id sid tid token lemma pos eblip-6807 1 1 evidence evidence NOUN eblip-6807 1 2 based base VERB eblip-6807 1 3 library library NOUN eblip-6807 1 4 and and CCONJ eblip-6807 1 5 information information NOUN eblip-6807 1 6 practice practice NOUN eblip-6807 1 7 evidence evidence NOUN eblip-6807 1 8     SPACE eblip-6807 1 9 based base VERB eblip-6807 1 10     SPACE eblip-6807 1 11 library library NOUN eblip-6807 1 12     SPACE eblip-6807 1 13 and and CCONJ eblip-6807 1 14     SPACE eblip-6807 1 15 information information NOUN eblip-6807 1 16     SPACE eblip-6807 1 17 practice practice NOUN eblip-6807 1 18     SPACE eblip-6807 1 19 2010 2010 NUM eblip-6807 1 20 , , PUNCT eblip-6807 1 21     SPACE eblip-6807 1 22 5.1 5.1 NUM eblip-6807 1 23     SPACE eblip-6807 1 24 evidence evidence NOUN eblip-6807 1 25     SPACE eblip-6807 1 26 based base VERB eblip-6807 1 27     SPACE eblip-6807 1 28 library library NOUN eblip-6807 1 29     SPACE eblip-6807 1 30 and and CCONJ eblip-6807 1 31     SPACE eblip-6807 1 32 information information NOUN eblip-6807 1 33     SPACE eblip-6807 1 34 practice practice NOUN eblip-6807 1 35             SPACE eblip-6807 1 36 evidence evidence NOUN eblip-6807 1 37     SPACE eblip-6807 1 38 summary summary NOUN eblip-6807 1 39         SPACE eblip-6807 1 40 benefits benefit NOUN eblip-6807 1 41     SPACE eblip-6807 1 42 of of ADP eblip-6807 1 43     SPACE eblip-6807 1 44 unionization unionization NOUN eblip-6807 1 45     SPACE eblip-6807 1 46 still still ADV eblip-6807 1 47     SPACE eblip-6807 1 48 unclear unclear ADJ eblip-6807 1 49     SPACE eblip-6807 1 50 for for ADP eblip-6807 1 51     SPACE eblip-6807 1 52 u.s u.s PROPN eblip-6807 1 53 . . PROPN eblip-6807 1 54     SPACE eblip-6807 1 55 academic academic ADJ eblip-6807 1 56     SPACE eblip-6807 1 57 libraries library NOUN eblip-6807 1 58     SPACE eblip-6807 1 59 and and CCONJ eblip-6807 1 60     SPACE eblip-6807 1 61 librarians librarian NOUN eblip-6807 1 62           SPACE eblip-6807 1 63 a a DET eblip-6807 1 64     SPACE eblip-6807 1 65 review review NOUN eblip-6807 1 66     SPACE eblip-6807 1 67 of of ADP eblip-6807 1 68 : : PUNCT eblip-6807 1 69       SPACE eblip-6807 1 70 applegate applegate ADJ eblip-6807 1 71 , , PUNCT eblip-6807 1 72     SPACE eblip-6807 1 73 r. r. PROPN eblip-6807 1 74     SPACE eblip-6807 1 75 ( ( PUNCT eblip-6807 1 76 2009 2009 NUM eblip-6807 1 77 ) ) PUNCT eblip-6807 1 78 . . PUNCT eblip-6807 1 79     SPACE eblip-6807 2 1 who who PRON eblip-6807 2 2     SPACE eblip-6807 2 3 benefits benefit VERB eblip-6807 2 4 ? ? PUNCT eblip-6807 2 5     SPACE eblip-6807 2 6 unionization unionization NOUN eblip-6807 2 7     SPACE eblip-6807 2 8 and and CCONJ eblip-6807 2 9     SPACE eblip-6807 2 10 academic academic ADJ eblip-6807 2 11     SPACE eblip-6807 2 12 libraries library NOUN eblip-6807 2 13     SPACE eblip-6807 2 14 and and CCONJ eblip-6807 2 15     SPACE eblip-6807 2 16 librarians librarian NOUN eblip-6807 2 17 . . PUNCT eblip-6807 2 18     SPACE eblip-6807 3 1 the the DET eblip-6807 3 2     SPACE eblip-6807 3 3 library library NOUN eblip-6807 3 4     SPACE eblip-6807 3 5 quarterly quarterly ADV eblip-6807 3 6 , , PUNCT eblip-6807 3 7     SPACE eblip-6807 3 8 79(4 79(4 NOUN eblip-6807 3 9 ) ) PUNCT eblip-6807 3 10 , , PUNCT eblip-6807 3 11     SPACE eblip-6807 3 12 443‐463 443‐463 PROPN eblip-6807 3 13 . . PUNCT eblip-6807 3 14         SPACE eblip-6807 3 15 reviewed review VERB eblip-6807 3 16     SPACE eblip-6807 3 17 by by ADP eblip-6807 3 18 : : PUNCT eblip-6807 3 19       SPACE eblip-6807 3 20 diana diana PROPN eblip-6807 3 21     SPACE eblip-6807 3 22 k. k. PROPN eblip-6807 3 23     SPACE eblip-6807 3 24 wakimoto wakimoto NOUN eblip-6807 3 25     SPACE eblip-6807 3 26 online online ADJ eblip-6807 3 27     SPACE eblip-6807 3 28 literacy literacy NOUN eblip-6807 3 29     SPACE eblip-6807 3 30 librarian librarian PROPN eblip-6807 3 31     SPACE eblip-6807 3 32 california california PROPN eblip-6807 3 33     SPACE eblip-6807 3 34 state state NOUN eblip-6807 3 35     SPACE eblip-6807 3 36 university university PROPN eblip-6807 3 37     SPACE eblip-6807 3 38 east east PROPN eblip-6807 3 39     SPACE eblip-6807 3 40 bay bay PROPN eblip-6807 3 41 , , PUNCT eblip-6807 3 42     SPACE eblip-6807 3 43 hayward hayward PROPN eblip-6807 3 44 , , PUNCT eblip-6807 3 45     SPACE eblip-6807 3 46 california california PROPN eblip-6807 3 47 , , PUNCT eblip-6807 3 48     SPACE eblip-6807 3 49 united united ADJ eblip-6807 3 50     SPACE eblip-6807 3 51 states state NOUN eblip-6807 3 52     SPACE eblip-6807 3 53 of of ADP eblip-6807 3 54     SPACE eblip-6807 3 55 america america PROPN eblip-6807 3 56     SPACE eblip-6807 3 57 email email NOUN eblip-6807 3 58 : : PUNCT eblip-6807 3 59     SPACE eblip-6807 3 60 diana.wakimoto@csueastbay.edu diana.wakimoto@csueastbay.edu PROPN eblip-6807 3 61         SPACE eblip-6807 3 62 received receive VERB eblip-6807 3 63 : : PUNCT eblip-6807 3 64     SPACE eblip-6807 3 65 26 26 NUM eblip-6807 3 66     SPACE eblip-6807 3 67 oct oct PROPN eblip-6807 3 68 . . PROPN eblip-6807 3 69     SPACE eblip-6807 3 70 2009 2009 NUM eblip-6807 3 71                     SPACE eblip-6807 3 72 accepted accept VERB eblip-6807 3 73 : : PUNCT eblip-6807 3 74     SPACE eblip-6807 3 75 04 04 NUM eblip-6807 3 76     SPACE eblip-6807 3 77 jan jan PROPN eblip-6807 3 78 . . PROPN eblip-6807 3 79     SPACE eblip-6807 3 80 2010 2010 NUM eblip-6807 3 81                 SPACE eblip-6807 3 82 2010 2010 NUM eblip-6807 3 83     SPACE eblip-6807 3 84 wakimoto wakimoto NOUN eblip-6807 3 85 . . PUNCT eblip-6807 3 86     SPACE eblip-6807 4 1 this this PRON eblip-6807 4 2     SPACE eblip-6807 4 3 is be AUX eblip-6807 4 4     SPACE eblip-6807 4 5 an an DET eblip-6807 4 6     SPACE eblip-6807 4 7 open open ADJ eblip-6807 4 8     SPACE eblip-6807 4 9 access access NOUN eblip-6807 4 10     SPACE eblip-6807 4 11 article article NOUN eblip-6807 4 12     SPACE eblip-6807 4 13 distributed distribute VERB eblip-6807 4 14     SPACE eblip-6807 4 15 under under ADP eblip-6807 4 16     SPACE eblip-6807 4 17 the the DET eblip-6807 4 18     SPACE eblip-6807 4 19 terms term NOUN eblip-6807 4 20     SPACE eblip-6807 4 21 of of ADP eblip-6807 4 22     SPACE eblip-6807 4 23 the the DET eblip-6807 4 24     SPACE eblip-6807 4 25 creative creative ADJ eblip-6807 4 26     SPACE eblip-6807 4 27 commons‐ commons‐ NOUN eblip-6807 4 28 attribution‐noncommercial‐share attribution‐noncommercial‐share PROPN eblip-6807 4 29     SPACE eblip-6807 4 30 alike alike ADV eblip-6807 4 31     SPACE eblip-6807 4 32 license license VERB eblip-6807 4 33     SPACE eblip-6807 4 34 2.5 2.5 NUM eblip-6807 4 35     SPACE eblip-6807 4 36 canada canada PROPN eblip-6807 4 37     SPACE eblip-6807 4 38 ( ( PUNCT eblip-6807 4 39 http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by‐nc‐ http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by‐nc‐ PROPN eblip-6807 4 40 sa/2.5 sa/2.5 NOUN eblip-6807 4 41 / / SYM eblip-6807 4 42 ca/ ca/ NOUN eblip-6807 4 43 ) ) PUNCT eblip-6807 4 44 , , PUNCT eblip-6807 4 45     SPACE eblip-6807 4 46 which which PRON eblip-6807 4 47     SPACE eblip-6807 4 48 permits permit VERB eblip-6807 4 49     SPACE eblip-6807 4 50 unrestricted unrestricted ADJ eblip-6807 4 51     SPACE eblip-6807 4 52 use use NOUN eblip-6807 4 53 , , PUNCT eblip-6807 4 54     SPACE eblip-6807 4 55 distribution distribution NOUN eblip-6807 4 56 , , PUNCT eblip-6807 4 57     SPACE eblip-6807 4 58 and and CCONJ eblip-6807 4 59     SPACE eblip-6807 4 60 reproduction reproduction NOUN eblip-6807 4 61     SPACE eblip-6807 4 62 in in ADP eblip-6807 4 63     SPACE eblip-6807 4 64 any any DET eblip-6807 4 65     SPACE eblip-6807 4 66 medium medium NOUN eblip-6807 4 67 , , PUNCT eblip-6807 4 68     SPACE eblip-6807 4 69 provided provide VERB eblip-6807 4 70     SPACE eblip-6807 4 71 the the DET eblip-6807 4 72     SPACE eblip-6807 4 73 original original ADJ eblip-6807 4 74     SPACE eblip-6807 4 75 work work NOUN eblip-6807 4 76     SPACE eblip-6807 4 77 is be AUX eblip-6807 4 78     SPACE eblip-6807 4 79 properly properly ADV eblip-6807 4 80     SPACE eblip-6807 4 81 attributed attribute VERB eblip-6807 4 82 , , PUNCT eblip-6807 4 83     SPACE eblip-6807 4 84 not not PART eblip-6807 4 85     SPACE eblip-6807 4 86 used use VERB eblip-6807 4 87     SPACE eblip-6807 4 88 for for ADP eblip-6807 4 89     SPACE eblip-6807 4 90 commercial commercial ADJ eblip-6807 4 91     SPACE eblip-6807 4 92 purposes purpose NOUN eblip-6807 4 93 , , PUNCT eblip-6807 4 94     SPACE eblip-6807 4 95 and and CCONJ eblip-6807 4 96 , , PUNCT eblip-6807 4 