





































  
 

Copyright © The Author(s) 
Vol. 3, No. 1, January 2022 

e-ISSN: 2723-4126 
p-ISSN: 2776-8880 

 

1 
 

BILINGUALISM IN ENGLISH AS A FOREIGN LANGUAGE 
(EFL) CLASSROOM CONTEXT 

 
Siti Patonah1 & Rifki Irawan 2* 

1,2 Universitas PGRI Yogyakarta, Yogyakarta, Indonesia 

 
*rifkizam@upy.ac.id 

 

ABSTRACT 

This study explores the process and obstacles of bilingualism at SMP Muhammadiyah 3 
Yogyakarta. The research was descriptive qualitative research. The samples of this research 
were 20 students. The data used were collected from observation, questionnaires, 
interviews, and documentation. This data sources were students of grade VIII and one 
English teacher at SMP Muhammadiyah 3 Yogyakarta. Data analysis was performed using a 
Linker's scale for questionnaire data, data reduction, data presentation, verification, and 
conclusions.  The results showed that students' interactions with students and students 
with teachers in the bilingual class of SMP Muhammadiyah 3 Yogyakarta in the learning 
process were still ineffective and experienced difficulties that hinder the interaction 
process. The findings were as follows (1) Students still felt insecure if they had to use full of 
English to interact with friends in a bilingual class, they still felt afraid of mispronouncing 
English correctly and adequately, they did not master vocabulary well, and they used 
English in bilingual with the teacher only in the classroom. (2) The obstacles that students 
experienced in the teaching and learning process in a bilingual class as follows: Students 
still felt ashamed to use English to interact in a bilingual class, they still taught that using 
English was not a necessity in a bilingual class, sometimes, Bahasa Indonesia was still a 
language to interact with friends, and they were still afraid of using English by with 
excellent and correct English in pronunciation. 

Keywords: Bilingual class, Students' Interaction, Teacher Strategies 

INTRODUCTION 

Talking about bilingual cannot be separated from aspects of interaction. Interaction is 
the heart of communication in the era of communicative language instruction (Brown, 
2001). Communication must be included in every language learning activity since it is the 
most important aspect in communicative language education. In language learning 
environments, students are expected to be able to speak and communicate with others. 
Through the interaction, they will learn how to communicate and interact. As a result, the 
interaction among the language classroom participants might reveal the communication in 
the language teaching and learning classroom . 

Interaction is important because it is claimed that only through interaction can the 
learner decompose the target language structures and derive meanings from classroom 

http://u.lipi.go.id/1593190689
http://u.lipi.go.id/1593190689


  
 

Copyright © The Author(s) 
Vol. 3, No. 1, January 2022 

e-ISSN: 2723-4126 
p-ISSN: 2776-8880 

 

2 
 

events. Moreover, interaction allows learners to incorporate the target language structure 
into their own speech. In addition, any classroom event, whether thought or not, has 
meaning for learners (Chaudron, 1998). Moreover, Interaction and input is important an 
needed in second language acquisition. The 'correct size and form' of input, as well as the 
suitable frequency of engagement, should theoretically lead to more effective second 
language acquisition (Maharsi, 2016). 

The functions of verbal interaction, which focuses on students' verbal language, the 
character, and intent of students' utterances in peer group interaction, is the first of three 
analytical aspects of interaction. The second was cognitive processing, which looked at how 
students approached and processed learning tasks in social interactions. Finally, there's 
social processing, which looks into the nature of the social bonds formed throughout 
students' social activities (Sembiring, 2018). 

The existence of an international standard school in Indonesia has attracted the 
attention of researchers. The program that was featured was a breakthrough to improve 
the competitiveness of human resources. Support comes from parents who want their 
children to be more independent and able to compete. Some reasons why the parents want 
their children choose the bilingual school are first, superior English language skills are 
expected; second, preparation for foreign schools, abroad schools, and university 
admission; and third, parental satisfaction (Santos, 2019). 

The mission of organizing an international standard school is to create intelligent and 
internationally competitive Indonesians who can compete and collaborate globally 
(Depdiknas, 2006). However, there has been no reference or school that can be used as a 
model for an ideal international school according to Indonesian standards. One of the 
fundamental steps that have been used as a marker for international standard schools is 
still the use of a different language of instruction, namely the international language 
(English). However, There are some misalignments between the policies and the principles 
of bilingual education. They were unregulated curriculum creation based on a mix of 
international and national standards, the government's Teacher Training Program for 
Bilingual School Teachers (PLPG), and the establishment of standardized tests (Surdyanto, 
2018). 

