id sid tid token lemma pos expositions-1796 1 1 microsoft microsoft PROPN expositions-1796 1 2 word word NOUN expositions-1796 1 3 eif-4-final.docx eif-4-final.docx VERB expositions-1796 1 4 [ [ X expositions-1796 1 5 expositions exposition NOUN expositions-1796 1 6 8.2 8.2 NUM expositions-1796 1 7 ( ( PUNCT expositions-1796 1 8 2014 2014 NUM expositions-1796 1 9 ) ) PUNCT expositions-1796 2 1 38–49 38–49 NUM expositions-1796 2 2 ] ] X expositions-1796 3 1 expositions exposition NOUN expositions-1796 3 2 ( ( PUNCT expositions-1796 3 3 online online ADV expositions-1796 3 4 ) ) PUNCT expositions-1796 3 5 issn issn PROPN expositions-1796 3 6 : : PUNCT expositions-1796 3 7 1747–5376 1747–5376 NOUN expositions-1796 3 8     SPACE expositions-1796 3 9 dissolving dissolve VERB expositions-1796 3 10 the the DET expositions-1796 3 11 debunker debunker NOUN expositions-1796 3 12 ’s ’s PART expositions-1796 3 13 puzzle puzzle NOUN expositions-1796 3 14 terence terence PROPN expositions-1796 3 15 cuneo cuneo PROPN expositions-1796 3 16 university university PROPN expositions-1796 3 17 of of ADP expositions-1796 3 18 vermont vermont PROPN expositions-1796 3 19 there there PRON expositions-1796 3 20 is be VERB expositions-1796 3 21 a a DET expositions-1796 3 22 two two NUM expositions-1796 3 23 - - ADJ expositions-1796 3 24 fold fold ADJ expositions-1796 3 25 dynamic dynamic NOUN expositions-1796 3 26 at at ADP expositions-1796 3 27 work work NOUN expositions-1796 3 28 in in ADP expositions-1796 3 29 chapter chapter NOUN expositions-1796 3 30 five five NUM expositions-1796 3 31 of of ADP expositions-1796 3 32 thomas thomas PROPN expositions-1796 3 33 nagel nagel PROPN expositions-1796 3 34 ’s ’s PART expositions-1796 3 35 mind mind NOUN expositions-1796 3 36 and and CCONJ expositions-1796 3 37 cosmos.1 cosmos.1 NOUN expositions-1796 3 38 the the DET expositions-1796 3 39 first first ADJ expositions-1796 3 40 dynamic dynamic ADJ expositions-1796 3 41 consists consist VERB expositions-1796 3 42 in in ADP expositions-1796 3 43 nagel nagel PROPN expositions-1796 3 44 conceding concede VERB expositions-1796 3 45 that that SCONJ expositions-1796 3 46 what what PRON expositions-1796 3 47 evolutionary evolutionary ADJ expositions-1796 3 48 biology biology NOUN expositions-1796 3 49 ( ( PUNCT expositions-1796 3 50 as as SCONJ expositions-1796 3 51 it it PRON expositions-1796 3 52 ’s ’s AUX expositions-1796 3 53 standardly standardly ADV expositions-1796 3 54 understood understand VERB expositions-1796 3 55 ) ) PUNCT expositions-1796 3 56 implies imply VERB expositions-1796 3 57 about about ADP expositions-1796 3 58 the the DET expositions-1796 3 59 origin origin NOUN expositions-1796 3 60 and and CCONJ expositions-1796 3 61 nature nature NOUN expositions-1796 3 62 of of ADP expositions-1796 3 63 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 3 64 judgment judgment NOUN expositions-1796 3 65 is be AUX expositions-1796 3 66 incompatible incompatible ADJ expositions-1796 3 67 with with ADP expositions-1796 3 68 his his PRON expositions-1796 3 69 favored favor VERB expositions-1796 3 70 version version NOUN expositions-1796 3 71 of of ADP expositions-1796 3 72 non non ADJ expositions-1796 3 73 - - ADJ expositions-1796 3 74 naturalistic naturalistic ADJ expositions-1796 3 75 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 3 76 realism realism NOUN expositions-1796 3 77 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 4 1 the the DET expositions-1796 4 2 second second ADJ expositions-1796 4 3 dynamic dynamic ADJ expositions-1796 4 4 consists consist VERB expositions-1796 4 5 in in ADP expositions-1796 4 6 nagel nagel PROPN expositions-1796 4 7 ’s ’s PART expositions-1796 4 8 resisting resist VERB expositions-1796 4 9 the the DET expositions-1796 4 10 conclusion conclusion NOUN expositions-1796 4 11 that that SCONJ expositions-1796 4 12 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 4 13 non non ADJ expositions-1796 4 14 - - NOUN expositions-1796 4 15 naturalism naturalism NOUN expositions-1796 4 16 is be AUX expositions-1796 4 17 false false ADJ expositions-1796 4 18 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 5 1 rather rather ADV expositions-1796 5 2 than than SCONJ expositions-1796 5 3 concede concede VERB expositions-1796 5 4 that that SCONJ expositions-1796 5 5 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 5 6 nonnaturalism nonnaturalism NOUN expositions-1796 5 7 is be AUX expositions-1796 5 8 false false ADJ expositions-1796 5 9 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 5 10 nagel nagel PROPN expositions-1796 5 11 would would AUX expositions-1796 5 12 conclude conclude VERB expositions-1796 5 13 that that SCONJ expositions-1796 5 14 what what PRON expositions-1796 5 15 evolutionary evolutionary ADJ expositions-1796 5 16 biology biology NOUN expositions-1796 5 17 ( ( PUNCT expositions-1796 5 18 as as SCONJ expositions-1796 5 19 it it PRON expositions-1796 5 20 ’s ’s AUX expositions-1796 5 21 standardly standardly ADV expositions-1796 5 22 understood understand VERB expositions-1796 5 23 ) ) PUNCT expositions-1796 5 24 implies imply VERB expositions-1796 5 25 about about ADP expositions-1796 5 26 the the DET expositions-1796 5 27 origin origin NOUN expositions-1796 5 28 and and CCONJ expositions-1796 5 29 nature nature NOUN expositions-1796 5 30 of of ADP expositions-1796 5 31 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 5 32 judgment judgment NOUN expositions-1796 5 33 is be AUX expositions-1796 5 34 incorrect incorrect ADJ expositions-1796 5 35 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 6 1 i i PRON expositions-1796 6 2 share share VERB expositions-1796 6 3 nagel nagel PROPN expositions-1796 6 4 ’s ’s PART expositions-1796 6 5 sympathies sympathy NOUN expositions-1796 6 6 with with ADP expositions-1796 6 7 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 6 8 nonnaturalism.2 nonnaturalism.2 NOUN expositions-1796 7 1 so so ADV expositions-1796 7 2 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 7 3 i i PRON expositions-1796 7 4 applaud applaud VERB expositions-1796 7 5 his his PRON expositions-1796 7 6 resistance resistance NOUN expositions-1796 7 7 to to ADP expositions-1796 7 8 concluding conclude VERB expositions-1796 7 9 that that SCONJ expositions-1796 7 10 this this DET expositions-1796 7 11 position position NOUN expositions-1796 7 12 is be AUX expositions-1796 7 13 false false ADJ expositions-1796 7 14 on on ADP expositions-1796 7 15 the the DET expositions-1796 7 16 basis basis NOUN expositions-1796 7 17 of of ADP expositions-1796 7 18 what what PRON expositions-1796 7 19 evolutionary evolutionary ADJ expositions-1796 7 20 biology biology NOUN expositions-1796 7 21 appears appear VERB expositions-1796 7 22 to to PART expositions-1796 7 23 imply imply VERB expositions-1796 7 24 about about ADP expositions-1796 7 25 the the DET expositions-1796 7 26 origin origin NOUN expositions-1796 7 27 and and CCONJ expositions-1796 7 28 nature nature NOUN expositions-1796 7 29 of of ADP expositions-1796 7 30 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 7 31 judgment judgment NOUN expositions-1796 7 32 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 8 1 i i PRON expositions-1796 8 2 believe believe VERB expositions-1796 8 3 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 8 4 however however ADV expositions-1796 8 5 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 8 6 that that SCONJ expositions-1796 8 7 nagel nagel PROPN expositions-1796 8 8 concedes concede VERB expositions-1796 8 9 far far ADV expositions-1796 8 10 more more ADJ expositions-1796 8 11 than than SCONJ expositions-1796 8 12 he he PRON expositions-1796 8 13 should should AUX expositions-1796 8 14 when when SCONJ expositions-1796 8 15 he he PRON expositions-1796 8 16 says say VERB expositions-1796 8 17 that that SCONJ expositions-1796 8 18 what what PRON expositions-1796 8 19 evolutionary evolutionary ADJ expositions-1796 8 20 biology biology NOUN expositions-1796 8 21 ( ( PUNCT expositions-1796 8 22 as as SCONJ expositions-1796 8 23 it it PRON expositions-1796 8 24 ’s ’s AUX expositions-1796 8 25 standardly standardly ADV expositions-1796 8 26 understood understand VERB expositions-1796 8 27 ) ) PUNCT expositions-1796 8 28 implies imply VERB expositions-1796 8 29 about about ADP expositions-1796 8 30 the the DET expositions-1796 8 31 origin origin NOUN expositions-1796 8 32 and and CCONJ expositions-1796 8 33 nature nature NOUN expositions-1796 8 34 of of ADP expositions-1796 8 35 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 8 36 judgment judgment NOUN expositions-1796 8 37 is be AUX expositions-1796 8 38 incompatible incompatible ADJ expositions-1796 8 39 with with ADP expositions-1796 8 40 non non ADJ expositions-1796 8 41 - - ADJ expositions-1796 8 42 naturalistic naturalistic ADJ expositions-1796 8 43 realism realism NOUN expositions-1796 8 44 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 9 1 the the DET expositions-1796 9 2 better well ADJ expositions-1796 9 3 response response NOUN expositions-1796 9 4 to to ADP expositions-1796 9 5 so so ADV expositions-1796 9 6 - - PUNCT expositions-1796 9 7 called call VERB expositions-1796 9 8 evolutionary evolutionary ADJ expositions-1796 9 9 challenges challenge NOUN expositions-1796 9 10 to to ADP expositions-1796 9 11 non non ADJ expositions-1796 9 12 - - ADJ expositions-1796 9 13 naturalist naturalist ADJ expositions-1796 9 14 realism realism NOUN expositions-1796 9 15 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 9 16 i i PRON expositions-1796 9 17 believe believe VERB expositions-1796 9 18 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 9 19 is be AUX expositions-1796 9 20 to to PART expositions-1796 9 21 point point VERB expositions-1796 9 22 out out ADP expositions-1796 9 23 that that SCONJ expositions-1796 9 24 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 9 25 even even ADV expositions-1796 9 26 if if SCONJ expositions-1796 9 27 we we PRON expositions-1796 9 28 concede concede VERB expositions-1796 9 29 the the DET expositions-1796 9 30 standard standard ADJ expositions-1796 9 31 evolutionary evolutionary ADJ expositions-1796 9 32 picture picture NOUN expositions-1796 9 33 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 9 34 these these DET expositions-1796 9 35 challenges challenge NOUN expositions-1796 9 36 have have VERB expositions-1796 9 37 little little ADJ expositions-1796 9 38 bite bite NOUN expositions-1796 9 39 against against ADP expositions-1796 9 40 these these DET expositions-1796 9 41 realist realist ADJ expositions-1796 9 42 views view NOUN expositions-1796 9 43 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 10 1 in in ADP expositions-1796 10 2 this this DET expositions-1796 10 3 short short ADJ expositions-1796 10 4 essay essay NOUN expositions-1796 10 5 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 10 6 i i PRON expositions-1796 10 7 sketch sketch VERB expositions-1796 10 8 two two NUM expositions-1796 10 9 reasons reason NOUN expositions-1796 10 10 why why SCONJ expositions-1796 10 11 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 11 1 the the DET expositions-1796 11 2 debunker debunker NOUN expositions-1796 11 3 ’s ’s PART expositions-1796 11 4 puzzle puzzle NOUN expositions-1796 11 5 let let VERB expositions-1796 11 6 me i PRON expositions-1796 11 7 begin begin VERB expositions-1796 11 8 by by ADP expositions-1796 11 9 stating state VERB expositions-1796 11 10 the the DET expositions-1796 11 11 central central ADJ expositions-1796 11 12 puzzle puzzle NOUN expositions-1796 11 13 with with ADP expositions-1796 11 14 which which PRON expositions-1796 11 15 nagel nagel PROPN expositions-1796 11 16 is be AUX expositions-1796 11 17 concerned concern VERB expositions-1796 11 18 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 11 19 what what PRON expositions-1796 11 20 i i PRON expositions-1796 11 21 ’ll ’ll AUX expositions-1796 11 22 call call VERB expositions-1796 11 23 the the DET expositions-1796 11 24 evolutionary evolutionary ADJ expositions-1796 11 25 debunker debunker NOUN expositions-1796 11 26 ’s ’s PART expositions-1796 11 27 puzzle puzzle NOUN expositions-1796 11 28 — — PUNCT expositions-1796 11 29 or or CCONJ expositions-1796 11 30 the the DET expositions-1796 11 31 debunker debunker NOUN expositions-1796 11 32 ’s ’s PART expositions-1796 11 33 puzzle puzzle NOUN expositions-1796 11 34 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 11 35 for for ADP expositions-1796 11 36 short.3 short.3 NOUN expositions-1796 11 37 the the DET expositions-1796 11 38 puzzle puzzle NOUN expositions-1796 11 39 consists consist VERB expositions-1796 11 40 of of ADP expositions-1796 11 41 these these DET expositions-1796 11 42 three three NUM expositions-1796 11 43 claims claim NOUN expositions-1796 11 44 : : PUNCT expositions-1796 11 45 ( ( PUNCT expositions-1796 11 46 1 1 X expositions-1796 11 47 ) ) PUNCT expositions-1796 11 48 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 11 49 non non ADJ expositions-1796 11 50 - - NOUN expositions-1796 11 51 naturalism naturalism NOUN expositions-1796 11 52 : : PUNCT expositions-1796 11 53 there there PRON expositions-1796 11 54 are be VERB expositions-1796 11 55 non non ADJ expositions-1796 11 56 - - ADJ expositions-1796 11 57 natural natural ADJ expositions-1796 11 58 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 11 59 facts fact NOUN expositions-1796 11 60 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 11 61 including include VERB expositions-1796 11 62 reasons reason NOUN expositions-1796 11 63 to to PART expositions-1796 11 64 act act VERB expositions-1796 11 65 in in ADP expositions-1796 11 66 certain certain ADJ expositions-1796 11 67 ways way NOUN expositions-1796 11 68 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 12 1 ( ( PUNCT expositions-1796 12 2 2 2 X expositions-1796 12 3 ) ) PUNCT expositions-1796 12 4 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 12 5 knowledge knowledge NOUN expositions-1796 12 6 : : PUNCT expositions-1796 12 7 we we PRON expositions-1796 12 8 have have VERB expositions-1796 12 9 some some DET expositions-1796 12 10 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 12 11 knowledge knowledge NOUN expositions-1796 12 12 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 13 1 ( ( PUNCT expositions-1796 13 2 3 3 X expositions-1796 13 3 ) ) PUNCT expositions-1796 13 4 evolutionary evolutionary ADJ expositions-1796 13 5 influence influence NOUN expositions-1796 13 6 : : PUNCT expositions-1796 13 7 evolutionary evolutionary ADJ expositions-1796 13 8 forces force NOUN expositions-1796 13 9 have have AUX expositions-1796 13 10 not not PART expositions-1796 13 11 only only ADV expositions-1796 13 12 determined determine VERB expositions-1796 13 13 which which DET expositions-1796 13 14 cognitive cognitive ADJ expositions-1796 13 15 faculties faculty NOUN expositions-1796 13 16 we we PRON expositions-1796 13 17 have have VERB expositions-1796 13 18 but but CCONJ expositions-1796 13 19 also also ADV expositions-1796 13 20 considerably considerably ADV expositions-1796 13 21 shaped shape VERB expositions-1796 13 22 their their PRON expositions-1796 13 23 workings working NOUN expositions-1796 13 24 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 13 25 including include VERB expositions-1796 13 26 the the DET expositions-1796 13 27 workings working NOUN expositions-1796 13 28 of of ADP expositions-1796 13 29 the the DET expositions-1796 13 30 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 13 31 faculty faculty NOUN expositions-1796 13 32 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 13 33 which which PRON expositions-1796 13 34 is be AUX expositions-1796 13 35 simply simply ADV expositions-1796 13 36 that that DET expositions-1796 13 37 ability ability NOUN expositions-1796 13 38 ( ( PUNCT expositions-1796 13 39 or or CCONJ expositions-1796 13 40 cluster cluster NOUN expositions-1796 13 41 of of ADP expositions-1796 13 42 abilities ability NOUN expositions-1796 13 43 ) ) PUNCT expositions-1796 13 44 by by ADP expositions-1796 13 45 which which PRON expositions-1796 13 46 we we PRON expositions-1796 13 47 form form VERB expositions-1796 13 48 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 13 49 judgments judgment NOUN expositions-1796 13 50 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 14 1 a a DET expositions-1796 14 2 comment comment NOUN expositions-1796 14 3 regarding regard VERB expositions-1796 14 4 each each PRON expositions-1796 14 5 of of ADP expositions-1796 14 6 these these DET expositions-1796 14 7 claims claim NOUN expositions-1796 14 8 is be AUX expositions-1796 14 9 in in ADP expositions-1796 14 10 order order NOUN expositions-1796 14 11 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 14 12 beginning begin VERB expositions-1796 14 13 with with ADP expositions-1796 14 14 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 14 15 non non ADJ expositions-1796 14 16 - - NOUN expositions-1796 14 17 naturalism naturalism NOUN expositions-1796 14 18 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 15 1 while while SCONJ expositions-1796 15 2 non non NOUN expositions-1796 15 3 - - NOUN expositions-1796 15 4 naturalists naturalist NOUN expositions-1796 15 5 hold hold VERB expositions-1796 15 6 that that SCONJ expositions-1796 15 7 there there PRON expositions-1796 15 8 are be VERB expositions-1796 15 9 non non ADJ expositions-1796 15 10 - - ADJ expositions-1796 15 11 natural natural ADJ expositions-1796 15 12 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 15 13 facts fact NOUN expositions-1796 15 14 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 15 15 there there PRON expositions-1796 15 16 is be VERB expositions-1796 15 17 little little ADJ expositions-1796 15 18 agreement agreement NOUN expositions-1796 15 19 about about ADP expositions-1796 15 20 what what PRON expositions-1796 15 21 a a DET expositions-1796 15 22 non non ADJ expositions-1796 15 23 - - ADJ expositions-1796 15 24 natural natural ADJ expositions-1796 15 25 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 15 26 fact fact NOUN expositions-1796 15 27 would would AUX expositions-1796 15 28 be be AUX expositions-1796 15 29 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 16 1 in in ADP expositions-1796 16 2 what what PRON expositions-1796 16 3 follows follow VERB expositions-1796 16 4 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 16 5 i i PRON expositions-1796 16 6 ’ll ’ll AUX expositions-1796 16 7 assume assume VERB expositions-1796 16 8 only only ADV expositions-1796 16 9 that that PRON expositions-1796 16 10 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 16 11 were be AUX expositions-1796 16 12 such such ADJ expositions-1796 16 13 39 39 NUM expositions-1796 16 14 cuneo cuneo VERB expositions-1796 16 15 facts fact NOUN expositions-1796 16 16 to to PART expositions-1796 16 17 exist exist VERB expositions-1796 16 18 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 16 19 they they PRON expositions-1796 16 20 would would AUX expositions-1796 16 21 have have VERB expositions-1796 16 22 four four NUM expositions-1796 16 23 distinguishing distinguish VERB expositions-1796 16 24 characteristics.4 characteristics.4 NOUN expositions-1796 16 25 first first ADJ expositions-1796 16 26 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 16 27 many many ADJ expositions-1796 16 28 of of ADP expositions-1796 16 29 these these DET expositions-1796 16 30 facts fact NOUN expositions-1796 16 31 would would AUX expositions-1796 16 32 be be AUX expositions-1796 16 33 strongly strongly ADV expositions-1796 16 34 mind mind NOUN expositions-1796 16 35 - - PUNCT expositions-1796 16 36 independent independent ADJ expositions-1796 16 37 in in ADP expositions-1796 16 38 the the DET expositions-1796 16 39 sense sense NOUN expositions-1796 16 40 that that SCONJ expositions-1796 16 41 they they PRON expositions-1796 16 42 exist exist VERB expositions-1796 16 43 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 16 44 but but CCONJ expositions-1796 16 45 not not PART expositions-1796 16 46 in in ADP expositions-1796 16 47 virtue virtue NOUN expositions-1796 16 48 of of ADP expositions-1796 16 49 our our PRON expositions-1796 16 50 valuing valuing NOUN expositions-1796 16 51 or or CCONJ expositions-1796 16 52 desiring desire VERB expositions-1796 16 53 ( ( PUNCT expositions-1796 16 54 or or CCONJ expositions-1796 16 55 being be AUX expositions-1796 16 56 such such ADJ expositions-1796 16 57 that that SCONJ expositions-1796 16 58 we we PRON expositions-1796 16 59 would would AUX expositions-1796 16 60 value value VERB expositions-1796 16 61 or or CCONJ expositions-1796 16 62 desire desire VERB expositions-1796 16 63 ) ) PUNCT expositions-1796 16 64 non non ADJ expositions-1796 16 65 - - ADJ expositions-1796 16 66 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 16 67 features feature NOUN expositions-1796 16 68 of of ADP expositions-1796 16 69 the the DET expositions-1796 16 70 world world NOUN expositions-1796 16 71 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 17 1 in in ADP expositions-1796 17 2 this this DET expositions-1796 17 3 regard regard NOUN expositions-1796 17 4 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 17 5 they they PRON expositions-1796 17 6 differ differ VERB expositions-1796 17 7 from from ADP expositions-1796 17 8 the the DET expositions-1796 17 9 fact fact NOUN expositions-1796 17 10 that that SCONJ expositions-1796 17 11 yo yo PROPN expositions-1796 17 12 - - PUNCT expositions-1796 17 13 yo yo PROPN expositions-1796 17 14 - - PUNCT expositions-1796 17 15 ma ma PROPN expositions-1796 17 16 is be AUX expositions-1796 17 17 an an DET expositions-1796 17 18 admired admired ADJ expositions-1796 17 19 cellist cellist NOUN expositions-1796 17 20 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 17 21 which which PRON expositions-1796 17 22 does do AUX expositions-1796 17 23 depend depend VERB expositions-1796 17 24 on on ADP expositions-1796 17 25 the the DET expositions-1796 17 26 attitudes attitude NOUN expositions-1796 17 27 of of ADP expositions-1796 17 28 admiration admiration NOUN expositions-1796 17 29 that that SCONJ expositions-1796 17 30 people people NOUN expositions-1796 17 31 take take VERB expositions-1796 17 32 toward toward ADP expositions-1796 17 33 him he PRON expositions-1796 17 34 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 18 1 second second ADV expositions-1796 18 2 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 18 3 these these DET expositions-1796 18 4 facts fact NOUN expositions-1796 18 5 would would AUX expositions-1796 18 6 not not PART expositions-1796 18 7 play play VERB expositions-1796 18 8 ( ( PUNCT expositions-1796 18 9 or or CCONJ expositions-1796 18 10 be be AUX expositions-1796 18 11 reducible reducible ADJ expositions-1796 18 12 to to ADP expositions-1796 18 13 any any DET expositions-1796 18 14 facts fact NOUN expositions-1796 18 15 that that PRON expositions-1796 18 16 play play VERB expositions-1796 18 17 ) ) PUNCT expositions-1796 18 18 explanatory explanatory ADJ expositions-1796 18 19 roles role NOUN expositions-1796 18 20 in in ADP expositions-1796 18 21 the the DET expositions-1796 18 22 usual usual ADJ expositions-1796 18 23 sciences science NOUN expositions-1796 18 24 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 18 25 such such ADJ expositions-1796 18 26 as as ADP expositions-1796 18 27 physics physics NOUN expositions-1796 18 28 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 18 29 biology biology NOUN expositions-1796 18 30 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 18 31 or or CCONJ expositions-1796 18 32 chemistry chemistry NOUN expositions-1796 18 33 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 19 1 third third ADJ expositions-1796 19 2 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 19 3 and and CCONJ expositions-1796 19 4 relatedly relatedly ADV expositions-1796 19 5 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 19 6 these these DET expositions-1796 19 7 facts fact NOUN expositions-1796 19 8 would would AUX expositions-1796 19 9 be be AUX expositions-1796 19 10 causally causally ADV expositions-1796 19 11 inert inert ADJ expositions-1796 19 12 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 19 13 not not PART expositions-1796 19 14 ( ( PUNCT expositions-1796 19 15 in in ADP expositions-1796 19 16 any any DET expositions-1796 19 17 direct direct ADJ expositions-1796 19 18 sense sense NOUN expositions-1796 19 19 ) ) PUNCT expositions-1796 19 20 entering enter VERB expositions-1796 19 21 into into ADP expositions-1796 19 22 the the DET expositions-1796 19 23 causal causal ADJ expositions-1796 19 24 flow flow NOUN expositions-1796 19 25 of of ADP expositions-1796 19 26 nature nature NOUN expositions-1796 19 27 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 19 28 as as SCONJ expositions-1796 19 29 they they PRON expositions-1796 19 30 would would AUX expositions-1796 19 31 be be AUX expositions-1796 19 32 abstract abstract ADJ expositions-1796 19 33 entities entity NOUN expositions-1796 19 34 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 20 1 and and CCONJ expositions-1796 20 2 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 20 3 fourth fourth ADJ expositions-1796 20 4 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 20 5 these these DET expositions-1796 20 6 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 20 7 facts fact NOUN expositions-1796 20 8 would would AUX expositions-1796 20 9 be be AUX expositions-1796 20 10 ( ( PUNCT expositions-1796 20 11 or or CCONJ expositions-1796 20 12 would would AUX expositions-1796 20 13 necessarily necessarily ADV expositions-1796 20 14 imply imply VERB expositions-1796 20 15 ) ) PUNCT expositions-1796 20 16 reasons reason NOUN expositions-1796 20 17 of of ADP expositions-1796 20 18 various various ADJ expositions-1796 20 19 sorts sort NOUN expositions-1796 20 20 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 21 1 some some PRON expositions-1796 21 2 of of ADP expositions-1796 21 3 these these DET expositions-1796 21 4 reasons reason NOUN expositions-1796 21 5 would would AUX expositions-1796 21 6 be be AUX expositions-1796 21 7 categorical categorical ADJ expositions-1796 21 8 in in ADP expositions-1796 21 9 the the DET expositions-1796 21 10 sense sense NOUN expositions-1796 21 11 that that SCONJ expositions-1796 21 12 they they PRON expositions-1796 21 13 apply apply VERB expositions-1796 21 14 to to ADP expositions-1796 21 15 agents agent NOUN expositions-1796 21 16 regardless regardless ADV expositions-1796 21 17 of of ADP expositions-1796 21 18 what what PRON expositions-1796 21 19 desires desire NOUN expositions-1796 21 20 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 21 21 goals goal NOUN expositions-1796 21 22 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 21 23 or or CCONJ expositions-1796 21 24 social social ADJ expositions-1796 21 25 allegiances allegiance NOUN expositions-1796 21 26 they they PRON expositions-1796 21 27 may may AUX expositions-1796 21 28 have have AUX expositions-1796 21 29 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 22 1 in in ADP expositions-1796 22 2 his his PRON expositions-1796 22 3 presentation presentation NOUN expositions-1796 22 4 of of ADP expositions-1796 22 5 his his PRON expositions-1796 22 6 view view NOUN expositions-1796 22 7 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 22 8 nagel nagel PROPN expositions-1796 22 9 affirms affirm VERB expositions-1796 22 10 all all DET expositions-1796 22 11 four four NUM expositions-1796 22 12 of of ADP expositions-1796 22 13 these these DET expositions-1796 22 14 claims.5 claims.5 NOUN expositions-1796 22 15 as as ADP expositions-1796 22 16 for for ADP expositions-1796 22 17 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 22 18 knowledge knowledge NOUN expositions-1796 22 19 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 22 20 in in ADP expositions-1796 22 21 what what PRON expositions-1796 22 22 follows follow VERB expositions-1796 22 23 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 22 24 we we PRON expositions-1796 22 25 can can AUX expositions-1796 22 26 remain remain VERB expositions-1796 22 27 relatively relatively ADV expositions-1796 22 28 non non ADJ expositions-1796 22 29 - - NOUN expositions-1796 22 30 committal committal ADJ expositions-1796 22 31 regarding regard VERB expositions-1796 22 32 what what PRON expositions-1796 22 33 it it PRON expositions-1796 22 34 is be AUX expositions-1796 22 35 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 22 36 assuming assume VERB expositions-1796 22 37 only only ADV expositions-1796 22 38 the the DET expositions-1796 22 39 following following NOUN expositions-1796 22 40 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 23 1 first first ADV expositions-1796 23 2 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 23 3 states state NOUN expositions-1796 23 4 of of ADP expositions-1796 23 5 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 23 6 knowledge knowledge NOUN expositions-1796 23 7 would would AUX expositions-1796 23 8 be be AUX expositions-1796 23 9 constituted constitute VERB expositions-1796 23 10 by by ADP expositions-1796 23 11 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 23 12 judgments judgment NOUN expositions-1796 23 13 or or CCONJ expositions-1796 23 14 beliefs belief NOUN expositions-1796 23 15 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 24 1 and and CCONJ expositions-1796 24 2 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 24 3 second second ADJ expositions-1796 24 4 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 24 5 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 24 6 judgments judgment NOUN expositions-1796 24 7 would would AUX expositions-1796 24 8 be be AUX expositions-1796 24 9 candidates candidate NOUN expositions-1796 24 10 for for ADP expositions-1796 24 11 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 24 12 knowledge knowledge NOUN expositions-1796 24 13 