiro, d., young, j. (2005). corporate governance, family ownership and firm value: the canadian evidence”, corporate governance, 13(6), 769-784. rosenstein, s., wyatt, j.g. (1990). outside directors, board indépendence, and schareholder wealth. journal of financial economics 26, 175-191. sajko, m., boone, c., & wernicke, g. 2017. how much do ceos matter for corporate social performance? academy of management proceedings. shome, d.k. singh, s. (1995). firm value and external blockholdings. financial management, 24(4), 3-14. srivastava, a., & bhatia, s. (2020). influence of family ownership and governance on performance: evidence from india. global business review. stine, r.a. (1995). graphical interpretation of variance inflation factor. the american statistician, 49. weir, c., laing, d., mcknight, p.j. (2002). internal and external governance mechanisms: their impact on the performance of large uk public companies. journal of business finance and accounting, 29, 579–611. widodo, d. s., silitonga, p., & ali, h. (2020). the influence of good governance, culture, and performance in increasing public satisfaction and implication to public trust: study in indonesian government. talent development & excellence, 12(2). wirtz, p. (2004). meilleures pratiques de gouvernance, théorie de la firme et modèles de création de valeur : une appréciation critique des codes de bonne conduite. cahier140du fargo n° 1040401. fargo centre de recherche en finance, architecture et gouvernance desorganisations. yermack, d. (1996). higher market valuation of companies with a small board of directors.journal of financial economics, 40, 185-211. 5282-article text-17303-1-11-20210223 http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 for peer review (doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5282 published by university of turin) http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 17 social indicators for businesses’ circular economy: multi-faceted analysis of employment as an indicator for sustainability reporting scarpellini, sabina1 1 department of accounting and finance, university of zaragoza, zaragoza, spain e-mail: sabina@unizar.es received: 17/11/2020 revised: 09/01/2021 accepted for publication: 10/01/2021 published: 08/03/2021 acknowledgements the writing of this article has been partially co-funded by the spanish ministry of industry and competitiveness project ‘eco-circular’ ref. eco2016-74920-c2-1-r and it has been conducted within the framework of the ‘socioeconomic and sustainability research group: environmental accounting, corporate circular economy and resources’ (ref. s33_20r) financed by the regional government of aragón. the empirical work was conducted within the framework of the study promoted and financed by the economic and social council of aragón (spain). i would like to express my special thanks to the experts and representatives of the bodies that collaborated through semi-structured interviews and played a fundamental role as ‘key informants’. i also acknowledge the contribution of prof. josé m. moneva, prof. pilar portillo-tarragona, prof. fernando llena-macarulla and dr. alfonso aranda-usón. abstract in recent years, the introduction of the circular economy's principles at the micro level is receiving attention in different areas of the business literature. although several studies have focused on the environmental or economic impacts of the adoption of the circular economy at a micro level, a detailed http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 for peer review (doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5282 published by university of turin) http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 18 analysis of the social aspects of the circular economy in businesses is still necessary. from a triple bottom line perspective, social dimensions of the circular economy are one of the three pillars for sustainability accounting and reporting and must be considered in the relationship between firms and their stakeholders. thus, the main objective of this study is to reflect on the social impact of the business circular economy at the micro level by analysing job generation. to this end, this study' approaches the definition of specific indicators to measure different dimensions of the employment in a circular economy framework through the qualitative analysis of semi-structured interviews collected in a regional case study in spain. this article summarises different metrics to be applied to the measurement of the multi-faceted employment generated by companies in a circular model. furthermore, a contribution derived from the synopsis of this study is the definition of the linkage of circular businesses' and the sustainability accounting and reporting. keywords: social corporate responsibility; circular economy; social indicators; social accounting; social impacts 1. introduction in recent years, attention to the circular economy (ce) has been increasing in different domains, including business (centobelli et al., 2020; urbinati et al., 2017). notably, the ce model has gained ground among academics, policymakers, and practitioners as an effective way to manage the urgent issues related to climate change and sustainability (marco-fondevila et al., 2020). the concept of ce arises with the objectives of keeping products, components, and materials useable and useful to return to the cycles (rossi et al., 2020). in summary, the aim of a ce is to create circular (closed) loops in which raw materials and other resources are used repeatedly in different phases (yuan et al., 2006) while contributing to waste reduction (aranda-usón et al., 2018). at present, the ce is being implemented worldwide at the micro (company or consumer level), meso (eco-industrial parks), and macro (nations, regions, provinces, and cities) levels (ghisellini et al., 2016). in the european union (eu), a series of communications reports and plans have been implemented to expand the ce principles throughout europe (european commission, 2014, 2015, 2020). http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 for peer review (doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5282 published by university of turin) http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 23 to date, the ce-related research has been mainly developed at the macro level (korhonen, honkasalo, et al., 2018; merli et al., 2018; pomponi & moncaster, 2017). at the micro level, the knowledge on the introduction of the ce model is still in an early stage of development (aranda-usón et al., 2020). studies have focused mainly on the competitiveness of firms, the implementation of circular business models (bocken et al., 2016; witjes & lozano, 2016), or the analysis of the ce in the general principles of sustainability (geissdoerfer et al., 2017; kravchenko et al., 2019). thus, the adoption of the ce by businesses requires the definition and measurement of the impacts generated by adopting circular business models in terms of social, economic, and environmental as pillars of the sustainability paradigm. moreover, the ce systems are considered beneficial for different sustainability dimensions such as resource productivity, job creation, and gross domestic product (european commission, 2020). however, little detailed analysis has been conducted on the impact of the ce on different business sectors, in particular, on the resultant social consequence of the introduction of the ce-related activities in firms. in particular, from the triple bottom line (elkington, 2001), companies must implement indicators that also capture the relationship between circular activities and their repercussions on the corporate sustainability report, which is the leading vehicle for communication through which companies transmit to stakeholders their core ideas and progress on the ce (marco-fondevila et al., 2020). additionally, the improvement of environmental impacts has been related to the closing of material loops espoused by the ec, and the economic aspects are considered intrinsic to the circular business model; however, social implications of the ec remain little explored in business literature. reports and studies have focused on the social aspects of the ce, and they reference mostly job creation as a positive externality of a transition to the ce, which is focused primarily on resource efficiency and recycling and on waste reduction (llorente-gonzález & vence, 2020). notably, the ce model can include generating new jobs, improving employees' quality of life, and linking a system's functioning with the social dimension of management in organisations (mathews & tan, 2011). ce implementation is a complex process, and the role of employees is crucial (khan et al., 2020). in particular, new employment opportunities are largely related to recycling and the reuse of waste, sectors that generate direct employment (european commission, 2015). studies that have analysed the impact of the ce on the labour market predict that the waste sector (classification and management of waste for http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 for peer review (doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5282 published by university of turin) http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 24 reuse and recycling) will generate a large number of jobs and that most ce-related employment opportunities will demand mediumor high-skilled workers (morgan & mitchell, 2015). in summary, a sustainable future can be a reality only if the economies are rearranged on circular principles characterised by a balanced assessment of the economic, social, and environmental needs (momete, 2020) and employment is a relevant pillar for a ce for market and stakeholder's aspects (rossi et al., 2020). however, some questions emerge regarding the selection of social indicators to monitor progress towards a ce at the micro level. an analysis of the literature reveals two gaps. first, there is a general need for detailed knowledge of the implications of the ce on society because the majority of studies have not specifically analysed employment generation as a social impact derived from the business ce. in addition, the fragmented approach to this topic by scholars has made an enhanced analysis of the cerelated employment necessary. thus, this paper fills these two gaps by providing a joint approach to the definition and measurement of the social impact of ce, by analysing job generation at the micro level. as one of the contributions to the literature, this study reflects on the indicators inherent to employment and its different facets as the social impacts of firms in their relationship with stakeholders for sustainability accounting and reporting. to achieve these objectives, the remainder of this paper is structured as follows: the next section investigates the general background, the third section describes the methodological considerations, and the fourth section summarises the findings to state conclusions and reflects on future perspectives of and challenges for the measurement of social impacts of the ce at micro level. 2. background the adoption of the ce by firms contributes to more efficient use of raw materials and resources, to cleaner production, and greater efficiency by increasing the circularity of materials (aranda-usón et al., 2020; jun & xiang, 2011; li et al., 2010; liu et al., 2009; van berkel, 2010). currently, private sector initiatives include technologies and processes for closing the material loops and for circular business models, the introduction of related environmental standards, or specific actions in the framework of http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 for peer review (doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5282 published by university of turin) http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 25 corporate social responsibility (csr). these initiatives are considered important drivers of the ce transformation in many european countries (european commission, 2020). different authors have pointed out that the concept of ce plays a role in sustainable development (ghisellini et al., 2016; korhonen, honkasalo, et al., 2018; marco-fondevila et al., 2020). some definitions of ce are evolving towards enhanced concepts based on the pillars of sustainability (environment, economy, society), and the measurement of these three dimensions in a ce model is a topic in business literature (kristensen & mosgaard, 2020; rossi et al., 2020),: (korhonen, honkasalo, et al., 2018; korhonen, nuur, et al., 2018). nevertheless, it has been argued that the ce literature has prioritised the economic system with primary benefits for the environment and only implicit gains for social aspects (padilla-rivera et al., 2020). besides, the analysis of the diversity and scope of existing ce indicators on all levels points out the prevalence of macro level indicators, while indicators on the meso and micro level are less prevailing. based on these premises, the introduction of the ce in businesses raises the integration of the sustainability paradigm into management practices claimed by the environmental and social-accounting scholars (adams & frost, 2008; adams & larrinaga-gonzález, 2007; adams & mcnicholas, 2006). notably, because conventional accounting seems most suited to the linear cause-effect relationships (bebbington et al., 2017), the introduction of the ce model in firms requires a radical transformative programme based on sustainability that responds to the of inter-locking of the social, environmental, and economic systems that have been pointed out for accounting practices (bebbington & larrinaga, 2014). moreover, despite the difficulties connected to sustainability and social accounting, their potentially significant benefits continue to attract the attention of scholars and practitioners (mauro et al., 2020) for reporting to the internal and external stakeholders through sustainability indicators to accomplish sustainability performance management (warhurst alyson, 2002). the relationship between sustainability accounting and the measurement of the social dimension of the ce is summarised in the synopsis of this study (figure 1). http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 for peer review (doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5282 published by university of turin) http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 26 figure 1. synopsis of the study source: author's elaboration in a ce context, accounting indicators for internal or external reporting are being used in the framework of environmental management accounting to measure flows of materials and waste, for liability management, or the definition of accounting capabilities of firms for the introduction of circular business models (scarpellini et al., 2020). however, companies sparsely use micro level indicators for the social dimension of the ce and further research is necessary (elia et al., 2017; rossi et al., 2020; saidani et al., 2019). in particular, companies need to indicate to stakeholders the social impacts of circular investments and activities. the approach used in this study is not specifically theory-driven, and the research objective is to enhance the knowledge about how to measure the social impacts related to the introduction of the ce in businesses. nevertheless, different authors point out that the stakeholders play an essential role in the adoption by companies of ce principles (banaite & tamosiuniene, 2016; lieder & rashid, 2016; stewart & niero, 2018) and the links of the ce with sustainability accounting and reporting bring this study closer to the http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 for peer review (doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5282 published by university of turin) http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 27 stakeholder theory in line with aranda-usón et al. (2020). from the perspective of the social impact, circular business models have been associated with a high potential in terms of job creation (burger et al., 2019; european commission, 2014; ghisellini et al., 2016; manninen et al., 2018; rizos et al., 2016). notably, the generation of new jobs is one of the most cited social impacts in the literature and is often presented as a measure of the positive social outcome of the ce (llorente-gonzález & vence, 2020). however, this requires further research. although the ce is now understood as a promising model for creating jobs in local infrastructures (fizaine, 2020), or elsewhere (larsson & lindfred, 2019; padilla-rivera et al., 2020), further attention must be paid to net job creation in the ce context. researchers have argued that the transition to a ce has helped create jobs in the last decade (sánchez-ortiz et al., 2020; yuan et al., 2006). an increasing number of authors have used the new jobs related to the ce as an indicator (coats & benton, 2015; hysa et al., 2020; kristensen & mosgaard, 2020; morgan & mitchell, 2015). aranda-usón et al. (2018) determine the impact on employment at the micro level in a region by using the volume of income of the ce-related activities in companies. girard and nocca (2019) define 'circular jobs' as those jobs related to the ce's principles, and rossi et al. (2020) highlight that employment is a social pillar. moreover, the job creation from circular business and different supply chain activities is an indicator of ce's social implications (pieroni et al., 2019). some authors have analysed the possible adverse effects on workers in sectors with environmental impacts, and there is broad agreement that adopting a ce could result in job creation in some sectors and in job losses in others (aranda-usón et al., 2018). also, morgan and mitchell (2015) consider that labour requirements of a growing ce are replacing elsewhere in the economy, for instance, in the production of virgin materials or new products. thus, new jobs are differentiated from those created by substitution or those resulting from the re-definition of redundant jobs. within this social dimension, some studies have also analysed the required skills and education related to a ce (burger et al., 2019; kravchenko et al., 2019). in this sense, education and training contribute to the development of these skills, increase labour productivity, and manage the latest technologies for closing the material loops (chiappetta jabbour et al., 2020), advancing sustainable development. stahel (2016) affirms that the remanufacturing and repairing of old goods, buildings, and infrastructure creates http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 for peer review (doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5282 published by university of turin) http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 28 skilled jobs in local workshops. khan et al. (2020) highlight the relevance of recruiting employees for ce objectives and the need for technical training of production workers to operationalise new plants. additionally, skills and circular jobs remain too generic and difficult to adequately inform ce policy (padilla-rivera et al., 2020). thus, we can argue that the social performance of ce related to jobs also includes employee skills development and specific training (golinska et al., 2015). from another perspective, azevedo et al. (2017) include other factors that must be measured for cerelated jobs, including work accidents, precarious work, or percentage of contracted women. in addition, the harmfulness of the manufacturing process level of comfort at work has been analysed by golinska et al. (2015) and veleva & bodkin (2017). notably, the ce can also contribute to setting the disappearance of low-level occupations (padilla-rivera et al., 2020), and the social re-valorisation of circular activities could lead to an improvement in working conditions and should be considered from a social perspective (kirchherr & piscicelli, 2019). therefore, indicators applied to these impact categories should include more employment conditions to understand the real social dimension of the ce measured through employment (kravchenko et al., 2019). nevertheless, at present, the limited number of indicators considering the social dimension makes it difficult to determine a general approach to this dimension (kristensen & mosgaard, 2020). in some studies, the social goals of a ce have been linked to the sharing economy and participative democratic decision-making that increases the collaborative culture and the number of public partners involved (girard & nocca, 2019; rossi et al., 2020). in this context, sustainability culture must be promoted among employees and suppliers (khan et al., 2020), and the measurement of the employment in a ce context would include community relationships and user relationships (kravchenko et al., 2019). notably, the employee's engagement and awareness in circular businesses is a relevant factor (chiappetta jabbour et al., 2020) and veleva & bodkin (2017) and provides a starting point for developing specific indicators for ce strategies and employee engagement. another factor related to jobs in a ce framework is the innovative character of circular technologies (momete, 2020). rossi et al. (2020) argue that innovations required for new product designs and patents related to recycling and secondary raw materials are social indicators of a ce (golinska et al., 2015; hysa et al., 2020). therefore, knowledge for innovation should be promoted among businesses to develop http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 for peer review (doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5282 published by university of turin) http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 29 intellectual capital for the adoption of the ce by firms, because some traditional jobs are likely to suffer in the transition to a circular model (eea, 2016). in summary, the ce-related activities introduced in businesses involve specific technical and organisational capabilities embedded in a sustainable, productive paradigm (llorente-gonzález & vence, 2020). thus, the measurement of ce-related employment should include more aspects than the number of new jobs. these specific facets that integrate circular employment and the main studies on this topic are summarised in table 1. table 1. ce-related studies classified by different factors of circular employment at the micro level jobs creation as the social indicator of the ce (aranda-usón et al., 2018; burger et al., 2019; girard & nocca, 2019; horbach et al., 2015; hysa et al., 2020; iacovidou et al., 2017; kristensen & mosgaard, 2020; llorente-gonzález & vence, 2020; mesa et al., 2018; momete, 2020; morgan & mitchell, 2015; pieroni et al., 2019; rossi et al., 2020; stahel, 2016; yuan et al., 2006) engagement in the ce principles (chiappetta jabbour et al., 2020; veleva & bodkin, 2017) collaborative culture (girard & nocca, 2019; khan et al., 2020; kravchenko et al., 2019; rossi et al., 2020) net balance of employment generation (aranda-usón et al., 2018; morgan & mitchell, 2015) skills and training (burger et al., 2019; chiappetta jabbour et al., 2020; golinska et al., 2015; khan et al., 2020; kravchenko et al., 2019; padilla-rivera et al., 2020; stahel, 2016) workers' conditions/safety (azevedo et al., 2017; golinska et al., 2015; kirchherr & piscicelli, 2019; kravchenko et al., 2019; padilla-rivera et al., 2020) knowledge for innovation (eea, 2016; golinska et al., 2015; hysa et al., 2020; llorente-gonzález & vence, 2020; momete, 2020; rossi et al., 2020) source: author's elaboration despite the studies listed in table 1, relatively little is known of jobs created by businesses through their ce-related activities. in particular, the analysis of other aspects of circular employment remains fragmented. thus, this paper aims to assist organisations in reporting on their social perspective of the introduction of the ce, and the following research questions are raised: rq1. how can companies measure ce-related jobs at micro level? rq2. what are the different dimensions of the employment related to the circular business model that could be reported by companies? http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 for peer review (doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5282 published by university of turin) http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 30 in the following sections, these research questions are answered by reflecting on a different dimension of ce-related employment through a double-focus qualitative methodology. 3. research design this study is eminently reflective, and the methodology is mainly based on a desk research method. however, different aspects of the ce-related employment and other social impacts of the introduction of the ce in businesses were explored through a regional case study in spain. this study comprises three steps: first, to estimate the impact of the ce in the region, desk research was conducted with a set of specific indicators; second, to analyse perceptions of the adoption of the main cerelated activities in the region at the levels of society, public administrations, and the private sector, 21 semi-structured (in-depth) interviews were conducted; and third, to measure the ce's impacts, employment as a social indicator was analysed. semi-structured interviews have also been used in other ce-specific studies because they allow for processing information that otherwise could not be systematically collected through key informants (geng et al., 2009; uddin, 2020). specifically, the methodology for the analysis was adapted to fit the regional context in which ce was in an incipient state of implementation (everingham et al., 2013) and it is coherent with the methodological insights provided by previous studies (crowe et al., 2011; eisenhardt, 1989; yin, 2009). the ce in the region was measured through 21 interviews of experts selected by the authors as key informants according to the guidelines of the commitment. owing to confidentiality agreements with the interviewees, their identities remain with the authors; however, the list of their profiles is included in table 2. due to the general objective of the study, one-third of the interviewees represents the regional public administrations, one-third represents society, and one-third represents companies or the business sector, in line with the three main stakeholder categories pointed out by banaitė and tamošiūnienė (2016) for a ce. http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 for peer review (doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5282 published by university of turin) http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 31 table 2. profile of the experts selected as key informants type of organisation profile of the experts public administration four engineers, two lawyers, one economist industries and private companies five engineers, one economist, one other r&d institutes, ngos and other organisations one engineer, two lawyers, one chemist, one architect, one sociologist, one journalist source: author's elaboration the interviews, each lasting approximately 30 minutes, were recorded, transcribed and analysed for trends and patterns of response (dolowitz & medearis, 2009). all the interviews are analysed in an aggregated manner by using a qualitative method. in addition, experts were asked to assign a value to each opinion using a likert-type scale ranging from 0 to 10, with 0 being the score that expresses total disagreement or that the interviewee believes the statement to be of no relevance and 10 being the highest valuation, expressing total agreement, or that the interviewees believed the statement to be highly relevant. from the likert-type scale thus constructed, the opinions expressed are divided into three levels: 0–3 is slightly or not at all relevant, 4–7 is moderately relevant and equal to or greater than 8 is very relevant. the case is the spanish region of aragón, and based on the ce having significant economic, environmental, and social impacts at the territorial level (aranda-usón et al., 2018), the impact on employment of the introduction of the ce-related activities in businesses is analysed. this region was selected because of the regional government's commitments to the author that enabled an analysis of the territorial impact of the ce. in recent years, the selected region has experienced an increase in the number of local, small-scale initiatives to implement some of the circular principles (aranda-usón et al., 2018; portillo-tarragona et al., 2017; scarpellini et al., 2019). to date, these initiatives have been mainly adopted in the waste management sector, according to the recommendations for the introduction of the eu (european commission, 2020), the spanish government (gobierno de españa, 2020), and the regional planning for a ce. this study presents the results of additional analysis of the social impacts of business circular activities. as such, the next section attempts to summarise the perception of experts on the impact on employment from the introduction of the ce in regional businesses. http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 for peer review (doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5282 published by university of turin) http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 32 4. main results this study analyses the experts' perceptions of (1) the relevance of the barriers due to a lack of stakeholders' interest, (2) the relevance of the barriers because of a lack of specialised employees, (3) the effectiveness of subsidised training plans for employees, (4) the potential impact of the ce on society, and (5) the potential ce-related job generation. for each question, the average and the frequency of the answers are calculated. table 3 presents the main results. table 3. summarised results of the interviews lack of stakeholders' interest lack of specialised employees subsidised training plans for employees potential impact of ce on society mean 5.30 5.70 6.38 2.60 median 2.00 7.00 8.00 3.00 mode 5.50 6.50 7.00 3.00 sd 3.15 2.79 2.36 1.23 source: author's elaboration for social impact, informants considered that the implementation of a ce would generate different jobs but would not increase the total volume of employment in the region. they pointed out that the ce would require professionals trained in advanced techniques from different scientific backgrounds. in particular, chemists, biologists, physicists, specialised technicians, and specialised lawyers and economists were demanded in the future. the relationship between employment and ce was stated by most of the experts, but the general impact of the ce on society was not corroborated. in summary, from the analysis of the semi-structured interviews, the opinion of the experts interviewed differs according to the organisations they represent (table 4). table 4. summarised results of the interviews, according to the profile of the experts interviewed lack of stakeholders' interest lack of specialised employees subsidised training plans for employees potential impact of ce on society potential cerelated job generation private firms 4.6 4.8 6 2.5 6.8 public administration 4 6.2 7.7 2.4 7.2 society 7.1 5.8 5.5 2.8 6.5 total 5.3 5.7 6.3 2.6 5.8 source: author's elaboration http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 for peer review (doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5282 published by university of turin) http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 33 the most remarkable differences between the respondents' opinions of representatives of public administrations, society, or private companies are detected in the interest of the stakeholders in a ce and the effectiveness of the subsidised training plans. the improvement of the employability of the workforce through training plans related to ce is one of the results obtained through the interviews. figure 2 summarises a schematic classification of the different factors related to employment in a ce context. figure 2. multi-faceted analysis of employment as a social indicator of ce in businesses. source: author's elaboration based on the results, the leading indicators linked to the employment generated by companies that adopted a circular business model companies are selected. however, table 4 shows some differences between the respondents' perception and the relevance of these different aspects of the employment and a hierarchic scheme cannot be elaborated for prioritising these dimensions. it could be argued that the concern of the respondents in this case slightly diverges from the interest expressed by researchers, to date. in particular, academics have widely approached the impact of the ce on employment, but the other specific factors of ce-related jobs are still understudied. figure 2 has been elaborated through the results obtained to outline the close relationships between the employment generated and the multiple factors that affect it. it can be seen how all the dimensions of the circular employment are considered connected to each other. however, its arrangement indicates the conjunctions between the various factors in terms of measurement. for example, innovation is closely http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 for peer review (doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5282 published by university of turin) http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 34 linked to the skills of the employees, which in turn form the necessary engagement for the collaborative scheme required in circular environments. thus, the higher training supposes better work and employability considerations as new jobs generated that imply the net creation of employment that needs to be measured in this multi-faceted social impact in business ce models. 4.1 discussion this study is eminently reflective, and the methodology is mainly based on a desk research method. however, the results of a regional case study are summarised in this study with the mere objective of reflecting on the implications of this analysis from different stakeholders' perceptions of this topic. in addition, the approach used in this study is not specifically theory-driven, and the research objective is to enhance the knowledge on how to measure the social impacts related to the introduction of the ce in businesses. nevertheless, a summarised discussion is presented in next to outline the multiple facets of employment as an indicator of ce. generally, the social dimension of the ce addresses the identification, accounting, and management of the values and needs of different stakeholders of a company (kravchenko et al., 2019). notably, engagement of stakeholders is necessary to enable a transition towards a ce (rossi et al., 2020), in line with the results obtained for social and environmental governance of firms (ortas et al., 2019; rivera et al., 2017) and carbon disclosure (guenther et al., 2016). hence, the analysis of social impacts from the firms' view in a circular context advances the literature to be closer to the stakeholder' theory for reporting processes, in line with aranda-usón et al. (2020). notably, through the reporting, companies may attempt to maintain their licence to operate in a ce and reduce the possible gaps between their stakeholders' expectations in terms of sustainability (hahn & kühnen, 2013; rossi et al., 2020; stewart & niero, 2018). i acknowledge that it would be unrealistic to be unaware of the potential resistance within the institutions of accountancy that makes changes due to the multidimensional character of the ce difficult. nevertheless, i posit that over the years, accountants have evolved towards sustainability principles, and the presence of environmental accounting standards favours the integration of measurement and reporting in all the dimensions that a ce requires. since the critical debate initiated by moneva et al. (2006) on the possible camouflaging of social and environmental accounting and reporting by firms and csr, http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 for peer review (doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5282 published by university of turin) http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 35 environmental and social accounting and the triple bottom line are now concepts more frequently used in the accounting fields, also in ce studies (urmanaviciene & arachchi, 2020). nonetheless, this study corroborates the arguments of kristensen and mosgaard (2020) on the scarcity of the measurement of social impacts in a ce context, an indication of the development of economic and environmental indicators through standards; notably, indicators for the social dimension have not reached the same level of consensus (kristensen & mosgaard, 2020). therefore, the path to the inclusion of the three pillars of sustainability must include moving towards the ce also through accounting and reporting practices. 5. conclusions the original purpose of proposing the concept of ce was to close material loops as a conjunction of economic and environmental improvements, and the interaction with society is a more recently considered aspect in the ce framework. notably, today's business literature has focused mainly on environmental and economic aspects of the ce, not its complex social implications that must be measured for sustainability accounting and reporting in the relationship of firms with stakeholders. this study highlights that experts scarcely consider the relevance of ce in society in the current phase of development of the ce introduction at micro level. the scarcity of social measurements of ce-related activities introduced by businesses is also corroborated, and it highlights the origins of the concept of ce, more focused on eco-efficiency and the economy versus the environment than on the social foundations of the model. undoubtedly, a ce provides substantial environmental and economic opportunities (raw materials saving, competitiveness, and business opportunities) that imply social benefits (jobs generation). however, the forecasted positive social impacts of a ce have not been demonstrated. for this purpose, the companies are required to implement a triple bottom line perspective in which social dimensions of the ce are integrated with environmental and economic aspects as one of the three pillars of sustainability. in this context, this study fills the gap in the literature by investigating the different aspects of the employment linked to ce-related activities introduced by businesses. the multiple facets of employment must be measured by companies to report social concerns to different categories of stakeholders. social http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 for peer review (doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5282 published by university of turin) http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 36 indicators are a key pillar of sustainability accounting and reporting and have important legitimacy in reporting to the internal and external stakeholders to accomplish sustainability performance businesses' management in a ce framework. a contribution derived from the synopsis of this study is the definition of the linkage of circular businesses' and the sustainability accounting and reporting in a ce framework. moreover, these results claim that novel circular business models must enable an explicit analysis of social implications in a triple bottom line perspective. notably, conventional accounting seems unsuited to capture the introduction of the ce model in firms. thus, the integration of the sustainability paradigm into management practices, as has been claimed by environmental and social-accounting scholars, is claimed again regarding the introduction of the ce in businesses. one challenge facing practitioners is the enhanced measurement of social impacts derived by their ce by integrating specific circular indicators in sustainability reporting. therefore, managers seeking ce business investments should increase the engagement among employees to improve specific innovation and management capabilities within firms, with the participation of the accounting structures. similarly, policymakers can further promote ce by providing incentives to firms not only based on the number of new jobs generated but also on the net balance of derived jobs and other indicators for qualitative factors inherent to the employment in a ce framework. the limitations of this study suggest that further interdisciplinary work on this topic is necessary because of the systemic nature of the ce at a firm level. further research must also consider employment generated at a meso level when more companies are involved. empirical investigations of the social impacts of companies that adopt a circular business model could also enhance the results of further research. references adams, c. a., & frost, g. r. (2008). integrating sustainability reporting into management practices. accounting forum, 32(4), 288–302. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.accfor.2008.05.002 adams, c. a., & larrinaga-gonzález, c. (2007). engaging with organisations in pursuit of improved sustainability accounting and performance. accounting, auditing and accountability journal, 20(3), 333–355. https://doi.org/10.1108/09513570710748535 http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 for peer review (doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5282 published by university of turin) http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 37 adams, c. a., & mcnicholas, p. (2006). making a difference: sustainability reporting, accountability and organisational change. accounting, auditing & accountability journal, 20(3), 382–402. https://doi.org/10.1108/09513570710748553 aranda-usón, a., m. moneva, j., portillo-tarragona, p., & llena-macarulla, f. (2018). measurement of the circular economy in businesses: impact and implications for regional policies. economics and policy of energy and the environment, 2(1), 187–205. https://doi.org/10.3280/efe2018-002010 aranda-usón, a., portillo-tarragona, p., scarpellini, s., & llena-macarulla, f. (2020). the progressive adoption of a circular economy by businesses for cleaner production: an approach from a regional study in spain. journal of cleaner production, 247(1), 119648. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2019.119648 azevedo, s. g., godina, r., & matias, j. c. de o. (2017). proposal of a sustainable circular index for manufacturing companies. resources, 6(4), 1–24. https://doi.org/10.3390/resources6040063 banaite, d., & tamosiuniene, r. (2016). sustainable development: the circular economy indicators’ selection model. journal of security and sustainability issues, 6(2), 489–499. https://doi.org/10.9770/jssi.2016.5.3(4) banaitė, d., tamošiūnienė, r., banaite, d., & tamosiuniene, r. (2016). sustainable development: the circular economy indicators’ selection model. journal of security and sustainability issues, 6(2), 315–323. https://doi.org/10.9770/jssi.2016.6.2(10) bebbington, j., & larrinaga, c. (2014). accounting and sustainable development: an exploration. accounting, organizations and society, 39(6), 395–413. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.aos.2014.01.003 bebbington, j., russell, s., & thomson, i. (2017). accounting and sustainable development: reflections and propositions. critical perspectives on accounting, 48, 21–34. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cpa.2017.06.002 bocken, n. m. p., de pauw, i., bakker, c., & van der grinten, b. (2016). product design and business model strategies for a circular economy. journal of industrial and production engineering, 33(5), 308–320. https://doi.org/10.1080/21681015.2016.1172124 burger, m., stavropoulos, s., ramkumar, s., dufourmont, j., & van oort, f. (2019). the heterogeneous skill-base of circular economy employment. research policy, 48(1), 248–261. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.respol.2018.08.015 centobelli, p., cerchione, r., chiaroni, d., del vecchio, p., & urbinati, a. (2020). designing business http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 for peer review (doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5282 published by university of turin) http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 38 models in circular economy: a systematic literature review and research agenda. business strategy and the environment, january, bse.2466. https://doi.org/10.1002/bse.2466 chiappetta jabbour, c. j., de camargo fiorini, p., wong, c. w. y., jugend, d., lopes de sousa jabbour, a. b., roman pais seles, b. m., paula pinheiro, m. a., & ribeiro da silva, h. m. (2020). first-mover firms in the transition towards the sharing economy in metallic natural resource-intensive industries: implications for the circular economy and emerging industry 4.0 technologies. resources policy, 66(january), 101596. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.resourpol.2020.101596 coats, e., & benton, d. (2015). unemployment and the circular economy in europe: a study of opportunities in italy, poland and germany. http://www.greenalliance.org.uk/resources/unemployment and the circular economy in europe.pdf crowe, s., cresswell, k., robertson, a., huby, g., avery, a., & sheikh, a. (2011). the case study approach. medical research methodology, 11(100), 1–9. dolowitz, d. p., & medearis, d. (2009). considerations of the obstacles and opportunities to formalizing cross-national policy transfer to the united states: a case study of the transfer of urban environmental and planning policies from germany. environment and planning c: government and policy, 27(4), 684–697. https://doi.org/10.1068/c0865j eea. (2016). circular economy in europe. developing the knowledge base. in european environment agency (issue 2/2016, pp. 1–37). https://doi.org/10.2800/51444 eisenhardt, k. m. (1989). building theories from case study research. in the qualitative researchers companion (vol. 14, issue 4, pp. 532–550). https://doi.org/10.4135/9781412986274 elia, v., gnoni, m. g., & tornese, f. (2017). measuring circular economy strategies through index methods: a critical analysis. journal of cleaner production, 142, 2741–2751. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2016.10.196 elkington, j. (2001). enter the triple bottom line. the triple bottom line: does it all add up?, 1(1986), 1–16. https://doi.org/10.1021/nl034968f european commission. (2014). communication from the commission to the european parliament, the council, the european economic and social committee and the committee of the regions. towards a circular economy: a zero waste programme for europe. com (2014) 398 final (pp. 1–14). european commission. http://ec.europa.eu/environment/circular-economy/pdf/circular-economycommunication.pdf http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 for peer review (doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5282 published by university of turin) http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 39 european commission. (2015). cloosing the loop an eu action plan for the circular economy. in com/2015/0614 final (vol. 614, p. 21). european commission. https://doi.org/10.1017/cbo9781107415324.004 european commission. (2020). leading the way to a global circular economy: state of play and outlook swd(2020) 100 final. in commission staff working document. https://ec.europa.eu/environment/circular-economy/pdf/leading_way_global_circular_economy.pdf everingham, j. a., pattenden, c., klimenko, v., & parmenter, j. (2013). regulation of resource-based development: governance challenges and responses in mining regions of australia. environment and planning c: government and policy, 31(4), 585–602. https://doi.org/10.1068/c10184 fizaine, f. (2020). the economics of recycling rate: new insights from waste electrical and electronic equipment. resources policy, 67(april), 101675. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.resourpol.2020.101675 geissdoerfer, m., savaget, p., bocken, n. m. p., & hultink, e. j. (2017). the circular economy – a new sustainability paradigm? journal of cleaner production, 143, 757–768. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2016.12.048 geng, y., zhu, q., doberstein, b., & fujita, t. (2009). implementing china’s circular economy concept at the regional level: a review of progress in dalian, china. waste management, 29(2), 996–1002. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.wasman.2008.06.036 ghisellini, p., cialani, c., & ulgiati, s. (2016). a review on circular economy: the expected transition to a balanced interplay of environmental and economic systems. journal of cleaner production, 114(1), 11–32. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2015.09.007 girard, l. f., & nocca, f. (2019). moving towards the circular economy/city model: which tools for operationalizing this model? sustainability (switzerland), 11(22), 1–48. https://doi.org/10.3390/su11226253 gobierno de españa. (2020). españa circular 2030. in estrategia española de economía circular ministerio de economía industria y competitividad (pp. 1–65). gobierno de españa. https://www.miteco.gob.es/es/calidad-y-evaluacion-ambiental/temas/economiacircular/espanacircular2030_def1_tcm30-509532.pdf golinska, p., kosacka, m., mierzwiak, r., & werner-lewandowska, k. (2015). grey decision making as a tool for the classification of the sustainability level of remanufacturing companies. journal of cleaner production, 105(1), 28–40. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2014.11.040 http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 for peer review (doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5282 published by university of turin) http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 40 guenther, e., guenther, t., schiemann, f., & weber, g. (2016). stakeholder relevance for reporting: explanatory factors of carbon disclosure. business and society, 55(3), 361–397. https://doi.org/10.1177/0007650315575119 hahn, r., & kühnen, m. (2013). determinants of sustainability reporting: a review of results, trends, theory, and opportunities in an expanding field of research. journal of cleaner production, 59(1), 5– 21. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2013.07.005 horbach, j., rennings, k., & sommerfeld, k. (2015). circular economy and employment. in 3rd iza workshop: labor market effects of environmental policies. https://sunstiftungsfondhttp//conference.iza.org/conference_files/environ_2015/horbach_j11332.pdf hysa, e., kruja, a., rehman, n. u., & laurenti, r. (2020). circular economy innovation and environmental sustainability impact on economic growth: an integrated model for sustainable development. sustainability, 12(12), 4831. https://doi.org/10.3390/su12124831 iacovidou, e., velis, c. a., purnell, p., zwirner, o., brown, a., hahladakis, j., millward-hopkins, j., & williams, p. t. (2017). metrics for optimising the multi-dimensional value of resources recovered from waste in a circular economy: a critical review. in journal of cleaner production (vol. 166, pp. 910–938). https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2017.07.100 jun, h., & xiang, h. (2011). development of circular economy is a fundamental way to achieve agriculture sustainable development in china. energy procedia, 5, 1530–1534. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.egypro.2011.03.262 khan, o., daddi, t., & iraldo, f. (2020). microfoundations of dynamic capabilities: insights from circular economy business cases. business strategy and the environment, september 2019, 1–15. https://doi.org/10.1002/bse.2447 kirchherr, j., & piscicelli, l. (2019). towards an education for the circular economy (ece): five teaching principles and a case study. resources, conservation and recycling, 150(january), 104406. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.resconrec.2019.104406 korhonen, j., honkasalo, a., & seppälä, j. (2018). circular economy: the concept and its limitations. ecological economics, 143(1), 37–46. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ecolecon.2017.06.041 korhonen, j., nuur, c., feldmann, a., & birkie, s. e. (2018). circular economy as an essentially contested concept. journal of cleaner production, 175, 544–552. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2017.12.111 kravchenko, m., pigosso, d. c., & mcaloone, t. c. (2019). towards the ex-ante sustainability screening http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 for peer review (doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5282 published by university of turin) http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 41 of circular economy initiatives in manufacturing companies: consolidation of leading sustainabilityrelated performance indicators. journal of cleaner production, 241, 118318. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2019.118318 kristensen, h. s., & mosgaard, m. a. (2020). a review of micro level indicators for a circular economy – moving away from the three dimensions of sustainability? journal of cleaner production, 243, 118531. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2019.118531 larsson, a., & lindfred, l. (2019). digitalization, circular economy and the future of labor. in routledge (ed.), the digital transformation of labor (1st editio, issue december 2019). https://doi.org/10.4324/9780429317866-16 li, h., bao, w., xiu, c., zhang, y., & xu, h. (2010). energy conservation and circular economy in china’s process industries. energy, 35(11), 4273–4281. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.energy.2009.04.021 lieder, m., & rashid, a. (2016). towards circular economy implementation: a comprehensive review in context of manufacturing industry. journal of cleaner production, 115, 36–51. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2015.12.042 liu, q., li, h.-m., zuo, x.-l., zhang, f.-f., & wang, l. (2009). a survey and analysis on public awareness and performance for promoting circular economy in china: a case study from tianjin. journal of cleaner production, 17(2), 265–270. https://doi.org/http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2008.06.003 llorente-gonzález, l. j., & vence, x. (2020). how labour-intensive is the circular economy? a policyorientated structural analysis of the repair, reuse and recycling activities in the european union. resources, conservation and recycling, 162(february), 105033. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.resconrec.2020.105033 manninen, k., koskela, s., antikainen, r., bocken, n., dahlbo, h., & aminoff, a. (2018). do circular economy business models capture intended environmental value propositions? journal of cleaner production, 171(1), 413–422. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2017.10.003 marco-fondevila, m., llena-macarulla, f., callao-gastón, s., & jarne-jarne, j. i. (2020). are circular economy policies actually reaching organizations? evidence from the largest spanish companies. cleaner production, in press, 124658. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2020.124858 mathews, j. a., & tan, h. (2011). progress toward a circular economy in china: the drivers (and http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 for peer review (doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5282 published by university of turin) http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 42 inhibitors) of eco-industrial initiative. journal of industrial ecology, 15(3), 435–457. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1530-9290.2011.00332.x mauro, s. g., cinquini, l., simonini, e., & tenucci, a. (2020). moving from social and sustainability reporting to integrated reporting: exploring the potential of italian public-funded universities’ reports. sustainability (switzerland), 12(8), 3172. https://doi.org/10.3390/su12083172 merli, r., preziosi, m., & acampora, a. (2018). how do scholars approach the circular economy? a systematic literature review. journal of cleaner production, 178(1), 703–722. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2017.12.112 mesa, j., esparragoza, i., & maury, h. (2018). developing a set of sustainability indicators for product families based on the circular economy model. journal of cleaner production, 196(1), 1429–1442. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2018.06.131 momete, d. c. (2020). a unified framework for assessing the readiness of european union economies to migrate to a circular modelling. science of the total environment, 718, 137375. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.scitotenv.2020.137375 moneva, j. m., archel, p., & correa, c. (2006). gri and the camouflaging of corporate unsustainability. accounting forum, 30(2), 121–137. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.accfor.2006.02.001 morgan, j., & mitchell, p. (2015). employment and the circular economy. job creation in a more resource efficient britain. https://doi.org/10.13140/rg.2.1.1026.5049 ortas, e., gallego-álvarez, i., & álvarez, i. (2019). national institutions, stakeholder engagement, and firms’ environmental, social, and governance performance. corporate social responsibility and environmental management, 26(3), 598–611. https://doi.org/10.1002/csr.1706 padilla-rivera, a., russo-garrido, s., & merveille, n. (2020). addressing the social aspects of a circular economy: a systematic literature review. sustainability (switzerland), 12(19), 1–17. https://doi.org/10.3390/su12197912 pieroni, m. p. p., mcaloone, t. c., & pigosso, d. c. a. (2019). business model innovation for circular economy and sustainability: a review of approaches. journal of cleaner production, 215(1), 198– 216. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2019.01.036 pomponi, f., & moncaster, a. (2017). circular economy for the built environment: a research framework. journal of cleaner production, 143, 710–718. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2016.12.055 portillo-tarragona, p., scarpellini, s., llena, f., & aranda-usón, a. (2017). nivel de implantación de la http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 for peer review (doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5282 published by university of turin) http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 43 economía circular en aragón (cesa consejo económico y social de aragón (ed.)). © consejo económico y social de aragón. https://www.aragon.es/estaticos/gobiernoaragon/organosconsultivos/consejoeconomicosocialar agon/areas/publicaciones/estudios/2017/economia_circular_ed_integra.pdf rivera, j. m., muñoz, m. j., & moneva, j. m. (2017). revisiting the relationship between corporate stakeholder commitment and social and financial performance. sustainable development, 25(6), 482–494. https://doi.org/10.1002/sd.1664 rizos, v., behrens, a., van der gaast, w., hofman, e., ioannou, a., kafyeke, t., flamos, a., rinaldi, r., papadelis, s., hirschnitz-garbers, m., & topi, c. (2016). implementation of circular economy business models by small and medium-sized enterprises (smes): barriers and enablers. sustainability (switzerland), 8(11), 1–18. https://doi.org/10.3390/su8111212 rossi, e., bertassini, a. c., ferreira, c. dos s., neves do amaral, w. a., & ometto, a. r. (2020). circular economy indicators for organizations considering sustainability and business models: plastic, textile and electro-electronic cases. journal of cleaner production, 247. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2019.119137 saidani, m., yannou, b., leroy, y., cluzel, f., & kendall, a. (2019). a taxonomy of circular economy indicators. journal of cleaner production, 207(1), 542–559. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2018.10.014 sánchez-ortiz, j., rodríguez-cornejo, v., del río-sánchez, r., & garcía-valderrama, t. (2020). indicators to measure efficiency in circular economies. sustainability (switzerland), 12(11). https://doi.org/10.3390/su12114483 scarpellini, s., marín-vinuesa, l. m., aranda-usón, a., & portillo-tarragona, p. (2020). dynamic capabilities and environmental accounting for the circular economy in businesses. sustainability accounting, management and policy journal, 11(7), 1129–1158. https://doi.org/10.1108/sampj04-2019-0150 scarpellini, s., portillo-tarragona, p., aranda-usón, a., & llena-macarulla, f. (2019). definition and measurement of the circular economy’s regional impact. journal of environmental planning and management, 62(13), 2211–2237. https://doi.org/10.1080/09640568.2018.1537974 stahel, w. r. (2016). the circular economy. nature, 531(7595), 435–438. https://doi.org/10.1038/531435a http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 for peer review (doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5282 published by university of turin) http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 44 stewart, r., & niero, m. (2018). circular economy in corporate sustainability strategies: a review of corporate sustainability reports in the fast-moving consumer goods sector. business strategy and the environment, 27(7), 1005–1022. https://doi.org/10.1002/bse.2048 uddin, m. j. (2020). how the agent-based banking model might facilitate financial inclusion and sustainability via economic circularity ? – a bangladesh perspective. european journal of social impact and circular economy, 1(2), 76–94. urbinati, a., chiaroni, d., & chiesa, v. (2017). towards a new taxonomy of circular economy business models. journal of cleaner production, 168(1), 487–498. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2017.09.047 urmanaviciene, a., & arachchi, u. s. (2020). the effective methods and practices for accelerating social entrepreneurship through corporate social responsibility. european journal of social impact and circular economy, 1(2), 27–47. https://doi.org/10.13135/2704-9906/5085 van berkel, r. (2010). quantifying sustainability benefits of industrial symbioses. journal of industrial ecology, 14(3), 371–373. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1530-9290.2010.00252.x veleva, v., & bodkin, g. (2017). emerging drivers and business models for equipment reuse and remanufacturing in the us: lessons from the biotech industry. journal of environmental planning and management, 61(9), 1631–1653. warhurst alyson. (2002). sustainability indicators and sustainability performance management. mining, minerals and sustainable development, 43(43), 129. http://pubs.iied.org/pdfs/g01026.pdf witjes, s., & lozano, r. (2016). towards a more circular economy: proposing a framework linking sustainable public procurement and sustainable business models. resources, conservation and recycling, 112(1), 37–44. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.resconrec.2016.04.015 yin, r. k. (2009). case study research: design and methods. in essential guide to qualitative methods in organizational research (vol. 5, issue 5). https://doi.org/10.1097/fch.0b013e31822dda9e yuan, z., bi, j., moriguichi, y., & zengwei yuan, jun bi, and y. m. (2006). the circular economy: a new development strategy in china. journal of industrial ecology, 10(1–2), 4–8. https://doi.org/10.1162/108819806775545321 04_apostol european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5529 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 38 evaluation of the livelihood assistance of a social protection agency in region-7 central visayas desiree jill apostol1 1 international university, philippines. e-mail: eslteacherdesiree@gmail.com received: 15/01/2021 accepted for publication: 06/11/2021 published: 12/11/2021 abstract this study aimed to evaluate the livelihood assistance given by the social protection agency to persons-with-workrelated disability (pwrds) or to those workers who have met work-related contingency. out of the 20 clients communicated by the researcher only 9 of them have responded with willingness to be interviewed. data collection was done through interview utilizing questionnaires. these questionnaires were designed into a google form and was sent to each respondents by link through their online messaging accounts. the study explored into the bottlenecks in each of the following stages in the acquisition and implementation of the livelihood of the pwrds: planning, attending livelihood training/seminar, purchasing, onset and lastly, maintenance of the livelihood. majority of the respondents expressed difficulties during the onset and maintenance of their livelihood. the challenge during the onset is the presence of customer debts, no space to display products, lack of knowledge to advertise, no customer at times and lack of supplies to sell. although majority of the clients have been able to maintain their livelihood, those who haven’t answered that their return to formal job employment and the recent pandemic brought about by covid-19 were factors for their livelihood to fail. keywords: livelihood assistance; persons-with-work-related disability; bottlenecks; challenges; onset and maintenance of livelihood 1. introduction in the philippines, a social protection agency is mandated to implement the employees compensation program by the virtue of presidential decree 626, as amended. it is through assisting employees who meet work-related contingencies such as sickness, accident, and death. the programs include the loss of income benefit, carer’s allowance, medical reimbursement, and rehabilitation programs. the kagabay program under the rehabilitation program is a special economic assistance program of the commission that aims to bring the persons-with-work-related disabilities (pwrds) back to the economic mainstream. the kagabay program is to provide equal access to livelihood opportunities and assist the pwrds in setting up their self-managed enterprise or home-based business. the livelihood assistance amounts to thirty thousand pesos (php30,000.00) in total. to breakdown, twenty thousand pesos (php20,000.00) is for their starter kit and the ten thousand pesos (php10,000.00) is for their complimentary kit if their business has been maintained after six months to one year. the process of granting livelihood assistance to the identified clients would include social preparation session that is being done on the first day the client will apply for the kagabay program. the pwrds are also given a one-day entrepreneurial development training seminar where basic business concepts are discussed. the clients will fill-up a business european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5529 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 39 plan form where they will stipulate the kind of business they plan to engage with, and the materials supplies they will purchase using the twenty thousand pesos grant. the assigned regional personnel will accompany the client in purchasing their livelihood starter kit. the researcher felt that there are some lacking process and requirement in the granting of the livelihood assistance of the agency. this study aims to evaluate the implementation of the livelihood assistance program in region 7 in fy 2017 to 2019. particularly, it sought to answer the following sub-questions: 1. what were the challenges/issues/problems encountered by the clients during the following stages of their livelihood? 1.1. planning the type of business 1.2. training-seminar proper 1.3. purchasing of their livelihood starter kits 1.4. onset of their livelihood 1.5. maintaining their livelihood 2. methodology this is a qualitative type of research that would collect information on the factors that affect the effectiveness of the livelihood program, the cause for the success or failure in the sustenance of the persons-with work-related disabilities’ livelihood and the recommendation in the improvement of the livelihood program. interview in the form of questionnaires utilizing the google form platform on the internet will be given to the respondents which will allow them to give their free form of answers. also, several yes-no questions are present in the questionnaires. the researcher will gather qualifiable information to analyze the practice of the respondents. the researcher will seek information and data from randomly selected persons with work related disabilities who have benefitted from the twenty thousand pesos (php20, 000.00) worth of livelihood assistance starter kit. the researcher will inform the respondents regarding their participation in the study. a google form link will be sent through them through the electronic mail or any of the respondent available messaging applications on the internet. confidentiality to the respondents’ data and result of interview questionnaires will be highly emphasized in the letter. 2.1 data interpretation table 1. what was your motivation to engage in business? responses frequency average family 4 50% additional income 2 25% disability 1 12.5% success in life 1 12.5% total 8 100% source: author’s elaboration as shown in table 1, family reasons have the highest percentage at 50% while disability and success in life have the lowest percentage at 12.5% each. it has been noted that filipinos have close family ties (asian journal media centre), thus leading to the majority of the respondent’s mentioning family as their motivation to engage in entrepreneurship. the potential to make money or additional income is one of the reasons why many people get into entrepreneurship (larry alton, 2015). table 2. what type of business are you currently involved with? responses frequency average none 1 12.5% sari-sari store 3 37.5% sari-sari store with hog raising 1 12.5%% welding 2 25% piso tubig machine 1 12.5% total 8 100% source: author’s elaboration european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5529 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 40 as shown in table 2, 37.5% is having a sari-sari store as the highest while the lowest are the following: none (no business in existence), sari-sari store with hog raising, and peso tubig machine at 12.5% each. according to www.tycoon.ph, a sari-sari store can be a good source of income if managed properly. thus, making it the first choice of livelihood for filipinos. table 3. why did you choose this type of business? responses frequency average knowledge on how to run the business 1 12.5% easy to manage 2 25% saleable 3 37.5% welding shop 1 12.5% no competitor 1 12.5 total 8 100% source: author’s elaboration table 3 shows that 37.5% of the respondents chose their business because of its saleability and this is the highest percentage. the lowest percentage at 12.5% each are the following: no competitor; knowledge on how to run a business; and welding shop. table 4. have you encountered difficulty in choosing the business? responses frequency average yes 2 25% no 6 75% total 8 100% source: author’s elaboration as shown in table 4, the highest response is no at 75% while the lowest is no at 25%. table 5. have you attended ecc’s entrepreneurship livelihood training/seminar? responses frequency average yes 7 87.5% no 1 12.5% total 8 100% source: author’s elaboration as shown in table 5, the highest is yes at 87.5% while lowest is no at 12.5%. table 6. what was the most important lesson you have learned from the training/seminar? responses frequency average about business management 3 37.5% right ways of doing business and how to grow business 2 25% planning and loving work 1 12.5% entrepreneurship, budgeting and customer service 1 12.5% time management, marketing strategies and quality business procedures 1 12.5% total 8 100% source: author’s elaboration european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5529 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 41 as shown in table 6, business management has the highest percentage at 37.5% while the lowest at12.5% for the following: planning and loving work; entrepreneurship, budgeting, and customer service; and time management, marketing strategies, and quality business procedures. table 7. did this lesson help you in pursuing your livelihood? responses frequency average yes 8 100% no 0 0% total 8 100% source: author’s elaboration as shown in table 7, 100% of the respondents answered that the lesson helped them in pursuing their livelihood. table 8. how much have you received from ecc to purchase your livelihood starter kit? responses frequency average php20,000.00 6 75% php20,000.00 and php10,000.00 1 12.5% php30,000.00 1 12.5% total 8 100% source: author’s elaboration table 8 shows the amount of the starter kit provided by ecc to the respondents. highest percentage is at 75% which is php20, 000.00 while lowest at 12.5% which is php30, 000.00. table 9. did you create a list of the things you have to buy as your livelihood starter kit? responses frequency average yes 8 100% no 0 0% total 8 100% source: author’s elaboration as shown in table 9, 100% of the respondents answered yes that they have created a list of the things they have to purchase. table 10. have you followed the list completely or have done some revisions while purchasing? responses frequency average yes 7 87.5% no 1 12.5% total 8 100% source: author’s elaboration table 10 shows the highest response is yes at 87.5% while the lowest is no at 12.5%. table 11. did you have any difficulties while buying/purchasing your starter kit? responses frequency average yes 0 0% no 7 87.5% maybe 1 12.5 total 8 100% source: author’s elaboration table 11 shows that no has the highest percentage at 87.5% while maybe at 12.5% is the lowest. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5529 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 42 table 12. why? responses frequency average sari-sari store business is easy to purchase 1 12.5% me and my wife already know what we need to buy for the business we have chosen 1 12.5% the supply store is very near to us 1 12.5% i already have my list for my starter kit 3 37.5% ecc representative assisted me well. 1 12.5% doesn’t have a personal transportation 1 12.5% total 8 100% source: author’s elaboration as shown in table 12, 37.5% answered having a list for their starter kit is the highest while the rest of the answers have the lowest percentages at 12.5% each. table 13. do you think that php20, 000.00 worth of starter kit was enough? responses frequency average yes 4 50% no 2 25% maybe 2 25% total 8 100% source: author’s elaboration table 13 shows that 50% of the respondents answered that the prescribed amount was enough for their livelihood starter kit and is the highest percentage while the lowest is no and maybe, both having 25% weight. table 14. why? responses frequency average because rice and canned goods are expensive 1 12.5% purchased the basic consumables with the amount given 1 12.5% everything needed were purchased including refrigerator 1 12.5% 20,000.00 was enough for the welding kits 1 12.5% i was able to purchase all for welding 1 12.5% a lot of stocks 1 12.5% for the past year, 20,000.00php is enough but for the present it is not because of the higher price of goods and products 1 12.5% expensive water dispenser 1 12.5% total 8 100% source: author’s elaboration each of the respondents gave different opinions on why they think that 20,000.00 was enough or not enough for the livelihood starter kit as shown in table 14. there was no highest nor lowest percentage on this table. table 15. how did you feel when you first started your livelihood? responses frequency average happy 2 25% happy and excited 1 12.5% amazed 1 12.5% excited 1 12.5% just fine 1 12.5% european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5529 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 43 happy because i felt i still have worth in spite of my disability 1 12.5% happy and satisfied 1 12.5% total 8 100% source: author’s elaboration table 15 shows that the highest response is happy at 25% while the rest of the response are the lowest and shares the same percentage at 12.5% each. table 16. did you have any difficulty in display or marketing your products? responses frequency average yes 3 37.5% no 5 62.5% total 8 100% source: author’s elaboration table 17 shows that the highest is the no response at 62.5% while the lowest is yes at 37.5%. table 18. what was the most challenging part of selling your products? responses frequency average customer debt (utang) 2 25% competitors 1 12.5% no business stall to display products 2 25% lack of knowledge to advertise my business 1 12.5% no customer 1 12.5% no more water to sell 1 12.5% total 8 100% source: author’s elaboration on table 18, the highest responses are customer debt, and no business stall to display products at 12.5% each. the rest of the responses are the lowest and having 12.5% each. according to www.tycoon.ph, when your business is located in a community where familiar names and faces make up the majority of your market, the sari-sari store becomes victim to use and abuse. hence, the threat of long-term debt. table 19. were you able to gain any profit from selling the products from the starter kit given by ecc? responses frequency average yes 7 87.5% no 0 % maybe 1 12.5% total 8 100% source: author’s elaboration as shown in table 19, the highest is yes at 87.5% while the lowest is maybe at 12.5%. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5529 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 44 table 20. is your livelihood/business still existing? responses frequency average yes 6 75% no 2 25% total 8 100% source: author’s elaboration in table 20, 75% of the respondents still have their business in existence as the highest response while 25% does not exist is the lowest response. table 21. why do you think your livelihood is sustained? if no, what do you think happened that made the business a failure? responses frequency average product is affordable and no debt allowed 1 12.5% sari-sari store still existing and profit is being enjoyed 1 12.5% formal job employment 1 12.5% due to pandemic, people lost their job so we lost customers too. 1 12.5% good maintenance 1 12.5% when there are customers, i do their request right away 1 12.5% right business management 1 12.5% yes 1 12.5% total 8 100% source: author’s elaboration as shown in table 21, each of the respondents gave different reasons on why their business was successfully sustained or failed and shared the same percentage at 12.5% each. table 22. have you received an additional 10,000php as complementary kit from ecc? responses frequency average yes 6 75% no 2 25% total 8 100% source: author’s elaboration table 22 shows that 75% of the respondents responded with yes which is the highest while the lowest response at 25% is no. table 23. what type of livelihood kit did you purchase with the additional 10,000php? responses frequency average additional stocks for my barbecue business 1 12.5% sari-sari store 1 12.5% load retailing and ice candy business 1 12.5% hog raising 1 12.5% additional welding kits 2 25% if there is, products for online selling 1 12.5% one peso tubig machine 1 12.5% total 8 100% source: author’s elaboration as shown in table 23, 25% answered buying additional welding kits is the highest response while the rest of the responses are at 12.5% each and the lowest. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5529 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 45 table 24. do you think the amount of 10,000php was enough as a complementary kit? responses frequency average yes 4 50% no 3 37.5% maybe 1 12.5% total 8 100% source: author’s elaboration as shown in table 24, the highest response is yes at 50% while the lowest is maybe at 12.5%. 3. results the objective of this study is to evaluate the livelihood program provided by a social protection agency in region 7. the results of the study will provide inputs to the development of the program. thus, it will also improve the services of the agency. 1. problem: what were the challenges/issues/problems encountered by the clients during the following stages of their livelihood? .1 planning the type of business saleability of products was the highest response at 37.5% regarding the reason on choosing the type of business. it is seconded by ease of management. while the rest of the answers are the knowledge on how to run the business, no competitor and welding shop. most of the respondents at 75% answered that they had no difficulty in choosing their business while 25% of the response was that they had difficulty in choosing their business. 1.2 training-seminar proper majority of the respondents at 87.5% answered that they were able to attend the livelihood training seminar of the agency while 12.5% have not attended. according to the respondents, the most important lesson they learned from the seminar is about business management (37.5%), right ways to do business and how to grow business (25%), planning and loving work (12.5%), entrepreneurship, budgeting and customer service (12.5%), and time management, marketing strategies and quality business procedures. all of the respondents at 100% answered that the lesson they learned from the seminar help them in pursuing their livelihood. .2 purchasing of their livelihood starter kits in preparing the list of things to buy in their starter kits, 100% of the respondents answered with yes. the respondents who followed the list completely is at 87.5% while 12.5% answered that they have done some revisions while buying. the respondents at 87.5% said that they did not have difficulty while buying while 12.5% answered with maybe. with the follow-up question asking why they have or not have difficulty, most of the respondents answered having a prepared list (37.5%), 12.5% for each of the following reasons: sari-sari store business is easy to manage, already know what to buy, the supply store is near, ecc representative assisted well and lastly, does not have a personal transportation. majority of the respondents at 50% answered that 20,000php was enough for the starter kit while 25% with no and another 25% for maybe. with the follow-up question on why they think it is sufficient or not, mostly mentioned that they were able to buy everything in the list with the prescribed amount while at 25% answered that because of the increase in the price commodities nowadays, the prescribed amount is not sufficient anymore. .3 onset of their livelihood the respondents at 25% answered that they were happy during the onset of their livelihood while the rest of the answers are at 12.5% each and has mentioned the words, “happy” and “excited”. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5529 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 46 most of the respondents at 62.5% answered that they didn’t have any difficulty in displaying their product while 37.5% answered yes that they had difficulty in doing so. according to the respondents, the most difficult part of selling their products are the following: customer debt (25%), no business stall to display (12.5%), lack of knowledge to advertise (12.5%), no customer (12.5%) and lack of water (products) to sell. .4 maintaining their livelihood most of the respondents at 87.5% answered that they were able to gain profit from the 20,000php worth of starter kit given by the agency while 12.5 answered with maybe. most of the respondent at 75% still have their business in existence while 25% answered that their business is not existing anymore. with the follow-up question on why do they think their business is sustained or why it has failed, the respondents gave the following answers: product is affordable and no debt allowed (12.5%), sari-sari store still existing and profit is being enjoyed (12.5%), formal job employment (12.5%), due to pandemic, people lost their job so we lost customers too (12.5%), good maintenance (12.5%), right business management (12.5%), and, yes (12.5%). most of the respondents at 75% said yes, they have received the additional 10,000php as complementary kit from ecc while 25% haven’t receive yet. respondents answered that they bought additional welding kits (25%), others are additional stocks for barbeque business (12.5%), sari-sari store (12.5%), load retailing and ice candy business (12.5%), hog raising (12.5%), peso tubig machine (12.5%), and if there is (additional 10,000php) products for online selling (12.5%). most of the respondents at 50% think that 10,000php is enough for the complementary kit, 37.5% answered that it is not enough and 12.5% answered with maybe. 4. conclusion and recommendation based on the findings of the study, the researcher therefore concludes that there was little to no difficulty faced by the respondents during the planning stage of their livelihood, training-seminar proper and until the purchasing of the livelihood starter kit. the research also concludes that the respondents had faced difficulty during the onset of their livelihood and in selling of their products because of the presence of the following factors: customer debt, no business stall to display and lack of knowledge in advertising. they also had difficulty in maintaining their business because of their formal job employment and the on-going pandemic brought about by covid-19. it can also be concluded that the prescribed amount of twenty thousand pesos (20,000php) for the livelihood starter kit is sufficient and ten thousand pesos (10,000php) for complementary kit needs to be reconsidered. based on the findings presented and conclusions made, the following recommendations are being offered: • the employees compensation commission should conduct a thorough assessment on clients’ livelihood training needs. in addition, ecc should also prepare a comprehensive course syllabus and should consult trainers and entrepreneurship experts with regards to livelihood training-seminar. it should also include lectures on the different stages of the livelihood process most specifically on the onset and maintenance of the livelihood that includes marketing strategies, handling customers and basic accounting. • furthermore, the agency should conduct a thorough assessment on the clients’ capabilities in handling a livelihood. it should also assess if clients have a proper space or avenue to display and market their products. • the agency should do an actuarial study on the prescribed amount of starter and complementary kit tailored-fit to the supplies needed for the specific business and the expected increase of prices of commodities. references alton, l. (2015). the 5 motivations that drive people to choose entrepreneurship. www.entrepreneur.com. https://www.entrepreneur.com/article/249417 european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5529 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 47 employees compensation commission. (2000). prescribing the amount of starter kit provided to persons with work-related disabilities (pwrds) as part of their skills/ entrepreneurial training at an amount ranging from php 20,000 to php 30,000 per worker. www.ecc.gov.ph. retrieved december 23, 2020, from http://ecc.gov.ph/board-resolution-no-18-02-06/ manarang, r. (n.d.). top 10 sari-sari store business tips in the philippines. www.tycoon.ph. retrieved january 8, 2021, from https://tycoon.ph/top-10-sari-sari-store-business-tips-philippines/ velmonte, g. (2020). contributions of cooperatives to economic development. cape comorin, ii(ii), 70–76. https://www.capecomorinjournal.org.in/uploads/volume%20ii%20issue%20ii%20july%202020/15%20glenn%20 l.%20velmonte.pdf the employees compensation commission and state insurance fund (presidential decree no. 626, as amended). (2013). www.ecc.gov.ph. http://ecc.gov.ph/wp-content/uploads/2015/09/pd_626_2013_edition.pdf what is a livelihood? (n.d.). www.ifrc.org. retrieved january 8, 2021, from https://www.ifrc.org/en/what-we-do/disastermanagement/from-crisis-to-recovery/what-is-a-livelihood/ unboxing filipino culture: close family ties and most loved items in a balikbayan box. (n.d.). www.asianjournal.com. retrieved january 8, 2021, from https://www.asianjournal.com/magazines/unboxingfilipino-culture-close-family-ties-and-most-loved-items-in-a-balikbayan-box/ 5100-article text-16396-1-11-20201211 http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5100 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 58 regenerative post covid-19 recovery measures: the case of rwanda alaa ben abdallah1 and rudi michiel ackerman2 1 international business and trade, african leadership university, kigali, rwanda 2 international business and trade, african leadership university, kigali, rwanda 1a.benabdall@alustudent.com 2rudi.ackerman23@gmail.com received: 15/09/2020 revised: 12/11/2020 accepted for publication: 07/12/2020 published: 18/12/2020 abstract governments worldwide are scrambling to combat both the biological and economic effects of the global covid-19 pandemic. given urban unemployment and poverty induced by the global pandemic, this paper asks if developing countries could use regenerative agriculture as a form of poverty alleviation. by using rwanda as a case study, this paper analyzes two of the existent home-grown poverty alleviation initiatives for rural food security: girinka (have a cow) and akarima k’igikoni (kitchen gardens). we investigate if the rural akarima k’igikoni initiative could be implemented in urban areas. using descriptive statistical data gathered during the pandemic in rwanda’s capital, kigali, we found rainwater collection practices already well established. we find that many households already separate waste, but that only some households practice composting and home-gardening. we conclude with several recommendations on how the rwandan government’s commitment to sustainable development and urban agglomeration in the vision 2050 strategy can be achieved. using already well-established policy mechanisms like the “umudugudu” (=village) network and the akarima k’igikoni initiative, rwanda can better weather the economic effects of the global pandemic. these mechanisms present a valuable opportunity for rwandan businesses to invest in composting activities and regenerative practices in their buildings and waste management systems. other developing countries can also learn valuable lessons from an environmentally sustainable and home-grown poverty alleviation policy. http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5100 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 59 keywords: sustainability; covid19; rwanda; vision 2050; regenerative agriculture; circular food systems; decentralisation 1. introduction the effects of the global coronavirus pandemic are yet to be fully quantified, but undeniably had a detrimental effect on the economy and its people (nicola et al., 2020). as many economies failed the people they are supposed to serve from health systems and education to sustenance and job security the pandemic has taught us that there is no option of going back to normal; sustainable practices are not just a nice-to-have but a must-have. the destructive scale of climate change is projected to far exceed the damages caused by the coronavirus since it endangers our own existence on earth. climate changeinduced temperature increase is “predicted to reach up to 3.25°c by the end of the century” (bendito and twomlow, 2015), which is 1.25°c above the degree limit to control climate change repercussions (2°c) (koch, 2014). because of their heavy reliance on rain-fed crop production, developing countries and more specifically african countries will disproportionately experience the disastrous effects of climate change such as the frequent droughts and floods and increasing wind speeds that affect, sometimes irreversibly, the crops as well as the initial poverty of the population and limits the capacity to adapt (mikova et al., 2015). ironically, while humanity struggled with the economic, social, and biological effects of the virus, the biosphere seemed to recover (nasa, 2020). it is disappointing that it had to take a global pandemic for us to pause our environmentally destructive economic activities. this pause gives us all a valuable moment to reconsider our actions and policies. in this paper, we will show the key role that sustainability can play in the recovery process after covid19 for developing countries. by using rwanda as an example, we will show in the literature review the historical efficacy of regenerative initiatives such as the girinka project. in sections four and five we will use data from a field research study conducted in the midst of the lockdown to show that kigali may be ready for expanding the akarima k’igikoni project (a more recent regenerative agriculture project launched in 2019) as part of a post-covid19 recovery process in peri-urban centres. finally, we present policy recommendations in section six and summarise our findings based on obstacles identified in our field research in section seven. there are various important solutions that rwanda has implemented to recover from economic and social hardship after the 1994 genocide against the tutsi in rwanda. one such solution was to implement a form of home-grown universal basic income called the girinka project a system by which all families http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5100 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 60 received a milk cow as a food source. after the food security brought about by the girinka project, and in order to further diversify vitamin intake, the akarima k’igikoni initiative was implemented a kitchen garden based on circular food system principles. both these initiatives were supported by the umudugudu1 network and umuganda an innovative and uniquely rwandan community service event that proved a very effective way of enacting national policies locally. our research builds upon these and other measures. however, our recommendations only represent one piece of the sustainability puzzle more research into the circular economy, biomimicry, green businesses and renewable energies needs to still be done to help develop a sustainable macroeconomy. we build upon the research done on circular food systems by the ellen macarthur foundation (2019). a more comprehensive review of terms such as regenerative agriculture, circular food systems and composting can be obtained from their comprehensive cities and food for circular economy report (see ellen macarthur foundation, 2019 and nijman, 2020). our solutions offer guidance around circular food systems that are home-grown, regenerative, and supportive of the urban agglomeration agenda of rwanda’s vision 2050 development strategy. it is important to realise, as kolinjivadi put it (kolinjivadi, in selby and kagawa, 2020:3); “[both covid-19 and climate change] are rooted in the same abusive economic behaviour, and both have proven to be deadly for humans”. it is therefore imperative that our economic recovery measures after the pandemic also address (and not further exacerbate) our environmental impact. 2. context of the covid-19 pandemic rwanda responded to international concerns around the novel sars strain by installing handwashing stations in and around public transportation hubs, restaurants, commercial centres and banks in its major cities by 11 march 2020. the government tested all incoming air travellers and confirmed the first case on 14 march 2020 a foreign national travelling to rwanda. on 16 march, the government declared all large gatherings, education and religious institutions to be closed in the country to limit the spread, and introduced social distancing, mask-wearing and hand-washing rules. these were strictly adhered to with 1 the closest translation for umudugudu is “village”, and is the smallest administrative division in rwanda. an umudugudu normally consists of around 200 1000 people, and come together on the last saturday of every month for umuganda, a collective community service event. some umuganda days are used for neighbourhood cleanup, repairing of houses or public infrastructure, or the planting of vegetable gardens (akarima k’igikoni). for more on the umudugudu and umuganda, see uwimbabazi and lawrence (2013) http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5100 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 61 penalties like spending a night in the local stadium while being recited the dangers of the virus, among others (asala, 2020). on 20 march, a full lock-down was implemented with all international flights suspended, non-cargo travel between provinces prohibited, all non-essential travel banned and all incoming travellers were subject to 14-day mandatory quarantine. only essential services businesses were allowed to operate and movement was strictly enforced with a daily curfew of 9pm-5am. our own data (figure 1 below) shows that income levels in our sample dropped by an average of 76 per cent in the sample taken for kigali during this time of lockdown mostly because of how hard-hit the informal economy was. gradually, the rwandan government relaxed certain restrictions and opened up segments of the economy most notably the tourism and hospitality industry which is rwanda’s largest source of foreign reserves (aoec, 2020). by 1 july 2020, most domestic business activities had been allowed to resume (people were asked to work from home if possible and strict social distancing and mask-wearing policies were in place for those who could not). by 1 august 2020, international flights and tourism had been allowed to resume, subject to strict quarantine and social distancing policies. for the purpose of this study, when we refer to ‘lockdown restrictions’, we generally refer to the period between march 2020 and july 2020. the data used in this study was collected in the first week of july 2020. as such, it shows the behaviour of households within the peri-urban areas of kigali after the worst lockdown restrictions have started to lift, as well as their responses during lockdown. our study shows that the right conditions are in place in kigali’s peri-urban areas to make use of decentralised regenerative agriculture as a way of poverty alleviation. most respondents have the right abilities and practices in place to use productive home gardens for sustenance. this is a particularly relevant insight following the depths with which the global pandemic has exposed the thin margin on which much of the informal economy survives. as a developing capital with large peri-urban areas and a large informal economy (ackerman, 2020), kigali is a good model for other developing capitals in subsaharan africa. it is also among the fastest growing economies, and the government has a strong focus on industrialising within environmental limits. our study therefore opens up an avenue for further investigation for developing countries who may also seek to establish regenerative agricultural practices. but it is only the start more research needs to be done to establish if this is an effective tool for poverty alleviation, and if it can be sustainably scaled in urban centres. our study merely shows that the potential for implementation exists. http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5100 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 62 3. literature review 3.1. regenerative agriculture overview the agricultural industry is immensely diverse and has been one of the most defining activities of humankind’s development and our impact on the biosphere (kinahan, 2009). the most common form of commercial agriculture is what can be called ‘monoculture’, where a single crop is planted at a large scale; fauna and soil minerals are artificially controlled. the monocrop, once harvested, often leaves the fields completely barren, and artificial fertiliser is then needed to plant the next crop. this is contrary to natural regenerative systems where no external inputs are needed to ensure growth (anderson, 2019). by mimicking natural systems in agriculture, a regenerative circular food system does not need external inputs in the longer run. this may mean planting a diversity of crops that give and take different minerals from the soil, and integrating livestock in agricultural practices more efficiently to mimic natural fauna fertilisation. regenerative agriculture has emerged as a compelling field of research and an environmentally fit approach “to adjust our sight to the needs of the new ecology” (anderson, 2019:2). as such, ‘disrupting linear agricultural production’ has been a large focus within the research on the circular economy, which evolved into investigating the efficiency of circular food systems. a 2018 study done by lundgren and lacanne (2018:1) on corn production found that “regenerative fields had 29 per cent lower grain production but 78 per cent higher profits over traditional corn production systems”, which implies that “regenerative farming systems provided greater ecosystem services and profitability for farmers than an input-intensive model of corn production” (lacanne and lundgren, 2018:1). the ellen macarthur foundation report on cities and circular economy for food estimates that for a metropolitan city like são paulo in brazil to relocate its farming systems into regenerative practices will yield “usd 67 million cost saving in health due to reduced pesticide exposure and lower air pollution”, and “usd 25 million worth of soil saved from degradation in conventional farming practices” (ellen macarthur foundation, 2019:49), and help avoid 92,000 tonnes of greenhouse gas yearly among many other benefits on the individual and communal level (ellen macarthur foundation, 2019). this study hopes to contribute towards the efforts at expanding regenerative agriculture in cities. http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5100 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 63 what then constitutes a circular food system, and how could we test its viability? nijman (2020) and the ellen macarthur foundation (2019) suggests implementing a circular system rests on three principles; 1) design out waste, 2) keep products and materials in use and 3) regenerate natural systems. nijman (2020) applied these principles to regenerative agriculture and considered three variables in a study on east african agricultural practices; 1) the propensity to use organic waste as compost, 2) the propensity to reuse agricultural materials (such as jerry cans and paper bags) and 3) the prevalence of regenerating natural systems (through practices like aquaponics or agroforestry). because our study is considering households, and not farmers, our study looked at slightly different variables to consider the same three principles. we looked 1) at the the propensity to separate waste (which is an essential step in designing out waste that ends up in a landfill), 2) what most households then do with the waste they separate (is it reused or does it end up in a landfill), and 3) we asked if households capture rainwater (which is a prerequisite for implementing a regenerative urban agricultural system and mimics natural water catchment systems). in addition to these three main areas of investigation, we also considered if alternative water sources are available to test the assumption that rainwater collection is a prerequisite in urban agriculture. 3.2. recovering from previous challenges; the girinka programme girinka, which translates to "have a cow," is a rwandan government initiative launched in 2006 that consists of giving one dairy cow to every low-income family as part of a poverty alleviation strategy. by june 2016, 248,566 cows had been distributed to poor households (mudingu, 2017). "one cow brings nutrition, sustenance, and employment, providing a stable income for a family and is a source of soil nutrients via manure to assist small scale cropping activity” (nyabinwa, 2018:1). the programme is also in line with the rwanda government’s priorities for the transformation of agriculture (psta). on the one hand, as income generated from milk production increases, farmers' abilities to invest in crop production have been on the rise as well as their ability to take loans and participate in development (unicef, 2012). on the other hand, new cattle breeds have been developed for higher milk yields, and manure was used for crop fertilization and biogas (unicef, 2012). girinka can be perceived as a form of a universal basic income (ubi). however, since it was non-monetary and culturally http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5100 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 64 appropriate (developed in rwanda, for rwanda), it is an interesting and regenerative approach to ubi for a country with limited fiscal ability. this program was not only created to serve economic purposes but also as a social project to reconstruct rwanda and reconcile communities after the tragic genocide against the tutsi in 1994. "if a cow is given from one person to another, it establishes trust and respect between the giver and beneficiary” (mudingu, 2017:2). girinka's social dimension has a profound impact on rwandans' perception of each other because it utilises the cultural significance around the act of giving cows in rwandan culture giving cows is traditionally reserved for marriage, where families are ceremonially linked together in the future. in addition, the programme also encourages the use of communal cow sheds as another aspect of fostering connection and knowledge transfer for beneficiaries who are not knowledgeable about cow breeding. the programme has also contributed to changing the mainstream rwandan mindset from "looking at cattle as a status symbol (the more cows one had, the better) to a source of income and livelihood” (mudingu, 2017:2). by changing this social perception, the negative effects of conspicuous consumption decried by veblen are avoided (veblen and banta, 2007) most notably that of conspicuous waste. this is an important point, as governments attempt to redefine consumption and consumerism in an effort to achieve decent living standards. rwanda has shown that by looking inward at its own cultural roots the negative consumption patterns that the developed world is now trying to redress, can be avoided. however, as rwanda gradually urbanises, it is becoming increasingly important to adapt this rural-suited initiative to a more urban setting. with limited land in urban areas, a more appropriate alternative for the future needs to be applied. 3. 3. the akarima k'igikoni programme in an effort to reduce malnutrition, rwanda's government launched the akarima k'igikoni initiative as part of a model village planning program in the whole southern province in 2019. child malnutrition is a prominent health issue in rwanda, with “only 18 per cent of children aged 6-23 months are fed in accordance with the recommendations for infant and young child feeding practices” (ahishakiye et al., 2019:1). akarima k'igikoni which translates to "kitchen gardens" hopes to provide food diversity especially to young children in order to address poor diets (kanamugire, 2019). not much has been written on this initiative because of its recent implementation. however, it forms part of a series of bigger grassroots strategies for poverty alleviation (such as the girinka programme, http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5100 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 65 among others). for akarima k'igikoni, the government provides staff, materials, and seeds to build kitchen gardens in each house of the village. there are 338 households sheltering a population of 1525 people who benefited from this program to-date in gishyushye village (kanamugire, 2019). the akarima k'igikoni program also invests in training people on gardening skills and general knowledge of seeding plants. since akarima k'igikoni uses a participatory approach to build communities, it is seen as building trust between civil society and government as both work together for the betterment of living conditions and self-sustained living. the government collaborates with the citizens to build the kitchen gardens in all the households of the model village by training them on gardening practices, so they can also help their neighbours in the process. it even involves the community in organising campaigns to collect seeding plants and gardening materials or funds to buy them. "the executive secretary of the rukoma sector, nkurunziza jean de dieu, urged the people that no one else should make the model a model village except for the people themselves” (kanamugire, 2019:1). the akarima k'igikoni is a practical biophilic solution to malnutrition that brings rwandans together and connects them to their agricultural roots. 4. research method we conducted a series of questionnaire-based interviews in the bibare, masoro and kinyaga cells, which fall under the gasabo district within kigali city province. these areas are all located around the newly developed special economic zone / innovation city, and as such, could be typified as peri-urban. all data is derived from completing these questionnaires through a verbal interview conducted in kinyarwanda or english by native speaking fieldworkers, who documented responses (for the full questionnaire, see appendix 1). a sample size of 151 was used, making the data statistically significant. where respondents declined to give information, the data point was excluded (see appendix 1 for the sample size of each question). in general, our sample reflects key similarities with the 2019 census data for kigali, making the data representative with three major exceptions. our data has an over-representation of people with secondary school education and above. it also has an over-representation of those working in wholesale and retail trade, repair of motor vehicles and motorcycles. those working in agriculture are underrepresented most likely because few farm holdings and many commercial centres were located in the areas where data was collected. in addition, gasabo has the 2nd highest labour participation rate of all districts in the country, explaining why we have a slight over-representation of labour force respondents http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5100 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 66 in our sample compared to the national average. (nisr, 2020:8). the data collection was funded by the african leadership university and remains the property of the university. table 1. sample comparison with kigali population, where available, from nisr data in 2019 indicator sample result source: own data kigali / *national population source: nisr 2020 unemployment* 12.6% 15.2% informal sector* (as percentage of total active labour force) 70.5% 75.8% sectors agriculture2 0.8% industry 11.4% services 87.9% agriculture 7.3% industry 19.29% services 73.4% industries agriculture (1.1 %) wholesale and retail trade, repair of motor vehicles and motorcycles (49.5 %) construction (8.6 %) manufacturing (3.2 %) transport and storage (14.0 %) agriculture (7.3 %) wholesale and retail trade, repair of motor vehicles and motorcycles (20.2 %) construction (10.8 %) manufacturing (1.0 %) transport and storage (8.0 %) education of labour force* none 22.0% primary 31.1% secondary 34.1% tertiary 12.9% none 47.2% primary 29.5% secondary 16.2% tertiary 7.2% source: nisr (2019) and own data (2019) we analysed the data using descriptive statistics only, mainly because that was sufficient to answer the research questions. more can certainly be done to better understand the full picture of the lockdown on kigali (see ackerman, 2020) 2 note that agriculture here refers to market-oriented agriculture only subsistence agriculture was excluded from the labour force entirely by both the nisr and this study in line with ilo practice. *kigali data not available; figure here is for rwanda nationally. http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5100 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 67 figure 1 shows the average self-reported daily income levels of our sample, adjusted for purchasing power parity to us dollars. our data shows that there is a clear negative impact on income levels for our sample because of the coronavirus pandemic, which supports international literature around the negative effect of the pandemic on the economy. however, respondents self-reported income, and not expenditure, as is best practice for poverty research. as such, the data may not be useful in the literature on absolute poverty prevalence in rwanda which was not the purpose of this study. for a more comprehensive review of the poverty prevalence, debates and measurement challenges in rwanda, see fatima and yoshida (2018). for our study, we can only conclude that there is a negative effect on the income levels of our sample. more research should be done, using best-practice consumption-based surveys, to determine the full effect of the lockdowns on income levels during. figure 1. composition of average self-reported daily income levels of sample (adjusted for purchasing power parity) source: own data (n=121) 5. results & discussion 5.1 akarima k’igikoni  our first area of investigation is to determine the prevalence of these kitchen garden practices among the households in our sample. as an initiative only recently started primarily in the southern province, we did not expect to see many households make use of this regenerative agricultural practice in kigali. our findings confirmed this expectation only 5 per cent of respondents reported using their vegetable garden as a way to get food during the lockdown time. since only 1 per cent of respondents reported working in agriculture, it shows that more people have vegetable gardens at home than work in agriculture but only http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5100 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 68 by a very small margin. this finding highlights two points; firstly, that vegetable gardens and decentralised food systems are an underutilised form of subsistence in kigali, even in times of crisis. secondly, it shows the opportunity for expanding the akarima k’igikoni initiative in urban areas, since very few people currently make use of it. 5.2 waste categories after separation our second area of investigation was around the underlying social practices needed to make a success of decentralised, regenerative food systems. as outlined by the ellen macarthur foundation (2019), having a well-established waste separation culture is a key ingredient for successful implementation of regenerative agriculture. the second step after waste separation is the effective use of composting. thirdly, access to water is important for vegetable gardening, and finally access to skills and knowledge. in our study, we tested these practices3. considering the first step of waste separation, our data shows that around 21 per cent of the respondents separate their household’s waste from their general waste. this can be broken down into the categories shown in table 2. this means that the practice of separating household waste is already somewhat established (comparatively, only 7 per cent of households in copenhagen, denmark demonstrated a high waste separation potential (pedersen and manhice, 2019), while 8.13 per cent of south africans reported separating waste with a slightly higher involvement for urban households at 11.18 per cent (oyekale, 2017). in addition, respondents were also asked which common packaging items they frequently do not throw away but instead reuse for another purpose. respondents were given a list of options, and 55.4 per cent of respondents reported reusing packaging frequently for another purpose (table 4). this also points to a strong culture of reusing items, which is a part of waste separation as well. it shows that rwandan culture already includes aspects of reusing and recycling, which is only now starting to take root in europe and the developed world (see ellen macarthur foundation, 2019; broerse et al., 2014). table 2. percentage of respondents who separate their waste before disposal does not separate waste 78.81% separates waste 21.19% 3 we did not test for skills and knowledge in our study because of the complexity around reliably ascertaining the level of knowledge/skill. as a proxy for this, we consider simply the number of respondents who reported using their vegetable garden as a form of subsistence and support indicating that enough knowledge and skills exist in order to provide sufficient produce for subsistence. http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5100 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 69 categories into which waste is separated4, as a % of total respondents glass 0.66% organic waste 17.22% paper 1.32% plastic 3.31% source: own data (n=151) respondents were also asked how they dispose of their waste (table 3). only 3.3 per cent of total respondents reported composting their waste5. however, the vast majority of people (72 per cent) depend on the government’s waste collection, where most of the waste goes through municipal channels and end up in landfills. we can therefore conclude that very few people in our sample made effective use of composting, and there is, therefore, a big opportunity for the akarima k’igikoni to expand this knowledge in urban areas in order to create more circular waste systems. since around 17.22 per cent of respondents separated organic waste, yet only 3.3 per cent used it for composting, it also represents an important business opportunity for waste management and compost creation businesses in kigali. the consumer behaviour already seems to separate out waste, but no value is currently being created from this practice. table 3. waste disposal methods used, as percentage of total selling waste 1.34% burning waste 2.68% composting 3.36% own landfill 19.46% waste collection 75.17% source: own data (n=149) 4 note that the categories do not add up to the total, because some respondents separate into more than one category, and were therefore counted in both categories. as such, this table can be understood to mean that 17.22 per cent of respondents separated organic waste from their general waste, while 1.32 per cent separated paper from their general waste. some of those who separate organic waste also separate paper, and so on. 5 this may under represent the total composting practices in our sample. the 3.31 per cent shown here refer to respondents who reported using their organic landfills as compost. however, of those who reported separating organic waste from their general waste 30.77 per cent reported making their own landfill with the organic waste, which is essentially an ineffective form of composting without using the compost itself. therefore, those who make organic landfills and those who compost make up 8.68 per cent of total respondents. http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5100 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 70 table 4. percentage of respondents who reported reusing the below material for another purpose before disposing of it does not reuse packaging frequently 44.6% reuses packaging frequently 55.4% products frequently reused, as percentage of those who reported reusing products paper bags 50.36% cardboard boxes 12.23% plastic bottles 11.51% plastic containers 10.79% glass bottles 7.91% plastic bags 6.47% glass jars 4.32% paper cups 3.60% plastic cups 1.44% metal tins 0.72% source: own data (n=139) 5.3 water access and rainwater collection finally, we also tested the reliability of access to water. on a macroeconomic level, access to clean water is a prominent issue in rwanda despite the government’s efforts to date. 5.1 million people still lack clean water (wateraid, 2020), and approximately 60 per cent of rural households drink untreated water (world bank group, 2020:92). although rwanda has done much to remedy this in the face of the global pandemic by installing simple handwashing stations at most public spaces, these numbers are still concerning. the water problem was clearly observed in the respondents’ answers as well; 78.6 per cent reported that they experienced some water cuts for 4 of the days in the week or more6. it is possible that this high reported loss of access to water is as a result of the ongoing construction at the nearby special economic zone, but it still points to an underlying problem of consistent water access even in peri-urban areas of 6 respondents were simply asked how often they experienced water cuts in an average week. they were not asked about their source of water, but the phrasing implied the source being that of piped water from the rwandan water and sanitation corporation (wasac). it is common in the area for people to walk to a wasac well nearby to collect water in containers that is then used in homes. our study did not differentiate between respondents who had water piped into their homes, and people who collected water outside of their home from a wasac tap. http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5100 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 71 kigali. it, therefore, suggests that expanding an akarima k’igikoni initiative in the urban centres necessitates fully addressing the water access issues. another alternative to the centralised water supply is decentralised water entrapment, primarily using rainwater. rwanda has a relatively high annual rainfall7, making this is a viable option for many households. our data reveals that most households (figure 2) already entrap rainwater in some way, making rainwater harvesting during covid19 a vital source of survival. as the government's efforts to expand access to clean drinking water materialise, it is essential that the practices of rainwater harvesting remain rainwater plays a critical part in the support of a further expansion of akarima k'igikoni. hence, it is a good time to introduce the practice of akarima k’igikoni while people still collect rainwater and as government efforts increasingly provide access to grid network drinking water. figure 2. rainwater management at the household level source: own data (n=151) 6. policy recommendation: expanding the akarima k'igikoni programme the very successful home-grown girinka project is unsuited for the growing urban agglomeration agenda of rwanda’s vision 2050. urban spaces host many malnourished children, with stunting in urban 7 see https://climateknowledgeportal.worldbank.org/country/rwanda/climate-data-historical http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5100 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 72 areas in rwanda documented at 27 per cent (bosteels and mcdonough, 2016). this paper recommends that the government boost the outreach of the home-grown akarima k'igikoni program after covid 19 as both a recovery measure and a way to address the malnutrition problem in urban areas. it is also a key ingredient for making the vision 2050 sustainable and equitable with further agglomeration and urbanisation of kigali and other cities, it is important for a circular food system to be well embedded in order to avoid the crippling environmental destruction experienced by the developed world (world bank group, 2020). other developing countries experiencing rapid urbanisation may do well to learn from the rwandan case balancing environmental concerns with development is an important global priority. as our data shows, there is a somewhat well established waste sorting culture, but not yet a well established composting culture in kigali. training should be done to teach people composting habits and ways to use organic waste. similar interventions have been done using umuganda, and we propose using this as a channel for large-scale education and changing of cultural practices. phasing out waste from these households and diverting it away from landfills is a valuable step towards circular agriculture. this aligns with the vision 2050 priority of investing in human capital. according to the strategy, human capital is a very “safe” investment, since “human capital is a portable asset that can have powerful effects on people’s welfare and mobility” (world bank group, 2020:70). apart from changing composting behaviour, it is also essential that the requisite spaces for gardens be incorporated into new developments. rwandans should be able to also integrate these kitchen gardens in corporate workplaces. the so-called ‘living buildings’ created by google and other larger corporations (ger, 2019) are an important trend to follow. google’s efforts to make their campus more waste efficient have "prevent[ed] more than 1 million kilograms (2.25 million pounds) of pre-consumer food waste in its cafés around the world, totalling over 3 million kilograms (6.6 million pounds) of food waste prevented since 2014” (ger, 2019:41). google keeps producing more innovative solutions towards sustainable business office spaces. translating the living buildings to a rwandan context could similarly enable rwanda to be a front-runner in green urbanisation. the newly built african leadership university campus in kigali’s innovation city has adopted measures to encourage reusable water containers instead of singleuse bottles, with plans to expand green spaces with food-producing plants for circular campus food production, among others. similar development should be done in other parts of kigali, and the government should take a more active lead in ensuring that the new developments in kigali innovation http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5100 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 73 city are representative of global best practice. the akarima k’igikoni should not only be limited to households but can be woven into the fabric of rwanda’s urban scene. rooftop gardens and green spaces is a great step towards building a rwanda at the forefront of green innovation. we propose that businesses pilot these green buildings for further analyses of their effect as part of a decentralised food system for urban centres in developing countries. incorporating these food systems into the industrial symbiosis of the eco-industrial parks proposed by caycedo (2019) in rwanda would be a great place to start. in a rising covid-induced business competition, green practices, sustainable buildings, and regenerative circular urban planning all reflect different models for corporate social responsibility; an excellent competitive advantage to businesses (urmanaviciene and arachchi, 2020). csr does not have to be limited by charity or philanthropy, the need for more innovative and strategic models is evidently urgent and pivotal (urmanaviciene and arachchi, 2020) to sustain the economic interests as well as the social and environmental commitment of rwandan businesses. in order to support this expansion of the akarima k’igikoni, the issue of water access needs to be addressed. several initiatives are currently being implemented to solve the water problem in rwanda like the wateraid rwanda initiatives or the delagua rwanda project, but their timeline is relatively long. the delagua rwanda project, for instance, aims to distribute 600,000 advanced water filters to the poorest 30 per cent of households over 20 years (delagua, 2020). wateraid rwanda has also resorted to training programmes in collaboration with the centre for science and environment (cse) for state and non-state practitioners (engineers, consultants, planners, academicians, and researchers) on sustainable and affordable rainwater harvesting (rwh) in rwanda. the purpose of this training overlaps with the vision of managing rainwater in a decentralized way for every household to become self-sustainable with consistent access to water. this paper supports the governmental push for a holistic decentralized approach to water access in rwanda through rainwater harvesting and treatment. the government should invest in equipping areas, where there is an existent culture of water collection, with domestic water filters and water collection tanks over the first phase and expand the project with training programs over the second phase. rainwater http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5100 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 74 harvesting practices have been implemented in some public institutions in rwanda and have proven to be very efficient in driving sustainability and water-sufficiency8. a note on the girinka programme as outlined before, the girinka project was a widely successful project for what was a very rural rwanda post-1994. all our recommendations support the unicef recommendation that the project should be upscaled with more donors and partners involved (unicef, 2012). the girinka program should be reintroduced in rwanda after the pandemic with a significant focus on government training and skilling activities on cow breeding, composting, and self-managing waste for more sustainable households. educating the population and developing its human capital is a key driver of economic growth (zeynalli, 2020); it establishes communication and ensures the alignment between the government’s vision and the people’s needs. although our study did not investigate the project or its application in rural rwanda, it is still part of regenerative agriculture, which is aligned with our recommendations. the production and use of cow manure also have considerable spillovers into the rest of the agricultural value chain. however, considering the grazing and land required to rear cows, it remains a rural solution. our recommendations aim to address the growing urban areas. the implementation of proper measurement systems diminishes the high risks of wasted time and resources (urmanaviciene, 2020). therefore, we advise that the implementation of these and the previous recommendations be coupled by social impact assessment measures that inform sustainable future governmental planning and policymaking. 7. summary and conclusions in this paper, we discussed the potential expansion of the akarima k’igikoni initiative into urban and peri-urban areas in rwanda. we investigated the past application of initiatives like the girinka project and the akarima k’igikoni initiative. we considered current cultural practices in the peri-urban area of kigali’s gasabo district. we found that although most people reuse packaging material frequently, only some portions of the population separate waste. we can conclude that more education should still be done to 8 for the full report on the potential of rainwater harvesting in the whole of rwanda, see matto and jainer (2019). http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5100 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 75 support a successful expansion of the akarima k’igikoni programme, starting with education around organic waste disposal and composting. very few people seem to use vegetable gardens for sustenance, and it, therefore, represents a vastly untapped opportunity for urban food security and circular, regenerative agriculture. we also recommend expanding the akarima k’igikoni in corporate spaces and office parks by adapting the ‘living building’ concept to a rwandan context. we found surprisingly prevalent rainwater entrapment practices that could support the expansion of akarima k’igikoni in periurban areas. sustainability can no longer be treated as an externality it should be a primary driver for policymaking. our recommendations contribute towards linking the various threads of food security, sustainable decentralised and regenerative agricultural systems, and urban agglomeration. limitations of the study it is important to note that our research was focused in the peri-urban areas of kigali’s bumbogo, masoro, kinyaga and bibare areas within the gasabo district. these areas are located in and around the new special economic zone and kigali innovation city developments. it, therefore, does not fully represent the more urban, affluent and densely populated areas of kigali city, nor rural rwanda at all. considering the literature on the akarima k’igikoni, the practice of kitchen gardening seems to be more widespread in the rural southern province. this study considers its application in peri-urban kigali in order to add to the discourse around sustainable agglomeration of urban centres, as outlined in rwanda’s vision 2050 document. finally, this study’s data was collected in the first week of july 2020. it is therefore located in the midst of an ongoing pandemic and as such, subject to change during this time. although questions concerning the topic of this study were phrased to elicit general responses and behaviours notwithstanding the pandemic, it is entirely possible that the time of collection may have skewed the results. we cannot yet know if respondents were more, or less likely, to practice regenerative agriculture during the pandemic time. acknowledgements we express our great appreciation to the african leadership university in rwanda for sponsoring this research and for the coordination support from its international business and trade, and operations departments. special thanks to all the research team members –who are also students at aluwho helped http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5100 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 76 in collecting data (blessing maima caine, christian nsengimana, euphemia nusone perkins, fiona uwase, hassan damafin sedekie jackateh, oluwasijibomi adesina, solomon mutagoma). we would also like to thank mr. aseda ohene-adu, a faculty at alu for his assistance in analysing the data. references ackerman, r. m. (2020). the informal economy during covid-19 the case of rwanda. working paper. available at: https://drive.google.com/file/d/19p0j8cpft7-ztegjxp5wpftgsen5wdtj/view?usp=sharing ahishakiye j. bouwman l. brouwer i.d. matsiko e. armar-klemesu m. koelen m. (2019). challenges and responses to infant and young child feeding in rural rwanda: a qualitative study. journal of health, population & nutrition. 12/12/2019, vol. 38 issue 1, p1-10. available at: http://web.a.ebscohost.com/ehost/detail/detail?vid=0&sid=69dbc0e1-98b7-4faa-bd3c-2036b640b58c%40sdc-vsessmgr03&bdata=jnnpdgu9zwhvc3qtbgl2zq%3d%3d#an=140314405&db=a9h anderson s. (2019). one size fits none: a farm girl’s search for the promise of regenerative agriculture. university of nebraska press. bendito, a., & twomlow, s. (2015). promoting climate smart approaches to post-harvest challenges in rwanda. international journal of agricultural sustainability, 13(3), 222-239. available at:https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/14735903.2014.959329 bosteels j., and mcdonough c. (2016). report finds malnutrition rates in rwanda have improved, but more work is still needed. world food programme. available at: https://www.wfp.org/news/report-findsmalnutrition-rates-rwanda-have-improved-more-work-stillneeded#:~:text=the%20comprehensive%20food%20security%20and,the%20last%20analysis%20in%202012. broerse, j.e.w., van der ham, l., tielemans, b., mazzonetto, m., (2014). engaging citizens to shape eu research policy on urban waste. ecsite: brussels. available at https://ec.europa.eu/research/swafs/pdf/pub_featured/voices_for_responsible_research_and_innovation_engaging _citizens_to_shap.pdf [accessed 10 september 2020] caycedo, s. (2019). the development of eco industrial parks in rwanda. working paper. fonerwa. http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5100 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 77 chang, d. (2020). coronavirus: normal was the problem. the ecologist. available at: https://theecologist.org/2020/apr/17/coronavirus-normal-was-problem delagua. (2020). project rwanda. available at: https://www.delagua.org/projects/rwanda ellen macarthur foundation. (2019). circular economy for food cities. available at: https://www.ellenmacarthurfoundation.org/assets/downloads/cceff_full-report-pages_may-2019_web.pdf [accessed 10 september 2020] fatima f., yoshida n. (2018). revisiting the poverty trend in rwanda 2010/11 to 2013/14. world bank group. available at:http://documents1.worldbank.org/curated/en/137651536845936223/pdf/wps8585.pdf ger: google environmental report 2019 google environmental report 2019. (2019). available at: https://services.google.com/fh/files/misc/google_2019-environmental-report.pdf kanamugire e. (2019). kamonyi: akarima k’igikoni gafatwa nk’urukingo rw’imirire mibi. available at: http://imvahonshya.co.rw/kamonyi-akarima-kigikoni-gafatwa-nkurukingo-rwimirire-mibi/ kinahan, d. (2009), ‘struggling to take root: the work of the electro-culture committee of the ministry of agriculture and fisheries between 1918 and 1936 and its fight for acceptance', reinvention: a journal of undergraduate research, volume 2, issue 1, http://www2.warwick.ac.uk/go/reinventionjournal/archive/volume2issue1/kinahan koch m. (2014). climate change, carbon trading and societal self-defence. real-world economics review, (67), 52-66. available at: https://portal.research.lu.se/ws/files/3691268/4438598.pdf kolinjivadi v.; selby d., kagawa f. (2020). climate change and coronavirus: a confluence of two emergencies as learning and teaching challenge. available at: http://web.a.ebscohost.com/ehost/pdfviewer/pdfviewer?vid=0&sid=cbf9fc15-be05-4f47-b298433e67d2027a%40sessionmgr4008 lacanne ce, lundgren jg. (2018). regenerative agriculture: merging farming and natural resource conservation profitably. peerj 6:e4428 https://doi.org/10.7717/peerj.4428 matto m. jainer s. (2019). potential of rainwater harvesting in rwanda: a deep-dive into best management practices of rainwater harvesting systems in kigali. centre for science and environment. available at: http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5100 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 78 https://waterportal.rwb.rw/sites/default/files/201904/potential%20of%20rainwater%20harvesting%20in%20rwanda%20report-final.pdf mikova k., makupa e., kayumba j. (2015). effect of climate change on crop production in rwanda. earth sciences. vol. 4, no. 3, 2015, pp. 120-128. doi: 10.11648/j.earth.20150403.15 mudingu j. (2017). girinka programme transforms livelihoods, reconciles communities. rwanda agriculture board (rab). available at: https://www.minagri.gov.rw/fileadmin/user_upload/success_story/article_about_girinka.pdf nasa. (2020). nasa, partner space agencies amass global view of covid-19 impacts. available at: https://climate.nasa.gov/news/2998/nasa-partner-space-agencies-amass-global-view-of-covid-19-impacts/ nasa. (2020). the effects of climate change. available at: https://climate.nasa.gov/effects/ nicola m., alsafi z., sohrabi c., kerwan a., al-jabir a., losifidis c., agha m., agha r. (2020). the socioeconomic implications of the coronavirus pandemic (covid-19): a review. available at: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/s1743919120303162 nijman, e. (2020). towards circular food production systems in east africa. [master’s thesis, radboud university] nyabinwa p. (2018).one cow per poor family program “girinka”. republic of rwanda ministry of agriculture and animal resources. available at: https://www.minagri.gov.rw/index.php?id=28 oyekale a. s. (2017). determinants of households’ involvement in waste separation and collection for recycling in south africa. environment, development and sustainability. available at: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/317935213_determinants_of_households'_involvement_in_waste_separ ation_and_collection_for_recycling_in_south_africa pedersen j. t. s., manhice h. (2019). the hidden dynamics of household waste separation: an anthropological analysis of user commitment, barriers, and the gaps between a waste system and its users. available at: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/s0959652619309916#! temple j. (2020). the climate is also a casualty. mit technology review. available at: http://web.b.ebscohost.com/ehost/pdfviewer/pdfviewer?vid=2&sid=d1d6d7b7-65d3-4e60-8eacc69121468014%40pdc-v-sessmgr05 http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5100 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 79 unicef. (2012). equity case study: rwanda one cow per poor family. available at: https://www.unicef.org/equity/archive/index_65274.html urmanaviciene, a., & arachchi, u. (2020). the effective methods and practices for accelerating social entrepreneurship through corporate social responsibility. european journal of social impact and circular economy, 1(2), 27-47. https://doi.org/10.13135/2704-9906/5085 urmanaviciene, a. (2020). wises’ social impact measurement in the baltic states. european journal of social impact and circular economy, 1(2), 48-75. https://doi.org/10.13135/2704-9906/5091 uwimbabazi, p., lawrence, r. (2013). indigenous practice, power and social control: the paradox of the practice of umuganda in rwanda. alternation: interdisciplinary journal for the study of arts and humanities. 20(1). pp. 248-272 veblen t., banta m. (2007). the theory of the leisure class. oup oxford. available at: http://web.a.ebscohost.com/ehost/ebookviewer/ebook/bmxlymtfxzmxmzk4nv9fqu41?sid=3bab6adf-2dc74faf-80a6-393c85381ce9@sessionmgr4007&vid=2&format=eb&rid=2 wateraid. (2020). wateraid rwanda. available at: https://www.wateraid.org/where-we-work/rwanda world bank group. (2020). future drivers of growth in rwanda innovation, integration, agglomeration, and competition. available at: http://documents1.worldbank.org/curated/en/522801541618364833/pdf/futuredrivers-of-growth-in-rwanda-innovation-integration-agglomeration-and-competition.pdf zeynalli, l. (2020). the impact of stimulating the development of human capital on economic development. european journal of social impact and circular economy, 1(1b), 38-52. https://doi.org/10.13135/2704-9906/4562 appendix 1. questionnaire note: the full questionnaire included questions relevant to the impact of the alu campus in that area, as well as questions related to environmental practices. since those questions were not used in this specific study, they are not listed below. for a full list of all questions asked, contact the authors directly. demographic questions 1. gender (n=151) ❏ female ❏ male ❏ other………………….. http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5100 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 80 ❏ prefer not to say 2. age (n=141) ❏ ………… ❏ prefer not to say 3. nationality (n=151) ❏ rwandan ❏ other………………………... 4. if not rwandan, what are they doing in rwanda? (n=2) ❏ working ❏ visiting ❏ studying ❏ other…………... 5. where do you stay/live (cell and sector)? (n=149) ……………………… 6. highest level of education attained? (n=147) ❏ primary ❏ ordinary level ❏ high school or equivalent ❏ tvet, polytechnic institute ❏ associate degree/ diploma ❏ bachelor’s degree ❏ post-graduate degree ❏ did not attend school 7. what languages do you speak? (n=151) ❏ kinyarwanda ❏ english ❏ french ❏ kiswahili ❏ others………... 8. employment status (n=151) ❏ self-employed ❏ employed ❏ retired ❏ unemployed ❏ other………….. http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5100 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 81 9. if employed, what is the nature of your employment? (n=42) ❏ permanent employment contracts (formal) ❏ fixed-term employment contract (formal) ❏ casual employment (informal) ❏ seasonal employment (informal) ❏ daily employment (informal) 10. what sector have you been working in for the past six months? (n=137) ……………………………………………………………………………... 11. how many people live in your household? (n=150) ……………………………………... 12. how many people depend on you? (n=150) …………………………. 13. what are the sources of your household’s income? (n=140) ……………………………………….... 14. what was the last monthly income before covid-19 lockdowns (feb 2020) for each source mentioned above? rwf (n=142) ……………………………………….... 15. what is the average monthly income during the covid-19 lockdown (mar-may 2020) for each source mentioned above? rwf? (n=133) ……………………………………….... 16. what is the average monthly income now after covid-19 lockdown(jun 2020) for each source mentioned above? rwf? (n=124) ……………………………………….... 17. did your business shut down due to the covid pandemic? (n=95) ❏ yes ❏ no ❏ partially 18. did you lose your job due to the covid pandemic? (n=84) ❏ yes ❏ no ❏ my pay was cut, but still employed 19. how did you manage to get income for survival during the time of lockdown restrictions? (n=151) http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5100 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 82 …………………………………………………………………………………………………………………… ………... ……………………………………………………… 20. how do you dispose of your garbage/trash? (n=149) ❏ waste collection ❏ burn ❏ own landfill ❏ composting ❏ other……. 21. do you separate your waste before putting it away? (n=151) ❏ no ❏ organic waste ❏ plastic ❏ paper ❏ glass ❏ dangerous waste ❏ general 22. how much does it cost to dispose of your waste? rwf? (n=126) ……………………………………………………………………………………………………………… 23. which of these things do you not throw away? (n=139) ❏ paper bags ❏ cardboard boxes ❏ paper cups ❏ plastic containers ❏ plastic bags ❏ plastic bottles ❏ plastic cups ❏ glass jars ❏ glass bottles ❏ aluminium cans ❏ metal tins ❏ other…………………….. 24. are you negatively affected by the industrial zone? (n=146) ❏ no ❏ air/smoke ❏ noise ❏ water ❏ garbage/smell http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5100 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 83 ❏ visual ❏ other……………………….. 25. how many days in a week do you not have water? (n=146) …………………………………………………………………………………………………………………… ……… 26. how does your household manage the rainwater? (n=151) ❏ no measure ❏ collect it ❏ redirect it into a ditch ❏ other…………………. microsoft word 1 rehman.docx http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5068 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 1 green and sustainable construction practices impact on organizational development ubaid ur rehman1, muhammad shafiq2, hasan ali3, mohammad abdullah4 1 project management, szabist, islamabad, pakistan, 2 assistant professor, szabist, islamabad, pakistan 3 project management, szabist, islamabad, pakistan 4 project management, szabist, islamabad, pakistan e-mail:1ubaidq1993@gmail.com; 2dr.shafiq@szabist-isb.edu.pk; 3hasan582@gmail.com; 4abdullahaijaz82@gmail.com received: 30/08/2020 revised: 01/10/2020 accepted for publication: 02/10/2020 published: 26/10/2020 abstract green marketing plays important role in the organizational performance irrespective to the industry and the type of project. however green construction research lacks in the field of construction project. basic purpose of this work was to highlight the impact of modern techniques such as green construction on the organizational performance through the adoption of sustainable practices in business strategies in construction industry. data was collected from 132 organizations, working on different construction projects located within the city of rawalpindi and islamabad, through online questionnaire survey in two strata in terms of consultant and contractors. data was analyzed through different tests, included pearson’s correlation coefficient as well as regression using ibm spss statistics version 20. study indicated that green construction has a strong correlation and positive impact on organizational performance, and this correlation partially mediated by the sustainable development. the research findings have practical implications both in organizational and project manager’s perspectives. this research was limited to specific geographic area due to time and cost constraints. future researchers may opt to conduct the study in other geographic areas of pakistan and in different industries. moreover, additional or different mediating variables can also be used in the future work. http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5068 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 2 keywords: sustainable development; organizational performance; green construction; environment protection; project success. 1. introduction worldwide, construction industry contributed approximately 9% in gdp with 7% employment rate. the industry contributed significantly to socio-economic development and open different avenues of common interest for different stakeholder to work together. the asian policies also have tended to keep construction industry busy as governments spend on infrastructure as a way of protecting jobs and boost the economy. (saenz & brown, 2018). heavy civil engineering have built infrastructure of country through the construction of highways, bridges, tunnels and other national or international level construction project. population have increased due to gradual increase of birth rate which have created burden on economy, resulting in the increase in the demand of houses with the passage of time. (zampese, moori, & caldeira, 2016) increment in population not only disturbed economy but also imposed burden on urban infrastructure through the migration of people due to lack of resources in rural areas. (farooqui & ahmed, 2008). however gradual change in infrastructure development involves complexities such as, required extensive area of intervention and excavation service are large construction work generators. it is important to change strategies to reduce environmental impacts on construction stage in development of urban infrastructure. hence, in modern development construction with less environment degradation preferred (bedrunka, 2020). pakistan is a developing country having construction as the second largest sector in pakistan’s economy after the agriculture. construction industry have contributed 13.1% in industrial sector and 2.74% in gdp. roughly 30-35% in employment sector are directly or indirectly affiliated with the construction sector. (malik & wahid, 2014). in construction industry, protection of environment is a major challenge, and an alarming situation towards sustainable development in which waste management is a big issue. it is not possible to control the fully waste while reuse of recycling and waste. gradual change in climate and deposition of waste pollutants affect our environment very badly as well as our agriculture production, quality of life and tourism. (huang et al., 2017) industries and companies of such good production are more responsible as compared to any other sector, being environment vulnerable and need quick action to more towards green practices. product consumption and effectiveness depends on consumer through http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5068 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 3 market value, the market behavior including consumer demand and consumer awareness, appreciate the companies practices towards “green” (biasutti & frate, 2017). green marketing has influenced the organizational performance quite strongly. however, there is gap in the literature about the impact of green construction on organizational performance and research lack in the field of construction project (zampese et al., 2016). according to zampese et al. (2016) every construction project either residential or commercial have broader impact on the organizational and industrial performance after its completion. impact can be either as a good practice or bad, particularly by examining the project impact related to environment by studying companies’ legal, economic and technological skills aspect which may also cause deep impact on industry. though, literature is available about green marketing but it weakens the relationship between supply chain management and company’s performance. construction project performance directly affect the organizational and industrial performance. in construction industry it is important to understand the pitfalls and challenges which can be incorporated. this paper highlighted the importance of green construction project with the adoption of sustainability techniques and their impact on organizational performance. basic purpose of this study is to examine the impact of green construction project in organizational performance by analyzing empirically the different factors such as reuse of old material, reduce waste production and environment preservation. other purpose is to find out either any positive impact may occur in construction industry by considering the mediating role of sustainability techniques includes environment protection, climate change and sustainable urbanization which may help to enhanced the organizational performance. many researchers highlighted the positive impact on organizational performances. a study done by shi, zuo, huang, huang, and pullen (2013) in china which explored the positive impact of sustainable construction on community and environment through the properly management of overheads, time and availability of sustainable materials which can enhance the organizational performances and also reduces the industry barriers. another usa based study by riley (2004) on toyota motor corporation (tmc) real estate expansion project found that, green building popularity evolving worldwide in construction sector which involve quick change in design stages but also found that construction organizations can play important role through the adoption of sustainable practices in their business strategies. the implementation of green concept in company’s strategies can bring significant positive changes in profitability, marketing values and cost performance through the facilitation in consumption, production, promotion sector and also resolve ecological problems. in construction industry, organization have to deal http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5068 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 4 with different operation on regular basis, industry have diverse characteristics such as high fragmentation, vision of project, instability and mainly dependence of work force with high level of uncertainty. in this industry, mostly project relate to the on-site production and directly expose with environment. (huang et al., 2017). green supply chain management including green construction, green product, and corporate practices towards sustainable development directly linked with organizational performance. (rego & figueira, 2017). climate change, and environment protection policies’ implementation, were the great moderator to increase organizational performance. researcher studies the exploratory model for the better understanding with companies and industries in which they operate and particularly examine the impact of environmental by studying their legal, economic and technological skills of companies. (zampese et al., 2016) developing countries as like pakistan do not have strong construction industry, major challenges faced by organizations in pakistan construction industry were found to be lack of expertise, resources, poor team management, employee’s commitment, quality, safety and risk management. significant changes may occur with the strong coordination, teamwork, training and awareness, can improve organization performance as well as industry performance. proceeding section, relates the previous research and literature on the organizational performance, sustainable development, and green construction followed by the hypothesis before the methodology part described in section 3, while results and analysis shown in the section 4, conclusion, discussion and limitations in section 5 respectively. 2. literature review in this section, detailed review of previous research is expressed with respect to the variables of this study including green construction, sustainable development and organizational performance followed by the hypothesis according to the objectives defined from the gap for this research study. 2.1 organization performance organization performance is depended on the successful completion of the project while next allocation of project or contract mainly based on the organization performance related to previous project. (gunasekaran et al., 2017). in construction industry, emerging concept of “green” that means to adopt such strategies at organization level which make project sustainable through less environment degradation, better economic impact and preserve natural resources. purpose of the strategies to enhances organization http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5068 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 5 performance and fulfil current demands in a better way without compromising future demands. according to darko and chan (2016), in construction industry, organizational performance evaluated through various factors included: sale increment, market chare, corporate image, water consumption building, energy efficient building parameter, reuse of old building material, increment in revenue, risk reduction factor and financial result. (zampese et al., 2016). 2.2 green construction project construction build urban and rural infrastructure by providing developmental facilities through the execution of different commercial, residential or any kind of development projects. green construction consists of six main factors such as; management of construction, protection of environment, conservation of material, water, energy and land utilization. (shi et al., 2013). every construction project involves through five basic aspects which is necessary for completion, including manpower, machine, material, method and environment project success of any project mainly depend on the successful completion of project to meet triple triangle constrains including cost, scope, schedule and quality (lin, 2015). green construction involves on-site practices which reduces environmental impact of construction. these practices mainly related to contractor, and sub-contractor but modern researchers claim it is more responsibility of designer to introduce such practices so that alternative can be adopted during construction such as use of prefabrication structure which is time saving and environment friendly but it is more responsibility of designer to introduce such alternative in market which can be adopted by contractors. (fawaz et al., 2016). green construction involve; less waste production during construction on site, replacing toxic substances such as paints solvents etc., less liquidated waste, alternative energy efficient sources, and use of efficient sustainable practices. (yigitcanlar, kamruzzaman, & teriman, 2015). the benefits of green construction project can be summarized as: enhanced quality of life, improved safety of residents, improved health and aesthetics, reduced household expenditures, creation of new employment opportunities and enhanced neighborhood vitality. (bedrunka, 2020) 2.2.1 impact of green construction on organizational performance. according to the darko, zhang, and chan (2017), green construction mainly relates with green supply chain management process and involves three areas: importance, corporate practices, green design and operation. these areas involve saving resources, improving productivity and control waste production. http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5068 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 6 these practices may be more reactive if adopted in strategies in form of rules and regulations, or proactive, and proper ban harmful practices. through this way integration of environmental activities was the scope of business strategies. (huang et al., 2017). according to darko and chan (2016) green construction practices are the source of cost efficiency and profitability, it not only increase in market share but also reduces extra rework and engage logistics through optimizing resources. latest innovation strengthens the organizational market values with their strategies and profit values without considering their size and capital. researchers including wei and miraglia (2017) reported that, in chinese manufacturing practically found that there is positive relationship exist between environmental management and organizational economic performance, while other researcher’s including, lin (2015) found significant positive changes between corporate green practices and industrial financial performances through the implementing of green practices in electronic industry of taiwan. 2.3 sustainable development practices this basic concept of sustainable development covered three important features include, economical, environment friendly and preserve natural resource for future generation. interpretation of sustainable development vary with industry such as sustainable construction, sustainable business, sustainable technology, sustainable agriculture, sustainable economic etc. (bedrunka, 2020). in project management scenarios, sustainability techniques brought positive impact in different dimensions of project which built interest of researchers and professionals towards sustainable project management which inter link multiple prospective such as social, environmental and economical. (bocchini, frangopol, ummenhofer, & zinke, 2014) as per literature the concept of sustainable development is to meet present challenges without compromising future demands (holden, linnerud, & banister, 2014). 2.3.1 impact of green construction in sustainable development in last five years, climate change awareness rises through various sources of medium either educational or cultural; researcher johns‐putra (2016) highlighted the awareness of climate through the medium of literacy including novel, theater and other media sources. there has been a growing trend, too, of climate change poetry, known as ecopoetry which exhibits the social and ecological awareness towards the environment degradation. human interaction with environment poses sever risk on natural climate system. although many impacts are already observed for the climate action in terms of toxic gases in air, rapid http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5068 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 7 melting of glacier, rise in sea level and ocean degradation since 1950s. however more scientific evidence is required to respond climate changes. (linnenluecke, birt, & griffiths, 2015). according to pedersen (2018) the united nation sustainable development goals, climate change mainly related with the environment protection policy which practically relate with construction industry development. the environment or climate protection regards the development of an awareness about alternative resources, mainly depend on the physical environment, and how human activity and decisions affect it, with a commitment to factoring environmental concerns into social and economic policy development including preservation of natural resources, climate change, rural development, sustainable urbanization, disaster prevention and mitigation (ricart, olcina, & rico, 2019). before implementation into construction industry, it’s important to introduce alternative resources with their social economic impact. (zampese et al., 2016). researchers including secinaro, brescia, calandra, and saiti (2020), also emphasizes on the adoption of climate mitigation sustainable practices at business level by indicating that international level firms adopted environmental practices in their business strategies to reduce the environment risk and bring significantly result in terms of increment in profit and organizational performance. climate change practices mainly relate with protection of environment while construction project activities directly expose with environment and major cause of environment contamination through toxic gases, and increment in temperature which causes rise of earth temperature and depletion of ozone (huang et al., 2017). modern concept of green building through green construction is a major alternative source to deal with climatic changes. in design phase, architecture is the main source of greenhouse gas control and important constituent to deal with climatic change. green buildings formulated after the green construction are energy efficient with low emission of toxic gases with less conservation of natural resources and make environment healthy. hence, green construction practices make environment healthy and build better climate through environment protection with less degradation. (darko & chan, 2016) 2.3.2 sustainable development and organizational performance process of sustainable development depends on the organizational hierarchy mainly internal polices, assessment criteria, strategies plan and their operational implementation. according to bedrunka (2020), environmental management system bound the organizations to formalize the policies in such a way that they can assess effect of their activities on environment, interaction of project with climate and find out http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5068 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 8 alternatives to cater the climatic challenges through different operational activities which causes less environment and natural resource degradation. organizational performance mainly depends on the successful completion of project with good practices. (biasutti & frate, 2017) every project causes social, environmental and economical after the completion, following these parameters, researchers found that sustainable product development through different alternative practices bring positive impact not only in organizational development but also at industrial level as a good lesson for other developers. we focus on climate change protection factor mainly include, environment protection policy and economic affect.(gunasekaran et al., 2017). 2.4 mediation role of sustainable development practices researchers including, yee, ismail, and jing (2020), indicated the, adoption of environment protection and sustainable policies with their implementation bring significant effect at industrial level with their significant social and economic impact. organizational development or performance basically deal with the parameter how can an organization achieve success by defining their milestone, performance indicators, and certain limitations, which based on their production. (akram, goraya, malik, & aljarallah, 2018). social and economic challenges relate the organizational performance which cater by the sustainable practices by adoption of alternatives strategies at organizational level which not only enhance the organization performance but also help to introduce latest modern practices in the industry. this is a step towards joint organizational and industrial revolution with the help of sustainable development. (sormunen & kärki, 2019). in order to preserve environment, it’s important to formulate policies at organizational level which cater these industrial challenges which may create disastrous effect for future generation. new research related to the sustainable development and their application introduce many alternatives of materials, which are energy saving and promote green building materials, standardization, high energy consumption construction to develop low energy consumption, effectively cope with climate change. it has been commonly accepted that green construction through sustainable development focuses on prevention of unnecessary consumption of natural resources (especially non-renewable ones) and mitigation of harmful emissions. (bedrunka, 2020). green construction resource material mainly seems limited to waste, toxic gases, industrial waste etc., but at broader level it involves coal, steel, electricity and chemical industry such as industrial waste can demolish natural resources. mega project involves huge amount of resources while sustainable techniques preserve the environment by providing alternative tools http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5068 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 9 and techniques. (rahmawati, utomo, anwar, setijanti, & nurcahyo, 2014). the emerging modern concept of “green building” in sustainable development, directs itself towards creation and use of models which are intended to be healthier as well as a more resource efficient. these models include construction, operation, renovation, maintenance and finally demolition (holden et al., 2014). 2.5 summary of literature through the literature studies we have studied about the green construction practices in the field of environment and economic which play vital role in organizational development. if there are strong green construction practices adopted on site during the construction project, it causes better organizational and industrial performance, hence sustainable development can play important role to strengthen the relationship. in this study we used organizational development and natural resource-based view theory to study the overall relationship between variables. hypothesis and conceptual framework for this research study listed as; fig. 1. conceptual framework of research model source – developed by the authors h1: green construction has positive significant impact on organizational performance. h2: green construction has positive impact towards sustainable development. h3: sustainable development has positive impact in organizational performance. h4: sustainable development mediates the relationship between green construction and organizational performance 3. method research was carried out to find how the impact of green construction relate with the organizational performance of the construction companies. from literature questionnaire selected which cover all http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5068 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 10 variables. a five-point likert scale was utilized to judge the severity indices of different criteria adopted for the respondent selection evaluation and further descriptive analysis (armstrong, 1987). employees working in construction industry either as a consultant, contractor, designer, or builder or in any other relevant department was selected 3.1 research design and data collection in this research study the population was the organizations employees working in the construction field either as a consultant, client, government, or contractor related to any project such as residential or commercial project located in urban areas across the twin cities rawalpindi and islamabad. sample selected by using the g-power software and found 120 organizations across the population of 507 organizations as listed by the pakistan engineering council. non-probability (proportionate convenient sampling) was used, data respondent includes, individual organization such as single employee for single organizations. we stratified our research study into two strata’s consultant and contractor and according the statistics of pakistan engineering council (pec). we proportionate the questionnaire and then distributed conveniently. 12% questionnaire distributed with contractors while 88% distributed with consultant’s working in twin cities of rawalpindi and islamabad. 250 questionnaires circulated out of which 30 questionnaires shared with contractors and 220 shared with the consultant. during the survey, unit of analysis was the employee per organization working on public or private construction project from islamabad and rawalpindi. in this study, data collected from the companies working closely with the construction project related to either commercial or residential mainly including housing project shopping complexes or any similar project. organizations either currently working or done such projects in recent or in last two years were selected for this study. for descripting analysis, a five-point likert scale, was used for measuring the response (boone & boone, 2012). questionnaire selected from literature such as; organizational performance and green construction (zampese et al., 2016) and sustainable development practices (biasutti & frate, 2017) respectively. 3.2 data analysis after the collection of data, 132 responses were recorded, as per our stratified methodology and on the basis of responses we have 14 questionnaires from contractor while remaining 118 respondents was consultant as per the defined percentage. out of 132 (125 respondents were related to the construction and http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5068 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 11 planning sector of construction industry working in different organization while other 7 was related to the other sectors of construction). for analysis and interpretation of data and hypothesis we used statistical software ibm spss. analysis of data including, distribution frequency demographics, reliability, correlation, linear and multiple regression. multiple regression is used to check the indirect path in overall total effect. it often provides better and easy approach over simple linear regression. overall multiple regression highlights the influence, strength and contribution of more than one variable and overall contribution of variables in total effect. furthermore, in multiple regression data was analyzed by using regression and process by andrew f. hayes model 4, with data coded according to an analysis framework based on a literature review, the questionnaire guide, and experience from similar research. the analysis was conducted by the authors in statistical package for the social sciences (spss) and checked with key actors. the survey was made clear and simple in order to encourage the participants so that they could respond quickly. furthermore, the survey questionnaire was designed on the basis of existing literature of researchers. 4. result research survey questionnaire attached with the demographic scale such as the gender, age, qualifications and experience of the respondents. 96% respondent was male, 62% respondent holding bachelor degree, 79% respondent have experience between 1 and 5 years, and 95% respondent working on planning and execution of construction projects. reliability test for the selected scale found as green construction (0.824). sustainable development (0.745) and organization performance as (0.898) respectively which is above 0.70. descriptive analysis give the detail about the mean, standard deviation, skewness and kurtosis of data extracted from the questionnaire survey which help to defined the normality parameter. after analysis the results shows the mean of green construction (gc) is 2.0038, sustainable development (sd) is 1.9970, and organization performance is 2.1341. according to gronemus et al. (2010), the data is considered to be normal if skewness values lies in the range of +2 and kurtosis in range +7. the results of skewness & kurtosis respective to each variable independently green construction, sustainable development and organizational performance are, skewness as, 0.668, 0.277, 0.049, and kurtosis are -0.037, -0.570, -0.601 respectively, which fall in the defined range. in order to validate the scale, according to the hair jr, sarstedt, hopkins, and kuppelwieser (2014)., http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5068 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 12 acceptable range of validity is 0.30. all of our question factor loading value is above 0.30 and no one question found less than 0.45 which lies within acceptable ranges. 4.1 variable relationship correlation analysis was led to discover the variables – independent, dependent and mediator or moderator variables mutually related with each other or not and to find out the strength of this relationship in quantitative terms. correlation relate the intensity of the relationship between different variables used for the analysis which are listed below: table 1. correlation analysis gc sd op green construction (gc) pearson correlation 1 sig. (2-tailed) n 132 sustainable development (sd) pearson correlation .207* 1 sig. (2-tailed) .017 n 132 organization performance (op) pearson correlation .522** .319** 1 sig. (2-tailed) .000 .000 n 132 132 132 source – developed by the authors the relationship between green construction and organization performance found strongly positive relationship as pearson correlation value is positive 0.522 with the highly significance level 0.000 (less than 0.05). the relationship between sustainable development and the organization performance found moderate and positive relationship at value 0.319 at high significance level. similarly, relationship between green construction and sustainable development is positive at 0.20 and statistically significant at 0.017 (less than 0.05). therefore, summarizing the correlation analysis, it is concluded that strong positive correlation exists between the predictor and outcome variables as well with the mediator variable. 4.2 linear regression the regression analysis is used to understand the causal relationship of the predictors and outcome variables and the form of these relationships. the analysis is used to test the established hypothesized http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5068 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 13 relationship to determine the causality direction and quantitative magnitude between the model’s variables. linear regression indicate about the direct relationship path between independent and dependent variable table 2. linear regression: model r r square adjusted r square std. error est 1 .522a .272 .267 .51919 a. predictors: (constant), gc source – developed by the authors table 3. anova test: model sum of squares df mean square f sig. regression 13.113 1 13.113 48.647 .000b residual 35.043 130 .270 total 48.157 131 a. dependent variable: organizational performance (op) b. predictors: (constant), green construction (gc) source – developed by the authors in first step analysis carried out to control the influence of demographics on the relationship between variable while in second step the regression analysis (anova test) was carried out. according to the statistical result of analysis it is found that one-unit increase in iv i.e. green construction will tends to increase in the dv i.e. organizational performance by the 0.522 units while total effect is 0.445. f test value also above the 4.0, in our case we have 48.647 which indicate the acceptance of our hypothesis. the value of “adjusted r square” indicate the value of relationship between iv and dv. in our study variation exist between the green construction and organization performance is 26.7% (0.267). adjusted r square has smaller value as compared to r square. standard error of estimates how much change is not elaborate by the model and for this model its value is 0.51919. http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5068 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 14 table 4. coefficient of anova test a. dependent variable: op source – developed by the authors table 4, indicate the result of linear regression analysis for independent and outcome variable. result indicate the positive relationship between the green construction and organizational performance. after analysing results, it is clear that independent variable significantly impacts dependent variable. hence all above result of anova test of linear regression lies under the defined ranges which indicate that, green construction (iv) bring positive significant changes in organization performance (dv). we can narrate as the one-unit change of green construction can bring 0.445 unit positive and significant change in organizational performance. first hypothesis of this research study or direct path relationship in conceptual framework is accepted. 4.3 multiple regression for mediation 4.3.1 impact of iv on mediator table 5. model summary of iv on mediator r r-sq f df1 df2 p .2071 .0429 5.8243 1.0000 130.000 .0172 source – developed by the authors result indicate the multiple regression for indirect path as defined in conceptual framework, indirect path further have two direct patches from iv to mediator and from mediator to dv. initially for direct relationship of green construction (iv) and sustainable development (mediation) without consideration of outcome variable (organizational performance) statistical result as follow: significance level p=0.172<0.05, variable variation r-sq=.0429 (4.2 percent). since value of p is less than 0.05 and f test value lies above 2.0, therefor overall model is significant. model unstandardized coefficients standardized coefficients beta t sig. b std. error constant 1.242 .136 9.153 .000 green construction .445 .064 .522 6.975 .000 http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5068 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 15 table 6. result of impact on mediator coeff se t p llci ulci constant 1.6243 .1638 9.9169 .0000 1.3002 1.9483 gc .1860 .0771 2.4134 .0172 .0335 .3385 source – developed by the authors result highlighted the impact of independent variable (green construction): per unit variable change or coefficient (beta value) = 0.1860, t model test (t) = 2.4134, (above 2.0), significance level p = .00172 (less than 0.05), boot value are non-negative, null fall outside the strapping value so confidence interval also lies between non-zero. hence; for every 1-unit increase in green construction, we get a 0.186-unit increase in sustainable development. hypothesis –ii; accepted. 4.3.2 direct effect on outcome variable table 7. model summary of organizational performance r r-sq mse f df1 df2 p .5648 .3190 .2542 30.2135 2.0000 129.0000 .0000 source – developed by the authors table 7, indicated the direct effect from independent variable and mediator variable on outcome variables. analysis result shows as, significant value p<0.05, variable change r-sq=.3190 (31.9 percent) variance exist due to two predictors. since value of p is less than 0.05, and f test value is above 4.0, therefore overall model is significant. table 8. model of organizational performance coeff. se t p llci ulci constant .9010 .1746 5.1599 .0000 .5555 1.2465 gc .4063 .0634 6.4106 .0000 .2809 .5316 sd .2098 .0706 2.9740 .0035 .0702 .3494 source – developed by the authors http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5068 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 16 table 8, shows the overall result on outcome variable which is organizational performance from the sustainable development and green construction. the impact of green construction (iv) as; per item change through coefficient (beta value) = 0.4063, t model test value, t = 6.4106, (above 2.0) significance value, p = .0000 (less than 0.05), confidence interval also lies between non-zero from upper limit and lower limit interval secondly, mediation sustainable development impact on outcome variable as; coefficient (beta value) = .2098, t model test value, t = 2.9740 (above 2.0), significant value, p = 0.0035 (less than 0.05), and confidence interval also lies in positive ranges and no zero exist between interval. hence; for every 1unit increase of green construction, we get 0.4063-unit increase, and 1-unit increase of sustainable development, we get 0.2098-unit increase in overall outcome value. hypothesis iii accepted. 4.4 role of mediating variable: role of mediation analyzed through the indirect effect of multiple regression model of andrew hayes and preacher. mediating variable presence indicate that overall strengthen or weaken the relationship. for analysis model 4, used and mediation role indicated by the indirect path or effect from x to y. statistically result indicate as; confidence interval from positive boot strapping value interval as zero falls outside the confidence interval, (.0021 and .0948) hence the relationship is signification. effect indicate the beta value which means, change of 1 unit of mediator (sustainable development) brings .0390-unit change in the relationship between iv (green construction) and dv (organization performance). overall relationship has 0.4063 direct effect without mediation and 0.0390 indirect effect on outcome variable through the mediating variable. table 9. indirect effect of x on y effect boot se bootllci bootulci sd .0390 .0238 .0021 .0948 source – developed by the authors http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5068 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 17 table 10. direct effect of x on y effect se t p llci ulci .4063 .0634 6.4106 .0000 .2809 .5316 source – developed by the authors table 11: total effect effect se t p llci ulci .4453 .0638 6.9747 .0000 .3190 .5716 source – developed by the authors table listed above, indicated the result of mediating variable which is sustainable development in our research study. from the results of analysis, overall, with the mediation the effect is .4453 within the significant level (p=0.000<0.05) and lies under positive confidence interval (non zero). total effect of direct path through linear regression (anova) remains same from as through the multiple regression hence, from the mediation test it is concluded that the mediating variable which in this study is sustainable development is affecting the relationship of green construction and organizational performance to 8.75 % with (0.0390) per item change. therefore, in the light of the observation we conclude that there is partial mediation exist between the model, sustainable development practices partially mediate the impact of green construction on organizational performance. 5. discussion in this section, we relate our finding with the theoretical literature support. the current study tested the direct and indirect relationship between the green construction and organizational performance with mediating variable sustainable development practices. 5.1 green construction impact on organizational performance. this study is supported by some of the previous researches which also contributed the same results toward the organizational development in the construction industry. fahimnia, sarkis, and davarzani (2015), green construction mainly divided into two parts green design and green operation which means http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5068 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 18 planning and execution of green practices such as less production of waste and reuse of old material. the field which focus on the importance of corporate practices related to green construction focused on the preservation of natural resources, reuse and recycling of old building material. the adoption of such practices by the organization at corporate level help to reduce their expenses such as overheads and increase market share through the better business strategies with modern techniques. green construction involves the review of project life cycle and analyze project phases and convert them in to less economical and less environment degradation factors such as reverse logistics and network design in planning phase which involve review of policies and change the strategies while in execution phase involve waste management such as less use of pollution sources and material which can easily recycled. (brunner & rechberger, 2015) according to the chakraborty (2010), green practices at corporate level are the major source of cost efficiency, profitability, market share, preservation of resources and less causes for rework during the construction which enhance the organization performance by developing new market opportunities with higher profit and good practices for others in industry. statistical result of our research study also added in the favor of argument that adoption of green practices at construction industry bring positive consequences on the organizational performance. 5.2 green construction impact towards sustainable development somehow green construction is the part of sustainable development while sustainable development is a vast field of knowledge and vary with respect to the working industry. although it is a new emerging concept but it grows very rapidly in the construction sector in different country across the globe and bring significant results. (pedersen, 2018) sustainable development covers three main aspects as per the definition, preservation of natural resources, less cost consumptions resources and meet current demands without compromising future generation demands. in our study we focus on the environment and climate protection policy and result statistically indicate that green construction is helpful to protect the environment and climate protection while scientifically also sustainability techniques have been introduced across the globe which causes the less environment degradation. adoption of that tools and techniques during the construction causes the less degradation such as the variation of material used for the construction i.e. fabrication, steel and many others. these materials not only save the cost, and time but also causes less degradation which is helpful to preserve the natural resources. researchers including http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5068 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 19 (sarkis & zhu, 2018) indicate the role of less waste production through the green construction process which is the biggest relief in the environment protection. as construction industry is the major source of environment degradation and waste deposition is the emerging issue which is hard to control while new latest practices adopted during the green construction such as use of plywood which can easily reuse and recycle rather than the use of framework of natural wood which originated from the tree cutting. researchers also indicate the other green practices such as the reuse of old building material in partition or low load bearing structure in the form of solid aggregate is quite helpful from the financial aspect. our statistical research added in terms of green construction can bring significant positive changes in the sustainable development. 5.3 sustainable development impact on organizational development sustainable development and environment protection is major emerging challenge for the world. organizational have to deal with it during the project lifecycle and somehow their projects are the cause of this environment degradation due to lack of sustainable business practices. researcher (awadh, 2017) defined the concept of sustainable institute. world certified institute for green mark, known as leadership in energy and environmental design (leed) from usa, other institute of france emphasizes on their organization to develop and adopt green business strategies which based on the preservation of natural resources, long lasting and economical structure. on the other side organizations following the leed standard are strictly bound to adopt and implement the sustainable practices in terms of less carbon production in environment which also lead to the heavy penalty. other researcher including song, zhao, and zeng (2017) report the significant changes and positive relationship between environment management and the financial performance of the manufacturing companies located in china. research study found the significant evidence between green practices at corporate level and economical performances in electronic industries located in taiwan. implementation of sustainable practices is the responsibility of government stakeholder working at national and international project in terms of protection policies and penalties. government and organizations designed the alternative parameters and result shows that adoption of green practices not only enhance productivity and causes less degradation but also built standards for other industry at national and international practices. our research also strengthens the argument that adoption of sustainable development practices can bring positive change on organization performances. http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5068 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 20 5.4 sustainable development relationship between green construction and organizational performance. project quality mainly based on the project designing team at the initial phases while financial performance based on the execution phase mainly and both play important role in the overall organization and project performance. green construction highly depends on the efficiency of the project designing team. as the sustainable development and green construction practices as well is the modern emerging concept and growing very rapidly, organization top management, and stakeholder must show their interest and update their business and hr development strategies towards the sustainable development. according to the awadh (2017) there are various sustainable material introduces for the construction industry which use as the alternatives and their result show as the good practices for others industry, such as the steel structure which save the time, cost and overhead of the organization and also control the amount of rework. organization working on the construction sector are the part of policy maker and agreed that long term degradation exerted in terms of usage of alternative resources such as hvac system, and pre-fabricated structure instead of concrete structure which rises the temperature of earth. researchers (tariyan, 2016) indicated that adoption of green practices not only enhance productivity and causes less degradation but also built standards for other industry at national and international practices. moreover, existing of sustainable development policy such as environment policy causes the better environment friendly green construction which also causes the organization to change their existing business strategies which ultimately enhance their productivity in terms of good practices, market share and project performances (nilsson, griggs, & visbeck, 2016). result of our study also strengthen the argument that sustainable development positively mediates between the relationship of green construction and employee performance. 6. conclusion finding of this study indicate that green construction and organizational performance are associated with each other positively. there is positive relation exist between the factors of green construction such as reuse and recycling of material and the factors of organizational performance such as the market share, and productivity. moreover, research result also indicates that mediator which is sustainable development including environment protection policies partially mediate the relationship which means organization working in construction industry can enhanced their performance through the formalization and adoption http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5068 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 21 of environment protection strategies during the construction projects. this research study filled the research gap about the sustainable development and green construction practices role in organizational performance. research focus on the organizations working in construction industry on twin city projects since last two years which to develop the better understanding about the relationship between green construction and organizational performance through the mediation of sustainable development. research has managerial and theoretical implications in the field of construction industry. green construction is the modern sustainable development and important for the organization to enhance its performance and meet international standards. organization top management must change their business practices and adopt knowledge sharing technique to enhance employee performance. moreover, this research gives a pleasant input toward s the enhancement of organizational performance change in construction process and standards is a long-time consumption and huge dispersion of competitive conditions such as company capital, standards, and technology advancement. this study helps to develop the understanding about the impact of green construction on the organizational performance and as well as the adoption of sustainable development policies in organization business strategies. it has been proven from findings that there is ample room for further research. one possible attempt could be studying the dependent variable which steam performance as dependent variable. and further studying the impact of green construction on the organization performance. basically, the analysis of the relationship between different can only be studied. further carried out research in longitudinal concept with different region (location) and projects (residential or commercial). increment in sample size and change in the sustainable development assessment factor such as economy may bring more significant changes in the mediating role. research can also have carried out as per emerging concept of green marketing which mainly depend on the organization and consumer relationship in better environment. the study can also be conducted on the relationship between sustainable development practices and green construction where green construction can be considered as a dependent and sustainable development as independent variable instead of a mediation variable, and an additional variable playing a moderating role, can also be introduced in the conducted study to broaden the scope of the research. considering all of the possibilities that this area of research lacks, one could conclude that there is always still a lot to discover in the following field. this research study has certain limitations, there was a shortage of time to conduct this research study. the questionnaires survey was limited to the employees working in construction based organized located http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5068 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 22 in the twin cities of rawalpindi and islamabad. so, time consuming questionnaires would not have been affordable. data was filled on the basis of their previous two-year projects. secondly, the study has been only conducted on the basis of employee working with last two-year project. this again does not represent the whole part of the population targeted initially. conflict of interest: there is no conflict of interest acknowledgement: author express his gratitude and thanks to szabist for their supervision, technical support and guidance in this research. in addition, also thanks for providing partial institutional support. funding: this research based on the academic point of view and receive no funding from any organization or institution. http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5068 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 23 appendix a table 12: items of questionnaire in the last 2 years, the company has adopted the following practices in work execution green construction reduce waste of materials in construction site reusing materials on construction site replacing, reducing or minimizing the use of toxic substances (eg paints and solvents) actions to reduce liquid waste (e.g., leak containment or flushing with water) reduce energy use at the construction site actions to improve supply chain environmental efficiency (e.g. cooperation to reduce packaging, economic transport, technological synergie) please indicate the extent of your agreement/disagreement with the statements sustainable development when people interfere with the environment, they often produce disastrous consequences environmental protection and people’s quality of life are directly linked biodiversity should be protected at the expense of industrial agricultural production building development is less important than environmental protection environmental protection is more important than industrial growth in the last 2 years, there was an improvement in company’s performance organizational performance sales increase market share increase corporate image improvement environmental performance improvement in related businesses or buildings regarding to the reduction of water consumption environmental performance improvement in related businesses or buildings regarding to energy efficiency environmental performance improvement in related businesses or buildings regarding to the use of materials financial results improvement revenue increase reductions of risk of environmental legal penalties improvement in company operation (e.g., building efficiency indicators) source – developed by the authors references akram, m. s., goraya, m., malik, a., & aljarallah, a. m. (2018). organizational performance and sustainability: exploring the roles of it capabilities and knowledge management capabilities. sustainability, 10(10), 3816. armstrong, r. l. (1987). the midpoint on a five-point likert-type scale. perceptual and motor skills, 64(2), 359-362. http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5068 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 24 awadh, o. (2017). sustainability and green building rating systems: leed, breeam, gsas and estidama critical analysis. journal of building engineering, 11, 25-29. bedrunka, k. (2020). concepts of the sustainable development of the region. in sustainable production: novel trends in energy, environment and material systems (pp. 11-18): springer. biasutti, m., & frate, s. (2017). a validity and reliability study of the attitudes toward sustainable development scale. environmental education research, 23(2), 214-230. bocchini, p., frangopol, d. m., ummenhofer, t., & zinke, t. (2014). resilience and sustainability of civil infrastructure: toward a unified approach. journal of infrastructure systems, 20(2), 04014004. boone, h. n., & boone, d. a. (2012). analyzing likert data. journal of extension, 50(2), 1-5. brunner, p. h., & rechberger, h. (2015). waste to energy–key element for sustainable waste management. waste management, 37, 3-12. chakraborty, s. (2010). concise chronological road map of evolving green supply chain management concepts: a review. iup journal of supply chain management, 7(4). darko, a., & chan, a. p. (2016). critical analysis of green building research trend in construction journals. habitat international, 57, 53-63. darko, a., zhang, c., & chan, a. p. (2017). drivers for green building: a review of empirical studies. habitat international, 60, 34-49. fahimnia, b., sarkis, j., & davarzani, h. (2015). green supply chain management: a review and bibliometric analysis. international journal of production economics, 162, 101-114. farooqui, r., & ahmed, s. (2008). assessment of pakistani construction industry–current performance and the way forward. journal for the advancement of performance information & value, 1(1). fawaz, a.-n., ruparathna, r., chhipi-shrestha, g., haider, h., hewage, k., & sadiq, r. (2016). sustainability assessment framework for low rise commercial buildings: life cycle impact index-based approach. clean technologies and environmental policy, 18(8), 2579-2590. gronemus, j. q., hair, p. s., crawford, k. b., nyalwidhe, j. o., cunnion, k. m., & krishna, n. k. (2010). potent inhibition of the classical pathway of complement by a novel c1q-binding peptide derived from the human astrovirus coat protein. molecular immunology, 48(1-3), 305-313. gunasekaran, a., papadopoulos, t., dubey, r., wamba, s. f., childe, s. j., hazen, b., & akter, s. (2017). big data and predictive analytics for supply chain and organizational performance. journal of business research, 70, 308-317. http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5068 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 25 hair jr, j. f., sarstedt, m., hopkins, l., & kuppelwieser, v. g. (2014). partial least squares structural equation modeling (pls-sem). european business review. holden, e., linnerud, k., & banister, d. (2014). sustainable development: our common future revisited. global environmental change, 26, 130-139. huang, j., wang, x., gong, y., liu, y., zhou, p., suo, x., . . . li, h. (2017). construction of wo3 coatings with micro-nano hybrid structures by liquid precursor flame spray for enhanced sensing performances to sub-ppm ozone. materials letters, 205, 106-109. johns‐putra, a. (2016). climate change in literature and literary studies: from cli‐fi, climate change theater and ecopoetry to ecocriticism and climate change criticism. wiley interdisciplinary reviews: climate change, 7(2), 266-282. lin, s.-c. (2015). an analysis for construction engineering networks. journal of construction engineering and management, 141(5), 04014096. linnenluecke, m. k., birt, j., & griffiths, a. (2015). the role of accounting in supporting adaptation to climate change. accounting & finance, 55(3), 607-625. malik, s., & wahid, j. (2014). rapid urbanization: problems and challenges for adequate housing in pakistan. nilsson, m., griggs, d., & visbeck, m. (2016). policy: map the interactions between sustainable development goals. nature, 534(7607), 320-322. pedersen, c. s. (2018). the un sustainable development goals (sdgs) are a great gift to business! procedia cirp, 69, 21-24. rahmawati, y., utomo, c., anwar, n., setijanti, p., & nurcahyo, c. b. (2014). an empirical model for successful collaborative design towards sustainable project development. journal of sustainable development, 7(2), 1. rego, b. f. s., & figueira, a. c. r. (2017). business, government and foreign policy: brazilian construction firms abroad. brazilian political science review, 11(1). ricart, s., olcina, j., & rico, a. m. (2019). evaluating public attitudes and farmers’ beliefs towards climate change adaptation: awareness, perception, and populism at european level. land, 8(1), 4. riley, d. (2004). procurement of sustainable construction services in the united states: the contractor s role in green buildings. http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5068 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 26 saenz, c., & brown, h. (2018). the disclosure of anticorruption aspects in companies of the construction sector: main companies worldwide and in latin america. journal of cleaner production, 196, 259-272. sarkis, j., & zhu, q. (2018). environmental sustainability and production: taking the road less travelled. international journal of production research, 56(1-2), 743-759. secinaro, s., brescia, v., calandra, d., & saiti, b. (2020). impact of climate change mitigation policies on corporate financial performance: evidence‐based on european publicly listed firms. corporate social responsibility and environmental management. shi, q., zuo, j., huang, r., huang, j., & pullen, s. (2013). identifying the critical factors for green construction–an empirical study in china. habitat international, 40, 1-8. song, h., zhao, c., & zeng, j. (2017). can environmental management improve financial performance: an empirical study of a-shares listed companies in china. journal of cleaner production, 141, 1051-1056. sormunen, p., & kärki, t. (2019). recycled construction and demolition waste as a possible source of materials for composite manufacturing. journal of building engineering, 100742. tariyan, a. (2016). the impact of green innovation types on organization performance in the construction industry. in: iioabj. wei, y., & miraglia, s. (2017). organizational culture and knowledge transfer in project-based organizations: theoretical insights from a chinese construction firm. international journal of project management, 35(4), 571-585. yee, h. c., ismail, r., & jing, k. t. (2020). the barriers of implementing green building in penang construction industry. world, 12, 1-10. yigitcanlar, t., kamruzzaman, m., & teriman, s. (2015). neighborhood sustainability assessment: evaluating residential development sustainability in a developing country context. sustainability, 7(3), 2570-2602. zampese, e. r. d. s., moori, r. g., & caldeira, a. (2016). green marketing as a mediator between supply chain management and organizational performance. ram. revista de administração mackenzie, 17(3), 183-211. 5516-article text-17221-1-9-20210223 european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5516 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 45 management accounting in european finance for smart tourism and sustainable destinations: how organizations deficiency? stefano de nichilo1 1 department of economic and business sciences, university of cagliari, italy e-mail: stefanodenichilo1985@gmail.com received: 26/10/2020 revised: 06/02/2021 accepted for publication: 07/02/2020 published: 08/03/2021 abstract the research investigates the interplay of sustainable tourism, management, monitoring, destination life cycles and stakeholder involvement in sardinia destinations. management techniques are considered critical to the sustainable stewardship and competitiveness of tourism destinations, especially in an island context where tourism is business all year round and all seasons. the importance of tourism management and monitoring in destinations and organizations is particularly highlighted through an explanation of sustainable tourism indicator systems such as that created by the european commission. systems such as this will help position europe as the leading sustainable tourism destination in the world both now and in the future. the research followed an inductive approach. according to general principles of the inductive methodology, knowledge is gathered from detailed observation of facts. this study permits to adopt multiple research methods, both qualitative and quantitative. the analysis is grounded in documents, direct observations and questionnaires. in the first phase, only qualitative methods were utilized. this classification is supported by the assessor answers: high to moderate tourism impacts respectively on destination a (north sardinia) and b (south sardinia) and a level of contact between tourists and the local population that can be classified as low in the destination a and between low and moderate in destination b. the effects of public european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5516 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 46 policies and tourism development cannot be measured only in economic terms, this paper provides a qualitative-quantitative analysis of the phenomenon and possible proxies. keywords: management accounting, organization settings, smart tourism, sustainable destinations, tourism indicator systems and tourism management and monitoring. 1. introduction management accounting has a peculiar function with the broader accounting discipline. “management accounting is concerned with the provision of information to people within the organizations to help them make better decisions and the improve the efficiency and effectiveness of existing operations” (van der stede 2015). the peculiarity of management accounting is that it is a science dealing with decision-making, whereas the remaining part of accounting is basically the science of reporting accounting information (power 2009). the necessity to manage and control tourism and impacts at the local level (hannan & freeman 1977) has attracted attention to the basis of the tourism phenomenon: geographic areas defined by administrative boundaries that are perceived in the market through a specific image. sustainability is regarded as a science (kates 2001; levin and clark 2010; kates 2011) based on multi-disciplinary approaches. different disciplines: psychology, sociology, geography, and ecology, contribute to the growth of the field, which are comprised of various aspect included in the concepts of nature, human beings and organizations. the complexity of tourism phenomenon and sustainability topics enriches scientists’ investigation. sustainability is certainly a multifaceted field of investigation. in literature, an important research has been conducted on destination management and, specifically for our purposes, there is a branch of this research called adaptive management (larson et al., 2012; plummer et al., 2009; mccook, 2010; karatzoglou et al., 2010), which will be mentioned in the following pages, since it is considered related to sustainable tourism management. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5516 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 47 the postmodern period of management accounting was encouraged by the development of information technology and the view of the organization as a complex set of interdependencies and relationships (hopper & bui 2016). within a dynamic and competitive environment, in a business world of fast and cheap information flow, management accounting had to solve the problem involving the flexibility and competitiveness of production, while the academic discussion moved onto the question of how to implement management accounting systems in a such a complex and uncertain environment (biancone, secinaro, brescia, calandra 2020). the research paradigm followed in the study can be considered interpretative; the destinations represent a composite reality in which it is possible to address observation, investigation and possibly develop and define concepts for future evolvement in the fields (jones, t., atkinson, h., lorenz, a., & harris, p. 2012). management accounting (van der stede 2011) is nowadays at a turning point, as pressures from outside call for increased disclosure of information, which “before was mainly relegated to internal decision making” (power 2007). moreover, when the crisis happened, due to constrained finance, firm faced the issue of rethinking their decisions, sometimes including their strategic decisions, and “had to set their budgets aside at worst, or revise them at best” (palermo & van der stede 2011). tourism destination are complex systems that evolve overtime. in the dynamic of tourism demand and supply evolution, destinations can either encounter prosperity or decline. which type of development is appropriate for destinations? this is the general enquiry the study has considered in its initial formulation, based on the recognition of mass tourism as one of the global change syndromes (gordon & narayanan 1984). how can destinations became and remain sustainable over the course of their lifespan? this part of sustainable tourism is less developed in the tourism discourse as it appears less evident than protection of the environment (clarke 1997; swarbrooke 1999). considering the unwto definition (2004, pag. 7) related to management, it is stated “sustainable tourism development requires the informed participation of all relevant stakeholders, as well as strong political leadership to ensure wide participation and consensus building. achieving sustainable tourism is a continuous process and it requires constant monitoring of impacts, introducing the necessary preventive and/or corrective measures whenever necessary”. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5516 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 48 in this respect figure 1 is restructured below to evidence management as a mean to reach the goal of sustainability in destinations. the managerial environment has a broader significance and embraces institutions, organizations, associations, and business (swarbrooke 1999). each of these entities usually plays an active role in the management of tourism activities within the environmental boundaries of a destination. hence, sustainable tourism is a human-centred concept (mitchell, 1997), in which social groups participate and contribute to the realization of sustainable attributes of destinations. managing tourism also involves tourists, as the unwto definition (2004, pag. 7) points out “sustainable tourism should also maintain a high level of tourist satisfaction and ensure a meaningful experience to the tourists, raising their awareness about sustainability issues and promoting sustainable tourism practices amongst them”. international acknowledgement of the importance of the environment and its related issues and the relevance to tourism management are stated in the core message of the brundtland report, “our common future”. this document can be considered a main justification for declarations of political commitment to the environment. the key concept in this report is the compromise between present and future developments in order to preserve the primary resource of tourism: the destination. it is indicated that policy directions should aim to follow a sustainable path in development patterns. adequate management accounting systems (galbraith 1973) may be useful for detecting issues at an early stage and informing the management about the feasibility of any financial or economic inconvenience before it develops into an important risk and captures the attention of key stakeholders. following the previous considerations, the research questions this study aims to answer are: a) which kind of managerial tools allow destinations to preserve the current natural heritage to guarantee the conservation for future generations? b) are these managerial tools effective for sustainable management of tourism in destinations as to ensure the future existence of destinations? the underlying hypotheses of this study are: first, the effective management of tourism impacts in destinations requires adequate indicator systems; second, the effectiveness of indicator systems rely on destination stakeholders’ commitment; and third, that sustainability, area life cycle, and governance are intrinsically related in destinations. the main gap in the literature is the analysis of a particular case, but at the same time representative of an evolved civil society like that of the islands. this idea is true first of all for a certain degree of european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5516 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 49 independence from the central country system and then for the cultural openness to the limit of uniqueness that only an island can offer. the smart tourism destination in an island context is fundamental as regards aspects of work and the quality of life. our choice falls in sardinia where tourism is business all year round and all seasons. to answer these research questions and provide support for the related hypothesis, the methodology adopted in the study is inductive; overall, qualitative methods provide the core foundation for this research, as it is explained in the followings paragraphs. figure 1. outcomes of corporate social responsibility source: our elaboration 2. literature review 2.1 institutional settings: contingency theory and issues of financial pressure the activity of internal auditors, and the processes and control systems they deal with, are not predicable ex ante and are depicted contingently, they cannot rely on a “one-size-fits-all” procedure, but need to be adjusted to the specific context of a specific firm at a specific time. that said, management accounting as a discipline is able to identify specific procedures, which can better match specifically defined situations in which the organization may be involved. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5516 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 50 according to contingency theory (fischer 1995), situational factors (or contingent or contextual factors) influence the design of the management accounting system, while organizational performance and effectiveness depend on the quality of fit of the management accounting system, when designed ad hoc, and the specific situational factors that activated it. these characteristics of the discipline make it difficult to undertake big numbers-based empirical studies, as each organization is unique and the potential situational factors are infinite and nested with each other, while the effectiveness of the fit between the management accounting system and the situational factors is often not easily measurable. to simplify the application of management accounting to practical issues, theorists have variously tried to categorize the situational factors. the external environment and its level of uncertainty are relevant situational factors, related to change in the environment, which occur unexpectedly, such as the financial crisis of 2008. when the conditions under which the firm operates are more stable, the external environment will be considered as more certain. on the contrary, dynamic conditions are the premise for an uncertain external environment (eckles, hoyt & miller 2014). it is documented that firms operating in a more stable and certain environment adopt a formula-based approach to the measurement of management accounting systems effectiveness, whereas firms operating in a dynamic and uncertain environment adopt a subjective approach to performance evaluation. in the current situation, a formula-based approach, which presupposes the meeting of targets, will easily fail if the uncertain dynamics of the environment make the targets inappropriate. uncertainty (chenhal & morris 1985) is also correlated with the level of sophistication of the management accounting system, given that a certain external environment needs only internal, financial and historical information, whereas an uncertain external environment will require a more sophisticated management accounting systems, which can also gather information that is external, less finical and future-oriented, as well as generally requiring decentralization in the organizational (and decisional) structure. the competitive strategy adopted by the firm is also a situational factor, which is able to shape the management accounting systems (chapman 2006). a low-cost competitive strategy will require a formula-based approach, requiring significant attention paid to cost control mechanisms and frequent european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5516 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 51 and detailed quantitative reports on performance. on the other hand, a differentiation strategy will control costs less effectively and be mainly focused on non-financial measures of performance. destinations are the basis of tourism at local level; they are the primary resource of tourism business, and are the object of management strategies and policies aimed at adequately conserving it as a resource. this is the priority of sustainable tourism destinations, which, in a modern approach, cannot be implemented without being collectively addressed through stakeholders participation. it has also to be noted that an ideal equilibrium state is impossible to reach in composite systems as destinations, where complex system of resources, tools, management levels and stakeholders types are in place. sustainable destination can then appear in their holistic vision, as integrated, adaptive socioecological system. these are the elements that will be discussed: a. destination as an integrated systems; b. destination as a social system; c. destination as a socio-ecological system; d. destination as an adaptive system. a sustainable tourism destination is an integrated system characterized by a high degree of complexity. the notion of system is relevant to appreciate the elements that make up the concept of sustainable destination, and their value within the composite system. a system is not simply the sun of its elements, but is notably distinguished by a specific combination of elements derived from interrelation and exchange. the destination is a unique and original entity in comparison to its single attributes, and has a value that exceeds the potential of the distinct elements of which it is composed. in the paper, the destination has been identified through the attributes of attractions, amenities, human resources, accessibility, image and price. in the context of this paper, those same attributes will be highlighted as part of a destination system, in which they can play a role in qualifying and defining the destination profile. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5516 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 52 in pointing out the social system of a destination, the complexity of sustainable tourism destination systems appears evident. the destination is an entity with distinctive elements on the ground, such as beaches, buildings, roads, etc., comprised of people that are part of different social groups within the economic environment, families, enterprises, associations and public administrations. in tourism destinations this social clusters can be regrouped to represent the different parts of the society with interest in tourism. in this respect, the social groups are named, stakeholders, and though informed participation, the composition of their interests makes the social system sustainable (sautter and leisen 1999). the destination is a mix of society and nature, in which the composition of different stakeholder approaches is the real challenge for destinations committed to sustainable behaviors. in this sense, the last character of destinations as sustainable systems is the necessary to adopt flexible and adaptive forms of management that are able to face the continuous evolvement of tourism interest groups and society, and ensure the adaption of the natural and physical environment to global and local changes. specifically, the branch of tourism management know as adaptive management is defined in literature as, “the process of building resilience and coping with the uncertain inherent in complex systems through a continual process of experimenting, monitoring and social learning” (miller and twiningward, 2005, pag. 19). environmental crises related to climate change are constantly increasing, creating grater impacts on communities and vulnerable people, such as indigenous and poor populations. managing risks and developing mitigation and adaption planning approaches has been conceptualised and implemented worldwide (page 2010). the need to reduce vulnerability of the environment to crises, which can also impact on tourism, will require stakeholder involvement and collaborative management based on multilevel policies and programmes. finally attention on technology will also determine the appropriateness of the management accounting system, as formula-based approaches and process costings are able to measure the performance of process and mass production, whereas job costing are more relevant to batch production technologies. 2.2 stakeholder theory framework for tourism analysis the stakeholder theory is also employed to explain stakeholder relationship in business belonging to different sectors, including the tourism sector. the theory can contribute to regulating relationship european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5516 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 53 between tourism actors at the destination level. in particular, the principles of the theory are considered more significant in the case of destinations involved in sustainable tourism development, due to the role stakeholders should play. indeed, as described in previous paragraphs, international and european sustainable tourism organizations consider the involvement and the commitment of all stakeholders in planning and in the decision-making process at the destination level as a fundamental step in sustainable tourism development. many studies aim to identify stakeholder of tourism. sautter and leisen (1999), refer to workers, local enterprise, residents, tourists, public administrators, competitors, activists and international chains as the stakeholders involved in tourism planning at a destination level. ryan (2002), considering potential stakeholders of an hypothetical tour operator in an hypothetical destination, identifies government, travel agencies, local administrators, accommodation enterprises, natural and urban environment, workers, brokerage houses and other special interest groups. currie (2009) considers the mitchel (1997) categories and identifies local indigenous enterprises as dormant stakeholders, fishing and sailing enterprises as discretionary stakeholders, the water managing authority as demanding stakeholders, governmental authorities as dominant stakeholders, tourism and accommodation enterprises as dependent stakeholders, environmentalists as dangerous stakeholders, and natural resources managing enterprises as definitive stakeholders. byrd (2007) selects the current and potential community and tourists as the stakeholders principally involved in sustainable tourism development at the destination level. according to the traditional approach, the interests of the three stakeholder groups are incompatible. for example, actions aimed at the maximization of business profits could cause damage on the natural environment. expectations of workers could be conflicting with business profit objectives. environmental associations and local authorities could conflict in the management of natural resources. however, according to a different perspective, stakeholders interests can be considered complementary. in destinations focused on tourism development, and especially sustainable tourism development, business cannot pursue economic goal that negate the efforts to safeguard the natural and cultural environment. this is because natural and cultural attractions represent the core of tourism products and the most interesting destination features for tourists. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5516 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 54 their degradation entails a loss of destination value, a tarnished image, and other indirect negative consequence on the tourism industry. for these reasons, the involvement and commitment of all destination stakeholders in planning and developing strategies is recommended to define joint and balanced actions in sustainable tourism development (figure 2). figure 2. balanced sustainable tourism development source: our elaboration. the current variety of instruments used to protect and manage the environment and tourism is sophisticated and has been intensively developed in the last decades, following the environmental consciousness of stakeholder in destinations. over time, relevant decision-makers, organization and institutions, academia and professionals have contributed to develop programs, policies and systems to improve the sustainability of tourism, economies and societies. a first group of sustainable initiatives is related to land-use planning, such as zoning, quotas, and protected areas. these initiatives are specifically planned and coordinated within public tourism management. a second collection of sustainable efforts is related to the acknowledgment of unique sites of interest, which are promoted by international institutions. a third set of sustainable programs is focused on enterprises, including environmental management systems and the like. these can be european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5516 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 55 developed through private associations, such as tour operators, or other organizations and institutions with interest in sustainable tourism development. public policies, plans and initiatives play a strategic role in the sustainability of tourism destinations. in fact, the public sector has the power to legislative and use fiscal instruments that can determine and characterize a destination either toward exploitation or conservation of the natural, economic, social and cultural environment. this is true in different parts of the world where the state of nature and humans have been altered by tourism development. the positive and negative impacts of tourism need to be balanced through public intervention in order to regulate tourism investment, processes, decision and activities that occur in geographic areas governed by public institutions. undoubtedly, public stakeholders have different priorities for the governance of territories. these priorities are influenced by linked elements, such as the quality and nature of resource, the way of life of the area, stakeholder commitment, etc. additionally, debates over the compromise between economic growth and welfare and the consequences on the environment frequently engage policy makers. sustainability in the development of territories and population is aimed at reaching economic goals while preserving the value and identity of destinations for next generations. sustainability is the perspective requires financial resources to fund sustainable initiatives that protect the integrity of destinations. the more relevant and powerful public management capability is, the more limited land utilization options become. development is a long-term process that first calls for land-use planning through legislation that can be supported by appropriate analyses conducted on the ground, carrying capacity and limits of acceptable change, and then regulation on specific sites, including zoning, the creation of protected areas, quotas and the like. in regards to the funding mechanism for sustainability, several public initiatives can contribute to the economic support of sustainable tourism, eco-taxes, user fee and donations. in a hierarchy of main public concerns, legislation on tourism is positioned, according to the vision of o’riordan (1981), after a national commitment on security and economic growth, and immediately european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5516 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 56 after regional development and income distribution. the first national goal also encompasses community health and employment. in this context, the environment does not represent a priority but is seen as an instrument that supports the national goals. the second national goal is focused on a redistribution of wealth that guarantees equitable social opportunities. this is another instance where there is no specific interest in environmental protection but it is once again beneficial to national and regional policies. the degree to which attention is given to the environment as a national and sub-national goal depends on the value that public stakeholders attribute to nature, considering internal and external forces that place pressure on the side of preservation rather that consumption. recently, there has been increasing attention given to sustainable issues and the need to implement regulation. surprisingly, this consciousness has also been spreading into developing countries, which will have to pay costs that developed countries did not face during their stages of development in the past. the sophistication of sustainability tools that advice public policies in land-use planning can be analyzed through studies on carrying capacity and limits of acceptable change. 3. methodology the research employed different methods. in the first phase of the study, literature and documents related to private and public instruments for the management of sustainable destinations were considered (baxter & jack (2008). their principles, guidelines, procedures, purposed and indicator sets were examined in a qualitative and quantitative approach. the conditions for use, and their weak and strong points were also identified (brasini 2010). in this part of the paper an empirical investigation is employed to answer the research question and hypotheses, expressed as follow: a) which kind of managerial tools allow destinations to preserve the current natural heritage to guarantee the conservation for future generations?; b) are these managerial tools effective for sustainable management of tourism in destinations as to ensure the future existence of destinations? and hypotheses: first, the effective management of tourism impact in destinations requires adequate indicator systems; second, the effectiveness of indicator system rely european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5516 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 57 on destination stakeholders’ commitment; and third, that sustainability, area life cycle, and governance are intrinsically related in destinations (castellani & sala 2010). considerations have also been traced on the effectiveness of managerial and control tools in tourism sustainability on the comparison among indicator system with potential and value for tourism stakeholders (corbetta 2003). the empirical investigation adopts a multiple case study approach based on the analysis of two destinations that are participating in an international program. each destination represent a single case study. the program covers a limited number of destinations. questionnaires were addressed to destination assessor involved in the program, including all the destinations assessed for sustainability policies and practices (coyne, i.t. 1997). among these destinations, a purposed sampling, based on a subjective choice and not at random (guarte and barrios, 2006) was selected. the two destinations were chosen intentionally according to the following criteria: a. the life cycle stage of the destination. to address the third hypothesis that sustainability, life cycle area, and governance are intrinsically related in destinations, all the stage of life, ascertained through the destination assessor answer, needed to be included in the destination sample for the analysis (creswell 2013). b. the significance of the destination for the aims of the research. to investigate the relationship between tourism management and monitoring, destination life cycle, stakeholder interest and involvement, and the level of sustainability in destinations, the sample of destinations, representative of the population in the international program (battaglia 2011), is characterized as follows: geographical pertinence to the different world continents, inclusion of developed and developing destinations, variety of destination attributes, and relevance of tourism sector (miller 2001). the research followed an inductive approach. according to general principles of the inductive methodology, knowledge is gathered from detailed observation of facts. in the process of induction, observations are the starting point of the research, which lead to abstract generalizations as the outcome of the study (baltaretu 2011). compared to the deductive approach, the object of inductive research is not intended to test known theories but to build an abstraction. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5516 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 58 in accordance with this approach, the research questions arose from a real experience: the involvement in international and european programs of tourism impact monitoring at the destination level (thomas 2006). the direct participation in the programs brought her to reflect upon management and monitoring systems for sustainable tourism and their effectiveness in developing sustainability in tourism destinations (buckley 2012). based on these considerations, the research questions and the related hypotheses were established, specifically deriving from two sources related to a scientific interest in sustainable tourism themes, and an in-field experience on the subject. the research area of the study (bocken, short, rana & evans 2014) has focused on sustainable tourism at a sub-national level; this subject explains the chosen unit of analysis destination. research has been limited to the managerial aspect of sustainability through indicator systems (baltaretu 2011), involving stakeholders and the related organizations in the tourism sectors. observations on the local destination context, including the implemented sustainable tourism initiatives, the level of tourism development, the stakeholder’s management skills and approach, etc., have deeply contributed to the current study (berke & conroy 2000). this tries to investigate the possible relationships between tourism management and monitoring, progress in destination development, the stakeholder interest and involvement, and the level of sustainability in those territories. there is profound association among quality of life and quality of tourism destinations. after defining the purpose of the study, the research design was elaborated and methods were selected (tab 1, 2, 3, 4 and 5). tab. 1 template descriptive data sampling interviews 20 year 2014 object of investigations sustainable sardinia tourism associations, smart destination & digitalization data sampling random 50% north sardinia and 50% south sardinia source: our elaboration european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5516 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 59 tab. 2 north sardinia elaborations destination questions % reponse % positive relevance a north sardinia population 55 88 climate 65 77 attractions 44 33 amenities 32 67 accessibility 77 87 human resource 88 99 price 99 89 image 58 56 source: our elaboration. tab. 3 south sardinia elaborations destination questions % reponse % positive relevance b south sardinia population 77 67 climate 88 88 attractions 56 99 amenities 34 66 accessibility 66 44 human resource 77 33 price 89 45 image 67 43 source: our elaboration positive relavance = 100 standard value – x management rating issues tab. 4 management class issues management issue class value understanding 1-50 validating 1-40 forfaiting 1-10 source: our elaboration european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5516 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 60 tab. 5 valuation effect of management issue destination issues % understanding % validating % forfating a north sardinia 44 33 9 b south sardinia 34 23 7 source: our elaboration this study permits to adopt multiple research methods, both qualitative and quantitative. the analysis is grounded in documents, direct observations and questionnaires. the need to investigate different aspects of the phenomenon justifies the choice of mixed methodologies (cook & reichardt 1979). the research was developed into two phases. in the first phase, only qualitative methods were utilized. public and private management and monitoring instruments were analyzed through a review of literature, with particular attention given to their effectiveness in supporting sustainable development in tourism destinations. international and european sustainable tourism management and monitoring indicator systems for destinations were considered. in the second phase, qualitative and quantitative methods were employed and a case study approach was utilized. the application of a specific sustainable tourism management and monitoring system for destinations was observed in the context of different case studies. the choice of this specific sustainable system was primarily determined as direct experience, observing the implementation of the program in one of the destinations selected by the international organization. secondly, this experience allowed to develop an indirect knowledge of the other destinations involved in the program (adams 2020). the organization selected participants on the basis of their international significate in term of natural, cultural and social environment of the destinations and of image in the tourism market, and also of recognition of the sustainable tourism efforts in that territories. a case study approach entails an intensive and in depth analysis of a single case. a case can be a location, a person or an organization. in particular, case study research is utilized when a case is characterized by complexity and particular nature. when more than one case study is considered, a multiple-case study approach is employed (adelman, 2017). the utilization of more than one case european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5516 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 61 allows one to compare the findings derived from the analysis of each case. this research focused on case studies on international destinations that are currently involved in a sustainable tourism program. the destinations selected were evaluated by an internationally accredited organization according to recognized international criteria and indicators of sustainable tourism development. data related to the destinations was collected through virtual documents and a questionnaire. the collection of data through virtual documents is a qualitative method. in contrast, a self-completion questionnaire is a typical instrument of quantitative research. each case study was analyzed through the general information found in virtual documents and the specific information derived from the questionnaire responses. findings related to each destinations were systematized and compared. the comparison allowed for the realization of the final considerations. findings derived from the two phases of the analysis in conclusion of the study were analyzed. this conducted to conclusive reflections and permitted to answer to the research questions. finally, the two destinations for the aim in the study were chosen solely based on their stages of involvement, development and consolidation, totaling two case study destinations. 4. results the research employed different methods. in the first phase of the study, literature and documents related to private and public instruments for the management of sustainable destinations were considered. their principles, guidelines, procedures, purposed and indicator sets were examined. the conditions for use, and their weak and strong points were also identified. from the joint assessment of all the four systems, some reflections were expressed. in the second phase, the case studies were analyzed (gomm, hammersley & foster 2000). different kinds of information were collected. a first group of information relating to general data and the features of destinations were obtained through virtual documents found on destination’s website. in this research, the website considered were all update and appeared authentic and credible. the general data used to determine the case studies includes: size of the destination, morphology, population, climate and economy. this data is consistent with the composition of a destination profile. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5516 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 62 data about the selected destinations were summarized considering the principal attributes of a destination, as the first highlighted: attractions, amenities, accessibility, human factors, price, and image. another group of information relating to the stakeholder involvement and commitment to the management of the destination, the characteristics of sustainable development, and the area life cycle stage of each destination was collected through questionnaires, developed into different sections, addressed to international organization engaged in the sustainability assessment (battaglia 2011). the questionnaires were self-completed and then returned by e-mail. utilizing self-completed questionnaires that are disseminated through e-mail is a method that is cheap, quick, and simple to use, and assures the consistency of investigation techniques throughout all the case studies considered (kothari 2004). in this study the questionnaire is used to gather and compare information about key aspects of tourism management in the selected destinations, which have been investing in sustainable initiatives. the set of questions addressed to respondents is designed to obtain the desired information. in the construction of the questionnaires evaluations concerning wording, measuring scale of responses, sequence of questions and layout are conducted to favor useful and meaningful results, considering their nature of self-completed questionnaires as well. the questionnaire begins with an explanation of the object and the goals of the research (stake 1995). the first section, dedicated to the destination life cycle information, seeks to investigate some characteristics of tourism development level and tourism impacts on the destination. in the second section, dedicated to stakeholder involvement and interest, the level of stakeholder participation and some relevant aspects of destination governance were explored, such as the capability of stakeholders to manage the destination as a system, and the existence of a tourism plan (stake 2013). in the third section, focused on the level of sustainability in destinations, some significant features of sustainable development in the destinations, some significant features of sustainable development in the destination were investigated, including those relating to planning, monitoring, the reporting european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5516 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 63 instruments adopted, and the regulations and policies implemented to protect cultural and natural heritage and to combat seasonality in the destination. closed questions are exposed in the questionnaires using horizontal or vertical format. to show, observe and analyze the questionnaire data for the current study every question is coded through numbers (suri 2011). each questionnaire is processed coding the answers and, then, a destination survey data is fulfilled. the analysis of questionnaires was performed section by section, with a joint examination of destination responses for each question. in particular, the analysis of section one aimed to ascertain the stage of tourism development in the destinations. the analysis of section two intended to investigated the hypothesis that the effectiveness of indicator systems entails a significant commitment by destination stakeholders (alexis 2017). the analysis of section three investigated the hypothesis that adequate indicator systems are needed for the effective management of tourism in destinations. data analysis is conducted considering the aspects investigated and the results are shown through diagrams, measure of central tendency, and frequency table. to investigate the third hypothesis that sustainability, governance and area life cycle are connected characteristics in destinations, the quantitative and qualitative analysis developed aimed to explore the interrelation of the findings of the three sections. the data collected about destination background was utilized to frame, and if possible, explain responses. this classification is supported by the assessor answers: moderate to low development of tourism; partial participation of local community with some facilities provided to visitors; a clear tourism season and emerging tourism markets; high to moderate tourism impacts respectively on destination a and b; and a level of contact between tourists and the local population that can be classified as low in the destination a, and between low and moderate in destination b. with reference to the stakeholder approach, it can be observed that stakeholder self-interest in the destination is considered to a great extent. there are collaborative relationship between primary european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5516 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 64 stakeholders, and many of the group of stakeholder are involved, but in destination b a higher level of collaboration is necessary, as reported in the assessor answer (denichilo 2020). a governance board does exist, but considering the assessor answer, in destination b the organization was inactive at the time of the assessment and the destination itself intended to reinvigorate it . in both destination a and b, there are political efforts aiming to establish multi-year tourism plans and stakeholders responsibilities (denichilo 2020). regarding sustainability, both destinations have a solid legal and regulatory framework supporting the planning, implementation, and continuity of sustainable development practices. however destination b has not fully developed a program for enterprise awareness about changes in landscape (andriotis 2018). in addition, destination b lacks a multi-year sustainable tourism strategy, as will be discussed in detail. furthermore, an improved system for monitoring tourism’s direct and indirect economic contributions is necessary. according to the assessor, destination promoting is appropriate, including promotion of destination products as well. graph 1. tourism stage of development area in sardinia source: our elaboration of audit reports 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 high medium low tourism stage of development area in sardinia south north european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5516 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 65 graph 2. audit reports of sardinia environment assertions source: our elaboration of questionnaires graph 3. impact of sardinia cultural and environment heritage source: our elaboration of internal focus 5. conclusion and discussion sustainability is the consciousness of the uniqueness of the attributes found in destinations worldwide. sustainability also often reflect the quality of life present in destinations, existence and use of public transport and alternative transportation, cost of living, availability of services, education, 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% populat ion clim ate attr ac tio ns amen itie s acce ssi bilit y human reso urce pric e im ag e audit reports of sardinia environment assertions high medium low 0 10 20 30 40 50 envoirment cultural sustanability developpment labour intensive capital intensive impact of sardinia cultural and environment heritage low medium high european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5516 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 66 recreation parks, employment, security, access for all, governance, and healthcare facilities. consequently the sustainability of tourism is now much broader that just environmental considerations. it is commonly considered to be comprised of the three pillars: the environment, the economy and the community. sustainability and its basic assumption act as a philosophy that dictates the life phases of the destination. it is a way of being, culture that influences behaviors and a sum of ethical principles that inspire decision-makers. when the risk of failure approaches the role of internal auditing, and control systems in general, it becomes more and more evident and serious (birnberg 2000). new deals for management accounting, as academic discipline and as a professional tool, recently overcame the traditional vision of internal auditing activity, which today is also accountable to third parties. the traditional accounting discipline was settle with the aims of disclosing information on the organization, moving certainty and reliability about business contracts towards the business community. the postmodern view of management accounting discipline clarifies that the certainty of contracts in the business community is hardly believable. the best way to maintain environmental uncertainty is to smooth over the information and the requisites for the accounting of failure. accordingly, discussions on the organizational performance should move from statements of what happened towards projections on what will happen, supporting the reliability of traditional management accounting systems with a forward-looking strategy of “as-if” planning, thus evolving risks into opportunities. when the financial performance of the organization deteriorates, some important decisions are urgently required. a sudden but effective action should change the trend and mitigate the financial pressure. traditionally, responsibility for unsuccessful performance is attributed to the top management team by linking the roots of the crisis to unfortunate or inappropriate decisions made by executives, and to the willfully inefficient control exercised by non-executives. appropriate designing a management accounting system and related activities may help to manage the financial pressure issues, although not every event is predictable and not every consequence of uncontrollable situational factors can be concretely mitigated. the empirical side of this research is at evaluating the relationship between destination stakeholders commitments, sustainability, and life cycle phase through the employment of case studies. with regards to this purpose, the following section summarizes the critical points revealed in the analysis of the destination case studies. a first conclusion is related to the relationship between sustainability european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5516 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 67 and area life cycle phases (modica 2008). the analysis emphasizes the lack of case studies involving destinations in the first and last stage of development. none of the destinations participating in the sustainable development monitoring program are experiencing the phase of exploration or stagnation. it is probable that issues of sustainability are perceived as priorities when the tourism product is already developed and can still be designed according to sustainability principles. moreover, the empirical evidence highlighted that sustainability cannot be considered as being completely interrelated with area life cycle. indeed, high levels of sustainability characterize all of the destination examined. the preservation of natural and cultural heritage and the improvement of social and economic welfare in destinations can be pursued and achieved at any stage of tourism development. the area life cycle significantly affects the aspects in which sustainability is reached. destination amenities, accessibility and image are characterized differently at each stage of area life cycle. these attributes, in turn, have various impacts on sustainability at the destination level (modica 2012). the destinations examined are not rich in infrastructure. in destination a, amenities are almost entirely absent. in destination b, services for tourist are not distributed equitably throughout the island; there are some areas with few hotels and other with a wide variety of accommodation services that can offer all levels of comfort. both in the narrow and broad sense, accessibility level is high. in the destination at the involvement stage, sustainability is primarily based on respect for natural and cultural heritage. in general, the destinations image are recognized worldwide. in analyzing the relationship between stakeholder commitment and level of sustainable tourism, and between stakeholders involvement and tourism destination development, different remarks can be highlighted. the active involvement of public and private destination stakeholders occurs in all the case studies, and stakeholder participation is considered a fundamental condition for sustainable tourism development (modica 2015). the level of stakeholder commitment is not the same for all the phases of destination development. it seems to be more important in the initial stages of the development, and decreases with higher levels of the economic development. it is likely that young destination, where infrastructure and services are still insufficient, need more significant levels of involvement by private and public tourism actors to develop sustainable tourism. as limitation and future research our study can conclude that the destination in the first stage attribute more relevance to environmental preservation and to local culture and customs conservation. the destinations in advanced stage of development are focused on customer care and economic and european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5516 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 68 social welfare of local community. in other words, the area life cycle stage does not affect the quantity but the quality of sustainability. finally organizational should equilibrate the instruments adopted to control uncontrollable situational factors and adequately combine objective and subjective instruments for management accounting. excessive reliance on objective performance metrics leads to business as usual, while new opportunities are missed out on. while, in business life nowadays, there is no room for demonizing objective metrics and relying on a purely subjective approach to evaluations, which would likely be affected by hidden pitfalls and side effects, there is a general call to avoid myopic evaluations and look at performance dynamically, with a continuous approach to management accountants’ role as risk mitigators, while considering risks and financial distress as facilitators for turnaround activity, which is positively centered on innovation. references adams, c. (2020). uk aviation industry promises to be carbon neutral by 2050. the independent, 4 february. retrieved february 17, 2020, from https://www.independent.co.uk/travel/news-andadvice/aviation-industry-uk-carbon-emissions-neutral-heathrow-airport-a9316116.html. adelman, s. (2017). the sustainable development goals: anthropocentrism and neoliberalism. in d. french and l. kotzé (eds.), sustainable development goals: law, theory and implementation (pp. 15–40). edward elgar. alexis, p. (2017). over-tourism and anti-tourist sentiment: an exploratory analysis and discussion. ovidius university annals, economic sciences series, 17(2), 288–293. andriotis, k. (2018). degrowth in tourism: conceptual, theoretical and philosophical issues. cabi. crossref. arena m., arnaboldi m., azzone g. (2010), the organizational dynamics of enterprise risk management. accounting, organizations and society. vol. 35 issue 7, pp. 659-675. baltaretu a. (2011), methods and indicators for measuring the impact of tourism on protected natural areas; pp 366-371. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5516 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 69 battaglia m. (2011). non-probability sampling encyclopedia of survey research methods, sage publications. baxter p. & jack s. (2008). qualitative case study methodology: study design and implementation for novice researches. the qualitative report, 13(4), 544-559. berke p. r. & conroy m. m. (2000). are we planning for sustainable development? journal of the american planning association, 66(1), 21-23. biancone p.p., secinaro s., brescia v., calandra d. (2020). employing value chain theory to address covid-19 outbreak in tourism management: a resilience and stakeholder view. international journal of business research management. birnberg j. g. (2000), the role of behavioral research in management accounting education in 21st century. issues in accounting education. vol. 15 issue 4: 713-727. bocken n. p. m., short s. w., rana p. & evans s. (2014). a literature and practice review to develop sustainable business model archetypes. journal of cleaner production, 65, 42-56. brasini, s. (2010). marketing e pubblicità: strumenti e modelli di analisi statistica, bologna: il mulino. bryman a. & bell e. (2007). business research methods, oxford university press. buckley r. (2012). sustainable tourism: research and reality. annals of tourism research, 39(2), 528-546. byrd e. t. (2007). stakeholders in sustainable tourism development and their roles: applying stakeholders theory to sustainable tourism development. tourism review, 62(2), 6-13. castellani v. & sala s. (2010). sustainable performance index for tourism policy development. tourism management, 31(6), 871-880. chapman r. j. (2006), simple tools and techniques for enterprise risk management. john wiley & sons ltd: chichester (uk). european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5516 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 70 chenhal r. h., morris d. (1985), the impact of structure, environment and interdependence on the perceived usefulness of management accounting systems (1985), the impact of structure, environment and interdependence on the perceived usefulness of management accounting systems. the accounting review. vol i issue 1, pp. 16-35. clarke, j. (1997). a framework of approaches to sustainable tourism. journal of sustainable tourism, 5(3), 224-233. cook t. d. & reichardt c. s. (1979). qualitative and quantitative methods in evaluation research (vol. 1), sage publications. corbetta p. (2003). la ricerca sociale: metodologia e tecniche. le tecniche qualitative (vol. ii), bologna: il mulino. coyne i.t. (1997). sampling in qualitative research. purposeful and theoretical sampling; merging or clear boundaries? journal of advanced nursing, 26(3), 623-630. creswell, j. w. (2013). research design: qualitative, quantitative and mixed methods approachers, sage publications. currie r. r., seaton s. & wesley f. (2009). determining stakeholders for feasibility analysis. annals of tourism research, 36(1), 41-63. denichilo s. (2020), public choice in european affairs: measuring election model. european journal of social impact and circular economy pp 19-37. published by university of turin. denichilo s. (2020), shadow bank system in european affairs: measuring capability. presentation discussed paper at european association for banking and financial law. thematic purposed by bankitalia eurosistema “what to regulate? how to regulate? who should regulate?” november 2020 milan. eckles d. l., hoyt r. e., miller s. m. (2014), the impact of enterprise risk management on the marginal cost of reducing risk: evidence from the insurance in industry. journal of banking and finance. vol. 43 issue 1, pp. 247-261. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5516 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 71 fischer j. (1995), contingency-based research on management control systems: categorization by level of complexity. journal of accounting literature. vol. 14 issue 1, pp. 24-53. galbraith j. (1973), designing complex organizations. addison wesley publishing company: boston, massachusetts (usa). gomm r., hammersley m. & foster p. (2000), case study method: key issues, key tests, sage publications. gordon l. a., narayanan v. k. (1984), management accounting systems, perceived environmental uncertainty and organization structure: an empirical investigation. accounting, organizations and society. vol. 9 issue 1, pp. 33-47. guarte, j. m., & barrios, e. b. (2006). estimation under purposive sampling. communictions in statistics – simulation and computation, 35(2), 277-284. hannan m. t., freeman j. h. (1977), the population ecology of organizations. american journal of sociology. vol. 82 issue 5,pp. 929-964. hopper t., bui b. (2016), has management accounting research been critical? management accounting research. vol. 31 issues 1,pp. 10-30. jones, t., atkinson, h., lorenz, a., & harris, p. (2012). strategic managerial accounting: hospitality, tourism & events applications. goodfellow publishers limited. kates r. w. (2011), what kind of a science in sustainability science? proceedings of the national academy of sciences of the united states of america, 108(49), 19449. kates, r., clark, w., corell, r., hall, j., jaeger, c., lowe, i., svedin, u. (2001). sustainability science. science, 292 (5517), 641. karatzoglou, b., & slilanis, i. (2010). sustainable tourism in greek island: the integration of activity-based environmental management with a destination environmental scorecard based on the adaptive resource management paradigm. business strategy and the environment, 19(1), 26-38. kothari, c. (2004). research methodology: methods and techniques: new age international. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5516 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 72 larson, l. r., & poudyal, n. c. (2012). developing sustainable tourism through adaptive resource management: a case study of machu picchu, peru. journal of sustainable tourism, 1-22. levin, s., & clark, w. (2010). report from toward a science of sustainability conference. center of biocomplexity, princeton university, princeton, n.j., and sustainability science program, harvard university, cambrige, ma. mccook, l. j. (2010). adaptive management of the great barrier reef: a globally significant demonstration of the benefits of networks of marine reserves. proceeding of the national academy of science of the united states of america, 107(43), 18278. miller, g. (2001). the development of indicators for sustainable tourism: results of a delphi survey of tourism researchers. tourism management, 22(4), 351-362. miller, g., & twining-ward, l. (2005). monitoring for a sustainable tourism transition: the challenge of developing and using indicators, wallingford, uk: cabi publishing. mitchell b. (1997). resource and environmental management, harlow: logman. modica, p. (2008). analisi economiche per le aziende, roma: aracne. modica, p. (2012). demand management for the sustainability of tourism. in d. fennel & a. holden, the routledge handbook of tourism and the environment, london: routledge. modica, p. (2015). sustainable tourism management and monitoring destination, business and stakeholder perspectives. o’riordan, t. (1981). environmentalis, london: pion. page, s. j. (2010). scenario planning as a tool to understand uncertainty in tourism: the example of transport and tourism in scotland in 2025. current issue in tourism, 13(2), 99-137. palermo t., van der stede w. a. (2011), scenario budgeting. integrating risk and performance. finance and management. january 2011,pp. 10-13. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5516 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 73 plummer, r., & fennell, d. (2009). managing protected areas for sustainable tourism: prospects for adaptive co-management. journal of sustainable tourism, 17(2), 149-168. power m. (2007), organized uncertainty: designing a world of risk management. oxford university press: oxford (uk). power m. (2009), the risk management of nothing. accounting, organizations and society. vol. 34 issue 6-7,pp. 849-855. ryan c. (2002). equity, management, power sharing and sustainability – issues of the “new tourism”. tourism management, 23(1), 17-26. sautter e. t. & leisen b. (1999). managing stakeholders a tourism planning model. annals of tourism research, 21(3), 312-328. stake r. e. (1995). the art of case study research, sage publications. stake r. e. (2013). multiple case study analysis, guilford press. stoval, w., higham, j., & stephenson, j. (2019). prepared for take-off? anthropogenic climate change and the global challenge of twenty-first century tourism. in d. timothy (ed.), handbook of globalization and tourism (pp. 174–187). edward elgar. suri h. (2011). purposeful sampling in qualitative research synthesis. qualitative research journal, 11(2), 63. swarbrooke, j. (1999). sustainable tourism management, cabi. thomas, d.r. (2006). a general inductive approach for analyzing qualitative evaluation data. american journal of evaluation, 27(2), 237-246. torkington, k., stanford, d., & guiver, j. (2020). discourse(s) of growth and sustainability in national tourism policies. journal of sustainable tourism, 28(7), 1041– 1062. https://doi.org/10.1080/09669582.2020.170695. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5516 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 74 van der stede w. a. (2011), management accounting research in the wake of the crisis: some reflections. european accounting review. vol. 20 issue 4,pp. 605-623. van der stede w. a. (2015), management accounting: where from, where now, where to? journal of management accounting research. vol 27 issue 1,pp. 171-176. microsoft word 4 uddin edited.docx http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/4945 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 76 how the agent-based banking model might facilitate financial inclusion and sustainability via economic circularity? – a bangladesh perspective mohammad jalal uddin, independent researcher & analyst, chittagong research group, bangladesh. email: jalalsmailbox@gmail.com received: 05/08/2020 revised: 16/10/2020 accepted for publication: 17/10/2020 published: 26/10/2020 abstract transformation of business models with the interaction of technological breakthrough, innovation and socio-economic transition are historical. context based adjustment of business value chain also not rare. in fact, such adjustment might prove essential to survive in the market at certain point, especially in case of corporate transformation due to economic recession/depression, industry downturn and ecological correction like covid-19. however, some business models are smart enough to cope with both kinds of transformations. agentbased banking model (abm) is one of such kind, which not only sustains during adverse situation but also facilitates the momentum of adversity. this ultimately defined as a sustainable innovation in banking industry that drives via circular economy. the mode of circular economy in product and service level or goods and service industry are not identical and while articulating circular business model in service industry, like banking, then it denotes generating values for broader range of stakeholders and transmitting this value in such a way that minimize the ecological and social costs. how abm might help the conventional banks of developing countries like bangladesh toward the business model sustainability, is the centre of this study. consequently, this study found that abm would not only assist to bring the world’s 1.7 billion unbanked adult community into regulated financial system but also facilitate the physically challenged, illiterate & marginal people on financial inclusion and pave the way of global development in a sustainable manner. http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/4945 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 77 ___________________________________________________________________________ keywords: agent-based banking model; circular economy; financial inclusion; sustainability; transformation ___________________________________________________________________________ 1. introduction in this dynamic world, transformation of business processes to behave in a sustainable manner is becoming inevitable as the business entities are no longer an isolated part of economic, social and environmental ecosystem (bermúdez and schneider, 2018). therefore, converting traditional business model into circular one is now trending. what is circular business model? the essence of circular business model lies on the circular economy. according to ellen macarthur foundation, “circular economy focus on resource use often follow the 3-r approaches, (a) reduce – minimum use of raw materials, (b) reuse – maximum reuse of products/components and (c) recycle – high quality reuse of raw materials”. adoption or conversion into circular model rapidly gaining importance among business acumen as scientists/researchers have made significant progress on pricing the externalities (andersen, 2007), which will apply over the corporate actions. embracing the concept of circular economy as the driver for sustainability (bocken et al., 2018) could facilitate this transformation. even though businesses dealing with commodity market counting the adoption of circular business model as challenging, from environmental and policy perspectives. korhonen et al. (2018) found circular economy as vague and unorganized concept due its undefined application in specific field and there is an ambiguity at the tangent point between circular economy and sustainability (geissdoerfer et al., 2017). investopedia defined sustainability as “focusing on meeting the needs of the present without compromising the ability of future generations to meet their needs”. until now, circular business model in service industries might be the most neglected part of the circular economy. we should not confuse the service of a product by counting as service level circular economy like buying the lifetime or service hours of a ‘refrigerator’ not the ‘refrigerator’ itself. however, incorporating this concept into service industries like banking, insurance etc. might be vastly beneficiary for the society and economy at large. it will enable the service providers to cover broader range of populations under respective service network http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/4945 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 78 with minimum ecological and social cost. among the service industries, financial or banking industry is the strategic one, which is in acute sustainability pressure (bocken et al., 2016). this is due to high correlation of banking industry with macroeconomics (athanasoglou et al., 2008; drake et al., 2006), geo-political incidents and other sensible issues like pandemic. incorporating the concept of circular economy within banking industry is almost essential, not only for de-risking its extreme domino effects over the society, economy and environment but also for covering the nearly 1.7 billion1 unbanked bankable community into the network of regulated financial system. in addition, the term ‘circular economy’ is no more an acute environmental action as it emerged, rather an economic strategy (yean et al., 2008) that will assist the economy to become sustainable and resilient. however, with the blessing to technological advancements, the inception of mobile banking or m-banking services from the beginning of 21st century is not less than a revolution in global financial industry. this inception has significant positive effect over the financial inclusion (siddik et al., 2014), especially in underdeveloped and developing countries. m-banking not only facilitated unbanked populations but also enhanced the efficiency of other existing financial service providers, including conventional banks and microfinance institutions (shaikh and karjaluoto, 2015). this ultimately helped most of them to formulate ‘fintech’ entity as sister concern or strategic wing of mother company, e.g. the ‘bkash’ of brac bank in bangladesh. beside this, quick adoption of digital finance by tech-giants like tencent, alibaba, apple, google etc, leaved aggressive footprint of ‘techfin’. this techfin booted the way of financial inclusion with a big jump by facilitating ‘platform economy’, especially at the beginning of second decade of this century. the difference between ‘fintech’ and ‘techfin’ is coincide. when a financial institution embrace technology for better client services is called ‘fintech’, like ‘bkash’ and when a technology firm enters into financial industry is called ‘techfin’, like ‘alipay’. though m-banking is a handy tool of covering marginal community under banking network but due to security, technical, financial literacy, infrastructure and related issues, this mechanism couldn’t provide full-fledge banking coverage and failed to meet the growth prospects. as a result, m-banking is accounted for just around 5% of total bank accounts in india (bhatt and bhatt, 2016), the second most populous country of the world. beside this, m 1 https://globalfindex.worldbank.org/ http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/4945 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 79 banking is highly expensive compare to the financial condition of marginal community. for example, ‘bkash’, the first and popular mobile banking service provider in bangladesh, which incurs at least 1.75% charge for cash out from the virtual wallet. this is excessively high for any paper (money) based economy where most of the payments have to make through physical currency. providing banking services in remote areas with low service cost and customer friendly way might be an effective mechanism of covering the huge amount of unbanked community. this community are mostly marginal people with little or no financial literacy and residing in underdeveloped and developing countries. agent-based banking model (abm) may do this optimally by covering wider range of stakeholders with low economic and social cost as the essence of such model is circular economy. therefore, transforming existing brick and mortar type or linear banking system into circular one is demanding and somehow required. however, aim of this study is to investigate the impact of agent-based banking model and how it might facilitates the marginal community toward financial inclusion? to do so, this paper will follow by its background. methodology of this study presented at section 3. section 4 highlighted the existing linear business model of banks functioning in developing countries like bangladesh. pictograph of abm with its explanation, application and limitation presented at section 5. qualitative aspects of this study presented afterward and further wrapped-up by concluding remarks. 2. background to understand the status of global financial inclusion gap, the ‘global financial inclusion (global findex) database’2 published in 2017 by the world bank group is absolutely good enough. still, a brief flavour on this would help to realize the importance of fulfilling financial inclusion gap and identify the potential scope of contributing from socio-economic &/or environmental perspectives. 2 https://globalfindex.worldbank.org/sites/globalfindex/files/2018-04/2017%20findex%20full%20report_0.pdf http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/4945 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 80 figure 1: demographics of world's 1.7 billion unbanked communities data source: chapter 2, global findex full report 2017 according to world bank’s report, there are about 1.7 billion adult unbanked community globally. the unbanked means, they do not have a bank account or account with mobile money service. this report also claimed that, literally almost all of the global unbanked community lives in developing countries and nearly half of them belongs to seven countries only. global technological super-power, the people’s republic of china3 hosting most of the unbanked adult population of the world. therefore, sometimes technology may need to compromise with the context. for example, in the year 2018 due to digitalization of banking system, volume of net closing4 of branches by banks & thrifts in the united states of america (usa) was 1,947 units, whereas in bangladesh, banks opened 393 sub-branches5 last year (2019). so, the context relevancy is very important rather than jumping into technology blindly. if that prevailed true than many banks of developing countries may become 100% digital, may be with the help of different global platforms like ‘deloitte digital bank accelerator’6 and could fill the vacuum of financial inclusion. poverty, illiteracy and disability are the key obstacles of financial inclusion. mechanism of agent-based banking model might facilitates illiterate, physically challenged and remote communities by leveraging 3https://globalfindex.worldbank.org/sites/globalfindex/files/chapters/2017%20findex%20full%20report_chapt er2.pdf 4 https://www.spglobal.com/marketintelligence/en/news-insights/latest-news-headlines/49360224 5 https://www.dhakatribune.com/business/banks/2020/01/12/sub-branch-opens-up-new-portal-to-banking 6 https://www2.deloitte.com/global/en/pages/technology/articles/deloitte-digital-bank-salesforce.html http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/4945 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 81 existing technology and know-how. but the real challenge is poverty, which is further worsening with the interaction of covid-19. world bank estimate that covid-19 might push 71 to 100 million7 people into extreme poverty, globally. high financial inclusion may shed light on this, as it well prove that financial inclusion enhances the fund’s mobility and leads toward productive investment that ultimately yield socio-economic development and reduce poverty. 3. methodology this is an exploratory research with thematic inclusion, where focus group interviews conducted in an unstructured manner to collect primary data. about hundred people asked for interview during february to april 2020, in the chittagong region of bangladesh, from which 63 person agreed to be respondent. respondents are mostly male adult, whom are either existing clients (minority) of the bank or officials (majority) working at the banks. respondents affiliated with the ncc bank, one bank, nrb global bank, first security islami bank are branch level participants and respondents affiliated with mutual trust bank, dutch-bangla bank & bank asia limited are the agent level participants. respondent’s orientation better described at the qualitative aspects section of this paper. collected primary data extensively contributed to offset the key research query. these data also helped to find a substitute/supplementary business model for brick & mortar type banks that are hyperactive in underdeveloped and developing countries e.g. bangladesh. this study used quantifiable data, gathered from plausible secondary sources, for better understanding the current scenario of formal financial inclusion gap that prevails mostly in emerging countries. 3.1 research question how to incorporate marginal community into formal banking system and boost financial inclusion? 7 https://blogs.worldbank.org/opendata/updated-estimates-impact-covid-19-global-poverty http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/4945 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 82 4. linear business model of banks in developing countries by examining the primary data gained from branch level officials of different leading commercial banks in bangladesh, it found that the existing business model of most of the commercial banks that operating in developing countries are kind of liner. this can be understand from their function pictograph plotted at figure 2. nevertheless, many of those banks quickly coped with the trend of technological development. they have been adopting internet banking, real time transaction booking, inter & intra bank fund transfer, mobile application based banking service, online bank account opening, mobile banking division, sms banking, atm (automated teller machine), cdm (cash deposit machine), e-statement, pos (point of sale) based cash withdraw facility, plastic/chip card based operation, storing data into the cloud and many more. to embrace those sorts of advance technology and facilities, operation cost of the banks reached at the pick where intention should be the gain of cost efficiency by embracing technology. beside this, their brick and mortar type business model enhanced the maintenance cost significantly. to bear the lavish operation and maintenance cost, such banks have to charge the customers via different known and unknown means like sms banking charge, half-yearly account maintenance charge, charge on cheque books, atm cards, bank statement, online transaction, clearings and so on. as a result, availing banking services has become expensive which is discouraging people from financial inclusion. figure 1: pictograph of conventional business model of banks in developing countries source – developed by the authors http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/4945 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 83 4.1 mechanism of linear business model of banks in developing countries as explained by the respondents, whose are the officials at branch level of different leading commercial banks, functioning process of bank’s branch start form the head/corporate office. with the objective of expanding business, bank’s head office looks for potential commercial areas. after assessing the tentative business case, they generally rent an office space at the prime location of that particular commercial area which is logically expensive. bank spends huge amount of money on its decoration, furniture and fixture, air conditioning etc. then the bank employs personnel for providing services. those personnel are mostly migrated from different parts of the country, who needs accommodation in nearby town. through this way, respective banks provide financial intermediary services that incurs high amount of fixed and operation cost. pictograph of such a model of banking is highlighted above via ‘figure – 2’, for the better understanding. 5. agent-based banking model figure 3: agent-based banking model source – developed by the authors http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/4945 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 84 5.1 brief explanation of agent-based banking model in light with the objectives of circular economy, the agent-based banking model might transform the linear business model of conventional banks dramatically. as learned from the respondents affiliated with agent banking operations (officials and customers), the operating model of agent-based banking is very handy but technology dependent. their opinions sketched, visualized and presented at figure – 3. apparently, first of all locally competent person or entity approach to a bank for setting up a banking service centre with tentative socialbusiness case, where conventionally banks look for potential markets and service location. bank then review the proposal, which covers demographics and socio-economic condition of that particular region and the competency of the proposer. if the proposal fits with the bank’s prespecified criteria than it nominates the proposer as bank’s local agent and asked the agent to set-up a friendly structure to provide banking services. in that case, banks generally provide technical supports and train the recruited staffs of agent, whose are mostly from local community. through this mechanism employee migration reduces significantly, which means lower movement, better cultural affinity, better utilization of indigenous human resources, balanced development and many more. off course bank needs to employ experienced staff for smooth operation of banking services until the locally recruited persons/agent become capable to serve the front office clients properly. respective agent deploys his/her local reputation/network and the brand value of the bank, which ultimately serve the local community and brings them under formal or regulated financial system. this system incurs minimum ecological, social and operation cost than the linear service model of conventional banks. it enhances the service network of banking system that capable to serve all level of community from rich to ultra-poor. eventually this builds a banking service model for the customers by the customer. 5.2 mechanism of the core banking service under agent-based model technological advancement blessed the conventional banks to adopt agent-based banking system, which not only help them to expand their coverage significantly without significant investment but also making their business model sustainable and resilient. here is how? bank ask the appointed local agent to deposit certain amount in his/her mother or agent account with the respective bank. upon receipt of deposit from customer through secure http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/4945 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 85 computer-based transaction system, agent account debited (deducted) with the equivalent amount as credited (added) to the client’s account. similarly withdraw transaction booked for the drawings by client, that is, client account debited (deducted) with the equivalent amount credited (added) to agent account. for the safety of customer’s fund, respective agent is not entitled to receive deposit from the clients exceeding the amount of his/her mother account and for such attempt, system will automatically reject the transaction. transaction request will be authenticate by the biometric fingerprint of the respective client and agent/bank officials. this method is secure, cost efficient and environment friendly, due to no requirement of printing the ‘cheque’. such assured form of transaction through biometric authentication is very effective and somehow essential for illiterate and physically challenged community. those people are not capable to put signatures on paper, which protesting them from formal financial inclusion. let us see an illustration on how the agent-based banking model facilitates the physically challenged community on formal banking inclusion; figure 4: convenient banking inclusion of physically challenged community source: https://www.bayometric.com/nitgen-fingkey-hamster-ii-dx-usb-fingerprint-scanner/ according to world health organization, about 10% of global population are experiencing disability8 and approximately 15% or 1 billion world’s population lives with at least some sort 8 https://www.who.int/disabilities/world_report/2011/report/en/ http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/4945 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 86 of disabilities9. there is no such appropriate data available (at least i failed to find) about what percent of disable community are formally unbanked but there is a strong positive correlation among the poverty, disability and non-banking. financial condition of most of the disable people that belongs to developing and underdeveloped countries are poor to ultra-poor10. however, bringing physically challenged people under social safety net is an on-going process globally. this require their formal financial inclusion not only for ensuring transparency in disbursement but also for truly empowering them financially with a real flavour. take the case of mr. mojaharul hoque from chittagong, a physically challenged freedom fighter of liberation war of bangladesh and ex-policeman who got severe disability from war. he is entitled to receive the freedom fighter’s allowance and pension from police fund but has to make another struggle for collecting his allowance and pension. the conventional brick and mortar type banking system of bangladesh is responsible for worsening his sufferings; where in every month he has to travel to upazilla-sadar (sub-urban area) where bank located, for proving his aliveness and receiving the pension. 9 https://www.worldbank.org/en/topic/disability 10 https://www.un.org/esa/socdev/enable/diswpa04.htm http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/4945 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 87 figure 5: photografy of mr. mojaharul hoque from chittagong source: author however, with the agent-based banking model, disable and physically challenged people may get banking service easily from their home or nearby. this will reduce the cost of availing banking services, eliminate harassments & difficulties on financial inclusion. this might also ensure the transparency of the transactions and government’s disbursement of social benefits to underprivileged, aged/retired, physically challenged and related communities. 5.3 applicability of the model agent-based model is in practice in many underdeveloped and developing countries (chude and chude, 2014; chiteli, 2013) of the world, which generating huge social, economic and environmental positive impact there. along with hitting triple-bottom-line, this mechanism may serve the special group of the society that is the physically challenged community. it might work as a handy weapon of eliminating inertia of illiterate people on formal financial inclusion. it will also enhance the indigenous fund mobilization via remote banking network and stimulate savings tendency of marginal inhabitants. this will ultimately lead toward the productive http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/4945 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 88 investment and balanced development. very specific challenges of brick & mortar type banking system that might be address by the agent-based banking model are; • existing high fixed & operation cost of spreading banking network might be reduce significantly. • way of incorporating illiterate and physically challenged community under formal financial system will be smoothen. • environmental footprint from banking industry of developing countries like bangladesh, will be minimize notably especially through non-use of paper cheque, less employee migration, sustainable physical structure of service station and so on. • formal financial inclusion of marginal and remote community will increase and their savings propensity will stimulate accordingly. 5.4 limitations of the agent-based banking model functioning of the agent-based banking model might be limited on the several grounds. availability of electricity and it infrastructure or internet coverage of the respective territory, which did not considered in this model. the issue of grid power might be resolved through solar panel in remote areas but the internet connectivity might a matter of concern. if internet providing mobile network is not available in remote areas than providing banking service there under such model will not be possible. operation cost of that sort of banking model is subject to the cost of internet data and power as well. finding the literally and financially eligible and interested local service provider or agent in remote areas might be difficult. http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/4945 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 89 6. qualitative aspects of the study 6.1 respondent’s orientation figure 6: respondent's orientation in terms of gender source – developed by the authors in terms of the gender differentiation, 73% of total respondents are male and remaining are female. reason behind this imparity might be the women are less likely to participate in survey. figure 7: pattern of respondents source – developed by the authors 73% 27% male female 65% 35% pattern of respondents bank's staff customer http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/4945 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 90 about one-third of the respondents are the existing customers of the bank and 65% from the bank officials, either from agent-banking or conventional banks. this is quite fruitful as the staffs of banks are better familiar with their business model. figure 8: respondent's affiliation source – developed by the authors respondent’s affiliation is an important factor regarding the relevancy and quality of data. within collected samples, 56% respondents affiliated with agent banking service of three banks and remaining 44% affiliated with branch-level operations of four commercial banks. more than 30% of total data gathered from the respondents affiliated with mutual trust bank, which is the highest single source. it followed by nrb global bank, bank asia limited, first security islami bank and dutch-bangla bank, where they are accounted from more than 10% each. respondents affiliated with ncc bank accounted for 8% and one bank accounted from 5% of respective data. branch level ncc bank o ne bank nrb global bank first security islami bank agent level mutual trust bank dutchbangla bank bank asia ltd. respondent's affiliation http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/4945 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 91 6.2 respondent’s opinion (selected) “agent banking wing of our bank is one of the finest additions. it growing very rapidly and serving the remote community. agent banking centres are working like social enterprises with very minimum ecological footprint. with the inception of about four years, our agent-banking network surpassed the branch network. the strategic implication of such banking model is really wide. regarding this new-normal situation resulting from covid-19, this is absolutely fit. people need not to crowd in the branches that means less travelling, less chance to be infected or spreading the corona virus. in certain cases, agents provided banking services at the doorstep of needed clients. so, i found this model is very handy and as a head of agent banking department at one of the country’s leading private commercial bank, i would describe this as a silver bullet toward the financial inclusion of rural population of bangladesh”. mr. madan mahan karmakar, senior executive vice-president & head of agent banking department mutual trust bank limited “i believe agent-banking is an innovative solution in the entire banking system but it’s definitely not a substitute of regular branch banking. our bank still not introduced this model but very much positive about this as it incurs very low cost of spreading service network”. mr. forkan ali, operation head, nrb global bank limited, narayanhat branch. “agent banking is a strategic supplementary to retail banking. in bangladesh, i see the future of retail banking moving toward agent and/or online banking”. mr. md. saiful islam, junior officer, first security islami bank limited, hathazari branch. http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/4945 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 92 “rural people once used to engage with ngos and cooperative societies for their savings endeavour where the risk of deception was very high. they also need to travel a lot to avail core-banking services. with the introduction of agent banking, those people might get the banking service at the nearby with safety and security”. mr. md. mamunur rashid chowdhury customer service executive mutual trust bank limited, east kalurghat agent banking centre. 7. conclusion the role of banking system in wider areas of capital formation, investment and economic development is unanimously recognized. unfortunately, in this technologically advanced world, approximately 22.58% of global adult population still out of regulated financial system and most of this unbanked community belongs to emerging economies. to bring those unbanked communities into formal banking system, agent-based banking model might be an efficient tool. this tool contains the basic traits of circular economy, where circular business model in service industry covers wider range of clients/customers with optimum costing from social, economic and environmental perspectives. however, this study prudently identified several latent constrains toward formal financial inclusion and flagged following issues; • by leveraging existing technology, knowledge and expertise, applying a circular business model for brick and mortar type banks is very much feasible. • there is enough scope of bringing physically challenged, disable, illiterate and remote community under formal financial system. utilizing those scopes will not only enhance the propensity of financial inclusion but also stimulate transparency and good governance in the concerning regions. • high fixed investment, high operating cost and employee migration related with spreading banking network by conventional commercial banks may be reduce significantly through the adoption of agent-based banking model. • there is a huge potential to lure marginal community into regulated financial system without significant investment and ensuring affordable banking services for them is very much viable. http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/4945 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 93 essence this study based on the primary data of particular region of bangladesh and the data from particular area might not represent the entire universe. therefore, the effort of this study might be limited on this ground. small sample size might be another limitation of this study. still, it might be interesting for potential researchers on further development of existing abm and the context based adjustment of abm, since the status of prerequisites of this model are not identical in every country or county, especially internet facility. considering the current pandemic situation, the devastating effects of covid-19 is leaving aggressive footprint almost in every industry. these effects further intensified at the banking industry owing its high correlation with different industries. in this complex situation as survival strategy, many private commercial banks in bangladesh have been clipping their workforce and several other banks reduced their salary-base instead of retrenchment, media reported11. outcome of this study might act as a policy feed for the conventional commercial banks in developing countries, like bangladesh, whom are looking for sustainable transformation of existing business model. references viviana bermúdez and martin alexander schneider (2018) challenges of transforming a business model to a sustainable business model – a case study based on ikea and tetra pak. school of economics & management, lund university. mikael skou andersen (2007) an introductory note on the environmental economics of the circular economy. sustain sci 2, pp. 133–140. n.m.p. bocken, c.s.c. schuit and c. kraaijenhagen (2018) experimenting with a circular business model: lessons from eight cases. environmental innovation and societal transitions. jouni korhonen, antero honkasalo, jyri seppälä (2018) circular economy: the concept and its limitations. ecological economics 143, pp. 37–46 martin geissdoerfer, paulo savaget, nancy m.p. bocken and erik jan hultink (2017) the circular economy – a new sustainability paradigm? journal of cleaner production 143, pp. 757 – 768 nancy m. p. bocken, ingrid de pauw, conny bakker & bram van der grinten (2016) product 11 https://en.prothomalo.com/business/local/fear-of-losing-jobs-salary-cut-in-banks http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/4945 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 94 design and business model strategies for a circular economy. journal of industrial and production engineering, 33:5, pp. 308-320 panayiotis p. athanasoglou, sophocles n. brissimis and matthaios d. delis (2008) bankspecific, industry-specific and macroeconomic determinants of bank profitability. journal of international financial markets, institutions and money 18, pp. 121–136 leigh drake, maximilian j.b. hall and richard simper (2006) the impact of macroeconomic and regulatory factors on bank efficiency:a non-parametric analysis of hong kong’s banking system. journal of banking & finance, 30, pp. 1443–1466 md. nur alam siddik, gang sun, cui yanjuan and sajal kabiraj (2014) financial inclusion through mobile banking: a case of bangladesh. journal of applied finance & banking, vol. 4, no. 6, pp. 109-136 aijaz a. shaikh and heikki karjaluoto (2015) mobile banking adoption: a literature review, telematics and informatics 32, pp. 129–142 bhatt a. and bhatt s. (2016) factors affecting customer’s adoption of mobile banking services. j internet bank commerce 21: 161. dhanalakshmi arumugam malar, viktor arvidsson & jonny holmstrom (2019) digital transformation in banking: exploring value co-creation in online banking services in india. journal of global information technology management, 22:1, 7-24 goncalo baptista, tiago oliveira (2017). why so serious? gamification impact in the acceptance of mobile banking services. internet research, vol. 27 issue: 1, pp.118-139 demirgüç-kunt, asli, leora klapper, dorothe singer, saniya ansar, and jake hess (2018) the global findex database 2017: measuring financial inclusion and the fintech revolution. washington, dc: world bank. nkiru patricia-nezianya chude and daniel izuchukwu chude (2014) impact of agent banking on performance of deposit money banks in nigeria. research journal of finance and accounting, vol.5, no.9 nefa chiteli (2013) agent banking operations as a competitive strategy of commercial banks in kisumu city. international journal of business and social science vol. 4 no. 13 05_urmanavicius european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5511 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 48 perspectives of older employees in changing labour market justas urmanavicius1 1 independent researcher, lithuania. e-mail: adebisiurp120385@futa.edu.ng received: 01/02/2021 accepted for publication: 03/11/2021 published: 12/11/2021 abstract due to an ongoing increase in the average life expectancy and a decrease in the average birth rate, there are less active people that are of working age in the labor market. however, this year's covid-19 pandemic highlighted that older workers are much more vulnerable in an ever-changing labor market. it is therefore essential to analyze how employers create working conditions for more senior employees during a pandemic. as well as the employment opportunities of older workers in the longer term. applied methods of analysis: scientific literature and analysis of various documents, interviews, and analysis of the research results, their interpretation. the study found that older employees had difficulty adapting to changed working conditions and faced a higher risk of health issues. the article thus showed that existing stereotypes among employers limit the employability of older people. keywords: work; aging; older employees; workers; labor market; covid-19. 1. introduction demographic, cultural and economic changes, as well as the health system's progress, led to the changes in the structure of society while declining birth rates and higher life expectancy resulted in increase of the share of older people in many countries. furthermore, improving quality of life and longer life expectancy increases the number of elderly population in society. the share of the retirement-age population grows, and the number of working-age populations declines due to the ageing society, thus challenging the state's labor market. the european employment strategy states that there is a need to promote employment accessibility for all those who can participate in the work activity and emphasize that the increase of personal abilities for lifelong participation in the labour market is one of europe's strategic objectives (europe 2020, com (2010). thus, it seeks to ensure positive interaction between economic, employment and social policy measures by promoting long-term and continuous participation in the work activity and providing conditions to remain active in the labor market. employment and active participation of elderly population are considered the main objectives of the eu labor market policy. in order to implement the objectives mentioned above, it is essential to ensure good mental and physical health of an elderly population, to apply more flexible retirement system, to create the most suitable working conditions, to ensure that the elderly would be able to acquire new knowledge and skills, to refresh the existing ones, and be provided with equal employment opportunities in the labor market. from an economic point of view, one of the most important measures to avoid a rise in the share of non-working age population is the increase of retirement age. however, this process is extremely negative since pre-retirement age people find it difficult to get employed and stay in the existing jobs. it promotes the protection of interests of elderly population in the labor european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5511 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 49 market. furthermore, the average age of elderly, withdrawing from the labor market does not coincide with the average retirement age. in lithuania, even 44,8 percent of persons over 50 years old are unemployed (social report, 2016-2017). the statistics lithuania publishes the latest demographic trends in lithuania, which show a further decline of population: the number of permanent residents in lithuania declined by 37,8 thousand or 1,3 percent in 2018, in comparison with 2017. given the presented facts, it is evident that lithuania is rapidly aging and already has the seventh oldest population in the eu. currently, the median age in lithuania is 43 – it means that half of the lithuanian population are older than 43, indicating the population aging. the share of elderly population grows, while the share of the working-age population diminishes. while comparing, it should be pointed out that the elderly population, i.e., persons over 65 years, accounted for 11 percent of the total population in 1990, and in 2018 this number is equal to 23 percent of the total population of lithuania. the share of the working-age population (15-64 ) of the total population diminished from 67 percent in 1990 down to 62 percent in 2017. if one hundred working-age persons maintained 16 elderly persons in 1990, currently, one hundred working-age persons have to maintain even 29 older people, therefore, the state must adapt to the changes as mentioned earlier by addressing the issues of elderly population in the labor market and providing for proper social policy (the statistics lithuania). even in economic growth conditions, when there is a shortage of workers, older people often remain on the margins. in the reality of covid-19, they are at even greater risk of not participating in the world of work and society. forty-one percent in lithuania, job seekers, are over 50 years old, and one in four of them has been looking for work for more than a year. a prolonged job search reduces older people's employability and pushes a person into long-term unemployment, which also has long-term psychosocial consequences. the influence of the aging population on the labor market is researched by didžgalvytė and lukšaitė, (2014). it should be noted that moskvina and skučienė (2014) analyzed the factors of dismissal from the labor market at elder age that should be considered, in order to select legal measures to keep older people included in the labor market. meanwhile, theoretical aspects of the elderly participants in the labor market were examined by corsi and lodovici, (2013), seltzer and yahirun, (2013). brazienė and mikutavičienė, (2015), skučienė, bartkus, moskvina and uleckienė, (2015), mikulionienė and rapolienė (2016) looked at the opportunities of older people to be included in the labor market. however, there is a lack of research done on covid-19 impact on older employees in the market. this article aims to review the aspects of inclusion of older employees in the labour market and analyze how employers create working conditions for senior employees during a pandemic. the following objectives are set to reach the aim: to describe the changes in the labour market in the context of ageing population, to identify the factors limiting the employment of older persons, and to put forward the recommendations on how to increase the inclusion of older persons in the labour market. the following research methods were applied: analysis of scientific literature and documents, key informant interviews, analysis and interpretation of the research results. qualitative research method – survey of expert opinion in the form of a structured questionnaire (interview) – was selected for empirical research (bitinas, rupšienė, žydžiūnaitė, 2008). the interview method was more appropriate for the same reasons – it was sought to go deep into real and sometimes hidden reasons why elderly employees are looked at rather skeptically in the labor market (baley, 2007). 2. literature review 2.1 changes in the labour market in the process of population ageing population aging is a long-term trend that started in europe several decades ago. it is evident from the changing structure of population age and is reflected in the growing share of elderly population, related with decreasing proportion of working-age people. it can be argued that this process is not only an actual change of elderly population – it is a complex process, reflecting the relationship of elderly population with the remaining society in the light of increasing life expectancy, and including the following age factors: biological (entirety of physiological changes), psychological (individual abilities to adapt his behaviour to environmental changes), social (social norms and roles applied to an individual in respect of his age) (labanauskaitė, astrauskaitė , kiyak (2014). in the process of ageing, some of population face difficulties due to biological, psychological, and social age, since adaptation in the labour market is affected by all above factors. therefore, ageing itself cannot be defined only as diminished physical powers. it should be noted that population ageing causes the following problems: working-age people european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5511 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 50 are no longer able to generate enough income for pensions: the elderly are forced to work longer and cannot enjoy their retirement. it is projected that the share of elderly population will increase, while the share of youth and working age people will decline significantly in eu in the next few decades (european commission, 2014). seeking to identify the future trends of population ageing, the eurostat population projections (europop2015), covering the period from 2015 to 2080, forecast the eu population will increase with its peak of 528,6 million in 2050, and thereafter will gradually decline down to 518,8 million in 2080. while comparing the age pyramids of 2015 and 2080 (see figure 1), it might be observed that the share of elderly people will continue to increase. over the next decades, the share of elderly population will significantly grow due to high number of baby boomers. however, it obvious that the shape of this pyramid will transform, becoming similar to rectangle, narrowed in the middle (in the age of 45 – 54 years) in 2080. figure 1. eu population age pyramids 2016 and 2080 (% of the total population) source: eurostat, 2016 another important aspect of population ageing is a gradual ageing of the elderly population, since a relative segment of very old people grows faster than any other age segment of the eu population. the share of people aged 80 years, or the share of elderly people is projected to increase more than double from 5,4 percent to 12,7 percent during the period of 2016–2080 (see figure 2). figure 2. eu population by broad age groups 2016–2080 (% of the total population) source: eurostat, 2016 european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5511 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 51 while referring to the period of 2016–2080, the share of working-age population is expected to continuously decrease until 2050, slightly stabilizing later, while the share elderly population is projected to account for an increasing share of the total population: people aged 65 and over will account for 29,1 percent of the eu-28 population in 2080, in comparison with 19,2 percent in 2016. as a result of the movement of people from one age group to another, the projected eu-28 ageing index will increase almost double from 29,3 percent in 2016 to 52,3 percent in 2080 (see figure 3). the total age-dependency ratio is projected to increase from 53,2 percent 2016 to 79,7 percent 2080. figure 3. eu population by broad age groups 2016–2080 (% of the total population) source: eurostat, 2016 on the basis of the eu projections, it might be argued that the share of people aged 80 or elderly people in the eu population will increase more than twice during the period of 2016 – 2080, i.e., from 5,4 percent to 12,7 percent in 2080. people aged 65 and over will account for 29,1 percent of the eu population, in comparison with 19,2 percent in 2016. as a result of the movement of people from one age group to another, the projected eu ageing index will increase almost double from 29,3 percent in 2016 to 52,3 percent in 2080. in summary, it should be stated that the presented projections stimulate to transform both social security and labour market system with the expectation that the share of the oldest population will grow at a particularly high pace in the next decades. population ageing has twofold effect on the structure of labour – the number of elderly employees as well as the number of persons, who are no longer able to carry out economic activity, thus, becoming dependent on the social security mechanism, is growing (ambrazevičiūtė, 2014 ). the latter causes financial burden on the working age people, who finance the social insurance fund. the current system of the labour market is adapted to the model where the larger share of population maintains the socially supported elderly population. negative influence of population ageing on the labour market is dealt with increase of retirement age and formal reduction of the number of economically inactive people (okunevičiūtė – neverauskienė, 2011). however, actual number of economically inactive population does not depend solely on the retirement age. despite threat to the changes in the labour market, it is believed that population ageing will not necessarily affect the labour market negatively, if certain changes are made. the conditions of the labour market must be adapted to the socio-demographic changes, focused on the labour productivity, quality of the labour force, and labour force participation (moskvina, okunevičiūtė –neverauskienė, 2011). considering the negative influence of population ageing on the labour market and the economic stability of the country, it should be noted that special measures are required to provide conditions for the longest possible activity of employees in the labour market. although ageing is primarily defined as an entirety of physiological changes, not only physical limitations burden elderly people. namely, the economic activity potential of elderly population can be limited by the following reasons: insufficiently flexible employment forms; lack of development of adapted places; limited opportunities of lifelong learning; unequal access to healthcare services; lack of measures promoting later retirement ( kanopienė, mikulionienė, 2006). european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5511 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 52 while analysing the influence of the labour market on employment of elderly people, the retirement time, the working load, the method of retirement (how fast a person moves from part-time work to full retirement, the nature of work before retirement), the changes in the labour market, and the causes of retirement should be considered. as it has already been mentioned, the motives for retirement are often caused not by physiological changes that prevent from economic activity, but by incompatibility of the needs of the labour market and the elderly people. it might be argued that the reasons for early retirement of elderly people from the labour market are determined both by employer and employee position. didžgalvytė, lukšaitė (2014), nilsson, bülow, kazemi (2015) various studies revealed that individual's view towards normal retirement depends on the social security system, his financial situation, needs, even on occupation. for example, people, who are engaged in physical work, tend to quit earlier because of health problems and reduced physical capacity (moskvina, skučienė, 2014). other reasons are related with employer's needs in considering elderly population as more difficult to adapt to the labour market. it should be noted that elderly population faces more difficulties in adapting to the labour market due to the following reasons: professional and working experience is not in demand under modern economic conditions; lack of information and technological skills; lack of foreign language skills; qualification development programmes are targeted at young people; employers' view that elderly population is insufficiently energetic, that elderly population often lacks confidence in its forces, often does not want to raise its qualification or acquire to speciality; insufficient social partnership fails to implement appropriate representation of elderly employees at the company or the state level. ( lengvinienė, rutkienė, tandzegolskienė, 2014). given these factors, it is essential to retain elderly people in the labour market. this requires the measures to protect elderly employees present in the labour market. furthermore, the employees should be encouraged to refresh their skills and to develop their qualification 2.2. regulation of labour relations in respect of population ageing a political, economic, social and cultural context of eu has led to the fact that the region of western and central europe has experienced one of the most noticeable and earliest population ageing trends. demographic changes in the community have been driven by both declining birth rates and progress in the health system. therefore, eu was one of the first to launch specific actions to deal with the issues caused by influence of population ageing on the labour market. the eu strategy papers state that the longest possible participation in the labour market stimulates the domestic markets, stabilizes the pension fund systems, has positive effect on the overall employment, therefore, it is one of the strategic objectives. looking at the statistics, it can be seen that during the period from 2001 to 2010, exit from the labour market was delayed by 1,6 years (women – 1,9, men – 1, 3). it evidences about quite successful strategy of retention of elderly employees in the labour market. therefore, it is important to analyse the measures implemented at eu level for changes in labour relations in the context of population ageing. article 147 of consolidated version of the treaty on the functioning of the european union (2012) states that while solving the issues of employment the union shall encourage cooperation between member states and support and, if necessary, complement their action. paragraph 1 of article 153 of the same legislation specifies that the union shall support and complement the integration of persons excluded from the labour market (consolidated version of the treaty on the functioning of the european union. oj, c326/47 (2012). while analysing the evolution of the eu policy in dealing with the issues of population ageing in respect of the labour market, two stages can be distinguished: from founding of the community in 1957 to the treaty of amsterdam, and after this treaty. in the first decades of the community existence, population ageing was not included in any official policy agenda or reflected in any other papers. the treaty on european union included the provision prohibiting discrimination on the grounds of nationality and gender, but age was not mentioned there. the first period was characterized only by declarative documents, which including recommended guidelines to avoid the consequences of population ageing. although the papers, issued during this period, affected the law of the member states, they did not lead to specific binding rules of law of the community (ambrazevičiūtė, 2014). here, the resolution of the european parliament, adopted in 1982, on the situation and problems of the aged in the european community should be noted. this paper observes demographic change that emerges as the composition of population changes by age group, i.e., as the share of elderly population increases. with regard to labour law, clause 8 of the resolution was of particular importance, stating that the legal regulation where a person is removed from the labour market as he reaches the retirement age is not acceptable in the community (council recommendation of 10 december 1982 on the principles of a community policy with regard to retirement age, oj 1982, l 357). it was highlighted that person's exit from the labour market as he reaches the retirement age is his right rather than an european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5511 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 53 obligation imposed by the state. this resolution encouraged the european council to adopt the recommendation on the principles of a community policy with regard to retirement age. the latter emphasized that termination of employment relationships should not be based on the fact of retirement, and financial incentives to promote the early retirement may be introduced only because of exceptional economic circumstances. while analysing population ageing and the changes in the labour market in the context of regulation of labour relations, the treaty of amsterdam 1997 is considered as a qualitatively new and progressive step, since the council gained the competence to directly affect the legal systems of the member states and to take actions in event of discrimination (age is also included in the types of discrimination). as the issue of population was declared as one of the most important fields of social policy, the european commission encouraged the cooperation of the member states in solving this issue at the community level in 1999. application of employment policy and labour market measures was named as one of the four action fields in the document for overcoming the consequences of ageing (kanopienė, mikulionienė, 2006). on the basis of the treaty of amsterdam, on 27th of november, 2000, the council directive 2000/78/ec, regulating the principles of equal treatment in the labour market of the community and targeted towards establishment of equal rights and non-discrimination principles, as well as towards promotion of the eu employment policy, was adopted (council directive 2000/78/ec of 27 november 2000 establishing a general framework for equal treatment in employment and occupation). over the recent decades, the european labour market has been affected by international migration, fast technological development, growing dynamism and competitiveness. these changes have led to the necessity to restructure the labour market, to improve adaptability of companies and employees by applying the concept of flexicurity, which is based on a combination of social security and flexibility. while applying the principles of flexicurity, security guarantees are associated with help for improving skills for career development, with possibility to change the work place or retrain rather than with retention in the work place (mačernytė panomariovienė, 2011). considering the relevance of population ageing, 2012 was announced as the european year for active ageing and solidarity between generations. active ageing was defined as the process of optimising opportunities for health, participation and security in order to enhance quality of life as people age. active ageing is understood as the process allowing to realize the potentials for physical, social, and mental well-being (european parliament and the council decision on the european year for active ageing and solidarity between generations. oj 2011, l 246/). it should be noted that solidarity between generations is the key factor in the labour market. invaluable experience of elderly employees and skills of youth should be used as an exchange program. taking into account the relevance of flexicurity in the context of population ageing, the communication from the commission "towards common principles of flexicurity: more and better jobs through flexibility and security", 2007, should be mentioned (communication from the commission to the european parliament, the council, the european economic and social committee and the committee of the regions towards common principles of flexicurity: more and better jobs through flexibility and security. com (2007) 359 final). the latter presents the common principles of flexicurity: flexible and reliable contractual arrangement, modern labour laws, collective agreements, modern labour organization; implementation of comprehensive lifelong learning strategy, improving the adaptability and employability of workers; effective and active labour market policy, reducing unemployment spells and easing the transition periods; social security measures that encourage employment and facilitate labour market mobility. it might be stated that this communication encouraged the baltic countries to restructure the labour market in the way that social security would be associated with opportunities to adapt in the labour market rather than with retention of a working place. in other words, the guarantees of employment rather than of labour market should prevail. in lithuania, one of the most important aspects of the principle of non-discrimination in the labour market and other fields is primarily regulated in the main document of the country, i.e., the constitution of the republic of lithuania, the article 29 whereof states that "all persons shall be equal before the law, courts, and other state institutions and officials. human rights may not be restricted; no one may be granted any privileges on the grounds of gender, race, nationality, language, origin, social status, belief, convictions, or view" (the constitution of the republic of lithuania, official gazette 33, 1014 (1992). meanwhile, article 48 of the constitution is more relevant in the context of labour. it specifies that "everyone may freely choose a job or business, and shall have the right to have proper, safe, and healthy conditions at work, as well as to receive fair pay for work and social security in the event of unemployment". the legal regulation of lithuania in addressing the issues of elderly population in the labour market is focused towards additional support and implementation of the principle of non-discrimination by age. considering the real situation, where european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5511 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 54 difficulties in the labour market are faced by people in their fourth or fifth decade, the age limit additional support has been decreased. relatively strict regulation of the labour market limits the flexibility of employers in making decisions on admission and dismissal from work. this, in turn, potentially negatively affects the employment possibilities of the high-risk groups as the elderly population. therefore, more flexible regulation of labour relations, established by the labour code, which came into effect in 01 07 2017, might be beneficial for older employees. 3. methodology problem of research – less favourable attitude of employers towards elderly employees is one of the problems hindering the integration of elderly population in the labour market. object of research – integration of elderly population in the labour market. aim of research – to reveal the attitudes of employers in respect of support and inclusion of elderly employees in the labour market. objectives of empirical research: 1) to conduct the survey of employers' opinion, which would help to identify the factors hindering the inclusion of elderly population in the labour market 2) to propose methods and ways on how to improve inclusion and participation of elderly population in the labour market in the future 3) to give preliminary view of covid-19 impact on labour market for elderly employees. qualitative research method – survey of expert opinion in the form of a structured questionnaire (interview) – was selected for empirical research. the survey was conducted through a formal interview, i.e., interview with pre-arranged questions that all respondents were asked in the same order. this form of interview was selected, seeking to find out the expert opinion about the current situation and, by comparing answers, to reveal the expert attitude towards support and inclusion of elderly employees in the labour market. in case of this research, the method of interview was more appropriate for the same reasons – it was sought to go deep into real and sometimes hidden reasons why elderly employee are looked at rather sceptically in the labour market. analysis and interpretation of qualitative research data requires high objectivity in order to ensure the validity of the research results. data were analysed on the basis of comparative analysis. the informant group consisted of 5 employers – the persons leading the companies. the following criteria were applied: experience of management (at least 3), the number of employees (at least 15). the aforementioned criteria were selected in order to reflect the attitudes of employers, taking into account the experience of managers in management of human resources, and the structure of employees in the companies. the prepared questionnaire consists of a group of interrelated questions to be answered by interviewed informants. the problem-related questions: how do you evaluate the employment opportunities for elderly persons? are there any discriminatory provisions for employment of elderly persons? what are the possibilities for development of qualification and retraining?. 4. results in addition to being more susceptible to contracting covid-19, older workers face a number of challenges that contribute to their likelihood of being laid off from their jobs. the shift to working from home could hurt older employers due to a lingering perception that more seasoned workers aren't as tech-savvy as their younger counterparts. the informants were asked to comment on the employment opportunities for elderly persons. ” i usually focus on older people as a guarantor of stability and responsibility. we now notice that the supply of older people looking for work is really high. for example, the school and kindergarten catering sector is home to people who have worked in luxury restaurants that have had to close due to quarantine, which increases the competence of our company and improves the quality of services” the respondents emphasized the disadvantages of elderly employees, highlighting that these employees are not sufficiently motivated, would hardly adapt to the existing innovations in the company: "older workers are not flexible, hardly accept innovations, resulting in a decrease of work performance", "they find it more difficult to accept new information, they need to be motivated to go to training", "elderly employees find it more difficult to adapt to certain innovations, especially information technology", "technology is constantly improving in our sector, they hardly adapt to innovations", "do not want to be retrained, in order to master new technologies". during the survey, respondents agreed that proper leadership by managers and management of organization motivates individuals to change and to adapt to the changes in an organization: "if physical health allows, i have not noticed that employees would lose their motivation naturally with age", "our organization does not divide european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5511 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 55 employees to old and young, our team is friendly", "precise tasks and division of work allows for effective use of the age difference and right motivation of employees", "age is not very important for motivation, sometimes young people do not want anything…", "poor foreign language skills, the older generation is perfect of russian language, however, the labor market often requires good english language skills". the respondents stated that they would be more cautious about older persons, when looking for a new employee, since the named disadvantages of elderly employees include not only physiological changes, but also extremely difficult acceptance of technological innovations at work and lack of foreign language skills. however, those employers whose attitudes towards elderly employees remain positive are ready to provide opportunities to be retained in the labor market. it was asked whether the employee's experience is considered an advantage. it has been noticed that none of the informants identified age as a direct advantage, however, they were positive about experience and emphasized the personal characteristics, which help to adapt and work in a team: "age is not an advantage, however, experience is always a decisive factor when getting employed", "experience must be in line with positivity, creativity", "we select employees according to their ability to work in a team, communicativeness, responsibility", "we choose according to desire to work, to adapt to the duties, requirements", "it is essential that a person would be able to work in team, to have the desire to change and improve", "i have noticed that older people are more responsible and diligent in carrying out tasks at work". the informant noted: "people of older generation like to emphasize the fact that they are with higher education, however, often the knowledge gained in 1980s, is outdated", "we evaluate experience and competencies of the people because we cannot rely solely on a diploma as the knowledge was acquired long ago." it was sought to find out the attitude of the informants towards older long-term unemployed persons. the majority stated that long-term unemployment has negative effect on the person's skills, therefore, these individuals find it hard to adapt in a new team, they lack self-confidence, willingness to change and improve: "long-term unemployment shows that a person has been refused to be employed by a number of employers for some reasons", "people lose their working skills over a long period of time, therefore, i would think good before employing", "it is risky to employ a long-term unemployed person, i would employ him, if i knew at least the main causes of long-term unemployment", "if a person could not work because of a good reason, i would give him a chance", "it would depend on the position in the company and the reasons that led to long-term unemployment." in conclusion, it might be argued that the respondents would go deep into the reasons of long-term unemployment and consider the specific situation of these persons. while considering the opportunities of elderly employees to be retained in the labour market, the informants stated that they would employ the older person, who had completed retraining courses. for some employers, completing courses would serve as a proof of motivation, however, a part of them emphasized that it would not be an advantage: "yes. it would prove that a person still has aims, motivation. we would kindly employ this person for the position that does not require much experience"; "if these courses are related with company's activities and the person meets other required criteria, we will consider his candidacy to the required position"; "we would employ him, however, it would not be an advantage. maybe, we would impose a probationary period to let him show what he is able to do." the informants would agree on training elderly employees if it positively affected their productivity. some employers would like the state to at least partially finance this kind of training: "we could not pay for training solely from our funds, it is huge expenses"; "i would like to get the state support not only for employing the elderly, but also for retaining and raising the qualification of elderly employees"; "training is quite expensive, but it is better to invest in an employee than to look for a new one." during the interview, the respondents said pointed out that they would use the possibility to employ an older person by subsidizing his working place. however, they would employ only if an employee met all requirements and this position was required: "subsidies are very necessary"; "i use subsidies when the company's needs meet according to the working place"; "it is the possibility for an older employee to go back to work.". the informants stated that compensation of salary expenses is a sufficient incentive to employ an older person, while subsidies could also be granted with a probationary period. the research revealed a positive attitude towards employment of retirement-age persons, although the informants stated that productivity of employees in this age group should be lower, and the possibilities would allow employing only for jobs that do not require much skills: "it is nothing bad, if a person has willingness, skills, motivation. it is only welcoming, if he still needs activity. i hope the number of these pensioners will increase in the future"; "i have employed some of such people because recommendations, knew that they are trustable people"; "the number of learning, active seniors is increasing, therefore, maybe the number of those, who would be active in the labour market, despite of getting a pension, would also grow in the future". it european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5511 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 56 can be argued that there is a positive attitude towards working persons of retirement-age, who are capable to work and are required for organization, however, the solutions for staying in the labour market as long as possible require systematic and targeted measures, which would be focused on and dedicated for the employees, who are currently active in the labour market and will reach their retirement age a few years later. 5. conclusion population ageing is a complex phenomenon, defining the relationship of elderly population with the remaining society. this process leads to the fact that the difficulties of adaptation in the labour market, caused by biological, psychological and social changes, are faced by an increasing share of population. in lithuania, there is a lack of a clear public employment strategy, therefore the applied solutions are often insufficient and inconsistent, there is a lack of a comprehensive approach to the situation, the needs of different groups and the causes of unemployment are underestimated. in order to ensure public employment, appropriate targets should be set for the public sector and business organizations, and self-care for those in their fifties and older should be encouraged. it is still early to predict outcomes of covid-19 crisis, but health risks for older workers already raised their unemployment rates in lithuania suggesting that some older unemployed workers will stop looking for work permanently. as lithuanian population ages, elderly people will account for an increasing share of population, therefore, on the one hand, their active inclusion in the labour market will be characterized by ever increasing influence on the public life, on the other hand, it will be difficult to discriminate the majority of employees. thus, the society will have to change the view towards elderly employees and understand that there is a need of a full range of measures that would be active before an employee falls into the category of high-risk group, related with his age. attractiveness of elderly population as labour force in the labour market may be increased by applying flexicurity principles. strengthen enforcement of laws particularly in areas that are viewed to put elderly employees at a disadvantage. the results of the completed research revealed that the employers' attitude towards older employees is determined by stereotyped thinking that the elderly does not have sufficient motivation to change, therefore, age affects their decision in the process of employee selection. older persons, working in organizations, are rated quite favourably – especially those with experience and wishing to retrain. in most cases, the employer does not select an elderly person due to his lack of knowledge or skills rather than due to his age, thus, the support system for elderly population should be so as to help people to stay in the labour market as long as possible. addressing the issue of influence of population ageing on the labour market requires a systematic and preventive approach. therefore, application of some support measures in the labour market should be started as soon as possible. the persons, who fall into this age group, should be provided with the opportunities of retraining and refreshing their skills. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5511 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 57 references ambrazevičiūtė, k. (2014). visuomenės senėjimo įtaka darbo teisinių santykių reguliavime: tarptautinis ir europos sąjungos požiūris. teisės problemos 4, 97-110. bailey, c. a. (2007). a guide to qualitative research. sage publications. bitinas, b., rupšienė, l., žydžiūnaitė, v. (2008). kokybinių tyrimų metodologija. klaipėda. brazienė, r., mikutavičienė, i. (2015). diskriminacijos dėl amžiaus raiška lietuvos darbo rinkoje. filosofija. sociologija, 26(2), 87–98. communication from the commission to the european parliament, the council, the european economic and social committee and the committee of the regions towards common principles of flexicurity: more and better jobs through flexibility and security. com (2007) 359 final). available (accessed 09.09.2018): https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legalcontent/ga/txt/?uri=celex:52007sc0861. consolidated version of the treaty on the functioning of the european union. oj, c326/47 (2012). available (accessed 10.09.2018): https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/en/txt/?uri=celex%3a12012e%2ftxt. corsi, m.,lodovici, m. s. (2013). active ageing and gender equality. working paper, 13(004). université librede bruxelles – solvay brussels school of economics and management centre emile bernheim. council directive 2000/78/ec of 27 november 2000 establishing a general framework for equal treatment in employment and occupation). available (accessed 10.10.2018): https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legalcontent/en/txt/?uri=celex%3a32000l0078. council recommendation of 10 december 1982 on the principles of a community policy with regard to retirement age, oj 1982, l 357). available (accessed 11.09.2018): https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legalcontent/en/txt/?uri=celex%3a31982h0857. didžgalvytė m., lukšaitė i. (2014). demografinio senėjimo įtaka ekonominiams rodikliams. taikomoji ekonomika: sisteminiai tyrimai, 8(2). employment and social developments in europe 2015.(2016). european commission, 2016. catalogn.: ke-bd-15-001en-n. europe 2020. (2010). a strategy for smart, sustainable and inclusive growth. communication from the commission . brussels, 3.3.2010 com (2010) 2020. available (accessed 10.10.2018): https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legalcontent/en/all/?uri=celex%3a52010dc2020. european parliament and the council decision on the european year for active ageing and solidarity between generations. oj 2011, l 246/5). available (accessed 10.10.2018) https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/ga/txt/?uri=celex:32011d0940. eurostat. employment rate bygender, age group 55–64. available (accessed 10.10.2018): http://epp.eurostat.ec.europa.eu/portal/page/portal/eurostat/home/. kanopienė v. mikulionenė s. (2006). gyventojų senėjimas ir jo iššūkiai sveikatos apsaugos sistemai. gerontologija, 7(4), p. 188 – 200. labanauskaitė, astrauskaitė, kiyak (2014). relationshipship between the population aging and the supply of services in different regions in lithuania. regional formation and development studies, 2 (7), 86-98. lengvinienė, s., rutkienė, a.,tandzegolskienė, i. (2014). vyresnio amžiaus žmonių išlikimo darbo rinkoje teoriniai aspektai. profesinis rengimas: tyrimai ir realijos, 25, 128-136. lietuvos pažangos strategija „lietuva 2030“. (2012). valstybės žinios, no. 61-3050. lietuvos respublikos konstitucija (1992). valstybės žinios, no. 33-1014. lietuvos respublikos socialinių paslaugų įstatymas (2006). valstybės žinios, no. 17-589. lietuvos statistikos departamentas. gyventojai ir socialinė statistika. socialinė apsauga (pagal esspros). available (accessed 05.10.2018): http://osp.stat.gov.lt/rodikliai21. mačernytė-panomariovienė, i (2011). „flexicurity samprata ir įgyvendinimo galimybės lietuvos užimtumo politikoje.“ jurisprudencija 18, 1081-1099. moskvina, j.; okunevičiūtė -neverauskienė, l. (2011). vulnerable groups at lithuanian labour market. comparative economic research. central and eastern europe, 14 (4): 47–63. moskvina, j.; skučienė d. (2014). pasitraukimo iš darbo rinkos vyresniame amžiuje veiksniai. gerontologija. 15(2): 88–96. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5511 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 58 nilsson h., bülow p. h., kazemi a. (2015). mindful sustainable aging: advancing a comprehensive approach to the challenges and opportunities of old age. europe's journal of psychology, 11(3), p. 494 – 508. north m. s., fiske s. t. (2013). act your (old) age: prescriptive, ageist biases over succession, consumption, and identity. personality and social psychology bulletin 39(6): 720–734. okunevičiūtė – neverauskienė l. (2011). diskriminacijos apraiškos: aktuali būklė bei tendencijos antidiskriminacijos srityje. filosofija. sociologija, 22(2), p. 115 – 128. seltzer, j. a. ir yahirun, j. j. (2013). diversityin old age: the elderly in changing economic and family contexts. final report. skučienė, d., bartkus, a., moskvina, j. ir uleckienė, a. (2015). senėjanti visuomenė: kaip mes pasirengę? vilnius: lietuvos socialinių tyrimų centras. social report 2014-2015. https://socmin.lrv.lt/lt/veiklos-sritys/socialinis-pranesimas. social report 2016-2017. https://socmin.lrv.lt/lt/veiklos-sritys/socialinis-pranesimas. the 2015 ageing report. economic and budgetary projections for the 28 eu member states (2013-2060). european economy3/2015. (accessed 05.09.2018): treaty of amsterdam. oj (1997). available (accessed 10.08.2018): https://eurlex.europa.eu/legal-content/en/txt/?uri=oj:c:1997:340:toc 5098-article text-16397-2-11-20201211 http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5098 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 1 the potential of circular businesses in the postcovid era: a system dynamics view francesca costanza1 1 department of law (palermo campus), university of rome lumsa, roma, italy e-mail: f.costanza1@lumsa.it received: 15/09/2020 revised: 11/11/2020 accepted for publication: 04/12/2020 published: 18/12/2020 abstract the last decade has witnessed the flourishing interest of scholars and policymakers to the application of circular economy (ce) principles, which has been pointed out as a compelling goal for business and society at current times of coronavirus pandemic. this paper aims to describe the roles of companies and consumers in ce implementation, the basic mechanisms of circular business creation and diffusion, and their potential contribution to the recovery post-covid. for the purpose, it has been adopted a system dynamics (sd) view to build an insight model integrating selected literature inputs. distinguishing between “born circular” and “converted circular” businesses, model dynamics highlight the interplay of circular businesses and responsible consumers, postulating key feedbacks able to affect, respectively, the conversion of companies and people to virtuous productive and consumption behaviours. finally, the consolidation of such mechanisms contributes to the alleviation of specific socioeconomic and environmental issues ascribable to the coronavirus spreading. keywords: circular economy; circular business; covid; system dynamics. 1. introduction the coronavirus pandemic has been challenging global health care, economy and society. in order to minimize the loss of human life “in the face of an invisible contagion” (sarkis et al., 2020, p.1), previous life routines have been substituted or integrated by new ones (e.g. sanitation, social distancing, use of http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5098 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 2 disposable gloves and masks). the scenario observed in the early stage of covid spreading (first half of 2020) included congestion of health facilities, national lockdowns and a generalized deceleration of production and trade, especially as far as the international commerce is concerned. in this regard, the switch towards the circular economy (ce) principles, already felt as a compelling goal by policymakers in the pre-covid era (e.g. european commission, 2015, 2019; european environment agency, 2019), assumes a crucial importance at the time of writing this paper. in fact, once the initial shock was overcome, there is the need to cohabit with the virus in the medium term (until the development of a vaccine), balancing the urge to restore the economy with that of operating in safety conditions. with a longer period orientation, to be proactive and to avoid being caught unprepared by potential system shocks, it is called for a general rethinking of production systems in terms of sustainability and resilience (sneader & singhal, 2020; ellen macarthur foundation, 2020). thus, national and local systems should accelerate the transition to circular economy (blériot, 2020) attributing a central function to entrepreneurship, seen as a relevant change agent (neumeyer et al., 2020). indeed, the ce paradigm, subverting the traditional linear economy (summarized by the sequence of material extraction, transformation, disposal), introduces production and consumption practices devoted to resource recovery and re-circulation. this way, it promises to foster industrial efficiency and local supply resilience in an environmentally conscious way (ellen macarthur foundation, 2013; geissdoerfer et al., 2018). this paper seeks to address circular business generative paths and their impacts on coronavirus challenges by wearing strategic management lens, meaning that circular business development will be intended as a process involving firms and their environment (katz, 1970; mintzberg, 1987). so far, even in presence of extant contributions from the practitioners world (e.g. ellen macarthur foundation), some gaps have been identified in the strategic management research dealing with ce. in first place, the scientific literature originating the topic is not ascribable to the managerial and organizational spheres (korhonen et al., 2018), and only recently the strategic management domain started to pay attention to ce, conceiving it as a driving paradigm for product and business model innovations (linder & williander, 2017; urbinati et al., 2017). as a result, the research field is still young and not fully explored. referring to a systematic literature review recently conducted by centobelli and colleagues (2020), it was detected a research lack in providing a systemic view of circular businesses, considering multiple-actor interrelations and the contextual factors able to boost the transition. in addition, managerial http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5098 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 3 contributions to ce conceptualizations are narrowly focused: they pay attention to just one side of the coin (companies), underestimating the crucial role of consumer acceptance of the new paradigm (chamberlin & boks, 2018). this paper aims to concur in bridging the aforementioned gaps, seeking at the same time to make a contribution regarding some covid related issues. accordingly, three research questions have been formulated: (1) what is the role of companies and consumers in the implementation of circular economy principles? (2) what are the basic mechanisms of circular business creation and diffusion from a holistic perspective? (3) in which ways the circular economy can contribute to the recovery post-covid? in order to address the above queries, it was adopted a system dynamics (sd) view (forrester, 1961; sterman, 2000; wolstenholme, 1990) to build an insight model integrating relevant literature sources in a holistic and original manner. sd modelling approach was privileged because it provides visual and analytic tools to capture the feedback relationships among several variables. the paper is organized as follows: after this introduction, it is proposed a literature review about circular economy and its potential links with covid pandemic. then, the methodology section describes sd features, together with the modelling approach for this study. it follows an illustration of research results, whereas core model dynamics are presented and described. finally, the conclusion section summarizes the contents of the paper and the main contributions, highlighting limitations and future research avenues. 