Some relevant studies discussed about the use of a second language in learning. First,  
the use of a second language in learning does not reduce students' interaction . But with the 
existence of bilingualism can help in the learning process of students in the classroom. in 
this study using interpretative qualitative research methods. By involving questionnaires, 
classroom observations, and interviews. The conclusion in this study is the use of bilinguals 
in EFL classes will not reduce student learning intentions to learn English. In each learning 
teacher does not eliminate L1 in explaining what can not be explained by using the L2 
language, This is a huge source of motivation for EFL students. 

For the second study, speaking for a purpose: a case study of bilingual immersion 
pedagogy within the Chinese EFL context. By David Roman Potcek (2017) the University of 
Windsor in this study mentioned that the second language or bilingual in learning and the 
world of work or the world of work is needed, bilingual use can unite cross-cultural 
learning such as Canada and China. In this study, researchers used a qualitative framework 

http://u.lipi.go.id/1593190689
http://u.lipi.go.id/1593190689


  
 

Copyright © The Author(s) 
Vol. 3, No. 1, January 2022 

e-ISSN: 2723-4126 
p-ISSN: 2776-8880 

 

3 
 

method that is by applying narrative inquiry, observation, interview, and document 
analysis methods as primary data collection. The results of this study are that teachers who 
participate in EFL teachers must always try to develop students' intentions in learning 
English. Creating a good atmosphere, so that it will be easier for children to understand the 
lesson. 

The third study was "phenomenological study: bilingual teaching classroom of 
Malaysian community colleges" by fandatuljana Mohd Noor, Hairuddin Harun (2014) 
University Tun Hussein on Malaysia. This study uses non-structured interview methods, 
non-participant observation, and note-taking. The respondents in this study were 
instructors of course content from several different programs at the community college in 
Malaysia. The results of this study are that most trainers are less interested in using English 
in the classroom except the trainers from the tourism course. The use of English in 
classrooms depends on the relevance and needs of the instructor, not on the interests of 
students. Bilingual teaching classes are preferred because they help instructors to develop 
students' understanding of learning content and English translation. This study is well-
proven, proving that bilingual teaching classes are important phenomena that exist in 
Malaysian community colleges and this study hasn't been done before. 

The first thesis investigates the contribution of English in schools to English learning 
and the authors use mixed methods to achieve the objectives of this study; qualitative and 
quantitative methods. From these similarities and differences, researchers are interested in 
knowing the process of interaction and teaching and learning of students and teachers in 
bilingual classes, and the technique used in this study is a qualitative approach. This 
research is different from other researches because it is discussed in detail what students 
experienced when in a bilingual class, namely how the interactions occured, the obstacles 
faced by students, and the teacher's strategies in solving these obstacles, of course, the 
benefits that students get while in the bilingual class. 

The scope of this study is how the interaction process of students and students, 

students, and teachers and the implementation of bilingual classes in SMP Muhammadiyah 

3 Yogyakarta. Our study addresses three research questions how is the process of 

bilingualism at SMP Muhammadiyah 3 Yogyakarta? What are the obstacles during the 

implementation of bilingualism at SMP Muhammadiyah 3 Yogyakarta? and what are the 

teachers’ strategies to overcome the obstacles during the implementation of bilingualism at 

SMP Muhammadiyah 3 Yogyakarta? 

METHODS 

Research Setting 

This research was conducted in SMP Muhammadiyah 3 Yogyakarta. The researcher has 

selected 20 grade VIII students and one English teacher to learn related to the bilingual 

class. A teacher should know how important it is for a bilingual class to review the quality 

of learning in the classroom. Schools must also know how the effects and benefits of having 

bilingual classes are in the school. There are many things related to English in today's era, 

http://u.lipi.go.id/1593190689
http://u.lipi.go.id/1593190689


  
 

Copyright © The Author(s) 
Vol. 3, No. 1, January 2022 

e-ISSN: 2723-4126 
p-ISSN: 2776-8880 

 

4 
 

and sometimes we are required to use English as a medium for communication with 

friends, colleagues, and fellow professionals. Therefore, the authors wanted to know about 

the existence of a bilingual class in a school.   

