06-sondi.indd 61 � AB STRA CT A novel approach, designated as the particle-mediated, nano-scale, aggregation route, to the formation and growth of spherical and colloid-sized anhydrous carbonate mineral particles and hierarchically organized biomineral carbon- ate structures is discussed. This model is inconsistent with the conventional crystallization mechanism, which is pri- marily based on diffusion growth. It is determined by the initial formation of nanosized, crystalline particles, (sin- glets), and their subsequent aggregation into submicrometre and micron-sized carbonate particle assemblies. This concept is much more common in Nature than has previously been assumed. The number of new examples of its signifi cance in the formation of inorganic and biogenic carbonate mineral solids has signifi cantly increased in recent years. A few illustrations are presented to show the appearance of nanostructured and hierarchically organized car- bonate particles formed through the nano-scale aggregation route in natural systems, together with those obtained from laboratory model experiments. Keywords: aggregation, carbonates, mechanism of formation A novel concept in the growth and design of anhydrous carbonate minerals: nano-scale aggregation mechanisms � Ivan Sondi1*, Srečo D. Škapin2, Irena Jurina1 and Damir Slovenec3 1Center for Marine and Environmental Research, Ruđer Bošković Institute, Zagreb, Croatia; (*corresponding author: sondi@irb.hr) 2Advanced Materials Department, Jožef Stefan Institute, Ljubljana, Slovenia; (sreco.skapin@ijs.si) 3Croatian Geological Survey, Sachsova 2, Zagreb, Croatia; (damir.slovenec@hgi-cgs.hr) doi: 104154/gc.2011.06 Geologia Croatica 64/1 61–65 6 Figs. Zagreb 2011 Geologia CroaticaGeologia Croatica 1. INTRODUCTION Anhydrous carbonate minerals are frequently found in Na- ture, commonly occurring as the main mineral constituents in rocks and sediments, and as the most common constitu- ents of the bio-inorganic structures of the skeletons and tis- sues of many mineralizing organisms (TUCKER & WRI- GHT, 1990; FLÜGEL, 2004; SONDI & JURAČIĆ, 2010; SONDI et al., 2011). Physico-chemical processes leading to the formation of anhydrous calcium carbonate polymorphs, i.e., vaterite, aragonite, and calcite, of different structures, sizes, morphologies, and surface properties, have been in- tensively investigated because of their importance in geo- and biosciences (ADDADI & WEINER, 1992; RICHTER et al., 1995; WANG et al., 1999; SONDI & JURAČIĆ, 2010). Most of the previously reported studies deal with the precipitation of calcium carbonate minerals in aqueous me- dia through classical diffusion-type crystal growth (WES- TIN & RASMUSON, 2005). During the past decade, the formation of carbonate min- eral particles exhibiting unusual structural, morphological and physical properties has been investigated in terms of their mineralogy, biology and chemistry (MELDRUM, 2003; Geologia Croatica 64/1Geologia Croatica 62 SONDI & SALOPEK-SONDI, 2005; MELDRUM & CÖL- FEN, 2008; VIELZEUF et al., 2008). Lately, a new concept, the particle-mediated, non-classical crystallization process, in the formation of bio-inorganic, mesoscopically structured mesocrystals, was promoted (CÖLFEN & ANTONIETTI, 2005; NIEDEBERGER & CÖLFEN, 2006; WANG et al., 2006). These structures are composed of nanoparticle build- ing blocks, and are characterized by a well-faceted appear- ance and anisotropic properties. This concept is much more common in biomineralization processes than has previously been assumed, and the number of new examples of the sig- nifi cance of mesocrystals in biomineral formation has sig- nifi cantly increased in recent years. So far, only scant attention has been devoted to the for- mation of uniform and nearly spherical anhydrous carbonate particles, devoid of crystal habits and anisotropic properties, but still maintaining a crystal structure (SONDI & MA TI- JEVIĆ, 2003; SONDI & SALOPEK-SONDI, 2005; SONDI et al., 2008). The aim of this note is to discuss recent ad- vances in the formation of well-defi ned and uniform nanos- tructured, colloidal carbonate particles, through the non-clas- sical, inorganically and biologically induced nano-scale ag gregation route and to identify some of the problems that still need to be addressed. 