only only ADV expositions-1796 24 14 if if SCONJ expositions-1796 24 15 they they PRON expositions-1796 24 16 have have VERB expositions-1796 24 17 the the DET expositions-1796 24 18 proper proper ADJ expositions-1796 24 19 sort sort NOUN expositions-1796 24 20 of of ADP expositions-1796 24 21 etiology etiology NOUN expositions-1796 24 22 : : PUNCT expositions-1796 24 23 they they PRON expositions-1796 24 24 could could AUX expositions-1796 24 25 not not PART expositions-1796 24 26 be be AUX expositions-1796 24 27 the the DET expositions-1796 24 28 product product NOUN expositions-1796 24 29 of of ADP expositions-1796 24 30 luck luck NOUN expositions-1796 24 31 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 24 32 accident accident NOUN expositions-1796 24 33 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 24 34 or or CCONJ expositions-1796 24 35 the the DET expositions-1796 24 36 like like ADJ expositions-1796 24 37 but but CCONJ expositions-1796 24 38 must must AUX expositions-1796 24 39 be be AUX expositions-1796 24 40 “ " PUNCT expositions-1796 24 41 well well ADV expositions-1796 24 42 - - PUNCT expositions-1796 24 43 formed form VERB expositions-1796 24 44 ” " PUNCT expositions-1796 24 45 in in ADP expositions-1796 24 46 the the DET expositions-1796 24 47 sense sense NOUN expositions-1796 24 48 of of ADP expositions-1796 24 49 being be AUX expositions-1796 24 50 reliably reliably ADV expositions-1796 24 51 formed form VERB expositions-1796 24 52 or or CCONJ expositions-1796 24 53 the the DET expositions-1796 24 54 product product NOUN expositions-1796 24 55 of of ADP expositions-1796 24 56 cognitive cognitive ADJ expositions-1796 24 57 faculties faculty NOUN expositions-1796 24 58 that that PRON expositions-1796 24 59 are be AUX expositions-1796 24 60 working work VERB expositions-1796 24 61 well well ADV expositions-1796 24 62 in in ADP expositions-1796 24 63 a a DET expositions-1796 24 64 congenial congenial ADJ expositions-1796 24 65 environment environment NOUN expositions-1796 24 66 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 25 1 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 25 2 knowledge knowledge NOUN expositions-1796 25 3 probably probably ADV expositions-1796 25 4 requires require VERB expositions-1796 25 5 more more ADJ expositions-1796 25 6 than than ADP expositions-1796 25 7 this this PRON expositions-1796 25 8 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 25 9 but but CCONJ expositions-1796 25 10 i i PRON expositions-1796 25 11 ’ll ’ll AUX expositions-1796 25 12 assume assume VERB expositions-1796 25 13 it it PRON expositions-1796 25 14 would would AUX expositions-1796 25 15 involve involve VERB expositions-1796 25 16 at at ADP expositions-1796 25 17 least least ADJ expositions-1796 25 18 satisfying satisfy VERB expositions-1796 25 19 this this DET expositions-1796 25 20 “ " PUNCT expositions-1796 25 21 well well ADV expositions-1796 25 22 - - PUNCT expositions-1796 25 23 formedness formedness ADJ expositions-1796 25 24 ” " PUNCT expositions-1796 25 25 condition condition NOUN expositions-1796 25 26 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 26 1 while while SCONJ expositions-1796 26 2 nagel nagel PROPN expositions-1796 26 3 has have VERB expositions-1796 26 4 little little ADJ expositions-1796 26 5 to to PART expositions-1796 26 6 say say VERB expositions-1796 26 7 about about ADP expositions-1796 26 8 the the DET expositions-1796 26 9 nature nature NOUN expositions-1796 26 10 of of ADP expositions-1796 26 11 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 26 12 knowledge knowledge NOUN expositions-1796 26 13 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 26 14 he he PRON expositions-1796 26 15 also also ADV expositions-1796 26 16 accepts accept VERB expositions-1796 26 17 both both PRON expositions-1796 26 18 these these DET expositions-1796 26 19 claims.6 claims.6 NOUN expositions-1796 26 20 as as ADP expositions-1796 26 21 for for ADP expositions-1796 26 22 the the DET expositions-1796 26 23 evolutionary evolutionary ADJ expositions-1796 26 24 influence influence NOUN expositions-1796 26 25 on on ADP expositions-1796 26 26 our our PRON expositions-1796 26 27 cognitive cognitive ADJ expositions-1796 26 28 faculties faculty NOUN expositions-1796 26 29 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 26 30 i i PRON expositions-1796 26 31 will will AUX expositions-1796 26 32 assume assume VERB expositions-1796 26 33 that that SCONJ expositions-1796 26 34 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 26 35 according accord VERB expositions-1796 26 36 to to ADP expositions-1796 26 37 the the DET expositions-1796 26 38 picture picture NOUN expositions-1796 26 39 that that SCONJ expositions-1796 26 40 evolutionary evolutionary ADJ expositions-1796 26 41 biology biology NOUN expositions-1796 26 42 bequeaths bequeath VERB expositions-1796 26 43 us we PRON expositions-1796 26 44 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 26 45 natural natural ADJ expositions-1796 26 46 selection selection NOUN expositions-1796 26 47 has have AUX expositions-1796 26 48 rewarded reward VERB expositions-1796 26 49 whatever whatever DET expositions-1796 26 50 cognitive cognitive ADJ expositions-1796 26 51 traits trait NOUN expositions-1796 26 52 that that PRON expositions-1796 26 53 caused cause VERB expositions-1796 26 54 our our PRON expositions-1796 26 55 pleistocene pleistocene NOUN expositions-1796 26 56 ancestors ancestor NOUN expositions-1796 26 57 to to PART expositions-1796 26 58 maximize maximize VERB expositions-1796 26 59 the the DET expositions-1796 26 60 relative relative ADJ expositions-1796 26 61 representation representation NOUN expositions-1796 26 62 of of ADP expositions-1796 26 63 their their PRON expositions-1796 26 64 genes gene NOUN expositions-1796 26 65 in in ADP expositions-1796 26 66 the the DET expositions-1796 26 67 gene gene NOUN expositions-1796 26 68 pool pool NOUN expositions-1796 26 69 over over ADP expositions-1796 26 70 generations generation NOUN expositions-1796 26 71 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 26 72 often often ADV expositions-1796 26 73 doing do VERB expositions-1796 26 74 so so ADV expositions-1796 26 75 by by ADP expositions-1796 26 76 promoting promote VERB expositions-1796 26 77 their their PRON expositions-1796 26 78 survival survival NOUN expositions-1796 26 79 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 27 1 in in ADP expositions-1796 27 2 many many ADJ expositions-1796 27 3 cases case NOUN expositions-1796 27 4 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 27 5 i i PRON expositions-1796 27 6 ’ll ’ll AUX expositions-1796 27 7 also also ADV expositions-1796 27 8 assume assume VERB expositions-1796 27 9 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 27 10 we we PRON expositions-1796 27 11 have have VERB expositions-1796 27 12 excellent excellent ADJ expositions-1796 27 13 reason reason NOUN expositions-1796 27 14 to to PART expositions-1796 27 15 believe believe VERB expositions-1796 27 16 that that SCONJ expositions-1796 27 17 natural natural ADJ expositions-1796 27 18 selection selection NOUN expositions-1796 27 19 has have AUX expositions-1796 27 20 given give VERB expositions-1796 27 21 us we PRON expositions-1796 27 22 cognitive cognitive ADJ expositions-1796 27 23 capacities capacity NOUN expositions-1796 27 24 that that PRON expositions-1796 27 25 track track VERB expositions-1796 27 26 independent independent ADJ expositions-1796 27 27 truths truth NOUN expositions-1796 27 28 about about ADP expositions-1796 27 29 the the DET expositions-1796 27 30 world world NOUN expositions-1796 27 31 with with ADP expositions-1796 27 32 reasonable reasonable ADJ expositions-1796 27 33 accuracy accuracy NOUN expositions-1796 27 34 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 27 35 such such ADJ expositions-1796 27 36 as as ADP expositions-1796 27 37 truths truth NOUN expositions-1796 27 38 about about ADP expositions-1796 27 39 midsized midsized ADJ expositions-1796 27 40 material material NOUN expositions-1796 27 41 objects object NOUN expositions-1796 27 42 in in ADP expositions-1796 27 43 our our PRON expositions-1796 27 44 visual visual ADJ expositions-1796 27 45 field field NOUN expositions-1796 27 46 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 28 1 nagel nagel PROPN expositions-1796 28 2 agrees agree VERB expositions-1796 28 3 with with ADP expositions-1796 28 4 this this DET expositions-1796 28 5 last last ADJ expositions-1796 28 6 claim claim NOUN expositions-1796 28 7 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 28 8 but but CCONJ expositions-1796 28 9 holds hold VERB expositions-1796 28 10 that that SCONJ expositions-1796 28 11 it it PRON expositions-1796 28 12 has have VERB expositions-1796 28 13 no no DET expositions-1796 28 14 direct direct ADJ expositions-1796 28 15 bearing bearing NOUN expositions-1796 28 16 on on ADP expositions-1796 28 17 whether whether SCONJ expositions-1796 28 18 our our PRON expositions-1796 28 19 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 28 20 judgments judgment NOUN expositions-1796 28 21 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 28 22 which which PRON expositions-1796 28 23 are be AUX expositions-1796 28 24 practical practical ADJ expositions-1796 28 25 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 28 26 are be AUX expositions-1796 28 27 also also ADV expositions-1796 28 28 likely likely ADJ expositions-1796 28 29 to to PART expositions-1796 28 30 be be AUX expositions-1796 28 31 reasonably reasonably ADV expositions-1796 28 32 accurate.7 accurate.7 VERB expositions-1796 28 33 these these DET expositions-1796 28 34 introductory introductory ADJ expositions-1796 28 35 comments comment NOUN expositions-1796 28 36 having having AUX expositions-1796 28 37 been be AUX expositions-1796 28 38 made make VERB expositions-1796 28 39 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 28 40 we we PRON expositions-1796 28 41 can can AUX expositions-1796 28 42 see see VERB expositions-1796 28 43 that that SCONJ expositions-1796 28 44 the the DET expositions-1796 28 45 three three NUM expositions-1796 28 46 claims claim NOUN expositions-1796 28 47 stated state VERB expositions-1796 28 48 above above ADP expositions-1796 28 49 yield yield VERB expositions-1796 28 50 a a DET expositions-1796 28 51 puzzle puzzle NOUN expositions-1796 28 52 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 29 1 according accord VERB expositions-1796 29 2 to to ADP expositions-1796 29 3 this this DET expositions-1796 29 4 puzzle puzzle NOUN expositions-1796 29 5 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 29 6 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 29 7 knowledge knowledge NOUN expositions-1796 29 8 requires require VERB expositions-1796 29 9 that that SCONJ expositions-1796 29 10 some some PRON expositions-1796 29 11 of of ADP expositions-1796 29 12 our our PRON expositions-1796 29 13 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 29 14 judgments judgment NOUN expositions-1796 29 15 be be VERB expositions-1796 29 16 well well ADV expositions-1796 29 17 - - PUNCT expositions-1796 29 18 formed form VERB expositions-1796 29 19 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 29 20 which which PRON expositions-1796 29 21 is be AUX expositions-1796 29 22 what what PRON expositions-1796 29 23 claim claim NOUN expositions-1796 29 24 ( ( PUNCT expositions-1796 29 25 2 2 X expositions-1796 29 26 ) ) PUNCT expositions-1796 29 27 tells tell VERB expositions-1796 29 28 us we PRON expositions-1796 29 29 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 30 1 but but CCONJ expositions-1796 30 2 it it PRON expositions-1796 30 3 is be AUX expositions-1796 30 4 difficult difficult ADJ expositions-1796 30 5 to to PART expositions-1796 30 6 see see VERB expositions-1796 30 7 how how SCONJ expositions-1796 30 8 these these DET expositions-1796 30 9 judgments judgment NOUN expositions-1796 30 10 could could AUX expositions-1796 30 11 be be AUX expositions-1796 30 12 well well ADV expositions-1796 30 13 - - PUNCT expositions-1796 30 14 formed form VERB expositions-1796 30 15 if if SCONJ expositions-1796 30 16 the the DET expositions-1796 30 17 forces force NOUN expositions-1796 30 18 of of ADP expositions-1796 30 19 natural natural ADJ expositions-1796 30 20 selection selection NOUN expositions-1796 30 21 have have AUX expositions-1796 30 22 deeply deeply ADV expositions-1796 30 23 influenced influence VERB expositions-1796 30 24 the the DET expositions-1796 30 25 workings working NOUN expositions-1796 30 26 of of ADP expositions-1796 30 27 our our PRON expositions-1796 30 28 capacity capacity NOUN expositions-1796 30 29 for for ADP expositions-1796 30 30 forming form VERB expositions-1796 30 31 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 30 32 judgments judgment NOUN expositions-1796 30 33 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 30 34 which which PRON expositions-1796 30 35 is be AUX expositions-1796 30 36 what what PRON expositions-1796 30 37 claim claim NOUN expositions-1796 30 38 ( ( PUNCT expositions-1796 30 39 3 3 X expositions-1796 30 40 ) ) PUNCT expositions-1796 30 41 says say VERB expositions-1796 30 42 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 31 1 these these DET expositions-1796 31 2 forces force NOUN expositions-1796 31 3 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 31 4 after after ADV expositions-1796 31 5 all all ADV expositions-1796 31 6 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 31 7 are be AUX expositions-1796 31 8 geared gear VERB expositions-1796 31 9 toward toward ADP expositions-1796 31 10 producing produce VERB expositions-1796 31 11 not not PART expositions-1796 31 12 true true ADJ expositions-1796 31 13 beliefs belief NOUN expositions-1796 31 14 but but CCONJ expositions-1796 31 15 maximizing maximize VERB expositions-1796 31 16 the the DET expositions-1796 31 17 relative relative ADJ expositions-1796 31 18 representation representation NOUN expositions-1796 31 19 of of ADP expositions-1796 31 20 the the DET expositions-1796 31 21 genes gene NOUN expositions-1796 31 22 of of ADP expositions-1796 31 23 ancestral ancestral ADJ expositions-1796 31 24 humans human NOUN expositions-1796 31 25 in in ADP expositions-1796 31 26 the the DET expositions-1796 31 27 gene gene NOUN expositions-1796 31 28 pool pool NOUN expositions-1796 31 29 over over ADP expositions-1796 31 30 generations generation NOUN expositions-1796 31 31 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 32 1 in in ADP expositions-1796 32 2 certain certain ADJ expositions-1796 32 3 cases case NOUN expositions-1796 32 4 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 32 5 as as SCONJ expositions-1796 32 6 already already ADV expositions-1796 32 7 noted note VERB expositions-1796 32 8 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 32 9 it it PRON expositions-1796 32 10 is be AUX expositions-1796 32 11 plausible plausible ADJ expositions-1796 32 12 to to PART expositions-1796 32 13 hold hold VERB expositions-1796 32 14 that that SCONJ expositions-1796 32 15 this this PRON expositions-1796 32 16 resulted result VERB expositions-1796 32 17 in in ADP expositions-1796 32 18 cognitive cognitive ADJ expositions-1796 32 19 capacities capacity NOUN expositions-1796 32 20 that that PRON expositions-1796 32 21 accurately accurately ADV expositions-1796 32 22 track track VERB expositions-1796 32 23 independent independent ADJ expositions-1796 32 24 facts fact NOUN expositions-1796 32 25 in in ADP expositions-1796 32 26 our our PRON expositions-1796 32 27 environment environment NOUN expositions-1796 32 28 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 32 29 such such ADJ expositions-1796 32 30 as as ADP expositions-1796 32 31 ordinary ordinary ADJ expositions-1796 32 32 midsized midsized ADJ expositions-1796 32 33 material material NOUN expositions-1796 32 34 objects object NOUN expositions-1796 32 35 in in ADP expositions-1796 32 36 our our PRON expositions-1796 32 37 visual visual ADJ expositions-1796 32 38 field field NOUN expositions-1796 32 39 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 33 1 but but CCONJ expositions-1796 33 2 if if SCONJ expositions-1796 33 3 there there PRON expositions-1796 33 4 were be VERB expositions-1796 33 5 non non ADJ expositions-1796 33 6 - - ADJ expositions-1796 33 7 natural natural ADJ expositions-1796 33 8 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 33 9 facts fact NOUN expositions-1796 33 10 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 33 11 it it PRON expositions-1796 33 12 is be AUX expositions-1796 33 13 very very ADV expositions-1796 33 14 difficult difficult ADJ expositions-1796 33 15 to to PART expositions-1796 33 16 see see VERB expositions-1796 33 17 how how SCONJ expositions-1796 33 18 dissolving dissolve VERB expositions-1796 33 19 the the DET expositions-1796 33 20 debunker debunker NOUN expositions-1796 33 21 ’s ’s PART expositions-1796 33 22 puzzle puzzle NOUN expositions-1796 33 23 40 40 NUM expositions-1796 33 24 the the DET expositions-1796 33 25 forces force NOUN expositions-1796 33 26 of of ADP expositions-1796 33 27 natural natural ADJ expositions-1796 33 28 selection selection NOUN expositions-1796 33 29 would would AUX expositions-1796 33 30 have have AUX expositions-1796 33 31 influenced influence VERB expositions-1796 33 32 the the DET expositions-1796 33 33 workings working NOUN expositions-1796 33 34 of of ADP expositions-1796 33 35 our our PRON expositions-1796 33 36 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 33 37 faculty faculty NOUN expositions-1796 33 38 in in ADP expositions-1796 33 39 such such DET expositions-1796 33 40 a a DET expositions-1796 33 41 way way NOUN expositions-1796 33 42 that that PRON expositions-1796 33 43 we we PRON expositions-1796 33 44 reliably reliably ADV expositions-1796 33 45 grasp grasp VERB expositions-1796 33 46 them they PRON expositions-1796 33 47 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 34 1 the the DET expositions-1796 34 2 difficulty difficulty NOUN expositions-1796 34 3 that that PRON expositions-1796 34 4 faces face VERB expositions-1796 34 5 non non NOUN expositions-1796 34 6 - - NOUN expositions-1796 34 7 naturalists naturalist NOUN expositions-1796 34 8 is be AUX expositions-1796 34 9 described describe VERB expositions-1796 34 10 in in ADP expositions-1796 34 11 different different ADJ expositions-1796 34 12 ways way NOUN expositions-1796 34 13 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 35 1 sharon sharon PROPN expositions-1796 35 2 street street PROPN expositions-1796 35 3 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 35 4 whose whose DET expositions-1796 35 5 version version NOUN expositions-1796 35 6 of of ADP expositions-1796 35 7 the the DET expositions-1796 35 8 debunker debunker NOUN expositions-1796 35 9 ’s ’s PART expositions-1796 35 10 puzzle puzzle NOUN expositions-1796 35 11 nagel nagel PROPN expositions-1796 35 12 accepts accept VERB expositions-1796 35 13 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 35 14 holds hold VERB expositions-1796 35 15 that that SCONJ expositions-1796 35 16 since since SCONJ expositions-1796 35 17 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 35 18 as as ADP expositions-1796 35 19 a a DET expositions-1796 35 20 conceptual conceptual ADJ expositions-1796 35 21 matter matter NOUN expositions-1796 35 22 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 35 23 there there PRON expositions-1796 35 24 could could AUX expositions-1796 35 25 be be AUX expositions-1796 35 26 any any DET expositions-1796 35 27 number number NOUN expositions-1796 35 28 of of ADP expositions-1796 35 29 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 35 30 systems system NOUN expositions-1796 35 31 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 35 32 we we PRON expositions-1796 35 33 have have VERB expositions-1796 35 34 little little ADJ expositions-1796 35 35 reason reason NOUN expositions-1796 35 36 to to PART expositions-1796 35 37 hold hold VERB expositions-1796 35 38 that that DET expositions-1796 35 39 evolution evolution NOUN expositions-1796 35 40 would would AUX expositions-1796 35 41 have have AUX expositions-1796 35 42 “ " PUNCT expositions-1796 35 43 pushed push VERB expositions-1796 35 44 ” " PUNCT expositions-1796 35 45 us we PRON expositions-1796 35 46 toward toward ADP expositions-1796 35 47 the the DET expositions-1796 35 48 correct correct ADJ expositions-1796 35 49 one.8 one.8 NOUN expositions-1796 35 50 given give VERB expositions-1796 35 51 that that SCONJ expositions-1796 35 52 non non ADJ expositions-1796 35 53 - - ADJ expositions-1796 35 54 natural natural ADJ expositions-1796 35 55 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 35 56 facts fact NOUN expositions-1796 35 57 are be AUX expositions-1796 35 58 not not PART expositions-1796 35 59 the the DET expositions-1796 35 60 sort sort NOUN expositions-1796 35 61 of of ADP expositions-1796 35 62 thing thing NOUN expositions-1796 35 63 that that PRON expositions-1796 35 64 could could AUX expositions-1796 35 65 enter enter VERB expositions-1796 35 66 into into ADP expositions-1796 35 67 causal causal ADJ expositions-1796 35 68 relations relation NOUN expositions-1796 35 69 and and CCONJ expositions-1796 35 70 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 35 71 hence hence ADV expositions-1796 35 72 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 35 73 be be AUX expositions-1796 35 74 tracked track VERB expositions-1796 35 75 by by ADP expositions-1796 35 76 our our PRON expositions-1796 35 77 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 35 78 faculty faculty NOUN expositions-1796 35 79 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 35 80 there there PRON expositions-1796 35 81 seems seem VERB expositions-1796 35 82 to to PART expositions-1796 35 83 be be AUX expositions-1796 35 84 little little ADJ expositions-1796 35 85 prospect prospect NOUN expositions-1796 35 86 of of ADP expositions-1796 35 87 offering offer VERB expositions-1796 35 88 any any DET expositions-1796 35 89 kind kind NOUN expositions-1796 35 90 of of ADP expositions-1796 35 91 account account NOUN expositions-1796 35 92 according accord VERB expositions-1796 35 93 to to ADP expositions-1796 35 94 which which PRON expositions-1796 35 95 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 35 96 surprisingly surprisingly ADV expositions-1796 35 97 enough enough ADV expositions-1796 35 98 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 35 99 our our PRON expositions-1796 35 100 evolutionary evolutionary ADJ expositions-1796 35 101 heritage heritage NOUN expositions-1796 35 102 put put VERB expositions-1796 35 103 us we PRON expositions-1796 35 104 in in ADP expositions-1796 35 105 a a DET expositions-1796 35 106 good good ADJ expositions-1796 35 107 position position NOUN expositions-1796 35 108 to to PART expositions-1796 35 109 track track VERB expositions-1796 35 110 them they PRON expositions-1796 35 111 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 36 1 something something PRON expositions-1796 36 2 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 36 3 it it PRON expositions-1796 36 4 appears appear VERB expositions-1796 36 5 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 36 6 has have VERB expositions-1796 36 7 to to PART expositions-1796 36 8 give give VERB expositions-1796 36 9 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 37 1 responses response NOUN expositions-1796 37 2 to to ADP expositions-1796 37 3 this this DET expositions-1796 37 4 puzzle puzzle NOUN expositions-1796 37 5 fall fall VERB expositions-1796 37 6 into into ADP expositions-1796 37 7 three three NUM expositions-1796 37 8 broad broad ADJ expositions-1796 37 9 categories category NOUN expositions-1796 37 10 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 38 1 some some DET expositions-1796 38 2 philosophers philosopher NOUN expositions-1796 38 3 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 38 4 such such ADJ expositions-1796 38 5 as as ADP expositions-1796 38 6 richard richard PROPN expositions-1796 38 7 joyce joyce PROPN expositions-1796 38 8 and and CCONJ expositions-1796 38 9 jonas jonas PROPN expositions-1796 38 10 olson olson PROPN expositions-1796 38 11 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 38 12 propose propose VERB expositions-1796 38 13 that that SCONJ expositions-1796 38 14 we we PRON expositions-1796 38 15 reject reject VERB expositions-1796 38 16 claim claim NOUN expositions-1796 38 17 ( ( PUNCT expositions-1796 38 18 2 2 NUM expositions-1796 38 19 ) ) PUNCT expositions-1796 38 20 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 38 21 giving give VERB expositions-1796 38 22 up up ADP expositions-1796 38 23 the the DET expositions-1796 38 24 idea idea NOUN expositions-1796 38 25 that that SCONJ expositions-1796 38 26 there there PRON expositions-1796 38 27 is be VERB expositions-1796 38 28 any any DET expositions-1796 38 29 credible credible ADJ expositions-1796 38 30 account account NOUN expositions-1796 38 31 of of ADP expositions-1796 38 32 how how SCONJ expositions-1796 38 33 we we PRON expositions-1796 38 34 would would AUX expositions-1796 38 35 gain gain VERB expositions-1796 38 36 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 38 37 knowledge knowledge NOUN expositions-1796 38 38 if if SCONJ expositions-1796 38 39 there there PRON expositions-1796 38 40 were be VERB expositions-1796 38 41 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 38 42 facts.9 facts.9 NOUN expositions-1796 38 43 these these DET expositions-1796 38 44 philosophers philosopher NOUN expositions-1796 38 45 embrace embrace VERB expositions-1796 38 46 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 38 47 skepticism skepticism NOUN expositions-1796 38 48 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 39 1 other other ADJ expositions-1796 39 2 philosophers philosopher NOUN expositions-1796 39 3 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 39 4 such such ADJ expositions-1796 39 5 as as ADP expositions-1796 39 6 david david PROPN expositions-1796 39 7 copp copp PROPN expositions-1796 39 8 and and CCONJ expositions-1796 39 9 peter peter PROPN expositions-1796 39 10 railton railton PROPN expositions-1796 39 11 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 39 12 recommend recommend VERB expositions-1796 39 13 that that SCONJ expositions-1796 39 14 we we PRON expositions-1796 39 15 reject reject VERB expositions-1796 39 16 claim claim NOUN expositions-1796 39 17 ( ( PUNCT expositions-1796 39 18 1 1 NUM expositions-1796 39 19 ) ) PUNCT expositions-1796 39 20 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 39 21 embracing embrace VERB expositions-1796 39 22 metaethical metaethical ADJ expositions-1796 39 23 naturalism naturalism NOUN expositions-1796 39 24 according accord VERB expositions-1796 39 25 to to ADP expositions-1796 39 26 which which PRON expositions-1796 39 27 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 39 28 facts fact NOUN expositions-1796 39 29 are be AUX expositions-1796 39 30 ordinary ordinary ADJ expositions-1796 39 31 natural natural ADJ expositions-1796 39 32 facts fact NOUN expositions-1796 39 33 that that SCONJ expositions-1796 39 34 our our PRON expositions-1796 39 35 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 39 36 judgments judgment NOUN expositions-1796 39 37 could could AUX expositions-1796 39 38 track track VERB expositions-1796 39 39 by by ADP expositions-1796 39 40 bearing bear VERB expositions-1796 39 41 causal causal ADJ expositions-1796 39 42 relations relation NOUN expositions-1796 39 43 to to PART expositions-1796 39 44 them.10 them.10 VERB expositions-1796 39 45 these these DET expositions-1796 39 46 philosophers philosopher NOUN expositions-1796 39 47 reject reject VERB expositions-1796 39 48 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 39 49 non non NOUN expositions-1796 39 50 - - NOUN expositions-1796 39 51 naturalism naturalism NOUN expositions-1796 39 52 in in ADP expositions-1796 39 53 favor favor NOUN expositions-1796 39 54 of of ADP expositions-1796 39 55 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 39 56 naturalism naturalism NOUN expositions-1796 39 57 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 40 1 finally finally ADV expositions-1796 40 2 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 40 3 other other ADJ expositions-1796 40 4 philosophers philosopher NOUN expositions-1796 40 5 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 40 6 such such ADJ expositions-1796 40 7 as as ADP expositions-1796 40 8 nagel nagel PROPN expositions-1796 40 9 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 40 10 propose propose VERB expositions-1796 40 11 to to PART expositions-1796 40 12 reject reject VERB expositions-1796 40 13 claim claim NOUN expositions-1796 40 14 ( ( PUNCT expositions-1796 40 15 3 3 NUM expositions-1796 40 16 ) ) PUNCT expositions-1796 40 17 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 40 18 at at ADP expositions-1796 40 19 least least ADJ expositions-1796 40 20 when when SCONJ expositions-1796 40 21 it it PRON expositions-1796 40 22 is be AUX expositions-1796 40 23 understood understand VERB expositions-1796 40 24 to to PART expositions-1796 40 25 incorporate incorporate VERB expositions-1796 40 26 the the DET expositions-1796 40 27 assumption assumption NOUN expositions-1796 40 28 that that SCONJ expositions-1796 40 29 the the DET expositions-1796 40 30 forces force NOUN expositions-1796 40 31 of of ADP expositions-1796 40 32 natural natural ADJ expositions-1796 40 33 section section NOUN expositions-1796 40 34 select select NOUN expositions-1796 40 35 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 40 36 in in ADP expositions-1796 40 37 the the DET expositions-1796 40 38 first first ADJ expositions-1796 40 39 instance instance NOUN expositions-1796 40 40 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 40 41 not not PART expositions-1796 40 42 for for ADP expositions-1796 40 43 