Research Method 

For this purpose, it is not to separate individuals or groups into specific variables or 

theories. The data collected in this analysis have been collected qualitatively. There are also 

many types of data, including summaries of what the researcher saw and heard, what 
participants said and wrote, and what participants used and created. Thus the essence of 

the data is a narrative taken from in-depth interviews and a questionnaire to answer this 

research question. Qualitative research is a form of data to collect data from questionnaires 

and interviews with junior high school students. The theory above states that there are 

many ways to collect data when they see and hear something.   

Data and Data Sources 

Data to be taken from this research are English students, and the location will be 
taken at SMP Muhammadiyah 3 Yogyakarta. Sources of data come from questionnaires and 
interview data. Primary data is data collected in the field from first-hand data sources. The 
source of this data can be respondent or test subjects from the results of filling out 
questionnaires, interviews, and findings. The primary data in this research is the 
correspondence substance analysed.  

This research was conducted at SMP Muhammadiyah 3 Yogyakarta, one of the 
international standard Islamic schools. The researchers took this school because not all 
schools had bilingual classes, and not all students at SMP Muhammadiyah 3 Yogyakarta 
liked, understood, and were interested in learning languages. English, students lack 
motivation, lack self-confidence; the method used by the teacher is less attractive so that 
students find it challenging to learn English. Learning English, teachers use full English in 
delivering lessons to students and students who are not native speakers. Therefore, the 
researcher wanted to know how the bilingual class was implemented, the interaction 
process between students and students, and the teaching and learning process in the 
bilingual class during the learning process in the classroom at SMP Muhammadiyah 3 
Yogyakarta. 

Twenty students will be participants in the questionnaire, and some of them will be 
interview participants. Interviewing students will support the questionnaire. It involves 
English teachers at SMP Muhammadiyah 3 Yogyakarta Middle School. There will be about 
ten students being interviewed and taking the questionnaire and maintaining 
confidentiality by ensuring that the test findings, all information, and other issues, remain 
confidential. Researchers will store all information and data collected from respondents in 
this study. 
 

 

http://u.lipi.go.id/1593190689
http://u.lipi.go.id/1593190689


  
 

Copyright © The Author(s) 
Vol. 3, No. 1, January 2022 

e-ISSN: 2723-4126 
p-ISSN: 2776-8880 

 

5 
 

Techniques of Collecting Data 

The data collection techniques used in this study were questionnaires and interviews. 

Researchers will obtain direct interview information from respondents when speaking 

face-to-face via video calls and using cell phones as an instrument to record interview data, 

and there are ten interview questions. Researchers also distributed questionnaires to 

students to get factual data about their perceptions. The questionnaire contains about ten 

statements. The author translated it into Indonesian to help participants fill out the 
questionnaire quickly. The data collection instrument used a closed questionnaire. 

The questionnaire contains ten closed questions. These questions are categorized into 

the following concerns: students’ preferences, student interaction, significant influence, and 

the advantages and disadvantages.   

In this research, the researcher uses The Likert scale to analyze the data. The Likert 

scale is used to measure a person or group of individuals' attitudes, wealth, and beliefs 

about social phenomena (Danuri & Maisaroh, 2019). The variables to be evaluated are 

converted into indicator variables using a Likert scale. The indicator is then used to compile 

instrument objects as a starting point, which may be statements or queries.  

The Likert scale is a research scale used to measure attitudes and opinions (Miles & 

Huberman, 1994). With this Likert scale, respondents are asked to fill out a questionnaire 
that requires them to indicate their level of conformity with a series of questions. The 

questions or statements used in this research are usually referred to as research variables 

and are explicitly determined by researchers. The name of this scale is taken from its 

creator, Rensis Likert, a social psychologist from the United States. The level of approval 

referred to in this Likert scale consists of 5 choices of scales passed from Strongly Agree 

(SA) to Strongly Disagree (SDA). The five options include  Strongly Agree (SA), Agree (A), 

Neutral (N), Disagree (DA) and Strongly Disagree (SDA). 