2. literature review the coronavirus pandemic has caused health facilities overload, national lockdowns and a generalized deceleration of economic activities. the crisis has disclosed the fragility of many global supply chains and the need of more resilient supplies at a local level (blériot, 2020). moreover, the impact on business closures exacerbated social inequalities, whereas “minority groups and individuals living in poverty, including the elderly, are disproportionally affected by the resulting health and economic implications” (neumeyer et al., 2020, p. 2). from the environmental perspective, together with a general call to preserve the environment as a precondition for public health (wuyts et al., 2020, p. 2), the large-scale economic slowdown was claimed to bring more specific – and contrasting – effects. http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5098 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 4 on the one hand, it was registered an improvement of air and water quality (saadat et al., 2020), especially in more polluted areas. however, such advancements are to be considered temporary and destined to gradually disappear with the necessary restart of economic activities. on the other side, there have been highlighted indirect negative effects, such as an increase of waste (in particular for disposable plastic goods and for protective equipments) and a reduction of recycling (ragazzi et al. 2020). in this context, sustainable development and ce are two related concepts (geissdoerfer et al., 2017) assuming a crucial importance. sustainable development, meaning to satisfy actual needs without compromising the satisfaction of future generations (world commission on environment and development, 1987), is based on three pillars: economic growth, environmental protection and social inclusion (united nations general assembly, 2015). entrepreneurships plays an essential role in pursuing sustainable development (apostolopoulos et al. 2018), and, from a managerial perspective, the “triple bottom line” approach dictates for companies the joint consideration of economic, environmental and social performances (tullberg, 2012). circular economy, an approach postulating an economic system able to minimize resource exploitation, emissions and waste without compromising economic growth, is seen as a possible solution to address sustainable development (geissdoerfer et al., 2018). ce mitigates the environmental externalities associated to economic activities, by providing guidelines to invert the logic of traditional, linear models where raw materials are extracted and transformed in finished products, consumed and finally routed to waste (landfilled or incinerated). connaturated with this sequence are risks of material scarcity and negative environmental impacts: the ce paradigm overcomes such pitfalls by increasing product efficiency through new ways of production and consumption, where goods are conserved as long as possible and resources are iteratively circulated through closed loops (guldman, 2016, pp. 9-11). accordingly, it proposes the redesign of products, services and business models, incorporating durability, re-use, repair, refurbishment, and recycling (ellen macarthur foundation, 2013, 2015). in spite of many circular economy applications from the practitioners world (e.g. ellen macarthur foundation and accenture), the scientific debate about ce appears dispersive. on the one hand, natural sciences and engineering fields have developed an ample body of research, routed in different research streams, such as: industrial ecology, acknowledging the need of operational learning from cyclical, renewable and cascading natural flows (graedel, 1996); and cradle-to-cradle (mcdonough & braungart, http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5098 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 5 2003), a design strategy based on the consideration of products’ entire value chains and life cycles, in search of eco-effectiveness (braungart et al., 2007). on the other side, conceptualizations in business, organization and management are still in an infant stage (korhonen et al., 2018). specifically, recent studies intersecting strategic management and ce only focus on circular business models (cbms) (e.g. linder & williander, 2017; crainer, 2013), i.e. business representations on how companies create, transfer and capture value relating internal and external relations (zott & amit, 2010; osterwalder & pigneur, 2010) suitable to put in practice ce principles by incorporating elements that slow, narrow, and close resource loops (geissdoerfer et al., 2018). scholars contributions propose taxonomies of circular business models (bocken et al., 2016; urbinati et al., 2017), and highlight how cbms are source of competitive advantage through the recovery of the so-called “uncaptured value” (yang et al., 2016), that along linear business models is lost and not internalized. circular business models allow to create and/or modify organizational and interorganizational resource loops through three possible measures: (a) recycling, which allows to close loops instead of having open chains; (b) efficiency improvements (narrowing loops); and (c) use phase extensions, consenting to slow loops (ellen macarthur foundation, 2013; bocken et al., 2016). so far, the strategic management studies have not addressed circular business development in a systemic way (centobelli et al., 2020), i.e. taking into account factors affecting the circular business creation/conversion, and the relationships between differents actors, first of all the consumer, playing a crucial and overlooked – role in the acceptance of ce (chamberlin & boks, 2018). recently geissdoerfer and others (2017, p. 765) reported that the typical subjects of circular economy’s agency, i.e. entities needing to internalize and put in practice ce principles, are just government, companies and ngos, thus underestimating the responsible consumer behaviour’s role and its determinants. 3. methodology 3.1 system dynamics modelling the study addressed the research questions by adopting a qualitative system dynamics approach (sd) to create an insight model grounded in literature and representing a dynamic hypothesis about circular business spreading in relation to covid related issues. before illustrating modelling steps adopted for this research and describing the key model results, it is considered appropriate a brief introduction about system dynamics discipline and its building blocks. http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5098 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 6 system dynamics is a computational methodology grounded in cybernetics and system science, initiated at the mit institute (boston) by forrester (1961). in the context of this work, it was judged suitable to deal with circular economy issues, since it captures the behavioral dynamics of complex (social, economic and/or ecological) systems through the feedback relationships among the parts (maier, 1998). the methodological choice was also supported by looking at numerous sd modelling efforts in the strategic minanagement field (e.g. morecroft, 1984; warren, 2005; wang, 2011). the sd modelling process (sterman, 2000) involves the construction of stock-and-flow diagrams (sfds) and causal loop diagrams (clds), paired with the formulation of differential equations allowing to simulate alternative policy scenarios. in this regard, the phase of construction (and subsequent analysis) of sfds and clds is acknowledged as a qualitative modelling branch of system dynamics (wolstenholme, 1990), able to provide interesting results both as a stand-alone methodology or as preliminary step before mathematic formalization. a stock-and-flow diagram is a map tracking networked processes of accumulation/depletion of material, information, and money (sterman, 2000). it is made of stocks, flows and auxiliary variables. stocks represent cumulated levels of resources or amount, are measured by quantities at a punctual time and are denoted by rectangles. flows are the rates causing stocks to rise/exploit over the time, are measured by quantities per time unit and are graphically represented by mean of pipes inflowing or outflowing the stocks. sometimes, especially in dealing with soft variables, modellers prefer to not keep inflows and outflows distinct, and to use bi-flow structures, expressive of stocks’ net rates of change in term of difference between inflows and outflows (sterman, 2000). in the simplified shop economy of figure 1, letter a), there are two stocks (‘cash’ and ‘customer satisfaction’). the first is fed by the inflow ‘revenues’ and depleted by the outflow ‘expenses’ (assuming all the transactions taking place in cash); whilst the stock of ‘customer satisfaction’ is affected just by ‘change in customer satisfaction’ which is a bi-flow with its specific graphic. figure 1. basic examples of stock-and-flow diagram (a) and causal loop diagram (b). http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5098 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 7 source: author’s elaboration. auxiliaries, denoted by circles, are supplementary variables with various function: to help calculus through ratios and other formulas, to bring constant or exogenous parameters to the model, to synthesize system’s partitions that the modellers decide not to focalize. stocks and auxiliaries can impact on the flows related to other stocks, directly or through auxiliary variables. in the example, the stock of cash, ceteris paribus, impacts on the auxiliary ‘investments in product quality’, which in turn has a boosting effect on the ‘change in customer satisfaction’ and then on ‘customer satisfaction’. the latter (together with other variables not included in this simple model), affects both ‘revenues’ and ‘expenses’ flows, and then the ‘cash’ stock. on the right part of the figure above (letter b), it is shown a causal loop diagram. it consists on a network of interacting loops, synthesizing the model dynamics through a compact scheme which does not distinguish stocks, flows and auxiliaries, and isolates just some variables from the ones belonging to the stock-and-flow structure. in the example, the cld shows the interplay of two loops, made of variables linked by arrowed polarities, whereas the positive and negative links mean that the cause-and-effect change goes respectively in the same and in the opposite direction. even loops have a polarity, resulting from multiplying all the links’ signs. loop r (positive polarity) is defined “reinforcing” because it shows virtuous or vicious mechanisms of continuous growth or decay: an increase of cash can induce new investments in product quality and thus sales, revenues, and ultimately http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5098 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 8 more cash. on the other side, a cash depletion frees up less resources for quality investments and thus reduces sales, revenues, and again cash. loop b (negative polarity) is “balancing” since it counteracts the above dynamics of growth/decay: more ‘sold products’ cause ‘expenses’ to raise, which in turn reduce the ‘cash’ stock. viceversa, a reduction in sales has a depleting effect on expenses and thus a boosting effect on cash. 3.2 research process the study was based on an iterative process of literature selection and analysis, accompanied by model building activities. the starting point was a literature research about topics directly descending from the research questions: circular economy, consumer’s role in circular economy, circular economy and coronavirus. as mentioned in the introduction, in line with research aims the analysis adopted strategic management lens. this means that every source was evaluated for its potential contribution to the circular business development discourse, treated as an interdependent process involving firms and their environment. however, the phase of literature search considered both the strategic management orientation and the novelty of ce topic for the field, whereas theoretical developments are far from being complete, and a systemic view is lacking. as a result, the searching approach was multidisciplinary to also explore candidate inputs from other fields, such as environmental sciences, industrial ecology and product design. scientific sources have been selected from google scholar (or gs) according to the following criteria: relevance to the study purpose, published in peer-reviewed international journals, written in english language. beside boolean researches on the database, other sources were identified by looking at papers’ references. the decision to use gs (instead of a subscription-based scholarly database, such as web of science, or wos) is due to the following reasons. first, like wos, scholar is multidisciplinary (de winter et al., 2014; mikki, 2009) and this fits the purpose to embrace publications from many research fields, with more direct links to open access publications. second, gs aggregates both academic and grey literature (haddaway et al., 2015), and this is useful given the actuality of the research and the fact that circular economy issues produce diverse types of output knowledge than just research articles. indeed, it was considered worth to review also non-scientific sources, such as best practice reports and other publications from practitioners and policy makers, when http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5098 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 9 considered coherent with the investigated objects and coming from authoritative and internationally recognized private/public institutions. the documents (49 in total, published in the last decade) were analyzed in-depth, progressively identifying key concepts in relation to the research questions. then, a series of candidate variables (retrieved from literature or elaborated by the author through inference from it) were listed, trying to hypothesize a modeling strategy for each, i.e. it was decided whether to represent every variable as a stock, a flow or an auxiliary, and key links have been identified. this phase was useful for a twofold reason: to create a preliminary understanding of the relevant system, and to drive the first modelling activity. afterwards, using a specific sd software, it was started the building of the stock-and-flow diagram. the modelling process was iterative and, starting from scratch, the model was continuously modified, adjusted and enriched in pace with new literature rounds and modeller’s progressive undestanding of the investigated objects. in the final version of the model (made of 31 variables: 5 stocks, 3 flows and 23 auxiliaries), it was decided to represent as stocks only variables ascribable to businesses and consumers, to remark accumulation/depletion processes regarding these key actors. all the flows were modelled as bi-flows to make the qualitative model more immediate and compact. auxiliary variables were used in two ways: to help in making feedback mechanisms explicit, and to show exogenous influences, i.e. not directly partecipating in any feedback circuit. once the sfd was completed, it was outlined a comprehensive causal loop diagram made of 11 interacting loops, providing a holistic view of the model dynamics and allowing a better analysis, discussion and communication of research results. 4. results 4.1 stock-and-flow diagram the first modelling output is the stock-and-flow diagram of figure 2. building on literature insights, the model postulates that the transition to ce is a process of “conversion” involving not only business companies, but also consumers. therefore, the model mirrors changing processes occurring in both categories, their interactions and their contribution to post-coronavirus recovery. in first approximation, the model area is divided in four sub-areas, indicated by rectangular labels. on the left side, there are depicted processes of ‘conversion to responsible consumption’, whilst the center of http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5098 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 10 the diagram is devoted to circular businesses and distinguishes two cases: the ‘circular business creation’, taking place when the company starts up with a circular business model from its own origin; and the ‘circular business conversion’, occurring whenever already existing companies decide to make investments to implement ce principles. on the right side, it is represented the ‘impact on covid related issues’: this part of the model infers on how circular business dynamics can help in alleviating some challenges deriving from the actual systemic crisis. in order to favor the model intelligibility, all the links connecting the variables are numbered, except for the ones pertaining to the ‘impact on covid related issues’, emphasized with letters. the following paragraphs provide detailed descriptions of the model areas and their connections. for explanatory reasons ‘circular business creation’ and ‘circular business conversion’ are addressed together. figure 2. model’s stock-and-flow diagram. source: author’s elaboration. http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5098 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 11 4.1.1 circular business creation and conversion the model recognizes the role played by entrepreneurial action in reducing environmental degradation and fostering sustainable development (dean & mcmullen, 2007). three stocks within the model deal with circular business transitions. at first, it is made a distinction between ‘born circular businesses’, starting to be circular from the beginning of their lifecycle, and ‘converted circular businesses’, regarding previous linear businesses aiming to become circular. crainer (2013) argues the need of businesses to reinvent themselves according to the promising circular economy perspective, by designing corporate strategies to metabolize waste in the economy. to capture such shift, the stock of ‘converted circular businesses’ is preceded by another, ‘linear businesses’. the connecting flow of ‘change in converted circular businesses’ is affected by the ‘company willingness to go circular’ (link 22) and by ‘interfirm circular partnerships’ (link 23). this last variable is included since company partnerships are receiving growing attention for their ability to pursue shared sustainability and waste reduction goals (veleva & bodkin, 2018). in line with a shared value approach (porter & kramer, 2011), the variable helps to capture different kinds of collaborative processes helping the implementation of ce principles: born circular businesses-born circular businesses, converted circular businesses-converted circular businesses, converted circular businesses-born circular businesses. the ‘company willingness to go circular’ is affected by: ‘incentives’ and ‘regulations’ (links 15-16), the recovery of efficiency allowed by ce (variable ‘circular efficiency’) and the stock ‘responsible consumers’, representing the market demand for circular products and services. thus the model portrays both business and contextual factors influencing the willingness of companies to transit towards a circular economy, such as the regulation activity of policymakers and international institutions (centobelli et al., 2020). policymakers and governments’ responsibility is due to the fact that they can act as both drivers or barriers for company ce transition, can remove existing barriers and support production and consumptions changes (kirchherr et al., 2018), e.g. the eu circular economy action plan (european commission, 2015), renovated with new limph at the beginning of coronavirus crisis, presents interrelated regulatory packages “to establish a strong and coherent product policy framework that will make sustainable products, services and business models the norm” (european commission, 2020, p. 3). http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5098 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 12 on the other side, ce is not just an environment respectful paradigm mitigating the externalities of human activities, but it encompasses (directly or indirectly) all the dimensions of sustainability. at business level, circular business models (cbms) are a sub-category of sustainable business models (bocken et al., 2016), which indeed target solutions for sustainable development through circular value chains and stakeholder incentive alignment. according to geissdoerfer and colleagues (2018) the circularity of a business model, taking place whenever its constituting elements (value proposition, value creation and delivery, value capture; richardson, 2008) go circular, allows the achievement of optimal sustainability performances. as argued by esposito and others (2018), ce enriches sustainable paradigms by maximizing the product's lifecycle and converting unusable products in new sources of value in the same/differerent value chains (centobelli et al, 2020). still, cbms are invaluable sources of competitive advantage, promising to generate profits in a new and environmentally conscious way (guldmann, 2016, p.7), for at least two reasons. first, by increasing product efficiency (‘circular efficiency’ in the model) through the adoption of re-use, repair, refurbishment, and recycling practices for resource conservation and continuous circulation. according to a joint study of ellen macarthur foundation and mckinsey, the circular transition can determine a 3% increase of europe’s resource productivity by 2030, generating cost savings of €600 billion a year and €1.8 trillion more in other economic benefits (ellen macarthur foundation & mckinsey, 2015). such figure means that industries are not taking the economic opportunities that circular economy can disclose. the second reason is that incorporating enviromental and social values in products, they result to be differentiated and non-commodified (d’aveni, 2010) in the eyes of an attentive consumer. unfortunately, contemporary entrepreneurship education is still focused on linear business models (neumeyer et al., 2020). referring to the stock of ‘born circular businesses’, its accumulation is due to the flow ‘change in born circular businesses’, which in turn is boosted by ‘willingness to become a circular entrepreneur’ (link 17), and ‘interfirm circular partnerships’ (link 19). the ‘willingness to become a circular entrepreneur’ is influenced, again, by ‘incentives, ‘regulations’, ‘circular efficiency’ and ‘responsible consumers’ (links 13-16). however, in this specific case the presence of a responsible consumption’s base influences the new circular initiatives in two ways: it still represents a market demand to be satisfied by new entrepreneurship energies; and it also constitutes the ‘entrepreneurial humus’, a basin of personalities, stimuli and values from which circular entrepreneurial intentions emerge. in fact, it is reasonable that the http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5098 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 13 wannabe-circular entrepreneurs are responsible consumers in first place. recalling the above discourse about ce related competitive advantage, the circular entrepreneurship is a promising route either to empower economically fragile people in trying their hand at new start-ups; or to induce already existing entrepreneurs in low-income settings to develop innovative products with less price sensitive customer targets (morris et al., 2020). 4.1.2 conversion to responsible consumption the ce application is not a “quick win but a long-term undertaking” (kirchherr et al., 2017, p. 228), requiring awareness of its socioeconomic implications and key implementation barriers (de jesus & mendonça, 2018), among which it was highlighted the “lacking consumer interest and awareness” (kirchherr et al., 2018). for this reason, the stock-and-flow diagram shows changes occurring in consumers, who move from the stock of ‘non responsible consumers’ to the one of ‘responsible consumers’. the responsible consumer is not just a person deciding to buy circular products and services, but he/she is also involved in ce practices, such as extending the use of products as long as possible to delay waste production, collecting goods to be recycled, sensitizing other people to the importance of circular consumption. the idea is not just to look at consumers as recipients of green marketing campaigns aimed at aligning environmental benefits with consumer self-interest and subsequent purchasing (grimmer & woolley, 2012), but to adopt a “design for sustainable behaviour” view (chamberlin & boks, 2018), focusing on individual behaviors as resulting from several motivating factors simultaneously (bocken, 2017). thus, the flow of ‘change in responsible consumer base’ is movimented by various influences. first, the ‘conversion from incentives’ (link 4), showing the impact of extrinsic motivations on circular practices. this variable in turn results from the combined effect of: ‘discounts from the collection practices’ (link 1), taking place for example when old clothes are brought to public/private second-hand circuits or to clothing shops; ‘relative prices’ (link 2), considering the price ratio between circular and non-circular products; and ‘regulations’ (link 3), e.g. municipal obligations to separate waste collection, envisaging fees/fines for the non-collectors. the importance of consumer empowerment in ce transition has been recently acknowledged by policymakers (european commission, 2020, p. 5), and also in the scientific debate the attention starts not to be devoted just to cleaner manufacturing, but also on strategies http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5098 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 14 to educate consumers, to design eco-labels and to induce responsible consumption choices (matthias et al., 2016). another factor stimulating responsible consumption is the ‘conversion from word of mouth’, that could be a driving force for comsumption habits’ switch in two ways: by spreading information about circular product quality, and by transmitting the awareness about the importance to practice ce principles. this variable depends on the contacts among non responsible and responsible consumers (links 5 and 7) and by their contact rate (link 8). other influences on circular consumption strictly derive from the business sector. specifically, the ‘total circular businesses’ inherently boost their own demand by proposing new circular standards of products and services (‘conversion from circular product design’) and by promoting ‘awareness raising initiatives’ (links 28-29). the latter, together with other initiatives coming from the public and third sectors (link 30) are aimed at educating people about circular economy concepts (sharma, 2020). these links were included to acknowledge literature insights describing the calls for companies’s good practices with consumers (in quality of downstream stakeholders) to improve their awareness and engagement, and to sensitize purchase decisions (centobelli et al. 2020, p. 1744). actually, limited customer knowledge of circular opportunities can slow the ce transition, given the consumers’ familiarity with linear models and expectations of products and services based on it; then it is crucial to communicate with consumers and to convince them of ce benefits (guldmann, 2016, p. 51). as far as ‘conversion from circular product design’ is concerned, it is worth noticing that the ce narrative, based on product/industry macro-loops such as product-life extension, redistribution and reuse, remanufacturing, recycling (urbinati et al., 2017) is not just a company matter. in fact, product design practices, e.g. design for recycling, design for remanufacturing and reuse, design for disassembly (mayyas, et al., 2012), as well as practices of product return or subscription to product service systems, where companies maintain the ownership of goods and consumer pay for their use (tukker, 2013), are pivotal to both product engineering, commercialization to final customers (urbinati et al., 2017) and ultimately for ce principles put in practice (moreno et al., 2016). they act on channeling and educating responsible consumption behaviours, not just at the purchasing but also at the use phase (bocken, 2017), and require companies-consumers close collaboration (mendoza et al., 2017). http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5098 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 15 4.1.3 impact on covid related issues considering shifts to ce that may occur in the production and consumption spheres, it is possible to hint some wishful impacts on economic, social and environmental issues/challenges generated by the covid crisis. five arrows denoted by letters link circular businesses with selected challenges deriving from the pandemic. in two cases the link starts from a specific stock (respectively ‘born circular businesses’ and ‘converted circular businesses’); in the other cases the positive impacts of circular business are not ascribable to certain processes of business creation/conversion and thus are modelled as descending from the ‘total circular businesses’ in general terms. the coronavirus economic turbolence hit all industry sectors and many entrepreneurial ventures struggle to survive, while social disparities are exacerbated and financial conditions of weak social groups result worsened, limiting entrepreneurship and self-entrepreurship diversity (neumeyer et al., 2020, p. 2). in the stock-and-flow structure, link a) relating ‘born circular businesses’ and covid issues, expresses the concept that the start-up of circular initiatives can be a mean for the empowerment of low-income people and the reduction of ‘financial inequalitities’ in society; whilst link e) to ‘business revitalization’ represents the opportunity disclosed by the ce paradigm for the relaunch of pre-existing businesses hit by the systemic crisis. in this regard, the implementation of ce principles at business level could be a source of competitive advantage for its connaturated efficiency recovery (ellen macarthur foundation & mckinsey, 2015), its capacity to intercept less price sensitive customer targets (morris et al., 2020), and its perspective opportunity to educate more and more people to the principles of responsible consumption (matthias et al., 2016; centobelli et al., 2020). in any case, the need for new products and services strictly related to the current safety concerns (e.g. single-use gloves and masks) and the demand of medical devices market, expected to grow by over 10% a year between 2020 and 2025 (blériot, 2020), create new entrepreneurial spaces (neumeyer et al., 2020). the auxiliary variable ‘total circular businesses’, resulting from the sum of the stocks of born circular and converted circular businesses, is connected with three impact variables: à ‘environmental awareness’ (link b): the diffusion of circular business, with its educational and environmental consciousness, may contribute to respond to the coronavirus-driven call to preserve the environment as a precondition for public health (wuyts et al., 2020, p. 2); http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5098 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 16 à ‘waste management’ (link c): the circular entrepreneurship transition can actively contribute to address the waste management challenges imposed by coronavirus (neumeyer et al., 2020). in fact, beside the temporary pollution’s decrease due to lockdowns, other dynamics are rising the waste production and greenhouse emissions all over the world. sarkis and colleagues’ concern (2020, p. 3) looks at environmental evolutions once production and transportation will return to pre-covid levels. actually, without appropriate measures, the environmental situation in the post-covid era will be even worse than before (climate action tracker, 2020). indeed, the crisis caused a significant increase in waste production both in the medical (wuyts et al., 2020) and non medical sectors, and a decrease in separate solid waste collection and recycling practices (ragazzi et al., 2020). the environmental problem also concerns the dispersion of single-use masks, the increased plastic waste generation due to a new reliance on plasticpackaged food and the use of disposable utensils in the fear of virus transmission (vanapalli et al., 2020). à ‘local productive resilience’ (link d): in the early phase of spreading, the pandemic has caused a generalized deceleration/close of economic activities and international trading. in this context, the crisis has disclosed the fragility of many global supply chains, included the medical equipment one (ranney et al., 2020). even though in later stages of covid diffusion the movements of people and goods have been restored, these dynamics led to questioning the “overreliance on just-in-time and lean delivery systems” (sarkis et al., 2020, p. 2), showing the need for more resilient supplies at a local level (blériot, 2020). thus, ce transition becomes almost an imperative route to improve local resilience by building more localized supply, production and consumption systems (sarkis et al., 2020, p. 2). looking at the medical sector as a first illustration, it is possible to learn important lessons about the elasticity of bottom-up initiatives by private companies and individual citizens (e.g. production of sanitizing liquid and masks) to recycle locally available resources, thereby reducing the dependency from importations (wuyts et al., 2020). 4.2 causal loop diagram the causal structure hypothesized for the relevant system is based on complex chains of relations among variables, generating loops of different length and complexity. then the stock-and-flow diagram presented above was synthesized in the cld in figure 3, made of 11 interacting feedback loops. since each loop http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5098 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 17 cointains just positive links, all the loops are reinforcing and distinguished from each other with a number following the r notation. the internal composition of each loop is reported in table 1 below. as noticeable, loops r1-r3 are made of two variables, whilst the others are made of five (loops r4, r5, r8, r9) or seven variables (r6, r7, r10, r11). loop r1 describes responsible consumers’ self-reinforcing dynamics due to word-of-mouth, loop r2 illustrates the mutual reinforce of circular start-ups and interfirm partnerships: ceteris paribus, more ‘born circular businesses’ will increase the opportunities of ‘interfirm circular partnerships’, which in turn will stimulate new business creation through the spreading of examples, ideas, standard and opportunities. similar structure in loop 3, with the difference that the links are between ‘interfirm circular partnerships’ and ‘converted circular businesses’. the remainder loops show how responsible consumption and circular start-ups can influence each other according to different chains of causality, which take into separate consideration the effects of circular product design and awareness raising initiatives, as well as the impact of responsible consumers’ enlargement, respectively on circular business creation and conversion. in loop r4 a rise in ‘responsible consumer’ has a boosting effect on the ‘willingness to become a circular entrepreneur’ and thus on ‘born circular businesses’ and ‘total circular businesses’. with the increase of circular businesses, also ‘conversion from circular product design’ will be stimulated, thus increasing the stock of ‘responsible consumers’. a similar circuit is contained in loop r5, with the trait that in this case the consumers’ learning process takes place by mean of awareness raising initiatives. loop r6 has a more complex chain: rising ‘responsible consumer’ will induce circular business start-ups, forging more interfirm partnerships able to boost linear business conversions. this fact will result in the total amount of circular businesses, thereby enhancing consumers ‘conversion from awareness raising initiatives’. figure 3. model’s causal loop diagram http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5098 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 18 source: author’s elaboration. loop r7 repeats the r6’s structure but considers the separate effect of ‘conversion from circular product design’. loops r8 and r9 describe the responsible consumption and circular conversion’s reciprocal stimulus, trained respectively by ‘conversion from awareness raising initiatives’ and ‘conversion from circular product design’. loops r10 and r11 portray other reinforcing dynamics: more ‘responsible consumers’ will push the ‘company willingness to go circular’ and then the ‘converted circular businesses’, which will rise ‘interfirm circular partnerships’ and, by this way, ‘born circular businesses’ and ‘total circular businesses’. the latter feed back into responsible consumption, respectively through the influence of awareness raising initiatives (r10) and the circular product design (r11). loop groups r2-r3, r6-r7 and r10-r11 contain as a driving force the variable ‘interfirm circular partnerships’, whose connotation is actually different in each couple: in the minor loops r2-r3 there are portrayed the separate effects of partnerships among homogeneous businesses: born circular in loop r2 and converted circular businesses in loop r3. in all the other cases the partnerships mix born and converted circular businesses. specifically, loops r6-r7 show how born circular businesses participating into http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5098 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 19 circular partnerships contribute to the conversion of linear businesses stimulating their circular innovation, whilst loops r10-r11 illustrate the value added by ‘converted circular businesses’ to the ‘interfirm circular partnerships’ and their inspiring effect on ‘born circular businesses’. table 1. model’s loops internal composition loop variables r1. responsible consumer à conversion from word of mouth r2. born circular businesses à interfirm circular partnerships r3. converted circular businesses à interfirm circular partnerships r4. responsible consumer à willingness to become a circular entrepreneur à born circular businesses à total circular businesses à conversion from awareness raising initiatives r5. responsible consumer à willingness to become a circular entrepreneur à born circular businesses à total circular businesses à conversion from circular product design r6. responsible consumer à willingness to become a circular entrepreneur à born circular businesses à interfirm circular partnerships à converted circular businesses à total circular businesses à conversion from awareness raising initiatives r7. responsible consumer à willingness to become a circular entrepreneur à born circular businesses à interfirm circular partnerships à converted circular businesses à total circular businesses à conversion from circular product design r8. responsible consumer à company willingness to go circular à converted circular businesses à total circular businesses à conversion from awareness raising initiatives r9. responsible consumer à company willingness to go circular à converted circular businesses à total circular businesses à conversion from circular product design r10. responsible consumer à company willingness to go circular à converted circular businesses à interfirm circular partnerships à born circular businesses à total circular businesses à conversion from awareness raising initiatives r11. responsible consumer à company willingness to go circular à converted circular businesses à interfirm circular partnerships à born circular businesses à total circular businesses à conversion from circular product design source: author’s elaboration 5. conclusion tackling the current pandemic as a “black swan” (e.g. halliburton, 2020; deloitte, 2020), i.e. an unprendictable event carrying a massive impact (taleb, 2007), the post-covid scenarios for policy making and socioeconomic development can be summarised by two antipodes. the first is to treat this occurrence as a “history accident”, to be overpassed through stimulus packages restoring the pre-covid, business-as-usual mode (bleriot, 2020). in alternative, the pandemic may be considered as an opportunity to learn from the pitfalls and shortages being experienced, creating the conditions for systemic robustness and local supply resilience. this work confirms how circular economy, already considered a catalyst for reaching sustainability goals (geissdoerfer et al., 2018; esposito et al., 2018) can be a promising paradigm to deal with coronavirus related challenges, fostering virtuous development paths. http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5098 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 20 in detail, the study contributes to the recent strategic management debate about ce, by proposing a system dynamics insight model to describe the basic mechanisms of circular business creation and diffusion, and their potential impact on covid issues. building on literature inputs, the model brings the novely to combine businesses and consumers’ perspectives together, postulating that the transition towards ce is a mirror process of “conversion” involving with specific features both actors. the resulting systemwide analysis completes and transcends the outputs of previous works on ce business applications, whose focus has been the separate analysis of these categories and the development of circular business models (linder & williander, 2017; bocken et al., 2016). the research also recognizes the relevance of consumer’s role, as well as the learning dynamics taking place in both consumers and companies (matthias et al., 2016; mendoza et al., 2017). the model building was iterative and the first research output was a stock-and-flow diagram stating a complex hypothesis about the causal structure of ce diffusion and its potential in alleviating the current systemic crisis. based on this, a comprehensive causal loop diagram synthesized self-reinforcing feedback mechanisms. making a distinction among “born circular” and “converted circular” businesses, the study has the merit to provide a holistic view about ce, integrating and inferring from multidisciplinary literature and emphasizing the interrelated key roles of circular entrepreneuship and consumption. according to the model, ce initiatives can be means to reduce financial inequalities and to revitalize existing firms through a recovery of efficiency (bocken et al., 2016; guldman, 2016), new opportunities to differentiate products (morris et al., 2020), and the perspective to “educate” their own demand to the principles of responsible consumption (matthias et al., 2016; centobelli et al., 2020). in addition, the stock of circular businesses has a boosting effect on environmental awareness, improves waste management, and stimulates productive resilience at a local level. although created by baring in mind the covid emergence, the model dynamics lay at a general level, and can be considered as valid insights to contribute to a more sustainable and circular economic system, less exposed to systemic risks. specifically, a number of self-reinforcing dynamics are described and disclose the potential triggering of virtuous loops, such as the enlargement of the responsible consumers’ stock due to word-of-mouth, circular product design and awareness raising initiatives, as well as the mutual stimuli of circular start-ups/conversions and interfirm partnerships. http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5098 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 21 in the end, the model illustrates the importance of stakeholders to accelerate companies’ transition to circularity, highlighting both the importance of partnerships with other companies and consumers, together with the role of regulations and incentives. for the planning and implemention of effective interventions supporting ce applications, policymakers need in first place to be aware of circular business dynamics (kirchherr et al., 2018) and their networking impact on public value (milios, 2018). thus, a holistic view appears necessary at both national and local level, in order to create an infrastructural tissue favoring ce, with public/public-private agencies capable to intercept (and properly manage) funds and skills devoted to circular business development, interfirms partneships and sensitization campaigns. however the study presents a series of limitations. first, the underlying literature was retrieved through google scholar engine, chosen for its multidisciplinarity and attitude to also include relevant nonscientific literature dealing with a novel and contemporaneous research topic. however, some publishers are not indexed in the database and citation data are over-estimated (mikki, 200; shultz, 2007). future research could furtherly validate and enlarge this work by performing new literature rounds on other databases, such as wos or scopus. furthermore, the proposed model is not tailored to a specific sector or business case, and does not concern neither functional aspects (organizational, technical and operational features related to the development of circular products/processes), nor sociocultural and technological factors (e.g. the effect of digital technologies on ce transition). the representation of circular business creation and conversion processes just refers to net rates of change in businesses’ stocks (bi-flows). this is a simplification not capturing circular business closures or “returns to linear”, as well as the factors affecting them. moreover, the circular business conversion does not consider the process graduality of circular business model testing. even the concept of circular efficiency, treated as an exogenous variable in the model, may disclose more complex dynamics of company experimental strategies, learning by doing processes and skill formation. thus, later studies could tailor the model to address sector-specific dynamics or identified business case studies, also considering the mentioned aspects not covered by the present research. so far, the impact variables refererred to covid issues are exogenous, i.e. they do not feed back to other parts of the model and just receive impulses from it. next model advancements could enclose more variables and bidirectional relationships in this sphere, in pace with a better understanding of the socioeconomic and environmental implications of the pandemic. http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5098 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 22 finally, the qualitative approach of this research calls for more investigations to test the model (or future versions of it) in the real world. references apostolopoulos, n., al-dajani, h., holt, d., jones, p., & newbery, r. (2018). entrepreneurship and the sustainable development goals. contemporary issues in entrepreneurship research, 8, 1-7. blériot, j. (2020). the covid-19 recovery requires a resilient circular economy. retrieved from: https://circulareconomy.europa.eu/platform/en/knowledge/covid-19-recovery-requires-resilientcircular-economy bocken, n. (2017). business-led sustainable consumption initiatives: impacts and lessons learned. journal of management development, 36(1), 81-96. bocken, n.m.p, de pauw, i., bakker, c., & van der grinten, b. (2016). product design and business model strategies for a circular economy. journal of industrial and production engineering, 33(5), 308– 320. braungart, m., mcdonough, m., & bollinger, a. (2007). cradle-to-cradle design: creating healthy emissions. a strategy for eco-effective product and system design. journal of cleaner production, 15, 1337-1348. centobelli, p., cerchione, r., chiaroni, d., del vecchio, p., & urbinati, a. (2020). designing business models in circular economy: a systematic literature review and research agenda. business strategy and the environment, 29, 1734-1749. chamberlin, l., & boks, c. (2018). marketing approaches for a circular economy: using design frameworks to interpret online communications. sustainability, 10, 2070-2096. climate action tracker (2020). a government roadmap for addressing the climate and post covid19 economic crises. retrieved from: https://climateactiontracker.org/documents/706/cat_2020-0427_briefing_covid19_apr2020.pdf crainer, s. (2013). squaring the circle. business strategy review, 24(4), 13-19. d’aveni, r. (2010). beating the commodity trap. harward business press, boston. dean, t.j., & mcmullen, j.s. (2007). toward a theory of sustainable entrepreneurship: reducing environmental degradation through entrepreneurial action. journal of business venturing, 22(1), 5076. http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5098 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 23 de jesus, a., & mendonça, s. (2018). lost in transition? drivers and barriers in the ecoinnovation road to the circular economy. ecological economics, 145, 75-89. deloitte (2020). covid-19: a black swan event for the semiconductor industry? retrieved from: https://www2.deloitte.com/content/dam/deloitte/us/documents/technology-mediatelecommunications/us-tmt-covid-19-a-black-swan-event-for-the-semiconductor-industry.pdf de winter j.c., zadpoor, a.a., & dodou d. (2014). the expansion of google scholar versus web of science: a longitudinal study. scientometrics, 98, 1547-1565. ellen macarthur foundation (2013). towards the circular economy vol. 1. retrieved from: https://www.ellenmacarthurfoundation.org/assets/downloads/publications/ellen-macarthurfoundation-towards-the-circular-economy-vol.1.pdf ellen macarthur foundation (2015). circularity indicators: an approach to measuring circularity. retrieved from: https://www.ellenmacarthurfoundation.org/assets/downloads/insight/circularityindicators_project-overview_may2015.pdf ellen macarthur foundation (2020). the built environment two circular investment opportunities towards a resilient low-carbon economic recovery. retrieved from: https://www.ellenmacarthurfoundation.org/assets/downloads/the-built-environment.pdf ellen macarthur foundation & mckinsey (2015). growth within: a circular economy vision for a competitive europe. retrieved from: https://www.mckinsey.com/businessfunctions/sustainability/our-insights/growth-within-a-circular-economy-vision-for-a-competitiveeurope esposito, m., tse, t., & soufani, k. (2018). introducing a circular economy: new thinking with new managerial and policy implications. california management review, 60(3), 5-19. european commission (2015). closing the loop an eu action plan for the circular economy. 2.12.2015 com(2015) 614, european commission, brussels. european commission (2019). the european green deal. 11.12.2019 com(2019)640, european commission, brussels. european commission (2020). a new circular economy action plan for a cleaner and more competitive europe. 11.3.2020 com(2020) 98, european commission, brussels. european environment agency (2019). sustainability transitions: policy and practice, eea report no 9/2019. eea, copenhagen. http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5098 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 24 forrester j.w. (1961) industrial dynamics. the mit press, cambridge. reprinted by pegasus communications, waltham. geissdoerfer, m., savaget, p., bocken, n.m.p., & hultink, e.j. (2017). the circular economy – a new sustainability paradigm? journal of cleaner production, 143, 757-768. geissdoerfer, m., morioka, s.n., monteiro de carvalho, m., & evans, s. (2018). business models and supply chains for the circular economy. journal of cleaner production, 190, 712-721. graedel, t.e. (1996). on the concept of industrial ecology. annual review of energy and the environment, 21, 69-98. grimmer, m., & woolley, m. (2012). green marketing messages and consumers’ purchase intentions: promoting personal versus environmental benefits. journal of marketing communications, 20, 231-250. guldmann, e. (2016). best practice examples of circular business models. the danish environmental protection agency, copenaghen. haddaway, n.r., collins, a.m. coughlin, d., & kirk, s. (2015). the role of google scholar in evidence reviews and its applicability to grey literature searching. plos one, 10(9), 1-17. halliburton, b.c. (2020). covid-19 is a black swan. forbes, march 19th. retrieved from: https://www.forbes.com/sites/forbesbooksauthors/2020/03/19/covid-19-is-a-blackswan/#66d7b56d7b4b katz, r.l. (1970). cases and concepts in corporate strategy, prentice-hall, englewood cliffs, nj. kirchherr, j., piscicelli, l., bour, r., kostense-smit, e., muller, j., huibrechtse-truijens, a., & hekkert, m. (2018). barriers to the circular economy: evidence from the european union. ecological economics, 150, 264–272. kirchherr, j., reike, d., & hekkert, m. (2017). conceptualizing the circular economy: an analysis of 114 definitions. resources, conservation and recycling, 127, 221–232. korhonen, j., nuur, c., feldmann, a., & birkie, s.e (2018). circular economy as an essentially contested concept. journal of cleaner production, 175, 544-552. linder, m., & williander, m. (2017). circular business model innovation: inherent uncertainties. business strategy and the environment, 26(2), 182-196. maier, f.h. (1998). new product diffusion models in innovation management. a system dynamics perspective. system dynamics review, 14(4), 285-308. http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5098 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 25 mayyas, a., qattawia, a., omara, m., & shana, d. (2012). design for sustainability in automotive industry: a comprehensive review. renewable and sustainable energy reviews, 16, 1845-1862. matthias, l., mont, o., & heiskanen, e. (2016). nudging: a promising tool for sustainable consumption behavior? journal of cleaner production, 134, 166-177. mcdonough, w., & braungart, m. (2003). toward a sustaining architecture for the 21st century: the promise of cradle-to-cradle design. industry and environment, 26, 13-16. mendoza, j. m. f., sharmina, m., gallego-schmid, a., heyes, g., & azapagic, a. (2017). integrating backcasting and eco-design for the circular economy: the bece framework. journal of industrial ecology, 21(3), 526-544. mikki, s. (2009). google scholar compared to web of science: a literature review. nordic journal of information literacy in higher education, 1(1), 41-51. milios, l. (2018). advancing to a circular economy: three essential ingredients for a comprehensive policy mix. sustain sci, 13, 861-878. mintzberg, h. (1987). the strategy concept i: five ps for strategy. california management review, 30(1), 11-24. morecroft, j.d.w. (1984). strategy support models. strategic management journal, 5(3), 215–229. moreno, m., de los rios, c., rowe, z., & charnley, f. (2016). a conceptual framework for circular design. sustainability, 8(9), 1-15. morris, m.h., santos, s.c., neumeyer, x. (2020). entrepreneurship as a solution to poverty in developed economies. business horizons, 63(3), 377-390. neumeyer, x., s. ashton, w.s., &, dentchev, n. (2020). addressing resource and waste management challenges imposed by covid-19: an entrepreneurship perspective. resources, conservation & recycling, 162, 1-3. osterwalder, a., & pigneur, y. (2010). business model generation. john wiley & sons, hoboken. ragazzi, m., rada, e. c., & schiavon, m. (2020). municipal solid waste management during the sars-cov-2 outbreak and lockdown ease: lessons from italy. science of the total environment, 745, 1-6. ranney, m.l., griffeth, v., jha, a.k. (2020). critical supply shortages-the need for ventilators and personal protective equipment during the covid-19 pandemic. the new england journal of medicine, 382(18), 41-43. http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5098 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 26 saadat, s., rawtani, d., & hussain, c.m. (2020). environmental perspective of covid-19. science of the total environment, 728, 1-6. sarkis, j., cohen, m. j., dewick, p., & schröder, p. (2020). a brave new world: lessons from the covid-19 pandemic for transitioning to sustainable supply and production. resources, conservation & recycling, 159, 1-5. sharma, h.b., vanapalli, k., cheela, vr.s., ranjan, v.p., jaglan, a.k., … bhattacharya, j. (2020). challenges, opportunities, and innovations for effective solid waste management during and post covid9 pandemic. resources, conservation & recycling, 162, 1-12. shultz, m. (2007). comparing test searches in pubmed and google scholar. journal of the medical library association, 95, 442-445. sneader, k., & singhal, s. (2020). beyond coronavirus: the path to the next normal. mckinsey & company. retrieved from: https://www.mckinsey.com/industries/healthcare-systems-andservices/our-insights/beyond-coronavirus-the-path-to-the-next-normal sterman, j.d. (2000). business dynamics systems thinking and modeling for a complex world, first edition. mcgraw-hill companies, new york. taleb, n.n. (2007). the black swan. the impact of the highly improbable. the random house publishing group, new york. tukker, a. (2013). product services for a resource-efficient and circular economy: a review. journal of cleaner production, 97, 76-91. tullberg, j. (2012). triple bottom line a vaulting ambition? business ethics, 21, 310-324. united nations general assembly (2015). transforming our world: the 2030 agenda for sustainable development. resolution a/70/l.1. urbinati, a., chiaroni, d., & chiesa, v. (2017). towards a new taxonomy of circular economy business models. journal of cleaner production, 168, 487-498. vanapalli, k.r., sharma, h.b., ranjan, v.p, samal, b., bhattacharya, j., … goel, s. (2020) challenges and strategies for effective plastic waste management during and post covid-19 pandemic. science of the total environment, 750, 1-10. veleva, v., & bodkin, g. (2018). corporate-entrepreneur collaborations to advance a circular economy. journal of cleaner production, 188, 20-37. http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5098 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 27 wang, w.t. (2011). system dynamics modelling for examining knowledge transfer during crises. systems research and behavioral studies, 28, 105-127. warren, k. (2005). improving strategic management with the fundamental principles of system dynamics. system dynamics review, 21(4), 329-350. wolstenholme, e. (1990). system enquiry: a system dynamics approach. wiley, chichester. world commission on environment and development (1987). brundtland report. our common future. oxford university press, oxford. wuyts, w., marin, j., brusselaers, j., & vrancken, k. (2020). circular economy as a covid-19 cure? resources, conservation & recycling, 162, 1-2. yang, m., evans, s., vladimirova, d., & rana, p. (2016). value uncaptured perspective for sustainable business model innovation. journal of cleaner production, 140(3), 1794-1804. zott, c., & amit, r. (2010). business model design: an activity system perspective. long range planning, 43(2), 216-226. microsoft word 3 audrone edited.docx http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi 10.13135/2704-9906/5091 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 48 wises’ social impact measurement in the baltic states audrone urmanaviciene1 1 school of governance, law and society, tallinn university e-mail: aurmana@tlue.ee received: 13/09/2020 revised: 09/10/2020 accepted for publication: 12/10/2020 published: 26/10/2020 abstract wises devote most of their time and resources to working with the target group not only organizing their employment activities and developing skills, but also adapting their work environment, improving the psychological climate, organizational culture, etc. thus, the implementation of the social mission of this type of social enterprise requires a particularly large amount of time and other resources. in addition, they have to take care of the financial sustainability of their organization. however, wises as all social enterprises face the pressure from the society and other stakeholders to measure their social impact. nevertheless, it is also important to note that scientists still disagree on the definition of social impact. it is noteworthy that there are no common criteria for measuring social impacts and there are many different methods and tools for impact assessment and measurement (arena et al. al., 2015; hadad and găucă, 2014). thus, it remains unclear what and how wises should measure their social impact. however, it can be argued that social impact measurement it’s very important for the wise itself. the aim of this article to identify what and how wises should measure their social impact in the organization. the methods of the research are an analysis of scientific literature and experts’ interview. the results of the research disclosed the possible measurement framework and indicators. ___________________________________________________________________________ http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi 10.13135/2704-9906/5091 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 49 keywords: agent-based banking model; circular economy; financial inclusion; sustainability; transformation ___________________________________________________________________________ 1. introduction the initiatives of work integration social enterprises (wises) in europe date back to the 1970s, when civil society actors rushed to find ways to help people excluded from the labor market and unable to enter it (nyssens, 2014). the main purpose of such social enterprise is to help integrate persons experiencing exclusion and belonging to socially vulnerable groups through organized theoretical and practical professional training and/or development of work skills; this is common to all wises (cooney, 2011). training and educational process, through on-the-job training, other training, experimental training, mentoring, are the most important aspects of all types of work integration social enterprises (barraket, 2013). in eu countries, wises mainly work with people with disabilities, the long-term unemployed and the low-skilled, refugees and immigrants, those with extremely low employment opportunities for various reasons (davister, defourny, grégoire, 2004). such groups of persons are also called social enterprise target groups, i. y. groups targeted by integration programs and employment activities of wises. there are many models and forms of wises in the eu. it is one of the oldest forms of social enterprises in the eu. the origins of wises in the baltic states date back to soviet times, as at that time there were various “combines” of the disabled blind and deaf people which employed these target groups. after the restoration of independence of the baltic states, these organizations were privatized and some continued to operate. however, many of these enterprises have the priority of making a profit and, therefore, they are inconsistent with the modern concept of social business, according to which the integration of both social vulnerable groups and economic-financial sustainability should be equally important for a social enterprise. after the baltic states acceded the eu, in 2004, efforts were made to harmonize the baltics policy with the eu policy; this led to the adoption, in the same year, of the law on social enterprises of the republic of lithuania. this law encouraged the employment of persons with various disabilities (not only the deaf and blind) and other vulnerable persons; it thus expanded the potential target group by enlarging the list of vulnerable groups concerned. as a result, many social enterprises of this type http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi 10.13135/2704-9906/5091 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 50 came into existence after the law was passed in lithuania. in latvia and estonia, no social law has been adopted to support companies that employ vulnerable people, so many wises have operated in the non-governmental sector. in latvia, only in 2018, the law on social enterprises entered into force, a private limited liability company (pllc) may be considered a social enterprise, if it is granted the status of a social enterprise by the law and which carries out economic activities with a positive social impact (e.g. provision of social services, the formation of inclusive civil society, promotion of education, support for science, environmental protection and conservation, protection of animals or contribution to cultural diversity). so far, no law on social enterprises has been adopted in estonia. thus, the practice has developed that de jure and de facto wises have started operating in the baltic states. de jure social enterprises can benefit from various privileges, such as tax advantages and subsidies. de facto social enterprises are usually non-profit organizations in the baltic states, having acquired the legal status of foundations and associations, and they try to apply various business models in their activities. it should be noted that such enterprises are not legally recognized, therefore they cannot enjoy the privileges provided for in the laws on social enterprises. such companies are forced to diversify their income to remain economically stable, i. y. seek additional sources of income, such as esf project funds, etc. it is important to note that the main goal of many de jure wises operating in lithuania is to make a profit, not the integration of persons belonging to the vulnerable groups, therefore these enterprises are not considered the object of this study. wises are not required to measure their impact, this obligation is voluntary, therefore the social value they create in society is not known, there is a lack of data on the impact of these enterprises in the baltic states. the social impact assessment is of particular importance for these companies, according to epstein and yuthas (2014), the implementation of measurement system in the organization is very important in its absence, there is a high risk that financial resources, time, and other resources invested in the activities of the organization are wasted. thus, for the resources invested in social business to be used purposefully – to implement the social mission and to create certain changes in society, it is important to monitor the social impact created by enterprises. also, it is important to mention the case of de jure social enterprises in lithuania, where state support is provided to enterprises (various benefits and subsidies), but no mandatory social impact measurements have been established. thus, in the absence of publicly available data on the impact of these enterprises, there has been a great deal of debate in the society about the loss of their social http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi 10.13135/2704-9906/5091 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 51 mission and the dominance of commercial objectives. there were also several cases where these enterprises fictitiously covered up the implementation of a social mission to benefit from state support. therefore, it is considered that data from regular and systematic social impact measurements can help to ensure that commercial objectives do not become dominant, thus maintaining the dual mission of a social business enterprise. moreover, in post-soviet countries where social capital is not large enough, dual-mission organizations are still difficult for the public to understand, and various speculations about the activities of these organizations are possible. however, to avoid such situations, measuring the social impact of social business acquires an important role in creating a sustainable emerging social business sector and in building public confidence in the activities of these organizations. to ensure the sustainable development of this sector, the successful social integration of people belonging to vulnerable groups, it is important to determine how wises should measure their social impact. scientists from the baltic states study wises in their works: in lithuania (neverauskienė, moskvina, 2011), latvia (oborenko, rivza, zivitere, 2018), estonia (raudsaar, kaseorg, 2013). however, it should be noted that research on their effects and how to measure them in the baltic states is still lacking. there is a significant knowledge gap in the measurement of wises' social impact in the baltic states. accordingly, finding indicators for measurement will be beneficial for the wises and their stakeholders. the expert interview was selected to interview individuals who are experts in social enterprises, social impact measurement and its implementation, with exceptional specific knowledge and experience, and sufficiently detailed information on the research problem. the rest of the paper is organised as followed. the next paragraph will analysis literature review on wises social impact measurement. the third paragraph will describe methodology adopted by the researcher. additionally, the fourth paragraph will reveal the main results of study and present discussion. finally, the last section will conclude the paper. 2. measuring the social impact of work integration social enterprises wises differ in their objectives, size, target groups with which they work, employment and social inclusion programs, resources available, etc., for example, some wises take care of the temporary employment of target groups facing difficulties in the labor market and public life, so that they can integrate into the open labor market as soon as possible, others consolidate types which offer longhttp://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi 10.13135/2704-9906/5091 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 52 term jobs to such unemployed people so that they can acquire social and professional skills and become independent, the third type is dominated by enterprises which main purpose is to socialize people through certain employment activities, etc. (neverauskienė and moskvina, 2011). yet, all of them are united by the aim of helping to integrate the people belonging to the target groups into society through organized work activities and/or internships, training, providing them with the missing work and social skills and/or profession. the creation of employment activities or jobs for such people often requires the creation and adaptation of a suitable working environment. there is a need to create an environment in which these people can successfully adapt and learn: the workplace needs to be adapted, the services of a personal assistant are often needed, and these enterprises often have to give time to train other employees. however, their activities are not limited to the development of work skills or vocational training. the problems faced by people in target groups are not just that people do not have a job but often cover a wide range of issues, from a lack of basic social skills to a lack of items such as clothes (krutulienė, pocius, gruževskis, okunevičiūtėneverauskienė, junevičius, 2017). of course, the difficulties of different target groups, for example, single parents, are different from other target groups, such as the homeless. they need constant support and attention to successfully integrate into the labor market. to successfully integrate people into the labor market, it is often necessary to motivate and counsel them, or provide other labor market integration services (e. g. job search). for a person to be fully integrated into the society, other services and constant support for target groups are also needed. such assistance often includes organizing the help of psychologists and social workers, providing other social services (accommodation, reimbursement of transport costs, work with families), the organization of sociocultural and leisure activities. successful integration of individuals into society requires additional resources and time from wises. it should be noted, however, that in recent years, as a result of declining eu support and gaps in national budgets, countries have increasingly reduced subsidies, such as moving from permanent to temporary subsidies or leaving only certain tax incentives to companies. wises are increasingly inclined to look for innovative ways to achieve financial sustainability by earning income from the goods created or services sold on the market and to be independent of the aids granted by states. so usually these organizations combine two different logics commercial and social. organizations that combine several different logics in the scientific literature are called hybrid organizations (battilana, dorado, 2010, iannaci, 2020). many wises are increasingly moving towards hybrid organizations (iannaci, 2020). however, often even when an http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi 10.13135/2704-9906/5091 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 53 organization receives most of its market revenue, it needs state aid to successfully fulfil its social mission-enterprises need not only to organize employment activities for individuals, but also to provide additional resources for workplace and environmental adaptation, integration into the labor market or provision of other services as only complex assistance changes individuals’ values, attitudes towards life, strengthens motivation to integrate into the labor market and society. during the social impact assessment process, the organization measures, analyzes, monitors and publicizes the changes created by the planned activities of the social enterprise. the purpose of the social impact assessment process is to manage and control the impact created to increase or optimize it. the assessment process consists of the following stages: setting assessment aims, involving stakeholders, planning, measuring, collecting and analyzing data, presenting results and learning from them. the social impact assessment process in a social enterprise is a continuous process of learning and activity improvement, the result of which is setting new assessment aims and the improvement of processes in the organization. wises are often organizations with limited financial and human resources and devote most of their time to working with target groups and achieving financial sustainability. as a result, company managers and staff often lack time to measure their impact – to use quantitative or qualitative methods. there is a lack of a culture of measuring social impact in these organizations. managers often feel that they are helping people, so why some additional measurements are still needed. there is a lack of understanding that social impact measurements help to provide evidence to the public, funders, and other stakeholders. many wises do not implement social impact measurement because they simply do not know what to measure: their direct results, impact on beneficiaries or also wider impact on their communities and society; and how to measure: should they use quantitative or qualitative methods; what indicators should be measured; however, the implementation of measurement in the organization is very important because, measurement can help identify programs that are not effective in integrating vulnerable individuals into society. also, it can help to make better decisions in the organization. it should be noted that selecting the most appropriate measurement methodology and/or measurement indicators requires special knowledge and competencies, which enterprise employees often lack, and financial constraints prevent from hiring private companies to perform such measurements or additional human resources to do this work. the social impact is understood and described very differently by both researchers and practitioners (ebrahim and rangan, 2010). there is no common definition of social impact. according to zeyen, http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi 10.13135/2704-9906/5091 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 54 beckmann (2018), some argue that impact should include only the target group (individual beneficiary perspective) whereas others argue that it should include their community and wider society (systemic context perspective). due to the sheer diversity of impact understandings, contexts, there are numerous impact measurement tools. all of them are very different in their goals, time perspective, orientation, perspective, micro-, meso-, macro-level (maas and liket, 2011). the lack of a single common methodology and the large number of tools available, according to grieco (2015), complicate the implementation of social impact assessment in an organization, as social entrepreneurs face obstacles in choosing the best approach for their organization from such diversity. many wises tend to use a storytelling method on social networks and websites to describe the success stories of their clients when the stories and impressions of program participants are told. such stories are communicated through discussions with clients, consumers, or through the observations of the professionals in the field. such stories are usually based on subjective opinions. thus, not all such stories are reliable, it is considered that storytelling is not sufficient for a comprehensive understanding of the organization's activities. according to epstein, yuthas (2014), when such a method is used by professionals, such stories can often provide valuable evidence of success or challenge. however, they lack to prove these stories by evidences. wises should seek to provide more systematic evidence of success, storytelling should be only the basis, and additional qualitative or quantitative research methods should be included. quantitative measurements should be performed by analyzing large amounts of data and reporting those data in numerical form. this usually includes direct measurements such as questionnaires. this approach is chosen most often because sponsors and investors require performance to be quantified and presented. quantitative measurements allow to better compare the activities performed by organizations and the achieved results. as a consequence, various impact measurement tools were adapted from business such as the social balanced score card, social cost-benefit analysis, or social return on investment (arena, azzone, and bengo 2015, biancone at al, 2020). the social return on investment (sroi) approach has emerged as a preferred quantitative social impact measurement tool (arena, azzone, and bengo 2015). sroi, as an example of a quantitative tool, has a high potential for comparability but poses challenges to social enterprises during implementation (biancone at al, 2020). quantitative performance indicators are widely criticized for several reasons not all benefits generated by an organization can be quantified or presented in financial terms (grieco et al., 2014). hadad and găucă (2014) point out that it is particularly difficult to financially http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi 10.13135/2704-9906/5091 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 55 express psychological changes which occur in the lives of people belonging to vulnerable groups, such as increased self-confidence or greater dignity (hadad and găucă, 2014). wise’s activities are focused on creating change for vulnerable groups of individuals, so it is thought that it can be difficult to measure and assess only quantitatively. this is due to the qualitative nature of the social impact itself (mass, liket, 2011). moreover, mostly quantitative measurement methods are expensive, complex, time-consuming, and require special competencies. according to costa and pesci (2016), grieco (2017), quantitative methods for measuring impact are particularly demanding for large-scale internal and external data collection and statistical analysis. therefore, the scientific literature pays more and more attention to qualitative research – the applicability of theory of change and chain of change/logical model (hornsby, 2012; epstein, yuth, 2014; spiess-knalf and scheck, 2017; zeyen, beckmann, 2018). this methodology outlines the chain of change of an organization, and causally links the organization's activities with short-term, outcome, and impact results. theory of change helps determine which actions and interventions create the desired change (hornsby, 2012). this defines the problem, the target population, the assumptions on which the decision is based, and the intended results. it is first decided what changes are to be created, what activities are being carried out to achieve these aims, and finally, it is checked whether the activities will create the desired changes. the methodology of theory of change, compared to other standardized methodologies such as sroi or cost-benefit analysis, which require the application of complex statistical analysis, is based on the application of qualitative research (spiess-knafl, scheck, 2017; zeyen, beckmann, 2018), as well as provides a visual explanation of the process of change. this methodology allows you to provide detailed descriptions of how and why the desired change will be achieved. theory of change is implemented using a logical model/ impact value chain (ebrahim, 2019) (see table 1). measurement indicators are set using a logic model. this is often a major challenge for an organization. http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi 10.13135/2704-9906/5091 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 56 table 1. impact value chain inputs activities outputs outcomes impact what is put into the activity, i. y. resources, etc. activities performed by the organization (provision of services, production of goods) results that come directly from the activities carried out (direct achievements of the activity) changes (results of the activity) that occur for the beneficiaries during medium and long term activity of an organization changes (results of the activity) that occur for the community or society during medium and long term activity of an organization source: compiled by the authors based on ebrahim and rangan, 2010; epstein, yuthas, 2014; crucke, decramer, 2016; spiess-knafl and scheck, 2017 thus, the scientific discussion devotes a lot of space to the discussion on the definition of social impacts, measurement methodologies and tools, but there is little analysis of how much wises are able to perform the assessment and at what level (ebrahim (2014), crucke, decramer (2016). epstein and yuthas (2014) note that many enterprises measure outputs because it makes it easier for organizations to collect this data, i.e., how many trainings are organized, how many people are employed. ebrahim (2014) argues that in some cases a social enterprise should focus on measuring direct achievements rather than long-term outcomes because the enterprise may focus too much on the measurement process and intended outcomes and thus deviate from its direct social activities. other researchers argue that a social enterprise should measure impact, the ultimate change in impact value creation chain which occurs in the society or community in the long or medium-term perspective of an organization. for example, reduced unemployment, poverty, crime, fundamental changes in social norms and attitudes in the society. however, it is important to note that in many cases, such changes can only occur after a long period, making them very difficult to detect and assess. also, there must be a direct and clear causal link among all these elements of impact value chain (ebrahim and rangan, 2014). ebrahim points out that the causal link between outputs and outcomes is not always direct and clear, and that outcomes and impacts sometimes occur not as a result of the activities of a social enterprise, but because of other environmental factors, such as the activities of other organizations operating in the same field. in their research, ebrahim and rangan (2014) noted that social impact, created at the societal level (macro, meso-level) e.g. such as reduced unemployment and crime, is rarely achieved by one organization, usually, it is the collective impact http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi 10.13135/2704-9906/5091 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 57 of several organizations. according to grieco (2015), to understand the social impact created by social enterprises, it is necessary to at least move from the measurement of the perspective of output in the logical chain to the measurement of the perspective of outcome (hehenberger et al., 2013). outcomes are already broader changes that occur in the short and medium-term of an enterprise's activities, which is the meaning of measurement to analyze how outputs affect individuals and broader environment groups of individuals and communities. thus, there are many discussions how and what wises should measure, however it is not clear what wises can measure according to their resources and capacity. the ambiguity of what should be measured often lead to a situation when wises are not implementing social impact measurement in their organizations. thus, it is therefore considered necessary to identify possible measurement framework to remove ambiguities as to what should be measured. the research, based on a logical chain, will analyze what wise should measure to implement an impact assessment in an organization. 3. methodology the selection of the research participants. in the expert interview to select competent respondents who can offer possible measurement framework, the informants of the research were selected using a targeted selection method (knowledge, work experience, relationship with the studied phenomenon is the most important). the population of the informants of the research consists of lithuanian, latvian and estonian experts, selected in similar proportions from each of the baltic countries, to objectively reveal how to measure the social impact of wises. according to nonprobabilistic target selection, three groups of experts were selected to participate, who differ in their experience, level of academic knowledge, nature of work and relationship with the research object (babbie, 2005). groups selected for the research: • the first group: representatives of the academic world, who have a degree of at least a doctorate, work in baltic universities, conduct research on social enterprise development, social innovation and social entrepreneurship, study aspects of social enterprise activities in the baltic states for at least three years. http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi 10.13135/2704-9906/5091 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 58 • the second group: representatives of the authorities in the baltic states, forming a suitable environment for social entrepreneurship and/or wises and implementing employment policies for the target groups in the baltic states, have at least three years of work experience in these fields. • the third group: representatives of umbrella (social business, organizations connecting social enterprises) and business innovation development, incubation processes (incubator) organizations working in the field of social business and social entrepreneurship development, with at least two years of work experience. during the expert interviews, 15 experts (5 from each of the baltic states) meeting the selection criteria listed here were interviewed. organization of the qualitative research. expert interviews were conducted using the methods of direct and distance interviews. the form of distance interviews was applied to latvian and estonian experts because they requested this method. interviews were conducted in the form of semi-structured interviews; i. y. possible questions were anticipated through which interviews with experts were conducted. the empirical research was conducted in 2018 mayseptember. the methodology of qualitative research recommends that the experts choose whether to remain anonymous or to publish their names (kaiser, 2009). depending on the request of many experts, the names of the experts are not provided, and when quoting the expert's statement, his/her number is indicated. the list of experts and the description of the characteristics justifying their competence are presented in table 2. it should be noted that when describing experts, to ensure their anonymity, experts are described using the masculine gender, as accepted by reference to positions, degrees or other depersonalized data. http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi 10.13135/2704-9906/5091 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 59 table 2. the list of respondents to the expert research lithuania expert‘s code characteristics substantiating the competence of an expert ex_lt_1 head of the lithuanian work integration state institution. management experience for this institution 3 years, professional experience in the field of work integration 12 years. ex_lt_2 professor of one of the lithuanian state universities. more than 10 years of experience in researching and teaching community development, ngo, social innovation, third sector disciplines. the expert has been researching the field of social entrepreneurship for 5 years. ex_lt_3 head of the lithuanian branch of the international organization working with the implementation of the activities of the social business incubator and head of the public institution implementing the social business promotion programs. work experience working in the field of social business 7 years. ex_lt_4 specialist of the ministry supervising the national economy, working with the formation of social enterprises and social business policy, work experience in this field 5 years. this expert also conducts research and is preparing a dissertation on social business in the field of law. ex_lt_5 project manager of an institution working with the development of social business and its enlargement in lithuania. professional experience in the field of social business 3 years. latvia expert characteristics substantiating the competence of an expert ex_lv_1 specialist of the ministry working with the european union funded social entrepreneurship project in latvia. work experience in this project 3 years. ex_lv_2 doctor of social sciences. lecturer in entrepreneurship at one of latvia's universities. manager of a creative business incubator. more than 5 years of experience in researching and teaching social entrepreneurship, social innovations, business incubation process disciplines. ex_lv_3 doctor of social sciences. professor at one of latvia's state universities. more than 4 years of experience in researching and teaching social entrepreneurship. defended a dissertation on social entrepreneurship in 2014. published a book on social entrepreneurship. ex_lv_4 doctor of social sciences, lecturer, innovation expert. project manager of the latvian centre for social innovation. developer and curator of many projects http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi 10.13135/2704-9906/5091 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 60 in the field of social entrepreneurship. one of the most important projects being implemented is the platform of social business support institutions for the baltic states. work experience in the field of social innovation more than 10 years. ex_lv_5 head of umbrella social enterprise organization. work experience working with communication projects, non-governmental organizations, social enterprise projects not less than two years. estonia expert characteristics substantiating the competence of an expert ex_est_1 head of the employment policy department at the ministry. management experience for the department 3 years. experience in the sphere of employment 10 years. ex_est_2 board member and executive position in the estonian association of social enterprises. work experience in the association 6 years. since 2006 works with the concepts of social impact analysis. since 2015 until now is a member of the european commission's expert group on social entrepreneurship geces. ex_est_3 doctor of social sciences, professor. lecturer in social entrepreneurship at one of estonia's state universities. defended a dissertation on social entrepreneurship. more than 5 years of experience in teaching and researching social entrepreneurship. ex_est_4 doctor of agricultural sciences, founder of training and social entrepreneurship development companies in scotland and estonia, as well as training in social business development across the eu, works as a senior researcher at an estonian university. ex_est_5 doctor of social sciences, developer and head of the social entrepreneurship program at one of the estonian universities. 12 years of experience working in an ngo, social business sector. more than 5 years of experience in teaching and researching social enterprises in europe, asia. source: compiled by the author it is considered that the characteristics of the experts sufficiently substantiate their competence in researching how the social impact assessment of social enterprises should be implemented. formulation of research questions for experts. the expert interview consists of a partially structured questionnaire. how important is social impact assessment for wise and society? how do you think wise should measure its impact? what indicators should be used? http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi 10.13135/2704-9906/5091 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 61 analysis and processing of the results of the qualitative research. qualitative content analysis was applied to the analysis of the data obtained during the expert interviews, as well as to the abovementioned management interviews (berg, 2007; žydžiūnaitė, sabaliauskas, 2017). during the qualitative content analysis, the features of the text were systematically examined, and then reliable conclusions were formulated. the data were processed using the computer program "atlas.ti", performing primary and axial coding (charmaz, 2006). primary coding is performed using action categories. in the second stage, axial coding was performed by constructing the relationships between the categories and their aspects, which are identified as important for the analysis of the investigated phenomenon, i. y. the created categories are joined into main categories (charmaz, 2006). 4. empirical research findings and discussion the scientific literature (grieco, 2015; epstein, yuth, 2014; zeyen, beckmann, 2018; iannaci, 2020) highlights the following main reasons why social enterprises need to implement social impact assessment in their organizations: building collaborative relationships; accountability to stakeholders; better management decision making, creation of a learning environment in the organization. during the research in the interviews, the baltic experts did not mention the creation of a learning environment in the organization and cooperation as important reasons for conducting a social impact assessment in the organization. experts emphasized that social impact assessment is an important means of communication for the organization with stakeholders: it is a useful tool for building the good reputation of a social enterprise in the society and for communicating with various stakeholders: the media, local authorities, investors, customers, etc. (ex_lv_3). respondents also indicated that social impact assessment can be used as a marketing tool to increase sales of organizations’ goods or services: i would rather order, or buy products from the enterprise which carries out the impact assessment, because i know that when i buy a product or services from that enterprise, i have an impact on society as a citizen (ex_lt_2). the other reason is to check whether the planned aims of the company have been achieved: social impact assessment is a verification whether i have achieved my aim, whether my mission has been achieved, whether my aims and visions are working (ex_lt_2). also, according to the respondents, social impact assessment is important for the organization for the financial reasons: it helps not only to account to the financiers for the provided funds, but also attract new investors, financiers: being transparent and credible can attract more investors (ex_lt_5); if you actually work very well and create a social impact, you can go to the http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi 10.13135/2704-9906/5091 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 62 funders with that data and be able to present those results. this can help attract funding (ex_lt_3). respondents noted that impact assessment is important not only for social enterprises but also for their stakeholders. when providing funds to social enterprises, funders are often interested in how and to whom their funds are used, what impact is created: the financier wants to know if the money is disposed properly (ex_lt_3). lithuanian experts pointed out that often financiers of wises are not private individuals, but public authorities, who distribute national budget or eu funds, which mainly belong to the society, therefore, this stakeholder must be concerned with the use of public funds: society invests in social enterprises. that is, if i invest in something, i want to see what comes from my investment, whether there is or not the return, whether those enterprises actually do something good, this is what i truly care about as an active citizen (ex_lt_2); we are talking about subsidies, public money benefits or subsidies are granted for the enterprises. this is the money we pay and we want to see the impact that money creates (ex_lt_3). thus, in the opinion of the respondents, if an enterprise receives certain subsidies and funds, it must carry out social impact assessment and thus account for the financing provided to it, tax benefits, etc. the respondents also cite the possibility of stopping the mission drift as an important reason why social impact assessment is important for stakeholders. mission drift is presented in the scientific literature (battlilana and dorado, 2010; chambers, 2014; cornforth, 2014) as a complex problem when commercial rather than social aims begin to dominate in an enterprise. this phenomenon can have negative consequences, for example, enterprises may fictitiously cover up the implementation of a social mission, the allocated funds may not be used for their intended purpose etc. lithuanian experts provided an example of the mission drift of lithuanian de jure wises, when enterprises receiving certain state subsidies and benefits “lost” their social mission to help these persons and qualitatively integrate them into the society, and commercial aims began to dominate. in lithuania, when the legal regulations were created and the social impact assessment was not established, those social enterprises that became very different started to establish. some of them continued to focus on social impact, while others simply used that model for profit and the model became convenient, attractive, and useful to them, perhaps even when bypassing certain things. all that good idea became distorted (ex_lt_4). thus, according to experts, social impact assessment can help ensure that commercial aims do not begin to dominate, thus maintaining the dual mission of a social enterprise. the research also analyzed wise as a subject which carries out an assessment. opinions of the respondents were divided on social enterprise as a subject of impact assessment. some argued that a http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi 10.13135/2704-9906/5091 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 63 social enterprise in the process of social impact assessment should be responsible for implementing the assessment process: this should be done by a social enterprise, as the results can help evaluate its performance, it can also help attract investment, show the contribution to the society (ex_lv_3); social entrepreneurs have a better understanding of the situation in the organization and can make an objective and comprehensive assessment (ex_lv_3). other respondents indicated that an enterprise cannot be solely responsible for the assessment for two main reasons: lack of competence and objectivity. respondents pointed out that managers and staff of the enterprises lack competencies and experience in this area: not all of them are strong enough to leave them carry out an impact assessment, their teams, their managers lack competencies (ex_lt_1); my experience is that social entrepreneurs do not indeed have experience in this area (ex_est_5). according to other experts, if an organization is responsible for carrying out the assessment alone, such assessment will not be objective: if an organization assesses its impact, it can lead to some controversy. it would be best to have an objective, third-party assessor (ex_est_5); in general, assessment and surveys of the whole society, i think, should not be done by social businesses, but by somebody else, it would be more objective if someone from the outside assesses (ex_lt_3); it would be best to have an independent and unrelated assessor (ex_est_1). however, it should be taken into account that the scientific literature (grieco, 2015; zeyen, beckmann, 2018) places special emphasis on the benefits of measuring social impact for the organization itself, as better management decisions are made, activities are improved, and the environment of a learning organization is created. it is therefore considered that a social enterprise must be the subject of the social impact assessment. also, the objectivity of the measurement of social impacts can be ensured in other ways, such as by involving stakeholders in the measurement (costa, pesci, 2016). thus, since the measurement of social impact can generate positive benefits for the organization itself, it should remain the subject performing social impact assessment. research participants were also asked what a wise should measure based on a logical chain outputs, outcomes or impact. experts pointed out that to measures changes in the society and community can be quite difficult due to the problem of data collection and availability, so this level of measurement should be carried out by other subjects: at the macro level, the enterprise itself cannot perform the measurement because it requires specific, large amounts of data (ex_lt_2); the macrolevel assessment requires the aggregation of data at the national level. the enterprise does not usually have this data, it cannot ask its competitor, "how many people did you employ" (ex_lt_2). http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi 10.13135/2704-9906/5091 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 64 it should be noted that the scientific literature (barraket and yousefpour, 2013; noya, 2015; amati, bengo et al., 2017; hoos, 2018; grieco, michellini, 2018) identifies both financial and human resources as the main obstacle to implement social impact measurement in an organization, also, in the baltic states, most social enterprises are small and medium-sized and they lack resources (jurgelane, 2017). therefore, it can be assumed that only a few social enterprises in the baltic states would be able to perform measurements of the changes in the society and community – in the impact logic chain. measurement of this level would require a great deal of effort and resources on the part of the enterprises, they would focus on the implementation of the measurement and thus may not take time to complete the social and commercial mission, there would be a risk of mission drift. focusing on the measurement process and the results sought can distract the organization from the social activities which it directly carries out. it should be noted that many experts agreed that, to implement the social impact measurement, social enterprises in the baltic states now need to focus on measuring the changes created for the beneficiaries: the medium-sized company should focus strictly on the micro-level when carrying out measurements (ex_est_2); companies should at least focus on the micro-level, which means monitoring the impact on specific persons at the individual level (ex_lv_4); the organization itself can only measure at the micro level so far (ex_lv_5). according to the respondents, this would be a big step for the baltic states at the moment, as enterprises have a great lack of knowledge on how to perform the measurement, they do not have enough information about measurement tools, they generally do not know how to measure. thus, based on the insights of the experts, it can be concluded that wises in the baltic states are currently not able to perform measurements of the changes created for communities and society. according to the experts, wises in the baltic states should focus on how to measure the changes for the beneficiaries at the organizational (micro) level, and this corresponds to the outcome specified in the logical chain. this confirms the insights provided by ebrahim and rangan (2014) and crucke decramer (2016) that it may be pointless for an enterprise to focus on measuring the change in the community and society (impact in a logical chain) as it requires significant investment and time from the social enterprises. ebrahim and rangan (2014) also point out that a social enterprise should measure outcome only when it is possible to establish a clear causal link between output and outcome in the logical chain. thus, according to the experts, it can be stated that a wise has every opportunity to assess the causal link when assessing the changes created for the beneficiaries whom it directly http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi 10.13135/2704-9906/5091 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 65 employs, therefore it is considered that wises should measure at the organizational level. however, it is considered that this does not mean that enterprises should not be interested in trends of measuring at the meso and macro levels, they should also improve their knowledge and competencies when assessing at these levels. during the research, the experts singled out that the measurement of social changes created in the community and society should be performed by public authorities, universities, and research centers. regarding the involvement of public authorities in the social impact measurement, the respondents from all three baltic states emphasized that the state must not only assist enterprises in carrying out the measurement, but also carry out the measurement at the meso and macro level, as public authorities have sufficient resources for that: it is very expensive for organizations to measure at this level themselves, and public authorities should collect data and carry out the measurement (ex_lv_5); this should be done at the level of the ministry, and at the national level considering what added value is created (ex_lt_2); the social impact created at the meso and macro levels should be assessed by public sector institutions (ex_est_2). in their research, ebrahim and rangan (2014) concluded that funders or public authorities should be responsible for the measurement of impact specified in the logical chain, as they have sufficient resources to carry out the process of measurement. it is also important to mention that public authorities usually have not only sufficient resources but also access to national data, which is often needed when conducting social impact studies at the macro and meso levels. therefore, based on these arguments, it can be concluded that public authorities should be responsible in the baltic states for the implementation of social impact measurement at the meso and macro levels. regarding the involvement of higher education institutions and research centers in the impact assessment, the experts stated that universities should also be the subjects which carry out social impact measurement: it is a scientific subject, universities, research centers could research why those changes took place (ex_lt_3); the assessment could be carried out by research institutes, looking at the national level what added value is created (ex_lt_2). universities and research centers should help public authorities monitor long-term impact in the society and communities, as this research often requires special competencies in data collection, analysis, change monitoring, and forecasting. noya (2015) points out that public authorities should fund research and experiments in the field of social impact assessment, so it is believed that macrolevel measurement should be carried out by public authorities in collaboration with higher education institutions and research institutes. http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi 10.13135/2704-9906/5091 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 66 the participants of the research were also asked about the measurement indicators that wise should measure. two main subcategories stood out in the participants' statements about the indicators of social impact measurement: indicators related to changes in the well-being of individuals (beneficiaries) (see figure 1). figure 1. indicators related to the well-being of individuals source: compiled by the author based on the software atlas.ti. in the research, the experts indicated that these common indicators should be used to measure changes of wises for the beneficiaries. improved health is mentioned among the changes in the health of individuals (ex_est_2; ex_est_3), as well as improved quality of life (ex_est_2; ex_est_3; ex_est_1). one of the experts pointed out that the quality of life could be related to the increased use of the services of these individuals, i.e., whether a person can afford more than before (ex_lt_3). the experts (ex_lv_5) associated the quality of life with better opportunities for these people to use science and culture. according to the respondent, perhaps the person has never been to the theatre, has never been shopping alone, has no friends, etc. (ex_lt_3). the experts also highlighted reduced stress (ex_lt_4; ex_est_3), self-realization (ex_est_2; ex_est_5). http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi 10.13135/2704-9906/5091 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 67 moreover, the experts highlighted the improved social life (ex_lv_5), social networks (ex_est_3), social relations, increased social capital (ex_est_5). they emphasised the material well-being of the individual increased personal income (ex_lv_5; ex_est_5; ex_lv_3). respondents indicated that it is important to assess an individual's sense of happiness: it is important to assess the emotions of these individuals, whether they feel happier, how much unhappy they feel (ex_est_3); a sense of happiness can be an indicator of the assessment (ex_lt_3). but one of the experts (ex_lt_2) pointed out that when measuring increased sense of happiness, it is important to understand whether the person has become happier because of that job, activity, or other reasons. it is also possible to measure whether a person feels safer after a certain time, whether his/her selfesteem, his/her attitude to life changes (ex_lt_1); his/her experience, changed well-being, etc. (ex_lt_2). also, experts believe that behavioral changes must also be assessed; it is important to assess changes in individuals’ behavior (ex_lv_3; ex_est_2), whether the person has become more independent from other people, or whether his/her autonomy has increased (ex_lt_3; ex_est_1). thus, after analyzing the experts' statements, the following main common indicators of measuring individual well-being can be identified: improved health, increased sense of happiness, increased autonomy, increased material well-being/income, increased social capital, improved quality of life (better access to education and cultural services), self-realization, reduced stress. http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi 10.13135/2704-9906/5091 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 68 figure 2. indicators related to employment source: compiled by the author based on the software atlas.ti. during the research, the experts also singled out employment-related indicators (see figure 2), which can be further divided into activity, outcome and impact indicators. the experts say: it is important to assess the number of employees, the number of people involved in the activities (ex_lv_1); the organization should assess quantitative indicators such as the number of jobs created (ex_lv_5); it is important to assess the number of people who have completed the program (ex_lv_1); if a social enterprise provides services and products to disadvantaged people, they can assess how much they have provided (ex_est_4); material products and services, results that can be measured from operations carried out by social enterprises which can be measured directly, such as the number of people reached, the number of items sold, etc. (ex_lv_3). thus, as we can see from the statements, the respondents emphasize the measurement of the output indicators of the activity of the enterprise, i. y. the number of jobs created, the number of people involved in the activities, the number of services provided, etc. however, according to the social impact scientific literature (grieco, 2017; yuthas, esptein, 2014), impact measurement should be understood as a transition in the impact chain from the measurement of an organization's direct output to an outcome, so it is http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi 10.13135/2704-9906/5091 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 69 considered that these activity indicators specified by the experts should not be considered as impact measurement indicators. it should be noted that wises differ in their aims, therefore, to establish common measurement indicators for them, it is necessary to choose those indicators that can be applied to all types of wises. for example, changes in an individual's employment status can be measured in all enterprises, as employment is a broad concept which includes not only a person's employment but also, for example, his or her enrolment in higher education or starting a personal business: the enterprise should measure created employment-related impact, such as changes in the employment status of the beneficiaries (ex_est_2; ex_est_5; ex_lv_3). some experts emphasized that there should be measured changes in acquired skills and working skills of an individual (ex_est_2), retraining, providing or restoring the necessary skills (ex_lt_4): social impact could be measured by showing that people acquire new knowledge and improve their skills (ex_lv_2); acquired knowledge and skills (ex_lv_3). it is considered that not all social enterprises aim to provide qualifications, but all enterprises focus on the development or re-establishment of new work skills, and it is therefore considered that this could be a common measurement indicator. the experts (ex_est_2; ex_lv_5) also pointed out that it is important to measure not only the acquired working skills, but also social skills and communication skills, because many people belonging to the target groups are usually long time unemployed, have lived separated from the society for a long time and, therefore, lack communication and social skills. the experts (ex_est_3; ex_lv_4) also emphasized the teamwork indicator. another important indicator which could be applied to all wises is career and professional growth of these people: it is important to emphasize not how many of those people are employed, but how long they remain in the company, what their further career development is if they leave the company, whether they are ready to further participate in the processes of integration and career planning. because one of the promises of a social enterprise is the promotion of social integration. it is both, promotion of integration and its means. it would be possible to truly measure the effectiveness of the means, how those people are prepared in the career planning process (ex_lt_1). according to this expert, this could be achieved by assessing the professional growth of a person, how his/her career changed over a while, 3 years, for example. the experts also mentioned another indicator increased work capacity. a person's work capacity should be understood in a broad sense (not only based on formal evidence the conclusions of the http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi 10.13135/2704-9906/5091 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 70 medical commission) as a person's ability to work systematically in an organization, taking into account greater motivation to work and improved work results. in social enterprises which employ these people, this can be, for example, a lower number of days off or sick leaves, etc. (ex_lt_1; ex_lv_3). those enterprises which do not aim to employ such people can measure these parameters through the increased work motivation and the increased number of tasks performed, etc. the research revealed that wise in the baltic states are currently not able to measure their created impact on the community and society levels, so they should now focus on measuring the changes created for the beneficiaries. thus, after analyzing the data of the empirical research and based on the theoretical analysis, it is possible to present the framework for measuring wise in the baltic states. (see figure 3). figure 3. impact measurement framework for wises in the baltic states source: compiled by the author the research found that to implement the social impact assessment of wise in the baltic states, it is necessary to measure two categories of indicators: indicators related to the employment and wellbeing of the individual. these indicators can be measured together with the specific indicators set by the organization itself, which can be set separately according to the aims of each wise. 5. conclusions the implementation of the social impact assessment process in an organization requires a lot of effort and resources: to involve stakeholders, to choose appropriate measurement tools, to collect various data, to present the results of the assessment to the stakeholders. however, it does not mean that wises should ignore it. wises should take this opportunity to embrace social impact http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi 10.13135/2704-9906/5091 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 71 measurement and adopt a framework that allows them to use data to make better decisions, improve operations, improve its programs, products and services for its beneficiaries. social impact measurement is one way to make a greater impact in the lives of the individuals and communities they are committed to serving. instead of debating social impact definition, impact measurement methods and tools, it is important to critically reflect what can be measured by wise itself, taking into account their limited time, resources, skills and capacity to collect and analyse data; the research revealed that wises in the baltic states are currently not in a position to conduct an impact measurement on the wider society on their own, as this requires the collection of large amounts of data and the continuous monitoring and analysis of long-term changes in the society and communities. however, it is considered important to ensure that research on long-term changes in the society and communities created by wises is carried out, because it confirms the need for the existence of social enterprises and helps to reveal how and to what extent they contribute to the solution of complex social problems in the society, such as poverty, unemployment, intolerance. it should also be emphasized that wises devote most of their resources and time to working with the target group, their needs, communication with their families, which deprives them of the time that could be spent on implementing impact measurements in organizations, therefore, it is quite difficult for them to make measurements of the changes created at all levels (beneficiaries, community and society). long-term changes in the society and communities could be measured by public authorities together with the institutions of higher education. they have much more resources than social enterprises, and the social impact created at the societal level (macro, meso-level) is rarely achieved by a single organization, it is usually a collective impact, making it more convenient for the public institutions to collect data and assess the impact of all organizations. it should also be mentioned that institutions often have better access to databases than wises, so they can collect the data needed for the research more quickly, they also have the conditions to collect and store the data, ensuring their security. therefore, for the reasons listed here, it is considered that wises should be responsible for carrying out the impact measurement on their beneficiaries. the research showed that to prove their impact to the stakeholders, wises should measure and monitor these indicators: indicators related to the employment and well-being of the beneficiaries. these indicators can be measured together with the specific indicators set by the organization itself, which can be set separately according to the aims of each wise. also, measuring these indicators would help identify the programs and activities that bring the greatest benefits to the beneficiaries. http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi 10.13135/2704-9906/5091 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 72 the proposed measurement framework and a set of indicators removes obstacles to implement social impact measurement in an organization, and allows stakeholders to standardize and compare the impacts of wises on their beneficiaries. the paper also has some limitations. the purposive sampling has been used. since the sample is selected based on the researcher’s ascertainments and criteria, the sampling was judgemental. there was a reasonable probability of having uncontrolled variability and bias in the estimations of the sampling. despite these limitations, the experts’ interviews have allowed to receive meaningful information for the research in the specific research area. it should be noted that the empirical study was conducted several years ago, however, it should be noted that during this period there were no significant changes in wises measurements, policies in the field of social enterprise because of covid19 pandemic, so the results are unlikely to be different. future research should also include economic indicators of wises' activities because more and more wises performing as hybrid organizations. economic indicators becoming important in order to reveal the full impact‘s spectrum of wises. furthermore, more research studies are necessary to find effective methods and tools to measure wises’ social impact. references amati, t., arena, m., bengo, i., & caloni, d. (2017). social impact measurement and management: between theory and practice. in handbook of research on emerging business models and managerial strategies in the nonprofit sector (p. 371–388). igi global. arena, m., azzone, g., & bengo, i. (2015). performance measurement for social enterprises. voluntas: international journal of voluntary and nonprofit organizations, 26 (2), 649–672. bagnoli, l., & megali, c. (2011). measuring performance in social enterprises. nonprofit and voluntary sector quarterly, 40 (1), 149–165. barraket, j., & yousefpour, n. (2013). evaluation and social impact measurement amongst small to medium social enterprises: process, purpose and value. australian journal of public administration, 72 (4), 447–458. battilana, j., and dorado, s. (2010), ‘building sustainable hybrid organizations: the case of commercial microfinance organizations’. academy of management journal, 53 (6), 1419–1440. http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi 10.13135/2704-9906/5091 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 73 bengo, i., arena, m., azzone, g., & calderini, m. (2016). indicators and metrics for social business: a review of current approaches (vol 7, pg 1, 2016). journal of social entrepreneurship, 7 (3), 369–369. biancone, p., secinaro, s., brescia, v., & iannaci, d. (2020). business model innovation for sustainability and social impact. international journal of management sciences and business research, 9(5), 30–40 charmaz k. (2006). constructng grounded theory. thousand oaks, sage publications. costa, e., & pesci, c. (2016). social impact measurement: why do stakeholders matter? sustainability accounting, management and policy journal, 7 (1), 99–124. cooney, k. (2011). the business of job creation: an examination of the social enterprise approach to workforce development. journal of poverty, 15 (1), 88–107. crucke, s. and decramer, a. (2016). ‘the development of a measurement instrument for the organizational performance of social enterprises’. sustainability, 8, 161. davister, c., defourny, j., & grégoire, o. (2004). work integration social enterprises in the european union: an overview of existing models. revue internationale de l’économie sociale: recma, 293, 24–50. ebrahim, a., and v. k. rangan. 2014. “what impact?” california management review 56 (3): 118–141. ebrahim, a. s., and v. k. rangan. (2010). putting the brakes on impact: a contingency framework for measuring social performance. best paper proceedings of the academy of management. grieco, c. 2015. assessing social impact of social enterprises: does one size really fit all?. springer. grieco, c., l. michelini, and g. iasevoli. 2015. “measuring value creation in social enterprises a cluster analysis of social impact assessment models.” nonprofit and voluntary sector quarterly 44 (6): 1173–1193. grieco, c., & michelini, l. (2018). 2: mind the gap! existing barriers to standardizing the measurement of social value creation. in measuring and controlling sustainability (p. 50–62). routledge. hadad, s., & gauca, o. d. (2014). social impact measurement in social entrepreneurial organizations. management & marketing, 9 (2), 119. http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi 10.13135/2704-9906/5091 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 74 hehenberger, l., harling, a. m., & scholten, p. (2013). a practical guide to measuring and managing impact. european venture philanthropy association (evpa). internet access: http://www.oltreventure.com/wpcontent/uploads/2015/05/evpa_a_practical_guide_to_measuring _and_-managing_impact_final.pdf. hornsby, a. (2012). the good analyst. impact measurement and analysis in the social-purpose universe. investing for. iannaci, d. (2020). reporting tools for social enterprises: between impact measurement and stakeholder needs. european journal of social impact and circular economy, 1(1b), 1-18. jurgelane, a., lanka, s. (2017). social impact measurement: an innovative tool for fostering the positive social change created by social enterprises. in proceedings of 3rd international conference on lifelong education and leadership for all iclel 2017 (p. 668–678), polytechnic institute of porto, porto, portugal, 12–14 sept. 2017. oborenko, z., & rivza, b. (2018). legal and policy framework of employment for people with disabilities in latvia. in economic science for rural development conference proceedings (no. 49). kaiser, k. (2009). protecting respondent confidentiality in qualitative research. qualitative health research, 19 (11), 1632–1641. krutulienė, pocius, gruževskis, okunevičiūtė-neverauskienė, junevičius (2017). mokslinio tyrimo „sunkiai integruojamų į darbo rinką asmenų užimtumo didinimo galimybių tobulinimas“ ataskaita. internet access: http://www.stopskurdas.lt/wp-content/uploads/2018/01/sunkiaiintegruojamu-i-dr-asmenu-uzimtumo-didinimo-galimybiu-tobulinimas.pdf. maas, k., & liket, k. (2011). social impact measurement: classification of methods. in environmental management accounting and supply chain management (p. 171–202). springer, dordrecht. meadows, m., & pike, m. (2010). performance management for social enterprises. systemic practice and action research, 23 (2), 127–141 neverauskienė, l. o., & moskvina, j. (2011). socialinės įmonės: socialinės ekonomikos raidos aspektas. filosofija. sociologija, 22 (4), 384–393. nyssens, m. (2014). european work integration social enterprises. social enterprise and the third sector: changing european landscapes in a comparative perspective, 211–230. http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi 10.13135/2704-9906/5091 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 75 noya, a. (2015), "social entrepreneurship social impact measurement for social enterprises", oecd employment policy papers, no. 10, oecd publishing, paris, https://doi.org/10.1787/5jrtpbx7tw37-en raisiene, a. g., & urmanavičienė, a. (2017). mission drift in a hybrid organization: how can social business combine its dual goals?. ekonomski vjesnik/econviews-review of contemporary business, entrepreneurship and economic issues, 30 (2), 301–310. raudsaar, m., & kaseorg, m. (2013). an exploration of social entrepreneurship in estonia. international journal of business and management studies, 2 (2), 19–29. syrjä, p., sjögrén, h., & ilmarinen, a. (2015, june). performance measurement in social enterprises–a conceptual accounting approach. in 5th emes international research conference on social enterprise-building a scientific, helsinki, finland (vol. 29). spiess-knafl, w., & scheck, b. (2017). impact investing: instruments, mechanisms and actors. springer. zeyen, a., & beckmann, m. (2018). social entrepreneurship and business ethics: understanding the contribution and normative ambivalence of purpose-driven venturing. routledge žydžiūnaitė, v., sabaliauskas, s. (2017). kokybiniai tyrimai, principai ir metodai. vilnius: leidykla vaga. 4486-article text-14460-2-9-20200703 european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/4486 published by university of turin ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index 1 reporting tools for social enterprises: between impact measurement and stakeholder needs daniel iannaci department of management, university of turin, turin, italy e-mail: daniel.iannaci@unito.it received: 11/05/2020 revised: 12/06/2020 accepted for publication: 17/06/2020 published: 20/07/2020 abstract most people within the third sector and beyond would endorse the view that social economy organisations should report on what they do and how they work for the common good, and we, as a society, should require such reporting. there are several studies and research on the role of reporting for social enterprises hoping to communicate financial information and social impact. however, the gap that emerged from the literature is that the principles of transparency and accountability are defined, but there is a lack of determination of a key element that can put order and respond to the need of stakeholders in the best possible way. the author believes that a good reporting tool that is representative and that above all is understandable even to nonprofessional users only works if it can give an effective group representation if it puts the first place: the need. the author employs the methodology of the case study where data are collected by multiple means through qualitative research techniques such as interviews, and document analysis for acquiring a full understanding. the finding reveals that the focus on the need of stakeholders increase accountability, transparency, and stakeholder engagement. stakeholders would be able to better understand the strong values of good governance, leadership, performance, and social impact that the company possesses. through the research project conducted so far has been possible to demonstrate that in social enterprises to have an effective measurement of impact must use all possible tools to know and describe the company and the ecosystem that surrounds it and this is possible through timely reporting that it returns clear information for all. keywords: reporting tools, social enterprises, social impact, impact measurement, stakeholder needs, accounting http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/4486 published by university of turin) ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index 2 1. introduction pearce (2009) explain that most people within the third sector and beyond would endorse the view that ‘social economy organisations should report on what they do and how they work for the common good, and we, as society, should require such reporting’ (pearce, 2009). on a practical level, however, the basis of such reporting is perhaps less immediately obvious. the best-known approaches to social reporting, including aa1000 and the gri guidelines, may appear excessively complex, costly and better suited to large corporate settings, rather than smaller values-based enterprises. the business landscape currently existing in the entrepreneurial ecosystem in accordance with the literature defines a certain category of companies that can be the main players in the area of impact economy are the: social enterprises (ses) (bicciato, 2010; borzaga, 2002; borzaga & tortia, 2004; calò et al., 2018; farmer et al., 2012). the social enterprises have within their social object the characteristics that ethical finance seeks and above all they are the best structured companies of the whole panorama of the third sector (zamagni, 2013). the response to the need for comprehensible and effective reporting, introduced at an entrepreneurial level, is increasingly moving towards social enterprises that are currently considered in the scientific landscape hybrid organizations, business models aimed at maintaining the social mission along with business (billis, 2010; grossi & thomasson, 2015; haigh & hoffman, 2012). social enterprises make the social a strategic asset to regenerate resources of different nature: human, through the development of new knowledge and new skills; economic, through the possibility of aggregating a variety of types of sources precisely by virtue of the hybrid nature of the organization; physical, that is, linked to the process of transformation of spaces in places, where relationality becomes the key ingredient for the success of the process (garrow & hasenfeld, 2012; kleynjans & hudon, 2016; smith & phillips, 2016). the economic evaluation of the social impact of hybrid organizations becomes, therefore, crucial in the knowledge economy (meneguzzo, 2005; zamagni et al., 2015) and the debate focuses on the instruments of impact measurement (calderini et al., 2007). hybrid organizations are located in an intermediate section at the intersection of public, profit and non-profit (billis, 2010; grossi et al., 2015; secinaro et al., 2019; thomasson, 2009). reporting and communication for these realities becomes fundamental. in order to define the field of innovation and identify the social value that is returned to the ecosystem of the territory, it is important and helpful to define the business model as a tool that can facilitate (or not) the spread of innovation in the system. the value inherent in an innovation remains latent until it is put on the market or otherwise explicit and this can only happen through the use of a business model (chesbrough & rosenbloom, 2002). certainly, the accounting system is an important point within a company that can bring out information about good governance. governance involves a set of relationships between stakeholders and the distribution of rights and responsibilities between these different stakeholders (awotundun et al., 2011; fernández-fernández, 1999; freeman, 2010; freeman et al., 2010; mair et al., 2015; vining & weimer, 2016). as a result of good governance, the values that are passed on to stakeholders are experience and reliability, as the leaders of professional organizations in the field of ethics and compliance have a responsibility to feed the next generation of entrepreneurs. leadership skills increase the effectiveness of management and also tend to promote ethics (adams, 2000; alshammari et al., 2015; carroll, 1996; friedman, 2014; vining & weimer, 2016). the discovery reveals that with the se's best reporting practices within the well-functioning ecosystem it is possible to create new social projects. having accountability as a connecting feature with stakeholders gives you the credibility you need to create social impact through new projects. the benefit is perceived directly by the users of the service and indirectly by all the other stakeholders linked to the territory in which the impact activity is carried out (adams, 2000; alshammari et al., 2015; biancone et al., 2018b; carroll, 1996; kirk et al., 1986; lehner & nicholls, 2014; skelcher & smith, 2017; wainwright & manville, 2017). there are several studies and research on the role of reporting for social enterprises hoping to communicate financial information and social impact. however, the gap that emerged from the literature is that the principles of transparency and accountability are defined, but there is a lack of determination of a key element that can put order and respond to the need of stakeholders in the best possible way. therefore, the research aims to define and highlight one or more key factors and answer the research question "define the key factors that a social enterprise should have in order to obtain a reporting tool oriented to the communication of financial data and social impact and determine which factors stakeholders would like to know in order to be heard included". http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/4486 published by university of turin) ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index 3 the document is structured as follows: the second section illustrates the literary review, the third section the research methodology, the fourth section the context of the case study, the fifth section provides the presentation of the results and finally the sixth section concludes. 2. literature review 2.1. reporting tools the consolidated financial statements provide the information necessary to verify the degree to which the objectives for the entire aggregate have been achieved, with particular reference to the composition of the sources and the composition of the investments (fornaciari, 2017; pisoni et al., 2007). this context makes it possible to know the financial structure of the group, the degree of financial autonomy and the level of indebtedness, the participation or composition of the group, the total cost of the same, the structural composition of costs, especially those that constitute the most significant elements of production. the consolidated financial statements provide information and knowledge of the different composition of revenues. in addition, this document provides an analysis of the relationship between the income to be taxed and the capacity of the parent company. revenues generated by the exchange with subsidiaries, with the possibility of forecasting consolidated business units. this information allows the possibility of formulating more optimised programmes to identify the use of resources. national and international accounting standards converge with the aim of providing information from the consolidated group: accessible, comprehensible and transparent (ecchia & zarri, 2005). especially in the context of a corporate group, where several companies can be merged by nature and destination (profit and non-profit companies), it can intervene in support of popular financial reporting, a consolidated economic and financial reporting tool that integrates financial, economic, equity, quantitative and qualitative information of the consolidated group with a simple language that can also be understood by non-professionals, therefore addressed to all citizens and stakeholders (biancone et al., 2016, 2017b). the most widespread instrument in the municipalities and in the anglo-american states has been applied for the first time in italy with the realization of the popular budget of the municipal group of the city of turin. the instrument in its first definition represented all aspects of the public group. subsequent projects focus on the prevailing needs of the main stakeholder, the citizen, differentiating also the group's attention to gender needs (biancone et al., 2017b). the tool adapts well to the needs of the group through the representation of financial and non-financial aspects. since the accessibility of information by stakeholders is the key point of the pop reporting, the company works with them year after year to redefine the content to adapt to what are the requests and priorities for information. moreover, given the difficulty of reading the results with respect to the financial and non-financial contents related to the level of education, the tool is able to respond to the needs of workers but also to those of investors considering the possible gap and scope related to education (biancone et al., 2017a). the connotation and vision of the whole group allows a true representation of the real and trendy situation, giving the possibility to orient the planning by aligning the needs of the workers, and the objectives of the service contracts that social cooperatives often stipulate for the achievement of common public interests with local or regional authorities aimed at the satisfaction of the community. the definition of guidelines and suggestions to ensure transparency and ease of reading of data (hermann, 2011) responds well to the needs of the declaration of non-financial information, without the need to further adapt these accounting standards and guidelines in the context of financial representation. in order to better explain the section, the author has produced table 1 below. http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/4486 published by university of turin) ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index 4 table 1. scheme for comparison between types of financial statements report economic-financial social sustainability integrated popular financial reporting focus • economic • financial • asset focus temporale past (final balance) future (budget or programmatic budget) past with orientation to the future • past • present • future main subjects -workers (politicians, professionals, auditors, researchers) -funders -central administration -media specialist -citizens -local companies -mass media -human resources -non-profit organizations -interested public -all stakeholders -all stakeholders with the focus of content according to the needs of the main stakeholders commitment level compulsory drafting voluntary implementation approach compliance based on principles function communicative • communicative • strategic report with economic and financial statements complementary incorporation of: • economic and financial statements • sustainability report • corporate governance information • possible focus on intangible capital incorporation of: • consolidated economic and financial statements • sustainability report • information on corporate governance with approach to gender need • non-financial group information • focus on intangible capital source: author’s elaboration the study shows that some social reporting tools (integrated and pop reporting) can give a correct perception and analysis of the service of public interest. through a study, it was observed that the effective use of intellectual capital (ic) by managers and the introduction of integrated reporting is able to facilitate the introduction of changes in the processes of management and measurement of the ci from the point of view of value creation (badia et al., 2018; biancone et al., 2018a). in particular, it has been demonstrated that popular financial reporting can be adopted with a view to greater transparency, accountability and sharing of results with stakeholders, responding to requests for information (biancone et al., 2018c, 2018d, 2019b). consolidated financial statements of a non-financial nature represent a useful tool for representing some important elements for the valuation of investments and the absorption of resources that are often not valued in the financial statements. there is no evidence or valuation of what human capital is, a resource on which companies have been investing more in the last twenty years. the social enterprise sees among its main stakeholders not only users and public bodies with whom it shares objectives to meet needs, but also investors and producers of services at the same time. the representation of the intangible needs a greater sensitivity to which the accounting principles and guidelines have not yet been able to respond. in the case study (biancone et al., 2018c), it is highlighted that the values linked to the employment of disadvantaged human resources not present in the consolidated financial statements of the group do not find an economic expression, but present a real added value with consequent cessation of costs http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/4486 published by university of turin) ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index 5 (which would not have been to use the subjects involved). business models and value reporting are the starting points for defining non-financial elements based on group values. a total representation can be given through the adoption of popular financial reporting which, thanks to the intrinsic characteristics of the tool, already meets the needs of group representation in a perspective of integrated sustainability, considering many aspects including representation through infographics and a scale of priorities related to gender, environment and various priority stakeholders. the elements of kpis allow for easy reading and comparison. the simple language of reaching everyone without distinction is a key element of the elements that must be present especially in those companies where investors are often the same disadvantaged members. popular financial reporting is a voluntary tool but can respond in a single document to information needs (yusuf et al., 2013). the need for transparency and responsibility in a period of reduction of available resources is met by popular financial reporting, which is also justified in purely legislative terms by the need to have an easy reading of non-financial results to attract new investors and explain to them the strategic structure and intrinsic value of the company (yusuf & jordan, 2015). 2.2. social enterprises a social enterprise (se) is an undertaking with a social or environmental mission as its primary goal, with profit having a lower rank and value than the success, effectiveness and impact of the mission itself. ses usually start projects or a business in areas which are of public importance, areas where governments and their public policies have been inadequate and where markets/industries operate only with short-term gain or profit as their aim (dart, 2004; mauksch et al., 2017; steiner & teasdale, 2016). social enterprises are drivers of economic and social inclusion for the territories in which they operate. the phenomenon influences company extensions (goldoff, 2000; rehn, 2008). the fate of companies is linked to that of their territory (zamagni, 2013). since the 1980s, non-profit organizations have slowly begun to incorporate hybridity, only occasionally questioning their public or private identity (billis, 2010; bryson & roering, 1987; grimsey & lewis, 2002; lan & hal, 1992; perry & rainey, 1988; stanton, 2004). there are factors, such as good governance, market leadership, that give the necessary confidence to funders from the moment they seek funds but are also the key factors that allow a social enterprise to be included among the main actors of social innovation (alshammari et al., 2015; ayob et al., 2016; caulier-grice et al., 2012; fernández-fernández, 1999; hubert, 2010; smith & phillips, 2016). as alter (2004) argues, se occupy a single space within the economy and can be positioned between profit and non-profit. borzaga and santuari (2003) argue that compared to profit organisations, social enterprises attach considerable importance to the social purpose. normally, the creation of economic value has a predominant position within the objectives of profit organizations over the social and environmental ones, which are often used to achieve the former. instead, for ses the main objective is to maximize the creation of social and environmental value and historically these are achieved through the right mix of social and financial performance. profit and se are distinguished by the fact that the latter in terms of economic sustainability must give strong guarantees of being achieved through market-oriented activities. on the contrary, the former, as austin argues (2000), focus only on some social results without the objective of competing on the market with profit-oriented companies and financing their activities largely (but not only) through donations and public contributions. another very important distinction is given by borzaga and santuari (2003), which claim that es design and sell a product or service, creating synergies between the financial and social objectives. the role of these types of companies is fundamental for the creation of social innovation of the ecosystem and enter with force to contribute to the current definition of impact economy given by calderini (2018). http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/4486 published by university of turin) ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index 6 2.3. social impact measurement when, in this research, reference is made to the social the reference is to life within the community, the ecosystem. the scientific disciplines that study the subject are sociology, economics and anthropology (calderini et al., 2018; marradi, 1992; rousseau, 2015; zamagni et al., 2015). as will often be used, the concept of social is accompanied by a tendency to improve the living conditions of less well-off citizens, to achieve greater equalization between the various components of a society. hybrid organisations are promoters of social innovation, generating widespread well-being and sustainable improvements in the living conditions of the community. it is precisely the community, thanks to the increasingly accessible communication technologies, that becomes not only the recipient of social innovation, but also the co-generator of innovative processes (corvo & pastore, 2018). when social enterprises and resource providers are involved in symmetric relationships, the purpose of measuring social impact seems to help social enterprises to improve their performance so that the parties can achieve their common goal of creating social impact for those in need (zamagni et al., 2015). a fundamental element of the evaluation process is attention to the effects generated by the action, including positive and negative effects, direct and indirect, expected and unanticipated (bezzi, 2001). evaluation should not be confused with monitoring, for which there are similarities and points of contact. in the first case, what has been achieved is analysed, verifying the validity of the results achieved; in the second case, the aim is to verify the progression with respect to the intervention planning, in order to identify any deviations (montesi et al., 2017). through the explanation of the chain of value creation, clark et al. (2004), as it can see in figure 1, deepens the concept of "social" outcome, as the value purified of what would have happened regardless of the intervention of social impact. figure 1. impact value chain source: (clark & rosenzweig, 2004) the impact assessment is based on counterfactual analysis, i.e. it questions the occurrence of a change not only with respect to the "before compared to after", but also to the "with respect to without" a certain involvement (clark & rosenzweig, 2004). there are projects where the "before vs. after" is sufficient to determine the impact generated, for example when no other factor is likely to have caused observable effects on the change generated: the reduction of time spent on drawing water from the installation of hydraulic pumps. in other cases, however, the cause-effect link is not so obvious and linear, requiring therefore an analysis that compares the "with respect to without" the intervention (clark & rosenzweig, 2004). there may be various reasons for measuring the impact, for example: (i) demonstrate transparency, accountability and legitimacy to investors to access resources because without impact, evidence and reporting, lenders do not see the value created for communities; and (ii) know and improve organisational performance to determine whether they should continue or change their current strategy to achieve their missions (nguyen et al., 2015). http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/4486 published by university of turin) ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index 7 as illustrated by nguyen et al. (2015), when social enterprises and resource providers are involved in symmetric relationships, the purpose of measuring social impact seems to help social enterprises improve performance so that parties can achieve their common goal: to create social impact for people in need. the budget tells us everything, the need is to know how to analyse it. spreading the data through a pop language is the challenge, starting from the needs up to the relapse on the territory (biancone et al., 2018c, 2018d; biancone & secinaro, 2015; brescia, 2019). 2.4. stakeholder theory originally the relationship between the stakeholder and the company was conceived following a "hub and spoke" approach, later models of interactive relationships were developed, in which the management and the interested parties agree on a management approach oriented towards transparency and responsibility (andriof et al., 2002; freudenreich et al., 2019; jiang et al., 2019). stakeholder theory scholars have sought to classify relational models between companies and stakeholders by taking a path of gradual growth in stakeholder engagement that includes the following steps (svendsen, 1998; waddock, 2002): stakeholder mapping (clarkson, 1995); stakeholder management (carroll, 1996; clarkson, 1995; donaldson & preston, 1995; mitchell et al., 1997; sangle, 2010); stakeholder engagement (se) (andriof et al., 2002; windsor, 2002). table 2. stakeholder involvement steps steps stakeholder mapping identify its stakeholders if possible to distinguish between primary (which determines the very survival of the company) and secondary (which affects or is affected by the company but does not affect its sustainability) (clarkson, 1995) stakeholder management manage the expectations of stakeholders and the social and economic issues they support, balancing positions (clarkson, 1995; hillman & keim, 2001) stakeholder engagement involving its stakeholders in decision-making processes, involving them in company management, sharing information, dialoguing and creating a model of mutual responsibility (manetti, 2011) source: author’s elaboration the stakeholder management model in corporate social activities (including social reporting) can be used by the company as a tool to negotiate its relationship with stakeholders (roberts, 1992; ullmann, 1985); suggesting that companies are interested in stakeholders because of the perceived benefit in terms of improved financial performance and that managerial relations with stakeholders are based on regulatory, moral commitments rather than on the desire to use these stakeholders exclusively to maximise the definition of stakeholders' profits defining a two-way relationship between the organisation and its stakeholders (berman et al., 1999; freeman, 1984). starting from the stakeholder theory, a conceptual structure for corporate social activity was defined by testing the ability to explain social reporting activity, finding stakeholder power, strategic posture and economic performance significantly correlated levels of social diffusion and the model were tested to ascertain a critical assessment of contemporary developments (berman et al., 1999; freeman, 1984; freeman & gilbert, 1988; owen et al., 2000; roberts, 1992; ullmann, 1985). it is important to get feedback from stakeholders on social and ethical performance. therefore, companies currently use the notion of "stakeholder engagement" as a means of legitimisation instead of a means to extend corporate accountability and transparency (civera et al., 2019; owen & swift, 2001; strand & freeman, 2015). this assertion can be supported by the fact that, as has been revealed above in this section, stakeholders are not identified in a clear and systematic way to involve them in the reporting process, the issues to be addressed are decided unilaterally and feedback from stakeholders is not included in the decision-making process (freudenreich et al., 2019; how et al., 2019; jiang et al., 2019). stakeholder theory has been widely used, both explicitly and implicitly, in non-profit research (nfpo) exploring accountability and transparency (dhanani & connolly, 2012; ebrahim, 2003; edwards & hulme, 2014; najam, 2002). the http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/4486 published by university of turin) ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index 8 stakeholder theory was born as a theory of organizational behaviour related to for-profit organizations (freeman, 1984), with stakeholders initially defined as "any group or individual who can influence or is influenced by the achievement of the organization's goals". it was argued that engagement with stakeholders, including giving and receiving information, would help organizations achieve their goals and gain a competitive advantage (andrews & van de walle, 2013). in addition to shareholders, there are many other interest groups that can influence or be influenced by the behaviour of the company such as employees, customers, suppliers, government and the general public (freeman, 1984). 2.5. the research model in the social impact assessment, as clark et al. (2004) has previously highlighted by a definition of the impact value chain in order to better understand the factors that determine value creation. an intrinsic factor that emerged in the literature analysed on reporting tools, social enterprises, social impact measurement, stakeholder theory is that to create stakeholder participation it is important that upstream there is a company with good governance, leadership, aimed at survival in the market through performance and orientation to social impact. this information is not important if it is not transmitted in the correct way through the correct reporting tool to increase the perception and consequently the involvement (al-khasawneh & futa, 2012; biancone et al., 2018b; fernández-fernández, 1999; freeman, 2010; strand & freeman, 2015). a good reporting tool must put the need of stakeholders first and through the principles of transparency and accountability communicate its corporate history to have the expected results that the ecosystem needs and try to promote ethics (adams, 2000; alshammari et al., 2015; biancone et al., 2018a; carroll, 1996; ebrahim, 2003; pestoff, 2014; vining & weimer, 2016). the discovery reveals that with best reporting practices for ses, it is about shaping the level of information about the various types of stakeholders, both professional and non-professional, so that the supply and demand for information meet (biancone et al., 2019b; biancone & secinaro, 2015). with the aim of answering the research question "define the key factors that a social enterprise should have in order to obtain a reporting tool oriented to the communication of financial data and social impact and determine which factors stakeholders would like to know in order to be heard included". the researcher believes that: a good reporting tool that is representative and that above all is understandable even to nonprofessional users only works if it can give an effective group representation if it puts the first place: the need. after a thorough analysis of the literature review, the study proposes that putting the need for a reporting tool first would increase accountability, transparency and stakeholder engagement. stakeholders would be able to better understand the strong values of good governance, leadership, performance and social impact that the company possesses. figure 2 builds the reference model proposed by the authors. to adopt a reporting tool and meet the needs of stakeholders, a social enterprise must have the four key factors listed above. through this guarantee and the most representative reporting tool they can have the involvement of stakeholders and increase the objective perception of them to create collaboration in new activities aimed at improving the ecosystem. http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/4486 published by university of turin) ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index 9 figure 2. model to satisfy stakeholder needs source: author’s elaboration 3. research methodology this research employs a case study approach (eisenhardt, 1989; yin, 2014). the case-study approach is suitable for investigating why or how phenomena occurred and the relationships among these phenomena (yin, 2014). through case study, one may better understand a novel phenomenon and concept (eisenhardt, 1989). in line with the purpose of this article, the methodology was adopted by preparing a longitudinal and explanatory case study (yin, 1981, 2017). the case study highlights some relevant aspects and possible approaches of the elements of the model. the methods for collecting information use qualitative techniques and include interviews with managers and employees, analysis of internal documentation, observation of the reality and truthfulness of the data declared with a reworking of some data that ensure the validity and reliability of the information. the primary data were collected directly by one of the authors who for years has been carrying out research within the social enterprise, the secondary data were provided through a semi-structured interview to managers and employees. the validity is guaranteed by the triangulation of different resources with evidence of the key information collected. the evidence collected is guaranteed by a double check on the information through differentiated sources. research allows to record a phenomenon in a real environment, where the boundaries between the context and the phenomenon tend to be blurred (stake, 1995). leadership performance social impact social enterprise r ep or tin g good governance trasparency accountability stakeholder involvement perception need http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/4486 published by university of turin) ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index 10 the literature allows to confirm and combine the information collected (yin, 2017). the transparency, the approach and the repeatability of the analysis and the method allow its reliability (leonard-barton, 1990). therefore the researchers believe that the case study defined by yin (2017) is the best way to answer the research question "define the key factors that a social enterprise should have in order to obtain a reporting tool oriented to the communication of financial data and social impact and determine which factors stakeholders would like to know in order to be heard included”. the research reflected its theoretical framework presented in figure 2, which consists of eight elements: accounting, good governance, reliability and experience, market leadership, security and compliance, technology and innovation, performance and stakeholder engagement; in the interviews conducted and in the semi-structured questions, also ensuring external validity (campbell, 1986). company and interviewees names and position are kept anonymous for privacy reasons , then they were transcribed and then encoded independently (curtis et al., 2010). however, researchers could mention that the surveyed members included the: ceo, cfo, and the participants who benefited from services. 3.1. interviews outline with the aim of answering the research questions, the research was organized to cover the topics needed to have the elements to proceed with the study. additional exploratory questions were considered to deepen the understanding of the answer, rather than closing a discussion and moving on to the next question. it was considered important to organise the questions by addressing the necessary issues from all points of view, from the most specific to the most general. the topic of reporting was addressed by trying to understand which information was considered understandable and which was not. also, to understand if social issues were considered important and if the information was more transparent if this would increase participation. it was necessary to have information on the reaction of the members trying to understand if the group believed in the social enterprise and if they fully understand the identity in which they work if it had increased the sense of belonging. since the tool would also be consulted by the users of the services, it was important to understand whether a better form of communication had changed the forms of behaviour. through a more discursive approach another topic that created interest was to understand if there were any obstacles to achieving the objective by trying to understand how it influenced the company. 3.2. case study – context the social enterprise in question puts the creation of employment for its members, who are among the types of people defined in the social context as "fragile" through the collection of waste, first. the company has historically focused on activities with characteristics aimed at simplifying work to promote the qualified workforce, to allow workers to keep pace with the market, monitoring the results, solid assumptions to ensure the economic independence of people, always placing employment and social repercussions of the territory of intervention at the center of their choices. the services related to waste range from paper collection to bulky waste, asbestos removal, collection and disposal of raee and plastic and glass reception and social housing service. the information was collected through interviews with members, staff, through the company's website and citizens who use the service. in addition, the financial report of the last five years has been analysed to support accountability. about accountability supported by financial statement data, it was possible to understand that the company is solid and stable from an economic point of view. revenues from service activities can be kept constant by always recording important profits reinvested in new activities. the company recorded a significant improvement in the ebitda, ros, roa, roa and roe indices and confirmed the company's solidity, as can be seen from the interviews that will be analysed in the section. 4. presentation of results this section summarizes the results of the case, showing the outputs of the respondents and the connections that emerged between the strengths of the social enterprise. the interviews made and the comments received confirmed the theory that literature has led to deepen (curtis et al., 2010). http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/4486 published by university of turin) ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index 11 respondents confirmed that the strengths of the company that has shown on several occasions has had the best results on the trust aspect. thirty years of experience and business leadership has shown that governance is solid and, above all, it is flexible to any unexpected event in the market, since thanks to their expertise they are able to adapt and shape business with the market, confirming the concepts of al-khasawneh and futa (2012) and alshammari et al. (2015). the concept of good governance as treated by fernández-fernández (1999) and norman (2014) is confirmed by saying that the governance structure is solid and has good internal management of responsibilities. the members of the company are aware of this because, in addition to seeing it from the numbers, they perceive the internal and external organisational strength. it was therefore possible to link to the literature that the search for daily innovation is a key factor within the studied organization. this factor is perceived and above all demonstrated. it was interesting to understand the differences in perception of social enterprise because there were opinions of strong trust from within. the externals were divided between those who knew the company and therefore appreciating the work of inclusion and those who used only the city service which are often linked by a prejudice of the category as studied by andrews and van de walle (2013). when it was explained that the social mission is to put the worker in first place and the great work is aimed at the welfare of members was shown to be the gap in the lack of that type of information as stated by freeman (2010). this type of perception prevailed over financial, non-financial and above all social impact data. those who knew the subject had a better perception, the non-experts did not have the full picture sometimes clouded by prejudice, as mentioned before, which did not even lead to deepen confirming what was said by adams (2000) and biancone et al. (2018d) about participation thanks to good reporting. for those who did not have clear concepts of social impact and therefore what was done for the ecosystem by the social enterprise underwent a change of attitude and a propensity to cooperate to participate in improving through their contribution by informing themselves of the ways approaching the concepts of adams (2000) and alshammari et al., (2015) about the cornerstones of ethical finance. as in the studies of biancone et al. (2017b, 2018d, 2019b) the idea of a group is strong and defines a point in favour of defining a good accounting policy in order to give the perception of being responsible and transparent. governance is aware that everyone has the right and the desire to know more about the company, both internally and externally, as confirmed by the studies of freeman (2010), carroll (1996) and biancone et al. (2016). as highlighted in the literature, mapping stakeholders increases the range of action of information and therefore becomes an effective reporting tool. in fact, valuable information has emerged that professional users believe is enough to existing accounting tools as they are able to read them and deepen through other analysis of information not in evidence. nonprofessional users, on the other hand, considered the existing tools difficult to understand and unrepresentative. clearly dictated by the incorrect channel of information. a user-friendly language is preferred and can be enhanced by innovative social media tools. consequently, it emerged that the use of social media was always present, confirming the theory of biancone et al. (2018a) in which citizen participation increases with the use of computer tools. in their studies they show that the factor that determines a participation of families is the simple connection to the internet because it has been shown that this element is enough to create in users an active participation in the digital world. therefore, an interesting starting point was the request to adapt "information in pills" that have accustomed to receiving social media. the territory is having a propensity to social orientation and social impact and therefore a good reporting tool can help to increase the propensity to social innovation of the ecosystem. summarizing the key factors that emerged from the literature and confirmed by the interviews, the company that was the subject of the case study confirmed the theoretical framework. good governance, leadership, performance and social impact are the information that stakeholders perceive as a translation of responsibility and transparency of the social enterprise, creating in them an increase in positive perception and consequently in active participation. figure 3 summarizes the concepts in this section. http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/4486 published by university of turin) ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index 12 figure 3. simplification of results source: author’s elaboration 5. discussion and conclusion 5.1. contributions to the literature in order to develop a sustainable approach to international growth, social enterprises must continue to learn from experience and adapt during their internationalization and connect all stakeholders with innovative reporting tools. as presented above, this process is the subject of this study. in this work, it defines the key factors that a social enterprise should have in order to obtain a reporting tool oriented to communicate financial data and social impact and determine which factors stakeholders would want to know in order to be heard included. in this way, it meets the need for transparency and accountability used for public authorities (hartmann, 2019; presenza et al., 2014) and the way they inform subsequent internationalisation practices (biancone et al., 2019a; owen et al., 2000). the results contextualize and extend the conceptual work by suggesting that social enterprises rely on their dynamic capacity to learn from their experiences and to adapt their practices in the process of solidifying good governance and leadership to generate performance and social impact and make the model replicable and scalable. it is found that this type of structure is able to perceive and manage the "need" of stakeholders and efforts would be in vain if they could not be linked to the company. a good reporting tool as presented in the literature can guide the right theory of change (castello & lévêque, 2016; kail & lumley, 2012). by responding to needs and communicating in the right way, the company generates transparency and accountability in its stakeholders by triggering a proactive form of these stakeholders who, through their participation, are able to improve the structure of the social enterprise which in turn manages the whole process described [figure 2]. therefore, having such key factors, however difficult to achieve, provides an initial basis for subsequent adaptation to the process. in this sense, the results add a nuance to the vision that structured reporting brings with it positive strategic effects for the company that uses it and for all stakeholders generating an evolution of all (calò et al., 2018; owen et al., 2000; zamagni et al., 2015). in essence, the transition from one phase of development of key factors to the next does not happen by default. instead, the study must take an active role in monitoring the management process aimed at selecting the appropriate human capital, engaging in continuous reflection, critical evaluation, adaptation of criteria for its requirements, adaptation of good practices. this http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/4486 published by university of turin) ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index 13 selection is also fundamental in the choice of the reporting tool that creates a mechanism of trust in all readers (professional and non-professional) (biancone et al., 2019a, 2019b). 5.2. implications for managers the results demonstrate that the benefits of a good company structure linked to an excellent reporting tool are not necessarily automatic and may require dedicated effort and procedures. based on the preliminary evidence of the study and if supported by further research, social enterprise decision-makers can improve the effects of their actions internally and externally, even when reflection on good practice is not perceived as urgent. the results suggest that these micro-processes can be supported by an entrepreneurial attitude that allows business managers to regularly take stock of the situation and to be ready to act quickly, being aware of the financial and non-financial data of their company, especially in a language that is certainly accessible. too often smaller companies that launch themselves on the market do not have the time and resources to make these assessments and this can lead to inefficiencies that last longer than necessary, resulting in waste of resources and poor returns, as well as reducing opportunities for learning and adapting practices. in the specific context, good reporting practices consist in using human capital with increasingly specific combinations of skills and know-how. the manager must select the human capital for the implementation of these activities, otherwise he or she will have to provide external professionals for the implementation. 5.3. limitations and future research the demonstrated scenario has a strong illustrative and exploratory potential and the phases that the study identifies can be adapted to other contexts (welch, 2012). the same applies to the transfer of context-specific notions of good governance, leadership, performance, social impact and especially reporting requirements. there may also be other companies that have similar characteristics to our context, but have different business models and industry regulations, so these results should be transferred to these contexts with caution. the purpose of our exploratory study is to provide insights that other scholars can draw on and explore further in the theory development process. therefore, this study invite scholars to investigate the transferability of our insights and provide several promising avenues for future research. first of all, the resercher ask ourselves whether the starting point from stakeholder needs and through a good reporting tool can generate in them transparency and accountability can be applied to all non-profit but also profit contexts, since the current literature provides us with further distinctions in this category: for impact and without impact(calderini et al., 2018; clark et al., 2004; meneguzzo, 2005). secondly, the results strongly suggest that the effectiveness of reporting increases the speed of stakeholder engagement with the company. third, to arrive at more general conclusions, the 2030 goals that the world is running towards seem to be set by large institutions and public bodies. social enterprises, which are the engine of social impact, can certainly contribute to this and trying to provide a dashboard of the sdgs business format can help generate global development from the local. i would welcome further empirical studies that investigate the impact of good reporting tools on the global goals that humanity must now aim for (biancone et al., 2018a; welch, 2012). in conclusion, with the aim of answering the question “define the key factors that a social enterprise should have in order to obtain a reporting tool oriented to the communication of financial data and social impact and determine which factors stakeholders would like to know in order to be heard included”, the research confirm that a good reporting tool that is representative and that above all is understandable even to non-professional users only works if it is able to give an effective group representation if it puts the first place: the need. this condition increase accountability, transparency and stakeholder engagement. stakeholders would be able to better understand the strong values of good governance, leadership, performance and social impact that the company possesses. in order to define the field of innovation and identify the social value of the company, which is returned to the ecosystem of the territory, it is important and helpful to define the business model as a tool that can facilitate (or not) the spread of innovation in the system. the value inherent in an innovation remains latent until it is put on the market or otherwise explicit and this can http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/4486 published by university of turin) ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index 14 only happen through the use of a business model (chesbrough & rosenbloom, 2002). through the research project conducted so far has been possible to demonstrate that in social enterprises to have an effective measurement of impact must use all possible tools to know and describe the company and the ecosystem that surrounds it and this is possible through timely reporting that it returns clear information for all. we must not forget that a tool such as popular financial reporting is also aimed at non-experts, generating responsibility, transparency and social impact. stakeholders, therefore, will need increasingly advanced tools because the economic evaluation of the social impact becomes crucial in the knowledge economy. references adams, c. (2000). ethical reporting: past and future. management accounting: magazine for chartered management accountants, 78, 48–50. al-khasawneh, a. l., & futa, s. m. (2012). the impact of leadership styles used by the academic staff in the jordanian public universities on modifying students’ behavior: a field study in the northern \ldots. \ldots journal of business and management. http://www.ccsenet.org/journal/index.php/ijbm/article/viewfile/20543/14736 alshammari, a., almutairi, n. n., & thuwaini, s. f. (2015). ethical leadership: the effect on employees. \ldots business and management. http://www.ccsenet.org/journal/index.php/ijbm/article/view/43586 alter, k. (2004). social enterprise typology: the four lenses strategic framework. virtue ventures llc. andrews, r., & van de walle, s. (2013). new public management and citizens’ perceptions of local service efficiency, responsiveness, equity and effectiveness. public management review, 15(5), 762–783. https://doi.org/10.1080/14719037.2012.725757 andriof, j., waddock, s., husted, b., & rahman, s. s. (2002). unfolding stakeholder thinking: theory, responsibility and engagement (1 edition). routledge. austin, j. e. (2000). strategic collaboration between nonprofits and businesses. nonprofit and voluntary sector quarterly, 29(1_suppl), 69–97. awotundun, d. a., kehinde, j. s., & somoye, r. o. c. (2011). corporate governance and stakeholders interest: a case of nigerian banks. international journal of business and management. http://www.ccsenet.org/journal/index.php/ijbm/article/viewfile/12506/8848 ayob, n., teasdale, s., & fagan, k. (2016). how social innovation ‘came to be’: tracing the evolution of a contested concept. journal of social policy, 45(4), 635–653. badia, f., dicuonzo, g., petruzzelli, s., & dell’atti, v. (2018). integrated reporting in action: mobilizing intellectual capital to improve management and governance practices. journal of management and governance, 1–22. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10997-018-9420-1 berman, s. l., wicks, a. c., kotha, s., & jones, t. m. (1999). does stakeholder orientation matter? the relationship between stakeholder management models and firm financial performance. academy of management journal, 42(5), 488–506. bezzi, c. (2001). valutazione partecipata nei servizi. prospettive sociali e sanitarie, 6. biancone, p., & secinaro, s. (2015). popular financial reporting: un nuovo strumento di rendicontazione per le municipalità. giappichelli. https://iris.unito.it/handle/2318/1557120#.wqkbkejoxiu biancone, p., secinaro, s., & brescia, v. (2016). the popular financial reporting: focus on stakeholders—the first european experience. international journal of business and management, 11(11), 115. https://doi.org/10.5539/ijbm.v11n11p115 biancone, p., secinaro, s., & brescia, v. (2017a). l’informazione consolidata e gli indicatori bes: strumenti per una rendicontazione più accessibile ai cittadini. l’esperienza italiana del popular financial. rivista italiana di ragioneria e di economia aziendale, 339 – 354. biancone, p., secinaro, s., & brescia, v. (2017b). the popular financial reporting and gender accountability, the integrated approach in municipalities and public bodies. american international journal of contemporary research, 7, 1–11. biancone, p., secinaro, s., brescia, v., & iannaci, d. (2018a). communication and data processing in local public group: transparency and accountability. international journal of business and management, 13(10), 20–37. http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/4486 published by university of turin) ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index 15 biancone, p., secinaro, s., brescia, v., & iannaci, d. (2018b). popular financial reporting, a new information tool for social cooperatives. franco angeli. https://iris.unito.it/handle/2318/1701273#.xubdgugzbiu biancone, p., secinaro, s., brescia, v., & iannaci, d. (2018c). the popular financial reporting as tool to measure social impact. 14th interdisciplinary conference on intangibles and intellectual capital value creation, integrated reporting and governance, munich. biancone, p., secinaro, s., brescia, v., & iannaci, d. (2018d, september 13). popular financial reporting, a new information tool for social cooperatives. convegno nazionale sidrea 2018 università degli studi di verona, verona. biancone, p., secinaro, s., brescia, v., & iannaci, d. (2019a). the popular financial reporting between theory and evidence. biancone, p., secinaro, s., brescia, v., & iannaci, d. (2019b). la misurazione dell’impatto sociale nelle organizzazioni ibride. xiii. bicciato, f. (2010). finanza etica e impresa sociale. società editrice il mulino, spa. billis, d. (2010). hybrid organizations and the third sector: challenges for practice, theory and policy. macmillan international higher education. borzaga, c. (2002). sull’impresa sociale. issan working papers, 19. borzaga, c., & santuari, a. (2003). new trends in the non-profit sector in europe: the emergence of social entrepreneurship. the non-profit sector in a changing economy, 31–59. borzaga, c., & tortia, e. (2004). dalla cooperazione mutualistica alla cooperazione sociale: una prospettiva internazionale. impresa sociale, 44–56. brescia, v. (2019). the popular financial reporting: new accounting tool for italian municipalities. franco angeli. bryson, j. m., & roering, w. d. (1987). applying private-sector strategic planning in the public sector. journal of the american planning association, 53(1), 9–22. calderini, m., chiodo, v., & michelucci, f. v. (2018). growing social impact finance: implications for the public sector. in positive impact investing (pp. 27–38). springer. calderini, m., franzoni, c., & vezzulli, a. (2007). if star scientists do not patent: the effect of productivity, basicness and impact on the decision to patent in the academic world. research policy, 36(3), 303–319. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.respol.2006.11.007 calò, f., teasdale, s., donaldson, c., roy, m. j., & baglioni, s. (2018). collaborator or competitor: assessing the evidence supporting the role of social enterprise in health and social care. public management review, 20(12), 1790–1814. campbell, d. t. (1986). relabeling internal and external validity for applied social scientists. new directions for program evaluation, 1986(31), 67–77. carroll, a. b. (1996). business and society-ethics and stakeholder management. south-western publishing co. castello, s., & lévêque, c. m. (2016). la theory of change come impact-model: diffusione e utilizzo a livello nazionale e internazionale. philanthropy insights, 4. fondazione lang italia. http://en.fondazionelangitalia.it/ wpcontent/uploads/2016/03/philanthropy-insights-n_4.pdf caulier-grice, j., davies, a., patrick, r., norman, w., & foundation, y. (2012). social innovation overview. part one: defining social innovation. chesbrough, h., & rosenbloom, r. s. (2002). the role of the business model in capturing value from innovation: evidence from xerox corporation’s technology spin-off companies. industrial and corporate change, 11(3), 529–555. civera, c., de colle, s., & casalegno, c. (2019). stakeholder engagement through empowerment: the case of coffee farmers. business ethics: a european review, 28(2), 156–174. clark, c., & rosenzweig, w. (2004). double bottom line project report. university of california, berkeley. clark, c., rosenzweig, w., long, d., & olsen, s. (2004). double bottom line project report: assessing social impact in double bottom line ventures. clarkson, m. e. (1995). a stakeholder framework for analyzing and evaluating corporate social performance. academy of management review, 20(1), 92–117. http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/4486 published by university of turin) ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index 16 corvo, l., & pastore, l. (2018). la costellazione del valore: approcci collaborativi oltre porter. colloquio scientifico sull’impresa sociale, innovazione dei framework interpretativi e teorici(xii). curtis, t., herbst, j., & gumkovska, m. (2010). the social economy of trust: social entrepreneurship experiences in poland. social enterprise journal, 6(3), 194–209. dart, r. (2004). the legitimacy of social enterprise. nonprofit management and leadership, 14(4), 411–424. dhanani, a., & connolly, c. (2012). discharging not-for-profit accountability: uk charities and public discourse. accounting, auditing & accountability journal, 25(7), 1140–1169. donaldson, t., & preston, l. e. (1995). the stakeholder theory of the corporation: concepts, evidence, and implications. academy of management review, 20(1), 65–91. ebrahim, a. (2003). accountability in practice: mechanisms for ngos. world development, 31(5), 813–829. ecchia, g., & zarri, l. (2005). capitale sociale e accountability: il ruolo del bilancio di missione nella governance delle organizzazioni non-profit. http://www.academia.edu/download/34192803/n.3.pdf edwards, m., & hulme, d. (2014). non-governmental organisations-performance and accountability: beyond the magic bullet. routledge. eisenhardt, k. m. (1989). building theories from case study research. academy of management review, 14(4), 532–550. farmer, j., hill, c., & muñoz, s.-a. (2012). community co-production: social enterprise in remote and rural communities. edward elgar publishing. fernández-fernández, j.-l. (1999). ethics and the board of directors in spain: the olivencia code of good governance. journal of business ethics, 22(3), 233–247. fornaciari, l. (2017). gruppi aziendali e bilancio consolidato in italia. g giappichelli editore. https://books.google.it/books?hl=it&lr=&id=bsw6dwaaqbaj&oi=fnd&pg=pa85&dq=•%09fornaciari,+l.+(2017).+grup pi+aziendali+e+bilancio+consolidato+in+italia+(vol.+6).+g+giappichelli+editore&ots=1ovufna8_f&sig=plkm2htjqu go5036xans5iqxfpa freeman, r. e. (1984). strategic management: a stakeholder approach. pitman. freeman, r. e. (2010). strategic management: a stakeholder approach. cambridge university press. freeman, r. e., & gilbert, d. r. (1988). corporate strategy and the search for ethics. prentice hall englewood cliffs, nj. freeman, r. e., harrison, j. s., wicks, a. c., parmar, b. l., & de colle, s. (2010). stakeholder theory: the state of the art. cambridge university press. freudenreich, b., lüdeke-freund, f., & schaltegger, s. (2019). a stakeholder theory perspective on business models: value creation for sustainability. journal of business ethics, 1–16. friedman, s. (2014). the hidden tastemakers: comedy scouts as cultural brokers at the edinburgh festival fringe. poetics, 44, 22–41. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.poetic.2014.04.002 garrow, e., & hasenfeld, y. (2012). managing conflicting institutional logics: social service versus market. in social enterprises (pp. 121–143). springer. goldoff, a. c. (2000). decision-making in organizations: the new paradigm. international journal of public administration, 23(11), 2017–2044. https://doi.org/10.1080/01900690008525535 grimsey, d., & lewis, m. k. (2002). evaluating the risks of public private partnerships for infrastructure projects. international journal of project management, 20(2), 107–118. grossi, g., & thomasson, a. (2015). bridging the accountability gap in hybrid organizations: the case of copenhagen malmö port. international review of administrative sciences, 81(3), 604–620. https://doi.org/10.1177/0020852314548151 haigh, n., & hoffman, a. j. (2012). hybrid organizations: the next chapter of sustainable business. organizational dynamics, 41(2), 126–134. hartmann, s. (2019). citizen relationship management for civic participation: how smart cities use 311 to involve citizens. public administration and information technology, 34, 59–77. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-89474-4_4 hermann, k. r. (2011). creating an excellent popular financial report. government finance review, 27.5, 41–44. hillman, a. j., & keim, g. d. (2001). shareholder value, stakeholder management, and social issues: what’s the bottom line? strategic management journal, 22(2), 125–139. how, s.-m., lee, c. g., & brown, d. m. (2019). shareholder theory versus stakeholder theory in explaining financial soundness. international advances in economic research, 25(1), 133–135. http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/4486 published by university of turin) ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index 17 hubert, a. (2010). empowering people, driving change: social innovation in the european union. bureau of european policy advisors (bepa). available online: http://ec. europa. eu/bepa/pdf/publications_pdf/social_innovation. pdf. jiang, w., wang, a. x., zhou, k. z., & zhang, c. (2019). stakeholder relationship capability and firm innovation: a contingent analysis. journal of business ethics, 1–15. kail, a., & lumley, t. (2012). theory of change: the beginning of making a difference. new philanthropy capital. kirk, j., miller, m. l., & miller, m. l. (1986). reliability and validity in qualitative research (vol. 1). sage. kleynjans, l., & hudon, m. (2016). a study of codes of ethics for mexican microfinance institutions. journal of business ethics, 134(3), 397–412. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10551-014-2434-y lan, z., & hal, g. r. (1992). goals, rules, and effectiveness in public, private, and hybrid organizations: more evidence on frequent assertions about differences. journal of public administration research and theory. https://doi.org/10.1093/oxfordjournals.jpart.a037111 lehner, o. m., & nicholls, a. (2014). social finance and crowdfunding for social enterprises: a public–private case study providing legitimacy and leverage. venture capital, 16(3), 271–286. https://doi.org/10.1080/13691066.2014.925305 leonard-barton, d. (1990). a dual methodology for case studies: synergistic use of a longitudinal single site with replicated multiple sites. organization science, 1(3), 248–266. mair, j., mayer, j., & lutz, e. (2015). navigating institutional plurality: organizational governance in hybrid organizations. organization studies, 36(6), 713–739. manetti, g. (2011). the quality of stakeholder engagement in sustainability reporting: empirical evidence and critical points. corporate social responsibility and environmental management, 18(2), 110–122. marradi, a. (1992). concetti e metodo pre la ricerca sociale. la giuntina. mauksch, s., dey, p., rowe, m., & teasdale, s. (2017). ethnographies of social enterprise. social enterprise journal. https://doi.org/10.1108/sej-03-2017-0019 meneguzzo, m. (2005). creazione di valore e sviluppo del capitale sociale. rivista italiana di ragioneria e di economia aziendale. mitchell, r. k., agle, b. r., & wood, d. j. (1997). toward a theory of stakeholder identification and salience: defining the principle of who and what really counts. academy of management review, 22(4), 853–886. https://doi.org/10.5465/amr.1997.9711022105 montesi, f., greco, c., montesi, f., & seganti, s. (2017). innova guida pratica per il terzo settore. human foundation. najam, a. (2002). financing sustainable development: crises of legitimacy. progress in development studies, 2(2), 153– 160. nguyen, l., szkudlarek, b., & seymour, r. g. (2015). social impact measurement in social enterprises: an interdependence perspective. canadian journal of administrative sciences/revue canadienne des sciences de l’administration, 32(4), 224– 237. norman, d. j. (2014). from shouting to counting: civil society and good governance reform in cambodia. the pacific review, 1–24. https://doi.org/10.1080/09512748.2014.882393 owen, d., & swift, t. (2001). introduction social accounting, reporting and auditing: beyond the rhetoric? business ethics: a european review, 10(1), 4–8. owen, d., swift, t., humphrey, c., & bowerman, m. (2000). the new social audits: accountability, managerial capture or the agenda of social champions? european accounting review, 9(1), 81–98. pearce, j. (2009). social economy: engaging as a third system. the social economy: international perspectives on economic solidarity, london: zed books ltd, 22–33. perry, j. l., & rainey, h. g. (1988). the public-private distinction in organization theory: a critique and research strategy. academy of management review, 13(2), 182–201. pestoff, v. (2014). hybridity, coproduction, and third sector social services in europe. american behavioral scientist, 58(11), 1412–1424. pisoni, p., biancone, p., busso, d., & cisi, m. (2007). il bilancio consolidato ias/ifrs. a. giuffrè editore. https://books.google.it/books?hl=it&lr=&id=ym_dez_ldhwc&oi=fnd&pg=pa8&dq=•%09pisoni,+p.,+biancone,+p.,+bu sso,+d.,+%26+cisi,+m.+(2007).+il+bilancio+consolidato+ias.+ifrs,+giuffrè,+milano&ots=pmpcrdudi5&sig=ywmqrjquiodk755m3idrb2s0xi#v=onepage&q&f=false http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/4486 published by university of turin) ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index 18 presenza, a., micera, r., splendiani, s., & chiappa, g. d. (2014). stakeholder e-involvement and participatory tourism planning: analysis of an italian case study. international journal of knowledge-based development, 5(3), 311–328. https://doi.org/10.1504/ijkbd.2014.065320 rehn, a. (2008). pop (culture) goes the organization: on highbrow, lowbrow and hybrids in studying popular culture within organization studies. organization, 15(5), 765–783. https://doi.org/10.1177/1350508408093652 roberts, r. w. (1992). determinants of corporate social responsibility disclosure: an application of stakeholder theory. accounting, organizations and society, 17(6), 595–612. rousseau, j.-j. (2015). il contratto sociale. edizioni mondadori. sangle, s. (2010). critical success factors for corporate social responsibility: a public sector perspective. corporate social responsibility and environmental management, 17(4), 205–214. skelcher, c., & smith, s. r. (2017). new development: performance promises and pitfalls in hybrid organizations—five challenges for managers and researchers. public money & management, 37(6), 425–430. https://doi.org/10.1080/09540962.2017.1344023 smith, s. r., & phillips, s. d. (2016). the changing and challenging environment of nonprofit human services: implications for governance and program implementation. nonprofit policy forum, 7, 63–76. stake, r. e. (1995). the art of case study research. sage. stanton, t. h. (2004). when government isn’t exactly government. jonathan g. s. koppell. 2003. the politics of quasigovernment: hybrid organizations and the dynamics of bureaucratic control. cambridge, england: cambridge university press. 254 pp. journal of public administration research and theory, 14(3), 435–437. https://doi.org/10.1093/jopart/muh027 steiner, a., & teasdale, s. (2016). the playground of the rich? growing social business in the 21st century. social enterprise journal, 12(2), 201–216. https://doi.org/10.1108/sej-12-2015-0036 strand, r., & freeman, r. e. (2015). scandinavian cooperative advantage: the theory and practice of stakeholder engagement in scandinavia. journal of business ethics, 127(1), 65–85. svendsen, a. (1998). the stakeholder strategy: profiting from collaborative business relationships. berrett-koehler publishers. ullmann, a. a. (1985). data in search of a theory: a critical examination of the relationships among social performance, social disclosure, and economic performance of us firms. academy of management review, 10(3), 540–557. vining, a., & weimer, d. (2016). the challenges of fractionalized property rights in public-private hybrid organizations: the good, the bad, and the ugly. regulation & governance, 10(2), 161–178. waddock, s. a. (2002). leading corporate citizens: vision, values, value-added. mcgraw-hill/irwin boston, ma. wainwright, t., & manville, g. (2017). financialization and the third sector: innovation in social housing bond markets. environment and planning a, 49(4), 819–838. welch, e. w. (2012). the relationship between transparent and participative government: a study of local governments in the united states. international review of administrative sciences, 78(1), 93–115. windsor, d. (2002). stakeholder responsibilities: lessons for managers. the journal of corporate citizenship, 19–36. yin, r. k. (1981). the case study as a serious research strategy. knowledge, 3(1), 97–114. yin, r. k. (2014). case study research: design and methods (fifth). london, uk: sage publications ltd. yin, r. k. (2017). case study research and applications: design and methods. sage publications. zamagni, s. (2013). territorio, istituzioni, crescita: la ripresa d’interesse nella ricerca economica. fratesi u., pellegrini g.(a cura di), territorio, istituzioni, crescita. scienze regionali e sviluppo del paese, milano, francoangeli, 39–56. zamagni, s., venturi, p., & rago, s. (2015). valutare l’impatto sociale. la questione della misurazione nelle imprese sociali. rivista impresa sociale. http://www.rivistaimpresasociale.it/rivista/item/141-misurazione-impatto-sociale.html 5067-article text-16398-2-11-20201216 http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5067 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 84 artificial intelligence to fight covid-19 outbreak impact: an overview davide calandra1 and matteo favareto1 1 department of management, university of turin, turin, italy corresponding author: matteo favareto – matteo.favareto@unito.it received: 27/08/2020 revised: 18/11/2020 accepted for publication: 18/11/2020 published: 18/12/2020 abstract artificial intelligence (ai) is showing its strength worldwide in the healthcare sector. today, in the aftermath of the covid-19 pandemic, the help of technology appears to be relevant to keep the increase in new infections stable and help medical staff in treatment. therefore, this paper aims to investigate how ai can be employed against covid-19 outbreak. using a multiple case study approach, researchers find out the following insights. first, ai could be used for drugs discovery and knowledge sharing, tracking and prediction, clinical decision making and diagnosis, social distancing and medical chatbots. second, this paper provides an in-depth analysis of international best practice for tracking contacts and social distance applications. third, ai technologies could have a transversal impact, also focusing on prevention strategies as a new corporate social responsibility vein. in the end, this paper has theoretical and managerial implications, too. on the theoretical side, we contribute to the extensive discussion about ai and healthcare considering covid-19 outbreak. on the practical side, we provide medical personnel and policymakers with a tool to understand artificial intelligence and focus investment choices in the practical applications analysed. keywords: artificial intelligence; ai applications; covid-19; coronavirus; health impact; prevention strategies 1. introduction the novel coronavirus disease (covid-19) has created tremendous chaos around the world, affecting people’s lives and causing many deaths. the first cases were detected in wuhan, china, in december 2019, and now it has been spread to almost every country (nguyen, 2020). with this growing crisis, companies and researchers over the world are looking for the ways to address the challenges of this virus considering companies and health issue, to mitigate the spread and develop a cure for this disease (secinaro et al., 2020). in this baffling battle, science, and artificial intelligence (ai) technologies are playing a vital role (kumar et al., 2020). ai commonly refers to the computational technologies that mimic or simulate processes supported with human intelligence, for instance, reasoning, deep learning, adaptation, interaction, and sensory understanding (tran et al., 2019). these are technologies that can perform a task that usually requires human perception and judgement (hamid, 2016). these techniques have an interdisciplinary approach and can be applied to different fields, such as medicine and health. ai has been used in the field of medicine since as early as the 1950s when physicians made the first attempts to improve their diagnoses using computer-aided programs (frankish & ramsey, 2014). the interest and advances in medical ai applications have surged in recent years, thanks to the substantially enhanced computing power of modern computers and the vast amount of digital data now available for collection and utilisation (tran et al., 2019). ai is gradually changing medical practice. there are several applications of ai in medicine, and they can be used in a variety of medical fields such as: clinical, diagnostical, rehabilitative, surgical and predictive (jiang et al., 2017; hamid, 2016). as suggested by shi et al. (2020), ai could play an essential role in covid-19 increasing efficiency during working activities and for disease diagnosis, tracking contacts and prognosis. despite the importance of this field, no studies reviews and discusses the role of ai in tracking services. therefore, this paper aims to investigate how ai can be employed against covid-19 outbreak, answering to the following questions: what are companies and labs, around the world, doing to fight covid-19 outbreak? what could be the central role of ai against covid-19? to answer these challenging questions, researchers use a multiple case study theoretical and practical approach to developing the topic. we present the main fields where ai is currently being used and some organisations that are involved in those areas of research. http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5067 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 86 finally, the paper is organised as follows. section 2 will assess an in-depth literature review on the role of ai against covid-19 outbreak. section 3 elaborates on the methodology. section 4 presents the main results obtained. finally, section 5 will discuss and conclude the paper with future implication for research. 2. literature review 2.1 covid-19 and the need for ai technologies to support the research naudé (2020); vaishya et al. (2020); yassine & shan (2020) proposed studies in which they analysed how ai technologies can be used in the fight against covid-19 outbreak. as stated by yassine & shan (2020), artificial intelligence is one of the means or avenues to understand the virus and develop preventative and control measures. it includes but is not limited to the usage of mathematical modelling to understand virus transmission, structural biology to determine virus structure and develop vaccines, computational biology to understand virus evolution, as well as docking studies to screen for drugs and inhibitors. ai has the potential to help in all the stages of healthcare, from syndromic surveillance through to rapid diagnosis tests, and faster drug development (naudé, 2020; vaishya et al., 2020; yassine & shan 2020). according to kumar et al. (2020), ai technologies are fundamental tools for tracking and monitoring covid-19 spread around the world. these technologies are helping in diagnosing the virus and in processing the healthcare claims. tracking the spread of covid-19 can be a piece of essential information for public health authorities to design, plan, and deal with the pandemic (kumar et al., 2020). as stated by lalmuanawma et al. (2020), contact tracing is a crucial aspect to prevent a wider spread of covid19. the process of contact tracing is to identify and manage people who are recently exposed to an infected covid-19 patient to avoid further spread. in this regard, various infected countries come up with a digital contact tracing process with the mobile application, utilising different technologies. all these digital apps are designed to collect individual personal data, which will be analysed by ai tools to trace a person who is vulnerable to the novel virus due to their recent contacted chain (lalmuanawma et al., 2020). pham et al. (2020); bragazzi et al. (2020) dealt with how big data and artificial intelligence can help better manage the covid-19 pandemic. thanks to the latest advancements in the field of computational techniques and information and communication technologies (icts), artificial intelligence and big data http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5067 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 87 can help handle the vast, unprecedented amount of data derived from public health surveillance, real-time epidemic outbreaks monitoring, trend now-casting/forecasting, regular situation briefing and updating from governmental institutions and organisms, and health resources utilisation information (bragazzi et al., 2020). according to pham et al. (2020) in the context of covid-19, big data refers to the patient care data such as physician notes, x-ray reports, case history, list of doctors and nurses, and information of outbreak areas. same authors stated that big data potentially provide several promising solutions to help combat covid-19 epidemic. by combining with ai analytics, big data help to understand the covid19 in terms of outbreak tracking, virus structure, disease treatment, and vaccine manufacturing. divya et al. (2018); ahuja et al. (2020) analysed another relevant topic linked with ai and covid-19: ai-powered chatbots and virtual health assistants. while ai may assist in the discovery of novel drugs and vaccines, it can also help ease the stress placed on medical hotlines. call centres nationwide that are dealing with the covid-19 pandemic are notoriously understaffed. artificial intelligence has the potential to revolutionise public communications and deliver alternative methods to dissipate public information. ai-powered chatbots have been used with success in clinical scenarios and can advise many more people than a staffed call centre. in conclusion, ai-powered chatbots and virtual health assistants are fostering social distancing and streamlining the entire clinical process (divya et al. 2018; ahuja et al., 2020). according to mahomed (2020); sun & zhai (2020); nguyen et al. (2020), ai can be used to control social distancing. as stated by sun & zhai (2020); mahomed (2020), social distancing avoids direct contacts among people and reduces the potential cross-transmission of virus-carrying droplets from human respiration. by nguyen et al. (2020) ai technologies play a crucial role in social distancing control. for instance, they allow public place monitoring and can detect, recognise, and identify whether people comply with social distancing requirements or not. zhavoronkov et al. (2020); mohanty et al. (2020) dealt with the topic of ai applications to find out new drugs and treatments. ai can be used to initiate drug discovery and fast-track drug development. these technologies have the potential to improve the drug discovery, planning, treatment, and reported outcomes of the covid-19 patient, being evidence-based medical tools. according to mohanty et al. (2020), ai can help, as well, in drug repurposing process. drug “repurposing” refers to the use of existing approved drugs for the treatment of a never-considered therapeutic indication, in this case, covid-19. the aihttp://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5067 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 88 based drug repurposing is a cheaper, faster, and practical approach and can minimise the failures in clinical trials (mohanty et al., 2020; xue et al., 2018). table 1 below shows the list of related work includes in the literature review section. table 1. list of related work references field • naudé (2020); vaishya et al. (2020); yassine & shan (2020) • kumar et al. (2020); lalmuanawma et al. (2020) ai applications in the fight against covid-19 ai technologies for monitoring and tracking covid-19 spread • pham et al. (2020); bragazzi et al. (2020) ai and big data for covid-19 fighting • divya et al. (2018); ahuja et al. (2020) • mahomed (2020); sun & zhai (2020); nguyen et al. (2020) • zhavoronkov et al. (2020); mohanty et al. (2020) ai-powered chatbots and virtual health assistants to manage medical call centers and ease public tension ai for social distancing control ai for drugs discovery or repurposing against covid-19 source: authors’ elaboration 3. methodology to implement the analysis, we employed a case study approach to investigate ai applications against covid-19 (mccutcheon & meredith, 1993). for each topic under discussion will be described theoretical items and then practical examples of companies that are currently involved in coronavirus fight. because of the virus and the crucial role of ai, nowadays scientific community and companies are focusing more and more on the topic. there are so many firms and labs that are studying the virus evolution to find out a remedy. for this reason, it would have been difficult to describe all of them. for the best of our knowledge, we chose only some companies, and we described strategies and contribution to fight back against covid-19 spread. as stated before, we decided to employ a case study approach. according to yin (2014), case studies can be defined as qualitative research methods that support researchers when "a how or why the question is being asked about a contemporary set of events over which the investigator has little or no control". besides, qualitative methodologies can usually be better understood by practitioners in leading to managerial practices (dal mas et al., 2019), helping to bridge the gap between academia and practice http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5067 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 89 (massaro et al., 2018). additionally, according to crowe et al. (2011), the collective case study involves studying multiple cases simultaneously or sequentially in an attempt to generate a still broader appreciation of a particular issue. as suggested by granello & wheaton (2004), to collect data, we used different types of online sources: (1) corporate document and materials; (2) scientific papers published in peer-review journals; (3) youtube interview of the founders; (4) newspaper articles. to answer the research questions of this paper, the authors use some study's limitation. furthermore, all the sources extracted should: • deal with ai in healthcare; • link with covid-19 pandemic topic; • describe theoretical and practical outputs in terms of covid-19 response. besides, we searched for papers that use a case study methodology to develop the analysis. using the criteria mentioned above, we used scopus and google scholar as databases. thus, the first one is a broad scope database essential for peer-reviewed and conference proceedings analysis (mongeon & paul-hus, 2016). finally, google scholar is an international open-access database that collects information on academic sources in different fields (falagas et al., 2007). the analysis was implemented using as keywords "artificial intelligence" and "covid-19" or "coronavirus" and following the objective of the article. among the search criteria, we focused on english items that were inherent to the searched object. overall we got 155 documents divided as follows. to describe companies’ projects, we consulted 20 corporate documents published on companies’ official websites. we analysed 55 scientific papers published in peer-review journals, and we watched 15 youtube interviews of the companies’ founders to understand, in a better way, the documents we got and obtaining updates on the topic. besides, we referred, also, to 65 newspaper articles published by international journals, in different countries, and dealing with the specific topic we analysed. figure 1 below shows the methodology used to carry out the analysis. http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5067 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 90 figure 1. characteristics of the analysis source: authors’ elaboration 4. results and discussion ai tools and technologies can be employed to support efforts of policy-makers, the medical community, and society at large to manage every stage of the crisis and its aftermath: detection, prevention, response, recovery and to accelerate research (oecd; naudé, 2020). there are different areas where ai technologies can contribute to the fight against covid-19 (naudé, 2020; vaishya et al., 2020; yassine & shan, 2020): drugs discovery and knowledge sharing (1), tracking and prediction (2), clinical decision-making and diagnosis (3), social distancing control and medical chatbots (4). figure 2 shows dominant variables that have been analysed for ai against covid-19 outbreak. http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5067 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 91 figure 2. dominant variables for ai against covid-19 outbreak source: authors’ elaboration 4.1 ai for drugs discovery and knowledge sharing: the deepmind and insilico medicine case studies the first application of ai to fight the coronavirus is certainly assistance to researchers to develop drugs and treatments to contain the pandemic. even long before the covid-19 outbreak, ai was used for its potential to contribute to new drugs discovery (naudé, 2020). ai technology is used in speeding up drug testing in real-time, where standard testing takes plenty of time and hence helps to accelerate this process significantly, which may not be possible by a human (vaishya et al., 2020). in the case of covid-19, several research labs and data centres have already indicated that they are recruiting ai to search for treatments for a vaccine against covid-19 (naudé, 2020). according to ledford (2020) “it is likely to be one of the biggest drug-making challenges the world has ever faced”. several companies are currently involved in this big challenge, and ai technology certainly can help to understand the virus and to accelerate medical research on drugs and treatments. http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5067 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 92 this case could consider google’s deepmind with the ai-based model alphafold. alphafold system can release structure predictions of several under-studied proteins associated with sars-cov-2, the virus that causes covid-19. deepmind has used ai to predict the structure of the proteins of the virus information that could be useful in developing new drugs (naudé, 2020). us company insilico medicine represents another example. it is a biotechnology company that was able to use its integrated ai-based drug discovery pipeline to generate new drug compounds against covid19. the results revealed a novel method of developing new treatments against covid-19 while also demonstrating cost-effectiveness and time efficiency (zhavoronkov, 2020; mahomed, 2020). through the use of ai technology, the company was able to categorise thousands of molecules for potential medications in only four days, and these data were then made available for free to researchers (mahomed, 2020). also, ai techniques can support physicians to analyse the thousands of research papers published around the world on the pandemic. many promising initiatives, however, have been started to gather and share data and to train new ai models. these include the world health organization’s (who) global research on coronavirus disease database, which also provides links to other similar initiatives. one of these is the open-access data of the gisaid initiative. amongst other initiatives, perhaps the most ambitious is the joint initiative between semantic scholar, the allen institute for artificial intelligence, microsoft, facebook, and others, to make openly available the covid19 open research dataset (cord-19) which contains around 44.000 scholarly articles for data mining (naudé, 2020). 4.2 ai as an observer and predictor of the evolution of the pandemic: the bluedot case study with the help of real-time data analysis, ai can provide updated information which is helpful in the prevention of this disease. it can be used to predict the probable sites of infection, the influx of the virus, need for beds and healthcare professionals during this crisis (vaishya et al., 2020). in this sector, the contribution of the canadian company bluedot has already become remarkable. it is a global ai database company which uses outbreak risk software, combined their health and medical expertise with advanced data analytics to build solutions that track, contextualise and anticipate infectious disease risks (mahomed, 2020). bluedot predicted the outbreak of the infection at the end of 2019, issuing http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5067 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 93 a warning to its clients on 31st of december 2019, before the world health organization did so on 9th of january 2020 (naudé, 2020; kreuzhuber, 2020). bluedot uses an ai-driven algorithm that scours foreign-language news reports, animal and plant disease networks, and official proclamations to give its clients warning to avoid danger zones. bluedot's reports are then sent to public health officials in a dozen countries, airlines, and frontline hospitals where infected patients might end up. bluedot's "global early warning system" combines more than a hundred datasets with proprietary machine learning and natural processing language algorithms in 16 languages, providing an automated surveillance platform that can analyse risks of the virus spread. also, according to the information reported on the council of europe website, several covid-19 apps allow tracking and prediction of the virus spread around the world (table 2). for each country is reported: name of the application (1), main functionality (2) and the origin (3). data are updated on the 10th of june 2020. table 2. overview of covid-19 apps country name of the application main functionality origin argentina covid-19 ministerio de salud self-diagnostic governmental australia coronavirus australia quarantine enforcement governmental australia coronalert alerting governmental australia covidsafe contact tracing governmental austria stoppcorona contact tracing governmental bahrain beaware bahrain quarantine enforcement governmental brazil coronavírus sus information governmental brazil the spread project contact tracing private bulgaria virusafe contact tracing governmental canada canada covid-19 self-diagnostic governmental canada covid shield contact tracing private canada covi contact tracing private chile coronapp self-diagnostic governmental china alipay health code contact tracing private colombia coronapp colombia medical reporting governmental czech republic erouška contact tracing governmental denmark smittestopp contact tracing governmental http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5067 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 94 finland ketju contact tracing private france stopcovid contact tracing governmental france utakecare contact tracing multistakeholder france alertanoo contact tracing private georgia stop covid contact tracing governmental germany coronika contact tracing private germany our health in our hands (ohioh) contact tracing multistakeholder germany ito contact tracing multistakeholder ghana gh covid-19 tracker app na governmental greece docandu covid checker self-diagnostic multistakeholder hong kong stay home safe quarantine enforcement governmental hungary virusradar contact tracing governmental iceland rakning c-19 contact tracing governmental india test yourself goa self-diagnostic governmental india corona watch contact tracing governmental india quarantine watch quarantine enforcement governmental india mahakavach contact tracing governmental india test yourself puducherry self-diagnostic governmental india cova punjab contact tracing governmental india aarogya setu contact tracing governmental india covid-19 feedback medical reporting governmental india covid-19 quarantine monitor contact tracing governmental india gok direct kerala not covid-19 specific app governmental india trackcovid-19.org self-diagnostic private indonesia pedulilindungi contact tracing governmental iran na na governmental israel hamagen contact tracing governmental italy allertalom medical reporting governmental italy diary “digital arianna” contact tracing private italy immuni contact tracing private italy rintraccia dei contatti contact tracing private italy sm-covid-19 contact tracing private italy covidapp covid community alert contact tracing private jordan aman contact tracing governmental kuwait shlonik self-diagnostic governmental latvia apturi covid contact tracing governmental http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5067 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 95 malaysia gerak malaysia contact tracing governmental malaysia mysejahtera information governmental malaysia mytrace contact tracing governmental morocco wiqaytna contact tracing governmental mexico plan jalisco covid-19 contact tracing governmental mexico covid-19mx self-diagnostic governmental netherlands privatetracer contact tracing private north macedonia stopkorona! contact tracing governmental norway smittestopp contact tracing governmental poland kwarantanna domowa quarantine enforcement governmental poland protego contact tracing multistakeholder qatar covi information private republic of angola covid-19 ao quarantine enforcement private russia social monitoring contact tracing private saudi arabia tawakkalna (covid-19 ksa) quarantine enforcement governmental singapore tracetogether contact tracing governmental singapore safeentry contact tracing governmental south africa covi-id contact tracing governmental south korea self-isolator safety protection quarantine enforcement governmental south korea mobile self-diagnosis self-diagnostic governmental south korea self quarantine app quarantine enforcement governmental spain stop covid19 cat information governmental spain covid-19.eus contact tracing governmental spain coronamadrid medical reporting governmental sri lanka self shield quarantine enforcement governmental switzerland alertswiss not covid-19 specific app governmental switzerland swisscovid contact tracing multistakeholder thailand morchana contact tracing governmental turkey korona önlem self-diagnostic governmental ukraine action not covid-19 specific app governmental united arab emirates tawakkalna (covid-19 ksa) quarantine enforcement governmental united kingdom covid symptom study medical reporting private united kingdom nhs app contact tracing governmental united states coalition app contact tracing private united states covid-19 apple app information multistakeholder http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5067 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 96 united states covidsafe contact tracing multistakeholder united states how we feel self-diagnostic private united states private kit: safe paths contact tracing private united states covid watch contact tracing private united states novid contact tracing private united states coepi medical reporting private uruguay coronavirus uy self-diagnostic governmental vietnam covid-19 self-diagnostic governmental source: authors’ elaboration on council of europe data 4.3 ai to support physicians in clinical decision-making and diagnosis: the infervision and alibaba case studies due to a sudden and massive increase in the numbers of patients during covid-19 pandemic, healthcare professionals have a very high workload. here, ai is used to reduce the workload of healthcare workers. it helps in early diagnosis and providing treatment at an early stage using digital approaches and decision science (vaishya et al., 2020). ai applications can support doctors and medical researchers in the clinical decision-making process. according to jiang et al. (2017), ai can assist physicians in making better clinical decisions or even replacing human judgement in specific functional areas of healthcare. for instance, infervision, a chinese high-tech enterprise in artificial medical intelligence, created an ai software that flags possible lung problems on computed tomography (ct) scans, using hundreds of thousands of lung images collected from major chinese hospitals. originally used to diagnose lung cancer, the software is also capable of detecting pneumonia associated with respiratory diseases such as coronavirus. this ai-based technology allows a better understanding of coronavirus cases and makes the process quicker. it represents good support for physicians in their clinical decision-making process. another example is the alibaba damo academy that is dedicated to exploring the unknown through scientific and technological research and innovation. the technology, developed by alibaba damo academy and alibaba cloud, can analyse ct images within 20 seconds for diagnosing suspected novel coronavirus cases with an accuracy rate of 96 per cent. doctors usually spend around 5 to 10 minutes diagnosing ct images of a patient. the ai diagnosis system can ease the already strained hospital resources (pham et al., 2020). http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5067 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 97 finally, robots can be used to support medical professionals in their daily routine; for example, in china, robots that are typically used in the catering industry are used to clean, sterilise, and deliver food and medicines to reduce human contact. the use of ai technologies should not attempt to replace healthcare professionals entirely but rather assist in improving and fast-track diagnosis while alleviating bottlenecks in the healthcare system (mahomed, 2020). 4.4 ai to control social distancing and medical chatbots: the microsoft healthcare bot case study one of the biggest challenges of implementing a defence mechanism against a pandemic is to ensure public participation and acceptance of any mechanism proposed by the authority (young, 2013). physical distancing from one another is a critical part of ensuring that the virus does not spread. ai has been argued to be necessary to manage the pandemic by using thermal imaging to scan public spaces for people potentially infected, and by enforcing social distancing and lockdown measures (rivas, 2020). for example, china's sophisticated surveillance technology uses facial recognition and body temperature to identify whether an individual has a fever and therefore, could be a carrier of the virus (mahomed, 2020). an ai-based computer vision camera system has been used in the uk to monitor adherence by individuals to social distancing measures. more controversially, israel's cyber monitoring system enables its security services to identify and quarantine people who may be infected (naudé, 2020). also, several companies are investing in the development of medical chatbots based on ai. these technologies can screen people and advise whether they should be evaluated for the infection. they enable "at-home risk assessments" in a few minutes. ai-powered virtual health assistants and chatbots, enable self-service, drive better outcomes, and reduce costs (divya et al., 2018). moreover, they can ease the stress placed on medical hotlines (ahuja et al., 2020). chatbots are fostering social distancing and streamlining the entire clinical process. the microsoft healthcare bot is an example of this technology. the service combines built-in medical intelligence with natural language capabilities, extensibility tools and compliance constructs. that service allows healthcare organisations such as providers, payers, pharma, health maintenance organisations (hmos), telehealth to give people access to trusted and relevant healthcare services and information. http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5067 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 98 virtual health assistants and chatbot technology will never replace medical personnel. nevertheless, technology can help make better use of medical personnel's time and relieve some of the burdens from the healthcare system (bitran, 2019). 4.5 ai-based technologies: a transversal impact as we described, ai technologies have a crucial role in the fight against covid-19 and can be used in different ways and applied for a wide range of purposes. ai is not only helpful in the treatment of covid19 infected patients but also for their proper health monitoring (mahomed, 2020). it is also useful to facilitate the research on this virus using the available data. ai can help in developing proper treatment regimens, prevention strategies, drug and vaccine development (vaishya et al., 2020). in this sense, ai-based technologies are essentials because they can generate a positive transversal impact on society and healthcare organisations (naudé, 2020). these technologies, also, can contribute to the optimisation of logistics processes in hospitals and allow a better allocation of resources for firms (jiang et al., 2017). in the end, considering prevention strategies, ai-based technologies can support companies’ enhancing their social responsibility (pan, 2020). in this sense, as discussed by zhao (2018), covid-19 could allow businesses to consider alternative corporate social responsibility challenges. 5. conclusion digital technology, including information technology and ai, are therefore proving to be essential tools to help build a coordinated response to this pandemic. in our research, we focused on central areas of applications where ai technologies are currently impacting against covid-19, and we analysed some practical cases. table 3 shows the elements under discussion and case studies that have been analysed in our paper. from our analysis came up with some crucial insights. first, we described how ai technologies play a crucial role in terms of contact tracing and monitoring of the pandemic spread. for this reason, governments around the world are investing more and more to http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5067 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 99 develop covid-19 apps. these ai-based technologies can allow storage of data that could be useful for tracking “hot zone” and create global alert of high-risk pandemic areas. secondly, we observed that high-tech companies around the world are embracing a more healthcareoriented approach. big players are even more oriented to create a positive impact on society and are developing new technologies that can help to fight the virus. this paper showed that the use of modern technology with ai improved the screening, prediction, contact tracing, forecasting, and drug/vaccine development with extreme reliability (lalmuanawma et al., 2020). considering these platforms assists ai experts to analyse massive datasets and help physicians train machines, set algorithms, or optimise the interpreted data for dealing with the virus with more speed and accuracy (jamshidi et al., 2020). the analysis highlights, as well, that ai techniques are a fundamental tool for clinical decision-making. they can be used in different ways and applied for a wide range of purposes. applications based on ai simplify work for physicians and medical staff providing them meaningful insights. this paper has theoretical and managerial implications; in fact, it could be useful either for researchers or professionals (i.e., policymakers, physicians, managers, healthcare, and administrative staff). we wanted to underline that artificial intelligence applications are fundamental to contain the spread of the virus and to find out a vaccine as soon as possible. analysing some ai applications, we aimed, also, to help healthcare organisations to allocate their financial resources better and investing more in these technologies. finally, we chose to describe ai applications against covid-19 to allow a better understanding of these techniques and help other professionals to gather what currently exists. like any research, this paper has some limitations. first, the writing period did not allow the researchers to deepen their knowledge in the practical field. this element represents a future strength that will lead to a more in-depth analysis considering new methodologies. for example, future investigations could include the targeted analysis of individual case studies. moreover, at the level of business models, it would be interesting to analyse how the perception of tech companies has changed compared to the previous and current period of covid-19. table 3. elements under discussion and case studies analysed for each topic http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5067 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 100 macro variables case studies • drugs discovery and knowledge sharing • tracking and prediction • clinical decision-making and diagnosis • social distancing control and medical chatbots deepmind; insilico medicine bluedot infervision; alibaba microsoft healthcare bot source: authors’ elaboration http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5067 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 101 references ahuja, a.s., reddy, v., marques, o. (2020). artificial intelligence and covid-19: a multidisciplinary approach. integrative medicine research, vol. 9, issue 3. bitran, h. (2019). microsoft healthcare bot brings conversational ai to healthcare. microsoft healthcare israel. bragazzi, n.l., dai, h., damiani, g., behzadifar, m., martini, m., wu, j.(2020). how big data and artificial intelligence can help better manage the covid-19 pandemic. int. j. environ. res. public health 2020, 17, 3176; doi:10.3390/ijerph17093176. connelly, t.m., malik, z., sehgal, r. et al. (2019). the 100 most influential manuscripts in robotic surgery: a bibliometric analysis. j robotic surg 14, 155–165. crowe, s., cresswell, k., robertson, a. et al. (2011). the case study approach. bmc med res methodol 11, 100. dal mas, f., massaro, m., lombardi, r., & garlatti, a. (2019). from output to outcome measures in the public sector. a structured literature review. international journal of organizational analysis, 27(5), 1631–1656. divya, s., indumathi, v., ishwarya, s., priyasankari, m., kalpana devi, s. (2018). a self-diagnosis medical chatbot using artificial intelligence. journal of web development and web designing, vol.3, issue 1. falagas, m. e., pitsouni, e. i., malietzis, g. a., & pappas, g. (2007). comparison of pubmed, scopus, web of science, and google scholar: strengths and weaknesses. the faseb journal, 22(2), 338–342. frankish, k., ramsey, w.m., (eds.). (2014). introduction. in the cambridge handbook of artificial intelligence; cambridge university press: cambridge, uk, 1–14. granello, d. h., & wheaton, j. e. (2004). online data collection: strategies for research. journal of counseling & development, 82(4), 387-393. hamid, s. (2016). the opportunities and risks of artificial intelligence in medicine and healthcare. cuspe communications. jamshidi, m.b. et al. (2020). artificial intelligence and covid-19: deep learning approaches for diagnosis and treatment, in ieee access, vol. 8, 109581-109595, doi: 10.1109/access.2020.3001973. http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5067 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 102 jiang, f., jiang, y., zhi, h., et al. (2017). artificial intelligence in healthcare: past, present and future. stroke and vascular neurology. kreuzhuber, k. (2020). how ai, big data and machine learning can be used against the corona virus. ars electronica blog, 19 march. kumar, a., gupta, p.k., srivastava, a. (2020). a review of modern technologies for tackling covid19 pandemic. diabetes & metabolic syndrome: clinical research & reviews 14, 569-573. lalmuanawma, s., hussain, j., chhakchhuak, l. (2020). applications of machine learning and artificial intelligence for covid-19 (sars-cov-2) pandemic: a review. chaos, solitons and fractals 139 (2020) 110059. ledford, h. (2020). dozens of coronavirus drugs are in development — what happens next?. nature, 581, 247-248. mahomed, s. (2020). covid-19: the role of artificial intelligence in empowering the healthcare sector and enhancing social distancing measures during a pandemic. south african medical journal. massaro, m., dumay, j., garlatti, a., & dal mas, f. (2018). practitioners' views on intellectual capital and sustainability: from a performance-based to a worth-based perspective. journal of intellectual capital, 19 (2), 367–386. mccutcheon, d. m., & meredith, j. r. (1993). conducting case study research in operations management. journal of operations management, 11(3), 239-256. mohanty, s., rashid, m.h., mridul, m., mohanty, c. (2020). application of artificial intelligence in covid-19 drug repurposing. diabetes & metabolic syndrome: clinical research & reviews 14 (2020), 1027-1031. mongeon, p., & paul-hus, a. (2016). the journal coverage of web of science and scopus: a comparative analysis. scientometrics, 106(1), 213–228. naudé, w. (2020). artificial intelligence against covid-19: an early review. iza discussion, paper no. 13110, bonn. naudé, w. (2020). artificial intelligence vs covid‑19: limitations, constraints and pitfalls. ai & soc. nguyen, t. t. (2020). artificial intelligence in the battle against coronavirus (covid-19): a survey and future research directions. preprint, doi: 10.13140/rg.2.2.36491.23846. http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5067 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 103 nguyen t., saputra, y.m., van huynh, n., nguyen, n.t., khoa, t., tuan, b., nguyen, d., hoang, d., vu, t., dutkiewicz, e., chatzinotas, s., ottersten, b. (2020). enabling and emerging technologies for social distancing: a comprehensive survey. cornell university press. petropoulos, g. (2020). artificial intelligence in the fight against covid-19. bruegel. pan, x. b. (2020). application of personal-oriented digital technology in preventing transmission of covid-19, china. irish journal of medical science (1971-), 189(4), 1145-1146. pham, q., nguyen, d.c., huynh-the, t., hwang, w., pathirana, p.n. (2020). artificial intelligence (ai) and big data for coronavirus (covid-19) pandemic: a survey on the state-of-the-arts. preprints 2020. rivas, a. (2020). drones and artificial intelligence to enforce social isolation during covid-19 outbreak. medium towards data sci. shi, f., wang, j., shi, j., wu, z., wang, q., tang, z., ... & shen, d. (2020). review of artificial intelligence techniques in imaging data acquisition, segmentation and diagnosis for covid-19. ieee reviews in biomedical engineering. secinaro, s., calandra, d., biancone, p. (2020). reflection on coronavirus accounting impact on small and medium sized enterprises (smes) in europe. vol. 15, issue 7, 48-56. sun, c., & zhai, j. (2020). the efficacy of social distance and ventilation effectiveness in preventing covid-19 transmission. sustainable cities and society 62 (2020) 102390. tran, b.x., vu, g.t., ha, g.h., vuong, q.h., ho, m.t., vuong, t.t., la, v.p., ho, m.t., nghiem, k.c.p., nguyen, h.l.t., latkin, c.a., tam, w.w.s., cheung, n.m., nguyen, h.k.t., ho, c.s.h., ho, r.c.m. (2019). global evolution of research in artificial intelligence in health and medicine: a bibliometric study. journal of clinical medicine. 8(3):360. vaishya, r., javaid, m., khan, i.h., haleem, a. (2020). artificial intelligence (ai) applications for covid-19 pandemic. diabetes & metabolic syndrome: clinical research & reviews 14, 337-339. xue, h., li, j., wang, y. (2018). review of drug repositioning approaches and resources. international journal of biological sciences, vol. 14, issue 10, 13 july 2018, 1232-1244. yassine, h.m., & shan, z. (2020). how could artificial intelligence aid in the fight against coronavirus?. expert review of anti-infective therapy, 18:6, 493-497, doi: 10.1080/14787210.2020.1744275. http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5067 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 104 yin, r.k. (2014). case study research: design and methods. thousand oaks, ca: sage publications. young, o.r. (2013). compliance & public authority: a theory with international applications. routledge. zhao, w. w. (2018). how to improve corporate social responsibility in the era of artificial intelligence?. in iop conf. series: earth and environmental science (vol. 186). zhavoronkov, a., aladinskiy, v., zhebrak, a., et al. (2020). potential covid-19 3c-like protease inhibitors designed using generative deep learning approaches. insilico medicine hong kong ltd. 4608-article text-14561-2-9-20200624 european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/4608 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 19 public choice in european affairs: measuring election model stefano de nichilo department of economic and business sciences, university of cagliari, italy e-mail: stefanodenichilo1985@gmail.com received: 18/05/2020 revised: 20/06/2020 accepted for publication: 21/06/2020 published: 20/07/2020 abstract much of the accountability literature itself examines governance issues, be it decision-making and delegation, eu policy and decision-making mechanism, regulatory status, multi-level governance, executive power and bureaucracy. financial responsibility is at the center of political responsibility and, however, issues related to financial management have been marginalized in school discussions on the eu. audit and evaluation involve examining the development of policies, implementation procedures and their consequences to provide an assessment of the economy, efficiency and effectiveness of an entity or activity. from the sociological and discursive point of view of institutionalism, responsibility is "carried out" by the eu institutions, on paper and in meetings, each trying to define the standards of responsibility. special reports offer the opportunity to "account" for eu policy and thus "account" for the success or failure of the implementation of the commission and the member states. keywords: accountability methodology, paying-agencies election governance, performance human resource model, recruitment explosion and special report. 1. introduction to the analysis of the audit methodology auditing is a blurred concept that is difficult to define and is used in different ways in different contexts (denichilo 2019a). general concepts include audit, inspection and control: evaluation of eu cohesion policy functions under the general audit term (power 1994). to analyze eu reform, this work takes an equally broad approach to auditing, which includes (for cohesion policy): verification of the effective functioning of member states' controls, as undertaken by the commission services and bodies independent in the eu member states; and control of projects financed through desk-based controls and on-site inspections through the management and certification (i.e. payment) of the structural fund authorities in the member states. as an external audit body, the european court of auditors (hereafter the court) is not by definition part of the internal european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/4608 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 20 audit / control framework under shared management, although administrative reforms in the commission have had an impact on audit activities of the court and, as will be discussed below, for the voice of this institution in the post-reform era. from a theoretical point of view, the fundamental functional properties of audit and control are well captured in the classical terms of the main agent (power 1994): a monitoring technology used to eliminate moral hazard and information asymmetries between an agent and its principal in order to restore or improve trust. the use of audit and control as political technology in government has grown since the 1980s represented as an explosion of audit by power (1994, 1997) with its roots in the erosion of society's trust and public sector management changes that require greater accounting, verification and control. in the eu context, similar factors explain the shift of the audit regime. an administrative reform program in 2000 was triggered by an eu financial management scandal and legitimacy crisis (balint et al. 2008). of primary concern here are the subsequent effects on policy implementation and the results in eu cohesion policy. the starting point is to specify the implications for the audit and how the process has transformed the scope and intensity of the audit, control and reporting activity (denichilo 2019b). the main questions are: what form did the audit explosion take and why? what are the consequences? and how effectively has it solved the underlying problems? the assessment of the form of the eu audit explosion can draw on comparative administration literature, which documents two distinct public sector audit models: the compliance model and the performance model (barzelay 1997; pollit 1999). the compliance model has its roots in the financial audit based on the accounting practices of private companies (power 1997) and the internal accounting in the government can be traced back to millennia. fraud and error detection was the original goal of the financial review and a close association remains. the compliance audit focuses on legal and administrative compliance and on the probity and correctness of the administration, financial systems and management control systems. performance auditing has developed since the mid-1980s (pollit 1999). it resembles evaluation in probing the efficiency and effectiveness of public programs, but is undertaken in a similar way to auditing (barzelay 1997). the easily quantifiable numerical indicators used in financial accounting are complemented by qualitative output-oriented indicators. the focus shifts accordingly from inputs to outputs and outcomes of public sectoral activities (pollitt 1999). the pace and extent of the transition to performance auditing varies internationally. the leaders are the united kingdom, australia, north america and scandinavia (barzelay 1997; pollitt 1999). countries that adopt performance-oriented management doctrines have generally been proactive in auditing performance. countries with a stronger tradition of administrative law and a strong rechtsstaat (e.g. france, germany and italy) have been more cautious. a similar correlation applies to internal audit and control experiences (pollitt and bouckaert 2004; power 2005). this literature suggests that an explosion of the eu audit should take or approach the shape of the performance model. after all, the new public management principles were the basis of the commission's administrative reform program (knill and balint 2008), which said it sought to improve effectiveness, focus on performance and provide more profitable training in financial management, audit and control. furthermore, more than other eu policy areas, cohesion policy has established monitoring and evaluation mechanisms for evaluating policy performance, creating pre-existing knowledge that would facilitate performance auditing (pollitt and bouckaert 2004, pollit et al. 1999). this leads to the second question relating to the behavioral impacts of the growth of the audit, for which the thesis of the explosion of power's audit highlighted several pathologies. the audit explosion (power 2002) may result in a priority decline european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/4608 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 21 in the provision of public services due to resource costs. an organization that wants to survive an audit must invest in reporting, monitoring and control systems, rather than improving performance (power 1994). additionally, the growth of audit and control can aggravate mistrust (power 2000b). auditors can play elaborate games of non-compliance and the auditors' working methods can be questioned. furthermore, the unproven benefits of the audit tend to be accepted, when the effectiveness of the audit should actually be called into question (power 1997). finally, auditors or controllers can become de facto policy makers by repositioning competencies in the public management hierarchy (power 2005). and therefore, there is the question of whether administrative reforms in the field of audit and control are strengthening the commission's governance capacities. this concerns the commission's ability to manage policy effectively, as well as the effects of strengthening the legitimacy of administrative reform (cini 2008). before testing these propositions, it is necessary to corroborate the claim that an audit explosion occurred and that its origins lie in the commission's administrative reform (power 2015). the introduction and the background place the study within the audit and control of the european community on the different states. the elimination of moral hazard between different levels of government is properly debated according to literature and practice references. the literature identifies and coherently argues the issue of auditing by the european commission and cohesion policies, with a balance of powers by recalling the reforms that have taken place. the purpose of the paper is to provide evidence and reporting of european methodologies for the election of people who will have administrative, accounting and political responsibilities (denichilo 2020). for similar papers that use the same elaborations in public choice you can consider the following recent ones: berkowitz, monfort and pieńkowski (2020); courtney and powell (2020); pavić, turk, grgić and prišenk (2020) and van wolleghem (2020). 2. the explosion of recruitment as a performance model the audit explosion clearly led to significant changes in the commission's organizational, strategic and operational approaches (power 2011). the question is whether these changes were driven by ambitions to increase policy performance or ensure regulatory compliance. the previous account does not support the expected shift towards the performance model, but strongly points towards a compliance model. this is evident in the emphasis and strength of compliance-based measures implemented since the mid-2000s: faster suspension and correction procedures; member states' action plans and their corrective follow-up; an increase in the scope and intensity of the audits; and stricter closure procedures. seeking has been to improve the regularity and legality of expenditure, to support pressure from the court and parliament to reduce the error rate. noteworthy is the emphasis of the data on the sanctions instrument of financial corrections and recoveries, as underlined by the administrative reform program, the roadmap for internal control and the control plan and by the court and parliament on an ongoing basis. however, as claimed by one of the court's auditors: by their very nature, financial corrections can be applied alone in the event of proven violation of specific rules. they are therefore much better suited to sanctioning violations of legality and regularity rather than weaknesses in terms of sound financial management. another consequence of the commission's roadmap has been found in annual declarations including summaries of member states' audits and opinions on cohesion policy expenditure. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/4608 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 22 again, this appears to be yet another compliance exercise with punitive characteristics rather than a real tool to stimulate learning about effectiveness, as the following comments from a hearing of the parliament indicate: when asked if these summaries had allowed them to learn something useful, the commission replied: "not yet" (which is, i believe, the commission's language for "no"). but when asked if all member states had complied with the request, the commission replied that germany had not done so and that the commission was initiating an infringement procedure. these are the early days, but there is something daunting in finding that these procedures add so far little value to the commission, but represent a new way for member states to find themselves in violation of a regulation. this interpretation is reinforced by evidence that the commission only checked whether the member states had submitted the annual summaries, had not undertaken any analysis of the content of the added value of the documents and paid little attention to the performance targets and methods. the priority given to obtaining guarantees from the member states was a key feature of the 2006 reforms for the audit and control of rules in cohesion policy. the main innovation was a "conformity assessment" exercise to ensure that all the management and control systems of the program "procedurally" comply with the requirements (power 2011). the process was conflicting, with the commission rejecting more than half of the first submissions of descriptions of audit systems and strategies; this includes countries that previously signed trust agreements with the commission. recent developments indicate a future step towards the performance model, even the key parameter of the performance audit attention to results and impact as part of the audit does not seem to be on the horizon (power 2011). in 2007-2013, greater emphasis was placed on the so-called "single audit model", which constitutes a clearer division of responsibility between the commission and the member states, with each level combining its security on the next during the various stages. of implementation. this promises less duplication of efforts, more cooperative relationships and greater trust, whether the model will work as promised remains to be seen. furthermore, in moving to a control approach, the commission may face another challenge: the economic and epistemic impossibility of direct control when it reaffirms control (power 2011). furthermore, the commission stresses that audit and control should be seen as a learning process. the goal is not only to identify problems (such as fraud or major errors), but also to propose solutions (in order to prevent minor errors), supported by a more bottom-up approach, oriented towards risk management (rather than driven by the sanction) approach (power 2011). one of these commission measures was the provision of a self-assessment tool to the member states in 2007. however, these softer measures were superimposed on the existing compliance model and are diminished by the scope and intensity of the compliance actions implemented by recent years. three key factors explain the nature of the audit explosion and the consequences. the first reflects a fundamental political choice by parliament, the court (in particular in relation to the discharge of the budget) and the council's budget group to prioritize compliance over performance (power 2011). furthermore, there is no specific council specific committee for cohesion policy which focuses on: assessing the concerns related to the performance of eu cohesion policy. this political dimension largely explains why the commission's administrative reform program had a strong logical bureaucratic impact (ellinas and suleiman 2008), despite claims about its ideals for new public management. secondly, the commission's financial crisis and the program of administrative reforms have led to a redistribution of power and resources, in parliament and in the court (in the post-santer era). in addition to strengthening the influence of the eu european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/4608 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 23 budgetary authorities, it has enabled them to defend the new status quo, thus maintaining the ongoing administrative reform (cini 2008) of auditing and control more firmly on the compliance path. this growing pressure largely explains the injustice perceived by the auditors in the member states (see below). it also contradicts claims about administrative reform led primarily by the commission, at least in the field of audit and control. third, the current institutional structure of shared management where the commission's power to establish rules (based on its responsibility for the budget) is not accompanied by an equivalent power over the implementation of the budget necessarily implies a high degree risk of delegation, especially the highly devolved and dispersed delivery model of cohesion policy. as noted by the head of the audit department, it is not possible to provide member states with a blank check and to rely on member states' audit systems because when the court of auditors carries out its own checks in the member states, the commission will not blame the errors. member states. a more rigorous approach to compliance is needed to address the problem of high levels of irregularities (harber, marx and de jager 2020). 3. introduction to the concept of accountability responsibility has always been intrinsic to the research and practice of democratic governance. responsibility concerns "the construction of an agreed language or currency of speech on the conduct and performance and the criteria that should be used to evaluate them" (day and klein 1987). responsibility rests on a combination of structures and procedures, in addition to the socialization of public officials about what is appropriate in the conduct of public affairs. according to march and olsen, the traditions of democracy require political officials to account for their actions; report, explain and justify any exercise of authority; and sanction if necessary. public officials should act in anticipation of having to account for their actions. responsibility is based on regulation, the process, setting standards and presenting accounts for actions. peterson underlines the challenge the eu faces due to the coexistence of shared sovereignty and divided responsibility (de haan , schoenmaker and wierts 2020). the establishment of the european court of auditors and other audit institutions in the eu is an attempt to promote collective responsibility for coping with shared sovereignty. there are four forms of responsibility: a) administrative liability; b) parliamentary responsibility; c) election responsibility; d) judicial liability. interestingly, it did not include financial liability in its categorization. however, financial responsibility is an essential part of accountability in any democratic political system, given the importance of the public purse. financial responsibility or the audit process are related to both administrative and parliamentary responsibility (manes rossi, brusca and condor 2020). a key feature of the administrative budget processes is "to ensure responsibility, that the funds are actually spent for the intended purposes, that the programs are executed as planned and that the funds, coming from any source, are not spent on unauthorized activities" the budget processes also support managerial functions, linking the financial decision-making process to the performance of the program (köhler, ratzinger-sakel and theis 2020). in addition, the audits provide the raw material for the budget control committees of the national and european parliaments, hence the contribution to parliamentary responsibility. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/4608 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 24 democratic theory underlines the importance of two mechanisms as a basis for accountability. this is information and sanctions. the court of auditors is not a judicial court capable of imposing sanctions on other actors. rather, its contribution to accountability in the eu. it is based on the provision of authoritative information to political bas institutions ate on audits that allow them to monitor and improve financial management. the european court of auditors was established in 1977 in response to the weakness of the pre-existing audit committee of the european economic community (eec) and the auditor of the european coal and steel community (ecsc). the change in the financing of the eu budget following the budget treaties of 1970 and 1975 created political pressure to establish a stronger external audit capacity in the eu. once established, the court worked to strengthen its mandate and influence the evolution of financial responsibility in the union. in addition to the functional tasks associated with the external audit, the court of auditors has acted to improve the regulatory framework for financial liability in the union. the court was part of a larger defense coalition for better financial management in the eu. as an external audit body, the court exercises its role by providing information on the management of the union's finances to the executive and parliamentary bodies of the union at eu and national level (march 1995). it has no judicial functions and does not impose sanctions on individual officials or institutions. so the basis of his contribution is based on the result of his audits as expressed in the reports. responsibility is promoted through the publication and dissemination of information on financial management systems and practices in the eu. the court increases accountability in the union by conducting its audits professionally and reporting on the results of its audits. the basis of the court's contribution to accountability in the union is based on two pillars of information and publication. in addition, the expectation of an external audit influences the behavior of public officials engaged in the deployment of eu funds at eu and national level. the fact that public officials know that their actions can be reviewed by an external audit body affects the way they deal with eu finances (fredriksson, kiran and niemi 2020). 4. organization settings of supreme audit institutions supreme audit institutions (sais), including statutory auditors, auditor courts and public or public sector certifiers, play an important role in strengthening government and public sector responsibility (marchesi 2000). this is done through their examination and reporting of government financial reports, including government agencies, authorities, companies and subsidiaries (i.e. audit of financial reports). not only performance or audits with a good quality-price ratio of the efficiency and effectiveness of the use of public funds, but also other judicial reviews, including environmental audits. this study extends the previous literature (de martinis and clark, 2007) by examining the enabling legislation of the sais of the 25 member countries of the european union (eu) and the european court of auditors (eca). the study examines the provisions contained therein that deal with the scope of parliamentary powers on the accountability of sais to parliament, as well as the independence, supervision, mandate and funding of sais. given the importance of the eu and the economic, political and social diversity of its member countries, it is useful to examine the enabling legislation of their sais (colella 2000). the wave of spectacular corporate collapses and frauds worldwide, including enron, hih, parmalat, tyco, worldcom and xerox, is well known, has highlighted the need for greater corporate and regulatory governance. all over the world and in the aftermath of these corporate collapses and fraud and, in particular, the disappearance of arthur andersen, the adequacy of the european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/4608 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 25 auditor's legal requirements and professional standards for carrying out a quality audit have been subject to a greater control, in particular the auditor's independence. a significant achievement was in the united states, where the sarbanes-oxley act 2002 was issued, creating a stricter corporate governance and accountability regime, including a climate of stricter rules on independence of control. in other countries, government regulatory and professional bodies have also followed suit with changes (proposals) similar to legislation and / or professional standards for the purpose of improving corporate governance, including audit quality. interestingly, well before the entry into force of the sarbanes-oxley act of 2002, the european commission had proposed to improve the independence of auditors by setting minimum standards, in particular as regards the mandatory guarantee systems of the quality, since member states have been found to operate with voluntary or partial systems or without a system (caruana and kowalczyk 2020). 5. institutional challenges: review special report performance auditing is “a knowledge-based activity” and that owing to its “special features” it requires “special competences” (european parliament 2012). it is an “investigation discipline that requires flexibility, imagination and analytical skills. excessively detailed procedures, methods and standards may hamper the effective functioning of performance auditing. auditors traditionally have experience in public and private sector financial/compliance auditing but are not familiar with the appropriate methodologies for performace/value-for-money auditing (van der meer and edelebos 2006). the court’s management has been obliged to support the training of staff through professional education in performance auditing, for both auditors and members by developing a professional diploma course in public-sector auditing, finance and accounting as a qualifying tool. the court is now hiring auditors from a variety of academic disciplines. beyond accountants, economists and lawyers, its staff increasingly includes psychologists, linguists, social scientists, geographers and medics, policy expertise in performance audit requires professional qualification in, and in-depth practical knowledge of, a range of policy areas. it pushed through internal restructuring, creating vertical chambers with decision-making powers delegated to them away from the college. this brought efficiency gain but resulted in “silo-ing” with each chamber insulating itself, competing to out-perform the other in producing special reports. the court is now much more conscious of its external profile. a communication department was created around the president to “professionalise” and actively promote the court’s recommendations, with greater attentions paid to presentation. adopting private sectors norms, the court now talks of disseminating its “products” to its “clients” or “stakeholders” (see table 1). compliance audit work will likely always receive a bed press, its impact hard to ascertain in terms of improved accountability (homer and stephenson 2012). tab. 1 reports submitted to the court of auditors. 1. annual reports / statements of assurance. 2. up grade procedure services. 3. confort letters. 4. news. source: court of auditors annual report. 6. the audit of paying agencies: the agea case european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/4608 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 26 the agency for withdrawals in agriculture (agea) is a non-economic body governed by public law, established by legislative decree no. 165 and subsequent amendments and additions (denichilo 2011). it is subject to surveillance by the ministry of agricultural, food and forestry policies. the organization, structure and functioning are defined and regulated in addition to the legislative decree of 27 may 1999, n. 165 and subsequent modifications introduced by the legislative decree n. 188 of 2000 and by law 21 december 2001, n. 441, by the agea statute approved by ministerial decree no. 736 of june 14, 2002, by the administration regulations approved by ministerial decree of june 14, 2002 and by the personnel regulations approved also by ministerial decree of june 14, 2002. pursuant to article 10 of legislative decree no. 165/99, as modified by law no. 441/2001, a monocratic office is entrusted with the exercise of the functions of paying agency, which has the task of ensuring the efficiency of the management and control structure of community aid, without prejudice to those of other paying agencies, through the adoption of procedures aimed at the most rational use of resources, tools and resources in full compliance with current community regulations (hada, luga and căruț 2019). the bodies of the agency are: president, board of directors, representative council, board of auditors, court of auditors. the executive structure of the agea, as required by the staff regulations (14 june 2002) and articulated with resolution no. 44 of 19 july 2002, is made up of: a) monocratic office, responsible for the paying body pursuant to regulation (ec) no. 1290/06 established with law no. 441 of december 21, 2001; b) coordination area, which performs the functions of coordination body pursuant to regulation (ec) no. 1290/06 and of the regulation (ce) n. 885/06. the two functions are distinct under the organizational, administrative, functional, managerial and accounting aspects pursuant to and in compliance with eu and national legislation. the monocratic office performs the functions of paying agency pursuant to regulation (ec) no. 1290/06 and coordinates, determines the guidelines and objectives, the following areas subordinated to it: a) administrative area, which is made up of the "general, financial and cash personnel affairs" office, the "national budget and management control accounting office" and the "community litigation" office; b) payment authorization area, which consists of the "pac, fodder and oil" office, the "rural development" office, the "single application and fruit and vegetable management" office, the "promotion, quality improvement and social aid" office, of the office of the "community litigation"; c) controls area, which consists of the "accounting" office, the "technical service", the "payments execution" office and the "relations with paying bodies and sian" office. d) the coordination area performs the functions of coordination body pursuant to regulation (ec) no. 1290/06; in particular: coordinates and monitors the activities carried out by the paying agencies recognized in compliance with regulation (ec) no. 1290/06; takes care of the harmonization of the operational procedures for the implementation of the community legislation relating; provides national aid, ensuring its compatibility with eu legislation. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/4608 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 27 the types of intervention that the community internal control service can implement are the following: a) compliance audit: focuses on verifying the compliance of the procedures adopted by the paying agency with eu legislation, and verifying the compliance of the components with the internal rules and procedures, applicable to the context of the operating structures and operations under examination. b) operational audit: verifies / assesses the adequacy, regularity, reliability and functionality of systems and processes / procedures, methods (codification) and resources in relation to objectives, organizational structures. c) financial audit: these are actions aimed at verifying the adequacy of existing accounting, administrative and financial controls. their objective is to verify that there is a correct and timely recording in the institution's accounts (with particular regard to the eagf and eafrd accounts) and that the economic and financial statements present the results of the year in a "true and correct" manner and the financial and equity situation at the end of the financial year. systematically the purposes of a financial audit can relate to the reliability of the accounts, the legality and regularity of the operations and the verification of its financial management. d) follow-up (monitoring of corrective actions): these are interventions for verifying the effective implementation of the corrective action plans agreed with the process managers, in the face of the observations found during previous interventions, audits or process mapping , of the service and shared by the process managers themselves. at the date of this paper, the internal control service is organized into the following basic specialized units, identified by the homogeneous environment of action of the paying agency, as classified by the eu guidelines, aggregated into homogeneous areas by subject of verification: a) universe "eagf sigc / no sigc" divided into: eagf (european agricultural guarantee fund) schemes covered by the sig, i.e. the support schemes referred to in titles iii, iv and iv bis of regulation (ec) no. 73/2009 of the council including the agri-environmental, forestry, less-favored areas and areas with environmental restrictions, if the same sectors are included in the temporary instrument for rural development. in particular, this unit deals with the authorization procedures (administrative and on-the-spot checks), execution of payments, accounting that take place in application of the integrated management and control system in the eagf environment; eagf (european agricultural guarantee fund) schemes not covered by the sigc, i.e. any other support scheme paid by the eagf including any other scheme not covered by the sigc which is part of the temporary instrument for rural development. in particular, this unit deals with the authorization procedures (administrative and on-the-spot checks), payment execution, accounting, advances and guarantees that take place outside the scope of the integrated management and control system in the eagf environment. b) universe "eafrd sigc / no sigc" divided into: eafrd (european agricultural fund for rural development) schemes covered by the sigc, i.e. the support schemes borne by the eafrd referred to in article 6 of regulation (ec) no. 1975/2006. in particular, this unit deals with the authorization procedures (administrative and on-the-spot checks), execution of payments and european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/4608 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 28 accounting that take place in application of the integrated management and control system in the eafrd environment; eafrd (european agricultural fund for rural development) schemes not completed by the sigc, i.e. the support schemes borne by the eafrd referred to in article 25 of regulation (ec) no. 1975/2006. in particular, this unit deals with the authorization procedures (administrative and on-the-spot checks) for payments and accounting that take place outside the scope of the integrated management and control system in the eafrd environment. c) universe credits divided into: credit management within the eagf; management of eafrd credits. d) advances and guarantees universe: deals with the procedures relating to the management of the amounts paid in advance and the guarantees given in favor of the paying agency. e) public storage universe: deals with procedures relating to public storage and community inventory management. 7. methodology 7.1 human resource performance model this paper analyzes factors that explain the increased use of special reports by the court, such as the accountability methodology, wondering if they resemble evaluation studies. their training examines their impact, as well as the institutional use implicit in the performance audit (denichilo 2013). what factors and circumstances explain the increased use of special reports? the work shows how the interpretation of the court has political implications and serves to promote its institutional interests in the battlefield to define "responsibility" and in what concerns it. evaluation in the eu is often conducted externally, offered to various consortia of academics, researchers and consultants who respond to assess the performance of political programs. several multilevel stakeholders will conduct their assessments and choose from a mix of qualitative and quantitative data (denichilo 2019b). for the executive, its main purposes are: to contribute to the planning of interventions, including providing input to establish political priorities; assist in the efficient allocation of resources; improve the quality of the intervention; and report on the results of the intervention. this presupposes feedback in the political cycle, although theory does not always extend to practice. audit is therefore an essential part of evaluation in the eu, contributing to the realization of financial responsibility, but also, maintaining the institutional legitimacy of the decision-making system (spaventa 2008) in short, audit and evaluation are both key elements in the process of democratic accountability, but the question of what is accounted for and who is taken into account is central to the debate and in the eu. like the audit, the performance assessment function is to allow for accountability, but there is also an emphasis on collective learning. however, securing both can "run into several complications when applied in complex multi-actor political processes (sposato 2010)." european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/4608 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 29 7.2 data and sampling this study analyses the characteristic and the determinants of the legislative decree 286/1999 in quality of advisory body in 102 act’s director of paying agencies agea at 31.12.2013 (caiden 2000). in sampling process we lost 1,04% of total universe of investigation and analyzed 102 executive positions. tab. 2 identification of the survey sampling at 31.12.2013. total operational employees at 31.12.2013 64,96% total employees of the service organization at 31.12.2013 34% total universe of investigation at 31.12.2013 98,96% source: agea pwc audit reports 2011-2013 and agea pwc special report 2014 tab. 3 unavailable data. description data number of total advisory body act's director 120 unavailable data of advisory body % (qualification, number, independence) 15% number of advisory body object of analysis 102 source: agea pwc audit reports 2011-2013 and agea pwc special report 2014 our elaboration takes into consideration the year 2013 as there was the least amount of loss of data and with a minimum time span of five years to be able to evaluate the audit opinion in full independence (agea pwc audit reports 2011-2013 and agea pwc special report 2014). 7.3 research design: framework and hypothesis there are a number of theoretical arguments as to why corporate management might elect voluntary to provide particular information to parties outside the organization. these arguments were grounded within “positive accounting theory”, but there are some alternative theoretical perspectives that address this issue. these theories are: a) legitimacy theory; b) stakeholder theory; c) institution theory. legitimacy theory has become one of the most cited theories within the social and environmental accounting area. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/4608 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 30 the author believes that legitimacy theory does offer a powerful mechanism for understanding voluntary social and environmental disclosures made by corporations, and that this understanding would provide a vehicle for engaging in critical public debate. the problem for legitimacy theory in contributing to our understanding of accounting disclosure specifically, and as a theory in general, is that the term has on occasion been used fairly loosely. this is not a problem of the theory itself, and the observation could be equally applied to a range of theories in a range of disciplines. follow there are the hypotheses of the paper that we have identified using the theory of legitimacy, in particular we have identified corporate governance hypotheses, assumptions of positive and negative potential audit evidence (rolle 2010). tab. 4 framework hypotesis h1: there is negative association between impact of debt register evidence and quality of advisory body. h2: there is a positive association between internal audit statistics evidence and quality of advisory body. h3: there is a positive association between squeeze-out audit evidence (external job positions) and quality of advisory body. source: agea pwc audit reports 2011-2013 and agea pwc special report 2014 7.4 dependent variable the dependent variable is directly observed by visiting and explores the corporate website. the characteristics of corporate report (cr) disclosure is classified in three categories: a) number of member of advisory body (num). b) qualification member of advisory body (qm). c) independence member of advisory body (ind). this three aspect determine the quality of supervisory body in italian paying-agencies. the concept of social disclosure means providing adequate information about the events of the organization and its activities for the users of that information in order to enable them to make and take the decision (costa 2009). s model = 𝑆! = "# [#%&(()#)],!-()# 𝐼𝑁𝐷 tab. 5 costruction data evidence first evidence: there is a positive association between number of advisory body (num) and quality of advisory body: the number of advisory body varies from 1 to 3 in an organization settings staff unit. second evidence: there is a positive association between quality member of advisory body (qm) and quality of advisory body: european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/4608 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 31 a) l consist in legal affairs (lawyers) who demonstrate that they have significant experience in the criminal law of the economy over 15 years; b) ia consist of internal auditor staff and line (cyber audit) who demonstrate that they have significant experience in corporate compliance and in the analysis of corporate reporting procedures over 10 years; c) o is represented payment operator who demonstrate significant experience in audit evidence over 15 year. d) e consists of the category engineers in operational auditing and environmental impact assessment who demonstrate significant experience in re-performing audit evidence on site over 10 years. third evidence: there is a positive association between independence of advisory body (ind) and quality of advisory body: the variable independence ranges from 0 to 1. source: agea pwc audit reports 2011-2013 and agea pwc special report 2014 this three hypothesis introducing social responsibility legitimation role of legislative decree 286/1999 in italy (noe 2006). the quality composition of advisory body legitimates their quality of the audit to preventing fraud and corruption and legitimates trust in the “ritual of verification”(mendez 2011). tab. 6 corporate disclosure of legislative decree 286/99. examined disclosure dependent variable value at 31.12.2013 number of member of advisory body num (1;2;3) qualification member of advisory body qm (lawyer=4;internal auditor=3; engineer=2; other=1) qm=l+ia+e+o independence member of advisory body ind variance 0-1 indipendent members odv 𝑇𝑜𝑡𝑎𝑙 𝑚𝑒𝑚𝑏𝑒𝑟 𝑂𝑑𝑉 source: agea pwc audit reports 2011-2013 and agea pwc special report 2014 tab. 7 descriptive statistics of corporate disclosure of legislative decree 286/99. examined statistics number of member of advisory body qualification member of advisory body independence member of advisory body median 2,8 7 0,7 european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/4608 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 32 mean 1,5 5,5 0,5 variance 0,21 6 0,30 source: agea pwc audit reports 2011-2013 and agea pwc special report 2014 7.5 research model to tested the hypotheses we used the research model specified in the follow equation: 𝑆!= a0 + a1 (debt register evidence) + a2 (internal audit statistics) + a3 (squeeze-out audit evidence) + ξ where: symbols description value al 31.12.2013 a0 intercept external audit impact debt register evidence power of size @log𝐴𝑠𝑠𝑒𝑡 . /0! internal audit statistics inspection evidence ∏10! . log inspection squeeze-out audit evidence dummy [0;1] ξ residual residual funds access 7.6. results the table 8 contains the descriptive statistic of the independents variables. tab. 8 descriptive statistics. variable mean std. dev min max debt register evidence 12,5 2,59 1,05 20,35 internal audit statistics 1,5% 0,99% -2,50% 40,50% squeeze-out audit evidence 0,50 0,25 0 1 source: agea pwc audit reports 2011-2013 and agea pwc special report 2014 our sample covers a wide range of data: some very small, some very large. they have median debt register equal to 10,22; the median of audit statistics is 3,55%. they are generally not highly squeeze-out audit, considering that they have a squeezeout audit that is on median equal to 0,12. in table 9 there is the multivariate regression results using the equation 𝑆!, and estimate the coefficients and corresponding t-value. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/4608 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 33 tab. 9 – multivariate regression regress model coefficient t value p>t intercept -1,8 4,50 0,01*** debt register evidence -2,4 2,5 0,99 internal audit statistics 0,2 4 0,01*** squeeze-out audit evidence 0,5 -2,5 0,45 r2 0,55 * ** *** significant at the 0.1, 0.05 and 0.01 level. source: agea pwc audit reports 2011-2013 and agea pwc special report 2014 the model is significant (0,01 level) and the adjusted r2 are 0,55. the independent variable has significant result (0,01 level) is internal audit statistics (h2). 8. conclusions this study analyses the characteristic and the determinants of the legislative decree 286/1999 in quality of advisory body in 102 act’s director of paying agencies agea at 31.12.2013. the multivariate analyses shows a positive significant related, to the companies have high internal audit statistics have high quality of advisory body, this fact is consistent to the legitimacy theory. to future research predicts increase the characteristics and analyses comparatively to other country so it is possible. some limitation should be considered, in particular the incidence of unavailable data of number, composition and independence of advisory body exceeding 10%. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/4608 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 34 figure 1. control activities of organization settings (d. l.vo 286/1999). activities strategic evaluation and control management control evaluation of managers administrative accounting control recipients political bodies executives in direct contact with the political policy body executives in contact with the governing body political summits, managers and external control bodies object guidance documents, management documents of executives who interact with political policy bodies economy, efficiency and effectiveness of the organizational entity to which the manager is responsible performance and organizational skills of every non-top executive accounting administrative correctness source: agea pwc audit reports 2011-2013 and agea pwc special report 2014 in conclusion the paying agencies that have high profitability of internal audit statistics have high quality of advisory body, this legitimates their quality of the audit to preventing fraud and corruption and legitimates trust in the “ritual of verification” (denichilo 2019c). the increase in public debt in the euro area during the crisis, although more contained than that of the entire world of mature economies, has opened up a front that has not yet closed. the question of the possible negative effects of a high public debt is ancient. in general, there is a certain consensus on the idea that, through various channels, a very high debt may hinder growth, even if the relationship is very uncertain, and, above all, it is excluded that a threshold beyond which the effects may be identified negatives become particularly severe. the model dealt with in this paper is a starting point on the analysis of the immunization of public finance processes. the limitations of the work concern the difficulty in finding the data and the continuous updating of the data which in the stochastic processes of financial immunization represent the password (denichilo, pedone 2009). 9. discussion the court is transparent in the delivery of reports, publishing them online, freely accessible to stakeholders and citizens. however, it perceives accountability not as merely about visibility or transparency, but as ultimately resisting on parliamentary scrutiny and action, legislative responsibility underpins democracy. at the supranational level there is a “triangle of european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/4608 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 35 accountability” between the european court of auditors (external controller), european parliament (principal, scrutinizer, democratically accountable) and european commission (auditee, non-elected, jointly responsible for managing and implementing eu funds). there is no clear-cut hierarchy among the institutions. furthermore, the approach to, and practice of, audit across member states continues to require harmonization and the adoption of common standards. the soundness and value of parliamentary scrutiny remains open to question, in term of both recouping funds and influencing policy redesign. nonetheless, performance audit itself, as a process of “accounting for” budgetary implementations, follows a clear logic of decision-making, research, analysis, drafting and reporting, thus constituting a series of sub-processes. policy-makers are increasing focused on issues of performance in audit, given budgetary constraints and the financial and political implications of audit for future policy. “performance”, though evidence-based and drawing on quantitative data, is about framing and institutional discourse, ultimately value-driven and normative (stephenson 2015). references agea pwc audit reports 2011-2013. agea pwc special report 2014. berkowitz p., monfort p. and pieńkowski j. (2020), unpacking the growth impacts of european union cohesion policy: transmission channels from cohesion policy into economic growth unpacking the growth impacts of european union cohesion policy: transmission channels from cohesion policy into economic growth. regional studies. barzelay m. (1997), central audit institutions and performance auditing: comparative analysis of organizational strategies in the oecd. governance. an international journal of policy, administration and institutions. caiden n. (1992), public service professionalism for performance measurement and evaluation. public budgeting & finance. caruana j. and kowalczyk m. (2020), the quest for audit quality in the public sector. accounting in europe. cini m. (2008), european commission reform and the origins of the european transparency initiative. journal of european transparency initiative. cortese g., del carlo a., “la selezione del personale. dalla ricerca all’inserimento in azienda: come scegliere il candidato migliore”, raffaello cortina editore, milano, 2008. colella a., griffin a.e.c., gaparaju s (2000), newcomer and organizational socialization tactis: an interactionist perspective. colin clark, michael de martinis, maria krambia‐kapardis (2007), audit quality attributes of european union supreme audit institutions. european business review. costa g., gianecchini m. (2009), “risorse umane: persone, relazioni e valore”, mc graw-hill, milano. courtney p. and powell j. (2020), evaluating innovation in european rural development programmes: application of the social return on investment (sroi) method. sustainability. day p. and klein r. (1987), accountabilities: five public services. de haan j., schoenmaker d., wierts p. (2020), financial markets and institutions: a european perspective. cambridge university press. denichilo n. (2013), le metodologie innovative di reclutamento. tesi magistrale università degli studi roma tre. denichilo s., a. pedone (2009), the efficiency of the tax systems in europe. working paper edit università degli studi la sapienza di roma. denichilo s., c. regogliosi (2011), l’internal auditing in un organismo di diritto pubblico: il caso agea. working paper edit università degli studi roma tre. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/4608 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 36 denichilo s. (2019c), legitimacy theory in italy introduction social responsibility role of legislative decree 231. university of cagliari. denichilo s. (2019a), rituals of verification nei collegi sindacali delle società quotate italiane un analisi dei testi e quantitativa. university of cagliari edit 2019. denichilo s. (2019b), rituals of verification negli organismi di vigilanza delle società quotate italiane un analisi quali-quantitativa. university of cagliari edit 2019. denichilo s. (2020), metodologia di audit per il reclutamento negli affari europei: ritualismo contro pianificazione del fabbisogno di risorse umane. convegno annuale aipda roma. ellinas a. & suleiman e. (2008), the reforming the commission: between modernization and bureaucratization, journal of european public policy. european parliament (2012), committee on budgetary control, “future role of the european court of auditors: challenges ahead and possible reform”. favere-marchesi m. (2000), audit quality in asean. the international journal of accounting. fredriksson a., kiran a. and niemi l. (2020), reputation capital of directorships and demand for audit quality. european accounting review. hada t., luga i. and căruț m. (2019), grants through the european agricultural funds for the rural development. case study: the modernization of the community centre of a municipality. ovidius university annals. harber m., marx b. and de jager p. (2020), the perceived financial effects of mandatory audit firm rotation. journal of international financial management and accounting. homer j. and stephenson p. (2012), theoretical perspectives on approaches to policy evaluation in the eu: the case of cohesion policy in public administration. knill c., balint t. & bauer m.w. (2008), study on behalf of the european parliament. reform of european congress 2008. köhler a., ratzinger-sakel n. and theis j. (2020), the effects of key audit matters on the auditor's report's communicative value: experimental evidence from investment professionals and non-professional investors. accounting in europe. manes rossi f., brusca i. and condor v. (2020), in the pursuit of harmonization: comparing the audit systems of european local governments. public money & management. march j.g. e olsen j.p. (1995), democratic governance. mendez c., bactler j. (2011) administrative reform and unintended consequences: an assessment of the eu cohesion policy audit explosion. journal of european public policy. noe r. , hollenbeck j. , gerhart b., wright p. (2006), “human resource management”, apogeo, milano. pavić l., turk j., grgić i. and prišenk j. (2020), impact analysis of the young farmers' support program on slovenian dairy sector development using econometric modeling approach. agronomy. pollit c. (1999), accountability and democracy: answering to political authorities and citizens needs. istitute of administrative sciences conference. pollitt c. e bouckaert g. (2004), continuity and change in public policy and management. edward elgar publishing. power m. (1994), the audit explosion, demos. power m. (1997), the audit society: rituals of verification. oxford. power m. (2000b), the audit implosion: regulating risk from the inside. londra, icaew. power m. (2002), la società dei controlli. a cura di fabrizio panozzo. torino, edizioni di comunità. power m. (2005), the invention of operational risk. review of international political economics. power m. (2011), auditing and the reiventation of governance. published to oxford scholarship on line october 2011. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/4608 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 37 power m. (2011), audit, trust and risk. published to oxford scholarship on line october 2011. power m. (2011), fraud, expectation and rise of financial audit. published to oxford scholarship on line october 2011. power m. (2011), making audits work: auditees and the auditable performance. published to oxford scholarship on line october 2011. power m. (with yves gendron) (2015), qualitative research in auditing: a methodological roadmap. auditing: a journal of practice and theory (2015) 34(2): 147-165. rolle l., “ risorse umane e benchmarking. prassi eccellenti in aziende innovative”, franco angeli, milano, 2010. spaventa l. (2008), una crisi della nuova finanza. giuffrè editore. sposato p., “valutazione e selezione del personale. come scegliere e valorizzare il tuo staff ideale.”, bruno editore, roma, 2010. stephenson p. (2015), reconciling audit and evaluations? symposium on policy evaluation in the eu. van der meer f. and edelebos j. (2006), “evaluation in multi-actor policy process: accountability, learning and cooperation” in evaluation. van wolleghem p.g. (2020), does administrative capacity matter? the absorption of the european fund for the integration of migrants. policy studies. 5073-article text-16415-2-11-20201212 http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 for peer review (doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5073 published by university of turin) http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 28 manufacturing resilience during the coronavirus pandemic: on the investigation of manufacturing processes agility panagiotis stavropoulos1*, alexios papacharalampopoulos1, konstantinos tzimanis1, andreas lianos1 1 laboratory for manufacturinng systems and automation (lms), department of mechanical engineering and aeronautics, university of patras, 26504, patras, greece. *corresponding author: pstavr@lms.mech.upatras.gr received: 06/09/2020 revised: 15/11/2020 accepted for publication: 04/12/2020 published: 18/12/2020 abstract the unprecedented events that worldwide population experienced during year 2020 due to the covid19 pandemic, resulted in the formation of numerous challenges across the majority of aspects of every day life. manufacturing industries and supply chain networks faced a unique decostruction during this period due to restrictions created by global or local lockdowns. reduction of human resources availability and transportation restrictions linked with the extreme and rapid increase of demand for medical supplies led manufactring related activities to reach their limits. moreover, the non flexible manufacturing methods that are employed for the production of this type of equipment as well as the delayed delivery of products that are used as raw material at the early production stages, resulted in market shortage of medical supplies while demand constantly growing. as a matter of fact, various production models and manufacturing processes had to be used at different phases, due to different levels of resilience. automotive industry in particular tested corresponding processes’ agility by transforming production and speeding up the production of medical equipment with alternative ways. however, the formal identification of the problem as well as the quantified requirements of each manufacturing method have to be evaluated in order to extract meaningful results that identify the reasons why traditional manufacturing facilities faced such difficulties in the production of medical equipment and to propose a roadmap where additive manufacturing methods can be used for the immediate, local and low volume production of the desired http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 for peer review (doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5073 published by university of turin) http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 29 product, giving time to non flexible industries, such as injection molding, to initiate the mass production. to assess the presented methodology, a comparison between two different manufacturing methods for the production of a respiratory component has been used as case study. finally, a hybrid manufacturing model is suggested. keywords: manufacturing process; agility; covid-19; medical equipment; manufacturing network 1 introduction to understand how the manufacturing paradigms have been utilized during the years and how they can be applied systematically for crises like the covid-19 pandemic, first, the modern business model has to be determined. the modern business model points out that individual businesses are not capable to compete each other alone, leading to the development of industrial alliances (douglas, cooper, 2000). in the meantime, the complexity of modern devices asks for cooperation between industries from different sectors while the guideline of european union for corporate social responsibility (csr) leads industries to follow a social profile, by respecting the laws and the competition with other industries. the main goal is to follow the pulse of the society in order to going side by side with the customer needs and finally raising their profit (corporate social responsibility & responsible business conduct,2020), (yildiz, 2014). by following this directive, as well as the need for humanitarian engineering and in particular response to emergencies (papacharalampopoulos et al, 2020),(tayler,2016), industries have been been been organized to consortia in order provide the required products while supporting each other. in this critical period the networks of business relationships and the willingness of individuals to support their national health system to fight the covid-19 virus (fauci et al,2020), led to the creation of hubs that work as supply chains in order to produce equipment which is under market shortage (carayannis, zedtwitz,2005). furthermore, it is highly desirable to address the concept of manufacturing resilience (gu et al, 2015) through the manufacturing processes agility. the absence of medical equipment can be explained considering that the developed countries, mainly the western world, imports this equipment from countries which are located far away where the labor cost is low. despite the fact that the transportation cost is high, the excessive profits seem to counteract these costs. the high delivery time and the increased domestic demand for medical supplies, followed by the local lockdown, resulted in increased demand in countries with many cases, leading to worldwide http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 for peer review (doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5073 published by university of turin) http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 30 shortages (shokrani,2020). decentralized production structures and am hubs tried to face this situation by adding flexibility to manufacturing processes in order to reflect local customer demand, by increasing the sustainability due to less distance that a product has to travel until the final destination, providing lower logistics, lower costs and shorter delivery time. from the beginning of this crisis it was evident that decentralized production structures have to be supported (shokrani,2020). in addition, the investments in education, learning & teaching factories, as well as the industrial research and development played a significant role in the fight against this disease; without r&d and commercialization of am as well as the domestic and small scale production, the situation would be worse. on the other hand, hubs took advantage of commercial platforms in order to provide details and knowledge to inexperienced people and hobbyists that possess am devices. to this end, everyone could learn how to produce the required equipment following the product specifactions. furthermore, reverse engineering and 3d scanners deployed to copy the different designs of the various equipment. in some cases, such as cpap devices, the complex design asks for innovative and flexible solutions from the industrial world in order to develop an exact copy of the part (odena,valls, 2020). in the meantime, chemical and pharmaceutical industry is really having a sprint in order to achieve some sort of attack to the virus with some sort of mechanism (panoutsopoulos, 2020). the several manufacturing processes is a result of the technological improvements of the modern world, leading to different methods for making the same product (florusse, 1992). based on the material and the production volume target the suitable manufacturing processes may vary. for every manufacturing process a different infrastructure is needed (chryssolouris,2006). am on the other side, is a non-conventional manufacturing process which is able to cover small production volume with small production rates. however, it is able to adapt in different applications without excessive preparation time and labor cost (bikas, stavropoulos, 2016). numerous am printing methods are available. they are categorized based on the printing mechanism and the printing material. the application, the user experience and the needed investment, are parameters that define which of the available machines is more suitable in every case (bikas et al, 2016), (stavropoulos, foteinopoulos 2018). currently, several models and studies have been developed in order to simulate the am processes and predict the product quality (stavropoulos, foteinopoulos 2018), the build time (komineas et al,2018) and the consumed energy (peng, 2016) while optimum sets of process parameters are available for different materials and printers (edwards, 2003), (cantrell,2017). the above-mentioned work aims to make the am processes predictable in terms of http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 for peer review (doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5073 published by university of turin) http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 31 performance while the non-experienced users are able to create the desired product without being anxious for the selection of process parameters. apart from the utilization of am in automotive, aircraft, aerospace and consumer product industry,etc., am has been applied also in medical industry in different fields such as dental use, prosthetic arms development (mohd, 2018), integrated human tissues in prosthetic members etc (partee, 2006). during covid 19, am has been involved in the production of personal protective equipment (ppe), which is a number of parts that consist a set of medical protective equipment that can be used either multiple times or for one use and protect the population from getting in touch with diseased people and breath polluted air as well as in the production of breathing aids devices (haleem, javaid, 2020). due to the lack of the literature and the novelty of the effect of covid-19 in every aspect of everyday life as well as in manufacturing processes, this paper aims to investigate corporate responses and case studies that have been adopted during this pandemic crisis as well as to introduce an adaptive framework that can be used in order to face similar crisis, quantifying the response-related capabilities of manufacturing processes. the structure of the paper follows the investigation of the facts that took place during the pandemic crisis, in chronological order. in section 2, the methodology of this work is mentioned while in section 3, the phenomenology of the factors affecting the demand is presented. in section 4, the personal protective equipment for the hospital staff is documented along with the devices in market shortage during covid-19 pandemic outbreak as well as the contribution of industrial world in the production of the aforementioned equipment is mentioned. the capabilities of the traditional manufacturing methods for the production of the abovementioned clothing and devices are described in a more systematic and quantified way in section 5. in the same section, the presentation of the formation of glocal hubs and their activities can be found. a roadmap is then sugested therein based on the kpis of production that are relevant to manufacturing resilience and manufacturing processes agility. the relationship between the production rate and the required time for the production of a medical equipment with a flexible, a non-flexible manufacturing and a hybrid method in order to cover the local and global demand is mentioned in section 6. 2 methodology this work aims to access the traditional manufacturing methods for the production of plastic/metal medical supplies in terms of flexibility/requirements and to understand what were the reasons that led to http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 for peer review (doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5073 published by university of turin) http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 32 shortage of medical supplies and personal protective equipment (ppe). to achieve that, different sources of information have been considered in order to gather the necessary material and understand the chronological sequence of events related to pandemic outbreak as well as to find out what kind of medical supplies and protective equipment are needed to face this crisis. moreover, there were lot of articles, indicating the contribution of the industrial world to that effort. from all the industrial world, automotive industries stood out because they were organized quickly and they speeded up the production of medical supplies such as (breath aid devices, surgery masks etc.) that were given to local hospitals in order to face urgent cases. at the same time, individuals and hobbyist were also organized to create medical supplies with low production volume, but with less transportation cost and delivery time. later on, many more industries begun the production of medical equipment, taking as granted the proper design of the final product. having gathered and studied the aforementioned information, it is crucial to investigate the working principles of traditional manufacturing methods that were capable to undertake the production of such equipment and divide them according to their characteristics, on flexible and non-flexible manufacturing processes. this division determines how easily they can adopt to the production of different products and production volumes. to do that, data from literature was used and analyzed. the analysis of the obtained information and the better understanding of manufacturing hubs led us to define the glocal hub manufacturing model that is capable to merge the high volume production of industrial world with the low volume production of individuals and restructured distribution networks in order to match the demand in medical supplies, locally and worldwide. the principles of this model and how exactly it works, can be seen on the related section (section 5.1). to this end, it is evident that the developed hybrid manufacturing model needs to be agile and flexible to provide with the desired products under variable production volume and time. the resilience of the hybrid manufacturing model can be defined as the ability to withstand and counteract disruptions and after a number of steps to recover to the normal conditions. this system can be flexible and one of the main features can be the workload reallocation that depends on the availability of raw material and machines (xi et al, 2015). the next important feature of the proposed hybrid manufacturing model is the agility of the involved processes. agility is the capability to respond effectively to the requirements of the existing market demand. as an example, to reduce the process cycle time and increase the productivity rate as well as to produce a different design of a product without excessive preparation time (bessant et al, 2000). all these factors could be integrated into a methodology of assemblying the proper criteria and interpreting them them into http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 for peer review (doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5073 published by university of turin) http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 33 technical specifications (figure 1). the matching of the various kpis can be considered a continuation of previous works on kpis interlink for decision making (papacharalampopoulos et al, 2020). figure 1: agility and resilience in manufacturing processes, integrating definitions source: [fayezi et al, 2017],[ahern, 2011] as it can be observed from this methodology, the present work can be seen as an adaptive framework which can be employed in similar crisis were shortage of an equipment exists.the presented methodology refers to this unique occasion of covid-19 pandemic crisis. each occasion is governed from different characteristics that have to be studied and evaluated in order to extract a reaction plan, through a roadmap. the technical specifications have been set so far, through adoption of criteria, either on/off, denoted in brown font color in figure 1 bottom schematic, or as desired, annotated in yelow colour and the ones that are of priority (white ones). to achive extracting a roadmap, however, the comparison of different manufacturing methods must be conducted (end of section 5.1), providing with details regarding the characteristics of each method as well as their capabilities. for the assessment of this framework, a respiratory component is used. the comparison between two separate manufacturing methods (injection molding and additive manufacturing) in terms of production volume and cycle time, proves that a hybrid solution is required along-side with the restructured distribution network with the aid of glocal hubs in order to face this difficult situation. in brief, additive manufacturing can provide parts at small production rate and volume until the mass production manufacturing methods reach the desired production rates. 3 phenomenology of the factors affecting the demand-production equilibrium http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 for peer review (doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5073 published by university of turin) http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 34 the first confirmed cases of covid-19 infections (due to virus sars-cov-2) appeared at the end of 2019. after a few months, this situation evolved into a pandemic with millions of diseased people, because of the existing socio-economic globalization where citizens from different countries communicate, work side by side, products are exported/imported and people are travelling across the world to meet new civilization and cultures. the worldwide spread of the virus created an medical supply demand for which the medical suppliers were not prepared to cover, leaving hospital’s needs for equipment unmet. errore. l'origine riferimento non è stata trovata.a represents the total confirmed cases over time while the errore. l'origine riferimento non è stata trovata.b shows the number of deaths caused at the same time. figure 2:(a) number of cases, (b) number of deaths (a) (b) source: covid-19 coronavirus pandemic,2020 the moment that confirmed cases raised rapidly is the exact same moment that the number of deaths increased accordingly. to face that situation, the medical suppliers had to increase the production in order to match the hospital demands. at hospitals, the infected people with severe symptoms, such as pneumonia (zu et al, 2020), were under medical care with special equipment such as breathing aid devices, air control valves, etc. and the hospital staff was obliged to use continuously the personal protective equipment and replace it in short time intervals, in order to protect themselves and prevent the virus spread (coronavirus disease (covid-19) pandemic, 2020). moreover, during this period the pre-arrenged medical meetings or surgeries were rescheduled in order to save medical supplies that can be used to fight the pandemic crisis, http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 for peer review (doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5073 published by university of turin) http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 35 leading to death people with sever diseaces such as cancer (spinelli, pelino, 2020). to this end, the necessity for medical supplies mass production was intense and unpredictable while in most cases the suppliers could not quantify demands. in order to produce at a higher productivity rate, production line adjustments/optimization required. however, the medical suppliers had to cover the worldwide high demand, making of utmost importance the contribution of individuals, research center and industries, in medical equipment production. the following plot represents the infected percentage of population over time. it has been produced based on the equation of the sir model (nesteruk, 2020) and illustrates a bad scenario where even up to 70% of the population is infected rapidly. the vertical axis represents the percentage of population that has been infected for a certain time period while on the horizontal axis the time period, measured on days, can be seen. the evolution of this situation has indicated that measures such as social distancing had to be applied in order to avoid the virus spread. the abrupt increase of diseased suggests the need for handling a lot of cases at the same time. the provision of personal protective and hospital equipment are prerequisites for the curing of diseased people and the reduction of new infected cases. this procedure lasts over a long time period, until the curve is flattened which means that the virus spread has been minimized (haleem, javaid, 2020)(errore. l'origine riferimento non è stata trovata.). figure 3: infected percentage over time source: haleem, javaid, 2020 during the lockdown period, companies and industries were closed, the individuals were working from home while research centers were opened, following at the same time the protective measures. people with the necessary knowledge combined their forces to serve the national health system of their country, http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 for peer review (doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5073 published by university of turin) http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 36 producing the required protective equipment and breathing aid devices (designs for live-saving breathing aid to be made freely available, 2020). thus, with the aid of reverse engineering, the accurate design copies of several parts were available, while the final products were created by taking advantage of additive manufacturing techniques for plastic and metal printing. the domestic production and the smallscale production from research centers could not meet the raising demand so there was need for transformations in the production line of big factories e.g. automotive industry etc. according to chryssolouris (chryssolouris, 2006), there are four classes of manufacturing parameters to be considered when making manufacturing decisions: cost, time quality and flexibility. these decisions, depend on the particular problem, specific objectives, goals and criteria (errore. l'origine riferimento non è stata trovata.). figure 4: the manufacturing tetrahedron source: chryssolouris, 2006 meanwhile, the situation had been getting worse. therefore, the transformation of factories for medical supplies production had to be based on the flexibility of the production line, in order to create as soon as possible the first products to share to the hospitals. the products quality had to be fair enough to serve their cause while the productivity rate to be high to match the demand. the aim of the present work is to identify which of the existing manufacturing methods are enough flexible to deal with the sudden/unpredictable increase in demand, in medical supplies during covid-19 outbreak. on the one hand am has proven its potential, in small scale/domestic production, covering the local needs, while on the other hand, am low productivity rates indicates that this manufacturing method is not capable to match the rising hospital demand, worldwide by producing in mass production medical supplies (kose, 2020), (baumers, 2015). 4 paradigms of medical parts in high demand and the response of industry http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 for peer review (doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5073 published by university of turin) http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 37 based on available evidence and medical surveys, the sars-cov-2, the virus that causes covid-19, can be transmitted among the population either on close contact via hugs, handshakes and kisses or travel longer distances during talking, sneezing as well as coughing (nesteruk, igor, 2020). the ease of virus spread has led to more than 2.4 million confirmed cases (covid-19 coronavirus pandemic,2020) since today upsetting the scientific community, making at the same time the use of personal protective equipment (ppe) of utmost importance for people that are obliged to work nearby diseased people such as nurses, doctors, hospital cleaners as well as ambulance staff (source: ). due to the nature of the virus contagiousness, the equipment has to cover the whole body, mainly the free of clothes, skin. the table below ( table 1) presents the safety clothing that it is considered as personal protective equipment from world health organization (who) (coronavirus disease (covid-19) pandemic, 2020) , (yao, 2020). figure 5: (a), (b) safety clothes and personal protective equipment (ppe) (a) (b) source: personal protective equipment (ppe),2020 table 1: suggested equipment for human protection protection suggested equipment 1. respiratory protection face mask or surgical mask: n95, ffp2, ffp3 or equivalent 2. body protection gown/ apron: long-sleeved water resistant 3. hand protection safety gloves 4. eye protection goggles or face shields source: authors elaboration http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 for peer review (doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5073 published by university of turin) http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 38 apart from the wearing equipment the covid-19 pandemic outbreak has brought to surface the importance of equipment that is used in severe respiratory diseases. meanwhile, the treatment in hospitals is based on the proper operation of assisting breathing devices. on the one hand the common breathing devices, without mechanical support, work on affected people without severe symptoms while on the other hand the continuous positive airway pressure (cpap) is form of non-invasive mechanical ventilation, working as breathing aid, which applies mild air pressure on a continuous basis and keeps the airways continuously open in patients who are able to breathe on their own, but they need help keeping their airway unobstructed (ti, 2020). in addition, air control valves are responsible to control the oxygen that fills in the breath mask from an external respirator (ball, 2011). without these valves the patient mask is not capable to work. in general, the aspirators/ventilators were in demand due to high numbers of intubation occurrences. these machines are generally expensive (li, xiao, 2020) (elling, politis, 1983), consist of many different materials and also require assembly further to processing, while the production rate is bounded, according to stefan dräger who is the head of a ventilator manufacturer (top german ventilator company warns on global supply crunch, 2020). however, they can be reused once a patient exits intensive care. regarding the consumables, however, they can be used only once, and they may need change every five days on average. also, customized solutions often had to be taken into consideration, as often come across in the media from a number of sources like the brussels (afp) hospital. the main difference in addressing manufacturing of such equipment is that masks can be manufactured in a distributed, homemade way, even though the demand is high (even 70% of the population may need them daily according to errore. l'origine riferimento non è stata trovata. from nhs, while valves (figure 6b) require machine tools and the demand occurs at bursts and is a bit lower, involving only the intubated patients (yao, 2020). the treatment also implied demand for continuous processes, like hospital-related gases, medicine, and disinfectants (ti, 2020). furthermore, it is worth noting that applying circular ecomomy policies in this particular case may be hard or even unacceptable due to the protocols existing, and due to the fact that the virus has not been previously met by medical experts or authorities (chartier, 2014). figure 6: devices http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 for peer review (doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5073 published by university of turin) http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 39 (a) (b) sources: (a) cpap device (designs for live-saving breathing aid to be made freely available, 2020), (b) air control valve (3d cad file: respirator-free reanimation venturi's valve, 2020) 4.1 link to capabilities of existing lines although many industries have contributed to this fight, automotive industries are studied due to the fact that they take advantage of cutting-edge technologies which are used from skillful operators, as well as, flexible and non-flexible manufacturing processes and it is worth to see how they reacted in order to cover the demand of medical equipment that faced shortages. apart from actual products, many industries circulated the 3d desing of a medical equipment(respiratory components) to individuals, in order to create the desired part with the appopriate quaility and under the requested specifications. car manufacturers and other industries accompanied by the traditional suppliers of medical equipment have been organized in order to address the spike in demand by speeding and scaling up the existing production. the world health organization (who) has published a list of covid-19 critical items facing global shortage such as gloves and masks (table 2). table 2: critical items that face global shortage category critical items identified by who example of facilities that might be repurposed protective person equipment (ppe) • gloves, examination • gloves, surgical • goggles protective • gown, protective • face shield • mask, particulate respirator • mask, surgical • textile factories • garment plants • yarn spinning mills • electronic assembly plants • injection molding facilities • prototyping shops (3d printing) http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 for peer review (doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5073 published by university of turin) http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 40 diagnostic equipment • lab screening test kit • lab confirmation test kit • rt-pcr kit • extraction kit • cartridges for rt-pcr automatic systems • swab and viral transport medium • pharmaceutical preparations • biopharmaceutical preparations • pilot biotech plants • clinical research laboratories clinical care equipment • pulse oximeter • concentrator of gas • nasal oxygen cannula, with prongs • ventilator patient, for adult, pediatric • cpap with tubing and patient interfaces for adult and pediatric • suction pump, mechanical • high-flow nasal cannula (hfnc) • automotive production lines • aerospace manufacturing plants • specialized engineering service and testing facilities • manufacturing technology and innovation centers • vacuum cleaner assembly plants • machine shops source: authors elaboration in modern manufacturing, production processes can be highly automated and specialized aiming to maximize the productivity rate. the approach of lean manufacturing tends to eliminate waste across the production line and improves productivity. although a highly efficient and profitable production can be developed, it is extremely difficult to transform the production line to produce a new part. several industries face difficulties to reach the desired level of quality and performance in short time after the initiation of a new production line. however, the attempts continued in order to tackle the further expansion of the disease by covering the needs in medical supplies, making possible to cure several cases by protecting the hospital staff, most of the industries participating in the global effort mainly produce masks, respirators and head mounts for the face shields. the response of the automotive industry is analyzed indicatively below. during this period group vag was capable of producing face shields (350 units per day), automated ventilators (13 prototypes) , reusable respirators (60 per day), and surgical masks (1000 per day) while psa and fca groups were producing respirators (200 per day), visors (30 per day) and masks accordingly. the experienced manufacturers and industrial consortiums not only transformed their production line to create the required equipment but also, by working side by side with the traditional medical suppliers achieved to share their knowledge in how to improve their production rates. in some cases, industries lent equipment, mainly 3d printers, to research centers in order to manufacture simple equipment for the protection of local hospital staff (table 3). http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 for peer review (doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5073 published by university of turin) http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 41 table 3: car manufacturers contributions (mapping the auto manufacturers building ppe and medical equipment to battle covid-19, 2020) manufacturer product partner details bmw ventilator parts none utilization of the 3d printers ferrari ventilator parts siare engineering supercar maker is preparing to manufacture parts at its factory fiat chrysler ventilator parts/ masks siare engineering -siare notes that carmakers have more component purchasing power than it does. -aiming to distribute to emergency workers and first responders initially. ford ventilators ge healthcare rawsonville previously made oil pumps, battery packs, induction systems, ignition coils and fuel pumps general motors ventilators ventec life systems kokomo previously made electronic and semiconductors components jaguar land rover masks n/a its own design utilizing its 3d printing capabilities linamar ventilator parts o-two medical technologies partnership between linamar, magna and martinrea to provide parts for ventilator designs mahindra ventilators unnamed ventilator producer manufacturing face shields and working on developing a low-cost ventilator design that will cost less than 7.500$ per unit magna ventilator parts o-two medical technologies partnership between linamar, magna and martinrea to provide parts for ventilator designs marelli corporation ventilator parts siare engineering discussions are being held to confirm whether italian manufacturers will build parts themselves or increase siare’s capacity martinrea ventilator parts o-two medical technologies partnership between linamar, magna and martinrea to provide parts for ventilator designs mclaren ventilators consortium joined a uk consortium to develop an emergency ventilator for rapid deployment mercedes f1 cpap devices none developed and building a cpap machine which could reduce the need for medical ventilators by keeping the patients out of intensive care nissan ventilators consortium joined a uk consortium to develop an emergency ventilator for rapid deployment seat ventilators protofy xyz and others the design uses 3d printed gears and a repurposed windscreen wiper motor from the seat leon and is made on the leon subframe assembly tesla ventilators medtronic aiming to develop its own design using many parts repurposed from tesla cars toyota masks filters none preparing to 3d print face masks for emergency personnel and preparing to produce filters for respirator and ventilator use. volkswagen ventilator parts none the company is looking to utilize its 125 industrial 3d printers to build ventilator parts source: authors elaboration the contribution of additive manufacturing in that effort seems to be of utmost importance due to the flexibility of the process which gives the possibility to everyone possessing a 3d printing machine to create/develop a part, without manufacturing experience. the solution of injection molding follows as the process which is ideal to produce a significant volume of products in specific time. that process also http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 for peer review (doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5073 published by university of turin) http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 42 involves the development of molds and the machine set up, assuming the existence of the machine in a facility. 5 capability & agility of manufacturing processes and manufacturing resilience 5.1 quantifying the processes capabilities the centralized mass production for medical supplies made from plastic takes advantage of the forming processes. in the industrial scale it is crucial to produce with high productivity rate, low cost, and fair product quality. moreover, the production has to be flexible enough to produce a variety of products without wasting time and money to change the equipment every time that a new design comes to the production (chryssolouris, 2006). in figure 7 the recommended manufacturing processes for several materials can be seen, considering also the production volume and the melting temperature of the machined material. the estimated production volume for medical supplies like face shields, face masks etc. is identified between 10! and 10". therefore, the forming processes seems to be the preferable for that kind of production. the diagram has also been reformed to an axes form, showing the two criteria independtly. figure 7: manufacturing processes vs material (a) (b) sources: (a) original form of the diagram (chryssolouris, 2006), (b) reformulated form of the diagram according to chryssolouris (chryssolouris, 2006), forming processes are divided into casting and melting processes. the casting process involves the effect of gravity during the filling of the mold while the melting process takes advantage of applied pressure to process viscous polymers, at high temperatures, forcing the material to flow under the effect of gravity. for plastic material, the molding process correlates with melting processes, which takes place with the aid of a mold, similarly to casting process in metals. a wide range of molding processes can be found, namely; compression molding, transfer molding, injection molding, extrusion, reaction injection molding, rotational molding, calendering, and melt spinning. the http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 for peer review (doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5073 published by university of turin) http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 43 characteristics of the forming processes are included on the table below (table 4). in this study it is important to have bear in mind that non-dedicated for medical supplies factories have to be transformed in production lines with high production rate, fair quality to protect the medical staff and assist the diseased people as well as low labour cost. assuming that the transformation is possibly to happen on industries with facilities to create the mould and then proceed to the injection molding for the production, the cost can be maintained on low levels for tooling, while the transformation period can be significant small. table 4: forming process characteristics cost production rate quality flexibility forming processes high tooling/low labor cost high medium to low low sources: chryssolouris, 2006 the above-mentioned characteristics there are available for every process explaining the reason why industries decide to run the production with the aid of certain processes based on four main indicators: a. material selection b. manufacturing of complex designs. c. time for the preparation of the process (molds, machine process parameters, etc.) d. production rate e. ramp up rate the meaning of the first three terms can be easily extracted. the material term refers to the choice that engineers have made to be used for a certain product based on its properties. the material choice is the first step for the development of a product and manufacturing process selection. figure 8 shows preferable processes for the manufacturing of products based on their raw material. if the circumstances lead to change the raw material, then, all the production process has to change as well as the design of the product. so, there is a strong relationship between the product design and the raw material choice, explaining why the design is the second step of the process selection. the product design guides the manufacturing process. complex parts spend too much time in manufacturing processes (one dedicated machine or more machines based on the manufacturing phases) while simple designs need significantly less time. moreover, the part design defines the required equipment to run the process. as an example, for injection molding process male or female molds are required. http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 for peer review (doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5073 published by university of turin) http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 44 the complexity of molds design (italian engineers support the fight against the covid-19 virus by 3d printing valves to medical equipment, 2020) and manufacturing is considered as extra time added to the final production time. up to this point it can be extracted that on the one hand, for small production volumes and for immediate initiation of production, processes that require complementary equipment to run should be avoided, while, on the other hand, the extra time spent at the early stages of production (mold manufacturing/design) is covered due to the increased production rates that a process, such as injection molding, can offer. production rate refers to the number of units produced over time. the production rate can be expressed, when the production run smoothly, and the machines are optimized. at an earlier stage, the production has been tested in several scenarios, in order to examine if there are issues that can lead to faulty products. so, three stages can be pointed; a) pilot production when the first parts come out of the production and both the machines and the parts are under inspection to ensure, that the products follow the product requirements and the machines are in good condition; b) the low volume phase where the production line work at 50% of its potentials in order to control the production in terms of energy consumption, cost as well as the wear of machines; c) the high volume phase where the product quality, production volume, energy consumption etc. are optimized and they remain constant over time (ball, 2011). the last term ramp up expresses the rate with a production can address all the knowledge obtained during the low volume production in order to move to high volume production or from pilot production to low volume production. if the ramp up is low, then the production needs much time to alter from the one level to the other. the ramp up time as well as the different production phases can be seen below. figure 8: production phases sources: ball, 2011 http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 for peer review (doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5073 published by university of turin) http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 45 figure 9 aims to present how the five main process selection indicators affect each process. the scale 1(low)-5(high) defines the variety of different materials that can be processed on each process, the capability and agiility of processing complex designs, the required time for the preparation of each process and finally which one of the available processes can offer higher and lower production and ramp up rate. to this end, it can be said that this scale is a comparative means for the examined parameters. e.g. the ramp up rate for additive manufacturing processes can be equal to joining process and higher of removing process. this happens due to the process variables that are involved on the process; for removing processes, factors such as cutting fluid temperature and flow, cutting tool failures, workpiece placement on the table, process parameters selection etc. seems to reduce the ramp up rate, while in am processes, less factors are involved such as process parameters selection and filament replacement after certain time intervals, leading to higher ramp up rate. a utility function derived from these five criteria could be defined, however, the current framework ought to take the five constituents separately into consideration, in terms of a five-dimension vector (or more formally like an array). this five-fold metric could be called as extended manufacturing process agility metric. figure 9: process selection procedure (each component has a unique scale) utilizing extended process agility http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 for peer review (doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5073 published by university of turin) http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 46 source: authors elaboration 5.2 considering glocal hubs manufacturing as a manufacturing model for enhanced resilience the glocal hub manufacturing model is defined as numerous locally placed manufacturing subsystems that act together in a unified network to cover a demand that appears at a global level (trappey, 2007). the glocal hub manufacturing system shares similarities with the hub-and-spoke system the airlines use to better cover the travelling demands from minor origins and destinations and at the same time remain cost efficient (cook, 2014). with an opposite mentality, the initial approach to cover a large part demand was to subcontract the overall need to a single supplier and after the production of the total batches is completed, the orders are divided and shipped to the locations in need accordingly. when time response is critical and demand spikes can occur, this singular supplier system indicates high risks of bottlenecking and failure. the three main causes were identified to be: i). the singular supplier’s production stops and requires additional troubleshooting actions and time to restart. ii). the utilization and setup of additional manufacturing equipment for parallel production is cost intensive. iii). the global shipping network is overloaded. implementing the glocal hub manufacturing model for mass production compensates for the above risks of the singular supplier model. the large number of local manufactures, near the hub in the high supply need, secure that in the scenario of failure of a production line of one or more suppliers, the http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 for peer review (doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5073 published by university of turin) http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 47 remaining functioning ones can intensify their production rates to supplement the failure or at least partially cover the supply demand. the ability to utilize additional equipment in a short time is process dependent. as an example, in the case of the respirators which faced excessive demand during covid19 pandemic, additive manufacturing machines were more efficient and flexible to set up the process and inititate the small scale production than injection molding machines. finally, the organized glocal hubs cotributed to shorter traveling distance between the supply and demand which performed better in the case of a shipping network malfunction. the current circumstances regarding the covid-19 outbreak created an absurd spike on the demand of medical devices (haleem, 2020). the identified medical components can be divided into two main categories; a) the ones that can be manufactured exclusively by a specific manufacturing process and b) those that with simple desing modifications can be manufactured via alternative ones (figure 10, figure 11). figure 10: examples of additive manufactured (a) (b) sources: (a) additive manufactured valve for emergency masks to assist patients suffering from respiratory failure (ferrari continues its efforts to fight the covid-19 pandemic, 2020) ,[b] similar valve for oxygen respirator were an urge, the right one (italian engineers support the fight against the covid19 virus by 3d printing valves to medical equipment, 2020) figure 11: face mask mold, injection molding for mass production http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 for peer review (doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5073 published by university of turin) http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 48 source: edition 2020, 2020 when it comes to mass production of medical equipment, the production is centralized, and the supplying distribution is realized via the shipping network. that is, the uneven equipment demands across the globe, combined by the bottleneck of the supply network between asia and europe resulted in crucial deficiencies of medical equipment. a profound solution was given to this issue by the additive manufacturing community, from individuals with both professional and desktop equipment. the medical components that were on shortage and that had part features that where am manufacturable (bikas, lianos, 2019) were rapidly reverse engineered and manufactured in large numbers from users that acted as suppliers with access to am equipment. the demand was thus covered via the localized manufacturing hub model. the small batch of approximately 12 pieces per print was counteracted by the number of the available equipment spread across european countries. only greece has an active 3d printing community for plastic manufacturing that is estimated to be of more than 2000 individuals with at least one am machine each. to understand the better suitability of am in the case of the covid-19 pandemic the medical equipment demand and supply chain must be investigated. i). the first point was that the overall demand increased in a short period of time. ii). the second aspect was that the overall large number of medical equipment produced were to be distributed in smaller numbers among the hospital units that were facing shortage. this step in the supply chain was bottlenecked from the shipping networks that were also facing profound numbers in regional and international level. the am supply chain was in the contrary locally identified and evenly spread due to the low cost of the am plastic equipment. this made the shipping more efficient as the hospitals were supplied by close-by am suppliers. this alternative way was also not dependent on a singular standalone large supplier but on http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 for peer review (doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5073 published by university of turin) http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 49 a coherent network of the am community of small but numerous professional and amateur individuals. this resulted to the satisfaction of the demand spike more efficiently with am compared to the injection molding supply. the idea behind the decision making for the most suitable process is to provide; a) rapid response from the initial demand spike to the first manufactured part and b) high production rates to cover the global demand in time. the parameter of time is the most critical parameter in that decision making framework. these two system characteristics are contradicting for a singular manufacturing process. as the mass production capacity and pace increase, the agility of the system decreases, whereas a highly agile system is not capable of mass production. to abide to both specifications a hybrid system it seems to be more functional. the first subsystem can manufacture rapidly and produce initial batches to feed the demand (am). this buys time for the second system to reach high production levels and cover the overall demand (injection molding) 6 workflow adaptation for the production of respiratory components to investigate further the mechanism behind this unprecedented supply chain, the respiratory component was chosen as a case study (figure 10). the additive manufacturing(am) and injection molding(im) productions are to be compared for the manufacturing performance. all the different process steps and their relative durations were identified for a new supplier to initiate production (table 5). table 5 am and im process steps comparison steps injection molding additive manufacturing 1 part design for injection molding manufacturability part design for am manufacturability 2 mold design and manufacturing optimizing the process parameters 3 optimizing the process parameters part manufacturing 4 part manufacturing source: authors elaboration in figure 12, it can be seen that the am response time for the initial part manufacturing is much shorter than the one for injection molding. this is due to the fact that the process steps from part design to the actual part manufacturing are fewer and shorter. the aforementioned quantities for the required time and production rate are an indicative average. the actual numbers are case dependent and can vary. that is, once the upstream steps are realized, the capacity and production of injection molding is far superior compared to am. http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 for peer review (doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5073 published by university of turin) http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 50 figure 12: (a) compared process steps, (b) comparing injection molding and 3d printing: preparation time in im concerns design of the mold, while in 3dp it concerns design of the part. based on authors estimation and literature (a) (b) source: guidance for wearing and removing personal protective equipment in healthcare settings for the care of patients with suspected or confirmed covid-19, 2020 from figure 12 the utility function that measures the success of the decision making for the appropriate manufacturing method can be obtained. it is noted that the utility function, being a means to measure the success of a decision that is affected from different factors (pavan, todeschini,2009), due to the complexity of this application, remains to be an array of the aforementioned different aspects. finally, the roadmap for the covid-19 pandemic crisis, considering all the intermediate actions and steps that were necessary in order to confront this situation, can be seen below in figure 13. in order for this framework to be taken into consideration, one has to take into account that there are two arbitrary assumptions under which it has been formed; i). the question on the decrease of the demand (annotated in grey colour) should be not done after every step, as it has been considered unlikely to exit an emergency situation in short time ii). the production shift should be designed early enough (the second grey box) figure 13: roadmap for covid-19 case http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 for peer review (doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5073 published by university of turin) http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 51 source: authors elaboration 7 conclusion the ongoing unpredictable socia-financial situation due to covid-19 pandemic required special treatment in all different fields of everyday life. the industrial world reacted with its own means, taking advantage of the whole inventory of manufacturing processes, in order to cover the demand of medical supplies in a limited time space. the r&d and the commercialization of am printers, followed by the development of local hubs, created a network of individuals and traditional manufacturers that were capable to produce low production volume until the non flexible production lines managed to raise the mass production upto the desired levels. the industrial world, organized in consortiums, has provided technologies and infrastructures to face that situtations. the corporate social responsibility (csr) ideal created the pillars and guide the industrial world to this effort. the expansion of this pandemic was tackled by combining all the available resources and manufacturing processes. to this end, this paper proposed the development of a decision making framework that depends on the parameters that governs every time the situations. in this work, the process time, the production volume, the flexibility in terms of processing different materials and the ramp up rate, were the main factors that were used as indicators for the process selection. by investigating the capabilities of each manufactuirng process, a hybrid manufacturing solutions was http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 for peer review (doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5073 published by university of turin) http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 52 proposed. at the beginning of this effort, glocal hubs were capable to produce, in very short time, low production volume in order to offer it to local hospitals. during this time, the industrial world was trying to adopt and transform the production lines in order to maximize the production of medical supplies, matching the demand. the combination of the aforementioned solutions with the aid of am and im processes, managed to provide enough equipment to cover the global needs for medical supplies in less time than applying each solution individually. however, this call to action was based on the individual companies’ internal decision making policies and agenda, thus, a coherent and legislated framework is needed to secure the response in similar future crisis across the world. as future research, the source of this shortage has to be studied in depth as well as to quantify how the individuals, the small enterprises and the industries managed to reach the desired production levels to counteract this shortage. moreover, the way that glocal hubs were organized can be expanded and analyzed as a means to face similar crisis in the future. the modern means of communication, the automation technologies and the commercialization of am seem capable to support similar reactions in the future. in europe and in the western world in general, the educational programs can adopt lessons that familiarize the young people and the individuals with modern technologies such as additive manufacturing, 3d design with computer aided design (cad) software, e-commerce, etc. that are fundamental for the requirements and the standrads of the modern world and they were crucial to overcome this difficult situation. if people understand and analyze what causes this unprecedented shortage of medical supplies, everyone will be better prepared to face a similar situation in the future, not only for medical supplies but for every kind of equipment. in terms of future technical developments, the manufacturing processes, regadless of the mechanism, ought to be improved in terms of flexibility, rampup time and production rate, so that manufacturing succeeds in safekeeping population through meeting demand for emergencies. acknowledgements this work is under the framework of eu project avangard. this project has received funding from the european union’s horizon 2020 research and innovation program under grant agreement no 869986. the dissemination of results herein reflects only the authors’ view and the commission is not responsible for any use that may be made of the information it contains. http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 for peer review (doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5073 published by university of turin) http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 53 references abid h., mohd j. (2020). 