id sid tid token lemma pos eblip-30118 1 1 academic academic ADJ eblip-30118 1 2 librarians librarian NOUN eblip-30118 1 3 develop develop VERB eblip-30118 1 4 their their PRON eblip-30118 1 5 teaching teaching NOUN eblip-30118 1 6 identities identity NOUN eblip-30118 1 7 differently differently ADV eblip-30118 1 8 depending depend VERB eblip-30118 1 9 on on ADP eblip-30118 1 10 their their PRON eblip-30118 1 11 years year NOUN eblip-30118 1 12 of of ADP eblip-30118 1 13 instructional instructional ADJ eblip-30118 1 14 experience experience NOUN eblip-30118 1 15 evidence evidence NOUN eblip-30118 1 16 summary summary NOUN eblip-30118 1 17     SPACE eblip-30118 1 18 academic academic ADJ eblip-30118 1 19 librarians librarian NOUN eblip-30118 1 20 develop develop VERB eblip-30118 1 21 their their PRON eblip-30118 1 22 teaching teaching NOUN eblip-30118 1 23 identities identity NOUN eblip-30118 1 24 differently differently ADV eblip-30118 1 25 depending depend VERB eblip-30118 1 26 on on ADP eblip-30118 1 27 their their PRON eblip-30118 1 28 years year NOUN eblip-30118 1 29 of of ADP eblip-30118 1 30 instructional instructional ADJ eblip-30118 1 31 experience experience NOUN eblip-30118 1 32     SPACE eblip-30118 1 33 a a DET eblip-30118 1 34 review review NOUN eblip-30118 1 35 of of ADP eblip-30118 1 36 : : PUNCT eblip-30118 1 37 nichols nichols PROPN eblip-30118 1 38 hess hess PROPN eblip-30118 1 39 , , PUNCT eblip-30118 1 40 a. a. NOUN eblip-30118 1 41 ( ( PUNCT eblip-30118 1 42 2020 2020 NUM eblip-30118 1 43 ) ) PUNCT eblip-30118 1 44 . . PUNCT eblip-30118 2 1 instructional instructional ADJ eblip-30118 2 2 experience experience NOUN eblip-30118 2 3 and and CCONJ eblip-30118 2 4 teaching teaching NOUN eblip-30118 2 5 identities identity NOUN eblip-30118 2 6 : : PUNCT eblip-30118 2 7 how how SCONJ eblip-30118 2 8 academic academic ADJ eblip-30118 2 9 librarians librarian NOUN eblip-30118 2 10 ' ' PART eblip-30118 2 11 years year NOUN eblip-30118 2 12 of of ADP eblip-30118 2 13 experience experience NOUN eblip-30118 2 14 in in ADP eblip-30118 2 15 instruction instruction NOUN eblip-30118 2 16 impact impact NOUN eblip-30118 2 17 their their PRON eblip-30118 2 18 perceptions perception NOUN eblip-30118 2 19 of of ADP eblip-30118 2 20 themselves themselves PRON eblip-30118 2 21 as as ADP eblip-30118 2 22 educators educator NOUN eblip-30118 2 23 . . PUNCT eblip-30118 3 1 communications communication NOUN eblip-30118 3 2 in in ADP eblip-30118 3 3 information information NOUN eblip-30118 3 4 literacy literacy NOUN eblip-30118 3 5 , , PUNCT eblip-30118 3 6 14(2 14(2 NUM eblip-30118 3 7 ) ) PUNCT eblip-30118 3 8 , , PUNCT eblip-30118 3 9 153–180 153–180 NUM eblip-30118 3 10 . . PUNCT eblip-30118 4 1 https://doi.org/10.15760/comminfolit.2020.14.2.1 https://doi.org/10.15760/comminfolit.2020.14.2.1 X eblip-30118 4 2 reviewed review VERB eblip-30118 4 3 by by ADP eblip-30118 4 4 : : PUNCT eblip-30118 4 5 michelle michelle PROPN eblip-30118 4 6 dubroy dubroy PROPN eblip-30118 4 7 discipline discipline PROPN eblip-30118 4 8 librarian librarian NOUN eblip-30118 4 9 ( ( PUNCT eblip-30118 4 10 researcher researcher NOUN eblip-30118 4 11 services services PROPN eblip-30118 4 12 ) ) PUNCT eblip-30118 4 13 griffith griffith PROPN eblip-30118 4 14 university university PROPN eblip-30118 4 15 southport southport PROPN eblip-30118 4 16 , , PUNCT eblip-30118 4 17 queensland queensland PROPN eblip-30118 4 18 , , PUNCT eblip-30118 4 19 australia australia PROPN eblip-30118 4 20 email email NOUN eblip-30118 4 21 : : PUNCT eblip-30118 4 22 m.dubroy@griffith.edu.au m.dubroy@griffith.edu.au PROPN eblip-30118 4 23     SPACE eblip-30118 4 24 received receive VERB eblip-30118 4 25 : : PUNCT eblip-30118 4 26 7 7 NUM eblip-30118 4 27 mar mar PROPN eblip-30118 4 28 . . PROPN eblip-30118 4 29 2022 2022 NUM eblip-30118 4 30                                                                                                                                         SPACE eblip-30118 4 31 accepted accept VERB eblip-30118 4 32 : : PUNCT eblip-30118 4 33     SPACE eblip-30118 4 34 13 13 NUM eblip-30118 4 35 apr apr NOUN eblip-30118 4 36 . . PUNCT eblip-30118 5 1 2022 2022 NUM eblip-30118 5 2             SPACE eblip-30118 5 3 2022 2022 NUM eblip-30118 5 4 dubroy dubroy NOUN eblip-30118 5 5 . . PUNCT eblip-30118 6 1 this this PRON eblip-30118 6 2 is be AUX eblip-30118 6 3 an an DET eblip-30118 6 4 open open ADJ eblip-30118 6 5 access access NOUN eblip-30118 6 6 article article NOUN eblip-30118 6 7 distributed distribute VERB eblip-30118 6 8 under under ADP eblip-30118 6 9 the the DET eblip-30118 6 10 terms term NOUN eblip-30118 6 11 of of ADP eblip-30118 6 12 the the DET eblip-30118 6 13 creative creative ADJ eblip-30118 6 14 commons‐attribution‐noncommercial‐share