To determine the number of respondents studied, several techniques for determining 

the number of samples can be used, one of which is the sample determination technique 

using the Slovin formula. Mathematically the Slovin formula used to determine the number 

of samples is as follows (Creswell, 2012): 

n = N / ( 1 + N.(e)2) 
information: 
n = number of samples 
N = total population 
e = error tolerance limit  
below is how to solve it:  
n = N / ( 1 + N.(e)2) 
n= 32 / 1+32 x (0.05) 2 
n=32/1+32x0.0025 
n=32/1+0.08 
n=32/1+0.08 

http://u.lipi.go.id/1593190689
http://u.lipi.go.id/1593190689


  
 

Copyright © The Author(s) 
Vol. 3, No. 1, January 2022 

e-ISSN: 2723-4126 
p-ISSN: 2776-8880 

 

6 
 

n=32/1.08 
n=29,629 
n=30 

For example, in calculating the Slovin formula, the results are 100 respondents. We 

will analyze the answers from 100 respondents by doing calculations like the example 

below: 

30 respondents answered SA(Strongly Agree)  
30 respondents answered A (Agree) 
Five respondents answered N (Neutral) 
20 respondents answered DA (Disagree) 
15 respondents answered SDA (Strongly Disagree) 

Based on these data, 60 respondents or 60% answered agree (30 respondents) and 
strongly agreed (30 respondents). From these results, it can be concluded that the majority 
of employees in the company agree with the company regulations. 

Data Reduction 

Data reduction in this study aims to facilitate researchers' understanding of the data 
that has been collected from the research results. Researchers will collect data or 
information through questionnaires and interviews with respondents so that researchers 
can examine the research in detail. Then the data that has been reduced will provide a 
clearer picture and make it easier for researchers to carry out further data collection and 
search for it if needed. 

Data Display 

In qualitative research, data can be presented in the form of brief descriptions, charts, 
category correlations, flowcharts, and the like (Sugiyono, 2009). By displaying the data, it 
will be easier to understand what happened; plan the following work based on what has 
been understood because the method used in this research is a case study, so the data 
display that is done is more in the form of a description. The display of facts can enhance 
accepted interpretations. At this point, the researcher learns comprehensive knowledge 
based on the problem. 

Verification  

The final step is the drawing and verification conclusion of the interpretation by the 
researcher: the drawing of meaning from displayed data. The qualitative analyst begins 
determining what things mean; nothing is about regularities, trends, explications, potential 
configurations, casual flows, and prepositions from the start of data collection, Miles & 
Huberman (1994).  In the analysis of data related to the problem, the researcher made 
some moves. 
  

http://u.lipi.go.id/1593190689
http://u.lipi.go.id/1593190689


  
 

Copyright © The Author(s) 
Vol. 3, No. 1, January 2022 

e-ISSN: 2723-4126 
p-ISSN: 2776-8880 

 

7 
 

Data Validity  

There are some ways to check the validity of the data in qualitative analysis, including 
authenticity, transferability, reliability, and conformability. Four triangulation forms are 
included: process triangulation, inter-researcher triangulation, triangulation of data 
sources, and triangulation of theory (Creswell, 2012). 

Method triangulation is carried out in various directions by comparing the actual 
results or data. As is established in qualitative research, to obtain reliable data, the 
researcher obtains data from an interview, observation, questionnaire, and paper. 

Triangulation of data sources sees such data through different approaches and 
sources of data collection methods. In addition to interviewing and observing, researchers 
may use participant notes, written records, and pictures or photos. From this statement, the 
authors decided to use the triangulation method and the triangulation of data sources to 
check the validity of the data and gain data confidence. 

RESULTS AND DISCUSSIONS  

Table 1. statement 1 questionnaire and interview data 

No Statement 
Central 

Tendency 
Interpretation 

1 I like that teachers use English while teaching bilingual 
classes. 

66% Agree 

Because the index value that the researcher obtained from the calculation result was 
66%, it can be concluded that the respondent "agrees" with the statement, namely I like 
teachers to use English while teaching in bilingual classes. The results of the data value can 
be supported by several respondents who were interviewed and stated the same thing; the 
respondent agreed that it was supposed to use English in the bilingual class. 

Transcript 1 Students’ responses 

NS1 P1: 1. Yes ……. because I can learn more or be better at using English. 
NS2 P1: Yes ……. because yes have fun ..... not bored. 
NS7 P1: likes …….. because listening to people speak English is great fun 
NS3 P1: Like ………. because it can increase knowledge, and can practice my ability to     
use English. 
NS8 P1: Yes, I like it, because since I was in Elementary School I was used to using  
                 English for explanations from the teacher. 