true true ADJ expositions-1796 40 44 beliefs belief NOUN expositions-1796 40 45 but but CCONJ expositions-1796 40 46 traits trait NOUN expositions-1796 40 47 that that PRON expositions-1796 40 48 maximize maximize VERB expositions-1796 40 49 the the DET expositions-1796 40 50 relative relative ADJ expositions-1796 40 51 representation representation NOUN expositions-1796 40 52 of of ADP expositions-1796 40 53 genes gene NOUN expositions-1796 40 54 in in ADP expositions-1796 40 55 the the DET expositions-1796 40 56 gene gene NOUN expositions-1796 40 57 pool pool NOUN expositions-1796 40 58 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 41 1 these these DET expositions-1796 41 2 philosophers philosopher NOUN expositions-1796 41 3 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 41 4 then then ADV expositions-1796 41 5 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 41 6 reject reject VERB expositions-1796 41 7 the the DET expositions-1796 41 8 deliverances deliverance NOUN expositions-1796 41 9 of of ADP expositions-1796 41 10 the the DET expositions-1796 41 11 standard standard ADJ expositions-1796 41 12 evolutionary evolutionary ADJ expositions-1796 41 13 picture.11 picture.11 PROPN expositions-1796 41 14 in in ADP expositions-1796 41 15 nagel nagel PROPN expositions-1796 41 16 ’s ’s PART expositions-1796 41 17 case case NOUN expositions-1796 41 18 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 41 19 this this DET expositions-1796 41 20 rejection rejection NOUN expositions-1796 41 21 is be AUX expositions-1796 41 22 accompanied accompany VERB expositions-1796 41 23 by by ADP expositions-1796 41 24 a a DET expositions-1796 41 25 positive positive ADJ expositions-1796 41 26 explanatory explanatory ADJ expositions-1796 41 27 hypothesis hypothesis NOUN expositions-1796 41 28 — — PUNCT expositions-1796 41 29 what what PRON expositions-1796 41 30 he he PRON expositions-1796 41 31 calls call VERB expositions-1796 41 32 “ " PUNCT expositions-1796 41 33 the the DET expositions-1796 41 34 teleological teleological NOUN expositions-1796 41 35 hypothesis”—that hypothesis”—that PRON expositions-1796 41 36 is be AUX expositions-1796 41 37 supposed suppose VERB expositions-1796 41 38 to to PART expositions-1796 41 39 explain explain VERB expositions-1796 41 40 how how SCONJ expositions-1796 41 41 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 41 42 given give VERB expositions-1796 41 43 our our PRON expositions-1796 41 44 evolutionary evolutionary ADJ expositions-1796 41 45 history history NOUN expositions-1796 41 46 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 41 47 we we PRON expositions-1796 41 48 might might AUX expositions-1796 41 49 have have AUX expositions-1796 41 50 arrived arrive VERB expositions-1796 41 51 at at ADP expositions-1796 41 52 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 41 53 knowledge knowledge NOUN expositions-1796 41 54 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 42 1 according accord VERB expositions-1796 42 2 to to ADP expositions-1796 42 3 this this DET expositions-1796 42 4 hypothesis hypothesis NOUN expositions-1796 42 5 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 42 6 “ " PUNCT expositions-1796 42 7 the the DET expositions-1796 42 8 natural natural ADJ expositions-1796 42 9 world world NOUN expositions-1796 42 10 would would AUX expositions-1796 42 11 have have VERB expositions-1796 42 12 a a DET expositions-1796 42 13 propensity propensity NOUN expositions-1796 42 14 to to PART expositions-1796 42 15 give give VERB expositions-1796 42 16 rise rise NOUN expositions-1796 42 17 to to ADP expositions-1796 42 18 beings being NOUN expositions-1796 42 19 of of ADP expositions-1796 42 20 the the DET expositions-1796 42 21 kind kind NOUN expositions-1796 42 22 that that PRON expositions-1796 42 23 have have VERB expositions-1796 42 24 a a DET expositions-1796 42 25 good good ADJ expositions-1796 42 26 — — PUNCT expositions-1796 42 27 beings being NOUN expositions-1796 42 28 for for ADP expositions-1796 42 29 which which PRON expositions-1796 42 30 and and CCONJ expositions-1796 42 31 of of ADP expositions-1796 42 32 the the DET expositions-1796 42 33 things thing NOUN expositions-1796 42 34 can can AUX expositions-1796 42 35 be be AUX expositions-1796 42 36 good good ADJ expositions-1796 42 37 or or CCONJ expositions-1796 42 38 bad bad ADJ expositions-1796 42 39 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 43 1 ”12 ”12 PROPN expositions-1796 43 2 these these DET expositions-1796 43 3 beings being NOUN expositions-1796 43 4 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 43 5 nagel nagel PROPN expositions-1796 43 6 says say VERB expositions-1796 43 7 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 43 8 “ " PUNCT expositions-1796 43 9 are be AUX expositions-1796 43 10 all all DET expositions-1796 43 11 the the DET expositions-1796 43 12 actual actual ADJ expositions-1796 43 13 and and CCONJ expositions-1796 43 14 possible possible ADJ expositions-1796 43 15 forms form NOUN expositions-1796 43 16 of of ADP expositions-1796 43 17 life life NOUN expositions-1796 43 18 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 44 1 they they PRON expositions-1796 44 2 have have AUX expositions-1796 44 3 appeared appear VERB expositions-1796 44 4 through through ADP expositions-1796 44 5 the the DET expositions-1796 44 6 historical historical ADJ expositions-1796 44 7 process process NOUN expositions-1796 44 8 of of ADP expositions-1796 44 9 evolution evolution NOUN expositions-1796 44 10 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 44 11 but but CCONJ expositions-1796 44 12 part part NOUN expositions-1796 44 13 of of ADP expositions-1796 44 14 the the DET expositions-1796 44 15 explanation explanation NOUN expositions-1796 44 16 for for ADP expositions-1796 44 17 the the DET expositions-1796 44 18 existence existence NOUN expositions-1796 44 19 of of ADP expositions-1796 44 20 that that DET expositions-1796 44 21 process process NOUN expositions-1796 44 22 and and CCONJ expositions-1796 44 23 of of ADP expositions-1796 44 24 the the DET expositions-1796 44 25 possibilities possibility NOUN expositions-1796 44 26 on on ADP expositions-1796 44 27 which which PRON expositions-1796 44 28 natural natural ADJ expositions-1796 44 29 selection selection NOUN expositions-1796 44 30 operates operate NOUN expositions-1796 44 31 would would AUX expositions-1796 44 32 be be AUX expositions-1796 44 33 that that SCONJ expositions-1796 44 34 they they PRON expositions-1796 44 35 bring bring VERB expositions-1796 44 36 value value NOUN expositions-1796 44 37 into into ADP expositions-1796 44 38 the the DET expositions-1796 44 39 world world NOUN expositions-1796 44 40 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 44 41 in in ADP expositions-1796 44 42 a a DET expositions-1796 44 43 great great ADJ expositions-1796 44 44 variety variety NOUN expositions-1796 44 45 of of ADP expositions-1796 44 46 forms form NOUN expositions-1796 44 47 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 45 1 ”13 ”13 PROPN expositions-1796 45 2 nagel nagel PROPN expositions-1796 45 3 continues continue VERB expositions-1796 45 4 : : PUNCT expositions-1796 45 5 this this PRON expositions-1796 45 6 is be AUX expositions-1796 45 7 a a DET expositions-1796 45 8 revision revision NOUN expositions-1796 45 9 of of ADP expositions-1796 45 10 the the DET expositions-1796 45 11 darwinian darwinian ADJ expositions-1796 45 12 picture picture NOUN expositions-1796 45 13 rather rather ADV expositions-1796 45 14 than than ADP expositions-1796 45 15 an an DET expositions-1796 45 16 outright outright ADJ expositions-1796 45 17 denial denial NOUN expositions-1796 45 18 of of ADP expositions-1796 45 19 it it PRON expositions-1796 45 20 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 46 1 a a DET expositions-1796 46 2 teleological teleological ADJ expositions-1796 46 3 hypothesis hypothesis NOUN expositions-1796 46 4 will will AUX expositions-1796 46 5 acknowledge acknowledge VERB expositions-1796 46 6 that that SCONJ expositions-1796 46 7 the the DET expositions-1796 46 8 details detail NOUN expositions-1796 46 9 of of ADP expositions-1796 46 10 that that DET expositions-1796 46 11 historical historical ADJ expositions-1796 46 12 development development NOUN expositions-1796 46 13 are be AUX expositions-1796 46 14 explained explain VERB expositions-1796 46 15 largely largely ADV expositions-1796 46 16 through through ADP expositions-1796 46 17 natural natural ADJ expositions-1796 46 18 selection selection NOUN expositions-1796 46 19 among among ADP expositions-1796 46 20 the the DET expositions-1796 46 21 available available ADJ expositions-1796 46 22 possibilities possibility NOUN expositions-1796 46 23 on on ADP expositions-1796 46 24 the the DET expositions-1796 46 25 basis basis NOUN expositions-1796 46 26 of of ADP expositions-1796 46 27 reproductive reproductive ADJ expositions-1796 46 28 fitness fitness NOUN expositions-1796 46 29 in in ADP expositions-1796 46 30 changing change VERB expositions-1796 46 31 environments environment NOUN expositions-1796 46 32 [ [ X expositions-1796 46 33 … … X expositions-1796 46 34 ] ] X expositions-1796 46 35 the the DET expositions-1796 46 36 teleological teleological ADJ expositions-1796 46 37 hypothesis hypothesis NOUN expositions-1796 46 38 is be AUX expositions-1796 46 39 that that SCONJ expositions-1796 46 40 these these DET expositions-1796 46 41 things thing NOUN expositions-1796 46 42 may may AUX expositions-1796 46 43 be be AUX expositions-1796 46 44 determined determine VERB expositions-1796 46 45 not not PART expositions-1796 46 46 merely merely ADV expositions-1796 46 47 by by ADP expositions-1796 46 48 value value NOUN expositions-1796 46 49 - - PUNCT expositions-1796 46 50 free free ADJ expositions-1796 46 51 chemistry chemistry NOUN expositions-1796 46 52 and and CCONJ expositions-1796 46 53 physics physics NOUN expositions-1796 46 54 but but CCONJ expositions-1796 46 55 also also ADV expositions-1796 46 56 by by ADP expositions-1796 46 57 something something PRON expositions-1796 46 58 else else ADV expositions-1796 46 59 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 46 60 namely namely ADV expositions-1796 46 61 a a DET expositions-1796 46 62 cosmic cosmic ADJ expositions-1796 46 63 predisposition predisposition NOUN expositions-1796 46 64 to to ADP expositions-1796 46 65 the the DET expositions-1796 46 66 formation formation NOUN expositions-1796 46 67 of of ADP expositions-1796 46 68 life life NOUN expositions-1796 46 69 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 46 70 consciousness consciousness NOUN expositions-1796 46 71 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 46 72 and and CCONJ expositions-1796 46 73 the the DET expositions-1796 46 74 value value NOUN expositions-1796 46 75 that that PRON expositions-1796 46 76 is be AUX expositions-1796 46 77 inseparable inseparable ADJ expositions-1796 46 78 from from ADP expositions-1796 46 79 them.14 them.14 NOUN expositions-1796 46 80 41 41 NUM expositions-1796 46 81 cuneo cuneo NOUN expositions-1796 46 82 in in ADP expositions-1796 46 83 sum sum NOUN expositions-1796 46 84 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 46 85 given give VERB expositions-1796 46 86 the the DET expositions-1796 46 87 teleological teleological ADJ expositions-1796 46 88 hypothesis hypothesis NOUN expositions-1796 46 89 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 46 90 it it PRON expositions-1796 46 91 would would AUX expositions-1796 46 92 be be AUX expositions-1796 46 93 no no DET expositions-1796 46 94 surprise surprise NOUN expositions-1796 46 95 that that SCONJ expositions-1796 46 96 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 46 97 if if SCONJ expositions-1796 46 98 there there PRON expositions-1796 46 99 were be VERB expositions-1796 46 100 conscious conscious ADJ expositions-1796 46 101 beings being NOUN expositions-1796 46 102 ( ( PUNCT expositions-1796 46 103 as as SCONJ expositions-1796 46 104 there there PRON expositions-1796 46 105 are be VERB expositions-1796 46 106 ) ) PUNCT expositions-1796 46 107 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 46 108 then then ADV expositions-1796 46 109 there there PRON expositions-1796 46 110 would would AUX expositions-1796 46 111 also also ADV expositions-1796 46 112 be be AUX expositions-1796 46 113 values value NOUN expositions-1796 46 114 realistically realistically ADV expositions-1796 46 115 understood understand VERB expositions-1796 46 116 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 47 1 and and CCONJ expositions-1796 47 2 given give VERB expositions-1796 47 3 that that SCONJ expositions-1796 47 4 there there PRON expositions-1796 47 5 are be VERB expositions-1796 47 6 such such ADJ expositions-1796 47 7 values value NOUN expositions-1796 47 8 — — PUNCT expositions-1796 47 9 including include VERB expositions-1796 47 10 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 47 11 ones one NOUN expositions-1796 47 12 — — PUNCT expositions-1796 47 13 it it PRON expositions-1796 47 14 would would AUX expositions-1796 47 15 be be AUX expositions-1796 47 16 no no DET expositions-1796 47 17 surprise surprise NOUN expositions-1796 47 18 that that SCONJ expositions-1796 47 19 we we PRON expositions-1796 47 20 could could AUX expositions-1796 47 21 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 47 22 when when SCONJ expositions-1796 47 23 all all PRON expositions-1796 47 24 goes go VERB expositions-1796 47 25 well well ADV expositions-1796 47 26 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 47 27 know know VERB expositions-1796 47 28 them they PRON expositions-1796 47 29 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 48 1 that that PRON expositions-1796 48 2 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 48 3 too too ADV expositions-1796 48 4 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 48 5 would would AUX expositions-1796 48 6 be be AUX expositions-1796 48 7 a a DET expositions-1796 48 8 result result NOUN expositions-1796 48 9 of of ADP expositions-1796 48 10 the the DET expositions-1796 48 11 “ " PUNCT expositions-1796 48 12 cosmic cosmic ADJ expositions-1796 48 13 predisposition predisposition NOUN expositions-1796 48 14 ” " PUNCT expositions-1796 48 15 that that PRON expositions-1796 48 16 drives drive VERB expositions-1796 48 17 the the DET expositions-1796 48 18 evolutionary evolutionary ADJ expositions-1796 48 19 process process NOUN expositions-1796 48 20 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 49 1 i i PRON expositions-1796 49 2 believe believe VERB expositions-1796 49 3 that that SCONJ expositions-1796 49 4 we we PRON expositions-1796 49 5 should should AUX expositions-1796 49 6 reject reject VERB expositions-1796 49 7 each each PRON expositions-1796 49 8 of of ADP expositions-1796 49 9 these these DET expositions-1796 49 10 three three NUM expositions-1796 49 11 ways way NOUN expositions-1796 49 12 of of ADP expositions-1796 49 13 responding respond VERB expositions-1796 49 14 to to ADP expositions-1796 49 15 the the DET expositions-1796 49 16 debunker debunker NOUN expositions-1796 49 17 ’s ’s PART expositions-1796 49 18 puzzle puzzle NOUN expositions-1796 49 19 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 50 1 rather rather ADV expositions-1796 50 2 than than ADP expositions-1796 50 3 surrender surrender VERB expositions-1796 50 4 any any PRON expositions-1796 50 5 of of ADP expositions-1796 50 6 the the DET expositions-1796 50 7 claims claim NOUN expositions-1796 50 8 that that PRON expositions-1796 50 9 constitute constitute VERB expositions-1796 50 10 the the DET expositions-1796 50 11 puzzle puzzle NOUN expositions-1796 50 12 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 50 13 the the DET expositions-1796 50 14 best good ADJ expositions-1796 50 15 strategy strategy NOUN expositions-1796 50 16 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 50 17 in in ADP expositions-1796 50 18 my my PRON expositions-1796 50 19 view view NOUN expositions-1796 50 20 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 50 21 is be AUX expositions-1796 50 22 to to PART expositions-1796 50 23 dissolve dissolve VERB expositions-1796 50 24 it it PRON expositions-1796 50 25 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 50 26 contending contend VERB expositions-1796 50 27 that that SCONJ expositions-1796 50 28 it it PRON expositions-1796 50 29 fails fail VERB expositions-1796 50 30 to to PART expositions-1796 50 31 generate generate VERB expositions-1796 50 32 any any DET expositions-1796 50 33 reason reason NOUN expositions-1796 50 34 to to PART expositions-1796 50 35 reject reject VERB expositions-1796 50 36 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 50 37 nonnaturalism nonnaturalism NOUN expositions-1796 50 38 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 51 1 if if SCONJ expositions-1796 51 2 one one PRON expositions-1796 51 3 is be AUX expositions-1796 51 4 a a DET expositions-1796 51 5 non non ADJ expositions-1796 51 6 - - NOUN expositions-1796 51 7 naturalist naturalist NOUN expositions-1796 51 8 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 51 9 as as SCONJ expositions-1796 51 10 nagel nagel PROPN expositions-1796 51 11 is be AUX expositions-1796 51 12 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 51 13 the the DET expositions-1796 51 14 reasons reason NOUN expositions-1796 51 15 for for ADP expositions-1796 51 16 pursuing pursue VERB expositions-1796 51 17 this this DET expositions-1796 51 18 strategy strategy NOUN expositions-1796 51 19 are be AUX expositions-1796 51 20 at at ADP expositions-1796 51 21 least least ADJ expositions-1796 51 22 these these PRON expositions-1796 51 23 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 52 1 for for ADP expositions-1796 52 2 one one NUM expositions-1796 52 3 thing thing NOUN expositions-1796 52 4 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 52 5 non non NOUN expositions-1796 52 6 - - NOUN expositions-1796 52 7 naturalists naturalist NOUN expositions-1796 52 8 should should AUX expositions-1796 52 9 find find VERB expositions-1796 52 10 all all DET expositions-1796 52 11 three three NUM expositions-1796 52 12 claims claim NOUN expositions-1796 52 13 that that PRON expositions-1796 52 14 compose compose VERB expositions-1796 52 15 the the DET expositions-1796 52 16 debunker debunker NOUN expositions-1796 52 17 ’s ’s PART expositions-1796 52 18 puzzle puzzle NOUN expositions-1796 52 19 very very ADV expositions-1796 52 20 plausible plausible ADJ expositions-1796 52 21 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 52 22 albeit albeit SCONJ expositions-1796 52 23 for for ADP expositions-1796 52 24 different different ADJ expositions-1796 52 25 reasons reason NOUN expositions-1796 52 26 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 53 1 any any DET expositions-1796 53 2 non non ADJ expositions-1796 53 3 - - NOUN expositions-1796 53 4 naturalist naturalist ADJ expositions-1796 53 5 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 53 6 after after ADV expositions-1796 53 7 all all ADV expositions-1796 53 8 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 53 9 must must AUX expositions-1796 53 10 assent assent VERB expositions-1796 53 11 to to ADP expositions-1796 53 12 the the DET expositions-1796 53 13 first first ADJ expositions-1796 53 14 two two NUM expositions-1796 53 15 claims claim NOUN expositions-1796 53 16 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 53 17 while while SCONJ expositions-1796 53 18 our our PRON expositions-1796 53 19 best good ADJ expositions-1796 53 20 science science NOUN expositions-1796 53 21 supports support VERB expositions-1796 53 22 the the DET expositions-1796 53 23 third third ADJ expositions-1796 53 24 claim claim NOUN expositions-1796 53 25 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 54 1 secondly secondly ADV expositions-1796 54 2 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 54 3 while while SCONJ expositions-1796 54 4 i i PRON expositions-1796 54 5 am be AUX expositions-1796 54 6 not not PART expositions-1796 54 7 prepared prepare VERB expositions-1796 54 8 simply simply ADV expositions-1796 54 9 to to PART expositions-1796 54 10 dismiss dismiss VERB expositions-1796 54 11 nagel nagel PROPN expositions-1796 54 12 ’s ’s PART expositions-1796 54 13 teleological teleological ADJ expositions-1796 54 14 hypothesis hypothesis NOUN expositions-1796 54 15 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 54 16 it it PRON expositions-1796 54 17 would would AUX expositions-1796 54 18 be be AUX expositions-1796 54 19 unwise unwise ADJ expositions-1796 54 20 for for ADP expositions-1796 54 21 nonnaturalists nonnaturalist NOUN expositions-1796 54 22 to to PART expositions-1796 54 23 embrace embrace VERB expositions-1796 54 24 it it PRON expositions-1796 54 25 in in ADP expositions-1796 54 26 order order NOUN expositions-1796 54 27 to to PART expositions-1796 54 28 solve solve VERB expositions-1796 54 29 the the DET expositions-1796 54 30 debunker debunker NOUN expositions-1796 54 31 ’s ’s PART expositions-1796 54 32 puzzle puzzle NOUN expositions-1796 54 33 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 55 1 to to ADP expositions-1796 55 2 the the DET expositions-1796 55 3 contrary contrary NOUN expositions-1796 55 4 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 55 5 sound sound ADJ expositions-1796 55 6 philosophical philosophical ADJ expositions-1796 55 7 methodology methodology NOUN expositions-1796 55 8 would would AUX expositions-1796 55 9 counsel counsel VERB expositions-1796 55 10 non non NOUN expositions-1796 55 11 - - NOUN expositions-1796 55 12 naturalists naturalist NOUN expositions-1796 55 13 to to PART expositions-1796 55 14 take take VERB expositions-1796 55 15 a a DET expositions-1796 55 16 more more ADV expositions-1796 55 17 conservative conservative ADJ expositions-1796 55 18 approach approach NOUN expositions-1796 55 19 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 55 20 not not PART expositions-1796 55 21 taking take VERB expositions-1796 55 22 on on ADP expositions-1796 55 23 additional additional ADJ expositions-1796 55 24 controversial controversial ADJ expositions-1796 55 25 commitments commitment NOUN expositions-1796 56 1 that that PRON expositions-1796 56 2 they they PRON expositions-1796 56 3 do do AUX expositions-1796 56 4 n’t not PART expositions-1796 56 5 have have VERB expositions-1796 56 6 to to PART expositions-1796 56 7 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 57 1 in in ADP expositions-1796 57 2 the the DET expositions-1796 57 3 next next ADJ expositions-1796 57 4 two two NUM expositions-1796 57 5 sections section NOUN expositions-1796 57 6 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 57 7 i i PRON expositions-1796 57 8 contend contend VERB expositions-1796 57 9 that that SCONJ expositions-1796 57 10 non non NOUN expositions-1796 57 11 - - NOUN expositions-1796 57 12 naturalists naturalist NOUN expositions-1796 57 13 need need VERB expositions-1796 57 14 n’t not PART expositions-1796 57 15 take take VERB expositions-1796 57 16 on on ADP expositions-1796 57 17 such such ADJ expositions-1796 57 18 commitments commitment NOUN expositions-1796 57 19 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 58 1 dissolution dissolution NOUN expositions-1796 58 2 : : PUNCT expositions-1796 58 3 the the DET expositions-1796 58 4 first first ADJ expositions-1796 58 5 strategy strategy NOUN expositions-1796 58 6 i i PRON expositions-1796 58 7 have have AUX expositions-1796 58 8 already already ADV expositions-1796 58 9 noted note VERB expositions-1796 58 10 that that SCONJ expositions-1796 58 11 the the DET expositions-1796 58 12 version version NOUN expositions-1796 58 13 of of ADP expositions-1796 58 14 the the DET expositions-1796 58 15 debunker debunker NOUN expositions-1796 58 16 ’s ’s PART expositions-1796 58 17 puzzle puzzle NOUN expositions-1796 58 18 on on ADP expositions-1796 58 19 which which PRON expositions-1796 58 20 nagel nagel PROPN expositions-1796 58 21 has have VERB expositions-1796 58 22 his his PRON expositions-1796 58 23 eye eye NOUN expositions-1796 58 24 is be AUX expositions-1796 58 25 that that SCONJ expositions-1796 58 26 formulated formulate VERB expositions-1796 58 27 by by ADP expositions-1796 58 28 sharon sharon PROPN expositions-1796 58 29 street street PROPN expositions-1796 58 30 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 59 1 in in ADP expositions-1796 59 2 her her PRON expositions-1796 59 3 formulation formulation NOUN expositions-1796 59 4 of of ADP expositions-1796 59 5 the the DET expositions-1796 59 6 puzzle puzzle NOUN expositions-1796 59 7 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 59 8 street street NOUN expositions-1796 59 9 claims claim VERB expositions-1796 59 10 that that SCONJ expositions-1796 59 11 there there PRON expositions-1796 59 12 are be VERB expositions-1796 59 13 no no DET expositions-1796 59 14 conceptual conceptual ADJ expositions-1796 59 15 constraints constraint NOUN expositions-1796 59 16 on on ADP expositions-1796 59 17 what what PRON expositions-1796 59 18 counts count VERB expositions-1796 59 19 as as ADP expositions-1796 59 20 a a DET expositions-1796 59 21 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 59 22 system system NOUN expositions-1796 59 23 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 59 24 writing write VERB expositions-1796 59 25 : : PUNCT expositions-1796 59 26 according accord VERB expositions-1796 59 27 to to ADP expositions-1796 59 28 the the DET expositions-1796 59 29 normative normative ADJ expositions-1796 59 30 realist realist NOUN expositions-1796 59 31 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 59 32 there there PRON expositions-1796 59 33 are be VERB expositions-1796 59 34 normative normative ADJ expositions-1796 59 35 truths truth NOUN expositions-1796 59 36 that that PRON expositions-1796 59 37 hold hold VERB expositions-1796 59 38 independently independently ADV expositions-1796 59 39 of of ADP expositions-1796 59 40 all all PRON expositions-1796 59 41 of of ADP expositions-1796 59 42 our our PRON expositions-1796 59 43 evaluative evaluative ADJ expositions-1796 59 44 attitudes attitude NOUN expositions-1796 59 45 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 60 1 moreover moreover ADV expositions-1796 60 2 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 60 3 as as ADP expositions-1796 60 4 a a DET expositions-1796 60 5 purely purely ADV expositions-1796 60 6 conceptual conceptual ADJ expositions-1796 60 7 matter matter NOUN expositions-1796 60 8 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 60 9 these these DET expositions-1796 60 10 independent independent ADJ expositions-1796 60 11 normative normative ADJ expositions-1796 60 12 truths truth NOUN expositions-1796 60 13 might might AUX expositions-1796 60 14 be be AUX expositions-1796 60 15 anything anything PRON expositions-1796 60 16 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 61 1 in in ADP expositions-1796 61 2 other other ADJ expositions-1796 61 3 words word NOUN expositions-1796 61 4 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 61 5 for for ADP expositions-1796 61 6 all all DET expositions-1796 61 7 our our PRON expositions-1796 61 8 bare bare ADJ expositions-1796 61 9 normative normative ADJ expositions-1796 61 10 concepts concept NOUN expositions-1796 61 11 tell tell VERB expositions-1796 61 12 us we PRON expositions-1796 61 13 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 61 14 survival survival NOUN expositions-1796 61 15 might might AUX expositions-1796 61 16 be be AUX expositions-1796 61 17 bad bad ADJ expositions-1796 61 18 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 61 19 our our PRON expositions-1796 61 20 children child NOUN expositions-1796 61 21 ’s ’s PART expositions-1796 61 22 lives life NOUN expositions-1796 61 23 might might AUX expositions-1796 61 24 be be AUX expositions-1796 61 25 worthless worthless ADJ expositions-1796 61 26 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 61 27 and and CCONJ expositions-1796 61 28 the the DET expositions-1796 61 29 fact fact NOUN expositions-1796 61 30 that that SCONJ expositions-1796 61 31 someone someone PRON expositions-1796 61 32 has have AUX expositions-1796 61 33 helped help VERB expositions-1796 61 34 us we PRON expositions-1796 61 35 might might AUX expositions-1796 61 36 be be AUX expositions-1796 61 37 a a DET expositions-1796 61 38 reason reason NOUN expositions-1796 61 39 to to PART expositions-1796 61 40 hurt hurt VERB expositions-1796 61 41 that that DET expositions-1796 61 42 person person NOUN expositions-1796 61 43 in in ADP expositions-1796 61 44 return return NOUN expositions-1796 61 45 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 62 1 of of ADV expositions-1796 62 2 course course NOUN expositions-1796 62 3 we we PRON expositions-1796 62 4 think think VERB expositions-1796 62 5 that that SCONJ expositions-1796 62 6 these these DET expositions-1796 62 7 claims claim NOUN expositions-1796 62 8 are be AUX expositions-1796 62 9 false false ADJ expositions-1796 62 10 — — PUNCT expositions-1796 62 11 perhaps perhaps ADV expositions-1796 62 12 even even ADV expositions-1796 62 13 necessarily necessarily ADV expositions-1796 62 14 false false ADJ expositions-1796 62 15 — — PUNCT expositions-1796 62 16 but but CCONJ expositions-1796 62 17 the the DET expositions-1796 62 18 point point NOUN expositions-1796 62 19 is be AUX expositions-1796 62 20 that that SCONJ expositions-1796 62 21 if if SCONJ expositions-1796 62 22 they they PRON expositions-1796 62 23 are be AUX expositions-1796 62 24 false false ADJ expositions-1796 62 25 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 62 26 it it PRON expositions-1796 62 27 is be AUX expositions-1796 62 28 not not PART expositions-1796 62 29 our our PRON expositions-1796 62 30 bare bare ADJ expositions-1796 62 31 normative normative ADJ expositions-1796 62 32 concepts concept NOUN expositions-1796 62 33 that that PRON