commons‐attribution‐noncommercial‐share NOUN eblip-30118 6 15 alike alike ADJ eblip-30118 6 16 license license VERB eblip-30118 6 17 4.0 4.0 NUM eblip-30118 6 18 international international ADJ eblip-30118 6 19 ( ( PUNCT eblip-30118 6 20 http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/4.0/ http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/4.0/ PROPN eblip-30118 6 21 ) ) PUNCT eblip-30118 6 22 , , PUNCT eblip-30118 6 23 which which PRON eblip-30118 6 24 permits permit VERB eblip-30118 6 25 unrestricted unrestricted ADJ eblip-30118 6 26 use use NOUN eblip-30118 6 27 , , PUNCT eblip-30118 6 28 distribution distribution NOUN eblip-30118 6 29 , , PUNCT eblip-30118 6 30 and and CCONJ eblip-30118 6 31 reproduction reproduction NOUN eblip-30118 6 32 in in ADP eblip-30118 6 33 any any DET eblip-30118 6 34 medium medium NOUN eblip-30118 6 35 , , PUNCT eblip-30118 6 36 provided provide VERB eblip-30118 6 37 the the DET eblip-30118 6 38 original original ADJ eblip-30118 6 39 work work NOUN eblip-30118 6 40 is be AUX eblip-30118 6 41 properly properly ADV eblip-30118 6 42 attributed attribute VERB eblip-30118 6 43 , , PUNCT eblip-30118 6 44 not not PART eblip-30118 6 45 used use VERB eblip-30118 6 46 for for ADP eblip-30118 6 47 commercial commercial ADJ eblip-30118 6 48 purposes purpose NOUN eblip-30118 6 49 , , PUNCT eblip-30118 6 50 and and CCONJ eblip-30118 6 51 , , PUNCT eblip-30118 6 52 if if SCONJ eblip-30118 6 53 transformed transform VERB eblip-30118 6 54 , , PUNCT eblip-30118 6 55 the the DET eblip-30118 6 56 resulting result VERB eblip-30118 6 57 work work NOUN eblip-30118 6 58 is be AUX eblip-30118 6 59 redistributed redistribute VERB eblip-30118 6 60 under under ADP eblip-30118 6 61 the the DET eblip-30118 6 62 same same ADJ eblip-30118 6 63 or or CCONJ eblip-30118 6 64 similar similar ADJ eblip-30118 6 65 license license NOUN eblip-30118 6 66 to to ADP eblip-30118 6 67 this this DET eblip-30118 6 68 one one NUM eblip-30118 6 69 . . PUNCT eblip-30118 6 70         SPACE eblip-30118 7 1 doi doi NOUN eblip-30118 7 2 : : PUNCT eblip-30118 7 3 10.18438 10.18438 NUM eblip-30118 7 4 / / SYM eblip-30118 7 5 eblip30118 eblip30118 VERB eblip-30118 7 6         SPACE eblip-30118 7 7 abstract abstract ADJ eblip-30118 7 8     SPACE eblip-30118 7 9 objective objective NOUN eblip-30118 7 10 – – PUNCT eblip-30118 7 11 to to PART eblip-30118 7 12 examine examine VERB eblip-30118 7 13 how how SCONJ eblip-30118 7 14 an an DET eblip-30118 7 15 academic academic ADJ eblip-30118 7 16 librarian librarian NOUN eblip-30118 7 17 ’s ’s PART eblip-30118 7 18 years year NOUN eblip-30118 7 19 of of ADP eblip-30118 7 20 instructional instructional ADJ eblip-30118 7 21 experience experience NOUN eblip-30118 7 22 impacts impact NOUN eblip-30118 7 23 how how SCONJ eblip-30118 7 24 they they PRON eblip-30118 7 25 think think VERB eblip-30118 7 26 of of ADP eblip-30118 7 27 themselves themselves PRON eblip-30118 7 28 as as ADP eblip-30118 7 29 instructors instructor NOUN eblip-30118 7 30 . . PUNCT eblip-30118 7 31     SPACE eblip-30118 8 1 design design NOUN eblip-30118 8 2 – – PUNCT eblip-30118 8 3 survey survey NOUN eblip-30118 8 4 questionnaire questionnaire NOUN eblip-30118 8 5 . . PUNCT eblip-30118 8 6     SPACE eblip-30118 9 1 setting set VERB eblip-30118 9 2 – – PUNCT eblip-30118 9 3 american american ADJ eblip-30118 9 4 academic academic ADJ eblip-30118 9 5 library library NOUN eblip-30118 9 6 profession profession NOUN eblip-30118 9 7 . . PUNCT eblip-30118 9 8     SPACE eblip-30118 10 1 subjects subject NOUN eblip-30118 10 2 – – PUNCT eblip-30118 10 3 353 353 NUM eblip-30118 10 4 participants participant NOUN eblip-30118 10 5 selected select VERB eblip-30118 10 6 from from ADP eblip-30118 10 7 501 501 NUM eblip-30118 10 8 respondents respondent NOUN eblip-30118 10 9 . . PUNCT eblip-30118 10 10     SPACE eblip-30118 11 1 methods method NOUN eblip-30118 11 2 – – PUNCT eblip-30118 11 3 a a DET eblip-30118 11 4 qualtrics qualtric NOUN eblip-30118 11 5 survey survey NOUN eblip-30118 11 6 was be AUX eblip-30118 11 7 sent send VERB eblip-30118 11 8 via via ADP eblip-30118 11 9 email email NOUN eblip-30118 11 10 to to ADP eblip-30118 11 11 members member NOUN eblip-30118 11 12 of of ADP eblip-30118 11 13 several several ADJ eblip-30118 11 14 american american PROPN eblip-30118 11 15 library library PROPN eblip-30118 11 16 association association PROPN eblip-30118 11 17 discussion discussion NOUN eblip-30118 11 18 lists list NOUN eblip-30118 11 19 . . PUNCT eblip-30118 12 1 the the DET eblip-30118 12 2 author author NOUN eblip-30118 12 3 selected select VERB eblip-30118 12 4 a a DET eblip-30118 12 5 subset subset NOUN eblip-30118 12 6 of of ADP eblip-30118 12 7 respondents respondent NOUN eblip-30118 12 8 for for ADP eblip-30118 