From the interview statement, the respondents felt they understood and paid 
attention when the teacher used English in the bilingual class because the respondents felt 
challenged to understand what the teacher was talking about so that they could practice 
how to speak English better according to grammar. This statement was different from the 
research results on the perception of English in bilingual classes in schools in Bali. 
According to Luh Putu Artini (Artini, 2011), Students feel confused and unclear about what 
the teacher says using English in the bilingual class at the RSBI school in Bali. If students 

http://u.lipi.go.id/1593190689
http://u.lipi.go.id/1593190689


  
 

Copyright © The Author(s) 
Vol. 3, No. 1, January 2022 

e-ISSN: 2723-4126 
p-ISSN: 2776-8880 

 

8 
 

were asked what their opinion was about the teacher who delivers learning material in 
English, the student feels they do not fully understand what the teacher says, the 
percentage that gets was only 57.53%. In the bilingual class at SMP Muhammadiyah 
Yogyakarta, the students believe that they understand what the teacher says in every 
English lesson using English. Because the abilities owned in each school are different, in 
Muhammadiyah 3 Junior High School, Yogyakarta students have gone through the 
screening process. To register for the bilingual class, students were selected first. 

Table 2. Statement 2 questionnaire and interview data 

No Statement 
Central 

Tendency 
Interpretation 

2 I am happy that my English score has improved. 91% Strongly agree 

The second statement from the questionnaire found by the researcher was 91%, so it 
can be concluded that the respondent "strongly agrees" with the statement that the 
respondents' English score increased when they were in a bilingual class. The results of the 
data value can be supported by the results of the interviewee's statement. 

Transcript 2 Students’ responses 

NS1 P3: Yes, because the bilingual class teaches English more. 
NS5 P3: Yes, my English score has improved quite a lot. 
NS2 P3: You could say yes because you understand more about English. 
NS4 P3: Yes, because we are trained in English well so that we can understand  
                better… 
NS8 P3: yes, increased. 

From the second questionnaire, most of the respondents experienced an increase in 
their English scores. Even though some of them also tried to understand that their English 
scores increased, they understood that they felt they paid less attention to the teacher 
when their scores decreased. 

There were other studies on the implementation of bilingual classes in schools that 
were more or less the same as the answers or research results, showing that students in 
bilingual classes get more grades and progress in better English scores. According to 
Yulianie Kasari (Kasari, 2013), the results of this research show that students were more 
enthusiastic in using English, students understand more about vocabulary, students have 
started to understand when reading stories or watching films in English. It was evident 
from the evaluation results conveyed by parents. 

Table 3. Statement 3 questionnaire and interview data 

No Statement 
Central 

Tendency 
Interpretation 

3 My teacher always asks questions in English. 62% agree 

http://u.lipi.go.id/1593190689
http://u.lipi.go.id/1593190689


  
 

Copyright © The Author(s) 
Vol. 3, No. 1, January 2022 

e-ISSN: 2723-4126 
p-ISSN: 2776-8880 

 

9 
 

Because the index value of the statement that the researcher obtained from the 
calculation was 62%, it was be concluded that the respondent "agrees" with the statement 
that a teacher always asks questions in English in the classroom. The results of the data 
value can be supported by student interview statements. 

Transcript 3. Students’ responses 

NS4 P2: My opinion is good because the teacher trains our knowledge of English 
NS10 P2: Like it, because English classes require practice. 
NS9 P2: Yes, but if possible, someone can use Indonesian too, the problem is that I  
                don't understand 
NS8 P2: In my opinion, it is very good because it can improve the pronunciation of  
                English words 
NS4 P2: My opinion is good because the teacher trains our knowledge of English 

Most students can understand when the teacher asks questions in English and always 
uses English throughout the lesson in a bilingual class. However, some of them want the 
teacher to use Indonesian or translate what he was talking about. Some students feel less 
confident, so they feel embarrassed and afraid of misunderstanding what the teacher says. 

The questionnaire in this section states that the teacher always asks questions in 
English in bilingual classes, which gets good responses from students. Students themselves 
understand what the teacher says in the bilingual class. However, it was different from the 
junior high school in Klaten, namely the 2 Klaten public junior high school. Students still 
feel stiff if the teacher uses English continuously in class VII (Istianti, 2009). However, 
unlike class VIII, who had been in the bilingual class a year earlier, they felt no longer stiff 
to use English. 

Table 4. Statement 4 questionnaire and interview data 

No Statement 
Central 

Tendency 
Interpretation 

4 
I am happy that I interact more smoothly with friends and 
teachers using English. 

77% Agree 

From the results of the questionnaire data that the researcher got from the 
calculation, namely 77% for the statement, I was happy that I was more fluent in 
interacting with friends and the teacher using English was conclude that the respondent 
"agree" with the statement. The results of the interview data supported this value. 