2. CASE REPORT AND DISCUSSION The mechanisms of formation of unusual mineral structures and complex shapes have been a topic of discussion for de- cades. Morphological diversity and complexity of naturally occurring minerals in natural systems arises from the dife- rent physico-chemical mechanisms involved in their growth. The well-established, classical diffusion crystal-growth me- chanism proposed by LAMER & DINEGAR (1950) sug- gests that colloidal mineral particles are formed when nuclei, coming from a short-lived burst, grow from the attachment of constituent solutes. During the past decade, further, uni- que, observations were presented including the formation of unusually uniform, spheroidal calcium carbonate particles of distinct crystallinity, despite the fact that they are aggre- gates of nanosized subunits (SONDI & MATIJEVIĆ, 2001; SONDI & SALOPEK-SONDI, 2005). The signifi cance of the aggregation process in the formation of mineral particles from preformed nanocrystallites had already been observed in the late 1960s (PETRES et al., 1969). However, this dis- ocvery has long remained neglected. Recently, it has been experimentally and theoretically established that many inor- ganic colloids, prepared by precipitation from homogeneous solutions, are composed of nanosized subunits (BAILEY et al., 1993; SONDI & MATIJEVIĆ, 2003; HE et al., 2004; LIU & ZHENG, 2004; ŠKAPIN & SONDI, 2005). There- fore, this mechanism was shown to be relatively common in the formation of colloidal particles with crystalline charac- teristics (PRIVMAN et al., 1999; NAVROTSKY, 2004; NIE DEBERGER & CÖLFEN, 2006). Several important studies reported and discussed the for- mation of unusual structures based on a non-classical mech- anism involving aggregation processes (SONDI & SA LO- PEK-SONDI, 2005; PRIVMAN et al., 1999; BAILEY et al., 1993), oriented aggregation assembly (PENN & BAN- FIELD, 1999; ALIVISATOS, 2000; BANFIELD et al., 2000), the development of an oriented architecture of bridged nanocrystals embedded in an organic matrix (OAKI et al., 2006) and the recently developed mesocrystal concept (CÖLFEN & ANTONIETTI, 2005; SONG & CÖLFEN, 2010). Comprehensive coverage of all these would be im- practical here. Instead, a few basic examples are given con- cerning the aggregation mechanism involved in formation of nanostructured and colloidal mineral particles with re- markable morphological properties. Firstly, consider the example of simple aggregation of carbonate colloid particles. Figure 1 displays a fi eld-emission scanning electron microphotograph (FESEM) of unusual spherical and colloid-sized carbonate particles taken from Fi gu re 1: FESEM of spherical calcite particles composed of smaller nano- sized units (the samples originate from the sediment of the freshwater lake of Jezero Kuti located on the Neretva River delta plain). Unpublished illus- trations. Fi gu re 2: FESEM photomicrographs of spheroidal colloid-sized vaterite particles obtained by the enzyme-catalyzed decomposition of urea by ure- ase in aqueous calcium salt solutions at room temperature. (Figure adap- ted from SONDI & SALOPEK-SONDI, 2005). Sondi et al.: A novel concept in the growth and design of anhydrous carbonate minerals: nano-scale aggregation mechanisms Geologia Croatica 63 modern surface sediment of Kuti Lake, part of the deltaic system of the Neretva River, Croatia. At much higher mag- nifi cation it is clear that these solids are composed of much smaller aggregated nanosized subunits (inset in Fig. 1). This implies that these solids did not follow the growth pattern through the classical crystallization pathways and diffusion growth, but rather were formed by the nonconventional ag- gregation of initially formed nanocrystallites. Analagous to this observation, Fig. 2 displays an FESEM photomicrograph of uniform and spherical colloid-sized vaterite particles ob- tained in the laboratory by the enzyme-catalyzed decompo- sition of urea using the urease enzyme in aqueous calcium salt solutions at room temperature (SONDI & SALOPEK- SONDI, 