12 9 further further ADJ eblip-30118 12 10 analysis analysis NOUN eblip-30118 12 11 based base VERB eblip-30118 12 12 on on ADP eblip-30118 12 13 how how SCONJ eblip-30118 12 14 they they PRON eblip-30118 12 15 answered answer VERB eblip-30118 12 16 key key ADJ eblip-30118 12 17 questions question NOUN eblip-30118 12 18 on on ADP eblip-30118 12 19 the the DET eblip-30118 12 20 survey survey NOUN eblip-30118 12 21 . . PUNCT eblip-30118 13 1 selected select VERB eblip-30118 13 2 participants participant NOUN eblip-30118 13 3 were be AUX eblip-30118 13 4 those those PRON eblip-30118 13 5 who who PRON eblip-30118 13 6 believed believe VERB eblip-30118 13 7 they they PRON eblip-30118 13 8 had have AUX eblip-30118 13 9 experienced experience VERB eblip-30118 13 10 perspective perspective NOUN eblip-30118 13 11 transformation transformation NOUN eblip-30118 13 12 around around ADP eblip-30118 13 13 their their PRON eblip-30118 13 14 teaching teaching NOUN eblip-30118 13 15 identities identity NOUN eblip-30118 13 16 . . PUNCT eblip-30118 14 1 the the DET eblip-30118 14 2 author author NOUN eblip-30118 14 3 used use VERB eblip-30118 14 4 principal principal ADJ eblip-30118 14 5 component component NOUN eblip-30118 14 6 analysis analysis NOUN eblip-30118 14 7 and and CCONJ eblip-30118 14 8 confirmatory confirmatory NOUN eblip-30118 14 9 factor factor NOUN eblip-30118 14 10 analysis analysis NOUN eblip-30118 14 11 to to PART eblip-30118 14 12 identify identify VERB eblip-30118 14 13 twelve twelve NUM eblip-30118 14 14 transformative transformative ADJ eblip-30118 14 15 constructs construct NOUN eblip-30118 14 16 across across ADP eblip-30118 14 17 three three NUM eblip-30118 14 18 sub sub NOUN eblip-30118 14 19 - - NOUN eblip-30118 14 20 themes theme NOUN eblip-30118 14 21 : : PUNCT eblip-30118 14 22 relational relational ADJ eblip-30118 14 23 , , PUNCT eblip-30118 14 24 experiential experiential ADJ eblip-30118 14 25 , , PUNCT eblip-30118 14 26 and and CCONJ eblip-30118 14 27 professional professional ADJ eblip-30118 14 28 inputs input NOUN eblip-30118 14 29 . . PUNCT eblip-30118 15 1 the the DET eblip-30118 15 2 author author NOUN eblip-30118 15 3 then then ADV eblip-30118 15 4 labelled label VERB eblip-30118 15 5 each each DET eblip-30118 15 6 construct construct NOUN eblip-30118 15 7 based base VERB eblip-30118 15 8 on on ADP eblip-30118 15 9 its its PRON eblip-30118 15 10 respective respective ADJ eblip-30118 15 11 component component NOUN eblip-30118 15 12 parts part NOUN eblip-30118 15 13 . . PUNCT eblip-30118 16 1 one one NUM eblip-30118 16 2 - - PUNCT eblip-30118 16 3 way way NOUN eblip-30118 16 4 analysis analysis NOUN eblip-30118 16 5 of of ADP eblip-30118 16 6 variance variance NOUN eblip-30118 16 7 ( ( PUNCT eblip-30118 16 8 anova anova PROPN eblip-30118 16 9 ) ) PUNCT eblip-30118 16 10 tests test NOUN eblip-30118 16 11 were be AUX eblip-30118 16 12 then then ADV eblip-30118 16 13 conducted conduct VERB eblip-30118 16 14 using use VERB eblip-30118 16 15 spss spss PROPN eblip-30118 16 16 . . PUNCT eblip-30118 16 17     SPACE eblip-30118 17 1 main main ADJ eblip-30118 17 2 results result NOUN eblip-30118 17 3 – – PUNCT eblip-30118 17 4 statistically statistically ADV eblip-30118 17 5 significant significant ADJ eblip-30118 17 6 differences difference NOUN eblip-30118 17 7 were be AUX eblip-30118 17 8 found find VERB eblip-30118 17 9 between between ADP eblip-30118 17 10 experienced experienced ADJ eblip-30118 17 11 and and CCONJ eblip-30118 17 12 inexperienced inexperienced ADJ eblip-30118 17 13 instructional instructional ADJ eblip-30118 17 14 librarians librarian NOUN eblip-30118 17 15 . . PUNCT eblip-30118 18 1 participants participant NOUN eblip-30118 18 2 with with ADP eblip-30118 18 3 more more ADJ eblip-30118 18 4 instructional instructional ADJ eblip-30118 18 5 experience experience NOUN eblip-30118 18 6 tend tend VERB eblip-30118 18 7 to to PART eblip-30118 18 8 believe believe VERB eblip-30118 18 9 their their PRON eblip-30118 18 10 teaching teaching NOUN eblip-30118 18 11 identities identity NOUN eblip-30118 18 12 are be AUX eblip-30118 18 13 influenced influence VERB eblip-30118 18 14 to to ADP eblip-30118 18 15 a a DET eblip-30118 18 16 greater great ADJ eblip-30118 18 17 extent extent NOUN eblip-30118 18 18 by by ADP eblip-30118 18 19 these these DET eblip-30118 18 20 factors factor NOUN eblip-30118 18 21 : : PUNCT eblip-30118 18 22     SPACE eblip-30118 18 23 interpersonal interpersonal ADJ eblip-30118 18 24 relationships relationship NOUN eblip-30118 18 25 feedback feedback VERB eblip-30118 18 26 from from ADP eblip-30118 18 27 colleagues colleague NOUN eblip-30118 18 28 outside outside ADP eblip-30118 18 29 of of ADP eblip-30118 18 30 librarianship librarianship NOUN eblip-30118 18 31 self self