Transcript 4. Students’ responses 

NS1 P7: Not bad, during the English lesson. 
NS8 P7: just sometimes. 
NS6 P7: Not very often 
NS7 P7: It's rare to friends, it's not bad for teachers 
NS2 P7: You could say it is rare because it is not obligatory to use English. 

http://u.lipi.go.id/1593190689
http://u.lipi.go.id/1593190689


  
 

Copyright © The Author(s) 
Vol. 3, No. 1, January 2022 

e-ISSN: 2723-4126 
p-ISSN: 2776-8880 

 

10 
 

The questionnaire statement said that most students could interact with friends and 
teachers when English lessons take place. A small proportion of students think that they 
could not interact with teachers and friends because they were accustomed to using 
English and were not obliged according to them.  

In this questionnaire, in his statement, students feel happy interacting with the 
teacher using English only as necessary to use English during class hours. The result of the 
research was the occurrence of social interaction between teachers and students, namely 
when the teacher provides material, then students give arguments and ask questions. When 
outside the classroom or during class hours, they were free to use language for social 
interaction (Yuliani, 2010). 

Table 5. Statement 5 questionnaire and interview data 

No Statement 
Central 

Tendency 
Interpretation 

5 My teacher always uses English in giving instructions. 71% Agree 

Where the fifth statement from the questionnaire found by the researcher was 71%, 
so it can be said that the respondent "agrees" that the teacher always provides instructions 
in English in the bilingual class, they also understand that every teacher gives instructions 
in English. It was also supported by the statements of several answers to the questions I 
gave in the interview. 

Transcript 5. Students’ responses 

NS2 P4: Got it. 
NS9 P4: God willing, you understand, so far most of you have already understood  
                your sister. 
NS10 P4: Some I understand and some I don't. 
NS8 P4: yes, I understand and understand the lesson. 
NS7 P4: understand, if I don't understand I can ask the teacher directly 
NS5 P4: I understand the material provided by the teacher in English. 
NS3 P4: I can understand the explanation given by the teacher in English very well 
NS1 P4: Not bad, because I will learn the meaning word by word a little at a time. 

From the interview statement above the students "agree" with the statement. 
Students feel understanding what the teacher said and if students feel they do not 
understand what the teacher said, students dare to ask questions. Some students feel that 
instructing English is very important because they were in a bilingual class. some students 
do not understand a little, students slowly understand and continue to understand what the 
teacher says. 

  

http://u.lipi.go.id/1593190689
http://u.lipi.go.id/1593190689


  
 

Copyright © The Author(s) 
Vol. 3, No. 1, January 2022 

e-ISSN: 2723-4126 
p-ISSN: 2776-8880 

 

11 
 

Table 6. Statement 6,8  questionnaire and interview data 

 
The two statements above, namely the sixth statement from the questionnaire 

showing 82% presentation, namely "strongly agree," where students strongly agree with 
the teacher's statement, always justifies when I was wrong in interacting with friends using 
constructive sentences. Then for the eighth statement, the percentage was 82% or 
"strongly agree" with the questionnaire statement, namely, the English skills of the teachers 
motivated me to improve my English skills. 

In this questionnaire, students strongly agree when students were wrong in using 
good and correct English, the teacher always corrects. The English language skills 
possessed by the teacher motivate students to learn English to be even more active, to be 
more fluent in pronunciation and interaction using English. This was the same as the 
research studied by Anak Agung Putri Maharani and Ketut Sri Widhiasih (Maharani & 
Widhiasih, 2016). The research results were that students feel happy when learning 
English because students feel they get positive feedback from the teacher. However, it is not 
similar with the finding from (Purwanti, Adiwijaya, & ..., 2020) which bilingual education is 
not being implemented adequately in the teaching and learning process. 

Table 7. Statements 7 questionnaire and interview data 

No Statement 
Central 

Tendency 
Interpretation 

7 
I am excited to always try to interact using English with 
friends. 

74% Agree 

Where from the seventh statement, the percentage was 74%, which means "agree." 
The respondent agrees with the questionnaire statement. Namely, I was always excited to 
try to interact using English with friends. The questionnaire statement means that by 
interacting with their friends. Students feel their vocabulary increases and become 
smoother. It was also supported by the question of the answers from the interview. 

Transcript 6. Students’ responses 

NS1 P5: Not bad, when English lessons were held. 
NS2 P5: It's rare because it's better to use Indonesian. 
NS6 P5: Sometimes…. Yes 
NS3 P5: Sometimes "I interact in English with friends. 