97     SPACE eblip-6807 4 98 if if SCONJ eblip-6807 4 99     SPACE eblip-6807 4 100 transformed transform VERB eblip-6807 4 101 , , PUNCT eblip-6807 4 102     SPACE eblip-6807 4 103 the the DET eblip-6807 4 104     SPACE eblip-6807 4 105 resulting result VERB eblip-6807 4 106     SPACE eblip-6807 4 107 work work NOUN eblip-6807 4 108     SPACE eblip-6807 4 109 is be AUX eblip-6807 4 110     SPACE eblip-6807 4 111 redistributed redistribute VERB eblip-6807 4 112     SPACE eblip-6807 4 113 under under ADP eblip-6807 4 114     SPACE eblip-6807 4 115 the the DET eblip-6807 4 116     SPACE eblip-6807 4 117 same same ADJ eblip-6807 4 118     SPACE eblip-6807 4 119 or or CCONJ eblip-6807 4 120     SPACE eblip-6807 4 121 similar similar ADJ eblip-6807 4 122     SPACE eblip-6807 4 123 license license NOUN eblip-6807 4 124     SPACE eblip-6807 4 125 to to ADP eblip-6807 4 126     SPACE eblip-6807 4 127 this this DET eblip-6807 4 128     SPACE eblip-6807 4 129 one one NUM eblip-6807 4 130 . . PUNCT eblip-6807 4 131         SPACE eblip-6807 4 132 abstract abstract ADJ eblip-6807 4 133         SPACE eblip-6807 4 134 objective objective NOUN eblip-6807 4 135     SPACE eblip-6807 4 136 – – PUNCT eblip-6807 4 137     SPACE eblip-6807 4 138 to to PART eblip-6807 4 139     SPACE eblip-6807 4 140 investigate investigate VERB eblip-6807 4 141     SPACE eblip-6807 4 142 the the DET eblip-6807 4 143     SPACE eblip-6807 4 144 quantitative quantitative ADJ eblip-6807 4 145     SPACE eblip-6807 4 146 benefits benefit NOUN eblip-6807 4 147     SPACE eblip-6807 4 148 of of ADP eblip-6807 4 149     SPACE eblip-6807 4 150 unionization unionization NOUN eblip-6807 4 151     SPACE eblip-6807 4 152 for for ADP eblip-6807 4 153     SPACE eblip-6807 4 154 libraries library NOUN eblip-6807 4 155 , , PUNCT eblip-6807 4 156     SPACE eblip-6807 4 157 librarians librarian NOUN eblip-6807 4 158 , , PUNCT eblip-6807 4 159     SPACE eblip-6807 4 160 and and CCONJ eblip-6807 4 161     SPACE eblip-6807 4 162 students student NOUN eblip-6807 4 163     SPACE eblip-6807 4 164 at at ADP eblip-6807 4 165     SPACE eblip-6807 4 166 academic academic ADJ eblip-6807 4 167     SPACE eblip-6807 4 168 libraries library NOUN eblip-6807 4 169     SPACE eblip-6807 4 170 in in ADP eblip-6807 4 171     SPACE eblip-6807 4 172 the the DET eblip-6807 4 173     SPACE eblip-6807 4 174 united united ADJ eblip-6807 4 175     SPACE eblip-6807 4 176 states state NOUN eblip-6807 4 177 . . PUNCT eblip-6807 4 178           SPACE eblip-6807 4 179 design design NOUN eblip-6807 4 180     SPACE eblip-6807 4 181 – – PUNCT eblip-6807 4 182     SPACE eblip-6807 4 183 quantitative quantitative ADJ eblip-6807 4 184     SPACE eblip-6807 4 185 analysis analysis NOUN eblip-6807 4 186     SPACE eblip-6807 4 187 of of ADP eblip-6807 4 188     SPACE eblip-6807 4 189 existing exist VERB eblip-6807 4 190     SPACE eblip-6807 4 191 datasets dataset NOUN eblip-6807 4 192 . . PUNCT eblip-6807 4 193         SPACE eblip-6807 5 1 setting set VERB eblip-6807 5 2     SPACE eblip-6807 5 3 – – PUNCT eblip-6807 5 4     SPACE eblip-6807 5 5 academic academic ADJ eblip-6807 5 6     SPACE eblip-6807 5 7 libraries library NOUN eblip-6807 5 8     SPACE eblip-6807 5 9 in in ADP eblip-6807 5 10     SPACE eblip-6807 5 11 the the DET eblip-6807 5 12     SPACE eblip-6807 5 13 united united ADJ eblip-6807 5 14     SPACE eblip-6807 5 15 states state NOUN eblip-6807 5 16 . . PUNCT eblip-6807 5 17           SPACE eblip-6807 6 1 subjects subject NOUN eblip-6807 6 2     SPACE eblip-6807 6 3 – – PUNCT eblip-6807 6 4     SPACE eblip-6807 6 5 one one NUM eblip-6807 6 6     SPACE eblip-6807 6 7 thousand thousand NUM eblip-6807 6 8     SPACE eblip-6807 6 9 nine nine NUM eblip-6807 6 10     SPACE eblip-6807 6 11 hundred hundred NUM eblip-6807 6 12     SPACE eblip-6807 6 13 four four NUM eblip-6807 6 14     SPACE eblip-6807 6 15 accredited accredit VERB eblip-6807 6 16     SPACE eblip-6807 6 17 colleges college NOUN eblip-6807 6 18     SPACE eblip-6807 6 19 and and CCONJ eblip-6807 6 20     SPACE eblip-6807 6 21 universities university NOUN eblip-6807 6 22     SPACE eblip-6807 6 23 in in ADP eblip-6807 6 24     SPACE eblip-6807 6 25 the the DET eblip-6807 6 26     SPACE eblip-6807 6 27 united united ADJ eblip-6807 6 28     SPACE eblip-6807 6 29 states state NOUN eblip-6807 6 30 . . PUNCT eblip-6807 6 31           SPACE eblip-6807 7 1 methods method NOUN eblip-6807 7 2     SPACE eblip-6807 7 3 – – PUNCT eblip-6807 7 4     SPACE eblip-6807 7 5 institutions institution NOUN eblip-6807 7 6     SPACE eblip-6807 7 7 that that PRON eblip-6807 7 8     SPACE eblip-6807 7 9 provided provide VERB eblip-6807 7 10     SPACE eblip-6807 7 11 data datum NOUN eblip-6807 7 12     SPACE eblip-6807 7 13 for for ADP eblip-6807 7 14     SPACE eblip-6807 7 15 both both DET eblip-6807 7 16     SPACE eblip-6807 7 17 the the DET eblip-6807 7 18     SPACE eblip-6807 7 19 national national ADJ eblip-6807 7 20     SPACE eblip-6807 7 21 center center NOUN eblip-6807 7 22     SPACE eblip-6807 7 23 for for ADP eblip-6807 7 24     SPACE eblip-6807 7 25 education education NOUN eblip-6807 7 26     SPACE eblip-6807 7 27 statistics statistic NOUN eblip-6807 7 28     SPACE eblip-6807 7 29 ( ( PUNCT eblip-6807 7 30 nces nces PROPN eblip-6807 7 31 ) ) PUNCT eblip-6807 7 32     SPACE eblip-6807 7 33 academic academic ADJ eblip-6807 7 34     SPACE eblip-6807 7 35 libraries library NOUN eblip-6807 7 36     SPACE eblip-6807 7 37 survey survey NOUN eblip-6807 7 38     SPACE eblip-6807 7 39 ( ( PUNCT eblip-6807 7 40 als al NOUN eblip-6807 7 41 ) ) PUNCT eblip-6807 7 42     SPACE eblip-6807 7 43 and and CCONJ eblip-6807 7 44     SPACE eblip-6807 7 45 the the DET eblip-6807 7 46     SPACE eblip-6807 7 47 nces nce NOUN eblip-6807 7 48     SPACE eblip-6807 7 49 integrated integrated ADJ eblip-6807 7 50     SPACE eblip-6807 7 51 postsecondary postsecondary ADJ eblip-6807 7 52     SPACE eblip-6807 7 53 education education NOUN eblip-6807 7 54     SPACE eblip-6807 7 55 data data PROPN eblip-6807 7 56     SPACE eblip-6807 7 57 service service NOUN eblip-6807 7 58     SPACE eblip-6807 7 59 ( ( PUNCT eblip-6807 7 60 ipeds iped NOUN eblip-6807 7 61 ) ) PUNCT eblip-6807 7 62     SPACE eblip-6807 7 63 survey survey NOUN eblip-6807 7 64     SPACE eblip-6807 7 65 series series NOUN eblip-6807 7 66     SPACE eblip-6807 7 67 in in ADP eblip-6807 7 68     SPACE eblip-6807 7 69 2004 2004 NUM eblip-6807 7 70     SPACE eblip-6807 7 71 were be AUX eblip-6807 7 72     SPACE eblip-6807 7 73 considered consider VERB eblip-6807 7 74     SPACE eblip-6807 7 75 for for ADP eblip-6807 7 76     SPACE eblip-6807 7 77 inclusion inclusion NOUN eblip-6807 7 78     SPACE eblip-6807 7 79 in in ADP eblip-6807 7 80     SPACE eblip-6807 7 81 this this DET eblip-6807 7 82     SPACE eblip-6807 7 83 study study NOUN eblip-6807 7 84 . . PUNCT eblip-6807 7 85     SPACE eblip-6807 8 1 of of ADP eblip-6807 8 2     SPACE eblip-6807 8 3 these these DET eblip-6807 8 4     SPACE eblip-6807 8 5 institutions institution NOUN eblip-6807 8 6 , , PUNCT eblip-6807 8 7     SPACE eblip-6807 8 8 only only ADV eblip-6807 8 9     SPACE eblip-6807 8 10 those those PRON eblip-6807 8 11     SPACE eblip-6807 8 12 with with ADP eblip-6807 8 13     SPACE eblip-6807 8 14 student student NOUN eblip-6807 8 15     SPACE eblip-6807 8 16 populations population NOUN eblip-6807 8 17     SPACE eblip-6807 8 18 over over ADP eblip-6807 8 19     SPACE eblip-6807 8 20 500 500 NUM eblip-6807 8 21     SPACE eblip-6807 8 22 and and CCONJ eblip-6807 8 23     SPACE eblip-6807 8 24 employing employ VERB eblip-6807 8 25     SPACE eblip-6807 8 26 more more ADJ eblip-6807 8 27     SPACE eblip-6807 8 28 than than ADP eblip-6807 8 29     SPACE eblip-6807 8 30 one one NUM eblip-6807 8 31     SPACE eblip-6807 8 32 librarian librarian NOUN eblip-6807 8 33     SPACE eblip-6807 8 34 were be AUX eblip-6807 8 35     SPACE eblip-6807 8 36 included include VERB eblip-6807 8 37 . . PUNCT eblip-6807 8 38     SPACE eblip-6807 9 1 the the DET eblip-6807 9 2     SPACE eblip-6807 9 3 study study NOUN eblip-6807 9 4     SPACE eblip-6807 9 5 did do AUX eblip-6807 9 6     SPACE eblip-6807 9 7 not not PART eblip-6807 9 8     SPACE eblip-6807 9 9 include include VERB eblip-6807 9 10     SPACE eblip-6807 9 11 specialized specialized ADJ eblip-6807 9 12     SPACE eblip-6807 9 13 libraries library NOUN eblip-6807 9 14     SPACE eblip-6807 9 15 at at ADP eblip-6807 9 16     SPACE eblip-6807 9 17 institutions institution NOUN eblip-6807 9 18     SPACE eblip-6807 9 19 where where SCONJ eblip-6807 9 20     SPACE eblip-6807 9 