NOUN eblip-30118 18 32 - - PUNCT eblip-30118 18 33 directed direct VERB eblip-30118 18 34 learning learning NOUN eblip-30118 18 35 opportunities opportunity NOUN eblip-30118 18 36     SPACE eblip-30118 18 37 participants participant NOUN eblip-30118 18 38 with with ADP eblip-30118 18 39 less less ADJ eblip-30118 18 40 instructional instructional ADJ eblip-30118 18 41 experience experience NOUN eblip-30118 18 42 tend tend VERB eblip-30118 18 43 to to PART eblip-30118 18 44 believe believe VERB eblip-30118 18 45 their their PRON eblip-30118 18 46 teaching teaching NOUN eblip-30118 18 47 identities identity NOUN eblip-30118 18 48 are be AUX eblip-30118 18 49 influenced influence VERB eblip-30118 18 50 to to ADP eblip-30118 18 51 a a DET eblip-30118 18 52 greater great ADJ eblip-30118 18 53 extent extent NOUN eblip-30118 18 54 by by ADP eblip-30118 18 55 these these DET eblip-30118 18 56 factors factor NOUN eblip-30118 18 57 : : PUNCT eblip-30118 18 58     SPACE eblip-30118 18 59 feedback feedback NOUN eblip-30118 18 60 from from ADP eblip-30118 18 61 those those PRON eblip-30118 18 62 within within ADP eblip-30118 18 63 librarianship librarianship NOUN eblip-30118 18 64 library library ADJ eblip-30118 18 65 - - PUNCT eblip-30118 18 66 centric centric ADJ eblip-30118 18 67 inputs input NOUN eblip-30118 18 68 such such ADJ eblip-30118 18 69 as as ADP eblip-30118 18 70 their their PRON eblip-30118 18 71 formal formal ADJ eblip-30118 18 72 library library NOUN eblip-30118 18 73 studies study NOUN eblip-30118 18 74     SPACE eblip-30118 18 75 conclusion conclusion NOUN eblip-30118 18 76 – – PUNCT eblip-30118 18 77 different different ADJ eblip-30118 18 78 types type NOUN eblip-30118 18 79 of of ADP eblip-30118 18 80 professional professional ADJ eblip-30118 18 81 development development NOUN eblip-30118 18 82 opportunities opportunity NOUN eblip-30118 18 83 will will AUX eblip-30118 18 84 appeal appeal VERB eblip-30118 18 85 to to ADP eblip-30118 18 86 different different ADJ eblip-30118 18 87 librarians librarian NOUN eblip-30118 18 88 based base VERB eblip-30118 18 89 on on ADP eblip-30118 18 90 their their PRON eblip-30118 18 91 level level NOUN eblip-30118 18 92 of of ADP eblip-30118 18 93 instructional instructional ADJ eblip-30118 18 94 experience experience NOUN eblip-30118 18 95 . . PUNCT eblip-30118 19 1 less less ADV eblip-30118 19 2 experienced experienced ADJ eblip-30118 19 3 librarian librarian ADJ eblip-30118 19 4 instructors instructor NOUN eblip-30118 19 5 may may AUX eblip-30118 19 6 find find VERB eblip-30118 19 7 mentoring mentoring NOUN eblip-30118 19 8 and and CCONJ eblip-30118 19 9 informal informal ADJ eblip-30118 19 10 collegial collegial ADJ eblip-30118 19 11 relationships relationship NOUN eblip-30118 19 12 within within ADP eblip-30118 19 13 the the DET eblip-30118 19 14 library library NOUN eblip-30118 19 15 to to PART eblip-30118 19 16 be be AUX eblip-30118 19 17 beneficial beneficial ADJ eblip-30118 19 18 . . PUNCT eblip-30118 20 1 more more ADV eblip-30118 20 2 experienced experienced ADJ eblip-30118 20 3 librarian librarian ADJ eblip-30118 20 4 instructors instructor NOUN eblip-30118 20 5 may may AUX eblip-30118 20 6 prefer prefer VERB eblip-30118 20 7 to to PART eblip-30118 20 8 seek seek VERB eblip-30118 20 9 out out ADP eblip-30118 20 10 relationships relationship NOUN eblip-30118 20 11 with with ADP eblip-30118 20 12 colleagues colleague NOUN eblip-30118 20 13 outside outside ADP eblip-30118 20 14 the the DET eblip-30118 20 15 library library NOUN eblip-30118 20 16 to to PART eblip-30118 20 17 further far ADV eblip-30118 20 18 develop develop VERB eblip-30118 20 19 their their PRON eblip-30118 20 20 teaching teaching NOUN eblip-30118 20 21 identities identity NOUN eblip-30118 20 22 . . PUNCT eblip-30118 20 23     SPACE eblip-30118 21 1 commentary commentary NOUN eblip-30118 21 2     SPACE eblip-30118 21 3 the the DET eblip-30118 21 4 paper paper NOUN eblip-30118 21 5 is be AUX eblip-30118 21 6 part part NOUN eblip-30118 21 7 of of ADP eblip-30118 21 8 a a DET eblip-30118 21 9 series series NOUN eblip-30118 21 10 of of ADP eblip-30118 21 11 five five NUM eblip-30118 21 12 publications publication NOUN eblip-30118 21 13 by by ADP eblip-30118 21 14 the the DET eblip-30118 21 15 author author NOUN eblip-30118 21 16 , , PUNCT eblip-30118 21 17 reporting report VERB eblip-30118 21 18 the the DET eblip-30118 21 19 findings finding NOUN eblip-30118 21 20 from from ADP eblip-30118 21 21 a a DET eblip-30118 21 22 single single ADJ eblip-30118 21 23 survey survey NOUN eblip-30118 21 24 questionnaire questionnaire NOUN eblip-30118 21 25 , , PUNCT eblip-30118 21 26 such such ADJ eblip-30118 21 27 as as ADP eblip-30118 21 28 ( ( PUNCT eblip-30118 21 29 e.g. e.g. ADV eblip-30118 21 30 , , PUNCT