2005). Almost identical structures, (spherical col- loid-sized vaterite particles, composed of much smaller nanosized singlets), were observed. Notably, the XRD peaks of the latter precipitate were signifi cantly widened, addition- ally indicating that these spherical particles are composed of nanosize crystallites (Fig. 3). Applying the Debye-Scheerer equation, their size was estimated to be ~30 nm. In addition, SONDI & MATIJEVIĆ (2003) also demonstrated that uni- form and spheroidal anhydrous carbonate particles from the aragonite group, witherite (BaCO3) and strontianite (SrCO3), generated through a biomimetic precipitation process, also consisted of nanosized subunits. Following these fi ndings, aggregation processes at the nano-scale should be considered as an important mechanism in the formation of crystalline and colloidal carbonate mineral particles that are generated Fi gu re 3: XRD pattern of vaterite (V) precipitate obtained by aging a solu- tion containing 0.5 mol dm–3 urea, 0.2 mol dm–3 CaCl2, and 0.5 mg cm–3 B. pasteurii urease at 25 °C for 2 min. (Figure adapted from SONDI & SALOPEK-SONDI, 2005). Fi gu re 4: FESEM photomicrographs of diff erent types of morphology on the native surface of a septal unit within the calyx: submicrometre-sized, near- ly spherical crystallites (A), transitional forms of elongated cone structures built up of submicrometre-sized particles (B,C), and elongated aragonite fi bres (D). (Figure adapted from SONDI et al., 2011). Geologia Croatica 64/1Geologia Croatica 64 in natural systems through complex biogeochemical pro- cesses, and through the laboratory model experiments under various experimental conditions. Recently, several important studies have reported and dis cussed the fi ne-scale growth of unusual and hierarchically or ganized bio-inorganic aragonite structures involving a mo- re complex, oriented nano-scale aggregation route (SETH- MANN et al., 2007; VIELZEUF et al., 2008; SONDI et al. 2011). It was demonstrated that the internal crystal growth of aragonite fi bres is governed by the aligned aggregation of preformed nanocrystallites and the subsequent coalescence processes that occur simultaneously. As an example, Fig. 4 demonstrates the essential principle of the ma trix-mediated sequential growth of hierarchically organized fi brous arago- nite structures in a skeleton of Mediterranean zooxanthellate scleractinian coral Cladocora caespitosa involving the nano- scale aggregation route (SONDI et al., 2011). It is based on an initial organic matrix-mediated formation of nanosized spherulites in the centres of calcifi cation (Fig. 4A) and fol- lowed by the growth of aggregated and oriented cone-cluster assemblies, that are gradually built up of smaller nanosized units (Figs. 4B, C). What ensues is their subsequent morpho- logical conversion through the coalescence of primarily for- med nanoparticles and the formation of aligned fi brous units (Fig. 4D). Figure 5 is an FESEM photomicrograph of unusual sphe roidal aragonite particles of distinct crystallinity, which were aggregates of nanosized subunits obtained in the labo- ratory in an aqueous calcium salt solution containing urea and ethylene glycol at an elevated temperature of 160°C (ŠKAPIN & SONDI, 2010). Organization of the nanosized subunits of these aragonite particles closely resembles that of the fi brous aragonite in the skeleton of C. caespitosa shown in Fig. 4D. These fi ndings confi rm the hypothesis that the oriented aggregation is a common mechanism in the for- mation of naturally occurring and laboratory-obtained, hier- archically organized aragonite structures. The appearance of nanostructured and hierarchically shaped bio-mineral structures in Nature is the rule rather than a chance event. Various organisms base the functionality of their structural components on the formation of nanostruc- tured materials, functionally adapted to the living environ- ment through the aggregation mechanisms. Figure 6 shows an example of the heterotrophic protozoa that build up their lorica from highly organized and nanostructured calcium car- bonate solids (SONDI & ŠKAPIN, 2010). As a fi nal remark, the entire understanding of the role of the nano-scale aggregation processes in the formation of nanostructured colloidal carbonate minerals is still in its in- fancy. Further, more detailed and delicate investigations, fo- cused on the formation of nanosized precursor phases and their mutual specifi c physico-chemical interactions at the initial stage of their formation, might clarify the mechanism of the entire precipitation process. 