expositions-1796 62 34 tell tell VERB expositions-1796 62 35 us we PRON expositions-1796 62 36 so.15 so.15 NOUN expositions-1796 62 37 this this DET expositions-1796 62 38 thesis thesis NOUN expositions-1796 62 39 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 62 40 which which PRON expositions-1796 62 41 i i PRON expositions-1796 62 42 ’ll ’ll AUX expositions-1796 62 43 refer refer VERB expositions-1796 62 44 to to ADP expositions-1796 62 45 as as ADP expositions-1796 62 46 the the DET expositions-1796 62 47 no no DET expositions-1796 62 48 content content NOUN expositions-1796 62 49 thesis thesis NOUN expositions-1796 62 50 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 62 51 plays play VERB expositions-1796 62 52 an an DET expositions-1796 62 53 important important ADJ expositions-1796 62 54 role role NOUN expositions-1796 62 55 in in ADP expositions-1796 62 56 street street NOUN expositions-1796 62 57 ’s ’s PART expositions-1796 62 58 argument argument NOUN expositions-1796 62 59 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 63 1 given give VERB expositions-1796 63 2 that that SCONJ expositions-1796 63 3 there there PRON expositions-1796 63 4 are be VERB expositions-1796 63 5 an an DET expositions-1796 63 6 untold untold ADJ expositions-1796 63 7 number number NOUN expositions-1796 63 8 of of ADP expositions-1796 63 9 incompatible incompatible ADJ expositions-1796 63 10 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 63 11 systems system NOUN expositions-1796 63 12 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 63 13 it it PRON expositions-1796 63 14 would would AUX expositions-1796 63 15 be be AUX expositions-1796 63 16 a a DET expositions-1796 63 17 massive massive ADJ expositions-1796 63 18 stroke stroke NOUN expositions-1796 63 19 of of ADP expositions-1796 63 20 luck luck NOUN expositions-1796 63 21 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 63 22 according accord VERB expositions-1796 63 23 to to ADP expositions-1796 63 24 street street NOUN expositions-1796 63 25 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 63 26 if if SCONJ expositions-1796 63 27 evolutionary evolutionary ADJ expositions-1796 63 28 forces force NOUN expositions-1796 63 29 were be AUX expositions-1796 63 30 to to PART expositions-1796 63 31 have have AUX expositions-1796 63 32 directed direct VERB expositions-1796 63 33 us we PRON expositions-1796 63 34 to to ADP expositions-1796 63 35 the the DET expositions-1796 63 36 correct correct ADJ expositions-1796 63 37 one one NUM expositions-1796 63 38 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 64 1 dissolving dissolve VERB expositions-1796 64 2 the the DET expositions-1796 64 3 debunker debunker NOUN expositions-1796 64 4 ’s ’s PART expositions-1796 64 5 puzzle puzzle NOUN expositions-1796 64 6 42 42 NUM expositions-1796 64 7 in in ADP expositions-1796 64 8 one one NUM expositions-1796 64 9 place place NOUN expositions-1796 64 10 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 64 11 nagel nagel PROPN expositions-1796 64 12 concedes concede VERB expositions-1796 64 13 the the DET expositions-1796 64 14 no no DET expositions-1796 64 15 content content ADJ expositions-1796 64 16 thesis thesis NOUN expositions-1796 64 17 to to ADP expositions-1796 64 18 street.16 street.16 PROPN expositions-1796 64 19 in in ADP expositions-1796 64 20 my my PRON expositions-1796 64 21 judgment judgment NOUN expositions-1796 64 22 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 64 23 he he PRON expositions-1796 64 24 ought ought AUX expositions-1796 64 25 not not PART expositions-1796 64 26 to to PART expositions-1796 64 27 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 64 28 since since SCONJ expositions-1796 64 29 any any DET expositions-1796 64 30 minimally minimally ADV expositions-1796 64 31 eccentric eccentric ADJ expositions-1796 64 32 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 64 33 system system NOUN expositions-1796 64 34 that that PRON expositions-1796 64 35 concerns concern VERB expositions-1796 64 36 beings being NOUN expositions-1796 64 37 like like ADP expositions-1796 64 38 us we PRON expositions-1796 64 39 in in ADP expositions-1796 64 40 a a DET expositions-1796 64 41 world world NOUN expositions-1796 64 42 such such ADJ expositions-1796 64 43 as as ADP expositions-1796 64 44 ours ours PRON expositions-1796 64 45 must must AUX expositions-1796 64 46 have have VERB expositions-1796 64 47 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 64 48 content content NOUN expositions-1796 64 49 of of ADP expositions-1796 64 50 a a DET expositions-1796 64 51 certain certain ADJ expositions-1796 64 52 kind kind NOUN expositions-1796 64 53 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 65 1 to to PART expositions-1796 65 2 see see VERB expositions-1796 65 3 why why SCONJ expositions-1796 65 4 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 65 5 let let VERB expositions-1796 65 6 me i PRON expositions-1796 65 7 unpack unpack VERB expositions-1796 65 8 the the DET expositions-1796 65 9 terminology terminology NOUN expositions-1796 65 10 introduced introduce VERB expositions-1796 65 11 in in ADP expositions-1796 65 12 the the DET expositions-1796 65 13 last last ADJ expositions-1796 65 14 sentence.17 sentence.17 PROPN expositions-1796 65 15 suppose suppose VERB expositions-1796 65 16 we we PRON expositions-1796 65 17 say say VERB expositions-1796 65 18 that that SCONJ expositions-1796 65 19 a a DET expositions-1796 65 20 minimally minimally ADV expositions-1796 65 21 eccentric eccentric ADJ expositions-1796 65 22 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 65 23 system system NOUN expositions-1796 65 24 is be AUX expositions-1796 65 25 a a DET expositions-1796 65 26 reasonably reasonably ADV expositions-1796 65 27 comprehensive comprehensive ADJ expositions-1796 65 28 and and CCONJ expositions-1796 65 29 consistent consistent ADJ expositions-1796 65 30 body body NOUN expositions-1796 65 31 of of ADP expositions-1796 65 32 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 65 33 propositions proposition NOUN expositions-1796 65 34 that that PRON expositions-1796 65 35 apply apply VERB expositions-1796 65 36 to to ADP expositions-1796 65 37 beings being NOUN expositions-1796 65 38 like like ADP expositions-1796 65 39 us we PRON expositions-1796 65 40 in in ADP expositions-1796 65 41 a a DET expositions-1796 65 42 world world NOUN expositions-1796 65 43 such such ADJ expositions-1796 65 44 as as ADP expositions-1796 65 45 ours our NOUN expositions-1796 65 46 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 66 1 by by ADP expositions-1796 66 2 a a DET expositions-1796 66 3 reasonably reasonably ADV expositions-1796 66 4 comprehensive comprehensive ADJ expositions-1796 66 5 body body NOUN expositions-1796 66 6 of of ADP expositions-1796 66 7 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 66 8 propositions proposition NOUN expositions-1796 66 9 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 66 10 i i PRON expositions-1796 66 11 mean mean VERB expositions-1796 66 12 an an DET expositions-1796 66 13 array array NOUN expositions-1796 66 14 of of ADP expositions-1796 66 15 propositions proposition NOUN expositions-1796 66 16 that that PRON expositions-1796 66 17 concern concern NOUN expositions-1796 66 18 nearly nearly ADV expositions-1796 66 19 all all PRON expositions-1796 66 20 situations situation NOUN expositions-1796 66 21 that that PRON expositions-1796 66 22 agents agent NOUN expositions-1796 66 23 might might AUX expositions-1796 66 24 find find VERB expositions-1796 66 25 themselves themselves PRON expositions-1796 66 26 in in ADP expositions-1796 66 27 and and CCONJ expositions-1796 66 28 imply imply VERB expositions-1796 66 29 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 66 30 often often ADV expositions-1796 66 31 in in ADP expositions-1796 66 32 conjunction conjunction NOUN expositions-1796 66 33 with with ADP expositions-1796 66 34 empirical empirical ADJ expositions-1796 66 35 propositions proposition NOUN expositions-1796 66 36 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 66 37 a a DET expositions-1796 66 38 range range NOUN expositions-1796 66 39 of of ADP expositions-1796 66 40 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 66 41 assessments assessment NOUN expositions-1796 66 42 and and CCONJ expositions-1796 66 43 recommendations recommendation NOUN expositions-1796 66 44 for for ADP expositions-1796 66 45 those those DET expositions-1796 66 46 situations situation NOUN expositions-1796 66 47 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 67 1 beings being NOUN expositions-1796 67 2 like like ADP expositions-1796 67 3 us we PRON expositions-1796 67 4 are be AUX expositions-1796 67 5 mortal mortal ADJ expositions-1796 67 6 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 67 7 embodied embody VERB expositions-1796 67 8 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 67 9 not not PART expositions-1796 67 10 subject subject ADJ expositions-1796 67 11 to to ADP expositions-1796 67 12 daily daily ADJ expositions-1796 67 13 bouts bout NOUN expositions-1796 67 14 of of ADP expositions-1796 67 15 complete complete ADJ expositions-1796 67 16 amnesia amnesia NOUN expositions-1796 67 17 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 67 18 susceptible susceptible ADJ expositions-1796 67 19 to to ADP expositions-1796 67 20 physical physical ADJ expositions-1796 67 21 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 67 22 emotional emotional ADJ expositions-1796 67 23 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 67 24 and and CCONJ expositions-1796 67 25 other other ADJ expositions-1796 67 26 psychological psychological ADJ expositions-1796 67 27 pleasures pleasure NOUN expositions-1796 67 28 and and CCONJ expositions-1796 67 29 pains pain NOUN expositions-1796 67 30 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 67 31 capable capable ADJ expositions-1796 67 32 of of ADP expositions-1796 67 33 introspection introspection NOUN expositions-1796 67 34 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 67 35 of of ADP expositions-1796 67 36 friendship friendship NOUN expositions-1796 67 37 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 67 38 of of ADP expositions-1796 67 39 self self NOUN expositions-1796 67 40 - - PUNCT expositions-1796 67 41 esteem esteem NOUN expositions-1796 67 42 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 67 43 possessed possess VERB expositions-1796 67 44 of of ADP expositions-1796 67 45 some some DET expositions-1796 67 46 degree degree NOUN expositions-1796 67 47 of of ADP expositions-1796 67 48 empathy empathy NOUN expositions-1796 67 49 and and CCONJ expositions-1796 67 50 sympathy sympathy NOUN expositions-1796 67 51 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 67 52 and and CCONJ expositions-1796 67 53 able able ADJ expositions-1796 67 54 to to PART expositions-1796 67 55 reason reason VERB expositions-1796 67 56 deductively deductively ADV expositions-1796 67 57 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 67 58 inductively inductively ADV expositions-1796 67 59 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 67 60 and and CCONJ expositions-1796 67 61 abductively abductively ADV expositions-1796 67 62 in in ADP expositions-1796 67 63 at at ADV expositions-1796 67 64 least least ADJ expositions-1796 67 65 minimal minimal ADJ expositions-1796 67 66 ways way NOUN expositions-1796 67 67 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 68 1 finally finally ADV expositions-1796 68 2 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 68 3 a a DET expositions-1796 68 4 world world NOUN expositions-1796 68 5 such such ADJ expositions-1796 68 6 as as ADP expositions-1796 68 7 ours ours PRON expositions-1796 68 8 is be AUX expositions-1796 68 9 one one NUM expositions-1796 68 10 that that PRON expositions-1796 68 11 can can AUX expositions-1796 68 12 sustain sustain VERB expositions-1796 68 13 life life NOUN expositions-1796 68 14 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 68 15 one one NUM expositions-1796 68 16 in in ADP expositions-1796 68 17 which which PRON expositions-1796 68 18 people people NOUN expositions-1796 68 19 do do AUX expositions-1796 68 20 not not PART expositions-1796 68 21 pop pop VERB expositions-1796 68 22 in in ADP expositions-1796 68 23 and and CCONJ expositions-1796 68 24 out out ADP expositions-1796 68 25 of of ADP expositions-1796 68 26 existence existence NOUN expositions-1796 68 27 willy willy ADV expositions-1796 68 28 - - PUNCT expositions-1796 68 29 nilly nilly ADV expositions-1796 68 30 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 68 31 one one NUM expositions-1796 68 32 in in ADP expositions-1796 68 33 which which PRON expositions-1796 68 34 the the DET expositions-1796 68 35 future future NOUN expositions-1796 68 36 is be AUX expositions-1796 68 37 not not PART expositions-1796 68 38 known know VERB expositions-1796 68 39 to to PART expositions-1796 68 40 be be AUX expositions-1796 68 41 in in ADP expositions-1796 68 42 all all DET expositions-1796 68 43 respects respect NOUN expositions-1796 68 44 perfectly perfectly ADV expositions-1796 68 45 identical identical ADJ expositions-1796 68 46 to to ADP expositions-1796 68 47 the the DET expositions-1796 68 48 past past NOUN expositions-1796 68 49 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 68 50 one one NUM expositions-1796 68 51 in in ADP expositions-1796 68 52 which which PRON expositions-1796 68 53 material material NOUN expositions-1796 68 54 objects object NOUN expositions-1796 68 55 are be AUX expositions-1796 68 56 observable observable ADJ expositions-1796 68 57 — — PUNCT expositions-1796 68 58 in in ADP expositions-1796 68 59 short short ADJ expositions-1796 68 60 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 68 61 one one NOUN expositions-1796 68 62 that that PRON expositions-1796 68 63 is be AUX expositions-1796 68 64 regulated regulate VERB expositions-1796 68 65 by by ADP expositions-1796 68 66 laws law NOUN expositions-1796 68 67 of of ADP expositions-1796 68 68 nature nature NOUN expositions-1796 68 69 and and CCONJ expositions-1796 68 70 broad broad ADJ expositions-1796 68 71 empirical empirical ADJ expositions-1796 68 72 statistical statistical ADJ expositions-1796 68 73 generalizations generalization NOUN expositions-1796 68 74 that that PRON expositions-1796 68 75 are be AUX expositions-1796 68 76 at at ADP expositions-1796 68 77 least least ADJ expositions-1796 68 78 close close ADJ expositions-1796 68 79 to to ADP expositions-1796 68 80 the the DET expositions-1796 68 81 ones one NOUN expositions-1796 68 82 that that PRON expositions-1796 68 83 obtain obtain VERB expositions-1796 68 84 here here ADV expositions-1796 68 85 on on ADP expositions-1796 68 86 earth earth NOUN expositions-1796 68 87 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 69 1 non non NOUN expositions-1796 69 2 - - NOUN expositions-1796 69 3 naturalists naturalist NOUN expositions-1796 69 4 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 69 5 i i PRON expositions-1796 69 6 claim claim VERB expositions-1796 69 7 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 69 8 should should AUX expositions-1796 69 9 hold hold VERB expositions-1796 69 10 that that SCONJ expositions-1796 69 11 any any DET expositions-1796 69 12 minimally minimally ADV expositions-1796 69 13 eccentric eccentric ADJ expositions-1796 69 14 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 69 15 system system NOUN expositions-1796 69 16 must must AUX expositions-1796 69 17 include include VERB expositions-1796 69 18 an an DET expositions-1796 69 19 array array NOUN expositions-1796 69 20 of of ADP expositions-1796 69 21 propositions proposition NOUN expositions-1796 69 22 that that PRON expositions-1796 69 23 russ russ PROPN expositions-1796 69 24 shafer shafer PROPN expositions-1796 69 25 - - PUNCT expositions-1796 69 26 landau landau NOUN expositions-1796 69 27 and and CCONJ expositions-1796 69 28 i i PRON expositions-1796 69 29 have have AUX expositions-1796 69 30 elsewhere elsewhere ADV expositions-1796 69 31 called call VERB expositions-1796 69 32 the the DET expositions-1796 69 33 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 69 34 fixed fix VERB expositions-1796 69 35 points point NOUN expositions-1796 69 36 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 69 37 propositions proposition NOUN expositions-1796 69 38 such such ADJ expositions-1796 69 39 as as ADP expositions-1796 69 40 : : PUNCT expositions-1796 69 41   PRON expositions-1796 69 42 it it PRON expositions-1796 69 43 is be AUX expositions-1796 69 44 pro pro ADJ expositions-1796 69 45 tanto tanto ADV expositions-1796 69 46 wrong wrong ADJ expositions-1796 69 47 to to PART expositions-1796 69 48 engage engage VERB expositions-1796 69 49 in in ADP expositions-1796 69 50 the the DET expositions-1796 69 51 recreational recreational ADJ expositions-1796 69 52 slaughter slaughter NOUN expositions-1796 69 53 of of ADP expositions-1796 69 54 a a DET expositions-1796 69 55 fellow fellow ADJ expositions-1796 69 56 person person NOUN expositions-1796 69 57 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 70 1   PRON expositions-1796 71 1 it it PRON expositions-1796 71 2 is be AUX expositions-1796 71 3 pro pro ADJ expositions-1796 71 4 tanto tanto ADV expositions-1796 71 5 wrong wrong ADJ expositions-1796 71 6 to to PART expositions-1796 71 7 break break VERB expositions-1796 71 8 a a DET expositions-1796 71 9 promise promise NOUN expositions-1796 71 10 on on ADP expositions-1796 71 11 which which PRON expositions-1796 71 12 another another PRON expositions-1796 71 13 is be AUX expositions-1796 71 14 relying rely VERB expositions-1796 71 15 simply simply ADV expositions-1796 71 16 for for ADP expositions-1796 71 17 convenience convenience NOUN expositions-1796 71 18 ’s ’s PART expositions-1796 71 19 sake sake NOUN expositions-1796 71 20 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 72 1   PRON expositions-1796 73 1 it it PRON expositions-1796 73 2 is be AUX expositions-1796 73 3 pro pro ADJ expositions-1796 73 4 tanto tanto ADV expositions-1796 73 5 wrong wrong ADJ expositions-1796 73 6 to to PART expositions-1796 73 7 humiliate humiliate VERB expositions-1796 73 8 others other NOUN expositions-1796 73 9 simply simply ADV expositions-1796 73 10 for for ADP expositions-1796 73 11 pleasure pleasure NOUN expositions-1796 73 12 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 74 1   X expositions-1796 75 1 it it PRON expositions-1796 75 2 is be AUX expositions-1796 75 3 pro pro ADJ expositions-1796 75 4 tanto tanto ADV expositions-1796 75 5 wrong wrong ADJ expositions-1796 75 6 to to PART expositions-1796 75 7 torture torture VERB expositions-1796 75 8 others other NOUN expositions-1796 75 9 just just ADV expositions-1796 75 10 because because SCONJ expositions-1796 75 11 they they PRON expositions-1796 75 12 have have AUX expositions-1796 75 13 inconvenienced inconvenience VERB expositions-1796 75 14 you you PRON expositions-1796 75 15 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 76 1   PRON expositions-1796 77 1 it it PRON expositions-1796 77 2 is be AUX expositions-1796 77 3 pro pro ADJ expositions-1796 77 4 tanto tanto ADV expositions-1796 77 5 wrong wrong ADJ expositions-1796 77 6 to to PART expositions-1796 77 7 impose impose VERB expositions-1796 77 8 severe severe ADJ expositions-1796 77 9 burdens burden NOUN expositions-1796 77 10 on on ADP expositions-1796 77 11 others other NOUN expositions-1796 77 12 simply simply ADV expositions-1796 77 13 because because SCONJ expositions-1796 77 14 of of ADP expositions-1796 77 15 their their PRON expositions-1796 77 16 physical physical ADJ expositions-1796 77 17 appearance appearance NOUN expositions-1796 77 18 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 78 1 these these DET expositions-1796 78 2 apparent apparent ADJ expositions-1796 78 3 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 78 4 truths truth NOUN expositions-1796 78 5 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 78 6 i i PRON expositions-1796 78 7 suggest suggest VERB expositions-1796 78 8 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 78 9 are be AUX expositions-1796 78 10 excellent excellent ADJ expositions-1796 78 11 candidates candidate NOUN expositions-1796 78 12 for for ADP expositions-1796 78 13 being be AUX expositions-1796 78 14 a a DET expositions-1796 78 15 species species NOUN expositions-1796 78 16 of of ADP expositions-1796 78 17 conceptual conceptual ADJ expositions-1796 78 18 truth truth NOUN expositions-1796 78 19 in in ADP expositions-1796 78 20 the the DET expositions-1796 78 21 sense sense NOUN expositions-1796 78 22 that that SCONJ expositions-1796 78 23 nothing nothing PRON expositions-1796 78 24 could could AUX expositions-1796 78 25 be be AUX expositions-1796 78 26 a a DET expositions-1796 78 27 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 78 28 system system NOUN expositions-1796 78 29 that that PRON expositions-1796 78 30 failed fail VERB expositions-1796 78 31 to to PART expositions-1796 78 32 include include VERB expositions-1796 78 33 them they PRON expositions-1796 78 34 ( ( PUNCT expositions-1796 78 35 or or CCONJ expositions-1796 78 36 something something PRON expositions-1796 78 37 very very ADV expositions-1796 78 38 much much ADV expositions-1796 78 39 like like ADP expositions-1796 78 40 them they PRON expositions-1796 78 41 ) ) PUNCT expositions-1796 78 42 and and CCONJ expositions-1796 78 43 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 78 44 were be AUX expositions-1796 78 45 someone someone PRON expositions-1796 78 46 to to PART expositions-1796 78 47 deny deny VERB expositions-1796 78 48 a a DET expositions-1796 78 49 sufficient sufficient ADJ expositions-1796 78 50 number number NOUN expositions-1796 78 51 of of ADP expositions-1796 78 52 them they PRON expositions-1796 78 53 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 78 54 that that PRON expositions-1796 78 55 would would AUX expositions-1796 78 56 be be AUX expositions-1796 78 57 strong strong ADJ expositions-1796 78 58 prima prima NOUN expositions-1796 78 59 facie facie NOUN expositions-1796 78 60 reason reason NOUN expositions-1796 78 61 to to PART expositions-1796 78 62 hold hold VERB expositions-1796 78 63 that that SCONJ expositions-1796 78 64 that that DET expositions-1796 78 65 person person NOUN expositions-1796 78 66 suffers suffer VERB expositions-1796 78 67 from from ADP expositions-1796 78 68 a a DET expositions-1796 78 69 conceptual conceptual ADJ expositions-1796 78 70 deficiency deficiency NOUN expositions-1796 78 71 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 79 1 such such DET expositions-1796 79 2 a a DET expositions-1796 79 3 deficiency deficiency NOUN expositions-1796 79 4 would would AUX expositions-1796 79 5 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 79 6 presumably presumably ADV expositions-1796 79 7 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 79 8 consist consist VERB expositions-1796 79 9 in in ADP expositions-1796 79 10 an an DET expositions-1796 79 11 agent agent NOUN expositions-1796 79 12 ’s ’s PART expositions-1796 79 13 : : PUNCT expositions-1796 79 14 ( ( PUNCT expositions-1796 79 15 i i NOUN expositions-1796 79 16 ) ) PUNCT expositions-1796 79 17 lacking lack VERB expositions-1796 79 18 the the DET expositions-1796 79 19 relevant relevant ADJ expositions-1796 79 20 concepts concept NOUN expositions-1796 79 21 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 79 22 such such ADJ expositions-1796 79 23 as as ADP expositions-1796 79 24 the the DET expositions-1796 79 25 concept concept NOUN expositions-1796 79 26 ‘ ' PUNCT expositions-1796 79 27 being be AUX expositions-1796 79 28 wrong wrong ADJ expositions-1796 79 29 ’ ' PUNCT expositions-1796 79 30 ; ; PUNCT expositions-1796 79 31 ( ( PUNCT expositions-1796 79 32 ii ii X expositions-1796 79 33 ) ) PUNCT expositions-1796 79 34 having have VERB expositions-1796 79 35 an an DET expositions-1796 79 36 inadequate inadequate ADJ expositions-1796 79 37 grasp grasp NOUN expositions-1796 79 38 of of ADP expositions-1796 79 39 them they PRON expositions-1796 79 40 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 79 41 failing fail VERB expositions-1796 79 42 to to PART expositions-1796 79 43 see see VERB expositions-1796 79 44 that that SCONJ expositions-1796 79 45 they they PRON expositions-1796 79 46 apply apply VERB expositions-1796 79 47 to to ADP expositions-1796 79 48 some some DET expositions-1796 79 49 paradigm paradigm NOUN expositions-1796 79 50 cases case NOUN expositions-1796 79 51 ; ; PUNCT expositions-1796 79 52 ( ( PUNCT expositions-1796 79 53 iii iii X expositions-1796 79 54 ) ) PUNCT expositions-1796 79 55 having have VERB expositions-1796 79 56 a a DET expositions-1796 79 57 confused confused ADJ expositions-1796 79 58 grasp grasp NOUN expositions-1796 79 59 of of ADP expositions-1796 79 60 them they PRON expositions-1796 79 61 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 79 62 perhaps perhaps ADV expositions-1796 79 63 holding hold VERB expositions-1796 79 64 that that SCONJ expositions-1796 79 65 the the DET expositions-1796 79 66 concept concept NOUN expositions-1796 79 67 ‘ ' PUNCT expositions-1796 79 68 being be AUX expositions-1796 79 69 wrong wrong ADJ expositions-1796 79 70 ’ ' PUNCT expositions-1796 79 71 fails fail VERB expositions-1796 79 72 to to PART expositions-1796 79 73 apply apply VERB expositions-1796 79 74 to to ADP expositions-1796 79 75 acts act NOUN expositions-1796 79 76 taken take VERB expositions-1796 79 77 toward toward ADP expositions-1796 79 78 those those PRON expositions-1796 79 79 who who PRON expositions-1796 79 80 belong belong VERB expositions-1796 79 81 to to ADP expositions-1796 79 82 some some DET expositions-1796 79 83 “ " PUNCT expositions-1796 79 84 out out PROPN expositions-1796 79 85 group group NOUN expositions-1796 79 86 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 79 87 ” " PUNCT expositions-1796 79 88 such such ADJ expositions-1796 79 89 as as ADP expositions-1796 79 90 43 43 NUM expositions-1796 79 91 cuneo cuneo VERB expositions-1796 79 92 those those PRON expositions-1796 79 93 of of ADP expositions-1796 79 94 another another DET expositions-1796 79 95 ethnic ethnic ADJ expositions-1796 79 96 group group NOUN expositions-1796 79 97 ; ; PUNCT expositions-1796 79 98 or or CCONJ expositions-1796 79 99 ( ( PUNCT expositions-1796 79 100 iv iv X expositions-1796 79 101 ) ) PUNCT expositions-1796 79 102 failing fail VERB expositions-1796 79 103 to to PART expositions-1796 79 104 appreciate appreciate VERB expositions-1796 79 105 or or CCONJ expositions-1796 79 106 acknowledge acknowledge VERB expositions-1796 79 107 the the DET expositions-1796 79 108 manifest manifest ADJ expositions-1796 79 109 implications implication NOUN expositions-1796 79 110 of of ADP expositions-1796 79 111 the the DET expositions-1796 79 112 concepts concept NOUN expositions-1796 79 113 in in ADP expositions-1796 79 114 question question NOUN expositions-1796 79 115 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 79 116 owing owe VERB expositions-1796 79 117 to to ADP expositions-1796 79 118 some some DET expositions-1796 79 119 aspect aspect NOUN expositions-1796 79 120 of of ADP expositions-1796 79 121 his his PRON expositions-1796 79 122 psychology psychology NOUN expositions-1796 79 123 or or CCONJ expositions-1796 79 124 situation situation NOUN expositions-1796 79 125 that that PRON expositions-1796 79 126 inhibits inhibit VERB expositions-1796 79 127 him he PRON expositions-1796 79 128 from from ADP expositions-1796 79 129 acknowledging acknowledge VERB expositions-1796 79 130 that that SCONJ expositions-1796 79 131 actions action NOUN expositions-1796 79 132 such such ADJ expositions-1796 79 133 as as ADP expositions-1796 79 134 recreational recreational ADJ expositions-1796 79 135 slaughter slaughter NOUN expositions-1796 79 136 are be AUX expositions-1796 79 137 wrong wrong ADJ expositions-1796 79 138 ( ( PUNCT expositions-1796 79 139 even even ADV expositions-1796 79 140 though though SCONJ expositions-1796 79 141 they they PRON expositions-1796 79 142 may may AUX expositions-1796 79 143 seem seem VERB expositions-1796 79 144 to to ADP expositions-1796 79 145 him he PRON expositions-1796 79 146 to to PART expositions-1796 79 147 be be AUX expositions-1796 79 148 wrong wrong ADJ expositions-1796 79 149 ) ) PUNCT expositions-1796 79 150 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 80 1 these these DET expositions-1796 80 2 claims claim NOUN expositions-1796 80 3 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 80 4 it it PRON expositions-1796 80 5 is be AUX expositions-1796 80 6 worth worth ADJ expositions-1796 80 7 emphasizing emphasize VERB expositions-1796 80 8 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 80 9 do do AUX expositions-1796 80 10 not not PART expositions-1796 80 11 imply imply VERB expositions-1796 80 12 that that SCONJ expositions-1796 80 13 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 80 14 when when SCONJ expositions-1796 80 15 an an DET expositions-1796 80 16 agent agent NOUN expositions-1796 80 17 suffers suffer VERB expositions-1796 80 18 from from ADP expositions-1796 80 19 a a DET expositions-1796 80 20 conceptual conceptual ADJ expositions-1796 80 21 deficiency deficiency NOUN expositions-1796 80 22 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 80 23 she she PRON expositions-1796 80 24 must must AUX expositions-1796 80 25 be be AUX expositions-1796 80 26 conceptually conceptually ADV expositions-1796 80 27 confused confuse VERB expositions-1796 80 28 ; ; PUNCT expositions-1796 80 29 there there PRON expositions-1796 80 30 are be VERB expositions-1796 80 31 a a DET expositions-1796 80 32 variety variety NOUN expositions-1796 80 33 of of ADP expositions-1796 80 34 ways way NOUN expositions-1796 80 35 to to PART expositions-1796 80 36 suffer suffer VERB expositions-1796 80 37 from from ADP expositions-1796 