21 “ " PUNCT eblip-6807 9 22 most most ADJ eblip-6807 9 23     SPACE eblip-6807 9 24 of of ADP eblip-6807 9 25     SPACE eblip-6807 9 26 their their PRON eblip-6807 9 27     SPACE eblip-6807 9 28 degrees degree NOUN eblip-6807 9 29     SPACE eblip-6807 9 30 were be AUX eblip-6807 9 31     SPACE eblip-6807 9 32 awarded award VERB eblip-6807 9 33     SPACE eblip-6807 9 34 in in ADP eblip-6807 9 35     SPACE eblip-6807 9 36 a a DET eblip-6807 9 37     SPACE eblip-6807 9 38 single single ADJ eblip-6807 9 39     SPACE eblip-6807 9 40 area area NOUN eblip-6807 9 41 ” " PUNCT eblip-6807 9 42     SPACE eblip-6807 9 43 ( ( PUNCT eblip-6807 9 44 p. p. NOUN eblip-6807 9 45     SPACE eblip-6807 9 46 449 449 NUM eblip-6807 9 47 ) ) PUNCT eblip-6807 9 48 . . PUNCT eblip-6807 9 49     SPACE eblip-6807 10 1 the the DET eblip-6807 10 2     SPACE eblip-6807 10 3 institutions institution NOUN eblip-6807 10 4     SPACE eblip-6807 10 5 were be AUX eblip-6807 10 6     SPACE eblip-6807 10 7 categorized categorize VERB eblip-6807 10 8     SPACE eblip-6807 10 9 by by ADP eblip-6807 10 10     SPACE eblip-6807 10 11 type type NOUN eblip-6807 10 12     SPACE eblip-6807 10 13 derived derive VERB eblip-6807 10 14     SPACE eblip-6807 10 15 from from ADP eblip-6807 10 16     SPACE eblip-6807 10 17 data datum NOUN eblip-6807 10 18     SPACE eblip-6807 10 19 by by ADP eblip-6807 10 20     SPACE eblip-6807 10 21 carnegie carnegie NOUN eblip-6807 10 22     SPACE eblip-6807 10 23 and and CCONJ eblip-6807 10 24     SPACE eblip-6807 10 25 the the DET eblip-6807 10 26     SPACE eblip-6807 10 27 association association NOUN eblip-6807 10 28     SPACE eblip-6807 10 29 of of ADP eblip-6807 10 30     SPACE eblip-6807 10 31 research research NOUN eblip-6807 10 32     SPACE eblip-6807 10 33 libraries library NOUN eblip-6807 10 34 . . PUNCT eblip-6807 10 35     SPACE eblip-6807 11 1 the the DET eblip-6807 11 2     SPACE eblip-6807 11 3 final final ADJ eblip-6807 11 4     SPACE eblip-6807 11 5 categories category NOUN eblip-6807 11 6     SPACE eblip-6807 11 7 were be AUX eblip-6807 11 8 : : PUNCT eblip-6807 11 9     SPACE eblip-6807 11 10 arl arl PROPN eblip-6807 11 11 , , PUNCT eblip-6807 11 12     SPACE eblip-6807 11 13 doctoral doctoral PROPN eblip-6807 11 14     SPACE eblip-6807 11 15 non‐arl non‐arl PROPN eblip-6807 11 16 , , PUNCT eblip-6807 11 17     SPACE eblip-6807 11 18 masters master NOUN eblip-6807 11 19 , , PUNCT eblip-6807 11 20     SPACE eblip-6807 11 21 baccalaureate baccalaureate NOUN eblip-6807 11 22 , , PUNCT eblip-6807 11 23     SPACE eblip-6807 11 24 and and CCONJ eblip-6807 11 25     SPACE eblip-6807 11 26 associates associate NOUN eblip-6807 11 27 . . PUNCT eblip-6807 11 28     SPACE eblip-6807 12 1 governance governance NOUN eblip-6807 12 2     SPACE eblip-6807 12 3 was be AUX eblip-6807 12 4     SPACE eblip-6807 12 5 determined determine VERB eblip-6807 12 6     SPACE eblip-6807 12 7 by by ADP eblip-6807 12 8     SPACE eblip-6807 12 9 using use VERB eblip-6807 12 10     SPACE eblip-6807 12 11 information information NOUN eblip-6807 12 12     SPACE eblip-6807 12 13 from from ADP eblip-6807 12 14     SPACE eblip-6807 12 15 ipeds iped NOUN eblip-6807 12 16     SPACE eblip-6807 12 17 that that PRON eblip-6807 12 18     SPACE eblip-6807 12 19 classified classify VERB eblip-6807 12 20     SPACE eblip-6807 12 21 the the DET eblip-6807 12 22     SPACE eblip-6807 12 23 institutions institution NOUN eblip-6807 12 24     SPACE eblip-6807 12 25 as as ADP eblip-6807 12 26     SPACE eblip-6807 12 27 public public ADJ eblip-6807 12 28 , , PUNCT eblip-6807 12 29     SPACE eblip-6807 12 30 private private ADJ eblip-6807 12 31     SPACE eblip-6807 12 32 not‐for‐profit not‐for‐profit NOUN eblip-6807 12 33 , , PUNCT eblip-6807 12 34     SPACE eblip-6807 12 35 and and CCONJ eblip-6807 12 36     SPACE eblip-6807 12 37 private private ADJ eblip-6807 12 38     SPACE eblip-6807 12 39 for‐profit for‐profit NOUN eblip-6807 12 40 . . PUNCT eblip-6807 12 41     SPACE eblip-6807 12 42 unionization unionization NOUN eblip-6807 12 43     SPACE eblip-6807 12 44 status status NOUN eblip-6807 12 45     SPACE eblip-6807 12 46 was be AUX eblip-6807 12 47     SPACE eblip-6807 12 48 derived derive VERB eblip-6807 12 49     SPACE eblip-6807 12 50 from from ADP eblip-6807 12 51     SPACE eblip-6807 12 52 the the DET eblip-6807 12 53     SPACE eblip-6807 12 54 directory directory NOUN eblip-6807 12 55     SPACE eblip-6807 12 56 of of ADP eblip-6807 12 57     SPACE eblip-6807 12 58 faculty faculty NOUN eblip-6807 12 59     SPACE eblip-6807 12 60 contracts contract NOUN eblip-6807 12 61     SPACE eblip-6807 12 62 and and CCONJ eblip-6807 12 63     SPACE eblip-6807 12 64 bargaining bargaining NOUN eblip-6807 12 65     SPACE eblip-6807 12 66 agents agent NOUN eblip-6807 12 67     SPACE eblip-6807 12 68 in in ADP eblip-6807 12 69     SPACE eblip-6807 12 70 institutions institution NOUN eblip-6807 12 71     SPACE eblip-6807 12 72 of of ADP eblip-6807 12 73     SPACE eblip-6807 12 74 higher high ADJ eblip-6807 12 75     SPACE eblip-6807 12 76 education education NOUN eblip-6807 12 77 . . PUNCT eblip-6807 12 78     SPACE eblip-6807 13 1 after after ADP eblip-6807 13 2     SPACE eblip-6807 13 3 144 144 NUM eblip-6807 13 4 evidence evidence NOUN eblip-6807 13 5     SPACE eblip-6807 13 6 based base VERB eblip-6807 13 7     SPACE eblip-6807 13 8 library library NOUN eblip-6807 13 9     SPACE eblip-6807 13 10 and and CCONJ eblip-6807 13 11     SPACE eblip-6807 13 12 information information NOUN eblip-6807 13 13     SPACE eblip-6807 13 14 practice practice NOUN eblip-6807 13 15     SPACE eblip-6807 13 16 2010 2010 NUM eblip-6807 13 17 , , PUNCT eblip-6807 13 18     SPACE eblip-6807 13 19 5.1 5.1 NUM eblip-6807 13 20     SPACE eblip-6807 13 21 private private ADJ eblip-6807 13 22     SPACE eblip-6807 13 23 not‐for‐profit not‐for‐profit NOUN eblip-6807 13 24     SPACE eblip-6807 13 25 and and CCONJ eblip-6807 13 26     SPACE eblip-6807 13 27 private private ADJ eblip-6807 13 28     SPACE eblip-6807 13 29 for‐profit for‐profit NOUN eblip-6807 13 30     SPACE eblip-6807 13 31 classifications classification NOUN eblip-6807 13 32     SPACE eblip-6807 13 33 were be AUX eblip-6807 13 34     SPACE eblip-6807 13 35 collapsed collapse VERB eblip-6807 13 36     SPACE eblip-6807 13 37 into into ADP eblip-6807 13 38     SPACE eblip-6807 13 39 one one NUM eblip-6807 13 40     SPACE eblip-6807 13 41 category category NOUN eblip-6807 13 42 , , PUNCT eblip-6807 13 43     SPACE eblip-6807 13 44 governance governance NOUN eblip-6807 13 45     SPACE eblip-6807 13 46 and and CCONJ eblip-6807 13 47     SPACE eblip-6807 13 48 unionization unionization NOUN eblip-6807 13 49     SPACE eblip-6807 13 50 information information NOUN eblip-6807 13 51     SPACE eblip-6807 13 52 were be AUX eblip-6807 13 53     SPACE eblip-6807 13 54 combined combine VERB eblip-6807 13 55     SPACE eblip-6807 13 56 to to PART eblip-6807 13 57     SPACE eblip-6807 13 58 create create VERB eblip-6807 13 59     SPACE eblip-6807 13 60 the the DET eblip-6807 13 61     SPACE eblip-6807 13 62 final final ADJ eblip-6807 13 63     SPACE eblip-6807 13 64 governance governance NOUN eblip-6807 13 65     SPACE eblip-6807 13 66 categories category NOUN eblip-6807 13 67     SPACE eblip-6807 13 68 of of ADP eblip-6807 13 69 : : PUNCT eblip-6807 13 70     SPACE eblip-6807 13 71 private private ADJ eblip-6807 13 72 , , PUNCT eblip-6807 13 73     SPACE eblip-6807 13 74 public public NOUN eblip-6807 13 75     SPACE eblip-6807 13 76 nonunionized nonunionize VERB eblip-6807 13 77 , , PUNCT eblip-6807 13 78     SPACE eblip-6807 13 79 and and CCONJ eblip-6807 13 80     SPACE eblip-6807 13 81 public public NOUN eblip-6807 13 82     SPACE eblip-6807 13 83 unionized unionize VERB eblip-6807 13 84 . . PUNCT eblip-6807 13 85     SPACE eblip-6807 14 1 the the DET eblip-6807 14 2     SPACE eblip-6807 14 3 study study NOUN eblip-6807 14 4     SPACE eblip-6807 14 5 analyzed analyze VERB eblip-6807 14 6     SPACE eblip-6807 14 7 the the DET eblip-6807 14 8     SPACE eblip-6807 14 9 following follow VERB eblip-6807 14 10     SPACE eblip-6807 14 11 characteristics characteristic NOUN eblip-6807 14 12     SPACE eblip-6807 14 13 in in ADP eblip-6807 14 14     SPACE eblip-6807 14 15 terms term NOUN eblip-6807 14 16     SPACE eblip-6807 14 17 of of ADP eblip-6807 14 18     SPACE eblip-6807 14 19 institution institution NOUN eblip-6807 14 20     SPACE eblip-6807 14 21 type type NOUN eblip-6807 14 22 , , PUNCT eblip-6807 14 23     SPACE eblip-6807 14 24 governance governance NOUN eblip-6807 14 25 , , PUNCT