id sid tid token lemma pos expositions-1959 1 1 microsoft microsoft PROPN expositions-1959 1 2 word word PROPN expositions-1959 1 3 bassham bassham PROPN expositions-1959 1 4 review review PROPN expositions-1959 1 5 of of ADP expositions-1959 1 6 metz.docx metz.docx NOUN expositions-1959 1 7 [ [ X expositions-1959 1 8 expositions exposition NOUN expositions-1959 1 9 9.1 9.1 NUM expositions-1959 1 10 ( ( PUNCT expositions-1959 1 11 2015 2015 NUM expositions-1959 1 12 ) ) PUNCT expositions-1959 1 13 142–148 142–148 NUM expositions-1959 1 14 ] ] PUNCT expositions-1959 1 15 expositions exposition NOUN expositions-1959 1 16 ( ( PUNCT expositions-1959 1 17 online online ADV expositions-1959 1 18 ) ) PUNCT expositions-1959 1 19 issn issn PROPN expositions-1959 1 20 : : PUNCT expositions-1959 1 21 1747–5376 1747–5376 NOUN expositions-1959 1 22     SPACE expositions-1959 1 23 metz metz PROPN expositions-1959 1 24 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 1 25 thaddeus thaddeus NOUN expositions-1959 1 26 . . PUNCT expositions-1959 2 1 meaning mean VERB expositions-1959 2 2 in in ADP expositions-1959 2 3 life life NOUN expositions-1959 2 4 : : PUNCT expositions-1959 2 5 an an DET expositions-1959 2 6 analytic analytic ADJ expositions-1959 2 7 study study NOUN expositions-1959 2 8 . . PUNCT expositions-1959 3 1 oxford oxford NOUN expositions-1959 3 2 : : PUNCT expositions-1959 3 3 oxford oxford PROPN expositions-1959 3 4 university university PROPN expositions-1959 3 5 press press NOUN expositions-1959 3 6 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 3 7 2014 2014 NUM expositions-1959 3 8 . . PUNCT expositions-1959 4 1 288pp 288pp ADJ expositions-1959 4 2 . . PUNCT expositions-1959 5 1 $ $ SYM expositions-1959 5 2 45.00 45.00 NUM expositions-1959 5 3 ( ( PUNCT expositions-1959 5 4 cloth cloth NOUN expositions-1959 5 5 ) ) PUNCT expositions-1959 5 6 . . PUNCT expositions-1959 6 1 isbn isbn ADJ expositions-1959 6 2 : : PUNCT expositions-1959 6 3 978–0–199–59931–8 978–0–199–59931–8 NUM expositions-1959 6 4 questions question NOUN expositions-1959 6 5 about about ADP expositions-1959 6 6 the the DET expositions-1959 6 7 meaning meaning NOUN expositions-1959 6 8 of of ADP expositions-1959 6 9 life life NOUN expositions-1959 6 10 are be AUX expositions-1959 6 11 among among ADP expositions-1959 6 12 the the DET expositions-1959 6 13 deepest deep ADJ expositions-1959 6 14 and and CCONJ expositions-1959 6 15 most most ADV expositions-1959 6 16 important important ADJ expositions-1959 6 17 questions question NOUN expositions-1959 6 18 humans human NOUN expositions-1959 6 19 can can AUX expositions-1959 6 20 ask ask VERB expositions-1959 6 21 . . PUNCT expositions-1959 7 1 such such ADJ expositions-1959 7 2 questions question NOUN expositions-1959 7 3 include include VERB expositions-1959 7 4 : : PUNCT expositions-1959 7 5   PRON expositions-1959 7 6 does do AUX expositions-1959 7 7 the the DET expositions-1959 7 8 universe universe NOUN expositions-1959 7 9 have have VERB expositions-1959 7 10 any any DET expositions-1959 7 11 meaning meaning NOUN expositions-1959 7 12 or or CCONJ expositions-1959 7 13 purpose purpose NOUN expositions-1959 7 14 ? ? PUNCT expositions-1959 8 1 ( ( PUNCT expositions-1959 8 2 the the DET expositions-1959 8 3 question question NOUN expositions-1959 8 4 of of ADP expositions-1959 8 5 cosmic cosmic ADJ expositions-1959 8 6 meaning meaning NOUN expositions-1959 8 7 . . PUNCT expositions-1959 8 8 ) ) PUNCT expositions-1959 9 1   PRON expositions-1959 9 2 does do AUX expositions-1959 9 3 my my PRON expositions-1959 9 4 life life NOUN expositions-1959 9 5 have have VERB expositions-1959 9 6 any any DET expositions-1959 9 7 meaning meaning NOUN expositions-1959 9 8 or or CCONJ expositions-1959 9 9 purpose purpose NOUN expositions-1959 9 10 ? ? PUNCT expositions-1959 10 1 ( ( PUNCT expositions-1959 10 2 the the DET expositions-1959 10 3 question question NOUN expositions-1959 10 4 of of ADP expositions-1959 10 5 individual individual ADJ expositions-1959 10 6 meaning meaning NOUN expositions-1959 10 7 . . PUNCT expositions-1959 10 8 ) ) PUNCT expositions-1959 11 1   PUNCT expositions-1959 11 2 if if SCONJ expositions-1959 11 3 my my PRON expositions-1959 11 4 life life NOUN expositions-1959 11 5 does do AUX expositions-1959 11 6 have have VERB expositions-1959 11 7 some some DET expositions-1959 11 8 meaning meaning NOUN expositions-1959 11 9 or or CCONJ expositions-1959 11 10 purpose purpose NOUN expositions-1959 11 11 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 11 12 is be AUX expositions-1959 11 13 that that SCONJ expositions-1959 11 14 entirely entirely ADV expositions-1959 11 15 up up ADP expositions-1959 11 16 to to ADP expositions-1959 11 17 me i PRON expositions-1959 11 18 ? ? PUNCT expositions-1959 12 1 partially partially ADV expositions-1959 12 2 up up ADP expositions-1959 12 3 to to ADP expositions-1959 12 4 me i PRON expositions-1959 12 5 ? ? PUNCT expositions-1959 12 6 or or CCONJ expositions-1959 12 7 not not PART expositions-1959 12 8 up up ADP expositions-1959 12 9 to to ADP expositions-1959 12 10 me i PRON expositions-1959 12 11 at at ADV expositions-1959 12 12 all all ADV expositions-1959 12 13 ? ? PUNCT expositions-1959 13 1   PRON expositions-1959 13 2 could could AUX expositions-1959 13 3 it it PRON expositions-1959 13 4 be be AUX expositions-1959 13 5 — — PUNCT expositions-1959 13 6 as as SCONJ expositions-1959 13 7 existential existential ADJ expositions-1959 13 8 nihilists nihilist NOUN expositions-1959 13 9 claim claim VERB expositions-1959 13 10 — — PUNCT expositions-1959 13 11 that that PRON expositions-1959 13 12 life life NOUN expositions-1959 13 13 has have VERB expositions-1959 13 14 no no DET expositions-1959 13 15 meaning meaning NOUN expositions-1959 13 16 whatsoever whatsoever ADV expositions-1959 13 17 ? ? PUNCT expositions-1959 14 1 if if SCONJ expositions-1959 14 2 so so ADV expositions-1959 14 3 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 14 4 how how SCONJ expositions-1959 14 5 should should AUX expositions-1959 14 6 we we PRON expositions-1959 14 7 respond respond VERB expositions-1959 14 8 to to ADP expositions-1959 14 9 that that DET expositions-1959 14 10 complete complete ADJ expositions-1959 14 11 lack lack NOUN expositions-1959 14 12 of of ADP expositions-1959 14 13 meaning meaning NOUN expositions-1959 14 14 ? ? PUNCT expositions-1959 15 1   NOUN expositions-1959 16 1 if if SCONJ expositions-1959 16 2 life life NOUN expositions-1959 16 3 can can AUX expositions-1959 16 4 have have VERB expositions-1959 16 5 meaning meaning NOUN expositions-1959 16 6 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 16 7 what what DET expositions-1959 16 8 forms form NOUN expositions-1959 16 9 do do VERB expositions-1959 16 10 such such ADJ expositions-1959 16 11 meanings meaning NOUN expositions-1959 16 12 take take VERB expositions-1959 16 13 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 16 14 which which DET expositions-1959 16 15 modes mode NOUN expositions-1959 16 16 of of ADP expositions-1959 16 17 meaningfulness meaningfulness NOUN expositions-1959 16 18 are be AUX expositions-1959 16 19 most most ADV expositions-1959 16 20 important important ADJ expositions-1959 16 21 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 16 22 and and CCONJ expositions-1959 16 23 how how SCONJ expositions-1959 16 24 can can AUX expositions-1959 16 25 i i PRON expositions-1959 16 26 make make VERB expositions-1959 16 27 my my PRON expositions-1959 16 28 own own ADJ expositions-1959 16 29 life life NOUN expositions-1959 16 30 as as ADV expositions-1959 16 31 meaningful meaningful ADJ expositions-1959 16 32 as as ADP expositions-1959 16 33 possible possible ADJ expositions-1959 16 34 ? ? PUNCT expositions-1959 17 1 these these PRON expositions-1959 17 2 are be AUX expositions-1959 17 3 deep deep ADJ expositions-1959 17 4 questions question NOUN expositions-1959 17 5 because because SCONJ expositions-1959 17 6 they they PRON expositions-1959 17 7 force force VERB expositions-1959 17 8 us we PRON expositions-1959 17 9 to to PART expositions-1959 17 10 think think VERB expositions-1959 17 11 about about ADP expositions-1959 17 12 ultimate ultimate ADJ expositions-1959 17 13 issues issue NOUN expositions-1959 17 14 about about ADP expositions-1959 17 15 the the DET expositions-1959 17 16 nature nature NOUN expositions-1959 17 17 of of ADP expositions-1959 17 18 reality reality NOUN expositions-1959 17 19 and and CCONJ expositions-1959 17 20 what what PRON expositions-1959 17 21 our our PRON expositions-1959 17 22 highest high ADJ expositions-1959 17 23 priorities priority NOUN expositions-1959 17 24 in in ADP expositions-1959 17 25 life life NOUN expositions-1959 17 26 should should AUX expositions-1959 17 27 be be AUX expositions-1959 17 28 . . PUNCT expositions-1959 18 1 they they PRON expositions-1959 18 2 are be AUX expositions-1959 18 3 also also ADV expositions-1959 18 4 important important ADJ expositions-1959 18 5 questions question NOUN expositions-1959 18 6 because because SCONJ expositions-1959 18 7 the the DET expositions-1959 18 8 quest quest NOUN expositions-1959 18 9 for for ADP expositions-1959 18 10 meaning meaning NOUN expositions-1959 18 11 is be AUX expositions-1959 18 12 one one NUM expositions-1959 18 13 of of ADP expositions-1959 18 14 the the DET expositions-1959 18 15 most most ADV expositions-1959 18 16 fundamental fundamental ADJ expositions-1959 18 17 and and CCONJ expositions-1959 18 18 persistent persistent ADJ expositions-1959 18 19 drives drive NOUN expositions-1959 18 20 in in ADP expositions-1959 18 21 human human ADJ expositions-1959 18 22 nature nature NOUN expositions-1959 18 23 . . PUNCT expositions-1959 19 1 how how SCONJ expositions-1959 19 2 we we PRON expositions-1959 19 3 answer answer VERB expositions-1959 19 4 such such ADJ expositions-1959 19 5 questions question NOUN expositions-1959 19 6 may may AUX expositions-1959 19 7 determine determine VERB expositions-1959 19 8 whether whether SCONJ expositions-1959 19 9 we we PRON expositions-1959 19 10 live live VERB expositions-1959 19 11 lives life NOUN expositions-1959 19 12 of of ADP expositions-1959 19 13 happiness happiness NOUN expositions-1959 19 14 and and CCONJ expositions-1959 19 15 purpose purpose NOUN expositions-1959 19 16 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 19 17 or or CCONJ expositions-1959 19 18 instead instead ADV expositions-1959 19 19 struggle struggle VERB expositions-1959 19 20 with with ADP expositions-1959 19 21 feelings feeling NOUN expositions-1959 19 22 of of ADP expositions-1959 19 23 apathy apathy NOUN expositions-1959 19 24 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 19 25 anomie anomie NOUN expositions-1959 19 26 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 19 27 and and CCONJ expositions-1959 19 28 despair despair NOUN expositions-1959 19 29 . . PUNCT expositions-1959 20 1 over over ADP expositions-1959 20 2 the the DET expositions-1959 20 3 past past ADJ expositions-1959 20 4 three three NUM expositions-1959 20 5 decades decade NOUN expositions-1959 20 6 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 20 7 an an DET expositions-1959 20 8 extensive extensive ADJ expositions-1959 20 9 body body NOUN expositions-1959 20 10 of of ADP expositions-1959 20 11 high high ADJ expositions-1959 20 12 - - PUNCT expositions-1959 20 13 quality quality NOUN expositions-1959 20 14 literature literature NOUN expositions-1959 20 15 has have AUX expositions-1959 20 16 developed develop VERB expositions-1959 20 17 in in ADP expositions-1959 20 18 anglo anglo ADJ expositions-1959 20 19 - - PUNCT expositions-1959 20 20 american american ADJ expositions-1959 20 21 philosophy philosophy NOUN expositions-1959 20 22 on on ADP expositions-1959 20 23 the the DET expositions-1959 20 24 cluster cluster NOUN expositions-1959 20 25 of of ADP expositions-1959 20 26 related related ADJ expositions-1959 20 27 issues issue NOUN expositions-1959 20 28 collectively collectively ADV expositions-1959 20 29 known know VERB expositions-1959 20 30 as as ADP expositions-1959 20 31 “ " PUNCT expositions-1959 20 32 the the DET expositions-1959 20 33 meaning meaning NOUN expositions-1959 20 34 of of ADP expositions-1959 20 35 life life NOUN expositions-1959 20 36 . . PUNCT expositions-1959 20 37 ” " PUNCT expositions-1959 21 1 one one NUM expositions-1959 21 2 of of ADP expositions-1959 21 3 the the DET expositions-1959 21 4 most most ADV expositions-1959 21 5 significant significant ADJ expositions-1959 21 6 participants participant NOUN expositions-1959 21 7 in in ADP expositions-1959 21 8 that that DET expositions-1959 21 9 discussion discussion NOUN expositions-1959 21 10 has have AUX expositions-1959 21 11 been be AUX expositions-1959 21 12 the the DET expositions-1959 21 13 south south ADJ expositions-1959 21 14 african african ADJ expositions-1959 21 15 philosopher philosopher NOUN expositions-1959 21 16 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 21 17 thaddeus thaddeus NOUN expositions-1959 21 18 metz metz PROPN expositions-1959 21 19 . . PUNCT expositions-1959 22 1 metz metz PROPN expositions-1959 22 2 ’s ’s PART expositions-1959 22 3 meaning meaning NOUN expositions-1959 22 4 in in ADP expositions-1959 22 5 life life NOUN expositions-1959 22 6 is be AUX expositions-1959 22 7 an an DET expositions-1959 22 8 important important ADJ expositions-1959 22 9 contribution contribution NOUN expositions-1959 22 10 to to ADP expositions-1959 22 11 the the DET expositions-1959 22 12 growing grow VERB expositions-1959 22 13 academic academic ADJ expositions-1959 22 14 literature literature NOUN expositions-1959 22 15 on on ADP expositions-1959 22 16 the the DET expositions-1959 22 17 meaning meaning NOUN expositions-1959 22 18 of of ADP expositions-1959 22 19 life life NOUN expositions-1959 22 20 . . PUNCT expositions-1959 23 1 over over ADP expositions-1959 23 2 the the DET expositions-1959 23 3 past past ADJ expositions-1959 23 4 fifteen fifteen NUM expositions-1959 23 5 years year NOUN expositions-1959 23 6 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 23 7 metz metz PROPN expositions-1959 23 8 has have AUX expositions-1959 23 9 published publish VERB expositions-1959 23 10 prolifically prolifically ADV expositions-1959 23 11 in in ADP expositions-1959 23 12 the the DET expositions-1959 23 13 field field NOUN expositions-1959 23 14 and and CCONJ expositions-1959 23 15 is be AUX expositions-1959 23 16 the the DET expositions-1959 23 17 author author NOUN expositions-1959 23 18 of of ADP expositions-1959 23 19 a a DET expositions-1959 23 20 superb superb ADJ expositions-1959 23 21 stanford stanford PROPN expositions-1959 23 22 encyclopedia encyclopedia NOUN expositions-1959 23 23 of of ADP expositions-1959 23 24 philosophy philosophy NOUN expositions-1959 23 25 article article NOUN expositions-1959 23 26 on on ADP expositions-1959 23 27 the the DET expositions-1959 23 28 topic topic NOUN expositions-1959 23 29 . . PUNCT expositions-1959 24 1 meaning meaning NOUN expositions-1959 24 2 in in ADP expositions-1959 24 3 life life NOUN expositions-1959 24 4 is be AUX expositions-1959 24 5 mostly mostly ADV expositions-1959 24 6 cobbled cobble VERB expositions-1959 24 7 together together ADV expositions-1959 24 8 from from ADP expositions-1959 24 9 previously previously ADV expositions-1959 24 10 published publish VERB expositions-1959 24 11 articles article NOUN expositions-1959 24 12 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 24 13 and and CCONJ expositions-1959 24 14 shows show VERB expositions-1959 24 15 it it PRON expositions-1959 24 16 in in ADP expositions-1959 