80 38 such such DET expositions-1796 80 39 a a DET expositions-1796 80 40 deficiency deficiency NOUN expositions-1796 80 41 that that PRON expositions-1796 80 42 do do AUX expositions-1796 80 43 not not PART expositions-1796 80 44 consist consist VERB expositions-1796 80 45 in in ADP expositions-1796 80 46 being be AUX expositions-1796 80 47 confused confuse VERB expositions-1796 80 48 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 81 1 moreover moreover ADV expositions-1796 81 2 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 81 3 the the DET expositions-1796 81 4 claim claim NOUN expositions-1796 81 5 that that SCONJ expositions-1796 81 6 any any DET expositions-1796 81 7 minimally minimally ADV expositions-1796 81 8 eccentric eccentric ADJ expositions-1796 81 9 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 81 10 system system NOUN expositions-1796 81 11 must must AUX expositions-1796 81 12 incorporate incorporate VERB expositions-1796 81 13 the the DET expositions-1796 81 14 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 81 15 fixed fix VERB expositions-1796 81 16 points point NOUN expositions-1796 81 17 is be AUX expositions-1796 81 18 compatible compatible ADJ expositions-1796 81 19 with with ADP expositions-1796 81 20 there there PRON expositions-1796 81 21 being be AUX expositions-1796 81 22 many many ADJ expositions-1796 81 23 different different ADJ expositions-1796 81 24 normative normative ADJ expositions-1796 81 25 systems system NOUN expositions-1796 81 26 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 81 27 such such ADJ expositions-1796 81 28 as as ADP expositions-1796 81 29 those those PRON expositions-1796 81 30 embraced embrace VERB expositions-1796 81 31 by by ADP expositions-1796 81 32 hedonists hedonist NOUN expositions-1796 81 33 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 81 34 egoists egoist NOUN expositions-1796 81 35 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 81 36 and and CCONJ expositions-1796 81 37 nietzscheans nietzschean NOUN expositions-1796 81 38 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 82 1 not not PART expositions-1796 82 2 every every DET expositions-1796 82 3 normative normative ADJ expositions-1796 82 4 system system NOUN expositions-1796 82 5 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 82 6 however however ADV expositions-1796 82 7 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 82 8 is be AUX expositions-1796 82 9 a a DET expositions-1796 82 10 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 82 11 system system NOUN expositions-1796 82 12 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 83 1 if if SCONJ expositions-1796 83 2 the the DET expositions-1796 83 3 claims claim NOUN expositions-1796 83 4 articulated articulate VERB expositions-1796 83 5 in in ADP expositions-1796 83 6 the the DET expositions-1796 83 7 preceding precede VERB expositions-1796 83 8 paragraph paragraph NOUN expositions-1796 83 9 are be AUX expositions-1796 83 10 correct correct ADJ expositions-1796 83 11 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 83 12 it it PRON expositions-1796 83 13 follows follow VERB expositions-1796 83 14 that that SCONJ expositions-1796 83 15 the the DET expositions-1796 83 16 no no DET expositions-1796 83 17 content content NOUN expositions-1796 83 18 thesis thesis NOUN expositions-1796 83 19 is be AUX expositions-1796 83 20 false false ADJ expositions-1796 83 21 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 84 1 for for ADP expositions-1796 84 2 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 84 3 contrary contrary ADJ expositions-1796 84 4 to to ADP expositions-1796 84 5 what what PRON expositions-1796 84 6 street street NOUN expositions-1796 84 7 claims claim VERB expositions-1796 84 8 in in ADP expositions-1796 84 9 the the DET expositions-1796 84 10 passage passage NOUN expositions-1796 84 11 quoted quote VERB expositions-1796 84 12 above above ADV expositions-1796 84 13 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 84 14 there there PRON expositions-1796 84 15 are be VERB expositions-1796 84 16 contentful contentful ADJ expositions-1796 84 17 conceptual conceptual ADJ expositions-1796 84 18 constraints constraint NOUN expositions-1796 84 19 on on ADP expositions-1796 84 20 what what PRON expositions-1796 84 21 can can AUX expositions-1796 84 22 count count VERB expositions-1796 84 23 as as ADP expositions-1796 84 24 a a DET expositions-1796 84 25 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 84 26 system system NOUN expositions-1796 84 27 ( ( PUNCT expositions-1796 84 28 for for ADP expositions-1796 84 29 beings being NOUN expositions-1796 84 30 like like ADP expositions-1796 84 31 us we PRON expositions-1796 84 32 in in ADP expositions-1796 84 33 a a DET expositions-1796 84 34 world world NOUN expositions-1796 84 35 such such ADJ expositions-1796 84 36 as as ADP expositions-1796 84 37 ours our NOUN expositions-1796 84 38 ) ) PUNCT expositions-1796 84 39 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 84 40 and and CCONJ expositions-1796 84 41 the the DET expositions-1796 84 42 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 84 43 fixed fix VERB expositions-1796 84 44 points point NOUN expositions-1796 84 45 provide provide VERB expositions-1796 84 46 them they PRON expositions-1796 84 47 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 85 1 since since SCONJ expositions-1796 85 2 any any DET expositions-1796 85 3 such such ADJ expositions-1796 85 4 system system NOUN expositions-1796 85 5 must must AUX expositions-1796 85 6 of of ADP expositions-1796 85 7 conceptual conceptual ADJ expositions-1796 85 8 necessity necessity NOUN expositions-1796 85 9 incorporate incorporate VERB expositions-1796 85 10 the the DET expositions-1796 85 11 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 85 12 fixed fix VERB expositions-1796 85 13 points point NOUN expositions-1796 85 14 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 85 15 they they PRON expositions-1796 85 16 are be AUX expositions-1796 85 17 guaranteed guarantee VERB expositions-1796 85 18 to to PART expositions-1796 85 19 be be AUX expositions-1796 85 20 elements element NOUN expositions-1796 85 21 of of ADP expositions-1796 85 22 the the DET expositions-1796 85 23 uniquely uniquely ADV expositions-1796 85 24 correct correct ADJ expositions-1796 85 25 minimally minimally ADV expositions-1796 85 26 eccentric eccentric ADJ expositions-1796 85 27 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 85 28 system system NOUN expositions-1796 85 29 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 86 1 let let VERB expositions-1796 86 2 me i PRON expositions-1796 86 3 also also ADV expositions-1796 86 4 note note VERB expositions-1796 86 5 that that DET expositions-1796 86 6 appeal appeal NOUN expositions-1796 86 7 to to ADP expositions-1796 86 8 the the DET expositions-1796 86 9 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 86 10 fixed fix VERB expositions-1796 86 11 points point NOUN expositions-1796 86 12 helps help VERB expositions-1796 86 13 to to PART expositions-1796 86 14 neutralize neutralize VERB expositions-1796 86 15 a a DET expositions-1796 86 16 further further ADJ expositions-1796 86 17 argument argument NOUN expositions-1796 86 18 that that SCONJ expositions-1796 86 19 street street NOUN expositions-1796 86 20 offers offer NOUN expositions-1796 86 21 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 86 22 wherein wherein SCONJ expositions-1796 86 23 she she PRON expositions-1796 86 24 claims claim VERB expositions-1796 86 25 that that SCONJ expositions-1796 86 26 it it PRON expositions-1796 86 27 is be AUX expositions-1796 86 28 no no DET expositions-1796 86 29 use use NOUN expositions-1796 86 30 to to PART expositions-1796 86 31 appeal appeal VERB expositions-1796 86 32 to to ADP expositions-1796 86 33 rational rational ADJ expositions-1796 86 34 reflection reflection NOUN expositions-1796 86 35 as as ADP expositions-1796 86 36 a a DET expositions-1796 86 37 way way NOUN expositions-1796 86 38 to to PART expositions-1796 86 39 correct correct VERB expositions-1796 86 40 the the DET expositions-1796 86 41 distorting distort VERB expositions-1796 86 42 influence influence NOUN expositions-1796 86 43 of of ADP expositions-1796 86 44 evolution evolution NOUN expositions-1796 86 45 since since SCONJ expositions-1796 86 46 “ " PUNCT expositions-1796 86 47 the the DET expositions-1796 86 48 fund fund NOUN expositions-1796 86 49 of of ADP expositions-1796 86 50 evaluative evaluative ADJ expositions-1796 86 51 judgments judgment NOUN expositions-1796 86 52 with with ADP expositions-1796 86 53 which which PRON expositions-1796 86 54 human human ADJ expositions-1796 86 55 reflection reflection NOUN expositions-1796 86 56 began begin VERB expositions-1796 86 57 was be AUX expositions-1796 86 58 thoroughly thoroughly ADV expositions-1796 86 59 contaminated contaminate VERB expositions-1796 86 60 with with ADP expositions-1796 86 61 illegitimate illegitimate ADJ expositions-1796 86 62 influence influence NOUN expositions-1796 86 63 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 87 1 ”18 ”18 NOUN expositions-1796 87 2 if if SCONJ expositions-1796 87 3 this this PRON expositions-1796 87 4 is be AUX expositions-1796 87 5 supposed suppose VERB expositions-1796 87 6 to to PART expositions-1796 87 7 be be AUX expositions-1796 87 8 a a DET expositions-1796 87 9 claim claim NOUN expositions-1796 87 10 about about ADP expositions-1796 87 11 our our PRON expositions-1796 87 12 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 87 13 thinking thinking NOUN expositions-1796 87 14 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 87 15 then then ADV expositions-1796 87 16 it it PRON expositions-1796 87 17 is be AUX expositions-1796 87 18 false false ADJ expositions-1796 87 19 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 88 1 for for ADP expositions-1796 88 2 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 88 3 if if SCONJ expositions-1796 88 4 the the DET expositions-1796 88 5 view view NOUN expositions-1796 88 6 i i PRON expositions-1796 88 7 am be AUX expositions-1796 88 8 sketching sketch VERB expositions-1796 88 9 is be AUX expositions-1796 88 10 true true ADJ expositions-1796 88 11 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 88 12 to to PART expositions-1796 88 13 be be AUX expositions-1796 88 14 a a DET expositions-1796 88 15 competent competent ADJ expositions-1796 88 16 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 88 17 cognizer cognizer NOUN expositions-1796 88 18 would would AUX expositions-1796 88 19 require require VERB expositions-1796 88 20 one one NUM expositions-1796 88 21 to to PART expositions-1796 88 22 affirm affirm VERB expositions-1796 88 23 the the DET expositions-1796 88 24 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 88 25 fixed fix VERB expositions-1796 88 26 points point NOUN expositions-1796 88 27 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 89 1 by by ADP expositions-1796 89 2 relying rely VERB expositions-1796 89 3 on on ADP expositions-1796 89 4 the the DET expositions-1796 89 5 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 89 6 fixed fix VERB expositions-1796 89 7 points point NOUN expositions-1796 89 8 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 89 9 however however ADV expositions-1796 89 10 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 89 11 one one PRON expositions-1796 89 12 could could AUX expositions-1796 89 13 correct correct VERB expositions-1796 89 14 for for ADP expositions-1796 89 15 at at ADV expositions-1796 89 16 least least ADJ expositions-1796 89 17 some some PRON expositions-1796 89 18 malign malign ADJ expositions-1796 89 19 evolutionary evolutionary ADJ expositions-1796 89 20 influences influence NOUN expositions-1796 89 21 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 89 22 subjecting subject VERB expositions-1796 89 23 the the DET expositions-1796 89 24 rest rest NOUN expositions-1796 89 25 of of ADP expositions-1796 89 26 one one NUM expositions-1796 89 27 ’s ’s PART expositions-1796 89 28 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 89 29 beliefs belief NOUN expositions-1796 89 30 to to ADP expositions-1796 89 31 critical critical ADJ expositions-1796 89 32 scrutiny scrutiny NOUN expositions-1796 89 33 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 89 34 certifying certify VERB expositions-1796 89 35 some some PRON expositions-1796 89 36 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 89 37 and and CCONJ expositions-1796 89 38 rejecting reject VERB expositions-1796 89 39 others other NOUN expositions-1796 89 40 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 90 1 in in ADP expositions-1796 90 2 this this DET expositions-1796 90 3 sort sort NOUN expositions-1796 90 4 of of ADP expositions-1796 90 5 scenario scenario NOUN expositions-1796 90 6 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 90 7 the the DET expositions-1796 90 8 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 90 9 fixed fix VERB expositions-1796 90 10 points point NOUN expositions-1796 90 11 would would AUX expositions-1796 90 12 function function VERB expositions-1796 90 13 as as ADP expositions-1796 90 14 epistemic epistemic ADJ expositions-1796 90 15 anchors anchor NOUN expositions-1796 90 16 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 90 17 providing provide VERB expositions-1796 90 18 the the DET expositions-1796 90 19 means mean NOUN expositions-1796 90 20 not not PART expositions-1796 90 21 only only ADV expositions-1796 90 22 to to PART expositions-1796 90 23 arrive arrive VERB expositions-1796 90 24 at at ADP expositions-1796 90 25 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 90 26 knowledge knowledge NOUN expositions-1796 90 27 but but CCONJ expositions-1796 90 28 to to PART expositions-1796 90 29 also also ADV expositions-1796 90 30 to to PART expositions-1796 90 31 engage engage VERB expositions-1796 90 32 in in ADP expositions-1796 90 33 processes process NOUN expositions-1796 90 34 of of ADP expositions-1796 90 35 rational rational ADJ expositions-1796 90 36 belief belief NOUN expositions-1796 90 37 revision revision NOUN expositions-1796 90 38 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 90 39 such such ADJ expositions-1796 90 40 as as ADP expositions-1796 90 41 reflective reflective ADJ expositions-1796 90 42 equilibrium equilibrium NOUN expositions-1796 90 43 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 91 1 there there PRON expositions-1796 91 2 is be VERB expositions-1796 91 3 much much ADV expositions-1796 91 4 more more ADJ expositions-1796 91 5 to to PART expositions-1796 91 6 say say VERB expositions-1796 91 7 about about ADP expositions-1796 91 8 the the DET expositions-1796 91 9 role role NOUN expositions-1796 91 10 of of ADP expositions-1796 91 11 the the DET expositions-1796 91 12 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 91 13 fixed fix VERB expositions-1796 91 14 points point NOUN expositions-1796 91 15 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 91 16 and and CCONJ expositions-1796 91 17 i i PRON expositions-1796 91 18 do do AUX expositions-1796 91 19 not not PART expositions-1796 91 20 want want VERB expositions-1796 91 21 to to PART expositions-1796 91 22 give give VERB expositions-1796 91 23 the the DET expositions-1796 91 24 impression impression NOUN expositions-1796 91 25 that that PRON expositions-1796 91 26 appeal appeal VERB expositions-1796 91 27 to to ADP expositions-1796 91 28 them they PRON expositions-1796 91 29 settles settle VERB expositions-1796 91 30 all all DET expositions-1796 91 31 questions question NOUN expositions-1796 91 32 that that SCONJ expositions-1796 91 33 the the DET expositions-1796 91 34 debunker debunker NOUN expositions-1796 91 35 ’s ’s PART expositions-1796 91 36 puzzle puzzle NOUN expositions-1796 91 37 might might AUX expositions-1796 91 38 raise raise VERB expositions-1796 91 39 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 92 1 ( ( PUNCT expositions-1796 92 2 appeal appeal VERB expositions-1796 92 3 to to ADP expositions-1796 92 4 the the DET expositions-1796 92 5 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 92 6 fixed fix VERB expositions-1796 92 7 points point NOUN expositions-1796 92 8 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 92 9 for for ADP expositions-1796 92 10 example example NOUN expositions-1796 92 11 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 92 12 does do AUX expositions-1796 92 13 n’t not PART expositions-1796 92 14 settle settle VERB expositions-1796 92 15 any any DET expositions-1796 92 16 issues issue NOUN expositions-1796 92 17 regarding regard VERB expositions-1796 92 18 whether whether SCONJ expositions-1796 92 19 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 92 20 reasons reason NOUN expositions-1796 92 21 are be AUX expositions-1796 92 22 authoritative.19 authoritative.19 NOUN expositions-1796 92 23 ) ) PUNCT expositions-1796 92 24 nor nor CCONJ expositions-1796 92 25 do do AUX expositions-1796 92 26 i i PRON expositions-1796 92 27 want want VERB expositions-1796 92 28 to to PART expositions-1796 92 29 deny deny VERB expositions-1796 92 30 that that SCONJ expositions-1796 92 31 certain certain ADJ expositions-1796 92 32 versions version NOUN expositions-1796 92 33 of of ADP expositions-1796 92 34 the the DET expositions-1796 92 35 debunker debunker NOUN expositions-1796 92 36 ’s ’s PART expositions-1796 92 37 puzzle puzzle NOUN expositions-1796 92 38 might might AUX expositions-1796 92 39 deny deny VERB expositions-1796 92 40 the the DET expositions-1796 92 41 no no DET expositions-1796 92 42 content content NOUN expositions-1796 92 43 thesis thesis NOUN expositions-1796 92 44 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 93 1 my my PRON expositions-1796 93 2 claims claim NOUN expositions-1796 93 3 are be AUX expositions-1796 93 4 more more ADV expositions-1796 93 5 modest modest ADJ expositions-1796 93 6 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 94 1 i i PRON expositions-1796 94 2 maintain maintain VERB expositions-1796 94 3 only only ADV expositions-1796 94 4 that that SCONJ expositions-1796 94 5 the the DET expositions-1796 94 6 version version NOUN expositions-1796 94 7 of of ADP expositions-1796 94 8 the the DET expositions-1796 94 9 debunker debunker NOUN expositions-1796 94 10 ’s ’s PART expositions-1796 94 11 puzzle puzzle NOUN expositions-1796 94 12 that that PRON expositions-1796 94 13 nagel nagel PROPN expositions-1796 94 14 accepts accept VERB expositions-1796 94 15 appeals appeal NOUN expositions-1796 94 16 to to ADP expositions-1796 94 17 the the DET expositions-1796 94 18 no no DET expositions-1796 94 19 content content NOUN expositions-1796 94 20 thesis thesis NOUN expositions-1796 94 21 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 94 22 and and CCONJ expositions-1796 94 23 that that SCONJ expositions-1796 94 24 nonnaturalists nonnaturalist NOUN expositions-1796 94 25 should should AUX expositions-1796 94 26 reject reject VERB expositions-1796 94 27 this this DET expositions-1796 94 28 thesis thesis NOUN expositions-1796 94 29 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 95 1 a a DET expositions-1796 95 2 satisfactory satisfactory ADJ expositions-1796 95 3 response response NOUN expositions-1796 95 4 to to ADP expositions-1796 95 5 the the DET expositions-1796 95 6 debunker debunker NOUN expositions-1796 95 7 ’s ’s PART expositions-1796 95 8 puzzle puzzle NOUN expositions-1796 95 9 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 95 10 then then ADV expositions-1796 95 11 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 95 12 requires require VERB expositions-1796 95 13 non non NOUN expositions-1796 95 14 - - NOUN expositions-1796 95 15 naturalists naturalist NOUN expositions-1796 95 16 neither neither PRON expositions-1796 95 17 to to PART expositions-1796 95 18 reject reject VERB expositions-1796 95 19 its its PRON expositions-1796 95 20 third third ADJ expositions-1796 95 21 claim claim NOUN expositions-1796 95 22 nor nor CCONJ expositions-1796 95 23 to to PART expositions-1796 95 24 embrace embrace VERB expositions-1796 95 25 something something PRON expositions-1796 95 26 as as ADP expositions-1796 95 27 controversial controversial ADJ expositions-1796 95 28 and and CCONJ expositions-1796 95 29 speculative speculative ADJ expositions-1796 95 30 as as ADP expositions-1796 95 31 nagel nagel PROPN expositions-1796 95 32 ’s ’s PART expositions-1796 95 33 teleological teleological ADJ expositions-1796 95 34 hypothesis hypothesis NOUN expositions-1796 95 35 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 96 1 dissolution dissolution PROPN expositions-1796 96 2 : : PUNCT expositions-1796 97 1 the the DET expositions-1796 97 2 second second ADJ expositions-1796 97 3 strategy strategy NOUN expositions-1796 97 4 dissolving dissolve VERB expositions-1796 97 5 the the DET expositions-1796 97 6 debunker debunker NOUN expositions-1796 97 7 ’s ’s PART expositions-1796 97 8 puzzle puzzle NOUN expositions-1796 97 9 44 44 NUM expositions-1796 97 10 in in ADP expositions-1796 97 11 the the DET expositions-1796 97 12 last last ADJ expositions-1796 97 13 section section NOUN expositions-1796 97 14 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 97 15 i i PRON expositions-1796 97 16 quoted quote VERB expositions-1796 97 17 a a DET expositions-1796 97 18 passage passage NOUN expositions-1796 97 19 in in ADP expositions-1796 97 20 which which PRON expositions-1796 97 21 street street NOUN expositions-1796 97 22 claims claim VERB expositions-1796 97 23 that that SCONJ expositions-1796 97 24 “ " PUNCT expositions-1796 97 25 the the DET expositions-1796 97 26 fund fund NOUN expositions-1796 97 27 of of ADP expositions-1796 97 28 evaluative evaluative ADJ expositions-1796 97 29 judgments judgment NOUN expositions-1796 97 30 with with ADP expositions-1796 97 31 which which PRON expositions-1796 97 32 human human ADJ expositions-1796 97 33 reflection reflection NOUN expositions-1796 97 34 began begin VERB expositions-1796 97 35 was be AUX expositions-1796 97 36 thoroughly thoroughly ADV expositions-1796 97 37 contaminated contaminate VERB expositions-1796 97 38 with with ADP expositions-1796 97 39 illegitimate illegitimate ADJ expositions-1796 97 40 influence influence NOUN expositions-1796 97 41 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 97 42 ” " PUNCT expositions-1796 98 1 in in ADP expositions-1796 98 2 his his PRON expositions-1796 98 3 discussions discussion NOUN expositions-1796 98 4 of of ADP expositions-1796 98 5 the the DET expositions-1796 98 6 debunker debunker NOUN expositions-1796 98 7 ’s ’s PART expositions-1796 98 8 puzzle puzzle NOUN expositions-1796 98 9 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 98 10 william william PROPN expositions-1796 98 11 fitzpatrick fitzpatrick PROPN expositions-1796 98 12 has have AUX expositions-1796 98 13 argued argue VERB expositions-1796 98 14 that that SCONJ expositions-1796 98 15 this this DET expositions-1796 98 16 claim claim NOUN expositions-1796 98 17 needs need VERB expositions-1796 98 18 to to PART expositions-1796 98 19 be be AUX expositions-1796 98 20 carefully carefully ADV expositions-1796 98 21 evaluated.20 evaluated.20 VERB expositions-1796 98 22 for for ADP expositions-1796 98 23 while while SCONJ expositions-1796 98 24 nearly nearly ADV expositions-1796 98 25 everyone everyone PRON expositions-1796 98 26 party party NOUN expositions-1796 98 27 to to ADP expositions-1796 98 28 the the DET expositions-1796 98 29 discussion discussion NOUN expositions-1796 98 30 of of ADP expositions-1796 98 31 whether whether SCONJ expositions-1796 98 32 our our PRON expositions-1796 98 33 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 98 34 judgments judgment NOUN expositions-1796 98 35 are be AUX expositions-1796 98 36 well well ADV expositions-1796 98 37 - - PUNCT expositions-1796 98 38 formed form VERB expositions-1796 98 39 accepts accept VERB expositions-1796 98 40 that that SCONJ expositions-1796 98 41 evolutionary evolutionary ADJ expositions-1796 98 42 forces force NOUN expositions-1796 98 43 have have AUX expositions-1796 98 44 influenced influence VERB expositions-1796 98 45 the the DET expositions-1796 98 46 workings working NOUN expositions-1796 98 47 of of ADP expositions-1796 98 48 our our PRON expositions-1796 98 49 cognitive cognitive ADJ expositions-1796 98 50 faculties faculty NOUN expositions-1796 98 51 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 98 52 including include VERB expositions-1796 98 53 the the DET expositions-1796 98 54 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 98 55 faculty faculty NOUN expositions-1796 98 56 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 98 57 the the DET expositions-1796 98 58 crucial crucial ADJ expositions-1796 98 59 question question NOUN expositions-1796 98 60 is be AUX expositions-1796 98 61 to to ADP expositions-1796 98 62 what what DET expositions-1796 98 63 extent extent NOUN expositions-1796 98 64 evolutionary evolutionary ADJ expositions-1796 98 65 forces force NOUN expositions-1796 98 66 have have AUX expositions-1796 98 67 influenced influence VERB expositions-1796 98 68 the the DET expositions-1796 98 69 workings working NOUN expositions-1796 98 70 of of ADP expositions-1796 98 71 the the DET expositions-1796 98 72 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 98 73 faculty faculty NOUN expositions-1796 98 74 and and CCONJ expositions-1796 98 75 whether whether SCONJ expositions-1796 98 76 its its PRON expositions-1796 98 77 influence influence NOUN expositions-1796 98 78 has have AUX expositions-1796 98 79 been be AUX expositions-1796 98 80 counteracted counteract VERB expositions-1796 98 81 by by ADP expositions-1796 98 82 other other ADJ expositions-1796 98 83 influences influence NOUN expositions-1796 98 84 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 98 85 such such ADJ expositions-1796 98 86 as as ADP expositions-1796 98 87 reliable reliable ADJ expositions-1796 98 88 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 98 89 reflection reflection NOUN expositions-1796 98 90 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 99 1 here here ADV expositions-1796 99 2 are be AUX expositions-1796 99 3 two two NUM expositions-1796 99 4 possibilities possibility NOUN expositions-1796 99 5 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 100 1 on on ADP expositions-1796 100 2 the the DET expositions-1796 100 3 one one NUM expositions-1796 100 4 hand hand NOUN expositions-1796 100 5 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 100 6 the the DET expositions-1796 100 7 debunker debunker NOUN expositions-1796 100 8 ’s ’s PART expositions-1796 100 9 puzzle puzzle NOUN expositions-1796 100 10 may may AUX expositions-1796 100 11 rely rely VERB expositions-1796 100 12 on on ADP expositions-1796 100 13 a a DET expositions-1796 100 14 very very ADV expositions-1796 100 15 strong strong ADJ expositions-1796 100 16 claim claim NOUN expositions-1796 100 17 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 100 18 such such ADJ expositions-1796 100 19 as as ADP expositions-1796 100 20 the the DET expositions-1796 100 21 : : PUNCT expositions-1796 100 22 extreme extreme ADJ expositions-1796 100 23 explanatory explanatory ADJ expositions-1796 100 24 claim claim NOUN expositions-1796 100 25 ( ( PUNCT expositions-1796 100 26 eec eec PROPN expositions-1796 100 27 ): ): PUNCT expositions-1796 100 28 the the DET expositions-1796 100 29 content content NOUN expositions-1796 100 30 of of ADP expositions-1796 100 31 our our PRON expositions-1796 100 32 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 100 33 beliefs belief NOUN expositions-1796 100 34 across across ADP expositions-1796 100 35 the the DET expositions-1796 100 36 board board NOUN expositions-1796 100 37 : : PUNCT expositions-1796 100 38 ( ( PUNCT expositions-1796 100 39 i i NOUN expositions-1796 100 40 ) ) PUNCT expositions-1796 100 41 reflects reflect VERB expositions-1796 100 42 deep deep ADJ expositions-1796 100 43 shaping shaping NOUN expositions-1796 100 44 by by ADP expositions-1796 100 45 evolutionary evolutionary ADJ expositions-1796 100 46 forces force NOUN expositions-1796 100 47 that that PRON expositions-1796 100 48 operated operate VERB expositions-1796 100 49 on on ADP expositions-1796 100 50 the the DET expositions-1796 100 51 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 100 52 belief belief NOUN expositions-1796 100 53 - - PUNCT expositions-1796 100 54 forming form VERB expositions-1796 100 55 dispositions disposition NOUN expositions-1796 100 56 of of ADP expositions-1796 100 57 ancestral ancestral ADJ expositions-1796 100 58 humans human NOUN expositions-1796 100 59 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 100 60 according accord VERB expositions-1796 100 61 to to ADP expositions-1796 100 62 principles principle NOUN expositions-1796 100 63 insensitive insensitive ADJ expositions-1796 100 64 to to ADP expositions-1796 100 65 the the DET expositions-1796 100 66 truth truth NOUN expositions-1796 100 67 of of ADP expositions-1796 100 68 the the DET expositions-1796 100 69 content content NOUN expositions-1796 100 70 of of ADP expositions-1796 100 71 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 100 72 beliefs belief NOUN expositions-1796 100 73 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 100 74 and and CCONJ expositions-1796 100 75 ( ( PUNCT expositions-1796 100 76 ii ii NOUN expositions-1796 100 77 ) ) PUNCT expositions-1796 100 78 does do AUX expositions-1796 100 79 not not PART expositions-1796 100 80 reflect reflect VERB expositions-1796 100 81 any any DET expositions-1796 100 82 independent independent ADJ expositions-1796 100 83 influence influence NOUN expositions-1796 100 84 from from ADP expositions-1796 100 85 developed develop VERB expositions-1796 100 86 forms form NOUN expositions-1796 100 87 of of ADP expositions-1796 100 88 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 100 89 reflection reflection