eblip-30118 21 31 nichols nichols PROPN eblip-30118 21 32 hess hess PROPN eblip-30118 21 33 , , PUNCT eblip-30118 21 34 2020 2020 NUM eblip-30118 21 35 and and CCONJ eblip-30118 21 36 nichols nichols PROPN eblip-30118 21 37 hess hess PROPN eblip-30118 21 38 , , PUNCT eblip-30118 21 39 2019 2019 NUM eblip-30118 21 40 ) ) PUNCT eblip-30118 21 41 . . PUNCT eblip-30118 22 1 this this DET eblip-30118 22 2 work work NOUN eblip-30118 22 3 explores explore VERB eblip-30118 22 4 how how SCONJ eblip-30118 22 5 a a DET eblip-30118 22 6 range range NOUN eblip-30118 22 7 of of ADP eblip-30118 22 8 factors factor NOUN eblip-30118 22 9 influence influence VERB eblip-30118 22 10 academic academic ADJ eblip-30118 22 11 librarians librarian NOUN eblip-30118 22 12 ’ ’ PART eblip-30118 22 13 teaching teaching NOUN eblip-30118 22 14 identities identity NOUN eblip-30118 22 15 , , PUNCT eblip-30118 22 16 with with SCONJ eblip-30118 22 17 various various ADJ eblip-30118 22 18 sub sub NOUN eblip-30118 22 19 - - ADJ eblip-30118 22 20 findings finding NOUN eblip-30118 22 21 reported report VERB eblip-30118 22 22 separately separately ADV eblip-30118 22 23 . . PUNCT eblip-30118 23 1 it it PRON eblip-30118 23 2 is be AUX eblip-30118 23 3 grounded ground VERB eblip-30118 23 4 in in ADP eblip-30118 23 5 mezirow mezirow NOUN eblip-30118 23 6 ’s ’s PART eblip-30118 23 7 ( ( PUNCT eblip-30118 23 8 1978 1978 NUM eblip-30118 23 9 ) ) PUNCT eblip-30118 23 10 concept concept NOUN eblip-30118 23 11 of of ADP eblip-30118 23 12 transformative transformative ADJ eblip-30118 23 13 learning learning NOUN eblip-30118 23 14 . . PUNCT eblip-30118 23 15     SPACE eblip-30118 24 1 the the DET eblip-30118 24 2 study study NOUN eblip-30118 24 3 was be AUX eblip-30118 24 4 evaluated evaluate VERB eblip-30118 24 5 using use VERB eblip-30118 24 6 glynn glynn PROPN eblip-30118 24 7 ’s ’s PART eblip-30118 24 8 ( ( PUNCT eblip-30118 24 9 2006 2006 NUM eblip-30118 24 10 ) ) PUNCT eblip-30118 24 11 critical critical ADJ eblip-30118 24 12 appraisal appraisal NOUN eblip-30118 24 13 tool tool NOUN eblip-30118 24 14 . . PUNCT eblip-30118 24 15     SPACE eblip-30118 25 1 the the DET eblip-30118 25 2 literature literature NOUN eblip-30118 25 3 review review NOUN eblip-30118 25 4 provides provide VERB eblip-30118 25 5 a a DET eblip-30118 25 6 useful useful ADJ eblip-30118 25 7 summary summary NOUN eblip-30118 25 8 of of ADP eblip-30118 25 9 the the DET eblip-30118 25 10 theoretical theoretical ADJ eblip-30118 25 11 constructs construct NOUN eblip-30118 25 12 underpinning underpin VERB eblip-30118 25 13 the the DET eblip-30118 25 14 research research NOUN eblip-30118 25 15 . . PUNCT eblip-30118 26 1 however however ADV eblip-30118 26 2 , , PUNCT eblip-30118 26 3 it it PRON eblip-30118 26 4 is be AUX eblip-30118 26 5 not not PART eblip-30118 26 6 readily readily ADV eblip-30118 26 7 apparent apparent ADJ eblip-30118 26 8 how how SCONJ eblip-30118 26 9 this this DET eblip-30118 26 10 paper paper NOUN eblip-30118 26 11 connects connect VERB eblip-30118 26 12 to to ADP eblip-30118 26 13 the the DET eblip-30118 26 14 other other ADJ eblip-30118 26 15 papers paper NOUN eblip-30118 26 16 in in ADP eblip-30118 26 17 the the DET eblip-30118 26 18 series series NOUN eblip-30118 26 19 ( ( PUNCT eblip-30118 26 20 nichols nichols PROPN eblip-30118 26 21 hess hess PROPN eblip-30118 26 22 , , PUNCT eblip-30118 26 23 2020 2020 NUM eblip-30118 26 24 , , PUNCT eblip-30118 26 25 2019 2019 NUM eblip-30118 26 26 ) ) PUNCT eblip-30118 26 27 . . PUNCT eblip-30118 27 1 further far ADV eblip-30118 27 2 , , PUNCT eblip-30118 27 3 the the DET eblip-30118 27 4 author author NOUN eblip-30118 27 5 does do AUX eblip-30118 27 6 not not PART eblip-30118 27 7 clearly clearly ADV eblip-30118 27 8 articulate articulate VERB eblip-30118 27 9 why why SCONJ eblip-30118 27 10 one one PRON eblip-30118 27 11 would would AUX eblip-30118 27 12 read read VERB eblip-30118 27 13 this this DET eblip-30118 27 14 latest late ADJ eblip-30118 27 15 paper paper NOUN eblip-30118 27 16 as as SCONJ eblip-30118 27 17 opposed oppose VERB eblip-30118 27 18 to to ADP eblip-30118 27 19 the the DET eblip-30118 27 20 others other NOUN eblip-30118 27 21 in in ADP eblip-30118 27 22 the the DET eblip-30118 27 23 series series NOUN eblip-30118 27 24 . . PUNCT eblip-30118 28 1 in in ADP eblip-30118 28 2 fact fact NOUN eblip-30118 28 3 , , PUNCT eblip-30118 28 4 these these DET eblip-30118 28 5 other other ADJ eblip-30118 28 6 related related ADJ eblip-30118 28 7 papers paper NOUN eblip-30118 28 8 are be AUX eblip-30118 28 9 barely barely ADV eblip-30118 28 10 mentioned mention VERB eblip-30118 28 11 in in ADP eblip-30118 28 12 the the DET eblip-30118 28 13 literature literature PROPN eblip-30118 28 14 review review PROPN eblip-30118 28 15 . . PUNCT