id sid tid token lemma pos expositions-2352 1 1 microsoft microsoft PROPN expositions-2352 1 2 word word NOUN expositions-2352 1 3 2 2 NUM expositions-2352 1 4 taliaferro.docx taliaferro.docx NOUN expositions-2352 2 1 [ [ X expositions-2352 2 2 expositions exposition NOUN expositions-2352 2 3 12.2 12.2 NUM expositions-2352 2 4 ( ( PUNCT expositions-2352 2 5 2018 2018 NUM expositions-2352 2 6 ) ) PUNCT expositions-2352 2 7 15–26 15–26 NUM expositions-2352 2 8 ] ] PUNCT expositions-2352 2 9 expositions exposition NOUN expositions-2352 2 10 ( ( PUNCT expositions-2352 2 11 online online ADV expositions-2352 2 12 ) ) PUNCT expositions-2352 2 13 issn issn PROPN expositions-2352 2 14 : : PUNCT expositions-2352 2 15 1747–5376 1747–5376 NOUN expositions-2352 2 16     SPACE expositions-2352 2 17 less less ADV expositions-2352 2 18 manifesto manifesto NOUN expositions-2352 2 19 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 2 20 more more ADJ expositions-2352 2 21 philosophy philosophy NOUN expositions-2352 2 22 karen karen PROPN expositions-2352 2 23 taliaferro taliaferro PROPN expositions-2352 2 24 arizona arizona PROPN expositions-2352 2 25 state state PROPN expositions-2352 2 26 university university PROPN expositions-2352 2 27 why why SCONJ expositions-2352 2 28 should should AUX expositions-2352 2 29 american american ADJ expositions-2352 2 30 philosophy philosophy NOUN expositions-2352 2 31 departments department NOUN expositions-2352 2 32 assign assign VERB expositions-2352 2 33 non non ADJ expositions-2352 2 34 - - ADJ expositions-2352 2 35 western western ADJ expositions-2352 2 36 philosophers philosopher NOUN expositions-2352 2 37 ? ? PUNCT expositions-2352 3 1 there there PRON expositions-2352 3 2 are be VERB expositions-2352 3 3 at at ADV expositions-2352 3 4 least least ADJ expositions-2352 3 5 two two NUM expositions-2352 3 6 justifications justification NOUN expositions-2352 3 7 for for ADP expositions-2352 3 8 doing do VERB expositions-2352 3 9 so so ADV expositions-2352 3 10 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 4 1 the the DET expositions-2352 4 2 first first ADJ expositions-2352 4 3 revolves revolve NOUN expositions-2352 4 4 around around ADP expositions-2352 4 5 diversity diversity NOUN expositions-2352 4 6 : : PUNCT expositions-2352 4 7 one one PRON expositions-2352 4 8 might might AUX expositions-2352 4 9 argue argue VERB expositions-2352 4 10 that that SCONJ expositions-2352 4 11 assigning assign VERB expositions-2352 4 12 non non ADJ expositions-2352 4 13 - - ADJ expositions-2352 4 14 western western ADJ expositions-2352 4 15 philosophy philosophy NOUN expositions-2352 4 16 can can AUX expositions-2352 4 17 serve serve VERB expositions-2352 4 18 as as ADP expositions-2352 4 19 an an DET expositions-2352 4 20 antidote antidote NOUN expositions-2352 4 21 to to ADP expositions-2352 4 22 white white ADJ expositions-2352 4 23 privilege privilege NOUN expositions-2352 4 24 or or CCONJ expositions-2352 4 25 as as ADP expositions-2352 4 26 a a DET expositions-2352 4 27 necessary necessary ADJ expositions-2352 4 28 adjustment adjustment NOUN expositions-2352 4 29 to to ADP expositions-2352 4 30 changing change VERB expositions-2352 4 31 demographics demographic NOUN expositions-2352 4 32 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 4 33 an an DET expositions-2352 4 34 increasingly increasingly ADV expositions-2352 4 35 globalized globalize VERB expositions-2352 4 36 world world NOUN expositions-2352 4 37 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 5 1 another another DET expositions-2352 5 2 argument argument NOUN expositions-2352 5 3 could could AUX expositions-2352 5 4 begin begin VERB expositions-2352 5 5 from from ADP expositions-2352 5 6 the the DET expositions-2352 5 7 nature nature NOUN expositions-2352 5 8 of of ADP expositions-2352 5 9 philosophy philosophy NOUN expositions-2352 5 10 itself itself PRON expositions-2352 5 11 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 6 1 partisans partisan NOUN expositions-2352 6 2 of of ADP expositions-2352 6 3 this this DET expositions-2352 6 4 angle angle NOUN expositions-2352 6 5 might might AUX expositions-2352 6 6 suggest suggest VERB expositions-2352 6 7 that that SCONJ expositions-2352 6 8 the the DET expositions-2352 6 9 finitude finitude NOUN expositions-2352 6 10 of of ADP expositions-2352 6 11 the the DET expositions-2352 6 12 human human ADJ expositions-2352 6 13 mind mind NOUN expositions-2352 6 14 requires require VERB expositions-2352 6 15 that that SCONJ expositions-2352 6 16 we we PRON expositions-2352 6 17 examine examine VERB expositions-2352 6 18 sources source NOUN expositions-2352 6 19 from from ADP expositions-2352 6 20 not not PART expositions-2352 6 21 only only ADV expositions-2352 6 22 across across ADP expositions-2352 6 23 time time NOUN expositions-2352 6 24 but but CCONJ expositions-2352 6 25 also also ADV expositions-2352 6 26 across across ADP expositions-2352 6 27 space space NOUN expositions-2352 6 28 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 6 29 cultures culture NOUN expositions-2352 6 30 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 7 1 the the DET expositions-2352 7 2 love love NOUN expositions-2352 7 3 of of ADP expositions-2352 7 4 wisdom wisdom NOUN expositions-2352 7 5 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 7 6 in in ADP expositions-2352 7 7 other other ADJ expositions-2352 7 8 words word NOUN expositions-2352 7 9 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 7 10 requires require VERB expositions-2352 7 11 that that SCONJ expositions-2352 7 12 we we PRON expositions-2352 7 13 cast cast VERB expositions-2352 7 14 a a DET expositions-2352 7 15 wide wide ADJ expositions-2352 7 16 literary literary ADJ expositions-2352 7 17 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 7 18 cultural cultural ADJ expositions-2352 7 19 net net NOUN expositions-2352 7 20 in in ADP expositions-2352 7 21 order order NOUN expositions-2352 7 22 to to PART expositions-2352 7 23 attain attain VERB expositions-2352 7 24 our our PRON expositions-2352 7 25 goal goal NOUN expositions-2352 7 26 ; ; PUNCT expositions-2352 7 27 truth truth NOUN expositions-2352 7 28 is be AUX expositions-2352 7 29 not not PART expositions-2352 7 30 the the DET expositions-2352 7 31 purview purview NOUN expositions-2352 7 32 of of ADP expositions-2352 7 33 one one NUM expositions-2352 7 34 civilization civilization NOUN expositions-2352 7 35 or or CCONJ expositions-2352 7 36 heritage heritage NOUN expositions-2352 7 37 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 8 1 bryan bryan PROPN expositions-2352 8 2 w. w. PROPN expositions-2352 8 3 van van PROPN expositions-2352 8 4 norden norden PROPN expositions-2352 8 5 ’s ’s PART expositions-2352 8 6 taking take VERB expositions-2352 8 7 back back ADP expositions-2352 8 8 philosophy philosophy NOUN expositions-2352 8 9 : : PUNCT expositions-2352 8 10 a a DET expositions-2352 8 11 multicultural multicultural ADJ expositions-2352 8 12 manifesto manifesto NOUN expositions-2352 8 13 primarily primarily ADV expositions-2352 8 14 argues argue VERB expositions-2352 8 15 from from ADP expositions-2352 8 16 the the DET expositions-2352 8 17 first first ADJ expositions-2352 8 18 angle angle NOUN expositions-2352 8 19 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 8 20 suggesting suggest VERB expositions-2352 8 21 that that SCONJ expositions-2352 8 22 the the DET expositions-2352 8 23 primary primary ADJ expositions-2352 8 24 problems problem NOUN expositions-2352 8 25 with with ADP expositions-2352 8 26 those those DET expositions-2352 8 27 philosophers philosopher NOUN expositions-2352 8 28 ( ( PUNCT expositions-2352 8 29 as as ADV expositions-2352 8 30 well well ADV expositions-2352 8 31 as as ADP expositions-2352 8 32 politicians politician NOUN expositions-2352 8 33 ) ) PUNCT expositions-2352 8 34 who who PRON expositions-2352 8 35 close close VERB expositions-2352 8 36 themselves themselves PRON expositions-2352 8 37 off off ADP expositions-2352 8 38 from from ADP expositions-2352 8 39 non non ADJ expositions-2352 8 40 - - ADJ expositions-2352 8 41 western western ADJ expositions-2352 8 42 sources source NOUN expositions-2352 8 43 of of ADP expositions-2352 8 44 wisdom wisdom NOUN expositions-2352 8 45 are be AUX expositions-2352 8 46 their their PRON expositions-2352 8 47 presumed presume VERB expositions-2352 8 48 racism racism NOUN expositions-2352 8 49 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 8 50 chauvinism chauvinism NOUN expositions-2352 8 51 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 8 52 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 8 53 general general ADJ expositions-2352 8 54 closed close VERB expositions-2352 8 55 - - PUNCT expositions-2352 8 56 mindedness mindedness NOUN expositions-2352 8 57 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 9 1 at at ADP expositions-2352 9 2 the the DET expositions-2352 9 3 same same ADJ expositions-2352 9 4 time time NOUN expositions-2352 9 5 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 9 6 however however ADV expositions-2352 9 7 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 9 8 his his PRON expositions-2352 9 9 book book NOUN expositions-2352 9 10 provides provide VERB expositions-2352 9 11 an an DET expositions-2352 9 12 exploration exploration NOUN expositions-2352 9 13 of of ADP expositions-2352 9 14 such such ADJ expositions-2352 9 15 timeless timeless ADJ expositions-2352 9 16 questions question NOUN expositions-2352 9 17 as as ADP expositions-2352 9 18 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 9 19 what what PRON expositions-2352 9 20 is be AUX expositions-2352 9 21 philosophy philosophy NOUN expositions-2352 9 22 ? ? PUNCT expositions-2352 10 1 where where SCONJ expositions-2352 10 2 can can AUX expositions-2352 10 3 we we PRON expositions-2352 10 4 seek seek VERB expositions-2352 10 5 wisdom wisdom NOUN expositions-2352 10 6 ? ? PUNCT expositions-2352 11 1 how how SCONJ expositions-2352 11 2 do do AUX expositions-2352 11 3 we we PRON expositions-2352 11 4 read read VERB expositions-2352 11 5 a a DET expositions-2352 11 6 tradition tradition NOUN expositions-2352 11 7 ? ? PUNCT expositions-2352 12 1 in in ADP expositions-2352 12 2 so so ADV expositions-2352 12 3 doing do VERB expositions-2352 12 4 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 12 5 it it PRON expositions-2352 12 6 suggests suggest VERB expositions-2352 12 7 — — PUNCT expositions-2352 12 8 albeit albeit SCONJ expositions-2352 12 9 in in ADP expositions-2352 12 10 a a DET expositions-2352 12 11 quieter quieter ADJ expositions-2352 12 12 way way NOUN expositions-2352 12 13 than than ADP expositions-2352 12 14 his his PRON expositions-2352 12 15 explicit explicit ADJ expositions-2352 12 16 “ " PUNCT expositions-2352 12 17 manifesto manifesto NOUN expositions-2352 12 18 ” " PUNCT expositions-2352 12 19 against against ADP expositions-2352 12 20 white white ADJ expositions-2352 12 21 privileged privileged ADJ expositions-2352 12 22 faculty faculty NOUN expositions-2352 12 23 lounges lounge NOUN expositions-2352 12 24 — — PUNCT expositions-2352 12 25 that that SCONJ expositions-2352 12 26 those those PRON expositions-2352 12 27 who who PRON expositions-2352 12 28 love love VERB expositions-2352 12 29 wisdom wisdom NOUN expositions-2352 12 30 must must AUX expositions-2352 12 31 also also ADV expositions-2352 12 32 look look VERB expositions-2352 12 33 beyond beyond ADP expositions-2352 12 34 their their PRON expositions-2352 12 35 own own ADJ expositions-2352 12 36 city city NOUN expositions-2352 12 37 walls wall NOUN expositions-2352 12 38 to to PART expositions-2352 12 39 find find VERB expositions-2352 12 40 it it PRON expositions-2352 12 41 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 13 1 the the DET expositions-2352 13 2 book book NOUN expositions-2352 13 3 ’s ’s PART expositions-2352 13 4 five five NUM expositions-2352 13 5 relatively relatively ADV expositions-2352 13 6 brief brief ADJ expositions-2352 13 7 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 13 8 eminently eminently ADV expositions-2352 13 9 readable readable ADJ expositions-2352 13 10 chapters chapter NOUN expositions-2352 13 11 detail detail NOUN expositions-2352 13 12 van van PROPN expositions-2352 13 13 norden norden PROPN expositions-2352 13 14 ’s ’s PART expositions-2352 13 15 critiques critique NOUN expositions-2352 13 16 of of ADP expositions-2352 13 17 american american ADJ expositions-2352 13 18 universities university NOUN expositions-2352 13 19 ’ ' PUNCT expositions-2352 13 20 nearly nearly ADV expositions-2352 13 21 universal universal ADJ expositions-2352 13 22 tendency tendency NOUN expositions-2352 13 23 to to PART expositions-2352 13 24 ignore ignore VERB expositions-2352 13 25 or or CCONJ expositions-2352 13 26 outright outright ADJ expositions-2352 13 27 reject reject VERB expositions-2352 13 28 non non ADJ expositions-2352 13 29 - - ADJ expositions-2352 13 30 western western ADJ expositions-2352 13 31 philosophy philosophy NOUN expositions-2352 13 32 as as ADP expositions-2352 13 33 worthy worthy ADJ expositions-2352 13 34 of of ADP expositions-2352 13 35 the the DET expositions-2352 13 36 moniker moniker NOUN expositions-2352 13 37 “ " PUNCT expositions-2352 13 38 philosophy philosophy NOUN expositions-2352 13 39 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 13 40 ” " PUNCT expositions-2352 13 41 thereby thereby ADV expositions-2352 13 42 excluding exclude VERB expositions-2352 13 43 such such ADJ expositions-2352 13 44 sources source NOUN expositions-2352 13 45 from from ADP expositions-2352 13 46 their their PRON expositions-2352 13 47 departmental departmental ADJ expositions-2352 13 48 course course NOUN expositions-2352 13 49 catalogues catalogue NOUN expositions-2352 13 50 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 14 1 but but CCONJ expositions-2352 14 2 van van PROPN expositions-2352 14 3 norden norden PROPN expositions-2352 14 4 also also ADV expositions-2352 14 5 tackles tackle VERB expositions-2352 14 6 what what PRON expositions-2352 14 7 he he PRON expositions-2352 14 8 sees see VERB expositions-2352 14 9 as as ADP expositions-2352 14 10 trends trend NOUN expositions-2352 14 11 in in ADP expositions-2352 14 12 contemporary contemporary ADJ expositions-2352 14 13 public public ADJ expositions-2352 14 14 discourse discourse NOUN expositions-2352 14 15 — — PUNCT expositions-2352 14 16 particularly particularly ADV expositions-2352 14 17 right right ADJ expositions-2352 14 18 - - PUNCT expositions-2352 14 19 wing wing NOUN expositions-2352 14 20 political political ADJ expositions-2352 14 21 discourse discourse NOUN expositions-2352 14 22 — — PUNCT expositions-2352 14 23 to to PART expositions-2352 14 24 denigrate denigrate VERB expositions-2352 14 25 multiculturalism multiculturalism NOUN expositions-2352 14 26 ( ( PUNCT expositions-2352 14 27 chapter chapter NOUN expositions-2352 14 28 3 3 NUM expositions-2352 14 29 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 14 30 “ " PUNCT expositions-2352 14 31 trump trump VERB expositions-2352 14 32 ’s ’s PART expositions-2352 14 33 philosophers philosopher NOUN expositions-2352 14 34 ” " PUNCT expositions-2352 14 35 ) ) PUNCT expositions-2352 14 36 as as ADV expositions-2352 14 37 well well ADV expositions-2352 14 38 as as ADP expositions-2352 14 39 philosophical philosophical ADJ expositions-2352 14 40 study study NOUN expositions-2352 14 41 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 14 42 thought think VERB expositions-2352 14 43 in in ADP expositions-2352 14 44 general general ADJ expositions-2352 14 45 ( ( PUNCT expositions-2352 14 46 chapter chapter NOUN expositions-2352 14 47 4 4 NUM expositions-2352 14 48 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 14 49 “ " PUNCT expositions-2352 14 50 welders welder NOUN expositions-2352 14 51 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 14 52 philosophers philosopher NOUN expositions-2352 14 53 ” " PUNCT expositions-2352 14 54 ) ) PUNCT expositions-2352 14 55 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 15 1 out out ADP expositions-2352 15 2 of of ADP expositions-2352 15 3 these these DET expositions-2352 15 4 combined combine VERB expositions-2352 15 5 critiques critique NOUN expositions-2352 15 6 emerges emerge VERB expositions-2352 15 7 a a DET expositions-2352 15 8 vision vision NOUN expositions-2352 15 9 for for ADP expositions-2352 15 10 a a DET expositions-2352 15 11 truly truly ADV expositions-2352 15 12 globalized globalize VERB expositions-2352 15 13 society society NOUN expositions-2352 15 14 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 15 15 academy academy NOUN expositions-2352 15 16 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 15 17 one one NOUN expositions-2352 15 18 that that PRON expositions-2352 15 19 heeds heed VERB expositions-2352 15 20 van van PROPN expositions-2352 15 21 norden norden PROPN expositions-2352 15 22 ’s ’s PART expositions-2352 15 23 call call NOUN expositions-2352 15 24 to to PART expositions-2352 15 25 “ " PUNCT expositions-2352 15 26 take take VERB expositions-2352 15 27 less less ADJ expositions-2352 15 28 manifesto manifesto NOUN expositions-2352 15 29 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 15 30 more more ADJ expositions-2352 15 31 philosophy philosophy NOUN expositions-2352 15 32 16 16 NUM expositions-2352 15 33         SPACE expositions-2352 15 34 inspiration inspiration NOUN expositions-2352 15 35 ” " PUNCT expositions-2352 15 36 from from ADP expositions-2352 15 37 the the DET expositions-2352 15 38 biblical biblical ADJ expositions-2352 15 39 narrative narrative NOUN expositions-2352 15 40 of of ADP expositions-2352 15 41 jericho jericho PROPN expositions-2352 15 42 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 15 43 in in ADP expositions-2352 15 44 which which PRON expositions-2352 15 45 the the DET expositions-2352 15 46 walls wall NOUN expositions-2352 15 47 dividing divide VERB expositions-2352 15 48 two two NUM expositions-2352 15 49 peoples people NOUN expositions-2352 15 50 miraculously miraculously ADV expositions-2352 15 51 fell fall VERB expositions-2352 15 52 down down ADP expositions-2352 15 53 ( ( PUNCT expositions-2352 15 54 108–109).1 108–109).1 NUM expositions-2352 15 55 of of ADP expositions-2352 15 56 course course NOUN expositions-2352 15 57 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 15 58 as as SCONJ expositions-2352 15 59 anyone anyone PRON expositions-2352 15 60 familiar familiar ADJ expositions-2352 15 61 with with ADP expositions-2352 15 62 the the DET expositions-2352 15 63 book book NOUN expositions-2352 15 64 of of ADP expositions-2352 15 65 joshua joshua PROPN expositions-2352 15 66 knows know VERB expositions-2352 15 67 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 15 68 the the DET expositions-2352 15 69 walls wall NOUN expositions-2352 15 70 of of ADP expositions-2352 15 71 jericho jericho PROPN expositions-2352 15 72 came came AUX expositions-2352 15 73 tumbling tumble VERB expositions-2352 15 74 down down ADP expositions-2352 15 75 so so SCONJ expositions-2352 15 76 that that SCONJ expositions-2352 15 77 the the DET expositions-2352 15 78 israelites israelites PROPN expositions-2352 15 79 could could AUX expositions-2352 15 80 defeat defeat VERB expositions-2352 15 81 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 15 82 not not PART expositions-2352 15 83 engage engage VERB expositions-2352 15 84 or or CCONJ expositions-2352 15 85 befriend befriend VERB expositions-2352 15 86 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 15 87 the the DET expositions-2352 15 88 canaanites canaanites PROPN expositions-2352 15 89 inside inside ADV expositions-2352 15 90 — — PUNCT expositions-2352 15 91 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 15 92 even even ADV expositions-2352 15 93 that that DET expositions-2352 15 94 sort sort NOUN expositions-2352 15 95 of of ADP expositions-2352 15 96 meeting meeting NOUN expositions-2352 15 97 of of ADP expositions-2352 15 98 civilizations civilization NOUN expositions-2352 15 99 required require VERB expositions-2352 15 100 divine divine ADJ expositions-2352 15 101 intervention intervention NOUN expositions-2352 15 102 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 16 1 this this PRON expositions-2352 16 2 is be AUX expositions-2352 16 3 hardly hardly ADV expositions-2352 16 4 a a DET expositions-2352 16 5 model model NOUN expositions-2352 16 6 for for ADP expositions-2352 16 7 multiculturalism multiculturalism NOUN expositions-2352 16 8 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 16 9 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 16 10 one one NUM expositions-2352 16 11 wonders wonder VERB expositions-2352 16 12 why why SCONJ expositions-2352 16 13 van van PROPN expositions-2352 16 14 norden norden PROPN expositions-2352 16 15 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 16 16 who who PRON expositions-2352 16 17 must must AUX expositions-2352 16 18 certainly certainly ADV expositions-2352 16 19 be be AUX expositions-2352 16 20 aware aware ADJ expositions-2352 16 21 of of ADP expositions-2352 16 22 the the DET expositions-2352 16 23 joshua joshua PROPN expositions-2352 16 24 narrative narrative NOUN expositions-2352 16 25 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 16 26 invoked invoke VERB expositions-2352 16 27 it it PRON expositions-2352 16 28 for for ADP expositions-2352 16 29 a a DET expositions-2352 16 30 multicultural multicultural ADJ expositions-2352 16 31 project project NOUN expositions-2352 16 32 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 17 1 perhaps perhaps ADV expositions-2352 17 2 it it PRON expositions-2352 17 3 is be AUX expositions-2352 17 4 a a DET expositions-2352 17 5 subtle subtle ADJ expositions-2352 17 6 hint hint NOUN expositions-2352 17 7 that that SCONJ expositions-2352 17 8 van van PROPN expositions-2352 17 9 norden norden PROPN expositions-2352 17 10 ’s ’s PART expositions-2352 17 11 vision vision NOUN expositions-2352 17 12 is be AUX expositions-2352 17 13 less less ADV expositions-2352 17 14 easily easily ADV expositions-2352 17 15 realized realize VERB expositions-2352 17 16 than than SCONJ expositions-2352 17 17 one one NUM expositions-2352 17 18 might might AUX expositions-2352 17 19 hope hope VERB expositions-2352 17 20 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 17 21 that that SCONJ expositions-2352 17 22 perhaps perhaps ADV expositions-2352 17 23 walls wall NOUN expositions-2352 17 24 do do AUX expositions-2352 17 25 not not PART expositions-2352 17 26 come come VERB expositions-2352 17 27 down down ADP expositions-2352 17 28 so so ADV expositions-2352 17 29 by by ADP expositions-2352 17 30 education education NOUN expositions-2352 17 31 alone alone ADV expositions-2352 17 32 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 18 1 indeed indeed ADV expositions-2352 18 2 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 18 3 in in ADP expositions-2352 18 4 his his PRON expositions-2352 18 5 attempt attempt NOUN expositions-2352 18 6 to to PART expositions-2352 18 7 tear tear VERB expositions-2352 18 8 down down ADP expositions-2352 18 9 the the DET expositions-2352 18 10 walls wall NOUN expositions-2352 18 11 that that PRON expositions-2352 18 12 divide divide VERB expositions-2352 18 13 cultures culture NOUN expositions-2352 18 14 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 18 15 van van PROPN expositions-2352 18 16 norden norden PROPN expositions-2352 18 17 himself himself PRON expositions-2352 18 18 retains retain VERB expositions-2352 18 19 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 18 20 even even ADV expositions-2352 18 21 fortifies fortify VERB expositions-2352 18 22 walls wall NOUN expositions-2352 18 23 that that PRON expositions-2352 18 24 exist exist VERB expositions-2352 18 25 within within ADP expositions-2352 18 26 american american ADJ expositions-2352 18 27 culture culture NOUN expositions-2352 18 28 itself itself PRON expositions-2352 18 29 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 18 30 as as SCONJ expositions-2352 18 31 i i PRON expositions-2352 18 32 discuss discuss VERB expositions-2352 18 33 below below ADV expositions-2352 18 34 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 19 1 nor nor CCONJ expositions-2352 19 2 is be AUX expositions-2352 19 3 this this PRON expositions-2352 19 4 entirely entirely ADV expositions-2352 19 5 unintentional unintentional ADJ expositions-2352 19 6 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 19 7 it it PRON expositions-2352 19 8 would would AUX expositions-2352 19 9 seem seem VERB expositions-2352 19 10 : : PUNCT expositions-2352 19 11 van van PROPN expositions-2352 19 12 norden norden PROPN expositions-2352 19 13 states states PROPN expositions-2352 19 14 outright outright ADV expositions-2352 19 15 that that SCONJ expositions-2352 19 16 his his PRON expositions-2352 19 17 work work NOUN expositions-2352 19 18 is be AUX expositions-2352 19 19 intended intend VERB expositions-2352 19 20 to to PART expositions-2352 19 21 be be AUX expositions-2352 19 22 “ " PUNCT expositions-2352 19 23 polemical polemical ADJ expositions-2352 19 24 ” " PUNCT expositions-2352 19 25 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 19 26 “ " PUNCT expositions-2352 19 27 cheeky cheeky ADJ expositions-2352 19 28 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 19 29 ” " PUNCT expositions-2352 20 1 he he PRON expositions-2352 20 2 admits admit VERB expositions-2352 20 3 to to ADP expositions-2352 20 4 being be AUX expositions-2352 20 5 “ " PUNCT expositions-2352 20 6 openly openly ADV expositions-2352 20 7 partisan partisan ADJ expositions-2352 20 8 ” " PUNCT expositions-2352 20 9 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 20 10 deliberately deliberately ADV expositions-2352 20 11 prescinds prescind NOUN expositions-2352 20 12 from from ADP expositions-2352 20 13 the the DET expositions-2352 20 14 level level NOUN expositions-2352 20 15 of of ADP expositions-2352 20 16 formality formality NOUN expositions-2352 20 17 characteristic characteristic ADJ expositions-2352 20 18 of of ADP expositions-2352 20 19 normal normal ADJ expositions-2352 20 20 academic academic ADJ expositions-2352 20 21 work work NOUN expositions-2352 20 22 “ " PUNCT expositions-2352 20 23 in in ADP expositions-2352 20 24 the the DET expositions-2352 20 25 hope hope NOUN expositions-2352 20 26 that that SCONJ expositions-2352 20 27 [ [ X expositions-2352 20 28 the the DET expositions-2352 20 29 book book NOUN expositions-2352 20 30 ] ] PUNCT expositions-2352 20 31 will will AUX expositions-2352 20 32 incite incite VERB expositions-2352 20 33 discussion discussion NOUN expositions-2352 20 34 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 20 35 raise raise VERB expositions-2352 20 36 awareness awareness NOUN expositions-2352 20 37 ” " PUNCT expositions-2352 20 38 ( ( PUNCT expositions-2352 20 39 xxiii xxiii PROPN expositions-2352 20 40 – – PUNCT expositions-2352 20 41 xxiv xxiv NUM expositions-2352 20 42 ) ) PUNCT expositions-2352 20 43 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 21 1 this this DET expositions-2352 21 2 cheekiness cheekiness NOUN expositions-2352 21 3 does do AUX expositions-2352 21 4 indeed indeed ADV expositions-2352 21 5 incite incite VERB expositions-2352 21 6 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 21 7 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 21 8 the the DET expositions-2352 21 9 book book NOUN expositions-2352 21 10 delivers deliver VERB expositions-2352 21 11 strong strong ADJ expositions-2352 21 12 punches punch NOUN expositions-2352 21 13 against against ADP expositions-2352 21 14 critics critic NOUN expositions-2352 21 15 who who PRON expositions-2352 21 16 would would AUX expositions-2352 21 17 disagree disagree VERB expositions-2352 21 18 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 22 1 but but CCONJ expositions-2352 22 2 one one NUM expositions-2352 22 3 is be AUX expositions-2352 22 4 hard hard ADV expositions-2352 22 5 pressed pressed ADJ expositions-2352 22 6 to to PART expositions-2352 22 7 know know VERB expositions-2352 22 8 exactly exactly ADV expositions-2352 22 9 who who PRON expositions-2352 22 10 these these DET expositions-2352 22 11 critics critic NOUN expositions-2352 22 12 are be AUX expositions-2352 22 13 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 23 1 in in ADP expositions-2352 23 2 other other ADJ expositions-2352 23 3 words word NOUN expositions-2352 23 4 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 23 5 where where SCONJ expositions-2352 23 6 exactly exactly ADV expositions-2352 23 7 do do AUX expositions-2352 23 8 we we PRON expositions-2352 23 9 locate locate VERB expositions-2352 23 10 the the DET expositions-2352 23 11 xenophobic xenophobic ADJ expositions-2352 23 12 problem problem NOUN expositions-2352 23 13 that that PRON expositions-2352 23 14 van van PROPN expositions-2352 23 15 norden norden PROPN expositions-2352 23 16 identifies identify VERB expositions-2352 23 17 ? ? PUNCT expositions-2352 24 1 is be AUX expositions-2352 24 2 it it PRON expositions-2352 24 3 at at ADP expositions-2352 24 4 the the DET expositions-2352 24 5 level level NOUN expositions-2352 24 6 of of ADP expositions-2352 24 7 the the DET expositions-2352 24 8 academy academy NOUN expositions-2352 24 9 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 24 10 as as SCONJ expositions-2352 24 11 his his PRON expositions-2352 24 12 general general ADJ expositions-2352 24 13 criticisms criticism NOUN expositions-2352 24 14 of of ADP expositions-2352 24 15 syllabi syllabus NOUN expositions-2352 24 16 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 24 17 hiring hiring NOUN expositions-2352 24 18 practices practice NOUN expositions-2352 24 19 ( ( PUNCT expositions-2352 24 20 chapter chapter NOUN expositions-2352 24 21 1 1 NUM expositions-2352 24 22 ) ) PUNCT expositions-2352 24 23 seem seem VERB expositions-2352 24 24 to to PART expositions-2352 24 25 indicate indicate VERB expositions-2352 24 26 ? ? PUNCT expositions-2352 25 1 or or CCONJ expositions-2352 25 2 is be AUX expositions-2352 25 3 it it PRON expositions-2352 25 4 restricted restrict VERB expositions-2352 25 5 to to ADP expositions-2352 25 6 the the DET expositions-2352 25 7 general general ADJ expositions-2352 25 8 public public NOUN expositions-2352 25 9 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 25 10 to to PART expositions-2352 25 11 whom whom PRON expositions-2352 25 12 van van PROPN expositions-2352 25 13 norden norden PROPN expositions-2352 25 14 seems seem VERB expositions-2352 25 15 to to PART expositions-2352 25 16 be be AUX expositions-2352 25 17 addressing address VERB expositions-2352 25 18 his his PRON expositions-2352 25 19 cheeky cheeky ADJ expositions-2352 25 20 tone tone NOUN expositions-2352 25 21 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 25 22 relaxed relaxed ADJ expositions-2352 25 23 standards standard NOUN expositions-2352 25 24 of of ADP expositions-2352 25 25 argumentation argumentation NOUN expositions-2352 25 26 ? ? PUNCT expositions-2352 26 1 the the DET expositions-2352 26 2 answer answer NOUN expositions-2352 26 3 to to ADP expositions-2352 26 4 this this DET expositions-2352 26 5 question question NOUN expositions-2352 26 6 is be AUX expositions-2352 26 7 not not PART expositions-2352 26 8 entirely entirely ADV expositions-2352 26 9 clear clear ADJ expositions-2352 26 10 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 27 1 had have AUX expositions-2352 27 2 van van PROPN expositions-2352 27 3 norden norden PROPN expositions-2352 27 4 limited limit VERB expositions-2352 27 5 his his PRON expositions-2352 27 6 audience audience NOUN expositions-2352 27 7 to to ADP expositions-2352 27 8 academic academic ADJ expositions-2352 27 9 philosophers philosopher NOUN expositions-2352 27 10 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 27 11 his his PRON expositions-2352 27 12 critique critique NOUN expositions-2352 27 13 would would AUX expositions-2352 27 14 have have AUX expositions-2352 27 15 been be AUX expositions-2352 27 16 damming dam VERB expositions-2352 27 17 indeed indeed ADV expositions-2352 27 18 : : PUNCT expositions-2352 27 19 as as SCONJ expositions-2352 27 20 he he PRON expositions-2352 27 21 points point VERB expositions-2352 27 22 out out ADP expositions-2352 27 23 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 27 24 only only ADV expositions-2352 27 25 six six NUM expositions-2352 27 26 of of ADP expositions-2352 27 27 the the DET expositions-2352 27 28 top top ADJ expositions-2352 27 29 fifty fifty NUM expositions-2352 27 30 ph.d.