NOUN expositions-1796 100 90 guided guide VERB expositions-1796 100 91 by by ADP expositions-1796 100 92 independent independent ADJ expositions-1796 100 93 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 100 94 facts fact NOUN expositions-1796 100 95 as as ADP expositions-1796 100 96 such such ADJ expositions-1796 100 97 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 100 98 through through ADP expositions-1796 100 99 a a DET expositions-1796 100 100 grasp grasp NOUN expositions-1796 100 101 of of ADP expositions-1796 100 102 their their PRON expositions-1796 100 103 grounds ground NOUN expositions-1796 100 104 as as ADP expositions-1796 100 105 such such ADJ expositions-1796 100 106 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 101 1 on on ADP expositions-1796 101 2 the the DET expositions-1796 101 3 other other ADJ expositions-1796 101 4 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 101 5 the the DET expositions-1796 101 6 debunker debunker NOUN expositions-1796 101 7 ’s ’s PART expositions-1796 101 8 puzzle puzzle NOUN expositions-1796 101 9 may may AUX expositions-1796 101 10 rely rely VERB expositions-1796 101 11 on on ADP expositions-1796 101 12 a a DET expositions-1796 101 13 significantly significantly ADV expositions-1796 101 14 weaker weak ADJ expositions-1796 101 15 claim claim NOUN expositions-1796 101 16 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 101 17 such such ADJ expositions-1796 101 18 as as ADP expositions-1796 101 19 the the DET expositions-1796 101 20 : : PUNCT expositions-1796 101 21 modest modest ADJ expositions-1796 101 22 explanatory explanatory ADJ expositions-1796 101 23 claim claim NOUN expositions-1796 101 24 ( ( PUNCT expositions-1796 101 25 mec mec NOUN expositions-1796 101 26 ): ): PUNCT expositions-1796 101 27 some some DET expositions-1796 101 28 familiar familiar ADJ expositions-1796 101 29 but but CCONJ expositions-1796 101 30 suspect suspect ADJ expositions-1796 101 31 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 101 32 beliefs belief NOUN expositions-1796 101 33 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 101 34 such such ADJ expositions-1796 101 35 as as ADP expositions-1796 101 36 those those PRON expositions-1796 101 37 that that PRON expositions-1796 101 38 concern concern VERB expositions-1796 101 39 racial racial ADJ expositions-1796 101 40 purity purity NOUN expositions-1796 101 41 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 101 42 rigid rigid ADJ expositions-1796 101 43 gender gender NOUN expositions-1796 101 44 roles role NOUN expositions-1796 101 45 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 101 46 and and CCONJ expositions-1796 101 47 clan clan NOUN expositions-1796 101 48 loyalty loyalty NOUN expositions-1796 101 49 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 101 50 plausibly plausibly ADV expositions-1796 101 51 reflect reflect VERB expositions-1796 101 52 only only ADV expositions-1796 101 53 evolutionary evolutionary ADJ expositions-1796 101 54 influences influence NOUN expositions-1796 101 55 unguided unguide VERB expositions-1796 101 56 by by ADP expositions-1796 101 57 the the DET expositions-1796 101 58 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 101 59 facts fact NOUN expositions-1796 101 60 ( ( PUNCT expositions-1796 101 61 and and CCONJ expositions-1796 101 62 conditioned condition VERB expositions-1796 101 63 by by ADP expositions-1796 101 64 cultural cultural ADJ expositions-1796 101 65 influences influence NOUN expositions-1796 101 66 operating operate VERB expositions-1796 101 67 equally equally ADV expositions-1796 101 68 independently independently ADV expositions-1796 101 69 of of ADP expositions-1796 101 70 the the DET expositions-1796 101 71 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 101 72 facts fact NOUN expositions-1796 101 73 ) ) PUNCT expositions-1796 101 74 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 101 75 which which PRON expositions-1796 101 76 are be AUX expositions-1796 101 77 thus thus ADV expositions-1796 101 78 unlikely unlikely ADJ expositions-1796 101 79 to to PART expositions-1796 101 80 be be AUX expositions-1796 101 81 reliable reliable ADJ expositions-1796 101 82 and and CCONJ expositions-1796 101 83 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 101 84 hence hence ADV expositions-1796 101 85 ( ( PUNCT expositions-1796 101 86 given give VERB expositions-1796 101 87 our our PRON expositions-1796 101 88 knowledge knowledge NOUN expositions-1796 101 89 of of ADP expositions-1796 101 90 this this PRON expositions-1796 101 91 ) ) PUNCT expositions-1796 101 92 are be AUX expositions-1796 101 93 likely likely ADV expositions-1796 101 94 unjustified unjustified ADJ expositions-1796 101 95 instead.21 instead.21 NOUN expositions-1796 101 96 in in ADP expositions-1796 101 97 principle principle NOUN expositions-1796 101 98 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 101 99 when when SCONJ expositions-1796 101 100 claim claim NOUN expositions-1796 101 101 ( ( PUNCT expositions-1796 101 102 3 3 NUM expositions-1796 101 103 ) ) PUNCT expositions-1796 101 104 of of ADP expositions-1796 101 105 the the DET expositions-1796 101 106 debunker debunker NOUN expositions-1796 101 107 ’s ’s PART expositions-1796 101 108 puzzle puzzle NOUN expositions-1796 101 109 tells tell VERB expositions-1796 101 110 us we PRON expositions-1796 101 111 that that SCONJ expositions-1796 101 112 evolutionary evolutionary ADJ expositions-1796 101 113 forces force NOUN expositions-1796 101 114 have have AUX expositions-1796 101 115 “ " PUNCT expositions-1796 101 116 considerably considerably ADV expositions-1796 101 117 shaped shape VERB expositions-1796 101 118 ” " PUNCT expositions-1796 101 119 the the DET expositions-1796 101 120 workings working NOUN expositions-1796 101 121 of of ADP expositions-1796 101 122 the the DET expositions-1796 101 123 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 101 124 faculty faculty NOUN expositions-1796 101 125 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 101 126 it it PRON expositions-1796 101 127 could could AUX expositions-1796 101 128 express express VERB expositions-1796 101 129 either either PRON expositions-1796 101 130 of of ADP expositions-1796 101 131 these these DET expositions-1796 101 132 claims claim NOUN expositions-1796 101 133 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 102 1 the the DET expositions-1796 102 2 question question NOUN expositions-1796 102 3 that that PRON expositions-1796 102 4 faces face VERB expositions-1796 102 5 non non NOUN expositions-1796 102 6 - - NOUN expositions-1796 102 7 naturalists naturalist NOUN expositions-1796 102 8 is be AUX expositions-1796 102 9 whether whether SCONJ expositions-1796 102 10 they they PRON expositions-1796 102 11 should should AUX expositions-1796 102 12 interpret interpret VERB expositions-1796 102 13 ( ( PUNCT expositions-1796 102 14 3 3 NUM expositions-1796 102 15 ) ) PUNCT expositions-1796 102 16 to to ADP expositions-1796 102 17 state state NOUN expositions-1796 102 18 ( ( PUNCT expositions-1796 102 19 eec eec PROPN expositions-1796 102 20 ) ) PUNCT expositions-1796 102 21 or or CCONJ expositions-1796 102 22 ( ( PUNCT expositions-1796 102 23 mec mec PROPN expositions-1796 102 24 ) ) PUNCT expositions-1796 102 25 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 103 1 following follow VERB expositions-1796 103 2 street street PROPN expositions-1796 103 3 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 103 4 nagel nagel PROPN expositions-1796 103 5 interprets interpret VERB expositions-1796 103 6 claim claim NOUN expositions-1796 103 7 ( ( PUNCT expositions-1796 103 8 3 3 NUM expositions-1796 103 9 ) ) PUNCT expositions-1796 103 10 of of ADP expositions-1796 103 11 the the DET expositions-1796 103 12 debunker debunker NOUN expositions-1796 103 13 ’s ’s PART expositions-1796 103 14 puzzle puzzle NOUN expositions-1796 103 15 to to PART expositions-1796 103 16 express express VERB expositions-1796 103 17 ( ( PUNCT expositions-1796 103 18 eec eec PROPN expositions-1796 103 19 ) ) PUNCT expositions-1796 103 20 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 104 1 this this PRON expositions-1796 104 2 strikes strike VERB expositions-1796 104 3 me i PRON expositions-1796 104 4 as as ADP expositions-1796 104 5 a a DET expositions-1796 104 6 mistake mistake NOUN expositions-1796 104 7 for for ADP expositions-1796 104 8 two two NUM expositions-1796 104 9 reasons reason NOUN expositions-1796 104 10 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 105 1 first first ADV expositions-1796 105 2 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 105 3 although although SCONJ expositions-1796 105 4 street street NOUN expositions-1796 105 5 presents present VERB expositions-1796 105 6 her her PRON expositions-1796 105 7 argument argument NOUN expositions-1796 105 8 as as SCONJ expositions-1796 105 9 if if SCONJ expositions-1796 105 10 it it PRON expositions-1796 105 11 turns turn VERB expositions-1796 105 12 on on ADP expositions-1796 105 13 widely widely ADV expositions-1796 105 14 accepted accept VERB expositions-1796 105 15 scientific scientific ADJ expositions-1796 105 16 claims claim NOUN expositions-1796 105 17 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 105 18 the the DET expositions-1796 105 19 relevant relevant ADJ expositions-1796 105 20 sciences science NOUN expositions-1796 105 21 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 105 22 such such ADJ expositions-1796 105 23 as as ADP expositions-1796 105 24 evolutionary evolutionary ADJ expositions-1796 105 25 biology biology NOUN expositions-1796 105 26 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 105 27 do do AUX expositions-1796 105 28 not not PART expositions-1796 105 29 tell tell VERB expositions-1796 105 30 us we PRON expositions-1796 105 31 or or CCONJ expositions-1796 105 32 imply imply VERB expositions-1796 105 33 that that SCONJ expositions-1796 105 34 ( ( PUNCT expositions-1796 105 35 eec eec PROPN expositions-1796 105 36 ) ) PUNCT expositions-1796 105 37 is be AUX expositions-1796 105 38 more more ADV expositions-1796 105 39 likely likely ADJ expositions-1796 105 40 to to PART expositions-1796 105 41 be be AUX expositions-1796 105 42 true true ADJ expositions-1796 105 43 than than ADP expositions-1796 105 44 ( ( PUNCT expositions-1796 105 45 mec mec NOUN expositions-1796 105 46 ) ) PUNCT expositions-1796 105 47 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 106 1 these these DET expositions-1796 106 2 sciences science NOUN expositions-1796 106 3 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 106 4 after after ADV expositions-1796 106 5 all all ADV expositions-1796 106 6 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 106 7 have have VERB expositions-1796 106 8 nothing nothing PRON expositions-1796 106 9 to to PART expositions-1796 106 10 say say VERB expositions-1796 106 11 about about ADP expositions-1796 106 12 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 106 13 facts fact NOUN expositions-1796 106 14 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 107 1 how how SCONJ expositions-1796 107 2 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 107 3 then then ADV expositions-1796 107 4 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 107 5 would would AUX expositions-1796 107 6 a a DET expositions-1796 107 7 discipline discipline NOUN expositions-1796 107 8 such such ADJ expositions-1796 107 9 as as ADP expositions-1796 107 10 evolutionary evolutionary ADJ expositions-1796 107 11 biology biology NOUN expositions-1796 107 12 give give VERB expositions-1796 107 13 us we PRON expositions-1796 107 14 good good ADJ expositions-1796 107 15 reason reason NOUN expositions-1796 107 16 to to PART expositions-1796 107 17 believe believe VERB expositions-1796 107 18 that that SCONJ expositions-1796 107 19 the the DET expositions-1796 107 20 workings working NOUN expositions-1796 107 21 of of ADP expositions-1796 107 22 the the DET expositions-1796 107 23 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 107 24 faculty faculty NOUN expositions-1796 107 25 does do AUX expositions-1796 107 26 not not PART expositions-1796 107 27 reflect reflect VERB expositions-1796 107 28 any any DET expositions-1796 107 29 independent independent ADJ expositions-1796 107 30 influence influence NOUN expositions-1796 107 31 from from ADP expositions-1796 107 32 developed develop VERB expositions-1796 107 33 forms form NOUN expositions-1796 107 34 of of ADP expositions-1796 107 35 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 107 36 reflection reflection NOUN expositions-1796 107 37 guided guide VERB expositions-1796 107 38 by by ADP expositions-1796 107 39 independent independent ADJ expositions-1796 107 40 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 107 41 45 45 NUM expositions-1796 107 42 cuneo cuneo NOUN expositions-1796 107 43 facts fact NOUN expositions-1796 107 44 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 107 45 through through ADP expositions-1796 107 46 a a DET expositions-1796 107 47 grasp grasp NOUN expositions-1796 107 48 of of ADP expositions-1796 107 49 them they PRON expositions-1796 107 50 or or CCONJ expositions-1796 107 51 their their PRON expositions-1796 107 52 grounds ground NOUN expositions-1796 107 53 ? ? PUNCT expositions-1796 108 1 second second ADJ expositions-1796 108 2 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 108 3 proponents proponent NOUN expositions-1796 108 4 of of ADP expositions-1796 108 5 the the DET expositions-1796 108 6 debunker debunker NOUN expositions-1796 108 7 ’s ’s PART expositions-1796 108 8 puzzle puzzle NOUN expositions-1796 108 9 such such ADJ expositions-1796 108 10 as as ADP expositions-1796 108 11 street street NOUN expositions-1796 108 12 can can AUX expositions-1796 108 13 not not PART expositions-1796 108 14 simply simply ADV expositions-1796 108 15 assume assume VERB expositions-1796 108 16 at at ADP expositions-1796 108 17 the the DET expositions-1796 108 18 outset outset NOUN expositions-1796 108 19 that that SCONJ expositions-1796 108 20 ( ( PUNCT expositions-1796 108 21 eec eec PROPN expositions-1796 108 22 ) ) PUNCT expositions-1796 108 23 is be AUX expositions-1796 108 24 true true ADJ expositions-1796 108 25 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 108 26 for for ADP expositions-1796 108 27 that that PRON expositions-1796 108 28 would would AUX expositions-1796 108 29 be be AUX expositions-1796 108 30 to to PART expositions-1796 108 31 assume assume VERB expositions-1796 108 32 what what PRON expositions-1796 108 33 needs need VERB expositions-1796 108 34 to to PART expositions-1796 108 35 be be AUX expositions-1796 108 36 established establish VERB expositions-1796 108 37 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 109 1 what what PRON expositions-1796 109 2 we we PRON expositions-1796 109 3 need need VERB expositions-1796 109 4 at at ADP expositions-1796 109 5 this this DET expositions-1796 109 6 point point NOUN expositions-1796 109 7 in in ADP expositions-1796 109 8 the the DET expositions-1796 109 9 dialectic dialectic NOUN expositions-1796 109 10 is be AUX expositions-1796 109 11 a a DET expositions-1796 109 12 compelling compelling ADJ expositions-1796 109 13 argument argument NOUN expositions-1796 109 14 that that SCONJ expositions-1796 109 15 non non NOUN expositions-1796 109 16 - - NOUN expositions-1796 109 17 naturalists naturalist NOUN expositions-1796 109 18 should should AUX expositions-1796 109 19 accept accept VERB expositions-1796 109 20 ( ( PUNCT expositions-1796 109 21 eec eec PROPN expositions-1796 109 22 ) ) PUNCT expositions-1796 109 23 rather rather ADV expositions-1796 109 24 than than ADP expositions-1796 109 25 ( ( PUNCT expositions-1796 109 26 mec mec NOUN expositions-1796 109 27 ) ) PUNCT expositions-1796 109 28 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 110 1 while while SCONJ expositions-1796 110 2 there there PRON expositions-1796 110 3 might might AUX expositions-1796 110 4 be be AUX expositions-1796 110 5 such such DET expositions-1796 110 6 an an DET expositions-1796 110 7 argument argument NOUN expositions-1796 110 8 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 110 9 it it PRON expositions-1796 110 10 is be AUX expositions-1796 110 11 worth worth ADJ expositions-1796 110 12 noting note VERB expositions-1796 110 13 that that SCONJ expositions-1796 110 14 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 110 15 to to ADP expositions-1796 110 16 this this DET expositions-1796 110 17 point point NOUN expositions-1796 110 18 in in ADP expositions-1796 110 19 the the DET expositions-1796 110 20 discussion discussion NOUN expositions-1796 110 21 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 110 22 advocates advocate NOUN expositions-1796 110 23 of of ADP expositions-1796 110 24 the the DET expositions-1796 110 25 debunker debunker NOUN expositions-1796 110 26 ’s ’s PART expositions-1796 110 27 puzzle puzzle NOUN expositions-1796 110 28 have have AUX expositions-1796 110 29 not not PART expositions-1796 110 30 produced produce VERB expositions-1796 110 31 it it PRON expositions-1796 110 32 — — PUNCT expositions-1796 110 33 the the DET expositions-1796 110 34 main main ADJ expositions-1796 110 35 reason reason NOUN expositions-1796 110 36 being be AUX expositions-1796 110 37 that that SCONJ expositions-1796 110 38 they they PRON expositions-1796 110 39 have have AUX expositions-1796 110 40 not not PART expositions-1796 110 41 distinguished distinguish VERB expositions-1796 110 42 ( ( PUNCT expositions-1796 110 43 eec eec PROPN expositions-1796 110 44 ) ) PUNCT expositions-1796 110 45 from from ADP expositions-1796 110 46 ( ( PUNCT expositions-1796 110 47 mec mec PROPN expositions-1796 110 48 ) ) PUNCT expositions-1796 110 49 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 110 50 as as SCONJ expositions-1796 110 51 fitzpatrick fitzpatrick PROPN expositions-1796 110 52 does do VERB expositions-1796 110 53 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 111 1 now now ADV expositions-1796 111 2 consider consider VERB expositions-1796 111 3 ( ( PUNCT expositions-1796 111 4 mec mec NOUN expositions-1796 111 5 ) ) PUNCT expositions-1796 111 6 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 111 7 which which PRON expositions-1796 111 8 is be AUX expositions-1796 111 9 ( ( PUNCT expositions-1796 111 10 in in ADP expositions-1796 111 11 one one NUM expositions-1796 111 12 respect respect NOUN expositions-1796 111 13 ) ) PUNCT expositions-1796 111 14 considerably considerably ADV expositions-1796 111 15 more more ADV expositions-1796 111 16 modest modest ADJ expositions-1796 111 17 than than ADP expositions-1796 111 18 ( ( PUNCT expositions-1796 111 19 eec eec PROPN expositions-1796 111 20 ) ) PUNCT expositions-1796 111 21 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 111 22 since since SCONJ expositions-1796 111 23 it it PRON expositions-1796 111 24 does do AUX expositions-1796 111 25 not not PART expositions-1796 111 26 imply imply VERB expositions-1796 111 27 that that SCONJ expositions-1796 111 28 our our PRON expositions-1796 111 29 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 111 30 beliefs belief NOUN expositions-1796 111 31 have have AUX expositions-1796 111 32 been be AUX expositions-1796 111 33 saturated saturate VERB expositions-1796 111 34 by by ADP expositions-1796 111 35 distorting distort VERB expositions-1796 111 36 evolutionary evolutionary ADJ expositions-1796 111 37 influences influence NOUN expositions-1796 111 38 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 112 1 while while SCONJ expositions-1796 112 2 ( ( PUNCT expositions-1796 112 3 mec mec NOUN expositions-1796 112 4 ) ) PUNCT expositions-1796 112 5 implies imply VERB expositions-1796 112 6 that that SCONJ expositions-1796 112 7 some some PRON expositions-1796 112 8 of of ADP expositions-1796 112 9 our our PRON expositions-1796 112 10 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 112 11 beliefs belief NOUN expositions-1796 112 12 are be AUX expositions-1796 112 13 suspect suspect ADJ expositions-1796 112 14 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 112 15 it it PRON expositions-1796 112 16 is be AUX expositions-1796 112 17 compatible compatible ADJ expositions-1796 112 18 with with ADP expositions-1796 112 19 other other ADJ expositions-1796 112 20 of of ADP expositions-1796 112 21 our our PRON expositions-1796 112 22 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 112 23 beliefs belief NOUN expositions-1796 112 24 being be AUX expositions-1796 112 25 reflective reflective ADJ expositions-1796 112 26 and and CCONJ expositions-1796 112 27 informed inform VERB expositions-1796 112 28 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 112 29 the the DET expositions-1796 112 30 result result NOUN expositions-1796 112 31 of of ADP expositions-1796 112 32 our our PRON expositions-1796 112 33 having having AUX expositions-1796 112 34 grasped grasp VERB expositions-1796 112 35 the the DET expositions-1796 112 36 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 112 37 facts fact NOUN expositions-1796 112 38 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 112 39 such such ADJ expositions-1796 112 40 as as ADP expositions-1796 112 41 the the DET expositions-1796 112 42 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 112 43 fixed fix VERB expositions-1796 112 44 points point NOUN expositions-1796 112 45 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 112 46 and and CCONJ expositions-1796 112 47 employed employ VERB expositions-1796 112 48 reliable reliable ADJ expositions-1796 112 49 strategies strategy NOUN expositions-1796 112 50 of of ADP expositions-1796 112 51 refining refine VERB expositions-1796 112 52 our our PRON expositions-1796 112 53 beliefs belief NOUN expositions-1796 112 54 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 112 55 such such ADJ expositions-1796 112 56 as as ADP expositions-1796 112 57 reflective reflective ADJ expositions-1796 112 58 equilibrium equilibrium NOUN expositions-1796 112 59 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 113 1 as as SCONJ expositions-1796 113 2 fitzpatrick fitzpatrick PROPN expositions-1796 113 3 points point VERB expositions-1796 113 4 out out ADP expositions-1796 113 5 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 113 6 ( ( PUNCT expositions-1796 113 7 mec mec X expositions-1796 113 8 ) ) PUNCT expositions-1796 113 9 is be AUX expositions-1796 113 10 modest modest ADJ expositions-1796 113 11 in in ADP expositions-1796 113 12 another another DET expositions-1796 113 13 important important ADJ expositions-1796 113 14 sense sense NOUN expositions-1796 113 15 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 113 16 since since SCONJ expositions-1796 113 17 it it PRON expositions-1796 113 18 requires require VERB expositions-1796 113 19 rather rather ADV expositions-1796 113 20 little little ADJ expositions-1796 113 21 of of ADP expositions-1796 113 22 evolution evolution NOUN expositions-1796 113 23 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 114 1 for for ADP expositions-1796 114 2 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 114 3 while while SCONJ expositions-1796 114 4 nonnaturalists nonnaturalist NOUN expositions-1796 114 5 must must AUX expositions-1796 114 6 hold hold VERB expositions-1796 114 7 that that SCONJ expositions-1796 114 8 the the DET expositions-1796 114 9 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 114 10 faculty faculty NOUN expositions-1796 114 11 yields yield VERB expositions-1796 114 12 a a DET expositions-1796 114 13 range range NOUN expositions-1796 114 14 of of ADP expositions-1796 114 15 well well ADV expositions-1796 114 16 - - PUNCT expositions-1796 114 17 formed form VERB expositions-1796 114 18 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 114 19 beliefs belief NOUN expositions-1796 114 20 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 114 21 they they PRON expositions-1796 114 22 need need VERB expositions-1796 114 23 n’t not PART expositions-1796 114 24 defend defend VERB expositions-1796 114 25 the the DET expositions-1796 114 26 further further ADJ expositions-1796 114 27 thesis thesis NOUN expositions-1796 114 28 that that SCONJ expositions-1796 114 29 evolution evolution NOUN expositions-1796 114 30 furnished furnish VERB expositions-1796 114 31 this this DET expositions-1796 114 32 faculty faculty NOUN expositions-1796 114 33 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 115 1 all all DET expositions-1796 115 2 that that PRON expositions-1796 115 3 ’s ’s AUX expositions-1796 115 4 needed need VERB expositions-1796 115 5 is be AUX expositions-1796 115 6 for for ADP expositions-1796 115 7 evolution evolution NOUN expositions-1796 115 8 to to PART expositions-1796 115 9 have have AUX expositions-1796 115 10 given give VERB expositions-1796 115 11 us we PRON expositions-1796 115 12 [ [ X expositions-1796 115 13 t]he t]he ADJ expositions-1796 115 14 basic basic ADJ expositions-1796 115 15 raw raw ADJ expositions-1796 115 16 materials material NOUN expositions-1796 115 17 — — PUNCT expositions-1796 115 18 reflective reflective ADJ expositions-1796 115 19 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 115 20 intellectual intellectual ADJ expositions-1796 115 21 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 115 22 and and CCONJ expositions-1796 115 23 emotional emotional ADJ expositions-1796 115 24 potentialities potentiality NOUN expositions-1796 115 25 — — PUNCT expositions-1796 115 26 necessary necessary ADJ expositions-1796 115 27 for for SCONJ expositions-1796 115 28 us we PRON expositions-1796 115 29 to to PART expositions-1796 115 30 develop develop VERB expositions-1796 115 31 reliable reliable ADJ expositions-1796 115 32 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 115 33 belief belief NOUN expositions-1796 115 34 - - PUNCT expositions-1796 115 35 forming form VERB expositions-1796 115 36 dispositions disposition NOUN expositions-1796 115 37 ourselves ourselves PRON expositions-1796 115 38 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 115 39 by by ADP expositions-1796 115 40 developing develop VERB expositions-1796 115 41 those those DET expositions-1796 115 42 potentialities potentiality NOUN expositions-1796 115 43 through through ADP expositions-1796 115 44 the the DET expositions-1796 115 45 right right ADJ expositions-1796 115 46 forms form NOUN expositions-1796 115 47 of of ADP expositions-1796 115 48 experience experience NOUN expositions-1796 115 49 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 115 50 training training NOUN expositions-1796 115 51 and and CCONJ expositions-1796 115 52 reflection reflection NOUN expositions-1796 115 53 in in ADP expositions-1796 115 54 rich rich ADJ expositions-1796 115 55 cultural cultural ADJ expositions-1796 115 56 contexts contexts NOUN expositions-1796 115 57 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 115 58 in in ADP expositions-1796 115 59 such such DET expositions-1796 115 60 a a DET expositions-1796 115 61 way way NOUN expositions-1796 115 62 as as SCONJ expositions-1796 115 63 to to PART expositions-1796 115 64 come come VERB expositions-1796 115 65 reliably reliably ADV expositions-1796 115 66 to to PART expositions-1796 115 67 track track VERB expositions-1796 115 68 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 115 69 truths truth NOUN expositions-1796 115 70 through through ADP expositions-1796 115 71 gaining gain VERB expositions-1796 115 72 understanding understanding NOUN expositions-1796 115 73 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 116 1 this this PRON expositions-1796 116 2 is be AUX expositions-1796 116 3 directly directly ADV expositions-1796 116 4 analogous analogous ADJ expositions-1796 116 5 to to ADP expositions-1796 116 6 our our PRON expositions-1796 116 7 cultural cultural ADJ expositions-1796 116 8 development development NOUN expositions-1796 116 9 in in ADP expositions-1796 116 10 other other ADJ expositions-1796 116 11 domains domain NOUN expositions-1796 116 12 of of ADP expositions-1796 116 13 reliable reliable ADJ expositions-1796 116 14 capacities capacity NOUN expositions-1796 116 15 to to PART expositions-1796 116 16 track track VERB expositions-1796 116 17 truths truth NOUN expositions-1796 116 18 about about ADP expositions-1796 116 19 non non ADJ expositions-1796 116 20 - - ADJ expositions-1796 116 21 linear linear ADJ expositions-1796 116 22 algebra algebra NOUN expositions-1796 116 23 or or CCONJ expositions-1796 116 24 quantum quantum ADJ expositions-1796 116 25 non non ADJ expositions-1796 116 26 - - ADJ expositions-1796 116 27 locality locality ADJ expositions-1796 116 28 or or CCONJ expositions-1796 116 29 metaphysical metaphysical ADJ expositions-1796 116 30 modality modality NOUN expositions-1796 116 31 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 116 32 none none NOUN expositions-1796 116 33 of of ADP expositions-1796 116 34 which which PRON expositions-1796 116 35 played play VERB expositions-1796 116 36 any any DET expositions-1796 116 37 more more ADJ expositions-1796 116 38 role role NOUN expositions-1796 116 39 in in ADP expositions-1796 116 40 the the DET expositions-1796 116 41 evolution evolution NOUN expositions-1796 116 42 of of ADP expositions-1796 116 43 pleistocene pleistocene PROPN expositions-1796 116 44 human human ADJ expositions-1796 116 45 cognitive cognitive ADJ expositions-1796 116 46 capacities capacity NOUN expositions-1796 116 47 than than ADP expositions-1796 116 48 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 116 49 truths truth NOUN expositions-1796 116 50 did.22 did.22 NOUN expositions-1796 116 51 in in ADP expositions-1796 116 52 fact fact NOUN expositions-1796 116 53 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 116 54 if if SCONJ expositions-1796 116 55 i i PRON expositions-1796 116 56 am be AUX expositions-1796 116 57 right right ADJ expositions-1796 116 58 to to PART expositions-1796 116 59 hold hold VERB expositions-1796 116 60 that