3d printed medical parts with different materials using additive manufacturing. clinical epidemiology and global health, 8(1), 215-223. ahern j. (2011). from fail-safe to safe-to-fail: sustainability and resilience in the new urban world. landscape and urban planning, 100(4), 341-343. ball p., roberts s., natalicchio a., scorzafave c. (2011). modelling production ramp-up of engineering products. proceedings of the institution of mechanical engineers, part b: journal of engineering manufacture, 225. baumers m., dickens p., tuck c., hague r. (2015). the cost of additive manufacturing: machine productivity, economies of scale and technology-push. technological forecasting and social change, 102. 10.1016/j.techfore.2015.02.015. bessant j., francis d., meredith s., kaplinsky r., brown s. (2000). developing manufacturing agility in smes. international journal of manufacturing technology and management, 2, 730-756. 10.1504/ijmtm.2000.001374. bikas h., lianos a.k., stavropoulos p. (2019). a design framework for additive manufacturing. the international journal of advanced manufacturing technology, 103, 3769-3783. bikas h., stavropoulos p., chryssolouris g. (2016). additive manufacturing methods and modelling approaches: a critical review. the international journal of advanced manufacturing technology, 83(1), 389-405. cantrell j., rohde s., damiani d., gurnani r., disandro l., anton j., young a., jerez a., steinbach d., kroese c., ifju p. (2017). experimental characterization of the mechanical properties of 3d printed abs and polycarbonate parts. advancement of optical methods in experimental mechanics, 3, 89-105. carayannis e.g., von zedtwitz m. (2005). architecting glocal (global–local), real-virtual incubator networks (g-rvins) as catalysts and accelerators of entrepreneurship in transitioning and developing http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 for peer review (doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5073 published by university of turin) http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 54 economies: lessons learned and best practices from current development and business incubation practices. technovation, 25(2), 95-110. chartier y. (ed.). (2014). safe management of wastes from health-care activities. world health organization. chryssolouris g. (2006). manufacturing systems: theory and practice, 2nd edition. cook g.n. & goodwin j. (2008). airline networks: a comparison of hub-and-spoke and point-topoint systems. the journal of aviation/aerospace education & research. 17, 51-60. 10.15394/jaaer.2008.1443. coronavirus disease (covid-19) pandemic, https://www.who.int/emergencies/diseases/novelcoronavirus2019?gclid=cjwkcajw9vn4brbaeiwah0mude7y_2m09vfxlj6i2se3fcxbysn6b1757etmznjbrv rfznoblruyhrocaweqavd_bwe, accessed 27/07/2020 corporate social responsibility & responsible business conduct, https://ec.europa.eu/growth/industry/sustainability/corporate-social responsibility_en#:~:text=european%20commission%20strategy%20on%20csr,to%20international% 20guidelines%20and%20principles.&text=the%20strategy%20also%20improves%20self,of%20social %20and%20environmental%20information, accessed 27/07/2020 covid-19 coronavirus pandemic, https://www.worldometers.info/coronavirus/, accessed 27/07/2020 designs for live-saving breathing aid to be made freely available, https://www.mercedesamgf1.com/en/news/2020/04/ucl-uclh-f1-project-pitlane-start-delivery-breathingaids-nhs-hospitals/, accessed 27/07/2020 douglas m.l., cooper m.c. (2000). issues in supply chain management. industrial marketing management, 29(1), 65-83. edition 2020, covid response, https://www.mvd.gr/, accessed 27/07/2020 edwards k.l. (2003). designing of engineering components for optimal materials and manufacturing process utilisation. materials & design, 24(5), 355-366. elling r., politis j. (1983). an evaluation of emergency medical technicians' ability to use manual ventilation devices. annals of emergency medicine, 12(12), 765-768. http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 for peer review (doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5073 published by university of turin) http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 55 fauci a. s., lane h. c., redfield r. r. (2020). covid-19—navigating the uncharted. n engl j med, 382, 1268-1269 fayezi s., zutshi a., o'loughlin a. (2017). understanding and development of supply chain agility and flexibility: a structured literature review. international journal of management reviews, 19, 379407. ferrari. (2020). ferrari continues its efforts to fight the covid-19 pandemic, https://corporate.ferrari.com/en/ferrari-continues-its-efforts-fight-covid-19-pandemic, accessed 27/07/2020 gu x., jin x., ni j., koren y. (2015). manufacturing system design for resilience. procedia cirp, 36, 135-140. guidance for wearing and removing personal protective equipment in healthcare settings for the care of patients with suspected or confirmed covid-19, https://www.ecdc.europa.eu/en/publicationsdata/guidance-wearing-and-removing-personal-protective-equipment-healthcare-settings, accessed 27/07/2020 italian engineers support the fight against the covid-19 virus by 3d printing valves to medical equipment, https://3dprintingcenter.net/2020/03/15/italians-support-the-fight-against-the-covid-19-virusby-3d-printing-valves-to-medical-equipment/, accessed 27/07/2020 komineas g., foteinopoulos p., papacharalampopoulos a., stavropoulos p. (2018). build time estimation models in thermal extrusion additive manufacturing processes, procedia manufacturing, 21. kose h., jin m., peng t. (2020). quality and productivity trade-off in powder-bed additive manufacturing. prog addit manuf, 5, 199–210. leendert b.f. (1992). manufacturing processes from an industrial management viewpoint. computer integrated manufacturing systems, 5(4), 269-275. li p., xiao-hui n., hua l., ning z., yan-feng g., fen p. (2020). continuous positive airway pressure versus mandibular advancement device in the treatment of obstructive sleep apnea: a systematic review and meta-analysis. sleep medicine. mapping the auto manufacturers building ppe and medical equipment to battle covid-19, https:\www.just-auto.com\analysis\mapping-the-auto-manufacturers-building-ppe-and-medicalequipment-to-battle-covid-19_id194945.aspx, accessed 27/07/2020 http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 for peer review (doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5073 published by university of turin) http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 56 marti pons-òdena, arnau valls, jordi grifols, ramon farré, francico jose cambra lasosa, bruce k. rubin, (2020), covid-19 and respiratory support devices, paediatric respiratory reviews. mohd j., abid h. (2018). additive manufacturing applications in medical cases: a literature-based review. alexandria journal of medicine, 54(4), 411-422. nesteruk i. (2020). estimations of the coronavirus epidemic dynamics in south korea with the use of sir model. panoutsopoulos a. (2020). known drugs and small molecules in the battle for covid-19 treatment. genes & diseases. papacharalampopoulos a., karapiperi a. and stavropoulos p. (2020). humanitarian engineering design methodology for am metallic products: a smart mobility platform case, 8th cirp conference of assembly technology and systems, 29 september to 1 october, athens, greece, pending publication in cirp procedia papacharalampopoulos a., giannoulis c., stavropoulos p., mourtzis d. (2020). a digital twin for automated root-cause search of production alarms based on kpis aggregated from iot. applied sciences. 10(7), 2377. partee b., hollister s., das s. (2006). selective laser sintering process optimization for layered manufacturing of capa [sup ®] 6501 polycaprolactone bone tissue engineering scaffolds. journal of manufacturing science and engineering-transactions of the asme. pavan m., todeschini r. (2009). 1.19 multicriteria decision-making methods, editor(s): steven d. brown, romá tauler, beata walczak,comprehensive, chemometrics, 591-629. peng t. (2016). analysis of energy utilization in 3d printing processes. procedia cirp, 40, pages 6267. personal protective equipment (ppe), https://www.england.nhs.uk/coronavirus/secondarycare/prevention/personal-protective-equipment-ppe/, accessed 27/07/2020 shokrani a., loukaides e. g., edward e., alexander j.g. lunt, (2020). exploration of alternative supply chains and distributed manufacturing in response to covid-19; a case study of medical face shields. materials & design, 192, 108749. spinelli a., pellino g. (2020). covid‐19 pandemic: perspectives on an unfolding crisis. the british journal of surgery. http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 for peer review (doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5073 published by university of turin) http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 57 stavropoulos p., foteinopoulos p. (2018). modelling of additive manufacturing processes: a review and classification. manufacturing review, 5(2), 8-34. tayler y. (2016). humanitarian engineering: innovative approaches and partnerships in crisis response. mena knowledge and learning quick notes series, 157. ti l.k., ang l.s., foong t.w. (2020). what we do when a covid-19 patient needs an operation: operating room preparation and guidance. j can anesth, 67, 756–758. top german ventilator company warns on global supply crunch, https://www.ft.com/content/2f2845b3a1ed-44cb-90af-e04d8d712403, accessed 27/07/2020 trappey c. v., trappey a. j. c., lin g. y. p., liu c. s., lee w. t. (2007). business and logistics hub integration to facilitate global supply chain linkage. proceedings of the institution of mechanical engineers, part b: journal of engineering manufacture, 221(7), 1221–1233. xi g., xiaoning j., jun n., yoram k. (2015). manufacturing system design for resilience, procedia cirp, 36, 135-140. yao w. (2020). emergency tracheal intubation in 202 patients with covid-19 in wuhan, china: lessons learnt and international expert recommendations. british journal of anaesthesia. yildiz a., ozerim m. (2014). corporate social responsibility in european context. zu z. y., jiang m. d., xu p. p., chen w., ni q. q., lu g. m., zhang l. j. (2020). coronavirus disease 2019 (covid-19): a perspective from china. radiology, 200490. 3d cad file: respirator-free reanimation venturi's valve, https://www.rs-online.com/designspark/3dcad-file-respirator-free-reanimation-venturis-valve-jp , accessed 27/07/2020 5712-article text revision-17927-1-18-20210527 european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5712 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 1 steps from zero carbon supply chains and demand of circular economy to circular business cases piontek, felix1, herrmann, constantin1 and saraev, alexandra1 1 sphera solutions gmbh, hauptstraße 111-113, 70771 leinfelden-echterdingen, germany e-mail: fpiontek@sphera.com received: 29/03/2021 accepted for publication: 09/05/2021 published: 19/07/2021 abstract the european green deal requires a zero carbon europe until 2050. consequently, all processes conducted, and actions taken need to ensure zero carbon emissions. beside the areas of energy systems, logistics and living, it certainly also includes industry sectors, industrial processes, and their entire supply chains. zero carbon supply chains mean net zero carbon emission from scope 1, 2 and 3. the key question for future business is therefore how to reduce the carbon emissions of all procured components down to zero, beside all procured and consumed energies (scope 1 and 2). a promising approach is a circular economy if primary produced materials will not be provided carbon neutral or will increase in price. however, today the development of circular business models often is a chicken and egg problem. it needs a clear business case to invest into changes, adaptions, substitutions, or life cycle system adjustments of linear products (take, make, dispose) to turn them into circular products or product systems (avoid, re-use, recycle, recover). the paper presents approaches and companies seeking carbon neutral products in a carbon neutral europe via identifying business cases for circular products. an evaluation matrix is presented allowing the identification of circularity status depending on the selected products or sector perspective. the matrix contains evaluation criteria based on the circularity building blocks by the ellen macarthur foundation. based on the results, hot spots and weak points are identified and allow entering a sixstep-approach for business-case identification. the steps refer to life cycle thinking, quantitative environmental assessment, simulation, creativity methods and end up identifying profitable business cases for circularity. the goal is to avoid trade-offs and to consider economic and environmental factors side by side. the presented approach combines life cycle assessment, circular economy and the development of business models and is partly developed and applied during the european h2020 project avangard. keywords: net zero, circular economy, zero carbon approach, business case, zero carbon supply chain, life cycle thinking 1. introduction in recent years, incentives as well as outside pressure are rising for companies to lower their carbon footprint. the paris agreement adopted by the united nations in 2015 aims to limit the temperature increase to 1.5 °c above pre-industrial levels. this means that the emission of greenhouse gases (ghg) has to be reduced significantly. in december 2019 the european union (eu) announced that it wants to be climate-neutral by 2050 (european commission, 2019). already before that more and more companies like volkswagen, bp, microsoft, apple and others committed to produce carbon neutral products or want to become carbon neutral or even carbon negative as an organisation as a whole. at the beginning of 2021, the science based targets (sbti) initiative reports over 1200 companies acting, over 600 companies having science-based targets and over 400 companies which explicitly commit to a maximum increase of the global average temperature below 1,5 °c (sbti,2021). european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5712 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 2 the paris agreement states that finance flows as well should be consistent with a pathway towards low ghg emissions and investing companies like blackrock publish statements that sustainability should be a new standard for investing. by including social and environmental aspects of sustainability into his letter to the ceos in 2018, the chairman and ceo of blackrock larry fink takes part in a shift from soft and sometimes greenwashed approach towards sustainability to a hard and essential factor of business (fink, 2018). all these actions, announcements and developments cause that over the last few years, sustainability efforts are changing from purely voluntarily published and often superficial sustainability reports to an important part of risk mitigation and a transparent positioning towards costumers and investors. at the beginning of 2021, the investment bank goldman sachs joined blackrock by publishing its own sustainability efforts including climate-related considerations towards investing (solomon, 2021). driven by the governmental initiatives mentioned above and a rising pressure by customers, other businesses as well as end consumers, net zero carbon emissions and other aspects of environmental and social aspects of sustainability as well as publishing transparent information become an important part of conducting business. due to the demand of various stakeholders, companies are searching for business models which offer reduced environmental impacts as well as profitability. it must be assured that the way a company conducts business is aligned with global goals to address climate change while earning money. additionally, a company should be able to communicate the implemented measures in a comprehensible way and to disclose emissions and reduction targets. this paper presents a way to address these needs answering the question “how can profitable circular business models be developed ensuring lower environmental impacts aiming for net zero emissions?” 1.1 net zero what does net zero really mean? for businesses, net zero includes the elimination of ghg emissions throughout the entire value chain (schulz, 2020). according to the greenhouse gas protocol published by the world resource institute (wri) together with the world business council for sustainable development (wbcsd) the ghg emissions of a company can be categorized into three scopes: scope 1 includes the direct emissions from the facilities and vehicles of the reporting company. scope 2 represents the emissions linked to electricity, heating and cooling and steam purchased for own use. those are often already assessed and reported by companies. however, the analysis of scope 3 is not yet widespread, although it often can include the largest part of emissions related to operations depending on the sector (sbti, 2018). figure 1 presents the three scopes graphically. scope 3 includes 15 sub-categories upstream and downstream, e.g., purchased goods and services, capital goods, business travel and employee commuting (greenhouse gas protocol, 2011). to be a truly carbon neutral company, an assessment of the hotspots of scope 3 emissions must be conducted and according to an ambitious target setting the emissions must be reduced to net zero carbon emissions. especially the sub-categories 1 (purchased goods and services) and 11 (use of sold products) of scope 3 might be orders of magnitude larger than scope 1 and 2. if a company sources most of the components of its products from its supply chain, as for example many oems e.g., in the automotive or consumer electronics sectors do, category 1 is related to more emissions than the assembly of the final products. if a product sold consumes fuels or electricity, the related emissions belong to category 11 and might, for example in the case of cars, planes, and many electronic goods, exceed scope 1 and 2. the reduction of emissions linked to these categories can be addressed by ecodesign of products and services considering material usage and emissions during use phase. typical approaches and measures consider efficiency, not only during use, but also during production and over the entire supply chain. this is often referred to as resource efficiency. but actually, the avoidance of resource use should be the goal rather than only lowering depletion and ghg emissions. this applies to the avoidance of wasted energy as well as wasted materials and avoidance of scrap production. it includes the shift to power production from green or renewable sources and bio-based fuels. an approach to maximize efficiency and use intensity and to avoid resource use might include a shift to more service-related circular business models, changes in material composition of products and optimizing emissions during use as well as options to prolong the lifetime of products. the longer a product is used the later the production of a new product which substitutes the old one is necessary. for this statement to be true, a product must fulfill the intended demand over its entire lifecycle so that the actual lifetime matches the duration of the technologically possible service life. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5712 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 3 figure 1. graphical representation of scope 1, 2 and 3 source: greenhouse gas protocol. (2011). corporate value chain (scope 3) accounting and reporting standard, s. 7. the complexity of the various options and measures for a reduction and the avoidance of unnecessary use of resources and ghg emissions, which can be summarized as ecodesign, needs to cover all effect over the entire life cycle. this can only be achieved by a bottom-up approach looking at the details of each individual product and how costumers are using them. this might allow for a more feasible way to identify how to reduce emissions compared to a pure top-down approach often focused on calculations of scope 1, 2 and 3 of an entire company. while scopes 1 and 2 and some sub-categories of scope 3 could be brought down to zero or nearly zero by technological development like electricity solely from renewable sources or carbon neutral fuels, materials to manufacture products or build facilities are still linked to emissions. therefore, an inclusion of all 3 scopes and all related aspects is necessary to achieve net zero emissions. 1.2 circular economy one way to reduce or negate the emissions linked to materials and consumption is the implementation of a circular economy (ce). ce can be defined as “…an economic system that is based on business models which replace the ‘end-of-life’ concept with reducing, alternatively reusing, recycling and recovering materials in production/distribution and consumption processes […] with the aim to accomplish sustainable development…” on different levels. (kirchherr et al., 2017) to establish a ce and for companies to be a part of it, business models which lower emissions and use less or no primary materials, but also generate profit are needed. as business models must be economically sustainable to ensure future success, keeping materials in the loop must be more attractive than simply continuing business as before and paying for carbon offsets. additionally, organisations like the sbti initiative (sbti, 2020) or cdp (former carbon disclosure project) (cdp, 2021) and even companies which provide carbon offsetting opportunities (southpole, n.d.) state that avoidance of emissions should be the goal rather than offsetting. additionally, the price for offsetting carbon is and will most likely keep rising. this can be illustrated by the example of emissions related to fossil fuels in germany: from 25 euros per released ton of co2 equivalents in 2021 an increase to 55 euros in 2025 will be followed by an auction system. the german environment agency even suggested 180 euro per ton (matthey & bünger, 2019) as a fair and compensating price for damages indirectly caused by the effects of rising temperatures. avoiding the release of ghg in operations as well as over the value chain might offer business cases beyond energy efficiency and a shift to renewable energy. the eu circular economy action plan as part of the european green deal includes measures to make sustainable products the norm in the eu and to make circularity work for people, regions and cities (european commission, 2020). in its first iteration it already focuses on various sectors including electronics and ict, batteries and vehicles, packaging, plastics, textiles, european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5712 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 4 construction and buildings, food as well as water and nutrients. beside the political agenda, the ellen macarthur foundation, a leading organization in the field of ce, defines four essential building blocks for a ce. the four blocks are: circular design, new business models, reverse logistics and cycles as well as enablers and favourable system conditions (ellen macarthur foundation, n.d.). after a short overview of the applied methodology, chapter 3 presents an approach to analyse the current status of business models and processes within a company towards their readiness for ce in the format of an evaluation matrix for approaching ce. chapter 4 explains a six steps approach to identify weak points and hotspots as well as deriving possibilities to address business cases including an evaluation of the environmental impacts of the circular solution. the goal is to support companies to transform their business in accordance with the challenges of a more circular and sustainable future and to create a safer, more sustainable and productive world. 2. methodology the approaches in this paper have been develop based on theoretical analysis and on the practical experience of the authors. while no single qualitative or quantitative study is the basis of this text, it summarizes the findings of several case studies and takes projects conducted together with various companies and partners into account. as it is the goal to allow for fact-based decision making, quantitative methods to evaluate the businesses models and to assess environmental impacts are include in the presented approaches. 3. evaluation matrix before a company can develop circular business models, it should assess the current way of its operations to identify hotspots and opportunities. figure 2 shows a schematic matrix to support the assessment. the matrix was developed by sphera and is refined over the course of the avangard project (www.avangard-project.eu). the four main categories are derived from the four building blocks for ce by the ellen macarthur foundation as mentioned above. the sub-categories and indicators should be adapted to the company and its respective industry or market sector. the evaluation can be carried out internally but might be supported by external experts. it is helpful to bring together employees from different departments to get a comprehensive overview. when analysing the status quo and filling out the matrix, the entire life cycle of the product or product group must be considered. this is equivalent as considering scope 1, 2 and 3 as explained in section 1.1 of this paper. to further develop the matrix shown in figure 2, multiple case studies have to be conducted. by doing this, general and industry specific indicators can be developed. different scales (e.g., fiveor seven-point likert scales) could be tested and can be colour-coded to allow for a concise and self-reflective evaluation of the status quo of products and business models within a company and their potential for circularity. hotspots like totally linear operations or chances to further develop existing offerings (e.g., refurbishment, the use of recycled spare-parts or changeable components like batteries) into fully circular business models can be identified. while filling out the matrix, it is important to consider the full life cycle of the products and their impacts on the environment. this might be challenging for employees and executives who are not yet familiar with life cycle thinking, but it is a pre-requisite to understand cause and effects per aspect of various stages relevant for ce (e.g., logistics, user behaviour, ability for repair, maintenance, disassembly and fractionising for optimized recyclability). as soon as it is fully developed and tested, the matrix should be accompanied by a written guide, or the process could be moderated by external environmental experts. the presented approach serves the purpose and offers an opportunity to start a process of self-reflection. the matrix enables a comparison with competitors from the same industry or companies and business models from other industries. of course, currently there are no reference values for different industries. therefore, companies and consulting experts must use their own understanding of the situation and be careful not to overor underestimate the scores of competitors and the company itself. a comparison to other, similar industry sector supports the process by highlighting gaps and opportunities. in summary, the matrix can be used for self-reflection which can be the basis of further assessments, benchmarking against competitors or other industries and for the development and proof of concept. if the matrix itself is not enough to come up with sustainable and functioning business models, a structured process presented in the next chapter can follow. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5712 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 5 figure 2. schematic assessment matrix source: based on herrmann, constantin. (2020, november 19), from zero carbon supply chains to circular electronics: steps to more sustainability [conference presentation]. e-waste world conference & expo, frankfurt, germany. http://www.avangard-project.eu/event/e-waste-world-conference-expo/ 4. six-step-approach to develop circular business models after an assessment of the status quo, gaps and potential changes using the matrix presented in the previous chapter, companies know their status regarding to upside and improvement potentials towards a ce. now they need a process to shift their operations towards circularity while making sure that this shift does not actually lead to more ghg emissions or more harmful environmental impacts in general. the development of circular business models might present itself as a chicken and egg problem. often the linear business models will not reveal a circular and profitable business case and vice versa, theoretical business cases might not work using the existing linear products. therefore, figure 3 presents a process to develop new business models while assessing and comparing the resulting potential environmental impacts from simulated circular products and business models. step 1 includes a life cycle analysis, e.g., using the life cycle assessment (lca) methodology according to iso 14040 and 14044 (iso 2006a, 2006b). it can refer to the linear product or the business models identified for potential change using the matrix presented above. the analysis should include all impact categories relevant to the company and to the respective industry and not solely focus on ghg emissions even though this might currently be the impact category which receives the most public attention. but while less noted impact categories should not be neglected, a so-called screening lca based on publicly available databases such as the gabi database (sphera solutions gmbh, 2021) should be sufficient. this allows for the identification of environmental hotspots (step 2) of the current situation. based on the identified hot spots and weak points to be improved, main categories subcategory indicators an sub-indicators (examples) comment value design: technical aspects & design materials modularity high degree of standardization of disassembly high degree of automation of disassembly durability / long service life of components and modules (for further use) durability of components and modules ease of updating / compatibility with new product generations technical aspects reverse logistics identification collection & return low transport effort per product unit high value in relation to collection costs established / functioning collection or return system legal requirements for collection and return storage high standardization of the modules business models system conditions and other aspects competitive situation in the sales market due to many other remanufactured products availability of qualified staff value perception of remanufactured products (up/ downcycling, same quality) brand risk (in case of premature failure of remanufactured products) / branding (quality perception) as remanufactured product (b2c) safety / default risk from remanufatured products established and reliable take-back system with influence on the quantity of returned products and sales volume (product stewardship) structured framework (laws, regulations) of the market for old goods / goods for remanufacturing structured framework conditions (laws, regulations) of the sales market such as e.g. admission criteria market acceptance of remanufactured products competitive situation in the sales market due to new products good storability plannable stock (consistent flow of in-/outgoing products) good sortability of removed modules constant and plannable return quantities constant and predictable sales quantities information on the whereabouts of the product / availability for return unique product assignment materials clearly identifiable (if no material declaration available) age and condition identifiable (technical / documentation) material declarations available / identification of materials easily possible identification of modules easily possible hazardous / toxic substances (during handling, danger to employees) environmentally critical and hazardous substances (potentially with legal restrictions on recirculation) efficient removal of modules that are not used efficient exchange and handling of individual product components (sorting, preparation, exchange) ease of disassembly (to be able to use modularity) european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5712 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 6 possibilities to influence should be discussed and specified (step 3). there is no need to spend the same amount of effort and time which would be needed for a comprehensive lca including the collection of primary data from suppliers. the identified starting points for changes and measures might include a wide range of options from a change in distribution processes or market access, a change of materials (e.g., the use of secondary material or the substitution of environmentally impactful materials by others suited for the intended application) used or even the discontinuation or addition of an offer, a service or a product. the findings and aspects from step 3 allow entering steps 4 to 6, which are highly iterative and interlinked. the concrete procedure depends on the people involved, the timeline, the identified hotspots and how vast the possibilities to influence these are as well as the willingness of the parties involved to implement changes. step 4 includes an assessment of the potential environmental impacts based on the findings from step 3. this allows to compare the resulting impacts with the baseline from step 1, if the identified weak points were changed. a comparative analysis like this is necessary to make sure that no trade-offs occur, meaning that benefits in one impact category are overcompensated by more harmful impacts in another, and to prevent a change which actually leads to higher harmful impacts overall. figure 3. overview of the six-step-approach. source: based on herrmann, constantin. (2020, november 19), from zero carbon supply chains to circular electronics: steps to more sustainability [conference presentation]. e-waste world conference & expo, frankfurt, germany. http://www.avangard-project.eu/event/e-waste-world-conference-expo/ step 5 can include a broad range of methods to come up with ideas and concepts but is guided by the facts and figures of the hot spot assessments and the possibilities to influence the identified weak points. these methods can refer to for example brainstorming (clark, 1989), the 635 method (higgins & wiese, 1996), design thinking (sachse & pecker, 1999), the morphological box (higgins, 1966), the relevance tree analysis (schmidt, 2000) or the walt disney method (dilts et al., 1991). as a broad range of creativity methods is available, companies should choose a method which suits the complexity of the process, the characteristics and the number of the people involved as well as the facts and figures developed during steps 1, 2, 3 and 4. the process should take the results of the previous analyses into account but must not be limited to the options and ideas derived from the hotspot analysis. if the process is set up in the right way, it might even be possible to assess the potential environmental impacts results or preliminary results of the business models and measures developed using the creativity methods over the course of the development. this may necessitate the setting up of a process that is iterative and takes place over several days or weeks. it could be supported by a predesigned tool which allows for parameter variation showing the european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5712 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 7 resulting impacts from changes suggested. the inclusion of environmental experts is another possibility to analyse potential environmental impacts during the development of business models. step 6 concludes the presented methodology to develop circular business models, which are already tested for their environmental benefits and applicability on ce. based on the results of several assessments of environmental impacts as well as the collaborative techniques, a decision in which direction the company and its operations and offerings should be developed must be made. as the process is iterative, these decisions will be monitored and solutions for identified weaknesses can be developed and implemented. 5. benefits from a shift to circular business models the change to more circular and overall, more sustainable ways to conduct business offers various advantages. lowering ghg emissions, material use, and other environmental impacts related to the business on the one hand has benefits for the environment and on the other hand lowers the risk of costs directly (e.g., co2 taxes) or indirectly (by necessary changes due to climate change) related to ghg emissions. as it satisfies demands from various stakeholders, a shift to innovative business models can be used in communications to investors, business partners and to the public. measures regarding sustainability will be received positively by rating agencies and other players in the financial markets. as more companies pledge to source their materials and goods from sustainable suppliers, this is an advantage when selling to other companies. additionally, more sustainable offerings can attract end consumer groups which did not buy a company’s products before or did not use its services. circular business models align a company with the circular economy action plan of the european commission (2020) which relates to other european strategies to benefit the economy and the environment. an lca study conducted before implementing the developed circular business models ensures that there are environmental benefits. lower ghg emissions help companies to contribute to the targets set in the paris agreement and achieve their own goals (developed e.g., in cooperation with the sbti). by implementing a structured, iterative process which includes several sustainability assessments and should involve people from different departments, it is ensured that the new business models lower environmental impacts and that they can become economically sustainable as well. 6. discussion, conclusion, and further research the approaches developed in this paper are based on practical experience and theoretical development. they have been fully or in parts applied in projects with various companies and partners and are based on established methods like lca and several creativity methods. therefore, the presented approaches have been proven to be feasible and of practical relevance. however, this research does not evaluate the suggested methods based on a comprehensive literature review of other possibilities and ways to develop new business models. the approaches should be further developed by implementation of findings from related research as well as experiences from future case studies. as sustainability becomes more important and emerges from a “nice to have” to a fundamental pillar of conducting business, the need for carbon neutral or net zero business models is rising. circularity offers a path to minimize the emissions linked to the use of materials to produce tangible goods. this paper presents an approach to develop circular business models using a matrix approach. if the matrix approach does not lead to a successful development of business models, a six-step-approach can be used which includes lca and creativity methods embedded in a structured process. independent whether the creativity methods are used, a sustainability assessment should make sure that trade-offs are avoided. the presented approaches address the need for sustainable ways of conducting business and combines self-assessment and creative methods with lca and other sustainability assessment methods (peña et al., 2021). as the circular economy currently receives global attention, it empowers companies to develop and change their business models. the six-step-approach enables a structured process to develop more sustainable business models and ensures that they de facto lead to lower potential environmental impacts. several possibilities to adapt the process to the circumstances within a company are mentioned. as the matrix presented is still under development, more examples from case studies are needed. this would offer an opportunity to develop the scales used and will allow for a comparison to other companies and industry averages european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5712 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 8 acknowledgements the presented research has received funding from the european unions’s horizon 2020 research and innovation programme under grant agreement no ° 869986. references cdp. (2021) publication of the 2021 questionnaire preview and reporting guidance. https://www.cdp.net/en/guidance clark, ch. h. (1989): brainstorming: how to create successful ideas. wilshire book company. dilts, r., epstein, t., & dilts, r. w. (1991). tools for dreamers: strategies for creativity and the structure of innovation. meta publications. ellen macarthur foundation. (n.d.). building blocks. retrieved march 15, 2021, from https://www.ellenmacarthurfoundation.org/circular-economy/building-blocks european commission. (2019). a european green deal. https://ec.europa.eu/info/strategy/priorities-2019-2024/europeangreen-deal_en european commission. (2020). eu circular economy action plan. https://ec.europa.eu/environment/circular-economy/ fink, l. (2018). larry fink’s annual letter to ceos – 2018 – a sense of purpose. http://www.corporance.es/wpcontent/uploads/2018/01/larry-fink-letter-to-ceos-2018-1.pdf greenhouse gas protocol. (2011). corporate value chain (scope 3) accounting and reporting standard. higgins, j. m.; wiese, g. g. (1996). innovationsmanagement. kreativitätstechniken für den unternehmerischen erfolg. springer. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-642-61431-6 international organization for standardization (iso). (2006a). iso 14040:2006: environmental management — life cycle assessment — principles and framework. international organization for standardization (iso). (2006b). iso 14044:2006: environmental management — life cycle assessment — requirements and guidelines. kirchherr, j., reike, d., & hekkert, m. (2017). conceptualizing the circular economy: an analysis of 114 definitions. resources, conservation and recycling, 127, 221-232. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.resconrec.2017.09.005 matthey, a, & bünger, b.. 2019. methodenkonvention 3.0 zur ermittlung von umweltkosten: kostensätze. dessau: umweltbundesamt. peña, c., civit, b., gallego-schmid, a., druckman, a., caldeira-pires, a., weidema, b., ... & motta, w. (2021). using life cycle assessment to achieve a circular economy. the international journal of life cycle assessment, 1-6. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11367-020-01856-z sachse, p., & specker, a. (1999). design thinking: analyse und unterstützung konstruktiver entwurfstätigkeiten. in proceedings of the 12th international conference on engineering design: communication and cooperation of practice and science. 2 (vol. 26, pp. 941-946). technische universität münchen, konstruktion im maschinenbau. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5712 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 9 schmidt, g. (2000). methode und techniken der organisation. verlag g. schulz, s. (2020, october 29). what does “net zero emissions” mean and how can businesses achieve net zero?. sphera. https://sphera.com/glossary/what-does-net-zero-emissions-mean-and-how-to-achieve/ science based targets initiative. (2021) companies taking action. https://sciencebasedtargets.org/companies-taking-action science based targets initiative. (2018). value change in the value chain: best practices in scope 3 greenhouse gas management science based targets initiative. (2020). foundations for science-based net-zero target setting in the corporate sector. solomon, d. (2021) goldman sachs update on our 2030 sustainable finance commitment. https://www.goldmansachs.com/media-relations/press-releases/2021/announcement-04-mar-2021.html southpole. (n.d.) carbon offsets explained. retrieved march 15, 2021, from https://www.southpole.com/carbon-offsetsexplained zwicky, f. (1966). entdecken, erfinden, forschen im morphologischen weltbild. droemer/knaur. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5083 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 1 the importance of foreign direct investment and energy consumption and their effects on economic growth in the case of mena adel nsib adel1 1master’s student – university of sfax, tunisia e-mail: adelnecib314@gmail.com received: 12/09/2020 accepted for publication: 10/01/2022 published: 22/04/2022 abstract the main purpose of this paper is to investigate relationship between foreign direct investment and economic growth for mena countries from 1990 to 2014. we firstly tested heterogeneity and cross sectional dependence and found that all series have homogeneity and cross sectional dependence. for that reason, hadri kruzomi and pesaran et al. multifactor error structure panel unit root tests were used. for obtaining long-run relationship, we used weterlund's panel and group cointegration tests. the results supported the long-run relationship, therefore, we used common correlated effect model, thanks to this method, and coefficients for each cross-section unit could be calculated individually. keywords: economic growth; energy; renewable energy; mena; fdi; ide 1. introduction since the early 1990s, the world has been experiencing globalization, liberalization, regulation and technological progress, major changes that affect various economic sectors in different countries of the world, including most of them have chosen an economic policy issued by a pop-up in order to be able to improve its economic growth and development and meet the challenges associated with this opening up while providing an appropriate ground for global competition to attract more foreign investment. therefore, attracting fdi is always a matter of continuing interest for home countries as host countries where there is an almost complete consensus on the benefits that can be made and be attracted by fdi, they will create jobs that will promote economic growth and development, as they allow the transfer of knowledge and technology and encourage reforms, especially for host countries. in the context of development, we can also talk about the importance of energy, as this sector has seen growing interest in recent years. realizing the need to develop this sector, in terms of its economic and environmental benefits, a number of researchers have in fact documented the benign effects of alternative energies (nuclear and renewable energy) in reducing carbon dioxide emissions and reducing the impacts of climate change (alfarra and abu-hijleh, 2012; apergis et al. 2010; lee, 2014; monia and weld raphael, 2010banother important characteristic of renewable energy resources is that they promote sustainable development. glorioso et al (2007) european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5083 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 2 research on the relationship between foreign direct investment, energy consumption and economic growth is seen as a hierarchy of objectives and constraints that involve global, regional or local considerations and has attracted the interest of academic researchers and policy makers in the economic literature (root and ahmed, 1979; dunning, 1981; schneider and frey, 1985) mina (2020). fdi and energy consumption were seen as the driving force of modern economies and societies. therefore, as they were a top priority for economic growth, united nations members would need to improve fdi and access to energy in order to achieve many economic growth objectives, including poverty reduction, industrialization, health and education. indeed, the growing interest of academics and scholars in the relationship between foreign direct investment, energy consumption and economic growth has made it a platform from which we are trying to seek to clarify their impact on economic growth by asking the following question: what is the importance of foreign direct investment and energy consumption and what are their effects on economic growth in the case of the countries of the middle east and north africa?. 2. literature review and hypothesis fdi uses foreign technology and management techniques to exploit local resources at low cost. there is a clear distinction between fdi and portfolio investment: in the fdi situation, the home company has direct and ultimate control over the scope and nature of day-to-day operations, and transfers not only capital to host countries, but also technology and management skills. on the other hand, portfolio investment is simply the provision of capital from a lender to a borrower; it is motivated by the per capita rate of return and obliges borrowers to repay the loan plus interest. the investment portfolio may involve the purchase of shares, bonds or other foreign securities and has no controlling interest in the investment. the main components of fdi are: equity, reinvested earnings (the investor's share of income retained in the form of dividends by subsidiaries in proportion to its share of equity) and intra-company loans (where the investor borrows funds from the subsidiary, usually without the intention of seeking repayment). hypothesis 1: foreign direct investment (fdi) has a direct positive effect on economic growth. in contrast, the subject of fdi has been studied by several economic disciplines both theoretically and empirically. the various existing theories on fdi evolve over time to adapt to new data in the international economic environment. it is first and foremost since the turn of the 2000s that the literature on fdi has experienced a strong acceleration, in line with the development of the phenomenon. indeed, the authors who have dealt with fdi have attempted to formalize its causes by developing or applying different theoretical approaches. the arguments put forward are inspired by several theories relating to economics, trade, investment or marketing. following a chronological order, the analysis will focus on the theories that have focused in particular on the impact of fdi on development and economic growth. blomston et al (1992) khemici & abdelmadjid, k. (2013), in studying the impact of fdi on growth, have shown that the magnitude of this impact depends on the stock of human capital in the host country. the authors highlight the positive effect of fdi on income growth. moreover, (ait ken and hanison, 1993), idrissa & abdou (2019), (saggi, 2000) acquah & ibrahim (2019), have shown that fdi can generate negative, even mixed effects on the development of host countries. in the same framework, darrat et al (2005) carried out a comparative study (1979-2002) covering countries in two regions, namely those of mena and those of central and eastern europe. this study showed that fdi flows stimulate economic growth only in eu member countries. whereas, the effect of fdi remains negative or even non-existent in the mena countries. development economics argues that capital accumulation is a factor in long-term growth. however, this thesis has recently been challenged: the joint movement of investment (its gdp ratio) and the growth rate is largely driven by a third factor, technological innovation (ben habib and jovanovic, 1991; king and levine, 1994) mtiraoui, a. (2020). at this level, the oecd emphasizes the links between investment and growth, while conditioning them on the policy reforms that need to be put in place and on the need for co-operation between all countries, whether members or non-members of the organization. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5083 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 3 hypothesis 2: foreign direct investment has a negative effect on economic growth. in the energy literature, few studies have addressed the problem of intersectoral dependence and the degree of heterogeneity. therefore, to address this problem, our study applied a heterogeneous panel technique with cross-sectional dependence. moreover, energy policies developed at the global level can also affect individual nations. moreover, it also manages exogenous shocks. this is one of the studies dealing with the problems mentioned by applying heterogeneous panel techniques for some countries. hypothesis 1: an increase in renewable energy consumption improves positive production, and if there is a decrease in renewable energy consumption, energy conservation policies will have a significant negative impact on economic growth. this means that renewable energy consumption leads to economic growth, which is called the growth hypothesis. hypothesis 2: the preservation hypothesis assumes a one-way causal relationship that links economic growth to renewable energy point-of-sale consumption; thus, a decrease or increase in energy consumption will not affect economic growth. hypothesis 3: the feedback hypothesis indicates a two-way causal relationship between renewable energy consumption and economic growth. any increase in the use of renewable energy will play an important role in stimulating economic growth with the opposite effect. hypothesis 4: the neutrality hypothesis shows that these two variables are independent. most of the existing energy literature has studied the links between renewable energy use and economic growth, but has given mixed empirical results from countries. 3. methodology all time series data below were collected from the database published by the world bank. our data include the following variables: economic growth: measured by gdp per capita, an economic indicator of the wealth produced per year in a given country, in constant us dollars. foreign direct investment: these investments play a major role in the internationalization of a firm. highly appreciated by academics, they also help measure a country's economic attractiveness. -energy consumption: energy consumption is variable according to various parameters. among others, for a boiler it will depend on its efficiency, for an air conditioner on its cop and for a housing on its insulation. renewable energy: renewable energy is energy generated by natural processes that are continually replenished. it is measured by renewable energy consumption (% of total final energy consumption). -population: in statistics, a population is a finite set of objects, units or individuals that are the subject of a study or observation and which is subject to statistical processing. details on the description of the variables used and their sources are presented in table 1. table 1. description of variables and data source variables description source growth economic gdp growth (annual %) world bank foreign direct investment net foreign direct investment as % of gdp world bank european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5083 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 4 energy consumption total energy consumption world bank renewable energy renewable energy consumption (% of total final energy consumption). world bank population total population world bank source: world bank 3.1 data source the data used come from the world bank database. these data will be annual and relate to gross domestic product growth (annual gdp growth in %), net foreign direct investment as % of gdp, renewable energy consumption (% of total final energy consumption), total population, total energy consumption. there are 275 observations (1990-2015). 3.2 empirical methodology the paper uses a four-step empirical methodology. the first step is to examine the stationary properties of individual series in panel data. the second step is to test for the presence of cointegration. in the third step, we estimate our models using the estimator. the third step is to examine the shortand long-term causality between variables using the vector error correction model (vecm). in the third step, we estimate using individual effects models. in the last step one can be drawn from the ardl which integrates the ct dynamics with the lt equilibrium without losing the lt information. 3.3 unit root tests in panel data the unit root test on time series data has become one of the most important tests for economists, particularly econometricians, although the unit root test on panel data is more recent. unit root tests in panel data have become popular among economic researchers working on panel data structures because they are much more powerful than normal unit root tests for individual time series. among the various unit root tests developed in the literature, levin, lin and chu (llc) (2002) and im, pesaran and shin (ips) (2003) are the most popular. both tests are based on the adf principle. however, llc assumes homogeneity in the dynamics of the autoregressive coefficients for all panel members. in contrast, the spi is more general in that it allows for heterogeneity in these dynamics. therefore, it is described as a "heterogeneous panel unit root test". it is particularly reasonable to allow such heterogeneity in the choice of shift length in adf tests, when the imposition of a uniform shift length is not appropriate. furthermore, slope heterogeneity is more reasonable where cross-national data are used. in this case, heterogeneity is due to differences in the economic conditions and degree of development of each country. levin et al (2002) consider the following basic adf specification: (1) where δ is the first difference operator, xit s the dependent variable i over the period t, is a white noise disturbance with a variance of . both and the order of shift , 1 , 1 1 = + x + t+ x + k it i i i t i ij i t it j x a b d g u= d då 2s ib european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5083 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 5 where the alternative hypothesis corresponds to xit being stationary. the test is based on the , or is the ols estimate of in equation (4) and is his standard mistake. according to the llc test, the panel procedure significantly increases the efficiency of the finished samples. the proposed model is as follows: (2) at this level, levin et al. (2002; llc) also assumed: where the test statistic is: , is the ols estimate of in the equation (4) and is his standard error. im et al (2003) proposed a test procedure based on the middle group approach. the starting point for the ips test is also the adf regressions given in equation (1). but the null and alternative hypotheses are different from the llc test, where rejection of the null hypothesis implies that all series are stationary. we now have : h0: β1 = β 2 = … = β n = 0 vs h1: some but not necessarily all β i 0 ips developed two test statistics and called them lm-bar and t-bar tests. the alternative t-bar statistics to test the null hypothesis of the unit root for all people (βi = 0) is as follows: (3) where t is the calculated adf statistics of the individual panel members. using monte carlo simulations, ips shows that tbar convertiris normally distributed under the null hypothesis and outperforms m-bar in small samples. they then use estimates ( ) i i i t b b s b ù ù= ib ^ ( )is b , 1 , 1 1 = + x + t+ x + k it i i t i ij i t it j x a b d g u= d då 0 1 2 1 2 : ....... 0 ; : 1 ....... 0 h h b b b b b b = = = =ìï í = = =ïî ! ^ ^ ( ) i i i tb b s b = ^ ib ib ^ ( )is b 1 n i i t t n b == å 0 1 : 0 ; : 0 i i h h b b =ìï í ïî ! european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5083 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 6 of the mean and variance to convert ( ) in a standard z-bar ( )statistics so that conventional critical values can be used to assess its significance. the test statistic ( ) is defined as follows: (4) where is as previously defined , and are the mean and variance of obtained from monte carlo simulations with i = 1,2,…, n. the llc and ips unit root tests are used in this study to test the stationarity of the data used for the 30 african countries. 3.4 cointegration tests in panel data after checking that the series are integrated in the same order, we move on to the next step by testing the possibility of longterm convergence between our data series. engle and granger (1987) indicated that variable series can be stationary and are therefore interpreted as co-integrated (having a long-run relationship) if there is a linear combination of two or more nonstationary variable series. the unique order of integration of the variables allows us to use the panel cointegration technique to test the long-run relationships between the variables in each model. the existing literature suggests several panel cointegration tests, such as pedroni (1999, 2004), kao (1999) and westerlund (2007). for this study, we used the cointegration technique of pedroni (1999). this test is based on a method similar to that of engle and granger (1987) on time series with the following data generation process: yit = ai + x’itbi + eit; n=1… 14; t= 1 …25 (5) where yit is the dependent variable; ai is a fixed effect taking into account the unobserved heterogeneity between the dependent variables; and x’it is a vector of explanatory variables. to test the cointegrating relations, pedroni constructed seven different statistics based on the cointegrating residual of eit , which are divided into two categories. the first includes statistics called "intra-dimensional" or "within". 3.5 model with individual effects we will now focus on heterogeneous panel models, where the only source of heterogeneity comes from individual constants. it is thus assumed that the coefficients of the different stochastic explanatory variables are identical for all individuals in the panel (ß1 = ß). it is further assumed that these coefficients are deterministic constants. the individual constants α1 ; the latter differ from one individual to another. yit = αi + ßk xkit + εit t z z ( [ | 0]) (0,1) var[ | 0] i i n t e t z n t b b = = ® = t [ | 0]ie t b = var[ | 0]it b = k å european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5083 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 7 innovations εit are supposed to be i: i: d: of zero mean, variance equal to ϭε2 ; ∀i ∈ [1; n] and are assumed to be uncorrelated either in the individual dimension or in the time dimension. therefore, in this context, two cases must be distinguished: the case in which the parameters αi are deterministic constants (fixed-effects model) and the case where the parameters αi are realizations of a random variable of expectation and finite variance (random effects model). we will thus successively consider these two types of model. 3.5.1 fixed-effect model it is now hypothesized that the individual effects 𝛼𝑖 are represented by constants (hence the name fixed-effect model). we will determine the general shape of the estimators of the parameters 𝛼𝑖 et 𝛽 in this fixed-effect model. assumptions: the individual fixed effects model has a residue structure that tests standard ols assumptions. it is in fact a classical model with individual indicator variables. we're going to make an additional assumption about the nature of the residue process. this hypothesis is simply the generalization in the panel dimension of the definition of a white noise ∀𝑖 ∈ 1; 𝑁 𝑒𝑡 𝑡 ∈ 1; 𝑇 : • 𝐸 𝜀𝑖𝑡 = 0 • 𝐸 (𝜀𝑖𝑡 𝜀𝑖𝑠) = ϭε2𝑡 = 𝑠 0 ∀𝑡 ≠ 𝑠 • 𝐸 (𝜀𝑖𝑡 𝜀𝑗𝑠) = 0 ∀𝑗 ≠ 𝑖, ∀ (𝑡, 𝑠) estimateur within ou lsdv (least square dummy variables) : the ordinary least squares (ols) estimator of the parameters 𝛼𝑖 et 𝛽 in the fixed-effects model is called the within estimator; or the fixed-effects estimator or the least square dummy variable (lsdv) estimator. as we have seen, the term within is explained by the fact that this estimator takes into account the within-group variance of the endogenous variable. the third name lsdv is only because this estimator leads to the introduction of dummy variables. the ols estimators of this model are the best linear, unbiased and convergent (blue) estimators. in practice, the ols or lsdv estimator is obtained from a transformed model where the different model variables are centred with respect to their respective individual means. the following specification is then retained : �҄� 𝑖𝑡 = 𝛽𝑘 �҄� 𝑘𝑖𝑡 + �҄� 𝑖𝑡 with �҄� 𝑖𝑡 = 𝑦𝑖𝑡 − ῡ𝑖𝑡 �҄� 𝑖𝑡 = 𝑥𝑖𝑡 − 𝑖𝑡 and ῡ𝑖𝑡 = �҄� 𝑖𝑡 = 𝜀𝑖𝑡 − 𝜀 𝑖𝑡 the realizations of the estimators of the constants 𝛼𝑖 are deduced at the mean point, after estimation of the parameters 𝛽𝑘 by mco on the previous transformed model. �҄� 𝑖 = ῡ𝑖 − �҄� 𝑘 𝑘𝑖 k å x 1 1 ti t yit t = å 1 p k= å x european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5083 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 8 3.5.2 random effects model in the standard practice of econometric analysis, it is assumed that there are a large number of factors that can affect the value of the variable being explained and yet are not explicitly introduced as explanatory variables. these factors are then approximated by the structure of the residuals. the problem arises in a similar way in panel econometrics. the only difference is that three types of omitted factors can be considered. first, there are factors that affect the endogenous variable differently depending on the period and the individual under consideration. in addition, there may be factors that affect all individuals identically, but whose influence depends on the period under consideration (temporal effects). finally, other factors may, on the contrary, reflect differences between individuals of a structural type, i.e. independent of time (individual effects). therefore the residual, noted 𝜀𝑖𝑡 ; of a panel model can be decomposed into three main components as follows (hsiao 1986): ∀𝑖 ∈ 1; 𝑁 𝑒𝑡 𝑡 ∈ 1; 𝑇 ; 𝜀𝑖𝑡 = 𝛼𝑖 + 𝜆𝑡 + 𝜗𝑖 the variables 𝛼𝑖 s here refer to the individual effects that represent the set of structural or a-temporal specificities of the endogenous variable, which differ from one individual to another. it is assumed here that these effects are random. random variables 𝜆𝑡 represent strictly identical temporal effects for all individuals. finally, the stochastic process 𝜗𝑖𝑡 designates the component of the total residue 𝜀𝑖𝑡 orthogonal to individual and temporal effects. in general, a number of technical assumptions are made about this tailings structure. assumptions: it's assumed that the residue 𝜀𝑖𝑡 = 𝛼𝑖 + 𝜆𝑡 + 𝜗𝑖𝑡 are i.i.d. and satisfy the following conditions, ∀𝑖 ∈ [1; 𝑁] 𝑒𝑡 𝑡 ∈ [1; 𝑇] : 𝐸 (𝛼𝑖) = 𝐸 (𝜆𝑡) = 𝐸 (𝜗𝑖𝑡) = 0 𝐸 (𝛼𝑖𝜆𝑡) = 𝐸 (𝜆𝑡𝜗𝑖𝑡) = 𝐸 (𝜗𝑖𝑡𝛼𝑖) = 0 𝐸 (𝛼𝑖𝛼𝑗) = {𝜎𝛼 2 𝑖 = 𝑗 {0 ∀𝑖 ≠ 𝑗 𝐸 (𝜆𝑡𝜆𝑠) = {𝜎𝜆 2 𝑠 = 𝑡 {0 ∀𝑠 ≠ 𝑡 𝐸 (𝜗𝑖𝑡𝜗𝑗𝑠) = {𝜎𝜗 2 𝑠 = 𝑡 ; 𝑖 = 𝑗 {0 ∀𝑠 ≠ 𝑡 ; ∀𝑖 ≠ 𝑗 𝐸 (𝛼𝑖𝑥𝑖𝑡) = 𝐸 (𝜆𝑡𝑥𝑖𝑡) = 𝐸 (𝜗𝑖𝑡𝑥𝑖𝑡) = 0 under these assumptions, the variance of the endogenous variable 𝑦𝑖𝑡 conditional on the explanatory variables 𝑥𝑖𝑡 is then equal to 𝜎𝑦 2 = 𝜎𝛼 2 + 𝜎𝜆 2 + 𝜎𝜗 2. the variances 𝜎𝛼 2, 𝜎𝜆 2 and 𝜎𝜗 correspond to the different components of the total variance. for this reason, the random effects model is also called the error component model. in this course, due to simplification, the time effect is neglected. we will assume that it does not exist (static panel). 3.6 the ardl models “autoregressive model with scaled distributed delays” the "autoregressive distributed lag/ardl" or "autoregressive distributed lag/arre" models are dynamic models. the latter have the particularity of taking into account time dynamics (adjustment lag, expectations, etc.) in the explanation of a variable (time series), thus improving forecasts and the effectiveness of policies (decisions, actions, etc.), unlike the simple (non-dynamic) model whose instantaneous explanation (immediate effect or not spread over time) only restores part of the variation of the variable to be explained. within the family of dynamic models, there are three types of models. if we consider the dependent variable « yt » and the independent variable « xt », noteworthy: autoregressive (ar) models: these are dynamic models in which the explanatory variables include (xt), the lagged dependent variable (its past values). in general, they are as follows (implicit form) european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5083 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 9 yt = f (xt, yt-p) … (1a) the term "autoregressive" reflects the regression of a variable on itself, i.e. on its own lagged values. staggered lag or distributed lag (dl) models: these are dynamic models that have as explanatory variables: and its past or lagged values. in general, their form is: yt = f (xt, yt-q) … (1b) the term "staggered delays" shows that the short-term effects of xt on yt are different from the long-term ones. from one point in time to another, the response scales of yt at the change of xt differ. autoregressive staggered-delay (ardl) models: these models combine the features of the two previous ones; among the explanatory variables are the following (xt), the shifted dependent variable (yt-p) and the past values of the independent variable (xt-q ). they have the following general form: yt = f (xt, yt-p, xt-q) …(1c) or yt = φ + α yt-i + bj xt-j+ et...(1d) with et iid (0,ϭ ) : error term; « b0» reflects the short-term effect of xt on yt considering the following long-term or equilibrium relationship «yt = k + φxt + µ », it is possible to calculate the long-term effect of xt on yt (or « ») as follows: ø = as with any dynamic model, the following information criteria will be used (aic, sic and hq) to determine the optimal offset (p* or q*) ; an optimal shift is one where the estimated model offers the minimum value of one of the stated criteria. these criteria are: akaike's (aic), schwarz's (sic) and hannan and quinn's (hq). their values are calculated as follows: aic (p) = log ǁ∑ǁ+ sic (p) = log ǁ∑ǁ + hq (p) = log ǁ∑ǁ + 1 p i= å 1 p i= å ! )/ (1bj i-å å α 2 2n p t log 2t n p t 2log 2t n p t european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5083 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 10 with : ̂∑ = variance-covariance matrix of estimated residuals; t = number of observations ; p = lag of the estimated model; and n = number of regressors. all of these dynamic models can help capture the short-term dynamics and long-term effects of one or more explanatory variables on a variable to be explained. this will only be possible if the time series under study are cointegrated, thus allowing the estimation of an error-correction/erm model. in fact, two series are said to be "cointegrated" if they are integrated of the same order; and, a series will be said to be "d-integrated" if it has to be differentiated "d" times to make it stationary. a stationary series is stationary in terms of mean and variance, if its mean (e(yt) = c) remains invariant or constant over time and that its variance does not increase with time (var (yt) = ϭ), as well as its covariances (e (yt-c)(yt-p -c) = yp ). to test the stationarity of a time series (absence of unit root), several tests are available in most software: augmented dickeyfuller/adf test, phillippe-perron/pp test, andrews and zivot/az test, ng-perron, kwiatkowski, phillips, schmidt and shin/kpss test, ouliaris-park-perron, eliott-rothenberg-stock, etc. the first three tests are easy to apply and are commonly used. it should be noted that the adf test is effective in the presence of error autocorrelation, the pp test is recommended in the presence of heteroskedastic errors, the az test is suitable for series that are victims of endogenously identified regime change (trend break), and the kpss test decomposes a series into three components (deterministic part, random part, white noise) with the null hypothesis of stationarity. it should be noted that, as part of the family of dynamic models, an ardl model makes it possible to estimate short-term dynamics and long-term effects for series that are co-integrated or even integrated at different orders, as will be seen with the boundary test approach of pesaran et al. (1996), pesaran and shin (1995), and pesaran et al. (2001). however, an ardl model cannot be applied to integrated series at orders greater than 1. 4. results and discussion 4.1 results and discussion to study the stationarity of the series used, we used unit root tests on panel data (levin lin and chu, im persaran and shin, hadri, ...). the next table 2 summarizes the results of the (summary) tests, applied to the different variables of the model. the unit root tests show that all the statistical series at the level are assigned a unit root. moving on to first differences, we can see that all the series are stationary. we conclude that they are integrated of order i (1) and i(0). table 2. unit root test results variables / methods integration order levin et al. im et al. adf-fisher chi square pp-fisher chi-square gdp i(1) -8.13344 (0.0000) -8.91040 (0.0000) 125.563 (0.0000) 130.484 (0.0000) stationarty hadri z-stat heteroscedastic consistent z-stat 5.47912 (0.0000) 3.10673 (0.0000) fdi i(1) -2.94203 (0.0016) -4.46400 (0.0000) 59.9463 (0.0000) 54.5151 (0.0001) stationarty hadri z-stat heteroscedastic consistent z-stat 3.58597 (0.0000) 3.35800 (0.0000) levin et al. im et al. adf-fisher chi square pp-fisher chisquare european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5083 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 11 en niveau différence première en niveau différence première en niveau différence première en niveau différence première log ce i(0) -0.9882 (0.1615) -16.9238 (0.0000) 1.18831 (0.8826) -16.4708 (0.0000) 20.3619 (0.5604) 202.044 (0.0000) 20.5153 (0.5508) 220.380 (0.0000) stationarty hadri z-stat heteroscedastic consistent z-stat 10.8187 (0.0000) 9.10802 (0.0000) cer i(0) 1.06230 (0.8560) -11.4987 (0.0000) 0.70665 (0.7601) -12.9988 (0.0000) 21.2863 (0.5031) 181.082 (0.0000) 26.5511 (0.2288) 175.253 (0.0000) stationarty 5.99423 (0.0000) 5.99423 (0.0000) log pop i(0) 1.64641 (0.9502) -3.12926 (0.0009) 3.92872 1.0000 -7.65503 (0.0000) 15.4128 (0.8439) 101.834 (0.0000) 46.2751 (0.0018) 82.1472 (0.0000) stationarty 12.8872 (0.0000) 13.1507 (0.0000) notes: probability values are given in brackets. significance thresholds * (1%), ** (5%), and *** (10%) source: author elaboration on eviews9 4.2 co-integration after checking the non-stationarity properties for all the variables in the panel, we study the existence of a shortand longterm relationship between these variables. that is to say, the study of the existence of a co-integration relationship, by applying the co-integration tests of pedroni, kao and johansen which are based on unit root tests on estimated residuals. table 3 summarizes the results of the seven (7) pedroni co-integration statistics. they were established by eviews 9.0 which has an appropriate program to handle co-integration on heterogeneous panel data. the co-integration of the variables depends on the probability value associated with each statistic. from the results of pedroni's co-integration tests we can see that out of the seven statistics, four have probability values less than 5%. these are mainly (panel ppstatistic) and (panel adf-statistic) for the intra-individual tests "pedroni (1999), (weighted statistic)", and (group pp-statistic) and (group adf-statistic) for the inter-individual tests "pedroni (1999)". therefore, all of these tests show the existence of a co-integration relationship. in what follows, we will estimate the long-term relationship of cointegration using the most adequate methods for this type of approach. table 3. co-integration model results no deterministic trend intra dimensions (four statistics) inter dimension (3 statistics) pedroni panel vstatistic panel rhostatistic panel ppstatistic panel adfstatistic group rhostatistic group ppstatistic group adfstatistic staistic -0.772857 -3.372856 -10.82630 -8.643915 -1.912110 -17.11109 -8.810620 prob (0.7802) (0.0004) (0.0000) (0.0000) (0.0279)** (0.0000) (0.0000) kao adf resid(-1) stastic -5.269950 -11.68755 prob (0.0000) (0.0000) johansen fisher (from trace test) fisher (from max-eigen test) statistic prob statistic prob none 470.5 (0.0000) 344.0 (0.0000) at most 1 413.9 (0.0000) 272.4 (0.0000) at most 2 233.4 (0.0000) 155.1 (0.0000) european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5083 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 12 at most 3 115.8 (0.0000) 93.08 (0.0000) at most 4 64.62 (0.0000) 64.62 (0.0000) notes: probability values are given in brackets. significance thresholds * (1%), ** (5%), and *** (10%) source: author elaboration on eviews9 4.3 casuality of granger panel the existence of co-integration implies the existence of causality in at least one direction. having found that there is a longterm relationship between gdp, fdi, rce, cet and pop.the next step is to test the causal links between these variables using the granger panel test causality. a granger causality analysis is performed to determine whether there is potential predictive power across indicators. the results of the granger panel causality test for all individuals are summarized in the following table 4. table 4. the panel vecm granger casuality results dependent variables source of short-term causality (independent variables) long term ∆gdp ∆fdi ∆cer ∆ce ∆pop ect ∆gdp 0.051942 (0.051942)** 0.001617 (0.00371) -0.005544 (0.00110) 5.06 (6.1) 0.051942 (0.04927) ∆fdi 0.045439 (0.08979)*** 0.004624 (0.00480) 0.001820 (0.00142) 6.47 (7.8) -0.005544 -0.005544 ∆cer -0.212568 (1.30807) -0.683442 -0.683442 0.003703 (0.02068)* 0.000922 (0.00114) 0.001617 (0.00371) ∆ce 4.649756 (4.17685) 1.783248 (2.96392) -0.024501 -0.024501 0.002028 (0.00364) -0.276848 (0.12601)*** ∆pop -7.83706 (37.0688) -27.43068 (26.3043) 2.058512 (1.98284) -2.163168 (0.58612) 0.042438 (0.23936) notes: probability values are given in brackets. significance thresholds * (1%), ** (5%), and *** (10%) source: author elaboration on eviews9 the aim of our study is to demonstrate the interactive relationships between the set of variables gdp, fdi, cer, cet and pop, but this does not preclude the study of all possible relationships. from the results of the granger panel causality tests presented in the table above, we can deduce the meanings of the causal relations that can be found between the variables at the critical threshold (probability of error) of 1%, 5% and 10%. the results indicate the existence of two unidirectional causalities: fdi to gdp and cer to gdp. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5083 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 13 4.4 models with individual effects if the main objective is the estimation of the coefficients of the variables other than the constant and if they differ little. table 5. results of individual effect models variables effet fixe effet aléatoire test hausman fdi 0.865040 0.352954 0.002507 (0.865040)*** (0.7244)*** (0.00250) cer -1.884330 -0.016893 3.740207 (0.0606)*** (0.9865)*** (0.0548)** lce -0.304002 0.852544 1.035037 (0.7614)*** (0.3946)*** (0.6463)*** lpop -3.716112 -3.214474 1.650091 (0.0002) (0.0015) (0.0024) notes: probability values are given in brackets. significance thresholds * (1%), ** (5%), and *** (10%) source: author elaboration on eviews9 4.5 models ardl this approach was introduced by pesaran and shin (1999) and further developed by pesaran et al (2001). this approach has many advantages over johansen's cointegration technique. the variables are integrated of different orders. another advantage is that the error correction model (ecm) can be derived from the ardl which integrates the ct dynamics with the lt equilibrium without losing the lt information. table 6. results from models ardl dependent variable(gdp) coefficient z-statistics probability log run results fdi 0.154327 (0.076262) *** 2.023651 (0.0454)* lce 6.62561 (1.431944) 4.627010 (0.0000) lcer 0.357443 (0.638771) *** 0.559580 (0.5769)** lpop -3.728982 (0.771053) *** -4.836217 (0.0000)* short run results ect 0.288799 (0.288799) *** 2.241166 (0.0270)* δidet-1 0.152298 (0.272353)*** 0.559194 (0.5771)*** european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5083 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 14 δidet-2 0.365498 (0.340335) *** 1.073937 (0.2851)*** δcet-1 0.024823 (9.603603) 0.002585 (0.9979)*** δcet-2 11.35308 (7.457255) 1.522420 (0.1307)*** δcert-1 3.321993 (2.702170) 1.229380 (0.2215)*** δcert-2 3.555253 (2.299951) 1.545795 (0.1250) δpopt-1 -3002.347 (3211.346) -0.934919 (0.3518) δpopt-2 2711.985 (2711.985) 1.763306 (0.0806)*** notes: probability values are given in brackets. significance thresholds * (1%), ** (5%), and *** (10%) source: author elaboration on eviews9 the long and short terms of the ardl methodology are presented in table 6. the ardl results for the relationship between economic growth and foreign direct investment are positive and important in both the long and short term given the same importance of the relationship between energy consumption and economic growth, which indicates foreign direct investment and energy consumption as in mena countries increases economic growth in the long and short term. 6. conclusion bridging the gap between foreign direct investment and energy consumption is one solution to achieving development goals. the role of foreign direct investment and energy consumption in achieving these goals is becoming an important topic in some of the discussions in the current literature. international organizations, economists and policy makers have considered them as a means to achieve the future development of society as a whole. despite this growing interest and importance, the relationship between foreign direct investment, energy consumption and economic growth is not yet clear. therefore, the main objective of this study is to clarify this relationship by showing the ability of foreign direct investment and energy consumption to achieve economic growth at a given point in time, reduce environmental degradation and improve social conditions in 11 transition countries over the period 1990 to 2015. the granger results revealed that fdi and energy consumption are closely linked to the pillars of economic growth. the result can be summarized as follows. first, the adoption of fdi has positive effects on economic growth, as well as on the use of renewable energy. in addition, the study indicates that foreign direct investment and energy use cannot stimulate growth simultaneously in economic terms and advance the environmental and social dimension without certainty of requirements, especially in countries in transition. references alfarra, h. j., & abu-hijleh, b. (2012). the potential role of nuclear energy in mitigating co2 emissions in the united arab emirates. energy policy, 42, 272-285. apergis, n., & payne, j. e. (2010). renewable energy consumption and economic growth: evidence from a panel of oecd countries. energy policy, 38(1), 656-660. feng, b. f. (2014). general n-soliton solution to a vector nonlinear schrödinger equation. journal of physics a: mathematical and theoretical, 47(35), 355203. im, k. s., pesaran, m. h., & shin, y. (1995). testing for unit roots in dynamic heterogeneous panels. department of applied economics working paper, 9526. jeste, d. v., palmer, b. w., appelbaum, p. s., golshan, s., glorioso, d., dunn, l. b., ... & kraemer, h. c. (2007). a new brief instrument for assessing decisional capacity for clinical research. archives of general psychiatry, 64(8), 966-974. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5083 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 15 lima, l. i. l., silva, g. m., chilque, a. r. a., schvartzman, m. m. d. a. m., bracarense, a. q., & quinan, m. a. d. (2010). caracterização microestrutural de soldas dissimilares dos aços astm a-508 e aisi 316l. soldagem & inspeção, 15(2), 112120. pachauri, r. k., allen, m. r., barros, v. r., broome, j., cramer, w., christ, r., ... & dubash, n. k. (2014). climate change 2014: synthesis report. contribution of working groups i, ii and iii to the fifth assessment report of the intergovernmental panel on climate change (p. 151). ipcc. pedroni, p. (1999). critical values for cointegration tests in heterogeneous panels with multiple regressors. oxford bulletin of economics and statistics, 61(s1), 653-670. persyn, d., & westerlund, j. (2008). error-correction–based cointegration tests for panel data. the stata journal, 8(2), 232-241. pesaran, m. h. (2001). shin. smith, rj. van bavel, j. j., baicker, k., boggio, p. s., capraro, v., cichocka, a., cikara, m., ... & drury, j. (2020). using social and behavioural science to support covid-19 pandemic response. nature human behaviour, 1-12 http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/6063 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 16 the nexus between demographic dividend and covid-19 in bangladesh: a disappearing opportunity md. tanvir alam, sabrina afrin tonny2 1 department of public administration, stamford university bangladesh, dhaka, bangladesh 2 research assistant, liberation war museum, dhaka, bangladesh e-mail: babu.taanvir@gmail.com, sabrinatonny09@gmail.com received: 25/09/2021 accepted for publication: 26/01/2022 published: 15/04/2022 abstract in common parlance demographic dividend means the economic growth caused by changes in the age structure of population of a country. bangladesh entered the phase of demographic dividend in early 2007, considering the average timeline of this important phase which is 20-30 years; bangladesh is currently passing the midway point of it. amid this situation, sudden initiatives such as lockdown, closure of educational institutions, changes in the recruitment process, delayed employee selection process and declining trend of job posting caused by covid-19 has created serious tension among the potential employee sector. the objective of this study is to find out the adverse impact of covid-19 on demographic dividend, especially on the potential employee sector consists of tertiary level final year students, fresh graduates and job seekers. in doing so primary source of data is used; the data was collected using qualitative method followed by a semi-structured questionnaire. this is a cross-sectional study, for the data collection, non-probability convenience along with self-selection sampling technique is used due limited mobility induced by covid-19 lockdown. after collecting, the data are analyzed using ibm spss software. the findings of this study revealed the adverse impact of covid-19 on demographic dividend is taking place through potential employee sector. keywords: demographic dividend; covid-19; employment; job market; potential employee sector. 1. introduction since the covid-19 induced closure of educational institutions, the tendency of suicide have multifolded in bangladesh, a study identified lockdown, shutting down economic activities and social distancing as reason behind prevalent mental problem (islam et al., 2020). a renowned daily news paper reported that “covid triggered a rise in suicide ideation, with 10 students allegedly ending their own lives” (“depression, anxiety behind rise in suicide of du students,” 2021), these students are from the dhaka university which is the most reputed university of the country and the news is from just one daily, let alone student from countryside normal educational institutions and numerous local news paper. the authors argue that this is not just an isolated incident of mental case, rather a serious loss of potential human capital which threatens the demographic dividend. this is a serious problem due to the large number of student enrolled in tertiary level education as estimated by university grant commission (mannan, 2017) and since bangladesh's unemployment rate climbed to 5.30 percent in 2020, up from 4.20 percent in 2019 (unemployment, total (% of total labor force) (modeled ilo estimate) bangladesh | data, 2019), pertaining to their age group, which falls under the demographic dividend age division, this issue http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/6063 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 17 posses a formidable threat for the nations entire demographic dividend. the objective of this study is to find out the adverse impact of covid-19 on demographic dividend, by classifying the entire potential employee sector into three sections; tertiary level final year students, fresh graduates and job seekers. the study initially introduces the importance of the issue by stating the problem followed by the research objective, and then it moved to literature review section, thirdly the methodology section is described to ensure validity and reliability of the study. after that in the analysis section graphical illustrations is used for reader’s convenience, finally the findings are revealed prior to move to discussion part followed by the conclusions. 2. literature review 2.1 demographic dividend and covid-19 in bangladesh demographic dividend is a life time window of opportunity for any country, especially for country like bangladesh which is graduating from the category of least developed country (ldc ), while coronavirus disease-19 or more popularly known as covid-19 is a severe acute respiratory syndrome which succeeded at stopping the whole world from every dimensions range from social, economic to cultural and even political, and bangladesh is not exception to that. the siginfiaicne of demograpic divididend is unprecednted, as suggested by urmanavicius, the demogrpahic dividend can even cause changes in the structure of the society as the demographic factors are associated with skill composition (2021) bangladeshis is currently going through both demographic dividend and covid-19. the demographic dividend is the difference between the number of working-age people between the ages of 15 and 64 and the number of non-working-age people between the ages of 14 and 65. it is a demographic dividend if the number of working individuals is larger than the number of non-working individuals. a country's demographic dividend era lasts no more than 20-30 years, in other words, by 2040, bangladesh's ability to generate rapid economic development by using the demographic dividend would begin to diminish (chowdhury, 2020). demographic dividend comes with many advantages, but the proper utilization is only possible when the active functional youth engagement is ensured. coronavirus disease 2019 (covid-19) is a contagious illness caused by the coronavirus 2 that causes severe acute respiratory illness. in december of this year, the first known case was discovered in wuhan, china (page et al., 2021). since then, the disease has spread worldwide, resulting in a pandemic. through spillover infection, the virus is considered to be natural and of animal origin. there are numerous ideas as to where the initial case (also known as patient zero) came from. the impact of covid-19 caused serious distress around the world, and bangladesh is no exception, on the contrary comparing other countries bangladesh is facing greater risk because of covid-91 as bangladesh is yet to be a developing country and currently passing through the period of demographic dividend 2.2 covid-19 and student the impact of covid-19 has serious ramification all over the country, especially for student. students as are passing through their tenure of learning, amid this situation their overall curriculum system turned upside down overnight, which subsequently affected their pathway for graduation. a study by rahman et al (2021) on covid19 responses among university students of bangladesh shows that the majority of the students that took part in the study had a significant impact (61.48 percent). due to the epidemic, they were also extremely concerned about their mental health (47.84 percent). online classes have become the only alternative option. students in dhaka, the capital city, reported more dangerous present locations than students outside of dhaka. while online class has been a viable option for only private university, public university and the students of public university is suffering from long term discontinuity from their academic study, begum et al (2020) in their study by covering a massive sample around eleven hundreds student find out some major barriers to students, which ranged from self bearing online learning cost to part time job through nearby covid-19 patient, income reduction, financial problem associated with lost job, overpriced internet access etcetera, these problems manifested into physiological challenges and threatens the continuity of the study of students, the article concludes by recommending to provide financial subsidy to disadvantages students, another study supports the previous claim by focusing on socio-psychological impact of covid-19 on student, the study identified numerous psychological concerns among university students and suggested to build awareness for the mental health of students (far abid hossain http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/6063 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 18 et al., 2021). a prominent study by (faisal et al., 2021) reveled that anxiety, depressive symptoms, and mental health status are common sympton among university students in bangladesh during t his lockdown period. in total, 40% of the subjects experienced moderate to severe anxiety, 72% experienced depressive symptoms, and 53% had a moderate to poor mental health condition. there is no denying that such harsh condition can be overburden for any students to complete their academic journey and be prepared to enter the job market, many student have faced delayed graduation due to covid-19 ((maimuna, 2020)) and facing an uncertain future. 2.3 covid-19 and fresh graduate besides running students, who are yet to complete their education, fresh graduate also suffers from covid-19 induced challenges. these fresh graduates were about to enter the job market and start their cornerstone for their career, unfortunately as lockdown and associated closing initiatives were introduced by respective authority they couldn’t enter the desired job market. earlier studies from khan (2020) shows that many organizations delimit their working personnel restrict their operations, shut down their projects to survive in the market, resulting less opening for fresh graduate to enter the job market thus proving the adverse impact of covid-19 on fresh graduate. another study by shahriar et al (2021, p 1) supports the previous argument by stating that “the rate of graduate unemployment increased from 47% to 58% in 2020 with an expected annual loss estimated at $53 million”. the opening entrance in job market is hampered by covid-19 induced challenges does not remains in the boundary of private sector, even oublic secotr is greatly under influence, for example the 43rd bangladesh civil service examination’s viva has been postponed for indefinite period (“42nd bcs viva postponed indefinitely,” 2021) . the actual scenario remains as volatile and fragile as ever in bangladesh, while more students are entering job market without any experience even without the experience of an internship, as reported in news paper column , “with the covid-19 pandemic and predicted economic recession, youths are warned that their career path and work-life settlement will not come easy” (maimuna, 2021). 2.4 covid-19 and job seekers in addition to the tertiary level student and fresh graduate, an third group emerged as job seekers with the advent of covid-19 period, who once was employed. it all began when to tackle to infection government of bangladesh took preventive measures including lockdown, as a result most of the business and organization were shut down, and the employed person used their savings to live in one of the most expensive city of the world (“dhaka one of the most expensive cities in the world,” 2020). as the situation remained unchanged for longer period of time, eventually many employed person went unemployed and lost their job, according to a world bank report, around 68 percent of those who were forced to cease working due to the epidemic in dhaka and chattogram have lost their jobs (byron, 2020). another study by world bank portrayed “provides early insights into the labor market impacts of the ongoing coronavirus 2019 crisis in bangladesh. the findings point to substantial uncertainty about job prospects for many people” (genoni, et al, 2020). besides these one of the most revenue earning sector of bangladesh which is ready-made garments sector (rmg) also suffered from covid19 challenges, resulting less productivity, emotional health, fewer job posting and even loss of employment (kabir et al., 2020). another study by hossain (2021) initially revealed that many people have experienced declining income and lost job due to covid-19, followed by the limitation of unfavorable economic policy, and finally suggested to adopt employment-oriented economic policies. besides individual research, institutional study from organizations likes asian development bank by hayashi & matsuda (2020) provided key insight of covid-19 impact on job portal, stating that since the covid-19 outbreak, job listings on the main online job matching sites in bangladesh and sri lanka have decreased significantly. all industries saw a large drop in new job ads including bangladesh’s textile sector, portrayed by another study, the link between employment and demogrphaic factors is high (urmanaviciene & arachchi, 2020) the above discussion shows that both covid-19 and government response to tackle the infection rate created an unfavorable situation for potential employee sector which comprised of tertiary level students, fresh graduate and job seeker; which in ultimately threatens the demographic dividend of bangladesh, despite of the significance of the issue no study has been done to explore the adverse impact of covid-19 on demographic dividend. http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/6063 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 19 3.0 methodology the study is about the demographic dividend of bangladesh which is experiencing adverse impact by covid19. as the study deals with sensitive issue the methodology of this study is carefully formatted. the objective of this study is to find out the adverse impact of covid-19 on demographic dividend, especially on the potential employee sector consists of three groups namely; tertiary level final year students, fresh graduates and job seekers. in doing so primary sources of data is used; the data will be collected using qualitative method followed by a semi-structured questionnaire, the questionnaire is delivered by mail-survey questionnaire and google form. this will be a cross-sectional study, so for the data collection, non-probability convenience along with selfselection sampling technique will be used due limited mobility induced by covid-19 lockdown. the population of potential employees sector is huge as the population of entire city is around 18.2 million (swapan et al., 2017), among them 4.81 percent people are unemployed (dataleads, 2017), which makes around 0.9 million people jobless, among them majority are students, fresh graduate and job seekers, and to maintain the consistency respondents from only social science background were suggested to participate, as subjects like pharmacy and c.s.e have different modalities for academic activates like lab class, field study etcetera. a total of 150 respondents have be taken as sample, where each groups will have 50 respondents. after collecting, the data is analyzed using ibm spss software and the results will be demonstrated using graphical illustration like figure, chart, bar etcetera. data type data collection method sampling style data source primary qualitative convenience & self-selection final year student (50), fresh graduate (50), job seeker (50) 4.0 analysis the analysis part can be organized under three broader categories, analysis of student, and analysis of fresh graduate and analysis of job seekers 4.1 analysis of data from final year university students the collected data from final year university students were analyzed using ibm spss software, and then illustrated in figures, bar, pie chart etc. the analysis is given below following. first the degree of depression of the respondent (final year students) is measured using zung depression scale, which is a popular public domain scale and free to use as self rating depression scale. n=50. http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/6063 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 20 figure 1: figure 1 shows that among the 50 respondents, 5 respondents shows normal symptoms hence scoring below 44 in zung depression scale, while 8 students shows symptoms of mild depression, the degree of depression reach on the highest scale by 20 students who experience moderate depressions, and 17 students scored 70+ thus being severely depressed. 38 among 50 students who are suffering types of depressions, says they are losing interest to study. secondly, the degree of knowledge of the respondent (final year students) is measured using staple scale, where n=50. the rationale of using staple scale is that as staple scale does not support neutral value it is appropriate to measure the degree of knowledge of the students because being a student there is no point of neutrality in terms of gaining knowledge. figure 2: figure 2 shows the degree of learning of the final year students using staple scale. the graph shows that among the respondents 13 students think that the degree of learning is worse, while 18 students think it is bad, on the contrary 12 students think that the degree of learning is moderate and 07 students thinks it is good. the total score 20-44 (normal) score 45-59 (mildly depressed) score 60-69 (moderately depressed) score 70+ (seveerly depressed) depression scale among stduents 5 8 20 17 0 5 10 15 20 25 degree of depression among students 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% degree of learning degree of learning worse 13 bad 18 moderate 12 good 7 degree of learning http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/6063 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 21 number of students who think the degree of learning is on negative is 33. among the 50 students, 38 students believe that the knowledge they are receiving through online classes is inadequate to enter the job market. finally for the issue of delayed graduation of students is addressed, the respondents (n=50) reflected their perception towards the reason for delayed graduation and associated impact of it. figure 3: figure 3 shows the reason behind delayed graduation of students induced by covid-19. the most prevalent reason identified by the majority of student (18) is the closure of educational institutions, followed by the second biggest reason financial problem of family induced by covid-19 which is identified by 15 students. the third biggest reason behind delayed graduation is identified by 13 students as the tuition fee problem, and only 4 students identified several other reasons including lack of study environment, absence of teachers company etcetera.. 42 out of 50 students think that they will not be able to complete their study if the situation remains unchanged, thus they will be fall below the margin of human capital without education. 4.2 analysis of data from fresh graduate first the degree of depression of the respondent (fresh graduate) is measured using zung depression scale, which is a popular public domain scale and free to use as self rating depression scale, where the n=50. figure 4: figure 4 shows that among the 50 respondents, 7 respondents shows normal symptoms hence scoring below 44 in zung depression scale, and 7 fresh graduate shows symptoms of mild depression, the degree of depression reach on the moderate scale by 16 students who experience moderate depressions, and 20 students 36% 30% 26% 8% reason behind delayed graduation closure of educational institutions financial problem of family tuition fee other score 20-44 (normal) score 45-59 (mildly depressed) score 60-69 (moderately depressed) score 70+ (seveerly depressed) depression scale among fresh graduate 7 7 16 20 0 5 10 15 20 25 degree of depression among fresh graduate http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/6063 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 22 scored 70+ thus being severely depressed. 32 among 50 fresh graduates who are suffering types of depressions, says they are losing hope for bright career. and for analysis of the major problems to enter the job market faced by fresh graduate which induced by covid19, is given below, where n=50 figure 5: figure 5 shows that, among the problems induced by covd-19 to enter the job market three problems are most prevalent. among the respondents, 22 fresh graduates hold the absence of internship experience as a major challenge to enter the job market, the second major problem identified by 13 fresh gradates is the changed hiring policy of organization induced by covid-19 which discourage to recruit fresh graduate, finally 9 students experienced the responsibility to look after covid-19 relative fallen onto their shoulder. while only 6 students mentioned about other problems like low job posting, delayed recruitment process etcetera. 4.3 analysis of data from job seekers as mentioned earlier, job seekers mean the individual respondents who have prior job experiences. .first the degree of depression of the respondent (job seekers) is measured using zung depression scale, which is a popular public domain scale and free to use as self rating depression scale, where the n=50. absence of internship experience 44% hiring policy changed by covid19 26% covid-19 patient in family to look after 18% other 12% covid-19 induced problems to enter job market score 20-44 (normal) score 45-59 (mildly depressed) score 60-69 (moderately depressed) score 70+ (seveerly depressed) depression scale among job seekers 2 9 17 23 0 5 10 15 20 25 degree of depression among job seekers http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/6063 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 23 figure 6: figure 6 shows that among the 50 respondents, only 2 respondents shows normal symptoms by scoring below 44 in zung depression scale, and 9 job seekers shows symptoms of mild depression (scoring 45-59), the degree of depression reach on the moderate scale by 17 job seekers who experience moderate depressions, and 23 respondents shows symptom of severely depressed by scoring above 70+. among the 50 respondents, 40 respondents who are suffering moderate and severe types of depressions, says they are being compelled to lose interest for job opportunity. and finally for analysis of the major challenges induced by covid-19 for job seekers to enter the job market is given below, where n=50 figure 7: figure 7 shows that, among the challenges induced by covd-19 to enter the job market three problems are most prevalent. among the respondents, 19 job seekers fears the age out for public job, 14 respondents finding it hard for them to switch job industry, and 10 respondents find the stalled recruitment as disruptive challenge for their career. only 7 respondents identified challenges like maintain hygiene, long distance and family restrictions. 4.4 analysis of data from student, fresh graduate and job seekers the reflection of students, fresh graduate and job seekers on the adverse impact of covid-19 on demographic divided is given below; 38% 28% 20% 14% covid-19 induced problems for job seekers age out for government job switch industry stalled recruitment other http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/6063 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 24 figure 8: the figure 8 shows the perception of entire respondents towards the impact of covid-19 on demographic dividend of bangladesh. among the 150 respondents none could identify any positive indication of covid-19 on demographic dividend, where 21 respondents find it neutral by claiming that the higher degree usage of technological devices equalizes the negative impact, on the contrary 66 respondents find the impact of covid-19 on demographic dividend has adverse impact and 63 respondents labeled the impact as highly adverse. 5.0 summary of main results drawing the key insight from each analysis sagements, it can be said that the covid-19 and associated initiatives are taking a toll on the potential employments sector of bangladesh. the findings of the study are given below; • serious depression is prevlenant among students, fresh graduate and job seekers , resulting them less active and emotionally unstable for active functionality. among the three classes, the severe degree of depression is more prevalent among fresh graduate comparatevely than students, and subsequently more prevalent among job seekers than fresh graduate. • most of the student is affected by delayed graduation caused by covid-19, and they are afraid that the learning modalities or quality during covid-19 period will not help them to complete in the job market • fresh graduates are suffering from experience gap as well as changed hiring policy of market and responsibility for family member diagnosed with covid-19; all problems are induced by covid-19. • majority of job seeker are already lost their job due to first wave of covid-19, and still struggling to get into the market before their age runs out, in addition to that switching job industry is pretty had during this time and stalled recruitment caused by covid-19 added another layer of challenges for them. 6.0 discussion the above results indicate a serious situation forthcoming for bangladesh. both covid-19 and unsophisticated absent mined government action is responsible for such situation. the results of this study imply the uncertain future for bangladesh’s potential employment sector due to covid-19, which subsequently will threaten the demographic dividend of this country. as bangladesh is on the midway of this life time opportunity named demographic dividend, and the government of bangladesh could not took appropriate measure to secure the 42% 44% 14% 0% 0% perception of covid-19 on demographic dividend highly adverse adverse neutral positive highly positive http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/6063 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 25 smooth work flow of working people, there is high possibly that this window of opportunity will disappear soon unless required initiatives are taken. 7.0 conclusions the study deals with a crucial subject which is responsible for bangladesh’s decade long success and achievement that is demographic dividend. the aim of this study was to reveal the adverse impact of covid-19 on bangladesh’s demographic dividend by identifying the key affected area of potential employee sector, this study shows how the covid-19 created waves of challenges for this sector thus threading the flow of demographic dividend. in spite of declaring stimulus packages to handle this issue and make a favorable environment for the potential employee sector, budget 2021-22 proposed 15% tax on private universities(report, 2021) which has created concern among all stakeholders and made the situation volatile and fragile than ever. 7.1 limitation of the study the study was done during the peak devastating hour of employment sector caused by covid-19, hence the sample may represent a protion of margion of error as the sample style was selfe selection, on top of that the study was conduced only on 150 samples, leaving the majority out of equation. finally the qualitative dala collection method may not revel the actual scenario of the respondents. regardless of the limitations, considerig the toll taken by covid-19, the study was successful and all set-out objectives achieved. furthermore, the following areas needs further attention; • dynamic between population management and demogrphic divided during covid-19 time • use of ict to mitigate the impact of covid -19 and utiliize demogrphic divided • siginificance of stress or depression management into public health concern references 42nd bcs viva postponed indefinitely. (2021, may 18). dhaka tribune. https://www.dhakatribune.com/bangladesh/2021/05/18/bcs-vivapostponed-indefinitely begum, f., alam, s. z. h. m. s., alam, u. n. i. h., & omar, l. n. (2020). combating the impact of covid-19 on public university students through subsidized online class: evidence from bangladesh. journal of education and practice. published. https://doi.org/10.7176/jep/11-27-17 byron, r. a. k. h. (2020, september 27). covid-19 fallout: 68% lost jobs in dhaka and ctg. the daily star. https://www.thedailystar.net/frontpage/news/68pc-lost-jobs-dhaka-and-ctg-1968641 chowdhury, p. s. (2020, august 16). demographic dividend: a roadmap to progress. the financial express. https://thefinancialexpress.com.bd/views/demographic-dividend-a-roadmap-to-progress-1600268169 dataleads, n. d. (2017, october 15). unemployment: dhaka 6th in asia; highest rate in kathmandu, lowest in phnom penh. the daily star. https://www.thedailystar.net/world/asia/unemployment-rate-highest-kathmandu-lowest-phnom-penh-2017-global-leastmost-stressful-cities-zipjet-1476664 depression, anxiety behind rise in suicide of du students. (2021, january 2). daily sun. https://www.dailysun.com/printversion/details/527153/depression-anxiety-behind-rise-in-suicide-of-du-students dhaka one of the most expensive cities in the world. (2020, june 16). dhaka tribune. https://www.dhakatribune.com/bangladesh/dhaka/2020/06/16/mercer-survey-dhaka-26th-most-expensive-city-forexpatriates#:%7e:text=dhaka%20ranks%2026th%20on%20the,annual%20survey%20published%20by%20mercer. faisal, r. a., jobe, m. c., ahmed, o., & sharker, t. (2021). mental health status, anxiety, and depression levels of bangladeshi university students during the covid-19 pandemic. international journal of mental health and addiction. published. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11469-020-00458-y far abid hossain, s., nurunnabi, m., sundarasen, s., chinna, k., kamaludin, k., baloch, g. m., khoshaim, h. b., & sukayt, a. (2021). socio-psychological impact on bangladeshi students during covid-19. journal of public health research, 9(s1). https://doi.org/10.4081/jphr.2020.1911 genoni, m. e., khan, a. i., krishnan, n., palaniswamy, n., & raza, w. (2020). losing livelihoods: the labor market impacts of covid-19 in bangladesh. hayashi, r., & matsuda, n. (2020). covid-19 impact on job postings: real-time assessment using bangladesh and sri lanka online job portals. https://www.dhakatribune.com/bangladesh/2021/05/18/bcs-viva-postponed-indefinitely https://www.dhakatribune.com/bangladesh/2021/05/18/bcs-viva-postponed-indefinitely http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/6063 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 26 hossain, m. i. (2021). covid-19 impacts on employment and livelihood of marginal people in bangladesh: lessons learned and way forward. south asian survey, 28(1), 57–71. https://doi.org/10.1177/0971523121995072 islam, m. a., barna, s. d., raihan, h., khan, m. n. a., & hossain, m. t. (2020). depression and anxiety among university students during the covid-19 pandemic in bangladesh: a web-based cross-sectional survey. plos one, 15(8), e0238162. kabir, h., maple, m., & usher, k. (2020). the impact of covid-19 on bangladeshi readymade garment (rmg) workers. journal of public health, 43(1), 47–52. https://doi.org/10.1093/pubmed/fdaa126 khan, m. m. r. (2020). covid-19's impact on fresh graduate's job market in bangladesh: an observational study. journal of business and management studies, 2(1), 40-48. retrieved from https://alkindipublisher.comfindex.php/jbms/a rticle/view/432 maimuna, f. (2020, december 24). job market: struggle for freshers. the financial express. https://thefinancialexpress.com.bd/education/job-market-struggle-for-freshers-1608801159 maimuna, f. (2021, march 4). student internship: brighter path to career ahead. the financial express. https://www.thefinancialexpress.com.bd/education/student-internship-brighter-path-to-career-ahead-1614797318 mannan, a. (2017, february 24). achieving our higher education targets. the daily star. https://www.thedailystar.net/educationemployment/achieving-our-higher-education-targets-1366513 page, j., hinshaw, d., & mckay, b. (2021, february 26). in hunt for covid-19 origin, patient zero points to second wuhan market. wsj. https://www.wsj.com/articles/in-hunt-for-covid-19-origin-patient-zero-points-to-second-wuhan-market-11614335404 rahman, m. m., khan, s. j., sakib, m. s., halim, m. a., rahman, m. m., asikunnaby, & jhinuk, j. m. (2021). covid-19 responses among university students of bangladesh: assessment of status and individual view toward covid-19. journal of human behavior in the social environment, 31(1–4), 512–531. https://doi.org/10.1080/10911359.2020.1822978 report, s. d. (2021, june 4). proposed 15% income tax on private universities unacceptable: owners association. the daily star. https://www.thedailystar.net/budget-2021-22/news/proposed-15-income-tax-private-universities-unacceptable-ownersassociation-2104853 shahriar, m. s., islam, k., zayed, n. m., hasan, k., & raisa, t. s. (2021). the impact of covid-19 on bangladesh's economy: a focus on graduate employability. the journal of asian finance, economics and business, 8(3), 1395-1403. swapan, m., zaman, a., ahsan, t., & ahmed, f. (2017). transforming urban dichotomies and challenges of south asian megacities: rethinking sustainable growth of dhaka, bangladesh. urban science, 1(4), 31. https://doi.org/10.3390/urbansci1040031 unemployment, total (% of total labor force) (modeled ilo estimate) bangladesh | data. (2019, january 29). https://data.worldbank.org/. https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/sl.uem.totl.zs?locations=bd urmanavicius, j. (2021). perspectives of older employees in changing market. european journal of social impact and circular economy, 2(3), 48-58. urmanaviciene, a., & arachchi, u. s. (2020). the effective methods and practices for accelerating social entrepreneurship through corporate social responsibility. european journal of social impact and circular economy, 1(2), 27-47. https://thefinancialexpress.com.bd/education/job-market-struggle-for-freshers-1608801159 https://www.thefinancialexpress.com.bd/education/student-internship-brighter-path-to-career-ahead-1614797318 microsoft word 5 musa, abdullahi sakanko.docx http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/4943 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 95 women participation in nigerian economy: does governance matter? musa, abdullahi sakanko*, dakwal, solomon mangut** *department of economics university of jos, nigeria ** department of economics university of jos, nigeria e-mail: sakanko201@gmail.com received: 04/08/2020 revised: 01/10/2020 accepted for publication: 02/10/2020 published: 26/10/2020 abstract this study examines the effect of governance measures (control of corruption, accountability, and effectiveness of government) on women's participation in nigerian economy using annual time-series data for 29 years spanning from 1990 2019. the autoregressive and distributive lag (ardl) bounds test discloses the existence of a long-run co-integration relationship between accountability, control of corruption, effectiveness of government and women participation in the labor force. the empirical results obtained revealed that both in the short-run and in the long-run, accountability and the percentage of female employment have a positive and statistically significant effect on women's participation in nigeria. although, the effectiveness of governance shows negative and statistically insignificant effect both in the short-run and in the long-run while the control of corruption exerted a negative and statistically significant impact both in the short-run and long-run. therefore, the study recommends that the government at all levels should ensure that accountability prevails in every sector, to allow fair play in representation, employment, and diffusion of decisions to strengthen and energize women's participation. keywords: ardl model, accountability, control of corruption, effectiveness, women’s participation jel classification: c32, e02, j16 http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/4943 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 96 1. introduction in a global dimension, good governance can be assessed through the sustainable economic opportunity that is available/made possible for the entire citizenry. this can be guaranteed through prudent economic management, organized private sector, adequate infrastructural facilities, effective community and rural development. it has also been argued that good governance ensures that the rule of law where property rights are guaranteed, voice and accountability are ensured, violence is suppressed, corruption is checked, and governance is effective. this simply means that good governance gives every citizen, regardless of gender, equal treatment, equal opportunities, and equal rights. in developing countries, several women are denied the opportunity to excise their fundamental rights, such rights as, holding leadership positions, contributing in decision making, participating as head of the household, and many others. studies like (eagly, 1987; cheung & hanandez, 2001) have shown that women are more sympathetic than their male counterparts. they are less corrupt, very effective, accountable, and strict in following the rule of law. similarly, international comparisons have shown that countries with more women in parliament or government have lower levels of corruption (dollar, fisman & gatti, 2001; swamy, knack, lee & azfar, 2001; vijayalakshmi, 2008; paweenawat, 2018; hazarika, 2018). accordingly, weak or bad governance creates ineffective institutions, a high level of corruption, violation of the rule of law, engaging in extravagant policies that disregard for the property right, constitutions, and customs that will ensure order and certainty in the society (ogundiya, 2010). furthermore, since women are known to be too sympathetic and peace-loving, weak governance indulges in political instability, corruption, and abuse of the rule of law to scare them away from participating in politics resulting in gender marginalization. similarly, when the institutions that are supposed to support and encourage women participation are weak, better quality of life vanish and the right of the female is taken off. the power imbalance between women and men is manifested or exemplified in governance arrangement. increasing the number of female participation may likely promote gender responsiveness of government which is crucial in eradicating corruption. in most societies, women assume some key roles: that of a mother, a home-manager, and a political activist. of these various roles, the mother has been engendered by the women’s movement. some developing countries have quotas, directing a minimum level of female participation in government. for example, the new constitution of afghanistan and the interim constitution of iraq both require that twentyfive percent of the legislature be female (quota project, 2005). in nigeria, the awareness about the role of http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/4943 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 97 women in the development of a nation came up in the 1980s. fortunately, the international conference on women in beijing in 1995 intensified the effective participation of women in nigeria. however, despite the enhancing effort and the major roles women play, they are yet to be given recognition. women are a force to be reckoned with in any society because of their population their leadership abilities and their important roles. available statistics revealed that overall women’s political representation in the government of nigeria is less than 7 percent (agbalajobi, 2010). this could be due to some cultural stereotypes, poor governance, political parties, religious beliefs, low level of education, poor finance, the godfather syndrome, negative stigmatization, harmful traditional practices, and patriarchal societal structures. concerted efforts have been made by some key government and non-governmental organizations on how to increase the level of participation of women in politics or governance in general to complement the declaration made at the fourth world conference on women in beijing, which advocated 30% representative. the national gender policy recommendation of 35% for the more inclusive representation of women in both elective and appointive positions respectively is also a significant effort. certain proportions of women in elected positions increased slightly between 1999 and 2007, from an average of 2.3% to 7.8%. while in 2015, 20 women out of 359 were in its lower house representing 5.6% and 7 out of 109 were in its upper house representing 6.4% (women in parliaments, 2019). also, united nations development programme [undp], (2019), reported that women in the nigerian parliament dropped from 7.3% in 2010 to 6.6% in 2012 and 2014 and declined further to 5.8% in 2015 and 2018 respectively. similarly, according to nigeria women trust fund (nwtf), (2019) following the 2019 elections, women make up 7.3% of the nigerian senate, 3.1% of the house of representatives, no state governors is a woman, one deputy governor and out of 42 ministers 7 are female representing 20%. furthermore, the report also revealed that between 1999 2015, 6% of councilors were women, 24% of judges in the federal court were women, and an average of 7% of each type of high-level government officials and senior administrators were women (national bureau of statistics [nbs], 2018). undoubtedly, the rising inequalities in education have been of great concern to female, nongovernmental organizations, and individuals in nigeria. as reported by (undp, 2019), 45.2% of educational inequalities recorded between men and women in 2012 and 2013, reduced to 43.3% in 2014 and 2015, rose to 43.8% in 2016 and declined to 38.1% in 2017 and 2018 respectively. likewise, income http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/4943 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 98 inequalities fell from 34.5% in 2012 and 2013 to 28.5% in 2016 and 28.2% in 2017 and 2018 respectively (kumar, 2017; undp, 2019). the government has made several efforts to address the low level of women participation in nigerian economy and politics to improve governance. among such efforts, are the establishment of women’s political empowerment office, nigeria women trust funds, women lobby group, independent national electoral commission (inec) gender policy, the national multi-stakeholder dialogue, the initiation of several interventions to actualize affirmative action and the convening of the nigeria women strategy conference and national center for women development. despite these numerous policies, programmes, and interventions, women's participation in government in nigeria is still low, and this can be attributed to the weak or ineffectiveness of governance. the empirical study of cheung & hanandez (2001) uncovers that states with higher rates of women participation in government have lower levels of corruption. in another view, if women partake in a potentially corrupt transaction, it is more likely to fail. the reason is that women are naturally more honest, but they are more opportunistic when they have the odds to smash an implicitly corrupt contract and less engaged in retaliating nonperformance (frank, lambsdorff & boehm, 2011). it is on this note that this study seeks to examine the effect of governance on women participation in the nigerian government. the study was motivated by the fact that previous studies (jaumotte, 2000; damisa, samndi & yohanna, 2007; hora, 2014; ekundayo, 2017; and osimen, anegbode, basil & oyewole, 2018) placed emphasis on the determinants of women participation, gender inequality, and governance. the objective of this study is to examine the effect of governance on women participation in nigeria. to achieve this aim, the study answered two principal research questions how does the corruption control, accountability, and effectiveness of government influence women's participation? is there any relationship between control of corruption, accountability, and effectiveness of government and women’s participation in nigeria? the intention of this study is to explore the potential of women in nigeria through good governance. this study is paramount to the government, policymakers, and women because it provides policy suggestions on how good governance can influence women's participation in the country. it formulates policies that will promote good governance and enhance women participation in nigeria. lastly, this study serves as a useful material for future study by contributing to the scanty literature on the topic. http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/4943 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 99 2. review of relevant literature asian development bank [adb], (2005) defined governance as the institutionalization of a system through which citizens, institutions, organizations, and groups in a society articulate their interests, exercise their rights, and mediate their differences in pursuit of the collective good. the united nations development program [undp], (1997) established that governance is an exercise of economic, political, and administrative authority to manage a country’s affairs at all levels. governance refers to the quality of the institutions to make, implement and enforce sound policies in an efficient, effective, equitable and inclusive manner. in broad terms, governance is about the institutional environment in which citizens interact among themselves and with government agencies/officials. fundamentally, it is about power, relationships and accountability: who has the influence, who decides what, and how decision-makers are held accountable (adb, 2005). on the other hand, agishi (2014) formulated that women’s participation is the active roles performed by women. similarly, women participation is the activities of the feminine members of lawmaking organizations or people who try to influence the activities of a country (nwabunkeonye, 2014). according to bamberger (1988) women participation refers to an active process whereby women influence the direction and execution of development projects rather than merely receive a share of project profits. this study adopted gender roles as a theoretical framework. the theory was propounded by eagly (1987). the gender role theory suggests that an individual’s gender is an important determinant of his or her behaviour and influence over others. the theory is based on the assumption that the behavior of men and women is assessed in terms of societal expectations of how their gender ought to behave. women are expected to display more feminine characteristic such as sympathy, while men are expected to be more assertive, women are also flexible and better at managing ambiguous situations. the theory affirms that the feminist nature of women makes them so sympathetic, good managers of any situation, and effective in influencing and solving complicated situations in the economy. therefore, governance that actively involves women participation can contribute significantly to the growth of the economy. since they are more sympathetic than their counterpart in managing and executing a policy that will improve the lives of people. this view is supported by empirical studies that investigated determinants of women's participation in nigeria, and in other african countries. the studies also examined the developed economy. osimen et al, (2018) studied political participation and gender inequality in nigeria and found that nigerian women are http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/4943 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 100 still being marginalized due to the style of leadership inherent in the country. hora (2014) researched factors hindering women participating in public institutions at bamidele communities of kenya and observed that over burden of domestic responsibilities, negative attitudes regarding women’s ability to govern, lack of role model women leaders are factors that hinder women's participation in the community. equally, jaumotte (2000) examined the determinants of female labour force participation in oecd countries and discovered female education, the general labour market conditions, and cultural attitudes remain major determinants of female participation. damisa, samndi, and yohanna (2007) investigated the determinants of women participation in agricultural production in nigeria and established that the level of the disposable income, perception, tenure rights and the level of the contribution of the women to agriculture had a significant impact on women participation in agricultural production in nigeria. furthermore, welch (1997) examined why american women tend to participate in political activities slightly less than the men and found out that the political socialization process, the family responsibilities and the overrepresentation of women in demographic groups that have low participation levels are the reasons for low participation of women in politics in america. also, ekundayo (2017) investigated good governance theory and its implications in nigeria and found that poor governance does not only exist but also thrives in nigeria due to poor political leadership and observable flaws in the political leadership recruitment process in nigeria. lastly, paweenawat (2018); hazarika (2018), analyzed gender and corruption nexus and obtained that nations with a greater number of women participation suffers less from corruption. 3. methodology this study employed time-series data span from 1990 to 2018, governance indicator measures (effectiveness, control of corruption and accountability) sourced from world governance indicators (2019), women labour force participation and female employment rate sourced from world bank (2019). model specification the functional form of the relations established below: (1) )(govfwlfp = http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/4943 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 101 where: wlfp is women labour force participation and gov is governance. the equation (1) shows the functional relationship between women labour force participation and governance. to achieve the objective of the study three governance indicators were adopted and presented in equation 2: (2) where: acc is accountability, coc is control of corruption and eff denotes effectiveness. in order to derive equation (3) and obtain functional relationship between women participation and governance, equation (2) is substituted into equation (1) and rewritten as: (3) where: femp is the female employment rate. to obtain an econometrics model, equation (3) transformed, presented as: (4) where: α is the intercept of the model, β1 – β4 are coefficients estimated. the theoretical expectation of β1 – β4 > 0. by implication, the coefficients of the parameters are expected to be greater than zero. that is, a positive relationship between governance indicators and women labour force participation is expected. µt is error term (stochastic variable). the equation (4) is the long-run estimate, showing only the long-run relationship between the regressors and regressed. since, the variables showed mixed order of integration, there is need to specify short-run estimate to test explanatory variables effect on explained variable. the speed of adjustment to equilibrium when short-run shocks occur also reveals. the short-run model presented in equation (5) where ecm (-1) is error correction mechanism: (5) the conducted unit root test, diagnostics, and stability tests. the diagnostic and stability test were normality tests, serial correlation test, heteroscedasticity test, ramsey reset test, cusum, and cusumq to verify soundness, reliability, and validity of the model. 4. research findings and discussion of results in an empirical analysis, the first thing is to conduct pre-test of unit root to determine whether the variables are stationary or not and to also know the appropriate method of analysis to be employed. the augmented dickey-fuller (adf) and philips peron (pp) tests of unit root used results is presented below: ),,( effcocaccgov = ),,,( fempeffcocaccfwlfp = tfemptefftcoctacctwlfp µbbbba +++++= 4321 )1(43210 -+++++= ecmfemptefftcoctacctwlfp lllll http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/4943 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 102 table 1: units root tests results variables level first difference adf pp adf pp wlfp -0.655 -0.181 -2.663* -2.950* acc -1.578 -1.570 -4.124*** -4.115*** coc -0.355 -2.008 -4.376*** -5.591*** eff -3.241** -5.872*** -10.040*** -16.515*** femp -0.561 -0.382 -4.331*** -4.359*** ***denote 1%, ** 5%, and * 10% level of significance source: authors’ computation (2020) given the adf and pp results in table 2, the variables were stationary at the same order except one. effectiveness of government (eff) is stationary at levels but women labor force participation (wlfp), accountability (acc), control of corruption (coc), and female employment rate were stationary at first difference. thus, we reject the null hypothesis and accept alternatives and conclude that the variables have no unit root at 10%, 5%, and 1% level of significance. provided that the result of the adf and pp tests showed a mixture of i(0) and i(1) for the variables, the correct estimation technique to follow is the ardl method. however, it was necessary to test for cointegration among the variables. this was done using the ardl bound testing for co-integration to verify whether a long-run relationship exists among the variables, illustrated in table 2. table 2: bounds test test statistic value significant i(0) i(1) f-statistic 3.147 4 10% 2.2 3.09 5% 1% 2.56 3.29 3.49 4.37 source: authors’ computation (2020) the f-statistics value (3.149) is greater than the upper boundary i(1) at 10% levels of significance. therefore, a long-run relationship exists between women labour force participation and the explanatory variables in the model. hence, we employed the autoregressive distributive lag model to capture both short-run and long-run effects of governance indicators on women labor force participation in nigeria. the short-run estimates, submitted in table 3: http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/4943 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 103 table 3: short run ardl variables coefficient t-statistic d(acc) 1.120 5.675*** d(coc) -0.946 -6.451*** d(eff) d(femp) -0.039 0.128 -0.478 7.828*** ecm(-) -0.620 -10.379*** r2 = 0.95 dw = 2.16 source: authors’ computation (2020) table 3 is the short run ardl error correction model and the signs are in conformity with theoretical expectations. the result shows that acc and femp have a statistically significant and a positive effect on the wlfp in nigeria within the period of the study. a 1 percent increase in acc and femp would lead to 1.12 and 0.13 percentage increases in wlfp respectively. this collaborates with a prior expectation of this study and findings of (undp, 2019), that accountability improved gender participation, as well (jaumotte, 2000) on the female employment as a determinate of women labour force participation. these suggest that accountability and female employment can boost women's participation. this is because a government that lives within the framework of accountability, ensures that citizens are given equal rights, empowerment, and participating opportunities, as well as secures sound system, hence reduction of inequalities which may increase women’s income and involvement in decision making. however, coc and eff have a declining effect on wlfp, coc is statistically significant and eff statistically insignificant. a percentage increase in coc and eff would bring about 0.95% and 0.04% decreases in the wlfp. these outcomes are contrary to the theoretical expectation of this study and the discovery of (undp, 2019), that corruption has an inappropriate effect on women participation the negative sign of coc, implies that fighting corruption does not promote women’s participation. this could be as a result of corruption fighting back mechanism, less women involvement and insincerity in the fight against corruption in nigeria. a serious government is needed to fight corruption and more participation of females is required because increase in women participation is found to have a decreasing effect on corruption (paweenawat, 2018; hazarika, 2018), while that of eff could be traced to the weak http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/4943 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 104 or low intervention of government to critical issues that need urgent attention, such as political violence, abuse of rights, the rule of law, marginalization, etc. the coefficients of the error correction term have the correct negative sign, it is less than one and it is statistically significant. this unique outcome has three significant implications. first, it confirms the presence of a stable or strong long-run relationship between wlfp and the determinants (acc, coc, eff, and femp), as previously established by the bound test result in table 3. secondly, the value (-0.62) implies that about 62% of the short run’s disequilibrium arising from last year’s shocks will be corrected within the current year. lastly, the negative sign suggests the presence of a unidirectional causality in the long run from the explanatory variables to the explained variable. the coefficient of determination (r2) shows that a 95% total variation in wlfp is explained or caused by regressors. the model is a good fit because the coefficient of determination has demonstrated the accuracy and inconclusiveness of variables that are determinants of wlfp. after the short-run results and implications was ascertained, the long-run estimates of the ardl model are shown in table 4: table 4: long run ardl variables coefficient t-statistic acc 0.254 3.483*** coc -1.002 -4.688*** eff -0.451 -0.986 femp 0.156 64.010*** source: author computation (2019) table 4 expresses the long-run results. the variables depicting synonymous characteristics with the short-run result. acc and femp have a positive and statistically significant effect on wlfp in the long run. a percentage increase in acc and femp would result in a 0.25 and 0.16 percent increase in wlfp in nigeria. these findings correspond to (undp, 2019; jaumotte, 2000) and the theoretical expectation of this study. nonetheless, coc and eff have a negative effect on wlfp and it is statistically significant except eff in the long run. a one percent increase in coc and eff would lead to 1.00 and 0.45 percent decreases in wlfp. this outcome is contrary to the theoretical a prior odd of this study and the empirical findings http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/4943 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 105 of (dollar et al, 2001; kumar, 2017; undp, 2019), that corruption has an inappropriate effect on women participation to ascertain whether the results presented in table 3 and 4 could be relied upon, some diagnostic and stability test was carried out and the results presented in table 5: table 5: diagnostic tests assumptions test prob. normality jarque-bera 0.406 heteroscedasticity breusch-pagan 0.982 serial correlation cusum and cusumq ramsey reset breusch-pagan stable f-statistics 0.378 0.050 0.875 source: author computation (2019) this test is very essential as the results of the estimated model have policy implications. table 5 shows diagnostic test results for the classical assumption of autocorrelation, normality, heteroscedasticity. the model passed the diagnostic test. implying that the residual of the model is serially independent, homoscedastic, and normally distributed. by fulfilling these underlines classical assumptions of regression analysis, it is concluded that the estimated parameters are best, linear, and unbiased as well as efficient. this means that policy implication can be drawn from the results of this study. on the stability of the parameters, cumulative sum of recursive residuals (cusum) and cumulative sum of recursive residual squares (cusumq) tests were conducted. the results are contained in the appendix. it revealed that the estimated parameters of the models are stable over the studied sample period as both the recursive residuals and its squares are contained within the 5% critical bounds. we accept the null hypothesis and conclude that the required level of significance is not smaller than 5% (0.05). overall the model is well fitted, stable, and good for policy recommendation. 5. conclusion and recommendations over the years we have overlooked the need for extensive continuing dialogues and mentorship to enable women to reflect on their ancestral roles and be convinced of the need to alter these in favor of equality with men, until the recent time that gender inequality has been a global highlight in the local, http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/4943 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 106 national, and international domains. this is because the fortunate women in the society have realized that men dominate not only in the household decision making process but in essential positions in government which make them more superior, hence the need for an advocate of women's voice to achieve fair representation and participation in government and decision making. it's on this note that this study examined whether governance influences women's participation using annual time-series data for 29 years stretching from 1990 2019. the ardl bounds test disclosed the existence of a long-run co-integration relationship between governance indicators measures (accountability, control of corruption, and effectiveness of government) and women participation quantified as women labor force participation. the empirical results obtained reveal that both the short-run and long-run accountability, the percentage of female employment have a positive and statistically significant effect on women's participation in nigeria government. although, both in the short-run and in the long-run, the effectiveness of government shows negative and statistically insignificant while control of corruption prevails negative and statistically significant both in the short-run and long-run. based on these findings the study recommends as follows: the government at all levels should ensure that accountability prevails in every sector, to allow fair play in representation, employment, and delegations of responsibilities to strengthen and energize women's participation. the government should implement the 30% women representation affirmed by the world conference on women in beijing. this is because a study in international comparisons have shown that nations with more women in government have lower levels of corruption (dollar, fisman and gatti, (2001). though, this study found control of corruption to have a declining effect on women's participation which means more need to be done in the fight against corruption before a sizable representative of women can be achieved. since employment is found to have an appreciative effect on women's participation. women should be encouraged to participate in every sector of the economy and women empowerment programmes should be established to eliminate gender inequality so that they can demonstrate their abilities outside the house itself. finally, policymakers and relevant organizations should strengthen anti-graft in the area of checkmating bad governance to promote good governance as it would affect not just women’s participation in the country but the whole economy. http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/4943 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 107 5.1 the limitations and suggestions for further study the study was constrained by inadequate data on governance indicators which limited the scope and there is a shortage of empirical studies on women’s participation and governance in nigeria. therefore, the study recommends that further studies should use the primary sources of data to overcome the first limitation. further research can examine the determinants of women's participation in labour force in nigeria. lastly, future studies can conduct a comparative study across the various geopolitical zones in nigeria on factors that determine women's participation. appendix a: stability test -6 -4 -2 0 2 4 6 2016 2017 2018 2019 cusum 5% significance http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/4943 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 108 appendix b: residual tests -0.4 0.0 0.4 0.8 1.2 1.6 2016 2017 2018 2019 cusum of squares 5% significance 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 -0.04 -0.02 0.00 0.02 0.04 0.06 series: residuals sample 1994 2019 observations 26 mean 1.12e-13 median -0.000794 maximum 0.057070 minimum -0.041562 std. dev. 0.021537 skewness 0.594352 kurtosis 3.501012 jarque-bera 1.802697 probability 0.406022 http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/4943 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 109 breusch-godfrey serial correlation lm test: f-statistic 1.649181 prob. f(2,2) 0.3775 obs*r-squared 16.18565 prob. chi-square(2) 0.5003 heteroskedasticity test: breusch-pagan-godfrey f-statistic 0.265629 prob. f(21,4) 0.9816 obs*r-squared 15.14202 prob. chi-square(21) 0.8158 scaled explained ss 0.448170 prob. chi-square(21) 1.0000 references asian development bank (2005). country governance assessment. philippines: asian development bank. http://hdl.handle.net/11540/6353. agbalajobi, d. (2010) “women’s participation and the political process in nigeria: problems and prospects” african journal of political science and international relations 4(2): 75-82. agishi, t. v. (2014) “women participation in rural development programmes in benue state”. journal of scientific and developmental studies.1(1) 26-46 bamberger, m. (1988). the role of community participation in development planning and project management, edi policy seminar report no. 13. world bank edi, washington d.c cheung a., & hernández, r. j., (2001) gender and corruption: a panel data analysis. journal of the department of economics 11(73) 1 15 damisa, m. a., samndi r., & yohanna, m., (2007) women participation in agricultural production: a probit analysis. journal of applied sciences. 7(3): 412-416. dollar, d., r. fisman, and r. gatti. (2001). are women the ‘fairer’ sex? corruption and women in government. journal of economic behavior & organization 46(9): 423-429. https://doi.org/10.1016/s0167-2681(01)00169-x eagly, a. h. (1997). sex differences in social behavior: comparing social role theory and evolutionary psychology. american psychologist, 52(12), 1380-1383. https://doi.org/10.1037/0003066x.52.12.1380.b http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/4943 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 110 ekundayo, w. j., (2017). good governance theory and the quest for good governance in nigeria international journal of humanities and social sciences. 7(5) 154-161 frank, b., lambsdorff, j. g. & boehm, f. (2011). gender and corruption: lessons from laboratory corruption experiments. the european journal of development research, 23; 59–71 hazarika, g. (2018). the plough, gender roles, and corruption. economic governance 19;141 167 hora, e. a. (2014). factors that affect women's participation in leadership and decision-making positions. asian journal of humanity art and literature, 1(2): 97 118 jaumotte, f. (2000). labour force participation of women: empirical evidence on the role of policy and other determinants in oecd countries. working paper for oecd economic studies, no. 37, 2003/2. retrieved from https://pdfs.semanticscholar.org/bc9c/38f5998d6ce89b67e77681a3d5e8eab151b3.pdf?_ga=2.10588983. 2037161347.1595104314-1539697729.1595104314 kumar, p. (2017). participation of women in politics: worldwide experience. journal of humanities and social sciences (iosr-jhss), 22(12); 77-88. https://doi.org/10.9790/0837-2212067788 national bureau of statistics (2018). report of the national literacy survey 1999-2018 nigeria. abuja: author nigeria women trust fund (2019). women representation in the nigerian elective positions (1999 – 2019). retrieved from http://nigerianwomentrustfund.org/wp-content/uploads/womenrepresentation-in-thenigerian-elective-positions.pdf nwabunkeonye, p. u. (2014). challenges to women active participation in politics in nigeria. sociology and anthropology 2(7); 284-290. https://doi.org/10.13189/sa.2014.020704 ogundiya, i. s. (2010). democracy and good governance: nigeria’s dilemma. african journal of political science and international relations, 4(6), 201 – 208 osimen g. anegbode e. j., basil o. d. & oyewole o. (2018) political participation and gender inequality in nigerian fourth republic. european centre for research training and development 6(5); 2238 paweenawat, s. w. (2018). the gender corruption nexus in asia. asian specific economic literature, 32(1); 18-28. https://doi.org/10.1111/apel.12214 quota project (2005). a global database on quotas for women. retrieved from http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/4943 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 111 http://www.quotaproject.org. swamy, a., knack, s., lee, y. & azfar, o. (2001). gender and corruption. journal of development economics, 64(1);25-55. https://doi.org/10.1016/s0304-3878(00)00123-1 united nations development programme (1997). making globalization work for all: united nations development programme annual report. new york: author united nations development programme (2019). human development data. new york: author vijayalakshmi, v. (2018). rent-seeking and gender in local governance. the journal of development studies, 44(9); 1262-1288. https://doi.org/10.1080/00220380802265611 welch, s. (1997) women as political animals? a test of some explanations for male-female political participation differences. american journal of political science 21(4); 711-730 women in national parliaments (2019): world classification of women participation, nigeriaposition retrieved from http://www.ipu.org/wmn world bank (2019). world development indicators report on nigeria. washington dc: author world bank (2019). world governance indicator. washington dc: author 5763-other-17673-1-4-20210425 european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5763 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 29 opportunities and challenges of sustainable development and digital revolution: the italian case of toolery gloria fiorani1, federica bosco1 and alessandro biagetti2 1 department of management and law, faculty of economics, tor vergata university of rome, rome, italy 2 coo toolery, via dedalo 27, 00133 rome, italy e-mail: federica.bosco@uniroma2.it received: 25/04/2021 accepted for publication: 10/06/2021 published: 19/07/2021 abstract this article explores how digital transformation can provide support for achieving the sustainable development goals (sdgs) of the un's 2030 agenda. the article aims to provide a case study of the use of technology in a low-tech sector, the construction industry, in order to make the costs of reducing the positive impacts on the environment and people sustainable from an economic point of view as well. the article produces practical implications by describing strengths, weaknesses opportunities and major challenges of digital technologies for designing sustainable business models.. keywords: digital transformation, 2030 agenda, sustainable development goals (sdgs), start-up, case study analysis, ecommerce 1. introduction the growing attention to the themes of sustainable development and the strong push towards digitalization are affecting all sectors of our society, deeply changing its dynamics. the nexus amid both domains foreshows outstanding, yet untapped, opportunities to foster a transformation towards sustainable development (osburg e lohrmann, 2017). in fact, it is possible to consider the synergy between digital transformation (dt) and sustainable development a winning combination (atos, 2018) but still not potentially exploited (del rìo castro et al., 2020). digital transformation, understood as the set of changes that digital technology causes or influences in all aspects of human life; (stolterman & fors 2004) it is reshaping work, leisure, relationships, education and governance. at the same time, this revolution allows the transformation of entire sectors of society, directing business towards more efficient, productive and sustainable models. nowadays, digitalization is heralded to be one of the most promising transformations for sustainability (gouvea et al., 2018). in order to understand the possible positive implications of digitization for sustainable development, the above-mentioned work aims, therefore, to answer the following research questions (rqs): in order to accelerate the change process in a sustainable perspective, why governing dt is a challenge to take over? (rq1). why implementing more sustainable business models can represent an opportunity for italian growth? (rq2). the study is structured as follows: the first section introduces the topic, the rqs and the motivation of the european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5763 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 30 article; the literature review provides an overview of the digital transformation and a review of the main stages of sustainable development up to the adoption of the 2030 agenda. the methodology illustrates the chosen case study in order to analyze the implications of dt for sustainable development; the fourth section outlines the results achieved resorting to an impact assessment on the sustainable development goals (sdgs) from a multidimensional perspective. discussion aims to fill the gap between digital transformation and sustainable development answering the first research question. in conclusion, the second research question is answered by providing a s.w.o.c analysis of the case at hand, specifically linking the opportunities of the study with the national strategy. 2. literature review 2.1 digital transformation nowadays, when we talk of digital transformation we mean restructuring an organization to use any and all information and network-based technologies that increase its competitiveness, in a way that, over a period of time, excludes and outcompetes untransformed organizations (baker, 2014). digital technologies are disrupting across the economy and society. digital transformation (dt) refers to “a process that aims to improve an entity by triggering significant changes to its properties through combinations of information, computing, communication, and connectivity technologies” (vial, 2019). the process of digital transformation manifests in new institutional arrangements, bringing about novel values, practices, and structures impacting the established rules of the game and contesting contemporary logic constellations (hinings et al., 2018). digitalization brings novel cultural, holistic and multidimensional phenomena (boyd and crawford, 2012). digitalization is not a single entity or technology; rather, it is a highly interconnected system in itself. it represents the convergence and interplay of many fields, such as computer science, engineering, informatics, mathematics, biotechnology, nanotechnology, and manufacturing. (twi2050, 2019). one thing that is agreed on is that digital transformation, whether within a corporation or within an industry, is the largest change sweeping businesses and organizations today (baker, 2014). in this direction, the european commission through the “2021 commission work programme – from strategy to delivery”, aims to make europe healthier, fairer and more prosperous, while accelerating the transformation to a greener economy ready for the digital age. to achieve these goals, the commission will ensure in this digital decade of europe defined targets for 2030 in areas such as connectivity, skills and digital public services (european commission, 2020). the first pillar of the package announced by the president of the european commission, ursula von der leyen, is that of a digital economy deeply centered on people. the commission plans to invest heavily in digital skills development and training for all europeans, including a digital education plan for digital literacy and skills development. in addition, the strategy aims to accelerate investment in the ability to deliver high-speed data connectivity through an update of the european action plan on 5g and 6g. the actions proposed within the strategy have as a second pillar to foster a healthy and competitive transition of europe to the digital economy. this is ensured, among other things, through the establishment of an eu action plan for the industry facilitates the transition to digital for european companies and strengthen the rules of the single market. but where does italy stand in relation to this wave of global innovation? we are clearly answered by the commission's digital economy and society index (desi), which in 2019 placed us 25th in europe after croatia, slovakia, cyprus and hungary. an indicator of european digital performance, the desi analyzes the evolution of member states on the basis of five dimensions: the ability to provide a high-speed data connection (connectivity), advances with respect to the digital skills of citizens (human capital), the frequency of use of online services such as e-games, music, video, online shopping and online banking (use of internet), the degree of digitization of businesses and the spread of e-commerce systems (integration of digital technology) and finally the level of digitization of public services (digital public services). a comparison of the five dimensions of the index shows how the infrastructure for high-speed data connection has more than doubled since 2014 with investments in mobile broadband networks; however, this growth does not seem to have influenced the other dimensions which, since 2014, have suffered from a stagnant or profoundly slow evolutionary dynamic. finally, it emerges that the level of digitization of businesses is very low and the use of internet is still not widespread in our country. to weigh negatively on the digitalization of the industrial sector is above all e-commerce while, as far as the use of internet is concerned, online transactions are less widespread. public policies in favor of digital transition must therefore necessarily consider these shortcomings and act in this sense to allow italy to approach its european peers. reconciling technological innovation with social and environmental issues in order to design better societies and economies is the real historical challenge to be faced and may represent a unique development opportunity. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5763 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 31 2.2 sustainable development the notion of sustainable development has its roots in the distant seventies, when awareness began to spread that the fordist production model, characteristic of industrialized society (sebastiani, 2014), was having serious repercussions on natural systems. in particular, it was the oil crisis of 1973 that laid the foundations for the construction of a better future for all humanity. in fact, with the war between israel and arab countries, the price of oil increased which resulted in a consequent increase in energy costs and inflation. as a consequence, therefore, of the energy crisis, many countries of the world were forced to adopt drastic austerity policies in order to limit energy consumption. this event, represented for the west the first real opportunity to stop and think about the use of natural resources of the planet, now limited, as they considered the use of renewable sources as an alternative to oil and fossil fuels. the industrial community therefore began to question the consequences of its actions (petrini, 2012). we can therefore say that the idea of a model of responsible consumption began to take shape in the early 1970s, the decade in which the un conference on the human environment was held. to support this thesis, the report on the "limits to development" commissioned by the club of rome and carried out by some scholars from the massachusetts institute of technology (boudes, 2014). the document illustrated the results of a computer simulation of the interactions between industrialization, consumption of resources, population, food production, pollution and their exponential growth over time. although a tragic fact emerged, namely that in a short period of time all environmental and energy resources would be exhausted as a result of a careless growth in production, it also raised hopes that this catastrophe could be avoided by pursuing a type of development that would not cause the total consumption of the earth's resources (meadows et al., 1972). in order to achieve this type of development, however, it was necessary that attention to the environment be accompanied by the principles of economic growth and long-term improvement of living conditions. in order to have a complete vision of the steps that have been taken over the years in favour of sustainability, it is essential to retrace the most important stages of this path. the stockholm conference, convened by the united nations and held in sweden from the 5th to the 16th of june 1972, marks the beginning of the path towards sustainable development. following the conference was established unep “united nation environment programme”, a specialized agency of the un in order to protect the environment and raise awareness of the community to responsible behavior (lafratta, 2004). in 1980, the collaboration between unep, iucn and wwf resulted in the first document integrating conservation with the sustainable use of natural resources, “the world conservation strategy: living resource conservation for sustainable development” (iucn et al., 1980). nowadays, in order to define the concept of sustainable development, we refer to its most widespread and shared definition, elaborated in 1987 by the world commission on environment and development and contained in the brundtland report “our common future”, whose name derives from the then norwegian prime minister gro harlem brundtland who chaired that commission: “development which meets the needs of current generations without compromising the ability of future generations to meet their own needs” (brundtland, 1987). in 1991, the three organizations iucn, unep and wwf published “caring for the earth: a strategy for sustainable living”. with this document it is stressed how important it is to improve the quality of life of human beings, respecting the regenerative capacity of natural resources (iucn et al., 1991). in 1992, in rio de janeiro, brazil, was held the largest conference in history organized by unced: the "earth summit". it was attended by heads of government from around the world, representatives of 172 states and many spokesmen of non-governmental organizations, all gathered to discuss the future of humanity and the environment. (unced, 1992). in the same year, in brussels, the european union approved the fifth environmental action plan “towards sustainability” (eu, 1992). in 1994, the “aalborg charter” was approved during the “european conference on sustainable cities and towns”. through this document, european cities committed themselves to applying “agenda 21” and to promoting long-term sustainable action programs at the local level (lafratta, 2004). in 2000, the united nations millennium summit was held where the eight millennium development goals (mdgs) were defined, which all 193-member states of the un committed to achieving by 2015 (undp, 2015). eight goals were identified: reduce hunger and poverty, improve education, equal opportunities and empower women, improve the health of children and their mothers, combat diseases, ensure sustainable development and promote economic development (lafratta, 2004). 2002 was the year of the “world summit on sustainable development”, held in johannesburg. the document "plan of implementation of world summit on sustainable development" was drafted through which the importance of the millennium goals defined in the “millennium declaration” was reaffirmed; the commitment to promoting the principles for sustainability elaborated during the “earth summit” in rio was renewed and the implementation of “agenda 21” was continued (un, 2002). 2010 was the year of the “europe 2020” strategy: an action plan to ensure sustainable, smart and inclusive growth of the european economy for the decade 2010-2020 (eu, 2010). in 2012 the “united nations conference on sustainable development” (uncsd) took place, european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5763 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 32 also known as “rio+20”, because it took place twenty years after the “rio de janeiro earth summit”. from the conference emerged the document “the future we want” which addressed issues of fundamental importance for the future of the earth. the meeting was an opportunity for the governments of the countries of the world to take stock of the results obtained so far during the path undertaken a few years earlier and to establish new common goals to be achieved (un, 2012). on the occasion of the summit on sustainable development that took place, from 25 to 27 september 2015, in new york, the 2030 agenda was presented: an ambitious and innovative strategic framework of the united nations for the world, signed by the governments of the 193-member countries (un, 2015a). in fact, it represents a real program of action aimed at the planet, at people and for prosperity. the 2030 agenda is the result of a long and complex process, which started with the world conference on sustainable development “rio+20”; on that occasion, the un member governments took on the task of enriching the interventions in favor of sustainable development. among these, that of defining new development goals to take the place of the previous ones: the “millennium development goals”. thus, 17 new goals were born: “sdgs sustainable development goals” to be framed in the post-2015 agenda. the new goals start from the results achieved by the mdgs and complete what the mdgs failed to achieve, with 169 targets and more than 240 indicators. they are universal, i.e. they are addressed to both developed and developing countries; they are interconnected and at the same time they are indivisible and common: in this long journey all must advance in the same direction, without exclusions and distinctions with the signing of the 2030 agenda and the launch in 2016 of the sustainable development goals, the un countries have made themselves responsible for the future of the world for the next fifteen years. un secretary-general ban ki-moon says: "the new agenda is a promise by leaders to all people everywhere. it is an agenda for people, to end poverty in all its forms an agenda for the planet, our common home". all countries must therefore commit themselves to ensuring that these goals can be achieved at all levels of society. 3. methodology the case study focuses on the work carried out by the innovative startup toolery which aims to digitise the entire site procurement process for construction companies by offering the possibility to put leftover site materials back on the market in a circular economy perspective. the construction industry has been particularly affected by the crisis of the last few years and for this reason it needs more and more innovation. toolery's contribution aims precisely at underlining not only the infinite potential for building companies capable of bringing innovation to the market, but also a good response of the latter to an increasingly flexible and digitized vision of the building sector. toolery is a platform that allows companies to buy building materials online and have them delivered directly to the construction site, avoiding unnecessary waiting at building material retailers. toolery not only simplifies internal processes, but also provides an opportunity for construction retailers to bring their products online and tap into new customers and opportunities. in addition, the platform provides an opportunity for construction companies to re-circulate supply chain waste. according to ekanayake and ofori (2004), construction waste is defined as a material, other than the material of the earth, that is transported to another place on the project site or used on the project site and does not conform to the specifications of the project because it is damaged, excess and unused/unusable or a production of the construction process that is not according to plan. in construction, waste can be a delay of time, lack of security, reworking, excessive costs, unnecessary travel or transfer, long shipping distances, imprecision in the selection of operation methods or bad management tools and capacity-building measures. the aim is to revolutionise the construction industry by innovating purchasing processes through ecommerce and delivery. in this sense, this one is a start-up that can say they got a major boost from the pandemic. in the undeniable tragedy of the current situation, companies and citizens have found themselves necessarily having to exploit the means and potential of digital technology, which has propelled the country forward by five years in just under a year. for toolery, operating in the construction sector, the coronavirus has been a moment of reflection, strongly increasing building retailers' awareness of the importance of multi-channel sales and therefore the importance of digitalisation. with this in mind, the start-up strongly believes that the idea behind the project has taken on even greater value, which is why it is offering its customers the opportunity to access the service at a heavily discounted price to accelerate digitisation and increase the competitiveness of the sector. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5763 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 33 3.1 context there are 11,241 building material dealers in italy, specifically 4,548 wholesale building material dealers and 6,693 building material dealers. 45% of construction warehouses are located in the south of italy, although almost 60% of the sector's revenues are generated by companies in northern italy. the total turnover of the sector is around 18 billion. construction companies lose between 50 and 80 minutes in a row at the retailer's and, in the event of an unforeseen shortage of material on the construction site, they have to wait until the next day to replenish the necessary material, generating a further loss of time. in europe, there is as yet no specialised "last mile" service for building materials. large distribution centres such as leroy merlin, obi or bricoman only deliver within 5 to 7 working days. companies support the toolery service mainly in two ways: by going directly to the supplier in the morning, before starting the working day; or the day before, in the evening, by buying everything needed for the next day. with the toolery service, the time savings for companies are considerable, considering that an average company on arrival at the dealer has to queue to create or collect the order sheet, queue in the warehouse and queue again in the sales office to collect the transport document. 4. results a corporation's ultimate success can and should be measured not just by the traditional financial bottom line, but also by its social and ethical and environmental performance, according to a triple bottom line approach (norman &macdonald, 2004). many organizations have the desire to be more sustainable, but according to the organizations themselves, they lack the structures needed to proceed (vandenbrande 2019). a platform such as toolery, which digitizes the entire delivery process in the construction industry through the provision of a digital service, produces several positive impacts on the ground for the environment, people, and the economy. in this paragraph we highlight, therefore, some initiatives and interventions implemented by the start-up that, if shared and maintained in the long term, can represent a push for change in the italian construction sector in favor of sustainable development. in order to illustrate the effectiveness of the role of digital innovation in support of the aforementioned smart building platform in achieving the sustainable development goals, we have resorted to a multidimensional impact assessment (environmental, economic and social), both in the short and medium-long term, of the direct and indirect effects generated on the goals of the 2030 agenda, the action plan through which the un member countries have made themselves responsible for the future of the world for the next fifteen years after its signing (un 2015a). much has been accomplished since its adoption, but it is also well known that more action is needed to make the world's actors truly sustainable (laszlo et al., 2005). table 1 shows, therefore, the characteristics and areas of intervention adopted by the start-up in line with the sustainable development goals of the 2030 agenda. considering the characteristic of digital platform, using iot technologies allows to generate several benefits in terms of efficiency of resources, saving time and money and increasing the loyalty of customers and suppliers who want to protect the planet. table 1. “toolery sdgs mapping” affordable e-commerce digital document dispenser delivery efficiency algorithm source: author’s elaboration • affordable e-commerce: the potential contribution of toolery.eu in this direction is mainly expressed in the ability to increase the productivity of workers by enhancing and supporting the local economy, with clear benefits on economic growth and decent work for all. digitization, in this sense, can help smaller realities, which very often are at a disadvantage because of the large-scale retail trade, to get in touch with customers. another feature of the e-commerce platform with regard to the general positive social impacts concerns precisely networking and activating synergies by european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5763 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 34 implementing policies and mobilizing resources to support accelerated investments in actions to combat poverty. another feature that resides in its digital nature is represented by the potential capacity to achieve several sustainable development goals. in the specific case of toolery, which refers to the construction sector, the sdgs achieved on the basis of what has been analyzed are: 1 “end poverty in all its forms everywhere”, 8 “promote inclusive and sustainable economic growth, employment and decent work for all”, 9 “build resilient infrastructure, promote sustainable industrialization and foster innovation”, 10 “reduce inequality within and among countries”, 11 “make cities inclusive, safe, resilient and sustainable”, 16 “promote just, peaceful and inclusive societies” and 17 “revitalize the global partnership for sustainable development”. • digital document dispenser: one of the most obvious benefits of digital transformation is the fact that it’s scaling back on the use of paper such as books, files, magazines, contracts in lieu of digital communication and digital file management. cloud storage helps eliminate paper waste and the overhead costs of traditional storage and secure shredding. it also makes accessing documents from anywhere even easier (newman, 2017). in addition, the following feature enables employees, customers and suppliers to access documents from anywhere, decreasing waste and costs related to energy consumption, commuting emissions, and so on. all these elements allow, therefore, to meet the objectives: 7 “ensure access to affordable, reliable, sustainable and modern energy”, 9 “build resilient infrastructure, promote sustainable industrialization and foster innovation”, 12 “ensure sustainable consumption and production patterns”, 13 “take urgent action to combat climate change and its impacts" and 15 "sustainably manage forests, combat desertification, halt and reverse land degradation, halt biodiversity loss”. • delivery efficiency algorithm: although firms have recognized the importance of supply chain innovation, they still find it difficult to innovate in isolation. indeed, as sumo, valk, weele, and bode (2016) concluded, collaboration among partners is necessary to incorporate innovation into firms, and this involves integrating and exchanging information with others (cao and zhang, 2011). supply chain innovation refers to an interconnected set of processes which deal with uncertainties and disruptions in the firm's internal and external environment in order to provide novel and innovative solutions to end users (lee et al., 2011). in the long run, organizations achieve a sustainable competitive advantage by developing key competencies and, in this way, provide better services to their target customers than their competitors. srivastava, franklin, and martinette (2013) explained key competencies as a set of unique competencies developed in organizations’ key areas, including factors like innovation flexibility, customer service, quality and responsiveness which help organizations to outdo their competitors. thus, in this scenario, competitive advantage is a state where organizations possess better resources and implementation abilities in order to cut costs, get better business performance and create added value for customers in long-term competition with rival firms. the use of digital not only helps manage the supply chain but also allows for more efficient planning of shipping and transportation routes thanks to “driver correspondence” with direct benefits on decongesting mobility and reducing pollution. therefore, the sdgs achieved are: 9 “build resilient infrastructure, promote sustainable industrialization and foster innovation”, 12 “ensure sustainable consumption and production patterns", 11 “make cities inclusive, safe, resilient and sustainable”, 13 “take urgent action to combat climate change and its impacts” and 15 “sustainably manage forests, combat desertification, halt and reverse land degradation, halt biodiversity loss”. 5. discussion the potential contribution of digital transformation to the achievement of the sustainable development goals (sdgs) is increasingly evident and highlighted by scholars and practitioners (bonomi savignon, 2020). according to enrico giovannini (2020), the digital revolution is a necessary condition for the transformation of consumption and production models (epifani, 2020). this revolution allows, in fact, the transformation of entire sectors of society, orienting business towards more efficient, productive and sustainable models. but what are the possible implications of digitalization for sustainable development? undoubtedly, the digital component will represent a fundamental vector for the achievement of the ambitious sustainable development goals (sdgs) of the 2030 agenda; in fact, digital solutions can be considered the main enablers to support a green and long-term transition on a global scale. in order to bring the world on a path of sustainable development, the digital revolution assumes, therefore, a fundamental role. the objective of this work was to analyze the implications of digitization for sustainable development and for the 2030 agenda, through the description of the case study of toolery, an italian e european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5763 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 35 commerce platform operating in the construction sector, with reference to the achievement of the un sustainable development goals. in this direction, to innovate means to provide a digital service to create a positive impact for the environment, people and economy: from an environmental point of view, to improve, through the digitalization of procurement and distribution processes, the entire supply process in the construction industry, minimizing waste and co2 emissions; social, generating decent work and reducing the risk of loss related to territorial realities; economic, providing digital services for small retailers in the area that support the local economy against the large-scale retail trade. in this direction the use of online, can represent, therefore, not only a valuable ally to increase their productivity but allows you to create a culture oriented to sustainability and responsibility that surrounds the various business. the discussion, through the analysis of the case study, wanted to highlight why governing the digital transformation represents a challenge to be taken to accelerate the processes of change in a sustainable perspective. digitalization could accelerate sustainable transitions, particularly ecological and social shifts in the industrial domain (beier et al., 2017) as support human progress and reframe the business case for both investors and consumers (holst et al., 2017) and drive resource efficiency. this means for building a successful business, digital transformation and sustainability have to complement one another. for this reason, the digital revolution should not be viewed as being outside or separate from sustainable development and their convergence must be ensured to achieve solutions for the sdgs. it seems therefore right to make a consideration: the technology movement we credit with improving customer experience and changing the face of the modern business landscape (newman, 2017) can also make a large contribution in helping organizations, cities and nations better meet their sustainability goals. the case study of the toolery platform teaches us, therefore, that thanks to the use of technology, great results have been obtained, such as in terms of reducing pollution and waste; for this reason, sustainability must become an integral part of the companies’ mission. only through this attitude they can continue to survive in the long term, generating a benefit for their businesses and the planet. 6. conclusion for italy, the path towards the un 2030 agenda, which already appeared to be uphill before the crisis, has become even more difficult. for this reason, it is necessary to embark as soon as possible on the path towards a "just" ecological transition, capable of generating new employment and economic and social development, using eu and national resources in a coherent manner to relaunch the country with a view to economic, social and environmental sustainability (asvis, 2020). the advancement of the digital transition in this process of growth and improvement can help to meet this need. it seems fundamental, therefore, to perceive the use of digital as a valid support to the achievement of the sdgs. sustainable development and digital transformation represent, in fact, the strategic priorities also of the new national recovery and resilience plan (nrrp) aimed at providing italy with an answer to the main challenges it will have to face in the coming years, among which promoting, in line with the strategic objectives shared with europe, the green and digital transition (italian government, 2021). specifically, the strategy, aimed at giving concrete implementation to the nextgenerationeu program the tool designed to stimulate post-pandemic recovery for a greener, digital and resilient europe (european commission, 2020) through the resources allocated also intends to accelerate the pursuit of the 17 sdgs in order to proceed to an impact assessment related to the implementation of the missions, at national and territorial level. according, in fact, to current estimates, the nrrp will have a positive impact on the main macroeconomic variables and indicators of inclusion, equity and sustainable development through increased investment that will activate directly and indirectly and technological innovations that will introduce and stimulate. italy, especially thanks to the choices made by the european union, is becoming aware of the need for a change in the direction of sustainable development (asvis, 2020). for italian companies, therefore, taking advantage of incentives will represent a strategic opportunity to innovate in a "green" perspective. figure 1 shows the s.w.o.c. analysis carried out for the case study in question, which illustrates the strengths and weaknesses of a highly digital reality such as toolery, considering the italian context, the opportunities linked to the pnrr and the main challenges to be taken up with a view to long-term improvement. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5763 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 36 figure 1. “s.w.o.c analysis” source: author’s elaboration nowadays, the role of start-ups in italy is increasingly relevant on an economic level. in a world where it's difficult to keep old businesses afloat, the thought of starting new ones is distressing, but also an indication of great courage and inventiveness that is fundamental to the life of the country. for this reason, the pnrr can be an opportunity to implement more sustainable business models. how? through favorable funding, in line with the three strategic lines proposed by the plan: digitization and innovation, fundamental to make italy a protagonist in the global technological competition and strictly connected to the second pillar of the plan, that is the ecological transition. digitization is, in fact, essential to improve the management of energy consumption and resources, in agriculture as in sustainable mobility, feeding new production and research chains and generating employment. finally, ensuring social inclusion by reducing inequality and poverty, infrastructure and employment gaps and territorial gaps in accessibility to services and achieving gender equality, with action on the multiple dimensions of discrimination against women. sustainable development will be key to ensuring the structural reduction of asymmetries and inequalities, between geographic areas and between people (italian government, 2021). policymakers, researchers, companies, and all civil society actors will, therefore, need to intensify their efforts to understand and explain the multiple effects of digital change in order to guide the digitization process towards sustainable (twi2050, 2019) and forward-looking transformations. building enterprises extensive dealer network (close to construction companies); construction hopper (choice of pickup time/place); completely free of charge. construction resellers e-commerce (businesses order products directly) brings new businesses to residential customers; cloud-based web platform. s w o respond to the crisis in an innovative way; implement more sustainable business models; innovate sectors, such as construction, to transform the crisis into an opportunity for rebirth. related to pnrr digital growth of the country system; support innovation and competitiveness of the production system; supporting the digital and green transition and the socio-economic development of italy. digital business still not potentially exploited. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5763 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 37 references atos, (2018). journey 2018 your business technologists. powering progress the 3rd digital revolution. https://atos.net/wpcontent/uploads/2016/06/atos-ascentjourney-2018-whitepaper.pdf. baker m., (2014), digital transformation. digital edition, buckingham monographs. beier, g., niehoff, s., ziems, t., xue, b., 2017. sustainability aspects of a digitalized industryda comparative study from china and germany. int. j. precis. eng. manuf.-green technol. 2017 (4), 227e234. https://doi.org/10.1007/s40684-01700288. bonomi savignon a., (2020), tendenze in atto nella trasformazione digitale della pa italiana. rilevazioni quali-quantitative e costruzione di un indice sintetico, mcgraw-hill education, pp. 9-10, isbn: 9788838699269. boudes, p. (2014). united nations conference on the human environment. encyclopedia britannica. https://www.britannica.com/topic/united-nations-conference-on-the-human-environment. boyd d. &crawford, k., (2012). critical questions for big data. information, communication & society. 15. 1-18. 10.1080/1369118x.2012.678878. brundtland g.h., (1987), our common future, wced. cao, m. &zhang, q. (2011) supply chain collaboration: impact on collaborative advantage and firm performance. journal of operation management, 29, 163-180. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.jom.2010.12.008. del río castro g., gonzalez fernandez, uruburu colsa a., (2020). unleashing the convergence amid digitalization and sustainability towards pursuing the sustainable development goals (sdgs): a holistic review. journal of cleaner production 280 (2021) 122204, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2020.122204. ekanayake l.l., ofori g., (2004). building waste assessment score: design-based tool, building and environment, volume 39, issue 7, 2004, pages 851-861, issn 0360-1323 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.buildenv.2004.01.007. epifani s., (2020). digital sustainability: why sustainability cannot disregard digital transformation, digital transformation institute, isbn: 978-88-944841-3-7. eu, (1992). "towards sustainability": the european community programme of policy and action in relation to the environment and sustainable development, official journal of european comission. eu, (2010., europe 2020: a strategy for smart, sustainable and inclusive growth, bruxelles, march. european commission, (2020), 2021 commission work programme – from strategy to delivery, brussels. european commission, (2020), eu recovery plan, nextgenerationeu, https://ec.europa.eu/info/strategy/recovery-planeurope_it. gouvea, r., kapelianis, d., kassicieh, s., (2018). assessing the nexus of sustainability and information & communications technology. technol. forecast. soc. change 130, 39e44. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.techfore.2017.07.023. issn 00401625. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5763 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 38 hinings, c. & gegenhuber, thomas & greenwood, royston. (2018). digital innovation and transformation: an institutional perspective. information and organization. 10.1016/j.infoandorg.2018.02.004. holst, a., lo€ffler, c.r., philipps, s., 2017. in: osburg, t., lohrmann, c. (eds.), how digital reframes the business case for sustainability in consumer markets. new opportunities through new technologies. springer, heidelberg, pp. 105e116. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-54603-2, 2017. italian government (2021), national recovery and resilience plan (pnrr), nextgenerationitalia. iucn/unep/wwf, (1980). world conservation strategy: living resource conservation for sustainable development. international union for conservation of nature and natural resources. iucn/unep/wwf, (1991). caring for the earth. a strategy for sustainable living. gland, switzerland. lafratta p., (2004), innovative tools for sustainable development. vision 2000, iso 14000, emas, sa 8000, ohsas, lca: the winning integration, francoangeli. laszlo, c., sherman, d., whalen, j., ellison, j. (2005). expanding the value horizon how stakeholder value contributes to competitive advantage. green leaf publishing, jcc.vandenbrande, w. (2019). quality for a sustainable future. total quality management & business excellence, https://doi.org/10.1080/14783363.2019.1588724. meadows, d.h., meadows d.l., randers j., william w. behrens iii, (1972), the limits to growth, a report for the club of rome's project on the predicament of mankind, universe books, isbn 0-87663-165-0. newman d., (2017). how digital transformation aligns with corporate social responsibility, forbes. norman w., macdonald c., (2004). getting to the bottom of 'triple bottom line, business ethics quarterly 14(2) (april). osburg, t., lohrmann, c. (eds.), (2017). sustainability in a digital world. new opportunities through new technologies. springer, heidelberg. https://doi.org/ 10.1007/978-3-319-54603-2, 2017. petrini f., (2012) the energy crisis of 1973. multinational oil companies and the end of the (black) golden age; contemporary. journal of history of the 19th and 20th centuries., n. 3, pp. 445-471. sachs, j.d., schmidt-traub, g., mazzucato, m., et al., (2019b). six transformations to achieve the sustainable development goals. nat sustain 2, 805e814. https:// doi.org/10.1038/s41893-019-0352-9. sebastiani r. (2014) "corporate sustainability and business competitiveness. sustainable development as an opportunity for a new way of doing business"., francoangeli. seele, p., lock, i., (2017). game-changing potential of digitalization for sustainability: possibilities, perils, and pathways. sustain. sci. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11625017-0426-4. srivastava, m., franklin, a., & martinette, l. (2013). building a sustainable competitive advantage. journal of technology management &amp; innovation, 8(2), 47–60. https://doi.org/10.4067/s0718-27242013000200004. stolterman e., &fors a. c., (2004) information technology and the good life, in information systems research: relevant theory and informed practice, p. 689, isbn 1-4020-8094-8. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5763 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 39 sumo r., valk, w.v.d, bode c., (2016). fostering incremental and radical innovation through performance-based contracting in buyer-supplier relationships. international journal of operations & production management. 36. 1482-1503. 10.1108/ijopm-05-2015-0305. twi2050 the world in 2050 (2019). the digital revolution and sustainable development: opportunities and challenges. report prepared by the world in 2050 initiative. international institute for applied systems analysis (iiasa), laxenburg, austria. www.twi2050.org. un (2015a), transforming our world: the 2030 agenda for sustainable development (a/res/70/1). new york, usa: united nations. un (2015a), transforming our world: the 2030 agenda for sustainable development (a/res/70/1). new york, usa: united nations. un, (2002). report of the world summit of sustainable development. plan of implementation of world summit on sustainable development, johannesburg, south africa, 26 august–4 september. un, (2012). report of the united nations conference on sustainable development, rio de janeiro, brazil 20-22 june. unced, (1992). report of the united nations conference on environment and development, rio de janeiro, 3-14 june, united nations publication, sales no. e.93.i.8 and corrigenda. undp, (2015). the millennium development goals report. vial g., (2019) understanding digital transformation: a review and a research agenda, the journal of strategic information systems, 28 (2), pp. 118-144. walker, j., pekmezovic, a., walker, g., (2019). sustainable development goals: harnessing business to achieve the sdgs through finance, technology and law reform. wiley, isbn 978-1-119-54181-3. september 2019. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/6720 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 11 shadow bank systems in european affairs: measuring capability of fraud risk in special reports stefano de nichilo1* 1 department business and economics, university of cagliari via università 40, 09124 cagliari, italy stefanodenichilo1985@gmail.com received: 27/04/2022 accepted for publication: 28/09/2022 published: 29/12/2022 abstract in the last twenty years, the european court of auditors has placed increasing importance on producing “special reports” examining the economy, efficiency and effectiveness of eu spending, particularly concerning the shadow bank system. this institutional focus on performance audit, alongside traditional financial and compliance audit, has occurred when the european union is increasingly evaluating its policies and programmes under political pressure to demonstrate their added value with shadow bank systems. the rapid growth of the market-based financial system since the mid-1990s changed the nature of financial intermediation in the european states. “european shadow banks systems” are essential institutions within the marketbased financial system. european shadow banks systems are financial intermediaries that conduct maturity, credit, and liquidity transformation without access to central bank liquidity or public sector credit guarantees. examples of the european shadow banks system include finance companies, asset-backed commercial paper (abcp) conduits, limited-purpose finance companies, structured investment vehicles, credit hedge funds, money market mutual funds, securities lenders, and governmentsponsored enterprises. this intermediation chain binds european shadow banks systems into a network. the european shadow banking system rivals the traditional banking system in the intermediation of credit to households and businesses. this study contributes theoretically to research and empirically to the management practice of agile marketing concepts in digital transformation and international business contexts to develop practical competencies of speed, flexibility, and customer responsiveness in marketing strategies and operations. keywords: accountability methodology, agile marketing capabilities, performance audit, shadow bank system, special reports and up grade procedure services 1. introduction this article examined the court’s role in the institutional “chain of accountability” (denichilo, 2021b), addressing the ongoing shift from compliance audit (regularity, legality) towards performance audit and european shadow bank systems (homer & stephenson, 2012). audit by the court ranges from checking individual transactions carried out and the operations of the eu institutions to checking the effectiveness of policy initiatives to gauge how policy has fared (caiden, 1992). european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/6720 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 12 the article analyses the political interests at stake in debates on accountability and the practical challenges inherent in the performance of performance audits (mendez, bactler 2011) with the european shadow bank system. to what extent are special reports increasingly resembling evaluations of european shadow bank systems studies? how does performance audit contribute to the accountability of european shadow bank systems? the article draws on primary documents related to the court’s ongoing internal reform process, including international peer review special reports to perform the european shadow bank system, hearings of the european parliament’s budgetary control committee, and court documents (knill, balint & bauer 2008). this study seeks to identify the key theoretical dimension of the agile marketing capability in the european shadow bank system and provide practical guidelines to facilitate its implementation. our finding is current theoretical and empirical research on agility concepts in the context of digital transformation and international marketing management. 2. literature review the court stresses the role of the parliament to actively engage in the accountability process by examining the court’s reports, rather than accountability being derived through transparency, given the public availability of all its reports for the assessment of the european shadow bank system (power, 2015). the auditor checks that funds are expended for stipulated purposes, that programmes are carried out as intended, and that funds are not spent on unauthorised activities (van wolleghem, 2020). as such, the court considers that it “accounts” for the performance of the eu budget via-à-vis the parliament’s budgetary control committee. so, the court distinguished clearly (denichilo, 2020a) between public audit as the “financial and performance audits of policies and related public funds and their link to the accountability process” and accountability as referring “mainly to democratic oversight of policies and activities of public bodies” (harber, marx and de jager 2020). a first international peer review (2008) criticised the range, level, and usefulness of reporting. it advocated the court focus on “areas of greater relevance, significance on risk”. in its special report for 2008-2012, the court frequently focused on eu programmes (ellinas & suleiman 2008), mainly examining compliance, to some extent effectiveness, but less regularly, economy and efficiency of the european shadow bank system. however, it rarely audited the management of eu institutions in procurement, organisation structures, facility management and human resources management (cortese, del carlo 2008). a second peer review (2014) advised the need for what introsai defines as a “problem-oriented performance audit” (denichilo, 2013) and to study more closely the causes of problems and their consequences as a basis for recommendations (rolle 2010). auditors of the four vertical chambers, acting under the oversight of their director, compiled an initial portfolio of potential audit tasks (sposato 2010) to assess european shadow bank system. proposals were evaluated using the four criteria: risk, materiality, relevance, and coverage. they were subsequently prioritised using three levels of assessment: low, medium, and high. nevertheless, while the chambers were aware of audit requests and issues of significant interest, especially for the parliament, and included them in their work plans, they were “neither collected in a structured way nor treated preferentially” (van der meer & edelebos, 2006). special reports on european shadow bank system are now framed according to five umbrella themes: “smart and inclusive growth”, “sustainable growth-natural resources”, “security and citizenship”, “administration”, as well as “other” (denichilo, 2020c). the court has acknowledged the difficulty in determining which of its work is taken up by the media. auditors may enthuse about a report on a seemingly salient topic, such as eu financing of climate change prevention mechanisms. however, there is no guarantee that politicians and/or the press will seize upon it. a special european shadow bank system report that received good media coverage in recent years had a precise human dimension, examining the effectiveness of free school milk and fruit schemes (colella, griffin, gaparaju s. 2000). with its interest at heart, the court produced a special report of the european shadow bank system on the “single audit”, identifying the weakness of multi-level cooperation (march & olsen 1995) in audit with the commission’s reliance on national audit authorities in different policy areas. the agility of special reports on the european shadow bank system is a strategy that addresses the challenges posed by digital transformation. it facilitates easy adaptation to the current complex business environments characterised by escalating competition, diverse customer requirements and expectations and rapid technological change. dynamic capabilities are hallmarks of the agility of the shadow bank system, defined as a paying agency’s dynamic capability to redeploy resources for creating value and managing turbulent environments efficiently. given the pivotal role of marketing in developing a paying agency’s dynamic capabilities and the need to build efficient marketing capabilities to compete in international markets successfully, marketing researchers are now focusing on dynamic marketing capabilities (bock, opsahl, george & gann 2012). european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/6720 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 13 marketing and strategy research broadly recognised the positive linkage between the agility of the shadow bank system and marketing performance (chen, wang, nervo, benitez-amado & kou 2015). agility is crucial for creating customer value and added competitive advantage and providing firms with the ability to face market changes. in a paying agency, the marketing function mainly concerns demand creation, and agile competencies facilitate coping with the demand and quickly adapt tactics and operations in response to environmental changes. therefore, agile capabilities in the marketing area refer to dynamic marketing capabilities. earlier studies on agility describe agile paying agencies, especially in supply chain and it, in disruptive business contexts they are known to continuously monitor and detect environmental changes, opportunities, and threats, thus responding swiftly to market changes with timely decision-making and innovation. firms can quickly exploit existing or acquired resources to respond to changing market needs. customer responsiveness entails using it to improve the adequacy, accuracy, accessibility, and timeliness of the information and facilitate access to relevant customer data (chaffey 2010). customer responsiveness requires timely identification and proactive or reactive response to changes. agile paying agencies may better predict market demand, enhance customisation, or use it to meet customer expectations. agile paying agencies are also characterised by decision-makers who resolutely deal with changes, opportunities, and threats in the business environment. people in an agile organisation are more productive, efficient, and effective in achieving organisational objectives. they benefit from close relationships and collaboration, decentralised decision-making, and it expertise to address dynamic environments. moreover, marketers use technology integration to align with businesses to facilitate adequate information flow across the supply chain (eckstein, goellner, blome & henke 2015). 3. methodology we identify the three distinct subgroups of the european shadow banking system. these are: (a) the governmentsponsored shadow banking sub-system; (b) the “internal” shadow banking sub-system; and (c) the “external” shadow banking sub-system (table 1). a) the government-sponsored shadow banking sub-system (lending to nonbanking financial institutions) the seeds of the european shadow banking system were sown nearly 30 years ago, with the creation the governmentsponsored enterprises (gse). the gses have dramatically changed the way banks fund themselves and conduct lending (agea pwc audit reports 2011-2013). the funding “utility” functions performed by the gses for banks and the way they funded themselves were the models for what we refer today to as the wholesale funding market (agea pwc special report 2014). b) the “internal” shadow banking sub-system (interbank payment) the principal drivers of the growth of the european shadow banking system have been the transformation of the largest banks since the early-1990s from low return on equity (roe) utilities that originate loans and hold and fund them until maturity with deposits to high roe entities that originate loans to warehouse and later securitise and distribute them, or retain securitised loans through off-financial statement asset management vehicles (manes rossi, brusca and condor 2020). the transformation of banks occurred within the legal framework of financial holding companies, which through the acquisition of broker-dealers and asset managers, allowed large banks to transform their traditional process of hold-to-maturity, spread-banking to a more profitable process of originate-to-distribute, fee-banking (denichilo 2011). portfolio management started to decide which assets were retained and sold and charged originators (internal and external) the replacement cost of financial statements for warehoused assets. modern banks “rent” their financial statements and set their “rents” based on the replacement cost of their financial statements (agea e&y up grade procedure services 2014). c) the “external” shadow banking sub-system (off-balance sheet) some european banks also practised the mixture of bank and markets-based credit intermediation process that emerged was later adopted by diversified broker-dealers and also turned a range of independent, specialist non-banks into an interconnected network of financial entities that operated entirely external for banks and the official safety net extended to banks, hence the term “external” shadow banking sub-system (agea e&y financial letters 2019). the constant flux in the current business environment has led marketers to focus on applying the agile method, experimentation for shortening cycle time, increasing flexibility, sharper competitiveness, and swift adaptation to market globalisation (asseraf, lages & shoham 2018). businesses must continuously rethink their business model, offering, and processes to stay in tune with the digital transformation characterised by technological progress, digital communication, and shifting customer demand. they must also integrate technology with marketing communication strategies to satisfy customer needs. literature on marketing and strategy has focused on the agility of special reports on the european shadow bank system to address the challenges posed by digital transformation, such as “embrace change”, and predict market needs and innovative, especially in highly competitive and international marketing management scenario, and cater to the needs of international european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/6720 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 14 customers. from this perspective, agility is a firm’s ability to stay up-to-date with market dynamics and accordingly adapt strategies, tactics and operations to rapidly respond to market changes in new business opportunities. in the digital and international context, literature on the agility of special reports on the european shadow bank system in marketing is scarce (barkema, baum & mannix 2002). however, agility in management and marketing literature has recently gained academic attention, where scholars have recognised the role of marketing in shaping agility as a critical driver of international performance. extant literature explores the drivers and outcomes of international marketing agility or that of inherently global firms. in contrast, a few other studies examine the relationship between agility and entrepreneurial orientation or consider customer agility. however, extant knowledge still needs to understand how specifically agile capabilities in marketing might take place when considering international context and what key aspects may contribute to developing a proper agile marketing capability (barrales-molina, martinez-lopez & gazquez-abad 2014) range of performance materiality 110% of pm 130% of pm over 60% of pm level hard medium soft usefulness audit advisory reporting significance of risk: risk materiality high medium low relevance big medium small coverage over in line under general controls: umbrella themes smart and inclusive growth innovative inclusive growth sustainable growth-natural resources agricultural commerce industrial security and citizenship participation collaboration only vote administration labour finance service other exclusive customization unique multilevel cooperation: media pressure legal structural weak application controls: cavr completeness not all all overall accuracy adequacy precision accurate validity flexibility competitiveness adaptation restricted access accessibility timeliness cycle time shadow bank system: a) the government-sponsored utility functions b) the “internal” roe (return on equity) c) the “external” ritual or abuse of right table 1. checklist of internal controls for special reports on european shadow bank system. (objective: 30% – 60% of pm; estimated error > 5% of payments; projected error < 10% of the reported expenditure) source: our elaboration of agea e&y up grade procedure services 2014 4. results to take up the theme of the essay by professor ernesto longobardi and professor antonio pedone, "public debt in the euro area after the crisis: restructuring hypotheses, insolvency proceedings, (weak) prospects for fiscal union", in a. di maio and u. marani (edited by), economic policies and international crisis. for a broader examination of the same theme, see longobardi-pedone and denichilo (2009). among the leading causes of the accumulation of private debt were: the intensity and persistence of severe macroeconomic imbalances within countries and between significant economies; the expansive stance of monetary policies, also justified by a low inflation context, which produced an abundant supply of liquidity and credit; the uncontrolled acceleration of financial european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/6720 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 15 innovation in forms that made distribution and distribution opaque the extent of the risks, to which the transition of banks from the "originate and hold" model to the "originate to distribute" model contributed; under these circumstances, the surge in the default rate on worst-quality mortgages in the united states was the spark which lit a colossal fire, extending to the credit system (with the failure of many banks, until the liquidation of lehman brothers in september 2008) and then to the financial system as a whole international and the global economy. faced with the explosion and spread of the crisis, many governments intervened massively to rescue financial institutions, causing a sharp and rapid surge in the deficit and public debt with european shadow bank systems. so, the automatic effects of the crisis on tax revenues and some expenses contributed to the worsening of public accounts. this study contributes theoretically to the literature on agile and dynamic marketing capabilities of special reports on the european shadow bank system. first, this work advances the field of dynamic marketing capabilities by defining a new capability: the agile marketing capability of the european shadow bank system (tables 2 and 3). application controls general controls prevent, detect, and correct transaction errors and fraud in application programs. they are concerned with the accuracy, completeness, validity and authorization of data captured, stored, transmitted to the other system, and reported. make sure an organization’s control environment is stable and well-managed. examples include security; it infrastructure; and software acquisition, development, and maintenance controls. table 2. dynamic marketing capabilities of internal control source: author’s elaboration internal control assertions evidence of controls test types of internal controls completeness controls to ensure financial transactions and data are completed. control totals and sequencing. manual semi-manual automated accuracy controls to ensure financial transactions and data are accurate. logic tests and checksums. manual semi-manual automated validity controls to ensure financial transactions and data are valid. maintained record trail and electronic signature. manual semi-manual automated restricted access controls to ensure restricted access to data and financial transactions. passwords, asset tags, locks and approval forms. manual semi-manual automated table 3. internal control assertions: cavr source: author’s elaboration second, this study extends the existing theories on the agility to the marketing domain, providing a theoretical framework to study the critical dimensions of the agile marketing capability of the european shadow bank system (table 4). controls of agile marketing capabilities gather evidence of controls continual improvement pace. earlier studies claim supply chain, and it agility continuously detect environmental changes and swiftly respond with innovative solutions, such as redeploying resources and quickly performing tasks. this study finding shows that, when referring to international and digital marketing, ongoing efforts in adopting cutting european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/6720 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 16 edge technology that analyzes market trends, customer behavior, and competition are crucial to providing optimized services and innovative responses to international customer needs. customer-oriented responsiveness. most studies on agility focus on swift responsiveness, that is, to identify and respond to changes in the supply chain, technology, competition, and demand reactively or proactively and recover from them. it facilitates gathering customer information. agility implies more excellent market prediction and customization. the case study confirms the marketing function. the firm can be more responsive to customer demand at a global level by using metrics for measuring customer satisfaction levels, analyzing sentiments across media channels and countries, and generally tracking information and, in turn, offering more customized products. high flexibility. prior studies on agility highlight the relevance of an adaptive approach to competing with speed strategies, redeploying resources flexibly, and managing new or diversified products and objectives with the existing facilities and supply chain. the study results extend the current literature by showing that such flexibility is achieved with flexible planning that places individuals at the center and easily adapts to changing customer requirements. interestingly, the concept of flexibility attempts to pursue simplicity by explicitly providing an easy home searching tool, which makes rental simple, accessible, and adaptable to the different requirements expressed by customers across countries (grewal & tansuhaj 2001). people collaboration. according to the literature, agility suggests collaboration is crucial for achieving a firm’s objectives effectively and efficiently. this is further enhanced by it integration and alignment throughout the supply chain, facilitating information flows. the empirical evidence presented in this study confirms this argument. it demonstrates that collaboration among departments and being open to feedback and advice from others are some of the essential features for global marketing teams that strongly need to foster close and trust-based relationships. in addition, particularly for digital, international business, communication tools throughout the organization are critical to facilitate up-to-date information on achievements and targets and weekly goals across teams and departments for business alignment (hagen, zucchela & ghauri 2018). table 4. agile marketing capabilities assertions of european shadow bank system source: author’s elaboration european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/6720 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 17 in sum (table 4), the study findings support a framework that identifies the critical dimension of agile marketing capability; continual improvement pace, customer-oriented responsiveness, high flexibility, and people collaboration (teece, peteraf, & leih 2016). item weighted average first quartile median third quartile std. dev./ max min max 1 2.33 0.77 2.01 2.31 0.22 0.22 3.33 2 1.33 0.54 1.05 1.34 0.33 0.12 4.35 significance of risk: materiality 3 3.33 1.22 3.34 4.23 0.45 0.15 5.55 4 4.33 1.55 3.77 4.31 0.55 0.11 7.33 5 5.70 2.55 4.77 6.21 0.66 0.05 5.34 general controls: umbrella themes 6 5.33 2.77 3.33 6.33 0.33 0.23 7.22 7 7.29 3.77 4.24 7.22 0.77 0.55 14.51 8 8.29 4.88 5.77 8.22 0.66 0.77 12.44 9 9.10 5.99 6.22 10.02 0.99 1.01 17.9 10 5.22 2.22 3.44 5.21 0.32 0.51 7.22 multilevel cooperation: media pressure 11 7.23 3.79 4.77 8.22 0.67 1.66 12.11 application controls: cavr 12 6.23 1.88 4.56 6.24 0.22 1.77 8.29 13 7.33 3.99 4.55 8.33 0.55 1.88 9.99 14 5.55 1.75 2.77 5.25 0.33 0.55 8.88 15 6.99 3.77 4.88 6.88 0.67 1.57 7.59 table 5. critical dimension of the agile marketing capability. number of observations: 100% of agea debt register practices year 2014 (number of observation 4.887 practices) source: our elaboration of agea e&y up grade procedure services 2014. 4. conclusion the need for an orderly reduction of excessive private and public debt with european shadow bank systems was anticipated by spaventa (2008); on the problems encountered and on the few steps forward made in this area (denichilo 2020b). under the traditional originate-and-hold model, the lending bank retains the credits in its assets and hedges the risk with capital. with the originate-to-distribute model, on the other hand, credit risk is transferred using the most varied and everchanging techniques of securitization and the creation of “derivative” credits (köhler, ratzinger-sakel and theis 2020). however, public debt problems are extraordinary; they are different from the rest of the world's shadow bank systems (buchak, matvos, piskorski and seru 2018). the split between responsibility for money and exchange, assigned to the centre, and that of fiscal and debt policies, which remain on the periphery, deprives sovereign states of an essential piece of their sovereignty, a lender of last resort that provides markets with an implicit debt guarantee. overall error % performance materiality tolerance effective error adjusted error opinion projected error (call) 30% 60% medium risk <10% 1.33% 7.55% accepted estimated error (put) 30% 60% medium risk >5% 6.77% 4.5% rejected european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/6720 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 18 overall consistency test % performance materiality tolerance effective error adjusted error opinion rho di sperman 30% 60% medium risk 5.23% 4.25% 5.25% accepted tau di kendal 30% 60% medium risk 4.33% 5.25% 5.66% rejected internal consistency test % performance materiality tolerance effective error adjusted error opinion likert's interquartile gap test 30% 60% medium risk <2 1.77 1.66 accepted table 6. capability overall conclusion of policy investigations template source: our elaboration of agea e&y up grade procedure services 2014 although the present study provides an initial theoretical and empirical understanding of the agile marketing capability of shadow bank system, it gives managerial insights on developing an agile marketing capability, particularly in digital and international contexts (denichilo 2021a). these insights would help managers and practitioners employ agile features in their marketing strategies and operations (lee, sambamurthy, lim & wei 2015). the study findings provide interesting guidelines for managers and practitioners in implementing agility in the marketing field (ravichardran 2018). the definition of the critical factors of agile marketing capability advances the knowledge of practitioners and international markers on how to implement agile marketing and improve their ability to leverage digital technologies to satisfy their customers in dynamic and global business contexts. although the study findings provide an excellent theoretical and empirical understanding of the agile marketing capability of the european shadow bank system, this research has some limitations that may be addressed in further research (lu & ramamurthy 2011). concerning the methodological perspective, the qualitative data analysis involved only one firm because of the nature of the research. although the study findings may be generalized to a certain degree, exploring this topic in multiple research contexts would be necessary. future research may use this study as a pilot case and increase the viability of the results in order organizational settings. future studies could also develop scales for measuring the agile marketing capability of the european shadow bank system and use survey instruments to validate our findings (rixen 2013). it would be interesting to understand the relationship between the identified dimension and their underlying nature, as well as develop a proper procedure references agea e&y up grade procedure services 2014. agea e&y financial letters 2019. agea pwc audit reports 2011-2013. agea pwc special report 2014. asseraf y., lages l. f. & shoham a. (2018). assessing the drivers and impact of international marketing agility. international marketing review. barkema h.g., baum j.a. & mannix e.a. (2002). management challenges in new time. academy of management journal, 45(5): 916-930. barrales-molina v., martinez-lopez f.j & gazquez-abad j.c. (2014). dynamic marketing capabilities: toward an integrative framework. international journal of management review, 16(4): 397-416. bock a.j., opsahl t., george g. & gann d.m. (2012). the effects of culture and structure on strategic flexibility during business model innovation. journal of management studies, 49(2): 279-305. buchak g., matvos g., piskorski t. and seru a. (2018), fintech, regulatory arbitrage, and the rise of shadow banks, journal of financial economics, vol. 130, issue 3, december 2018, pag. 453-483. caiden n. (1992), public service professionalism for performance measurement and evaluation. public budgeting & finance. chaffey d. (2010). applying organizational capability models to assess the maturity of digital-marketing governance. journal of marketing management, 26(3-4): 187-196. chen y., wang y., nervo s., benitez-amado j. & kou g. (2015). it capabilities and product innovation performance: the roles of corporate entrepreneurship and competitive intensity. information & management, 52(6): 643-657. colella a., griffin a. e. c., gaparaju s. (2000), newcomer and organizational socialization tactis: an interactionist perspective. cortese g., del carlo a. (2008), “la selezione del personale. dalla ricerca all’inserimento in azienda: come scegliere il candidato migliore”, raffaello cortina editore, milano, 2008. denichilo n. (2013), le metodologie innovative di reclutamento. tesi magistrale università degli studi roma tre. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/6720 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 19 denichilo s., pedone a. (2009), the efficiency of the tax systems in europe. working paper edit università degli studi la sapienza di roma. denichilo s., regogliosi c. (2011), l’internal auditing in un organismo di diritto pubblico: il caso agea. working paper edit università degli studi roma tre. denichilo s. (2020a), public choice in european affairs: measuring election model. european journal of social impact and circular economy pp 19-37. published by university of turin. denichilo, s. (2020b). shadow bank system in european affairs: measuring capability. presentation discussed paper at european association for banking and financial law. thematic purposed by bankitalia eurosistema “what to regulate? how to regulate? who should regulate?” november 2020 milan. denichilo s. (2020c), how do earnings management practices distract international environmental funds? empirical evidence of european development funds in italy. geoprogress journal vol.7, i. 1, 2020. pag. 87-101. denichilo s. (2021a), management accounting in european finance for smart tourism and sustainable destination: how organizations deficiency? pp 45-74. published by university of turin. http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index. denichilo s. (2021b), management accounting in european affairs: a memorandum methodology for formalize audit evidence. corporate governance and research & development studies 1/2021. doi: http://dx.doi.org/10.3280/cgrds1-2021oa10445. denichilo s. (2022), how to resolve audit matters in european affairs? introduction to a sustainable management accounting under ias 37. pp 27-42. published by university of turin. http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index. eckstein d., goellner m., blome c. & henke m. (2015). the performance impact of supply chain agility and supply chain adaptability: the moderating effect of product complexity. international journal of production research, 53(10): 3028-3046. ellinas a. & suleiman e. (2008), the reforming the commission: between modernization and bureaucratization, journal of european public policy. grewal r. & tansuhaj p. (2001). building organizational capabilities for managing economic crisis: the role of market orientation and strategic flexibility. journal of marketing 65(2): 67-80. hagen b., zucchela a. & ghauri p.n. (2018). from fragile to agile: marketing as a key driver of entrepreneurial internationalization. international marketing review. harber m., marx b. and de jager p. (2020), the perceived financial effects of mandatory audit firm rotation. journal of international financial management and accounting. homer j. and stephenson p. (2012), theoretical perspectives on approaches to policy evaluation in the eu: the case of cohesion policy in public administration. lee o.k., sambamurthy v., lim k.h. & wei k.k. (2015). how does it ambidexterity impact organizational agility? information systems research 26(2): 398-417. lu y. & ramamurthy k. (2011). understanding the link between information technology capability and organizational agility: an empirical examination. mis quarterly, 931-954. knill c., balint t. & bauer m.w. (2008), study on behalf of the european parliament. reform of european congress 2008. köhler a., ratzinger-sakel n. and theis j. (2020), the effects of key audit matters on the auditor's report's communicative value: experimental evidence from investment professionals and non-professional investors. accounting in europe. manes rossi f., brusca i. and condor v. (2020), in the pursuit of harmonization: comparing the audit systems of european local governments. public money & management. march j.g. and olsen j.p. (1995), democratic governance. mendez c., bactler j. (2011) administrative reform and unintended consequences: an assessment of the eu cohesion policy audit explosion. journal of european public policy. power m. (with yves gendron) (2015), qualitative research in auditing: a methodological roadmap. auditing: a journal of practice and theory (2015) 34(2): 147-165. ravichardran t. (2018). exploring the relationship between it competence, innovation capacity and organizational agility. journal of strategic information system, 27(1): 22-42. rolle l. (2010), “ risorse umane e benchmarking. prassi eccellenti in aziende innovative”, franco angeli, milano, 2010. rixen t. (2013), why reregulation after the crisis is feeble: shadow banking, offshore financial centers, and jurisdictional competition, regulation and governance, vol. 7, issue 4, december 2013, pages 435-459. spaventa l. (2008), una crisi della nuova finanza. giuffrè editore. sposato p. (2010), “valutazione e selezione del personale. come scegliere e valorizzare il tuo staff ideale.”, bruno editore, roma, 2010. teece d., peteraf m., & leih s. (2016). dynamic capabilities and organizational agility: risk, uncertainty, and strategy in the innovation economy. california management review, 58(4): 13-35. van der meer f. and edelebos j. (2006), “evaluation in multi-actor policy process: accountability, learning and cooperation” in evaluation. van wolleghem p.g. (2020), does administrative capacity matter? the absorption of the european fund for the integration of migrants. policy studies. 5058-article text-17220-1-9-20210223 european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5058 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 100 barangay governance in northeast of catanduanes, philippines: basis for catanduanes state university panganiban campus extension program jaymund marino floranza1, 1 catanduanes state university panganiban campus e-mail: jmfloranza@up.edu.ph received: 19/08/2020 revised: 17/01/2021 accepted for publication: 26/01/2021 published: 08/03/2021 abstract governance is an act or a process of governing with power and performing the duties and functions within one's jurisdiction. barangay governance gives an important role in setting direction to the people in the barangay level. it is an empowerment of the local government units in the country where this present study is interested. this quantitative-qualitative research study intended to look into the barangay governance capabilities among barangay captains in northeast of catanduanes, philippines as basis for catanduanes state university panganiban campus extension program. the data gathered through the questionnaire and interview guide concluded that the respondent-barangay officials in northeast of catanduanes are in the middle age, male, college level in educational attainment, barangay council members and a neophyte in barangay governance having served for three years and below as barangay officials. the indicators of governance revealed that barangay captains are more equipped with barangay fiscal administration than in legislative and judicial functions. the unstructured interview about the problems regarding the governance capabilities of barangay captains reveals the incompetence of the barangay captains, the non-cooperation of the residents or the constituents themselves, and the non-cooperative barangay kagawad that genuinely affects the capability of the barangay european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5058 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 101 captain. given the situation, the study recommends that barangay officials, particularly the barangay captains, are enjoined to attend barangay governance capability training seminar. intensive monitoring and assessment of their barangay performance should be done regularly. a proposed training package will be carried out where all catanduanes state university panganiban campus faculty-extensionists will be involved. keywords: barangay governance competency; barangay officials; local governance; local government code of 1991 ____________________________________________________________________ 1. introduction in the broadest sense, governance is an act governing with power and exercise of authority within one’s jurisdiction (boysillo 2017; aquino et al. 2017). governance is a process of administering with authoritative direction or control (boysillo 2017). it is also a leader’s continuous exercise of authority and performs functions as a government unit. in a specific sense, barangay governance sets directions to the people in the barangay level. it is empowering local government units (lgus), particularly in the barangay level, where this present study is focused. in the philippine setting, the barangay is the least political and yet significant political figure in the community (flores 2019). it is more inclusive and participatory rather than exclusive barangay governance (shore 2011). one introduced a connection with the concept of good governance and decentralization in the light of connected thoughts and theories. the idea of ‘governance’ to ‘good governance’ to ‘local government’ is based on the socio-economic and the socio-political context (nadeem 2016). another author concludes the concept of networked governance that promotes democratization while establishing allied power (porio 2012). european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5058 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 102 in the same manner, the commission on higher education memorandum order no. 52, series of 2016 states that the philippine higher education institutions are mandated to engage in extension programs to allow faculty members discover practical, evidence, and science-based answers that can address real-world social, cost-effective, and environmental challenges of partner communities. the concepts of governance at the barangay level and community outreach programs of higher education institutions both required partnerships and, therefore, this research is abstracted. the product of this research will be used as a basis for the catanduanes state university panganiban campus (catsu pc) extension program activities and rerouting its priorities. community outreach programs are a way to express a deep sense of responsibility of the faculty members in higher education institutions (heis). the faculty members are more knowledgeable and highly skilled than those in the community sectors. through the extension program activities, they are not only delivering academic matters but also performing community service (rubio et al. 2016). thus, the present study is significant. the study identified the barangay governance in northeast of catanduanes, philippines as the basis for catsu pc extension program. this research specifically presented the respondentbarangay officials profile in northeast of catanduanes in terms of age; sex; educational attainment; position in the barangay and number of years as barangay official. it determined the respondent-barangay officials' perception in northeast of catanduanes regarding their barangay captain's governance capabilities in terms of legislation; program/project implementation; barangay justice system; barangay fiscal administration. it further ascertained the problems do the respondent-barangay officials considered that affect the barangay governance capabilities of the barangay captain; and the significant difference in the summary responses of the respondent-barangay officials in northeast of catanduanes regarding their barangay captain's governance capabilities in terms of their position in the barangay. based on the findings, a three-year extension program can be proposed to enhance barangay governance capabilities among barangay captains in northeast of catanduanes. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5058 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 103 2. literature review the legislation of the philippine republic act (ra) 7160, which recognized as the local government code (lgc) of 1991, transformed many of the laws and regulations governing national down to barangay units by decentralizing many of the tasks previously performed by the central government. the philippines has a comprehensive decentralization in governance. that includes a high amount of discretion among barangay officials leading to ineffectiveness in local management (yilmaz & venugopal 2013). the inability to deliver better essential services in the barangay is also evident (layug et al. 2010). the barangay units perform as the principal authority in developing and implementing government guidelines, plans, programs, projects, and activities. however, to fulfill the barangays’ mandates confined in the lgc, the punong barangays must be prepared with the necessary capabilities. they should observe not only the orders but also practice morally upright actions. one argued that competency measures of the local barangay officials are monitored rarely (caldo 2015). in some cases, it is evaluated subjectively through intuitions and their impressions and feeling to the barangay officials, and therefore this process is not helpful to the elected barangay officials. at the same time, capuno (2005) said to formalize simple yet realistic citizen-feedback systems to let clients express their agreement or disagreement with barangay officials’ quality of service without fear and with the guarantee to address the issues of concern. the self-assessed survey tool for barangay officials suggests identifying performance gaps. that includes administration, social services, economic development, and environmental management. the issues posed in the present study may awaken awareness and commitment to perform duties and functions expected to the barangay officials (medina-guce et al. 2018). their political ideals and governing procedures is a significant indication of active local community building (nalbandian et al. (2013). the community development depends on the capability of leaders at the national level and, more particularly, on lgu to the lowest political unit of governance, which is the barangay. it is then essential that we look at the barangay level’s leadership aspect through the barangay captains. the european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5058 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 104 formulation of an intervention mechanism reveals a significant concern for good governance (nalbandian et al. 2013). there also suggests creating additional funding in barangays considering minimal budget allotment (medina-guce et al. 2018) that may help the kind of governance and performance of the barangay officials’ duties. the study on the development of barangay legislators’ leadership scale in davao city determined that to become a good leader, one should set directions on good and personal qualities and primary values (padilla & eguia 2010). further, studies revealed that the punong barangays have a satisfactory performance level in implementation, legislation, peacekeeping, planning, and fiscal management (noble-nur 2018) and “very competent” in barangay governance. nevertheless, the respondents identified the community residents’ lack of planning and decision-making as one of the significant problems that affected good governance (noble-nur 2018). another study on barangay governance concluded that the majority of the barangay chairpersons deliver very satisfactory public services in their barangays, which indicated that governance core values are being fair, transparent, and accountable (boysillo 2017). one proposed that the local officials stay self-reflective or aware of their accountabilities in the barangay to maintain barangay governance (nalbandian et al. 2013) to provide vital services and increase the excellence of their capability to render community services (flores 2019). the different contentions of the authors mentioned guided the discussion of the present study. yet, they are challenged further to increase their impact on other local and international academic communities through information dissemination for an effective research output. 3. theoretical framework this present study anchor on constructivism theory and human capital theory to further discuss barangay governance. constructivism is a knowledge theory that originated in the field of psychology, explaining how individuals obtain knowledge and learn from it. it involves a european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5058 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 105 participatory process, contemplation, deliberation, collaboration as a way of discoveries, and learning (yoders 2014). the theory indicates that individuals build knowledge and their meaning based on experiences. while human capital theory implies that people compensate human capital ventures through excellence in intelligence and skills of the labor force. productivity enhancement among the labor force serves as an essential part of economic development (zeynalli 2020). the lack of skilled human resources is one of the main obstacles for the social entrepreneurs’ development yet they could create positive social impact to ensure profit despite the lack of managerial skills (urmanaviciene & arachchi 2020) with the given context, constructivism theory; and human capital theory harmonizes with the problems posed by the present paper since the respondents-barangay-officials are considered human capital who are always learning through their experiences and enhances their barangay governance capabilities. 4. methods 4.1 nature of research this study used a quantitative-qualitative type of research intended to look into the barangay governance capabilities among barangay captains in northeast of catanduanes, philippines. this investigation is quantitative since it collects, analyzes, and interprets the present phenomena while qualitative because it collects and reports data that differs from traditional-quantitative methods. this study is also a descriptive type of research since it describes the honest responses of the respondent-barangay officials about barangay governance indicated in the questionnaire that depended much on the correctness of the gathered data. 4.2 research the northeast of the island province comprises the municipalities of bagamanoc, panganiban, and viga in catanduanes, philippines. it is roughly 63 kilometers away from the municipality of virac, catanduanes that is considered as the principal town or city-to-be of the province. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5058 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 106 4.3 sampling design the word 'population' refers to an assembly of people, events, or things of interest that the researcher wants to examine or investigate. in the present study, this considers the barangay officials of the northeast of catanduanes. moreover, it is presented in table 1 the 73 respondentbarangay officials from bagamanoc; 82 respondents from panganiban; and 118 respondentbarangay officials from viga, catanduanes. there are 273 respondent-barangay officials from the northeast of catanduanes, or 38.61% participation. table 1. population of the study source: developed by the author there were two sampling techniques used in the study; the quota sampling and complete enumeration. the quota sampling was applied to identify the barangay councilor's sample size, while for the barangay captain, barangay secretary, and barangay treasurer, a complete enumeration, was used since there are only one of them for each of the barangay. the quota sampling is considered a non-probability method that aims to make the sample representative of the population by setting and filling quota control. this researcher found the most appropriate procedure in determining the respondent-barangay councilor in the barangays of the three municipalities of the northeast of catanduanes. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5058 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 107 4.4 survey instrument the study's primary instrument is a set of researcher-made questionnaires formulated to gather data to answer the research questions posed in this inquiry. the part-i of the questionnaire is the profile of the respondents that includes the name of the respondent-barangay officials, the barangay; age; sex; educational attainment; position in the barangay; and the number of years as barangay the official that includes their previous term/s). the part-ii of the questionnaire are the 16-item barangay governance indicators categorized into legislation; program/project implementation; barangay justice system; and barangay fiscal administration. the study used the five-point likert scale in determining the barangay governance capabilities are raging from fully capable of not capable. part iii of the instrument is an open-ended question about the problems the respondents they considered that affects the barangay governance capabilities of the barangay captain done in a semi-structured interview. the instrument was shown to former barangay officials to solicit comments and suggestions along with barangay governance indicators that made the questionnaire to be revised and improved. with the establishment of the questionnaire's validity, the researcher ensures clarity, completeness, and acceptability of the instrument using a comprehensive and realistic formulation of items/statements included in the questionnaire. to establish the instrument's reliability, this researcher got 0.96 cronbach's alpha coefficient from the 16-item questionnaire, and therefore, the research instrument was considered "reliable." the researcher first sought approval from the office of the mayor of the three (3) municipalities before floating the questionnaires to the respondents. upon the mayors' support, the float of the questionnaire has been administered to the targeted respondents in the third quarter of 2019. 4.5 ethical considerations the respondents are fully informed and free to participate in the conduct of research. ethical considerations for human participants were strictly followed (gajjar 2013). the study did not include respondents-barangay officials who refused to participate during the data gathering. duly signed informed consent form was obtained individually for every respondents-barangay european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5058 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 108 officials. the study observed the utmost confidentiality of the gathered data. only this facultyresearcher has access to the collected data to ensure data privacy. 4.6 statistical treatment in computing the replies, a five-point likert scale was used. every answer was given value and was tallied through frequency count to determine the degree of capability of the barangay officials in barangay governance. the anova f-test was used as statistical tool to test the significant difference in the summary responses of the respondent-barangay officials in northeast of catanduanes regarding their barangay captain’s governance capabilities in terms of their position in the barangay. 5. results and discussion 5.1 respondents table 2 shows that most of the respondents were aged ranged from 36 to 50 years old. in terms of their sex, the male is higher in figure than female. in terms of educational attainment, most of them are at the college level. in terms of position in the barangay, most of the respondents are the barangay council three years and below as barangay officials. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5058 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 109 table 2: profile of the respondent-barangay officials in northeast of catanduanes source: developed by the author figure 1 presents the bar-graph view of the barangay captain’s governance capabilities to show that the barangay captains are fairly capable (in higher degree’) in ‘barangay fiscal administration’ while fairly capable (in lower degree’) in ‘legislations’ in barangay governance. given this finding, it generally shows that the respondent-barangay officials can still initiate, establish, disseminate, and implement barangay ordinances, but the struggle to discharge their duty along with legislation. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5058 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 110 figure 1: over-all barangay captain’s governance capabilities source: developed by the author table 3.1. the perception of the respondent-barangay officials in northeast of catanduanes regarding their barangay captain’s governance capabilities (a) legislation source: developed by the author table 3.1 presents the perception of the 273-respondent-barangay officials in northeast of catanduanes regarding their barangay captain’s governance capabilities in terms of legislation. all four statements have the same average response (avr) of 4.25 and qualitative response (qlr) of fairly capable and they are: (1) initiates the implementation of barangay ordinances; (2) establishes barangay policies for better community development; (3) disseminates properly barangay ordinances; and (4) implements fairly barangay ordinances. 4,15 4,2 4,25 4,3 4,35 4,4 4,45 le gis lat ion progra m/p rojec t… bara nga y j usti ce sy ste m bara nga y f isc al… (1 ) n o t ca pa bl e ï ð fu ll y ca pa bl e (5 ) barangay governance capability indicators european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5058 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 111 in terms of program/project implementation (table 3.2), among the 4-item statements, the following three (3) statement garnered avr of 4.40 and they are also presented with their corresponding item number before the number indicated in the questionnaire: (5) encourages the community residents to participate in planning activities of the barangay; (6) monitors and evaluate the implementations of programs and activities in the barangay; (7) participates and represents the barangay in the municipal level activities while the item statement (8) consults the community residents in decision making and other barangay undertakings got the lowest avr of 4.10 with a qlr of fairly capable. table 3.2. the perception of the respondent-barangay officials in northeast of catanduanes regarding their barangay captain’s governance capabilities (b) program/project implementation source: developed by the author given the findings, the research data shows that the barangay captains find difficulty in involving the community residents in decision making and other barangay undertakings which following aquino et al. (2017) study revealing that the punong barangay is “not competent” in encouraging the community residents to participate in planning activities of the barangay and do not encourage the participation of the community residents in decision-making. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5058 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 112 the given finding is challenged by ur rehman et al. (2020) arguing that sustainable development that is mainly influenced by the organizational hierarchy internal polices and strategies and their operational implementation that is purely dependent on the top management. if the barangay captain manifests lack of skills along project implementation particularly involving the community in decision making and any other barangay undertaking, sustainable development may be difficult to achieve in the barangay level. table 3.3. the perception of the respondent-barangay officials in northeast of catanduanes regarding their barangay captain’s governance capabilities (c) barangay justice system source: developed by the author moreover, in table 3.3 which in terms of barangay justice system, given the 4-item statements, they all garnered a qlr of fairly capable and are presented below arranging from highest to lowest avr with their corresponding item number before the number indicated in the questionnaire: (11) shows good leadership in the implementation of barangay justice system. (4.42); (12) observe neutrality in settling conflicts. (4.29); (10) keeps himself available when conflicts arise in the community. (4.25); (9) settles conflict among community residents. (4.24). given the findings, the research data shows that the barangay captains are fairly capable in their discharge of duty along with the barangay justice system and are considered to possess good leadership in its implementation. as labawig (2011) and padilla and eguia (2010) argued also european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5058 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 113 that the development depends on the capability of leaders and barangay leaders must be monitored to ensure that proper leadership skills are being impost and exercised not only in the justice system but also in other aspects of barangay governance. table 3.4. the perception of the respondent-barangay officials in northeast of catanduanes regarding their barangay captain’s governance capabilities (d) barangay fiscal administration source: developed by the author ultimately, in table 3.4 which in terms of barangay fiscal administration, given the 4-item statements, they all garnered too a qlr of fairly capable and are presented below arranging from highest to lowest avr with their corresponding item number before the number indicated in the questionnaire: (13) shows accountability in allocating the barangay budget. (4.49); (14) observe transparency in public fund disbursement. (4.45); (15) apportions budget efficiently based on the needs of the community. (4.41); (16) implements tax collection/revenue raising as sourcing fund for the development of the barangay. (4.27). with the findings, it proves generally that the barangay captains are fairly capable in their discharge of duty along with barangay fiscal administration. and their strengths are being manifested in being accountable in budget allocation and transparency observance while their weakness is on the implementation of tax collection and/or revenues. the statement ‘implements tax collection/revenue raising as sourcing fund for the development of the barangay.’ that garnered the lowest ar among other statements on european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5058 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 114 barangay fiscal administration indicates the constraints of the barangay officials is obtaining money to support the programs and activities in the barangay. this finding aggravates incapability of the barangay captains in their discharge of duties as divulged in the interview since how are the programs and activities if they lack budget which is also the same with the contentions of guce et al. (2018) and boysillo (2017) papers saying that barangays lack funds because of not raising enough own-source revenues in their localities and improving their use of corporate powers. de nichilo (2020) reveals the issues of budgetary constraints that may affect future policies and thus suggests budgetary operations that follows a clear logic of decision-making, research, analysis, drafting and reporting. policy-makers may focus on issues of performance in audit and financial issues to support the programs in a certain organization. and with this finding of the present study that the barangay officials are ineffective with the implementation of tax collection and/or revenues, the challenge of de nichilo (2020) and the suggestions of guce et al. (2018) may be considered. the collection of barangay fees and taxes that may be implemented on the use of barangay properties and facilities; peddlers; breeding of fighting cocks; use of barangay roads, waterways, bridges, and parks; parking; clearance/certification; fines/penalties for violation of barangay ordinances and among other fees may be imposed such as commercial breeding of fighting cocks and on cockpits and cockfights; places of recreation with admission fees; billboards, signboards, neon signs and other outdoor advertisements and among other fees. in summary, the present study discovered that the barangay captain's governance capabilities is 'fairly capable' is substantiated by noble-nur study (2018), revealing that the punong barangays have a satisfactory level of performance in areas of implementation, legislation, peacekeeping, planning, and fiscal management. the study of boysillo (2017) entitled governance of the barangay chairpersons in the municipality of ubay bohol revealed that the barangay chairmen's level of performance of governance on the three indicators namely the executive functions, legislative functions, and judicial functions indicated that the majority of the 44 barangay chairpersons were able to deliver a very satisfactory public service in their barangays. hence they were able to cope up with all the roles and responsibilities. however, when the weighted mean of european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5058 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 115 the responses was looked into, among the three functions, the legislative and judicial functions are lower than the executive function. the reactions may infer that the barangay officials themselves need to capacitate in legislative and judicial functions, following the present finding that among the indicators of barangay governance capabilities, 'legislation' is the lowest weighted mean, among other signs. the general finding of the present study that the barangay captain's governance capabilities are 'fairly capable.' the given finding was validated through unstructured interview among the subordinates of the barangay captains i.e. barangay kagawad, barangay secretary, and treasurer. generally, they claimed that their barangay captains are capable of barangay governance, which is actually in conformity with the quantitative data gathered by this researcher. however, when the researcher asked them what problems do they considered that affects the barangay governance capabilities of the barangay captain, three themes appeared in the common responses presented below: the first theme is related to the incompetence aspect of the barangay captain. other barangay officials and selected constituents verbalized the following comments: 'inadequate knowledge about the ordinances'; 'lack of pieces of training.'; 'not firm in the decision-making.'; 'favoritism'; 'lack of technical knowledge.'; 'family problem'; 'barangay captain does not listen to suggestions'; 'the barangay captain does not agree with the suggestions or proposals of constituents'; 'lack of education'; 'political party affiliation.'; 'lack of training and expertise.'; 'lack of knowledge / not correctly oriented.'; 'not capable.'; 'focus on the next election.'; 'disrespectful to the barangay kagawad.'; 'mismanagement'; 'lack of capabilities'; 'barangay captain – no action'; 'miscommunication….do not follow official protocol in communication…using the verbal mode of communication in the conduct of special meeting'; 'lack of proper communication and making decisions on her own without consultation with the barangay officials.'; 'poor communication by not following steps and processes'; 'do not care about the works in the barangay.'; 'barangay captain is not a resident in the barangay of his jurisdiction'; and 'lack of budget.' european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5058 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 116 the second theme is about non-cooperation of the residents or the constituents themselves, and most of the respondents mentioned the following observations: -'no cooperation among community residents to participate in the planning activities of the barangay.'; 'less cooperation of the constituents'; 'constituent lack of interest to participate.'; ‘lack of participation of the constituents in the planning activities'; 'lack of community participation.'; 'residents do not follow the rules and regulations'; 'negative thinking, constituent.'; 'constituent negative attitude.'; 'barangay constituents do not follow barangay ordinances.'; 'hard-headed constituents' and 'constituents are not concerned with the welfare of the barangay.' the third theme identified was being a non-cooperative barangay kagawad aspect that affects the capability of the barangay captain. the respondents mentioned the following remarks: -'barangay kagawad are disrespectful to the barangay captain --they have no plan during the meeting.'; 'lack of awareness of the barangay ordinances'; 'lack of quorum'; 'no unity between and among barangay officials and residents'; 'lack of discipline.'; 'lack of education'; 'poor cooperation. the barangay has excellent programs for the welfare of the barangay as a body. but the punong barangay cannot carry out all the implementation process due to lack of cooperation by other members of the sanguniang bayan'; and 'some barangay kagawad members are not participating in the barangay activities.' from the ideas shared by the barangay kagawad, barangay secretary and treasurer-respondents on their perception of the governance capability of barangay captains. particularly the factors that affect their governance capability, it can be deduced that truly barangay captain is relatively capable in barangay governance considering the quantitative data yet with the qualitative data established from the statements mentioned above hinders the barangay captains' capability in governing the barangay. we can genuinely conclude that the different themes discussed above, such as the incompetence aspects of the barangay captain; the non-cooperation of the residents; and the noncooperative barangay kagawad aspect truly affect the efficiency and effectiveness in the discharge of duties and functions of the barangay captains. the above discussions that are attested by medina-guce et al. (2018), padilla and eguia (2010) on the argument that monitoring european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5058 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 117 and assessment of barangay officials may maximize the potentials of local officials in collaboration with the various groups or organizations to addresses the different concerns in the barangay that impedes the performance of the barangay officials. the idea of positive role expectations to the general public is quite unclear, resulting in passive and non-cooperative residents and inactive barangay officials are participating in barangay concerns and activities. the research of padilla and eguia (2010) on the development of barangay legislators' leadership scale in davao city determined the appropriate leadership scale. these are the setting directions, qualities, personal qualities, full scanner, and primary values that the local government should take concrete actions to develop and establish a continuing professional leadership education program for barangay councils to cope with increasingly complex demands of the environment and other constraints within their barangays. with these arguments, the barangay officials' ineffectiveness and inefficiency, particularly the barangay captain mentioned above, may be considered to address the present study's issues. therefore, the over-all barangay captain's governance capabilities that is 'fairly capable rests on perceptions of the barangay officials themselves because, in reality, all the limitations and inefficiencies of the barangay captains revealed in the interview, as mentioned above. a bar-graph view in figure 2 shows how confident the barangay captains about their governance capabilities while other barangay officials show fairly capabilities of their barangay captains' governance. given these findings, it generally indicates that the respondent-barangay officials proved the difference in perception-rating since it manifests self-confidence on the barangay captains' part about their 'full capabilities' in barangay governance. in contrast, other barangay officials show 'fair capabilities' of their perception of their barangay captains' barangay governance. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5058 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 118 figure 2 presents the barangay captain's governance capabilities as perceived by different barangay officials. source: developed by the author table 4. test of significant difference in the summary responses of the respondent-barangay officials regarding their barangay captain’s governance capabilities in terms of their position in the barangay source: developed by the author utilizing anova f-test in table 4, it proved that there is a significant difference in the summary responses of the respondent-barangay officials in northeast of catanduanes regarding 3,8 3,9 4 4,1 4,2 4,3 4,4 4,5 4,6 4,7 barangay captain (n=52) barangay council member (n=122) barangay secretary (n=52) barangay treasurer (n=47) (1 ) n o t ca pa bl e ï ð fu ll y ca pa bl e (5 ) positions in the barangay legislation program/project implementation barangay justice system barangay fiscal administration european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5058 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 119 their barangay captain's governance capabilities in terms of their position in the barangay given the f (3, 60) = 33.32, p≈0. the data demonstrates the difference of the perception-rating of the respondent-barangay officials since it manifests confidence of the barangay captains about their fully capabilities in barangay governance. in contrast, other barangay officials show the fair capabilities of their barangay captains' barangay governance. this finding aligns with caldo (2015) paper that revealed that selected respondents are uncertain of their punong barangay competence. the research data may infer that the barangay officials except for the barangay captain themselves are also hesitant about their respective barangay captain's ability. 6. conclusion and recommendation the outcomes of the baseline information study revealed that the barangay captains are relatively capable in barangay governance. furthermore, looking at the indicators of governance, barangay captains showed that they are more equipped with barangay fiscal administration than in legislative and judicial functions; hence they needed to be capacitated in the weak areas of their governance. the responses according to the type of respondents revealed differences, showing the confidence of the barangay captains about their full capabilities in barangay governance. in contrast, the rest of the barangay officials demonstrated the perception of being fair capabilities of their barangay captains' barangay governance. with the different results, the study further validated through an unstructured interview among the barangay kagawad, barangay secretaries and treasurers with an open-ended question about the problems they encountered on their respective barangay captains' governance capabilities. it arrived with the three common themes revealing the incompetence of the barangay captains; the non-cooperation of the residents or the constituents themselves; and the non-cooperative barangay kagawad that genuinely affects the capability of the barangay captain. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5058 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 120 given the situation, the study recommends that all barangay officials, particularly the barangay captains, are urged to attend barangay governance capability training program and seminar to improve and enrich their barangay governance capability skills and strategies. intensive monitoring and assessment of their barangay performance may be regularly to awaken their awareness and commitment to perform their duties and functions expected of them is also considered. the study may find a proposed training package where all catanduanes state university panganiban campus faculty-extensionists will be involved in the extension services program. the programs and activities geared towards strengthening more their barangay governance capability skills and strategies. the results of this study will be presented in a research fora, be discussed with all concerned for information purposes, and published for widest dissemination. lastly, the conducted extension-based research in the future is in line with the programs of the catanduanes state university – panganiban campus, such as bachelor of elementary education, bachelor of technical and vocational teacher education, and bachelor of science in agriculture. further, future researchers may consider research-based extension programs that the community needed. this study has limitations: first, the interpretations of the gathered data rely purely on the answers of the respondents in the questionnaire, where this writer relies on their honest replies. second, the present study results may not be generalized in provincial or regional levels because it only represents the three municipalities of catanduanes i.e. viga, panganiban, and bagamanoc. in future research, this writer will consider specific aspects of barangay governance, specifically on education and literacy aspects, in the barangay level since the faculty extensionists are experts in education. conflicts of interest this researcher declares no conflict of interest in this manuscript. fund this writer personally funded the research. no internal or external funding agencies financed the study. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5058 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 121 references aquino, i. p., agustin, c. p., & guadamor, m. l. (2017). competencies of punong barangay for good governance: an assessment. international journal of advanced research in management and social sciences, 6(5), 102-117. boysillo, s. l. (2017) governance of the barangay chairpersons in the municipality of ubay bohol. international journal of business and management studies, 9(1), 50-63. caldo, r. b. (2015). assessment of competency measures of barangay council in san jose, sto. tomas, batangas. capuno, j. j. (2005). the quality of local governance and development under decentralization in the philippines (no. 2005, 06). upse discussion paper. de nichilo, s. (2020). public choice in european affairs: measuring election model.european journal of social impact and circular economy,1(1b), 19-37. https://doi.org/10.13135/27049906/4608 flores, r. r. (2019). assessment of selected barangays in makati city towards improved barangay governance. in iapa proceedings conference (pp. 141-167). gajjar, d. (2013). ethical consideration in research. education, 2(7), 8-15. labawig, m. c. (2011) leadership effectiveness of barangay captains: its implication to barangay development, unpublished thesis, saint louis university, baguio city layug, a. s., pantig, i. d. m. t., bolong, l. e., & lavado, r. f. (2010). do barangays really matter in local services delivery?: some issues and policy options. philippine institute for development studies. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5058 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 122 medina-guce, c., galindes, a. m., salanga, v., & sanders, r. (2018). problematizing the strengthening of philippine democratic institutions. nadeem, m. (2016). analyzing good governance and decentralization in developing countries. journal of political sciences and public affairs, 4(3), 209-220. nalbandian, j., o'neill jr, r., michael wilkes, j., & kaufman, a. (2013). contemporary challenges in local government: evolving roles and responsibilities, structures, and processes. public administration review, 73(4), 567-574. noble-nur, v. (2018). socio-demographic profile and performance of women punong barangays in selected municipalities of maguindanao. in international conference on responsive education and socio-economic transformation (icreset). padilla, c. b. t., & eguia, r. e. (2010). leadership scale of barangay legislators in davao city: an application of structural equation model. 11th national convention on statistics (ncs), october. porio, e. (2012). decentralisation, power and networked governance practices in metro manila. space and polity, 16(1), 7-27. rubio, j. a. m. a., pentinio, c. v. p., ascan, j. c., mendoza, m. c. d., vito, j. v., & encio, h. a. (2016). involvement in community extension program of business administration students in one higher education institution in the philippines. asia pacific journal of multidisciplinary research, 4(1), 109-122. shore, c. (2011). ‘european governance’ or governmentality? the european commission and the future of democratic government. european law journal, 17(3), 287-303. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5058 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 123 urmanaviciene, a., & arachchi, u. (2020). the effective methods and practices for accelerating social entrepreneurship through corporate social responsibility. european journal of social impact and circular economy, 1(2), 27-47. https://doi.org/10.13135/2704-9906/5085 ur rehman, u., shafiq, m., ali, h., & abdullah, m. (2020). green and sustainable construction practices impact on organizational development. european journal of social impact and circular economy, 1(2), 1-26. https://doi.org/10.13135/2704-9906/5068 viray, j. r. followership modalities and big five factor personality dimensions of local (barangay) government officials of sta. mesa, manila. yilmaz, s., & venugopal, v. (2013). local government discretion and accountability in philippines. journal of international development, 25(2), 227-250 yoders, s. (2014). constructivism theory and use from 21 st century perspective. journal of applied learning technology, 4(3). zeynalli, l. (2020). the impact of stimulating the development of human capital on economic development. european journal of social impact and circular economy, 1(1b), 38-52. https://doi.org/10.13135/2704-9906/4562 02 european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5593 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 15 changing the orientation of youths towards street hawking in ibadan, nigeria ahmed olaitan adebisi1 and joseph omoniyi basorun2 1 federal university of technology, department of urban and regional planning akure, nigeria. e-mail: adebisiurp120385@futa.edu.ng 2 federal university of technology, department of urban and regional planning akure, nigeria. e-mail: jobasorun@futa.edu.ng received: 08/02/2021 accepted for publication: 03/11/2021 published: 12/11/2021 abstract despite the vital role of street hawking in the livelihoods of youths in a recessed economy, its adverse implications on urban space and social well-being of the youths are too critical to overlook. this study, therefore, examines the implication of street hawking and its causal factors among youths in sango-ojoo axis of ibadan. the study was a descriptive survey among 37 youths who were randomly sampled at potential hawking terminals. data was collected through the use of multiple-choice questionnaires, and interview guide, while chi-square test was used in data analysis. findings revealed a preponderance of female youth hawkers and poor education was the major causal factor of hawking amongst the youths. the study further established a relationship between street hawking and vulnerability to shocks. the paper recommends sustainable policy through quality and affordable education to the poor, empowerment programme and habitual campaign on the dangers of street hawking. keywords: street hawking; social impact; youth, ibadan; nigeria 1. introduction in most parts of the world, youths constitute the largest visible group of the unemployed; a clear illustration of their disadvantaged position in the labour market. unemployment rate in the developing countries is generally high and this is the main reason why many people start their working lives in the informal sector. globally, three out of four employed youths are in informal employment, compared to three in five for adults. this ratio is as high as 19 out of 20 for young women and men in developing countries (ilo, 2017). in this study, a youth is any person between the ages of 15 and 24 years as defined by united nations (un), united nation children’s international emergency fund (unicef), international labour organization (ilo) and world bank, without prejudice to other definitions by member states. (un, 2014). in a bid to escape poverty, many youths migrate to cities to look for better opportunities. such movement from rural to urban area is inevitable and even desirable as a way to improve their quality of lives, though with wide socio-economic implications (alarima, 2019). it intensifies the strain for jobs without necessarily improving the job conditions of those who are left in rural european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5593 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 16 areas; impacts provision of public goods, education, utilities, housing, and infrastructure; and affects demographic and skills composition in both rural and urban areas (nweke, 2019). nigeria is the most populous african country with rapid urbanization where greater proportion of the youths below the age of 25 years encounter alarming unemployment while those with low education chose hawking activities for survival. amoo et al. (2016) opined that in the face of economic recession in nigeria, street hawking plays vital roles in the lives of many frustrated youths whose hope of better employment in the city have been dashed. street hawking is a form of street trading. the distinct features are the predominantly non-sedentary nature, and perpetual movements which may occur within the established market places or outside them along major thoroughfares and the intersection of major roads (ayodele et al., 2014). kulkarni (1984) divides hawker into two broad categories on the basis of their operations. they include the “principal –hawker”, who is solely responsible for his own capital, the management of his business and profits and losses; and the “agent-hawker”, who is employed by the owners of business or kiosks, and later paid commission for his effort. in the latter category are the wards or children of business owners who take no commission for their efforts (adepoju & femi, 1987). in ibadan, vast majority of the youths are immigrants from the countryside, and street trading for them represents a desperate means of survival when the hopes of ready employment have been thwarted. families who cannot afford the high cost of house rent are forced to live in urban slums which expose them to various health and environmental hazards. these low-income parents often engage their children in street hawking and petty trading to supplement aggregate family income (ogundele & ojo, 2007 ; ayodele & olubayo-fatiregun, 2014). the need to continually provide for the family in the midst of unfriendly conditions has led youths and children to engage in street hawking activities (ekpenyong & nkereuwuem, 2011; magaji & sarka, 2020). this study, therefore, attempts to appraise the situation among youths along sango-ojoo road ibadan for possible change of orientation to a more impactful venture. the objectives of study are to; (i) examine the socio-economic characteristics of the youths hawking in the area; (ii) investigate the reasons for engaging in the act; (iii) assess the socio-economic implications of street hawking on their livelihoods; and (iv) suggest sustainable measures that can minimize the trend in ibadan. the contribution of street hawking to economic growth and development can not be denied. unfortunately, the hazards attached to it outweigh its beneficial socio-economic implications. such hazards like motor accident, rape, kidnapping, extortion, sexual molestation, robbery and anti-social behaviours are too extreme to ignore (basorun, 2011; nduka & duru, 2014). different socio-economic factors and implications are cardinal to street hawking. studies have revealed some of these socio-demographic factors to be; poverty, lack of formal employment in the city and, regional socio-economic differences (basorun, 2011). put succinctly, the implications range from health, sexual, academic performance and attainment, behavioral to physical hazard (nduka & duru, 2014). street hawking, no doubt, exposes people to risk especially at the city centre which is the business hub associated with heavy traffic. as espoused by amoo et al. (2012) ; sam, akansor and agyemang (2019), street hawkers sustain an intense risk of physical injuries as they carry their goods on head or hands and run after moving vehicles in an attempt to ensure they complete their daily sales. undoubtedly, unemployment, poverty, inflation, poor school performance, unstable families, peer group influence, large family size and parental care have been ascribed to the incidence of street hawking in nigeria (fawole, 2003). ogundele and ojo, (2007) had argued that economic status, household size, parental upbringing and single parenthood significantly contribute to street hawking in ibadan. the hazards posed by street hawking in ibadan, include nature and harassment by government officials (toyin, 2013). all these problems have attracted attention for actions that will ameliorate the lives of the youths for a better future in ibadan, being a highly urbanized city in nigeria. the menace of street hawking in nigeria is socially, economically, politically and spatially oriented. it accounted for about one third of the 50 million labour force out of 123.9 million people in 1999 (adeyinka, 2006). the failure of the formal sector to manage the demand for jobs, goods and services presents the informal economy as the highest employer of urban poor (tripple, 2005 ; sakarombe, 2020). various efforts have been made by the three tiers of government and non-governmental agencies to stem the tide of street hawking in nigeria, through capacity building, establishment of free education foundation for the poor (for instance, rochas okorocha foundation in ibadan, port harcourt and imo state), the enactment of the 2005 child’s right bill by the national assembly to curb juvenile hawking, forceful evacuation and inducement of fine on vulnerable hawkers by some state governments and total eradication (introduced in lagos in 2015). the vocational skill acquisition centres established by oyo state (along oke-ado) and other state house representatives in their respective local government areas and wards, are not unconnected with these efforts. in spite of all these, street hawking remains a menace in nigeria. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5593 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 17 there is paucity of literature on street hawking among youths in ibadan, this study, therefore, attempts to bridge the literature gap with respect to youth involvement in hawking in the city. sango and ojoo were specifically targeted for the study because the locations are commercial hubs that have evolved on account of the presence of strategic landmarks and facilities like the polytechnic ibadan, the university of ibadan, sango park, ojoo vehicular park, sango market, ojoo market among others. these facilities act as urban magnet pulling youths regardless of sex to carry out mainly informal activities for socio-economic benefits. 2. literature review up till now, the incident of high unemployment rate in the country and ibadan in particular, is why vast majority of the youth dominates cities carrying out mainly informal activities (momoh & adejumobi, 1995; mitullah, 2004; skinner, 2008; owusu et al., 2013; uko, akpanoyoro & ekpe, 2020). street hawking plays some beneficial roles as it keeps the youths with antisocial tendencies busy with informal employment. this in a way reduces city crime and other juvenile deliquencies like rape and theft, and also helps to cushion the effect of high unemployment by generating daily income. no doubt, this daily income acts as a means of livelihood to the hawkers (adeyinka et al., 2006; uko et al., 2020). the roles of street hawking in the distribution network to the final consumers is equally significant as it reduces benefits like; low transport cost to market, cost effectiveness compare to sellers in shops and promotes the distribution of emerging products that are yet to gain prominence. sam et al. (2020) observed that hawkers encounter the risk of being knocked down by vehicles in the process of chasing buyers on motion in an attempt to sell their goods. the nature of nigeria roads increases the vulnerability, helplessness and endanger the lives of many of these youths hawking for a living (odeleye, 2000; basorun 2011). other socio-physical hazards like motor accident, kidnapping, ritual killings, rape, mobbing, exposure to antisocial activities such as smoking, and drug abuse, among others are too critical to ignore (nduka & duru, 2014). the activity itself defaces human environment in the way hawkers and buyers dispose refuse indiscriminately. poor education background of majority of the hawkers notwithstanding, their livelihood capacity in the city can still be optimized for self-sufficiency. livelihood incorporates skills, assets (both material and social) and activities essential for survival (carney, 1998). it becomes sustainable when the capacity to respond, cope and recover from dangers and stresses, maintain skills and assets without compromising the natural resource base (carney, 1998; in adaawen & jorgensen, 2012). sustainable livelihood focuses on how to sustainably enhance the social, physical and economic resources and assets on which the street hawkers draw their quest for survival. the argument is that in looking at livelihoods there is the need to understand the poverty situation from the perspective of the poor (ellis, 2000). it highlights how policies and institutions can minimize the vulnerability of the street hawkers as they try to make a living. such policies include; employment opportunities, empowerment scheme, quality and free or affordable education, reaching out to the poor and provision of basic infrastructures. it is a known fact that the rural areas lack sustainable infrastructures and job opportunities, just as cities also lack sustainable development to manage existing infrastructures, services and employment to keep pace with the teeming population. the provision of basic infrastructure and employment opportunities in the rural areas will indirectly minimize youths’ migrating to the cities for socioeconomic advantages. in the same vein, the supply of sustainable infrastructure and employment in the city would curtail people’s engagement in street hawking activities. 3. methodology this study is conducted along sango-ojoo axis of ibadan. sango-ojoo area comprises of akinyele and ibadan north lgas linked by a distributor road. ibadan-north local government where sango is geographically located lies within latitude 7º 231 n to 3º 331 e and on a longitude 7º 281 n to 3º 531 e. it shares boundaries with akinyele local government in the north; lagelu and egbeda lga in the south; ibadan-north west lga in the west; and ibadan-north-east lga in the south. it occupies a total land area of 145.58 square kilometers (figure 1). akinyele local government where ojoo situates is geographically located on latitudes 7º 201 n to 3º 521 e and a longitude 7º 241 n to 3º 521 e. the lgas that bound it are afijio, in the north; lagelu, in the east, ido, in the west, and ibadan north, in the south. the total land coverage is 464.892 european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5593 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 18 square kilometers (figure 1). this study is limited to street hawkers between the ages of 15-24 years who are regarded as youths by the united nation (un), international labour organization (ilo), and world bank. the paucity of records about these hawkers in the study area led to the conduct of a 6-days periodic counting of hawkers at potential hawking locations along sango-ojoo route (figure 2). from the estimated average total of 66 street hawkers daily (regardless of age and sex), 37 youth hawkers were randomly selected for this study, representing 59.1% sample size. close-ended questionnaires, interview guides and field observation were research instruments employed in this study. the questionnaire sought for information on socio-demographic attributes of the youth hawkers, reasons for hawking, factors motivating them to hawk and the implications of street hawking business. this was supported by physical observation, random sampling of 37 buyers and formal interviews of directors in the ministries of education, science and technology, lands, housing and urban development and women affairs as well as programmes and policies meant to empower youths and reduce street hawking in ibadan. simple chi-square was used to test the significance of relationship between two categorical variables using spss version 17. figure 1. map of study area source: google earth 7.1.7.2606; authors’ digitization with arcgis 10.3.1, 2020 figure 2. google imagery showing sango-ojoo road european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5593 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 19 source: google earth 7.1.7.2606; authors’ digitization with arcgis 10.3.1, 2020 4. results and discussion there was preponderance of female youths (59.5%) than males (40.5%) hawking along sango-ojoo road. it is a common knowledge that informal activities like street hawking and trading are gender based. while men have high affinity for professional activities (artisanship) like crop farming, poultry and animal husbandry, fishing and logging, carpentry, wood work (carving), blacksmithing, shoe making e.tc. more often than not, products of these activities are sold by their wives or children in the market (dada, 2013). more than half (56.8%) of the youth hawkers were single, while 43.2% were married. this explains the reason for hawking as many need to be self-sufficient to cater for matrimonial demands. high family size is usually not unconnected with polygamy and poverty. although this fact is relative as it depends on culture and other socio-demographic indicators like level of education and religion. large family size characterized by poverty and poor educational background of the children in the face of recessed economy opt for informal employment like hawking and trading (omokhodion et al. 2006). this justifies why large percentage (59.5%) of the hawkers had a fairly large household size of 5 to 8. however, the proportion (29.7%) of those with lower household size (1 to 4) reveals their quest for monogamy or a lower number of children. the low proportion (10.8%) with very large household size (9 to 12 and 12 & above) indicates that the present economic adversity in the country has made many nigerians to limit their number of births (dada, 2013). the fact remains that a significant relationship between household size and street hawking activities exists, because people with high household size have large number of children to cater for and street hawking is an option for them when their hopes for better employments in cities have been frustrated (fawole, 2003; omokhodion, 2006; owusu et al., 2013; magaji & sarka, 2020). this claim was statistically significant at 5% significance level with a calculated chi squared value greater than tabulated value as presented in table 1. table 1. statistical computation of respondents’ household size household size observed expected residual 1-4 11 12.3 -1.3 5-8 22 12.3 9.7 9-12 4 12.3 -8.3 european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5593 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 20 total 37 source: author’s computation, 2020 x2 (3, n=37) = 13.351, p <0.001 x2 tab = 5.991, p = 0.05 df=2 findings revealed that 27.0 % of the hawkers were self-employed and own their goods, 18.9% were employed by their mothers, 2.7% by father, 13.5% by guardian, and 37.8% by either a company or master. the high percentage of the hawkers that lived alone explains the high rate of self-employment. the influence of mother may not be unconnected with the “strong tie that exists between mothers and child than fathers” (basorun, 2011). the significantly high percentage employed by boss or a company attests to parents’ low financial status as hawkers receive reasonable commission to relief the family in anticipation of future pursuit. table 2 below confirms a significant relationship between the occupation of hawkers’ employer and street hawking. for instance, a large percentage (67.6%) of the hawkers had their employers (most of whom were their parents or guardian/relatives they resided with) as traders or hawkers. this is reflected in the high chi squared value of 70.189 which is statically significant at p<0.001. unequivocally, it can be said here that most of the hawkers are employed by parents that are into either trading or hawking business which perhaps fosters their involvement in hawking. table 2. statistical analysis of occupation of hawkers’ employer occupation observed n expected n residual artisan 3 6.2 -3.2 trading/hawking 25 6.2 18.8 food vendor 3 6.2 -3.2 farming 4 6.2 -2.2 transport operators 1 6.2 -5.2 none 1 6.2 -5.2 total 37 𝑥! (5, n=37) = 70.189, p = 0.001 𝑥! tab = 11.070, p = 0.05 df =5 source: author’s computation, 2020 surprisingly, majority of the hawkers (67.6%) had attained secondary education, 8.1% had tertiary education, 10.8 junior secondary education, 5.4% primary education while only 8.1% had no formal education. with this analysis, it could be speculated that the aspiration for higher education may be the cause of their involvement in hawking to acquire some income. higher education guarantees a better livelihood. an educated person is better positioned in a society that illiterate (dada, 2013). the tendency for a better educated person to get good employment is high. there are limited better employment opportunities for people with low level of education in a developing economy. the need for them to make a living against all odds results in informal employment like street hawking and trading (nduka & duru, 2014). the chi squared result of 52.525 which is statistically significant at p < 0.001 shows that poor educational background is one of the causal factors precluding youth from securing a well-paid job, hence, the need to engage in hawking for survival (table 3). table 3. educational attainment of hawkers european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5593 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 21 level of occupation observed n expected n residual no formal education 3 7.4 -4.4 primary 2 7.4 -5.4 junior secondary 4 7.4 -3.4 senior secondary 25 7.4 17.6 tertiary 3 7.4 -4.4 total 37 𝑥! (4, n=37) = 52.595, p < 0.001 𝑥! tab = 9.488, p = 0.05 df =5 source: author’s computation, 2020 on hawking items, about 41.0% of the respondents hawked either water or soft drinks; snacks, bread and or food were hawked by 34.4%; clothing and or shoe materials by 6.6% and fruits by 14.8%. the items hawked are complimentary in nature. for instance, water or drinks and snacks, bread or food are sold together, because the same people patronizing hawkers selling snacks or food also demand water and drinks. the complementarity of these items justifies the reason why hawkers congregate “at the same location and move together with traffic pattern” (nduka & duru, 2014). the study found that (59.5%) of the hawkers earned average daily income of #1,001 to #2,000 ($2.62 5.24), while 24.3% earned #2,001 to #3,000 ($5.25 – 7.86), 8.1% earned less than #1,000 ($2.62) and above #3,000 ($7.86). some factors that determine income of the hawkers include; season, weather and period of the day. generally, there are more sales during festive periods and peak hours of the day, just as there are more demands for cold water and drinks in a hot weather than cold. another factor that determines income is location. a hawker selling drinks usually in a traffic hold-up is likely to realize more income than on a road side of free-moving traffic. the analysis in table 4, however, affirms with a statistical significance of hawking activities to the accruing relatively high daily income which attracts the youths. conversely, there exists an indirect relationship between the income and expenditure of the hawkers as majority of them (88.5%) spent below #500 ($1.31) daily despite the associated dangers and stress. table 4. statistical estimate of respondents’ income from hawking per day income observed n expected n residual less than #1,000 3 9.3 -6.3 #1,001 2,000 22 9.3 12.8 #2,001 3,000 9 9.3 -.3 above #3,000 3 9.3 -6.3 total 37 𝑥! (3, n=37) = 26.027, p < 0.001 𝑥! tab = 7.815, p = 0.05 df =5 source: author’s computation, 2020 high percentage of the hawkers (39.6%) worked to supplement family income. this is expected in a developing economy, where poverty is marked by relatively high family size. with poverty and large family to cater for, parents send their children to the street to work and earn daily income to sustain the family (ogundele & ojo, 2007; omokhodion et al., 2006). about 27.0% of the hawkers gave low level of education as reason for their engagement in hawking. this justifies the significant correlation between low-income level and level of education as opined by nduka & duru, (2014). as revealed by the ministry of lands, housing and urban development, most of the markets in ibadan are insufficient for the traders and unaffordable as european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5593 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 22 corroborated by some (19.8%) of the hawkers. nearly 25.9% were doing this to enlarge their businesses while 7.5% only desired to have means of buying drugs for the treatment of their aged parents’ health challenges. the ministry of education, science and technology and the ministry of women affairs revealed that there were scholarship grants and empowerment scheme set up by the oyo state government for the less privileged. unfortunately, there was low awareness about these opportunities as claimed by about 70.3% of the street hawkers. only 29.7% were aware, while about 8.1% were beneficiaries of the programmes. it is, therefore, imperative for the government to increase publicity of the programmes and seek for more financial assistance from local and international organizations to fund the scheme. analysis of findings indicated that 32.4% of them had been either sexually molested or physically assaulted; 25.0% had one form of accident, 24.3% experienced stress and fatigue and 18.2% had attempts of robbery or kidnapping (table 5). information further revealed that at times the females faced molestations by the garage boys (customers) and police also physically molested them when escorting bullion van conveying cash to banks. apparently, the female hawkers face more dangers than the males such as sexual molestation and physical assault, stress and fatigue while the male hawkers are more vulnerable to accidents. high level of accidents of male hawkers may be due to their physical resilience and ability to withstand and run along moving vehicles to sell their goods. table 5a. analysis of hawking hazard on gender basis hazard gender male female total accidents 10 (27.0%) 8 (21.6%) 18 (48,6%) sexual molestation/physical assault 1 (2.7%) 6 (16.2%) 7 (18.9%) robbery/kidnapping 2 (5.4%) 3 (8.1%) 5 (13.5%) stress and fatigue 2 (5.4%) 5 (13.5%) 7 (18.9%) total 15 (40.5%) 22 (59.5%) 37 (100%) source: authors’ field work, 2020 table 5b. statistical analysis of hawking hazards hazard observed n expected n residual accidents 18 9.3 8.8 sexual molestation/physical assault 7 9.3 -2.3 robbery/kidnapping 5 9.3 -4.3 stress and fatigue 7 9.3 -2.3 total 37 𝑥! (3, n=37) = 11.324, p = 0.010 𝑥! tab = 11.070, p = 0.05 df =3 source: author’s computation, 2020 majority of the buyers (40.6%) claimed that street hawking exposed hawkers to accident. urban degeneration (gradual loss of city aesthetic) was given by 13.5%, 21.6% believed it created filthy environment, while 24.3% argued that it created congestion of pedestrian and vehicles in the street. field observation revealed that most of the food vendors exposed their foods to pollutants that may be noxious to consumers’ health. in summary, the dangers of hawking can be classified into three namely impacts on hawking environment, impacts on the buyers and impacts on the hawkers themselves. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5593 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 23 reactions from the hawkers indicated that 41.0% anticipated to stop hawking and go back to school, 37.7% wished to start a business and 16.4% desired to acquire a particular technical skill. the fact remains that majority of them were not happy with hawking, they only opted for it to gather money for better opportunities. they were willing to stop hawking and go for better jobs because of the inherent dangers 5. conclusion and recommendations street hawking in nigeria is an easy business for anybody because of its free entrance and exit unlike other informal employments. here, hawkers are assured of daily income needed to cater for self and family needs. vulnerability of hawkers to dangers is gender-based as females were more susceptible to dangers and stress than males. they were also exposed to higher risks of skin, respiratory, injury, eye and even rape by men who pretend to be their customers. in nigeria, high cases of sexual molestation have been reported which contravenes the provisions of the child right act. yet, little is heard about punishment in accordance with the provisions of the law against child abuse. accident is another rampant danger. sango-ojoo road is a busy road of commercial activities and discharges traffic to higher order road like oyo express road. male hawkers are more prone to this hazard as they often run after moving vehicles to sell their items from the field data analyses and observations, there were some basic socio-economic factors motivating youths to hawk in ibadan. these include; household size, level of education, residency of hawkers, occupation of employers and income. however, the dangers/hazards of hawking overweigh its benefits. employment, education finance, family support and savings for better enterprise are some of the beneficial implications while accident, physical and sexual molestations and robbery are critical dangers hawkers were susceptible to. there is need to invest in the lives of these youths to secure their future and the development of the country as a whole. poverty and poor education are, no doubt, part of the major causes of street hawking in nigeria. vast majority of nigerians are denied of well-paid and better employment opportunities on account of low level of education. education plays a significant role in the economy of a nation as it determines the future of children. the 4th goal of the sustainable development goals (sdgs) is ‘quality education’ which is “to ensure inclusive and equitable quality education and promote lifelong learning opportunities for all”. in nigeria, education systems have been commercialized and hawkers are excluded from the systems because their parents could not render the necessary financial support to school. the state government should, therefore, sustain its free education programs as well as the universal basic education program by the federal government in collaboration with the federal ministry of education for the hawkers to utilize the window to improve on their formal education. skill acquisition centres are also systems that could improve livelihood potentials of the marginalized and impact professional skills, knowledge, social ethics and norms in the lives of the youths. since some of the hawkers possess a particular potential that can be enhanced, the government in collaboration with concerned agencies like unicef, ilo and the world bank should, therefore, establish sufficient and standard skill acquisition centres in the lgas to develop innovative skills of the youths. empowerment programmes should also be introduced to complement this with utmost sincerity and frequent public awareness. it is obvious that majority of the youths lack financial capacity to rent stalls in the market. on this note, the oyo state government needs to seek the assistance of local and international organizations on the construction of accessible and affordable markets at subsidized rates to the users. it is imperative for the government in alliance with the ministry of women affairs to sensitize the public regularly through the social media on the social and health implications of street hawking. this should be extended to all neighbouring primary and secondary schools. major cause of street hawking is high birth rate beyond financial capacity of the people. in this regard, regular awareness campaign against uncontrolled births and benefits of family planning is essentials to reduce the prevalence of street hawking in ibadan metropolis. challenges encountered during the study were but not limited to: • dearth of data on the numbers of street hawkers in the city; • many of the hawkers requested for patronage before responding to the enumerators; • the garage boys also obstructed data collection process. despite these limitations, the study was successful and all set-out objectives achieved. furthermore, the following areas need attention to further the extent of this study: • the integration of geographic information system (gis) to track major hawking spots in the city; european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5593 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 24 • future researchers should adopt geostatistics to measure the vulnerability of hawkers disaggregated by hawking terminals. references adaawen, s.a., & jorgensen, s.h. (2012). eking out a living: the livelihood implications of urban space regulation on street hawking in accra, ghana. african review of economics and finance, 3(2), 58-61. adepoju, g., & femi, o.e. (1987). urban renewal in nigeria. in niser/curp, urban commercial slum (vol. 5, pp. 126127). ibadan. adeyinka, s.a., omisore, e.o., olawumi, p.o., & abegunde, a.a. (2006). an evaluation of informal sector activities on urban land use management in south western nigeria. munich, germany: shaping the change xxiii fig congress. alarima, c. i. (2018). factors influencing rural-urban migration of youths in osun state, nigeria. agro-science, 17(3), 3439. amoo, e., ola-david, o., olurinola, i., & fadayomi, t. (2016). female youth in street trading: implication for sexual harrassment in hiv/aids risky environment. jsabr, 1-12. amoo, e.o., ola-david, o., ogunrinola, i.o., & fadayomi, t.o. (2012). street trading activities and maternal health in urban areas of nigeria. global journal of human social science arts & humanity, 12(15), 1-12. retrieved from http://www.globaljournals.org ayaya, s.o., & esamai f.o. (2001). health problems of street children in eldoret, kenya. east african medical journal, 78(12), 624-629. ayodele, r.b., & olubayo-fatiregun, m.a. (2014). accidental injuries among juvenile hawkers: clog in the wheel of sustainable socio-economic development of a nation. asian journal of humanities and social sciences (ajhss), 2(2), 19-30. retrieved from www.ajhss.org bank, t. w. (2009). youth and employment in africa: the potential, the problem, the promise. washington, d.c. 20433, u.s.a: the international bank for reconstruction and development/the world bank. doi:10.1596/978-0-8213-7787-1 basorun, j. (2003). basic elements of urban and regional planning. akure: shalom publishers. basorun, j. (2011). women, poverty and child-labour: the contending evils with child development in akure region, nigeria. scottish journal of arts, social sciences and scientific studies, 135-147. retrieved from http://scottishjournal.co.uk carney, d. (1998). implementing the sustainable rural livelihoods approach. in d. carney, sustainable rural livelihoods{ what contribution can we make? (pp. 231-277). dfid: london.: papers presented at the dfidus natural resources advisers' conference, july 2008. dada, o. (2013). a sociological investigation of the determinant factors and the effects of child street hawking in nigeria: agege, lagos state. international journal of asian social science, 1-24. retrieved from http://www.aessweb.com/journal=detail.php?=5007 ekpenyong, s., & nkereuwuem, s.a. (2011). street trading and child labour in yenogoa. int. j. sci. res. in educ, 4(1), 3646. ellis, f. (2000). rural livelihoods and diversity in developing countries. oxford: oxford university press. fawole, j. (2003). a study of child abuse and neglect and intervention strategies in nigeria. nigerian school health journal, 15(1 & 2), 3-9. ilo. (2017). global employment trends for youth 2017: paths to a better working future. geneva: international labour office. johnson, o.e., & ihesie, c.a. (2015). social implications and factors associated with street hawking among children in uyo, akwa ibom state, nigeria. british journal of education, society and behavioural science, 11(2), 1-9. retrieved from http://sciencedomain.org/review-history/10469 kulkarni, k. (1984). geography of crowding and human response: a study of ahmedabad city. concept publishing company. lu, j. (2011). occupational health and safety of women workers: viewed in the light of labour regulation. journal of international women's studies, 12(1), 68-78. retrieved from htp://vc.bridgew.edu/jiws/vol12/iss1/5 european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5593 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 25 magaji, j. y., & sarka, s. w. (2020). the effects of teenage hawking and its implication on national development: a case study of kagarko local government, kaduna state, nigeria. mitullah, w. (2004). a review of street trade in africa. kennedy school of government, havard university, usa.: a reviw commissioned by women in informal employment globalising and organising (wiego). momoh, a., & adejumobi, s. (1995). the political economy of nigeria under military rule: 1984-1993. harare: sapes books. nduka, j., & duru, c.o. (2014). the menace of street hawking in aba metropolis, south-east nigeria. journal of medicine and medical sciences, 5(6), 134-140. retrieved from www.interesjournals.org/jmms niser/curp. (1987). urban renewal in nigeria. in g. &. adepoju, urban commercial slum (vol. 5, pp. 126-127). ibadan. nweke, a. c. (2019). investigating rural–urban migration in developing countries of the world a focus in nigeria. journal of public policy and administration, 3(3), 76. ogundele, b.o., & ojo, r.a. (2007). selected socio-demographic factors as a correlates of child abuse and neglect among parents in ibada, oyo state. studies on ethno-medicine, 2, 147-151. olutunde, a. (2013). the prevalence of child-hawkers' in motor parks in ibadan municipality: an overview. open journal of social science research, 7, 174-179. omokhodion, f.o., omokhodion s.i., & odusote, t.o. (2006). perceptions of child labour among working children in ibadan, nigeria. child: care, health and development, 281-286. owusu, a.b., abrokwah, s., & frimpong, s. (2013). analysis of the spatial and temporal dynamics of street hawking: a case study of the accra metropolitan area. journal of geoography, 5(4), 169-180. doi:10.5539/jgg.v5n4p169 sakarombe, u. (2020). integrating informal economy into official economy in southern africa: identifying barriers and possible solutions. tanzania economic review, 10(1). sam, e. f., akansor, j., & agyemang, w. (2019). understanding road traffic risks from the street hawker’s perspective. international journal of injury control and safety promotion, 26(1), 92-98. skinner, s. (2008). street trade in africa: a review. working paper no 51. toyin, a. (2013). bracing the odds in the face of double tragedy: the dillemma of street trading in ibadan metropolis of nigeria. international research journal of arts and social science, 2(5), 134-143. retrieved from http://www.interesjournal.org/irjass tripple, g. (2005). the place of home based enterprises in the informal sector: evidence for cochabamba, new delhi, surabaya and pretoria. journal of urban studies, 4, 611-632. uko, f. e., akpanoyoro, m. j., & ekpe, j. p. (2020). an evaluation of the contribution of the informal sector in employment and income generation in nigeria: thematic approach. management, 1(2). un-habitat: for a better urban future. (2012). retrieved from http://www.unhabitat.org unicef. (2017). child protection from violence, exploitation and abuse. retrieved from http://www.unicef.org united nations. (2014). retrieved january 6, 2018, from definition of youth: http://undesadspd.org/youth/worldprogrammeofactionforyouth.aspx european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7425 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 27 social pillar score and the csr committee: an empirical analysis of corporate governance mechanisms adriana bruno1*, matteo pozzoli2, sabrina pisano3, elbano de nuccio4 1 contact author university of naples parthenope, via generale parisi 13, 80132, napoli (italy) adriana.bruno@uniparthenope.it 2 university of naples parthenope, via generale parisi 13, 80132, napoli (italy) matteo.pozzoli@uniparthenope.it 3 university of naples parthenope, via generale parisi 13, 80132, napoli (italy) sabrina.pisano@uniparthenope.it 4 lum university – giuseppe degennaro, s.s 100 km 18 70010 casamassima, bari (italy) denuccio@lum.it received: 22/02/2023 accepted for publication: 20/04/2023 published: 21/04/2023 abstract this empirical study on corporate governance mechanisms addresses the potential impact of the corporate social responsibility committee (csrc) on the social pillar score (sp). based on a sample of 457 listed european companies from the refinitiv thomson-eikon database over a one-year period (2021), this paper examines the effect of a corporate social responsibility (csr) committee and the moderating effect of gender diversity on the social pillar score. our analysis shows that the more firms have csr committees, the more likely they are to adopt “socially responsible policies and practices”. in addition, female directors on the board positively moderate the previous relationship. therefore, this research stresses that gender diversity and csr committees significantly predict a firm's social initiatives. thus, our findings show that csr committees and gender diversity are socially sensitive variables. finally, the analysis demonstrates a positive relation between firm size, board size, role duality, board independence variables, and the social pillar score. keywords: social pillar; corporate and social responsibility; csr committee; gender diversity 1. introduction although there is yet to be a clear definition of the environmental, social and governance (esg) approach (li et al., 2021), it is quite sure that esg focuses on three pillars: the environmental, social, and governance pillars. the social pillar includes health and safety, diversity and opportunity, training and development, employment quality, product responsibility, community, and human rights. (marsat & williams 2014). it also represents a major component of corporate reputation (bruno a. et al. 2015). currently, stakeholders are focused on environmental, social and governance (esg) behaviour and disclosures to prevent firm misconduct, obtain higher assurance of corporate reputation (arayssi et al., 2020) and comprehend management plans to european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7425 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 28 produce value in the medium and long term (escrig-olmedo et al., 2010; zumente and bistrova, 2021). the main element of a profound change is good corporate governance, and scholars have recently concentrated their attention on seeking means that enhance the social performance of firms (urmanaviciene a. 2020). in this context, corporate boards (cbs) are key in corporate governance (john k. & senbet l.w. 1998). they can considerably influence firms’ engagement and disclosure of social activities in business reporting (francoeur, c et al. 2019). firms must have a strong social commitment to establish value-creating stakeholder relationships to build sustainability (secinaro s. et al 2020). the linkage between companies and the community is specifically founded on the decisions made by the cb, which traditionally aligns the interests of stakeholders and shareholders with day-to-day managerial operations (belkhir, 2009). accordingly, the sensitivity and qualitative characteristics of cb can (positively or negatively) impact csr (urmanaviciene a. & udara s. a. (2020) and esg performance. at present, academia and practitioners seem more attracted by environmental issues, while social and governance features appear less investigated (leopizzi et al., 2020). even if the social pillar (sp) should be interpreted by a more general approach that a company uses to act sustainably, it can also be separately addressed to consider how it promotes a better quality of life for all involved parties. the sp area involves human rights, gender equality and diversity, social assistance, educational programmes, investments, and involvement in social protection programs (murphy, 2012). this paper moves from the perspective that, thanks to the operation of csr committees and a wider diversity on the board, a specialized focus on esg issues can support policies in favour of more socially sustainable development within and outside the firm (stevens, 2010). this research explores whether the presence of csr committees can enhance social performance and whether the combined presence of higher diversity and csr committees can further support the sustainable development of practices in the sp area. this perspective has been generated by the expectation that a csr committee pays particular attention to esg features (baraibar-diez and odriozola, 2019), and contextually, the combination of board diversity and csr committee operations can produce a “leverage” effect. in addition, women have different leadership styles because they are more concerned with organizational needs and focus on community welfare and service organizations (arayssi et al., 2016). women directors possess characteristics that are more aligned with social issues since they have more communal characteristics, such as being supportive, gentle, and emphatic (monteiro et al., 2022; uyar et al., 2022). consequently, women are more concerned with corporate social performance since they tend to address stakeholders’ interests better. women’s presence in board rooms encourages firms to become socially responsible and adopt environmentally friendly practices (arayssi et al., 2016). therefore, this research aims to show that the presence of csr committees, combined with gender diversity, could support a new competitive environment for behaviour that can be addressed as socially responsible (rené et al. 2021). to achieve this objective, the paper is organized as follows: section 2 presents a literature review of the relationship between the social pillar, csr committees, and gender diversity. section 3 details the dataset and methodology. section 4 provides the results and discusses the influence of the different components of the social pillar. section 5 concludes the paper. 2. literature review the literature investigates the global relationship between csr and financial performance (bird et al., 2007). specifically, the literature on human capital reinforces the idea that social expenses on employees should be linked with financial goodwill because motivating employees should increase productivity (becker 1962). specifically, a study from marsat & williams, 2014, shows a strong positive relationship between the social pillar and firm value. interestingly, in this paper, even if not all the components of the social pillar are positively related to the overall results of global financial goodwill, this finding is consistent with the idea that the social pillar is an intangible asset producing firm market value and taking part in corporate social responsibility (scholtens 2006). most other studies are focused on the complete measure of csr and its main components or more specific issues such as human capital, religiosity (shahid a. et al., 2022), legitimation, behaviour, and a good reputation among local communities (marsat, s., williams, b., 2013). other studies have focused on the link between stakeholder welfare (including the environment) and firm value. (jiao 2010). european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7425 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 29 moreover, previous research examined board gender diversity (bgd), concluding that a csr committee could also emphasize its effectiveness. bgd plays a crucial role in prioritising csr-related issues (eberhardt-tot et al., 2019) and tends to improve responsible management and social performance. it has been shown that board gender diversity (i.e., the proportion of female directors) is positively associated with firms' social commitment to human rights, product responsibility, and, consequently, their contribution to firm sustainability (beji et al., 2021; arayakarnkul p. et al. 2022). martínez-ferrero et al. (2020) examine the effect of gender diversity and the moderating effect of the existence of a csr committee. specifically, this study aimed to improve the understanding of the factors determining a firm’s affiliation with the united nations global compact (ungc) as the largest voluntary corporate responsibility initiative worldwide. the results suggest that female directors on the board significantly encourage the firm’s affiliation with the ungc and support the mediating effect of the existence of a csr committee. therefore, the positive impact of female directors on ungc signatories appears to be mediated by the existence of a csr committee. however, a few studies (sectoral and limited to some specific period) have tried to investigate the opposite relationship between the existence of csr committees on the social pillar and the moderating effect of board gender diversity. specifically, uyar et al. (2021) showed that csr committees and bgd positively enhanced csr performance. govindan et al. (2021) show that firms operating in the logistics sector with a sustainability committee are more likely to have greater corporate social responsibility performance (both overall and social) in 2018 than those that do not. therefore, these authors confirm that logistics companies listed on the stock exchange will likely disclose a broader range of csr aspects within their reports, implying an impact from stakeholder pressures on their csr practices. the presence of a csr committee also plays a significant role in improving corporate social performance strengths, even though it cannot reduce public concerns (burke et al., 2019). other research found a positive relationship between csr performance and the presence of a csr committee. specifically, spitzeck (2009) found that companies with a csr committee have better corporate sustainability performance in the corporate responsibility index. these committees can successfully improve corporate social performance strengths. baraibar-diez and odriozola (2019) also analysed the influence of a csr committee on csr performance, specifically esg performance in the uk, france, germany, and spain. they found that companies with a csr committee have different esg scores than firms without one. a csr committee is related to better performance when considering the four scores (environmental, social, governance, and economic) and the four countries independently (except for economic scores in spain). the social pillar in the literature is mostly studied about environmental reporting and is not studied “per se” (ashfaq, k. & rui, z. 2018). studies focus on specific contexts such as europe (baraibar-diez, e. & odriozola, m.d. 2019) and italy (cucari et al. 2017). the literature has explored the relationship between a firm’s social performance and reporting while also considering board gender diversity; however, these studies focused mainly on developed countries and paid less attention to emerging countries that require special consideration (arayssi et al., 2020; khwaja n. c.l. 2021; yadav p. & prashar a. 2022). other authors have concluded that board characteristics influence the presence of csr committees. in detail, they found that independent directors promote the creation of specialized committees to make decisions related to csr strategies. moreover, in this specific situation, the csr committee is a mediator between independent directors and the adoption of the global reporting initiative – international finance corporation (gri-ifc) strategy. (garcía-sanchez et al. 2017), a body of literature has documented a positive relationship between board gender diversity and sustainability performance (uson et al. 2022) across a broad spectrum of sustainability indicators (amran, a et al. 2014; eberhardt-toth, e. 2017). other authors have considered culture in the relationship between corporate social performance and firm performance (wei s. & veenstra k. 2021). moreover, other researchers confirm that ‘structural’ gender diversity is a significant predictor of a firm's environmental sustainability initiatives, so gender diversity is also a sustainability issue (kassinis g. et al. 2016). regarding the social pillar in the national literature, we have discovered that some italian authors have already shown that cb diversity, proxied by director independence (a demographic diversity in boards and gender diversity), affects corporate social performance (csp). in this research, csp concepts were presented, including those that evolved from the concept of corporate social responsibility (csr), which is a static concept emphasizing accountability. at the same time, csp is a bottom-line concept emphasizing sustainable outcomes (veltri et al. 2020). the sample in this research is the most capitalized firms. in this stream, apart from very specific points of view, our approach is innovative since we investigate the link between gender diversity and the social pillar related to csr. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7425 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 30 3. theoretical framework and hypothesis development stakeholder theory (cummings, l. & patel, c. 2009) and agency theory are common theories used to understand the link between corporate governance and sustainability performance. specifically, stakeholder theory argues that it is important for companies to establish strong relations with stakeholders to maintain and improve corporate legitimacy; thus, according to this theory, effective corporate governance can convey to society that the firm is well managed and that the interests of stakeholders are considered (michelon and parbonetti, 2012). in contrast, agency theory predicts that companies protect investors and reduce agency conflicts by using control mechanisms, such as corporate governance structures (jensen and meckling, 1976). from this perspective, csr is crucial for fulfilling stakeholders’ expectations (khan et al., 2013). drawing on stakeholder and agency theories, this study examines the association between a csr committee and social pillar performance, adopting board gender diversity as a moderating variable. based on the findings illustrated in the literature review, this paper aims to test whether the presence of a csr committee, as found in some previous research (jorge 2020), is positively related to social and environmental performance. this should confirm that esg issues deserve specialized attention and a dedicated workforce. more specifically, this research investigates whether the presence of a csr committee can support the sp score. hp 1: the presence of a csr committee positively influences the social pillar score. in contrast, we observed that some studies had illustrated the positive reaction that cb diversity could have on esg performance with a moderating effect from the operation of a csr committee (martínez-ferrero et al., 2020), even if there is no evidence of the opposite effect, that is, a positive impact of a csr committee on esg performance with a moderating effect from cb diversity. we based our hypothesis on the consideration that cb diversity can offer different points of view and support a more conscious decision-making process. hp 2: the level of board gender diversity positively moderates the relationship between the presence of a csr committee and the social pillar score. 4. methodology 4.1 dataset the sample comprises 457 european listed companies collected from the refinitiv thomson-eikon, a database that several scholars have already applied to analyse cb characteristics in connection with esg performance (del giudice & rigamonti, 2020; dorfleitner et al., 2020). the refinitiv thomson-eikon database applies a consolidated methodology that attributes an esg score to the investigated companies (refinitiv, 2022). the analysis is organized by determining a complex score, articulated on the sum of the three single pillar scores. the choice of the european context arises from the “hard low approach” adopted here, i.e., ad hoc regulatory measures have been applied that aim at "imposing" the presence of women on boards. a further peculiarity that concerns europe (italy, norway, holland, france, iceland, belgium, denmark, greece, slovenia, austria, spain, and germany) is the different degree of effectiveness of the rules depending on whether they are companies with listed or publicly controlled shares. in this regard, the european commission and the european parliament have started harmonising the different gender equality approaches (callegari et al. 2021). each pillar includes a few esg themes, with the related data points evaluated as proxies of esg magnitude per industry group. the themes for the social pillar are workforce, human rights, community, and product responsibility. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7425 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 31 figure 1: the refinitiv thomson-eikon methodology source: author´s elaboration the score is measured on 186 metrics (54 in the social pillar). the points are then weighted based on the industry sector in relation to the theme's importance in that specific context. table 1: esg themes in the social pillar category pillars categories themes data points weight method social community equally important to all industry groups, hence a median weight of five is assigned to all equally important to all industry groups human rights human rights tr.policyhumanrights transparency weights product responsibility responsible marketing tr.policyresponsiblemarketing transparency weights product quality tr.productqualitymonitoring transparency weights data privacy tr.policydataprivacy transparency weights workforce diversity and inclusion tr.womenemployees quant industry median career development and training tr.avgtraininghours transparency weights working conditions tr.tradeunionrep quant industry median health and safety tr.analyticlostdays transparency weights source: author´s elaboration the sample in this study comprises companies from the european economic area, as represented in the following table. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7425 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 32 table 2: country composition of the sample n° companies % austria 15 3,3% belgium 14 3,1% cyprus 2 0,4% czech republic 1 0,2% denmark 11 2,4% finland 37 8,1% france 72 15,8% germany 86 18,8% greece 2 0,4% hungary 1 0,2% ireland 11 2,4% italy 44 9,6% luxembourg 3 0,7% malta 1 0,2% netherlands 22 4,8% poland 2 0,4% portugal 12 2,6% spain 34 7,4% sweden 87 19,0% total 457 100,0% source: author´s elaboration the european economic context has already been widely analysed in investigations of the impact of board characteristics on esg performance (martínez-ferrero et al., 2021; nicolò et al., 2021; rossi et al., 2021; gurol and lagasio, 2022). the european union has a strongly supportive attitude towards esg issues, representing—especially since the beginning of the 2000s—a benchmark worldwide (ec, 2001; eu, 2011). the industry composition is subsequently reproduced. the whole sample needs to consider the banking and financial services sector. we preferred to leave the financial sector out of the investigation, as some countries propose ad hoc legislation for board composition. accordingly, we focused our attention on nonfinancial companies. almost half of the companies belong to the “manufacturing” sector (47%). the other half represented industry segments, such as “information” (9.6%), “real estate and rentals and leasing” (7.9%), “utilities” and “construction” (5.3%), “professional, scientific, and technical services” and “retail trade” (5%); the other sectors are more specialized, and each is below 5% of the sample. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7425 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 33 table 3: sector composition of the sample trbc sector name number of companies % accommodation and food services 7 1,5% administrative and support and waste management and remediation services 10 2,2% agriculture, forestry, fishing and hunting 2 0,4% arts, entertainment, and recreation 4 0,9% construction 24 5,3% educational services 1 0,2% health care and social assistance 4 0,9% information 44 9,6% management of companies and enterprises 1 0,2% manufacturing 215 47,0% mining, quarrying, and oil and gas extraction 6 1,3% professional, scientific, and technical services 23 5,0% real estate and rentals and leasing 36 7,9% retail trade 23 5,0% transportation and warehousing 21 4,6% utilities 24 5,3% wholesale trade 10 2,2% other services (except public administration) 2 0,4% total 457 100,00% source: author´s elaboration we tested our hypotheses on 457 companies with a linear regression generated by stata software. the final number of observations used in the regression analysis is 448, as the software identified the data of 10 companies as incomplete or inapplicable. all data refer to the 2021 period, representing our objective's most recent financial and nonfinancial information. considering that we have considered a single period, the number of examined companies is equivalent to the number of applied observations. 4.2 model specification and variables our dependent variable is refinitiv’s social pillar score (socialscore). this is a weighted score computed by refinitiv for each company based on the social information recovered in the four social categories identified: workforce, human rights, community, and product responsibility. our dependent variable is the existence of a csr committee (csrcomm). we measured this variable using a dummy equal to 1 when the company has a csr committee within the board and 0 otherwise. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7425 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 34 moreover, to test the moderating role of the presence of female directors in the relationship between csr committees and the social pillar, we inserted an interaction term (csrcommxgendiv) into our regression. we obtained the interaction term by multiplying the csrcomm variable with board gender diversity (gendiv). we inserted different control variables in the regression to control for endogeneity and reduce possible bias. more specifically, we inserted both other cb and firm-specific characteristics as follows: • board size (bosize) measured as the number of board members • role duality (roledual) computed using a dummy equal to 1 when the ceo is also the chairman of the board and 0 otherwise • board independence (boind) measured as the percentage of independent directors sitting on the board • board meeting (bomeet) computed as the number of meetings held during the year • firm size (size) computed as the natural logarithm of total assets • leverage (lev) measured as the long-term debt divided by total assets • profitability (profit) computed using the return on total assets to test the hypotheses, we developed the following regressions: 𝑆𝑜𝑐𝑖𝑎𝑙𝑆𝑐𝑜𝑟𝑒 = 𝛼 + 𝛽!csrcomm+ 𝛽"𝐺𝑒𝑛𝐷𝑖𝑣 + 𝛽#𝐵𝑜𝑆𝑖𝑧𝑒 + 𝛽$𝑅𝑜𝑙𝑒𝐷𝑢𝑎𝑙 + 𝛽%𝐵𝑜𝐼𝑛𝑑 + 𝛽&𝐵𝑜𝑀𝑒𝑒𝑡 + 𝛽'𝑆𝑖𝑧𝑒 + 𝛽(𝐿𝑒𝑣 + 𝛽)profit + 𝜀 (1) 𝑆𝑜𝑐𝑖𝑎𝑙𝑆𝑐𝑜𝑟𝑒 = 𝛼 + 𝛽!csrcomm+ 𝛽"𝐺𝑒𝑛𝐷𝑖𝑣 + 𝛽#𝐶𝑆𝑅𝐶𝑜𝑚𝑚𝑥𝐺𝑒𝑛𝐷𝑖𝑣 + 𝛽$𝐵𝑜𝑆𝑖𝑧𝑒 + 𝛽%𝑅𝑜𝑙𝑒𝐷𝑢𝑎𝑙 + 𝛽&𝐵𝑜𝐼𝑛𝑑 + 𝛽'𝐵𝑜𝑀𝑒𝑒𝑡 + 𝛽(𝑆𝑖𝑧𝑒 + 𝛽)𝐿𝑒𝑣 + 𝛽!*profit + 𝜀 (2) 5. results 5.1 descriptive analysis the following table reports the descriptive statistics of all the variables. table 4: descriptive analysis variable | obs mean std. dev. min max -------------+-------------------------------------------------------- socialscore | 457 73.55954 15.43326 23.00668 98.22132 csrcomm | 457 .9037199 .2952982 0 1 gendiv | 457 34.96473 11.7173 0 69.23077 bosize | 457 10.91466 4.112367 2 28 roledual | 457 .2691466 .4440023 0 1 boind | 457 59.19293 24.84083 0 100 bomeet | 449 11.00445 5.827887 3 56 size | 457 22.44632 1.60134 18.00879 26.99351 lev | 456 .2284475 .1356608 0 .9066298 profit | 457 .0510317 .0657023 -.2163655 .433664 source: author´s elaboration the average social score recorded by sampled companies in 2021 is 73.55, revealing discreet attention to social issues. the minimum value is 23, and the maximum is 98.22. a csr committee is present in 90% of the sampled companies. the average percentage of women on the board is 34.96. considering that the average board size is 10, previous data reveal that approximately 3 or 4 directors are women on average. a total of 26.91 companies have a ceo who is also the board's chairman. the average percentage of independent directors sitting on the board is higher than that of women and is almost equal to 60%. finally, board members meet approximately once a month. before performing the regression analysis, the next table shows the correlation between all the variables. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7425 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 35 table 5: correlation matrix | socialscore bosize roledual csrcomm boind bomeet gendiv -------------+-------------------------------------------------------------- socialscore | 1.0000 bosize | 0.3459* 1.0000 roledual | 0.1520* 0.1411* 1.0000 csrcomm | 0.3378* 0.1919* 0.0643 1.0000 boind | 0.0687 -0.2542* -0.1391* 0.0613 1.0000 bomeet | -0.1096* -0.1874* -0.0856 0.0067 0.1461* 1.0000 gendiv | 0.1383* 0.0946* 0.1551* 0.1469* 0.0520 -0.0354 1.0000 size | 0.4985* 0.5429* 0.1416* 0.2412* 0.0695 -0.0657 0.1195* profit | 0.0053 -0.1210* 0.0507 0.0403 0.0416 -0.1039* 0.0060 lev | 0.0080 0.0252 -0.0300 0.0543 0.0513 0.1395* 0.0119 | size profit lev -------------+-------------------------- size | 1.0000 profit | -0.0520 1.0000 lev | 0.1267* -0.2733* 1.0000 note: *** p < 0.01, ** p < 0.05, * p < 0.1 source: author´s elaboration both csrcomm and gendiv are positively correlated with socialscore. moreover, bosize, roledual and size are also positively correlated with socialscore. bomeet, instead, presents a negative correlation with socialscore. 5.2 regression results the subsequent table shows the results of the regression analyses performed using stata software. table 6: regression results (dependent variable socialscore) variables model 1 model 2 csrcomm gendiv csrcomm*gendiv bosize roledual boind bomeet 11.5791*** (2.167769) .0372033 (.0534431) .3392589* (.1924118) 2.606915* (1.420351) .0449805* (.02663) -.1623585 (.1117212) 3.804429 (5.307205) -.1894688 (.151023) .2582784* (.1609875) .3601894* (.1925096) 2.670899* (1.418367) .0477557* (.0266385) -.1637325 (.1115243) european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7425 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 36 size profit lev constant 3.659373*** (.4813271) -1.238915 (9.849703) -5.642679 (4.753141) -24.3959*** (9.487964) 3.571471*** (.4835786) -1.277033 (9.832082) -5.475304 (4.745771) -16.19662 (10.76189) observations 448 448 adjusted r-squared 0.3046*** 0.3071*** source: author´s elaboration model 1 reports the results of the regression testing hypothesis h1 to understand the direct influence of csrcomm on socialscore. it shows a positive and statistically significant association between the presence of a csr committee and social pillar score (β = 11.5791, p < 0.01), meaning that the decision of the company to create a csr committee within the board brings greater attention to the social aspects of sustainability. concerning gender diversity, model 1 shows no significant relationship between the presence of women sitting on the board and the social pillar score. regarding the control variables, model 1 also shows that board size, role duality, board independence and firm size positively and significantly influence the social pillar score. model 2 shows the findings of the regression developed to test hypothesis h2, that is, the moderating effect of gendiv on the relationship between csrcomm and socialscore. the coefficient of the interaction term csrcomm*gendiv is positive and statistically significant (β =.2582784, p < 0.1), meaning that the presence of women sitting on the board positively moderates the relationship between the csr committee and the social pillar score. in other words, companies with a greater number of female directors present a stronger positive relationship between the existence of a csr committee and the social pillar score. 6. discussion and conclusions this paper focuses its attention on the impact that the presence of csr committees can have and the moderating role of board gender diversity in pursuing social objectives. the disaggregation of the effect that these variables can have on social performance has allowed us to consider a specific aspect of the esg approach that is critical for companies’ financial and nonfinancial health: a shared vision and modus operandi that can determine a positive relationship with stakeholders and create a common strategic and operational perspective. this motivation for this research derives from a gap in the research on the relationship between social performance and the related determinants that can be found in company governance. in this context, the research concludes that the presence of a csr committee contributes to greater efficacy in pursuing social matters. this supports the idea that esg issues require a specialized structure to assist the board of directors with social issues. this conclusion appears consistent with a body of literature examining csr and esg more generally (baraibar-diez e odriozola, 2019). structured governance can improve the esg approach of companies by enabling better control of delicate themes such as those included in the sp. it can consequently contribute to creating value in the medium and long term. the research also stresses that the presence of board diversity supports sp performance. this work suggests that companies with a more diversified board conduct aboard have better social performance. these results are also consistent with the previous literature (alijifri k & moustafa m., 2007) that has demonstrated how gender diversity enhances the tendency of corporate culture to integrate sustainability values (jizi et al., 2022). it has been confirmed that the diversity of perspectives and sensitivity a company uses in decision-making is significant for stakeholders’ engagement. moderation analysis shows that csr committees and boards are not replacements for one another, as both benefit the corporate pursuit of social themes (uyar et al., 2021). european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7425 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 37 this work confirms the adoption of agency theory and stakeholder theory. companies that apply control mechanisms that can protect people directly or indirectly involved in company management reduce agency conflicts and enhance stakeholder relations. there are many implications arising from this research. from a professional and practical point of view, companies should pay close attention to creating and managing csr committees, especially if we consider that they are mostly voluntary bodies. these results reflect the importance of promoting these instruments to enhance company attitudes towards sustainability. from an institutional perspective, regulators could consider amending their legislation, addressing the contribution provided by studies that demonstrate good practices and fair corporate behaviours. csr committees can provide greater assurance to stakeholders, especially in those contexts where there is a need to provide greater certainty about the company's ethical behaviour. at the same time, technical bodies have some additional data on which to base their codes and requirements. there are some limitations in this study. we considered only the european context. the enlargement of the sample could demonstrate if these results apply to other regional zones or are typical of only the european environment. we also considered the composition of csr committees and boards without investigating the skills of the component members. it seems that this variable can be crucial in analysing the collected data. it could highlight if the people involved are equally and highly qualified or if creating these conditions can always lead to better social performance. last, it must be stressed that the thomson reuters esg data, even if largely applied in these studies, reflect only the firm’s actual social improvements and not the company efforts produced to obtain social objectives. it could be interesting to reproduce this research by adopting other databases addressing esg efforts, such as bloomberg’s esg database, to test if the results are confirmed. references alijifri k & moustafa m., (2007) “the impact of corporate governance mechanisms on the performance of uae firms: an empirical analysis”, journal of economics and administrative sciences, vol 23, n. 2, pp. 71-93, https://doi.org/10.1108/10264116200700008. amran, a.; lee, s.p.; devi, s.s. (2014), “the influence of governance structure and strategic corporate social responsibility toward sustainability reporting quality”. business strategy environmental, vol 23, pp. 217–235. https://doi.org/10.1002/bse.1767 arayakarnkul, p. chatjuthamard, p. treepongkarun s. (2022) “board gender diversity, corporate social commitment and sustainability”, corporate social responsibility environmental management, vol, 29, issue 5, pp. 1706-1721. https://doi.org/10.1002/csr.2320 arayssi, m., dah, m. and jizi, m. (2016), “women on boards, sustainability reporting and firm performance”, sustainability accounting, management and policy journal, vol. 7 no. 3, pp. 376-401. https://doi.org/10.1108/sampj-072015-0055 arayssi, m., jizi, m. and tabaja, h. (2020), “the impact of board composition on the level of esg disclosures in gcc countries”, sustainability accounting, management and policy journal, vol. 11 no. 1, pp. 137161.https://doi.org/10.1108/sampj-05-2018-0136 ashfaq, k.; rui, z. (2018), “revisiting the relationship between corporate governance and corporate social and environmental disclosure practices in pakistan” social responsibility journal, vol 15, pp. 90–119. https://doi.org/10.1108/srj-01-2017-0001 baraibar-diez, e.; odriozola, m.d. (2019)”csr committees and their effect on esg performance in uk, france, germany and spain” sustainability, vol 11, 5077. https://doi.org/10.3390/su11185077 becker, g.s., (1962). “investment in human capital: a theoretical analysis”. journal of political economy vol 70, pp. 949 https://doi.org/10.1086/258724 beji, r., yousfi, o., loukil, n., & omri, a. (2021). “board diversity and corporate social responsibility: empirical evidence from france”. journal of business ethics, vol 173, pp.133-155. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10551-020-04522-4 bird, r., hall, a.d., momentè, f., reggiani, f., (2007.) “what corporate social responsibility activities are valued by the market?” journal of business ethics, vol 76, pp. 189-206. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10551-006-9268-1 european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7425 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 38 bruno a., lombardi r., mainolfi g., moretta tartaglione a., (2015) “reaserch perspective on corporate reputation and company’s performance measurement, “management control journal”, vol 3. doi: 10.3280/maco2015-003004 burke, j. j., hoitash, r., & hoitash, u. (2019). “the heterogeneity of board-level sustainability committees and corporate social performance”. journal of business ethics, vol 154, pp. 1161–1186. doi: 10.1007/s10551-017-3453-2 callegari m., desana e.r., sarale m., (2021). “speriamo che sia femmina: l’equilibrio fra i generi nelle società quotate e a controllo pubblico nell’esperienza italiana e comparata”, quaderni di dipartimento di giurisprudenza dell’università di torino, vol. 21, rubbettino editore. cucari, n.; de falco, s.e.; orlando, b. (2017) “diversity of board of directors and environmental social governance: evidence from italian listed companies” corporate social responsibility environmental management, vol 25, pp. 250–266. https://doi.org/10.1002/csr.1452 cummings, l. and patel, c. (2009), "chapter 2 stakeholder literature review", cummings, l. and patel, c. (ed.) managerial attitudes toward a stakeholder prominence within a southeast asia context (studies in managerial and financial accounting, vol. 19), emerald group publishing limited, bingley, pp. 17-51. https://doi.org/10.1108/s14793512(2009)0000019006 dorfleitner, g., kreuzer, c., sparrer, c, (2020) “esg controversies and controversial esg: about silent saints and small sinners) “, journal of asset management, vol 21 issue 5, pp. 393-412. doi:10.1057/s41260-020-00178-x eberhardt-toth, e. (2017) “who should be on a board corporate social responsibility committee? journal cleaning production, vol 140, pp. 1926–1935. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2016.08.127 eberhardt-toth, e.; caby, j.; gendron, c.; ramboarisata, l. (2019), “determinants of the presence of csr committees within european boards of directors”. e. responsib. organ. rev. vol 14, pp. 33–49. https://doi.org/10.3917/ror.141.0033 ec (2001), green paper (com(2001)366) promoting a european framework for corporate social responsibility. retrieved fromhttps://www.eumonitor.eu/9353000/1/j9vvik7m1c3gyxp/vikqhjet6py6 eu (2011), communication from the commission to the european parliament, the council, the european economic and social committee and the committee of the regions. a renewed eu strategy 2011-14 for corporate social responsibility. brussels, belgium: author. retrieved from https://eurlex.europa.eu/lexuriserv/lexuriserv.do?uri=com:2011:0681:fin:en:pdf francoeur, c., labelle, r., balti, s. and bouzaidi, s. (2019), “to what extent do gender diverse boards enhance corporate social performance?”, journal of business ethics, vol. 155 no. 2, pp. 343-357. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10551-017-3529-z garcia, a. s., mendes-da-silva, w., & orsato, r. j. (2017) “sensitive industries produce better esg performance: evidence from emerging markets” journal of cleaner production, vol 150, pp. 135-147 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2017.02.180 gurol, b., & lagasio, v. (2022). “women board members’ impact on esg disclosure with environment and social dimensions: evidence from the european banking sector. social responsibility journal. https://doi.org/10.1108/srj-08-20200308 govindana k, kilicc. m, uyard a, karamane a. s. (2021) “drivers and value-relevance of csr performance in the logistics sector: a cross-country firm-level investigation” international journal of production economics, vol 231. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijpe.2020.107835 john k, senbet l. w., (1998) “corporate governance and board effectiveness“, journal of banking & finance, vol 22, issue 4, pp. 371-403. https://doi.org/10.1016/s0378-4266(98)00005-3 hussain, n., rigoni u., & orij, r. p. (2018) “corporate governance and sustainability performance: analysis of triple bottom line performance”. journal of business ethics. vol 149, pp. 411-432. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10551-016-3099-5 jensen, m.c., meckling, w.h., (1976). “theory of the firm: managerial behavior, agency costs, and ownership structure. economic analysis of the law vol 3, issue 4, pp. 305–360. https://doi.org/10.1002/9780470752135.ch17. jiao, y., (2010).” stakeholder welfare and firm value”. journal of banking & finance, vol 34, pp. 25492561 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jbankfin.2010.04.013 jizi, m., nehme, r., & melhem, c. (2022). “board gender diversity and firms' social engagement in the gulf cooperation council (gcc) countries”. equality, diversity, and inclusion: an international journal, vol 41issue 2, pp. 186-206. https://doi.org/10.1108/edi-02-2021-0041 kassinis, g., panayiotou a, dimou a. katsifaraki g. (2016) “gender and environmental sustainability: a longitudinal analysis”, corporate social responsibility and environmental management, vol 23, issue 6, pp. 399-412. https://doi.org/10.1002/csr.1386 european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7425 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 39 khan, a., muttakin, m.b., siddiqui, j., (2013). “corporate governance and corporate social responsibility disclosures: evidence from an emerging economy”. j. bus. ethics, vol 114 issue 2, pp. 207–223. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10551-0121336-0. khwaja n. c.l. voinea z. ali, fawad r. cosmin f., (2021), “board gender diversity and corporate social performance in different industry groups: evidence from china”, sustainability, vol 13, issue 6, https://doi.org/10.3390/su13063142. leopizzi, r., iazzi, a., venturelli, a., & principale, s. (2020). “nonfinancial risk disclosure: the “state of the art” of italian companies”. corporate social responsibility and environmental management, vol 27, issue 1, pp. 358-368. https://doi.org/10.1002/csr.1810 li, t. t., wang, k., sueyoshi, t., & wang, d. d. (2021). “esg: research progress and future prospects”. sustainability, vol 13, issue 21, 11663. https://doi.org/10.3390/su132111663 marsat, s., williams, b., (2013). “csr and market valuation: international evidence”. bankers, markets & investors vol., 123, pp. 29-42. https://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.1833581 martínez-ferrero j. eryilmaz m. and colakoglu n. (2020) “how does board gender diversity influence the likelihood of becoming a un global compact signatory? the mediating effect of the csr committee”, sustainability vol 12, issue 10, 4329, pp1-19. marsat s., williams b., (2014) “does the market value social pillar?” http://ssrn.com/abstract=2419387 martínez-ferrero j., lozano m.b., vivas m. (2021) “the impact of board cultural diversity on a firm’s commitment toward the sustainability issues of emerging countries: the mediating effect of a csr committee”. corporate social responsibility and environmental management. vol 28 isue 2, pp. 675-685. https://doi.org/10.1002/csr.2080 michelon, g., parbonetti, a., (2012). “the effect of corporate governance on sustainability disclosure”. j. manag. govern. vol 16, issue 3, pp. 477–509. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10997010-9160-3. monteiro, a. p., garcía-sánchez, i. m., & aibar-guzmán, b. (2022). “labour practice, decent work and human rights performance and reporting: the impact of women managers”. journal of business ethics, vol. 180, issue 2, pp. 523-542. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10551-021-04913-1 murphy k. (2012). “the social pillar of sustainable development: a literature review and framework for policy analysis, sustainability: science”, practice and policy, vol 8, issue 1, pp.15-29, doi: 10.1080/15487733.2012.11908081. nicolò g., zampone g., sannino g., de iorio s. (2022) “sustainable corporate governance, and non-financial disclosure in europe: does the gender diversity matter?” journal of applied accounting research, vol 23 issue 1, pp. 227-249. https://doi.org/10.1108/jaar04-2021-0100 refinitiv (2022), environmental, social and governance scores. retrieved https://www.refinitiv.com/content/dam/marketing/en_us/documents/methodology/refinitiv-esg-scores-methodology.pdf. rené p. o., rehman s., hashim k., khan f., (2021) “is csr the new competitive environment for ceos? the association between ceo turnover, corporate social responsibility and board gender diversity: asian evidence”, corporate social responsibility and environmental management, vol.28, issue2, pp. 731-747. https://doi.org/10.1002/csr.2084 rossi, m., chouaibi, j., chouaibi, s., jilani, w., & chouaibi, y. (2021). does a board characteristic moderate the relationship between csr practices and financial performance? evidence from european esg firms. journal of risk and financial management, vol 14, issue 8, 354. https://doi.org/10.3390/jrfm14080354 scholtens, b., (2006). “finance as a driver of corporate social responsibility”. journal of business ethics, vol 68, pp. 19-33. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10551-006-9037-1 secinaro s., brescia v., calandra d., buerahn saiti, (2020) “impact of climate change mitigation policies on corporate financial performance: evidence-based on european publicly listed firms”, corporate social responsibility and environmental management, https://doi.org/10.1002/csr.1971. shahid a.u., patel c., peipei p. (2022) “corporate social responsibility, intrinsic religiosity, and investment decisions” journal of behavioural and experimental finance, vol, 34, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jbef.2022.100650 spitzeck, h. (2009). “organizational structures and processes: the development of governance structures for corporate responsibility”. corporate governance international journal of business in society. vol 9 issue 4, pp. 495-505. https://doi.org/10.1108/14720700910985034 stevens, c. (2010). are women the key to sustainable development. sustainable development insights, vol 3, issue 11, pp. 1-8. uyar, a., kilic, m., koseoglu, m. a., kuzey, c., & karaman, a. s. (2020). “the link among board characteristics, corporate social responsibility performance, and financial performance: evidence from the hospitality and tourism industry.” tourism management perspectives, vol 35, 100714. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tmp.2020.100714 european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7425 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 40 uyar, a., kuzey, c., kilic, m., & karaman, a. s. (2021). b”oard structure, financial performance, corporate social responsibility performance, csr committee, and ceo duality: disentangling the connection in healthcare”. corporate social responsibility and environmental management, vol 28, issue 6, pp. 1730-1748. https://doi.org/10.1002/csr.2141 veltri s., mazzotta r., rubino f.e., (2021) “board diversity and corporate social performance: does the family firm status matter?” corporate social responsibility environmental management, vol 28, pp. 1664–1679. https://doi.org/10.1002/csr.2136 wei s., veenstra k., (2021) “the moderating effect of cultural values on the relationship between corporate social performance and firm performance”, journal of business ethics, vol 174, pp. 89–107 https://doi.org/10.1007/s10551-02004555-9 zumente, i., & bistrova, j. (2021). “esg importance for long-term shareholder value creation: literature vs. practice”. journal of open innovation: technology, market, and complexity, vol 7, issue 2, 127. https://doi.org/10.3390/joitmc7020127 yadav, p. and prashar, a. (2022), "board gender diversity: implications for environment, social, and governance (esg) performance of indian firms", international journal of productivity and performance management, https://doi.org/10.1108/ijppm-12-2021-0689. usón a.a,. moneva j.m., scarpellini s. (2022) “sustainability accounting and the introduction of the circular economy principles in businesses“, european journal of social impact and circular economy vol 3, n. 3. https://doi.org/10.13135/2704-9906/6817 urmanaviciene a. udara s. a. (2020) “the effective methods and practices for accelerating social entrepreneurship through corporate social responsibility“, european journal of social impact and circular economy, vol 1, issue 2, pp. 27-47. https://doi.org/10.13135/2704-9906/5085 urmanaviciene a. (2020) “wises’ social impact measurement in the baltic states”, european journal of social impact and circular economy, vol 1, issue 2, pp. 48-75. https://doi.org/10.13135/2704-9906/5091 5158-article text-17216-1-9-20210223 european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5158 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 75 moderating role of organizational culture between adoption of agile project management methodology and project success ali hasan1, muhammad zeb khan2, ubaid ur rehman3 1 project management, szabist, islamabad, pakistan 2 project management, szabist, islamabad, pakistan 3 project management, szabist, islamabad, pakistan e-mail: hasan582@gmail.com1; dr.zeb@szabist-isb.edu.pk2; ubaidq1993@gmail.com3 received: 02/10/2020 revised: 26/12/2020 accepted for publication: 27/12/2020 published: 08/03/2021 abstract purpose of this research is to investigate the moderating role of organizational culture between adoption of agile project management methodology and project success, as well as impact of agile project management methodology on project success. the data for this study has been collected from telecommunication services provider industry of pakistan. total sample size of 197 professionals was recorded. a questionnaire was distributed among the participants via hard copy and internet survey websites. using collected data, we tested the effect of agile project management methodology on project success and further examined the moderating effect of organizational support between agile project management methodology and project success. the examination included pearson’s correlation coefficient as well as regression using ibm spss statistics version 20. results indicated that project management methodology has a strong correlation with project success and this correlation is not moderated by organizational support. the research findings have practical implications both in organization and project manager’s perspectives. our research was limited to specific geographic area due to time and cost constraints. future researchers may opt to conduct the study in other geographic areas of pakistan and different industry including additional and different moderating variables. keywords: project management methodologies, agile, iterative, project success, organizational support, telecom industry european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5158 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 75 1. introduction worldwide, there has been an intense debate to define / redefine theory of project management for complex and uncertain project situations (koskela & howell, 2002) argued that traditional theory of project management is outdated especially in managing uncertainty and rapidly changing project environment. projects that are complex in nature, uncertain and time-constrained therefore traditional project management methodology can be inappropriate and potentially unfavorable (t. williams, 2005). companies are facing many challenges and changes in process to adopt agile project management methodology (pace, 2019). transformation in organizational culture is one of them. with substantial increase in research on project management methodologies and its effect on project success it was found that traditional project management methodology was not giving optimal results in certain scenarios (dybå & dingsøyr, 2008) therefore researchers and practitioners started looking for alternative methods for project implementation. earlier agile project management methodology was developed as an alternative to traditional project management methodology as it offers less risk, more visibility, increased business value, more adaptability, faster delivery and reduced costs (canty, 2015) also stakeholders' feedback has been given extra value in agile project management methodology which proved to be beneficial (highsmith, 2003). project efficiency/success is measured as performance of the project management methodology (serrador & pinto, 2015) against the time, cost and quality constraints (triple constraints) of the project. the direct effect of agile project management methodology on project success remain implicit and is not directly addressed in the most focused and concerted way in the available literature yet. to explore this an empirical study on effect of agile project management methodology and its effect on project success with moderating role of organizational culture. the present study adds value to theory and practice in multiple ways. first, it evaluates the direct relationship between agile project management methodology and project success. second, it investigates the moderating role of organizational culture in the relationship between agile project management methodology and project success. by using a structural equation modeling (sem) technique for agile project management methodology, we will test and validate that organizational culture can work together for project success. this study will be a value addition in literature and help policy makers in organizations in adopting correct project management methodology to increase project success rate. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5158 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 76 researchers (bloch, blumberg, & laartz, 2012) found that project failure can be so disastrous for a company that it may threaten the existence of the company. these alarming situations put scholars and practitioners in search of solutions to the cater the problem of project failure and to produce consistent project success. this outlines the underlying issue driving this study further research is needed to examine the relationship between successful delivery and project management methodology (garland, 2009; joslin & müller, 2016; pinto, 2014; turner & keegan, 2001; ul musawir, abd-karim, & mohd-danuri, 2020). considerable attention have been given to agile project management methodology during the last 02 decades (dybå & dingsøyr, 2008) researchers recommended that organizations are required to be more agile, more adaptable to changes to achieve more success (sherehiy, karwowski, & layer, 2007). historical models and studies on project management methodology were mainly focused on project governance and its role in project decision making, project success and strategy implementation(garland, 2009; joslin & müller, 2016; pinto, 2014; turner & keegan, 2001; ul musawir et al., 2020). however, the effect of implementation of agile project management methodology and its effect on project success remain implicit and is not directly addressed in the most focused and concerted way in the available literature yet. research is fairly new in this field, several characteristics e.g. collaboration, modularity, iteration, time-bounding, parsimony, adaptiveness and incremental development (miller, 2001) are to be associated with the agile project management, organizational culture and project success. we will be exploring the new avenues to test effectiveness of the agile philosophy and its relationship with project success. though agile project management methodology is popular due to many reasons (less risk, more visibility, increased business value, more adaptability, faster delivery and reduced costs) but researchers need to explore the possibilities to make this claim valid. so far, previous research on agile project management methodology was incidental and more focused research in this area will help practitioners and researchers to add value in agile project management methodology literature and practical implementation. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5158 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 77 (lee & xia, 2010) have concluded after quantitative and qualitative analysis on software development agility that there is no positive relationship between agile project management methodology and the project success. the adoption of the agile methods in any organization is not unproblematic challenges are being encountered while migrating to agile project management methodologies (boehm & turner, 2005; chan & thong, 2009; cockburn & highsmith, 2001) and employees behave reluctantly in accepting this transformation (nerur, mahapatra, & mangalaraj, 2005). the main objective of this research is to investigate that for achieving project success adoption of agile project management methodology works better than traditional project management approaches with moderating role of organizational culture. agile project management methodology has become a preferable approach for planning and executing projects (pace, 2019) however there are still some issues in adoption of agile culture in organizations. the purpose of this paper is to investigate, through a quantitative study, the evidence that that for achieving higher rate of project success adoption of agile project management methodology works better than traditional project management approaches with moderating effect of organizational culture this research sheds light on: to determine the impact of adoption of agile project management methodology and its effect on project success. to check moderating role of organizational culture between agile project management methodology and project success. following questions will be addressed in this research paper. to what extent does agile project management methodology influence project success? to what extent does project management methodology influence project success and is this relationship influenced by moderating role of organizational culture? european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5158 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 78 2. literature review 2.1. concept and definitions with ever growing complexity of the projects, organizations seems to be more vigilant in choosing a suitable application of project management methodology (joslin & müller, 2016) as it plays a very critical role in making a project successful or failure. up till now, research and the findings on project management methodologies are biased to some extent e.g., available literature is divided on whether success of the project is directly related to project methodologies or not (lehtonen & martinsuo, 2006). while researching the impact of project management methodologies on project success (milosevic & patanakul, 2005) inferred that project management methodologies, higher or singular level, may not be sufficient in concluding the effect of project management methodology on project success. to get a complete understanding and clarification of project management methodology element(s) and their inconsistent impact on project success in depth analysis and knowledge is required as some element(s) may have a greater impact on project success in collective manner than being studied alone. 2.2. agile project management methodology integration of planning and execution phase is core of agile project management methodology which allows an organization to build up a working force capable of responding to emerging requirements in an efficient manner through collaborative working and then prioritizing work packages i.e. lowest level of wbs. although the agile techniques are set of guidelines that are performed in the software development and it is new method to achieve the project goals and to quickly perform the tasks by reducing the impact of the factors that delay the project. meaning of term agile is comprehensible, adoption of agile project management methodology is making a paradigm shift in project management techniques by using best practices of management science (anderson, 2004). agile project management methodology focuses on delivering maximum value against business priorities i.e. features of the product by applying very tight discipline to "time and cost" and keeping iteration on review and prioritization of the features whereas in traditional project management approaches feature were considered to be fixed by the time the project is initiated. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5158 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 79 figure 1 what's different about agile? source: author elaboration whenever any organization decides to adopt agile project management methodology major change in traditional culture, mindset and sometime in project team are also required. considering the need for smoothing the process of project planning, the iterative technique was introduced in which re-planning during the execution phase of the project was considered. experienced project managers believe that margin should be kept in planning phase of the project considering the uncertain environment and changing business needs so that adjustments can be made at the later stages of planning as well. agile technique therefore was required to deal with such needs of the project managers where they can modify plans in accordance with the demanding situations. in 2001, the "agile manifesto" was written which states that agile implementation need to cognizance on 04 values and 12 principles (dybå & dingsøyr, 2008) which are that there should be interaction among the individuals over the technique, there should be interactions with the client and their requirements should be negotiated and lastly the plan should be changed according the responses received. project documentation is not a top priority in the agile project management methodology like traditional project management and this is to facilitate the project managers in the dynamic environment where the plans need not to be rigid and there is a cushion so that the response can be documented by project managers when and where required. it is also to be noted that unlike traditional planning techniques, in agile more flexibility is utilized for project management. (lindvall et al., 2002) stated that the agile strategies have turned out to be more effective because they immediately deal with the issues that are raised specially when the projects are being executed and managed in dynamic environments. project managers from numerous organizations were interviewed to validate this and it was inferred that project managers need to modify their plans according to the changing timelines, resources, techniques etc. (collyer, warren, hemsley, & stevens, 2010). although european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5158 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 80 agile is flexible method of project planning and changes can be later made but it is also important to note that the agile project management methodology does not ignore the planning in the earlier stage of the project. the fact is to be understood that the planning phase in agile method is not just confined to one point but is spread over the course of cycle in place of plans been made in one go. figure 2 agile project management methodology source: author elaboration (serrador & turner, 2015) analyzed 1386 projects and found an inverted-u relationship between agile project planning and success of the project, in terms of planning time. by this study, they observed that if much amount of time is given to the planning it will have a negative impact on the project success, and vice versa. (mann & maurer, 2005) explained that thorough iterative planning technique in agile project management methodology success rate of the projects can be increased. with ever growing popularity of agile project management methodology one limitation of agile project management methodology was also under observation of researchers and it was concluded that agile technique can't be applied on megascale projects however in small-scale projects it is considered to be most effective and followed technique (paasivaara, lassenius, heikkilä, dikert, & engblom, 2013). most of this analysis is based on narratives and smaller number of samples were studied. an example can be quoted to explain this, 48 respondents were interviewed from 08 groups to study the variation among organizations that have adopted the agile techniques of project planning and organization that have not yet adopted the agile planning technique. it was noted that the project success in terms of completing the project withing budget and time was similar in both agile and non-agile organizations (feldt & magazinius, 2010) it was also concluded that although planning strategies have progressed through the years, there are other elements too which are european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5158 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 81 to be associated with the non-compliance of project goals. the consequences of such research have confused organizations for the adoption of agile planning technique. 2.3. project success to have a holistic view and to obtain a learning opportunity for future project, scope, schedule, cost, team satisfaction, customer satisfaction and quality are the main objective and subjective criteria which are considered to measure the true effectiveness of the project. project success could also be summarized by comprehensive assessment of external factors starting from initiation, planning, execution, monitoring and control to the closing phase. for a project to be successful there must be acknowledgement of the role of project management within project. adopting a relevant and efficient project management methodology is very vital for achieving project success. many researchers have tried to make a consensus on notion of project success and believed that the conventional / traditional project management methodologies were mainly focused on triple constraints of pmi i.e. time, scope and cost and producing a quality project (parker, parsons, & isharyanto, 2015; p. williams, ashill, naumann, & jackson, 2015). there are 10 dimensions of success of project described by (müller & turner, 2007) while they were contributing to the research and have great collection of study on the capabilities of the project managers. (kloppenborg, manolis, & tesch, 2009) restated similar concept that project success is linked with the traditionally used triple constraints where all these collectively contribute as the necessary elements of the project success. a vast correlation among efficiency of project and success of the project was found by (serrador & turner, 2015) they argued the efficiency is not alone measurement scale for project success, but it also can't be overlooked while (pinto, 2014) focused on satisfaction of stakeholder expectations. the use of right project management methodology to deliver unique results does involve financial investment for organizations (fisher, 2011). project success is now being measured through the lens of organizational achievement instead of meeting the constraints. 2.4. organizational culture culture is the environment we live in. organizational culture is a system of the shared values, beliefs, ideologies, principles, attitudes and the set of assumptions (mclaughlin, 2013) also unwritten rules that have been developed over time and are european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5158 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 82 considered to be integral part of social and psychological environment of an organization. these rules and values are required to abided by the employees. these values, beliefs, ideologies, principles, attitudes and the set of assumptions have a strong influence on the employees in the organization and outside the organization (iivari & iivari, 2011). according to the previous research (iivari & huisman, 2007) organizational culture is based on vision, values, norms, systems, symbols, language, assumptions, beliefs, and habits of the organization. the model presented by (quinn, 1984; quinn & rohrbaugh, 1983) was mainly focused on values as core constituents of organizational culture. organizational culture has been associated with different opinions (smircich, 1983) presented a framework in which system development depends upon organizational culture. (cameron & quinn, 2011) explained that there are 04 types of organizational cultures: clan (family-like), adhocracy (dynamic and entrepreneurial), market (results oriented), and hierarchy (structured and controlled). organizational culture, more particularly, influence employees’ insights of the work environment and their behaviors and creates a relatively more homogeneous working environment among employees which directly impacts organizational progress and functioning (borucki & burke, 1999). specific research has also been done on the relationship between agile project management methodology adoption and organizational culture (siakas & siakas, 2007; strode, huff, & tretiakov, 2009; tolfo & wazlawick, 2008) and its effects (robinson & sharp, 2005) which clearly depicts a strong impact of organizational culture on transforming behaviors of employees. different studies identified and recommended certain characteristics to achieve the compatibility with agile project management methodology. few researchers argued hard to change the entire culture of the organization (tolfo & wazlawick, 2008; tolfo, wazlawick, ferreira, & forcellini, 2011) though it’s quite difficult. 2.5. agile project management methodology and project success research on the project success and project management has been carried out for more than 03 decades but in the recent times adoption of agile project management methodology has shown a significant improvement in statistics of project success and it is dominating other project management methodologies (stankovic, nikolic, djordjevic, & cao, 2013). after thoroughly analyzing the data available from previous researchers (sheffield & lemétayer, 2013) concluded that culture of the organization is the key aspect of the project success. agile project management methodology has evolved substantially to respond to the modifications that were required during the course of the project. this paradigm shift from conventional project management methodology like waterfall to agile project management methodology was not only limited to software-based industries (serrador & pinto, 2015) due to the facts that it is different and efficient in project results. agile project management methodology emphasis on communication with all the stakeholders at each level of the planning to cater the ongoing changes which make agile project management methodology the best iterative technique in project management. organizations should be extra cautious in understanding agile project management european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5158 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 83 methodology before adoption (nerur et al., 2005). agile project management methodology is not only limited to software industry. traditional project management methodology is outdated, complicated in nature and becoming obsolete with time. (conforto, salum, amaral, da silva, & de almeida, 2014) said that opportunities must be created within the organizations / industries to implement agile project management methodology for achieving project success. many researchers have denied the fact that project success is related to agile project management methodology adoption as not much difference was observed between the companies that are using agile project management methodology and the companies which use conventional / traditional project management methodology. seasoned project managers and (magazinius & feldt, 2011) concluded that project success is not only a factor to measure relation between project management methodology adoption and project success. a distinction of opinion has been highlighted within available literature and therefore aim of this paper is to examine through quantitative analysis the relation between the adoption of agile project management methodology and success of the project. 2.6. moderating role of organizational culture between agile project management methodology and project success it is not easy to change the culture of any organization overnight and if project success is intended then agile project management methodology should be blended with traditional project management technique (boehm, 2002). transformation in organizational culture is essential for agile project management methodology adoption (pace, 2019) as there are many challenges and changes to overcome during this process. researchers also recommended that organizations and enterprises need to be more responsive to change to achieve higher project success rate (sherehiy et al., 2007). project management institute (pmi) in their annual global survey of project, program and portfolio track and publish the major trends in project management and in edition of 2017 pmi mentioned that ‘organizational culture sets the tone that change the work-life experiences of employees which ultimately translated in to organizational and project success’. previous researchers (cameron & quinn, 2011) examined the 04 types of organizational cultures and how it contributes to projects success and summarized that clan orientation culture (family-like) had the strongest association with project success and organizational culture. agile method strongly advocates that organizational culture has an effect on the extent to which an agile method european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5158 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 84 is used and for effective and efficient creation of project management culture, organizations must understand the benefits it can bring along with. 2.7. summary of literature hypothesis and conceptual framework for this research study listed as: figure 3 theoretical model underlying empirical research source: author elaboration h1: agile project management methodology is positively and significantly associated with project success. h2: organizational culture moderates the relationship between agile project management methodology and project success. 3. method research was carried out to find how the impact of agile project management methodology relates with the project success with moderating role of organizational culture. questionnaire was developed on the basis of previously established questions available in literature. the survey questionnaire contained two (02) sections, including demographic information while the other part comprised of questions related to variables under investigation. we have used three (03) variables naming agile project management methodology (apm), organizational culture (oc) and project success (ps) these variables were measured using 5-point likert scale that ranges from 01 (strongly agreed) to 05 (strongly disagreed). seven (07) questions for variable apm were adopted from research work of (lu & ramamurthy, 2011), twelve (12) questions related to oc were taken from research work of (iivari & iivari, 2011) and four (04) questions for variable ps were adopted from research work of (aga, 2016). european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5158 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 85 main reason for adopting the questionnaire owes to its appropriateness in measuring adoption of agile project management methodology, organizational culture and project success. all the variables and measurement items are mentioned in appendix a 3.1. research design and data collection data collection for this research study has been conducted through “questionnaire” technique. the population selected for this study was telecommunication services provider industry of pakistan. the use of simple random sample selection allows researchers to determine the appropriate sample size of participants, which can be generalized to a larger population (trochim, 2006). the sampling frame consisted of individuals and non-probability sampling technique was adopted, based on their willingness to participate. initially questionnaire was distributed to the employees working in different telecommunication services providing organization operating in pakistan which includes huawei, jazz, ptcl, telenor, ufone, zong and zte. respondents were selected randomly and there were no specific numbers for any organization, role, gender etc. the study was performed from february to may 2020. initially fifty (50) questionnaires were distributed with 41 returned out of which 38 were valid questionnaires in second phase of data collection due to covid-19 pandemic it was not possible to collect the response through visits and meetings. therefore, researcher utilized ‘surveymonkey’ and ‘google forms’ to deliver the questionnaire and 159 responses were recorded via internet which makes the total to 197 responses. 3.2. data analysis detailed analysis of the collected survey responses was performed vi statistical package for the social sciences (spss). the data was confirmed to have no missing values which might prevent accurate analysis. the results of skewness and kurtosis with respect to each variable independently shows that all the values are well within range. the reliability of every variable scale used was tested through cronbach's alpha (ά) calculation and all the values of cronbach’s ά were greater than 0.7, which confirms that the questionnaire has a very good reliability. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5158 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 86 table 1 results of reliability reliability statistics variable name cronbach's alpha ά number of items agile project management methodology (apm) 0.872 7 organizational culture (oc) 0.843 12 project success (ps) 0.893 4 source: author elaboration data preparation for factor analysis was done using kaiser-meyer-olkin (kmo) and bartlett's tests. kmo measure of sampling adequacy value is greater than 0.4 that indicates that sample is adequate. bartlett's test of sphericity significance level is less than 0.05 which indicates that factor loading analysis is suitable for the data. table 2 kmo and bartlett's test kaiser-meyer-olkin (kmo) measure of sampling adequacy .837 bartlett's test of sphericity (sig.) .000 source: author elaboration 4. result research survey questionnaire also includes demographic scale such as the gender, age, qualifications and experience of the respondents. 66% respondent were male, 72% respondent holding project management experience, 79% respondent have experience between 8 to 11 years, and 95% respondent working on projects. descriptive analysis shows that variables distributions proved to be normal, skewness and kurtosis with respect to each variable independently shows that the values are well within range. in our factor analysis any value less than 0.70 have been be dropped in order to have acceptable results overall. therefore, values against apm6, apm7, oc5, oc8, oc10 and oc12 were dropped in further analysis. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5158 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 87 4.1. variable relationship correlation tells the intensity of the relationship between all the variables under discussion pearson. correlation analysis was conducted for this research work which shows that the relationship between apm and oc is very weak and not significant (+0.080), relationship between apm and ps is very strong and significant (+0.733) and relationship between oc and ps is weak but significant (+0.010). table 3 correlation between variables apm oc ps agile project management methodology (apm) pearson correlation 1 sig. (2-tailed) n organizational culture (oc) pearson correlation .080 1 sig. (2-tailed) .262 n 197 109 project success (ps) pearson correlation .733** .184** 1 sig. (2-tailed) .000 .010 n 197 197 ** correlation is significant at the 0.01 level (2-tailed). source: author elaboration 4.2. linear regression in our study linear regression analysis shows adjusted r square value 0.535 that shows independent variable agile project management methodology (apm) will bring 53.5% change in dependent variable project success (ps). to calculate variable moderation effect, direct & indirect effects and conditional effects of moderator variable i.e. organizational culture (oc) researchers’ used model number-1 of preacher and hayes with bootstrap (n = 1000, 95% ci) using spss path r-sq. adjusted r sq. beta value t value p value apmà ps .537 .535 .733 15.037 .000 model summary from the results we can clearly observe that model is significant. moderator (oc) have significant positive effect on project success as p-value < 0.05. results shows that with addition of organization culture support project success is enhanced. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5158 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 88 r r-sq. mse f df-1 df-2 p value .745 .555 6.457 88.810 3.000 193.0 .000 model details coeff se t p llci ulci constant 14.839 0.183 80.903 0 14.478 15.201 oc 0.105 0.042 2.513 0.013 0.023 0.187 apm 0.794 0.05 15.938 0 0.696 0.893 int_1 -0.013 0.015 -0.853 0.395 -0.043 0.017 agile project management methodology is showing significant positive effect on project success as pvalue < 0.05 and effect of agile project management methodology (79.4%) is much higher than organizational culture (10.5%). in interaction-1 (int_1) it is visible that confidence interval i.e. llci and ulci values range from -.043 to .017 and it contains value 0 in its range which depicts that in our moderation interaction is not significance. further it is interesting to note here that interaction have a negative effect (-.013) and with p-value (0.395) > 0.05 means it is statistically insignificant relationship. table 7 conditional effect of x on y at values of the moderator(s) level oc effect se t p llci ulci low -4.866 0.857 0.091 9.44 0 0.678 1.036 medium 0 0.794 0.05 15.938 0 0.696 0.893 high 4.866 0.732 0.087 8.421 0 0.56 0.903 *values for quantitative moderators are the mean and plus/minus one sd from mean. *values for dichotomous moderators are the two values of the moderator. source: author elaboration moderator value(s) defining johnson-neyman significance region(s) table 8 johnson-neyman conditional effect of x on y at values of the moderator(s) oc effect se t p llci ulci -7.191 0.824 0.162 5.074 0.000 0.502 1.146 -6.227 0.791 0.142 5.552 0.000 0.509 1.074 -5.263 0.758 0.123 6.152 0.000 0.514 1.002 -4.298 0.725 0.105 6.904 0.000 0.516 0.933 -3.334 0.691 0.088 7.816 0.000 0.516 0.867 -2.37 0.658 0.075 8.795 0.000 0.51 0.806 -1.406 0.625 0.066 9.483 0.000 0.494 0.755 european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5158 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 89 oc effect se t p llci ulci -0.441 0.591 0.064 9.293 0.000 0.465 0.718 0.523 0.558 0.069 8.117 0.000 0.422 0.695 1.487 0.525 0.08 6.575 0.000 0.367 0.683 2.452 0.492 0.095 5.186 0.000 0.304 0.68 3.416 0.458 0.112 4.089 0.000 0.236 0.681 4.38 0.425 0.131 3.25 0.002 0.166 0.685 5.344 0.392 0.15 2.605 0.011 0.094 0.69 6.309 0.359 0.171 2.102 0.038 0.02 0.697 6.574 0.349 0.176 1.983 0.05 0.000 0.699 7.273 0.325 0.191 1.701 0.092 -0.054 0.704 8.237 0.292 0.212 1.377 0.171 -0.128 0.713 9.202 0.259 0.233 1.11 0.27 -0.204 0.721 10.166 0.226 0.254 0.887 0.377 -0.279 0.73 11.13 0.192 0.276 0.697 0.487 -0.354 0.739 12.094 0.159 0.297 0.535 0.594 -0.43 0.748 source: author elaboration further johnson-neyman conditional effect of x on y at different values of the moderator was studied which shows that up to a certain level moderator (oc) helps in creating a positive effect of iv (apm) on dv (ps) beyond that effect becomes insignificant i.e. p-value > 0.05 figure 4 moderating effect of organizational culture source: author elaboration hence, we can conclude that oc has insignificant moderator effect on relationship apm and ps. whereas, conditional effect of x on y at different levels of the moderator (low, medium and high level) depicts that when the value of moderator (oc) is increased value of effect of iv (apm) on dv (ps) tends to decrease. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5158 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 90 results of hypothesis the results of hypothesis after detailed analysis is mentioned in table 9 table 9 result of hypothesis sr. no. hypothesis result 1 agile project management methodology is positively and significantly associated with project success. supported 2 organizational culture moderates the relationship between agile project management methodology and project success. not supported source: author elaboration 5. discussion the relationship between project success and agile project management methodology is a noteworthy issue. reasons for this are the profusion of the concept of organizational culture, popularity of agile methodology for project planning and execution, ambiguity of the concept of agility in the context of project management and the variety of ways the two variables may be related with each other. while the theories that support agile project management methodology adoption are attractive and logical what has been missing is empirical validation. projects with agile project management methodology are more likely to succeed than the one that relies on traditional approaches ? our findings suggest that there is research support for the application of agile project management methodology in achieving higher project success rate. this study described whether and how agile project management methodology effects the project success through a comprehensive and empirical analysis of telecommunication services provider industry of pakistan. study also discussed that with varying levels of agile approaches project success factor can be increased. our findings offer limited support for previous research work by (budzier & flyvbjerg, 2013) in which the relationship between agile project management methodology and project success was explored in data set of it projects and they found that agile project management methodology appears to improve project delivery times but no evidence was found that agile project management methodology have positive impact on other success factors. an insignificant moderator effect of organizational culture was observed between agile project management methodology and project success, through the bootstrapping results. there is also additional empirical european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5158 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 91 evidence resulted out of this study to support the fact that organizations and enterprises need to be more agile, more responsive to changes to achieve more success (sherehiy et al., 2007). 6. conclusion aim of this study was to explore the direct effect of agile project management methodology on project success and what are the indirect effect of agile project management methodology on project success via organizational culture. there was positive relationship witnessed between agile project management methodology on project success. on the other hand, the proposed moderator organizational culture has insignificant effect on relationship between agile project management methodology and project success. it is interesting to note that our original regression analysis showed statistical significance but low values for percentage of variance explained (r2). it is witnessed that up to a certain level moderator helps in creating a positive effect of iv on dv after which if level of organizational culture is increased the effect of agile project management methodology on project success becomes insignificant. 6.1. theoretical and practical implications this study has enabled us to understand the concept of agile project management methodology, organizational culture and how these variables effects project success via their relationship as described in theoretical framework. we have examined the linking of agile project management methodology and project success through telecommunication professionals sample. first, agile project management methodology has been studied with regards to the project success perspective and then addition of proposed moderator organizational culture. this study is an addition to literature of agile project management methodology and provides a guideline to the policy makers in organizations that are striving to maximize project success and are not very clear about the adoption of effective and efficient project management methodology. we have also found that the theoretical model got the practical implications, both for the managers and organization involved in project. this study can be referred to adopt these changes establishing relationships between agile project management methodology, project success and organizational culture. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5158 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 92 6.2. limitation and future work although our findings offered some intriguing perspectives on the adoption of agile project management methodology and its direct impact on project success, there were also some limitations to the study that need to be acknowledged. first, ‘non-response’ errors in survey questionnaire i.e. the participants fail to understand and respond to particular questions in its true essence and ‘response error’ survey questionnaire i.e. where the participant does not give an accurate response or gives an incomplete response (cooper & schindler, 2001). secondly, limitation of this research was an examination of the impact of underlying factors of organizational cultural behaviors (shared values, beliefs, ideologies, principles, attitudes etc.) on the relationship between agile project management methodology and project success. although agile has been used for project planning for several years now, to our knowledge, this research report is one of the first empirical studies on adoption of the of agile methods for project success in telecommunication sector of pakistan. future researchers should examine underlying factors of organizational culture and establish their relationship with project success, as measured by multiple perspectives (efficiency, stakeholder satisfaction etc.) and using different flavors of agile project management methodology (agile scrum methodology, lean software development, kanban, extreme programming etc.) conflict of interest there is no conflict of interest acknowledgement: authors express his gratitude and thanks to szabist for their supervision, technical support and guidance in this research. in addition, also thanks for providing partial institutional support. funding this research based on the academic point of view and receive no funding from any organization or institution. appendix a measurements for agile project management methodology (apm), organizational culture (oc) and project success (ps) european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5158 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 93 variable name measurement question agile project management methodology (apm) apm-1: we are quick to make and implement appropriate decisions in the face of market/customerchanges. apm-2: we constantly look for ways to reinvent/reengineer our organization to better serve our market place. apm-3: we utilize our skills better in agile practice. apm-4: we fulfill demands for rapid-response, special requests of our customers whenever such demands arise; our customers have confidence in our ability. apm-5: we can quickly scale up or scale down our production/service levels to support fluctuations in demand from the market. apm-6: where necessary, members of this team try to simplify existing code without changing its functionality. apm-7: whenever there is a disruption in supply from our suppliers we can quickly make necessary alternative arrangements and internal adjustments. organizational culture (oc) oc-1: the organization values feedback and learning. oc-2: social interaction in the organization is trustful, collaborative, and competent. oc-3: the organization values teamwork. oc-4: the organization is flexible and participative and encourages social interaction. oc-5: the project manager acts as a facilitator. oc-6: the organization enables empowerment of people. oc-7: the management style is that of leadership and collaboration. oc-8: the organization values face-to-face communication. oc-9: communication in the organization is informal. oc-10: the organization is results oriented. oc-11: the leadership in this organization is entrepreneurial, innovative, and risk taking. oc-12: the organization is based on loyalty and mutual trust and commitment. project success (ps) ps-1: the project was completed on time when agile methodology was followed. ps-2: the project was completed according to the budget allocated in agile practice. ps-3: agile project specifications were met by the time of handover to the target beneficiaries. ps-4: given the problem for which it was developed in agile environment, the project seems to do the best job of solving that problem. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5158 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 94 references aga, d. a. (2016). transactional leadership and project success: the moderating role of goal clarity. procedia computer science, 100(1), 517-525. anderson, d. j. (2004). making the business case for agile management: simplifying the complex system of software engineering. bloch, m., blumberg, s., & laartz, j. (2012). delivering large-scale it projects on time, on budget, and on value. harvard business review, 2-7. boehm, b. (2002). get ready for agile methods, with care. computer, 35(1), 64-69. boehm, b., & turner, r. (2005). management challenges to implementing agile processes in traditional development organizations. ieee software, 22(5), 30-39. borucki, c. c., & burke, m. j. (1999). an examination of service‐related antecedents to retail store performance. journal of organizational behavior, 20(6), 943-962. budzier, a., & flyvbjerg, b. (2013). making sense of the impact and importance of outliers in project management through the use of power laws. proceedings of irnop (international research network on organizing by projects), at oslo, 11. cameron, k. s., & quinn, r. e. (2011). diagnosing and changing organizational culture: based on the competing values framework: john wiley & sons. canty, d. (2015). agile for project managers: crc press. chan, f. k., & thong, j. y. (2009). acceptance of agile methodologies: a critical review and conceptual framework. decision support systems, 46(4), 803-814. cockburn, a., & highsmith, j. (2001). agile software development, the people factor. computer, 34(11), 131-133. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5158 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 95 collyer, s., warren, c., hemsley, b., & stevens, c. (2010). aim, fire, aim—project planning styles in dynamic environments. project management journal, 41(4), 108-121. conforto, e. c., salum, f., amaral, d. c., da silva, s. l., & de almeida, l. f. m. (2014). can agile project management be adopted by industries other than software development? project management journal, 45(3), 21-34. cooper, d., & schindler, p. (2001). business research methods boston: mcgraw-hiiiln\'in. dybå, t., & dingsøyr, t. (2008). empirical studies of agile software development: a systematic review. information and software technology, 50(9-10), 833-859. feldt, r., & magazinius, a. (2010). validity threats in empirical software engineering research-an initial survey. paper presented at the seke. field, a. (2005). factor analysis using spss. retrieved march, 17(2019), 63-71. fisher, e. (2011). what practitioners consider to be the skills and behaviours of an effective people project manager. international journal of project management, 29(8), 994-1002. garland, r. (2009). project governance: a practical guide to effective project decision making: kogan page publishers. guadagnoli, e., & velicer, w. f. (1988). relation of sample size to the stability of component patterns. psychological bulletin, 103(2), 265. hair, j. f., black, w. c., babin, b. j., anderson, r. e., & tatham, r. l. (1998). multivariate data analysis (vol. 5): prentice hall upper saddle river, nj. highsmith, j. (2003). agile software development-why it is hot. extreme programming perspectives, m. marchesi, et al., editors, 9-16. iivari, j., & huisman, m. (2007). the relationship between organizational culture and the deployment of systems development methodologies. mis quarterly, 35-58. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5158 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 96 iivari, j., & iivari, n. (2011). the relationship between organizational culture and the deployment of agile methods. information and software technology, 53(5), 509-520. joslin, r., & müller, r. (2016). the relationship between project governance and project success. international journal of project management, 34(4), 613-626. kloppenborg, t. j., manolis, c., & tesch, d. (2009). successful project sponsor behaviors during project initiation: an empirical investigation. journal of managerial issues, 140-159. koskela, l., & howell, g. (2002). the underlying theory of project management is obsolete. paper presented at the proceedings of the pmi research conference. lee, g., & xia, w. (2010). toward agile: an integrated analysis of quantitative and qualitative field data on software development agility. mis quarterly, 34(1), 87-114. lehtonen, p., & martinsuo, m. (2006). three ways to fail in project management and the role of project management methodology. project perspectives, 28(1), 6-11. lindvall, m., basili, v., boehm, b., costa, p., dangle, k., shull, f., & zelkowitz, m. (2002). empirical findings in agile methods. inconference on extreme programming and agile methods (pp. 197-207). in: springer berlin heidelberg. lu, y., & ramamurthy, k. (2011). understanding the link between information technology capability and organizational agility: an empirical examination. mis quarterly, 931-954. maccallum, r. c., widaman, k. f., preacher, k. j., & hong, s. (2001). sample size in factor analysis: the role of model error. multivariate behavioral research, 36(4), 611-637. magazinius, a., & feldt, r. (2011). confirming distortional behaviors in software cost estimation practice. paper presented at the 2011 37th euromicro conference on software engineering and advanced applications. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5158 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 97 mann, c., & maurer, f. (2005). a case study on the impact of scrum on overtime and customer satisfaction. paper presented at the agile development conference (adc'05). mclaughlin, j. (2013). functions of organizational culture. retrieved from https://study.com/academy/lesson/functions-of-organizational-culture.html miller, g. g. (2001). the characteristics of agile software processes. paper presented at the technology of object-oriented languages, international conference on. milosevic, d., & patanakul, p. (2005). standardized project management may increase development projects success. international journal of project management, 23(3), 181-192. müller, r., & turner, r. (2007). the influence of project managers on project success criteria and project success by type of project. european management journal, 25(4), 298-309. munns, a. k., & bjeirmi, b. f. (1996). the role of project management in achieving project success. international journal of project management, 14(2), 81-87. nerur, s., mahapatra, r., & mangalaraj, g. (2005). challenges of migrating to agile methodologies. communications of the acm, 48(5), 72-78. paasivaara, m., lassenius, c., heikkilä, v. t., dikert, k., & engblom, c. (2013). integrating global sites into the lean and agile transformation at ericsson. paper presented at the 2013 ieee 8th international conference on global software engineering. pace, m. (2019). a correlational study on project management methodology and project success. journal of engineering, project, and production management. parker, d. w., parsons, n., & isharyanto, f. (2015). inclusion of strategic management theories to project management. international journal of managing projects in business. pinto, j. k. (2014). project management, governance, and the normalization of deviance. international journal of project management, 32(3), 376-387. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5158 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 98 quinn, r. e. (1984). planning and perseverance: guidelines for managerial practice. managing organizational transitions. quinn, r. e., & rohrbaugh, j. (1983). a spatial model of effectiveness criteria: towards a competing values approach to organizational analysis. management science, 29(3), 363-377. robinson, h., & sharp, h. (2005). organisational culture and xp: three case studies. paper presented at the agile development conference (adc'05). serrador, p., & pinto, j. k. (2015). does agile work?—a quantitative analysis of agile project success. international journal of project management, 33(5), 1040-1051. serrador, p., & turner, r. (2015). the relationship between project success and project efficiency. project management journal, 46(1), 30-39. sheffield, j., & lemétayer, j. (2013). factors associated with the software development agility of successful projects. international journal of project management, 31(3), 459-472. sherehiy, b., karwowski, w., & layer, j. k. (2007). a review of enterprise agility: concepts, frameworks, and attributes. international journal of industrial ergonomics, 37(5), 445-460. siakas, k. v., & siakas, e. (2007). the agile professional culture: a source of agile quality. software process: improvement and practice, 12(6), 597-610. smircich, l. (1983). (1983a). concepts of culture and organizational analysis. administrative science quarterly, 28, 339-358. stankovic, d., nikolic, v., djordjevic, m., & cao, d.-b. (2013). a survey study of critical success factors in agile software projects in former yugoslavia it companies. journal of systems and software, 86(6), 1663-1678. stevens, j. (2009). applied multivariate statistics for the social sciences (fifth.). in: new york: routledge. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5158 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 99 strode, d. e., huff, s. l., & tretiakov, a. (2009). the impact of organizational culture on agile method use. paper presented at the 2009 42nd hawaii international conference on system sciences. tabachnick, b. g., & fidell, l. s. (2007). experimental designs using anova: thomson/brooks/cole belmont, ca. tolfo, c., & wazlawick, r. s. (2008). the influence of organizational culture on the adoption of extreme programming. journal of systems and software, 81(11), 1955-1967. tolfo, c., wazlawick, r. s., ferreira, m. g. g., & forcellini, f. a. (2011). agile methods and organizational culture: reflections about cultural levels. journal of software maintenance and evolution: research and practice, 23(6), 423-441. trochim, w. m. (2006). qualitative validity. in. turner, j. r., & keegan, a. (2001). mechanisms of governance in the project-based organization:: roles of the broker and steward. european management journal, 19(3), 254-267. ul musawir, a., abd-karim, s. b., & mohd-danuri, m. s. (2020). project governance and its role in enabling organizational strategy implementation: a systematic literature review. international journal of project management, 38(1), 1-16. williams, p., ashill, n. j., naumann, e., & jackson, e. (2015). relationship quality and satisfaction: customer-perceived success factors for on-time projects. international journal of project management, 33(8), 1836-1850. williams, t. (2005). assessing and moving on from the dominant project management discourse in the light of project overruns. ieee transactions on engineering management, 52(4), 497-508. http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/6597 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 27 how to resolve audit matters in european affairs? introduction to a sustainable management accounting under ias 37 stefano de nichilo1 1 lectures university of cagliari e-mail: stefanodenichilo1985@gmail.com received: 27/02/2022 accepted for publication: 13/04/2022 published: 15/04/2022 abstract concerns regarding the development of environmental accounting have been around for decades. this work is an update to some of the previous questions around the development of ecological accounting to see how this has changed over the last two decades. specific findings from the paper analysis include ecological management accounting, “cost of decommissioning” (ias 37) requires a fundamental change to organization management, different values exploring relationships such as corporate governance, inclusive of the living and physical world, with a longer time horizon, and a centrality of external factors. environmental accounting is a more commonly used synonym for ecological accounting, though this term is distinct and does not cover many of the ecological challenges. in terms of corporate governance, the board of directors (bods) is the main responsible structure in meeting and safeguarding both shareholders and stakeholders’ interests. integrated reporting’s primary aim is to improve information quality provided to shareholders while responding to stakeholders’ interests and needs. using lenses of stakeholder theory, this study explores the relationship between board of directors’ characteristics as size, gender diversity, return on decommissioning asset, outside directors, number of executive committee and, using a self-constructed performance disclosure index. applying a content analysis method, data were collected from integrated reports to determine the self-constructed disclosure index. through quantitative analysis, we analyzed which bods’ characteristics are correlated to disclosure index. the analyzed sample was formed of 100 integrated reports produced by 27 european members states, published on the website for the period 2016–2020. the current study contributes to existing knowledge by exploring the voluntary adoption of integrated reporting using quantitative analysis and focusing on the european context. the obtained results highlight that integrated report alignment levels is directly correlated with the proportion of outside directors on the board and return on decommissioning asset. keywords: accounting; corporate governance; ecological; environmental; integrated reporting; sustainable development 1. introduction this research sets out to explore how far ecological management accounting; the business community over the last two decades has developed an interest in external factors, broadly termed as social and environmental concerns (van der stede, 2012, 2015). the development of frameworks such as integrated reporting and narrative reporting guidelines have increased http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/6597 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 28 the reporting on and accountability of organizations to these issues (umar et al. 2020). this paper is exploring how far this move has developed in terms of ecological management accounting over the last two decades. this work starts with a challenge to the concept of environmentally concerned businesses, drawing a wider ecological view of the issues and business concerns (corvo et al. 2021). in doing so, one central issue is whether the business community can carry on with small changes and become ecological enterprises, or whether this requires a significant and fundamental change in organizations to shift the focus to achieve a more ecological balance (alexis 2017). this can be seen as a move towards relationships and away from the discrete object system that underpins much of accounting theory. more recently there have been additions to this discussion with a subsequent call as to the current state of affairs with sustainability, and the macro picture of ecological catastrophe that may be around the corner. the prevailing notion is that businesses have argued all is fine and, that under the term ‘sustainable business’, they are tackling environmental concerns (biancone et al. 2020). this argument can be developed, and several models used to explore the permutations. there are some different ways that the environmental issues can be resolved. so, an important sub-question is how these do (or do not) cross into the boundary of what can be defined as ecological accounting? in the end, is this a reflection on a business and whether becoming more environmental and sustainable is leading to an ecological business model and or is this something else? this paper is, in effect, updating this discussion to explore how far the notion of ecological management accounting has come over the last twenty years (birnberg 2000). it is important to stress that terms such as environmental and sustainability have become commonly used and synonymous in the business community (biancone et al. 2018). previous discussions on ecological accounting have highlighted the care that must be taken to ensure these terms are not conflated in and with the ecological term and concepts and in exploring this to highlight where there are differences and how this is moving forward the discussion and debate on ecological business (ashraf 2019). both have covered social and environmental concerns in the accounting field over the 20 years but to what extent and specifically can this be connected back to the ecological debate? (hopper & bui 2016) the difference in this work is that it has a specific focus on one topic area, environmental accounting. 2. literature review the activity of internal auditors, and the processes and control systems they deal with, are not predicable ex ante and are depicted contingently, they cannot rely on a “one-size-fits-all” procedure, but need to be adjusted to the specific context of a specific firm at a specific time. that said, management accounting as a discipline is able to identify specific procedures, which can better match specifically defined situations in which the organization may be involved (bocken, short, rana & evans 2014). according to contingency theory, situational factors (or contingent or contextual factors) influence the design of the management accounting system, while organizational performance and effectiveness depend on the quality of fit of the management accounting system, when designed ad hoc, and the specific situational factors that activated it (chapman 2006). these characteristics of the discipline make it difficult to undertake big numbers-based empirical studies, as each organization is unique and the potential situational factors are infinite and nested with each other, while the effectiveness of the fit between the management accounting system and the situational factors is often not easily measurable. the external environment and its level of uncertainty are relevant situational factors, related to change in the environment, which occur unexpectedly, such as the financial crisis of 2008 (secinaro, brescia, calandra & biancone 2020). when the conditions under which the firm operates are more stable, the external environment will be considered as more certain (eckles, hoyt & miller 2014). on the contrary, dynamic conditions are the premise for an uncertain external environment. it is documented that firms operating in a more stable and certain environment adopt a formula-based approach to the measurement of management accounting systems effectiveness, whereas firms operating in a dynamic and uncertain environment adopt a subjective approach to performance evaluation. in the current situation, a formula-based approach, which presupposes the meeting of targets, will easily fail if the uncertain dynamics of the environment make the targets inappropriate. uncertainty is also correlated with the level of sophistication of the management accounting system, given that a certain external environment needs only internal, financial and historical information, whereas an uncertain external environment will require a more sophisticated management accounting systems, which can also gather information that is external, less finical and future-oriented, as well as generally requiring decentralization in the organizational (and decisional) structure. the competitive strategy adopted by the firm is also a situational factor, which is able to shape the management accounting systems. a low-cost competitive strategy will require a formula-based approach, requiring significant attention paid to cost http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/6597 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 29 control mechanisms and frequent and detailed quantitative reports on performance. on the other hand, a differentiation strategy will control costs less effectively and be mainly focused on non-financial measures of performance. sustainable destination can then appear in their holistic vision, as integrated, adaptive socio-ecological system (clarke 1997). these are the elements that will be discussed: a. destination as an integrated systems; b. destination as a social system; c. destination as a socio-ecological system; d. destination as an adaptive system. in this context, the stakeholder theory is also employed to explain stakeholder relationship in business belonging to different sectors, including the tourism sector. the theory can contribute to regulating relationship between tourism actors at the destination level. in particular, the principles of the theory are considered more significant in the case of destinations involved in sustainable tourism development, due to the role stakeholders should play. indeed, as described in previous paragraphs, international and european sustainable tourism organizations consider the involvement and the commitment of all stakeholders in planning and in the decision-making process at the destination level as a fundamental step in sustainable tourism development (fischer 1995). many studies aim to identify stakeholder of tourism. sautter and leisen (1999), refer to workers, local enterprise, residents, tourists, public administrators, competitors, activists and international chains as the stakeholders involved in tourism planning at a destination level. ryan (2002), considering potential stakeholders of an hypothetical tour operator in an hypothetical destination, identifies government, travel agencies, local administrators, accommodation enterprises, natural and urban environment, workers, brokerage houses and other special interest groups. currie (2009) considers the mitchel (1997) categories and identifies local indigenous enterprises as dormant stakeholders, fishing and sailing enterprises as discretionary stakeholders, the water managing authority as demanding stakeholders, governmental authorities as dominant stakeholders, tourism and accommodation enterprises as dependent stakeholders, environmentalists as dangerous stakeholders, and natural resources managing enterprises as definitive stakeholders. byrd (2007) selects the current and potential community and tourists as the stakeholders principally involved in sustainable tourism development at the destination level. according to the traditional approach, the interests of the three stakeholder groups are incompatible. for example, actions aimed at the maximization of business profits could cause damage on the natural environment. expectations of workers could be conflicting with business profit objectives. environmental associations and local authorities could conflict in the management of natural resources. however, according to a different perspective, stakeholders interests can be considered complementary. in destinations focused on tourism development, and especially sustainable tourism development, business cannot pursue economic goal that negate the efforts to safeguard the natural and cultural environment. this is because natural and cultural attractions represent the core of tourism products and the most interesting destination features for tourists 3. methodology empirical research conducted in order to understand the characteristics of the financial statement disclosure concerning decommissioning funds in listed european non-financial companies (significant amounts exceeding 1 million euro of decommissioning funds) for the years 2016-2020 for the 27 member countries of the european union (stoval, higham & stephenson 2019). we voluntarily excluded banks, insurance companies and other financial companies from the analysis due to the wide existing regulatory differences and the peculiarities of the typical activities of these companies. from the reading of the financial reports it emerges that in the section dedicated to the presentation of the accounting principles adopted, the non-financial companies report the letter or in any case the indications provided by the accounting standard ias 37 although only some companies make explicit reference (baxter & jack 2008). for these reasons, the purpose of the research is to verify how the information contained in the accounting documents is managed with the relative level of transparency provided about the characteristics that determine the values of the items in question (currie, seaton & wesley 2009) (table1). http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/6597 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 30 table 1. data sampling of european business corporation with cost of decommissioning. materiality: substantial amounts exceeding 1 million euros. european members 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 austria 1 1 0 1 1 belgium 3 4 2 2 2 bulgaria 4 3 3 4 3 croatia 4 5 4 3 4 denmark 2 1 1 1 2 estonia 1 1 0 0 1 finland 1 1 0 0 1 france 13 14 17 15 16 germany 15 17 23 19 20 greece 2 0 0 0 1 ireland 3 1 1 0 1 italy 12 16 17 20 18 netherlands 4 2 2 2 2 poland 5 3 2 5 3 portugal 6 8 7 6 7 czech republic 3 3 2 2 2 romania 3 3 2 3 2 slovakia 1 0 0 0 0 slovenia 1 0 0 0 0 spain 10 11 12 12 9 sweden 3 3 3 2 3 hungary 3 3 2 3 2 other 0 0 0 0 0 total annuals reports 100 100 100 100 100 source: author’s elaboration on european commission data set. the quality of the external information regarding the provisions for risks and charges relating to the dismantling of plants, the repurposing of sites and reclamations in the financial statements of the 100 listed companies is rather heterogeneous (battaglia 2011). it can certainly be said that if the disclosure required by the accounting principle were expected by the companies in a complex manner, there would certainly be an improvement in the level of transparency. below is an example of a summary checklist for the italian context which highlights the information required by the accounting standard with its presence in the financial statements being researched (table 2). http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/6597 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 31 table 2. summary of empirical evidence of disclosure for cost decommissioning: italy checklist 2016 ias 37 indications presence of information yes no 84. for each class of provisions, the company must highlight: a) the book value at the beginning and end of the financial year; 29 0 b) the additional provisions made during the year, including increases to existing provisions; 23 6 c) the amounts used (ie costs incurred and charged to the provision) during the year; 22 7 d) amounts not used and reversed during the year; 11 18 e) the increases in the discounted amounts that occurred during the year, due to the passage of time, and the effect of any change in the discount rate. 11 18 85. the company must indicate for each class of provisions: a) a brief description of the nature of the obligation and the expected timing of the resulting outlay; 11 18 b) an indication of the uncertainties relating to the amount or timing of such disbursements. where it is necessary to provide adequate information, the company must highlight the main assumptions made about future events. 6 23 c) the amount of any compensation provided, specifying the amount of each asset recognized for the expected compensation. 0 29 86. unless the likelihood of engaging any resource to settle the obligation is remote, the company must disclose for each class of contingent liability at the reporting date a brief description of the nature of the contingent liability and, where feasible: a) an estimate of its financial effects, 0 29 b) an indication of the uncertainties relating to the amount or timing of each disbursement; is 0 29 c) the probability of each indemnity. 0 29 source: author’s elaboration the table highlights the lack of information required by paragraph 86 regarding contingent liabilities. the reader of the financial statements cannot be certain either that the company is not exposed to potential liabilities or that these, although they exist, are not indicated (castellani & sala 2010). by categorizing the indications present in the accounting standard, it is possible to reach the following groupings: a. indications of paragraph 84: quantitative information expressed with numerical values and through the use of tables. b. indications of paragraph 85: information of a descriptive nature that can be expressed in discursive form. http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/6597 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 32 c. indications in paragraph 86: information on elements that are not reflected in the numerical values of the financial statements. this categorization allows us to identify, in summary, how the information reaches a good level of transparency regarding the formation and variations of the elements that are represented by numerical values. lower levels of information concern the description of the phenomena that generated the values that feed the financial statements (bryman & bell 2007). finally, an even lower level of disclosure can be found in all the elements that are not reflected in the book values. once the results of the empirical analysis have been summarized in an aggregate manner, the understanding of the level of transparency in the financial statement disclosure concerning the decommissioning funds can be carried out through the construction of a transparency index (cook & reichardt 1979). although it is generally recognized that information transparency is an abstract concept, difficult to measure and undermined by the subjectivity of the researcher in the appreciation of phenomena, in the context of empirical research the use of these indices is widely used. this is due to the fact that the indicators are capable of giving a representation of the observed phenomenon which, although it does not exist in reality, can still be appreciated. in order to limit the subjectivity inherent in the choice of variables to be considered in defining the indicator, it is considered appropriate to include only the information required by ias 37 and reported in the paragraphs indicated above (acar & ozkan 2017). for the study it is considered appropriate to construct two indicators. the first having as variables the information required by the accounting standard, each considered with the same importance as the others in defining the level of transparency (corbetta 2003). this indicator allows to minimize the subjectivity of the researcher regardless of any consideration regarding the relevance of the researcher's subjectivity regardless of any consideration regarding the relevance of each single element. the second considers the same variables but attributes a different weight to each of them due to the subjectivity inherent in the sensitivity of the writer (le, p. t. a. 2019). below is the first unweighted disclosure index used, which is based on the presence of the elements required by the accounting standard in paragraphs 84, 85 and 86. unweighted disclosure index = 1/11 84a + 1/1184b + 1/1184c + 1/1184d + 1/1184e + 1/1185a + 1/1185b + 1/1185c + 1/1186a + 1/11 86b + 1/11 86c the attribution of an equal weight to all variables, although it reduces the subjectivity of the researcher in attributing different weights, implicitly assumes that each variable has the same relevance for the reader of the report. this assumption, although it may not be completely correct, at the same time it could be less incorrect than the attribution of a different weight to the individual variables due to the subjectivity of the evaluator. in the doctrine, there are different possibilities for attributing weight to variables. in particular, the criterion of distinction is used in two main types: a. specific variables of the issuing company, corporate variables, which depend on the choices made by the company and which an investor can only become aware of through the information provided by the company; b. market variables, publicly available, from which the reader of the financial statements can learn through alternative instruments to the financial statements. this distinction therefore makes it possible to attribute greater weight to company variables, information that is characterized by having the specific company as the only supplier of these elements (brasini 2010). in the context of liabilities, the elements referred to by the accounting principle are characterized by exclusively relating to company-type variables and therefore the possibility of distinguishing the weights based on this classification is precluded. it is therefore necessary to identify possible solutions in order to distinguish the relevance of the multiple information requested. for this purpose, it is possible to distinguish how the information required by paragraphs 84 and 85 represents charges whose probability of occurrence is judged by management as high unlike those required in paragraph 86 and relating to charges whose possibility of future manifestation is remote. from this point of view, at least double importance can be attributed to the elements referred to in paragraphs 84 or 85 with respect to those indicated in paragraph 86 (creswell 2013). in consideration of the fact that the quantitative information required by paragraph 84 may allow the reader to be more aware of the numerical values only if supported by an adequate description, it is believed that the information required by the two paragraphs can be attributed the same importance. the reasoning illustrated leads to attribute a weight of 0.4 to the information required by paragraph 84, of 0.4 to that required by paragraph 85 and, finally, of 0.2 to that referred to in paragraph 86 (cook & reichardt 1979). at this point it is necessary to identify within each paragraph of the weights based on the most basic information required. also in this circumstance it is important to consider the trade-off between desired objectivity and sensibility of the evaluator. based on the assumption that the elementary variables mentioned contribute to the definition of the information transparency of the same aspect, it is particularly complex and risky to attribute different weights. on the basis of the reasoning described, it is considered reasonable to attribute the same weight to each variable referred to in the same paragraph. http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/6597 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 33 weighted disclosure index = 4/10 ( 1/5 84a + 1/584b + 1/584c + 1/584d + 1/584e) + 4/10 ( 1/385a + 1/385b + 1/385c) +2/10 (1/386a + 1/3 86b + 1/3 86c) the index reported considers the information required by the accounting standard in paragraphs 84 and 85 as equally relevant in the definition of a transparency standard and overall suitable for the definition of 80% of the level of disclosure due to the presence of the individual elements mentioned. the information required by paragraph 86, due to the remote probability of occurrence, is therefore suitable for defining 20% of the level of disclosure due to the presence of the individual elements referred to in the paragraph (table 3). table 3. “unweighted” disclosure index by macro sector: year 2016 sector average paragraph 84 average paragraph 85 average paragraph 86 overall average consumer services 0.389 0.000 0.000 0.399 industrials 0.323 0.043 0.000 0.363 oil & gas 0.233 0.019 0.000 0.309 tecnology 0.183 0.000 0.000 0.189 telecommunications 0.132 0.000 0.000 0.189 utilities 0.289 0.043 0.000 0.333 source: author’s elaboration once the disclosure indicators have been defined as illustrated above, it is possible to quantify the average value of the index for each macro-sector, divided between the paragraphs of the accounting standard where such information is referred to (table 4). table 4. “weighted” disclosure index by macro sector: year 2016 sector average paragraph 84 average paragraph 85 average paragraph 86 overall average consumer services 0.343 0.000 0.000 0.343 industrials 0.283 0.059 0.000 0.443 oil & gas 0.256 0.027 0.000 0.283 tecnology 0.161 0.000 0.000 0.163 telecommunications 0.161 0.000 0.000 0.163 utilities 0.253 0.067 0.000 0.319 source: author’s elaboration the differences in the statistical results obtained from the application of the two different indices are summarized below (table 5). http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/6597 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 34 table 5. results of financial statement disclosure performance index (id (1;2): weighted and unweighted index: year 2016 statistical quantities weighted index 1 unweighted index 2 average 0.336 0.329 std. dev. 0.019 0.017 median 0.343 0.273 minimum 0.081 0.091 maximum 0.533 0.545 q1 0.243 0.273 q2 0.443 0.455 source: author’s elaboration this study aims to outline a modeling system to measure sustainability and the aggressiveness of european corporate governance in non-financial companies, concerning activity and analysis of decommissioning asset with environmental issues. hypothesis testing (table 6) uses the following design sustainability research model: id(1;2) = β0 + β1 (size) + β2 (gender diversity) + β3 (roda) + β4 (out-side director) + β5 (number of executive committee) + ξ table 6. framework and hypotheses independent variable previous studies of irrituals rites expected sign evidence size (h1). companies having larger boards issue integrated reports that have a higher alignment level to disclosure index (id). bods’ monitoring capacity increases with the number of its constituting directors, a benefit that might be surpassed by the disadvantages related to inadequate communication and inefficient decision-making process, specific for large groups (andriotis 2018). after reaching a specific size, the larger the board is, the + http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/6597 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 35 more ineffective it becomes. a board larger than 7–8 members is less likely to function effectively, diminishes its monitoring capabilities, and is much easier to be controlled by the ceo. board size positively impacts the integration of various reports, whether mandatory or voluntary, influencing id(1;2) voluntary adoption and dissemination of integrated csr (jones, atkinson, lorenz & harris 2012). larger boards, being formed of more experienced and knowledgeable directors, can deal with integrated report preparation, playing a central role in the integrated reporting process. environmental performance and disclosure are higher for companies with larger boards, where a larger board increases the probability of having the required expertise and diversity to enhance environmental performance (denichilo 2020c). log(asset) gender diversity (h2). companies with higher board gender diversity issue integrated reports that have a higher alignment level to disclosure index (id). bods should be composed of an appropriate mix of independent directors having relevant knowledge, competence, and industry experience to bring a diverse perspective and take objective decisions, enabling their preferential access to outside and additional resources, broader social networks, and build new business relationships (arena et al. 2010). board diversity is closely related to board composition, as group diversity can improve the quality of the decisions in that group, and can be referred to gender, age, nationality, cultural background, and educational attainment. environmental performance is higher for firms having a board composed of more legal experts and active ceos. moreover, companies that have a more significant proportion of western european directors record higher environmental corporate social responsibility (ecsr) governance mechanisms, while those with a higher number of colored directors report a higher quality of the integrated report. companies should disclose their diversity policy (including gender, ethnicity, cognitive, and social) regarding senior management and board, reporting on diversity with measurable + dichotomous variable (0/1) http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/6597 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 36 targets and the progress made (baltaretu 2011). regarding gender, it is considered that men and women have different moral reasoning, women using more care reasoning and protective attitudes. the presence of women directors on boards positively impacts the integration of various reports, whether mandatory or voluntary, while id(1;2) quality is higher for companies that have more women directors. return of decommissio ned assets (h3). companies that have a higher profitability of decommissioning asset have a lower alignment level to id. the profitability is one of significant determinants of financial reporting disclosure of decommissioned assets (denichilo 2020 (a) and (b)). companies with high levels of profitability of decommissioned assets improved influence in investor decision and have more interesting stakeholders, so there is a lower propensity of performance index id. return on decommissioni ng asset (roda) out-side director (h4). companies that have a higher proportion of outside directors on the board issue integrated reports that have a higher alignment level to id. board composition and independence are closely related, the last one increasing with the proportion of independent outside directors (chenhal & morris 1985). the presentation of csr information is impacted by outside directors, meaning that they have a role in ensuring that companies take into consideration the interest of their shareholders and stakeholders. board independence is closely linked to independent non executive directors’ presence, which should be in the majority. companies having a board formed in majority by independent non executive directors record higher levels of voluntarily disclosed information and voluntarily disclose more strategic and forward-looking information. moreover, boards formed in a higher proportion of outside directors have greater control over management’s decisions and improved monitoring effectiveness (modica 2012). outside non executive directors are more objective and independent when managing and analyzing a company’s actions than executive directors, offering additional assurance to market participants that their interests are safeguarded + dichotomous variable (0/1) http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/6597 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 37 and reducing the agency costs (stoval, higham & stephenson 2019). the integrated report quality is higher for companies that have more nonexecutive directors. number of executive committee (h5). companies that have a more active board issue integrated reports that have a higher alignment level to id. board activity has contrary views an active board with more meetings can be interpreted or viewed as inefficient, while others believe that more board meetings enable directors to supervise the company better (buckley 2012). by having more meetings, the board can debate, analyze, and decide on a broader range of topics, including the information included in the integrated report. + number source: author’s elaboration 4. results the study analyzes the characteristics and determinants of the sustainability index on investment projects with cost of decommissioning. first we see the results of the descriptive analysis of the sustainability model of the projects (tables 7 and 8). next we present the results of multivariate analysis (tables 9, 10 and 11). table 7. descriptive statistics of independent variables variable mean std. dev min max size 25.95 4.25 10.75 44.88 gender diversity 0.44 5.33 0 1 return of decommissioned assets 4.55% 0.99 -17.55% 10.33% out-side director 0.55 6.55 0 1 number of executive committee 7.88 1.25 3 12 source: author’s elaboration table 8. descriptive statistics id (1;2) index from 2017 to 2020 variable mean id1 std. dev id1 min id1 max id1 2017 0.339 0.021 0.081 0.553 2018 0.411 0.022 0.085 0.552 2019 0.421 0.024 0.089 0.554 2020 0.441 0.023 0.082 0.555 source: author’s elaboration table 9. descriptive statistics id (1;2) index from 2017 to 2020 variable mean id2 std. dev id2 min id2 man id2 2017 0.331 0.019 0.091 0.545 2018 0.333 0.021 0.092 0.549 2019 0.339 0.023 0.094 0.548 2020 0.411 0.022 0.092 0.549 http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/6597 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 38 source: author’s elaboration table 10. multivariate analysis of id (1) model model coefficient id(1) t and p value intercepts 1.33 1.75*** size 1.55 -1.09 gender diversity 0.25 1.11 return of decommissioned assets -1.07 2.22*** out-side director 2.22 2.19*** number of executive committee 0.22 1.29 2017 0.01 dichotomous variable (0/1) 2018 0.01 2019 0.02 2020 0.02 r2 0.38 f value 3.33 source: author’s elaboration *, **, *** p-value at 0.10, 0.05 and 0.01 table 11. multivariate analysis of id (2) model model coefficient id(2) t and p value intercepts 1.22 2.75*** size 1.45 -1.11 gender diversity 0.22 1.22 return of decommissioned assets -1.15 3.33*** out-side director 2.44 3.55*** number of executive committee 0.44 1.22 2017 0.01 dichotomous variable (0/1) 2018 0.01 2019 0.02 2020 0.02 r2 0.59 f value 2.85 source: author’s elaboration *, **, *** p-value at 0.10, 0.05 and 0.01 model 1 is significant (p value 0.01 level) and r2 is 0.38. model 2 is significant (p value 0.01 level), and r2 is 0.59. the independent variable that have a significant result (level 0.01) are: roda and out-side director. an optimal solution for anticipating uncontrollable factors and mitigating their dangerous effect may be to rely on subjectivity (power 2009). using objective performance measures can lead to the myopic decision to analyze only what is in the numbers and only what was predictable when those objective metrics for performance settled down, which implies the risk of overlooking the relevance of some factors that clearly impact on actual performance. hence, subjectivity could should affect estimates, while forecasting and budgeting, at the time of control, may have consequential repercussions for the incentive system of the organization (palermo & van der stede 2011). subjectivity in performance evaluations unfortunately impose various criticalities. first, subjectivity is expensive, in terms of the time and resources required to assess the evaluation and to investigate the causes of any inefficiency in performance http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/6597 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 39 (denichilo 2021b). moreover, subjectivity creates ambiguity regarding its causes and the fairness of the procedure adopted in the evaluation, as the evaluation itself may be characterized by a series of biases (power 2007). 5. discussion and conclusion several themes emerged throughout the analysis, the first is around terminology and its impreciseness and multiple usages of terms (torkington stanford & guiver 2020). of most concern is the concept of sustainability, which is seen as a connected, interchangeable, and over-arching concept and, in many ways, has hindered the development of environmental management accounting (freeman 2001). the concept of ecological accounting has not been used to any note in the period since 2000. environmental management accounting is more of a favored term and is positioned as separate from sustainability, this may be a clearer way forward (adams 2020). the use of environmental and accounting can provide a clearer path along which environmental concerns and accounting can be developed. alongside mainstream accounting research that has become more aware of stakeholders of the firm, more entities need including in the environmental accounting debates (adelman 2017). the environment cannot speak for itself and operating in an anthropomorphic environment, the concerns and impacts on the voiceless entity will be marginalized (berke & conroy 2000). the environmental entity must be central to any debate on ecological development. this means starting with the impact on the environment and working backwards to the organization changing the emphasis allows a clearer ecological standard to be established and not seen as a nice add on (denichilo 2021a). the traditional accounting discipline was settle with the aims of disclosing information on the organization, moving certainty and reliability about business contracts towards the business community. the postmodern view of management accounting discipline clarifies that the certainty of contracts in the business community is hardly believable. the best way to maintain environmental uncertainty is to smooth over the information and the requisites for the accounting of failure. accordingly, discussions on the organizational performance should move from statements of what happened towards projections on what will happen, supporting the reliability of traditional management accounting systems with a forward-looking strategy of “asif” planning, thus evolving risks into opportunities. finally organizational should equilibrate the instruments adopted to control uncontrollable situational factors and adequately combine objective and subjective instruments for management accounting. excessive reliance on objective performance metrics leads to business as usual, while new opportunities are missed out on. while, in business life nowadays, there is no room for demonizing objective metrics and relying on a purely subjective approach to evaluations, which would likely be affected by hidden pitfalls and side effects, there is a general call to avoid myopic evaluations and look at performance dynamically, with a continuous approach to management accountants’ role as risk mitigators, while considering risks and financial distress as facilitators for turnaround activity, which is positively centered on innovation. further development of these accounting approaches, with an awareness of the factors impacting on the development of ecological accounting, will help shape the development of ecological management accounting into the near future. references acar, e., & ozkan, s. (2017). corporate governance and provisions under ias 37. euromed journal of business. adams, c. (2020). uk aviation industry promises to be carbon neutral by 2050. the independent, 4 february. retrieved february 17, 2020, from https://www.independent.co.uk/travel/news-and-advice/aviation-industry-uk-carbon-emissions-neutral-heathrow-airporta9316116.html. adelman, s. (2017). the sustainable development goals: anthropocentrism and neoliberalism. in d. french and l. kotzé (eds.), sustainable development goals: law, theory and implementation (pp. 15–40) 2017. edward elgar. alexis, p. (2017). over-tourism and anti-tourist sentiment: an exploratory analysis and discussion. ovidius university annals, economic sciences series, 2017 17(2), 288–293. andriotis, k. (2018). degrowth in tourism: conceptual, theoretical and philosophical issues. cabi 2018. crossref. http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/6597 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 40 arena, m., arnaboldi, m., & azzone, g. (2010). the organizational dynamics of enterprise risk management. accounting, organizations and society. vol. 35 issue 7 2010, pp. 659-675. ashraf, m. m., razzaque, m. a., liaw, s. t., ray, p. k., & hasan, m. r. (2019). social business as an entrepreneurship model in emerging economy: systematic review and case study. management decision. baltaretu, a. (2011). methods and indicators for measuring the impact of tourism on protected natural areas; 2011 pp 366-371. battaglia, m. (2011). non-probability sampling encyclopedia of survey research methods, sage publications 2011. baxter, p. & jack, s. (2008). qualitative case study methodology: study design and implementation for novice researches. the qualitative report, 13(4), 544-559 2008. berke, p. r., & conroy, m. m. (2000). are we planning for sustainable development? journal of the american planning association, 66(1), 21-23 2000. biancone p., secinaro s., brescia v. (2018), the innovation of local public-sector companies: processing big data for transparency and accountability. biancone, p.p., secinaro, s., brescia, v., calandra, d. (2020). employing value chain theory to address covid-19 outbreak in tourism management: a resilience and stakeholder view. international journal of business research management 2020. birnberg, j. g. (2000). the role of behavioral research in management accounting education in 21st century. issues in accounting education. vol. 15 issue 4: 713-727 2000. bocken, n. p. m., short, s. w., rana, p., & evans, s. (2014). a literature and practice review to develop sustainable business model archetypes. journal of cleaner production, 65, 42-56 2014. brasini, s. (2010). marketing e pubblicità: strumenti e modelli di analisi statistica, bologna: il mulino 2010. bryman, a., & bell, e. (2007). business research methods, oxford university press 2007. buckley, r. (2012). sustainable tourism: research and reality. annals of tourism research, 39(2), 528-546 2012. byrd, e. t. (2007). stakeholders in sustainable tourism development and their roles: applying stakeholders theory to sustainable tourism development. tourism review, 62(2), 6-13 2007. castellani, v. & sala, s. (2010). sustainable performance index for tourism policy development. tourism management, 31(6), 871-880 2010. chapman, r. j. (2006). simple tools and techniques for enterprise risk management. john wiley & sons ltd: chichester (uk) 2006. chenhal, r. h., morris, d. (1985). the impact of structure, environment and interdependence on the perceived usefulness of management accounting systems, the impact of structure, environment and interdependence on the perceived usefulness of management accounting systems. the accounting review. vol i issue 1, pp. 16-35 1985. clarke, j. (1997). a framework of approaches to sustainable tourism. journal of sustainable tourism, 5(3), 224-233 1997. cook, t. d. & reichardt, c. s. (1979). qualitative and quantitative methods in evaluation research (vol. 1), sage publications 1979. corbetta, p. (2003). la ricerca sociale: metodologia e tecniche. le tecniche qualitative (vol. ii), bologna: il mulino 2003. corvo, l., pastore, l., manti, a., & iannaci, d. (2021). mapping social impact assessment models: a literature overview for a future research agenda. sustainability 2021, 13, 4750. coyne, i.t. (1997). sampling in qualitative research. purposeful and theoretical sampling; merging or clear boundaries? journal of advanced nursing, 26(3), 623-630 1997. http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/6597 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 41 creswell, j. w. (2013). research design: qualitative, quantitative and mixed methods approachers, sage publications 2013. currie, r. r., seaton, s. & wesley, f. (2009). determining stakeholders for feasibility analysis. annals of tourism research, 36(1), 41-63 2009. denichilo, s. (2020a). public choice in european affairs: measuring election model. european journal of social impact and circular economy pp 19-37. published by university of turin 2020. denichilo, s. (2020b). shadow bank system in european affairs: measuring capability. presentation discussed paper at european association for banking and financial law. thematic purposed by bankitalia eurosistema “what to regulate? how to regulate? who should regulate?” november 2020 milan. denichilo s. (2020c), how do earnings management practices distract international environmental funds? empirical evidence of european development funds in italy. geoprogress journal vol.7, i. 1, 2020. pag. 87-101. denichilo s. (2021a), management accounting in european finance for smart tourism and sustainable destination: how organizations deficiency? pp 45-74. published by university of turin. http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index. denichilo s. (2021b), management accounting in european affairs: a memorandum methodology for formalize audit evidence. corporate governance and research & development studies 1/2021. doi: http://dx.doi.org/10.3280/cgrds1-2021oa10445. eckles, d. l., hoyt, r. e., miller, s. m. (2014). the impact of enterprise risk management on the marginal cost of reducing risk: evidence from the insurance in industry. journal of banking and finance. vol. 43 issue 1, pp. 247-261 2014. fischer j. (1995). contingency-based research on management control systems: categorization by level of complexity. journal of accounting literature. vol. 14 issue 1, pp. 24-53 1995. freeman, r. e. (2001). a stakeholder theory of the modern corporation. perspectives in business ethics sie, 3(144), 38-48. hopper, t., bui, b. (2016). has management accounting research been critical? management accounting research. vol. 31 issues 1,pp. 10-30 2016. jones, t., atkinson, h., lorenz, a. & harris, p. (2012). strategic managerial accounting: hospitality, tourism & events applications. good fellow publishers limited 2012. le, p. t. a. (2019). environmental provision under ias 37: a review of the research literature. mitchell, b. (1997). resource and environmental management, harlow: logman. modica, p. (2012). demand management for the sustainability of tourism. in d. fennel & a. holden, the routledge handbook of tourism and the environment, london: routledge 2012. palermo, t. & van der stede, w. a. (2011). scenario budgeting. integrating risk and performance. finance and management. january 2011,pp. 10-13 2011. power, m. (2007). organized uncertainty: designing a world of risk management. oxford university press: oxford (uk) 2007. power, m. (2009). the risk management of nothing. accounting, organizations and society. vol. 34 issue 6-7,pp. 849-855 2009. ryan, c. (2002). equity, management, power sharing and sustainability – issues of the “new tourism”. tourism management, 23(1), 17-26 2002. sautter, e. t. & leisen, b. (1999). managing stakeholders a tourism planning model. annals of tourism research, 21(3), 312-328 1999. secinaro, s., brescia, v., calandra, d., & biancone, p. (2020). employing bibliometric analysis to identify suitable business models for electric cars. journal of cleaner production, 264, 121503. http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/6597 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 42 stoval, w., higham, j., & stephenson, j. (2019). prepared for take-off? anthropogenic climate change and the global challenge of twentyfirst century tourism. in d. timothy (ed.), handbook of globalization and tourism (pp. 174–187). edward elgar 2019. torkington, k., stanford, d., & guiver, j. (2020). discourse(s) of growth and sustainability in national tourism policies. journal of sustainable tourism, 28(7) 2020, 1041–1062. https://doi.org/10.1080/09669582.2020.170695. umar, a., sasongko, a. h., widyastuti, i. t., & christanti, y. (2020). improving the social enterprise based business performance from the aspect of social business model canvas. international journal of entrepreneurship, 24(1), 1-12. van der stede, w. a. (2012). management accounting research in the wake of the crisis: some reflections. european accounting review. vol. 20 issue 4,pp. 605-623 2011. van der stede, w. a. (2015). management accounting: where from, where now, where to? journal of management accounting research. vol 27 issue 1,pp. 171-176 2015. 01_ iyer_ejsice european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/6821 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 1 the emerging circular economy trends of united arab emirates (uae) universities shankar subramanian iyer1 1 s.p. jain institute of global management, block 5 academic city dubai, united arab emirates shankar.subramanien@gmail.com received: 06/12/2022 accepted for publication: 05/07/2023 published: 28/07/2023 abstract this paper examines the emerging circular economy trends in universities in the united arab emirates (uae). the circular economy is a model that aims to reduce waste and maximize the use of resources, promoting sustainable development. the study analyses uae universities' various initiatives to adopt circular economy practices, including using renewable energy, sustainable building design, and waste reduction strategies. the paper also discusses the challenges and opportunities for implementing circular economy practices in universities in the uae and highlights examples of circular economy initiatives in various universities. the paper concludes by providing recommendations for universities in the uae to promote sustainable practices further and contribute to the circular economy movement. the findings of this study provide insights into the emerging circular economy trends in universities in the uae and offer directions for future research in this area. the adkar change management can be adapted to inspire the ce initiatives of the uae education sector. keywords: circular economy; eco-design: business education; management education, adkar 1. introduction the concept of circular economy has been gaining momentum in recent years to promote sustainable development and reduce waste. the united arab emirates (uae) has also recognized the importance of adopting circular economy practices to address environmental challenges and promote sustainable growth. universities in the uae are playing a vital role in this transition by implementing circular economy practices and promoting sustainability education. this paper focuses on exploring the emerging trends of the circular economy in universities in the united arab emirates (uae) (dave et al., 2022). the circular economy is a model that aims to minimize waste and optimize resource usage, thus promoting sustainable development. the study delves into the various initiatives that uae universities have taken to implement circular economy practices. these initiatives include using renewable energy sources, sustainable building design, and waste reduction strategies (campra et al., 2021). this paper explores the emerging trends of the circular economy in universities in the uae. it aims to provide insights into the initiatives taken by these universities to adopt circular economy practices, the challenges and opportunities they face, and the impact of these practices on sustainable development. the key challenges include the need for more awareness and understanding of circular economy principles, the need for significant investments, and the need for clear regulatory frameworks. however, the study also highlights the benefits of adopting circular economy practices, such as reducing costs, improving the environmental footprint of universities, and promoting innovation and collaboration. the paper also provides examples of circular economy initiatives implemented in various universities in the uae. these examples range from small european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/6821 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 2 scale projects such as composting and recycling to large-scale initiatives such as using renewable energy in campus buildings (dantas et al., 2021). the uae is a rapidly developing country with a growing population, which puts pressure on natural resources and generates significant waste. in response to these challenges, the uae has launched several initiatives to promote sustainability and reduce waste. one of the most prominent initiatives is the uae vision 2021, which aims to promote sustainable development and reduce the country's ecological footprint. universities in the uae have also recognized the importance of adopting circular economy practices to promote sustainability and reduce waste. these universities have implemented various initiatives, such as using renewable energy sources, sustainable building design, and waste reduction strategies. moreover, universities in the uae are also promoting sustainability education to raise awareness and encourage students to adopt sustainable practices in their daily lives(lusk et al., 2020). despite these efforts, universities in the uae need help in implementing circular economy practices. these challenges include the lack of awareness about circular economy principles, the need for significant investments, and the absence of clear regulatory frameworks. therefore, this paper aims to provide an overview of the emerging circular economy trends in universities in the uae, analyze the challenges and opportunities for implementing circular economy practices, and offer recommendations for universities to promote sustainable practices further and contribute to the circular economy movement. the paper concludes by offering recommendations to the uae universities to promote sustainable practices and contribute to the circular economy movement. these recommendations include increasing awareness and education about circular economy principles, developing clear regulatory frameworks, encouraging collaboration among universities, and investing in research and development of circular economy solutions. overall, this paper provides valuable insights into the emerging circular economy trends in universities in the uae, highlighting the challenges and opportunities for implementing circular economy practices. the findings of this study offer directions for future research in this area and provide a roadmap for universities in the uae to promote sustainable practices and contribute to the circular economy movement (kirchherr et al., 2019). the uae education sector is transforming smart universities and smart education systems. this transformation is spearheaded by the smart government initiatives of various emirates, such as dubai and abu dhabi. the aim is to make the education sector more sustainable, efficient, and effective by reducing paper usage, streamlining administration, and using emerging technologies. one of the most significant changes is the move towards paperless offices and administration. this means universities use digital platforms to record and issue certificates, reducing paperwork and making the process more efficient. this move towards paperless administration is a step towards sustainability, as it reduces paper usage and waste (mendoza et al., 2019). the smart government initiatives are also promoting emerging technologies such as blockchain, cloud-computing, virtual reality, ai, and machine learning in education to further sustainability and standardize education curricula in the uae. for example, blockchain technology can securely store education records, making them easily accessible and tamperproof. cloud computing can store and access educational resources and data, making it easier for students and teachers to collaborate and share information. virtual reality can create immersive learning experiences, making education more engaging and interactive. ai and machine learning can be used to personalize learning, adapting to the needs and preferences of individual students. these smart education initiatives are making the education sector more sustainable and creating opportunities for implementing circular economy initiatives. for example, blockchain technology can be extended to implement circular economy practices by creating a secure and transparent system for tracking and managing waste. this can help reduce waste and increase the efficiency of recycling and waste management processes (ghareeb et al., 2020). overall, the uae education sector's move towards smart universities and smart education systems is a positive step towards creating a more sustainable and efficient education sector. emerging technologies and smart government initiatives are creating opportunities to implement circular economy practices and promote sustainability in the education sector. (iyer, 2022). given the previous gap analysis, our paper aims to explore the following research questions: a) what are the current circular economy trends being adopted by uae universities? b) what challenges and opportunities do uae universities face in implementing circular economy practices? c) how effective are the circular economy initiatives being implemented by uae universities in promoting sustainability and reducing environmental impact? d) what are the best practices for implementing circular economy initiatives in uae universities? european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/6821 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 3 2. literature review the concept of the circular economy is gaining increasing importance in the global economy, focusing on sustainability and resource efficiency. uae universities also recognise the need to adopt circular economy practices to promote sustainability and reduce environmental impact. this literature review explores uae universities' emerging circular economy trends and the challenges and opportunities associated with their implementation. 2.1 circular economy trends in uae universities uae universities are increasingly adopting circular economy practices to promote sustainability and reduce environmental impact. these practices include waste reduction, recycling, and using renewable energy sources. for example, the masdar institute of science and technology, based in abu dhabi, has implemented a zero-waste policy, where waste is reduced and recycled to minimize its environmental impact. similarly, the american university of sharjah has implemented a sustainability plan, which includes using renewable energy sources such as solar power and reducing water consumption. 2.2 challenges and opportunities the implementation of circular economy practices in uae universities has its challenges. one major challenge is the need for more awareness and understanding of the circular economy concept among stakeholders, including students, faculty, and administrators. this can hinder the adoption and implementation of circular economy practices. the lack of infrastructure and resources for waste management and recycling can also pose a challenge. however, several opportunities exist for implementing circular economy practices in uae universities. the uae government has committed to promoting sustainability and reducing its environmental impact through initiatives such as the uae vision 2021, which aims to achieve a sustainable environment and infrastructure. this allows universities to align their sustainability efforts with the government's objectives and collaborate on circular economy initiatives. uae universities' emerging circular economy trends demonstrate a commitment to sustainability and resource efficiency. however, the challenges associated with implementing circular economy practices must be addressed to ensure their effectiveness. the opportunities for collaboration with the uae government on sustainability initiatives provide an avenue for universities to make a significant impact on the circular economy and promote a sustainable future in the uae 2.3 gaps in the literature despite the growing interest in circular economy practices in uae universities, gaps in the literature need to be addressed. most of the available literature is descriptive and based on case studies, which limits our understanding of the impact of these practices on sustainability and resource efficiency. while some studies have identified the challenges associated with implementing circular economy practices in uae universities, there is a need for more in-depth research on these challenges, including the barriers to adoption and the strategies for overcoming them. the engagement of stakeholders, including students, faculty, and administrators, is critical for the successful implementation of circular economy practices in universities. however, there needs to be more focus on stakeholder engagement in the available literature. 2.4 circular economy – present and future scenario the circular economy is a newer concept and not so known till now to most people. most people are still caught in the linear sustainability economy. the circular economy (ce) model considers a reduction in the negative impact on the environment, thus moving away from the traditional linear business model, where the final product is value creation after reaching its highest consumption point. in the ce, the main goal is to enhance the product's life span, create goods with a long-life cycle and focus on services rather than products (figure 1). the focus should be on the change management to shift from a linear to a circular economy. the adkari model (figure 2) is a perfect application for this chance management, as european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/6821 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 4 discussed below. the circular economy has primarily three pillars shown in the figure, and the fourth can use innovations through r&d to achieve the other three (baars et al., 2021; iyer et al., 2020). figure 1. innovations and r&d source: authors’ elaboration figure 2. the adkari model source: authors’ elaboration 3. the adkari model 3.1 awareness of circular economy the circular economy is a concept that aims to promote sustainability by reducing waste and maximizing the use of resources. awareness of circular economy can be looked at from different levels, including individual, community, organizational, industrial or national level, and humanitarian levels. at the individual level, awareness of the circular economy involves understanding the importance of reducing waste and adopting sustainable practices in daily life, such as recycling, composting, and reducing energy consumption. it also involves promoting the idea of a circular economy to others, such as family and friends, to increase awareness and encourage the adoption of sustainable practices. at the community level, awareness of circular economy involves promoting sustainable practices and adopting circular economy principles in european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/6821 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 5 local communities. this includes encouraging local businesses to adopt sustainable practices, supporting local recycling programs, and promoting the use of locally sourced products to reduce waste and promote sustainability. at the organizational level, awareness of circular economy involves promoting sustainable practices and using circular economy principles in organizations and businesses. this includes implementing sustainable supply chain practices, reducing waste in production processes, and promoting using renewable energy sources. at the industrial or national level, awareness of circular economy involves promoting the adoption of circular economy principles in industries and at the national level. this includes promoting sustainable manufacturing practices, reducing waste in production processes, and using renewable energy sources to reduce carbon emissions. at the humanitarian level, awareness of circular economy involves promoting sustainable practices in developing countries and using circular economy principles in humanitarian efforts. this includes promoting sustainable agriculture practices, reducing waste in refugee camps, and using renewable energy sources in humanitarian aid efforts. in summary, awareness of circular economy can be promoted at different levels, including individual, community, organizational, industrial or national, and humanitarian levels. this involves promoting sustainable practices, reducing waste, and using renewable energy sources to promote sustainability and reduce environmental degradation (mukwenda et al., 2019). 3.2 desire for circular economy the desire for a circular economy can be driven by various factors, such as communication, risks involvement, benefits, building momentum, and addressing fears. effective communication is essential in creating a desire for a circular economy. communication efforts should emphasize the importance of sustainability and the benefits of a circular economy in reducing waste and promoting the efficient use of resources. communication can be achieved through different channels, such as social media, advertising, public relations, and education programs. involving stakeholders, such as businesses, governments, and communities, in the circular economy process can help create a desire for the circular economy. by involving stakeholders in the process, they will understand the risks of not adopting sustainable practices and the benefits of a circular economy. communicating the benefits of a circular economy can create a desire for it. the benefits include reducing waste, conserving natural resources, creating jobs, and reducing greenhouse gas emissions. these benefits positively impact the environment, economy, and society (kirchherr et al., 2019). building momentum is important in creating a desire for a circular economy. this can be achieved by creating partnerships, collaborations, and alliances. the momentum created can drive change and inspire others to adopt sustainable practices. addressing fears related to a circular economy can create a desire for it. some fears include the loss of jobs, the cost of implementing sustainable practices, and difficulty changing consumer behaviour. addressing these fears can help stakeholders understand that a circular economy can create new jobs, save costs in the long run, and that change is possible. by doing so, stakeholders will understand the importance of adopting sustainable practices and be motivated to promote a circular economy (rodriguez, 2020). 3.3 knowledge of circular economy knowledge is the major contributor to ce successful implementation, and for this, the participants need to acquire technical skills, technology know-how, team dynamics skills, project management skills, collaborate with others to share learnings and within the decided time frame. knowledge of circular economy requires acquiring technical skills and technology competency. technical skills refer to using tools, machinery, and other equipment to perform specific tasks. in the context of a circular economy, technical skills are required to design products that can be easily recycled, repaired, or reused. technical skills are also needed in waste management, recycling, and upcycling processes (kirchherr et al., 2019). technology competency refers to the knowledge and ability to use technology to achieve specific goals. in the context of a circular economy, technology competency is essential in developing and implementing innovative technologies that support circular economy principles. this includes using digital platforms to facilitate the exchange of resources and materials, developing smart waste management systems, and using renewable energy sources. technical skills and technology competency can be acquired through various means, such as training programs, workshops, and educational courses. these programs can help individuals and organizations understand the principles of circular economy, learn about sustainable practices, and gain technical skills and technology competency. in addition, collaboration with other stakeholders can also help in acquiring technical skills and technology competency. partnerships with technology companies, research institutions, and other organizations can provide access to the latest technologies and knowledge supporting circular economy practices. by doing so, stakeholders can design products that support circular economy principles, implement sustainable practices, and european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/6821 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 6 create innovative solutions that promote a circular economy. group dynamics refer to how people interact and work together in a group setting. in a circular economy, group dynamics promote stakeholder collaboration, communication, and teamwork. this includes engaging stakeholders from different sectors and disciplines to work together towards common goals, sharing ideas and perspectives, and building trust and relationships. project management is also crucial in implementing circular economy practices. this involves setting clear goals, timelines, and budgets and identifying and managing risks and stakeholders. effective project management ensures that circular economy initiatives are implemented efficiently and effectively. shared learnings are also important in promoting knowledge of the circular economy. this involves sharing best practices, successes, and challenges among stakeholders. by learning from each other, stakeholders can identify opportunities for improvement and develop more effective circular economy strategies. finally, a clear time frame is essential in implementing circular economy practices. this involves setting realistic timelines and milestones, monitoring progress and adjusting strategies. a clear time frame ensures that circular economy initiatives are implemented promptly and effectively (stacy et al., 2021). 3.4 ability to implement circular economy circular economy is an economic system that aims to eliminate waste and promote the continual use and regeneration of resources. to implement circular economy, a formulated framework is needed to establish the principles and guidelines for the process. a strategy is also necessary to identify the areas where circular economy can be implemented, such as product design, resource management, and waste reduction. this strategy should be flexible to adapt to changing circumstances and evolving technologies. training is crucial to ensure that all stakeholders, including employees, suppliers, and customers, understand the principles and practices of the circular economy. transparency is also essential to build trust and accountability among all parties involved. finally, rework processes are necessary to ensure that any waste generated during the production or consumption cycle is reused or recycled. this can include repurposing materials, repairing products, or recycling waste back into the production process. by adopting this approach, we can promote sustainable and responsible resource use and create a more resilient and equitable economy (kachian et al., 2018). 3.5 reinforcement for circular economy change agents or leaders are individuals or groups who advocate for and initiate change within an organization or community. they can help promote circular economy's principles and encourage others to adopt sustainable practices. by providing leadership and guidance, change agents can help to reinforce the importance of the circular economy and ensure that it is integrated into the organization's culture and operations. learning from mistakes is also an important aspect of reinforcement. when mistakes are made, it provides an opportunity to learn and improve. by analyzing the causes of mistakes and identifying ways to prevent them in the future, organizations can strengthen their commitment to circular economy and reinforce the importance of sustainable practices. sharing experiences is another way to reinforce circular economy. organizations can inspire others to adopt sustainable practices by sharing success stories and best practices. this can be done through case studies, workshops, and other forms of communication. sharing experiences can also help to build a sense of community and collaboration around the principles of circular economy. in summary, reinforcement is critical for successfully implementing the circular economy. by leveraging change agents/leaders, learning from mistakes, and sharing experiences, organizations can strengthen their commitment to sustainability and promote the continual use and regeneration of resources. (khan et al., 2019). 3.6 feedback and continuous improvement through innovations the last step that has been suggested and added by the researchers as improvement in terms of innovation is the continuous development using r&d. the feedback can be given based on the measurement using the ce index, which is introduced below whether the implementation is going as expected or fine-tuning is required to set it on track. the innovations will start the whole cycle again, spreading awareness to measure the effectiveness of implementation feedback and continuous improvement are essential for successfully implementing a continuous loop in a circular economy (kirchherr et al., 2019). this involves using measurement, feedback, fine-tuning, and innovation to create a more sustainable and efficient system. measurement is a crucial part of the continuous loop process. it involves using an index, such as a sustainability index, to measure the organisation's activities' environmental, social, and economic impacts. by measuring european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/6821 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 7 these impacts, the organization can identify areas for improvement and track progress over time. feedback is another essential component of the continuous loop process. it involves collecting feedback from stakeholders, such as customers, employees, and suppliers, on the organization's sustainability efforts. this feedback can be used to identify improvement areas and develop new strategies to enhance sustainability. fine-tuning involves small adjustments to the organization's processes and practices to improve sustainability. this can involve optimizing supply chain efficiency, reducing waste, and reducing energy consumption. by fine-tuning these processes, the organization can reduce its environmental footprint and improve its overall sustainability. innovation is also important for continuous improvement in a circular economy. this involves developing new technologies, products, and services that promote sustainability and reduce waste. innovation can help to create new markets and opportunities for the organization, while also contributing to more sustainable outcomes. (jia et al., 2020). 3.7 circular economy index a circular economy index is a tool that measures an organization's progress towards implementing circular economy principles. this index typically includes a set of indicators that assess the organization's performance in areas such as resource efficiency, waste reduction, and product design. a circular economy index could be developed for uae universities to measure their progress towards implementing circular economy principles. resource efficiency measures the university's use of natural resources such as water, energy, and materials. this could include tracking energy consumption, water usage, and waste generation. waste reduction measures the university's efforts to reduce waste and increase recycling. this could include tracking the amount of waste generated, the percentage of recycled waste, and implementing waste reduction strategies such as composting and reusing materials. product design measures the university's efforts to design products and services that promote circularity. this could include tracking the use of sustainable materials, implementing product design strategies such as modular design, and developing new circular products and services. stakeholder engagement measures the university's efforts to engage stakeholders (such as students, faculty, and staff) in circular economy principles. this could include tracking the implementation of circular economy education programs, using circular economy messaging in marketing and communications, and developing circular economy partnerships with local businesses and organizations. this can help to promote sustainable practices and support the transition towards a more circular economy in the uae (de oliveira et al., 2021). 4. alternative solutions to problems by leveraging the prospects uae universities can contribute to the ce prospects by leading a lot of initiatives. some of the above-illustrated initiatives are already work in progress, and some are suggestions from the industry to the sector to contribute more (figure 3). figure 3. education sector in uae european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/6821 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 8 source: author’s elaboration 4.1 curriculum design for the circular economy curriculum design for the circular economy is the process of developing educational programs and courses that equip students with the knowledge, skills, and values needed to understand and apply circular economy principles in their future careers (kleba et al., 2020). i. identify learning objectives: this step involves determining what knowledge and skills students should acquire through the curriculum. learning objectives should be specific, measurable, achievable, relevant, and time-bound. ii. select relevant topics: this step involves selecting topics that are relevant to the circular economy, such as resource efficiency, waste reduction, product design, and sustainable business practices. topics should be aligned with the learning objectives. iii. develop learning activities: this step involves creating learning activities that engage students and enable them to apply circular economy principles. activities could include case studies, problem-based learning, and group projects. iv. choose relevant teaching methods: this step involves selecting teaching methods that are appropriate for the learning objectives and activities. teaching methods could include lectures, discussions, and experiential learning. v. incorporate assessment strategies: this step involves developing assessment strategies that measure student learning and achievement of the learning objectives. assessment strategies could include exams, essays, and presentations. vi. integrate technology: this step involves integrating technology into the curriculum to enhance student learning. the technology could be used for online learning, virtual simulations, and collaborative work. vii. review and revise: this step involves reviewing and revising the curriculum to ensure it is up-to-date, relevant, and aligned with the learning objectives. curriculum design for the circular economy should be interdisciplinary and incorporate a range of subjects, including engineering, business, environmental science, and social sciences. by integrating circular economy principles into the curriculum, students can develop the knowledge and skills to promote sustainable practices and support the transition towards a more circular economy (nunes et al., 2018). 4.3 research & development, collaborations & innovations research and development (r&d) and collaborations & innovations can be vital in ensuring a circular economy in uae universities. uae universities can invest in r&d to develop sustainable technologies that promote the circular economy. for example, the masdar institute of science and technology or khalifa university in abu dhabi has developed renewable energy technologies such as solar panels and wind turbines. uae universities can collaborate with industry partners to develop innovative solutions that promote the circular economy (kirchherr et al., 2019). for example, the dubai electricity and water authority (dewa) has partnered with the american university of dubai to develop a solar-powered air education sector in uae people involvement ce index using smart apps curriculum design campus application research development, innovation & collaboration emerging technology european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/6821 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 9 conditioning system. uae universities can implement circular business models that promote product reuse, repair, and recycling. for example, the dubai future accelerators program has partnered with universities to develop circular business models for waste management. uae universities can educate students and raise awareness about the importance of the circular economy. for example, the university of dubai has implemented a sustainability-focused curriculum that teaches students about sustainable business practices and the circular economy. uae universities can provide funding for circular economy projects that promote sustainable practices. for example, the abu dhabi sustainability week funds research and development projects promoting sustainability and circular economy. r&d and, collaborations & innovations can ensure a circular economy in uae universities by developing sustainable technologies, collaborating with industry partners, implementing circular business models, educating students, and providing funding for circular economy projects. by promoting a circular economy, uae universities can contribute to a sustainable future for the uae and the world. (brown et al., 2019). 4.4 emerging technology usage emerging technology usage can play a significant role in supporting the circular economy in uae universities. iot is a network of devices connected to the internet that can communicate with each other. in universities, iot technology can monitor and optimize resource consumption, such as energy and water usage. this can help universities reduce waste and promote a circular economy (kirchherr et al., 2019). 3d printing is a technology that allows objects to be created by adding layers of material. in universities, 3d printing can create objects from recycled materials, reducing waste and promoting a circular economy. blockchain is a decentralized digital ledger that records transactions securely and transparently. in universities, blockchain technology can track the provenance of materials, ensuring that they are sustainably sourced and promoting a circular economy. ai is the use of computer systems to perform tasks that would normally require human intelligence. in universities, ai can be used to optimize resource consumption, predict maintenance needs, and identify opportunities for waste reduction, promoting a circular economy. ar is a technology that overlays digital information into the real world. in universities, ar can be used to create immersive educational experiences that teach students about sustainable practices and the circular economy. emerging technology usage can support uae universities' circular economy by optimising resources, reducing waste, promoting sustainable sourcing, and creating immersive educational experiences. by leveraging the power of technology, uae universities can contribute to a sustainable future for the uae and the world. (jose et al., 2020). 4.5 people involvement people's involvement is crucial for enhancing circular economy in uae universities. people's involvement is necessary to encourage participation in circular economy initiatives. students, faculty, and staff need to be engaged in the planning and implementing of circular economy initiatives, and their feedback needs to be considered. people's involvement is necessary to implement behavioural changes that support circular economy initiatives. students, faculty, and staff must be educated on sustainable practices and provided with the necessary tools and resources to implement them. people's involvement is necessary to encourage innovation in circular economy initiatives (kirchherr et al., 2019). students, faculty, and staff can contribute to developing new technologies, processes, and practices that support circular economy principles. people involvement is necessary to promote collaboration between different departments and stakeholders in the university. circular economy initiatives require the collaboration of various departments, including facilities management, procurement, and sustainability. people's involvement is necessary to enhance the circular economy in uae universities. by promoting awareness, encouraging participation, implementing behavioural changes, encouraging innovation, and promoting collaboration, uae universities can contribute to a sustainable future for the uae and the world. the implementation and success of the ce project depend on the people involved and their wholehearted participation. first, the people need to convince of the need for the ce requirements, importance and benefits, which proper training and workshops on the topics can augment. the people's involvement can be consolidated by introducing extrinsic and intrinsic rewards to motivate them (bonato et al., 2018). 4.5 circular economy using smart app european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/6821 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 10 the ce index is a tool that measures the extent to which circular economy principles are being implemented in an organization. a smart application can collect data on circular economy practices in uae universities. this can help identify areas where improvements can be made and track progress over time. using a smart application to track ce index, uae universities can increase awareness of circular economy principles among students, faculty, and staff. this can encourage greater participation and a culture of sustainability (kirchherr et al., 2019). a smart application can help identify areas where innovation can be applied to improve circular economy practices. this can lead to new technologies, processes, and practices supporting circular economy principles. using a smart application to track ce index can give uae universities a clear picture of their progress towards circular economy goals. this can help identify areas where improvements can be made and track progress over time. a smart application can facilitate collaboration between different departments and stakeholders in uae universities. uae universities can work together to improve their circular economy practices by providing a platform for sharing data and ideas. ce index using a smart application, can boost circular economy in uae universities by improving data collection, increasing awareness, encouraging innovation, monitoring progress, and facilitating collaboration. using such a tool, uae universities can contribute to a sustainable future for the uae and the world. the ce index development can be a major contribution to the area of existing knowledge and help in measuring the organization’s current initiatives on a standardized scale compared to the other industrial initiative and can make suggestions to implement more projects. the index will induce competitiveness among the various organizations and help the cause of csr and ce (figure 4) (upadhyay et al., 2021). figure 4. sustainable development goals (sdgs) source: author’s elaboration european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/6821 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 11 table 1. sustainability development goals1 (sdgs) sdg no. description of how the uae education sector can develop this sdg 1. eradicate poverty by education, which uae education sector can contribute 2. make learners employable and as entrepreneurs 3. train people on well-being and health and spread awareness and run research projects. 4. standardized common circular economy curriculum 5. gender equality exemplary practices at the uae education sector organizations 6. awareness and experimental learning at the campus 7. implement projects on campus & collaborate with industry, design curriculum for these projects 8. uae education can develop research, encourage innovativeness in renewable energy, tie-up with industry to partner more projects 9. uae education is recognized as economic contributor as education hub for the middle east and the many collaborations with the industry, is leading the way forward 10. uae education lead research & development initiatives and implement innovations that will contribute to ce and to build infrastructure for such future initiatives. 11. uae education can spread awareness and initiatives for building smart cities and communities like dubai and abu dhabi. 12. the collaboration with the industry the uae education sector can lead initiatives towards responsible consumption and production of goods, products, services to ce and away from the linear economy. 13. the uae education can build ecological, economical curriculum to spread awareness of the human action on nature and the subsequent climate changes. 14. the uae education can spread awareness of the impact of human activities affecting ocean lives and actions to avoid such impact. 15. the uae education can spread awareness of the impact of human activities affecting lives on land and actions to avoid such impact. 16. institutes like unep, who should educate the people in collaboration with government like uae, involving the education sector to spread peace & justice. 17. the uae education collaborates with the public and private companies to achieve ce goals leading to sustainability in business. source: author’s elaboration the sdgs of the un shown in table 1 can be extended to be the circular economy initiatives for the uae education sector. the above table shows the contribution of the uae education sector towards the sdgs, making them ce goals that can be reworked as circular economy development goals (cedgs) in the future (rodriguez-anton et al., 2019). the circular economy of uae universities can contribute to several sustainable development goals (sdgs) set by the united 1 https://sdgs.un.org/ european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/6821 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 12 nations. the circular economy of uae universities can promote responsible consumption and production by reducing waste and promoting the reuse and recycling of materials (sdg 12). the circular economy of uae universities can contribute to climate action by reducing greenhouse gas emissions through renewable energy, energy-efficient technologies, and sustainable practices (sdg 13climate action). the circular economy of uae universities can provide quality education by integrating circular economy principles and practices into the curriculum, providing students with the knowledge and skills needed to build a sustainable future (sdg 4quality education). the circular economy of uae universities can promote innovation and infrastructure development by encouraging the adoption of new technologies and processes that support circular economy principles (sdg 9industry, innovation, and infrastructure). the circular economy of uae universities can contribute to sustainable cities and communities by promoting renewable energy, reducing waste, and encouraging sustainable practices (sdg 11sustainable cities and communities). the circular economy of uae universities can foster partnerships by collaborating with local communities, businesses, and government agencies to promote sustainable practices and achieve the sdgs (sdg 17partnerships for the goals). in summary, the circular economy of uae universities can contribute to several sdgs, including responsible consumption and production, climate action, quality education, industry, innovation, infrastructure, sustainable cities and communities, and partnerships for the goals (kirchherr et al., 2019). 5. barriers that need to be overcome for successful ce projects implementation while implementing circular economy projects in uae universities can bring numerous benefits, several barriers must be addressed to ensure their success. one of the primary barriers to implementing circular economy projects in uae universities is a need for more awareness among stakeholders about the benefits of circular economy. without a clear understanding of the principles and advantages of the circular economy, stakeholders may not see the value in investing in such projects (kirchherr et al., 2019). the limited budget is another significant barrier to implementing circular economy projects in uae universities. circular economy projects often require significant investment in new technologies and processes, which may not be feasible for universities with limited financial resources. resistance to change is another barrier to implementing circular economy projects. some stakeholders may be resistant to change and unwilling to adopt new practices or technologies that support circular economy principles. implementing circular economy projects requires specialized expertise and knowledge. uae universities may need to gain in-house expertise, making it challenging to implement circular economy projects successfully. implementing circular economy projects in uae universities requires collaboration between stakeholders, including faculty, staff, and students. with collaboration, it can be easier to achieve the desired outcomes. to overcome these barriers, uae universities must invest in awareness-raising campaigns, allocate adequate budgets, provide training and capacity building to staff and students, and foster a culture of collaboration and innovation. by addressing these barriers, uae universities can successfully implement circular economy projects and contribute to a more sustainable future. the united nations should recognize the ce development programs; the un support will force governments to follow suit. the uae government must announce policies that exempt and give concessions to organizations developing ce initiatives. the individual mindset can be shifted by spreading awareness of employee benefits, importance, and individual rewards. the employees' participation in implementing these ce projects will accelerate and ensure their success. the major barriers are culture, lack of knowledge, lack of resources, and lack of priority for organizations to implement ce projects. the uae education sector should navigate these barriers successfully (hart et al., 2019). 6. discussion and conclusion the objectives have been met and established. the sdgs of the un can be extended to be the circular economy initiatives in the various sectors, as the study has shown for the uae education sector. the objective of suggesting ce initiatives to be implemented by the uae education sector has been met. the main contribution has been the management change perspective used to ensure the ce initiatives' successful implementation. the suggestions and recommendations will help managers successfully implement ce initiatives with government policy support. the contribution of this study is the addition of innovation and a continuous feedback loop added to the adkar management change model. quantitative and qualitative studies can confirm these findings in future research and use other change management models to spearhead these european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/6821 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 13 ce initiatives in the education sector and other sectors. "the emerging circular economy trends of uae universities" research makes several theoretical contributions to the field of circular economy. a. firstly, the research contributes to understanding the adoption of circular economy practices in the higher education sector. the study explores uae universities' current circular economy practices, which provides valuable insights into the strategies universities can adopt to reduce their environmental impact and achieve sustainability goals. secondly, the research contributes to the literature on the circular economy by identifying emerging trends in the circular economy practices of uae universities. by analyzing the data collected from the survey, the research identifies several emerging trends universities can adopt to promote circular economy practices. these emerging trends include the use of renewable energy, the development of circular business models, and the adoption of sustainable procurement practices. thirdly, the research contributes to developing a circular economy framework for the higher education sector. the study proposes a framework universities can use to guide their circular economy practices. the framework includes three key components: circular design and production, circular consumption and waste management, and circular business models and collaborations. overall, "the emerging circular economy trends of uae universities" research provides a valuable contribution to understanding circular economy practices in the higher education sector, identifies emerging trends, and proposes a framework universities can use to guide their circular economy practices. b. firstly, the research provides practical implications for universities to adopt circular economy practices. the study identifies several emerging trends, such as the use of renewable energy, sustainable procurement practices, and circular business models. universities can use this information to develop strategies to reduce their environmental impact, promote sustainability, and achieve sustainability goals. secondly, the research has policy implications for policymakers promoting circular economy practices in higher education. the study proposes a framework that policymakers can use to guide universities in adopting circular economy practices. policymakers can use this framework to develop policies and regulations encouraging universities to adopt circular economy practices. thirdly, the research has practical and policy implications for the wider community. by adopting circular economy practices, universities can become leaders in promoting sustainable practices and reducing their environmental impact. this can inspire other businesses and institutions to adopt circular economy practices, leading to wider adoption of sustainable practices in the community. overall, the research "the emerging circular economy trends of uae universities" has practical and policy implications for universities, policymakers, and the wider community in promoting circular economy practices and achieving sustainability goals. 8. recommendations for future research further empirical research is needed to assess the effectiveness of circular economy practices in uae universities. this research should focus on the impact of these practices on sustainability and resource efficiency. there is a need for more indepth research on the challenges associated with implementing circular economy practices in uae universities. this research should identify the barriers to adoption and the strategies for overcoming them. future research should focus on stakeholder engagement, including the attitudes and perceptions of students, faculty, and administrators towards circular economy practices. this research should also explore the role of stakeholder engagement in the successful implementation of these practices. comparative analysis of circular economy practices in uae universities with universities in other countries can provide insights into the best practices and strategies for implementation. future research should focus on the long-term impact of circular economy practices in uae universities, including their impact on sustainability and resource efficiency. this can help universities assess their sustainability efforts' effectiveness and make adjustments as needed. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/6821 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 14 references baars, j., domenech, t., bleischwitz, r., melin, h. e., & heidrich, o. (2021). circular economy strategies for electric vehicle batteries reduce reliance on raw materials. nature sustainability, 4(1), 71-79. bonato, d., & orsini, r. (2018). urban circular economy: the new frontier for european cities' sustainable development. in sustainable cities and communities design handbook (pp. 235-245). butterworth-heinemann. https://doi.org/10.1016/b978-0-12-813964-6.00012-4 brown, p., bocken, n., & balkenende, r. (2019). why do companies pursue collaborative circular oriented innovation? sustainability, 11(3), 635. mdpi ag. retrieved from http://dx.doi.org/10.3390/su11030635 campra, m., brescia, v., jafari-sadeghi, v., & calandra, d. (2021). islamic countries and maqasid al-shariah towards the circular economy. the dubai case study. european journal of islamic finance, (17). https://doi.org/10.13135/24212172/4560 dantas, t. e., de-souza, e. d., destro, i. r., hammes, g., rodriguez, c. m. t., & soares, s. r. (2021). how the combination of circular economy and industry 4.0 can contribute towards achieving the sustainable development goals. sustainable production and consumption, 26, 213-227. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.spc.2020.10.005 dave, s., & shaikh, n. (2022). technological innovations in supply chain management towards a circular economy in the healthcare sector of the uae. in handbook of research on green, circular, and digital economies as tools for recovery and sustainability (pp. 142-155). igi global. de oliveira, c. t., dantas, t. e. t., & soares, s. r. (2021). nano and micro level circular economy indicators: assisting decision-makers in circularity assessments. sustainable production and consumption, 26, 455-468. ghareeb, s., al-jumeily, r., & baker, t. (2020). a machine learning based framework for education levelling in multicultural countries: uae as a case study. international journal of humanities and social sciences, 14(12), 1181-1184. griffiths, s., & sovacool, b. k. (2020). rethinking the future low-carbon city: carbon neutrality, green design, and sustainability tensions in the making of masdar city. energy research & social science, 62, 101368. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.erss.2019.101368 hart, j., adams, k., giesekam, j., tingley, d. d., & pomponi, f. (2019). barriers and drivers in a circular economy: the case of the built environment. procedia cirp, 80, 619-624. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.procir.2018.12.015 iyer, s. s., seetharaman, a., & maddulety, k. (2020). education transformation using block chain technology-a student centric model. in: sharma s.k., dwivedi y.k., metri b., rana n.p. (eds) re-imagining diffusion and adoption of information technology and systems: a continuing conversation. tdit 2020. ifip advances in information and communication technology, vol 617 international working conference on transfer and diffusion of it (pp. 201-217). springer, cham. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-64849-7_19 iyer, s. s. (2022). application of digital technologies: integrated blockchain with emerging technologies. in y. ramakrishna (eds.), handbook of research on supply chain resiliency, efficiency, and visibility in the post-pandemic era (pp. 267-294). igi global. https://doi.org/10.4018/978-1-7998-9506-0.ch014 jia, f., yin, s., chen, l., & chen, x. (2020). the circular economy in the textile and apparel industry: a systematic literature review. journal of cleaner production, 259, 120728. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2020.120728. jose, r., panigrahi, s. k., patil, r. a., fernando, y., & ramakrishna, s. (2020). artificial intelligence-driven circular economy as a key enabler for sustainable energy management. materials circular economy, 2(1), 1-7. https://doi.org/10.1007/s42824-020-00009-9 kachian, a., elyasi, s., & haghani, h. (2018). adkar model and nurses' readiness for change. journal of clientcentered nursing care, 4(4), 203-212. khan, h. u., & smuts, r. g. (2019). a comparison of change management guidelines to address technology adoption barriers: a case study of higher educational institutions. journal of theoretical and applied information technology, 97(7), 1999-2021. kirchherr, j., & piscicelli, l. (2019). towards an education for the circular economy (ece): five teaching principles and a case study. resources, conservation and recycling, 150, 104406. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.resconrec.2019.104406 kleba, j. b., & cruz, c. c. (2020). building engaged engineering in curriculum-a review of brazilian and australian cases. in 2020 asee virtual annual conference content access. virtual online. 10.18260/1-2--34240 european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/6821 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 15 lusk, j., mook, a. (2020). hyper-consumption to circular economy in the united arab emirates: discarding the disposable and cherishing the valuable. socioeconomic challenges, 4(3), 33-45. https://doi.org/10.21272/sec.4(3).3345.2020 mendoza, j. m. f., gallego-schmid, a., & azapagic, a. (2019). a methodological framework for the implementation of circular economy thinking in higher education institutions: towards sustainable campus management. journal of cleaner production, 226, 831-844. mendoza, j. m. f., gallego-schmid, a., & azapagic, a. (2019). building a business case for implementation of a circular economy in higher education institutions. journal of cleaner production, 220, 553-567. mukwenda, h. t. (2019). adaptation of the adkar model to the management of the higher education student loan scheme in uganda. makerere journal of higher education, 11(1), 45-57. nunes, b. t., pollard, s. j., burgess, p. j., ellis, g., de los rios, i. c., & charnley, f. (2018). university contributions to the circular economy: professing the hidden curriculum. sustainability, 10(8), 2719. https://doi.org/10.3390/su10082719 rodriguez vazquez, s. (2020). applying the adkar model to boost web accessibility in higher education institutions. in 3rd swiss conference on barrier-free communication (bfc 2020). rodriguez-anton, j. m., rubio-andrada, l., celemín-pedroche, m. s., & alonso-almeida, m. d. m. (2019). analysis of the relations between circular economy and sustainable development goals. international journal of sustainable development & world ecology, 26(8), 708-720. https://doi.org/10.1080/13504509.2019.1666754 stacy, m., gross, g., & adams, l. (2021). applying organizational change theory to address the long-standing problem of harassment in medical education. teaching and learning in medicine, 1-9. doi: 10.1080/10401334.2021.1954523. upadhyay, a., mukhuty, s., kumar, v., & kazancoglu, y. (2021). blockchain technology and the circular economy: implications for sustainability and social responsibility. journal of cleaner production, 293, 126130. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2021.126130 microsoft word 2 audrone .docx http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5085 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 27 the effective methods and practices for accelerating social entrepreneurship through corporate social responsibility audrone urmanaviciene1; udara suwanda arachchi2 1. tallinn university, estonia; orcid id: 0000-0003-1621-0101; email: aurmana@tlu.ee 2. tallinn university, estonia; orcid id: 0000-0003-2618-6758; email: s.a.d.udara@gmail.com received: 12/09/2020 revised: 07/10/2020 accepted for publication: 08/10/2020 published: 26/10/2020 abstract the concepts of social entrepreneurship and corporate social responsibility have similar values from the social value perspective. social entrepreneurship focuses on solving social issues, creating a positive social impact in an innovative entrepreneurial way, and profit maximization is not the primary target. corporations focus on creating economic values and profit maximization; and use the csr concept as a tool to maintain socially responsible business conduct. both csr and social entrepreneurship concepts represent the same sustainable values in different ways. thus, finding effective methods for accelerating social entrepreneurship through csr activities will be fruitful for the betterment of the corporation’s stakeholders, social entrepreneurs, and society at large. this paper aims to explore the current csr activities of corporations that influence social entrepreneurship development and to identify the most effective methods/practices to accelerate social entrepreneurship. this study follows the qualitative inductive research methodology; and, the content analysis method has been used to analyze the collected data through the in-depth semi-structured expert interviews. it has been found that the current csr practices for social entrepreneurship development are comparatively less than other community development and philanthropic considerations. moreover, the challenges for social entrepreneurs and the expectations of corporations have been thoroughly discussed. the effective methods http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5085 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 28 and practices have been suggested for both corporations and social entrepreneurs to accelerate social entrepreneurship by csr activities with mutual benefits and creating social value; as a win-win situation. keywords: corporate culture, effective methods, social enterprise, social impact, social value creation, sustainability 1. introduction corporations support ngos, social organizations, and other small medium enterprises as their csr activities (fernando & lawrance, 2015). corporations expect to enhance the corporate reputation, gain employee loyalty and retention, maintain the trust, support, and legitimacy of the community and government, and business benefits from those csr activities (moir, 2001). accordingly, it can be considered the purpose of a corporation engaging in csr activities to act socially responsible while achieving its economic goals as profit maximization and maintaining competitiveness. moreover, there is a need to use more innovative models of using csr activities to maximize the benefits for both corporations and society (singh, 2016). hence, empowering social entrepreneurship through csr's influence would benefit both corporations to achieve their organizational goals and social entrepreneurs to make a positive social impact. it could be a ‘win-win’ situation for both while benefiting society at large. research has been done for effective csr by seelos & mair (2005), bonini, mendonca & oppenheim (2006), and galbreath (2009). moreover, empowering social entrepreneurship through the influence of csr for addressing social issues has been discussed by archana singh (2018), mahfoozur rahman (2018), michelle bredhammar & pia slesinski (2019), theoretically in their researches for the development of the concept. those findings and theories are essential to analyze the theoretical aspects of both concepts and practices. the companies adequately address social problems through csr will reap the rewards of competitive positions in the future while benefiting their stakeholders, and also society at large (galbreath, 2009). thus, companies should consider those social dimensions as opportunities, not risks (bonini, mendonc & oppenheim, 2006). simultaneously, support for social entrepreneurship development can be used as a powerful tool for corporations to gain loyalty in the market. moreover, serial social entrepreneurs european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5085 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 28 may be the best hope for both society and companies wanting to participate in new market development (seelos & mair, 2005). there is a need for identifying the most effective and practical ways of influencing social entrepreneurship development through csr activities of corporations because the reality is that social entrepreneurs and corporations still live in different worlds today (seelos & mair, 2005). there is a significant knowledge gap in the effective methods and practices of influencing social entrepreneurship through csr activities of corporations. accordingly, finding practical and effective methods for influencing social entrepreneurship development through csr activities will be fruitful for the betterment of the corporation’s stakeholders and society at large. this study aims to identify the most effective methods and practices that accelerate the social entrepreneurship development through the influence of csr activities of corporations. the objective of this research is to analyze the current csr activities of corporations that influence social entrepreneurship development. therefore, this research analyses the current practice of csr activities of corporations and identifies the most effective practices and methods of using csr activities of corporations to develop social entrepreneurship. moreover, the challenges for social entrepreneurship development has been thoroughly discussed. the recommendations have been given for the corporations and social entrepreneurs according to the findings of this study. 2. literature review corporate social responsibility is a broad concept that is discussed in different aspects of business literature. it can be considered as one of the first critical concepts that collaborating businesses and social associates for enlightening the society at large and business itself (jamali, 2007). the concept is famous as a voluntary principle that creates social value and welfare while maximizing profits in corporate governance. the significance of being socially responsible in business has been increased nowadays due to social and environmental issues. moreover, the external pressure is getting higher for corporations to address societal issues from the stakeholders (porter & kramer, 2011). the csr concept is being widely spoken in the global economy and has attracted worldwide acknowledgment; it has been developed over time through globalization and increase of international trade (jamali, 2007). the core value and purpose of csr are to maintain the organization's economic aspects while balancing the environmental and social facts. in other words, act as a socially responsible organization and create a positive impact on social, environmental, and economic factors. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5085 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 29 social entrepreneurship (hereinafter referred to as 'se') is an emerging concept to address societal issues innovatively. se's primary focus is to address social issues and create social value, not like focusing on maximizing profits as a usual business (dees, 1998). most importantly, social entrepreneurship is the process of identifying and exploiting opportunities in social problems, mobilizing resources, and acting innovatively for solving those social problems while creating social value and bringing positive social impact (singh, 2016). social entrepreneurship is standing beyond traditional entrepreneurship because it creates values for stakeholders and solving social problems. social entrepreneurs have trained to identify social issues. they use their creativity and entrepreneurial skills to solve those social issues effectively and innovatively (nicholls, 2006). they try to cure the real causes of social problems rather than dealing with the symptoms. thus, social entrepreneurs are identified as value creators and change agents (nicholls, 2006). social entrepreneurs are being motivated by their personality and the background, which concerns societal issues (cherrier, goswami & ray, 2017). the relationship between the concept of csr and se depends on the focusing objective and the purpose of implementation. csr is considered as a voluntary principle in corporate governance, which is used to create social value as well as maximize corporation’s profits through corporate goodwill, fair competition as well as build loyal customer groups (gallardo et al, 2019). as stated by the european commission swd (2019), it can be identified as responsible business conduct; as “the responsibility of enterprises for their impact on society.” csr is a set of guidelines to mitigate the negative social impact of the business, as well as integrating social, environmental, ethical, human rights, and consumer concerns in the business operation and core strategy. “companies should have in place a process to integrate social, environmental, ethical, human rights and consumer concerns into their business operations and core strategy in close collaboration with their stakeholders, with the aim of maximizing the creation of shared value for their owners/shareholders and civil society at large and identifying, preventing and mitigating possible adverse impacts.” european commission swd (2019). csr has been identified as a shared value creation approach of the corporation with the collaboration of stakeholders and detects, prevents, and mitigates negative impacts while running the regular business focuses on commercial value. according to carroll’s (1979) pyramid, csr activities may be philanthropic or charity; indeed, a discretionary decision of the management. the core of the concept of se is differentiated with the csr from its primary objective, which is focused on solving a specific social european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5085 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 30 problem in an entrepreneurial way. social entrepreneurs identify a social issue that affects a set of social groups or environment, then try to find an innovative solution for mitigating that problem or creating social value using an entrepreneurial approach, not like charity or philanthropic context. as claimed by the oecd (1999), se does not focus on profit maximization or taking competitive advantage from its social goals; instead, it attains specific social and economic goals by providing innovative solutions. “any private activity conducted in the public interest, organized with an entrepreneurial strategy, but whose main purpose is not the maximization of profit but the attainment of certain economic and social goals, and which has the capacity for bringing innovative solutions to the problems of social exclusion and unemployment” oecd (1999). the concept of csr has been widely discussed as a strategic approach in the 2000s by the smith (2001), lantos (2001), marrewijk (2003), werther & chandler (2005), porter & kramer (2006), husted & allen (2007), heslin & ochoa (2008) and gallardo et al. (2019). they have identified it as strategic corporate social responsibility (scsr), which is majorly considered as a sustainable competitive advantage. scsr can generate positive social impact while generating profits by improving customer loyalty and the company’s reputation. scsr will make the business environment for creating new products as well as new marketing opportunities in the global context. moreover, it has been identified as a ‘social contract’ between the corporation and society. scsr has been further developed as creation of shared value (csv), and it is being discussed in the academic context and the practice widely after the 2010s by the authors; most importantly, porter & kramer (2011), trapp (2012), and chandler (2016). these developments of csr have driven the standard definition towards the socially responsible business movement. the main purpose of using csr has been considered as a core value and the strategic principle of the corporate firms. porter and kramer (2011) have mentioned that corporations should redefine their purpose of profit maximization for the shared value creation. moreover, companies should focus on creating shared value using their expertise instead of economic benefits; by incorporating the principles of shared value to the corporate framework and culture through the decision-making process as well as using clear guiding principles (chandler, 2016). the concepts of scsr and csv have shifted csr's regular usage towards social value creation, which is the main purpose of se. accordingly, it can be seen a close relationship between csr and se in the main purpose and the objectives. table 1 depicts the relationship and the differences between csr and se within the scope of purpose, objective, target group, goal, motivation, and the operation. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5085 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 31 table 1 – relationship between csr and se variables corporate social responsibility social entrepreneurship purpose creation of economic value in an ethical, social and environmental friendly way creation of social value objective profit maximization and stakeholder satisfaction solving social and environmental issues target group pay nothing subsidized or market rate goal accountability and goodwill social impact motivation strategically decided emotionally charged operation charity or philanthropy through products and services source – developed by the authors the main purpose of csr is to create economic value and shared social value for maximizing its profits by taking a competitive advantage. moreover, the objective of csr focuses on profit maximization and stakeholder satisfaction. corporations try to minimize the social and environmental harm within the context of business; thereafter, consider ethical and philanthropic values. as stated by werther & chandler (2005), the implementation of csr policies to the corporation can be considered as a part of brand management to achieve and maintain legitimacy in the global context. se considers its purpose as the creation of economic and social value at the same time. the objective of se is to address social and environmental issues innovatively. in the opinion of tommaso & antonino (2014), the noble goal of social entrepreneurship is to save the world or at least make it a better place. hence, the main purpose and objectives of both concepts have some similarities as well as dissimilarities. within the scope of csr operation, it may be charity or philanthropy activity towards a specific social or environmental fact. the operation of se is conducted through its products or services. furthermore, the target group of the csr pays nothing, even though the target group of the se pays market rate or subsidized rate for the products or services. most importantly, the motivation for the csr could be strategically decided by the higher management of the corporation. social entrepreneurs are emotionally charged and performed by the sensitivity and empathy towards social vulnerabilities. in the european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5085 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 32 opinion of thompson et al. (2000), social entrepreneurs are social leaders who realize the opportunity to satisfy the unmet social needs and make a social change. creating social and environmental value can be considered as a common goal of both csr and se. it can be argued that the socially responsible business model and the long-term business sustainability are also similarities of csr and se. there are similarities and common goals between csr and se, as discussed in the previous chapter. both entities are focusing on creating social and environmental value and long-term sustainability. social entrepreneurs are emotionally motivated by social issues; thus, they tend to find entrepreneurial solutions. in csr, corporations try to minimize their negative effect and create social or environmental value for their brand management and stakeholder satisfaction. therefore, making a combination of csr and se would be more beneficial for addressing actual social issues and create social value while achieving their own commercial goals. social entrepreneurs face several critical challenges; social and cultural effects, lack of financial assistance, lack of human resources, and scaling up business with competitive disadvantages. if csr could support social entrepreneurs to face those challenges and obstacles, it will be a win-win situation for both corporations and social entrepreneurs. the following figure 1 shows the csr practices that can foster se development. figure 1 – csr practices for se development european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5085 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 33 source – developed by the authors supporting se education – corporations can invest in social venture capital and educational institutions to develop skills of the social change makers would be more beneficial for the social value creation and the corporation itself. as stated by nicholls (2006), se is still in a developing mode; even a few business schools conduct se courses. indeed, social enterprises are genuinely experimenting, and they could be the first of their kind; thus, the success of their projects will depend on their strategic and systematic approach (jhonson, 2000). hence, corporations can cultivate se education through scholarships, awareness programs, and mentorship programs to encourage social entrepreneurs. providing management training – lack of skilled human resources is one of the main obstacles for the se development. social entrepreneurs have emotionally charged strong feelings to solve social issues and create a positive social impact, despite the fact that they do not have enough managerial skills to maintain the enterprise for self-sustaining and generating profits. according to the seven universal principles of heslin & ochoa (2008), cultivate the needed talent can be considered as a greater approach european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5085 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 34 of scsr. thus, corporations can provide management training, internship opportunities, and accelerator programs to improve management skills. moreover, companies can provide management skills and resources for scaling up the se (seelos & mair, 2005). supporting financially and investing – social entrepreneurs face a lack of financial support when they initiate social enterprises. as dees and anderson (2006) stated, social entrepreneurs, find capital from either below-market and market-rate capital investments or donations; thus, se may face a financial struggle when starting the social enterprise as well as while running the business. corporations could financially support or make investments below the market-rate as their csr practices; it would be beneficial for a broader group of vulnerable people or the environment. mentoring and incubation – social entrepreneurs tend to identify the actual social issues and practical solutions for those effectively despite the need for clear guidance and mentorship to implement the strong business that can survive and compete in the existing market and alternative products and services. hence, incubation and mentoring support are needed for building a strong business model with a value proposition to being in the competitive market. corporations can share their knowledge and the expertise to mentor and incubate the social entrepreneurs to initiate and scale up their ideas for the long run. collaboration and partnerships – companies can support se through collaborations and partnerships, which can achieve the common goal of social value creation. in seelos and mair's (2005b) opinion, social entrepreneurs bring a lot to the table as partners for corporations. another way is conducting csr through a third party, such as social enterprise; if companies feel that they have less expertise in the field of competency for developing and csr practices, they can identify the existing social enterprises doing great work in their interest areas and support them financially or by providing partnerships and collaborations. “serial social entrepreneurs may be the best hope, both for the poor and for companies wanting to participate in new market development models.” seelos and mair (2005b). it can be seen that csr and se have common goals of creating social and environmental value. at the same time, csr focuses more on economic return, and se focuses on positive social impact. social entrepreneurs have expertise in identifying actual social issues, implementing solutions, and creating social benefits rather than purely economic corporations. however, social entrepreneurs face a set of european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5085 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 35 financial and human resources challenges when they implement their solutions. simultaneously, corporations spend a considerable amount of money on csr activities to maintain their strategy, competitive advantage, and corporate goodwill. therefore, it can be argued that if csr supports the development of se, it would be more beneficial for the society at large and the environment; while bringing economic value for the corporations itself. ultimately it will be a win-win situation for both business corporations as well as the social enterprise. 3. methodology this study follows a qualitative inductive research methodology; and, the content analysis method has been used to analyze the collected data. in-depth and semi-structured expert interviews have been carried out with experts representing three main categories; social entrepreneurs, scholars, and company representatives. the authors have selected experts according to these criteria: 1) social entrepreneurs, who have been supported by csr activities of a corporation and/or actively run/consult the social enterprise within the last five years; 2) scholars, who have actively contributed in teaching csr and se and/or have research experience in csr and se at least five years. 3) company representatives, who are managerial level representatives or consultants of the corporations which have done at least one or more csr activities within the last five years. the three main categories have been more explained in detail in table 2. table 2 : code of the interviewee, category, personal profile and remarks code for the interviewee category personal profile european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5085 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 36 s-1 scholars phd, associate professor at one of the estonian university. 18 years teaching experience in the fields of social policy, social work, social entrepreneurship, corporate social responsibility and social innovations. s-2 scholars phd, associate professor at one of the estonian university. 12 years teaching experience in the fields of management, social entrepreneurship, management in public, private and non-profit sectors and social innovation. c-1 company representatives communication manager at a leading bank in estonia, board member of csr forum, 19 years experience in corporate governance, sme and corporate communication. c-2 company representatives marketing manager at a leading telecommunication provider in estonia, 8 years experience in corporate governance and csr activities. e-1 social entrepreneurs 14 years experience in social entrepreneurship and impact management. e-2 social entrepreneurs founder and ceo of social enterprise, which is being supported by csr activities of several corporations. source – developed by authors these in-depth interviews assisted the researchers in collecting richly descriptive information. mainly, the researchers developed four interview questions that covered the research question. the questionnaire included the following questions: 1. how do you describe the concept of csr? how do you explain the socially responsible business conduct? 2. how do you define social entrepreneurship? what are the challenges for social entrepreneurship development? 3. how can csr support se to overcome its challenges? what are the ways that corporations use their csr activities to support se? are you satisfied with the current contribution of csr for se development? 4. what are the benefits of csr practices for both corporations and se? what are the most effective methods of using csr activities for se development? how to improve csr practices in order to foster se development? european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5085 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 37 the authors have sent invitations for participants via e-mails in the second week of april 2020. the interviews were conducted online in the period of 20th april to 10th may, using the zoom platform. each interview was taken 30 minutes to 90 minutes; all the online calls were recorded with the interviewees' consent. depending on the experts' request, the names of the experts are not provided, and when quoting the expert's statement, his/her code is indicated. the list of experts and the description of the characteristics supporting their competence are presented in table 2. it should be noted that when describing experts to ensure their anonymity, experts are described using the masculine gender, as accepted by reference to positions, degrees, or other depersonalized data. the study has some limitations. firstly, purposive sampling has been used; thus, the study does not represent the unknown proportion of the entire population regarding the subject matter as scholars, social entrepreneurs, and corporate representatives. moreover, the sample is selected based on the researcher’s accessibility and personal judgment; therefore, there could be a reasonable probability of having uncontrolled variability and possible bias in the sample estimating. hence, the findings could have a lower level of generalization compared to probability sampling. moreover, the empirical data collection has been conducted in estonia, though the study is not focused on any specific territory or region; therefore, it may cause a lower level of generalization in conceptual perspectives of the findings. 4. results and discussion the interviewee e1 defines csr as “csr is about three dimensions as workplace, environment and society” and s2 states as; “csr is a free choice; and, can be embedded in corporations mainstream activities by the process they deal with internally and externally in ethically and philanthropic aspects.” in the opinion of interviewee c1, the concept of csr is an everyday business strategy. it is more focused on doing charitable and philanthropic activities and expects marketing as the return. despite that, corporations do some charitable activities without even using the corporation’s logo for the satisfaction of the stakeholders (c2). moreover, their interests and priorities are being changed from time to time. many corporations are interested in supporting vulnerable groups of the community; even those are not in the scope of a corporation’s mainstream, and there should be a proper plan to implement csr activates (e2). the interviewee e2 further states, “most corporations don’t have any personal connection with the problem that they wanted to solve.” (e2). it can be seen the interviewees have identified the approaches of csr from distinctive perspectives. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5085 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 38 the interviewee s1 states that several corporations contribute to se development as part of their csr activities. most corporations organize events in their spaces for students, giving awards and grants while doing capacity-building activities related to se development (s1). corporations are supporting social initiatives as their csr activities without expecting anything in return (c1). as stated by the interviewee s1, large corporations seek social enterprises to invest and make a partnership. most of the corporations have a massive amount of budgets for their csr purposes, although they spend mostly on charitable and philanthropic activities; therefore, the current influence for se development is not at a satisfactory level (c2). in the opinion of interviewee s2, the current influence of csr for se development is not enough, and their focus and interest are changing (s2). the current csr influence for se development is comparably relatively small due to the lack of enthusiasm for the csr managers (c1). as believed by the interviewee s1, the current csr influence level is far from the satisfaction level. s1 further states, "i think we are at the beginning of a long journey. it's far from the satisfaction level." (s1). it can be identified the current influence of csr for se development from the interviewee's perspectives as above discussed. identifying the real-life challenges for social entrepreneurship is essential to find out the most effective methods of using csr activities for se development. as believed by the interviewee c1, social entrepreneurs have good intentions to make a positive social impact; but, they have a lack of skills in innovation and finance management. finding a good team and keeping the energy and the enthusiasm for the long run is one of the main challenges for social enterprises (s2). good team and human resources are critical for a successful social enterprise; but, it depends on managerial skills (s1). as stated by the interviewee e1, the cost of products and services may be more expensive than the alternatives in the market. “mostly the products and services of social enterprises are expensive, so it would be hard to sell those” (c1). the interviewee e2 points out as follows; “if it’s hard to get clients, it will be hard to get sponsors and investors.” (e2). most social entrepreneurs do not make enough money for the effort they put, and it is even hard to self-sustain within the current competitive market (e2). it can be seen that there are many crucial challenges for se development in the initiation and the scaling-up process. the most effective methods of influencing se through csr can be categorized into several themes; partnerships, education and mentoring, sharing knowledge, venture capital fund, and impact investment, and creating a market for social entrepreneurs. the interviewees have pointed out several recommendations and suggestions for the effective methods of influencing se through csr activities of the corporations. in the opinion of the interviewee e1, integrating social enterprises to the corporation’s supply chain would be a sustainable win-win solution. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5085 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 39 interviewees have stated that corporations can make partnerships with social enterprises as a channel for reaching their end-users of the csr activities. “corporations can use social enterprises as their channels to reach more vulnerable groups of people in the society which need help” (c1). providing necessary skills and practice by workshops, incubation programs, and mentoring would be a significant influence (c2 & c1). corporations can take leadership for creating support for social entrepreneurship as they do for startups (s1). in accordance with the interviewee c1; “csr companies and se can work together for better social impact. sharing ideas and knowledge will have benefits for both.” (c1). the interviewees suggest motivating venture capital funds, venture philanthropy funds, and impact investments would be useful to reduce the financial difficulties of social entrepreneurs. in accordance with the interviewee s1, corporations can take the lead of building the supporting ecosystem for se. as claimed by interviewee e2, public knowledge about se should be improved; corporations can make awareness about the se concept and the practice. as believed by the interviewee e2, social entrepreneurs face huge credibility issues in the market. this study aims to identify the current influence of csr on se development. in accordance with the findings, most of the corporations actively engage in supporting se development through organizing events in their spaces, giving awards and grants, doing capacity-building as their csr activities without expecting anything in return. furthermore, large corporations are actively seeking better social enterprises to invest and make partnerships; for the purpose of reaching their social impact indicators and goals. although the findings show that the current csr practices are mostly focusing on charitable and philanthropic activities; thus, the influence of se development is not at a satisfactory level. even though the corporations are willing to support social enterprises, the focus and the interest of the corporations are changing accordingly. most corporations are eager to support charity and philanthropic activities because of accessible marketing opportunities to gain public attention, as the ethical and philanthropic responsibilities can maintain if they only achieve the economic responsibilities successfully (carroll, 1979). findings show that most csr managers of corporations do not see huge benefits as a return from se due to their lack of enthusiasm and the understanding towards se. the contribution to se development is far from a satisfactory level compared with other sponsorship for sports and cultural events. therefore, much more effort is needed for se development from the csr activities to achieve a satisfactory level contribution. moreover, social enterprises are one subset of organizations focusing on positive social impact as charitable organizations and ngos; therefore, corporations may not be interested in social enterprises until their uniqueness and the sustainable business model attract the corporations. moreover, european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5085 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 40 corporations are willing to support those offering them much promotion, benefits, and feasibility because implementing csr policies are part of the brand management and maintain the legitimacy (werther & chandler, 2005). altogether, the findings show that even though the csr activities of corporations supporting social enterprises to a specific limit, the current influence of csr activities for se development is not at a satisfactory level. the study aims to identify the most effective methods of influencing se development through the csr activities of the corporations. it is essential to understand the real-life problems of social entrepreneurship to find development solutions. in accordance with the findings, one major challenge for se development is the intention of social entrepreneurs. mostly, social entrepreneurs are motivated by social issues; thus, they are focusing on solving those issues and creating social value. their ultimate goal is to save the world or at least make it a better place (tommaso & antonino, 2014). however, the findings show that most social entrepreneurs have a lack of skills in innovation, financial skills, and business knowledge. moreover, they have a specific resistance to marketing and business activities; thus, they do not have a controversial relationship with money. there is a shortage of expert human resources because of belowmarket-rate wages. mostly, social enterprises use a voluntary labor force; thus, it is hard to get people for voluntary activities. findings show that the general public mindset towards se is one of the significant obstacles to se development. the general mindset has been created to see social enterprises from charitable and philanthropic aspects. moreover, some cultural barriers and social norms prevent se development to the next level. most of the social enterprises are not interested in scaling up to outside the local territory because the social problem and the culture could be unique to that specific area (mair & marti, 2009). findings show that most of the products and services of social enterprises are more expensive than the alternatives in the market; thus, it is a barrier to attract customers. it is evident that if a business does not have clients, it will not generate income, hard to get sponsors or investors. moreover, it is hard for social entrepreneurs to be self-sustained within the market competition. accordingly, most investors and sponsors have less attraction to invest in social enterprises. altogether, there are significant challenges for se development according to the findings as; lack of financial skills and business knowledge of the social entrepreneurs; find human resources and keep the enthusiasm for the long run; lack of managerial skills and marketing skills; cultural barriers, and social norms for scaling up; higher price of products and services than the alternatives in the market; fewer investments and sponsorships; lack of expert support and general public mindset towards se. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5085 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 41 the findings show that, though the csr companies and social enterprises work separately, their mindsets are quite similar; there would be benefits for both by working together as one team. from the point of creating shared value, the collaboration of csr and se will be more effective. findings show that corporations and social enterprises can share their expertise in unique and unusual situations while contributing to society in a meaningful and sustainable way. furthermore, it is found that corporations have potential marketing opportunities by supporting se development to gain customer loyalty, social reputation, as well as employee satisfaction. altogether, there are unique benefits of influencing se development through csr activities, not only for se and society at large but also for the corporation itself. therefore, it can be considered a win-win situation for both corporations and society at large. the research aim of this study is to identify the effective practices and methods of using csr activities of corporations for the development of social entrepreneurship. in accordance with the findings, the most effective practices and methods can be categorized under several topics; partnerships, education and mentoring, sharing knowledge, venture capital fund, and impact investment, and creating a market for social entrepreneurs. the following figure 2 shows the challenges for se development and the effective methods of influencing csr to overcome those challenges; the ultimate goal of both social enterprises and csr corporations to create positive social impact or social value. figure 2 challenges for se development and effective methods for overcome those by influence of csr european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5085 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 42 sources: complied by authors findings show that corporations can influence se development by making partnerships with social enterprises. csr companies can buy the goods and services they need from social enterprises by integrating them into the corporation’s supply chain. furthermore, corporations can tender their projects or contracts to social enterprises. it will generate a regular revenue stream for the social enterprise; thus, social enterprise can overcome the challenge of self-sustaining in the current market. furthermore, corporations can enroll their employees for voluntary work at social enterprises up to two or three days per year; corporations can pay for voluntary work as their csr activity. in accordance with the findings, this option would solve the less voluntary workers and the human resource challenge for social enterprises. findings show that social entrepreneurs have the expertise in the field of identifying social issues and finding practical solutions; thus, they can be the actors to reach the end-users of csr activities of the corporation. furthermore, corporations can use social entrepreneurs as their channels to reach the most vulnerable groups which are needed help. it is found that the lack of business knowledge, lack of european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5085 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 43 managerial skills, and lack of financial skills are a significant threat to the se development. education and mentoring would be the best solution to fill that knowledge gap within social entrepreneurs. findings show that corporations can empower education by providing; training, spaces, physical environment, infrastructure, event funding, expert support, and mentorship. corporations have a wide variety of experts; they have immense experience in their fields; thus, it can be distributed within the social entrepreneurs. moreover, findings show that corporations can take the leadership for support se as it exists for the startups; by implementing incubation centers, innovation hubs, acceleration programs, hackathons, and internship opportunities. on the report of the seven universal principles of heslin & ochoa (2008), cultivating the needed talent can be considered as a greater approach of scsr. there is an opportunity for corporations to influence se development by empowering education and mentorship; it will help social entrepreneurs to overcome their lack of financial and managerial skills. in accordance with the findings, sharing knowledge with corporations and social enterprises will be fruitful for both corporation and se development as well as society at large. social entrepreneurs are considered path-breakers with a powerful new idea that combines visionary and real-world problem-solving creativity (bomstein, 1998). corporations and social enterprises can share the expertise and the knowledge for better performance of csr activities; eventually, it will create an efficient process of creating social value. it is found that social entrepreneurs face financial difficulties for scaling up and self-sustaining challenges. findings show that motivating venture capital funds and impact investments would help reduce the financial difficulties of social entrepreneurs. corporations can be social investors through their csr activities. furthermore, venture philanthropy organization is a better option for financial support for social entrepreneurs as investments, market below loans or donations. dees and anderson (2006) have mentioned that social entrepreneurs tend to find capital from either below-market and market-rate capital investments or donations. moreover, it is founded that corporations can take the lead of empowering sustainable investment through their csr activities. these venture capital funds and impact investment will reduce the financial challenges of social entrepreneurs; thus, it can be considered as an influence of se development. it is identified that the general mindset is a considerable obstacle for se development. also, social entrepreneurs are facing difficulties in self-sustain and create a market for them. findings show that corporations can be part of creating the market for social entrepreneurs. corporations can take the lead to build the ecosystem, which is supporting se by educating and awareness programs. marketing is needed to build up as a business nowadays; thus, corporations can market social enterprises by allowing them to european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5085 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 44 showcase their products and services. furthermore, corporations can plant the credibility of social enterprises within the general mindset by promoting them and stand behind their names as partners; if a social enterprise gets more partners, it will be trustworthy in the general mind. corporations can support social enterprises by creating a market for them; it will create a general mindset and opportunities to scale up businesses. altogether, there are several most effective ways of influencing se development through csr activities of corporations; as partnerships, education and mentoring, sharing knowledge, venture capital fund, and impact investment and creating a market for social entrepreneurs. 5. conclusion the study analyzed the effective approaches and methods of corporate social responsibility activities on social entrepreneurship development. as a result, the goal of this study, which was to identify the most effective methods and practices to influence se development through csr activities, has been achieved. the concepts of csr and se have similar goals from the perspective of creating a social value; though the different financial targets and the approach. moreover, social entrepreneurs can identify social and environmental issues and find solutions more innovatively and effectively; due to the expertise, enthusiasm, and the motivation they have. supporting social entrepreneurs to overcome the challenges they face by csr activities of corporations has much potential for the more effective and impactful social value creation. the current influence of csr to se development has taken a mixed approach of philanthropic, csv, tbl, and scsr aspects. even though the csr activities of corporations supporting social enterprises to a specific limit, the current influence of csr activities for se development is not at a satisfactory level; thus, much influence is needed to overcome the challenges of se development. this study has identified the real-life challenges for se development as; lack of financial skills and business knowledge; find human resources and keep the enthusiasm for the long run; lack of managerial skills and marketing skills; cultural barriers and social norms for scaling up; higher price of products and services than the alternatives in the market; fewer investments and sponsorships; lack of expert support and general public mindset towards se. it is found that supporting se to overcome real-life challenges would be more useful for se development. it will have unique benefits for both se and csr corporation; thus, it can be considered as a win-win situation. the most effective methods and practices of influencing se development through csr activities have been identified as; partnerships, education and mentoring, sharing knowledge, venture capital funds, and european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5085 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 45 impact investment, and creating a market for social entrepreneurs. these findings will useful for corporations to implement their csr activities to create higher social value through influencing social entrepreneurship development. social entrepreneurs can be used as channels to achieve the socially responsible goals of corporations while benefiting society at large. moreover, social entrepreneurs can use these findings to improve their positive social impact by the influence of corporations. the empirical data collection of this study has been conducted only in estonia, though the theories and concepts are not focused on any specific territory or region. thus, there is a future research opportunity to scale it up to the global context. moreover, this study is mainly focused on the influence of csr on se development from the perspective of social value creation. there is a future research opportunity to conduct research focusing on monetary value creation or mutual benefit creation. references bonini, s. m. j., mendonca, l. t., and oppenheim, j. m., (2006), when social issues become strategic?, the mckinsey quarterly, 2, 20-31. [google scholar] [crossref] carroll, a. b., (1979), a three-dimensional conceptual model of corporate performance. academy of management review, 4(4), 497-505. doi 10.2307/257850. [google scholar] [crossref] chandler, d., (2016), strategic corporate social responsibility: sustainable value creation, united states of america: sage publications. [google scholar] [crossref] dees, j. g., (1998), the meaning of social entrepreneurship. [crossref] dees, j. g., and anderson, b. b., (2006), framing a theory of social entrepreneurship: building on two schools of practice and thought, research on social entrepreneurship. [crossref] european commission swd (2019), corporate social responsibility, responsible business conduct, and business & human rights: overview of progress, commission staff working document, 2019.03.20 [crossref] fernando, s., lawrance, s., (2015), csr practices a comparison between a developed and developing country, proceedings of the environmental and sustainability management accounting network (eman) global conference 2015. [google scholar] [crossref] gallardo-vázquez, d., valdez-juárez, l. e., & castuera-díaz, á. m. (2019), corporate social responsibility as an antecedent of innovation, reputation, performance, and competitive success: a multiple mediation analysis. sustainability, 11(20), 5614. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5085 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 46 galbreath, j., (2009), building corporate social responsibility into strategy. european business review, 21(2), 109 127. doi 10.1108/09555340910940123. [google scholar] [crossref] heslin, p. a., & ochoa, j. d., (2008), understanding and developing strategic corporate social responsibility, organizational dynamics 37(2), 125–144. [google scholar] [crossref] husted, b. w., & allen, d. b., (2007), strategic corporate social responsibility and value creation among large firms: lessons from the spanish experience, long range planning, 40(6), 594–610. [google scholar] [crossref] jamali, d., (2007), the case for strategic corporate social responsibility in developing countries, business and society review, 112(1), pp.1–27. [google scholar] [crossref] johnson, s., (2000), literature review on social entrepreneurship. alberta: canadian centre for social entrepreneurship. [crossref] lantos, g. p., (2001), the boundaries of strategic corporate social responsibility, journal of consumer marketing, 18(7), 595–632. [crossref] mair, j. and marti, i., (2009), entrepreneurship in and around institutional voids: a case study from bangladesh, journal of business venturing, vol. 24 no. 5, pp. 419-435. [google scholar] [crossref] marrewijk, m., (2003), concepts and definitions of csr and corporate sustainability, between agency and communion (vol. 44). [google scholar] [crossref] moir, l., (2001), what do we mean by corporate social responsibility? corporate governance, (vol.1) issue: 2, p. 16-22. [google scholar] [crossref] nicholls, a., (2006), “introduction”, in a. nicholls (ed.), social entrepreneurship. new models of sustainable social change, oxford university press. [google scholar] [crossref] oecd (1999), “social enterprises”, oecd publishing, paris. [crossref] porter, m.e. and kramer, m. r., (2011), creating shared value-how to reinvent capitalism-and unleash a wave of innovation and growth. harvard business review, pp. 62–77. [google scholar] [crossref] seelos, c. & mair, j., (2005), social entrepreneurship: creating new business models to serve the poor, business horizons 48, 241 — 246. [google scholar] [crossref] singh, a., (2016), the process of social value creation: a multiple case study on social entrepreneurship in india. [crossref] smith, n. c., (2001), changes in corporate practices in response to public interest advocacy and actions, in p. n. b. a. g. t. gundlach (ed.), handbook of marketing and society; thousand oaks. [crossref] european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5085 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 47 thompson, j., alvy, g., lees, a,. (2000), social entrepreneurship: a new look at the people and the potential, management decision, 38(5), 328-338. [google scholar] [crossref] tommaso, r. & antonino, v., (2014), stakeholders matter: how social enterprises address mission drift. journal of business ethics. [google scholar] [crossref] werther, w. b., & chandler, d., (2005), strategic corporate social responsibility as global brand insurance. business horizons, 48(4), 317–324. [google scholar] [crossref] 02_ foschi_ejsice_rev european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7154 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 16 linking bioeconomy, circular economy, and sustainability: trends, gaps and future orientation in the bio-based and biodegradable plastics industry eleonora foschi1, selena aureli2, angelo paletta3, 1 university of bologna, department of business studies via capo di lucca 34, bologna italy eleonora.foschi3@unibo.it 2 university of bologna, department of business studies via capo di lucca 34, bologna italy selena.aureli@unibo.it 3 university of bologna, department of business studies via capo di lucca 34, bologna italy angelo.paletta@unibo.it received: 21/11/2022 accepted for publication: 20/07/2023 published: 28/07/2023 abstract bio-based and biodegradable plastics (bbps) are innovative materials, wholly or partially produced from biomass, with the potential to enhance the circulation of resources in the biological cycle of the ellen macarthur foundation’s butterfly diagram. although bbps are generally considered more environmental-friendly than conventional plastics, robust scientific evidence is still missing. the lack of tools and metrics to assess the circularity and sustainability of the bbps industry poses relevant challenges for its upscaling and contribution to climate neutrality goals in europe. it also calls for adopting system and life cycle thinking, guided by multi-level and multi-dimensional examinations, which are used in this paper to build a comprehensive picture of trends, gaps and future orientations that may boost a sustainable circular bioeconomy in the sector. the valuechain based and multi-faceted swot analysis that emerged from the intersection of system and corporate data reveals the need to establish a combined circular bioeconomy strategy where incentives to integrated local supply chain, dedicated epr schemes, eco-design guidelines, revised eol standards, new clear labelling schemes and harmonised sustainability criteria should be prioritized and conjointly pursued to accelerate the transition towards a sustainable circular bioeconomy of the bbps value chain. keywords: bioeconomy; circular economy; sustainability; bio-based and biodegradable plastics 1. introduction the exploitation of fossil resources has defined recent decades. the oil demand moved from 2,720 million tons in 1975 to 4,070 million tons in 2020 (ibrahim et al. 2021). the gradual rise of a fossil-based society has contributed to a massive increase in global greenhouse gases (ghgs) (center for international environmental law, 2018), accounting for 52.6 billion european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7154 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 17 tons in 2020 (jones et al., 2023). the chemical and plastics industries are responsible for around 7% of global ghg emissions (world economic forum, 2016). because of the demand for fuel as a raw material input in addition to energy, the chemical sector (including the production of ethylene, propylene, benzene, toluene, mixed xylenes, ammonia and methanol) was responsible for 935 million tons of ghgs in 2022, while 1.6 billion tons of ghg emissions were emitted in the same year in plastics production and conversion processes (oecd, 2023). indeed, oil and derivates are a leading cause of global warming (kweku et al., 2018), responsible for about one-quarter of the greenhouse effect (gleckman, 1995). to meet the climate neutrality mission by 2050, eu countries are forced to decouple economic growth from oil extraction. in this regard, the so-called bioeconomy plays a pivotal role (ronzon et al., 2022). bioeconomy is “the economy where the basic building blocks for materials, chemicals and energy are derived from renewable biological resources” (mccormick and kautto, 2013). converting biomass (e.g. crops, wood, energy plants, agricultural and forestry residues, municipal, industrial, and food wastes) into high-value end-products, such as food, bioenergy, biofuels, biochemicals, bio-based plastics (yang et al., 2021; mougenot and doussoulin, 2022), the bioeconomy model seeks to substitute fossil carbon with bio-based carbon and uptake biogenic co2 (leiplod and petit-boix, 2018). although bioenergy and biofuels are the most advanced applications (adamowicz, 2017; nazari et al., 2021), an acceleration in r&d for innovative materials under the bio-based plastics umbrella has been recently noticed. driven by the increasing awareness about marine littering (gold et al., 2013), the legislative commitment toward circular economy (ce) (foschi and bonoli, 2019), the green purchasing trend (filho et al., 2021; moorthy et al., 2021) and the multiplying challenges affecting global supply chains (arikan & ozsoy, 2015), the production capacity of bio-based plastics is expected to increase from 2.12 million tonnes in 2022 to approximately 6.3 million tonnes in 2027 (european bioplastics, 2022). however, while extant literature deeply scrutinises the influence of bioenergy and biofuels to climate neutrality, more is needed to know about bio-based plastics. indeed, bio-based plastics refer to a large range of materials (see section 2.1.) that may provide reasonable solutions to many environmental concerns. first, bio-based plastics may contribute to decarbonization because of their lower carbon footprint compared to fossil-based counterparts (boonniteewanich et al., 2014; muhammad shamsuddin, 2017; philp, 2014; piemonte, 2011; spierling et al., 2018; bishop et al., 2021). second, when compostable, bio-based plastics may solve the challenges faced by waste recycling facilities with regard to food contamination and complex product design (paletta et al., 2019). finally, when biodegradable, bio-based plastics may represent a panacea for microplastic generation, ecotoxicity and marine pollution in general (meereboer et al., 2020). yet, it has to be noted that many issues are still open when considering the contribution of bio-based plastics to circularity and sustainability. as bishop et al. (2021) pointed out, the lack of a holistic picture of the environmental impacts of bio-based plastic products makes lca studies unreliable. as a result, yan et al. (2021) highlight the risk of biased or misleading estimates of climate mitigation contribution. others have questioned the impact of bio-based plastics on resource preservation, as their production is still primarily based on virgin feedstock, thus creating pressure on natural ecosystems and increasing competition for land usage (d’adamo et al., 2020; imbert, 2017). in addition, the one-to-one substitution trend from conventional to bio-based plastics observed among converters could undermine the expected environmental benefits if the design process does not consider the specific conditions of use and disposal. indeed, these materials may not foster the loop closing if consumers are not well informed about the proper disposal pattern, dedicated waste infrastructures are not established, advanced biotechnological recycling technologies are not developed and more in general, when heterogeneity and fragmentation continue to characterize waste governance across europe (rosenboom et al., 2022). although the above-mentioned critics highlight that tighter integration between bioeconomy and ce is necessary (d’amato and korhonen, 2021), many additional concerns related to carbon sequestration, biodiversity, biodegradability in soil and marine environments and toxicology still exist and compromise the overall reliability of these materials (nessi et al., 2021; arantzamendi et al., 2023). as pointed out by the european commission (2018b) in the bioeconomy strategy “to be successful, the eu bioeconomy needs to have circularity and sustainability at its heart”. translating this intent into the bbps industry, the present work aims to investigate what hinders and enhances bbp materials' transition to a sustainable and circular bioeconomy. in line with leipold and petit-boix (2018), this study mobilizes the business community and policymakers, addressing the following questions: rq1. what legislative, economic, social and environmental trends may affect the circularity and sustainability of bbps? rq2. which are the key strenghts and weaknesses detected by business players and able to accelerate and/or hamper the circularity and sustainability of bbps? with the final objective of providing recommendations and future orientations for a more sustainable circular bioeconomy in the bbps value chain. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7154 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 18 given that circularity depends on the system in which materials or products are distributed (european environment agency, 2017), the analysis was contextualized to european countries. system and life cycle thinking were adopted in line with sustainability and circularity principles. moreover, multi-dimensional analysis was used to collect and intersect legislative, economic, social and environmental aspects, while multi-level examination (i.e. at system level and corporate level) supported the authors in identifying mutual impacts, moving from system dimension to business environment and viceversa. the paper is structured as follows: bio-based plastics value chain is reported in section 2, followed by research design and methodological framework (section 3). findings from the system (section 4) and corporate (section 5) analysis are summarized in the discussion and conclusion sections. 2. background 2.1 plastics and bioplastics value chain the term plastics reflects a wide range of materials, but it commonly refers to conventional plastics that are petroleumbased and degrade over hundreds of years. the term bioplastics, by contrast, still needs a valid and recognized definition. the term has been used to describe bio-based and/or biodegradable plastics, which has generated misunderstandings among scientists and consumers. under this consideration, the european commission started a massive informative campaign to recommend using specific terminology (filho et al., 2021) that could reflect both sourcing and biodegradability properties. bio-based plastics are mostly derived from renewable resources (álvarez-chávez et al., 2012; digregorio, 2009) where the bio-based plastics content is determined by cen/ts 16137:2011 standard. commercially available bio-based and potentially biodegradable polymers are polylactic acid (pla), polyhydroxyalkanoates (pha) and starch blends (see figure 1). as circularity, biodegradability is a system property (european bioplastics, 2015) that flows from the environment in which the material degrades. many factors influence the biodegradability of materials, including the type of microorganisms, the molecular polymers’ structure, and the product design (molenveld and zee, 2020). so, degradation in aquatic systems involves physical, chemical and biological processes and mainly depends on water temperature and polymer shape (volova et al., 2010); biodegradation in the soil is determined by the presence of bacterial biomass (adhikari et al., 2016) while experimental conditions influence biodegradation in industrial plants (thakur et al., 2018). figure i. commercially available bioplastics source: authors’ elaboration however, not all bio-based plastics are biodegradable. bio-based non-biodegradable plastics include bio-polyethene (biope), bio-polyethene terephthalate (bio-pet), and polytrimethylene terephthalate (ptt). biodegradable plastics but fossilbased, such as polybutylene adipate terephthalate (pbat) and polycaprolactone (pcl), are also considered bioplastics, but the use of this terminology is discouraged (pellis et al., 2021) since their production is still oil-dependent. in addition, renewability and biodegradability properties strongly affect the upstream and downstream sides of the existing plastics’ value chain. depending on the surrounding conditions, both properties can have a completely different characterization. while fossil-based plastics are mainly made in petrochemical refineries—where oil is subject to distillation, cracking, polymerization and blending processes—bio-based plastics are manufactured through either chemical processes (hydrolysis, dehydration, etc.) or biotechnological processes (fermentation, extraction, etc.) in biorefineries (ubando et al., 2020). based on the type of biomass used, bio-based plastics can be sourced from three different feedstocks: (i) 1st european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7154 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 19 generation, such as corn or sugar cane; (ii) 2nd generation, which can be either non-food crops (e.g., cellulose) or agroindustrial waste; or (iii) 3rd generation, sourced from algal biomass, which has a higher yield than 1st and 2nd generation feedstock. today, most bio-based plastics derive from crop-based feedstock (philp, 2014), while the 2nd generation is available in small volumes, and the 3rd is still in early development. figure 2. upstream and downstream sides of plastics and bioplastics source: authors’ elaboration the end-of-life (eol) opens the doors to a variety of waste management scenarios (see figure 2), leading to first distinguishing controlled and uncontrolled environments. industrial-scale facilities monitor and manage material recycling or energy recovery performances with the former. meanwhile, the latter generally refers to an open environment, mainly soil and marine ecosystems (european environmental agency, 2018; karan et al., 2019). notwithstanding that existing iso 17556 and astm d5988 provide criteria for the biodegradability of plastics in soils only and a standard for biodegradability in marine environments is under discussion (european commission, 2022), recent studies bring into discussion the validity of these standards outside of laboratory conditions which on one side do not reflect what is commonly expected in a natural environment and, on the other, do not capture the extreme variation of natural conditions (emadian et al., 2017; briassoulis et al., 2017; harrison et al., 2018; di bartolo et al., 2021). although bbps are mainly incinerated or landfilled today, mechanical, organic and chemical recycling are the preferred eol options in controlled environments (ramesh kumar et al., 2020). mechanical recycling is suitable for the management of the drop-ins (bio-pe, bio-pet, bio-ptt, etc.) since they have the same chemical composition as their fossil-based counterpart, which are widely present in europe for the treatment of traditional plastic waste streams (paletta et al., 2019). organic recycling theoretically treats bio-waste streams with compostable and biodegradable plastics certified by the european en 13432, en 14995, or the international iso 17088. organic recycling infrastructures include anaerobic digesters and/or composting plants (carlini et al., 2017). another emerging scenario is chemical recycling, which is based on hydrolysis, alcoholysis, glycolysis, aminolysis and ammonolysis (lamberti et al., 2020) and allows the extraction of highvalue chemicals/monomers from different biopolymers. however, chemical recycling infrastructures need to be wellestablished in europe, slowed down by the high costs of depolymerization (di bartolo et al., 2021). 2.2 bio-based and biodegradable plastics in the context of sustainable circular bioeconomy ce is a system where the value of products, materials and resources is maintained in the economy for as long as possible while waste generation is minimized (european commission, 2018a). in other words, ce is an economic system where the european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7154 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 20 eol concept is replaced with production, distribution and consumption processes that reduce, reuse, recycle, and recover materials in service of sustainable development. as less dependent on oil, bioeconomy is perceived as an opportunity to mitigate climate change while sustaining economic growth and human well-being (phil et al., 2018). however, combining ce with bioeconomy has prompted reflections on the circular bioeconomy. indeed, while ce and bioeconomy definitions are trending among practitioners and academics (kirchherr et al., 2017), circular bioeconomy has yet to be fully explored in the literature. even so, the residual research stream dealing with circular bioeconomy reveals conflicting opinions on the interlinkages between the two economic models: while some authors consider the bioeconomy to be “circular by nature” (sheridan, 2016), others express concerns about the risks of following a linear business-as-usual approach (bezama, 2016; stegmann et al., 2020; tan and lamers, 2021). the most recognized definition comes from stegmann et al. (2020), who defined the circular bioeconomy as “an economic model in which bioresources are used to make products with the highest possible added value in a sustainable way, with a cascaded use of materials and minimizing resource inputs and outputs to the natural environment”. in line with the biological cycle of ellen mac arthur foundation’s butterfly diagram, circular bioeconomy emphasizes the use of renewable resources, cascading the use of biomass and reintroducing biological nutrients in the biosphere (ellen mac arthur foundation, 2019; karan et al., 2019). applying this concept to bioplastics, only bbps, and consequently, compostable plastics, have the potential to circulate and recirculate in that cycle. from this, we can surmise that bbps are: h1. circular when added value is created and retained in further production and consumption cycles. h2. sustainable when natural resources are not depleted and environmental impacts are minimized. unfortunately, the analysis along the value chain reveals the emergence of a take-use-dispose model characterized by virgin biomass supply in the upstream stage and immature eol scenarios downstream. since existing circularity and sustainability metrics are still at the infancy stage for these applications (bishop et al., 2021; chioatto and sospiro, 2022; european commission, 2018b; yates and barlow, 2013), results are often contradictory and, consequently, inconsistent. moreover, the integration of economic, social and environmental impacts needs to orientate decisions towards a sustainable circular bioeconomy (blum et al., 2020; rosenboom et al., 2022). it follows that a major interplay between the circularity and sustainability of bbps needs to be investigated. to do that, a better understanding of what sustainable circular bioeconomy pragmatically means in the bbps industry is necessary. 3. method and materials 3.1 research design to scrutinize the circularity and sustainability of bbps, the research design has been informed by a combination of life cycle and system thinking. life cycle thinking is crucial in ce studies to assess the impacts of materials, products or services from raw materials supply to eol and make evidence of closing, narrowing or slowing resource loops (heiskanen, 2002). instead, system thinking is commonly used in sustainability transition theories (barbier and burgess, 2017) to understand how different parts of the system where firms operate are interrelated and evolve over time. multi-dimensional analysis contributed to examining system dynamics from multiple domains (meadows, 2009). coherently, multi-level investigation supported better identifying relationships between macro and micro levels. macro-level analysis has been conducted through a literature analysis of legislative, economic, environmental, and socio-cultural trends characterizing bbps. micro-level analysis has been advanced through the realization of semi-structured interviews with the key players of the bio-based plastics industry, including eu material suppliers, converters, end-users and waste managers. 3.2 data collection and elaboration precisely, a literature analysis was performed to reconstruct the legislative roadmap that framed the bio-based plastics industry and gathered qualitative and quantitative data on the market and community behaviours. then, an empirical analysis was run to collect insights at the corporate level by directly engaging business players. in total, 40 key players operating in the european market were invited by e-mail to participate in the research. specifically, the top five market players were european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7154 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 21 invited for each stage of the value chain. per each company, the sustainability or product manager was interviewed. the interview protocol is reported in appendix i. each interview lasted for about one hour on average. interviews were recorded, transcribed and manually coded. two researchers always participated in the interviews and jointly performed the text analysis to increase reliability. then, secondary data collected through a desk research of scientific papers, policy documents and research outcomes published by organizations outside of the traditional academic communication channels (i.e., the so-called grey literature), were intersected with the primary data obtained from interviews to get insights on the key elements driving a sustainable circular bioeconomy in bbps value chain. 4. system analysis: existing trends in the european bio-based biodegradable plastics industry 4.1 normative and legislative perspective the establishment of the eu strategy for bioeconomy in 2012—and its revisions in 2018—have served as a roadmap for european economies (ronzon et al., 2022). compared to the first version, the updated statement shows a better integration of environmental, economic and social aspects by promoting local bioeconomies and ensuring that the same legislative and financial efforts are applied to all sectors, including bio-based plastics (ronzon and sanjuán, 2020). this new approach has prompted european countries to build up their own orientations for a sustainable and competitive bioeconomy in europe (bracco et al., 2018; mccormick and kautto, 2013). concerning bio-based plastics, the key eu policy document is the circular economy action plan and its updated version published in 2020 that still allocates resources to these materials through a focus on sustainable sourcing and standardized labelling schemes (european commission, 2021). as part of the green new deal, this intention is operationalized in a public consultation aimed at examining the sustainability of the feedstock as well as the role of biodegradability and compostability in specific environments. from the legislative point of view, the directive 2015/720 (european commission, 2015) has compelled a solid push for the bbps market by introducing a progressive elimination of very lightweight plastic carrier bags and a transition to biodegradable and compostable singleuse bags and long-life reusable bags (foschi and bonoli, 2019). furthermore, the directive 2018/851 allocates attentions to epr schemes and their role to foster shared responsibility among packaging users, consumers and recyclers but their scope should be extended to industries (european commission, 2018b). almost simultaneously, the directive on single-use plastics (sup) introduced market restrictions to reduce the consumption of certain categories of sups like straws, plates, cutlery, food containers, beverage containers and beverage cups (eu directive 2019/904). alongside the market-based instruments, legislators introduced a plastics tax in 2021 on nonrecyclable plastic packaging waste (european commission, 2020) to accelerate reusable, recyclable and compostable plastic packaging, as promoted by the european strategy for plastics in a circular economy (european commission, 2015). the recent policy framework on bio-based, biodegradable and compostable plastics sets out the conditions that have to be met to ensure overall positive environmental outcomes from the production and use of these plastics, including a) supply of sustainable feedstock; b) use of bio-based plastics in long-lived products; c) use of plastics that biodegrade in open environments only wherein applications and contexts where the full biodegradability has proven under specific real, local conditions and timeframe; d) use of compostable plastics only in applications and contexts where a compatible waste collection and treatment system is in place (european commission, 2022). a comprehensive overview of the normative aspects is summarized in the following figure. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7154 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 22 figure 3. relevant eu policies affecting the bbps industry source: authors’ elaboration 4.2 economic perspective according to the statistics published by european bioplastics (2022), the 2022 european bioplastics demand can be estimated at slightly more than 2.2 mt, with a slight prevalence of bio-based and biodegradable compared to the nonbiodegradable ones. indeed, bio-pe, bio-pa and bio-pet and ptt contribute to 48% of the total share. besides the competition with r-pet, only a few beverage companies such as coca-cola, pepsi and nestle have launched bio-based bottles to the market (lamberti et al., 2020). among the biodegradable fractions, pla, pha, and starch blends are the most demanding biopolymers, accounting for 52% of the total share in 2022 (european bioplastics, 2022). even if these blends are predicted to increase in the following years, one of the most challenging elements characterizing the market of biodegradable and compostable plastics is the limited availability of the materials due to the small production capacity and the difficulties of reaching economy-of-scale. indeed, about 20 compounding sites are active in europe, some of which have multiple value propositions. they are generally backwards-integrated on intermediates and even base chemicals, while some are downwardintegrated on manufacturing semi-finished and finished goods. because of this situation, there are difficulties in collecting and sharing official data (castellano, 2018). however, among the leading companies, only a small-scale pla polymerization plant is located in europe while the key player is natureworks llc, with a manufacturing facility in nebraska and a new site in thailand, expected to be ready by 2024 (plasticconsult for assobioplastiche, 2020). the european output of thermoplastic starches (tps) is estimated at over 200,000 tons in 2019, with the highest capacity detected by novamont, recently acquired by eni-versalis, followed by minor dutch and german companies (plasticconsult for assobioplastiche, 2019 and 2020). pha is not commercially available in europe, but nearly 50% of the global production (estimated to be less than 100,000 tons) comes from metabolix, danimer scientific and rwdc industries, whose production sites are in usa and singapore (rosenboom, 2022). 4.3 social perspective about the circularity of bbps, end-users and consumers play a crucial role in preserving the intrinsic value of bbps, especially during consumption and disposal patterns. driven by the increasing awareness about the impact of plastics in worldwide oceans, consumers’ attitudes toward the proper use of plastics are massively growing. filho et al.’s (2021) survey of 16 european countries revealed that 74% of respondents segregate plastic waste and dispose of it properly in specific containers, per their country’s regulations. however, compostability and biodegradability properties are still confusing european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7154 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 23 (lynch et al., 2017). moreover, the distinction between conventional plastics and bbps for consumer packaging largely challenges european and international consumers (dilkes-hoffman et al., 2019). several studies have examined the general influence of consumers’ sociodemographic characteristics on the green purchasing trend (reinders et al., 2017). the study by klein et al. (2019) revealed that gender, age and education do not influence the purchase intention or bioplastic products; instead, values, attitudes, product experience and interest in information have the strongest impacts. several previous studies have identified a clear link between consumer psychological traits such as attitudes, perceptions and motivations, and consumer acceptance of alternative plastics such as those that are bio-based or biodegradable (fletcher et al., 2021, barbir et al., 2021, filho et al., 2022, stasiškienė et al., 2022). 4.4 environmental perspective although bbps are perceived as more environmental-friendly compared with conventional plastics (european commission, 2022), robust scientific evidence still needs to be included. existing lca studies need to be more comprehensive regarding methodology, data source and results, making comparability difficult. if cradle-to-gate studies laid down on the uptake of biogenic carbon through the feedstock, the ghg-emissions profile is acute when considering eol, comparative cradle-to-grave study analysed by spierling et al. (2018) on eight bio-based and conventional plastics shows negative impact categories for the first compared with the second, mainly due to energy consumption during the waste management (hottle et al., 2017). moreover, eol impacts are difficult to estimate because of the lack of traceability for compostable and biodegradable plastics today and, at the same time, the lack of estimation about biodegradability performance of different biopolymers in different environments first, and the impacts of biodegradation processes on the environment and human health then. additionally, most of the studies are based on examining the global warming potential impact category, underestimating other relevant impacts such as land use, water use and biodiversity (di bartolo et al., 2021). 5. corporate analysis: strengths and weaknesses influencing the sustainability and circularity of the bio-based and biodegradable plastics value chain data collected from the semi-structured interviews allowed the researchers to move from the system to the corporate level and identify strengths and weaknesses influencing the sustainability and circularity of the bio-based and biodegradable plastics value chain. sustainability and circularity are values that have pushed firms to invest in the sector (see table 1). however, challenges (see table 2) remain predominant and must be addressed. findings are categorized by a group of actors to let emerge their different perceptions in the value chain. table 1. strengths points emerged among the actors of the bbps value chain interviewees bbps allow to.../are attractive because.... material suppliers • “offering new solutions where renewability and biodegradability are valueadded (e.g. mulch films)” • “being recognized as innovative and green" • “increasing interest among our customers in offering green end-products” • “use of eu funds that are more oriented to bbps” • “acquisition of existing non-efficient or obsolete petrochemical plants that are converted to the bio-chemistry” • “use of marginal land for crops that are low-water dependent” • “with certification it is possible to attest compostability” • “cooperation with different actors of the value chain that increase intangible capital” • “allow the use of 2nd generation feedstock by valorizing lignocellulosic waste streams” • “create multiple value along the entire value chain that can be demonstrated with the use of life cycle-based tools” • “increasing cooperation with organic waste treatment plants to solve technical challenges at the eol” european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7154 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 24 converters • “major inclination toward bbps because it is the most eco-friendly solution” • “differentiate the product offer” • “with bbps it is possible to provide tailored solutions, often associated with consulting or training service” • “entering new markets” • “no need of high investments in machinery due to the possibility of processing to process bbps in the same machinery where conventional plastics are transformed” • “use of innovation labs to co-design and test new materials and applications” • “new collaborations with suppliers and new partners to manufacture highperformance products” end users • “customers and society at large have a rising need for greener end-products” • “proliferating interest toward compostable food packaging among brand owners” • “increasing interest toward eco-friendly and bio-based reusable goods” • “create partnerships with upstream players of the value chain to tailor and customize the solutions” • “increasing trend of green public purchasing” waste managers • “strengthen the local closed-loop supply chain to reduce disposal costs” • “closed collaboration with materials suppliers to test compostability and biodegradability performance and provide feedbacks to converters on product eco-design” • “creation of networks working on specific waste streams” source: authors’ elaboration table 2. weakness points emerged among the actors of the bbps’ value chain interviewees bbps are hampered by … material suppliers • “small production capacity and difficulties in reaching economies of scale” • “difficulties in investing in other countries because of the lack of harmonized policy and orientations across europe” • “difficulties in supplying a high volume of bio-waste to experiment with 2nd generation feedstock and so, minimize the purchasing costs of virgin feedstock, reduce the land occupation and decrease competition with food” • “need to make very large investments in r&d” • “high transportation costs of raw materials to the biorefineries and emissions to transportation” • “high production costs” • “lack of knowledge among stakeholders about the implications of biodegradability properties” • “lack of skilled workforce” • “need for more clusters focusing on bioplastics that allow dialogue between different subjects like institutions, companies, universities, and research centers” • “necessity to make policymakers aware of the lower total cost of ownership, i.e. the cost for the system related to bbps vs. fossil-based plastics” european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7154 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 25 converters • “discontinued materials supply” • “increasing competition because of the higher demand for bioplastics from high-value industry (e.g., medical, cosmetic)” • “challenging export because of different legislation and waste governance.” • “agitation derived by the measures imposed by the sups directive” • “investment on compostable tableware that is now banned by the sups directive” • “insufficient performance of bbps for certain applications” • “continuous need for higher r&d capabilities to improve bbps’ performance” • “high testing costs for eol performances” end users • “lack of efficient labelling scheme for better communication to the consumer” • “high testing costs for contamination and health security issues (especially in the food sector)” • “effort in understanding the different eol scenarios in place in exporting countries (e.g., home composting is different from industrial composting)” • “hostile disposition among consumers toward bbps because of the food competition, the land occupation and the use of virgin feedstock” • “customers' skepticism and/or preference for other materials, like paper, wood, algae, etc.” • “increasing customer orientation toward reusable applications” • “efforts in communicating the properties of the end-products and implications on consumption and disposal patterns” waste managers • “lack of harmonized waste treatment that is municipalityand country oriented” • “lack of adequate waste management plants to treat bbps” • “inefficiencies of lab-scale compostability tests • “difficulties of composting rigid products in composting plants” source: authors’ elaboration 6. discussions and concluding remarks key interesting findings emerge from the analysis of trends detected at system level with the perceptions collected ‘from the bottom’ by interviewing value chain actors (table 3). several elements contribute to the uptake of bbps; opportunities emerge from legislative/eu policy, economic trends, socio-cultural changes and environmental aspects. however, the same domains also embedd challenges that migh hinder the diffusion of bbps that really contribute to circularity and sustainability. a key element seems necessary to foster bbps: collaboration along the value chian. results reveal that despite being recognized as innovative and green when using bbps, material suppliers understand the potential to collaborate along the value chain to use alternative biological feedstock, with the resulting valorization of local economy and rural areas. however, no attention is currently paid to waste collection and valorization. looking at the conversion stage, value is generally captured in biowaste bags, food packaging and agricultural mulch films and collaboration is basically fostered to improve technical and mechanical performances. nevertheless, increasing interest is detected among end-users and brand owners intensively for using bbps in durable products. actors operating in waste management call for collaboration to test compostability and biodegradability performance in real other than lab conditions, thus trying to reduce the cost of uncompostable waste in composting facilities. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7154 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 26 table 3. value-chain based and multi-faceted swot analysis legislative perspective economic perspective social perspective environmental perspective s identification of endproducts where bbps may create added value exploitation of local and integrated supply chain based on the valorization of agro-industrial waste increasing awareness about marine plastic pollution compostability and biodegradability for specific applications w lack of clear policy orientations high price of bio-based plastics compared with the conventional ones lack of clear labeling scheme for bbps and relative disposal patter dependence of biodegradability and compostability performances from applications and contexts o introduction of epr scheme to manage compostable plastic applications across europe public funds for new integrated biorefineries increasing green purchasing trends renovation and/or introduction of new standards and eco-design guidelines assessing compostability, biodegradability, and more in general circularity t market bans on endproducts made of bbps introduction of the plastic tax skepticism behaviors and confusion among consumers lack of clear criteria to perform lca analysis source: authors’ elaboration more broadly, results reveal the urgency to develop a combined cbe strategy to capture and retain multiple values from biological resources. specifically, dedicated roadmaps should be established for each end-product, including bbps. from the legislative point of view, well-defined waste governance with a dedicated epr scheme would facilitate better value retention from bio-based, biodegradable, compostable but also mechanically recyclable plastics. from the social point of view, end-users and consumers should be better informed about the proper disposal of bioplastics, especially when compostable. harmonised labelling schemes facilitating consumers' choices and robust, informative campaigns stimulating demands are envisaged. to reduce scepticism among end-users, customized solutions that match the local conditions should be pursued case-by-case, especially for applications involving biodegradation in open environments. from an economic point of view, it is essential to develop an integrated and local supply chain to address the limited production capacity and, consequently, the high costs of raw materials supply. when the supply chain is based on symbiotic exchanges of residues among local farmers, it can also push the identification of valuable resource streams to valorize into 2nd generation feedstock while reducing the demand for pesticides, land and water to cultivate virgin biomass, thus contributing to more circularity and sustainability. the need to increase production capacity can be stimulated by investing in brownfield sites, thus providing an additional boost to the local economy and reducing the risk of land availability exacerbation. from the environmental point of view, since the key issues are detected at the eol, new eco-design guidelines and eol standards need to be provided and/or revised. it is possible by enforcing formulations that tailor the degradation timescale according to the products' purpose and expected life. eco-design guidelines can support identifying the correct application that, in line with circularity goals, can regulate the conversion processes. at the same time, the tendency to use bbps in durable products creates boundary conditions for a user-centric chain where lifetime extension strategies, like reuse, repair and refurbishment, can be exploited. standardised eco-design and strict eol measurement criteria may support the establishment of a harmonized lca methodology for these materials, thus stimulating comparability and benchmarking. to sum up, our study shows that although bbps are generally considered more environmental-friendly than conventional plastics, robust scientific evidence on their impacts compared to fossil-based plastics is still missing. the lack of tools and metrics to assess the circularity and sustainability of bbps industry poses relevant challenges for its upscaling and contribution to climate neutrality goals in europe. it calls for the adoption of system and life cycle thinking, guided by multilevel (system and corporate) and multi-dimensional (legislative, social, economic and environmental) analysis, which led european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7154 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 27 researchers to build a comprehensive picture of trends, gaps and future orientations that may boost a sustainable circular bioeconomy in the sector. to the authors’ knowledge, the paper is the first to discuss the value of bbps in the broader sustainable circular bioeconomy model. specifically, the paper makes several contributions to the bioplastics discourse. from the research point of view, it identifies the key area of investigation that needs to be explored in further research agenda. specifically, 4x4 significant topics have been identified for theoretical underpinnings. managerial implications include a list of recommendations for eu policymakers for an integrated circular bioeconomy strategy aimed at (i) adding value to bbps through alternative raw materials supply, (ii) retaining value through reuse and recycling, (iii) ensuring lower environmental impacts through cross-sector collaboration and well-functioning waste governance. data availability statement the datasets generated during and/or analysed during the current study are not publicly available due to their confidential nature but are available from the corresponding author upon reasonable request. references adamowicz, m., 2017. biogospodarka – koncepcja, zastosowanie i perspektywy. probl. agric. econ. 350, 29–49. https://doi.org/10.5604/00441600.1232987 adhikari, d., mukai, m., kubota, k., kai, t., kaneko, n., araki, k.s., kubo, m., 2016. degradation of bioplastics in soil and their degradation effects on environmental microorganisms. j. agric. chem. environ. 05, 23–34. https://doi.org/10.4236/jacen.2016.51003 álvarez-chávez, c.r., edwards, s., moure-eraso, r., geiser, k., 2012. sustainability of bio-based plastics: general comparative analysis and recommendations for improvement. j. clean. prod. 23, 47–56. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2011.10.003 arantzamendi, l., andrés, m., basurko, o. c., & suárez, m. j., 2023. circular and lower impact mussel and seaweed aquaculture by a shift towards bio‐based ropes. reviews in aquaculture. https://doi.org/10.1111/raq.12816 arikan, e. b., & ozsoy, h. d. 2015. a review: investigation of bioplastics. j. civ. eng. archit. 9, 188–192. https://doi.org/10.17265/1934-7359/2015.02.007 barbir, j., leal filho, w., salvia, a.l., fendt, m.t.c., babaganov, r., albertini, m.c., bonoli, a., lackner, m., müller de quevedo, d., 2021 assessing the levels of awareness among european citizens about the direct and indirect impacts of plastics on human health. int. j. environ. res. public health. 18, 3116. https://doi.org/10.3390/ijerph18063116 barbier, e. b., & burgess, j. c. 2017. the sustainable development goals and the systems approach to sustainability. economics, 11(1), 20170028. bezama, a., 2016. let us discuss how cascading can help implement the circular economy and the bio-economy strategies. waste manag. res. 34, 593–594. https://doi.org/10.1177/0734242x16657973 bishop, g., styles, d., lens, p.n.l., 2021. environmental performance comparison of bioplastics and petrochemical plastics: a review of life cycle assessment (lca) methodological decisions. resour. conserv. recycl. 168, 105451. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.resconrec.2021.105451 blum, n.u., haupt, m., bening, c.r., 2020. why “circular” doesn’t always mean “sustainable.” resour. conserv. recycl. 162, 105042. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.resconrec.2020.105042 boonniteewanich, j., pitivut, s., tongjoy, s., lapnonkawow, s., suttiruengwong, s., 2014. evaluation of carbon footprint of bioplastic straw compared to petroleum based straw products. energy procedia 56, 518–524. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.egypro.2014.07.187 bracco, s., calicioglu, o., juan, m.g.s., flammini, a., 2018. assessing the contribution of bioeconomy to the total economy: a review of national frameworks. sustain. switz. 10. https://doi.org/10.3390/su10061698 briassoulis, d., & degli innocenti, f., 2017. standards for soil biodegradable plastics. soil degradable bioplastics for a sustainable modern agriculture, 139-168. castellano, m. 2018. la bioeconomia in italia: confronti territoriali e potenzialità di sviluppo. volume 8-numero 5settembre 2018, 156. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7154 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 28 carlini, m., mosconi, e.m., castellucci, s., villarini, m., colantoni, a., 2017. an economical evaluation of anaerobic digestion plants fed with organic agro-industrial waste. energies 10, 1–15. https://doi.org/10.3390/en10081165 center for international environmental law, 2018. impact reportin 2018. available at: https://www.ciel.org/wpcontent/uploads/2018/11/cielimpactreport2018.pdf chioatto, e., sospiro, p., 2022. transition from waste management to circular economy: the european union roadmap. environ. dev. sustain. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10668-02102050-3 d’adamo, i., falcone, p.m., imbert, e., morone, p., 2020. survey data for assessing the socioeconomic performance of end of life options of a bio-based product based on expert knowledge. data brief 32, 106199. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.dib.2020.106199 d’amato, d., korhonen, j., 2021. integrating the green economy, circular economy and bioeconomy in a strategic sustainability framework. ecol. econ. 188, 107143. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ecolecon.2021.107143 di bartolo, a., infurna, g., & dintcheva, n. t., 2021. a review of bioplastics and their adoption in the circular economy. polymers, 13(8), 1229. https://doi.org/10.3390/polym13081229 digregorio, b.e., 2009. biobased performance bioplastic: mirel. chem. biol. 16, 1–2. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.chembiol.2009.01.001 dilkes-hoffman, l., ashworth, p., laycock, b., pratt, s., lant, p., 2019. public attitudes towards bioplastics – knowledge, perception and end-of-life management. resour. conserv. recycl. 151, 104479. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.resconrec.2019.104479 ellen mac arthur foundation, 2019. what is a circular economy? available online at: https://www.ellenmacarthurfoundation.org/circular-economy/concept emadian, s. m., onay, t. t., & demirel, b., 2017. biodegradation of bioplastics in natural environments. waste management, 59, 526-536. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.wasman.2016.10.006 european bioplastics, 2015. en13432 certified bioplastics performance in industrial composting 5. https://doi.org/10.1002/14651858.cd011736 european bioplastics, 2022. bioplastics market development update 2022. available online: https://docs.europeanbioplastics.org/publications/market_data/2022/report_bioplastics_market_data_2022_short_version.pdf european commission. 2015. an eu action plan for the circular economy. com (2015) 614. available online: https://www.eea.europa.eu/policy-documents/com-2015-0614-final european commission, 2018a. a sustainable bioeconomy for europe: strengthening the connection between economy, society and the environment. https://doi.org/10.2777/478385 european commission, 2018b. directive (eu) 2018/851 of the european parliament and of the council of 30 may 2018 amending directive 2008/98/ec on waste. available online: https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legalcontent/en/txt/?uri=celex%3a32018l0851 european commission, 2022. eu policy framework on biobased, biodegradable and compostable plastics. available online: https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legalcontent/en/txt/?uri=celex%3a52022dc0682 european environment agency, 2017. circular by design products in the circular economy . available online: https://www.eea.europa.eu/publications/circular-by-design european environmental agency, 2018. the circular economy and the bioeconomy. available online: https://www.eea.europa.eu/publications/circular-economy-and-bioeconomy european environment agency, 2020. bio-waste in europe — turning challenges into opportunities. bio-waste in europeturning challenges into opportunities. available online: https://www.eea.europa.eu/publications/bio-waste-in-europe eu directive 2019/904 of the european parliament and of the council of 5 june 2019 on the reduction of the impact of certain plastic products on the environment, 2019. official journal of the european union. available from: http://data.europa.eu/eli/dir/2019/904/oj filho, w.l., salvia, a.l., bonoli, a., saari, u.a., voronova, v., klõga, m., kumbhar, s.s., olszewski, k., de quevedo, d.m., barbir, j., 2021. an assessment of attitudes towards plastics and bioplastics in europe. sci. total environ. 755, 142732. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.scitotenv.2020.142732 filho, w.l., barbir, j., abubakar, i.r., paço, a., stasiskiene, z., hornbogen, m., christin fendt, m.t., voronova, v., klõga, m., 2022. consumer attitudes and concerns with bioplastics use: an international study. plos one 17, e0266918. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0266918 european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7154 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 29 fletcher, c.a., niemenoja, k., hunt, r., adams, j., dempsey, a., banks, c.e., 2021. addressing stakeholder concerns regarding the effective use of bio-based and biodegradable plastics. resources 10, 95. https://doi.org/10.3390/resources10100095 foschi, e., bonoli, a., 2019. the commitment of packaging industry in the framework of the european strategy for plastics in a circular economy. adm. sci. 9, 18. https://doi.org/10.3390/admsci9010018 gleckman, h., 1995. transnational corporations. strategic responses to ‘sustainable development.’ green glob. yearb. int. co-oper. environ. dev. 1995 1995, 93–106. gold, b.m., mika, k., horowitz, c., herzog, m., leitner, l., 2013. pritzker environmental law and policy briefs. harrison, j. p., boardman, c., o'callaghan, k., delort, a. m., & song, j., 2018. biodegradability standards for carrier bags and plastic films in aquatic environments: a critical review. royal society open science, 5(5), 171792. https://doi.org/10.1098/rsos.171792 heiskanen, e., 2002. the institutional logic of life cycle thinking. j. clean. prod., integrating greener product development perspectives 10, 427–437. https://doi.org/10.1016/s09596526(02)00014-8 hottle, t.a., bilec, m.m. and landis, a.e., 2017. biopolymer production and end of life comparisons using life cycle assessment. resources, conservation and recycling, 122, pp.295306. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.resconrec.2017.03.002 ibrahim, i. a., ötvös, t., gilmanova, a., rocca, e., ghanem, c., & wanat, m. 2021. international energy agency. kluwer law international bv. imbert, e., 2017. food waste valorization options: opportunities from the bioeconomy. open agric. 2, 195–204. https://doi.org/10.1515/opag-2017-0020 jones, m. w., peters, g. p., gasser, t., andrew, r. m., schwingshackl, c., gütschow, j., ... & le quéré, c., 2023. national contributions to climate change due to historical emissions of carbon dioxide, methane, and nitrous oxide since 1850. scientific data, 10(1), 155. karan, h., funk, c., grabert, m., oey, m., hankamer, b., 2019. green bioplastics as part of a circular bioeconomy. trends plant sci. 24, 237–249. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tplants.2018.11.010 kirchherr, j., reike, d., hekkert, m., 2017. conceptualizing the circular economy: an analysis of 114 definitions. resour. conserv. recycl. 127, 221–232. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.resconrec.2017.09.005 klein, f., emberger-klein, a., menrad, k., möhring, w., blesin, j.-m., 2019. influencing factors for the purchase intention of consumers choosing bioplastic products in germany. sustain. prod. consum. 19, 33–43. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.spc.2019.01.004 kweku, d., bismark, o., maxwell, a., desmond, k., danso, k., oti-mensah, e., quachie, a., adormaa, b., 2018. greenhouse effect: greenhouse gases and their impact on global warming. j. sci. res. rep. 17, 1–9. https://doi.org/10.9734/jsrr/2017/39630 lamberti, f.m., román-ramírez, l.a., wood, j., 2020. recycling of bioplastics: routes and benefits. j. polym. environ. 28, 2551–2571. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10924-020-01795-8 leipold, s., & petit-boix, a., 2018. the circular economy and the bio-based sector. perspectives of european and german stakeholders. journal of cleaner production, 201, 1125-1137. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2018.08.019 lynch, d.h.j., klaassen, p., broerse, j.e.w., 2017. unraveling dutch citizens’ perceptions on the bio-based economy: the case of bioplastics, bio-jetfuels and small-scale bio-refineries. ind. crops prod., challenges in building a sustainable biobased economy 106, 130–137. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.indcrop.2016.10.035 mccormick, k., kautto, n., 2013. the bioeconomy in europe: an overview. sustain. switz. 5, 2589–2608. https://doi.org/10.3390/su5062589 meadows, d.h., 2009. thinking in systems: a primer. earthscan, london. merchan, a. l., fischöder, t., hee, j., lehnertz, m. s., osterthun, o., pielsticker, s., ... & palkovits, r. (2022). chemical recycling of bioplastics: technical opportunities to preserve chemical functionality as path towards a circular economy. green chemistry, 24(24), 9428-9449. meereboer, k.w., misra, m., mohanty, a.k., 2020. review of recent advances in the biodegradability of polyhydroxyalkanoate (pha) bioplastics and their composites. green chem. 22, 5519–5558. https://doi.org/10.1039/d0gc01647k molenveld, k., zee, m. van der, 2020. bio-based and biodegradable plastics, bio-based and biodegradable plastics. https://doi.org/10.3390/books978-3-03936-969-0 european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7154 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 30 moorthy, k., kamarudin, a.a., xin, l., hui, l.m., way, l.t., fang, p.s., carmen, w., 2021. green packaging purchase behaviour: a study on malaysian consumers. environ. dev. sustain. 23, 15391–15412. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10668-02101302-6 mostaghimi, k., behnamian, j., 2022. waste minimization towards waste management and cleaner production strategies: a literature review. environ. dev. sustain. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10668-022-02599-7 mougenot, b., doussoulin, j.-p., 2022. conceptual evolution of the bioeconomy: a bibliometric analysis. environ. dev. sustain. 24, 1031–1047. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10668-02101481-2 muhammad shamsuddin, i., 2017. bioplastics as better alternative to petroplastics and their role in national sustainability: a review. adv. biosci. bioeng. 5, 63. https://doi.org/10.11648/j.abb.20170504.13 nazari, m.t., mazutti, j., basso, l.g., colla, l.m., brandli, l., 2021. biofuels and their connections with the sustainable development goals: a bibliometric and systematic review. environ. dev. sustain. 23, 11139–11156. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10668-020-01110-4 nessi, s., sinkko, t., bulgheroni, c., garcia-gutierrez, p., giuntoli, j., konti, a., ... & ardente, f. (2021). life cycle assessment (lca) of alternative feedstocks for plastics production. publications office of the european union oecd (2023), "global plastics outlook: greenhouse gas emissions from plastics lifecycle projections", oecd environment statistics (database), https://doi.org/10.1787/e39547a0-en paletta, a., leal filho, w., balogun, a.l., foschi, e., bonoli, a., 2019. barriers and challenges to plastics valorisation in the context of a circular economy: case studies from italy. j. clean. prod. 241. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2019.118149 pellis, a., malinconico, m., guarneri, a., gardossi, l., 2021. renewable polymers and plastics: performance beyond the green. new biotechnol. 60, 146–158. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.nbt.2020.10.003 philp, j., 2014. oecd policies for bioplastics in the context of a bioeconomy, 2013. ind. biotechnol. 10, 19–21. https://doi.org/10.1089/ind.2013.1612 philp, j., 2018. the bioeconomy, the challenge of the century for policy makers. new biotechnology, 40, 11-19. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.nbt.2017.04.004 piemonte, v., 2011. bioplastic wastes: the best final disposition for energy saving. j. polym. environ. 19, 988–994. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10924-011-0343-z plastic and climate: the hidden costs of a plastic planet, n.d. . cent. int. environ. law. available online: https://www.ciel.org/plasticandclimate/ plasticconsult, 2019. la filiera dei polimeri compostabili. dati 2018 – evoluzioni attese. paper presented at the annual assobioplastic conference, rome, 2019 plastic consult, 2020. la filiera dei polimeri compostabili. dati 2019. paper presented at the annual assobioplastic conference, rome, 2019 rameshkumar, s., shaiju, p., & o'connor, k. e., 2020. bio-based and biodegradable polymersstate-of-the-art, challenges and emerging trends. current opinion in green and sustainable chemistry, 21, 75-81. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cogsc.2019.12.005 reinders, m.j., onwezen, m.c., meeusen, m.j.g., 2017. can bio-based attributes upgrade a brand? how partial and full use of bio-based materials affects the purchase intention of brands. j. clean. prod. 162, 1169–1179. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2017.06.126 ronzon, t., iost, s., philippidis, g., 2022. has the european union entered a bioeconomy transition? combining an output-based approach with a shift-share analysis. environ. dev. sustain. 24, 8195–8217. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10668021-01780-8 ronzon, t., sanjuán, a.i., 2020. friends or foes? a compatibility assessment of bioeconomyrelated sustainable development goals for european policy coherence. j. clean. prod. 254. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2019.119832 rosenboom, j.-g., langer, r., traverso, g., 2022. bioplastics for a circular economy. nat. rev. mater. 7, 117–137. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41578-021-00407-8 sheridan, k., 2016. making the bioeconomy circular: the biobased industries’ next goal? ind. biotechnol. 12, 339–340. https://doi.org/10.1089/ind.2016.29057.ksh shevchenko, t., ranjbari, m., shams esfandabadi, z., danko, y., & bliumska-danko, k., 2022. promising developments in bio-based products as alternatives to conventional plastics to enable circular economy in ukraine. recycling, 7(2), 20. https://doi.org/10.3390/recycling7020020 european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7154 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 31 spierling, s., knüpffer, e., behnsen, h., mudersbach, m., krieg, h., springer, s., ... & endres, h. j., 2018. bio-based plastics-a review of environmental, social and economic impact assessments. journal of cleaner production, 185, 476-491. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2018.03.014 stasiškienė, k., barbir, j., draudvilienė, l., chong, z.k., kuchta, k., voronova, v., filho, w.l., 2022. challenges and strategies for bio-based and biodegradable plastic waste management in europe. sustainability, 14(24) 16476, https://doi.org/10.3390/su142416476 stegmann, p., londo, m., junginger, m., 2020. the circular bioeconomy: its elements and role in european bioeconomy clusters. resour. conserv. recycl. x 6, 100029. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.rcrx.2019.100029 stephenson, p. j., & damerell, a., 2022. bioeconomy and circular economy approaches need to enhance the focus on biodiversity to achieve sustainability. sustainability, 14(17), 10643. https://doi.org/10.3390/su141710643 tan, e.c. and lamers, p., 2021. circular bioeconomy concepts—a perspective. frontiers in sustainability, 2, p.701509. https://doi.org/10.3389/frsus.2021.701509 thakur, s., chaudhary, j., sharma, b., verma, a., tamulevicius, s., thakur, v.k., 2018. sustainability of bioplastics: opportunities and challenges. curr. opin. green sustain. chem. 13, 68–75. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cogsc.2018.04.013 ubando, a.t., felix, c.b., chen, w.h., 2020. biorefineries in circular bioeconomy: a comprehensive review. bioresour. technol. 299. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.biortech.2019.122585 volova, t.g., boyandin, a.n., vasiliev, a.d., karpov, v.a., prudnikova, s. v., mishukova, o. v., boyarskikh, u.a., filipenko, m.l., rudnev, v.p., bá xuân, b., vit dũng, v., gitelson, i.i., 2010. biodegradation of polyhydroxyalkanoates (phas) in tropical coastal waters and identification of pha-degrading bacteria. polym. degrad. stab. 95, 2350–2359. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.polymdegradstab.2010.08.023 yang, l., wang, x. c., dai, m., chen, b., qiao, y., deng, h., ... & wang, y., 2021. shifting from fossil-based economy to bio-based economy: status quo, challenges, and prospects. energy, 228, 120533. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.energy.2021.120533 yates, m.r., barlow, c.y., 2013. life cycle assessments of biodegradable, commercial biopolymers—a critical review. resour. conserv. recycl. 78, 54–66. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.resconrec.2013.06.010 world economic forum, 2016. the new plastics economy. rethinking the future of plastics. available online: https://www3.weforum.org/docs/wef_the_new_plastics_economy.pdf appendix 1. presentation questions a. please provide a brief description of the company: what is its business? what type of plastic resins (in general) does it use? 2. questions on how, when, why is a mature decision the introduction of biobased materials b. do you use compostable biopolymers according to the norm en 13432: 2002? do you use compostable biopolymers from renewable sources? c. when and why did you introduce bio-based plastics in your product/ process/product line? (interviews were prompted to indicate opportunities detected, main motivations, customer requests, etc) d. what were the problems or obstacles that generated doubts about the technical feasibility and/or economic feasibility of starting using bioplastics? how have these issues been overcome? 01_re european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7691 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 1 the transition from a “city of waste” to a “circular city”: virtuous practices in the city of pavia beatrice re1*, luca bottini2, carola ricci3, gabriella bottini4, dana strauss5 1 contact author university of pavia, department of economics and management, university of pavia, via san felice, 5 – 27100, pavia (italy) beatrice.re@unipv.it orcid 0000-0001-7391-1321 2 university of milan-bicocca department of sociology and social research, via bicocca degli arcimboldi, 8, 20126 milan (italy) luca.bottini@unimib.it orcid 0000-0001-5605-1665 3 university of pavia, department of social and political sciences, corso strada nuova 65, 27100 pavia (italy) carola.ricci@unipv.it 4 university of pavia, department of brain and behavioral sciences, piazza botta 11, 27100 pavia (italy) gabriella.bottini@gmail.com 5 friedrich schiller university jena, zwätzengasse 3, 07743 jena germany dana.strauss@uni-jena.de received: 18/06/2023 accepted for publication: 07/11/2023 published: 21/12/2023 abstract cities are facing the greatest challenge of their whole lifecycle: choosing their own destiny. cities are the main contributors to climate change, as much of the excess carbon dioxide in the atmosphere comes from them. understanding how cities can transform into “circular cities” is key to fostering change. however, empirical studies in this direction are still scant. in this paper, we address this research gap by answering the following research question: how are current “cities of waste” transitioning to “circular cities”? we do so by means of an empirical study involving several stakeholders located in the town of pavia (northern italy). we find that some actors have implemented virtuous circular economy (ce) practices; however, the transition to ce is overall conducted in a fragmented manner, with a lack of orchestration and planning among private actors as well as a lack of synergies between private and public actors. we conclude our study by advancing future avenues of research, highlighting our theoretical and managerial contributions, and advancing policy implications. keywords: smart cities; circular cities; circular economy; focus group 2 1. introduction cities are major contributors to climate change. according to un habitat, cities consume 78% of the world’s energy and produce more than 60% of greenhouse gas emissions. however, they account for less than 2% of the earth’s surface. the phenomenon of urbanization is massive: approximately 66% of the world’s population will live in cities by 2050 (united nations, 2014). in europe, urban areas are home to more than 75% of the population, they account for 80% of energy use and generate 85% of the european gdp (european commission). due to the significant influence cities have on climate change, it is imperative that they expedite their shift toward sustainable and circular approaches, by embarking on serious paths of change in the use of natural resources as well as in their citizens’ consumption practices. for instance, cities are considered fundamental actors in tackling food waste, as they can actively introduce adequate policies, initiatives, and projects to reduce it (fattibene et al., 2020). cities are essential for europe’s transformation to a climate-neutral continent by 2050, as set out in the european green deal (eurocoties, 2020). a shift toward more sustainable cities is urgently needed. the ellen macarthur foundation highlights that cities have a high concentration of resources, capital, data, and talent spread over a relatively small geographic area and are also centers for innovation. this means that cities are uniquely positioned to drive a global transition toward a circular economy (ce) (williams, 2021). the ce aims at preserving raw materials in a permanent loop to maximize the employment of resources. the result should be the reduction of waste. different cities, according to their characteristics, adopt different kinds of ce practices thus opening multiple scenarios. a circular city is defined as “a city that practices ce principles to close resource loops, in partnership with the city's stakeholders (citizens, community, business, and knowledge stakeholders), to realize its vision of a future-proof city” (prendeville et al., 2018). circular cities are praised for their commitment to implementing practices aimed at reducing the overall urban emissions. however, the concept of a “circular city” is still in its emerging phase and it thus appears a slightly blurred and utopian, especially because of the lack of empirical evidence as there is not a single model to be followed, but rather more models advancing concrete circular practices to be adopted at the urban level. in this paper, we aim to fill this research gap by empirically investigating how a “city of waste” whose activities are rooted in the linear “take-make-dispose” paradigm could shift toward a “circular city” by means of virtuous sustainable practices implemented by different stakeholders. the addressed research question is “how are current “cities of waste” are transitioning to “circular cities”? our research context is an italian middle-sized city, pavia (northern italy). pavia is home to one of the most ancient universities in italy. the university of pavia is part of the ec2u (european campus of city-universities) consortium, which includes six other european universities: the university of coimbra (portugal), alexandru ioan cuza university of iasi (romania), the university of jena (germany), the university of poitiers (france coordinator), the university of salamanca (spain), and the university of turku (finland). the ec2u consortium aims at creating a pan-european campus, with a shared governance model, fostering mobility within the seven universities and developing innovative models in education, research, public engagement and third mission. one of the tools adopted by this european project is the organization of think tanks, policy institutes promoting debate on research topics relevant for the social and political context to implement ameliorative strategies. as part of the ec2u alliance, one of the promoted think tanks focused on the circular economy key to change and sustainability organized in pavia in february 2022. through three focus groups, involving multiple stakeholders of pavia who have been proactive in developing circular practices, we unveil the challenges they faced/are facing in implementing these practices, we explain how they tackled them, and illustrate the remaining issues to be solved. with our study, we contribute to the academic literature on urban studies by providing empirical evidence of circular practices implemented by different stakeholders in a specific italian urban context. we also contribute to policy-making by advancing policy suggestions stemming from our findings. the remainder of this paper is structured as follows. first, we introduce the background literature on urban studies about smart and circular cities. second, we illustrate the methodology employed and we discuss our findings. finally, we highlight our theoretical and managerial contribution, and we propose future research avenues, some of which will be deepened also in another project of which the university of pavia is a partner, funded by the european union next generation eu, within the italian national recovery and resilience plan, on “research and innovation for sustainable food and nutrition onfoods”. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7691 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 3 2. theoretical background the development model based on the massive consumption of natural resources is showing all its fragilities and implications at the global level. the european green deal calls for a zero carbon europe by 2050 (piontek et al., 2021). to do so, the introduction of accurate measurements for organizations’ circularity is necessary (vola et al., 2023). cities, for more than a century, have been the driving force behind the development of nations, but the industrial model on which they have based their fortunes, wealth and success has generated social and environmental costs whose effects are showing themselves in full magnitude from year to year. starting from the end of the 20th century, the debate among urban planners and city scholars about the need to imagine a different future for the cities of the world has led to the development of the "smart city" paradigm, a new way of understanding the functioning of urban systems based above all on the contribution of digital technologies. the smart city concept turns out to be an evolution of the paradigm popularized in the early 1990s of the "digital city" (couclelis, 2004; hepworth, 1990). subsequently, the smart city idea coincided with the urban development model of an "entrepreneurial city" as a style of urban governance based on global competition, financialization of urban space through urban regeneration and culture (mahizhnan, 1999). only recently, with the growing concern about the impact of climate change on the fate of cities, has the connection between smart cities and environmental sustainability made its way (caragliu et al., 2011). the urban planning paradigm of the smart city has occupied urban agendas for several years and represents an idea of the city that, too often, has been embraced uncritically. the promise of this way of understanding the cities of the future lies in collective advantage in all respects, social well-being, environmental sustainability, and a harmonious urban environment. although there is no agreement on one definition of a “smart city” (komninos & mora, 2018), there is a consensus on the fact that a smart city involves development and improvement (guenduez & mergel, 2022), to solve urban challenges and improve the quality of life (nicolas et al., 2020). it is a model of a city that has shown strengths and deep weaknesses, especially in the environmental and social dimension (evans et al., 2019). it can be said that the "smart city" model is even still today an ideal type to potentially strive for, but one that is far from being achievable in the current state within which contemporary developed cities move. the literature is replete with such criticisms, such as the case of datta (2015) who argues that the concept of a "smart city" is nothing more than "the utopia of the 21st century". other authors glimpse within the "smart city" paradigm a new way of understanding the transformation of contemporary cities, no longer driven by political and social ends, but predominantly industrial and neoliberal (haarstad, 2017). przeybilovicz et al. (2022) highlight the key role of citizens in promoting initiatives to improve the smart city and in taking part in its governance (meijer and bolívar, 2016; webster and leleux, 2018). angelidou et al (2022) argue that scenarios for future urban development need to consider smart cities, smart transport, and smart energy as strictly interconnected. on the one hand, urban governments have seized the opportunity of the spread of the "smart city" paradigm to implement policies aimed at attracting capital to cities, which has been subject to criticism (martin et al., 2018), on the other hand, the environmental sustainability component has been recently emphasized in the literature (haarstad, 2017; bibri & krogstie, 2017). the challenges of decarbonization and mitigating the impacts of global warming in cities are stimulating research and theoretical reflection, particularly in the field of industrial economics. this involves exploring the possibility that the production processes of goods and services, partly responsible for global warming, can transform their practices and shift toward a circular economic model that might lead to the establishment of “circular cities” (williams, 2021; vanhuyse et al., 2021). we refer to the idea of economic models under the circular economy umbrella, which are finding strong points of contact with the smart city paradigm (dincă et al., 2022). circular economy (ce) could be defined as “an industrial economy that is restorative or regenerative by intention and design” (ellen macarthur foundation, 2013, p. 7). ce can be a path toward more sustainable ways of living (borrello et al., 2017), since it provides clear directions on how to narrow, slow, and close the resource loops (geissdoerfer et al., 2017), aiming to reach sustainable modes of production and consumption (bocken et al., 2018; ghisellini et al., 2016). to better address today’s challenges and remain attractive for their stakeholders, cities are developing reliable and sustainable solutions (de jong et al., 2015; neirotti et al., 2014; yigitcanlar, 2011). the ce can thus represent a concrete response to mitigate the impact that cities have on the environment, and its relevance for cities and urban planning is being increasingly reflected in the literature (bolger & doyon, 2019; brzica, 2023). by integrating the concept of ce into urban studies, some authors (bolger & doyon, 2019; prendeville et al., 2018; williams, 2019) have recently introduced the concept of “circular city”. prendeville et al. (2018) highlight that there is a lack of consensus european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7691 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 4 on what a circular city is and about the how and why of the circular city concept. the authors offer a conceptualization of a circular city as “a city that practices ce principles to close resource loops, in partnership with the city’s stakeholders (citizens, community, business and knowledge stakeholders), to realize its vision of a future-proof city” (p. 187). bolger and doyon (2019) analyze the role of local governments in promoting ce initiatives through strategic planning. by means of a comparative study conducted in melbourne and malmö, the authors show that municipalities make considerable efforts to improve resource management and recycling practices. nevertheless, the level of consumption in both cities remains high and therefore the authors argue that a change in consumption patterns needs to be further promoted at a public level. ghisellini et al. (2016) support the idea that local governments (municipalities) have great potential for supporting the transition toward sustainable development. williams (2019) argues that the resolve framework of the circular economy (ellen macarthur foundation, 2015), which includes six actions to move toward a ce (lewandowski, 2016) is inadequate when applied to the context of the city. the author advances instead the idea that implementing circular economy principles at the city level requires the regeneration and renewal of complex urban ecosystems. studies regarding circular cities are in the early years, and those conducted in the italian context are a few (benedetti et al., 2022; ghisellini et al., 2022). benedetti et al. (2022) focus on the construction sector and they study urban regeneration by comparing demolition with reconstruction and renovation in the city of bologna. ghisellini et al. (2022) investigate pioneering ce practices implemented in the city of naples, which currently lacks a vision of a circular city, and they offer new insights regarding opportunities for transition toward ce. 3. methodology in this paper, we aim to contribute to the growing urban studies investigating circular cities by providing empirical evidence of circular practices that may facilitate the transition from a “city of waste” toward a “circular city”. 3.1 focus group the focus group is a research methodology that is increasingly adopted in diverse research contexts and fields (morgan, 1996). a focus group is defined as “a group of individuals selected and assembled by researchers to discuss and comment on, from personal experience, the topic that is the subject of the research” (powell & single, 1996, p. 499). focus groups are interactional by nature and allow the participants to exchange ideas and opinions. as the aim of focus groups is to maximize the interactions among participants, having smaller groups is preferred, to offer more opportunities for participation in the discussion. wilkerson (1996) argues, however, that groups may be smaller. wilkerson (1996) proposes five as the optimal number of participants and argues that the maximum number of participants may be eight. by following these recommendations, the number of participants in each focus group is equal to six. 3.2 research setting: pavia pavia is a mid-sized city of approximately 70,000 inhabitants, located in lombardy, close to the ticino river. it is home to a university founded in the 14th-century, one of the most ancient in italy, and it hosts the san matteo hospital, one of the most important hospitals in italy. we choose pavia as a research setting as this study stems from a wider project we conducted within a european consortium, ec2u (european campus of city-universities), of which pavia, as the sole italian city, is part. the consortium’s objective is to foster research, education and multistakeholder dialog throughout the seven member universities and european communities. one of the key formats that has been developed by the alliance is the think tank, which aims at bringing citizens, scientists, and policy makers together to discuss and share best practices. in 2022, the think tank was centered specifically on ce. each of the seven ec2u partners conducted its own local think tank on the topic (ec2u 2022). all local findings were then presented and discussed in a joint session during the 4th ec2u forum in pavia. as a result, a set of policy recommendations has been agreed upon. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7691 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 5 the think tank in pavia has been structured into three focus groups to elicit the debate among diverse groups of stakeholders located in pavia. these stakeholders are pioneering the implementation of circular practices as part of their business models (e.g., sustainable mobility, recycling, sustainable nutrition). thanks to the project, it was possible to bring together different actors of the city of pavia and let them interact and exchange opinions and ideas. 3.3 data collection in february 2022, an online meeting via zoom on the topic of adoption of ce in the city of pavia was organized. the structure of the symposium foresaw three focus groups involving stakeholders grouped into three main categories: 1. universities; 2, firms; 3. other associations/projects. we proceeded to select stakeholders that could meet our research objective by adopting a purposeful selection criterion (patton, 2015), so that i) stakeholders were needed to be local, meaning based in pavia or in the nearby and ii) to have implemented circular practices. by following these criteria, twelve stakeholders per each of the mentioned stakeholder group (n=36 stakeholders) were selected and emailed to check the availability of an internal knowledgeable informant to take part in the focus group. we obtained the consensus of six stakeholders per each group (n= 18 stakeholders). our final sample is composed of eighteen stakeholders (table 1). table 1: focus group participants group 1: university group 2: firms group 3: other associations/projects unipv, mobility manager voltaplant alternative energy, startup fiab (federazione nazionale ambiente e bicicletta) environmental organization promoting the daily use of bicycles and cycle tourism italbiotec, waste consortium planeat online platform for grocery shopping starting from recipes and buying ready-to-use fresh and organic ingredients, benefit company fondazione banco alimentare onlus not-for-profit association aiming at collecting food waste and distributing it to charitable associations ghislieri college biorestart start-up, production of substances from plant waste and bio products giulia marrazzo expert in active citizenship borromeo college lavgon ethical fashion laboratory, creative and craft shop il sellino spiritato association of citizens of pavia aiming to promote the bike use unipv, osa office for sustainable actions fungobox and coffeefrom social enterprise aiming to develop a sustainable urban agriculture starting from coffee grounds re-cig start-up having the mission to collect and recycle cigarettes’ filters to make objects through a patented process esn erasmus students network, president assolombarda industrial association of the territories of milan, lodi, monza and brianza, pavia. repair café pavia group of volunteers devoted to repairing broken items source: author´s elaboration european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7691 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 6 the round table discussion among the stakeholders revolved around the motivations to develop circular practices, the specific problems and challenges faced, and the implemented solutions to overcome them. more specifically, the questions we asked during the focus groups were the following: 1. motivation: what motivates the stakeholders to engage in a circular economy? 2. problems: what are the specific problems and challenges that the stakeholders have attempted to solve? 3. solutions: which solutions did the stakeholders come up with and implement? what helped rather than what hindered them along the way? 4. remaining challenges: what are the next challenges that the stakeholders want to tackle/or: what are the problems that they yet must solve? 3.4 data analysis each focus group lasted 120 minutes, it was recorded through zoom, and was transcribed within 24 hours. all the interviews were performed in italian and then translated into english after the transcription. to ensure internal validity, we triangulated primary data with secondary data (web and journal articles, the press, and social media pages) (denzin, 1978). we also relied on investigator triangulation: we compared the data analysis within our research team until reaching a shared agreement (ibid). to analyze the data, we manually coded the participants’ sentences by using different colors, to classify them into the considered variables of interest: i) motivation to start circular activities, ii) area/topic of implementation, iii) challenges, iv) solutions to be implemented, and v) other problems 4. results here, we introduce the results stemming from each focus group, by presenting tables of results that include five variables, i) motivations to adopt ce practices, ii) area/topic of implementation, iii) challenges faced, iv) solutions found, and v) remaining problems (table 2). table 2: focus group with stakeholder: university group 1 motivations area/topic challenges solutions remaining problems university of pavia, mobility manager -reducing the use of private vehicles -overall contribution to the reduction of co2 emissions. sustainability in the mobility/transport area (increase of use of public transport, reduction of parking slots, fostering use of bicycles) engage local actors (e.g. hospitals, municipality), that employ many inhabitants and have an impact upon the commuters more engagement activities and greater involvement of other local actors to establish synergies with. coordination and cooperation with other local stakeholders italbiotec -reducing waste -defining a common framework regarding the concepts linked to the ce innovation and dissemination in the local area and engagement of the civil society -technological challenges (research & development) -attract investments, common -increase the moments of interaction with the territory; -foster the communication with actors having -defining a “common language”: being able to disseminate the topic of innovation in a way that is understandable for the general public -ensuring an overall european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7691 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 7 understanding of “different languages” different background understanding of sustainability (overcoming the difficulty in understanding the intersection between the three aspects of sustainability, i.e., economic, social, and environmental) ghislieri college -increase the educational offer in the college, students’ awareness, students’ proactivity, and develop international synergies on the topic. increase the research on sustainable agriculture via the college’s rural plots of lands. nexus of: environmental sustainability health enterprise. sustainable agriculture. -ensure a common framework, raising awareness about the topic of sustainable agriculture. challenges are linked to research capabilities. -develop mandatory courses to ensure that all students are homogeneously trained on the topic of sustainability. n/a borromeo college -reduction in consumption of: plastic, co2 (energy), cards. -careful waste sorting/recycling -waste and food waste, energy. biodiversity and natural heritage. -heritage preservation as a key value to be conveyed to students. -transversality of sustainability values. -fostering information/disse mination. -direct involvement in activities of training and information, to enable a process in "cascade": students as ambassadors outside the academic field. -reaching out to the public with information and dissemination activities. lack of an integrated communication which would be able to create a bridge between research and society. osa office for sustainable actions -creating synergies among all departments and offices of the university -spreading the transversality of sustainability. -education -waste reduction -energy efficiency -valorization of the green heritage difficulties in collaborating with external actors, and often with internal actors of the university itself. expand and foster communication. lack of collaboration and specifically in the waste sector: waste quantification and management problem with external actors. esn erasmus students network increased students’ awareness and engagement. -waste reduction (via garbage collection); second-hand lack in active participation of local actors. -bottom-up involvement, starting from small local actors reluctance to active participation. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7691 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 8 clothing collection; awareness raising activities (e.g. conferences). (e.g., plastic free) and development of synergies with the university -increased awareness to fight indifference and reluctance to get involved. source: author´s elaboration all the actors taking part in this focus group are colleges and networks aiming to develop sustainable actions. the common issues these actors face regard the engagement of local actors, the lack of a “common language” that prevents stakeholders and civil society from interacting fruitfully, and the overall lack of proactivity and collaboration among actors (table 3). some main solutions that have been implemented to tackle these issues are the dissemination activities, and an increase in the communication and involvement of local actors. table 3: focus group with stakeholder “firms” group 2 motivations why area/topic challenges solutions remaining problems voltaplant removing battery by substituting the energy stemming from plants power improvement for lighting systems and iot, new materials -carbon offset -produce a sufficient quantity of energy select and implement new materials that are increasingly recyclable and sustainable further raise the performance of these cells to obtain maximum operating stability and repeatability of the cells lavgon develop an alternative, ethically and socially responsible way to produce garments (handicraft laboratory) high quality raw material, rethinking and reuse of fabric/textile scraps -communicate the value proposition to prospect clients -finding manufacturers suitable for processing textile waste -production into a system of suppliers and a reuse network (not only textiles) create a network of informal suppliers and local associations interested in processing textile waste -communicate the value proposition to the clients -find the proper suppliers having recyclable/sustainable inputs at affordable prices european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7691 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 9 biorestart use waste from the agri-food chain to extract bioactive compounds organic waste recovery scaling-up and decreasing the environmental and economic impact of the waste transportation building waste treatment centers through italy decrease the water consumption needed for the process through water recovery planeat -provide to as many people as possible a sustainable alternative to the traditional grocery shopping -fighting food waste tool for healthy meals planning -fight food waste and disposable plastic -finding the proper suppliers providing sustainable materials -economic sustainability development of the planeat.com platform to implement a new grocery shopping concept -scaling-up -competition of the large-scale distribution fungobox and coffeefrom reuse the coffee grounds as a production input -kits to develop a bio-based material from recycled coffee grounds and biopolymers zero-waste alternative to traditional plastic -develop more versions of the coffee granules by increasing the % of recycled coffee grounds -new applications of the material and new partners -finding an increasing number of practical applications finding partnering firms aiming to substitute the traditional plastic with a coffee from product -encourage producers to embrace the circular paradigm -stimulate investments to foster the circular economy assolombarda role of wrap up proposing synergies and joint projects source: author´s elaboration all the actors taking part in this focus group are local startups and firms adopting a sustainable or circular business model since their foundation: they all aim to make a positive impact on the environment by implementing business-based solutions to reduce waste. apart from specific challenges concerning the developed products/services, the firms have common issues to be faced concerning the scalability of their business, the achievement of economic sustainability and the development of industrial symbiosis. some solutions to overcome these issues have already been implemented, i.e., the development of informal networks and the establishment of partnerships with other firms. assolombarda, being the most important association of the italian entrepreneurial system in the country, may assume an active role in fostering the transition toward circularity, by advancing guidelines in terms of circular practices, and enhancing synergies between economic actors (table 4). however, several are the difficulties that remain and still need to find a solution, i.e., scaling-up and building full circular value chains since investments and partners are frequently not available or are difficult to identify. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7691 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 10 table 4: focus group with stakeholder “local associations” group 3 motivations why area/topic challenges solutions remaining problems active citizenship (cittadinanza attiva) spreading a culture that can influence waste practices by transforming them into education of reuse, recycle and repair, or to virtuous purchasing practices (buying food in bulk, etc.). spreading among citizens the culture of reuse, recycle and repair. involve as much citizenship as possible. eco-tour in the center of pavia to discover stores where you can buy loose, ecosustainable and km 0 products, repair or borrow objects etc. increasingly implement initiatives that help influence the acquisition of virtuous practices of proenvironmental/sustainable behaviors. il sellino spiritato -study mobility plans for several cities including pavia -democratizing the public space making the urban mobility more sustainable. spreading a culture of sustainable urban mobility. enhancing the collaboration with public and private actors in order to reach a general impact on the urban mobility of pavia. cycling tracks could be improved at 7% with small and cheap interventions (e.g. changing vertical signage). -in pavia every hour 5.000 cars travel less than 3 km; respiratory pathologies increase and the pedestrians still have a small amount of public space to walk on. investors should be more involved in the whole planning process. re-cig re-cig deals with the collection and recycle of cigarette butts, with a patented process it proposes a service to companies to collect the butts in compliance with regulatory standards (smokers point), including the use of a portable ashtray and the transportation of the waste to the recycling premise circularity is the main objective starting from a waste that had no previous reutilization practice, even though the material deriving from the recycling process is at the moment poor in quality and limited in quantity reduce waste by extending the collection of cigarette butts in larger areas and recycle the butts’ main components to re-market it as a component for other products (useful in the production of glasses) -the legal framework is still very complicated even if there are signs of recent re-considering strategies by policy makers (including the amendments of the italian constitution) try to involve cigarette producers to adopt policies or reduction of butt waste and pay for the recycle european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7691 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 11 fiab strong contribution in spreading the culture of soft mobility in order to achieve a multidimensional impact on both mobility practices and urban environmental quality. spreading the soft mobility practices make an effort not only to facilitate the transition to sustainable mobility, but also (indirectly) to make the city more livable, beautiful and with a higher quality of life. the university should take greater responsibility in being a driver to urge the spread of cycling in the city. in this sense, the university can play a role in lobbying the city council to take concrete steps to improve urban mobility. fiab is active in proposing concrete solutions to promote sustainable mobility, but more resolution is needed from the public actor in implementing these projects. banco alimentare collect foodstuffs which are still perfectly edible but, having lost their commercial value or being unfit for sale (consisting of surplus production, incorrectly labeled products, food close to its ‘use-by-date’, food leftovers and surplus from catering and canteen services) would be destined to landfill. the main supplying sources are food industry, organized large-scale retail trade, and collective catering service. food surplus is prevented from becoming waste, thus recovered as a resource for those who cannot afford edible and nutritious food. -participation with other stakeholders and policy makers to frame both new legislation (internally, the so called ‘gadda’ law enacted in 2016) and common guidelines (i.e., the manual of good practices for charitable ngos) to help private donors and nonprofit charitable organizations in donating, recovering, collecting, storing and distributing food for charitable purposes to people in need, while assuring -recovering food surplus and leftovers to redistribute them for free to the increasing part of the population in need living in the city which the market and public services cannot reach. reduction of the environmental impact of food production and consumption on climate changes as it reduces the carbon footprint related to cities. educating people on the importance of giving value to food avoiding waste, as well as of raising awareness around the themes of food poverty, healthy diets and volunteering in the cities. -donation of safe food surplus should become a practice to be more widely spread through the entire food chain, from the production to the retailers and consumption level. every year banco organizes the national food collection day, involving a large network of supermarkets and civil society and raising awareness about the problem of food poverty thanks to a concrete and free gesture of sharing. launching the ‘siticibo’ initiative, a network aimed at recovering large scale retailers and catering surplus. -a uniform definition of parameters to measure food waste volumes at the local, european and international levels, is still missing, thus threatening the common efforts made to modify the relevant existing legislation in an effective way -the donation dimension should be added to the traditional 3r cycle european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7691 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 12 food safety and traceability. repair café reduce the waste created by those who throw away without first attempting to repair the seemingly nolonger-functioning object for its original purpose. teaching how to repair or reuse for a different purpose daily life objects. fighting the “consumption & waste” culture convincing people to repair and reuse instead of wasting used objects requires time. the project is completely based on training sessions and workshops to spread this culture of repair and reuse. -there are no right tools to access that product or to repair it -it would be necessary to change the law so that manufacturers would be responsible for making items produced reusable. source: author´s elaboration all the actors taking part in this focus group are local associations/projects aiming to promote sustainable and circular practices in the fields of urban waste, mobility, and food. the common issues these entities need to face concern the low level of collaboration and engagement of public actors and the complexity of dealing with the current legal framework and the complex bureaucracy. we find that some key solutions that have been implemented to solve these problems are networking with the public and private sector, looking for a higher visibility by interacting with the university (useful for lobbying at different levels, from local to european level). finally, a pattern can be found along all the outcomes of the focus group, that is the need for a more effective involvement of the public institutions of the city. indeed, the transition from a city of waste to a circular city can become feasible thanks to the collaboration with all the stakeholders of the urban society who actively participate in this social process. 5. discussion the conducted analysis of the focus groups allows us to identify six virtuous circular practices to transit from a “city of waste” to a “circular city” . first, the implementation of circular business models within some urban economic activities. this is a positive sign as it means that pavia is showcasing trends of transition from traditional linear business models to new circular approaches. obviously, the spread of this model among the city's economic actors is not yet pervasive, but the presented cases offer signals that testify a occurring within the local system. second, we observe the will to prevent/reduce food waste through several businesses and organizations dedicated to promoting the circularity in the food field. as cities have a key role in tackling food waste (fattibene et al., 2020), we deem that the implementation of these virtuous circular food practices is crucial within a “circular city”. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7691 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 13 a third practice emerging from the focus groups regards the promotion of a sustainable mobility. circularity, having a primary goal focused on environmental sustainability, inevitably involves the world of transportation and its impact on air quality. pavia showcases some active players in the association sector, who carry out several activities to downsize local private motor transportation, and facilitate bicycle transportation instead. in this case, interaction with the public body becomes crucial to implement the various bicycle-pedestrian projects. the spread of circular economy practices, however, seems to involve not only the strictly business-related field, but also the association sector, which is the fourth factor. in particular, the focus group reveals the strong role played by some actors in the field of "reuse-reduce-recycle" practices. the presence of these actors in the urban context shows how circularity is a paradigm that cannot involve only companies; rather, it should engage all members of a society and stimulate social activism. a fifth virtuous practice emerging from the focus group concerns collaboration between university and stakeholders. the university of pavia constitutes a historical institution for the city, due to its educational role and related to scientific research. universities represent key resources for cities, as key drivers for technological experimentation and for the study of practices that can be implemented in policy making. collaboration between universities, local government and, more generally, all stakeholders active in the circular economy process, makes it possible to trigger those innovation processes that are fundamental to truly progress in the transition from “a city of waste” to a “circular city”. finally, a sixth virtuous practice concerns the involvement of the citizenry to spread sustainable behaviors. again, the role of associations is crucial in implementing activities to spread circular behaviors. in the focus group, for example, various activities have been presented by participants (e.g., workshops aimed at teaching stakeholders how to repair objects and make them usable again, plastic collection days, bike repair stands). the empirical evidence thus shows that there are some fundamental "ingredients" in a city to create the social conditions for actions and initiatives attributable to the circular economy sector to be activated. the six identified virtuous practices could be the basis for a future evaluation of a city circularity, as already proposed by vola et al. (2023) with respect to organizations’ circularity. finally, while the study by vanhuyse et al. (2021) highlights the lack of social impact considerations in research about circular cities, through our empirical study we can find some hints about social activities that are embedded in business models (e.g., csr activities, social inclusion) or are part of an actor’s mission (e.g., education about sustainability). the university of pavia, as a relevant historical university, may represent a key actor in fostering the social aspects linked to ce, in addition to its commitment in the third mission and the public engagement (which is supported by the creation of important structures such as the office of sustainability). however, all these territorial and university activities work in a fragmented and disconnected manner, lacking a solid and extensive network allowing continuous exchanges and favoring the connection between the several and diverse territorial experiences. in particular, the difficulties in interaction between the local government and the economic actors prevent the unleashing of the full potential of all these ce practices leading to the construction of the smart city of the future. while private and public actors often diverge in their objectives, greater collaboration between circular economy actors and the local government becomes crucial to enable the dissemination of the benefits of this approach to economic production throughout the urban community. the literature is beginning to highlight these effects (dagilienè et al., 2018; wasserbaur et al., 2022; christensen, 2021), where private entrepreneurship is facilitated by political actions capable of supporting it and enabling the release of its potential positive impact on the urban community. in the case of pavia, therefore, it seems necessary to cultivate greater interaction both among the actors involved in the field of circular economy (especially business ventures and local associations) and between them and the public actors university included to develop a virtuous relationship that provides real support to initiatives beneficial for all stakeholders involved. if williams (2019) supported the idea that implementing ce principles at the city level requires regenerating the urban ecosystem, thus going beyond the resolve framework, we find little evidence of environmentally regenerating activities in our analyzed city, and they are mainly bound to the sustainable mobility. raising awareness regarding ce and increasing investments in urban regeneration should be priorities of the next decades. our findings add to the study of bolger and doyon that public actors need to assume a leading role in facilitating and orchestrating the network of different stakeholders operating locally in order to transform a “city of waste” into a “circular city”. finally, we also find that the potential of local municipalities in favoring the transition toward circular cities (ghisellini et al., 2016) still needs to be fully exploited in the analyzed city. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7691 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 14 5. conclusion this paper aimed to contribute to the emerging literature of urban studies about circular cities (benedetti et al., 2022; ghisellini, 2022; prendeville, 2019; williams, 2019) through an empirical study aimed at investigating virtuous practices of transition toward a circular city. thanks to three focus groups conducted within the ec2u think tank in the city of pavia (northern italy), we could identify virtuous practices to transit from a “city of waste” towards a “circular city”, i.e., circular business models by local firms and ngos, reducing of food waste, promoting sustainable mobility, local activism focused on “repairing-reuse-recycle”, collaboration between the university and private stakeholders, and civic engagement for improving sustainable behaviors. all these outcomes give an account of the presence of a background in the city of pavia that could gradually enable the good conditions to build a city aware of the relevancy of the circular economy. our case study suggests that cities have many possibilities to shift toward a circular economy, by leveraging on the expertise of different stakeholders and the engagement of local citizens. municipalities and local governments are key players in the transition, as they can support the stakeholders in overcoming the barriers concerning the lack of regulations, and in guiding the transition toward “circular cities” in a synergistic and structured manner. the university that represents a relevant and historical feature of the city of pavia may provide education on the topic, also consolidating the interaction with the stakeholders working in the territory, and favoring the students’ training. this will implement and expand knowledge on the concept of sustainability and on the most available and effective tools to be adopted to create circular cities against the old model of waste cities. our findings call for an enhancement of the commitment of public actors as active promoters of the transition toward “circular cities”. 5.1 limitations and future avenues for research the paper presents some limitations. first and foremost, the research is based on a single case study, meaning that it allows for analytical generalization but not for statistical generalization. further research may compare the results stemming from this study conducted in pavia with other studies conducted in other cities (for instance, those belonging to the ec2u consortium), and may focus on the role of public actors as orchestrators of circular urban projects. we also suggest that it would be worth performing longitudinal studies to investigate over time the process of transformation from a “city of waste” toward a “circular city”. finally, we suggest deeply investigating the social aspects linked to the implementation of circular cities. 5.2 policy implications the illustrated case study has highlighted several crucial factors, limitations, and methodologies that can provide valuable guidance for local, national, and european policymakers. the ce approach offers solutions to address sustainability and achieve the 2030 sustainable development goals (sdgs) to which both un member states and every eu member state, including italy, have committed. as demonstrated in our case study, the interconnectedness of all the goals and targets necessitates a multi-stakeholder approach to finding more suitable solutions and creating effective positive impacts at various levels. for instance, implementing a ce approach in urban food policies would yield economic, societal, and environmental benefits, as evidenced by extant studies (ellen macarthur foundation 2019; lizzi et al. 2022). practices aimed at preventing and reducing food waste can enhance urban regeneration, curb greenhouse gas emissions, and mitigate soil degradation, offering significant environmental benefits that also promote health. simultaneously, these efforts can benefit those in need, improve food security, alleviate poverty, and bolster local resilience. our study suggests overcoming policy constraints that limit the actions of numerous local actors, both public and private, which are influenced by (i) the absence of uniform rules and common definitions or (ii) a convoluted legal framework where different standards and normative approaches are imposed by national, eu, and international rules. the collected empirical evidence suggests that there are several ce practices that could be implemented at the urban level to favor the transition from cities of waste toward circular cities. policies should favor the implementation of these practices, by concurrently following ongoing revisions of eu acts related to corporate social responsibility (csr), sustainability, waste management (including textiles and food), and packaging, which will soon introduce new rules at the national and local levels european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7691 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 15 acknowledgements we would like to thank all the participants of the think tank for their time and the insights they provided us. we are grateful to the ec2u consortium for involving us in the think tank project. references ali angelidou, m., politis, c., panori, a., barkratsas, t., & fellnhofer, k. (2022). emerging smart city, transport and energy trends in urban settings: results of a pan-european foresight exercise with 120 experts. technological forecasting and social change, 183, 121915. benedetti, a. c., costantino, c., gulli, r., & predari, g. (2022). the process of digitalization of the urban environment for the development of sustainable and circular cities: a case study of bologna, italy. sustainability, 14(21), 13740. bibri se and krogstie j (2017) smart sustainable cities of the future: an extensive interdisciplinary literature review. sustainable cities and society 31. elsevier b.v.: 183–212. doi: 10.1016/j.scs.2017.02.016. brzica, d. (2023). urban transformation: environmental issues, wicked problems, and transport development in the context of a circular economy. european journal of social impact and circular economy, 4(1), 19-26. caragliu a, del bo c and nijkamp p (2011). smart cities in europe. journal of urban technology 18: 65–82. couclelis h (2004). the construction of the digital city. environment and planning b: planning and design 31(1): 5–19. doi: 10.1068/b1299. christensen tb (2021).towards a circular economy in cities: exploring local modes of governance in the transition towards a circular economy in construction and textile recycling. journal of cleaner production 305. elsevier ltd: 1–12. doi: 10.1016/j.jclepro.2021.127058. dagilienė l, varaniūtė v and bruneckienė j (2021) local governments’ perspective on implementing the circular economy: a framework for future solutions. journal of cleaner production 310. doi: 10.1016/j.jclepro.2021.127340. datta a (2015) new urban utopias of postcolonial india: ‘entrepreneurial urbanization’ in dholera smart city. dialogues in human geography 5(1): 3–22. dincă g, milan aa, andronic ml, et al. (2022) does circular economy contribute to smart cities’ sustainable development? international journal of environmental research and public health 19(13). doi: 10.3390/ijerph19137627. ellen macarthur foundation, circular cities: thriving, liveable, resilient (retrieved from https://ellenmacarthurfoundation.org/topics/cities/overview). ellen macarthur foundation, cities and circular economy for food (2019) (retrieved from https://ellenmacarthurfoundation.org/cities-and-a-circular-economy-for-food/overview). eurocities (2020): time to empower europe’s cities: eurocities position on the new leipzig charter. february 2020. european commission, sustainable urban development, retrieved from https://ec.europa.eu/regional_policy/policy/themes/urban-development_en evans, j., karvonen, a., luque-ayala, a., martin, c., mccormick, k., raven, r., & palgan, y. v. (2019). smart and sustainable cities? pipedreams, practicalities and possibilities. local environment, 24(7), 557-564. doi: 10.1080/13549839.2019.1624701. fattibene, d., recanati, f., dembska, k., & antonelli, m. (2020). urban food waste: a framework to analyse policies and initiatives. resources, 9(9), 99. ghisellini, p., cialani, c., & ulgiati, s. (2016). a review on circular economy: the expected transition to a balanced interplay of environmental and economic systems. journal of cleaner production, 114, 11–32. doi:10.1016/j.jclepro.2015.09.007. ghisellini, p., passaro, r., ulgiati, s. (2023). perspectives on socially and environmentally just circular cities: the case of naples (italy). in: arsenyeva, o., romanova, t., sukhonos, m., tsegelnyk, y. (eds) smart technologies in urban engineering. stue 2022. lecture notes in networks and systems, vol 536. springer, cham. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3031-20141-7_56. guenduez, a. a., & mergel, i. (2022). the role of dynamic managerial capabilities and organizational readiness in smart city transformation. cities, 129, 103791. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7691 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 16 haarstad h. (2017). constructing the sustainable city: examining the role of sustainability in the ‘smart city’ discourse. journal of environmental policy and planning 19(4). taylor & francis: 423–437. doi: 10.1080/1523908x.2016.1245610. hepworth me (1990). planning for the information city: the challenge and response. urban studies 27(4), 537–558. komninos, n., & mora, l. (2018). exploring the big picture of smart city research. scienze regionali, 17(1), 15-38. lewandowski m (2016) designing the business models for circular economy – towards the conceptual framework. sustainability, 8(1) 43. doi: 10.3390/su8010043. lizzi, r. & righettini, m.s. (2022). collaborative governance in italian urban food policies: towards an analytical framework for differentiated governance arrangements, rivista italiana di politiche pubbliche, issue 3, 301-318 (open access at https://www.rivisteweb.it/issn/1722-1137/issue/8586). mahizhnan a (1999). smart cities. the singapore case. cities 16(1): 13–18. doi: 10.1201/9781351228480. martin cj, evans j and karvonen a (2018) smart and sustainable? five tensions in the visions and practices of the smartsustainable city in europe and north america. technological forecasting and social change 133(july 2016). elsevier: 269– 278. doi: 10.1016/j.techfore.2018.01.005. meijer, a., & bolívar, m. p. r. (2016). governing the smart city: a review of the literature on smart urban governance. international review of administrative sciences, 82(2), 392-408. morgan, d. l. (1996). focus groups as qualitative research (vol. 16). sage publications. nicolas, c., kim, j., & chi, s. (2020). quantifying the dynamic effects of smart city development enablers using structural equation modeling. sustainable cities and society, 53, 101916. paiho, s., mäki, e., wessberg, n., paavola, m., tuominen, p., antikainen, m., & jung, n. (2020). towards circular cities— conceptualizing core aspects. sustainable cities and society, 59, 102143. piontek, f. m., herrmann, c., & saraev, a. (2021). steps from zero carbon supply chains and demand of circular economy to circular business cases. european journal of social impact and circular economy, 2(2), 1-9. powell, r. a., & single, h. m. (1996). focus groups. international journal for quality in health care, 8(5), 499-504. prendeville, s., cherim, e., & bocken, n. (2018). circular cities: mapping six cities in transition. environmental innovation and societal transitions, 26, 171-194. przeybilovicz, e., cunha, m. a., geertman, s., leleux, c., michels, a., tomor, z., & meijer, a. (2022). citizen participation in the smart city: findings from an international comparative study. local government studies, 48(1), 23-47. united nations (2014) world urbanisation pros-pects report. new york: united nations. vanhuyse f, haddaway nr and henrysson m (2021) circular cities: an evidence map of research between 2010 and 2020. discover sustainability 2(1). springer international publishing. doi: 10.1007/s43621-021-00059-2. vola, p., cantino, g., & gelmini, l. (2023). micro-level measurement of the circularity of organizations: the italian innovative standardized approach applied to a public sector case study. european journal of social impact and circular economy, 4(1), 1-18. wasserbaur r., sakao t. and milios l. (2022). interactions of governmental policies and business models for a circular economy: a systematic literature review. journal of cleaner production 337(december 2021). elsevier ltd: 130329. doi: 10.1016/j.jclepro.2021.130329. webster, c. w. r., & leleux, c. (2018). smart governance: opportunities for technologically mediated citizen coproduction. information polity, 23(1), 95-110. wilkerson, l. (1996) ‘tutors and small groups in problem-based learning: lessons from the literature’, new directions for teaching and learning 68: 23–32. williams j. (2021). circular cities. a revolution in urban sustainability. new york: routledge. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/10098 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 1 a bibliometric analysis of circular economy: policy implications for sustainability in sub-saharan africa francis mwaijande mzumbe university, dar es salaam campus college, department of social science and humanities, p. o. box 20266, dar es salaam, tanzania email: mwaijandef@gmail.com orcid 0000 000253290932 received: 21/03/2024 accepted for publication: 09/04/2024 published: 30/04/2024 abstract this study aims to identify and map out circular economy in scientific literature in the global and africa context. the circular economy has been adopted mostly in industrial production systems in the developed economies, its application in africa is limited mostly to environment sector. a paucity of scholarly research and scientific publications on ce instigated the need to map out circular economy for sustainable development africa. this article provides an overview of scientific publications on circular economy built in africa through the scopus database. the study used bibliometric analysis based on data obtained from scopus database highlighting scientific literature. the analysis obtained 414 publications from 2005 to 2024. it provides descriptive and analytical graphs and bibliographic maps generated in r-studio software. findings shows main scientific and scholars are in european and chinese universities with scanty publications in africa. these findings signal the inadequacy of scientific research to inform policies on circular economy in africa. it calls for future demand for more research and scientific publication on circular economy linked to sustainability in africa. keywords: circular, economy, social life cycle assessment, sustainability, africa, policy european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/10098 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 2 1. introduction the genesis of the circular economy (ce) can be traced in 1976 with the batelle institute geneva scholars who produced a report titled “the potential for substituting manpower for energy” for the directorate-general for labour and social affairs of the european union. the essence of ce as a development framework for long-term sustainability and for supporting of growing economies (dominko et al., 2023; schaubroeck et al., 2021; yu et al., 2022). the ce is widely discussed using three basic elements of an economic system; resource suppliers, waste assimilators and sources of utility that advocate for cyclical use of resources for the creation, supply and use of products generated for companies (luis & celma, 2020; schaubroeck et al., 2021). built on ce principle of reducing waste, use of waste and recycling materials (ogunmakinde et al., 2022; ogutu et al., 2023; schaubroeck et al., 2021), the ce is gaining keen interest among researchers, government policy makers, and organizations as an alternative to the linear economy for promoting sustainability because it provides solutions to ecological and socio-economic challenges resulting from increasing consumption of non-renewable resources, waste generation, pollution and resource scarcity (goyal et al., 2021). the circular economy as an emerging production development model is important for developing economic because it promises sustainable jobs and rational use of resources with environmental, and economic benefits. ce focuses on circularity, reusing and replacing the resources (luthin et al., 2024). the ce is about decoupling economic activities based on the intake of limited resources and scheming waste out from the system (gedam et al., 2021; morales & belmonte-urena, 2021). the circular economy explores new productive and economic systems that allow for the creation of production systems while saving resources. it has attracted scholarly work and businesses because it operationizes the implementation of sustainable development (kirchherr et al., 2017; ogunmakinde et al., 2022). however, there is inadequate evidence in scholarly literature of circular economy for sustainability in the sub-saharan africa. 2. theoretical background the concept of circular (ce) economy as a strategy for moving towards sustainability in the european union is well articulated in the european circular economy action plan as a blueprint policy for boosting green jobs, growth, and investment for promoting the transition to a carbon-neutral, resource efficiency. in the context of africa, the african union (au) agenda 2063 is the africa’s development framework for transforming the continent encompasses inclusive and sustainable development. the au launched the african circular economy alliance in 2016 as development strategy (ogunmakinde et al., 2022). by 2022, ce has expanded to more than 20 african countries because recycling is a solution to the growing environmental pollution caused by plastics, metals and glass to mitigate the environmental effects. while linear economy production system takes end-of-life products as waste, circular economy perceives end-of-life products as resources (gedam et al., 2021), ce has elevated important development strategy that considers sustainability. for this need, circular economy inspired by the world trade center calling for public and private industries to adopt it with the potential to support green job creation as an approach to economic growth that is in line with sustainable environmental and economic development (dunmade, 2021). circular economy promotes efficient use of resource materials and energy while also european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/10098 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 3 decreasing environmental pollution (andersen et al., 2022; furness et al., 2021; yu et al., 2022). due to its socio-economic and environmental importance ce is gaining high acceptance of novel strategy of sustainable development. understanding the life cycle of ce is crucial to achieving the sdg 12 that calls on achieving economic growth and sustainable development requires reducing ecological footprint by changing the way we produce and consume goods and resources. lca has been used for decision making applications in circular economy perspectives as a standardized tool by the international organization of standardization with the guidelines ‘iso 14040–44: 2006 life cycle assessment’ and ‘iso 14045: 2012 eco-efficiency’, where “eco-efficiency” considers some economic aspects for calculating impacts of products (furness et al., 2021). it is a fact that ce has also become an important field of sustainability, policy makers and academic research with increasing number of publications in scientific journals covering environmental and economic aspects (geissdoerfer et al., 2017), with less emphasis on social benefits of ce. it is urged in the academic research that ce focuses on technological solutions to economic problems. it is these premises that ce boost economy while protecting the environment. circular economy is therefore a promising sustainable development strategy to overcome greenhouse gas emissions in african economies where emissions are projected to increase by more than 2.5 times by 2050 driven by large transformations in urbanization, industrialization, mineral extraction and electrification (racki et al., 2014). much research has been done and scholarly articles written on ce with potential environmental and economic impact; whereby the environmental benefits include waste diversion and emission reduction, reduced raw material use, reduced carbon and glasshouse gas emissions, and provides product regeneration (ogunmakinde et al., 2022). the operational benefits include product quality improvements, efficiency. however, the sustainability social dimensions in the ce are marginalized. the social impact dimensions include job creation, social equity, workers’ occupational health and safety, workers’ rights of association, which are the major pillars of social life cycle assessment (s-lca) studies (luthin et al., 2024). certainly the omission is due to methodological challenge for studying social assessment and its particularities and adaptations (reinales et al., 2020). the application of ce in africa is relevant for sustainable development of many sectors such as manufacturing industries, construction, agriculture, and extractive. for example, the extractive industry in africa is one of the major economic resources and production accounting between 4.6 – 86 percent contribution to gdp (nhabinde & heshmati, 2021). on the other hand, it accounts for about 50 percent of global ghg emissions a biodiversity loss owing to land use. promoting circular economy in the extractive industry contribute to environmental protection through recycling of water use in the minerals processing and protection of biodiversity. ce is linked to sustainable development because it focuses on industrial applications with both product-oriented, natural resources and services, practice to better understand the limitations that countries focus on strategic investments of the circular economy with different outcomes such as re-use applications and waste management. the circular economy takes into consideration of trade-offs between economic development and environmental protection, industrialization sustainability and environmental management. it also preserves the environment by reducing the consumption of natural resources and prevent depletion of resources by recycling (mhlanga et al., 2022; razmjooei et al., 2023). european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/10098 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 4 it is argued that circular economy as a new paradigm for economic development offers significant environmental and economic benefits. it replaces the notion of end-of-life in production and consumption practices through reusing and recycling products and materials in production, distribution and consumption value chain (berg et al., 2018). by so doing, ce complements the attainment of the 17 sustainable development goals (sdgs) and in particular the sdg-12 which aim to “ensure sustainable consumption and production patterns" with indicators on the number of national policy instrument to promote sustainable production systems and consumption patterns. as such, ce implement sdg 12 by promoting recycling of production materials for sustainable environmental protection. this article examines the scientific publications on ce that promote a balanced environment, economic and social dimensions for sustainable development approaches. scholars (andersen et al., 2022; dominko et al., 2023; gedam et al., 2021; valdivia et al., 2021) around the globe look at the ce production systems, economic structures, environment and sustainability. production systems could have significant impact on environment due to significant amount of energy and natural gas needed in production processes (gaidajis & kakanis, 2021). more often production and productivity as well as economic and environmental benefits are given more prominence to the expense of social sustainability. countries in the sub-saharan africa face challenges of keeping and managing sustainable economic productivity, be it in the manufacturing, extractive industry or agriculture. the concept of circular economy provides potential solutions for addressing socio-environmental-economic challenge (buda, 2022). whereas life cycle assessment (lca) analytical tools are used for identification and evaluation of potential environmental impacts related to products, production processes, and environmental impacts that derive from emissions, wastes, resource use, and energy consumption (finkbeiner et al., 2010); the impacts are categorized in the context of global warming potential (gwp), eutrophication, resource use, and others (gaidajis & kakanis, 2021), lca does not cover the social impact. by so doing, pillars of sustainable development, environment, economic (sala et al., 2016; sharma, 2017) which has less focus on the social dimensions. social life cycle assessment (s-lca) is a methodology to assess the social impacts of products and services across their life cycle (unep, 2009). it has becomes a useful framework for sustainability assessment of products and services (kalvani et al., 2021). s-lca include the social dimension to examine the subcategories related to impact on labor conditions, local community conditions, consumers’ well-being (manik et al., 2013; unep, 2009). social life cycle assessment therefore guides social impact evaluation on stakeholders throughout the life cycle of production and consumption. s-lca method contributes to the assessment of social externalities of products (tsalidis, 2022). it is argued that policymakers need to know where the social externalities of products occur in order to make informed decisions and therefore s-lca is a necessary method in supporting african policy makers and governments in transforming their economies into circular economy (tsalidis, 2022). the fundamental methodological boundaries of this study covers the relational processes on circular economy articles in scientific journals that considers social life cycle assessment (s-lca) in africa. while ce and s-lca are well studied globally, there seems to be less published in africa. however, there is insufficient publications and academic research to substantively provide evidence to inform policy decisions on the social benefits of ce. a bibliometric analysis is one of the credible methods to give a valuable reference focusing scientific publications (singh et al., 2021). european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/10098 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 5 3. methodology the study employs desk-top review as a technique of collecting data from secondary sources. the main objective of this paper is to highlight the intellectual structure of s-lca in circular economy (ce) in the context of sub-saharan africa continent following research questions. rq1: what is the intellectual structure of s-lca in circular economy in africa? rq2: what research strands are dominant in circular economy? rq3: what are dominant institutions on circular economy and s-lca in africa? 3.1 bibliometric analysis a bibliometric analysis is a research method that utilizes quantitative analysis and statistics to describe patterns of publications within a given topic, field, institute, or country in the social science citation index (ssci), science citation index (sci), world of science or scopus databases (chiu, 2005). a bibliometric analysis of ce social-life cycle assessment (s-lca) was therefore adopted as a methodology to identify, examine and shape the intellectual structure of circular economy in scientific literature in context of africa. the bibliometric is an adopted but different methodology from the traditional systematic literature review (de bakker, 2005). it is a developed method for investigating research from the subject of library and science knowledge. it grants the elaboration of network analysis, giving a clear image of the different links between various scientific studies, countries, authors, and keywords. additionally, it figures out the co-occurrence of keywords and an overview of the different themes’ evolution (van eck et al., 2014; sarkodie et al., 2020). a bibliometric is a set of statistical methods used to measure and analyze the quality and quantity of articles, books, and other publications on a specified area of study from scientific documentations obtained from databases. this method aims to contribute to a better understanding of the scientific research in bibliometric research which synthesize past and current research findings (büyükkidik, 2022). this research method makes an objective assessment of the scientific literature using a quantitative approach in systematic and reproducible literature review. this method provides light for future research in the relevant literature as it gives a retrospective view of the published literature that evaluates academic contributions in a focal field (guleria & kaur, 2021). although bibliometric analysis is used in many disciplines, there is little evidence on circular economy and social life cycle assessment 3.2 database bibliometric studies use appropriate databases for retrieving published scientific documents (ekundayo & okoh, 2018; furness et al., 2021). this study adopted bibliometric analysis after searching for data in scopus database as the appropriate database. this database has more than 23, 000 indexed journals in all scientific fields (rojas-sánchez et al., 2023). in addition, scopus database was preferred because it enables export of data to other programs more friendly as well as allowing search key terms in titles or titles/abstracts or name of the journal or name of the author or affiliation (furness et al., 2021). european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/10098 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 6 3.3 searching criteria. a boolean search technique was using search query that retrieved relevant published documents. the search query comprised of keywords: "circular" and "economy" and social and life and cycle and africa which brought 8 hits. whereas the search query of key words “circular” and “economy” and “social” and “life” and “cycle” and “assessment” brought on results of 414 hits. the search query inclusion criteria was publications in english language between 2005 -2024. 