eblip-30118 28 16     SPACE eblip-30118 29 1 to to PART eblip-30118 29 2 get get VERB eblip-30118 29 3 a a DET eblip-30118 29 4 complete complete ADJ eblip-30118 29 5 understanding understanding NOUN eblip-30118 29 6 of of ADP eblip-30118 29 7 the the DET eblip-30118 29 8 methodology methodology NOUN eblip-30118 29 9 and and CCONJ eblip-30118 29 10 practical practical ADJ eblip-30118 29 11 implications implication NOUN eblip-30118 29 12 of of ADP eblip-30118 29 13 this this DET eblip-30118 29 14 work work NOUN eblip-30118 29 15 , , PUNCT eblip-30118 29 16 readers reader NOUN eblip-30118 29 17 must must AUX eblip-30118 29 18 consult consult VERB eblip-30118 29 19 all all DET eblip-30118 29 20 the the DET eblip-30118 29 21 other other ADJ eblip-30118 29 22 papers paper NOUN eblip-30118 29 23 in in ADP eblip-30118 29 24 the the DET eblip-30118 29 25 series series NOUN eblip-30118 29 26 . . PUNCT eblip-30118 30 1 the the DET eblip-30118 30 2 author author NOUN eblip-30118 30 3 notes note VERB eblip-30118 30 4 “ " PUNCT eblip-30118 30 5 the the DET eblip-30118 30 6 findings finding NOUN eblip-30118 30 7 should should AUX eblip-30118 30 8 be be AUX eblip-30118 30 9 considered consider VERB eblip-30118 30 10 with with ADP eblip-30118 30 11 the the DET eblip-30118 30 12 other other ADJ eblip-30118 30 13 statistically statistically ADV eblip-30118 30 14 significant significant ADJ eblip-30118 30 15 relationships relationship NOUN eblip-30118 30 16 from from ADP eblip-30118 30 17 this this DET eblip-30118 30 18 research research NOUN eblip-30118 30 19 ” " PUNCT eblip-30118 30 20 ( ( PUNCT eblip-30118 30 21 p. p. NOUN eblip-30118 30 22 167–168 167–168 NUM eblip-30118 30 23 ) ) PUNCT eblip-30118 30 24 . . PUNCT eblip-30118 31 1 this this PRON eblip-30118 31 2 makes make VERB eblip-30118 31 3 it it PRON eblip-30118 31 4 difficult difficult ADJ eblip-30118 31 5 for for SCONJ eblip-30118 31 6 readers reader NOUN eblip-30118 31 7 to to PART eblip-30118 31 8 understand understand VERB eblip-30118 31 9 the the DET eblip-30118 31 10 overarching overarching ADJ eblip-30118 31 11 significance significance NOUN eblip-30118 31 12 of of ADP eblip-30118 31 13 the the DET eblip-30118 31 14 study study NOUN eblip-30118 31 15 . . PUNCT eblip-30118 32 1 it it PRON eblip-30118 32 2 can can AUX eblip-30118 32 3 also also ADV eblip-30118 32 4 be be AUX eblip-30118 32 5 a a DET eblip-30118 32 6 burden burden NOUN eblip-30118 32 7 on on ADP eblip-30118 32 8 readers reader NOUN eblip-30118 32 9 ’ ’ PART eblip-30118 32 10 time time NOUN eblip-30118 32 11 ( ( PUNCT eblip-30118 32 12 elsevier elsevier NOUN eblip-30118 32 13 , , PUNCT eblip-30118 32 14 2019 2019 NUM eblip-30118 32 15 ) ) PUNCT eblip-30118 32 16 . . PUNCT eblip-30118 32 17     SPACE eblip-30118 33 1 the the DET eblip-30118 33 2 author author NOUN eblip-30118 33 3 has have AUX eblip-30118 33 4 made make VERB eblip-30118 33 5 good good ADJ eblip-30118 33 6 use use NOUN eblip-30118 33 7 of of ADP eblip-30118 33 8 a a DET eblip-30118 33 9 previously previously ADV eblip-30118 33 10 validated validate VERB eblip-30118 33 11 survey survey NOUN eblip-30118 33 12 ( ( PUNCT eblip-30118 33 13 king king NOUN eblip-30118 33 14 , , PUNCT eblip-30118 33 15 2009 2009 NUM eblip-30118 33 16 ) ) PUNCT eblip-30118 33 17 . . PUNCT eblip-30118 34 1 the the DET eblip-30118 34 2 author author NOUN eblip-30118 34 3 provides provide VERB eblip-30118 34 4 the the DET eblip-30118 34 5 survey survey NOUN eblip-30118 34 6 in in ADP eblip-30118 34 7 full full ADJ eblip-30118 34 8 in in ADP eblip-30118 34 9 the the DET eblip-30118 34 10 appendix appendix NOUN eblip-30118 34 11 , , PUNCT eblip-30118 34 12 allowing allow VERB eblip-30118 34 13 for for ADP eblip-30118 34 14 replication replication NOUN eblip-30118 34 15 . . PUNCT eblip-30118 34 16     SPACE eblip-30118 35 1 respondents respondent NOUN eblip-30118 35 2 were be AUX eblip-30118 35 3 self self NOUN eblip-30118 35 4 - - PUNCT eblip-30118 35 5 selected select VERB eblip-30118 35 6 , , PUNCT eblip-30118 35 7 so so SCONJ eblip-30118 35 8 they they PRON eblip-30118 35 9 may may AUX eblip-30118 35 10 not not PART eblip-30118 35 11 accurately accurately ADV eblip-30118 35 12 represent represent VERB eblip-30118 35 13 the the DET eblip-30118 35 14 wider wide ADJ eblip-30118 35 15 population population NOUN eblip-30118 35 16 . . PUNCT eblip-30118 36 1 further far ADV eblip-30118 36 2 , , PUNCT eblip-30118 36 3 this this DET eblip-30118 36 4 analysis analysis NOUN eblip-30118 36 5 considers consider VERB eblip-30118 36 6 only only ADV eblip-30118 36 7 those those DET eblip-30118 36 8 respondents respondent NOUN eblip-30118 36 9 ( ( PUNCT eblip-30118 36 10 353/501 353/501 NUM eblip-30118 36 11 , , PUNCT eblip-30118 36 12 approx approx NOUN eblip-30118 36 13 . . PUNCT