that SCONJ expositions-1796 116 61 the the DET expositions-1796 116 62 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 116 63 fixed fix VERB expositions-1796 116 64 points point NOUN expositions-1796 116 65 are be AUX expositions-1796 116 66 a a DET expositions-1796 116 67 species species NOUN expositions-1796 116 68 of of ADP expositions-1796 116 69 conceptual conceptual ADJ expositions-1796 116 70 truth truth NOUN expositions-1796 116 71 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 116 72 then then ADV expositions-1796 116 73 to to PART expositions-1796 116 74 acquire acquire VERB expositions-1796 116 75 some some DET expositions-1796 116 76 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 116 77 knowledge knowledge NOUN expositions-1796 116 78 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 116 79 evolution evolution NOUN expositions-1796 116 80 need need AUX expositions-1796 116 81 only only ADV expositions-1796 116 82 have have AUX expositions-1796 116 83 equipped equip VERB expositions-1796 116 84 us we PRON expositions-1796 116 85 with with ADP expositions-1796 116 86 the the DET expositions-1796 116 87 ability ability NOUN expositions-1796 116 88 to to PART expositions-1796 116 89 grasp grasp VERB expositions-1796 116 90 to to ADP expositions-1796 116 91 a a DET expositions-1796 116 92 sufficient sufficient ADJ expositions-1796 116 93 degree degree NOUN expositions-1796 116 94 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 116 95 concepts concept NOUN expositions-1796 116 96 such such ADJ expositions-1796 116 97 as as ADP expositions-1796 116 98 ‘ ' PUNCT expositions-1796 116 99 being be AUX expositions-1796 116 100 wrong wrong ADJ expositions-1796 116 101 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 116 102 ’ ' PUNCT expositions-1796 117 1 with with ADP expositions-1796 117 2 such such ADJ expositions-1796 117 3 abilities ability NOUN expositions-1796 117 4 at at ADP expositions-1796 117 5 our our PRON expositions-1796 117 6 disposal disposal NOUN expositions-1796 117 7 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 117 8 we we PRON expositions-1796 117 9 could could AUX expositions-1796 117 10 thereby thereby ADV expositions-1796 117 11 come come VERB expositions-1796 117 12 to to PART expositions-1796 117 13 know know VERB expositions-1796 117 14 a a DET expositions-1796 117 15 variety variety NOUN expositions-1796 117 16 of of ADP expositions-1796 117 17 fundamental fundamental ADJ expositions-1796 117 18 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 117 19 truths truth NOUN expositions-1796 117 20 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 118 1 conclusion conclusion NOUN expositions-1796 118 2 let let VERB expositions-1796 118 3 us we PRON expositions-1796 118 4 return return VERB expositions-1796 118 5 to to ADP expositions-1796 118 6 the the DET expositions-1796 118 7 debunker debunker NOUN expositions-1796 118 8 ’s ’s PART expositions-1796 118 9 puzzle puzzle NOUN expositions-1796 118 10 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 118 11 which which PRON expositions-1796 118 12 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 118 13 you you PRON expositions-1796 118 14 ’ll ’ll AUX expositions-1796 118 15 remember remember VERB expositions-1796 118 16 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 118 17 includes include VERB expositions-1796 118 18 the the DET expositions-1796 118 19 following follow VERB expositions-1796 118 20 three three NUM expositions-1796 118 21 claims claim NOUN expositions-1796 118 22 : : PUNCT expositions-1796 118 23 ( ( PUNCT expositions-1796 118 24 1 1 X expositions-1796 118 25 ) ) PUNCT expositions-1796 118 26 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 118 27 non non ADJ expositions-1796 118 28 - - NOUN expositions-1796 118 29 naturalism naturalism NOUN expositions-1796 118 30 : : PUNCT expositions-1796 118 31 there there PRON expositions-1796 118 32 are be VERB expositions-1796 118 33 non non ADJ expositions-1796 118 34 - - ADJ expositions-1796 118 35 natural natural ADJ expositions-1796 118 36 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 118 37 facts fact NOUN expositions-1796 118 38 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 118 39 including include VERB expositions-1796 118 40 reasons reason NOUN expositions-1796 118 41 to to PART expositions-1796 118 42 act act VERB expositions-1796 118 43 in in ADP expositions-1796 118 44 certain certain ADJ expositions-1796 118 45 ways way NOUN expositions-1796 118 46 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 119 1 ( ( PUNCT expositions-1796 119 2 2 2 X expositions-1796 119 3 ) ) PUNCT expositions-1796 119 4 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 119 5 knowledge knowledge NOUN expositions-1796 119 6 : : PUNCT expositions-1796 119 7 we we PRON expositions-1796 119 8 have have VERB expositions-1796 119 9 some some DET expositions-1796 119 10 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 119 11 knowledge knowledge NOUN expositions-1796 119 12 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 120 1 dissolving dissolve VERB expositions-1796 120 2 the the DET expositions-1796 120 3 debunker debunker NOUN expositions-1796 120 4 ’s ’s PART expositions-1796 120 5 puzzle puzzle NOUN expositions-1796 120 6 46 46 NUM expositions-1796 120 7 ( ( PUNCT expositions-1796 120 8 3 3 NUM expositions-1796 120 9 ) ) PUNCT expositions-1796 120 10 evolutionary evolutionary ADJ expositions-1796 120 11 influence influence NOUN expositions-1796 120 12 : : PUNCT expositions-1796 120 13 evolutionary evolutionary ADJ expositions-1796 120 14 forces force NOUN expositions-1796 120 15 have have AUX expositions-1796 120 16 not not PART expositions-1796 120 17 only only ADV expositions-1796 120 18 determined determine VERB expositions-1796 120 19 which which DET expositions-1796 120 20 cognitive cognitive ADJ expositions-1796 120 21 faculties faculty NOUN expositions-1796 120 22 we we PRON expositions-1796 120 23 have have VERB expositions-1796 120 24 but but CCONJ expositions-1796 120 25 also also ADV expositions-1796 120 26 considerably considerably ADV expositions-1796 120 27 shaped shape VERB expositions-1796 120 28 their their PRON expositions-1796 120 29 workings working NOUN expositions-1796 120 30 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 120 31 including include VERB expositions-1796 120 32 the the DET expositions-1796 120 33 workings working NOUN expositions-1796 120 34 of of ADP expositions-1796 120 35 the the DET expositions-1796 120 36 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 120 37 faculty faculty NOUN expositions-1796 120 38 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 120 39 which which PRON expositions-1796 120 40 is be AUX expositions-1796 120 41 simply simply ADV expositions-1796 120 42 that that DET expositions-1796 120 43 ability ability NOUN expositions-1796 120 44 ( ( PUNCT expositions-1796 120 45 or or CCONJ expositions-1796 120 46 cluster cluster NOUN expositions-1796 120 47 of of ADP expositions-1796 120 48 abilities ability NOUN expositions-1796 120 49 ) ) PUNCT expositions-1796 120 50 by by ADP expositions-1796 120 51 which which PRON expositions-1796 120 52 we we PRON expositions-1796 120 53 form form VERB expositions-1796 120 54 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 120 55 judgments judgment NOUN expositions-1796 120 56 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 121 1 suppose suppose VERB expositions-1796 121 2 you you PRON expositions-1796 121 3 were be AUX expositions-1796 121 4 to to PART expositions-1796 121 5 accept accept VERB expositions-1796 121 6 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 121 7 as as SCONJ expositions-1796 121 8 nagel nagel PROPN expositions-1796 121 9 does do VERB expositions-1796 121 10 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 121 11 the the DET expositions-1796 121 12 no no DET expositions-1796 121 13 content content NOUN expositions-1796 121 14 thesis thesis NOUN expositions-1796 121 15 and and CCONJ expositions-1796 121 16 the the DET expositions-1796 121 17 extreme extreme ADJ expositions-1796 121 18 explanatory explanatory ADJ expositions-1796 121 19 claim claim NOUN expositions-1796 121 20 ( ( PUNCT expositions-1796 121 21 eec eec PROPN expositions-1796 121 22 ) ) PUNCT expositions-1796 121 23 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 122 1 if if SCONJ expositions-1796 122 2 you you PRON expositions-1796 122 3 wished wish VERB expositions-1796 122 4 to to PART expositions-1796 122 5 resist resist VERB expositions-1796 122 6 rejecting reject VERB expositions-1796 122 7 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 122 8 non non ADJ expositions-1796 122 9 - - NOUN expositions-1796 122 10 naturalism naturalism NOUN expositions-1796 122 11 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 122 12 that that PRON expositions-1796 122 13 might might AUX expositions-1796 122 14 require require VERB expositions-1796 122 15 you you PRON expositions-1796 122 16 to to PART expositions-1796 122 17 reject reject VERB expositions-1796 122 18 claim claim NOUN expositions-1796 122 19 ( ( PUNCT expositions-1796 122 20 3 3 NUM expositions-1796 122 21 ) ) PUNCT expositions-1796 122 22 of of ADP expositions-1796 122 23 the the DET expositions-1796 122 24 puzzle puzzle NOUN expositions-1796 122 25 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 122 26 offering offer VERB expositions-1796 122 27 an an DET expositions-1796 122 28 alternative alternative ADJ expositions-1796 122 29 explanation explanation NOUN expositions-1796 122 30 of of ADP expositions-1796 122 31 how how SCONJ expositions-1796 122 32 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 122 33 given give VERB expositions-1796 122 34 our our PRON expositions-1796 122 35 evolutionary evolutionary ADJ expositions-1796 122 36 history history NOUN expositions-1796 122 37 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 122 38 we we PRON expositions-1796 122 39 might might AUX expositions-1796 122 40 have have AUX expositions-1796 122 41 arrived arrive VERB expositions-1796 122 42 at at ADP expositions-1796 122 43 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 122 44 knowledge.23 knowledge.23 PROPN expositions-1796 122 45 in in ADP expositions-1796 122 46 response response NOUN expositions-1796 122 47 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 122 48 i i PRON expositions-1796 122 49 ’ve ’ve AUX expositions-1796 122 50 argued argue VERB expositions-1796 122 51 that that SCONJ expositions-1796 122 52 we we PRON expositions-1796 122 53 should should AUX expositions-1796 122 54 prefer prefer VERB expositions-1796 122 55 a a DET expositions-1796 122 56 more more ADV expositions-1796 122 57 conservative conservative ADJ expositions-1796 122 58 approach approach NOUN expositions-1796 122 59 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 123 1 we we PRON expositions-1796 123 2 should should AUX expositions-1796 123 3 accept accept VERB expositions-1796 123 4 all all DET expositions-1796 123 5 three three NUM expositions-1796 123 6 claims claim NOUN expositions-1796 123 7 of of ADP expositions-1796 123 8 the the DET expositions-1796 123 9 debunker debunker NOUN expositions-1796 123 10 ’s ’s PART expositions-1796 123 11 puzzle puzzle NOUN expositions-1796 123 12 but but CCONJ expositions-1796 123 13 reject reject VERB expositions-1796 123 14 both both DET expositions-1796 123 15 the the DET expositions-1796 123 16 no no DET expositions-1796 123 17 content content NOUN expositions-1796 123 18 thesis thesis NOUN expositions-1796 123 19 and and CCONJ expositions-1796 123 20 the the DET expositions-1796 123 21 extreme extreme ADJ expositions-1796 123 22 explanatory explanatory ADJ expositions-1796 123 23 claim claim NOUN expositions-1796 123 24 ( ( PUNCT expositions-1796 123 25 eec eec PROPN expositions-1796 123 26 ) ) PUNCT expositions-1796 123 27 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 124 1 notes note VERB expositions-1796 124 2 1 1 NUM expositions-1796 124 3 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 125 1 nagel nagel PROPN expositions-1796 125 2 2012 2012 NUM expositions-1796 125 3 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 126 1 2 2 X expositions-1796 126 2 . . X expositions-1796 126 3 i i PRON expositions-1796 126 4 have have VERB expositions-1796 126 5 reservations reservation NOUN expositions-1796 126 6 about about ADP expositions-1796 126 7 some some PRON expositions-1796 126 8 of of ADP expositions-1796 126 9 the the DET expositions-1796 126 10 claims claim NOUN expositions-1796 126 11 that that PRON expositions-1796 126 12 nagel nagel PROPN expositions-1796 126 13 attributes attribute VERB expositions-1796 126 14 to to ADP expositions-1796 126 15 non non NOUN expositions-1796 126 16 - - NOUN expositions-1796 126 17 naturalists naturalist NOUN expositions-1796 126 18 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 126 19 but but CCONJ expositions-1796 126 20 these these DET expositions-1796 126 21 differences difference NOUN expositions-1796 126 22 will will AUX expositions-1796 126 23 not not PART expositions-1796 126 24 matter matter VERB expositions-1796 126 25 for for ADP expositions-1796 126 26 present present ADJ expositions-1796 126 27 purposes purpose NOUN expositions-1796 126 28 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 127 1 3 3 X expositions-1796 127 2 . . X expositions-1796 127 3 variations variation NOUN expositions-1796 127 4 of of ADP expositions-1796 127 5 the the DET expositions-1796 127 6 puzzle puzzle NOUN expositions-1796 127 7 can can AUX expositions-1796 127 8 be be AUX expositions-1796 127 9 found find VERB expositions-1796 127 10 in in ADP expositions-1796 127 11 greene greene PROPN expositions-1796 127 12 2008 2008 NUM expositions-1796 127 13 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 127 14 joyce joyce PROPN expositions-1796 127 15 2006 2006 NUM expositions-1796 127 16 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 127 17 kitcher kitcher NOUN expositions-1796 127 18 2005 2005 NUM expositions-1796 127 19 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 127 20 2011 2011 NUM expositions-1796 127 21 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 127 22 locke locke PROPN expositions-1796 127 23 2014 2014 NUM expositions-1796 127 24 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 127 25 ruse ruse VERB expositions-1796 127 26 1998 1998 NUM expositions-1796 127 27 ( ( PUNCT expositions-1796 127 28 ch ch NOUN expositions-1796 127 29 . . PROPN expositions-1796 127 30 6 6 NUM expositions-1796 127 31 ) ) PUNCT expositions-1796 127 32 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 127 33 and and CCONJ expositions-1796 127 34 street street NOUN expositions-1796 127 35 2006 2006 NUM expositions-1796 127 36 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 127 37 2008a 2008a NUM expositions-1796 127 38 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 127 39 forthcoming forthcoming ADJ expositions-1796 127 40 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 128 1 4 4 X expositions-1796 128 2 . . X expositions-1796 128 3 defenders defender NOUN expositions-1796 128 4 of of ADP expositions-1796 128 5 non non ADJ expositions-1796 128 6 - - NOUN expositions-1796 128 7 naturalism naturalism NOUN expositions-1796 128 8 include include VERB expositions-1796 128 9 cuneo cuneo NOUN expositions-1796 128 10 and and CCONJ expositions-1796 128 11 shafer shafer NOUN expositions-1796 128 12 - - PUNCT expositions-1796 128 13 landau landau NOUN expositions-1796 128 14 2014 2014 NUM expositions-1796 128 15 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 128 16 enoch enoch PROPN expositions-1796 128 17 2011 2011 NUM expositions-1796 128 18 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 128 19 fitzpatrick fitzpatrick PROPN expositions-1796 128 20 2008 2008 NUM expositions-1796 128 21 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 128 22 2011 2011 NUM expositions-1796 128 23 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 128 24 parfit parfit NOUN expositions-1796 128 25 2011 2011 NUM expositions-1796 128 26 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 128 27 scanlon scanlon PROPN expositions-1796 128 28 1998 1998 NUM expositions-1796 128 29 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 128 30 shafer shafer NOUN expositions-1796 128 31 - - PUNCT expositions-1796 128 32 landau landau NOUN expositions-1796 128 33 2003 2003 NUM expositions-1796 128 34 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 128 35 2006 2006 NUM expositions-1796 128 36 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 128 37 and and CCONJ expositions-1796 128 38 wedgwood wedgwood PROPN expositions-1796 128 39 2007 2007 NUM expositions-1796 128 40 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 129 1 5 5 NUM expositions-1796 129 2 . . X expositions-1796 130 1 nagel nagel PROPN expositions-1796 130 2 2012 2012 NUM expositions-1796 130 3 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 130 4 98–113 98–113 PROPN expositions-1796 130 5 . . PROPN expositions-1796 130 6 6 6 NUM expositions-1796 130 7 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 130 8 nagel nagel PROPN expositions-1796 130 9 2012 2012 NUM expositions-1796 130 10 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 130 11 107–09 107–09 NUM expositions-1796 130 12 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 130 13 7 7 NUM expositions-1796 130 14 . . X expositions-1796 130 15 nagel nagel PROPN expositions-1796 130 16 2012 2012 NUM expositions-1796 130 17 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 130 18 108 108 NUM expositions-1796 130 19 . . NOUN expositions-1796 130 20 8 8 NUM expositions-1796 130 21 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 130 22 street street PROPN expositions-1796 130 23 2006 2006 NUM expositions-1796 130 24 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 130 25 121 121 NUM expositions-1796 130 26 . . NOUN expositions-1796 130 27 9 9 X expositions-1796 130 28 . . X expositions-1796 130 29 see see VERB expositions-1796 130 30 joyce joyce PROPN expositions-1796 130 31 2001 2001 NUM expositions-1796 130 32 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 130 33 2006 2006 NUM expositions-1796 130 34 and and CCONJ expositions-1796 130 35 olson olson NOUN expositions-1796 130 36 2014 2014 NUM expositions-1796 130 37 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 131 1 10 10 NUM expositions-1796 131 2 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 132 1 see see VERB expositions-1796 132 2 copp copp ADJ expositions-1796 132 3 2008 2008 NUM expositions-1796 132 4 and and CCONJ expositions-1796 132 5 railton railton NOUN expositions-1796 132 6 2010 2010 NUM expositions-1796 132 7 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 133 1 11 11 NUM expositions-1796 133 2 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 134 1 see see VERB expositions-1796 134 2 nagel nagel PROPN expositions-1796 134 3 2012 2012 NUM expositions-1796 134 4 and and CCONJ expositions-1796 134 5 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 134 6 somewhat somewhat ADV expositions-1796 134 7 differently differently ADV expositions-1796 134 8 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 134 9 plantinga plantinga ADV expositions-1796 134 10 1993 1993 NUM expositions-1796 134 11 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 134 12 2002 2002 NUM expositions-1796 134 13 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 134 14 and and CCONJ expositions-1796 134 15 plantinga plantinga ADV expositions-1796 134 16 and and CCONJ expositions-1796 134 17 tooley tooley NOUN expositions-1796 134 18 2008 2008 NUM expositions-1796 134 19 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 135 1 12 12 NUM expositions-1796 135 2 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 136 1 nagel nagel PROPN expositions-1796 136 2 2012 2012 NUM expositions-1796 136 3 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 136 4 121 121 NUM expositions-1796 136 5 . . NOUN expositions-1796 136 6 13 13 NUM expositions-1796 136 7 . . X expositions-1796 136 8 ibid ibid NOUN expositions-1796 136 9 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 137 1 47 47 NUM expositions-1796 137 2 cuneo cuneo NOUN expositions-1796 137 3 14 14 NUM expositions-1796 137 4 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 138 1 nagel nagel PROPN expositions-1796 138 2 2012 2012 NUM expositions-1796 138 3 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 138 4 123 123 NUM expositions-1796 138 5 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 138 6 15 15 NUM expositions-1796 138 7 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 138 8 street street PROPN expositions-1796 138 9 2008a 2008a NUM expositions-1796 138 10 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 138 11 208 208 NUM expositions-1796 138 12 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 139 1 this this DET expositions-1796 139 2 claim claim NOUN expositions-1796 139 3 is be AUX expositions-1796 139 4 assumed assume VERB expositions-1796 139 5 as as ADV expositions-1796 139 6 well well ADV expositions-1796 139 7 in in ADP expositions-1796 139 8 street street NOUN expositions-1796 139 9 2006 2006 NUM expositions-1796 139 10 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 139 11 passim passim NOUN expositions-1796 139 12 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 140 1 16 16 NUM expositions-1796 140 2 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 141 1 nagel nagel PROPN expositions-1796 141 2 2012 2012 NUM expositions-1796 141 3 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 141 4 107 107 NUM expositions-1796 141 5 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 141 6 17 17 NUM expositions-1796 141 7 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 142 1 in in ADP expositions-1796 142 2 what what PRON expositions-1796 142 3 follows follow VERB expositions-1796 142 4 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 142 5 i i PRON expositions-1796 142 6 sketch sketch VERB expositions-1796 142 7 the the DET expositions-1796 142 8 approach approach NOUN expositions-1796 142 9 developed develop VERB expositions-1796 142 10 and and CCONJ expositions-1796 142 11 defended defend VERB expositions-1796 142 12 at at ADP expositions-1796 142 13 greater great ADJ expositions-1796 142 14 length length NOUN expositions-1796 142 15 in in ADP expositions-1796 142 16 cuneo cuneo PROPN expositions-1796 142 17 and and CCONJ expositions-1796 142 18 shafer shafer PROPN expositions-1796 142 19 - - PUNCT expositions-1796 142 20 landau landau NOUN expositions-1796 142 21 2014 2014 NUM expositions-1796 142 22 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 143 1 18 18 NUM expositions-1796 143 2 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 143 3 street street PROPN expositions-1796 143 4 2006 2006 NUM expositions-1796 143 5 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 143 6 124 124 NUM expositions-1796 143 7 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 143 8 19 19 NUM expositions-1796 143 9 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 144 1 although although SCONJ expositions-1796 144 2 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 144 3 i i PRON expositions-1796 144 4 believe believe VERB expositions-1796 144 5 that that DET expositions-1796 144 6 appeal appeal NOUN expositions-1796 144 7 to to ADP expositions-1796 144 8 them they PRON expositions-1796 144 9 helps help VERB expositions-1796 144 10 ; ; PUNCT expositions-1796 144 11 see see VERB expositions-1796 144 12 cuneo cuneo NOUN expositions-1796 144 13 2014 2014 NUM expositions-1796 144 14 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 144 15 ch ch NOUN expositions-1796 144 16 . . PROPN expositions-1796 144 17 7 7 NUM expositions-1796 144 18 . . NUM expositions-1796 144 19 20 20 NUM expositions-1796 144 20 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 145 1 see see VERB expositions-1796 145 2 fitzpatrick fitzpatrick PROPN expositions-1796 145 3 2014a 2014a PROPN expositions-1796 145 4 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 145 5 2014b 2014b NUM expositions-1796 145 6 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 146 1 21 21 NUM expositions-1796 146 2 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 147 1 cf cf NOUN expositions-1796 147 2 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 148 1 fitzpatrick fitzpatrick PROPN expositions-1796 148 2 2014a 2014a PROPN expositions-1796 148 3 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 149 1 22 22 NUM expositions-1796 149 2 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 150 1 fitzpatrick fitzpatrick PROPN expositions-1796 150 2 2014b 2014b PROPN expositions-1796 150 3 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 150 4 245 245 NUM expositions-1796 150 5 . . NOUN expositions-1796 150 6 23 23 NUM expositions-1796 150 7 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 151 1 although although SCONJ expositions-1796 151 2 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 151 3 see see VERB expositions-1796 151 4 enoch enoch PROPN expositions-1796 151 5 2011 2011 NUM expositions-1796 151 6 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 151 7 ch ch NOUN expositions-1796 151 8 . . PROPN expositions-1796 151 9 7 7 NUM expositions-1796 151 10 and and CCONJ expositions-1796 151 11 wielenberg wielenberg NOUN expositions-1796 151 12 2010 2010 NUM expositions-1796 151 13 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 152 1 works work NOUN expositions-1796 152 2 cited cite VERB expositions-1796 152 3 copp copp PROPN expositions-1796 152 4 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 152 5 david david PROPN expositions-1796 152 6 . . PROPN expositions-1796 152 7 2008 2008 NUM expositions-1796 152 8 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 153 1 “ " PUNCT expositions-1796 153 2 darwinian darwinian VERB expositions-1796 153 3 skepticism skepticism NOUN expositions-1796 153 4 about about ADP expositions-1796 153 5 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 153 6 realism realism NOUN expositions-1796 153 7 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 153 8 ” " PUNCT expositions-1796 154 1 philosophical philosophical ADJ expositions-1796 154 2 issues issue NOUN expositions-1796 154 3 18 18 NUM expositions-1796 154 4 : : PUNCT expositions-1796 154 5 184–204 184–204 NUM expositions-1796 154 6 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 155 1 cuneo cuneo PROPN expositions-1796 155 2 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 155 3 terence terence PROPN expositions-1796 155 4 . . PROPN expositions-1796 155 5 2014 2014 NUM expositions-1796 155 6 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 156 1 speech speech NOUN expositions-1796 156 2 and and CCONJ expositions-1796 156 3 morality morality NOUN expositions-1796 156 4 : : PUNCT expositions-1796 156 5 on on ADP expositions-1796 156 6 the the DET expositions-1796 156 7 metaethical metaethical ADJ expositions-1796 156 8 implications implication NOUN expositions-1796 156 9 of of ADP expositions-1796 156 10 speaking speak VERB expositions-1796 156 11 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 157 1 oxford oxford NOUN expositions-1796 157 2 : : PUNCT expositions-1796 157 3 oxford oxford PROPN expositions-1796 157 4 university university PROPN expositions-1796 157 5 press press NOUN expositions-1796 157 6 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 158 1 cuneo cuneo PROPN expositions-1796 158 2 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 158 3 terence terence PROPN expositions-1796 158 4 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 158 5 and and CCONJ expositions-1796 158 6 russ russ PROPN expositions-1796 158 7 shafer shafer PROPN expositions-1796 158 8 - - PUNCT expositions-1796 158 9 landau landau NOUN expositions-1796 158 10 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 159 1 2014 2014 NUM expositions-1796 159 2 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 160 1 “ " PUNCT expositions-1796 160 2 the the DET expositions-1796 160 3 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 160 4 fixed fix VERB expositions-1796 160 5 points point NOUN expositions-1796 160 6 : : PUNCT expositions-1796 160 7 new new ADJ expositions-1796 160 8 directions direction NOUN expositions-1796 160 9 for for ADP expositions-1796 160 10 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 160 11 nonnaturalism nonnaturalism NOUN expositions-1796 160 12 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 160 13 ” " PUNCT expositions-1796 161 1 philosophical philosophical ADJ expositions-1796 161 2 studies study NOUN expositions-1796 161 3 doi doi VERB expositions-1796 161 4 10.1007 10.1007 NUM expositions-1796 161 5 / / SYM expositions-1796 161 6 s11098–013–0277–5 s11098–013–0277–5 PROPN expositions-1796 161 7 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 162 1 enoch enoch PROPN expositions-1796 162 2 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 162 3 david david PROPN expositions-1796 162 4 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 162 5 2011 2011 NUM expositions-1796 162 6 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 163 1 taking take VERB expositions-1796 163 2 morality morality NOUN expositions-1796 163 3 seriously seriously ADV expositions-1796 163 4 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 164 1 oxford oxford NOUN expositions-1796 164 2 : : PUNCT expositions-1796 164 3 oxford oxford PROPN expositions-1796 164 4 university university PROPN expositions-1796 164 5 press press NOUN expositions-1796 164 6 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 165 1 fitzpatrick fitzpatrick PROPN expositions-1796 165 2 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 165 3 william william PROPN expositions-1796 165 4 . . PROPN expositions-1796 165 5 2014a 2014a NUM expositions-1796 165 6 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 166 1 “ " PUNCT