3. CONCLUSIONS This note underscores the importance of nano-scale aggre- gation processes in the formation of biogenic and inorganic colloid-sized carbonate mineral particles. Understanding these mechanisms sheds light on the non-conventional for- mation of carbonate mineral phases in modern sediments, a situation commonly encountered in natural systems. It needs to be pointed out that aggregation mechanisms are too complex to entirely determine the role of single proc- esses of chemical and physical events involved in the forma- tion of aggregated mineral solids in natural systems. It is clear that more focused and detailed investigations of sub- structured carbonate minerals from sedimentary systems, to- gether with those obtained by model laboratory experiments could possibly contribute to the clarifi cation of the mecha- nism of the aggregation processes encountered in bioinor- ganic and inorganic mineral structures in Nature. Fi gu re 5: FESEM photomicrographs of aragonite obtained by ageing ethylene glycol solution containing 0.75 mol dm−3 urea, 0.25 mol dm−3 CaCl2 at 160°C for 10 min. (Figure adapted from ŠKAPIN & SONDI, 2010). Fi gu re 6: FESEM photomicrographs of heterotrophic protozoa showing the nanostructured shape of their lorica (the samples originate from the sediment of the marine lake of Malo Jezero on the island of Mljet, Adriatic Sea). (Figure adapted from SONDI & ŠKAPIN, 2010). Sondi et al.: A novel concept in the growth and design of anhydrous carbonate minerals: nano-scale aggregation mechanisms Geologia Croatica 65 ACKNOWLEDGEMENT This work was supported by the Ministry of Science, Edu- cation and Sports of the Republic of Croatia (Grants 098- 0982934-2742, 119-0000000-1158), and by the Ministry of Higher Education, Science and Technology of the Republic of Slovenia (Grant P2-0091-0106). REFERENCES ALIVISATOS, A.P. (2000): Biomineralization: Naturally aligned nanoc- rystals.– Science, 289, 736−737. ADDADI, L. & WEINER, S. (1992): Control and design principles in bio logical mineralization.– Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl., 31, 153−169. BAILEY, K., BRINKER, C.J. & MECARTNEY, M.L. (1993): Growth mechanisms of iron oxide particles of differing morphologies from the forced hydrolysis of ferric chloride solutions.– J. Colloid Inter- face Sci., 157, 1−13. BANFIELD, J.F., WELCH, S.A., ZHANG, H., EBERT, T.T. & PENN, R.L. (2000): Aggregation-based crystal growth and microstructure development in natural iron oxyhydroxide biomineralization prod- ucts.– Science, 289, 751−754. CÖLFEN, H. & ANTONIETTI, M. (2005): Mesocrystals: Inorganic su- perstructures made by highly parallel crystallization and controlled alignment.– Angew. Chem. Int. Edit., 44, 5576−5591. FLÜGEL, E. (2004): Microfacies of carbonate rocks.– Springer, Berlin, Heidelberg, New York, 976 p. HE, T., CHEN, D. & JIAO, X. (2004): Controlled synthesis of Co3O4 nanoparticles through oriented aggregation.– Chem. Mater., 16, 737−743. LAMER, V.K. & DINEGAR, R. (1950): Theory, production and me- chanism of formation of monodispersed hydrosols.– Am. Chem. Soc., 72, 4847−4854. LIU, B. & ZENG, H.C. (2004): Mesoscale organization of CuO na- noribbons: Formation of “Dandelions”.– J. Am. Chem. Soc., 126, 8124–8125. MELDRUM, F.C. (2003): Biomimetic control of calcifi cation.– Int. Mater. Rev., 48, 187–224. MELDRUM, F.C. & CÖLFEN, H. (2008): Controlling mineral mor- phologies and structures in biological and synthetic systems.– Chem. Rev., 108, 4332–4432. NAVROTSKY, A. (2004): Energetic clues to pathways to biomineraliza- tion: Precursors, clusters and nanoparticles.– P. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA, 101, 12096–12101. NIEDERBERGER, M. & CÖLFEN, H. (2006): Oriented attachment and mesocrystals: Non-classical crystallization mechanisms based on nanoparticle assembly.