24 17 places place NOUN expositions-1959 24 18 with with ADP expositions-1959 24 19 certain certain ADJ expositions-1959 24 20 oddities oddity NOUN expositions-1959 24 21 of of ADP expositions-1959 24 22 emphasis emphasis NOUN expositions-1959 24 23 and and CCONJ expositions-1959 24 24 focus focus VERB expositions-1959 24 25 . . PUNCT expositions-1959 25 1 whatever whatever DET expositions-1959 25 2 one one PRON expositions-1959 25 3 thinks think VERB expositions-1959 25 4 about about ADP expositions-1959 25 5 the the DET expositions-1959 25 6 particular particular ADJ expositions-1959 25 7 conclusions conclusion NOUN expositions-1959 25 8 metz metz PROPN expositions-1959 25 9 defends defend VERB expositions-1959 25 10 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 25 11 the the DET expositions-1959 25 12 book book NOUN expositions-1959 25 13 unquestionably unquestionably ADV expositions-1959 25 14 provides provide VERB expositions-1959 25 15 a a DET expositions-1959 25 16 helpful helpful ADJ expositions-1959 25 17 framework framework NOUN expositions-1959 25 18 and and CCONJ expositions-1959 25 19 vocabulary vocabulary NOUN expositions-1959 25 20 for for ADP expositions-1959 25 21 thinking think VERB expositions-1959 25 22 about about ADP expositions-1959 25 23 the the DET expositions-1959 25 24 relevant relevant ADJ expositions-1959 25 25 issues issue NOUN expositions-1959 25 26 . . PUNCT expositions-1959 26 1 143 143 NUM expositions-1959 26 2 bassham bassham PROPN expositions-1959 26 3             SPACE expositions-1959 26 4 like like ADP expositions-1959 26 5 most most ADJ expositions-1959 26 6 contemporary contemporary ADJ expositions-1959 26 7 philosophers philosopher NOUN expositions-1959 26 8 who who PRON expositions-1959 26 9 write write VERB expositions-1959 26 10 on on ADP expositions-1959 26 11 the the DET expositions-1959 26 12 meaning meaning NOUN expositions-1959 26 13 of of ADP expositions-1959 26 14 life life NOUN expositions-1959 26 15 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 26 16 metz metz PROPN expositions-1959 26 17 focuses focus VERB expositions-1959 26 18 almost almost ADV expositions-1959 26 19 entirely entirely ADV expositions-1959 26 20 on on ADP expositions-1959 26 21 questions question NOUN expositions-1959 26 22 of of ADP expositions-1959 26 23 individual individual ADJ expositions-1959 26 24 meaning meaning NOUN expositions-1959 26 25 . . PUNCT expositions-1959 27 1 issues issue NOUN expositions-1959 27 2 of of ADP expositions-1959 27 3 “ " PUNCT expositions-1959 27 4 cosmic cosmic ADJ expositions-1959 27 5 ” " PUNCT expositions-1959 27 6 or or CCONJ expositions-1959 27 7 “ " PUNCT expositions-1959 27 8 holistic holistic ADJ expositions-1959 27 9 ” " PUNCT expositions-1959 27 10 meaning meaning NOUN expositions-1959 27 11 are be AUX expositions-1959 27 12 addressed address VERB expositions-1959 27 13 only only ADV expositions-1959 27 14 to to ADP expositions-1959 27 15 the the DET expositions-1959 27 16 extent extent NOUN expositions-1959 27 17 that that SCONJ expositions-1959 27 18 they they PRON expositions-1959 27 19 directly directly ADV expositions-1959 27 20 impinge impinge VERB expositions-1959 27 21 on on ADP expositions-1959 27 22 questions question NOUN expositions-1959 27 23 of of ADP expositions-1959 27 24 individual individual ADJ expositions-1959 27 25 meaning meaning NOUN expositions-1959 27 26 . . PUNCT expositions-1959 28 1 metz metz PROPN expositions-1959 28 2 ’s ’s PART expositions-1959 28 3 book book NOUN expositions-1959 28 4 has have VERB expositions-1959 28 5 three three NUM expositions-1959 28 6 main main ADJ expositions-1959 28 7 parts part NOUN expositions-1959 28 8 . . PUNCT expositions-1959 29 1 the the DET expositions-1959 29 2 first first ADJ expositions-1959 29 3 part part NOUN expositions-1959 29 4 seeks seek VERB expositions-1959 29 5 to to PART expositions-1959 29 6 clarify clarify VERB expositions-1959 29 7 what what PRON expositions-1959 29 8 we we PRON expositions-1959 29 9 mean mean VERB expositions-1959 29 10 when when SCONJ expositions-1959 29 11 we we PRON expositions-1959 29 12 ask ask VERB expositions-1959 29 13 about about ADP expositions-1959 29 14 the the DET expositions-1959 29 15 “ " PUNCT expositions-1959 29 16 meaning meaning NOUN expositions-1959 29 17 ” " PUNCT expositions-1959 29 18 of of ADP expositions-1959 29 19 an an DET expositions-1959 29 20 individual individual ADJ expositions-1959 29 21 human human ADJ expositions-1959 29 22 life life NOUN expositions-1959 29 23 . . PUNCT expositions-1959 30 1 in in ADP expositions-1959 30 2 part part PROPN expositions-1959 30 3 ii ii PROPN expositions-1959 30 4 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 30 5 he he PRON expositions-1959 30 6 considers consider VERB expositions-1959 30 7 a a DET expositions-1959 30 8 number number NOUN expositions-1959 30 9 of of ADP expositions-1959 30 10 supernaturalist supernaturalist NOUN expositions-1959 30 11 theories theory NOUN expositions-1959 30 12 of of ADP expositions-1959 30 13 meaning meaning NOUN expositions-1959 30 14 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 30 15 and and CCONJ expositions-1959 30 16 in in ADP expositions-1959 30 17 part part NOUN expositions-1959 30 18 iii iii NOUN expositions-1959 30 19 he he PRON expositions-1959 30 20 discusses discuss VERB expositions-1959 30 21 two two NUM expositions-1959 30 22 prominent prominent ADJ expositions-1959 30 23 naturalistic naturalistic ADJ expositions-1959 30 24 accounts account NOUN expositions-1959 30 25 of of ADP expositions-1959 30 26 meaning meaning NOUN expositions-1959 30 27 : : PUNCT expositions-1959 30 28 what what PRON expositions-1959 30 29 he he PRON expositions-1959 30 30 calls call VERB expositions-1959 30 31 subjective subjective ADJ expositions-1959 30 32 naturalism naturalism NOUN expositions-1959 30 33 and and CCONJ expositions-1959 30 34 objective objective ADJ expositions-1959 30 35 naturalism naturalism NOUN expositions-1959 30 36 . . PUNCT expositions-1959 31 1 he he PRON expositions-1959 31 2 concludes conclude VERB expositions-1959 31 3 with with ADP expositions-1959 31 4 a a DET expositions-1959 31 5 critique critique NOUN expositions-1959 31 6 of of ADP expositions-1959 31 7 existential existential ADJ expositions-1959 31 8 nihilism nihilism NOUN expositions-1959 31 9 . . PUNCT expositions-1959 32 1 metz metz PROPN expositions-1959 32 2 begins begin VERB expositions-1959 32 3 by by ADP expositions-1959 32 4 unpacking unpack VERB expositions-1959 32 5 the the DET expositions-1959 32 6 general general ADJ expositions-1959 32 7 concept concept NOUN expositions-1959 32 8 of of ADP expositions-1959 32 9 meaning meaning NOUN expositions-1959 32 10 and and CCONJ expositions-1959 32 11 setting set VERB expositions-1959 32 12 forth forth ADP expositions-1959 32 13 what what PRON expositions-1959 32 14 he he PRON expositions-1959 32 15 believes believe VERB expositions-1959 32 16 a a DET expositions-1959 32 17 theory theory NOUN expositions-1959 32 18 of of ADP expositions-1959 32 19 meaning meaning NOUN expositions-1959 32 20 must must AUX expositions-1959 32 21 include include VERB expositions-1959 32 22 . . PUNCT expositions-1959 33 1 in in ADP expositions-1959 33 2 his his PRON expositions-1959 33 3 view view NOUN expositions-1959 33 4 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 33 5 meaning mean VERB expositions-1959 33 6 is be AUX expositions-1959 33 7 something something PRON expositions-1959 33 8 that that PRON expositions-1959 33 9 comes come VERB expositions-1959 33 10 in in ADP expositions-1959 33 11 degrees degree NOUN expositions-1959 33 12 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 33 13 varies vary VERB expositions-1959 33 14 from from ADP expositions-1959 33 15 person person NOUN expositions-1959 33 16 to to ADP expositions-1959 33 17 person person NOUN expositions-1959 33 18 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 33 19 can can AUX expositions-1959 33 20 be be AUX expositions-1959 33 21 manifested manifest VERB expositions-1959 33 22 in in ADP expositions-1959 33 23 both both CCONJ expositions-1959 33 24 the the DET expositions-1959 33 25 parts part NOUN expositions-1959 33 26 and and CCONJ expositions-1959 33 27 in in ADP expositions-1959 33 28 the the DET expositions-1959 33 29 whole whole NOUN expositions-1959 33 30 of of ADP expositions-1959 33 31 an an DET expositions-1959 33 32 individual individual NOUN expositions-1959 33 33 ’s ’s PART expositions-1959 33 34 life life NOUN expositions-1959 33 35 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 33 36 is be AUX expositions-1959 33 37 intrinsically intrinsically ADV expositions-1959 33 38 desirable desirable ADJ expositions-1959 33 39 as as ADP expositions-1959 33 40 an an DET expositions-1959 33 41 end end NOUN expositions-1959 33 42 in in ADP expositions-1959 33 43 itself itself PRON expositions-1959 33 44 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 33 45 is be AUX expositions-1959 33 46 roughly roughly ADV expositions-1959 33 47 synonymous synonymous ADJ expositions-1959 33 48 with with ADP expositions-1959 33 49 terms term NOUN expositions-1959 33 50 such such ADJ expositions-1959 33 51 as as ADP expositions-1959 33 52 “ " PUNCT expositions-1959 33 53 significance significance NOUN expositions-1959 33 54 ” " PUNCT expositions-1959 33 55 or or CCONJ expositions-1959 33 56 “ " PUNCT expositions-1959 33 57 importance importance NOUN expositions-1959 33 58 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 33 59 ” " PUNCT expositions-1959 33 60 and and CCONJ expositions-1959 33 61 is be AUX expositions-1959 33 62 exemplified exemplify VERB expositions-1959 33 63 most most ADV expositions-1959 33 64 saliently saliently ADV expositions-1959 33 65 by by ADP expositions-1959 33 66 certain certain ADJ expositions-1959 33 67 kinds kind NOUN expositions-1959 33 68 of of ADP expositions-1959 33 69 intellectual intellectual ADJ expositions-1959 33 70 excellence excellence PROPN expositions-1959 33 71 ( ( PUNCT expositions-1959 33 72 think think VERB expositions-1959 33 73 : : PUNCT expositions-1959 33 74 albert albert PROPN expositions-1959 33 75 einstein einstein PROPN expositions-1959 33 76 ) ) PUNCT expositions-1959 33 77 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 33 78 moral moral ADJ expositions-1959 33 79 achievement achievement NOUN expositions-1959 33 80 ( ( PUNCT expositions-1959 33 81 think think NOUN expositions-1959 33 82 : : PUNCT expositions-1959 33 83 mother mother NOUN expositions-1959 33 84 teresa teresa PROPN expositions-1959 33 85 ) ) PUNCT expositions-1959 33 86 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 33 87 and and CCONJ expositions-1959 33 88 artistic artistic ADJ expositions-1959 33 89 creation creation NOUN expositions-1959 33 90 ( ( PUNCT expositions-1959 33 91 think think VERB expositions-1959 33 92 : : PUNCT expositions-1959 33 93 pablo pablo PROPN expositions-1959 33 94 picasso picasso PROPN expositions-1959 33 95 ) ) PUNCT expositions-1959 33 96 . . PUNCT expositions-1959 34 1 meaning mean VERB expositions-1959 34 2 should should AUX expositions-1959 34 3 not not PART expositions-1959 34 4 be be AUX expositions-1959 34 5 confused confuse VERB expositions-1959 34 6 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 34 7 he he PRON expositions-1959 34 8 argues argue VERB expositions-1959 34 9 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 34 10 with with ADP expositions-1959 34 11 absurdity absurdity NOUN expositions-1959 34 12 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 34 13 which which PRON expositions-1959 34 14 consists consist VERB expositions-1959 34 15 in in ADP expositions-1959 34 16 a a DET expositions-1959 34 17 kind kind NOUN expositions-1959 34 18 of of ADP expositions-1959 34 19 conspicuous conspicuous ADJ expositions-1959 34 20 or or CCONJ expositions-1959 34 21 ludicrous ludicrous ADJ expositions-1959 34 22 incongruity incongruity NOUN expositions-1959 34 23 . . PUNCT expositions-1959 35 1 nor nor CCONJ expositions-1959 35 2 should should AUX expositions-1959 35 3 meaning meaning AUX expositions-1959 35 4 be be AUX expositions-1959 35 5 confused confuse VERB expositions-1959 35 6 with with ADP expositions-1959 35 7 futility futility NOUN expositions-1959 35 8 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 35 9 which which PRON expositions-1959 35 10 is be AUX expositions-1959 35 11 roughly roughly ADV expositions-1959 35 12 the the DET expositions-1959 35 13 idea idea NOUN expositions-1959 35 14 of of ADP expositions-1959 35 15 persistent persistent ADJ expositions-1959 35 16 failure failure NOUN expositions-1959 35 17 to to PART expositions-1959 35 18 achieve achieve VERB expositions-1959 35 19 one one NUM expositions-1959 35 20 ’s ’s PART expositions-1959 35 21 ends end NOUN expositions-1959 35 22 ( ( PUNCT expositions-1959 35 23 6 6 NUM expositions-1959 35 24 ) ) PUNCT expositions-1959 35 25 . . PUNCT expositions-1959 36 1 more more ADV expositions-1959 36 2 debatably debatably ADV expositions-1959 36 3 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 36 4 metz metz PROPN expositions-1959 36 5 argues argue VERB expositions-1959 36 6 that that SCONJ expositions-1959 36 7 a a DET expositions-1959 36 8 meaningful meaningful ADJ expositions-1959 36 9 life life NOUN expositions-1959 36 10 should should AUX expositions-1959 36 11 not not PART expositions-1959 36 12 be be AUX expositions-1959 36 13 identified identify VERB expositions-1959 36 14 with with ADP expositions-1959 36 15 a a DET expositions-1959 36 16 happy happy ADJ expositions-1959 36 17 life life NOUN expositions-1959 36 18 . . PUNCT expositions-1959 37 1 metz metz PROPN expositions-1959 37 2 rightly rightly ADV expositions-1959 37 3 notes note VERB expositions-1959 37 4 that that SCONJ expositions-1959 37 5 that that SCONJ expositions-1959 37 6 there there PRON expositions-1959 37 7 is be VERB expositions-1959 37 8 nothing nothing PRON expositions-1959 37 9 contradictory contradictory ADJ expositions-1959 37 10 in in ADP expositions-1959 37 11 speaking speak VERB expositions-1959 37 12 of of ADP expositions-1959 37 13 a a DET expositions-1959 37 14 “ " PUNCT expositions-1959 37 15 happy happy ADJ expositions-1959 37 16 but but CCONJ expositions-1959 37 17 meaningless meaningless ADJ expositions-1959 37 18 life life NOUN expositions-1959 37 19 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 37 20 ” " PUNCT expositions-1959 37 21 or or CCONJ expositions-1959 37 22 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 37 23 conversely conversely ADV expositions-1959 37 24 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 37 25 of of ADP expositions-1959 37 26 a a DET expositions-1959 37 27 “ " PUNCT expositions-1959 37 28 meaningful meaningful ADJ expositions-1959 37 29 but but CCONJ expositions-1959 37 30 unhappy unhappy ADJ expositions-1959 37 31 life life NOUN expositions-1959 37 32 . . PUNCT expositions-1959 37 33 ” " PUNCT expositions-1959 38 1 as as ADP expositions-1959 38 2 examples example NOUN expositions-1959 38 3 of of ADP expositions-1959 38 4 meaningless meaningless ADJ expositions-1959 38 5 but but CCONJ expositions-1959 38 6 happy happy ADJ expositions-1959 38 7 lives life NOUN expositions-1959 38 8 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 38 9 he he PRON expositions-1959 38 10 cites cite VERB expositions-1959 38 11 ( ( PUNCT expositions-1959 38 12 a a PRON expositions-1959 38 13 ) ) PUNCT expositions-1959 38 14 nozick nozick NOUN expositions-1959 38 15 ’s ’s PART expositions-1959 38 16 example example NOUN expositions-1959 38 17 of of ADP expositions-1959 38 18 an an DET