-granting ph.d.-grante VERB expositions-2352 27 31 philosophy philosophy NOUN expositions-2352 27 32 departments department NOUN expositions-2352 27 33 in in ADP expositions-2352 27 34 the the DET expositions-2352 27 35 u.s u.s PROPN expositions-2352 27 36 . . PROPN expositions-2352 27 37 have have VERB expositions-2352 27 38 at at ADV expositions-2352 27 39 least least ADJ expositions-2352 27 40 one one NUM expositions-2352 27 41 full full ADJ expositions-2352 27 42 - - PUNCT expositions-2352 27 43 time time NOUN expositions-2352 27 44 faculty faculty NOUN expositions-2352 27 45 member member NOUN expositions-2352 27 46 who who PRON expositions-2352 27 47 teaches teach VERB expositions-2352 27 48 chinese chinese ADJ expositions-2352 27 49 philosophy philosophy NOUN expositions-2352 27 50 ( ( PUNCT expositions-2352 27 51 2 2 NUM expositions-2352 27 52 ) ) PUNCT expositions-2352 27 53 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 27 54 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 27 55 figures figure NOUN expositions-2352 27 56 are be AUX expositions-2352 27 57 hardly hardly ADV expositions-2352 27 58 more more ADV expositions-2352 27 59 promising promising ADJ expositions-2352 27 60 for for ADP expositions-2352 27 61 other other ADJ expositions-2352 27 62 non non ADJ expositions-2352 27 63 - - ADJ expositions-2352 27 64 anglo anglo ADJ expositions-2352 27 65 - - PUNCT expositions-2352 27 66 european european ADJ expositions-2352 27 67 traditions tradition NOUN expositions-2352 27 68 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 28 1 however however ADV expositions-2352 28 2 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 28 3 his his PRON expositions-2352 28 4 treatment treatment NOUN expositions-2352 28 5 of of ADP expositions-2352 28 6 non non ADJ expositions-2352 28 7 - - ADJ expositions-2352 28 8 western western ADJ expositions-2352 28 9 philosophy philosophy NOUN expositions-2352 28 10 weaves weave VERB expositions-2352 28 11 in in ADP expositions-2352 28 12 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 28 13 out out ADP expositions-2352 28 14 of of ADP expositions-2352 28 15 the the DET expositions-2352 28 16 academy academy NOUN expositions-2352 28 17 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 28 18 sometimes sometimes ADV expositions-2352 28 19 entreating entreat VERB expositions-2352 28 20 “ " PUNCT expositions-2352 28 21 fellow fellow ADJ expositions-2352 28 22 philosophers philosopher NOUN expositions-2352 28 23 ” " PUNCT expositions-2352 28 24 to to PART expositions-2352 28 25 lend lend VERB expositions-2352 28 26 their their PRON expositions-2352 28 27 ears ear NOUN expositions-2352 28 28 ( ( PUNCT expositions-2352 28 29 108 108 NUM expositions-2352 28 30 ) ) PUNCT expositions-2352 28 31 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 28 32 sometimes sometimes ADV expositions-2352 28 33 addressing address VERB expositions-2352 28 34 politics politic NOUN expositions-2352 28 35 or or CCONJ expositions-2352 28 36 public public ADJ expositions-2352 28 37 discourse discourse NOUN expositions-2352 28 38 in in ADP expositions-2352 28 39 general general ADJ expositions-2352 28 40 ( ( PUNCT expositions-2352 28 41 see see VERB expositions-2352 28 42 the the DET expositions-2352 28 43 book book NOUN expositions-2352 28 44 ’s ’ VERB expositions-2352 28 45 the the DET expositions-2352 28 46 numerous numerous ADJ expositions-2352 28 47 discussions discussion NOUN expositions-2352 28 48 of of ADP expositions-2352 28 49 the the DET expositions-2352 28 50 2016 2016 NUM expositions-2352 28 51 republican republican ADJ expositions-2352 28 52 presidential presidential ADJ expositions-2352 28 53 primaries primary NOUN expositions-2352 28 54 ) ) PUNCT expositions-2352 28 55 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 29 1 for for ADP expositions-2352 29 2 instance instance NOUN expositions-2352 29 3 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 29 4 chapter chapter NOUN expositions-2352 29 5 1 1 NUM expositions-2352 29 6 spills spill VERB expositions-2352 29 7 a a DET expositions-2352 29 8 good good ADJ expositions-2352 29 9 portion portion NOUN expositions-2352 29 10 of of ADP expositions-2352 29 11 its its PRON expositions-2352 29 12 ink ink NOUN expositions-2352 29 13 responding respond VERB expositions-2352 29 14 to to ADP expositions-2352 29 15 the the DET expositions-2352 29 16 comments comment NOUN expositions-2352 29 17 section section NOUN expositions-2352 29 18 of of ADP expositions-2352 29 19 van van PROPN expositions-2352 29 20 norden norden PROPN expositions-2352 29 21 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 29 22 jay jay PROPN expositions-2352 29 23 garfield garfield PROPN expositions-2352 29 24 ’s ’s PART expositions-2352 29 25 new new PROPN expositions-2352 29 26 york york PROPN expositions-2352 29 27 magazine magazine NOUN expositions-2352 29 28 article article NOUN expositions-2352 29 29 that that PRON expositions-2352 29 30 argued argue VERB expositions-2352 29 31 for for ADP expositions-2352 29 32 diversity diversity NOUN expositions-2352 29 33 in in ADP expositions-2352 29 34 philosophy philosophy NOUN expositions-2352 29 35 departments department NOUN expositions-2352 29 36 ’ ’ PART expositions-2352 29 37 teaching teaching NOUN expositions-2352 29 38 repertoires repertoire NOUN expositions-2352 29 39 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 30 1 the the DET expositions-2352 30 2 comments comment NOUN expositions-2352 30 3 certainly certainly ADV expositions-2352 30 4 did do AUX expositions-2352 30 5 reflect reflect VERB expositions-2352 30 6 an an DET expositions-2352 30 7 17 17 NUM expositions-2352 30 8 taliaferro taliaferro NOUN expositions-2352 30 9     SPACE expositions-2352 30 10 animus animus NOUN expositions-2352 30 11 towards towards ADP expositions-2352 30 12 non non ADJ expositions-2352 30 13 - - ADJ expositions-2352 30 14 western western ADJ expositions-2352 30 15 philosophy philosophy NOUN expositions-2352 30 16 ( ( PUNCT expositions-2352 30 17 e.g. e.g. ADV expositions-2352 30 18 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 30 19 labeling label VERB expositions-2352 30 20 van van PROPN expositions-2352 30 21 norden norden PROPN expositions-2352 30 22 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 30 23 garfield garfield PROPN expositions-2352 30 24 ’s ’s PART expositions-2352 30 25 impetus impetus NOUN expositions-2352 30 26 “ " PUNCT expositions-2352 30 27 an an DET expositions-2352 30 28 ooshy ooshy ADJ expositions-2352 30 29 gooshy gooshy ADJ expositions-2352 30 30 need need NOUN expositions-2352 30 31 to to PART expositions-2352 30 32 pretend pretend VERB expositions-2352 30 33 that that SCONJ expositions-2352 30 34 all all DET expositions-2352 30 35 cultures culture NOUN expositions-2352 30 36 are be AUX expositions-2352 30 37 equally equally ADV expositions-2352 30 38 advanced advanced ADJ expositions-2352 30 39 ” " PUNCT expositions-2352 30 40 ; ; PUNCT expositions-2352 30 41 another another PRON expositions-2352 30 42 asks ask VERB expositions-2352 30 43 “ " PUNCT expositions-2352 30 44 does do AUX expositions-2352 30 45 anyone anyone PRON expositions-2352 30 46 want want VERB expositions-2352 30 47 to to PART expositions-2352 30 48 fly fly VERB expositions-2352 30 49 in in ADP expositions-2352 30 50 a a DET expositions-2352 30 51 plane plane NOUN expositions-2352 30 52 built build VERB expositions-2352 30 53 with with ADP expositions-2352 30 54 non non ADJ expositions-2352 30 55 - - ADJ expositions-2352 30 56 western western ADJ expositions-2352 30 57 math math NOUN expositions-2352 30 58 ? ? PUNCT expositions-2352 30 59 ” " PUNCT expositions-2352 30 60 ( ( PUNCT expositions-2352 30 61 11–12 11–12 NUM expositions-2352 30 62 ) ) PUNCT expositions-2352 30 63 ) ) PUNCT expositions-2352 30 64 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 30 65 but but CCONJ expositions-2352 30 66 they they PRON expositions-2352 30 67 in in ADP expositions-2352 30 68 no no DET expositions-2352 30 69 way way NOUN expositions-2352 30 70 implicate implicate VERB expositions-2352 30 71 actual actual ADJ expositions-2352 30 72 academic academic ADJ expositions-2352 30 73 philosophers philosopher NOUN expositions-2352 30 74 or or CCONJ expositions-2352 30 75 philosophy philosophy NOUN expositions-2352 30 76 departments department NOUN expositions-2352 30 77 ( ( PUNCT expositions-2352 30 78 except except SCONJ expositions-2352 30 79 in in ADP expositions-2352 30 80 those those DET expositions-2352 30 81 rare rare ADJ expositions-2352 30 82 cases case NOUN expositions-2352 30 83 in in ADP expositions-2352 30 84 which which PRON expositions-2352 30 85 the the DET expositions-2352 30 86 commenting comment VERB expositions-2352 30 87 reader reader NOUN expositions-2352 30 88 identified identify VERB expositions-2352 30 89 herself herself PRON expositions-2352 30 90 as as ADP expositions-2352 30 91 an an DET expositions-2352 30 92 academic academic ADJ expositions-2352 30 93 philosopher philosopher NOUN expositions-2352 30 94 ) ) PUNCT expositions-2352 30 95 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 31 1 likewise likewise ADV expositions-2352 31 2 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 31 3 “ " PUNCT expositions-2352 31 4 trump trump VERB expositions-2352 31 5 ’s ’s PART expositions-2352 31 6 philosophers philosopher NOUN expositions-2352 31 7 ” " PUNCT expositions-2352 31 8 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 31 9 “ " PUNCT expositions-2352 31 10 welders welder NOUN expositions-2352 31 11 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 31 12 philosophers philosopher NOUN expositions-2352 31 13 ” " PUNCT expositions-2352 31 14 ( ( PUNCT expositions-2352 31 15 chapters chapter NOUN expositions-2352 31 16 3 3 NUM expositions-2352 31 17 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 31 18 4 4 NUM expositions-2352 31 19 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 31 20 respectively respectively ADV expositions-2352 31 21 ) ) PUNCT expositions-2352 31 22 deal deal NOUN expositions-2352 31 23 with with ADP expositions-2352 31 24 mainstream mainstream ADJ expositions-2352 31 25 partisan partisan ADJ expositions-2352 31 26 politics politic NOUN expositions-2352 31 27 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 31 28 whether whether SCONJ expositions-2352 31 29 in in ADP expositions-2352 31 30 america america PROPN expositions-2352 31 31 or or CCONJ expositions-2352 31 32 china china PROPN expositions-2352 31 33 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 31 34 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 31 35 only only ADV expositions-2352 31 36 tangentially tangentially ADV expositions-2352 31 37 addresses address VERB expositions-2352 31 38 the the DET expositions-2352 31 39 university university NOUN expositions-2352 31 40 at at ADV expositions-2352 31 41 all all ADV expositions-2352 31 42 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 31 43 sometimes sometimes ADV expositions-2352 31 44 veering veer VERB expositions-2352 31 45 so so ADV expositions-2352 31 46 far far ADV expositions-2352 31 47 as as SCONJ expositions-2352 31 48 not not PART expositions-2352 31 49 to to PART expositions-2352 31 50 seem seem VERB expositions-2352 31 51 relevant relevant ADJ expositions-2352 31 52 to to ADP expositions-2352 31 53 the the DET expositions-2352 31 54 topic topic NOUN expositions-2352 31 55 of of ADP expositions-2352 31 56 the the DET expositions-2352 31 57 book book NOUN expositions-2352 31 58 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 32 1 “ " PUNCT expositions-2352 32 2 trump trump VERB expositions-2352 32 3 ’s ’s PART expositions-2352 32 4 philosophers philosopher NOUN expositions-2352 32 5 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 32 6 ” " PUNCT expositions-2352 32 7 for for ADP expositions-2352 32 8 instance instance NOUN expositions-2352 32 9 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 32 10 includes include VERB expositions-2352 32 11 discussions discussion NOUN expositions-2352 32 12 of of ADP expositions-2352 32 13 the the DET expositions-2352 32 14 republican republican PROPN expositions-2352 32 15 party party PROPN expositions-2352 32 16 ’s ’s PART expositions-2352 32 17 track track NOUN expositions-2352 32 18 record record NOUN expositions-2352 32 19 on on ADP expositions-2352 32 20 lgbt lgbt PROPN expositions-2352 32 21 issues issue NOUN expositions-2352 32 22 as as ADV expositions-2352 32 23 well well ADV expositions-2352 32 24 as as ADP expositions-2352 32 25 elite elite ADJ expositions-2352 32 26 universities university NOUN expositions-2352 32 27 ’ ' PUNCT expositions-2352 32 28 legacy legacy NOUN expositions-2352 32 29 admissions admission NOUN expositions-2352 32 30 practices practice NOUN expositions-2352 32 31 ( ( PUNCT expositions-2352 32 32 106–107 106–107 NUM expositions-2352 32 33 ) ) PUNCT expositions-2352 32 34 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 32 35 giving give VERB expositions-2352 32 36 the the DET expositions-2352 32 37 appearance appearance NOUN expositions-2352 32 38 that that PRON expositions-2352 32 39 the the DET expositions-2352 32 40 manifesto manifesto NOUN expositions-2352 32 41 may may AUX expositions-2352 32 42 be be AUX expositions-2352 32 43 more more ADV expositions-2352 32 44 political political ADJ expositions-2352 32 45 than than ADP expositions-2352 32 46 philosophical philosophical ADJ expositions-2352 32 47 — — PUNCT expositions-2352 32 48 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 32 49 thereby thereby ADV expositions-2352 32 50 less less ADV expositions-2352 32 51 relevant relevant ADJ expositions-2352 32 52 to to ADP expositions-2352 32 53 academic academic ADJ expositions-2352 32 54 philosophy philosophy NOUN expositions-2352 32 55 departments department NOUN expositions-2352 32 56 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 33 1 of of ADP expositions-2352 33 2 course course ADV expositions-2352 33 3 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 33 4 there there PRON expositions-2352 33 5 is be VERB expositions-2352 33 6 the the DET expositions-2352 33 7 possibility possibility NOUN expositions-2352 33 8 that that SCONJ expositions-2352 33 9 van van PROPN expositions-2352 33 10 norden norden PROPN expositions-2352 33 11 aiming aim VERB expositions-2352 33 12 at at ADP expositions-2352 33 13 both both CCONJ expositions-2352 33 14 the the DET expositions-2352 33 15 academy academy NOUN expositions-2352 33 16 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 33 17 public public ADJ expositions-2352 33 18 discourse discourse NOUN expositions-2352 33 19 with with ADP expositions-2352 33 20 one one NUM expositions-2352 33 21 blow blow NOUN expositions-2352 33 22 — — PUNCT expositions-2352 33 23 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 33 24 that that SCONJ expositions-2352 33 25 he he PRON expositions-2352 33 26 is be AUX expositions-2352 33 27 doing do VERB expositions-2352 33 28 so so ADV expositions-2352 33 29 precisely precisely ADV expositions-2352 33 30 because because SCONJ expositions-2352 33 31 he he PRON expositions-2352 33 32 sees see VERB expositions-2352 33 33 a a DET expositions-2352 33 34 link link NOUN expositions-2352 33 35 between between ADP expositions-2352 33 36 the the DET expositions-2352 33 37 two two NUM expositions-2352 33 38 : : PUNCT expositions-2352 33 39 namely namely ADV expositions-2352 33 40 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 33 41 that that SCONJ expositions-2352 33 42 public public ADJ expositions-2352 33 43 discourse discourse NOUN expositions-2352 33 44 is be AUX expositions-2352 33 45 informed inform VERB expositions-2352 33 46 by by ADP expositions-2352 33 47 elite elite ADJ expositions-2352 33 48 academic academic ADJ expositions-2352 33 49 culture culture NOUN expositions-2352 33 50 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 34 1 stating state VERB expositions-2352 34 2 this this DET expositions-2352 34 3 outright outright ADJ expositions-2352 34 4 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 34 5 though though ADV expositions-2352 34 6 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 34 7 would would AUX expositions-2352 34 8 have have AUX expositions-2352 34 9 raised raise VERB expositions-2352 34 10 what what PRON expositions-2352 34 11 may may AUX expositions-2352 34 12 be be AUX expositions-2352 34 13 the the DET expositions-2352 34 14 strongest strong ADJ expositions-2352 34 15 obstacle obstacle NOUN expositions-2352 34 16 for for ADP expositions-2352 34 17 van van PROPN expositions-2352 34 18 norden norden PROPN expositions-2352 34 19 ’s ’s PART expositions-2352 34 20 thesis thesis NOUN expositions-2352 34 21 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 34 22 namely namely ADV expositions-2352 34 23 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 34 24 that that SCONJ expositions-2352 34 25 while while SCONJ expositions-2352 34 26 students student NOUN expositions-2352 34 27 should should AUX expositions-2352 34 28 ( ( PUNCT expositions-2352 34 29 absolutely absolutely ADV expositions-2352 34 30 ! ! PUNCT expositions-2352 34 31 ) ) PUNCT expositions-2352 34 32 be be AUX expositions-2352 34 33 exposed expose VERB expositions-2352 34 34 to to ADP expositions-2352 34 35 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 34 36 take take VERB expositions-2352 34 37 seriously seriously ADV expositions-2352 34 38 the the DET expositions-2352 34 39 thought thought NOUN expositions-2352 34 40 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 34 41 philosophy philosophy NOUN expositions-2352 34 42 of of ADP expositions-2352 34 43 cultures culture NOUN expositions-2352 34 44 not not PART expositions-2352 34 45 their their PRON expositions-2352 34 46 own own ADJ expositions-2352 34 47 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 34 48 there there PRON expositions-2352 34 49 is be VERB expositions-2352 34 50 still still ADV expositions-2352 34 51 reason reason NOUN expositions-2352 34 52 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 34 53 in in ADP expositions-2352 34 54 an an DET expositions-2352 34 55 american american ADJ expositions-2352 34 56 university university NOUN expositions-2352 34 57 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 34 58 to to PART expositions-2352 34 59 favor favor VERB expositions-2352 34 60 western2 western2 NOUN expositions-2352 34 61 philosophy philosophy NOUN expositions-2352 34 62 — — PUNCT expositions-2352 34 63 the the DET expositions-2352 34 64 simple simple ADJ expositions-2352 34 65 reason reason NOUN expositions-2352 34 66 being be AUX expositions-2352 34 67 that that SCONJ expositions-2352 34 68 western western ADJ expositions-2352 34 69 philosophy philosophy NOUN expositions-2352 34 70 is be AUX expositions-2352 34 71 more more ADJ expositions-2352 34 72 salient salient NOUN expositions-2352 34 73 in in ADP expositions-2352 34 74 the the DET expositions-2352 34 75 roots root NOUN expositions-2352 34 76 of of ADP expositions-2352 34 77 american american ADJ expositions-2352 34 78 life life NOUN expositions-2352 34 79 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 34 80 consequently consequently ADV expositions-2352 34 81 to to ADP expositions-2352 34 82 the the DET expositions-2352 34 83 lives life NOUN expositions-2352 34 84 of of ADP expositions-2352 34 85 american american ADJ expositions-2352 34 86 students student NOUN expositions-2352 34 87 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 35 1 thus thus ADV expositions-2352 35 2 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 35 3 if if SCONJ expositions-2352 35 4 part part NOUN expositions-2352 35 5 of of ADP expositions-2352 35 6 the the DET expositions-2352 35 7 task task NOUN expositions-2352 35 8 of of ADP expositions-2352 35 9 a a DET expositions-2352 35 10 university university NOUN expositions-2352 35 11 is be AUX expositions-2352 35 12 to to PART expositions-2352 35 13 educate educate VERB expositions-2352 35 14 students student NOUN expositions-2352 35 15 to to PART expositions-2352 35 16 function function VERB expositions-2352 35 17 well well ADV expositions-2352 35 18 as as ADP expositions-2352 35 19 members member NOUN expositions-2352 35 20 of of ADP expositions-2352 35 21 society society NOUN expositions-2352 35 22 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 35 23 it it PRON expositions-2352 35 24 seems seem VERB expositions-2352 35 25 reasonable reasonable ADJ expositions-2352 35 26 that that SCONJ expositions-2352 35 27 they they PRON expositions-2352 35 28 be be AUX expositions-2352 35 29 educated educate VERB expositions-2352 35 30 to to PART expositions-2352 35 31 function function VERB expositions-2352 35 32 first first ADV expositions-2352 35 33 ( ( PUNCT expositions-2352 35 34 but but CCONJ expositions-2352 35 35 not not PART expositions-2352 35 36 exclusively exclusively ADV expositions-2352 35 37 ) ) PUNCT expositions-2352 35 38 well well ADV expositions-2352 35 39 in in ADP expositions-2352 35 40 their their PRON expositions-2352 35 41 society.3 society.3 NOUN expositions-2352 35 42 but but CCONJ expositions-2352 35 43 here here ADV expositions-2352 35 44 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 35 45 van van PROPN expositions-2352 35 46 norden norden PROPN expositions-2352 35 47 would would AUX expositions-2352 35 48 likely likely ADV expositions-2352 35 49 disagree disagree VERB expositions-2352 35 50 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 36 1 he he PRON expositions-2352 36 2 comes come VERB expositions-2352 36 3 close close ADV expositions-2352 36 4 to to ADP expositions-2352 36 5 addressing address VERB expositions-2352 36 6 this this DET expositions-2352 36 7 point point NOUN expositions-2352 36 8 in in ADP expositions-2352 36 9 his his PRON expositions-2352 36 10 comments comment NOUN expositions-2352 36 11 on on ADP expositions-2352 36 12 allan allan PROPN expositions-2352 36 13 bloom bloom PROPN expositions-2352 36 14 ’s ’s PART expositions-2352 36 15 the the DET expositions-2352 36 16 closing closing NOUN expositions-2352 36 17 of of ADP expositions-2352 36 18 the the DET expositions-2352 36 19 american american ADJ expositions-2352 36 20 mind mind NOUN expositions-2352 36 21 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 36 22 which which PRON expositions-2352 36 23 called call VERB expositions-2352 36 24 for for ADP expositions-2352 36 25 an an DET expositions-2352 36 26 education education NOUN expositions-2352 36 27 grounded ground VERB expositions-2352 36 28 in in ADP expositions-2352 36 29 a a DET expositions-2352 36 30 traditional traditional ADJ expositions-2352 36 31 liberal liberal ADJ expositions-2352 36 32 arts art NOUN expositions-2352 36 33 education education NOUN expositions-2352 36 34 largely largely ADV expositions-2352 36 35 informed inform VERB expositions-2352 36 36 by by ADP expositions-2352 36 37 western western ADJ expositions-2352 36 38 texts text NOUN expositions-2352 36 39 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 37 1 bloom bloom NOUN expositions-2352 37 2 wrote write VERB expositions-2352 37 3 that that SCONJ expositions-2352 37 4 “ " PUNCT expositions-2352 37 5 men man NOUN expositions-2352 37 6 must must AUX expositions-2352 37 7 love love VERB expositions-2352 37 8 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 37 9 be be AUX expositions-2352 37 10 loyal loyal ADJ expositions-2352 37 11 to to ADP expositions-2352 37 12 their their PRON expositions-2352 37 13 families family NOUN expositions-2352 37 14 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 37 15 their their PRON expositions-2352 37 16 peoples people NOUN expositions-2352 37 17 in in ADP expositions-2352 37 18 order order NOUN expositions-2352 37 19 to to PART expositions-2352 37 20 preserve preserve VERB expositions-2352 37 21 them they PRON expositions-2352 37 22 ” " PUNCT expositions-2352 37 23 ( ( PUNCT expositions-2352 37 24 103 103 NUM expositions-2352 37 25 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 37 26 citing cite VERB expositions-2352 37 27 bloom bloom NOUN expositions-2352 37 28 37 37 NUM expositions-2352 37 29 ) ) PUNCT expositions-2352 37 30 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 38 1 van van PROPN expositions-2352 38 2 norden norden PROPN expositions-2352 38 3 labels label NOUN expositions-2352 38 4 this this DET expositions-2352 38 5 belief belief NOUN expositions-2352 38 6 “ " PUNCT expositions-2352 38 7 ethnocentrism ethnocentrism NOUN expositions-2352 38 8 ” " PUNCT expositions-2352 38 9 ( ( PUNCT expositions-2352 38 10 103 103 NUM expositions-2352 38 11 ) ) PUNCT expositions-2352 38 12 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 38 13 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 38 14 then then ADV expositions-2352 38 15 accuses accuse VERB expositions-2352 38 16 bloom bloom NOUN expositions-2352 38 17 of of ADP expositions-2352 38 18 a a DET expositions-2352 38 19 “ " PUNCT expositions-2352 38 20 fundamental fundamental ADJ expositions-2352 38 21 incoherence incoherence NOUN expositions-2352 38 22 ” " PUNCT expositions-2352 38 23 when when SCONJ expositions-2352 38 24 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 38 25 in in ADP expositions-2352 38 26 advocating advocate VERB expositions-2352 38 27 reading read VERB expositions-2352 38 28 the the DET expositions-2352 38 29 bible bible NOUN expositions-2352 38 30 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 38 31 bloom bloom NOUN expositions-2352 38 32 adds add VERB expositions-2352 38 33 that that SCONJ expositions-2352 38 34 one one PRON expositions-2352 38 35 might might AUX expositions-2352 38 36 substitute substitute VERB expositions-2352 38 37 “ " PUNCT expositions-2352 38 38 a a DET expositions-2352 38 39 book book NOUN expositions-2352 38 40 of of ADP expositions-2352 38 41 similar similar ADJ expositions-2352 38 42 gravity gravity NOUN expositions-2352 38 43 ” " PUNCT expositions-2352 38 44 in in ADP expositions-2352 38 45 order order NOUN expositions-2352 38 46 to to PART expositions-2352 38 47 supply supply VERB expositions-2352 38 48 the the DET expositions-2352 38 49 student student NOUN expositions-2352 38 50 ’s ’s PART expositions-2352 38 51 mind mind NOUN expositions-2352 38 52 with with ADP expositions-2352 38 53 what what PRON