– Phys. Chem. Chem. Phys, 8, 3271–3287. OAKI, Y., KOTACHI, A., MIURA, T. & IMAI, H. (2006): Bridged nanocrystals in biominerals and their biomimetics: Classical yet modern crystal growth on the nanoscale.– Adv. Funct. Mater., 16, 1633–1639. PENN, R.L. & BANFIELD, J.F. (1999): Morphology development and crystal growth in nanocrystalline aggregates under hydrothermal conditions: Insights from titania.– Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta, 63, 1549–1557. PETRES, J.J., DEŽELIĆ, GJ. & TEŽAK, B. (1969): Monodisperse sols of barium sulfate. III. Electron-microscopic study of internal struc- ture of particles.– Croat. Chem. Acta, 41, 183–186. PRIVMAN, V., GOIA, D.V., PARK, J. & MATIJEVIĆ, E. (1999): Mech- anism of formation of monodispersed colloids by aggregation of nanosize precursors.– J. Colloid Interface Sci., 213, 36–45. RICHTER, A., PETZOLD, D., HOFMA N, H. & ULLRICH, B. (1995): Herstellung, Eigenschaften und Verwendung von Calciumcarbonat- pulvern. Teil 1: Herstellung von Calciumcarbonat durch Fallung aus Loesungen.– Chem. Tech., 47, 306–313. SETHMANN, I., HELBIG, U. & WORHEIDE, G. (2007): Octocoral sclerite ultrastructures and experimental approach to underlying bi- omineralisation principles.– Cryst. Eng. Comm., 9, 1262–1268. SONDI, I. & MATIJEVIĆ, E. (2001): Homogenous precipitation of cal- cium carbonate by enzyme catalyzed reactions.– J. Colloid Interface Sci., 238, 208–214. SONDI, I. & MATIJEVIĆ, E. (2003): Homogeneous precipitation by enzyme-catalyzed reactions. 2. Strontium and barium carbonates.– Chem. Mater., 15, 1322–1326. SONDI, I. & SALOPEK-SONDI, B. (2005): Infl uence of the primary structure of enzymes on the formation of CaCO3 polymorphs: A comparison of plant (Canavalia ensiformis) and bacterial (Bacillus pasteurii) ureases.– Langmuir, 21, 8876–8882. SONDI, I., ŠKAPIN, S.D. & SALOPEK-SONDI, B. (2008): Biomimet- ic precipitation of nanostructured colloidal calcite particles by en- zyme-catalyzed reaction in the presence of magnesium ions.– Cryst. Growth Des., 8, 435–441. SONDI, I. & JURAČIĆ, M. (2010): Whiting events and the formation of aragonite in Mediterranean karstic marine lakes: New evidence on its biologically induced inorganic origin.– Sedimentology, 57, 85–95. SONDI, I. & ŠKAPIN, S.D. (2010): A biomimetic nano-scale aggrega- tion route for the formation of submicron-size colloidal calcite par- ticles.– In: MUKHERJEE, A. (ed.): Biomimetics, learning from nature. In-Tech, Vienna, 241–255. SONDI, I., SALOPEK-SONDI, B., ŠKAPIN, S.D., ŠEGOTA, S., JU- RINA, I. & VUKELIĆ, B. (2011): Colloid-chemical processes in the growth and design of the bio-inorganic aragonite structure in the scleractinian coral Cladocora caespitosa.– J. Colloid Interface Sci., 354, 181–189. SONG, R.Q. & CÖLFEN, H. (2010): Mesocrystals – ordered nanopar- ticle superstructures.– Adv. Mater., 22, 1301–1330. ŠKAPIN, S.D. & SONDI, I. (2005): Homogeneous precipitation of mixed anhydrous Ca-Mg and Ba-Sr carbonates by enzyme-cata- lyzed reactions.– Cryst. Growth Des., 5, 1933–1938. ŠKAPIN, S.D. & SONDI, I. (2010): Synthesis and characterization of calcite and aragonite in polyol liquids: Control over structure and morphology.– J. Colloid Interface Sci., 347, 221–226. TUCKER, M.E. & WRIGHT, V.P. (1990): Carbonate Sedimentology.– Blackwell Scientifi c Publications, Oxford, 482 p. VIELZEUF, D., GARRABOU, J., BARONNET, A., GRAUBY, O. & MARSCHAL, C. (2008): Nano to macroscale biomineral archi- tecture of red coral (Corallium rubrum).– Am. Mineral., 93, 1799–1815. WANG, L., SONDI, I. & MATIJEVIĆ, E. (1999): Preparation of uniform needle-like aragonite particles by homogeneous precipitation.– J. Colloid Interface Sci., 218, 545–553. WANG, T.P., ANTONIETTI, M. & CÖLFEN, H. (2006): Calcite meso- crystals: “Morphing” crystals by a polyelectrolyte.– Chem. Eur. J., 12, 5722–5730. WESTIN, K. & RASMUSON, A.C. (2005): Crystal growth of aragonite and calcite in presence of citric acid, DTPA, EDTA and pyromel- litic acid.– J. Colloid Interface Sci., 282, 359–369. Manuscript received December 09, 2010 Revised manuscript accepted January 12, 2011 Available online February 22, 2011