expositions-1959 38 19 intensely intensely ADV expositions-1959 38 20 pleasure pleasure NOUN expositions-1959 38 21 - - PUNCT expositions-1959 38 22 filled fill VERB expositions-1959 38 23 life life NOUN expositions-1959 38 24 lived live VERB expositions-1959 38 25 inside inside ADP expositions-1959 38 26 an an DET expositions-1959 38 27 experience experience NOUN expositions-1959 38 28 machine1 machine1 PROPN expositions-1959 38 29 and and CCONJ expositions-1959 38 30 ( ( PUNCT expositions-1959 38 31 b b PROPN expositions-1959 38 32 ) ) PUNCT expositions-1959 38 33 richard richard PROPN expositions-1959 38 34 taylor taylor PROPN expositions-1959 38 35 ’s ’s PART expositions-1959 38 36 example example NOUN expositions-1959 38 37 of of ADP expositions-1959 38 38 a a DET expositions-1959 38 39 drug drug NOUN expositions-1959 38 40 - - PUNCT expositions-1959 38 41 fueled fuel VERB expositions-1959 38 42 sisyphus sisyphu NOUN expositions-1959 38 43 joyously joyously ADV expositions-1959 38 44 ( ( PUNCT expositions-1959 38 45 but but CCONJ expositions-1959 38 46 futilely futilely ADV expositions-1959 38 47 ) ) PUNCT expositions-1959 38 48 rolling roll VERB expositions-1959 38 49 a a DET expositions-1959 38 50 rock rock NOUN expositions-1959 38 51 up up ADP expositions-1959 38 52 a a DET expositions-1959 38 53 hill hill NOUN expositions-1959 38 54 for for ADP expositions-1959 38 55 all all DET expositions-1959 38 56 eternity.2 eternity.2 NOUN expositions-1959 38 57 plausibly plausibly ADV expositions-1959 38 58 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 38 59 he he PRON expositions-1959 38 60 takes take VERB expositions-1959 38 61 such such ADJ expositions-1959 38 62 examples example NOUN expositions-1959 38 63 to to PART expositions-1959 38 64 show show VERB expositions-1959 38 65 that that SCONJ expositions-1959 38 66 meaning meaning NOUN expositions-1959 38 67 does do AUX expositions-1959 38 68 not not PART expositions-1959 38 69 consist consist VERB expositions-1959 38 70 simply simply ADV expositions-1959 38 71 in in ADP expositions-1959 38 72 pleasure pleasure NOUN expositions-1959 38 73 or or CCONJ expositions-1959 38 74 happiness happiness NOUN expositions-1959 38 75 . . PUNCT expositions-1959 39 1 but but CCONJ expositions-1959 39 2 metz metz PROPN expositions-1959 39 3 also also ADV expositions-1959 39 4 argues argue VERB expositions-1959 39 5 for for ADP expositions-1959 39 6 a a DET expositions-1959 39 7 stronger strong ADJ expositions-1959 39 8 conclusion conclusion NOUN expositions-1959 39 9 — — PUNCT expositions-1959 39 10 that that DET expositions-1959 39 11 pleasure pleasure NOUN expositions-1959 39 12 or or CCONJ expositions-1959 39 13 happiness happiness NOUN expositions-1959 39 14 as as ADP expositions-1959 39 15 such such ADJ expositions-1959 39 16 can can AUX expositions-1959 39 17 not not PART expositions-1959 39 18 even even ADV expositions-1959 39 19 contribute contribute VERB expositions-1959 39 20 to to ADP expositions-1959 39 21 a a DET expositions-1959 39 22 meaningful meaningful ADJ expositions-1959 39 23 life life NOUN expositions-1959 39 24 ( ( PUNCT expositions-1959 39 25 27 27 NUM expositions-1959 39 26 ) ) PUNCT expositions-1959 39 27 . . PUNCT expositions-1959 40 1 as as SCONJ expositions-1959 40 2 he he PRON expositions-1959 40 3 sees see VERB expositions-1959 40 4 it it PRON expositions-1959 40 5 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 40 6 a a DET expositions-1959 40 7 life life NOUN expositions-1959 40 8 of of ADP expositions-1959 40 9 sisyphean sisyphean ADJ expositions-1959 40 10 rock rock NOUN expositions-1959 40 11 - - PUNCT expositions-1959 40 12 rolling rolling NOUN expositions-1959 40 13 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 40 14 however however ADV expositions-1959 40 15 pleasurable pleasurable ADJ expositions-1959 40 16 or or CCONJ expositions-1959 40 17 joyous joyous ADJ expositions-1959 40 18 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 40 19 is be AUX expositions-1959 40 20 a a DET expositions-1959 40 21 paradigm paradigm NOUN expositions-1959 40 22 of of ADP expositions-1959 40 23 absolute absolute ADJ expositions-1959 40 24 meaninglessness meaninglessness NOUN expositions-1959 40 25 . . PUNCT expositions-1959 41 1 it it PRON expositions-1959 41 2 follows follow VERB expositions-1959 41 3 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 41 4 therefore therefore ADV expositions-1959 41 5 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 41 6 that that DET expositions-1959 41 7 pleasure pleasure NOUN expositions-1959 41 8 or or CCONJ expositions-1959 41 9 happiness happiness NOUN expositions-1959 41 10 per per X expositions-1959 41 11 se se X expositions-1959 41 12 can can AUX expositions-1959 41 13 contribute contribute VERB expositions-1959 41 14 nothing nothing PRON expositions-1959 41 15 to to ADP expositions-1959 41 16 a a DET expositions-1959 41 17 meaningful meaningful ADJ expositions-1959 41 18 life life NOUN expositions-1959 41 19 . . PUNCT expositions-1959 42 1 this this DET expositions-1959 42 2 claim claim NOUN expositions-1959 42 3 is be AUX expositions-1959 42 4 implausible implausible ADJ expositions-1959 42 5 . . PUNCT expositions-1959 43 1 as as SCONJ expositions-1959 43 2 richard richard PROPN expositions-1959 43 3 taylor taylor PROPN expositions-1959 43 4 famously famously ADV expositions-1959 43 5 argues argue VERB expositions-1959 43 6 ( ( PUNCT expositions-1959 43 7 but but CCONJ expositions-1959 43 8 later later ADV expositions-1959 43 9 retracted retract VERB expositions-1959 43 10 ( ( PUNCT expositions-1959 43 11 metz metz PROPN expositions-1959 43 12 174 174 NUM expositions-1959 43 13 – – PUNCT expositions-1959 43 14 75 75 NUM expositions-1959 43 15 ) ) PUNCT expositions-1959 43 16 ) ) PUNCT expositions-1959 43 17 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 43 18 a a DET expositions-1959 43 19 joyous joyous ADJ expositions-1959 43 20 sisyphean sisyphean ADJ expositions-1959 43 21 life life NOUN expositions-1959 43 22 of of ADP expositions-1959 43 23 endlessly endlessly ADV expositions-1959 43 24 pointless pointless ADJ expositions-1959 43 25 rock rock NOUN expositions-1959 43 26 - - PUNCT expositions-1959 43 27 rolling rolling NOUN expositions-1959 43 28 would would AUX expositions-1959 43 29 not not PART expositions-1959 43 30 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 43 31 in in ADP expositions-1959 43 32 fact fact NOUN expositions-1959 43 33 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 43 34 be be AUX expositions-1959 43 35 a a DET expositions-1959 43 36 paradigm paradigm NOUN expositions-1959 43 37 of of ADP expositions-1959 43 38 complete complete ADJ expositions-1959 43 39 meaninglessness meaninglessness NOUN expositions-1959 43 40 . . PUNCT expositions-1959 44 1 rather rather ADV expositions-1959 44 2 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 44 3 it it PRON expositions-1959 44 4 would would AUX expositions-1959 44 5 possess possess VERB expositions-1959 44 6 a a DET expositions-1959 44 7 kind kind NOUN expositions-1959 44 8 of of ADP expositions-1959 44 9 “ " PUNCT expositions-1959 44 10 subjective subjective ADJ expositions-1959 44 11 meaning meaning NOUN expositions-1959 44 12 ” " PUNCT expositions-1959 44 13 in in ADP expositions-1959 44 14 virtue virtue NOUN expositions-1959 44 15 of of ADP expositions-1959 44 16 the the DET expositions-1959 44 17 fact fact NOUN expositions-1959 44 18 that that SCONJ expositions-1959 44 19 sisyphus sisyphus PROPN expositions-1959 44 20 finds find VERB expositions-1959 44 21 it it PRON expositions-1959 44 22 to to PART expositions-1959 44 23 be be AUX expositions-1959 44 24 deeply deeply ADV expositions-1959 44 25 meaningful meaningful ADJ expositions-1959 44 26 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 44 27 enjoyable enjoyable ADJ expositions-1959 44 28 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 44 29 and and CCONJ expositions-1959 44 30 fulfilling fulfil VERB expositions-1959 44 31 . . PUNCT expositions-1959 45 1 moreover moreover ADV expositions-1959 45 2 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 45 3 such such DET expositions-1959 45 4 a a DET expositions-1959 45 5 life life NOUN expositions-1959 45 6 may may AUX expositions-1959 45 7 also also ADV expositions-1959 45 8 possess possess VERB expositions-1959 45 9 a a DET expositions-1959 45 10 kind kind NOUN expositions-1959 45 11 of of ADP expositions-1959 45 12 objective objective ADJ expositions-1959 45 13 meaning mean VERB expositions-1959 45 14 inasmuch inasmuch ADJ expositions-1959 45 15 as as SCONJ expositions-1959 45 16 it it PRON expositions-1959 45 17 involves involve VERB expositions-1959 45 18 at at ADV expositions-1959 45 19 least least ADV expositions-1959 45 20 two two NUM expositions-1959 45 21 objective objective ADJ expositions-1959 45 22 and and CCONJ expositions-1959 45 23 intrinsic intrinsic ADJ expositions-1959 45 24 goods good NOUN expositions-1959 45 25 ( ( PUNCT expositions-1959 45 26 happiness happiness NOUN expositions-1959 45 27 and and CCONJ expositions-1959 45 28 pleasure pleasure NOUN expositions-1959 45 29 ) ) PUNCT expositions-1959 45 30 . . PUNCT expositions-1959 46 1 if if SCONJ expositions-1959 46 2 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 46 3 as as SCONJ expositions-1959 46 4 many many ADJ expositions-1959 46 5 theorists theorist NOUN expositions-1959 46 6 claim claim VERB expositions-1959 46 7 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 46 8 whatever whatever PRON expositions-1959 46 9 has have AUX expositions-1959 46 10 intrinsic intrinsic ADJ expositions-1959 46 11 value value NOUN expositions-1959 46 12 has have VERB expositions-1959 46 13 at at ADP expositions-1959 46 14 least least ADJ expositions-1959 46 15 some some PRON expositions-1959 46 16 degree degree NOUN expositions-1959 46 17 of of ADP expositions-1959 46 18 meaningfulness meaningfulness NOUN expositions-1959 46 19 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 46 20 then then ADV expositions-1959 46 21 ( ( PUNCT expositions-1959 46 22 pace pace NOUN expositions-1959 46 23 metz metz NOUN expositions-1959 46 24 ) ) PUNCT expositions-1959 46 25 sisyphus sisyphus PROPN expositions-1959 46 26 ’s ’s PART expositions-1959 46 27 life life NOUN expositions-1959 46 28 does do AUX expositions-1959 46 29 have have VERB expositions-1959 46 30 at at ADP expositions-1959 46 31 least least ADJ expositions-1959 46 32 some some DET expositions-1959 46 33 meaning meaning NOUN expositions-1959 46 34 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 46 35 however however ADV expositions-1959 46 36 minimal minimal ADJ expositions-1959 46 37 . . PUNCT expositions-1959 47 1 review review NOUN expositions-1959 47 2 of of ADP expositions-1959 47 3 meaning meaning NOUN expositions-1959 47 4 in in ADP expositions-1959 47 5 life life NOUN expositions-1959 47 6 144 144 NUM expositions-1959 47 7     SPACE expositions-1959 47 8 as as SCONJ expositions-1959 47 9 metz metz PROPN expositions-1959 47 10 acknowledges acknowledge VERB expositions-1959 47 11 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 47 12 his his PRON expositions-1959 47 13 view view NOUN expositions-1959 47 14 of of ADP expositions-1959 47 15 the the DET expositions-1959 47 16 connection connection NOUN expositions-1959 47 17 between between ADP expositions-1959 47 18 meaning meaning NOUN expositions-1959 47 19 and and CCONJ expositions-1959 47 20 happiness happiness NOUN expositions-1959 47 21 seems seem VERB expositions-1959 47 22 to to PART expositions-1959 47 23 commit commit VERB expositions-1959 47 24 him he PRON expositions-1959 47 25 to to ADP expositions-1959 47 26 the the DET expositions-1959 47 27 highly highly ADV expositions-1959 47 28 implausible implausible ADJ expositions-1959 47 29 claim claim NOUN expositions-1959 47 30 that that SCONJ expositions-1959 47 31 taylor taylor PROPN expositions-1959 47 32 ’s ’s PART expositions-1959 47 33 classic classic ADJ expositions-1959 47 34 discussion discussion NOUN expositions-1959 47 35 of of ADP expositions-1959 47 36 the the DET expositions-1959 47 37 meaning meaning NOUN expositions-1959 47 38 of of ADP expositions-1959 47 39 life life NOUN expositions-1959 47 40 is be AUX expositions-1959 47 41 n’t not PART expositions-1959 47 42 about about ADP expositions-1959 47 43 “ " PUNCT expositions-1959 47 44 meaning mean VERB expositions-1959 47 45 ” " PUNCT expositions-1959 47 46 at at ADV expositions-1959 47 47 all all ADV expositions-1959 47 48 . . PUNCT expositions-1959 48 1 those those DET expositions-1959 48 2 theorists theorist NOUN expositions-1959 48 3 who who PRON expositions-1959 48 4 speak speak VERB expositions-1959 48 5 of of ADP expositions-1959 48 6 empty empty ADJ expositions-1959 48 7 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 48 8 objectively objectively ADV expositions-1959 48 9 insignificant insignificant ADJ expositions-1959 48 10 pleasures pleasure NOUN expositions-1959 48 11 as as ADP expositions-1959 48 12 contributing contribute VERB expositions-1959 48 13 to to ADP expositions-1959 48 14 meaningfulness meaningfulness NOUN expositions-1959 48 15 are be AUX expositions-1959 48 16 “ " PUNCT expositions-1959 48 17 conceptually conceptually ADV expositions-1959 48 18 confused confused ADJ expositions-1959 48 19 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 48 20 ” " PUNCT expositions-1959 48 21 metz metz PROPN expositions-1959 48 22 argues argue VERB expositions-1959 48 23 ( ( PUNCT expositions-1959 48 24 30 30 NUM expositions-1959 48 25 ) ) PUNCT expositions-1959 48 26 . . PUNCT expositions-1959 49 1 in in ADP expositions-1959 49 2 his his PRON expositions-1959 49 3 view view NOUN expositions-1959 49 4 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 49 5 nothing nothing PRON expositions-1959 49 6 that that PRON expositions-1959 49 7 belongs belong VERB expositions-1959 49 8 merely merely ADV expositions-1959 49 9 to to ADP expositions-1959 49 10 our our PRON expositions-1959 49 11 “ " PUNCT expositions-1959 49 12 animal animal NOUN expositions-1959 49 13 self self NOUN expositions-1959 49 14 ” " PUNCT expositions-1959 49 15 can can AUX expositions-1959 49 16 confer confer VERB expositions-1959 49 17 any any DET expositions-1959 49 18 meaning meaning NOUN expositions-1959 49 19 whatsoever whatsoever ADV expositions-1959 49 20 ( ( PUNCT expositions-1959 49 21 29 29 NUM expositions-1959 49 22 – – SYM expositions-1959 49 23 30 30 NUM expositions-1959 49 24 ) ) PUNCT expositions-1959 49 25 . . PUNCT expositions-1959 50 1 what what PRON expositions-1959 50 2 has have AUX expositions-1959 50 3 gone go VERB expositions-1959 50 4 wrong wrong ADJ expositions-1959 50 5 here here ADV expositions-1959 50 6 ? ? PUNCT expositions-1959 51 1 the the DET expositions-1959 51 2 fatal fatal ADJ expositions-1959 51 3 mistake mistake NOUN expositions-1959 51 4 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 51 5 i i PRON expositions-1959 51 6 suggest suggest VERB expositions-1959 51 7 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 51 8 is be AUX expositions-1959 51 9 metz metz PROPN expositions-1959 51 10 ’s ’s PART expositions-1959 51 11 virtual virtual ADJ expositions-1959 51 12 identification identification NOUN expositions-1959 51 13 of of ADP expositions-1959 51 14 “ " PUNCT expositions-1959 51 15 meaning meaning NOUN expositions-1959 51 16 ” " PUNCT expositions-1959 51 17 with with ADP expositions-1959 51 18 the the DET expositions-1959 51 19 notions notion NOUN expositions-1959 51 20 of of ADP expositions-1959 51 21 “ " PUNCT expositions-1959 51 22 significance significance NOUN expositions-1959 