expositions-2352 38 54 it it PRON expositions-2352 38 55 needs need VERB expositions-2352 38 56 to to PART expositions-2352 38 57 assist assist VERB expositions-2352 38 58 her she PRON expositions-2352 38 59 as as ADP expositions-2352 38 60 a a DET expositions-2352 38 61 citizen citizen NOUN expositions-2352 38 62 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 39 1 to to ADP expositions-2352 39 2 van van PROPN expositions-2352 39 3 norden norden PROPN expositions-2352 39 4 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 39 5 this this DET expositions-2352 39 6 escape escape NOUN expositions-2352 39 7 clause clause NOUN expositions-2352 39 8 gives give VERB expositions-2352 39 9 the the DET expositions-2352 39 10 lie lie NOUN expositions-2352 39 11 to to PART expositions-2352 39 12 bloom bloom VERB expositions-2352 39 13 ’s ’s PART expositions-2352 39 14 westerncentric westerncentric ADJ expositions-2352 39 15 argument argument NOUN expositions-2352 39 16 — — PUNCT expositions-2352 39 17 what what PRON expositions-2352 39 18 matters matter NOUN expositions-2352 39 19 is be AUX expositions-2352 39 20 not not PART expositions-2352 39 21 that that SCONJ expositions-2352 39 22 we we PRON expositions-2352 39 23 read read VERB expositions-2352 39 24 the the DET expositions-2352 39 25 books book NOUN expositions-2352 39 26 that that PRON expositions-2352 39 27 have have AUX expositions-2352 39 28 informed inform VERB expositions-2352 39 29 our our PRON expositions-2352 39 30 civilization civilization NOUN expositions-2352 39 31 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 39 32 less less ADV expositions-2352 39 33 manifesto manifesto NOUN expositions-2352 39 34 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 39 35 more more ADJ expositions-2352 39 36 philosophy philosophy NOUN expositions-2352 39 37 18 18 NUM expositions-2352 39 38         SPACE expositions-2352 39 39 but but CCONJ expositions-2352 39 40 that that SCONJ expositions-2352 39 41 we we PRON expositions-2352 39 42 read read VERB expositions-2352 39 43 good good ADJ expositions-2352 39 44 books book NOUN expositions-2352 39 45 of of ADP expositions-2352 39 46 any any DET expositions-2352 39 47 culture culture NOUN expositions-2352 39 48 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 40 1 “ " PUNCT expositions-2352 40 2 if if SCONJ expositions-2352 40 3 reading read VERB expositions-2352 40 4 the the DET expositions-2352 40 5 bible bible PROPN expositions-2352 40 6 intently intently ADV expositions-2352 40 7 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 40 8 seriously seriously ADV expositions-2352 40 9 gives give VERB expositions-2352 40 10 breadth breadth NOUN expositions-2352 40 11 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 40 12 depth depth NOUN expositions-2352 40 13 to to ADP expositions-2352 40 14 one one NUM expositions-2352 40 15 ’s ’s PART expositions-2352 40 16 mind mind NOUN expositions-2352 40 17 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 40 18 ” " PUNCT expositions-2352 40 19 van van PROPN expositions-2352 40 20 norden norden PROPN expositions-2352 40 21 asks ask VERB expositions-2352 40 22 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 40 23 “ " PUNCT expositions-2352 40 24 why why SCONJ expositions-2352 40 25 not not PART expositions-2352 40 26 also also ADV expositions-2352 40 27 the the DET expositions-2352 40 28 mengzi mengzi NOUN expositions-2352 40 29 ? ? PUNCT expositions-2352 40 30 or or CCONJ expositions-2352 40 31 the the DET expositions-2352 40 32 bhagavad bhagavad PROPN expositions-2352 40 33 gita gita PROPN expositions-2352 40 34 ? ? PUNCT expositions-2352 41 1 or or CCONJ expositions-2352 41 2 chūshingura chūshingura NOUN expositions-2352 41 3 ? ? PUNCT expositions-2352 42 1 there there PRON expositions-2352 42 2 is be VERB expositions-2352 42 3 more more ADJ expositions-2352 42 4 than than ADP expositions-2352 42 5 one one NUM expositions-2352 42 6 ‘ ' PUNCT expositions-2352 42 7 great great ADJ expositions-2352 42 8 conversation conversation NOUN expositions-2352 42 9 ’ ' PUNCT expositions-2352 42 10 in in ADP expositions-2352 42 11 the the DET expositions-2352 42 12 world world NOUN expositions-2352 42 13 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 42 14 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 42 15 more more ADJ expositions-2352 42 16 than than ADP expositions-2352 42 17 one one NUM expositions-2352 42 18 way way NOUN expositions-2352 42 19 to to PART expositions-2352 42 20 furnish furnish VERB expositions-2352 42 21 a a DET expositions-2352 42 22 soul soul NOUN expositions-2352 42 23 ” " PUNCT expositions-2352 42 24 ( ( PUNCT expositions-2352 42 25 105 105 NUM expositions-2352 42 26 ) ) PUNCT expositions-2352 42 27 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 43 1 van van PROPN expositions-2352 43 2 norden norden PROPN expositions-2352 43 3 ’s ’s PART expositions-2352 43 4 statement statement NOUN expositions-2352 43 5 is be AUX expositions-2352 43 6 certainly certainly ADV expositions-2352 43 7 true true ADJ expositions-2352 43 8 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 43 9 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 43 10 i i PRON expositions-2352 43 11 take take VERB expositions-2352 43 12 no no DET expositions-2352 43 13 issue issue NOUN expositions-2352 43 14 with with ADP expositions-2352 43 15 it it PRON expositions-2352 43 16 as as ADP expositions-2352 43 17 such such ADJ expositions-2352 43 18 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 44 1 but but CCONJ expositions-2352 44 2 in in ADP expositions-2352 44 3 the the DET expositions-2352 44 4 context context NOUN expositions-2352 44 5 of of ADP expositions-2352 44 6 bloom bloom NOUN expositions-2352 44 7 ’s ’s PART expositions-2352 44 8 book book NOUN expositions-2352 44 9 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 44 10 the the DET expositions-2352 44 11 challenges challenge NOUN expositions-2352 44 12 it it PRON expositions-2352 44 13 poses pose VERB expositions-2352 44 14 to to ADP expositions-2352 44 15 van van PROPN expositions-2352 44 16 norden norden PROPN expositions-2352 44 17 ’s ’s PART expositions-2352 44 18 project project NOUN expositions-2352 44 19 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 44 20 it it PRON expositions-2352 44 21 misses miss VERB expositions-2352 44 22 the the DET expositions-2352 44 23 point point NOUN expositions-2352 44 24 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 45 1 bloom bloom NOUN expositions-2352 45 2 suggested suggest VERB expositions-2352 45 3 that that SCONJ expositions-2352 45 4 a a DET expositions-2352 45 5 person person NOUN expositions-2352 45 6 must must AUX expositions-2352 45 7 love love VERB expositions-2352 45 8 first first ADV expositions-2352 45 9 her her PRON expositions-2352 45 10 family family NOUN expositions-2352 45 11 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 45 12 her her PRON expositions-2352 45 13 people people NOUN expositions-2352 45 14 in in ADP expositions-2352 45 15 order order NOUN expositions-2352 45 16 to to PART expositions-2352 45 17 preserve preserve VERB expositions-2352 45 18 them they PRON expositions-2352 45 19 — — PUNCT expositions-2352 45 20 not not PART expositions-2352 45 21 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 45 22 importantly importantly ADV expositions-2352 45 23 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 45 24 that that SCONJ expositions-2352 45 25 she she PRON expositions-2352 45 26 remain remain VERB expositions-2352 45 27 ignorant ignorant ADJ expositions-2352 45 28 of of ADP expositions-2352 45 29 other other ADJ expositions-2352 45 30 families family NOUN expositions-2352 45 31 or or CCONJ expositions-2352 45 32 peoples people NOUN expositions-2352 45 33 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 45 34 nor nor CCONJ expositions-2352 45 35 that that SCONJ expositions-2352 45 36 there there PRON expositions-2352 45 37 might might AUX expositions-2352 45 38 not not PART expositions-2352 45 39 be be AUX expositions-2352 45 40 something something PRON expositions-2352 45 41 more more ADJ expositions-2352 45 42 to to ADP expositions-2352 45 43 life life NOUN expositions-2352 45 44 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 45 45 civilization civilization NOUN expositions-2352 45 46 than than ADP expositions-2352 45 47 preservation preservation NOUN expositions-2352 45 48 alone alone ADV expositions-2352 45 49 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 46 1 rather rather ADV expositions-2352 46 2 than than ADP expositions-2352 46 3 betraying betray VERB expositions-2352 46 4 the the DET expositions-2352 46 5 “ " PUNCT expositions-2352 46 6 ethnocentrism ethnocentrism NOUN expositions-2352 46 7 ” " PUNCT expositions-2352 46 8 of of ADP expositions-2352 46 9 which which PRON expositions-2352 46 10 van van PROPN expositions-2352 46 11 norden norden PROPN expositions-2352 46 12 accuses accuses PROPN expositions-2352 46 13 bloom bloom NOUN expositions-2352 46 14 ( ( PUNCT expositions-2352 46 15 103 103 NUM expositions-2352 46 16 ) ) PUNCT expositions-2352 46 17 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 46 18 i i PRON expositions-2352 46 19 submit submit VERB expositions-2352 46 20 that that DET expositions-2352 46 21 bloom bloom NOUN expositions-2352 46 22 ’s ’s PART expositions-2352 46 23 view view NOUN expositions-2352 46 24 simply simply ADV expositions-2352 46 25 acknowledges acknowledge VERB expositions-2352 46 26 the the DET expositions-2352 46 27 embedded embed VERB expositions-2352 46 28 nature nature NOUN expositions-2352 46 29 of of ADP expositions-2352 46 30 human human ADJ expositions-2352 46 31 life life NOUN expositions-2352 46 32 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 47 1 we we PRON expositions-2352 47 2 are be AUX expositions-2352 47 3 incapable incapable ADJ expositions-2352 47 4 of of ADP expositions-2352 47 5 participating participate VERB expositions-2352 47 6 in in ADP expositions-2352 47 7 the the DET expositions-2352 47 8 lives life NOUN expositions-2352 47 9 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 47 10 cultures culture NOUN expositions-2352 47 11 of of ADP expositions-2352 47 12 distant distant ADJ expositions-2352 47 13 peoples people NOUN expositions-2352 47 14 to to ADP expositions-2352 47 15 the the DET expositions-2352 47 16 same same ADJ expositions-2352 47 17 extent extent NOUN expositions-2352 47 18 that that PRON expositions-2352 47 19 we we PRON expositions-2352 47 20 participate participate VERB expositions-2352 47 21 in in ADP expositions-2352 47 22 the the DET expositions-2352 47 23 lives life NOUN expositions-2352 47 24 of of ADP expositions-2352 47 25 those those PRON expositions-2352 47 26 around around ADP expositions-2352 47 27 us we PRON expositions-2352 47 28 — — PUNCT expositions-2352 47 29 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 47 30 efforts effort NOUN expositions-2352 47 31 to to PART expositions-2352 47 32 pretend pretend VERB expositions-2352 47 33 otherwise otherwise ADV expositions-2352 47 34 often often ADV expositions-2352 47 35 end end VERB expositions-2352 47 36 in in ADP expositions-2352 47 37 violence violence NOUN expositions-2352 47 38 of of ADP expositions-2352 47 39 some some DET expositions-2352 47 40 sort sort NOUN expositions-2352 47 41 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 48 1 acknowledging acknowledge VERB expositions-2352 48 2 this this DET expositions-2352 48 3 embeddedness embeddedness NOUN expositions-2352 48 4 in in ADP expositions-2352 48 5 no no DET expositions-2352 48 6 way way NOUN expositions-2352 48 7 precludes preclude VERB expositions-2352 48 8 engagement engagement NOUN expositions-2352 48 9 with with ADP expositions-2352 48 10 other other ADJ expositions-2352 48 11 cultures culture NOUN expositions-2352 48 12 ; ; PUNCT expositions-2352 48 13 it it PRON expositions-2352 48 14 simply simply ADV expositions-2352 48 15 aims aim VERB expositions-2352 48 16 to to PART expositions-2352 48 17 equip equip VERB expositions-2352 48 18 students student NOUN expositions-2352 48 19 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 48 20 citizens citizen NOUN expositions-2352 48 21 to to PART expositions-2352 48 22 live live VERB expositions-2352 48 23 in in ADP expositions-2352 48 24 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 48 25 serve serve VERB expositions-2352 48 26 their their PRON expositions-2352 48 27 own own ADJ expositions-2352 48 28 communities community NOUN expositions-2352 48 29 well well ADV expositions-2352 48 30 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 49 1 as as ADP expositions-2352 49 2 an an DET expositions-2352 49 3 illustration illustration NOUN expositions-2352 49 4 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 49 5 an an DET expositions-2352 49 6 american american ADJ expositions-2352 49 7 mother mother NOUN expositions-2352 49 8 may may AUX expositions-2352 49 9 speak speak VERB expositions-2352 49 10 to to ADP expositions-2352 49 11 her her PRON expositions-2352 49 12 son son NOUN expositions-2352 49 13 exclusively exclusively ADV expositions-2352 49 14 in in ADP expositions-2352 49 15 french french NOUN expositions-2352 49 16 in in ADP expositions-2352 49 17 the the DET expositions-2352 49 18 hopes hope NOUN expositions-2352 49 19 that that SCONJ expositions-2352 49 20 he he PRON expositions-2352 49 21 will will AUX expositions-2352 49 22 grow grow VERB expositions-2352 49 23 up up ADP expositions-2352 49 24 bilingual bilingual ADJ expositions-2352 49 25 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 49 26 yet yet ADV expositions-2352 49 27 be be AUX expositions-2352 49 28 nevertheless nevertheless ADV expositions-2352 49 29 more more ADV expositions-2352 49 30 concerned concerned ADJ expositions-2352 49 31 that that SCONJ expositions-2352 49 32 he he PRON expositions-2352 49 33 learn learn VERB expositions-2352 49 34 english english PROPN expositions-2352 49 35 because because SCONJ expositions-2352 49 36 that that PRON expositions-2352 49 37 is be AUX expositions-2352 49 38 the the DET expositions-2352 49 39 language language NOUN expositions-2352 49 40 of of ADP expositions-2352 49 41 the the DET expositions-2352 49 42 culture culture NOUN expositions-2352 49 43 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 49 44 society society NOUN expositions-2352 49 45 in in ADP expositions-2352 49 46 which which PRON expositions-2352 49 47 he he PRON expositions-2352 49 48 will will AUX expositions-2352 49 49 ( ( PUNCT expositions-2352 49 50 most most ADV expositions-2352 49 51 likely likely ADJ expositions-2352 49 52 ) ) PUNCT expositions-2352 49 53 live live VERB expositions-2352 49 54 the the DET expositions-2352 49 55 majority majority NOUN expositions-2352 49 56 of of ADP expositions-2352 49 57 his his PRON expositions-2352 49 58 life life NOUN expositions-2352 49 59 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 50 1 none none NOUN expositions-2352 50 2 of of ADP expositions-2352 50 3 this this PRON expositions-2352 50 4 requires require VERB expositions-2352 50 5 that that SCONJ expositions-2352 50 6 she she PRON expositions-2352 50 7 consider consider VERB expositions-2352 50 8 english english PROPN expositions-2352 50 9 to to PART expositions-2352 50 10 be be AUX expositions-2352 50 11 a a DET expositions-2352 50 12 superior superior ADJ expositions-2352 50 13 language language NOUN expositions-2352 50 14 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 50 15 nor nor CCONJ expositions-2352 50 16 america america PROPN expositions-2352 50 17 to to PART expositions-2352 50 18 be be AUX expositions-2352 50 19 superior superior ADJ expositions-2352 50 20 to to ADP expositions-2352 50 21 france france PROPN expositions-2352 50 22 ; ; PUNCT expositions-2352 50 23 she she PRON expositions-2352 50 24 simply simply ADV expositions-2352 50 25 wants want VERB expositions-2352 50 26 her her PRON expositions-2352 50 27 child child NOUN expositions-2352 50 28 to to PART expositions-2352 50 29 be be AUX expositions-2352 50 30 equipped equip VERB expositions-2352 50 31 to to PART expositions-2352 50 32 live live VERB expositions-2352 50 33 in in ADP expositions-2352 50 34 the the DET expositions-2352 50 35 world world NOUN expositions-2352 50 36 in in ADP expositions-2352 50 37 which which PRON expositions-2352 50 38 he he PRON expositions-2352 50 39 lives live VERB expositions-2352 50 40 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 50 41 to to PART expositions-2352 50 42 understand understand VERB expositions-2352 50 43 its its PRON expositions-2352 50 44 heritage heritage NOUN expositions-2352 50 45 without without ADP expositions-2352 50 46 translation translation NOUN expositions-2352 50 47 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 51 1 van van PROPN expositions-2352 51 2 norden norden PROPN expositions-2352 51 3 ’s ’s PART expositions-2352 51 4 charge charge NOUN expositions-2352 51 5 of of ADP expositions-2352 51 6 ethnocentrism ethnocentrism NOUN expositions-2352 51 7 against against ADP expositions-2352 51 8 bloom bloom NOUN expositions-2352 51 9 may may AUX expositions-2352 51 10 seem seem VERB expositions-2352 51 11 like like ADP expositions-2352 51 12 a a DET expositions-2352 51 13 small small ADJ expositions-2352 51 14 matter matter NOUN expositions-2352 51 15 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 51 16 but but CCONJ expositions-2352 51 17 i i PRON expositions-2352 51 18 think think VERB expositions-2352 51 19 it it PRON expositions-2352 51 20 is be AUX expositions-2352 51 21 rather rather ADV expositions-2352 51 22 a a DET expositions-2352 51 23 telling tell VERB expositions-2352 51 24 indicator indicator NOUN expositions-2352 51 25 of of ADP expositions-2352 51 26 his his PRON expositions-2352 51 27 approach approach NOUN expositions-2352 51 28 in in ADP expositions-2352 51 29 this this DET expositions-2352 51 30 book book NOUN expositions-2352 51 31 — — PUNCT expositions-2352 51 32 as as ADV expositions-2352 51 33 well well ADV expositions-2352 51 34 as as ADP expositions-2352 51 35 an an DET expositions-2352 51 36 indicator indicator NOUN expositions-2352 51 37 of of ADP expositions-2352 51 38 what what PRON expositions-2352 51 39 i i PRON expositions-2352 51 40 termed term VERB expositions-2352 51 41 earlier early ADV expositions-2352 51 42 “ " PUNCT expositions-2352 51 43 relaxed relaxed ADJ expositions-2352 51 44 standards standard NOUN expositions-2352 51 45 of of ADP expositions-2352 51 46 argumentation argumentation NOUN expositions-2352 51 47 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 51 48 ” " PUNCT expositions-2352 52 1 laying lay VERB expositions-2352 52 2 aside aside ADV expositions-2352 52 3 jay jay PROPN expositions-2352 52 4 garfield garfield PROPN expositions-2352 52 5 ’s ’s PART expositions-2352 52 6 introduction introduction NOUN expositions-2352 52 7 ( ( PUNCT expositions-2352 52 8 xiii xiii PROPN expositions-2352 52 9 ) ) PUNCT expositions-2352 52 10 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 52 11 which which PRON expositions-2352 52 12 labels label VERB expositions-2352 52 13 an an DET expositions-2352 52 14 anonymous anonymous ADJ expositions-2352 52 15 critic critic NOUN expositions-2352 52 16 as as ADP expositions-2352 52 17 emblematic emblematic ADJ expositions-2352 52 18 of of ADP expositions-2352 52 19 white white ADJ expositions-2352 52 20 privilege privilege NOUN expositions-2352 52 21 ( ( PUNCT expositions-2352 52 22 without without ADP expositions-2352 52 23 knowing know VERB expositions-2352 52 24 this this DET expositions-2352 52 25 individual individual ADJ expositions-2352 52 26 ’s ’s PART expositions-2352 52 27 own own ADJ expositions-2352 52 28 ethnicity ethnicity NOUN expositions-2352 52 29 — — PUNCT expositions-2352 52 30 nor nor CCONJ expositions-2352 52 31 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 52 32 more more ADV expositions-2352 52 33 importantly importantly ADV expositions-2352 52 34 in in ADP expositions-2352 52 35 my my PRON expositions-2352 52 36 view view NOUN expositions-2352 52 37 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 52 38 did do AUX expositions-2352 52 39 garfield garfield PROPN expositions-2352 52 40 take take VERB expositions-2352 52 41 on on ADP expositions-2352 52 42 the the DET expositions-2352 52 43 critic critic NOUN expositions-2352 52 44 ’s ’s PART expositions-2352 52 45 actual actual ADJ expositions-2352 52 46 charge charge NOUN expositions-2352 52 47 ) ) PUNCT expositions-2352 52 48 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 52 49 van van PROPN expositions-2352 52 50 norden norden PROPN expositions-2352 52 51 suggests suggest VERB expositions-2352 52 52 that that SCONJ expositions-2352 52 53 all all DET expositions-2352 52 54 philosophy philosophy NOUN expositions-2352 52 55 departments department NOUN expositions-2352 52 56 not not PART expositions-2352 52 57 teaching teach VERB expositions-2352 52 58 non non ADJ expositions-2352 52 59 - - ADJ expositions-2352 52 60 western western ADJ expositions-2352 52 61 philosophy philosophy NOUN expositions-2352 52 62 are be AUX expositions-2352 52 63 “ " PUNCT expositions-2352 52 64 ethnocentric ethnocentric ADJ expositions-2352 52 65 ” " PUNCT expositions-2352 52 66 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 52 67 challenges challenge VERB expositions-2352 52 68 their their PRON expositions-2352 52 69 “ " PUNCT expositions-2352 52 70 chauvinism chauvinism NOUN expositions-2352 52 71 ” " PUNCT expositions-2352 52 72 without without ADP expositions-2352 52 73 bothering bother VERB expositions-2352 52 74 to to PART expositions-2352 52 75 demonstrate demonstrate VERB expositions-2352 52 76 that that SCONJ expositions-2352 52 77 their their PRON expositions-2352 52 78 lack lack NOUN expositions-2352 52 79 of of ADP expositions-2352 52 80 non non ADJ expositions-2352 52 81 - - ADJ expositions-2352 52 82 western western ADJ expositions-2352 52 83 offerings offering NOUN expositions-2352 52 84 are be AUX expositions-2352 52 85 due due ADJ expositions-2352 52 86 to to ADP expositions-2352 52 87 ethnocentrism ethnocentrism NOUN expositions-2352 52 88 or or CCONJ expositions-2352 52 89 chauvinism chauvinism NOUN expositions-2352 52 90 rather rather ADV expositions-2352 52 91 than than ADP expositions-2352 52 92 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 52 93 say say INTJ expositions-2352 52 94 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 52 95 a a DET expositions-2352 52 96 dearth dearth NOUN expositions-2352 52 97 of of ADP expositions-2352 52 98 qualified qualified ADJ expositions-2352 52 99 scholars scholar NOUN expositions-2352 52 100 on on ADP expositions-2352 52 101 the the DET expositions-2352 52 102 market.4 market.4 PROPN expositions-2352 52 103 such such ADJ expositions-2352 52 104 labeling labeling NOUN expositions-2352 52 105 is be AUX expositions-2352 52 106 irresponsible irresponsible ADJ expositions-2352 52 107 in in ADP expositions-2352 52 108 the the DET expositions-2352 52 109 current current ADJ expositions-2352 52 110 political political ADJ expositions-2352 52 111 climate climate NOUN expositions-2352 52 112 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 52 113 in in ADP expositions-2352 52 114 which which PRON expositions-2352 52 115 explicit explicit ADJ expositions-2352 52 116 ethnocentrism ethnocentrism NOUN expositions-2352 52 117 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 52 118 chauvinism chauvinism NOUN expositions-2352 52 119 have have AUX expositions-2352 52 120 made make VERB expositions-2352 52 121 significant significant ADJ expositions-2352 52 122 gains gain NOUN expositions-2352 52 123 in in ADP expositions-2352 52 124 recent recent ADJ expositions-2352 52 125 years year NOUN expositions-2352 52 126 ; ; PUNCT expositions-2352 52 127 it it PRON expositions-2352 52 128 is be AUX expositions-2352 52 129 19 19 NUM expositions-2352 52 130 taliaferro taliaferro NOUN expositions-2352 52 131     SPACE expositions-2352 52 132 important important ADJ expositions-2352 52 133 that that SCONJ expositions-2352 52 134 actual actual ADJ expositions-2352 52 135 chauvinism chauvinism NOUN expositions-2352 52 136 not not PART expositions-2352 52 137 be be AUX expositions-2352 52 138 minimized minimize VERB expositions-2352 52 139 by by ADP expositions-2352 52 140 accusations accusation NOUN expositions-2352 52 141 against against ADP expositions-2352 52 142 those those PRON expositions-2352 52 143 who who PRON expositions-2352 52 144 teach teach VERB expositions-2352 52 145 kant kant NOUN expositions-2352 52 146 in in ADP expositions-2352 52 147 place place NOUN expositions-2352 52 148 of of ADP expositions-2352 52 149 krishna krishna PROPN expositions-2352 52 150 in in ADP expositions-2352 52 151 their their PRON expositions-2352 52 152 classrooms classroom NOUN expositions-2352 52 153 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 53 1 but but CCONJ expositions-2352 53 2 beyond beyond ADP expositions-2352 53 3 the the DET expositions-2352 53 4 political political ADJ expositions-2352 53 5 implications implication NOUN expositions-2352 53 6 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 53 7 is be AUX expositions-2352 53 8 van van PROPN expositions-2352 53 9 norden norden PROPN expositions-2352 53 10 not not PART expositions-2352 53 11 concerned concerned ADJ expositions-2352 53 12 that that SCONJ expositions-2352 53 13 his his PRON expositions-2352 53 14 argument argument NOUN expositions-2352 53 15 — — PUNCT expositions-2352 53 16 viz viz PROPN expositions-2352 53 17 . . PROPN expositions-2352 53 18 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 53 19 that that SCONJ expositions-2352 53 20 american american ADJ expositions-2352 53 21 philosophy philosophy NOUN expositions-2352 53 22 departments department NOUN expositions-2352 53 23 are be AUX expositions-2352 53 24 largely largely ADV expositions-2352 53 25 chauvinist chauvinist ADJ expositions-2352 53 26 — — PUNCT expositions-2352 53 27 is be AUX expositions-2352 53 28 not not PART expositions-2352 53 29 backed back VERB expositions-2352 53 30 by by ADP expositions-2352 53 31 sufficient sufficient ADJ expositions-2352 53 32 evidence evidence NOUN expositions-2352 53 33 ( ( PUNCT expositions-2352 53 34 say say INTJ expositions-2352 53 35 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 53 36 interview interview NOUN expositions-2352 53 37 or or CCONJ expositions-2352 53 38 survey survey NOUN expositions-2352 53 39 data datum NOUN expositions-2352 53 40 beyond beyond ADP expositions-2352 53 41 the the DET expositions-2352 53 42 comment comment NOUN expositions-2352 53 43 sections section NOUN expositions-2352 53 44 of of ADP expositions-2352 53 45 a a DET expositions-2352 53 46 magazine magazine NOUN expositions-2352 53 47 ) ) PUNCT expositions-2352 53 48 ? ? PUNCT expositions-2352 54 1 if if SCONJ expositions-2352 54 2 not not PART expositions-2352 54 3 — — PUNCT expositions-2352 54 4 if if SCONJ expositions-2352 54 5 this this DET expositions-2352 54 6 “ " PUNCT expositions-2352 54 7 manifesto manifesto NOUN expositions-2352 54 8 ” " PUNCT expositions-2352 54 9 is be AUX expositions-2352 54 10 intended intend VERB expositions-2352 54 11 only only ADV expositions-2352 54 12 to to PART expositions-2352 54 13 “ " PUNCT expositions-2352 54 14 raise raise VERB expositions-2352 54 15 awareness awareness NOUN expositions-2352 54 16 ” " PUNCT expositions-2352 54 17 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 54 18 “ " PUNCT expositions-2352 54 19 incite incite VERB expositions-2352 54 20 discussion discussion NOUN expositions-2352 54 21 ” " PUNCT expositions-2352 54 22 without without ADP expositions-2352 54 23 leading lead VERB expositions-2352 54 24 to to ADP expositions-2352 54 25 any any DET expositions-2352 54 26 particular particular ADJ expositions-2352 54 27 conclusions conclusion NOUN expositions-2352 54 28 — — PUNCT expositions-2352 54 29 then then ADV expositions-2352 54 30 it it PRON expositions-2352 54 31 is be AUX expositions-2352 54 32 unclear unclear ADJ expositions-2352 54 33 why why SCONJ expositions-2352 54 34 we we PRON expositions-2352 54 35 are be AUX expositions-2352 54 36 talking talk VERB expositions-2352 54 37 about about ADP expositions-2352 54 38 philosophy philosophy NOUN expositions-2352 54 39 rather rather ADV expositions-2352 54 40 than than ADP expositions-2352 54 41 politics politic NOUN expositions-2352 54 42 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 54 43 rhetoric rhetoric NOUN expositions-2352 54 44 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 54 45 or or CCONJ expositions-2352 54 46 even even ADV expositions-2352 54 47 journalism journalism NOUN expositions-2352 54 48 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 55 1 but but CCONJ expositions-2352 55 2 if if SCONJ expositions-2352 55 3 van van PROPN expositions-2352 55 4 norden norden PROPN expositions-2352 55 5 is be AUX expositions-2352 55 6 concerned concerned ADJ expositions-2352 55 7 about about ADP expositions-2352 55 8 the the DET expositions-2352 55 9 standards standard NOUN expositions-2352 55 10 of of ADP expositions-2352 55 11 argumentation argumentation NOUN expositions-2352 55 12 of of ADP expositions-2352 55 13 his his PRON expositions-2352 55 14 discipline discipline NOUN expositions-2352 55 15 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 55 16 then then ADV expositions-2352 55 17 the the DET expositions-2352 55 18 tendentiousness tendentiousness NOUN