eblip-6807 14 26     SPACE eblip-6807 14 27 and and CCONJ eblip-6807 14 28     SPACE eblip-6807 14 29 institution institution NOUN eblip-6807 14 30     SPACE eblip-6807 14 31 type type NOUN eblip-6807 14 32     SPACE eblip-6807 14 33 and and CCONJ eblip-6807 14 34     SPACE eblip-6807 14 35 governance governance NOUN eblip-6807 14 36     SPACE eblip-6807 14 37 interaction interaction NOUN eblip-6807 14 38 : : PUNCT eblip-6807 14 39     SPACE eblip-6807 14 40 ratio ratio NOUN eblip-6807 14 41     SPACE eblip-6807 14 42 of of ADP eblip-6807 14 43     SPACE eblip-6807 14 44 students student NOUN eblip-6807 14 45     SPACE eblip-6807 14 46 to to ADP eblip-6807 14 47     SPACE eblip-6807 14 48 librarians librarian NOUN eblip-6807 14 49 , , PUNCT eblip-6807 14 50     SPACE eblip-6807 14 51 ratio ratio NOUN eblip-6807 14 52     SPACE eblip-6807 14 53 of of ADP eblip-6807 14 54     SPACE eblip-6807 14 55 library library NOUN eblip-6807 14 56     SPACE eblip-6807 14 57 expenditures expenditure NOUN eblip-6807 14 58     SPACE eblip-6807 14 59 to to ADP eblip-6807 14 60     SPACE eblip-6807 14 61 institutional institutional ADJ eblip-6807 14 62     SPACE eblip-6807 14 63 budget budget NOUN eblip-6807 14 64     SPACE eblip-6807 14 65 expenditures expenditure NOUN eblip-6807 14 66 , , PUNCT eblip-6807 14 67     SPACE eblip-6807 14 68 average average ADJ eblip-6807 14 69     SPACE eblip-6807 14 70 librarian librarian ADJ eblip-6807 14 71     SPACE eblip-6807 14 72 salary salary NOUN eblip-6807 14 73 , , PUNCT eblip-6807 14 74     SPACE eblip-6807 14 75 percentage percentage NOUN eblip-6807 14 76     SPACE eblip-6807 14 77 of of ADP eblip-6807 14 78     SPACE eblip-6807 14 79 staff staff NOUN eblip-6807 14 80     SPACE eblip-6807 14 81 who who PRON eblip-6807 14 82     SPACE eblip-6807 14 83 were be AUX eblip-6807 14 84     SPACE eblip-6807 14 85 librarians librarian NOUN eblip-6807 14 86 , , PUNCT eblip-6807 14 87     SPACE eblip-6807 14 88 librarian librarian ADJ eblip-6807 14 89     SPACE eblip-6807 14 90 salaries salary NOUN eblip-6807 14 91     SPACE eblip-6807 14 92 as as ADP eblip-6807 14 93     SPACE eblip-6807 14 94 a a DET eblip-6807 14 95     SPACE eblip-6807 14 96 percentage percentage NOUN eblip-6807 14 97     SPACE eblip-6807 14 98 of of ADP eblip-6807 14 99     SPACE eblip-6807 14 100 staff staff NOUN eblip-6807 14 101     SPACE eblip-6807 14 102 salaries salary NOUN eblip-6807 14 103 , , PUNCT eblip-6807 14 104     SPACE eblip-6807 14 105 and and CCONJ eblip-6807 14 106     SPACE eblip-6807 14 107 percentage percentage NOUN eblip-6807 14 108     SPACE eblip-6807 14 109 of of ADP eblip-6807 14 110     SPACE eblip-6807 14 111 the the DET eblip-6807 14 112     SPACE eblip-6807 14 113 library library NOUN eblip-6807 14 114     SPACE eblip-6807 14 115 budget budget NOUN eblip-6807 14 116     SPACE eblip-6807 14 117 spent spend VERB eblip-6807 14 118     SPACE eblip-6807 14 119 on on ADP eblip-6807 14 120     SPACE eblip-6807 14 121 staff staff NOUN eblip-6807 14 122     SPACE eblip-6807 14 123 salaries salary NOUN eblip-6807 14 124 . . PUNCT eblip-6807 14 125           SPACE eblip-6807 15 1 main main ADJ eblip-6807 15 2     SPACE eblip-6807 15 3 results result NOUN eblip-6807 15 4     SPACE eblip-6807 15 5 – – PUNCT eblip-6807 15 6     SPACE eblip-6807 15 7 analysis analysis NOUN eblip-6807 15 8     SPACE eblip-6807 15 9 revealed reveal VERB eblip-6807 15 10     SPACE eblip-6807 15 11 statistically statistically ADV eblip-6807 15 12     SPACE eblip-6807 15 13 significant significant ADJ eblip-6807 15 14     SPACE eblip-6807 15 15 differences difference NOUN eblip-6807 15 16     SPACE eblip-6807 15 17 ( ( PUNCT eblip-6807 15 18 p p X eblip-6807 15 19 < < X eblip-6807 15 20     SPACE eblip-6807 15 21 .05 .05 NUM eblip-6807 15 22 ) ) PUNCT eblip-6807 15 23     SPACE eblip-6807 15 24 between between ADP eblip-6807 15 25     SPACE eblip-6807 15 26 governance governance NOUN eblip-6807 15 27     SPACE eblip-6807 15 28 and and CCONJ eblip-6807 15 29     SPACE eblip-6807 15 30 student‐librarian student‐librarian ADJ eblip-6807 15 31     SPACE eblip-6807 15 32 ratio ratio NOUN eblip-6807 15 33     SPACE eblip-6807 15 34 and and CCONJ eblip-6807 15 35     SPACE eblip-6807 15 36 between between ADP eblip-6807 15 37     SPACE eblip-6807 15 38 governance governance NOUN eblip-6807 15 39     SPACE eblip-6807 15 40 and and CCONJ eblip-6807 15 41     SPACE eblip-6807 15 42 percentage percentage NOUN eblip-6807 15 43     SPACE eblip-6807 15 44 of of ADP eblip-6807 15 45     SPACE eblip-6807 15 46 library library NOUN eblip-6807 15 47     SPACE eblip-6807 15 48 budget budget NOUN eblip-6807 15 49     SPACE eblip-6807 15 50 spent spend VERB eblip-6807 15 51     SPACE eblip-6807 15 52 on on ADP eblip-6807 15 53     SPACE eblip-6807 15 54 staff staff NOUN eblip-6807 15 55     SPACE eblip-6807 15 56 salaries salary NOUN eblip-6807 15 57 . . PUNCT eblip-6807 15 58     SPACE eblip-6807 16 1 no no DET eblip-6807 16 2     SPACE eblip-6807 16 3 consistently consistently ADV eblip-6807 16 4     SPACE eblip-6807 16 5 beneficial beneficial ADJ eblip-6807 16 6     SPACE eblip-6807 16 7 relationship relationship NOUN eblip-6807 16 8     SPACE eblip-6807 16 9 between between ADP eblip-6807 16 10     SPACE eblip-6807 16 11 governance governance NOUN eblip-6807 16 12     SPACE eblip-6807 16 13 and and CCONJ eblip-6807 16 14     SPACE eblip-6807 16 15 student‐librarian student‐librarian ADJ eblip-6807 16 16     SPACE eblip-6807 16 17 ratio ratio NOUN eblip-6807 16 18     SPACE eblip-6807 16 19 was be AUX eblip-6807 16 20     SPACE eblip-6807 16 21 determined determine VERB eblip-6807 16 22 . . PUNCT eblip-6807 16 23     SPACE eblip-6807 17 1 a a DET eblip-6807 17 2     SPACE eblip-6807 17 3 consistently consistently ADV eblip-6807 17 4     SPACE eblip-6807 17 5 positive positive ADJ eblip-6807 17 6     SPACE eblip-6807 17 7 relationship relationship NOUN eblip-6807 17 8     SPACE eblip-6807 17 9 was be AUX eblip-6807 17 10     SPACE eblip-6807 17 11 found find VERB eblip-6807 17 12     SPACE eblip-6807 17 13 between between ADP eblip-6807 17 14     SPACE eblip-6807 17 15 governance governance NOUN eblip-6807 17 16     SPACE eblip-6807 17 17 and and CCONJ eblip-6807 17 18     SPACE eblip-6807 17 19 percent percent NOUN eblip-6807 17 20     SPACE eblip-6807 17 21 of of ADP eblip-6807 17 22     SPACE eblip-6807 17 23 the the DET eblip-6807 17 24     SPACE eblip-6807 17 25 library library NOUN eblip-6807 17 26     SPACE eblip-6807 17 27 budget budget NOUN eblip-6807 17 28     SPACE eblip-6807 17 29 spent spend VERB eblip-6807 17 30     SPACE eblip-6807 17 31 on on ADP eblip-6807 17 32     SPACE eblip-6807 17 33 librarian librarian ADJ eblip-6807 17 34     SPACE eblip-6807 17 35 salaries salary NOUN eblip-6807 17 36 ; ; PUNCT eblip-6807 17 37     SPACE eblip-6807 17 38 all all DET eblip-6807 17 39     SPACE eblip-6807 17 40 public public ADJ eblip-6807 17 41     SPACE eblip-6807 17 42 unionized unionize VERB eblip-6807 17 43     SPACE eblip-6807 17 44 institution institution NOUN eblip-6807 17 45     SPACE eblip-6807 17 46 types type NOUN eblip-6807 17 47     SPACE eblip-6807 17 48 had have VERB eblip-6807 17 49     SPACE eblip-6807 17 50 higher high ADJ eblip-6807 17 51     SPACE eblip-6807 17 52 percentages percentage NOUN eblip-6807 17 53     SPACE eblip-6807 17 54 of of ADP eblip-6807 17 55     SPACE eblip-6807 17 56 the the DET eblip-6807 17 57     SPACE eblip-6807 17 58 library library NOUN eblip-6807 17 59     SPACE eblip-6807 17 60 budget budget NOUN eblip-6807 17 61     SPACE eblip-6807 17 62 devoted devote VERB eblip-6807 17 63     SPACE eblip-6807 17 64 to to ADP eblip-6807 17 65     SPACE eblip-6807 17 66 librarian librarian ADJ eblip-6807 17 67     SPACE eblip-6807 17 68 salaries salary NOUN eblip-6807 17 69     SPACE eblip-6807 17 70 than than ADP eblip-6807 17 71     SPACE eblip-6807 17 72 private private ADJ eblip-6807 17 73     SPACE eblip-6807 17 74 and and CCONJ eblip-6807 17 75     SPACE eblip-6807 17 76 public public ADJ eblip-6807 17 77     SPACE eblip-6807 17 78 nonunionized nonunionized ADJ eblip-6807 17 79     SPACE eblip-6807 17 80 institutions institution NOUN eblip-6807 17 81 . . PUNCT eblip-6807 17 82     SPACE eblip-6807 18 1 all all DET eblip-6807 18 2     SPACE eblip-6807 18 3 five five NUM eblip-6807 18 4     SPACE eblip-6807 18 5 dependent dependent ADJ eblip-6807 18 6     SPACE eblip-6807 18 7 variables variable NOUN eblip-6807 18 8     SPACE eblip-6807 18 9 showed show VERB eblip-6807 18 10     SPACE eblip-6807 18 11 statistically statistically ADV eblip-6807 