51 23 ” " PUNCT expositions-1959 51 24 or or CCONJ expositions-1959 51 25 “ " PUNCT expositions-1959 51 26 importance importance NOUN expositions-1959 51 27 ” " PUNCT expositions-1959 51 28 ( ( PUNCT expositions-1959 51 29 see see VERB expositions-1959 51 30 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 51 31 e.g. e.g. ADV expositions-1959 51 32 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 51 33 79 79 NUM expositions-1959 51 34 ) ) PUNCT expositions-1959 51 35 . . PUNCT expositions-1959 52 1 as as SCONJ expositions-1959 52 2 tom tom PROPN expositions-1959 52 3 morris morris PROPN expositions-1959 52 4 argues argue VERB expositions-1959 52 5 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 52 6 meaning mean VERB expositions-1959 52 7 has have VERB expositions-1959 52 8 to to PART expositions-1959 52 9 do do VERB expositions-1959 52 10 not not PART expositions-1959 52 11 only only ADV expositions-1959 52 12 with with ADP expositions-1959 52 13 significance significance NOUN expositions-1959 52 14 or or CCONJ expositions-1959 52 15 importance importance NOUN expositions-1959 52 16 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 52 17 but but CCONJ expositions-1959 52 18 also also ADV expositions-1959 52 19 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 52 20 crucially crucially ADV expositions-1959 52 21 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 52 22 with with ADP expositions-1959 52 23 the the DET expositions-1959 52 24 notions notion NOUN expositions-1959 52 25 of of ADP expositions-1959 52 26 purpose purpose NOUN expositions-1959 52 27 and and CCONJ expositions-1959 52 28 value.3 value.3 PROPN expositions-1959 52 29 metz metz PROPN expositions-1959 52 30 focuses focus VERB expositions-1959 52 31 unduly unduly ADV expositions-1959 52 32 on on ADP expositions-1959 52 33 one one NUM expositions-1959 52 34 element element NOUN expositions-1959 52 35 of of ADP expositions-1959 52 36 this this DET expositions-1959 52 37 triad triad NOUN expositions-1959 52 38 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 52 39 forcing force VERB expositions-1959 52 40 him he PRON expositions-1959 52 41 to to PART expositions-1959 52 42 draw draw VERB expositions-1959 52 43 counterintuitive counterintuitive ADJ expositions-1959 52 44 conclusions conclusion NOUN expositions-1959 52 45 at at ADP expositions-1959 52 46 many many ADJ expositions-1959 52 47 points point NOUN expositions-1959 52 48 in in ADP expositions-1959 52 49 his his PRON expositions-1959 52 50 analysis analysis NOUN expositions-1959 52 51 . . PUNCT expositions-1959 53 1 having having AUX expositions-1959 53 2 clarified clarify VERB expositions-1959 53 3 what what PRON expositions-1959 53 4 he he PRON expositions-1959 53 5 takes take VERB expositions-1959 53 6 to to PART expositions-1959 53 7 be be AUX expositions-1959 53 8 the the DET expositions-1959 53 9 generic generic ADJ expositions-1959 53 10 concept concept NOUN expositions-1959 53 11 of of ADP expositions-1959 53 12 individual individual ADJ expositions-1959 53 13 ( ( PUNCT expositions-1959 53 14 human human NOUN expositions-1959 53 15 ) ) PUNCT expositions-1959 53 16 life life NOUN expositions-1959 53 17 - - PUNCT expositions-1959 53 18 meaning meaning NOUN expositions-1959 53 19 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 53 20 metz metz PROPN expositions-1959 53 21 turns turn VERB expositions-1959 53 22 next next ADV expositions-1959 53 23 to to PART expositions-1959 53 24 consider consider VERB expositions-1959 53 25 the the DET expositions-1959 53 26 leading lead VERB expositions-1959 53 27 theories theory NOUN expositions-1959 53 28 of of ADP expositions-1959 53 29 meaningfulness meaningfulness NOUN expositions-1959 53 30 in in ADP expositions-1959 53 31 the the DET expositions-1959 53 32 academic academic ADJ expositions-1959 53 33 literature literature NOUN expositions-1959 53 34 . . PUNCT expositions-1959 54 1 his his PRON expositions-1959 54 2 principal principal ADJ expositions-1959 54 3 focus focus NOUN expositions-1959 54 4 is be AUX expositions-1959 54 5 on on ADP expositions-1959 54 6 the the DET expositions-1959 54 7 conditions condition NOUN expositions-1959 54 8 that that PRON expositions-1959 54 9 contribute contribute VERB expositions-1959 54 10 to to ADP expositions-1959 54 11 what what PRON expositions-1959 54 12 we we PRON expositions-1959 54 13 might might AUX expositions-1959 54 14 term term VERB expositions-1959 54 15 a a DET expositions-1959 54 16 highly highly ADV expositions-1959 54 17 or or CCONJ expositions-1959 54 18 richly richly ADV expositions-1959 54 19 meaningful meaningful ADJ expositions-1959 54 20 life life NOUN expositions-1959 54 21 . . PUNCT expositions-1959 55 1 he he PRON expositions-1959 55 2 says say VERB expositions-1959 55 3 relatively relatively ADV expositions-1959 55 4 little little ADJ expositions-1959 55 5 — — PUNCT expositions-1959 55 6 directly directly ADV expositions-1959 55 7 at at ADP expositions-1959 55 8 least least ADJ expositions-1959 55 9 — — PUNCT expositions-1959 55 10 about about ADP expositions-1959 55 11 such such ADJ expositions-1959 55 12 important important ADJ expositions-1959 55 13 issues issue NOUN expositions-1959 55 14 as as ADP expositions-1959 55 15 : : PUNCT expositions-1959 55 16 a a X expositions-1959 55 17 ) ) PUNCT expositions-1959 55 18 are be AUX expositions-1959 55 19 there there PRON expositions-1959 55 20 any any DET expositions-1959 55 21 human human ADJ expositions-1959 55 22 beings being NOUN expositions-1959 55 23 that that PRON expositions-1959 55 24 lead lead VERB expositions-1959 55 25 ( ( PUNCT expositions-1959 55 26 or or CCONJ expositions-1959 55 27 could could AUX expositions-1959 55 28 lead lead VERB expositions-1959 55 29 ) ) PUNCT expositions-1959 55 30 completely completely ADV expositions-1959 55 31 meaningless meaningless ADJ expositions-1959 55 32 lives life NOUN expositions-1959 55 33 ? ? PUNCT expositions-1959 56 1 if if SCONJ expositions-1959 56 2 so so ADV expositions-1959 56 3 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 56 4 why why SCONJ expositions-1959 56 5 ? ? PUNCT expositions-1959 57 1 what what PRON expositions-1959 57 2 are be AUX expositions-1959 57 3 the the DET expositions-1959 57 4 necessary necessary ADJ expositions-1959 57 5 and and CCONJ expositions-1959 57 6 sufficient sufficient ADJ expositions-1959 57 7 conditions condition NOUN expositions-1959 57 8 for for ADP expositions-1959 57 9 a a DET expositions-1959 57 10 life life NOUN expositions-1959 57 11 to to PART expositions-1959 57 12 have have VERB expositions-1959 57 13 any any DET expositions-1959 57 14 meaning meaning NOUN expositions-1959 57 15 at at ADV expositions-1959 57 16 all all ADV expositions-1959 57 17 ? ? PUNCT expositions-1959 58 1 b b X expositions-1959 58 2 ) ) PUNCT expositions-1959 58 3 given give VERB expositions-1959 58 4 that that SCONJ expositions-1959 58 5 some some DET expositions-1959 58 6 activities activity NOUN expositions-1959 58 7 ( ( PUNCT expositions-1959 58 8 e.g. e.g. ADV expositions-1959 58 9 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 58 10 twiddling twiddle VERB expositions-1959 58 11 your your PRON expositions-1959 58 12 thumbs thumb NOUN expositions-1959 58 13 ) ) PUNCT expositions-1959 58 14 can can AUX expositions-1959 58 15 be be AUX expositions-1959 58 16 meaning mean VERB expositions-1959 58 17 - - PUNCT expositions-1959 58 18 neutral neutral ADJ expositions-1959 58 19 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 58 20 and and CCONJ expositions-1959 58 21 other other ADJ expositions-1959 58 22 activities activity NOUN expositions-1959 58 23 ( ( PUNCT expositions-1959 58 24 cf cf NOUN expositions-1959 58 25 . . NOUN expositions-1959 58 26 64 64 NUM expositions-1959 58 27 ) ) PUNCT expositions-1959 58 28 can can AUX expositions-1959 58 29 be be AUX expositions-1959 58 30 meaning meaning NOUN expositions-1959 58 31 - - PUNCT expositions-1959 58 32 subtractors subtractor NOUN expositions-1959 58 33 ( ( PUNCT expositions-1959 58 34 e.g. e.g. ADV expositions-1959 58 35 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 58 36 blowing blow VERB expositions-1959 58 37 up up ADP expositions-1959 58 38 the the DET expositions-1959 58 39 sphinx sphinx NOUN expositions-1959 58 40 just just ADV expositions-1959 58 41 for for ADP expositions-1959 58 42 the the DET expositions-1959 58 43 fun fun NOUN expositions-1959 58 44 of of ADP expositions-1959 58 45 it it PRON expositions-1959 58 46 ) ) PUNCT expositions-1959 58 47 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 58 48 what what PRON expositions-1959 58 49 are be AUX expositions-1959 58 50 the the DET expositions-1959 58 51 necessary necessary ADJ expositions-1959 58 52 and and CCONJ expositions-1959 58 53 sufficient sufficient ADJ expositions-1959 58 54 conditions condition NOUN expositions-1959 58 55 for for ADP expositions-1959 58 56 a a DET expositions-1959 58 57 human human ADJ expositions-1959 58 58 life life NOUN expositions-1959 58 59 to to AUX expositions-1959 58 60 “ " PUNCT expositions-1959 58 61 meaningful meaningful ADJ expositions-1959 58 62 ” " PUNCT expositions-1959 58 63 on on ADP expositions-1959 58 64 balance balance NOUN expositions-1959 58 65 ? ? PUNCT expositions-1959 59 1 metz metz PROPN expositions-1959 59 2 focuses focus VERB expositions-1959 59 3 on on ADP expositions-1959 59 4 three three NUM expositions-1959 59 5 main main ADJ expositions-1959 59 6 ( ( PUNCT expositions-1959 59 7 families family NOUN expositions-1959 59 8 of of ADP expositions-1959 59 9 ) ) PUNCT expositions-1959 59 10 theories theory NOUN expositions-1959 59 11 of of ADP expositions-1959 59 12 what what PRON expositions-1959 59 13 gives give VERB expositions-1959 59 14 meaning meaning NOUN expositions-1959 59 15 to to ADP expositions-1959 59 16 individual individual ADJ expositions-1959 59 17 human human ADJ expositions-1959 59 18 lives life NOUN expositions-1959 59 19 : : PUNCT expositions-1959 59 20 supernaturalism supernaturalism NOUN expositions-1959 59 21 ( ( PUNCT expositions-1959 59 22 roughly roughly ADV expositions-1959 59 23 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 59 24 the the DET expositions-1959 59 25 view view NOUN expositions-1959 59 26 that that SCONJ expositions-1959 59 27 god god PROPN expositions-1959 59 28 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 59 29 or or CCONJ expositions-1959 59 30 something something PRON expositions-1959 59 31 spiritual spiritual ADJ expositions-1959 59 32 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 59 33 gives give VERB expositions-1959 59 34 meaning meaning NOUN expositions-1959 59 35 to to ADP expositions-1959 59 36 life life NOUN expositions-1959 59 37 ) ) PUNCT expositions-1959 59 38 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 59 39 subjective subjective ADJ expositions-1959 59 40 naturalism naturalism NOUN expositions-1959 59 41 ( ( PUNCT expositions-1959 59 42 roughly roughly ADV expositions-1959 59 43 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 59 44 the the DET expositions-1959 59 45 idea idea NOUN expositions-1959 59 46 that that SCONJ expositions-1959 59 47 individuals individual NOUN expositions-1959 59 48 give give VERB expositions-1959 59 49 their their PRON expositions-1959 59 50 own own ADJ expositions-1959 59 51 lives life NOUN expositions-1959 59 52 meaning mean VERB expositions-1959 59 53 through through ADP expositions-1959 59 54 their their PRON expositions-1959 59 55 own own ADJ expositions-1959 59 56 freely freely ADV expositions-1959 59 57 - - PUNCT expositions-1959 59 58 chosen choose VERB expositions-1959 59 59 values value NOUN expositions-1959 59 60 and and CCONJ expositions-1959 59 61 commitments commitment NOUN expositions-1959 59 62 ) ) PUNCT expositions-1959 59 63 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 59 64 and and CCONJ expositions-1959 59 65 objective objective ADJ expositions-1959 59 66 naturalism naturalism NOUN expositions-1959 59 67 ( ( PUNCT expositions-1959 59 68 the the DET expositions-1959 59 69 view view NOUN expositions-1959 59 70 that that PRON expositions-1959 59 71 lives live VERB expositions-1959 59 72 have have VERB expositions-1959 59 73 meaning meaning NOUN expositions-1959 59 74 to to ADP expositions-1959 59 75 the the DET expositions-1959 59 76 extent extent NOUN expositions-1959 59 77 that that PRON expositions-1959 59 78 they they PRON expositions-1959 59 79 connect connect VERB expositions-1959 59 80 with with ADP expositions-1959 59 81 important important ADJ expositions-1959 59 82 objective objective ADJ expositions-1959 59 83 values value NOUN expositions-1959 59 84 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 59 85 such such ADJ expositions-1959 59 86 as as ADP expositions-1959 59 87 truth truth NOUN expositions-1959 59 88 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 59 89 goodness goodness NOUN expositions-1959 59 90 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 59 91 beauty beauty NOUN expositions-1959 59 92 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 59 93 etc etc X expositions-1959 59 94 . . X expositions-1959 59 95 ) ) PUNCT expositions-1959 59 96 . . PUNCT expositions-1959 60 1 ( ( PUNCT expositions-1959 60 2 confusingly confusingly ADV expositions-1959 60 3 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 60 4 metz metz PROPN expositions-1959 60 5 classifies classify VERB expositions-1959 60 6 any any DET expositions-1959 60 7 naturalistic naturalistic ADJ expositions-1959 60 8 theory theory NOUN expositions-1959 60 9 that that PRON expositions-1959 60 10 allows allow VERB expositions-1959 60 11 for for ADP expositions-1959 60 12 both both CCONJ expositions-1959 60 13 subjective subjective ADJ expositions-1959 60 14 and and CCONJ expositions-1959 60 15 objective objective ADJ expositions-1959 60 16 modes mode NOUN expositions-1959 60 17 of of ADP expositions-1959 60 18 meaningfulness meaningfulness NOUN expositions-1959 60 19 as as ADP expositions-1959 60 20 an an DET expositions-1959 60 21 “ " PUNCT expositions-1959 60 22 objective objective ADJ expositions-1959 60 23 ” " PUNCT expositions-1959 60 24 theory theory NOUN expositions-1959 60 25 . . PUNCT expositions-1959 61 1 it it PRON expositions-1959 61 2 would would AUX expositions-1959 61 3 be be AUX expositions-1959 61 4 preferable preferable ADJ expositions-1959 61 5 to to PART expositions-1959 61 6 call call VERB expositions-1959 61 7 these these DET expositions-1959 61 8 “ " PUNCT expositions-1959 61 9 mixed mixed ADJ expositions-1959 61 10 ” " PUNCT expositions-1959 61 11 theories theory NOUN expositions-1959 61 12 . . PUNCT expositions-1959 61 13 ) ) PUNCT expositions-1959 62 1 metz metz PROPN expositions-1959 62 2 ultimately ultimately ADV expositions-1959 62 3 defends defend VERB expositions-1959 62 4 a a DET expositions-1959 62 5 version version NOUN expositions-1959 62 6 of of ADP expositions-1959 62 7 objective objective ADJ expositions-1959 62 8 naturalism naturalism NOUN expositions-1959 62 9 . . PUNCT expositions-1959 63 1 briefly briefly ADV expositions-1959 63 2 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 63 3 metz metz PROPN expositions-1959 63 4 argues argue VERB expositions-1959 63 5 that that SCONJ expositions-1959 63 6 subjective subjective ADJ expositions-1959 63 7 naturalism naturalism NOUN expositions-1959 63 8 is be AUX expositions-1959 63 9 untenable untenable ADJ expositions-1959 63 10 because because SCONJ expositions-1959 63 11 it it PRON expositions-1959 63 12 implies imply VERB expositions-1959 63 13 that that SCONJ expositions-1959 63 14 utterly utterly ADV expositions-1959 63 15 