expositions-2352 55 19 that that PRON expositions-2352 55 20 appears appear VERB expositions-2352 55 21 at at ADP expositions-2352 55 22 various various ADJ expositions-2352 55 23 points point NOUN expositions-2352 55 24 in in ADP expositions-2352 55 25 this this DET expositions-2352 55 26 otherwise otherwise ADV expositions-2352 55 27 thought think VERB expositions-2352 55 28 - - PUNCT expositions-2352 55 29 provoking provoke VERB expositions-2352 55 30 book book NOUN expositions-2352 55 31 is be AUX expositions-2352 55 32 a a DET expositions-2352 55 33 problem problem NOUN expositions-2352 55 34 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 56 1 van van PROPN expositions-2352 56 2 norden norden PROPN expositions-2352 56 3 ’s ’s PART expositions-2352 56 4 invocation invocation NOUN expositions-2352 56 5 of of ADP expositions-2352 56 6 the the DET expositions-2352 56 7 late late PROPN expositions-2352 56 8 justice justice PROPN expositions-2352 56 9 antonin antonin PROPN expositions-2352 56 10 scalia scalia PROPN expositions-2352 56 11 ’s ’s PART expositions-2352 56 12 dissent dissent NOUN expositions-2352 56 13 in in ADP expositions-2352 56 14 obergefell obergefell NOUN expositions-2352 56 15 v. v. ADP expositions-2352 56 16 hodges hodges PROPN expositions-2352 56 17 is be AUX expositions-2352 56 18 exemplary exemplary ADJ expositions-2352 56 19 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 57 1 there there ADV expositions-2352 57 2 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 57 3 as as SCONJ expositions-2352 57 4 van van PROPN expositions-2352 57 5 norden norden PROPN expositions-2352 57 6 notes notes PROPN expositions-2352 57 7 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 57 8 scalia scalia PROPN expositions-2352 57 9 lampooned lampoon VERB expositions-2352 57 10 the the DET expositions-2352 57 11 majority majority NOUN expositions-2352 57 12 opinion opinion NOUN expositions-2352 57 13 as as ADP expositions-2352 57 14 “ " PUNCT expositions-2352 57 15 having having AUX expositions-2352 57 16 descended descend VERB expositions-2352 57 17 from from ADP expositions-2352 57 18 the the DET expositions-2352 57 19 disciplined discipline VERB expositions-2352 57 20 legal legal ADJ expositions-2352 57 21 reasoning reasoning NOUN expositions-2352 57 22 of of ADP expositions-2352 57 23 john john PROPN expositions-2352 57 24 marshall marshall PROPN expositions-2352 57 25 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 57 26 joseph joseph PROPN expositions-2352 57 27 story story NOUN expositions-2352 57 28 to to ADP expositions-2352 57 29 the the DET expositions-2352 57 30 mystical mystical ADJ expositions-2352 57 31 aphorisms aphorism NOUN expositions-2352 57 32 of of ADP expositions-2352 57 33 the the DET expositions-2352 57 34 fortune fortune NOUN expositions-2352 57 35 cookie cookie NOUN expositions-2352 57 36 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 58 1 ”5 ”5 PUNCT expositions-2352 58 2 to to ADP expositions-2352 58 3 van van PROPN expositions-2352 58 4 norden norden PROPN expositions-2352 58 5 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 58 6 this this DET expositions-2352 58 7 fortune fortune NOUN expositions-2352 58 8 cookie cookie NOUN expositions-2352 58 9 reference reference NOUN expositions-2352 58 10 signals signal VERB expositions-2352 58 11 clear clear ADJ expositions-2352 58 12 western western ADJ expositions-2352 58 13 centrism centrism NOUN expositions-2352 58 14 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 59 1 why why SCONJ expositions-2352 59 2 ? ? PUNCT expositions-2352 60 1 because because SCONJ expositions-2352 60 2 chief chief PROPN expositions-2352 60 3 justice justice PROPN expositions-2352 60 4 anthony anthony PROPN expositions-2352 60 5 kennedy kennedy PROPN expositions-2352 60 6 had have AUX expositions-2352 60 7 quoted quote VERB expositions-2352 60 8 two two NUM expositions-2352 60 9 great great ADJ expositions-2352 60 10 thinkers thinker NOUN expositions-2352 60 11 of of ADP expositions-2352 60 12 antiquity antiquity NOUN expositions-2352 60 13 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 60 14 confucius confucius NOUN expositions-2352 60 15 ( ( PUNCT expositions-2352 60 16 551–479 551–479 NUM expositions-2352 60 17 bce bce NOUN expositions-2352 60 18 ) ) PUNCT expositions-2352 60 19 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 60 20 cicero cicero PROPN expositions-2352 60 21 ( ( PUNCT expositions-2352 60 22 106 106 NUM expositions-2352 60 23 – – SYM expositions-2352 60 24 43 43 NUM expositions-2352 60 25 bce bce NOUN expositions-2352 60 26 ) ) PUNCT expositions-2352 60 27 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 61 1 “ " PUNCT expositions-2352 61 2 notice notice NOUN expositions-2352 61 3 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 61 4 ” " PUNCT expositions-2352 61 5 van van PROPN expositions-2352 61 6 norden norden PROPN expositions-2352 61 7 advises advise VERB expositions-2352 61 8 the the DET expositions-2352 61 9 reader reader NOUN expositions-2352 61 10 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 61 11 “ " PUNCT expositions-2352 61 12 that that DET expositions-2352 61 13 scalia scalia PROPN expositions-2352 61 14 said say VERB expositions-2352 61 15 nothing nothing PRON expositions-2352 61 16 that that PRON expositions-2352 61 17 could could AUX expositions-2352 61 18 might might AUX expositions-2352 61 19 be be AUX expositions-2352 61 20 interpreted interpret VERB expositions-2352 61 21 as as ADP expositions-2352 61 22 an an DET expositions-2352 61 23 aspersion aspersion NOUN expositions-2352 61 24 upon upon SCONJ expositions-2352 61 25 cicero cicero NOUN expositions-2352 61 26 ; ; PUNCT expositions-2352 61 27 only only ADV expositions-2352 61 28 confucius confucius NOUN expositions-2352 61 29 earned earn VERB expositions-2352 61 30 his his PRON expositions-2352 61 31 contempt contempt NOUN expositions-2352 61 32 ” " PUNCT expositions-2352 61 33 ( ( PUNCT expositions-2352 61 34 12–13 12–13 NUM expositions-2352 61 35 ) ) PUNCT expositions-2352 61 36 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 62 1 but but CCONJ expositions-2352 62 2 of of ADP expositions-2352 62 3 course course NOUN expositions-2352 62 4 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 62 5 scalia scalia PROPN expositions-2352 62 6 mentioned mention VERB expositions-2352 62 7 nothing nothing PRON expositions-2352 62 8 of of ADP expositions-2352 62 9 either either CCONJ expositions-2352 62 10 thinker thinker ADJ expositions-2352 62 11 ; ; PUNCT expositions-2352 62 12 rather rather ADV expositions-2352 62 13 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 62 14 he he PRON expositions-2352 62 15 merely merely ADV expositions-2352 62 16 decried decry VERB expositions-2352 62 17 the the DET expositions-2352 62 18 legal legal ADJ expositions-2352 62 19 reasoning reasoning NOUN expositions-2352 62 20 of of ADP expositions-2352 62 21 the the DET expositions-2352 62 22 court court NOUN expositions-2352 62 23 as as ADV expositions-2352 62 24 equal equal ADJ expositions-2352 62 25 to to ADP expositions-2352 62 26 “ " PUNCT expositions-2352 62 27 the the DET expositions-2352 62 28 mystical mystical ADJ expositions-2352 62 29 aphorisms aphorism NOUN expositions-2352 62 30 of of ADP expositions-2352 62 31 the the DET expositions-2352 62 32 fortune fortune NOUN expositions-2352 62 33 cookie cookie NOUN expositions-2352 62 34 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 62 35 ” " PUNCT expositions-2352 63 1 upon upon SCONJ expositions-2352 63 2 closer close ADJ expositions-2352 63 3 examination examination NOUN expositions-2352 63 4 of of ADP expositions-2352 63 5 scalia scalia PROPN expositions-2352 63 6 ’s ’s PART expositions-2352 63 7 dissent dissent NOUN expositions-2352 63 8 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 63 9 the the DET expositions-2352 63 10 move move NOUN expositions-2352 63 11 from from ADP expositions-2352 63 12 “ " PUNCT expositions-2352 63 13 fortune fortune NOUN expositions-2352 63 14 cookie cookie NOUN expositions-2352 63 15 ” " PUNCT expositions-2352 63 16 to to ADP expositions-2352 63 17 “ " PUNCT expositions-2352 63 18 confucius confucius NOUN expositions-2352 63 19 ” " PUNCT expositions-2352 63 20 is be AUX expositions-2352 63 21 even even ADV expositions-2352 63 22 less less ADV expositions-2352 63 23 justified justified ADJ expositions-2352 63 24 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 63 25 which which PRON expositions-2352 63 26 would would AUX expositions-2352 63 27 have have AUX expositions-2352 63 28 been be AUX expositions-2352 63 29 clear clear ADJ expositions-2352 63 30 had have AUX expositions-2352 63 31 van van PROPN expositions-2352 63 32 norden norden PROPN expositions-2352 63 33 cited cite VERB expositions-2352 63 34 the the DET expositions-2352 63 35 entire entire ADJ expositions-2352 63 36 footnote footnote NOUN expositions-2352 63 37 in in ADP expositions-2352 63 38 which which PRON expositions-2352 63 39 scalia scalia PROPN expositions-2352 63 40 ’s ’s PART expositions-2352 63 41 alleged allege VERB expositions-2352 63 42 “ " PUNCT expositions-2352 63 43 contempt contempt NOUN expositions-2352 63 44 ” " PUNCT expositions-2352 63 45 against against ADP expositions-2352 63 46 confucius confucius NOUN expositions-2352 63 47 appears appear VERB expositions-2352 63 48 : : PUNCT expositions-2352 63 49 if if SCONJ expositions-2352 63 50 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 63 51 even even ADV expositions-2352 63 52 as as SCONJ expositions-2352 63 53 the the DET expositions-2352 63 54 price price NOUN expositions-2352 63 55 to to PART expositions-2352 63 56 be be AUX expositions-2352 63 57 paid pay VERB expositions-2352 63 58 for for ADP expositions-2352 63 59 a a DET expositions-2352 63 60 fifth fifth ADJ expositions-2352 63 61 vote vote NOUN expositions-2352 63 62 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 63 63 i i PRON expositions-2352 63 64 ever ever ADV expositions-2352 63 65 joined join VERB expositions-2352 63 66 an an DET expositions-2352 63 67 opinion opinion NOUN expositions-2352 63 68 for for ADP expositions-2352 63 69 the the DET expositions-2352 63 70 court court NOUN expositions-2352 63 71 that that PRON expositions-2352 63 72 began begin VERB expositions-2352 63 73 : : PUNCT expositions-2352 63 74 “ " PUNCT expositions-2352 63 75 the the DET expositions-2352 63 76 constitution constitution NOUN expositions-2352 63 77 promises promise VERB expositions-2352 63 78 liberty liberty NOUN expositions-2352 63 79 to to ADP expositions-2352 63 80 all all ADV expositions-2352 63 81 within within ADP expositions-2352 63 82 its its PRON expositions-2352 63 83 reach reach NOUN expositions-2352 63 84 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 63 85 a a DET expositions-2352 63 86 liberty liberty NOUN expositions-2352 63 87 that that PRON expositions-2352 63 88 includes include VERB expositions-2352 63 89 certain certain ADJ expositions-2352 63 90 specific specific ADJ expositions-2352 63 91 rights right NOUN expositions-2352 63 92 that that PRON expositions-2352 63 93 allow allow VERB expositions-2352 63 94 persons person NOUN expositions-2352 63 95 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 63 96 within within ADP expositions-2352 63 97 a a DET expositions-2352 63 98 lawful lawful ADJ expositions-2352 63 99 realm realm NOUN expositions-2352 63 100 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 63 101 to to PART expositions-2352 63 102 define define VERB expositions-2352 63 103 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 63 104 express express VERB expositions-2352 63 105 their their PRON expositions-2352 63 106 identity identity NOUN expositions-2352 63 107 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 63 108 ” " PUNCT expositions-2352 63 109 i i PRON expositions-2352 63 110 would would AUX expositions-2352 63 111 hide hide VERB expositions-2352 63 112 my my PRON expositions-2352 63 113 head head NOUN expositions-2352 63 114 in in ADP expositions-2352 63 115 a a DET expositions-2352 63 116 bag bag NOUN expositions-2352 63 117 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 64 1 the the DET expositions-2352 64 2 supreme supreme PROPN expositions-2352 64 3 court court PROPN expositions-2352 64 4 of of ADP expositions-2352 64 5 the the DET expositions-2352 64 6 united united PROPN expositions-2352 64 7 states states PROPN expositions-2352 64 8 has have AUX expositions-2352 64 9 descended descend VERB expositions-2352 64 10 from from ADP expositions-2352 64 11 the the DET expositions-2352 64 12 disciplined discipline VERB expositions-2352 64 13 legal legal ADJ expositions-2352 64 14 reasoning reasoning NOUN expositions-2352 64 15 of of ADP expositions-2352 64 16 john john PROPN expositions-2352 64 17 marshall marshall PROPN expositions-2352 64 18 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 64 19 joseph joseph PROPN expositions-2352 64 20 story story NOUN expositions-2352 64 21 to to ADP expositions-2352 64 22 the the DET expositions-2352 64 23 mystical mystical ADJ expositions-2352 64 24 aphorisms aphorism NOUN expositions-2352 64 25 of of ADP expositions-2352 64 26 the the DET expositions-2352 64 27 fortune fortune NOUN expositions-2352 64 28 cookie cookie NOUN expositions-2352 64 29 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 65 1 less less ADV expositions-2352 65 2 manifesto manifesto NOUN expositions-2352 65 3 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 65 4 more more ADJ expositions-2352 65 5 philosophy philosophy NOUN expositions-2352 65 6 20 20 NUM expositions-2352 65 7         SPACE expositions-2352 65 8 the the DET expositions-2352 65 9 “ " PUNCT expositions-2352 65 10 mystical mystical ADJ expositions-2352 65 11 aphorism aphorism NOUN expositions-2352 65 12 ” " PUNCT expositions-2352 65 13 referred refer VERB expositions-2352 65 14 to to ADP expositions-2352 65 15 here here ADV expositions-2352 65 16 is be AUX expositions-2352 65 17 not not PART expositions-2352 65 18 the the DET expositions-2352 65 19 quotation quotation NOUN expositions-2352 65 20 from from ADP expositions-2352 65 21 confucius confucius NOUN expositions-2352 65 22 but but CCONJ expositions-2352 66 1 the the DET expositions-2352 66 2 rather rather ADV expositions-2352 66 3 what what PRON expositions-2352 66 4 scalia scalia PROPN expositions-2352 66 5 considered consider VERB expositions-2352 66 6 “ " PUNCT expositions-2352 66 7 silly silly ADJ expositions-2352 66 8 extravagances extravagance NOUN expositions-2352 66 9 … … PUNCT expositions-2352 66 10 of of ADP expositions-2352 66 11 thought thought NOUN expositions-2352 66 12 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 66 13 expression expression NOUN expositions-2352 66 14 ” " PUNCT expositions-2352 66 15 contained contain VERB expositions-2352 66 16 in in ADP expositions-2352 66 17 the the DET expositions-2352 66 18 court court NOUN expositions-2352 66 19 ’s ’s PART expositions-2352 66 20 official official ADJ expositions-2352 66 21 opinion opinion NOUN expositions-2352 66 22 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 67 1 it it PRON expositions-2352 67 2 is be AUX expositions-2352 67 3 admittedly admittedly ADV expositions-2352 67 4 possible possible ADJ expositions-2352 67 5 that that SCONJ expositions-2352 67 6 somewhere somewhere ADV expositions-2352 67 7 in in ADP expositions-2352 67 8 scalia scalia PROPN expositions-2352 67 9 ’s ’s PART expositions-2352 67 10 mind mind NOUN expositions-2352 67 11 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 67 12 knowingly knowingly ADV expositions-2352 67 13 or or CCONJ expositions-2352 67 14 unknowingly unknowingly ADV expositions-2352 67 15 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 67 16 it it PRON expositions-2352 67 17 was be AUX expositions-2352 67 18 really really ADV expositions-2352 67 19 the the DET expositions-2352 67 20 confucius confucius NOUN expositions-2352 67 21 quote quote INTJ expositions-2352 67 22 that that PRON expositions-2352 67 23 had have AUX expositions-2352 67 24 so so ADV expositions-2352 67 25 stoked stoke VERB expositions-2352 67 26 his his PRON expositions-2352 67 27 ire ire NOUN expositions-2352 67 28 ( ( PUNCT expositions-2352 67 29 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 67 30 van van PROPN expositions-2352 67 31 norden norden PROPN expositions-2352 67 32 is be AUX expositions-2352 67 33 not not PART expositions-2352 67 34 alone alone ADJ expositions-2352 67 35 in in ADP expositions-2352 67 36 assuming assume VERB expositions-2352 67 37 that that SCONJ expositions-2352 67 38 it it PRON expositions-2352 67 39 was be AUX expositions-2352 67 40 ) ) PUNCT expositions-2352 67 41 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 68 1 given give VERB expositions-2352 68 2 the the DET expositions-2352 68 3 difference difference NOUN expositions-2352 68 4 in in ADP expositions-2352 68 5 substance substance NOUN expositions-2352 68 6 between between ADP expositions-2352 68 7 chief chief PROPN expositions-2352 68 8 justice justice PROPN expositions-2352 68 9 kennedy kennedy PROPN expositions-2352 68 10 ’s ’s PROPN expositions-2352 68 11 ratio ratio PROPN expositions-2352 68 12 legis legis PROPN expositions-2352 68 13 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 68 14 that that PRON expositions-2352 68 15 of of ADP expositions-2352 68 16 scalia scalia PROPN expositions-2352 68 17 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 68 18 however however ADV expositions-2352 68 19 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 68 20 it it PRON expositions-2352 68 21 seems seem VERB expositions-2352 68 22 more more ADV expositions-2352 68 23 plausible plausible ADJ expositions-2352 68 24 — — PUNCT expositions-2352 68 25 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 68 26 certainly certainly ADV expositions-2352 68 27 a a DET expositions-2352 68 28 more more ADV expositions-2352 68 29 charitable charitable ADJ expositions-2352 68 30 reading reading NOUN expositions-2352 68 31 of of ADP expositions-2352 68 32 the the DET expositions-2352 68 33 late late ADJ expositions-2352 68 34 justice justice NOUN expositions-2352 68 35 ’s ’s PART expositions-2352 68 36 dissent dissent NOUN expositions-2352 68 37 — — PUNCT expositions-2352 68 38 to to PART expositions-2352 68 39 assume assume VERB expositions-2352 68 40 that that SCONJ expositions-2352 68 41 this this PRON expositions-2352 68 42 was be AUX expositions-2352 68 43 not not PART expositions-2352 68 44 the the DET expositions-2352 68 45 case case NOUN expositions-2352 68 46 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 69 1 nor nor CCONJ expositions-2352 69 2 is be AUX expositions-2352 69 3 it it PRON expositions-2352 69 4 fitting fitting ADJ expositions-2352 69 5 of of ADP expositions-2352 69 6 a a DET expositions-2352 69 7 philosopher philosopher NOUN expositions-2352 69 8 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 69 9 who who PRON expositions-2352 69 10 certainly certainly ADV expositions-2352 69 11 knows know VERB expositions-2352 69 12 that that DET expositions-2352 69 13 correlation correlation NOUN expositions-2352 69 14 ( ( PUNCT expositions-2352 69 15 kennedy kennedy PROPN expositions-2352 69 16 refers refer VERB expositions-2352 69 17 to to ADP expositions-2352 69 18 chinese chinese PROPN expositions-2352 69 19 thinker thinker PROPN expositions-2352 69 20 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 69 21 scalia scalia PROPN expositions-2352 69 22 disparages disparage VERB expositions-2352 69 23 allegedly allegedly ADV expositions-2352 69 24 chinese chinese ADJ expositions-2352 69 25 “ " PUNCT expositions-2352 69 26 fortune fortune NOUN expositions-2352 69 27 cookie cookie NOUN expositions-2352 69 28 ” " PUNCT expositions-2352 69 29 aphorisms aphorism NOUN expositions-2352 69 30 ) ) PUNCT expositions-2352 69 31 in in ADP expositions-2352 69 32 no no DET expositions-2352 69 33 way way NOUN expositions-2352 69 34 equates equate VERB expositions-2352 69 35 to to ADP expositions-2352 69 36 causation causation NOUN expositions-2352 69 37 ( ( PUNCT expositions-2352 69 38 therefore therefore ADV expositions-2352 69 39 it it PRON expositions-2352 69 40 is be AUX expositions-2352 69 41 the the DET expositions-2352 69 42 chineseness chineseness NOUN expositions-2352 69 43 of of ADP expositions-2352 69 44 kennedy kennedy PROPN expositions-2352 69 45 ’s ’s PART expositions-2352 69 46 opinion opinion NOUN expositions-2352 69 47 that that PRON expositions-2352 69 48 provoked provoke VERB expositions-2352 69 49 scalia scalia PROPN expositions-2352 69 50 ’s ’s PART expositions-2352 69 51 comment comment NOUN expositions-2352 69 52 — — PUNCT expositions-2352 69 53 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 69 54 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 69 55 furthermore furthermore ADV expositions-2352 69 56 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 69 57 that that SCONJ expositions-2352 69 58 scalia scalia PROPN expositions-2352 69 59 holds hold VERB expositions-2352 69 60 confucius confucius NOUN expositions-2352 69 61 in in ADP expositions-2352 69 62 “ " PUNCT expositions-2352 69 63 contempt contempt NOUN expositions-2352 69 64 ” " PUNCT expositions-2352 69 65 ) ) PUNCT expositions-2352 69 66 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 70 1 again again ADV expositions-2352 70 2 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 70 3 van van PROPN expositions-2352 70 4 norden norden PROPN expositions-2352 70 5 is be AUX expositions-2352 70 6 explicit explicit ADJ expositions-2352 70 7 about about ADP expositions-2352 70 8 the the DET expositions-2352 70 9 partisan partisan ADJ expositions-2352 70 10 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 70 11 polemic polemic ADJ expositions-2352 70 12 nature nature NOUN expositions-2352 70 13 of of ADP expositions-2352 70 14 this this DET expositions-2352 70 15 work work NOUN expositions-2352 70 16 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 70 17 so so CCONJ expositions-2352 70 18 in in ADP expositions-2352 70 19 some some DET expositions-2352 70 20 respects respect NOUN expositions-2352 70 21 this this DET expositions-2352 70 22 tendentious tendentious ADJ expositions-2352 70 23 argumentation argumentation NOUN expositions-2352 70 24 should should AUX expositions-2352 70 25 not not PART expositions-2352 70 26 come come VERB expositions-2352 70 27 as as ADP expositions-2352 70 28 a a DET expositions-2352 70 29 surprise surprise NOUN expositions-2352 70 30 ; ; PUNCT expositions-2352 70 31 he he PRON expositions-2352 70 32 is be AUX expositions-2352 70 33 not not PART expositions-2352 70 34 aiming aim VERB expositions-2352 70 35 for for ADP expositions-2352 70 36 scholarly scholarly ADJ expositions-2352 70 37 standards standard NOUN expositions-2352 70 38 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 71 1 still still ADV expositions-2352 71 2 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 71 3 i i PRON expositions-2352 71 4 question question VERB expositions-2352 71 5 the the DET expositions-2352 71 6 merit merit NOUN expositions-2352 71 7 of of ADP expositions-2352 71 8 this this DET expositions-2352 71 9 tactic tactic NOUN expositions-2352 71 10 for for ADP expositions-2352 71 11 achieving achieve VERB expositions-2352 71 12 the the DET expositions-2352 71 13 desired desire VERB expositions-2352 71 14 end end NOUN expositions-2352 71 15 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 71 16 at at ADP expositions-2352 71 17 least least ADJ expositions-2352 71 18 if if SCONJ expositions-2352 71 19 we we PRON expositions-2352 71 20 understand understand VERB expositions-2352 71 21 the the DET expositions-2352 71 22 ultimate ultimate ADJ expositions-2352 71 23 end end NOUN expositions-2352 71 24 of of ADP expositions-2352 71 25 writing write VERB expositions-2352 71 26 a a DET expositions-2352 71 27 “ " PUNCT expositions-2352 71 28 multicultural multicultural ADJ expositions-2352 71 29 manifesto manifesto NOUN expositions-2352 71 30 ” " PUNCT expositions-2352 71 31 to to PART expositions-2352 71 32 be be AUX expositions-2352 71 33 not not PART expositions-2352 71 34 merely merely ADV expositions-2352 71 35 provoking provoke VERB expositions-2352 71 36 discussion discussion NOUN expositions-2352 71 37 for for ADP expositions-2352 71 38 discussion discussion NOUN expositions-2352 71 39 ’s ’s PART expositions-2352 71 40 sake sake NOUN expositions-2352 71 41 but but SCONJ expositions-2352 71 42 to to PART expositions-2352 71 43 change change VERB expositions-2352 71 44 the the DET expositions-2352 71 45 minds mind NOUN expositions-2352 71 46 of of ADP expositions-2352 71 47 those those PRON expositions-2352 71 48 who who PRON expositions-2352 71 49 are be AUX expositions-2352 71 50 not not PART expositions-2352 71 51 yet yet ADV expositions-2352 71 52 convinced convince VERB expositions-2352 71 53 that that SCONJ expositions-2352 71 54 philosophy philosophy NOUN expositions-2352 71 55 departments department NOUN expositions-2352 71 56 ought ought AUX expositions-2352 71 57 to to PART expositions-2352 71 58 teach teach VERB expositions-2352 71 59 non non ADJ expositions-2352 71 60 - - ADJ expositions-2352 71 61 anglo anglo ADJ expositions-2352 71 62 - - PUNCT expositions-2352 71 63 european european ADJ expositions-2352 71 64 philosophy philosophy NOUN expositions-2352 71 65 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 72 1 in in ADP expositions-2352 72 2 other other ADJ expositions-2352 72 3 words word NOUN expositions-2352 72 4 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 72 5 my my PRON expositions-2352 72 6 chief chief ADJ expositions-2352 72 7 complaint complaint NOUN expositions-2352 72 8 with with ADP expositions-2352 72 9 the the DET expositions-2352 72 10 “ " PUNCT expositions-2352 72 11 manifesto manifesto NOUN expositions-2352 72 12 ” " PUNCT expositions-2352 72 13 aspect aspect NOUN expositions-2352 72 14 of of ADP expositions-2352 72 15 this this DET expositions-2352 72 16 book book NOUN expositions-2352 72 17 is be AUX expositions-2352 72 18 that that SCONJ expositions-2352 72 19 it it PRON expositions-2352 72 20 makes make VERB expositions-2352 72 21 the the DET expositions-2352 72 22 overall overall ADJ expositions-2352 72 23 project project NOUN expositions-2352 72 24 less less ADV expositions-2352 72 25 likely likely ADJ expositions-2352 72 26 to to PART expositions-2352 72 27 succeed succeed VERB expositions-2352 72 28 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 73 1 i i PRON expositions-2352 73 2 should should AUX expositions-2352 73 3 note note VERB expositions-2352 73 4 that that SCONJ expositions-2352 73 5 in in ADP expositions-2352 73 6 my my PRON expositions-2352 73 7 own own ADJ expositions-2352 73 8 case case NOUN expositions-2352 73 9 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 73 10 van van PROPN expositions-2352 73 11 norden norden PROPN expositions-2352 73 12 is be AUX expositions-2352 73 13 preaching preach VERB expositions-2352 73 14 to to ADP expositions-2352 73 15 the the DET expositions-2352 73 16 choir choir NOUN expositions-2352 73 17 ; ; PUNCT expositions-2352 73 18 i i PRON expositions-2352 73 19 already already ADV expositions-2352 73 20 incorporate incorporate VERB expositions-2352 73 21 non non ADJ expositions-2352 73 22 - - ADJ expositions-2352 73 23 anglo anglo ADJ expositions-2352 73 24 - - PUNCT expositions-2352 73 25 european european ADJ expositions-2352 73 26 sources source NOUN expositions-2352 73 27 from from ADP expositions-2352 73 28 my my PRON expositions-2352 73 29 own own ADJ expositions-2352 73 30 area area NOUN expositions-2352 73 31 of of ADP expositions-2352 73 32 study study NOUN expositions-2352 73 33 ( ( PUNCT expositions-2352 73 34 islamic islamic ADJ expositions-2352 73 35 philosophy philosophy NOUN expositions-2352 73 36 ) ) PUNCT expositions-2352 73 37 as as ADV expositions-2352 73 38 well well ADV expositions-2352 73 39 as as ADP expositions-2352 73 40 those those PRON expositions-2352 73 41 i i PRON expositions-2352 73 42 am be AUX expositions-2352 73 43 less less ADV expositions-2352 73 44 comfortable comfortable ADJ expositions-2352 73 45 teaching teaching NOUN expositions-2352 73 46 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 73 47 including include VERB expositions-2352 73 48 confucianism confucianism NOUN expositions-2352 73 49 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 73 50 hinduism hinduism NOUN expositions-2352 73 51 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 73 52 into into ADP expositions-2352 73 53 my my PRON expositions-2352 73 54 syllabi syllabus NOUN expositions-2352 73 55 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 74 1 i i PRON expositions-2352 74 2 also also ADV expositions-2352 74 3 share share VERB expositions-2352 74 4 most most ADJ expositions-2352 74 5 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 74 6 if if SCONJ expositions-2352 74 7 not not PART expositions-2352 74 8 all all PRON expositions-2352 74 9 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 74 10 of of ADP expositions-2352 74 11 his his PRON expositions-2352 74 12 objections objection NOUN expositions-2352 74 13 to to ADP expositions-2352 74 14 popular popular ADJ expositions-2352 74 15 ( ( PUNCT expositions-2352 74 16 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 74 17 partisan partisan ADJ expositions-2352 74 18 ) ) PUNCT expositions-2352 74 19 disdain disdain NOUN expositions-2352 74 20 for for ADP expositions-2352 