18 12     SPACE eblip-6807 18 13 significant significant ADJ eblip-6807 18 14     SPACE eblip-6807 18 15 differences difference NOUN eblip-6807 18 16     SPACE eblip-6807 18 17 ( ( PUNCT eblip-6807 18 18 p p X eblip-6807 18 19 < < X eblip-6807 18 20     SPACE eblip-6807 18 21 .05 .05 NUM eblip-6807 18 22 ) ) PUNCT eblip-6807 18 23     SPACE eblip-6807 18 24 when when SCONJ eblip-6807 18 25     SPACE eblip-6807 18 26 analyzed analyze VERB eblip-6807 18 27     SPACE eblip-6807 18 28 by by ADP eblip-6807 18 29     SPACE eblip-6807 18 30 institution institution NOUN eblip-6807 18 31     SPACE eblip-6807 18 32 type type NOUN eblip-6807 18 33 . . PUNCT eblip-6807 18 34     SPACE eblip-6807 18 35 analysis analysis NOUN eblip-6807 18 36     SPACE eblip-6807 18 37 by by ADP eblip-6807 18 38     SPACE eblip-6807 18 39 institution institution NOUN eblip-6807 18 40     SPACE eblip-6807 18 41 type type NOUN eblip-6807 18 42     SPACE eblip-6807 18 43 and and CCONJ eblip-6807 18 44     SPACE eblip-6807 18 45 governance governance NOUN eblip-6807 18 46     SPACE eblip-6807 18 47 interaction interaction NOUN eblip-6807 18 48     SPACE eblip-6807 18 49 found find VERB eblip-6807 18 50     SPACE eblip-6807 18 51 statistically statistically ADV eblip-6807 18 52     SPACE eblip-6807 18 53 significant significant ADJ eblip-6807 18 54     SPACE eblip-6807 18 55 differences difference NOUN eblip-6807 18 56     SPACE eblip-6807 18 57 ( ( PUNCT eblip-6807 18 58 p p X eblip-6807 18 59 < < X eblip-6807 18 60     SPACE eblip-6807 18 61 .05 .05 NUM eblip-6807 18 62 ) ) PUNCT eblip-6807 18 63     SPACE eblip-6807 18 64 for for ADP eblip-6807 18 65     SPACE eblip-6807 18 66 student‐ student‐ PROPN eblip-6807 18 67 librarian librarian PROPN eblip-6807 18 68     SPACE eblip-6807 18 69 ratios ratio NOUN eblip-6807 18 70 , , PUNCT eblip-6807 18 71     SPACE eblip-6807 18 72 librarian librarian ADJ eblip-6807 18 73     SPACE eblip-6807 18 74 salary salary NOUN eblip-6807 18 75 , , PUNCT eblip-6807 18 76     SPACE eblip-6807 18 77 and and CCONJ eblip-6807 18 78     SPACE eblip-6807 18 79 percentage percentage NOUN eblip-6807 18 80     SPACE eblip-6807 18 81 of of ADP eblip-6807 18 82     SPACE eblip-6807 18 83 library library NOUN eblip-6807 18 84     SPACE eblip-6807 18 85 budget budget NOUN eblip-6807 18 86     SPACE eblip-6807 18 87 devoted devote VERB eblip-6807 18 88     SPACE eblip-6807 18 89 to to PART eblip-6807 18 90     SPACE eblip-6807 18 91 staff staff NOUN eblip-6807 18 92     SPACE eblip-6807 18 93 salaries salary NOUN eblip-6807 18 94 . . PUNCT eblip-6807 18 95     SPACE eblip-6807 19 1 strong strong ADJ eblip-6807 19 2     SPACE eblip-6807 19 3 r2 r2 PROPN eblip-6807 19 4     SPACE eblip-6807 19 5 values value NOUN eblip-6807 19 6     SPACE eblip-6807 19 7 were be AUX eblip-6807 19 8     SPACE eblip-6807 19 9 determined determine VERB eblip-6807 19 10     SPACE eblip-6807 19 11 for for ADP eblip-6807 19 12     SPACE eblip-6807 19 13 the the DET eblip-6807 19 14     SPACE eblip-6807 19 15 dependent dependent ADJ eblip-6807 19 16     SPACE eblip-6807 19 17 variables variable NOUN eblip-6807 19 18     SPACE eblip-6807 19 19 of of ADP eblip-6807 19 20 : : PUNCT eblip-6807 19 21     SPACE eblip-6807 19 22 staff staff NOUN eblip-6807 19 23     SPACE eblip-6807 19 24 salaries salary NOUN eblip-6807 19 25     SPACE eblip-6807 19 26 as as ADP eblip-6807 19 27     SPACE eblip-6807 19 28 a a DET eblip-6807 19 29     SPACE eblip-6807 19 30 proportion proportion NOUN eblip-6807 19 31     SPACE eblip-6807 19 32 of of ADP eblip-6807 19 33     SPACE eblip-6807 19 34 library library NOUN eblip-6807 19 35     SPACE eblip-6807 19 36 budget budget NOUN eblip-6807 19 37     SPACE eblip-6807 19 38 ( ( PUNCT eblip-6807 19 39 .51 .51 NUM eblip-6807 19 40 ) ) PUNCT eblip-6807 19 41     SPACE eblip-6807 19 42 and and CCONJ eblip-6807 19 43     SPACE eblip-6807 19 44 student‐ student‐ PROPN eblip-6807 19 45 librarian librarian PROPN eblip-6807 19 46     SPACE eblip-6807 19 47 ratio ratio NOUN eblip-6807 19 48     SPACE eblip-6807 19 49 ( ( PUNCT eblip-6807 19 50 .34 .34 NUM eblip-6807 19 51 ) ) PUNCT eblip-6807 19 52 . . PUNCT eblip-6807 19 53             SPACE eblip-6807 20 1 conclusion conclusion NOUN eblip-6807 20 2     SPACE eblip-6807 20 3 – – PUNCT eblip-6807 20 4     SPACE eblip-6807 20 5 based base VERB eblip-6807 20 6     SPACE eblip-6807 20 7 on on ADP eblip-6807 20 8     SPACE eblip-6807 20 9 the the DET eblip-6807 20 10     SPACE eblip-6807 20 11 results result NOUN eblip-6807 20 12 , , PUNCT eblip-6807 20 13     SPACE eblip-6807 20 14 the the DET eblip-6807 20 15     SPACE eblip-6807 20 16 author author NOUN eblip-6807 20 17     SPACE eblip-6807 20 18 stated state VERB eblip-6807 20 19     SPACE eblip-6807 20 20 that that SCONJ eblip-6807 20 21     SPACE eblip-6807 20 22 unionization unionization NOUN eblip-6807 20 23     SPACE eblip-6807 20 24 appears appear VERB eblip-6807 20 25     SPACE eblip-6807 20 26 to to PART eblip-6807 20 27     SPACE eblip-6807 20 28 have have VERB eblip-6807 20 29     SPACE eblip-6807 20 30 positive positive ADJ eblip-6807 20 31     SPACE eblip-6807 20 32 or or CCONJ eblip-6807 20 33     SPACE eblip-6807 20 34 neutral neutral ADJ eblip-6807 20 35     SPACE eblip-6807 20 36 benefits benefit NOUN eblip-6807 20 37     SPACE eblip-6807 20 38 for for ADP eblip-6807 20 39     SPACE eblip-6807 20 40 the the DET eblip-6807 20 41     SPACE eblip-6807 20 42 library library NOUN eblip-6807 20 43 , , PUNCT eblip-6807 20 44     SPACE eblip-6807 20 45 librarians librarian NOUN eblip-6807 20 46 , , PUNCT eblip-6807 20 47     SPACE eblip-6807 20 48 and and CCONJ eblip-6807 20 49     SPACE eblip-6807 20 50 students student NOUN eblip-6807 20 51 , , PUNCT eblip-6807 20 52     SPACE eblip-6807 20 53 regardless regardless ADV eblip-6807 20 54     SPACE eblip-6807 20 55 of of ADP eblip-6807 20 56     SPACE eblip-6807 20 57 institutional institutional ADJ eblip-6807 20 58     SPACE eblip-6807 20 59 type type NOUN eblip-6807 20 60 . . PUNCT eblip-6807 20 61     SPACE eblip-6807 20 62 further far ADV eblip-6807 20 63     SPACE eblip-6807 20 64 quantitative quantitative ADJ eblip-6807 20 65     SPACE eblip-6807 20 66 and and CCONJ eblip-6807 20 67     SPACE eblip-6807 20 68 qualitative qualitative NOUN eblip-6807 20 69     SPACE eblip-6807 20 70 research research NOUN eblip-6807 20 71     SPACE eblip-6807 20 72 is be AUX eblip-6807 20 73     SPACE eblip-6807 20 74 needed need VERB eblip-6807 20 75     SPACE eblip-6807 20 76 to to PART eblip-6807 20 77     SPACE eblip-6807 20 78 analyze analyze VERB eblip-6807 20 79     SPACE eblip-6807 20 80 the the DET eblip-6807 20 81     SPACE eblip-6807 20 82 effects effect NOUN eblip-6807 20 83     SPACE eblip-6807 20 84 of of ADP eblip-6807 20 85     SPACE eblip-6807 20 86 unionization unionization NOUN eblip-6807 20 87     SPACE eblip-6807 20 88 on on ADP eblip-6807 20 89     SPACE eblip-6807 20 90 library library NOUN eblip-6807 20 91     SPACE eblip-6807 20 92 quality quality NOUN eblip-6807 20 93 . . PUNCT eblip-6807 20 94         SPACE eblip-6807 21 1 commentary commentary NOUN eblip-6807 21 2         SPACE eblip-6807 21 3 this this DET eblip-6807 21 4     SPACE eblip-6807 21 5 study study NOUN eblip-6807 21 6     SPACE eblip-6807 21 7 looks look VERB eblip-6807 21 8     SPACE eblip-6807 21 9 at at ADP eblip-6807 21 10     SPACE eblip-6807 21 11 whether whether SCONJ eblip-6807 21 12     SPACE eblip-6807 21 13 quantitative quantitative ADJ eblip-6807 21 14     SPACE eblip-6807 21 15 “ " PUNCT eblip-6807 21 16 benefits benefit NOUN eblip-6807 21 17 ” " PUNCT eblip-6807 21 18     SPACE eblip-6807 21 19 are be AUX eblip-6807 21 20     SPACE eblip-6807 21 21 associated associate VERB eblip-6807 21 22     SPACE eblip-6807 21 23 with with ADP eblip-6807 21 24     SPACE eblip-6807 21 25 unionization unionization NOUN eblip-6807 21 26     SPACE eblip-6807 21 27 in in ADP eblip-6807 21 28     SPACE eblip-6807 21 29 u.s u.s PROPN eblip-6807 21 30 . . PROPN eblip-6807 21 31     SPACE eblip-6807 21 32 academic academic ADJ eblip-6807 21 33     SPACE eblip-6807 21 34 libraries library NOUN eblip-6807 21 35 . . PUNCT eblip-6807 21 36     SPACE eblip-6807 22 1 it it PRON eblip-6807 22 2     SPACE eblip-6807 22 3 will will AUX eblip-6807 22 4     SPACE eblip-6807 22 5 be be AUX eblip-6807 22 6     SPACE eblip-6807 22 7 of of ADP eblip-6807 22 8     SPACE eblip-6807 22 9 interest interest NOUN eblip-6807 22 10     SPACE eblip-6807 22 11 to to ADP eblip-6807 22 12     SPACE eblip-6807 22 13 academic academic ADJ eblip-6807 22 14     SPACE eblip-6807 