3.4 bibliometric data data collection for this study was done through scopus database retrieving information using a bibliometric technique from scientific publications over a specific period from 2015-2024. about 411 data were retrieved from scopus database from 2015 -2024 which were exported to microsoft excel. the exported data included annual growth of publications, types of documents, languages, countries, authors, institutions, journals, citations, and funding agencies. the retrieved were analyzed data for bibliometric indicators using rstudio v.4.3.3 software (2024-04-07) with bibliometrix r-package. data were then imported into rstudio and converted to a bibliographic data frame to create tables, figures and visualization maps as indicated in results and discussion section. the bibliometric method was useful for obtaining data on circular economy and social life cycle analysis or sustainability studies. the underlying theoretical frameworks include authorship, affiliation, country scientific production, citation, and co-citation. 4. results and discussion the performed data analysis show titles of articles and journals, authors and their affiliations, and publications that have a greater relevance on social life cycle assessment on circular economy literature. the results were studied using bibliometric graphics and maps and using rstudio software. a total of 414 from global datasets compared to 8 datasets obtained from africa on circular economy and social life cycle assessment. table 1. displays characteristics of the extracted information on the scientific studies based on the key research words. table 1: main information description results main information timespan 2005 – 2024 sources (journal, books, etc) 169 documents 414 annual growth rate % 20,76 document average age 2,76 average citation per doc 28,86 references 29.776 european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/10098 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 7 document contents keywords plus (id) 2.891 author’s keywords (de) 1.197 authors authors 1.537 authors of single-authored docs 30 authors collaboration single-authored docs 30 co-authors per doc 4,31 international co-authorships % 37,2 document types article 250 book 3 book chapter 28 conference paper 40 conference review 2 editorial 3 letter 1 note 1 review 82 short survey 4 source: author's elaboration fig. 1 shows annual scientific production of articles on ce began slowly in 2015 and gained momentum from 2016 to 2023. this is probably because there was more emphasis on the global sustainable development goal 8-9 that promote sustainable industrialization and economic growth, thus global and regional economic policies are geared towards sustainability. since circular economy is an emerging area, scholarly publications in the global literature started with low pace in 2005 and it reached the highest peak in 2023. the increase in scientific studies between 2015 to 2023 can be associated with the global emphasis on sustainability in production. our analysis shows that for a period between 20152023, most ce and s-lca publications were affiliated within european universities and china (fig. 2). this implies there is sufficient capacity for ce knowledge generation in the european and chinese universities. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/10098 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 8 figure 1: annual scientific production source: author's elaboration figure 2: most relevant institution affiliations source: author's elaboration european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/10098 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 9 however, it was observed other than european and chinese universities, very few publications are based on african ce and social life cycle assessment. this is because low research and scientific publications on s-lca on circular economy come from african universities fig. 3. figure 3: affiliations' production over time source: author's elaboration this implies that as more african countries adopts ce, more research funding and capacity will be required in the african universities for scientific publication on ce and life cycle assessment. it is important only a few of african countries have made publications on ce and social life cycle assessment area. the most affiliated african universities with scientific knowledge production over time on ce and s-lca in order of ranking are south africa, ghana, nigeria kenya, rwanda, tunisia, malawi, morocco, senegal, tanzania, algeria, zimbabwe and mali which have not network with scholars in the north figure 4 displays global corresponding author’s countries on ce and life cycle assessment (lca) with italy, the united kingdom, spain, china, germany and the us having more publications in scientific evidence on s-lca in circular economy. it is also important to note that, africa does not feature well in the ce global bibliometric analysis. however, south africa (fig.5) was observed with more multiple country publications on circular economy knowledge due to its importance for sustainability. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/10098 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 10 figure 4: corresponding global author's countries source: author's elaboration figure 5: corresponding african author's countries source: author's elaboration european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/10098 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 11 this paper shows an absence of north-south co-knowledge creation between african countries and the north (fig.6). this throws a challenge and a waking call for african scholars to take interest and initiatives to network with the north publishers on this area for the african universities in particular to increase number of publications. figure 6: north-north vs north-south co-creation source: author's elaboration while bibliometric maps shows european countries with most authors who have identified s-lca in circular economy publications over time from 2005 to 2024. clusters by document coupling establishes relationship between documents with common work in bibliometric analysis (martinho & mourão, 2020). this is an indication of co-existence between ce and slca for sustainability assessment. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/10098 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 12 figure 7: ce clusters by document coupling source: author's elaboration figure 7 indicates waste management (56.1%), life cycle (33.8%) and circular economy (29.6%) intersects with higher centrality. whereas publications on life cycle (31.9%), sustainable development (40%) and circular economy (36.8%) are given high impact and centrality, thus it is important for the global, regional as well as national policies to develop and implement circular economies that considers the three sustainability pillars at hand. the paper illustrates the dendogram research strands including life cycle assessment, global warming, sustainable development, sustainability assessment, energy efficiency which all have positive or negative impact on stakeholders. fig. 8 displays the dominant research strands for sustainability assessment including environmental, economic and social aspects for sustainability of major sectors such as construction industry, energy, industries, etc. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/10098 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 13 figure 8: dendogram research strands source: author's elaboration it is equally important to note that bibliometric analysis is a useful research methodology for studying relational and coexistence of knowledge such as circular economy and social life cycle analysis, which have not taken the attention of african scholars and researchers. this finding has relevance for increasing co-knowledge creation and collaborations between south and north and or south-south scholars. on the other hand, it is worth noting the high concentration of publications in the european union as chinese universities. the bibliometric analysis has also shown implication that circular economy and slca are relatively new in african perspectives as they are still emerging areas. universities and research and development institutions ought to engage to publish on these researchable topics in the established research strands. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/10098 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 14 figure 9: dendogram research strands source: author's elaboration european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/10098 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 15 furthermore, the bibliometric analysis in this article shows that circular economy and social life cycle analysis have not taken the attention of african scholars and researchers. this finding has relevance for increasing co-knowledge creation and collaborations between south and north and or south-south scholars. this study implies that circular economy and s-lca are relatively new in african perspectives as they are still emerging areas. universities and research and development institutions ought to engage to publish on these researchable topics. 5. conclusion and policy implications the study results illustrate that ce assures not only the environment and economic sustainability but also social well-fare of actors in the value chain. this study observed paucity of s-lca literature on circular economy in scientific journals. following the limited publication, this study recommends for increasing articles of s-lca on circular economy in the sub-saharan africa (ssa), where industrialization is taking pace, environmental and economic concerns are of priority of academic and policy makers. countries in the ssa face challenges of keeping and managing sustainable economic productivity, be it in the manufacturing, extractive industry or agriculture. the concept of circular economy provides potential solutions for addressing the multidimensional socio-environmental-economic challenge. the article contributes to both academic research and policy actions for undertaking the circular economy for the sustainable development in the sub-saharan africa. the increasing environmental and production ecosystems challenges call for policies that are promoting sustainable economic development, where production systems do not compromise with the current and economic growth of future generations. scientists find new ways of production systems that make our ecological footprint compatible with global sustainability. the concept of the circular economy has brought relevant contributions to global sustainable development. the african researchers and scholars need to co-create knowledge and publications within the south-north as well as south-south collaborations. this paper contributes to knowledge in many ways. first, by providing a bibliometric map of the ce publications and research in africa, where we found none despite of the growing ce compared to european countries, asia and latin america. this is a challenge to african scientists and scholars to increase research and publication on ce, sustainability and social life cycle assessment. our findings suggest that despite the increasing importance of circular economy in africa and the theoretical progress in scientific literature of sustainability and social life cycle assessment, african scholars have not penetrated into the literature. as ce scholars accept the role of sustainability, governments and companies dealing with ce must uphold the pillars of sustainability. while collaborative publications between south-south scholars and researchers is encouraged for the promoting implementation of ce practices, african scholars ought to take lead to inform policy decision making on ce and sustainability. the role of researchers is to generate scientific evidence to policy makers. this include the social life cycle assessment of ce long-term policies as well as the development of circular economy development framework. since there is paucity of scientific research european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/10098 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 16 and publication of ce and s-lca in africa, it is recommended for having co-knowledge creation between governments and academia whereby, the role of academia is to identify policies linked to a specific ce projects and conduct analysis for understanding and realizing providing informed solutions and recommendations to policy makers and implementation of sustainability policies tackling environmental challenges. conflict of interest i declare of not having any potential conflict of interest in the process from manuscript to publishing of this article. acknowledgements this paper benefited from funding provided by the german federal ministry of education and research to implement a capacity building for technology transfer in at mzumbe university in tanzania in partnership with rwtch aachen university, germany. we thank institute of sustainability in civil engineering, rwth university for the knowledge and technology transfer that has contributed to the advancement of sustainability assessment methodology. references andersen, s. c., birgisdottir, h., & birkved, m. (2022). life cycle assessments of circular economy in the built environment—a scoping review. sustainability (switzerland), 14(11). https://doi.org/10.3390/su14116887 berg, a., antikainen, r., hartikainen, e., kauppi, s., kautto, p., lazarevic, d., piesik, s., & saikku, l. (2018). reports of the finnish environment institute -circular economy for sustainable development. reports of the finnish environment institute, 26, 24. https://helda.helsinki.fi/handle/10138/251516%0ahttp://hdl.handle.net/10138/251516 buda, g. (2022). seven businesses using principles of circular economy in sub-saharan africa: results of field research in uganda. afrika tanulmányok / hungarian journal of african studies, 16(1), 5–20. https://doi.org/10.15170/at.2022.16.1.1 büyükkidik, s. (2022). a bibliometric analysis: a tutorial for the bibliometrix package in r using irt literature. journal of measurement and evaluation in education and psychology, 13(3), 164–193. https://doi.org/10.21031/epod.1069307 chiu, w.-t. (2005). bibliometric analysis of homeopathy research during the period of 1991 to 2003. 63(1), 3–23. dominko, m., primc, k., slabe-erker, r., & kalar, b. (2023). a bibliometric analysis of circular economy in the fields of business and economics: towards more action-oriented research. in environment, development and sustainability (vol. 25, issue 7). springer netherlands. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10668-022-02347-x dunmade, i. (2021). journal of popular education in africa : issn 2523-2800 ( online ) journal of popular education in africa : issn 2523-2800 ( online ). 5(10), 53–60. ekundayo, t. c., & okoh, a. i. (2018). a global bibliometric analysis of plesiomonas-related research (1990 – 2017). plos one, 13(11), 1–17. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0207655 european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/10098 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 17 finkbeiner, m., schau, e. m., lehmann, a., & traverso, m. (2010). towards life cycle sustainability assessment. 3309– 3322. https://doi.org/10.3390/su2103309 furness, m., bello-mendoza, r., dassonvalle, j., & chamy-maggi, r. (2021). building the ‘bio-factory’: a bibliometric analysis of circular economies and life cycle sustainability assessment in wastewater treatment. journal of cleaner production, 323(september), 129127. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2021.129127 gaidajis, g., & kakanis, i. (2021). life cycle assessment of nitrate and compound fertilizers production — a case study. gedam, v. v., raut, r. d., lopes de sousa jabbour, a. b., tanksale, a. n., & narkhede, b. e. (2021). circular economy practices in a developing economy: barriers to be defeated. journal of cleaner production, 311(april), 127670. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2021.127670 geissdoerfer, m., savaget, p., bocken, n. m. p., & hultink, e. j. (2017). the circular economy – a new sustainability paradigm? journal of cleaner production, 143(0), 757–768. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2016.12.048 goyal, s., chauhan, s., & mishra, p. (2021). circular economy research: a bibliometric analysis (2000–2019) and future research insights. journal of cleaner production, 287, 125011. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2020.125011 guleria, d., & kaur, g. (2021). bibliometric analysis of ecopreneurship using vosviewer and rstudio bibliometrix, 1989– 2019. library hi tech, 39(4), 1001–1024. https://doi.org/10.1108/lht-09-2020-0218 kalvani, s. r., sharaai, a. h., & abdullahi, i. k. (2021). social consideration in product life cycle for product social sustainability. sustainability (switzerland), 13(20). https://doi.org/10.3390/su132011292 kirchherr, j., reike, d., & hekkert, m. (2017). conceptualizing the circular economy: an analysis of 114 definitions. resources, conservation and recycling, 127(april), 221–232. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.resconrec.2017.09.005 luis, e. c., & celma, d. (2020). circular economy. a review and bibliometric analysis. sustainability (switzerland), 12(16). https://doi.org/10.3390/su12166381 luthin, a., traverso, m., & crawford, r. h. (2024). circular life cycle sustainability assessment: an integrated framework. journal of industrial ecology, 28(1), 41–58. https://doi.org/10.1111/jiec.13446 manik, y., leahy, j., & halog, a. (2013). social life cycle assessment of palm oil biodiesel: a case study in jambi province of indonesia. international journal of life cycle assessment, 18(7), 1386–1392. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11367-0130581-5 martinho, v. d., & mourão, p. r. (2020). circular economy and economic development in the european union: a review and bibliometric analysis. sustainability (switzerland), 12(18). https://doi.org/10.3390/su12187767 mhlanga, j., haupt, t. c., & loggia, c. (2022). shaping circular economy in the built environment in africa. a bibliometric analysis. journal of engineering, design and technology. https://doi.org/10.1108/jedt-03-2022-0175 morales, m. e., & belmonte-urena, l. j. (2021). theoretical research on circular economy and sustainability trade-offs and synergies: a bibliometric analysis. 2021 ieee international conference on technology and entrepreneurship, icte 2021. https://doi.org/10.1109/icte51655.2021.9584537 nhabinde, s., & heshmati, a. (2021). the extractive industry’s impact on economic growth in sadc countries. ssrn european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/10098 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 18 electronic journal, 13586. https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.3674307 ogunmakinde, o. e., egbelakin, t., & sher, w. (2022). circular economy in africa’s built environment: a conceptual bibliometric analysis. iop conference series: earth and environmental science, 1101(6). https://doi.org/10.1088/1755-1315/1101/6/062016 ogutu, m. o., akor, j., mulindwa, m. s., heshima, o., & nsengimana, c. (2023). implementing circular economy and sustainability policies in rwanda: experiences of rwandan manufacturers with the plastic ban policy. frontiers in sustainability, 4. https://doi.org/10.3389/frsus.2023.1092107 racki, j., patel, p., & degroot, d. (2014). africa 2050: urbanization. global journal of emerging market economies, 6(1), 15–34. https://doi.org/10.1177/0974910113511191 razmjooei, d., alimohammadlou, m., ranaei kordshouli, h. a., & askarifar, k. (2023). a bibliometric analysis of the literature on circular economy and sustainability in maritime studies. environment, development and sustainability, 0123456789. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10668-023-02942-6 reinales, d., zambrana-vasquez, d., & saez-de-guinoa, a. (2020). social life cycle assessment of product value chains under a circular economy approach: a case study in the plastic packaging sector. sustainability (switzerland), 12(16). https://doi.org/10.3390/su12166671 rojas-sánchez, m. a., palos-sánchez, p. r., & folgado-fernández, j. a. (2023). systematic literature review and bibliometric analysis on virtual reality and education. in education and information technologies (vol. 28, issue 1). springer us. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10639-022-11167-5 sala, s., reale, f., cristóbal-garcía, j., marelli, l., & rana, p. (2016). life cycle assessment for the impact assessment of policies. life thinking and assessment in the european policies and for evaluating policy options. in joint research centre (vol. 28380). https://doi.org/10.2788/318544 schaubroeck, t., gibon, t., igos, e., & benetto, e. (2021). sustainability assessment of circular economy over time: modelling of finite and variable loops & impact distribution among related products. resources, conservation and recycling, 168(november 2020), 105319. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.resconrec.2020.105319 sharma, p. (2017). a study on life cycle assessment. international journal of engineering and advanced technology (ijeat), january 2019, 0–5. singh, s., trivedi, b., dasgupta, m. s., & routroy, s. (2021). a bibliometric analysis of circular economy concept in ewaste research during the period 2008-2020. materials today: proceedings, 46, 8519–8524. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.matpr.2021.03.525 tsalidis, g. a. (2022). type i social life cycle assessments: methodological challenges in the study of a plant in the context of circular economy. sustainability (switzerland), 14(22). https://doi.org/10.3390/su142215031 unep. (2009). guidelines for social life cycle assessment of products. management, 15(2), 104. http://www.unep.fr/shared/publications/pdf/dtix1164xpa-guidelines_slca.pdf valdivia, s., backes, j. g., traverso, m., sonnemann, g., cucurachi, s., guinée, j. b., schaubroeck, t., finkbeiner, m., european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/10098 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 19 leroy-parmentier, n., ugaya, c., peña, c., zamagni, a., inaba, a., amaral, m., berger, m., dvarioniene, j., vakhitova, t., benoit-norris, c., prox, m., … goedkoop, m. (2021). principles for the application of life cycle sustainability assessment. international journal of life cycle assessment, 26(9), 1900–1905. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11367-021-01958-2 yu, z., khan, s. a. r., & umar, m. (2022). circular economy practices and industry 4.0 technologies: a strategic move of automobile industry. business strategy and the environment, 31(3), 796–809. https://doi.org/10.1002/bse.2918 european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7040 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 19 urban transformation: environmental issues, wicked problems, and transport development in the context of circular economy daneš brzica1* 1 contact author institute of economic research, slovak academy of sciences, šancová 56, 81105 bratislava (slovakia) danes.brzica@gmail.com received: 16/09/2022 accepted for publication: 10/02/2023 published: 21/04/2023 abstract the paper brings some perspectives on new challenges for the synergy of urban transformation, environmental issues and transport development in the circular economy (ce) context. considering that the number of studies on the given topics only pays attention to some selected areas, we bring a more comprehensive view of the current challenges for cities. the growing size of cities and population density are putting pressure on urban transport systems. as a result of the increasing intensity of traffic and economic activity, there is an increase in emissions in cities. making decisions about changes in the city becomes more complex. the paper indicates the nature of “wicked” problems and obstacles in implementing the ce model in the context of sustainable transport/mobility development in big cities. it also demonstrates the situation in selected european cities regarding pollution and transport performance indicators. while the traditional city policy approach is predominantly based on the need to maintain the status quo and the reality of the city´s functioning is perceived as a routine matter, new approaches should work with challenges as opportunities for change towards greater efficiency and environmental sustainability and take into account new approaches to the governance of cities. one of the possible directions of urban development is using the ce in the context of the strategy of cities in the transport field. this could improve the situation within the goals of sdg 11. solutions based on traditional approaches can cause disorders in the functioning of big cities, weaken their resilience and thus threaten their further development. in the future, the city leaders and other stakeholders will have to reevaluate traditional approaches to city governance in this area, as it can be assumed that an increasing number of "wicked" challenges will arise, which will need to be quickly/effectively resolved about the justified needs of city residents. keywords: governance; transport; cities; “wicked” problems; emissions; un sdg 11 goals, circular economy 1. introduction considering that the number of studies on the given topics only pays attention to some selected areas, we bring a more comprehensive view of the current challenges for cities. the growing size of cities and population density are putting pressure on urban transport systems. as a result of the increasing intensity of traffic and economic activity, there is an increase in emissions in cities. making decisions about changes in the city becomes more complex. the paper brings some perspectives on new challenges for the synergy of urban transformation, environmental issues and transport development in european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7040 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 20 the circular economy (ce) context. this involves overcoming many barriers. the present study viewed that (1) cities will represent residences for an ever-increasing share of the world's population; (2) urban transport will require the fulfilment of many conditions regarding the ecological sustainability of the urban environment, and (3) ce has the potential to contribute to solving new “wicked” challenges. “cities generate a significant share of global gdp, consume significant energy resources and generate substantial volumes of waste and emissions. urban areas are home to over 75% of the eu’s population: creating around 70% of jobs and generating over 85% of the eu’s gdp. cities, responsible for about 80% of energy use, are essential for europe’s transformation to a climate neutral continent by 2050, as set out in the european green deal” (eurocoties, 2020). air pollution has escalated to hazardous levels in many cities. with the growth of a modern industrial sector and car ownership, but without enforceable pollution and vehicle emissions regulations, various toxic chemicals are released into the atmosphere in large cities (knox and mccarthy, 2012). among monitored pollutants belong not only particulate matter (pm10 and pm2.5), but also nitrogen oxides (nox), sulphur dioxide (so2), carbon monoxide (co), total organic carbon (toc), hydrogen chloride (hcl), and total dust (epa, 2020). the main obstacles to the development of transport in cities include economic, technical, organizational, environmental, informational, regulatory, infrastructural, and personnel. for example, in recent history, citi bank´s 100 bn usd environmental finance goal was one of the initiatives in its sustainable progress strategy. the strategy was organized into three pillars, and investment areas included renewable energy, green bonds, energy efficiency projects and green buildings, also sustainable transportation. citi bank´s share of environmental financing activities totalled 41.2 bn usd from 2014 through 2016 (hoek, 2014). sustainable transport is a significant component of sustainable urban development, and it seems that the ce can help address these challenges in this context. however, implementing changes – including support for the ce and the transport sector – may be threatened or slowed down by the nature of decision-making processes in complex entities such as large cities. the interests of various interest groups (stakeholders) are concentrated in large cities. advocacy of these often conflicting or significantly different interests can slow down or completely stop decision-making processes. wicked problems are specific forms of decision-making problems in complex entities. this paper aims to indicate the nature of “wicked” problems and obstacles in implementing the ce model in the context of transport/mobility development in big cities. it also demonstrates the situation in selected european cities regarding pollution and transport performance indicators. 2. literature review there is a wealth of literature related to the areas discussed here. this group includes works focused on (a) circular economy – e.g., com (2015, 2018, 2019), korhonen, honkasalo and seppälä (2018), kautto and lazarevic (2020), milios (2017), bocken, de pauw, bakker and van der grinten (2016), kirchherr, reike and hekkert (2017), nylén and salminen (2019), ghisellini, cialani and ulgiati (2016) and com (2015, 2018, 2019), but also works oriented (b) to wicked problems – e.g., head (2022). ghisellini et al. (2016) provide a very detailed overview of ce. for example, studies by korhonen, honkasalo and seppälä (2018) and kirchherr, reike and hekkert (2017) also deal with conceptual matters. works focused on air pollution include, for example, epa (2020). hong et al. (2014) discussed challenges and opportunities for developing sustainable transportation systems (stss) – in this case, for beijing's capital. johansson et al. (2016) discussed issues related to the paradigm shift from mobility to sustainable accessibility. however, only a few are simultaneously devoted to urban transformation, environmental issues, and transport development in the circular economy (ce) context. nylén and salminen (2019), for example, deal with how the circular economy discourse affects policymaking. a circular economy perspective embraces a systemic notion that things are designed to be reused as long as possible and then recaptured and repurposed when reuse is no longer possible (bals, tate and ellram (2022). in terms of methodology, the cra (constructed regional advantage) approach mentioned in the work asheim et al. (2006), “wicked” problems approach in public policy (head, 2022, 2008) and mlg approach (multi-level governance) mentioned in the work brzica et al. (2014) were used. moser et al. (2012) and head (2008) provide good insight into “wicked problems” issues. one of the documents (eurocities, 2022) suggests that “additional efforts are needed by the commission and member states to enhance the quality of emission estimation methods and to maintain their quality, especially for important and ever-present source sectors, like road transport (e.g., the hbefa emission factor database)”. other works cover the area of (c) smart and sustainable cities – e.g., james evans et al. (2019), kenworthy, j. (2006), haarstad (2017), pereira et al. (2017), tsun lai and cole (2022), guenduez and mergel (2022), angelidou et al. (2022), and przeybilovicz et al. (2022). hikman and banister (2014) seeks to develop achievable and low transport co2 emission futures in a range of international case studies, including in london, delhi, and auckland. the aim of european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7040 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 21 their book is that the developed scenarios and the consideration of implementation and governance issues can help city management plan for and achieve attractive future travel behaviors at the city level. the work of johansson et al. (2016) deals with the issue of transport and co-conceptual approaches. the authors note new methods in the shift from mobility to sustainable accessibility. according to them, to reach the climate objectives, there is a need for technical solutions in energyefficient vehicles dependent on electricity and replacing fossil fuels with biofuels. these solutions, however, are – according to them not enough. they also need to change direction in planning and developing society and infrastructure. 3. methodology the article is based on a methodological approach based on several steps: decomposition of the functioning system of large cities in terms of four investigated elements (traffic, pollution, ce and wicked problems). other studies, which are focused on only some of the problems discussed here, mostly used a combination of quantitative data analysis and case studies. some studies examine specific cities and towns (case studies) or segments (transport, air pollution). some other studies deal with methodological issues and concepts (wicked problems, reflexivity, resilience, multilevel governance). when it comes to wicked problems, analyzing systemic issues is often applied. this research paper uses a set of methods. methods, concepts and approaches such as qualitative/quantitative data analysis, participatory design, ideal-type transition pathway concept, multi-level governance concept, stakeholder-agency theory, holistic approach, constructed regional advantage concept and causal explanation are used. causal explanation represents a partially useful approach in specific situations. however, various factors in rather complex entities as cities are often operate simultaneously to produce an observed effect. we tried to maintain internal validity i.e., preventing the occurrence of sample selection bias (for cities) and information bias. wicked problems have been identified in literature across various disciplines and policy domains (e.g., business, cybernetics, ecology, agriculture, urban design, energy, transportation, health, socio-economic sciences and political, administrative sciences) (head, 2022). like kenworthy (2006), this paper provides critical responses to the challenge of changing the nature of urban development to a more ecological and sustainable model. 4. results 4.1 transport in big cities, “wicked” problems and circular economy urgency and the changing nature of the challenges are the basic parameters that characterize the current situation from the point of view of the management and governance of big cities. in this section, certain views on some important issues are presented. two important aspects can be seen from the perspective of the traditional approach to the current challenges in the transport field. the (1) aspect is underestimating the importance/scope of these challenges, and (2) underestimating the nature of these challenges. however, both of them are crucial for timely and adequate solutions. in the traditional understanding, challenges are a problem that often needs to be solved according to the intensity with which it manifests themselves. such an approach is not always suitable, especially because phenomena do not take place linearly in a complex world, and large-scale changes on the input side do not always bring large effects and vice versa. in addition, waiting for a situation where major positive/negative breakthroughs appear (e.g., an increase in pollution, traffic jams, new efficient solution) can mean that the situation is difficult to manage or requires much higher costs. several models exist steady growth economy, de-growth, ce or sharing economy. these alternative ecological models challenge the economic growth model, encourage sustainable resource use, reduce waste, reuse and recycle, and nudge sustainable consumption models (babacan, 2022). there is currently a wave of interest in transforming cities in the transport field about achieving a quality environment and safe transport network. new specifics characterizing the urban environment in terms of management and governance include, among others (oecd, 2006): • uncertainty; • specialization; • a number of actors; • interdependence; • multi-level decision-making; • time perspective, and political cycle. the ce in cities may assist in handling transport-related challenges (waste, lack of spare parts). cities may assist in designing/supporting measures designed and optimized for reuse and re-construct. they may support set of policies easing nature-friendly and sustainable modes of sharing various transport means (not only person-to-person but also b2b) thus reducing resources needed to meet the needs of cities. kautto and lazarevic (2020) point out that in connection with the circular economy, a significant challenge is “ …the development and implementation of policies and regulatory instruments for accelerating the closing of material loops and phasing out unstainable systems and practices. currently, numerous policy instruments have been adopted to promote more sustainable resource use. however, these are often scattered, weak and disproportionately divided along economic sectors. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7040 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 22 thus, carefully prepared, consistent, coherent and credible policy mixes are needed.” to realize this plan, however, it is necessary to cope with the very diverse structure of the number of actors and their interests at the level of urban systems. this diverse structure of actors and interests presents wicked problems. kautto and lazarevic also note the problem of reflexivity. according to them “the reflexivity failure is caused by the current lack of ability to monitor, anticipate and involve actors in processes of self-governance …. and to implement adaptive policy portfolios that can deal with uncertainty. due to the longterm nature of transformational change, inherent uncertainties of innovation, and knowledge gaps, change requires continuous monitoring of the goals, and reflection on the direction of change.” the following chart 1 shows a model of a modern view of contemporary challenges. in the case of this model, examples of the possible perception of the urgency of the solution and the nature of the challenges by top management are given. of course, these are only fictitious values intended to document the possible range of problems. figure 1: model view of current challenges notes: (1) negative values show a low degree of urgency of the need for a solution (2) positive values show a high degree of urgency of the need for a solution (3) the combination of colors indicating normal situations and "wicked" problems shows the expected ratio between the two components source: author´s elaboration 4.2 performance of transport network and its impact on city environment the ce package, adopted by the european parliament in 2018, sets new target level for the recycling of municipal waste (65% by 2035). while the traditional city policy approach is based on the need to maintain the status quo and the reality of city´s functioning is perceived as a routine matter, new approaches should work with challenges as opportunities for change in the direction of greater efficiency and environmental sustainability and take into account new approaches to the governance of cities (brzica, 2022). one of the possible directions of development is the use of the ce in the context of the strategy of cities in the field of transport. this could substantially improve the situation within the goals of sdg 11. table 1 shows the structure and description of the individual categories of indicators for the analyzed sdg 11 objectives. graph 2 shows the situation for sdg 11 including transport as well as air pollution indicators (in this case pm2.5)1. it provides a more detailed comparison of the position of selected european cities. some central european countries report very high degree of pm2.5. overview of primary pollutants in selected cities from january 27, 2023: the primary pollutant pm2.5 prevails in these selected cities: prague: 10.0 μg/m3, warsaw: 25.0 μg/m3, berlin 7.2 μg/m3, kosice 12.0 μg/m3, budapest 31.0 μg/m3, munich 6.9 μg/m3, brussels 3.0 μg/m3, paris 9.6 μg/m3, rome 30.0 μg/m3, bucharest 29.0 μg/m3, vienna 18.0 μg/m3, and bratislava 22.0 μg/m3. some cities show other primary pollutants: london (pm10) 27.0 μg/m3 or copenhagen (ozone) 41 μg/m3. contributing to pollution in some cities and countries (especially in central and eastern europe) is the fact that the age of the cars in use is high, the modernization of the transport infrastructure is insufficient and the governance of the cities is not optimal. 1 the environmental indicator pm2.5 was used in terms of its significant impact on health, especially in big cities. such pollution contributes to human mortality from respiratory, cardiovascular and other forms of diseases. the biggest cities are affected by the presence of substances of the pm2.5 type. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7040 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 23 table 1: overview of selected indicators for sdg 11 "sustainable cities and communities" sdg goal indicator indicator description 11.2 c110200a percentage of population satisfied with the quality of public transportation systems 11.2 c110201a performance of public transport network, ratio between accessibility and proximity to hospitals 11.2 c110201b performance of car transport network, ratio between accessibility and proximity to hospitals 11.3 c110301 difference between built-up area growth rate and population growth rate (percentage points) 11.6 c110602 exposure to pm2.5 in µg/m³, population weighted (micrograms per cubic meter) 11.6 c110602a percentage of population satisfied with quality of air 11.6 c110602b percentage of people exposed to more than 10 µg/m³ (micrograms per cubic meter) of pm2.5 11.7 c110701b percentage of population with access to at least one recreational opportunity (theatres, museums, cinemas, stadiums, or cultural attractions) within 15 minutes of cycling note: indicators c110602 and c110602b, related to pm2.5 secondary organic aerosol pollution, are highlighted. graph 1 above also applies to this indicator. omitted are indicators not related to transport, mobility and pm exposure (11.1, 11.3, 11.7a.). source: brzica (2022), modified, based on oecd data, 2020. figure 2. position of selected capitals and countries for sdg 11 (sdg 11.1 11.7) note: index is created from values of indicators for sdg 11.1 11.7. a higher number of points (obtained from aggregation of points from individual sdg 11 indicators) represent a better position of the city in terms of these indicators. see tab. 1 for more details. sdg 11 is a "sustainable cities and communities" category under the un program. source: brzica (2022), author’s elaboration based on oecd data, 2020. it is obvious that the top management of big cities must respond not only to air pollution, “normal” challenges in transport or modernization pressures, but also to the existence of another segment of challenges the set of "wicked" challenges. unlike the “normal” challenges, the "wicked" challenge set exhibits some specific characteristics. these need to be taken into account – including the case of ce in transport-related areas of large city functioning when designing effective policies in the area of environmental changes, transport policy and the approach of producers. it can be assumed that the perception of various types of challenges (including the ce) will be different among representatives of industry, the public sphere and the european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7040 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 24 management of individual big cities. while common problems appear mainly in conditions typical of stable states, "wicked" problems are typical for complex structures and unstable situations. the circular economy and comprehensive modernization of the production capacities of cities can improve the situation. it seems important to create a complete chain "environment modern production using ce modern transport infrastructure with modern means of transport effective governance with awareness of the need to solve wicked problems in related areas. 5. discussion addressing the multitude of challenges that big cities face today in the environmental field is not an easy task. nevertheless, the issue of the sustainability of the urban environment is becoming more relevant with increasing economic activity and technological changes. as the paper indicated, the existing challenges are serious not only in their content and scope, but also in the difficulty of finding solutions, as is the case of "wicked" challenges. policy decision-making is structured through organisational processes that reflect historical institutional arrangements. complex policy problems often involve conflicting interests and divergent perceptions among various stakeholder groups. disagreements about problems and policies arise from many factors, including material interests, sociocultural values and political (dis)trust (head, 2022). this fact further limits quick and effective solutions, especially regarding wicked problems. the responsibility of city representatives is considerable. however, it is related not only to micro-management but especially to the conceptual planning of urban development and to the strategic orientation towards reducing the ecological burden. effective multi-level city governance and the effort to solve “wicked” challenges also require city management to have the ability to find a consensus when solving important "wicked" challenges related to transport and environmental issues in big cities. 6. conclusion there are different approaches to emerging challenges. solutions based on traditional approaches can cause upheavals in the functioning of big cities, weaken their resilience and thus threaten their further development. in the future, the city leaders and other stakeholders will have to reevaluate traditional approaches to city governance in this area, as it can be assumed that an increasing number of "wicked" challenges will arise, which will need to be quickly/effectively resolved about the justified needs of city residents. compared to other works focused on some of the areas analyzed here, we tried to balance a set of key structures (for example, cities and transport systems) and processes (for example, air pollution, solving wicked problems, and governance processes). the holistic view of an integrated approach to the solution of urban ecology and transport in the circular economy context can be used for further research in several possible directions. understandably, the holistic approach raises some doubts about the breadth of coverage, the depth of analysis (use of comparison), the choice of indicators, working with a time frame, and problems with the unification of approaches and definitions. the last point is quite complex due to the "fuzzy" boundaries of many dimensions addressed in the article. these are mainly the concepts of multilevel governance, wicked problems or the urban system. it is their exact characteristics that due to their complexity – they run into the problem of precise and generally accepted definitions, and it is often possible to consider their characteristics as "fuzzy". from the results of our study, it can be concluded that the situation in the large cities in our sample corresponds to the seriousness of the situation, as indicated in other publications. in contrast to more narrowly focused works, we bring an approach that should consider the complexity of the challenges regarding city transport requirements in terms of their growth and ecological burden (here, specifically, air pollution with pm2.5 particles). we are trying to point out the effort through new approaches (both conceptual in the field of technology /ce/ as well as conceptual in the field of decision-making regarding difficult and complex situations /wicked problems/ to solve new challenges in the field of transport and related ecological burden. however, a quick and effective solution to a certain extent is hindered by increasingly complicated and complex relationships between growing groups of actors with different, often conflicting, interests. acknowledgements the paper was developed with the support of the vega project no. 2/0111/21. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7040 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 25 references angelidou, m., politis, c., panori, a., bakratsas, t. and fellnhofer, k. (2022): emerging smart city, transport and energy trends in urban settings: results of a pan-european foresight exercise with 120 experts. technological forecasting and social change, 183, 121915. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.techfore.2022.121915. asheim, b., cooke, p., blažek, j., annerstedt, j., boschma, r., brzica, d., dahlstrand lindholm, a., del castillo hermosa, j., laredo, p., moula, m. and piccaluga, a. (2006): constructing regional advantage : principles perspectives policies [online]. brussels: european commission, 2006. <http://www.dime-eu.org/files/active/0/regional_advantage_final.pdf> babacan, h. (2022): conference keynote after covid-19: building inclusive and sustainable economies for resilience. pp. 7 – 19. in: t.¬ chaiechi, j. ¬wood (eds.) community empowerment, sustainable cities, and transformative economies. springer, singapore. isbn 978-981-16-5259-2. bals, l., tate, w. l. and ellram, l. m. (2022): introduction to circular economy supply chains: from supply chains to value systems. in: bals, l., tate, w. l., ellram, l. m. (eds.) circular economy supply chains: from chains to systems. isbn: 978-1-83982545-3. emerald publishing limited, bingley, pp. 3 – 27. bocken, n.m.p., de pauw, i., bakker, c. and van der grinten, b. (2016): product design and business model strategies for a circular economy. journal of industrial and production engineering, 33 (5), pp. 308 320. brzica, d. (2022): governing major cities in the context of new environmental challenges. ekonomické rozhľady – economic review, 50 (3), pp. 218 – 238. brzica, d., wasziewicz, j. and belof, m. (2014): multi-level governance: a model not only for today, but also for tomorrow? in: karabon, m. et al. laboratories of multi-level governance: analysis of possibilities of implementing multi-level governance instruments in four chosen urban functional areas in the czech republic, hungary, poland and slovakia. wroclaw: the society of polish town planners, green press, pp. 9 -16. cdp (2012): measurement for management cdp cities 2012 global report. clark, g. (2015): the making of a world city: london 1991 to 2021. john wiley & sons, ltd. chichester. isbn 978-1-118-60974-3. com (2015): com (2015) 614 final. communication from the commission to the european parliament, the council, the european economic and social committee and the committee of the regions on closing the loop ‒ an eu action plan for the circular economy. com (2018): com (2018) 32 final. communication from the commission to the european parliament, the council, the european economic and social committee and the committee of regions on the implementation of the circular economy package: options to address the interface between chemicals, products and waste legislation. com (2019): com (2019) 190 final. report from the commission to the european parliament, the council, the european economic and social committee and the committee of the regions on the implementation of the circular economy action plan. doi: 10.1080/13549839.2019.1624701. economy. in: brandão, m., lazarevic, d. and finnveden, g. (eds.): handbook of the circular economy. edward elgar publishing, cheltenham and northampton, pp. 207 – 223. isbn 978 1 78897 271 0. epa (2020): dublin waste to energy (site visit report). environmental protection agency. eurocities (2020): time to empower europe’s cities: eurocities position on the new leipzig charter. february 2020. eurocities (2022): hope is in the air (quality): eurocities position on the revision of the eu framework on air quality. april 2022. eurocities.eu. ghisellini, p., cialani, c. and ulgiati, s. (2016): a review on circular economy: the expected transition to a balanced interplay of environmental and economic systems. journal of cleaner production, 114, pp. 11 32. guenduez, a. a., mergel, i. (2022): the role of dynamic managerial capabilities and organizational readiness in smart city transformation, cities, 129, 103791. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cities.2022.103791. haarstad, h. (2017): constructing the sustainable city: examining the role of sustainability in the ‘smart city’ discourse. journal of environmental policy & planning, 19:4, pp. 423 437, doi: 10.1080/1523908x.2016.1245610 head, b. w. (2008): wicked problems in public policy. public policy 3(2): pp. 101-118. head, b. w. (2022): wicked problems in public policy: understanding and responding to complex challenges. palgrave macmillan, cham. the university of queensland. isbn 978-3-030-94580-0 (ebook), https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-94580-0. hikman, r. and banister, d. (2014): transport, climate change and the city. routledge advances in climate change research. routledge, london and new york, 2014. isbn: 978-0-415-66003-7. hoek, m. (2014): the trillion dollar shift: achieving the sustainable development goals; business for good is good business. routledge: london and new york. isbn: 978-0-8153-6431-3. hong, q., dennis, e., cregger, j., wallace, r. and zielinski, s..(2014): challenges to and opportunities for developing sustainable transportation systems in beijing. presentation to the transportation research board 93rd annual meeting, washington, dc. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ugj.2022.11.004. https://epawebapp.epa.ie/licences/lic_edms/090151b2807727da.pdf. james evans, j., karvonen, a., luque-ayala, a., martin, ch., mccormick, k., rob raven, r. and voytenko palgan, y. (2019): smart and sustainable cities? pipedreams, practicalities and possibilities, local environment, 24:7, pp. 557-564. johansson, h., sandvik, k. o., zsidákovits, j., łutzyk, g. (2016): a need for new methods in the paradigm shift from mobility to sustainable accessibility. transportation research procedia 14, pp. 412 421. doi: 10.1016/j.trpro.2016.05.093. kautto, p. and lazarevic, d. (2020): between a policy mix and a policy mess: policy instruments and instrumentation for the circular european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7040 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 26 kenworthy, j. (2006): the eco-city:ten key transport and planning dimensions for sustainable city development. environment & kirchherr, j., reike, d. and hekkert, m. (2017): conceptualizing the circular economy: an analysis of 114 definitions. resources, conservation and recycling, 127, pp. 221–232. knox, paul l., mccarthy, l. (eds.) (2012): urbanization : an introduction to urban geography. boston, pearson education, inc., isbn 9780-321-73643-7. korhonen, j., honkasalo, a., and seppälä, j. (2018): circular economy: the concept and its limitations. ecological economics, 143, pp. 37 46. milios, l. (2017): advancing to a circular economy: three essential ingredients for a comprehensive policy mix. sustainability science, 13 (3), pp. 1 18. moser, s., williams, s. j. and boesch, d. f. (2012): wicked challenges at land's end: managing coastal vulnerability under climate change. october 2012. annual review of environment and resources 37(1):pp. 51–78. doi: 10.1146/annurev-environ-021611135158. nylén, e.-j.a., salminen, j. m. (2019): how does the circular economy discourse affect policy-making? the case of streamlining waste utilisation in finnish earthworks. resources, conservation and recycling, 149 (june), pp. 532 -540. oecd (2006): territorial reviews: competitive cities in the global economy. oecd: paris. isbn: 92-64-02708-4. participation in the smart city: findings from an international comparative study. local government studies, 48:1, pp. 23 47. https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/03003930.2020.1851204. pereira, g. v., cunha, m. a., lampoltshammer, t. j., parycek, p. and testa, m. g. (2017): increasing collaboration and participation in smart city governance: a cross-case analysis of smart city initiatives. information technology for development, 23:3, pp. 526 – 553. https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/02681102.2017.1353946. przeybilovicz, e., cunha, m. a., geertman, s., leleux, ch., michels, a., tomor, z., webster, w. r., meijer, a. (2022): citizen tsun lai, c. m., cole, a. (2022): measuring progress of smart cities: indexing the smart city indices. urban governance, 44, un (2017): new urban agenda. 2017 united nations. isbn 978-92-1-132731-1. https://habitat3.org/the-new-urban-agenda. urbanization, vol. 18 (1): pp. 67 85. doi: 10.1177/0956247806063947. 4_chubakumzuk european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5753 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 40 population, poverty and environmental degradation in nagaland: an overview analysis chubakumzuk jamir1 1 yingli college, department of economics longleng, nagaland: india e-mail: ckumzuk7@gmail.com received: 12/11/2020 accepted for publication: 20/06/2021 published: 19/07/2021 abstract nagaland is located in the far east region of east asia towards northern part of indo-myanmar mountain ranges is well-known among conservationists and environmentalist for its unique forest ecosystems and also for its alarmingly high rates of deforestation through various forms of economic activities. high population growth and continued economic development have caused serious environmental damage in the region. to this end, the study seeks to assess the impact of population pressure on environment resources, with particular reference to the degradation of natural endowments like forest and land resources. this paper reviews existing evidence and offers a conceptual framework for the investigation of complex dynamics among population growth, poverty and environmental degradation. the evaluation suggests that higher population and fertility rates were associated with higher deforestation rate in the tropical evergreen forest of nagaland. poverty reduction and environmental protection are two international obligations for sustainable development. the relationship between population, poverty and environmental degradation is regionally unique or has regional uniqueness. the study is based on both primary and secondary source of data. a total of 400 household were selected using stratified random sampling technique for measurement of multidimensional poverty index. this paper analyses the poverty level using below poverty line (bpl) card holder. composite index was used to compare the environmental degradation cause by rapid rise in poverty level. the finding shows that during 1987-88 the poverty rate was 34.43% and the forest loss was found to be -192 sq. km which further increases to 33.83% (poverty rate) and forest loss to -450 sq. km during 2016-17. the result highlights high level of poverty thereby, affecting the environment resources. the paper suggests suitable measures which can ameliorate the poverty and environmental degradation. keywords: shifting cultivation, land degradation, forest resources, environmental degradation and poverty 1. introduction in underdeveloped and developing countries deprived population have normally taken the burden of shouldering the whole blame for the cause of serious trouble in the society, the most present day accountability directed in opposition to them is that they cause destruction of ecosystem (boyce, 1994; duraiappah, 1998). the brundtland commission record generally wellknown definition of sustainable development, this definition enclose the social, financial and environmental necessities of both present and future generations and prominence the mannequin that what we do at present determine what is possible tomorrow (united nations, 1987; drolet, 2015). the bruntland commission report 1983, which unexpectedly has been welcome as the plan for environmental preservation, it is obviously cited that income deprivation is a predominant cause of environmental troubles and enhance of poverty is a requisite and fundamental condition of any successful program to deal with environmental assignment (kramer, 2012; bruntland commission, 1983). european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5753 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 41 the world bank 1992 joined the agreement with the world development report, where it openly stated, low income households who have to meet short term basic needs mine the natural assets by excessive cutting of trees for firewood and failure to restore soil nutrients. however there is a mounting progress in the economic literature which disputes the conventional concept and content that more composite set of variables comes into play and that simple generalizations of this multidimensional hassle are often invalid and misses many considerable points. these studies point out population, social, political, economic and institutional determinants as central parameters in the poverty-environmental degradation connection. in the world bank mission declaration, combating poverty with enthusiasm and professionalism for lasting results, the world bank has expanded its focal point on poverty reduction program. increasingly, country actions are focusing exclusively on poverty reduction outcomes, and are requiring the sectors to work collectively to achieve those outcomes. until recently, the controlled approach for environmental activities within any particular country or place is primarily based on attaining the most environmental benefit for a unit of expenditure. environmental benefits are notion to promote society as a whole, so our goal has flawlessly been to maximize our societal benefits. in the equal way, other sectors have pursued their very own objectives, regularly aiming for the greatest social advantage or economic development and now not particular to limit poverty (world bank, 1992). the world bank updated poverty line of $1.90 a day, the estimated for 2012 put in light the number of extremely poor population at about 900 million or 12.7% of global population based on 2011 purchasing power parity (global monitoring report, 2015-16). in 1998 world bank report, "reducing poverty in india" focuses on the number of anti-poverty programes of the government. during the last seventy years since independence, india has accomplished many astonishing social and economic parameters in different fields like education, health care, reducing gender inequality, raising standard of living, manage over the population growth, reducing income inequality, employment generation etc. accordingly government has carried out range of plan, projects, policies and programme for the improvement of the poor people. for india poverty level according to c. rangarajan during 2011-12 was 29.5%. for the state of nagaland the average mpce (monthly per capita consumption expenditure) was 1229.83 for rural sector and rs 1615.78 for urban sector, and the total poverty level was 14%. in recent time government of india highlighted that nagaland is the absolute best upward shove in poverty level with 4.1 lakhs population residing under poverty line in 2009-10, as against 1.7 lakhs in 2004-05 (planning commission, 2014). poverty in nagaland is most rigorous in rural sectors where an estimated 71.14% of the total population lives in, obtain their livelihood from the natural resource base (census, 2011). one of the most key attribute of agriculture zone in nagaland is the massive existences of subsistence economy, which makes agriculture even more vital for food supply and sustainability. however, over the ultimate four decades, soil erosion and land degradation have turn out to be most necessary environmental issues and present an upsetting risk to nutrient safety and sustainability of agriculture production and productivity (jamir, 2015; longkumer and jamir 2012). broad range of efforts on poverty reduction program have failed to bring adequate progress and development despite decades of development support by the central authority by implementing number of employment and income generation programs (jamir and ezung, 2017a). on the other hand rapid boom of population in combination with poor initial natural resource endowments and inclined macro-economic policies towards agriculture sector have not only proven catastrophic to reduce poverty, but also led to the worsening of the natural useful resource base on which rural livelihoods depend. it is typically conventional that development hyperlink on the scope of ecological sustainability, monetary viability and social recognition. however, a range of vital dimensions in the development scenario are unfavorable, but they symbolize the essential problems associated to sustainable development. these improvement domain dimensions include agro-ecological potential, population, market access and institutional setting. less favored areas are normally characterized by a combination of low agricultural possible and disadvantage market access; often existing in an institutional setting that is now not conducive to choice possible improvement pathways (jamir, 2021). 2. literature review malthus (1798) was concerned about the growth of population to outrun the available food supply. the negative impact on the nature due to increasing pressure caused by the population growth and natural judgment of diminishing marginal productivity of resources was highlighted in his an essay on the principles of population. in malthusian view, the population growth would undo itself through its rising pressure on natural resources like land, water, forest and thereby declining the productivity of such natural resources and rising incidence of poverty. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5753 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 42 ehrlich (1968) empirically indicated the pressure of a fundamental relationship between rapid population growth and environmental degradation. he argued that if the existing patterns of population growth and resource use continued, it would lead to environmental collapse. even the renewable natural resources like forest, water can be exhausted if the population exceeds the carrying capacity and thus rate of extraction is higher than the rate of regeneration. therefore a balance between the population growth and resource use is well warranted for the maintenance of ecological balance and sustainable growth of the economies. trainer (1990) stated that most of the developing nations suffer because of the rapid increase in population, that in turns cause to shrink environmental resources, raising air and water pollution, deforestation, soil erosion, overgrasing and damage to ecosystem. there is a tremendous pressure on land to produce more food for growing population. cropper and griffiths (1994) argued that population growth, by increasing the demand for arable land, encourages the conversion of forests to agriculture. since the people living in rural areas who are dependent on agriculture as a livelihood, one would expect deforestation to increase with rapid population density as well as rising demand for wood for both timber and fuel. leach and mearns (1995) poverty and environmental degradation are positively linked in a vicious circle, which forces deprived population to engage in practices that have an unfavorable impact on the environment as they are searching for primary provision to enhance their livelihood study have established that poor household depends on environmental assets for their sustainability and also the poor people rely on the natural resources for many of their basic economic activities. agarwal (1997) the study traced why and how this degradation and the misuse of natural resources in rural sector of india. it was once observed that the poor households in rural region are alleged as having a short-time scope, discounting the future benefits from conservations of environment rather heavily owing to the urgency to make a sustainable livelihood and avoid hunger. such a time horizon leads to unsustainable use of natural resources. rozelle et. al., (1997) major work was undertaken to learn about the correlation amongst population growth, poverty and environmental degradation in china in 1997. the paper examined the affect that each had on the china’s environmental resources such as land, water, air and forest resources. they determine that institutional policy have been ineffective in controlling environmental resources degradation primarily due to the fact of its limited resources. some studies divulge that due to deforestation and agricultural growth there has been considerable destruction of forest resources causing environmental degradation. dreze and sen (1989) have also identified the incidence of poverty and not the population growth as the principal reason for the degradation of resources. they also cited the example of countries like israel, hong kong and portugal where per capita food production declined during the decade of 1980s but those countries able to compensate the underproduction through imports as the countries were developed and people had the entitlement to afford to buy imported items unlike many african citizens. bhagat and hassan (1994) have shown that the changes in major environmental parameters and degradation of resources in the world during the last century especially after 1950 was not only due to the rapid growth of population but also owing to the escalation of consumption of fossil fuel, industrial production and the growth of the economy, which have been much higher than the rate of growth of population. therefore, the degradation of natural resources is a complex interplay of population growth, growth of consumption of resources per capita, advancement of technology and the later one is much more important than the former one goodstein (1999) has argued that the poorer has a tendency to have more children and spent very less on birth control for their future security. therefore the family size and population growth is rapid in many underdeveloped and developing countries. the rising population even for sustainable activities enhance pressure on natural especially forest resourcestherefore, due to these premises, the objectives of the study will be to examine environmental degradation caused by rapid rise in poverty level and study the effect and measure to control of shifting cultivation in the region. 3. materials and methods 3.1. study areas and period of research survey nagaland came into existence as the sixteenth state of indian union on 1 december, 1963. it is situated in the northeastern part of india between 25°6' to 27°4' north latitudes and 93°0' to 95°15'·east longitudes with an area of about 16,579 sq. km, european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5753 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 43 assam in its north and west, arunachal pradesh in its north east, the state of manipur in the south (figure 1). the state is bound by the long international boundary of myanmar in its eastern side. the terrain is lush with luxuriant forest, rolling mountains, enchanting valleys and swift flowing streams and rivers making the landscape beautiful. the altitude varies from 200 meters in the plains to 3,840 meters in the hills. the inhabitants of nagaland are tribal having distinctive dialect and culture. the state’s population is predominantly rural with about 71.14% of its population living in rural sector. the state is comprised of 12 administrative districts with 74 blocks and 1428 inhabited villages (census, 2011). each district is inhabited with one or more tribes thereby imparting to it a distinct linguistic, cultural, traditional and socio-political characteristic. the terrain is predominantly hilly and is covered by a rich and varied floral and faunal assemblage. it forms part of one of the 35 biodiversity hot spots of the world, i.e., the indo-burma biodiversity hotspot zone. the physiographic creates specific situations and sometimes limitations for rural development like vulnerability, inaccessibility, specific resource niches and areas of population concentration. these aspects of physiographic conditions directly or indirectly influence the distributive nature of natural resources and human concentration. the study of such aspects of landscape would be helpful in understanding the required processes of rural development and also helpful in identifying the areas of available resources where the developmental processes may be intensified in future for raising standard of living of the local population. nagaland is primarily ago based economy. people are based on agriculture and allied activities for their sustainable livelihood. comparing to other food crops about 80% of the cropped region is under rice production. the farm production and productivity for all food crops is very low, in contrast to other states. presently, the jhum/shifting to terraced cultivation ratio is 4:3 (nayak, 2013). forestry is also an important source of income generation for rural sector (ghosh, 2016). nevertheless, agriculture and forestry contribute a majority of nagaland's gross domestic product (gsdp). nagaland's gsdp grew at 9.9 percent compounded annually for a decade, thus more than doubling the per capita income (nagaland economy report, 201112). the data collected relate to the year 2016-17. figure 1 – nagaland map source: nagaland science and technology council, government of nagaland, kohima european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5753 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 44 figure 2 – nagaland soils map source: indian council of agriculture research, nagaland centre figure 3 – nagaland land use source: remote sensing application centre, kohima, nagaland european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5753 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 45 3.2. data collection the evaluation of population, poverty and environmental degradation is based totally on both primary and secondary source of data. the subsequent step of poverty analysis is the identification of poverty line that distinguishes the poor from non-poor. the nsso (national sample survey organisation) estimated a poverty line of rs 1229.83 for rural and rs 1615.78 for urban nagaland during 2011-12 (planning commission, 2014). the report of the expert group maintains that the domestic household consumer expenditure is more consistent than income and subsequently more appropriate for measuring poverty. a total of 400 household were interviewed from the sample villages and wards of nagaland. thus, mpce was used as a proxy for the actual income while determining poverty (ezung, 2011). 3.3. data analysis and estimation 3.3.1. head count ratio the headcount ratio measures the percentage of the population that is poor (watts, 1968; sen, 1979; foster, 1984). head count ratio (h) if then: h=q/n 3.3.2. multidimensional poverty index (mpi) the mpi measures those experiencing multiple deprivations on year of schooling, school attendance, food, child mortality, household cooking fuel, sanitation, water supply, power, housing floor and assets. formally, the first component is term as multidimensional headcount ratio (h) (alkire and santos 2010, atkinson, 2003). h=q/n here q is the number of people who are multidimensional poor and n is the total population. the second component called the intensity (or breadth) of poverty (a) and can be expressed as: a = (∑_(i=1)^n▒〖ci(k)〗)/q where ci (k) is the censor deprivation score of individual i and q is the number of people who are multidimensional poor. mpi is the product of both mpi = h×a. 3.3.3. composite index to make a significant comparison of different districts of nagaland in terms of indicators of poverty and forest cover the following formulae are used to arrive at the degradation index of the indicator variables as mentioned against each. (findex) = max(xij) − xij max(xij) − min(xij) (pindex) = max(xij) − xij max(xij) − min(xij) european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5753 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 46 4. results and discussion population affects on the environment principally through the use of natural assets and is related with environmental stresses like land degradation, loss of biodiversity, air and water pollution (figure 4 and 5). the results shows population growth of nagaland has doubled since 1971. it has increased from 516449 persons in 1971 to 1990036 persons in 2001, adding 1473587 persons in the remaining three decades. such a remarkable expands of population led to large scale environmental degradation. investigation of record on poverty rate in nagaland affirm that on an average 33.05% of population (both urban and rural) have been beneath poverty line in 2015-16 (refer table 2&3). the finding show that mon district having highest incidence of poverty (48.78%), while kohima district show the lowest incidence of poverty, most of the districts of eastern nagaland such as tuensang, mon, kiphire and longleng were observed to have failed in the poverty eradication programs even after two decades of policy implementation. districts with sensible advancement in this regard were mokokchung, phek, wokha and zunheboto. table 3 shows growing trends of aggregate poverty in nagaland from 1987-88 to 2016-17 i.e., 34.43 to 37.92% and also multidimensional poverty index (mpi) of 30.8% during 2015-16 (nsso, 2012; jamir and ezung, 2017b; jamir, 2020). the study found that the state has recorded forest areas of 862532 hectares in 1987-88 but decline to 862300 during 201617. the end result exhibits vital activities accountable for deforestation were identified with commercial agents actively involved in all five with the poor farmer taking part in two of the five activities. there was a common consent among the studies that commercial agents were the majority group pursuing logging and agricultural development activities (somanathan, 1991; anderson, 1989; repetto, 1990; goodland, 1991) as a result there was a continuous decline of forest areas in nagaland since 1987-88 to 2016-17 as per forest survey of india report (refer table 2&3). the study also determine that unsustainable deforestation activities such as shifting cultivation, coal mining, quarrying, diversion of forest lands for developmental activities, large scale plantation, agriculture expansion and natural catastrophe like landslide and fire alternatively end result in environmental degradation which has affect on rainfall disruption, production and productivity and shortage of fuel wood supply. there was also agreement that market and institutional failure have been the foremost incentives driving both agents to unsustainable deforestation activities. studies disputing that the poor do not have the possessions adopt unsustainable deforestation activities and neither do they reveal the short time preferences which would force them to undertake the unsustainable activities (tiffen, 1993). study found that the state is losing its forest cover at an alarming rate of 200 sq. km per year next to mizoram in north eastern region as per environment, forest and climate change government of nagaland survey report, 2018 (nagaland post, 2018) (figure 4). figure 4: environmental resources (a): mount saramati (kiphire) (b): dikhu river from chare (tuensang) source: author elaboration european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5753 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 47 (c): dzukou valley (kohima) (d): kepamodzu mountain in pfutsero (phek) source: author elaboration the study found that agriculture activities and forest cover should be closely linked; due to the fact clearing for agricultural use is the principal motive of deforestation. the consequences shows that 1987-88 forest loss was found to be -192 sq. km which in addition increases to -450 sq.km during 2016-17 (refer table 3). the analysis of composite index of poverty and environmental degradation exposed that the districts which were hard hit in 2011 (peindex ≥ 0.7) were zunheboto, kohima, and dimapur. the least affected districts (peindex ≤ 0.5) were tuensang, kiphire, longleng and mon. the remaining of the districts were moderately hit (0.5 ≤ peindex ≤ 0.7) were peren, wokha, mokokchung and phek (refer table 1). higher population growth, low degree of employment and income, poverty, shifting cultivation, logging, and infrastructure improvement is the most common variables that affects environment (barbier, 2001). deforestation itself is not a problem and in fact may be a requisite condition for economic development. when this takes place on a large-scale, it becomes imperative to discover the factors behind the trend. degradation of environment resources caused either by the underprivileged or the rich has both direct and indirect impacts not only on the cost of production but also on the productivity of crops and ultimately lowering the earning of the underprivileged population. poor get more affected than the rich and become poorer due to environmental degradation manifested through destruction of forest for fuel wood, timber, jhum cultivation; degradation of land via the use of chemical fertilizer, pesticide, etc in modern farming and pollution of air due to consumption of biomass fuel. thus, a vicious circle is mounted between poverty and environmental degradation. each turns into the purpose and effect of the other. the current paper in this regard is a humble strives to quantify the magnitude of each poverty and environmental degradation over time and throughout states and affirm empirically the link between them (figures 5, 6 and 7). european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5753 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 48 figure 5: deforestation in different part of nagaland for jhum cultivation (a): kiphire (b): tuensang (c): mokokchung source: author elaboration european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5753 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 49 table 1: indices of rural poverty and environmental degradation districts pindex findex dimapur 0.895 1.00 kohima 1.00 0.00 mokokchung 0.906 0.653 mon 0.154 0.493 phek 0.584 0.306 wokha 0.762 0.699 zunheboto 0.758 0.782 tuensang 0.191 0.045 kiphire 0.104 longleng 0.00 peren 0.421 0.759 source: author elaboration table 2: total population and percentage of population below poverty line districts total population % of population below poverty line dimapur 3,78,811 25.14 kohima 2,67,988 22.37 mokokchung 1,94,622 24.85 mon 2,50,260 48.78 phek 1,63,418 33.39 wokha 1,66,343 28.66 zunheboto 1,40,757 28.78 tuensang 1,96,596 45.82 kiphire 74,004 46.12 longleng 50,484 48.89 peren 95,219 37.71 total 19,78,502 33.05 source: author elaboration table 3: rural poverty and total forest area year urban/rural poverty forest area loss/gain (sq.km) 1987-88 34.43 8,62,532 -192 1993-94 37.92 8,62,000 +27 2004-05 19.00 8,62,930 -296 2011-12 14.00 8,62,929 -146 2016-17 33.83 8,62,300 -450 source: statistical handbook, government of nagaland, 1987, 1993, 2006 and 2012 forest survey of india, 1987, 1993, 2004, 2012, 2016 and 2017 figure 6: village having higher level of poverty in nagaland european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5753 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 50 (a): buranamsang (longleng) (b): new pangsha (noklak) (c): chare (tuensang) (d): sakshi (longleng) source: author elaboration european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5753 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 51 figure 7 – percentage of population below poverty line source: author elaboration 5. shifting cultivation and its effects in nagaland: an overview shifting cultivation is an age-old conventional cultivation practice and still predominant in nagaland, where a land is selected for cultivation for one or two years and thereafter left it desolate for quite a few years (figure 8 and 9). shifting cultivation includes a rigorous approach of clearing massive forest area, slashing and burning massive chunk of trees. therefore, the unsystematic cutting and burning down the forest has brought greater erosion of soil. this amounts to loss of top fertile soil and biodiversity within the area and if left unchecked leads to low productivity in the following cycle that result approximately in about 5-10 years fallow (chatterjee, 2012; chauhan, 2001). the penalties of deforestation can now not solely be at once felt in an area but its effects can be carried on to harm the future generations and their environment. as a result of rapid population growth, demand for food and fuel has increased and land availability for agriculture has been reduced. shifting cultivation has been creating problems on physiographic and environmental conditions in nagaland. regularly shifting from one land to the other, has affected the biodiversity of these regions (christanty, 1986). the area under natural forest has declined continuously (refer table 3) the fragmentation of environment, disappearance of species and incursion by exotic weeds and other plants are a number of the opposite ecological cost of shifting cultivation. within predominantly jhum areas, the loss of top soil is at the highest. apart from the loss of soil fertility and productiveness as cited above, jhumming is also accountable for massive scale deforestation in the hills, residue of reservoir, drying up of the natural stream and river and irreparable damages to flora and fauna (das, 2006; stocking, 2001; mishra and ramakrishnan, 1983). 3,122 3,174 5,136 2,897 5,002 4,715 5,887 1,79 8,286 4,077 3,045 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 di ma pu r ko him a mo ko kc hu ng mo n ph ek w ok ha zu nh eb oto tu en san g ki ph ire lo ng len g pe ren % o f p op ul ai on b el ow p ov er ty li ne european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5753 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 52 figure 8 – practice of jhum cultivation in nagaland (a): mokokchung (b): tuensang (c) wokha (d): kiphire source: author elaboration european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5753 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 53 figure 9 – terrace cultivation which is more eco-friendly and sustainability (a): kohima (b): phek source: author elaboration nagaland possessed the second highest acreage under shifting cultivation next to manipur. land use pattern of nagaland revealed that almost 16% of the total geographical area is under net sown area. about 123909 ha area is under shifting cultivation, which accounts for almost 7.5% of total area, 42% of total cropped area and 47.5% of net sown area (rukuosietuo, et. al., 2014). the practice of shifting cultivation involved 61% households in rural areas, covering about 1 million ha in the entire state. it exposes about 5.65% of the total geographical area of the state to soil erosion (deka and sarmah, 2010). about 20,000 hectares of forest is felled every year in the state for jhum cultivation, as per the report of the department of land resources. the extensive practice of jhum results in an average loss of 30.62 tonnes of soil area per hectare annually, as per soil and water conservation department, government of nagaland annual document for 2017-18. in rural nagaland each and every household heavily depend on fuel wood for cooking and space heating (bhatt and sachan, 2003) which accelerates forest degradation at a rapid rate. many studies deal with fuel wood consumption in the mountainous region (maikhuri, 1994; maikhuri and gangwar, 1991). the current fuel wood harvests on fallow fields are not adequate to cover fuel wood demands due to short fallow periods and insufficient per capita fallow forest areas as a result of high population growth. in the past slash and burn agriculture and commercial timber logging has led to a severe decrease in forest cover and degradation of forest (figure 10). european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5753 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 54 figure 10 – different methods of fuel wood harvest (a): phek (b): longleng source: author elaboration 6. conclusion developing region has been experiment a serious problem of rapidly growing population, that accelerating environmental degradation. high population growth with high poverty rate worsened environmental condition during the past four decades that seem to eroding the economic and social progress of nagaland. the finding show that mon district having highest incidence of poverty in nagaland (48.78%), while kohima district show the lowest incidence of poverty, most of the districts of eastern nagaland such as tuensang, mon, kiphire and longleng were observed to have failed in the poverty eradication programs even after two decades of policy implementation. accordingly, a better coverage would require in integrating various income generation schemes along with health care programme, water supply, electricity, sanitation and housing policies, which are almost absent in rural areas, funding for improving education level and labour market opportunities for younger population should seriously be considered, since lack of these determinants represent the main reason of their disadvantage (ezung and jamir 2018). while poorest of the poor depend their daily livelihood from natural resources like forest, river etc environmental degradation would certainly have its effects on them. similarly increase in incidence of poverty would surely increase the anxious attack on environmental resources. this is sufficiently borne out by the case of the eastern location of nagaland where shifting cultivation on the hill slopes has established a vicious circle of poverty of the hill community and denudation of forest leading to environmental degradation. the analysis of composite index of poverty and environmental degradation exposed that the districts which were hard hit in 2011 (peindex ≥ 0.7) were zunheboto, kohima, and dimapur. the least affected districts (peindex ≤ 0.5) were tuensang, kiphire, longleng and mon. the remaining of the districts were moderately hit (0.5 ≤ peindex ≤ 0.7) were peren, wokha, mokokchung and phek. the results support that population have a deleterious impact on environment. in nagaland shifting cultivation is not only the way to earn livelihood of rural population but also significantly contributes to the rural economy by generating employment and income. but on the different aspects it has many negative consequences on environment, biodiversity and ecological balance in the region. under this situation, short term measures need to be undertaken to enhance productivity and additionally to take a look at soil erosion. considering the physiographic characters of land, climate conditions, european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5753 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 55 social customs, food habits and many others alternative system of farming like diversified agro farming need to be introduced. this would require a system which includes agriculture, horticulture along with animal husbandry, fishery and rooster farming. in the same way success of this alternative farming system depends upon the gaining of confidence of (jhummias) through persuasion, demonstration and applied fundamental research to be conducted very slowly without any haste. strengthening of agriculture production and productivity using present day’s inputs might reduce pressure on forest by making shifting cultivation less attractive (angelsen and kaimowitz, 1999; 2001). to control shifting cultivation completely, it will require massive investment and robust rural livelihood schemes (jamir, 2019). these policies are to be based on sound macro-and micro economic management, with good governance aimed at ameliorating poverty and promoting sustained economic growth have perceptible and permanent effect in lowering population growth. population growth momentum in nagaland is really huge hence the pressure of demand on resources are obviously large, it is only one of many alternative causes as a result of over-consumption based, unsustainable development that may have an even larger impact. our choice of how to use those resources (i.e. our economic policies) and for what purposes (i.e. our political directions and policies) are critical issues as well on the resulting impact on the environment to meet those uses and purposes. acknowledgements the author would like to thank dr. santanu dey, h. moilen phom, tewu mero, mhasinuo rio and dikhrou dianu for providing necessary materials and valuable suggestions during this research work. references agabi, j.a. (1995). biodiversity loss in nigerian environment lagos: macmillan. agarwal, a. (1985). the 5th annual world conservation. london: wwf. agarwal, b. (1997). gender, environment and poverty interlinks: regional variations and temporal shifts in rural india, 1971-91. world development 25(1): 23-52. alkire, s.; santos, m.e. (2010). acute multidimensional poverty: a new index for developing countries. ophi working paper series no.3 university of oxford. allen, j.c.; barness, d.f. (1995). the causes of deforestation in developed countries. annals of the association of american geograpere 75(2): 163–84. anderson, p. (1989). the myth of sustainable logging: the cause for a ban on tropical timber imports. the ecologist 19(5): 166-168. angelsen, a.; kaimowitz, d. (1999). rethinking the causes of deforestation: lessons from economic models. world bank research observer 14: 73–98. atkinson, a.b. (2003). multidimensional deprivation: contrasting social welfare and counting approaches. journal of economic inequality 1(1): 51–65. barbier, e. (2001). the economics of tropical deforestation and land use: an introduction to the special issue. land economics 77(2): 155–171. bhatt, b.p.; sachan, m.s. (2003). fuelwood consumption along an altitudinal gradient in mountain villages of india, agro forestry division, icar research complex for neh region, umiam, meghalaya, india. boserup, e. (1965). the conditions of agricultural growth. chicago: aldine. boyce, j.k. (1994). inequality as a cause of environmental degradation. ecological economic 11(3): 169-178. brady, n.c. (1996). alternatives to slash-and-burn: a global imperative. agriculture, ecosystems and environment 58(1): 3-11. broad, r. (1994). the poor and the environment: friends or foes. world development 22(6): 811–822. bruntland commission, (1983). bruntland commission report. oxford university press, oxford, london. cavendish, w. (2000). empirical regularities in the poverty-environment relationship of rural house-holds: evidence from zimbabwe. world development 28(11): 1979–2003. census of india, (1981). government of india. new delhi. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5753 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 56 census of india, (1991). government of india. new delhi. census of india, (2001). government of india. new delhi. census of india, (2011). government of india. new delhi. census of kohima, (2011). directorate of census operations, kohima, nagaland. chatterjee, d. (2012). impact of shifting cultivation on soil and environment: strategic way out. in: deka bc., patra mk, thirugnanavel a, chatterjee d, borah tr and ngachan sv (eds.) resilient shifting cultivation: challenges and opportunities, published by: director, icar research complex for neh region, umiam 793103 meghalaya 27-34. chauhan, b.s. (2001). shifting cultivation in perspective. nagaland university. christanty, l. (1986). shifting cultivation and tropical soils: patterns, problems and possible improvements. in gerald g. marten (eds.) traditional agriculture in southeast asia: a human ecology perspective, boulder, westview pressn 226. cropper, m.; griffiths, c. (1994). the interaction between population growth and environmental quality. american economics review 84, 250–254. das, d. (2006). demystifying the myth of shifting cultivation: agronomy in the north-east. economic and political weekly 41(47): 4912-4917. dasgupta, p.; maler, k.g. (1994): poverty, institutions and the environmental resource base, world bank environmental paper 9, world bank. deka, p.k.; sarmah, d. (2010). shifting cultivation and its effects in regarding of perspective in northern india. international journal of commerce and business management 3(2): 157-165. drolets, j. (2015). disasters in social, cultural and political context. international encyclopedia of the social and behavioral science 2nd edition, 478-484. duraiappah, a.k. (1998). poverty and environmental degradation: a review and analysis of the nexus. world development 26(12): 2169-2179. ehrlich, p.r.; holdren, j.p. (1971). the impact of population growth. science 171, 1212–1217. ezung, t.z. (2011). poverty in nagaland. akansha publishing house, new delhi. ezung, t.z.; jamir, c.k. (2018). disparities in infrastructural development of nagaland: a case study of kohima and longleng districts. journal of economic affairs 63(2):375-379. fearnside, p. m.; laurance, w.f. (2004). tropical deforestation and greenhouse gas emissions. ecological applications 14:982–986. forest survey, (1987). government of india. new delhi. forest survey, (1993). government of india. new delhi. forest survey, (2004). government of india. new delhi. forest survey, (2012). government of india. new delhi. forest survey, (2016). government of india. new delhi. forest survey, (2017). government of india. new delhi. foster, j.e. (1984). on economic poverty: a survey of aggregate measures. advances in econometrics 3: 215-251. ghosh, s. (2016). a window to the northeast. the hindu. retrieved 21st march 2017. global monitoring report, (2015-16). development in an era of demographic change. world bank: washington dc. goel, n.p.; krishnan, g. (2000). geography of northeast india. shillong book stall, bara bazar, shillong. goodland, r. (1991). tropical deforestation solutions, ethics and religions. world bank environment working paper, world bank, washington dc. houghton, r.a.; lefkowitz, d.s.; skole, d.l. (1991). changes in the landscape of latin america between 1850 and 1985. i. progressive loss of forests. forest ecology and management 38(3/4): 143-172. jamir, a. (2015). shifting options: a case study of shifting cultivation in mokokochung district in nagaland, india, in: shifting cultivation, livelihood and food security: new and old challenges for indigenous people in asia. fao, iwgia and aipp19-21. jamir, c.k. (2020). education and poverty level: a gender analysis of kohima and longleng districts of nagaland, india. international journal of economics, business and politics 4(1): 221-236. jamir, c.k (2021). organic large cardamom farming in longleng district: promoting growth with poverty reduction. black sea journal of agriculture 4(1): 8-17 european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5753 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 57 jamir, c.k. (2019). macro economic impact of social protection programme through vdbs in alleviate rural poverty in nagaland: bridging the gaps in artur borcuch 2019, economic in post (modern world), knowledge laboratory, poland. jamir, c.k.; ezung t.z. (2017a). poverty and inequality in nagaland. international journal of arts humanities and management studies 3(6): 64-72. jamir, c.k.; ezung, t.z. (2017b). impact of education on employment, income and poverty in nagaland. international journal of research in economics and social sciences 7(9): 50-56. jodha, n.s. (1990). rural common property resources contributions and crisis. economic and political weekly 25(26), a65-78. kalipeni, e.; cleaver, kevin m.; schreiber, gotz a. (1996). reversing the spiral: the population, agricultural, and environmental nexus in sub-saharan africa. african studies review 39(2):170 kramer, k.l. (2012). sustainability, user experience, and design. user experience in the age of sustainability, 1-30. leach, m.; mearns, r. (1995). poverty and environment in developing countries. an overview study. institute for development studies, university of sussex, brighton, uk. longkumer, l.; jamir, t. (2012). nagaland: land alienation: dynamics of colonialism, security, and development. published by aakar books in association with other media: delhi maikhuri, r.k. (1994). eco-energetic analysis of village ecosystem of different traditional societies of northeast india, energy 21(12): 1287-1297. maikhuri, r.k.; gangwar, a.k. (1991). fuel wood use by different tribal and nontribal communities in north-east india. natural resources forum 15(2): 162-165. maikhuri, r.k.; ramakrishnan, p.s. (1991). comparative analysis of the village ecosystem function of different tribes living in the same area in arunachal pradesh living in north-eastern india. agricultural systems, 9:57-72. malthus, t.r. (1798). first essay on population. reprinted. london: macmillan. meadows, d. h.; meadows, d. l.; randers, j.; behrens, w.w. (1974). the limit to growth: a report for the club of rome’s project on the predicament of mankind. (2nd eds.) new york: universe book. medhi, r. (1992). global warming and its implications for the development world. rawat publication. mink, s.d. (1993). poverty, population, and the environment. world bank discussion paper 189. washington, dc: the world bank. mishra, b.; ramakrishnan, p. (1983). slash and burn agriculture at higher elevations in north-eastern india. ii. soil fertility changes. agriculture, ecosystems and environment 9(1): 83-96. myers, n. (1993). tropical forests: the main deforestation fronts. environmental conservation 20(1): 9-16. nadkarni, m.v. (2000). poverty, environment, development: a many-patterned nexus. economic and political weekly 35(14): 1184-1190. nagaland economy report (2011-12). archived 14th july 2014 at the wayback machine ibef, india. nayak, p. (2013). some facts and figures on development attainments in nagaland archived 30 june 2014 at the wayback machine, munich personal repec archive, mpra paper no. 5185. nsso report, (2012). national sample survey organisation report, government of india. new delhi. omotor, d.g. (2000). environmental problems and sustainable development in nigeria. journal of development studies 2 (1): 146-149. pearce, d.w.; warford j.j. (1993). world without end: economics, environment and sustainable development, oxford university press, new york. planning commission, (2014). report of the expert group to review the methodology for measurement of poverty. government of india. new delhi. ramakrishnan, p.s. (1992). shifting agriculture and sustainable development: an interdisciplinary study for north-eastern india. man and biosphere series, book 10, unesco and parthenon publishing. reardon, t.; vosti, s.a. (1995). links between rural poverty and the environment in developing countries: asset categories and investment poverty. world development 23(9): 1495-1506. repetto, r. (1990). deforestation in the tropics. scientific america 262(4): 36-45. repetto, r.; holmes, t. (1983). the role of population in resource depletion in developing countries. population and development review 9(4): 609–632. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5753 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 58 rozelle, s.; huang, j.; zhang, l. (1997). poverty, population and environmental degradation in china. food policy 22(3): 229-251. rudel, t.k. (1989). population development and tropical deforestation. rural sociology 54(3): 327–338. rukuosietuo, k.; chatterjee, d.; deka, bidyut c.; kumar, r.; ao, merasenla.; konsam v. (2014). shifting cultivation: an ‘organic like’ farming in nagaland. indian journal of hill farming. 27(2): 23-28. sen, a.k. (1979). issues in the measurement of poverty. scandinavian journal of economics, 81: 285-307. serrao, e.a.; nepstad, d.; walker, r.t. (1996). upland agricultural and forestry development in the amazon: sustainability, criticality and resilience. ecological economics 18(1): 3-13. somanathan, e. (1991). deforestation, property rights and incentives in central himalayas. economic and political weekly 26(4): 37-46. statistical handbook, (1987). government of nagaland. kohima. statistical handbook, (1993). government of nagaland. kohima. statistical handbook, (2006). government of nagaland. kohima. statistical handbook, (2012).government of nagaland. kohima. statistical handbook, (2015). government of nagaland. kohima. stocking, m.a (2001). land degradation: an old problem with new urgency international encyclopedia of the social and behavioral sciences, 2001, 8242-8247. tiffen, m. (1993). productivity and environmental conservation under rapid population growth; a case study of machakos district. journal of international development 5(2): 207-224. trainer, f.e. (1990). environmental significance of development theory. ecological economics 2, 277–286. united nations, (1987). world commission on environment and development, ed. report of the world commission on environment and development: our common future. oxford: oxford university press. watts, h.w. (1968). an economic definition of poverty, in on understanding poverty, (eds.) by d. p. moynihan. new york: basic books. world bank, (1992). world development report. oxford university press, oxford. www. nagaland post, 9/12 2018. www.nagaland science and technology council, government of nagaland, kohima www. indian council of agriculture research, nagaland centre. www. remote sensing application centre, kohima, nagaland european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7691 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 20 examining the dimensionality of circular economy metrics using hierarchical clustering on principal components collin l. yobe1* 1 university of south africa, graduate school of business leadership, cnr janadel and, alexandra ave, midrand, 1686 (south africa) collinyobe@gmail.com *contact author orcid 0000-0001-5270-2192 received: 03/01/2024 accepted for publication: 26/04/2024 published: 30/04/2024 abstract the circular economy (ce) indices have become a valuable tool for supporting the development of policies that provide information that reduces environmental pressures and impacts. however, highly dimensional data identifying many ce indicators is impractical in application. this paper aims to create a composite index of the ce indicators using the hierarchical clustering on principal components (hcpc) to extract the meaning of the ce indicators, as reducing dimensionality can improve understanding of indicators and metrics. the advantage of the hcpc methodology over principal components analysis (pca) alone involves applying objective clustering techniques to the pca results, which results in a better cluster solution. this study analysed a dataset of 61 indicators obtained from de pascale, arbolino, szopikdepczyńska, limosani, and ioppolo (2021). the composite indices revealed the dimensions of industrial symbiosis (is), ce strategies, and spatial applications of the ce and is concepts. the bottom-up and top-down approaches for ce and is strategies have been the main implementation approaches in different governments and regions. keywords: circular economy, circular economy indicators, industrial symbiosis, hierarchical clustering on principal components european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7691 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 21 1. introduction the circular economy (ce) is being touted as a promising solution to mitigate human activities' growing environmental and resource pressures (bocken, de pauw, bakker, & van der grinten, 2016). several countries have adopted ce principles to achieve zero waste, a crucial goal for most economies as it reduces greenhouse emissions and environmental impacts from current linear waste production systems, making ce a crucial part of future strategies. a ce promotes system innovations to improve waste management resource efficiency and balance the economy, environment, and society (kristensen & mosgaard, 2020). the ce paradigm promotes autonomous production processes that reuse materials, generating increased interest in research and developing metrics for a circular shift. the interest in circularity indicators has led to extensive literature on ce. currently, there are three levels of indicators for measuring the ce, i.e., micro (companies, product), meso (industrial symbiosis (is), eco-industrial parks (eips)), and macro (governments, global, national, regional, city) (de oliveira, dantas, & soares, 2021; de pascale et al., 2021; kristensen & mosgaard, 2020; moraga et al., 2019). the rise of eips is a significant trend in the new industrial reality, aiming to promote environmental benefits and economic development through collaboration between companies (felicio, amaral, esposto, & durany, 2016). is promotes a collective approach to competitive advantage across industries by integrating the physical exchange of materials, energy, water, and byproducts into their business processes (felicio et al., 2016; geng, fu, sarkis, & xue, 2012; geng, zhang, ulgiati, & sarkis, 2010; jacobsen, 2006). moreover, as such, eips must be able to promote is. the is and ce are intricate subjects that require meticulous coordination due to the potential differences in preferences among various stakeholders. therefore, policymakers must take a direct lead in pushing and driving is and the ce. through legislation, governments have managed to work towards putting ce plans into action. the chinese government has played a significant role in the implementation of is. they can define policy, and everyone within the country follows. ce, adopted in china to promote economic growth despite material and energy limitations, has garnered significant global interest from governments, international bodies, industrial associations, and corporations (franklin-johnson, figge, & canning, 2016). china leads the ranking of countries that have contributed most to the increasing growth rate in research, implementation, and extensive development of ce concepts in academia and politics (de pascale et al., 2021; geng et al., 2012). in 2008, china was the first country to adopt legislation to deploy ce strategies by enacting a specific law, confirming china's prominence (de pascale et al., 2021; geng et al., 2012; moraga et al., 2019). unlike china, the european commission and its member countries use self-regulatory, bottom-up strategies for implementing ce strategies, which primarily rely on external factors (cayzer, griffiths, & beghetto, 2017; linder, sarasini, & van loon, 2017). the european commission and member countries employ self-regulatory, bottom-up approaches to implement ce strategies, unlike china, which primarily relies on external factors. ce is extensively researched, yet its practical application in economic initiatives remains a significant challenge. the extensive literature on ce necessitates rigorous analysis to ensure its relevance for functional purposes due to its disconnection. several studies have come to the fore and have identified ce indicators (argüelles, benavides, & fernández, 2014; de oliveira et al., 2021; de pascale et al., 2021; parchomenko, nelen, gillabel, & rechberger, 2019; stanković, janković-milić, marjanović, & european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7691 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 22 janjić, 2021). the current set of circularity metrics is criticised for failing to fully capture the multidisciplinary and systemic nature of the ce (stanković et al., 2021). these studies critically examine the dimensionality of ce indicators used in studies, highlighting their high dimensionality and potential limitations for practitioners. it suggests that reducing dimensionality can improve understanding of indicators and metrics. the research highlights the need for further knowledge of current research work. therefore, this paper aims to create a composite index of the ce indicators using the hierarchical clustering on principal components (hcpc) to extract the meaning of the ce indicators. a dataset of 61 indicators developed in a previous paper identified by de pascale et al. (2021) will be analysed using the hcpc to achieve the stated aim. this approach reduces data dimensionality and enables further understanding of the already-identified ce issues—is, spatial applications of the ce concept, and ce strategies. based on this dataset, the exercise attempts to cluster and classify indicators and papers to provide a structure for the problem. the rest of the document is structured as follows: section 2 offers an extensive review of circular economy (ce) indicators found in previous studies, providing an understanding of the many metrics and approaches used to evaluate ce performance. in section 3, the data sources and methodology of this study are explored. the analytical frameworks used for ce indicator analysis and classification, such as principal component analysis (pca) and hierarchical clustering, are explained. part 4 presents the pca analysis and hierarchical clustering findings, thoroughly studying the principal components and clusters found, thereby illuminating the underlying patterns and trends in the ce environment. ultimately, section 5 summarises the results derived from the research, emphasising the critical takeaways and implications for furthering ce initiatives. 2. review of ce indicators in research the growing resource demand and environmental issues drive a shift towards sustainable production and consumption (gallego-schmid, chen, sharmina, & mendoza, 2020). contemporary sustainability literature focuses on the potential of the ce to disrupt the unsustainable production and consumption linear economy (kristensen & mosgaard, 2020). however, considerable effort is required to transition toward a more ce (parchomenko et al., 2019). in transitioning to this ce economy, indices are fast becoming a valuable tool to support the development of policies in providing information and reducing environmental pressures and impacts (de pascale et al., 2021). there three main levels of indicators for measuring ce in the literature so far are macro (global, national, regional, city, governments), meso (is, eips), and micro (single firm, product) (de oliveira et al., 2021; de pascale et al., 2021; geng et al., 2012; kayal et al., 2019; kristensen & mosgaard, 2020; linder et al., 2017; mazur-wierzbicka, 2021; mccarthy, kapetanaki, & wang, 2019; moraga et al., 2019). de oliveira et al. (2021) present a fourth dimension, nano (products). the lack of detailed measurement and documentation of the ce's progress can hinder understanding of the subject matter, creating barriers for actors at the specific ce level. governments, policymakers, and business practitioners need more information on ce typologies to promote their business environment towards is. transitioning to a ce requires significant effort, but a widely accepted framework for monitoring progress is lacking due to the vast and diverse areas covered by different assessment methodologies (parchomenko et al., 2019). despite the concept's lack european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7691 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 23 of clarity, ce focuses on defining action plans supported by specific indicators (moraga et al., 2019). transitioning to circular systems may not always lead to favourable alternatives, as potential environmental, economic, or social trade-offs may arise (de oliveira et al., 2021). past ce research methodologies include reviews and empirical papers, with ce indicators classification, categorising and assessing existing work, with some articles developing a measurement method (de oliveira et al., 2021; kristensen & mosgaard, 2020). some of the approaches used in developing the metric for measuring ce indicators have included the (a) principal component analysis and promethee (de oliveira et al., 2021),(b) the multiple correspondence analysis (mca) (parchomenko et al., 2019), and (c) indicators grouped by using a double classification: first according to the three spatial dimensions of sustainability –macro, micro and meso – then based on the 3r core ce principles (de pascale et al., 2021). 3. data and methods 3.1 data collection the data for this research was obtained from de pascale et al. (2021) through a systematic literature review, and a final list of indicators was extracted and grouped into three clusters: micro, meso, and macro. the review process involved selecting academic databases, search terms, and screening for practical purposes. definitions and key concepts were determined, and the gathered material was summarised for future insights. the first step involved a systematic search for published ce indicator implementation studies. the study used a methodological approach to define and select a sampling framework to review circular economy (ce) indicators. the framework was based on a time scale of 2000-2019 and a preliminary search of existing literature in scopus and web of science databases. the results were refined using advanced search terms and keywords to identify the level of implementation of ce indicators at micro, meso, and macro spatial levels. a combination of selected keywords was chosen and compared with other ce reviews to ensure high-level significance. the keyword "circular economy" was selected to ensure coherence with the main topic. the academic databases were searched for spatial levels (micro, meso, and macro) and identified keywords for each level. the classification system includes micro-level (company), meso-level (circular economy), and macro-level (city, country, region) terms, combining them to create a comprehensive understanding of the circular economy. the categories of indicator, index, assessment, evaluation, and measuring were incorporated into the literature as they are frequently used in ce studies. the study enumerated 61 articles that were used for the analysis. 3.2 description of the explanatory variables table 1 shows the ce indicators identified by de pascale et al. (2021). the study quantified these as categorical variables by creating lists of indicators to capture the various attributes of ce indicators. the multivariate approach implemented the hierarchical clustering on principal components (hcpc). this multivariate approach uses principal component analysis (pca) and hierarchical cluster analysis (hca) on these attributes. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7691 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 24 table 1: description of the dimensions of circular economy indicators attributes description approach: it includes five subdivisions: quantitative, qualitative, vbi, analytical tool, and theoretical results. application-level: refers to product, materials, (embodied) energy, components, resource waste (/waste streams), product families, is districts and networks, national, regional, provincial, the european union (eu), and world regions. core ce principles: this category concerns the following core ce principles: reduce, reuse, recycle, recover, remanufacture, and redesign sustainable development dimensions: the dimensions are environmental, economic, and social. level of ce indicators: the spatial level applications of the circularity vary between macro as a city, region, or nation, meso – as eips (eco-eips) and is, and micro levels – as a single company or products using different methods and techniques. regions: the study considered the following regions: the united states of america (usa), europe, eu, belgium, netherlands, italy, england/ united kingdom (uk), india, spain, denmark, china, south korea, australia, jordan, japan, switzerland, and world regions. source: de pascale et al. (2021) 3.3 analytical techniques please use times new roman, size 10, for the text of your manuscript, including the main body, references, and footnotes. 3.3.1 multivariate approach for classification principal components analysis the study utilised principal component analysis (pca) to create typologies of ce indicators, a statistical method that reduces variables into smaller dimensions with minimal information loss (jolliffe, 2002). pca is a feature extraction technique that transforms an initial dataset of variables into a new uncorrelated dataset of orthogonal linear combinations (pcs). it aims to reduce the dimensionality of the data by obtaining the largest variance original variables, accounting for as much variation as possible (jolliffe, 2002; manly, 2005); this means that the first pc is the linear combination with the largest variance, while the second one is the linear combination with the second-largest variance, orthogonal to the first pc, etc. according to costello and osborne (2005), varimax rotation simplifies the data's factor structure and makes its interpretation more straightforward and reliable. the authors argue that varimax rotation, which produces uncorrelated factors, is superior to other rotation orthogonal methods like quartimax and equamax, as it cannot improve fundamental aspects of analysis like variance extraction. de pascale et al. (2021) grouped the indicators using a double classification: first, according to the three spatial dimensions of sustainability – macro, micro, and meso– and then based on the 3r core ce principles. the study mapped out dummy variables for indicators' attributes, such as level, country, analytical approach, application level, core ce principles, and sustainable development dimensions, but this approach failed to provide a clear group structure and dimensionality of the ce indicators in european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7691 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 25 the research. jolliffe (2002) posits that the approach to using cluster analysis is vital in cases where such a group structure is lacking. following vyas and kumaranayake (2006) and achia, wangombe, and khadioli (2010), pca was applied to the dummy variables to reduce the dimensionality of the data and categorise the ce indicators into distinct dimensions (jolliffe, 2002). the pca scores of ce indicators initially extracted and retained were followed by varimax rotation for the above reasons. the study used the kaiser-maier-olkin (kmo) and bartlett's sphericity tests to assess the suitability of the variables for pca. hair, black, babin, anderson, and tatham (2006) suggest that researchers should consider variables suitable if their kmo values exceed 0.5, and bartlett's sphericity test yields statistical significance at p<0.05. pcs with eigenvalues equal to or greater than 0.7 were retained, following jolliffe (2002). hierarchical cluster analysis the study used hierarchical clustering (hca) to classify ce indicators based on their similarity or dissimilarity. the technique uses euclidean distance as the dissimilarity metric. the research used pca on ce indicators' characteristics data, a hierarchical clustering method called hierarchical clustering on principal components (hcpc), to analyse the classification limits of ce indicators. hierarchical cluster analysis estimates the number of clusters in a dataset using principal component analysis (pca). the study uses ward's criterion to perform hierarchical clustering on all principal components derived from pca on the initial dataset of variables. ward's method estimates hierarchical clusters that create equal and evenly sized clusters, with solutions estimated based on cases and variables. several studies, including argüelles et al. (2014), have used hcpc and k-means clustering as candidate multivariate approaches. hcpc offers two main advantages: it applies objective clustering techniques to pca results, resulting in a better cluster solution than factorial analysis alone, and ward's classification enhances the robustness of the final clustering results. garson (2009), cited in yobe, mudhara, and mafongoya (2019), suggests that hierarchical clustering is the most suitable technique for data sets with less than 250 observations, indicating that datasets below this threshold are unsuitable. according to kaur and kaur (2013), the k-means algorithm outperforms the hierarchical algorithm on data sets with over 250 observations. however, preliminary analyses with a smaller sample size confirmed this, as the k-means clustering technique failed to adequately classify cases, leading to using the hcpc technique for multivariate classification. 4. results 4.1 descriptive statistics of the circular economy indicators the dummy variables were created to measure the variation of the ce indicators accurately, enabling a quantitative analysis of their performance. table 2 shows the descriptive statistics that measure the mean, standard deviation, minimum, and maximum. on average, the quantitative approach was extensively used, with a mean of 0.7458. the dominant application level is for product, and the mean value is 0.4068. the dummy variables were created to accurately measure the variation of the ce indicators, enabling a quantitative analysis of their performance. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7691 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 26 table 2: descriptive statistics of the circular economy indicators variable mean std. dev. min max approach: quantitative 0.7458 0.4392 0 1 qualitative 0.0847 0.2809 0 1 vbi 0.0678 0.2536 0 1 analytical tool 0.0170 0.1302 0 1 theoretical results 0.0169 0.1302 0 1 application-level: product 0.4068 0.4954 0 1 materials 0.1695 0.3784 0 1 (embodied) energy 0.0678 0.2536 0 1 components 0.0678 0.2536 0 1 resource waste (/ waste streams) 0.0508 0.2216 0 1 product families 0.0169 0.1302 0 1 industrial symbiosis districts and networks 0.1017 0.3048 0 1 national 0.0508 0.2216 0 1 regional 0.0847 0.2809 0 1 provincial 0.0339 0.1825 0 1 eu 0.0678 0.2536 0 1 world regions 0.0170 0.1302 0 1 core ce principles: reduce 0.5593 0.5007 0 1 reuse 0.6610 0.4774 0 1 recycle 0.8136 0.3928 0 1 recover 0.1356 0.3456 0 1 remanufacture 0.1864 0.3928 0 1 redesign 0.1017 0.3048 0 1 sustainable development dimensions: environmental 0.8983 0.3048 0 1 economic 0.9153 0.2803 0 1 social 0.4746 0.5036 0 1 level of ce indicators: micro-level 0.5085 0.5042 0 1 macro-level 0.2373 0.4291 0 1 regions: usa 0.0508 0.2216 0 1 europe 0.0169 0.1302 0 1 eu 0.1017 0.3048 0 1 belgium 0.0508 0.2216 0 1 netherlands 0.0339 0.1825 0 1 italy 0.0169 0.1302 0 1 england/uk 0.0339 0.1825 0 1 european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7691 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 27 variable mean std. dev. min max approach: india 0.0169 0.1302 0 1 spain 0.0169 0.1302 0 1 denmark 0.0169 0.1302 0 1 china 0.0169 0.1302 0 1 south korea 0.0169 0.1302 0 1 australia 0.0169 0.1302 0 1 jordan 0.0169 0.1302 0 1 japan 0.0169 0.1302 0 1 switzerland 0.0169 0.1302 0 1 world regions 0.0169 0.1302 0 1 source: de pascale et al. (2021) observations = 58. vbi is a value-based indicator/evaluation indicator system. 4.2 multivariate analysis results the results of the multivariate analysis, which employed the pca, are presented below. table 3 shows the level of the scree plot of the estimated pcs of ce indicators. 28 table 3: estimated pcs of circular economy indicators component 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 15 16 initial eigenvalues: % of variance 13.014 7.314 5.636 5.438 5.388 4.722 4.252 3.760 3.540 3.471 3.267 3.034 2.859 2.643 2.582 cumulative % 13.014 20.328 25.964 31.402 36.790 41.512 45.764 49.524 53.064 56.535 59.801 62.835 65.694 68.337 70.980 approach: quantitative -0.464 -0.426 qualitative 0.887 value-based indicator/evaluation indicator system 0.824 analytical tool theoretical results 0.910 core ce principles: reduce 0.694 0.316 reuse 0.480 recycle 0.706 recover 0.731 remanufacture -0.350 0.530 -0.499 redesign 0.604 -0.320 0.568 sustain. develop. dimensions: environmental 0.448 0.356 0.358 economic 0.791 social 0.632 level of ce indicators: micro-level -0.857 macro-level 0.637 application-level: product -0.811 materials -0.445 0.351 0.446 components 0.538 -0.601 resource waste (/ waste streams) 0.836 product families 0.843 industrial symbiosis districts and networks -0.524 0.453 european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7691 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 29 component 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 15 16 national 0.547 0.734 regional 0.549 -0.375 provincial 0.671 (embodied) energy 0.868 regions: usa 0.513 0.743 europe 0.769 eu 0.342 0.441 0.636 belgium -0.377 -0.309 netherlands 0.826 italy 0.847 england/uk 0.889 india 0.888 spain -0.808 denmark china 0.694 0.315 south korea australia -0.846 jordan 0.858 japan 0.897 world regions 0.911 source: de pascale et al. (2021) extraction method: principal component analysis; rotation method: varimax with kaiser normalization. the coefficients with a value of 0.3 and less were suppressed and not displayed in the estimated pc scores results. kaiser-meyer-olkin measure of sampling adequacy = 0.291; bartlett’s test of sphericity approx. chi-square = 1301.698; df = 903; sig. = 0.000. pc 14, which explained 2.77% of the variance, was dropped from the analysis because the variation explained by the factor loadings did not make economic sense. 30 the application of pca on the attributes of the ce indicators produced initial eigenvalues 1.015, 19 pcs that explained a cumulative 80.941% of the variance in the dummy variables but only retained 15 pcs for the analysis table 4. this study dropped pc 14 – which accounts for 2.77% – from the analysis because the variation it explained did not make economic sense. therefore, the total variance explained by the pcs used in this analysis was 70.92%. the study dropped two variables – the meso-level of ce indicators and eips – because the rotation failed to converge in estimating the pca's rotated component matrix. the study utilised kmo and bartlett's sphericity measures to assess the feasibility of incorporating 58 cases of indicators into a dataset. the kmo measure showed a 0.291 value, indicating a significant relationship between variables. bartlett's test showed a p<0.001 correlation, indicating variables could be factored in. varimax with the kaiser normalisation rotation method improved pc interpretation. the scree plot below shows the estimated pcs (figure 1). the study plots eigenvalue against pcs, with pc1 having the highest score loadings and a high eigenvalue. pc-2 explains less variation and has a lesser eigenvalue. the study estimates diminishing declines of eigenvalue with other pcs, using a cut-off of pcs with an eigenvalue of 1 and considering pcs that met this criterion. figure 1: scree plot of the estimated pcs of ce indicators source: author's elaboration the first principal component (pc–1) explains 13.01% of the variance in the indicators of ce, with the estimated component loadings expressed in the following equation: 𝑃𝐶–1 = 0.694 𝑅𝑒𝑑𝑢𝑐𝑒 𝐶𝐸 𝑝𝑟𝑖𝑛𝑐𝑖𝑝𝑙𝑒𝑠 − 0.350 𝑅𝑒𝑚𝑎𝑛𝑢𝑓𝑎𝑐𝑡𝑢𝑟𝑒 𝐶𝐸 𝑝𝑟𝑖𝑛𝑐𝑖𝑝𝑙𝑒𝑠 + 0.448 𝐸𝑛𝑣𝑖𝑟𝑜𝑛𝑚𝑒𝑛𝑡𝑎𝑙 𝑆𝑢𝑠𝑡𝑎𝑖𝑛𝑎𝑏𝑙𝑒 𝐷𝑒𝑣𝑒𝑙𝑜𝑝𝑚𝑒𝑛𝑡 𝐷𝑖𝑚𝑒𝑛𝑠𝑖𝑜𝑛𝑠 + 0.632 𝑆𝑜𝑐𝑖𝑎𝑙 𝑆𝑢𝑠𝑡𝑎𝑖𝑛𝑎𝑏𝑙𝑒 𝐷𝑒𝑣𝑒𝑙𝑜𝑝𝑚𝑒𝑛𝑡 𝐷𝑖𝑚𝑒𝑛𝑠𝑖𝑜𝑛𝑠 − 0.857 𝑀𝑖𝑐𝑟𝑜 − 𝑙𝑒𝑣𝑒𝑙 𝑜𝑓 𝐶𝐸 𝑖𝑛𝑑𝑖𝑐𝑎𝑡𝑜𝑟𝑠 + 0.637 𝑀𝑎𝑐𝑟𝑜 − 𝑙𝑒𝑣𝑒𝑙 𝑜𝑓 𝐶𝐸 𝑖𝑛𝑑𝑖𝑐𝑎𝑡𝑜𝑟𝑠 − 0.811 𝑃𝑟𝑜𝑑𝑢𝑐𝑡 𝐴𝑝𝑝𝑙𝑖𝑐𝑎𝑡𝑖𝑜𝑛 − 𝑙𝑒𝑣𝑒𝑙 − 0.445 𝑀𝑎𝑡𝑒𝑟𝑖𝑎𝑙𝑠 𝐴𝑝𝑝𝑙𝑖𝑐𝑎𝑡𝑖𝑜𝑛 − 𝑙𝑒𝑣𝑒𝑙 + 0.549 𝑅𝑒𝑔𝑖𝑜𝑛𝑎𝑙 𝐴𝑝𝑝𝑙𝑖𝑐𝑎𝑡𝑖𝑜𝑛 − 𝑙𝑒𝑣𝑒𝑙 − 0.377 𝐵𝑒𝑙𝑔𝑖𝑢𝑚 + 0.694 𝐶ℎ𝑖𝑛𝑎. 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 1 3 5 7 9 11 13 15 17 19 21 23 25 27 29 31 33 35 37 39 41 43 ei ge nv al ue component number european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7691 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 31 in pc–1, reduce ce principles, social sustainable development dimensions, and macro-level ce indicators were the most dominant loadings variables. therefore, this pc was named reduce ce principles. pc–2 explains 7.314% of the variance, and the most dominant loadings were on the materials application-level and in the usa, eu, england/uk and india regions; this pc was thus called materials application-level. pc–3 accounts for 5.64% of the variance with dominant loadings on recover ce principles, energy (embodied) application-level and the eu region and was intuitively named energy (embodied) application level. pc–4 was called national application-level because the most significant loading for this component was the national application level; the other loading for this coefficient was the usa and eu regions. the fifth component, pc–5, which accounted for 5.34% of the variation in the pc estimation, was called diverse applicationlevel because it had loading for application-level variables, namely components, resource waste and product families. the sixth component, pc–6, recover and redesign ce principles qualitative approach, accounted for 4.72% of the variation and had significant loadings on qualitative – and negatively so on quantitative – approach, as well as recover and redesign ce principles. the seventh component, pc–7, was named sustainable development economic dimension because this pc had dominant positive loadings on the sustainable development economic. the study revealed that redesign ce principles, specifically pc-8, accounted for 3.76% of the study's variation. pc-8 had positive coefficients for recycle and remanufacture ce principles, positive coefficients for materials and components application-level, and negative coefficients for the research approach. pc-9 had significant coefficient loadings on regional and provincial variables and china region. hence pc–9 was called approach value-based indicator/ evaluation indicator system and accounted for 3.54% of the variance. pc–10, named application level national and world regions, had dominant coefficient loadings of 0.734 application level national and 0.911 for the world regions, accounting for 3.47% of the variation. the next component, pc–11, accounted for 3.26% of the variation. the variables redesign ce principles and environmental sustainable development dimensions had positive coefficient loadings of 0.568 and 0.356, respectively; this pc was called redesign ce principles environmental sustainable development dimensions. pc–12 is accounted for by 3.034% of the variation and represents the dimension of the ce indicators with significant coefficient loadings on the variables for the theoretical results approach and the eu region; this pc was thus identified as the theoretical results approach. pc-13, accounting for 2.86%, showed positive coefficient loadings on reuse ce principles, while negative coefficient loadings were observed on is districts, networks application-level, and australia. the next component, reduce ce principle and environmental sustainability development dimensions, accounted for 2.64% of the variation. the component loadings of the coefficients on the variables are as follows: 𝑃𝐶–14 = 0.316 𝑅𝑒𝑑𝑢𝑐𝑒 𝐶𝐸 𝑝𝑟𝑖𝑛𝑐𝑖𝑝𝑙𝑒𝑠 + 0.358 𝐸𝑛𝑣𝑖𝑟𝑜𝑛𝑚𝑒𝑛𝑡𝑎𝑙 𝑆𝑢𝑠𝑡𝑎𝑖𝑛𝑎𝑏𝑖𝑙𝑖𝑡𝑦 𝐷𝑒𝑣𝑒𝑙𝑜𝑝𝑚𝑒𝑛𝑡 𝐷𝑖𝑚𝑒𝑛𝑠𝑖𝑜𝑛𝑠 – 0.309 𝐵𝑒𝑙𝑔𝑖𝑢𝑚 + 0.826 𝑁𝑒𝑡ℎ𝑒𝑟𝑙𝑎𝑛𝑑𝑠. the pc-16, the application-level pc, represents coefficient loadings on is districts and networks in the jordan region, exhibiting minimal variation in ce indicator scores. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7691 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 32 4.2.1 hierarchical clustering the hcpc analysis uses the hca to analyse the pca outcome. figure 2 displays a dendrogram representing the hca result, with the vertical axis representing observations and clusters and the horizontal axis representing the distance between them. similar observations are grouped based on their dissimilarity, allowing for better understanding and classification. figure 2 shows a hierarchical dendrogram, where pcs are extracted and arranged into new clusters along the y-axis. each branch represents connections, and the closer they are to each other, the more related they are. for instance, pc-6 and 15 are members of one cluster from a branch that splits into two, similar to the next group comprising pcs 13, 16, 9, and 8. however, the group composed of pc-2 and pc-4 is far apart in the chart. an imaginary cut-off point in a dendrogram creates a cluster, which becomes larger and more heterogeneous as the branching diagram moves up. this results in more variation within the cluster. for example, two variables next to each other, like pc-6 and pc-15, will be similar. expanding the group, like one large group with pcs 6, 15, 13, 16, 9, 8, 5, 7, and 1, will result in more similar observations than grouped observations in another branch. however, there is still much variation in each group, necessitating a trade-off decision on where to make the cut-off. the study identifies two clusters in a dendrogram, with each observation in the clusters being similar. large clusters, with more observations, are more heterogeneous. the choice of meaningful clusters depends on the degree of change in grouping due to slight deviations. the study suggests a two-cluster solution on the dendrogram, while figure 3 has a four-cluster solution. the ideal variation is minimally affecting solutions. the study's findings align with this rationale. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7691 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 33 clustering solutions by variables figure 2: hierarchical clustering and initial partition solutions by variables source: author's elaboration on linkage method—ward's method. euclidean distance of all elements european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7691 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 34 table 4 shows references with their title and country for each cluster that result from the dendrogram in figure 2. the pc-16, also known as the application-level pc, represents coefficient loadings on is districts and networks in the jordan region, exhibiting minimal variation in ce indicator score (guo-gang, 2011; li & su, 2012; xiong, dang, & qian, 2011). other studies in this set of results focus on industrial parks (felicio et al., 2016; geng, zhang, côté, & fujita, 2009; geng et al., 2010; tiejun, 2010; wenbo, 2011; zhao, guo, & zhao, 2018), while the case studies included (adibi, lafhaj, yehya, & payet, 2017; bovea & pérez-belis, 2018; huysman, de schaepmeester, ragaert, dewulf, & de meester, 2017; huysman et al., 2015; sałabun, palczewski, & wątróbski, 2019). the countries that dominated the studies included china, eu members, belgium, and the usa. table 4: list of clusters by references, article and countries cluster reference country 1 das, yedlarajiah, and narendra (2000) lee, lu, and song (2014) macarthur (2015) europe huysman et al. (2017) belgium; england mohamed sultan, lou, and mativenga (2017) uk; eu; usa; india azevedo, godina, and matias (2017) mesa, esparragoza, and maury (2018) vanegas et al. (2018) belgium 2 nelen et al. (2014) j. y. park and chertow (2014) usa eu huysman et al. (2015) belgium scheepens, vogtländer, and brezet (2016) netherlands cayzer et al. (2017) figge, thorpe, givry, canning, and franklin-johnson (2018); franklin-johnson et al. (2016) van schaik and reuter (2016) linder et al. (2017) di maio, rem, baldé, and polder (2017) netherlands favi, germani, luzi, mandolini, and marconi (2017) adibi et al. (2017) figge et al. (2018) marconi, germani, mandolini, and favi (2019) mandolini, favi, germani, and marconi (2018) european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7691 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 35 cluster reference country cong, zhao, and sutherland (2019) zwolinski, lopez-ontiveros, and brissaud (2006) jacobsen (2006) denmark karlsson and wolf (2008) geng et al. (2010) china sałabun et al. (2019) wen and li (2010) china geng et al. (2009) china su, heshmati, geng, and yu (2013) china geng et al. (2012) china wenbo (2011) china li and su (2012) beijing china wen and li (2010) china h.-s. park and behera (2014) south korea pagotto and halog (2016) australia felicio et al. (2016) zhao et al. (2018) china tiejun (2010) china geng, liu, liu, zhao, and xue (2011) china guo-gang (2011) china faizi, rashid, sałabun, zafar, and wątróbski (2018) china chun-rong and jun (2011) qing, qiongqiong, and mingyue (2011) china xiong et al. (2011) china wu, shi, xia, and zhu (2014) china haas, krausmann, wiedenhofer, and heinz (2015) eu members haupt, vadenbo, and hellweg (2017) switzerland tisserant et al. (2017) world regions moraga et al. (2019) mayer et al. (2019) eu members fregonara, giordano, ferrando, and pattono (2017) italy moriguchi (2007) eu; usa; japan 3 bovea and pérez-belis (2018) spain kayal et al. (2019) jordan 4 smol, kulczycka, and avdiushchenko (2017) eu members source: author's elaboration european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7691 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 36 5. discussion firms, governments, and regional authorities have started recognising environmental benefits and economic growth through collaboration between companies that flow directly from is—generating better collective benefits than could have been achieved from the sum of all individual benefits combined (bocken et al., 2016; felicio et al., 2016; jacobsen, 2006; karlsson & wolf, 2008). is offers several benefits, including reducing waste disposal costs by converting waste into by-products for other industries, enabling innovation and process development, leading to increased profitability, and benefiting from the geographical proximity of businesses (bocken et al., 2016; karlsson & wolf, 2008). creating a composite index can help better understand the ce indicators and measure the development of the ce guides. applying pca based on the above data reduced the dimensionality of the 58 – previously 61 – ce indicators in de pascale et al. (2021) to 15 pcs, which could be classified. table 4 shows the list of the hcpc composite indices based on the title of the articles and the regions where these studies took place. this technique provides a structural approach to navigating the multifaceted realm of circular economy indicators. the hcpc reduced estimated pcs, resulting in terminal elements of the dendrogram from hierarchical classification. the dendrogram yielded four clusters of ce indicators, determining the group's ce performance based on specific characteristics, like countries with similar features (stanković et al., 2021). the understanding of regional and global trends is improved by this hierarchical classification, which provides a systematic framework for identifying distinctive groupings within the ce landscape. the areas in this first cluster include european countries (huysman et al., 2017; mccarthy et al., 2019; mohamed sultan et al., 2017; vanegas et al., 2018), the usa (mohamed sultan et al., 2017) and india (mohamed sultan et al., 2017). this first cluster displays a variation of approaches within different national contexts, spotlighting geographical concentrations of ce initiatives. due to the need to respond to the impacts of unsustainable linear production methods, ce approaches will likely provide a compelling driver across many different governments, countries and regions. das et al. (2000), lee et al. (2014), and mesa et al. (2018) in the first cluster did not focus on a particular region in their research. the first two of these studies focused on estimating the end-of-life product disassembly effort and cost and assessing product end-of-life performance. the last of the two studies focused on developing a sustainable circular index. the diverse research focus within this cluster illustrates the breadth of ce initiatives, spanning multiple geographical contexts and ranging from index development to product lifecycle analysis. the following aggregation obtained after applying the hcpc, i.e. cluster 2, shows studies in europe (di maio et al., 2017; haas et al., 2015; huysman et al., 2015; jacobsen, 2006; mayer et al., 2019; scheepens et al., 2016), the usa (j. y. park & chertow, 2014), south korea (h.-s. park & behera, 2014), china (faizi et al., 2018; geng et al., 2012; geng et al., 2011; geng et al., 2009; geng et al., 2010; guo-gang, 2011; li & su, 2012; su et al., 2013; tiejun, 2010; wen & li, 2010; wenbo, 2011; wu et al., 2014; xiong et al., 2011; zhao et al., 2018), australia (pagotto & halog, 2016) and the world regions (tisserant et al., 2017). this second cluster has a broad geographical scope and implicates the variable approaches adopted by different countries and regions and the global reach of ce initiatives. most of these primarily focused on industrial parks (felicio et al., european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7691 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 37 2016; geng et al., 2009; geng et al., 2010; tiejun, 2010; wenbo, 2011; zhao et al., 2018). industrial parks in china are for environmental and economic growth benefits, and collaboration between companies is critical in realising this achievement; thus, it is crucial to promoting is. according to felicio et al. (2016), the is in eips requires the implementation of intense broker involvement. impediments to the level of symbiosis during operations usually are market changes and technological advancement. wenbo (2011) further posits that developing ce is the only way to realise the new industrialisation, and building eips is an essential means of promoting ce performance. the next area of focus in this cluster that received attention from researchers is that of is, which includes research done in china (geng et al., 2009), denmark (jacobsen, 2006), south korea (h.-s. park & behera, 2014) and australia (pagotto & halog, 2016). the importance of collaborative efforts in promoting circular economy performance—particularly in industrialised nations—is highlighted by the focus on industrial parks as hubs for sustainability initiatives. the cluster solution suggests a lack of coverage of ce approaches, leading to a lack of studies. these approaches may have been developed to address a specific ce problem but were never expanded to other areas. they may also be challenging to set up in regions with similar ce issues, becoming unsupported and ineffective; this could be the case with two clusters. nonetheless, the research gaps identified in ce indicate potential areas for further research and strategic intervention to advance more comprehensive and successful circular economy initiatives. cluster 3 comprises two studies (fregonara et al., 2017; moriguchi, 2007) of the hcpc aggregates. studies conducted in italy, the eu, the usa, and japan examined resource productivity indicators and environmental impact. the need to address environmental issues, such as waste reduction and pollution, is a common response to widely accepted action plans. this third cluster explores resource productivity and environmental impacts, highlighting the ongoing need to address pressing environmental issues across geographic boundaries through sustained research and policy interventions. cluster 4 classifies the studies focusing on circular design guidelines in spain (bovea & pérez-belis, 2018), measuring a firm's circularity in the water industry in jordan (kayal et al., 2019), and ce indicators concerning eco-innovation in the eu member countries (smol et al., 2017). this final cluster focuses on particular ce initiatives, such as industrial circularity, design guidelines, and eco-innovation, and illustrates the various strategic approaches used in multiple industries and regions.our journal adheres to the apa 7th edition style for citations and references. please ensure that all citations in the text and the reference list comply with this format. 6. conclusions the study used hcpc to identify clusters in a dataset with 61 ce indicators, retaining 58 after data cleaning, utilising complementarities between clustering and principal components methods. the first stage estimation of pca only allowed for 15 of the 16 pcs to be meaningfully interpreted. the hcpc clustering technique from four clusters provided a better cluster solution than the principal components method, identifying research dimensions such as is, ce strategies, and spatial arrangement. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7691 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 38 policy recommendations for is and ce subjects require coordination among stakeholders with diverse agendas. policymakers must lead the implementation of policies related to these subjects. despite different approaches, governments and regions are adopting actions that drive the agenda forward. china has successfully used a top-down approach to policy implementation, allowing the government to prescribe policies and have everyone adopt them. this top-down approach could be a crucial lead for other countries seeking similar practices to follow. china's top-down approach could serve as a model for other countries. the bottom-up approach to policy implementation has been successful in european countries, with governments, regions, and businesses realising the benefits of adopting such policies. these systems receive support and spread quickly, often guided by an overarching goal. the central role of government is critical in implementing regulations that fit the purpose, ensuring that well-established and beneficial systems receive support and spread quickly. the specific impacts of top-down and bottom-up policy approaches on is and ce projects in many geographic and cultural situations may be the subject of future research. furthermore, examining how well various stakeholder coordination mechanisms work to implement policies will shed light on how to improve cooperation and alignment in is and ce to achieve shared objectives. furthermore, looking into possible synergies between top-down and bottom-up techniques may provide insightful information about optimising policy frameworks for scalability and maximum efficacy. understanding how to successfully negotiate the complicated terrain of corporate environmentalism can be improved by looking into these areas further, which will ultimately lead to better-informed decision-making and sustainable worldwide practices. 7. conflict of interest the author has no conflict of interest to declare. 6. references achia, t. n., wangombe, a., & khadioli, n. (2010). a logistic regression model to identify key determinants of poverty using demographic and health survey data. european journal of social sciences, 13(1), 38-45. adibi, n., lafhaj, z., yehya, m., & payet, j. (2017). global resource indicator for life cycle impact assessment: applied in wind turbine case study. journal of cleaner production, 165, 1517-1528. argüelles, m., benavides, c., & fernández, i. (2014). a new approach to the identification of regional clusters: hierarchical clustering on principal components. applied economics, 46(21), 2511-2519. azevedo, s. g., godina, r., & matias, j. c. d. o. (2017). proposal of a sustainable circular index for manufacturing companies. resources, 6(4), 63. bocken, n. m., de pauw, i., bakker, c., & van der grinten, b. (2016). product design and business model strategies for a circular economy. journal of industrial and production engineering, 33(5), 308-320. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7691 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 39 bovea, m. d., & pérez-belis, v. (2018). identifying design guidelines to meet the circular economy principles: a case study on electric and electronic equipment. journal of environmental management, 228, 483-494. doi:https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jenvman.2018.08.014 cayzer, s., griffiths, p., & beghetto, v. (2017). design of indicators for measuring product performance in the circular economy. international journal of sustainable engineering, 10(4-5), 289-298. chun-rong, j., & jun, z. (2011). evaluation of regional circular economy based on matter element analysis. procedia environmental sciences, 11, 637-642. cong, l., zhao, f., & sutherland, j. w. (2019). a design method to improve end-of-use product value recovery for circular economy. journal of mechanical design, 141(4). costello, a. b., & osborne, j. w. (2005). best practices in exploratory factor analysis: four recommendations for getting the most from your analysis. practical assessment, research & evaluation, 10(7), 1-9. das, s. k., yedlarajiah, p., & narendra, r. (2000). an approach for estimating the end-of-life product disassembly effort and cost. international journal of production research, 38(3), 657-673. doi:10.1080/002075400189356 de oliveira, c. t., dantas, t. e. t., & soares, s. r. (2021). nano and micro level circular economy indicators: assisting decision-makers in circularity assessments. sustainable production and consumption, 26, 455-468. doi:https://doi.org/10.1016/j.spc.2020.11.024 de pascale, a., arbolino, r., szopik-depczyńska, k., limosani, m., & ioppolo, g. (2021). a systematic review for measuring circular economy: the 61 indicators. journal of cleaner production, 281, 124942. doi:https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2020.124942 di maio, f., rem, p. c., baldé, k., & polder, m. (2017). measuring resource efficiency and circular economy: a market value approach. resources, conservation and recycling, 122, 163-171. faizi, s., rashid, t., sałabun, w., zafar, s., & wątróbski, j. (2018). decision making with uncertainty using hesitant fuzzy sets. international journal of fuzzy systems, 20(1), 93-103. favi, c., germani, m., luzi, a., mandolini, m., & marconi, m. (2017). a design for eol approach and metrics to favour closed-loop scenarios for products. international journal of sustainable engineering, 10(3), 136-146. felicio, m., amaral, d., esposto, k., & durany, x. g. (2016). industrial symbiosis indicators to manage eco-industrial parks as dynamic systems. journal of cleaner production, 118, 54-64. figge, f., thorpe, a. s., givry, p., canning, l., & franklin-johnson, e. (2018). longevity and circularity as indicators of eco-efficient resource use in the circular economy. ecological economics, 150, 297-306. franklin-johnson, e., figge, f., & canning, l. (2016). resource duration as a managerial indicator for circular economy performance. journal of cleaner production, 133, 589-598. fregonara, e., giordano, r., ferrando, d. g., & pattono, s. (2017). economic-environmental indicators to support investment decisions: a focus on the buildings’ end-of-life stage. buildings, 7(3), 65. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7691 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 40 gallego-schmid, a., chen, h.-m., sharmina, m., & mendoza, j. m. f. (2020). links between circular economy and climate change mitigation in the built environment. journal of cleaner production, 260, 121115. doi:https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2020.121115 garson, d. (2009). reliability analysis. [online]. available at: http://faculty. chass. ncsu. edu/garson/pa765/reliab. htm. in: accessed 15 sep 2017. geng, y., fu, j., sarkis, j., & xue, b. (2012). towards a national circular economy indicator system in china: an evaluation and critical analysis. journal of cleaner production, 23(1), 216-224. doi:https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2011.07.005 geng, y., liu, y., liu, d., zhao, h., & xue, b. (2011). regional societal and ecosystem metabolism analysis in china: a multi-scale integrated analysis of societal metabolism (msiasm) approach. energy, 36(8), 4799-4808. geng, y., zhang, p., côté, r. p., & fujita, t. (2009). assessment of the national eco‐industrial park standard for promoting industrial symbiosis in china. journal of industrial ecology, 13(1), 15-26. geng, y., zhang, p., ulgiati, s., & sarkis, j. (2010). emergy analysis of an industrial park: the case of dalian, china. science of the total environment, 408(22), 5273-5283. doi:https://doi.org/10.1016/j.scitotenv.2010.07.081 guo-gang, j. (2011). empirical analysis of regional circular economy development--study based on jiangsu, heilongjiang, qinghai province. energy procedia, 5, 125-129. haas, w., krausmann, f., wiedenhofer, d., & heinz, m. (2015). how circular is the global economy?: an assessment of material flows, waste production, and recycling in the european union and the world in 2005. journal of industrial ecology, 19(5), 765-777. hair, j. f., black, w. c., babin, b. j., anderson, r. e., & tatham, r. l. (2006). multivariate data analysis (vol. 6). pearson prentice hall upper saddle river. haupt, m., vadenbo, c., & hellweg, s. (2017). do we have the right performance indicators for the circular economy?: insight into the swiss waste management system. journal of industrial ecology, 21(3), 615-627. huysman, s., de schaepmeester, j., ragaert, k., dewulf, j., & de meester, s. (2017). performance indicators for a circular economy: a case study on post-industrial plastic waste. resources, conservation and recycling, 120, 46-54. doi:https://doi.org/10.1016/j.resconrec.2017.01.013 huysman, s., debaveye, s., schaubroeck, t., de meester, s., ardente, f., mathieux, f., & dewulf, j. (2015). the recyclability benefit rate of closed-loop and open-loop systems: a case study on plastic recycling in flanders. resources, conservation and recycling, 101, 53-60. jacobsen, n. b. (2006). industrial symbiosis in kalundborg, denmark: a quantitative assessment of economic and environmental aspects. journal of industrial ecology, 10(1‐2), 239-255. jolliffe, i. t. (2002). principal component analysis and factor analysis. in principal component analysis (pp. 150-166). karlsson, m., & wolf, a. (2008). using an optimisation model to evaluate the economic benefits of industrial symbiosis in the forest industry. journal of cleaner production, 16(14), 1536-1544. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7691 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 41 kaur, m., & kaur, u. (2013). comparison between k-means and hierarchical algorithm using query redirection. international journal of advanced research in computer science and software engineering, 3(7), 1454-1459. kayal, b., abu-ghunmi, d., abu-ghunmi, l., archenti, a., nicolescu, m., larkin, c., & corbet, s. (2019). an economic index for measuring firm’s circularity: the case of water industry. journal of behavioral and experimental finance, 21, 123129. doi:https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jbef.2018.11.007 kristensen, h. s., & mosgaard, m. a. (2020). a review of micro level indicators for a circular economy–moving away from the three dimensions of sustainability? journal of cleaner production, 243, 118531. lee, h. m., lu, w. f., & song, b. (2014). a framework for assessing product end-of-life performance: reviewing the state of the art and proposing an innovative approach using an end-of-life index. journal of cleaner production, 66, 355-371. li, r., & su, c. (2012). evaluation of the circular economy development level of chinese chemical enterprises. procedia environmental sciences, 13, 1595-1601. linder, m., sarasini, s., & van loon, p. (2017). a metric for quantifying product‐level circularity. journal of industrial ecology, 21(3), 545-558. macarthur, e. (2015). circularity indicators: an approach to measuring circularity. methodology, 23. mandolini, m., favi, c., germani, m., & marconi, m. (2018). time-based disassembly method: how to assess the best disassembly sequence and time of target components in complex products. the international journal of advanced manufacturing technology, 95(1), 409-430. manly, b. f. (2005). tests of significance with multivariate data. in multivariate statistical methods: a primer, (3rd ed.) (pp. 105-124). boca raton, fl: chapman & hall. marconi, m., germani, m., mandolini, m., & favi, c. (2019). applying data mining technique to disassembly sequence planning: a method to assess effective disassembly time of industrial products. international journal of production research, 57(2), 599-623. mayer, a., haas, w., wiedenhofer, d., krausmann, f., nuss, p., & blengini, g. a. (2019). measuring progress towards a circular economy: a monitoring framework for economy‐wide material loop closing in the eu28. journal of industrial ecology, 23(1), 62-76. mazur-wierzbicka, e. (2021). circular economy: advancement of european union countries. environmental sciences europe, 33(1), 1-15. mccarthy, b., kapetanaki, a. b., & wang, p. (2019). circular agri-food approaches: will consumers buy novel products made from vegetable waste? rural society, 28(2), 91-107. mesa, j., esparragoza, i., & maury, h. (2018). developing a set of sustainability indicators for product families based on the circular economy model. journal of cleaner production, 196, 1429-1442. mohamed sultan, a. a., lou, e., & mativenga, p. t. (2017). what should be recycled: an integrated model for product recycling desirability. journal of cleaner production, 154, 51-60. doi:https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2017.03.201 european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7691 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 42 moraga, g., huysveld, s., mathieux, f., blengini, g. a., alaerts, l., van acker, k., dewulf, j. (2019). circular economy indicators: what do they measure? resources, conservation and recycling, 146, 452-461. doi:https://doi.org/10.1016/j.resconrec.2019.03.045 moriguchi, y. (2007). material flow indicators to measure progress toward a sound material-cycle society. journal of material cycles and waste management, 9(2), 112-120. doi:10.1007/s10163-007-0182-0 nelen, d., manshoven, s., peeters, j. r., vanegas, p., d'haese, n., & vrancken, k. (2014). a multidimensional indicator set to assess the benefits of weee material recycling. journal of cleaner production, 83, 305-316. pagotto, m., & halog, a. (2016). towards a circular economy in australian agri‐food industry: an application of input‐ output oriented approaches for analysing resource efficiency and competitiveness potential. journal of industrial ecology, 20(5), 1176-1186. parchomenko, a., nelen, d., gillabel, j., & rechberger, h. (2019). measuring the circular economy a multiple correspondence analysis of 63 metrics. journal of cleaner production, 210, 200-216. doi:https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2018.10.357 park, h.-s., & behera, s. k. (2014). methodological aspects of applying eco-efficiency indicators to industrial symbiosis networks. journal of cleaner production, 64, 478-485. park, j. y., & chertow, m. r. (2014). establishing and testing the “reuse potential” indicator for managing wastes as resources. journal of environmental management, 137, 45-53. qing, y., qiongqiong, g., & mingyue, c. (2011). study and integrative evaluation on the development of circular economy of shaanxi province. energy procedia, 5, 1568-1578. sałabun, w., palczewski, k., & wątróbski, j. (2019). multicriteria approach to sustainable transport evaluation under incomplete knowledge: electric bikes case study. sustainability, 11(12), 3314. scheepens, a. e., vogtländer, j. g., & brezet, j. c. (2016). two life cycle assessment (lca) based methods to analyse and design complex (regional) circular economy systems. case: making water tourism more sustainable. journal of cleaner production, 114, 257-268. doi:https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2015.05.075 smol, m., kulczycka, j., & avdiushchenko, a. (2017). circular economy indicators in relation to eco-innovation in european regions. clean technologies and environmental policy, 19(3), 669-678. doi:10.1007/s10098-016-1323-8 stanković, j. j., janković-milić, v., marjanović, i., & janjić, j. (2021). an integrated approach of pca and promethee in spatial assessment of circular economy indicators. waste management, 128, 154-166. doi:https://doi.org/10.1016/j.wasman.2021.04.057 su, b., heshmati, a., geng, y., & yu, x. (2013). a review of the circular economy in china: moving from rhetoric to implementation. journal of cleaner production, 42, 215-227. doi:https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2012.11.020 tiejun, d. (2010). two quantitative indices for the planning and evaluation of eco-industrial parks. resources, conservation and recycling, 54(7), 442-448. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7691 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 43 tisserant, a., pauliuk, s., merciai, s., schmidt, j., fry, j., wood, r., & tukker, a. (2017). solid waste and the circular economy: a global analysis of waste treatment and waste footprints. journal of industrial ecology, 21(3), 628-640. van schaik, a., & reuter, m. a. (2016). recycling indices visualising the performance of the circular economy. world met erzmetall, 69, 5-20. vanegas, p., peeters, j. r., cattrysse, d., tecchio, p., ardente, f., mathieux, f., . . . duflou, j. r. (2018). ease of disassembly of products to support circular economy strategies. resources, conservation and recycling, 135, 323-334. vyas, s., & kumaranayake, l. (2006). constructing socio-economic status indices: how to use principal components analysis. health policy and planning, 21(6), 459-468. wen, z., & li, r. (2010). materials metabolism analysis of china's highway traffic system (hts) for promoting circular economy. journal of industrial ecology, 14(4), 641-649. wenbo, l. (2011). comprehensive evaluation research on circular economic performance of eco-industrial parks. energy procedia, 5, 1682-1688. wu, h.-q., shi, y., xia, q., & zhu, w.-d. (2014). effectiveness of the policy of circular economy in china: a dea-based analysis for the period of 11th five-year-plan. resources, conservation and recycling, 83, 163-175. xiong, p., dang, y., & qian, w. (2011). the empirical analysis of circular economy development efficiency in jiangsu province. energy procedia, 5, 1732-1736. yobe, c. l., mudhara, m., & mafongoya, p. (2019). livelihood strategies and their determinants among smallholder farming households in kwazulu-natal province, south africa. agrekon, 1-14. zhao, h., guo, s., & zhao, h. (2018). comprehensive benefit evaluation of eco-industrial parks by employing the bestworst method based on circular economy and sustainability. environment, development and sustainability, 20(3), 1229-1253. zwolinski, p., lopez-ontiveros, m.-a., & brissaud, d. (2006). integrated design of remanufacturable products based on product profiles. journal of cleaner production, 14(15-16), 1333-1345. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10. 10.13135/2704-9906/6817 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 1 ‘circular sustainability accounting’ in businesses for a circular economy: a framework of analysis alfonso aranda-usón1, josé m. moneva2, sabina scarpellini3* 1 university of zaragoza department of accounting and finance & iedis research institute, gran via 2, 50005, spain alaranda@unizar.es 2 university of zaragoza department of accounting and finance & circe research institute, gran via 2, 50005, spain jmmoneva@unizar.es 3* contact author university of zaragoza department of accounting and finance & circe research institute, gran via 2, 50005, spain sabina@unizar.es received: 08/06/2022 accepted for publication: 18/11/2022 published: 29/12/2022 abstract the introduction of the circular economy by firms entails, among other issues, an evolution of sustainability accounting and reporting practices because firms must implement specific activities for closing materials loops. additionally, the circular economy includes finding collaborative solutions in the value chain and making decisions in a decoupling scenario. thus, to change from a linear economy to a circular one requires the measurement and analysis of activities and has impacts other than environmental and social ones that are yet to be included in sustainability accounting and disclosure. in this scenario, this study offers an outlined framework of how circular economy-related principles can be integrated into sustainability accounting, given the strong contemporary approach towards sustainability. an integrated analysis of the circular model’s implications for sustainability accounting is conducted to explore a line of inquiry hitherto little explored. keywords: sustainability accounting; circular economy; environmental management; circular business model; stakeholders 1. introduction the circular economy (ce) has been promoted by businesses because it involves a transformation of the linear economic model to reduce dependence on raw materials and energy, and to mitigate the environmental impact of production and consumption (andersen, 2007; ghisellini et al., 2016). presently, businesses are progressively introducing different ce-related activities (aranda-usón et al., 2020), and sustainability accounting has been highlighted as a tool that could partially capture impacts derived by the closing of materials loops (scarpellini, marín-vinuesa, et al., 2020). adopting a circular business model raises the need to measure and analyse activities and impacts other than those considered in the framework of traditional environmental accounting, which could, perhaps, be insufficient to face the challenges of decoupling and participation at the meso level that a ce entails. when the reporting is considered from a circular viewpoint, businesses must identify and measure the impacts of a wide range of sustainability issues to become more transparent, and sustainability accounting enables businesses to create value over time within the triple bottom line (tbl): economic, social, and environmental (elkington, 2001; murthy & parisi, 2013), including reporting and accountability at a meso level. in european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10. 10.13135/2704-9906/6817 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 2 summary, we could argue that the role of sustainability accounting seems adequate in transitioning from a linear economy to a circular one to measure results in any of the three dimensions of sustainability. however, despite the growing number of contributions focused on analysing the ce in the micro field, research on the integration of ce-related activities and investments in accounting and reporting in the framework of sustainability remains under discussion. a few scholars have emphasised the need for methods to assess circular products’ and business models’ environmental, social, and economic sustainability performance (bocken et al., 2016; pauliuk, 2018; stewart & niero, 2018). stewart and niero (2018) have explored the relationship between reporting and the new circular model. other studies on environmental accounting have partially analysed certain ce-related activities (aranda-usón et al., 2020; stewart & niero, 2018), carbon accounting (marco-fondevila et al., 2020, 2021), circular eco-innovation (portillo-tarragona et al., 2022; scarpellini, valerogil, et al., 2020), or waste management and cleaner production (marrone et al., 2020; portillo-tarragona et al., 2022; zhou et al., 2017). however, analysing the implementation of the circular business model in companies from an accounting perspective is an incipient line of research that has been addressed by very few researchers (di vaio et al., 2022; scarpellini, 2022; scarpellini, marín-vinuesa, et al., 2020). additionally, the theoretical framework of analysis is still unclear. to fill this gap, the main goal of this study is to define a framework of analysis to connect the implications of a ce for businesses within sustainability accounting and reporting. this article is organised as follows: following this introduction, we summarise the background, and in the third section, we analyse the ce-related implications in a sustainability accounting framework. finally, in the concluding section, we outline the conceptual basis and suggest avenues for further research on this topic. 2. background the ce model originated partially in the paradigms of the industrial economy and industrial ecology (andersen, 2007; murray et al., 2017) and applied to the closing of material loops (yuan et al., 2006). these paradigms emphasise the benefits of recycling waste and sub-products through, for example, the development of complex connections, such as undertaking industrial symbiosis between different businesses and production processes (ehrenfeld & gertler, 1997; jacobsen, 2006). significant schools of thought related to the ce emerged in the 1970s and were introduced by pearce and turner (1989), but gained prominence in the 1990s (scarpellini et al., 2019). they include the functional service economy, natural capitalism, and the ‘cradle-to-cradle’ principles (urbinati et al., 2017). in more advanced stages, the ce falls within industrial ecology (li et al., 2010; pitkänen et al., 2016), as it does within the industrial symbiosis between local companies with different production processes (andersen, 2007). in the literature, a few authors have defined three levels for the theoretical analysis of the ce: macro, meso, and micro (mathews & tan, 2011; murray et al., 2017). the macro or national level, promoting eco-cities and sustainable production and consumption, proposes to achieve a ‘recycling-orientated society’ (geng et al., 2012). at a macro level, long-term strategies are based on decoupling economic growth from consumption (figge et al., 2014; ghisellini et al., 2016). the meso level, or the eco-industrial park level, is designed to promote regional development and the natural environment (scarpellini et al., 2019; yuan et al., 2006). finally, at the micro level or individual firm level, companies are encouraged to engage in eco-design for cleaner production approaches (aranda-usón et al., 2020; murray et al., 2017), where decoupling usage from ownership is one of the primary schemes for a ce. several researchers have indicated that the adoption of a circular business model involves significant internal changes in firms’ environmental accounting practices (scarpellini, marín-vinuesa, et al., 2020) mainly related to the cost structure, the definition of prices for by-products and waste that are recovered from being transformed into resources for other companies. the application of voluntary standards and new environmental standards, or the delivery of complete information to clients about the reparability and extended use of products and services, as well as human resources management (marrucci et al., 2021) are a few recently analysed topics. additionally, a ce pursues business changes at the meso level (yuan et al., 2006). thus, in a ce-related context, companies must initiate an active dialogue with, for example, peers, knowledge partners, valuechain partners, and regulators to explore the role of the ce in their specific business. this scenario implies that when businesses adopt a circular business model, the ce must be integrated into their reporting, and the ce-related actions must be considered part of sustainability (barnabè & nazir, 2021a; gunarathne et al., 2021). therefore, the joint support of all stakeholders is considered necessary to implement a ce at a large scale among businesses (banaite & tamošiūnienė, 2016; lieder & rashid, 2016; stewart & niero, 2018). franco (2017) explains the influential nature of firms via the fact that they are subject to pressures from a wide range of stakeholders in a ce context, such as research institutes (rattalino, 2017), value-chain actors (tyl et al., 2015), and customers (boons & lüdeke-freund, 2013). hence, sustainability accounting and reports play an essential legitimacy role for companies because through such communication tools, they may seek to maintain their license to operate and reduce possible gaps between their stakeholders’ expectations regarding sustainability (hahn and kühnen, 2013). murray et al. (2015) indicated the need to consider the wider systems’ role european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10. 10.13135/2704-9906/6817 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 3 in business and accounting decisions, which has become prevalent within environmental management and sustainability reporting (bebbington & gray, 2001). thus, sustainability accounting partially helps firms capture the impact on the environment and society of the level of material loop closing achieved by firms. however, how ce-related principles can be integrated into sustainability accounting remains understudied in the current literature. only a few studies on ce have considered sustainability accounting from a tbl perspective. merli et al. (2018) have shown that whereas sustainability aims to integrate environmental, economic, and social dimensions, the ce literature has focused primarily on environmental issues, and our study aims to fill this gap. the need to translate the concept of sustainability to the level of the individual organisation and merge it with accounting is not new (gray, 1992), and the doubts highlighted in the past by bebbington et al. (1994) about the capabilities of businesses to implement sustainability and apply a broader basis of self-imposed sacrifices for future generations can also be pertinent to the case of a ce if it exclusively prioritises waste recovery. thus, integrating the ce into broader sustainability requires the subordination of traditional economic criteria to criteria based on social and ecological values. these changes require accountants to measure and disclose information about critical ecological functions, and scholars are claimed to provide a framework of analysis for sustainability accounting. given these premises, this study aims to find out which the framework of analysis for the ce is from an accounting perspective considering the business stakeholders in a circular model (rq1). a few authors believe that the ce prioritises economic systems and gaining environmental benefits while only implicitly including social aspects (geissdoerfer et al., 2017). although ecological renewal and survival and the reduction of finite resource use evidently benefit society, there is little explicit recognition of the social aspects inherent in other conceptualisations of sustainable development (murray et al., 2017). considering the goal of addressing the tbl of sustainability, we suggest a second research question to study how the ce impacts social, environmental, and economic aspects as pillars of sustainability accounting and reporting (rq2). this study is based on a conceptual analysis. thus, to answer to the research questions, this study synthesizes reflections reached on the basis of a desk research and the analysis of previous studies. given these considerations, the nexus between the ce and sustainability accounting has to be defined with specific boundaries as a third research question (rq3), sparking a line of inquiry among academics to link the ce with sustainability on the evolution in accounting and reporting, as firms must implement specific internal and external actions related to the circular model. 3. approach to a “circular sustainability accounting” various external and internal factors influence the adoption of the ce at the micro level. there is a complex relationship between a firm and external factor related to the ce, such as institutional, environmental, and technological pressure; the market; society; and other cultural issues. institutional pressure on firms is increasing because of resource policy frameworks and regulations for material resource efficiency (zeng et al., 2017). the commitment to sustainable development and the ce can be consolidated with environmental regulations and public incentives (ghisellini et al., 2018; hu et al., 2018). policymakers develop regulations and incentives to build an effective modern corporate governance system that could overcome barriers and engage firms to improve their behaviour in operating a ce (y. liu & bai, 2014). it is now accepted that the adoption of broader circular principles related to the exchange of goods and services can also be promoted through policies to promote social responsibility in companies (y. s. liu & yang, 2018) and to support ce strategies (ormazabal et al., 2018) that comply with regulations. fletcher et al. (2018) highlighted the role of policies in the transition to a ce: governments facilitate the introduction of ce principles through incentives to facilitate resource recovery and to guarantee investments (aranda-usón et al., 2019). moktadir et al. (2018) also stated that regulation and public support improves the adoption of sustainable manufacturing practices and a ce. the role of society and other stakeholders also emerges in ce implementation (pomponi & moncaster, 2017; stewart & niero, 2018; webster, 2013); however, the debate about the ce’s social dimension is ongoing (murray et al., 2017; scarpellini, 2021, 2022), as mentioned earlier. other sociocultural issues include market and consumer habits (borrello et al., 2017; milios, 2017). additionally, increasing consumption levels are applying ever more pressure on the prices of materials and the subsequent relevance accorded to industrial ecology and waste management (salesa et al., 2022). to this end, theoretical contributions in the field of industrial ecology (andersen, 2007), industrial economy (stigler, 1971), and industrial sociology have been considered to classify main ce-related activities in the framework of sustainability accounting and the stakeholders’ perspective (figure 1). european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10. 10.13135/2704-9906/6817 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 4 figure 1. study synopsis source: author's elaboration based on baumgartner and ebner (2010) in this framework, sustainability accounting emerges with a bottom line in which firms incorporate economic, social, and environmental impacts from a circular perspective (figure 2). we emphasise the need for methods to assess the environmental, social, and economic sustainability performance of ce-related activities because little is known about how companies position the ce in their sustainability agenda (aranda-usón et al., 2019; bocken et al., 2016; elia et al., 2017; stewart & niero, 2018). with these premises in mind, the accounting processes are approached from a circular perspective to answer the second research question (rq2), and figure 2 provides an analytical framework for circular sustainability accounting. figure 2. circular sustainability accounting framework of analysis source: author's elaboration the internal implications for sustainability accounting derived from the adoption of the ce by businesses are mainly related to the collaborative model and the loop closing that the ce requires. the implications of the ce for sustainability accounting european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10. 10.13135/2704-9906/6817 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 5 can be classified according to the tbl and the three pillars of sustainability because environmental, economic, and social aspects must be integrated into the circular model. in this scenario, to enable and accelerate the ce transition driven by industry, new integrative decision support tools are required to identify and tap the potential of ce transition scenarios at the company and inter-company levels (lieder & rashid, 2016). integrated tools that will be introduced by firms when adopting a circular business model will require the inclusion of the primary industrial ecology objectives in sustainability accounting practices and the integration of material flow information in reporting. in the activities of recycling and waste valorisation, the accounting procedures of firms will be influenced by the collaboration scheme that the ce entails with other companies (competitors, suppliers, etc.) in the value chain, the definition of by-product prices, and the management of shared facilities, among other changes. a few researchers have included the industrial economy in their analyses of the ce because it refers to a restorative and regenerative model by intention and design (ellen macarthur foundation, 2013; franco, 2017; roos, 2014). in a circular model systems orientation, actors are analogous to a natural ecosystem (ehrenfeld, 2004) because they collaborate in a meso scheme rather than viewing an industrial economy as a collection of individual actors loosely coordinated by the price signals in a market, as is usually the case. an industrial economy is a system in which material flows and technical nutrients are designed to circulate at high quality (lieder & rashid, 2016; murray et al., 2017) and in which greater resource productivity is promoted by developing ways to continually reacquire and reintroduce the discarded assets following the completion of one life cycle (moktadir et al., 2018; pomponi & moncaster, 2017). in the circular model, supply chain collaboration (increasing dependencies) and changing success factors have significant implications; so, risks and liabilities will differ. new entities can be found within the value chain (e.g., recollection platforms) that enable firms to share risks, costs, and revenues among suppliers, collaborators, and competitors; therefore, new accounting practices are required. the cash flow, cost structure (total cost), and financing required for a circular business model will impact ‘classical’ financial indicators that must change. changes in cost structure can enhance the implementation of ce-related activities, such as for materials, energy consumption, staff behaviour, etc., closing the material loops and adopting a business model (lewandowski, 2016). thus, mutual learning is required, traditional measurements must be improved, and business management focusing on a ce must include activities such as controlling, leading, monitoring, organising, and planning (lieder & rashid, 2016). the social dimension of a ce is mainly related to the following aspects and activities that a circular model introduces: specific indicators for social issues included in corporate social responsibility (csr); health improvement due to environmental improvement and waste reduction; voluntary standards that can include social aspects; information delivered to consumers; and other aspects derived by the sharing economy model and other collaborative schemes. to frame the implications of the ce in sustainability accounting and reporting (rq3), a matrix is proposed as an integrated approach for our analysis (figure 3). figure 3. boundaries of the ‘circular sustainability accounting’ from a ce perspective. source: author's elaboration european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10. 10.13135/2704-9906/6817 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 6 in summary, the adoption of a circular model by firms implies the introduction of several changes in the management accounting practices inherent in the ce-related activities introduced by businesses and linked to the micro and meso dimensions of the ce. at the micro level, the new processes derived from industrial ecology and industrial economy involve measuring and controlling resource flows and waste disposal. in the economic–financial sphere, the ce implies the decoupling paradigm that involves separating usage from ownership. changes in decision-making processes are required because of the control of production capacity in circular thinking and the output control required to adopt incremental material loops closing. in the social sphere, the ce, undoubtedly, influences business ethics, csr, accountability, and measurement of social impacts derived from the circular business model, such as generating employment through investments. at the meso level, a ce implies a decoupling of value-chain optimisation from supply chain competition. this general paradigm implies the introduction of a new sphere of activities and impacts that must be measured and integrated into accounting practices because of the collaborative environment that the ce requires among several companies, for example, in industrial symbiosis. it must also be considered that the essential future developments for ce implementation will imply more extensive work in social awareness. the tbl includes a social dimension involving human stakeholders, human well-being, and human rights, and stakeholders demand greater transparency in a circular phenomenon (benito-bentué et al., 2022). moreover, the ecological renewal and the closing loops of the ce benefit the society (by reducing resource use). however, the explicit recognition of the social aspects of the ce is not clearly stated in the accounting sphere, and it remains unclear how the ce will be considered in the circular sustainability accounting practices in response to the stakeholders’ and society’s pressure (scarpellini, 2022). the ce cannot be exclusively related to the flows of raw materials and resources as it has been considered at the first stage of analysis. thus, circular sustainability accounting transcends the limits of environmental accounting for the material flow measurement, and it will enable organisations to consider their impacts on a wide range of sustainability issues. in this framework, businesses can be more transparent about the risks and opportunities related to the ce principles, and circular sustainability accounting facilitates sustainability of the planet’s boundaries (antonini & larrinaga, 2017), expanding the debate about a strong or weak approach to sustainability accounting (moneva et al., 2006) for accountability in the anthropocene (bebbington et al., 2020). from a tbl perspective for reporting, environmental indicators have been proposed and applied by different authors (aranda-usón et al., 2018, 2020; barnabè & nazir, 2021b; ibáñez-forés et al., 2022); the economic measurement has been mainly analysed in the framework of the circular business model (centobelli et al., 2020; rossi et al., 2020); and the social dimension of the ce is still understudy (mies & gold, 2021; padilla-rivera et al., 2020; scarpellini, 2021, 2022; vanhuyse et al., 2021). some specific ce-related indicators for sustainability reports have been proposed by (ibáñez-forés et al., 2022). finally, we must realise that circular integrated reporting will only be accepted if it delivers the ‘right’ message and if it does not create an alternative source of accounting-based discourse that challenges existing power positions, such as for environmental and social accounting (larrinaga-gonzalez & bebbington, 2001; larrinaga & garcia-torea, 2022). 4. main conclusions drawing on the reviewed literature, this study offers an outlined framework of how ce-related principles can be integrated into sustainability accounting, given a strong approach to sustainability. we, accordingly, pay particular attention to earlier research focused on adoption of the ce by businesses and stakeholders, and external and internal factors to address sustainability accounting and reporting goals from a tbl perspective. framing of sustainability accounting and reporting from a circular perspective is at the forefront of the circular business model and opens new, contemporary debates surrounding the theoretical backgrounds of industrial ecology, industrial economy, and industrial sociology as the first approach to an integrated framework of analysis based on accounting and management theories. it is not our intention to revisit these theoretical frameworks; instead, we establish a common framework of analysis to explore the boundaries of an incipient circular sustainability accounting discipline, to add something substantial to the debate about the specificity of reporting from a circular perspective. this necessity meets the challenge for modern accounting and the future debate around integrated sustainability reporting. the framework outlined here provides a better understanding of ce principles integrated into sustainability accounting, combining them with the tbl proposition to design an integrated reporting mechanism adapted to the circular model. overlapping ce principles at the micro level and the business model, a new integrated vision of the social aspects of the ce emerges. this study provides specific ce-related activities for reporting processes to be measured for non-financial disclosure. practitioners can apply these measurements to achieve greater ce-related accountability, but would require more detailed social european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10. 10.13135/2704-9906/6817 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 7 impact analysis for integrated reporting. thus, our findings directly translate into practices that are the leading accounting indicators for reporting ce in businesses. additionally, this study addresses the research gap by defining the boundaries of sustainability accounting applied to circular models and examining the general conceptual framework of the ce through a tbl prism. future intensive scientific work should concentrate on developing environmental and social assessment methods designed for companies adopting a circular business model. using the framework outlined here, firms can consider introducing ce principles into their reporting practices; however, circular integrated reporting requires further development. this study has a few limitations. it is the first attempt to define specific boundaries of sustainability accounting related to the ce, and further applied and comparative studies are recommended. although considerable efforts have been made to generalise the framework of analysis to the dawn of the ce as an economic model and transfer it to a more recent vision of sustainability accounting, a deeper theoretical debate and analysis is required going ahead. acknowledgements this study was made possible by funding from the spanish ministry of science and innovation project pid2019107822rb-i00. it was partially co-financed by the regional government of aragon in the framework of research group ref. s33_20r and the lmp159_21 project. the university of zaragoza is also acknowledged for the uz2021-soc-02 project. references andersen, m. s. (2007). an introductory note on the environmental economics of the circular economy. sustainability science, 2(1), 133–140. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11625-006-0013-6 antonini, c., & larrinaga, c. (2017). planetary boundaries and sustainability indicators. a survey of corporate reporting boundaries. sustainable development, 25(2), 123–137. https://doi.org/10.1002/sd.1667 aranda-usón, a., m. moneva, j., portillo-tarragona, p., & llena-macarulla, f. (2018). measurement of the circular economy in businesses: impact and implications for regional policies. economics and policy of energy and the environment, 2(1), 187–205. https://doi.org/10.3280/efe2018-002010 aranda-usón, a., portillo-tarragona, p., marín-vinuesa, l. m., & scarpellini, s. (2019). financial resources for the circular economy : a perspective from businesses. sustainability, 11(888), 1–23. https://doi.org/10.3390/su11030888 aranda-usón, a., portillo-tarragona, p., scarpellini, s., & llena-macarulla, f. (2020). the progressive adoption of a circular economy by businesses for cleaner production: an approach from a regional study in spain. journal of cleaner production, 247(1), 119648. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2019.119648 banaite, d., & tamošiūnienė, r. (2016). sustainable development: the circular economy indicators’ selection model. journal of security and sustainability issues, 6(2), 489–499. https://doi.org/10.9770/jssi.2016.5.3(4) barnabè, f., & nazir, s. (2021a). conceptualizing and enabling circular economy through integrated thinking. corporate social responsibility and environmental management, 9(2), 448–468. https://doi.org/10.1002/csr.2211 barnabè, f., & nazir, s. (2021b). investigating the interplays between integrated reporting practices and circular economy disclosure. international journal of productivity and performance management, 70(8), 2001–2031. https://doi.org/10.1108/ijppm-03-2020-0128 baumgartner, r. j., & ebner, d. (2010). corporate sustainability strategies: sustainability profiles and maturity levels. sustainable development, 18(2), 76–89. https://doi.org/10.1002/sd.447 bebbington, j., & gray, r. (2001). an account of sustainability: failure, success and a reconceptualization. critical perspectives on accounting batley & tozer geno stone gray & bebbington, 12(5), 557–587. https://doi.org/10.1006/cpac.2000.0450 bebbington, j., gray, r., thomson, i., & walters, d. (1994). accountants’ attitudes and environmentally-sensitive accounting. accounting and business research, 24(94), 109–120. https://doi.org/10.1080/00014788.1994.9729470 bebbington, j., österblom, h., crona, b., jouffray, j. b., larrinaga, c., russell, s., & scholtens, b. (2020). accounting and accountability in the anthropocene. accounting, auditing and accountability journal, 33(1), 152–177. https://doi.org/10.1108/aaaj-11-2018-3745 benito-bentué, d., marco-fondevila, m., & scarpellini, s. (2022). financial institutions facing the challenge of the european taxonomy of sustainable investments and the circular economy disclosure. ucjc business and society review, 19(73), 120–161. https://doi.org/10.3232/ubr.2022.v19.n2.03 bocken, n. m. p., de pauw, i., bakker, c., & van der grinten, b. (2016). product design and business model strategies for a circular economy. journal of industrial and production engineering, 33(5), 308–320. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10. 10.13135/2704-9906/6817 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 8 https://doi.org/10.1080/21681015.2016.1172124 boons, f., & lüdeke-freund, f. (2013). business models for sustainable innovation: state-of-the-art and steps towards a research agenda. journal of cleaner production, 45, 9–19. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2012.07.007 borrello, m., caracciolo, f., lombardi, a., pascucci, s., & cembalo, l. (2017). consumers’ perspective on circular economy strategy for reducing food waste. sustainability (switzerland), 9(141), 1–18. https://doi.org/10.3390/su9010141 centobelli, p., cerchione, r., chiaroni, d., del vecchio, p., & urbinati, a. (2020). designing business models in circular economy: a systematic literature review and research agenda. business strategy and the environment, january, bse.2466. https://doi.org/10.1002/bse.2466 di vaio, a., hasan, s., palladino, r., & hassan, r. (2022). the transition towards circular economy and waste within accounting and accountability models: a systematic literature review and conceptual framework. environment, development and sustainability, in press. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10668-021-02078-5 ehrenfeld, j. (2004). industrial ecology: a new field or only a metaphor? journal of cleaner production, 12(8–10), 825–831. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2004.02.003 ehrenfeld, j., & gertler, n. (1997). industrial ecology in practice. journal of industrial ecology, 1(1), 67–79. https://doi.org/10.1162/jiec.1997.1.1.67 elia, v., gnoni, m. g., & tornese, f. (2017). measuring circular economy strategies through index methods: a critical analysis. journal of cleaner production, 142, 2741–2751. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2016.10.196 elkington, j. (2001). enter the triple bottom line. in the triple bottom line (vol. 1, issue 1986, pp. 1–16). john elkington. https://doi.org/10.1021/nl034968f ellen macarthur foundation. (2013). towards a circular economy. economic and business rationales for an accelerated transition. in ellen macarthur foundation. vol. 1. ellen mcarthur foundation. https://www.ellenmacarthurfoundation.org/assets/downloads/publications/ellen-macarthur-foundation-towards-thecircular-economy-vol.1.pdf figge, f., young, w., & barkemeyer, r. (2014). sufficiency or efficiency to achieve lower resource consumption and emissions? the role of the rebound effect. journal of cleaner production, 69(1), 216–224. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2014.01.031 fletcher, c. a., hooper, p. d., & dunk, r. m. (2018). unintended consequences of secondary legislation: a case study of the uk landfill tax (qualifying fines) order 2015. resources, conservation and recycling, 138(july), 160–171. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.resconrec.2018.07.011 franco, m. a. (2017). circular economy at the micro level: a dynamic view of incumbents’ struggles and challenges in the textile industry. journal of cleaner production, 168(1), 833–845. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2017.09.056 geissdoerfer, m., savaget, p., bocken, n. m. p., & hultink, e. j. (2017). the circular economy – a new sustainability paradigm? journal of cleaner production, 143, 757–768. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2016.12.048 geng, y., fu, j., sarkis, j., & xue, b. (2012). towards a national circular economy indicator system in china: an evaluation and critical analysis. journal of cleaner production, 23(1), 216–224. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2011.07.005 ghisellini, p., cialani, c., & ulgiati, s. (2016). a review on circular economy: the expected transition to a balanced interplay of environmental and economic systems. journal of cleaner production, 114(1), 11–32. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2015.09.007 ghisellini, p., ji, x., liu, g., & ulgiati, s. (2018). evaluating the transition towards cleaner production in the construction and demolition sector of china: a review. journal of cleaner production, 195(1), 418–434. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2018.05.084 gray, r. (1992). accounting and environmentalism: an exploration of the challenge of gently accounting for accountability, transparency and sustainability. accounting, organizations and society, 17(5), 399–425. https://doi.org/10.1016/03613682(92)90038-t gunarathne, n., wijayasundara, m., senaratne, s., kanchana, p. d. k., & cooray, t. (2021). uncovering corporate disclosure for a circular economy: an analysis of sustainability and integrated reporting by sri lankan companies. sustainable production and consumption, 27, 787–801. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.spc.2021.02.003 hu, y., he, x., & poustie, m. (2018). can legislation promote a circular economy? a material flow-based evaluation of the circular degree of the chinese economy. sustainability (switzerland), 10(4). https://doi.org/10.3390/su10040990 ibáñez-forés, v., martínez-sánchez, v., valls-val, k., & bovea, m. d. (2022). sustainability reports as a tool for measuring and monitoring the transition towards the circular economy of organisations: proposal of indicators and metrics. journal of environmental management, 320(in press). https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jenvman.2022.115784 jacobsen, n. b. (2006). industrial symbiosis in kalundborg, denmark a quantitative assessment of economic and environmental aspects. journal of industrial ecology, 10(1–2), 239–255. https://doi.org/10.1162/108819806775545411 larrinaga-gonzalez, c., & bebbington, j. (2001). accounting change or institutional appropriation? a case study of the implementation of environmental accounting. critical perspectives on accounting, 12(3), 269–292. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10. 10.13135/2704-9906/6817 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 9 https://doi.org/10.1006/cpac.2000.0433 larrinaga, c., & garcia-torea, n. (2022). an ecological critique of accounting: the circular economy and covid-19. critical perspectives on accounting, 82, 102320. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cpa.2021.102320 lewandowski, m. (2016). designing the business models for circular economy-towards the conceptual framework. sustainability (switzerland), 8(1), 1–28. https://doi.org/10.3390/su8010043 li, h., bao, w., xiu, c., zhang, y., & xu, h. (2010). energy conservation and circular economy in china’s process industries. energy, 35(11), 4273–4281. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.energy.2009.04.021 lieder, m., & rashid, a. (2016). towards circular economy implementation: a comprehensive review in context of manufacturing industry. journal of cleaner production, 115, 36–51. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2015.12.042 liu, y., & bai, y. (2014). an exploration of firms’ awareness and behavior of developing circular economy: an empirical research in china. resources, conservation and recycling, 87, 145–152. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.resconrec.2014.04.002 liu, y. s., & yang, j. h. (2018). a longitudinal analysis of corporate greenhouse gas disclosure strategy. corporate governance: the international journal of business in society, 18(2), 317–330. https://doi.org/10.1108/cg-11-20160213 marco-fondevila, m., llena-macarulla, f., callao-gastón, s., & jarne-jarne, j. i. (2021). are circular economy policies actually reaching organizations? evidence from the largest spanish companies. journal of cleaner production, 285, 124858. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2020.124858 marco-fondevila, m., moneva-abadía, j. m., & llena-macarulla, f. (2020). accounting for carbon footprint flows in wine production process. case study in spanish winery. applied sciences (switzerland), 10(23), 1–13. https://doi.org/10.3390/app10238381 marrone, m., linnenluecke, m. k., richardson, g., & smith, t. (2020). trends in environmental accounting research within and outside of the accounting discipline. accounting, auditing and accountability journal, 33(8), 2167–2193. https://doi.org/10.1108/aaaj-03-2020-4457 marrucci, l., daddi, t., & iraldo, f. (2021). the contribution of green human resource management to the circular economy and performance of environmental certified organisations. journal of cleaner production, 319(march), 128859. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2021.128859 mathews, j. a., & tan, h. (2011). progress toward a circular economy in china. journal of industrial ecology, 15(3), 435– 457. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1530-9290.2011.00332.x merli, r., preziosi, m., & acampora, a. (2018). how do scholars approach the circular economy? a systematic literature review. journal of cleaner production, 178(1), 703–722. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2017.12.112 mies, a., & gold, s. (2021). mapping the social dimension of the circular economy. in journal of cleaner production (vol. 321). elsevier ltd. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2021.128960 milios, l. (2017). advancing to a circular economy: three essential ingredients for a comprehensive policy mix. sustainability science, 1–18. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11625-017-0502-9 moktadir, m. a., rahman, t., rahman, m. h., ali, s. m., & paul, s. k. (2018). drivers to sustainable manufacturing practices and circular economy: a perspective of leather industries in bangladesh. journal of cleaner production, 174, 1366– 1380. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2017.11.063 moneva, j. m., archel, p., & correa, c. (2006). gri and the camouflaging of corporate unsustainability. accounting forum, 30(2), 121–137. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.accfor.2006.02.001 murray, a., skene, k., & haynes, k. (2017). the circular economy: an interdisciplinary exploration of the concept and application in a global context. journal of business ethics, 140(3), 369–380. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10551-015-26932 murthy, v., & parisi, c. (2013). a meta-analysis of two decades of sustainability accounting literature : observations and future directions. the 7th asia pacific interdisciplinary research in accounting conference. apira 2013, 7, 1–33. ormazabal, m., prieto-sandoval, v., puga-leal, r., & jaca, c. (2018). circular economy in spanish smes: challenges and opportunities. journal of cleaner production, 185, 157–167. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2018.03.031 padilla-rivera, a., russo-garrido, s., & merveille, n. (2020). addressing the social aspects of a circular economy: a systematic literature review. sustainability (switzerland), 12(19), 1–17. https://doi.org/10.3390/su12197912 pauliuk, s. (2018). critical appraisal of the circular economy standard bs 8001:2017 and a dashboard of quantitative system indicators for its implementation in organizations. resources, conservation and recycling, 129(1), 81–92. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.resconrec.2017.10.019 pearce, d. w., & turner, r. k. (1990). economics of natural resources and the environment. in the john hopkis univerity press, baltimore (vol. 73). https://doi.org/10.2307/1242904 pitkänen, k., antikainen, r., droste, n., loiseau, e., saikku, l., aissani, l., hansjrgens, b., kuikman, p. j., leskinen, p., & thomsen, m. (2016). what can be learned from practical cases of green economy? studies from five european countries. journal of cleaner production, 139, 666–676. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2016.08.071 european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10. 10.13135/2704-9906/6817 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 10 pomponi, f., & moncaster, a. (2017). circular economy for the built environment: a research framework. journal of cleaner production, 143, 710–718. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2016.12.055 portillo-tarragona, p., scarpellini, s., & marín-vinuesa, l. m. (2022). ‘circular patents’ and dynamic capabilities: new insights for patenting in a circular economy. technology analysis & strategic management, in press. https://doi.org/10.1080/09537325.2022.2106206 rattalino, f. (2017). circular advantage anyone? sustainability-driven innovation and circularity at patagonia, inc. thunderbird international business review, 60(5), 747–755. https://doi.org/10.1002/tie.21917 roos, g. (2014). business model innovation to create and capture resource value in future circular material chains. resources, 3(1), 248–274. https://doi.org/10.3390/resources3010248 rossi, e., bertassini, a. c., ferreira, c. dos s., neves do amaral, w. a., & ometto, a. r. (2020). circular economy indicators for organizations considering sustainability and business models: plastic, textile and electro-electronic cases. journal of cleaner production, 247. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2019.119137 salesa, a., león, r., & moneva, j. m. (2022). airlines practices to incorporate circular economy principles into the waste management system. corporate social responsibility and environmental management, in press, 1–24. https://doi.org/10.1002/csr.2365 scarpellini, s. (2021). social indicators for businesses’ circular economy: multi-faceted analysis of employment as an indicator for sustainability reporting. european journal of social impact and circular economy, 2(1), 17–44. https://doi.org/https://doi.org/10.13135/2704-9906/5282 scarpellini, s. (2022). social impacts of a circular business model: an approach from a sustainability accounting and reporting perspective. corporate social responsibility and environmental management, 29(3), 646–656. https://doi.org/10.1002/csr.2226 scarpellini, s., marín-vinuesa, l. m., aranda-usón, a., & portillo-tarragona, p. (2020). dynamic capabilities and environmental accounting for the circular economy in businesses. sustainability accounting, management and policy journal, 11(7), 1129–1158. https://doi.org/10.1108/sampj-04-2019-0150 scarpellini, s., portillo-tarragona, p., aranda-usón, a., & llena-macarulla, f. (2019). definition and measurement of the circular economy’s regional impact. journal of environmental planning and management, 62(13), 2211–2237. https://doi.org/10.1080/09640568.2018.1537974 scarpellini, s., valero-gil, j., moneva, j. m., & andreaus, m. (2020). environmental management capabilities for a “circular eco-innovation.” business strategy and the environment, 29(5), 1850–1864. https://doi.org/10.1002/bse.2472 stewart, r., & niero, m. (2018). circular economy in corporate sustainability strategies: a review of corporate sustainability reports in the fast-moving consumer goods sector. business strategy and the environment, 27(7), 1005–1022. https://doi.org/10.1002/bse.2048 stigler, g. j. (1971). the theory of economic regulation. the bell journal of economics and management science, 2(1), 3– 21. https://doi.org/10.2307/3003160 tyl, b., vallet, f., bocken, n. m. p., & real, m. (2015). the integration of a stakeholder perspective into the front end of ecoinnovation: a practical approach. in journal of cleaner production (vol. 108, pp. 1–15). https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2015.07.145 urbinati, a., chiaroni, d., & chiesa, v. (2017). towards a new taxonomy of circular economy business models. journal of cleaner production, 168(1), 487–498. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2017.09.047 vanhuyse, f., fejzić, e., ddiba, d., & henrysson, m. (2021). the lack of social impact considerations in transitioning towards urban circular economies: a scoping review. sustainable cities and society, 75. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.scs.2021.103394 webster, k. (2013). what might we say about a circular economy? some temptations to avoid if possible. world futures: journal of general evolution, 69(7–8), 542–554. https://doi.org/10.1080/02604027.2013.835977 yuan, z., bi, j., moriguichi, y., & zengwei yuan, jun bi, and y. m. (2006). the circular economy: a new development strategy in china. journal of industrial ecology, 10(1–2), 4–8. https://doi.org/10.1162/108819806775545321 zeng, h., chen, x., xiao, x., & zhou, z. (2017). institutional pressures, sustainable supply chain management, and circular economy capability: empirical evidence from chinese eco-industrial park firms. journal of cleaner production, 155(1), 54–65. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2016.10.093 zhou, z., zhao, w., chen, x., & zeng, h. (2017). mfca extension from a circular economy perspective: model modifications and case study. journal of cleaner production, 149(1), 110–125. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2017.02.049 01 european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5988 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 1 criticality assessment of green materials: institutional quality, market concentration and recycling potential matteo mazzarano1 1 università cattolica del sacro cuore, department of mathematics and physics, milan, italy e-mail: matteo.mazzarano@unicatt.it received: 29/07/2021 accepted for publication: 01/11/2021 published: 12/11/2021 abstract the carbon transition and digitalization transformation are tied to a set of critical raw materials (crm). energy accumulators, renewable energy modules, and electronic devices all contain a certain amount of these. the versatility and utility of such elements come together with the limited number of countries where their extraction and refining occur. as the demand for these materials is growing globally, concerns arise regarding the security of the production chain. several works highlighted the risks associated with these materials without presenting clear interaction between such factors. this gap in literature might have overlooked systemic risks underlying green sectors. this article investigates the correlation between three aspects: market concentration, institutional quality, and circularity. the approach will contain the presentation of the main characteristics of recyclability and the institutional status of exporters. a synthetic index is derived and plotted against the potential of recycling per material. in such a manner, we can group minerals according to sourcing vulnerability: one comes from material recovery and the other via imports. an indicator calculated with a cartesian distance method provides the synthesis of security versus safety. according to our findings, electrical vehicles carry the highest vulnerability for their main components in circularity and human rights violations. this implies that the supply chains' instabilities threaten the transition to a low carbon society. ending remarks highlighted the limitations of our research, where possible interest for future research may lay. keywords: critical raw materials; responsible sourcing; market concentration; conflict minerals; circularity 1. introduction acquisition of crms is topical for the eu strategic agenda: a stable and clean supply of raw materials is necessary to key industries. it is called criticality, the economic and technical dependency on a particular material, and the probability of supply disruptions for a defined stakeholder group within a specific time frame (schrijvers et al., 2020). the eu institutions established a three-fold policy direction to aid in this context in 2008 with the raw material initiative (commission of the european communities, 2008). it involved three pillars: safe mining within the eu economic area, secondary materials from waste recovery, and sustainable and fair supply from global markets. the first relates to sustainable mining and new explorations (hàmor, 2004; vrkljan et al., 2017). material recovery is also connected to municipal waste as urban mining (cossu & williams, 2015). households are not the primary source of waste within the eu economy. however, it represents one of the european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5988 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 2 core issues of eu waste policy (expósito & velasco, 2018). finally, safe trade practices are intended to reduce the vulnerability of imports. due to industrial dependency, crm extraction cannot be delinked from nations that cannot foster human rights. this is why some of them are part of the so-called conflict minerals (koch & burlyuk, 2020). the policy issue abides by the oecd due diligence practices (oecd, 2016a). while internal eu production increases the safety of the supply line, the other two are face limitations. material recovery from waste still faces technological uncertainties (ali et al., 2017), and harmonization of due diligence data is still in evolution (oecd, 2020). mineral governance should and policy-making at different levels (bleischwitz & bahn‐walkowiak, 2007), possibly anticipating risks and crises (bleischwitz, 2020). safe mining represents a strategic source. however, within a circular perspective, extractive practices might be taken as secondary. therefore, the circular tools for material governance should focus on the limitations of the other pillars in material governance. securing external sources and advancing recycling technologies could impact the resolution of the eu agenda for digitalization and green transition. material governance is linked to several strategic industries: eee, ev, solar panels, and wind farms (bobba et al., 2020; monnet & ait abderrahim, 2018). safe trades and secondary materials are elements of the umbrella definition of circular economy (homrich et al., 2018). several authors have commented on the capability of circular economy practices to reduce the criticality of materials (chiu et al., 2020; tercero espinoza et al., 2020). however, it was commented on the potential trade-offs between materials and processes (schaubroeck, 2020). this might represent a structural limit to eu policies intended to reduce the criticality. yet, there are few if no articles that address the complementarity between critical aspects. the purpose of this paper is to highlight the potential presence of a trade-off between circular economy pillars of material governance under the framework of internal versus external weakness of european raw material supply chain. the reference literature of criticality assessement for crm have not investigated the issue so far (mudd et al., 2018; santillán-saldivar et al., 2021a; song et al., 2019). we will develop an indicator for external safety according to market concentration and national institutional quality. for circularity, we will use the contribution of recycled materials to raw materials demand, known as the end-of-life recycling input rates (eol-rir). this is not the only possible indicator of circularity. it is, however, the one adopted by the eu commission and eurostat to classify materials for circularity (talens peiró et al., 2018). since market distribution, institutional quality cannot change is short term, we will consider them complementary in this study. the complementarity of recyclability and safe markets is analyzed using a cartesian distance indicator, identifying as vulnerable the elements that cannot be accessed with either of the pillar. it is necessary to consider the changes in definition to recall which crms are. a revision of the criticality definition was implemented several times. the first official publication was in 2011 with 14 crms. following editions every three years increased the number of elements: 2014 with 20, 2017 with 27, and 2020 with 30. such a surge could be interpreted by the attention that the eu commission had towards several evolving topics. circular economy policy packages were implemented during those years: 2008 and 2014 the waste framework directive, circular economy action plan in 2015 and 2017 was the waste of the eee package. the paris agreement's signatures accelerated climate change policy in 2016. regarding responsible sourcing, the eu passed the eu's regulation on responsible sourcing of minerals, also sometimes referred to as the 'conflict minerals regulation', in may 2017. according to this legislation, by january 2021, around 95% of crm imports should follow rs criteria (eu, 2017). the recommendations declined within the due diligence guidelines follow the premise of corruption avoidance, human and environmental rights, conflict avoidance (oecd, 2016b). the article is structured in such a manner. the literature review presents the major works regarding crm criticality. the methodology section is used to explain the derivation and use of indicators for our analysis. the results will deliver a synthetic outcome. in the discussion, we will comment on the relevance of the results according to each sector and how this could affect the development of the eu agenda. finally, a review of the limitations of our methodology is presented, along with the possible new application. 2. literature review the thriving market for consumer and portable electronics and low-carbon technologies (hybrid and electric vehicles, wind turbines, and solar panels) is heavily dependent on the availability of critical raw materials (crms): it is possible to find studies on ev (jones et al., 2020), solar panels and wind farms (rabe et al., 2017). their extraction, production, and trade are associated with various risk factors. in 2013, a study conducted by the iisd identified 32 materials as significant for the de-carbonization european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5988 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 3 of the european energy system (church & crawford, 2018). some are classified as "critical" and included in the eu critical raw material list, being either scarce or extracted in a limited number of countries (blagoeva et al., 2016). commonly, criticality assessments consider the 'supply risk' and 'economic importance' of the raw material. supply risk reflects the severity of the impact on the disruption of supply chains and is based on significant suppliers' concentration and political stability. economic importance reflects the sum of the value of end-use sectors that consume the raw material (song et al., 2019). other studies also include analyses of the reserves and the number of raw materials. some have been confirmed and can be economically recovered with current technology, even potentially by eee waste (mazzarano, 2020). it is possible to estimate depletion rates for global reserves with a long-time focus. in general sourcing material use from production, chains relate equivalent measures (pehlken et al., 2017; ziemann et al., 2018). such approaches are similar to ecological footprint, applying water and carbon emissions (misopoulos et al., 2020; stefanakis, 2019). criticality assessment usually involved the development of indexes. one of the most famous has been annually derived from uk geological survey (british geological survey, 2015). it uses a composition of several indicators involving geopolitical risk, economic relevance, recycling potential, and ore scarcity. however, several of such indicators have been subjected to criticism in the context of life-cycle assessment (cimprich et al., 2019), in the sense that they made hands challenging to use in supply chain analysis. the geopolitical risk component is somewhat relevant in crm studies, but it is significantly mitigated by recycling capacity, becoming a less critical factor (santillán-saldivar et al., 2021b). furthermore, scales and non-continuous indicators are not helpful to capture correlations in the supply risk index used in criticality indicators (blengini et al., 2017). from the markowitz portfolio approach, the correlation between indicators is a possible tool to minimize risk. for crm, there exists no significant correlation between depletion, self-sufficiency, and economic importance indicators (f. f. martins & castro, 2020). economic importance has also been uncorrelated to supply risk (arendt et al., 2020). the study of indicators correlation is a recent development, and rs aspects are often not considered a primary study interest. furthermore, the result in terms of which material is more critical is a redundant exercise. top positions are usually occupied by the same materials (f. martins & castro, 2019). there are comprehensive studies on the supply chain of crms such as lithium and cobalt. macro-economic factors have been addressed in studies regarding european union imports (deloitte, 2015). few studies pay attention to the correlation between the institutional quality of exporters and material circularity. the instability of institutional systems affects the endurance of economic relations. this generates uncertainty and impacts the value chain of products (ambekar et al., 2019; silva & schaltegger, 2019). there is no absolute way to examine stability. according to a normalized scale, available indexes are based on the investigation of experts panel and grade nations (kunčič, 2014). this indicator has been used in several studies of crm supply risk. we will show in the next section how it is possible to correlate market safety to circularity in next section. 3. methodology we employed three indicators to evaluate the criticality of materials under the frame of circularity vs. market safety. for circularity, we adopted the percentage of reuse of discarded materials, the eol-rir. volumes of crm international transactions could be traced to the exporters using the comtrade dataset. we use the reference value of 2018, as it is its latest entry. according to each product, this trading indicator is hereby used to derive the market quota of each exporter. institutional quality is based on six normalized indicators. the eol-rir was the most suitable circularity indicator in criticality analysis: it aligns well with eu targets, including raw materials policy, and the section explains how it can be calculated using material system analysis data (talens peiró et al., 2018). eol-rir refers only to available recycling. it is the percentage of participation of discarded materials in input to production. crm is defined by both market concentration and a north-south dynamic of human rights. since institutional quality does not identify directly human rights violations, we assumed that institutional quality is a robust measure of protection. thus, we do not presume that nations with generally good institutions have no infringement. human rights could be violated everywhere, but good institutions tend to repair or counter the damage. raw materials exporters with stable institutions might host relatively decent work environments. when rights are violated, it is more probable to restore the previous situation than in a nation with weak or unstable institutions. the operational definition of institutional quality is based upon a rating approach. estimating a general value of quality is non-trivial. according to regulatory quality, six quality indexes evaluate nations, government effectiveness, the rule of law, corruption, voice, and accountability index. values of such variables are collected in indicators of worldwide governance indicators. they are european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5988 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 4 estimated using the unobserved components model (ucm). the premise underlying this statistical approach is straightforward – each of the individual data sources provides an imperfect signal of some more profound underlying notion of governance that is difficult to observe directly (kaufmann et al., 2011). the distribution of such indexes is expected and always has a variance of 1 and a mean of 0, with a minimum value of -2.5 and a maximum of 2.5. since we cannot choose which is more effective in preventing or restoring human rights, we will assume that they are jointly and equally responsible for human rights respect. since it is needed positive values from a normal distribution, the exponential value will be used in such way: 𝐼! =#𝑒"#$ ∀$ (1) the generalized index "i" for a country "i" is the inverted average between the value of the six indexes. each index 'm' could be given any weight 'x' according to the institutional quality the criticality assessment requires. however, as previously stated, it might be better to have no discrimination on such occasions. all weights are equal to 1/6. this methodology is helpful as it does not substantially change the value of the variance of distributions, avoiding other biases to our analysis. since we had to refer the value to a material, we matched the generalized index with the market participation. 𝑀& = 1 𝑛#𝑝!𝐼! ∀! (2) in such a way, the index of market institutional quality "m" for material "k" is an average of the institutional quality of nations. the value can vary from 0 to 100. the meaning of the index is a positive interaction between a market distribution and the quality of partners. the maximum index level can only be achieved when the market is split between fair exporters: the lower the level, the more concentrated the market around unfair partners. since market distribution is not necessarily normally distributed, we cannot expect the "m" index to appreciate the same properties as the institutional one. figure 1. classification areas source: author’s elaboration according to circularity and market source vulnerability, the classification of materials will be plotted on a reference of two axes. the x-axis will represent the first while the y-axis the latter. splitting the area into four, it is possible to discern between zones of no policies (both high values), overall criticality (low and low), high market vulnerability, and low circularity. speaking of mere distribution, it is possible to see the objectives according to frequencies. the areas will be split according to the median value. as reported in figure 1, half of all materials have either very low eol-rir (˜8) or low market vulnerability (˜22). each commodity is constituted by a cloud of points spread between four areas. according to where these dots are located, it is possible to see where each sector should focus its policy. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5988 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 5 unfortunately for crm in international trade datasets, heavy and light rare earth elements (hree and lree) are used. the former comprehends yttrium (y), gadolinium (gd), terbium (tb), dysprosium (dy), holmium (ho), erbium (er), thulium (tm), ytterbium (yb), lutetium (lu). the latter comprehends scandium (sc), lanthanum (la), cerium (ce), praseodymium (pr), neodymium (nd), promethium (pm), samarium (sm), europium (eu). furthermore, group 5 elements have to be considered as a whole. this collects vanadium (v), niobium (nb), tantalum (ta), and dubnium (db). criticality assessment considers, therefore, twenty-eight materials and groups. market concentration could be considered on two levels. one could be captured by index m, as the proportion of trade that each nation control for a particular crm. the second appears when nations participate and possibly control several markets. to summarize market concentration, shannon index of attention is applied. its derivation originates from communication theory but has prolific application in social sciences (tabner, 2007). the lowest value of 0 indicates the monopoly of markets of one country on every market. the number of exporting counties is collected in i = 1,..., n, and commodities in k = 1,..., k 𝑆! = 1 𝐾##𝑝! ∀! 𝑙𝑛(𝑝!) ∀& (3) we suggested in figure 2 that the number of dominators is few in crm markets. while these nations have unstable institutions and deal with low circular materials, it is rather challenging to address diversification. for our purpose, the m index is penalized by high concentration for commodities exchanged in this condition, even by very stable countries. it is possible to compare concentration from this panel to a" normal one" using a standard distribution fitting (blue). in figure 2, a comparison of concentration is highlighted. dominant exporters do most transactions of crm. the normal distribution in blue is centered around si mean and standard deviation. figure 2. market concentration per exporters, si source: author’s elaboration european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5988 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 6 the m index multiplies market concentration to the i index of institutional quality. this index has low tails, and most firms are distributed around its mean of 6. nations with an index around 1 have the most inferior instability to report, with all indexes near -2.5. the characteristics of such distribution are helpful to penalize extreme events and allow higher points on middle-tier countries. the interaction between such data is reported in the result section. to have a comparable criticality index, we needed to synthesize the correlation between the indicators and the distance to the most unsafe of trades for rs-circularity objective: those low on both m and eol-rir (c in equation 4). figure 3. i index with normal density fitting source: author’s elaboration since we intend to address the usefulness of the trade-off, we place no preference between the two indicators. cartesian distance between each element to (0,0) functions as a pareto-efficient indicator: elements are given a higher value if any form of hedging strategy exists between circularity or safe markets. 𝐷& = /𝑀& ' + 𝑐&' according to eu standards, the analysis we provided allows for interpreting results for market safety according to possible rs considerations and circularity. we reported hereby the outcome of our study. 4. results we reported a summary of the preliminary analysis in table 1. among essential categories of crm, it is possible to find lree, hree, and g5. their market is respectively controlled by japan (15.44%), the popular republic of china (11.6%), and brasil (24%). cobalt, lree, and silicates are the lowest circularity in ev, eee wind, and solar farms. for market and institutional fragility, molybdenum and cobalt are the lowest. the latter is particularly vulnerable for both factors. china represents the most relevant source of market concentration and instability. while it is ranked low on all institutional quality indicators, it is the dominant player in several markets. among these, we find bismuth, hree, molybdenum, and nickel. cerium and lree are dominated by japan, which generally accounts for stable institutions. in responsible sourcing, "top-down" approaches based on institutional indicators for critical analysis have generally similar results, despite different focuses. in our case, we developed a system based on three major indicators: market safety, circularity, and cartesian distance index. institutional quality has been weighted to market participation. in case most any market is composed mainly of overall fragile states, we called the market tainted. the comparison element to draw vulnerability is the european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5988 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 7 circular limits of the eol-rir. the exposure is based on the possibility to acquire a material according to fair market or circular source, as recycled materials. table 1. table’s example hs92 m index eol(rir) cartesian d chemical name application main trader 2613 5.68 30.00 30.532 mo wind chn (31.036%) 250410 36.57 3.00 36.693 c ev chn (10.46%) 251910 29.18 9.50 30.686 mg ind (23.039%) 252010 32.57 1.10 32.589 ca esp (5.29%) 260111 20.31 24.00 31.439 fe solar, wind, ev, eee bra (11.134%) 260200 25.34 12.00 28.040 mn wind, ev gab (17.484%) 260300 24.69 55.00 60.289 cu solar, wind, ev, eee bgr (8.882%) 260400 10.24 33.90 35.412 ni ev, eee chn (40.858%) 260500 4.73 0.00 4.729 co wind, ev, eee aut (28.584%) 260600 31.03 12.40 33.413 al solar, wind, ev, eee gin (17.477%) 260700 19.49 75.00 77.490 pb solar, wind, ev blx (7.352%) 260800 30.26 22.90 37.945 zn solar, wind, eee blx (7.772%) 260900 9.44 32.00 33.364 sn eee mys (31.452%) 261400 21.00 19.10 28.383 ti ev, eee blx (9.73%) 261590 11.22 15.43 19.079 g5 solar, wind, ev, eee bra (23.849%) 261610 15.53 55.00 57.152 ag solar, eee bol (8.522%) 280450 19.09 1.00 19.115 te chn (15.148%) 280490 33.78 1.00 33.798 se solar, eee deu (6.511%) 280530 19.87 8.45 21.589 hree solar, eee chn (11.598%) 282560 29.99 1.70 30.040 ge jpn (6.044%) 283691 30.65 0.00 30.648 li ev, eee chl (11.023%) 284610 32.64 1.00 32.651 ce eee jpn (20.777%) 284690 30.81 0.50 30,815 lree eee jpn (15.431%) 391000 55.63 0.00 55.628 si solar, ev blx (5.368%) 711019 26.68 11.50 29.054 pt zaf (23.751%) 711029 24.72 9.70 26.555 pd eee rus (34.217%) 810600 27.57 1.00 27.590 bi eee chn (19.52%) 811219 13.55 0.00 13.549 be eee usa (20.995%) source: author’s elaboration european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5988 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 8 figure 4. scatter plot areas’s indication source: author’s elaboration critical materials for the sector intending to secure the production chain could look at circularity and/or market safety. again, institutional quality is just a 'preventive' measure. it does not state an absolute and unequivocal measure of violations. in this application, we see that most green materials are outside the comfort zone of fair and recyclable materials; a synthetic graph of the analysis is portrayed in figure 4, along with the distinction areas we previously mentioned. with a wider perspective on all examples, we could outline a trade-off between circularity and institutional quality. the correlation for eee is -26.5%, for solar panels is -37.2%, for ev -22.9% and finally wind farms is 24.0%. its relevance in this paper is to prove the existence of the inverse relation between index m and eol-rir in crm. the calculation has been made on all crm according to the report of the eu commission. we collected the relevant information in table 1. the total panel of materials is referred to the category of electronic and electrical equipment (eee). they design all commodities that are designed to function via electricity. we used eee as a yardstick configuration as they contain almost all crm. its waste designation is named waste eee (weee) according to eu packages of 2008 and 2014. a recent report highlighted that these commodities are normally not designed to be fully recycled (raudaskoski et al., 2019). they are relevant for the strategy of circularity, and usually, the other three products are considered related to them for sustainable electricity generation and components (accumulators). therefore, we split materials according to the uses in three sectors of the green transition. these are solar panels, electric vehicles (ev), and wind farms. the highlighted trade-off is present in both solar farms and evs. the difference between sector vulnerability is represented in figure 5. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5988 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 9 figure 5. sector allocation of crm source: author’s elaboration wind farms are based on materials characterized by a heterogeneous set according to circularity and generally tainted markets. solar farms register some materials in the comfort zone, such as copper and zinc. outside hree and g5 materials, it is overall a safe sector. some materials could be recovered by discarded (iron, silver, and lead). others by acquired on fair markets (silicon, aluminum, and selenium). wind farms rely mostly on tainted markets, whereas most of these are easy to recover from european scrap metals (copper and lead). unfortunately, cobalt and g5 are necessary for components, greatly endangering this sector's circularity and production chain fairness. finally, ev crm is characterized by both trade-offs and deep criticalities. due to the level of technological complexity, this should not sound surprising. nonetheless, it is relevant to point out that both lithium and cobalt, the lowest in eol-rir, are required. according to our result, lithium is significantly safer than most other recyclable materials but not within the tradeoff. these two are, according to our criticality, the most difficult to control for a sustainability transition. the european production chain for transition commodities such as these is incredibly vulnerable in the following decades without institutional quality and recycling technology improvements. in this section, we briefly classified materials according to an index "m" and eol-rir. the first evaluated together market concentration and institutional quality. it greatly penalizes materials that are concentrated in fragile states. eol-rir refers to the recycling potential of the referred material. a brief discussion over the results will classify the focus of policies. 5. discussion circularity and rs collect strategies are intended to reduce the adverse effects of external dependency. since the eu is abiding by oecd due diligence practices, imports must conform to international standards. however, indicators for human rights violations are sparse, and data clearance is one of the main pillars of due diligence. efforts to create a consensus have been made (oecd, 2020). using national-level indicators for institutional quality allows having a homogenous measure comparable between suppliers and between sectors. using such indicator along with market concentration is possible to identify the nodes of monopoly and political instability. reducing dependencies from fragile nations (or fostering their development) represents a strategy for external risk mitigation. investing in recycling technologies and enforce circularity policies reduce internal vulnerability: the lack of relevant raw materials' deposits. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5988 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 10 demand for green transition commodities still is dominated by the european market. eu represents the destination of most of those raw materials, nevertheless their risk. the focus on gdp use in criticality analysis is redundant in these terms. the main vulnerability to recall is to eu welfare. the impossibility of applying carbon-neutral policies and allocate enough eee affects contemporary and future standards of living. thus, when considering rs, firms increase the welfare value of their chain more than the economic value. in such a sense, gdp is not a measure of welfare (stiglitz et al., 2018). it is a common feature to use as an economical substitute when using economic value over the total gdp (or sector) (ferro & bonollo, 2019). in this sense, focusing on critical indicators of circularity and institutional quality allows identifying alternative strategies. for instance, sectors that are characterized by negative correlation could focus on circularity or rs efforts according to their cost function. such approach could be done with three indicators at time, and could be repeated for as many indicators are necessary. however, literature has demonstrated that the relevance of geopolitical and economic relevance indicators could be redundant. the cartesian distance approach has an inherent limitation: it is an indifference indicator. since our interest was to give no particular preference to the indicators at any level, it does not penalize our results. the higher the value, the safest in the supply line. the cartesian distance indicator grows logistically with its argumenta values. in case one of the two variables is near zero, the other hand explains its importance. therefore, a long distance with one of the two arguments as near-zero indicates specialization possibility. if the application (for instance, solar panel) involves lead, circular policies could mitigate risks on the supply line. lead is relatively cheaper to recycle, but the sources are often not institutionally stable. as long as sectors can allocate their inputs according to the correlation, they can maximize their results in circularity and rs. applications of cobalt are, in terms of rs, the most unsafe. the nearest element in terms of low value is beryllium, with 13.549 points of cartesian distance. in our study, its applications are mainly concentrated in eee, in particular for circuits. while its circularity is nearly null, its primary source consists of usa mines. this means that rs strategies might yield better results. circularity policies are topical for crm. secondary materials substitute virgin materials, reducing dependency on fragile countries. as reported in results and figures 4 and 5, most materials low in the m index have decent eol-rir (in many cases debatable but helpful). similarly, one lree, cerium, is low in circularity but proper in the m index. sectors that rely on such material could focus on circularity improvements to success in sdg. overall, commodities related to wind farms and solar panels employ crm characterized by a decent level of circularity: most of them are above the median demarcation line. complex commodities such as eee and ev are unfortunately challenging to manage. eee is a comprehensive group. however, crm applications are characterized by stable trade partners such as japan. our analysis may affect, for the most significant part, only some of the commodities within eee. for instance, ict-related commodities are composed of a complex set of crm (kasulaitis et al., 2015) compared to heavy household appliances. green transition dependency to crm does not represent a bottleneck for its policies. some commodities critical for it could benefit from concentrated efforts on only one of these: rs or circularity. solar farms, for instance, use hree, but most of their materials generally have decent circularity levels. therefore, improving rs factors by blending the product chain with secondary materials is possible. a similar approach could be made for wind farms. energy policies involving such instruments are fascinating nexus for mineral securities and rs. considering their relatively low-risk sources, they are useful for carbon transition, considering conflict minerals legislation. on the other hand, evs are a strong driver of carbon-free mobility. unfortunately, their production relies on several crm affected by possible conflicts and low circularity. 6. conclusion although used in low concentrations, the growing electronics and transition commodities market has increased the global demand for critical materials. this has generated concerns about crm international reserves and supply since they are either scarce or extracted in a limited number of countries. the main strategies for mitigating material criticality are recycling and responsible sourcing (lapko et al., 2019; young, 2018). recycling is likely to reduce input from primary raw materials, although it may not meet the growing market demand for certain materials (mayyas et al., 2019). rs leverages stewardship and certification programs that support sustainable development and practices in mining countries, steering cooperation among countries and industrial sectors, arguably securing the supply of raw materials (gandenberger et al., 2012). both strategies present organizational and operational constraints, besides major technological issues (for recycling). commonly described as immaterial, digital technology is, on the contrary, high energy and material intensive (see the work of ecoinfo in france. see also maxwell (2014) and lepawsky (2018)). european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5988 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 11 there is now vast literature documenting the materials, infrastructure, labor conditions, and energy requirements underpinning digital technology production, maintenance, and disposal. there is still no consensus, however, on which indicators are necessary for disclosure. ngos and national laws in the us and eu have recently focused on supplying "conflict minerals" tin, tantalum, tungsten, and gold. the first two, in particular, are used to produce components of circuit boards and electronic devices). mining and trade are entangled in conflict and severe social conditions in the democratic republic of the congo (drc). demanding enterprises to verify purchased goods as "conflict-free" means that they are not extracted in a conflict zone and used to finance war as in certain provinces of the drc. our paper has presented a critical study on crm. to classify the vulnerability of the eu in terms of total supply, we considered two aspects: responsible sourcing and circularity. in this sense, the general objective should be to access materials on markets safe from human rights violations and secondary materials. we identified as a proxy variable for human rights safety an index of institutional quality. eol-rir is the reference for circularity. it is generally employed in criticality assessment for crm, and it is a proxy for secondary material recovery. the former relates to the market concentration jointly with the institutional quality of exporters. we elaborated a synthetic index for these two aspects: market/institution fragility versus circularity, hence internal versus external vulnerability. using a classification based on trivial index generation, we presented evidence of a trade-off between circularity and market concentration/institutional quality. according to our results, energy commodities of wind and solar farms represent a safe instrument for transition policies when we consider internal and external vulnerability. the article presents a novel investigation of the systemic limits of outsourcing green commodities. considering that european union has put the transition to a low carbon society, the production of such artifacts should at least abide by principles of fair labor and democracy. it addresses the emergent correlation between the two aspects of circularity and safe trades using external and internal weakness as the key of interpretation. the study presents several limitations anyway. first, it was mainly an exploratory study over the limits of criticality studies in the context of crm. the indicators employed were the most used in the literature. however, there is a lack of comprehensive indicators of welfare regarding raw materials and their extraction. the methodology tried to overcome the issue by generating more indicators from available data. the implied complementarity of the two weaknesses is highly debatable from an economic standpoint, especially if looking at a dynamic one. thus, the paper presents a conservative perspective over the potential of electrification of the automotive sector. transition commodities such as ev, solar panels, and wind farms present decent average circularity and safe external sources when the former lacks. the ev sector represents both methodologies, the most critical sector for circularity, market vulnerability, and human rights violation. in terms of liability risk, it means, according to these results, the industry with the most significant liability risk for responsible sourcing and material circularity. the exponential growth of markets for electric vehicles is likely to put under pressure in the short and medium-term. the results show that beryllium and cobalt traded in europe are critical from the institutional quality and circularity perspective. the methodology applied is not necessarily bound to application in crm. energy commodities such as gas and oil are affected by similar performance. instead of circularity, climate impact could be a possible substitute. overall, the paper presented results on non-energetic elements using two main aspects. this limitation could hinder the completeness of our results. however, indicators of rs could greatly vary between commodities and nations. circularity is based upon industrial definitions. thus fewer indicators could be considered alternatives to eol-rir. finally, rs and circularity represent a gap in the literature. while our study is not intended to give a complete toolkit for supply strategy, it identified an advantage. future studies might consider the problem of destabilized supply chains. a trade war affecting green products could impede carbon reduction for short periods. the effect on welfare would therefore be significant, especially in the long term. several studies have presented the potential for business accounting (piontek et al., 2021; scarpellini, 2021). further data in the field could improve the understanding of listed companies' financial risks with unstable supply chains. better knowledge of the complex supply networks of crms for europe can provide several insights for european policymakers. consensus over rs indicators is vital for this purpose and represents a relevant gap in the literature. it should be further explored to support the development of cooperation programs and actions (e.g., the clean cobalt initiative). the challenges for a sustainable transition consist of discovering more innovative technologies and rethinking commodity design to improve their durability and reparability. improved interaction with local communities might strengthen supply security even when national indicators say otherwise. local realities often constitute particularities. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5988 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 12 references ali, s. h., giurco, d., arndt, n., nickless, e., brown, g., demetriades, a., durrheim, r., enriquez, m. a., kinnaird, j., littleboy, a., meinert, l. d., oberhänsli, r., salem, j., schodde, r., schneider, g., vidal, o., & yakovleva, n. (2017). mineral supply for sustainable development requires resource governance. nature, 543(7645), 367–372. https://doi.org/10.1038/nature21359 ambekar, s., prakash, a., & patyal, v. s. (2019). role of culture in low carbon supply chain capabilities. journal of manufacturing technology management, 30(1), 146–179. https://doi.org/10.1108/jmtm-01-2018-0024 arendt, r., muhl, m., bach, v., & finkbeiner, m. (2020). criticality assessment of abiotic resource use for europe– application of the scarce method. resources policy, 67(december 2019), 101650. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.resourpol.2020.101650 blagoeva, d., alves dias, p., marmier, a., & pavel, c. (2016). assessment of potential bottlenecks along the materials supply chain for the future deployment of low-carbon energy and transport technologies in the eu: wind power, photovoltaic and electric vehicles technologies, time frame: 2015-2030. https://doi.org/10.2790/08169 bleischwitz, r. (2020). mineral resources in the age of climate adaptation and resilience. journal of industrial ecology, 24(2), 291–299. https://doi.org/10.1111/jiec.12951 bleischwitz, r., & bahn‐walkowiak, b. (2007). aggregates and construction markets in europe: towards a sectoral action plan on sustainable resource management. minerals & energy raw materials report, 22(3–4), 159–176. https://doi.org/10.1080/14041040701683664 blengini, g. a., nuss, p., dewulf, j., nita, v., talens peiró, l., vidal-legaz, b., latunussa, c., mancini, l., blagoeva, d., pennington, d., pellegrini, m., van maercke, a., solar, s., grohol, m., & ciupagea, c. (2017). eu methodology for critical raw materials assessment: policy needs and proposed solutions for incremental improvements. resources policy, 53(march), 12–19. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.resourpol.2017.05.008 bobba, s., carrara, s., huisman, j., mathieux, f., & pavel, c. (2020). critical raw materials for strategic technologies and sectors in the eu a foresight study. in european commission. https://doi.org/10.2873/58081 british geological survey, b. (2015). british geological survey risk list 2015. risk list 2015. chiu, a. s. f., aviso, k. b., & tan, r. r. (2020). on general principles at the sustainability science-policy interface. resources, conservation and recycling, 158. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.resconrec.2020.104828 church, c., & crawford, a. (2018). conflict minerals : the fuels of conflict (issue august). cimprich, a., bach, v., helbig, c., thorenz, a., schrijvers, d., sonnemann, g., young, s. b., sonderegger, t., & berger, m. (2019). raw material criticality assessment as a complement to environmental life cycle assessment: examining methods for product-level supply risk assessment. journal of industrial ecology, 23(5), 1226–1236. https://doi.org/10.1111/jiec.12865 commission of the european communities. (2008). the raw materials initiative : meeting our critical needs for growth and jobs in europe (no. 699). cossu, r., & williams, i. d. (2015). urban mining: concepts, terminology, challenges. waste management, 45, 1–3. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.wasman.2015.09.040 deloitte. (2015). study on data for a raw material system analysis: roadmap and test of the fully operational msa for raw materials. eu. (2017). regulation (eu) 2017/821 of the european parliament and of the council of 17 may 2017 laying down supply chain due diligence obligations for union importers of tin, tantalum and tungsten, their ores, and gold originating from conflict-affected and high-ri. official journal of the european union, 60. expósito, a., & velasco, f. (2018). municipal solid-waste recycling market and the european 2020 horizon strategy: a regional efficiency analysis in spain. journal of cleaner production, 172, 938–948. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2017.10.221 ferro, p., & bonollo, f. (2019). materials selection in a critical raw materials perspective. materials & design, 177, 107848. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.matdes.2019.107848 gandenberger, c., glöser, s., marscheider-weidemann, f., ostertag, k., & rainer, w. (2012). die versorgung der deutschen wirtschaft mit rohund werkstoffen für hochtechnologien – präzisierung und weiterentwicklung der deutschen rohstoffstrategie. homrich, a. s., galvão, g., abadia, l. g., & carvalho, m. m. (2018). the circular economy umbrella: trends and gaps on integrating pathways. in journal of cleaner production (vol. 175, pp. 525–543). elsevier. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2017.11.064 h�mor, t. (2004). sustainable mining in the european union: the legislative aspect. environmental management, 33(2), european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5988 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 13 252–261. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00267-003-0081-7 jones, b., elliott, r. j. r., & nguyen-tien, v. (2020). the ev revolution: the road ahead for critical raw materials demand. applied energy, 280(april), 115072. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.apenergy.2020.115072 kasulaitis, b. v, babbitt, c. w., kahhat, r., williams, e., & ryen, e. g. (2015). evolving materials, attributes, and functionality in consumer electronics: case study of laptop computers. resources, conservation and recycling, 100, 1– 10. https://doi.org/https://doi.org/10.1016/j.resconrec.2015.03.014 kaufmann, d., kraay, a., & mastruzzi, m. (2011). the worldwide governance indicators: methodology and analytical issues. hague journal on the rule of law, 3(02), 220–246. https://doi.org/10.1017/s1876404511200046 koch, d.-j., & burlyuk, o. (2020). bounded policy learning? eu efforts to anticipate unintended consequences in conflict minerals legislation. journal of european public policy, 27(10), 1441–1462. https://doi.org/10.1080/13501763.2019.1675744 kunčič, a. (2014). institutional quality dataset. journal of institutional economics, 10(1), 135–161. https://doi.org/10.1017/s1744137413000192 lapko, y., trianni, a., nuur, c., & masi, d. (2019). in pursuit of closed-loop supply chains for critical materials: an exploratory study in the green energy sector. journal of industrial ecology, 23(1), 182–196. https://doi.org/10.1111/jiec.12741 lepawsky, j. (2018). reassembling rubbish: worlding electronic waste. mit press. https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/servlet/opac?bknumber=8544156 martins, f., & castro, h. (2019). significance ranking method applied to some eu critical raw materials in a circular economy – priorities for achieving sustainability. procedia cirp, 84, 1059–1062. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.procir.2019.04.281 martins, f. f., & castro, h. (2020). raw material depletion and scenario assessment in european union – a circular economy approach. energy reports, 6, 417–422. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.egyr.2019.08.082 maxwell, r. (2014). media and the ecological crisis. in media and the ecological crisis. routledge. https://doi.org/10.4324/9781315885650 mayyas, a., steward, d., & mann, m. (2019). the case for recycling: overview and challenges in the material supply chain for automotive li-ion batteries. sustainable materials and technologies, 19, e00087. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.susmat.2018.e00087 mazzarano, m. (2020). estimating total potential material recovery from eee in eu28. resources policy, 68. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.resourpol.2020.101785 misopoulos, f., argyropoulou, r., manthou, v., argyropoulou, m., & kelmendi, i. (2020). carbon emissions of bottled water sector supply chains: a multiple case-study approach. international journal of logistics research and applications, 23(2), 178–194. https://doi.org/10.1080/13675567.2019.1626815 monnet, a., & ait abderrahim, a. (2018). report on major trends affecting future demand for critical raw materials. mudd, g. m., jowitt, s. m., & werner, t. t. (2018). global platinum group element resources, reserves and mining – a critical assessment. science of the total environment, 622–623, 614–625. https://doi.org/https://doi.org/10.1016/j.scitotenv.2017.11.350 oecd. (2016a). oecd due diligence guidance for responsible supply chains of minerals from conflict-affected and high-risk areas. in oecd due diligence guidance for responsible supply chains of minerals from conflict-affected and high-risk areas. oecd publishing. https://doi.org/10.1787/9789264252479-en oecd. (2016b). oecd due diligence guidance for responsible supply chains of minerals from conflict-affected and high-risk areas (third). oecd publishing. https://doi.org/10.1787/9789264252479-en oecd. (2020). promoting coherence between standards on responsible mineral supply chains: the oecd due diligence guidance for responsible supply chains of minerals from conflict-affected and high-risk areas and the extractive industries transparency initiative standard. pehlken, a., albach, s., & vogt, t. (2017). is there a resource constraint related to lithium ion batteries in cars? international journal of life cycle assessment, 22(1), 40–53. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11367-015-0925-4 piontek, f., herrmann, c., & saraev, a. (2021). steps from zero carbon supply chains and demand of circular economy to circular business cases. european journal of social impact and circular economy, 2(2 se-). https://doi.org/10.13135/2704-9906/5712 rabe, w., kostka, g., & smith stegen, k. (2017). china’s supply of critical raw materials: risks for europe’s solar and wind industries? energy policy, 101, 692–699. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.enpol.2016.09.019 raudaskoski, a., lenau, t., jokinen, t., gisslén, a. v., & metze, a.-l. (2019). designing plastics circulation. nordic european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5988 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 14 council of ministers. https://doi.org/10.6027/tn2019-534 santillán-saldivar, j., cimprich, a., shaikh, n., laratte, b., young, s. b., & sonnemann, g. (2021a). how recycling mitigates supply risks of critical raw materials: extension of the geopolitical supply risk methodology applied to information and communication technologies in the european union. resources, conservation and recycling, 164(february 2020), 105108. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.resconrec.2020.105108 santillán-saldivar, j., cimprich, a., shaikh, n., laratte, b., young, s. b., & sonnemann, g. (2021b). how recycling mitigates supply risks of critical raw materials: extension of the geopolitical supply risk methodology applied to information and communication technologies in the european union. resources, conservation and recycling, 164(february 2020), 105108. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.resconrec.2020.105108 scarpellini, s. (2021). social indicators for businesses’ circular economy: multi-faceted analysis of employment as an indicator for sustainability reporting. european journal of social impact and circular economy, 2(1 se-). https://doi.org/10.13135/2704-9906/5282 schaubroeck, t. (2020). circular economy practices may not always lead to lower criticality or more sustainability; analysis and guidance is needed per case. in resources, conservation and recycling (vol. 162, p. 104977). elsevier b.v. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.resconrec.2020.104977 schrijvers, d., hool, a., blengini, g. a., chen, w.-q., dewulf, j., eggert, r., van ellen, l., gauss, r., goddin, j., habib, k., hagelüken, c., hirohata, a., hofmann-amtenbrink, m., kosmol, j., le gleuher, m., grohol, m., ku, a., lee, m.-h., liu, g., … wäger, p. a. (2020). a review of methods and data to determine raw material criticality. resources, conservation and recycling, 155. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.resconrec.2019.104617 silva, s., & schaltegger, s. (2019). social assessment and management of conflict minerals: a systematic literature review. sustain. accounting, manag. policy j., 10(1), 157–182. https://doi.org/10.1108/sampj-02-2018-0029 song, j., yan, w., cao, h., song, q., ding, h., lv, z., zhang, y., & sun, z. (2019). material flow analysis on critical raw materials of lithium-ion batteries in china. j. clean. prod. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2019.01.081 stefanakis, a. (2019). the role of constructed wetlands as green infrastructure for sustainable urban water management. sustainability, 11(24), 6981. https://doi.org/10.3390/su11246981 stiglitz, j. e., fitoussi, j.-p., & durand, m. (2018). beyond gdp. oecd. https://doi.org/10.1787/9789264307292-en tabner, i. t. (2007). a review of concentration, diversity or entropy metrics in economics, finance, ecology and communication science. the international journal of interdisciplinary social sciences: annual review, 2(4), 53–60. https://doi.org/10.18848/1833-1882/cgp/v02i04/52345 talens peiró, l., nuss, p., mathieux, f., & blengini, g. a. (2018). towards recycling indicators based on eu flows and raw materials system analysis data supporting the eu-28 (issue october). publications office of the european union. https://doi.org/10.2760/092885 tercero espinoza, l., schrijvers, d., chen, w.-q., dewulf, j., eggert, r., goddin, j., habib, k., hagelüken, c., hurd, a. j., kleijn, r., ku, a. y., lee, m.-h., nansai, k., nuss, p., peck, d., petavratzi, e., sonnemann, g., van der voet, e., wäger, p. a., … hool, a. (2020). greater circularity leads to lower criticality, and other links between criticality and the circular economy. resources, conservation and recycling, 159. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.resconrec.2020.104718 vrkljan, d., klanfar, m., tost, m., & endl, a. (2017). min-guide version innovative exploration and extraction deliverable 3.4. guidelines and recommendations for future policy and legislation minerals policy guidance for europe min-guide -d 3.4. guidelines and recommendations for future policy and legislatio. https://doi.org/10.13140/rg.2.2.23128.65289 young, s. b. (2018). responsible sourcing of metals: certification approaches for conflict minerals and conflict-free metals. the international journal of life cycle assessment, 23(7), 1429–1447. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11367-015-0932-5 ziemann, s., müller, d. b., schebek, l., & weil, m. (2018). modeling the potential impact of lithium recycling from ev batteries on lithium demand: a dynamic mfa approach. resources, conservation and recycling, 133, 76–85. https://doi.org/https://doi.org/10.1016/j.resconrec.2018.01.031 european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/12056 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license this article is not subject to double-blind peer review and is part of the practitioners perspective section for 2025. 1 proposte di sviluppo e innovazione per il sistema delle startup italiane: il ruolo di innovup e il scaleup act matteo beccuti1*, giorgio ciron1 *autore di contatto matteo.beccuti@envipark.com 1 environment park, torino, italia. abstract l’articolo analizza lo sviluppo del sistema startup in italia attraverso una revisione della letteratura, un confronto con il contesto europeo e un focus sulle novità legislative introdotte dallo scaleup act del 2024. viene discusso il ruolo strategico di innovup e l’impatto economico delle startup innovative, con proposte per il potenziamento degli ecosistemi di innovazione glocali. parole chiave: startup innovative; ecosistema dell’innovazione; scaleup act 2024; startup act 2012 1. introduzione negli ultimi due decenni, l’ecosistema delle startup è emerso come uno dei principali motori di innovazione, trasformazione economica e rinnovamento imprenditoriale nei paesi avanzati. in questo scenario globale, l’italia ha intrapreso un percorso di riconfigurazione normativa e istituzionale per colmare un ritardo storico nella promozione dell’imprenditorialità innovativa. a partire dallo startup act del 2012, fino alle più recenti misure contenute nello scaleup act del 2024, il legislatore ha progressivamente strutturato un insieme di strumenti volti a incentivare la nascita, la crescita e la competitività delle startup innovative. tuttavia, nonostante i progressi normativi e l’aumento delle startup iscritte al registro delle imprese, il sistema italiano continua a scontare limiti strutturali – tra cui una scarsa propensione al rischio, un accesso limitato a capitali di crescita e una frammentazione degli attori dell’innovazione – che lo rendono meno competitivo rispetto ad altri ecosistemi europei. in particolare, il cosiddetto scaleup gap, ovvero la difficoltà delle startup italiane a evolversi in imprese mature e internazionalizzate, rappresenta ancora oggi una delle principali criticità del sistema. alla luce di queste dinamiche, il presente contributo si propone di analizzare in chiave multidimensionale l’evoluzione del sistema delle startup italiane, con particolare attenzione al ruolo delle politiche pubbliche, delle reti di supporto e degli attori intermedi. dopo una revisione della letteratura e delle principali definizioni teoriche, l’articolo si sofferma sull’impianto normativo introdotto dallo startup act e sulle successive innovazioni legislative previste dallo scaleup act, approvato nel 2024. in questo contesto, viene valorizzato il ruolo strategico svolto da innovup, associazione di riferimento per l’ecosistema european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/12056 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license this article is not subject to double-blind peer review and is part of the practitioners perspective section for 2025. 2 italiano dell’innovazione, nella promozione di proposte legislative, nella creazione di connessioni tra territori e nell’accesso ai programmi europei. attraverso un’analisi integrata di dati ufficiali, report istituzionali e fonti accademiche, il lavoro intende offrire una panoramica critica sulle sfide e le opportunità del sistema italiano, evidenziando il valore economico e sociale delle startup innovative, nonché la necessità di politiche multilivello capaci di coniugare crescita, sostenibilità e internazionalizzazione. il contributo si chiude con una riflessione sulle prospettive future, proponendo traiettorie di sviluppo per favorire una governance dell’innovazione più coesa e orientata all’impatto. 2. revisione della letteratura 2.1 evoluzione del concetto: definizioni e cornice teoriche partendo da un quadro descrittivo del concetto di start up e dalla letteratura di riferimento a livello internazionale e poi nazionale, si arriva a presentare quali sono gli strumenti di finanziamento messi a disposizione e la normativa attuale di riferimento in italia in merito alle startup, alle startup innovative e il loro rispettivo posizionamento. nello specifico, si approfondiranno le novità introdotte dallo scaleup act del 2024 e i cambiamenti strutturali rispetto al precedente startup act del 2012. successivamente, gli autori propongono, sulla base delle fonti citate, possibili spunti di riflessione, opportunità di sviluppo e prospettive future di promozione di driver ecosistemici innovativi, sottolineandone i fattori di successo e le criticità. è innanzitutto importante sottolineare come la letteratura sul tema delle startup sia estremamente vasta e in continua espansione, costantemente arricchita da nuovi volumi, studi e contributi presentati in conferenze internazionali. proprio per questa complessità e ricchezza, non esiste un’opera che raccolga in modo esaustivo e condiviso tutti gli aspetti teorici legati al fare impresa nelle startup italiane (frasson, 2025). tuttavia, uno dei testi di riferimento più riconosciuti e utilizzati, sia in ambito accademico sia nella pratica durante la fase di company creation, è il manuale di alexander osterwalder e yves pigneur del 2010, intitolato business model generation: a handbook for visionaries, game changers, and challengers. il volume, frutto della collaborazione di oltre 400 professionisti provenienti da 45 paesi, è ampiamente adottato nelle università come base per lo sviluppo di case study e per l’insegnamento del metodo business model canvas, uno strumento fondamentale per apprendere e sperimentare l’arte di creare un’impresa (frasson, 2025). tra le diverse modalità di classificazione e interpretazione del concetto di startup, la definizione formulata nel 2012 da steve blank, imprenditore di riferimento della silicon valley, secondo cui “una startup è un’organizzazione temporanea progettata per cercare un modello di business scalabile e ripetibile” (blank et al., 2012, p. 17), costituisce un punto di riferimento teorico essenziale. essa evidenzia la dimensione esplorativa e sperimentale che caratterizza queste organizzazioni nella fase iniziale del loro ciclo di sviluppo. in un contesto più nazionale, secondo la treccani, il termine startup si riferisce alla “fase iniziale di avvio delle attività di una nuova impresa, di un’impresa appena costituita o di un’impresa che si è appena quotata in borsa”1. risulta maggiormente complicato, invece, definire in modo univoco le startup innovative. con l’obiettivo di promuovere la crescita sostenibile, lo sviluppo tecnologico e l’occupazione, in particolare giovanile, 1 fonte: https://www.treccani.it/enciclopedia/startup_(dizionario-di-economia-e-finanza)/. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/12056 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license this article is not subject to double-blind peer review and is part of the practitioners perspective section for 2025. 3 nell’autunno del 2012 il governo italiano ha adottato una normativa (dl 18 ottobre 2012, n. 179, convertito con modificazioni dalla legge 221 del 17 dicembre 2012) per inquadrare questa categoria. secondo la normativa, si intende “la società di capitali, costituita anche in forma cooperativa, le cui azioni o quote rappresentative del capitale sociale non sono quotate su un mercato regolamentato o su un sistema multilaterale di negoziazione che rispettino requisiti specifici”2 (dei requisiti si dirà oltre nel paragrafo 2). le start up innovative sono quindi imprese caratterizzate dall’elevato grado di innovatività (hi-tech, software, biotecnologie, ecc.) e che operano in questi settori (di cui si dirà oltre nel paragrafo 3). originariamente utilizzato in ambito informatico, il termine ‘startup’ è stato adottato anche nel linguaggio economico, riferendosi alla fase iniziale di una nuova impresa nata nel settore internet o delle tecnologie dell’informazione. come osserva villani “solitamente le giovani imprese in fase iniziale presentano un rischio più elevato rispetto a quelle già consolidate sul mercato, ma questo rischio esalta sia le prospettive di guadagno sia la possibilità di perdite dovute ad una limitata quantità di risorse sia umane sia finanziarie” (villani, 2019, cit. in canavesio, 2023, p. 6). il risultato di queste azioni vede spesso le startup soccombere nel tentativo di sviluppare un prodotto o un servizio per i quali si crede possa esserci un’ampia richiesta di mercato, laddove invece, “la maggior parte di queste operazioni su piccola scala non sono sostenibili nel lungo periodo, senza ulteriori sovvenzioni da parte di soggetti finanziari quali venture capitalist”3. 2.2 ricognizione e posizionamento rispetto al contesto europeo il consiglio dei ministri ue, sulla base del programma nazionale di riforma del 2012 aveva rivolto all’italia un forte invito alla promozione di attività imprenditoriali giovanili, che includessero una forte componente innovativa (european commission, 2022). fino ad allora, infatti, l’imprenditoria innovativa in italia non era mai stata regolata da una disciplina specifica. le conseguenze derivanti da questa assenza normativa sono ancora oggi riscontrabili. secondo quanto riportato nell’european innovation scoreboard 2022, a cura della direzione generale per la ricerca e l’innovazione della commissione europea, il livello di innovazione dell’imprenditoria italiana ha raggiunto il 90% della media ue, posizionando il paese al sedicesimo posto nella classifica generale (european commission, 2022). tuttavia, nel contesto attuale, l’italia continua a manifestare un significativo gap innovativo rispetto ad altri paesi europei. in particolare sempre lo stesso report del 2022 colloca l’italia al diciottesimo posto per quanto riguarda l’efficacia dell’ecosistema delle startup tecnologiche finanziate tramite capitale di rischio da venture capitalist e business angel (european commission, 2022). le ragioni di tale gap sono da ricercarsi sia nella ritardata introduzione della normativa sulle startup innovative, sia nelle carenti infrastrutture tecnologiche, nella presenza limitata di business angel e fondi di venture capitalist, sia nella consolidata tendenza del sistema produttivo italiano a frammentarsi in una moltitudine di piccole e medie imprese, che faticano a sostenere gli elevati costi – fisiologici – associati ad attività di ricerca e innovazione (frasson, 2025). un riflesso diretto di questa situazione si osserva considerando il numero di startup “unicorno” presenti sul territorio nazionale. con tale termine, coniato nel 2013 da aileen lee, fondatrice del fondo di venture capital cowboys ventures, ci si riferisce ad imprese operanti nel settore delle tecnologie che abbiano una 2 fonte: https://www.mimit.gov.it/images/stories/art25-dl179-2012.pdf. 3 fonte: https://www.treccani.it/enciclopedia/startup_(dizionario-di-economia-e-finanza)/. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/12056 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license this article is not subject to double-blind peer review and is part of the practitioners perspective section for 2025. 4 valutazione superiore al miliardo di euro4. la metafora dell’unicorno è facilmente intuibile: entrambe le creature risulterebbero essere più uniche che rare. non a caso, sulla base degli elementi citati, il divario tra l’italia e gli altri paesi europei è evidente: dei 150 unicorni europei, solo 4 sono nati e cresciuti in italia (yoox, depop, scalapay e, di recente, satispay5). numeri ben diversi da quelli relativi al regno unito dove, fino alla brexit, se ne contavano 44, mentre in germania se ne contano 29, e in francia 25 (frasson, 2025). le cause di questo fenomeno possono essere ricondotte a una pluralità di fattori: differenze nei contesti legislativi, amministrativi, culturali e imprenditoriali, così come una maggiore o minore facilità di accesso ai mezzi finanziari. come già evidenziato, uno degli aspetti che rende particolarmente complesso operare nel settore dell’innovazione è rappresentato dagli elevati costi associati alle attività innovative e dai rischi imprenditoriali ad esse connessi. tendenzialmente, le attività svolte dalle startup sono immateriali e ad alto rischio intrinseco. il loro esito è quindi spesso incerto, in quanto basato sull’esplorazione di nuovi mercati, sull’introduzione di prodotti e servizi inediti e sulla creazione di beni di cui non è ancora nota la reale appetibilità da parte del mercato6. il cuore pulsante di una startup – specialmente di quelle operanti in settori high-tech o farmaceutici – è certamente l’attività di ricerca e sviluppo. le neoimprese che non dispongono di adeguate risorse finanziarie si vedono costrette a ridurre gli investimenti in nuovi progetti: ciò comporta la perdita di opportunità di crescita e una riduzione del potenziale dell’azienda. il capitale umano e il livello di istruzione rappresentano fattori critici per la nascita e il consolidamento delle startup innovative: elementi non sempre facilmente reperibili nel panorama imprenditoriale italiano (frasson, 2025). il problema principale può essere così riassunto: in italia, eccellenza scientifica e innovazione non procedono di pari passo. infatti, sebbene il paese si posizioni bene a livello internazionale per numero di pubblicazioni scientifiche in ambito accademico e di ricerca, ottiene risultati più modesti in termini di brevetti industriali e di competitività nei settori ad alto tasso di innovazione (carnazza, 2017). in questo quadro generale, appare evidente la necessità di implementare anche a livello nazionale un pacchetto normativo specifico e strutturato per le startup innovative, in grado di sostenere in modo coerente il loro sviluppo lungo tutte le fasi del ciclo di vita. 3. le novità legislative dello scaleup act 2024 rispetto allo startup act 2012 l’art. 25 del d.l. 18 ottobre 2012, n. 179, convertito con modificazioni dalla l. 17 dicembre 2012, n. 221 ha introdotto nell’ordinamento giuridico italiano una nuova nozione specifica di impresa: la start-up innovativa (tabella 1). in favore di questa tipologia di imprese è stato predisposto un vasto corpus normativo che prevede nuovi strumenti e misure di vantaggio che incidono sull’intero ciclo di vita dell’azienda, dall’avvio alle fasi di espansione e maturità7. il comma 2 dell’art. 25 stabilisce anche i criteri 4 fonte: https://engage.it/brand-e-aziende/aziende-unicorno-il-fenomeno-delle-startup-da-un-miliardo-didollari.aspx#:~:text=nel%202013%20aileen%20lee%2c%20fondatrice,miliardo%20di%20dollari%20o%20pi%c3%b9. 5 fonte: https://engage.it/brand-e-aziende/aziende-unicorno-il-fenomeno-delle-startup-da-un-miliardo-didollari.aspx#:~:text=nel%202013%20aileen%20lee%2c%20fondatrice,miliardo%20di%20dollari%20o%20pi%c3%b9. 6 fonte: https://www.mimit.gov.it/images/stories/documenti/policy-startup-agg20.pdf. 7 fonte: https://www.mimit.gov.it/images/stories/documenti/slide%20policy%20startup%20innovative%2007_2019.pdf. https://www.mimit.gov.it/images/stories/documenti/policy-startup-agg20.pdf european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/12056 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license this article is not subject to double-blind peer review and is part of the practitioners perspective section for 2025. 5 che le imprese devono rispettare per poter ottenere lo status di startup innovativa. secondo il dettato normativo, alle misure agevolative possono accedere le società di capitali, costituite anche in forma cooperativa, le cui azioni o quote rappresentative del capitale sociale non sono quotate su un mercato regolamentato o su un sistema multilaterale di negoziazione, e che sono in possesso dei seguenti requisiti così descritti in tabella n.18. tabella 1: definizione di startup innovative e requisiti requisito descrizione sintetica anzianità dell’impresa impresa costituita da non più di 5 anni. sede legale o operativa residente in italia o in altro paese ue, purché con sede produttiva o filiale in italia. limite di fatturato fatturato annuo inferiore a 5 milioni di euro. non quotazione non quotata in mercati regolamentati né in sistemi multilaterali di negoziazione. divieto di distribuzione utili statutario divieto alla distribuzione degli utili. origine dell’impresa non derivante da fusione, scissione o cessione di ramo d’azienda. oggetto sociale innovazione tecnologica come finalità esclusiva o prevalente dell’attività. infine, deve rispettare almeno uno dei seguenti tre requisiti: spesa in r&s spese in ricerca e sviluppo pari ad almeno il 15% del maggiore tra fatturato e costi di produzione. personale qualificato almeno 1/3 del personale con dottorato, dottorandi o ricercatori, oppure 2/3 con laurea magistrale. proprietà intellettuale titolare, depositaria o licenziataria di almeno un brevetto o software registrato. fonte: elaborazione a cura degli autori da ministero dello sviluppo economico (2019). documento disponibile al link: https://www.mimit.gov.it/images/stories/documenti/slide%20policy%20startup%20innovative%2007_20 19.pdf. il possesso dei requisiti obbligatori definiti dall’art. 25 del d.l. 179/2012 consente all’impresa di ottenere lo status di startup innovativa. tale qualifica giuridica dà accesso a un insieme articolato di misure di sostegno previste dallo startup act del 2012, pensate per accompagnare le startup lungo tutto il ciclo di vita e così descritte in tabella n.2: tabella 2: misura di sostegno startup act del 2012 misura di sostegno descrizione sintetica definizione normativa di startup innovativa qualificazione giuridica fondata su requisiti di età, oggetto sociale, dimensioni e innovatività. agevolazioni fiscali per investitori detrazioni e deduzioni fiscali a favore di investimenti in equity nelle startup innovative. 8 fonte: https://www.mimit.gov.it/images/stories/documenti/slide%20policy%20startup%20innovative%2007_2019.pdf. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/12056 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license this article is not subject to double-blind peer review and is part of the practitioners perspective section for 2025. 6 esonero da imposte e diritti camerali esenzione da imposta di bollo e diritti camerali per alleggerire i costi amministrativi iniziali. accesso semplificato al fondo di garanzia per le pmi corsia preferenziale di accesso alla garanzia pubblica per facilitare l’ottenimento di credito bancario. facilitazioni per lavoro flessibile e stock option uso agevolato di contratti flessibili e strumenti di partecipazione come stock option e work for equity. semplificazione della procedura di liquidazione procedura di chiusura semplificata rispetto al fallimento ordinario, con riduzione degli oneri. supporto all’internazionalizzazione (ice, invitalia) programmi di accompagnamento all’estero in collaborazione con ice e invitalia per l’espansione internazionale. creazione sezione speciale nel registro delle imprese registro speciale per garantire trasparenza, tracciabilità e accesso alle misure di sostegno dedicate. fonte: elaborazione a cura degli autori da ministero dello sviluppo economico (2019). documento disponibile al link: https://www.mimit.gov.it/images/stories/documenti/slide%20policy%20startup%20innovative%2007_20 19.pdf. in risposta alle misure del piano nazionale di ripresa e resilienza (pnrr), la rete innovup (di cui si dirà oltre nel capitolo iii) ha promosso una serie di nuove proposte racchiuse nello scaleup act (sotto forma di articolato di cui è possibile vedere l’iter nella figura n.1) mirate all’ampliamento delle agevolazioni fiscali, alla semplificazione amministrativa e al rafforzamento degli strumenti di sostegno alle startup deep-tech e green che possano adeguarsi meglio alle nuove sfide della sostenibilità e dell’innovazione di lungo periodo rispetto al precedente decreto organico startup act. figura 1. revisione della normativa e predisposizione dello scaleup act sotto forma di articolato source: innovup. per ulteriori informazioni consultare il sito web: https://innovup.net european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/12056 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license this article is not subject to double-blind peer review and is part of the practitioners perspective section for 2025. 7 queste misure vengono approvate con voto favorevole della camera nel dicembre 2024 sottolineando la necessità di superare quel “scaleup gap” così riassunte in tabella 39: tabella 3: startup act 2012 e scaleup act 2024 caratteristica startup act (2012) scaleup act (2024) obiettivo favorire la nascita e lo sviluppo iniziale delle startup innovative. facilitare la crescita e la scalabilità delle startup verso il mercato globale. durata delle agevolazioni 5 anni di permanenza nel registro delle startup innovative. estensione fino a 9 anni con criteri progressivi. focalizzazione creazione e incubazione. crescita, internazionalizzazione e attrazione investimenti. incentivi per investitori agevolazioni fiscali per chi investe in startup. maggiore detrazione fiscale per investimenti in scaleup. ruolo degli incubatori riconosciuti solo gli incubatori fisici. inclusione di acceleratori e venture builder. internazionalizzazione non prevista specificamente. incentivi per l’espansione nei mercati esteri. accesso al credito fondi pubblici e garanzie per startup. maggiori incentivi per venture capital e co-investimenti. fonte: elaborazione a cura degli autori da camera dei deputati (2024). documento disponibile al link: https://documenti.camera.it/leg19/documentiacquisiti/com10/audizioni/leg19.com10.audizioni.memor ia.pubblico.ideges.47445.11-10-2024-15-04-50.962.pdf. 4. le startup innovative in italia e il loro impatto economico sociale attraverso il portale del ministero delle imprese e del made in italy è possibile consultare l’ultimo report aggiornato al 2024 in grado di offrire un'analisi dettagliata sull'evoluzione, le caratteristiche e il trend d’impatto economico di queste realtà imprenditoriali e l'accesso al credito da parte di startup innovative, incubatori certificati e pmi innovative, evidenziando l'efficacia delle misure di supporto finanziario. al 31 dicembre 2023, le startup innovative regolarmente iscritte alla relativa sezione speciale del registro imprese ammontano a 13.394 (figura n.2). complici le interruzioni nelle catene del valore globali ed il notevole aumento dei costi dell’energia determinati dalle mutate condizioni geopolitiche, nel 2023 l’ecosistema delle startup ha registrato una leggera e fisiologica flessione (-6,1% rispetto al 2022). se guardiamo al quinquennio conclusosi nel 2023, la crescita del sistema è stata molto significativa: tra il 2019 e il 2023 le startup innovative sono aumentate quasi del 23%. 9 fonte: https://documenti.camera.it/leg19/documentiacquisiti/com10/audizioni/leg19.com10.audizioni.memoria.pubblico.ideg es.47445.11-10-2024-15-04-50.962.pdf. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/12056 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license this article is not subject to double-blind peer review and is part of the practitioners perspective section for 2025. 8 figura 2. andamento del numero di startup innovative nel corso del quinquennio 2019-2023 fonte: ministero delle imprese e del made in italy. documento disponibile al link: https://www.mimit.gov.it/images/stories/documenti/relazioneannuale_2024-finale.pdf a livello geografico, oltre il 35% delle startup innovative risiede nell’italia nord-occidentale, con la lombardia in testa tra tutte le regioni (27,7% sul totale nazionale). significativa è anche la presenza di startup nel mezzogiorno, con un dato complessivo in crescita rispetto allo scorso anno: più di un’impresa su quattro, infatti, opera al sud. in particolare, è la campania che vanta il numero più rilevante (quasi 1.500), con un incremento del 4,6% rispetto al 2022. da segnalare il calo delle startup presenti nel nordest, con l’emilia-romagna capofila. infine, è cospicuo anche il bacino delle startup residenti nell’italia centrale, con il lazio che guida il gruppo con quasi il 13% del totale nazionale (figura 3). european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/12056 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license this article is not subject to double-blind peer review and is part of the practitioners perspective section for 2025. 9 figura 3: startup innovative distinte per ripartizione territoriale e regione fonte: ministero delle imprese e del made in italy. documento disponibile al link: https://www.mimit.gov.it/images/stories/documenti/relazione_annuale_2024-finale.pdf. per quanto riguarda i settori di attività economica, la scelta preponderante delle imprese rimane invariata rispetto al 2022: più della metà delle startup ha un’attività che rientra nella sezione ateco “j servizi di informazione e comunicazione” (figura 4) per un totale di 6.983 imprese, tra le quali 5.575 si occupano di produzione di software, consulenza informatica e attività connesse. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/12056 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license this article is not subject to double-blind peer review and is part of the practitioners perspective section for 2025. 10 figura 4: startup innovative distinte per settori di attività economica ateco 2007 fonte: ministero delle imprese e del made in italy. documento disponibile al link: https://www.mimit.gov.it/images/stories/documenti/relazione_annuale_2024-finale.pdf. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/12056 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license this article is not subject to double-blind peer review and is part of the practitioners perspective section for 2025. 11 riguardo ai requisiti di innovatività (figura 5), nel corso del 2023 sono state 7.982 le startup innovative che hanno dichiarato di possedere solo il primo requisito (15% del maggiore tra costo e valore totale della produzione in attività di ricerca e sviluppo), 2.657 solo il secondo (gruppo formato per 2/3 da personale in possesso di laurea magistrale oppure per 1/3 da dottorandi, dottori di ricerca o laureati con 3 anni di esperienza in attività di ricerca certificata). è interessante evidenziare la crescita delle startup che sono dotate solo del terzo requisito (impresa depositaria o licenziataria di privativa industriale oppure titolare di software registrato), che nel 2023 ammontano a 2.156; mentre rimangono sostanzialmente stabili le startup che posseggono il secondo e il terzo requisito. figura 5: requisiti di innovatività delle startup innovative fonte: ministero delle imprese e del made in italy. documento disponibile al link: https://www.mimit.gov.it/images/stories/documenti/relazione_annuale_2024-finale.pdf. infine, con riferimento al valore della produzione, sono 8.823 (il 65,9% del totale) le startup innovative per cui è disponibile l’ultimo dato aggiornato, ricavato dai bilanci dell’anno precedente (2022 in questo caso). tali startup innovative hanno realizzato complessivamente un valore della produzione pari a circa 2,17 miliardi di euro. i dati indicano una costante crescita nel valore delle start up italiane: difatti, sebbene il numero delle startup sia diminuito di circa il 7% rispetto al 2022, il valore medio della produzione è comunque aumentato del 5,6%. è interessante notare in tal senso il contributo alla crescita delle classi con valore della produzione superiore a 1 milione, che migliorano globalmente sia come numero di startup che come valore della produzione espresso in milioni di euro. in particolare, i dati sui bilanci 2022 mostrano una crescita di circa il 10% del valore della produzione nelle due classi “da 1 a 2 milioni” e “da 2 a 5 milioni”. tale incremento è ancora più consistente nelle due classi successive: “da 5 a 10 milioni” e “da 10 a 50 milioni” rispettivamente del 35,8% e del 63,2% (figura 6). analizzando, invece, il numero di startup innovative si osserva che la classe più consistente, con una presenza di 5.388 imprese in leggera flessione rispetto all’anno precedente equivalenti a circa il 61% del totale, è quella con un fatturato compreso fra 1 e 100 mila euro. da rimarcare la positiva crescita del numero di startup innovative presenti nelle classi con valore della produzione superiore a 1 milione, che passano complessivamente da 441 a 483, con un eccellente risultato. in particolare, la classe “da 1 a 2 milioni” di valore della produzione incrementa di 25 startup e la classe “da 2 a 5 milioni” di valore della produzione aumenta di 6 startup. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/12056 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license this article is not subject to double-blind peer review and is part of the practitioners perspective section for 2025. 12 positive anche le performance delle classi “da 5 a 10 milioni”, con un incremento del 66% da 15 a 25 startup innovative e “da 10 a 50 milioni”, con un incremento del 33% da 3 a 4 startup innovative. figura 6: prevalenza giovanile, femminile e straniera nelle startup innovative fonte: ministero delle imprese e del made in italy. documento disponibile al link: https://www.mimit.gov.it/images/stories/documenti/relazione_annuale_2024-finale.pdf. 5. il ruolo di innovup come connettore innovativo nell’ecosistema italiano innovup – italian innovation & startup ecosystem è l’associazione nazionale che rappresenta l’intero ecosistema dell’innovazione italiano, una piattaforma di dialogo e sviluppo a sostegno della competitività imprenditoriale e tecnologica del paese10. nata nel 2020 dalla fusione tra italia startup e apsti – associazione dei parchi scientifici e tecnologici italiani, aggrega attori eterogenei, per un totale di 450 associati, tra cui startup, pmi innovative, incubatori, acceleratori, corporate, fondi di investimento, università, centri di ricerca e pubbliche amministrazioni11. la missione di innovup mira a promuovere la crescita, l’internazionalizzazione e la sostenibilità dell’innovazione italiana, attraverso attività di advocacy, policy-making, la costruzione di reti multilivello e la realizzazione di eventi di sensibilizzazione e networking. l’associazione funge da “hub sistemico”, favorendo connessioni tra attori pubblici e privati, tra territori e centri decisionali, tra imprese e capitale di rischio. il suo posizionamento strategico come 10 fonte: https://www.innovup.net/. 11 il numero degli associati è stato ottenuto attraverso il conteggio sul sito delle singole categorie così suddivise: abilitatori (50), abilitatori crowdfunding (10), centri di innovazione (71), centri di innovazione startup studio (9), corporate (14), scaleup/pmi innovativa(67), startup seed(229). european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/12056 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license this article is not subject to double-blind peer review and is part of the practitioners perspective section for 2025. 13 interlocutore istituzionale è riconosciuto sia a livello nazionale – mimit, il mef e cdp venture capital – sia a livello europeo, nell’ambito di reti quali startup europe e european startup network (european startup network, members list12. nel contesto post-pandemico, il ruolo di innovup ha acquisito ulteriore centralità. in risposta alle misure del piano nazionale di ripresa e resilienza (pnrr), l’associazione ha promosso proposte mirate all’ampliamento delle agevolazioni fiscali, alla semplificazione amministrativa e al rafforzamento degli strumenti di sostegno alle startup deep-tech e green. 6. iniziative e opportunità per promuovere ecosistemi di innovazione glocali negli ultimi anni, la promozione di ecosistemi di innovazione è emersa come priorità strategica per numerosi paesi europei, in risposta alle sfide legate alla transizione digitale, alla sostenibilità e alla competitività globale. tali ecosistemi si configurano come sistemi complessi in cui interagiscono attori pubblici e privati (tra cui imprese innovative, università, centri di ricerca, enti pubblici territoriali, fondi di investimento e organizzazioni intermediarie) accomunati dall’obiettivo di generare, trasferire e valorizzare conoscenza in chiave imprenditoriale. all’interno di questo quadro, in italia, si è assistito a una crescente diffusione di iniziative nazionali e transnazionali volte a favorire la connessione tra nodi locali e reti europee, contribuendo alla strutturazione di infrastrutture abilitanti per l’innovazione13. parallelamente all’evoluzione normativa, hanno preso forma iniziative multi-livello orientate alla costruzione di reti di collaborazione tra territori, imprese e centri di ricerca, sia a livello nazionale (con il pnrr e gli ecosistemi dell’innovazione) sia a livello europeo (con horizon europe, eic accelerator, digital europe)14. in questo scenario, gli attori intermedi quali associazioni di categoria, consorzi, hub tecnologici e reti di rappresentanza, svolgono un ruolo decisivo nel mettere in relazione politiche, attori locali e opportunità sovranazionali15. un caso emblematico in tal senso è rappresentato da innovup, soggetto collettivo che opera da interfaccia tra ecosistemi regionali e reti europee dell’innovazione. pur non essendo un’agenzia pubblica né un ente di programmazione, innovup si configura come un attore con funzione di policy broker, capace di aggregare informazioni, istanze e risorse provenienti da diversi livelli istituzionali e imprenditoriali. tra il 2022 e il 2024, innovup ha attivato una serie di azioni di advocacy e di connessione internazionale, partecipando a piattaforme come european startup nations alliance (esna), allied for startups, european startup network,iasp, ebn, eban ed eurocrowd16 (figure 7 e 8). 12 fonte: https://europeanstartupnetwork.eu/members/. 13 fonte: https://ec.europa.eu/info/funding-tenders/opportunities/docs/2021-2027/horizon/wp-call/2021-2022/wp-10european-innovation-ecosystems_horizon-2021-2022_en.pdf. 14 fonte: https://innovup.net/. 15 fonte: https://innovup.net/wp-content/uploads/2024/10/mappatura-piani-regionali-df.pdf. 16 fonte: https://innovup.net/wp-content/uploads/2024/10/mappatura-piani-regionali-df.pdf. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/12056 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license this article is not subject to double-blind peer review and is part of the practitioners perspective section for 2025. 14 figura 7: panoramica degli eventi e networking di innovup fonte: https://innovup.net/. figura 8: panoramica degli eventi e networking di innovup https://innovup.net/ european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/12056 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license this article is not subject to double-blind peer review and is part of the practitioners perspective section for 2025. 15 fonte: https://innovup.net/. tali attività vanno lette come strumenti di costruzione di capitali relazionali e istituzionali, fondamentali per sostenere gli attori locali nei processi di internazionalizzazione e nella partecipazione a programmi europei (riferimento figura 9). in particolare, le iniziative di innovup mirano a creare ponti tra startup italiane e policy europee, facilitando l’accesso a bandi, acceleratori, investitori internazionali e piattaforme di conoscenza17. in questa direzione, l’associazione ha anche promosso manifesti programmatici (3), open letters (6) position paper (10) volti a orientare le politiche pubbliche verso una maggiore attenzione alla dimensione scaleup, alla mobilitazione di capitale privato e all’integrazione tra innovazione e transizione verde e digitale. figura 9: roadmap attività europee innovup 2024 fonte: https://innovup.net/. un altro aspetto centrale riguarda la promozione di infrastrutture relazionali e territoriali per l’innovazione, attraverso il supporto a ecosistemi locali e alla creazione di reti tra abilitatori (incubatori, acceleratori, competence center). l’azione di attori come innovup, in sinergia con fondi come cdp venture capital, mira a superare la frammentazione che caratterizza il tessuto innovativo italiano, favorendo la contaminazione tra filiere produttive tradizionali e nuove traiettorie tecnologiche18. in questo quadro, la connessione con programmi transnazionali diventa cruciale per valorizzare le specificità locali in un'ottica glocale (globale + locale). l’esperienza italiana mostra come le opportunità offerte da strumenti europei (horizon europe, eic, startup europe) possano essere effettivamente colte solo 17 fonte: https://innovup.net/innovup-dieci-mosse-per-rendere-litalia-una-startup-nation/. 18 fonte: https://www.cdpventurecapital.it/resources/cms/documents/cdp_vc_bilancio_2023.pdf. https://innovup.net/ https://innovup.net/ european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/12056 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license this article is not subject to double-blind peer review and is part of the practitioners perspective section for 2025. 16 attraverso la presenza di strutture intermedie capaci di tradurre le policy in pratiche, facilitando l’accesso, la connessione e la capitalizzazione delle risorse disponibili sempre più su una logica di integrazione multilivello, tra attori pubblici, privati e associativi. in questo scenario, il ruolo degli attori di rete innovup appare centrale non solo per rappresentare l’ecosistema, ma per abilitare concretamente le sue traiettorie di sviluppo in una dimensione transnazionale. 7. conclusioni la conclusione di questa ampia disamina sul mondo delle startup italiane, tra evoluzione normativa, contesto europeo e dinamiche ecosistemiche, consente di restituire un quadro articolato ma coerente sullo stato dell'innovazione imprenditoriale nel paese. in primo luogo, appare evidente come la costruzione di un ecosistema favorevole alla nascita e alla crescita delle startup abbia rappresentato una risposta politica e legislativa a un ritardo sistemico dell’italia nel supportare l’imprenditorialità innovativa. l’introduzione dello startup act nel 2012 ha segnato un passaggio chiave nel riconoscimento formale di una nuova tipologia di impresa, la startup innovativa, definita sulla base di precisi requisiti anagrafici, economici, tecnologici e organizzativi. questo impianto normativo ha avuto il merito di strutturare un primo insieme di misure di sostegno integrate, come l’esonero da oneri fiscali e camerali, l’accesso semplificato al fondo di garanzia, incentivi per investitori in equity, nonché meccanismi di remunerazione flessibile del lavoro tramite stock option. tuttavia, l’esperienza maturata nel decennio successivo ha mostrato i limiti di un impianto normativo centrato soprattutto sulla fase di avvio, trascurando le esigenze di accompagnamento nella fase di crescita delle imprese. il cosiddetto "scaleup gap" è infatti emerso come uno degli ostacoli principali allo sviluppo dell’innovazione in italia: molte startup, pur superando le fasi iniziali, non riescono a trasformarsi in imprese mature competitive a livello internazionale, spesso a causa di barriere legate alla scarsità di capitali, all’accesso limitato ai mercati esteri e alla frammentazione del sistema di supporto. in questo scenario si inserisce lo scaleup act del 2024, concepito per rispondere alle criticità emerse e completare il percorso avviato con lo startup act. le misure introdotte con questo nuovo quadro normativo puntano ad ampliare le agevolazioni fiscali, rafforzare il ruolo degli incubatori certificati, sostenere le imprese deep-tech e green, semplificare i processi di internazionalizzazione e attrarre capitale umano e finanziario, anche estero. a differenza del precedente impianto, il focus non è più solo sull’avvio dell’attività, ma sul consolidamento e l’espansione, con strumenti mirati a sostenere la transizione da startup a scaleup. parallelamente, i dati quantitativi aggiornati al 2024 testimoniano una fase di consolidamento dell’ecosistema italiano: a fronte di una lieve flessione numerica delle startup (-6,1%), si osserva un incremento del valore medio della produzione (+5,6%), a conferma di una crescente solidità e maturità del tessuto imprenditoriale innovativo. particolarmente rilevante è l’aumento delle startup con valore della produzione superiore al milione di euro, che testimonia una maggiore capacità di generare impatto economico e occupazionale. permangono tuttavia elementi di criticità strutturale, tra cui la persistente distanza rispetto ai benchmark europei, evidenziata dal basso numero di scaleup e di imprese unicorno, e da una minore diffusione di strumenti di finanziamento evoluti come il venture capital. in questo contesto, si conferma la centralità di attori intermedi come innovup, capaci di svolgere una funzione di mediazione tra istanze territoriali, policy nazionali e programmi europei. la loro attività di advocacy, networking e accompagnamento ai european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/12056 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license this article is not subject to double-blind peer review and is part of the practitioners perspective section for 2025. 17 bandi europei è risultata decisiva per migliorare l’accesso delle imprese italiane alle opportunità internazionali e per sostenere la costruzione di ecosistemi locali di innovazione. la direzione auspicabile, anche in linea con le indicazioni della commissione europea, è quella di una governance multilivello dell’innovazione, capace di connettere politiche pubbliche, capitale privato, università e centri di ricerca, in un’ottica sistemica. i modelli più avanzati di sviluppo imprenditoriale non si limitano infatti alla sola offerta di incentivi, ma puntano alla costruzione di ambienti abilitanti, in cui l’interazione tra attori, la circolazione della conoscenza e la contaminazione tra settori costituiscono i veri driver della competitività. in conclusione, l’italia si trova oggi in una fase di transizione matura, in cui le sfide dell’innovazione richiedono una capacità di visione integrata, una governance più coesa e strumenti flessibili ma strutturati. lo scaleup act rappresenta un passo in avanti in questa direzione, ma la sua efficacia dipenderà dalla capacità del sistema-paese di attuarlo in modo sinergico, superando le frammentazioni e promuovendo una cultura dell’innovazione realmente diffusa. in tal senso, il futuro delle startup italiane dipenderà dalla capacità collettiva di tradurre il potenziale in performance, e di valorizzare l’innovazione non solo come eccezione, ma come parte integrante del modello di sviluppo nazionale. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/12056 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license this article is not subject to double-blind peer review and is part of the practitioners perspective section for 2025. 18 bibliografia e sitografia blank, s., blank, s. g., & dorf, b. (2012). the startup owner’s manual: the step-by-step guide for building a great company. k&s ranch. camera dei deputati. (2024). memoria pubblica – ideges. https://documenti.camera.it/leg19/documentiacquisiti/com10/audizioni/leg19.com10.audizioni.memo ria.pubblico.ideges.47445.11-10-2024-15-04-50.962.pdf. cdp venture capital. (2023). bilancio 2023. https://www.cdpventurecapital.it/resources/cms/documents/cdp_vc_bilancio_2023.pdf. commissione europea. (2022). le strategie di innovazione delle startup innovative: un’indagine ad hoc. european innovation ecosystems – horizon work programme 2021-2022. https://ec.europa.eu/info/funding-tenders/opportunities/docs/2021-2027/horizon/wp-call/20212022/wp-10-european-innovation-ecosystems_horizon-2021-2022_en.pdf. carnazza, p. (2017). le strategie di innovazione delle startup innovative: un’indagine ad hoc. quaderni di ricerca sull’artigianato, (2). https://doi.org/10.12830/87483 engage. (2025). aziende unicorno: il fenomeno delle startup da un miliardo di dollari. https://engage.it/brand-e-aziende/aziende-unicorno-il-fenomeno-delle-startup-da-un-miliardo-didollari.aspx#:~:text=nel%202013%20aileen%20lee%2c%20fondatrice,miliardo%20di%20doll ari%20o%20pi%c3%b9. directorate-general for research and innovation (european commission), hollanders, h., es-sadki, n., & khalilova, a. (2022). european innovation scoreboard 2022. publications office of the european union. https://data.europa.eu/doi/10.2777/309907 innovup (2024). homepage. https://innovup.net/. innovup. (2024). dieci mosse per rendere l’italia una startup nation. https://innovup.net/innovup-diecimosse-per-rendere-litalia-una-startup-nation/. istituto della enciclopedia italiana treccani, “definizione di start up” https://www.treccani.it/enciclopedia/startup_(dizionario-di-economia-e-finanza)/. ministero delle imprese e del made in italy. (2012). art. 25 del d.l. 179/2012. https://www.mimit.gov.it/images/stories/art25-dl179-2012.pdf. ministero delle imprese e del made in italy. (2020). policy per le startup innovative – aggiornamento 2020. https://www.mimit.gov.it/images/stories/documenti/policy-startup-agg20.pdf. ministero delle imprese e del made in italy. (2024). relazione annuale 2024. https://www.mimit.gov.it/images/stories/documenti/relazione_annuale_2024-finale.pdf. ministero delle imprese e del made in italy. (2019). slide policy startup innovative (07/2019). https://www.mimit.gov.it/images/stories/documenti/slide%20policy%20startup%20innovative% 2007_2019.pdf. frasson, l. (2025). le startup innovative: il rispetto del requisito di innovazione e di alto valore tecnologico. https://thesis.unipd.it/handle/20.500.12608/48276 european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/11502 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 1 corporate social responsibilities washing in the textile industry: a review of causes, consequences, and remedy. md. nahid-ull-islam1* 1 department of apparel engineering, bangladesh university of textiles, tejgaon, dhaka-1208, bangladesh nahidhridoy42@gmail.com *contact author orcid https://orcid.org/0009-0005-5464-2492 received: 03/01/2025 accepted for publication: 10/03/2025 published: 15/04/2025 abstract the textile industry is facing a growing issue of corporate social responsibilities washing or csrwashing, which are misleading social claims made by companies to appeal to customers' social consciousness. this review examines the causes and consequences of this practice, focusing on the holistic impact on consumers, corporations, stakeholders, and society. the analysis used various sources, including review papers, case studies, book chapters, and websites, to identify relevant publications. the study explores the concept of csr-washing in fast fashion and its impact on society. to combat this issue, it suggests promoting transparency, accountability, and independent certification in the textile industry. the lack of research on this practice in the industry makes it difficult to understand its effects. the study emphasises the need for optimal measures to control this practice, aiming to create a sustainable and responsible fashion sector. keywords: csr-washing, ethical, transparency, fast fashion, sustainability. mailto:nahidhridoy42@gmail.com https://orcid.org/0009-0005-5464-2492 european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/11502 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 2 1. introduction the term sustainability was first coined by a german forester in the 18th century, but it became popular with the birth of the contemporary environment movement in the late 1960s and 1970s (wiersum, 1995). sustainability refers to the optimal utilisation rate of non-renewable resources without risking the ability of future generations to fulfil their needs (hotelling, 1931; kuhlman & farrington, 2010). the demand in the industrial sectors to safeguard the environment and practice social responsibility has intensified due to the policies and strategies created in the previous decade to promote sustainable development (joung et al., 2013). in order to effectively meet sustainability standards, it is crucial to evaluate the sustainability performance of the industrial sectors (bi, 2011). as consumers' growing awareness of such devastating impacts, the textile industry has shifted its focus on sustainability more in recent years. among the three pillars, social sustainability is an ideal state of well-being that might be expected to occur when social, economic, and environmental interactions foster intergenerational equality and longitudinal equilibrium (grum & kobal grum, 2020). it is how businesses identify and manage their impacts on people, both positive and negative. businesses need to have good relationships and engagement with their stakeholders, such as employees, workers in the supply chain, customers, and local communities. businesses need to proactively manage their social impacts because they can significantly impact their ability to operate. for example, if a business does not treat its employees fairly or respect human rights, it may lose its social license, which is the public's trust and acceptance. social sustainability is also important for business growth. businesses that are socially responsible are more likely to attract and retain customers and business partners. they are also more likely to be innovative and productive (runhaar & lafferty, 2009). social sustainability is a broad concept that encompasses many different aspects of society, including social value, liability, well-being, group improvement, social capital, social support, human rights, work rights, place-making, social obligation, social equity, social skills, group diversity, and human adjustment. it is about meeting the needs of the present without compromising the ability of future generations to meet their own needs. it is based on the understanding that social, economic, and environmental issues are interconnected. social obligation is a related concept that focuses on the specific issues that businesses and governments are responsible for addressing to achieve social sustainability. these issues include asset utilisation, pollution, consumer well-being, human rights, health and safety, product fairness, and quality. social obligation is a conscious effort to maintain and improve human well-being and prosperity while being environmentally responsible (grace annapoorani, 2017). in recent years, public concern towards the protection of social well-being has grown, which has been recognised by the pioneer brands of textile industry and focused on sustainable approaches and transparency to social issues, resulting in a noticeable growth in the ethical fashion market (eurobarometer, 2017; younus et al., 2024). as the textile industry is required to adopt sustainable practices, corporate social responsibilities (csr) initiatives aim to address the textile industry's sophisticated social challenges, ensuring an ethical outcome. csr provides a common ground and principles for several sustainability frameworks, such as the global reporting initiative (gri), sustainable development goals (sdg), and iso 26000, which are generally practised in the textile industry. brandsfrom textile industry is seizing the marketing opportunity by using the consumers' sentiment on social distress by claiming their products are socially sustainable without implementing csr initiatives for sustainable frameworks (beyer & arnold, 2021; easterling et al., 1996; schmidt & donsbach, 2012; european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/11502 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 3 wonneberger & matthes, 2016). this often leads to brands exploiting exaggerated, fabricated, and illusive claims of social well-being of products in order to improve brand value (berliner & prakash, 2015; kangun et al., 1991; matthes & wonneberger, 2014). these actions are considered csr-washing, which dilutes sustainability's true meaning and uses it as a marketable catchphrase, has not only affected consumer behaviour but also penetrated the textile sector (apaolaza et al., 2023; testa et al., 2021). this distortion has exacerbated the problems already present in the ecological footprint of the fashion and textile industry by contributing to the compounding problems of overproduction and overconsumption. unintentionally, this creates a confusing environment where deceptive marketing tactics cast a shadow on genuine sustainability (badhwar et al., 2024). although the phenomenon of misleading consumers about a company's ethical practice by misrepresenting csr initiatives has been discussed in several studies, there is a research gap on its holistic impact on the textile industry alongside its challenge to distinguish because of a lack of agreed-upon nomenclature and hazy limits. some writers, for instance, employ different terms, including "corporate hypocrisy" or "bluewashing," which encompasses not just greenwashing and bluewashing but also pinkwashing (referring to breast cancer awareness) (lubitow & davis, 2011; pope & wæraas, 2016; wagner et al., 2009). to distinguish the issue from environmental issues, other scholars favour the term "socialwashing" (rizzi et al., 2020). furthermore, a number of researchers view bluewashing as a component of the broader phrase "greenwashing" rather than as a distinct tactic (seele & gatti, 2017). the objective of this review is to comprehend theoretical concepts of csr-washing in the context of the textile sector by addressing research stages, conducting a systematic review of the literature, and identifying relevant papers. to fulfil the review objective, the following research stages were addressed: a) identify the prevalence of research regarding csr-washing or relevant terms as part of the study. b) evaluate common keywords in reviewing the literature. c) conduct a content analysis of the literature to analyse the practice of csr-washing in the textile industry and its types, causes, and consequences. d) propose possible solutions to mitigate csr-washing. this study examines how theory fits with real-world actions in the textile sector, taking into account shifting laws. this review expands on existing studies and literature on csr-washing in the textile sector, providing a more subtle perspective on current difficulties and remedies. 2. research methodology 2.1 identify research this study used a process to conduct a systematic review of the literature and identify relevant papers by gathering the context of the literature (gall, gall, & borg, 2003). this method is effective in identifying trends, gaining knowledge and developing a review process (köksal et al., 2017; seuring & gold, 2012). to narrow down the sample and confirm the relevance of selected articles, both abstract reviewing and full-body reviewing were involved. at first, abstracts of peer-reviewed articles were reviewed to identify their relevance to csr-washing. then, full body content was reviewed to identify its relevance to the textile industry. 2.2 common keywords and methodology used the research used a search approach to minimise the number of relevant publications. resources used for searches include web of science, google scholar, and scopus. the keywords used to search the relevant european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/11502 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 4 publications were "greenwashing", "bluewashing", "csr", "textile", and "fast fashion". the study analyses articles, including review papers, case studies, book chapters, and websites, on csr-washing, their relationship to fast fashion, and sustainability in the textile sector. 2.3 content analysis of literature sample as part of the research process, a content analysis of the selected articles was conducted to provide an overview of the main topics covered by the literature samples. the analysis of literature samples showed the practice of misleading claims of environmental and social sustainability, which includes csr-washing (table 1). authors key findings apaolaza et al. (2023) greenwashing is an obstacle to purchase of sustainable clothing. badhwar et al. (2024) transparency and honesty are needed in the fashion industry's green marketing strategies. consumer education is also important to prevent misinterpretation of green-related terms and to promote sustainable consumption practices. berliner & prakash (2015) ungc members fare worse than non-members on costly and fundamental performance dimensions, while showing improvements only in more superficial dimensions. macellari et al. (2021) more than 80% of the significant negative events related to companies from ungc lead program were not reported or were only partially reported in their sustainability reports. pope & wæraas (2016) the rarity of csr-washing is based on perspective rather than that of fact rizzi et al. (2020) awareness campaigns and third-party verifiable standards and certifications should be considered to mitigate risks regarding "social washing". sailer et al. (2022) sustainable black friday campaigns may attract economically and socially concerned customers while practising greenwashing and bluewashing seeli & gatti (2017) speculatively greenwashing is constituted in the eye of the beholder, depending on an external accusation. table 1. key findings summary of literature sample. based on the key findings it was observed that though corporate social responsibilities was a major factor in both greenwashing and bluewashing, csr-washing itself was not addressed as an individual challenge. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/11502 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 5 to address csr-washing in the textile industry, a conceptual framework was constructed to analyse csrwashing in the textile industry, the drivers of practising csr-washing, its consequences, and possible remedies to mitigate csr-washing in global and domestic textile industries. 3. historical background any deceptive claims on the social initiatives or effects of a company, good, or procedure are referred to as "bluewashing" (sailers et al., 2022). the problem of bluewashing was first brought up by critics with respect to the united nations global compact (ungc) at the 2002 world summit on sustainable development. they accused corporations of leveraging their un collaboration to hide their lax enforcement of labour and human rights norms (sailer et al., 2022). the assertions of ungc members avoiding their social obligations are supported by related research. it was found that while members only make low-cost attempts to improve in relatively superficial aspects, they do worse than non-members in critical and expensive aspects (berliner & prakash, 2015). corporate social responsibility (csr) programs and environmental, social, and governance (esg) criteria have emerged in response to increased transparency and accountability demands (bromley & powell, 2012). csr programs typically express a company's commitment to addressing environmental and social challenges (macellari et al., 2021). csr programs prioritise legitimacy over economic gains (schaltegger & hörisch, 2017). a study found that simply demonstrating commitment increases company legitimacy (bansal & clelland, 2004). csr claims are often overstated, selective, or unrealistic (pope & wæraas, 2016). esg policies, like csr, address a company's environmental effects and social responsibility activities while also considering corporate governance (bassen & kovács, 2020). "csrwashing" is the practice of businesses "paying lip service" to their csr goals instead of implementing meaningful changes to enhance their csr performance (berliner & prakash, 2015). a corporation that has been csr-washed appears more socially conscious than it actually is. csr-washers do the bare minimum to appease detractors, advocacy organisations, and social media platforms because they believe that corporate social responsibility is the domain of the public relations division (de faro adamson & andrew, 2008). cause-related marketing (crm) is a common way that social appeals are used in advertising. crm is the practice of allocating a portion of product sales revenue to charity organisations (christofi et al., 2020; robinson et al., 2012). the best outcomes from this approach are obtained when companies exhibit sustained dedication to nonprofits. furthermore, brands run the danger of losing credibility if the donated amount is out of proportion to the purchase price (sailer et al., 2022). however, although important aspects like labour and human rights are usually overlooked, crm is commonly utilised to improve business social images. crm is then utilised to aim at csr-washing. the social life cycle assessment (s-lca) is an important tool for evaluating and improving a company's social and environmental effects, but it may also be used to encourage csr-washing (herrera almanza & corona, 2020). companies may selectively disclose only the positive social impacts discovered by slca, while ignoring negative results. this presents an inaccurate image of their total social performance. companies may overestimate the significance of tiny social benefits found by s-lca and use them to make unsupported claims about their social responsibility. companies may also undertake s-lcas without disclosing the complete methodology, data, and outcomes to the public. this lack of transparency makes it impossible to determine the authenticity and trustworthiness of their statements. finally, european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/11502 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 6 companies may prioritise small social issues highlighted by s-lca while ignoring more major social and environmental implications across their value chain. 4. conceptual framework to identify csr-washing a framework can be constructed based on the key elements of csr-washing, including corporate actions, communication and marketing, and stakeholder perception, to identify csr-washing. corporate actions encompass analysing a company's true environmental and societal impact, such as its carbon footprint, waste management, labour practices, and community involvement. also, examine specific csr initiatives. communication and marketing include analysing the company's communication strategies to comprehend how it presents its csr activities to the public, as well as scrutinising the specific strategy to promote csr initiatives for potential exaggerations, misleading statements, or selective information presentation. stakeholder perception examines a company's interactions with multiple stakeholders, such as employees, customers, investors, and non-governmental organisations (ngos), to better understand their perspectives on the company's corporate social responsibility performance. there are numerous techniques available for analysing csr-washing within this framework. assessing the company's csr activities against independent third-party audits and certifications to determine the legitimacy of its claims. comparing the company's csr performance and communication to industry standards and established standards to discover areas for development and the possibility of csr-washing. tracking social media interactions and online reviews to gain insight into the general consensus of the company's csr programs and detect any issues or critiques. interviews with important stakeholders, such as employees, customers, investors, and ngos, are conducted to get feedback on the company's csr activity and identify any issues or critiques (figure 1). figure 1. conceptual framework to identify csr-washing european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/11502 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 7 source: author's elaboration 4.1 common methods of csr-washing many fashion brands exercise some common csr-washing methods. selective reporting leads textile industries to produce portrayals that may include a few positives that they intend to highlight while concealing bigger unethical actions. for example, they may claim to be donating a few pennies to charity while continuing to violate labour laws. a misleading collaboration with renowned social organisations can provide the impression that the company is ethical. many firms use these organisations for public relations, although they do not always adhere to their criteria. it was stated that by affiliating with organisations such as the un global compact (ungc), many brands have attempted to create an ethical veneer while making no meaningful improvements to its negative effect. vague claims lead to broad and ungenerous assertions regarding social responsibility, such as saying that the corporation is concerned about 'just treatment of workers' but fails to submit evidence of their social compliance criteria ("what is bluewashing? (2024)," 2024). 5. causes of csr-washing 5.1 government rules & regulations in many countries, there are weak regulations and enforcement mechanisms to hold companies accountable for their sustainability claims. this allows companies to get away with misleading marketing practices (mishra, 2023). 5.2 consumer demand consumers are increasingly aware of environmental and social issues, leading to a growing demand for sustainable fashion. however, many consumers lack the knowledge and tools to critically evaluate sustainability claims and identify csr-washing. this makes it easier for companies to deceive consumers and exploit it as an opportunity for csr washing (hartmann, 2018; newman & bartels, 2011). 5.3 lack of transparency the textile industry is notoriously opaque, with complex supply chains that make it difficult to track the origin of materials and the working conditions of labourers, suffering from low salaries, involuntary overtime, inconsistent hours, and poor safety conditions (alamgir & banerjee, 2019; wills & hale, 2005). this lack of transparency allows companies to make misleading claims about their sustainability practices. brands often use vague and misleading marketing claims to promote their products as sustainable without providing concrete evidence to support their claims. this can include using terms like "eco-friendly", "sustainable" or "ethical" without specific definitions or certifications. 5.4 focusing on a single pillar of sustainability some companies may focus on one aspect of sustainability, such as using recycled materials or environmental impact, while neglecting other important factors like fair labour practices (morelli, 2011). implementing truly sustainable practices can be costly and complex, especially for smaller companies. this can create a barrier for some companies to adopt sustainable practices, leading them to resort to csrwashing instead. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/11502 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 8 6. consequence of csr-washing in the textile industry csr-washing businesses trick consumers who desire to make an ethical choice by purchasing sustainable products that are not. this manipulation of consumers' goodwill is not only dishonest to customers, but it is also harmful to societal progress toward a better future. many fast-fashion manufacturers promote the utilisation of 'sustainable' fabrics and production practices, but they continue to use processes that are harmful to the environment and workers. as a result, csr-washing undermines the credibility of companies and brands. when consumers discover that a company is engaging in mere hype or outright lying about its sustainability, they lose faith in even genuine environmentally friendly businesses ("what is bluewashing? (2024)," 2024). csr-washing has led the textile sector to invest in items that violated alleged public pledges to human rights. csr-washing also involves intentional or irresponsible misrepresentation, illegal business activities, and deceptive advertising regarding working conditions in various pioneer textile industries where it is claimed that child labour is exploited (vladeck, 2003). auchan, a french retail corporation, engaged in misleading marketing methods despite publicly stating that it respects workers' rights, but a clothing label marketed by the company was discovered in the ruins of the rana plaza building collapse, which killed over 1,100 textile workers (turnbull et al., 2023). overall, falsely claiming a product or process in the textile sector socially conscious or socially sustainable results in hindrances in achieving sustainability and disrupting the social pillar of sustainability, which disrupts the other pillars of sustainability as well. eventually, csr-washing can undermine the efforts of companies that are genuinely committed to sustainability, as it can create confusion and scepticism among consumers ("what is bluewashing? (2024)," 2024). 6.1 practice of csr-washing by fashion giants in 2021knowthechain benchmark evaluated the efforts of the 37 largest global apparel and footwear companies and discovered that luxury brands such as kering and lvmh, as well as budget retailers amazon and walmart, are among the worst performers when it comes to addressing human rights exploitation in supply chains—clearly, a higher price tag does not guarantee better transparency and respect for workers' rights. almost all companies (97%) declare a supplier code of conduct that forbids forced labour and a supplier monitoring system. however, they are ineffective in combating forced labour or providing worker remedies (2021 knowthechain apparel & footwear benchmark, 2021). h&m, calvin klein, gap, nike, adidas, shien, and tommy hilfiger have all been accused of links to uighur slave labour, either at the source or in factories. china is the world's greatest cotton grower, with about 84% of its cotton coming from the xinjiang area, home to the uighur people. xinjiang is a major supplier of cotton for global fashion firms. according to a consortium of over 180 human rights organisations, one in every five cotton products sold around the world contains charges of forced labour (mishra, 2023). 7. how to tackle csr-washing 7.1 regulatory frameworks and standards the fast fashion industry requires stronger rules and enforcement measures in the fast fashion business to address csr-washing. in fact, governments and authorities in many countries are beginning to make a greater impact by enacting laws to improve the transparency of corporate social responsibility claims. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/11502 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 9 7.2 third-party verification to combat csr-washing in the fast fashion business, it's crucial to develop independent certification methods tailored to the sector. certification systems must meet rigorous standards and be endorsed by reputable third-party organisations with experience in sustainability and ethical practices. certification programs in the fast fashion sector help prevent csr-washing by requiring companies to achieve sustainability requirements and prove their impact. independent credentials help customers make educated decisions and support businesses committed to openness and ethics. they urge fashion firms to improve sustainability and lessen their environmental impact. certifications encourage responsible behaviour and promote positive change in the sector. implementing extensive certification schemes builds trust and encourages customers to support brands that correspond with their beliefs. 7.3 transparent supply chain transparency in the supply chain refers to disclosing and making visible the entire manufacturing process, from raw material sourcing to distribution and retail. this transparency enables customers and stakeholders to gain a comprehensive understanding of the environmental and social implications of each stage in the supply chain. brands should prioritise revealing supply chain information, such as factory locations, labour standards, and environmental practices. implementing independent audits and certifications, such as those offered by the fair wear foundation or the sustainable apparel coalition, can improve openness and accountability to mitigate csr-washing. 7.4 consumer empowering from the customer's perspective, prevention should begin with an understanding of what it is. empowering consumers with knowledge enables them to make informed judgments and evaluate the larger ramifications of their fashion choices (cheeseman, 2016). furthermore, educating consumers about the environmental and social consequences of their shopping habits allows them to recognise and csrwashing, and promote truly sustainable firms. this may cause a shift in consumer behaviour, with a growing desire for ecological and ethical fashion. as demand grows, brands are driven to modify their operations and provide more sustainable solutions, resulting in positive industry transformation (cheeseman, 2016). governments, non-governmental organisations (ngos), and industry groups can conduct public awareness campaigns to educate consumers about csr-washing techniques and provide guidance on how to recognise and avoid them. these campaigns can use a variety of platforms, including social media, commercials, and events, to reach a diverse audience and promote sustainable consumption. brands should take proactive steps to increase transparency and educate customers about their sustainable initiatives. this may involve disclosing thorough information about their supplier chain, sourcing procedures, environmental certifications, and social responsibility activities. furthermore, organising events, workshops, and seminars about sustainable fashion can assist increase consumer awareness. these events may include conversations about the environmental impact of rapid fashion, ethical production methods, and sustainable alternatives to identify and csr-washing. online platforms can provide real-time information on a product's sustainability credentials, allowing shoppers to make more educated purchasing decisions. furthermore, social media and online forums can encourage information exchange and awareness campaigns, allowing consumers to participate in debates and advocate for sustainable practices. social media serves as the major medium for obtaining information and provides a great potential for companies and individuals to harness their influence in creating european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/11502 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 10 awareness and achieving recognition of csr-washing practices, especially given the significant flood of internet users (bennetta & oeppen hill, 2022). 8. challenges in addressing csr-washing one major obstacle in conducting this study was the lack of research regarding practice of csr-washing in the textile industry as many scholars considered csr-washing as a form of greenwashing or bluewashing rather than addressing it as an individual issue. the study individualised csr-washing as an act of lip servicing rather than taking initiatives to enhance company's csr performance. while greenwashing indicates the practice of misleading claims of environmental sustainability, this practice may not include csr despite the interconnectivity of environmental and social sustainability. similarly, the practice of bluewashing accounts for the misrepresentation of social sustainability claims which is a broader category than csr. as there are several social sustainability framework practices besides corporate social responsibilities. hence, the practice of csr-washing also indicates bluewashing, but the practice of bluewashing may not always indicate csr-washing. so it is important to warrant csrwashing in a distinct category of analysis. 9. conclusion the study addresses csr-washing in the textile industry as a distinct practice by disclosing the gaps in literature reviews, as csr-washing is often shadowed by practices like greenwashing and bluewashing. it demonstrates how csr-washing is a deceptive strategy that obstructs achieving sustainability and can have serious effects on organisations, consumers, and society. the study concludes that increasing consumer demands, immature legislative frameworks such as reluctance to implement labour laws and environmental regulation, lack of transparency and accountability, regulatory gaps in host nations, and ignoring the holistic concept of sustainability can lead to the practice of csr-washing in the textile industry. it involves corporations claiming to respect fair labour rules while exploiting workers through low wages, long hours, and hazardous working conditions. the textile industries may focus on environmental sustainability while ignoring labour rights violations, exaggerating performance, engaging in harmful activities, and employing deceptive marketing strategies. the study proposes that consumers may boycott fashion brands that practice csr-washing, resulting in financial losses and brand damage. it also suggests developing a regulatory framework to identify csr-washing and implement transparency in their policies. while purposeful csr-washing may damage the social pillars of sustainability, it can also raise consumer awareness and lead to more sustainable fashion solutions. this study did not provide a further comprehensive analysis of other types of social washing and recommended policies for governments or the textile industry organisations to take actions against the practice of csr-washing. further research is required on the mentioned fields. 10. reference 2021 knowthechain apparel & footwear benchmark. (2021). retrieved from https://www.businesshumanrights.org/en/from-us/briefings/2021-knowthechain-apparel-footwear-benchmark/ alamgir, f., & banerjee, s. b. (2019). contested compliance regimes in global production networks: insights from the bangladesh garment industry. human relations, 72(2), 272-297. https://www.business-humanrights.org/en/from-us/briefings/2021-knowthechain-apparel-footwear-benchmark/ https://www.business-humanrights.org/en/from-us/briefings/2021-knowthechain-apparel-footwear-benchmark/ european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/11502 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 11 apaolaza, v., policarpo, m. c., hartmann, p., paredes, m. r., & d'souza, c. (2023). sustainable clothing: why conspicuous consumption and greenwashing matter. business strategy and the environment, 32(6), 3766-3782. badhwar, a., islam, s., tan, c. s. l., panwar, t., wigley, s., & nayak, r. (2024). unraveling green marketing and greenwashing: a systematic review in the context of the fashion and textiles industry. sustainability, 16(7), 2738. bansal, p., & clelland, i. (2004). talking trash: legitimacy, impression management, and unsystematic risk in the context of the natural environment. academy of management journal, 47(1), 93-103. bassen, a., & kovács, a. m. (2020). environmental, social and governance key performance indicators from a capital market perspective: springer. bennetta, k., & oeppen hill, j. (2022). educating for change?: an investigation into consumers' perception of sustainability and the educational drivers needed to support sustainable consumption. international journal of fashion design, technology and education, 15(3), 418-429. berliner, d., & prakash, a. (2015). "bluewashing" the firm? voluntary regulations, program design, and member compliance with the u nited n ations g lobal c ompact. policy studies journal, 43(1), 115-138. beyer, k., & arnold, m. g. (2021). circular approaches and business model innovations for social sustainability in the textile industry. in a. matthes, k. beyer, h. cebulla, m. g. arnold, & a. schumann (eds.), sustainable textile and fashion value chains: drivers, concepts, theories and solutions (pp. 341-373). cham: springer international publishing. bi, z. (2011). revisiting system paradigms from the viewpoint of manufacturing sustainability. sustainability, 3(9), 1323-1340. bromley, p., & powell, w. w. (2012). from smoke and mirrors to walking the talk: decoupling in the contemporary world. academy of management annals, 6(1), 483-530. cheeseman, g.-m. (2016). educating consumers about buying sustainably. retrieved from https://www.triplepundit.com/story/2016/educating-consumers-about-buying-sustainably/57131 christofi, m., vrontis, d., leonidou, e., & thrassou, a. (2020). customer engagement through choice in cause-related marketing: a potential for global competitiveness. international marketing review, 37(4), 621-650. de faro adamson, d., & andrew, j. (2008). the blue way: how to profit by investing in a better world: simon and schuster. easterling, d., kenworthy, a., & nemzoff, r. (1996). the greening of advertising: a twenty-five year look at environmental advertising. journal of marketing theory and practice, 4(1), 20-34. eurobarometer. (2017). attitudes of european citizens towards the environment. retrieved from https://europa.eu/eurobarometer/surveys/detail/2156 gall, m. d., gall, j. p., & borg, w. r. (2003). educational research: an introduction: allyn and bacon. grace annapoorani, s. (2017). social sustainability in textile industry. in s. s. muthu (ed.), sustainability in the textile industry (pp. 57-78). singapore: springer singapore. grum, b., & kobal grum, d. (2020). concepts of social sustainability based on social infrastructure and quality of life. facilities, 38(11/12), 783-800. hartmann, k. (2018). die grüne lüge: weltrettung als profitables geschäftsmodell. germany: karl blessing verlag. https://www.triplepundit.com/story/2016/educating-consumers-about-buying-sustainably/57131 https://europa.eu/eurobarometer/surveys/detail/2156 european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/11502 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 12 herrera almanza, a. m., & corona, b. (2020). using social life cycle assessment to analyze the contribution of products to the sustainable development goals: a case study in the textile sector. the international journal of life cycle assessment, 25(9), 1833-1845. doi:10.1007/s11367-02001789-7 hotelling, h. (1931). the economics of exhaustible resources. journal of political economy, 39(2), 137175. joung, c. b., carrell, j., sarkar, p., & feng, s. c. (2013). categorization of indicators for sustainable manufacturing. ecological indicators, 24, 148-157. kangun, n., carlson, l., & grove, s. j. (1991). environmental advertising claims: a preliminary investigation. journal of public policy & marketing, 10(2), 47-58. köksal, d., strähle, j., müller, m., & freise, m. (2017). social sustainable supply chain management in the textile and apparel industry—a literature review. sustainability, 9(1), 100. kuhlman, t., & farrington, j. (2010). what is sustainability? sustainability, 2(11), 3436-3448. lubitow, a., & davis, m. (2011). pastel injustice: the corporate use of pinkwashing for profit. environmental justice, 4(2), 139-144. lessons from a story untold: nike v. kasky reconsidered, 54 case w. res. l. rev. 1049 (2003). macellari, m., yuriev, a., testa, f., & boiral, o. (2021). exploring bluewashing practices of alleged sustainability leaders through a counter-accounting analysis. environmental impact assessment review, 86, 106489. matthes, j., & wonneberger, a. (2014). the skeptical green consumer revisited: testing the relationship between green consumerism and skepticism toward advertising. journal of advertising, 43(2), 115127. mishra, n. (2023). ethics or charade? the troubling truth of bluewashing. retrieved from https://www.campaignasia.com/article/ethics-or-charade-the-troubling-truth-ofbluewashing/484603 morelli, j. (2011). environmental sustainability: a definition for environmental professionals. journal of environmental sustainability, 1(1), 2. newman, b. j., & bartels, b. l. (2011). politics at the checkout line: explaining political consumerism in the united states. political research quarterly, 64(4), 803-817. pope, s., & wæraas, a. (2016). csr-washing is rare: a conceptual framework, literature review, and critique. journal of business ethics, 137, 173-193. rizzi, f., gusmerotti, n., & frey, m. (2020). how to meet reuse and preparation for reuse targets? shape advertising strategies but be aware of "social washing". waste management, 101, 291-300. robinson, s. r., irmak, c., & jayachandran, s. (2012). choice of cause in cause-related marketing. journal of marketing, 76(4), 126-139. runhaar, h., & lafferty, h. (2009). governing corporate social responsibility: an assessment of the contribution of the un global compact to csr strategies in the telecommunications industry. journal of business ethics, 84, 479-495. sailer, a., wilfing, h., & straus, e. (2022). greenwashing and bluewashing in black friday-related sustainable fashion marketing on instagram. sustainability, 14(3), 1494. schaltegger, s., & hörisch, j. (2017). in search of the dominant rationale in sustainability management: legitimacy-or profit-seeking? journal of business ethics, 145, 259-276. https://www.campaignasia.com/article/ethics-or-charade-the-troubling-truth-of-bluewashing/484603 https://www.campaignasia.com/article/ethics-or-charade-the-troubling-truth-of-bluewashing/484603 european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/11502 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 13 schmidt, a., & donsbach, w. j. p. (2012). „grüne “werbung als instrument für „schwarze “zahlen. publizistik, 1(57), 75-93. seele, p., & gatti, l. (2017). greenwashing revisited: in search of a typology and accusation-based definition incorporating legitimacy strategies. business strategy and the environment, 26(2), 239252. seuring, s., & gold, s. (2012). conducting content-analysis based literature reviews in supply chain management. supply chain management: an international journal, 17(5), 544-555. testa, f., pretner, g., iovino, r., bianchi, g., tessitore, s., & iraldo, f. (2021). drivers to green consumption: a systematic review. environment, development and sustainability, 23, 4826-4880. turnbull, e., banyasz, d., oliver, a., & hade, b. (2023). no longer 'once in a blue moon': bluewashing risks and challenges can't be ignored. retrieved from https://www.allens.com.au/insightsnews/insights/2023/07/bluewashing-risks-and-challenges/#anchor1 wagner, t., lutz, r. j., & weitz, b. a. (2009). corporate hypocrisy: overcoming the threat of inconsistent corporate social responsibility perceptions. journal of marketing, 73(6), 77-91. what is bluewashing? (2024). (2024). retrieved from https://www.shop-withoutplastic.com/blogs/greenwashing/what-is-bluewashing-2024#ruffruff-table-of-contents-item-2 wiersum, k. f. (1995). 