74 21 philosophy philosophy NOUN expositions-2352 74 22 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 74 23 confusion confusion NOUN expositions-2352 74 24 over over ADP expositions-2352 74 25 its its PRON expositions-2352 74 26 merits merit NOUN expositions-2352 74 27 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 75 1 even even ADV expositions-2352 75 2 as as ADP expositions-2352 75 3 such such ADJ expositions-2352 75 4 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 75 5 i i PRON expositions-2352 75 6 found find VERB expositions-2352 75 7 the the DET expositions-2352 75 8 tone tone NOUN expositions-2352 75 9 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 75 10 direction direction NOUN expositions-2352 75 11 of of ADP expositions-2352 75 12 the the DET expositions-2352 75 13 book book NOUN expositions-2352 75 14 sufficiently sufficiently ADV expositions-2352 75 15 offputting offputting ADJ expositions-2352 75 16 that that SCONJ expositions-2352 75 17 i i PRON expositions-2352 75 18 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 75 19 a a DET expositions-2352 75 20 sympathetic sympathetic ADJ expositions-2352 75 21 reader reader NOUN expositions-2352 75 22 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 75 23 was be AUX expositions-2352 75 24 more more ADV expositions-2352 75 25 inclined inclined ADJ expositions-2352 75 26 to to PART expositions-2352 75 27 look look VERB expositions-2352 75 28 for for ADP expositions-2352 75 29 ways way NOUN expositions-2352 75 30 to to PART expositions-2352 75 31 disagree disagree VERB expositions-2352 75 32 with with ADP expositions-2352 75 33 van van PROPN expositions-2352 75 34 norden norden PROPN expositions-2352 75 35 than than ADP expositions-2352 75 36 ways way NOUN expositions-2352 75 37 to to PART expositions-2352 75 38 agree agree VERB expositions-2352 75 39 with with ADP expositions-2352 75 40 him he PRON expositions-2352 75 41 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 75 42 which which PRON expositions-2352 75 43 is be AUX expositions-2352 75 44 hardly hardly ADV expositions-2352 75 45 promising promise VERB expositions-2352 75 46 for for ADP expositions-2352 75 47 the the DET expositions-2352 75 48 book book NOUN expositions-2352 75 49 ’s ’s PART expositions-2352 75 50 potential potential NOUN expositions-2352 75 51 to to PART expositions-2352 75 52 change change VERB expositions-2352 75 53 minds mind NOUN expositions-2352 75 54 of of ADP expositions-2352 75 55 less less ADJ expositions-2352 75 56 sympathetic sympathetic ADJ expositions-2352 75 57 readers reader NOUN expositions-2352 75 58 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 76 1 in in ADP expositions-2352 76 2 fairness fairness NOUN expositions-2352 76 3 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 76 4 van van PROPN expositions-2352 76 5 norden norden PROPN expositions-2352 76 6 does do AUX expositions-2352 76 7 acknowledge acknowledge VERB expositions-2352 76 8 that that DET expositions-2352 76 9 lack lack NOUN expositions-2352 76 10 of of ADP expositions-2352 76 11 awareness awareness NOUN expositions-2352 76 12 of of ADP expositions-2352 76 13 non non ADJ expositions-2352 76 14 - - ADJ expositions-2352 76 15 western western ADJ expositions-2352 76 16 philosophy philosophy NOUN expositions-2352 76 17 is be AUX expositions-2352 76 18 not not PART expositions-2352 76 19 only only ADV expositions-2352 76 20 a a DET expositions-2352 76 21 conservative conservative ADJ expositions-2352 76 22 problem problem NOUN expositions-2352 76 23 ( ( PUNCT expositions-2352 76 24 e.g. e.g. ADV expositions-2352 76 25 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 76 26 13 13 NUM expositions-2352 76 27 ) ) PUNCT expositions-2352 76 28 ; ; PUNCT expositions-2352 76 29 still still ADV expositions-2352 76 30 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 76 31 his his PRON expositions-2352 76 32 engagement engagement NOUN expositions-2352 76 33 with with ADP expositions-2352 76 34 those those PRON expositions-2352 76 35 with with ADP expositions-2352 76 36 ideological ideological ADJ expositions-2352 76 37 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 76 38 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 76 39 to to PART expositions-2352 76 40 put put VERB expositions-2352 76 41 a a DET expositions-2352 76 42 finer fine ADJ expositions-2352 76 43 point point NOUN expositions-2352 76 44 on on ADP expositions-2352 76 45 it it PRON expositions-2352 76 46 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 76 47 political political ADJ expositions-2352 76 48 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 76 49 convictions conviction NOUN expositions-2352 76 50 that that PRON expositions-2352 76 51 clash clash VERB expositions-2352 76 52 with with ADP expositions-2352 76 53 his his PRON expositions-2352 76 54 own own ADJ expositions-2352 76 55 rarely rarely ADV expositions-2352 76 56 goes go VERB expositions-2352 76 57 very very ADV expositions-2352 76 58 deep deep ADJ expositions-2352 76 59 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 77 1 this this PRON expositions-2352 77 2 is be AUX expositions-2352 77 3 most most ADV expositions-2352 77 4 evident evident ADJ expositions-2352 77 5 in in ADP expositions-2352 77 6 the the DET expositions-2352 77 7 opening opening NOUN expositions-2352 77 8 chapter chapter NOUN expositions-2352 77 9 but but CCONJ expositions-2352 77 10 borders border NOUN expositions-2352 77 11 on on ADP expositions-2352 77 12 hypocriticism hypocriticism NOUN expositions-2352 77 13 in in ADP expositions-2352 77 14 chapter chapter NOUN expositions-2352 77 15 3 3 NUM expositions-2352 77 16 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 77 17 “ " PUNCT expositions-2352 77 18 trump trump VERB expositions-2352 77 19 ’s ’s PART expositions-2352 77 20 philosophers philosopher NOUN expositions-2352 77 21 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 77 22 ” " PUNCT expositions-2352 77 23 which which PRON expositions-2352 77 24 purports purport VERB expositions-2352 77 25 to to PART expositions-2352 77 26 take take VERB expositions-2352 77 27 to to ADP expositions-2352 77 28 task task NOUN expositions-2352 77 29 all all DET expositions-2352 77 30 those those PRON expositions-2352 77 31 who who PRON expositions-2352 77 32 want want VERB expositions-2352 77 33 to to PART expositions-2352 77 34 distinguish distinguish VERB expositions-2352 77 35 the the DET expositions-2352 77 36 west west NOUN expositions-2352 77 37 from from ADP expositions-2352 77 38 the the DET expositions-2352 77 39 21 21 NUM expositions-2352 77 40 taliaferro taliaferro NOUN expositions-2352 77 41     SPACE expositions-2352 77 42 rest rest NOUN expositions-2352 77 43 ( ( PUNCT expositions-2352 77 44 or or CCONJ expositions-2352 77 45 between between ADP expositions-2352 77 46 china china PROPN expositions-2352 77 47 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 77 48 the the DET expositions-2352 77 49 rest rest NOUN expositions-2352 77 50 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 77 51 or or CCONJ expositions-2352 77 52 between between ADP expositions-2352 77 53 any any DET expositions-2352 77 54 one one NUM expositions-2352 77 55 alleged allege VERB expositions-2352 77 56 civilization civilization NOUN expositions-2352 77 57 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 77 58 any any DET expositions-2352 77 59 other other ADJ expositions-2352 77 60 ): ): PUNCT expositions-2352 77 61 “ " PUNCT expositions-2352 77 62 they they PRON expositions-2352 77 63 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 77 64 ” " PUNCT expositions-2352 77 65 van van PROPN expositions-2352 77 66 norden norden PROPN expositions-2352 77 67 writes write VERB expositions-2352 77 68 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 77 69 “ " PUNCT expositions-2352 77 70 are be AUX expositions-2352 77 71 all all PRON expositions-2352 77 72 in in ADP expositions-2352 77 73 the the DET expositions-2352 77 74 business business NOUN expositions-2352 77 75 of of ADP expositions-2352 77 76 building build VERB expositions-2352 77 77 walls wall NOUN expositions-2352 77 78 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 77 79 ” " PUNCT expositions-2352 78 1 this this PRON expositions-2352 78 2 is be AUX expositions-2352 78 3 followed follow VERB expositions-2352 78 4 on on ADP expositions-2352 78 5 the the DET expositions-2352 78 6 very very ADV expositions-2352 78 7 next next ADJ expositions-2352 78 8 page page NOUN expositions-2352 78 9 by by ADP expositions-2352 78 10 a a DET expositions-2352 78 11 criticism criticism NOUN expositions-2352 78 12 of of ADP expositions-2352 78 13 president president PROPN expositions-2352 78 14 donald donald PROPN expositions-2352 78 15 trump trump PROPN expositions-2352 78 16 ’s ’s PART expositions-2352 78 17 supporters supporter NOUN expositions-2352 78 18 for for ADP expositions-2352 78 19 “ " PUNCT expositions-2352 78 20 separat[ing separat[e VERB expositions-2352 78 21 ] ] PUNCT expositions-2352 78 22 ‘ ' PUNCT expositions-2352 78 23 us we PRON expositions-2352 78 24 ’ ' PUNCT expositions-2352 78 25 from from ADP expositions-2352 78 26 ‘ ' PUNCT expositions-2352 78 27 them they PRON expositions-2352 78 28 ’ ' PUNCT expositions-2352 78 29 ” " PUNCT expositions-2352 78 30 ( ( PUNCT expositions-2352 78 31 86–87 86–87 NUM expositions-2352 78 32 ) ) PUNCT expositions-2352 78 33 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 79 1 while while SCONJ expositions-2352 79 2 it it PRON expositions-2352 79 3 is be AUX expositions-2352 79 4 fair fair ADJ expositions-2352 79 5 to to PART expositions-2352 79 6 criticize criticize VERB expositions-2352 79 7 those those PRON expositions-2352 79 8 who who PRON expositions-2352 79 9 seek seek VERB expositions-2352 79 10 to to PART expositions-2352 79 11 divide divide VERB expositions-2352 79 12 civilizations civilization NOUN expositions-2352 79 13 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 79 14 as as SCONJ expositions-2352 79 15 this this PRON expositions-2352 79 16 is be AUX expositions-2352 79 17 the the DET expositions-2352 79 18 project project NOUN expositions-2352 79 19 of of ADP expositions-2352 79 20 the the DET expositions-2352 79 21 book book NOUN expositions-2352 79 22 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 79 23 van van PROPN expositions-2352 79 24 norden norden PROPN expositions-2352 79 25 ’s ’s PART expositions-2352 79 26 polemic polemic NOUN expositions-2352 79 27 itself itself PRON expositions-2352 79 28 tends tend VERB expositions-2352 79 29 towards towards ADP expositions-2352 79 30 divisiveness divisiveness NOUN expositions-2352 79 31 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 80 1 the the DET expositions-2352 80 2 label label NOUN expositions-2352 80 3 “ " PUNCT expositions-2352 80 4 they they PRON expositions-2352 80 5 ” " PUNCT expositions-2352 80 6 to to PART expositions-2352 80 7 capture capture VERB expositions-2352 80 8 a a DET expositions-2352 80 9 wide wide ADJ expositions-2352 80 10 intellectual intellectual ADJ expositions-2352 80 11 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 80 12 political political ADJ expositions-2352 80 13 swatch swatch NOUN expositions-2352 80 14 of of ADP expositions-2352 80 15 people people NOUN expositions-2352 80 16 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 80 17 philosophers philosopher NOUN expositions-2352 80 18 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 80 19 not not PART expositions-2352 80 20 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 80 21 is be AUX expositions-2352 80 22 telling tell VERB expositions-2352 80 23 ; ; PUNCT expositions-2352 80 24 one one NUM expositions-2352 80 25 wonders wonder VERB expositions-2352 80 26 whether whether SCONJ expositions-2352 80 27 it it PRON expositions-2352 80 28 is be AUX expositions-2352 80 29 helpful helpful ADJ expositions-2352 80 30 to to PART expositions-2352 80 31 lump lump VERB expositions-2352 80 32 an an DET expositions-2352 80 33 ardent ardent ADJ expositions-2352 80 34 supporter supporter NOUN expositions-2352 80 35 of of ADP expositions-2352 80 36 the the DET expositions-2352 80 37 proposed propose VERB expositions-2352 80 38 physical physical ADJ expositions-2352 80 39 wall wall NOUN expositions-2352 80 40 between between ADP expositions-2352 80 41 the the DET expositions-2352 80 42 u.s u.s PROPN expositions-2352 80 43 . . PROPN expositions-2352 80 44 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 80 45 mexico mexico PROPN expositions-2352 80 46 together together ADV expositions-2352 80 47 with with ADP expositions-2352 80 48 a a DET expositions-2352 80 49 philosopher philosopher NOUN expositions-2352 80 50 who who PRON expositions-2352 80 51 wants want VERB expositions-2352 80 52 to to PART expositions-2352 80 53 stress stress VERB expositions-2352 80 54 the the DET expositions-2352 80 55 importance importance NOUN expositions-2352 80 56 of of ADP expositions-2352 80 57 classical classical ADJ expositions-2352 80 58 western western ADJ expositions-2352 80 59 sources source NOUN expositions-2352 80 60 in in ADP expositions-2352 80 61 philosophy philosophy NOUN expositions-2352 80 62 curriculum curriculum NOUN expositions-2352 80 63 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 81 1 likewise likewise ADV expositions-2352 81 2 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 81 3 later later ADV expositions-2352 81 4 in in ADP expositions-2352 81 5 chapter chapter NOUN expositions-2352 81 6 3 3 NUM expositions-2352 81 7 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 81 8 van van PROPN expositions-2352 81 9 norden norden PROPN expositions-2352 81 10 moves move NOUN expositions-2352 81 11 between between ADP expositions-2352 81 12 terms term NOUN expositions-2352 81 13 like like ADP expositions-2352 81 14 “ " PUNCT expositions-2352 81 15 contemporary contemporary ADJ expositions-2352 81 16 conservatives conservative NOUN expositions-2352 81 17 ” " PUNCT expositions-2352 81 18 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 81 19 “ " PUNCT expositions-2352 81 20 fundamentalist fundamentalist ADJ expositions-2352 81 21 ” " PUNCT expositions-2352 81 22 homeschooling homeschoole VERB expositions-2352 81 23 parents parent NOUN expositions-2352 81 24 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 81 25 free free ADJ expositions-2352 81 26 market market NOUN expositions-2352 81 27 enthusiasts enthusiast NOUN expositions-2352 81 28 without without ADP expositions-2352 81 29 considering consider VERB expositions-2352 81 30 whether whether SCONJ expositions-2352 81 31 there there PRON expositions-2352 81 32 might might AUX expositions-2352 81 33 be be AUX expositions-2352 81 34 important important ADJ expositions-2352 81 35 differences difference NOUN expositions-2352 81 36 among among ADP expositions-2352 81 37 these these DET expositions-2352 81 38 categories category NOUN expositions-2352 81 39 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 82 1 this this DET expositions-2352 82 2 partisan partisan ADJ expositions-2352 82 3 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 82 4 polemical polemical ADJ expositions-2352 82 5 tone tone NOUN expositions-2352 82 6 of of ADP expositions-2352 82 7 the the DET expositions-2352 82 8 book book NOUN expositions-2352 82 9 is be AUX expositions-2352 82 10 a a DET expositions-2352 82 11 great great ADJ expositions-2352 82 12 shame shame NOUN expositions-2352 82 13 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 82 14 though though ADV expositions-2352 82 15 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 82 16 because because SCONJ expositions-2352 82 17 beyond beyond ADP expositions-2352 82 18 the the DET expositions-2352 82 19 “ " PUNCT expositions-2352 82 20 manifesto manifesto NOUN expositions-2352 82 21 ” " PUNCT expositions-2352 82 22 aspect aspect NOUN expositions-2352 82 23 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 82 24 van van PROPN expositions-2352 82 25 norden norden PROPN expositions-2352 82 26 ’s ’s PART expositions-2352 82 27 book book NOUN expositions-2352 82 28 is be AUX expositions-2352 82 29 a a DET expositions-2352 82 30 fascinating fascinating ADJ expositions-2352 82 31 read read NOUN expositions-2352 82 32 that that PRON expositions-2352 82 33 serves serve VERB expositions-2352 82 34 as as ADP expositions-2352 82 35 an an DET expositions-2352 82 36 excellent excellent ADJ expositions-2352 82 37 entrée entrée NOUN expositions-2352 82 38 into into ADP expositions-2352 82 39 chinese chinese ADJ expositions-2352 82 40 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 82 41 confucian confucian ADJ expositions-2352 82 42 philosophy philosophy NOUN expositions-2352 82 43 for for ADP expositions-2352 82 44 the the DET expositions-2352 82 45 lay lay ADJ expositions-2352 82 46 person person NOUN expositions-2352 82 47 who who PRON expositions-2352 82 48 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 82 49 like like ADP expositions-2352 82 50 myself myself PRON expositions-2352 82 51 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 82 52 would would AUX expositions-2352 82 53 like like VERB expositions-2352 82 54 to to PART expositions-2352 82 55 incorporate incorporate VERB expositions-2352 82 56 more more ADV expositions-2352 82 57 chinese chinese ADJ expositions-2352 82 58 thought think VERB expositions-2352 82 59 into into ADP expositions-2352 82 60 her her PRON expositions-2352 82 61 syllabi syllabus NOUN expositions-2352 82 62 but but CCONJ expositions-2352 82 63 who who PRON expositions-2352 82 64 lacks lack VERB expositions-2352 82 65 the the DET expositions-2352 82 66 expertise expertise NOUN expositions-2352 82 67 to to PART expositions-2352 82 68 conduct conduct VERB expositions-2352 82 69 more more ADJ expositions-2352 82 70 than than ADP expositions-2352 82 71 a a DET expositions-2352 82 72 cursory cursory NOUN expositions-2352 82 73 reading read VERB expositions-2352 82 74 on on ADP expositions-2352 82 75 her her PRON expositions-2352 82 76 own own ADJ expositions-2352 82 77 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 83 1 the the DET expositions-2352 83 2 book book NOUN expositions-2352 83 3 is be AUX expositions-2352 83 4 at at ADP expositions-2352 83 5 its its PRON expositions-2352 83 6 strongest strong ADJ expositions-2352 83 7 in in ADP expositions-2352 83 8 the the DET expositions-2352 83 9 second second ADJ expositions-2352 83 10 chapter chapter NOUN expositions-2352 83 11 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 83 12 “ " PUNCT expositions-2352 83 13 traditions tradition NOUN expositions-2352 83 14 in in ADP expositions-2352 83 15 dialogue dialogue NOUN expositions-2352 83 16 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 83 17 ” " PUNCT expositions-2352 83 18 which which PRON expositions-2352 83 19 demonstrates demonstrate VERB expositions-2352 83 20 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 83 21 through through ADP expositions-2352 83 22 exegesis exegesis NOUN expositions-2352 83 23 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 83 24 analysis analysis NOUN expositions-2352 83 25 of of ADP expositions-2352 83 26 well well ADV expositions-2352 83 27 - - PUNCT expositions-2352 83 28 chosen choose VERB expositions-2352 83 29 texts text NOUN expositions-2352 83 30 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 83 31 topics topic NOUN expositions-2352 83 32 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 83 33 that that SCONJ expositions-2352 83 34 chinese chinese ADJ expositions-2352 83 35 philosophy philosophy NOUN expositions-2352 83 36 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 83 37 western western ADJ expositions-2352 83 38 philosophy philosophy NOUN expositions-2352 83 39 can can AUX expositions-2352 83 40 be be AUX expositions-2352 83 41 woven weave VERB expositions-2352 83 42 seamlessly seamlessly ADV expositions-2352 83 43 together together ADV expositions-2352 83 44 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 83 45 whether whether SCONJ expositions-2352 83 46 in in ADP expositions-2352 83 47 teaching teaching NOUN expositions-2352 83 48 or or CCONJ expositions-2352 83 49 scholarship scholarship NOUN expositions-2352 83 50 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 84 1 most most ADV expositions-2352 84 2 notable notable ADJ expositions-2352 84 3 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 84 4 perhaps perhaps ADV expositions-2352 84 5 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 84 6 is be AUX expositions-2352 84 7 van van PROPN expositions-2352 84 8 norden norden PROPN expositions-2352 84 9 ’s ’s PART expositions-2352 84 10 detailed detailed ADJ expositions-2352 84 11 exploration exploration NOUN expositions-2352 84 12 of of ADP expositions-2352 84 13 the the DET expositions-2352 84 14 idea idea NOUN expositions-2352 84 15 of of ADP expositions-2352 84 16 weakness weakness NOUN expositions-2352 84 17 of of ADP expositions-2352 84 18 will will NOUN expositions-2352 84 19 ( ( PUNCT expositions-2352 84 20 akrasia akrasia NOUN expositions-2352 84 21 ) ) PUNCT expositions-2352 84 22 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 85 1 van van PROPN expositions-2352 85 2 norden norden PROPN expositions-2352 85 3 draws draw VERB expositions-2352 85 4 from from ADP expositions-2352 85 5 the the DET expositions-2352 85 6 neo neo ADJ expositions-2352 85 7 - - ADJ expositions-2352 85 8 confucian confucian ADJ expositions-2352 85 9 text text NOUN expositions-2352 85 10 the the DET expositions-2352 85 11 great great ADJ expositions-2352 85 12 learning learning NOUN expositions-2352 85 13 in in ADP expositions-2352 85 14 showing show VERB expositions-2352 85 15 how how SCONJ expositions-2352 85 16 a a DET expositions-2352 85 17 distinction distinction NOUN expositions-2352 85 18 between between ADP expositions-2352 85 19 “ " PUNCT expositions-2352 85 20 genuine genuine ADJ expositions-2352 85 21 knowledge knowledge NOUN expositions-2352 85 22 ” " PUNCT expositions-2352 85 23 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 85 24 “ " PUNCT expositions-2352 85 25 common common ADJ expositions-2352 85 26 knowledge knowledge NOUN expositions-2352 85 27 ” " PUNCT expositions-2352 85 28 can can AUX expositions-2352 85 29 inform inform VERB expositions-2352 85 30 the the DET expositions-2352 85 31 debate debate NOUN expositions-2352 85 32 — — PUNCT expositions-2352 85 33 present present ADJ expositions-2352 85 34 in in ADP expositions-2352 85 35 the the DET expositions-2352 85 36 neo neo ADJ expositions-2352 85 37 - - ADJ expositions-2352 85 38 confucian confucian ADJ expositions-2352 85 39 sources source NOUN expositions-2352 85 40 as as ADP expositions-2352 85 41 in in ADP expositions-2352 85 42 plato plato PROPN expositions-2352 85 43 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 85 44 aristotle aristotle PROPN expositions-2352 85 45 — — PUNCT expositions-2352 85 46 over over ADP expositions-2352 85 47 whether whether SCONJ expositions-2352 85 48 weakness weakness NOUN expositions-2352 85 49 of of ADP expositions-2352 85 50 will will AUX expositions-2352 85 51 exists exist VERB expositions-2352 85 52 ( ( PUNCT expositions-2352 85 53 see see VERB expositions-2352 85 54 72ff 72ff NOUN expositions-2352 85 55 ) ) PUNCT expositions-2352 85 56 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 86 1 this this DET expositions-2352 86 2 chapter chapter NOUN expositions-2352 86 3 deals deal VERB expositions-2352 86 4 a a DET expositions-2352 86 5 strong strong ADJ expositions-2352 86 6 rebuke rebuke NOUN expositions-2352 86 7 to to ADP expositions-2352 86 8 van van PROPN expositions-2352 86 9 norden norden PROPN expositions-2352 86 10 ’s ’s PART expositions-2352 86 11 critics critic NOUN expositions-2352 86 12 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 86 13 other other ADJ expositions-2352 86 14 skeptics skeptic NOUN expositions-2352 86 15 of of ADP expositions-2352 86 16 non non ADJ expositions-2352 86 17 - - ADJ expositions-2352 86 18 western western ADJ expositions-2352 86 19 philosophy philosophy NOUN expositions-2352 86 20 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 86 21 thought think VERB expositions-2352 86 22 ; ; PUNCT expositions-2352 86 23 his his PRON expositions-2352 86 24 comparisons comparison NOUN expositions-2352 86 25 of of ADP expositions-2352 86 26 various various ADJ expositions-2352 86 27 aspects aspect NOUN expositions-2352 86 28 of of ADP expositions-2352 86 29 chinese chinese ADJ expositions-2352 86 30 philosophy philosophy NOUN expositions-2352 86 31 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 86 32 politics politic NOUN expositions-2352 86 33 with with ADP expositions-2352 86 34 their their PRON expositions-2352 86 35 analogues analogue NOUN expositions-2352 86 36 in in ADP expositions-2352 86 37 the the DET expositions-2352 86 38 west west NOUN expositions-2352 86 39 betray betray VERB expositions-2352 86 40 a a DET expositions-2352 86 41 love love NOUN expositions-2352 86 42 of of ADP expositions-2352 86 43 both both PRON expositions-2352 86 44 in in ADP expositions-2352 86 45 such such DET expositions-2352 86 46 a a DET expositions-2352 86 47 way way NOUN expositions-2352 86 48 that that PRON expositions-2352 86 49 van van PROPN expositions-2352 86 50 norden norden PROPN expositions-2352 86 51 could could AUX expositions-2352 86 52 likely likely ADV expositions-2352 86 53 win win VERB expositions-2352 86 54 over over ADP expositions-2352 86 55 even even ADV expositions-2352 86 56 the the DET expositions-2352 86 57 most most ADV expositions-2352 86 58 anglophile anglophile NOUN expositions-2352 86 59 of of ADP expositions-2352 86 60 philosophers philosopher NOUN expositions-2352 86 61 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 87 1 the the DET expositions-2352 87 2 book book NOUN expositions-2352 87 3 leaves leave VERB expositions-2352 87 4 the the DET expositions-2352 87 5 reader reader NOUN expositions-2352 87 6 wanting want VERB expositions-2352 87 7 to to PART expositions-2352 87 8 revisit revisit VERB expositions-2352 87 9 the the DET expositions-2352 87 10 analects analect NOUN expositions-2352 87 11 with with ADP expositions-2352 87 12 a a DET expositions-2352 87 13 fresh fresh ADJ expositions-2352 87 14 eye eye NOUN expositions-2352 87 15 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 87 16 certainly certainly ADV expositions-2352 87 17 recommends recommend VERB expositions-2352 87 18 his his PRON expositions-2352 87 19 excellent excellent ADJ expositions-2352 87 20 list list NOUN expositions-2352 87 21 of of ADP expositions-2352 87 22 less less ADV expositions-2352 87 23 commonly commonly ADV expositions-2352 87 24 taught teach VERB expositions-2352 87 25 philosophies philosophy NOUN expositions-2352 87 26 on on ADP expositions-2352 87 27 his his PRON expositions-2352 87 28 website website NOUN expositions-2352 87 29 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 88 1 chapter chapter NOUN expositions-2352 88 2 2 2 NUM expositions-2352 88 3 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 88 4 then then ADV expositions-2352 88 5 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 88 6 achieves achieve VERB expositions-2352 88 7 through through ADP expositions-2352 88 8 enactment enactment NOUN expositions-2352 88 9 what what PRON expositions-2352 88 10 van van PROPN expositions-2352 88 11 norden norden PROPN expositions-2352 88 12 sets set VERB expositions-2352 88 13 out out ADP expositions-2352 88 14 to to PART expositions-2352 88 15 achieve achieve VERB expositions-2352 88 16 through through ADP expositions-2352 88 17 argumentation argumentation NOUN expositions-2352 88 18 in in ADP expositions-2352 88 19 the the DET expositions-2352 88 20 rest rest NOUN expositions-2352 88 21 of of ADP expositions-2352 88 22 the the DET expositions-2352 88 23 book book NOUN expositions-2352 88 24 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 88 25 namely namely ADV expositions-2352 88 26 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 88 27 to to PART expositions-2352 88 28 persuade persuade VERB expositions-2352 88 29 the the DET expositions-2352 88 30 reader reader NOUN expositions-2352 88 31 that that SCONJ expositions-2352 88 32 non non ADJ expositions-2352 88 33 - - ADJ expositions-2352 88 34 western western ADJ expositions-2352 88 35 thought think VERB expositions-2352 88 36 less less ADV expositions-2352 88 37 manifesto manifesto NOUN expositions-2352 88 38 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 88 39 more more ADJ expositions-2352 88 40 philosophy philosophy NOUN expositions-2352 88 41 22 22 NUM expositions-2352 88 42         SPACE expositions-2352 88 43 can can AUX expositions-2352 88 44 be be AUX expositions-2352 88 45 just just ADV expositions-2352 88 46 as as ADV expositions-2352 88 47 philosophical philosophical ADJ expositions-2352 88 48 as as ADP expositions-2352 88 49 western western ADJ expositions-2352 88 50 thought thought NOUN expositions-2352 88 51 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 88 52 therefore therefore ADV expositions-2352 88 53 merits merit VERB expositions-2352 88 54 a a DET expositions-2352 88 55 place place NOUN expositions-2352 88 56 within within ADP expositions-2352 88 57 the the DET expositions-2352 88 58 halls hall NOUN expositions-2352 88 59 of of ADP expositions-2352 88 60 western western ADJ expositions-2352 88 61 universities university NOUN expositions-2352 88 62 ’ ’ PART expositions-2352 88 63 philosophy philosophy NOUN