22 15 librarians librarian NOUN eblip-6807 22 16 , , PUNCT eblip-6807 22 17     SPACE eblip-6807 22 18 especially especially ADV eblip-6807 22 19     SPACE eblip-6807 22 20 those those PRON eblip-6807 22 21     SPACE eblip-6807 22 22 who who PRON eblip-6807 22 23     SPACE eblip-6807 22 24 are be AUX eblip-6807 22 25     SPACE eblip-6807 22 26 interested interested ADJ eblip-6807 22 27     SPACE eblip-6807 22 28 in in ADP eblip-6807 22 29     SPACE eblip-6807 22 30 comparing compare VERB eblip-6807 22 31     SPACE eblip-6807 22 32 the the DET eblip-6807 22 33     SPACE eblip-6807 22 34 benefits benefit NOUN eblip-6807 22 35     SPACE eblip-6807 22 36 of of ADP eblip-6807 22 37     SPACE eblip-6807 22 38 working work VERB eblip-6807 22 39     SPACE eblip-6807 22 40 at at ADP eblip-6807 22 41     SPACE eblip-6807 22 42 a a DET eblip-6807 22 43     SPACE eblip-6807 22 44 different different ADJ eblip-6807 22 45     SPACE eblip-6807 22 46 institution institution NOUN eblip-6807 22 47     SPACE eblip-6807 22 48 or or CCONJ eblip-6807 22 49     SPACE eblip-6807 22 50 under under ADP eblip-6807 22 51     SPACE eblip-6807 22 52 a a DET eblip-6807 22 53     SPACE eblip-6807 22 54 different different ADJ eblip-6807 22 55     SPACE eblip-6807 22 56 governance governance NOUN eblip-6807 22 57     SPACE eblip-6807 22 58 structure structure NOUN eblip-6807 22 59 . . PUNCT eblip-6807 22 60     SPACE eblip-6807 23 1 the the DET eblip-6807 23 2     SPACE eblip-6807 23 3 author author NOUN eblip-6807 23 4     SPACE eblip-6807 23 5 clearly clearly ADV eblip-6807 23 6     SPACE eblip-6807 23 7 defined define VERB eblip-6807 23 8     SPACE eblip-6807 23 9 the the DET eblip-6807 23 10     SPACE eblip-6807 23 11 context context NOUN eblip-6807 23 12     SPACE eblip-6807 23 13 of of ADP eblip-6807 23 14     SPACE eblip-6807 23 15 the the DET eblip-6807 23 16     SPACE eblip-6807 23 17 study study NOUN eblip-6807 23 18     SPACE eblip-6807 23 19 with with ADP eblip-6807 23 20     SPACE eblip-6807 23 21 an an DET eblip-6807 23 22     SPACE eblip-6807 23 23 overview overview NOUN eblip-6807 23 24     SPACE eblip-6807 23 25 of of ADP eblip-6807 23 26     SPACE eblip-6807 23 27 the the DET eblip-6807 23 28     SPACE eblip-6807 23 29 previous previous ADJ eblip-6807 23 30     SPACE eblip-6807 23 31 research research NOUN eblip-6807 23 32     SPACE eblip-6807 23 33 on on ADP eblip-6807 23 34     SPACE eblip-6807 23 35 unionization unionization NOUN eblip-6807 23 36     SPACE eblip-6807 23 37 and and CCONJ eblip-6807 23 38     SPACE eblip-6807 23 39 libraries library NOUN eblip-6807 23 40 . . PUNCT eblip-6807 23 41     SPACE eblip-6807 24 1 while while SCONJ eblip-6807 24 2     SPACE eblip-6807 24 3 this this DET eblip-6807 24 4     SPACE eblip-6807 24 5 study study NOUN eblip-6807 24 6     SPACE eblip-6807 24 7 does do AUX eblip-6807 24 8     SPACE eblip-6807 24 9 add add VERB eblip-6807 24 10     SPACE eblip-6807 24 11 to to ADP eblip-6807 24 12     SPACE eblip-6807 24 13 the the DET eblip-6807 24 14     SPACE eblip-6807 24 15 understanding understanding NOUN eblip-6807 24 16     SPACE eblip-6807 24 17 of of ADP eblip-6807 24 18     SPACE eblip-6807 24 19 unionization unionization NOUN eblip-6807 24 20     SPACE eblip-6807 24 21 of of ADP eblip-6807 24 22     SPACE eblip-6807 24 23 academic academic ADJ eblip-6807 24 24     SPACE eblip-6807 24 25 libraries library NOUN eblip-6807 24 26 , , PUNCT eblip-6807 24 27     SPACE eblip-6807 24 28 the the DET eblip-6807 24 29     SPACE eblip-6807 24 30 stated state VERB eblip-6807 24 31     SPACE eblip-6807 24 32 results result NOUN eblip-6807 24 33     SPACE eblip-6807 24 34 do do AUX eblip-6807 24 35     SPACE eblip-6807 24 36 not not PART eblip-6807 24 37     SPACE eblip-6807 24 38 support support VERB eblip-6807 24 39     SPACE eblip-6807 24 40 the the DET eblip-6807 24 41     SPACE eblip-6807 24 42 conclusions conclusion NOUN eblip-6807 24 43     SPACE eblip-6807 24 44 of of ADP eblip-6807 24 45     SPACE eblip-6807 24 46 this this DET eblip-6807 24 47     SPACE eblip-6807 24 48 article article NOUN eblip-6807 24 49 . . PUNCT eblip-6807 24 50           SPACE eblip-6807 25 1 the the DET eblip-6807 25 2     SPACE eblip-6807 25 3 author author NOUN eblip-6807 25 4     SPACE eblip-6807 25 5 clearly clearly ADV eblip-6807 25 6     SPACE eblip-6807 25 7 explained explain VERB eblip-6807 25 8     SPACE eblip-6807 25 9 the the DET eblip-6807 25 10     SPACE eblip-6807 25 11 methodology methodology NOUN eblip-6807 25 12 , , PUNCT eblip-6807 25 13     SPACE eblip-6807 25 14 described describe VERB eblip-6807 25 15     SPACE eblip-6807 25 16 the the DET eblip-6807 25 17     SPACE eblip-6807 25 18 variables variable NOUN eblip-6807 25 19     SPACE eblip-6807 25 20 analyzed analyze VERB eblip-6807 25 21     SPACE eblip-6807 25 22 as as ADV eblip-6807 25 23     SPACE eblip-6807 25 24 well well ADV eblip-6807 25 25     SPACE eblip-6807 25 26 as as ADP eblip-6807 25 27     SPACE eblip-6807 25 28 the the DET eblip-6807 25 29     SPACE eblip-6807 25 30 confounding confound VERB eblip-6807 25 31     SPACE eblip-6807 25 32 variables variable NOUN eblip-6807 25 33 , , PUNCT eblip-6807 25 34     SPACE eblip-6807 25 35 and and CCONJ eblip-6807 25 36     SPACE eblip-6807 25 37 used use VERB eblip-6807 25 38     SPACE eblip-6807 25 39 appropriate appropriate ADJ eblip-6807 25 40     SPACE eblip-6807 25 41 descriptive descriptive ADJ eblip-6807 25 42     SPACE eblip-6807 25 43 and and CCONJ eblip-6807 25 44     SPACE eblip-6807 25 45 inferential inferential ADJ eblip-6807 25 46     SPACE eblip-6807 25 47 statistics statistic NOUN eblip-6807 25 48     SPACE eblip-6807 25 49 for for ADP eblip-6807 25 50     SPACE eblip-6807 25 51 the the DET eblip-6807 25 52     SPACE eblip-6807 25 53 variables variable NOUN eblip-6807 25 54     SPACE eblip-6807 25 55 analyzed analyze VERB eblip-6807 25 56 . . PUNCT eblip-6807 25 57     SPACE eblip-6807 26 1 however however ADV eblip-6807 26 2 , , PUNCT eblip-6807 26 3     SPACE eblip-6807 26 4 one one NUM eblip-6807 26 5     SPACE eblip-6807 26 6 of of ADP eblip-6807 26 7     SPACE eblip-6807 26 8 the the DET eblip-6807 26 9     SPACE eblip-6807 26 10 variables variable NOUN eblip-6807 26 11 , , PUNCT eblip-6807 26 12     SPACE eblip-6807 26 13 librarian librarian ADJ eblip-6807 26 14     SPACE eblip-6807 26 15 salaries salary NOUN eblip-6807 26 16     SPACE eblip-6807 26 17 as as ADP eblip-6807 26 18     SPACE eblip-6807 26 19 percentage percentage NOUN eblip-6807 26 20     SPACE eblip-6807 26 21 of of ADP eblip-6807 26 22     SPACE eblip-6807 26 23 staff staff NOUN eblip-6807 26 24     SPACE eblip-6807 26 25 salaries salary NOUN eblip-6807 26 26 , , PUNCT eblip-6807 26 27     SPACE eblip-6807 26 28 was be AUX eblip-6807 26 29     SPACE eblip-6807 26 30 never never ADV eblip-6807 26 31     SPACE eblip-6807 26 32 analyzed analyze VERB eblip-6807 26 33 . . PUNCT eblip-6807 26 34     SPACE eblip-6807 27 1 data datum NOUN eblip-6807 27 2     SPACE eblip-6807 27 3 from from ADP eblip-6807 27 4     SPACE eblip-6807 27 5 either either PRON eblip-6807 27 6     SPACE eblip-6807 27 7 als als NOUN eblip-6807 27 8     SPACE eblip-6807 27 9 or or CCONJ eblip-6807 27 10     SPACE eblip-6807 27 11 ipeds iped NOUN eblip-6807 27 12     SPACE eblip-6807 27 13 was be AUX eblip-6807 27 14     SPACE eblip-6807 27 15 lacking lack VERB eblip-6807 27 16     SPACE eblip-6807 27 17 for for ADP eblip-6807 27 18     SPACE eblip-6807 27 19 some some PRON eblip-6807 27 20     SPACE eblip-6807 27 21 of of ADP eblip-6807 27 22     SPACE eblip-6807 27 23 the the DET eblip-6807 27 24     SPACE eblip-6807 27 25 institutions institution NOUN eblip-6807 27 26     SPACE eblip-6807 27 27 for for ADP eblip-6807 27 28     SPACE eblip-6807 27 29 three three NUM eblip-6807 27 30     SPACE eblip-6807 27 31 of of ADP eblip-6807 27 32     SPACE eblip-6807 27 33 the the DET eblip-6807 27 34     SPACE eblip-6807 27 35 variables variable NOUN eblip-6807 27 36     SPACE eblip-6807 27 37 analyzed analyze VERB eblip-6807 27 38 . . PUNCT eblip-6807 27 39     SPACE eblip-6807 28 1 it it PRON eblip-6807 28 2     SPACE eblip-6807 28 3 is be AUX eblip-6807 28 4     SPACE eblip-6807 28 5 impossible impossible ADJ eblip-6807 28 6     SPACE eblip-6807 28 7 to to PART eblip-6807 28 8     SPACE eblip-6807 28 9 determine determine VERB eblip-6807 28 10     SPACE eblip-6807 28 11 the the DET eblip-6807 28 12     SPACE eblip-6807 28 13 effect effect NOUN eblip-6807 28 14     SPACE eblip-6807 28 15 on on ADP eblip-6807 28 16     SPACE eblip-6807 28 17 the the DET eblip-6807 28 18     