eblip-30118 37 1 70.5 70.5 NUM eblip-30118 37 2 % % NOUN eblip-30118 37 3 ) ) PUNCT eblip-30118 37 4 who who PRON eblip-30118 37 5 experienced experience VERB eblip-30118 37 6 instructional instructional ADJ eblip-30118 37 7 identity identity NOUN eblip-30118 37 8 transformation transformation NOUN eblip-30118 37 9 . . PUNCT eblip-30118 38 1 comparing compare VERB eblip-30118 38 2 the the DET eblip-30118 38 3 practices practice NOUN eblip-30118 38 4 of of ADP eblip-30118 38 5 those those PRON eblip-30118 38 6 who who PRON eblip-30118 38 7 have have AUX eblip-30118 38 8 not not PART eblip-30118 38 9 experienced experience VERB eblip-30118 38 10 transformation transformation NOUN eblip-30118 38 11 to to ADP eblip-30118 38 12 those those PRON eblip-30118 38 13 who who PRON eblip-30118 38 14 have have VERB eblip-30118 38 15 may may AUX eblip-30118 38 16 have have AUX eblip-30118 38 17 been be AUX eblip-30118 38 18 useful useful ADJ eblip-30118 38 19 . . PUNCT eblip-30118 38 20     SPACE eblip-30118 39 1 the the DET eblip-30118 39 2 author author NOUN eblip-30118 39 3 provides provide VERB eblip-30118 39 4 useful useful ADJ eblip-30118 39 5 discussion discussion NOUN eblip-30118 39 6 around around ADP eblip-30118 39 7 the the DET eblip-30118 39 8 study study NOUN eblip-30118 39 9 ’s ’s PART eblip-30118 39 10 limitations limitation NOUN eblip-30118 39 11 and and CCONJ eblip-30118 39 12 gives give VERB eblip-30118 39 13 reasonable reasonable ADJ eblip-30118 39 14 suggestions suggestion NOUN eblip-30118 39 15 for for ADP eblip-30118 39 16 future future ADJ eblip-30118 39 17 research research NOUN eblip-30118 39 18 . . PUNCT eblip-30118 39 19     SPACE eblip-30118 40 1 the the DET eblip-30118 40 2 study study NOUN eblip-30118 40 3 will will AUX eblip-30118 40 4 be be AUX eblip-30118 40 5 of of ADP eblip-30118 40 6 interest interest NOUN eblip-30118 40 7 to to ADP eblip-30118 40 8 academic academic ADJ eblip-30118 40 9 library library NOUN eblip-30118 40 10 administrators administrator NOUN eblip-30118 40 11 looking look VERB eblip-30118 40 12 for for ADP eblip-30118 40 13 ways way NOUN eblip-30118 40 14 to to PART eblip-30118 40 15 support support VERB eblip-30118 40 16 staff staff NOUN eblip-30118 40 17 development development NOUN eblip-30118 40 18 . . PUNCT eblip-30118 41 1 readers reader NOUN eblip-30118 41 2 , , PUNCT eblip-30118 41 3 however however ADV eblip-30118 41 4 , , PUNCT eblip-30118 41 5 would would AUX eblip-30118 41 6 benefit benefit VERB eblip-30118 41 7 from from ADP eblip-30118 41 8 having have VERB eblip-30118 41 9 a a DET eblip-30118 41 10 single single ADJ eblip-30118 41 11 , , PUNCT eblip-30118 41 12 overarching overarching ADJ eblip-30118 41 13 publication publication NOUN eblip-30118 41 14 detailing detail VERB eblip-30118 41 15 the the DET eblip-30118 41 16 key key ADJ eblip-30118 41 17 findings finding NOUN eblip-30118 41 18 and and CCONJ eblip-30118 41 19 most most ADV eblip-30118 41 20 important important ADJ eblip-30118 41 21 recommendations recommendation NOUN eblip-30118 41 22 resulting result VERB eblip-30118 41 23 from from ADP eblip-30118 41 24 the the DET eblip-30118 41 25 study study NOUN eblip-30118 41 26 . . PUNCT eblip-30118 41 27     SPACE eblip-30118 42 1 references reference NOUN eblip-30118 42 2     SPACE eblip-30118 42 3 elsevier elsevier NOUN eblip-30118 42 4 . . PUNCT eblip-30118 43 1 ( ( PUNCT eblip-30118 43 2 2019 2019 NUM eblip-30118 43 3 ) ) PUNCT eblip-30118 43 4 . . PUNCT eblip-30118 44 1 factsheet factsheet NOUN eblip-30118 44 2 : : PUNCT eblip-30118 44 3 salami salami ADJ eblip-30118 44 4 slicing slicing NOUN eblip-30118 44 5 . . PUNCT eblip-30118 45 1 elsevier elsevier NOUN eblip-30118 45 2 . . PUNCT eblip-30118 46 1 https://www.elsevier.com/__data/assets/pdf_file/0011/653888/salami-slicing-factsheet-march-2019.pdf https://www.elsevier.com/__data/assets/pdf_file/0011/653888/salami-slicing-factsheet-march-2019.pdf NOUN eblip-30118 46 2     SPACE eblip-30118 46 3 glynn glynn PROPN eblip-30118 46 4 , , PUNCT eblip-30118 46 5 l. l. PROPN eblip-30118 46 6 ( ( PUNCT eblip-30118 46 7 2006 2006 NUM eblip-30118 46 8 ) ) PUNCT eblip-30118 46 9 . . PUNCT eblip-30118 47 1 a a DET eblip-30118 47 2 critical critical ADJ eblip-30118 47 3 appraisal appraisal NOUN eblip-30118 47 4 tool tool NOUN eblip-30118 47 5 for for ADP eblip-30118 47 6 library library NOUN eblip-30118 47 7 and and CCONJ eblip-30118 47 8 information information NOUN eblip-30118 47 9 research research NOUN eblip-30118 47 10 . . PUNCT eblip-30118 48 1 library library NOUN eblip-30118 48 2 hi hi INTJ eblip-30118 48 3 tech tech NOUN eblip-30118 48 4 , , PUNCT eblip-30118 48 5 24(3 24(3 NUM eblip-30118 48 6 ) ) PUNCT eblip-30118 48 7 , , PUNCT eblip-30118 48 8 387–399 387–399 NUM eblip-30118 48 9 . . PUNCT eblip-30118 