pointless pointless ADJ expositions-1959 63 16 and and CCONJ expositions-1959 63 17 insignificant insignificant ADJ expositions-1959 63 18 activities activity NOUN expositions-1959 63 19 like like ADP expositions-1959 63 20 joyous joyous ADJ expositions-1959 63 21 sisyphean sisyphean ADJ expositions-1959 63 22 rock rock NOUN expositions-1959 63 23 - - PUNCT expositions-1959 63 24 rolling roll VERB expositions-1959 63 25 or or CCONJ expositions-1959 63 26 nozickian nozickian ADJ expositions-1959 63 27 experiencemachine experiencemachine NOUN expositions-1959 63 28 pleasure pleasure NOUN expositions-1959 63 29 - - PUNCT expositions-1959 63 30 surfing surfing NOUN expositions-1959 63 31 would would AUX expositions-1959 63 32 be be AUX expositions-1959 63 33 meaningful meaningful ADJ expositions-1959 63 34 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 63 35 when when SCONJ expositions-1959 63 36 in in ADP expositions-1959 63 37 fact fact NOUN expositions-1959 63 38 they they PRON expositions-1959 63 39 are be AUX expositions-1959 63 40 completely completely ADV expositions-1959 63 41 devoid devoid ADJ expositions-1959 63 42 of of ADP expositions-1959 63 43 meaning meaning NOUN expositions-1959 63 44 . . PUNCT expositions-1959 64 1 we we PRON expositions-1959 64 2 have have AUX expositions-1959 64 3 seen see VERB expositions-1959 64 4 how how SCONJ expositions-1959 64 5 this this DET expositions-1959 64 6 analysis analysis NOUN expositions-1959 64 7 might might AUX expositions-1959 64 8 be be AUX expositions-1959 64 9 challenged challenge VERB expositions-1959 64 10 . . PUNCT expositions-1959 65 1 metz metz PROPN expositions-1959 65 2 turns turn VERB expositions-1959 65 3 next next ADV expositions-1959 65 4 to to ADP expositions-1959 65 5 supernaturalist supernaturalist VERB expositions-1959 65 6 theories theory NOUN expositions-1959 65 7 of of ADP expositions-1959 65 8 meaning meaning NOUN expositions-1959 65 9 . . PUNCT expositions-1959 66 1 his his PRON expositions-1959 66 2 rich rich ADJ expositions-1959 66 3 and and CCONJ expositions-1959 66 4 complex complex ADJ expositions-1959 66 5 eighty eighty NUM expositions-1959 66 6 - - PUNCT expositions-1959 66 7 page page NOUN expositions-1959 66 8 discussion discussion NOUN expositions-1959 66 9 of of ADP expositions-1959 66 10 various various ADJ expositions-1959 66 11 supernaturalist supernaturalist NOUN expositions-1959 66 12 theories theory NOUN expositions-1959 66 13 of of ADP expositions-1959 66 14 meaning meaning NOUN expositions-1959 66 15 can can AUX expositions-1959 66 16 not not PART expositions-1959 66 17 be be AUX expositions-1959 66 18 summarized summarize VERB expositions-1959 66 19 adequately adequately ADV expositions-1959 66 20 here here ADV expositions-1959 66 21 . . PUNCT expositions-1959 67 1 one one NUM expositions-1959 67 2 form form NOUN expositions-1959 67 3 of of ADP expositions-1959 67 4 supernaturalism supernaturalism NOUN expositions-1959 67 5 he he PRON expositions-1959 67 6 scrutinizes scrutinize VERB expositions-1959 67 7 in in ADP expositions-1959 67 8 detail detail NOUN expositions-1959 67 9 is be AUX expositions-1959 67 10 what what PRON expositions-1959 67 11 he he PRON expositions-1959 67 12 calls call VERB expositions-1959 67 13 “ " PUNCT expositions-1959 67 14 purpose purpose NOUN expositions-1959 67 15 theory theory NOUN expositions-1959 67 16 . . PUNCT expositions-1959 67 17 ” " PUNCT expositions-1959 68 1 according accord VERB expositions-1959 68 2 to to ADP expositions-1959 68 3 purpose purpose NOUN expositions-1959 68 4 theory theory NOUN expositions-1959 68 5 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 68 6 god god PROPN expositions-1959 68 7 is be AUX expositions-1959 68 8 absolutely absolutely ADV expositions-1959 68 9 necessary necessary ADJ expositions-1959 68 10 for for ADP expositions-1959 68 11 any any DET expositions-1959 68 12 form form NOUN expositions-1959 68 13 of of ADP expositions-1959 68 14 meaning meaning NOUN expositions-1959 68 15 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 68 16 and and CCONJ expositions-1959 68 17 the the PRON expositions-1959 68 18 closer close ADJ expositions-1959 68 19 a a DET expositions-1959 68 20 person person NOUN expositions-1959 68 21 145 145 NUM expositions-1959 68 22 bassham bassham PROPN expositions-1959 68 23             SPACE expositions-1959 68 24 comes come VERB expositions-1959 68 25 to to ADP expositions-1959 68 26 fulfilling fulfil VERB expositions-1959 68 27 the the DET expositions-1959 68 28 ( ( PUNCT expositions-1959 68 29 collective collective ADJ expositions-1959 68 30 or or CCONJ expositions-1959 68 31 individualized individualized ADJ expositions-1959 68 32 ) ) PUNCT expositions-1959 68 33 purpose purpose NOUN expositions-1959 68 34 god god PROPN expositions-1959 68 35 has have AUX expositions-1959 68 36 assigned assign VERB expositions-1959 68 37 to to ADP expositions-1959 68 38 her she PRON expositions-1959 68 39 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 68 40 the the DET expositions-1959 68 41 more more ADV expositions-1959 68 42 meaningful meaningful ADJ expositions-1959 68 43 her her PRON expositions-1959 68 44 life life NOUN expositions-1959 68 45 is be AUX expositions-1959 68 46 . . PUNCT expositions-1959 69 1 metz metz PROPN expositions-1959 69 2 offers offer VERB expositions-1959 69 3 a a DET expositions-1959 69 4 mixed mixed ADJ expositions-1959 69 5 bag bag NOUN expositions-1959 69 6 of of ADP expositions-1959 69 7 objections objection NOUN expositions-1959 69 8 against against ADP expositions-1959 69 9 supernaturalist supernaturalist ADJ expositions-1959 69 10 accounts account NOUN expositions-1959 69 11 of of ADP expositions-1959 69 12 meaning meaning NOUN expositions-1959 69 13 . . PUNCT expositions-1959 70 1 one one NUM expositions-1959 70 2 plausible plausible ADJ expositions-1959 70 3 objection objection NOUN expositions-1959 70 4 he he PRON expositions-1959 70 5 gives give VERB expositions-1959 70 6 is be AUX expositions-1959 70 7 that that SCONJ expositions-1959 70 8 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 70 9 intuitively intuitively ADV expositions-1959 70 10 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 70 11 some some DET expositions-1959 70 12 things thing NOUN expositions-1959 70 13 can can AUX expositions-1959 70 14 be be AUX expositions-1959 70 15 meaningful meaningful ADJ expositions-1959 70 16 even even ADV expositions-1959 70 17 if if SCONJ expositions-1959 70 18 nothing nothing PRON expositions-1959 70 19 supernatural supernatural ADJ expositions-1959 70 20 exists exist VERB expositions-1959 70 21 ( ( PUNCT expositions-1959 70 22 144 144 NUM expositions-1959 70 23 ) ) PUNCT expositions-1959 70 24 . . PUNCT expositions-1959 71 1 for for ADP expositions-1959 71 2 example example NOUN expositions-1959 71 3 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 71 4 feeding feed VERB expositions-1959 71 5 a a DET expositions-1959 71 6 hungry hungry ADJ expositions-1959 71 7 child child NOUN expositions-1959 71 8 seems seem VERB expositions-1959 71 9 to to PART expositions-1959 71 10 have have VERB expositions-1959 71 11 significance significance NOUN expositions-1959 71 12 — — PUNCT expositions-1959 71 13 and and CCONJ expositions-1959 71 14 therefore therefore ADV expositions-1959 71 15 meaning meaning NOUN expositions-1959 71 16 — — PUNCT expositions-1959 71 17 even even ADV expositions-1959 71 18 if if SCONJ expositions-1959 71 19 we we PRON expositions-1959 71 20 decide decide VERB expositions-1959 71 21 that that SCONJ expositions-1959 71 22 there there PRON expositions-1959 71 23 is be VERB expositions-1959 71 24 no no DET expositions-1959 71 25 god god NOUN expositions-1959 71 26 or or CCONJ expositions-1959 71 27 spiritual spiritual ADJ expositions-1959 71 28 realm realm NOUN expositions-1959 71 29 . . PUNCT expositions-1959 72 1 metz metz PROPN expositions-1959 72 2 ’s ’s PART expositions-1959 72 3 primary primary ADJ expositions-1959 72 4 argument argument NOUN expositions-1959 72 5 against against ADP expositions-1959 72 6 supernaturalism supernaturalism NOUN expositions-1959 72 7 is be AUX expositions-1959 72 8 more more ADV expositions-1959 72 9 questionable questionable ADJ expositions-1959 72 10 . . PUNCT expositions-1959 73 1 essentially essentially ADV expositions-1959 73 2 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 73 3 he he PRON expositions-1959 73 4 argues argue VERB expositions-1959 73 5 that that SCONJ expositions-1959 73 6 supernatural supernatural ADJ expositions-1959 73 7 accounts account NOUN expositions-1959 73 8 of of ADP expositions-1959 73 9 meaning meaning NOUN expositions-1959 73 10 depend depend VERB expositions-1959 73 11 on on ADP expositions-1959 73 12 a a DET expositions-1959 73 13 conception conception NOUN expositions-1959 73 14 of of ADP expositions-1959 73 15 god god PROPN expositions-1959 73 16 that that PRON expositions-1959 73 17 is be AUX expositions-1959 73 18 ultimately ultimately ADV expositions-1959 73 19 incoherent incoherent ADJ expositions-1959 73 20 . . PUNCT expositions-1959 74 1 he he PRON expositions-1959 74 2 argues argue VERB expositions-1959 74 3 that that SCONJ expositions-1959 74 4 meaning meaning NOUN expositions-1959 74 5 can can AUX expositions-1959 74 6 be be AUX expositions-1959 74 7 wholly wholly ADV expositions-1959 74 8 dependent dependent ADJ expositions-1959 74 9 on on ADP expositions-1959 74 10 god god PROPN expositions-1959 74 11 only only ADV expositions-1959 74 12 if if SCONJ expositions-1959 74 13 god god PROPN expositions-1959 74 14 is be AUX expositions-1959 74 15 an an DET expositions-1959 74 16 absolutely absolutely ADV expositions-1959 74 17 perfect perfect ADJ expositions-1959 74 18 being being NOUN expositions-1959 74 19 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 74 20 and and CCONJ expositions-1959 74 21 god god PROPN expositions-1959 74 22 can can AUX expositions-1959 74 23 be be AUX expositions-1959 74 24 an an DET expositions-1959 74 25 absolutely absolutely ADV expositions-1959 74 26 perfect perfect ADJ expositions-1959 74 27 being be AUX expositions-1959 74 28 only only ADV expositions-1959 74 29 if if SCONJ expositions-1959 74 30 he he PRON expositions-1959 74 31 is be AUX expositions-1959 74 32 outside outside ADP expositions-1959 74 33 of of ADP expositions-1959 74 34 time time NOUN expositions-1959 74 35 and and CCONJ expositions-1959 74 36 completely completely ADV expositions-1959 74 37 unchangeable unchangeable ADJ expositions-1959 74 38 . . PUNCT expositions-1959 75 1 but but CCONJ expositions-1959 75 2 if if SCONJ expositions-1959 75 3 god god PROPN expositions-1959 75 4 is be AUX expositions-1959 75 5 wholly wholly ADV expositions-1959 75 6 atemporal atemporal ADJ expositions-1959 75 7 and and CCONJ expositions-1959 75 8 immutable immutable ADJ expositions-1959 75 9 he he PRON expositions-1959 75 10 presumably presumably ADV expositions-1959 75 11 can can AUX expositions-1959 75 12 not not PART expositions-1959 75 13 do do VERB expositions-1959 75 14 things thing NOUN expositions-1959 75 15 like like ADP expositions-1959 75 16 “ " PUNCT expositions-1959 75 17 choose choose VERB expositions-1959 75 18 ” " PUNCT expositions-1959 75 19 to to PART expositions-1959 75 20 create create VERB expositions-1959 75 21 a a DET expositions-1959 75 22 universe universe NOUN expositions-1959 75 23 or or CCONJ expositions-1959 75 24 to to PART expositions-1959 75 25 “ " PUNCT expositions-1959 75 26 assign assign VERB expositions-1959 75 27 ” " PUNCT expositions-1959 75 28 individual individual ADJ expositions-1959 75 29 life life NOUN expositions-1959 75 30 - - PUNCT expositions-1959 75 31 purposes purpose NOUN expositions-1959 75 32 . . PUNCT expositions-1959 76 1 such such ADJ expositions-1959 76 2 activities activity NOUN expositions-1959 76 3 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 76 4 metz metz PROPN expositions-1959 76 5 argues argue VERB expositions-1959 76 6 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 76 7 are be AUX expositions-1959 76 8 possible possible ADJ expositions-1959 76 9 only only ADV expositions-1959 76 10 if if SCONJ expositions-1959 76 11 god god PROPN expositions-1959 76 12 exists exist VERB expositions-1959 76 13 in in ADP expositions-1959 76 14 time time NOUN expositions-1959 76 15 and and CCONJ expositions-1959 76 16 can can AUX expositions-1959 76 17 change change VERB expositions-1959 76 18 ( ( PUNCT expositions-1959 76 19 106–14 106–14 NUM expositions-1959 76 20 ) ) PUNCT expositions-1959 76 21 . . PUNCT expositions-1959 77 1 here here ADV expositions-1959 77 2 four four NUM expositions-1959 77 3 things thing NOUN expositions-1959 77 4 should should AUX expositions-1959 77 5 be be AUX expositions-1959 77 6 noted note VERB expositions-1959 77 7 : : PUNCT expositions-1959 78 1 1 1 X expositions-1959 78 2 . . X expositions-1959 78 3 many many ADJ expositions-1959 78 4 contemporary contemporary ADJ expositions-1959 78 5 philosophers philosopher NOUN expositions-1959 78 6 of of ADP expositions-1959 78 7 religion religion NOUN expositions-1959 78 8 do do AUX expositions-1959 78 9 not not PART expositions-1959 78 10 accept accept VERB expositions-1959 78 11 the the DET expositions-1959 78 12 kind kind NOUN expositions-1959 78 13 of of ADP expositions-1959 78 14 classical classical ADJ expositions-1959 78 15 “ " PUNCT expositions-1959 78 16 perfect perfect ADJ expositions-1959 78 17 being being NOUN expositions-1959 78 18 theology theology NOUN expositions-1959 78 19 ” " PUNCT expositions-1959 78 20 metz metz PROPN expositions-1959 78 21 ’s ’s PART expositions-1959 78 22 argument argument NOUN expositions-1959 78 23 presupposes presuppose VERB expositions-1959 78 24 . . PUNCT expositions-1959 79 1 traditional traditional ADJ expositions-1959 79 2 notions notion NOUN expositions-1959 79 3 of of ADP expositions-1959 79 4 god god PROPN expositions-1959 79 5 as as ADP expositions-1959 79 6 immutable immutable ADJ expositions-1959 79 7 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 79 8 atemporal atemporal ADJ expositions-1959 79 9 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 79 10 and and CCONJ expositions-1959 79 11 perfectly perfectly ADV expositions-1959 79 12 simple simple ADJ expositions-1959 79 13 have have AUX expositions-1959 79 14 been be AUX expositions-1959 79 15 widely widely ADV expositions-1959 79 16 challenged.4 challenged.4 NOUN expositions-1959 79 17 2 2 NUM expositions-1959 79 18 . . PUNCT expositions-1959 80 1 there there PRON expositions-1959 80 2 are be VERB expositions-1959 80 3 familiar familiar ADJ expositions-1959 80 4 and and CCONJ expositions-1959 80 5 plausible plausible ADJ expositions-1959 80 6 responses response NOUN expositions-1959 80 7 to to ADP expositions-1959 80 8 the the DET expositions-1959 80 9 sorts sort NOUN expositions-1959 80 10 of of ADP expositions-1959 80 11 incoherence incoherence NOUN expositions-1959 80 12 - - PUNCT expositions-1959 80 13 arguments argument NOUN expositions-1959 80 14 metz metz NOUN expositions-1959 80 15 offers offer VERB expositions-1959 80 16 . . PUNCT expositions-1959 81 1 for for ADP expositions-1959 81 2 example example NOUN expositions-1959 81 3 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 81 4 thomists thomist NOUN expositions-1959 81 5 would would AUX expositions-1959 81 6 deny deny VERB expositions-1959 81 7 that that SCONJ expositions-1959 81 8 we we PRON expositions-1959 81 9 can can AUX expositions-1959 81 10 speak speak VERB expositions-1959 81 11 of of ADP expositions-1959 81 12 god god PROPN expositions-1959 81 13 “ " PUNCT expositions-1959 81 14 acting act VERB expositions-1959 81 15 ” " PUNCT expositions-1959 81 16 or or CCONJ expositions-1959 81 17 “ " PUNCT expositions-1959 81 18 choosing choose VERB expositions-1959 81 19 ” " PUNCT expositions-1959 81 20 in in ADP expositions-1959 81 21 the the DET expositions-1959 81 22 same same ADJ expositions-1959 81 23 univocal univocal ADJ expositions-1959 81 24 sense sense NOUN expositions-1959 81 25 that that SCONJ expositions-1959 81 26 we we PRON expositions-1959 81 27 employ employ VERB expositions-1959 81 28 when when SCONJ expositions-1959 81 29 speaking speak VERB expositions-1959 81 30 of of ADP expositions-1959 81 31 human human ADJ expositions-1959 81 32 agency agency NOUN expositions-1959 81 33 . . PUNCT expositions-1959 82 1 likewise likewise ADV expositions-1959 82 2 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 82 3 might might AUX expositions-1959 82 4 not not PART expositions-1959 82 5 god god PROPN expositions-1959 82 6 be be AUX expositions-1959 82 7 wholly wholly ADV expositions-1959 82 8 immutable immutable ADJ expositions-1959 82 9 and and CCONJ expositions-1959 82 10 outside outside ADJ expositions-1959 82 11 time time NOUN expositions-1959 82 12 and and CCONJ expositions-1959 82 13 yet yet ADV expositions-1959 82 14 able able ADJ expositions-1959 82 15 to to PART expositions-1959 82 16 express express VERB expositions-1959 82 17 his his PRON expositions-1959 82 18 eternal eternal ADJ expositions-1959 82 19 will will NOUN expositions-1959 82 20 in in ADP expositions-1959 82 21 ways way NOUN expositions-1959 82 22 that that PRON expositions-1959 82 23 have have VERB expositions-1959 82 24 temporal temporal ADJ expositions-1959 82 25 effects effect NOUN expositions-1959 82 26 ? ? PUNCT expositions-1959 83 1 3 3 X expositions-1959 83 2 . . X expositions-1959 83 3 it it PRON expositions-1959 83 4 is be AUX expositions-1959 83 5 far far ADV expositions-1959 83 6 from from ADP expositions-1959 83 7 clear clear ADJ expositions-1959 83 8 that that SCONJ expositions-1959 83 9 the the DET expositions-1959 83 10 most most ADV expositions-1959 83 11 defensible defensible ADJ expositions-1959 83 12 account account NOUN expositions-1959 83 13 of of ADP expositions-1959 83 14 how how SCONJ expositions-1959 83 15 meaning meaning NOUN expositions-1959 83 16 could could AUX expositions-1959 83 17 be be AUX expositions-1959 83 18 entirely entirely ADV expositions-1959 83 19 dependent dependent ADJ expositions-1959 83 20 on on ADP expositions-1959 83 21 god god PROPN expositions-1959 83 22 must must AUX expositions-1959 83 23 presume presume VERB expositions-1959 83 24 that that SCONJ expositions-1959 83 25 god god PROPN expositions-1959 83 26 is be AUX expositions-1959 83 27 absolutely absolutely ADV expositions-1959 83 28 perfect perfect ADJ expositions-1959 83 29 . . PUNCT expositions-1959 84 1 4 4 X expositions-1959 84 2 . . NUM expositions-1959 84 3 nor nor CCONJ expositions-1959 84 4 is be AUX expositions-1959 84 5 it it PRON expositions-1959 84 6 clear clear ADJ expositions-1959 84 7 that that SCONJ expositions-1959 84 8 the the DET expositions-1959 84 9 most most ADV expositions-1959 84 10 defensible defensible ADJ expositions-1959 84 11 supernaturalist supernaturalist NOUN expositions-1959 84 12 account account NOUN expositions-1959 84 13 of of ADP expositions-1959 84 14 meaning meaning NOUN expositions-1959 84 15 must must AUX expositions-1959 84 16 claim claim VERB expositions-1959 84 17 that that SCONJ expositions-1959 84 18 all all DET expositions-1959 84 19 possible possible ADJ expositions-1959 84 20 meaning meaning NOUN expositions-1959 84 21 is be AUX expositions-1959 84 22 totally totally ADV expositions-1959 84 23 dependent dependent ADJ expositions-1959 84 24 on on ADP expositions-1959 84 25 god god PROPN expositions-1959 84 26 . . PUNCT expositions-1959 85 1 why why SCONJ expositions-1959 85 2 not not PART expositions-1959 85 3 adopt adopt VERB expositions-1959 85 4 a a DET expositions-1959 85 5 mixed mixed ADJ expositions-1959 85 6 theory theory NOUN expositions-1959 85 7 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 85 8 which which PRON expositions-1959 85 9 claims claim VERB expositions-1959 85 10 that that SCONJ expositions-1959 85 11 some some DET expositions-1959 85 12 kinds kind NOUN expositions-1959 85 13 of of ADP expositions-1959 85 14 meanings meaning NOUN expositions-1959 85 15 ( ( PUNCT expositions-1959 85 16 e.g. e.g. ADV expositions-1959 85 17 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 85 18 certain certain ADJ expositions-1959 85 19 kinds kind NOUN expositions-1959 85 20 of of ADP expositions-1959 85 21 “ " PUNCT expositions-1959 85 22 deep deep ADJ expositions-1959 85 23 ” " PUNCT expositions-1959 85 24 or or CCONJ expositions-1959 85 25 “ " PUNCT expositions-1959 85 26 ultimate ultimate ADJ expositions-1959 85 27 ” " PUNCT expositions-1959 85 28 meanings meaning NOUN expositions-1959 85 29 ) ) PUNCT expositions-1959 85 30 are be AUX expositions-1959 85 31 dependent dependent ADJ expositions-1959 85 32 on on ADP expositions-1959 85 33 god god PROPN expositions-1959 85 34 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 85 35 but but CCONJ expositions-1959 85 36 other other ADJ expositions-1959 85 37 sorts sort NOUN expositions-1959 85 38 of of ADP expositions-1959 85 39 meanings meaning NOUN expositions-1959 85 40 ( ( PUNCT expositions-1959 85 41 e.g. e.g. ADV expositions-1959 85 42 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 85 43 feeding feed VERB expositions-1959 85 44 a a DET expositions-1959 85 45 hungry hungry ADJ expositions-1959 85 46 child child NOUN expositions-1959 85 47 or or CCONJ expositions-1959 85 48 finding find VERB expositions-1959 85 49 a a DET expositions-1959 85 50 cure cure NOUN expositions-1959 85 51 for for ADP expositions-1959 85 52 aids aid NOUN expositions-1959 85 53 ) ) PUNCT expositions-1959 85 54 are be AUX expositions-1959 85 55 not not PART expositions-1959 85 56 ( ( PUNCT expositions-1959 85 57 except except SCONJ expositions-1959 85 58 perhaps perhaps ADV expositions-1959 85 59 in in ADP expositions-1959 85 60 the the DET expositions-1959 85 61 sense sense NOUN expositions-1959 85 62 that that SCONJ expositions-1959 85 63 all all DET expositions-1959 85 64 things thing NOUN expositions-1959 85 65 are be AUX expositions-1959 85 66 dependent dependent ADJ expositions-1959 85 67 upon upon SCONJ expositions-1959 85 68 god god PROPN expositions-1959 85 69 for for ADP expositions-1959 85 70 their their PRON expositions-1959 85 71 existence existence NOUN expositions-1959 85 72 ) ) PUNCT expositions-1959 85 73 ? ? PUNCT expositions-1959 86 1 in in ADP expositions-1959 86 2 general general ADJ expositions-1959 86 3 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 86 4 metz metz PROPN expositions-1959 86 5 ’s ’s PART expositions-1959 86 6 entire entire ADJ expositions-1959 86 7 discussion discussion NOUN expositions-1959 86 8 of of ADP expositions-1959 86 9 how how SCONJ expositions-1959 86 10 meaning(s meaning(s NOUN expositions-1959 86 11 ) ) PUNCT expositions-1959 86 12 might might AUX expositions-1959 86 13 depend depend VERB expositions-1959 86 14 upon upon SCONJ expositions-1959 86 15 god god PROPN expositions-1959 86 16 could could AUX expositions-1959 86 17 benefit benefit VERB expositions-1959 86 18 from from ADP expositions-1959 86 19 a a DET expositions-1959 86 20 closer close ADJ expositions-1959 86 21 engagement engagement NOUN expositions-1959 86 22 with with ADP expositions-1959 86 23 the the DET expositions-1959 86 24 ( ( PUNCT expositions-1959 86 25 vast vast ADJ expositions-1959 86 26 ) ) PUNCT expositions-1959 86 27 theological theological ADJ expositions-1959 86 28 literature literature NOUN expositions-1959 86 29 on on ADP expositions-1959 86 30 notions notion NOUN expositions-1959 86 31 such such ADJ expositions-1959 86 32 as as ADP expositions-1959 86 33 the the DET expositions-1959 86 34 divine divine NOUN expositions-1959 86 35 “ " PUNCT expositions-1959 86 36 will will AUX expositions-1959 86 37 ” " PUNCT expositions-1959 86 38 or or CCONJ expositions-1959 86 39 “ " PUNCT expositions-1959 86 40 purpose purpose NOUN expositions-1959 86 41 . . PUNCT expositions-1959 86 42 ” " PUNCT expositions-1959 87 1 to to PART expositions-1959 87 2 take take VERB expositions-1959 87 3 but but CCONJ expositions-1959 87 4 one one NUM expositions-1959 87 5 example example NOUN expositions-1959 87 6 : : PUNCT expositions-1959 87 7 suppose suppose VERB expositions-1959 87 8 god god PROPN expositions-1959 87 9 ’s ’s PART expositions-1959 87 10 individualized individualized ADJ expositions-1959 87 11 “ " PUNCT expositions-1959 87 12 purpose purpose NOUN expositions-1959 87 13 ” " PUNCT expositions-1959 87 14 for for ADP expositions-1959 87 15 smith smith PROPN expositions-1959 87 16 is be AUX expositions-1959 87 17 that that SCONJ expositions-1959 87 18 he he PRON expositions-1959 87 19 write write VERB expositions-1959 87 20 ten ten NUM expositions-1959 87 21 world world NOUN expositions-1959 87 22 - - PUNCT expositions-1959 87 23 class class NOUN expositions-1959 87 24 religious religious ADJ expositions-1959 87 25 novels novel NOUN expositions-1959 87 26 and and CCONJ expositions-1959 87 27 save save VERB expositions-1959 87 28 1,000 1,000 NUM expositions-1959 87 29 lives life NOUN expositions-1959 87 30 from from ADP expositions-1959 87 31 a a DET expositions-1959 87 32 burning burn VERB expositions-1959 87 33 building building NOUN expositions-1959 87 34 . . PUNCT expositions-1959 88 1 smith smith PROPN expositions-1959 88 2 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 88 3 alas alas INTJ expositions-1959 88 4 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 88 5 writes write VERB expositions-1959 88 6 only only ADV expositions-1959 88 7 nine nine NUM expositions-1959 88 8 world world NOUN expositions-1959 88 9 - - PUNCT expositions-1959 88 10 class class NOUN expositions-1959 88 11 novels novel NOUN expositions-1959 88 12 and and CCONJ expositions-1959 88 13 saves save VERB expositions-1959 88 14 only only ADV expositions-1959 88 15 999 999 NUM expositions-1959 88 16 people people NOUN expositions-1959 88 17 from from ADP expositions-1959 88 18 the the DET expositions-1959 88 19 fire fire NOUN expositions-1959 88 20 ( ( PUNCT expositions-1959 88 21 unhappily unhappily ADV expositions-1959 88 22 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 88 23 one one NUM expositions-1959 88 24 victim victim NOUN expositions-1959 88 25 review review NOUN expositions-1959 88 26 of of ADP expositions-1959 88 27 meaning meaning NOUN expositions-1959 88 28 in in ADP expositions-1959 88 29 life life NOUN expositions-1959 88 30 146 146 NUM expositions-1959 88 31     SPACE expositions-1959 88 32 jumped jump VERB expositions-1959 88 33 to to ADP expositions-1959 88 34 her her PRON expositions-1959 88 35 death death NOUN expositions-1959 88 36 ) ) PUNCT expositions-1959 88 37 . . PUNCT expositions-1959 89 1 jones jones PROPN expositions-1959 89 2 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 89 3 on on ADP expositions-1959 89 4 the the DET expositions-1959 89 5 other other ADJ expositions-1959 89 6 hand hand NOUN expositions-1959 89 7 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 89 8 has have VERB expositions-1959 89 9 a a DET expositions-1959 89 10 much much ADV expositions-1959 89 11 more more ADV expositions-1959 89 12 limited limited ADJ expositions-1959 89 13 “ " PUNCT expositions-1959 89 14 purpose purpose NOUN expositions-1959 89 15 ” " PUNCT expositions-1959 89 16 or or CCONJ expositions-1959 89 17 “ " PUNCT expositions-1959 89 18 assignment assignment NOUN expositions-1959 89 19 ” " PUNCT expositions-1959 89 20 from from ADP expositions-1959 89 21 god god PROPN expositions-1959 89 22 — — PUNCT expositions-1959 89 23 namely namely ADV expositions-1959 89 24 to to PART expositions-1959 89 25 produce produce VERB expositions-1959 89 26 a a DET expositions-1959 89 27 single single ADJ expositions-1959 89 28 crayon crayon NOUN expositions-1959 89 29 drawing drawing NOUN expositions-1959 89 30 of of ADP expositions-1959 89 31 an an DET expositions-1959 89 32 angel angel NOUN expositions-1959 89 33 before before ADP expositions-1959 89 34 tragically tragically ADV expositions-1959 89 35 dying die VERB expositions-1959 89 36 at at ADP expositions-1959 89 37 age age NOUN expositions-1959 89 38 three three NUM expositions-1959 89 39 . . PUNCT expositions-1959 90 1 as as SCONJ expositions-1959 90 2 metz metz PROPN expositions-1959 90 3 describes describe VERB expositions-1959 90 4 it it PRON expositions-1959 90 5 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 90 6 purpose purpose NOUN expositions-1959 90 7 theory theory NOUN expositions-1959 90 8 seems seem VERB expositions-1959 90 9 to to PART expositions-1959 90 10 imply imply VERB expositions-1959 90 11 that that SCONJ expositions-1959 90 12 jones jones PROPN expositions-1959 90 13 led lead VERB expositions-1959 90 14 a a DET expositions-1959 90 15 more more ADV expositions-1959 90 16 meaningful meaningful ADJ expositions-1959 90 17 life life NOUN expositions-1959 90 18 than than SCONJ expositions-1959 90 19 smith smith PROPN expositions-1959 90 20 did do VERB expositions-1959 90 21 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 90 22 because because SCONJ expositions-1959 90 23 jones jones PROPN expositions-1959 90 24 perfectly perfectly ADV expositions-1959 90 25 fulfilled fulfil VERB expositions-1959 90 26 god god PROPN expositions-1959 90 27 ’s ’s PART expositions-1959 90 28 purpose purpose NOUN expositions-1959 90 29 for for ADP expositions-1959 90 30 his his PRON expositions-1959 90 31 life life NOUN expositions-1959 90 32 and and CCONJ expositions-1959 90 33 smith smith NOUN expositions-1959 90 34 did do VERB expositions-1959 90 35 not not PART expositions-1959 90 36 . . PUNCT expositions-1959 91 1 a a DET expositions-1959 91 2 brief brief ADJ expositions-1959 91 3 glance glance NOUN expositions-1959 91 4 into into ADP expositions-1959 91 5 the the DET expositions-1959 91 6 theological theological ADJ expositions-1959 91 7 writings writing NOUN expositions-1959 91 8 of of ADP expositions-1959 91 9 ( ( PUNCT expositions-1959 91 10 say say INTJ expositions-1959 91 11 ) ) PUNCT expositions-1959 91 12 aquinas aquinas PROPN expositions-1959 91 13 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 91 14 molina molina PROPN expositions-1959 91 15 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 91 16 or or CCONJ expositions-1959 91 17 suarez suarez PROPN expositions-1959 91 18 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 91 19 would would AUX expositions-1959 91 20 have have AUX expositions-1959 91 21 steered steer VERB expositions-1959 91 22 metz metz PROPN expositions-1959 91 23 into into ADP expositions-1959 91 24 much much ADV expositions-1959 91 25 more more ADV expositions-1959 91 26 plausible plausible ADJ expositions-1959 91 27 waters water NOUN expositions-1959 91 28 . . PUNCT expositions-1959 92 1 having having AUX expositions-1959 92 2 rejected reject VERB expositions-1959 92 3 supernaturalist supernaturalist NOUN expositions-1959 92 4 and and CCONJ expositions-1959 92 5 subjectivist subjectivist ADJ expositions-1959 92 6 theories theory NOUN expositions-1959 92 7 of of ADP expositions-1959 92 8 meaning meaning NOUN expositions-1959 92 9 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 92 10 metz metz PROPN expositions-1959 92 11 next next ADJ expositions-1959 92 12 turns turn VERB expositions-1959 92 13 to to PART expositions-1959 92 14 consider consider VERB expositions-1959 92 15 a a DET expositions-1959 92 16 variety variety NOUN expositions-1959 92 17 of of ADP