expositions-2352 88 64 departments department NOUN expositions-2352 88 65 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 89 1 but but CCONJ expositions-2352 89 2 this this PRON expositions-2352 89 3 raises raise VERB expositions-2352 89 4 a a DET expositions-2352 89 5 basic basic ADJ expositions-2352 89 6 question question NOUN expositions-2352 89 7 behind behind ADP expositions-2352 89 8 van van PROPN expositions-2352 89 9 norden norden PROPN expositions-2352 89 10 ’s ’s PART expositions-2352 89 11 entire entire ADJ expositions-2352 89 12 project project NOUN expositions-2352 89 13 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 89 14 one one NUM expositions-2352 89 15 he he PRON expositions-2352 89 16 leaves leave VERB expositions-2352 89 17 unanswered unanswered ADJ expositions-2352 89 18 : : PUNCT expositions-2352 89 19 what what PRON expositions-2352 89 20 is be AUX expositions-2352 89 21 at at ADP expositions-2352 89 22 stake stake NOUN expositions-2352 89 23 in in ADP expositions-2352 89 24 labeling label VERB expositions-2352 89 25 a a DET expositions-2352 89 26 given give VERB expositions-2352 89 27 figure figure NOUN expositions-2352 89 28 a a DET expositions-2352 89 29 “ " PUNCT expositions-2352 89 30 philosopher philosopher NOUN expositions-2352 89 31 ” " PUNCT expositions-2352 89 32 rather rather ADV expositions-2352 89 33 than than ADP expositions-2352 89 34 a a DET expositions-2352 89 35 “ " PUNCT expositions-2352 89 36 thinker thinker NOUN expositions-2352 89 37 ” " PUNCT expositions-2352 89 38 ? ? PUNCT expositions-2352 90 1 van van PROPN expositions-2352 90 2 norden norden PROPN expositions-2352 90 3 seems seem VERB expositions-2352 90 4 to to PART expositions-2352 90 5 conflate conflate VERB expositions-2352 90 6 definitional definitional ADJ expositions-2352 90 7 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 90 8 qualitative qualitative ADJ expositions-2352 90 9 distinctions distinction NOUN expositions-2352 90 10 ; ; PUNCT expositions-2352 90 11 that that PRON expositions-2352 90 12 is is ADV expositions-2352 90 13 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 90 14 he he PRON expositions-2352 90 15 seems seem VERB expositions-2352 90 16 to to PART expositions-2352 90 17 take take VERB expositions-2352 90 18 disputes dispute NOUN expositions-2352 90 19 over over ADP expositions-2352 90 20 what what DET expositions-2352 90 21 philosophy philosophy NOUN expositions-2352 90 22 is be AUX expositions-2352 90 23 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 90 24 or or CCONJ expositions-2352 90 25 what what DET expositions-2352 90 26 types type NOUN expositions-2352 90 27 of of ADP expositions-2352 90 28 activities activity NOUN expositions-2352 90 29 fall fall VERB expositions-2352 90 30 into into ADP expositions-2352 90 31 the the DET expositions-2352 90 32 category category NOUN expositions-2352 90 33 of of ADP expositions-2352 90 34 philosophy philosophy NOUN expositions-2352 90 35 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 90 36 as as ADP expositions-2352 90 37 disputes dispute NOUN expositions-2352 90 38 over over ADP expositions-2352 90 39 what what PRON expositions-2352 90 40 forms form NOUN expositions-2352 90 41 of of ADP expositions-2352 90 42 thought thought NOUN expositions-2352 90 43 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 90 44 literature literature NOUN expositions-2352 90 45 are be AUX expositions-2352 90 46 good good ADJ expositions-2352 90 47 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 90 48 worthwhile worthwhile ADJ expositions-2352 90 49 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 91 1 for for ADP expositions-2352 91 2 instance instance NOUN expositions-2352 91 3 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 91 4 he he PRON expositions-2352 91 5 takes take VERB expositions-2352 91 6 to to ADP expositions-2352 91 7 task task NOUN expositions-2352 91 8 both both DET expositions-2352 91 9 heidegger heidegger PROPN expositions-2352 91 10 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 91 11 derrida derrida PROPN expositions-2352 91 12 for for ADP expositions-2352 91 13 claiming claim VERB expositions-2352 91 14 that that DET expositions-2352 91 15 philosophy philosophy NOUN expositions-2352 91 16 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 91 17 properly properly ADV expositions-2352 91 18 speaking speak VERB expositions-2352 91 19 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 91 20 is be AUX expositions-2352 91 21 greek greek ADJ expositions-2352 91 22 or or CCONJ expositions-2352 91 23 european european ADJ expositions-2352 91 24 in in ADP expositions-2352 91 25 origin origin NOUN expositions-2352 91 26 ; ; PUNCT expositions-2352 91 27 in in ADP expositions-2352 91 28 derrida derrida PROPN expositions-2352 91 29 ’s ’s PART expositions-2352 91 30 words word NOUN expositions-2352 91 31 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 91 32 “ " PUNCT expositions-2352 91 33 china china PROPN expositions-2352 91 34 does do AUX expositions-2352 91 35 not not PART expositions-2352 91 36 have have VERB expositions-2352 91 37 any any DET expositions-2352 91 38 philosophy philosophy NOUN expositions-2352 91 39 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 91 40 only only ADV expositions-2352 91 41 thought think VERB expositions-2352 91 42 ” " PUNCT expositions-2352 91 43 ( ( PUNCT expositions-2352 91 44 cited cite VERB expositions-2352 91 45 in in ADP expositions-2352 91 46 van van PROPN expositions-2352 91 47 norden norden PROPN expositions-2352 91 48 25 25 NUM expositions-2352 91 49 ) ) PUNCT expositions-2352 91 50 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 92 1 this this PRON expositions-2352 92 2 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 92 3 to to ADP expositions-2352 92 4 van van PROPN expositions-2352 92 5 norden norden PROPN expositions-2352 92 6 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 92 7 is be AUX expositions-2352 92 8 equivalent equivalent ADJ expositions-2352 92 9 to to ADP expositions-2352 92 10 “ " PUNCT expositions-2352 92 11 condescending condescend VERB expositions-2352 92 12 … … PUNCT expositions-2352 92 13 talk talk NOUN expositions-2352 92 14 of of ADP expositions-2352 92 15 ‘ ' PUNCT expositions-2352 92 16 noble noble ADJ expositions-2352 92 17 savages savage NOUN expositions-2352 92 18 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 92 19 ’ ' PUNCT expositions-2352 92 20 ” " PUNCT expositions-2352 93 1 but but CCONJ expositions-2352 93 2 is be AUX expositions-2352 93 3 it it PRON expositions-2352 93 4 really really ADV expositions-2352 93 5 ? ? PUNCT expositions-2352 94 1 if if SCONJ expositions-2352 94 2 it it PRON expositions-2352 94 3 is be AUX expositions-2352 94 4 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 94 5 then then ADV expositions-2352 94 6 there there PRON expositions-2352 94 7 must must AUX expositions-2352 94 8 be be AUX expositions-2352 94 9 something something PRON expositions-2352 94 10 very very ADV expositions-2352 94 11 special special ADJ expositions-2352 94 12 about about ADP expositions-2352 94 13 philosophy philosophy NOUN expositions-2352 94 14 that that PRON expositions-2352 94 15 elevates elevate VERB expositions-2352 94 16 it it PRON expositions-2352 94 17 over over ADP expositions-2352 94 18 all all DET expositions-2352 94 19 other other ADJ expositions-2352 94 20 forms form NOUN expositions-2352 94 21 of of ADP expositions-2352 94 22 thought thought NOUN expositions-2352 94 23 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 94 24 or or CCONJ expositions-2352 94 25 at at ADP expositions-2352 94 26 least least ADJ expositions-2352 94 27 over over ADP expositions-2352 94 28 those those DET expositions-2352 94 29 forms form NOUN expositions-2352 94 30 of of ADP expositions-2352 94 31 thought thought NOUN expositions-2352 94 32 that that SCONJ expositions-2352 94 33 derrida derrida PROPN expositions-2352 94 34 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 94 35 heidegger heidegger PROPN expositions-2352 94 36 saw see VERB expositions-2352 94 37 in in ADP expositions-2352 94 38 china china PROPN expositions-2352 94 39 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 95 1 this this PRON expositions-2352 95 2 may may AUX expositions-2352 95 3 be be AUX expositions-2352 95 4 true true ADJ expositions-2352 95 5 — — PUNCT expositions-2352 95 6 but but CCONJ expositions-2352 95 7 it it PRON expositions-2352 95 8 may may AUX expositions-2352 95 9 not not PART expositions-2352 95 10 ; ; PUNCT expositions-2352 95 11 one one PRON expositions-2352 95 12 need need AUX expositions-2352 95 13 only only ADV expositions-2352 95 14 recall recall VERB expositions-2352 95 15 medieval medieval ADJ expositions-2352 95 16 disputes dispute NOUN expositions-2352 95 17 over over ADP expositions-2352 95 18 the the DET expositions-2352 95 19 proper proper ADJ expositions-2352 95 20 ordering ordering NOUN expositions-2352 95 21 of of ADP expositions-2352 95 22 philosophy philosophy NOUN expositions-2352 95 23 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 95 24 prophecy prophecy NOUN expositions-2352 95 25 ( ( PUNCT expositions-2352 95 26 see see VERB expositions-2352 95 27 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 95 28 e.g. e.g. ADV expositions-2352 95 29 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 95 30 maimonides maimonides PROPN expositions-2352 95 31 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 95 32 aquinas aquinas PROPN expositions-2352 95 33 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 95 34 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 95 35 al al PROPN expositions-2352 95 36 - - PUNCT expositions-2352 95 37 ghazali ghazali PROPN expositions-2352 95 38 ) ) PUNCT expositions-2352 95 39 to to PART expositions-2352 95 40 see see VERB expositions-2352 95 41 that that SCONJ expositions-2352 95 42 this this PRON expositions-2352 95 43 is be AUX expositions-2352 95 44 not not PART expositions-2352 95 45 to to PART expositions-2352 95 46 be be AUX expositions-2352 95 47 taken take VERB expositions-2352 95 48 for for ADP expositions-2352 95 49 granted grant VERB expositions-2352 95 50 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 96 1 in in ADP expositions-2352 96 2 any any DET expositions-2352 96 3 case case NOUN expositions-2352 96 4 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 96 5 it it PRON expositions-2352 96 6 would would AUX expositions-2352 96 7 be be AUX expositions-2352 96 8 helpful helpful ADJ expositions-2352 96 9 if if SCONJ expositions-2352 96 10 van van PROPN expositions-2352 96 11 norden norden PROPN expositions-2352 96 12 had have AUX expositions-2352 96 13 explained explain VERB expositions-2352 96 14 what what PRON expositions-2352 96 15 was be AUX expositions-2352 96 16 at at ADP expositions-2352 96 17 stake stake NOUN expositions-2352 96 18 in in ADP expositions-2352 96 19 specifically specifically ADV expositions-2352 96 20 identifying identify VERB expositions-2352 96 21 ( ( PUNCT expositions-2352 96 22 in in ADP expositions-2352 96 23 this this DET expositions-2352 96 24 case case NOUN expositions-2352 96 25 ) ) PUNCT expositions-2352 96 26 chinese chinese ADJ expositions-2352 96 27 “ " PUNCT expositions-2352 96 28 thought think VERB expositions-2352 96 29 ” " PUNCT expositions-2352 96 30 as as ADP expositions-2352 96 31 specifically specifically ADV expositions-2352 96 32 “ " PUNCT expositions-2352 96 33 philosophy philosophy NOUN expositions-2352 96 34 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 96 35 ” " PUNCT expositions-2352 97 1 why why SCONJ expositions-2352 97 2 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 97 3 in in ADP expositions-2352 97 4 other other ADJ expositions-2352 97 5 words word NOUN expositions-2352 97 6 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 97 7 ca can AUX expositions-2352 97 8 n’t not PART expositions-2352 97 9 we we PRON expositions-2352 97 10 read read VERB expositions-2352 97 11 both both DET expositions-2352 97 12 “ " PUNCT expositions-2352 97 13 philosophy philosophy NOUN expositions-2352 97 14 ” " PUNCT expositions-2352 97 15 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 97 16 other other ADJ expositions-2352 97 17 forms form NOUN expositions-2352 97 18 of of ADP expositions-2352 97 19 “ " PUNCT expositions-2352 97 20 thought thought NOUN expositions-2352 97 21 ” " PUNCT expositions-2352 97 22 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 97 23 consider consider VERB expositions-2352 97 24 them they PRON expositions-2352 97 25 both both CCONJ expositions-2352 97 26 important important ADJ expositions-2352 97 27 ? ? PUNCT expositions-2352 98 1 should should AUX expositions-2352 98 2 we we PRON expositions-2352 98 3 not not PART expositions-2352 98 4 read read VERB expositions-2352 98 5 confucius confucius NOUN expositions-2352 98 6 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 98 7 proverbs proverb NOUN expositions-2352 98 8 ( ( PUNCT expositions-2352 98 9 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 98 10 plato plato PROPN expositions-2352 98 11 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 98 12 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 98 13 ibn ibn PROPN expositions-2352 98 14 rushd rushd NOUN expositions-2352 98 15 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 98 16 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 98 17 kant kant NOUN expositions-2352 98 18 ) ) PUNCT expositions-2352 98 19 because because SCONJ expositions-2352 98 20 these these DET expositions-2352 98 21 texts text NOUN expositions-2352 98 22 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 98 23 the the DET expositions-2352 98 24 ideas idea NOUN expositions-2352 98 25 in in ADP expositions-2352 98 26 them they PRON expositions-2352 98 27 are be AUX expositions-2352 98 28 in in ADP expositions-2352 98 29 some some DET expositions-2352 98 30 important important ADJ expositions-2352 98 31 way way NOUN expositions-2352 98 32 texts text NOUN expositions-2352 98 33 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 98 34 questions question NOUN expositions-2352 98 35 worthy worthy ADJ expositions-2352 98 36 of of ADP expositions-2352 98 37 our our PRON expositions-2352 98 38 attention attention NOUN expositions-2352 98 39 — — PUNCT expositions-2352 98 40 because because SCONJ expositions-2352 98 41 they they PRON expositions-2352 98 42 raise raise VERB expositions-2352 98 43 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 98 44 address address VERB expositions-2352 98 45 timeless timeless ADJ expositions-2352 98 46 questions question NOUN expositions-2352 98 47 about about ADP expositions-2352 98 48 human human ADJ expositions-2352 98 49 nature nature NOUN expositions-2352 98 50 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 98 51 political political ADJ expositions-2352 98 52 life life NOUN expositions-2352 98 53 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 98 54 existence existence NOUN expositions-2352 98 55 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 98 56 knowledge knowledge NOUN expositions-2352 98 57 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 98 58 etc.—rather etc.—rather ADP expositions-2352 98 59 than than ADP expositions-2352 98 60 because because SCONJ expositions-2352 98 61 they they PRON expositions-2352 98 62 are be AUX expositions-2352 98 63 “ " PUNCT expositions-2352 98 64 philosophy philosophy NOUN expositions-2352 98 65 ” " PUNCT expositions-2352 98 66 ? ? PUNCT expositions-2352 99 1 i i PRON expositions-2352 99 2 anticipate anticipate VERB expositions-2352 99 3 two two NUM expositions-2352 99 4 objections objection NOUN expositions-2352 99 5 to to ADP expositions-2352 99 6 my my PRON expositions-2352 99 7 suggestion suggestion NOUN expositions-2352 99 8 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 100 1 first first ADV expositions-2352 100 2 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 100 3 one one PRON expositions-2352 100 4 may may AUX expositions-2352 100 5 point point VERB expositions-2352 100 6 out out ADP expositions-2352 100 7 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 100 8 those those DET expositions-2352 100 9 texts text NOUN expositions-2352 100 10 that that PRON expositions-2352 100 11 raise raise VERB expositions-2352 100 12 important important ADJ expositions-2352 100 13 questions question NOUN expositions-2352 100 14 about about ADP expositions-2352 100 15 existence existence NOUN expositions-2352 100 16 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 100 17 knowledge knowledge NOUN expositions-2352 100 18 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 100 19 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 100 20 politics politic NOUN expositions-2352 100 21 are be AUX expositions-2352 100 22 almost almost ADV expositions-2352 100 23 always always ADV expositions-2352 100 24 categorized categorize VERB expositions-2352 100 25 as as ADP expositions-2352 100 26 philosophy philosophy NOUN expositions-2352 100 27 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 101 1 but but CCONJ expositions-2352 101 2 surely surely ADV expositions-2352 101 3 this this PRON expositions-2352 101 4 is be AUX expositions-2352 101 5 not not PART expositions-2352 101 6 true true ADJ expositions-2352 101 7 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 102 1 even even ADV expositions-2352 102 2 restricting restrict VERB expositions-2352 102 3 ourselves ourselves PRON expositions-2352 102 4 to to PART expositions-2352 102 5 prose prose VERB expositions-2352 102 6 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 102 7 innumerable innumerable ADJ expositions-2352 102 8 thinkers thinker NOUN expositions-2352 102 9 fall fall VERB expositions-2352 102 10 outside outside ADV expositions-2352 102 11 of of ADP expositions-2352 102 12 philosophy philosophy NOUN expositions-2352 102 13 as as ADP expositions-2352 102 14 a a DET expositions-2352 102 15 discipline discipline NOUN expositions-2352 102 16 but but CCONJ expositions-2352 102 17 address address VERB expositions-2352 102 18 these these DET expositions-2352 102 19 exact exact ADJ expositions-2352 102 20 issues issue NOUN expositions-2352 102 21 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 103 1 alexis alexis PROPN expositions-2352 103 2 de de PROPN expositions-2352 103 3 tocqueville tocqueville PROPN expositions-2352 103 4 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 103 5 for for ADP expositions-2352 103 6 instance instance NOUN expositions-2352 103 7 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 103 8 has have AUX expositions-2352 103 9 never never ADV expositions-2352 103 10 really really ADV expositions-2352 103 11 been be AUX expositions-2352 103 12 considered consider VERB expositions-2352 103 13 a a DET expositions-2352 103 14 philosopher philosopher NOUN expositions-2352 103 15 ( ( PUNCT expositions-2352 103 16 a a DET expositions-2352 103 17 sociologist sociologist NOUN expositions-2352 103 18 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 103 19 usually usually ADV expositions-2352 103 20 — — PUNCT expositions-2352 103 21 but but CCONJ expositions-2352 103 22 also also ADV expositions-2352 103 23 a a DET expositions-2352 103 24 “ " PUNCT expositions-2352 103 25 travelwriter travelwriter NOUN expositions-2352 103 26 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 103 27 ” " PUNCT expositions-2352 103 28 i i PRON expositions-2352 103 29 have have AUX expositions-2352 103 30 been be AUX expositions-2352 103 31 told tell VERB expositions-2352 103 32 ) ) PUNCT expositions-2352 103 33 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 103 34 yet yet CCONJ expositions-2352 103 35 his his PRON expositions-2352 103 36 insights insight NOUN expositions-2352 103 37 into into ADP expositions-2352 103 38 democratic democratic ADJ expositions-2352 103 39 life life NOUN expositions-2352 103 40 rival rival NOUN expositions-2352 103 41 those those PRON expositions-2352 103 42 of of ADP expositions-2352 103 43 any any DET expositions-2352 103 44 bona bona ADJ expositions-2352 103 45 fide fide ADJ expositions-2352 103 46 political political ADJ expositions-2352 103 47 philosopher philosopher NOUN expositions-2352 103 48 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 104 1 friedrich friedrich PROPN expositions-2352 104 2 nietzsche nietzsche PROPN expositions-2352 104 3 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 104 4 likewise likewise ADV expositions-2352 104 5 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 104 6 was be AUX expositions-2352 104 7 a a DET expositions-2352 104 8 philologist philologist NOUN expositions-2352 104 9 whose whose DET expositions-2352 104 10 works work NOUN expositions-2352 104 11 range range VERB expositions-2352 104 12 from from ADP expositions-2352 104 13 the the DET expositions-2352 104 14 aphoristic aphoristic ADJ expositions-2352 104 15 to to ADP expositions-2352 104 16 the the DET expositions-2352 104 17 short short ADJ expositions-2352 104 18 story story NOUN expositions-2352 104 19 to to ADP expositions-2352 104 20 the the DET expositions-2352 104 21 rant rant NOUN expositions-2352 104 22 — — PUNCT expositions-2352 104 23 hardly hardly ADV expositions-2352 104 24 typical typical ADJ expositions-2352 104 25 forms form NOUN expositions-2352 104 26 for for ADP expositions-2352 104 27 philosophy philosophy NOUN expositions-2352 104 28 — — PUNCT expositions-2352 104 29 but but CCONJ expositions-2352 104 30 his his PRON expositions-2352 104 31 insights insight NOUN expositions-2352 104 32 into into ADP expositions-2352 104 33 the the DET expositions-2352 104 34 philosophy philosophy NOUN expositions-2352 104 35 of of ADP expositions-2352 104 36 language language NOUN expositions-2352 104 37 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 104 38 its its PRON expositions-2352 104 39 implications implication NOUN expositions-2352 104 40 for for ADP expositions-2352 104 41 both both DET expositions-2352 104 42 epistemology epistemology NOUN expositions-2352 104 43 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 104 44 ethics ethic NOUN expositions-2352 104 45 are be AUX expositions-2352 104 46 beyond beyond ADP expositions-2352 104 47 dispute dispute NOUN expositions-2352 104 48 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 105 1 in in ADP expositions-2352 105 2 other other ADJ expositions-2352 105 3 words word NOUN expositions-2352 105 4 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 105 5 it it PRON expositions-2352 105 6 seems seem VERB expositions-2352 105 7 that that SCONJ expositions-2352 105 8 the the DET expositions-2352 105 9 fact fact NOUN expositions-2352 105 10 of of ADP expositions-2352 105 11 being be AUX expositions-2352 105 12 philosophy philosophy NOUN expositions-2352 105 13 is be AUX expositions-2352 105 14 neither neither CCONJ expositions-2352 105 15 a a DET expositions-2352 105 16 necessary necessary ADJ expositions-2352 105 17 nor nor CCONJ expositions-2352 105 18 23 23 NUM expositions-2352 105 19 taliaferro taliaferro NOUN expositions-2352 105 20     SPACE expositions-2352 105 21 sufficient sufficient ADJ expositions-2352 105 22 condition condition NOUN expositions-2352 105 23 for for ADP expositions-2352 105 24 something something PRON expositions-2352 105 25 to to PART expositions-2352 105 26 be be AUX expositions-2352 105 27 worth worth ADJ expositions-2352 105 28 reading read VERB expositions-2352 105 29 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 106 1 so so ADV expositions-2352 106 2 why why SCONJ expositions-2352 106 3 does do AUX expositions-2352 106 4 it it PRON expositions-2352 106 5 matter matter VERB expositions-2352 106 6 if if SCONJ expositions-2352 106 7 we we PRON expositions-2352 106 8 label label VERB expositions-2352 106 9 confucius confucius NOUN expositions-2352 106 10 or or CCONJ expositions-2352 106 11 plato plato PROPN expositions-2352 106 12 or or CCONJ expositions-2352 106 13 heidegger heidegger PROPN expositions-2352 106 14 a a DET expositions-2352 106 15 philosopher philosopher NOUN expositions-2352 106 16 or or CCONJ expositions-2352 106 17 something something PRON expositions-2352 106 18 else else ADV expositions-2352 106 19 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 106 20 so so ADV expositions-2352 106 21 long long ADV expositions-2352 106 22 as as SCONJ expositions-2352 106 23 we we PRON expositions-2352 106 24 read read VERB expositions-2352 106 25 them they PRON expositions-2352 106 26 ? ? PUNCT expositions-2352 107 1 but but CCONJ expositions-2352 107 2 this this DET expositions-2352 107 3 question question NOUN expositions-2352 107 4 leads lead VERB expositions-2352 107 5 directly directly ADV expositions-2352 107 6 into into ADP expositions-2352 107 7 what what PRON expositions-2352 107 8 would would AUX expositions-2352 107 9 likely likely ADV expositions-2352 107 10 be be AUX expositions-2352 107 11 van van PROPN expositions-2352 107 12 norden norden PROPN expositions-2352 107 13 ’s ’s PART expositions-2352 107 14 own own ADJ expositions-2352 107 15 rejoinder rejoinder NOUN expositions-2352 107 16 : : PUNCT expositions-2352 107 17 calling call VERB expositions-2352 107 18 confucius confucius NOUN expositions-2352 107 19 a a DET expositions-2352 107 20 “ " PUNCT expositions-2352 107 21 philosopher philosopher NOUN expositions-2352 107 22 ” " PUNCT expositions-2352 107 23 is be AUX expositions-2352 107 24 a a DET expositions-2352 107 25 prerequisite prerequisite NOUN expositions-2352 107 26 for for ADP expositions-2352 107 27 his his PRON expositions-2352 107 28 appearing appear VERB expositions-2352 107 29 on on ADP expositions-2352 107 30 philosophy philosophy NOUN expositions-2352 107 31 departments department NOUN expositions-2352 107 32 ’ ' PUNCT expositions-2352 107 33 syllabi syllabus NOUN expositions-2352 107 34 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 107 35 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 107 36 this this PRON expositions-2352 107 37 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 107 38 in in ADP expositions-2352 107 39 turn turn NOUN expositions-2352 107 40 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 107 41 will will AUX expositions-2352 107 42 inform inform VERB expositions-2352 107 43 the the DET expositions-2352 107 44 broader broad ADJ expositions-2352 107 45 culture culture NOUN expositions-2352 107 46 ’s ’s PART expositions-2352 107 47 exposure exposure NOUN expositions-2352 107 48 to to ADP expositions-2352 107 49 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 107 50 understanding understanding NOUN expositions-2352 107 51 of of ADP expositions-2352 107 52 the the DET expositions-2352 107 53 thought thought NOUN expositions-2352 107 54 / / SYM expositions-2352 107 55 wisdom wisdom NOUN expositions-2352 107 56 / / SYM expositions-2352 107 57 philosophy philosophy NOUN expositions-2352 107 58 of of ADP expositions-2352 107 59 non non ADJ expositions-2352 107 60 - - ADJ expositions-2352 107 61 western western ADJ expositions-2352 107 62 cultures culture NOUN expositions-2352 107 63 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 108 1 true true ADJ expositions-2352 108 2 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 109 1 however however ADV expositions-2352 109 2 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 109 3 it it PRON expositions-2352 109 4 would would AUX expositions-2352 109 5 seem seem VERB expositions-2352 109 6 that that SCONJ expositions-2352 109 7 doing do VERB expositions-2352 109 8 so so ADV expositions-2352 109 9 requires require VERB expositions-2352 109 10 us we PRON expositions-2352 109 11 to to PART expositions-2352 109 12 come come VERB expositions-2352 109 13 up up ADP expositions-2352 109 14 with with ADP expositions-2352 109 15 a a DET expositions-2352 109 16 definition definition NOUN expositions-2352 109 17 of of ADP expositions-2352 109 18 philosophy philosophy NOUN expositions-2352 109 19 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 109 20 which which PRON expositions-2352 109 21 is be AUX expositions-2352 109 22 no no DET expositions-2352 109 23 easy easy ADJ expositions-2352 109 24 feat feat NOUN expositions-2352 109 25 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 110 1 van van PROPN expositions-2352 110 2 norden norden PROPN expositions-2352 110 3 does do AUX expositions-2352 110 4 eventually eventually ADV expositions-2352 110 5 proffer proffer VERB expositions-2352 110 6 one one NUM expositions-2352 110 7 such such ADJ expositions-2352 110 8 definition definition NOUN expositions-2352 110 9 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 110 10 though though SCONJ expositions-2352 110 11 he he PRON expositions-2352 110 12 rather rather ADV expositions-2352 110 13 curiously curiously ADV expositions-2352 110 14 waits wait VERB expositions-2352 110 15 until until SCONJ expositions-2352 110 16 the the DET expositions-2352 110 17 final final ADJ expositions-2352 110 18 chapter chapter NOUN expositions-2352 110 19 to to PART expositions-2352 110 20 do do VERB expositions-2352 110 21 so so ADV expositions-2352 110 22 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 111 1 ( ( PUNCT expositions-2352 111 2 curious curious ADJ expositions-2352 111 3 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 111 4 that that ADV expositions-2352 111 5 is is ADV expositions-2352 111 6 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 111 7 because because SCONJ expositions-2352 111 8 the the DET