expositions-1796 166 2 debunking debunk VERB expositions-1796 166 3 evolutionary evolutionary ADJ expositions-1796 166 4 debunking debunking NOUN expositions-1796 166 5 of of ADP expositions-1796 166 6 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 166 7 realism realism NOUN expositions-1796 166 8 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 166 9 ” " PUNCT expositions-1796 167 1 philosophical philosophical ADJ expositions-1796 167 2 studies study NOUN expositions-1796 167 3 doi doi VERB expositions-1796 167 4 10.1007 10.1007 NUM expositions-1796 167 5 / / SYM expositions-1796 167 6 s11098–014–0295 s11098–014–0295 NOUN expositions-1796 167 7 - - ADJ expositions-1796 167 8 y. y. NOUN expositions-1796 167 9 _ _ PUNCT expositions-1796 168 1 _ _ PUNCT expositions-1796 169 1 _ _ PUNCT expositions-1796 170 1 _ _ PUNCT expositions-1796 171 1 _ _ PUNCT expositions-1796 171 2 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 172 1 2014b 2014b NUM expositions-1796 172 2 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 173 1 “ " PUNCT expositions-1796 173 2 why why SCONJ expositions-1796 173 3 there there PRON expositions-1796 173 4 is be VERB expositions-1796 173 5 no no DET expositions-1796 173 6 darwinian darwinian ADJ expositions-1796 173 7 dilemma dilemma NOUN expositions-1796 173 8 for for ADP expositions-1796 173 9 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 173 10 realism realism NOUN expositions-1796 173 11 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 173 12 ” " PUNCT expositions-1796 174 1 in in ADP expositions-1796 174 2 challenges challenge NOUN expositions-1796 174 3 to to ADP expositions-1796 174 4 religious religious ADJ expositions-1796 174 5 and and CCONJ expositions-1796 174 6 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 174 7 belief belief NOUN expositions-1796 174 8 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 174 9 edited edit VERB expositions-1796 174 10 by by ADP expositions-1796 174 11 michael michael PROPN expositions-1796 174 12 bergman bergman PROPN expositions-1796 174 13 and and CCONJ expositions-1796 174 14 patrick patrick PROPN expositions-1796 174 15 kain kain PROPN expositions-1796 174 16 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 174 17 237–255 237–255 NUM expositions-1796 174 18 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 175 1 oxford oxford NOUN expositions-1796 175 2 : : PUNCT expositions-1796 175 3 oxford oxford PROPN expositions-1796 175 4 university university PROPN expositions-1796 175 5 press press NOUN expositions-1796 175 6 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 176 1 greene greene PROPN expositions-1796 176 2 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 176 3 joshua joshua PROPN expositions-1796 176 4 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 176 5 2008 2008 NUM expositions-1796 176 6 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 177 1 “ " PUNCT expositions-1796 177 2 the the DET expositions-1796 177 3 secret secret ADJ expositions-1796 177 4 joke joke NOUN expositions-1796 177 5 of of ADP expositions-1796 177 6 kant kant PROPN expositions-1796 177 7 ’s ’s PART expositions-1796 177 8 soul soul NOUN expositions-1796 177 9 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 177 10 ” " PUNCT expositions-1796 178 1 in in ADP expositions-1796 178 2 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 178 3 psychology psychology NOUN expositions-1796 178 4 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 178 5 vol vol NOUN expositions-1796 178 6 . . PROPN expositions-1796 178 7 3 3 NUM expositions-1796 178 8 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 178 9 edited edit VERB expositions-1796 178 10 by by ADP expositions-1796 178 11 walter walter PROPN expositions-1796 178 12 sinnott sinnott PROPN expositions-1796 178 13 - - PUNCT expositions-1796 178 14 armstrong armstrong PROPN expositions-1796 178 15 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 178 16 35–80 35–80 PROPN expositions-1796 178 17 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 179 1 cambridge cambridge PROPN expositions-1796 179 2 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 179 3 ma ma PROPN expositions-1796 179 4 : : PUNCT expositions-1796 179 5 mit mit PROPN expositions-1796 179 6 press press NOUN expositions-1796 179 7 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 180 1 joyce joyce PROPN expositions-1796 180 2 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 180 3 richard richard PROPN expositions-1796 180 4 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 180 5 2001 2001 NUM expositions-1796 180 6 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 181 1 the the DET expositions-1796 181 2 myth myth NOUN expositions-1796 181 3 of of ADP expositions-1796 181 4 morality morality NOUN expositions-1796 181 5 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 182 1 cambridge cambridge PROPN expositions-1796 182 2 : : PUNCT expositions-1796 182 3 cambridge cambridge PROPN expositions-1796 182 4 university university PROPN expositions-1796 182 5 press press NOUN expositions-1796 182 6 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 183 1 dissolving dissolve VERB expositions-1796 183 2 the the DET expositions-1796 183 3 debunker debunker NOUN expositions-1796 183 4 ’s ’s PART expositions-1796 183 5 puzzle puzzle NOUN expositions-1796 183 6 48 48 NUM expositions-1796 183 7 _ _ PUNCT expositions-1796 184 1 _ _ PUNCT expositions-1796 185 1 _ _ PUNCT expositions-1796 186 1 _ _ PUNCT expositions-1796 187 1 _ _ PUNCT expositions-1796 187 2 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 188 1 2006 2006 NUM expositions-1796 188 2 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 189 1 the the DET expositions-1796 189 2 evolution evolution NOUN expositions-1796 189 3 of of ADP expositions-1796 189 4 morality morality NOUN expositions-1796 189 5 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 190 1 cambridge cambridge PROPN expositions-1796 190 2 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 190 3 ma ma PROPN expositions-1796 190 4 : : PUNCT expositions-1796 190 5 mit mit PROPN expositions-1796 190 6 press press NOUN expositions-1796 190 7 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 191 1 kitcher kitcher PROPN expositions-1796 191 2 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 191 3 philip philip PROPN expositions-1796 191 4 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 191 5 2005 2005 NUM expositions-1796 191 6 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 192 1 “ " PUNCT expositions-1796 192 2 biology biology NOUN expositions-1796 192 3 and and CCONJ expositions-1796 192 4 ethics ethic NOUN expositions-1796 192 5 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 192 6 ” " PUNCT expositions-1796 193 1 in in ADP expositions-1796 193 2 the the DET expositions-1796 193 3 oxford oxford PROPN expositions-1796 193 4 handbook handbook NOUN expositions-1796 193 5 of of ADP expositions-1796 193 6 ethical ethical ADJ expositions-1796 193 7 theory theory NOUN expositions-1796 193 8 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 193 9 edited edit VERB expositions-1796 193 10 by by ADP expositions-1796 193 11 david david PROPN expositions-1796 193 12 copp copp PROPN expositions-1796 193 13 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 193 14 163–185 163–185 NUM expositions-1796 193 15 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 194 1 oxford oxford NOUN expositions-1796 194 2 : : PUNCT expositions-1796 194 3 oxford oxford PROPN expositions-1796 194 4 university university NOUN expositions-1796 194 5 press press NOUN expositions-1796 194 6 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 195 1 _ _ PUNCT expositions-1796 196 1 _ _ PUNCT expositions-1796 197 1 _ _ PUNCT expositions-1796 198 1 _ _ PUNCT expositions-1796 199 1 _ _ PUNCT expositions-1796 199 2 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 200 1 2011 2011 NUM expositions-1796 200 2 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 201 1 the the DET expositions-1796 201 2 ethical ethical ADJ expositions-1796 201 3 project project NOUN expositions-1796 201 4 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 202 1 cambridge cambridge PROPN expositions-1796 202 2 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 202 3 ma ma PROPN expositions-1796 202 4 : : PUNCT expositions-1796 202 5 harvard harvard PROPN expositions-1796 202 6 university university PROPN expositions-1796 202 7 press press NOUN expositions-1796 202 8 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 203 1 locke locke PROPN expositions-1796 203 2 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 203 3 dustin dustin PROPN expositions-1796 203 4 . . PROPN expositions-1796 203 5 2014 2014 NUM expositions-1796 203 6 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 204 1 “ " PUNCT expositions-1796 204 2 darwinian darwinian VERB expositions-1796 204 3 normative normative ADJ expositions-1796 204 4 skepticism skepticism NOUN expositions-1796 204 5 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 204 6 ” " PUNCT expositions-1796 205 1 in in ADP expositions-1796 205 2 challenges challenge NOUN expositions-1796 205 3 to to ADP expositions-1796 205 4 religious religious ADJ expositions-1796 205 5 and and CCONJ expositions-1796 205 6 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 205 7 belief belief NOUN expositions-1796 205 8 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 205 9 edited edit VERB expositions-1796 205 10 by by ADP expositions-1796 205 11 michael michael PROPN expositions-1796 205 12 bergman bergman PROPN expositions-1796 205 13 and and CCONJ expositions-1796 205 14 patrick patrick PROPN expositions-1796 205 15 kain kain PROPN expositions-1796 205 16 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 205 17 210–236 210–236 NUM expositions-1796 205 18 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 206 1 oxford oxford NOUN expositions-1796 206 2 : : PUNCT expositions-1796 206 3 oxford oxford PROPN expositions-1796 206 4 university university PROPN expositions-1796 206 5 press press NOUN expositions-1796 206 6 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 207 1 nagel nagel PROPN expositions-1796 207 2 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 207 3 thomas thomas PROPN expositions-1796 207 4 . . PROPN expositions-1796 207 5 2012 2012 NUM expositions-1796 207 6 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 208 1 mind mind NOUN expositions-1796 208 2 and and CCONJ expositions-1796 208 3 cosmos cosmos PROPN expositions-1796 208 4 : : PUNCT expositions-1796 208 5 why why SCONJ expositions-1796 208 6 the the DET expositions-1796 208 7 materialist materialist ADJ expositions-1796 208 8 neo neo ADJ expositions-1796 208 9 - - ADJ expositions-1796 208 10 darwinian darwinian ADJ expositions-1796 208 11 conception conception NOUN expositions-1796 208 12 of of ADP expositions-1796 208 13 nature nature NOUN expositions-1796 208 14 is be AUX expositions-1796 208 15 almost almost ADV expositions-1796 208 16 certainly certainly ADV expositions-1796 208 17 false false ADJ expositions-1796 208 18 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 209 1 oxford oxford NOUN expositions-1796 209 2 : : PUNCT expositions-1796 209 3 oxford oxford PROPN expositions-1796 209 4 university university PROPN expositions-1796 209 5 press press NOUN expositions-1796 209 6 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 210 1 olson olson PROPN expositions-1796 210 2 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 210 3 jonas jonas PROPN expositions-1796 210 4 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 211 1 2014 2014 NUM expositions-1796 211 2 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 212 1 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 212 2 error error NOUN expositions-1796 212 3 theory theory NOUN expositions-1796 212 4 : : PUNCT expositions-1796 212 5 history history NOUN expositions-1796 212 6 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 212 7 critique critique NOUN expositions-1796 212 8 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 212 9 defence defence NOUN expositions-1796 212 10 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 213 1 oxford oxford PROPN expositions-1796 213 2 : : PUNCT expositions-1796 213 3 oxford oxford PROPN expositions-1796 213 4 university university PROPN expositions-1796 213 5 press press NOUN expositions-1796 213 6 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 214 1 parfit parfit NOUN expositions-1796 214 2 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 214 3 derek derek PROPN expositions-1796 214 4 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 215 1 2011 2011 NUM expositions-1796 215 2 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 216 1 on on ADP expositions-1796 216 2 what what PRON expositions-1796 216 3 matters matter NOUN expositions-1796 216 4 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 216 5 vol vol NOUN expositions-1796 216 6 . . PROPN expositions-1796 216 7 2 2 NUM expositions-1796 216 8 . . X expositions-1796 216 9 oxford oxford NOUN expositions-1796 216 10 : : PUNCT expositions-1796 216 11 oxford oxford PROPN expositions-1796 216 12 university university PROPN expositions-1796 216 13 press press NOUN expositions-1796 216 14 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 217 1 plantinga plantinga PROPN expositions-1796 217 2 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 217 3 alvin alvin PROPN expositions-1796 217 4 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 217 5 1993 1993 NUM expositions-1796 217 6 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 218 1 warrant warrant NOUN expositions-1796 218 2 and and CCONJ expositions-1796 218 3 proper proper ADJ expositions-1796 218 4 function function NOUN expositions-1796 218 5 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 219 1 oxford oxford NOUN expositions-1796 219 2 : : PUNCT expositions-1796 219 3 oxford oxford PROPN expositions-1796 219 4 university university NOUN expositions-1796 219 5 press press NOUN expositions-1796 219 6 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 220 1 _ _ PUNCT expositions-1796 221 1 _ _ PUNCT expositions-1796 222 1 _ _ PUNCT expositions-1796 223 1 _ _ PUNCT expositions-1796 224 1 _ _ PUNCT expositions-1796 224 2 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 225 1 2002 2002 NUM expositions-1796 225 2 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 226 1 “ " PUNCT expositions-1796 226 2 the the DET expositions-1796 226 3 evolutionary evolutionary ADJ expositions-1796 226 4 argument argument NOUN expositions-1796 226 5 against against ADP expositions-1796 226 6 naturalism naturalism NOUN expositions-1796 226 7 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 226 8 ” " PUNCT expositions-1796 227 1 in in ADP expositions-1796 227 2 naturalism naturalism NOUN expositions-1796 227 3 defeated defeat VERB expositions-1796 227 4 ? ? PUNCT expositions-1796 228 1 essays essay NOUN expositions-1796 228 2 on on ADP expositions-1796 228 3 plantinga plantinga PROPN expositions-1796 228 4 ’s ’s PART expositions-1796 228 5 evolutionary evolutionary ADJ expositions-1796 228 6 argument argument NOUN expositions-1796 228 7 against against ADP expositions-1796 228 8 naturalism naturalism NOUN expositions-1796 228 9 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 228 10 edited edit VERB expositions-1796 228 11 by by ADP expositions-1796 228 12 james james PROPN expositions-1796 228 13 beilby beilby PROPN expositions-1796 228 14 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 228 15 1–14 1–14 PROPN expositions-1796 228 16 . . PROPN expositions-1796 228 17 ithaca ithaca PROPN expositions-1796 228 18 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 228 19 ny ny PROPN expositions-1796 228 20 : : PUNCT expositions-1796 228 21 cornell cornell PROPN expositions-1796 228 22 university university PROPN expositions-1796 228 23 press press NOUN expositions-1796 228 24 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 229 1 plantinga plantinga PROPN expositions-1796 229 2 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 229 3 alvin alvin PROPN expositions-1796 229 4 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 229 5 and and CCONJ expositions-1796 229 6 michael michael PROPN expositions-1796 229 7 tooley tooley PROPN expositions-1796 229 8 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 230 1 2008 2008 NUM expositions-1796 230 2 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 231 1 knowledge knowledge NOUN expositions-1796 231 2 of of ADP expositions-1796 231 3 god god PROPN expositions-1796 231 4 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 232 1 oxford oxford PROPN expositions-1796 232 2 : : PUNCT expositions-1796 233 1 blackwell blackwell PROPN expositions-1796 233 2 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 234 1 railton railton PROPN expositions-1796 234 2 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 234 3 peter peter PROPN expositions-1796 234 4 . . PROPN expositions-1796 234 5 2010 2010 NUM expositions-1796 234 6 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 235 1 “ " PUNCT expositions-1796 235 2 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 235 3 camouflage camouflage NOUN expositions-1796 235 4 or or CCONJ expositions-1796 235 5 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 235 6 monkeys monkey NOUN expositions-1796 235 7 ? ? PUNCT expositions-1796 235 8 ” " PUNCT expositions-1796 236 1 the the DET expositions-1796 236 2 new new PROPN expositions-1796 236 3 york york PROPN expositions-1796 236 4 times times PROPN expositions-1796 236 5 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 236 6 the the DET expositions-1796 236 7 stone stone NOUN expositions-1796 236 8 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 236 9 july july PROPN expositions-1796 236 10 18 18 NUM expositions-1796 236 11 : : PUNCT expositions-1796 236 12 http://opinionator.blogs.nytimes.com/2010/07/18/moral-camouflage-ormoral-monkeys/?_php=true&_type=blogs&_r=0 http://opinionator.blogs.nytimes.com/2010/07/18/moral-camouflage-ormoral-monkeys/?_php=true&_type=blogs&_r=0 NOUN expositions-1796 236 13 ruse ruse NOUN expositions-1796 236 14 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 236 15 michael michael PROPN expositions-1796 236 16 . . PROPN expositions-1796 236 17 1998 1998 NUM expositions-1796 236 18 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 237 1 taking take VERB expositions-1796 237 2 darwin darwin PROPN expositions-1796 237 3 seriously seriously ADV expositions-1796 237 4 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 238 1 oxford oxford NOUN expositions-1796 238 2 : : PUNCT expositions-1796 239 1 blackwell blackwell PROPN expositions-1796 239 2 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 240 1 scanlon scanlon PROPN expositions-1796 240 2 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 240 3 t.m t.m PROPN expositions-1796 240 4 . . PROPN expositions-1796 240 5 1998 1998 NUM expositions-1796 240 6 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 241 1 what what PRON expositions-1796 241 2 we we PRON expositions-1796 241 3 owe owe VERB expositions-1796 241 4 to to ADP expositions-1796 241 5 each each DET expositions-1796 241 6 other other ADJ expositions-1796 241 7 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 242 1 cambridge cambridge PROPN expositions-1796 242 2 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 242 3 ma ma PROPN expositions-1796 242 4 : : PUNCT expositions-1796 242 5 harvard harvard PROPN expositions-1796 242 6 university university PROPN expositions-1796 242 7 press press NOUN expositions-1796 242 8 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 243 1 shafer shafer NOUN expositions-1796 243 2 - - PUNCT expositions-1796 243 3 landau landau NOUN expositions-1796 243 4 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 243 5 russ russ PROPN expositions-1796 243 6 . . PROPN expositions-1796 243 7 2003 2003 NUM expositions-1796 243 8 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 244 1 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 244 2 realism realism NOUN expositions-1796 244 3 : : PUNCT expositions-1796 244 4 a a DET expositions-1796 244 5 defence defence NOUN expositions-1796 244 6 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 245 1 oxford oxford NOUN expositions-1796 245 2 : : PUNCT expositions-1796 245 3 oxford oxford PROPN expositions-1796 245 4 university university NOUN expositions-1796 245 5 press press NOUN expositions-1796 245 6 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 246 1 _ _ PUNCT expositions-1796 247 1 _ _ PUNCT expositions-1796 248 1 _ _ PUNCT expositions-1796 249 1 _ _ PUNCT expositions-1796 250 1 _ _ PUNCT expositions-1796 251 1 _ _ PUNCT expositions-1796 251 2 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 252 1 2006 2006 NUM expositions-1796 252 2 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 253 1 “ " PUNCT expositions-1796 253 2 ethics ethic NOUN expositions-1796 253 3 as as ADP expositions-1796 253 4 philosophy philosophy NOUN expositions-1796 253 5 : : PUNCT expositions-1796 253 6 a a DET expositions-1796 253 7 defense defense NOUN expositions-1796 253 8 of of ADP expositions-1796 253 9 ethical ethical ADJ expositions-1796 253 10 nonnaturalism nonnaturalism NOUN expositions-1796 253 11 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 253 12 ” " PUNCT expositions-1796 254 1 in in ADP expositions-1796 254 2 metaethics metaethic NOUN expositions-1796 254 3 after after ADP expositions-1796 254 4 moore moore PROPN expositions-1796 254 5 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 254 6 edited edit VERB expositions-1796 254 7 by by ADP expositions-1796 254 8 terry terry PROPN expositions-1796 254 9 horgan horgan PROPN expositions-1796 254 10 and and CCONJ expositions-1796 254 11 mark mark PROPN expositions-1796 254 12 timmons timmon NOUN expositions-1796 254 13 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 254 14 209–233 209–233 NUM expositions-1796 254 15 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 255 1 oxford oxford PROPN expositions-1796 255 2 university university PROPN expositions-1796 255 3 press press NOUN expositions-1796 255 4 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 256 1 _ _ PUNCT expositions-1796 257 1 _ _ PUNCT expositions-1796 258 1 _ _ PUNCT expositions-1796 259 1 _ _ PUNCT expositions-1796 260 1 _ _ PUNCT expositions-1796 260 2 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 261 1 2012 2012 NUM expositions-1796 261 2 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 262 1 “ " PUNCT expositions-1796 262 2 evolutionary evolutionary ADJ expositions-1796 262 3 debunking debunking NOUN expositions-1796 262 4 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 262 5 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 262 6 realism realism NOUN expositions-1796 262 7 and and CCONJ expositions-1796 262 8 moral moral ADJ expositions-1796 262 9 knowledge knowledge NOUN expositions-1796 262 10 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 262 11 ” " PUNCT expositions-1796 262 12 journal journal NOUN expositions-1796 262 13 of of ADP expositions-1796 262 14 ethics ethic NOUN expositions-1796 262 15 and and CCONJ expositions-1796 262 16 social social ADJ expositions-1796 262 17 philosophy philosophy NOUN expositions-1796 262 18 9 9 NUM expositions-1796 262 19 : : PUNCT expositions-1796 262 20 1–38 1–38 PROPN expositions-1796 262 21 . . PROPN expositions-1796 262 22 49 49 NUM expositions-1796 263 1 cuneo cuneo PROPN expositions-1796 263 2 street street PROPN expositions-1796 263 3 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 263 4 sharon sharon PROPN expositions-1796 263 5 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 263 6 2006 2006 NUM expositions-1796 263 7 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 264 1 “ " PUNCT expositions-1796 264 2 a a DET expositions-1796 264 3 darwinian darwinian ADJ expositions-1796 264 4 dilemma dilemma NOUN expositions-1796 264 5 for for ADP expositions-1796 264 6 realist realist ADJ expositions-1796 264 7 theories theory NOUN expositions-1796 264 8 of of ADP expositions-1796 264 9 value value NOUN expositions-1796 264 10 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 264 11 ” " PUNCT expositions-1796 265 1 philosophical philosophical ADJ expositions-1796 265 2 studies study NOUN expositions-1796 265 3 127 127 NUM expositions-1796 265 4 : : PUNCT expositions-1796 265 5 109–166 109–166 NUM expositions-1796 265 6 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 266 1 _ _ PUNCT expositions-1796 267 1 _ _ PUNCT expositions-1796 268 1 _ _ PUNCT expositions-1796 269 1 _ _ PUNCT expositions-1796 270 1 _ _ PUNCT expositions-1796 270 2 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 271 1 2008a 2008a NUM expositions-1796 271 2 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 272 1 “ " PUNCT expositions-1796 272 2 reply reply NOUN expositions-1796 272 3 to to PART expositions-1796 272 4 copp copp VERB expositions-1796 272 5 : : PUNCT expositions-1796 272 6 naturalism naturalism NOUN expositions-1796 272 7 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 272 8 normativity normativity NOUN expositions-1796 272 9 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 272 10 and and CCONJ expositions-1796 272 11 the the DET expositions-1796 272 12 varieties variety NOUN expositions-1796 272 13 of of ADP expositions-1796 272 14 realism realism NOUN expositions-1796 272 15 worth worth ADJ expositions-1796 272 16 worrying worry VERB expositions-1796 272 17 about about ADP expositions-1796 272 18 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 272 19 ” " PUNCT expositions-1796 273 1 philosophical philosophical ADJ expositions-1796 273 2 issues issue NOUN expositions-1796 273 3 18 18 NUM expositions-1796 273 4 : : PUNCT expositions-1796 273 5 207–28 207–28 X expositions-1796 273 6 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 274 1 _ _ PUNCT expositions-1796 275 1 _ _ PUNCT expositions-1796 276 1 _ _ PUNCT expositions-1796 277 1 _ _ PUNCT expositions-1796 278 1 _ _ PUNCT expositions-1796 278 2 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 279 1 2008b 2008b NUM expositions-1796 279 2 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 280 1 “ " PUNCT expositions-1796 280 2 constructivism constructivism NOUN expositions-1796 280 3 about about ADP expositions-1796 280 4 reasons reason NOUN expositions-1796 280 5 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 280 6 ” " PUNCT expositions-1796 281 1 in in ADP expositions-1796 281 2 oxford oxford PROPN expositions-1796 281 3 studies study NOUN expositions-1796 281 4 in in ADP expositions-1796 281 5 metaethics metaethic NOUN expositions-1796 281 6 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 281 7 vol vol NOUN expositions-1796 281 8 . . PROPN expositions-1796 281 9 3 3 NUM expositions-1796 281 10 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 281 11 edited edit VERB expositions-1796 281 12 by by ADP expositions-1796 281 13 russ russ PROPN expositions-1796 281 14 shafer shafer PROPN expositions-1796 281 15 - - PUNCT expositions-1796 281 16 landau landau NOUN expositions-1796 281 17 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 281 18 207–245 207–245 NUM expositions-1796 281 19 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 282 1 oxford oxford NOUN expositions-1796 282 2 : : PUNCT expositions-1796 282 3 oxford oxford PROPN expositions-1796 282 4 university university NOUN expositions-1796 282 5 press press NOUN expositions-1796 282 6 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 283 1 _ _ PUNCT expositions-1796 284 1 _ _ PUNCT expositions-1796 285 1 _ _ PUNCT expositions-1796 286 1 _ _ PUNCT expositions-1796 287 1 _ _ PUNCT expositions-1796 287 2 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 288 1 forthcoming forthcoming ADJ expositions-1796 288 2 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 289 1 “ " PUNCT expositions-1796 289 2 objectivity objectivity NOUN expositions-1796 289 3 and and CCONJ expositions-1796 289 4 truth truth NOUN expositions-1796 289 5 : : PUNCT expositions-1796 289 6 you you PRON expositions-1796 289 7 ’d ’d NOUN expositions-1796 289 8 better well ADV expositions-1796 289 9 believe believe VERB expositions-1796 289 10 it it PRON expositions-1796 289 11 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 289 12 ” " PUNCT expositions-1796 290 1 wedgwood wedgwood PROPN expositions-1796 290 2 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 290 3 ralph ralph PROPN expositions-1796 290 4 . . PROPN expositions-1796 290 5 2007 2007 NUM expositions-1796 290 6 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 291 1 the the DET expositions-1796 291 2 nature nature NOUN expositions-1796 291 3 of of ADP expositions-1796 291 4 normativity normativity NOUN expositions-1796 291 5 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 292 1 oxford oxford NOUN expositions-1796 292 2 : : PUNCT expositions-1796 292 3 oxford oxford PROPN expositions-1796 292 4 university university PROPN expositions-1796 292 5 press press NOUN expositions-1796 292 6 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 293 1 wielenberg wielenberg PROPN expositions-1796 293 2 , , PUNCT expositions-1796 293 3 erik erik PROPN expositions-1796 293 4 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 294 1 2010 2010 NUM expositions-1796 294 2 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 295 1 “ " PUNCT expositions-1796 295 2 on on ADP expositions-1796 295 3 the the DET expositions-1796 295 4 evolutionary evolutionary ADJ expositions-1796 295 5 debunking debunking NOUN expositions-1796 295 6 of of ADP expositions-1796 295 7 morality morality NOUN expositions-1796 295 8 . . PUNCT expositions-1796 295 9 ” " PUNCT expositions-1796 295 10 ethics ethic NOUN expositions-1796 295 11 120 120 NUM expositions-1796 295 12 : : PUNCT expositions-1796 295 13 441–64 441–64 PROPN expositions-1796 295 14 . . PUNCT