SPACE eblip-6807 28 19 analyses analysis NOUN eblip-6807 28 20     SPACE eblip-6807 28 21 as as SCONJ eblip-6807 28 22     SPACE eblip-6807 28 23 there there PRON eblip-6807 28 24     SPACE eblip-6807 28 25 were be AUX eblip-6807 28 26     SPACE eblip-6807 28 27 no no DET eblip-6807 28 28     SPACE eblip-6807 28 29 further further ADJ eblip-6807 28 30     SPACE eblip-6807 28 31 explanations explanation NOUN eblip-6807 28 32     SPACE eblip-6807 28 33 on on ADP eblip-6807 28 34     SPACE eblip-6807 28 35 which which DET eblip-6807 28 36     SPACE eblip-6807 28 37 categories category NOUN eblip-6807 28 38     SPACE eblip-6807 28 39 the the DET eblip-6807 28 40     SPACE eblip-6807 28 41 lack lack NOUN eblip-6807 28 42     SPACE eblip-6807 28 43 of of ADP eblip-6807 28 44     SPACE eblip-6807 28 45 data datum NOUN eblip-6807 28 46     SPACE eblip-6807 28 47 affected affect VERB eblip-6807 28 48 . . PUNCT eblip-6807 28 49           SPACE eblip-6807 28 50 while while SCONJ eblip-6807 28 51     SPACE eblip-6807 28 52 the the DET eblip-6807 28 53     SPACE eblip-6807 28 54 results result NOUN eblip-6807 28 55     SPACE eblip-6807 28 56 do do AUX eblip-6807 28 57     SPACE eblip-6807 28 58 support support VERB eblip-6807 28 59     SPACE eblip-6807 28 60 the the DET eblip-6807 28 61     SPACE eblip-6807 28 62 conclusion conclusion NOUN eblip-6807 28 63     SPACE eblip-6807 28 64 that that SCONJ eblip-6807 28 65     SPACE eblip-6807 28 66 “ " PUNCT eblip-6807 28 67 being be AUX eblip-6807 28 68     SPACE eblip-6807 28 69 private private ADJ eblip-6807 28 70     SPACE eblip-6807 28 71 is be AUX eblip-6807 28 72     SPACE eblip-6807 28 73 ‘ ' PUNCT eblip-6807 28 74 best good ADJ eblip-6807 28 75 ’ ' PUNCT eblip-6807 28 76     SPACE eblip-6807 28 77 on on ADP eblip-6807 28 78     SPACE eblip-6807 28 79 most most ADJ eblip-6807 28 80     SPACE eblip-6807 28 81 quantitative quantitative ADJ eblip-6807 28 82     SPACE eblip-6807 28 83 measures measure NOUN eblip-6807 28 84     SPACE eblip-6807 28 85 for for ADP eblip-6807 28 86     SPACE eblip-6807 28 87 the the DET eblip-6807 28 88     SPACE eblip-6807 28 89 library library NOUN eblip-6807 28 90 , , PUNCT eblip-6807 28 91 ” " PUNCT eblip-6807 28 92     SPACE eblip-6807 28 93 they they PRON eblip-6807 28 94     SPACE eblip-6807 28 95 do do AUX eblip-6807 28 96     SPACE eblip-6807 28 97 not not PART eblip-6807 28 98     SPACE eblip-6807 28 99 support support VERB eblip-6807 28 100     SPACE eblip-6807 28 101 the the DET eblip-6807 28 102     SPACE eblip-6807 28 103 conclusion conclusion NOUN eblip-6807 28 104     SPACE eblip-6807 28 105 that that SCONJ eblip-6807 28 106     SPACE eblip-6807 28 107 “ " PUNCT eblip-6807 28 108 unionization unionization NOUN eblip-6807 28 109     SPACE eblip-6807 28 110 is be AUX eblip-6807 28 111     SPACE eblip-6807 28 112 best good ADJ eblip-6807 28 113     SPACE eblip-6807 28 114 for for ADP eblip-6807 28 115     SPACE eblip-6807 28 116 librarians librarian NOUN eblip-6807 28 117 ” " PUNCT eblip-6807 28 118     SPACE eblip-6807 28 119 ( ( PUNCT eblip-6807 28 120 p. p. NOUN eblip-6807 28 121     SPACE eblip-6807 28 122 461 461 NUM eblip-6807 28 123 ) ) PUNCT eblip-6807 28 124 . . PUNCT eblip-6807 28 125     SPACE eblip-6807 29 1 private private ADJ eblip-6807 29 2     SPACE eblip-6807 29 3 institutions institution NOUN eblip-6807 29 4     SPACE eblip-6807 29 5 showed show VERB eblip-6807 29 6     SPACE eblip-6807 29 7 lower low ADJ eblip-6807 29 8     SPACE eblip-6807 29 9 student‐librarian student‐librarian ADJ eblip-6807 29 10     SPACE eblip-6807 29 11 ratios ratio NOUN eblip-6807 29 12     SPACE eblip-6807 29 13 than than ADP eblip-6807 29 14     SPACE eblip-6807 29 15 either either ADV eblip-6807 29 16     SPACE eblip-6807 29 17 unionized unionize VERB eblip-6807 29 18     SPACE eblip-6807 29 19 or or CCONJ eblip-6807 29 20     SPACE eblip-6807 29 21 nonunionized nonunionized ADJ eblip-6807 29 22     SPACE eblip-6807 29 23 public public ADJ eblip-6807 29 24     SPACE eblip-6807 29 25 institutions institution NOUN eblip-6807 29 26 . . PUNCT eblip-6807 29 27     SPACE eblip-6807 30 1 librarians librarian NOUN eblip-6807 30 2     SPACE eblip-6807 30 3 at at ADP eblip-6807 30 4     SPACE eblip-6807 30 5 public public ADJ eblip-6807 30 6     SPACE eblip-6807 30 7 unionized unionize VERB eblip-6807 30 8     SPACE eblip-6807 30 9 institutions institution NOUN eblip-6807 30 10     SPACE eblip-6807 30 11 have have VERB eblip-6807 30 12     SPACE eblip-6807 30 13 higher high ADJ eblip-6807 30 14     SPACE eblip-6807 30 15 student‐ student‐ PROPN eblip-6807 30 16 librarian librarian PROPN eblip-6807 30 17     SPACE eblip-6807 30 18 ratios ratio NOUN eblip-6807 30 19     SPACE eblip-6807 30 20 than than ADP eblip-6807 30 21     SPACE eblip-6807 30 22 at at ADP eblip-6807 30 23     SPACE eblip-6807 30 24 public public ADJ eblip-6807 30 25     SPACE eblip-6807 30 26 nonunionized nonunionized ADJ eblip-6807 30 27     SPACE eblip-6807 30 28 institutions institution NOUN eblip-6807 30 29 , , PUNCT eblip-6807 30 30     SPACE eblip-6807 30 31 except except SCONJ eblip-6807 30 32     SPACE eblip-6807 30 33 at at ADP eblip-6807 30 34     SPACE eblip-6807 30 35 the the DET eblip-6807 30 36     SPACE eblip-6807 30 37 arl arl PROPN eblip-6807 30 38     SPACE eblip-6807 30 39 and and CCONJ eblip-6807 30 40     SPACE eblip-6807 30 41 baccalaureate baccalaureate NOUN eblip-6807 30 42     SPACE eblip-6807 30 43 levels level NOUN eblip-6807 30 44 . . PUNCT eblip-6807 30 45     SPACE eblip-6807 31 1 librarians librarian NOUN eblip-6807 31 2     SPACE eblip-6807 31 3 at at ADP eblip-6807 31 4     SPACE eblip-6807 31 5 unionized unionized ADJ eblip-6807 31 6     SPACE eblip-6807 31 7 public public ADJ eblip-6807 31 8     SPACE eblip-6807 31 9 institutions institution NOUN eblip-6807 31 10     SPACE eblip-6807 31 11 also also ADV eblip-6807 31 12     SPACE eblip-6807 31 13 have have VERB eblip-6807 31 14     SPACE eblip-6807 31 15 lower low ADJ eblip-6807 31 16     SPACE eblip-6807 31 17 salaries salary NOUN eblip-6807 31 18     SPACE eblip-6807 31 19 than than ADP eblip-6807 31 20     SPACE eblip-6807 31 21 at at ADP eblip-6807 31 22     SPACE eblip-6807 31 23 public public ADJ eblip-6807 31 24     SPACE eblip-6807 31 25 nonunionized nonunionized ADJ eblip-6807 31 26     SPACE eblip-6807 31 27 institutions institution NOUN eblip-6807 31 28 , , PUNCT eblip-6807 31 29     SPACE eblip-6807 31 30 except except SCONJ eblip-6807 31 31     SPACE eblip-6807 31 32 at at ADP eblip-6807 31 33     SPACE eblip-6807 31 34 the the DET eblip-6807 31 35     SPACE eblip-6807 31 36 masters master NOUN eblip-6807 31 37     SPACE eblip-6807 31 38 and and CCONJ eblip-6807 31 39     SPACE eblip-6807 31 40 baccalaureate baccalaureate NOUN eblip-6807 31 41     SPACE eblip-6807 31 42 levels level NOUN eblip-6807 31 43 . . PUNCT eblip-6807 31 44     SPACE eblip-6807 32 1 most most ADJ eblip-6807 32 2     SPACE eblip-6807 32 3 of of ADP eblip-6807 32 4     SPACE eblip-6807 32 5 the the DET eblip-6807 32 6     SPACE eblip-6807 32 7 statistically statistically ADV eblip-6807 32 8     SPACE eblip-6807 32 9 significant significant ADJ eblip-6807 32 10     SPACE eblip-6807 32 11 findings finding NOUN eblip-6807 32 12     SPACE eblip-6807 32 13 reported report VERB eblip-6807 32 14     SPACE eblip-6807 32 15 in in ADP eblip-6807 32 16     SPACE eblip-6807 32 17 this this DET eblip-6807 32 18     SPACE eblip-6807 32 19 study study NOUN eblip-6807 32 20     SPACE eblip-6807 32 21 came come VERB eblip-6807 32 22     SPACE eblip-6807 32 23 from from ADP eblip-6807 32 24     SPACE eblip-6807 32 25 the the DET eblip-6807 32 26     SPACE eblip-6807 32 27 analyses analysis NOUN eblip-6807 32 28     SPACE eblip-6807 32 29 by by ADP eblip-6807 32 30     SPACE eblip-6807 32 31 institutions institution NOUN eblip-6807 32 32     SPACE eblip-6807 32 33 type type NOUN eblip-6807 32 34     SPACE eblip-6807 32 35 and and CCONJ eblip-6807 32 36     SPACE eblip-6807 32 37 not not PART eblip-6807 32 38     SPACE eblip-6807 32 39 by by ADP eblip-6807 32 40     SPACE eblip-6807 32 41 governance governance NOUN eblip-6807 32 42 . . PUNCT eblip-6807 32 43     SPACE eblip-6807 33 1 also also ADV eblip-6807 33 2 , , PUNCT eblip-6807 33 3     SPACE eblip-6807 33 4 it it PRON eblip-6807 33 5     SPACE eblip-6807 33 6 is be AUX eblip-6807 33 7     SPACE eblip-6807 33 8 unclear unclear ADJ eblip-6807 33 9     SPACE eblip-6807 33 10 how how SCONJ eblip-6807 33 11     SPACE eblip-6807 33 12 the the DET eblip-6807 33 13     SPACE eblip-6807 33 14 study study NOUN