expositions-2352 111 9 primary primary ADJ expositions-2352 111 10 argument argument NOUN expositions-2352 111 11 of of ADP expositions-2352 111 12 the the DET expositions-2352 111 13 book book NOUN expositions-2352 111 14 seems seem VERB expositions-2352 111 15 to to PART expositions-2352 111 16 be be AUX expositions-2352 111 17 that that PRON expositions-2352 111 18 non non ADJ expositions-2352 111 19 - - ADJ expositions-2352 111 20 western western ADJ expositions-2352 111 21 thought thought NOUN expositions-2352 111 22 should should AUX expositions-2352 111 23 be be AUX expositions-2352 111 24 considered consider VERB expositions-2352 111 25 by by ADP expositions-2352 111 26 philosophers philosopher NOUN expositions-2352 111 27 to to PART expositions-2352 111 28 be be AUX expositions-2352 111 29 philosophy philosophy NOUN expositions-2352 111 30 — — PUNCT expositions-2352 111 31 whatever whatever PRON expositions-2352 111 32 that that PRON expositions-2352 111 33 is be AUX expositions-2352 111 34 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 111 35 ) ) PUNCT expositions-2352 112 1 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 112 2 even even ADV expositions-2352 112 3 then then ADV expositions-2352 112 4 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 112 5 he he PRON expositions-2352 112 6 is be AUX expositions-2352 112 7 careful careful ADJ expositions-2352 112 8 to to PART expositions-2352 112 9 stress stress VERB expositions-2352 112 10 that that SCONJ expositions-2352 112 11 his his PRON expositions-2352 112 12 definition definition NOUN expositions-2352 112 13 pertains pertain VERB expositions-2352 112 14 to to PART expositions-2352 112 15 philosophy philosophy NOUN expositions-2352 112 16 as as SCONJ expositions-2352 112 17 we we PRON expositions-2352 112 18 practice practice VERB expositions-2352 112 19 it it PRON expositions-2352 112 20 today today NOUN expositions-2352 112 21 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 112 22 is be AUX expositions-2352 112 23 not not PART expositions-2352 112 24 a a DET expositions-2352 112 25 timeless timeless ADJ expositions-2352 112 26 definition definition NOUN expositions-2352 112 27 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 113 1 philosophy philosophy NOUN expositions-2352 113 2 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 113 3 then then ADV expositions-2352 113 4 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 113 5 is be AUX expositions-2352 113 6 “ " PUNCT expositions-2352 113 7 dialogue dialogue NOUN expositions-2352 113 8 about about ADP expositions-2352 113 9 important important ADJ expositions-2352 113 10 unsolved unsolved ADJ expositions-2352 113 11 problems problem NOUN expositions-2352 113 12 ” " PUNCT expositions-2352 113 13 ( ( PUNCT expositions-2352 113 14 142 142 NUM expositions-2352 113 15 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 113 16 emphasis emphasis NOUN expositions-2352 113 17 van van PROPN expositions-2352 113 18 norden norden PROPN expositions-2352 113 19 ’s ’s PART expositions-2352 113 20 ) ) PUNCT expositions-2352 113 21 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 113 22 where where SCONJ expositions-2352 113 23 “ " PUNCT expositions-2352 113 24 unsolved unsolved ADJ expositions-2352 113 25 ” " PUNCT expositions-2352 113 26 means mean VERB expositions-2352 113 27 a a DET expositions-2352 113 28 lack lack NOUN expositions-2352 113 29 of of ADP expositions-2352 113 30 agreement agreement NOUN expositions-2352 113 31 on on ADP expositions-2352 113 32 method method NOUN expositions-2352 113 33 ( ( PUNCT expositions-2352 113 34 143).6 143).6 NUM expositions-2352 113 35 van van PROPN expositions-2352 113 36 norden norden PROPN expositions-2352 113 37 contrasts contrast VERB expositions-2352 113 38 philosophy philosophy NOUN expositions-2352 113 39 with with ADP expositions-2352 113 40 other other ADJ expositions-2352 113 41 disciplines discipline NOUN expositions-2352 113 42 in in ADP expositions-2352 113 43 which which PRON expositions-2352 113 44 “ " PUNCT expositions-2352 113 45 there there PRON expositions-2352 113 46 is be VERB expositions-2352 113 47 ( ( PUNCT expositions-2352 113 48 generally generally ADV expositions-2352 113 49 ) ) PUNCT expositions-2352 113 50 agreement agreement NOUN expositions-2352 113 51 about about ADP expositions-2352 113 52 what what PRON expositions-2352 113 53 counts count VERB expositions-2352 113 54 as as ADP expositions-2352 113 55 reliable reliable ADJ expositions-2352 113 56 evidence evidence NOUN expositions-2352 113 57 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 113 58 good good ADJ expositions-2352 113 59 arguments argument NOUN expositions-2352 113 60 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 113 61 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 113 62 well well ADV expositions-2352 113 63 - - PUNCT expositions-2352 113 64 established establish VERB expositions-2352 113 65 conclusions conclusion NOUN expositions-2352 113 66 ” " PUNCT expositions-2352 113 67 ( ( PUNCT expositions-2352 113 68 143 143 NUM expositions-2352 113 69 ) ) PUNCT expositions-2352 113 70 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 114 1 philosophy philosophy NOUN expositions-2352 114 2 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 114 3 he he PRON expositions-2352 114 4 implies imply VERB expositions-2352 114 5 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 114 6 is be AUX expositions-2352 114 7 prior prior ADV expositions-2352 114 8 to to ADP expositions-2352 114 9 this this PRON expositions-2352 114 10 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 115 1 in in ADP expositions-2352 115 2 other other ADJ expositions-2352 115 3 words word NOUN expositions-2352 115 4 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 115 5 philosophy philosophy NOUN expositions-2352 115 6 is be AUX expositions-2352 115 7 a a DET expositions-2352 115 8 meta meta ADJ expositions-2352 115 9 - - PUNCT expositions-2352 115 10 discipline discipline NOUN expositions-2352 115 11 ; ; PUNCT expositions-2352 115 12 we we PRON expositions-2352 115 13 practice practice VERB expositions-2352 115 14 philosophy philosophy NOUN expositions-2352 115 15 when when SCONJ expositions-2352 115 16 we we PRON expositions-2352 115 17 dispute dispute VERB expositions-2352 115 18 those those DET expositions-2352 115 19 questions question NOUN expositions-2352 115 20 which which PRON expositions-2352 115 21 we we PRON expositions-2352 115 22 do do AUX expositions-2352 115 23 not not PART expositions-2352 115 24 have have VERB expositions-2352 115 25 shared share VERB expositions-2352 115 26 criteria criterion NOUN expositions-2352 115 27 for for ADP expositions-2352 115 28 answering answer VERB expositions-2352 115 29 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 116 1 for for ADP expositions-2352 116 2 instance instance NOUN expositions-2352 116 3 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 116 4 asking ask VERB expositions-2352 116 5 “ " PUNCT expositions-2352 116 6 what what PRON expositions-2352 116 7 is be AUX expositions-2352 116 8 the the DET expositions-2352 116 9 good good ADJ expositions-2352 116 10 life life NOUN expositions-2352 116 11 ? ? PUNCT expositions-2352 116 12 ” " PUNCT expositions-2352 116 13 requires require VERB expositions-2352 116 14 agreement agreement NOUN expositions-2352 116 15 over over ADP expositions-2352 116 16 what what PRON expositions-2352 116 17 constitutes constitute VERB expositions-2352 116 18 “ " PUNCT expositions-2352 116 19 good good ADJ expositions-2352 116 20 ” " PUNCT expositions-2352 116 21 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 116 22 “ " PUNCT expositions-2352 116 23 life life NOUN expositions-2352 116 24 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 116 25 ” " PUNCT expositions-2352 116 26 both both PRON expositions-2352 116 27 of of ADP expositions-2352 116 28 which which PRON expositions-2352 116 29 are be AUX expositions-2352 116 30 themselves themselves PRON expositions-2352 116 31 issues issue NOUN expositions-2352 116 32 of of ADP expositions-2352 116 33 contention contention NOUN expositions-2352 116 34 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 117 1 but but CCONJ expositions-2352 117 2 does do AUX expositions-2352 117 3 this this DET expositions-2352 117 4 definition definition NOUN expositions-2352 117 5 work work VERB expositions-2352 117 6 ? ? PUNCT expositions-2352 118 1 two two NUM expositions-2352 118 2 problems problem NOUN expositions-2352 118 3 arise arise VERB expositions-2352 118 4 when when SCONJ expositions-2352 118 5 we we PRON expositions-2352 118 6 place place VERB expositions-2352 118 7 it it PRON expositions-2352 118 8 under under ADP expositions-2352 118 9 the the DET expositions-2352 118 10 microscope microscope NOUN expositions-2352 118 11 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 119 1 it it PRON expositions-2352 119 2 would would AUX expositions-2352 119 3 seem seem VERB expositions-2352 119 4 that that DET expositions-2352 119 5 philosophy philosophy NOUN expositions-2352 119 6 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 119 7 as as ADP expositions-2352 119 8 a a DET expositions-2352 119 9 discipline discipline NOUN expositions-2352 119 10 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 119 11 does do AUX expositions-2352 119 12 have have VERB expositions-2352 119 13 some some DET expositions-2352 119 14 shared share VERB expositions-2352 119 15 notions notion NOUN expositions-2352 119 16 of of ADP expositions-2352 119 17 what what PRON expositions-2352 119 18 constitutes constitute VERB expositions-2352 119 19 a a DET expositions-2352 119 20 good good ADJ expositions-2352 119 21 argument argument NOUN expositions-2352 119 22 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 119 23 reliable reliable ADJ expositions-2352 119 24 evidence evidence NOUN expositions-2352 119 25 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 119 26 at at ADP expositions-2352 119 27 least least ADJ expositions-2352 119 28 to to ADP expositions-2352 119 29 the the DET expositions-2352 119 30 extent extent NOUN expositions-2352 119 31 that that SCONJ expositions-2352 119 32 other other ADJ expositions-2352 119 33 non non ADJ expositions-2352 119 34 - - ADJ expositions-2352 119 35 empirical empirical ADJ expositions-2352 119 36 disciplines discipline NOUN expositions-2352 119 37 can can AUX expositions-2352 119 38 be be AUX expositions-2352 119 39 said say VERB expositions-2352 119 40 to to PART expositions-2352 119 41 have have VERB expositions-2352 119 42 such such ADJ expositions-2352 119 43 criteria criterion NOUN expositions-2352 119 44 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 120 1 the the DET expositions-2352 120 2 basic basic ADJ expositions-2352 120 3 rules rule NOUN expositions-2352 120 4 of of ADP expositions-2352 120 5 logic logic NOUN expositions-2352 120 6 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 120 7 including include VERB expositions-2352 120 8 truth truth NOUN expositions-2352 120 9 of of ADP expositions-2352 120 10 premises premise NOUN expositions-2352 120 11 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 120 12 validity validity NOUN expositions-2352 120 13 of of ADP expositions-2352 120 14 reasoning reasoning NOUN expositions-2352 120 15 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 120 16 could could AUX expositions-2352 120 17 be be AUX expositions-2352 120 18 starters.7 starters.7 PROPN expositions-2352 120 19 even even ADV expositions-2352 120 20 if if SCONJ expositions-2352 120 21 one one PRON expositions-2352 120 22 takes take VERB expositions-2352 120 23 issue issue NOUN expositions-2352 120 24 with with ADP expositions-2352 120 25 these these DET expositions-2352 120 26 criteria criterion NOUN expositions-2352 120 27 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 120 28 she she PRON expositions-2352 120 29 would would AUX expositions-2352 120 30 have have VERB expositions-2352 120 31 to to PART expositions-2352 120 32 answer answer VERB expositions-2352 120 33 how how SCONJ expositions-2352 120 34 there there PRON expositions-2352 120 35 can can AUX expositions-2352 120 36 be be AUX expositions-2352 120 37 departments department NOUN expositions-2352 120 38 of of ADP expositions-2352 120 39 philosophy philosophy NOUN expositions-2352 120 40 with with ADP expositions-2352 120 41 their their PRON expositions-2352 120 42 own own ADJ expositions-2352 120 43 journals journal NOUN expositions-2352 120 44 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 120 45 graduate graduate NOUN expositions-2352 120 46 students student NOUN expositions-2352 120 47 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 120 48 university university NOUN expositions-2352 120 49 press press NOUN expositions-2352 120 50 editors editor NOUN expositions-2352 120 51 — — PUNCT expositions-2352 120 52 the the DET expositions-2352 120 53 very very ADV expositions-2352 120 54 disciplinary disciplinary ADJ expositions-2352 120 55 contours contours NOUN expositions-2352 120 56 which which PRON expositions-2352 120 57 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 120 58 by by ADP expositions-2352 120 59 taking take VERB expositions-2352 120 60 aim aim NOUN expositions-2352 120 61 at at ADP expositions-2352 120 62 them they PRON expositions-2352 120 63 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 120 64 van van PROPN expositions-2352 120 65 norden norden PROPN expositions-2352 120 66 implicitly implicitly ADV expositions-2352 120 67 accepts accept VERB expositions-2352 120 68 as as ADP expositions-2352 120 69 existent existent ADJ expositions-2352 120 70 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 121 1 the the DET expositions-2352 121 2 second second ADJ expositions-2352 121 3 problem problem NOUN expositions-2352 121 4 with with ADP expositions-2352 121 5 van van PROPN expositions-2352 121 6 norden norden PROPN expositions-2352 121 7 ’s ’s PART expositions-2352 121 8 working work VERB expositions-2352 121 9 definition definition NOUN expositions-2352 121 10 of of ADP expositions-2352 121 11 philosophy philosophy NOUN expositions-2352 121 12 becomes become VERB expositions-2352 121 13 clear clear ADJ expositions-2352 121 14 when when SCONJ expositions-2352 121 15 we we PRON expositions-2352 121 16 operationalize operationalize VERB expositions-2352 121 17 it it PRON expositions-2352 121 18 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 122 1 if if SCONJ expositions-2352 122 2 philosophy philosophy NOUN expositions-2352 122 3 as as ADP expositions-2352 122 4 such such ADJ expositions-2352 122 5 has have VERB expositions-2352 122 6 no no DET expositions-2352 122 7 general general ADJ expositions-2352 122 8 agreement agreement NOUN expositions-2352 122 9 as as ADP expositions-2352 122 10 to to ADP expositions-2352 122 11 what what PRON expositions-2352 122 12 counts count VERB expositions-2352 122 13 as as ADP expositions-2352 122 14 reliable reliable ADJ expositions-2352 122 15 evidence evidence NOUN expositions-2352 122 16 or or CCONJ expositions-2352 122 17 good good ADJ expositions-2352 122 18 arguments argument NOUN expositions-2352 122 19 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 122 20 there there PRON expositions-2352 122 21 is be VERB expositions-2352 122 22 no no DET expositions-2352 122 23 immediate immediate ADJ expositions-2352 122 24 reason reason NOUN expositions-2352 122 25 why why SCONJ expositions-2352 122 26 either either CCONJ expositions-2352 122 27 confucius confucius NOUN expositions-2352 122 28 or or CCONJ expositions-2352 122 29 plato plato PROPN expositions-2352 122 30 should should AUX expositions-2352 122 31 be be AUX expositions-2352 122 32 either either CCONJ expositions-2352 122 33 included include VERB expositions-2352 122 34 or or CCONJ expositions-2352 122 35 excluded exclude VERB expositions-2352 122 36 — — PUNCT expositions-2352 122 37 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 122 38 consequently consequently ADV expositions-2352 122 39 the the DET expositions-2352 122 40 debate debate NOUN expositions-2352 122 41 over over ADP expositions-2352 122 42 whether whether SCONJ expositions-2352 122 43 something something PRON expositions-2352 122 44 “ " PUNCT expositions-2352 122 45 counts count NOUN expositions-2352 122 46 ” " PUNCT expositions-2352 122 47 as as ADP expositions-2352 122 48 less less ADV expositions-2352 122 49 manifesto manifesto NOUN expositions-2352 122 50 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 122 51 more more ADJ expositions-2352 122 52 philosophy philosophy NOUN expositions-2352 122 53 24 24 NUM expositions-2352 122 54         SPACE expositions-2352 122 55 philosophy philosophy NOUN expositions-2352 122 56 is be AUX expositions-2352 122 57 beside beside ADP expositions-2352 122 58 the the DET expositions-2352 122 59 point point NOUN expositions-2352 122 60 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 123 1 again again ADV expositions-2352 123 2 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 123 3 by by ADP expositions-2352 123 4 petitioning petition VERB expositions-2352 123 5 those those PRON expositions-2352 123 6 within within ADP expositions-2352 123 7 the the DET expositions-2352 123 8 philosophy philosophy NOUN expositions-2352 123 9 guild guild NOUN expositions-2352 123 10 to to PART expositions-2352 123 11 admit admit VERB expositions-2352 123 12 such such ADJ expositions-2352 123 13 worthy worthy ADJ expositions-2352 123 14 members member NOUN expositions-2352 123 15 as as ADP expositions-2352 123 16 confucius confucius NOUN expositions-2352 123 17 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 123 18 dai dai PROPN expositions-2352 123 19 zhen zhen PROPN expositions-2352 123 20 ( ( PUNCT expositions-2352 123 21 14 14 NUM expositions-2352 123 22 ) ) PUNCT expositions-2352 123 23 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 123 24 van van PROPN expositions-2352 123 25 norden norden PROPN expositions-2352 123 26 thereby thereby ADV expositions-2352 123 27 acknowledges acknowledge VERB expositions-2352 123 28 that that SCONJ expositions-2352 123 29 belonging belong VERB expositions-2352 123 30 to to ADP expositions-2352 123 31 the the DET expositions-2352 123 32 guild guild NOUN expositions-2352 123 33 means mean VERB expositions-2352 123 34 something something PRON expositions-2352 123 35 ; ; PUNCT expositions-2352 123 36 in in ADP expositions-2352 123 37 other other ADJ expositions-2352 123 38 words word NOUN expositions-2352 123 39 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 123 40 there there PRON expositions-2352 123 41 must must AUX expositions-2352 123 42 be be AUX expositions-2352 123 43 some some DET expositions-2352 123 44 “ " PUNCT expositions-2352 123 45 agreement agreement NOUN expositions-2352 123 46 about about ADP expositions-2352 123 47 what what PRON expositions-2352 123 48 counts count VERB expositions-2352 123 49 as as ADP expositions-2352 123 50 reliable reliable ADJ expositions-2352 123 51 evidence evidence NOUN expositions-2352 123 52 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 123 53 good good ADJ expositions-2352 123 54 arguments argument NOUN expositions-2352 123 55 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 123 56 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 123 57 well well ADV expositions-2352 123 58 - - PUNCT expositions-2352 123 59 established establish VERB expositions-2352 123 60 conclusions conclusion NOUN expositions-2352 123 61 ” " PUNCT expositions-2352 123 62 ( ( PUNCT expositions-2352 123 63 143 143 NUM expositions-2352 123 64 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 123 65 above above ADV expositions-2352 123 66 ) ) PUNCT expositions-2352 123 67 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 123 68 after after ADV expositions-2352 123 69 all all ADV expositions-2352 123 70 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 124 1 i i PRON expositions-2352 124 2 suggest suggest VERB expositions-2352 124 3 that that SCONJ expositions-2352 124 4 we we PRON expositions-2352 124 5 should should AUX expositions-2352 124 6 read read VERB expositions-2352 124 7 confucius confucius NOUN expositions-2352 124 8 ( ( PUNCT expositions-2352 124 9 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 124 10 al al PROPN expositions-2352 124 11 - - PUNCT expositions-2352 124 12 ghazali ghazali PROPN expositions-2352 124 13 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 124 14 augustine augustine PROPN expositions-2352 124 15 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 124 16 gandhi gandhi PROPN expositions-2352 124 17 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 124 18 du du PROPN expositions-2352 124 19 bois bois PROPN expositions-2352 124 20 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 124 21 et et PROPN expositions-2352 124 22 al al PROPN expositions-2352 124 23 . . PROPN expositions-2352 124 24 ) ) PUNCT expositions-2352 125 1 not not PART expositions-2352 125 2 because because SCONJ expositions-2352 125 3 their their PRON expositions-2352 125 4 works work NOUN expositions-2352 125 5 qualify qualify VERB expositions-2352 125 6 as as ADP expositions-2352 125 7 philosophy philosophy NOUN expositions-2352 125 8 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 125 9 or or CCONJ expositions-2352 125 10 because because SCONJ expositions-2352 125 11 doing do VERB expositions-2352 125 12 so so ADV expositions-2352 125 13 helps help VERB expositions-2352 125 14 us we PRON expositions-2352 125 15 check check VERB expositions-2352 125 16 our our PRON expositions-2352 125 17 required require VERB expositions-2352 125 18 diversity diversity NOUN expositions-2352 125 19 boxes box NOUN expositions-2352 125 20 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 125 21 but but CCONJ expositions-2352 125 22 because because SCONJ expositions-2352 125 23 they they PRON expositions-2352 125 24 write write VERB expositions-2352 125 25 things thing NOUN expositions-2352 125 26 worth worth ADJ expositions-2352 125 27 reading read VERB expositions-2352 125 28 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 126 1 philosophy philosophy NOUN expositions-2352 126 2 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 126 3 whatever whatever PRON expositions-2352 126 4 else else ADV expositions-2352 126 5 it it PRON expositions-2352 126 6 might might AUX expositions-2352 126 7 be be AUX expositions-2352 126 8 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 126 9 should should AUX expositions-2352 126 10 be be AUX expositions-2352 126 11 at at ADP expositions-2352 126 12 least least ADJ expositions-2352 126 13 the the DET expositions-2352 126 14 love love NOUN expositions-2352 126 15 of of ADP expositions-2352 126 16 wisdom wisdom NOUN expositions-2352 126 17 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 127 1 if if SCONJ expositions-2352 127 2 this this PRON expositions-2352 127 3 serves serve VERB expositions-2352 127 4 as as ADP expositions-2352 127 5 our our PRON expositions-2352 127 6 guide guide NOUN expositions-2352 127 7 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 127 8 we we PRON expositions-2352 127 9 have have VERB expositions-2352 127 10 a a DET expositions-2352 127 11 globe globe NOUN expositions-2352 127 12 ’s ’s PART expositions-2352 127 13 worth worth NOUN expositions-2352 127 14 of of ADP expositions-2352 127 15 thinkers thinker NOUN expositions-2352 127 16 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 127 17 writers writer NOUN expositions-2352 127 18 to to PART expositions-2352 127 19 consider consider VERB expositions-2352 127 20 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 127 21 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 127 22 we we PRON expositions-2352 127 23 are be AUX expositions-2352 127 24 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 127 25 i i PRON expositions-2352 127 26 submit submit VERB expositions-2352 127 27 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 127 28 least least ADV expositions-2352 127 29 likely likely ADJ expositions-2352 127 30 to to PART expositions-2352 127 31 be be AUX expositions-2352 127 32 concerned concern VERB expositions-2352 127 33 about about ADP expositions-2352 127 34 walls wall NOUN expositions-2352 127 35 — — PUNCT expositions-2352 127 36 whether whether SCONJ expositions-2352 127 37 building build VERB expositions-2352 127 38 them they PRON expositions-2352 127 39 to to PART expositions-2352 127 40 cordon cordon VERB expositions-2352 127 41 off off ADP expositions-2352 127 42 our our PRON expositions-2352 127 43 own own ADJ expositions-2352 127 44 civilization civilization NOUN expositions-2352 127 45 from from ADP expositions-2352 127 46 others other NOUN expositions-2352 127 47 or or CCONJ expositions-2352 127 48 tearing tear VERB expositions-2352 127 49 them they PRON expositions-2352 127 50 down down ADP expositions-2352 127 51 prematurely prematurely ADV expositions-2352 127 52 in in ADP expositions-2352 127 53 strained strained ADJ expositions-2352 127 54 attempts attempt NOUN expositions-2352 127 55 to to PART expositions-2352 127 56 force force VERB expositions-2352 127 57 assimilation assimilation NOUN expositions-2352 127 58 where where SCONJ expositions-2352 127 59 some some DET expositions-2352 127 60 measure measure NOUN expositions-2352 127 61 of of ADP expositions-2352 127 62 embedded embed VERB expositions-2352 127 63 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 127 64 localized localized ADJ expositions-2352 127 65 differences difference NOUN expositions-2352 127 66 might might AUX expositions-2352 127 67 better well ADV expositions-2352 127 68 prevail prevail VERB expositions-2352 127 69 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 128 1 if if SCONJ expositions-2352 128 2 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 128 3 on on ADP expositions-2352 128 4 the the DET expositions-2352 128 5 other other ADJ expositions-2352 128 6 hand hand NOUN expositions-2352 128 7 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 128 8 we we PRON expositions-2352 128 9 read read VERB expositions-2352 128 10 confucius confucius NOUN expositions-2352 128 11 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 128 12 gandhi gandhi NOUN expositions-2352 128 13 either either CCONJ expositions-2352 128 14 because because SCONJ expositions-2352 128 15 they they PRON expositions-2352 128 16 “ " PUNCT expositions-2352 128 17 count count VERB expositions-2352 128 18 ” " PUNCT expositions-2352 128 19 as as ADP expositions-2352 128 20 philosophy philosophy NOUN expositions-2352 128 21 in in ADP expositions-2352 128 22 the the DET expositions-2352 128 23 same same ADJ expositions-2352 128 24 ways way NOUN expositions-2352 128 25 that that PRON expositions-2352 128 26 kant kant PROPN expositions-2352 128 27 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 128 28 aristotle aristotle PROPN expositions-2352 128 29 mysteriously mysteriously ADV expositions-2352 128 30 “ " PUNCT expositions-2352 128 31 count count ADJ expositions-2352 128 32 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 128 33 ” " PUNCT expositions-2352 128 34 or or CCONJ expositions-2352 128 35 because because SCONJ expositions-2352 128 36 we we PRON expositions-2352 128 37 need need VERB expositions-2352 128 38 our our PRON expositions-2352 128 39 syllabi syllabus NOUN expositions-2352 128 40 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 128 41 library library ADJ expositions-2352 128 42 shelves shelf NOUN expositions-2352 128 43 to to PART expositions-2352 128 44 reflect reflect VERB expositions-2352 128 45 a a DET expositions-2352 128 46 certain certain ADJ expositions-2352 128 47 cosmopolitan cosmopolitan ADJ expositions-2352 128 48 diversity diversity NOUN expositions-2352 128 49 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 128 50 then then ADV expositions-2352 128 51 we we PRON expositions-2352 128 52 will will AUX expositions-2352 128 53 end end VERB expositions-2352 128 54 by by ADP expositions-2352 128 55 chasing chase VERB expositions-2352 128 56 ever ever ADV expositions-2352 128 57 - - PUNCT expositions-2352 128 58 shifting shift VERB expositions-2352 128 59 goals goal NOUN expositions-2352 128 60 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 128 61 never never ADV expositions-2352 128 62 sure sure ADJ expositions-2352 128 63 that that SCONJ expositions-2352 128 64 we we PRON expositions-2352 128 65 have have AUX expositions-2352 128 66 struck strike VERB expositions-2352 128 67 the the DET expositions-2352 128 68 right right ADJ expositions-2352 128 69 representational representational ADJ expositions-2352 128 70 balance balance NOUN expositions-2352 128 71 or or CCONJ expositions-2352 128 72 avoided avoid VERB expositions-2352 128 73 the the DET expositions-2352 128 74 sins sin NOUN expositions-2352 128 75 of of ADP expositions-2352 128 76 imperialism imperialism NOUN expositions-2352 128 77 or or CCONJ expositions-2352 128 78 cultural cultural ADJ expositions-2352 128 79 appropriation appropriation NOUN expositions-2352 128 80 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 129 1 this this DET expositions-2352 129 2 latter latter ADJ expositions-2352 129 3 approach approach NOUN expositions-2352 129 4 is be AUX expositions-2352 129 5 also also ADV expositions-2352 129 6 likely likely ADJ expositions-2352 129 7 to to PART expositions-2352 129 8 prove prove VERB expositions-2352 129 9 a a DET expositions-2352 129 10 trojan