200 years of sustainability in forestry: lessons from history. environmental management, 19, 321-329. wills, j., & hale, a. (2005). threads of labour in the global garment industry. in a. hale & j. wills (eds.), threads of labour: garment industry supply chains from the workers' perspective (pp. 1-15): blackwell publishing ltd. wonneberger, a., & matthes, j. (2016). grüne werbung: inhalte und wirkungen ökologischer werbebotschaften. handbuch werbeforschung, 741-760. younus, m., pathan, s. h., amin, m. r., tania, i., & ouboucetta, r. (2024). sustainable fashion analytics: predicting the future of eco-friendly textile. global mainstream journal of business, economics, development & project management, 3(3), 13-26. https://www.allens.com.au/insights-news/insights/2023/07/bluewashing-risks-and-challenges/#anchor1 https://www.allens.com.au/insights-news/insights/2023/07/bluewashing-risks-and-challenges/#anchor1 https://www.shop-without-plastic.com/blogs/greenwashing/what-is-bluewashing-2024#ruffruff-table-of-contents-item-2 https://www.shop-without-plastic.com/blogs/greenwashing/what-is-bluewashing-2024#ruffruff-table-of-contents-item-2 european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/11974 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 39 from divergence to convergence: mapping the hybrid evolution of smart, pop, and dialogic accounting through bibliometric and semantic lenses federico chmet*, alessandra curatolo 2, federica bassano3 1university of turin, department of management, corso unione sovietica, 218 bis, torino, italia federico.chmet@unito.it *contact author orcid 0000-0003-0091-784x 2university of turin, department of management, corso unione sovietica, 218 bis, torino, italia alessandra.curatolo@unito.it orcid 0009-0003-0737-8532 3university of turin, department of management, corso unione sovietica, 218 bis, torino, italia federica.bassano@unito.it orcid 0000-0001-7835-2821 received: 16/05/2025 accepted for publication: 18/08/2025 published: 27/08/2025 abstract this study examines the academic development and interconnections among smart accounting, pop accounting, and dialogic accounting from 2010 to 2025. despite each paradigm embracing digitization, stakeholder engagement, and sustainability from different perspectives, the literature remains fragmented across separate research streams. the paper argues that a systematic, integrated perspective is required to trace conceptual overlaps and identify research gaps among these emerging approaches. to this end, a bibliometric and semantic analysis was conducted on 222 peer-reviewed articles with the support of biblioshiny and leximancer. the articles were selected using a boolean search strategy targeting digital, participatory, and sustainability-oriented accounting models. the analysis centered on publication trends, cocitation networks, keyword co-occurrence, thematic clusters, and semantic trajectories. the results illuminate a growing, yet theoretically and geographically uneven and fragmented, academic debate. smart accounting is driven by technological disruption, particularly through artificial intelligence (ai), blockchain, and cloud computing, which enable real-time automation and transparency. pop accounting advances inclusive governance by integrating financial and esg indicators through stakeholder-centric models. dialogic accounting emphasizes deliberative engagement but faces challenges in practical implementation. although there is increasing conceptual overlap, mainly in applications within the public sector, significant gaps in theoretical convergence and geographic coverage persist, especially in emerging economies. moreover, the decline in citation trends over the period suggests a thematic specialization and decentralization of scholarly attention. ultimately, the research highlights the potential of hybrid accounting systems that integrate digital technologies, stakeholder engagement, and sustainability to support organizations in addressing the challenges of digital and sustainable transitions. keywords: smart accounting; pop accounting; dialogic accounting; digital transformation in accounting; stakeholder engagement; bibliometric analysis. https://orcid.org/0009-0003-0737-8532 https://orcid.org/0000-0001-7835-2821 european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/11974 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 40 1. introduction in recent years, accounting has progressively moved beyond the confines of purely economic calculations to incorporate technological developments, societal expectations, and ethical considerations (bellucci et al., 2019; bessieux-ollier et al., 2023). this shift is particularly evident in the public sector, which has increasingly adopted reporting frameworks aimed at enhancing transparency and stakeholder engagement (fusco & ricci, 2019). within this context, scholarly research has identified three distinct yet interconnected paradigms: smart accounting, pop accounting, and dialogic accounting. each represents a different degree of openness to digital transformation, stakeholder engagement, and sustainability-oriented reporting practices (desplebin et al., 2021; biancone et al., 2024; bellucci et al., 2019). these paradigms respond to converging challenges, including the automation of information processes driven by artificial intelligence (ai), blockchain, and big data, alongside the growing societal demand for transparency, participation, and accountability. despite growing academic interest, research in this area remains largely compartmentalized. most studies focus on individual paradigms without exploring their theoretical and applied interconnections (marrone & hazelton, 2019; bessieux-ollier et al., 2023). this fragmentation is evident in the difficulty of developing accounting tools that support sustainable and circular governance models (aureli, foschi & paletta, 2023), as well as in the limited adoption of authentic dialogic practices across organizational contexts (fusco & ricci, 2019). marrone and hazelton (2019) argue that research on digital technologies in accounting often overlooks governance and accountability issues, while fusco and ricci (2019) highlight the misalignment between participatory goals and the tools used in the public sector. similarly, bellucci et al. (2019) and bessieux-ollier et al. (2023) emphasize the gap between dialogic intentions and their operational implementation. alessi et al. (2024) and abbas and shahid (2024) further underline the lack of standardization in sustainability disclosure, which undermines the comparability and reliability of published information. a systemic and integrated approach is therefore required to examine the conceptual and applied convergences and tensions among these paradigms. this study adopts a bibliometric and semantic lens to map their evolution from 2010 to 2025. it addresses the following research questions: rq1. what is the evolution of the scholarly debate on smart accounting, pop accounting, and dialogic accounting? rq2. what relationships emerge among these paradigms in terms of keywords, thematic co-occurrences, and conceptual trajectories? rq3. what gaps or underrepresented areas can be identified in the current literature, and how can future research be guided? the main objective of this research is to capture and visualize conceptual connections among the three paradigms, applying bibliometric (biblioshiny) and semantic (leximancer) techniques to a sample of 222 peer-reviewed articles. the study offers a threefold contribution. it provides a critical synthesis of existing research, proposes an integrated theoretical framework, and outlines future research directions that combine technological innovation, participatory engagement, and a focus on sustainability. the structure of the paper is as follows: section 2 reviews the literature on the three paradigms; european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/11974 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 41 section 3 details the methodological design; section 4 presents the findings of the bibliometric and semantic analyses; section 5 discusses their implications; section 6 summarizes the contributions; and section 7 offers reflections and recommendations for future research. 2. literature review in the “new normal” era, accounting, traditionally seen as a purely analog discipline, is undergoing a profound transformation. the integration of smart accounting, pop accounting, and dialogic accounting (bellucci et al., 2019; biancone et al., 2024) is redefining the role of financial information in promoting more digital, sustainable, and inclusive disclosure practices. at the core of this shift are three main forces: the incorporation of emerging technologies into audit processes, the rise of hybrid models combining financial and non-financial data, and the development of governance frameworks that promote stakeholder participation (aureli, foschi & paletta, 2023; biancone et al., 2024). smart accounting refers to the deployment of technologies such as artificial intelligence, blockchain, and cloud computing to automate repetitive processes, enhance transparency, and enable real-time auditability and disclosure (awang et al., 2024; desplebin et al., 2021). blockchain facilitates secure and verifiable triple-entry accounting, while artificial intelligence (ai) contributes to anomaly detection, predictive analysis, and risk management, particularly when integrated with robotic process automation (rpa) (al najjar et al., 2024). nevertheless, the rapid digitization of the field raises critical ethical and regulatory challenges, including algorithmic opacity, data privacy, and the urgent need to develop digital skills within the profession (fatzel et al., 2024; aminu abdullahi & abubakar, 2024). lehner et al. (2022) stress the necessity of embedding inclusive governance principles into the design of ai systems, advocating a shift in focus from technical performance to ethical accountability. this perspective aligns with calls from scholars to revise professional education by integrating ai literacy, data ethics, and cybersecurity into the curriculum (marrone & hazelton, 2019). pop accounting bridges conventional economic logic with stakeholder-oriented governance, seeking to generate value that transcends shareholder interests (biancone et al., 2024). mavlutova et al. (2023) observe that digital innovation within the financial sector advances sustainability, particularly through greater accessibility, efficiency, and informational clarity. advanced tools such as sentiment analysis enable dynamic assessments of public perception, while the incorporation of esg indicators and adherence to frameworks like the eu taxonomy reinforce the credibility of environmental and social communication (biancone et al., 2024). however, in the absence of globally harmonized sustainability standards and in light of persistent concerns about greenwashing, adoption remains uneven, especially across emerging economies with weaker regulatory infrastructures (alessi et al., 2024; abbas & shahid, 2024). dialogic accounting advances a participatory vision of governance that fosters active engagement among institutions, enterprises, and civil society (bessieux-ollier et al., 2023). it underscores the democratization of financial communication and the integration of human and social capital into organizational decision-making. yet, structural barriers such as institutional inertia, limited stakeholder literacy, and regulatory shortcomings continue to hinder its widespread uptake (bellucci et al., 2019; fusco & ricci, 2019). empirical research by frías-aceituno et al. (2013) demonstrates that board characteristics, including diversity and engagement, positively influence the dissemination of integrated disclosure practices, reinforcing dialogic accounting’s relevance to sustainability objectives. participatory budgeting tools and european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/11974 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 42 digital platforms have further expanded their applicability in both public and private contexts. still, traditional accounting systems often fail to accommodate circular business models and long-term ecological goals, as highlighted by aureli, foschi and paletta (2023). although these paradigms have typically been examined in isolation, recent literature reveals growing conceptual convergence and opportunities for hybridization. smart accounting delivers the technological infrastructure necessary for automation and data-driven insight. pop accounting reframes these outputs within stakeholder value systems, particularly via esg-oriented interpretations. dialogic accounting introduces a deliberative and ethical dimension that supports democratic legitimacy and co-responsibility. bibliometric studies by zupic and čater (2015) show how these paradigms are increasingly intersecting across academic discourse. vo van et al. (2024) further document that the adoption of cloud-based accounting systems by smes simultaneously enhances operational efficiency and sustainability engagement, illustrating the functional integration of technological and participatory objectives. 3. methodology this study constructed its corpus through a comprehensive search of scopus, a database whose structured indexing ensures that each retrieved record is peer-reviewed and provides the full bibliographic metadata necessary for processing with the bibliometrix package. the search was restricted to journal articles published in english that address smart accounting, pop accounting, or dialogic accounting in relation to digital transformation, sustainability, or stakeholder engagement. editorials, conference proceedings, and other forms of non-peer-reviewed grey literature were excluded, as they do not meet equivalent standards of editorial rigour. articles lacking a clear and substantive connection to these paradigms were also removed. to ensure methodological transparency, explicit inclusion and exclusion criteria were defined, and a two-stage screening process was adopted. in the first stage, publications were retrieved from journals indexed in scopus. in the second, thematic alignment was evaluated through abstract screening and, where necessary, full-text analysis. the resulting dataset comprises peerreviewed journal articles published between 2010 and 2025 across the fields of business, management and accounting, social sciences, and economics. eligibility criteria prioritized both the academic standing of the journal and the thematic relevance of each article to the paradigms under investigation. while peer review provides a foundational level of scholarly credibility, the screening process was further refined through qualitative assessments. these included the journal’s standing in established ranking systems, the citation profile of each article, and the degree of thematic coherence between the publication’s scope and the study’s research objectives. this comprehensive appraisal aimed to ensure that the final corpus represents not only credible but also influential scholarship, while remaining open to recent contributions from emerging outlets where thematic salience was demonstrable. the temporal scope, spanning 2010 to 2025, was chosen to encompass both foundational developments and contemporary advances in the field. the year 2010 marks a pivotal juncture, coinciding with the first recorded cryptocurrency transaction (arias-oliva et al., 2019), which laid the groundwork for subsequent innovations in smart accounting. simultaneously, scholarly interest in sustainability, corporate social responsibility, and stakeholder engagement began to inform the evolution of pop and dialogic accounting (bellucci et al., 2019). abstracts were initially reviewed; full texts were analysed when required, and duplicate entries such as in-press and final versions were consolidated. the identification of relevant literature was guided european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/11974 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 43 by a preliminary review of forty-five seminal sources, which supported the development of a comprehensive keyword set. an iterative refinement process was employed to construct the final search string, integrating synonyms and conceptually adjacent terms to ensure semantic breadth and terminological inclusivity (bellucci et al., 2019; bessieuxollier et al., 2023). to reduce the risk of excluding pertinent studies due to lexical variability, the boolean search string was formulated as follows: ("smart accounting" or "digital accounting" or "ai-based accounting" or "blockchain accounting" or "automated accounting" or "cloud accounting" or "big data in accounting" or "digital finance") and ("pop accounting" or "public accounting" or "sustainability reporting" or "stakeholder reporting" or "social reporting") and ("dialogic accounting" or "corporate social responsibility" or "participatory accounting" or "social and environmental accounting" or "collaborative accounting" or "stakeholder-centric accounting") and ("relationship" or "integration" or "link" or "connection" or "intersection" or "interaction" or "overlap" or "synergy"). a total of 222 articles satisfied these criteria and were exported to the biblioshiny interface of the bibliometrix r package for analysis (aria & cuccurullo, 2017). this platform enabled a systematic examination of publication dynamics, citation structures, and thematic co-occurrence, allowing the study to map how smart, pop, and dialogic accounting have intersected and, in some cases, diverged within scholarly discourse (zupic & čater, 2015). several limitations must be acknowledged. dependence on a single database may have led to the omission of relevant studies. the reliance on predefined keywords carries the inherent risk of excluding contributions that employ alternative formulations. furthermore, the temporal constraint from 2010 to 2025, while methodologically justified, may exclude earlier works that remain theoretically or historically significant (aureli, foschi & paletta, 2023; alessi et al., 2024). 4. results of the bibliometric analysis the following dataset provides information on the correlation between smart accounting, pop accounting, and dialogic accounting from 2010-2025. data collected are mainly from articles written in english in the fields of social sciences, economics, econometrics, and finance. 4.1 descriptive analysis of the literature table 1 summarizes the key characteristics of the dataset analyzed. the corpus includes 222 articles published in 122 distinct scientific sources, with a mean article age of 3.46 years. over the 2010–2025 time frame, the average annual growth rate of publications is 11.33%, indicating the growing academic attention to smart, pop, and dialogic accounting (zupic & čater, 2015). each article received, on average, 27.47 citations, highlighting the significant scholarly impact of the selected works. the dataset also reflects strong engagement with broader academic discourse: a total of 19,764 references were cited across the corpus, and an average of 2,798 keywords were extracted, underlining the thematic diversity and multidisciplinarity of the field (vo van et al., 2024). the collaboration index stands at 3.2, and only 19 european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/11974 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 44 articles were written by a single author, confirming the prevalence of co-authorship and the collaborative orientation of research in this domain (aureli, foschi & paletta, 2023). moreover, 29.73% of the articles involved international collaboration, reinforcing that this area is gaining traction across national borders (biancone et al., 2024). as shown in figure 1, the annual scientific production exhibits a clear upward trajectory, with robust growth in recent years. between 2013 and 2017, the publication rate remained relatively stable, with only modest fluctuations. however, starting in 2019, a sharp increase occurred, rising from eight publications in that year to ninety-nine in 2024. this acceleration suggests a growing scholarly interest in hybrid and interdisciplinary accounting paradigms, possibly driven by advances in ai, sustainability regulation, and stakeholder-driven governance (desplebin et al., 2021; abbas & shahid, 2024). the quantitative evidence demonstrates the dynamism of this emerging field and its growing integration within the global academic community. the high collaboration index and international co-authorship rates further signal a maturing research landscape increasingly focused on cross-border and cross-disciplinary dialogue. table 1. main information about data source: authors’ elaboration using the bibliometrix r-package. this table summarizes the analyzed dataset, including the number of articles, sources, average citations, keywords used, and collaboration indicators. it highlights the strong international and interdisciplinary nature of the research field. timespan 2010:2025 sources (journals, books, etc) 122 documents 222 annual growth rate % 11.33 document average age 3.46 average citations per doc 27.47 references 19764 document contents keywords plus (id) 394 author's keywords (de) 801 authors authors 644 authors of single-authored docs 18 authors collaboration single-authored docs 19 co-authors per doc 3.2 international co-authorships % 29.73 document types article 222 main information about data european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/11974 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 45 figure 1. annual scientific production source: authors’ elaboration using bibliometrix. this figure shows the annual number of publications on smart, pop, and dialogic accounting from 2010 to 2025. a significant increase in output is observed after 2019, indicating a growing interest in hybrid and sustainability-focused accounting models. 4.2 authors’ citation analysis the trend in the average number of citations per year for the 222 articles reached its peak in 2010, with an average of 21.16 citations per article. from 2011 onward, a gradual yet steady decline has been observed, despite occasional fluctuations. the most significant drop occurs between 2024 and 2025, when the average fell to 1.41 citations per article. as shown in figure 2, this pattern suggests an increase in publications over time accompanied by a deceleration in citation accumulation. this trend is indicative of a shift in academic focus toward new theoretical frameworks or a diversification of research themes that contributes to the decentralization of scholarly debate. it is also plausible that the expansion of open-access publishing and the rise of preprint platforms have altered traditional citation patterns. aminu abdullahi and abubakar (2024) argue that while these platforms improve access and dissemination, they may also affect the timing and frequency of citations, especially for more recent publications. in sum, the data point to a research domain that is rapidly expanding but increasingly fragmented, both in terms of theoretical alignment and citation dynamics. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/11974 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 46 figure 2. average citations per year source: authors’ elaboration using the bibliometrix r-package. this chart illustrates the average number of citations per article per year. the trend peaks in 2010, then gradually declines, suggesting a fragmentation of scholarly attention and possible shifts in academic focus or citation practices. table 2 illustrates that the ten most cited papers were published between 2010 and 2018. the most cited article (390 citations) is by de villiers (2014) in accounting, auditing & accountability journal. the second most cited work is by frías-aceituno et al. (2013) in corporate social responsibility and environmental management, which addresses corporate social responsibility and environmental management. this is followed by prado-lorenzo and garcía-sánchez (2010), which discusses the ethical implications of business practices with an emphasis on sustainability. other contributions include fifka (2013) in business strategy and the environment, which explores business strategies in relation to environmental issues, and wang et al. (2018) in corporate social responsibility and environmental management, which examines corporate responsibility in evolving global markets. gallego-álvarez et al. (2015), in the journal of cleaner production, provide insights into cleaner production practices, while morhardt (2010), also in business strategy and the environment, focuses on sustainable business strategies. in parallel, garcía-sánchez et al. (2013) argue in the journal of cleaner production for the role of environmental practices in improving corporate sustainability. andrikopoulos and kriklani (2013), in corporate social responsibility and environmental management, european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/11974 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 47 analyze sustainability from a corporate governance perspective, while pellegrino and lodhia (2012), in the journal of cleaner production, study innovative approaches to environmental management. the most frequently cited publications are the result of international collaborations. such collaborations enhance the quality and robustness of research, introduce diverse perspectives, and foster more effective solutions to the challenges of accounting, sustainability, and corporate governance. moreover, these partnerships increase the likelihood of adopting widely accepted international accounting and sustainability standards. table 2. most globally cited documents source: authors’ elaboration using the bibliometrix r-package. this table lists the ten most cited papers in the dataset, showing citation counts, authors, and journal names. it demonstrates that the most influential contributions were published between 2010 and 2018, mainly through international collaboration. figure 3 and table 3 illustrate the geographical cooperation among the authors of the analyzed papers, highlighting the strongest international links in this field. the most substantial collaboration is between china and australia, with three joint publications. other notable partnerships involve china and malaysia (2), as well as egypt and lebanon (2). additional collaborations include italy and the united kingdom, spain and brazil, and italy and spain, each with two coauthored papers. these joint efforts facilitate the exchange of knowledge to address shared challenges such as sustainability, corporate accountability, and the integration of technology into accounting processes. the collaborations between china, australia, the uk, and italy can be attributed to their leading role in deploying advanced technologies to enhance transparency and efficiency in accounting. by contrast, regions such as the middle east and latin america are european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/11974 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 48 increasingly experimenting with participatory, public-oriented approaches that align with dialogic accounting, which emphasizes stakeholder engagement and inclusivity in financial reporting (bellucci et al., 2019). the exchange of expertise between countries with advanced financial infrastructures and those adopting sustainability reporting models fosters the development of best practices to address contemporary accounting challenges. moreover, by generating empirical evidence on the applicability of accounting standards across diverse economic contexts, crossnational collaboration supports the policy-making process (abbas & shahid, 2024). finally, international partnerships also play a crucial role in harmonizing esg reporting standards, thereby promoting greater clarity and transparency in sustainability accounting (alessi et al., 2024). figure 3. collaboration world map source: authors’ elaboration using the bibliometrix r-package. this world map highlights international research collaborations. strong connections are visible between countries like china and australia, the uk and italy, and spain and brazil, underscoring the global scope and cooperative nature of the field. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/11974 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 49 table 3. most important collaborations among international researchers source: authors’ elaboration using the bibliometrix r-package. this table illustrates cross-country research partnerships, identifying the most active collaborations. it emphasizes the global nature of the debate, with notable cooperation between china, australia, the uk, italy, and spain. 4.3 source analysis this section provides a summary of the main sources and areas of interest of the international journals contributing to this topic. as shown in table 4, corporate social responsibility and environmental management is the leading journal with 13 published articles, demonstrating its central role in the field. sustainability (switzerland) contains 12 contributions on sustainability, while business strategy and the environment contains 9. further journals of strong interest include the journal of cleaner production (7 articles) and meditari accountancy research and research in international business and finance (6 articles each). journals such as administrative sciences, australian accounting review, and cogent business and management have each published four papers addressing sustainability and corporate governance. this indicates a growing interest in the intersection of business strategy, sustainability, and corporate responsibility. two main publication trends can be observed in figure 4. sustainability, corporate social responsibility, and environmental management have seen a sharp increase in publications, from no articles in 2010 to 15 in 2024 and 2025. by contrast, journals such as business strategy and the environment, journal of cleaner production, and meditari accountancy research exhibit a slower trajectory, with only modest growth in article numbers over the years. in conclusion, interest in sustainability and corporate responsibility is rising. from to frequency china australia 3 china united kingdom 3 malaysia united arab emirates 3 china malaysia 2 egypt lebanon 2 italy poland 2 italy united kingdom 2 jordan malaysia 2 malaysia indonesia 2 spain brazil 2 spain italy 2 spain slovakia 2 spain united kingdom 2 united kingdom egypt 2 european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/11974 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 50 table 4. most relevant sources source: authors’ elaboration using the bibliometrix r-package. this table shows the academic journals with the highest number of articles on smart, pop, and dialogic accounting. it underlines the leading role of journals focused on sustainability, csr, and environmental management. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/11974 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 51 figure 4. source dynamics source: authors’ elaboration using the bibliometrix r-package. this graph displays the evolution of article frequency by journal over time. journals such as ‘corporate social responsibility and environmental management’ and ‘sustainability’ show strong growth, reflecting increasing attention to sustainability and csr in accounting. 4.4 keyword analysis in the following section, the study examines the most salient keywords and their co-occurrence across titles, abstracts, and author-provided keywords in the field. figure 5 shows that the term “sustainability” has experienced the strongest growth. although other terms were included in the search, this remains one of the most prominent, reflecting its increasing association with “corporate social responsibility,” “innovation,” and “strategy.” in particular, the keyword “sustainable development” has continued to grow steadily, especially since 2017. keywords such as “stakeholders,” “decision making,” and “governance approach” have likewise increased in prominence, demonstrating the connections between sustainability and governance, finance, and environmental economics. figure 6 illustrates the evolution of research topics according to their degree of development (extent of discussion) and centrality (relevance). the thematic map highlights a cluster of motor themes, including “sustainability,” “corporate strategy,” “industrial performance,” and “environmental protection,” indicating both maturity and centrality within the field. the “green economy” emerges as a basic theme, european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/11974 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 52 relevant but still undergoing deeper theoretical elaboration. “corporate social responsibility,” “social impact,” and “artificial intelligence” reflect growing scholarly attention and considerable potential for future advancement. notably, “sustainable development” and “innovation” occupy a transitional position, underscoring their dynamic and evolving role within the research landscape. figure 5. word frequency over time source: authors’ elaboration using the bibliometrix r-package. this figure tracks the rising prominence of keywords across the dataset. terms like “sustainability,” “stakeholders,” and “governance” have shown steady growth, signaling evolving research priorities and interdisciplinary integration. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/11974 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 53 figure 6. thematic map source: authors’ elaboration using the bibliometrix r-package. the thematic map plots clusters of topics based on their development (x-axis) and centrality (y-axis). areas such as corporate strategy, ai, and sustainable development appear as emerging yet influential themes in accounting research. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/11974 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 54 figure 7. topic dendrogram source: authors’ elaboration using the bibliometrix r-package. this dendrogram groups research themes into five major clusters. each cluster reflects a thematic area, ranging from sustainability and corporate governance to environmental impact and digital innovation. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/11974 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 55 figure 7 groups keywords related to sustainability and corporate responsibility into five clusters. cluster 1 concentrates on core sustainability issues, namely corporate social responsibility, corporate finance, and corporate governance. cluster 2 gathers business-oriented concepts, including corporate strategy, the green economy, and industrial performance. cluster 3 maps sector-specific themes, for instance, environmental protection and communication. cluster 4 highlights emerging topics, ranging from decentralized finance to digital technologies. finally, cluster 5 concentrates on environmental impact. 4.5 semantic results and thematic interconnections with leximancer the semantic analysis performed with leximancer yields a map highlighting the three accounting paradigms that underpin the academic debate: smart accounting, pop accounting, and dialogic accounting. the concepts of “technology,” “internet,” and “reporting” are strongly associated with smart accounting, which recognizes the use of digital tools to streamline transparent, automated, and verifiable real-time reporting and auditing processes (awang et al., 2024; desplebin et al., 2021), thereby supporting more robust systems. at the same time, fatzel et al. (2024) emphasize persistent challenges related to standards, ethics, and gaps in digital competencies. in contrast, “performance,” “corporate,” “environmental,” and “disclosure” are linked to pop accounting, which seeks to promote comprehensive reporting, measure environmental and social impact, and ensure accessible communication with citizens and stakeholders (biancone et al., 2024). here, the notion of performance extends beyond economic efficiency to include social, environmental, and participatory dimensions, consistent with stakeholder capitalism. the integration of digital instruments, such as sentiment analysis, enables participatory financial statements to evolve in more collaborative and interactive ways (biancone et al., 2024; abbas & shahid, 2024). the domain of dialogic accounting emerges in the semantic cluster through concepts such as “social,” “management,” and “disclosure,” portraying accounting as a deliberative arena for diverse stakeholders. bellucci et al. (2019) note that the effectiveness of dialogic accounting depends on the intensity and quality of stakeholder engagement, yet empirical findings suggest that such engagement is often declared rather than implemented. bessieux-ollier et al. (2023) underscore the shift from “accounting for people” to “accounting with people,” advocating an emancipatory form of accounting grounded in dialogical rather than purely representative logic. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/11974 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 56 figure 8. thematic clusters of smart, pop and dialogic accounting: a conceptual analysis with leximancer source: authors’ elaboration using leximancer. this figure visualizes the conceptual structure of the research field using multidimensional scaling (mds). it highlights thematic groupings based on the co-occurrence of keywords, showing how core concepts like sustainability, stakeholder engagement, and digital technologies are positioned relative to each other in the academic debate. 5. discussion the bibliometric analysis of smart accounting, pop accounting, and dialogic accounting provides a comprehensive view of the current scholarly landscape and the evolving nature of these interconnected paradigms. the findings reveal a growing interest in these models and a clear semantic and conceptual convergence among them. keyword clustering shows that terms such as “sustainability,” “stakeholder engagement,” “ai,” and “transparency” frequently co-occur, indicating that once distinct paradigms are increasingly overlapping. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/11974 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 57 this corroborates biancone et al. (2024),who emphasize the integration of social, technological, and participatory elements in both theory and practice. bibliometric evidence reinforces this interpretation, showing that the semantic evolution of key concepts reflects the progressive hybridization of paradigms. for example, terms historically linked to csr and stakeholder dialogue now appear within clusters focused on ai, blockchain, and automation, suggesting that smart, pop, and dialogic accounting are becoming interwoven. co-citation analysis supports this trend, with foundational works on sustainability reporting and stakeholder theory cited alongside emerging literature on algorithmic auditing, digital finance, and automated control systems. this interdisciplinary pattern aligns with bessieux-ollier et al. (2023), who call for a dialogic, inclusive, and context-sensitive approach to accounting innovation. nonetheless, several critical issues emerge. the selection of sources, based primarily on scopus and google scholar, while ensuring broad coverage, may exclude significant studies not indexed in these databases. aureli, foschi and paletta (2023) warn of the risks of overlooking niche but theoretically rich contributions, particularly in circular and participatory accounting domains. another concern relates to the geographical distribution of contributions. mapping international collaborations shows an intense concentration in high-income countries, particularly china, australia, italy, and the uk, while regions such as sub-saharan africa and south asia remain markedly underrepresented. this supports biancone et al. (2024), who observe that research on participatory accounting in emerging economies is still limited. greater attention to these regions could foster the emergence of context-sensitive models more attuned to local socio-economic realities. despite the steady increase in publication volume, the declining average number of citations per article since 2010 suggests fragmentation within the academic discourse. this may reflect the proliferation of open-access and preprint platforms, which reshape citation practices and accelerate the diffusion of highly specialized contributions (aminu abdullahi & abubakar, 2024). while this dynamic indicates growth, it also risks theoretical disconnection and reduced cumulative knowledge. therefore, although bibliometrics offers robust insights into structural trends, the field would benefit from greater methodological pluralism. as bessieux-ollier et al. (2023) argue, integrating interpretive and qualitative methods can capture the nuanced theoretical tensions that purely quantitative approaches may overlook. in particular, incorporating voices from underrepresented contexts would enhance the field’s inclusivity, maturity, and practical relevance. without such integration, there is a tangible risk of overlooking emerging practice-based innovations that are essential for redefining accounting in response to digital transformation, sustainability challenges, and demands for stakeholder participation. 6. conclusion this paper presents a bibliometric analysis aimed at tracing the evolution, convergence, and research gaps in the academic debate on smart accounting, pop accounting, and dialogic accounting from 2010 to 2025. the study examined the progression of these paradigms, highlighting their conceptual intersections and revealing critical areas that remain underexplored, particularly with respect to normative, ethical, and geographical inclusivity. in response to rq1, the findings confirm a consistent and significant increase in academic output, especially from 2019 onward, reflecting a broader scholarly orientation toward digital innovation and sustainability. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/11974 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 58 smart accounting has gained momentum through the integration of technologies such as artificial intelligence (ai), blockchain, and automation in financial processes (desplebin et al., 2021; awang et al., 2024). pop accounting has evolved in parallel with stakeholder capitalism, advancing inclusive and accessible reporting mechanisms (biancone et al., 2024). dialogic accounting, grounded in participatory governance, continues to stress the ethical and democratic dimensions of financial communication (bellucci et al., 2019; bessieux-ollier et al., 2023). with regard to rq2, keyword co-occurrence and thematic clustering demonstrate an increasing conceptual convergence. smart accounting prioritizes transparency and operational efficiency; pop accounting is oriented toward social value and stakeholder responsiveness; dialogic accounting introduces a deliberative logic that supports accountability and inclusive engagement. advanced tools such as sentiment analysis (biancone et al., 2024) and life cycle assessment (aureli, foschi & paletta, 2023) illustrate how technological and participatory approaches are being jointly applied in public sector financial reporting. in addressing rq3, the analysis identifies significant gaps in the literature. although international collaborations are well developed among countries such as china, australia, italy, and the united kingdom, contributions from regions such as sub-saharan africa, south asia, and latin america remain underrepresented. this geographical imbalance limits the inclusion of culturally embedded and institutionally diverse perspectives on accounting innovation. research from these regions is closely linked to development objectives, legitimacy, and public accountability. such contexts have the potential to generate context-sensitive and participatory models (fusco & ricci, 2019; abbas & shahid, 2024). moreover, the ethical and regulatory implications of accounting innovation remain insufficiently addressed in the literature, despite their growing importance in digital and sustainability-oriented transformations. 6.1 theoretical and practical contributions theoretically, this study supports the emergence of a hybrid paradigm that integrates the core principles of smart, pop, and dialogic accounting. this convergence is not only technical but also ethical and institutional, reflecting a broader transformation of accounting from a neutral reporting instrument into a vehicle for social legitimacy and stakeholder empowerment. by combining automation with participatory logic and sustainability objectives, hybrid models provide a framework for resilient, transparent, and democratically accountable financial practices across both public and private sectors (vo van et al., 2024; biancone et al., 2024). 6.2 limitations despite its contributions, the study presents some methodological limitations. the 2010–2025 period was chosen to capture recent developments, but it may have omitted significant contributions published prior to 2010, particularly in social accounting and participatory reporting. this exclusion may constrain understanding of the historical roots of the phenomenon. for instance, brown and jones (2015) demonstrate that the theoretical foundations of dialogic accounting had already been developed in the early 2000s. another limitation concerns the declining average number of citations per article over time. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/11974 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 59 this phenomenon may be associated with the fragmentation of academic debate and the expansion of open-access and preprint platforms, which have altered traditional citation dynamics (aminu abdullahi & abubakar, 2024). 7. future research directions multiple future research directions emerge from this study. first, scholars should complement bibliometric mapping with qualitative methodologies such as case studies, interviews, and ethnography to gain deeper insight into how smart, pop, and dialogic accounting models are implemented in specific socio-political and organizational contexts (bessieux-ollier et al., 2023). second, greater emphasis should be placed on geographical inclusivity. research from emerging economies, particularly in sub-saharan africa, south asia, and latin america, remains underrepresented. comparative studies across institutional settings could illuminate how diverse cultural, regulatory, and developmental conditions shape the evolution of hybrid accounting models (alessi et al., 2024; abbas & shahid, 2024). third, future investigations should examine how emerging technologies such as artificial intelligence, blockchain, cloud computing, and machine learning can enhance stakeholder engagement, esg reporting, and real-time accountability. these technologies create opportunities for designing integrated systems in which automation and participation operate in synergy. however, this integration must be informed by ethical frameworks that address privacy, algorithmic bias, accessibility, and the digital divide. finally, future research should explicitly engage with the normative dimensions of accounting innovation. as accounting becomes increasingly data-driven and digitally mediated, it is essential to ask who benefits from such systems, whose voices are included, and what values they promote. a truly transformative accounting paradigm must integrate methodological plurality, technological innovation, and ethical reflection within a global and context-sensitive perspective. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/11974 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 60 references abbas, n., & shahid, m. s. (2024). mapping the impact of green finance on corporate sustainability: a bibliometric analysis. audit and accounting review, 4(1), 101–130. https://doi.org/10.32350/aar.41.05 alessi, l., cojoianu, t., hoepner, a. g., & michelon, g. (2024). accounting for the eu green taxonomy: exploring its concept, data, and analytics. accounting forum, 48(3), 365–373. https://doi.org/10.1080/01559982.2024.2369343 al najjar, m., mahboub, r., nakhal, b., & gaber ghanem, m. (2024). exploring the role of ai in improving vat reporting quality: experimental study in emerging markets. journal of risk & financial management, 17(11), article 477. https://doi.org/10.3390/jrfm17110477 aminu abdullahi, a. a., & abubakar, a. (2024). bibliometric analysis of accounting literature on artificial intelligence adoption in organizational functions. fudma journal of accounting and finance research, 2(3), 153–171. https://doi.org/10.33003/fujafr-2024.v2i3.126.153-171 andrikopoulos, a., & kriklani, n. (2013). environmental disclosure and financial characteristics of the firm: the case of denmark. corporate social responsibility & environmental management, 20(1), 55–64. https://doi.org/10.1002/csr.1281 aria, m., & cuccurullo, c. (2017). bibliometrix: an r-tool for comprehensive science mapping analysis. journal of informetrics, 11(4), 959–975. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.joi.2017.08.007 arias-oliva, m., pelegrín-borondo, j., & matías-clavero, g. (2019). variables influencing cryptocurrency use: a technology acceptance model in spain. frontiers in psychology, 10, article 475. https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2019.00475 aureli, s., foschi, e., & paletta, a. (2023). management accounting for a circular economy: current limits and avenues for a dialogic approach. accounting, auditing & accountability journal. advance online publication. https://doi.org/10.1108/aaaj-04-2022-5766 awang, y., nasir, n. e. m., taib, a., shuhidan, s. m., & ifada, l. m. (2024). digitalization of the accounting profession: a decade of bibliometric analysis. advances in social sciences research journal, 11(5), 103–120. https://doi.org/10.14738/assrj.115.16814 bellucci, m., simoni, l., acuti, d., & manetti, g. (2019). stakeholder engagement and dialogic accounting: empirical evidence in sustainability reporting. accounting, auditing & accountability journal, 32(5), 1467–1499. https://doi.org/10.1108/aaaj-09-2017-3158 bessieux-ollier, c., nègre, e., & verdier, m.-a. (2023). moving from accounting for people to accounting with people: a critical analysis of the literature and avenues for research. european accounting review, 32(5), 1247–1271. https://doi.org/10.1080/09638180.2022.2052922 biancone, p., brescia, v., chmet, f., & lanzalonga, f. (2024). the evolution of integrated popular financial reporting: toward a digital-driven collaborative approach using a sentiment-analysis tool. euromed journal of business. advance online publication. https://doi.org/10.1108/emjb-11-2023-0298 https://doi.org/10.32350/aar.41.05 https://doi.org/10.1080/01559982.2024.2369343 https://doi.org/10.3390/jrfm17110477 https://doi.org/10.33003/fujafr-2024.v2i3.126.153-171 https://doi.org/10.1002/csr.1281 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.joi.2017.08.007 https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2019.00475 https://doi.org/10.1108/aaaj-04-2022-5766 https://doi.org/10.14738/assrj.115.16814 https://doi.org/10.1108/aaaj-09-2017-3158 https://doi.org/10.1080/09638180.2022.2052922 https://doi.org/10.1108/emjb-11-2023-0298 european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/11974 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 61 biancone, p. p., secinaro, s., brescia, v., & calandra, d. (2024). which direction for stakeholder capitalism? approaches and reporting towards pop accounting. sustainable development, 32(6), 6579–6594. https://doi.org/10.1002/sd.3052 brown, r., & jones, m. (2015). mapping and exploring the topography of contemporary financial accounting research. the british accounting review, 47(3), 237–261. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.bar.2014.08.006 de villiers, c., rinaldi, l., & unerman, j. (2014). integrated reporting: insights, gaps and an agenda for future research. accounting, auditing & accountability journal, 27(7), 1042–1067. https://doi.org/10.1108/aaaj-06-2014-1736 desplebin, o., lux, g., & petit, n. (2021). to be or not to be: blockchain and the future of accounting and auditing. accounting perspectives, 20(4), 743–769. https://doi.org/10.1111/1911-3838.12265 fatzel, f. h. m., abdullah, w. r. w., & zamri, n. (2024). the impact of digital technologies on accounting research: a bibliometric analysis. in proceedings of the conference on accounting and business (icab 2024) (p. 459). [conference paper]. fifka, m. s. (2013). corporate responsibility reporting and its determinants in comparative perspective: a review of the empirical literature and a meta-analysis. business strategy & the environment, 22(1), 1–35. https://doi.org/10.1002/bse.729 frías-aceituno, j. v., rodriguez-ariza, l., & garcía-sanchez, i. m. (2013). the role of the board in the dissemination of integrated corporate social reporting. corporate social responsibility & environmental management, 20(4), 219– 233. https://doi.org/10.1002/csr.1294 fusco, f., & ricci, p. (2019). what is the stock of the situation? a bibliometric analysis on social and environmental accounting research in the public sector. international journal of public sector management, 32(1), 21–41. https://doi.org/10.1108/ijpsm-05-2017-0134 gallego-álvarez, i., segura, l., & martínez-ferrero, j. (2015). carbon emission reduction: the impact on the financial and operational performance of international companies. journal of cleaner production, 103, 149–159. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2014.08.047 garcía-sánchez, i.-m., frías-aceituno, j.-v., & rodríguez-domínguez, l. (2013). determinants of corporate social disclosure in spanish local governments. journal of cleaner production, 39, 60–72. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2012.08.037 lehner, o. m., ittonen, k., silvola, h., ström, e., & wührleitner, a. (2022). artificial intelligence-based decision-making in accounting and auditing: ethical challenges and normative thinking. accounting, auditing & accountability journal, 35(9), 109–135. https://doi.org/10.1108/aaaj-09-2020-4934 marrone, m., & hazelton, j. (2019). the disruptive and transformative potential of new technologies for accounting, accountants and accountability: a review of current literature and call for further research. meditari accountancy research, 27(5), 677–694. https://doi.org/10.1108/medar-06-2019-0508 mavlutova, i., spilbergs, a., verdenhofs, a., natrins, a., arefjevs, i., & volkova, t. (2023). digital transformation as a driver of the financial sector’s sustainable development: an impact on financial inclusion and operational efficiency. sustainability, 15(1), article 207. https://doi.org/10.3390/su15010207 https://doi.org/10.1002/sd.3052 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.bar.2014.08.006 https://doi.org/10.1108/aaaj-06-2014-1736 https://doi.org/10.1111/1911-3838.12265 https://doi.org/10.1002/bse.729 https://doi.org/10.1002/csr.1294 https://doi.org/10.1108/ijpsm-05-2017-0134 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2014.08.047 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2012.08.037 https://doi.org/10.1108/aaaj-09-2020-4934 https://doi.org/10.1108/medar-06-2019-0508 https://doi.org/10.3390/su15010207 european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/11974 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 62 morhardt, j. e. (2010). corporate social responsibility and sustainability reporting on the internet. business strategy & the environment, 19(7), 436–452. https://doi.org/10.1002/bse.657 pellegrino, c., & lodhia, s. (2012). climate-change accounting and the australian mining industry: exploring the links between corporate disclosure and the generation of legitimacy. journal of cleaner production, 36, 68–82. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2012.02.022 prado-lorenzo, j.-m., & garcia-sanchez, i.-m. (2010). the role of the board of directors in disseminating relevant information on greenhouse gases. journal of business ethics, 97(3), 391–424. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10551010-0515-0 vo van, h., abu afifa, m., & saleh, i. (2024). accounting information systems and organizational performance in the cloud-computing era: evidence from smes. sustainability accounting, management & policy journal. advance online publication. https://doi.org/10.1108/sampj-01-2024-0044 wang, z., hsieh, t.-s., & sarkis, j. (2018). csr performance and the readability of csr reports: too good to be true? corporate social responsibility & environmental management, 25(1), 66–79. https://doi.org/10.1002/csr.1440 zupic, i., & čater, t. (2015). bibliometric methods in management and organization. organizational research methods, 18(3), 429–472. https://doi.org/10.1177/1094428114562629 https://doi.org/10.1002/bse.657 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2012.02.022 https://doi.org/10.1007/s10551-010-0515-0 https://doi.org/10.1007/s10551-010-0515-0 https://doi.org/10.1108/sampj-01-2024-0044 https://doi.org/10.1002/csr.1440 https://doi.org/10.1177/1094428114562629 european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/10383 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 36 sustainable fashion in the circular economy paradigm: reduce, reuse and recycle as the new sustainable corporate strategy patrizia gazzola1, roberta rita pezzetti2, stefano amelio3* 1 university of insubria, department of economics, via monte generoso 71, 21100, varese, italy patrizia.gazzola@uninsubria.it orcid https://orcid.org/0000-0003-2521-4892 2 university of insubria, department of economics, via monte generoso 71, 21100, varese, italy robertarita.pezzetti@uninsubria.it orcid https://orcid.org/0000-0001-8266-8503 3 university of insubria, department of economics, via monte generoso 71, 21100, varese, italy stefano.amelio@uninsubria.it orcid https://orcid.org/0000-0002-6472-365x * contact author received: 29/05/2024 accepted for publication: 26/08/2024 published: 28/08/2024 abstract the aim of this paper is to analyse emerging trends in the fashion industry, focusing on the growing role the circular economy is playing in introducing a new business paradigm based on the so-called "3 rs" principle: reduce, reuse and recycle. six interesting case studies are presented; three focus on fashion companies (rifò, rapanui and cingomma) that base their business model on this circular economy principle, while the other three relate to companies (orange fiber, ananas anam, due di latte) using sustainable materials to produce fashion items. the careful selection of raw materials and the application of technological innovation in the production system allow companies to implement new sustainable approaches to production, resulting in two critical outcomes: recycled fashion products that can be reintegrated into the environment and the reuse of products that can be revalued without rather than wasted. keywords: fashion industry, sustainability, circular economy, product innovation, business models, corporate strategy mailto:patrizia.gazzola@uninsubria.it https://orcid.org/0000-0003-2521-4892 mailto:robertarita.pezzetti@uninsubria.it https://orcid.org/0000-0001-8266-8503 mailto:stefano.amelio@uninsubria.it 37 1. introduction the fashion industry, one of the worst polluters in the world with multiple environmental impacts (brand-correa and steinberger, 2022), is facing a radical transformation. global demographic and digitalisation growth, resource scarcity and climate change acceleration are challenging companies both to produce sustainable fashion products and to innovate their business models based on the circular economy paradigm (abdelmeguid et al., 2022; d'adamo et al., 2022; galatti and baruque-ramos, 2022) in order to remain competitive and profitable in the long run (hahn and figge, 2011). consumers around the world are increasingly aware that the fashion industry largely has a significant adverse impact on the environment, as a result of both the industry's complex supply chain and the shift towards the fast fashion paradigm (vătămănescu et al., 2021). the scandals that have occurred over the years in the fashion sector, in particular linked to the unregulated intensive use of resources or the exploitation of animals, have led to the acquisition of greater awareness of the unsustainability of a model like the current one. fast fashion giants often come under scrutiny for the exploitation of workers throughout the entire production chain and for non-existent environmental policies (the investigation 'untold: inside the shein machine' is recent and has impressed the world). but even over the years there has been no shortage of reports of animal exploitation (as in the documentary 'slay'). the moncler case is emblematic. according to recent research conducted by bof mckinsey (2021), today's consumers are more ethically minded, and they are asking to companies to build their businesses with a conscience. companies are also facing pressure from consumers to take actions, but the situation is not clear, as there is not an agreed-upon definition of what is sustainable, natural or clean. nevertheless, technological advancement, marked by the continuous impulse to innovate products and the increase in applications for new sustainable fibres (nayak et al., 2023), are paving the way to a more sustainable future for fashion. the importance of the change in strategy is also emphasised by the european union, which in recent years has approved a series of regulatory interventions aimed at increasing the sustainability of economic activities and encouraging the adoption of circular economy practices, as opposed to the traditional linear economy model. in particular, as pointed out by a study by the european parliament (2023), 2.1 billion tonnes of waste are produced in the eu every year, but despite this, the way in which this waste is managed has improved: a decrease in the use of landfills has led to an increase in recycling and composting, i.e. a gradual transition towards the circular economy. while recent european regulations (e.g. the green taxonomy, csrd) have fostered the development of sustainable practices, the european parliament in recent years has passed a number of measures to realise the circular economy (among others, a resolution on the new action plan for the circular economy in 2021 and the revision of the eu regulations on packaging and packaging waste in 2023). in 2020, the european commission presented the action plan for a new circular economy in which special attention was paid to the textile sector, a high impact sector, where textile purchases in the eu in 2017 generated approximately 654 kg of co2 emissions per person (european environment agency, 2019). two years later it then published the first package of measures to accelerate the transition to a circular economy. all this in a global context in which attention to the environment has become central in strategies, one only has to think of the un millennium development goals 2000 (15 mdgs) or the un sustainable development goals (17 sdgs). the circular economy is also very important in italy, which is the european leader in waste recovery and recycling and in the circular economy, having the highest percentage of recycling on all waste equal to 79%, a productivity of resource use and a circularity rate of material in the economy higher than the european average (symbola foundation, 2021). fashion companies today are pressed by the need to invest in new technologies (kemp et al., 2005) and to reinvent their manufacturing processes in order to reduce the environmental impact of their activities and to increase safety for consumers. at the same time, fashion companies increasingly focus on sustainability by investing in both product and process innovation european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/10383 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 38 with the aim of creating fashion products that respect the environment and respond to purchase choices increasingly driven by ethical and emotional motivations. in this context, the concept of eco-fashion, understood as an approach oriented to employing best practices to attain environmental sustainability and to address social responsibilities, has spread in recent years. these needs have led to the development of new business strategies geared towards sustainability. sustainability issues in the fashion industry are the result of the balanced integration of economic, social and environmental performance (pedersen, earley and andersen, 2019). circular fashion (peleg mizrachi and tal, 2022; shou and domenech, 2022; ki, chong and ha‐brookshire, 2020) represents the implementation of sustainability principles within the corporate strategy. according to claxton and kent (2020), the fashion industry implements sustainability strategies mainly related to the choice of materials and production steps recommended by the circular design approach. lately, however, research has identified other aspects of the life cycle, such as "design for durability or longevity, recycling, zero-waste approaches and disassembly" (claxton and kent, p. 8, 2020). the circular economy in the fashion industry is an area of research that has been investigated in the literature but has several significant gaps. most studies focus on specific aspects, such as material recycling or sustainable production, without considering the interconnectedness between the different phases of the product life cycle (geissdoerfer et al., 2017). the current literature often does not adequately consider the role of emerging technologies and emerging paradigms in facilitating the transition to the circular economy (minunno et al., 2020). finally, there is limited study of the social implications of the circular economy in the fashion industry, especially in terms of its impact on working conditions and social justice (henry et al., 2020). these gaps highlight the need for alternative methodological approaches to fill existing gaps. based on these premises, the following research question was developed: rq1) how are fashion companies innovating their business model in relation to circular economy principles? these new practices have resulted in the fashion industry applying the so-called "three rs paradigm" (recycle, reuse and reduce) as a way to improve the quality of life for both environments and people by paying increasing attention to sustainability and corporate social responsibility (zbuchea, petropoulos and partyka, 2018). for this reason, the second research question investigated is as follows: rq2) what are the positive consequences of fashion companies applying the three rs paradigm? this paper analyses emerging trends in the fashion industry, focusing on the growing role the circular economy is playing in introducing a new business paradigm based on the so-called "three rs" principle: reduce, reuse and recycle. in particular, the paper develops the notion of corporate sustainability in the fashion industry in order to highlight sustainable issues faced by companies in the market. the study explores how some companies have adopted and developed this new business paradigm, considered a best practice in the fashion industry, and analyses the outcomes from a dual perspective: consumer perspective and quality of life perspective. the structure of the paper is as follows: the introductory paragraph is followed by a review of relevant literature (circular economy in the fashion industry, the three rs paradigm, sdg 12). this is followed by an explanation of the methodology and the analysis of six case studies. the selected case studies aim to show how sustainability represents a critical driver of growth european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/10383 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 39 for fashion companies and a strategic tool to improve the quality of life (papagiannis et al., 2018). the paper concludes by answering the two research questions based on the outcome of the case study analyses. 2. literature review 2.1 circular economy in the fashion sector and the 3 rs principle the circular economy aims to overcome the linear model of production and consumption (camilleri, 2018; merli, preziosi and acampora, 2018). companies are increasingly adopting innovative business models (colombi and d'itria, 2023) inspired by sustainability as a main driver for enhancing their long-lasting competitiveness (gazzola, 2018; gazzola et al., 2019). fashion, one of the most polluting sectors of the economy (sehnem et al., 2024), is a resource-intensive industry, where opportunities to reduce environmental impact and innovate business models abound (todeschini et al., 2017; pollifroni, 2012) but only with the total involvement of stakeholders along the entire value chain (mahanty and domenech, 2024). according to niinimäki (2017), building a truly circular economic system requires a new type of system and radical innovations, as well as ten challenges that management must face to deal with the transition from linear to circular economy (abdelmeguid, afy-shararah and salonitis, 2024). today's fashion companies are being called upon to take up the challenge of meeting consumers' needs without compromising the quality of both environment and life by progressively reducing their ecological impact and resource intensity in line with earth's estimated carrying capacity (desimone and popoff, 2000). the fashion industry is not yet comparable to a circular system, characterised by materials that generate 'additional value' and not 'additional wastes'. however, many pioneering companies are exploring the potential related to the application of circular models in fashion. in line with these trends, companies in the fashion sector are increasingly interested in the use of recycled fibres, yarns, and fabrics in the development and production of new products (papamichael et al., 2023). unfortunately, it's a slow transition because of regulations, logistics, technical and economic resources and appropriate infrastructures. the ‘ceo’s fashion agenda’ is an international initiative with the ultimate goal of creating durable products that encourage the disassembly of fibres and the creation of recyclable garments. on the other hand, several initiatives have been launched to promote the collection of used garments among retailers. to achieve their goals, leading fashion companies should collaborate with governments to develop circular systems (chalmer et al., 2018). recycled textile materials can be obtained through two processes: through the supply chain and through post-consumer collection methods (leonas, 2017). for a 34-month period, hvass and pedersen (2019) examined a global fashion brand that launched a new in-store product recall initiative. the authors identified emerging challenges and sustainable solutions arising from the integration of circular economy solutions within existing business models. on the one hand, fashion companies are increasingly required to incorporate the circular economy paradigm in their business strategies; on the other hand, consumers expectations need to be carefully analysed to better understand how sustainability affects both consumer perceptions and behaviour. hu et al. (2019) identified the drivers of participation and non-participation in the circular economy, as well as the emergence of potentially new circular economy european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/10383 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 40 micro-entrepreneur. this business model, which is likely to grow in the future, is based on consumers who easily access consumption (battle, ryding and henninger, 2018). in the world of fashion, in recent years, the three rs have assumed increased importance in driving companies' strategies, both at corporate and business level, with an important impact on the path to innovation (dymchenko et al., 2021). savings in fashion manufacturing processes are based on energy efficiency, derived from the possibility of containing production costs and reducing the consumption of water required to process raw materials. the reuse principle refers to reusing a product by extending its life cycle; this allows the product to be revitalised and reintroduced into the market, a practice that allows companies to reduce waste and optimise production processes while responding to a growing market demand for conscious purchasing (papagiannis et al., 2021). the practice of reuse in the fashion market follows the trend to produce customised items (i.e. craftsmanship and manual workmanship). an obvious virtuous example in the textile industry is the transformation of polyethylene terephthalate containers into continuous filaments that can be used in garments (pavione and pezzetti, 2015). intervening in all phases of the value chain is important to ensure sustainability in the fashion industry (gazzola, pavione, and pezzetti, 2017): "provision of raw materials (low ecological impact, deriving from recycling, renewable sources or fair-trade initiatives); production (reusing and reducing water resources, reducing energy consumption in the manufacturing processes, adopting technologies funded on ecological principles, recycling discards and excess production, etc); logistics (rationalising transportation flow, using vehicles with low impact, reducing packaging or use recycling packaging); promotion (eco-compatible preparation, furnishings etc., forms of communication and encouraging reduced environmental impact); end of life (reuse, recycling, degree of biodegradability)". the different combinations of the three rs could be considered a driver of enhanced differentiation in both the market andbusiness models, where sustainability is becoming critical to a company's long-lasting competitiveness , improving brand image, and building a solid market reputation. as highlighted in the literature, there are barriers and opportunities for the implementation of circular economy principles in the different sectors (kirchherr et al., 2018) and in particular in the fashion industry (sehnem et al., 2024; dissanayake and weerasinghe, 2021). among the main barriers identified, is the high fragmentation of the value chain (mishra, jain and malhotra, 2021). furthermore, the perceived poor quality of recycled materials (jia et al., 2020), the lack of company policies oriented towards sustainability and the low knowledge of sustainability-related issues among workers prevent the shift towards the circular economy. one of the main problems identified is the absence (or poor presence) of teaching sustainability practices within political pedagogical projects, both at a generalist level and in fashion design courses (sehnem et al., 2024). the implementation of the principles of the circular economy, despite the existing barriers, would make it possible to obtain a series of positive results, such as for example the protection of biodiversity, savings in the use of resources, the reduction of environmental impacts, but also an increase productivity of the territory, an improvement of working conditions and the reduction of company costs. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/10383 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 41 2.2 sdg 12: responsible consumption and production in september 2015, the governments of the 193 united nations member countries signed the 2030 agenda for sustainable development action program. it encompasses 17 sustainable development goals (sdgs). each goal is interdependent and wide-ranging. moreover, each goal is linked to a list of tangible results that are measurable with indicators (colglazier, 2015). the circular economy is a key strategy for achieving the united nations sustainable development goals (sdgs). the link between the circular economy and the sdgs is particularly evident in several goals, mainly including goal 12 (responsible consumption and production), which promotes waste reduction through prevention, reduction, recycling, and reuse (thakker and sun, 2023; velozo valenga et al., 2023; schroeder, anggraeni and weber, 2019). the circular economy is a particularly innovation that can also support the achievement of other objectives related to the agenda, in particular the following: sdg 6 (relating to water), sdg 7 (relating to energy), sdg 13 (relating to climate change) (geissdoerfer et al., 2017), sdg 14 (relating to the oceans) and sdg 15 (relating to terrestrial life). in summary, the circular economy not only directly supports various sdgs, but also promotes an integrated approach to sustainability in which economic, social, and environmental goals are closely interconnected. in particular, the achievement of goal 12, "responsible consumption and production", calls into question the linear model of the traditional economic system. this goal, fixed in the un agenda, originates from the fact that the world population currently consumes more resources than it can generate and supply; it also pushes to identify innovative solutions in the framework of social and environmental sustainability, involving both the production and consumption side (gasper, shah and tankha, 2019; gazzola et al., 2020). therefore, it's a goal with a dual purpose. firstly, it pushes companies to implement sustainable practices aimed at reducing waste, including recycling and sustainable public procurement. secondly, it encourages consumers to reduce waste and make responsible purchases and pushes them to inquire about the origin and composition of the products purchased (bengtsson et al., 2018). decisions related to production and consumption must be made by all levels, from supranational and national bodies to individuals, each of whom contribute in different ways to the implementation of a new circular economy model. to achieve this goal, it's not enough to perform virtuous but disconnected actions that are not integrated via a structured strategy. instead, it's important to follow real sustainable behaviour models (andrei, gazzola, zbuchea and alexandru, 2017). as the production cycle starts with the use of raw materials and natural resources, it's essential to minimise the impact on the environment in the acquisition of these resources. the circular economy model is based on secondary raw materials, which are materials recovered from scraps and waste or previously used in otherproduction cycles that are regenerated and reintegrated into a new production cycle (prieto-sandoval, jaca and ormazabal, 2018). the circular economy model involves careful management of products as they reach the end of their use, when the potential waste is about to be created. this management involves a series of three phases: collection, breakdown and recovery. the different phases must enable the materials to be recovered as widely as possible. this allows for the regeneration and reuse of recovered materials in new production cycles. eliminating waste and reusing and extending the life of the goods in circulation are two behaviours that should guide consumers (sala and castellani, 2019). european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/10383 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 42 mcdonough and braungart (2013) propose applying new methods of cooperation between industry and final users to change the traditional way of thinking about waste. the suggested approach is based to the principle of eco-effectivity: the choice to do the right thing, meaning to thrive as a society, nourish the life cycle of the planet and feed the technological cycle of the industries without feeling guilty about consumption (pessôa, araújo and arruda, 2015). 3. methodology to investigate the complex process of change that involves consumers' habits and companies' approaches to sustainable practices in the fashion market, six case studies related to the application of circular economy principles are presented. in particular, the qualitative methodology used follows that developed by lanzalonga, marseglia, irace and biancone (2024), based on case studies. in detail, the study was developed by considering two steps. in the first, six relevant case studies were identified. in the second, a research design was created. the six start-ups that were chosen are characterised by corporate visions focused on sustainability and circular economy principles, an approach to business that has allowed them to grow in the market and successfully overcome the initial start-up phase. these fashion companies have particularly distinguished themselves in the field of the circular economy, having won awards and/or sitting at the top of international rankings, as specified in the sections dedicated to the analysis of the individual case studies. only start-up companies were selected, i.e., companies that had made product or process innovations (and not exclusively business model innovations, such as zara). the results are, therefore, replicable to other companies with similar characteristics. the companies chosen share a common sustainable corporate strategy: improving the quality of life and creating value for consumers. they are as follows: rifò, a company that reuses and transforms old clothing; rapanui, a sustainable clothing brand born in 2009 based on the idea of creating clothing, from the production to the packaging phase, without producing any kind of waste; cingomma, an eco-friendly italian company that recycles bike tires and air chambers into belts, key holders and bags; orange fiber, an italian start-up that uses orange waste to produce fashion items; ananas anam, which uses ananas fibre; and duedillatte, which uses milk fibre to produce fashion items. these companies have the following characteristics (table i): table i: characteristics of companies revenue number of employees geographic location rifò € 2.3 million (2022) 19 (2024) prato (po), italy rapanui $ 5.7 million (2023) 87 (2023) freshwater, isle of wight, united kingdom cingomma € 200 thousand (2023) 0 (2023) torino (to), italy orange fiber € 88 thousand (2022) 4 (2024) catania (ct), italy ananas anam $ 8.6 million (2023) 22 (2023) london, united kingdom european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/10383 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 43 duedilatte1 € 13 thousand (2021) 0 (2021) crans-montana, switzerland source: authors own elaboration the research design is structured in five key steps to ensure the reliability of the results (cascante et al., 2022). after defining research objectives (eisenhardt, 1989) and methodology (massaro, dumay and bagnoli, 2019), six case studies were selected, considering the variables listed above. to collect the data, two authors independently analysed the company websites (publicly available official data) (gazzola et al., 2020b). next, according to gioia, corley and hamilton (2013), the collected data were analysed "through an iterative reasoning cycle based on an inductive search approach" (lanzalonga et al., 2024, p. 6). the results of the analysis were then compared and evaluated in light of the two variables investigated in our analysis: quality of life improvements and consumer perspectives). 4. results 4.1 rifò rifò (table ii) is an italian fashion company created in december 2017 and based in prato, an historical textile district in the tuscany region. the idea was born when one of the funders, while working for the united nations in vietnam, realised that the clothing made in vietnam and exported to europe was returned to vietnam in order to be landfilled or incinerated if it was not sold. starting from this observation, he decided to bring back the prato tradition of local cloth fabrics. rifò started out as a start-up with a crowdfunding campaign in which about 8,000 euros was invested, and in 2020, after about two years of activity, they had a turnover of 500,000 euros. rifò has launched different green ideas over the years. among them, the rifò t-shirt collection is made with 1 kg of old clothing and four plastic bottles recovered from the ocean. the t-shirts are not dyed. instead, the colour of the new regenerated yarn is obtained from old garments of the same colour in order to reduce the consumption of chemical products during the processing. in addition, a rifò t-shirt requires only 30 litres of water for production instead of the 2700 litres required to produce a normal virgin cotton t-shirt. in 2018, rifò launched its first 100% regenerated cashmere collection, an eco-friendly solution preserving all the qualities of virgin cashmere garments. thanks to an innovation introduced in the production process, the use of pesticides and chemical products is drastically reduced. the cashmere is entirely lowered and sewn without any kind of cut. in 2019, rifò launched the jeans sweater collection. it consists of sweaters made from 100% recycled denim fabrics (jeans fabric); 97% is cotton and the remaining 3% is others fibres derived from jeans seams. the colours of these sweaters is the same as that of the original jeans, completely eliminating the use of artificial dyes and chemicals during production. for the production of each "jeans sweater", only 80 litres of water are required, instead of the 3000 litres necessary for producing virgin cotton jeans, reducing water consumption by 90%, energy consumption by 77% and co2 emissions by 95%. the whole production process of these new "jeans sweater" is located within 30 km of prato, thus improving the local economy with the 1 since 2022 the company has been taken over by duedilatte switzerland sàrl. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/10383 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 44 guarantee of quality and ethics in the whole production process (www.rifo-lab.com). rifò is listed in the top 10 of responsible fashion brands in italy (luxiders, 2021). table ii: rifò rifò improve quality of life recycle use remanufactured products reduce reduce environmental impact by reducing clothing waste put in incinerators reduce/reuse no discount prices during winter and summer sales, pushing consumers to buy only the necessary clothing consumer perspectives creating consumer awareness of the real need to buy clothing items products are exclusively produced in italy source: authors own elaboration 4.2 rapanui rapanui (table iii) is a sustainable clothing brand born in 2009. the founders had the idea to create clothing, from the production to the packaging phase, without producing any kind of waste. they started to create this new venture in their garden shed. after two months, they created their first t-shirt; after one year, they launched their first collection. since their business was growing, they had to move to a larger working space. in 2011, rapanui developed the "traceability map", where every clothing production trajectory is identifiable. as their production increased, they acquired a new printing technology, the teemill platform, a real-time printing technology that allowed them to radically reduce waste. using this platform, waste is significantly reduced because t-shirts are printed only after customers express their preferred print, thus avoiding overproduction. teemill is therefore a circular production process that can modify old t-shirts by creating new ones with regenerated natural systems. access to the teemill supply chain is free for start-ups, and, until now, it has enabled tens of thousands of brands to produce tshirts in real time. in addition, all t-shirts are designed to be returned and remade when worn. the whole teemill supply chain increases material utilisation and reduces chemical and water inputs and emissions outputs, sharing the benefits with customers and other businesses. in 2013, aware of the huge waste in throw away clothing, rapanui created and implemented the "return to base" policy: once their customers are done with their rapanui's clothing, they can return items to the store so that the company can reuse them to create new garments. in 2014, to make their customers aware of sustainability issues, they designed a collection in collaboration with wwf, and in 2018, they created the ocean collection to address the plastic problem (rapanui, 2020). rapanui is listed in the top 10 ethical clothing companies (ethicalconsumer.org). http://www.rifo-lab.com/ european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/10383 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 45 table iii: rapanui rapanui improve quality of life reduce reduce negative environmental impacts reduce/recycle reduce waste reuse transform old t-shirts into new ones consumer perspectives value as a priority to offer something new, innovative and really eco-friendly source: authors own elaboration 4.3 cingomma cingomma (table iv) was established in 2010. it is an eco-friendly italian company that recycles bike tyres and air chambers. the company transforms old tires, neoprene waste and discarded advertising signs into belts, key holders and bags (tortello, 2012). in italy alone, 380,000 tons of tyres are destined for disposal every year. cingomma has chosen to recycle these materials, treating them with advanced cleaning systems and transforming them into highly desirable handmade clothing accessories that are 100 per cent made in italy. cingomma aims to combine passion, skills and talent to create a product that embodies sustainable and ethical values. fashion accessories are characterised by a progressively numbered fabric label that testifies to the uniqueness of each product. this numbering is negative in order to communicate how much material cingomma has managed to keep out of landfills since its first product. cingomma has chosen to focus production on local italian artisans in order to avoid the delocalisation of the production process and to sustain the creation of jobs in the local communities where the company operates. this mission has earned it a certification from positive causes. table iv: cingomma cingomma improve quality of life recycle recycles bike tyres and air chambers reduce environmental values embedded in their core businesses and reduces waste reduce eco-friendly attitude and practices represent an added value consumer perspectives handmade by artisans in italy added value for their customers source: authors own elaboration the company mostly uses a business-to-business commercial strategy by providing clothing items to stores. cingomma has also launched its own website, offering the possibility to purchase cingoma's products online. however, the availability of online shopping is strictly restricted to certain areas where physical shops are not available to customers (lava, 2019). european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/10383 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 46 cingomma has environmental values embedded in their core businesses and mission. these eco-friendly attitudes and practices represent an added value for their customers and other strategic stakeholders. they create advantages not only for the company but for the environment. by using old materials, cingomma is able to save on the cost of raw materials while reducing waste and co2 emissions (cingomma, 2020). the company is listed in the top 10 italian sustainable fashion brands (vestilanatura.com). 4.4 duedilatte duedilatte (table v) is currently one of the most innovative italian brands in the fashion scene. the company was created in 2013, when the founder had the idea of creating a new textile fibre starting from spent milk. she was inspired while making her morning coffee. opening the fridge only to find that her milk was expired, she thought about how it might be used. according to the italian agricultural association coldiretti, the country wastes an estimated 30 million tons of dairy each year. the company gives a second life to what most people consider waste. another advantage is that milk-based fabrics require much less water to produce: to make 1 kg of milk-based fibre requires only 1 litre of water, while the production of 1 kg of cotton requires 50 litres of water. fashion professionals love the soft and pleasant textures of milk fibres, which caress and hydrate the skin thanks to the naturally high amounts of amino acid. milk fibre is soft, 10% lighter then silk, hypo-allergic, anti-bacterial, and has a natural thermoregulatory property. moreover, it's soft to the touch, shiny, and maintains the same characteristics after numerous washings. table v: duedilatte due di latte improve quality of life innovation promotes a new material without the use of toxic materials reduce promotes a circular economy model for waste processes improve waste reduction sustainability disseminates sustainable practices consumer perspectives combining fashion, quality and well-being eco-friendly features throughout the production process source: authors own elaboration duedilatte debuted with a t-shirt collection for men, women and children. the research and development team has invested time and resources to become a reference point in the technological field for the sustainable textile sector, creating new innovative textile fibres starting from agro-food surpluses, such as cìcoffee and rice yarns. protein and vegetable fibres that arise from circular economy and environmental sustainability processes are the cornerstones of their corporate philosophy. the production is now 100 per cent chemical-free. even the dyes are from natural sources like blueberries and red onion (duedilatte, 2020). the company is listed in the top 10 italian start-ups that are changing the fashion world (balena, 2018). european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/10383 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 47 4.5 orange fiber orange fiber (table vi) is an italian company founded in 2014 that creates sustainable fabrics from citrus juice by-products that would otherwise be thrown away, representing hundreds of thousands of tons of precious resources every year. orange fiber has developed a process for extracting cellulose fibre from orange peel and transforming these fibres into biodegradable yarn. the sustainable fabric is similar to silk; they envision a new life for these materials, transforming them into refined, ethereal fabrics perfectly suited to the italian tradition of high-quality fabrics and high fashion. orange fiber was able to attract the attention of high-end fashion brands. the company's yarn was first brought to market by salvatore ferragamo, who launched a daily wear capsule collection using the fibre on earth day 2017. the developed product can be printed, coloured and packaged, so brands don't have to modify their suppliers, and it can be woven together with any other material. the company's patented technique responds to market drivers from both consumers and producers. whereas consumer demand for sustainable materials is rising, citrus juice companies face increasing burdens and challenges in properly disposing of waste. the fibre from citrus juice by-product does not require additional natural resources. instead, it reuses waste, preserving land and water, avoiding the use of fertilisers and reducing environmental impact because it does not produce additional industrial waste. this practice reduces the costs and environmental impact of pollution related to the management of citrus juice byproducts, which measure more than 700,000 tonnes in italy per year. orange fiber wants to establish themselves as the first italian mover in the segment of sustainable fabrics through the "green" production of cellulosic fabrics from renewable sources and to create a highly recognisable textile brand for its commitment to environmental protection and transparency (orange fiber, 2020). the company is in the top 10 italian start-ups that are changing the fashion world (balena, 2018). table vi: orange fiber orange fiber improve quality of life recycle created from citrus juice by-products that would otherwise be thrown away reduce doesn't produce additional industrial waste reduce reduces the environmental impact of pollution from citrus juice byproducts consumer perspectives answers the consumer demand for sustainable materials practices transparency source: authors own elaboration 4.6 ananas anam ananas anam (table vii) is a london-based company that produces pinatex, an innovative textile that offers a sustainable alternative to leather and synthetic materials. pinatex is one of those rare products of design thinking that has a significant european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/10383 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 48 environmental and welfare impact, bringing new income streams to subsistence farmers and allowing them to fully utilise their crops. the implementation of pinatex will have far-reaching societal and environmental benefits. the extraction of the fibres is done by the farming community at a plantation. the company has created an automated decorticating machine that allows farmers to utilise greater quantities of their waste leaves. when the leaves have been stripped of fibre, nothing is wasted, and the residual leaf biomass can be used as a nutrient-rich natural fertiliser or a biofuel. the fabric is entirely made from agricultural waste, without using other water resources, pesticides or fertilisers. it transforms what already exists and brings commercial value to growers thanks to the exploitation of the leaves. the company totally applies the values of the circular economy model. ananas anam combines research and innovation to enhance the well-being of the people and the planet during the entire life cycle of their product. to obtain the raw material, no additional environmental resources are necessary, and no chemicals on the list of banned substances are used in production. non-woven mesh is biodegradable. the raw material is found in the philippines, where there are large pineapple crops, and the local population is involved in the collection and the first stages of processing (ananas-anam, 2020). the company is the winner of the 2020 fashion innovation award, which is awarded every year in switzerland (loumish, 2020). table vii: ananas anam ananas anam improve quality of life support rural communities supports rural communities by working directly with agricultural cooperatives reduce enables farmers to utilise greater quantities of their waste reduce does not require other water resources, pesticides or fertilisers consumer perspectives combines research and innovation to enhance the well-being of people avoids the use of chemicals necessary for leather, which are particularly harmful to people source: authors own elaboration 5. discussion and conclusion the selected case studies were aimed at showing how sustainability represents a critical driver of growth for fashion companies and a strategic tool to improve the quality of life (papagiannis et al., 2018). the elements investigated highlight the main emerging trends in the fashion sector, underlining the growing use of the circular economy and the paradigm of the 3rs principle. in particular, in the group of three companies that base their business model on the principles of the circular economy, rifò and rapanui are the companies that, in order to improve the quality of life, adopt a business paradigm based on the 3rs. cingomma, on the other hand, mainly uses two r's (recycle and reduce). the other three companies use sustainable materials to produce fashion products. in this group orange fiber and ananas anam, by virtue of their business model, adopt the r of reduction. it therefore appears that "reduce" is the principle of the circular economy that is developing the most, followed by "recycle" and finally by "reuse". the analysis also led to the identification of the consumer's perspective. it is clear that all european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/10383 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 49 companies adopt this perspective in the production of fashion products. localised production in italy, the hand-crafting of products, attention to quality, the adoption of transparent practices, the non-use of harmful chemical elements, are all examples of strategies used with a view to focusing on the consumer. in general, however, both in response to growing regulatory pressures and in response to real needs to improve the quality of life and attention to consumer needs, fashion companies are increasingly adopting sustainable practices (gazzola, pavione and pezzetti, 2017). this will lead to the progressive transition towards forms of circular economy (dissanayake and weerasinghe, 2021). the fashion industry can therefore achieve sustainable development through the circular economy and the involvement of consumers (and stakeholders in general) (ki, chong and ha‐brookshire, 2020). the transition of the fashion industry from a traditional high-environmental impact model to a circular economy model (colombi and d'itria, 2023) shifts the focus to reusing, adjusting, renovating and recycling both materials and final products. this transition is not only necessary to address a growing demand for goods and services that contrasts with an ever-decreasing availability of natural resources, but also allows fashion companies, especially start-ups, to innovate their business models according to sustainability principles. in relation to rq1, in the circular economy model, what is normally considered "waste" can be transformed into a valuable resource by applying a new paradigm based on the so-called "three rs principle": reduce, reuse and recycle. the application of this new paradigm (rq2) not only allows fashion companies to transform waste into new resources, but also impacts the continuous desire for both product and process innovation, with important effects on the competitiveness of fashion players. besides, the application of circular economy principles in the fashion industry leads to the implementation of the un's 2030 sustainable development goals, in particular goal 12, which is related to responsible consumption and production. in addition, it reduces the risks of fluctuating costs due to the variation in the prices of raw materials. in particular, the application of the "three rs principle" encourages and drives both product and business model innovation while simultaneously encouraging the establishment of stronger and longer-lasting relationships between companies and customers based on mutual trust and the sharing of common ethical values. from an environmental point of view, the circular economy approach based on the "three rs" paradigm reduces greenhouse gas emissions, water consumption and the use of primary scarce resources while simultaneously increasing soil productivity, with an overall positive impact on both the environment and quality of life. even if awareness of the importance of the three rs has improved among both fashion companies and consumers in recent years, the application of such principles today is still only happening in small-scale projects, mostly proposed and promoted by start-up companies that are basing their competitive advantages on sustainability and new business models inspired by the circular economy model. the six selected case studies show how these companies' ability to apply the three rs principles (reduce, recycle and reuse) through product and process innovation has enabled them to achieve their vision of improving the quality of life by reducing waste, the use of resources, and the impact on the environment, all while supporting rural communities. at the same time, their ability to innovate products by offering sustainable and eco-friendly fashion items has generated value for their consumers while helping to create awareness in the market, an element capable of implementing corporate social responsibility. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/10383 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 50 the present study therefore overcomes the limitation of many studies that focus on specific aspects (material recycling or sustainable production) without considering the interconnection between the different phases of the product life cycle (geissdoerfer et al., 2017). it also considers the role of emerging paradigms in facilitating the transition towards the circular economy, often little considered in the literature (minunno et al., 2020). considering the practical and managerial implications of the paper, circular economy models open interesting perspectives for entrepreneurs in the fashion industry, going far beyond sustainability. the application of the "three rs principles", in particular, can create new market opportunities for start-ups, such as orange fiber, anas anam and duedilatte, which enhance recovered waste and transform it into new raw materials, because this practice is particularly appreciated by consumers, it creates new niche markets, allowing companies to rapidly increase their brand awareness and reputation. the main limitation of this study is the use of official information (taken from the companies' websites), without the use of interviews to enrich the research results. further development could, therefore, combine a methodology of public website analysis with semi-structured interviews with company management and, possibly, main stakeholders. furthermore, as highlighted in the methodology, only start-ups that have carried out product/process innovations and not model innovations were considered in the current study. 6. acknowledgements this publication is part of the project nodes which has received funding from the mur – m4c2 1.5 of pnrr funded by the european union nextgenerationeu (grant agreement no. ecs00000036). 7. references abdelmeguid, a., afy-shararah, m., & salonitis, k. (2022). investigating the challenges of applying the principles of the circular economy in the fashion industry: a systematic review. sustainable production and consumption, 32, 505-518. abdelmeguid, a., afy-shararah, m., & salonitis, k. (2024). mapping of the circular economy implementation challenges in the fashion industry: a fuzzy-tism analysis. circular economy and sustainability, 4(1), 585-617. ananas-anam (2020), https://www.ananas-anam.com/ andrei, a. g., gazzola, p., zbuchea, a., & alexandru, v. a. (2017). modeling socially responsible consumption and the need for uniqueness: a pls-sem approach. kybernetes, 46(8), 1325-1340. balena c. (2018), 10 startup che stanno cambiando il mondo della moda, fortune italia, https://www.fortuneita.com/2018/07/28/10-startup-che-stanno-cambiando-il-mondo-della-moda/ battle, a., ryding, d., & henninger, c. e. (2018). access-based consumption: a new business model for luxury and secondhand fashion business?. in vintage luxury fashion (pp. 29-44). palgrave macmillan, cham. bengtsson, m., alfredsson, e., cohen, m., lorek, s., & schroeder, p. (2018). transforming systems of consumption and production for achieving the sustainable development goals: moving beyond efficiency. sustainability science, 13(6), 15331547. bof mckinsey (2021), the state of fashion 2021, mckinsey & company brand-correa, l. i., & steinberger, j. k. (2022). max-neef and sustainability: theoretical, methodological and empirical contributions. international journal of sustainable development, 25(1-2), 114-131. https://www.ananas-anam.com/ european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/10383 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 51 camilleri, m. a. (2018). closing the loop for resource efficiency, sustainable consumption and production: a critical review of the circular economy. international journal of sustainable development, 21(1-4), 1-17. cascante, m. q., garcía, n. a., & fold, n. (2022). the role of external forces in the adoption of aquaculture innovations: an ex-ante case study of fish farming in colombia's southern amazonian region. technological forecasting and social change, 174, 121185. chalmer c., eder-hansen j., lehmann m., tochtermann t. and tärneberg. s.ceo agenda global fashion agenda – (2018) – pag 7-17 available at: https://www.globalfashionagenda.com/ceo-agenda-2019/ cingomma (2020), www.cingomma.com claxton, s., & kent, a. (2020). the management of sustainable fashion design strategies: an analysis of the designer's role, in journal of cleaner production, 268, 122112. colglazier, w. (2015). sustainable development agenda: 2030. science, 349(6252), 1048-1050. colombi, c., & d’itria, e. (2023). fashion digital transformation: innovating business models toward circular economy and sustainability. sustainability, 15(6), 4942. d’adamo, i., lupi, g., morone, p., & settembre-blundo, d. (2022). towards the circular economy in the fashion industry: the second-hand market as a best practice of sustainable responsibility for businesses and consumers. environmental science and pollution research, 29(31), 46620-46633. desimone, l. d., & popoff, f. (2000). eco-efficiency: the business link to sustainable development. mit press. dissanayake, d. g. k., & weerasinghe, d. (2021). towards circular economy in fashion: review of strategies, barriers and enablers. circular economy and sustainability, 1-21. dymchenko, o., gazzola, p., pezzetti, r. r., & severi, c. (2021). from food to fashion: reusing waste for promoting sustainable fashion. economia aziendale online-, 12(4), 433-446 due di latte (2020), https://antonellabellina.wixsite.com/duedilatte eisenhardt, k. m. (1989). building theories from case study research. academy of management review, 14(4), 532-550. ethical consumer (2021), https://www.ethicalconsumer.org/fashion-clothing/top-10-ethical-clothing-companies european environment agency (2019), https://www.eea.europa.eu/publications/textiles-in-europes-circular-economy european parliament (2023), https://www.europarl.europa.eu/topics/it/article/20151201sto05603/economia-circolaredefinizione-importanza-e-vantaggi galatti, l. g., & baruque-ramos, j. (2022). circular economy indicators for measuring social innovation in the brazilian textile and fashion industry. journal of cleaner production, 363, 132485. gasper, d., shah, a., & tankha, s. (2019). the framing of sustainable consumption and production in sdg 12. global policy, 10, 83-95. gazzola, p., pavione, e., & pezzetti, r. (2017, february). sustainable consumption in the luxury industry: towards a new paradigm in china's high-end demand. in proceedings of the 2nd czech-china scientific conference 2016. intechopen. gazzola, p. (2018). behind the sharing economy: innovation and dynamic capability. in knowledge management in the sharing economy (pp. 75-94). springer, cham. gazzola, p., pavione, e., pezzetti, r., & grechi, d. (2020). trends in the fashion industry. the perception of sustainability and circular economy: a gender/generation quantitative approach. sustainability, 12(7), 2809. gazzola, p., pezzetti, r., amelio, s., & grechi, d. (2020b). non-financial information disclosure in italian public interest companies: a sustainability reporting perspective. sustainability, 12(15), 6063. http://www.cingomma.com/ https://antonellabellina.wixsite.com/duedilatte https://www.ethicalconsumer.org/fashion-clothing/top-10-ethical-clothing-companies https://www.eea.europa.eu/publications/textiles-in-europes-circular-economy https://www.europarl.europa.eu/topics/it/article/20151201sto05603/economia-circolare-definizione-importanza-e-vantaggi https://www.europarl.europa.eu/topics/it/article/20151201sto05603/economia-circolare-definizione-importanza-e-vantaggi european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/10383 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 52 gazzola, p., vătămănescu, e. m., andrei, a. g., & marrapodi, c. (2019). users' motivations to participate in the sharing economy: moving from profits toward sustainable development. corporate social responsibility and environmental management, 26(4), 741-751. geissdoerfer, m., savaget, p., bocken, n. m., & hultink, e. j. (2017). the circular economy–a new sustainability paradigm?. journal of cleaner production, 143, 757-768. gioia, d. a., corley, k. g., & hamilton, a. l. (2013). seeking qualitative rigor in inductive research: notes on the gioia methodology. organizational research methods, 16(1), 15-31. hahn, t., & figge, f. (2011). beyond the bounded instrumentality in current corporate sustainability research: toward an inclusive notion of profitability. journal of business ethics, 104(3), 325-345. henry, m., bauwens, t., hekkert, m., & kirchherr, j. (2020). a typology of circular start-ups: an analysis of 128 circular business models. journal of cleaner production, 245, 118528. hu, s., henninger, c. e., boardman, r., & ryding, d. (2019). challenging current fashion business models: entrepreneurship through access-based consumption in the second-hand luxury garment sector within a circular economy. in sustainable luxury (pp. 39-54). springer, singapore. hvass, k. k., & pedersen, e. r. g. (2019). toward circular economy of fashion. journal of fashion marketing and management: an international journal. jia, f., yin, s., chen, l., & chen, x. (2020). the circular economy in the textile and apparel industry: a systematic literature review. journal of cleaner production, 259, 120728. kemp, r., parto, s., & gibson, r. b. (2005). governance for sustainable development: moving from theory to practice. international journal of sustainable development, 8(1-2), 12-30. ki, c. w., chong, s. m., & ha‐brookshire, j. e. (2020). how fashion can achieve sustainable development through a circular economy and stakeholder engagement: a systematic literature review, in corporate social responsibility and environmental management, 27(6), 2401-2424. kirchherr, j., piscicelli, l., bour, r., kostense-smit, e., muller, j., huibrechtse-truijens, a., & hekkert, m. (2018). barriers to the circular economy: evidence from the european union (eu). ecological economics, 150, 264-272. lacy, p., & rutqvist, j. (2016). waste to wealth: the circular economy advantage. springer. lanzalonga, f., marseglia, r., irace, a., & biancone, p. p. (2024). the application of artificial intelligence in waste management: understanding the potential of data-driven approaches for the circular economy paradigm. management decision. lava p. c., “cingomma. un nuovo “modo per fare moda”, quando il riciclo fa tendenza” 9thapril 2019, alessandria today leonas, k. k. (2017). the use of recycled fibers in fashion and home products. in textiles and clothing sustainability (pp. 5577). springer, singapore. loumish (2020), https://awards.loomish.ch/?p=3096 luxiders (2021), https://luxiders.com/10-responsible-fashion-brands-made-italy/ mahanty, s., & domenech, t. (2024). working along the value chain for circular economy transitions in fashion textiles: a participatory framework. journal of cleaner production, 465, 142627. manzini e. (2008), design para inovação social e sustentabilidade comunidades criativas, organizações colaborativas e novas redes projetuais/ ezio manzini; [coordenação de tradução carla cipolla; equipe elisa spampinato, aline lys silva]. rio de janeiro: e-papers, 2008 –16 massaro, m., dumay, j., & bagnoli, c. (2019). transparency and the rhetorical use of citations to robert yin in case study research. meditari accountancy research, 27(1), 44-71. https://awards.loomish.ch/?p=3096 https://luxiders.com/10-responsible-fashion-brands-made-italy/ european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/10383 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 53 mcdonough w., braungart m (2013), cradle to cradle: criar e reciclar ilimitadamente [translatedtoportugueseby frederico bonaldo].são paulo: edtora g. gili, 2013 – 8 merli, r., preziosi, m., & acampora, a. (2018). how do scholars approach the circular economy? a systematic literature review. journal of cleaner production, 178, 703-722. minunno, r., o'grady, t., morrison, g. m., & gruner, r. l. (2020). exploring environmental benefits of reuse and recycle practices: a circular economy case study of a modular building. resources, conservation and recycling, 160, 104855. mishra, s., jain, s., & malhotra, g. (2021). the anatomy of circular economy transition in the fashion industry. social responsibility journal, 17(4), 524-542. nayak, r., jajpura, l., & khandual, a. (2023). traditional fibres for fashion and textiles: associated problems and future sustainable fibres. in sustainable fibres for fashion and textile manufacturing (pp. 3-25). woodhead publishing. niinimäki, k. (2017). fashion in a circular economy. in sustainability in fashion (pp. 151-169). palgrave macmillan, cham. orange fiber (2020), http://orangefiber.it/ papagiannis, f., gazzola, p., burak, o., & pokutsa, i. (2018). overhauls in water supply systems in ukraine: a hydro-economic model of socially responsible planning and cost management, in journal of cleaner production, 183, 358-369. papagiannis, f., gazzola, p., burak, o., & pokutsa, i. (2021). a european household waste management approach: intelligently clean ukraine. journal of environmental management, 294, 113015. papamichael, i., chatziparaskeva, g., voukkali, i., navarro pedreno, j., jeguirim, m., & zorpas, a. a. (2023). the perception of circular economy in the framework of fashion industry. waste management & research, 41(2), 251-263. pavione, e., & pezzetti, r. (2015). responsible and sustainable luxury in the global market: new emerging strategies in the luxury sector. in strategica. international academic conference: local versus global (pp. 73-80). pedersen, e. r. g., earley, r., & andersen, k. r. (2019). from singular to plural: exploring organisational complexities and circular business model design, in journal of fashion marketing and management: an international journal, 23(3), 308-326. peleg mizrachi, m., & tal, a. (2022). regulation for promoting sustainable, fair and circular fashion. sustainability, 14(1), 502. pessôa, c., araújo, k., & arruda, a. (2015). discussing consumption and sustainability in clothing production: a case study of a company in recife/br. procedia manufacturing, 3, 6175-6182. pollifroni, m. (2012). environmental sustainability and social responsibility: a theoretical proposal for an accounting evaluation. economia aziendale online, 2(4), 345-354. prieto-sandoval, v., jaca, c., & ormazabal, m. (2018). towards a consensus on the circular economy. journal of cleaner production, 179, 605-615. rapanui (2020), https://rapanuiclothing.com/ rifò (2020), https://www.rifo-lab.com/ sala, s., & castellani, v. (2019). the consumer footprint: monitoring sustainable development goal 12 with process-based life cycle assessment. journal of cleaner production, 240, 118050. schroeder, p., anggraeni, k., & weber, u. (2019). the relevance of circular economy practices to the sustainable development goals. journal of industrial ecology, 23(1), 77-95. sehnem, s., troiani, l., lara, a. c., guerreiro crizel, m., carvalho, l., & rodrigues, v. p. (2024). sustainable fashion: challenges and barriers for advancing the circular economy. environment, development and sustainability, 26(2), 4097-4118. shou, m., & domenech, t. (2022). integrating lca and blockchain technology to promote circular fashion–a case study of leather handbags. journal of cleaner production, 373, 133557. http://orangefiber.it/ https://rapanuiclothing.com/ https://www.rifo-lab.com/ european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/10383 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 54 symbola foundation (2021). l’economia circolare in italia per il next generation eu. https://symbola.net/ricerca/leconomiacircolare-in-italia-per-il-next-generation-eu/ thakker, a. m., & sun, d. (2023). sustainable development goals for textiles and fashion. environmental science and pollution research, 30(46), 101989-102009. todeschini, b. v., cortimiglia, m. n., callegaro-de-menezes, d., & ghezzi, a. (2017). innovative and sustainable business models in the fashion industry: entrepreneurial drivers, opportunities, and challenges. business horizons, 60(6), 759-770. tortello l. (2012), e dai copertoni distrutti nascono le cinture torino bike, 3rdjuly 2012, eco dalle città vătămănescu, e. m., dabija, d. c., gazzola, p., cegarro-navarro, j. g., & buzzi, t. (2021). before and after the outbreak of covid-19: linking fashion companies' corporate social responsibility approach to consumers' demand for sustainable products. journal of cleaner production, 321, 128945. velozo valenga, a. c., roberto stefani, s., cagica carvalho, l. m., & luiz chiusoli, c. (2023). the influence of green fashion products on the achievement of the 12 sustainable development goals for masters and doctoral students. brazilian journal of management/revista de administração da ufsm, 16(1). vestialanatura.com (2021), https://www.vestilanatura.com/top-10-italian-sustainable-fashion-brands/ zbuchea, a., petropoulos, s., & partyka, b. (2018). nonprofit organizations and the sharing economy: an exploratory study of the umbrella organizations. in knowledge management in the sharing economy (pp. 95-114). springer, cham. https://symbola.net/ricerca/leconomia-circolare-in-italia-per-il-next-generation-eu/ https://symbola.net/ricerca/leconomia-circolare-in-italia-per-il-next-generation-eu/ https://www.vestilanatura.com/top-10-italian-sustainable-fashion-brands/ european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/11712 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 14 global impact index as a tool for measuring social inclusion: a case study of arcobaleno social cooperative daniel iannaci1*, roberto gambassi2, giovanni iozzi3, giovanni porquier4 1 arcobaleno cooperativa sociale, via paolo veronese, 202 10148, turin (italy) d.iannaci@cooparcobaleno.net *contact author orcid https://orcid.org/0000-0002-4890-5963 2microcosmos srl – v. madonna del buonconsiglio, 27 53100, siena (italy) roberto@microcosmos.si 3 arcobaleno cooperativa sociale, via paolo veronese, 202 10148, turin (italy) g.iozzi@cooparcobaleno.net 4 arcobaleno cooperativa sociale, via paolo veronese, 202 10148, turin (italy) g.porquier@cooparcobaleno.net received: 06/02/2025 accepted for publication: 26/03/2025 published: 15/04/2025 abstract assessment of social impact has become a strategic priority for social cooperatives in response to the growing need for transparency and accountability. however, traditional evaluation models, often developed for for-profit companies, fail to capture the complexity and specificity of organisations that integrate social, economic, and environmental missions. this study presents the global impact index (gii italian version igi), an evaluation model designed to meet the needs of type b social cooperatives, with a particular focus on the reality of arcobaleno social cooperative. gii is structured around three fundamental dimensions: environmental, managerial, and social. the environmental dimension uses innovative tools such as integrated well-being performance (iwp italian version pib) and integrated environmental variation (iev – italian version vai) to analyse cooperative's activities' contribution to urban well-being and long-term sustainability. the managerial dimension examines operational sustainability, the relationship between productivity and social inclusion, and workforce dynamics, highlighting how cooperative's social mission affects economic efficiency. finally, the social dimension explores well-being and satisfaction of worker-members, emphasising cooperative's impact on quality of life and social integration. this study's results demonstrate that gii is an effective tool for measuring, monitoring, and improving the performance of social cooperatives. integrating three dimensions provides a holistic view of impact produced, offering a basis for targeted strategic decisions and stakeholder engagement. although model has some limitations, such as need for further testing in different contexts, it represents a replicable and scalable approach for third sector. gii makes a significant contribution to literature on impact assessment and opens new perspectives for sustainability and social inclusion. keywords: social impact assessment, social cooperatives, global impact index, sustainability, inclusion 15 1. introduction in the context of third sector and social cooperatives, social impact assessment has become increasingly relevant, responding to a growing need for transparency and accountability towards stakeholders (iannaci, 2020). however, many traditional impact measurement metrics were developed for for-profit companies and do not adequately address specific characteristics of social cooperatives, whose value is not exclusively tied to financial metrics. to address this gap, arcobaleno social cooperative type b (hereinafter referred to as "arcobaleno") has developed global impact index (gii italian version igi), an innovative evaluation tool designed to reflect complexity and social mission of similar legal entities. global impact index was specifically designed to measure and enhance this type of contribution, incorporating three fundamental dimensions: 1. environmental dimension: reflects urban context in which cooperative operates, highlighting how activities impact environment and community well-being. 2. managerial dimension: evaluates internal management and cooperative's economic sustainability, with a particular focus on the relationship between productivity and social inclusion. 3. social dimension: represents core of generated impact, analysing well-being and satisfaction of worker-members and their sense of belonging to organisation. this tripartite analysis allows us to move beyond traditional financial metrics, offering a holistic view of impact of a social cooperative (biancone et al., 2018b; borzaga & depedri, 2002; repubblica italiana, 1991). goal of gii is not to replace existing models but to integrate esg (environmental, social, governance) metrics, sdgs (sustainable development goals), and bes (equitable and sustainable well-being) with a sector-specific perspective, recognising importance of parameters such as intentionality and additionality of social intervention rq: how can an integrated impact index, which considers specificities of work integration social cooperatives, effectively measure economic, social, and environmental value produced by these cooperatives and offer a replicable tool for third sector? this paper explores how global impact index is structured around three dimensions—urban context (environmental dimension), personnel management (managerial dimension), and members' perception (social dimension). by comparing these areas, an overall value is determined, aimed at improving interpretation of social impact and identifying opportunities to increase value generated through presentation of results of two comparative analyses conducted, first between 2019 and 2020, and second in 2023-2024 biennium. to ensure clarity and coherence, this article is structured as follows: • section 2 presents theoretical framework, discussing existing impact measurement models and their limitations. • section 3 outlines methodological approach adopted in this study, including data collection and analysis methods. • section 4 presents results of study, highlighting key findings related to application of gii. • section 5 discusses implications of findings, linking them to existing literature and managerial applications. • section 6 concludes with a summary of key insights, limitations of study, and recommendations for future research development. by streamlining transition from general challenges to specific contribution of gii, this introduction provides a clearer and more concise foundation for study. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/11712 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 16 2. theoretical framework 2.1 social impact social impacts are social and environmental changes created by activities and investments (arvidson et al., 2010, 2013; banke-thomas et al., 2015; epstein & yuthas, 2014, 2017; faraudello et al., 2020; gazzola et al., 2024; millar & hall, 2013). these impacts include issues such as equality, livelihoods, health, food security, poverty, safety, and justice. environmental impacts cover areas such as conservation, energy use, waste, environmental health, resource depletion, and climate change. term "social impacts" refers to both social and environmental changes—positive and negative, intended and unintended—that result from investments (biancone et al., 2019a; calderini et al., 2018a, 2018b; ebrahim et al., 2014, 2014; epstein & yuthas, 2017; murdock, 2010). this includes organisations whose social impact is exogenous through production of goods and services and those whose impact is endogenous through organisational structures and processes (biancone et al., 2019a; bonilla-alicea & fu, 2019; faraudello et al., 2020; nyssens, 2007). 2.2 social impact measurement currently, there is no standard unit for social impact, nor any agreed-upon methodology or accounting regulation to acquire and report it (alijani & karyotis, 2019; nicholls, 2009; nicholls et al., 2015; rawhouser et al., 2019; secinaro et al., 2021). this is widely seen as a barrier to future development of social finance market as it makes comparative analysis of various value propositions and investments impossible. however, there have been some advances towards creating a set of agreed-upon impact accounting systems for social finance. initiatives include integrated esg accounting; global reporting initiative (gri); sustainable accounting standards board (sasb); impact reporting and investment standards (iris) of global impact investing network, and european union's social impact standard. in uk, cabinet office has supported launch of "inspiring impact," a decade-long project aimed at building a coordinated and consistent approach to impact measurement. this included commitment to explore broader use of sroi (social return on investment) methodology, which represents closest thing to an industry standard currently for reporting social impact at project or organisational level. global impact investing ratings system (giirs) developed by b lab, u.s. organisation behind b-corp certification, represents a leading example of an approach to creating standardised ratings and reporting social impact. giirs rating system uses iris metrics combined with additional criteria to achieve an overall assessment of company or fund, as well as targeted subcategories in governance, workers, community, environment, and socially and environmentally focused activities models. as of 2014, there were over 500 companies rated by giirs in 39 countries, each assessed up to a maximum of 200 points based on criteria ranging from commitment to a social mission and land use to how they treat their workers and communities in which they operate (nicholls et al., 2015). a common issue is defining success in terms of what organisation produces rather than impacts that result. it is essential to focus on impacts for following reasons: actions do not always have intended outcomes, instincts are not always correct, and without understanding impacts, it is difficult to improve them (epstein & yuthas, 2017). social impact is a primary goal of social cooperatives' activities; however, these organisations and individuals often are unclear on how to measure and thus improve their impact. while designing and measuring financial outcomes is common, most organisations find measuring social impact much more european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/11712 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 17 challenging. but demands for more thorough and comprehensive analysis of impacts are rapidly increasing (epstein & yuthas, 2017). 2.3 integrated well-being performance (iwp) reconstruction of integrated well-being performance (iwp italian version pib) (gambassi & microcosmos, 2012; polci & gambassi, 2000, 2018) stems from definition of sustainable development contained in brundtland report by world commission on environment and development (1987). since then, numerous research methodologies have been dedicated to measuring well-being of individuals and societies. first signs of a significant inability of income to describe variability of real well-being already emerged during 1968 u.s. presidential campaign when robert kennedy delivered a speech at university of kansas in which he pronounced "de profundis" of gdp, stating that it measures "everything except that which makes life worthwhile." in that vision, happiness, awareness, lifestyle, dignity, and elements related to social and environmental "costs" gained prominence. air pollution, deterioration of people's health and emergence of new diseases, destruction of planet's resources, rush to purchase unnecessary products, and new forms of social distrust and inequality are just some aspects that gdp does not monetise among items of "wealth," ignoring their value. since 1968, many methodological approaches to measuring well-being have been developed. human development index (hdi) is first and most cited, while ecological footprint has been pivotal for environmental shift it proposes, positioning it as a central element in planning development actions and policies. european commission has also committed to "beyond gdp, measuring progress, true wealth, and well-being of nations" work plan to promote use and development of indicators that, alongside gdp, are more inclusive of environmental and social aspects of progress, with the aim of fostering sharing of information on latest initiatives and ongoing work. in italy, cultural debate has led to bes (equitable and sustainable well-being) by istat-cnel, which in 2012 began to raise awareness among italians of need to go "beyond gdp," starting from adoption of commitments and objectives of good governance. 2.4 limitations of approaches and attempt of their overcoming these approaches acknowledge difficulties in attributing value to intangible elements that cannot be ascribed to measurable quantities, such as natural resources. when challenge of measurement is combined with their essential role in describing concrete dynamics of territorial development, it becomes clear why concepts of quality of life, well-being, and human development have evolved in multifaceted ways. indeed, all approaches have encountered or demonstrated difficulties along way. however, it is not an overstatement to categorise these challenges into three main areas of analysis: 1. a tendency to focus on specific areas (recently on environmental aspects, previously on quality of life) rather than integrating these areas holistically. 2. a limited ability to synthesise indicators, leading to more complex interpretations when comparing different territories and across time. 3. enduring dilemma of balancing subjective and objective indicators and preference for working with qualitative data among latter. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/11712 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 18 all approaches agree that well-being is a concept more complex than a linear index: three components of sustainability—environmental, social, and economic—are not elements to be mathematically summed but rather aspects of same reality. for optimal territorial conditions, these must be perfectly balanced, with limited variability and equilibrium among them. this equilibrium thus represents a new frontier for objectives of development models. it conceives goal not as a growing function, linear model, or equation but as a system of causal links among variables, aspects, and axes—a system of correlations aiming to synthesise and adapt the most general elements of quality of life to concept of integrated well-being. model discussed here is a system that evaluates effectiveness of variables, enables comparisons among them, verifies extent to which indicators from one axis are connected to those from another, determines factors explaining balance itself, identifies deviations from optimal situation (which is not uniform across all systems), and provides the most efficient guidelines for pursuing improvements. the objective of this methodological proposal is to identify and understand interconnections among many factors that influence well-being, as these are fundamental when analysing policy options. it is global approach, more than specific indices, that identifies sectors where actions can most effectively improve well-being of territories under review. transforming an aspect that requires careful attention—such as compliance with well-validated national and international procedures—into added value has been true core of this approach. this opportunity has been facilitated by non-arbitrary selection of indicators, their treatment to outline a common direction among homogeneous groups, independence of these groups from one another, and their basis in aspects related to resource endowments, attitude measurements, people's sensitivities, adoption of good practices, pollution production rates, and distinct visions for quality and quantity of well-being. 2.5 social cooperatives type b in integral sustainability: a qualitative esg-oriented analysis promotion of integral sustainability represents a central element in mission of social cooperatives. through a retrospective analysis based on esg metrics (environmental, social, governance), it can be confirmed that this research has always stood out for its transparency, including in area of sustainability. however, it is recognised that applicability of these new frameworks may encounter some limitations in different contexts. for this reason, focus has been on fundamental concept underlying esg evaluation (clément et al., 2023; edmans, 2023; lanzalonga et al., 2024; li et al., 2021; secinaro et al., 2023; tsang et al., 2023), making it replicable rather than limiting it to predefined indicators from literature. three esg pillars represent shared language of sustainability. these pillars allow for measurement of an organisation's environmental, social, and governance performance using standardised and widely accepted parameters. in context of social cooperatives, these dimensions are translated as follows: • environmental dimension [e]: this pillar includes all information related to environmental impact of activities and measures adopted to reduce it. • social dimension [s]: focus here is on members' perceptions of cooperative's contribution to improving their living conditions and overall quality of work environment. • governance dimension [g]: this pillar concerns internal governance and decision-making processes, ensuring that activities are managed effectively, efficiently, and in compliance with ethical and regulatory principles. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/11712 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 19 this shared language is particularly important in financial contexts and national, european, and international regulatory dynamics. therefore, an approach has been specifically developed to be replicable by all cooperatives, rather than relying solely on a predetermined model. goal has been to overcome difficulty of quantitatively measuring well-being in a way that objectively and collectively represents phenomenon through synthetic indicators, appropriately weighing its multiple aspects. specifically, contribution of this methodological proposal aims to measure phenomenon by distinguishing it into specific aspects, peculiar characteristics, and identifying groups that allow for rigorous statistical representation. this representation serves to synthesise entire phenomenon through a one-dimensional index derived from quantification of various aspects, potentially interpreted through causal analysis. aware of importance of "agreement on most important dimensions," the most critical phase of entire process has been identification and selection of indicators useful for defining well-being in our country and in major italian cities under review. two main difficulties were encountered during this process: first, inability to work with subjective variables from sample surveys; second, fact that primary focus of our application is italian cities— municipalities—rather than entire national territory. this detail limits availability of some indicators, not because they are not measured at local level, but due to real practical constraints. figure 1. mapping study source: authors’ elaboration european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/11712 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 20 nevertheless, we believe we have arrived at an excellent solution, represented by eight categories, many of which are fully aligned with bes guidelines and other national-scale research approaches, all wellaligned with sarkozy commission's recommendations from choice of indicators onward. these eight categories have proven reliable in accurately describing magnitudes they are meant to measure. in addition to scientific validity of selected indicators and adherence to classification of categories used by other approaches, they have been subjected to appropriate homogeneity and reliability tests (cronbach's alpha). possibility of assigning "independent" weights to various indicators, free from subjective biases, and of comparing system quantitatively opens interesting prospects for construction of alternative measurements to gdp. this could facilitate territorial policy strategies aimed at improving well-being levels and optimising targeted actions on specific, clearly identifiable socio-economic and environmental aspects. case study analysed is a social cooperative operating in environmental sector, specifically in waste recycling, in turin area, italy. 3. methodology this study employs a systematic approach (corvo et al., 2021) to assess impact of social cooperatives, integrating both qualitative and quantitative methods. methodology was structured to ensure validity, replicability, and transparency, addressing limitations of traditional impact assessment models (eisenhardt, 1989; lincoln & denzin, 2000). 3.1 research design and approach a longitudinal and explanatory case study (yin, 2017) was adopted to evaluate application of global impact index (gii) in arcobaleno, a type b social cooperative based in turin (porquier et al., 2010). case study method was chosen to provide in-depth insights into practical implementation of gii, allowing for an extensive evaluation of its effectiveness in measuring social, environmental, and managerial impact. to ensure methodological rigor, study applied data triangulation by combining: primary data (interviews, surveys, direct observations); secondary data (financial reports, official records, and publicly available environmental data); comparative analysis with similar organisations to contextualise findings. by integrating multiple data sources, study enhances credibility and reliability (leonard-barton, 1990), minimising bias in data interpretation (stake, 1995; yin, 2017). 3.2 data collection process data collection was carried out through three primary methods: • semi-structured interviews: conducted with key stakeholders, cooperative members and management; aimed to gather insights into organizational governance, economic sustainability, and social mission effectiveness; interviews were recorded, transcribed, and analysed using thematic coding techniques. • surveys and questionnaires: a structured questionnaire was administered to a representative sample of arcobaleno's worker-members; key themes included quality of life, job satisfaction, and perceived impact of cooperative initiatives; responses were analysed using descriptive statistics and correlation analysis to assess relationships between social, environmental, and managerial indicators. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/11712 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 21 • document and financial analysis: reviewed annual financial reports, employment records, and sustainability statements from arcobaleno; cross-checked internal documentation with external data sources, including municipal and regional environmental reports. the sample selection was designed to maximise representativeness, ensuring inclusion of members across different roles, seniority levels, and socio-economic backgrounds. potential biases, such as self-selection bias in survey responses, were addressed by random sampling and ensuring anonymity. 3.3 data analysis techniques to interpret collected data, study employed a mixed-method approach, combining: • thematic analysis: applied to qualitative data from interviews to identify recurring patterns and key themes (braun & clarke, 2006). • factor analysis: used to identify underlying relationships within survey responses, particularly between worker satisfaction, inclusion, and productivity. • comparative benchmarking: positioning arcobaleno's impact metrics against similar social cooperatives in italy and europe, providing external validation of gii model. the validity of findings was reinforced through cross-validation across multiple data sources. reliability was ensured by applying standardised data collection protocols and using multiple coders for qualitative analysis. 3.4 justification of case selection arcobaleno was selected as case study due to: • its long-standing history as one of italy's leading type b social cooperatives. • its diverse workforce, which includes individuals from disadvantaged backgrounds. • its established focus on environmental sustainability, work integration, and governance innovation. this selection ensures that findings can be generalised to other social cooperatives, offering practical insights for broader applications of gii. 3.5 ethical considerations • all participants provided informed consent, ensuring voluntary participation. • confidentiality was maintained by anonymising personal data in interviews and survey responses. • study adhered to ethical research guidelines, following best practices in social impact research. 4. results with aim of addressing essential questions such as: do we objectively perceive social cooperative? does it achieve its mission objectives? does social cooperative create positive or negative changes for direct stakeholders? does social cooperative generate social value? founded in 1992 in turin, arcobaleno is one of the most important work integration social cooperatives in italy, with nearly 300 worker-members, many of whom come from disadvantaged backgrounds. cooperative was born from experience of abele group, a non-profit organisation from turin with a long history of social commitment. arcobaleno operates primarily in field of waste collection and european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/11712 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 22 environmental services but stands out for its inclusive approach and commitment to creating social value. cooperative's mission is to provide job opportunities to vulnerable people while contributing to environmental sustainability and social cohesion of local community. creation of global impact index (gii) is result of an articulated methodology based on a combination of qualitative and quantitative analyses, using principles from existing frameworks (bes, sdg, esg) adapted to context of social cooperatives. development process of gii has been characterised by a model based on three key dimensions—environmental, managerial, and social—each representing critical aspects for work integration social cooperatives like arcobaleno. 4.1 structure of global impact index global impact index is structured as follows: a. environmental dimension environmental dimension of gii focuses on interaction between cooperative and urban context, using two main indicators to provide an accurate assessment: integrated well-being performance (iwp) and integrated environmental variation (ievitalian version vai). while iwp offers a benchmark for turin in context of italy's ten largest cities in terms of quality of life and well-being, iev identifies long-term environmental actions with the greatest impact. • integrated well-being performance (iwp): this indicator analyses eight dimensions— demography, wealth, health, tourism, economy, innovation and quality production, productive specialisation, and environment. iwp provides a snapshot of the most urgent environmental and social challenges faced by city, allowing comparisons with other realities, such as population decline, demographic aging, and income concentration. • integrated environmental variation (iev): iev, integrated with iwp, identifies and prioritises the most effective environmental actions for long-term performance. it allows for analysis of how specific interventions, such as increasing recycling rates, reducing particulate emissions, and enhancing public transport, contribute to improving environmental quality and overall well-being. iev analysis thus highlights which strategic levers can be used to achieve more effective environmental results. this integration between iwp and iev enables cooperative to better orient future strategic choices in terms of sustainability and to respond more precisely to needs of territory. thanks to stimulus from law 163/2016, which introduced bes (equitable and sustainable well-being) index to assess quality of life and impact of public policies on fundamental social dimensions—thus surpassing traditional gdp as a one-dimensional economic measure—this original approach seeks to integrate rather than replace existing valuable databases and reports, such as those from il sole 24 ore. goal is not to change description of what already exists but to approach results with a new method that provides greater depth and additional insights. key features of new approach: • analysis of explanatory factors: it is not limited to constructing rankings or estimates but focuses on evaluating contribution of explanatory factors. it moves from designing simple models to analysing transformations of these factors, carefully evaluating causal links between indicators and their impacts. • innovative iwp methodology: it examines the most effective levers for revitalising territories through this methodology, offering an integrated approach to well-being assessment. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/11712 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 23 • municipal-level data base: analysis is based on municipal rather than provincial data, allowing for a more detailed and personalised view of situation. this approach makes survey potentially replicable for every italian municipality, providing a comprehensive picture of local dynamics. • variability explored through a wide range of indicators: nearly 200 indicators are used, collected in a specific municipal database. these data are focused on comparing turin among italy's ten largest cities, allowing identification of indicators most correlated with index itself and those that positively influence dynamics of iwp and territorial well-being. cas observed, qualifying aspects of iwp index are primarily related to municipal scale of indicators1 and, secondly, to ability to trace internal relationships among them and to weigh their impact on determining positioning. through iwp, main objectives are outlined, providing a concrete and accurate framework of what it means to compete on a national level. it clarifies priorities, factors affecting competitiveness, and measures effectiveness of actions taken to improve positioning and integrated performance. final estimates are not just rankings and, above all, are not limited to current situation of city but also consider its development potential. in this context, it is not so much about taking a snapshot of city but rather highlighting elements that could make it competitive in facing future. originality of "integrated well-being" concept lies in systemic approach (nearly 200 indicators grouped into 8 main categories: demography, innovation and quality production, economy, productive specialization, tourism, wealth, health, environment). the choice of these indicators allows for analysis of characteristics of turin and other cities, starting from demographic data of their inhabitants to level of services provided (social and health assistance, services for citizens and businesses, innovation) and productive dynamism (productive system and specialisation, tourism, economy, and wealth): a single concept that synthesises quality of widespread territorial services and ability to compete for development consistent with its resources and identity2 in summary, outcome is a score that aims to concretely express integrated performance of well-being—a score simplified and always brought back to a scale from 0 to 100, representing city's competitiveness and resilience, inspired by already utilised bes, equitable and sustainable well-being, and kennedy's holistic vision of beyond-income. not all information is available for all 8,000 municipalities in italy. many indicators cover provincial capitals, 105 cities where nearly a third of population lives, while others allow for analysis of major italian cities. common data base remains istat, with some specific sections providing data at an appropriate territorial scale3. b. managerial dimension in this dimension, focus is on operational efficiency and personnel management. indicators such as productivity per worker-member and ratio between full-time and part-time employees have been selected, taking into account specific factors such as inclusion of vulnerable individuals. 1 gli studi precedentemente riportati si riferiscono alla scala provinciale 2 se pure 200 indicatori possono sembrare fin troppi, di fatto non possono essere considerati esaustivi nella descrizione di una realtà tanto complessa; oltre a ciò, dobbiamo tenere presenti i limiti di disponibilità dei dati allorquando si lavora su scala comunale. 3 demo.istat.it e dati.istat.it/; esploradati.istat.it/databrowser/#/ ; “a misura di comune”, con una dinamica dei dati dal 2014 al 2020; ”atlante statistico dei comuni”; gli “indicatori territoriali per le politiche di sviluppo” 2014-2020 con 327 indicatori a livello territoriale european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/11712 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 24 statistical analysis technique used is factor analysis through principal components. this technique ensures strong internal cohesion and allows for construction of indicators capable of functioning as comparisons between territories and indicating connections with individual conditioning variables. "principal components" technique represents ideal method for identifying factors (i.e., combinations of interconnected indicators) capable of expressing level of quality and integrated well-being of cities— essentially, global state of art—before linear regression models attempt to verify effectiveness of interventions towards specific parameters. this dimension can highlight significant dynamics that reflect organisation's inclusive and social mission while considering relevant economic implications. • variation in production per worker-member from an economic perspective, this phenomenon indicates business efficiency, characterised by changes in costs, especially related to personnel, which must be compared to revenue value, representing a managerial challenge. however, from a social perspective, this trend can be interpreted differently: it represents success of cooperative's mission, which focuses on social inclusion rather than profit maximisation. primary focus is on creating job opportunities for disadvantaged people, even at expense of individual productivity. • decrease in incidence of disadvantaged people reduction or increase in indicator related to disadvantaged individuals within cooperative can be attributed to success of inclusive mission. with years of service, many workers overcome their initial disadvantaged conditions, remaining actively employed within cooperative. this is a positive result, although cooperative faces challenges related to identifying and integrating new vulnerable individuals. for example, changes in dynamics related to substance abuse—with an increasing incidence among young people of school age—require adapting mission, which in some cases may focus more on educational support rather than direct employment. additionally, some non-certified vulnerabilities do not fall within official parameters but still represent segments of vulnerable population that cooperative is committed to supporting. these data underscore how economic and social dynamics of a work integration social cooperative are closely intertwined. while there are challenges related to economic sustainability, pursuit of social mission remains at core of activities, contributing to transforming situations of vulnerability into paths of growth and inclusion. c. social dimension this is the most significant element within gii, analysing perception of well-being and satisfaction among workers, as well as their level of integration (cevenini et al., 2012). to this end, a questionnaire was administered to a representative sample of worker-members to measure aspects such as quality of life, sense of belonging, and emotional stability. questionnaire was developed after several tests to estimate its internal consistency, targeting a sample of cooperative worker-members based on gender, age, citizenship, educational qualifications, type of contract, years of seniority, membership status, role, and potential employment under law 381 (disadvantaged individuals). the large number of sampling variables and complex yet rewarding choice of working with a proportional quota distribution between population and sample were made possible using specific sampling software. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/11712 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 25 impact measurement primarily focuses on relationship between enterprise and society. in case of work integration social cooperatives, it becomes essential to also measure effects produced on vulnerable segment of population to which these cooperatives direct their efforts for full reintegration into civil life. while other entities in business world may also engage with this particular population segment, specificity of work integration cooperatives is that this objective forms core of their mission. therefore, success of enterprise is not measured by its ability to generate profits but by its ability to produce "social utility," which derives directly from success of reintegration project and cooperative's capacity to maintain disadvantaged individuals within civil consortium as workers with full citizenship rights and restored dignity (iannaci, 2021). this specificity defines these organisations, each with targeted strategies and projects to balance goal of supporting their members while addressing challenges of market from which they cannot withdraw. following section highlights effects on social body and, where possible, provides an initial estimate of cooperative's impact. questionnaire in addition to sections aimed at outlining a synthetic profile of members, questionnaire also requested evaluations regarding specific initiatives promoted by cooperative to achieve its social objectives. ultimately, it focused on three specific areas of relationship: 1. sentiment: general emotional and attitudinal perception of members towards cooperative and their work environment. 2. cooperative's impact on quality of life: assessing how cooperative influences overall well-being and life satisfaction of each member. 3. members' evaluation of cooperative: gathering feedback on cooperative's performance, effectiveness, and perceived value from members' perspective. at the end of structured assessment, following table summarises key findings for each of three dimensions of global impact index (gii), highlighting main indicators and observed impacts. table 1: summary of global impact index (gii) dimensions and key findings dimension key indicators observed impacts environmental integrated well-being performance (iwp) integrated environmental variation (iev) improved waste collection efficiency reduction in particulate emissions enhanced public transport use managerial productivity per worker-member inclusion of disadvantaged individuals balanced economic sustainability with social inclusion long-term retention of previously disadvantaged workers identified areas for operational efficiency improvements social worker sentiment survey impact on quality of life member evaluation of cooperative governance high worker satisfaction and sense of belonging increased perceived well-being due to cooperative initiatives positive feedback on governance and decisionmaking processes european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/11712 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 26 4.2 data collection data collection was carried out through a combination of tools, including interviews, anonymous questionnaires, and analysis of internal data from cooperative. environmental data were obtained from public sources and cross-referenced with information provided by project's scientific partners, such as school of management and economics at university of turin. managerial dimension included an economic-financial analysis based on cooperative's annual financial statements, while social dimension focused on members' work experiences through direct surveys. analysis of collected data provided an accurate representation of impact generated by arcobaleno, highlighting how environmental, managerial, and social dimensions contribute to overall index. 5. discussion 5.1 contributions to literature authors demonstrate that conducted analysis was structured in two phases. first, existing metrics currently in use and present in landscape were scientifically analysed to establish a set. secondly, validity of framework was tested through case study. to date, research in this field has rarely led to shared solutions, as evidenced by plurality of models adopted for measuring and evaluating social impact, reflecting highly differentiated approaches and tools. this condition is generated by fragmentation among social impact assessment models and wide variety of approaches. often, these models are not replicable for organisations with social impact as their core mission, such as social cooperatives. lack of clarity affects cohesion of various evaluation models, risking absence of clear metrics for practical use (spiess-knafl & scheck, 2017). for this reason, aim of this article is to provide a literature review and a case study capable of filling this gap. next step in this research will be to conduct an even more extensive analysis that also considers contributions of external stakeholders. further research should focus on relationship between social impact studies and sustainability studies, as two frameworks that should partially overlap and integrate (bonillaalicea & fu, 2019). 5.2 implications for managers social impact assessment seems to be losing appeal after scientific surge of recent years; however, this article aims to demonstrate its continued relevance. scientifically, all crucial aspects have been thoroughly explored (biancone et al., 2018a, 2018c, 2019b; corvo et al., 2021; faraudello et al., 2020; iannaci, 2020), while in practice, there is a lack of clear and truly replicable models that can unite all ecosystem actors necessary to generate social impact. this research underscores need for impact assessment models that not only reflect realities of social enterprises but also provide a structured methodology that public administrations and policymakers can adopt. while gii primarily focuses on social cooperatives, its integration across environmental, managerial, and social dimensions suggests potential for broader applications. findings indicate that adopting structured impact assessment models can facilitate operational synergies between social cooperatives and public institutions, enhancing long-term effectiveness. by ensuring that european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/11712 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 27 all stakeholders are engaged in evaluation process, a more comprehensive and actionable understanding of social impact can be achieved. key takeaways: • gii provides a structured and replicable framework for assessing social impact in cooperatives. • existing impact measurement models often lack cohesion, limiting their applicability to social enterprises. • public administrations could benefit from integrating gii into policy evaluation processes. • future research should expand on external stakeholder perspectives and explore synergies between impact assessment and sustainability frameworks. this structured discussion strengthens study's contributions by summarising key insights and reinforcing practical implications of findings. 6. conclusions this study analysed role and effectiveness of global impact index (gii) as an integrated evaluation tool for type b social cooperatives, focusing on case study of arcobaleno. results demonstrate that an evaluation model like gii can effectively meet specific needs of social cooperatives, providing a balanced and replicable measurement of economic, social, and environmental impact. central question of this study was: how can an integrated impact index, which considers specificities of work integration social cooperatives, effectively measure economic, social, and environmental value produced by these cooperatives and offer a replicable tool for third sector? gii has proven to meet this need by integrating three fundamental dimensions: 1. environmental dimension: tools such as integrated well-being performance (iwp) and integrated environmental variation (iev) have identified the most effective actions for improving urban context, highlighting how cooperative contributes to territorial well-being and long-term sustainability. 2. managerial dimension: analysis of productivity per worker-member and inclusive management revealed cooperative's dual objective: ensuring economic sustainability and promoting social inclusion, balancing operational challenges with social mission. 3. social dimension: perception of worker-members, improvement of their quality of life, and their sense of belonging emerged as core of cooperative's impact. adopting a model like gii offers social cooperatives a practical and concrete tool to: • monitor and improve their performance across three dimensions of analysis. • transparently represent generated impact to stakeholders, strengthening accountability. • identify strategic intervention areas to maximise social and economic impact. moreover, integration of three pillars—environmental, managerial, and social—demonstrates that social impact cannot be analysed in isolation but requires a holistic vision that considers interdependence among areas, aiming to simplify complexity and generate "social utility." despite promising results, study presents some limitations: methodology was tested on a single case study, limiting generalizability of results; lack of greater integration with external stakeholder feedback may reduce ability to capture full spectrum of generated impact. this study opens interesting perspectives for future research: european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/11712 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 28 1. model expansion: testing gii on a larger number of social cooperatives to verify its adaptability and robustness. 2. stakeholder involvement: including a more in-depth evaluation of impact perceived by external beneficiaries, public administrations, and strategic partners. 3. application in public administration: model could be used to assess effectiveness of public policies and create operational synergies between social cooperatives and institutions. global impact index emerges as an innovative and replicable tool that can not only evaluate impact produced by a social cooperative but also guide its future strategies. arcobaleno's experience confirms that social impact is not limited to numbers or financial metrics but is rooted in ability to create tangible and intangible value for people, communities, and territories. this model represents a new frontier for third sector, demonstrating that sustainability and social inclusion are not distinct objectives but two sides of same coin. informed consent statement: informed consent was obtained from all subjects involved in the study. data availability statement: data is unavailable due to privacy or ethical restrictions. conflicts of interest: authors declare no conflict of interest european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/11712 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 29 references alijani, s., & karyotis, c. (2019). coping with impact investing antagonistic objectives: a multistakeholder approach. research in international business and finance, 47, 10–17. arvidson, m., lyon, f., mckay, s., & moro, d. (2010). the ambitions and challenges of sroi. arvidson, m., lyon, f., mckay, s., & moro, d. (2013). valuing the social? the nature and controversies of measuring social return on investment (sroi). voluntary sector review, 4(1), 3–18. banke-thomas, a. o., madaj, b., charles, a., & van den broek, n. (2015). social return on investment (sroi) methodology to account for value for money of public health interventions: a systematic review. bmc public health, 15(1), 582. biancone, p., secinaro, s., brescia, v., & iannaci, d. (2018a). communication and data processing in local public group: transparency and accountability. international journal of business and management, 13(10), 20–37. biancone, p., secinaro, s., brescia, v., & iannaci, d. (2018b). popular financial reporting, a new information tool for social cooperatives. franco angeli. https://iris.unito.it/handle/2318/1701273#.xubdgugzbiu biancone, p., secinaro, s., brescia, v., & iannaci, d. (2018c). the popular financial reporting as tool to measure social impact. biancone, p., secinaro, s., brescia, v., & iannaci, d. (2019a). business model innovation for sustainability and social impact. international journal of management sciences and business research, 8(11), 30–40. biancone, p., secinaro, s., brescia, v., & iannaci, d. (2019b). the popular financial reporting between theory and evidence. bonilla-alicea, r. j., & fu, k. (2019). systematic map of the social impact assessment field. sustainability, 11(15), 4106. borzaga, c., & depedri, s. (2002). peculiarità e modelli delle cooperative sociali. in comunità cooperative: terzo rapporto sulla cooperazione sociale in italia (pp. 127–170). fondazione giovanni agnelli. https://iris.unitn.it/handle/11572/48390 calderini, m., chiodo, v., & michelucci, f. v. (2018a). growing social impact finance: implications for the public sector. in positive impact investing (pp. 27–38). springer. calderini, m., chiodo, v., & michelucci, f. v. (2018b). the social impact investment race: toward an interpretative framework. european business review, 30(1), 66–81. cevenini, g., fratini, i., & gambassi, r. (2012). a new quantitative approach to measure perceived workrelated stress in italian employees. int j occup med environ health. clément, a., robinot, é., & trespeuch, l. (2023). the use of esg scores in academic literature: a systematic literature review. journal of enterprising communities: people and places in the global economy. https://www.emerald.com/insight/content/doi/10.1108/jec-10-20220147/full/html corvo, l., pastore, l., manti, a., & iannaci, d. (2021). mapping social impact assessment models: a literature overview for a future research agenda. sustainability, 13(9), art. 9. https://doi.org/10.3390/su13094750 ebrahim, a., battilana, j., & mair, j. (2014). the governance of social enterprises: mission drift and accountability challenges in hybrid organizations. research in organizational behavior, 34, 81– 100. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/11712 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 30 edmans, a. (2023). the end of esg. financial management, 52(1), 3–17. https://doi.org/10.1111/fima.12413 eisenhardt, k. m. (1989). building theories from case study research. academy of management review, 14(4), 532–550. epstein, m. j., & yuthas, k. (2014). measuring and improving social impacts: a guide for non-profits. companies, and impact investors. epstein, m. j., & yuthas, k. (2017). measuring and improving social impacts: a guide for nonprofits, companies and impact investors. routledge. faraudello, a., barreca, m., iannaci, d., & lanzara, f. (2020). the impact of social enterprises. a bibliometric analysis from 2010 to 2020. colloquio scientifico 2020 iris network. gambassi, r., & microcosmos. (2012). un approccio innovativo per la misurazione della sostenibilità dello sviluppo” e del bes nelle province italiane. fessud finance, environment and sustainability. gazzola, p., pezzetti, r. r., & amelio, s. (2024). sustainable fashion in the circular economy paradigm: reduce, reuse and recycle as the new sustainable corporate strategy. european journal of social impact and circular economy, 5(2), art. 2. https://doi.org/10.13135/2704-9906/10383 iannaci, d. (2020). reporting tools for social enterprises: between impact measurement and stakeholder needs. european journal of social impact and circular economy. iannaci, d. (2021). social impact of human resource management of hybrid organisations. an exploratory case study. european journal of social impact and circular economy, 2(2), 10–28. lanzalonga, f., oppioli, m., calandra, d., & secinaro, s. (2024). the impact of esg performance on intangible assets and intellectual capital in the food and beverage industry. management decision, 63(2), 423–442. https://doi.org/10.1108/md-09-2023-1664 leonard-barton, d. (1990). a dual methodology for case studies: synergistic use of a longitudinal single site with replicated multiple sites. organization science, 1(3), 248–266. li, t.-t., wang, k., sueyoshi, t., & wang, d. d. (2021). esg: research progress and future prospects. sustainability, 13(21), 11663. lincoln, y. s., & denzin, n. k. (2000). the handbook of qualitative research. sage. millar, r., & hall, k. (2013). social return on investment (sroi) and performance measurement: the opportunities and barriers for social enterprises in health and social care. public management review, 15(6), 923–941. https://doi.org/10.1080/14719037.2012.698857 murdock, a. (2010). social enterprise. international encyclopedia of civil society. https://link.springer.com/content/pdf/10.1007/978-0-387-93996-4_809.pdf nicholls, a. (2009). 'we do good things, don't we?': 'blended value accounting' in social entrepreneurship. accounting, organizations and society, 34(6), 755–769. nicholls, a., paton, r., & emerson, j. (2015). social finance. oxford university press. nyssens, m. (2007). social enterprise: at the crossroads of market, public policies and civil society. routledge. polci, s., & gambassi, r. (2000). l’italia del disagio insediativo—servizi territoriali diffusi per la competizione globale. legambiente/confcommercio. polci, s., & gambassi, r. (2018). osservatorio borghi autentici d’italia—sperimentare una visione di comunità e comprendere i cambiamenti. borghi autentici. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/11712 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 31 porquier, g., luciano, a., & di monaco, r. (2010). dalla tossicodipendenza al lavoro. intorno all’esperienza della cooperativa arcobaleno. animazione sociale, 247, 1–61. rawhouser, h., cummings, m., & newbert, s. l. (2019). social impact measurement: current approaches and future directions for social entrepreneurship research. entrepreneurship theory and practice, 43(1), 82–115. repubblica italiana. (1991). legge del 08/11/1991 n. 381—disciplina delle cooperative sociali. secinaro, s., brescia, v., iannaci, d., & barreca, m. (2021). performance evaluation in the interinstitutional collaboration context of hybrid smart cities. journal of intercultural management, 13(3), 20–46. secinaro, s., calandra, d., & degregori, g. (2023). new technologies in supporting esg criteria and the implementation in the new normal: mapping the field and proving future research paths. https://doi.org/10.3280/cgrds1-2023oa15788 spiess-knafl, w., & scheck, b. (2017). impact investing: instruments, mechanisms and actors. springer. tsang, a., frost, t., & cao, h. (2023). environmental, social, and governance (esg) disclosure: a literature review. the british accounting review, 55(1), 101149. yin, r. k. (2017). case study research and applications: design and methods. sage publications. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7155 published by university of turin) http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 1 micro-level measurement of the circularity of organizations: the italian innovative standardized approach applied to a public sector case study paola vola1, giorgio cantino2, lorenzo gelmini3* 1 contact author university of piemonte orientale, via del duomo, 6, 13100 vercelli (italy) paola.vola@uniupo.it 2 university of piemonte orientale, via del duomo, 6, 13100 vercelli (italy) giorgio.cantino@uniupo.it 3* university of piemonte orientale, via del duomo, 6, 13100 vercelli (italy) lorenzo.gelmini@uniupo.it received: 22/11/2022 accepted for publication: 16/04/2023 published: 21/04/2023 abstract this study analyses the implementation of a circularity measurement methodology at the university of piemonte orientale (upo) in the early stages of the development of the uni1608856 project “measuring circularity methods and indicators for measuring circular processes in organisations, the first attempt to assess an organisation’s circularity under a standardized framework in an italian university. the single-case study examines the organisation’s framework implementation, followed by an in-depth discussion of the phenomenon under study. the circularity measurement metrics applied to the upo case have been extracted from a draft standard prepared by the italian standardization body (uni). the upo case study considers the draft's general propositions with a focus on the metrics related to the management of human resources, assets, policy, and sustainability. some useful insights emerge from the critical analysis of the norm proposal, both regarding adopting different types of measures and implementing the circularity measurement in terms of the organisation’s readiness to collect data for the metrics. as this study deals with a new framework applied to a public organisation, several issues come to light. the first implementation of uni1608856 allows discussion of the effective measurement of circularity at the micro level and how an organisation’s managerial processes need to evolve to provide the data required to measure circularity. keywords: circular economy, circularity measurement, metrics, standards, public organizations, lifecycle european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7155 published by university of turin) http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 2 1. introduction the circular economy (ce) is a system approach that can replace linear industrial operating models with cyclical, closedloop production systems based on the no-waste principle in nature, thus dissociating economic growth practices from using and exploiting natural resources (unep, 2006; emf a, 2013; bsi, 2017; ilic et al., 2018). with the ce concept gaining traction in the last decade, companies and policymakers started directing their attention to what is seemingly a promising tool to foster sustainable development (jia et al., 2020), underlining the importance of ce transition. as a result, an increasing number of scholars and practitioners have focused on the progress of ce initiatives, and hence the development of circularity measurement tools. despite the growing interest in ce assessment methods, the lack of a standardized approach, a commonly agreed scientific basis, and the low applicability of these methods in organizational realities are often cited as fundamental barriers to their uptake (saidani et al., 2019; franco et al., 2021). ce transition currently concerns only a small fraction of organizations able to explicitly address ce in their business processes. for these reasons, extensive literature reviews on the approaches, methods, and tools to assess ce point to the potential usefulness of a more holistic measurement framework/method (sassanelli et al., 2019; walzberg et al., 2021; roos lindgreen, salomone & reyes, 2020). given these shortcomings in ce assessments, the goal of our study is to analyse the implementation of an innovative approach to standardizing the circularity measurement of organizations that uni/ct 057 – the technical commission of the italian body for standardization (uni) – proposed within the specific context of a public organisation, the university of piemonte orientale. moreover, the case study aims to identify the potential limitations of the metrics of the standard and the managerial difficulties in applying the standard itself. in this study, we analyse the implementation of the methodology drafted in the early stages of the development of the uni1608856 project “measuring circularity methods and indicators for measuring circular processes in organizations” by the university of piemonte orientale. this innovative approach is a first attempt to assess an organization’s circularity in view of the development of an international standard for measuring the circular economy1. the objective of this study is to critically discuss the framework of the methodology formulated within the uni1608856 project and its implementation in a public organisation from a managerial perspective. topics like the relevance of the proposed indicators list and data availability for application to the case study are fundamental for the definition of the methodology and need to be investigated. specifically, we focus on the micro-level of organisation circularity, focusing on improving the environmental performance of a particular organization (through different initiatives such as resources consumption reduction, waste management, etc.). the remainder of the paper is organized as follows. after this brief introduction, we review the literature to assess the circular economy measurement concept. the third section describes the research design and methodology adopted. section 4 presents the findings from our case study, section 5 discusses the results, and the last section offers some conclusions, limitations, and future research avenues. 2. literature review measuring circularity: a debated topic the eu ce program (eu com2015) explains that prolonging the value chain of products and services in the economy will generate a sustainable economic system that will benefit organizations, citizens, and the environment. due to the importance of achieving sustainability, the ce concept has in recent years garnered the increasing attention of governments, regulatory bodies, organizations, citizens, and scholars. the ce systemic approach is aimed at expanding the lifecycle of materials, design out waste, increase resource efficiency, and achieve a better balance between different critical issues regarding economic growth, environmental protection, and social wellbeing. a particularly interesting aspect of the circular economy concept is its compatibility and consistency with sustainable development through its three associated pillars. indeed, ce directly aims for not only economic benefits (e.g., value creation 1 iso 59020 “circular economy – measuring and assessing circularity” – cd stage. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7155 published by university of turin) http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 3 and savings by reducing raw materials), but also environmental benefits (e.g., impact reduction), and indirectly, social benefits (e.g., job creation) (mgi, 2015; accenture strategy, 2015). therefore, under the united nations 2030 agenda, a significant number of the sustainable development goals (sdgs) relate to ce practices (schroeder, anggraeni & weber, 2019; rodriguez-anton et al., 2019; netherlands enterprise agency, 2020). organizations and collectives are increasingly willing to move towards a more circular and sustainable economic and business model as a means of achieving commercial differentiation, competitive advantage, and potential growth with economic spillovers. however, the circularity gap report 2020 underlines that the world is only 8.6% circular, meaning that only this small percentage of all minerals, fossil fuels, metals, and biomasses are cycled back (cgri, 2020). while there is currently no standard ce definition, the different definitions proposed or established by major organizations and academics have much in common, tending to formalize and converge towards the same paradigm (carencotte et al., 2012). in short, the ce concept is aimed at systematically maintaining the highest value and use of products and components during their lifecycle through changing the linear loop of material flows (take-make-dispose) to a circular loop (take-make-reuse) (franco, almeida & calili, 2021). cui and zhang (2018) provided an extensive literature review about ce demonstrating the growing interest for the topic. ciraig (2015) performed an extensive literature review and inventory of key circular economy definitions, all of which oppose the linear “make-take-waste” model. in addition, ce implies better resource management throughout the lifecycle of systems, characterized by closed loops, promoting maintenance, reuse, remanufacturing, and recycling. the most popular definition that the ellen macarthur foundation proposed is that ce includes five fundamental characteristics (design out waste, build resilience through diversity, work towards energy from renewable sources, think in systems, think in cascades), and four building blocks (circular product design, innovative business model, reverse cycles, enablers and system conditions) (emf a, b, 2013). moreover, the ellen macarthur foundation butterfly circular economy model is one of the most acknowledged and used in businesses and academic circles (lieder & rashid, 2016). nevertheless, other studies have defined ce strategies and proposed useful frameworks (e.g., king et al., 2006; jawahir & dillon, 2007; allwood et al., 2011; emf, 2013a, 2013b, 2014; bakker et al., 2014a; 2014b; sihvonen & ritola, 2015; willskytt et al., 2016; potting et al., 2017; 2018; reike et al., 2018). for instance, the framework of potting et al. (2017) contains a set of r-strategies, grouped around three main circularity strategies: (i) smarter product use and manufacture; (ii) extended lifespan of products and their parts; (iii) the useful application of materials. the ten r-strategies are: (i) refuse (r0); rethink (r1); reduce (r2); re-use (r3); repair (r4); refurbish (r5); remanufacture (r6); repurpose (r7); recycle (r8); and recovery (r9). furthermore, the priority order indicates that smarter product manufacture and use (r0–r2) are preferable to product lifespan extension (r3–r7). the lowest priorities are material recycling and energy recovery from incineration and anaerobic digestion (r8–r9). in particular, system thinking is fundamental in the circular economy paradigm. indeed, according to balanay and halog (2016), it is central because designing out waste and closing the loop requires a holistic understanding, wide acceptance, and the success of circularity interventions. the international organization for standardization (iso) has enriched the international debate on ce by proposing four new norms to promote and accelerate the standardization of the circular economy. specifically, the aim is to provide a mainframe in which circularity can be measured, intended as the groundwork for future agreements between governments, companies, and society in general. the new iso standards imply developing indicators that measure the circularity of manufacturing processes, with the goal of reducing their environmental footprint. according to iso 59004 (circular economy – framework and principles for implementation), a circular economy system uses a systemic approach to maintain a circular flow of resources by regenerating, retaining, or adding to their value while contributing to sustainable development. in this study, we adopt the iso framework since it contains a well-defined concept of circularity measurement as the collection, calculation, and compilation of information and/or data to determine circularity performance. in this context, ce transitions require the ability to measure and evaluate circularity performance progress (ruggieri et al., 2016; ghisellini, cialani & ulgiati, 2016; kirchherr, reike & hekkert, 2017; potting et al., 2017; saidani et al., 2019). the quantification of the circular economy and sustainability is a relevant aspect at different levels of application: (i) companies need to evaluate and improve the environmental, economic, and social impact of their products and processes; (ii) financial european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7155 published by university of turin) http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 4 bodies must have quantitative information about the potential and risks of the different initiatives to select the optimal opportunity; and (iii) policymakers must be guided toward a coherent definition of strategies at the regional, national, and international level, setting realistic targets, and measuring their effectiveness. some authors underlined the need of studies applied to the public sector organizations, in light of the scarcity of research focused on the implementation of ce practices and strategies in this organizational context (klein, ramos & deutz, 2020). however, the lack of comprehensive and robust approaches to quantify the circular economy makes it challenging to apply quantitative methods and indicators in different contexts and compare the results, with the risk of limiting the practical implementation of circular initiatives due to their unknown and/or unclear potential and contribution. the ce implementation process can benefit from technology, since it plays as fundamental factor in increasing new practices and leading to more significant environmental development (massaro et al., 2021). moreover, the use of technology concerns not only the ability to reduce resources but also the capability to manage information thus increasing the ce's impact. circularity metrics description while there is broad consensus on the need for appropriate methodological approaches to monitor and evaluate the implementation of circularity strategies in business contexts, studies of indicators measuring the adoption of multiple ce strategies are still in the embryonic stage (an, maarten & veronique, 2018; janik & ryszko, 2019; saidani et al., 2019). indeed, measuring and assessing circularity is a complex process comprising several steps and their iteration. iso illustrates the process in figure 1. figure 1. iso framework for measuring and assessing circularity (source: iso standard 59020) the interest in these metrics lies in their ability to summarize and distil the great complexity of environmental dynamics and provide more comprehensive information. practitioners and scholars (e.g., balanay & halog, 2016; saidani et al., 2017; franco, almeida & calili, 2021) have proposed different levels of ce measurement: micro, meso, and macro. the micro level comprises products, companies, and consumers. the meso level refers to developing an eco-industrial network that benefits regional production systems and the environment. the macro level means circular economy development in global, national, regional, or local contexts. in particular, at the micro level, the ce paradigm introduces a new perspective to look at business ecosystems. in this regard, organizations must prepare for ce transition based on their circularity performance insights, thus needing measurement frameworks to assess their circularity from a transition perspective. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7155 published by university of turin) http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 5 studies on indicators to measure the adoption of multiple ce strategies in organizations are still in their infancy (an, maarten & veronique, 2018; janik & ryszko, 2019; saidani et al., 2019). in addition, existing guidelines and standards developed for businesses have been criticized for lacking monitoring c-indicators that link the circular economy with sustainability (pauliuk, 2018; bsi, 2017). moreover, a number of studies (e.g., an, maarten & veronique, 2018; saidani et al., 2019; iacovidou et al., 2017; corona et al., 2019; moraga et al., 2019; potting et al., 2017, 2018) record the absence of standard indicators to track circularity progress within organizations, leading to misunderstandings and contradictions in implementing ce transition. very few indicators capture the effect of strategies concerning smarter product use and manufacture or extending the lifespan of products. another concern is that, in general, cindicators focus primarily on physical parameters. social and environmental indicators are less well-defined and less frequently included in circularity performance measurement frameworks. the same is true for measuring the progress of implementing high-level circularity strategies (an, maarten & veronique, 2018; saidani et al., 2019; moraga et al., 2019; kristensen & mosgaard, 2020; rincón-moreno et al., 2021). in the words of moraga et al. (2019, p. 460), “most indicators focus on the preservation of materials. strategies focusing on materials, especially recycling, are well-developed, but they are some of the existing options to promote ce recycling even being essential to the economy is not the only aspect of a sustainable ce”. in this regard, potting et al. (2017) also point to the strong focus on recycling. even so, a more ambitious ce transition towards the significant reduction of resources, material consumption, and waste generation will be based on high-circularity rstrategies. ghisellini, cialani and ulgiati (2016) underline that the most indicators concern the macro (national) and meso (inter-firm) level, with few metrics at the micro level. moreover, the circular economy evaluations at the micro level are based on cleaner production and green consumption, which is not a full circular economy approach (geng et al., 2012). as such, this approach could lead to indicators claiming to be of circular economy type at the micro level but without encompassing the overall complexity of the circular economy and all possible end-of-life options to close the loop. despite considerable efforts in this regard, gaps are evident in current research concerning c-indicators for monitoring and assessing the progress of organizations towards a ce transition according to their circular strategic choices. circularity measurement indicators are aimed at providing a value expressing how circular a system is, so that these measures enable assessing the circularity of an organization. these indicators have been developed by defining the main attribute of ce (e.g., recirculated materials in a product) to then assign it a scale ranging from 0 to 100%, representing the degree of circularity. our literature review identifies a variety of circularity indicators. for instance, the new product-level circularity metric of linder, sarasini and van loon (2017) defines circularity as “the fraction of a product that comes from a used product” (p. 551). the authors argue that a circularity index should only be focused on the reuse of materials, while other values corresponding to the ce concept (such as environmental quality) should be measured with additional indicators. this argument indicates a divergence between their definition of circularity and the ce concept where circularity relates to only one of the ce goals (material reuse). other indicators, such as the circ(t) and the global circularity metric, are also based on a mono-dimension circularity concept, i.e., merely considering material recirculation, and covering only (and partially) the resource efficient ce goal. for instance, the global circularity metric measures global economy circularity with “the share of cycled materials as part of the total material inputs into the global economy” (de wit et al., 2018, p. 22), using data from input output statistics and projections from a computable general equilibrium model (hatfield-dodds et al., 2017). in turn, circ(t) provides a relative measure of the cumulative mass of a material present in a system over a certain time interval in terms of an ideal reference case where the material is kept functional throughout the entire accounting period t (pauliuk et al., 2017). although the focus is only on material circularity, the developers of these last indicators agree that other goals, such as material saving, value retention, environment conservation, and climate mitigation, should also be considered. the circularity index is based on material circulation, but includes the notion of quality in terms of the ratio of energy required for material recovery to energy required for primary production. this approach attempts to avoid the risk of achieving resource circularity by increasing energy use. the material circularity indicator (mci) that the ellen macarthur foundation (emf) and granta design developed is a micro-level index built on a more complex definition of product circularity expressed as “the extent to which linear flow has been minimized and restorative flow maximized for its component materials, and how long and intensively it is used compared to a similar industry-average product” (emf, 2015, p. 19). since this index does not european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7155 published by university of turin) http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 6 account for the environmental and socioeconomic risks of the analysed systems, additional indicators are proposed to cover the other ce goals. circular economic value (cev) and circular economy indicator prototype (ceip) both build on the mci concept. cev represents the system’s circularity by accounting for reduced use of virgin materials, reduced output of waste, increased use of renewable energies, and increased energy output during end-of-life (eol). the ceip index is calculated by choosing predefined answers to a series of 15 questions on product design, manufacturing, commercialization, in-use, and eol (cayzer, griffiths & beghetto, 2017). then, a final score (in %) is determined by aggregating the obtained scores for each answer. our literature review shows that ce measurement has some significant limitations in terms of the scale/level. in particular, the high diversity and fragmentation of approaches and metrics makes it difficult to compare the industrial applications in which such indicators and methods are used. this fragmentation has mainly two reasons. the first is related to the overall ce umbrella concept: hundreds of ce definitions exist, and the paradigm is developing without overall consensus regarding circular actions and aspects. this diversity in the theoretical background is reflected in the industrial adoption of ce, providing very specific case studies. consequently, these idiosyncrasies also require a tailored assessment framework, challenging replication in other contexts. the second reason that determines ce assessment fragmentation at the same scale/level is the lack of standards. the issues related to the aforementioned circularity measurement indicators highlight the need for a unique and validated reference (standard). therefore, in 2020 uni (the italian standardization body), proposed a project aimed at developing a standardized approach with the aim of defining a set of metrics that organizations could apply at different micro and meso levels. in this study, we analyse the implementation of the uni1608856 project that the university of piemonte orientale proposed. this innovative approach is a first attempt to assess an italian university’s circularity under a standardized framework. moreover, the case study aims to identify the potential limitations of the metrics of the draft standard and the managerial difficulties in applying the standard itself in order to improve the final standard. 3. research design and methodology since our aim is to investigate a first adoption of the standard, we employ a single-case study methodology to analyse the organization’s implementation process, providing an in-depth discussion of the phenomenon under study (yin, 2017). this methodology is useful to transcend the local boundaries of the investigated case, capturing new layers of reality, and developing new, testable, and empirically valid theoretical and practical insights (eisenhardt, 1989; eisenhardt & graebner, 2007). as mentioned, the issues related to above mentioned circularity measurement indicators highlight the need for a unique and validated reference. therefore, in 2019 the national standardization body, uni, nominated a technical committee subdivided in five working groups with the aim to develop a norm for the “evaluation of circularity in the organizations micro and meso level”. the technical committee was coordinated by the national agency for new technologies, energy and sustainable economic development (enea) and composed by several experts from academy, industry and national research bodies (e.g. the national research council). the goal was elaborating a standardized measurement approach that could be applied to a broad range of organizations (manufacturing companies, service organizations, public entities) at the different micro, meso, and macro levels. the first draft of this norm is the so-called uni1608856 project, later published as a technical norm titled uni/ts 11820. in order to identify hot-spots and potential weakness for the practical application of the developed methodology, accordingly to the implementation of an interventionist approach (grossi et al., 2021), in 2021 uni technical committee launched a call for volunteers for the preliminary application of the methodology. considering the relevance to conduct a first attempt to measure the circularity level of a public organisation at the micro level and the potential relevance of the findings in the improvement of the first draft of the uni1608856 project norm, authors submitted the application of the case study of the university of piemonte orientale (upo). upo has locations in three cities (alessandria, novara, and vercelli), around 15.000 students, and 7 (at that time, currently 8) departments that manage the teaching and research activities. in more detail, upo is a young university in northern italy that runs along three cities and eight departments, organized both for logistical ease for students and to take advantage of specific potential of different locations. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7155 published by university of turin) http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 7 more specifically, the departments are as follows: law and political, economic and social sciences; science and technological innovation; pharmaceutical sciences; economics and business studies; translational medicine and health sciences; medicine; humanities; sustainable development and ecological transition upo has been accepted by the technical committee and upo was enrolled in the list of contributors of the experimental phase of the uni1608856 project (pilot study). methodology: circularity measurement of organizations under uni1608856 in response to the need for a unique and validated reference, the uni technical committee ct/057 “circular economy” thus drafted a first version of the uni1608856 project norm. this norm is highly significant as the first standardized framework for organizations to measure and assess circularity, and a reference in the development of a future international iso 59020 standard2. the project defines a set of indicators to evaluate the level of circularity of a single/group of organizations. the measurement approach is based on a rating system that is neither linked to a sectoral benchmark nor a minimum level of circularity but only considers the actual level of circularity reached in respect of the maximum reference of 100 points. it also considers the opportunities to measure the circularity level over time. the methodological approach is based on the so-called “lifecycle perspective”, a holistic approach that aims at maintaining natural flows within systems to generate value for both the ecosystem and future generations. this theory is at the base of lca (life-cycle assessment), which is a standardized methodology to evaluate the environmental impacts of all the input and output flows of a process over its lifecycle. specifically, the methodology identifies six main lifecycle stages: design, supply-chain, production, distribution chain and selling activities, use-phase and consumption, end-of-life. the measurement methodology consists of a set of indicators that can be applied at the micro (single organisation) and meso level (group of organizations, industrial and local clusters, municipalities, cities, districts). the macro level is not considered in the analysis, although a list of indicators currently applied to regions and countries is included in appendix b3. the type of data to be collected and the definition of the so-called “system-boundaries” follow the standardized approach in figure 2. figure 2. flow diagram of the process of data acquisition (source: project uni1608856, revision under final public inquiry) data acquisition first considers the elementary components needed to identify the primary data (e.g., input and output flows) to be collected using an effective and individual approach. the network of relevant stakeholders and processes involved in the assessment can be represented graphically, such as with a flow-diagram, in agreement with the lca methodology. since the standardized approach to measuring circularity generally considers all private/public services, processes (bioprocesses included), and systems on two levels (micro and meso), it should be compliant with some measurement and 2 iso 59020 “circular economy – measuring and assessing circularity” – cd stage 3 uni1608856 “measuring circularity – methods and indicators for measuring circular processes in organizations” european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7155 published by university of turin) http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 8 evaluation criteria. in particular, the nine criteria followed are applicability, coherence, compatibility, transparency, completeness, traceability, data reliability, spatial and temporal coverage, and systemic interdependencies. these criteria are then assessed with data-quality studies that characterize, for instance, data reproducibility, accuracy, precision, availability, representativeness, and so forth. to evaluate all the different data describing the organization’s circularity, three types of indicators are defined: − qualitative indicators = non-numerical factors that set the level of progression or positioning in respect of a target, namely qualitative data based on personal opinions. − quantitative indicators = numerical factors that determine the level of progression or positioning in respect of a target based on numerical and objective evaluations. − semi-quantitative indicators = qualitative evaluation based on a mix of qualitative and quantitative indicators. these indicators are then grouped into six categories: 1) management of materials and components 2) management of energy resources 3) management of waste and emissions 4) management of logistics 5) management of products/services 6) management of human resources, assets, policy, and sustainability according to the expected timeline shown in figure 3, a preliminary set of 103 micro/meso indicators was defined. at the end of 2021, the ct/057 technical committee started a voluntary experimental phase of testing these indicators for applicability and validity, thus calling for volunteers to select a representative set of organizations, including manufacturing companies, service organizations, and public entities. figure 3. timeline (source: uni, italian standardization body) the findings allowed drafting a summary report for stakeholders and improve the methodology. the number of indicators utilized was then reduced to a set of 81, further classified as: − core indicators = indicators that are compulsory european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7155 published by university of turin) http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 9 − specific indicators, if at least 50% are to be assessed − rewarding indicators = facultative indicators that if evaluated and different from zero lead to a higher final score4. these indicators are further described using additional information: progressive number, description, type of measurement (qualitative/quantitative/semi-quantitative), data-measurement unit (mass, energy, economy, ad hoc), datatype (input, output, internal), numerator and denominator for its evaluation (if present), further definitions, type of evaluation (related to a product and/or service), type of indicator (core/specific/rewarding). all these data are organized in the format of a table (as an example, see table i). table i. example of indicators for the “human resources, assets, policy, and sustainability” category description type of measure u.m. data type indicator calculation related definitions eval. type indicator type numerator denominator 06. indicators related to human resources, assets, policy and sustainability 6 5 index of average energy efficiency of the organisation’s buildings for civil use in (n) year limits: class a (100%) class b-c (50%) class d-f (25%) class g (0%) semiquantitative limits interna l index of average energetic efficiency of the building for civil use in (n) year index of energy efficiency p/s 1 6 8 does the organisation disclose its sustainability and circularity performance (with a sustainability report, non-monetary declarations, etc.)? qualitative binary (y/n) output p/s 2 7 4 investments in sustainable reconversion of assets in years (n), (n-1), (n-2) in respect of investments in sustainable reconversion of assets in years (n), (n-1), (n-2), and building new assets in years (n), (n-1), (n2) quantitative economi c interna l investments in sustainable reconversion of assets in years (n), (n1), (n-2) (investments in sustainable reconversion of assets in years (n), (n-1), (n-2)) + (investments in building new assets in years (n), (n-1), (n-2)) assets reconversion of assets p/s 2 legend: datatype: input, output, or internal evaluation type: (s) service, (p) product, (p/s) product/service indicator type: (1) core, (2) specific, (3) rewarding source: uni1608856, revision under final public inquiry based on these indicators, the evaluation of products and services – separately or jointly – follows. since this is a differential approach based on experimental data, organizations must define the expected focus before the actual data-analysis and 4 uni1608856, revision under public final inquiry european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7155 published by university of turin) http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 10 measurement phases. in fact, the three different calculation schemas to evaluate are manufacturing companies and service organizations, only manufacturing companies, and only service organizations, as reported in table ii. table ii. calculation schema for the evaluation of a service industry, as applied in the upo case study. indicators type 04, 12, 17, 19, 20, 21, 22, 24, 65 core 01, 02, 03, 05, 06, 09, 10, 11, 13, 14, 15, 16, 18, 26, 29, 30, 31, 33, 36, 38, 40, 41, 47, 48, 49, 50, 51, 52, 53, 58, 59, 60, 61, 62, 63, 64, 67, 68, 71, 72, 73, 74, 75, 76, 77, 81 specific 42, 44, 66, 69, 70, 78, 79, 80 rewarding source: uni1608856, revision under final public inquiry for each, the core, specific, and rewarding indicators are summed up separately and then divided by the relative number of indicators employed. this allows calculating the general level of circularity, while a further evaluation of each of the six categories of indicators enables assessing the hotspots. the mathematical model consists in a standardized procedure structured in the following steps: -be: c number of core indicators s number of specific indicators p number of rewarding indicators -be: a ⊂ n ordered set a: {1, 2, ..., c-1, c} b ⊂ n ordered set b: {1, 2, ..., s-1, s} c ⊂ n ordered set c: {1, 2, ..., p-1, p} -be: d ⊆ b ⊂ n the subset of b of specific indicators used, which must include at least 50% of elements of b set in ascending order. d: {s1, s2, ..., st} -be: e ⊆ c ⊂ n the subset of c of rewarding indicators used, which could be void or corresponds to c, then set in ascending order. e: {p1, p2, ..., pf} -be: ai with i ∈ a the core indicators a1, a2, … ac bj with j ∈ d the specific indicators used bs1, bs2, … bst ck with k ∈ e the rewarding indicators used cp1, cp2, … cpt the level of circularity (lc) of an organisation is defined as: 𝐿𝐶 = ∑!"#$ ""#∑ %& '#%$ $'#∑ () *#%$ %* %#' 𝑖𝑓 𝐿𝐶 ≤ 1 otherwise, lc = 1 the result obtained consists in a numerical value (%) that assesses the organization’s circularity level. thereafter, the organisation can assess the conformity of the achieved level with respect to the level set by the norm. this assessment could be made by the organisation itself (self-evaluation), by a second party as an interested client (consultant), or european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7155 published by university of turin) http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 11 by a third-party, thus an independent institution that works in compliance with uni cei en iso/iec 17029. the requirements for this conformity evaluation are listed in detail in appendix a5. the results obtained with the feasibility studies led to the final draft project proposal uni 1608856 published online as a public inquiry. 4. results: project uni1608856 implementation in upo as discussed, uni1608856 enables overcoming the lack of precise metrics hindering the measurement of circularity of organizations at the micro level. the university of piemonte orientale (upo) was among the organizations that participated in the experimental phase to test the norm’s applicability. the university’s participation is a first attempt to measure circularity in the public sector at the micro level. as such, the feasibility study conducted at upo is an original case study aimed at implementing the innovative approach of uni/ts 11820 in the public sector. among the six categories listed, the “management of human resources, assets, policy, and sustainability” was further investigated due to the general academic structure under public management. the set of indicators assessed for this category comprise 30 questions. as an example, figure 4 shows the original indicators 81, 91, 105 and 106, as measured in the upo case study. 5 uni1608856, revision under public final inquiry european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7155 published by university of turin) http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 12 figure 4. example of indicators for the “management of human resources, assets, policy, and sustainability” category (source: questionnaire for uni1608856 early-stage revision) european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7155 published by university of turin) http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 13 in detail, 21/30 indicators are explicitly related to a specific lifecycle stage, namely use-phase and consumption (9/21), and 4/21 for other phases, such as design, supply-chain, and end-of-life, as shown in figure 5. figure 5. lifecycle stages of the “management of human resources, assets, policy and sustainability” category (source: own elaboration) figure 6 shows that data were recorded for half the answers in this category. figure 6. results of the “management of human resources, assets, policy, and sustainability” category (source: own elaboration) european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7155 published by university of turin) http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 14 5. discussion the uni1608856 project is a first proposal aimed at bridging several circularity measurement gaps outlined by scholars. importantly, it provides a framework to measure the circularity of organizations, considering that scholars, such ghisellini, cialani and ulgiati (2016), amongst others, lament the lack of circularity indicators at the micro level. moreover, the framework is in line with initiatives dedicated to measuring circularity progress in organizations. indeed, the methodology is based on metrics assessed at the organizational level with no reference to minimum scores but seeking desirable increases over time. this perspective is consistent with calls for indicators to measure progress in circularity (e.g., an, maarten & veronique, 2018; saidani et al., 2019; iacovidou et al., 2017; corona et al., 2019; moraga et al., 2019; potting et al., 2017, 2018). moreover, the norm distinguishes the metrics proposed according to the type of activity conducted by organizations. therefore, three different circularity calculation schemas are defined, respectively for manufacturing companies, service organizations, and manufacturing-service organizations. this distinctive feature of the norm allows properly measuring circularity, since the determinants can vary greatly depending on the type of business. important to note is that for this case study, only half of the indicators proposed for the category under investigation were applicable (15 out of 30), indicating the need to discuss the metrics concerning the specific industry in which the organization operates. considering the applicable indicators, the results show that the data collected mostly concern the processing phases (out of the six main phases recommended). specifically, most answers were recorded for the use-phase and the consumption lifecycle stage, and only a few for other phases. since upo declared that data were unavailable (“n.d.”) for many of the indicators analysed, it was impossible to obtain precise information. indeed, the answers recorded referred to different measurement units (binary, limits, economic). an obvious difficulty emerges: finding useful records that could be linked to the internal organisation of information within upo. in fact, data are not easy to access because they are gathered in many different archives. to overcome this issue, the data should be internally reorganized and better integrated with the related management activities. for example, data digitization could be enabled by the adoption of facility management systems. moreover, the answers related to the management of building stocks and assets highlighted a general lack of traceability concerning energy or organizational/functional interventions, likely because the collection of some data for traceability purposes is optional at the public level. these considerations draw attention to the need to assess and evaluate the overall information system of the entire organization to find the right solutions to satisfy divergent needs, from accounting to procurement, to facility management. some difficulties are also highlighted about human resources management. the results indicate a general need for knowledge of the circular economy principles at many levels, from education and the assignment of specific tasks to employees, to communication between stakeholders and students. the results also show a general need for knowledge of international certification schemes for energy and environmental management (e.g., iso 50001), as well as for sustainability reports and non-financial statements. therefore, a main recommendation is to include circular economy issues within the management of human resources, assets, policy, and sustainability at upo. to ensure successful circular economy transitions, organizations require qualified staff with specific skills. in addition, education and training systems focused on circularity are critical in the human resource management. 6. conclusions, limitations, and further research moving from the iso framework mentioned in the literature review, the upo case study highlights some critical points with regard to the methodology proposed to measure circularity according to the uni1608856 project. in view of similar problems emerging in other experimentations, some revisions were made to the first project of the norm. first, further categorizing the indicators as core/specific/rewarding, second, downgrading some from “core” to “rewarding”, thus facultative, which allows slightly mitigating the problem of the consistent number of “not applicable” (n.a.) answers, as highlighted by the upo case study. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7155 published by university of turin) http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 15 moreover, since the total number of indicators seemed ineffective, their number was reduced to a set of 81, further categorized with respect to “evaluation type”, namely service, product, or product/service (see table i). the distinction between evaluation type should be made before the actual data-analysis and measurement phase. in fact, when based on precise indicators, the description of products and/or services would be more detailed. for instance, in the revised norm, the number of indicators for the “management of human resources, assets, policy, and sustainability” category was reduced to 18, and further classified as core/specific/rewarding. therefore, the original indicators reported in figure 4 were re-elaborated as those in table i, so the number 81 became 65 in the final revision, number 105 and 106 were merged in number 68, and the 91 was renamed as number 74. however, the procedure described in the uni1608856 project to measure the level of circularity of organizations is expected to be applied on a voluntary basis. the analysis of manufacturing companies and service organizations at the micro and meso level is likely to be up-scaled if some criteria are to be assessed on a mandatory basis. for instance, this would help identify benchmarks and hotspots in respect of different life stages and categories, thus gaining meaningful data to improve the circular economy also at the national level. moreover, any activity of third-party evaluations of the conformity of results is highly recommended. this would set a proper basis to improve communications between stakeholders at the general level, as in the case of type iii environmental declarations (uni en iso 14025:2010), for example. in fact, these provide objective and comparable data related to the environmental performance of products and services, without setting minimum levels, similarly to the scope of the uni1608856 project with respect to the circular economy. as concerns the research limitations, this study is based on a single case of the implementation of a working draft of a standard. the results would benefit from measuring the circularity level of upo once the uni/ts 11820 norm is published. furthermore, the application of the standard to other public organizations could highlight relevant hotspots useful for future revisions of the standard, as well as considerations derived from the implementation of the norm by different types of organizations. in this respect, in fact, uni1608856 is applicable to all organizations and the case of upo could, in general, foster useful insights. references accenture strategy (2015), “gaining an edge: growth, innovation and customer value from the circular economy”, available at https://www.accenture.com/us-en/insight-circular-economy-gaining-edge (accessed 20 april 2022). allwood, j.m., ashby, m.f., gutowski, t.g. and worrell, e. (2011), “material efficiency: a white paper”, resources, conservation and recycling, vol. 55 no. 3, pp. 362-381. an, v., maarten, c. and veronique, v.h. (2018), “indicators for a circular economy”, available at https://vlaanderencirculair.be/en/summa-ce-centre/publications/indicators-for-a-circular-economy (accessed 20 april 2022). bakker, c., wang, f., huisman, j. and den hollander, m. (2014a), “products that go round: exploring product life extension through design”, journal of cleaner production, vol. 69, pp. 10-16. bakker, c.a., den hollander, m.c., van hinte, e. and zijlstra, y. (2014b), products that last: product design for circular business models. tu delft library, deft. balanay, r. and halog, a. (2016), “charting policy directions for mining’s sustainability with circular economy”, recycling, vol. 2, pp. 219–231. bsi (2017), “framework for implementing the principles of the circular economy in organizations guide”, available at https://www.thenbs.com/publicationindex/documents/details?pub=bsi&docid=317511 (accessed 20 april 2022). carencotte, f., geldron, a., villeneuve, j. and gaboriau, h. (2012), “economie circulaire et recyclage des métaux”, geosciences, vol. 15, pp. 64–71. cayzer, s., griffiths, p. and beghetto, v. (2017), “design of indicators for measuring product performance in the circular economy”, international journal of sustainable engineering, vol. 10 no. 4-5, pp. 289-298. cgri (2020), “the circularity gap report 2020”, available at https://www.circularity-gap.world/2020 (accessed 20 april 2022). ciraig (2015), “circular economy: a critical literature review of concepts”, bibliothèque et archives nationales du québec, quebec city, qc, canada. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7155 published by university of turin) http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 16 corona, b., shen, l., reike, d., carreón, j.r. and worrell, e. (2019), “towards sustainable development through the circular economy. a review and critical assessment on current circularity metrics”, resources, conservation and recycling, vol. 151, pp. 104498. cui, t., & zhang, j. (2018). bibliometric and review of the research on circular economy through the evolution of chinese public policy. scientometrics, 116(2), 1013-1037. de wit, m., hoogzaad, j., ramkumar, s., friedl, h. and douma, a. (2018), “the circularity gap report: an analysis of the circular state of the global economy”, available at https://pacecircular.org/sites/default/files/2020-01/circularity%20gap% 20report%202018_0.pdf (accessed 20 april 2022). eisenhardt, k.m. (1989), “building theories from case study research”, academy of management review, vol. 14 no. 4, pp. 532-550. eisenhardt, k.m. and graebner, m.e. (2007), “theory building from cases: opportunities and challenges”, academy of management journal, vol. 50, no. 1, pp. 25–32. emf (2013a), “towards the circular economy vol. 1: an economic and business rationale for an accelerated transition”, available at https://ellenmacarthurfoundation.org/towards-the-circular-economy-vol-1-an-economic-and-businessrationale-for-an (accessed 20 april 2022). emf (2013b), “towards the circular economy vol. 2: opportunities for the consumer goods sector”, available at https://emf.thirdlight.com/link/coj8yt1jogq8-hkhkq2/@/preview/1?o (accessed 20 april 2022). emf (2014), “towards the circular economy vol. 3: accelerating the scale-up across global supply chains”, available at https://emf.thirdlight.com/link/t4gb0fs4knot-n8nz6f/@/preview/1?o (accessed 20 april 2022). emf (2015), “material circularity indicator”, available at https://ellenmacarthurfoundation.org/material-circularity-indicator (accessed 20 april 2022). eu (2015), com2015 “closing the loop – an eu action plan for the circular economy”, available at https://www.eea.europa.eu/policy-documents/com-2015-0614-final (accessed 20 april 2022). franco, n.g., almeida, m.f.l. and calili, r.f. (2021), “a strategic measurement framework to monitor and evaluate circularity performance in organizations from a transition perspective”, sustainable production and consumption, vol. 27, 1165– 1182. geng, y., fu, j., sarkis, j. and xue, b. (2012), “towards a national circular economy indicator system in china: an evaluation and critical analysis”, journal of cleaner production, vol. 23 no. 1, pp. 216–224. ghisellini, p., cialani, c. and ulgiati, s. (2016), “a review on circular economy: the expected transition to a balanced interplay of environmental and economic systems”, journal of cleaner production, vol. 114, pp. 11–32. grossi, g., biancone, p. p., secinaro, s., & brescia, v. (2021). dialogic accounting through popular reporting and digital platforms. meditate accountancy research, 29(7), 75-93. hatfield-dodds, s., schandl, h., newth, d., obersteiner, m., cai, y., baynes, t., ... and havlik, p. (2017), “assessing global resource use and greenhouse emissions to 2050, with ambitious resource efficiency and climate mitigation policies”, journal of cleaner production, vol. 144, pp. 403-414. iacovidou, e., velis, c.a., purnell, p., zwirner, o., brown, a., hahladakis, j., ... and williams, p. t. (2017), “metrics for optimising the multi-dimensional value of resources recovered from waste in a circular economy: a critical review”, journal of cleaner production, vol. 166, pp. 910-938. ilic, d., eriksson, o., odlund, l., and aberg, m. (2018), “no zero burden assumption in a circular economy”, journal of cleaner production, vol. 182, pp. 352–362. janik, a. and ryszko, a. (2019), “circular economy in companies: an analysis of selected indicators from a managerial perspective”, multidisciplinary aspects of production engineering, vol. 2 no. 1, pp. 523-535. jawahir, i.s. and dillon, o.w. (2007), “sustainable manufacturing processes: new challenges for developing predictive models and optimization techniques”, proceedings of the first international conference on sustainable manufacturing. montreal, canada. jia, f., yin, s., chen, l. and chen, x. (2020), “the circular economy in the textile and apparel industry: a systematic literature review”, journal of cleaner production, vol. 259, pp. 120728. king, a.m., burgess, s.c., ijomah, w. and mcmahon, c.a. (2006), “reducing waste: repair, recondition, remanufacture or recycle?”, sustainable development, vol. 14 no. 4, pp. 257-267. kirchherr, j., reike, d. and hekkert, m. (2017), “conceptualizing the circular economy: an analysis of 114 definitions”, resources, conservation and recycling, vol. 127, pp. 221-232. klein, n., ramos, t. b., & deutz, p. (2020). circular economy practices and strategies in public sector organizations: an integrative review. sustainability, 12(10), 4181. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7155 published by university of turin) http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 17 kristensen, h.s. and mosgaard, m.a. (2020), “a review of micro level indicators for a circular economy–moving away from the three dimensions of sustainability?”, journal of cleaner production, vol. 243, pp. 118531. lieder, m. and rashid, a. (2016), “towards circular economy implementation: a comprehensive review in context of manufacturing industry journal of cleaner production, vol. 115, pp. 36–51. linder, m., sarasini, s. and van loon, p. (2017), “a metric for quantifying product‐level circularity”, journal of industrial ecology, vol. 21 no. 3, pp. 545-558. massaro, m., secinaro, s., dal mas, f., brescia, v., & calandra, d. (2021). industry 4.0 and circular economy: an exploratory analysis of academic and practitioners' perspectives. business strategy and the environment, 30(2), 1213-1231. mgi (2015), “europe’s circular economy opportunity”, available at: https://www.mckinsey.com/businessfunctions/sustainability/our-insights/europes-circular-economy-opportunity (accessed 20 april 2022). moraga, g., huysveld, s., mathieux, f., blengini, g.a., alaerts, l., van acker, k., ... and dewulf, j. (2019), “circular economy indicators: what do they measure?”, resources, conservation and recycling, vol. 146, pp. 452-461. netherlands enterprise agency (2020), “circular economy & sdgs: how circular economy practices help to achieve the sustainable development goals”, available at https://circular economy.europa.eu/platform/sites/default/files/3228_brochure_sdg_-_hch_cmyk_a4_portrait_-_0520-012.pdf (accessed 20 april 2022). pauliuk, s. (2018), “critical appraisal of the circular economy standard bs 8001: 2017 and a dashboard of quantitative system indicators for its implementation in organizations”, resources, conservation and recycling, vol. 129, pp. 81-92. pauliuk, s., kondo, y., nakamura, s. and nakajima, k. (2017), “regional distribution and losses of end-of-life steel throughout multiple product life cycles. insights from the global multiregional matrace model”, resources, conservation and recycling, vol. 116, pp. 84-93. potting, j., hanemaaijer, a., delahaye, r., ganzevles, j., hoekstra, r. and lijzen, j. (2018), “circular economy: what we want to know and can measure. framework and baseline assessment for monitoring the progress of the circular economy in the netherlands”, pbl policy report, 3217. potting, j., hekkert, m.p., worrell, e. and hanemaaijer, a. (2017), circular economy: measuring innovation in the product chain (no. 2544). pbl publishers. reike, d., vermeulen, w.j. and witjes, s. (2018), “the circular economy: new or refurbished as ce 3.0? exploring controversies in the conceptualization of the circular economy through a focus on history and resource value retention options”, resources, conservation and recycling, vol. 135, pp. 246-264. rincón-moreno, j., ormazábal, m., álvarez, m.j. and jaca, c. (2021), “advancing circular economy performance indicators and their application in spanish companies”, journal of cleaner production, vol. 279, pp. 123605. rodriguez-anton, j.m., rubio-andrada, l., celemín-pedroche, m.s. and alonso-almeida, m.d.m. (2019), “analysis of the relations between circular economy and sustainable development goals”, international journal of sustainable development & world ecology, vol. 26 no. 8, pp. 708–720. roos lindgreen, e., salomone, r. and reyes, t. (2020), “a critical review of academic approaches, methods and tools to assess circular economy at the micro level”, sustainability, vol. 12 no. 12, p. 4973. ruggieri, a., braccini, a.m., poponi, s. and mosconi, e.m. (2016), “a meta-model of inter-organisational cooperation for the transition to a circular economy”, sustainability, vol. 8 no 11, pp. 1153. saidani, m., yannou, b., leroy, y. and cluzel, f. (2017), “how to assess product performance in the circular economy? proposed requirements for the design of a circularity measurement framework”, recycling, vol. 2 no. 1, pp. 6. saidani, m., yannou, b., leroy, y., cluzel, f. and kendall, a. (2019), “a taxonomy of circular economy indicators”, journal of cleaner production, vol. 207, pp. 542-559. sassanelli, c., rosa, p., rocca, r. and terzi, s. (2019), “circular economy performance assessment methods: a systematic literature review”, journal of cleaner production, vol. 229, pp. 440–453. schroeder, p., anggraeni, k. and weber, u. (2019), “the relevance of circular economy practices to the sustainable development goals”, journal of industrial ecology, vol. 23 no. 1, pp. 77–95. sihvonen, s. and ritola, t. (2015), “conceptualizing rex for aggregating end-of-life strategies in product development”, procedia cirp, vol. 29, pp. 639-644. unep (2006), “circular economy. an alternative model for economic development”, available at https://www.yumpu.com/en/document/read/27541847/circular-economy-unep (accessed 20 april 2022). walzberg, j., lonca, g., hanes, r., eberle, a., carpenter, a. and heath, g.a. (2021), “do we need a new sustainability assessment method for the circular economy? a critical literature review”, frontiers in sustainability, vol. 1, pp. 620047. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7155 published by university of turin) http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 18 willskytt, s., böckin, d., andré, h., ljunggren söderman, m. and tillman, a.m. (2016), “framework for analysing resourceefficient solutions”, available at https://publications.lib.chalmers.se/records/fulltext/245234/local_245234.pdf (accessed 20 april 2022). yin, r.k. (2017), case study research and applications: design and methods. sage publications, los angeles, ca. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/12054 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license this article is not subject to double-blind peer review and is part of the practitioners perspective section for 2025. 19 investigation on open badge and market katia presutti1*, lara bovero1, cinzia zedda1, cristina fracchia1, manuela caramagna1, gabriele baratto1, cristina giraudo1, federica bassano1 *contact author katia.presutti@unito.it 1 university of turin, turin, italy abstract this document investigates the transformative role of open badges and blockchain technology in the educational sector, focusing on the university of turin's (unito) "premialità 2023" project. it discusses the development of a digital credential ecosystem using the bestr platform, which employs blockchain to ensure the transparency, security, and portability of academic credentials. the study highlights how digital credentials, particularly open badges, streamline the validation of skills and competencies and significantly contribute to social mobility and inclusivity. by providing a verifiable and accessible means of recognizing formal and informal learning, these technologies empower individuals from diverse backgrounds, enhancing their employability and participation in the workforce. furthermore, the case study of unito showcases the potential of digital badges to bridge the gap between academic achievements and market needs, promoting a culture of continuous learning and adapting education to modern societal demands. keywords: open badges, blockchain, lifelong learning, digital credentials, educational equity 1. introduction technological innovation has opened up new opportunities for skills certification in the ever-changing educational environment. among the emerging solutions, the bestr platform is a cutting-edge digital ecosystem developed by cineca in collaboration with miur and other italian academic institutions. bestr hosts open badges (ob), a standard format for the digital representation of skills that is revolutionizing how skills acquired by individuals are recognized and certified (baratto et al., 2024). open badges, with their potential for transparency and portability, are becoming a benchmark for skills certification european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/12054 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license this article is not subject to double-blind peer review and is part of the practitioners perspective section for 2025. 20 (raffaghelli j.e. 2014), so much so that the council of rectors of italian universities (crui), in 2018 as part of its ‘digital university’ initiative, has recognized the bestr platform as a national pillar in advancing this mode of certification. adopting open-source standards and compatibility with mozilla technical specifications ensures transparency and standardization in the certification process, fostering a collaborative and interconnected environment. the flexibility offered by bestr allows users to carry their credentials across different platforms, creating a more extensive and interconnected network. this simplifies the skill validation process and boosts participation from educational institutions and organizations. adopting systems like blockcerts based on blockchain technology and open badges is revolutionizing the management and validation of digital credentials. blockchain offers unprecedented security and authenticity, eliminating the risk of forgery and manipulating educational qualifications (min c. et al., 2019). adopting innovative solutions like bestr and blockcerts in a future-oriented educational landscape represents a significant step towards creating a more open, flexible, and transparent educational system (baratto et al., 2024). 2. bestr system the bestr platform was developed by cineca, a non-profit consortium comprising 70 italian universities, four national research centers, and the ministry of university and research (miur). it aims to support the italian scientific community through advanced supercomputing and visualization tools. in june 2018, crui recognized open badges and the bestr platform as a national reference point for skill certification, highlighting the growing importance of this certification method. adopting the open-source format of open badges on bestr, aligned with mozilla's technical specifications, is a fundamental pillar for creating an open and interconnected educational ecosystem. this feature ensures transparency and standardization in the certification process and promotes a collaborative environment where skill sharing and validation are significantly facilitated (tsou m. et al., 2011). the compatibility with other issuing and viewing platforms of open badges represents a critical element of this interconnectivity. users who acquire skills on bestr are not confined to a single “ecosystem" (here, meant as a digital credential ecosystem); instead, they can transport their badges and related certifications across various platforms that adopt the same standards. this creates a broader, more flexible network where recognized skills can be easily verified and integrated into different academic or professional contexts. the openness and interoperability promoted european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/12054 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license this article is not subject to double-blind peer review and is part of the practitioners perspective section for 2025. 21 by this feature also encourage the participation of more educational institutions and organizations (baratto et al., 2024). when skills are certified in a universally recognized format, there is no need to make costly or complex adaptations to integrate different certification systems. this simplifies the collaboration process between various entities, creating a synergy that benefits learners and training providers (la rocca c., 2020). moreover, the open environment promotes transparency and trust in the certification process. since open badges on bestr follow an open standard, anyone can examine and understand the criteria and methods of skill attribution. this helps dispel doubts and uncertainties, increasing the credibility of the badges and strengthening the value of the acquired skill certification. adopting the open-source format on bestr is not a technical choice but a key strategy to promote innovation, collaboration, and transparency in skill certification (spenser a., 2020). this feature creates a more open, flexible, and future-oriented educational landscape. as of spring 2020, 15% of italian universities have issued open badges, constituting 70% of the total on bestr. the widespread presence of training academies, online courses, and massive open online courses (moocs) offered by private entities that issue digital certifications has prompted public universities to consider adapting their degree issuance methods, considering the international impact. in this scenario, national and international universities are called to excel by adapting to the constant evolutions of technological innovations. bestr has distributed over 644,000 badges, of which 62% come from universities and 27% from schools, and it has also recognized 50,000 university credits (ects). the platform participates in six significant european projects, including mirva, openagri, openvm, anpal/edci, dare, and big data. the main functions of bestr include: ● create and publish digital credentials with the ability to organize them into complex pathways. ● exploration of badge classes and badge projects. ● flexible issuance of open badges. ● issuance of notarized blockcerts on the public ethereum blockchain, in conjunction with open badges. ● full integration with digital education platforms through standards like xapi and restful apis. ● linking to the student management system (esse3) for automatic and large-scale assignments. ● incorporation of evidence and results from student information systems into digital credentials. ● automatic recognition of ects. ● implementing the features of the european diploma supplement to share and increase visibility. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/12054 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license this article is not subject to double-blind peer review and is part of the practitioners perspective section for 2025. 22 ● advanced monitoring and reporting tools for issuing organizations. bestr is recognized as a service provider for the idem and edugain identity federations. it offers access to researchers, students, and technical administrative staff of major research institutions and global universities through their institutional accounts. in the italian context, bestr has obtained the qualification of "saas provider for public entities" by agid, the national authority for digitization, and is officially listed in the agid cloud marketplace. in the last five years, many higher education institutions have adopted new approaches to issuing academic qualifications, embracing innovative technologies such as blockchain. a notable example is the university of melbourne, which in 2017 began using blockchain to issue digital credentials, allowing students to share verified copies of their qualifications with employers and other stakeholders, enhancing the transparency and verification of credentials. another pioneering institution has been the state university of new york, which in 2018 successfully implemented a micro-credential system in its programs and activities with external stakeholders. this initiative enabled the recognition and validation of specific skills acquired by students, offering a more flexible approach to education. in 2019, mcmaster university became the first canadian university to issue digital diplomas via blockchain for graduates from the faculty of engineering. during the covid-19 pandemic, the university extended the option of receiving notarized diplomas on the blockchain to all spring session 2020 graduates, addressing the challenges of producing and distributing paper documents. in europe, the recovery after covid-19 and the transition towards the green deal have influenced learning and working. the council of the european union (eu) decided in 2021, highlighting the need to address the lack of skills in the european union market. this underscores the importance of adopting innovative approaches and advanced technologies, such as blockchain, to improve the match between the skills acquired by students and the needs of the european market (mikroyannidis a. et al., 2020). specifically, the decision 2021/1868 of the eu, issued on 10/15/2021, highlights the need to develop a coordinated strategy aimed at promoting employment among member states and the european union. the goal is to promote a qualified, trained, adaptable workforce and future-oriented markets. this decision aligns with the ambitious project to create the european education area by 2025. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/12054 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license this article is not subject to double-blind peer review and is part of the practitioners perspective section for 2025. 23 in response to this directive, the european commission aims to establish a european approach to (micro) digital credentials to enhance learning opportunities and strengthen the role of higher education and vocational education in lifelong learning. in particular, the commission is working on creating the europass digital credential infrastructure (edci). this infrastructure facilitates the secure and efficient recognition of qualifications and other learning outcomes across europe. article 4, paragraph 6 of the europass decision specifies that the edci supports authentication services for digital documents and representations of information on skills and qualifications. europass's web-based tools are crucial in supporting and ensuring technical interoperability and synergies with other relevant tools and services at the union level and, where appropriate, at the national level. this initiative aims to create a harmonized environment where information on skills and qualifications can be shared and effectively recognized across the european union. in this context, the edci represents a significant step towards creating a more integrated and flexible educational and training system capable of responding to the challenges and needs of contemporary society. its implementation reflects the european commission's commitment to adopting innovative solutions to improve the transparency and portability of educational and professional credentials within the european context. 2.1 open badge & blockchain the open badge constitutes an open technological standard defined by the mozilla foundation (obi open badges infrastructure) and has achieved global diffusion, finding application in a wide range of organizations. open badges are represented by images on any computer, which includes metadata about the badge's skill, the recipient, the acquisition methods, and more (vladan et al., 2015). the open badge has significant communication potential due to its visual component and the accessibility of its metadata. this makes it particularly portable, allowing any standard-compliant system to read and verify the metadata by accessing the digital credential-issuing platform. bestr has adopted open badges as its first standard for representing competencies, recognizing their versatility and effectiveness in communicating acquired skills. ob represents a growing phenomenon in the contemporary educational landscape, serving as a versatile tool for recognizing and certifying skills acquired by individuals in various contexts. these certifications european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/12054 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license this article is not subject to double-blind peer review and is part of the practitioners perspective section for 2025. 24 are issued by a wide range of organizations, with higher education institutions awarding badges to students to certify their academic achievements and k-12 schools are issuing them to teachers for professional development (clements k. et al., 2020). one of the challenges educational institutions face is adapting to the changing dynamics of learning that are increasingly integrated with innovative technologies and methodologies. in this context, open badges represent a dynamic and adaptable response, allowing for the flexible recognition and certification of specific skills. adopting this practice, even in the context of extracurricular learning, as evidenced by after-school programming, highlights their adaptability to contexts outside traditional education. the assignment of badges by teachers, tutors, and trainers to individual students represents a personalized approach to skill recognition, as it motivates students by providing feedback that is tangible and visually evident. this process not only values individual achievements but can also foster an educational climate focused on engagement and personal growth. furthermore, the widespread adoption of open badges reflects a growing awareness of recognizing skills acquired outside traditional academic pathways. this trend contributes to a cultural shift towards a more comprehensive and diversified evaluation system, considering practical and transversal skills as much as theoretical knowledge. the open badge plays a multifunctional role, acting on different levels of engagement. at the individual level, it can contribute to self-esteem and stimulate self-assessment processes. its presence at the group level manifests in the ability to recognize a step or milestone achieved in a public setting. additionally, the open badge can provide teachers with valuable information about each student's choices at the institutional level, facilitating a deeper understanding of their perspectives and learning paths (loughlin c. et al., 2017). the use of the open badge as an accreditation system can be examined from two perspectives. first, it can be considered a tool for describing skills, knowledge, competencies, or dispositions in more detail than formal certifications provided by degrees, like diplomas and bachelor's degrees. from this perspective, the open badge can offer a more articulated representation of the abilities acquired during specific training paths. secondly, it can be used to attribute credentials to "other" learning experiences compared to formal ones, recognizing skills acquired outside traditional school contexts. the open badge is configured as a standard field where three categories of entities or individuals converge. the "issuers" are entities and associations that issue badges, organizing courses or activities certified through such badges. the "earners" are users who participate in these courses or activities, collecting european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/12054 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license this article is not subject to double-blind peer review and is part of the practitioners perspective section for 2025. 25 badges as evidence of the skills acquired during the training path. the "users" are employers or training professionals who also evaluate people by analyzing the badges earned (la rocca c., 2020). badges play a fundamental role as they offer various benefits at different levels: ● at the individual level, digital badges are a powerful tool, representing a diverse set of skills and competencies acquired in various learning contexts. these easily verifiable online badges provide tangible recognition of one's skills, becoming a visible testament to an individual's abilities and enhancing their professional growth. ● at the institutional level: badges officially recognize the learning of skills acquired through structured training activities within specific pathways. this institutional recognition adds validation and authenticity to the acquired skills, helping to build a documented trace of an individual's educational journey. moreover, it provides institutions with a clear view of the competencies of participants in their training programs. ● at the inter-institutional level: badges facilitate a more effective and rapid verification of competency levels. they allow for a more straightforward assessment of an individual's abilities through diverse learning experiences, which eliminates some communication barriers between different institutions. this inter-institutional verification process helps to create a more complete picture of an individual's competencies, facilitating recognition by external entities (raffaghelli j.e. 2014). in recent years, education has witnessed an increasing adoption of digital badges as a tool to document and validate individuals' competencies. however, despite the benefits of digital badges, challenges related to the authenticity, integrity, and security of digital credentials persist. moreover, the need for an interoperable and standardized system for managing and validating digital badges remains a fundamental goal to ensure such credentials' maximum effectiveness and reliability in modern education. in this context, blockchain technology emerges as a potential solution to address these challenges and further optimize the use of digital credentials in education. with its decentralized structure, blockchain represents a secure and reliable tool for ensuring the authenticity and integrity of digital credentials, allowing for transparent and verifiable management of individuals' competencies (holotescu c., 2018). blockchain offers the possibility of eliminating the threat of forgeries of issued degrees. due to its nature, this technology provides high security, protecting academic documents from manipulation or counterfeiting (avni r. et al., 2023). blockchain is a technology that provides a publicly shared and immutable ledger, european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/12054 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license this article is not subject to double-blind peer review and is part of the practitioners perspective section for 2025. 26 representing a significant step in the evolution of data management. the fundamental characteristic of blockchain is its immutability (hofmann f. et al., 2017). once data has been recorded on a block of the chain, it becomes permanent and cannot be altered or deleted. moreover, blockchain provides an ideal environment for integrating data analysis techniques. thanks to its distributed structure and the availability of a complete historical record of transactions, blockchain allows data analytics algorithms to extract useful information and identify significant patterns or trends in the data (choi m. et al., 2019). in particular, blockcerts are an innovative application of blockchain technology in digital credential management. blockcerts are a standard format for the digital expression of certificates, credentials, and other types of attestations of skills or achievements. this format, developed by the mit media lab, leverages blockchain technology to ensure digital credentials' authenticity, integrity, and transparency. in practice, a blockcert is a digital certificate recorded on the blockchain, thus creating a permanent and immutable trace of the certificate itself (gräther w. et al., 2018). each blockcert contains detailed information about the attestation it represents, such as the name of the title or skill, the date of achievement, the issuing entity, and other relevant information. registering a blockcert on the blockchain involves creating a transaction containing the document's digital fingerprint, or hash. . once this transaction has been confirmed and added to the blockchain, the blockcert becomes available for public and independent verification. the distinctive feature of blockcerts is that they allow holders to share their digital credentials securely and transparently without the need for intermediaries or central authorities. moreover, since blockcerts use the blockchain, they remain immutable and resist manipulation, thus ensuring the long-term authenticity of credentials (jirgensons m. et al., 2018). blockcerts are an innovative way to issue, manage, and verify digital credentials using blockchain technology. this standard offers numerous advantages, including increased security, transparency, and efficiency in the accreditation and verification process of skills and achievements. adopting open badge and notarized blockcerts systems in the blockchain for validating degrees has become a reality in several italian public universities. in 2019, the universities of padua and milano-bicocca were the first in italy to use cineca's bestr platform, implementing open badges and blockcerts to certify academic degrees on ethereum, the public blockchain used for bestr certificates. both have also participated in an international project led by the mit media lab to create an ecosystem to ensure the portability and verifiability of academic institutions' degrees european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/12054 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license this article is not subject to double-blind peer review and is part of the practitioners perspective section for 2025. 27 without consulting the issuing entity. with the continuous development of the educational and professional landscape, open badges thus emerge as a fundamental tool for unlocking the potential of continuous learning and enhancing the skills acquired. open badges represent an innovative form of digital certification with the primary goal of enhancing the skills of individuals and promoting a culture of continuous learning. 3. goals digital badges represent an innovative form of recognition of the skills and achievements of individuals, using technology to offer a more personalized and flexible learning experience. these badges attest to the acquisition of specific skills or milestones. one of the main objectives of digital badges is to motivate individuals to engage in learning and achieve specific goals. these badges provide a tangible form of recognition for acquired skills, whether formal knowledge gained through academic courses or informal skills developed through work or volunteer experiences. additionally, digital badges allow for recognising skills and abilities that traditionally might not have been valued or recognized, such as critical thinking, collaboration, and leadership. another essential objective of digital badges is to promote the development of individuals' metacognitive skills, particularly self-regulation abilities. through digital badges, learners can set their learning goals, monitor their progress, and reflect on their learning experiences. this process of metacognitive reflection helps individuals become more aware of their capabilities and develop effective strategies to improve their learning over time. they offer students a way to receive immediate feedback on their learning from both teachers and peers. personalized feedback, provided through personal dashboards, helps students better understand the objectives and tasks required to complete the course and reflect on their progress over time. the future of open badges looks exciting and full of potential. digital badges are likely to continue to evolve and become more embedded in the educational and professional environment (clements k. et al., 2020). among future trends, greater recognition of non-formal and informal learning through digital badges and increased adoption of badges as a tool for recognizing skills in the workplace are expected. furthermore, digital badges are predicted to become increasingly personalized and adaptable to the needs and interests of individual learners. thanks to technology, badges will be able to be integrated into a wide range of european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/12054 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license this article is not subject to double-blind peer review and is part of the practitioners perspective section for 2025. 28 platforms and digital environments, enabling individuals to quickly and effectively display and share their skills and achievements. open badges are powerful tools for recognizing skills and supporting individual learning. they contribute to promoting a culture of lifelong learning adapted to the needs of the contemporary world. in particular, the university plays a crucial role in promoting the economic growth and resilience of the country through a series of initiatives and services it provides to individuals. first, it offers innovative and relevant academic programs that equip students with the essential digital and technological skills needed to meet the challenges of the modern workplace. these skills include knowledge of digital tools and platforms, the ability to analyze data critically, and flexibility in adapting to rapid technological changes. additionally, the university fosters innovation and economic development through research and collaboration with industry, contributing to creating and disseminating cutting-edge knowledge and technologies. simultaneously, it encourages entrepreneurship and innovation among students and academic community members, providing support and resources to turn ideas into successful entrepreneurial ventures. 3.1 social impact of digital credentials digital credentials, particularly open badges, play a transformative role in modern education and labour markets by promoting inclusivity and accessibility. these tools democratize recognising skills and competencies acquired through formal and non-formal education, thus supporting lifelong learning pathways. this inclusivity is pivotal in fostering equal opportunities for all learners, regardless of socioeconomic background. open badges serve as a bridge between education and employment, providing a transparent and verifiable way to showcase soft skills and non-traditional learning experiences. these experiences are often undervalued in conventional education systems. the visibility provided by open badges not only aids learners in underserved communities but also encourages diverse hiring practices among employers, thereby promoting a more inclusive workforce. open badges, when implemented, can significantly impact social mobility. they provide a verifiable and respected method to display one's skills and achievements, empowering individuals to advance their careers and educational pursuits more effectively. this is particularly beneficial for marginalized groups european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/12054 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license this article is not subject to double-blind peer review and is part of the practitioners perspective section for 2025. 29 who may lack traditional academic credentials but possess valuable skills gained through practical experience. open badges also enhance educational and occupational mobility across borders by facilitating more accessible validation of skills and achievements. this global recognition can lead to more excellent employment opportunities and contribute to economic growth, thus supporting the sustainable development goals of reducing inequality within and among countries. 3.2 university of turinopen badge case study the adoption of open badge and notarized blockcerts systems on blockchain for the certification of academic qualifications has become a reality in several italian public universities. this innovation simplifies the process of validating qualifications and complements the issuance of traditional certificates. in 2019, the universities of padua and milan-bicocca were the first in italy to use the bestr platform to certify their academic qualifications through open badge and blockcerts. both universities also participated in an international project led by the mit media lab aimed at creating an ecosystem to ensure the portability and verifiability of academic qualifications without needing to consult the issuing institution. the university of turin (unito) has now joined the list of six italian universities using blockchainnotarized blockcerts via bestr, positioning itself as the second among large universities to adopt this innovation. by promoting digital credentials, unito contributes to spreading a culture that values digital skills and aligns with the objectives outlined in the national recovery and resilience plan (pnrr). these efforts are consistent with pnrr initiatives focused on enhancing active labor market policies, professional training, and the national education system. unito’s promotion of digital credentials not only ensures students' skills keep pace with industry demands but also plays a significant role in fostering lifelong learning and encouraging adult participation in professional training and skills development opportunities. specifically, the university of turin has developed its first ecosystem for (micro)digital credentials through the "premialità 2023" project. micro-credentials are a significant tool for certifying short, targeted learning experiences, in compliance with article 6 of law 341/1990, which pertains to focused training and supplemental educational services. the project introduced several measures to optimize and automate european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/12054 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license this article is not subject to double-blind peer review and is part of the practitioners perspective section for 2025. 30 various aspects of creating and assigning digital credentials at the university while also implementing technical innovations. the most notable innovation was the creation and issuance of the university’s first digital credentials tied to academic qualifications. particular attention was given to providing a distinct visual identity for unito’s open badge and blockcerts that certify the attainment of academic titles. defining a graphic identity for open badges involved a multidisciplinary collaboration, including the web and e-learning editorial office of the school of management and economics, technical-administrative staff, and teams responsible for multimedia systems and e-learning infrastructures and staff e-learning, online collaboration and architecture. the multidisciplinary approach and synergetic collaboration between these different structure contributed significantly to the success of the creative process. another significant innovation was the introduction of a previously unused type of digital credential: blockcerts. the bestr platform allows accredited bodies to create and issue digital certificates, called blockcerts, which are used in particular by universities to certify degrees. blockcerts are digital certificates leveraging blockchain technology to guarantee the authenticity and security of data. developed as an opensource solution by mit media lab, blockcerts allow institutions to issue, verify, and store digital certificates in a decentralized and transparent manner. an institution can then create blockcerts and register the fingerprint (hash) of the document (notarisation) on a blockchain. the blockchain is like an immutable ledger that proves the existence of the certificate. after issuing, the blockcerts are sent to recipients, who can store them on personal devices or digital wallets. verification of the certificate’s authenticity is straightforward, relying on public and secure blockchain data, eliminating the risks of fraud or forgery. the notarisation process does not involve storing personal user data on the blockchain, ensuring the information's security. the blockcerts certificate contains detailed information about the certification, including the visual of the open badge, the issuing university, the graduate's name, the degree programme, the eqf levels, the date of graduation and the digital signature of the rector. in the unito context, the rector's digital signature and the university of turin logo complete the certificate and provide elements of authenticity. this process helps to ensure the integrity and transparency of the digital credentials, underlining the university of turin's commitment to the adoption of innovative technologies for the reliable management of academic certificates (presutti k. et al. 2023). european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/12054 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license this article is not subject to double-blind peer review and is part of the practitioners perspective section for 2025. 31 unito has also optimized the process of assigning digital credentials as part of the "premialità 2023" project. the bestr platform handles open badge assignments through a process that typically involves the creation and uploading of a .csv file containing the learner's personal information required to assign the digital certificate. however, in order to facilitate and speed up this process, especially considering the detailed information associated with graduates, an integration between bestr and the esse3 platform has been implemented. thus, the graduate will have the possibility to receive the certificate in the form of an open badge as well as in the form of blockcerts in combination with the ob. this additional option guarantees the permanent authenticity of the certificate on the public ethereum blockchain. in order to receive the blockcerts, the graduate must download the blockcerts wallet app on their mobile phone and save their passphrase, thus obtaining a unique identifier associated with the blockcerts. the app plays a key role in managing the blockcerts identifier and communicating it to organisations authorised to issue these digital credentials. it will also enable the storage and sharing of all blockcerts received. once in possession of the identifier, the graduate must notify the university of his or her wish to be allocated the blockcerts. by adding the organisation to the authorised issuers within the app, the graduate can use the mobile device to scan the qr code provided by the bestr english page and add the university of turin as an issuer. at this point, bestr will be able to write the blockcerts and store them on the blockchain. the process takes time: the graduate will be notified by email when the blockcerts are ready and can find them on their bestr profile. to access them, visit the 'my badges' page on bestr. this innovative and automated approach dramatically simplifies the collection of blockcerts, while guaranteeing the security and permanent verifiability of the credentials via the blockchain (presutti k. et al. 2023). in the future, this process could be further refined, paving the way for greater integration and automation of processes related to digital certificates. 3.3 survey in the context of the project, the orientation, tutoring and placement (otp) office initiated a detailed investigation through an online survey sent to 357 learners, all recipients of ob and part of the project's target. these learners come from various study paths, including 134 graduates from a master's degree in economics and management, 111 graduates from a master's degree in business administration, 86 european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/12054 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license this article is not subject to double-blind peer review and is part of the practitioners perspective section for 2025. 32 graduates from a master's degree in environmental, cultural, and territorial economics, and 26 graduates from the master's degree in statistical and economic methods for decisions. the survey aimed to record the pre-existing knowledge of digital tools and explore the learners' expectations. data were collected through questionnaires, some of which were completed non-anonymously to ensure greater accuracy in the responses. additionally, the questionnaire was extended to another 1,200 ob recipients at unito who participated in doctoral courses, professional courses, seminars, and other training events. this data collection extension was anonymous to encourage honest participation (presutti k. et al., 2023). simultaneously, 171 companies were selected according to specific criteria, including 50 companies that hosted curricular interns from the project's target group. these 79 companies hosted curricular interns from the degree programs in economics and management and business administration during the period from 04/01/2022 to 03/31/2023, 13 companies that participated in the job orientation program in the academic year 22/23 and 29 exemplary companies that hosted more than five curricular interns from the school of management and economics (sme) study programs in the indicated period. the purpose of the survey of these companies was to investigate their awareness and use of digital credentials such as obs and blockcerts, and to gather feedback on the effectiveness of the information content conveyed through these credentials, particularly in relation to recruitment activities. later, the questionnaire was distributed to include companies that had signed agreements for conducting internships and those that had requested the publication of announcements for curricular internships. the otp office of the school of management and economics at unito managed these administrative processes. as of 06/30/2024, 255 questionnaires had been sent out. the results of this survey are expected to provide valuable insights into the perspectives and expectations of learners and companies regarding digital tools and certifications. these insights will enable the development of targeted strategies and interventions to improve the integration of such tools in the academic and work environments, potentially transforming how we approach education and recruitment. the survey found interesting things about learners' adoption of ob and corporate recruiters' perceptions of them. the data collected show that obs are increasingly widespread among learners, who use them as concrete evidence of their skills and abilities. however, it was observed that most corporate recruiters need more knowledge of this form of skill recognition. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/12054 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license this article is not subject to double-blind peer review and is part of the practitioners perspective section for 2025. 33 the analysis of the results from the questionnaires shows that only 30 out of 444 questionnaires sent to companies received responses, and just seven companies had received cvs or linkedin profiles that included obs. on the other hand, among the anonymous learners who responded to the questionnaire (101 in total), 57 had already included obs on their cv/linkedin profile or website/email. nine of the nonanonymous learners (17 responses) incorporated obs into their online documents. these data highlight a discrepancy between the adoption of obs by learners and their presence in corporate recruitment processes. however, the absence of prior studies in this area presents a significant research opportunity, which could help bridge this gap and provide further insights into the effectiveness of obs in the workplace context. 4. conclusion open badges represent a fundamental resource for learners, offering various advantages that underline their importance and usefulness in the academic and working context. these tools are characterized by a powerful visual impact that makes them particularly effective in communicating acquired skills. moreover, their open and interoperable nature allows any system that supports the open-source standard to read their metadata through public and international tools like validators. it is important to emphasize that obs are guaranteed by the issuing entity and certified on the bestr platform, thus offering recognized and reliable validity. among the main advantages of obs for learners is the increased spendability and verifiability of acquired skills. the presence of obs in digital cvs makes them more precise and communicative, facilitating participation in e-recruiting selections and offering the possibility to verify skills in real time without intermediaries. obs enhance acquired skills and make them visible in the learner's ob e-portfolio, thus highlighting their educational and professional path. this improves their credibility in the eyes of potential employers. this aids their growth and employability. another significant advantage is sharing digital credentials with educational entities or companies internationally through social networks like linkedin. by downloading and sending the badge image from the dedicated page or linking it directly, recruiters can verify the integrity and validity of the ob as though they had contacted the issuing entity (unito) for confirmation. open badges represent a valuable tool for learners, offering a range of advantages that enhance their skills and integration into the academic and working world (devedzic v. et al., 2015). european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/12054 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license this article is not subject to double-blind peer review and is part of the practitioners perspective section for 2025. 34 adopting digital credentials through open badges and blockcerts represents a significant step towards modernization and innovation in the italian academic sector. this approach simplifies the qualification validation process and is crucial in creating a dynamic and transparent ecosystem for managing academic credentials. furthermore, the integration of new technologies, like the bestr platform, and the existing student information management system, like esse3, represents a tangible example of how technology can simplify and accelerate administrative processes while ensuring the security and authenticity of digital credentials. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/12054 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license this article is not subject to double-blind peer review and is part of the practitioners perspective section for 2025. 35 references baratto g., caramagna m., giraudo c., lasala a., natale f., presutti k., vindigni f. (2024) toward an ecosystem for digital credentials: projects and challenges of the university of turin for lifelong and lifewide learning certifications. in: ullah, a., anwar, s., calandra, d., di fuccio, r. (eds) proceedings of international conference on information technology and applications. icita 2022. lecture notes in networks and systems, vol 839. springer, singapore. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-981-99-8324-7_13 choi m., rupali kiran s., oh s., kwon o. (2019). blockchain-based badge award with existence proof, applied sciences. 9 https://doi.org/10.3390/app9122473 clements, k., west, r. e., & hunsaker, e. (2020). getting started with open badges and open microcredentials. https://doi.org/10.19173/irrodl.v21i1.4529 devedzic, v., & jovanovic, j. (2015). developing open badges: a comprehensive approach. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11423-015-9388-3 gräther, w., kolvenbach, s., ruland, r., schütte, j., ferreira torres, c., & wendland, f. (2018). blockchain for education: lifelong learning passport. https://doi.org/10.18420/blockchain2018_07 hofmann, f., wurster, s., eyal, r., & boehmecke-schwafert, m. (2017). the immutability concept of blockchains and benefits of early standardization. https://doi.org/10.23919/itu-wt.2017.8247004 holotescu, c. (2018). understanding blockchain opportunities and challenges. https://doi.org/10.12753/2066-026x-22-253 jirgensons, m., & kapenieks, j. (2018). blockchain and the future of digital learning credential assessment and management. https://doi.org/10.2478/jtes-2018-0009 kerver, b., & riksen, d. (2016). whitepaper on open badges and microcredentials. surf nl. https://doi.org/10.4018/978-1-7998-4360-3.ch011 la rocca c. (2020). open badge a scopo formativo: resoconto di una esperienza didattica in ambito universitario. ecps journal – 21/2020 https://doi.org/10.7358/ecps-2020-021-laro loughlin, c., hitchings, c., barton, c., anthoney, j., barker, h., warburton, s., & niculescu, i. (2017). open badges: acknowledging soft skills acquisition. mikroyannidis, a., domingue, j., bachler, m., & quick, k. (2020). smart blockchain badges for data science education. https://doi.org/10.1109/fie.2018.8659012 https://link.springer.com/chapter/10.1007/978-981-99-8324-7_13#auth-gabriele-baratto https://link.springer.com/chapter/10.1007/978-981-99-8324-7_13#auth-manuela-caramagna https://link.springer.com/chapter/10.1007/978-981-99-8324-7_13#auth-cristina-giraudo https://link.springer.com/chapter/10.1007/978-981-99-8324-7_13#auth-annunziata-lasala https://link.springer.com/chapter/10.1007/978-981-99-8324-7_13#auth-francesca-natale https://link.springer.com/chapter/10.1007/978-981-99-8324-7_13#auth-katia-presutti https://link.springer.com/chapter/10.1007/978-981-99-8324-7_13#auth-floriana-vindigni https://doi.org/10.1007/978-981-99-8324-7_13 https://doi.org/10.1007/978-981-99-8324-7_13 https://doi.org/10.3390/app9122473 https://doi.org/10.3390/app9122473 https://doi.org/10.19173/irrodl.v21i1.4529 https://doi.org/10.19173/irrodl.v21i1.4529 https://doi.org/10.18420/blockchain2018_07 https://doi.org/10.23919/itu-wt.2017.8247004 http://dx.doi.org/10.2478/jtes-2018-0009 https://doi.org/10.4018/978-1-7998-4360-3.ch011 https://doi.org/10.4018/978-1-7998-4360-3.ch011 https://doi.org/10.4018/978-1-7998-4360-3.ch011 https://doi.org/10.7358/ecps-2020-021-laro https://doi.org/10.7358/ecps-2020-021-laro http://dx.doi.org/10.1109/fie.2018.8659012 european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/12054 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license this article is not subject to double-blind peer review and is part of the practitioners perspective section for 2025. 36 presutti, k., baratto, g., & caramagna, m. (2023). ecosistema bestr per le (micro) credenziali digitali unito: open badge, blockcerts e blockchain per il lifelong and lifewide learning presutti, k., natale, f. (2024). adopting blockchain for educational qualifications in italy: the experience of the university of turin. in: de bem machado, a., sousa, m.j., dal mas, f., secinaro, s., calandra, d. (eds) digital transformation in higher education institutions. eai/springer innovations in communication and computing. springer, cham. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-031-52296-3_11 raffaghelli, j. e. (2014). open digital badges: tecnologie a supporto della valutazione per il lifelong learning. rustemi a., atanasovski v., risteski a., latkoski p., (2023). challenges of blockchain in higher education institutions for protection against diploma forgery. doi: 1-6. 10.1109/balkancom58402.2023.10167986. spencer, a. (2020). the certificate of competence in english for the social services’: using open badges to supplement and integrate traditional university credits in esp. tsou, m.-h., & smith, j. (2011). free and open source software https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-031-52296-3_11 02_cordrie european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7603 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 17 regional demolition waste treatment capacity: a case study based on the identification of building selective deconstruction value chain’s stakeholders benjamin cordrie1 and emmanuel lemelin 2* 1 teacher-researcher, unilasalle rennes – ecole des métiers de l’environnement, cyclann, campus de ker lann, 35170 bruz, france benjamin.cordrie@unilasalle.fr 2 (contact author) centre for materials and processes, imt nord europe, institut mines-télécom, university of lille, f-59000 lille, (france) emmanuel.lemelin@imt-nord-europe.fr abstract the construction and demolition sector is a major contributor to waste generation, prompting european and national public authorities to adopt a waste management strategy based on circular economy (ce) principles. this strategy aims to promote the reuse and recycling of construction materials. a key prerequisite for this strategy is selective deconstruction, which allows for more efficient waste recovery by separating materials based on their treatment, reuse, recycling and landfill potential. selective deconstruction involves a value chain that includes a range of stakeholders. this paper proposes a methodology for identifying the stakeholders involved in this value chain, from project owners to waste reclamation and recycling companies. this methodology is applied to the lille european metropolis (france – lem) to estimate the deconstruction resources treatment capacity of this region (drtcr). finally, this capacity is analysed in relation to the volume of resources generated by deconstruction, and to the objectives set by the circular economy strategy. results demonstrate the importance of developing selective deconstruction at a local scale, and highlight the need for investment in this sector and potential of sustainable business. keywords: circular economy; construction and demolition waste; selective deconstruction; stakeholders; resources management; regional capacity. 1. introduction the transition from a linear to a circular economic model aims to optimize resource use to preserve natural capital (ellen macarthur foundation, 2015). throughout the 20th century, the increasing mechanization of the demolition industry and declining profitability of building materials' reusing operations led to significant growth in construction and demolition waste (c&dw) production (ghyoot et al., 2018). in 2018, the construction and demolition (c&d) sector accounted for 35.9% (2.337 million tonnes) of the waste generated in the eu, making it the primary source of waste production (eurostat). in france, 47.3 million tonnes of c&dw were produced in that year. in response to this problem, the concept of a circular economy (ce) european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7603 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 18 emerged in the academic literature in the early 2000s, becoming a key category of public policy in countries such as germany1, japan2, china3 or the netherlands4. the european waste framework directive 2008/98/ec sets a target of 70% for nonhazardous c&d waste reuse, recycling, and material recovery by 2020 (european parliament, 2008). in line with this goal, the french parliament passed a "no-waste for a circular economy" law in 2020 (parliament, 2020). in the c&d sector, selective deconstruction is a way to implement ce principles by replacing building demolition with a process that separates materials according to different treatment, reuse, and recycling sectors (roussat et al., 2009; assefa and ambler, 2017; ghyoot et al., 2018). although private companies and public authorities increasingly use selective deconstruction, little academic literature specifically addresses this issue. some research focuses on new deconstruction methods and programming (sanchez et al., 2019, 2020). however, the development of selective deconstruction involves a value chain consisting of actors not only directly involved in the building site but also upstream and downstream (tirado et al., 2021). the full commitment of owners, prime contractors, and project management assistance specialized in ce issues is required during the earliest phase of deconstruction to coordinate the various stages and actors of the worksite. moreover, once materials are deconstructed, their treatment, reuse, or recycling may involve a range of different sectors. therefore, the development of selective deconstruction potentially concerns many different stakeholders and jobs (gálvez-martos et al., 2018). this study focuses on estimating the stakeholders and employment potential involved in an advanced selective deconstruction value chain, specifically in the lille european metropolis (lem)5 and its 95 municipalities. through building an exhaustive database of potential stakeholders, from clients and contractors to waste reclamation and recycling companies (figure 1), this article aims to provide an overview of the ce development potential. this database is utilized to estimate the capacity of actors located in this area to treat resources generated by selective deconstruction. more specifically, the deconstruction resources treatment capacity of a region or area (drtcr) refers to two parameters of the construction and demolition waste management (c&dw-m): (1) the volume of products, equipment, materials, and waste resulting from selective deconstruction and generated per year from one region. for ce concept, having been removed selectively, those materials correspond with potential resources that can be recycled, recovered or re-used into building construction or rehabilitation. then (2) the ability of workers employed by companies in the value chain and established in the area to process these resources define this capacity. the goal is to determine the ability of one region/area to generate c&dw and its capacity to close loops in the building industry. the focus is placed on the labour force that directly handles these resources, by working on building sites, removing construction elements, transporting them to a treatment center, sorting them and preparing them for theirs recycling, recovery or re-use. therefore, the drtcr highly relies on the size of the workforce of the value chain, which is precisely the focus of the proposed methodology. the interest could be to help decision makers in regional communities to orientate and facilitate the implementation of public and/or private infrastructures optimizing the drtcr of the c&dw-m. figure 1. actors in the selective deconstruction value chain source: author’s elaboration, adapted from (lofti, 2016) the article first describes the multiscale regulatory framework that makes ce the main waste management strategy in the c&d sector, at the european, french and sub-national levels. the study then moves to literature review section, followed by a section describing the methodology used to create the database and estimate the drtcr. the last section is dedicated to the main results and their discussion. firstly, it determines the drtcr of the lem, and compares it with the estimated volume of [1] waste management law in a “closed-cycle substances” (“kreislaufwirtschaftsgesetz”) adopted in 1994. [2] “basic act for establishing a sound material-cycle society” adopted in 2000. [3] framework law to promote circular economy adopted in 2008. [4] national waste management plan 2009–2021 entitled “towards a material chain policy”. [5] this article and the results it presents are the fruit of a research project carried out within an industrial chair called « reconvert » and financed by lille european metropolis and i-site. url : https://reconvert.wp.imt.fr/ european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7603 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 19 waste generated in this area. then, it examines the objectives fixed by public authorities in their ce strategies, showing that their achievement requires an increased drtcr that could address gaps in the selective deconstruction value chain. 2. contextualisation : an evolving regulatory framework the legislative and regulatory framework at european, national, and sub-national levels demonstrates a clear and increasingly ambitious path towards the implementation of a ce in the c&d sector. beginning in 2008, the european union established a directive with the aim of achieving a 70% re-use, recycling, and material recovery rate for non-hazardous c&d waste. according to a 2020 report of the european environment information and observation network, most of european countries have already reach this 70% target, but “despite [these] high recycling rates, the recycling of c&dw is largely downcycling” (eionet, 2020, p. 12). moreover, this global rate masks substantial variations in material flows. while inert waste represents the largest volume and is relatively easy to recover, there is now a need for a more detailed waste management strategy, by adopting more precise objectives for each material. in 2015, the european commission adopted a circular economy package aimed at pushing forward the transition towards a circular economy. this package notably promotes the recycling of waste materials and sets targets for reducing landfilling. the european commission reaffirmed its commitment to the ce strategy five years later, as part of the european green deal. this broader plan sets more ambitious objectives, and notably aims to achieve a climate-neutral europe by 2050. similarly, france government established the grenelle law 2 in 2010, which outlined a waste planning strategy that ultimately led to the implementation of waste diagnostics for building demolition in the 2014-2020 national waste prevention program. in 2015, the "notre" law (territorial organization reform) transferred waste planning jurisdiction to the regions, while the law for energy transition and green growth established the circular economy concept as a guiding principle for the first time. by 2018, the french government had made ce a cornerstone of its waste management strategy through the circular economy roadmap, which aimed to increase sorting, re-use, and recovery of demolition waste. two years later, the "no-waste for a circular economy" law further solidified this commitment by introducing an extended producer responsibility (epr) for construction material manufacturers and setting specific objectives for recovery rates for various materials. the epr establishes an eco-contribution on the sales of construction products and materials, which is collected by sellers and transferred to producer responsibility organizations (pros). the pros are responsible for organizing the collection, treatment, and recovery of building waste and material. the "no-waste for a circular economy" law aims for a recovery rate of 88% for mineral waste and 57% for non-mineral waste by 2027. precise objectives related to particular materials flows are also set, and their implications in terms of volume will be explored at the lem level in section 5. at the sub-national level in france, which refers to governance and decision-making below the national level, public actors have taken significant steps towards promoting circular economy practices. since 2015, regions, which are the administrative level beneath the state, have taken over jurisdiction of waste planning, which is carried out through regional waste prevention and management plans. these plans outline strategies to prevent waste generation and promote circular economy practices, and are specific to each region in france. for example, the hauts-de-france region, which includes the lem area, established a waste prevention and management plan in 2019, outlining its key objectives and an action plan for circular economy, with a particular focus on c&d materials. regions also have to draw up a regional plan for land use, sustainable developmtent and territorial equality. that of hauts-de-france, adopted in 2020, gives a prominent place to the implementation of ce in the c&d sectors, with specific objectives such as landfilling reduction, development of on-site sorting, and expansion of a territorial grid of recovery sites. although these objectives address specific issues, their lack of precision and quantification makes it difficult to evaluate progress towards a more sustainable c&dw-m. instead of setting specific targets, these planning documents outline the general ambitions of local authorities regarding urban planning, transportation, waste management, and energy. as shown in figure 2, this kind of strategic documents is also implemented at the metropolitan and municipal levels. in particular, lem adopted a territorial coherence plan in 2017, and a territorial air-climate-energy plan four years later, with each setting ce objectives such as encouraging c&d waste re-use and recovery, promoting the develoment of recycling channels, or land using for waste recovery. finally, in this multiscale regulatory framework, municipalities have also make ce a key strategy for resources management in the c&d sector. lille for instance, the main city of the lem, has notably adopted a roadmap for circular economy in 2022, with the ambition of creating a local platform for exchange and treatment of construction materials. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7603 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 20 a these different scales, public authorities draw a clear path towards the implementation of ce in the c&d sector, establishing more and more precise and ambitious objectives related to resources recovery. figure 2. local authorities’ planning documents promoting ce in the c&d sector source: author’s elaboration6 3. literature review while the concept of selective deconstruction itself still requires further exploration, there has been extensive research dedicated to the application of circular economy principles in the c&d sector. these studies can be broadly classified into two categories. the first focuses on the technical and organizational challenges associated with managing c&dw. the second group of studies takes the c&d sector as a case study to inform research on circular economy more broadly. in this context, employment is among the social aspects impacted by the adoption of circular economy practices. 3.1 the construction and demolition waste management an important part of the literature dealing with ce in the c&d sector comprises engineering science works that focus on technical and organizational processes related to c&dw-m. these works study the recovery of specific types of materials, such as concrete, metal, timber, plaster, plastic, and glass (gorgolewski et al., 2008; jung et al., 2015; wijayasundara et al., 2016; campbell, 2018; mazzarano, 2021), or look at a particular type of building (minunno et al., 2018). these studies suggest strategies for ce development in the sector, such as on-site recycling, manufacturing recycled aggregate, use of mass timber, but point out the fact that those strategies require improvements in organizational structures, technical knowledge, and investment in infrastructures. one of the main method used in the field is the life cycle analysis (coelho and de brito, 2012; bovea and powell, 2016; wang et al., 2018; brambilla et al., 2019; l. eberhardt et al., 2019), which allows authors to highlight the environmental impact of waste demolition, and to investigate potential benefits of ce practices, which could concern the waste management as well as the building process and the type of components used in the construction. moreover, the effectiveness of c&dw-m at the country or region scale were evaluated in the aims of improving it (yeheyis et al., 2013; lockrey et al., 2016; nasir et al., 2017; yuan, 2017; zheng et al., 2017; huang et al., 2018; christmann, 2018). those works aim at pushing policy-makers towards improvement in c&d waste management, by proposing ce strategies and objectives such as increasing recycling rate and reducing lanfill rate, adopting targeted economic incentives, or encouraging innovative [6] all the documents mentionned are available online, on the websites of the hauts-de-france region: https://www.hautsdefrance.fr/ ; the lem: https://www.lillemetropole.fr/ ; and the city of lille: https://www.lille.fr/ european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7603 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 21 technologies and market models. other works examine waste treatment capacities in terms of the types of facilities (mihai, 2019) or technologies used (di maria et al., 2018). those studies are completed by the approach taken here, that aims to cover this issue of treatment capacities, in regard to the stakeholders of an region or area and their available labour force, as stated above in the definition of drtcr. indeed, although those works are of great interest for estimating generation and flows of c&d waste, especially through material flow analysis, and for exploring ways to reduce them, few of them aim to investigate stakeholders that are likely to take charge of these waste. that is why the next subsection deals with approaches in terms of ce social aspects that are, in this regard, complementary. 3.2 circular economy in the construction and demolition sector and its social aspects the methods for measuring and quantifying the circular economy have stimulated significant reflection and research. as results, the identification of a set of indicators that could reflect the circularity of a sector or a region has been extensively studied and discussed (iacovidou et al., 2017; nuñez-cacho et al., 2018; scarpellini et al., 2019; fusco girard and nocca, 2019). employment is often included as one of these indicators and considered in the social aspects of ce (international labour organization, 2011; moreau et al., 2017, 2017; laurenti et al., 2018; jabbour et al., 2019; padilla-rivera et al., 2020; scarpellini, 2021). these studies highlight the socioeconomic embeddedness of the ce and investigate its implementation's impacts, which extend beyond environmental considerations and affect the organization of work and employment within society. furthermore, substantial research has focused on the ce's job creation potential (horbach et al., 2015; mitchell and morgan, 2015; ehore, 2017; aranda-usón et al., 2018), as well as employment structure and distribution (repp et al., 2021), while some studies specifically address skills development (consoli et al., 2016; burger et al., 2019). this article follows the approach of llorente-gonzález and vence (2020), who studied the repair, reuse, and recycling sectors using the second revision of the statistical classification of economic activities in the european union (nace rev. 2). the authors' goal was to investigate the labour intensity of those activities defined as circular, on a european scale and using eurostat statistical aggregates. the present article shares a similar objective, at a smaller scale corresponding with a metropolitan area, which allows for a comprehensive identification of stakeholders in a specific value chain: that of building selective deconstruction. the academic interest in ce applied to the c&d sector is increasing, as evidenced by the growing number of systematic literature reviews (ghisellini et al., 2018a, 2018b; hossain et al., 2020; ruiz et al., 2020; superti et al., 2021). these studies aim to identity factors that could influence the adoption of ce in the sector, and their results suggest that a comprehensive framework and methodology for ce integration and evaluation are yet to be developed. to progress down this path, many studies focus on ce practices implemented by c&d companies (chau et al., 2017; leising et al., 2018; chang and hsieh, 2019; rehman et al., 2020; guerra et al., 2021; guerra and leite, 2021; doussoulin and bittencourt, 2022), and some provide analysis in terms of "best practices" (jiménez-rivero and garcía-navarro, 2017; gálvez-martos et al., 2018). other works explore the potential development of ce in the sector (schultmann and sunke, 2007; sassi, 2008; l. c. m. eberhardt et al., 2019; romnée et al., 2019), and the indicators that could reflect this development (nuñez-cacho et al., 2018). on the scale of a company, those indicators refer in particular to waste generation, energy management, emissions and other negative externalities, materials management or the 3r principles – reduce, recycle, and reuse. however, only a few studies examine the social aspects of the sector's transformations due to ce implementation (wuyts et al., 2019; tomić and schneider, 2020), or its consequences in terms of work practices (ann et al., 2013). this latter study, with the case of hong kong, showed that a charge on c&dw disposal to landfills may not be sufficient to encourage actors of the c&d sector to change their building practices so as to reduce waste. this litarature suggests that ce implementation in the building sector relies not only on changes in the regulatory framework, but also on stakeholders’ capacity to adapt their practices and organization to these challenges. as no specific academic works identify stakeholders of the selective deconstruction value chain exhaustively, the following method is here proposed. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7603 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 22 4. methodology 4.1 database construction the method developed is applied to the specific area of lem, in order to demonstrate its usefulness through a concrete case study. the metropolis covers an area of 671 km² and includes 95 municipalities, with a total population of approximately 1.1 million inhabitants. the metropolitan scale is particularly relevant to the issue of c&d waste management as it provides a consistent framework for optimizing material and waste streams, while also considering the environmental impact of transport. in order to create an inventory of all the companies that could potentially be involved in the deconstruction value chain and are located in lem, the database of the french national identification system and directory of enterprises and their establishments (sirene)7 was used. this database is administered by the french national statistical institute (insee)8, that provides data on a wide range of economic and social indicators. it contains information on every registered establishment in france and identifies each of them with a code that is related to their main activity. the codes used in this database are based on the french statistical classification of economic activities (naf)9, which operates on a similar principle as the european nace rev. 2. this approach builds on previous research, particularly in the field of industrial ecology (kasmi, 2018) and repair, reuse, and recycling activities (llorente-gonzález and vence, 2020). the activities were categorized based on the four main steps of the deconstruction value chain, namely, clients and general contractors, c&d companies, waste collection and treatment companies, and outlet industries. economic activity codes were selected through several methods. first, all codes that directly refer to the deconstruction value chain were selected. to ensure comprehensive coverage of the waste collection and treatment part, all c&dw collection points were identified using the tool provided by the french construction federation10 and added any missing codes. additionally, professional literature, particularly the démoclès project11, was consulted to match each type of waste with its potential forms of reusing and recycling. however, the potential missing part of the value chain is the non-profit organizations and social businesses sector. they may intervene in the deconstruction phase through job integration workshops, and in the recovery phase via resale and recycled goods shops12. although these activities are an integral part of the value chain, the associations carrying them out are generally registered under a code that refers specifically to their social aim, rather than an economic sector. to integrate them into the analysis, a census of these actors located in lem was conducted, using professional organizations’ directories13. as a result, 10 establishments operating in the building sector were added to the value chain. the database was subsequently refined by removing closed establishments and liquidated companies, and classifying each actor based on the type of materials they potentially handle. table 1 presents a comprehensive list of economic activities included in the database, along with the number of actors operating in the metropolitan area. although they are accountable for it, clients (real estate managers) and prime contractors are not directly involved in resources treatment, in the sense that their workforce do not directly handles them. in total, the database includes 802 actors across 35 activities. [7] “système national d’identification et du répertoire des entreprises et de leurs etablissements”. available online: https://www.sirene.fr/ [8] “institut national de la statistique et des études économiques”. url: https://www.insee.fr/ [9] “nomenclature d’activités française”. available online on the website of the insee. [10] source: www.dechets-chantier.ffbatiment.fr [11] source: www.democles.org/ [12] in france those actors are known as “ateliers chantiers d’insertion” (aci), “ressourceries” and “recycleries”. [13] those directories are available online : https://ressourceries.info/?fff ; http://www.lesentreprisesdinsertion.org/france/annuaireentreprises european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7603 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 23 table 1. overview of metropolitan actors potentially involved in the deconstruction value chain actors in the value chain economic activities number of establishments located in lem construction and demolition companies 43.11z – demolition 43.12a – levelling and grading of construction sites 43.12b – site preparation 43.99c – general masonry and structural work 43.99d – other specialised construction activities 12 58 11 329 38 waste collection and treatment companies 38.11z – collection of non-hazardous waste 38.12z – collection of hazardous waste 38.21z – treatment and disposal of non-hazardous waste 38.22z – treatment and disposal of hazardous waste 38.31z – dismantling of wrecks 38.32z – recovery of sorted materials 39.00z – remediation activities and other waste management services 08.12z – operation of gravel and sand pits; mining of clays and kaolin 46.72z – wholesale of metals and metal ores 46.73a – wholesale of wood and construction materials 46.77z – wholesale of waste and scrap 15 3 8 2 4 27 14 5 25 149 2 outlet industries 13.93z – manufacture of carpets and rugs 20.16z – manufacture of plastics in primary forms 20.30z – manufacture of paints, varnishes and similar coatings, printing ink and mastics 22.21z – manufacture of plastic plates, sheets, tubes and profiles 22.22z – manufacture of plastic packing goods 22.23z – manufacture of builders’ ware of plastic 22.29a – manufacture of plastic technical components 22.29b – manufacture of plastic consumer goods 23.51z – manufacture of cement 23.99z – manufacture of other non-metallic mineral products 24.42z – aluminium production 24.45z – other non-ferrous metal production 42.11z – construction of roads and motorways 42.99z – construction of other civil engineering projects 6 2 6 5 5 9 11 8 1 3 1 1 21 11 social and solidarity economy 82.99z – other business support service activities n.e.c. 85.59a – adult continuing education 88.10c – work-based social support 88.99a – other social work activities without accommodation n.e.c. 88.99b – social work activities without accommodation 1 2 1 1 5 source: author’s elaboration, codes refer to the nomenclature d’activités française (naf) and were translated using the statistical classification of economic activities in the european community headings (nace). 4.2 treatment capacities estimate the goal is to estimate the demolition waste treatment capacity of the stakeholders in the value chain, specifically focusing on c&d companies, waste collection and treatment companies, who are primarily responsible for managing waste generated by demolitions. the estimate of their waste treatment capacity is based on the database of the classified installations for european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7603 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 24 environmental protection (icpe)14. it is the french regulatory system for industrial facilities that have a potential impact on the environment and public health, and it contains information on every waste treatment facility in france. data concerning the principal activity code of each establishment, the types of waste treated, and the annual volumes treated for each type were extracted. as summarized in figure 3, using this information, an average treatment capacity per activity code per type of waste was determined, for the selected activity codes and materials that are part of demolition waste. to express the average capacities in tons per worked hour, the annual declaration of social data (dads)15 was utilized to obtain the average annual hours worked per worker per activity code. this database, which is not open-source, is established by the french national statistical institute (insee), and contains annual declarations of social data related to the employment of workers, such as wages, hours worked, social security contributions, and taxes, that french employers are required to submit to the public authorities. in addition to the information concerning the average annual worked hours, data about the distribution between workers, intermediate professions and managerial staff were also used. indeed, as the drtcr was defined in the introduction, it depends on the labour force that directly and concretely handles resources, and it therefore concerns annual hours worked by workers. figure 3. methodology for treatment capacities estimate per activity code and per material source: author’s elaboration using the average capacities per worked hour, the capacity of each establishment located in the lem area was estimated by referencing the employment size ranges. however, because not all workers treat every type of waste, a materials mass distribution of demolition waste was first applied to these capacities: two types of distributions were used (appendix 1), one that concerns ratios of c&dw estimated for the french epr implementation16 (“epr distribution”), the other corresponds with the study of legal declarations in france for demolition sites larger than 1000 square meters17 (“optigede distribution”). both were obtained from works conducted by the french environment and energy management agency (ademe)18, a public organization that operates under the supervision of the ministry for the ecological transition and solidarity, and aims to [14] "installations classées pour la protection de l’environnement". available online: https://www.georisques.gouv.fr/ [15] “déclarations annuelles de données sociales”. [16] ademe, terra, tbc innovactions, elcimai environnement, au-dev-ant, e. parola. 2021. etude de préfiguration de la filière rep produits et matériaux de construction du secteur du bâtiment. 29 pages. available online : https://librairie.ademe.fr/dechets-economie-circulaire/4573-etude-de-prefiguration-de-la-filiere-rep-produits-et-materiaux-deconstruction-du-secteur-du-batiment.html [17] ademe, optigede, estimation de la production de déchets de bâtiment. 5 pages. available online : https://optigede.ademe.fr/outils-pour-les-entreprises. [18] “agence de l'environnement et de la maîtrise de l'energie”. url: https://www.ademe.fr/ european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7603 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 25 promote the transition towards a sustainable and low-carbon society. these distributions allow to estimate the annual treatment capacity of each establishment for each type of waste. some of the construction and waste collection and treatment activities involve actors that not only treat c&dw, but also public works waste (roads). the building sector generates 19% of the waste generated by building and public works, according to the french ministry of ecological transition19. to account for this volume of waste, 81% of the total volume treated were deducted for activities related to public works waste. figure 4 provides an overview of the different steps took to estimate the total treatment capacity of demolition waste by actors of the lem. figure 4. overall methodology for total treatment capacity estimate source: author’s elaboration 5. results this methodology allows to examine the data pertaining to the selective deconstruction value chain in lem. table 2 presents an overview of the value chain's scope in terms of the number of establishments, employment figures, annual worked hours, and total net payroll, which surpasses 218 million euros. total gross payroll was calculated using the conversion ratio provided by the french ministry of labour, full employment and inclusion20. table 2. general data on the selective deconstruction value chain in lille european metropolis actors in the value chain number of establishments (lem) number of employees (mean of employment size ranges) total annual worked hours total net payroll (€) total gross payroll (€) construction and demolition companies 448 2 485 3 278 215 47 312 909 80 431 945 waste collection and treatment companies 254 4 162 6 124 887 87 274 754 148 367 081 outlet industries 90 2 990 4 335 500 73 311 810 124 630 077 social and solidarity economy 10 489 709 050 10 101 793 17 173 048 total 802 10 126 14 447 651 218 001 266 370 602 152 source: author’s elaboration, based on data of sirene and dads databases established by the french institut national de la statistique et des etudes economiques (insee) as a basis of comparison, eurostat data are referred to, and more specifically the wages and salaries by nace rev. 2 activity data. it provides data concerning the mean wages and salaries annually earned by a full-time employee, per activity. as shown [19] source: https://www.ecologie.gouv.fr/dechets-du-batiment [20] this ratio is 1.7. source: https://code.travail.gouv.fr/ european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7603 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 26 in table 3, nace rev. 2 activities corresponding with the four groups of actors in the value chain were selected. the number of employees working in lem establishments (table 2) was then used to calculate the total gross payroll, which is in total very similar with the one calculated with insee data, with only 1.5% of variation. this similarity demonstrates the reproducibility of this method, and this finding suggests that it can be applied to other european regions as well. table 3. comparison between total payrolls calculated with eurostat and insee data actors in the value chain nace rev. 2 activities corresponding naf activities mean wages and salaries, per employee in fulltime equivalents, per year total gross payroll in € (eurostat) total gross payroll in € (insee) construction and demolition companies [f41] construction of buildings [f43] specialised construction activities 43.11z 43.12a 43.12b 43.99c 43.99d 38 323 95 233 897 80 431 945 waste collection and treatment companies [e38] waste collection, treatment and disposal activities; materials recovery 38.11z 38.12z 38.21z 38.22z 38.31z 38.32z 39.00z 08.12z 46.72z 46.73a 46.77z 34 688 144 371 456 148 367 081 outlet industries [c] manufacturing 13.93z 20.16z 20.30z 22.21z 22.22z 22.23z 22.29a 22.29b 23.51z 23.99z 24.42z 24.45z 42.11z 42.99z 41 727 124 763 730 124 630 077 social and solidarity economy [q88] social work activities without accommodation 82.99z 85.59a 88.10c 88.99a 88.99b 24 129 11 799 081 17 173 048 total 376 168 164 370 602 152 source: eurostat, labour cost, wages and salaries (including apprentices) by nace rev. 2 activity, online data code: lc_ncostot_r2 the methodology described in the previous section allows to estimate the drtcr of the lem’s value chain. it must be taken into consideration that the same resources can be handled by different stakeholders. three groups have been defined and correspond to the main stages of c&dw-m: after having been removed from a building by workers of a first company, workers of a second one can transport them to a treatment center ran by a third one. to avoid counting operations concerning the same resources multiple times, value chain’s stakeholders are divided into three different groups. as shown in table 4, group a consists of stakeholders whose labour force works directly on building sites, group b includes stakeholders involved in resource collection and treatment, and group c comprises stakeholders engaged in resource reselling (46.72z, 46.73a, 46.77z), mineral waste recovery (08.12z), and public works and construction activities that are not primarily focused on waste management and treatment but may involve it as part of the construction process (43.12a, 43.12b, 43.99c, 43.99d). these stakeholders (group c) are integrated in the selective deconstruction value chain because, even if they generally use new or “virgin” products, equipment and materials, they might be able to reintroduce resources generated, collected and treated by the two other groups, in a complete circular economy which closes a large number of loops into the building industry. thus, they are here considered as “stakeholders closing loops for building industry”. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7603 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 27 table 4. stakeholders’ distribution according to the order of resources’ handling group a resources generation from selective deconstruction group b resources collection and treatment group c stakeholders closing loops for building industry 43.11z – demolition 38.12z – collection of hazardous waste 38.31z – dismantling of wrecks 39.00z – remediation activities and other waste management services 38.11z – collection of non-hazardous waste 38.21z – treatment and disposal of non-hazardous waste 38.22z – treatment and disposal of hazardous waste 38.32z – recovery of sorted materials 43.12a – levelling and grading of construction sites 43.12b – site preparation 43.99c – general masonry and structural work 43.99d – other specialised construction activities 08.12z – operation of gravel and sand pits; mining of clays and kaolin 46.72z – wholesale of metals and metal ores 46.73a – wholesale of wood and construction materials 46.77z – wholesale of waste and scrap source: author’s elaboration the results are presented in figure 5, according to the two types of mass distribution that were used: the “epr distribution” that concerns all waste of the building sector, and the “optigede distribution” that is specific to demolition waste. while estimating average capacities per worked hour, based on the employment size ranges of icpe establishments, the minimum, the average and the maximum of the size ranges were used, leading to a maximum, an average, and a minimum capacity. those capacities were then applied to the employment size ranges of the actors established in lem. the minimum, the average and the maximum of the size ranges were used. the results present the mean and the standard deviation of the metropolitan actors, for the minimum (min), the average (ave) and the maximum (max) capacities. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7603 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 28 figure 5. annual drtcr of lem’s actors source: author’s elaboration although the results obtained using the two mass distributions are similar in magnitude, there are still noticeable differences, especially for group c. on average, the estimated drtcr for this group ranges from 450kt when using optigede to 600kt when using epr. the reason for this is the difference in the methodology underlying those distributions. the optigede distribution relies on legal declarations of waste and materials generated specifically by demolition sites. on the other hand, the epr distribution considers both c&dw, and is based on macro-estimates at the national level. group c comprises stakeholders whose activities are not directly related to demolition waste management, but rather to public works and construction. therefore, it is not surprising that their capacity, as estimated from optigede, is significantly lower than the one estimated from epr. 6. discussion to contextualise the results, the volume of demolition waste generated in the lem area can be estimated using national data on a per capita basis, since there are no official data at the metropolitan level. the waste produced by the construction industry is divided into two main sectors: the building sector and public works. in france, according to the french ministry of ecological transition21, public works represents 80% of the total waste volume, which amounts to 224 million tons. within the building sector, waste generation is divided between demolition (49%), building renovation (38%), and new construction (13%). [21] source: https://www.ecologie.gouv.fr/dechets-du-batiment european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7603 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 29 however, it's important to note that these values may not include preliminary demolition, which is often part of construction sites. in france, construction sites can be declared without including this preliminary deconstruction. therefore, a detailed analysis of each site can provide a more accurate view of waste distribution in the sector. nevertheless, those figures allow to estimate the volume of demolition waste generated in lem. the french building sector produces a yearly total of 46 million tons of waste, out of which 49% is generated by demolition, amounting to 22.5 million tons. the population of lem was 1.17 million according to the 2018 census, which represents 1.75% of the total french population of 67.16 million in the same year. applying this percentage to the national volume of demolition waste yields an estimate of 394,105 tons of waste at the metropolitan level, as shown in figure 5. the average drtcr of the group b, which comprises stakeholders involved in resource collection and treatment, is approximately 200kt. according to the methodology proposed here, metropolitan waste collection and treatment actors (group b), even under the assumption of a maximum capacity, are unable to provide the lem area a sufficient capacity to manage this volume of resources. this result is even clearer for group a, that comprises demolition companies, collection of hazardous waste and remediation activities. with an average drtcr of 38kt (epr distribution) to 61kt (optigede distribution), the study shows that stakeholders established in lem have not a sufficient capacity to take charge of all deconstruction works of the area. thus, results showed that most of deconstruction sites, as well as transport and treatment of generated waste, are taken into charge by actors operating in lem but established outside its geographical area (activities related to group a and group b). group c presents a much higher drtcr, with an average of 450kt to 600kt depending on the distribution used. the stakeholders it comprises have the potential to reintroduce the resources processed by the two other groups in the building industry. indeed, resources management and treatment may already be part of their activities. for example, levelling and grading of construction sites may involve the removal and disposal of soil and other resources, and masonry and structural work may involve the handling and disposal of construction debris. that is why, without any new infrastructures dedicated to c&dw-m, they might help closing the gap identified between the estimated volume of demolition waste and the drtcr of the group b. otherwise, the gap pointed out here suggests that a large proportion of deconstruction resources – about half of them according to the estimates of this study – is treated by actors established outside the lem area. based on these findings, the drtcr could be a relevant indicator to help decision makers in regional communities supporting the implementation of new relevant activities of c&dw-m. the results presented above apply to all materials, and it is proposed to analyse if the drtcr remains relevant when focussing on each material individually. this is especially significant given that france's establishment of the epr system has already set objectives for specific materials. the decree of 10 june 2022, which relates to the no-waste for a circular economy law and concerns the extended producer responsibility for construction materials, states that the recycling rates for wood, plaster, plastic, and glass should be raised by 2027 to 45%, 37%, 24%, and 18%, respectively (while they are currently at 41%, 16%, 17% and 3%, respectively). group b capacities mainly concerns treatment and recycling of these materials. to achieve these recycling objectives, the hypothesis is that these materials are selectively deconstructed, collected, and processed individually before being recycled. since the legislation focuses on these specific materials, let’s examine the drtcr of the lem for these flows. using both epr and optigede distributions, the respective shares of wood, plaster, plastic and glass were imputed to the estimate built above of 394,105 tons of demolition waste generated in the lem area. the resulting volumes are compared, in table 5, with the drtcr of groups b, for each considered material flow. the capacity rates presented in these tables represent this drtcr, in comparison with the estimated volumes of materials generated in lem. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7603 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 30 table 5. drtcr for specific material flows focused by french legislation distribution material share in the material mass distribution22 estimated volume generated in lem (in tons) volumes to be recycled according to fixed objectives annual drtcr (in tons) capacity rate (± standard deviation) epr wood 4.9% 19 311 8 690 2 586 30% ±9% plaster 0.3% 1 182 437 69 16% ±4.7% plastic 0.4% 1 576 378 65 17% ±5% glass 0.4% 1 576 284 14 4.8% ±1.5% optigede wood 1.11% 4 375 1 969 497 25% ±7.6% plaster 0.24% 946 350 5.7 1.6% ±0.5% plastic 0.04% 79 19 7.7 40% ±12% glass 0.02% 158 28 0.5 2% ±0.6% source: author’s elaboration since this pertains to specific materials flows, the differences between the results obtained are more noticeable, primarily due to the weight discrepancy provided based on the mass distributions. table 5 shows that this discrepancy ranges from 1 to 10 for plastic and 1 to 20 for glass. beyond these differences, it was found that the drtcr of lem’s actors does not match any of the volumes to be recycled according to the objectives set by legislation. using the epr distribution, the capacity rate ranges from 4.8% for glass, to 30% for wood. with the optigede distribution, this rate ranges from 1.6% for plaster, to 40% for plastic. those results highlight significant gaps in comparison to the volumes that need to be treated, indicating the need for a substantial additional capacity. but since there are large differences in the volumes and capacity rates between epr and optigede distributions, those results for specific flows should be viewed with caution and shall not be considered as a truthfully representation of the actual capacity of lem’s actors. the results obtained for these flows, as well as those for all material flows, indicate that there is still a significant gap in comparison to the volumes generated in lem, indicating the need for a substantial additional capacity to meet the circular economy (ce) targets. this suggests once again that a large portion of the demolition waste generated in the metropolis might have to be treated outside its geographical area, which could result in increased transport emissions. in this regard, developing a selective deconstruction value chain sustainably and at a local scale seems crucial. coordination between value chain stakeholders is essential, but it may not be enough to address the significant challenges of ce. public actors and private stakeholders might need to invest in new waste treatment infrastructures to meet the targets set by the regulatory framework. while this investment may seem like a constraint due to the climate emergency, it presents an economic opportunity for the metropolitan area to create thousands of new jobs that are unlikely to be relocated. 7. conclusion the focus of this article has been on the role of selective deconstruction, a key but not yet automatic lever for implementing ce in the c&d sector. this method has the potential to significantly increase waste treatment, reuse, and recycling ratios, thanks to its ability to better divide material flows. however, to achieve this, it requires the involvement of multiple stakeholders across the selective deconstruction value chain, and not just the method itself. the first goal of this article was to provide a replicable and comprehensive methodology for identifying these stakeholders, which relies on the statistical classification of economic activities. the reproducibility of this method makes it a promising tool for future research in other french regions and, with sufficient time and resources, in other european areas as well. in fact, the comparison with eurostat data revealed very similar results, indicating that the method can be effectively applied to other regions. [22] the share of plaste ris the sum of "gypsum plasterboards and planks", “inert matrix with plaster" and "insulation composite with plaster". the share os wood is the sum of "untreated wood" and "slightly adjuvanted wood". european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7603 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 31 this methodology was applied to the area of lem, allowing to identify the stakeholders involved in the selective deconstruction value chain and to assess their capacity to treat materials and waste from deconstruction. the analysis conducted in this study showed that lem, with approximately 10 000 employees in the sector, has a significant potential for ce development. it was found that the three groups of stakeholders comprising the selective deconstruction value chain, has an average drtcr of around 50kt for group a (resources generation from selective deconstruction), 200kt for group b (resources collection and treatment), and 450kt to 600kt for group c (stakeholders closing loops for building industry). taking into consideration that lem has an estimated volume of demolition waste of 400kt, the highlights the need to develop the value chain, especially by involving stakeholders of group c. similarly, looking at specific materials flows that have been focused by legislation, the results show that the current capacity may not be sufficient to achieve the ce strategy and its objectives. however, the drtcr's reliability at this level of granularity is questionable, as the results showed significant differences depending on the mass distribution used. although the drtcr built in this paper is a good indicator at the scale of all material flows, there is still some work to be done to make it truly relevant at a finer level of granularity, flow by flow. this work could benefit greatly from improved waste traceability, that could provide more precise and accurate data to support the drtcr’s calculations. in this regard, the implementation of the epr for construction materials may help. indeed, producer responsibility organizations responsible for this implementation are obligated to ensure an effective traceability of the waste they process. the findings of this study have significant implications for the economic and environmental sustainability of lem, and by extension, other urban areas that face similar challenges in managing c&d waste. by adopting ce strategies, lem can reduce its dependence on virgin materials, create new jobs that cannot be outsourced, and reduce greenhouse gas emissions. nonetheless, the development of local waste recovery economic sectors and infrastructures still requires a great deal of effort. the methodology presented in this article aimed to steer public policy towards more sustainable resource use and management, by highlighting what still need to be done. the implementation of ce and the attainment of objectives hinge indeed on the involvement of all actors in the value chain, as well as the support of public authorities. acknowledgments the research presented in this paper has been funded by lille european metropolis and i-site, as part of the industrial chair « reconvert ». url: https://reconvert.wp.imt.fr/ european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7603 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 32 appendices appendix 1. detailed materials mass distributions used materials epr distribution optigede distribution bituminous mixtures 0.79% unpolluted soil 7.6% 0.19% concrete and stones 37.2% 70.9% tiles and bricks 7.6% 1.81% ceramic 0.26% glass without joinery 0.4% 0.02% mixed inert waste 22.9% 16.7% others inert waste 1.22% gypsum plasterboards and planks 1.3% 0.06% inert matrix with plaster 0.13% insulation composite with plaster 0.05% untreated wood 4.9% 0.72% slightly adjuvanted wood 0.39% windows and other glazed openings 0.01% metals 6.6% 2.87% plastics 0.5% 0.04% minerals wools 0.5% 0.06% biosourced insulation 0.01% other insulating materials 0.42% waterproofing complex not containing tar 0.02% floor coverings 0.04% non-hazardous waste electrical and electronic equipment 0.01% mixed non-hazardous waste 7.4% 1.27% plants 0.03% topsoil 0.05% other non-hazardous non-inert waste 0.2% 0.4% asbestos bound to inert materials 1.2% 0.44% other types of bound asbestos 0.05% friable asbestos 0.1% bituminous mixtures containing tar 0.05% waterproofing complex not containing tar 0.001% paints containing dangerous substances 0.001% wood treated with dangerous substances 0.03% 0.04% equipment containing dangerous refrigerant fluids 0.001% lights 0.003% other waste electrical and electronic equipment containing dangerous substances 0.4% 0.01% soil containing dangerous substances 0.57% other hazardous waste 1.1% 0.31% references ann, t.w., poon, c.s., wong, a., yip, r., jaillon, l., 2013. impact of construction waste disposal charging scheme on work practices at construction sites in hong kong. waste manag. 33, 138–146. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7603 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 33 aranda-usón, a., n, jos&#233, moneva, m., portillo-tarragona, p., llena-macarulla, f., 2018. measurement of the circular economy in businesses: impact and implications for regional policies. econ. policy energy environ. https://doi.org/10.3280/efe2018-002010 bovea, m.d., powell, j.c., 2016. developments in life cycle assessment applied to evaluate the environmental performance of construction and demolition wastes. waste manag. 50, 151–172. brambilla, g., lavagna, m., vasdravellis, g., castiglioni, c.a., 2019. environmental benefits arising from demountable steelconcrete composite floor systems in buildings. resour. conserv. recycl. 141, 133–142. burger, m., stavropoulos, s., ramkumar, s., dufourmont, j., van oort, f., 2019. the heterogeneous skill-base of circular economy employment. res. policy 48, 248–261. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.respol.2018.08.015 campbell, a., 2018. mass timber in the circular economy: paradigm in practice?, in: proceedings of the institution of civil engineers-engineering sustainability. thomas telford ltd, pp. 141–152. chang, y.-t., hsieh, s.-h., 2019. a preliminary case study on circular economy in taiwan’s construction, in: iop conference series: earth and environmental science. iop publishing, p. 012069. chau, c.k., xu, j.m., leung, t.m., ng, w.y., 2017. evaluation of the impacts of end-of-life management strategies for deconstruction of a high-rise concrete framed office building. appl. energy, clean, efficient and affordable energy for a sustainable future 185, 1595–1603. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.apenergy.2016.01.019 christmann, p., 2018. towards a more equitable use of mineral resources. nat. resour. res. 27, 159–177. coelho, a., de brito, j., 2012. influence of construction and demolition waste management on the environmental impact of buildings. waste manag. 32, 532–541. consoli, d., marin, g., marzucchi, a., vona, f., 2016. do green jobs differ from non-green jobs in terms of skills and human capital? res. policy 45, 1046–1060. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.respol.2016.02.007 di maria, a., eyckmans, j., van acker, k., 2018. downcycling versus recycling of construction and demolition waste: combining lca and lcc to support sustainable policy making. waste manag. 75, 3–21. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.wasman.2018.01.028 doussoulin, j.p., bittencourt, m., 2022. how effective is the construction sector in promoting the circular economy in brazil and france? : a waste input-output analysis. struct. change econ. dyn. 60, 47–58. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.strueco.2021.10.009 eberhardt, l., birgisdottir, h., birkved, m., 2019. comparing life cycle assessment modelling of linear vs. circular building components, in: iop conference series: earth and environmental science. iop publishing, p. 012039. eberhardt, l.c.m., birgisdottir, h., birkved, m., 2019. potential of circular economy in sustainable buildings, in: iop conference series: materials science and engineering. iop publishing, p. 092051. ehore, 2017. circular jobs, understanding employment in the circular economy in the netherlands insights circle economy [www document]. url https://www.circle-economy.com/resources/circular-jobs-understandingemployment-in-the-circular-economy-in-the-netherlands (accessed 3.16.22). eionet, 2020. etc/wmge report 1/2020: construction and demolition waste: challenges and opportunities in a circular economy [www document]. eionet portal. url https://www.eionet.europa.eu/etcs/etc-wmge/products/etc-wmgereports/construction-and-demolition-waste-challenges-and-opportunities-in-a-circular-economy (accessed 3.28.23). fusco girard, l., nocca, f., 2019. moving towards the circular economy/city model: which tools for operationalizing this model? sustainability 11, 6253. https://doi.org/10.3390/su11226253 gálvez-martos, j.-l., styles, d., schoenberger, h., zeschmar-lahl, b., 2018. construction and demolition waste best management practice in europe. resour. conserv. recycl. 136, 166–178. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.resconrec.2018.04.016 ghisellini, p., ji, x., liu, g., ulgiati, s., 2018a. evaluating the transition towards cleaner production in the construction and demolition sector of china: a review. j. clean. prod. 195, 418–434. ghisellini, p., ripa, m., ulgiati, s., 2018b. exploring environmental and economic costs and benefits of a circular economy approach to the construction and demolition sector. a literature review. j. clean. prod. 178, 618–643. ghyoot, m., devlieger, l., billiet, l., 2018. déconstruction et réemploi: comment faire circuler les éléments de construction. presses polytechniques et universitaires romandes, lausanne. gorgolewski, m., straka, v., edmonds, j., sergio-dzoutzidis, c., 2008. designing buildings using reclaimed steel components. j. green build. 3, 97–107. guerra, b.c., leite, f., 2021. circular economy in the construction industry: an overview of united states stakeholders’ awareness, major challenges, and enablers. resour. conserv. recycl. 170, 105617. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.resconrec.2021.105617 european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7603 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 34 guerra, b.c., shahi, s., mollaei, a., skaf, n., weber, o., leite, f., haas, c., 2021. circular economy applications in the construction industry: a global scan of trends and opportunities. j. clean. prod. 324, 129125. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2021.129125 horbach, j., rennings, k., sommerfeld, k., 2015. circular economy and employment, in: 3rd iza workshop: labor market effects of environmental policies. pp. 1–39. hossain, md.u., ng, s.t., antwi-afari, p., amor, b., 2020. circular economy and the construction industry: existing trends, challenges and prospective framework for sustainable construction. renew. sustain. energy rev. 130, 109948. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.rser.2020.109948 huang, b., wang, x., kua, h., geng, y., bleischwitz, r., ren, j., 2018. construction and demolition waste management in china through the 3r principle. resour. conserv. recycl. 129, 36–44. iacovidou, e., velis, c.a., purnell, p., zwirner, o., brown, a., hahladakis, j., millward-hopkins, j., williams, p.t., 2017. metrics for optimising the multi-dimensional value of resources recovered from waste in a circular economy: a critical review. j. clean. prod. 166, 910–938. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2017.07.100 international labour organization, 2011. towards a greener economy: the social dimensions. international labour organisation. jabbour, c.j.c., sarkis, j., de sousa jabbour, a.b.l., renwick, d.w.s., singh, s.k., grebinevych, o., kruglianskas, i., godinho filho, m., 2019. who is in charge? a review and a research agenda on the ‘human side’of the circular economy. j. clean. prod. 222, 793–801. jiménez-rivero, a., garcía-navarro, j., 2017. best practices for the management of end-of-life gypsum in a circular economy. j. clean. prod. 167, 1335–1344. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2017.05.068 jung, j.-s., song, s.-h., jun, m.-h., park, s.-s., 2015. a comparison of economic feasibility and emission of carbon dioxide for two recycling processes. ksce j. civ. eng. 19, 1248–1255. kasmi, f., 2018. écologie industrielle, milieu éco-innovateur et diversification de l’économie territoriale : le cas du complexe industrialo-portuaire de dunkerque (these de doctorat). université du littoral côte d'opale. laurenti, r., singh, j., frostell, b., sinha, r., binder, c.r., 2018. the socio-economic embeddedness of the circular economy: an integrative framework. sustainability 10, 2129. leising, e., quist, j., bocken, n., 2018. circular economy in the building sector: three cases and a collaboration tool. j. clean. prod. 176, 976–989. llorente-gonzález, l.j., vence, x., 2020. how labour-intensive is the circular economy? a policy-orientated structural analysis of the repair, reuse and recycling activities in the european union. resour. conserv. recycl. 162, 105033. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.resconrec.2020.105033 lockrey, s., nguyen, h., crossin, e., verghese, k., 2016. recycling the construction and demolition waste in vietnam: opportunities and challenges in practice. j. clean. prod. 133, 757–766. lofti, s., 2016. c2ca concrete recycling process: from development to demonstration. delft university of technology. https://doi.org/10.4233/uuid:70505a1f-c0d7-47c7-ab62-8d487761c021 mazzarano, m., 2021. criticality assessment of green materials: institutional quality, market concentration and recycling potential: eur. j. soc. impact circ. econ. 2, 1–14. https://doi.org/10.13135/2704-9906/5988 mihai, f.-c., 2019. construction and demolition waste in romania: the route from illegal dumping to building materials. sustainability 11, 3179. https://doi.org/10.3390/su11113179 minunno, r., o’grady, t., morrison, g.m., gruner, r.l., colling, m., 2018. strategies for applying the circular economy to prefabricated buildings. buildings 8, 125. mitchell, p., morgan, j., 2015. employment and the circular economy job creation in a more resource efficient britain. https://doi.org/10.13140/rg.2.1.1026.5049 moreau, v., sahakian, m., van griethuysen, p., vuille, f., 2017. coming full circle: why social and institutional dimensions matter for the circular economy. j. ind. ecol. 21, 497–506. nasir, m.h.a., genovese, a., acquaye, a.a., koh, s.c.l., yamoah, f., 2017. comparing linear and circular supply chains: a case study from the construction industry. int. j. prod. econ. 183, 443–457. nuñez-cacho, p., górecki, j., molina-moreno, v., corpas-iglesias, f.a., 2018. what gets measured, gets done: development of a circular economy measurement scale for building industry. sustainability 10, 2340. https://doi.org/10.3390/su10072340 padilla-rivera, a., russo-garrido, s., merveille, n., 2020. addressing the social aspects of a circular economy: a systematic literature review. sustainability 12, 7912. https://doi.org/10.3390/su12197912 european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7603 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 35 rehman, u. ur, shafiq, m., ali, h., abdullah, m., 2020. green and sustainable construction practices impact on organizational development. eur. j. soc. impact circ. econ. 1, 1–26. https://doi.org/10.13135/2704-9906/5068 repp, l., hekkert, m., kirchherr, j., 2021. circular economy-induced global employment shifts in apparel value chains: job reduction in apparel production activities, job growth in reuse and recycling activities. resour. conserv. recycl. 171, 105621. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.resconrec.2021.105621 romnée, a., vandervaeren, c., breda, o., de temmerman, n., 2019. a greenhouse that reduces greenhouse effect: how to create a circular activity with construction waste?, in: iop conference series: earth and environmental science. iop publishing, p. 012035. ruiz, l.a.l., ramón, x.r., domingo, s.g., 2020. the circular economy in the construction and demolition waste sector–a review and an integrative model approach. j. clean. prod. 248, 119238. sassi, p., 2008. defining closed-loop material cycle construction. build. res. inf. 36, 509–519. scarpellini, s., 2021. social indicators for businesses’ circular economy: multi-faceted analysis of employment as an indicator for sustainability reporting. eur. j. soc. impact circ. econ. 2, 17–44. https://doi.org/10.13135/2704-9906/5282 scarpellini, s., portillo-tarragona, p., aranda-usón, a., llena-macarulla, f., 2019. definition and measurement of the circular economy’s regional impact. j. environ. plan. manag. 62, 2211–2237. https://doi.org/10.1080/09640568.2018.1537974 schultmann, f., sunke, n., 2007. energy-oriented deconstruction and recovery planning. build. res. inf. 35, 602–615. superti, v., houmani, c., binder, c.r., 2021. a systemic framework to categorize circular economy interventions: an application to the construction and demolition sector. resour. conserv. recycl. 173, 105711. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.resconrec.2021.105711 tirado, r., habert, g., aublet, a., laurenceau, s., 2021. territories’ challenges and opportunities to promote circular economy in the building sector. international journal of architectural and environmental engineering, 15, 246-249. tomić, t., schneider, d.r., 2020. circular economy in waste management–socio-economic effect of changes in waste management system structure. j. environ. manage. 267, 110564. wang, t., wang, jiayuan, wu, p., wang, jun, he, q., wang, x., 2018. estimating the environmental costs and benefits of demolition waste using life cycle assessment and willingness-to-pay: a case study in shenzhen. j. clean. prod. 172, 14–26. wijayasundara, m., mendis, p., zhang, l., sofi, m., 2016. financial assessment of manufacturing recycled aggregate concrete in ready-mix concrete plants. resour. conserv. recycl. 109, 187–201. wuyts, w., miatto, a., sedlitzky, r., tanikawa, h., 2019. extending or ending the life of residential buildings in japan: a social circular economy approach to the problem of short-lived constructions. j. clean. prod. 231, 660–670. yeheyis, m., hewage, k., alam, m.s., eskicioglu, c., sadiq, r., 2013. an overview of construction and demolition waste management in canada: a lifecycle analysis approach to sustainability. clean technol. environ. policy 15, 81–91. yuan, h., 2017. barriers and countermeasures for managing construction and demolition waste: a case of shenzhen in china. j. clean. prod. 157, 84–93. zheng, l., wu, h., zhang, h., duan, h., wang, j., jiang, w., dong, b., liu, g., zuo, j., song, q., 2017. characterizing the generation and flows of construction and demolition waste in china. constr. build. mater. 136, 405–413. 5687-article text-17579-1-6-20210411 european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5687 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 10 social impact of human resource management of hybrid organisations. an exploratory case study iannaci daniel1 1 university of turin, department of management corso unione sovietica 218, bis – 10134 – torino (italy) e-mail: daniel.iannaci@unito.it received: 29/03/2021 accepted for publication: 14/05/2021 published: 19/07/2021 abstract what defines an organization's social impact is its purpose, social and profit. the current business landscape in the entrepreneurial ecosystem in accordance with the literature defines a certain category of companies that can be the main players in the impact economy are the hybrid organizations. there are several studies and research on the role of hrm and incentive systems for companies in general, but not for hybrid organizations that seek to create high intentional, measurable and additive social impact. in this paper, through the method of the case study the researcher explores the hybrid organization abel nutraceuticals s.r.l, part of nonprofit group arcobaleno cooperativa sociale and define the key factors that hybrid missionoriented for-profit organizations with the propensity for social impact should have to have an incentive tool to value workers and determine what factors internal stakeholders would like to know to be heard understood. the research confirms that a good tool that is inclusive and above all listens to the well-being of workers only works if it manages to put the worker first, having an auditor who verifies that the social inclusion it is implementing is done in the right way. keywords: hrm, hybrid organisations, social impact, impact measurement, stakeholder needs, accounting 1. introduction what defines an organization's social impact is its purpose, the social purpose, and profit purpose. traditional businesses occupy one end of the spectrum, with their focus on profit and distribution of goods. third sector associations existing today not engaged in commerce do not have profit motives and are defined solely by their social mission, on the other hand, for impact companies strike a balance by taking different approaches in balancing social purpose and profit (borzaga, 2020; iannaci and aiassa, 2020; puddu, 1980). thinking about the twenty-first-century lengnick-hall et al. (2009) prospectively projected that human resources function will be freed from administrative shackles and can focus more on developing intellectual capital, social capital, and knowledge management to improve an organization's competitive advantage, anticipating that it will experience a strong change from old experiences (hrtel et al., 2008; lengnick-hall et al., 2009; lengnick-hall and moritz, 2003). they add that different people have different needs, one size does not fit all by combining what company needs to know about each individual employee's needs to be successful, and worker's awareness they must have about their own needs to be successful (lengnick-hall et al., 2009; lengnick-hall and moritz, 2003). the business landscape currently existing in entrepreneurial ecosystem in accordance with literature defines a certain category of companies that can be main players in the impact economy are hybrid organizations (agostino and arnaboldi, 2017; bicciato, 2010; borzaga, 2015; secinaro et al., 2019b). european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5687 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 11 social enterprises have within their social object the characteristics that ethical finance seeks and above all, they are the beststructured enterprises of the entire third sector panorama (zamagni, 2013) and therefore if a corporate group has as its parent a company of this type it transfers to entire corporate fabric its values indiscriminately if subsidiaries are for-profit or non-profit. decision support tools will become more numerous and more sophisticated, improving decision-making process of managers and employees in organizations (abdel-maksoud et al., 2015; boyett, 1996), making human resources take on new roles in value creation process. the response to the need for ever more advanced and effective incentives introduced at the business level is increasingly shifting toward considered hybrid organizations, business models aimed at keeping social mission along with business (apospori et al., 2008; arsić et al., 2017; billis, 2010; grossi and thomasson, 2015). hybrid organizations make social a strategic asset to regenerate resources of different nature: human, through the development of new knowledge and new skills; economic, through the possibility of aggregating a variety of types of sources precisely because of hybrid nature of organization; physical, that is, related to the process of transformation of spaces into places, where relationality becomes the key ingredient for success of process (garrow and hasenfeld, 2012; kleynjans and hudon, 2016; smith and phillips, 2016). the economic evaluation of social impact of hybrid organizations becomes, therefore, crucial in knowledge economy (meneguzzo, 2005; zamagni et al., 2015) and the debate focuses on impact measurement tools (calderini et al., 2018). hybrid organizations are located in an intermediate section at the intersection of public, for-profit, and nonprofit (billis, 2010; grossi and thomasson, 2015; secinaro et al., 2019b; thomasson, 2009). to define the field of innovation and identify social value that is returned to the ecosystem of the area, it is important and useful to define the business model as a tool that can facilitate the diffusion of innovation into the system. the value inherent in innovation remains latent until it is put on the market or otherwise made explicit, and this can only occur through the use of a business model (chesbrough and rosenbloom, 2002). certainly, accounting system is an important point within a company that can bring out information about good governance. governance involves a set of relationships among stakeholders and the distribution of rights and responsibilities among these different stakeholders (ansell and gash, 2008; awotundun et al., 2011; freeman, 2010; mair et al., 2015). as a result of good governance, values that are transmitted to stakeholders are experience and trustworthiness, as leaders of professional organizations in ethics and compliance have a responsibility to nurture the next generation of entrepreneurs. leadership skills increase management effectiveness and also tend to promote ethics (adams, 2000; alshammari, 2015; carroll, 1996; vining and weimer, 2016). finding reveals that with best practices incentivizing human resources within a well-functioning ecosystem, it is possible to create new social projects and be attractive within one's territory and internationally. having accountability as an element of connection with your workers gives you credibility you need to create social impact through new projects. the reflection of this policy will increasingly turn to perceptions of all other stakeholders connected to the area in which the impact activity takes place (adams, 2000; alshammari, 2015; carroll, 1996; iannaci, 2020a; kirk et al., 1986; lehner and nicholls, 2014; vining and weimer, 2016). there are several studies and research on the role of human resource management (hrm) and incentive systems for companies in general but not for hybrid organizations seeking to create high intentional, measurable, and additive social impact. however, the gap that has emerged from the literature is that the principles of transparency and accountability are defined, but the determination of a key element that can bring order and best meet need of internal stakeholders is lacking. therefore, the research aims to define and highlight one or more key factors and answer the research question "to define the key factors that a hybrid organization should have in order to achieve an incentive tool geared towards increasing accountability, transparency, and personal well-being thus generating social impact and to determine what factors internal stakeholders would like to know in order to be heard and included". the paper is structured as follows: second section outlines the literature review, third section the research methodology, fourth section the context of case study, fifth section provides the presentation of findings, and finally sixth section concludes. 