Table 8. Statement 9 questionnaire and data interview 

No Statement 
Central 

Tendency 
Interpretation 

6 
The teacher always corrects me when I am wrong in 
interacting with friends by using constructive sentences. 

82% Strongly agree 

8 
The English skills of the teachers motivated me to 
improve my English skills. 

82% Strongly agree 

http://u.lipi.go.id/1593190689
http://u.lipi.go.id/1593190689


  
 

Copyright © The Author(s) 
Vol. 3, No. 1, January 2022 

e-ISSN: 2723-4126 
p-ISSN: 2776-8880 

 

12 
 

No Statement 
Central 

Tendency 
Interpretation 

9 
I understand easily when the teacher explains in English in a 
bilingual class. 

71% Agree 

10 
I am excited when the teacher uses English to give 
instructions. 

69% Agree 

The ninth statement shows the percentage of 71%, which means "agree" with the 
questionnaire statement. I quickly understood when the teacher explains using English in a 
bilingual class. Then for the tenth questionnaire statement, the percentage was 69%, which 
means "agree" with the following statement I was excited when the teacher uses English to 
give instructions. interview answers supported this. 

Transcript 7. Teachers’ Interview 

1. The implementation of bilingual classes currently still focuses on additional English in 
collaboration with ELTI institutions. In the future, it is hoped that it can continue to 
develop, bilingual class students, can present English dramas and can communicate actively 
using English. 

2. One of the main problems is the lack of self-confidence of students. If the school is busy 
with class hours so that additional English is done too late. 

3. Yes. Often 
4. Yes 
5. Quite good, even at the time of graduation and graduation the bilingual class students are 

ranked in the top 10 parallel. 
6. Quite often 
7. Prepare students to face the global era. 
8. Through selection. Multiple-choice questions were given and an interview was conducted 

in English. 
9. Very influential 
10. Since 2011 

The interaction between teachers and students always occurs in bilingual classes 
using English. For student and student interaction, many students still use Indonesian. In 
the teaching and learning process, bilingual education is not well implemented (Purwanti et 
al., 2020).  Another evidence reveals that billingual class disproportionately serves middle 
and upper-income households when evaluating these some communities arguments (80 
percent from these strata). Many causes contribute to this predicament, including a variety 
of financial, social, and academic reasons, and the government must devote more attention 
to ensuring that low-income compliance criteria are followed (Jayanti & Sujarwo, 2019). 

From the results of the interviews, it is not surprising that students who enter the 
bilingual class are often included in the top 10 parallel winners during the distribution of 
report cards each semester and at graduation. There are still many hopes and aspirations 
for bilingual classes so that for now and in the future, the bilingual class at SMP 
Muhammadiyah 3 Yogyakarta will make breakthroughs and ways to overcome some of the 

http://u.lipi.go.id/1593190689
http://u.lipi.go.id/1593190689


  
 

Copyright © The Author(s) 
Vol. 3, No. 1, January 2022 

e-ISSN: 2723-4126 
p-ISSN: 2776-8880 

 

13 
 

obstacles that students experience in bilingual classes, such as collaborating with ELTI 
institutions and it is hoped that who entered. In the future, bilingual classes can constantly 
interact with anyone who uses English and can appreciate drama activities in English. 
Moreover, each individual is expected to be able to prepare for the global era. 

CONCLUSION 

Based on data analysis and discussion, it can be concluded that interactions among 
students and teachers that occurred in the bilingual class of SMP Muhammadiyah 3 
Yogyakarta in the learning process were still ineffective and experienced difficulties. The 
difficulties were students still felt insecure if they had to use full English to interact with 
others, still felt afraid of mispronouncing English properly and correctly. In addition, they 
did not master vocabulary well and used English in bilingual classes with the teacher only 
in the learning process. 

The obstacles that students experienced in the teaching and learning process in a 
bilingual class were students still felt ashamed to use English to interact and still thought 
that using English was not a necessity in a bilingual class. Bahasa Indonesia was still a 
language to interact with friends because they were still afraid of using English is not by 
good and correct English in pronunciation. 

The teacher's strategies in dealing with the obstacles that occurred in the learning 
process in the bilingual class at Muhammadiyah 3 Junior High School in Yogyakarta were 
the school collaborated with the ELTI institution which was expected to continue to 
develop. This strategy would hone its potential so that the bilingual class could present 
English drama, and actively interacted using English to face the global era. Moreover, there 
were additional hours for English classes outside of active learning hours. 