48 10     SPACE eblip-30118 49 1 https://doi.org/10.1108/07378830610692154 https://doi.org/10.1108/07378830610692154 NOUN eblip-30118 49 2     SPACE eblip-30118 49 3 king king NOUN eblip-30118 49 4 , , PUNCT eblip-30118 49 5 k. k. PROPN eblip-30118 50 1 p. p. PROPN eblip-30118 50 2 ( ( PUNCT eblip-30118 50 3 2009 2009 NUM eblip-30118 50 4 ) ) PUNCT eblip-30118 50 5 . . PUNCT eblip-30118 51 1 the the DET eblip-30118 51 2 handbook handbook NOUN eblip-30118 51 3 of of ADP eblip-30118 51 4 the the DET eblip-30118 51 5 evolving evolve VERB eblip-30118 51 6 research research NOUN eblip-30118 51 7 of of ADP eblip-30118 51 8 transformative transformative ADJ eblip-30118 51 9 learning learning NOUN eblip-30118 51 10 : : PUNCT eblip-30118 51 11 based base VERB eblip-30118 51 12 on on ADP eblip-30118 51 13 the the DET eblip-30118 51 14 learning learning NOUN eblip-30118 51 15 activities activity NOUN eblip-30118 51 16 survey survey NOUN eblip-30118 51 17 ( ( PUNCT eblip-30118 51 18 10th 10th ADJ eblip-30118 51 19 ed ed NOUN eblip-30118 51 20 ) ) PUNCT eblip-30118 51 21 . . PUNCT eblip-30118 52 1 information information NOUN eblip-30118 52 2 age age NOUN eblip-30118 52 3 publishing publishing NOUN eblip-30118 52 4 . . PUNCT eblip-30118 52 5     SPACE eblip-30118 53 1 mezirow mezirow NOUN eblip-30118 53 2 , , PUNCT eblip-30118 53 3 j. j. PROPN eblip-30118 53 4 ( ( PUNCT eblip-30118 53 5 1978 1978 NUM eblip-30118 53 6 ) ) PUNCT eblip-30118 53 7 . . PUNCT eblip-30118 54 1 perspective perspective NOUN eblip-30118 54 2 transformation transformation NOUN eblip-30118 54 3 . . PUNCT eblip-30118 55 1 adult adult NOUN eblip-30118 55 2 education education NOUN eblip-30118 55 3 , , PUNCT eblip-30118 55 4 28(2 28(2 NUM eblip-30118 55 5 ) ) PUNCT eblip-30118 55 6 , , PUNCT eblip-30118 55 7 100–110 100–110 NUM eblip-30118 55 8 . . PUNCT eblip-30118 56 1 https://doi.org/10.1177%2f074171367802800202 https://doi.org/10.1177%2f074171367802800202 PROPN eblip-30118 56 2     SPACE eblip-30118 56 3 nichols nichols PROPN eblip-30118 56 4 hess hess PROPN eblip-30118 56 5 , , PUNCT eblip-30118 56 6 a. a. NOUN eblip-30118 56 7 ( ( PUNCT eblip-30118 56 8 2019 2019 NUM eblip-30118 56 9 ) ) PUNCT eblip-30118 56 10 . . PUNCT eblip-30118 57 1 academic academic ADJ eblip-30118 57 2 librarians librarian NOUN eblip-30118 57 3 ’ ’ PART eblip-30118 57 4 educational educational ADJ eblip-30118 57 5 factors factor NOUN eblip-30118 57 6 and and CCONJ eblip-30118 57 7 perceptions perception NOUN eblip-30118 57 8 of of ADP eblip-30118 57 9 teaching teach VERB eblip-30118 57 10 transformation transformation NOUN eblip-30118 57 11 : : PUNCT eblip-30118 57 12 an an DET eblip-30118 57 13 exploratory exploratory ADJ eblip-30118 57 14 examination examination NOUN eblip-30118 57 15 . . PUNCT eblip-30118 58 1 evidence evidence NOUN eblip-30118 58 2 based base VERB eblip-30118 58 3 library library NOUN eblip-30118 58 4 and and CCONJ eblip-30118 58 5 information information NOUN eblip-30118 58 6 practice practice NOUN eblip-30118 58 7 , , PUNCT eblip-30118 58 8 14(3 14(3 NUM eblip-30118 58 9 ) ) PUNCT eblip-30118 58 10 , , PUNCT eblip-30118 58 11 52–76 52–76 NUM eblip-30118 58 12 . . PUNCT eblip-30118 59 1 https://doi.org/10.18438/eblip29526 https://doi.org/10.18438/eblip29526 NOUN eblip-30118 59 2     SPACE eblip-30118 59 3 nichols nichols PROPN eblip-30118 59 4 hess hess PROPN eblip-30118 59 5 , , PUNCT eblip-30118 59 6 a. a. NOUN eblip-30118 59 7 ( ( PUNCT eblip-30118 59 8 2020 2020 NUM eblip-30118 59 9 ) ) PUNCT eblip-30118 59 10 . . PUNCT eblip-30118 60 1 academic academic ADJ eblip-30118 60 2 librarians librarian NOUN eblip-30118 60 3 ’ ’ PART eblip-30118 60 4 teaching teach VERB eblip-30118 60 5 identities identity NOUN eblip-30118 60 6 and and CCONJ eblip-30118 60 7 work work NOUN eblip-30118 60 8 experiences experience NOUN eblip-30118 60 9 : : PUNCT eblip-30118 60 10 exploring explore VERB eblip-30118 60 11 relationships relationship NOUN eblip-30118 60 12 to to PART eblip-30118 60 13 support support VERB eblip-30118 60 14 perspective perspective ADJ eblip-30118 60 15 transformation transformation NOUN eblip-30118 60 16 in in ADP eblip-30118 60 17 information information NOUN eblip-30118 60 18 literacy literacy NOUN eblip-30118 60 19 instruction instruction NOUN eblip-30118 60 20 . . PUNCT eblip-30118 61 1 journal journal NOUN eblip-30118 61 2 of of ADP eblip-30118 61 3 library library PROPN eblip-30118 61 4 administration administration NOUN eblip-30118 61 5 , , PUNCT eblip-30118 61 6 60(4 60(4 NUM eblip-30118 61 7 ) ) PUNCT eblip-30118 61 8 , , PUNCT eblip-30118 61 9 331–353 331–353 NUM eblip-30118 61 10 . . PUNCT eblip-30118 61 11 https://doi.org/10.1080/01930826.2020.1721939 https://doi.org/10.1080/01930826.2020.1721939 PUNCT eblip-30118 61 12         SPACE