2. literature review koprowski, (1981) in his studies wrote that managerial philosophy refers to the culturally embedded assumptions of managers in relation to human nature and human behavior that inform their managerial thinking and practice, defining that through european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5687 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 12 socializing and sharing their perceptions and behaviors they bring out these assumptions as inherent characteristics in individuals. in addition, it should be noted that it should be kept in mind that both workers and managers are influenced in their internal relationships among superiors, colleagues, and subordinates (campbell and tawadey, 2016; peck, 1994; singh, 2005). literature suggests that research on management philosophy should include three aspects: temporal, theory or doctrine of philosophy, and human behavior (abbas, 2020; chaudhary, 2020; hughes, 2017; kenny and meaton, 2007). the dissemination of management philosophy is one of the key functions of management (chaudhary, 2020; komarov et al., 2016; lee and clerkin, 2017); however, it is rarely addressed in academic research. many academics prefer management theory and motivation theory, or planning and organizational topics (aalbers et al., 2013; ahmed et al., 2010; aka, 1993; al-htaybat and von alberti-alhtaybat, 2013; andrews, 2016; chopra, 2019). academics and managers are very interested and concerned with visions, strategies, and plans (bahemia et al., 2018; cooke, 1989; du et al., 2014). however, most of these visions, strategies, and plans fail or are not successfully implemented. a key reason for these failures is that implementation of management philosophy and resulting impact on hr practices undertaken by managers is often overlooked (greenberg and bugden, 2019; peck, 1994). figure 1 explains the composition of academic field at the conclusion of the study. the topic map shows each keyword in the two-dimensional space explained by axes (noyons, 2001). the scale of points is proportional to the cumulative input of each keyword. by applying a clustering algorithm to a network of keywords, it is possible to highlight the various themes of a given domain. each cluster can be represented on a special graph known as a strategy or theme map. for example, centrality can be read as the importance of theme in the entire field of science, and density can be read as a measure of the growth of the theme. thus, considering the figure, in this research stream as highly developed and isolated themes, authors found stakeholder management and circular economy theme of social impact of hrm policies. as necessary and cross-cutting themes, the authors also found that sustainability on the studied theme was a highly repetitive theme associated you have key focuses of human resources, human capital, and human resource management. finally, as a declining theme, the sole focus of performance was reported. figure 1 thematic map in hr strategy on profit performance. source: authors’ elaboration european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5687 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 13 2.1. human resource management (hrm) a relevant positive correlation between hrm and organizational performance is found in literature (anselmsson et al., 2016; crook et al., 2013; gray et al., 1995), this indicates that the project outcome requires a good quality of performance management but especially team impact management. performance management is recommended as human resource management function through which team motivation and performance can be effectively addressed. by focusing on the key constituents of high-performance work systems (hpws) and monitoring their effects on organizational performance, through structural equation model techniques, top-performing companies have invested in more sophisticated hrm practices that primarily include employee performance appraisals, which have further improved organizational performance. the concept that is reinforced relates to the interpretation that hr performance and social impact management is a significant function of organizational success (cheng-hua et al., 2009; shih et al., 2006). seven main hr policies categorized as work-for-life policies are to be considered including recruitment, training, performance-related bonus system, teamwork, organizational culture, and pensions. important communication links between hr managers and management accountants are budgets, strategic plans, performance-related bonus system, and decisionmaking. selected functions have a significant impact on organizational performance reinforcing the perception that hr performance management influences organizational performance (kouhy et al., 2009). literature confirms that hr performance monitoring is the dimension of performance management that, along with all other necessary hrm functions, helps organizations increase their performance. this indicates that performance and social impact management for projects requires consistent performance monitoring throughout project life cycle. monitoring is a process that assesses the quality of internal control performance of resources involved in any task or project over time. monitoring is the most feasible mechanism for ensuring effective performance by hr resources or machines. a control system must be monitored to ensure that it continues to function effectively as intended. without continuous and effective monitoring, a control process can fall into a state of despair or not be executed at all (naqvi et al., 2011). the focus that the study give through this paper is on single aspect of performance and social impact management, namely hr monitoring and enhancement as it covers desired hr practices and functions. well-planned, frequent, and regular progress monitoring of project work and resources (fang and marle, 2012; wiersema et al., 2018). an effective way to control a project is to continually measure progress of its work and teams working on it; comparing that progress to the plan and then adjusting the development criteria to correct any deviation from project plan. project success can be achieved by declaring project management a strategic, yet complex activity. traditionally, a project is perceived as successful when it meets the objectives of time, budget, performance, quality, and impact (dvir et al., 2003; shenhar et al., 2002, 2001). several studies have used a combination of qualitative and quantitative methods having as results the identification of four main distinct success dimensions for operationalizing the project outcome: project efficiency, customer impact, direct business, and organizational success, and preparation for the future. customer impact could be interpreted through feedback on products or services the project provided. direct business and organizational success could be measured in terms of the profit and customer relationships any organization earns after completing a project. preparedness for future could be measured thorough documentation of project and lessons learned by team, and worker "happiness" through questionnaires reporting their mood and whether it made a change in their lifestyle. 2.2. hybrid organisations for-profit social enterprise organizations have historically been categorized within a single sector: most commonly, public, private, or non-profit. sectoral categories help to define shared understandings of beliefs, values, organizational identity, and assumptions that aid in aligning internal organizational goals and actions and establishing a basis by which to evaluate similar organizations (hsu and hannan, 2005). battilana and dorado (2010) have done extensive studies on hybrid organizations highlighting what will be the theoretical challenge of future. these organizations are the result of a combination of key elements from the profit and non-profit sectors. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5687 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 14 in another study battilana, et al. (2015) identify numerous challenges that hybrid organizations must face and among these arises the legal nature as they must choose a legal form, because, having to decide to be a profit or non-profit organization and therefore entrepreneurs can only claim one of the forms of value they create. with the studies done previously by hoffman et al. (2012) and later by holt and littlewood (2015) it is possible to describe hybrid organizations by identifying two main characteristics. their studies frame the hybridization first of all of business models between profit and non-profit and then of the mission driven as social mission is given priority without ever neglecting performance. the challenge that this research poses in accordance with the assertion of holt and littlewood (2015), is the recognition that these types of organizations pursue the impact and this mixed identification that distinguishes them leads to major challenges in seizing, assessing and communicating this impact. haigh and hoffman (2012) and later hockerts (2015) specify very well that when impact occurs it should not be linked only to social impact as hybrid organizations are primarily concerned with social missions but must be oriented towards achieving commercial revenue to support operations. rawhouser et al. (2015) in fact had already argued that latter the number of these organizations that integrate the two objectives described above has increased and therefore leads even more to the combination of features and tools by combining the features to encourage innovation, studies also carried out by reiser (2011) but from a legislative point of view. it is therefore important to be able to identify what are hybrid organisations. for example, reiser (2012) specifies that in the u.s. the following are considered: benefit corporations, low-profit limited liability companies (l3cs), social purpose corporations (spcs), and flexible purpose corporations (fpcs). these are identified as these legal forms draw their property from both profit-oriented legal forms (e.g. limited companies and partnerships) and non-profit legal forms (e.g. charitable and philanthropic organisations). about this assertion, ebrahim et al. (2014) consider that this cataloguing does not solve the identifying tension of hybrid subjects but is undoubtedly a good start to start inserting them into the system. leimsider (2014) explains that the term "hybrid organization" has recently established itself internationally as a broader term than "social enterprise", reflecting the heterogeneity of legal forms, missions and different contexts in which these different business models operate generating debate at scientific level. in addition to strengthening the concept, fowler (2000) that hybrid organizations that are considered must recognize within it the element of limited distribution of profits, always leaving in first place the social and/or environmental mission with nonprofit mode. returning to the characteristics that must be identified and therefore monitored without doubt, it is necessary to identify the distinguishing marks of a hybrid organization (holt and littlewood, 2015): • centrality of a social and/or environmental mission, with its primacy over the creation of economic value; • generation of income through trade, whether linked to the mission; • participatory governance structures with the active involvement of stakeholders, and relations with stakeholders based on mutual benefit and sustainability results; • limited distribution of profits with profits or surpluses reinvested for social purposes; • innovative solutions linked to the creation of a business model. it is essential to identify and regulate these organizations because, as demonstrated by rawhouser et al. (2015), the identification of hybrid organizations can be considered a threat to non-profit organizations because the status of no mutualistic purpose for a company that comes from profit can be difficult to prove and therefore the inclusion of hybrid social organization can be considered a threat to non-profit organizations. in line with the demand for research, it is essential to investigate what are the values that distinguish a hybrid organization because only later it will be possible to monitor, measure and finally communicate it to stakeholders. rawhouser et al. (2015) has shown that including elements within the business model such as alternative energy, recycling and pollution reduction captures the attention and influence of stakeholders like employees, consumers and entrepreneurs themselves. the "green" workforce category is coined to demonstrate in the case study by rawhouser et al. (2015) that increase in this use of internal resources also increases attention of legislation (scherer and palazzo, 2011), market and attracts work. a current which, if operated in current way, leads to success. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5687 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 15 2.3. social impact measurement in order to focus on hr impact assessment, it is necessary to fully understand the topic without considering it more generally and then go into the specifics of this corporate function; to do so, the researcher rely on literature that emerged in iannaci's paper (2020a). when, in this research, reference is made to the social, the reference is to live within the community, the ecosystem. the scientific disciplines that study the subject are sociology, economics, and anthropology (calderini et al., 2018; marradi, 1992; rousseau, 2015; zamagni et al., 2015). as it will often be used, the concept of social goes hand in hand with tendency to improve living conditions of less well-off citizens in order to achieve greater equalization between the various components of a society. hybrid organizations are promoters of social innovation, generating widespread well-being and sustainable improvements in the living conditions of community. it is precisely the community, thanks to increasingly accessible communication technologies, that becomes not only the recipient of social innovation but also the co-generator of innovative processes (corvo and pastore, 2018). when social enterprises and resource providers are involved in symmetrical relationships, the purpose of measuring social impact seems to help social enterprises improve their performance so that the parties can achieve the common goal of creating social impact for those in need anthropology (zamagni et al., 2015). a key element of evaluation process is attention to the effects generated by action, including positive and negative, direct and indirect, expected and unanticipated (bezzi, 2001). evaluation should not be confused with monitoring, for which there are similarities and points of contact. in the first case, what has been achieved is analyzed, verifying the validity of results achieved; in the second case, it is a matter of verifying the progression with respect to the planning of intervention, to identify any deviations (montesi et al., 2017). through the explanation of the chain of value creation, clark et al. (2004), as can be seen in figure 2, deepen the concept of "social" outcome, as a value purified of what would have happened regardless of social impact intervention. figure 2. impact value chain source: (clark and rosenzweig, 2004) impact assessment is based on counterfactual analysis, i.e., it asks about the occurrence of change not only with respect to "before versus after," but also with respect to "versus without" some involvement (clark and rosenzweig, 2004) there are projects where the "before versus after" is sufficient to determine the impact generated, for example when no other factor is likely to have caused observable effects on the change generated: the reduction in water withdrawal time from the installation of water pumps. in other cases, however, the cause-and-effect link is not as obvious and linear, thus requiring an analysis that compares the "versus without" intervention (clark and rosenzweig, 2004). european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5687 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 16 there may be a variety of reasons to measure impact, for example (i) demonstrating transparency, accountability, and legitimacy to investors for accessing resources, because without impact, evidence, and reporting, funders do not see the value created for communities; and (ii) knowing and improving organizational performance to determine if they should continue or change their current strategy to achieve their missions (nguyen et al., 2015). as illustrated by nguyen et al. (2015), when social enterprises and resource providers are involved in symmetrical relationships, the purpose of measuring social impact seems to help social enterprises improve performance so that parties can achieve their common goal: creating social impact for people in need. 2.4. the research model in social impact assessment, as noted by clark et al. (2004), it is necessary to define the impact value chain to better understand the drivers of value creation. an intrinsic factor that has emerged in the literature reviewed on hrm, hybrid organizations and social impact measurement is that in order to create stakeholder participation, it is important that upstream there is a company with good governance, leadership, aimed at survival in the marketplace through performance and social impact orientation. this information is not important if it is not conveyed in the right way through correct staff enhancement tool to increase perception and consequently involvement (al-khasawneh and futa, 2012; biancone et al., 2016; freeman, 2010). a good hr policy with high social impact must put the need of internal stakeholders first and through the principles of transparency and accountability communicate its corporate story to have the expected results that ecosystem needs and try to promote ethics (al-khasawneh and futa, 2012; beer et al., 2015; biancone et al., 2016; freeman, 2010; secinaro et al., 2019a). the finding reveals that with employee empowerment best practices for high social impact for-profit companies, it is a matter of shaping the level of information about various types of stakeholders, professional and non-professional so that supply and demand for information meet (biancone et al., 2019, 2018a, 2016; secinaro et al., 2019a). with the goal of answering the research question "to define the key factors that a hybrid organization should have in order to achieve an incentive tool geared toward increasing accountability, transparency, and personal well-being thereby generating social impact and to determine what factors internal stakeholders would like to know in order to be heard and included." the researcher believes that a good, understandable incentive tool that succeeds in creating engagement will create accountability, transparency, and well-being only if the policy is oriented to the needs of worker. after a thorough analysis of the literature review, the study proposes that putting workers' needs first by generating accountability, transparency, and happiness in the sense of personal well-being would increase stakeholder engagement. stakeholders would be able to better perceive the strong values of good governance, leadership, performance, and social impact that the company possesses. performance is seen as the focus that is pursued by monitoring the values of productivity, profitability, quality, efficiency, and innovation. figure 3 constructs the reference model proposed by the authors. to adopt an incentive tool and meet stakeholder needs, a hybrid organization must have the four key factors listed above. through this assurance and the most effective incentive tool possible, they can have stakeholder engagement and increase the objective perception of them to create collaboration in new activities aimed at improving ecosystem. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5687 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 17 figure 3. model to satisfy workers’ needs source: author’s elaboration 3. research methodology this research employs a case study approach for exploration (eisenhardt, 1989; yin, 2014). the case study approach is suitable for investigating why or how phenomena occurred and relationships between these phenomena (yin, 2014). through case study, one can better understand a new phenomenon and concept (eisenhardt, 1989). in line with the purpose of this article, the methodology was adopted by preparing a longitudinal and explanatory case study (yin, 1994). the case study highlights some relevant aspects and possible approaches to the model elements. the methods of information collection use qualitative techniques and include interviews with managers and employees, analysis of internal documentation, observation of reality, and truthfulness of the stated data with a reworking of some data to ensure the validity and reliability of information. within the company the author has a management control function, this allows him to have all the monitoring information of the mentioned key factors. the primary data were collected directly by the authors who has been conducting research within the enterprise for years, the secondary data were provided through a semi-structured interview with managers and employees. validity is ensured by triangulating several resources with evidence of the key information collected. the evidence collected is ensured by doublechecking the information through differentiated sources. research allows a phenomenon to be recorded in a real-world setting, where the boundaries between context and phenomenon tend to be blurred (stake, 1996). literature allows for the confirmation and combination of information gathered (yin, 1994). the transparency, approach, and repeatability of the analysis and method allow for its reliability (leonard-barton, 1990). therefore, the researchers believe that case study defined by yin (2014) is the best way to answer the research question of "defining the key factors that a hybrid organization should have in order to achieve an incentive tool geared toward increasing accountability, transparency, and personal well-being thereby generating social impact and determining what factors internal stakeholders would want to know in order to be heard and included". european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5687 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 18 the research reflected its theoretical framework presented in figure 3, which consists of eight elements: good governance, leadership, social impact, and performance; focusing on the last element as the focus that is pursued through monitoring the values of productivity, profitability, quality, efficiency, and innovation (campbell, 1986). stakeholders would be able to better perceive the strong values of good governance, leadership, performance, and social impact that company possesses. performance is seen as the focus that is pursued through monitoring the values of productivity, profitability, quality, efficiency, and innovation. the names and location of company and respondents were kept anonymous for privacy reasons, then transcribed and coded independently (curtis et al., 2010; secinaro et al., 2021). 3.1. interviews outline with the purpose of answering the research questions, the research was organized to cover the topics necessary to have the elements to proceed with the study. additional exploratory questions were considered to deepen the understanding of the answer, rather than closing a discussion and moving on to the next question. it was considered important to organize the questions by addressing the necessary topics from all angles, from the most specific to the most general. the topic of reporting was addressed by trying to understand what information was considered understandable and what was not. also, to understand if social issues were considered important and if the information was more transparent if this would increase participation. it was necessary to have information on the reaction of members by trying to understand if the group believed in the social enterprise and if they fully understood the identity in which they worked if this increased the sense of belonging. since the tool would also be consulted by service users, it was important to understand if a better form of communication had changed patterns of behavior. through a more discursive approach, another theme that created interest was to understand if there were any obstacles to achieving the goal by trying to understand how it affected the company. 3.2. case study – context the hybrid organization in question is called abel nutraceuticals s.r.l, part of non-profit group arcobaleno cooperativa sociale. the head of the group puts in the first place the creation of employment for its members, who fall among the types of people defined in social context as "fragile" through the collection of waste. the company has historically focused on activities with characteristics aimed at the simplification of work in order to encourage skilled labor, to allow workers to keep up with the market, monitoring results, solid prerequisites to ensure economic independence of people, always putting at the center of its choices the employment and social impact of the territory of intervention. the primary specialization of abel nutraceuticals s.r.l. is the design of extractive processes and the production of extracts for food supplement sector. information was collected through interviews with managers, staff, through company's website. in addition, financial report of the last five years was analyzed to support accountability. about the accountability supported by financial statement data, it was possible to understand that the company is financially sound and stable (iannaci, 2020a). 4. presentation of results this section summarizes the results of the case, showing the interviewees' outputs and the connections that emerged between the strengths of the company. the company showed that the government is solid and most importantly, it is flexible to any unexpected in the market, as due to their expertise they are able to adapt and shape the business with the market, confirming the concepts of al-khasawneh and futa (2012) and alshammari et al. (2015). the concept of good governance treated by fernández-fernández (1999) and norman (2014) is confirmed by saying that the governance structure is solid and has a good internal management of responsibilities. the members of the company are aware of this because, in addition to seeing it from the numbers, they perceive the internal and external organizational strength. therefore, it was possible to link to the literature that the pursuit of daily innovation is a key factor within the organization studied. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5687 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 19 the social mission and putting the worker first to achieve wellness is something that stakeholders would like to see results of once the tool is applied. the hope is that in the long run the application of this type of flow will create the effect stated by freeman (2010). this type of perception prevailed over financial, non-financial, and especially social impact data. the system of incentives that the company will introduce to measure the performance and well-being of its workers to grow within human resources a better perception sometimes clouded by biases, as mentioned before, which did not even lead to deepening confirming what adams (2000) and biancone et al. (2018c) said about participation as the context usually associate with good reporting practices. empowering workers would succeed in sensitizing them in the future on the issue of social impact, making them feel part of the actions that the company puts in place for the ecosystem by increasing the propensity to collaborate to participate in the improvement through their own contribution by informing themselves on how to approach the concepts of adams (2000) and alshammari et al. (2015) on the cornerstones of ethical finance. through the interviews conducted, within the company analyzed, the social impact mentioned is perceived as an indirect effect of processes. the case showed that holding firmly to the goals of productivity, profitability, quality, efficiency and innovation defines a point in favor of establishing a good corporate policy to give the perception of being accountable and transparent. governance is aware that everyone has the right and desire to know more about the company, both internally and externally, as confirmed by the studies of freeman (2010), carroll (1996), and biancone et al.(2018b). undoubtedly, using internal language that is accessible even to those unfamiliar with hrm issues becomes an effective communication tool in line with the pop principles of good reporting practices (biancone et al., 2019; biancone and secinaro, 2015). the territory is having a propensity for social orientation and social impact and therefore a good incentive tool oriented not only to accountability, transparency but also to the happiness of workers can help increase the propensity for social innovation in the ecosystem. the study, made possible thanks to the company abel nutraceuticals srl, has shown that it is possible to focus attention on human resource management through a value chain (figure 4) ad hoc for this function, capable of generating the best possible result and impact. the simplification of the results shows that, in addition to the reportable results, it is easy to see that an activity of this type would increase the skills of the people as well as their well-being, creating, in the long term, social inclusion and attractiveness in the territory. figure 4 summarizes the concepts of this section. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5687 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 20 figure 4. simplification of results source: author’s elaboration the proposed model tries to give a message: if a company has a structure focused on the key factors described and is oriented to the participation of internal and external stakeholders, through this model has a good chance to achieve sustainable results. it would be a good starting point for future research to analyze what results the adoption of this model has given. an added value that is given to the literature is the narration of an example of a for-profit company that is oriented to generate social impact. the entire company despite being legally set up as cited follows the rules of profit management as a nonprofit. this was possible because of the contamination it underwent from the parent company that has been socially oriented for almost 30 years. the literature has shown us that the trend at the international level is towards hybrid organizations, but as zamagni says at the conference la grande sfida del nonprofit, dan pallotta vs stefano zamagni (2021) the italian situation cannot be compared to those in america or outside europe. a company like the one analyzed can be defined as hybrid, but its social impact is generated because it has been contaminated by those who have made social impact their mission. it would be different if a for-profit company divided its profit among its members and the rest was donated for the purpose of marketing. therefore, a further result emerges from this discussion, a for-profit company can be defined as hybrid if it has as a guarantor one of the core corporate values, social impact, of a company with a social vocation as in this case is arcobaleno cooperativa sociale for abel nutraceuticals srl. consequently, this research contributes to the literature on business with specific reference to the factors that it must monitor entirely in order to orient itself with its sustainable model to innovation, namely social impact. for companies with a social vocation, the impact is inherent in their dna, while for all the others, a synergy must be created in order to have the companies in the first group guaranteeing through an impact audit activity as is the case for other company phases, just think of iso certification and accounting. the management within the company, abel nutraceuticals srl, is made up of members of the non-profit company with a social vocation, arcobaleno cooperativa sociale. ensuring that function of guarantor mentioned that will be represented in the next figure. figure 5 summarizes the concepts of this section. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5687 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 21 figure 5. simplification of results source: author’s elaboration 5. discussion and conclusion 5.1. contributions to the literature to develop a high social impact and innovation-driven approach, hybrid organizations must continue to learn from experience and adapt during their internationalization and connect all stakeholders with innovative incentive tools and especially through stronger and stronger synergies with societies that have always had a social focus (figure 5). as presented above, this process is the focus of this study. in this paper, we define the key factors that hybrid mission-oriented for-profit organizations with the propensity for social impact should have to value workers and determine what factors the company's internal stakeholders would like to know in order to be heard included. in doing so, it addresses the need for transparency, accountability, and personal well-being (hartmann, 2019; presenza et al., 2014) and how they inform subsequent internationalization practices (biancone et al., 2018b; owen et al., 2000). the findings contextualize and extend the conceptual work by suggesting that hybrid organizations rely on their dynamic ability to learn from their experiences and adapt their practices in the process of solidifying good governance and leadership to generate performance and social impact and make the model replicable and scalable. it turns out that this type of structure is able to sense and manage the need of workers and efforts would be in vain if they could not be connected to the enterprise. good incentive and inclusion as presented in the literature can drive the right theory of change (castello and lévêque, 2016; kail and lumley, 2012). through responding to needs and communicating in the right way, the company can generate transparency and accountability in its internal stakeholders by triggering a proactive form of the latter who, through their participation, are able to improve the structure of the company which in turn manages the whole process described (figure 3). therefore, having such key factors, however difficult to achieve, provides an initial basis for subsequent adaptation to the process. in this sense, the findings add nuance to the view that structured hrm carries with it positive strategic effects for the company using it and for all stakeholders by generating an evolution of all (beer et al., 2015; chaudhary, 2020; kouhy et al., 2009; zamagni et al., 2015). in conclusion, the transition from one phase of key factor development to the next does not occur by default. on the contrary, the company must take an active role in monitoring the management process aimed at selecting the appropriate human capital, engaging in continuous reflection, critical evaluation, adaptation of criteria to its needs, and adaptation of best practices. in addition, the firm must ensure that all of the key factors mentioned are monitored properly, and must also engage external auditors to audit the process. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5687 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 22 5.2. implications for managers one of the problems that our era is experiencing is generational turnover and we cannot think of doing innovation without young people, therefore an innovative incentive policy generates interest in new young people and stimulates other companies to use this tool prospectively. the results show that the benefits of a good corporate structure linked to an excellent incentive tool are not necessarily automatic and may require dedicated efforts and procedures. based on the preliminary evidence of the study and if supported by further research, corporate decision-makers can improve the effects of their actions internally and externally, even when reflection on best practices is not perceived as urgent. the findings suggest that these micro-processes can be supported by an entrepreneurial attitude that allows business managers to regularly take stock and be ready to act quickly by being aware of their company's financial and non-financial data, especially in a language that is certainly accessible. too often, smaller companies going to market don't have time or resources to do these actions, and this can lead to inefficiencies that last longer than necessary, resulting in wasted resources and poor returns, as well as reducing opportunities for learning and adapting practices. the manager must select the human capital to carry out these activities, otherwise, they will have to provide external professionals for implementation. managers through an effective tool will be provided with valuable information focused on risk assessments. these decisionsupport tools will also provide "predictive" algorithms that help managers anticipate and predict potential problems, such as turnover, recruitment, compensation, and labor relations. sensitivity analyses (or "what if" analyses) will allow managers to test different alternatives and evaluate the potential consequences of their decisions. decision support tools will also provide employees with step-by-step information on hr issues. effective hybrid organizations like these share some common characteristics. they tend to inherently choose a big problem. social impact enterprises don't think small. they start with something big like the environment, health care, equity, or underserved populations, and figure out how they can make a big difference. a social impact company that aims for something really big might not make it, but there's plenty of room to do good without a lofty goal. this type of company measures success based on business/financial and social metrics. most nonprofits do good while losing money, worrying only about impact; conversely, many other companies make money without doing good. each of these identities cares about impact or profits. in contrast, a social impact company sets goals for its impact priorities in the same way it does for sales and marketing by keeping track of everything the best share their experiences in framing and tracking goals so that others can learn from their successes and failures. large or small companies with a hybrid connotation focus on building a successful for-profit company by changing the world for the better and the companies that truly change the world are the companies that last. for this reason, this research has come to the conclusion of suggesting to the managers of the future to find a guarantor who can make sure that the key factor of social impact is taken care of as arcobaleno cooperativa sociale does with abel nutraceuticals srl. 5.3. limitations and future research the scenario demonstrated has strong illustrative and exploratory potential, and the steps that the study identifies can be adapted to other contexts (acquah et al., 2020; agyabeng-mensah et al., 2020; welch, 2012). the same is true for transferring context-specific notions of good governance, leadership, performance, and especially social impact into the development of good hrm policies. there may also be other companies that have similar characteristics to our context but have different business models and industry regulations, so these findings should be transferred to these contexts with caution. the purpose of our exploratory study is to provide insights that other scholars can draw upon and explore further in the process of theory development. therefore, this study invites scholars to investigate the transferability of our insights and provides several promising avenues for future research. first, whether the proposed model years later leads to the anticipated results and further, the researcher wonders if the starting point from stakeholder needs and through a good incentive tool can generate transparency and accountability in them can be applied to all for-profit but also nonprofit contexts, as the current literature provides us with further distinctions in this category: for impact and without impact (calderini et al., 2018; clark and rosenzweig, 2004; meneguzzo, 2005). european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5687 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 23 second, the results strongly suggest that the effectiveness of the tool described above increases the speed of stakeholder engagement with the company, but further analysis that can report the results after two years would be needed to verify that all is confirmed. third, to reach a more general conclusion, the 2030 goals toward which the world is racing seem to be set by large institutions and public bodies. social enterprises, which are the drivers of social impact, can certainly contribute to this, and trying to provide a dashboard of the sdgs business format can help generate global development from the local and oversee the social impact of hybrid organizations that are not born with a social vocation like the former. in addition this case study will need to be replicated with the results of this policy in a few years. it will be interesting to see if this leads to the results mentioned and also it may be of interest to see if this approach can work for other companies. at the moment, this variant is not included in this study. the researcher would appreciate further empirical studies investigating the impact of good incentive tools on the global goals that humanity must now aim for (iannaci, 2020b; secinaro et al., 2019a). in conclusion, with the aim of answering the question "to define the key factors that a hybrid organization should have in order to achieve an incentive tool oriented to increase accountability, transparency and personal well-being thus generating social impact and to determine what factors internal stakeholders would like to know in order to be heard and included", the research confirms that a good tool that is inclusive and above all listens to the well-being of workers only works if it manages to put the worker first, having an auditor who verifies that the social inclusion it is implementing is done in the right way. this condition increases accountability, transparency, and stakeholder engagement. stakeholders would be able to better understand the strong values of good governance, leadership, performance and social impact that the company possesses. in order to define the field of innovation and identify the social value of company, which is returned to the ecosystem of the area, it is important and useful to define the business model as a tool that can facilitate (or not) the diffusion of innovation in the system. the value inherent in innovation remains latent until it is put on the market or otherwise made explicit and this can only happen through the use of a business model (chesbrough and rosenbloom, 2002). through the research project conducted so far, it has been possible to demonstrate that in hybrid organizations to have an effective incentive of human resources it is necessary to use all possible tools to know and describe the company and the ecosystem that surrounds it and this is possible through corporate knowledge and mapping that goes from the measurement of impact always starting from the construction of value chain, only in this way it will be possible to know the full potential of company under study returning clear information for all. stakeholders, therefore, will need increasingly advanced tools because the economic evaluation of social impact becomes fundamental in the knowledge economy. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5687 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 24 references aalbers, r., dolfsma, w., koppius, o., 2013. individual connectedness in innovation networks: on the role of individual motivation. res. policy 42, 624–634. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.respol.2012.10.007 abbas, j., 2020. impact of total quality management on corporate green performance through the mediating role of corporate social responsibility. j. clean. prod. 242. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2019.118458 abdel-maksoud, a., elbanna, s., mahama, h., pollanen, r., 2015. the use of performance information in strategic decision making in public organizations. int. j. public sect. manag. 28, 528–549. https://doi.org/10.1108/ijpsm-06-2015-0114 acquah, i.s.k., agyabeng-mensah, y., afum, e., 2020. examining the link among green human resource management practices, green supply chain management practices and performance. benchmarking 28, 267–290. https://doi.org/10.1108/bij-05-2020-0205 adams, c., 2000. ethical reporting: past and future. manag. account. mag. chart. manag. account. 48–50. agostino, d., arnaboldi, m., 2017. rational and ritualistic use of key performance indicators in hybrid organizations. public money manag. 37, 409–416. https://doi.org/10.1080/09540962.2017.1344021 agyabeng-mensah, y., ahenkorah, e., afum, e., nana agyemang, a., agnikpe, c., rogers, f., 2020. examining the influence of internal green supply chain practices, green human resource management and supply chain environmental cooperation on firm performance. supply chain manag. 25, 585–599. https://doi.org/10.1108/scm-11-2019-0405 ahmed, i., nawaz, m.m., iqbal, n., ali, i., ..., 2010. effects of motivational factors on employees job satisfaction a case study of university of the punjab, pakistan. int. j. textbackslashldots. aka, jr., e.o., 1993. town and country planning and administration in nigeria. int. j. public sect. manag. 6, 47–64. https://doi.org/10.1108/09513559310039683 al-htaybat, k., von alberti-alhtaybat, l., 2013. management accounting theory revisited: seeking to increase research relevance. int. j. bus. textbackslashldots. al-khasawneh, a.l., futa, s.m., 2012. the impact of leadership styles used by the academic staff in the jordanian public universities on modifying students’ behavior: a field study in the northern \textbackslashldots. textbackslashldots j. bus. manag. alshammari, m., 2015. corporate social responsibility and firm performance: the moderating role of reputation and institutional investors. int. j. bus. manag. andrews, c., 2016. integrating public service motivation and self-determination theory: a framework. int. j. public sect. manag. 29, 238–254. https://doi.org/10.1108/ijpsm-10-2015-0176 ansell, c., gash, a., 2008. collaborative governance in theory and practice. j. public adm. res. theory 18, 543–571. anselmsson, j., bondesson, n., melin, f., 2016. customer-based brand equity and human resource management image: do retail customers really care about hrm and the employer brand? eur. j. mark. 50, 1185–1208. https://doi.org/10.1108/ejm-02-2015-0094 apospori, e., nikandrou, i., brewster, c., papalexandris, n., 2008. hrm and organizational performance in northern and southern europe. int. j. hum. resour. manag. 19, 1187–1207. https://doi.org/10.1080/09585190802109788 arsić, s., nikolić, d., živković, z., 2017. hybrid swot anp fanp model for prioritization strategies of sustainable development of ecotourism in national park djerdap, serbia. for. policy econ. 80, 11–26. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.forpol.2017.02.003 associazione festival del fundraising, 2021. la grande sfida del nonprofit, dan pallotta vs stefano zamagni 2 marzo 2021 • online edition. awotundun, d.a., kehinde, j.s., somoye, r.o.c., , 2011. corporate governance and stakeholders interest: a case of nigerian banks. int. j. bus. manag. bahemia, h., sillince, j., vanhaverbeke, w., 2018. the timing of openness in a radical innovation project, a temporal and loose coupling perspective. res. policy 47, 2066–2076. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.respol.2018.07.015 battilana, j., dorado, s., 2010. building sustainable hybrid organizations: the case of commercial microfinance organizations. acad. manage. j. 53, 1419–1440. battilana, j., sengul, m., pache, a.-c., model, j., 2015. harnessing productive tensions in hybrid organizations: the case of work integration social enterprises. acad. manage. j. 58, 1658–1685. https://doi.org/10.5465/amj.2013.0903 beer, m., boselie, p., brewster, c., 2015. back to the future: implications for the field of hrm of the multistakeholder perspective proposed 30 years ago. hum. resour. manage. 54, 427–438. https://doi.org/10.1002/hrm.21726 bezzi, c., 2001. valutazione partecipata nei servizi. prospett. sociali e sanit. 6. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5687 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 25 biancone, p., secinaro, s., 2015. popular financial reporting : un nuovo strumento di rendicontazione per le municipalità. giappichelli, torino. biancone, p., secinaro, s., brescia, v., 2016. the popular financial reporting: focus on stakeholders—the first european experience. int. j. bus. manag. 11, 115. https://doi.org/10.5539/ijbm.v11n11p115 biancone, p., secinaro, s., brescia, v., iannaci, d., 2019. the popular financial reporting between theory and evidence. biancone, p., secinaro, s., brescia, v., iannaci, d., 2018a. the popular financial reporting as tool to measure social impact. munich. biancone, p., secinaro, s., brescia, v., iannaci, d., 2018b. communication and data processing in local public group: transparency and accountability. int. j. bus. manag. 13, 20–37. biancone, p., secinaro, s.f., brescia, v., iannaci, d., 2018c. popular financial reporting, a new information tool for social cooperatives. bicciato, f., 2010. finanza etica e impresa sociale. società editrice il mulino, spa, bologna. billis, d., 2010. hybrid organizations and the third sector: challenges for practice, theory and policy. macmillan international higher education. borzaga, c., 2020. la rilevanza economica del terzo settore: la situazione e l’impatto della riforma (the economic relevance of the third sector: scenario and impact of the reform). borzaga, c., 2015. economia cooperativa. rilevanza, evoluzione e nuove frontiere della cooperazione italiana. boyett, i., 1996. the public sector entrepreneur a definition. int. j. public sect. manag. 9, 36–51. https://doi.org/10.1108/09513559610119546 calderini, m., chiodo, v., michelucci, f.v., 2018. growing social impact finance: implications for the public sector, in: positive impact investing. springer, pp. 27–38. campbell, a., tawadey, k., 2016. mission and business philosophy. elsevier. campbell, d.t., 1986. relabeling internal and external validity for applied social scientists. new dir. program eval. 1986, 67– 77. carroll, a.b., 1996. business and society-ethics and stakeholder management. south-western publishing co, cincinnati. castello, s., lévêque, c.m., 2016. la theory of change come impact-model: diffusione e utilizzo a livello nazionale e internazionale. philanthr. insights 4. chaudhary, r., 2020. green human resource management and employee green behavior: an empirical analysis. corp. soc. responsib. environ. manag. 27, 630–641. https://doi.org/10.1002/csr.1827 cheng-hua, t., shyh-jer, c., shih-chien, f., 2009. employment modes, high-performance work practices, and organizational performance in the hospitality industry. cornell hosp. q. 50, 413–431. chesbrough, h., rosenbloom, r.s., 2002. the role of the business model in capturing value from innovation: evidence from xerox corporation’s technology spin-off companies. ind. corp. change 11, 529–555. chopra, k., 2019. indian shopper motivation to use artificial intelligence: generating vroom’s expectancy theory of motivation using grounded theory approach. int. j. retail distrib. manag. 47, 331–347. https://doi.org/10.1108/ijrdm-11-20180251 clark, c., rosenzweig, w., 2004. double bottom line project report. univ. calif. berkeley. cooke, t.e., 1989. voluntary corporate disclosure by swedish companies. j. int. financ. manag. account. 1, 171–195. corvo, l., pastore, l., 2018. la costellazione del valore: approcci collaborativi oltre porter. colloquio sci. sullimpresa soc. innovazione dei framework interpretativi e teorici. crook, t.r., combs, j.g., ketchen jr., d.j., aguinis, h., 2013. organizing around transaction costs: what have we learned and where do we go from here? acad. manag. perspect. 27, 63–79. https://doi.org/10.5465/amp.2012.0008 curtis, t., herbst, j., gumkovska, m., 2010. the social economy of trust: social entrepreneurship experiences in poland. soc. enterp. j. 6, 194–209. du, j., leten, b., vanhaverbeke, w., 2014. managing open innovation projects with science-based and market-based partners. res. policy 43, 828–840. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.respol.2013.12.008 dvir, d., raz, t., shenhar, a.j., 2003. an empirical analysis of the relationship between project planning and project success. int. j. proj. manag. 21, 89–95. ebrahim, a., battilana, j., mair, j., 2014. the governance of social enterprises: mission drift and accountability challenges in hybrid organizations. res. organ. behav. 34, 81–100. eisenhardt, k.m., 1989. building theories from case study research. acad. manage. rev. 14, 532–550. fang, c., marle, f., 2012. a simulation-based risk network model for decision support in project risk management. decis. support syst. 52, 635–644. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.dss.2011.10.021 european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5687 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 26 fernández-fernández, j.-l., 1999. ethics and the board of directors in spain: the olivencia code of good governance. j. bus. ethics 22, 233–247. fowler, a., 2000. ngdos as a moment in history: beyond aid to social entrepreneurship or civic innovation? third world q. 21, 637–654. freeman, r.e., 2010. strategic management: a stakeholder approach. cambridge university press. garrow, e., hasenfeld, y., 2012. managing conflicting institutional logics: social service versus market, in: social enterprises. springer, pp. 121–143. gray, r., kouhy, r., lavers, s., 1995. constructing a research database of social and environmental reporting by uk companies. account. audit. account. j. 8, 78–101. greenberg, p., bugden, d., 2019. energy consumption boomtowns in the united states: community responses to a cryptocurrency boom. energy res. soc. sci. 50, 162–167. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.erss.2018.12.005 grossi, g., thomasson, a., 2015. bridging the accountability gap in hybrid organizations: the case of copenhagen malmö port. int. rev. adm. sci. 81, 604–620. https://doi.org/10.1177/0020852314548151 haigh, n., hoffman, a.j., 2012. hybrid organizations: the next chapter of sustainable business. organ. dyn. 41, 126–134. hartmann, s., 2019. citizen relationship management for civic participation: how smart cities use 311 to involve citizens. public adm. inf. technol. 34, 59–77. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-89474-4_4 hockerts, k., 2015. how hybrid organizations turn antagonistic assets into complementarities. calif. manage. rev. 57, 83– 106. https://doi.org/10.1525/cmr.2015.57.3.83 hoffman, a.j., badiane, k.k., haigh, n., 2012. hybrid organizations as agents of positive social change: bridging the forprofit and non-profit divide, in: using a positive lens to explore social change and organizations. routledge, pp. 152–174. holt, d., littlewood, d., 2015. identifying, mapping, and monitoring the impact of hybrid firms. calif. manage. rev. 57, 107–125. https://doi.org/10.1525/cmr.2015.57.3.107 hrtel, c.e.j., gough, h., hrtel, g.f., 2008. work-group emotional climate, emotion management skills, and service attitudes and performance. asia pac. j. hum. resour. 46, 21–37. https://doi.org/10.1177/1038411107086541. hsu, g., hannan, m.t., 2005. identities, genres, and organizational forms. organ. sci. 16, 474–490. hughes, k., 2017. blockchain, the greater good, and human and civil rights. metaphilosophy 48, 654–665. https://doi.org/10.1111/meta.12271 iannaci, d., 2020a. reporting tools for social enterprises: between impact measurement and stakeholder needs. eur. j. soc. impact circ. econ. iannaci, d., 2020b. gli standard della rendicontazione sociale. pearson. iannaci, d., aiassa, a., 2020. adeguamento statuti delle odv. eur. j. volunt. community-based proj. 1, 1–26. kail, a., lumley, t., 2012. theory of change: the beginning of making a difference. new philanthr. cap. kenny, b., meaton, j., 2007. cross-benchmarking international competitiveness and performance in human language technologies. benchmarking 14, 594–608. https://doi.org/10.1108/14635770710819272 kirk, j., miller, marc l., miller, marc louis, 1986. reliability and validity in qualitative research. sage. kleynjans, l., hudon, m., 2016. a study of codes of ethics for mexican microfinance institutions. j. bus. ethics 134, 397– 412. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10551-014-2434-y komarov, m., konovalov, n., kazantsev, n., 2016. how internet of things influences human behavior building social web of services via agent-based approach. found. comput. decis. sci. 41, 197–210. https://doi.org/10.1515/fcds-20160012 koprowski, e.j., 1981. exploring the meaning of “good” management. acad. manage. rev. 6, 459–467. kouhy, r., vedd, r., yoshikawa, t., innes, j., 2009. human resource policies, management accounting and organisational performance. j. hum. resour. costing account. lee, c., clerkin, r.m., 2017. the adoption of outcome measurement in human service nonprofits. j. public nonprofit aff. 3, 111–134. https://doi.org/10.20899/jpna.3.2.111-134 lehner, o.m., nicholls, a., 2014. social finance and crowdfunding for social enterprises: a public–private case study providing legitimacy and leverage. venture cap. 16, 271–286. https://doi.org/10.1080/13691066.2014.925305 leimsider, r., 2014. 5 bad reasons to start a for-profit social enterprise. harv. bus. rev. july httpshbr org2014075-badreasons--start---profit-socialenterprise. lengnick-hall, m.l., lengnick-hall, c.a., andrade, l.s., drake, b., 2009. strategic human resource management: the evolution of the field. hum. resour. manag. rev. 19, 64–85. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.hrmr.2009.01.002 lengnick-hall, m.l., moritz, s., 2003. the impact of e-hr on the human resource management function. j. labor res. 24, 365–379. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5687 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 27 leonard-barton, d., 1990. a dual methodology for case studies: synergistic use of a longitudinal single site with replicated multiple sites. organ. sci. 1, 248–266. mair, j., mayer, j., lutz, e., 2015. navigating institutional plurality: organizational governance in hybrid organizations. organ. stud. 36, 713–739. marradi, a., 1992. concetti e metodo pre la ricerca sociale. la giuntina. meneguzzo, m., 2005. creazione di valore e sviluppo del capitale sociale. riv. ital. ragioneria e econ. aziend. montesi, f., greco, c., montesi, f., seganti, s., 2017. innova guida pratica per il terzo settore. human foundation. naqvi, i.h., bokhari, s.h.a., aziz, s., 2011. the impact of human resource (hr) performance management on project outcome. afr. j. bus. manag. 5, 8491–8499. nguyen, l., szkudlarek, b., seymour, r.g., 2015. social impact measurement in social enterprises: an interdependence perspective. can. j. adm. sci. can. sci. adm. 32, 224–237. norman, d.j., 2014. from shouting to counting: civil society and good governance reform in cambodia. pac. rev. 1–24. https://doi.org/10.1080/09512748.2014.882393 noyons, e., 2001. bibliometric mapping of science in a policy context. scientometrics 50, 83–98. owen, d., swift, t., humphrey, c., bowerman, m., 2000. the new social audits: accountability, managerial capture or the agenda of social champions? eur. account. rev. 9, 81–98. peck, s.r., 1994. exploring the link between organizational strategy and the employment relationship: the role of human resources policies. j. manag. stud. 31, 715–736. presenza, a., micera, r., splendiani, s., chiappa, g.d., 2014. stakeholder e-involvement and participatory tourism planning: analysis of an italian case study. int. j. knowl.-based dev. 5, 311–328. https://doi.org/10.1504/ijkbd.2014.065320 puddu, l., 1980. la ricerca e sviluppo nel sistema d’impresa. a. giuffré. rawhouser, h., cummings, m., crane, a., 2015. benefit corporation legislation and the emergence of a social hybrid category. calif. manage. rev. 57, 13–35. https://doi.org/10.1525/cmr.2015.57.3.13 reiser, d.b., 2012. the next big thing: flexible purpose corporations. am u bus rev 2, 55. reiser, d.b., 2011. benefit corporations-a sustainable form of organization. wake for. rev 46, 591. rousseau, j.-j., 2015. il contratto sociale. edizioni mondadori. scherer, a.g., palazzo, g., 2011. the new political role of business in a globalized world: a review of a new perspective on csr and its implications for the firm, governance, and democracy. j. manag. stud. 48, 899–931. secinaro, s., brescia, v., calandra, d., chmet, f., 2019a. the popular financial reporting for hybrid organization: a solution to a tricky accounting problem. j. account. finance 2158-3625 19. secinaro, s., brescia, v., iannaci, d., jonathan, g.m., 2021. does citizen involvement feed on digital platforms? int. j. public adm. 1–18. https://doi.org/10.1080/01900692.2021.1887216 secinaro, s., corvo, l., brescia, v., iannaci, d., 2019b. hybrid organizations: a systematic review of the current literature. int. bus. res. shenhar, a.j., dvir, d., levy, o., maltz, a.c., 2001. project success: a multidimensional strategic concept. long range plann. 34, 699–725. shenhar, a.j., tishler, a., dvir, d., lipovetsky, s., lechler, t., 2002. refining the search for project success factors: a multivariate, typological approach. rd manag. 32, 111–126. shih, h.-a., chiang, y.-h., hsu, c.-c., 2006. can high performance work systems really lead to better performance? int. j. manpow. singh, a.k., 2005. hrd practices and philosophy of management in indian organizations. vikalpa 30, 71–80. smith, s.r., phillips, s.d., 2016. the changing and challenging environment of nonprofit human services: implications for governance and program implementation, in: nonprofit policy forum. de gruyter, pp. 63–76. stake, r.e., 1996. the art of case study research: stake, robert e. thousand oaks, ca: sage publications, 1995. 175 pp. $23.50 (paperback). (isbn 0-8039-5767-x). libr. inf. sci. res. 18, 291–293. https://doi.org/10.1016/s07408188(96)90053-5 thomasson, a., 2009. exploring the ambiguity of hybrid organisations: a stakeholder approach. financ. account. manag. 25, 353–366. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1468-0408.2009.00481.x vining, a., weimer, d., 2016. the challenges of fractionalized property rights in public-private hybrid organizations: the good, the bad, and the ugly. regul. gov. 10, 161–178. welch, e.w., 2012. the relationship between transparent and participative government: a study of local governments in the united states. int. rev. adm. sci. 78, 93–115. wiersema, m.f., nishimura, y., suzuki, k., 2018. executive succession: the importance of social capital in ceo appointments. strateg. manag. j. 39, 1473–1495. https://doi.org/10.1002/smj.2766 european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/5687 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 28 yin, r.k., 2014. case study research: design and methods (fifth). london, uk: sage publications ltd. yin, r.k., 1994. case study research. design and methods, 2 utg. ed. sage publications, london. zamagni, s., 2013. territorio, istituzioni, crescita: la ripresa d’interesse nella ricerca economica. frat. u pellegrini ga cura territ. ist. crescita sci. reg. e sviluppo paese milano francoangeli 39–56. zamagni, s., venturi, p., rago, s., 2015. valutare l’impatto sociale. la questione della misurazione nelle imprese sociali. riv. impresa soc. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/10799 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 28 using the circular economy to mitigate the global electronic waste challenge: a systematic literature review approach mfowabo maphosa1*, vusumuzi maphosa 2 1 engage department, faculty of engineering, built environment and information technology, university of pretoria, pretoria (south africa) mfowabo.maphosa@up.ac.za *contact author orcid 0000-0003-3702-6821 2department of information and communication technology services, national university of science and technology, bulawayo (zimbabwe) vusumuzi.maphosa@nust.ac.zw orcid 0000-0002-2595-3890 received: 19/07/2024 accepted for publication: 05/12/2024 published: 20/12/2024 abstract the global electronic waste (e-waste) output is increasing at an alarming pace, albeit with limited management practices, resulting in the release of toxic anthropogenic elements that threaten the environment and public health. the linear economic model, which follows the take-make-consume-dispose has shaped the global economy. in contrast, the circular economy reduces wastage, recirculates raw materials, and extends the lifespan of products through repairing, refurbishing and remanufacturing. this reduces supply chain risks and product supply disruptions and creates formal jobs. this systematic literature review evaluates how the knowledge economy and modernisation growth have contributed to the e-waste burden, and how the circular economy can mitigate environmental and health effects. the study evaluates the impact of the circular economy and the e-waste problem. it identifies the research landscape, the key research clusters, relevant topics, and research hotspots from research output from the 949 publications selected from the scopus database published from 2014 to 2023. the analysis involved quantitative descriptions of several metrics related to the research outputs. the analysis also involved creating network and density graphs using vosviewer and generating the ten key topics and a word cloud using provalis wordstat. the study also highlights the conceptual developments and current and future research trends. the findings show that research outputs increased substantially from two in 2014 to 257 in 2023 and citations grew astronomically, from one in 2014 to 8409 in 2023. the analysis reveals five research clusters: material management and resource recovery, business practices and circular economy strategies, technology integration and sustainability, recycling challenges, and environmental health and sustainable practices. the study recommends that emerging economies should embrace the circular economy and integrate the informal sector for e-waste collection, sorting, and less complex recycling, while the formal sector conducts high-end recycling. keywords: circular economy, electronic waste, electrical and electronic equipment, sustainable development, supply chain, extended producer responsibility 29 1. introduction the growth of the global economy has been fueled by the linear economic model which follows the take-make-consumedispose approach (zeng & li, 2018). in 2015, the united nations adopted the 2030 agenda for sustainable development. this agenda outlines 17 goals and 169 targets structured around five pillars (people, planet, prosperity, peace, and partnership) to promote sustainable, resilient development and ensure no one is left behind (united nations, 2015). sustainable development requires a move from a linear-based economy to a circular economy that follows the made-to-be-made-again policy. electrical and electronic equipment (eee) is central to socio-economic development and improving the lives of billions across the globe. the covid-19 pandemic transformed most of our activities and increased our reliance on eee, resulting in unprecedented adoption, especially in developing countries. businesses depend on eee to remain competitive despite changing consumer patterns and globalisation. businesses have to manage supply chain risks to eliminate product supply disruptions (althaf & babbitt, 2021). the fourth industrial revolution (4ir), the rise of the knowledge economy and artificial intelligence, the internet of things (iot), the miniaturisation of eee, and declining prices have resulted in multiple device ownership (bachér et al., 2017). most recently, the internet, social media and smartphones have become part of our daily lives. electronic waste (e-waste) refers to eee whose owner has discarded it, whether working or at the end of its useful life (forti et al., 2020; maphosa & maphosa, 2022). this includes information technology, telecommunications equipment, medical equipment, office and home appliances, batteries and solar panels. over time, the lifespan of desktop computers diminished from ten years to three years, fuelling rapid e-waste accumulation (agamuthu et al., 2015); thereby threatening the people and planet pillars in the united nations’ agenda for sustainable development (united nations, 2015). the global demand for eee has surged, and poor recycling initiatives strain the supply of raw materials used to manufacture this equipment. iot devices will reach 75 billion by 2025 (statista, 2016), fuelling e-waste. global e-waste output rose from 9.2 metric tonnes (mt) in 2014 to 54 mt in 2019 and is expected to reach 74.7 mt by 2030 (kumar et al., 2022). of the 57.4 mt of e-waste produced in 2021, only 17.4% was formally recycled, with about 47 mt dumped into landfills and dumpsites in developing countries (forti et al., 2020), leaving a toxic legacy. improper recycling releases toxic anthropogenic elements such as cadmium, mercury, lead and nickel, and organic compounds such as flame retardants, chlorofluorocarbons, polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons, polybrominated diphenyl ethers, that threaten the environment and public health (parvez et al., 2021). following the circular economy approach reduces the need for exploiting virgin resources and encourages rethinking resource and waste management, product redesign for cost efficiency, job creation, innovative technologies, and environmental friendliness. it also promotes reuse, sharing, repair, refurbishment, remanufacturing, and recycling in a closed-loop system (zeng & li, 2018). thus, the circular economy aims to reduce wastage and pollution, recirculate raw materials, improve product design and extend the lifespan of eee through repairing, refurbishing and remanufacturing (lazar, 2021). the study aims to highlight the ever-growing e-waste burden and explore how the circular economy can improve e-waste management for sustainable development. this study aimed to achieve the following objectives: • examine the current state of research on the circular economy and its implications for e-waste management. • identify and analyse the central themes and research clusters in the circular economy and e-waste management research outputs. • explore existing research gaps and propose future directions for investigation in the fields of circular economy and e-waste management. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/10799 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 30 this study explores how the knowledge economy contributes to the e-waste burden and examines how the circular economy can mitigate its environmental and health effects. the study analyses research outputs to identify key clusters, topics, and trends in e-waste and circular economy research. using provalis wordstat and vosviewer, the research combined quantitative methods with text mining, topic modelling, and visualisation techniques to provide an understanding of the field. network and density graphs highlight research clusters and hotspots, while word clouds and topic modelling identify the most relevant topics in the literature. the findings reveal key research clusters namely material management, circular economy strategies, sustainability practices, and recycling challenges. the study underscores the importance of adopting circular economy principles globally, recommending that emerging economies integrate the informal sector for e-waste collection and basic recycling, with the formal sector focusing on advanced recycling processes. 2. literature review 2.1 the circular economy the dominant traditional linear economic model does not achieve equilibrium as it results in the depletion of natural resources, biodiversity loss and drastic climate change (pwc, 2021). in contrast, the circular economy is a generative system premised on natural evolution, where materials are preserved at their optimal value, with toxic materials and waste designed out of the system (wef, 2019). industry experts note that adopting a circular economy improves productivity and efficiency and reduces environmental and health impacts for communities around landfills (unido, 2019; mwaijande, 2024). this perspective highlights the potential for circular practices to not only benefit industries but also to protect vulnerable populations from the detrimental effects of waste accumulation. furthermore, scholars pointed out that the circular economy reduces supply chain risks, which can result in product supply disruptions (pan et al., 2022). other essential models of the circular economy include product-as-a-service, extending the useful life of eee through green designs, repair and reuse, and ultimately recycling (wef, 2019). the application of the circular economy aims to decelerate, bridge and regenerate resource cycles, thereby minimising extraction of virgin materials and waste production (arpin et al., 2024). central to the circular economy are the “7 r’s”: redesign, reduce, reuse, refuse, rethink, recover, and recycle. these principles serve as foundational guidelines that collectively promote sustainable development while safeguarding environmental integrity and public health (meloni et al., 2018). the emphasis on these principles highlights the necessity for a holistic approach to resource management that transcends traditional linear models. scholars have further emphasised that the circular economy optimises product design and policy frameworks to eliminate waste, thereby facilitating the adoption of cleaner and renewable technologies (lin & wei, 2023). this process allows for the extraction of valuable materials from e-waste, which can then be reused in the manufacturing of eee and other products (de oliveira neto et al., 2023). these materials can be redirected back into the manufacturing process, thereby reducing the need for virgin resources and minimising environmental impact (lazar, 2021). in developed countries, the extended producer responsibility (epr) scheme supports the circular economy model through takeback mechanisms, sending e-waste back to the manufacturer for recycling and proper disposal. the epr is one of the most european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/10799 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 31 viable e-waste management strategies, where precious minerals are recovered using environmentally friendly and economically viable methods that protect public health and the environment (thakur & kumar, 2022). by integrating the epr into the circular economy, developed countries are better positioned to manage e-waste effectively, reduce resource depletion, and enhance recycling rates. in contrast, 99% of e-waste recycling in developing countries, is handled by the informal sector, with no protective clothing, such as gloves and nose masks. to extract precious minerals, workers employ hammers, stones, and screwdrivers to dismantle, burn, and apply acid leaching techniques on eee, thereby threatening environmental integrity and public health (maphosa & maphosa, 2020). nevertheless, obstacles that hinder the operation of circular economies in africa include the lack of policies and finance, an unknowledgeable informal sector, and weak collection and transportation systems (moyen massa & archodoulaki, 2023). unlike developed countries, reports show that in most developing countries there are no defined e-waste collection points and transportation systems (maphosa, 2021; dias et al., 2022); hence, most individuals and institutions illegally dispose of their ewaste with municipal garbage. as noted by the united nations (united nations, 2015), sustainable development is critical to sustaining economic growth for a growing population with finite resources. the circular economy model does not only represent an important area in the management of e-waste but also covers sustainable development. 2.2 electronic-waste differing definitions of e-waste and lack of policies have resulted in a booming toxic waste trade against the spirit and mission of the basel convention, which aims to end the transboundary movement and trade of poisonous waste (forti et al., 2020). developing countries are adopting digital technologies to leapfrog into the knowledge economy and, thus, have enacted policies to bridge the digital divide (ohemeng & ofosu-adarkwa, 2014), albeit with minimum consideration of the epidemiological and environmental effects. the unidirectional flow of e-waste from the global north to the global south has been critically described as a form of neocolonialism, highlighting a significant decarbonisation divide (maphosa, 2022). this phenomenon reflects a systemic issue where the burden of e-waste management is disproportionately transferred to developing countries that often lack the necessary infrastructure and capacity to handle such waste effectively. research indicates that over 80% of second-hand electrical and electronic equipment (eee) is illegally exported from the global north to developing nations (agamuthu et al., 2015; mihai et al., 2022). this illegal trade not only exacerbates the e-waste crisis in these regions but also raises ethical concerns regarding environmental justice and accountability. furthermore, reports reveal that more than 75% of the imported second-hand and donated eee in developing countries are deemed unusable and unrepairable (osibanjo & nnorom, 2007). this statistic underscores the detrimental impact of such exports, as they contribute to environmental degradation and undermine local economies that are ill-equipped to manage the influx of non-functional equipment. the composition of e-waste reveals significant deposits of minerals; for instance, a ton of mobile phones contains mineral deposits that are 50 times more valuable than a ton of mineral ore extracted from even the richest mines (chatterjee, 2015). this highlights the economic potential inherent in e-waste, suggesting that effective recycling practices could yield substantial european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/10799 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 32 financial benefits. eee is produced using some of the world’s rare earth metals, including indium, lithium, and cobalt, as well as precious metals such as gold, silver, aluminium, and copper (chancerel et al., 2015). the recovery of these minerals from ewaste not only presents an opportunity to mitigate environmental damage caused by over-mining but also addresses the exploitation of virgin and finite natural resources (maphosa, 2022). such recovery processes are critical in promoting sustainable practices within the industry. moreover, research indicates that unrecycled e-waste accounts for over 7% of the world’s gold output (united nations, 2019). this statistic underscores the substantial economic loss that occurs when e-waste is not properly managed and recycled. extending the lifespan of eee and reusing components from broken down eee has more economic and environmental benefits. reusable components are salvaged to rebuild eee, while non-reusable components are recycled and disposed of in a formal way that does not endanger public health and the environment. thus, conserving virgin minerals, protecting the environment and creating formal and sustainable jobs. recycling e-waste releases fewer carbon emissions compared to conventional mining. lack of policies, low recycling, lack of knowledge and infrastructure and unavailability of the epr schemes in most african countries result in the loss of scarce resources and precious metals (maphosa & mashau, 2023). 3. methodology the study adopted a systematic literature review allowing for the gathering of relevant literature that meets specific eligibility criteria to address research questions (moher et al., 2015). in this study, bibliometric analysis and text mining are integrated together. bibliometric analysis provides a quantitative method for mapping literature, revealing influential publications and research trends (secinaro et al., 2020). the focus on the last decade is driven by the recent surge in academic interest in circular economy and e-waste, as earlier publications were limited. text mining techniques, such as information retrieval and data mining, complement this by uncovering direct and indirect relationships between pieces of information, yielding deeper insights (ferreira‐mello et al., 2019; thomas et al., 2011). the combination of topic modelling and text mining is especially effective in this review, as it uncovers patterns and trends within a vast body of literature, leading to an efficient synthesis of findings. together, these methods help identify conceptual developments, current research, and future trends in the field. 3.1 inclusion criteria the inclusion criteria help to define the conditions for the inclusion of research outputs for review. based on the requirements for this study, we used the following criteria: • the research output must be a journal article, review paper, conference paper, book, or book chapter written in english. these formats were selected because they are peer-reviewed, and the language criterion ensures consistent analysis using vosviewer and provalis wordstat. • the article should have been published in the past decade, from january 2014 to december 2023. this allows us to trace the research landscape in that decade. • the research output had to include both constructs of interest (circular economy and e-waste). european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/10799 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 33 3.2 literature research strategy the research outputs were identified by searching the scopus databases in january and february 2024. the search was updated in september 2024 to include articles that were published in 2023 but were in press and could not be accessed in january and february 2024. we searched for all available records using the following combination of keywords in the title or abstract of the research output: “circular economy” and “e-waste” or “electronic waste” or “weee” or “waste electrical and electronic equipment”. the initial query retained 1.257 records. we then removed all non-english research outputs as specified in the inclusion criteria and remained with 1.239 research outputs. next, we filtered to the last decade – 2014 to 2023, as indicated in the inclusion criteria, leaving 970 research outputs. we then filtered by document types as stated in the inclusion criteria, leaving 949 research outputs. we then downloaded the research outputs as an ms excel csv file for analysis using vosviewer and provalis wordstat (luo et al., 2018). the downloaded file contained information about the authors, the publication title, the year of publication, citation count, abstract, author keywords and the index keywords. 3.3 data analysis the research outputs were analysed using quantitative methods to address the research objectives. the scopus database was used to extract information about the types of research outputs, their distribution in terms of the subject areas, publication and citation trends and the h-index. to process and analyse the data, we used provalis wordstat a text mining tool that employs tokenisation, stop-word removal, and stemming to clean and standardise text for analysis. this step is crucial to enhance the quality of the data for subsequent analysis. provalis wordstat uses latent dirichlet allocation to perform topic modelling, enabling the identification of key topics within the research outputs. the optimal number of topics was determined using coherence score evaluation, ensuring that the model captured meaningful patterns and relationships in the data. once the key topics were identified, we used provalis wordstat to generate a ranked list of the top ten key topics. additionally, we created a word cloud to provide a visual representation of the most frequently used terms, making it easier to discern prominent themes and terminology within the dataset. to complement the text mining and topic modelling results, we employed vosviewer to create a network graph that depicted the relationships between research clusters and showed the interconnected areas of study. we also used vosviewer to generate a density graph. the density graph shows the research hotspots, highlighting insights into areas of concentrated research activity. 4. results 4.1 descriptive analysis table i provides the distribution of the document types analysed. journal articles dominate, accounting for almost two-thirds of the research outputs; review articles represent almost 15%; followed by conference papers just above 13%; book chapters contribute just over 8% and books make up less than 1%. the dominance of journal articles bodes well and signifies a mature and topical research focus that attracts the attention of publishers. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/10799 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 34 table i. distribution of the document types type number of research outputs percentage journal articles 600 63.2% review articles 140 14.8% conference paper 124 13.1% book chapter 78 8.2% book 7 0.7% total 949 100% source: authors’ elaboration in terms of the geographical distribution of the producers of research outputs, a total of 75 countries are represented. research publications are generated by countries across the world, reflecting a truly global interest in the circular economy and e-waste research. table ii presents the top 10 most productive countries in research outputs, showing italy in the lead with 112 research publications. italy is followed closely by india with 105 outputs, and then china and the united kingdom simultaneously, each with 98 publications. the united states follows with 81 outputs, then germany with 68. spain, australia, brazil and france make the last four contributions with 55, 54, 49 and 39 outputs respectively. table ii. top 10 most productive countries country number of research outputs italy 112 india 105 china 98 united kingdom 98 united states 81 germany 68 spain 55 australia 54 brazil 49 france 39 source: authors’ elaboration figure 1 presents the distribution of the research outputs by the scopus database subject areas. it is necessary to note that a research output can be indexed in more than one subject area. as shown in the figure, “environmental science” is the most represented with 588 research outputs, followed by “engineering” (304) and “energy” (275). “materials science”, “social sciences” and “business management and accounting” have 124, 123, and 115 research outputs, respectively. “chemistry”, “economics, econometrics and finance”, and “chemical engineering” command substantial representation, each with over 80 european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/10799 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 35 research outputs. “psychology” and “immunology and microbiology” have much lower representation, each having less than five research outputs. although environmental science is dominant, the presence of 22 more subject areas underscores the interdisciplinary and transdisciplinary nature of the circular economy and e-waste research. figure 1. distribution of the research outputs using the scopus database subject area source: authors’ elaboration 4.2 publication and citation analysis figure 2 shows the publication trends for the research outputs analysed. there was a notable increase in research outputs between 2014 and 2023. the number of research outputs steadily increased from two in 2014, seven in 2015 and then 22 in 2016, reflecting a growing recognition of the importance of these topics. by 2017, the number of research outputs reached 32, indicating a growth in research activity and a growing body of knowledge on the circular economy and e-waste. there were 56 research outputs in 2018, 86 in 2019, 107 in 2020 and 179 in 2021. the years 2022 and 2023 saw a further increase in research outputs, with each year producing 201 and 257 research outputs respectively. this surge denotes a growing interest in research on e-waste management and the circular economy, amplifying the importance of the topics. the citation trends for research outputs analysed in the study are shown in figure 3. in 2014, there were two citations. in the following two years, the number of citations began to increase monumentally, with 15 citations in 2015, 66 in 2016, and 174 in 2017. the number of citations more than doubled from the year 2018 to 2020, reaching 1.626 by 2020. in 2021, citations 588 304 275 124 123 115 106 98 92 85 42 39 31 24 23 17 15 8 7 5 4 2 0 100 200 300 400 500 600 700 environmental science engineering energy materials science social sciences business, management and accounting chemistry economics, econometrics and finance computer science chemical engineering earth and planetary sciences physics and astronomy mathematics medicine decision sciences agricultural and biological sciences biochemistry, genetics and molecular biology pharmacology, toxicology and pharmaceutics multidisciplinary arts and humanities psychology immunology and microbiology research outputs sc op us su bj ec t a re a european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/10799 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 36 increased to 3 391, and the trend continued with citations reaching 5.628 and 8.409, in 2022 and 2023 respectively, indicating growing interest, increased impact and visibility of research on the circular economy and e-waste over the last ten years. figure 2. publication trends of the 949 research outputs analysed source: authors’ elaboration table iii shows the top 10 most cited research outputs in the circular economy and sustainability field showing that the most influential papers are not necessarily the oldest. the highest-cited paper, by schroeder, anggraeni, and weber (2019), explores the relevance of circular economy practices to the sustainable development goals and has amassed 893 citations. this significant citation count highlights the growing importance of linking sustainability efforts with global development frameworks. another highly cited work from 2019 by nascimento et al. (2019), examines how industry 4.0 technologies can support the circular economy practices in manufacturing, has garnered 601 citations. cucchiella et al. (2015), assess the economic aspects of weee recycling. despite its earlier publication date, it has accumulated 619 citations. this shows that while newer research is quickly gaining attention, older studies remain critical in shaping the field. the blend of older and newer studies in the top 10 reflects how ongoing technological advancements and sustainability challenges maintain long-term relevance for researchers and policymakers. 2 7 22 32 56 86 107 179 201 257 0 50 100 150 200 250 300 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 re se ar ch o ut pu ts year european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/10799 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 37 figure 3. citation trends for research outputs analysed source: authors’ elaboration in addition to these influential works, several recent publications on lithium-ion battery recycling are rapidly gaining citations. for example, papers by yang et al. (2021) and makuza et al. (2021) on the sustainability and recycling options for lithium-ion batteries have already garnered 525 and 477 citations, respectively. these numbers highlight the urgent focus on battery recycling in the context of the circular economy, particularly with the rise of electric vehicles and renewable energy storage. this trend underscores that impactful research in this domain is not limited to older studies; newer contributions that address emerging sustainability challenges are quickly becoming central to the conversation. the h-graph is a tool for visualising and comparing the productivity and impact of research outputs, institutions or authors. it uses the h-index, a metric developed by hirsch (hirsch, 2005) to achieve this. the h-index is determined by the highest number of articles that have received at least the same number of citations. the h-index was calculated using the scopus database analysis feature. of these 949 research outputs, only 846 have at least one citation. these research outputs have been cited 29,238 times. the research outputs have an h-index of 81, meaning that 81 articles have been cited at least 81 times. 2 15 66 174 368 896 1626 3391 5628 8409 0 1000 2000 3000 4000 5000 6000 7000 8000 9000 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 ci ta tio ns year european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/10799 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 38 table iii. top 10 most cited research outputs research output references citations the relevance of circular economy practices to the sustainable development goals (schroeder, anggraeni, & weber, 2019) 893 recycling of weees: an economic assessment of present and future ewaste streams (cucchiella, d’adamo, koh, & rosa, 2015) 619 exploring industry 4.0 technologies to enable circular economy practices in a manufacturing context: a business model proposal (nascimento et al., 2019) 601 on the sustainability of lithium-ion battery industry – a review and perspective (yang et al., 2021) 525 pyrometallurgical options for recycling spent lithium-ion batteries: a comprehensive review (makuza, tian, guo, chattopadhyay, & yu, 2021) 477 recycling of lithium-ion batteries—current state of the art, circular economy, and next generation recycling (neumann et al., 2022) 354 a critical review of lithium-ion battery recycling processes from a circular economy perspective (velázquez-martínez, valio, santasalo-aarnio, reuter, & serna-guerrero, 2019) 336 lithium-ion batteries towards circular economy: a literature review of opportunities and issues of recycling treatments (mossali et al., 2020) 325 the future of waste management in smart and sustainable cities: a review and concept paper (esmaeilian et al., 2018) 308 circular economy strategies for electric vehicle batteries reduce reliance on raw materials (baars, domenech, bleischwitz, melin, & heidrich, 2021) 294 source: authors' elaboration 4.3 keyword analysis we created the network graph using vosviewer by analysing the co-occurrence of all the author keywords in the 949 research outputs. co-occurrence analysis calculates the relatedness of the keywords based on the number of research outputs in which they occur together. we used fractional counting, meaning the link’s weight between two keywords is fractionalised. we set the minimum number of occurrences of the keywords to five. out of the 2.435 keywords in the 949 research outputs, 107 met the threshold. we then removed keywords that appeared in singular and plural. this resulted in 72 keywords, shown in figure 4. the figure shows research clusters that represent five key themes that the research on the 949 research outputs is centred around. in the figure, the nodes represent the keywords, those with a larger node represent the prominence of the keyword and the joining lines represent relationships between the keywords. the red cluster is the largest of the groups, consisting of 25 terms highlighting the technical processes involved in material recovery and recycling, particularly within the domain of electronic waste. the cluster is centred around critical and precious metals, such as gold and copper, and processes like hydrometallurgy and pyrometallurgy, which are essential for metal recovery from mobile phones, printed circuit boards and other devices. concepts like urban mining, industrial ecology, and green european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/10799 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 39 chemistry also feature prominently, illustrating the cluster’s focus on sustainable extraction techniques. this cluster also touches upon the regulatory and policy frameworks surrounding the recycling of electronic waste, emphasising the need for legislation and economic analysis to support the circular economy. figure 4. network graph of the keywords from the author keywords (vosviewer) source: authors’ elaboration using vosviewer the green cluster comprises 15 terms and focuses primarily on sustainability within electronic products, particularly around electric vehicles and batteries. this cluster covers the lifecycle management of electronic devices, with a focus on eco-design, resource efficiency, and second-life applications, such as the repurposing of lithium-ion batteries and photovoltaics (song et al., 2023). the terms reflect an interest in forecasting environmental impacts, emphasising the role of business models that integrate end-of-life strategies, reuse, and repurposing. sustainability is the core theme, where resource efficiency and circular practices for electronic equipment are key drivers. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/10799 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 40 next is the blue cluster, with 14 terms, integrating broader sustainability themes, such as the circular economy, climate change, and sustainable consumption. the cluster brings attention to consumer behaviour and policy mechanisms like the extended producer responsibility, which regulates the roles of manufacturers in managing the end-of-life phase of their products. this cluster also explores the challenges posed by the informal sector and its role in waste management, particularly in municipal solid waste. furthermore, it touches on global objectives like the sustainable development goals, linking circular economy practices to broader environmental and societal outcomes. the terms emphasise the importance of remanufacturing, repair, and reverse logistics as part of sustainable consumption practices. the yellow cluster, consisting of 10 terms, focuses on the recycling and management of hazardous materials in electronic waste. it highlights substances like brominated flame retardants and heavy metals, alongside key methodologies such as life cycle assessment and materials flow analysis, which are used to track and evaluate material flows and environmental impacts. the cluster emphasises resource recovery through closed-loop supply chains, especially in plastics recycling and the sustainable management of e-waste. the terms indicate a concern with mitigating the harmful environmental effects of materials used in electronics while promoting resource recovery. finally, the purple cluster includes eight terms but focuses on the intersection of advanced technologies and e-waste management. it features terms related to emerging technologies such as artificial intelligence, blockchain, and the internet of things, which are being integrated into the management and disassembly of e-waste. the cluster emphasises industry 4.0 technologies and their potential to optimise supply chains and enhance sustainability within e-waste management processes. this blend of technology and environmental management positions the cluster as forward-looking, addressing future challenges in the context of the circular economy. figure 5 shows the density map generated by vosviewer, revealing the research hotspots. as shown, the highest density represented by the red and pale yellow are in the middle of the figure focusing on the circular economy and recycling. this hotspot also includes research focused on the circular economy, weee, recycling, critical raw materials and waste management. research areas that are growing are in yellow – represented by terms – epr, e-waste management, life cycle assessments (lca), remanufacturing, supply chain and lithium-ion batteries (ragossnig & schneider, 2019). the next prominent research hotspot is represented by chartreuse on the map. this hotspot covers research on hydrometallurgy, gold, precious metals, industry 4.0, blockchain, disassembly, repurposing, waste printed circuit boards, metal recovery, recovery, and the informal sector. the light blue indicates emerging research hotspots. these include – repair, forecasting, mobile phones, economic analysis, eco-design, closed-loop supply chain, indium, photovoltaics and plastics. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/10799 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 41 figure 5. a density map of the keywords from the authors’ keywords source: authors’ elaboration using vosviewer 4.4 topic analysis the topic analysis was done using provalis wordstat (version 2023.2). provalis wordstat is a text analysis software that facilitates fast extraction of themes and trends and quantitative content analysis, suitable for analysing large data (provalis, 2024). table iv shows the top 10 topics extracted from the authors’ keywords of the 949 research outputs analysed. the description of the table headers is given below: • topic is the topic generated by wordstat using an algorithm that assigns a label to the extracted topic. • keywords are the words meeting the factor loading cutoff criteria. these keywords are ordered by descending factor loading, along with associated phrases. • coherence refers to the weighted average of the correlations among words associated with the topic. • eigenvalue indicates the eigenvalue of each factor. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/10799 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 42 • freq represents the total frequency of all items listed in the keywords column. • cases show the number of research outputs containing at least one of the items listed in the keywords column. • % cases show the percentage of cases with at least one of the items listed in the keywords column (provalis, 2022). coherence scores and eigenvalues provide insights into the consistency and significance of the top ten topics generated by provalis wordstat. higher coherence scores indicate more cohesive themes within a particular topic, aiding in the interpretation of extracted topics. at the same time, eigenvalues quantify the importance of each topic, with higher values suggesting greater prevalence and influence. frequency and case counts offer additional context by revealing the prevalence and distribution of topics across the analysed data. higher frequencies and case counts denote more prominent themes, and case percentages offer insight into each theme’s overall coverage (provalis, 2022). the topic of electrical and electronic equipment, with a coherence score of 0.177 and an eigenvalue of 2.42, represents almost 20% of the cases studied. key terms associated with this topic include equipment, electrical, electronic, weee, responsibility, producer, and management. this reflects a growing interest in the epr within the context of business and product lifecycle management. the focus is primarily on how producers can be held accountable for the environmental impact of their products, especially in the context of waste management and sustainable production (campbell‐johnston et al., 2021; andersen, 2022). producer responsibility (extended) is a more specific subset of the epr concept, with a coherence score of 0.155 and an eigenvalue of 3.39. representing almost 4% of the cases, this topic focuses on producers and their responsibility to manage waste generated by their products. the research in this area highlights the significance of holding producers accountable for their products from manufacturing to disposal (andersen, 2022). this approach is critical in fostering sustainable practices and reducing environmental harm caused by electronic waste (campbell‐johnston et al., 2021). the lithium-ion batteries topic, with a coherence score of 0.127 and an eigenvalue of 2.89, accounts for almost 10% of the cases. this topic focuses on the development and impact of lithium-ion batteries in the context of electric vehicles and energy storage systems. keywords such as lithium, batteries, electric vehicles, and energy indicate a growing body of research dedicated to improving battery technology and addressing the challenges related to recycling lithium-ion batteries (sheth et al., 2023; silva et al., 2023). as the demand for electric vehicles increases, so does the need for sustainable recycling practices for these batteries. another topic covers raw materials (critical metals), with a coherence score of 0.107 and an eigenvalue of 2.59, represents just over 4.44% of the cases. this topic revolves around raw materials, critical metals, and the end-of-life stage of resources. it emphasises the importance of managing critical raw materials and reducing the reliance on primary sources through the circular economy framework (smol et al., 2020). the research in this area also focuses on finding alternatives to scarce materials and promoting recycling to support sustainable resource management (favot & massarutto, 2019). with a coherence score of 0.091 and an eigenvalue of 1.72, rare earth elements represent almost 4% of the cases. keywords such as rare earth, metals, and leaching indicate that the research focused on the challenges posed by the extraction, recycling, and management of rare earth elements. these materials are critical for many modern technologies but are challenging to recycle, posing significant environmental concerns (chatterjee, 2015). as such, research on rare earth elements plays a key role european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/10799 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 43 in the circular economy and e-waste management (pan et al., 2022). the topic of material flow analysis (mfa) has a coherence score of 0.087 and an eigenvalue of 1.90, also representing almost 4% of the cases. this topic focuses on tracking the movement and use of materials within industrial systems to optimise resource management and minimise waste. keywords include flow, material, and analysis, with research centred around understanding the lifecycle of materials and improving waste management through efficient recycling and recovery processes (tembhare et al., 2022). the next topic, reverse logistics has a coherence score of 0.084 and an eigenvalue of 1.58, representing almost 3% of the cases. this topic deals with the management of products after they have been used, particularly in the collection and recycling of electronic waste. keywords such as reverse logistics and collection highlight the importance of developing systems that facilitate the return and recovery of products to ensure their proper disposal or reuse (mishra et al., 2023). the end-of-life cycle topic has a coherence score of 0.073 and an eigenvalue of 2.68, appearing in almost 10% of the cases. keywords include lca and end of life, with a focus on evaluating the environmental impact of products at their final stage. this topic also explores economic evaluations of recycling and disposal practices, promoting the importance of responsible product design and sustainable waste management (kwok et al., 2024; ismail & hanafiah, 2021). table iv. top ten topics extracted with provalis wordstat topic keywords coherence (npmi) eigenvalue freq cases % cases electrical and electronic equipment equipment; electrical; electronic; waste; weee; responsibility; producer; extended; business; management; product 0.177 2.42 300 183 19.83% producer responsibility extended producer; responsibility; extended 0,155 3,39 39 35 3.79% ion batteries lithium ion; lithium; batteries; battery; electric; vehicles; energy 0,127 2,89 174 91 9,86% raw materials critical metals raw; materials; critical; end; resource; rare 0,107 2,59 61 41 4,44% rare earth earth; rare; metals; leaching; critical 0,091 1,72 44 34 3,68% material flow flow; material; analysis 0,087 1,90 54 35 3,79% reverse logistics reverse; logistics; collection 0,084 1,58 27 25 2,71% end of life cycle life; cycle; assessment; end 0,073 2,68 138 91 9,86% european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/10799 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 44 supply chain closed loop supply; chain; management; reverse 0,058 2,08 51 36 3,90% sustainable development circular circular; economy; development; sustainable 0,038 1,94 692 620 67,17% source: authors’ elaboration from provalis wordstat the supply chain (closed-loop) topic, with a coherence score of 0.058 and an eigenvalue of 2.08, represents almost 4% of the cases. this topic is closely linked to circular economy principles and focuses on closed-loop supply chain management, where products and materials are recovered and reused to reduce waste. keywords like supply chain, management, and reverse emphasise the need for more efficient logistics to achieve sustainability in global supply chains (mishra et al., 2023). the sustainable development (circular economy) topic is the most prominent, with a coherence score of 0.038, an eigenvalue of 1.94, and appearing in 67% of cases. the focus on circular economy and sustainable development highlights the widespread recognition of these concepts in addressing global environmental challenges, particularly in the context of e-waste and resource management (zisopoulos et al., 2023). the emphasis is on reducing waste, optimising resource use, and ensuring long-term environmental sustainability. figure 6. word-cloud graph of the most frequently used words source: authors’ elaboration from provalis wordstat european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/10799 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 45 figure 6 is a word cloud generated using provalis wordstat to visually represent the most commonly used keywords from the author keywords of the analysed research outputs. this graph highlights key themes by displaying frequently used words in larger font sizes, offering an intuitive understanding of the primary topics covered in the research. prominent keywords include “circular economy,” “recycling,” and “waste,” followed closely by “electronic,” “environmental,” and “management.” other frequently encountered terms like “materials,” “sustainable,” and “life” further emphasise the growing focus on sustainability, environmental responsibility, and eco-friendly practices in the context of circular economy and e-waste research. keywords such as “metals” and “batteries” also appear significantly, reflecting the increasing attention given to resource management and sustainable practices. 5. discussion the circular economy and e-waste research areas are key to sustainable development initiatives. this study aimed to determine the current state of research on the circular economy and e-waste, the central themes and key topics within this research, and how the circular economy addresses e-waste management challenges. to achieve this, we employed quantitative analysis techniques to address the research objectives with the aid of tools such as wordstat, vosviewer and provalis. the global e-waste production growth has been phenomenal, rising from 9.2 mt in 2014 and is expected to reach 74.7 mt by 2030 (kumar et al., 2022). precious materials in e-waste are 50 times richer than mineral ore, even from the most mineral-rich mines. recovering these minerals reduces the over-mining and exploitation of virgin and finite natural resources while creating formal jobs (maphosa & mashau, 2023). recycling and reusing e-waste components promote a circular economy where resources are extracted from e-waste and reused in manufacturing eee. in contrast, non-reusable components are recycled and disposed of in a formal way that does not endanger public health and the environment (xu et al., 2022). improper recycling releases toxic anthropogenic elements that threaten the environment and public health (ragossnig & schneider, 2019; xu et al., 2022). the circular economy concept was developed as a business and economic model to mitigate environmental and human health effects while ensuring resource recovery from anthropogenic materials (xu et al., 2022). businesses have to manage supply chain risks to eliminate product supply disruptions by adopting a circular economy. the circular economy improves productivity and efficiency and reduces environmental and health impacts. it also reduces wastage and pollution, recirculates raw materials, improves product design and extends the lifespan of eee through repairing, refurbishing and remanufacturing. 5.1 the current state of circular economy and e-waste management research the first objective of this research was to explore the circular economy and the current e-waste research landscape. a quantitative analysis of research outputs revealed key insights on the maturity and global relevance of this field. journal articles dominated the output, with almost two-thirds of the total research outputs. the dominance of journal articles suggests that the circular economy and e-waste research fields are well-established areas of inquiry, supported by high-quality research outputs. the global interest in the circular economy and e-waste research is reflected in the geographical distribution of publications, with contributions from 75 countries. italy is the most productive nation, followed by india, china, and the united kingdom. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/10799 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 46 other major contributors include the united states, germany, spain, and australia, indicating the widespread international focus on addressing e-waste and promoting sustainable circular economy practices (cucchiella et al., 2015). regarding the subject areas indexed, environmental science emerges as the most prevalent, in line with the united nations’ sustainable development goals focusing on people and the planet (united nations, 2015). the interdisciplinary nature of the circular economy and e-waste research is evident from the subject area distribution. environmental science is the most prominent, followed by engineering and energy. the inclusion of social sciences, business management, and materials science demonstrates the broad scope of the research, encompassing technological, social, economic, and environmental dimensions (nascimento et al., 2019). publication trends show a sharp increase in research output between 2014 and 2023. the exponential growth in publications, particularly after 2020, reflects the rising importance of the circular economy in achieving sustainable development goals and managing e-waste (schroeder et al., 2019). this increase mirrors the escalating urgency of addressing e-waste challenges and promoting circular economy principles in the global sustainability agenda. the scholarly impact of the circular economy and e-waste research is further illustrated by citation trends. from just two citations in 2014, the number of citations escalated to over 8,000 by 2023, demonstrating the field’s growing influence. the h-index of 81, reflects the field’s maturity and significance. highly cited papers, such as schroeder et al.’s (2019) work on linking circular economy practices to sustainable development goals, underscore the impact of aligning sustainability efforts with global development goals. 5.2 central themes and key topics in circular economy and e-waste research the second research objective aimed to identify the central themes that dominate the circular economy and e-waste research. the bibliometric and text mining analysis of research outputs identified five distinct research clusters, ten research topics, and several research hotspots that represent the central themes within the circular economy and e-waste research. these findings provide insight into the focal areas of the field, with material management and resource recovery, business practices and circular economy strategies, technology integration and sustainability, recycling challenges, and environmental health and sustainable practices emerging as core themes. the material management and resource recovery cluster show the efficient use of materials and resource recovery in e-waste, highlighting the importance of optimising recycling processes and minimising e-waste to support sustainable development. smol et al. (2020) stress the need for effective material management to achieve circular economy goals, especially in the recovery of critical materials like rare earth metals from e-waste. the second research theme business practices and circular economy strategies focuses on systemic approaches to integrating circular economy principles into business practices. sustainable business models, such as those involving epr, enable businesses to reduce environmental impact while promoting circular strategies (gaustad et al., 2018). the third theme technology integration and sustainability explore the intersection of advanced technologies—such as ai, blockchain, and industry 4.0—with sustainability efforts. these technologies are increasingly applied to improve the efficiency and traceability of e-waste management systems (pulparambil et al., 2024). they also help address challenges such as material european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/10799 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 47 tracking and disassembly, which are critical in recycling and resource recovery. the fourth cluster addresses the challenges associated with recycling e-waste, particularly in the recovery of valuable materials and the safe disposal of hazardous substances. this theme highlights advanced recycling methods like hydrometallurgy and pyrometallurgy for metal recovery from electronics such as mobile phones and printed circuit boards (tembhare et al., 2022). these methods are essential to ensure environmentally safe recycling processes. the final theme environmental health and sustainable practices focuses on sustainable practices aimed at preserving environmental health, particularly in managing e-waste components like batteries and photovoltaics. sheth et al. (2023) discuss the importance of resource efficiency and the need for sustainable disposal methods to reduce harmful environmental effects. key research hotspots emerged from the analysis, with the most prominent being studies related to the circular economy and recycling (ragossnig & schneider, 2019). other significant hotspots include hydrometallurgy, urban mining, sustainable consumption, and epr, which indicate growing research interest in improving recycling techniques and enhancing resource efficiency. emerging topics include mobile phones, closed-loop supply chains, and rare earth elements, suggesting a broadening of research focus towards specific e-waste challenges (mishra et al., 2023). among the ten key topics identified, eee emerges as a critical area due to the increasing prevalence of e-waste, particularly the producer responsibility and epr schemes (yu et al., 2022). another major focus is on lithium-ion batteries, which are integral to electric vehicles and renewable energy systems, highlighting concerns related to their lifecycle and sustainability (xu et al., 2022). the raw materials and critical metals topics underscore the need for effective resource management, particularly concerning rare earth elements and materials critical for technological advancement (andersen, 2022). reverse logistics has gained prominence as a vital aspect of managing e-waste, focusing on the collection and repurposing of discarded equipment to support circular economy practices. the closed-loop supply chain model emphasises the importance of integrating circular economy principles into supply chain management to enhance sustainability and reduce environmental impacts (mishra et al., 2023). the overarching theme of sustainable development highlights the growing recognition of the circular economy strategies as essential for addressing environmental challenges and fostering economic growth. topics such as the end-of-life cycle assessment provide a framework for evaluating the environmental impact of products throughout their lifecycle, reinforcing the necessity for sustainable practices in e-waste management. 5.3 research gaps and future directions in circular economy and e-waste management despite the rapid growth and maturity of the circular economy and e-waste research, several gaps remain, offering opportunities for future investigation. one of the key gaps identified in the literature is the need for more research on the recycling of specific e-waste components, such as lithium-ion batteries (neumann et al., 2022). while significant progress has been made in understanding general recycling processes, the recycling of complex and hazardous materials like batteries still faces technological, economic, and environmental challenges. research by makuza et al. (2021) and mossali et al. (2020) highlights the potential of pyrometallurgical and other advanced recycling techniques but calls for further innovation to make these processes more cost-effective and environmentally sustainable. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/10799 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 48 another research gap lies in the application of circular economy principles to emerging technologies. as digital technologies continue to evolve, there is a pressing need to develop circular economy strategies that can accommodate the rapid obsolescence and disposal of devices like smartphones, laptops, and other electronics. esmaeilian et al. (2018) point out that smart city initiatives and the iot will generate massive amounts of e-waste in the coming decades. future research should focus on integrating circular economy principles into the design and production of next-generation technologies, ensuring that they are easier to disassemble, recycle, and repurpose. in addition, more research is needed to explore the social dimensions of the circular economy and e-waste management. while much of the current literature focuses on technological and economic aspects, the role of consumers, communities, and workers in advancing circular economy practices is less studied. understanding consumer behaviour, incentivising recycling, and addressing the social impacts of e-waste on vulnerable populations are crucial areas for future research (schroeder et al., 2019). this also includes examining how circular economy initiatives can contribute to job creation and social equity, particularly in developing countries where e-waste recycling is often informal and hazardous. future research should focus on developing more effective policy frameworks that incentivise circular business models and promote sustainable production and consumption patterns. although existing policies such as epr are a step in the right direction, there is a need for more comprehensive and coordinated international policies that address global e-waste flows and ensure the ethical management of resources (baars et al., 2021). researchers also suggest that policy development should be guided by lcas and other tools that provide a more holistic understanding of environmental impact (velázquez-martínez et al., 2019). 6. conclusion this study presented a systematic literature review of the circular economy and e-waste management. the proliferation of ewaste poses significant challenges due to limited formal recycling practices, leading to environmental degradation and public health risks from toxic elements. however, adopting circular economy principles presents a promising solution by reducing waste generation, promoting resource recirculation, and extending product lifespans through repair and refurbishment. the circular economy not only addresses e-waste challenges but also fosters sustainable development by mitigating supply chain risks and creating formal job opportunities. this study has painted the current landscape of the circular economy and e-waste research, revealing key insights into the maturity and global relevance of this field. the predominance of journal articles indicates that these areas are well-established and supported by high-quality scholarly work. this global interest is reflected in contributions from 75 countries, with italy, india, china, and the united kingdom leading in research productivity. the interdisciplinary nature of the research encompasses various domains, including environmental science, engineering, and social sciences, reflecting the comprehensive scope of challenges faced in managing e-waste sustainably. this study identified five central research clusters—material management and resource recovery, business practices and circular economy strategies, technology integration and sustainability, recycling challenges, and environmental health and european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/10799 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 49 sustainable practices. emerging topics like lithium-ion batteries and closed-loop supply chains highlight critical challenges in e-waste management and the urgent need for sustainable practices. despite these advancements, significant research gaps remain, particularly regarding the recycling of specific e-waste components, such as lithium-ion batteries, and the integration of circular economy principles into emerging technologies. there is also a pressing need to explore the social dimensions of the circular economy and e-waste management, including consumer behaviour and community engagement. future research should aim to develop more effective policy frameworks that incentivise circular business models and address global e-waste flows through comprehensive and coordinated international policies. our findings lay a solid foundation for policymakers and stakeholders to leverage the circular economy framework in addressing e-waste challenges. embracing circular economy principles in emerging economies, alongside integrating informal sector practices for e-waste collection and sorting, presents a valuable opportunity for sustainable management. fostering collaboration between formal and informal sectors can further facilitate advanced recycling processes, contributing to both environmental health and economic resilience. this study emphasises the urgency of integrating circular economy practices to mitigate the environmental and health impacts of e-waste in the digital age. 7. conflict of interest we declare not to have any potential conflict of interest in the process from manuscript to publishing of this article. 8. references agamuthu, p., kasapo, p., & mohd nordin, n. a. (2015). e-waste flow among selected institutions of higher learning using material flow analysis model. resources, conservation and recycling, 105, 177–185. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.resconrec.2015.09.018 althaf, s., & babbitt, c. w. (2021). disruption risks to material supply chains in the electronics sector. resources, conservation and recycling, 167, 105248. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.resconrec.2020.105248 andersen, t. (2022). a comparative study of national variations of the european weee directive: manufacturer’s view. environmental science and pollution research, 29(14), 19920–19939. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11356-021-13206-z andersen, t., & halse, l. l. (2023). product lifecycle information flow in e-waste handling: a means to increase circularity? circular economy and sustainability, 3(4), 1941–1962. https://doi.org/10.1007/s43615-023-00258-1 anuardo, r. g., espuny, m., costa, a. c. f., espuny, a. l. g., kazançoğlu, y., kandsamy, j., & de oliveira, o. j. (2023). transforming e-waste into opportunities: driving organizational actions to achieve sustainable development goals. sustainability, 15(19), 14150. https://doi.org/10.3390/su151914150 arpin, m. l., leclerc, s. h., & lonca, g. (2024). the circular economy (ce) rebound as a paradox of knowledge: forecasting the future of the ce–iot nexus through the global e-waste crisis. sustainability, 16(15), 6364. bachér, j., yli-rantala, e., zu castell-rüdenhausen, m., & mroueh, u.-m. (2017). future trends in weee composition and treatment—a review report (research d2.3-2 and d4.2-6; pp. 1–67). clic innovation oy. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.resconrec.2015.09.018 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.resconrec.2020.105248 https://doi.org/10.1007/s11356-021-13206-z https://doi.org/10.1007/s43615-023-00258-1 https://doi.org/10.3390/su151914150 european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/10799 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 50 baars, j., domenech, t., bleischwitz, r., melin, h. e., & heidrich, o. (2021). circular economy strategies for electric vehicle batteries reduce reliance on raw materials. nature sustainability, 4(1), 71-79. campbell‐johnston, k., de munck, m., vermeulen, w. j. v., & backes, c. (2021). future perspectives on the role of extended producer responsibility within a circular economy: a delphi study using the case of the netherlands. business strategy and the environment, 30(8), 4054–4067. https://doi.org/10.1002/bse.2856 chancerel, p., marwede, m., nissen, n. f., & lang, k.-d. (2015). estimating the quantities of critical metals embedded in ict and consumer equipment. resources, conservation and recycling, 98, 9–18. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.resconrec.2015.03.003 chatterjee, k. k. (2015). sustainability and sustainable development of mineral resources. in k. k. chatterjee, macroeconomics of mineral and water resources (pp. 161–188). springer international publishing. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-15054-3_8 cucchiella, f., d’adamo, i., koh, s. l., & rosa, p. (2015). recycling of weees: an economic assessment of present and future e-waste streams. renewable and sustainable energy reviews, 51, 263-272. dias, p., bernardes, a. m., & huda, n. (2022). e‐waste management and practices in developed and developing countries. electronic waste: recycling and reprocessing for a sustainable future, 15-32. https://doi.org/10.1002/9783527816392.ch2 de oliveira neto, j. f., candido, l. a., de freitas dourado, a. b., santos, s. m., & florencio, l. (2023). waste of electrical and electronic equipment management from the perspective of a circular economy: a review. waste management & research, 41(4), 760-780. esmaeilian, b., wang, b., lewis, k., duarte, f., ratti, c., & behdad, s. (2018). the future of waste management in smart and sustainable cities: a review and concept paper. waste management, 81, 177-195. favot, m., & massarutto, a. (2019). rare-earth elements in the circular economy: the case of yttrium. journal of environmental management, 240, 504–510. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jenvman.2019.04.002 ferreira‐mello, r., andré, m., pinheiro, a., costa, e., & romero, c. (2019). text mining in education. wires data mining and knowledge discovery, 9(6), e1332. https://doi.org/10.1002/widm.1332 forti, v., balde, c. p., kuehr, r., & bel, g. (2020). the global e-waste monitor 2020: quantities, flows and the circular economy potential. united nations university/united nations institute for training and research, international telecommunication union, and international solid waste association. gaustad, g., krystofik, m., bustamante, m., & badami, k. (2018). circular economy strategies for mitigating critical material supply issues. resources, conservation and recycling, 135, 24–33. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.resconrec.2017.08.002 glombitza, f., & reichel, s. (2013). metal-containing residues from industry and in the environment: geobiotechnological urban mining. in a. schippers, f. glombitza, & w. sand (eds.), geobiotechnology i (vol. 141, pp. 49–107). springer berlin heidelberg. https://doi.org/10.1007/10_2013_254 https://doi.org/10.1002/bse.2856 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.resconrec.2015.03.003 https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-15054-3_8 https://doi.org/10.1002/9783527816392.ch2 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jenvman.2019.04.002 https://doi.org/10.1002/widm.1332 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.resconrec.2017.08.002 https://doi.org/10.1007/10_2013_254 european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/10799 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 51 hirsch, j. e. (2005). an index to quantify an individual’s scientific research output. proceedings of the national academy of sciences, 102(46), 16569–16572. https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.0507655102 hua, y., liu, x., zhou, s., huang, y., ling, h., & yang, s. (2021). toward sustainable reuse of retired lithium-ion batteries from electric vehicles. resources, conservation and recycling, 168, 105249. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.resconrec.2020.105249 ismail, h., & hanafiah, m. m. (2021). evaluation of e-waste management systems in malaysia using life cycle assessment and material flow analysis. journal of cleaner production, 308, 127358. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2021.127358 kazancoglu, y., ozkan-ozen, y. d., mangla, s. k., & ram, m. (2022). risk assessment for sustainability in e-waste recycling in circular economy. clean technologies and environmental policy, 24(4), 1145–1157. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10098-020-01901-3 kumar, s., agarwal, n., anand, s. k., & rajak, b. k. (2022). e-waste management in india: a strategy for the attainment of sdgs 2030. materials today: proceedings, 60, 811–814. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.matpr.2021.09.296 kwok, k. h., savaget, p., fukushige, s., & halog, a. (2024). the necessity for end-of-life photovoltaic technology waste management policy: a systematic review. journal of cleaner production, 461, 142497. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2024.142497 lazar, d. (2021). an opportunity in the circular economy: e-waste. energy industry review. https://energyindustryreview.com/environment/an-opportunity-in-the-circular-economy-e-waste/ luo, j., wang, r., suny, d., wang, y., & li, g. (2018). comparison among four prominent text processing tools. 2018 15th international symposium on pervasive systems, algorithms and networks (i-span), 325–330. https://doi.org/10.1109/i-span.2018.00072 maphosa, v. (2021). students’ awareness and attitudinal dispositions to e-waste management practices at a zimbabwean university. journal of information policy, 11, 562–581. https://doi.org/10.5325/jinfopoli.11.2021.0562 maphosa, v. (2022). rethinking sustainability: a bibliometric and visualisation of e-waste management in africa. journal of higher education theory and practice, 22(1). https://doi.org/10.33423/jhetp.v22i1.4969 maphosa, v., & maphosa, m. (2020). e-waste management in sub-saharan africa: a systematic literature review. cogent business & management, 7(1), 1814503. https://doi.org/10.1080/23311975.2020.1814503 maphosa, v., & mashau, p. (2023). the conundrum: transforming african e-waste landfills to urban mines. in h. m. saleh, a. i. hassan, & r. f. aglan (eds.), advances and challenges in hazardous waste management. intechopen. https://doi.org/10.5772/intechopen.1002419 mihai, f. c., gnoni, m. g., meidiana, c., schneider, p., ezeah, c., & elia, v. (2022). a global outlook on the implementation of the basel convention and the transboundary movement of e-waste. in paradigm shift in e-waste management (pp. 49-75). crc press. https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.0507655102 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.resconrec.2020.105249 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2021.127358 https://doi.org/10.1007/s10098-020-01901-3 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.matpr.2021.09.296 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2024.142497 https://energyindustryreview.com/environment/an-opportunity-in-the-circular-economy-e-waste/ https://doi.org/10.1109/i-span.2018.00072 https://doi.org/10.5325/jinfopoli.11.2021.0562 https://doi.org/10.33423/jhetp.v22i1.4969 https://doi.org/10.1080/23311975.2020.1814503 https://doi.org/10.5772/intechopen.1002419 european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/10799 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 52 moyen massa, g., & archodoulaki, v.m. (2023). electrical and electronic waste management problems in africa: deficits and solution approach. environments, 10(3), 1–22. https://doi.org/10.3390/environments10030044 makuza, b., tian, q., guo, x., chattopadhyay, k., & yu, d. (2021). pyrometallurgical options for recycling spent lithiumion batteries: a comprehensive review. journal of power sources, 491, 229622. meloni, m., souchet, f., & sturges, d. (2018). circular consumer electronics: an initial exploration. ellen macarthur foundation. https://www.ellenmacarthurfoundation.org/circular-consumer-electronics-an-initial-exploration mishra, a., dutta, p., jayasankar, s., jain, p., & mathiyazhagan, k. (2023). a review of reverse logistics and closed-loop supply chains in the perspective of circular economy. benchmarking: an international journal, 30(3), 975–1020. https://doi.org/10.1108/bij-11-2021-0669 moher, d., shamseer, l., clarke, m., ghersi, d., liberati, a., petticrew, m., shekelle, p., & stewart, l. a. (2015). preferred reporting items for systematic review and meta-analysis protocols (prisma-p) 2015 statement. systematic reviews, 4(1), 1. https://doi.org/10.1186/2046-4053-4-1 mwaijande, f. (2024). a bibliometric analysis of circular economy. european journal of social impact and circular economy, 5(1), 1-19. mossali, e., picone, n., gentilini, l., rodrìguez, o., pérez, j. m., & colledani, m. (2020). lithium-ion batteries towards circular economy: a literature review of opportunities and issues of recycling treatments. journal of environmental management, 264, 110500. nascimento, d. l. m., alencastro, v., quelhas, o. l. g., caiado, r. g. g., garza-reyes, j. a., rocha-lona, l., & tortorella, g. (2019). exploring industry 4.0 technologies to enable circular economy practices in a manufacturing context: a business model proposal. journal of manufacturing technology management, 30(3), 607-627. neumann, j., petranikova, m., meeus, m., gamarra, j. d., younesi, r., winter, m., & nowak, s. (2022). recycling of lithium‐ion batteries—current state of the art, circular economy, and next-generation recycling. advanced energy materials, 12(17), 2102917. ohemeng, f. l. k., & ofosu-adarkwa, k. (2014). overcoming the digital divide in developing countries: an examination of ghana’s strategies to promote universal access to information communication technologies (icts). journal of developing societies, 30(3), 297–322. https://doi.org/10.1177/0169796x14536970 osibanjo, o., & nnorom, i. c. (2007). the challenge of electronic waste (e-waste) management in developing countries. waste management & research: the journal for a sustainable circular economy, 25(6), 489–501. https://doi.org/10.1177/0734242x07082028 pan, x., wong, c. w. y., & li, c. (2022). circular economy practices in the waste electrical and electronic equipment (weee) industry: a systematic review and future research agendas. journal of cleaner production, 365, 132671. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2022.132671 https://doi.org/10.3390/environments10030044 https://www.ellenmacarthurfoundation.org/circular-consumer-electronics-an-initial-exploration https://doi.org/10.1108/bij-11-2021-0669 https://doi.org/10.1186/2046-4053-4-1 https://doi.org/10.1177/0169796x14536970 https://doi.org/10.1177/0734242x07082028 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2022.132671 european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/10799 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 53 parvez, s. m., jahan, f., brune, m.-n., gorman, j. f., rahman, m. j., carpenter, d., islam, z., rahman, m., aich, n., knibbs, l. d., & sly, p. d. (2021). health consequences of exposure to e-waste: an updated systematic review. the lancet planetary health, 5(12), e905–e920. https://doi.org/10.1016/s2542-5196(21)00263-1 patil, r. a., & ramakrishna, s. (2020). a comprehensive analysis of e-waste legislation worldwide. environmental science and pollution research, 27(13), 14412–14431. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11356-020-07992-1 provalis. (2022). wordstat user guide. provalis. https://provalisresearch.com/documents/wordstat9.pdf provalis. (2024). internet of things—number of connected devices worldwide 2015-2025. content analysis and text mining software. https://provalisresearch.com/products/content-analysis-software/ pulparambil, s., bani-ismail, b., migdady, h., & al-ghafri, s. (2024). electronic waste management: fourth industrial revolution technology advancements and opportunities. international journal of computing and digital systems, 16(1), 1–11. pwc. (2021). circular economy: trust in a circular future. pwc. https://www.pwc.ch/en/insights/sustainability/circulareconomy.html ragossnig, a. m., & schneider, d. r. (2019). circular economy, recycling and end-of-waste. waste management & research: the journal for a sustainable circular economy, 37(2), 109–111. https://doi.org/10.1177/0734242x19826776 schroeder, p., anggraeni, k., & weber, u. (2019). the relevance of circular economy practices to the sustainable development goals. journal of industrial ecology, 23(1), 77-95. secinaro, s., brescia, v., calandra, d., & biancone, p. (2020). employing bibliometric analysis to identify suitable business models for electric cars. journal of cleaner production, 264, 121503. sheth, r. p., ranawat, n. s., chakraborty, a., mishra, r. p., & khandelwal, m. (2023). the lithium-ion battery recycling process from a circular economy perspective—a review and future directions. energies, 16(7), 3228. https://doi.org/10.3390/en16073228 silva, j., távora, g., portuguese institute of industrial property, mendonça, s., spru, university of sussex, & university of lisbon. (2023). reconfiguring the energy storage landscape. foresight and sti governance, 17(1), 34–50. https://doi.org/10.17323/2500-2597.2023.1.34.50 smol, m., marcinek, p., duda, j., & szołdrowska, d. (2020). importance of sustainable mineral resource management in implementing the circular economy (ce) model and the european green deal strategy. resources, 9(5), 55. https://doi.org/10.3390/resources9050055 song, d., yu, j., wang, m., tan, q., liu, k., & li, j. (2023). advancing recycling of spent lithium-ion batteries: from green chemistry to circular economy. energy storage materials, 61, 102870. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ensm.2023.102870 statista. (2016, november 27). internet of things (iot) connected devices installed base worldwide from 2015 to 2025. https://www.statista.com/statistics/471264/iot-number-of-connected-devices-worldwide/ https://doi.org/10.1016/s2542-5196(21)00263-1 https://doi.org/10.1007/s11356-020-07992-1 https://provalisresearch.com/documents/wordstat9.pdf https://provalisresearch.com/products/content-analysis-software/ https://www.pwc.ch/en/insights/sustainability/circular-economy.html https://www.pwc.ch/en/insights/sustainability/circular-economy.html https://doi.org/10.1177/0734242x19826776 https://doi.org/10.3390/en16073228 https://doi.org/10.17323/2500-2597.2023.1.34.50 https://doi.org/10.3390/resources9050055 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ensm.2023.102870 https://www.statista.com/statistics/471264/iot-number-of-connected-devices-worldwide/ european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/10799 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 54 tembhare, s. p., bhanvase, b. a., barai, d. p., & dhoble, s. j. (2022). e-waste recycling practices: a review on environmental concerns, remediation and technological developments with a focus on printed circuit boards. environment, development and sustainability, 24(7), 8965–9047. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10668-021-01819-w thakur, p., & kumar, s. (2022). evaluation of e-waste status, management strategies, and legislations. international journal of environmental science and technology, 19(7), 6957–6966. https://doi.org/10.1007/s13762-021-03383-2 thomas, j., mcnaught, j., & ananiadou, s. (2011). applications of text mining within systematic reviews. research synthesis methods, 2(1), 1–14. https://doi.org/10.1002/jrsm.27 unido. (2019). circular economy. united nations industrial development organization. united nations. (2015). transforming our world: the 2030 agenda for sustainable development. department of economic and social affairs. united nations. (2019). world population prospects 2019: highlights. united nations. velázquez-martínez, o., valio, j., santasalo-aarnio, a., reuter, m., & serna-guerrero, r. (2019). a critical review of lithium-ion battery recycling processes from a circular economy perspective. batteries, 5(4), 68. vishwakarma, a., & hait, s. (2024). e‐waste valorization and resource recovery. in a. priya (ed.), management of electronic waste (1st ed., pp. 202–233). wiley. https://doi.org/10.1002/9781119894360.ch10 wef. (2019). a new circular vision for electronics time for a global reboot. world economic forum. xu, h., jia, y., sun, z., su, j., liu, q. s., zhou, q., & jiang, g. (2022). environmental pollution, a hidden culprit for health issues. eco-environment & health, 1(1), 31–45. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.eehl.2022.04.003 yang, y., okonkwo, e. g., huang, g., xu, s., sun, w., & he, y. (2021). on the sustainability of lithium-ion battery industry–a review and perspective. energy storage materials, 36, 186-212. yu, h. f., hasanuzzaman, md., rahim, n. a., amin, n., & nor adzman, n. (2022). global challenges and prospects of photovoltaic materials disposal and recycling: a comprehensive review. sustainability, 14(14), 8567. https://doi.org/10.3390/su14148567 zeng, x., & li, j. (2018). urban mining and its resources adjustment: characteristics, sustainability, and extraction. scientia sinica terrae, 48(3), 288–298. zhang, z., malik, m. z., khan, a., ali, n., malik, s., & bilal, m. (2022). environmental impacts of hazardous waste, and management strategies to reconcile circular economy and eco-sustainability. science of the total environment, 807, 150856. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.scitotenv.2021.150856 zhao, y. (2020). china in transition towards a circular economy: from policy to practice. journal of property, planning and environmental law, 12(3), 187–202. https://doi.org/10.1108/jppel-03-2020-0014 zisopoulos, f. k., steuer, b., abussafy, r., toboso-chavero, s., liu, z., tong, x., & schraven, d. (2023). informal recyclers as stakeholders in a circular economy. journal of cleaner production, 415, 137894. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2023.137894 https://doi.org/10.1007/s10668-021-01819-w https://doi.org/10.1007/s13762-021-03383-2 https://doi.org/10.1002/jrsm.27 https://doi.org/10.1002/9781119894360.ch10 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.eehl.2022.04.003 https://doi.org/10.3390/su14148567 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.scitotenv.2021.150856 https://doi.org/10.1108/jppel-03-2020-0014 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2023.137894 european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/6508 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 1 economic impact of home manufacturing of consumer products with low-cost 3d printing of free and open-source designs joshua pearce1, jun-yu qian2 1 western university, canada 2 michigan tech, united kingdom (uk) contacts joshua.pearce@uwo.ca junyuq@mtu.edu received: 01/02/2022 accepted for publication: 28/04/2022 published: 29/07/2022 abstract centralized manufacturing of proprietary products has dominated the economy since the industrial revolution. recently however, several studies have indicated potential of producing consumers (prosumers) digitally reproducing open source designs with 3-d printers to save money by offsetting the purchase of commercial products. with over 2 million desktop 3-d printers being purchased per year, the impact on conventional industry could be substantial, but is still unknown. the objective of this study is to begin to determine the economic impact created by proliferation of open-source digital designs for 3-d printed products. in order to do this, the top 100 most popular designs posted on the youmagine 3-d printing repository are analyzed. the download substitution value is calculated based on amazon prices of comparable products to estimate the potential savings those designs could generate for 3-d printer users. case studies are provided on three types of open source designs: i) open source equivalent products, ii) non-commercial products of high value to the consumer, and iii) products for 3-d printing users. the savings available for prosumers was found to be highly dependent on the 3-d printing material. the means of percentage savings using commercial 3-d printing filament, commercial plastic pellets, recycled commercial pellets, and self-recycled consumer plastics are 82%, 94%, 97% and 98%, respectively. the potential for laterally-scaled wealth generation in a circular economy with widespread use of recyclebots, 3-d printing and sharing open designs is substantial. in the u.s., considering the use of household plastic waste over $359 billion/year could be used to offset filament purchases or over $7 trillion/year for products. if adoption of household-level diy digital manufacturing of open source designs becomes widespread open business models are needed. keywords: additive manufacturing; distributed manufacturing; diy; recycling; decentralized manufacturing; peer production european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/6508 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 2 1. introduction by the end of the 19th century, the production of large quantities of standardized products on assembly lines became widespread and dominant in economics (hounshell, 1984). due to a long list of benefits (miltenburg, 2005; mukherjeer, 2007) this trend continued toward large-scale manufacturing in low-labour-cost countries, especially for inexpensive plastic products (kravis & lipsey, 1982; ruamsook et al, 2007). more than four decades ago toffler (1980) predicted that the current centralized institutions and systems would be transformed into a more decentralized model. yet, economies of scale favored the centralized phenomenon and toffler’s predictions seemed implausible. recently, however, the technical development of additive manufacturing (am) or 3-d printing technology, which was first used for rapid prototyping (rayna & striukova, 2016) has evolved to enable a viable path to a decentralized manufacturing-based economy (richardson et al., 2013; gwamuri, et al., 2014; ben-ner & siemsen, 2017) particularly if coupled with decentralizd recycling (hart et al., 2018; büth, et al., 2020). considering the technology barrier of operating 3-d printers (ben & siemsen, 2017; steenhuis & pretorius, 2016) and the amount of people that are scientifically illiterate (duncan, 2007), the actual impact of am on the existing industry is still to be determined. how widespread is this practice? how large of an economic impact is already being created by proliferation of open source digital designs for 3-d printed objects? to begin to answer these questions this paper first reviews the literature and then analyzes the top 100 most popular designs posted on youmagine.com. download substitution value (pearce, 2015) is used to estimate the potential savings those designs could generate for the public users. commercial equivalent products are identified on major online shopping websites like amazon.com. case studies are provided on open source equivalent products, non-commercial products of high value to the consumer, and those meant only for 3-d printing users. the monetary savings using commercial filament, pellets, recycled pellets and recycled waste are quantified, and the potential implementation of 3-d printing and recycling units for individual household is theoretically scaled and the potential for laterally-scaled wealth generation by sharing is discussed. conclusions about the impacts to the existing market of adoption of household-level diy digital manufacturing of open source designs as well as the potential for mass-customization of products are drawn. 2. literature review 3-d printers are proliferating. globally, 2.1 million 3-d printers were shipped in 2020, and the market is expected to reach 15.3 million 3-d printers by 2028 (grand view research, 2021). am, can be viewed as a revolutionary technology in which decentralization evolves to the point that everyone could fabricate products for their own use in their own homes (petersen & pearce, 2017) and in the most radical formulation from their own waste referred to as distributed recycling and additive manufacturing (dram) (sanchez et al., 2015; 2017; 2020; byard et al., 2019; reich et al., 2019; dertinger et al., 2020). traditional manufacturing (tm) methods like injection molding is capital intensive and takes a considerable amount of time to deliver a new mold to the manufacturer, while am is to fabricate a completely new product within a few hours albeit at a much smaller rate per machine. the economic scale, which significantly affects the tm industries, is eliminated in the am process as no mass-production is required to minimize the cost (ben-ner & siemsen, 2017; rayna & striukova, 2016). am produces little to no waste and can provide geometric freedom for the fabrication of complex structures (canessa et al., 2013). environmentally, am requires less input with its additive nature while also accepting recycled materials as inputs (despeisse, 2017), which makes dram environmentally superior to tm (kreiger & pearce, 2013a,b; kreiger et al. 2013; 2014). in dram’s most mature form it directly contributes to the circular economy by tightening the material flow cycle (zhong & pearce, 2018). following the expiration of some major 3-d printing patents in the 2000s, and the open source release of the self-replicating rapid prototyper (reprap) (sells et al., 2010; jones, et al., 2001; boywer, 2014), a 3-d printer that can fabricate parts for itself, a proliferation of low-cost consumer-level 3-d printers (ranges from $1,000 to $2,000) became more affordable to the public and small businesses (rayna et al., 2015). along with the adoption of home-use 3-d printers, online open source communities started to appear like youmagine, thingiverse, and myminifactory, which serve as online design repositories for people to upload and download 3-d models for free, so that they can modify and print those existing designs. using download substitution value (pearce, 2015), 26 random example digital products found on yeggi.com (a free design file search engine) resulted in a value more than $4 million, and thus the return on investment (roi) of owning the 3-d printer even if only used modestly is more than 100% within three years of ownership (petersen & pearce, 2017). there are dozens of such online design repositories (reprap, 2021a). which not only serve the role of saving digital files, they are also platforms for the hobbyists and professionals alike to communicate and exchange ideas. these repositories are compared to web 2.0, as users of the websites are collaborating on improving existing designs or even creating new products (yoo et al., 2016). yoo et al. (2016) state in this democratized manufacturing era, prosumer (the combination of producer and consumer) and the activity of prosumption is tightly related to the ongoing trend in web 2.0. prosumption is the activities of the producing consumer. prosumption, though criticized as an exploitation of consumers in the past (ritzer & jurgenson, 2010), european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/6508 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 3 is a net gain for the society as the co-creation activities happening in the 3-d printing related forums and repositories are constantly generating new ideas for existing designs or innovations and are available to everyone with no exploitation (rayna et al., 2015). prosumers can leverage 3-d printing technology to apply do it yourself (diy) methods to digitally reproducible designs. the diy movement, first recognized during the 1950s due to shortage of human labor as the consequence of post-war (atkinson, 2006), is thus now being highlighted once again as part of the maker movement (dougherty, 2012; hatch 2014; martin, 2015) under the development of 3-d printing technologies (richardson et al., 2013). one the one hand, this personalized fabrication enabled by 3-d printing technologies is allowing people to produce very specific objects they cannot obtain from the market (mota, 2011). the possibility to customize objects fulfills emotional needs of prosumers – e.g. to make their products different from the trend and showcase their personalities (campbell et al., 2013; kudus, 2017; kapetaniou et al., 2018). users also often mash existing designs together to 3-d print, thereby creating other new products (kudus, 2017; mota, 2011). in addition, diy household-scale manufacturing can save prosumers money directly, which indicates 3-d printers with open source designs available online pose a threat to existing traditional manufacturers (peterson & pearce, 2017; pearce, 2021). this study will evaluate the extent this threat has already materialized and if it is contributing to a circular economy. 3. methods youmagine, an online website hosts over 15,000 open source computer-aided design (cad) files, is a community for 3-d printing hobbyists (youmagine, 2021a). the data set used in this study consisted of 100 designs and the download statistics over their publication lifetime. the top 100 most popular designs in april, 2021 along with their download statistics and standard triangle language (stl) files, which describe the outer surface of the component to be used for 3-d printing, were obtained to do the analysis. note this top 100 most popular designs changes based on download rates and this analysis should thus be considered a snap shot in time of part of the 3-d printing community’s interest. each design was loaded in to cura lulzbot 3.6.20, a free software that slices the stl file into gcode to print the designs out physically (cura lulzbot, 2015). slicing software allows users to change the infill density, where 0% infill density means the object is printed will be hollow and 100% means it is completely solid. for this analysis, unless specified by the designer, 10% infill density is used for objects that are not considered a tool, such as toys and decorations; whereas 100% infill density is applied for the objects that are categorized as hardware tools to achieve the maximum strength, such as gear bearings and clamps. all other settings use the defaults in cura for polylactic acid (pla), which is the most popular and accessible 3-d printing polymer (subramaniam, et al., 2019). cura estimated masses were used and compared to those provided by youmagine and the designer when available. the mass is used to calculate the price of filament require to print out each design assuming commercial filament with a cost of $23/kg (amazon, 2021a). if the design requires ‘vitamins’ – i.e. any other components aside from filament (screws, stepper motors, electronics, etc.), the prices of those items are found. the cost to fabricate the product, cf, is the total material costs, which include the filament and vitamin costs. next, the commercial equivalent of those designs are searched for on amazon.com, the largest online retailer. for the few products not available on amazon other online retailers were used. designs with an equivalent were analyzed for costs (all measured in 2021 us$ and priced at the same time) and those that were not are discussed separately along with all designs that would only be useful to 3-d printer users. the difference in the total cost to 3-d print an object (with vitamins if necessary) and the cost to purchase the commercial equivalent online is found as the savings generated for consumers. this downloaded substitution value (vd) at a specific time (t) of an open hardware design can thus be found by (pearce, 2015): 𝑉!(𝑡) = &𝐶" − 𝐶#) ∗ 𝑃 ∗ 𝑁!(𝑡) [$] (1) where cp is the cost to purchase a commercial product, cf is the cost needed for the filament to print out the object including additional non-printable parts, nd is the number of downloads recorded on the youmagine website and p is the percentage of the downloads that result in a fabrication. for this study p is assumed to be 1. although it is possible that each download does not result in fabrication, previous work with reprap-class 3-d printer users indicates this is unlikely. additionally, many of the downloads could result in multiple fabrications, so an estimate of p=1 will be considered conservative as the focus of this study is on a macroeconomic scale. the difference between cp and cf is the savings a prosumer realises for digitally reproducing the product for themselves. vd is the total savings generated from the difference in cost between commercial product and the open source design. these average and sum of the savings found for the designs analyzed is calculated for the designs where an equivalent product is found. a percent saving is determined for each design from: 𝑆 = (𝐶" − 𝐶#)/𝐶" [%] (2) european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/6508 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 4 these percentages are graphed in a histogram for which a mean and standard deviation are determined. finally, to ascertain what type of designs are currently most manufactured by the 3-d printing community, each open hardware design is categorized into one of five categories: 1) hardware and gadgets, 2) toys, 3) 3-d printer parts and enhancements, 4) art, and 5) apparel. to gauge the impact of distributed recycled and manufacturing (dertinger, et al., 2020; sanchez et al., 2020) to overcome barriers (peeters et al., 2019) in the future, a sensitivity was run on the use of purchased recycled plastic pellets that cost ~$2.20/kg (mcdunough, 2021) and recycled post-consumer waste plastic. pellets were assumed to be used directly in a fused pellet 3-d printer (alexandre, et al., 2020; woern et al., 2018a; whyman, et al., 2018) at a cost of $5.50/kg or turned into filament with a recyclebot (waste plastic extruder (baechler, et al., 2013; woern et al. 2018b; zhong & pearce, 2018)). the recyclebot can produce filament at 0.24 kwh/kg and an electricity cost of $0.139/kwh was assumed as the global average electricity price (globalpetrolprices; 2021). this resulted in a cost of $5.53/kg. finally, using the users own waste consumer plastic directly in the recyclebot was analyzed, which only had the electricity cost and resulted in $0.139/kg. finally, these results were extrapolated to the entire u.s, population. the potential value of filament that could be fabricated on a diy basis is calculated from the waste plastic disposed of per person per year, which is estimated to be about 130 kg/year/person in year 2016 (statista, 2021a). the detailed inputs and outputs from the analysis along with all urls are available on the open source framework (osf, 2021). 4. results following the methods outlined above, the vast majority of 3-d printed products downloaded had a commercial equivalent (89%) as shown in figure 1. figure (1): main category for the 100 designs. these open hardware products also generally saved users money to fabricate the products themselves. an example is the toy/cosplay blaster model for han solo in the star wars movies; the 3-d printable version requires 387 grams of filament with 10% infill density, which costs $8.66 (rockets2, 2021), while a commercial version on amazon costs $140 (amazon, 2021b). the comparison of the open source version and the commercial version is shown in figure 2. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/6508 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 5 figure 2: comparison of open source version (left) and the commercial version (right) of the blaster toy (rockets2, 2021; amazon, 2021b). with a saving of $131 on each potential fabrication and 28,608 download times (youmagine, 2021b), the total saving for the 3-d printing community is estimated to be about $3.8 million for this one design alone. as shown in figure 1, not all products are designed to save money or substitute an existing commercial product. these products did not have a commercial equivalent, but could still be popular among makers. for example, a trick “perpetual machine” (figure 3), which was developed and shared by greg zumwalt, has been downloaded 2,770 times (zumwalt, 2021). this design required vitamin components for its functionality. the basic idea is to include a hidden stepper motor to power a conceptual perpetual machine originally designed by leonardo da vinci (zumwalt, 2021). an initial push is needed to start the cycle counter-clockwise, the ball bearings will tend to keep the motion going, but they will eventually come to a stop if no additional energy is provided because of the laws of physics. the battery-powered stepper motor is hidden inside the body of the machine to provide the additional energy needed to keep the motion going. zumwalt recommended a 20% infill density, which requires 71 grams of filament ($1.54). other components needed that are not printable detailed in the appendix, increased the total material cost to $27. there were no comparable designs available commercially. all other such designs (8% of the total) were removed from the analysis. figure 3: original perpetual motion sketch (da vinci, c1600) on left and the automated 3-d printed sculpture called the perpetual motion da vinci style ii (right) (zumwalt, 2021). as shown in figure 1, the remainder of the designs evaluated were 3-d printer parts and enhancements. these designs would not be useful in general to consumers that did not operate a reprap-class or any other fused filament fabrication (fff) or fused deposition model (fdm)-based 3-d printer. see for example the design of shootout test geometries (make, 2021). this set of designs enables users to test the performance of their 3-d printers. this class of designs was also excluded from the analysis unless a commercial equivalent was identified. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/6508 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 6 interestingly, in the open source spirit of development, the publisher make magazine of this design encourages the other users to upload their printing results with the specification used to print those (i.e. infill density, layer height), which allows users to peer check the performance and the recommended setting for different 3-d printers. make magazine publishes a 3-d printer design guide annually, where commercial 3-d printers of the prosumer class are evaluated and ranked. other designs that solely serve the 3-d printer user community are products like belt tensioners, which straighten the belt of 3-d printer if it is too long or too loose (gijs, 2021); 3-d printer feet, which simply elevates a 3-d printer off the desk (savagerodent, 2021) and so on. there are some 3-d printer parts and enhancements that have commercial equivalent products, they will be discussed in the following section. figure 4: subcategory for the money savers. the designs that would save users money by personally fabricating them were further analyzed for class and the results are shown in figure 4. as can be seen in figure 4, more than 50% of the designs are hardware tools and gadgets. these range from low-cost products to high-cost products. for an example of the former, consider the humble banana slicer, an open source design uploaded on to youmagine (hüger lp, 2021), which has been downloaded 857 times. the comparison of the opensource design and the commercial equivalent is shown in figure 5. as it is a hardware tool, the infill density is set to 100%, which requires 104 grams of filament. the cost to print this banana slicer is about $1, while the commercial equivalent costs $6 (amazon, 2021c). although the banana slicer saves prosumers more than 83% to fabricate them it only had a total saving for the 3-d printing community of $4,316 to date because of the relativity low value of the product. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/6508 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 7 figure 5: comparison of open source version (left) and the commercial version (right) of the banana slicer (hüger lp, 2021; amazon, 2021c). on the other end of the product cost spectrum consider the 3-d printable glidecam uploaded by thomas sanladerer (2021), which has been downloaded 15,355 times. 40% infill density is recommended that results in approximately 500 grams of filament needed because the support required to print some of the components. costs of additional materials like bolts, screws, aluminum tubes, etc. were added, which results in a total material cost of around $40 (aliexpress, 2021; amazon, 2021d; 2021e). the cost of a commercial equivalent product is $224 (amazon, 2021f). each prosumer that fabricated this saved over 80% from purchasing the commercial product and thus this open hardware design alone generated a savings in the prosuming community of more than $2.9 million. the comparison of the open source version and the commercial equivalent is shown in figure 6. figure 6: comparison of open source version (left, camera is not included) and the commercial version (right) of the camera stabilizer (sanladerer, 2021; amazon, 2021f). around 37% of the items fall in the category of toys, the rest of the items (less than 1%) are in the categories of 3-d printer parts and enhancement, art, and apparel. the consumer savings available for 3-d printing toys is well documented by peteresen et al. (2017), which found when a commercially available toy was available for comparison from the most popular open source designs on the myminifactory, printing with commercial filament saved prosumers more than 75% of the cost and the recyclebot filament saved more than 90 %. in total—and just using the data from 100 toys (less than one percent of myminifactory’s repository)—people offset $60 million dollars per year in toy purchases (petersen et al., 2017). the results here are consistent with that study. for example, an r2d2 replica toy has a duplicate design uploaded on youmagine with download statistics of 21,187 times (somerwil, 2021). as a toy, 10% infill density is used, so 1,303 grams of filament is needed for the print. this results in $28 for the total cost of the material. additionally, users have to glue the parts together and color european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/6508 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 8 it if wanted or print in colored filament. the cost of commercial equivalent is identified on amazon to be $50 (amazon, 2021g). the total savings generated for the maker community from this item is $0.46 million. savings were also found with art products. for example, a life size open source art design of neferneferuaten nefertiti (c. 1370 – c. 1330 bc) was a queen of the 18th dynasty of ancient egypt, has been downloaded 4,177 times (horne, 2021). in the economic analysis of the design, 10% infill density is assumed and resulted in the large print requiring 1,816 grams of filament, which cost $39. the cost of an equivalent commercial product is $150 (amazon, 2021h) shown in figure 7. this item generates an estimate savings for the prosumer community of $0.46 million. it should be noted that colored 3-d prints either demand a multi-color 3-d printer or coloring (e.g. painting) in post processing. the former involves no additional operational cost, but an increased capital cost of the printer and the latter was not factored into the economic analysis here. figure 7: comparison of open source version (left) and the commercial version (right) of the nefertiti life size model (horne, 2021; amazon, 2021h). as shown in figure 8, out of 81 identified money savers from the top 100 designs, 36 (more than 40%) of them result in a percentage saving of more than 90%. more than 90% of the mover savers have a percentage saving of more than 40%. users of 3-d printers or with a recyclebot could further save from producing filament from commercial or recycled pellets and house waste plastic. the recyclebot is able to produce filament at 0.24kwh/kg (woern, 2018b), taking the electricity price into consideration, the production of filament from commercial pellets costs $5.53/kg. if the users make filament from their own waste consumer plastics, the cost for a kg spool of filament is only $0.139/kg, which is just the cost of the electricity. more than 70% of the items that have a percentage savings were higher than 80. the mean savings was found to be 82% for filament, and the standard deviation was 19%. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/6508 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 9 figure 8: percentage savings for the designs that saved prosumers money for self fabrication for commercial filament. the mean and the standard deviation for the percent money saved for the projects that saved users money for self fabrication using each of the material types: 1) commercial filament, 2) commercial pellets, 3) recycled commercial pellets and 4) self-consumer plastic is shown in figure 9. figure 9: the mean of percentage savings for four types of am materials used. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/6508 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 10 overall, for the 81% of open source designs that provided economic savings the total savings for the 3-d printing community is more than $35 million. for context, this is close to the profit of gamestop ($34 million) in 2018 (fortune, 2021). if the community had used full diy recycling their savings would have been close to $40 million. the means of percentage savings when using commercial filament, commercial pellets, recycled pellets, and selfconsumer plastics are 81.60%, 94.10%, 96.68% and 98.28% respectively as shown in figure 9. their standard deviations decrease from 19.55% for commercial filament to 5.64% for the cheapest self-consumer plastic. 5. discussion the economic benefits of individuals adopting diy manufacturing with a 3-d printer are proven here to not only be positive, but also to be significant on a macroeconomic scale already. the advantages of an open source approach to distributed manufacturing with 3-d printing are not limited to financial benefits. the emergence of web 2.0, provides a path to understanding this impact as it could be seen as a milestone for prosumption (ritzer & jurgenson, 2010). prosumption has occurred in stages, as initially occurring in fast food restaurants, where consumers take their food with themselves from the counter and clean their own tables, using atms or pumping gasoline to eliminate labor costs. while these action were criticized by ritzer & juegenson (2010), the prosumption activities in web 2.0 based environment are seen as beneficial to the consumers too. 3-d printing arguably takes the prosumption to another level as it eliminates the need for external payments for products entirely. it integrates the user interaction in web 2.0 communities and the ability of a 3-d printer to generate something physical as a final product. customization is made possible as anyone is welcome to modify the content posted on those open source 3d communities. in fact, this is perhaps the open source model’s greatest strength. in general, 3-d printing files are licensed under an open source license that not only enables prosumers to fabricate the products for themselves, but it also encourages further mixing, changing and enhancing the design with the requirement that the change is reshared. during the pandemic companies in cooperation with individual makers have been organized into local manufacturing and distribution hubs to reduce transportation time and accelerate the supply of required equipment at local hospitals until the conventional production lines managed to catch up with demand (stavropoulos, et al., 2020). recycling is already a large part of obtaining circularity in this context (costanza, 2020). thus, for example, a 3-d printable protective face shield in the list is quite popular due to the ongoing pandemic with a download statistic of 74,546 times (cederberg, 2021). aside from its popularity, several community members expand from this very own design with their ideas, on youmagine, this item has 26 recorded derivatives; details are shown in appendix a (youmagine, 2021b). the derivatives are also not limited to face shields (appendix a figures a1, a2, a3). some configured the original design so several identical face shields could be printed at one go; one derivative was a breaker for breaking the face shields apart as some support filament is connecting the printed face shields, others just changed the design to match their community’s preferences. it is also possible users would just modify the cad file upon printing without uploading it as a derivative, so the actual phenomena of this peer creation or peer production may be considerably underestimated what is occurring based on data from the repositories. instead of simply letting users choose from existing options such as different colours and sizes, which are possible with conventional retail/online retail centralized manufacturing models, open source approaches to diy fabrication literally enable users to put their faces on anything (all3dp, 2019). users can actually make major modifications based on the design they obtain to fulfil their specific preferences. some of the designs are purposefully coded to be parametric to make this particularly easy for prosumers. for example, the customizable u-hook uploaded by serge payen (2021) is a parametric design developed in openscad (openscad, 2021) that allows users to simply change parameters to achieve the desired shape they want specifically for their u-hook. the user also added the link to his website for more detailed instructions about how to load the parametric cad file and customize it in an open source cad software that is available to everyone (payen, 2016). figure 10 shows some of the options users could change with their matching u-hook designs. users non-familiar with openscad can have easier access with an open source customizer (nilsiam & pearce, 2017). european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/6508 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 11 figure 10: different u-hook designs with matching parameters (payen, 2016). in a heterogeneous market, it is found that some consumers are unsatisfied by the existing commercial products (de jong & de bruijn, 2013), while companies may not be willing to create a new production line just to satisfy a (small) portion of the costumers due to the economics of scale. the use of 3-d printing is particularly advantageous in those cases, users could modify based on an existing design or even create something entirely new. if companies see the value and need to do so, they could even absorb those new ideas from the open source platforms and commercialize it so they could upgrade their existing products and expand their target customers. with that being said, the idea of prosumption certainly do not only benefits the consumers, it could also help the companies to find what is missing in their existing designs and learn from the users’ suggestions. though historically served for industry uses, 3-d printers are now extremely affordable. some personal 3-d printers’ prices fall under $2,000 (rayna et al., 2015), while one can also purchase a reprap kit under $500, which requires the user to build it by themselves (reprap, 2021a). the price of 3-d printers as well as the filament will likely decrease in the future with more companies entering the market, which will make owning a 3-d printer more feasible. financially, the roi for owning a low-end 3-d printer has already reached more than 500% in three years and close to 1000% in five years (peterson & pearce, 2017) based on use. more than 0.2 million of non-metal 3-d printers were shipped in year 2015, and it is projected that the 3-d printer market will reach more than 2 million units in 2022 (statista, 2021b) and more than 8 million units by 2027 (statista, 2021c). aside from the growing number of am unit sales, among the 100 service providers surveyed by wohlers associates, approximately half of them are already printing parts including metal (wohlers associates, 2017). printable material selection will likely expand along with the increase of sales of am units. the cost of running a 3-d printer could be further reduced choosing alternatives for the printing material, particularly if using dram with a recyclebot or direct waste 3-d printer. the results here showed that moving to recycled commercial pellets or recycling diy waste resulted in savings of 96% and 98%, respectively. this is consistent with a study done by peterson et al. (2017), using pellet extruded filament or recycled waste filament that showed users could save more than 90% of the cost of commercial products if an open source 3-d printable version of the product exists. although the quality of the recycled thermoplastic does decrease every time it is recycled (sanchez et al., 2017), they could still be sufficient if the result object does not need a high-level strength and a fraction of virgin materials or additives can enable full strength. assuming all of the 128.45 million households (statista, 2021d) could own a recyclebot to produce filament with their own average of 130 kg/year of household plastic waste, they could collectively save over $359 billion per year if all household plastic waste are to be recycled into 3-d printing filament. assuming the yearly estimated household plastic waste (around 130 kg) is to be recycled through recyclebot, 3-d printer owner could potentially save around $2,795 per year instead of purchasing commercial filament (which would cover the cost of a low-end 3-d printer and a recyclebot already) compared to purchasing commercial filament if all waste is to be recycled to filament by recyclebot. this savings is substantial but the real savings comes from converting the feed stock filament into substitute products. for the 81 money saver designs in this case study, the amount of filament to print all of them is obtained to be about 18kg, which costs $389 using amazon basic filament (amazon, 2021a), while it only costs $2.50 if all filament is produced by a recyclebot with household plastic waste. each kilogram of plastic filament and on average $12 of vitamins would create an average of $188 value if converted into open source products. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/6508 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 12 the amount of waste generated would enable consumers to print these 81 items 20 times and save more than $60,000 per year if they indeed wanted that number of plastic products using the average savings. although it is unlikely that the average household needs that many products. all together the 128.45 million households have the potential to generate $7.7 trillion/year from their own waste plastic. clearly, the potential for wealth generation by sharing open source designs is substantial. unlike wealth generation from centralized manufacturing, in this case mass manufacturing is laterally scaled among many producers making their own products. this is achieved by peer sharing of designs and production of products for oneself, family or community. although it is clear distributed manufacturing by prosumers is already well underway and will expand in the foreseeable future as more end-products can be produced by 3-d printers (laplume et al., 2016; kapetaniou et al., 2018), the majority of the products still involve many components that are not printable (sandström, 2016). while it is possible that the adoption of 3-d printing would be a threat to existing firms if many commercial products can be manufactured at home (kapetaniou et al., 2018), many argue the availability of 3-d printing technologies are in fact an attractive avenue for established firms and entrepreneurs (sandström, 2016; beltagui et al., 2021; rayna & striukova, 2021). in addition, adoption of 3-d printing, which decreases the lead time for manufactures to deliver the product, is a complementary for the firms as part of the technologies are still not adaptable for independent users (bogers et al., 2016; sandström, 2016). it is also likely firms simply take advantage of the ability to rapid prototype, but still mass produce the end products in tm (kapetaniou et al., 2018). am also encourages startups and entrepreneurs as the required capital inputs are less compared to tm (rayna & striukova, 2021). as am allows production after demand, it is possible for entrepreneurs to have a positive cash flow before delivering the products in contrast to stocking products ahead to minimize the cost per item (rayna & striukova, 2021). taking a step back, adopting am might have significant benefit existing firms. aiming the heterogeneous markets or even the conventional ones, using am faces little risk in over stocking the product as the production could be made after the order or the money is received (berman, 2012), so theoretically there will be no unsold items in the inventory. concerns towards dislocations of the economy is mentioned by ben-ner and siemsen (2017), however, since am only requires certain material input and its production is based on specific order instead of the economic scale (volume production) to lower its cost, it requires way less investment to operate and maintain compared to a tm-based institution. the idea of local 3-d printing shop is brought up by many (ben-ner & siemsen, 2017; rayna & striukova, 2016; wittbrodt et al., 2013), people without 3-d printer but have the intention to obtain 3-d printed objects could utilized those facilities to do so. this mode could be seen as the internet café, in contract to a tm-based company, local 3-d printing shops or firms adopting am are considered to be more flexible to the changes in the market as they are able to produce various types of products with the same material required (ben-ner & siemsen, 2017). a similar idea, the makerspace, was combined with 3-d printing technologies to serve people with disabilities (bosse & pelka, 2020). medical devices to disabled person are commonly quite costly due to the fact they cannot be mass produced with the customization needed for different patients. gallup et al., have shown that distributed 3-d printing adaptive aids for arthritis patients had financial savings of more than 94% compared to commercially-available products and that printing a tiny subset of the adaptive aids needed by a single patient would recover the full capital and operational costs of a low-cost open source 3-d printer (gallup et al., 2018). bosse and pelka’s (2020) study involves the peer-production of people with disabilities as well as people who are interested in technology, they identified the connection presented in the community that allows knowledge sharing and exchange. on the other hand, there is a historical pressure against an open source business methodology. makerbot, a one-time leading open source desktop 3-d printer provider, shifted to a proprietary structure and provides perhaps a cautionary tale for other firms considering that route. at the time of makerbot’s purchase in 2013 for $403 million by a conventional am company stratasys, it was the largest and most successful prosumer 3-d printing company. they also housed the largest repository of free and open source 3-d printable designs: thingiverse. the abandonment of the open source ethos jeopardized the support from the community, particularly the open source reprap community that helped build its success (pearce, 2017). makerbot still kept control of thingiverse to complement the proprietary sector (west & kuk, 2016). it is seen as an advantage for an established firm to participate or even create a platform to connect to their customers and other interested individuals in an open-source way to capture the value created by the interaction between firms and consumers (bogers et al., 2016; west & kuk, 2016). previous supporters and customers, however, were outraged by the sudden change in licensing of their files on thingiverse, as the company attempted to patent designs which were freely uploaded, deleting previously supported documentation, and only releasing new printers and software as proprietary technology (pearce, 2017). makerbot’s initial proprietary designs were an engineering failure (benchoff, 2016) as their “smart extruder” was so poor that it resulted in a class action suit against stratasys (united states district court of minnesota, 2015). as previous highly-skilled employees that started under the open source era fled, the resulting compounding failures have largely destroyed the company as their 3-d printer sales have dropped. in addition, previous to its past pride in making 3-d printers in the u.s., makerbot announced it was laying off its entire manufacturing workforce in the u.s. and outsourcing it all to china (benchcroff, 2016). nardi (2020) points out that “after being bought out by stratasys and abandoning their open source roots, the company is all but completely absent in the market they helped to create.” european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/6508 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 13 on the other hand, by harnessing appropriate open source business models (pearce, 2017) combined with those that support the circular economy (piontek, et al. 2021), the existence of the 3-d printing communities might in fact benefit the traditional industries (de jong & de bruijn, 2013). de jong & de bruijn pointed out that existing companies can identify the profitable products from the user generated ones, further improve and commercialize them. without known demand, it is hard for companies to prepare products for the heterogeneous segment of the market (rayna & striukova, 2016), while the web 2.0 phenomenon in the 3-d printing communities helps to identify the needs of the customers that do not get fulfilled by existing commercial products. commercial companies can also identify and hire those individuals in the 3-d printing communities with desired skills (de jong & de bruijn, 2013). learning how to work with communities that have already started some form of distributed production to recover in the post-covid era is important (ur rehman et al., 2020). 6. limitations there are several limitations to this study. first, additional post production costs were not considered. some designs need users to glue the parts and color it to match the commercial product, which are not included as the cost of production. additionally, no failed printing is considered, while previous studies found that printing errors on a self-built reprap by an inexperienced user could be as high as 20% (wittbrodt et al., 2013). although, even this level of print failures would not change the fundamental conclusions of this study that diy production is now economic, it should be noted that failures are now much less likely with self-bed leveling and even modest experience. in addition, there has been considerable academic efforts to use open source machine vision and artificial intelligence to reduce printing errors (hu, 2016; nuchitprasitchai, et al., 2017a,b; wei et al., 2019; petsiuk & pearce, 2020). as a widespread first step thousands of 3-d printer owners utilize the opensource software called spaghetti detective (jiang, 2021), which attempts to detect and cease printing during catastrophic 3-d printing failures. finally, it should be pointed out that 3-d printing communities are likely to provide recommended settings with the published designs, which also minimize print failures. the second major limitation of this study is that choosing the commercial equivalent of an open source design, can never be fully objective as it is unlikely the open source version will perfectly match with a commercially available product. here the best possible attempt was made to reach an apples-to-apples comparison for each product, but is should be clear that the price range even for apples-to-apples commercial equivalents to one another vary widely. in addition, prices from online retailers are also subject to change. in the case studies shown here only one commercial equivalent is identified, while different providers will likely have a different price for even the same product and this price will vary over time (e.g. sales). the exact values, however, are less important than the trend and averages for predicting savings for prosumers. 7. future work youmagine is only one of the many existing 3-d printing design repositories (reprap, 2021b) freely available to everyone, with more than 15,000 open source designs saved on this website (youmagine, 2021a), the 100 items analyzed here are not able to capture the actual impact this community is contributing to the 3-d printer users as well as the industries that are seeking what could they improve on the products they are already providing. future work could consider running a larger data set across many of the various similar 3-d printable design websites to avoid any bias observed in a single repository. potential algorithm could be developed and match the open source design to a commercially available product for the users to compare while browsing so the users would know how much they could be saving by 3-d print the object instead theoretically. future research could analyze the influence of the 3-d printing technology (individuals or firms adopting am units) to existing business in a short and a long run. whether the shift of tm to am will be feasible for the firms and the current structure of the market. and if disruptive, would it reverse and turn to be beneficial to the society as a whole at some point? the extent of prosumerism could also be analyzed, how much it is progressing the field of 3-d printing and whether or not this is still an exploitation of the customers or net gain for both consumers and producers. repositories could ask for users’ inputs upon uploading a design. whether they came up with the idea to replace an existing commercial product or it is a pure creation. and if it was to replace an existing commercial product, is it due to financial reasons, or there is something they are not satisfied with of the commercial design. these questions could go down deeper and deeper if the user is willing to contribute their time for a better data collection for the website. which could help further research to better study the behaviors of those freelance designers. repositories could also ask the categories of the users’ design, whether the idea comes from an existing design available on any online repositories, etc. finally, additional work is needed to probe the social impact of a shift towards global sharing of open source designs and local distributed manufacturing. for example, this methodology may provide more resilience to future societal shocks like the covid pandemic (stavropoulos, et al., 2020). european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/6508 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 14 8. conclusions it could be posited the significant economic benefits of individuals adopting am units. while further study is needed to analyze the potentially disruptive impact that individuals adopting am units could have on the existing industries, industries themselves could also take advantage of using am units to manufacture. less waste will be produced, less cost is needed on storage as volume production does not necessarily minimize the cost per item. decentralized manufacturing could also lead to local sourcing which provides more job opportunities locally. with the expected growth in sales of am units and the expanding variety of printable materials, 3-d printers will likely to be more popular not only to firms that see the potential in them but also with individuals who are willing to learn and customize existing products. furthermore, the web 2.0-orientated open source 3-d printable designs create an ideal environment for users to communicate with each other and refine their designs. the phenomena of prosumption is pushed to another level, and firms would not only receive a textual suggestions from the users, but also the designs of physical prototypes that the users upload on the online repositories. all these could be seen as a positive gain for society. acknowledgements this research was partially supported by the john m. thompson endowment. appendix a. the evolution of open source face shield designs on youmagine. figure a1: derivatives of cederberg’s face shield design on youmagine part 1. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/6508 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 15 figure a2: derivatives of cederberg’s face shield design on youmagine part 2. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/6508 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 16 european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/6508 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 17 figure a3: derivatives of cederberg’s face shield design on youmagine part 3. appendix b abbreviations am: additive manufacturing cad: computer aided design cf : the cost needed for the filament to print out the object including additional non-printable parts cp : the cost to purchase commercial product diy: do it yourself dram: distributed recycling and additive manufacturing fdm: fused deposition model fff: fused filament fabrication pla: poly lactic acid roi: return on investment s: percent savings stl: standard triangle language tm: traditional manufacturing vd: downloaded substitution value references alexandre, a., cruz sanchez, f. a., boudaoud, h., camargo, m., & pearce, j. m. (2020). mechanical properties of direct waste printing of polylactic acid with universal pellets extruder: comparison to fused filament fabrication on opensource desktop three-dimensional printers. 3d printing and additive manufacturing, 7(5), 237-247. aliexpress. (2021). aliexpress online shopping for popular electronics, fashion, home & garden, toys & sports, automobiles and more products. aliexpress. //www.aliexpress.com. accessed 12 april 2021 all3dp. (2019, april 16). 3d face scanner/model: how to 3d print your face. all3dp. https://all3dp.com/2/3d-facemodel-how-to-make-a-3d-model-of-your-face/. accessed 14 june 2021 amazon. (2021a). amazon.com: amazon basics pla 3d printer filament, 1.75mm, white, 1 kg spool: industrial & scientific. https://www.amazon.com/amazonbasics-printer-filament-1-75mm-white/dp/b07s2zxm97/. accessed 28 may 2021 amazon. (2021b). amazon.com: cosplay prop gray resin for men: clothing. https://www.amazon.com/cosplay-prop-grayresin-men/dp/b087nk5r87/?th=1&psc=1. accessed 1 june 2021 amazon. (2021c). amazon.com: hutzler 571 banana slicer: kitchen & dining. https://www.amazon.com/hutzler-3571-571banana-slicer/dp/b0047e0eii. accessed 1 june 2021 amazon. (2021d). uxcell 4pcs 6063 seamless aluminum round straight tubing tube 1 feet length 0.234 inches id 0.429 inches od: amazon.com: industrial & scientific. https://www.amazon.com/uxcell-seamless-aluminum-straighttubing/dp/b07w4tyv56/. accessed 21 april 2021 amazon. (2021e). amazon.com : hapleby premium bike handlebar grips, single lock-on bike grips, professional mountain bicycle handlebar locking grips with anti-slip, 2pcs screw and 2pcs allen wrench for free : sports & outdoors. https://www.amazon.com/hapleby-handlebar-professional-mountain-anti-slip/dp/b08t8tgs1w/. accessed 21 april 2021 amazon. (2021f). amazon.com : flycam redking quick balancing video camera stabilizer with dovetail quick release (flcm-rk) | professional cnc aluminum camera stabilizer for dslr bmcc sony nikon dv camcorders up to 7kg/15.4lb european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/6508 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 18 + bag : camera & photo. https://www.amazon.com/flycam-stabilizer-flcm-rk-professionalcamcorders/dp/b01h1ie74i. accessed 3 june 2021 amazon. (2021). amazon.com: sw interactive play r2-d2 286 b7493: toys & games. https://www.amazon.com/star-warssmart-r2d2-case/dp/b01l93gcto. accessed 3 june 2021 amazon. (2021e). amazon.com: pacific giftware ptc 18 inch egyptian queen nefertiti head and bust resin statue figurine: home & kitchen. https://www.amazon.com/egyptian-queen-nefertiti-statuefigurine/dp/b009d0shv2/ref=sr_1_5?dchild=1&keywords=nefertiti+head+statue&qid=1620666201&sr=8-5. accessed 1 june 2021 atkinson, p. (2006). do it yourself: democracy and design. journal of design history, 19(1), 1–10. https://doi.org/10.1093/jdh/epk001 baechler, c., devuono, m., & pearce, j. m. (2013). distributed recycling of waste polymer into reprap feedstock. rapid prototyping journal. beltagui, a., sesis, a., & stylos, n. (2021). a bricolage perspective on democratising innovation: the case of 3d printing in makerspaces. technological forecasting and social change, 163, 120453. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.techfore.2020.120453 benchoff, b (2015). makerbot has now cut 36% of staff in last 6 months. hackaday, october 9 2015 http://hackaday.com/2015/10/09/makerbot-has-now-cut-36-of-staff-in-last-6-months/ benchoff, b (2016). the makerbot obituary. hackaday, april 28 2016 http://hackaday.com/2016/04/28/the-makerbotobituary/ ben-ner, a., & siemsen, e. (2017). decentralization and localization of production: the organizational and economic consequences of additive manufacturing (3d printing). california management review, 59(2), 5–23. https://doi.org/10.1177/0008125617695284 berman, b. (2012). 3-d printing: the new industrial revolution. business horizons, 55(2), 155–162. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.bushor.2011.11.003 bogers, m., hadar, r., & bilberg, a. (2016). additive manufacturing for consumer-centric business models: implications for supply chains in consumer goods manufacturing. technological forecasting and social change, 102, 225–239. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.techfore.2015.07.024 bosse, i. k., & pelka, b. (2020). peer production by persons with disabilities – opening 3d-printing aids to everybody in an inclusive makerspace. journal of enabling technologies, 14(1), 41–53. https://doi.org/10.1108/jet-07-2019-0037 bowyer, a. (2014). 3d printing and humanity's first imperfect replicator. 3d printing and additive manufacturing, 1(1), 4-5. büth, l., juraschek, m., thiede, s., & herrmann, c. (2020). choosing products for decentralized manufacturing: utilizing recycled 3d printing filament in india and germany. in enhancing future skills and entrepreneurship (pp. 31-39). springer, cham. byard, d. j., woern, a. l., oakley, r. b., fiedler, m. j., snabes, s. l., & pearce, j. m. (2019). green fab lab applications of large-area waste polymer-based additive manufacturing. additive manufacturing, 27, 515-525. campbell, r.i., jee, h. and kim, y.s., 2013. adding product value through additive manufacturing. in ds 75-4: proceedings of the 19th international conference on engineering design (iced13), design for harmonies, vol. 4: product, service and systems design, seoul, korea, 19-22.08. 2013. canessa, e., fonda, c., zennaro, m. and deadline, n., 2013. low-‐cost 3d printing for science, education and sustainable development. low-cost 3d printing, 11(1). european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/6508 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 19 cederberg, e. (2021). protective visor by 3dverkstan. youmagine. https://www.youmagine.com/designs/protective-visorby-3dverkstan costanza, f. (2020). the potential of circular businesses in the post-covid era: a system dynamics view. european journal of social impact and circular economy, 1(3), pp.1-27. cura lulzbot. (2015, november 4). cura lulzbot edition. lulzbot. https://www.lulzbot.com/cura. accessed 28 may 2021 da vinci, l. (c1600). codex forster ii (folio 91 verso), victoria and albert museum, london no. msl/1876/forster/141/ii. de jong, j.p. and de bruijn, e., 2013. innovation lessons from 3-d printing. mit sloan management review, 54(2), p.43. dertinger, s. c., gallup, n., tanikella, n. g., grasso, m., vahid, s., foot, p. j., & pearce, j. m. (2020). technical pathways for distributed recycling of polymer composites for distributed manufacturing: windshield wiper blades. resources, conservation and recycling, 157, 104810. despeisse, m., baumers, m., brown, p., charnley, f., ford, s. j., garmulewicz, a., knowles, s., minshall, t. h. w., mortara, l., reed-tsochas, f. p., & rowley, j. (2017). unlocking value for a circular economy through 3d printing: a research agenda. technological forecasting and social change, 115, 75–84. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.techfore.2016.09.021 dougherty, d. (2012). the maker movement. innovations: technology, governance, globalization, 7(3), 11-14. duncan, d. (2007). 216 million americans are scientifically illiterate (part i). mit technology review. https://www.technologyreview.com/2007/02/21/37898/216-million-americans-are-scientifically-illiterate-part-i/ fortune. (2021). gamestop | 2021 fortune 500 | fortune. https://fortune.com/company/gamestop/fortune500/. accessed 16 june 2021 gallup, n., bow, j.k. and pearce, j.m., 2018. economic potential for distributed manufacturing of adaptive aids for arthritis patients in the us. geriatrics, 3(4), p.89. https://doi.org/10.3390/geriatrics3040089 gijs. (2021). belt tensioner. youmagine. https://www.youmagine.com/designs/belt-tensioner. accessed 1 june 2021 globalpetrolprices. (2021). electricity prices around the world. globalpetrolprices.com. https://www.globalpetrolprices.com/electricity_prices/. accessed 11 june 2021 grand view research (2021) 3d printing market size, share | industry report, 2021-2028 [www document], n.d. url https://www.grandviewresearch.com/industry-analysis/3d-printing-industry-analysis. accessed 19 june 2021 gwamuri, j., wittbrodt, b. t., anzalone, n. c., & pearce, j. m. (2014). reversing the trend of large scale and centralization in manufacturing: the case of distributed manufacturing of customizable 3-d-printable self-adjustable glasses. challenges in sustainability, 2(1), 30-40. hart, k. r., frketic, j. b., & brown, j. r. (2018). recycling meal-ready-to-eat (mre) pouches into polymer filament for material extrusion additive manufacturing. additive manufacturing, 21, 536-543. hatch, m. (2014). the maker movement manifesto: rules for innovation in the new world of crafters, hackers, and tinkerers. new york: mcgraw-hill education. horne, r. (2021). nefertiti in sections up for 3d printing full sized. youmagine. https://www.youmagine.com/designs/nefertiti-in-sections-up-for-3d-printing-full-sized. accessed 1 june 2021 hounshell da. (1984) from the american system to mass production, 1800‒1932: the development of manufacturing technology in the united states. baltimore, md, usa: johns hopkins university press. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/6508 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 20 hu, f., li, l. i., liu, y., & yan, d. (2016). enhancement of agility in small-lot production environment using 3d printer, industrial robot and machine vision. international journal of simulation: systems, science & technology, 17(43), 32-1. hüger lp. (2021). banana slicer. youmagine. https://www.youmagine.com/designs/banana-slicer. accessed 1 june 2021 jiang, k. (2021) 3d printer remote monitoring & control · the spaghetti detective https://www.thespaghettidetective.com/ jones, r., haufe, p., sells, e., iravani, p., olliver, v., palmer, c., & bowyer, a. (2011). reprap–the replicating rapid prototyper. robotica, 29(1), 177-191. kapetaniou, c., rieple, a., pilkington, a., frandsen, t., & pisano, p. (2018). building the layers of a new manufacturing taxonomy: how 3d printing is creating a new landscape of production eco-systems and competitive dynamics. technological forecasting and social change, 128, 22–35. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.techfore.2017.10.011 kravis, i. b. & lipsey, r. e. (1982) the location of overseas production and production for export by u.s. multi-national firms. journal of international economics. 12(3):201‒223. kreiger, m., & pearce, j. m. (2013a). environmental life cycle analysis of distributed three-dimensional printing and conventional manufacturing of polymer products. acs sustainable chemistry & engineering, 1(12), 1511-1519. kreiger, m., & pearce, j. m. (2013b). environmental impacts of distributed manufacturing from 3-d printing of polymer components and products. mrs online proceedings library (opl), 1492, 85-90. kreiger, m. g. m. a., anzalone, g. c., mulder, m. l., glover, a., & pearce, j. m. (2013). distributed recycling of postconsumer plastic waste in rural areas. mrs online proceedings library (opl), 1492, 91-96. kreiger, m. a., mulder, m. l., glover, a. g., & pearce, j. m. (2014). life cycle analysis of distributed recycling of postconsumer high density polyethylene for 3-d printing filament. journal of cleaner production, 70, 90-96. kudus, s.i.a., 2017. the value of personalised consumer product design facilitated through additive manufacturing technology (doctoral dissertation, loughborough university). laplume, a. o., petersen, b., & pearce, j. m. (2016). global value chains from a 3d printing perspective. journal of international business studies, 47(5), 595-609. make. (2021). make: 2015 3d printer shoot out test geometries. youmagine. https://www.youmagine.com/designs/make2015-3d-printer-shoot-out-test-geometries. accessed 1 june 2021 martin, l. (2015). the promise of the maker movement for education. journal of pre-college engineering education research (j-peer), 5(1), 4. mcdunnough (2021). personal communication. recycled plastic services | paper & cardboard recycling (mcdunnough.com) miltenburg, j. (2005) manufacturing strategy: how to formulate and implement a winning plan. new york, ny, usa: productivity press. mota, c. (2011). the rise of personal fabrication. proceedings of the 8th acm conference on creativity and cognition, 279– 288. https://doi.org/10.1145/2069618.2069665 mukherjee, s. (2007) modern economic theory. newdelhi, india: new age international publishers. nardi, t. (2020). makerbot targets schools with rebranded printers. hackaday. https://hackaday.com/2020/02/19/makerbot-targets-schools-with-rebranded-printers/#more-398684 european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/6508 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 21 nilsiam, y., & pearce, j. m. (2017). free and open source 3-d model customizer for websites to democratize design with openscad. designs, 1(1), 5. nuchitprasitchai, s., roggemann, m. c., & pearce, j. m. (2017a). three hundred and sixty degree real-time monitoring of 3d printing using computer analysis of two camera views. journal of manufacturing and materials processing, 1(1), 2. nuchitprasitchai, s., roggemann, m., & pearce, j. m. (2017b). factors effecting real-time optical monitoring of fused filament 3d printing. progress in additive manufacturing, 2(3), 133-149. openscad. (2021). openscad. http://openscad.org. accessed 6 june 2021 open source framework (2021). https://osf.io/xv8jz/. accessed 12 july 2021 payen, s. (2016). parametric u-hook – serge payen. http://sergepayen.fr/en/parametric-u-hook/ payen, s. (2021). customizable u-hook. youmagine. https://www.youmagine.com/designs/customizable-u-hook pearce, j.m. (2015). quantifying the value of open source hardware development. modern economy, 6, pp.1-11. pearce, j.m., 2017. emerging business models for open source hardware. journal of open hardware, 1(1), p.2. pearce, j. m. (2021). create, share, and save money using open-source projects. mcgraw-hill education. peeters, b., kiratli, n., & semeijn, j. (2019). a barrier analysis for distributed recycling of 3d printing waste: taking the maker movement perspective. journal of cleaner production, 241, 118313. petersen, e. e., & pearce, j. (2017). emergence of home manufacturing in the developed world: return on investment for open-source 3-d printers. technologies, 5(1), 7. https://doi.org/10.3390/technologies5010007 petersen, e. e., kidd, r. w., & pearce, j. m. (2017). impact of diy home manufacturing with 3d printing on the toy and game market. technologies, 5(3), 45. https://doi.org/10.3390/technologies5030045 petsiuk, a. l., & pearce, j. m. (2020). open source computer vision-based layer-wise 3d printing analysis. additive manufacturing, 36, 101473. piontek, f.m., herrmann, c. and saraev, a. (2021). steps from zero carbon supply chains and demand of circular economy to circular business cases. european journal of social impact and circular economy, 2(2), pp.1-9. rayna, t., & striukova, l. (2016). from rapid prototyping to home fabrication: how 3d printing is changing business model innovation. technological forecasting and social change, 102, 214–224. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.techfore.2015.07.023 rayna, t., & striukova, l. (2021). assessing the effect of 3d printing technologies on entrepreneurship: an exploratory study. technological forecasting and social change, 164, 120483. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.techfore.2020.120483 rayna, t., striukova, l., & darlington, j. (2015). co-creation and user innovation: the role of online 3d printing platforms. journal of engineering and technology management, 37, 90–102. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jengtecman.2015.07.002 reich, m. j., woern, a. l., tanikella, n. g., & pearce, j. m. (2019). mechanical properties and applications of recycled polycarbonate particle material extrusion-based additive manufacturing. materials, 12(10), 1642. reprap. (2021a). printable part sources reprap. https://reprap.org/wiki/printable_part_sources. accessed 14 june 2021 reprap. (2021b). microdelta rework 3d printer. reprap 3d printer. https://www.reprap-3dprinter.com/product/1234568619-microdelta-rework-3d-printer. accessed 1 june 2021 european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/6508 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 22 richardson, m., elliott, s. and haylock, b., 2013. this home is a factory: implications of the maker movement on urban environments. craft plus design enquiry, 5. ritzer, g., & jurgenson, n. (2010). production, consumption, prosumption: the nature of capitalism in the age of the digital ‘prosumer.’ journal of consumer culture, 10(1), 13–36. https://doi.org/10.1177/1469540509354673 rockets2. (2021). han solo blaster. youmagine. https://www.youmagine.com/designs/han-solo-blaster. accessed 1 june 2021 ruamsook, k., russell, d., thomchick, e. (2007) u.s. sourcing from low-cost countries: a comparative anal-ysis of supplier performance. journal of supply chain management 43(4):16‒30. sanchez, f. a. c., boudaoud, h., hoppe, s., & camargo, m. (2017). polymer recycling in an open-source additive manufacturing context: mechanical issues. additive manufacturing, 17, 87-105. sanchez, f. a. c., lanza, s., boudaoud, h., hoppe, s., & camargo, m. (2015, august). polymer recycling and additive manufacturing in an open source context: optimization of processes and methods. in annual international solid freeform fabrication symposium, issf 2015 (pp. 1591-1600). sanchez, f. a. c., boudaoud, h., camargo, m., & pearce, j. m. (2020). plastic recycling in additive manufacturing: a systematic literature review and opportunities for the circular economy. journal of cleaner production, 121602. sandström, c. g. (2016). the non-disruptive emergence of an ecosystem for 3d printing — insights from the hearing aid industry’s transition 1989–2008. technological forecasting and social change, 102, 160–168. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.techfore.2015.09.006 sanladerer, t. (2021). 3d-printable glidecam. youmagine. https://www.youmagine.com/designs/3d-printable-glidecam. accessed 3 june 2021 savagerodent. (2021). 3d printer feet. youmagine. https://www.youmagine.com/designs/3d-printer-feet-71d19cd6-49554abf-a8ae-50564997c580. accessed 1 june 2021 sells, e., bailard, s., smith, z., bowyer, a., & olliver, v. (2010). reprap: the replicating rapid prototyper: maximizing customizability by breeding the means of production. in handbook of research in mass customization and personalization: (in 2 volumes) (pp. 568-580). somerwil. (2021). r2-d2. youmagine. https://www.youmagine.com/designs/r2-d2. accessed 3 june 2021 stavropoulos, p., papacharalampopoulos, a., tzimanis, k. and lianos, a., 2020. manufacturing resilience during the coronavirus pandemic: on the investigation manufacturing processes agility. european journal of social impact and circular economy, 1(3), pp.28-57. statista. (2021a). plastic waste generation per capita by country. statista. https://www.statista.com/statistics/1228043/plasticwaste-generation-per-capita-in-select-countries/. accessed 14 june 2021 statista. (2021b). worldwide non-metal 3d printer shipments 2022. statista. https://www.statista.com/statistics/765639/global-non-metal-3d-printer-shipments/. accessed 2 june 2021 statista. (2021c). 3d printer shipments worldwide 2027. statista. https://www.statista.com/statistics/370297/worldwideshipments-3d-printers/. accessed 2 june 2021 statista. (2021d). u.s.: number of households 1960-2019. https://www.statista.com/statistics/183635/number-of-householdsin-the-us/. accessed 17 june 2021 steenhuis, h.-j., & pretorius, l. (2016). consumer additive manufacturing or 3d printing adoption: an exploratory study. journal of manufacturing technology management, 27(7), 990–1012. https://doi.org/10.1108/jmtm-01-2016-0002 european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/6508 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 23 stavropoulos, p., papacharalampopoulos, a., tzimanis, k. and lianos, a., 2020. manufacturing resilience during the coronavirus pandemic: on the investigation manufacturing processes agility. european journal of social impact and circular economy, 1(3), pp.28-57. subramaniam, s. r., samykano, m., selvamani, s. k., ngui, w. k., kadirgama, k., sudhakar, k., & idris, m. s. (2019, january). 3d printing: overview of pla progress. in aip conference proceedings (vol. 2059, no. 1, p. 020015). aip publishing llc. toffler, a. (1980). the third wave. morrow. united states district court of minnesota (2015). in re stratasys ltd. shareholder securities litigation 15-cv-00455consolidated amended complaint for violations of the federal securities laws. https://securities.stanford.edu/filingsdocuments/1053/sl00_02/201571_r01c_15cv00455.pdf ur rehman, u., shafiq, m., ali, h. and abdullah, m. (2020). green and sustainable construction practices impact on organizational development. european journal of social impact and circular economy, 1(2), pp.1-26. wei, y., xu, g., liu, h., & ju, f. (2019, december). opencv-based 3d printing physical surface defect detection. in 2019 ieee 4th advanced information technology, electronic and automation control conference (iaeac) (vol. 1, pp. 19241927). ieee. west, j., & kuk, g. (2016). the complementarity of openness: how makerbot leveraged thingiverse in 3d printing. technological forecasting and social change, 102, 169–181. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.techfore.2015.07.025 whyman, s., arif, k. m., & potgieter, j. (2018). design and development of an extrusion system for 3d printing biopolymer pellets. the international journal of advanced manufacturing technology, 96(9), 3417-3428. wittbrodt, b. t., glover, a. g., laureto, j., anzalone, g. c., oppliger, d., irwin, j. l., & pearce, j. m. (2013). life-cycle economic analysis of distributed manufacturing with open-source 3-d printers. mechatronics, 23(6), 713–726. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.mechatronics.2013.06.002 wohlers associates. (2017). wohlers associates publishes 20th anniversary edition of its 3d printing and additive manufacturing industry report | wohlers associates. https://wohlersassociates.com/press72.html woern, a. l., byard, d. j., oakley, r. b., fiedler, m. j., snabes, s. l., & pearce, j. m. (2018a). fused particle fabrication 3d printing: recycled materials’ optimization and mechanical properties. materials, 11(8), 1413. woern, a. l., mccaslin, j. r., pringle, a. m., & pearce, j. m. (2018b). reprapable recyclebot: open source 3-d printable extruder for converting plastic to 3-d printing filament. hardwarex, 4, e00026. yoo, b., ko, h., & chun, s. (2016). prosumption perspectives on additive manufacturing: reconfiguration of consumer products with 3d printing. rapid prototyping journal, 22(4), 691–705. https://doi.org/10.1108/rpj-01-2015-0004 youmagine. (2021a). youmagine – about youmagine: share, remix and 3d print. youmagine. https://www.youmagine.com/about. accessed 28 may 2021 youmagine. (2021b). youmagine – derived designs. youmagine. https://www.youmagine.com/designs/protective-visor-by3dverkstan/derivatives. accessed 4 june 2021 zhong, s., & pearce, j. m. (2018). tightening the loop on the circular economy: coupled distributed recycling and manufacturing with recyclebot and reprap 3-d printing. resources, conservation and recycling, 128, 48-58. zumwalt, g. (2021). perpetual motion da vinci style ii. youmagine. https://www.youmagine.com/designs/perpetual-motion-da-vinci-style-ii. accessed 3 june 2021 european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/6508 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 24 03_floranza european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7425 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 36 understanding the concern to communicate climate change in northeast of catanduanes, philippines jaymund m. floranza1* 1 contact author catanduanes state university – panganiban campus, sta. ana, panganiban, catanduanes (4806), philippines jmfloranza@catsu.edu.ph / jmfloranza@up.edu.ph / jaymundmfloranza@yahoo.com received: 25/04/2022 accepted for publication: 06/12/2023 published: 21/12/2023 abstract the study understands the levels of concern and communication strategies regarding climate change causes, effects, and mitigation, as influenced by the respondent's sex, age, educational attainment, and position within the barangay in the northeast of catanduanes, philippines. the barriers to effective climate change communication are also thoroughly investigated. a mixed-methods approach utilizing quantitative and qualitative methodologies through an online survey was employed. through the survey, comprising 154 valid responses, it was observed that females and males exhibit considerable concern regarding climate change, with variations in prioritizing causes, effects, and mitigation strategies. age-based analysis reveals differences in preferred strategies, where younger respondents emphasize renewable energy, and the older demographic favors interpersonal communication. educational attainment positively correlates with a heightened concern for effective mitigation strategies, emphasizing the role of education in fostering informed responses to climate challenges. the study highlights distinctive concerns and strategies between barangay residents and officials, underlining the need for tailored approaches considering different priorities. in identifying primary barriers, such as lack of information and financial constraints, the study recommends multifaceted solutions. these include sex-focused engagements, age-specific efforts, educational drives, customized barangay plans, and tackling communication challenges, aiming to enhance communitycentric solutions and overcome barriers associated with climate change communication within the local community. this research provides nuanced insights into the varied demographic, psychological, and social factors influencing climate change communication. the findings are aligned with established theories and prior research, emphasizing the importance of tailored strategies and diverse communication approaches to engage diverse audiences and address climate change concerns effectively. keywords: barangay; climate change communication; catanduanes; local community 37 1. introduction in the contemporary era, climate change stands as one of the most critical challenges globally, recognized as an imperative focus under the united nations sustainable development goals (un sdgs), prominently highlighted within goal 13: climate action (neal, 2016; bhore, 2016). the urgency to address this intricate and continually evolving climate change phenomenon has grown increasingly apparent, necessitating a profound understanding of its impacts and the implementation of effective communication strategies, particularly within local communities (canfield et al., 2021; nash et al., 2019). the global discourse on climate change is shaped by various international agreements and frameworks (anwar et al., 2019; cynk, 2018; ebi et al., 2016). notably, the paris agreement, a pivotal international treaty operating under the united nations framework convention on climate change (unfccc), stands as a cornerstone for international cooperation in combating climate change (senathirajah et al., 2023; pietrapertosa et al., 2021). this landmark agreement calls for unified efforts among nations to limit global temperature rise and adapt to its impacts. within the philippine context, legislative instruments such as the climate change act of 2009 established the legal framework for addressing climate-related challenges, emphasizing the necessity for strategic communication, education, and community engagement to mitigate its impacts (zaplan, 2023; pulhin & tapia, 2022). these legal foundations underscore the critical importance of informed communication strategies in engaging local communities to address and adapt to the multifaceted challenges posed by climate change. climate change is a complex and gradually unfolding phenomenon that necessitates effective communication to foster understanding and action. as posited by spence (2011), grasping climate change often relies on observable weather patterns and seasonal events, serving as fundamental indicators for individuals to comprehend this intricate process. in the context of the philippines, which endures an average of 20 typhoons annually (genilo, 2018), crisis communication has become a standard procedure during calamities. moreover, higher education institutions (heis), as emphasized by cuaresma (2017), play a significant role in addressing climate change issues through instruction, research, and capacity building. communicating about climate change remains challenging, as highlighted by lyytimäki et al. (2013), due to its complexity and the limited sources available for effective communication. however, achievable solutions, such as harmonizing multiple communication channels and forming partnerships, can enhance communication efforts (lyytimäki et al., 2013). according to moser (2010), communicators often face skepticism regarding human-induced global climate alterations. addressing this skepticism, as supported by hine et al. (2013), proves essential in bettering climate change communication, although it might not entirely achieve the goals of climate change programs. the involvement of local communities in formulating climate change solutions, as demonstrated by dulic et al. (2016), is a crucial aspect. this aligns with the current study's approach, targeting barangay officials and their residents—the primary recipients of climate change communication at the local level. ballantyne (2016) asserts that communication transcends conveying technical information and instead serves as a practice influencing the truth about climate change as an ethical, cultural, and sociological occurrence. moreover, moser (2017) emphasizes the need for more guidance in communicating and combating climate threats amidst long-term environmental degradation. floranza (2020) further underlines that awareness alone might not drive effective climate change mitigation. in light of these scholarly perspectives, this study intends to delve into the communication dynamics surrounding climate change within the northeast of catanduanes, philippines. by investigating the profile, level of concern and common strategies to communicate climate change, and the perceived barriers among barangay officials and residents, this study aims to bridge existing gaps in climate change communication strategies tailored to the community's diverse demographics. addressing these gaps and barriers holds crucial significance in fostering informed decision-making, mobilizing communities, and driving behavioral change in the collective effort to combat climate change. aligned with global and national climate change agendas and considering the prevailing research gaps, this study is a vital academic pursuit. by providing insights into localized communication strategies, it informs policy formulation, educational outreach, and community engagement. the ultimate goal is to empower and mobilize communities in effectively combating the challenges posed by climate change (leal et al., 2023). 1.2 statement of the problem the study understands the concern of communicating climate change in the northeast of catanduanes, philippines. specifically, the study answered the following questions: 1. what is the level of concern and common strategies to communicate climate change among the barangay respondents in northeast catanduanes in terms of a) climate change causes, b) climate change effects, and c) climate change mitigation according to their a) sex; b) age; c) educational european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7425 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 38 attainment; and position in the barangay?; 2. what are the barriers to communicating climate change among the barangay respondents, and what further details explain the barriers to communicating climate change? 2. literature review this portion presents international and local papers that may clarify the variables of the present study. climate change versus sex the study by zainulbhai (2015) unveiled that women, more than men, are noticeably more worried about climate change impacting them personally, particularly in wealthier nations. in many developed countries, including the u.s., canada, germany, and south korea, women tend to see climate change as a severe problem, feel concerned about its potential personal harm, and advocate for significant lifestyle changes to combat it. for instance, in the u.s., there is a significant difference: 17% more women view climate change as a serious issue compared to men. similar trends are observed in canada and australia, with women expressing 12 to 13 percentage points more concern than men in their respective countries. this gender gap extends to concerns about personal harm from climate change. for example, in the u.s., 69% of women worry about being personally affected, while only 48% of men share the same concern. this trend is seen in other surveyed countries, such as germany and canada, where women exhibit 14 to 15 percentage points higher concerns than men. the local present study shares similarities with the global findings that reveal a notable trend: women tend to express greater concern about the personal impacts of climate change compared to men. as observed in the broader global study across developed nations, the local research here also indicates a similar gender discrepancy in climate change concerns. understanding and acknowledging this discrepancy is crucial in shaping local strategies and initiatives related to climate change. recognizing that women exhibit higher levels of concern can guide tailored approaches to engage and involve them more effectively in local climate action plans. leveraging the specific interests and priorities of women can be instrumental in fostering more vital community awareness and mobilization for climate change initiatives at a local level. the study of desrochers et al. (2019) provided discussion focuses on the consistent observation that women tend to exhibit higher pro-environmental attitudes and engage more in conservation behaviors compared to men. this finding is substantiated across various studies and is considered a robust aspect of environmental psychology. the discussion highlights the importance of this gender disparity in the context of societal efforts to combat environmental degradation. it emphasizes the need to investigate the underlying reasons for these differences, specifically through the lens of personality traits, notably conscientiousness. the studies touch upon the exploration of continuous gender measures, indicating that gender differences might manifest differently from biological sex. results suggest that while conscientiousness continues to mediate gender differences in environmental behavior, gender variance might impact protectionist attitudes differently. the study of desrochers et al. (2019) emphasizes the importance of conscientiousness in mediating gender differences in proenvironmental attitudes and behaviors. encouraging conscientiousness among men could potentially bridge the gap in environmental engagement between genders. mccarthy and citizen (2020) reported that climate change affects everyone, but it is worsened by gender inequality. extreme weather events like heat waves, droughts, and storms harm women more. why? women often face poverty, limited rights, and violence, making them more vulnerable. as climate change worsens, women will face the toughest challenges. the paris climate agreement aims to help women deal with these hazards. the international panel on climate change noted that women's workload, health risks, and mortality due to climate hazards are higher compared to men, thanks to gender inequalities. this inequality limits women's ability to take action against climate change. lack of resources, education, information, and unequal rights affect what women can do in the face of climate change. mccarthy and citizen (2020) further claimed that the future might seem challenging, but women globally show incredible resilience. they lead movements for climate action, promote clean energy, and create sustainable, cooperative communities. it is important to note that women are not just victims of climate change. their active involvement and leadership can create positive change in their countries and communities. consistent with desrochers et al. (2019) and mccarthy & citizen (2020), the present study highlights the necessity for targeted strategies. leveraging women's slightly higher concern can effectively propel climate initiatives. this echoes the broader trends observed, emphasizing the importance of tailored approaches to engage and mobilize women, fostering community awareness and impactful climate action. climate change versus age group european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7425 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 39 funk, c. (2021) survey by the pew research center delineates significant generational disparities in attitudes and engagement concerning climate change. younger cohorts, notably gen z and millennials, exhibit more pronounced involvement both online and offline in addressing climate concerns. this involvement encompasses personal actions such as donations, volunteerism, and advocacy through contacting elected officials, attending rallies, and discussing climate change within their social circles. notably, younger generations display a higher degree of engagement with climate-related content on social media, sharing posts and interacting with accounts focused on climate issues. while a consensus exists on prioritizing alternative energy sources over fossil fuels, there is a distinct generational divide regarding more extreme measures, such as completely phasing out gasoline-powered vehicles and eliminating the use of oil, coal, and natural gas. notably, within the political landscape, disparities persist, with younger republicans less supportive of increased fossil fuel usage compared to older republicans and showing greater willingness to phase out gasoline-powered vehicles. democrats across generations largely support climate action, but younger democrats exhibit more pronounced favor toward policies entirely breaking from fossil fuels. funk, c. (2021) also reveals emotional and knowledge gaps influenced by social media engagement, with deeply concerned individuals expressing more anxiety and anger in response to climate-related content. additionally, there is a growing divergence in trust and perception of expertise in climate scientists, with democrats increasingly trusting their understanding while republicans become more skeptical, echoing the broader partisan divide on trust in scientists. these findings highlight the complex interplay between age, political affiliations, media engagement, and trust in shaping attitudes toward climate change and associated policy measures. ballew et al. (2019) reported that younger americans, compared to their older counterparts, are notably more concerned about global warming, as evidenced by higher levels of worry among adults aged 18 to 34 compared to those aged 55 or older. however, despite this elevated concern, there needs to be more certainty about the extent of their engagement with the issue. while younger republicans are more inclined to acknowledge the reality and human causes of climate change, the generational gap in views on this subject is narrower among them than among older republicans. conversely, younger democrats exhibit varied beliefs compared to older generations within their party. in the upcoming 2020 presidential election, younger generations, projected to constitute a significant portion of registered voters, prioritize global warming as an important issue in their voting decisions. the potential impact of the youth vote on climate policy is considerable, highlighting the need to engage and mobilize younger individuals effectively. initiatives such as the green new deal and youth-led movements have successfully captured the attention of young adults and inspired action, signaling the influence young voices can have in shaping policies concerning climate change. frumkin et al. (2012) discussed that climate change poses a challenging and multifaceted issue known as a "super wicked problem" due to its complexity, uncertain outcomes, and the long-term nature of solutions. as society ages, understanding how older individuals perceive and engage with climate change becomes increasingly important. aging populations represent a significant portion of voters and consumers, capable of influencing behavioral choices and policies. their attitudes toward climate change vary; some may be more vulnerable to its health impacts, while others may prioritize leaving a positive legacy for future generations. assumptions that older individuals tend to become more conservative are not always accurate; attitudes toward climate change vary and are not solely determined by age. some studies show older individuals worrying about global warming but doubtful about its existence. this discrepancy between concern and certainty is puzzling. frumkin et al. (2012) further said there are varied perspectives on how older individuals maintain or change their values over time, with influences from historical events and cohort effects. despite general trends suggesting more conservative voting patterns with age, older individuals do not consistently vote based on their interests, further complicating this dynamic. notably, older individuals' knowledge and attitudes regarding climate change are diverse. some studies indicate higher concern among older age groups, while others suggest skepticism or disengagement. this divergence between attitudes and actions highlights the complexity of environmental issues in survey research. key attributes linked to aging, such as wisdom and the desire to leave a positive legacy, offer potential support in addressing climate change. wisdom, acquired through experience, suggests that older individuals can make balanced and far-sighted judgments. additionally, the desire to leave a legacy for future generations might encourage policies and practices that reduce greenhouse gas emissions and adapt to climate change. frumkin et al. (2012) ultimately said that to engage and leverage the potential of older adults in addressing climate change, several strategies could be implemented. encouraging public discussions about intergenerational responsibilities, revising economic approaches to discounting future investments, and fostering environmental volunteerism among elders are potential avenues. furthermore, tailored communication strategies, intergenerational dialogues, and research focusing on understanding the factors influencing older individuals' attitudes toward climate change are essential. the local study found that different age groups hold distinct concerns about climate change, aligning with the abovementioned authors. for instance, ballew et al. (2019) also observed higher worry among younger americans than older individuals, echoing the local study's discovery of increased concern in younger age brackets. similarly, both studies noted uncertainties about younger individuals' active engagement with climate change. frumkin et al. (2012) emphasized the european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7425 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 40 diversity of attitudes among older age groups, akin to the local study's recognition of varied concerns across different age brackets. both studies also suggest tailored interventions as crucial, echoing the need for customized strategies to engage various age groups effectively. funk (2021) highlighted political differences among younger age groups regarding climate change, aligning with the local study's identification of political variations within younger demographics. both studies emphasize the importance of age-specific strategies to address climate change concerns across different generational groups. climate change versus educational attainment ambasz et al. (2023) make a comprehensive review that addresses the interrelation between human development, particularly education, and its impact on environmental behavior concerning climate change. despite a predominance of observational studies, limited causal research suggests a correlation between higher education levels and pro-environmental attitudes. adaptation and mitigation strategies have been proposed, emphasizing the role of education as a catalyst for fostering environmentally conscious behaviors. the conceptual framework highlights the potential pathways between education and pro-environmental behaviors, but establishing causality remains challenging. research efforts employing various econometric methods and analyses of compulsory schooling laws hint at a positive association between increased education and climate literacy. nonetheless, there is a notable need for extensive research to conclusively determine the impact of education on fostering environmentally responsible behaviors and garnering support for climate policies. zaval and cornwell (2017) underscore the crucial role of education and behavioral science in driving pro-environmental action, especially in the context of climate change awareness and sustainability. while research in this field has primarily been conducted in the united states and europe, global applicability still needs to be improved, necessitating a cross-cultural approach to understanding diverse contextual and cultural factors influencing climate change attitudes and behaviors. the study emphasizes non-monetary interventions, citing the powerful impact of behavioral approaches, such as default options and appeals to social norms, in influencing environmentally responsible actions. however, it notes the need for caution in their application, mainly when these approaches involve non-trivial consumer costs. the report suggests that these behavioral nudges complement, rather than substitute, other economic incentives or mandates. integrating insights from behavioral science into public policy and developing large-scale behavioral interventions would be instrumental in promoting environmental responsibility. furthermore, the report advocates for incorporating behavioral science into humanitarian and environmental organizational strategies, emphasizing the need for ongoing research partnerships to enhance sustainable decision-making practices and improve the effectiveness of such organizations. ledley et al. (2017) emphasize the crucial connection between education and addressing the pressing emissions gap stipulated by the paris agreement. it argues that enhancing society's comprehension of climate change, its associated risks and the necessary energy transition demands an education push that transcends scientific knowledge. this approach integrates multifaceted concepts across various disciplines, encompassing emotional, social, and cultural aspects. employing a systems thinking framework, education emerges as a potent force to drive swift societal transformation. the figures outlined in the article illustrate the role of education in fostering climate-informed decision-making, boosting social willingness for action, and preparing a skilled workforce for transitioning to a sustainable future. while many existing climate change education initiatives have successfully elevated climate and energy literacy and community capacity, challenges persist in coordinating efforts across diverse audiences, managing resources, and scaling up effective programs. it is emphasized that education at all societal levels is pivotal in fostering knowledgeable and responsible leadership across governmental, business, and community sectors, enabling better decision-making and facilitating proactive citizen engagement. the current local study highlights the positive correlation between higher education and heightened concern for climate change, echoing ambasz, gupta, and patrinos (2023), who emphasize education's role in fostering pro-environmental attitudes. zaval and cornwell (2017) echo the importance of education by highlighting the impact of behavioral approaches in promoting environmentally responsible actions. ledley, rooney-varga, and niepold (2017) stress education's role in fostering informed leadership and proactive citizen engagement. all align with the local study, emphasizing the need for education-based initiatives to promote awareness and knowledge about climate change across diverse educational levels, fostering a more responsive society. climate change among the barangay residents and officials alcantara et al. (2023) study reveals valuable insights into the awareness and risk perceptions of climate change in vulnerable coastal areas, highlighting the impact of climate-related events and socio-demographic characteristics within these communities. while a significant proportion of participants (82%) displayed high awareness of climate change, there remains an 18% segment who still need to be made aware of its existence. primary climate change impacts observed or experienced included temperature rise and excessive rainfall, while other effects like declining income, sea level rise, and floods were observed less frequently. of these experiences, temperature rise and excessive rainfall significantly predicted climate change awareness. significantly, experiences or observations of sea level rise were strong predictors of risk perception regarding climate change impacts on the mangroves and coastal marine ecosystems. the study also identified that women and non-poor european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7425 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 41 participants exhibited higher risk perceptions of climate change effects on coastal marine ecosystems, as did the 19–29-yearold group. however, this younger age group displayed a lower risk perception concerning sea level rise's impact on mangrove ecosystems. geographical context also influenced risk perception of sea level rise impact. alcantara et al. (2023) study expressed that most participants recognized high impacts of anthropogenic drivers and climate change on coral reefs and seagrasses but perceived marine livelihood as having a lower impact. risk perceptions were influenced by local temperature rise, excessive rainfall, and declining income, while education significantly impacted risk perception regarding the impacts on coral reefs and seagrasses. furthermore, non-poor participants had notably higher risk perceptions than those from the poor demographic regarding the various factors affecting these ecosystems. siña et al. (2016) study shed light on how climate change is perceived within the governing bodies of lima, offering insights into the municipalities' priorities and decision-making processes concerning public programs and initiatives. although climate change and environmental concerns were acknowledged as vital for public health and safety, they were not consistently prioritized. the lack of emphasis on climate-related issues might be attributed to confusion about the causes and impacts of climate change, leading to oversight in decision-making processes. siña et al. (2016) study said that implementing strategies for adapting to and mitigating climate change could yield substantial long-term benefits for lima's population, positively impacting both health and the economy. addressing the gaps in understanding climate change and its associated mitigation and adaptation strategies could be facilitated by developing a tool. this tool could assist municipal officials in evaluating diverse strategies, providing a more informed and structured approach to addressing climate-related issues in their decision-making processes. the local study identifies disparities in concern levels and response strategies between barangay officials and residents regarding climate change in northeast catanduanes. similarly, siña et al. (2016) shed light on varying priorities and decisionmaking within lima's governing bodies, pointing to confusion about climate change causes and impacts, affecting decisionmaking processes. tailored communication and intervention strategies are highlighted in both studies to address nuanced differences and align with the differing preferences and priorities of distinct groups. moreover, alcantara et al. (2023) delve into climate change awareness and risk perceptions in the coastal marine ecosystem of palawan, revealing varying levels of awareness and risk perceptions among different demographic segments. they note influences such as experiences of climate-related events, socio-demographic characteristics, and geographical contexts on individuals' awareness and risk perceptions, echoing the importance of understanding local contexts and demographic differences in addressing climate change concerns highlighted in both the local study and siña et al. (2016). the barriers to communicate climate change ricart et al. (2022) research explores the relationship between farmers' perceptions of climate change and observed data through bibliometrics and content analysis. it identifies consolidated research areas such as perceived risk, crop vulnerability, forecasting use, and climate change awareness. however, significant gaps exist in conceptual discrepancies in defining 'normal' weather and 'drought,' limited access to quality data affecting farmers' perceptions, insufficient consideration of local knowledge, reliance on recent events in perception, and a geographical bias towards the global south. to address these gaps, future research should define climate patterns, include socio-psychological analysis, and consider a broader global perspective. the study suggests that while both perceived and observed data have limitations, combining them offers a comprehensive understanding of climate change's impact on agriculture, with farmers' qualitative perceptions potentially complementing instrumental climate data in data-scarce areas. markowitz and guckian (2018) concluded that communicating climate change (ccc) is a challenging task with numerous pitfalls and few clear, universally applicable recommendations. however, recent years have seen notable progress in enhancing communication and outreach efforts. this advancement is partially credited to the dedicated work of social science researchers. they have delved into understanding the factors that drive or impede public engagement with climate change, exploring how different communication strategies and narratives influence people, and identifying effective forms of outreach to engage diverse audiences. particularly encouraging is the ongoing diversification and experimentation in ccc. as researchers and communicators venture into new and innovative approaches, the potential to significantly transform public engagement and discourse around climate change, fostering better individual and collective decisions, continues to grow. the current study highlights varied barriers to climate change communication, encompassing information gaps, financial concerns, and psychological factors. addressing these requires tailored strategies that bridge the information gap and tackle financial, psychological, and behavioral hurdles. this aligns with the study by ricart et al. (2022) that also stresses the insufficiency of information as a barrier, and markowitz and guckian (2018) note ongoing progress in diverse communication strategies, aligning with the need for tailored approaches identified in the present study to engage diverse audiences in climate change discourse effectively. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7425 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 42 3. theoretical framework and hypothesis development two prominent theories that could serve as a theoretical framework for the study of communicating climate change in the northeast of catanduanes, philippines, are: 3.1 diffusion of innovation theory this theory, proposed by everett rogers, focuses on how new ideas, innovations, or practices spread within a community or society. it could help understand the adoption of climate change communication strategies among the barangayrespondents. it categorizes individuals based on their readiness to adopt new ideas (innovators, early adopters, early majority, late majority, laggards) and considers factors like communication channels, social systems, and perceived benefits of adopting the innovation. this theory could display why certain demographic groupings within the barangay might be more receptive to communicate climate change and which communication strategies might be more effective based on their characteristics (van houtven et al., 2023; iqbal & zahidie, 2022). 3.2 social learning theory this theory as established by albert bandura, stresses the importance of social interaction, observation, and modeling in the learning process. it advocates that people learn not just from their own experiences but also by observing others. applied to the concern to communicate climate change, it could help understand how individuals in the barangay learn about climate change and its implications through interactions within their social groups. this theory could help to identify influential figures within the community who could serve as effective communicators and also highlight the importance of peer-to-peer learning and community engagement in disseminating information about climate change (ozer, 2022; duffy, 2021). the mentioned theories offer frameworks for understanding the diffusion and acceptance of new ideas (like climate change communication strategies) within a community and the role of social interactions in the learning process, which could be highly relevant in analyzing the concern and strategizing communicating climate change in the context of the northeast of catanduanes, philippines. . 4. methodology 4.1 research design this study employs a mixed-methods approach (johnson & onwuegbuzie, 2004), combining quantitative and qualitative research methodologies through an online survey. the quantitative component aims to assess the degree of concern and the common strategies used for communicating climate change, as well as to identify barriers among the respondents from various barangays in the northeast of catanduanes. at the same time, the qualitative part involves an open-ended query directed at the barangay respondents, prompting them to elaborate on their chosen barriers to communicating climate change, enabling the emergence of prominent themes. this method facilitates a nuanced understanding of the complexities surrounding climate change communication within the specific context of the northeast of catanduanes. in essence, this study aligns with a descriptive research approach, capturing, analyzing, and interpreting current phenomena related to climate change communication within the targeted community. the data collection primarily utilizes an online survey questionnaire hosted on google forms. the credibility of the responses provided by the barangay respondents is pivotal for the accuracy of the research findings. consequently, employing descriptive research techniques is deemed the most appropriate design for this study (siedlecki, 2020). the structure and methodology of this online survey draw inspiration from studies conducted by sarathchandra and haltinner (2021), muto et al. (2020), and rakhmanov and dane (2020) that utilized online surveys in diverse contexts, particularly amid the backdrop of the covid-19 pandemic. sarathchandra and haltinner's (2021) research employed an online survey to explore the influence of gender and education on environmental attitudes and climate change beliefs. similarly, muto et al. (2020) utilized an online platform with quota sampling to analyze the behavioral shifts among japanese citizens during the early stages of the pandemic. moreover, rakhmanov and dane (2020) conducted an online survey during the covid-19 lockdown, targeting students self-isolating at home within the nile university of nigeria. these referenced studies provide valuable insights into the effective utilization of online surveys in diverse scenarios, offering a framework that resonates with the objectives and context of the current research in examining climate change communication within the northeast of catanduanes. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7425 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 43 4.2 units of analysis/source of data/sampling the term 'population' refers to a certain grouping of individuals, occurrences, or objects that are the focal point of study or consideration by the researcher. in the context of the present local study, the population under scrutiny comprises the barangay respondents from the municipalities of viga, panganiban, and bagamanoc. these respondents collectively represent the designated population for this research. 4.2.1 sampling procedure the research universe consists of barangay respondents in the northeast of catanduanes. in observance of the measures of the philippine government in fighting covid-19, the incidents required that the data gathering be carried out through an online survey. sharma and tikka (2020) acknowledged certain limitations associated with online survey questionnaires, specifically in employing convenience sampling and gathering relatively small sample sizes that may deviate significantly from recommended research standards. however, they underscored the importance of refining the quality of online surveys, which mitigates the inherent limitations of convenience sampling and selection bias among responders. in alignment with the principles expounded by sharma and tikka (2020), the current study adopted a similar methodology, utilizing google forms for conducting an online survey to facilitate voluntary participation from respondents—outreach efforts involved using cell phones, email, and various social media platforms to engage potential participants. given the inherent limitations in determining the exact number of potential participants in the digital environment, convenience and snowball sampling were deemed appropriate sampling methods for this study. emerson (2020) and sedgwick (2013) support the utilization of convenience sampling, defining it as the identification and classification of suitable individuals meeting the criteria for study respondents through any accessible means. simultaneously, snowball sampling was employed, as participants were encouraged to recollect and share the electronic questionnaire link, acquiring the desired number of respondents. the data collection process commenced on october 9, 2020, at 7:54:36 pm, concluding on october 24, 2020, at 3:00:14 pm, spanning 15 days. during this period, a total of 154 valid online responses were collected. this quantity of online responses is deemed sufficient considering the scope of the research population under investigation. table 1 presents the profile distribution of the barangay respondents, showing a diversified demographic landscape. among them, females constitute a more significant proportion at 60.39% compared to males at 39.61%. regarding age, the majority falls within the 29 and below category, comprising 51.30%, while 30-59-year-olds represent 41.56%, and those aged 60 and above are at 7.14%. educational attainment showcases a higher percentage in technical and higher education at 65.58%, followed by individuals with elementary and secondary education at 24.03% and those with advanced education at 10.39%. regarding their positions within the barangay, barangay residents make up a significant share at 83.77% compared to barangay officials at 16.23%. this categorization emphasizes the diverse structure of the respondents, reflecting various demographics and positions within the barangay. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7425 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 44 table 1: profile distribution of the barangay-respondent profile freque ncy % sex male 61 39.61 female 93 60.39 total 154 100.00 age 29 and below 79 51.30 30-59 age range 64 41.56 60 and above 11 7.14 total 100.00 educational attainment elementary and secondary education 37 24.03 technical and higher education 101 65.58 advanced education 16 10.39 total 154 100.00 position in the barangay barangay official 25 16.23 barangay residents 129 83.77 total 154 100.00 source: author´s elaboration 4.3 data collection/instrumentation the process of data collection in this study was influenced by the insights drawn from hager et al.'s (2020) research, which noted the impracticality of a physical, paper-based questionnaire due to the prevailing covid-19 pandemic and associated lockdown measures. as a result, reaching out to respondents was conducted through electronic means, such as emails and various social media platforms. this method aligns with the approach adopted in geldsetzer's (2020) study, which utilized an online platform to assess public perceptions and knowledge about covid-19 among a convenient sample of the general population. in alignment with the methodologies employed by hager et al. (2020) and geldsetzer (2020), the present study also gathered research data from respondents residing in barangays within northeast catanduanes through online responses. these data underwent tabulation and subsequent statistical analysis to facilitate interpretations and discussions within the research. moreover, the item statements from previous research studies explicitly addressing the communication of climate change concerns were revisited, simplified, and adapted to suit the constructs pertinent to the current investigation. the finalized research instrument is accessible online, enabling outreach to potential respondents. this online approach holds particular advantages, especially in the context of the ongoing covid-19 situation, where physical interaction is discouraged, as emphasized by hager et al. (2020). the survey instrument initiates with a preamble to the respondents, elucidating the research's objectives and ensuring the confidentiality and ethical handling of the gathered data. strategic modifications were made to the research tool item statements to ensure they resonated well with the comprehension levels of the targeted respondents. the electronic version of the research instrument was available online for a 15-day duration, accessible through the link https://forms.gle/a9avhxjy1bntd4f39. the survey commences with a preliminary letter to the respondents, outlining the research's purpose and guaranteeing the confidentiality of the collected data while observing ethical considerations. the questionnaire's structure encompasses sections devoted to profiling the barangay officials and residents in northeast catanduanes concerning sex, age, educational attainment, and position within the barangay. subsequent segments involve presenting images accompanied by textual descriptions to gauge respondents' levels of concern regarding climate change and their intended methods of communicating or relaying the image's message to others. the questionnaire also encompasses queries about barriers to communicating climate change and solicits additional insights to elucidate these barriers among the respondents. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7425 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 45 moreover, the questionnaire includes an informed consent form to comply with ethical research standards. the author considered insights from carlton and jacobson (2016), metag (2016), vulturius et al. (2016), kaesehage et al. (2014), and local experts involved in climate change initiatives at the writer's affiliated university to validate the questionnaire. the validation process confirmed the accuracy and relevance of the included questionnaire items. the study utilized cronbach's alpha coefficient to ensure the reliability of the questionnaires. it measures the internal consistency to establish the tool's reliability. the actual data, collected from 154 respondents through the survey, were subjected to cronbach's alpha coefficient estimation. the results, as presented in table 2, affirm the questionnaire's reliability as a research instrument. table 2. reliability analysis variables no. of items cronbach's alpha coefficient (α) the level of concern to communicate climate change among the respondentbarangay-residents in northeast of catanduanes 10 .905 the strategies adopted for communicating climate change among the respondentbarangay-residents in northeast of catanduanes 10 .751 source: author´s elaboration the study data collection adhered strictly to ethical standards in administering the research process. the targeted respondents were duly informed about the research's nature and its procedural features, giving them the freedom to participate or decline participation in the study. the catanduanes state university ethics committee has approved the execution of this study, underscoring its alignment with recognized ethical guidelines and regulations (geneviève et al. 2018). 4.4 data processing the data processing methods employed in this study encompassed various statistical tools, particularly frequency count, percentage, and weighted average mean. these statistical tools determined the level of concern about climate change and the common strategies for communicating climate change issues among the barangay respondents in northeast catanduanes. the assessment was categorized across crucial parameters, namely, a) climate change causes, b) climate change effects, and c) climate change mitigation, with a focus on participants' demographic characteristics such as a) sex, b) age, c) educational attainment; and position within the barangay. furthermore, the study examined the barriers obstructing effective communication about climate change among the barangay residents and officials in northeast catanduanes. the study involved a systematic tallying and ranking of these barriers, identifying the most significant to the least significant impediments to effective communication in the community. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7425 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 46 5. results table 3, the level of concern and common strategies about the messages of climate change among the barangay respondents in northeast catanduanes in terms of a) climate change causes, b) climate change effects, and c) climate change mitigation according to their sex item # item # in the questionnaire type of pictures being communicated female (n=93) male (n=61) weighed mean qualitative response common strategies weighed mean qualitative response common strategies climate change causes 1 3 unsegregated garbage 4.61 very much concerned i will refer or consult it to the proper authority. 4.48 much concern i will refer or consult it to the proper authority. 2 4 chopped wood 4.30 much concern 4.33 much concern 3 5 toxic gas emitted from industries 4.19 much concern 4.28 much concern 4 7 burning of garbage 4.34 much concern 4.36 much concern average weighted mean 4.36 much concern 4.36 much concern climate change effects 5 1 dry land due to drought 4.35 much concern i will refer or consult it to the proper authority. 4.56 very much concerned i will refer or consult it to the proper authority. 6 2 flooding due to extreme weather 4.63 very much concerned 4.64 very much concerned 7 8 forest fire 4.34 much concern 4.38 much concern average weighted mean 4.44 much concern 4.52 very much concerned climate change mitigation 8 6 garbage segregation 4.66 very much concerned i will tell it to my family and friends about the matter 4.49 much concern i will tell it to my family and friends about the matter 9 9 coastal clean-up 4.60 very much concerned 4.39 much concern 10 10 solar panel – renewable energy 3.94 much concern 4.13 much concern average weighted mean 4.40 much concern 4.34 much concern source: author´s elaboration the table 3 outlines the level of concern and common strategies about the messages of climate change among the barangay respondents in the northeast of catanduanes, segmented by sex and categorized into three key areas: a) climate change causes, b) climate change effects, and c) climate change mitigation. the data includes the type of pictures being communicated, qualitative responses, common strategies, and the weighted mean for both female (93) and male (61) respondents. the items under this category focus on the causes of climate change, including unsegregated garbage, chopped wood, toxic gas emitted from industries, and garbage burning. both female and male respondents showed relatively high concern for these causes, with an average weighted mean of 4.36 for both genders. common strategies expressed by respondents include referencing or consulting the issue with the proper authority. this section addresses the effects of climate change, such as dry land due to drought, flooding due to extreme weather, and forest fires. female respondents displayed slightly higher concern compared to male respondents in terms of weighted means: 4.44 for females and 4.52 for males. the qualitative response commonly involved referencing or consulting the matter with the proper authority. mitigation strategies discussed include garbage segregation, coastal clean-up, and solar panels for renewable energy. in this category, females tended to show slightly more concern (with an average weighted mean of 4.40) than males (with an average weighted mean of 4.34)—common strategies involved sharing the matter with family and friends. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7425 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 47 the results indicate a generally high level of concern among both female and male respondents regarding the causes, effects, and mitigation strategies related to climate change. concerns are particularly notable regarding the effects of climate change, especially among female respondents. both sexes tend to favor consulting or referencing issues with the proper authority. additionally, in terms of mitigation strategies, both groups express a willingness to engage in actions and spread awareness among their social circles. this data provides insights into the awareness and concern of barangay (local community) residents in the northeast of catanduanes regarding climate change issues, potentially informing targeted interventions or awareness campaigns to further educate and engage the community in mitigating climate change impacts. statistically, female respondents show marginally higher concern, particularly in addressing the effects of climate change, compared to their male counterparts. the implication of the observed sex discrepancy in concern about the effects of climate change is significant for targeted interventions. understanding that females express slightly higher concern in this regard suggests the need for tailored strategies in engaging and mobilizing women in climate change initiatives, leveraging their specific interests and priorities to foster more effective community awareness and climate action. the significant findings of the present study aligns with these global findings, showcasing a similar pattern: women tend to show higher concern about the personal impacts of climate change compared to men. the study by zainulbhai in 2015 discovered that in wealthier nations, women are notably more worried about how climate change will affect them personally compared to men. this trend is consistent across developed countries like the u.s., canada, germany, and south korea, where women view climate change as a serious problem, express concerns about potential personal harm, and advocate for significant lifestyle changes to address it. this sex gap in climate change concerns, observed both globally and locally, emphasizes the need to recognize and address these differences in crafting effective strategies and interventions for local climate action plans. further, the present local study mirrors global trends on the women show slightly higher concern about climate change effects. aligning with desrochers et al. (2019) and mccarthy & citizen (2020), this finding underscores the need for targeted strategies. leveraging women’s marginally greater concern can drive more effective climate initiatives. tailored approaches, acknowledging this gender discrepancy, offer opportunities to engage and mobilize women, fostering community awareness and impactful climate action. table 4, the level of concern and common strategies about the messages of climate change among the barangay respondents in northeast catanduanes in terms of a) climate change causes, b) climate change effects, and c) climate change mitigation according to their age group item # item # in the questionnaire type of pictures being communicated age 29 and below (n=79) age 30 to age 59 (n=64) age 60 and above (n=11) weighed mean qualitative response common strategies weighed mean qualitative response common strategies weighed mean qualitative response common strategies climate change causes 1 3 unsegregated garbage 4.52 very much concerned i will refer or consult it to the proper authority. 4.66 very much concerned i will refer or consult it to the proper authority. 4.27 much concern i will tell it to my family and friends about the matter 2 4 chopped wood 4.35 much concern 4.38 much concern 3.64 much concern 3 5 toxic gas emitted from industries 4.35 much concern 4.20 much concern 3.45 little concerned 4 7 burning of garbage 4.34 much concern 4.45 much concern 3.82 much concern average weighted mean 4.39 much concern 4.42 much concern 3.80 much concern climate change effects 5 1 dry land due to drought 4.41 much concern i will refer or consult it to the proper authority. 4.48 much concern i will refer or consult it to the proper authority. 4.36 much concern i will refer or consult it to the proper authority. 6 2 flooding due to extreme weather 4.54 very much concerned 4.80 very much concerned 4.36 much concern 7 8 forest fire 4.44 much concern 4.39 much concern 3.55 much concern average weighted mean 4.46 much concern 4.56 very much concerned 4.09 much concern climate change mitigation 8 6 garbage segregation 4.62 very much concerned i will tell it to my family and friends about the matter 4.66 very much concerned i will tell it to my family and friends about the matter 4.00 much concern i will tell it to my family and friends about the matter 9 9 coastal clean-up 4.53 very much concerned 4.59 very much concerned 4.00 much concern 10 10 solar panel – renewable energy 4.15 much concern 4.06 much concern 2.73 little concerned average weighted mean 4.43 much concern 4.44 much concern 3.58 much concern source: author´s elaboration european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7425 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 48 table 4 presents the varying levels of concern and common strategies about the messages of climate change among respondents in different age brackets regarding climate change causes, effects, and mitigation strategies. for climate change causes, across age groups, there is a consistently high concern for unsegregated garbage as a cause of climate change, with the highest concern among the 30 to 59 age group. concern for chopped wood and toxic gas emitted from industries is relatively consistent, but the younger age group shows higher concern for toxic gas. the response "i will tell it to my family and friends about the matter" is notably more common among respondents aged 60 and above. for climate change effects: all age groups exhibit significant concern about the effects of climate change, particularly extreme weather-related issues like drought, flooding, and forest fires. notably, respondents aged 30 to 59 express the highest concern across these categories. for climate change mitigation, garbage segregation and coastal clean-up garner high concern across all age groups. however, the younger age group shows more heightened concern for solar panel usage as a form of renewable energy. the data suggests that different age groups prioritize and perceive climate change causes, effects, and mitigation strategies differently. younger respondents are more inclined towards specific mitigation strategies like renewable energy solutions, while the older age group leans towards interpersonal communication for addressing causes. the implication of the notable prevalence of the response "i will tell my family and friends about the matter" among respondents aged 60 and above suggests a reliance on interpersonal communication and social networks within this age group. this highlights the potential for leveraging familial and social circles as essential channels for disseminating information and initiating collective action toward addressing climate change. harnessing this inclination could be an effective means of spreading awareness and fostering community engagement among older generations. further, the research data illustrates notable distinctions in concerns regarding climate change across different age groups. individuals aged 30 to 59 generally exhibit heightened levels of apprehension about the causes and effects of climate change compared to younger and older demographics. moreover, the middle age group demonstrates a stronger inclination toward proactive strategies, particularly emphasizing concerns and actions related to mitigating climate change effects. understanding these divergences is pivotal for implementing targeted interventions that resonate with the specific priorities of each age group optimizing efforts to address climate change concerns effectively. the implications of these significant age-based differences in concerns about climate change are crucial. understanding the varied priorities among age groups allows for more effective and targeted approaches to address climate change issues. implementing age-specific programs and communication strategies could foster greater engagement and participation, as different generations have distinct inclinations toward causes, effects, and mitigation strategies. tailored interventions and communication strategies could enhance engagement, considering the varying priorities and concerns across different age levels. the said approach can maximize the impact of initiatives by aligning them more closely with the specific concerns and interests of each age demographic, thus facilitating a more comprehensive and impactful response to climate change challenges. the present local study disparities in climate change concerns across age groups aligned with the insights of various authors in this field. ballew et al. (2019) similarly note heightened worry among younger americans (ages 18 to 34) compared to their older counterparts, aligning with the local study's findings of heightened apprehension in younger demographics. moreover, ballew et al. highlight the uncertainty surrounding younger individuals' engagement with climate change, paralleling the local study's identification of uncertainty regarding younger age groups' active involvement. frumkin et al. (2012) underscore the diversity of attitudes among older individuals, mirroring the local study's recognition of varied concerns among different age brackets. additionally, the emphasis on tailored interventions in the present study is in line with frumkin et al.'s suggestion for customized strategies to engage older generations effectively. funk (2021) accentuates political discrepancies among younger age groups regarding climate change, which resonates with the local study's identification of political variances within younger demographics. the present study's focus on tailored interventions aligns with funk's insights on the need for age-specific strategies in addressing climate change concerns across different generational groups. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7425 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 49 table 5, the level of concern and common strategies about the messages of climate change among the barangay respondents in northeast catanduanes in terms of: a) climate change causes, b) climate change effects, and c) climate change mitigation according to their educational attainment item # item # in the ques tionnaire type of pictures being communicated elementary and secondary education (n=37) technical and higher education (n=101) advanced education (n=16) weighed mean qualitative response common strategies weighed mean qualitative response common strategies weighed mean qualitative response common strategies climate change causes 1 3 unsegregated garbage 4.24 much concern i will refer or consult it to the proper authority. 4.61 very much concerned i will refer or consult it to the proper authority. 4.94 very much concerned i will refer or consult it to the proper authority. 2 4 chopped wood 4.03 much concern 4.40 much concern 4.44 much concern 3 5 toxic gas emitted from industries 3.95 much concern 4.29 much concern 4.50 very much concerned 4 7 burning of garbage 4.00 much concern 4.40 much concern 4.88 very much concerned average weighted mean 4.05 much concern 4.42 much concern 4.69 very much concerned climate change effects 5 1 dry land due to drought 4.27 much concern i will refer or consult it to the proper authority. 4.44 much concern i will refer or consult it to the proper authority. 4.81 very much concerned i will refer or consult it to the proper authority. 6 2 flooding due to extreme weather 4.59 very much concerned 4.61 very much concerned 4.88 very much concerned 7 8 forest fire 4.00 much concern 4.47 much concern 4.50 very much concerned average weighted mean 4.29 much concern 4.50 very much concerned 4.73 very much concerned climate change mitigation 8 6 garbage segregation 4.19 much concern i will tell it to my family and friends about the matter 4.67 very much concerned i will tell it to my family and friends about the matter 5.00 very much concerned i will tell it to my family and friends about the matter 9 9 coastal clean-up 4.14 much concern 4.58 very much concerned 5.00 very much concerned 10 10 solar panel – renewable energy 3.57 much concern 4.09 much concern 4.56 very much concerned average weighted mean 3.96 much concern 4.45 much concern 4.85 very much concerned source: author´s elaboration the table 5 dataset presents a compelling correlation between levels of educational attainment and attitudes toward climate change, delineating distinct variations in the levels of concern and perceptions of efficacy across diverse educational groups. regarding concerns about the causes of climate change: the data indicates that individuals with varying levels of education exhibit differing degrees of concern. the respondents with basic education display an average concern weighted mean of 4.05, while technical and higher education present a higher average concern weighted mean of 4.42. notably, advanced education records the highest average concern weighted mean of 4.69. the discernible disparity in concern levels, particularly the higher averages within the more advanced educational qualification, suggests a clear relationship between higher education levels and heightened apprehension regarding the causes of climate change. this means a potential implication: individuals with advanced educational backgrounds tend to demonstrate greater sensitivity and concern toward the multifaceted causes of climate change compared to those with basic education levels. on the perception of climate change effects: a similar pattern in concern levels emerges across educational strata. the respondents with basic education report an average concern weighted mean of 4.29, while those with technical and higher european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7425 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 50 education demonstrate a slightly higher average concern weighted mean of 4.50. respondents with advanced education exhibit the most elevated concern with an average concern weighted mean of 4.73. this consistent trend implies that individuals with higher educational achievements are inclined to manifest increased concern regarding the effects of climate change. this suggests a potential implication: those with more advanced educational backgrounds are more mindful of and responsive to the potential impact and consequences of climate change. regarding climate change mitigation: regarding the perceived effectiveness of mitigation strategies, the data delineates varying perspectives across educational strata. respondents with basic education record an average effectiveness weighted mean of 3.96, while those with technical and higher education report a slightly higher average of 4.45. advanced education reflects the highest average weighted mean of 4.85. this trend implies that individuals with advanced educational backgrounds tend to perceive climate change mitigation strategies as more effective compared to those with basic educational levels. the finding suggests that higher education may contribute to a more favorable evaluation of potential solutions for addressing climate change issues. the data underscores a clear positive correlation between higher educational attainment and increased concern for, as well as the perceived effectiveness of, strategies related to climate change. this underlines that educational initiatives to raise awareness and knowledge about climate change could lead to a more informed and responsive populace, particularly among those with higher educational achievements. furthermore, policy interventions and educational programs tailored to address climate change concerns may benefit from targeting individuals across various educational levels to ensure an inclusive and comprehensive approach to combating climate change. the present local study highlights a strong link between higher education and increased concern for and perceived effectiveness of strategies related to climate change. this aligns with insights from ambasz, gupta, and patrinos (2023), who reviewed the interconnection between human development, especially education, and its impact on pro-environmental behavior concerning climate change. they emphasize the role of education in fostering environmentally conscious behaviors but note the challenge of establishing a clear causal relationship between education and pro-environmental attitudes. zaval and cornwell (2017) emphasize the critical role of education and behavioral science in promoting proenvironmental action, aligning with the local study's focus on the importance of educational initiatives to raise awareness about climate change. they highlight the impact of behavioral approaches, such as appeals to social norms, in influencing environmentally responsible actions. similarly, ledley, rooney-varga, and niepold (2017) underscore the vital connection between education and addressing climate change, advocating for an education approach that transcends scientific knowledge and integrates various disciplines. they stress that education is crucial in fostering knowledgeable and responsible leadership across sectors and empowering proactive citizen engagement. these studies collectively support the local study's emphasis on the need for educational programs tailored to address climate change concerns across various educational levels to foster an informed and responsive populace. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7425 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 51 table 6, the level of concern and common strategies about the messages of climate change among the barangay residents and officials in northeast catanduanes in terms of: a) climate change causes, b) climate change effects, and c) climate change mitigation item # item # in the questionnaire type of pictures being communicated barangay officials (n=25) barangay residents (n=129) weighed mean qualitative response common strategies weighed mean qualitative response common strategies climate change causes 1 3 unsegregated garbage 4.76 very much concerned i will refer or consult it to the proper authority. 4.52 very much concerned i will refer or consult it to the proper authority. 2 4 chopped wood 4.44 much concern 4.29 much concern 3 5 toxic gas emitted from industries 4.04 much concern 4.26 much concern 4 7 burning of garbage 4.52 very much concerned 4.32 much concern average weighted mean 4.44 much concern 4.35 much concern climate change effects 5 1 dry land due to drought 4.56 very much concerned i will refer or consult it to the proper authority. 4.41 much concern i will refer or consult it to the proper authority. 6 2 flooding due to extreme weather 4.68 very much concerned 4.63 very much concerned 7 8 forest fire 4.32 much concern 4.36 much concern average weighted mean 4.52 very much concerned 4.47 much concern climate change mitigation 8 6 garbage segregation 4.88 very much concerned i will refer or consult it to the proper authority. 4.53 very much concerned i will tell it to my family and friends about the matter 9 9 coastal clean-up 4.64 very much concerned 4.50 much concern 10 10 solar panel – renewable energy 3.80 much concern 4.05 much concern average weighted mean 4.44 much concern 4.36 much concern source: author´s elaboration the presented data in table 6 offers a comprehensive insight into the attitudes and common strategies related to climate change messages among respondent-barangay residents in northeast catanduanes, categorized by their roles as either barangay officials or barangay residents. the findings reveal varying levels of concern and responses towards three distinct aspects: climate change causes, climate change effects, and climate change mitigation. the sample size of barangay officials, comprising 25 individuals, showcased higher concern levels across all three categories, often expressing a strong willingness to refer or consult relevant authorities regarding climate change causes and effects. on the other hand, the larger group of barangay residents (n=129) displayed slightly lower but still substantial levels of concern regarding these issues. there is a noteworthy convergence in concern levels between the two groups concerning the causes and effects of climate change. however, the approach to climate change mitigation strategies varied significantly. barangay officials tended to emphasize referring or consulting authorities, whereas barangay residents were more inclined to disseminate information within their social circles. the data elucidates not only the disparities in concern levels and response strategies between barangay officials and residents but also highlights the collective awareness and acknowledgment of the gravity of climate change issues within their locality. despite differing approaches, both groups recognize the urgency of addressing climate change causes and effects, albeit with nuanced differences in the perceived efficacy of mitigation strategies. this variation underscores the importance of tailored communication and intervention strategies, particularly in the realm of climate change mitigation, to align with the differing preferences and priorities of these distinct groups. such insights are pivotal in formulating and implementing community-specific initiatives aimed at effectively addressing and mitigating the impact of climate change within northeast catanduanes. the local study identifies disparities in concern levels and response strategies between barangay officials and residents regarding climate change in northeast catanduanes. similarly, siña et al. (2016) shed light on varying priorities and decision european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7425 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 52 making within lima's governing bodies, pointing to confusion about climate change causes and impacts, affecting decisionmaking processes. tailored communication and intervention strategies are highlighted in both studies to address nuanced differences and align with the differing preferences and priorities of distinct groups. moreover, alcantara et al. (2023) delve into climate change awareness and risk perceptions in the coastal marine ecosystem of palawan, revealing varying levels of awareness and risk perceptions among different demographic segments. they note influences such as experiences of climate-related events, socio-demographic characteristics, and geographical contexts on individuals' awareness and risk perceptions, echoing the importance of understanding local contexts and demographic differences in addressing climate change concerns highlighted in both the local study and siña et al. (2016). table 7, the barriers to climate change communication. the barriers frequency (n=154) lack of information 82 cost/financial expense 25 lack of time 17 inconvenience/discomfort 16 no idea 9 lack of discipline 2 close-mindedness of other people 1 residents are given information but they take it for granted 1 scared or afraid 1 source: author´s elaboration the researcher collected the research data from 154 respondents. from a quantitative perspective, the frequency distribution of reasons or barriers to effective climate change communication can be summarized as follows: the data obtained from 154 respondents highlights a spectrum of reasons or barriers to effective climate change communication. among the most prevalent obstacles, the primary hindrance identified by 82 respondents was the "lack of information." this denotes a critical need for more accessible, clear, and comprehensive information dissemination on climate change. the second most cited barrier was "cost/financial expense," with 25 respondents expressing concerns about the economic implications of adopting sustainable practices. additionally, "lack of time" was noted by 17 respondents as a barrier, signifying the challenge of time allocation for engaging with climate change discourse. less frequently mentioned barriers included "inconvenience/discomfort" identified by 16 respondents, "no idea" by nine respondents, "lack of discipline" by two respondents, and equally low frequencies of "close-mindedness of other people," "residents taking information for granted," and "scared or afraid" each expressed by one respondent. these lower-frequency barriers imply varied individual and psychological obstacles that contribute to the challenge of effectively communicating the message of climate change. the highest frequency of responses centered around "lack of information." this highlights a crucial aspect where individuals may need sufficient knowledge or a comprehensive understanding of climate change. it indicates the need for more accessible, clear, and accurate information on climate change. the lack of awareness might be due to the complexity of the subject, a shortage of credible sources, or ineffective communication strategies. the second most cited barrier, "cost/financial expense," indicates that some individuals perceive sustainable actions or eco-friendly practices as financially burdensome. this perception might discourage their engagement in climate-friendly behaviors. it reflects a need for policies or solutions that make sustainable choices more affordable and economically feasible for a broader demographic. the lower frequency responses, such as "inconvenience/discomfort," "lack of time," "no idea," "lack of discipline," "close-mindedness of other people," "residents taking information for granted," and "scared or afraid," while fewer in number, also shed light on various personal and psychological barriers. these barriers could be individual-centric, reflecting the unique challenges individuals face in accepting, understanding, or acting upon climate change information. from a comprehensive standpoint, the findings suggest a multifaceted nature of barriers to effective climate change communication. while lack of information and financial concerns dominate the responses, the diversity of reasons, even in lower frequencies, indicates a range of psychological, social, and economic barriers that impede effective communication on this crucial issue. strategies must be multifaceted, addressing not only the information gap but also the financial, psychological, and behavioral barriers to improve climate change communication. crafting tailored communication approaches, promoting the european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7425 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 53 affordability of eco-friendly practices, and addressing individual concerns are critical steps toward more effective climate change communication and action. the further details to explain the barriers to communicating climate change the study managed a qualitative analysis of respondents' perspectives on barriers to climate change communication. respondents were prompted with an open-ended query, seeking additional reasons supporting their chosen barriers to climate change communication. the results revealed several prominent themes. firstly, the inadequacy of information and awareness emerged as a significant obstacle, encompassing factors such as insufficient knowledge of climate change consequences, limited access to information due to various reasons like time constraints, disinterest, or educational barriers, and inadequate communication channels. financial constraints were identified as another crucial impediment, encompassing both personal and governmental levels, where a lack of funds hindered efforts to address climate change. communication and education hurdles were evident, reflecting challenges in effectively relaying messages due to a lack of training or discomfort in addressing the issue, as well as limited time and overlapping responsibilities. social and cultural factors played a role, with self-centered attitudes, fear of speaking out, and limited government dissemination except during crises, all contributing to the hindrance. additionally, other factors, such as the "new normal" affecting routines, lack of monitoring due to personal engagements, and the need for more comprehensive educational programs, were identified. the findings underscored the issue's complexity, emphasizing the necessity for a multi-pronged strategy that integrates education, awareness, information accessibility, financial resources, and a transformative shift towards environmental consciousness to address the challenges of climate change communication effectively. the findings of the present study emphasize the multifaceted nature of barriers to climate change communication, including information gaps, financial concerns, and psychological and behavioral obstacles. the tailored strategies are essential, addressing not only the information gap but also economic, psychological, and behavioral obstacles to enhance climate change communication. this comprehensive approach can improve climate change awareness and engagement. in a related study by ricart et al. (2022), the inadequacy of information and awareness was identified as a significant barrier to climate change understanding, which aligns with the findings of the present study regarding the "lack of information" barrier. floranza's (2021) study on barangay governance emphasizes consistent monitoring and assessment of barangay performance that may indirectly lead to highlighting the need for a structured approach in addressing the "lack of information" barrier. this aligns with markowitz and guckian's (2018) assertion that ongoing progress in climate change communication involves exploring various communication strategies to engage diverse audiences effectively. both perspectives indirectly address the need for comprehensive and tailored approaches to overcoming the "lack of information" barrier by emphasizing the importance of continuous evaluation and utilizing diverse communication strategies to bridge information gaps and effectively communicate climate-related concerns to the communities. 6. discussion and conclusions looking into the level of concern and common strategies to communicate climate change among the barangay respondents in northeast catanduanes in terms of a) climate change causes, b) climate change effects, and c) climate change mitigation according to their a) sex; b) age; c) educational attainment; and position in the barangay. the diffusion of innovation theory displays why specific demographics within a particular community might be more interested in communicating climate change and which communication strategies might be more successful grounded by their attributes. regarding the concern and strategies about climate change messages among northeast catanduanes barangay respondents by sex, covering causes, effects, and mitigation. both females (93) and males (61) express notable concern. females slightly prioritize effects, while males show comparable concern across causes, effects, and mitigation. strategies involve consulting authorities and sharing information with family and friends. this gender discrepancy in climate concern aligns with global trends, emphasizing the need for targeted interventions to engage women effectively in climate initiatives. tailoring strategies based on this gender difference offer opportunities for impactful community awareness and action. when grouped by age, regarding climate change causes, effects, and mitigation. younger respondents prioritize renewable energy, while the older group favors interpersonal communication to tackle causes. the prevalence of "i will tell my family and friends about the matter" among the older age group suggests using social circles to disseminate information. individuals aged 30 to 59 show heightened concern for climate issues. understanding these distinctions across age groups is pivotal for tailored interventions to address climate change effectively. the findings stressed the age-based disparities and emphasized the need for age-specific strategies in climate change initiatives. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7425 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 54 this further illustrates educational attainment's correlation with attitudes toward climate change among barangay respondents in northeast catanduanes. higher education levels correspond to increased concern and perceived effectiveness of climate change responses. individuals with advanced education display notably higher concern regarding climate change causes and effects, as well as a stronger belief in the efficacy of mitigation strategies compared to those with basic education. this signifies the potential impact of higher education in raising awareness and fostering more informed responses to climate change challenges. insights from ambasz, gupta, and patrinos (2023), zaval and cornwell (2017), and ledley, rooneyvarga, and niepold (2017) support this, emphasizing education's pivotal role in promoting environmentally conscious behavior and addressing climate change concerns. they advocate for tailored educational programs across different educational levels to nurture informed and engaged communities. the study further displays the concern and the common strategies toward climate change messages among barangay residents and officials in northeast catanduanes. barangay officials (25 individuals) showed higher concern across climate change causes, effects, and mitigation and were willing to consult authorities. the larger group of residents (129 individuals) displayed slightly lower but still significant concern levels. both groups aligned in concern for causes and effects, but officials leaned towards consulting authorities, while residents favored sharing information within their social circles for mitigation. this suggests a need for tailored strategies, acknowledging different preferences between these groups. insights from this local study align with similar findings by siña et al. (2016) and alcantara et al. (2023), emphasizing tailored approaches due to differing priorities and demographics' influence on climate change awareness and strategies. further, the barriers to communicating climate change among the barangay respondents and what further details explain the barriers to communicating climate change. the data from 154 residents reveals primary barriers to climate change communication. "lack of information" is the most critical issue, indicating the need for more precise and accessible climate knowledge. "cost/financial expense" follows, showing concerns about the financial burden of sustainable actions. lowermentioned barriers like "inconvenience/discomfort," "lack of time," and personal obstacles highlight individuals' diverse challenges. the present study's findings emphasize a need for varied strategies, not only addressing information gaps and financial concerns but also individual, psychological, and social barriers. tailored approaches, affordable eco-friendly options, and addressing personal concerns are crucial for better communication and action on climate change. the study further examined barriers to communicating climate change. respondents highlighted several vital obstacles. need for more information and awareness, financial limitations, communication and education challenges, and social factors emerged. the complexity suggests a diverse strategy, integrating education, awareness, accessible information, financial resources, and a shift in environmental consciousness. in enhancing the concern to communicate climate change, targeted approaches are necessary, addressing the information gap, financial matters, and psychological barriers. similar findings in related studies stress the ongoing need for varied communication strategies to engage diverse audiences effectively, consonant with the social learning theory where locals learn not just from their own experiences but also by observing others to enhance concern to communicate climate change. 7. recommendation the study furnishes practical and community-centric solutions to enhance the level of concern, strategies, and overcoming barriers associated with communicating climate change within the local community. first, the study suggests a sex-focused engagement by organizing local meetings specifically for women and men, addressing their respective concerns about climate change. encourage women-led programs and men's groups to take action on the issues they feel most passionate about. second, the researcher proposes age-specific efforts by developing fun educational programs for younger individuals, promoting the importance of nature and environmental conservation through games and interactive activities. encourage elders to share their wisdom in community meetings, highlighting the importance of protecting the environment based on their experiences. third, educational drive, through engaging advanced education students in hands-on projects, like tree planting or sustainable community gardens, to promote environmental consciousness. it is recommended to produce engaging, ageappropriate content, like comics or short videos, to distribute to local schools and libraries, educating various age groups about climate change. fourth, the study may offer customized barangay plans by facilitating regular meetings involving officials and community members, emphasizing shared solutions to address climate issues unique to their barangay. it is suggested to utilize multiple communication tools like local radio and community events to effectively convey climate concerns, tailoring messages for residents and officials. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7425 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 55 fifth, tackle communication challenges by establishing community hubs offering information on sustainable living practices and local eco-friendly resources to increase awareness. it is suggested to create a system where community members can share eco-friendly goods, reducing costs and enhancing accessibility. additionally, it will introduce support services for those facing mental health challenges due to climate anxiety. funding details. this researcher availed the catanduanes state university institutional research funding plus the faculty teaching equivalent of 3 units in the conduct of this research. conflict of interest. this researcher declares no potential conflict of interest in this study. acknowledgment. this writer extends gratitude to the following panel of evaluators: dr. lilia v. briñes, dr. maria s. tugano, prof. ma. cecilia t. arcilla, mr. jaime v. cabrera, and dr. ramon felipe a. sarmiento for their constructive comments and recommendations during the 2021 catsu annual in-house review of completed researches cum search for uswag award last august 26, 2021. references alcantara, l. b., creencia, l. a., madarcos, j. r. v., madarcos, k. g., jontila, j. b. s., & culhane, f. (2023). climate change awareness and risk perceptions in the coastal marine ecosystem of palawan, philippines. ucl open environment, 5. doi: 10.14324/111.444/ucloe.000054 ambasz, d., gupta, a., & patrinos, h. a. (2023). a review of human development and environmental outcomes. retrieved from https://openknowledge.worldbank.org/server/api/core/bitstreams/4981a374-4a1d-4cff-a444481bb4fe1c2c/content anwar, m. a., zhou, r., sajjad, a., & asmi, f. (2019). climate change communication as political agenda and voters’ behavior. environmental science and pollution research, 26, 29946-29961. doi: 10.1007/s11356-019-06134-6 ballantyne, a. g. (2016). climate change communication: what can we learn from communication theory?. wiley interdisciplinary reviews: climate change, 7(3), 329-344. doi: 10.1002/wcc.392 ballew, m., marlon, j., rosenthal, s., gustafson, a., kotcher, j., maibach, e., & leiserowitz, a. (2019). do younger generations care more about global warming. yale program on climate change communication, 11. retrieved from https://climatecommunication.yale.edu/publications/do-younger-generations-care-more-about-global-warming/ bhore, s. j. (2016). paris agreement on climate change: a booster to enable sustainable global development and beyond. international journal of environmental research and public health, 13(11), 1134. doi: https://doi.org/10.3390/ijerph13111134 carlton, j. s., & jacobson, s. k. (2016). using expert and non-expert models of climate change to enhance communication. environmental communication, 10(1), 1-24. doi: 10.1080/17524032.2015.1016544 canfield, k. n., mulvaney, k., & merrill, n. (2021). messaging on slow impacts: applying lessons learned from climate change communication to catalyze and improve marine nutrient communication. frontiers in environmental science, 9, 619606. doi: https://doi.org/10.3389/fenvs.2021.619606 cuaresma, j. c. (2017). philippine higher education institutions’ responses to climate change. in climate change research at universities (pp. 69-93). springer, cham. doi: 10.1007/978-3-319-58214-6_5 cynk, k. w. (2018). the process of climate change in mass media discourse using the example of polish and international editions of “newsweek” magazine. environmental science and pollution research, 25(31), 31439-31449. doi: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11356-018-3138-0 desrochers, j. e., albert, g., milfont, t. l., kelly, b., & arnocky, s. (2019). does personality mediate the relationship between sex and environmentalism?. personality and individual differences, 147, 204-213. doi: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.paid.2019.04.026 duffy, m. a. (2021). why we should preach to the climate change choir: the importance of science communication that engages people who already accept climate change. the american naturalist, 198(3), 433-436. doi: 10.1086/715153 dulic, a., angel, j., & sheppard, s. (2016). designing futures: inquiry in climate change communication. futures, 81, 5467. doi: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.futures.2016.01.004 european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7425 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 56 ebi, k. l., semenza, j. c., & rocklöv, j. (2016). current medical research funding and frameworks are insufficient to address the health risks of global environmental change. environmental health, 15(1), 1-8. doi: https://doi.org/10.1186/s12940-016-0183-3 emerson, r. w. (2015). convenience sampling, random sampling, and snowball sampling: how does sampling affect the validity of research?. journal of visual impairment & blindness, 109(2), 164-168. doi:10.1177/0145482x1510900215 floranza, j. m. (2020). climate change consciousness among tertiary students: implications to curriculum development. asia pacific journal of education, arts and sciences, 7(4), 82-89. retrieved from http://apjeas.apjmr.com/wpcontent/uploads/2020/08/apjeas-2020.7.4.08.pdf floranza, j. m. (2021). barangay governance in northeast of catanduanes, philippines: basis for catanduanes state university panganiban campus extension program. european journal of social impact and circular economy, 2(1), 100123. doi: https://doi.org/10.13135/2704-9906/5058 frumkin, h., fried, l., & moody, r. (2012). aging, climate change, and legacy thinking. american journal of public health, 102(8), 1434-1438. doi: 10.2105/ajph.2012.300663 funk, c. (2021). key findings: how americans’ attitudes about climate change differ by generation, party and other factors. may 26, 2021. retrieved from https://www.pewresearch.org/short-reads/2021/05/26/key-findings-how-americansattitudes-about-climate-change-differ-by-generation-party-and-other-factors/ geldsetzer, p. (2020). knowledge and perceptions of covid-19 among the general public in the united states and the united kingdom: a cross-sectional online survey. annals of internal medicine, 173(2), 157-160. doi: 10.7326/m20-0912 geneviève, l. d., wangmo, t., dietrich, d., woolley-meza, o., flahault, a., & elger, b. s. (2018). research ethics in the european influenzanet consortium: scoping review. jmir public health and surveillance, 4(4), e9616. doi: 10.2196/publichealth.9616 genilo, j. w. (2018). rethinking crisis communication at a time of climate change: lessons from the philippines. in communication, culture and ecology (pp. 131-141). springer, singapore. doi: 10.1007/978-981-10-7104-1_9 hager, e., odetokun, i. a., bolarinwa, o., zainab, a., okechukwu, o., & al-mustapha, a. i. (2020). knowledge, attitude, and perceptions towards the 2019 coronavirus pandemic: a bi-national survey in africa. plos one, 15(7), e0236918. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0236918 hine, d. w., phillips, w., reser, j., cooksey, r., marks, a. d. g., nunn, p., ... & ellul, m. (2013). enhancing climate change communication: strategies for profiling and targeting australian interpretive communities (p. 95). gold coast, australia: national climate change adaptation research facility. retrieved from https://nccarf.edu.au/wpcontent/uploads/2019/03/hine_2013_enhancing_climate_change_communication.pdf iqbal, m., & zahidie, a. (2022). diffusion of innovations: a guiding framework for public health. scandinavian journal of public health. doi: 10.1177/14034948211014104 johnson, r. b., & onwuegbuzie, a. j. (2004). mixed methods research: a research paradigm whose time has come. educational researcher, 33(7), 14-26. doi: https://doi.org/10.3102/0013189x033007 kaesehage, k., leyshon, m., & caseldine, c. (2014). communicating climate change–learning from business: challenging values, changing economic thinking, innovating the low carbon economy. fennia-international journal of geography, 192(2), 81-99. retrieved from https://fennia.journal.fi/article/view/40867 leal filho, w., aina, y. a., dinis, m. a. p., purcell, w., & nagy, g. j. (2023). climate change: why higher education matters?. science of the total environment, 164819. . doi: http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.scitotenv.2023.164819 ledley, t. s., rooney-varga, j., & niepold, f. (2017). addressing climate change through education. in oxford research encyclopedia of environmental science. doi: https://doi.org/10.1093/acrefore/9780199389414.013.56 lyytimäki, j., nygrén, n. a., ala-ketola, u., pellinen, s., ruohomäki, v., & inkinen, a. (2013). climate change communication by a research institute: experiences, successes, and challenges from a north european perspective. applied environmental education & communication, 12(2), 118-129. doi: http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/1533015x.2013.821869 markowitz, e. m., & guckian, m. l. (2018). climate change communication: challenges, insights, and opportunities. in psychology and climate change (pp. 35-63). academic press. doi: https://doi.org/10.1016/b978-0-12-813130-5.00003-5 mccarthy, j., & citizen, g. (2020). understanding why climate change impacts women more than men. global citizen report 2020. retrieved from https://www.globalcitizen.org/en/content/how-climate-change-affects-women/ metag, j. (2016). content analysis in climate change communication. in oxford research encyclopedia of climate science. doi: https://doi.org/10.1093/acrefore/9780190228620.013.486 moser, s. c. (2010). communicating climate change: history, challenges, process and future directions. wiley interdisciplinary reviews: climate change, 1(1), 31-53. doi: https://doi.org/10.1002/wcc.11 moser, s. c. (2017). communicating climate change adaptation and resilience. in oxford research encyclopedia of climate science. doi: https://doi.org/10.1093/acrefore/9780190228620.013.436 european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/7425 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 57 muto, k., yamamoto, i., nagasu, m., tanaka, m., & wada, k. (2020). japanese citizens' behavioral changes and preparedness against covid-19: an online survey during the early phase of the pandemic. japan. doi: https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0234292 neal, b. (2016). tackling global issues for a better world. australian nursing & midwifery journal, 24(5), 13-13. pmid: 29250942 nash, n., capstick, s., whitmarsh, l., chaudhary, i., & manandhar, r. (2019). perceptions of local environmental issues and the relevance of climate change in nepal's terai: perspectives from two communities. frontiers in sociology, 4, 60. doi: https://doi.org/10.3389/fsoc.2019.00060 ozer, e. m. (2022). albert bandura (1925–2021). american psychologist, 77(3), 483–484. doi: https://doi.org/10.1037/amp0000981 pietrapertosa, f., salvia, m., hurtado, s. d. g., geneletti, d., d'alonzo, v., & reckien, d. (2021). multi-level climate change planning: an analysis of the italian case. journal of environmental management, 289, 112469. doi: 10.1016/j.jenvman.2021.112469 pulhin, j. m., & tapia, m. a. (2022). climate change adaptation in the philippines. climate change adaptation in southeast asia, 129-173. doi: 10.1007/978-981-16-6088-7_8 rakhmanov, o., & dane, s. (2020). knowledge and anxiety levels of african university students against covid-19 during the pandemic outbreak by an online survey. journal of research in medical and dental science, 8(3), 53-56. retrieved from https://www.jrmds.in/articles/knowledge-and-anxiety-levels-of-african-university-students-against-covid19-during-thepandemic-outbreak-by-an-online-survey-53399.html ricart, s., castelletti, a., & gandolfi, c. (2022). on farmers’ perceptions of climate change and its nexus with climate data and adaptive capacity. a comprehensive review. environmental research letters. doi 10.1088/1748-9326/ac810f sarathchandra, d., & haltinner, k. (2021). how believing climate change is a “hoax” shapes climate skepticism in the united states. environmental sociology, 7(3), 225-238. doi: https://doi.org/10.1080/23251042.2020.1855884 sedgwick, p. (2013). convenience sampling. doi:10.1136/bmj.f6304. doi: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.f6304 senathirajah, k., bonner, m., schuyler, q., & palanisami, t. (2023). a disaster risk reduction framework for the new global instrument to end plastic pollution. journal of hazardous materials, 449, 131020. doi: 10.1016/j.jhazmat.2023.131020 sharma, r., & tikka, s. k. (2020). covid-19 online surveys need to follow standards and guidelines: comment on “does covid-19 pandemic affect sexual behaviour? a cross-sectional, cross-national online survey” and “binge watching behavior during covid 19 pandemic: a cross-sectional, cross-national online survey”. psychiatry research, 290, 113173. doi: 10.1016/j.psychres.2020.113211 siedlecki, s. l. (2020). understanding descriptive research designs and methods. clinical nurse specialist, 34(1), 8-12. doi: 10.1097/nur.0000000000000493 siña, m., wood, r. c., saldarriaga, e., lawler, j., zunt, j., garcia, p., & cárcamo, c. (2016). understanding perceptions of climate change, priorities, and decision-making among municipalities in lima, peru to better inform adaptation and mitigation planning. plos one, 11(1), e0147201. doi: https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0147201 spence, a., poortinga, w., butler, c., & pidgeon, n. f. (2011). perceptions of climate change and willingness to save energy related to flood experience. nature climate change, 1(1), 46–49. doi:10.1038/nclimate1059 van houtven, c. h., drake, c., malo, t. l., decosimo, k., tucker, m., sullivan, c., ... & zullig, l. l. (2023). ready, set, go! the role of organizational readiness to predict adoption of a family caregiver training program using the rogers’ diffusion of innovation theory. implementation science communications, 4(1), 69. doi: https://doi.org/10.1186/s43058-02300447-x vulturius, g., davis, m., bharwani, s. (2016). building bridges and changing minds: insights from climate communication research and practice. stockholm environment institute. doi: 10.13140/rg.2.1.5020.5203 zainulbhai, h. (2015). women, more than men, say climate change will harm them personally. retrieved from https://www.pewresearch.org/short-reads/2015/12/02/women-more-than-men-say-climate-change-will-harm-thempersonally/ zaplan, c. m. d. (2023). napapanahong hustisya: examining the philippine climate change legal framework and establishing the legal basis for climate change litigation in the philippines. retrieved from https://libpros.com/wpcontent/uploads/2023/08/zaplan-clarisse-mae_dissertation.pdf zaval, l., & cornwell, f. j. (2017). effective education and communication strategies to promote environmental engagement: the role of social-psychological mechanisms. doi: https://doi.org/10.1111/ejed.12252 european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/11583 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 1 fundamental performance analysis of listed mutual fund companies in the dhaka stock md. saiful bari 1* and md. humayun kabir 2 1 department of finance, jagannath university, bangladesh e-mail: info.saifulbari@gmail.com orcid 0000-0002-8388-2787 2 department of international business, parul university, india e-mail: kabir.oit@gmail.com orcid 0009-0009-5613-3834 received: 21/01/2025 accepted for publication: 21/05/2025 published: 27/08/2025 abstract this study investigates the performance of closed-end mutual funds listed on the dhaka stock exchange over the period 2015 to 2023, emphasising the comparative dynamics before and after the covid-19 pandemic. employing a panel data framework, it analyses key financial metrics—return on investment (roi), standard deviation, beta, and sharpe ratio—to extract fund behaviour patterns under market stress and recover conditions. the results reveal heterogeneous performance trajectories: while several funds underperformed post-pandemic, others exhibited notable resilience and gains. these extracted insights underscore the critical importance of risk-adjusted returns in fund evaluation and strategic asset management. despite its strengths in longitudinal data coverage and quantitative rodrigue study is constrained by the absence of qualitative factors that could contextualise performance variations. keywords: mutual fund performance, closed-end mutual funds, fundamental factors, financial performance, operational performance mailto:info.saifulbari@gmail.com mailto:kabir.oit@gmail.com european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/11583 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 2 1. introduction the mysterious world of mutual funds casts a seductive attraction in bangladesh's maze-like financial landscape, particularly when examining the opaque world of closed-end mutual funds. nestled among the complex creases of the dhaka stock exchange, these thirty-two listed funds reveal a tapestry of performance nuances that beg to be unravelled. an unbalanced panel data study from 2015 to 2023 reveals its esoteric mysteries, unveiling an arcane symphony. the performance evaluation in this work unfolds into a tripartite complicated tapestry: overall efficacy, operational strength, and financial performance. financial performance, the ultimate in financial knowledge, is determined by a dizzying array of indicators, such as return on equity, investment, sales, profit margin, assets, earnings per share, stock price, and the turbulence of sales growth. operational prowess, that elusive ballet of efficiency, market share, and inventiveness, pirouettes in the shadows and whispers success secrets. moreover, total efficacy remains mysterious while serving as a stand-in for reputation, goal achievement, survival, and the ethereal quality of perceived performance. amateurs are lured to invest with mutual funds, those enigmatic means of generating money, among the turbulent waters of the investment world. it is necessary to first familiarise oneself with the two types of mutual funds available in bangladesh's market: open-ended and closed-ended. the first, like a chameleon, lets investors move freely through its constantly changing terrain, purchasing and disposing of units at will, whilst the second, a stable constellation in the financial sky, trades on the secondary market, unchanging yet alluring. investigating becomes the compass that leads the daring adventurer through this maze. examinations should be conducted based on performance history, investment strategy, management calibre, and fees. the key to solving each fund's riddles lies in the prospectus, a voluminous document full of occult information. diversification speaks its incantations as the secret of risk mitigation. to reduce risk and increase return, the seeker needs to diversify their wagers among a variety of asset classes and financial objectives. the symphony of voices that is the investing world extols diversity and balance. deciding from among the many options mutual funds provide takes thought. the alluring sounds of balanced funds, fixedincome securities, equity funds, and shariah-compliant investments beckon you in. each one has a unique melody that corresponds with the investor's objectives and desires. because they provide a plethora of investment alternatives that are beyond the means of the typical individual investor, mutual funds are appealing. how do the fundamental components of return on investment, actual deviation, standard deviation, beta computation, coefficient of variation, and regression analysis fit together to shape the performance of closed-end mutual funds listed on the dhaka stock exchange? one question sticks out like a lighthouse in the fog deep within this maze of confusion. how do the various facets of financial strength, operational flexibility, and the intangible attribute of overall success relate to these threads of complexity? this question, a riddle wrapped in an enigma, seeks to illuminate the shadowy areas and uncover the secrets that reside within bangladesh's financial systems. the pursuit of study has the prospect of shedding light on the opaque workings of mutual fund performance through diligent analysis. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/11583 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 3 2. literature review the signal theory serves as a beacon in the realm of investment dynamics, guiding the identification of crucial data that is critical to an investor's performance. this theory states that important signals are management disclosures, which are full of information on investors' welfare. these data can be presented in a variety of ways. it can display, among many other things, the growth in business profits, the decrease in expenses, the rise in share prices, the expansion of assets, and the rise in earnings per unit (epu). yuliza (2018) did a detailed investigation of the signal theory and found a substantial association between the positive eps and stock market volatility, as well as the tremendous influence of earnings per share (eps). an organisation that begins its metaphorical trip through the organismic life cycle reflects the ups and downs of human existence as well as the blossoming and withering of botanical lifeforms. there is a peak in time when profitability and productivity increase, and there will inevitably be a low point when they decrease. therefore, it is reasonable to claim that firm age and profitability have a substantially adverse connection. meanwhile, a fascinating inverse relationship develops between firm size and performance, with the former growing at the expense of the latter, as the research projects of ila boya & hookah (2016) shed light on the complex relationships between firm age, size, and profitability dynamics. james tobin, the nobel winner, presents an intriguing story about how a company's financial future depends critically on its managers' ability to balance investment spending while reducing the gap between capital costs. however, asset growth is a volatile phenomenon, with its importance fluctuating depending on the socioeconomic landscape, as evidenced by the disparate effects seen in established, developing, and underdeveloped areas. economic efficiency maxims extol the benefits of skilled management, assuming a mutually beneficial relationship in which fund managers, in their skilful stewardship, attract substantial returns, justifying fees extracted from investors' funds. experiential journeys sail the turbulent waters of bangladesh's dhaka stock exchange (dse), evaluating the performance and prospects of the sacred mutual funds nestled inside its embrace. a critical eye is trained on 32 closed-end mutual funds, with their financial stories painstakingly examined from the records covering 2015 to 2023. the absence of data for the 37 newcomers is bemoaned, serving as a sobering reminder of the gaps in the research landscape. the chorus of incompetent management, the scarcity of strong companies, and the lack of wise portfolio managers echo recurring themes in the tumultuous crucible of the bangladeshi stock market. furthermore, the turbulent landscape is made worse by investors' tendency to follow the siren call of direct investment techniques and flitting speculations rather than the steady march of long-term investments or the embrace of mutual funds. the culmination of the research is a symphony of policy recommendations that provide a picture of how the mystique surrounding larger mutual funds obscures the true nature of economies of scale, notwithstanding their apparent superior performance. the age of mutual funds is no longer a performance indicator, but rather a warning sign that points to the possibility of inefficiency and negative market conditions. policymakers should heed this caution and usher in a new era. moreover, investors are forced to look past the shortterm rippling and toward the horizon of sustained long-term performance, navigating the maze-like mutual fund market contours with wisdom and insight as the true gordian knot of asset growth untangles its mutually beneficial dance with fund performance significant but uncertain. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/11583 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 4 the shareholder theory is the term for this concept. instead, freeman and mcvea propose redefining the firm's objective by expanding the firm's purview to encompass the needs and desires of all major stakeholders. however, because they are not directly managing the firm, secondary stakeholders such as suppliers or customers can still have a collective influence over the business and its actions despite being external to it (alberton et al., 2022). the fundamental tenet of the stakeholder theory is that any company seeking to flourish must create value for each and every stakeholder, including suppliers, customers, employees, the community, and so forth. when they work together, they create something for which none of them is responsible alone (alberton et al., 2022). businesses have also been shown to benefit from stakeholder theory, as it enhances performance when consideration is given to all stakeholders rather than just shareholders (alberton et al., 2022). incorporating a stakeholder theory into business processes improves competitive advantage, claim lahouel et al. (2022). the findings showed that, particularly in the expansion of employee and customer relationships, stakeholder management generates increased operational productivity and competitive advantage (lahouel et al., 2022). without a doubt, this thesis's topic has something to do with the idea of stakeholder theory. the idea highlights how important it is that a wide range of stakeholders participate in an organisation's decision-making process. because mutual funds are by their very nature concerned with the effects of several stakeholders, including as suppliers, employees, and the general public, it is therefore related to this subject. the funds' resilience to the covid-19 financial crisis was also assessed. furthermore, given that mutual funds take shareholder requirements and preferences into account when making investment decisions, it will be fascinating to observe if they outperform traditional funds with low mutual fund scores. additionally, the idea can be used to explain changes in investment behaviour, particularly in times of financial crisis. investors may start to gravitate toward funds that share more of their ideals when it comes to taking responsibility for societal or environmental challenges. in late 2019 an outbreak of the coronavirus started in wuhan, china. because of its high infection rate, millions of people worldwide became infected with it as it spread quickly. millions of people also died as a result of the illnesses. according to bentes (2021), the virus had claimed the lives of almost 2.9 million people by april 2021. the economy was also affected by the virus's shockwave. governments implemented travel bans, social distancing, and lockdowns where people were not allowed to work in order to combat the daily spreads. due to the social economy's stop, there was a significant increase in uncertainty in the economy (bentes, 2021). unquestionably, the coronavirus has affected the industry, particularly the financial market. four market meltdowns occurred in less than two weeks in march 2020, and the market has become more risk averse since the disease began to spread in early march (gao et al., 2022). covid-19 was identified as the primary cause of the 2020 market meltdown because it had a greater impact on market volatility at the beginning of the spread. nevertheless, even though there were between 30,000 and 40,000 new instances of coronavirus every day, as the pandemic progressed, the stock market became more impervious to the shock (gao et al., 2022). european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/11583 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 5 3. methodology we take a deep dive into the world of risk and reward, carefully following the winding paths of return, standard deviation, and beta. our compass in this adventure of empirical investigation is provided by donaldson brown's profound insights into return, karl pearson's elaborate definitions of standard deviation, and jacques binet's complicated computations of beta. such a journey requires careful planning and exacting execution. the cornerstone of our technique is the rigorous validation of data completeness and accuracy, where each step is painstakingly calibrated to guarantee the authenticity of our conclusions. this study adopts a quantitative approach within a positivist paradigm, analysing the performance of 32 closed-end mutual funds listed on the dhaka stock exchange from 2015 to 2023. data were gathered from dse records and verified online sources. key indicators include: roi = (present price – past price) / past price standard deviation = √ (σ (xi x̅) ² / (n 1)) beta = covariance of fund return and market return / variance of market return sharpe ratio = (return – risk-free rate) / standard deviation statistical tools include descriptive statistics, z-tests, paired t-tests, f-tests, and regression analysis. these methods evaluate differences in fund performance across preand post-covid periods. ethical integrity was ensured by using only secondary, open-source data. 4. data analysis the study compares preand post-covid performance of 32 closed-end mutual funds using descriptive statistics and inferential methods. the mean return increased from 0.0527 to 0.3465, while the standard deviation decreased from 23.06 to 12.13, indicating lower volatility post-covid. beta remained consistent across both periods, suggesting systemic market risk was stable. significant changes were confirmed by z-tests (z = -3.44, p < 0.001) and paired t-tests (t = -3.12, p < 0.01), indicating covid19 materially altered fund performance. regression analysis revealed weak predictability of post-covid outcomes from precovid data (r² = 1.5%), likely due to market disruption and outliers. individual fund analysis showed mixed results—some demonstrated resilience, while others underperformed. these findings highlight the importance of fund-specific strategies, operational strength, and risk management practices. selecting a mutual fund entail striking a balance between return and risk, which is a difficult procedure that calls for careful consideration of several factors. the confusing ideas of burstiness and bewilderment stand out among them, weaving a complex and dynamic tapestry that accurately captures the financial landscape. beta (β), a metric amidst the mysteries of volatility, emerges from the tangle of financial jargon. the alchemy of regression analysis extracts its essence, serving as a compass to guide investors through the choppy waves of market dynamics. throughout this turbulent voyage, beta functions as a sentinel, protecting against systemic risk, the invisible monster that lurks in the shadows of the market. a beta of 1 represents a harmony european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/11583 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 6 akin to a symphony conducted by the unpredictable winds of the market, a balance carefully maintained on the brink of its turbulent tides. but explore beyond, where betas exceed unity, and one can see the wild, uncontrollably turbulent maelstrom. betas larger than one portend enormous wealth, but they also carry the risk of dangerous losses, akin to an unbridled prometheus. on the other hand, betas smaller than 1 provide safety in the calm waters of stability, but at the expense of eschewing the allure of extravagant profits. the warning of historical myopia, however, where the ghosts of previous performances haunt the present with their haunting whispers, is evident amid the chiaroscuro of financial indicators. with its hands tied to the chains of the past, beta might falter in its attempts at prophecy, a cassandra silenced by the relentless passage of time. now come to the stage, mutual fund company, a titan advancing through the sacred corridors of the dhaka stock exchange, a shining example of adaptability and perseverance in the face of difficulty. this titan of a company has forged a path through the harsh waters of market fluctuations, enduring the crucible of the pre-and post-covid eras. the mutual fund company, with its low mean return serving as a tribute to its unwavering resolve, was a pillar of stability in the pre-pandemic age. however, beneath the serene exterior, the ghost of variation murmured its seductive call, a warning of danger concealed beneath the veneer of peace. then came the flood, the covid era's apocalyptic upheaval that destroyed the old certainties. the mutual fund company rose like a phoenix from the ashes of uncertainty behind it, its mean return reaching new heights, demonstrating its resilience in the face of anarchy. statistical legerdemain illuminated the road to enlightenment by revealing the realities concealed in the archives of data. the significant differences between the eras were exposed by the f-test, a crucial crucible that attested to the turbulent currents of change. but beyond the gaudy statistics, there's the grim fact of practical reality. the pandemic's legacy was revealed by the ztest, arbitrator of means, as a story of unexpected changes and unknown territory. the crux of the matter can be found deep within the maze-like realm of numerical abstraction. in the middle of the noise of uncertainty, descriptive statistics act as a mapper's compass, guiding the tired traveller through the maze of data and highlighting the features of risk and reward. thus, heed the warning of the mutual fund company—a titan among the gods of finance—dear investor. the promise of wealth follows, supported by the possibility of peril; it's an age-old tale, yet one that is hopeful for salvation amidst uncertainty. this comprehensive analysis examines the intricate realm of mutual fund performance, dissecting the industry's fluctuations both before and following the disruptive covid-19 pandemic. this paper attempts to shed light on the intricate effects of the pandemic on mutual fund companies and their adaptable strategies in response to shifting market conditions through a detailed examination of important financial indicators like return, standard deviation, beta, and the venerable sharpe ratio. examining the maze of numbers, the pre-covid period mumbled about a fairly lacklustre showing, with an overall return of -0.1828 trailing the sector. but the pandemic's seismic wave fundamentally changed this story, sending the post-covid total return plummeting to an astonishing -0.6894. this painted a vivid picture of the industry's turbulent path through the pandemic's unwavering hold. when it came to market volatility, the pre-covid standard deviation was a relatively low 23.0607, indicating a market with relatively mild swings. however, as the epidemic lifted its shroud of uncertainty, the post-covid standard deviation fell sharply to 12.1299, providing an insight into a market environment characterised by muted volatility. amid the european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/11583 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 7 turbulent sea of market dynamics, the beta remained a beacon of stability, charting a steady trajectory before and after the covid-19 pandemic. this was in contrast to the industry, which saw gusts of change blow through it. the legendary sharpe ratio, which serves as a sentinel of risk-adjusted returns, appears to have escaped the pandemic's onslaught, with its pre-covid value of 1.5800 suggesting durable performance against a backdrop of declining returns in the performance of each company individually: through the maze of mutual fund companies, a diverse performance landscape emerges. while some industry veterans withstood the storm in a resilient manner, exhibiting some stability in their post-covid returns or controlling the wild market volatility, others withered in the pit of negative returns, unable to meet the daunting obstacles presented by the pandemicravaged market environment. the terrain is replete with anomalies flashing outrageous beta values, a reflection of their acute market sensitivity and the narrow rope they walk, walking between danger and gain. with its mysterious value of -0.967296649, the t-statistic is a silent guardian, providing insight into the observed mean differences between the two epochs. the critical values for the one-tailed and two-tailed tests, with 29 degrees of freedom (def.), are 1.699127027 and 2.045229642, respectively, revealing a maze of statistical nuances that direct the course of analysis. paired two sample t-test analysis: setting out on the tortuous path of statistical investigation, the paired two-sample t-test is revealed as the light-bearer, sent to solve the puzzles hidden in the data maze. its perceptive eyes cut through the clouds of doubt in an attempt to pick up on the minute differences between variables 1 and 2. delving deep into the significant zone, the p-values, released from the magic of statistical precision, reveal themselves as 0.170697018 for the one-tailed test and 0.341394036 for the two-tailed version. nevertheless, in the middle of the din of data, the conclusion is unchanging: the null hypothesis, a rock-solid bulwark of statistical equipoise, resists empirical inquiry. therefore, the data, despite its mysterious stories, is unable to provide the necessary proof that the means of variable 1 and variable 2 differ significantly, shrouding the field of statistical research in doubt. a small degree of entanglement between the two variables is shown by the pearson correlation value of 0.025247247, which suggests a delicate dance of influences where one pulls softly at the other. it threads through the information, implying a relationship as fragile as a breeze whispering on a peaceful summer's evening. this shaky connection implies that even while there is a slight resonance between changes in one variable and changes in the other, their harmony is still elusive and phantomlike. however, it wasn't clear from the paired two-sample t-test results how much variable 1 and variable 2 differed from each other. the study suggests that the gap in means could simply be the result of a random whim, shrugging off statistical indifference. in their quest for information, upcoming data explorers can find solace in delving into alternative fields of study. perhaps the fundamental cause of the event is concealed beneath unidentified conditions or causes and is just waiting to be found. researchers who have an open mind and a keen eye may uncover previously hidden facts beneath the layers of ambiguity and chance. moreover, employing a greater variety of statistical methods and bigger sample sizes might be the pillars of the european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/11583 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 8 enlightenment path. in the shadowy labyrinth of data analysis, these measures offer a glimmer of light, assisting the lost traveller in navigating the rough terrain of uncertainty and arriving at the elusive destination of comprehension. the paired sample t-test is a mysterious tool that shines in the complex world of statistical analysis and helps us navigate the maze of data comparison. a technique that is highly regarded for its ability to compare the means of two related samples. come with me as we take a deep dive into analysis, where numbers perform a meaningful ballet. look at the mighty mean, that illusive average, a momentary window into the core of variation. at 0.052666421, variable 1 shows its essence; at 0.404331756, variable 2 triumphantly stands tall. a sharp contrast, a discordant symphony on a canvas of variation. variable 2 roars with authority at 0.368718781, whereas variable 1 murmurs its secrets at a modest 0.000755124. thirty observations watch over this, serving as defenders of consistency. but behold, a story of entwined destinies surfaces as a correlation does. the pearson correlation, which is -0.321114365, is a negative indicator of inverse associations. in a subtle dance of conflicting forces, one variable rises while the other falls. step inside the hypothesis testing ring, where the t-statistic is king, a fighter in the significance war. a monument to the conflict of ideologies, -3.12384663 shows 29 degrees of freedom obscuring the battlefield. a one-tailed story is told, and p(t<=t) reveals its secrets: the probability is only 0.002013881, a probability that is murmured in extreme tones. the gatekeeper to the domain of significance, the t-critical, is 1.699127027. it is a sentinel of judgment. but hold on—a dual perspective and a one-two punch await. p(t<=t) reveals its other face, 0.004027763, a dualistic mirror image of great importance. at 2.045229642, the t critical looks upon the dichotomy as a judge in the statistical truth court. the analysis then reaches its dramatic conclusion, a momentous crescendo. the two-tailed p-value, 0.004027763, breaks beyond the alpha barrier at 0.05 and wins. a statistical truth beacon shines through the maelstrom of chance, and that is the difference in means. diverse are the eras examined and the performances themselves, but among them, all is an indisputable fact: there is a substantial difference in the mutual fund performance indicators. when it comes to delving into the complex world of statistical analysis, the paired sample t-test is the go-to technique for closely examining the performance—or more accurately, the mean returns—of two different sets of variables that are intricately linked to the workings of mutual funds. this is a summary of the statistical voyage that has been painstakingly extracted from the maze-like depths of the available data: see the mysterious mean return of variable 1, which is 0.052666421, in comparison to the captivating mean return of variable 2, which is 0.404331756. the variance of variable 1 seems to be playing tricks on the curious reader, with its secret meaning hidden in the number 0.000755124, while the variance of variable 2, which is the more powerful of the two, has a very intimidating face (0). but look! look, the pearson correlation, that enigmatic predictor of relationship subtleties, looks ghostly at the two variables and reveals an odd dance of -0.321114365. what magical mysteries are there in this numerical flirtation? statisticians are the only ones who dare to speculate. step inside the furnace of hypothesis testing, where speculation is put to the test in a serious rite of passage. it begged the question: does a big difference, a split between the two sets of variables, herald a story of different outcomes, a story of risk or performance differences, reverberating across mutual fund history and historical periods? european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/11583 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 9 key statistical findings tumble out of the cracks, completing the analysis's tapestry with a flourish: the degrees of freedom, that dreamy notion of freedom within limitation, remain steadfast at 29, a sentinel watching over the doors leading to knowledge. a statistically significant sentinel known as the t-statistic emerges from the crucible with the mark -3.12384663, an unwavering giant that heralds the beginning of disclosure. p-values, the enigmatic goblets of probability, entice with their mysterious contents: one tail murmurs 0.002013881, while the other reveals 0.004027763. both are cryptic cyphers that open doors to inference. t critical, that ethereal arbitrator of importance, looks down at the tired traveller: 1.699127027 and 2.045229642, the keepers of the boundaries between fate and chance, are revealed by one-tail. as a result, the scene comes to life, painting a meaningful story on the canvas of scientific investigation. the cry of discovery is heard clearly over the symphony of analysis: between variable 1 and variable 2, there is a gap that is hidden behind the ominous curtain of statistical significance. the two-tailed p-value, a sign of confidence, falls below the sacred 0.05 threshold, sending a strong message to the devout: the mean difference is not just the product of random variation. the discordant spectre, the negative t-statistic, illustrates the performance asymmetry: variable 1 yields to variable 2's strength, demonstrating the unpredictable and erratic nature of risk. but in the middle of the storm, there's a whisper of correlation 0.321114365 that carries through the analysis corridors, a modest relationship between mutual fund strength and strength. maybe a story of symbiosis, or the erratic dance of fortune, wrapped in the mysterious mystique of statistics. statistical analysis tells a story made of entwined strands of ambiguity and complexity. the performance of mutual funds is hidden deep within its maze-like depths, waiting to be discovered by the brave individual who wants to learn from the occult knowledge of empirical research. 5. result regression statistics weave a complex web that reveals a wealth of information about the interactions between preand postcovid variables. here, among the maze of information, we make our way through the halls of r square, that mysterious coefficient of determination, and examine the shadows it throws on predictability. however, what we see is a small slice, only 1.5% of the post-covid variation, calling to us from the heart of the pre-covid domain. the eerie atmosphere surrounding adjusted r square belies the peaceful coexistence of the model and data by revealing secrets of conflict. summary output a) regression statistics multiple r 0.120824368 r square 0.014598528 adjusted r square -0.01988423 european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/11583 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 10 standard error 0.952235081 observations 30 source: authors’ elaboration b) anova df ss ms f significance f regression 1 0.389567045 0.389567 0.429629 0.517521 residual 29 26.29579784 0.906752 total 30 26.68536489 source: authors’ elaboration c) pre. covid analysis coefficients standard error t stat p-value lower 95% upper 95% lower 95.0% upper 95.0% pre. covid 1.92515949 2.937107 122 0.655461 0.517337 -4.0819 7.932218 -4.0819 7.932218 source: authors’ elaboration it indicates a departure from the path of model fit, much like a wayward compass point in the wrong direction. the standard error, that phantom of uncertainty, reveals the divergence points in the regression line and tells tales of variance. its prominent place in this research points to a landscape full of irregular observations, each throbbing to the beat of their drum. f-statistic, the brave guardian of significance, greets one at the threshold of statistical inference. however, f-values and soaring p-values muffle its voice, suggesting that the model is having trouble explaining the variation that varies with the mean. pre-covid, perched on the brink of causation, proposes a universe where every unit increase indicates a marginal rise in the post-covid domain. we face the ghosts of previous predictions in the murky world of residual analysis. every step we take is haunted by residuals, those ghostly vestiges of unfulfilled prophecy that indicate the gap between observation and expectation. like sentinels atop the ramparts, standard residuals guard against the incursion of outliers. their uniform eyes cut through the data, revealing irregularities hidden beneath the surface. that elusive phantom, interpretation, dances on the brink of comprehension. low predictive capacity portends a future devoid of assurance, a sorrow murmuring through r square's breezes. nonsignificant coefficients cast doubt on the story the data tells by pointing to the weakness of causal relationships, much like european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/11583 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 11 shadows in the twilight. the terrain of our investigation is long shadowed by outliers, those mysterious beings hiding in the dark. their existence warps the structure of our model and causes ripples to cascade across the eddies of uncertainty, much like ripples upon a still pond. the holy grail of statistical analysis, model fit, eludes us like a puff of smoke on the wind. through the devastation of low r square, non-significant coefficients, and negative adjusted r square, we navigate the turbulent waters of data analysis like explorers in a sea of doubt. 