expositions-1959 92 18 leading lead VERB expositions-1959 92 19 objectivist objectivist NOUN expositions-1959 92 20 naturalistic naturalistic ADJ expositions-1959 92 21 theories theory NOUN expositions-1959 92 22 . . PUNCT expositions-1959 93 1 after after ADP expositions-1959 93 2 arguing argue VERB expositions-1959 93 3 that that SCONJ expositions-1959 93 4 all all PRON expositions-1959 93 5 of of ADP expositions-1959 93 6 the the DET expositions-1959 93 7 most most ADV expositions-1959 93 8 widely widely ADV expositions-1959 93 9 discussed discuss VERB expositions-1959 93 10 objectivist objectivist NOUN expositions-1959 93 11 theories theory NOUN expositions-1959 93 12 have have VERB expositions-1959 93 13 fatal fatal ADJ expositions-1959 93 14 weaknesses weakness NOUN expositions-1959 93 15 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 93 16 metz metz PROPN expositions-1959 93 17 lays lay VERB expositions-1959 93 18 out out ADP expositions-1959 93 19 and and CCONJ expositions-1959 93 20 defends defend VERB expositions-1959 93 21 what what PRON expositions-1959 93 22 he he PRON expositions-1959 93 23 takes take VERB expositions-1959 93 24 to to PART expositions-1959 93 25 be be AUX expositions-1959 93 26 the the DET expositions-1959 93 27 correct correct ADJ expositions-1959 93 28 theory theory NOUN expositions-1959 93 29 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 93 30 a a DET expositions-1959 93 31 view view NOUN expositions-1959 93 32 that that SCONJ expositions-1959 93 33 he he PRON expositions-1959 93 34 calls call VERB expositions-1959 93 35 the the DET expositions-1959 93 36 “ " PUNCT expositions-1959 93 37 fundamentality fundamentality NOUN expositions-1959 93 38 view view NOUN expositions-1959 93 39 . . PUNCT expositions-1959 93 40 ” " PUNCT expositions-1959 94 1 the the DET expositions-1959 94 2 final final ADJ expositions-1959 94 3 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 94 4 heavily heavily ADV expositions-1959 94 5 qualified qualified ADJ expositions-1959 94 6 version version NOUN expositions-1959 94 7 of of ADP expositions-1959 94 8 this this DET expositions-1959 94 9 view view NOUN expositions-1959 94 10 ( ( PUNCT expositions-1959 94 11 labelled label VERB expositions-1959 94 12 “ " PUNCT expositions-1959 94 13 ft3 ft3 NOUN expositions-1959 94 14 ” " PUNCT expositions-1959 94 15 in in ADP expositions-1959 94 16 the the DET expositions-1959 94 17 absurd absurd ADJ expositions-1959 94 18 fashion fashion NOUN expositions-1959 94 19 all all ADV expositions-1959 94 20 - - PUNCT expositions-1959 94 21 too too ADV expositions-1959 94 22 - - PUNCT expositions-1959 94 23 common common ADJ expositions-1959 94 24 in in ADP expositions-1959 94 25 hyperanalytic hyperanalytic ADJ expositions-1959 94 26 philosophy philosophy NOUN expositions-1959 94 27 ) ) PUNCT expositions-1959 94 28 is be AUX expositions-1959 94 29 stated state VERB expositions-1959 94 30 as as SCONJ expositions-1959 94 31 follows follow VERB expositions-1959 94 32 : : PUNCT expositions-1959 94 33 a a DET expositions-1959 94 34 human human ADJ expositions-1959 94 35 person person NOUN expositions-1959 94 36 ’s ’s PART expositions-1959 94 37 life life NOUN expositions-1959 94 38 is be AUX expositions-1959 94 39 more more ADV expositions-1959 94 40 meaningful meaningful ADJ expositions-1959 94 41 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 94 42 the the DET expositions-1959 94 43 more more ADJ expositions-1959 94 44 that that SCONJ expositions-1959 94 45 she she PRON expositions-1959 94 46 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 94 47 without without ADP expositions-1959 94 48 violating violate VERB expositions-1959 94 49 certain certain ADJ expositions-1959 94 50 moral moral ADJ expositions-1959 94 51 constraints constraint NOUN expositions-1959 94 52 against against ADP expositions-1959 94 53 degrading degrade VERB expositions-1959 94 54 sacrifice sacrifice NOUN expositions-1959 94 55 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 94 56 employs employ VERB expositions-1959 94 57 her her PRON expositions-1959 94 58 reason reason NOUN expositions-1959 94 59 and and CCONJ expositions-1959 94 60 in in ADP expositions-1959 94 61 ways way NOUN expositions-1959 94 62 that that PRON expositions-1959 94 63 either either CCONJ expositions-1959 94 64 positively positively ADV expositions-1959 94 65 orient orient ADJ expositions-1959 94 66 rationality rationality NOUN expositions-1959 94 67 towards towards ADP expositions-1959 94 68 fundamental fundamental ADJ expositions-1959 94 69 conditions condition NOUN expositions-1959 94 70 of of ADP expositions-1959 94 71 human human ADJ expositions-1959 94 72 existence existence NOUN expositions-1959 94 73 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 94 74 or or CCONJ expositions-1959 94 75 negatively negatively ADV expositions-1959 94 76 orient orient VERB expositions-1959 94 77 it it PRON expositions-1959 94 78 towards towards ADP expositions-1959 94 79 what what PRON expositions-1959 94 80 threatens threaten VERB expositions-1959 94 81 them they PRON expositions-1959 94 82 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 94 83 such such ADJ expositions-1959 94 84 that that SCONJ expositions-1959 94 85 the the DET expositions-1959 94 86 worse bad ADJ expositions-1959 94 87 parts part NOUN expositions-1959 94 88 of of ADP expositions-1959 94 89 her her PRON expositions-1959 94 90 life life NOUN expositions-1959 94 91 cause cause VERB expositions-1959 94 92 better well ADJ expositions-1959 94 93 parts part NOUN expositions-1959 94 94 towards towards ADP expositions-1959 94 95 its its PRON expositions-1959 94 96 end end NOUN expositions-1959 94 97 by by ADP expositions-1959 94 98 a a DET expositions-1959 94 99 process process NOUN expositions-1959 94 100 that that PRON expositions-1959 94 101 makes make VERB expositions-1959 94 102 for for ADP expositions-1959 94 103 a a DET expositions-1959 94 104 compelling compelling ADJ expositions-1959 94 105 and and CCONJ expositions-1959 94 106 ideally ideally ADV expositions-1959 94 107 original original ADJ expositions-1959 94 108 life life NOUN expositions-1959 94 109 - - PUNCT expositions-1959 94 110 story story NOUN expositions-1959 94 111 ; ; PUNCT expositions-1959 94 112 in in ADP expositions-1959 94 113 addition addition NOUN expositions-1959 94 114 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 94 115 the the DET expositions-1959 94 116 meaning meaning NOUN expositions-1959 94 117 in in ADP expositions-1959 94 118 a a DET expositions-1959 94 119 human human ADJ expositions-1959 94 120 person person NOUN expositions-1959 94 121 ’s ’s PART expositions-1959 94 122 life life NOUN expositions-1959 94 123 is be AUX expositions-1959 94 124 reduced reduce VERB expositions-1959 94 125 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 94 126 the the PRON expositions-1959 94 127 more more ADJ expositions-1959 94 128 it it PRON expositions-1959 94 129 is be AUX expositions-1959 94 130 negatively negatively ADV expositions-1959 94 131 oriented orient VERB expositions-1959 94 132 towards towards ADP expositions-1959 94 133 fundamental fundamental ADJ expositions-1959 94 134 conditions condition NOUN expositions-1959 94 135 of of ADP expositions-1959 94 136 human human ADJ expositions-1959 94 137 existence existence NOUN expositions-1959 94 138 or or CCONJ expositions-1959 94 139 exhibits exhibit VERB expositions-1959 94 140 narrative narrative NOUN expositions-1959 94 141 disvalue disvalue NOUN expositions-1959 94 142 . . PUNCT expositions-1959 95 1 ( ( PUNCT expositions-1959 95 2 235 235 NUM expositions-1959 95 3 ) ) PUNCT expositions-1959 95 4 or or CCONJ expositions-1959 95 5 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 95 6 in in ADP expositions-1959 95 7 a a DET expositions-1959 95 8 simplified simplified ADJ expositions-1959 95 9 nutshell nutshell NOUN expositions-1959 95 10 : : PUNCT expositions-1959 95 11 individual individual ADJ expositions-1959 95 12 lives life NOUN expositions-1959 95 13 have have VERB expositions-1959 95 14 meaning meaning NOUN expositions-1959 95 15 to to ADP expositions-1959 95 16 the the DET expositions-1959 95 17 extent extent NOUN expositions-1959 95 18 that that SCONJ expositions-1959 95 19 they they PRON expositions-1959 95 20 positively positively ADV expositions-1959 95 21 engage engage VERB expositions-1959 95 22 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 95 23 through through ADP expositions-1959 95 24 active active ADJ expositions-1959 95 25 uses use NOUN expositions-1959 95 26 of of ADP expositions-1959 95 27 reason reason NOUN expositions-1959 95 28 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 95 29 with with ADP expositions-1959 95 30 fundamental fundamental ADJ expositions-1959 95 31 values value NOUN expositions-1959 95 32 such such ADJ expositions-1959 95 33 as as ADP expositions-1959 95 34 truth truth NOUN expositions-1959 95 35 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 95 36 goodness goodness NOUN expositions-1959 95 37 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 95 38 and and CCONJ expositions-1959 95 39 beauty beauty NOUN expositions-1959 95 40 . . PUNCT expositions-1959 96 1 on on ADP expositions-1959 96 2 such such DET expositions-1959 96 3 an an DET expositions-1959 96 4 account account NOUN expositions-1959 96 5 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 96 6 a a DET expositions-1959 96 7 deeply deeply ADV expositions-1959 96 8 and and CCONJ expositions-1959 96 9 paradigmatically paradigmatically ADV expositions-1959 96 10 meaningful meaningful ADJ expositions-1959 96 11 life life NOUN expositions-1959 96 12 would would AUX expositions-1959 96 13 be be AUX expositions-1959 96 14 one one NUM expositions-1959 96 15 of of ADP expositions-1959 96 16 outstanding outstanding ADJ expositions-1959 96 17 moral moral ADJ expositions-1959 96 18 achievement achievement NOUN expositions-1959 96 19 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 96 20 high high ADV expositions-1959 96 21 - - PUNCT expositions-1959 96 22 flying fly VERB expositions-1959 96 23 intellectual intellectual ADJ expositions-1959 96 24 excellence excellence NOUN expositions-1959 96 25 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 96 26 and and CCONJ expositions-1959 96 27 significant significant ADJ expositions-1959 96 28 artistic artistic ADJ expositions-1959 96 29 creation creation NOUN expositions-1959 96 30 . . PUNCT expositions-1959 97 1 this this PRON expositions-1959 97 2 is be AUX expositions-1959 97 3 a a DET expositions-1959 97 4 not not PART expositions-1959 97 5 altogether altogether ADV expositions-1959 97 6 implausible implausible ADJ expositions-1959 97 7 conception conception NOUN expositions-1959 97 8 if if SCONJ expositions-1959 97 9 you you PRON expositions-1959 97 10 accept accept VERB expositions-1959 97 11 the the DET expositions-1959 97 12 network network NOUN expositions-1959 97 13 of of ADP expositions-1959 97 14 naturalistic naturalistic ADJ expositions-1959 97 15 and and CCONJ expositions-1959 97 16 objectivist objectivist NOUN expositions-1959 97 17 presuppositions presupposition NOUN expositions-1959 97 18 on on ADP expositions-1959 97 19 which which PRON expositions-1959 97 20 it it PRON expositions-1959 97 21 rests rest VERB expositions-1959 97 22 . . PUNCT expositions-1959 98 1 from from ADP expositions-1959 98 2 a a DET expositions-1959 98 3 theistic theistic ADJ expositions-1959 98 4 view view NOUN expositions-1959 98 5 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 98 6 of of ADP expositions-1959 98 7 course course NOUN expositions-1959 98 8 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 98 9 it it PRON expositions-1959 98 10 is be AUX expositions-1959 98 11 wildly wildly ADV expositions-1959 98 12 off off ADP expositions-1959 98 13 the the DET expositions-1959 98 14 mark mark NOUN expositions-1959 98 15 . . PUNCT expositions-1959 99 1 metz metz PROPN expositions-1959 99 2 ’s ’s PART expositions-1959 99 3 view view NOUN expositions-1959 99 4 seems seem VERB expositions-1959 99 5 to to PART expositions-1959 99 6 imply imply VERB expositions-1959 99 7 ( ( PUNCT expositions-1959 99 8 for for ADP expositions-1959 99 9 example example NOUN expositions-1959 99 10 ) ) PUNCT expositions-1959 99 11 that that SCONJ expositions-1959 99 12 babies baby NOUN expositions-1959 99 13 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 99 14 the the DET expositions-1959 99 15 severely severely ADV expositions-1959 99 16 mentally mentally ADV expositions-1959 99 17 challenged challenge VERB expositions-1959 99 18 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 99 19 and and CCONJ expositions-1959 99 20 people people NOUN expositions-1959 99 21 with with ADP expositions-1959 99 22 alzheimer alzheimer PROPN expositions-1959 99 23 ’s ’s PART expositions-1959 99 24 do do AUX expositions-1959 99 25 not not PART expositions-1959 99 26 live live VERB expositions-1959 99 27 meaningful meaningful ADJ expositions-1959 99 28 lives life NOUN expositions-1959 99 29 ( ( PUNCT expositions-1959 99 30 or or CCONJ expositions-1959 99 31 live live VERB expositions-1959 99 32 only only ADV expositions-1959 99 33 minimally minimally ADV expositions-1959 99 34 meaningful meaningful ADJ expositions-1959 99 35 lives life NOUN expositions-1959 99 36 ) ) PUNCT expositions-1959 99 37 because because SCONJ expositions-1959 99 38 they they PRON expositions-1959 99 39 can can AUX expositions-1959 99 40 not not PART expositions-1959 99 41 actively actively ADV expositions-1959 99 42 use use VERB expositions-1959 99 43 their their PRON expositions-1959 99 44 reason reason NOUN expositions-1959 99 45 to to PART expositions-1959 99 46 perform perform VERB expositions-1959 99 47 acts act NOUN expositions-1959 99 48 of of ADP expositions-1959 99 49 moral moral ADJ expositions-1959 99 50 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 99 51 intellectual intellectual ADJ expositions-1959 99 52 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 99 53 or or CCONJ expositions-1959 99 54 artistic artistic ADJ expositions-1959 99 55 significance significance NOUN expositions-1959 99 56 . . PUNCT expositions-1959 100 1 it it PRON expositions-1959 100 2 is be AUX expositions-1959 100 3 true true ADJ expositions-1959 100 4 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 100 5 of of ADP expositions-1959 100 6 course course NOUN expositions-1959 100 7 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 100 8 that that SCONJ expositions-1959 100 9 they they PRON expositions-1959 100 10 can can AUX expositions-1959 100 11 not not PART expositions-1959 100 12 perform perform VERB expositions-1959 100 13 such such ADJ expositions-1959 100 14 acts act NOUN expositions-1959 100 15 in in ADP expositions-1959 100 16 this this DET expositions-1959 100 17 life life NOUN expositions-1959 100 18 . . PUNCT expositions-1959 101 1 but but CCONJ expositions-1959 101 2 according accord VERB expositions-1959 101 3 to to ADP expositions-1959 101 4 classical classical ADJ expositions-1959 101 5 theism theism NOUN expositions-1959 101 6 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 101 7 this this DET expositions-1959 101 8 life life NOUN expositions-1959 101 9 is be AUX expositions-1959 101 10 tiny tiny ADJ expositions-1959 101 11 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 101 12 infinitesimal infinitesimal ADJ expositions-1959 101 13 fraction fraction NOUN expositions-1959 101 14 of of ADP expositions-1959 101 15 the the DET expositions-1959 101 16 actual actual ADJ expositions-1959 101 17 lives life NOUN expositions-1959 101 18 of of ADP expositions-1959 