trojan NOUN expositions-2352 129 11 horse horse NOUN expositions-2352 129 12 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 129 13 importing import VERB expositions-2352 129 14 a a DET expositions-2352 129 15 new new ADJ expositions-2352 129 16 divisiveness divisiveness NOUN expositions-2352 129 17 inside inside ADP expositions-2352 129 18 its its PRON expositions-2352 129 19 attempt attempt NOUN expositions-2352 129 20 to to PART expositions-2352 129 21 unite unite VERB expositions-2352 129 22 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 129 23 for for ADP expositions-2352 129 24 in in ADP expositions-2352 129 25 order order NOUN expositions-2352 129 26 to to PART expositions-2352 129 27 ensure ensure VERB expositions-2352 129 28 appropriate appropriate ADJ expositions-2352 129 29 representation representation NOUN expositions-2352 129 30 of of ADP expositions-2352 129 31 the the DET expositions-2352 129 32 different different ADJ expositions-2352 129 33 origins origin NOUN expositions-2352 129 34 of of ADP expositions-2352 129 35 philosophers philosopher NOUN expositions-2352 129 36 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 129 37 one one PRON expositions-2352 129 38 must must AUX expositions-2352 129 39 create create VERB expositions-2352 129 40 labels label NOUN expositions-2352 129 41 for for ADP expositions-2352 129 42 them they PRON expositions-2352 129 43 ( ( PUNCT expositions-2352 129 44 “ " PUNCT expositions-2352 129 45 chinese chinese ADJ expositions-2352 129 46 philosophy philosophy NOUN expositions-2352 129 47 ” " PUNCT expositions-2352 129 48 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 129 49 “ " PUNCT expositions-2352 129 50 islamic islamic ADJ expositions-2352 129 51 philosophy philosophy NOUN expositions-2352 129 52 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 129 53 ” " PUNCT expositions-2352 129 54 for for ADP expositions-2352 129 55 instance instance NOUN expositions-2352 129 56 ) ) PUNCT expositions-2352 129 57 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 129 58 labels label NOUN expositions-2352 129 59 that that PRON expositions-2352 129 60 distract distract VERB expositions-2352 129 61 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 129 62 reinforce reinforce VERB expositions-2352 129 63 notions notion NOUN expositions-2352 129 64 of of ADP expositions-2352 129 65 “ " PUNCT expositions-2352 129 66 us us PROPN expositions-2352 129 67 ” " PUNCT expositions-2352 129 68 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 129 69 “ " PUNCT expositions-2352 129 70 them they PRON expositions-2352 129 71 ” " PUNCT expositions-2352 129 72 even even ADV expositions-2352 129 73 as as SCONJ expositions-2352 129 74 their their PRON expositions-2352 129 75 partisans partisan NOUN expositions-2352 129 76 — — PUNCT expositions-2352 129 77 including include VERB expositions-2352 129 78 van van PROPN expositions-2352 129 79 norden norden PROPN expositions-2352 129 80 — — PUNCT expositions-2352 129 81 may may AUX expositions-2352 129 82 initially initially ADV expositions-2352 129 83 intend intend VERB expositions-2352 129 84 the the DET expositions-2352 129 85 exact exact ADJ expositions-2352 129 86 opposite opposite NOUN expositions-2352 129 87 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 130 1 overall overall ADV expositions-2352 130 2 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 130 3 taking take VERB expositions-2352 130 4 back back ADP expositions-2352 130 5 philosophy philosophy NOUN expositions-2352 130 6 provides provide VERB expositions-2352 130 7 a a DET expositions-2352 130 8 valuable valuable ADJ expositions-2352 130 9 exposition exposition NOUN expositions-2352 130 10 of of ADP expositions-2352 130 11 the the DET expositions-2352 130 12 contribution contribution NOUN expositions-2352 130 13 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 130 14 both both CCONJ expositions-2352 130 15 in in ADP expositions-2352 130 16 itself itself PRON expositions-2352 130 17 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 130 18 in in ADP expositions-2352 130 19 comparison comparison NOUN expositions-2352 130 20 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 130 21 of of ADP expositions-2352 130 22 non non ADJ expositions-2352 130 23 - - ADJ expositions-2352 130 24 western western ADJ expositions-2352 130 25 philosophy philosophy NOUN expositions-2352 130 26 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 131 1 van van PROPN expositions-2352 131 2 norden norden PROPN expositions-2352 131 3 ’s ’s PART expositions-2352 131 4 bilingual bilingual ADJ expositions-2352 131 5 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 131 6 bicultural bicultural ADJ expositions-2352 131 7 expertise expertise NOUN expositions-2352 131 8 is be AUX expositions-2352 131 9 in in ADP expositions-2352 131 10 lamentably lamentably ADV expositions-2352 131 11 short short ADJ expositions-2352 131 12 supply supply NOUN expositions-2352 131 13 in in ADP expositions-2352 131 14 philosophy philosophy NOUN expositions-2352 131 15 ( ( PUNCT expositions-2352 131 16 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 131 17 other other ADJ expositions-2352 131 18 ) ) PUNCT expositions-2352 131 19 departments department NOUN expositions-2352 131 20 across across ADP expositions-2352 131 21 the the DET expositions-2352 131 22 country country NOUN expositions-2352 131 23 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 131 24 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 131 25 students student NOUN expositions-2352 131 26 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 131 27 scholars scholar NOUN expositions-2352 131 28 alike alike ADV expositions-2352 131 29 would would AUX expositions-2352 131 30 benefit benefit VERB expositions-2352 131 31 enormously enormously ADV expositions-2352 131 32 from from ADP expositions-2352 131 33 reading read VERB expositions-2352 131 34 “ " PUNCT expositions-2352 131 35 traditions tradition NOUN expositions-2352 131 36 in in ADP expositions-2352 131 37 dialogue dialogue NOUN expositions-2352 131 38 ” " PUNCT expositions-2352 131 39 with with ADP expositions-2352 131 40 him he PRON expositions-2352 131 41 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 132 1 unfortunately unfortunately ADV expositions-2352 132 2 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 132 3 because because SCONJ expositions-2352 132 4 this this DET expositions-2352 132 5 book book NOUN expositions-2352 132 6 is be AUX expositions-2352 132 7 heavy heavy ADJ expositions-2352 132 8 on on ADP expositions-2352 132 9 the the DET expositions-2352 132 10 manifesto manifesto NOUN expositions-2352 132 11 side side NOUN expositions-2352 132 12 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 132 13 regrettably regrettably ADV expositions-2352 132 14 light light ADJ expositions-2352 132 15 on on ADP expositions-2352 132 16 the the DET expositions-2352 132 17 very very ADV expositions-2352 132 18 comparative comparative ADJ expositions-2352 132 19 work work NOUN expositions-2352 132 20 such such ADJ expositions-2352 132 21 scholars scholar NOUN expositions-2352 132 22 as as ADP expositions-2352 132 23 van van PROPN expositions-2352 132 24 norden norden PROPN expositions-2352 132 25 are be AUX expositions-2352 132 26 uniquely uniquely ADV expositions-2352 132 27 fit fit ADJ expositions-2352 132 28 to to PART expositions-2352 132 29 do do VERB expositions-2352 132 30 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 132 31 it it PRON expositions-2352 132 32 seems seem VERB expositions-2352 132 33 that that SCONJ expositions-2352 132 34 its its PRON expositions-2352 132 35 impact impact NOUN expositions-2352 132 36 will will AUX expositions-2352 132 37 remain remain VERB expositions-2352 132 38 limited limited ADJ expositions-2352 132 39 to to ADP expositions-2352 132 40 “ " PUNCT expositions-2352 132 41 inciting incite VERB expositions-2352 132 42 discussion discussion NOUN expositions-2352 132 43 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 132 44 raising raise VERB expositions-2352 132 45 awareness”—and awareness”—and CCONJ expositions-2352 132 46 likely likely ADJ expositions-2352 132 47 ire ire NOUN expositions-2352 132 48 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 132 49 among among ADP expositions-2352 132 50 some some DET expositions-2352 132 51 readers reader NOUN expositions-2352 132 52 — — PUNCT expositions-2352 132 53 rather rather ADV expositions-2352 132 54 than than ADP expositions-2352 132 55 making make VERB expositions-2352 132 56 a a DET expositions-2352 132 57 genuinely genuinely ADV expositions-2352 132 58 philosophical philosophical ADJ expositions-2352 132 59 case case NOUN expositions-2352 132 60 for for ADP expositions-2352 132 61 a a DET expositions-2352 132 62 topic topic NOUN expositions-2352 132 63 worthy worthy ADJ expositions-2352 132 64 of of ADP expositions-2352 132 65 philosophical philosophical ADJ expositions-2352 132 66 treatment treatment NOUN expositions-2352 132 67 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 133 1 25 25 NUM expositions-2352 133 2 taliaferro taliaferro NOUN expositions-2352 133 3     SPACE expositions-2352 133 4 notes note NOUN expositions-2352 133 5 1 1 NUM expositions-2352 133 6 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 134 1 see see VERB expositions-2352 134 2 joshua joshua PROPN expositions-2352 134 3 5–6 5–6 NUM expositions-2352 134 4 . . PROPN expositions-2352 135 1 2 2 X expositions-2352 135 2 . . X expositions-2352 136 1 i i PRON expositions-2352 136 2 find find VERB expositions-2352 136 3 this this DET expositions-2352 136 4 a a DET expositions-2352 136 5 fraught fraught ADJ expositions-2352 136 6 term term NOUN expositions-2352 136 7 but but CCONJ expositions-2352 136 8 it it PRON expositions-2352 136 9 carries carry VERB expositions-2352 136 10 sufficient sufficient ADJ expositions-2352 136 11 cachet cachet NOUN expositions-2352 136 12 that that PRON expositions-2352 136 13 i i PRON expositions-2352 136 14 will will AUX expositions-2352 136 15 adopt adopt VERB expositions-2352 136 16 it it PRON expositions-2352 136 17 here here ADV expositions-2352 136 18 ; ; PUNCT expositions-2352 136 19 the the DET expositions-2352 136 20 reader reader NOUN expositions-2352 136 21 will will AUX expositions-2352 136 22 likely likely ADV expositions-2352 136 23 be be AUX expositions-2352 136 24 well well ADV expositions-2352 136 25 acquainted acquaint VERB expositions-2352 136 26 with with ADP expositions-2352 136 27 reasons reason NOUN expositions-2352 136 28 why why SCONJ expositions-2352 136 29 the the DET expositions-2352 136 30 term term NOUN expositions-2352 136 31 “ " PUNCT expositions-2352 136 32 western western ADJ expositions-2352 136 33 ” " PUNCT expositions-2352 136 34 falls fall VERB expositions-2352 136 35 apart apart ADV expositions-2352 136 36 upon upon SCONJ expositions-2352 136 37 closer close ADJ expositions-2352 136 38 scrutiny scrutiny NOUN expositions-2352 136 39 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 137 1 the the DET expositions-2352 137 2 salient salient NOUN expositions-2352 137 3 point point NOUN expositions-2352 137 4 is be AUX expositions-2352 137 5 that that SCONJ expositions-2352 137 6 one one PRON expositions-2352 137 7 should should AUX expositions-2352 137 8 be be AUX expositions-2352 137 9 educated educate VERB expositions-2352 137 10 in in ADP expositions-2352 137 11 those those DET expositions-2352 137 12 texts text NOUN expositions-2352 137 13 that that PRON expositions-2352 137 14 have have AUX expositions-2352 137 15 most most ADV expositions-2352 137 16 strongly strongly ADV expositions-2352 137 17 influenced influence VERB expositions-2352 137 18 her her PRON expositions-2352 137 19 own own ADJ expositions-2352 137 20 civilization civilization NOUN expositions-2352 137 21 — — PUNCT expositions-2352 137 22 a a DET expositions-2352 137 23 civilization civilization NOUN expositions-2352 137 24 that that SCONJ expositions-2352 137 25 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 137 26 in in ADP expositions-2352 137 27 america america PROPN expositions-2352 137 28 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 137 29 is be AUX expositions-2352 137 30 still still ADV expositions-2352 137 31 referred refer VERB expositions-2352 137 32 to to ADP expositions-2352 137 33 as as ADP expositions-2352 137 34 “ " PUNCT expositions-2352 137 35 the the DET expositions-2352 137 36 west west NOUN expositions-2352 137 37 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 137 38 ” " PUNCT expositions-2352 138 1 3 3 X expositions-2352 138 2 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 139 1 this this PRON expositions-2352 139 2 does do VERB expositions-2352 139 3 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 139 4 it it PRON expositions-2352 139 5 is be AUX expositions-2352 139 6 true true ADJ expositions-2352 139 7 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 139 8 disregard disregard VERB expositions-2352 139 9 the the DET expositions-2352 139 10 case case NOUN expositions-2352 139 11 of of ADP expositions-2352 139 12 foreign foreign ADJ expositions-2352 139 13 students student NOUN expositions-2352 139 14 who who PRON expositions-2352 139 15 will will AUX expositions-2352 139 16 leave leave VERB expositions-2352 139 17 the the DET expositions-2352 139 18 u.s u.s PROPN expositions-2352 139 19 . . PROPN expositions-2352 139 20 after after ADP expositions-2352 139 21 their their PRON expositions-2352 139 22 studies study NOUN expositions-2352 139 23 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 140 1 still still ADV expositions-2352 140 2 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 140 3 a a DET expositions-2352 140 4 similar similar ADJ expositions-2352 140 5 case case NOUN expositions-2352 140 6 could could AUX expositions-2352 140 7 be be AUX expositions-2352 140 8 made make VERB expositions-2352 140 9 : : PUNCT expositions-2352 140 10 if if SCONJ expositions-2352 140 11 a a DET expositions-2352 140 12 student student NOUN expositions-2352 140 13 leaves leave VERB expositions-2352 140 14 his his PRON expositions-2352 140 15 own own ADJ expositions-2352 140 16 country country NOUN expositions-2352 140 17 to to PART expositions-2352 140 18 study study VERB expositions-2352 140 19 in in ADP expositions-2352 140 20 another another PRON expositions-2352 140 21 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 140 22 it it PRON expositions-2352 140 23 is be AUX expositions-2352 140 24 presumably presumably ADV expositions-2352 140 25 because because SCONJ expositions-2352 140 26 there there PRON expositions-2352 140 27 is be VERB expositions-2352 140 28 ultimately ultimately ADV expositions-2352 140 29 something something PRON expositions-2352 140 30 distinct distinct ADJ expositions-2352 140 31 about about ADP expositions-2352 140 32 that that DET expositions-2352 140 33 country country NOUN expositions-2352 140 34 or or CCONJ expositions-2352 140 35 its its PRON expositions-2352 140 36 heritage heritage NOUN expositions-2352 140 37 that that PRON expositions-2352 140 38 the the DET expositions-2352 140 39 student student NOUN expositions-2352 140 40 finds find VERB expositions-2352 140 41 desirable desirable ADJ expositions-2352 140 42 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 140 43 therefore therefore ADV expositions-2352 140 44 worthy worthy ADJ expositions-2352 140 45 of of ADP expositions-2352 140 46 study study NOUN expositions-2352 140 47 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 141 1 4 4 X expositions-2352 141 2 . . X expositions-2352 141 3 in in ADP expositions-2352 141 4 the the DET expositions-2352 141 5 introduction introduction NOUN expositions-2352 141 6 ( ( PUNCT expositions-2352 141 7 xii xii PROPN expositions-2352 141 8 ) ) PUNCT expositions-2352 141 9 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 141 10 garfield garfield PROPN expositions-2352 141 11 assures assure VERB expositions-2352 141 12 the the DET expositions-2352 141 13 reader reader NOUN expositions-2352 141 14 that that PRON expositions-2352 141 15 answers answer NOUN expositions-2352 141 16 are be AUX expositions-2352 141 17 forthcoming forthcoming ADJ expositions-2352 141 18 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 141 19 in in ADP expositions-2352 141 20 van van PROPN expositions-2352 141 21 norden norden PROPN expositions-2352 141 22 ’s ’s PART expositions-2352 141 23 book book NOUN expositions-2352 141 24 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 141 25 to to ADP expositions-2352 141 26 non non ADJ expositions-2352 141 27 - - ADJ expositions-2352 141 28 chauvinistic chauvinistic ADJ expositions-2352 141 29 objections objection NOUN expositions-2352 141 30 to to ADP expositions-2352 141 31 teaching teach VERB expositions-2352 141 32 non non ADJ expositions-2352 141 33 - - ADJ expositions-2352 141 34 western western ADJ expositions-2352 141 35 philosophy philosophy NOUN expositions-2352 141 36 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 141 37 including include VERB expositions-2352 141 38 lack lack NOUN expositions-2352 141 39 of of ADP expositions-2352 141 40 expertise expertise NOUN expositions-2352 141 41 in in ADP expositions-2352 141 42 the the DET expositions-2352 141 43 relevant relevant ADJ expositions-2352 141 44 languages language NOUN expositions-2352 141 45 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 141 46 or or CCONJ expositions-2352 141 47 sufficient sufficient ADJ expositions-2352 141 48 knowledge knowledge NOUN expositions-2352 141 49 of of ADP expositions-2352 141 50 the the DET expositions-2352 141 51 sources source NOUN expositions-2352 141 52 to to PART expositions-2352 141 53 judge judge VERB expositions-2352 141 54 the the DET expositions-2352 141 55 scholarship scholarship NOUN expositions-2352 141 56 of of ADP expositions-2352 141 57 job job NOUN expositions-2352 141 58 candidates candidate NOUN expositions-2352 141 59 who who PRON expositions-2352 141 60 might might AUX expositions-2352 141 61 be be AUX expositions-2352 141 62 able able ADJ expositions-2352 141 63 to to PART expositions-2352 141 64 teach teach VERB expositions-2352 141 65 them they PRON expositions-2352 141 66 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 142 1 while while SCONJ expositions-2352 142 2 garfield garfield PROPN expositions-2352 142 3 promises promise VERB expositions-2352 142 4 that that SCONJ expositions-2352 142 5 van van PROPN expositions-2352 142 6 norden norden PROPN expositions-2352 142 7 address address NOUN expositions-2352 142 8 these these PRON expositions-2352 142 9 “ " PUNCT expositions-2352 142 10 carefully carefully ADV expositions-2352 142 11 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 142 12 in in ADP expositions-2352 142 13 detail detail NOUN expositions-2352 142 14 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 142 15 ” " PUNCT expositions-2352 142 16 as as ADV expositions-2352 142 17 far far ADV expositions-2352 142 18 as as SCONJ expositions-2352 142 19 i i PRON expositions-2352 142 20 can can AUX expositions-2352 142 21 tell tell VERB expositions-2352 142 22 van van PROPN expositions-2352 142 23 norden norden PROPN expositions-2352 142 24 spends spend VERB expositions-2352 142 25 one one NUM expositions-2352 142 26 paragraph paragraph NOUN expositions-2352 142 27 ( ( PUNCT expositions-2352 142 28 33–34 33–34 NUM expositions-2352 142 29 ) ) PUNCT expositions-2352 142 30 on on ADP expositions-2352 142 31 “ " PUNCT expositions-2352 142 32 the the DET expositions-2352 142 33 pipeline pipeline NOUN expositions-2352 142 34 problem problem NOUN expositions-2352 142 35 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 142 36 ” " PUNCT expositions-2352 142 37 noting note VERB expositions-2352 142 38 that that SCONJ expositions-2352 142 39 the the DET expositions-2352 142 40 society society NOUN expositions-2352 142 41 for for ADP expositions-2352 142 42 asian asian ADJ expositions-2352 142 43 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 142 44 comparative comparative ADJ expositions-2352 142 45 philosophy philosophy NOUN expositions-2352 142 46 has have VERB expositions-2352 142 47 over over ADP expositions-2352 142 48 600 600 NUM expositions-2352 142 49 members member NOUN expositions-2352 142 50 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 142 51 “ " PUNCT expositions-2352 142 52 there there PRON expositions-2352 142 53 are be VERB expositions-2352 142 54 enough enough ADJ expositions-2352 142 55 strong strong ADJ expositions-2352 142 56 scholars scholar NOUN expositions-2352 142 57 currently currently ADV expositions-2352 142 58 doing do VERB expositions-2352 142 59 research research NOUN expositions-2352 142 60 that that SCONJ expositions-2352 142 61 we we PRON expositions-2352 142 62 could could AUX expositions-2352 142 63 double double VERB expositions-2352 142 64 the the DET expositions-2352 142 65 number number NOUN expositions-2352 142 66 of of ADP expositions-2352 142 67 top top ADJ expositions-2352 142 68 institutions institution NOUN expositions-2352 142 69 teaching teach VERB expositions-2352 142 70 asian asian ADJ expositions-2352 142 71 philosophy philosophy NOUN expositions-2352 142 72 overnight overnight ADV expositions-2352 142 73 if if SCONJ expositions-2352 142 74 there there PRON expositions-2352 142 75 were be VERB expositions-2352 142 76 the the DET expositions-2352 142 77 will will NOUN expositions-2352 142 78 to to PART expositions-2352 142 79 do do AUX expositions-2352 142 80 so so ADV expositions-2352 142 81 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 142 82 ” " PUNCT expositions-2352 143 1 perhaps perhaps ADV expositions-2352 143 2 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 143 3 but but CCONJ expositions-2352 143 4 as as SCONJ expositions-2352 143 5 anyone anyone PRON expositions-2352 143 6 who who PRON expositions-2352 143 7 has have AUX expositions-2352 143 8 sat sit VERB expositions-2352 143 9 on on ADP expositions-2352 143 10 a a DET expositions-2352 143 11 failed fail VERB expositions-2352 143 12 search search NOUN expositions-2352 143 13 committee committee NOUN expositions-2352 143 14 knows know VERB expositions-2352 143 15 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 143 16 numbers number NOUN expositions-2352 143 17 alone alone ADV expositions-2352 143 18 do do AUX expositions-2352 143 19 not not PART expositions-2352 143 20 guarantee guarantee VERB expositions-2352 143 21 a a DET expositions-2352 143 22 hire hire NOUN expositions-2352 143 23 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 144 1 5 5 X expositions-2352 144 2 . . X expositions-2352 144 3 antonin antonin PROPN expositions-2352 144 4 scalia scalia PROPN expositions-2352 144 5 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 144 6 dissenting dissent VERB expositions-2352 144 7 opinion opinion NOUN expositions-2352 144 8 in in ADP expositions-2352 144 9 obergefell obergefell NOUN expositions-2352 144 10 v. v. ADP expositions-2352 144 11 hodges hodges PROPN expositions-2352 144 12 576 576 NUM expositions-2352 144 13 us we PRON expositions-2352 144 14 8n22 8n22 NUM expositions-2352 144 15 ( ( PUNCT expositions-2352 144 16 2015 2015 NUM expositions-2352 144 17 ) ) PUNCT expositions-2352 144 18 ; ; PUNCT expositions-2352 145 1 https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/576/14-556/dissent5.html https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/576/14-556/dissent5.html X expositions-2352 145 2 . . NOUN expositions-2352 146 1 6 6 X expositions-2352 146 2 . . X expositions-2352 146 3 van van PROPN expositions-2352 146 4 norden norden PROPN expositions-2352 146 5 eventually eventually ADV expositions-2352 146 6 revises revise VERB expositions-2352 146 7 this this PRON expositions-2352 146 8 to to PART expositions-2352 146 9 add add VERB expositions-2352 146 10 that that SCONJ expositions-2352 146 11 “ " PUNCT expositions-2352 146 12 ‘ ' PUNCT expositions-2352 146 13 importance importance NOUN expositions-2352 146 14 ’ ' PUNCT expositions-2352 146 15 ultimately ultimately ADV expositions-2352 146 16 gets get VERB expositions-2352 146 17 its its PRON expositions-2352 146 18 sense sense NOUN expositions-2352 146 19 from from ADP expositions-2352 146 20 the the DET expositions-2352 146 21 question question NOUN expositions-2352 146 22 of of ADP expositions-2352 146 23 the the DET expositions-2352 146 24 way way NOUN expositions-2352 146 25 one one PRON expositions-2352 146 26 should should AUX expositions-2352 146 27 live live VERB expositions-2352 146 28 ” " PUNCT expositions-2352 146 29 ( ( PUNCT expositions-2352 146 30 151 151 NUM expositions-2352 146 31 ) ) PUNCT expositions-2352 146 32 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 147 1 7 7 X expositions-2352 147 2 . . X expositions-2352 147 3 starters starter NOUN expositions-2352 147 4 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 147 5 that that ADV expositions-2352 147 6 is is ADV expositions-2352 147 7 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 147 8 because because SCONJ expositions-2352 147 9 i i PRON expositions-2352 147 10 do do AUX expositions-2352 147 11 not not PART expositions-2352 147 12 here here ADV expositions-2352 147 13 wish wish VERB expositions-2352 147 14 to to PART expositions-2352 147 15 take take VERB expositions-2352 147 16 up up ADP expositions-2352 147 17 van van PROPN expositions-2352 147 18 norden norden PROPN expositions-2352 147 19 ’s ’s PART expositions-2352 147 20 ( ( PUNCT expositions-2352 147 21 cheeky cheeky ADJ expositions-2352 147 22 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 147 23 polemical polemical ADJ expositions-2352 147 24 ) ) PUNCT expositions-2352 147 25 claim claim NOUN expositions-2352 147 26 that that SCONJ expositions-2352 147 27 any any DET expositions-2352 147 28 “ " PUNCT expositions-2352 147 29 philosophy philosophy NOUN expositions-2352 147 30 graduate graduate NOUN expositions-2352 147 31 student student NOUN expositions-2352 147 32 who who PRON expositions-2352 147 33 casually casually ADV expositions-2352 147 34 threw throw VERB expositions-2352 147 35 around around ADP expositions-2352 147 36 terms term NOUN expositions-2352 147 37 such such ADJ expositions-2352 147 38 as as ADP expositions-2352 147 39 less less ADJ expositions-2352 147 40 manifesto manifesto NOUN expositions-2352 147 41 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 147 42 more more ADJ expositions-2352 147 43 philosophy philosophy NOUN expositions-2352 147 44 26 26 NUM expositions-2352 147 45         SPACE expositions-2352 147 46 ‘ ' PUNCT expositions-2352 147 47 logical logical ADJ expositions-2352 147 48 reasoning reasoning NOUN expositions-2352 147 49 ’ ' PUNCT expositions-2352 147 50 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 147 51 ‘ ' PUNCT expositions-2352 147 52 empirical empirical ADJ expositions-2352 147 53 ’ ' PUNCT expositions-2352 147 54 as as SCONJ expositions-2352 147 55 if if SCONJ expositions-2352 147 56 they they PRON expositions-2352 147 57 were be AUX expositions-2352 147 58 unambiguous unambiguous ADJ expositions-2352 147 59 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 147 60 uncontroversial uncontroversial ADJ expositions-2352 147 61 would would AUX expositions-2352 147 62 be be AUX expositions-2352 147 63 given give VERB expositions-2352 147 64 a a DET expositions-2352 147 65 remedial remedial ADJ expositions-2352 147 66 reading reading NOUN expositions-2352 147 67 list list NOUN expositions-2352 147 68 including include VERB expositions-2352 147 69 the the DET expositions-2352 147 70 works work NOUN expositions-2352 147 71 of of ADP expositions-2352 147 72 pierre pierre NOUN expositions-2352 147 73 duhem duhem NOUN expositions-2352 147 74 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 147 75 gaston gaston PROPN expositions-2352 147 76 bachelard bachelard PROPN expositions-2352 147 77 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 147 78 thomas thomas PROPN expositions-2352 147 79 kuhn kuhn PROPN expositions-2352 147 80 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 147 81 jean jean PROPN expositions-2352 147 82 - - PUNCT expositions-2352 147 83 françois françois PROPN expositions-2352 147 84 lyotard lyotard PROPN expositions-2352 147 85 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 147 86 paul paul PROPN expositions-2352 147 87 feyerabend feyerabend PROPN expositions-2352 147 88 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 147 89 michel michel PROPN expositions-2352 147 90 foucault foucault PROPN expositions-2352 147 91 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 147 92 w.v.o w.v.o PROPN expositions-2352 147 93 . . PUNCT expositions-2352 147 94 quine quine PROPN expositions-2352 147 95 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 147 96 wilfrid wilfrid PROPN expositions-2352 147 97 sellars sellars PROPN expositions-2352 147 98 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 147 99 donald donald PROPN expositions-2352 147 100 davidson davidson PROPN expositions-2352 147 101 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 147 102 and and CCONJ expositions-2352 147 103 richard richard PROPN expositions-2352 147 104 rorty rorty PROPN expositions-2352 147 105 , , PUNCT expositions-2352 147 106 for for ADP expositions-2352 147 107 starters starter NOUN expositions-2352 147 108 ” " PUNCT expositions-2352 147 109 ( ( PUNCT expositions-2352 147 110 13 13 NUM expositions-2352 147 111 ) ) PUNCT expositions-2352 147 112 . . PUNCT