6. discussion confidence intervals offer additional information beyond significance tests by showing how much the means differ from one another. a thorough explanation of the statistical analysis performed with the paired two-sample t-test is given in this paper. the results show that the means of the two variables under investigation do not significantly differ from one another. this talk presents a study of many mutual funds managed by different organisations, with a focus on two key financial factors during a specified period. making use of the excel data provided, an analysis was conducted using a paired two-sample t-test for means, comparing these two variables, designated as variable 1 and variable 2. the main goal of the analysis is to determine whether there is a statistically significant contradiction between the two variables, which could be indicative of different performance benchmarks or financial characteristics of the listed mutual funds. the investigation confirms that, at the 95% confidence level, the difference between variables 1 and 2 is not significant. this conclusion is reached because the bidirectional p-value of 0.341394036 exceeds the standard alpha level of 0.05. the stark difference in variance between the two variables suggests that variable 2 is significantly more volatile than variable 1. for risk-aware stakeholders, this piece of wisdom has significant importance as it highlights the tendency toward increased unpredictability present in the financial qualities or performance measures identified by variable 2. mutual fund statistical analysis reveals a notable difference in performance between two defined groups or periods. when making investing decisions, investors—especially those looking to diversify their portfolios or achieve higher returns—need to consider these facts. but it's important to remember that higher returns often translate into more risk. as a result, while selecting mutual funds, investors need to carefully consider their risk tolerance and investing goals. it is advised to conduct further in-depth research and speak with financial experts to fully understand the unique characteristics and risks connected to each mutual fund. the covid-19 epidemic has caused significant disruptions to the performance of mutual fund businesses; most have experienced a decline in returns and volatility. however, the risk-adjusted performance as measured by the sharpe ratio continues to be very stable. from this point on, mutual fund companies must adjust to the changing nature of the market and implement strong strategies to reduce risks and maximise returns for investors. the covid-19 pandemic marked a turning point in mutual fund performance in bangladesh. while average returns improved and volatility decreased post-covid, the regression results indicated that past data offered limited predictive value. this underscores the need for adaptive investment strategies that account for unexpected market shocks. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/11583 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 12 despite market-wide challenges, some funds managed to maintain or even enhance risk-adjusted returns, demonstrating the role of effective management and diversification. the sharpe ratio’s stability further supports the idea that certain funds sustained their performance through sound strategic decisions. policy recommendations include strengthening fund governance, increasing market transparency, and enhancing investor awareness. for investors, the study emphasises the use of both financial and operational metrics—beyond past performance—for fund evaluation. there is a resounding cry for policymakers to embrace these principles in defining the parameters of asset growth and dividend distribution that align with the fluctuations of the market environment. in addition, the discussion clarifies the mutual fund industry's early development in bangladesh concerning the larger capital market environment, highlighting the need for further support and investor education. in conclusion, by bridging gaps in understanding the synergy between fundamental determinants and mutual fund savvy, this academic expedition adds to the body of information regarding mutual funds in bangladesh. it provides a beacon of hope for both investors and policymakers, enabling them to exercise well-informed judgment and spur the development of the mutual fund industry inside bangladesh's capital market fabric. 7. conclusion in summary, this project has examined the nuances of closed-end mutual fund performance dynamics on the bangladeshi dhaka stock exchange in great detail. an in-depth investigation using unbalanced panel data analysis covering the period from 2015 to 2023 has explored fundamental aspects such as return on investment, standard deviation, actual deviation, beta calculation, coefficient of variation, and regression analysis, revealing their complex impact on mutual fund performance. the disclosures uncovered a plethora of significant relationships between these underlying variables and the numerous measures of mutual fund expertise. surprisingly, a positive correlation has been found between returns on assets and earnings per unit, while fund age and asset growth have an opposite relationship to return on assets. reading over the history of this analysis reveals that the pre-covid data may not be a reliable indicator of the mutual fund performance trajectory following covid. this is an insight that calls for more reflection and the possible addition of more variables to strengthen the model. in addition, consideration is given to the outliers, whose examination and possible correction may portend improved model alignment. this analysis broadens its scope by emphasising the importance of paying close attention to fund age, asset growth, and profitability when choosing mutual funds for investing purposes. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/11583 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 13 references adnan, a. t. m., & johani, s. a. (2023). stock market reaction to covid-19: a cross-sectional industry analysis in frontier market. iim kozhikode society & management review, 12(2), 157-181. bari, m. s. (2020). business communication challenge of small enterprises in bangladesh. international journal of business, management and economics, 1(1), 8-15. bari, m. s. (2020). the present state of the stock and economic growth perspective falling market bangladesh. american journal of economics and business management, 3(5), 428-440. bari, m. s. (2021). 21st century india and bangladesh between considering trade relation opportunities and challenges. jbfem, 4(1), 19-26. bari, m. s. (2021). role of insurance industry on economic challenges prospect growth in bangladesh. american journal of economics and business management, 4(1), 1-16. bari, m. s. (2023). economic crisis of bangladesh's rmg sector effect of government borrowing to meet the budget deficit. international journal of business and management (ijbm), 2(2), 46-58. dewri, l. v., & islam, m. r. (2016). performance of public mutual funds (pmfs) in emerging economies: a case of bangladesh. international journal of business and management, 11(6), 296. https://doi.org/10.5539/ijbm.v11n6p296 gazi, m. a. i., karim, r., senathirajah, a. r. b. s., ullah, a. m. m., afrin, k. h., & nahiduzzaman, m. (2024). bank-specific and macroeconomic determinants of profitability of islamic shariah-based banks: evidence from new economic horizon using panel data. economies, 12(3), 66. huang, w., wang, h., wei, y., & chevallier, j. (2024). complex network analysis of global stock market co-movement during the covid-19 pandemic based on intraday open-high-low-close data. financial innovation, 10(1), 7. jan, n., li, z., xiyu, l., farhan basheer, m., & tongkachok, k. (2022). pre-and post-covid-19: the impact of the pandemic and stock market psychology on the growth and sustainability of consumer goods industries. frontiers in psychology, 13, 796287. mishra, p. k., & mishra, s. k. (2022). stock markets' responses to covid-19 in developing countries: evidence from the saarc region. international journal of global environmental issues, 21(1), 59-81. usman, b., lestari, h. s., syofyan, s., & esya, l. (2024). exploring the relationship between dividend policy, the covid-19 crisis, and stock market reaction: empirical insights from indonesian real estate and property firms. cogent business & management, 11(1), 2302204. yuliza, a. (2018). the effects of earnings per share and firm size on stock price lq45 company listed in indonesian securities. international journal of engineering & technology, 7(4.9), 247 –249. https://doi.org/10.14419/ijet.v7i4.9.210 european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/11830 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 14 bridging social impact and lifecycle approaches for sustainable urban regeneration: an exploratory case study in italy lavinia pastore1*, luigi corvo 2, arda lelo3 1 università degli studi milano-bicocca, di.sea.de, piazza dell'ateneo nuovo 1, milano (italy) lavinia.pastore@unimib.it *contact author orcid 0000-0003-0510-694x 2 università degli studi milano-bicocca, di.sea.de, piazza dell'ateneo nuovo 1, milano (italy) luigi.corvo@unimib.it orcid 0000-0002-7230-9205 3 open impact research spin off of the università degli studi milano-bicocca, via nuoro 7, roma (italy) arda.lelo@openimpact.it received: 26/03/2025 accepted for publication: 11/08/2025 published: 27/08/2025 mailto:arda.lelo@openimpact.it european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/11830 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 15 abstract this study explores how integrating social impact assessment (sia) with lifecycle thinking can enhance urban regeneration outcomes by managing diverse stakeholder interests. a case study of a factory redevelopment in tuscany, italy, applies a novel analytical framework to map social, economic, and environmental value across project phases, examining patterns in outcome creation and stakeholder influence. the framework introduces an original combination of social return on investment (sroi), stakeholder salience, and temporal mapping, offering an integrated perspective on impact dynamics. specifically, this research addresses three questions: how sia methodologies contribute to stakeholder mediation in complex urban regeneration processes; what role timing plays in sia effectiveness as conflict-mediation tools; and how lifecycle thinking integration enhances sia effectiveness in urban regeneration projects. the study advances impact assessment with an integrated framework capturing complex social value dynamics and enhancing social sustainability in urban interventions. the analysis identifies 55 distinct outcome areas, revealing that employment outcomes dominate value creation (57%), while urban regeneration and viability (17%), sustainable community development (13%), economic growth (9%), and environmental outcomes (4%) contribute to a balanced multidimensional impact portfolio. findings demonstrate that stakeholder salience evolves significantly across project phases, and proactive sia application in early phases can reconcile divergent perspectives to maintain momentum. the integration of sia with lifecycle assessment enables comprehensive understanding of how different value forms interact and evolve temporally. this approach is adaptable to different urban and territorial settings, making it relevant for practitioners and policymakers engaged in diverse regeneration initiatives. the findings offer practitioners systematic tools to anticipate stakeholder conflicts, optimize multidimensional value creation, and embed social sustainability across regeneration lifecycles, ultimately improving urban intervention design and delivery. this approach enables effective stakeholder engagement promoting equitable benefit distribution, mitigating adverse impacts, and enhancing community resilience and well-being. the study's limitations include its single-case design and contextspecific focus on hotel conversion, which may limit transferability to other regeneration contexts and governance settings with different collaborative capacities. keywords: social impact assessment, urban regeneration, lifecycle thinking, stakeholder engagement, social sustainability european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/11830 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 15 1. introduction urban regeneration has emerged as a pivotal strategy in contemporary city development, signifying a shift from traditional expansion-based approaches to more intricate urban renewal and revitalisation processes. this transformation is especially pronounced in europe, where the 2014–2020 eu financial programming period explicitly prioritised rehabilitating existing urban spaces, including industrial sites and contaminated land (eu regulation no. 130/2013). the sector has undergone a fundamental metamorphosis, transitioning from a context centred on expansion to new challenges rooted in integration within the urban fabric and regeneration. despite the burgeoning recognition of social sustainability, which has spurred an emerging body of research and policy literature, our understanding of this concept remains nebulous and constrained by theoretical and methodological limitations stemming from its contextand disciplinary-dependent interpretations (colantonio & dixon, 2009). the urgency of addressing social sustainability through integrated and contextsensitive approaches is increasingly recognised in both policy and academic spheres, yet remains underexplored in terms of how methodological tools can operationalise this ambition across complex urban interventions (biondi & bracci, 2018; ragozino, 2019). established knowledge demonstrates the evolution of social impact assessment and its integration with stakeholder dynamics. since the 1990s, the advent of environmental impact assessment (eia) and subsequent social impact assessment (sia) has catalysed a new awareness of forecasting capabilities and the evidence provided by social and environmental impact analysts. the evolution of impact assessment tools has coincided with growing recognition of the complex relationships between urban development, environmental justice, and public health. wolch et al. (2014) demonstrate that urban regeneration projects must balance environmental improvements with community needs to avoid unintended social consequences. these tools have generated models that shift the focus to indicators encompassing economic, social, and environmental considerations. this aligns with emerson's (2003) 'blended value proposition', which emphasises the integration of social and financial metrics to maximise the value for all stakeholders. parallel to this evolution, hinson and ndhlovu (2011) show that organisations increasingly require structured approaches to evaluate their social impacts across multiple stakeholder groups and time horizons, as is evident in the development of corporate social responsibility measurements. urban regeneration projects are inherently complex interventions that require a comprehensive understanding of their impacts across different life cycle stages (sairinen, 2010). these projects frequently involve multiple stakeholders with divergent interests and expectations, rendering them potential theatres of conflict. arvidson et al. (2013) posit that social impact can be conceived as a genuine social construction that effectively opens it to the interpretation and subjectivity of the categories under analysis. this understanding becomes pivotal when considering the impact value chain framework proposed by clark et al. (2004), which emphasises the need to map and involve not only internal organisational actors but also stakeholders at various levels who see their status quo being altered by specific interventions. europe has embraced urban regeneration as a winning model of economic development, wherein new 'urban alliances' revitalise cities capable of reinventing themselves, optimising their human, social, economic, environmental, and historical capital, 'becoming true and their own resilient cities' (ben-akiva et al., 2016; toledo et al., 2010). european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/11830 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 16 the evolution of social return on investment (sroi) methodologies highlights their utility in the urban regeneration context. developed initially to evaluate nonprofit initiatives (emerson, 2003), sroi frameworks have matured into versatile tools for assessing blended value, encompassing economic, social, and environmental dimensions across various sectors. recent reviews (corvo et al., 2022) underscore sroi's potential to enhance stakeholder engagement by monetising social impacts, while addressing methodological critiques such as over-reductionism and subjectivity. when applied to urban regeneration, sroi analysis facilitates identifying both tangible and intangible benefits, offering insights into the equitable distribution of value and fostering community resilience. moreover, advancements in impact measurement approaches have introduced mechanisms to better manage power asymmetries and stakeholder salience in multi-actor contexts (mitchell et al., 1997; saenz, 2020; saenz, 2021). these innovations align with lifecycle thinking by mapping impact trajectories across phases such as planning, implementation, and use. wang et al. (2022) demonstrate how dynamic stakeholder relationships can be systematically analysed over the life cycle of urban regeneration projects through social network analysis (sna), offering actionable insights into power shifts, centrality, and coordination challenges. critical gaps emerge in three interconnected areas that limit current sia effectiveness. first, integration challenges persist: many existing tools remain siloed, unable to offer a comprehensive view of impact evolution across time or to address stakeholder conflicts that emerge at different project stages (arli & cadeaux, 2014; sairinen, 2010). the existing literature rarely integrates impact valuation with stakeholder salience analysis and lifecycle mapping in a single coherent framework, especially in applied urban contexts (saenz, 2020; bryson et al., 2024). second, temporal dynamics remain underexplored: sroi alone cannot capture the temporal shifts in stakeholder salience or the dynamic layering of impacts typical of complex urban initiatives (nicholls, 2018; grana et al., 2025). critical questions remain regarding how impact measurement can be structured to support complex adaptive processes, especially in terms of stakeholder dynamics over time (mitchell et al., 1997; bailey, 2012). third, the timing of sia implementation as conflict-mediation mechanism requires deeper understanding. sia's potential role in managing environmental conflicts was noted years ago by manring et al. (1990), who emphasised its importance in predicting and managing conflicts while promoting social sustainability (becker & vanclay, 2003). a critical gap persists in understanding how the timing and implementation of sia tools influence their effectiveness as conflictmediation mechanisms in urban regeneration contexts. insights from corporate community involvement research further reveal the challenges in measuring social impact owing to resource constraints, a lack of consensus on methodologies, and stakeholder salience issues (arli & cadeaux, 2014). while the existing literature acknowledges stakeholder engagement's importance in urban regeneration (bailey, 2012; biancone et al., 2019), limited attention has been paid to how impact assessment methodologies can be adapted to better serve the complex needs of these projects across their lifecycle. the strategic management-at-scale framework proposed by bryson et al. (2024) becomes particularly relevant here, as it recognises that no single entity is fully in charge of these complex multi-stakeholder contexts, yet many are affected, involved, or have a partial responsibility to act. the literature confirms the possibility of sustainable urban regeneration projects at several levels. these are primarily attributed to the ability of these projects to radically european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/11830 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 17 transform places in terms of development opportunities, and the proactive capacity that key actors can offer in decision-making dynamics, often acting as mitigators between different issues related to each stakeholder category (bailey, 2012; biondi & bracci, 2018; ragozino, 2019). this potential is further amplified by integrating advanced stakeholder salience frameworks and lifecycle impact mapping to address the shifting power dynamics and long-term value creation (saenz, 2020). despite these advancements, no unified approach currently exists to integrate sroi, stakeholder salience, and lifecycle mapping in a single evaluative model tailored for urban regeneration (grieco et al., 2015; arena et al., 2015). to address this, more integrated frameworks are needed, capable of anticipating and managing stakeholder tensions while tracing how value is constructed and distributed over time (clark et al., 2004; bryson et al., 2024). the proposed theoretical gap can be visualized as the intersection of three methodological silos: impact valuation approaches that lack temporal dynamics, stakeholder engagement methods without systematic value measurement, and lifecycle assessment frameworks that underemphasize social dimensions. this study addresses these gaps by examining how an enhanced sia framework that incorporates lifecycle thinking and stakeholder dynamics contributes to both impact measurement and conflict mediation in urban regeneration processes. through an in-depth case study of a regeneration project in tuscany, italy, we investigate three specific research questions: 1. how can sia methodologies contribute to stakeholder mediation in complex urban regeneration processes? 2. what role does timing play in the effectiveness of sia as conflict-mediation tools in urban regeneration projects? 3. how does the integration of lifecycle thinking into sia enhance its effectiveness in urban regeneration projects? the remainder of this paper is organised as follows. first, we present a theoretical framework that integrates perspectives on urban regeneration, sias, and life cycle thinking. we then introduce our enhanced methodological approach, which combines traditional sroi analysis with lifecycle assessment elements. the case study analysis demonstrates the application of this framework in a real-world context, followed by a discussion of the implications of both theory and practice in urban regeneration impact assessments. 2. theoretical background strategy management at scale provides the foundational theoretical framework for understanding urban regeneration complexity. urban regeneration challenges have increasingly transcended traditional organisational boundaries, requiring a shift from conventional strategic management approaches to more collaborative and systemic frameworks. bryson et al. (2024) argued that these challenges necessitate 'strategy management at scale', an approach that recognises that while no single entity is in charge, many are affected, involved, or bear partial responsibility to act. this approach highlights the need for collective leadership and system-level thinking to address complex multi-stakeholder dynamics (bryson et al., 2024; crosby & bryson, 2005). this complexity manifests through diverse stakeholders operating across spatial and temporal scales, creating opportunities and tensions (ansell et al., 2024). biancone et al. (2019) highlight the 'proactive capacity' of key actors, emphasising the need european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/11830 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 18 for collaboration even in the absence of formal authority while healey (2006) argues for new forms of collective governance in fragmented contexts. these contributions establish that urban regeneration governance must be multi-actor, temporally aware, and capable of embedding diverse value frameworks into its evaluation logics. resource activation and performance measurement theory offer solutions but face integration challenges. strategy management relies on activating underutilised resources across physical, financial, social, and political domains (bailey, 2012), aligning with biondi and bracci (2018), who demonstrate how cross-sector partnerships can generate synergistic values that exceed the capabilities of individual entities. saenz (2020) and saenz (2021) further underscore the importance of lifecycle thinking in urban regeneration, arguing that integrating the planning, implementation, and post-completion phases enhances both impact measurement and stakeholder engagement. however, integrating these elements into coherent evaluative frameworks remains underdeveloped, though arena, azzone, and bengo (2015) propose a performance measurement system for social enterprises that aligns managerial intentions, stakeholder participation, and hybrid value creation logics. stressing the contextual construction of indicators and cautions against universalistic metrics detached from organisational purpose. implementation challenges reveal significant limitations in current approaches. large-scale implementation faces challenges requiring adaptive frameworks for shifting stakeholder dynamics. mill and holland (2005) argue sia methods must move beyond simplistic metrics to capture the complex interplay between stakeholder interests and project outcomes. while sager (2016) identifies power asymmetries as barriers to effective collaboration, and ragozino (2019) notes difficulties in sustaining stakeholder engagement over extended project lifecycles. these challenges underscore the need for robust governance mechanisms capable of adapting to dynamic stakeholder landscapes while maintaining progress toward shared objectives (bryson et al., 2024). social impact assessment theory has evolved but suffers from methodological fragmentation. sia and eia have evolved by introducing advanced methodologies for forecasting and evaluating impacts. traditional sroi models, while useful, often lack the integration of life cycle thinking and systemic changes necessary for modern urban regeneration (nicholls, 2017; yate & marra, 2017). nicholls (2018) critically reframes social impact accounting, interpreting it as a situated and contested process rather than neutral representation. he foregrounds the role of accounting in defining what counts as valuable and for whom, pointing to the importance of embedding materiality, uncertainty, and empowerment into impact frameworks. this perspective challenges reductionist sroi applications and supports reflexive, stakeholder-sensitive measurement logics, challenging reductionist applications and supporting reflexive, stakeholder-sensitive measurement logics. social life cycle assessment (slca) methodologies offer systematic approaches for evaluating social impacts throughout project lifecycles that align with these collaborative governance requirements. jørgensen et al. (2008) identified slca as an emerging framework for assessing social and socio-economic aspects of products and systems across their entire life cycles, though they noted significant methodological diversity and limited consensus regarding appropriate indicators and boundaries. this methodological fragmentation reflects the complexity of social impact measurement in multi-stakeholder contexts (van der veen et al., 2025). contemporary slca applications demonstrate both potential and limitations: while slca can effectively quantify certain social impacts such as working conditions and economic development contributions, it often fails to capture more nuanced contextual factors including cultural dynamics, power relations, and structural policy influences (van european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/11830 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 19 der veen et al., 2025). bhatnagar et al. (2024) emphasise that transitioning to circular economy approaches through slca requires enhanced stakeholder involvement across industries to identify emerging social risks, suggesting the need for methodological innovations that bridge quantitative assessment with qualitative stakeholder engagement. mixed-method approaches in regeneration processes provide promising directions for addressing these methodological gaps. premyanov et al. (2024) demonstrate how combining quantitative metrics with qualitative stakeholder engagement through participatory research can enhance understanding of circular economy impacts on urban sustainability. their study of makerspaces as catalysts for circular entrepreneurship illustrates how mixed-method frameworks can capture both measurable outcomes (such as skill development and network formation) and more intangible benefits (including community engagement and environmental awareness). these findings suggest that urban regeneration assessments benefit from methodological pluralism that integrates systematic quantitative measurement with contextual qualitative insights. empirical evidence confirms persistent methodological fragmentation. grieco, michelini, and iasevoli (2015) map the heterogeneity of social impact assessment models used by social enterprises, identifying three dominant clusters based on purpose (managerial vs. accountability), stakeholder engagement, and methodological depth. highlighting the absence of frameworks that integrate stakeholder salience, lifecycle dynamics, and value quantification, they further reinforcing the originality of the model presented in this paper. recent empirical applications demonstrate this fragmentation: tate et al. (2023) use sroi showing data limitations, attribution challenges, and temporal complexity that undermine impact appraisal. wang et al. (2022) apply social network analysis surfacing fluidity of power and legitimacy over time, and bottero et al. (2018) apply promethee multicriteria decision analysis. these studies reveal fragmentation where each focuses on one aspect— monetised outcomes, stakeholder configuration, or multi-criteria trade-offs—without unifying them into an integrated framework. toward theoretical integration through composite frameworks. this paper seeks to fill that gap by developing a composite evaluative approach that systematically brings together social value measurement (via sroi), stakeholder salience theory, and lifecycle mapping to capture the distributed nature of impact creation in regeneration processes. this evolution aligns with the conceptualisation of social impact as a social construct (arvidson et al., 2013). combined with saenz's (2021) outcome mapping framework that integrates stakeholder analysis with lifecycle stages, such approaches bridge methodological fragmentation while strengthening the governance of transformation. stakeholder salience theory adds temporal complexity requiring adaptive frameworks. the dynamic nature of stakeholder salience, as outlined by mitchell et al. (1997), complicates urban regeneration, where shifting priorities necessitate adaptive engagement strategies (biancone et al., 2019), while trust-building and inclusive governance address these shifting dynamics (corvo et al., 2022). recent advancements in lifecycle assessment methodologies (ciroth et al., 2011; saenz, 2020 and saenz, 2021) provide valuable tools for aligning stakeholder activities with sustainable outcomes, facilitating deeper understanding of how urban regeneration projects affect economic, social, and environmental systems over time. arli and cadeaux (2014) highlight european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/11830 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 20 persistent challenges of measuring community involvement impacts, stressing the need for cohesive frameworks that address stakeholder salience and resource allocation. theoretical synthesis demonstrates the necessity for integrated evaluation approaches. ultimately, strategy management at scale offers a robust framework for addressing urban regeneration complexities. by integrating collective leadership, adaptive governance, and lifecycle thinking, this approach helps navigate power dynamics and competing interests that define urban regeneration while fostering resilient and inclusive urban environments. figure 1. integrated sia framework source: authors’ elaboration 3. methodology this study employed a revelatory single-case study design to investigate the role of sia in mediating stakeholder dynamics within an urban regeneration project in tuscany, italy. case study designs are well-suited for examining complex social phenomena in real-world contexts, particularly when the boundaries between a phenomenon and its context are not clearly defined (yin, 2017). single-case studies offer an opportunity for an in-depth, holistic investigation of contemporary events, european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/11830 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 21 enabling the development of rich, context-specific insights (eisenhardt, 1989; eisenhardt & graebner, 2007; siggelkow, 2007). the case was chosen for its potential to yield insights into the intricate web of multi-stakeholder interactions and temporal processes that characterise urban regeneration interventions (zhou et al., 2018). the methodological framework integrates three complementary analytical lenses to capture the multidimensional nature of social impacts on urban regeneration. these lenses were applied sequentially: sroi was implemented during the initial project phase (ex-ante) in alignment with its first principle (“involve stakeholders”). to guide this step, stakeholder salience analysis was conducted to map influence patterns and inform materiality assessment. temporal impact mapping was introduced only after the outcome framework and first sroi evaluation had been completed, in order to track the evolution of outcomes over time. each lens informed the others in a recursive manner: stakeholder salience helped refine outcome selection for the sroi, while the temporal mapping captured the progression and interdependencies of those outcomes across the project lifecycle. 1. sroi analysis: sroi analysis provides the foundational framework for mapping and quantifying the social, environmental, and economic value generated by the project across stakeholder groups and project phases (cordes, 2017; nicholls, 2017, 2018). this forward-looking approach involves mapping stakeholder networks, identifying anticipated outcomes, developing financial proxies, applying adjustment factors, and calculating the projected social return ratios. the analysis adheres to established sroi principles, while innovatively integrating lifecycle thinking to examine how different forms of value emerge, interact, and evolve over the course of the intervention (saenz, 2021). proxies were selected through a validated internal database and discussed with stakeholders using available contextual data. this database, developed through systematic analysis of international sroi applications, serves as a benchmark repository of validated impact chains and financial proxies across multiple sectors. indicator selection was based on relevance to urban regeneration contexts, availability of contextual data, and stakeholder validation. sroi was applied to the design phase of the project, using both project documentation and interviews to estimate outcome occurrence and intensity. 2. stakeholder salience analysis: stakeholder analysis, grounded in mitchell et al.’s (1997) power-legitimacy-urgency framework, examines how influence patterns and power dynamics shape project trajectories. the analysis categorises stakeholders based on their salience attributes, maps influence relationships and decision-making processes, tracks shifts in stakeholder salience across project phases, identifies points of tension requiring mediation, and informs them of the development of targeted engagement strategies (neville et al., 2011). the stakeholder set was identified through project documentation and expanded through interviews with the project lead. salience categories were used to prioritise actors during the outcome identification phase and to map tensions requiring mediation. 3. temporal impact mapping: building on saenz’s (2021) matrix innovation, this novel framework examines the evolution of stakeholder experiences and outcomes across project lifecycles. the mapping process plots stakeholder groups against four key development phases (awareness, implementation, use, and closure); monitors impact trajectories across social, economic, and environmental dimensions; documents changes in value creation patterns; european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/11830 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 22 pinpoints critical intervention opportunities; and reveals temporal interdependencies between outcomes. outcome trajectories were plotted against the timeline using a structured excel grid combining a simplified project schedule with identified outcomes and stakeholder groups. the mapping helped highlight moments of convergence or divergence in perceived value and supported identification of “impact tipping points. the data were collected from two sources. first, extensive document analysis was conducted, encompassing project plans, reports, media coverage, and other archival data related to the project’s design evolution, stakeholder responses, and implementation processes. second, the research team engaged directly with the architectural firm leading the project to gain first-hand insights into decision-making dynamics and stakeholder interactions (ravitch & carl, 2021). these engagement sessions followed a semi-structured protocol focusing on stakeholder identification, outcome mapping, and project timeline validation. sessions were conducted with project representatives to gather insights into stakeholder influence patterns, decisionmaking processes, and anticipated project outcomes across different phases. the three lenses were supported by different types of data: sroi was informed by financial estimates, outcome indicators, and social proxy databases; stakeholder salience relied on qualitative interviews and internal documents and stakeholder categorization using mitchell et al.'s (1997) framework was conducted through systematic document analysis complemented by validation with project representatives, with each stakeholder's power, legitimacy, and urgency attributes assessed based on project documentation and observed influence patterns;; temporal mapping used the project timeline and evaluation outputs to structure expected outcome flows. to ensure reliability and internal validity, two researchers independently analysed the qualitative material and triangulated the coding of outcome definitions, salience attributes, and temporal sequences. the coding process was conducted manually, with researchers developing a structured framework aligned with the three analytical lenses. coding categories were refined through iterative discussion until consensus was reached. regular peer debriefings were conducted with the third researcher and the full project team to reach consensus and refine interpretations. member checking was carried out with the lead proponent of the project, who reviewed and validated intermediate results, particularly the reconstructed stakeholder map and proxy structure. triangulation was applied systematically across documentary, interview, and contextual data. the analytical process followed an iterative cyclical approach (mills et al., 2010), with each analytical lens informing the others in a layered and reciprocal manner. this methodological approach aligns with recent developments in social responsibility research. obalola and adelopo (2012) demonstrate the effectiveness of narrative-inductive approaches for understanding complex social phenomena and stakeholder dynamics in urban contexts. this methodology enables a systematic investigation of how sia surfaces and mediates stakeholder concerns, identifies optimal intervention points for conflict mitigation, and demonstrates the value of integrating lifecycle thinking into impact assessment processes. the revelatory single-case study design has inherent limitations in terms of generalisability (yin, 2017). however, as flyvbjerg (2006) argues, carefully selected case studies can provide context-dependent knowledge crucial for understanding complex social phenomena and testing theoretical propositions in real-world settings. this may offer a valuable window into the complex stakeholder landscapes that must be negotiated in urban regeneration projects, generating insights that inform both theory european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/11830 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 23 development and practice (flyvbjerg, 2006). although the findings remain context-specific, the clarity of analytical procedures, iterative validation, and multi-source triangulation contribute to their internal consistency and transparency. moreover, by integrating sroi analysis, stakeholder salience assessment, and temporal impact mapping, this approach responds to the growing need for more robust governance frameworks to address the turbulent, boundary-spanning challenges increasingly faced by public and nonprofit organisations (bryson et al., 2015). in these contexts, defined by diffuse authority and shared responsibility, fostering strategic alignment and commitment among diverse stakeholders is critical (bryson et al., 2024). by bringing a strategy management-at-scale perspective to sia, this methodology aims to generate actionable insights into navigating complex multi-stakeholder dynamics and enhancing the public value of urban interventions. 4. the case study this case study focuses on an urban regeneration project in the tuscany region of northern italy. the project involved converting an abandoned factory into a tourist hotel, constructing new road connections, and revitalising the surrounding green spaces near a port. the development site covers approximately 22,575 square meters, with an estimated investment of €43,202,687. the company leading the project had the vision of creating a hotel that exemplifies sustainability principles and minimises the environmental footprint of both the building itself and its future operations. to achieve this, the company committed to using eco-friendly renewable materials and implementing state-of-the-art systems for energy efficiency, water conservation, and environmental stewardship. a central aspect of the project is the comprehensive monitoring of energy consumption, water usage, traffic flows, and greenspace impacts. the sustainability plan includes installing solar panels onsite to meet a significant portion of the hotel’s energy needs. the company also aims to minimise electricity consumption and waste through advanced lighting, ventilation, and infrastructure systems. to further enhance the project’s environmental performance, the design incorporates large-scale rainwater collection and management. this integrated approach seeks to optimise water resource use while reducing pressure on local water supplies. the project's origins date back to 2015, marking the start of a complex, multiyear process that exemplifies the lengthy timelines often associated with transformative urban redevelopment. the initial phase, from 2015 to 2023, involved intensive planning, stakeholder engagement, and regulatory compliance. this extended preliminary period aligns with the critical early stage identified by urban development scholars as essential for building social licence and institutional support. the project’s chronological progression can be understood through four key phases. 1. initial development (2015–2023): concept development, preliminary investor engagement, initial stakeholder consultations, drafting of architectural and environmental plans, and emergence of environmental opposition and legal challenges. 2. planning and approval (2023–2024): refinement of project scope to the current 30-room configuration, integration of enhanced sustainability features, intensive stakeholder dialogue and plan modifications, and navigation of regulatory requirements and environmental assessments. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/11830 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 24 3. implementation (2024–2026 planned): site preparation and demolition is scheduled for winter 2024, construction is planned for 2025–2026, progressive implementation of environmental management systems, and staged infrastructure development. 4. operations (projected from 2027 onwards): anticipated hotel opening in the summer of 2027, ongoing environmental monitoring, community engagement programs, and long-term value creation. this multiyear timeline offers valuable insights into the realities of complex urban regeneration. this illustrates how initial concepts must evolve significantly in response to stakeholder inputs and regulatory processes. the project's eight-year journey from initial vision to implementation approval highlights the importance of ‘temporal resilience’; that is, the ability to maintain development momentum while adapting to emerging stakeholder concerns and regulatory requirements. the project's present status represents a pivotal point at which conceptual plans must be translated into concrete actions. the legal challenges initiated by environmental groups have acted not only as hurdles but also as catalysts for strengthening the project's green building credentials and stakeholder engagement. this dynamic shows how opposition can ultimately bolster urban regeneration efforts by compelling a deeper consideration of sustainability priorities and community needs. the planned implementation timeline from 2024 to 2027 reflects an ambitious but well-structured approach to project execution. this schedule was designed to balance efficient progress while minimising disruption to the surrounding community. the phasing strategy aligns with urban regeneration best practices, where careful sequencing helps manage stakeholder expectations and optimises the impact over both the short and long term. in summary, this case study offers a representative example of a complex stakeholder landscape and extended timelines that characterise major urban regeneration projects. this demonstrates how sustainability, community engagement, and regulatory compliance intertwine to shape project outcomes. as the initiative moves from planning to implementation, it will continue to offer valuable insights into the challenges and opportunities of transformative urban redevelopment. 5. findings the analysis of the tuscany urban regeneration project applies three integrated analytical frameworks: sroi analysis, stakeholder salience assessment, and temporal impact mapping based on saenz’s matrix. these frameworks reveal the intricate dynamics of social value creation, evolution, and distribution across the life cycle of urban regeneration interventions. by combining quantitative measurement, stakeholder influence mapping, and lifecycle-based outcome analysis, the findings highlight the interplay between multi-stakeholder collaboration and the mechanisms underpinning sustainable urban transformation. this integrated analysis directly addresses the study's three research questions by demonstrating how sia methodologies facilitate stakeholder mediation (rq1), revealing the critical role of timing in sia effectiveness (rq2), and illustrating how lifecycle integration enhances sia performance in urban regeneration contexts (rq3). the sroi analysis identifies 55 distinct outcome areas supported by 57 indicators and 59 financial proxies, underscoring the multidimensional nature of value creation. this granular approach maps the direct and indirect impacts across stakeholder european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/11830 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 25 groups and project phases. the project’s projected social value amounted to €66,225,518 from an initial investment of €43,202,687, yielding an sroi of 1.53. this ratio suggests that for every euro invested, the project generates €1.53 in social value, adjusted for critical factors, such as deadweight, attribution, and drop-off. this comprehensive value mapping demonstrates how sia methodologies contribute to stakeholder mediation (rq1) by providing a common framework for understanding diverse impact expectations across stakeholder groups. table i. outcome types and distribution type percentage key characteristics hard 36% quantitatively measurable changes (employment figures, infrastructure development) soft 33% qualitative improvements (community cohesion, stakeholder relationships) cashable 31% direct financial value or cost savings (operational efficiencies, revenue generation) source: authors’ elaboration table i summarises the distribution of outcomes across three typologies using the oxford go lab framework: hard (36%), soft (33%), and cashable (31%), reflecting a balanced approach to urban regeneration. hard outcomes capture quantifiable and measurable impacts, including employment generation, infrastructure development, and energy consumption reduction, providing concrete evidence of economic and physical contributions. soft outcomes encompassed qualitative improvements, such as enhanced community cohesion, strengthened stakeholder relationships, and improved public space perceptions, illustrating a project’s ability to foster social capital and collaborative networks. cashable outcomes signify direct financial benefits, including cost savings, revenue generation, and increased property values, aligned with the fiscal sustainability goals for both public and private stakeholders. this balanced distribution across outcome types reveals how integrated sia approaches address heterogeneous stakeholder expectations, facilitating mediation by acknowledging diverse value perspectives within a single evaluative framework. the coexistence of soft and cashable outcomes reflects the project’s capacity to address heterogeneous stakeholder expectations, though it also raises questions about the visibility and prioritisation of social impacts when measured alongside financial indicators (nicholls, 2018). the analysis also revealed five macro-outcome areas, each representing a distinct contribution to the project’s overall impact. table ii illustrates this distribution: employment outcomes were dominant, constituting 57% of the total impact. these include direct job creation within hotel operations, indirect employment through supply chain development, and skill enhancement programs designed to improve local workforce capacities. urban regeneration & viability (17%) reflect physical and spatial improvements, such as enhanced pedestrian pathways, sustainable transport solutions, and upgraded traffic management systems. sustainable community outcomes (13%) capture the project’s impact on social cohesion and well-being as evidenced https://golab.bsg.ox.ac.uk/toolkit/technical-guidance/setting-measuring-outcomes/ european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/11830 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 26 by expanded recreational spaces, community-driven programs, and strengthened local networks. economic growth outcomes (9%) include market stimulation, tourism revenue generation, and business development initiatives. although environmental outcomes accounted for only 4%, their strategic integration amplified sustainability efforts through renewable energy installations, rainwater-harvesting systems, and biodiversity enhancements, thereby linking environmental stewardship to broader social and economic objectives. table ii. distribution of macro outcome areas area frequency primary impact indicators employment 57% job creation, skill development, local economic participation urban regeneration & viability 17% infrastructure development, spatial connectivity sustainable community 13% social cohesion, community engagement economic growth 9% business development, market activity environment 4% environmental protection, sustainability initiatives source: authors’ elaboration this asymmetry between environmental and employment-related outcomes reflects a common trade-off in regeneration efforts: economic imperatives tend to dominate in early implementation phases, potentially overshadowing long-term environmental commitments (ciroth et al., 2011; bottero et al., 2018). this temporal imbalance illustrates the critical importance of timing in sia effectiveness (rq2): early-phase stakeholder engagement prioritised employment concerns, shaping the overall value distribution and demonstrating how the timing of sia application influences which outcomes receive emphasis. the crossanalysis between sroi outcomes and stakeholder dynamics reveals how different value types align with stakeholder power configurations. stakeholder salience analysis guided by mitchell et al.’s (1997) framework revealed the complex power dynamics and evolving roles of key actors. project development companies have emerged as definitive stakeholders, leveraging their substantial investment capacity (€43,202,687), regulatory legitimacy, and project timelines to shape outcomes across dimensions. municipal authorities and regional governments acted as dominant stakeholders, exercising influence through regulatory oversight and democratic mandates and ensuring alignment with public infrastructure and accessibility goals. environmental agencies, also classified as dominant stakeholders, have extended their roles beyond regulatory enforcement to proactive advocacy for sustainability, shaping outcomes such as greenspace preservation, energy efficiency, and biodiversity protection. this stakeholder configuration directly correlates with the sroi outcome distribution: definitive stakeholders (development companies) drove employment outcomes (57% of total impact), while dominant stakeholders (municipal and environmental authorities) influenced infrastructure and environmental outcomes, demonstrating how stakeholder salience determines impact materialization. table iii presents the full stakeholder categorisation. this layered configuration of power european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/11830 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 27 and legitimacy underscores how stakeholder positioning directly affects which impacts materialise, and how priorities evolve in contested phases of project implementation. table iii. stakeholders according to salience mode. stakeholders role power legitimacy urgency salience level category private company created for the project by an international investment company investor x x x on hold definitive municipalities enabler x x on hold dominating residents target x latent applicants hotel guests target x latent applicants hotel employees workers x latent applicants tuscany region enabler x x on hold dominating environmental superintendence enabler x x on hold dominating mibac – ministry of cultural heritage and activities enabler x x on hold dominating associations interest group x latent applicants company that manages the port enabler x x on hold dominating engineering company designer x x x important definitive architecture and design company specialised in complex buildings designer x x x important definitive designer team designer x x x important definitive source: authors’ elaboration as the project evolved, the latent stakeholders, including residents and future hotel employees, experienced significant shifts in salience. initial concerns about environmental and social disruptions transitioned into active engagement and the co-creation of outcomes, such as employment opportunities and improved community amenities. environmental associations, which were initially latent, demonstrated their capacity to drive significant changes through legal interventions that led to key environmental design modifications, highlighting the fluidity of stakeholder influence. enabling stakeholders such as port management companies facilitates the integration of transport and connectivity solutions and amplifies economic and social outcomes through collaboration. definitive stakeholders, including design and engineering firms, play pivotal roles in integrating technological innovation with local cultural elements and sustainability priorities, ensuring that project outcomes are aligned with regional identity and values. temporal impact mapping provides the clearest evidence for addressing rq2 and rq3. temporal impact mapping contextualised these dynamics across the awareness (2015–2023), implementation (2024–2026), and use (2027 onwards) phases, revealing how the outcomes emerged and evolved over time. table iv shows the phase-wise distribution of outcomes. this temporal analysis demonstrates that timing plays a decisive role in sia effectiveness (rq2): early-phase application during european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/11830 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 28 the awareness stage generated 23 outcomes and enabled project modifications, while later implementation would have reduced sia's conflict-mediation potential. during the awareness phase, intensive stakeholder engagement generated 23 outcomes, including 12 social impacts, which shaped the project trajectory through modifications, such as reduced hotel capacity and enhanced environmental features. these modifications illustrate how lifecycle thinking integration enhances sia effectiveness (rq3) by enabling adaptive responses to emerging stakeholder concerns across project phases. the implementation phase recorded the highest concentration of economic outcomes (15), driven by construction activities, supply chain engagement, and activation of investment flows. in the use phase, the project exhibited a more balanced distribution of outcomes, with social (10), economic (12), and environmental (5) impacts reflecting operational maturity and sustained multidimensional value creation. the relative delay in environmental outcomes reflects both planning constraints and the subordinate position of ecological priorities in stakeholder negotiations—a finding aligned with saenz’s (2021) observations on outcome sequencing and institutional inertia. table iv. distribution of outcomes across project lifecycle stages lifecycle stage social impact type number of outcomes awareness social 12 economic 8 environmental 3 implementation social 8 economic 15 environmental 4 use social 10 economic 12 environmental 5 end social 5 economic 6 environmental 2 source: authors’ elaboration european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/11830 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 29 although environmental outcomes were numerically fewer, their integration with other value dimensions amplified their impact. features such as energy-efficient systems and rainwater harvesting provide operational cost savings, environmental conservation benefits, and community acceptance, demonstrating emerson’s (2003) concept of blended value creation in which distinct value streams mutually reinforce and magnify. the relatively constant presence of environmental outcomes across phases highlights a project’s commitment to sustainability, supporting ciroth et al.’s (2011) emphasis on lifecycle-integrated environmental considerations. stakeholder relationships evolve dynamically across project phases. environmental associations, initially adversarial, transitioned to collaborative roles, influencing sustainability features and aligning themselves with broader project goals. to ensure community-centric outcomes, municipal authorities expanded their influence from regulatory compliance to active participation in infrastructure design. collaboration between design firms and local stakeholders generated innovations, such as expanded rainwater systems, that supported both operational needs and community green spaces, fostering shared value creation across social, economic, and environmental dimensions. these collaborative innovations illustrate how stakeholderled adjustments can simultaneously serve operational efficiency, environmental resilience, and social acceptance—key components of integrated regeneration (arena et al., 2015; nicholls, 2018). the integration of these analytical frameworks reveals the sophisticated mechanisms that drive social value creation in urban regeneration. the project’s ability to balance diverse stakeholder interests, adapt through temporal insights, and generate a broad spectrum of impacts underscores the transformative potential of strategic urban interventions. however, the concentration of value in certain dimensions (e.g., employment) at specific phases also suggests the need for stronger institutional mechanisms to rebalance attention across social, environmental, and financial priorities over time. this analysis highlights the importance of life cycle thinking, multi-stakeholder engagement, and systemic alignment in maximising public value and fostering sustainable urban regeneration. this multidimensional approach to value assessment reflects emerging trends in social responsibility measurements. das and uma rao (2013) highlighted that performance evaluation in socially oriented projects requires frameworks that can capture both quantitative and qualitative social impacts across different stakeholder groups. 6. discussion: advancing urban regeneration evaluation this study addressed three research questions concerning the role of social impact assessment (sia) in urban regeneration: how sia can support stakeholder mediation; how timing affects its ability to do so; and how integrating lifecycle thinking enhances its relevance. the most important findings demonstrate that: sia, when operationalised through stakeholder salience analysis and temporal mapping, does more than quantify outcomes—it functions as an infrastructure for negotiation and realignment. first, sia's mediation potential is evidenced by the project's early application which surfaced latent conflicts and supported iterative redesign, illustrating its mediating potential. second, timing emerged as the most critical factor: the shifting salience of actors and outcomes across project phases confirmed the need for adaptive engagement strategies, with early-phase application generating 23 outcomes and enabling project modifications that prevented conflicts. third, lifecycle thinking european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/11830 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 30 integration proved essential: by embedding lifecycle thinking into sroi, the study captured how social, economic, and environmental value unfold and interact over time, enabling a longitudinal and multidimensional perspective on impact creation that revealed temporal interdependencies previously invisible in static approaches. theoretical contribution 1: dynamic stakeholder salience integration. this research makes a multifaceted contribution to urban regeneration literature by emphasising the dynamic interplay between stakeholder salience, lifecycle thinking, and social value creation. however, unlike traditional stakeholder theories, which treat stakeholder influence as relatively static (freeman, 1984), this study highlights the evolving salience of power, legitimacy, and urgency attributes across project phases. this dynamic perspective aligns with crosby and bryson's (2005) concept of a 'shared-power world', underscoring the need for flexible governance structures in complex, multi-stakeholder interventions. theoretical contribution 2: temporal value construction framework. building on arvidson et al.'s (2013) conceptualisation of social impact as a social construction, this study demonstrates how value interpretations shift temporally across life cycle stages. for instance, stakeholder groups initially focused on potential risks during the awareness phase and transitioned to emphasising tangible benefits during the implementation and use phases. these findings align with dentoni et al.'s (2016) assertion that cross-sector partnerships must adapt over time to maintain strategic alignment and collaboration. furthermore, the interplay of hard, soft, and cashable outcomes reflects emerson's (2003) blended value proposition, providing empirical evidence of how different forms of value interact to reinforce each other across temporal dimensions. theoretical contribution 3: lifecycle-informed impact assessment. the research also advances lifecycle assessment principles (jørgensen et al., 2008; weidema, 2006) by offering a framework that systematically captures temporal interdependencies among outcomes. by integrating life cycle thinking with stakeholder salience analysis, this study bridges a critical gap in traditional sroi methodologies (nicholls, 2017, 2018), offering new pathways for evaluating complex social interventions. practical contribution 1: process-oriented evaluation framework. this contribution gains further nuance when contrasted with recent empirical literature. tate et al. (2023), for instance, demonstrate the promise of sroi for evaluating regeneration outcomes in real settings, but also document its fragility when confronted with sparse or fragmented data. unlike their study, which emphasises final outcomes, our framework brings into focus the processual dimension—how salience and value attribution co-evolve—thus offering a dynamic rather than static reading of social return. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/11830 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 31 practical contribution 2: integrated stakeholder analysis tools. wang et al. (2022) apply social network analysis to map stakeholder influence in urban regeneration. while effective in tracing relational dynamics, their approach lacks a normative frame for evaluating which actors matter and when. in contrast, the salience-based method adopted here not only maps actors but qualifies their roles over time through the integration with impact trajectories. practical contribution 3: dynamic governance architecture. bottero et al. (2018) use promethee to expose the difficulty of managing trade-offs between economic, environmental, and social priorities. while insightful in supporting decision-making, their framework remains decision-centric and lacks the backward link to stakeholder dynamics. the current study complements this by situating trade-offs within governance processes and stakeholder configurations, making distributional tensions both visible and accountable. in sum, this study moves beyond technical or descriptive applications of sroi by showing how value can be structured and interpreted within a dynamic governance environment. this contributes both to theory (integrating lifecycle thinking and salience) and to practice (designing more reflexive evaluation architectures). moreover, this work reinforces the insights of arena et al. (2015) on aligning measurement systems with organisational logics, and complements grieco et al. (2015) by advancing toward a cluster-crossing framework that combines stakeholder participation, monetisation, and lifecycle orientation. based on these theoretical and practical contributions, the case study evidence provides actionable insights for practitioners implementing integrated sia frameworks in urban regeneration contexts. in appendix a there are implementation guidelines that synthesise the key findings into operational protocols that address timing, stakeholder salience management, and conflict mediation strategies across project phases. 7. conclusion, limitations and future directions this study's central contribution lies in demonstrating that integrated sia frameworks can effectively mediate stakeholder dynamics in urban regeneration through three key mechanisms. returning to the three research questions that guided this study: sia methodologies contribute to stakeholder mediation through comprehensive value mapping that addresses heterogeneous priorities (rq1). timing proves critical, with early-phase application generating 23 outcomes and enabling project modifications that prevent conflicts (rq2). lifecycle thinking integration captures temporal interdependencies and enables adaptive responses unavailable to static approaches (rq3). study limitations and their implications for future research require careful consideration. as a single-case design situated in a specific regional and institutional context, its findings are not immediately generalisable. the framework's transferability faces significant risks in contexts with less collaborative governance structures. the tuscan institutional environment features established multi-stakeholder dialogue traditions and regional development frameworks that facilitate the salience-based approach. in contexts with more adversarial stakeholder relations, fragmented municipal authority, or limited participatory democracy traditions, the framework's conflict-mediation effectiveness may be substantially reduced. power imbalances may european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/11830 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 32 prevent meaningful stakeholder engagement, while weak institutional capacity could undermine the temporal mapping essential to the approach. while triangulation across document analysis, stakeholder interviews, and proxy modeling increases robustness, the central role of one lead actor may introduce narrative bias. additionally, the focus on a single project type (hotel conversion) limits transferability to other regeneration contexts such as mixed-use developments or social housing projects. future research should pursue three specific directions to advance this field. first, comparative studies across different urban contexts (post-industrial cities, developing urban areas, historic districts) would test the framework's applicability and reveal context-specific adaptations needed. second, longitudinal tracking of regeneration projects from conception to post-completion phases would provide deeper insights into how stakeholder salience and value creation evolve over extended timeframes, potentially revealing cycles or patterns not visible in single-phase studies. third, methodological innovations should focus on developing digital tools and platforms that can support real-time stakeholder engagement and adaptive evaluation, potentially incorporating artificial intelligence to identify emerging stakeholder concerns and predict conflict points before they fully materialize. roadmap for comparative multi-case research. a systematic research programme should prioritise: (1) cross-contextual validation across governance regimes—comparing collaborative versus adversarial municipal environments to establish boundary conditions and adaptation requirements; (2) sectoral diversity testing—applying the framework across hotel conversions, mixed-use developments, social housing, and infrastructure projects to identify sector-specific modifications; (3) institutional capacity assessment—examining how varying levels of municipal expertise, stakeholder organisation capacity, and participatory democracy traditions affect framework implementation; (4) temporal scaling—tracking multiple projects through complete lifecycles to establish patterns of stakeholder salience evolution and value creation trajectories; (5) methodological refinement—developing standardised protocols for stakeholder identification, salience assessment, and outcome mapping that maintain contextual sensitivity while enabling cross-case comparison. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/11830 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 33 appendix a: implementation guidelines for policy‑makers and urban developers phase 1: early stakeholder mapping (awareness stage) ● conduct comprehensive stakeholder identification using power-legitimacy-urgency analysis ● prioritize engagement with high-salience actors (municipal authorities, environmental associations, community groups) ● apply sroi outcome mapping during project design phase to surface latent conflicts early ● establish baseline stakeholder expectations across social, economic, and environmental dimensions phase 2: adaptive engagement strategy (implementation stage) ● monitor stakeholder salience shifts as project progresses through lifecycle phases ● adjust engagement intensity based on evolving power-legitimacy-urgency configurations ● implement iterative project modifications based on stakeholder feedback mechanisms ● track outcome distribution to ensure balanced value creation (target: ~35% hard, 30% soft, 35% cashable) phase 3: temporal value tracking (use stage) ● establish monitoring systems for long-term impact measurement across stakeholder groups ● document value attribution evolution through systematic data collection protocols ● maintain stakeholder dialogue platforms to capture changing priorities and concerns ● use lifecycle thinking to anticipate and manage temporal interdependencies critical success factors: ● early-phase sia application generates 40% more outcomes than late-phase implementation ● municipal leadership capacity essential for coordinating multi-stakeholder dynamics ● environmental integration requires dedicated technical expertise and community liaison ● conflict-mediation effectiveness depends on transparent value distribution mechanisms appendix b: outcome (55) increased quality and usage of water decreased noise pollution rainwater reuse for green areas decreased wasted time to find a parking spot reduction in consumption and energy waste better access to alternative transport service reduction in energy waste consumption decreased incidents and road rage new trees and green areas near the hotel increased tourists in the port during the summer hotel waste treatment people can walk and be healthy co2 reduction from a reduction in room waste people and tourist can know better the place in which they are co2 reduction due to better air-conditioning increased access to information about local events collective savings due to resource scarcity increased capacity to promote educational activities near the hotel area co2 reduction from a reduction in food waste promotion of respectful behaviour about the environment reduction in carbon emission and km for food transit increased social inclusion and customer satisfaction co2 reduction due to reduced oil consumption increased capacity to practice sports and other physical activities european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/11830 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 34 new seasonal workers for managing the info point being more relaxed and healthier working positions permanently opened change perception in green spaces new seasonal workers for managing the building site (full-time) better home-work route new seasonal workers for managing the building site (part-time) events and activities in the park reduced public expenditure on unemployment subsidy cultural activities in the park young workers entering the job market being more relaxed when outside in appropriate places new seasonal workers for managing the restaurant schools can promote outdoor activities and lessons working positions permanently opened (restaurant) feeling safe outside lead to increased outdoor habits working positions permanently opened (bar) more equilibrated lunch at the workplace new seasonal workers for managing the bar better perception of the hotel's objectives increased possibility to work near home increased consciousness about food waste young workers entering the job market increased consumption of fruits and vegetables working positions permanently opened for managing the hotel increased spending in the local market new seasonal workers for managing the hotel reduced spending for not biological food working positions permanently opened for managing the shuttle service increased financial value of properties decreased time and costs to transport materials source: authors’ elaboration european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/11830 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 35 8. references ansell, c., boon, w., bryson, j., crosby, b., ferlie, e., grotenbreg, s., jukić, t., kitchener, m., meijer, a., ongaro, e., pluchinotta, i., sancino, a., sørensen, e., torfing, j., van gestel, n., & williams, h. (2024). strategic management of the transition to public sector co-creation. policy press. arena, m., azzone, g., & bengo, i. (2015). performance measurement for social enterprises. voluntas: international journal of voluntary and nonprofit organizations, 26(2), 649–672. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11266-013-9436-8 arli, d. i., & cadeaux, j. (2014). drivers of corporate community involvement and challenges in measuring its impact. social responsibility journal, 10(1), 161–183. doi: 10.1108/srj-10-2012-0116. arvidson, m., lyon, f., mckay, s., & moro, d. (2013). valuing the social? the nature and controversies of measuring social return on investment (sroi). voluntary sector review, 4(1), 3–18. doi: 10.1332/204080513x661554. bailey, n. (2012). the role, organisation and contribution of community enterprise to urban regeneration policy in the uk. progress in planning, 77(1), 1–35. doi: 10.1016/j.progress.2011.11.001. becker, h. a., & vanclay, f. (2003). the international handbook of social impact assessment: conceptual and methodological advances. edward elgar publishing. ben-akiva, m. e., toledo, t., santos, j., cox, n., zhao, f., lee, y.j., & marzano, v. (2016). freight data collection using gps and web-based surveys: insights from us truck drivers’ survey and perspectives for urban freight. case studies on transport policy, 4(1), 38–44. bhatnagar, a., harri, a., levanen, j., & niinimaki, k. (2024). exploring the role of social life cycle assessment in transition to circular economy: a systematic review. resources, conservation & recycling, 207, 107702. biancone, p., secinaro, s., brescia, v., & iannaci, d. (2019). the popular financial reporting between theory and evidence. international business research, 12(7), 45–56. doi: 10.5539/ibr.v12n7p45. biondi, l., & bracci, e. (2018). sustainability, popular and integrated reporting in the public sector: a fad and fashion perspective. sustainability, 10(9), 3112. doi: 10.3390/su10093112. bottero, m., d’alpaos, c., & oppio, a. (2018). multicriteria evaluation of urban regeneration processes: an application of promethee method in northern italy. advances in operations research, 2018, article 9276075. https://doi.org/10.1155/2018/9276075 bryson, j. m., barberg, b., & crosby, b. c. (2024). the future of public service and strategy management-at-scale. policy quarterly, 20(1), 50–59. doi: 10.26686/pq.v20i1.9052. bryson, j. m., crosby, b. c., & stone, m. m. (2015). designing and implementing cross-sector collaborations: needed and challenging. public administration review, 75(5), 647–663. doi: 10.1111/puar.12432. ciroth, a., finkbeiner, m., hildenbrand, j., klöpffer, w., mazijn, b., prakash, s., sonnemann, g., traverso, m., ugaya, c., & vickery/niederman, g. (2011). towards a life cycle sustainability assessment: making informed choices on products. ebook edition, unep/setac life cycle initiative. www.lifecycleinitiative.org/wp-content/uploads/2012/12/2011%20%20towards%20lcsa.pdf https://doi.org/10.1007/s11266-013-9436-8 https://doi.org/10.1332/204080513x661554 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.progress.2011.11.001 https://doi.org/10.5539/ibr.v12n7p45 https://doi.org/10.3390/su10093112 https://doi.org/10.1155/2018/9276075 https://doi.org/10.1155/2018/9276075 https://doi.org/10.1155/2018/9276075 https://doi.org/10.26686/pq.v20i1.9052 https://doi.org/10.1111/puar.12432 european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/11830 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 36 clark, c., rosenzweig, w., long, d., & olsen, s. (2004). double bottom line project report: assessing social impact in double bottom line ventures. university of california berkeley. colantonio, a., & dixon, t. (2009). measuring socially sustainable urban regeneration in europe. oxford institute for sustainable development. cordes, j. j. (2017). using cost-benefit analysis and social return on investment to evaluate the impact of social enterprise: promises, implementation, and limitations. evaluation and program planning, 64, 98–104. doi: 10.1016/j.evalprogplan.2016.11.008. corvo, l., pastore, l., mastrodascio, m., & cepiku, d. (2022). the social return on investment model: a systematic literature review. meditari accountancy research, 30(7), 49–86. doi: 10.1108/medar-05-2021-1307. crosby, b. c., & bryson, j. m. (2005). leadership for the common good: tackling public problems in a shared-power world. john wiley & sons. das, p. k., & uma rao, s. p. (2013). performance evaluation of socially responsible mutual funds using style analysis. social responsibility journal, 9(1), 109–123. doi: 10.1108/17471111311307840. dentoni, d., bitzer, v., & pascucci, s. (2016). cross-sector partnerships and the co-creation of dynamic capabilities for stakeholder orientation. journal of business ethics, 135(1), 35–53. doi: 10.1007/s10551-015-2728-8. eisenhardt, k. m. (1989). building theories from case study research. academy of management review, 14(4), 532–550. doi: 10.2307/258557. eisenhardt, k. m., & graebner, m. e. (2007). theory building from cases: opportunities and challenges. academy of management journal, 50(1), 25–32. doi: 10.5465/amj.2007.24160888. emerson, j. (2003). the blended value proposition: integrating social and financial returns. california management review, 45(4), 35–51. doi: 10.2307/41166187. ferris, s. p., & rykaczewski, k. p. (1986). social investing and portfolio management. business and society, 25(1), 1–7. doi: 10.1177/000765038602500101. flyvbjerg, b. (2006). five misunderstandings about case-study research. qualitative inquiry, 12(2), 219–245. doi: 10.1177/1077800405284363. freeman, r. e. (1984). strategic management: a stakeholder approach. pitman. geels, f. w. (2004). from sectoral systems of innovation to socio-technical systems. research policy, 33(6–7), 897–920. doi: 10.1016/j.respol.2004.01.015. grieco, c., michelini, l., & iasevoli, g. (2015). measuring value creation in social enterprises: a cluster analysis of social impact assessment models. nonprofit and voluntary sector quarterly, 44(6), 1173–1193. https://doi.org/10.1177/0899764014555986 grana, f., arena, m., & busco, c. (2025). addressing systemic challenges: the role of accounting and accountability practices. accounting, auditing & accountability journal. advance online publication. https://doi.org/10.1108/aaaj-12-20226175 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.evalprogplan.2016.11.008 https://doi.org/10.1108/medar-05-2021-1307 https://doi.org/10.1108/17471111311307840 https://doi.org/10.1007/s10551-015-2728-8 https://doi.org/10.2307/258557 https://doi.org/10.5465/amj.2007.24160888 https://doi.org/10.2307/41166187 https://doi.org/10.1177/000765038602500101 https://doi.org/10.1177/1077800405284363 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.respol.2004.01.015 https://doi.org/10.1108/aaaj-12-2022-6175 https://doi.org/10.1108/aaaj-12-2022-6175 european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/11830 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 37 healey, p. (2006). collaborative planning: shaping places in fragmented societies. macmillan international higher education. hinson, r. e., & ndhlovu, t. p. (2011). conceptualising corporate social responsibility (csr) and corporate social investment (csi): the south african context. social responsibility journal, 7(3), 332–346. doi: 10.1108/17471111111154491. jørgensen, a., le bocq, a., nazarkina, l., & hauschild, m. (2008). methodologies for social life cycle assessment. the international journal of life cycle assessment, 13(2), 96–103. doi: 10.1065/lca2007.11.367. lumpkin, g. t., bacq, s., & pidduck, r. j. (2018). where change happens: community-level phenomena in social entrepreneurship research. journal of small business management, 56(1), 24–50. doi: 10.1111/jsbm.12379. maccallum, d., moulaert, f., hillier, j., & vicari haddock, s. (2009). social innovation and territorial development. ashgate publishing. manring, n., west, p. c., & bidol, p. (1990). social impact assessment and environmental conflict management. environmental impact assessment review, 10, (3), 302–310. mill, g. a., & holland, l. (2005). socially responsible investment, information and the myth of underperformance. social responsibility journal, 1(1/2), 91–97. doi: 10.1108/eb045799. mills, a. j., durepos, g., & wiebe, e. (eds.). (2010). encyclopedia of case study research. sage publications. doi: 10.4135/9781412957397. mitchell, r. k., agle, b. r., & wood, d. j. (1997). toward a theory of stakeholder identification and salience: defining the principle of who and what really counts. academy of management review, 22(4), 853–886. doi: 10.2307/259247. neville, b. a., bell, s. j., & whitwell, g. j. (2011). stakeholder salience revisited: refining, redefining, and refueling an underdeveloped conceptual tool. journal of business ethics, 102(3), 357–378. doi: 10.1007/s10551-011-0818-9. nicholls, a. (2018). a general theory of social impact accounting: materiality, uncertainty and empowerment. journal of social entrepreneurship, 9(2), 132–153. doi: 10.1080/19420676.2018.1452785. nicholls, j. (2017). social return on investment-development and convergence. evaluation and program planning, 64, 127– 135. doi: 10.1016/j.evalprogplan.2016.11.011. obalola, m., & adelopo, i. (2012). measuring the perceived importance of ethics and social responsibility in financial services: a narrative-inductive approach. social responsibility journal, 8(3), 418–432. doi: 10.1108/17471111211247992. premyanov, n., roma-athanasiadou, e., metta, j., tsoniotis, n., angelidou, m., & tsolakis, a. c. (2024). circular entrepreneurship via makerspaces towards fostering sustainable cities: a mixed-method approach with case studies. journal of circular economy, 2(3), 1-31. ragozino, s. (2019). navigating neo-liberal urbanism in the uk. could a social entrepreneur be considered an activist planner?. in calabrò, f., della spina, l., & bevilacqua, c. (eds.), new metropolitan perspectives (pp. 625–634). springer international publishing. doi: 10.1007/978-3-319-92099-3_70. ravitch, s. m., & carl, n. m. (2021). qualitative research: bridging the conceptual, theoretical, and methodological (2nd ed.). sage publications. https://doi.org/10.1108/17471111111154491 https://doi.org/10.1065/lca2007.11.367 https://doi.org/10.1111/jsbm.12379 https://doi.org/10.1108/eb045799 https://doi.org/10.4135/9781412957397 https://doi.org/10.2307/259247 https://doi.org/10.1007/s10551-011-0818-9 https://doi.org/10.1080/19420676.2018.1452785 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.evalprogplan.2016.11.011 https://doi.org/10.1108/17471111211247992 https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-92099-3_70 european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/11830 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 38 saenz, c. (2020). a framework proposal for regional sustainability assessment: the case of the mining industry. environmental development, 34, 100513. saenz, c. s. (2021). a new mapping outcome method to measure social return on investment: a case study in peru. social responsibility journal, 17(4), 562–577. doi: 10.1108/srj-04-2018-0097. sairinen, r. (2010). special issue: conflict mediation and social impact assessment. in environmental conflict mediation and social impact assessment: approaches for enhanced environmental governance? (conference held on 14–15 february 2008 organised by helsinki, finland). elsevier. sager, t. (2016). activist planning: a response to the woes of neo-liberalism? european planning studies, 24, 1262–1280. doi: 10.1080/09654313.2016.1168786. siggelkow, n. (2007). persuasion with case studies. academy of management journal, 50(1), 20–24. doi: 10.5465/amj.2007.24160882. tate, c., o’neill, c., tran, n., heron, l., kee, f., tully, m. a., ... & hunter, r. f. (2023). the social return on investment of an urban regeneration project using real-world data: the connswater community greenway, belfast, uk. cities & health, 7(5), 699–718. https://doi.org/10.1080/23748834.2021.1929411 toledo, t., ben-akiva, m., santos, j., cox, n., & zhao, f. (2010). urban freight tour models: state of the art and practice. proceedings of the commodity flow survey workshop. irvine, ca. van der veen, s., van rechteren limpurg, e., asveld, l., & chandrasekaran, s. (2025). strengthening social life cycle assessment for a just bioeconomy: insights from namibia's bush-based value chains. sustainable production and consumption, 45, 1-16. wang, y., yao, y., zhang, y., & xiang, l. (2022). a framework of stakeholder relationship analysis for an urban regeneration project based on social network analysis: a dynamic perspective. journal of urban planning and development, 148(4), 04022035. https://doi.org/10.1061/(asce)up.1943-5444.0000861 weidema, b. p. (2006). the integration of economic and social aspects in life cycle impact assessment. the international journal of life cycle assessment, 11(s1), 89–96. doi: 10.1065/lca2006.04.016. wolch, j. r., byrne, j., & newell, j. p. (2014). urban green space, public health, and environmental justice: the challenge of making cities ‘just green enough’. landscape and urban planning, 125, 234–244. doi: 10.1016/j.landurbplan.2014.01.017. yates, b. t., & marra, m. (2017). social return on investment (sroi): problems, solutions . . . and is sroi a good investment? evaluation and program planning, 64, 136–144. yin, r. k. (2017). case study research and applications: design and methods (6th ed.). sage publications. zhou, j., love, p. e., matthews, j., lavender, m., & olatunji, o. (2018) enhancing sustainability through understanding stakeholder perspectives on urban regeneration projects. sustainability, 10(9), 3155. https://doi.org/10.1108/srj-04-2018-0097 https://doi.org/10.1080/09654313.2016.1168786 https://doi.org/10.5465/amj.2007.24160882 https://doi.org/10.1080/23748834.2021.1929411 https://doi.org/10.1061/(asce)up.1943-5444.0000861 https://doi.org/10.1065/lca2006.04.016 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.landurbplan.2014.01.017 european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/9819 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 1 strategies for circular supplier selection: a case study from the netherlands devrim yurdaanik eskiyerli 1*, celina thoenissen 2 1 fontys university of applied sciences, research group business innovation, tegelseweg 255, venlo, the netherlands. d.eskiyerli@fontys.nl orcid 0000-0002-5067-2003 * contact author 2 fontys university of applied sciences, research group business innovation, tegelseweg 255, venlo, the netherlands. celinathonnissen@icloud.com received: 14/02/2024 accepted for publication: 24/07/2024 published: 28/08/2024 abstract developing and validating circular supplier selection criteria within sustainable supply chain management is crucial for integrating circular economy principles. by addressing a significant gap in empirical research, our study emphasizes the necessity of incorporating circular economy principles into supplier selection criteria to enhance sustainability and competitiveness in an international context. our research identifies and validates key criteria essential for selecting suppliers aligned with circular economy objectives by recognizing the increasing importance of circular economy principles. the identified gap prompted our research, aiming to bridge the divide by providing practical insights and empirical evidence. we employed a mixed-methods approach to define the supplier selection criteria framework, ensuring its relevance and applicability across different contexts. we validated eight supplier selection criteria, including material type, collaboration, sustainability incentives, and eco-friendly practices, highlighting their alignment with economic, environmental, and social dimensions. our findings stress the necessity of integrating circular principles into supplier selection criteria, emphasizing environmental certifications, compliance with standards, and support for closed-loop processes. our study reveals that effective circular practices can utilize unique resources such as recycled materials and innovative technologies, offering firms a competitive edge. additionally, the research highlights the importance of collaboration and stakeholder engagement in advancing circular economy practices, encouraging mutual growth and sustainable supply chains. the validated supplier selection criteria framework provides a strategic tool for businesses to enhance their supplier selection process, ensuring transparency and collaboration while promoting long-term sustainability. keywords: circular economy, circular supplier selection criteria, sustainable supplier selection, supplier selection criteria, supply chain management, green supplier selection mailto:d.eskiyerli@fontys.nl https://orcid.org/0000-0002-5067-2003 mailto:celinathonnissen@icloud.com european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/9819 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 2 1. introduction the increasing complexity of supplier selection in today's globalized economy necessitates the development of thoughtful and comprehensive supplier selection criteria (ssc). this complexity is further compounded when incorporating circular economy principles, which aim to minimize waste and maximize the reuse of materials (prosman & sacchi, 2016; tushar et al., 2022). despite the growing importance of these principles, there remains a significant gap in the literature regarding the development of ssc that integrates circular economy objectives into the supplier selection process and in international contexts. current literature has extensively explored various supplier selection methodologies and the inclusion of sustainability aspects (govindan et al., 2015; taherdoost & brard, 2019). however, there is a notable absence of empirical studies that validate these criteria within real-world business contexts, particularly concerning circular supplier selection (el barky et al., 2022; tushar et al., 2022). there is a need to understand the conditions that encourage or impede engagement in circular economy (ce) practices by identifying the enabling and hindering factors among the actors in the supply chain. this includes overcoming collaboration barriers and enhancing collective incentives for advancing ce practices. although stakeholder engagement is recognized as vital for the successful implementation of ce, there is a gap in effectively aligning interests, fostering a shared vision, and building trust-based relationships that facilitate knowledge and information exchange (farooque et al., 2022; govindan & hasanagic, 2018). moreover, international business research has thoroughly examined the standardization and adaptation of business strategies across borders but has rarely considered these aspects concerning sustainability and circularity criteria (dow, 2006; zou & cavusgil, 2002). these gaps highlight the need for research that develops and validates ssc with empirical findings, integrating circular economy objectives, specifically within international markets. in addressing these research gaps, our study focuses on an illustrative case study from the netherlands. it specifically analyses a company known for its innovative approach to utilizing waste materials in the furniture industry. the choice of this company, eco company, is motivated by its unique circular business model that transforms waste into valuable products, thereby representing the principles of the circular economy. eco company stands out for its innovative methods of refurbishing and revitalizing waste materials, including textiles, leather, and cork, through a patented grinder and binder system. this makes eco company suitable for examining the application and validation of circular ssc. the main research question (mrq) guiding this study is: "what strategic circular ssc can be empirically validated to address the gap in integrating circular economy principles within international supplier selection frameworks?" by answering this question, our study aims to develop a strategic framework that can be utilized by companies looking to expand their circular practices internationally. we studied the mrq in two research questions (rqs) and two sub-research questions (srqs) as follows: rq1: which ssc can be derived from the producer’s and supplier’s internal requirements? rq2: which ssc can be validated in terms of suppliers’ ability to provide information respectively? srq1. which ssc facilitate the acquisition of relevant information from suppliers? srq2: what challenges need consideration to enhance suppliers’ ability to provide information for producer’s supplier selection in the target market country?” our research has both theoretical and practical implications. theoretically, we contribute to the existing literature by providing empirical validation of circular ssc, which is currently underrepresented (govindan et al., 2020; münch et al., 2022). one way of contributing to theory is to improve it through “incremental, interesting contribution”, where “new insights are gained through empirical studies or new conceptualizations” (reay & whetten, 2011). we integrate circular economy principles with european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/9819 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 3 established theories such as the resource-based view (rbv) (barney, 1991), dynamic capabilities theory (teece et al., 1997), and internationalization theories demonstrating how companies can support their unique resources and capabilities to achieve competitive advantage through sustainable practices in an international context. click or tap here to enter text. by incorporating ssc that aligns with circular economy principles, companies can better meet the expectations of various stakeholders, including customers, regulators, and the community, thus enhancing their overall sustainability performance. additionally, we address the gaps in empirical research by substantiating the practicality and effectiveness of these criteria in real-world settings (el barky et al., 2022; tushar et al., 2022). practically, the study offers a strategic framework and a practical tool, the supplier selection fill out form (ssfof), for businesses aiming to implement circular economy principles in their supply chains. this tool facilitates efficient and effective supplier evaluations, reducing the time-intensive communication typically required in the supplier selection process. the study also highlights the importance of collaboration and transparency between suppliers and buyers, promoting stronger partnerships that can lead to more innovative and sustainable solutions in supply chain management (scm) internationally. the remainder of this paper is organized as follows. the next section provides a literature review based on the theoretical background of our research, the evolution of the supplier selection criteria, and the widely used approaches for supplier selection. this is followed by our methodology and research design, a description of the case study we used, and the findings. our paper concludes with a discussion of the implications of our research on circular supplier selection for theory and practice, as well as limitations and recommendations for future research. 2. literature review 2.1 theoretical background the theoretical grounding for studying circular supplier selection criteria internationally is rooted in several key theories. in recent years, the circular economy (ce) concept has gathered significant attention in both theoretical and practical settings (geissdoerfer et al., 2018). ce is defined as an economic system where resources are utilized for as long as possible to maximize their value, highlighting the advantages of recycling waste materials and by-products (geissdoerfer et al., 2018; jacobsen et al., 2018). however, due to its interdisciplinary nature, there is no single, universally accepted definition of ce (kirchherr et al., 2017; tecchio et al., 2017). according to the ellen macarthur foundation (2017), ce is “an industrial system that is restorative or regenerative by intention and design.” driven by the rising demand from customers and stakeholders, companies are increasingly compelled to adopt sustainable practices throughout their supply chains (mena et al., 2013; vachon & klassen, 2006). this increased pressure means that producers must ensure sustainable outcomes even after selling their products, extending their responsibility to the consumption and post-consumption phases. consequently, this responsibility shifts from a linear supply chain model to a circular one (taghikhah et al., 2019). integrating ce into supply chain management (scm) becomes essential to implement this shift, leading to the concept of circular supply chain (csc) management. this approach involves both forward and reverse logistics and waste management, aiming for zero waste by reintroducing resources into the supply chain through various “r” strategies, such as refusing, reducing, reusing, european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/9819 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 4 repairing, refurbishing, remanufacturing, repurposing, recycling, and recovering (farooque et al., 2022; kirchherr et al., 2017). described as “the integration of circular thinking into the management of the supply chain and its surrounding industrial and natural ecosystems” (farooque et al., 2022), csc ensures the continuous use of resources without them becoming waste, emphasizing the crucial role of supplier collaboration (bundgaard et al., 2017; nasir et al., 2017). thus, supplier selection becomes an important aspect of reaching circularity goals. building on this framework, companies can achieve competitive advantage by developing capabilities based on valuable, rare, inimitable, and non-substitutable resources. the resource-based view (rbv) highlights the importance of internal, nontransferable organizational resources such as assets, capabilities, processes, information, and knowledge (barney, 1991; eisenhardt & martin, 2000; grant, 1991; peteraf, 1993). extending rbv, the natural rbv (nrbv) integrates the firm’s interaction with its natural environment, identifying key strategic capabilities: pollution prevention, product stewardship, and sustainable development (hart, 1995; hart & dowell, 2010). pollution prevention focuses on reducing waste and emissions through continuous improvement, which directly links to cost reduction and enhanced economic performance. meanwhile, product stewardship considers the entire product lifecycle, involving multiple stakeholders to minimize environmental costs and gain competitive advantage (hart, 1995; pinheiro et al., 2023). sustainable development, particularly significant in developing countries, aims to create products that deliver long-term environmental, economic, and social benefits (hart, 1995; hart & dowell, 2010; kumar et al., 2021). incorporating these strategic capabilities into circular supplier selection emphasizes environmental certifications, compliance with standards, clean technologies, and eco-friendly practices in production and logistics. firms effectively integrating circular practices can leverage unique resources like recycled materials and innovative technologies to gain a competitive edge (bodhanwala & bodhanwala, 2020). further complementing rbv and nrbv, dynamic capabilities theory highlights the necessity for firms to adapt and reconfigure their resources in response to changing environments, maintaining resilience and sustainability (teece et al., 1997). within circular supply chains, dynamic capabilities facilitate continuous innovation and process improvement. importantly, collaboration emerges as critical for implementing ce principles, facilitating material recovery, and ensuring social welfare among value-chain actors (batista et al., 2018; mwaijande, 2024; scarpellini, 2021). economic challenges such as limited production capacity and high raw material costs highlight the importance of developing integrated and local supply chains. (foschi, 2023). effective collaboration necessitates understanding conditions that encourage or impede engagement in ce practices by identifying enabling and hindering factors among sc actors (touboulic & walker, 2015). this understanding is vital for grasping the relational and business dynamics in cross-sectoral collaboration advancing ce practices. dynamic capabilities play a significant role in overcoming collaboration barriers and enhancing collective incentives, promoting ce principles and maintaining long-term competitive advantages in dynamic network environments (borland & lindgreen, 2013; teece, 2007). aligned with these theoretical perspectives, stakeholder theory emphasizes considering the interests and expectations of various stakeholders, including customers, regulators, and the community (freeman, 1984). stakeholder engagement involves practices to identify and manage stakeholder needs, develop interaction methods, and create mutual learning opportunities european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/9819 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 5 through education and training (freeman et al., 2018; greenwood, 2007). samant & sangle (2016) recognize a shift in organizational sustainability literature, where stakeholders are seen as essential for value co-creation rather than inhibitors. engaging stakeholders is crucial for aligning interests, fostering a shared vision, and building trust-based relationships that facilitate knowledge and information exchange in the context of ce (bertassini et al., 2021; calicchio berardi & peregrino de brito, 2021). furthermore, responsible sourcing of raw materials stimulates stewardship and certification programs that enable sustainability and circularity internationally (mazzarano, 2021). effective stakeholder engagement is, therefore, vital for the successful implementation of ce, as integrating ce principles within scm relies heavily on it (baah et al., 2023; farooque et al., 2022; govindan & hasanagic, 2018). by adopting innovative, sustainable business models and incorporating ce principles into supplier selection, firms can better meet stakeholder demands for sustainability and transparency, enhancing their reputation and long-term success (piontek et al., 2021). finally, addressing sustainability challenges requires companies to develop innovative business models domestically and adapt them internationally, considering the business’s value chain may span beyond domestic boundaries (tallman et al., 2018; yurdaanik eskiyerli & ewertz, 2024). although substantial research has focused on sustainable business model innovations locally and the internationalization of these innovations, there remains a gap in exploring sustainable business model innovation in an international context (foss & saebi, 2017; geissdoerfer et al., 2018; gölgeci et al., 2021; josephson et al., 2016; ostrom et al., 2010; shakeel et al., 2020; von delft et al., 2019). integrating sustainability into international business strategies, particularly through collaboration with global supply chain partners, is essential (dow, 2006; yurdaanik eskiyerli & ewertz, 2024; zou & cavusgil, 2002). in this regard, the uppsala model suggests that firms should expand their international activities progressively, developing deeper relationships with international suppliers over time to align with sustainability goals (johanson & vahlne, 1977, 2009; vahlne & johanson, 2017). dunning’s eclectic paradigm emphasizes leveraging unique capabilities and selecting regions that support sustainability initiatives (dunning, 1977, 1988). the network theory of internationalization highlights the importance of building strong relationships with international suppliers to drive sustainable practices and share knowledge (johanson & mattsson, 2015). in synthesizing these theoretical perspectives, it becomes evident that designing effective circular supplier selection criteria hinges on a multidimensional approach that incorporates sustainability, resource optimization, adaptability, and stakeholder collaboration. by adopting a circular economy framework, companies can extend their responsibility beyond the traditional supply chain, ensuring that resources are continuously reused and regenerated. this approach not only uses valuable and unique organizational capabilities to gain a competitive advantage but also emphasizes the need for continuous adaptation and innovation to maintain resilience in a changing environment. engaging stakeholders across the supply chain fosters trust and collaboration, which are crucial for implementing sustainable practices and achieving long-term goals. furthermore, expanding these sustainable business models internationally requires strategic partnerships and a deep understanding of different market dynamics to align global supply chain activities with sustainability objectives. ultimately, integrating these concepts leads to a robust and adaptable circular supply chain that supports environmental sustainability, economic efficiency, and social responsibility. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/9819 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 6 2.2 evolution of the supplier selection criteria the supplier selection process involves evaluating and choosing suppliers for goods and services based on a set of predefined criteria that align with the company’s strategic objectives (choi & hartley, 1996). developing ssc dates way back (dickson, 1966). in the more “traditional” supplier selection criteria, aspects such as “price”, “quality”, “on-time delivery”, “performance history of the supplier”, and “warranty used by the supplier” were considered to be of high importance (dickson, 1966; ding et al., 2008; govindan et al., 2013). as global awareness of environmental issues and sustainability grew, organizations faced the imperative to address sustainability concerns in business, driven by government regulations and heightened community knowledge (govindan et al., 2013; idil gaziulusoy, 2015). a main decision to enhance business performance and gain competitiveness in industrial supply chains led to the selection of green and sustainability-focused suppliers (govindan et al., 2013; grimm et al., 2014). the sustainability-focused supply chain, an extension of the green supply chain, incorporates social criteria alongside economic and green considerations within a supply chain context (mangla et al., 2014). green or sustainable practices have become integral to the planning processes of modern manufacturing organizations, aiming to improve overall supply chain performance (rostamzadeh et al., 2015). suppliers play a vital role in implementing sustainable supply chain initiatives and achieving gains in social, environmental, and economic dimensions (govindan et al., 2013; shen et al., 2013). in a similar vein, the concept of circular economy aims to mitigate environmental impacts by incorporating circular principles in the supplier selection process (govindan et al., 2020; lahane et al., 2020). circular supply chain management differs from sustainable supply chain management. while sustainable supply chains focus on minimizing environmental impact and enhancing social responsibility through practices such as reducing carbon emissions and ensuring fair labour practices, circular supply chains go further by emphasizing the regeneration of resources and the elimination of waste. in traditional economic supply chains, products are considered waste at the end of their lifecycle. in contrast, circular or closed-loop supply chains aim to maintain end-of-life products in the production cycle through self-sustaining production by continuously using and regenerating materials (shooshtarian et al., 2022; tushar et al., 2022). this approach involves rethinking product design, manufacturing, and consumption to support multiple lifecycles (ellen macarthur foundation, 2017). by implementing strategies such as remanufacturing, refurbishing, and repurposing, circular supply chains reduce the need for virgin materials and contribute to the circulation of resources, requiring more complex coordination and collaboration (farooque et al., 2022; kirchherr et al., 2017). embedding circular principles enables firms to achieve long-term sustainability, economic resilience, and competitive advantage through a regenerative system that prioritizes resource efficiency and material longevity over traditional waste management practices (bundgaard et al., 2017; nasir et al., 2017). this shift necessitates the development of new supplier selection criteria that account for circular principles, such as the ability to provide recycled materials, support for closed-loop processes, and compliance with circular economy standards (govindan et al., 2020; münch et al., 2022). the connection between these concepts highlights the need for specific criteria addressing the unique requirements of circular supply chains, such as providing secondary raw materials and supporting remanufacturing and recycling processes (münch et al., 2022). european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/9819 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 7 in the literature, there is an abundance of studies providing comparative lists of ssc from various perspectives, including traditional and sustainable perspectives. the work of taherdoost & brard (2019) studies the critical aspects of the scm and supplier selection within the context of modern business dynamics. they highlight the transformative role of scm in the global economy, emphasizing its integral nature to business success by enhancing customer service, reducing costs, and fostering longer relationships between buyers and suppliers. their work also categorizes and discusses a multitude of supplier selection methods, emphasizing the absence of a standard approach and the need for flexibility based on product, expectations, and industry. they emphasize the importance of understanding these methods and their appropriateness in diverse situations, providing a comprehensive and insightful overview of the complex landscape of scm and supplier selection. the study by luthra et al. (2017) conducts a comprehensive review of relevant literature on supplier selection and evaluation in the context of supply chain sustainability. the chosen criteria for the review include the adoption of environmental, ecological, and social sustainability. in their study, a total of 22 sscs are identified and categorized into three dimensions of sustainability (economic, environmental and social). they emphasize the significance of supplier selection in sustainabilityfocused supply chains and the complexity introduced when sustainability criteria are added to conventional qualities. recent research, such as the study of münch et al. (2022), explores the shift from a linear to a circular paradigm in supply chain management and reviews the research on supplier selection within circular supply chains, highlighting the significance of circular supply chains for companies’ competitiveness. ten relevant articles from the previous two years are identified, with a focus on criteria formulation, supplier selection, and network design. they categorize circular supplier selection criteria based on key strategic capabilities: pollution prevention, product stewardship, and sustainable development. criteria include environmental certifications, compliance with standards, clean technologies, clean transportation, emissions and pollution control, waste management, resource consumption, research and development, eco-friendly packaging, material selection, product design, and sustainability-oriented supplier practices. similarly, el barky et al. (2022) developed a list of 23 supplier selection criteria towards sustainability performance in the context of circularity with four dimensions (economic, environment, social, and circular). münch et al. (2022) developed supplier selection criteria in a circular supply chain, classified under pollution prevention, product stewardship and sustainable development. these four studies by luthra et al. (2017), taherdoost & brard (2019), münch et al. (2022) and el barky et al. (2022) comprehensively reviewed and categorized ssc and therefore are selected as the literature pillar for our study. despite the abundance of studies on supplier selection, there are fewer empirical studies than conceptual ones, especially in terms of circularity aspects and international contexts. empirical studies, such as those by el barky et al. (2022), tushar et al. (2022), kusi-sarpong et al. (2023), and ali et al. (2023), have started exploring the practical applications of circular principles in supplier selection. these studies, while insightful, are limited in number and vary in scope. this gap signifies an opportunity for conducting more empirical research, such as case studies, which could provide valuable insights into the practical challenges and successes of implementing circular supplier selection criteria in various industries. our case study involves a circular business model utilizing secondary raw materials or by-products as inputs. therefore, suppliers need to be identified in terms of their ability to provide such raw materials. the data will be collected initially to understand the internal specifications of european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/9819 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 8 both parties (supplier-producer) involved. existing criteria presented in the current literature will allow us to complement the internal requirements of the companies. solely focusing on one company’s internal standards and requirements of its international joint venture partners would cause a limited and biased perspective. therefore, using standards from the literature as a benchmark will allow us to develop a scalable and adaptable list of criteria. 2.3 supplier selection and widely used approaches for supplier selection supplier selection involves a comprehensive process where businesses aim to identify, evaluate, scrutinize, analyze, and form agreements with suppliers (chai & ngai, 2020). the supplier selection process can be portrayed as one of the most comprehensive challenges to be managed by the procurement department (taherdoost & brard, 2019). the procedure intends to establish a final list of suppliers with respect to a firm’s objectives. a review of the literature on supplier selection reveals that a wide array of quantitative multicriteria decision-making criteria have been formulated over time, including the analytic hierarchy process (ahp), analytic network process (anp), fuzzy-based approach and data mining (chai et al., 2013; fahimnia et al., 2015; wetzstein et al., 2016; zimmer et al., 2016). regarding literature reviews based on sustainable supplier selection criteria, these quantitative multicriteria decision-making criteria still prevail with the addition of data envelopment analysis, technique for order preference by similarity to ideal solution (topsis) decision making trial and evaluation laboratory (dematel) and multi-attribute utility theory (maut) (govindan et al., 2015). among these, ahp has been praised for its ability to break down decision criteria and offer a straightforward, defensible approach including qualitative and quantitative parameters, making it highly accessible for practitioners, whilst also been criticized for having been used by researchers for its convenience than theoretical rigour (govindan et al., 2015). govindan et al. (2015) also warn against integrating multiple methods in an effort to reach a more comprehensive decision-making tool since the complexity of using multiple methods can deter practitioner acceptance, suggesting a need for research into simplifying these approaches for better usability. behind all these analyses for supplier selection lies the fundamental structure which can be summarized in four steps: (1) problem formulation, which refers to the understanding of the incentive for supplier selection; (2) formulation of criteria, which addresses the process in which criteria and related importance weights should be selected with respect to a firm’s objectives, (3) qualification, which incorporates the selection of qualified suppliers based on their performance, (4) final selection, which refers to establishing a final list of suppliers (de boer et al., 2001). in our study, we aim to provide a set of selection criteria based on in-depth qualitative analysis where the data is collected based on circularity criteria through an empirical study. our study does not intend to provide a final list of suppliers but aims to identify a set of criteria that allows our case study company, as well as their joint venture partners, to identify and validate foreign suppliers that can supply suitable waste materials. therefore, only steps 1 and 2 of the above criteria will be carried out. the determination of applicable ssc enables the identification of suitable suppliers. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/9819 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 9 3. methodology 3.1 design of the conceptual model we incorporated relevant principles and ssc from existing literature into our conceptual model (cm). in developing our cm, three determinants guided our selection: (1) repetitiveness of criteria and principles, (2) relevance to the business problems of case study companies selected for our study (eco company and eco design), and (3) alignment with the research objective. to identify overarching principles, a comparison of literature reviews made by taherdoost & brard (2019), luthra et al. (2017), el barky et al. (2022), and münch et al. (2022) was carried out. notably, literature since 2017 emphasizes linking ssc with economic, environmental, and social dimensions, highlighting the contemporary importance of sustainability in the supplier selection process. considering the relevance of circularity, a categorization system that includes economic, environmental, social, and circular dimensions is proposed. this also aligns with the current literature. economic dimension criteria: for the economic dimension, the criteria “quality,” “price,” and “delivery” were identified through a comparative analysis of (taherdoost & brard, 2019), luthra et al. (2017) and el barky et al. (2022). these criteria, consistently highlighted across all three studies, provide a solid foundation for the cm. specific definitions from each study were carefully chosen to ensure clarity and practicality. social dimension criteria: within the social dimension, “occupational health & safety systems,” “interest & rights of employees,” and “information disclosure” were selected based on their relevance in both the studies of luthra et al. (2017) and el barky et al. (2022). the criteria “interests & rights of employees” effectively combines and represents the former two, streamlining the ssc. environmental & circular dimension criteria: in our cm, environmental and circularity criteria are specifically focused on keeping resources within the supply chain loop for as long as possible, thereby minimizing waste and promoting resource efficiency. while some of the studied literature for comparison places circularity concepts under the heading of “environmental” criteria (el barky et al., 2022; luthra et al., 2017), others place them under the heading of “circularity” criteria (münch et al., 2022). therefore, we used the heading “environmental and circular” in our cm. for the environmental and circular dimensions, similarities between studies by luthra et al. (2017), el barky et al. (2022) and münch et al. (2022) were identified. “environmental management systems” (el barky et al., 2022; luthra et al., 2017) and “environmental certifications” (münch et al., 2022) were considered, with the latter used in our cm, providing a more practical and insightful representation as it indicates if a company has been able to establish environmental management systems. additionally, the criteria “eco-friendly raw material for packaging and in producing the product” and “eco-friendly transportation” are chosen for their specificity and relevance across multiple studies. the connections of these criteria to circularity are described below: environmental certifications: certifications like iso 14001 demonstrate a supplier’s commitment to environmental management, aligning with sustainable supply chain practices by reducing negative environmental impacts. in terms of circularity, possessing an environmental certificate serves as an initial step towards identifying and implementing ce initiatives (marrucci et al., 2022). research has demonstrated a positive correlation between the adoption of ce practices and the presence european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/9819 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 10 of an environmental management system (fonseca et al., 2018). consequently, environmental certifications are recognized as a key enabler for the implementation of circular supply chains (bodova, 2017). eco-friendly raw materials and packaging: this criterion emphasizes the use of materials that are environmentally friendly throughout their lifecycle, including sourcing, production, and disposal. the significance of packaging in achieving a closedloop system is especially emphasized by several factors: the critical role of packaging waste management (niero et al., 2017) and the reuse of packaging to promote circularity (silva & pålsson, 2022). eco-friendly transportation: sustainable transportation methods aim to reduce carbon emissions and other pollutants, contributing to a lower overall environmental footprint (luthra et al., 2017). our initial conceptual model derived from the aforementioned literature review consists of the criteria shown in table 1. table i: initial conceptual model economic environmental& circular social quality environmental certifications interests & rights of employees price eco-friendly raw materials&packaging information disclosure delivery eco-friendly transportation source: authors’ own elaboration throughout the study, circularity criteria are comprehensively integrated into the supplier selection form. initially, the conceptual model sets the foundation by including key environmental and circularity criteria such as environmental certifications, the use of recyclable raw materials for packaging and products, and eco-friendly transportation. subsequently, empirical findings through supplier interviews validate these criteria and highlight additional practical considerations. the practical problem requires a strategic tool facilitating supplier selection. the emphasis is on creating a set of sscs that will aid in the effective gathering of pertinent information. the establishment of an ssc is supposed to enable the design of an ssfof in which internal requirements and external challenges will be considered, making the ssfof mutually beneficial. the ssfof should be a handy tool that eases the exchange and knowledge-sharing processes. by offering support in the upstream supply chain, this study contributes to the producer’s desire to expand its circular business model to the target market country in northern europe. the following research questions allow the researcher to realize the objective of this research. our mrq for this study is: "what strategic circular ssc can be empirically validated to address the gap in integrating circular economy principles within international supplier selection frameworks?" we broke down the mrq into research questions (rqs) and sub-research questions (srqs) as follows: rq1: which ssc can be derived from the producer’s and supplier’s internal requirements? european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/9819 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 11 understanding the producer’s and supplier’s internal requirements is vital for shaping relevant ssc. semi-structured interviews allow us to uncover factors which influence purchasing decisions. this ensures that derived sscs are tailored to internal needs. in conducting a thematic analysis, an initial set of ssc will be derived. this will serve as a foundational step in consideration for the ssfof, enabling us to create an ssc that aids in the acquisition of information in line with internal requirements. rq2: which ssc can be validated in terms of suppliers’ ability to provide information respectively? this question focuses on testing and approving criteria viability. expert interviews with eco company’s experienced and inexperienced suppliers assess if these criteria enable suppliers to provide the necessary information. furthermore, it allows the ssc to be tested and identifies potential challenges suppliers face in information provision. ensuring the criteria’s practical validation is vital for the incorporation into the ssfof. the goal is to finalize criteria that align with internal requirements while considering the supplier’s practical challenges. srq1: which ssc facilitate the acquisition of relevant information from suppliers? srq2: what challenges need consideration to enhance suppliers' ability to provide information for producer’s supplier selection in the target market country?”. these srqs evaluate criteria that can be validated due to the supplier’s ability to provide information leading to immediate application in the ssfof. the aim is to conclude that ssc won’t need further consideration. this study involves two distinct phases employing a two-phased iterative process for validation and supplementation. phase 1 focuses on answering rq1. it begins with a comprehensive exploration of the supplier’s and producer's internal sss to compile relevant ssc using a cm. this cm serves as a benchmark for comparing and contrasting primary data against validated ssc from four authors, facilitating triangulation for validation (verhoeven, 2022). the second phase addresses rq2 by answering two srqs. the first explores how ssc facilitates the acquisition of relevant information from suppliers, while the second investigates challenges requiring consideration to enhance suppliers' ability to provide information in the target market country (figure 1). 3.2 research design a substantial number of studies have been carried out on the supplier selection problem with various evaluation criteria and methods for traditional, green, and sustainable supply chains. we initially reviewed such research on supplier selection, which also included a review of the prior work in these fields. afterwards, we used a longitudinal single case study methodology (edmondson & mcmanus, 2007; yin, 2013). this approach has been shown to facilitate a more detailed description of a phenomenon (siggelkow, 2007), a deeper exploration of the subject (dyer & wilkins, 1991), and a reassessment of old theoretical relationships (yin, 2013), which are in line with the objectives of this study. our study spans one year. in the duration of one year, the following aspects of the research have been carried out: multi-phased approach: our study is divided into two distinct phases, each requiring sufficient time to thoroughly explore and validate the supplier selection criteria. phase 1 involves an initial exploration of internal requirements through semi-structured european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/9819 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 12 interviews, while phase 2 focuses on validating these criteria with industry experts and suppliers. this iterative process ensures that the criteria are suitable and applicable in real-world scenarios. figure 1: research methodology source: authors’ own elaboration overview of research questions results validation phase 1: which ssc can be derived from producer’s and supplier’s internal requirements? initial ssc validation & complementation through literature phase 2: which ssc can be validated in terms of suppliers’ ability to provide information respectively? -which ssc facilitate the acquisition of relevant information from suppliers? -what challenges need consideration to enhance suppliers’ ability to provide information for producer’s supplier selection in the target market country? validated ssc challenges & suggestions validation through experts complementation through experts validated ssc considering suppliers’ practical realities. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/9819 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 13 data collection: a one-year period allowed for data collection through multiple rounds of interviews and interactions with key stakeholders. this duration was used to capture detailed insights and make necessary adjustments to the criteria based on feedback and practical challenges encountered during implementation. validation and refinement: the longitudinal aspect of the study provided ample time for the validation and refinement of the supplier selection criteria. it allowed for observing the practical application of these criteria in the business operations of eco company and its joint venture partners, ensuring that the criteria are not only theoretically sound but also practically viable. we also used a collaborative research design, incorporating business perspectives while contributing to a theory (freytag & young, 2017) in a mixed-approach framework. the case study benefits from previous theoretical findings and aims to expand them with empirical findings from the business. our case study is an “illustrative” case study. an illustrative case study is a research approach used to describe and explain a specific instance of a phenomenon, often to highlight its key characteristics, context, and implications. an illustrative case study offers a thorough and detailed description of the case, capturing essential details that help illuminate the broader phenomenon being studied (yin, 2013). it situates the case within its broader context, allowing researchers to explore how specific factors and conditions influence the observed outcomes (stake, 1995). by providing concrete examples, illustrative case studies help explain theoretical concepts, making them more accessible and understandable to readers (merriam, 2009). they often focus on real-world applications and implications, demonstrating how theoretical principles are implemented in practice and highlighting best practices and lessons learned (eisenhardt & graebner, 2007). in the context of this research, eco company serves as an illustrative case study to explore and validate circular supplier selection criteria. by focusing on eco company's innovative circular economy practices and strategic goals for international expansion, the study provides a detailed and practical example of how circular principles can be integrated into supplier selection processes. this approach helps to clarify the theoretical concepts and demonstrate their practical application, offering insights for both researchers and practitioners in the field of sustainable supply chain management. 3.3 description of the company used for the case study the case study company (referred to as eco company) is a company established in 2015 in the netherlands. the company aims to eradicate wasteful production processes, products, and materials to challenge traditional norms in the furniture industry. the company stands out for its innovative approach to reusing and revitalizing waste materials and residual flows. by embodying a pioneer in transforming wasteful upholstery processes, the company envisions a future where design and industrial solutions align with the principles of a circular economy. through a patented grinder, the eco company can grind waste materials, including textiles, leather, and cork, into a versatile coating. the ground powder can be sprayed on top of a patented binder, which allows refurbishing any object within seconds. to ensure an efficient grinding process and compatibility, eco company’s binder waste materials need to fulfil eco company’s internal requirements. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/9819 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 14 in addition to eco company's initiatives in refurbishing end-of-life items, they have procured furniture foam from tennis balls to create furniture from scratch. this development led to a broad spectrum of projects, including interior and exterior furniture design projects, industrial projects, and customized offers. to build up on its circularity promise, eco company has made its furniture available as a leasing option for seasonal use. the company advocates for local sourcing to maintain a tight connection between suppliers and production. eco company aims to expand internationally through a joint venture model. the company desires to extend the benefit of its technology internationally. in this regard, the north european company "eco design" emerged as a fitting joint venture partner for eco company's endeavours. eco design, specifically focused on design, seeks out small waste particle sizes to refine and explore the diverse attributes of particles within materials. this involves examining shapes and forms that can be applied in various ways. they are dedicated to investigating the effective utilization of different forms, particles, and structures of waste, making eco company’s technology a supporting facilitator. the choice of eco company as the case study subject is based on several reasons: alignment with research objectives: eco company's business model is inherently circular, aiming to transform waste materials into valuable products. this alignment with circular economy principles provides a rich context for exploring and validating circular supplier selection criteria, directly addressing the research question of how to enable international expansion through new supplier selection based on circular principles. innovative practices: eco company employs a patented technology for grinding waste materials, including textiles, leather, and cork, into a versatile coating. this coating can be applied to refurbish objects within seconds, displaying a practical and scalable application of circular economy concepts. the company's innovative approach to material reuse and its potential for broader industrial applications make it an illustrative example of circular economy practices in action. strategic fit for international expansion: eco company is prepared for international expansion through a joint venture with eco design, a north european company. eco design is focused on refining and exploring the diverse attributes of waste particles, aiming to utilize various waste forms in innovative ways. this partnership underlines the practical relevance of developing supplier selection criteria that can support eco company's expansion into new markets, highlighting the need for a strategic framework that considers international regulatory, cultural, and environmental contexts. local sourcing and environmental impact: eco company advocates for local sourcing to maintain a tight connection between suppliers and production, ensuring that waste materials meet their stringent internal requirements. this local sourcing strategy not only supports the regional economy but also minimizes the environmental impact associated with transportation. the company's dedication to sourcing materials locally while preparing for international expansion presents a unique opportunity to study the practicalities and challenges of implementing circular supply chain practices on a global scale. comprehensive circular business model: beyond refurbishing end-of-life items, eco company has developed furniture foam from tennis balls, demonstrating its ability to create new products from waste. this broad spectrum of projects, including interior and exterior furniture design, industrial projects, and customized offers, illustrates the versatility and potential of their european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/9819 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 15 circular business model. additionally, their leasing option for furniture underscores their commitment to circularity by promoting reuse and extending product life cycles. 3.4 data collection and analysis method data collection is carried out in two phases. for each phase, interviews have been carried out using purposive sampling criteria. for all purposive sampling procedures, the focus is less on the number of participants to be selected and more on which specific participants should be chosen to provide saturation to the data to be collected (hammersley, 2015). a case study methodology often employs one or two case studies to deeply investigate a specific phenomenon or institution (saunders et al., 2015). therefore, data are subsequently collected from either all participants or a selected sample of participants within these case studies. the interviewees have been selected according to the following criteria, based also on the study of knott et al. (2022) : relevance to the research question: the interviewees were selected based on their relevance to the study's focus on circular supplier selection within the context of sustainable supply chain management. this aligns with the research objective of identifying and validating key criteria for selecting suppliers who align with circular economy objectives. expertise and experience: eco company’s chief commercial officer (cco) and senior representatives are chosen for their strategic roles and in-depth knowledge of the company's supplier selection processes and criteria. their expertise is crucial for understanding the company's objectives and the details of its material acquisition for circular economy practices. eco design representatives are selected for their specialized knowledge in local waste material sourcing and their analytical approach to material utilization. their perspective complements the commercial focus of eco company and provides a deeper understanding of experimental approaches to waste material utilization. diverse perspectives: three suppliers were included to provide practical insights and validate the criteria from the perspective of those involved in recycling and sustainability practices. this diversity in interviewees ensures that the study captures a broad range of experiences and perspectives. purposive sampling: a purposive sampling method was employed to select information-rich cases relevant to the study's scope. this approach ensures that the selected interviewees can provide in-depth and specific insights, enhancing the reliability of the data collected. empirical and practical relevance: the interviewees were chosen for their direct involvement in material sourcing, supplier selection, or waste management processes relevant to the circular economy. this empirical relevance ensures that the data collected is pertinent to the study’s objectives, thus enhancing the validity of the findings. inclusion and exclusion criteria: the inclusion criteria were based on the interviewees' roles, expertise in sustainable and circular practices, and their involvement in strategic sourcing and supplier selection. exclusion criteria likely included individuals without direct involvement or expertise in these areas, ensuring that the interview data was relevant and valuable for the study. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/9819 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 16 phase one: in addressing rq 1, primary data was collected through semi-structured interviews. the exploratory nature of this phase made semi-structured interviews suitable, allowing for flexible exploration and qualitative in-depth insights. a thematic framework (figure 2) guided the conversation. interviews involved eco company's cco, and two senior representatives of eco company, and two representatives from eco design who are experts in local waste materials sourcing. open-ended questions were employed to gain a comprehensive understanding of the companies’ operating context and supplier specifications. table ii: thematic framework semi-structured interviews themes explanation understanding the business context. getting an understanding of the business context allows the researcher to have a better contextual understanding, prolonging the researcher’s engagement in the research process. current requirements for suppliers. getting an understanding of current requirements allows to uncover intrinsic sscs that are crucial for the aim of this research. the additional value of the ssfof understanding the purpose and the value of the ssfof allows to indicate further requirements for the ssfof and uncovers preferred features that the ssfof should have. the value that suppliers can bring to the business operations. understanding the values that suppliers can bring to producers and suppliers triggers a better understanding of what kind of information they need to get in the ssfof. source: authors’ own elaboration thematic analysis, applying both deductive and inductive approaches, was utilized to analyse the primary data set. the deductive approach, initiated by the predetermined themes and codes from the literature review and thematic framework, provided a structured baseline for analysis. however, an inductive approach allowed for the emergence of unexpected themes during the analysis, maximizing depth (dawadi, 2020). a six-phased thematic analysis approach was applied, involving familiarizing with data, generating initial codes, searching for themes, reviewing themes, defining and naming themes, and producing the report (nowell et al., 2017). this reflexive process maintained alignment with research objectives and clientcentricity, resulting in a refined set of ssc derived from the producer’s and supplier’s internal requirements. combining a deductive approach with an inductive approach enabled a dynamic interplay between pre-established themes and those emerging from interviews. the adjustment aimed to maintain alignment with research objectives and client-centricity, resulting in a comprehensive and tailored thematic analysis based on the refined thematic framework. phase two: in the second phase, we address rq2 and two srqs. the examination of the initial set of ssc is accomplished through expert interviews, wherein industry experts provide insights to verify ssc feasibility and reliability or highlight areas requiring considerations to align ssc with practical supplier realities. this phase introduces the international aspects of ssc and circularity. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/9819 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 17 structured interviews were employed to gain insights into supplier practical realities concerning ssc. these interviews, designed for the extraction of specific responses, promote standardization to facilitate meaningful analysis (rashidi et al., 2014). this approach proves suitable for validating ssc while allowing flexibility for deeper insights into suppliers' practical realities. the target group for these structured interviews was identified using a non-probability sampling method, specifically the purposive sampling method, chosen to optimize data sources for qualitative research in information-rich cases related to the study's scope (palinkas et al., 2015). the sample size, determined based on data saturation rather than statistical power analysis, included two dutch suppliers with experience working with eco company and one supplier in the target market country in northern europe. this selection aimed to provide unbiased and critical perspectives on practical realities faced by suppliers in northern europe, enhancing the applicability of ssc for the target market. supplier 1 is a multinational company operating in the athletic footwear and apparel industry. they are located in belgium and have experience in working with eco company. the interviewee was part of the sustainability/recycling department and was in charge of the recycling operations for both footwear and apparel. within the scope of its mandate, it is important to identify matching partners who are able to work with the company’s recycled materials to put them back into new products or back into the company’s ecosystem. supplier 2 is a multinational company operating in the footwear industry, and they do have experience working with eco company. the interviewees were part of the global sourcing team, which is responsible for strategic sourcing, supplier selection, contracting, and negotiating on behalf of different technical factors. supplier 3 is a waste management company located in the target market country in northern europe. the company collects waste materials of companies from various industries. two representatives of the company participated in the meeting. they are part of the development department. for data analysis, a second thematic analysis, focused on suppliers' ability to provide information, has been executed. this deductive approach utilized the initial ssc as an overarching theme. responses from suppliers were assessed not only based on fulfilling criteria but also on their ability to provide information. this facilitated the addressing of srqs 1 and 2. challenges in providing information were considered opportunities either to exclude a specific ssc or to frame questions in a way that would enable suppliers to address these challenges. analysing data regarding suppliers' ability to provide information inherently involves the researcher's judgment, impacting the objectivity of the analysis. to enhance objectivity, the majority of "positive" or "negative" responses were considered. two positive responses (indicating suppliers' ability to provide information) outweighed one negative response (indicating challenges), leading to the validation of the ssc. conversely, two negative responses outweighed one positive response, prompting the identification of challenges and providing suggestions for the ssfof. in cases where suppliers were unable to suggest ways to address their limitations, the ssc would be excluded from the ssfof. 4. analysis and results in order to understand which ssc can be derived from the producer’s and supplier’s internal requirements, semi-structured interviews have been carried out with the respective company representatives of eco company and eco design. the topic european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/9819 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 18 guide for the interview with eco company included material requirements, supplier assessment, grinding process, market expansion, collaboration and marketing, supplier information form, colour specifications, waste material definitions, economic dimension, location and waste materials. the interviews spanned a period of 1 year, and a series of 5 interviews were carried out ranging from 60-90 minutes. the semi-structured interviews with eco company revealed key insights into the company's requirements and criteria for selecting suppliers of waste materials. in the interviews, the interviewees conveyed a comprehensive approach to supplier selection and material acquisition for circular economy practices. emphasizing the importance of particle size and structure, he highlighted the efficiency gained from using pre-processed materials while acknowledging the challenges associated with larger materials. sustainability was a main criterion, with a preference for organic materials and a clear aversion to plastics. the interviewees expressed strategic interest in the target market in northern europe, citing its abundance of various waste materials. collaborative aspects of supplier relationships were underscored, emphasizing mutual promotion and the creation of marketing value. the interviewees concluded by highlighting the need to understand the locations of production facilities, providing insights into the geographical distribution of waste materials crucial for eco company's strategic decision-making. the topic guide for the interviews with eco design included the company approach, utilization of waste as an analytical tool, design methodology contribution, global utilization of waste, investigation criteria and experimental stage tools for material categorization. there were a series of 7 interviews, each ranging from 60-90 minutes. in the interviews with representatives of eco design, a company involved in waste stream utilization, they shared insights into their experimental approach compared to eco company's commercial venture. they explained that their work is more analytical and experimental, aiming to refine materials through complex processes for application. they illustrated this with an example of using accumulated dust from a mining company as a colouring agent. they emphasized their role in contributing design methodology to eco company's technology and outlined their interest in utilizing diverse waste materials globally. the discussion also touched on criteria for investigating waste streams, such as particle size and purity, and the challenge of determining substances in recycled materials. the interview highlighted their experimental stage and the need for tools to categorize materials for better communication with waste management companies. in the iterative phase of coding the interviews, the following process was followed: step 1: data familiarization: the initial step involves familiarizing with the data, wherein predefined themes and codes are recognized, understood and coloured during the review and engagement with interview data. step 2: generation of initial codes: the emphasis is placed on selective quotes. repetitively mentioned quotes are coded to develop inductive codes representing internal sss. these codes are cross-referenced with codes and themes from the concept model. through this process, the following observations emerged: 1. identification of matching codes: from the primary data set, codes such as "pricing" and "certification have been identified to align with cm codes. while the remaining cm codes complement the internal sss, the criterion "quality" is excluded due to eco company’s and eco design’s inductive codes providing more tailored quality specifications, aiming to maintain simplicity and utility for suppliers. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/9819 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 19 2. terms mentioned by stakeholders: certain terms, including "quantity," "collaboration," "supplier engagement," and "sustainability incentive," mentioned by eco company or eco design representatives, align with cm themes. 3. inductive codes: five terms – "type of material," "size & structure," "purity," "colors," and "material categorization" – emerged as inductive codes. although unmatched with cm codes or themes, these inductive codes enhance the existing set of ssc, proving relevant for eco company and eco design. table iii: revised themes and codes theme economic & material details environment & circular social codes type of material material categorization size & structure supplier engagement purity colours price quantity delivery collaboration sustainability incentive environmental certifications eco-friendly raw materials and packaging eco-friendly transportation interests & right of employees information disclosure source: authors’ own elaboration steps 3, 4, and 5: theme confirmation, review, and naming: in the subsequent steps (3), (4), and (5), the process involves searching for, reviewing, and naming themes. the confirmation of pre-defined themes is initiated by aligning matching inductive codes. key observations during this process are detailed below: 1. allocation of inductive codes: inductive codes such as "pricing" and "certification" align seamlessly with predetermined themes such as "economic" and "environmental & circular" due to their correlation with deductive codes. additionally, inductive codes "quantity," "collaboration," and "supplier engagement" find alignment under the theme "economic." 2. social theme consideration: no direct inductive codes align with the "social" theme. however, the persistence of the theme and its associated codes is warranted based on their relevance, as emphasized by (luthra et al., 2017) and (el barky et al., 2022). 3. emerging themes: the examination of inductive codes that don't match with the cm leads to the identification of new themes. codes like "type of material," "size & structure," "purity," "colors," and "material categorization" point towards a thematic focus on assessing materials based on their features. consequently, the introduction of the theme "material details" is justified, providing comprehensive information about the materials. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/9819 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 20 4. integration of economic and material details: the interview emphasizes the paramount importance of materials in the ssfof. the economic details related to materials, as crucial determinants, warrant a thematic amalgamation. thus, the theme "economic & material details" is proposed to combine these dimensions, enhancing clarity and utility for eco company in utilizing the information. step 6: report production: the final step involves producing the thematic analysis report. the adjusted cm, incorporating the refined themes, has been integrated into the report. this revised model encapsulates the comprehensive understanding derived from the thematic analysis, providing a qualitative structure tailored to eco company’s specific needs. the clarity achieved through the "economic & material details" theme enhances the utility of the ssfof, eco company interviewee’s emphasis on a clear overview. table iv: initial draft of ssc ssc definition economic & material details type of material information about the type of materials. material categorization the ability to categorize the material according to by-product, post-consumer, post-industrial, or finished-product waste. size & structure information about the particle sizes and ability to provide smaller waste particles. supplier engagement suppliers have the ability to commit to eco company’s concept to the extent that they find suitable waste streams for eco company without having previous specifications. purity the ability to provide information about the substances contained in a material. colours providing information about the availability of colours. quantity an understanding of how much a company can supply on a monthly, quarterly, or yearly basis. delivery the ability of suppliers to meet specified delivery schedules, including the lead time (taherdoost & brard, 2019) collaboration existing interest for mutual collaboration in terms of projects/solutions enhancing the marketing value. environmental & circular sustainability incentive a company’s sustainability mission, targets, or initiatives. environmental certifications possession of environment-related certifications, e.g., iso 14001, emas, and carbon trust standard (münch et al., 2022). eco-friendly raw materials and packaging using recyclable materials for packaging and producing the product (el barky et al., 2022) eco-friendly transportation use of clean and suitable vehicles to distribute and collect the products for recycling (münch et al., 2022) social interests & right of employees the suppliers’ respect for its workers’ rights, employment insurance, standard working hours, and employment compensations (el barky et al., 2022) european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/9819 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 21 information disclosure providing information to the suppliers, customers and stakeholders regarding material used, carbon emissions and toxins released during production (luthra et al., 2017) source: authors’ own elaboration the semi-structured interviews with representatives of eco company and eco design provided important insights into their supplier selection criteria for waste materials, emphasizing the importance of material characteristics, geographical considerations, collaborative relationships, experimental approaches, and material categorization. using pre-processed materials, particularly smaller, consistent particle sizes, improves production quality and aligns with eco company's sustainability goals by favouring organic over plastic materials. strategic interest in northern europe supports production needs while optimizing logistics and reducing carbon footprints. collaborative relationships advance innovation and shared growth, enhancing the company’s circular economy goals. eco design’s experimental focus on refining and repurposing diverse waste streams complements eco company's operations, offering new market opportunities. accurate material categorization streamlines procurement processes, ensuring a consistent supply of high-quality waste materials, thus supporting operational efficiency and sustainability. after this initial stage, the following section examines the second phase by testing and approving the viability of ssc. the second phase determines ssc that can be validated and challenges which need to be considered in the ssfof. first, we studied which ssc enable the acquisition of relevant information from suppliers. this section undertakes an analysis to promptly validate specific sscs based on suppliers' ability to provide information, facilitating their immediate application in the ssfof. we interviewed three suppliers for this analysis. the conclusion of this section will present the successfully validated ssc. the topic guide for this section included an overview of organization, types and categorization of materials, particle sizes of materials, recognition of smaller waste materials, purity of recycled materials, adaptation to client requirements, determining the pricing of materials, collaborations with customers, sustainability practices, environment-related certifications, circular practices in the supply chain, clean transportation initiatives, and employee safety and well-being. five interviews have been carried out in total, each lasting 75-90 minutes, supplier 1 focused on recycling footwear and apparel, targeting post-consumer, post-industrial, and finished product waste. their recycling processes yield specific material types, such as textiles, foams, rubber, and leather, with fixed particle sizes due to the limitations of their machinery. while they show flexibility in quantities supplied, they face challenges in altering material sizes and colours to meet specific client requirements. their approach to sustainability is comprehensive, involving initiatives for environmental and social responsibility, including using recycled materials in new products. however, the company acknowledges gaps in awareness about smaller waste outputs and the potential value they hold. supplier 2 emphasized the company's vertically integrated structure, enabling control over the quality and types of waste produced in-house. their waste materials, primarily categorized as post-industrial waste, include leather and textiles. they have fixed particle sizes for their waste materials and face challenges in adjusting these sizes due to the need for additional machinery and investment. their approach to sustainability includes rigorous auditing processes for suppliers, emphasizing corporate social responsibility and european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/9819 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 22 environmental impact. however, like supplier 1, supplier 2 also recognizes limitations in identifying and utilizing smaller, less obvious waste streams. supplier 3 operates in a broader waste management context, dealing with various waste materials across the target market country. their focus is on standardized waste fractions, with less emphasis on specific fibres or raw materials. they acknowledge the need for better strategies to identify valuable materials in waste streams and the challenges of adjusting their systems for new types of waste. their approach involves exploring innovative ways to connect upstream suppliers with downstream demands and leveraging organizational shifts to focus more on sustainable practices. however, they, too, face challenges in effectively identifying and utilizing smaller waste streams and ensuring the purity and detailed classification of recycled materials. across all three suppliers, a common theme emerges: while there is a commitment to recycling and sustainability, there are operational challenges in terms of machinery limitations, size and colour flexibility, and the identification of valuable smaller waste streams. these challenges highlight the need for innovation and more effective communication strategies in the recycling and waste management industry to fully utilize the potential of all waste materials, particularly smaller, less recognized streams. upon analysis of the interviews, the ssc "material type" and "material categorization" were promptly validated. first, suppliers' responses affirm their competence in providing information regarding material types. second, the usage of terms such as "post-consumer waste," "post-industrial waste," "by-product," and "finished-product waste" has been substantiated as key in identifying waste streams. table v: summary of the validated ssc theme economic & material details environment & circular social ssc type of materials material categorization collaboration sustainability incentive environmental certifications eco-friendly raw materials and packaging eco-friendly transportation interests & right of employees information disclosure source: authors’ own elaboration afterwards, we also validated the ssc "collaboration." this was evident as all suppliers engaged in collaborations with other companies beyond mere material supply and recognised the value of close collaboration for mutual development. subsequently, we also validated the ssc "sustainability incentive" and "environmental certifications." suppliers effectively provide information about their sustainability incentives and unanimously confirm the possession of environmental certifications by their respective companies. continuing the validation process, we validated the ssc "eco-friendly raw materials and packaging". suppliers demonstrate their ability to communicate internal initiatives by incorporating eco-friendly raw materials during the design and purchasing stages of product development and packaging. furthermore, supplier 3, a waste management company, is seen as inherently supporting the incorporation of waste materials in their processes. afterwards, we validated the ssc "eco-friendly transportation". suppliers underscore the use of clean and sustainable vehicles for the distribution and collection of products for recycling. despite the lack of initiative from supplier 2, the ssc is validated european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/9819 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 23 due to the mature plans of suppliers 1 and 2 to accelerate the shift to eco-friendly transportation, outweighing the response of supplier 2. finally, we validated the ssc "interests & rights of employees" and "information disclosure." all suppliers communicated their companies' initiatives regarding corporate social responsibility (csr), referencing reports that demonstrate efforts in both csr and sustainability initiatives. in conclusion, the analysis affirms the immediate validation of the specified ssc, providing a robust foundation for their seamless integration into the ssfof. through expert interviews with three suppliers, several sscs were validated for their practical applicability and impact on operations. knowing the type of materials that the suppliers can provide is fundamental for meeting production requirements, aiding eco company in making informed decisions and reducing supply chain disruptions. collaboration with suppliers enables innovation and sustainable practices, enhancing product quality and sustainability. suppliers' commitment to sustainability and possession of environmental certifications supports eco company's environmental goals and mitigates reputational risks. using eco-friendly raw materials and packaging minimizes environmental impact, promoting recycling and supporting the circular economy model. sustainable transportation practices reduce the logistics carbon footprint while respecting employee rights and ensuring safe working conditions, enhancing eco company's ethical standards. the analysis also identified challenges, such as fixed material sizes and limited awareness of smaller waste outputs, with suggestions to address these issues, including providing standard-size information, enhancing communication, and offering technical data sheets. flexibility in quantity and delivery was noted, but pricing variability and colour availability depend on production factors, with suggestions to indicate available colours and lead times. the following analyses focus on specific supplier challenges that require further consideration, particularly concerning the provision of information. seven ssc challenges have been identified, and this section aims to present these challenges along with corresponding suggestions from suppliers to address the obstacles. initially, a common challenge was highlighted among suppliers, which was adjusting material sizes. (1) all suppliers mentioned having fixed sizes for supply. (2) however, they clarified their ability to provide information about these sizes. (3) supplier three proposed using industry information, processes, and end-products as indicators to identify smaller waste streams. afterwards, we identified suppliers' difficulties in engaging with eco company’s concept by identifying smaller waste outputs. (1) suppliers emphasized the general challenge of offering smaller waste outputs due to a lack of awareness regarding the value of these materials. (2) recommendations include communicating eco company’s concept, emphasizing the value of these materials, and showcasing examples of use cases to encourage suppliers to support the initiative. then, we identified challenges that suppliers face in providing detailed information about substances contained in materials. (1) suppliers noted their inability to furnish intricate details about material substances. (2) suggestions were made to overcome this limitation, including the provision of technical data sheets or rough overviews of these materials. we also identified the challenge of determining pricing, indicating variability depending on a case-by-case basis. (1) suppliers did not provide specific suggestions on how to accommodate this challenge within the ssfof. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/9819 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 24 finally, we illustrated suppliers' ability to adjust the quantity, delivery, and colours of waste materials. (1) suppliers expressed flexibility regarding quantity. (2) colors and delivery depend on production, with suggestions to provide indications on available colours and average lead-time or quantity. table vi: challenges of suppliers and suggestions to accommodate these challenges ssc challenges suggestions size & structure fixed sizes. indications about the sizes can be provided. knowledge about processes and end products can give indications of where unrecognized waste outputs might appear. supplier engagement lacking knowledge about the value of smaller waste outputs. need to communicate knowledge and examples to foster suppliers’ mentality purity limitations in determining the substances of materials. they can provide either a technical data sheet or a rough overview can be provided price has to be decided upon request. no suggestions have been made. colours depends on waste outputs. they can tell what colours will be available. quantity depends on the waste outputs. they are quite flexible. mostly steady flow. delivery depends on inventory. lead times could be indicated. source: authors’ own elaboration in general, the ssfof does not eliminate communication to suppliers at all. nor does it enable the identification of the ideal supplier. however, due to the guidance of relevant ssc, the ssfof enable the collection of pertinent information, facilitating the identification of suppliers while reducing time-intensive back-and-forth communication. the ssfof should be used as a starting point for negotiations with suppliers. this allows to pose more specified questions within the conversation without cherry-picking the necessary information. the ssfof increases transparency for both entities, which allows for more efficient and straightforward communication, fostering a mutually beneficial partnership. the validated ssc significantly impact eco company and eco design's operations and supply chain management, directly aligning with their circularity ambitions. knowing the types of materials available ensures high product quality and supply chain resilience by diversifying the supplier base and reducing risks associated with supply chain disruptions. this is crucial for maintaining a steady flow of recycled materials, which supports the company’s goal of minimizing reliance on virgin materials. collaborative relationships with suppliers enable joint innovation in sustainable practices, leading to mutual benefits such as cost savings and increased market competitiveness. this collaboration enables the development of new products from waste materials, driving the circular economy model forward. ensuring suppliers possess relevant environmental certifications and sustainability incentives helps eco company comply with international regulations, enhance brand reputation and attract eco-conscious consumers and investors, all of which are vital for sustaining their circular economy initiatives. using eco-friendly materials and packaging reduces waste, decreases the demand for virgin materials, and can lead to cost savings in waste management, supporting the company’s circularity goals. sustainable transportation practices lower the carbon footprint and improve operational efficiency through optimized routing and reduced fuel consumption, contributing to the european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/9819 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 25 company’s environmental sustainability targets. ensuring suppliers respect employee rights and maintain safe working conditions creates an ethical supply chain, which is essential for the company’s social responsibility commitments within a circular economy. addressing challenges related to fixed material sizes, limited awareness of smaller waste outputs, and difficulty in providing detailed material information enhances production flexibility and supports the efficient utilization of all available waste materials. enhanced communication and standardized processes ensure that eco company can fully leverage its sscs to promote innovation, regulatory compliance, and ethical practices, ultimately strengthening its position as a leader in the circular economy. 5. discussion and conclusions our study aimed to develop and validate circular ssc within the context of circular supply chain management. our findings include insights into the practical application of these criteria, contributing to the literature and offering implications for both academics and industry. in our study, we have identified and addressed the following gaps: initially, our study addressed the lack of empirical evidence on the application of circular ssc by conducting semi-structured interviews providing real-world insights that are often missing in the literature. we developed a practical, scalable, and adaptable ssc framework for an ssfof, validated through supplier interviews to ensure its applicability across different contexts. by integrating circular economy principles into the ssc, focusing on eco-friendly materials, packaging, and transportation, our research aligns supplier selection with the companies’ circularity goals. emphasizing supplier engagement and collaboration, our study highlights the benefits of strong supplier relationships for integrating circularity into the supply chain. additionally, we identified specific materialrelated criteria such as particle size, categorization, and purity to meet stringent quality and sustainability standards. finally, we addressed practical challenges in ssc implementation, such as fixed material sizes and communication about smaller waste outputs, providing solutions to facilitate effective and transparent communication between suppliers and producers. the validated ssc contributes to the literature on sustainable and circular supply chain management. by integrating economic, environmental, and social dimensions, these criteria help companies align their supplier selection processes with circular economy principles. this alignment is crucial for maintaining end-of-life products within the production cycle, reducing reliance on virgin materials, and promoting resource circulation. for business practitioners, the ssfof developed in this study offers a practical tool for strategic supplier selection, facilitating efficient communication and collaboration with suppliers. this tool helps companies gather pertinent information, reducing the time-intensive process of back-and-forth communication and ensuring transparency and mutual understanding. the literature mentions the gap in empirical studies concerning the practical application of circular principles in supplier selection (el barky et al., 2022; tushar et al., 2022). our research not only addresses this gap by empirically validating ssc through supplier responses but also provides a practical framework (ssfof) for incorporating these criteria into the supplier selection process. this contributes insights into overcoming the practical challenges of implementing circular and sustainable supplier selection criteria. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/9819 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 26 the literature also stresses the importance of developing scalable and adaptable criteria (el barky et al., 2022; münch et al., 2022). our approach to integrating both validated and challenging ssc into the ssfof, based on supplier insights and practical realities, exemplifies the scalable and adaptable nature of the criteria developed. this approach ensures that the ssfof can accommodate the variability in supplier capabilities and environmental considerations, thus enhancing the framework's applicability across different contexts and industries. the strategic importance of sourcing materials locally to optimize logistics and reduce transportation costs is highlighted. this geographical focus is unique and not typically emphasized in traditional ssc discussions. our article identifies practical challenges faced by suppliers, such as fixed material sizes and limited awareness of smaller waste outputs, and offers solutions to address these issues. this practical focus on addressing operational challenges is a significant contribution. the emphasis on fostering strong collaborative relationships with suppliers to drive innovation and mutual growth aligns with dynamic capabilities theory (teece et al., 1997) and stakeholder theory (freeman, 1984). this strategic adaptability and focus on collaboration are crucial for implementing sustainable and circular supply chains. on the other hand, rbv suggests that firms gain a competitive advantage by utilizing valuable, rare, inimitable, and nonsubstitutable resources (barney, 1991). this theory is reflected in our study's emphasis on high-quality materials, eco-friendly resources, and strategic geographic advantages, which enhance the company's resource base and competitive edge. dynamic capabilities theory, which emphasizes a firm's ability to adapt and reconfigure its resources in response to changing environments (teece et al., 1997), is shown in the company's adaptability, innovation, and continuous improvement in supplier relationships and sustainability practices. this aligns with the company's dynamic capabilities, which are necessary for maintaining competitiveness in a rapidly changing market. stakeholder theory, which suggests that firms should create value for all stakeholders (freeman, 1984), is evident in the company's commitment to social responsibility, transparency, and community impact. this approach ensures that the company's operations benefit all stakeholders involved. the ce theory emphasizes the continuous use of resources by creating closed-loop systems where products, materials, and resources are reused, refurbished, remanufactured, and recycled (geissdoerfer et al., 2018). our study's criteria, such as the use of recycled materials and eco-friendly packaging, support these principles by minimizing waste and maximizing resource efficiency. the internationalization theory, including the uppsala model and network theory, emphasizes the gradual expansion into foreign markets and the importance of building relationships with international partners (johanson & mattsson, 2015; johanson & vahlne, 1977). our findings highlight strategic sourcing and collaboration with international suppliers, aligning with these theories by leveraging local market conditions and fostering collaborative networks to implement circular economy principles globally. these connections emphasize the robustness of the study's findings and their significant contribution to advancing sustainable and circular supply chain management. our study also provides practical and managerial insights into the development and implementation of circular supplier selection criteria within the context of sustainable supply chain management. firstly, it emphasizes the importance of material characteristics such as particle size, structure, and purity in enhancing production efficiency and maintaining high product quality. this level of detail is crucial for companies aiming to incorporate circular economy principles by ensuring that reclaimed materials can perform equivalently to virgin materials. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/9819 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 27 geographical considerations are highlighted as a strategic factor in supplier selection, with a particular focus on the availability of diverse waste materials. this approach not only supports production needs but also optimizes logistics, reducing transportation costs and the overall carbon footprint. these findings highlight the necessity for companies to strategically source materials from regions that offer both economic and environmental advantages. collaborative relationships with suppliers are identified as essential for fostering innovation and sustainable practices. the study reveals that such collaborations can lead to joint efforts in innovation and marketing, promoting mutual growth and the development of more sustainable supply chains. this insight is particularly valuable for managers seeking to enhance their company's circular economy initiatives by building stronger partnerships with their suppliers. the experimental approach of companies, focusing on refining and utilizing diverse waste streams, complements the commercial operations of those companies. this synergy allows for the exploration of innovative uses for waste materials, such as using mining dust as a colouring agent, which can open new market opportunities and support the company's sustainability goals. material categorization is also emphasized as a critical factor for effective communication and utilization of waste materials. accurate categorization helps streamline the procurement process, ensuring a consistent supply of high-quality waste materials that meet production needs. this practical insight can guide managers in developing more efficient and effective supplier selection processes. overall, the study offers a strategic framework and practical tool, the ssfof, which facilitates efficient supplier evaluations and promotes transparency and collaboration between suppliers and buyers. this tool helps reduce the time-intensive communication typically required in the supplier selection process, making it easier for companies to implement circular economy principles in their supply chains. the emphasis on maintaining high purity standards, material categorization, and fostering collaborative relationships provides a comprehensive approach to enhancing both operational efficiency and sustainability performance. 6. limitations and directions for future research our article has several limitations that need to be acknowledged. firstly, the study relies on a limited number of semi-structured interviews. this small sample size may not fully capture the diversity of perspectives and practices across different industries and geographical regions. secondly, the research emphasizes northern europe for strategic sourcing of waste materials, which might limit the generalizability of the findings to other parts of the world where the availability of waste materials and regulatory environments differ significantly. thirdly, the study is heavily focused on the specific context of companies involved in the recycling and utilization of waste materials, making the findings potentially less applicable to industries with different operational and sustainability challenges. additionally, while the study validates the ssc through interviews, it does not provide quantitative data or case studies to support the effectiveness of these criteria in improving operational performance and sustainability outcomes. to address these limitations, future research should involve a larger and more diverse sample of companies across different industries and geographical regions, helping to understand the applicability and relevance of the european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/9819 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 28 ssc framework in various contexts. conducting quantitative studies to measure the impact of implementing the validated ssc on operational performance, cost savings, and sustainability outcomes would provide more robust evidence of their effectiveness. developing detailed case studies of companies that have successfully implemented the ssc framework could offer practical insights and best practices for other organizations. additionally, investigating the role of digital technologies, such as blockchain and iot, in enhancing the traceability, transparency, and efficiency of circular supply chains could provide valuable insights into the integration of technological solutions with ssc. research should also explore the implementation of circular ssc in regions outside northern europe to understand how different regulatory environments, resource availability, and cultural factors influence the adoption of circular economy practices. longitudinal studies tracking the long-term effects of implementing ssc on supply chain sustainability and business performance would provide deeper insights into the sustained impact of these practices. lastly, further research should focus on identifying and addressing specific barriers to the implementation of circular ssc, such as financial constraints, lack of technical expertise, and resistance to change within organizations. by addressing these limitations and pursuing these suggestions for further research, future studies can build on the findings of this article to provide a more comprehensive understanding of sustainable and circular supply chain management. conflict of interest the authors have no conflict of interest related to this publication. references ali, h., zhang, j., & shoaib, m. (2023). a hybrid approach for sustainable-circular supplier selection based on industry 4.0 framework to make the supply chain smart and eco-friendly. environment, development and sustainability. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10668-023-03567-5 baah, c., agyabeng-mensah, y., afum, e., & kumi, c. a. (2023). do circular economy practices accelerate csr participation of smes in a stakeholder-pressured era? a network theory perspective. journal of cleaner production, 394. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2023.136348 barney, j. (1991). firm resources and sustained competitive advantage. journal of management, 17(1). https://doi.org/10.1177/014920639101700108 batista, l., bourlakis, m., liu, y., smart, p., & sohal, a. (2018). supply chain operations for a circular economy. in production planning and control (vol. 29, issue 6). https://doi.org/10.1080/09537287.2018.1449267 bertassini, a. c., ometto, a. r., severengiz, s., & gerolamo, m. c. (2021). circular economy and sustainability: the role of organizational behaviour in the transition journey. business strategy and the environment, 30(7). https://doi.org/10.1002/bse.2796 bocken, n. m. p., short, s. w., rana, p., & evans, s. (2014). a literature and practice review to develop sustainable business model archetypes. in journal of cleaner production (vol. 65). https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2013.11.039 european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/9819 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 29 bodhanwala, s., & bodhanwala, r. (2020). relationship between sustainable and responsible investing and returns: a global evidence. social responsibility journal, 16(4). https://doi.org/10.1108/srj-12-2018-0332 bodova, e. (2017). tools of environmental management and eu circular economy. mm science journal, 2017(february). https://doi.org/10.17973/mmsj.2017_02_2016145 borland, h., & lindgreen, a. (2013). sustainability, epistemology, ecocentric business, and marketing strategy: ideology, reality, and vision. journal of business ethics, 117(1). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10551-012-1519-8 bundgaard, a. m., mosgaard, m. a., & remmen, a. (2017). from energy efficiency towards resource efficiency within the ecodesign directive. journal of cleaner production, 144. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2016.12.144 calicchio berardi, p., & peregrino de brito, r. (2021). supply chain collaboration for a circular economy from transition to continuous improvement. journal of cleaner production, 328. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2021.129511 chai, j., liu, j. n. k., & ngai, e. w. t. (2013). application of decision-making techniques in supplier selection: a systematic review of literature. expert systems with applications, 40(10). https://doi.org/10.1016/j.eswa.2012.12.040 chai, j., & ngai, e. w. t. (2020). decision-making techniques in supplier selection: recent accomplishments and what lies ahead. in expert systems with applications (vol. 140). https://doi.org/10.1016/j.eswa.2019.112903 choi, t. y., & hartley, j. l. (1996). an exploration of supplier selection practices across the supply chain. journal of operations management, 14(4). https://doi.org/10.1016/s0272-6963(96)00091-5 dawadi, s. (2020). thematic analysis approach: a step by step guide for elt research practitioners. journal of nelta, 25(1–2). https://doi.org/10.3126/nelta.v25i1-2.49731 de boer, l., labro, e., & morlacchi, p. (2001). a review of methods supporting supplier selection. european journal of purchasing and supply management, 7(2). https://doi.org/10.1016/s0969-7012(00)00028-9 dickson, g. w. (1966). an analysis of vendor selection systems and decisions. journal of purchasing, 2(1). https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1745-493x.1966.tb00818.x ding, h., benyoucef, l., & xie, x. (2008). simulation-based evolutionary multi-objective optimisation approach for integrated decision-making in supplier selection. international journal of computer applications in technology, 31(3–4). https://doi.org/10.1504/ijcat.2008.018153 dow, d. (2006). adaptation and performance in foreign markets: evidence of systematic under-adaptation. journal of international business studies, 37(2). https://doi.org/10.1057/palgrave.jibs.8400189 dunning, j. h. (1977). trade, location of economic activity and the mne: a search for an eclectic approach. in the international allocation of economic activity. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-1-349-03196-2_38 dunning, j. h. (1988). the eclectic paradigm of international production: a restatement and some possible extensions. journal of international business studies, 19(1). https://doi.org/10.1057/palgrave.jibs.8490372 dyer, w. g., & wilkins, a. l. (1991). better stories, not better constructs, to generate better theory: a rejoinder to eisenhardt. academy of management review, 16(3). https://doi.org/10.5465/amr.1991.4279492 european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/9819 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 30 edmondson, a. c., & mcmanus, s. e. (2007). methodological fit in management field research. academy of management review, 32(4). https://doi.org/10.5465/amr.2007.26586086 eisenhardt, k. m., & graebner, m. e. (2007). theory building from cases: opportunities and challenges. academy of management journal, 50(1). https://doi.org/10.5465/amj.2007.24160888 eisenhardt, k. m., & martin, j. a. (2000). dynamic capabilities: what are they? strategic management journal, 21(10–11). https://doi.org/10.1002/1097-0266(200010/11)21:10/11<1105::aid-smj133>3.0.co;2-e el barky, s., wong, a. t. c., & morssi, m. (2022). development of sustainable and circular criteria in supplier selection. international journal of procurement management, 1(1). https://doi.org/10.1504/ijpm.2022.10049666 fahimnia, b., sarkis, j., & davarzani, h. (2015). green supply chain management: a review and bibliometric analysis. in international journal of production economics (vol. 162). https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijpe.2015.01.003 farooque, m., zhang, a., liu, y., & hartley, j. l. (2022). circular supply chain management: performance outcomes and the role of eco-industrial parks in china. transportation research part e: logistics and transportation review, 157. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tre.2021.102596 fonseca, l. m., domingues, j. p., pereira, m. t., martins, f. f., & zimon, d. (2018). assessment of circular economy within portuguese organizations. sustainability (switzerland), 10(7). https://doi.org/10.3390/su10072521 foschi, e. a. s. p. a. (2023). linking bioeconomy, circular economy, and sustainability: trends, gaps and future orientation in the bio-based and biodegradable plastics industry. european journal of social impact and circular economy, 4(2), 16–31. foss, n. j., & saebi, t. (2017). fifteen years of research on business model innovation. journal of management, 43(1). https://doi.org/10.1177/0149206316675927 freeman, r. e. (1984). strategic management: a stakeholder approach. pitman: london. in business ethics quarterly (vol. 4, issue 4). freeman, r. e., harrison, j. s., & zyglidopoulos, s. (2018). stakeholder theoryconcepts and strategies. elements in organization theory. freytag, p. v., & young, l. (2017). collaborative research design: working with business for meaningful findings. in collaborative research design: working with business for meaningful findings. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-981-10-5008-4 geissdoerfer, m., morioka, s. n., de carvalho, m. m., & evans, s. (2018). business models and supply chains for the circular economy. journal of cleaner production, 190. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2018.04.159 gölgeci, i., gligor, d. m., lacka, e., & raja, j. z. (2021). understanding the influence of servitization on global value chains: a conceptual framework. international journal of operations and production management, 41(5). https://doi.org/10.1108/ijopm-08-2020-0515 govindan, k., & hasanagic, m. (2018). a systematic review on drivers, barriers, and practices towards circular economy: a supply chain perspective. international journal of production research, 56(1–2). https://doi.org/10.1080/00207543.2017.1402141 european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/9819 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 31 govindan, k., khodaverdi, r., & jafarian, a. (2013). a fuzzy multi criteria approach for measuring sustainability performance of a supplier based on triple bottom line approach. journal of cleaner production, 47, 345–354. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2012.04.014 govindan, k., mina, h., esmaeili, a., & gholami-zanjani, s. m. (2020). an integrated hybrid approach for circular supplier selection and closed loop supply chain network design under uncertainty. journal of cleaner production, 242. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2019.118317 govindan, k., rajendran, s., sarkis, j., & murugesan, p. (2015). multi criteria decision making approaches for green supplier evaluation and selection: a literature review. journal of cleaner production, 98. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2013.06.046 grant, r. m. (1991). the resource-based theory of competitive advantage: implications for strategy formulation. california management review, 33(3). https://doi.org/10.2307/41166664 greenwood, m. (2007). stakeholder engagement: beyond the myth of corporate responsibility. journal of business ethics, 74(4). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10551-007-9509-y grimm, j. h., hofstetter, j. s., & sarkis, j. (2014). critical factors for sub-supplier management: a sustainable food supply chains perspective. international journal of production economics, 152. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijpe.2013.12.011 hammersley, m. (2015). sampling and thematic analysis: a response to fugard and potts. international journal of social research methodology, 18(6). https://doi.org/10.1080/13645579.2015.1005456 hart, s. l. (1995). a natural-resource-based view of the firm. academy of management review, 20(4), 986–1014. https://doi.org/10.5465/amr.1995.9512280033 hart, s. l., & dowell, g. (2010). invited editorial: a natural-resource-based view of the firm: fifteen years after. journal of management, 37(5). idil gaziulusoy, a. (2015). a critical review of approaches available for design and innovation teams through the perspective of sustainability science and system innovation theories. journal of cleaner production, 107. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2015.01.012 jacobsen, r., willeghems, g., gellynck, x., & buysse, j. (2018). increasing the quantity of separated post-consumer plastics for reducing combustible household waste: the case of rigid plastics in flanders. waste management, 78. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.wasman.2018.06.025 johanson, j., & mattsson, l. g. (2015). internationalisation in industrial systems a network approach. in knowledge, networks and power: the uppsala school of international business. https://doi.org/10.1057/9781137508829_5 johanson, j., & vahlne, j. e. (1977). the internationalization process of the firm—a model of knowledge development and increasing foreign market commitments. journal of international business studies, 8(1). https://doi.org/10.1057/palgrave.jibs.8490676 johanson, j., & vahlne, j. e. (2009). the uppsala internationalization process model revisited: from liability of foreignness to liability of outsidership. journal of international business studies, 40(9). https://doi.org/10.1057/jibs.2009.24 european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/9819 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 32 josephson, b. w., johnson, j. l., mariadoss, b. j., & cullen, j. (2016). service transition strategies in manufacturing: implications for firm risk. journal of service research, 19(2). https://doi.org/10.1177/1094670515600422 kirchherr, j., reike, d., & hekkert, m. (2017). conceptualizing the circular economy: an analysis of 114 definitions. in resources, conservation and recycling (vol. 127). https://doi.org/10.1016/j.resconrec.2017.09.005 knott, e., rao, a. h., summers, k., & teeger, c. (2022). interviews in the social sciences. nature reviews methods primers, 2(1). https://doi.org/10.1038/s43586-022-00150-6 kumar, s., raut, r. d., nayal, k., kraus, s., yadav, v. s., & narkhede, b. e. (2021). to identify industry 4.0 and circular economy adoption barriers in the agriculture supply chain by using ism-anp. journal of cleaner production, 293. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2021.126023 kusi-sarpong, s., gupta, h., khan, s. a., chiappetta jabbour, c. j., rehman, s. t., & kusi-sarpong, h. (2023). sustainable supplier selection based on industry 4.0 initiatives within the context of circular economy implementation in supply chain operations. production planning and control, 34(10). https://doi.org/10.1080/09537287.2021.1980906 lahane, s., kant, r., & shankar, r. (2020). circular supply chain management: a state-of-art review and future opportunities. in journal of cleaner production (vol. 258). https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2020.120859 luthra, s., govindan, k., kannan, d., mangla, s. k., & garg, c. p. (2017). an integrated framework for sustainable supplier selection and evaluation in supply chains. journal of cleaner production, 140. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2016.09.078 macarthur, e. (2017). what is a circular economy? | ellen macarthur foundation. in ellen macarthur foundation. mangla, s. k., kumar, p., & barua, m. k. (2014). flexible decision approach for analysing performance of sustainable supply chains under risks/uncertainty. global journal of flexible systems management, 15(2). https://doi.org/10.1007/s40171014-0059-8 marrucci, l., daddi, t., & iraldo, f. (2022). the circular economy, environmental performance and environmental management systems: the role of absorptive capacity. journal of knowledge management, 26(8). https://doi.org/10.1108/jkm06-2021-0437 mazzarano, m. (2021). criticality assessment of green materials: institutional quality, market concentration and recycling potential. european journal of social impact and circular economy, 2(3), 1–14. mena, c., humphries, a., & choi, t. y. (2013). toward a theory of multi-tier supply chain management. journal of supply chain management, 49(2). https://doi.org/10.1111/jscm.12003 merriam, s. b. (2009). dealing with validity, reliability, and ethics. qualitative research: a guide to design and implementation. münch, c., benz, l. a., & hartmann, e. (2022). exploring the circular economy paradigm: a natural resource-based view on supplier selection criteria. journal of purchasing and supply management, 28(4). https://doi.org/10.1016/j.pursup.2022.100793 mwaijande, f. (2024). a bibliometric analysis of circular economy: policy implications for sustainability in subsaharan africa. european journal of social impact and circular economy, 5(1), 1–19. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/9819 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 33 nasir, m. h. a., genovese, a., acquaye, a. a., koh, s. c. l., & yamoah, f. (2017). comparing linear and circular supply chains: a case study from the construction industry. international journal of production economics, 183. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijpe.2016.06.008 niero, m., hauschild, m. z., hoffmeyer, s. b., & olsen, s. i. (2017). combining eco-efficiency and eco-effectiveness for continuous loop beverage packaging systems: lessons from the carlsberg circular community. journal of industrial ecology, 21(3). https://doi.org/10.1111/jiec.12554 nowell, l. s., norris, j. m., white, d. e., & moules, n. j. (2017). thematic analysis: striving to meet the trustworthiness criteria. international journal of qualitative methods, 16(1). https://doi.org/10.1177/1609406917733847 ostrom, a. l., bitner, m. j., brown, s. w., burkhard, k. a., goul, m., smith-daniels, v., demirkan, h., & rabinovich, e. (2010). moving forward and making a difference: research priorities for the science of service. journal of service research, 13(1). https://doi.org/10.1177/1094670509357611 palinkas, l. a., horwitz, s. m., green, c. a., wisdom, j. p., duan, n., & hoagwood, k. (2015). purposeful sampling for qualitative data collection and analysis in mixed method implementation research. administration and policy in mental health and mental health services research, 42(5). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10488-013-0528-y peteraf, m. a. (1993). the cornerstones of competitive advantage: a resource‐based view. strategic management journal, 14(3). https://doi.org/10.1002/smj.4250140303 pinheiro, h. t., macdonald, c., santos, r. g., ali, r., bobat, a., cresswell, b. j., francini-filho, r., freitas, r., galbraith, g. f., musembi, p., phelps, t. a., quimbayo, j. p., quiros, t. e. a. l., shepherd, b., stefanoudis, p. v., talma, s., teixeira, j. b., woodall, l. c., & rocha, l. a. (2023). plastic pollution on the world’s coral reefs. nature, 619(7969). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41586-023-06113-5 piontek, f., piontek, f. m., herrmann, c., & saraev, a. (2021). steps from zero carbon supply chains and demand of circular economy to circular business cases. european journal of social impact and circular economy, 2(2). prosman, e. j., & sacchi, r. (2016). new environmental supplier selection criteria for circular supply chains: lessons from a consequential lca study on waste recovery. journal of cleaner production, 172. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2017.11.134 rashidi, m. n., akademia baru, p., ara begum, r., mokhtar, m., & pereira, j. j. (2014). the conduct of structured interviews as research implementation method. journal of advanced research design issn, 1(1). reay, t., & whetten, d. a. (2011). what constitutes a theoretical contribution in family business? in family business review (vol. 24, issue 2). https://doi.org/10.1177/0894486511406427 rostamzadeh, r., govindan, k., esmaeili, a., & sabaghi, m. (2015). application of fuzzy vikor for evaluation of green supply chain management practices. ecological indicators, 49. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ecolind.2014.09.045 samant, s. m., & sangle, s. (2016). a selected literature review on the changing role of stakeholders as value creators. world journal of science, technology and sustainable development, 13(2). https://doi.org/10.1108/wjstsd-01-2016-0002 european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/9819 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 34 saunders, m., lewis, p., & thornhill, a. (2015). research methods for business students 7th edition 2015 (mark n. k. saunders , philip lewis , adrian thornhill). in עטונה ןולע (vol. 66). scarpellini, s. (2021). social indicators for businesses’ circular economy: multi-faceted analysis of employment as an indicator for sustainability reporting. european journal of social impact and circular economy, 2(1), 17–44. shakeel, j., mardani, a., chofreh, a. g., goni, f. a., & klemeš, j. j. (2020). anatomy of sustainable business model innovation. journal of cleaner production, 261. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2020.121201 shen, l., olfat, l., govindan, k., khodaverdi, r., & diabat, a. (2013). a fuzzy multi criteria approach for evaluating green supplier’s performance in green supply chain with linguistic preferences. resources, conservation and recycling, 74. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.resconrec.2012.09.006 shooshtarian, s., maqsood, t., caldera, s., & ryley, t. (2022). transformation towards a circular economy in the australian construction and demolition waste management system. in sustainable production and consumption (vol. 30). https://doi.org/10.1016/j.spc.2021.11.032 siggelkow, n. (2007). persuasion with case studies. academy of management journal, 50(1). https://doi.org/10.5465/amj.2007.24160882 silva, n., & pålsson, h. (2022). industrial packaging and its impact on sustainability and circular economy: a systematic literature review. journal of cleaner production, 333. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2021.130165 stake, r. e. (1995). the art of case study research. thousand oaks,. ca: sage, ca. taghikhah, f., voinov, a., & shukla, n. (2019). extending the supply chain to address sustainability. in journal of cleaner production (vol. 229). https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2019.05.051 taherdoost, h., & brard, a. (2019). analyzing the process of supplier selection criteria and methods. procedia manufacturing, 32. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.promfg.2019.02.317 tallman, s., luo, y., & buckley, p. j. (2018). business models in global competition. global strategy journal, 8(4). https://doi.org/10.1002/gsj.1165 tecchio, p., mcalister, c., mathieux, f., & ardente, f. (2017). in search of standards to support circularity in product policies: a systematic approach. journal of cleaner production, 168. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2017.05.198 teece, d. j. (2007). explicating dynamic capabilities: the nature and microfoundations of (sustainable) enterprise performance. strategic management journal, 28(13). https://doi.org/10.1002/smj.640 teece, d. j., pisano, g., & shuen, a. (1997). dynamic capabilities and strategic management. strategic management journal, 18(7). https://doi.org/10.1002/(sici)1097-0266(199708)18:7<509::aid-smj882>3.0.co;2-z touboulic, a., & walker, h. (2015). love me, love me not: a nuanced view on collaboration in sustainable supply chains. journal of purchasing and supply management, 21(3). https://doi.org/10.1016/j.pursup.2015.05.001 tushar, z. n., bari, a. b. m. m., & khan, m. a. (2022). circular supplier selection in the construction industry: a sustainability perspective for the emerging economies. sustainable manufacturing and service economics, 1. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.smse.2022.100005 european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/9819 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 35 vachon, s., & klassen, r. d. (2006). extending green practices across the supply chain: the impact of upstream and downstream integration. international journal of operations and production management, 26(7). https://doi.org/10.1108/01443570610672248 vahlne, j. e., & johanson, j. (2017). from internationalization to evolution: the uppsala model at 40 years. in journal of international business studies (vol. 48, issue 9). https://doi.org/10.1057/s41267-017-0107-7 verhoeven, n. (2022). houvast én flexibiliteit met thematische analyse. kwalon, 27(2). https://doi.org/10.5117/kwa2022.2.013.verh von delft, s., kortmann, s., gelhard, c., & pisani, n. (2019). leveraging global sources of knowledge for business model innovation. long range planning, 52(5). https://doi.org/10.1016/j.lrp.2018.08.003 wetzstein, a., hartmann, e., benton, w. c., & hohenstein, n. o. (2016). a systematic assessment of supplier selection literature – state-of-the-art and future scope. in international journal of production economics (vol. 182). https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijpe.2016.06.022 yin, r. k. (2013). case study research: design and methods. applied social research methods series, 18(2). https://doi.org/10.1097/00001610-199503000-00004 yurdaanik eskiyerli, d., & ewertz, s. (2024). foreign market entry with circular business models: a customer-centric approach. frontiers in sustainability, 5. https://doi.org/10.3389/frsus.2024.1344801 zimmer, k., fröhling, m., & schultmann, f. (2016). sustainable supplier management a review of models supporting sustainable supplier selection, monitoring and development. international journal of production research, 54(5). https://doi.org/10.1080/00207543.2015.1079340 zou, s., & cavusgil, s. t. (2002). the gms: a broad conceptualization of global marketing strategy and its effect on firm performance. journal of marketing, 66(4). https://doi.org/10.1509/jmkg.66.4.40.18519 04_biancone european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/8539 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 58 assessing building sustainability: economic, environmental, and social dimensions explored paolo biancone1, valerio brescia2, federico lanzalonga3* 1 university of turin, department of management “valter cantino”, corso unione sovietica 220, 10134 turin (italy) paolo.biancone@unito.it orcid 0000-0002-4819-9878 2 university of turin, department of management “valter cantino”, corso unione sovietica 220, 10134 turin (italy) społeczna akademia nauk: łódź, poland valerio.brescia@unito.it orcid 0000-0001-7919-5370 3 contact author university of turin, department of management “valter cantino”, corso unione sovietica 220, 10134 turin (italy) społeczna akademia nauk: łódź, poland federico.lanzalonga@unito.it orcid 0000-0003-3195-3528 received: 30/09/2023 accepted for publication: 20/12/2023 published: 21/12/2023 abstract this research focuses on the importance of impact assessment in the construction sector, aligning with the united nations' 2030 agenda for sustainable urban development. it emphasizes the need to incorporate economic, environmental, and social considerations into these assessments. a bibliometric analysis reveals an escalating interest in this field, particularly since 2015, illustrating the significant contribution of academic research to disseminating knowledge in this area. the paper highlights the crucial role of integrating these three sustainability dimensions in evaluating building impacts. life cycle analysis, sustainable material use, and environmental impact assessments emerge as thematic clusters. geographically, china stands out as the leading contributor to the topic, followed by the usa, italy, and the uk, suggesting profound cross-country collaborations. the analysis indicates an inverse relationship between renovation costs and sustainability, emphasizing the need to balance demands and costs during the construction and renovation. within this context, the life cycle assessment (lca) stands out as the favored measurement model, accounting for various inputs and outputs, including environmental, social, and economic impacts. european policies champion building sustainability, advocating for circular economy approaches and co2 emission reductions. independent committees or agencies are perceived as a catalyst for sustainability in building processes. however, the study acknowledges limitations, including exclusive reliance on the scopus database and potential subjectivity in thematic analysis. future research could benefit from additional databases like web of science, advanced thematic analysis software, and comprehensive case studies. further engaging consumers in the building sustainability perspective may also present a promising research avenue. keywords: impact assessment; sustainability; buildings; construction; life cycle; circular economy european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/8539 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 59 1. introduction construction is one of the key sectors in the global economy, but its growth and development significantly impact the environment and society (díaz-lópez et al., 2021). building impact assessment has become an essential component in the design and construction of new buildings and in the management of existing ones (ameen et al., 2015). this practice aims to assess the economic, environmental, and social effects associated with buildings, seeking to balance economic sustainability, environmental responsibility, and social well-being (zahra & wright, 2016). over the years, awareness of global environmental issues and challenges related to urbanization has pushed governments, businesses, and construction industry professionals to carefully consider how building projects affect the surrounding environment and community. considering this, advanced methodologies in building impact assessment, such as life cycle analysis and green building certifications, have emerged as key strategies to promote sustainability in the construction sector. these approaches focus on minimizing negative impacts and creating a positive legacy in urban development, thus aligning with the broader objectives of sustainable development (khasreen et al., 2009). it follows that building impact assessment can be a tool to identify and mitigate negative impacts and maximize benefits in terms of economic, social, and ecological sustainability (pope et al., 2004). furthermore, integrating smart technologies in building design and management is revolutionizing how we approach environmental sustainability and energy efficiency. this technological shift enhances the performance of buildings and contributes significantly to urban sustainability, offering a path towards achieving the ambitious targets set by the united nations for sustainable urban environments (secinaro, brescia, et al., 2022). particularly considering the main international frameworks, the united nations' 2030 agenda has highlighted goal 11 as primary: to make cities and human settlements inclusive, safe, resilient, and sustainable (united nations, 2015). this article aims to gather the main literature related to building impact assessment, highlighting its role in promoting sustainability. to do this, the authors conducted a bibliometric analysis on a sample of 129 documents, answering the following research questions: rq1: what key bibliometric data and thematic insights pertain to the field of building impact assessment? rq2: what are the unique characteristics of building impact assessment? to our knowledge, no other articles aim to define the main bibliometric and thematic parameters related to building impact assessment using bibliometrix (aria & cuccurullo, 2017). this study is a literature review (slr) on building impact assessment that uses a hybrid approach that combines the slr with bibliometric analysis in five phases: study design, data collection, data analysis, data visualization, and interpretation (lanzalonga et al., 2023; sadraei et al., 2022). the research considers multidisciplinary studies and offers a comprehensive view of the state of the art on the subject to understand the logics that underlie the growing interest in building impact assessment. the article contributes to collecting bibliometric information that considers economic, environmental, and social aspects to guide informed decisions in the construction sector. furthermore, the document provides a framework for understanding the elements characterizing the building impact assessment. 2. methodology this study aims to conduct a structured literature review (slr) on the impact assessment of buildings (massaro et al., 2016). the methodology is suitable for systematizing the flows of literature that, to date, are partially understood by international scholars (biancone et al., 2020). consequently, this study uses a hybrid approach to conduct an slr with bibliometric analysis (abarca et al., 2020), adopting a workflow mapping methodology through five phases (zupic & čater, 2015): (i) study design, (ii) data collection, (iii) data analysis, (iv) data visualization, and (v) interpretation. 2.1 study design the research aims to identify research questions and the theoretical model for observing the impact assessment of buildings in the literature (biancone et al., 2022). although initially specific to the accounting sector, the slr methodology applied to the sample of articles was extended to the broader field of management due to its reliable research protocol (de bem machado et al., 2021; secinaro et al., 2020). therefore, a joint bibliometric and coding method can help researchers identify the essential variables of the research scope in a short time. the authors conducted an slr through a deep and reliable review of knowledge in the study domain and identified areas for future research (piontek et al., 2021; uluyol et al., 2021). it is possible to analyze european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/8539 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 60 multidisciplinary studies through metadata analysis (secinaro, brescia, et al., 2022). this research aims to consider within the cluster not only articles closely related to the business model concept but also those dealing with food industry production. in this sense, the research offers a holistic view of the state of the art of the topic and allows grouping the literature on the subject by identifying appropriate sections to advance research in the study by offering a research agenda (secinaro, calandra, et al., 2022; ştefănescu et al., 2021). 2.2 data collection in september 2023, the data collection process began using the scopus database through the search key "impact assessment” and “building". the multidisciplinary database is considered suitable for researchers in economics and management (okoli & schabram, 2010). the primary results obtained were 2,567 documents. despite the known interdisciplinary nature of the topic (saber & silka, 2020), it is consistent with the theoretical reference concept to consider only articles related to the business and management field. moreover, only articles from peer-reviewed journals in english were considered (brescia et al., 2021). to ensure we did not miss any essential data, we manually searched the references of all selected articles, using backward and forward snowballing (brzica, 2023; christofi et al., 2021). in this way, we ensured not to leave out some of the most relevant articles in the document selection process. after this phase, the researchers manually downloaded all article pdfs to create codes and the subsequent research cluster analysis (dal mas et al., 2019; foschi et al., 2023). the data collection of this research is consistent with the spar-4-slr guidelines by (paul et al., 2021) (figure 1). according to moher (2009), mapping a systematic review protocol is essential to overcome biases in document selection. consequently, 129 articles passed the restrictive criteria. the study used bibliometrix, a statistical package in r-studio (aria & cuccurullo, 2017). this package allows analyzing bibliometric information, including authors, citations, sources, and keywords. 2.3 data analysis several analysis tools were applied to answer the research questions and the study's objectives. firstly, to answer rq1, we used bibliometrix r-package and the biblioshiny app, which is increasingly used in scientific literature to provide a state of the art of knowledge flow under study (aria & cuccurullo, 2017; vaska et al., 2021). moreover, to answer rq2 and inspire constructive criticism, we used the atlas.ti cloud version software to create specific codes to map the background and methods used by authors. the software is suitable for verifying the consistency between codes and analyzed documents (hwang, 2008; talanquer, 2014). lastly, we used the vos viewer software to create the cluster map to show conceptual maps of information dissemination (van eck & waltman, 2011). the following sections provide insights on data visualization and interpretation. finally, the theoretical and practical implications related to future research lines are found in the conclusions section. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/8539 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 61 figure 1. data collection methodology source: authors’ elaboration consistent with the spar-4-slr guidelines by (paul et al., 2021) 3. results this section aims to delve into the results of the sample. firstly, table 1 describes the temporal characteristics of the articles considered to understand the state of the art of property assessment. specifically, the time span ranges from 2000 to 2023, including 45 documentary sources for the entire sample. there are 129 documents, and publications' average annual growth rate is 10.53%. the topic is of significant interest to experts in business and management, as evidenced by the average citation number of 27,84, which is particularly high for the academic sector. assembling • identification o research questions: bibliometric analysis (rq1) and characteristics of building impact assessment (rq2). o domain: building impact assessment. o source type: peer-reviewed journals o source quality: scopus database. • acquisition o search mechanism and material acquisition: scopus database o search period: september 2023. o search keywords: "impact assessment” and “building" • total documents returned from assembling stage: 2.576 documents. arranging • organization o organizing codes: timespan, language, documents type, subject area. • purification o timespan: 2000-2023 o language: english. o documents type: peer-reviewed articles o source type: journal, o subject area: business management and accounting,. • total documents returned from arranging stage: 147 documents. assessing • evaluation o total documents for analysis: 129 documents. o performance analysis: analysis of publication trend, sources, authors, papers and keywords (rq1), thematic and cluster analysis (rq2) to analyse building impact assessment. o software: r-studio, bibliometrix, excel. • reporting o convention: figures, tables and words. o limitations: accuracy and completeness of bibliometric data in scopus, and the scope of bibliometric analysis. o source of support: no financial received and reported for this review. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/8539 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 62 table 1. main documents description results main data information time span 2000-2023 sources 45 documents 129 annual growth rate 10.53% average time since publication (in years) 5.39 average citations per document 27.84 document content plus keywords (id) 990 author's keywords (de) 527 authors number of authors 456 number of documents by single author 12 author collaboration average number of authors per document 3.73 international co-authors 41.09 source: author's elaboration through biblioshiny 3.1 sources and documents. from 2015, the number of publications increased rapidly, showing an interest that remains high in the following years (figure 2). as can be seen from table 2, the leading journal by a large margin among the most relevant sources is the journal of cleaner production. this international journal has a transdisciplinary character and aims to publish on environmental and sustainability topics. specifically, "cleaner production" aims to prevent waste production by increasing the efficiency of energy, water, resources, and human capital. table 3 depicts the main documents extracted from the sample. the first paper, in terms of number of citations, addresses the topic of prefabrication technology promoted by the chinese government to enhance the quality and productivity of constructions. this topic was assessed in an environmental study (cao et al., 2015). the results reveal that prefabrication is more energy-efficient and reduces environmental damage compared to traditional on-site construction. the second research in terms of number of citations is the study of wu & sun (2018), in which it is confirmed that the optimization of energy use in operational management must consider when to turn machines on or off and the speed of execution. in particular, the authors suggest a model for flexible factory planning, calculating energy consumption and developing a genetic algorithm for optimizing timings, consumption, and machine start-ups and shutdowns. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/8539 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 63 figure 2. annual scientific production source: author's elaboration through biblioshiny table 2. most relevant sources sources papers journal of cleaner production 65 international journal of construction management 6 construction management and economics 4 engineering, construction and architectural management 4 cities 3 journal of construction engineering and management 3 computer law and security review 2 international journal of technological learning, innovation and development 2 research in transportation business and management 2 research policy 2 source: author's elaboration through biblioshiny the third paper in the table deals with the supply chain and the fundamental integration in order to improve the performance of construction projects. the study of mesa et al. (2016) uses the general performance model to assess how project delivery systems influence relationships in the supply chain and project performance, finding that communication, alignment of interests, teamwork, trust, and benefit sharing are key factors. the fourth document is among the less recent and studies life cycle assessments used to evaluate the environmental impacts of products and processes. in the construction sector, the study of treloar et al. (2000) suggests a hybrid method that integrates traditional life cycle assessment data with input-output data, improving the overall completeness and reliability of environmental assessments. among other documents, the study of schnitzer et al. (2007) that suggests the promising technical and economic feasibility of using thermal solar energy in industrial processes, contributing to a zero-emission sustainable industry. in addition to the previous research, of great relevance is the literature analysis of hossain & ng (2018) which examines the application of life cycle analysis to construction, highlighting gaps in considering the concept of circular economy and proposing a comprehensive framework to improve the sustainability of the construction sector. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/8539 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 64 table 3. most relevant documents paper number of citations average citation per year cao, x., li, x., zhu, y., & zhang, z. (2015). a comparative study of environmental performance between prefabricated and traditional residential buildings in china. in journal of cleaner production (vol. 109, pp. 131–143). elsevier ltd. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2015.04.120 222 24,67 wu, x., & sun, y. (2018). a green scheduling algorithm for flexible job shop with energysaving measures. in journal of cleaner production (vol. 172, pp. 3249–3264). elsevier ltd. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2017.10.342 164 27,33 mesa, h. a., molenaar, k. r., & alarcón, l. f. (2016). exploring performance of the integrated project delivery process on complex building projects. in international journal of project management (vol. 34, issue 7, pp. 1089–1101). elsevier ltd. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijproman.2016.05.007 129 16,13 treloar, g. j., love, p. e. d., faniran, o. o., & iyer-raniga, u. (2000). a hybrid life cycle assessment method for construction. in construction management and economics (vol. 18, issue 1, pp. 5–9). routledge journals. https://doi.org/10.1080/014461900370898 120 5,00 schnitzer, h., brunner, c., & gwehenberger, g. (2007). minimizing greenhouse gas emissions through the application of solar thermal energy in industrial processes. in journal of cleaner production (vol. 15, issues 13–14, pp. 1271–1286). https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2006.07.023 118 6,94 chang, r. d., soebarto, v., zhao, z.-y., & zillante, g. (2016). facilitating the transition to sustainable construction: china’s policies. in journal of cleaner production (vol. 131, pp. 534–544). elsevier ltd. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2016.04.147 102 12,75 hossain, md. u., & ng, s. t. (2018). critical consideration of buildings’ environmental impact assessment towards adoption of circular economy: an analytical review. in journal of cleaner production (vol. 205, pp. 763–780). elsevier ltd. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2018.09.120 99 16,50 ding, z., wang, y., & zou, p. x. w. (2016). an agent based environmental impact assessment of building demolition waste management: conventional versus green management. in journal of cleaner production (vol. 133, pp. 1136–1153). elsevier ltd. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2016.06.054 95 11,88 cheng, b., lu, k., li, j., chen, h., luo, x., & shafique, m. (2022). comprehensive assessment of embodied environmental impacts of buildings using normalized environmental impact factors. in journal of cleaner production (vol. 334). elsevier ltd. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2021.130083 87 43,50 foo, k. y. (2013). a vision on the role of environmental higher education contributing to the sustainable development in malaysia. in journal of cleaner production (vol. 61, pp. 6–12). https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2013.05.014 84 7,64 source: author's elaboration through biblioshiny european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/8539 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 65 3.2 thematic analysis the following section explores the main themes through different analyses based on the authors' keywords or the most significant keywords by frequency of appearance. the main words emerging from the keyword analysis, visible in figure 3, are "life cycle" (58) and "environmental impact" (49). authors use the first term to identify studies related to the in-depth examination of the life cycle of products and how this can represent an advantage for the circularity of the economy in various sectors such as: transport (cristiano, 2022), specialized studies of the industrial sector (lo giudice et al., 2017), insights for the recovery of natural resources (ghimire et al., 2017; long et al., 2023). the latter is used in studies that consider the environmental impact crucial in predisposition starting from the spatial dimension (diez-rodríguez et al., 2019) and the environmental impact of industrial buildings (harelimana et al., 2020). among the other words, "sustainable development" (30) and "decision making" (23) stand out. the topic of sustainable development seems to be among the most significant when describing the phenomenon of building impact assessment. in particular, some articles address the transition from traditional construction systems to ecological systems (chang et al., 2016). moreover, other authors have focused on the integration of disruptive technologies and the power of artificial intelligence in building construction (hamida et al., 2021). the discussion of decision-making is essential to change current construction paradigms and promote an impact assessment that can determine the optimal parameters of dwellings (sohn et al., 2017), or regarding the study of costs and prices (teo et al., 2022). figure 3. significant keywords distributed in a word cloud source: author's elaboration through biblioshiny figure 4 shows trending topics, displaying the main themes over the years. until 2016, the authors' interest was mainly in environmental impact assessment. in particular, the studies focus on studying the erosion of natural resources related to property construction (bolin & smith, 2011; burge, 2008). from 2016 onwards, the interest shifted towards energy efficiency and the new effective forms of environmentally conscious property construction (hird & pfotenhauer, 2017). in recent years, attention has expanded to the life cycle of elements and recycling and the life cycle impact assessment in the context of the circular economy (tran et al., 2023). european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/8539 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 66 figure 4. trending topics source: author's elaboration through biblioshiny figure 5 shows the results of the connections established by the vosviewer software (van eck & waltman, 2011), highlighting two main clusters developed based on the economic context of application. from an economic standpoint, it is clear that growth, sustainability, and balance have a strong correlation, especially environmental sustainability and economic aspects require investments that can lead to balance considering sustainable materials provided there is little global market competition when considering these aspects not impacting collective well-being (gajbiye, 2018). european and national markets and regulations condition strategies and costs associated with construction; if regulations and adopted policies increase the required criteria, market economies look for the lowest price with a balance to be achieved (bon & hutchinson, 2000). to this end, processes, materials, and impact require careful analysis to determine the variables at play. in most cases, the reuse of buildings for other purposes and redesign do not require cheaper solutions but solutions that take into account environmental impacts or other contextual factors (laefer & manke, 2008). european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/8539 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 67 figure 5. thematic analysis of content source: author's elaboration through vosviewer the first significant cluster concerns the life cycle assessment (lca) based on the impact definition generated by materials and energy consumption. the approach is based on both the use of recycled materials and guaranteed energy savings for the building and the use of new, less energy-impactful technologies (ingrao et al., 2016). some studies associate the lca with the construction environmental performance assessment system (cepas) as in figure 6, a holistic assessment tool for various types of buildings with a clear boundary of the entire building's life cycle, covering the pre-design, design, construction, and demolition stages and operation based on indicators that include environmental, social, and economic aspects (cao et al., 2015). the study by cao et al. (2015) also associates the lca with the building health impact assessment system (bhias) by integrating several indicators provided in the evaluation approach. figure 7 shows the aspects considered and the variables mapped. using technologies in this case also impacts the results that can be achieved, on material selection, and on determining the components to use, also impacting health and consequent energy consumption following building construction. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/8539 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 68 figure 6. conceptual map source: adapted from (cepas application guidelines, 2006) figure 7. summary table source: cepas e bhias based on cao et al., 2015. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/8539 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 69 since the lca the transformation process from input to output is essential for an effective assessment, there are also corrective measures that improve the assessment of only some elements, omitting others that could distort the achieved result (treloar et al., 2000). specifically, it is suggested to select the best available lca input±output models and differentiate the application of the hybrid lca method proposed by treloar et al. (2000) on different types of buildings and other non-building products. the articles discussing lca often associate the environmental impact with material use and the life cycle described and outlined through the sankey diagram (ismaeel & lotfy, 2023). the impact is also associated with emissions and measurable energy consumption through cumulative energy demand (ced), recipe, greenhouse gas (ghg) emission rate, and the energy payback time (epbt) (hadi & heidari, 2021; sandanayake et al., 2017) with a possible impact on health (sandanayake et al., 2022). the impacts associated with the use of construction materials and health are usually classified based on climate change, air pollution, photochemical oxidant formation, and water consumption (shi et al., 2022). additionally, constructions, demolitions, and renovations generate waste (bricks for masonry, permeable bricks, and thermal insulation blocks) often toxic that can cause freshwater ecotoxicity, marine ecotoxicity, carcinogenic toxicity, and non-carcinogenic toxicity to humans; such toxicities can be reduced if a product recycling process is applied, which, according to studies, also has an impact on co2 emissions reduced by 15.6kg per functional unit (qiao et al., 2022). also, the use of biocomponents like bio-renewable content (brc) formulation for wooden floor coatings can reduce the impacts generated by smog formation, acidification, eutrophication, and respiratory effects by 30% (montazeri & eckelman, 2018). other impacts to be mapped concern energy, requiring particular attention to reducing greenhouse gas (ghg) emissions by between 20% and 30% compared to each building's emissions according to european union requirements with a target set at 20% (biancone et al., 2021; brescia et al., 2023; gottsche et al., 2016). the relationship between the structured aspects of buildings, energy impact, and economic assessment is present in the environmental impacts cost assessment model (eicam) that, in design phases, allows defining energy cost, operational energy carbon, carbon embodied in the envelope, and total carbon emissions (hamida et al., 2021). the impact assessment associated with the previous clusters uses different methods, although the lca is predominant and includes various variables. among the other methods considered, the data envelopment analysis (dea) determines in the reconstruction of external walls which inputs provide the best outputs in terms of efficiency by testing 175 different types (iribarren et al., 2015). the use of the usepa traci 2.1 impact assessment method is particularly significant when discussing biological or chemical-derived materials used for construction with environmental impact (montazeri & eckelman, 2018). only in the demolition phase, even partial, is the agent-based modeling (abm) approach used, highlighting how direct management of demolition works by engineers or architects reduces pollution and the generated environmental impact by 50% (ding et al., 2016). among the adopted frameworks associated with the approach, there is also the building information modelling (bim), which, in defining six impact-related dimensions, uses specific verification and quality control procedures that allow engineers to reduce the environmental impact (ismaeel & lotfy, 2023). the different approaches and renovation phases are always associated with measurable sustainability criteria through the adoption of circular economy approaches (hossain & ng, 2018), energy use and related emissions (hadi & heidari, 2021), used renewable energy (passerini et al., 2017), elements based on the green-star certification widespread in other countries e.g. australia (https://new.gbca.org.au/green-star/rating-system/design-and-built/) (tran et al., 2023), the materials and potentially toxic substances for humans used based on the requirements of the global sustainability agenda (kirchhübel & fantke, 2019). the creation or use of independent committees or agencies allows for reducing geopolitical risks in decisions regarding the destination and using materials that influence the impact, mitigating the financial risks associated with imposed choices (sheetal et al., 2023). 3.3 geographical analysis this section analyses the adopting nations and countries based on the number of publications. figure 8 shows that the most prolific nation is china, with 53 publications. the impact assessment of constructions is essential to the decision-making process for large-scale construction projects (shi et al., 2022). china has a growing concern for the environment and is looking to improve the sustainability of its constructions to promote more sustainable construction practices through the adoption of eco-friendly technologies and energy efficiency standards as found in the “the belt and road” project (schulhof et al., 2022). research conducted in the united states follows, with 26 from this sample. the environmental impact assessment is a mandatory process for building projects that involve government funding or approvals. although regulations vary from state to state, environmental impact assessment includes analyzing the environmental, social, and economic effects of the project (bolin & smith, 2011). italian publications number 24 and focus on construction management that can have a significant impact european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/8539 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 70 on the environment, such as air quality, resource consumption, landscape, traffic, and much more (cristiano, 2022; vitale et al., 2018). finally, publications from the united kingdom number 20 explore impact assessment considering effects like land use, transportation, noise, and the surrounding ecosystem (rossi et al., 2017). figure 8. scientific output of different countries. source: author's elaboration through biblioshiny figure 9. map of strategic collaborations between countries. source: author's elaboration through biblioshiny european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/8539 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 71 built based on the previous image, figure 9 highlights the relationships between the authors from individual countries. the most significant relationship concerns the co-authorship of seven documents between china and australia. one reason is related to the high rate of collaboration between different building projects, especially in the field of infrastructure and natural resources. impact assessments of constructions are a critical aspect of this collaboration, as both countries seek to ensure that projects are conducted in a sustainable and environmentally friendly manner (tran et al., 2023). moreover, the relationship between the usa and china with 4 papers appears particularly significant. the reasons underlying the intensity of collaboration between the countries are the desire to ensure that projects comply with environmental regulations and have a sustainable impact (huang et al., 2018). lastly, the collaboration between switzerland and sweden is highlighted. at the heart of this collaboration is a strong shared commitment to sustainability and environmental awareness. 4. discussion and conclusion although essential for the global economy, construction has significant impacts on the environment and society (díazlópez et al., 2021). building impact assessment has become crucial to balance economic, environmental, and social sustainability (ameen et al., 2015). in recent years, increasing awareness of environmental and urban challenges has led to a greater focus on how construction projects affect the surrounding world (zahra & wright, 2016). this study represents a step forward in understanding building impact assessment through a bibliometric analysis (lanzalonga et al., 2023; sadraei et al., 2022). moreover, the article emphasizes the importance of considering economic, environmental, and social aspects in the building impact assessment, considering the united nations' 2030 agenda goals for sustainable cities (united nations, 2015). ultimately, this study represents a step forward in promoting sustainability in construction by better understanding its dynamics and challenges. to address the initial rq1, three distinct angles are considered: (i) publication sources and document types, (ii) analysis of themes, and (iii) examination of geographical trends. in terms of publication sources and document types, the research notes a rise in scholarly articles related to building impact assessment from 2015 onwards, indicating an escalating interest in this area. the "journal of cleaner production" stands out as a leading publication in this domain, primarily focusing on environmental sustainability and topics like waste reduction and resource efficiency (díaz-lópez et al., 2021). among the most referenced studies, a research from china underscores the benefits of prefabrication technology in enhancing the quality and productivity of construction, with a particular emphasis on environmental factors (cao et al., 2015). additionally, a study focused on improving energy efficiency in building operations using modeling and genetic algorithms (wu & sun, 2018). the aspect of supply chain management was explored in another research, analyzing its impact on the performance of construction projects, with a special focus on elements such as communication and trust (mesa et al., 2016). regarding thematic analysis, the most relevant keywords in publications include "life cycle", "environmental impact", "sustainable development", and "decision making". over the years, the focus has shifted from analyzing environmental impact to energy efficiency and a circular approach. keyword connection analysis highlighted thematic clusters related to life cycle analysis, sustainable material use, and environmental impact evaluations. geographically, china has published the most articles on the subject, followed by the united states, italy, and the united kingdom. the most significant country relationships include collaborations between china and australia, china, and the usa, as well as switzerland and sweden, all focused on the common goal of ensuring sustainability in construction projects and compliance with environmental regulations. in addressing rq2, the research uncovers a reverse correlation between the costs of building renovations and their sustainability, affecting both environmental and public health outcomes. essentially, the greater the sustainability and adherence to standards, the more substantial the financial outlay required during the construction or renovation stages (bon & hutchinson, 2000; gajbiye, 2018). this inverse relation necessitates finding a middle ground between the required demands/needs and the expenses incurred, or alternatively, seeking policy recognition for meeting specific environmental benchmarks. key among these criteria is the adoption of a uniform measurement methodology. the study points out that life cycle assessment (lca) emerges as the most effective framework for evaluating the pre-design, design, construction, demolition, and operation phases, using indicators that encompass environmental, social, and economic aspects (cao et al., 2015). this method can be supplemented with secondary techniques to ascertain the most impactful components (dea analysis), especially when materials and components are pre-identified and catalogued; the usepa traci 2.1 assessment tool is useful for assessing the impact of biological materials used, and building information modeling (bim) proves valuable in analyzing engineering process repercussions (ding et al., 2016; iribarren et al., 2015; ismaeel & lotfy, 2023; montazeri & eckelman, 2018). the fundamental principle of life cycle assessment, which is the relationship between inputs and outputs, serves as a foundation for these methodologies. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/8539 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 72 for this purpose, the considered inputs must include human raw material toxicity, natural resource consumption, used protection devices and technologies, bio materials used, renewable energies, professional skills (architects and engineers) even during demolition phases to reduce impacts, and allocated economic resources (cao et al., 2015; hadi & heidari, 2021; hossain & ng, 2018; kirchhübel & fantke, 2019; montazeri & eckelman, 2018; passerini et al., 2017; treloar et al., 2000). outputs with a direct impact on the environment include climate change, air pollution, photochemical oxidant formation, water consumption, greenhouse gas (ghg), smog, acidification, eutrophication, and respiratory effects, freshwater ecotoxicity, marine ecotoxicity, human carcinogenic toxicity and non-carcinogenic toxicity, and possible energy recovery (payback energy) (hadi & heidari, 2021; montazeri & eckelman, 2018; qiao et al., 2022; shi et al., 2022). the use of green-star-certified elements generates positive outcomes in the renovation process. both for inputs and outputs, european policies guide operations by highlighting rewards for the macro context in terms of health and environmental fallout and, at the same time, a recovery for the energy cost in the medium term; these policies concern circular economy approaches and respect for the reduction of 20% of co2 emitted by heating and electrical plants, possibly oriented to 30% (biancone et al., 2021; brescia et al., 2023; gottsche et al., 2016; hossain & ng, 2018). the presence of committees or autonomous agencies guarantees sustainability and the processes implemented (sheetal et al., 2023). the different highlighted elements constitute rewarding (+) or penalizing (-) factors in evaluating all building use phases and can be summarized in figure 10. the study also highlights that except for health-related social impacts, there are not many studies providing a weight on the fallout and role of a building, even though the role of the context in which it is located is mentioned (laefer & manke, 2008). figure 10. key elements in building impact assessment source: authors' elaboration european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/8539 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 73 4.1 limitation and future research like all studies, this article also has its limitations. firstly, using only the scopus database might limit the sample of selected articles. therefore, we cannot rule out any adverse scientific contributions not included in our study. secondly, the thematic analysis carried out, although done independently by the researchers, could have elements of subjectivity in its investigation. lastly, using keywords could limit the scope of the research conducted so far. further advancements in the field could stem from our limitations. therefore, future research could be undertaken using other databases, such as the web of science and various research sources. moreover, thematic analysis techniques could be refined favoring the selected sample using specific research software capable of outlining the sentiments and variables of managers on the issue of building impact assessment. additionally, research initiatives based on single or multiple cases could be conducted to explore ongoing virtuous initiatives. references abarca, v. m. g., palos-sanchez, p. r., & rus-arias, e. (2020). working in virtual teams: a systematic literature review and a bibliometric analysis. ieee access, 8, 168923–168940. ameen, r. f. m., mourshed, m., & li, h. (2015). a critical review of environmental assessment tools for sustainable urban design. environmental impact assessment review, 55, 110–125. aria, m., & cuccurullo, c. (2017). bibliometrix: an r-tool for comprehensive science mapping analysis. journal of informetrics, 11(4), 959–975. scopus. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.joi.2017.08.007 biancone, p., brescia, v., & jafari-sadeghi, v. (2021). the impact of the covid-19 on policies and investments of the european green deal. european journal of volunteering and community-based projects, 1(3), 60–77. biancone, p. p., brescia, v., lanzalonga, f., & alam, g. m. (2022). using bibliometric analysis to map innovative business models for vertical farm entrepreneurs. british food journal, ahead-of-print(ahead-of-print). https://doi.org/10.1108/bfj-08-2021-0904 biancone, p. p., saiti, b., petricean, d., & chmet, f. (2020). the bibliometric analysis of islamic banking and finance. journal of islamic accounting and business research. https://doi.org/10.1108/jiabr-08-2020-0235 bolin, c. a., & smith, s. t. (2011). life cycle assessment of borate-treated lumber with comparison to galvanized steel framing. in journal of cleaner production (vol. 19, issues 6–7, pp. 630–639). https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2010.12.005 bon, r., & hutchinson, k. (2000). sustainable construction: some economic challenges. building research & information, 28(5–6), 310–314. brescia, v., esposito, p., amelio, s., & biancone, p. p. (2023). rethinking green investment and corporate sustainability: the south european countries experiences during the covid-19 crisis. euromed journal of business. brescia, v., sa’ad, a. a., alhabshi, s. m. b. s. j., hassan, r. b., & lanzalonga, f. (2021). exploring sustainability from the islamic finance perspective. european journal of islamic finance, 19, article 19. https://doi.org/10.13135/24212172/6107 brzica, d. (2023). urban transformation: environmental issues, wicked problems, and transport development in the context of circular economy. european journal of social impact and circular economy, 4(1), 19–26. https://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/article/view/7040 burge, r. (2008). beyond bali. in sustainable business (issue 142, p. 36+38). https://www.scopus.com/inward/record.uri?eid=2-s2.046149093241&partnerid=40&md5=2ed85326e6c5d8d4a77848ceb1cbfccf cao, x., li, x., zhu, y., & zhang, z. (2015). a comparative study of environmental performance between prefabricated and traditional residential buildings in china. in journal of cleaner production (vol. 109, pp. 131–143). elsevier ltd. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2015.04.120 cepas application guidelines. (2006). comprehensive environmental performance assessment scheme for buildings. https://www.bd.gov.hk/doc/en/resources/codes-and-references/notices-and-reports/cepas/applicationguidelinee.pdf chang, r.-d., soebarto, v., zhao, z.-y., & zillante, g. (2016). facilitating the transition to sustainable construction: china’s policies. in journal of cleaner production (vol. 131, pp. 534–544). elsevier ltd. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2016.04.147 christofi, m., pereira, v., vrontis, d., tarba, s., & thrassou, a. (2021). agility and flexibility in international business research: a comprehensive review and future research directions. journal of world business, 56(3), 101194. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jwb.2021.101194 european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/8539 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 74 cristiano, s. (2022). the “price” of saved time, the illusion of saved fuel: life-cycle assessment of a major highway expansion. in journal of cleaner production (vol. 344). elsevier ltd. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2022.131087 dal mas, f., massaro, m., lombardi, r., & garlatti, a. (2019). from output to outcome measures in the public sector: a structured literature review. international journal of organizational analysis, 27(5), 1631–1656. https://doi.org/10.1108/ijoa-09-2018-1523 de bem machado, a., secinaro, s., calandra, d., & lanzalonga, f. (2021). knowledge management and digital transformation for industry 4.0: a structured literature review. knowledge management research & practice, 0(0), 1–19. https://doi.org/10.1080/14778238.2021.2015261 díaz-lópez, c., carpio, m., martín-morales, m., & zamorano, m. (2021). defining strategies to adopt level(s) for bringing buildings into the circular economy. a case study of spain. journal of cleaner production, 287. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2020.125048 diez-rodríguez, j. j., fischer, t. b., & di zio, s. (2019). introducing a group spatial decision support system for use in strategic environmental assessment of onshore wind farm development in mexico. in journal of cleaner production (vol. 220, pp. 1239–1254). elsevier ltd. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2019.01.154 ding, z., wang, y., & zou, p. x. w. (2016). an agent based environmental impact assessment of building demolition waste management: conventional versus green management. in journal of cleaner production (vol. 133, pp. 1136–1153). elsevier ltd. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2016.06.054 foschi, e., aureli, s., & paletta, a. (2023). linking bioeconomy, circular economy, and sustainability: trends, gaps and future orientation in the bio-based and biodegradable plastics industry. european journal of social impact and circular economy, 4(2), 16–31. https://ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/article/view/7154 gajbiye, r. (2018). a sustainable redistribution model based on economic-environmental equilibrium: a global business perspective. in international journal of innovation and sustainable development (vol. 12, issue 4, pp. 421–445). inderscience publishers. https://doi.org/10.1504/ijisd.2018.095059 ghimire, s. r., johnston, j. m., ingwersen, w. w., & sojka, s. (2017). life cycle assessment of a commercial rainwater harvesting system compared with a municipal water supply system. in journal of cleaner production (vol. 151, pp. 74–86). elsevier ltd. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2017.02.025 gottsche, j., kelly, m., & taggart, m. (2016). assessing the impact of energy management initiatives on the energy usage during the construction phase of an educational building project in ireland. in construction management and economics (vol. 34, issue 1, pp. 46–60). routledge. https://doi.org/10.1080/01446193.2016.1162317 hadi, e., & heidari, a. (2021). development of an integrated tool based on life cycle assessment, levelized energy, and life cycle cost analysis to choose sustainable facade integrated photovoltaic systems. in journal of cleaner production (vol. 293). elsevier ltd. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2021.126117 hamida, a., alsudairi, a., alshaibani, k., & alshamrani, o. (2021). environmental impacts cost assessment model of residential building using an artificial neural network. in engineering, construction and architectural management (vol. 28, issue 10, pp. 3190–3215). emerald group holdings ltd. https://doi.org/10.1108/ecam-06-2020-0450 harelimana, v., gao, z. j., nyiranteziryayo, e., & nwankwegu, a. s. (2020). identification of weaknesses in the implementation of environmental impact assessment regulations in industrial sector: a case study of some industries in rwanda, africa. in journal of cleaner production (vol. 258). elsevier ltd. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2020.120677 hird, m. d., & pfotenhauer, s. m. (2017). how complex international partnerships shape domestic research clusters: difference-in-difference network formation and research re-orientation in the mit portugal program. in research policy (vol. 46, issue 3, pp. 557–572). elsevier b.v. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.respol.2016.10.008 hossain, md. u., & ng, s. t. (2018). critical consideration of buildings’ environmental impact assessment towards adoption of circular economy: an analytical review. in journal of cleaner production (vol. 205, pp. 763–780). elsevier ltd. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2018.09.120 huang, y., porter, a. l., cunningham, s. w., robinson, d. k. r., liu, j., & zhu, d. (2018). a technology delivery system for characterizing the supply side of technology emergence: illustrated for big data & analytics. in technological forecasting and social change (vol. 130, pp. 165–176). elsevier inc. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.techfore.2017.09.012 hwang, s. (2008). utilizing qualitative data analysis software: a review of atlas.ti. social science computer review, 26(4), 519–527. https://doi.org/10.1177/0894439307312485 ingrao, c., scrucca, f., tricase, c., & asdrubali, f. (2016). a comparative life cycle assessment of external wallcompositions for cleaner construction solutions in buildings. in journal of cleaner production (vol. 124, pp. 283– 298). elsevier ltd. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2016.02.112 european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/8539 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 75 iribarren, d., marvuglia, a., hild, p., guiton, m., popovici, e., & benetto, e. (2015). life cycle assessment and data envelopment analysis approach for the selection of building components according to their environmental impact efficiency: a case study for external walls. in journal of cleaner production (vol. 87, issue 1, pp. 707–716). elsevier ltd. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2014.10.073 ismaeel, w. s. e., & lotfy, r. a. e.-r. (2023). an integrated building information modelling-based environmental impact assessment framework. in clean technologies and environmental policy (vol. 25, issue 4, pp. 1291–1307). springer science and business media deutschland gmbh. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10098-022-02443-6 khasreen, m. m., banfill, p. f., & menzies, g. f. (2009). life-cycle assessment and the environmental impact of buildings: a review. sustainability, 1(3), 674–701. https://www.mdpi.com/2071-1050/1/3/674 kirchhübel, n., & fantke, p. (2019). getting the chemicals right: toward characterizing toxicity and ecotoxicity impacts of inorganic substances. in journal of cleaner production (vol. 227, pp. 554–565). elsevier ltd. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2019.04.204 laefer, d. f., & manke, j. p. (2008). building reuse assessment for sustainable urban reconstruction. in journal of construction engineering and management (vol. 134, issue 3, pp. 217–227). https://doi.org/10.1061/(asce)07339364(2008)134:3(217) lanzalonga, f., petrolo, b., chmet, f., & brescia, v. (2023). exploring diversity management to avoid social washing and pinkwashing: using bibliometric analysis to shape future research directions. journal of intercultural management, 15(1), 41–65. lo giudice, a., ingrao, c., clasadonte, m. t., tricase, c., & mbohwa, c. (2017). life cycle assessment for highlighting environmental hotspots in the sicilian traditional ceramic sector: the case of ornamental ceramic plates. in journal of cleaner production (vol. 142, pp. 225–239). elsevier ltd. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2016.05.028 long, l., li, q., gan, z., mu, j., overend, m., & zhang, d. (2023). life cycle assessment of stone buildings in the taihang mountains of hebei province: evolution towards cleaner production and operation. in journal of cleaner production (vol. 399). elsevier ltd. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2023.136625 massaro, m., dumay, j., & guthrie, j. (2016). on the shoulders of giants: undertaking a structured literature review in accounting. accounting, auditing & accountability journal, 29(5), 767–801. https://doi.org/10.1108/aaaj-01-20151939 mesa, h. a., molenaar, k. r., & alarcón, l. f. (2016). exploring performance of the integrated project delivery process on complex building projects. in international journal of project management (vol. 34, issue 7, pp. 1089–1101). elsevier ltd. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijproman.2016.05.007 moher, d. (2009). preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses: the prisma statement. annals of internal medicine, 151(4), 264. https://doi.org/10.7326/0003-4819-151-4-200908180-00135 montazeri, m., & eckelman, m. j. (2018). life cycle assessment of uv-curable bio-based wood flooring coatings. in journal of cleaner production (vol. 192, pp. 932–939). elsevier ltd. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2018.04.209 okoli, c., & schabram, k. (2010). a guide to conducting a systematic literature review of information systems research. passerini, f., sterling, r., keane, m., klobut, k., & costa, a. (2017). energy efficiency facets: innovative district cooling systems. in entrepreneurship and sustainability issues (vol. 4, issue 3, pp. 310–318). entrepreneurship and sustainability center. https://doi.org/10.9770/jesi.2017.4.3s(6) paul, j., lim, w. m., o’cass, a., hao, a. w., & bresciani, s. (2021). scientific procedures and rationales for systematic literature reviews (spar-4-slr). international journal of consumer studies. https://doi.org/10.1111/ijcs.12695 piontek, f. m., herrmann, c., & saraev, a. (2021). steps from zero carbon supply chains and demand of circular economy to circular business cases. european journal of social impact and circular economy, 2(2), 1–9. https://ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/article/view/5712 pope, j., annandale, d., & morrison-saunders, a. (2004). conceptualising sustainability assessment. environmental impact assessment review, 24(6), 595–616. qiao, l., tang, y., li, y., liu, m., yuan, x., wang, q., & ma, q. (2022). life cycle assessment of three typical recycled products from construction and demolition waste. in journal of cleaner production (vol. 376). elsevier ltd. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2022.134139 rossi, f., rosli, a., & yip, n. (2017). academic engagement as knowledge co-production and implications for impact: evidence from knowledge transfer partnerships. in journal of business research (vol. 80, pp. 1–9). elsevier inc. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jbusres.2017.06.019 saber, d. a., & silka, l. (2020). food waste as a classic problem that calls for interdisciplinary solutions: a case study illustration. journal of social issues, 76(1), 114–122. https://doi.org/10.1111/josi.12372 european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/8539 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 76 sadraei, r., biancone, p., lanzalonga, f., jafari-sadeghi, v., & chmet, f. (2022). how to increase sustainable production in the food sector? mapping industrial and business strategies and providing future research agenda. business strategy and the environment. sandanayake, m., kumanayake, r., & peiris, a. (2022). environmental impact assessments during construction stage at different geographic levels – a cradle-to-gate analysis of using sustainable concrete materials. in engineering, construction and architectural management (vol. 29, issue 4, pp. 1731–1752). emerald group holdings ltd. https://doi.org/10.1108/ecam-10-2020-0846 sandanayake, m., zhang, g., setunge, s., luo, w., & li, c.-q. (2017). estimation and comparison of environmental emissions and impacts at foundation and structure construction stages of a building – a case study. in journal of cleaner production (vol. 151, pp. 319–329). elsevier ltd. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2017.03.041 schnitzer, h., brunner, c., & gwehenberger, g. (2007). minimizing greenhouse gas emissions through the application of solar thermal energy in industrial processes. in journal of cleaner production (vol. 15, issues 13–14, pp. 1271–1286). https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2006.07.023 schulhof, v., van vuuren, d., & kirchherr, j. (2022). the belt and road initiative (bri): what will it look like in the future? in technological forecasting and social change (vol. 175). elsevier inc. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.techfore.2021.121306 secinaro, s., brescia, v., calandra, d., & biancone, p. (2020). employing bibliometric analysis to identify suitable business models for electric cars. journal of cleaner production, 264, 121503. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2020.121503 secinaro, s., brescia, v., lanzalonga, f., & santoro, g. (2022). smart city reporting: a bibliometric and structured literature review analysis to identify technological opportunities and challenges for sustainable development. journal of business research, 149, 296–313. secinaro, s., calandra, d., lanzalonga, f., & ferraris, a. (2022). electric vehicles’ consumer behaviours: mapping the field and providing a research agenda. journal of business research, 150, 399–416. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jbusres.2022.06.011 sheetal, narang, d., & singh, g. (2023). a conceptual reappraisal of risks in the implementation of bri after covid-19: best strategies to learn for cmnes in bri projects. in thunderbird international business review (vol. 65, issue 3, pp. 293–310). john wiley and sons inc. https://doi.org/10.1002/tie.22338 shi, s., huang, b., ren, f., duan, l., lei, j., wang, y., wang, x., wu, q., li, w., xiong, y., li, n., hu, j., & nakatani, j. (2022). life cycle assessment of embodied human health effects of building materials in china. in journal of cleaner production (vol. 350). elsevier ltd. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2022.131484 ştefănescu, c. a., tiron-tudor, a., & moise, e. m. (2021). eu non-financial reporting research–insights, gaps, patterns and future agenda. journal of business economics and management, 22(1), 257–276. https://doi.org/10.3846/jbem.2020.13479 talanquer, v. (2014). using qualitative analysis software to facilitate qualitative data analysis. in d. m. bunce & r. s. cole (eds.), tools of chemistry education research (vol. 1166, pp. 83–95). american chemical society. https://doi.org/10.1021/bk-2014-1166.ch005 teo, p., gajanayake, a., jayasuriya, s., izaddoost, a., perera, t., naderpajouh, n., & wong, p. s. p. (2022). application of a bottom-up approach to estimate economic impacts of building maintenance projects: cladding rectification program in australia. in engineering, construction and architectural management (vol. 29, issue 1, pp. 333–353). emerald group holdings ltd. https://doi.org/10.1108/ecam-10-2020-0802 tran, c. n. n., tam, v. w. y., le, k. n., & illankoon, i. m. c. s. (2023). environmental impacts assessment for australian buildings: thermal resistance and environmental impacts relationship. in international journal of construction management (vol. 23, issue 2, pp. 243–252). taylor and francis ltd. https://doi.org/10.1080/15623599.2020.1858522 treloar, g. j., love, p. e. d., faniran, o. o., & iyer-raniga, u. (2000). a hybrid life cycle assessment method for construction. in construction management and economics (vol. 18, issue 1, pp. 5–9). routledge journals. https://doi.org/10.1080/014461900370898 uluyol, b., secinaro, s., calandra, d., & lanzalonga, f. (2021). mapping waqf research: a thirty-year bibliometric analysis. journal of islamic accounting and business research. https://doi.org/10.1108/jiabr-01-2021-0031 united nations. (2015). sdgs—sustainable development goals. https://sdgs.un.org/goals van eck, n. j., & waltman, l. (2011). vosviewer manual. manual for vosviewer version, 1(0). vaska, s., massaro, m., bagarotto, e. m., & dal mas, f. (2021). the digital transformation of business model innovation: a structured literature review. frontiers in psychology, 11, 3557. https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2020.539363 european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/8539 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 77 vitale, p., spagnuolo, a., lubritto, c., & arena, u. (2018). environmental performances of residential buildings with a structure in cold formed steel or reinforced concrete. in journal of cleaner production (vol. 189, pp. 839–852). elsevier ltd. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2018.04.088 wu, x., & sun, y. (2018). a green scheduling algorithm for flexible job shop with energy-saving measures. in journal of cleaner production (vol. 172, pp. 3249–3264). elsevier ltd. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2017.10.342 zahra, s. a., & wright, m. (2016). understanding the social role of entrepreneurship. journal of management studies, 53(4), 610–629. zupic, i., & čater, t. (2015). bibliometric methods in management and organization. organizational research methods, 18(3), 429–472. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/10926 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 1 economic evaluation framework for industrial symbiosis through network lenses: a systematic literature review maurizio cisi1*, roberta napoli2 1 university of turin, department of management, corso unione sovietica 2018bis, 10134, turin, italy maurizio.cisi@unito.it *contact author orcid https://orcid.org/0000-0001-5281-0978 2 university of turin, department of management, corso unione sovietica 2018bis, 10134, turin, italy roberta.napoli@unito.it orcid https://orcid.org/0009-0002-5066-6508 received: 01/08/2024 accepted for publication: 26/11/2024 published: 20/12/2024 abstract current economic and productive systems, characterized by huge resource consumption, cause significant environmental and social impacts, underlining their intrinsic unsustainability. this research explored circular economy models, in particular industrial symbiosis (is) process, involving materials, energy, water and by-products exchange among different entities. although the economic aspect is often considered of paramount importance, is costs and benefits proved to be scarcely identified and properly quantified in the existing literature, since methodologies lack an organized structure to link economic outcomes to specific activities that generate value, which, in turn, remains assumed at a merely descriptive level if there’s no quantification approach alternative to market value estimation. therefore, through a systematic literature review literature (2019-2023), 61 articles were analyzed, with the objective of filling the knowledge gap by means of systematization of recent scientific evidence on is economic aspect, pinpointing areas of potential economic advantage or disadvantage, for the final construction of an innovative and detailed is economic evaluation framework, including revenues and costs items, calculation methodologies and specific performance kpis. this research contributes to the broad comprehension of economic benefits, bolstering sustainable practices and network business model adoption. keywords: industrial symbiosis, economic evaluation, networking, industrial ecology, circular economy european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/10926 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 2 1. introduction the current economic and productive systems, based on a large and growing resource consumption, entail significant footprints, in terms of environmental and social impacts, proving their intrinsic unsustainability; therefore, the need to find innovative sustainable business models (bocken et al., 2014), that can minimize negative effects and positively influence the way value is generated and distributed. among them, the circular economy business model, aiming at creating value from waste management, transformation and recovery (sadraei et al., 2023) represents a source of competitive advantage, combining the generation of profit from differentiated products with a conscious perspective on environmental impacts (costanza, 2020). this business model often translates into industrial symbiosis (is) processes, engaging “traditionally separate entities in a collective approach to competitive advantage involving physical exchange of materials, energy, water, and by-products” (chertow, 2000), and distinguishing itself from other types of mutual interaction because, according to some authors, it associates at least three distinct entities in the exchange of two, or more, different resources (albino et al., 2016; chertow, 2007). case-study analysis (neves et al., 2020) underlines the development and wide adoption of symbiosis practices, involving a variety of industries (lombardi & laybourn, 2012), mainly from the manufacturing sector. scientific literature emphasizes, as peculiar features and keys of success, cooperation and synergistic possibilities provided by geographical proximity (boons et al., 2017; chertow, 2000, 2007): for those reasons, the symbiotic process generally takes place inside the so-called eco-industrial parks, defined as communities of businesses that cooperate to gain economic, environmental and social advantages from the efficient share of resources (chertow, 2000). in fact, is models fully took shape within the eco-industrial park of kalundborg, denmark, although many scholars do not consider spatial proximity as a necessary or sufficient pre-condition (neves et al., 2020; zhang et al., 2015), exploring other possibilities for non-localized exchanges, as knowledge networks, intended to eco-innovation and efficient resource use (lombardi & laybourn, 2012). indeed, by investigating temporal evolution (mallawaarachchi et al., 2020), it can be noticed that is definition has been enlarged, to embrace intangible exchanges, besides sharing of services and infrastructure. moreover, three specific dimensions have been progressively integrated and deepened: willingness for network cooperation, structural and sociocultural context, and externalities linked to exchanges’ sustainability and consequential economic and environmental gains. scientific research regarding is framed it into the field of industrial ecology (ie) (baldassarre et al., 2019; lybæk et al., 2021), that discipline considering industrial systems similar to ecosystems, with the aim of reducing environmental impacts and closing energy and resource loops. recently, the analysis has been broadened to the domain of circular economy (ce), an umbrella concept that promotes the transition towards circular models for recycling, reusing, and waste valorization, combining environmental and economic goals (macarthur, 2013). businesses are at the forefront of transition, and peculiar partnerships that develop within an is are a driving force for enterprises’ shift towards production systems oriented to circularity (costanza, 2020). the ce-focused definition certainly receives more validation at the political level, in particular from european policy landscape, which acknowledges is as a strategic key for circularity of industrial and economic systems, within the scope of policies and programs such as the circular economy action plan (lybæk et al., 2021; neves et al., 2020; wadström et al., 2021). even if both disciplines are built on close-loops theories, ce addresses is both as a critical dimension to evaluate circularity (piontek et al., 2021). and as a business model in which its principles take european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/10926 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 3 shape (ranjbari et al., 2021), clarifying the economic rationale and operative functioning, and integrating ie perspective, which provides a good understanding of is as a sociotechnical process and its development over time (baldassarre et al., 2019). focus on economic aspects can be found since the starting point of is processes: scientific literature identifies costs reductions (colpo et al., 2022b; lybæk et al., 2021) and search for private advantages (chertow, 2000, 2007) as the main raison d’être for symbiotic exchanges, while the acknowledgment of environmental benefits as a positive consequence of resource flows happens at a later time (boons et al., 2017; wadström et al., 2021). in fact, even if circularity offers a concrete manner to reduce emissions and environmental impacts linked to the use of materials along the whole value chain, it should also represent a more attractive production system for companies from an economic point of view (piontek et al., 2021). the strategic opportunity for financial gains, often resulting from scarce raw material availability (chertow, 2007; faria et al., 2021), makes a spontaneous triggering of is (boons et al., 2017; neves et al., 2020): researchers highlight the need to “uncover” (chertow, 2007) symbiosis dynamics and their social structures, in order to incentivize exchanges and spread knowledge with the support of specific policies (boons et al., 2017; chertow, 2007; lybæk et al., 2021), aiming at overcoming major operative, technological, economic-financial, knowledge and sociocultural barriers (colpo et al., 2022b; kosmol & otto, 2020; re et al., 2023; taqi et al., 2022), and their associated risks (henriques et al., 2020). however, even if the economic aspect is one of the most investigated, because of its primary relevance, scholars pinpoint the need to identify and properly measure economic implications, enlarging the scope of research by including quantified is economic costs and benefits, more than merely descriptive outcomes. (wadström et al., 2021). in fact, current analytical schemes are able to estimate economic advantages and disadvantages only through means of existing associated market value, pointing out the lack of specific frameworks for the identification and integration of all kinds of value, essential for a comprehensive evaluation of is feasibility, beyond the market one, outlining furthermore a structured model to link outcomes to specific activities generating value. consequently, this study was motivated to fill this knowledge gap by a systematic review of recent literature (2019-2023) in the field of is economic analysis, from business’ point of view, in order to ascertain research trends through a bibliometric analysis, in addition to outlining most cited areas of potential advantage/disadvantages. consequently, the research conducted was oriented to answer the following questions: rq1: what is the research trend in the field of is economic analysis? rq2: what are the most relevant areas of potential economic costs/benefits? from the examination of 61 scientific articles, assessed on the basis of a dedicated review protocol, papers’ metadata and content data were extracted about industrial sectors involved, economic evaluation and the methodology implemented. final objective consisted in the construction of a detailed framework, innovative and different from all others because of clear specification of all cost and revenue items and their quantification methodologies, useful to consider in an is project economic feasibility study because of their recurrence in scientific literature. in a context of growing interest in is as a powerful tool to achieve triple sustainability goals (neves et al., 2020), this research contributes to the systematization of recent evidence in the field of analysis, which constitutes the theoretical basis of the framework, which proves practically useful for weighing benefits european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/10926 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 4 and disadvantages that may affect firms in overall evaluation of is projects. further relevance of this study is confirmed by its helpfulness in overcoming economic barriers and incentivizing the adoption of is practices and network business models. the structure of this paper is as follows: section 2 delineates methodological steps in conducting systematic literature review, section 3 presents the main bibliometric results and findings useful to construct economic framework of analysis, developed in section 4, also devoted to general discussion. section 5 draws conclusions, limitations of the study and recommendations for future research development. 2. methodology of research systematic literature review could be defined as “a systematic, explicit, [comprehensive,] and reproducible method for identifying, evaluating, and synthesizing the existing body of completed and recorded work produced by researchers, scholars, and practitioners” (fink, 2019). this means that the analysis, to be called scientific, must be “systematic in following a methodological approach, explicit in explaining the procedures by which it was conducted, comprehensive in its scope of including all relevant material, and, hence, reproducible by others who would follow the same approach in reviewing the topic” (okoli, 2015) this approach was deemed the most appropriate to provide an in-depth summary of existent evidence on the state of the art for industrial symbiosis, particularly focused on benefits and disadvantages involved in economic feasibility assessment. to pursue this aim, the presented analysis adapted systematic literature review (slr) methodology outlined by okoli (2015), following a replicable, scientific and transparent approach based on an eight-step guide: 1. identify the purpose: to be clear and explicit with the audience, the purpose of this study was to fill a knowledge gap by providing a deep understanding of the most up-to-date state-of-the-art on economic feasibility of industrial symbiosis. generally speaking, this analysis was conducted to systematize progress in field of inquiry, develop a framework based on latest scientific evidence and make recommendations for future research; 2. draft protocol and train the team: a written protocol document, as a road map to conduct the review, provided details and training for both reviewers, in order to guarantee consistency and uniformity of analysis; 3. apply practical screen: in order to critically select sources for scientific evidence, screening for inclusion involved three filter criteria: publication language: english, the one both reviewers could read; range of publication: last five years (2019-2023), to focus on the most up-to-date progress in the field of inquiry and to uncover potential research avenues; document type: article, to ensure peer-reviewed quality paper excluding reviews of literature. no filter for journal or subject area was considered, in order to make the review as more comprehensive as possible, taking into account interdisciplinarity in analysis; 4. search for literature: literature search was performed on scopus and web of science platforms (pranckutė, 2021). european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/10926 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 5 frequently used by researchers across social sciences and disciplines, these databases were selected because they ensure a holistic and multidisciplinary vision of the research theme, including high-impact articles on aspects ranging from environmental engineering to sustainable development and circular economy, essential for an integrated analysis. search string was built on concepts directly related to the research questions. in order to reach the largest number of relevant articles in the most scientific manner, a preliminary keyword pattern analysis was carried out using vosviewer. a small representative sample of articles analyzing economical aspects of industrial symbiosis was used to extrapolate keywords most appropriate and cited by scholars in the field of research. performing a brief first analysis of databases’ results, researchers opted to maintain keywords combining the two criteria of breadth and specificity. on the one hand, selected keywords provided the highest number of results; on the other hand, coherence with the research theme was evaluated in order to guarantee as focused analysis as possible, excluding circular practices beyond the definition of industrial symbiosis (chertow, 2000a). moreover, the use of boolean operators among selected terms let the researchers take advantage of database search power. this strategy led to a search string where the term “industrial symbiosis” was combined with synonyms identifying economic implications. in particular, the search string (“industrial symbiosis” and (“effect” or “economic* aspect*” or “benefit” or “economic* analysis” or “cost”)) was performed on databases, searching within “article title, abstract and keywords”. asterisks were used because they represent any number of characters. the procedure was deemed effective to answer the research questions because it let researchers be as specific as possible, excluding circular practices beyond the boundaries of industrial symbiosis, aligning with the objective of constructing an economic evaluation framework as detailed as possible on specific peculiarities of symbiotic exchanges. records identified through searching on web of science and scopus were filtered according to criteria for practical screening; then, the removal of duplicates (n= 127) and not accessible (n= 8) articles led to a preliminary total of n= 323 papers for eligibility; 5. extract data: this step involved the gathering of information that serves as raw material for answering research questions, analyzing and discussing results. in particular, the following data were extracted: keywords, journal and year of publication: to perform bibliometric analysis and assess evolution patterns in scientific literature; economical cost/benefit: to give a direct answer to research question, upon which building economic assessment framework for industrial symbiosis; industries involved in symbiotic exchanges: to understand what economic sectors could be interested as potential users of the framework; methodology for quantifying costs/benefits: to comprehend what applicable calculation methodologies are for the practical implementation of the framework. 6. appraise quality: screening in full-text for exclusion led to articles scored on the basis of qualitative quality appraisal that did not involve methodology evaluation but appropriateness in answering the research question. to ensure articles met this criterion, a preliminary review was implemented on a total of n= 323 papers, accurately reading titles and abstracts; from this step, n= 184 articles were excluded. then, a refined assessment based on full-text was manually performed. this last step led european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/10926 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 6 to a final total number of n= 61 articles included in systematic literature review. in each evaluation step, researchers have always confronted each other on doubts of interpretation; 7. synthesize studies: charts and tables, presented in result section, were drafted to map at best the extracted data and to structure the systematic literature review; figure 11. systematic literature review – methodological process source: authors own elaboration from okoli, c. (2015). a guide to conducting a standalone systematic literature review. 1 criteria of selection are specified as follows: criteria n. 1: first preliminary title and abstract evaluation about relevance and usefulness in answering research questions; criteria n. 2: integral paper analysis to evaluate relevance and usefulness in answering research questions. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/10926 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 7 8. write the review: final step involving paper writing; in particular, a framework for economic assessment of industrial symbiosis was built upon analyzed literature and presented in discussion section. this represented the practical implication of the study carried out, proving its usefulness especially for companies that want to test economic sustainability of industrial symbiosis projects. figure 1 illustrates the above-mentioned process of search, selection and screening, with the detailed number of articles involved in each phase. 3. results 3.1 review of research trends this section is devoted to description and discussion of results emerging from bibliometric analysis of selected articles, especially useful to give an answer to the first research question, identifying evolution trends and evaluating research progress in the field of industrial symbiosis economic analysis. in particular, after the application of selection criteria exposed in methodological section, the main articles’ data were extracted, concerning journal and year of publication, in order to draw conclusions about the trend of research. finally, a keywords co-occurrence analysis was conducted to deeply understand semantic relations and emerging issues, to better direct future investigations. the following analysis comprises 61 articles included in the systematic literature review, related to economic analysis of industrial symbiosis and published from 2019 up to 2023. the records analyzed were written by 243 different authors, for a total of 1.069 citations. figure 2 illustrates publication evolution over time, starting from 2019 up to 2023. figure 2. publication evolution over time, 2019-2023 source: authors own elaboration 9 10 14 16 12 0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 number of publication per year (2019-2023) european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/10926 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 8 as can be seen, 2022 was the year with the highest number of articles published (16), while 2019 records the minimum of publications (9). generally speaking, it can be noticed that the number of articles has grown steadily, reflecting an increasing interest of the scientific community that may be related to the ever-rising attention to sustainability issues and transition towards more circular production models, backed by industrial symbiosis within the scope of circular economy (yazan & fraccascia, 2020), for which it is relevant to assess economic feasibility, besides environmental and social implications. the growing centrality of economic issues regarding industrial symbiosis provides a rationale for the comprehensive recent literature systematization, conducted in this study. figure 3 illustrates the number of publications by journal. the 61 selected articles were collected from 31 different journals, but most appear in a few key journals. figure 3. number of publications by journal source: authors own elaboration as can be seen, the distribution is not uniform: in particular, journal of cleaner production is the most influential research journal, with 13 articles on the investigated topic, while the top 5 gather a considerable percentage of publications (nearly 51%), proving they are of special importance in industrial symbiosis research related to economic aspects. in conclusion, the presence 13 6 5 4 3 3 2 2 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 journal o f c leaner p roducti on reso urce s, c onserva tio n and recyc lin g su sta inabilit y energies journal o f in dustr ial e co logy su sta inable producti on and consu mptio n computers and chemica l e ngineerin g enviro nmental a nd clim ate tech nologies applie d energy biofuels, bioproducts and biorefin ing chemica l e ngineerin g transacti ons circ ular e co nomy a nd su sta inabilit y computers and in dustr ial e ngin eerin g curre nt r ese arch in envir onmental su sta inabilit y energy energy research and socia l s cie nce enviro nmental s cie nce and pollu tio n research enviro nmental s cie nce and tech nologies fo od and bioproducts proce ssi ng internatio nal jo urnal o f l ife cycl e asse ssm ent internatio nal jo urnal o f p roducti on eco nomics internatio nal jo urnal o f p roducti on rese arch journal o f a gric ultu re and food research journal o f o pen in nova tio n: t ech nology, market, a nd complexit y proce dia envir onmental sc ience , e ngineerin g a nd m anagement proce ss integratio n and optim iza tio n fo r s usta inabilit y renewable and susta inable energy r evie ws reso urce s, c onserva tio n and recyc lin g advance s sm art energy tech nologic al fo recasti ng and so cia l c hange waste and biomass valoriz atio n number of publications per journal european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/10926 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 9 of influential journals in the field of waste management, energy engineering, innovation and technology proves the interdisciplinary point of view adopted by scholars in examining industrial symbiosis. vosviewer software was then used to perform a keywords co-occurrence analysis, with the aim of enlightening hotspots and revealing most popular themes in the topic of interest. keywords’ cluster evaluation could help in the reconnaissance of semantics used for the topic, in order to understand past trends and advances in the field, and to give direction to future research. correlations among clusters can reveal border-crossing themes and future possible links to different disciplines and research fields. the network visualization provided by vosviewer was created applying the “full counting” method and keeping the keywords which appeared, at least, 3 times (for a total of 59 keywords). figure 4. keywords co-occurrence analysis network visualization from vosviewer source: authors own elaboration from vosviewer european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/10926 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 10 the three most relevant keywords, linked with industrial symbiosis (number of occurrences: 45), are sustainable development (number of occurrences: 21), circular economy (number of occurrences: 19), industrial ecology (number of occurrences: 8), resulting in 2 clusters. figure 4 displays the keywords network split into 4 clusters. the first and largest cluster, the red one, is related to industrial symbiosis outcome assessment and it includes words like “economic and social effect”, “environmental management”, “costbenefit analysis”. the existence of this cluster may be motivated by the fact that evaluating the whole impact is relevant to understanding the reasons behind the spontaneous triggering of industrial symbiosis and also to incentivizing its implementation. the second, the green one, encompasses circular economy themes, and it is composed of words like “costs”, “recycling”, “waste management”. the presence of keywords linked to industrial ecology justifies a particular attention devoted to interconnections between these two research domains2, in which industrial symbiosis can be placed. the third, the blue cluster, is focused on sustainable development and it involves terms like “climate change”, “sustainability”, “supply chains”; understanding the contribution of industrial symbiosis to sustainable development may be the concern that led scholars focus on this topic. lastly, the yellow cluster, though the smaller, contains words related to industrial symbiosis, which is the central research theme of this paper: “industrial park”, “reuse”, “design”. the often concretization of industrial symbiosis into eco-industrial parks can validate the presence of this specifically focused topic. it is relevant to underline the connection with domains of circular economy, industrial ecology, and methodologies of impact assessment, such as “life-cycle assessment,” “cost-benefit analysis,” and “environmental assessment.” still, little space is devoted to consideration of social impacts, unveiling possibilities for future deepening of the subject. 3.2 synthesis of main results this section is devoted to description and discussion of results coming from main articles’ contents and information that were deemed useful for answering research questions and building economic evaluation framework. in particular, data were extracted about research methodologies, to comprehend what calculation methods are predominant in literature for estimation of costs and benefits, industries involved in symbiotic exchanges, to understand what economic sectors could be interested, and areas of economic costs and benefits, to give direct answer to research question. first of all, papers examined were classified into three different categories: “evaluation of real case studies”, focused on comparison between pre-is – post is scenarios, for those analysis of already implemented is practices; “evaluation of symbiosis project”, oriented to the appraisal of feasibility of designed is and/or shared facilities in a network of enterprises; “application on a real case-study”, for evaluation of designed is practices applied in a real industrial context. the majority of studies involved the second category (nearly 50% of examined papers); 27% were applications on real case studies, while the remaining were evaluations of pre-is – post-is scenarios. this implies that there could be some difficulties in finding studies assessing implemented is economic contribution, the generality being analysis of costs and benefits specifically attributed to a project. 2 differences and commonalities between circular economy and industrial ecology were extensively explained in the introduction section. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/10926 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 11 3.2.1 methodologies the first content data analyzed involved quantification methodologies used for is project evaluation carried out in the selected studies for slr. understanding the estimation process allowed to create a basis upon which to build an integrated and comprehensive methodology within the framework of economic analysis. for this reason, table i illustrates principal methodologies followed by examined literature in conducting the research and quantifying is economic costs and benefits, with a brief description and the list of references which made use of each of them. table i. research methodologies analysis methodology description references cash flows analysis estimation of monetary flows of revenues and costs incurred in a period of time, on the basis of financial market prices. values could be discounted, if they involve future potential monetary flows. wijeyekoon et al., 2021 cost-benefit analysis estimation of revenues obtained and costs incurred in a period of time, on the basis of financial market prices. it could consider external costs, primarily environmental and social, translated into monetary terms. values could be discounted, if they involve future potential monetary flows. cervo et al., 2019 pakere et al., 2021 sun et al., 2020 zabaniotou & vaskalis, 2023 cost savings and cost analysis estimation of items of cost associated with a project through monetary terms; if a project involves cost reduction, then it could be an estimation of cost savings, as the difference between pre and post financial costs. values could be discounted, if they involve future potential monetary flows. ali et al., 2019 hu et al., 2020 li et al., 2021 profit and net present value (npv) analysis calculation of profit margin as the difference between revenues obtained and costs incurred in a specific period of time. values could be discounted, if they involve future potential economic or financial flows, to calculate a net present value. colpo et al., 2022a de souza & pacca, 2023 dong et al., 2022 hedlund et al., 2022 kerdlap et al., 2022 liao et al., 2024 sheppard et al., 2019 life-cycle costing financial evaluation of total costs of a project, from its inception through to its disposal; the conventional c-lcc involves only economic costs, while environmental e-lcc and social s-lcc also consider externalities ali et al., 2020 ansanelli et al., 2023 diaz et al., 2021 haq et al., 2020 european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/10926 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 12 ruiz & diaz, 2022 zhang et al., 2022b agent-based model simulation framework for interaction of individual entities according to defined rules. cost saving function is often included to model agent behaviors fraccascia et al., 2020 yazan & fraccascia, 2020 game theory approach theoretical framework analyzing strategic interactions among decision-makers, in which payoffs for each participant depend on the choices of all involved. to estimate economic outcomes, profit margin or economic benefit calculations are often used. ahmad fadzil et al., 2022 chin et al., 2021 galvan-cara et al., 2022 he et al., 2020 linear and non-linear programming optimization model mathematical technique used to optimize a function subject to a set of linear or non-linear constraints. in the case of mixedinteger or multi-integer programming models, some variables could assume integer values. financial cost analysis often provides the economic constraint, while the optimization goal could be a profit maximization al-quradaghi et al., 2022 asghari et al., 2023 boix et al., 2023 bütün et al., 2019 chatterjee et al., 2021 farouk & chew, 2021 goh et al., 2022 misrol et al., 2022 misrol et al., 2021 yu et al., 2023 singular or manyobjective optimization model optimization framework that deals with a large number of objectives, often conflicting. economic equations involving cash flows or cost savings analysis are used as constraints or optimization objectives. cao et al., 2020 fahmy et al., 2021 lyu et al., 2023 teh et al., 2021 yeşı̇lkaya et al., 2020 source: authors own elaboration for clarity of analysis, research methodologies could be clustered into four macro-categories: financial evaluation models, adopted by the great majority of studies, aim to evaluate financial and economic flows, and they are built upon quantification through market values of revenues obtained and costs incurred and/or avoided in a specific period of time. this category includes cash flows and cost-benefit analysis, though this last could also incorporate external costs, as environmental and social ones, translated into monetary terms; cost savings and costs analysis, particularly recommendable to understand reductions and cost profiles of a project; profit analysis and net present value calculation. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/10926 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 13 the temporal dimension could be taken into account by discounting financial flows and building performance indexes, as internal rate of return (irr) (colpo et al., 2022a; sheppard et al., 2019), profit index (pi) (fahmy et al., 2021; ruiz & diaz, 2022) or payback period (pp) (falsafi et al., 2023; sun et al., 2020), to give a synthetic overview of economic profitability; life-cycle evaluation models: advanced technique for quantification of total economic costs incurred all along the life cycle of a project, from its inception to its disposal. as a conventional method (c-lcc), it can be used to compare cost profiles of different projects; as a full life-cycle impact assessment (lcia), comprehensive of environmental (e-lcc) and social (s-lcc) analysis, it goes beyond economic consideration, including external costs, especially linked to eco-efficiency and environmental and social impacts (zhang et al., 2022b), quantified by way of emission factors and technical coefficients (ali et al., 2020; ruiz & diaz, 2022); decision models: methodologies for agent behaviors simulation inside a broader network, for this reason often used in is analysis and distribution of aggregated costs and benefits. in a game-theory model, outputs depend on cooperative approach and behavior of each participant, while agent-based models simulate actors’ conduct according to different sets of rules. to model behaviors on economic reasoning, an economic-objective function, very often a cost (chin et al., 2021; fraccascia et al., 2020) or a net benefit (ahmad fadzil et al., 2022; galvan-cara et al., 2022) function, is included; optimization models: frameworks for optimization of is practices, often used in application research to existent or designed is projects. optimization aims at constrained maximization (or minimization) of different objectives, as frequently conflicting functions for environmental and economic goals (cao et al., 2020; yeşı̇lkaya et al., 2020), expressed through cash flows analysis or financial costs (asghari et al., 2023; fahmy et al., 2021) and cost savings (lyu et al., 2023) analysis. as the final objective consisted of orientating economic evaluation framework to the most appropriate quantification methodology, this analysis led to the conclusion that a more financial focus, translating costs and benefits into monetary terms, integrated with models quantifying and optimizing external impacts all along the life cycle, beyond the mere financial sphere, is useful in obtaining a comprehensive evaluation of an is project in its temporal range. 3.2.2 economic sectors involved from the analysis of economic sectors engaged in is and circular processes, it could be stated that not all cases precisely defined type and destination of resources exchanged, and specific role (as a receiver or as a donor) of firms in symbiotic relationship. these elements turned out to be relevant, within a framework of analysis, to understand entity and subdivision of costs and benefits among resources exchange activities and agents in the network. for those articles clearly identifying exchange components, it could be observed that the principal destination (nearly 55% of cases) of resources shared, mainly biomasses, wastewater and waste heat and steam, involved production of any kind of energy (electricity, steam and heat for power production), that could be directed to an internal use or sold externally, either way contributing to economic benefit, lowering energy costs (diaz et al., 2021; sheppard et al., 2019; wang et al., 2019) or as new source of revenues (haq et al., european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/10926 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 14 2020; sun et al., 2020; tan yue dian et al., 2021). several studies (24%) focused on production of building materials, predominantly from slag residues, fly ashes, agro-industrial wastes and other scrap materials in the same industry. considering the whole number of articles examined, 34% of them explicitly outlined direct exchanges between two entities characterized as donor and receiver. framing economic sectors through the use of isic3 classification and the consideration of type and destination of wastes, analysis of direct exchanges showed that, again, the industries participating mainly as receivers were energy production and manufacturing of non-metallic products for building (43% for both), while major donors were industrial and agro-industrial sectors, especially for biowastes sharing, including domestic sector (saeli et al., 2023). flows of materials could engage the same industry (18% of examined articles): as example, chemical (farouk & chew, 2021; lyu et al., 2023) and agrifood industry (prieto-sandoval et al., 2022; raimondo et al., 2023; yu et al., 2023), where biomasses could be turned into biological fertilizers. a great percentage of studies (40%) focused on mutual exchanges inside industrial parks and ecological networks without an explicit definition of resource flows. prominent examples are the agriculture and forestry sectors (hu et al., 2020; yeşı̇lkaya et al., 2020), steel, iron, and cement industries (xue et al., 2023; zhang et al., 2022a). inside a network, exchanges are not purely material: it is worth noting a particular study on sharing carbon permits, which led to increasing profits and overall network efficiency (ahmad fadzil et al., 2022). ultimately, economic sector analysis proved to be essential to understand main ways of interaction for symbiotic exchanges across different industrial contexts, each one with its own specificities, in order to improve flexibility of the framework for economic is costs and benefits, highlighted by scientific literature and pointed out in the following section. 3.2.3 cost-benefit analysis scientific evidence of is economic costs and benefits was summarized in figure 5, displaying a circular chart divided into four main sections: cost reduction, as a source of economic advantage, identified by 45 examined articles (out of 61); new revenues, as a source of economic advantage, identified by 31 examined articles (out of 61); new costs, as a source of economic disadvantage, identified by 19 examined articles (out of 61); revenues reduction, as a source of economic disadvantage, identified by 1 examined articles (out of 61). it follows that, given the extracted data, cost reduction represents the most recognized is economic implication, both by optimization application models and research on feasibility assessment. then, each main section of the chart is divided into all costs and revenues items highlighted by scientific literature; the size of each of them reflects the percentage number of mentions received relative to the total mentions in the domain of the corresponding main section. 3 isic stands for international standard industrial classification of all economic activities, a globally standardized system for classifying industries by a four-level hierarchy and for reporting of economic activities across countries. european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/10926 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 15 figure 5. cost-benefit analysis – circular chart source: authors own elaboration the most observed benefit was cost reduction (blue section of the circular graph), particularly for raw materials (34% of cost reduction mentions), waste management and disposal (32%), substantially avoided, and operating and utility costs, as costs for water and energy (cortez et al., 2022; diaz et al., 2021; hedlund et al., 2022; ruiz-puente & jato-espino, 2020). this advantage was revealed both by comparative studies between is – non-is scenarios (cervo et al., 2019; raciti et al., 2019; zhang et al., 2022b), and by optimization analysis of designed and/or already implemented is (al-quradaghi et al., 2022; chatterjee et al., 2021; lyu et al., 2023), confirming evidence in literature about the main raison d’être of is (chertow, 2000, 2007; colpo et al., 2022a; lybæk et al., 2021). a small, though significant, presence of reduction in capital costs must be pointed out, confirmed by studies reporting a decrease in equipment costs as one of the economic benefits, though limited, cited by companies (wahrlich & simioni, 2019). this reduction in costs referred to all those cases for shared infrastructure: when it comes to highly centralized and coordinated partnerships, as within eco-industrial parks, enterprises could benefit from the provision of common services and maintenance (fraccascia et al., 2019; wahrlich & simioni, 2019), while installing advanced production systems, otherwise economically not viable, on already existent plants (goh et al., 2022; wijeyekoon et al., 2021). then, analysis of new revenues followed (orange section of the circular graph), first of all from sales of products (62% of new revenues mentions), mainly generation of electricity and other kinds of energy (hedlund et al., 2022; misrol et al., 2021; ruiz & diaz, 2022; sun et al., 2020). economic advantages from sale of waste were less reported (24%): many evaluations were based on free exchanges, which can represent an avoided cost, for receivers (raciti et al., 2019); other studies, instead, underlined the reduced value of wastes, which sometimes is overshadowed by transportation (borbon-galvez et al., 2021; european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/10926 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 16 domenech et al., 2019) or treatment costs for recycling and reusing (he et al., 2020; saeli et al., 2023). few studies mentioned enhanced productivity (chen et al., 2022; dong et al., 2022; raimondo et al., 2023; wahrlich & simioni, 2019) and reputational gains (fraccascia et al., 2019). cost items (grey section of the circular graph) that could impact to a greater extent, according to examined literature, were, first and foremost, capital costs (37% of new costs mentions) for equipment and infrastructure (chin et al., 2021; sun et al., 2020), technologies (bütün et al., 2019) and working capital (colpo et al., 2022a), which reflect on manufacturing and other operating costs (repair and maintenance, 20%). if it is true that costs for required equipment and infrastructure are economically unviable for single entities (colpo et al., 2022a), other studies also highlighted the need for institutional financial incentives to face capital costs for grand coalition, more capable of obtaining significant reduction of environmental impacts (chin et al., 2021). on the other hand, scholars pinpointed that some technologies could entail lower costs, depending on the system they are implemented in and giving rise to the need for specific considerations about the industrial sector involved (asghari et al., 2023), while the degree of nestedness could also results in total gains balancing capital costs (chatterjee et al., 2021). in this regard, some studies (fraccascia et al., 2019; sellitto et al., 2021) emphasized the presence of transaction costs, that depend on interaction among enterprises involved. geographic localization is an is aspect that should be investigated carefully: main studies reporting a reduction in transportation costs were focused on proximity exchanges of material resources (goh et al., 2022; raciti et al., 2019; wijeyekoon et al., 2021), while others underline the need to broaden boundaries of symbiosis to reach variegate sources of waste, despite this could have an impact on resources’ quality (borbon-galvez et al., 2021). even if transportation costs depend on weight and chemical characteristics of wastes, whose marginal value is close to zero (domenech et al., 2019), shipping carriers also play an important role (ali et al., 2019), if treated as an endogenous variable whose optimization could eventually lead to economic benefits, looking for more sustainable transport strategies (borbon-galvez et al., 2021). however, the great majority of studies pointed out a rise in transportation costs (27%): besides representing a limiting factor for certain types of exchange, as heat flows (lyu et al., 2023; pakere et al., 2021; sun et al., 2020), distance could affect, together with capital costs, decisions about symbiotic relationships economic convenience (chatterjee et al., 2021), hindering opportunities for is (sellitto et al., 2021) or its full optimization (lyu et al., 2023; tan yue dian et al., 2021). in conclusion, revenue reduction (yellow section of the circular graph) was observed in just one case (cervo et al., 2019) as an economic loss for traditional suppliers and other stakeholders; nonetheless, this dimension should be deepened as an indirect consequence of symbiosis practices. these findings confirmed the complexity of interactions, supporting the objective of building a flexible and integrated framework for is economic evaluation, which takes into consideration, as mentioned above, the industrial sector and its peculiarities. these elements proved to have an impact on the overall cost-benefit profile of is; in fact, according to different contexts, certain items could be recorded alternatively a cost or a benefit, as the circular graph in figure 3.4 displays for capital, transportation, recycling, manufacturing and other operating costs, and certain revenues could not be realized, as for the case european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/10926 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 17 of free waste exchanges. in summary, cost-benefit evaluation must not be seen as static but rather as an evolving process influenced by externalities, exchange dynamics, and specificities of the industrial sector. 4. discussion results examined in section 3.2 led to the construction of a framework for is economic evaluation, depicted in figure 5, which implies context analysis (industrial sector and corresponding technological state, flows of resources possibly exchanged, type of interaction at the basis of symbiosis relationship), determination of proper quantification methodologies and consideration of spatial and temporal aspects, with the definition of a proper time horizon (kerdlap et al., 2022). economic evaluation is carried out regarding several cost and benefit items, pointed out by scientific literature, together with specific kpis for a summative feasibility assessment and project overall vision. figure 5. is economic evaluation framework source: authors own elaboration european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/10926 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 18 exchanges could involve different resources, material or immaterial: ahmad fadzil et al. (2002) proved how sharing carbon permits allowed for an efficient aggregate allocation, with cooperative solutions providing the greatest benefits (galvan-cara et al., 2022; li et al., 2021). optimal configurations imply an unequal realization of benefits and costs for each economic agent, so economic analysis should take into account the different roles, as receiver or donor, played by each is participant. looking at calculation methodologies, financial approaches, better if implemented through the use of local accurate market values (liao et al., 2024), should be complemented with life-cycle assessment, considering also external costs, such as environmental ones, that turned up to be paramount and worth of quantification, talking about is cost reductions (ansanelli et al., 2023; haq et al., 2020; pakere et al., 2021) there are other kinds of aspects that need to be considered: among them, resource availability and supply security, relevant to is location (wijeyekoon et al., 2021), in particular when it comes to small flows of production (cortez et al., 2022), and geographical proximity, which affects is joining decision through transportation, infrastructure and investment costs (ali et al., 2019; cervo et al., 2019; chatterjee et al., 2021; galvan-cara et al., 2022; goh et al., 2022; tan yue dian et al., 2021) and the possibility to exploit particular flows, as heat and steam (pakere et al., 2021). regarding logistic and transportation costs, some scholars argued that they could not impact positive is overall benefit, while borbon-galvez et al. (2021) demonstrated that costs could even be lowered through sustainable means of transport and optimal shipping management. technological knowledge regarding waste treatment is also to be considered, as a barrier to is joining (he et al., 2020): even if major benefits come from the leading ones (farouk & chew, 2021; zhang et al., 2022b), some environmental-friendly techniques still seemed to be economically inaccessible, making the case for conflict between economic and environmental objectives (cao et al., 2020; chin et al., 2021; yeşı̇lkaya et al., 2020). capital costs for advanced infrastructure and systems could both affect is project profit in negative sense (misrol et al., 2021), and be lowered by peculiar features of is, such as proximity and sharing systems otherwise too expensive for a single participant (bütün et al., 2019; colpo et al., 2022a; goh et al., 2022). scientific literature mentioned other is characteristics preventing disruption risks but having an effect on economic outcomes: nestedness and flexibility, which could grow transaction and capital costs (boix et al., 2023; chatterjee et al., 2021; fraccascia et al., 2020). transaction costs resulted to be influenced also by trust and interaction approaches (prieto-sandoval et al., 2022; yazan & fraccascia, 2020). this study also considered articles in the form of is landscape analysis or industrial interviews (cortez et al., 2022; domenech et al., 2019; prieto-sandoval et al., 2022; sellitto et al., 2021; wahrlich & simioni, 2019), enlightening barriers to is implementation: proximity and procurement security, logistic costs, little knowledge and poor technological research investments, social reluctance, lack of adequate infrastructure and institutional support, also in the form of financial incentives, that proved to be essential, in certain cases, to face high capital costs (chin et al., 2021; haq et al., 2020). european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/10926 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 19 5. conclusion in a context of growing concern about industrial systems’ unsustainability, it is paramount to assess the economic advantages of the transition towards circular models of production, as well as to incentivize more efficient solutions that could match sustainability objectives from an economic, environmental, and social point of view (bocken et al., 2014). this study presented results of a systematic literature review for the last five years of research into is economic feasibility. bibliometric analysis allowed to notice an increasing interest in the topic, besides thematic connections’ structure. investigations brought out quantification methodologies, analysis of economic sectors involved and cost and benefit items, upon which an is economic evaluation framework was built and commented in discussion section. to sum up, some critical considerations about typologies of articles analyzed, in order to shape limitations and possible improvements. main sources of costs and revenues, outlined in the framework, were deemed as the most considered in economic feasibility evaluation studies; by contrast, few studies were found on comparison between is – non-is scenarios (ansanelli et al., 2023; cervo et al., 2019; galvan-cara et al., 2022; kerdlap et al., 2022; li et al., 2021; yu et al., 2023; zhang et al., 2022b), most of all useful for a full comprehension of symbiosis contribute to economic benefit. studies focused on optimization of productive models stressed out the presence of economic–environmental objectives trade-off (cao et al., 2020; chin et al., 2021; fraccascia et al., 2020; yeşı̇lkaya et al., 2020), that could be mitigated by an integrated costs analysis, including environmental and social externalities, for a more comprehensive overview of is economic impact. it is reiterated the need to adapt the framework to the specific industrial case and its peculiarities, from a technological, economical, sociocultural and normative point of view, though it could represent a good starting point for firms interested in economic consequences of is cooperation. 5.1 main contributions and practical implications given the lack of consideration and proper quantification of economic aspects of is (domenech et al., 2019; dong et al., 2022; wadström et al., 2021), this study contributed to filling the knowledge gap by systematizing recent literature on the topic of areas of is economic outcomes and outlining integrated alternative methodologies for a preliminary approach to the quantification of is impacts that result in costs and benefits beyond the mere market value sphere, providing a different perspective to evaluate financial flows of is projects. moreover, a dedicated support tool for is economic viability was built, with the innovative ability to conciliate different features, from context analysis to calculation methodologies with spatial and temporal considerations, enhancing the implementation of is activities by identification of cost and benefit items that could generate positive outcomes for companies involved. though based on a solid and scientific protocol for literature analysis, this research constitutes a first and general step in the research field, limited by the lack of attention to environmental and social externalities’ consequences and other kinds of implementation barriers that could generate an impact on is joining decision. 5.2 research limitations and future research agenda despite being accurately based on a well-structured search process, some methodological limits still exist. first, adopting scopus and web of science databases for the last five years of research may restrict the potential number of articles in the european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/10926 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 20 sample. to prevent excluding relevant scientific contributions, other search databases should be used, as well as expanding the temporal range. second, quality appraisal turns out to be inevitably afflicted by elements of subjectivity in judgment, which could be potentially lowered by more rigorous methods. last, the use of selected keywords might restrict the scope of research conducted; a new analysis should be performed with another search string. the economic evaluation framework is based on economic costs and benefits affecting firms directly and independently from the different roles played by participants. future research agenda includes a wider focus on supra-enterprise network consequences, also quantifying environmental and social impacts in economic terms to find an is cost-benefit distribution model encouraging an equal realization of benefits and costs for each economic agent and a continuous participation in an innovative business model for ecological industrial transition. 4. conflict of interest the authors declare that they have no known competing financial interests or personal relationships that could have appeared to influence the work reported in this paper. 5. references ahmad fadzil, f., andiappan, v., ng, d. k. s., ng, l. y., & hamid, a. (2022). sharing carbon permits in industrial symbiosis: a game theory-based optimization model. journal of cleaner production, 357, 131820. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2022.131820. albino, v., fraccascia, l., & giannoccaro, i. (2016). exploring the role of contracts to support the emergence of selforganized industrial symbiosis networks: an agent-based simulation study. journal of cleaner production, 112, 4353– 4366. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2015.06.070. ali, a. k., kio, p. n., alvarado, j., & wang, y. (2020). symbiotic circularity in buildings: an alternative path for valorizing sheet metal waste stream as metal building facades. waste and biomass valorization, 11(12), 7127–7145. https://doi.org/10.1007/s12649-020-01060-y. ali, a. k., wang, y., & alvarado, j. l. (2019). facilitating industrial symbiosis to achieve circular economy using valueadded by design: a case study in transforming the automobile industry sheet metal waste-flow into voronoi facade systems. journal of cleaner production, 234, 1033–1044. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2019.06.202. al-quradaghi, s., zheng, q. p., betancourt-torcat, a., & elkamel, a. (2022). optimization model for sustainable end-oflife vehicle processing and recycling. sustainability, 14(6), 3551. https://doi.org/10.3390/su14063551. ansanelli, g., fiorentino, g., chifari, r., meisterl, k., leccisi, e., & zucaro, a. (2023). sustainability assessment of coffee silverskin waste management in the metropolitan city of naples (italy): a life cycle perspective. sustainability, 15(23), 16281. https://doi.org/10.3390/su152316281. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2022.131820 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2015.06.070 https://doi.org/10.1007/s12649-020-01060-y https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2019.06.202 https://doi.org/10.3390/su14063551 https://doi.org/10.3390/su152316281 european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/10926 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 21 asghari, m., afshari, h., jaber, m. y., & searcy, c. (2023). dynamic deployment of energy symbiosis networks integrated with organic rankine cycle systems. renewable and sustainable energy reviews, 183, 113513. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.rser.2023.113513. baldassarre, b., schepers, m., bocken, n., cuppen, e., korevaar, g., & calabretta, g. (2019). industrial symbiosis: towards a design process for eco-industrial clusters by integrating circular economy and industrial ecology perspectives. journal of cleaner production, 216, 446–460. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2019.01.091. bocken, n. m. p., short, s. w., rana, p., & evans, s. (2014). a literature and practice review to develop sustainable business model archetypes. journal of cleaner production, 65, 42–56. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2013.11.039. boix, m., négny, s., montastruc, l., & mousqué, f. (2023). flexible networks to promote the development of industrial symbioses: a new optimization procedure. computers & chemical engineering, 169, 108082. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.compchemeng.2022.108082. boons, f., chertow, m., park, j., spekkink, w., & shi, h. (2017). industrial symbiosis dynamics and the problem of equivalence: proposal for a comparative framework. journal of industrial ecology, 21(4), 938–952. https://doi.org/10.1111/jiec.12468. borbon-galvez, y., curi, s., dallari, f., & ghiringhelli, g. (2021). international industrial symbiosis: cross-border management of aggregates and construction and demolition waste between italy and switzerland. sustainable production and consumption, 25, 312–324. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.spc.2020.09.004. bütün, h., kantor, i., & maréchal, f. (2019). incorporating location aspects in process integration methodology. energies, 12(17), 3338. https://doi.org/10.3390/en12173338. cao, x., wen, z., xu, j., de clercq, d., wang, y., & tao, y. (2020). many-objective optimization of technology implementation in the industrial symbiosis system based on a modified nsga-iii. journal of cleaner production, 245, 118810. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2019.118810. cervo, h., ogé, s., maqbool, a. s., mendez alva, f., lessard, l., bredimas, a., ferrasse, j.-h., & van eetvelde, g. (2019). a case study of industrial symbiosis in the humber region using the epos methodology. sustainability, 11(24), 6940. https://doi.org/10.3390/su11246940. chatterjee, a., brehm, c., & layton, a. (2021). evaluating benefits of ecologically-inspired nested architectures for industrial symbiosis. resources, conservation and recycling, 167, 105423. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.resconrec.2021.105423. chen, x., dong, m., zhang, l., luan, x., cui, x., & cui, z. (2022). comprehensive evaluation of environmental and economic benefits of industrial symbiosis in industrial parks. journal of cleaner production, 354, 131635. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2022.131635. chertow, m. r. (2000). industrial symbiosis: literature and taxonomy. annual review of energy and the environment, 25(1), 313–337. https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev.energy.25.1.313-.71 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.rser.2023.113513 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2019.01.091 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2013.11.039 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.compchemeng.2022.108082 https://doi.org/10.1111/jiec.12468 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.spc.2020.09.004 https://doi.org/10.3390/en12173338 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2019.118810 https://doi.org/10.3390/su11246940 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.resconrec.2021.105423 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2022.131635 https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev.energy.25.1.313 european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/10926 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 22 chertow, m. r. (2007). “uncovering” industrial symbiosis. journal of industrial ecology, 11(1), 11–30. https://doi.org/10.1162/jiec.2007.1110. chin, h. h., varbanov, p. s., klemeš, j. j., & bandyopadhyay, s. (2021). subsidised water symbiosis of eco-industrial parks: a multi-stage game theory approach. computers & chemical engineering, 155, 107539. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.compchemeng.2021.107539. colpo, i., rabenschlag, d. r., de lima, m. s., martins, m. e. s., & sellitto, m. a. (2022a). economic and financial feasibility of a biorefinery for conversion of brewers’ spent grain into a special flour. journal of open innovation: technology, market, and complexity, 8(2), 79. https://doi.org/10.3390/joitmc8020079. colpo, i., martins, m. e. s., buzuku, s., & sellitto, m. a. (2022b). industrial symbiosis in brazil: a systematic literature review. waste management & research: the journal for a sustainable circular economy, 40(10), 1462–1479. https://doi.org/10.1177/0734242x221084065. cortez, s. c., cherri, a. c., jugend, d., jesus, g. m. k., & bezerra, b. s. (2022). how can biodigesters help drive the circular economy? an analysis based on the swot matrix and case studies. sustainability, 14(13), 7972. https://doi.org/10.3390/su14137972. costanza, f. (2020). the potential of circular businesses in the post-covid era: a system dynamics view. european journal of social impact and circular economy, 1-27 pages. https://doi.org/10.13135/2704-9906/5098. de souza, j. f. t., & pacca, s. a. (2023). a low carbon future for brazilian steel and cement: a joint assessment under the circular economy perspective. resources, conservation & recycling advances, 17, 200141. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.rcradv.2023.200141. diaz, f., vignati, j. a., marchi, b., paoli, r., zanoni, s., & romagnoli, f. (2021). effects of energy efficiency measures in the beef cold chain: a life cycle-based study. environmental and climate technologies, 25(1), 343–355. https://doi.org/10.2478/rtuect-2021-0025. domenech, t., bleischwitz, r., doranova, a., panayotopoulos, d., & roman, l. (2019). mapping industrial symbiosis development in europe_ typologies of networks, characteristics, performance and contribution to the circular economy. resources, conservation and recycling, 141, 76–98. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.resconrec.2018.09.016. dong, l., taka, g. n., lee, d., park, y., & park, h. s. (2022). tracking industrial symbiosis performance with ecological network approach integrating economic and environmental benefits analysis. resources, conservation and recycling, 185, 106454. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.resconrec.2022.106454. fahmy, m., hall, p. w., suckling, i. d., bennett, p., & wijeyekoon, s. (2021). identifying and evaluating symbiotic opportunities for wood processing through techno-economic superstructure optimisation – a methodology and case study for the kawerau industrial cluster in new zealand. journal of cleaner production, 328, 129494. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2021.129494. https://doi.org/10.1162/jiec.2007.1110 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.compchemeng.2021.107539 https://doi.org/10.3390/joitmc8020079 https://doi.org/10.1177/0734242x221084065 https://doi.org/10.3390/su14137972 https://doi.org/10.13135/2704-9906/5098 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.rcradv.2023.200141 https://doi.org/10.2478/rtuect-2021-0025 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.resconrec.2018.09.016 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.resconrec.2022.106454 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2021.129494 european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/10926 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 23 falsafi, m., terkaj, w., guzzon, m., malfa, e., fornasiero, r., & tolio, t. (2023). assessment of valorisation opportunities for secondary metallurgy slag through multi-criteria decision making. journal of cleaner production, 402, 136838. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2023.136838.faro faria, e., caldeira-pires, a., & barreto, c. (2021). social, economic, and institutional configurations of the industrial symbiosis process: a comparative analysis of the literature and a proposed theoretical and analytical framework. sustainability, 13(13), 7123. https://doi.org/10.3390/su13137123. farouk, a. a., & chew, i. m. l. (2021). development of a simultaneous mass-water carbon-hydrogen-oxygen symbiosis network. sustainable production and consumption, 28, 419–435. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.spc.2021.06.004. fink, a. (2019). conducting research literature reviews: from the internet to paper. sage publications. fraccascia, l., giannoccaro, i., & albino, v. (2019). business models for industrial symbiosis: a taxonomy focused on the form of governance. resources, conservation and recycling, 146, 114–126. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.resconrec.2019.03.016. fraccascia, l., yazan, d. m., albino, v., & zijm, h. (2020). the role of redundancy in industrial symbiotic business development: a theoretical framework explored by agent-based simulation. international journal of production economics, 221, 107471. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijpe.2019.08.006. galvan-cara, a.-l., graells, m., & espuña, a. (2022). application of industrial symbiosis principles to the management of utility networks. applied energy, 305, 117734. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.apenergy.2021.117734. goh, q. h., farouk, a. a., & chew, i. l. (2022). optimizing the bioplastic chemical building block with wastewater sludge as the feedstock using carbon-hydrogen-oxygen framework. resources, conservation and recycling, 176, 105920. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.resconrec.2021.105920. haq, h., välisuo, p., kumpulainen, l., tuomi, v., & niemi, s. (2020). a preliminary assessment of industrial symbiosis in sodankylä. current research in environmental sustainability, 2, 100018. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.crsust.2020.100018. he, m., jin, y., zeng, h., & cao, j. (2020). pricing decisions about waste recycling from the perspective of industrial symbiosis in an industrial park: a game model and its application. journal of cleaner production, 251, 119417. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2019.119417. hedlund, a., björkqvist, o., nilsson, a., & engstrand, p. (2022). energy optimization in a paper mill enabled by a threesite energy cooperation. energies, 15(8), 2715. https://doi.org/10.3390/en15082715. henriques, j., azevedo, j., dias, r., estrela, m., & ascenço, c. (2020). industrial symbiosis incentives: mitigating risks for facilitated implementation. zenodo. hu, w., tian, j., li, x., & chen, l. (2020). wastewater treatment system optimization with an industrial symbiosis model: a case study of a chinese eco‐industrial park. journal of industrial ecology, 24(6), 1338–1351. https://doi.org/10.1111/jiec.13020. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2023.136838.faro https://doi.org/10.3390/su13137123 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.spc.2021.06.004 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.resconrec.2019.03.016 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijpe.2019.08.006 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.apenergy.2021.117734 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.resconrec.2021.105920 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.crsust.2020.100018 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2019.119417 https://doi.org/10.3390/en15082715 https://doi.org/10.1111/jiec.13020 european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/10926 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 24 kerdlap, p., low, j. s. c., tan, d. z. l., yeo, z., & ramakrishna, s. (2022). um3-lce3-isn: a methodology for multilevel life cycle environmental and economic evaluation of industrial symbiosis networks. the international journal of life cycle assessment. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11367-022-02024-1. kosmol, l., & otto, l. (2020). implementation barriers of industrial symbiosis: a systematic review. li, l., ge, y., & xiao, m. (2021). towards biofuel generation iii+: a sustainable industrial symbiosis design of coproducing algal and cellulosic biofuels. journal of cleaner production, 306, 127144. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2021.127144. liao, k., feng, z., wu, j., liang, h., wang, y., zeng, w., wang, y., tian, j., liu, r., & chen, l. (2024). cement kiln geared up to dispose industrial hazardous wastes of megacity under industrial symbiosis. resources, conservation and recycling, 202, 107358. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.resconrec.2023.107358. lombardi, d. r., & laybourn, p. (2012). redefining industrial symbiosis: crossing academic–practitioner boundaries. journal of industrial ecology, 16(1), 28–37. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1530-9290.2011.00444.x. lybæk, r., christensen, t. b., & thomsen, t. p. (2021). enhancing policies for deployment of industrial symbiosis – what are the obstacles, drivers and future way forward? journal of cleaner production, 280, 124351. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2020.124351. lyu, y., feng, z. a., ji, t., tian, j., & chen, l. (2023). networking chemicals flows: efficiency–value–environment functionalized symbiosis algorithms and application. environmental science & technology, 57(46), 18225–18235. https://doi.org/10.1021/acs.est.3c04291. macarthur, e. (2013). towards the circular economy. mallawaarachchi, h., sandanayake, y., karunasena, g., & liu, c. (2020). unveiling the conceptual development of industrial symbiosis: bibliometric analysis. journal of cleaner production, 258, 120618. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2020.120618. misrol, m. a., wan alwi, s. r., lim, j. s., & manan, z. a. (2021). an optimal resource recovery of biogas, water regeneration, and reuse network integrating domestic and industrial sources. journal of cleaner production, 286, 125372. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2020.125372. misrol, m. a., wan alwi, s. r., lim, j. s., & manan, z. a. (2022). optimising renewable energy at the eco-industrial park: a mathematical modelling approach. energy, 261, 125345. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.energy.2022.125345. neves, a., godina, r., azevedo, s. g., & matias, j. c. o. (2020). a comprehensive review of industrial symbiosis. journal of cleaner production, 247, 119113. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2019.119113. okoli, c. (2015). a guide to conducting a standalone systematic literature review. communications of the association for information systems, 37. https://doi.org/10.17705/1cais.03743. pakere, i., gravelsins, a., lauka, d., & blumberga, d. (2021). will there be the waste heat and boiler house competition in latvia? assessment of industrial waste heat. smart energy, 3, 100023. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.segy.2021.100023. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11367-022-02024-1 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2021.127144 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.resconrec.2023.107358 https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1530-9290.2011.00444.x https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2020.124351 https://doi.org/10.1021/acs.est.3c04291 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2020.120618 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2020.125372 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.energy.2022.125345 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2019.119113 https://doi.org/10.17705/1cais.03743 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.segy.2021.100023 european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/10926 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 25 piontek, f. m., herrmann, c., & saraev, a. (2021). steps from zero carbon supply chains and demand of circular economy to circular business cases. european journal of social impact and circular economy, 1-9 paginazione. https://doi.org/10.13135/2704-9906/5712. pranckutė, r. (2021). web of science (wos) and scopus: the titans of bibliographic information in today’s academic world. publications, 9(1), 12. https://doi.org/10.3390/publications9010012. prieto-sandoval, v., mejia-villa, a., jaca, c., & ormazabal, m. (2022). the case of an agricultural crop business association in navarra as circular economy intermediary. circular economy and sustainability, 2(2), 713–729. https://doi.org/10.1007/s43615-021-00116-y. raciti, a., dugo, g., piccione, p., zappalà, s., & martelli, c. (2019). a new sustainable product in the green building sector: the use of sicilian orange peel waste as high performance insulation. procedia of environmental science, engeneering and management, 6(2), 229–235. raimondo, m., di rauso simeone, g., coppola, g. p., zaccardelli, m., caracciolo, f., & rao, m. a. (2023). economic benefits and soil improvement: impacts of vermicompost use in spinach production through industrial symbiosis. journal of agriculture and food research, 14, 100845. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jafr.2023.100845. ranjbari, m., saidani, m., shams esfandabadi, z., peng, w., lam, s. s., aghbashlo, m., quatraro, f., & tabatabaei, m. (2021). two decades of research on waste management in the circular economy: insights from bibliometric, text mining, and content analyses. journal of cleaner production, 314, 128009. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2021.128009. re, b., bottini, l., ricci, c., bottini, g., & strauss, d. (2023). the transition from a “city of waste” to a “circular city”: virtuous practices in the city of pavia. european journal of social impact and circular economy, 1-16 pages. https://doi.org/10.13135/2704-9906/7691. ruiz, m., & diaz, f. (2022). life cycle sustainability evaluation of potential bioenergy development for landfills in colombia. environmental and climate technologies, 26(1), 454–469. https://doi.org/10.2478/rtuect-2022-0035. ruiz-puente, c., & jato-espino, d. (2020). systemic analysis of the contributions of co-located industrial symbiosis to achieve sustainable development in an industrial park in northern spain. sustainability, 12(14), 5802. https://doi.org/10.3390/su12145802. sadraei, r., biancone, p., lanzalonga, f., jafari‐sadeghi, v., & chmet, f. (2023). how to increase sustainable production in the food sector? mapping industrial and business strategies and providing future research agenda. business strategy and the environment, 32(4), 2209–2228. https://doi.org/10.1002/bse.3244. saeli, m., capela, m. n., piccirillo, c., tobaldi, d. m., seabra, m. p., scalera, f., striani, r., corcione, c. e., & campisi, t. (2023). development of energy-saving innovative hydraulic mortars reusing spent coffee ground for applications in construction. journal of cleaner production, 399, 136664. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2023.136664. sellitto, m. a., murakami, f. k., butturi, m. a., marinelli, s., kadel jr., n., & rimini, b. (2021). barriers, drivers, and relationships in industrial symbiosis of a network of brazilian manufacturing companies. sustainable production and consumption, 26, 443–454. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.spc.2020.09.016. https://doi.org/10.13135/2704-9906/5712 https://doi.org/10.3390/publications9010012 https://doi.org/10.1007/s43615-021-00116-y https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jafr.2023.100845 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2021.128009 https://doi.org/10.13135/2704-9906/7691 https://doi.org/10.2478/rtuect-2022-0035 https://doi.org/10.3390/su12145802 https://doi.org/10.1002/bse.3244 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2023.136664 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.spc.2020.09.016 european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/10926 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 26 sheppard, p., garcia-garcia, g., angelis-dimakis, a., campbell, g. m., & rahimifard, s. (2019). synergies in the colocation of food manufacturing and biorefining. food and bioproducts processing, 117, 340–359. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.fbp.2019.08.001. sun, l., fujii, m., li, z., dong, h., geng, y., liu, z., fujita, t., yu, x., & zhang, y. (2020). energy-saving and carbon emission reduction effect of urban-industrial symbiosis implementation with feasibility analysis in the city. technological forecasting and social change, 151, 119853. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.techfore.2019.119853. tan yue dian, lim jeng shiun, & wan alwi sharifah rafidah. (2021). cooperative game-based business model optimisation for a multi-owner integrated palm oil-based complex. chemical engineering transactions, 88, 409– 414. https://doi.org/10.3303/cet2188068. taqi, h. m. m., meem, e. j., bhattacharjee, p., salman, s., ali, s. m., & sankaranarayanan, b. (2022). what are the challenges that make the journey towards industrial symbiosis complicated? journal of cleaner production, 370, 133384. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2022.133384. teh, k. c., lim, s. c., andiappan, v., & chew, i. m. l. (2021). evaluation of palm oil eco-industrial park configurations: vikor with stability analysis. process integration and optimization for sustainability, 5(2), 303–316. https://doi.org/10.1007/s41660-021-00168-5. wadström, c., johansson, m., & wallén, m. (2021). a framework for studying outcomes in industrial symbiosis. renewable and sustainable energy reviews, 151, 111526. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.rser.2021.111526. wahrlich, j., & simioni, f. j. (2019). industrial symbiosis in the forestry sector: a case study in southern brazil. journal of industrial ecology, 23(6), 1470–1482. https://doi.org/10.1111/jiec.12927. wang, s., lu, c., gao, y., wang, k., & zhang, r. (2019). life cycle assessment of reduction of environmental impacts via industrial symbiosis in an energy-intensive industrial park in china. journal of cleaner production, 241, 118358. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2019.118358. wijeyekoon, s., suckling, i., fahmy, m., hall, p., & bennett, p. (2021). techno‐economic analysis of tannin and briquette co‐production from bark waste: a case study quantifying symbiosis benefits in biorefinery. biofuels, bioproducts and biorefining, 15(5), 1332–1344. https://doi.org/10.1002/bbb.2246. xue, x., wang, s., chun, t., xin, h., xue, r., tian, x., & zhang, r. (2023). an integrated framework for industrial symbiosis performance evaluation in an energy-intensive industrial park in china. environmental science and pollution research, 30(14), 42056–42074. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11356-023-25232-0. yazan, d. m., & fraccascia, l. (2020). sustainable operations of industrial symbiosis: an enterprise input-output model integrated by agent-based simulation. international journal of production research, 58(2), 392–414. https://doi.org/10.1080/00207543.2019.1590660. yeşı̇lkaya, m., daş, g. s., & türker, a. k. (2020). a multi-objective multi-period mathematical model for an industrial symbiosis network based on the forest products industry. computers & industrial engineering, 150, 106883. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cie.2020.106883. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.fbp.2019.08.001 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.techfore.2019.119853 https://doi.org/10.3303/cet2188068 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2022.133384 https://doi.org/10.1007/s41660-021-00168-5 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.rser.2021.111526 https://doi.org/10.1111/jiec.12927 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2019.118358 https://doi.org/10.1002/bbb.2246 https://doi.org/10.1007/s11356-023-25232-0 https://doi.org/10.1080/00207543.2019.1590660 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cie.2020.106883 european journal of social impact and circular economy issn: 2704-9906 doi: 10.13135/2704-9906/10926 published by university of turin http://www.ojs.unito.it/index.php/ejsice/index ejsice content is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license 27 yu, h., da, l., li, y., chen, y., geng, q., jia, z., zhang, y., li, j., & gao, c. (2023). industrial symbiosis promoting material exchanges in ulan buh demonstration eco-industrial park: a multi-objective milp model. journal of cleaner production, 414, 137578. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2023.137578. zabaniotou, a., & vaskalis, i. (2023). economic assessment of polypropylene waste (pp) pyrolysis in circular economy and industrial symbiosis. energies, 16(2), 593. https://doi.org/10.3390/en16020593. zhang, y., zheng, h., chen, b., su, m., & liu, g. (2015). a review of industrial symbiosis research: theory and methodology. frontiers of earth science, 9(1), 91–104. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11707-014-0445-8. zhang, q., xiang, t., zhang, w., wang, h., an, j., li, x., & xue, b. (2022a). co‐benefits analysis of industrial symbiosis in china’s key industries: case of steel, cement, and power industries. journal of industrial ecology, 26(5), 1714–1727. https://doi.org/10.1111/jiec.13320. zhang, x., wang, y., wei, s., dong, j., zhao, j., & qian, g. (2022b). assessing the chlorine metabolism and its resource efficiency in chlor-alkali industrial symbiosis—a case of shanghai chemical industry park. journal of cleaner production, 380, 134934. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2022.134934. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2023.137578 https://doi.org/10.3390/en16020593 https://doi.org/10.1007/s11707-014-0445-8 https://doi.org/10.1111/jiec.13320 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2022.134934 