REFERENCES 

Artini, L. P. (2011). Persepsi Guru Dan Siswa Terhadap Penggunaan Bahasa Inggris Di Kelas 
Bilingual Di Sekolah Menengah Atas Berstatus Rsbi Di Bali. Jurnal Ilmu Pendidikan, 17(4), 307–
312. 

Brown, H. D. (2001). Teaching By Principles: An Interactive Approach To Language Pedagogy. New 
York: Pearson Education. 

Chaudron, C. (1998). Second Language Classrooms. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. 

Creswell, J. (2012). Educational Research: Planning, Conducting And Evaluating Quantitative And 
Qualitative Research (Fourth Edi). Boston: Pearson Education. Retrieved From 

Http://Www.Ghbook.Ir/Index.Php?Name=  های رسانه  و  فرهنگ 

Option=Com_Dbook&Task=Readonline&Book_Id=13650&Page=73&Chkhashk=Ed9c949&نوین
1b4&Itemid=218&Lang=Fa&Tmpl=Component 

Danuri, & Maisaroh, S. (2019). Metodelogi Penelitian Pendidikan. Yogyakarta: Samudra Biru 
(Anggota Ikapi). 

Depdiknas. (2006). Kurikulum Tingkat Satuan Pendidikan. Jakarta: Departmen Pendidikan Nasional. 

Istianti. (2009). Implementasi Pembelajaran Bilingual Sebagai Wujud Rintisan Sekolah Berstaraf 
Internasioal. Surakarta: Universitas Sebelas Maret Surakarta. 

http://u.lipi.go.id/1593190689
http://u.lipi.go.id/1593190689


  
 

Copyright © The Author(s) 
Vol. 3, No. 1, January 2022 

e-ISSN: 2723-4126 
p-ISSN: 2776-8880 

 

14 
 

Jayanti, D., & Sujarwo, A. (2019). Bilingual Education In Indonesia: Between Idealism And The 
Reality. Script Journal: Journal Of Linguistic And English Teaching, 4(1), 12. 
Https://Doi.Org/10.24903/Sj.V4i1.271 

Kasari, Y. (2013). Analisis Penerapan Bilingual Class Guna Meningkatkan Keterampilan Bahasa 
Inggris Siswa. Jakarta. 

Maharani, A. A. P., & Widhiasih, L. K. S. (2016). Respon Siswa Terhadap Umpan Balik Guru Saat 
Pelajaran Bahasa Inggris Di Sd Saraswati 5 Denpasar. Jurnal Bakti Saraswati, 5(2). 

Maharsi, I. (2016). The Importance Of Input And Interaction In Second Language Acquisition. 
Journal Of English And Education, 5(1), 45–53. Https://Doi.Org/10.20885/Jee.Vol5.Iss1.Art4 

Miles, M., & Huberman, A. M. (1994). Qualitative Data Analysis. Newbury: Ca Sage. 

Purwanti, K. A., Adiwijaya, P. A., & ... (2020). The Implementation Of Bilingual Education At Bali 
Bilingual School Kindergarten (A Case Study). … Language Teaching …, 1–15. Retrieved From 
Http://E-Journal.Unmas.Ac.Id/Index.Php/Joselt/Article/View/704 

Santos, L. M. Dos. (2019). Bilingual English Education: Expectation Of Parents Who Enrol Their 
Children In Bilingual Primary Schools. International Journal Of Instruction, 12(4). 

Sembiring, L. T. A. B. (2018). Researching Students’ Interaction In Collaborative Learning Class. Jall 
(Journal Of Applied Linguistics And Literacy), 2(2), 125. 
Https://Doi.Org/10.25157/Jall.V2i2.2197 

Sugiyono. (2009). Metode Penelitian Kuantitatif, Kualitatif Dan R&D. Bandung: Alfabeta. 

Surdyanto, A. (2018). A Brief View On Bilingual Schools In The Capital Of Indonesia. Ijee (Indonesian 
Journal Of English Education), 5(1). Https://Doi.Org/10.15408/Ijee.V5i1.8018 

Yuliani, R. (2010). Interaksi Social Dalam Kelompok English Public Speaking Club (Eps) Di Smp-Sma 
Semesta Bilingual Boarding School Gunungpati Semarang. Semarang: Universitas Negeri 
Semarang. 

 

 

http://u.lipi.go.id/1593190689
http://u.lipi.go.id/1593190689