eblip-6807 33 15     SPACE eblip-6807 33 16 is be AUX eblip-6807 33 17     SPACE eblip-6807 33 18 summarized summarize VERB eblip-6807 33 19     SPACE eblip-6807 33 20 results result NOUN eblip-6807 33 21     SPACE eblip-6807 33 22 in in ADP eblip-6807 33 23     SPACE eblip-6807 33 24 table table NOUN eblip-6807 33 25     SPACE eblip-6807 33 26 9 9 NUM eblip-6807 33 27     SPACE eblip-6807 33 28 relate relate VERB eblip-6807 33 29     SPACE eblip-6807 33 30 to to ADP eblip-6807 33 31     SPACE eblip-6807 33 32 the the DET eblip-6807 33 33     SPACE eblip-6807 33 34 145 145 NUM eblip-6807 33 35 evidence evidence NOUN eblip-6807 33 36     SPACE eblip-6807 33 37 based base VERB eblip-6807 33 38     SPACE eblip-6807 33 39 library library NOUN eblip-6807 33 40     SPACE eblip-6807 33 41 and and CCONJ eblip-6807 33 42     SPACE eblip-6807 33 43 information information NOUN eblip-6807 33 44     SPACE eblip-6807 33 45 practice practice NOUN eblip-6807 33 46     SPACE eblip-6807 33 47 2010 2010 NUM eblip-6807 33 48 , , PUNCT eblip-6807 33 49     SPACE eblip-6807 33 50 5.1 5.1 NUM eblip-6807 33 51     SPACE eblip-6807 33 52 146 146 NUM eblip-6807 33 53 previously previously ADV eblip-6807 33 54     SPACE eblip-6807 33 55 discussed discuss VERB eblip-6807 33 56     SPACE eblip-6807 33 57 statistically statistically ADV eblip-6807 33 58     SPACE eblip-6807 33 59 significant significant ADJ eblip-6807 33 60     SPACE eblip-6807 33 61 findings finding NOUN eblip-6807 33 62 . . PUNCT eblip-6807 33 63           SPACE eblip-6807 34 1 applegate applegate NOUN eblip-6807 34 2     SPACE eblip-6807 34 3 frankly frankly ADV eblip-6807 34 4     SPACE eblip-6807 34 5 states state NOUN eblip-6807 34 6     SPACE eblip-6807 34 7 “ " PUNCT eblip-6807 34 8 this this DET eblip-6807 34 9     SPACE eblip-6807 34 10 study study NOUN eblip-6807 34 11     SPACE eblip-6807 34 12 provides provide VERB eblip-6807 34 13     SPACE eblip-6807 34 14 some some PRON eblip-6807 34 15 , , PUNCT eblip-6807 34 16     SPACE eblip-6807 34 17 but but CCONJ eblip-6807 34 18     SPACE eblip-6807 34 19 very very ADV eblip-6807 34 20     SPACE eblip-6807 34 21 limited limit VERB eblip-6807 34 22 , , PUNCT eblip-6807 34 23     SPACE eblip-6807 34 24 answers answer NOUN eblip-6807 34 25     SPACE eblip-6807 34 26 in in ADP eblip-6807 34 27     SPACE eblip-6807 34 28 the the DET eblip-6807 34 29     SPACE eblip-6807 34 30 unionization unionization NOUN eblip-6807 34 31     SPACE eblip-6807 34 32 area area NOUN eblip-6807 34 33 ” " PUNCT eblip-6807 34 34     SPACE eblip-6807 34 35 ( ( PUNCT eblip-6807 34 36 p. p. NOUN eblip-6807 34 37     SPACE eblip-6807 34 38 461 461 NUM eblip-6807 34 39 ) ) PUNCT eblip-6807 34 40     SPACE eblip-6807 34 41 and and CCONJ eblip-6807 34 42     SPACE eblip-6807 34 43 the the DET eblip-6807 34 44     SPACE eblip-6807 34 45 results result NOUN eblip-6807 34 46     SPACE eblip-6807 34 47 can can AUX eblip-6807 34 48 not not PART eblip-6807 34 49     SPACE eblip-6807 34 50 be be AUX eblip-6807 34 51     SPACE eblip-6807 34 52 generalized generalize VERB eblip-6807 34 53     SPACE eblip-6807 34 54 beyond beyond ADP eblip-6807 34 55     SPACE eblip-6807 34 56 u.s u.s PROPN eblip-6807 34 57 . . PROPN eblip-6807 34 58     SPACE eblip-6807 34 59 “ " PUNCT eblip-6807 34 60 traditional traditional ADJ eblip-6807 34 61 , , PUNCT eblip-6807 34 62     SPACE eblip-6807 34 63 mainstream mainstream NOUN eblip-6807 34 64     SPACE eblip-6807 34 65 academia academia NOUN eblip-6807 34 66 ” " PUNCT eblip-6807 34 67     SPACE eblip-6807 34 68 ( ( PUNCT eblip-6807 34 69 p. p. NOUN eblip-6807 34 70     SPACE eblip-6807 34 71 449 449 NUM eblip-6807 34 72 ) ) PUNCT eblip-6807 34 73 . . PUNCT eblip-6807 34 74     SPACE eblip-6807 35 1 the the DET eblip-6807 35 2     SPACE eblip-6807 35 3 analyses analysis NOUN eblip-6807 35 4     SPACE eblip-6807 35 5 do do AUX eblip-6807 35 6     SPACE eblip-6807 35 7 reveal reveal VERB eblip-6807 35 8     SPACE eblip-6807 35 9 that that SCONJ eblip-6807 35 10     SPACE eblip-6807 35 11 some some DET eblip-6807 35 12     SPACE eblip-6807 35 13 quantitative quantitative ADJ eblip-6807 35 14     SPACE eblip-6807 35 15 differences difference NOUN eblip-6807 35 16     SPACE eblip-6807 35 17 can can AUX eblip-6807 35 18     SPACE eblip-6807 35 19 be be AUX eblip-6807 35 20     SPACE eblip-6807 35 21 correlated correlate VERB eblip-6807 35 22     SPACE eblip-6807 35 23 with with ADP eblip-6807 35 24     SPACE eblip-6807 35 25 governance governance NOUN eblip-6807 35 26 , , PUNCT eblip-6807 35 27     SPACE eblip-6807 35 28 but but CCONJ eblip-6807 35 29     SPACE eblip-6807 35 30 add add VERB eblip-6807 35 31     SPACE eblip-6807 35 32 more more ADJ eblip-6807 35 33     SPACE eblip-6807 35 34 to to ADP eblip-6807 35 35     SPACE eblip-6807 35 36 the the DET eblip-6807 35 37     SPACE eblip-6807 35 38 understanding understanding NOUN eblip-6807 35 39     SPACE eblip-6807 35 40 of of ADP eblip-6807 35 41     SPACE eblip-6807 35 42 differences difference NOUN eblip-6807 35 43     SPACE eblip-6807 35 44 correlated correlate VERB eblip-6807 35 45     SPACE eblip-6807 35 46 with with ADP eblip-6807 35 47     SPACE eblip-6807 35 48 institution institution NOUN eblip-6807 35 49     SPACE eblip-6807 35 50 type type NOUN eblip-6807 35 51 . . PUNCT eblip-6807 35 52     SPACE eblip-6807 35 53 therefore therefore ADV eblip-6807 35 54     SPACE eblip-6807 35 55 the the DET eblip-6807 35 56     SPACE eblip-6807 35 57 results result NOUN eblip-6807 35 58     SPACE eblip-6807 35 59 are be AUX eblip-6807 35 60     SPACE eblip-6807 35 61 most most ADJ eblip-6807 35 62     SPACE eblip-6807 35 63 helpful helpful ADJ eblip-6807 35 64     SPACE eblip-6807 35 65 for for ADP eblip-6807 35 66     SPACE eblip-6807 35 67 librarians librarian NOUN eblip-6807 35 68     SPACE eblip-6807 35 69 who who PRON eblip-6807 35 70     SPACE eblip-6807 35 71 are be AUX eblip-6807 35 72     SPACE eblip-6807 35 73 considering consider VERB eblip-6807 35 74     SPACE eblip-6807 35 75 where where SCONJ eblip-6807 35 76     SPACE eblip-6807 35 77 it it PRON eblip-6807 35 78     SPACE eblip-6807 35 79 would would AUX eblip-6807 35 80     SPACE eblip-6807 35 81 be be AUX eblip-6807 35 82     SPACE eblip-6807 35 83 “ " PUNCT eblip-6807 35 84 best good ADJ eblip-6807 35 85 ” " PUNCT eblip-6807 35 86     SPACE eblip-6807 35 87 to to PART eblip-6807 35 88     SPACE eblip-6807 35 89 work work VERB eblip-6807 35 90     SPACE eblip-6807 35 91 based base VERB eblip-6807 35 92     SPACE eblip-6807 35 93 on on ADP eblip-6807 35 94     SPACE eblip-6807 35 95 institution institution NOUN eblip-6807 35 96     SPACE eblip-6807 35 97 type type NOUN eblip-6807 35 98     SPACE eblip-6807 35 99 and and CCONJ eblip-6807 35 100     SPACE eblip-6807 35 101 not not PART eblip-6807 35 102     SPACE eblip-6807 35 103 on on ADP eblip-6807 35 104     SPACE eblip-6807 35 105 governance governance NOUN eblip-6807 35 106     SPACE eblip-6807 35 107 type type NOUN eblip-6807 35 108 . . PUNCT eblip-6807 35 109     SPACE eblip-6807 35 110 further far ADV eblip-6807 35 111     SPACE eblip-6807 35 112 qualitative qualitative NOUN eblip-6807 35 113     SPACE eblip-6807 35 114 and and CCONJ eblip-6807 35 115     SPACE eblip-6807 35 116 quantitative quantitative ADJ eblip-6807 35 117     SPACE eblip-6807 35 118 research research NOUN eblip-6807 35 119 , , PUNCT eblip-6807 35 120     SPACE eblip-6807 35 121 as as SCONJ eblip-6807 35 122     SPACE eblip-6807 35 123 noted note VERB eblip-6807 35 124     SPACE eblip-6807 35 125 by by ADP eblip-6807 35 126     SPACE eblip-6807 35 127 the the DET eblip-6807 35 128     SPACE eblip-6807 35 129 author author NOUN eblip-6807 35 130 , , PUNCT eblip-6807 35 131     SPACE eblip-6807 35 132 is be AUX eblip-6807 35 133     SPACE eblip-6807 35 134 warranted warrant VERB eblip-6807 35 135     SPACE eblip-6807 35 136 in in ADP eblip-6807 35 137     SPACE eblip-6807 35 138 analyzing analyze VERB eblip-6807 35 139     SPACE eblip-6807 35 140 the the DET eblip-6807 35 141     SPACE eblip-6807 35 142 effects effect NOUN eblip-6807 35 143     SPACE eblip-6807 35 144 of of ADP eblip-6807 35 145     SPACE eblip-6807 35 146 unionization unionization NOUN eblip-6807 35 147     SPACE eblip-6807 35 148 for for ADP eblip-6807 35 149     SPACE eblip-6807 35 150 academic academic ADJ eblip-6807 35 151     SPACE eblip-6807 35 152 libraries library NOUN eblip-6807 35 153     SPACE eblip-6807 35 154 and and CCONJ eblip-6807 35 155     SPACE eblip-6807 35 156 librarians librarian NOUN eblip-6807 35 157 . . PUNCT eblip-6807 35 158     SPACE