101 19 such such ADJ expositions-1959 101 20 persons person NOUN expositions-1959 101 21 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 101 22 all all PRON expositions-1959 101 23 of of ADP expositions-1959 101 24 whom whom PRON expositions-1959 101 25 may may AUX expositions-1959 101 26 be be AUX expositions-1959 101 27 destined destine VERB expositions-1959 101 28 to to ADP expositions-1959 101 29 lives life NOUN expositions-1959 101 30 of of ADP expositions-1959 101 31 eternal eternal ADJ expositions-1959 101 32 significance significance NOUN expositions-1959 101 33 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 101 34 value value NOUN expositions-1959 101 35 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 101 36 and and CCONJ expositions-1959 101 37 purpose purpose NOUN expositions-1959 101 38 in in ADP expositions-1959 101 39 the the DET expositions-1959 101 40 hereafter hereafter NOUN expositions-1959 101 41 . . PUNCT expositions-1959 102 1 moreover moreover ADV expositions-1959 102 2 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 102 3 according accord VERB expositions-1959 102 4 to to ADP expositions-1959 102 5 one one NUM expositions-1959 102 6 widely widely ADV expositions-1959 102 7 held hold VERB expositions-1959 102 8 version version NOUN expositions-1959 102 9 of of ADP expositions-1959 102 10 theism theism NOUN expositions-1959 102 11 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 102 12 every every DET expositions-1959 102 13 human human ADJ expositions-1959 102 14 life life NOUN expositions-1959 102 15 has have VERB expositions-1959 102 16 meaning meaning NOUN expositions-1959 102 17 — — PUNCT expositions-1959 102 18 and and CCONJ expositions-1959 102 19 in in ADP expositions-1959 102 20 fact fact NOUN expositions-1959 102 21 transcendent transcendent NOUN expositions-1959 102 22 meaning meaning NOUN expositions-1959 102 23 and and CCONJ expositions-1959 102 24 value value NOUN expositions-1959 102 25 — — PUNCT expositions-1959 102 26 because because SCONJ expositions-1959 102 27 all all DET expositions-1959 102 28 human human ADJ expositions-1959 102 29 persons person NOUN expositions-1959 102 30 are be AUX expositions-1959 102 31 created create VERB expositions-1959 102 32 in in ADP expositions-1959 102 33 the the DET expositions-1959 102 34 image image NOUN expositions-1959 102 35 of of ADP expositions-1959 102 36 god god PROPN expositions-1959 102 37 and and CCONJ expositions-1959 102 38 thereby thereby ADV expositions-1959 102 39 possess possess VERB expositions-1959 102 40 equal equal ADJ expositions-1959 102 41 inherent inherent ADJ expositions-1959 102 42 worth worth NOUN expositions-1959 102 43 and and CCONJ expositions-1959 102 44 dignity dignity NOUN expositions-1959 102 45 . . PUNCT expositions-1959 103 1 furthermore furthermore ADV expositions-1959 103 2 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 103 3 on on ADP expositions-1959 103 4 a a DET expositions-1959 103 5 theistic theistic ADJ expositions-1959 103 6 view view NOUN expositions-1959 103 7 the the DET expositions-1959 103 8 value value NOUN expositions-1959 103 9 or or CCONJ expositions-1959 103 10 147 147 NUM expositions-1959 103 11 bassham bassham NOUN expositions-1959 103 12             SPACE expositions-1959 103 13 meaning meaning NOUN expositions-1959 103 14 of of ADP expositions-1959 103 15 a a DET expositions-1959 103 16 human human ADJ expositions-1959 103 17 life life NOUN expositions-1959 103 18 can can AUX expositions-1959 103 19 not not PART expositions-1959 103 20 be be AUX expositions-1959 103 21 measured measure VERB expositions-1959 103 22 by by ADP expositions-1959 103 23 actual actual ADJ expositions-1959 103 24 achievement achievement NOUN expositions-1959 103 25 or or CCONJ expositions-1959 103 26 worldly worldly ADJ expositions-1959 103 27 “ " PUNCT expositions-1959 103 28 significance significance NOUN expositions-1959 103 29 ” " PUNCT expositions-1959 103 30 or or CCONJ expositions-1959 103 31 “ " PUNCT expositions-1959 103 32 importance importance NOUN expositions-1959 103 33 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 103 34 ” " PUNCT expositions-1959 103 35 for for ADP expositions-1959 103 36 these these PRON expositions-1959 103 37 are be AUX expositions-1959 103 38 all all PRON expositions-1959 103 39 partly partly ADV expositions-1959 103 40 matters matter NOUN expositions-1959 103 41 of of ADP expositions-1959 103 42 luck luck NOUN expositions-1959 103 43 and and CCONJ expositions-1959 103 44 all all DET expositions-1959 103 45 human human ADJ expositions-1959 103 46 achievements achievement NOUN expositions-1959 103 47 are be AUX expositions-1959 103 48 smoke smoke NOUN expositions-1959 103 49 and and CCONJ expositions-1959 103 50 “ " PUNCT expositions-1959 103 51 vanity vanity NOUN expositions-1959 103 52 ” " PUNCT expositions-1959 103 53 from from ADP expositions-1959 103 54 what what PRON expositions-1959 103 55 sidgwick sidgwick PROPN expositions-1959 103 56 called call VERB expositions-1959 103 57 “ " PUNCT expositions-1959 103 58 the the DET expositions-1959 103 59 point point NOUN expositions-1959 103 60 of of ADP expositions-1959 103 61 view view NOUN expositions-1959 103 62 of of ADP expositions-1959 103 63 the the DET expositions-1959 103 64 universe universe NOUN expositions-1959 103 65 . . PUNCT expositions-1959 103 66 ”5 ”5 PUNCT expositions-1959 104 1 the the DET expositions-1959 104 2 christian christian ADJ expositions-1959 104 3 view view NOUN expositions-1959 104 4 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 104 5 rather rather ADV expositions-1959 104 6 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 104 7 is be AUX expositions-1959 104 8 that that PRON expositions-1959 104 9 of of ADP expositions-1959 104 10 milton milton PROPN expositions-1959 104 11 : : PUNCT expositions-1959 104 12 “ " PUNCT expositions-1959 104 13 they they PRON expositions-1959 104 14 also also ADV expositions-1959 104 15 serve serve VERB expositions-1959 104 16 who who PRON expositions-1959 104 17 only only ADV expositions-1959 104 18 stand stand VERB expositions-1959 104 19 and and CCONJ expositions-1959 104 20 wait wait VERB expositions-1959 104 21 . . PUNCT expositions-1959 104 22 ”6 ”6 NOUN expositions-1959 104 23 and and CCONJ expositions-1959 104 24 the the DET expositions-1959 104 25 christian christian ADJ expositions-1959 104 26 view view NOUN expositions-1959 104 27 is be AUX expositions-1959 104 28 also also ADV expositions-1959 104 29 that that PRON expositions-1959 104 30 of of ADP expositions-1959 104 31 mother mother NOUN expositions-1959 104 32 teresa teresa PROPN expositions-1959 104 33 : : PUNCT expositions-1959 104 34 some some PRON expositions-1959 104 35 are be AUX expositions-1959 104 36 called call VERB expositions-1959 104 37 merely merely ADV expositions-1959 104 38 “ " PUNCT expositions-1959 104 39 to to PART expositions-1959 104 40 be be AUX expositions-1959 104 41 faithful faithful ADJ expositions-1959 104 42 . . PUNCT expositions-1959 104 43 ”7 ”7 PUNCT expositions-1959 105 1 gregory gregory PROPN expositions-1959 105 2 bassham bassham PROPN expositions-1959 105 3 king king PROPN expositions-1959 105 4 ’s ’s PART expositions-1959 105 5 college college PROPN expositions-1959 105 6 ( ( PUNCT expositions-1959 105 7 pa pa PROPN expositions-1959 105 8 ) ) PUNCT expositions-1959 105 9 notes note VERB expositions-1959 105 10 1 1 NUM expositions-1959 105 11 . . PUNCT expositions-1959 105 12 nozick nozick PROPN expositions-1959 105 13 1974 1974 NUM expositions-1959 105 14 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 105 15 42–45 42–45 NUM expositions-1959 105 16 . . NOUN expositions-1959 106 1 2 2 NUM expositions-1959 106 2 . . X expositions-1959 106 3 taylor taylor PROPN expositions-1959 106 4 2000 2000 NUM expositions-1959 106 5 . . PUNCT expositions-1959 107 1 3 3 X expositions-1959 107 2 . . X expositions-1959 107 3 morris morris PROPN expositions-1959 107 4 1999 1999 NUM expositions-1959 107 5 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 107 6 284–85 284–85 NUM expositions-1959 107 7 . . X expositions-1959 108 1 4 4 X expositions-1959 108 2 . . X expositions-1959 108 3 see see AUX expositions-1959 108 4 generally generally ADV expositions-1959 108 5 morris morris PROPN expositions-1959 108 6 1991 1991 NUM expositions-1959 108 7 . . PUNCT expositions-1959 109 1 5 5 NUM expositions-1959 109 2 . . X expositions-1959 109 3 sidgwick sidgwick PROPN expositions-1959 109 4 1907 1907 NUM expositions-1959 109 5 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 109 6 382 382 NUM expositions-1959 109 7 . . NOUN expositions-1959 110 1 6 6 NUM expositions-1959 110 2 . . X expositions-1959 110 3 milton milton PROPN expositions-1959 110 4 1963 1963 NUM expositions-1959 110 5 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 110 6 line line NOUN expositions-1959 110 7 14 14 NUM expositions-1959 110 8 . . PUNCT expositions-1959 110 9 7 7 X expositions-1959 110 10 . . PUNCT expositions-1959 110 11 chawla chawla PROPN expositions-1959 110 12 2008 2008 NUM expositions-1959 110 13 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 110 14 xxv xxv PROPN expositions-1959 110 15 . . PROPN expositions-1959 111 1 works works PROPN expositions-1959 111 2 cited cite VERB expositions-1959 111 3 chawla chawla PROPN expositions-1959 111 4 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 111 5 navin navin PROPN expositions-1959 111 6 . . PROPN expositions-1959 111 7 2008 2008 NUM expositions-1959 111 8 . . PUNCT expositions-1959 112 1 mother mother NOUN expositions-1959 112 2 teresa teresa PROPN expositions-1959 112 3 : : PUNCT expositions-1959 112 4 the the DET expositions-1959 112 5 centenary centenary ADJ expositions-1959 112 6 edition edition NOUN expositions-1959 112 7 . . PUNCT expositions-1959 113 1 new new PROPN expositions-1959 113 2 york york PROPN expositions-1959 113 3 : : PUNCT expositions-1959 113 4 penguin penguin PROPN expositions-1959 113 5 . . PUNCT expositions-1959 114 1 milton milton PROPN expositions-1959 114 2 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 114 3 john john PROPN expositions-1959 114 4 . . PROPN expositions-1959 114 5 1963 1963 NUM expositions-1959 114 6 . . PUNCT expositions-1959 115 1 “ " PUNCT expositions-1959 115 2 sonnet sonnet NOUN expositions-1959 115 3 19 19 NUM expositions-1959 115 4 . . PUNCT expositions-1959 115 5 ” " PUNCT expositions-1959 116 1 in in ADP expositions-1959 116 2 the the DET expositions-1959 116 3 complete complete ADJ expositions-1959 116 4 poetry poetry NOUN expositions-1959 116 5 . . PUNCT expositions-1959 117 1 ed ed NOUN expositions-1959 117 2 . . PUNCT expositions-1959 118 1 john john PROPN expositions-1959 118 2 t. t. PROPN expositions-1959 118 3 shawcross shawcross PROPN expositions-1959 118 4 . . PUNCT expositions-1959 119 1 new new PROPN expositions-1959 119 2 york york PROPN expositions-1959 119 3 : : PUNCT expositions-1959 119 4 anchor anchor PROPN expositions-1959 119 5 doubleday doubleday PROPN expositions-1959 119 6 . . PUNCT expositions-1959 120 1 242–243 242–243 NUM expositions-1959 120 2 . . PUNCT expositions-1959 120 3 morris morris PROPN expositions-1959 120 4 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 120 5 thomas thomas PROPN expositions-1959 120 6 v. v. ADP expositions-1959 120 7 1991 1991 NUM expositions-1959 120 8 . . PUNCT expositions-1959 121 1 our our PRON expositions-1959 121 2 idea idea NOUN expositions-1959 121 3 of of ADP expositions-1959 121 4 god god PROPN expositions-1959 121 5 : : PUNCT expositions-1959 121 6 an an DET expositions-1959 121 7 introduction introduction NOUN expositions-1959 121 8 to to ADP expositions-1959 121 9 philosophical philosophical ADJ expositions-1959 121 10 theology theology NOUN expositions-1959 121 11 . . PUNCT expositions-1959 122 1 downers downers PROPN expositions-1959 122 2 grove grove PROPN expositions-1959 122 3 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 122 4 il il PROPN expositions-1959 122 5 : : PUNCT expositions-1959 122 6 intervarsity intervarsity NOUN expositions-1959 122 7 press press NOUN expositions-1959 122 8 . . PUNCT expositions-1959 123 1 _ _ PUNCT expositions-1959 124 1 _ _ PUNCT expositions-1959 125 1 _ _ PUNCT expositions-1959 126 1 _ _ PUNCT expositions-1959 127 1 _ _ PUNCT expositions-1959 127 2 . . PUNCT expositions-1959 128 1 1999 1999 NUM expositions-1959 128 2 . . PUNCT expositions-1959 129 1 philosophy philosophy NOUN expositions-1959 129 2 for for ADP expositions-1959 129 3 dummies dummy NOUN expositions-1959 129 4 . . PUNCT expositions-1959 130 1 foster foster PROPN expositions-1959 130 2 city city PROPN expositions-1959 130 3 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 130 4 ca ca PROPN expositions-1959 130 5 : : PUNCT expositions-1959 130 6 idg idg PROPN expositions-1959 130 7 books book NOUN expositions-1959 130 8 . . PUNCT expositions-1959 131 1 nozick nozick ADJ expositions-1959 131 2 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 131 3 robert robert PROPN expositions-1959 131 4 . . PROPN expositions-1959 131 5 1974 1974 NUM expositions-1959 131 6 . . PUNCT expositions-1959 132 1 anarchy anarchy NOUN expositions-1959 132 2 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 132 3 state state NOUN expositions-1959 132 4 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 132 5 and and CCONJ expositions-1959 132 6 utopia utopia NOUN expositions-1959 132 7 . . PUNCT expositions-1959 133 1 new new PROPN expositions-1959 133 2 york york PROPN expositions-1959 133 3 : : PUNCT expositions-1959 133 4 basic basic ADJ expositions-1959 133 5 books book NOUN expositions-1959 133 6 . . PUNCT expositions-1959 134 1 review review NOUN expositions-1959 134 2 of of ADP expositions-1959 134 3 meaning meaning NOUN expositions-1959 134 4 in in ADP expositions-1959 134 5 life life NOUN expositions-1959 134 6 148 148 NUM expositions-1959 134 7     SPACE expositions-1959 134 8 sidgwick sidgwick PROPN expositions-1959 134 9 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 134 10 henry henry PROPN expositions-1959 134 11 . . PUNCT expositions-1959 135 1 1907 1907 NUM expositions-1959 135 2 . . PUNCT expositions-1959 136 1 the the DET expositions-1959 136 2 methods method NOUN expositions-1959 136 3 of of ADP expositions-1959 136 4 ethics ethic NOUN expositions-1959 136 5 . . PUNCT expositions-1959 137 1 7th 7th ADJ expositions-1959 137 2 ed ed NOUN expositions-1959 137 3 . . PUNCT expositions-1959 138 1 new new PROPN expositions-1959 138 2 york york PROPN expositions-1959 138 3 : : PUNCT expositions-1959 139 1 macmillan macmillan PROPN expositions-1959 139 2 . . PROPN expositions-1959 139 3 taylor taylor PROPN expositions-1959 139 4 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 139 5 richard richard PROPN expositions-1959 139 6 . . PROPN expositions-1959 139 7 2000 2000 NUM expositions-1959 139 8 . . PUNCT expositions-1959 140 1 “ " PUNCT expositions-1959 140 2 the the DET expositions-1959 140 3 meaning meaning NOUN expositions-1959 140 4 of of ADP expositions-1959 140 5 life life NOUN expositions-1959 140 6 . . PUNCT expositions-1959 140 7 ” " PUNCT expositions-1959 141 1 in in ADP expositions-1959 141 2 good good ADJ expositions-1959 141 3 and and CCONJ expositions-1959 141 4 evil evil NOUN expositions-1959 141 5 . . PUNCT expositions-1959 142 1 amherst amherst PROPN expositions-1959 142 2 , , PUNCT expositions-1959 142 3 ny ny PROPN expositions-1959 142 4 : : PUNCT expositions-1959 142 5 prometheus prometheus NOUN expositions-1959 142 6 books book NOUN expositions-1959 142 7 . . PUNCT expositions-1959 143 1 319–334 319–334 NUM expositions-1959 143 2 . . PUNCT